Datasets:

giuliadc

/

arxiv-filtered-978rows

like 0

cond-mat0204224

since the mode - coupling theory ( mct ) of the liquid - glass transition has been proposed in the mid - eighties @xcite , considerable work has been done in order to compare its predictions with experimental data and computer simulation results @xcite . most of these tests of the mct are based on the use as fitting functions of the quasi - universal laws that are obtained from an asymptotic analysis of the family of non - linear equations to which the mode - coupling equations belong and that are valid only in the vicinity of the predicted so - called ideal glass transition singularity . for experimental data , this is essentially the only practicable approach , since typical glass - formers are molecular liquids for which a first - principle study is out of reach and since most experiments , like dynamic light - scattering spectroscopy @xcite , probe complex mechanisms in which various types of dynamical processes are entangled . in the case of computer simulations , the situation appears more comfortable , since simple systems can be considered for which all the data needed for an extensive comparison with the theory can be directly obtained with high precision . however , it turns out that one still has to rely on asymptotic results of the theory at some point . indeed , one finds that the mct is not able to predict accurately the location of the putative ideal glass transition : it has thus to be determined from the simulation results , usually with a fit to an asymptotic law , in order to calibrate the comparison between theory and simulation @xcite . such a use of the asymptotic laws does not go without difficulties , originating in the fact that the ideal glass transition is never observed as such : it is usually argued to be avoided because of the existence of so - called `` activated processes '' not taken into account by the theory , whose effect is to restore the ergodicity of the system in the predicted ideal glassy state . thus the transition is expected to be replaced by a smooth crossover between two dynamical regimes , one dominated by the mode - coupling mechanism and the other dominated by activated processes . a first problem with the occurrence of these additional processes is that it hinders a clear separation of time scales between the fast transient dynamics and the structural relaxation , with which mct exclusively deals , and thus makes the domain where the asymptotic regime of mct is expected more difficult to resolve . in addition , the study of the corrections to the asymptotic laws shows that these laws are valid only in a very small domain around the ideal glass transition @xcite : it can thus be expected that the dynamics in this domain will be markedly affected by crossover effects . finally , from a more pragmatic point of view , since the asymptotic laws of the theory apply to rather specific aspects of the dynamics ( for instance , in the @xmath0 relaxation regime , since the shape of the relaxation itself is non - universal , the main quantitative asymptotic prediction deals with the variation of the relaxation time with temperature ) , only selected parts of the available experimental information are usually involved in most experimental tests of the mct on molecular glassformers , a situation which can be considered quite unsatisfactory . for these reasons , it appears desirable to have a means to test the mct on experimental data which is not limited to the use of the critical predictions of the theory and which is able to give an overall account of the dynamics . this can precisely be achieved within the so - called schematic approach to experimental data . schematic mode - coupling models are simple sets of mode - coupling equations retaining the essential non - linear structure of the equations of the mct in one or two equations and with only a few parameters . they played a major role in the development of the theory to investigate the universal properties of the general mode - coupling equations and to demonstrate the potentialities of the theory @xcite . recently , they have been found useful as quantitative models for numerical fits of experimental data covering a wide time or frequency range . the basic idea behind this schematic approach to experimental data is that , since all equations of the mode - coupling type share distinctive universal properties , meaningful informations are likely to be obtained if a suitable minimal set of equations of this family is used as an effective mode - coupling model to describe experimental data . one interest of the method is then that the universal properties of the mode - coupling equations are used in a milder sense than in their usual direct applications : it is thus possible to numerically take into account corrections to the asymptotic laws that can be important if the system is too far from its putative ideal glass transition . in addition , one can tentatively describe the full dynamics , including the non - universal @xmath0 relaxation and the fast transient dynamics ( although through rather crude approximations ) , and thus possibly overcome the problem of insufficient separation of time scales . for these reasons , the schematic approach appears as a method of choice to critically investigate the validity of the previous tests of the theory based on the asymptotic laws . of course , the power of the method comes at a price : even a minimal schematic model ( in a sense to be defined latter ) will have numerous adjustable parameters . this makes the approach numerically extremely flexible , and one finds for instance that it is possible to give an account of the experimental dynamics with an ideal mct schematic model even at low temperatures where ideal mct is known inadequate . thus one should not overestimate the physical meaning of the fitted parameters . however , as was found in previous works , by critically looking at the results of a schematic analysis , one can address from a renewed point of view the problem of testing the predictions of the mct on experimental data . in the present paper , the third of a series devoted to the schematic approach to experimental data @xcite , we aim to address various issues that have been overlooked in previous works , in order to better settle and understand the principles and results of this approach . in the next section , we give an overview of the schematic studies proposed so far and of the models on which they were based . in sec . [ sec3 ] , a set of simple requirements that need to be fulfilled in order to define a suitable minimal schematic model is proposed . in sec . [ sec4 ] , we examine the influence of the choice of the schematic model on the results of the analysis of a given set of experimental data , and sec . [ sec5 ] is devoted to a tentative validation of the method , by analyzing model spectra with well defined properties within the schematic approach . we finally present our conclusions and draw perspectives for the approach . in this section , we give an overview of the schematic studies proposed so far . this gives us the opportunity to settle a few definitions and notations to be used latter . the first schematic study has been proposed by alba - simionesco and krauzman @xcite , where they analyzed low - frequency raman scattering spectra of the fragile glassformer metatoluidine with various two - correlator schematic models . one of them , based on the so - called f@xmath1 model @xcite , is defined by the equations [ f12model ] @xmath2 with initial conditions @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath5 , and has subsequently been used in studies of raman spectra of other glassformers @xcite and , more importantly , of depolarized light - scattering spectra of salol and ckn [ @xmath6 covering a wide frequency range ( more than four decades ) @xcite . in all these works , where other choices for the memory - function @xmath7 have occasionally been considered @xcite , the fitting function was defined , up to an amplitude factor , as the susceptibility associated with the effective correlator @xmath8 another widely used model differs only from the preceding one through the choice @xmath9 an expression first proposed by sjgren @xcite , and the use as the fitting function of the susceptibility associated to @xmath10 , with an adjustable amplitude factor . it has been used to study depolarized light - scattering spectra of glycerol @xcite and orthoterphenyle ( otp ) @xcite , as well as coherent neutron - scattering and brillouin spectra of @xmath11 @xcite . an extended mct version of this model has also been used recently to study depolarized light - scattering , dielectric - loss and incoherent neutron - scattering spectra of propylene carbonate @xcite . finally , self - intermediate scattering functions obtained by molecular dynamics simulations of a nickel - zirconium model have been analyzed by teichler @xcite with a single - correlator model with @xmath7 defined as @xmath12 at variance with the works mentioned above , a retarded damping term involving four adjustable parameters has been used in the present case instead of the simple markovian approximation made in eq . involving the single parameter @xmath13 . looking at the equations , one sees that these models involve _ a priori _ a large number of fitting parameters . to reduce this number , simplifying assumptions are usually made : in refs . , , , and , the only temperature - dependent parameters are chosen to be @xmath14 and @xmath15 , whereas in ref . , these are @xmath15 and @xmath16 , and in ref . , @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 change with temperature , the latter depending also on the wave vector modulus in all schematic studies proposed so far , a certain degree of arbitrariness has often been involved in the choice of the details of the model to be used . the most serious case relates perhaps to the use of the memory function in our preceding works @xcite , which , at variance with sjgren s model@xcite , can not be given any precise theoretical foundations . but other minor choices can also be questioned . there is indeed no physical reason to prefer using a simple correlator as the fitting function instead of a composite one like in eq . , the apparent advantage of the former choice , which seems to make the relation between the fitting function and the dynamical variable probed by the experiment transparent , relying on a mere tautology . one can also wonder why , for similar experimental data and schematic equations , the effective vertex entering the second memory function ( @xmath17 or @xmath16 ) has been held constant with temperature in refs . and and not in ref . for instance , where it is @xmath14 which has been kept fixed . in most cases , these various choices have been only validated _ a posteriori _ by the success of the model to fit the data under study and/or the obtention of parameters whose variations match the expectations from the microscopic theory @xcite . there are nevertheless a few difficulties that could be expected , related to the possible existence of non - generic features of the chosen model . indeed , as stated in the introduction , generic mode - coupling equations display remarkable universal properties @xcite , but , when a schematic model is considered , because it is very simple , one can experience severe limitations in the realization of these universal features : certain values of important parameters of the theory can be unattainable or _ ad hoc _ correlations between these parameters can be imposed . an example of the first situation is provided by the f@xmath18 models , @xmath19 , for which @xmath20 is the only possible value of the exponent parameter @xmath21 , whereas it can take any value in the interval @xmath22 $ ] for the general mode - coupling equations . the second situation is realized with the f@xmath1 model , where the exponent parameter and the critical non - ergodicity parameter @xmath23 are always related through @xmath24 . for these reasons , it seems desirable to understand what are the minimal requirements that must be met by a schematic model in order to avoid such biases and possible consequent inconsistencies in the results of its application . we propose here a series of criteria based on a discussion of the asymptotic properties of the mode - coupling equations in the vicinity of the ideal glass transition . for this , we consider the case of an experiment probing the evolution of a normalized correlation function @xmath25 associated to an unspecified dynamical process in a given glassforming liquid , when a thermodynamic parameter @xmath26 ( temperature or density for instance ) is varied . note that the following discussion can easily be extended to situations where more than one observable are considered in a unified framework @xcite , with exactly the same conclusions . by looking at the asymptotic predictions of the theory @xcite , a few important parameters emerge . on the one hand , one finds parameters that characterize the liquid under study and the thermodynamic path along which the experiment is performed . these are @xmath27 , the value of @xmath26 at the ideal glass transition , @xmath28 , the proportionality constant relating the separation parameter @xmath29 defined by the theory to @xmath26 through the relation @xmath30 and @xmath21 , the exponent parameter governing numerous aspects of the critical dynamics . on the other hand , one finds parameters that are specific to the correlation function @xmath25 : @xmath31 , the non - ergodicity parameter at the transition , and @xmath32 , the so - called critical amplitude . thus we identify five parameters that are expected to be of special relevance . the first three of them are involved in the description of the relative evolution of the two characteristic time scales of the dynamics in the ergodic phase , @xmath33 and @xmath34 characterizing the @xmath35 regime and the @xmath0 relaxation respectively . this can be seen from the ratio @xmath36 where @xmath37 and @xmath38 are uniquely determined by @xmath21 @xcite . in addition , @xmath21 alone determines the shape of the dynamics in the @xmath35 regime . the two remaining parameters , @xmath31 and @xmath32 , are related to the amplitudes of the @xmath0 relaxation and of the @xmath35 process , as shown for instance by the scaling relation @xmath39 describing the @xmath35 process and the onset of @xmath0 relaxation in the ergodic phase close to the singularity . but in fact , this parameter counting is only valid when the full mode - coupling equations describing the dynamics of the system are known . two differences appear when the only available information is the function @xmath25 at different @xmath26 values . first , it can be seen that @xmath32 never appears alone in the asymptotic laws , but always inside products @xmath40 . for this reason , the relevant parameter is rather the physical amplitude @xmath41 , which appears for instance in the relation between @xmath26 and the non - ergodicity parameter in the ideal glassy state , @xmath42 this remark would be irrelevant if it was possible to know @xmath28 from the data at hand , but this is not the case . indeed , according to the theory , the shape of the @xmath0 relaxation is non - universal . this means that there exists an undetermined proportionality constant relating @xmath34 , the value emerging from the theoretical calculation , to the phenomenological @xmath0 relaxation time @xmath43 , which can be defined for instance after @xmath44 and which is the only type of value that can be accessed from the knowledge of @xmath25 alone . such a problem does not occur for the @xmath35 process which is universal , i.e. it depends only on @xmath21 . this means that the ratio can only be known up to an undetermined factor and thus that the value of @xmath28 can not be obtained . this is in fact an important result , since it shows that one can know the absolute distance ( in terms of the separation parameter @xmath29 ) of a system to its ideal glass transition only if the mode - coupling equations describing the full dynamics are known . moving now back to the schematic approach to experimental data , one finds thus that , in order to analyze the evolution of the correlation function @xmath25 with an effective schematic correlator @xmath45 , the model must be able to reproduce the values of @xmath21 , @xmath31 and @xmath46 characterizing the system and the observable under investigation . a point on the transition surface of the schematic model must exist where one will have @xmath47 the last equality is not a strong constraint since @xmath48 and @xmath49 relate to decoupled aspects of the description of the dynamics , the first one being defined at the transition point , whereas the second one describes the approach of this point . one can thus expect that the interplay of these two aspects will allow to compensate possible non - generic features relative to @xmath48 ( like in the case of the f@xmath1 model where @xmath50 ) . the first two constraints are on the contrary very strong and need to be taken into account . one has in particular to worry about the accessible domain for the values of @xmath51 and @xmath52 and to avoid the introduction of arbitrary correlations between these parameters . eventually , one finds thus that a schematic model needs to have at least three adjustable coupling constants , at least one of them changing with temperature . indeed , with a single coupling constant , only one pair ( @xmath51,@xmath52 ) is possible . with two coupling constants , a relation linking @xmath51 and @xmath52 exists , and for a given value of @xmath51 , only a finite number of @xmath52 values will exist . one needs three coupling parameters to be able to decouple @xmath51 and @xmath52 . we can now look at the schematic models introduced in the previous section at the light of these new results . it is easy to see that these conditions are matched by the model used in ref . and defined by eqs . and , since it relies on four coupling parameters ( @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath17 and @xmath53 ) to obtain the values of @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath54 . this is not the case of the model used by teichler @xcite , which has only two coupling parameters @xmath53 and @xmath55 , and one indeed finds inconsistencies in the results : for instance , the exponent parameter @xmath21 appears to change with the considered observable . it seems thus likely that the success of the calculation is essentially to be credited to the flexibility of the fitting procedure ( in particular through the choice of a four - parameter retarded friction ) and to the consideration of observables with high plateau values which probably turn out to be compatible with the value of the real exponent parameter . about the other studies , one finds in fact that the present discussion is inoperant , because only part of the dynamics is considered : the @xmath0 relaxation is not present in refs . and , and the fast transient dynamics is not included in refs . , , and , with the effect of releasing in both cases the constraint on the value of @xmath52 . an interesting consequence of these constraints is that they restrain the possibility to give a precise physical meaning to the separate components of a schematic model . this is especially clear when a composite correlator like eq . indeed , the relations between the components of the fitting function are expected to be mainly imposed by the need to reproduce the values of @xmath21 , @xmath31 and @xmath46 : it is then hardly conceivable that the value of the coupling constant @xmath53 or the effect of the details of the expression for @xmath45 will reflect any physical reality , for instance in terms of the light scattering mechanism . this is of course less obvious when the fitting function is a pure correlator , because of the tautological relation between the fitting function and the dynamical variable probed by the experiment , but , for the previous reasons , we believe that in general a schematic model has to be considered in its globality as a minimal phenomenological model allowing to give an account of the dynamics of a system in terms of mode - coupling effects , and nothing more has to be expected from it . to conclude this part , it is worth stressing that the present discussion refers only to the asymptotic predictions of the theory and that problems originating in pre - asymptotic corrections or the existence of activated processes have been ignored . moreover , only a few numbers have been considered . in particular , the precise shape of the relaxation ( particularly in the @xmath0 relaxation domain ) has not been taken into account , whereas it can make an _ a priori _ well - suited model totally inefficient for the schematic approach . for these reasons , the preceding remarks are only guidelines aimed at rationalizing and optimizing the use of schematic models , but they offer no guarantee of success . in the present section , we propose a study of depolarized light - scattering spectra of a fragile glassformer by means of a variety of schematic models . the aim of this work is twofold . first , in all previous schematic analysis , only one model has ever been used at a time for a given set of experiments and no systematic investigation of the influence of the choice of the model on the results has been proposed so far . secondly , in the previous section , a few parameters have been isolated that are expected to play a special role in the description of the dynamics of a given observable . the use of different schematic models to analyze the same set of experimental data , depending of their ability to provide consistent estimates for these values , should thus allow us to confirm or infirm the corresponding discussion . the data we have studied are the ckn depolarized light - scattering spectra measured by cummins _ _ @xcite and already analyzed with a schematic model in ref . . the reason ckn has been chosen ( and not salol for instance ) for this study is the low intensity of its @xmath0 peak , which is slightly smaller than the microscopic peak : this guarantees that , when the spectra are studied with a composite effective correlator like in eq . , the amplitudes of the contributions of both terms will not be too different and thus this allows one to obtain a better contrast between the outcome of different schematic analysis . to limit the influence of the avoidance of the ideal glass transition , only rather high temperatures , between 383 and 468 k , have been considered . compared to our previous work , the two lower temperatures ( 363 and 373 k ) have been excluded , leading to small differences in the results ( within the error bars of the method ) . note that at the temperatures we have considered , one can expect the spectra to be free of the influence of the spurious experimental artifacts evidenced in ref . . only schematic models closely related to the one used in ref . and with the same number of parameters have been considered . as in this previous work , they have been used to perform simultaneous fits of the experimental data at the nine selected temperatures : the whole dynamical scenario developing as temperature varies is thus encoded in the only temperature dependent parameters of the schematic models , which are the effective vertices entering in the expression of the memory function @xmath7 . we first stick to the two - correlator f@xmath1 model . there are two routes by which the model can be modified . on the one hand , different second memory functions can be chosen . we have considered two cases : [ varmem1 ] @xmath56 on the other hand , one can vary the expression of the effective correlator as a function of @xmath57 and @xmath10 . we have considered four possibilities : [ varcorreff ] @xmath58 in previous works @xcite , the choice of a specific expression was originally motivated by assumptions on the light - scattering mechanism . however , from the discussion of the preceding section , it seems very unlikely that this question is of any relevance : indeed , since individually each correlator has no real physical meaning , the precise way it enters the calculation is clearly unimportant . * 7c model & i & ii & iii & iv & v & vi + @xmath59 & & + @xmath45 & & & & & & + @xmath17 & 8.6 & 3.6 & 5.9 & 2.2 & & + @xmath16 & & & & & 14.2 & 7.5 + @xmath53 & 0.30 & 0.29 & 0.31 & 0.22 & 0.32 & 0.49 + @xmath60 ( k ) & 388.5 & 388.9 & 388.5 & 388.8 & 390.1 & 390.8 + @xmath21 & 0.712 & 0.704 & 0.700 & 0.698 & 0.705 & 0.701 + @xmath61 & 0.448 & 0.452 & 0.446 & 0.449 & 0.424 & 0.429 + @xmath48 & 0.779 & 0.696 & 0.887 & 0.799 & 0.657 & 0.707 + @xmath62 & 0.150 & 0.183 & 0.113 & 0.133 & 0.230 & 0.150 + @xmath54 & 0.563 & 0.548 & 0.544 & 0.530 & 0.580 & 0.501 a total of six models ( numbered from i to vi , see table [ globalt ] for definition ) obtained by various combinations of the previous expressions have been used . model i , defined by eqs . and , was used in ref . , whereas model vi , using eqs . and , is close to the one used in refs . the fits are always very good ( see fig . [ fitexp ] for spectra and fits at two representative sample temperatures ) and of equal quality for all models . the corresponding results for the various coupling constants and relevant mode - coupling parameters are reported in table [ globalt ] and fig . [ vert1 ] . each model provides its own series of effective vertices @xmath14 and @xmath15 and values of the coupling constants @xmath17 or @xmath16 and @xmath53 , distinct from those obtained with the other models . the description of the dynamics in terms of effective mode - coupling parameters is thus clearly non - unique , as expected from the non - universality of the @xmath0 relaxation . for all models , a behavior similar to the one found in ref . is recovered , interpreted as follows : at the highest temperatures the effective vertices are linear functions of temperature and show the progressive evolution of the system towards an ideal glass transition point , but , before this point is reached , this behavior breaks down , evidencing the phenomenon of avoidance of the transition and the inadequateness of the present ideal mct approach at low temperature . the reader is referred to previous work for a discussion of the consequences of this observation @xcite . looking at the trajectories in the @xmath63 plane , one sees that the change in behavior of the effective vertices between the high and low temperature domains is less visible when sjgren s model , eq . , is used : in this case , the trajectories seem to behave rather regularly in the full temperature domain and to bend gently to follow the transition line , at variance with what is found from the use of eq . , where one can easily separate a domain where @xmath14 does not vary much from a domain where it decreases rather rapidly . we attribute this qualitative difference between the two models to the way the temperature dependence is entered in the schematic model at the level of the second memory function @xmath59 . indeed , at a given point @xmath63 of the ergodic domain , one can qualitatively quantify the strength of the mode - coupling term in eq . , @xmath64 , by considering the value of @xmath59 for representative values @xmath65 and @xmath66 of the correlation functions @xmath57 and @xmath10 , respectively @xcite . when eq . is used with constant @xmath16 , the corresponding factor @xmath67 depends only _ implicitly _ on temperature through the variation of @xmath65 and @xmath66 with the position of the representative point of the system in the control parameter space @xmath63 , whereas , when eq . is used with constant @xmath17 , the factor @xmath68 shows an additional _ explicit _ temperature dependence , since @xmath59 is defined directly in terms of the coupling constants @xmath14 and @xmath15 , and in fact this explicit dependence dominates the implicit one . if one now compares the evolution of these factors for both models when one explores the @xmath63 plane , one easily finds that , in order to have similar increases in the strength of the mode - coupling terms , one has to consider trajectories in the case of sjgren s model that lie above the corresponding trajectories for eq . and that come rather close to the transition line , since in its vicinity only are found significant increases in @xmath65 and @xmath66 , hence the difference in the results obtained with these two models : the catastrophic behavior of the vertices due to the avoidance of the transition is less visible in the case of sjgren s model , because it is by construction already constrained to follow rather closely the transition line . once this subtle non - generic feature has been recognized , one is able to rationalize the similarities and differences between the results of the various schematic analysis proposed so far . since the light - scattering spectra of glycerol have been analyzed with the same parameterization of sjgren s model as the one used here for model v and vi , it is no surprise that the trajectory found by franosch _ @xcite is similar to those obtained here with these two models . this is the case of the study of @xmath11 as well , despite the choice of a temperature - dependent @xmath16 : above @xmath69 , the numerical fits result in a slow increase of this parameter when temperature is decreased , which converts , as one would expect , to a trajectory in the @xmath63 plane that is not different from what is obtained when @xmath16 is taken constant @xcite . the case of otp provides another illustration of this point @xcite . indeed , in this work , the relative position of the vertex trajectory and the transition line is imposed from the start through the choice of a temperature - independent @xmath14 , a constraint that is compatible with the results obtained above for models i to iv , and , as could be anticipated from the previous discussion , this coincides with a rapidly increasing @xmath16 when temperature is decreased , i.e. a strong explicit temperature - dependence of the second memory function . the same seems to hold for the extended mode - coupling analysis of gtze and voigtmann @xcite , where a neat intersection of the ideal glass transition line by the trajectory in the parameter space of the schematic model is associated with values of @xmath16 increasing rapidly with decreasing temperature . these observations appear at first sight rather anecdotic . they have nevertheless at least one important physical implication . indeed , comparing the results for glycerol and @xmath11 , two liquids with intermediate fragility , to those for salol , ckn , and otp , that are all very fragile , it is tempting to propose a connection between the fragility of a glassformer and the shape of the effective vertex trajectory that describes its dynamics . the previous discussion rules out such a tentative connection and shows that the analogies and differences found between the various fluids simply originate in the details of the implementation of the schematic approach . we now turn to the quantitative analysis of our results . for each schematic model , the values of the various parameters characterizing the ideal glass transition have been obtained by extrapolation of the linear dependence of the effective vertices with temperature at high temperature , which we have identified as the signature of the domain where the ideal mct is adequate ( in the next section , support will be given to this analysis that differs from the one used in refs . and ) . they are reported in table [ globalt ] . all six models provide consistent estimates for @xmath69 , @xmath21 , @xmath61 and @xmath54 . this consistency tends to validate the discussion proposed in the previous section about the relevant variables to describe a given observable in terms of mode - coupling parameters . this is clearly a non - trivial observation , since the values of the different parameters entering the calculation vary notably from one model to another ( for instance , @xmath70 changes by a factor of two between model iii and v ) . in order to investigate stronger changes to the schematic model , we have considered other memory functions @xmath7 , keeping @xmath71 as in . one of the most studied schematic models after f@xmath1 is f@xmath72 defined as @xcite @xmath73 we have studied two models based on this memory function . they will be denoted i and iv , since they are directly analogous to the preceding i and iv f@xmath1 models . we observe a clear deterioration of the quality of the fits compared to f@xmath1 , but it remains nevertheless acceptable ( see fig . [ fitexp ] ) . in fact , the use of the f@xmath72 model is made difficult by one of its non - generic properties . indeed , when a b - transition line has a termination point or when two transition lines meet , strong corrections to the generic asymptotic laws appear and noticeably affect the shape of the dynamics @xcite . these corrections can make it impossible to use a schematic model to fit experimental data if the description of the system under study requires to come close to such singularities . in the f@xmath1 model , a termination point is found at @xmath74 , but here @xmath75 , which is quite far from the values characterizing the typical glassformers , of the order of 0.7 . thus no problem has to be expected _ a priori_. but in the f@xmath72 model , one finds that the a- and b - transition lines meet when @xmath76 , @xmath77 , with @xmath78 . this is rather close to the values usually associated to experimental systems and one can thus anticipate difficulties with this model , which we actually see . * 3c model & i & iv + @xmath17 & 1.79 & 0.62 + @xmath53 & 0.11 & 0.050 + @xmath60 ( k ) & 389.3 & 389.7 + @xmath21 & 0.688 & 0.670 + @xmath61 & 0.443 & 0.439 + @xmath48 & 0.541 & 0.444 + @xmath62 & 0.254 & 0.373 + @xmath54 & 0.489 & 0.472 the results we have obtained with the f@xmath72 models are reported in table [ f13tab ] and in fig . [ f13fig ] . the behavior of the effective vertices is the same as with f@xmath1 , but slightly less regular . critical parameters have been obtained from high temperatures as before . the agreement with the previous results for the values of @xmath69 and @xmath61 is very good , but less good for the values of @xmath21 and @xmath54 . however one can hardly conclude from these results , since these parameters characterize the @xmath35 process , in which the non - generic limitations of the f@xmath72 model precisely show up . as it was stressed in the previous section , when using the schematic approach to experimental data , one has to avoid any arbitrary correlation between important parameters of the theory introduced in an _ ad hoc _ way by the choice of a specific schematic model . in all models studied so far , one can identify such a correlation in the fact that , along the b type transition line , an increase of @xmath23 is systematically associated to a decrease of @xmath21 . this could have introduced a bias in the schematic calculation that would have made the avoidance of the ideal glass transition line a purely numerical artifact of the method . indeed , despite the absence of a true ergodicity breaking at @xmath69 in real systems , one expects that the increase of the non - ergodicity parameter below @xmath69 survives under the form of an increase of the @xmath0 peak height of the susceptibility . the vertex drift found with the f@xmath1 model could thus be simply traced back to the need to give an account of this evolution , the obtained trajectories corresponding precisely to an increase of @xmath23 ( and thus of @xmath61 ) @xcite . it would then reflect a misconception and limitation of the schematic approach itself and not more generally a failure of the underlying ideal mct as it was argued in ref . 15 . to show that our calculations are indeed free of this artifact , we have investigated a model in which the variations of @xmath21 and @xmath23 can be decoupled . we chose the f@xmath79 model , the transition line of which is made of two branches along which @xmath21 varies between @xmath20 and 1 : between the points @xmath80 , @xmath81 and @xmath82 , @xmath83 , @xmath21 and @xmath23 grow simultaneously , whereas between the points @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath21 decreases and @xmath23 increases . clearly , we have chosen this somewhat far - fetched model only for its mathematical properties and one could hardly give any physical motivation for the specific f@xmath79 functional form . however , we stress that , from the point of view of the criteria of the preceding section , this model is _ a priori _ free from any non - generic features and thus a perfectly acceptable schematic model : first , it does not show any limitation on the accessible values of @xmath21 , at variance with all other f@xmath86 different from f@xmath1 ; secondly , in the domain of @xmath21 we are interested in ( around 0.7 ) , the influence of the higher - order a@xmath87 singularity from which its special mathematical features originate is expected to be negligible . we have performed schematic analysis with this model in the vicinity of each branch of the transition line , in an attempt to find if the coupling of the evolutions of @xmath21 and @xmath23 plays any role in our calculations . the corresponding fits are quite poor : they only give a qualitative account of the evolution of the dynamics and it would seem unreasonable to extract quantitative values for the critical parameters of the theory from the results . however , a clear pattern manifests itself : close to both transition branches , the behavior of the effective vertices corresponds to a decrease of the exponent parameter , irrespective of the evolution of @xmath23 . in fact , this could have been anticipated from the fact that , below the value of @xmath69 we have determined , the maximum of the @xmath0 peak lies outside the available frequency window , and this eliminates the requirement to reproduce its amplitude at these low temperatures . however it is reassuring to show by an independent calculation that our results are free from this potential bias , that should certainly be taken into account if data where available on a wider frequency range . to summarize , we have shown in this section that different schematic models applied to a same set of experimental data provide qualitatively similar results . we have found that they are in good quantitative agreement for the determination of the values of the parameters that have been distinguished in the previous section , provided no non - generic features , the importance of which has been emphasized for the f@xmath72 model , interfere with their determination . in the previous section , we have tried to validate the schematic approach and its results showing that different models provide consistent results when applied to a same set of experimental data . however , on various aspects , this study is not quite satisfactory . indeed , despite favorable indications gained from the use of the f@xmath79 model , the meaningfulness of the anomalous behavior of the effective vertices at low temperature remains to be assessed . in our previous work @xcite , it has been attributed to the existence of relaxation processes that are not taken into account in the ideal mct and that make it impossible to describe consistently the dynamics of the studied systems with a schematic model based on this theory . to strengthen this point of view , it would be necessary to show that the schematic approach is actually able to give an account of a complex purely mode - coupling dynamics with smoothly varying fitting parameters , despite of the extreme simplicity of the schematic equations compared to the complexity of the equations of the original problem . moreover , it would be interesting to analyze data for which the values of the essential parameters @xmath21 , @xmath31 et @xmath46 are known in advance , in order to check to what extent the schematic approach is able to provide quantitative estimates for them . a possibility to perform such a test is to calculate series of curves from mode - coupling equations known in advance and to analyze them as one would do for any set of experimental data . it remains then to compare the results obtained within the schematic approach with the properties that can be directly determined from the starting equations . we report the results of such a test in the present section . recently , franosch _ et al . _ have proposed a detailed study of the mct predictions for the collective dynamics of a simple liquid , with special emphasis on the asymptotic laws valid in the vicinity of the ideal glass transition and their corrections @xcite . because their model has been very well and extensively characterized , it appears clearly as the model of choice to be the basis of the present evaluation of the schematic approach . besides it has already been used in a similar spirit for a critical study of the method consisting of the use of numerical fits of the @xmath35 correlator for experimental tests of the mct @xcite . the model is based on the mode - coupling equations for the brownian dynamics of the hard - sphere fluid with particle diameter @xmath88 , the thermodynamic state of which is determined by a single parameter , the compacity @xmath89 , related to the number density @xmath90 through the relation @xmath91 . one starts with the generalized langevin equations for the time evolution of the fourier components of the normalized density - density correlation functions @xmath92 , [ hsmodel ] @xmath93 with the initial condition @xmath94 . @xmath95 is chosen equal to @xmath96 , where @xmath97 is some arbitrary molecular time scale and @xmath98 is the structure factor of the fluid . the mode - coupling memory kernel , defined as a double integral in fourier space ( thus a six - dimensional integral ) , is approximated after moving to bipolar coordinates , by the riemann sum of the resulting two - dimensional integral on a grid of @xmath99 equidistant values of the wave vector modulus , with a grid step @xmath100 such that the @xmath101 values vary between @xmath102 and @xmath103 . one obtains @xmath104 ^ 2 \phi_k(t)\phi_p(t),\ ] ] with @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 and @xmath108 , @xmath109 , @xmath110 . @xmath111 is the direct correlation function related to the structure factor through the ornstein - zernike relation @xmath112 . as in previous works@xcite , the static quantities have been computed within the percus - yevick approximation , @xmath113 and @xmath114 have been used , and the length and time units have been chosen such that @xmath115 and @xmath116 . one finds then that the ideal glass transition of the model occurs at a compacity @xmath117 comprised between @xmath118 and @xmath119 . this model aims to represent the dynamics of a hard - sphere colloidal suspension and has been shown to compare very favorably at a quantitative level with the experimental data of van megen _ et al _ @xcite . the equations have been solved following the algorithm described in ref . , then the associated susceptibilities have been computed by fourier transform using filon s algorithm . we concentrate on the susceptibilities , for which it has been shown that the range of validity of the asymptotic laws is usually smaller than for the corresponding correlation functions @xcite , in order to be as close as possible to the situations in which the schematic approach is usually applied to experimental data . five values of the compacity such that the distances to the ideal glass transition are @xmath120 have been considered . larger @xmath121 values have been excluded , since they would correspond to spectra covering a much wider frequency range compared to the experimental situation . we have analyzed spectra for three values of the wave vector modulus : @xmath122 , corresponding to the main peak of the structure factor , @xmath123 , corresponding to the first minimum after the main peak , and @xmath124 , where certain pre - asymptotic corrections seem to be rather small . having now our reference spectra to be used as input like experimental data would be , each series of curves at a given @xmath125 value has been fitted with the two correlator f@xmath1 model referred to as model iv in the previous section . for compatibility reasons , no inertial term is included , i.e. one has @xmath126 note that an inertial term would be required both in the microscopic theory and in a schematic model to study a molecular glassformer , the dynamics of which is newtonian , and to reproduce its oscillatory dynamics in the raman band or in the boson - peak region . however , for the goal we wish to achieve here , i.e. an assessment of the shape of the vertex trajectory and the calculation of the critical parameters of the theory from model theoretical spectra , the fact that it has been consistently omitted in the original model and in the schematic equations is irrelevant . no amplitude factor is needed , since the data are already normalized ( to check this point , a few calculations have been done with such a factor , showing that it remains equal to 1 ) . as above , only the effective vertices @xmath14 and @xmath15 are allowed to vary with @xmath127 . this means in particular that constant values of @xmath128 and @xmath129 are imposed , despite the fact that the @xmath95 values of the original equations actually change with compacity through @xmath98 . the quality of the fits is good , comparable to what is obtained when experimental light - scattering spectra are analyzed , as illustrated in fig . [ fiths ] . values obtained for the various adjustable mode - coupling parameters are reported in table [ hstab ] and in fig . [ hsvert ] . * 7c @xmath125 & & & + & schem . & theor . & schem . & theor . & schem . & theor . + @xmath17 & 20.3 & & 1.8 & & 0.58 + @xmath53 & 0.102 & & 0.329 & & 0.503 + @xmath130 & 0.5153 & 0.5159 & 0.5155 & 0.5159 & 0.5154 & 0.5159 + @xmath21 & 0.678 & 0.735 & 0.676 & 0.735 & 0.679 & 0.735 + @xmath131 & 0.846 & 0.849 & 0.414 & 0.419 & 0.268 & 0.269 + @xmath132 & 0.306 & 0.323 & 0.738 & 0.642 & 0.603 & 0.582 + @xmath133 & 2.48 & 1.54 & 1.36 & 1.54 & 1.81 & 1.54 + @xmath134 & 0.849 & 0.779 & 1.513 & 1.548 & 1.433 & 1.403 as usual , the effective vertices are the important parameters of the calculation . to each series of curves corresponds a different set of effective vertices , stressing the fact that the study of a single observable is not enough to give an unequivocal account of the dynamics of the system . here again , this is a consequence of the non - universality of the @xmath0 relaxation as described in the mct framework . the important observation is that the behavior of the effective vertices is perfectly regular : @xmath14 and @xmath15 are approximately linear with @xmath135 ( and thus @xmath14 is linear with @xmath15 ) . nothing similar to what has been found with experimental data close to the transition line shows up in the results . this tends to confirm the assumption that the anomalous behavior found from experiments and attributed to the avoidance of the ideal glass transition is not connected to a technical limitation of the schematic approach , but actually , at a more fundamental level , to the inadequateness of ideal mct in a temperature domain starting noticeably above the extrapolated ideal glass transition point . we can now determine the critical parameter values by extrapolating the linear behavior we have found and compare the results with those obtained directly from the original equations , in order to see if the procedure we have used previously is meaningful and if the corresponding results are quantitative . the values are reported in table [ hstab ] . of the three parameters whose importance has been stressed in section [ sec3 ] , @xmath131 is clearly the one for which the agreement between the original value and the schematic calculation is the best . the determination of @xmath134 is less precise but remains satisfactory . on the contrary , a notable disagreement on the value of the crucial exponent parameter @xmath21 is found . the difference we find is significant and shows unambiguously that the schematic approach does not allow _ a priori _ to obtain the exact value of the exponent parameter , at least when the studied dynamics only covers a frequency range of the order of four or five decades . from this point of view , the schematic approach suffers from the same difficulties as the use of the @xmath35 correlator , which has been shown not to be able to give the value of @xmath21 in the same conditions @xcite . it has however to be stressed that , even if it is not perfect , the schematic approach turns out to perform much better than the latter approach . surprisingly , it is found that the three series of curves do not provide values scattered around the exact value @xmath136 , but instead , the same underestimated value is consistently found at all three wave numbers . it seems thus very likely that no improvement would be obtained if the three observables were analyzed in a unified framework , in the spirit of the most recent schematic calculations @xcite . the origin of the present problem is strictly connected to the existence in the analyzed data of corrections to the asymptotic behavior predicted by the theory and not to a deficiency of the schematic approach . indeed , when spectra corresponding to larger values of @xmath121 ( i.e. corresponding to compacity values closer to the critical one ) are analyzed , a slight change in the behavior of the effective vertices occurs around @xmath137 and the trajectory described in the @xmath63 plane bends to indicate the point of the transition line corresponding to the correct value of @xmath21 . we stress , to avoid any ambiguity , that this change of behavior has nothing to do with the one found from experimental data : its amplitude is very small and it occurs in a domain where the points representative of the system in the @xmath63 plane are extremely close to the ideal glass transition line , meaning that the dynamics spreads over more than eight decades in frequency and corresponding for a real glassformer like ckn to a regime where the behavior of the effective vertices is already strongly affected by the existence of activated processes . in this paper we have proposed a detailed study of the schematic mode - coupling approach to experimental data . our aim was twofold . first , we wanted to settle the whole approach on firmer theoretical grounds , through a better understanding of the parameterization it involves and a clarification of the nature of the results it can provide . indeed , the schematic approach involves a certain degree of arbitrariness in the choice of the models to be used and the introduction of numerous adjustable parameters , which are never considered as good things when it comes to testing a theory . thus in order to credibilize the whole approach , one has to address these _ a priori _ problematic issues and show that they are actually harmless . hence this investigation , whose outcome is the formulation of simple rules that need to be taken into account in order to define minimal schematic models suitable for use in this context and the isolation of a few parameters which are particularly relevant for the description of the dynamics and for which the schematic approach should provide estimates . following these criteria , it turns out that most previous schematic studies are based on well designed schematic models and use parameterizations which are close to the minimal one , in particular by letting only effective vertices vary with temperature . secondly , our goal was a validation of the approach , through the investigation of its robustness and of its potential quantitative character by a variety of numerical tests . the results are rather satisfactory . indeed , we have been able to validate the results obtained in ref . and the way they were analyzed . we have shown that they have a limited , if any , dependency in the schematic model we use and we have been able to identify and rule out many potential biases that could have affected our results . most properties of the dynamics whose relevance have been emphasized in the theoretical discussion of the approach appear to be quantitatively evaluated , with the notable exception of the exponent parameter @xmath21 , for which the method is not too bad , but still far from perfect . it has thus to be stressed that the precise and unambiguous determination of this parameter , which actually plays a very important role in the theory , remains elusive , by any of the methods that are available so far : all calculations indeed seem to be too sensitive to the presence of significant pre - asymptotic corrections ( as is shown here or , in the case of the use of the @xmath35 correlator , by ref . ) and very probably to the existence of crossover effects due to the non - ideal behavior of real and simulated glassformers @xcite . in conclusion , we believe that the present work paves the way to new applications of the schematic approach . indeed , the interest of the method to analyze experimental data has been emphasized in all previous works and we think its relevance has been further strengthened here . however , at this level , it was only a kind of simple phenomenological mode - coupling approach and the main issue was its ability to consistently describe a set of experimental data with a simple model . now , from our results , it seems possible to go one step further and to use this approach as an effective means to obtain precise estimates of transition temperatures , non - ergodicity parameters and critical amplitudes to be used for instance in quantitative tests of the mct on simple systems that are amenable to a full first - principle treatment . the authors are indebted to prof . w. gtze and dr . m. fuchs for providing them the codes for some parts of the calculations . we are also grateful to prof . cummins and dr . g. li for the use of their experimental data . dr . g. tarjus is acknowledged for fruitful discussions . w. gtze , in _ liquids , freezing and glass transition , les houches 1989 _ , edited by j .- hansen , d. levesque , and j. zinn - justin ( north holland , amsterdam , 1991 ) , p. 287 ; w. gtze and l. sjgren , rep . prog . phys . * 55 * , 241 ( 1992 ) ; w. gtze , j. phys . : condens . matter * 11 * , a1 ( 1999 ) . schematic models have been used earlier to fit experimental data @xcite , but only to give an account of the shape of the @xmath0 relaxation , and not of the evolution with temperature of the full dynamics as in the more recent schematic approaches . g. li , w. m. du , x. k. chen , h. z. cummins , and n. j. tao , phys . rev . a * 45 * , 3867 ( 1992 ) ; h. z. cummins , w. m. du , m. fuchs , w. gtze , s. hildebrand , a. latz , g. li , and n. j. tao , phys . e * 47 * , 4223 ( 1993 ) . n. v. surotsev , j. a. h. wiedersich , v. n. novikov , e. rssler , and a. p. sokolov , phys . b * 58 * , 14888 ( 1998 ) ; j. gapiski , w. steffen , a. patkowski , a. p. sokolov , a. kisliuk , u. buchenau , m. russina , f. mezei , and h. schober , j. chem . phys . * 110 * , 2312 ( 1999 ) ; h. c. barshilia , g. li , g. q. shen , and h. z. cummins , phys e * 59 * , 5625 ( 1999 ) . @xmath65 and @xmath66 can be defined in various ways . a rigorous definition based on a bifurcation theory analysis has been proposed by gtze and sjgren @xcite , but more simple _ ad hoc _ choices can be used , like taking the values of the non - ergodicity parameters at the point of the transition line such that the corresponding exponent parameter @xmath21 maximizes @xmath141 ( remember that @xmath29 is negative in the ergodic domain ) . w. van megen and p. n. pusey , phys . a * 43 * , 5429 ( 1991 ) ; w. van megen , s. m. underwood , and p. n. pusey , phys . rev . lett . * 67 * , 1586 ( 1991 ) ; w. van megen and s. m. underwood , phys . rev . a * 47 * , 248 ( 1993 ) ; phys . * 70 * , 2766 ( 1993 ) ; phys . rev . e * 49 * , 4206 ( 1994 ) . a very well documented illustration of this fact is provided by the simulation work of w. kob and h. c. andersen [ phys . * 73 * , 1376 ( 1994 ) ; phys . e * 51 * , 4626 ( 1995 ) ; * 52 * , 4134 ( 1995 ) ] , where rather different values of @xmath21 are obtained depending on the method of analysis and the considered observable .

we propose a detailed investigation of the schematic mode - coupling approach to experimental data , a method based on the use of simple mode - coupling equations to analyze the dynamics of supercooled liquids . our aim here is to clarify different aspects of this approach that appeared so far uncontrolled or arbitrary , and to validate the results obtained from previous works . analyzing the theoretical foundations of the approach , we first identify the parameters of the theory playing a key role and obtain simple requirements to be met by a schematic model for its use in this context . then we compare the results obtained from the schematic analysis of a given set of experimental data with a variety of models and show that they are all perfectly consistent . a number of potential biases in the method are identified and ruled out by the choice of appropriate models . finally , reference spectra computed from the mode - coupling theory for a model simple liquid are analyzed along the same lines as experimental data , allowing us to show that , despite the strong simplification in the description of the dynamics it involves , the method is free from spurious artifacts and provides accurate estimates of important parameters of the theory . the only exception is the exponent parameter , the evaluation of which is hindered , as for other methods , by corrections to the asymptotic laws of the theory present when the dynamics is known only in a limited time or frequency range .

astro-ph0009136

if quantum gravity lies fundamentally in ten spatial dimensions , then the seven `` extra '' dimensions must somehow be hidden . the traditional approach , going back to kaluza and klein , is to make extra dimensions very small , close the planck scale . recently there has been a resurgence of interest in another approach where many of the extra dimensions are of much larger size@xcite . the standard model fields are confined to a three - dimensional wall or `` brane '' , a 3-d defect in the higher - dimensional space ; only gravity can propagate in the other dimensions or `` bulk '' . these ideas are observationally constrained from the particle - physics side and from the gravity side . roughly speaking , the success of the standard model limits the unification energy scale to energies well above 1 tev , although some of the most interesting brane+bulk scenarios are those where the unification scale is not many orders of magnitude more than a tev , providing a solution to to the `` hierarchy problem . '' laboratory measurements of gravity limit the size ( or radius of curvature ) of the extra dimensions to be smaller than about 0.3 mm@xcite . constraints of a model - dependent nature , including astrophysical ones , extend these limits , since the models generally add new particles and interactions to the standard model ( e.g.,@xcite ) . a broad range of unification scales and brane configurations is consistent with current constraints ; the unification scale and extra dimension size can be anywhere between the tev / mm limits and the planck scale . this broad range of possibilities of course just reflects the relative lack of data in the physics / cosmology `` desert '' . standard unification ideas often show running couplings extrapolated from actual experiments at 100 gev by 14 orders of magnitude to the unification scale at @xmath5 gev , but there are few direct particle data beyond the tev scale . a similar lacuna appears in the cosmological data ; we can cite direct information from cosmic abundances about microphysical processes as early as 1 mev , which can be affected by inhomogeneities originating as early as 100 gev ( e.g. @xcite ) and about earlier inflationary effects on very large scales ( such the microwave background anisotropy , e.g. @xcite ) , but we have almost no direct data about early `` mesoscopic '' structure on comoving scales smaller than a few centimeters at 100 gev ( a quantity of energy about equal to the mass of the earth ) at times earlier than @xmath6 second ( except possibly for the mean baryon - to - photon ratio and the mean density of some forms of dark matter . ) scalar metric perturbations are very effectively erased on these small scales by neutrino diffusion long before they can have any effect on observables such as element abundances@xcite . small - scale perturbations in baryon / photon ratio @xmath7 on small scales , even of large amplitude , are erased by nucleon diffusion before nucleosynthesis@xcite . from most of cosmic history ( in log space ) since the planck time , and on most scales of structure , only the tensor modes gravitational waves survive to the present . new gravitational wave observatories now under development will soon achieve a critical level of sensitivity at frequencies where they can plausibly detect the relic stochastic background of gravitational waves from cosmological events far into the early , previously unobservable `` mesoscopic '' era . one of the most interesting possible sources of radiation , from the point of view of both physics and cosmology , is the formation of our 3-brane . this paper surveys broadly the circumstances and the values of parameters the number and the size of large extra dimensions , and the scale of unification for which the background might be detected with current technology . to create a detectable background , the metric during the unification era must be far from equilibrium it must be close ( within a few orders of magnitude ) to chaotic on the mesoscopic scale of the horizon at unification . such circumstances can indeed be more generic than the usual assumption of a uniform equlibrium system . the brane+bulk configurations being contemplated are classical setups : the vacua of the fundamental theory have effective potentials that tend to drive them to forming classical three - dimensional defects . the details of the stabilization of the setup are not known but the cosmological formation of such defects is in general not an equilibrium achieved by a microscopic quantum process it involves macroscopic ( or at least mesoscopic ) collective dynamics , in the same way that spontaneous symmetry breaking occurs in the standard higgs mechanism . in the cosmological context , symmetry breaking during the setting up of the brane is likely to create gravitational waves via mechanisms analogous to such intense classical sources as cosmic strings or first - order phase transitions . the properties of the waves can be informative about both the physics of the brane and its early cosmological history . the formation and stabilization of the brane are associated with two new geometrical degrees of freedom , radion modes governing the size or curvature of the extra dimensions and nambu - goldstone modes corresponding to spatial variations in brane displacement@xcite . the characteristic scales of the resulting broadband background spectra can be estimated from general scaling considerations . the characteristic amplitude of the metric perturbations induced by brane condensation is of the the order of unity and the characteristic frequency is the horizon scale . we will use the `` maximal amplitude '' and `` hubble frequency '' to estimate the extra - dimensional scales accessible to gravitational wave detectors . the characteristic scale for setting up our 3 + 1 world is the gravitational timescale @xmath8 in standard 3 + 1 general relativity . this is cleanly determined by general relativity and thermodynamics except for a weak dependence on the particle - physics uncertainties encapsulated in the number of effective relativistic degrees of freedom @xmath9 ( e.g.@xcite ) . the characteristic frequency of observed gravitational waves is thus@xcite the hubbble frequency redshifted to the present day , @xmath10 : @xmath11 the estimate is valid back to the threshold of the extradimensional dynamics : @xmath12 , ( where @xmath13 is the size or curvature radius of the largest extra dimension ) , or @xmath14 , whichever comes first . the fiducial `` maximal '' energy density is set@xcite by the mean energy density in all relativistic species ( photons and three massless neutrinos ) , @xmath15 , where @xmath16 refers to the hubble constant . the energy density of relativistic matter redshifts in the same way as gravitational waves so they have the same ratio of energy densities today as when the waves were generated . ( constraints from nucleosynthesis limit the gravitational waves to about 10% or less of the relativistic matter density , or rms strain about three times smaller than the maximal value . ) at the low frequencies observed by spacecraft interferometers ( such as lisa ) there are many astrophysical foregrounds , including known sources such as galactic binaries . a stochastic background can however be distinguished from other sources of noise and astrophysical wave sources by resolving the background in frequency . for the projected sensitivity of lisa , a maximal background is detectable above the instrument noise or the other likely astrophysical foregrounds@xcite over a frequency range from about @xmath17 to @xmath18hz . in the center of this range , @xmath19hz , backgrounds are detectable with @xmath20 at the higher frequencies observed by ground - based observatories ( e.g. , ligo , virgo , tama300 , geo600 ) it could well be that other stochastic astrophysical backgrounds are relatively weak , and that the observable sources are so limited in time duration and frequency that the main contribution to the rms noise comes from the instrument itself . in this case we can use the entire bandwidth to measure the background and reach a level which places meaningful constraints on backgrounds@xcite . the most promising technique is to correlate the signals from two interferometers within a wavelength of each other . combining two early ligo or virgo systems will likely achieve a sensitivity@xcite @xmath21 and ligo ii may reach another two orders of magnitude below this@xcite close to the level where other stochastic astrophysical backgrounds ( such as neutron star emission ) may be expected . sufficient sensitivity to constrain primordial stochastic backgrounds may be expected for early ground - based interferometers roughly from 50 to 500 hz . there are many possible `` brane worlds '' with various configurations of large extra dimensions . to simplify the discussion we will assume that there are @xmath22 equal - size largest extra dimensions of size @xmath13 and all the others are much smaller , of size @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the true fundamental unification scale . the apparent ( usual ) planck mass in 3 + 1-d , @xmath25 , is approximately given by @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the volume of the extra dimensions . in our situation , @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the volume of @xmath22 extra large dimensions . thus each choice of @xmath22 defines a relation between @xmath24 and @xmath13 , shown in figure [ fig : variousn ] . the various relations intersect at @xmath30 : @xmath31 gravity is `` normal '' law for @xmath32 , and @xmath33 for @xmath34 . ] on scales larger than @xmath13 ; standard field theory holds on the brane at energies below @xmath24 . the cosmological formation of the brane setup is regulated on the gravitational timescale . in the 3 + 1-d era , this is just given by the hubble scale discussed above , @xmath35 which defines the usual gravitational relationship between length and energy . if we follow 3 + 1-d cosmology back using this equation , we come first to either ( 1 ) the time when @xmath36 and extra - dimensional effects come into play on a small scale , possibly associated with a first - order phase transition ; or ( 2 ) the time when @xmath37 , and the geometrical degrees of freedom of the extra dimensions are important even on large scales . in general the excitation of the extra - dimensional modes has a different character depending on whether @xmath38 lies above or below the hubble relation @xmath39 . the former case produces displacement modes at with a scale determined by @xmath13 ; the latter case produces radion modes with a scale determined by @xmath24 . the hubble relation @xmath40 is degenerate with the @xmath41 relation between @xmath13 and @xmath24 , meaning that in this case macroscopic and microscopic departures from the standard picture happen at about the same time . the transition to new microscopic unification physics and to 5-dimensional cosmological expansion would both happen at the same point on these lines , also corresponding to the condensation of the brane and the creation of the gravitational waves . in the @xmath42 case where @xmath43 , the condensation of the brane ( at @xmath36 ) takes place while the hubble length is still much smaller than @xmath13 . in this case a long evolution takes place after the brane forms ( and non - gravitational fields are confined to 3d as today ) , during which the cosmological evolution involves one classically large extra dimension and the usual relativistic cosmology does not apply . in particular there is not time for signals to propagate as far as @xmath13 in an expansion time . if the formation of the brane spontaneously breaks poincar invariance of the whole spacetime , the position of the brane when it condenses is therefore uncorrelated on scales larger than @xmath44 and less than @xmath13 . the nambu - goldstone modes corresponding to brane displacement are therefore substantially excited by the kibble mechanism@xcite up to wavelength @xmath13 . these large - amplitude scalar perturbations dynamically couple to the tensor modes to produce a gravitational wave background , in much the same way that gravitational waves are generated by defects confined to a 3 + 1-d space@xcite . the spectrum is peaked at the corresponding redshifted hubble frequency @xmath45 and falls off as a power law at higher and lower frequencies . the spectrum at high frequencies depends on details of the @xmath46-d era of cosmic evolution , but may be as strong as @xmath47 constant ; at lower frequencies , it is estimated@xcite to fall off as @xmath48 . in the @xmath49 case where @xmath50 , the universe can find itself in a macroscopic space of conventional 3-d dimensionality ( on the hubble scale ) at the temperature where new extra - dimensional unification physics comes into play on a microscopic scale . conventional cosmology can therefore be used as a framework . the stabilization of the @xmath49 extra dimensions appears as a change of physics , nongravitational and gravitational , which can be described macroscopically as a change in the energy - momentum tensor of cosmic matter , and may be ( 3d- ) spatially inhomogeneous as a result of symmetry breaking . the excitation of these `` radion modes '' can be described as a change in the order parameter of a vacuum state in 3d , as is familiar in cosmological phase transitions . if this transition described by the effective radion potential is first order , free energy is released in macroscopic flows created by bubble nucleation and collisions , and can have a substantial gravitational - wave component@xcite , although for most plausible situations these backgrounds are several orders of magnitude weaker than @xmath51 . figure [ fig : variousn ] illustrates that the phase - transition bubbles are smaller than the horizon and the peak of the spectrum lies significantly higher than the redshifted hubble frequency . although based on a simplified picture , figure [ fig : variousn ] illustrates accurately the wide range of @xmath52 potentially accessible via this technique . the possibilities include both the radion and nambu - goldstone displacement modes , and include , for some @xmath24 and @xmath13 , all likely values of @xmath22 . the observatories constrain theories with values of these parameters including the limits accessible by other means , near @xmath53 tev and @xmath54 mm , and extending beyond this range by many orders of magnitude . for example , direct laboratory gravitational experiments become extremely challenging below the mm scale , whereas primordial gravitational wave backgrounds at the highest detectable frequencies ( about 1 khz ) probe new classical spacetime dimensions directly ( via the displacement modes ) on scales 14 orders of magnitude smaller aided by the cosmological redshift which stretches the waves to detectable wavelengths . even a nondetection of backgrounds will constrain the behavior of theories with these numbers and sizes of extra dimensions . of particular interest are the models which potentially solve the hierarchy problem , where @xmath24 is not many orders of magnitude more than 1 tev . for these models , backgrounds in the lisa band can arise from all the viable numbers of extra dimensions ( @xmath41 to @xmath55 ) , and a large range of dimension sizes @xmath56 mm , depending on @xmath22 . ( it is already known that the @xmath42 case requires a unification scale of at least @xmath57 tev to be consistent with the eotwash limits ) . the ligo / virgo frequencies probe much higher energy unification scales , from @xmath58 to @xmath3 tev , and @xmath13 less than @xmath59 mm . the intermediate range of @xmath13 and @xmath24 , corresponding to the frequency gap between these two sets of experiments , would be obervable with a space interferometer with a smaller baseline than lisa . the smallest dimension accessible is determined by the highest frequency , which is set by the photon noise limit of ligo or its successors . it is reasonable to expect high sensitivity with this technology up to about 1 khz , which probes displacement modes down to @xmath60 mm . the largest @xmath24 probed ( corresponding to @xmath42 ) can be as high as about @xmath3 tev ; the smallest @xmath13 ( corresponding to @xmath55 ) can be as short as @xmath4 mm . there are no known strong astrophysical sources of gravitational radiation above @xmath61hz , so new types of experiments at higher frequency , with sufficient sensitivity ( i.e. @xmath62 ) , would probe even more extreme physics with little astrophysical contamination . as an aside , it is interesting to consider the traditional case with all the extra dimensions at the classical planck scale . this point corresponds to @xmath63 for any value of @xmath22 . ( the relation @xmath64 shown in figure [ fig : variousn ] for other values of @xmath24 corresponds to the @xmath65 limit of equation [ eqn : gauss ] . ) the gravitational wave background in this model has a peak frequency of about @xmath66 hz , or a peak wavelength of about 0.3 mm ! although the maximal classical background typically has @xmath3 times more energy density than tensor perturbations from inflationary quantum effects , . this is most easily detected on comoving scales close to the present - day hubble length , @xmath67 hz , where background radiation anisotropy implies an amplitude @xmath68 . of course the amplitude might be very different on the scales of the @xmath18 to 1000 hz waves considered here , but since @xmath69 generally decreases slowly during inflation the `` tilt '' from a scale - free spectrum generally makes @xmath70 smaller at higher frequencies . the energy density of this background is @xmath71 times smaller than the maximal value ( @xmath72 ) and is likely to be unobservable . ] there is no plausible technique for detecting a gravitational wave background at such high frequencies . in models enclosed by the boxes in figure [ fig : variousn ] , properties of these backgrounds can in some circumstances provide measurements of the main parameters of the largest extra dimensions : @xmath22 , @xmath13 and @xmath24 . for example , suppose that a stochastic background is detected with various signatures ( such as anisotropy statistics ) leading us to suspect that it comes from high redshift . if the background is within one or two orders of magnitude of @xmath51 it is likely from a displacement mode . this in turn indicates that @xmath42 or @xmath41 one or two extra dimensions are much larger than the rest . since only @xmath42 undergoes a substantial period of classical expansion with @xmath73 , the background spectra in these two situations are likely to be qualitatively different : the @xmath41 spectrum is more sharply peaked at @xmath74 and the @xmath42 spectrum includes a more intense high - frequency tail from modes excited before @xmath75 . knowing @xmath22 , the frequency of the spectral peak then provides an estimate of @xmath13 and @xmath24 . a nondection of a displacement - mode background conveys a significant constraint on parameters and on cosmology since the conditions for generating a background from symmetry breaking in this regime are relatively generic . in the case of the @xmath76 radion modes , it is difficult to break the degeneracies using just the information available from the background measurements . for example , the peak frequency and intensity depend on the details of bubble nucleation dynamics as well as on @xmath74 ; these in turn depend on the details of the effective radion potential . that is , a weaker transition leads to a smaller nucleation scale , a higher frequency peak and a less intense background . ( the interpretation of the background might in the case of lisa - band backgrounds be supplemented by other data , since the energy scale @xmath24 is not too far above energies accessible by direct experiment . ) a nondetection in this regime will only constrain the corresponding parameters in particular models ; lack of a background could just mean that the relevant transition is not strongly first order , but occurs gently and does not generate intense gravitational waves . i am grateful for useful discussions with e. adelberger , b. allen , b. barish , p. bender , d. kaplan , a. nelson , and k. thorne . i thank the albert einstein institute , golm , the ligo hanford observatory , and jpl for hospitality . this work was supported at the university of washington by nsf . hogan , c. j. 2000 , phys . 85 , 2044 applegate , j. and hogan , c. j. 1985 , phys . d 31 , 3037 r. a. malaney and g. j. mathews , phys . 229 , 1445 , 1993 kainulainen , k. , kurki - suonio , h. , and sihvola , e. phys.rev . d59 , 083505 ( 1999 ) heckler , a. and hogan , c. j. , phys . d 47 4256 ( 1993 ) arkani - hamed , n. , dimopoulos , s. , and dvali , g. phys . b429 , 263 ( 1998 ) antoniadas , i. , arkani - hamed , n. , dimopoulos , s. , and dvali , g. , phys . b436 , 257 ( 1998 ) arkani - hamed , n. , dimopoulos , s. , and dvali , g. phys . d59 , 086004 ( 1999 ) randall , l. and sundrum , r. , phys.rev.lett . 83 , 3370 ( 1999 ) randall , l. , and sundrum , r. , phys . 83 , 460 ( 1999 ) lykken , j. and randall , l. , j. high en . 0006 , 014 ( 2000 ) hoyle , c. d. , heckel , b. , adelberger , e. , schmidt , u. , gundlach , j. , swenson , e. , & kapner , d. , in preparation ( 2000 ) goldberger , w. d. and wise , m. , `` phenomenology of a stabilized modulus , '' hep - ph/9911457 kaplan , d. b. and wise , m. , `` couplings of a light dilaton and violations of the equivalence principle '' , hep - ph/0008116 kolb , e. w. and turner , m. s. , _ the early universe _ , ( addison - wesley,1990 ) hogan , c. j. , `` cosmological gravitational wave backgrounds , '' in _ second international lisa symposium on the detection and observation of gravitational waves in space _ , aip conference proceedings 456 , ed . w. m. folkner , pp . 79 - 86 ( 1999 ) , astro - ph/9809364 maggiore , m. , `` gravitational wave experiments and early universe cosmology '' , phys . rep . in press ( 2000 ) , gr - qc/9909001 maggiore , m. , `` stochastic backgrounds of gravitational waves '' , gr - qc/0008027 lisa study team , _ lisa pre - phase a report _ ( 1998 ) ; this document and others are available at http://lisa.jpl.nasa.gov/documents/ armstrong , j. w. , estabrook , f. b. , and tinto , m. , astrophys . j. 527 , 814 ( 1999 ) allen , b. , in _ les houches school on astrophysical sources of gravitational waves _ , eds . jean - alain marck and jean - pierre lasota , ( cambridge university press , 1996 ) ; gr - qc/9604033 k. thorne , private communication zeldovich , ya . b. , kobzarev , i. yu . and okun , l. b. , zh . eksp . 67 , 3 ( 1974)[sov . jetp 40 , 1 ( 1975 ) ] . kibble , t. w. b. , j. phys . a 9 , 1387 ( 1976 ) vilenkin , a. , phys . 48 , 59 ( 1982 ) krauss , l. m. , phys . b 284 , 229 ( 1992 ) hogan , c. j. , phys . lett . 74,3105 ( 1995 ) witten , e. , phys . d 30 , 272 ( 1984 ) hogan , c. j. , mon . not . 218 , 629 ( 1986 ) kamionkowski , m. , kosowsky , a. , and turner , m. s. , phys.rev . d 49 , 2837 ( 1994 ) gleiser , m . and roberts , r. , phys.rev.lett . 81 , 5497 ( 1998 )

circumstances are described in which symmetry breaking during the formation of our three - dimensional brane within a higher - dimensional space in the early universe excites mesoscopic classical radion or brane - displacement degrees of freedom and produces a detectable stochastic background of gravitational radiation . the spectrum of the background is related to the unification energy scale and the the sizes and numbers of large extra dimensions . it is shown that properties of the background observable by gravitational - wave observatories at frequencies @xmath0 hz to @xmath1 hz contain information about unification on energy scales from @xmath2 to @xmath3 tev , gravity propagating through extra - dimension sizes from 1 mm to @xmath4 mm , and the dynamical history and stabilization of from one to seven extra dimensions .

1601.03891

complex networks @xcite have been conjectured to be embedded in hidden metric spaces , in which distances among nodes encode their similarity and , thus , their likelihood of being connected @xcite . this hypothesis , combined with a suitable underlying space , has offered a geometric interpretation of the complex topologies observed in real networks , including scale - free degree distributions , the small - world effect , strong clustering as a reflection of the triangle inequality , and self - similarity . it has also explained their efficient inter - node communication without a knowledge of the complete structure @xcite . moreover , it has been shown that for networks whose degree distribution is scale - free , the natural geometry of their underlying metric space is hyperbolic @xcite . all these results have then been used to propose geometric models for real growing networks that reproduce their evolution and in which preferential attachment emerges from local optimization principles @xcite . finally , mapping real complex networks into a hidden metric space has yielded a sustainable solution to the scaling limitations of the internet @xcite , and has shed light on the hierarchical organization of biochemical pathways in cells @xcite . these achievements have been accomplished while considering a _ binary _ network representation in which links either exist or are absent . there exists , however , a class of complex networks for which the magnitude of the interactions between nodes ( i.e. , the weights ) plays a central role in their structural organization and dynamics @xcite . for instance , the quantification of the rich - club effect in real weighted networks , in sharp contrast to results in unweighted representations , unveils the formation of alliances in multipolarized environments or the lack of cohesion even in the presence of rich - club ordering @xcite . similarly , the propagation of emergent diseases in the international airports network is intimately linked to the number of passengers flying from one airport to the other @xcite . a shift towards a paradigm of weighted networks is therefore in order to fully understand the interplay between their structural organization and their function . while several models have been proposed to address this matter @xcite , none of them , except to some extent the maximum - entropy class of models @xcite , is general enough to reproduce the topology and weighted structure of real weighted complex networks . in this paper , we present a general and versatile class of weighted networks embedded in hidden metric spaces . built upon the so - called _ newtonian _ class of binary networks in hidden metric spaces @xcite , our framework preserves all the qualities of complex topologies embedded in underlying metric spaces and , in addition , it allows to enforce explicitly the strength ( sum of weights of a node ) distribution and the correlation between the strength and the degree of nodes . moreover , the level of coupling between the weights and the underlying metric space enables to control the local disparity of the weights associated to the nodes @xcite as well as the shape of the weight distribution . our model lends itself to analytical treatment and includes an approach to estimate whether an underlying metric space is needed to explain the weighted features of real networks . one of the most remarkable aspects of the proposed class of models is the fact that the degree and strength distributions can be adjusted independently of the coupling with the underlying metric space . this critical property opens the path towards the uncovering of the natural geometry or real weighted complex networks . indeed , using our model , we find strong empirical evidence of metric properties in real networks , not only at the level of their topology but also in their weighted structure . our model is a nontrivial generalization to weighted networks of a class of random networks with hidden variables embedded in a metric space @xcite . in this model , @xmath0 nodes are uniformly distributed with density @xmath1 in a @xmath2-dimensional homogeneous and isotropic metric space -dimensional spheres of radius @xmath3 . however , the constraint of having constant density implies that the radius diverges in the thermodynamic limit and , thus , the metric space is equivalent to a @xmath2-dimensional euclidean space . ] , and are assigned a hidden variable @xmath4 according to the probability density function ( pdf ) @xmath5 . two nodes with hidden variables @xmath4 and @xmath6 separated by a metric distance @xmath7 are connected with a probability @xmath8 where @xmath9 is a free parameter and @xmath10 is an arbitrary positive function taking values within the interval @xmath11 . whenever the integral @xmath12 is bounded , the free parameter @xmath13 can be chosen such that @xmath14 . hence , @xmath4 corresponds to the expected degree of nodes , so the degree distribution can be specified through the pdf @xmath5 @xmath15 regardless of the specific form of @xmath10 ( see apps . [ sec : app_average_degree_of_nodes ] and [ sec : app_degree_distribution ] for details ) . the freedom in the choice of @xmath16 allows us to tune the level of coupling between the topology of the networks and the metric space , which in turn allows us to control many properties such as the clustering coefficient and the navigability @xcite . moreover , the form of the connection probability in eq . implies that networks generated with this model are small worlds for any heterogeneous pdf @xmath5 since high degree nodes are then likely to be connected regardless of the metric distance between them @xcite . to generalize this model to weighted networks , a second hidden variable @xmath17 is associated to each node . this new hidden variable can be correlated with @xmath4 so , hereafter , we assume that the pair of hidden variables @xmath18 associated with the same node are drawn from the joint pdf @xmath19 . the weight of an _ existing _ link between two nodes with hidden variables @xmath4 , @xmath17 , @xmath6 and @xmath20 , respectively , and at a metric distance @xmath7 is distributed according to the pdf @xmath21 where @xmath22 is any probability density function in the domain @xmath23 with @xmath24 , and where @xmath25 with @xmath26 and @xmath27 . the particular form of the distribution of weights eq . implies that the weight between nodes @xmath28 and @xmath29 can be written as @xmath30 where @xmath31 is a random variable drawn from the pdf function @xmath32 . equations and constitute the keystone of our model . indeed , as shown in app . [ sec : app_average_strength_of_nodes ] , the form of eq . is the only ensuring that @xmath33 , provided that the integral @xmath34 converges . the new hidden variable @xmath17 can therefore be interpreted as the expected strength of a node , and the joint pdf @xmath35 controls the correlation between degrees and strengths in the network . indeed , as shown in app . [ sec : app_average_strength_of_nodes_given_degree ] , the average strength of nodes with a given degree , @xmath36 , relates to the first moment of the conditional pdf @xmath37 , @xmath38 , through the relation @xmath39 therefore , when @xmath40 then @xmath41 . this limit stands as a good approximation for the behaviour of high degree nodes in real weighted networks . remarkably , these relations hold independently of the specific form of the connection probability @xmath10 and of the distribution of weights @xmath22 , thus conferring great versatility to our model . even more remarkable , the shape of the connection probability @xmath10 and the value of the parameter @xmath42coupling topology and weights to the metric space do not affect the relations @xmath43 and @xmath44 and , therefore , the join degree - strength distribution @xmath45 . this property conveys a degree of control over the weight distribution as well as over the disparity of nodes which is independent of the specification of degrees and strengths and , more importantly , opens the possibility to measure the metric properties of complex weighted networks . all results presented in the previous section hold in arbitrary dimension and for any form of the connection probability @xmath10 and weight probability density @xmath22 in eqs . and . to apply the formalism to real weighted networks , we particularize to the @xmath46 model as generator of the topology @xcite . in that model , we choose the circle @xmath46 of radius @xmath48 to be the underlying geometry over which nodes are uniformly distributed with density @xmath49 . distances among nodes are measured in terms of arc lengths , that is , two nodes with angular positions @xmath50 and @xmath51 are therefore at a distance @xmath52 where @xmath53 . the connection probability is set to @xmath54 where @xmath55 is a free parameter that can be used to tune the clustering . equation casts the ensemble of networks generated by the model into exponential random networks @xcite , i.e. , networks that are maximally random given the constraints imposed by the free parameters ( that is , @xmath5 and @xmath56 ) . to obtain a scale - free degree distribution , hidden variables @xmath4 are distributed according to @xmath57 with @xmath58 and @xmath59 . notice that by keeping the explicit dependence in the upper cutoff it is possible to model networks with @xmath60 and a hard cutoff , as found for instance in airport networks @xcite . moreover , since it is generally more convenient to fix the average degree @xmath61 explicitly , we choose @xmath62 such that @xmath63 and fix the remaining free parameters @xmath64 and @xmath65 externally . , i.e. , the _ natural _ cut - off of a scale - free distribution @xcite . however , in general @xmath64 can take any value in response to particular mechanisms at play , like the limited capacity to handle more than a given number of connections in the airport network . ] from eq . , we expect @xmath66 where @xmath67 is the generalized incomplete gamma function . ( the regular complete and incomplete gamma functions can be retrieved by setting the bounds @xmath68 and @xmath69 to the appropriate values ) . whenever @xmath70 , a condition holding for most realistic degree distributions , the double incomplete gamma function scales as @xmath71 with @xmath72 and @xmath73 @xcite . ] to assign weights on top of the topology generated by the model , the noise distribution in eq . is chosen to be a gamma distribution of average @xmath24 , that is , @xmath74 this particular choice allows us to interpolate with a single parameter between a zero noise limit when @xmath75 , exponential noise when @xmath76 , and strongly heterogeneous noise when @xmath77 . finally , to control the correlation between strength and degree and , therefore , to tune the strength distribution , we assume a deterministic relation between hidden variables @xmath17 and @xmath4 of the form @xmath78 , as observed in real complex networks @xcite . from eq . , we thus expect @xmath79 notice that the relation between average strength and degree in the previous expression is totally independent of the underlying metric space . it implies that the strength distribution scales as @xmath80 for @xmath81 with @xmath82 . figure [ fig : illustration ] shows the basic topological and weighted properties of a network generated using eqs . and compares them to the theoretical predictions presented in this section . apart from some expected fluctuations due to finite size , the agreement between the two is excellent . geometry has a strong effect on the strength and weight distributions , which depend on the coupling parameter @xmath42 . in fact , as shown in appendix [ sec : app_theoretical_calculations ] , the second moment of the strength distribution @xmath83 is proportional to the integral @xmath84 , which diverges whenever @xmath85 . the origin of these fluctuations is rooted in the strong constraints that geometry imposes on the weights of individual links . in the absence of coupling ( i.e. , @xmath86 ) the metric distance between nodes does not influence the magnitudes of the weights . consequently , the distribution of weights generated by the model is the original pdf in eqs . and convoluted with the distribution of values of the ratio @xmath87 . conversely , in the case of strong coupling ( i.e. , @xmath88 ) , short range links are constrained to have larger weights whereas long range ones have small weights . this effect increases the heterogeneity in the weight distribution and causes the divergence of @xmath83 when @xmath85 . figure [ fig : coupling]*a * shows this effect on synthetic networks generated with the model with identical parameters except for the value of @xmath42 . the same effect is visible in the local heterogeneity of the weights attached to a given node . to characterize such heterogeneity , we use the disparity measure defined as @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the weight of the link between nodes @xmath28 and @xmath29 ( @xmath91 if there is no link ) and @xmath92 @xcite . in fig . [ fig : coupling]*b * , we see that in the absence of coupling ( i.e. , @xmath86 ) the disparity scales as @xmath93 corresponding to the situation in which weights are roughly homogeneously distributed among the links @xcite . on the other side of the spectrum , we see that under maximal coupling ( i.e. , @xmath88 ) , the disparity decreases slower than @xmath94 meaning that weights are heterogeneous and that the large strength of nodes is due to a handful of links with large weights . as already discussed , our class of models has the critical ability to fix the local properties of the network , namely the joint degree - strength distribution , while changing the level of coupling with the metric space , quantified by parameter @xmath42 . this allows us to discern whether a metric space is needed to explain the observed topological and weighted properties of real complex networks and to compare them with synthetic networks generated with the model . given a real weighted complex network , how can we determine whether its weighted organization is influenced by any means by the properties of an underlying metric space ? an answer to this question must necessarily go through a test of the triangle inequality . the triangle inequality is one of the fundamental properties of any metric space . in simple words , it states that whenever point a is close to point b and point b is close to point c , then points a and c must also be close . in the case of networks embedded in metric spaces , the triangle inequality induces the existence of a large number of triangles in the graph and so a high clustering coefficient that remains finite even for model networks in the thermodynamic limit . considering the topology of the network without an explicit embedding of the network , a direct check of the triangle inequality is not possible as the binary structure of the graph does not contain information about distances between nodes . an indirect empirical evidence of the connection between complex networks and hidden metric spaces can nevertheless be found by analyzing the self - similarity properties of the degree - dependent clustering coefficient @xcite . in contrast , weights associated to connections among nodes in weighted networks do contain information about their distances in the metric space so that , in principle , a direct check of the triangle inequality should be possible . in order to ensure that the metric properties of triples in the graph are in correspondence to the metric properties of the corresponding triangles in the underlying space , only triples of nodes forming triangles in the graph are taken into account to evaluate the triangle inequality . there are however two main problems when one tries to apply this program . the first problem is related to the fact that connections in the @xmath47 model depend not only on angular distances but also on hidden degrees such that we need first a purely geometrical formulation of the weighted hidden metric space network model . the second issue is related to the intrinsic noise present in the system due to the stochastic nature of the processes conforming it . below , we propose a way to overcome these two limitations . notice that , as shown in @xcite , the model described by eq . is equivalent , in the one dimensional case , to a purely geometric model where nodes are embedded within a disk of radius @xmath3 in the hyperbolic plane of constant curvature @xmath96 . indeed , by mapping the hidden variable @xmath4 to a radial coordinate @xmath97 as follows @xmath98 } \ ; \;\mbox { with } \ ; \ ; r=2\ln{\left [ \frac{n}{\mu \pi \kappa_0 ^ 2}\right]}\ ] ] and keeping the same angular coordinates , the connection probability eq . can be written as @xmath99 where @xmath100 is a very good approximation of the hyperbolic distance between two points at radial coordinates @xmath97 and @xmath101 and angular separation @xmath102 . under this framework , graphs generated with our model are geometric random graphs in the hyperbolic plane and , consequently , the triangle inequality must hold in hyperbolic geometry . to check the triangle inequality , we can then select as triples of points the vertices of topological triangles in the graph , with the condition that distances between these nodes are the hyperbolic ones . by using the mapping eq . , the weight between nodes @xmath28 and @xmath29 in eq . transforms into @xmath103 from where it is possible to get an estimate of the hyperbolic distance @xmath104 between the two nodes . by using this method , the triangle inequality @xmath105 becomes @xmath106}+\ln{\left[\frac{\mu^{\alpha}}{\nu } \right]}-\frac{1}{2}\alpha r \le \ln{\left [ \frac{\epsilon_{ij } \epsilon_{jk}}{\epsilon_{ik } } \right]}.\ ] ] the first term in the left hand side of this inequality is a function of the actual weights and network topology and , thus , can be empirically measured in any network . the next two terms on the left hand side have an explicit dependence on the parameter @xmath42 also depends on @xmath42 ] , which tunes the coupling between the intensity of weights and the underlying metric space . the term in the right hand side is a noise term whose mean value is close to zero . let us first assume that this noise term is zero . in this case , the inequality should hold approximately for any value of @xmath42 equal to or larger than the value of @xmath108 used to generate the graph . the inequality does not hold exactly because some of the triangles in the graph may have been generated by chance and , thus , they are unrelated to the metric distances among their vertices . we then propose to measure , for a fixed topology and different values of @xmath42 , the triangle inequality violation spectrum @xmath109 defined as the ratio between the number of times the triangle inequality is violated ( left hand side of eq . is positive ) and the number of triangles in the graph . in the absence of noise , @xmath109 should take a very small value when @xmath110 if the weighted structure of the network is congruent with the existence of an underlying metric space . in fig . [ fig : tiv]*a * , we show @xmath109 for synthetic networks generated with the model with different values of @xmath42 . as predicted , the curves fall rapidly precisely at the real values of @xmath42 , as indicated by the dashed vertical lines . in real situations , however , noise is typically present and has an impact on function @xmath109 . indeed , [ fig : tiv]*b * shows its behavior for a fixed value of @xmath42 and different values of the noise @xmath111 . this implies that , to obtain the value of @xmath108 from the spectrum @xmath109 , we need an independent measure of the noise . for this purpose , we use the square of the coefficient of variation of the strength evaluated in appendix [ sec : app_theoretical_calculations ] , which reads @xmath112 the left hand side in this equation can be directly measured from the network . the right hand side depends linearly on the noise @xmath111 whereas its pre - factor depends both on the topology and on @xmath108 through the integrals @xmath113 and @xmath114 ( see appendix [ sec : app_theoretical_calculations ] for technical details ) . with all these results at hand , we can define a procedure to test the triangle inequality in any real complex network and , from it , to infer the value of @xmath108 that best matches the empirical observations . the test is fully described in appendix [ appendix : tiv ] . very briefly , we estimate the values of parameter @xmath42 and @xmath111 which best reproduce simultaneously the coefficient of variation of the strength in eq . and the spectrum @xmath109 of the real network . in fig . [ fig : alpharealvsinferred ] , we show the result of this program in the case of synthetic networks with different values of @xmath108 and of noise levels . as it can be seen , the inferred values of @xmath42 match the true values in most of the cases . our method also allows us to find lower bounds on the inferred values , as shown by the gray areas in fig . [ fig : alpharealvsinferred ] . the most remarkable aspect of the test is that it can be performed without any explicit embedding of the network and , thus , it can be readily applied to real networks for which an embedding is not available . in the next section , we analyze three different real weighted complex networks and show that not only the topology can be nicely reproduced by our model but also that the architecture of weights can be fully explained by the existence of a metric space . .model parameters used to reproduce real networks . note that the value of @xmath0 is not the measured value in the real network because the model generates nodes with zero degree . similarly , the value of @xmath61 is higher than the measured one to account for finite size effects . with these parameters , generated synthetic networks end up having the same number of non - zero degree nodes and average degree . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ table:1 ] next , we study three real - world weighted complex networks from different domains : version ijo1366 of the metabolic network of the bacteria _ escherichia coli ( e. coli ) _ k-12 mg1655 @xcite , the us airport network in 2013 , and the world trade web ( wtw ) @xcite . we reconstruct a metabolic network representation in which two metabolites are connected by a weighted link accounting for the number of different metabolic reactions in which both participate . in the us airport network , two airports are connected by a weighted link measuring the total number of passengers traveling between them during the year 2013 . finally , weights in the wtw measure the total trade between pairs of countries in the world during the year 2013 . due to their high average degree , the us airport network and the wtw are filtered by the disparity filter defined in @xcite to preserve the most statistically significant interactions . in the us airport network , the filtered network coincides with the network defined by regular commercial flights . in the wtw , the filter is able to recover the correlation between degrees of countries and economic indicators , in particular their gross domestic products @xcite . we applied the method described in appendix [ appendix : tiv ] to infer @xmath42 and @xmath111 for the three real networks finding strong evidence of metric properties , both at the topological and weighted levels . indeed , in fig . [ fig:5 ] , we show the triangle inequality violation curves for the three real networks studied and the same curves for synthetic networks generated by the model with values of the coupling parameter @xmath42 and noise level @xmath111 inferred by our method from the real data . in the three cases , the agreement is excellent , suggesting that the coupling with a metric space is a most plausible explanation of the observed weighted architecture . in table [ table:1 ] , we show the optimal parameters for the three networks . using these parameters , we generate synthetic networks and confront their topological and weighted properties against the _ e. coli _ metabolic network in fig . [ fig:6 ] . the agreement between the model and the real network is excellent in all measured properties . the analyses of the us airport network and the wtw is shown in fig . [ fig:7 ] and fig . [ fig:8 ] , respectively . in this work , we have presented a new class of weighted networks embedded in ( hidden ) metric spaces . this versatile class of networks explicitly prescribes the degree and strength distributions , as well as the correlation between them , independently of the coupling with the metric space . this allows us to reproduce the supra - linear relationship between strength and degree observed in real weighted complex networks and , at the same time , other relevant properties such as the weight distribution , disparity measure , and triangle inequality , which are strongly affected by the coupling with the metric space . the assessment of the triangle inequality allowed us to find strong empirical evidence of metric properties in the weighted architecture of three real complex networks from very different domains . two of them the us airport network and wtw are naturally embedded on the surface of the earth and , therefore , it would not be totally surprising to find a metric dependence at the weighted level . it is however important to notice that the distance in our model is not the geodesic distance on the earth but an effective ( hyperbolic ) distance encoding all the particularities of the system . in any case , the test of the triangle inequality that we have devised does not make use of any explicit embedding but only of the network topology and the corresponding weights and , consequently , can be applied to any weighted network . in particular , the ijo1366 metabolic network of the bacteria _ e. coli _ is not embedded in any obvious metric space . the high value of @xmath42 inferred by our method for this network , together with the high levels of clustering and the quality of the previous embedding of its topology @xcite , provides yet another empirical evidence towards the existence of hidden metric spaces shaping the architecture of this system and , more generally , of real complex networks @xcite . the class of binary networks embedded in hidden metric spaces that our new model builds upon has a purely geometrical equivalent whose natural geometry is hyperbolic @xcite . using this class of models , it has been possible to map real complex networks into the hyperbolic plane with an excellent congruency @xcite . in the case of the internet , for instance , such mapping offers a sustainable and realistic solution to the scaling limitations of the internet routing architecture . similarly , the work presented in this paper paves the way towards the unveiling of the natural geometry of weighted complex networks . this will lead to a deeper understanding of their structural organization , which will in turn offer insights on their dynamics and on the impact they have on the dynamical processes they support . we acknowledge support from the james s. mcdonnell foundation scholar award in complex systems ; the fonds de recherche du qubec nature et technologies ; the icrea academia prize , funded by the generalitat de catalunya ; the mineco project no.fis2013-47282-c2-1-p ; the generalitat de catalunya grant no.2014sgr608 ; and apvv ( project apvv-0760 - 11 ) . most of the theoretical calculations for the model presented in sec . [ sec : the_model ] are carried out using the probability density function ( pdf ) @xmath115 corresponding to the probability that a node with hidden variables @xmath4 and @xmath17 has a degree equal to @xmath116 and a strength in the interval @xmath117 . to compute this pdf , we first consider a pair of nodes whose positions in space are @xmath118 and @xmath119 and whose hidden variables are @xmath120 , @xmath121 and @xmath122 , @xmath123 , respectively . the pdf for the weight @xmath90 between these two nodes ( @xmath91 means that there is no link ) is @xmath124 \delta(w_{ij } ) + p(\kappa_i,\kappa_j , d_{ij } ) \phi(w_{ij}|\kappa_i,\sigma_i,\kappa_j,\sigma_j , d_{ij } ) \theta(w_{ij } ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath125 is the dirac delta function and @xmath126 is the left - continuous heaviside step function ( i.e. , @xmath127 ) . without loss of generality , we take the perspective of node @xmath28 , place it at the origin of the coordinate system , and integrate over the possible values of the hidden variables of node @xmath29 @xmath128 in this last equation , @xmath129 is the ( uniform ) pdf for the position of nodes in the metric space . this last expression does not depend on the position of node @xmath28 due to the isotropy , homogeneity and large size ( @xmath130 ) of the metric space . because the weights @xmath131 are assigned independently in the model , the probability that a node has a degree @xmath132 and a strength @xmath133 is equal to the product of the contribution of each potential @xmath134 links , given that the number of existing links is equal to @xmath132 and that their weights sum up to @xmath133 @xmath135 \delta\bigg(k_i - \sum_{l } \theta(w_{il } ) \bigg ) \delta\bigg(s_i - \sum_{l } w_{il } \bigg ) \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] although it is not possible to further the calculation and obtain a closed form the the pdf @xmath115 , many useful results can be obtained using its generating function defined as @xmath136 which , dropping the subscripts @xmath28 and @xmath29 , can be written as @xmath137 + p(\kappa,\kappa^\prime , d ) x \int \phi(w|\kappa,\sigma,\kappa^\prime,\sigma^\prime , d ) \mathrm{e}^{-wy } dw \bigg\ } d\bm{x^\prime } d\sigma^\prime d\kappa^\prime \bigg]^{n-1 } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] from eq . , we can readily see that the average degree of nodes with hidden variables @xmath4 and @xmath17 only depends on @xmath4 @xcite @xmath138 where @xmath5 is the marginal pdf of @xmath19 , and where @xmath139 is the density of nodes in the metric space ( we consider here that @xmath130 ) . using the definition of @xmath16 given in sec . [ sec : the_model ] and switching to @xmath2-dimensional spherical coordinates ( @xmath140 is the solid angle subtended by a @xmath2-dimensional object ) , this last equation becomes @xmath141 where we have noted @xmath142 and @xmath143 . the average degree for the whole network is @xmath144 consequently , we see that the free parameter @xmath13 can be chosen such that @xmath14 and @xmath145 . the degree distribution of the networks generated by the model can therefore be controlled through the pdf @xmath5 . following similar steps , we also find that @xmath146 = \bar{k}(\kappa ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which implies that @xmath147}}{\bar{k}(\kappa ) } = \frac{1}{\sqrt{\kappa } } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in other words , nodes with a same high value of their hidden variable @xmath4 tend to all have a degree close to the expected value @xmath14 . by definition , evaluating eq . at @xmath148 yields the generating function for the degree distribution of nodes with hidden variable @xmath4 @xmath149 assuming @xmath150 and using eq . , we obtain @xmath151^{n-1 } = \mathrm{exp}\left\ { ( x-1 ) \bar{k}(\kappa ) \right\ } = \sum_{k } \frac{\mathrm{e}^{-\bar{k}(\kappa ) } \bar{k}(\kappa)^k}{k ! } x^k \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in other words , the degrees of nodes with hidden variable @xmath4 follow a poisson distribution with mean @xmath152 @xcite . using @xmath14 , the degree distribution of the whole network is therefore @xmath153 thus unveiling the precise link between @xmath5 and @xmath154 . following similar steps as in sec . [ sec : app_average_degree_of_nodes ] , we can compute the average strength of nodes with hidden variables @xmath4 and @xmath17 @xmath155 & = \frac{2\pi^{d/2}\delta \mu^{1-\alpha / d } \nu i_2}{\gamma(d/2 ) } \sigma \int \sigma^\prime \rho(\sigma^\prime ) d\sigma^\prime \int \chi^{d-\alpha-1 } p(\chi ) d\chi \frac{2\pi^{d/2}\delta \mu^{1-\alpha / d } \nu i_2 \langle \sigma \rangle i_3}{\gamma(d/2 ) } \sigma \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath156 is the other marginal pdf of @xmath19 , and where we have noted @xmath157 , @xmath158 , and @xmath159 . we therefore conclude that the strength of nodes only depends on @xmath17 , hence @xmath160 . the average strength for the whole network is @xmath161 as for the average degree , we see that we can set the free parameter @xmath162 such that @xmath33 and @xmath163 . the strength distribution of the networks generated by the model can therefore be controlled through the pdf @xmath156 . following similar steps , we find that @xmath164 = \delta \iiint \rho(\kappa^\prime,\sigma^\prime ) p(\kappa,\kappa^\prime , d ) \int w^2 \phi(w|\sigma,\sigma^\prime , d ) dw d\bm{x^\prime } d\sigma^\prime d\kappa^\prime = \frac{2\pi^{d/2}\delta \mu^{1 - 2\alpha / d } \nu^2 i_4 \langle \sigma^2/\kappa \rangle i_5 } { \gamma(d/2 ) } \frac{\sigma^2}{\kappa } \ , % \iint \kappa^\prime { \sigma^\prime}^2 \rho(\kappa^\prime,\sigma^\prime ) d\sigma^\prime d\kappa^\prime \int \chi^{d-2\alpha-1 } p(\chi ) d\chi \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have noted @xmath165 , @xmath166 and @xmath167 . setting @xmath13 such that @xmath168 [ see eq . ] , we find that @xmath169}}{\bar{s}(\sigma ) } = \frac{\sqrt{\bar{\kappa}\langle \sigma^2/\kappa \rangle i_1 i_4 i_5}}{\langle \sigma \rangle i_2 i_3 } \frac{1}{\sqrt{\kappa } } \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] i.e. , the strength of high - degree nodes is close to its expected value given by eq . . unfortunately , it is not possible to obtain a general closed form of the pdf @xmath170 , similar to eq . , from eq . we can however characterize the strengths of nodes through the average strength of nodes with a given degree , @xmath36 . let us first explicit its calculation @xmath171 \rho(\kappa,\sigma ) d\sigma d\kappa \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] from eq . , we see that the integral in brackets can be obtained from eq . @xmath172 x^k \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] assuming @xmath130 and using eqs . and , we find @xmath173^{n-2 } = x \bar{s}(\sigma ) \mathrm{exp}\left\ { ( x-1 ) \bar{k}(\kappa ) \right\ } = \sum_{k>0 } \left [ \frac{\bar{s}(\sigma ) \mathrm{e}^{-\bar{k}(\kappa ) } \bar{k}(\kappa)^{k-1}}{(k-1 ) ! } \right ] x^{k } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] excluding the case @xmath174 in this last expression is not problematic since @xmath175 , by definition , and therefore the coefficient in front of @xmath176 must be zero [ see eq . ] . combining eqs . , @xmath14 and @xmath33 , we obtain @xmath177 thus further clarifying how the joint pdf @xmath19 controls the correlation between the degree and the strength of nodes . in fact , assuming no correlation , i.e. , @xmath178 , yields @xmath179 , which is independent of the degree , as expected . to test the triangle inequality in a given weighted complex network , we first find the parameters @xmath180 and @xmath65 that best match the empirical topology . to achieve the optimal matching , we first use the empiric sequence of degrees as input for the sequence of @xmath4 s so that the fluctuations in the tail of the degree distribution of the input network are preserved . subsequently , the sequence of @xmath4 s is slightly modified to maximize the similarity between the degree distribution and clustering coefficient of synthetic networks and the real one . after this process , the sequence of @xmath4 s is kept fixed during the rest of the process . the sequence is then used to generate different weighted networks as follows . from the empiric relation strength - degree , we measure the exponent @xmath181 , as well as the first and second moments of the strength distribution @xmath83 and @xmath182 . for fixed values of @xmath42 and @xmath111 , we generate a large number of synthetic weighted networks and measure the average value of @xmath183 and its ensemble fluctuations . in fig . [ fig : testtiv]*a * , we show @xmath183 as a function of @xmath111 and different values of @xmath42 for one of the synthetic networks used in fig . [ fig : alpharealvsinferred ] with @xmath184 and noise @xmath185 . the intersection of these curves with the empirical value of @xmath183 defines a collection of @xmath42 s as a function of the noise , @xmath186 , which become the potential candidates to be the estimate of @xmath108 , see fig . [ fig : testtiv]*b*. finally , for each pair @xmath187 in fig . [ fig : testtiv]*b * we measure the function @xmath109 and compare it with the same function measured in the input network , see fig . [ fig : testtiv]*c*. the comparison is performed by measuring the standard @xmath188 statistics . the inferred value of @xmath108 corresponds to the value of @xmath189 minimizing the value of @xmath188 , see fig . [ fig : testtiv]*d*. to find a lower bound of the inferred value of @xmath108 , we use the ensemble fluctuations of @xmath183 . for any fixed value of @xmath111 , the lower bound of @xmath190 is the value of @xmath42 that is still able to reproduce the empirical value of @xmath183 ( see fig . [ fig : testtiv]*b * ) . the lower bound for the inferred value of @xmath108 is the lower bound of @xmath190 that corresponds to the optimal value of the noise @xmath111 in fig . [ fig : testtiv]*d*. 46ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.100.078701 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.102.058701 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys1130 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.82.036106 [ * * , ( ) ] in link:\doibase 10.1007/978 - 3 - 642 - 31585 - 5_51 [ _ _ ] , , vol . , ( , ) pp . in link:\doibase 10.1007/978 - 88 - 7642 - 475 - 5_68 [ _ _ ] , , vol . , ( , ) pp . in link:\doibase 10.1007/978 - 3 - 319 - 13123 - 8_1 [ _ _ ] , , vol . , ( , ) pp . in link:\doibase 10.1007/978 - 3 - 662 - 47666 - 6_49 [ _ _ ] , , vol . , ( , ) pp . link:\doibase 10.1038/nature11459 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/ncomms8651 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/ncomms1063 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1039/c2mb05306c [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1073/pnas.0400087101 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1245200 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1209/epl / i2005 - 10167 - 2 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.92.228701 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.86.5835 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.99.228701 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.71.026103 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.67.040102 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.72.046140 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/8/5/072 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/16/4/043022 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/11/7/073005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.102.038701 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.88.062806 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.92.052816 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physa.2004.08.047 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.74.055101 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1073/pnas.0808904106 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.80.035101 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.68.036112 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1080/00018730110112519 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epjb / e2004 - 00038 - 8 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , , )

we present a general and powerful , yet simple , class of weighted networks embedded in hidden metric spaces . this class of weighted networks allows an explicit prescription of the joint degree and strength distributions , and the control of the weight distribution and the local disparity of weights by tuning their coupling with the underlying metric space . we present an approach to estimate whether an underlying metric space is needed to explain the weighted features of real networks and show that the model generates networks that reproduce these properties advantageously . the results suggest that the nontrivial weighted structure of real networks could be explained by the coupling between the weights and an underlying metric space , and open the way to the embedding of real weighted networks and to unveiling their natural hidden geometry .

hep-th0209050

physics in warped higher dimensional spacetimes may play an important role in nature , as illustrated by the rs1 model @xcite . however , effective field theory calculations are particularly complicated in such contexts . when warp factors vary greatly in the extra dimension(s ) it becomes difficult to power - count the size of feynman diagrams . for examples of such calculations see refs . @xcite . in this paper , we begin a program of honing `` holographic renormalization group '' ideas @xcite , applied to the rs scenario in @xcite , into a tool for simplifying and gaining insight into warped effective field theory . in particular we will apply this tool to understand the robustness of the goldberger - wise stabilization mechanism @xcite within effective field theory , although the methods are clearly very general . we use the ads / cft conjecture to inspire the form of a concrete and explicit renormalization group procedure , but do not rely on any unproven aspects of the conjecture . the form our rg will take is as a flow of effective field theories in rs1-type geometries of varying radius , @xmath0 , theories with smaller @xmath0 having lower warped down effective energy cutoffs . two effective theories lying on the same flow are matched to describe the same physics at energies below the lower of the two associated cutoffs . in particular this means that matched theories with different radii have the same `` ir '' or `` visible '' brane positions , but different `` uv '' or `` hidden '' brane positions . the matching is accomplished by tuning the hidden brane localized lagrangian as a function of @xmath0 . this 4d lagrangian depends on the values of bulk fields induced on the hidden brane . we will show that formally the flow of hidden brane lagrangians looks like a wilsonian rg flow of purely 4d effective field theories . a crucial feature of the associated 4d effective lagrangians is that they are local which greatly simplifies power - counting . we identify a conformal fixed point in the rg as the concrete realization of the ads / cft connection within our formalism . refs . @xcite have developed a related rg formalism focusing on renormalization of boundary divergences and properties of the holographic stress tensor . rg flows associated to branes in codimension two were studied in refs . while this paper was being completed , refs . @xcite appeared , which also discusses similar rg ideas . the utility of our rg formalism is this ; one can integrate the flow to take low - energy calculations in a highly warped compactification where they are difficult , to simpler calculations in a much smaller compactification ( smaller @xmath0 ) where the effect of warping is much less significant . of course this requires computing the effective couplings on the hidden brane in the new compactification , but this is facilitated by perturbing about the conformal fixed point and by working systematically in the small couplings of the theory . in this paper , we deal only with classical and tree - level quantum effective field theory involving a bulk scalar field , deferring a treatment of full effective quantum field theory with varying spins . already at this level , many of the non - trivial features of the rg procedure come into play . the paper is organized as follows . in section ii , we discuss free field theory and point out the basic rg structure and fixed point . in section iii , we apply our results to rederive in a simple way the goldberger - wise stabilization mechanism when the bulk scalar is identified with the one introduced by goldberger and wise . ( since we do not make gravity dynamical , our analysis is necessarily restricted to neglect the backreaction of the scalar on the geometry , the same approximation made in the original analysis . ) in section iv , we generalize our rg procedure to include a large class of interactions , in the bulk and on branes . we then use this in section v to demonstrate the robustness of the goldberger - wise mechanism within classical effective field theory in a manner that lends itself to generalization to the quantum case . in section vi , we switch from the language of classical field theory to consider tree - level feynman diagrams , setting the stage for the case of quantum loops , and showing how one deals with general effective interactions . section vii contains some concluding remarks . we consider a bulk 5d scalar field , @xmath1 , propagating on a fixed rs1 background with metric , @xmath2 the @xmath3 coordinate parametrizes the direction in a compact orbifolded space . this is a slice of ads space bounded by the hidden brane at @xmath4 and the visible brane at @xmath5 . we take @xmath6 . in this section we begin by studying a simple action which is exactly quadratic in @xmath1 , @xmath7 where @xmath8 the brane actions are written in terms of the induced brane metrics , @xmath9 and the dimensionless @xmath10-derivative expansions ( the 4d dalembertian is @xmath11 for the metric defined in ( [ metric1 ] ) and ( [ gident ] ) ) . @xmath12 and similarly for @xmath13 . the subscript `` @xmath14 '' denotes that the brane terms are quadratic in fields , which we generalize later . we denote the dimensions explicitly in units of the warping constant , @xmath15 . note that 4d general covariance ensures that in the space of 4-momenta , @xmath16 , the operator @xmath17 . the equation of motion is @xmath18 in 4-momentum space this is @xmath19 strictly in the bulk , @xmath20 satisfies the @xmath21 independent differential equation @xmath22 with boundary conditions @xmath23 we now define an `` effective '' hidden brane whose location is a variable , @xmath24 . we seek a new set of `` effective couplings '' on this brane replacing @xmath25 on the original hidden brane , @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the induced metric on the brane , which imply a new set of boundary conditions at @xmath28 , @xmath29 we require : 1 . the matching condition that @xmath30 which are solutions to the original equations of motion ( inluding boundary conditions ) , ( [ bulkeom ] ) , are also solutions to the effective equations of motion when confined to the effective domain @xmath31 . the boundary condition that @xmath32 for @xmath33 . this is obviously consistent with the previous requirement . + we interpret @xmath34 as a set of running couplings , @xmath35 , and associated 4d generally - covariant derivative operators , @xmath36 , just as in ( [ lambdadefn ] ) . we would like to find the `` renormalization group '' flow , @xmath37 , of this set . we proceed by taking the logarithmic derivative of the boundary condition ( [ bca ] ) , use the bulk equation of motion ( [ zhindpeom ] ) as @xmath38 to eliminate second @xmath3-derivatives of @xmath1 at @xmath28 , and ( [ bca ] ) again to eliminate any first @xmath3-derivatives of @xmath1 at @xmath28 , thereby obtaining + [ lambda2running ] _ 2 ( q^2a^2 , a ) = 4 _ 2 - + 2 - 2(qa)^2 . clearly , the @xmath28 dependence in the first variable of @xmath39 is entirely fixed by 4d general covariance . we will focus on the non - trivial dependence in the second variable , getting a set of @xmath40 functions , @xmath41 since @xmath16 varies freely , this represents a set of coupled differential equations for the @xmath42 . this flow has a set of fixed points . in the vicinity of such fixed points , the rg flow simplifies . when @xmath43 for all @xmath44 we solve the differential equation @xmath45 to find the fixed point @xmath46 this can be expanded in powers of @xmath47 and therefore corresponds to a local fixed - point effective brane lagrangian when written in position space . there is another solution , involving @xmath48 s , which is non - analytic in @xmath16 and therefore can not be interpreted as a local lagrangian on the effective brane . it is therefore rejected . for small momentum ( @xmath49 ) @xmath50 . as @xmath51 ( [ closedfixpt ] ) tells us @xmath52 . the same result is also obvious from the @xmath40 function equation ( [ lambda2running ] ) by first setting @xmath51 . in fact one can solve ( [ lambda2running ] ) for the fixed point by working order by order in powers of @xmath53 . this will generate ( [ closedfixpt ] ) as a series in @xmath53 . at leading order ( [ lambda2running ] ) implies ( _ 2^*(0 ) ) ^2 - 4 _ 2^*(0 ) - 2=0 . taking the positive root to match ( [ closedfixpt ] ) as @xmath54 , we again find @xmath55 at higher order in @xmath53 we find @xmath56 . this method of working out the @xmath40 functions in powers of @xmath53 will be more useful when we add interactions and the coupled rg equations are not soluable in closed form . notice that nowhere did the matching procedure specifically require that the bulk metric be ads space . for example , expressions equivalent to ( [ lambda2running ] ) and ( [ lambda20fixpt ] ) can be obtained for a 5d flat spacetime with the extra dimension taken as an orbifolded circle . since there is no curvature @xmath15 , we measure the coupling @xmath34 with an arbitrary mass scale @xmath57 . we use the metric @xmath58 so that the @xmath40 function has no explicit @xmath28 dependence . we find @xmath59 there is no fixed point for @xmath60 . for @xmath61 the fixed point is @xmath62 thus for massless or sufficiently light bulk fields there is no fixed point about which the rg flow simplifies . in particular there is no guarantee that one can match the original theory to an effective one in which the extra dimension is much smaller , with only small perturbations to the effective hidden brane action . that is a special property of having ( nearly ) ads bulk geometry . carefully taking the flat space limit of rs1 , one can check that ( [ lambda2running ] ) makes a smooth transition to ( [ minkrunning ] ) . adding a tadpole term to both branes will allow us to reproduce the goldberger - wise stabilization mechanism @xcite using the rg analysis . since in this paper we are keeping a fixed background geometry for simplicity , we will necessarily be making the same approximation as goldberger and wise , of neglecting the back - reaction of the scalar profile on the geometry . however , we expect that the generalization to dynamical gravity is straightforward . exact solutions that exhibit stability have been examined in @xcite . a perturbative approach to stability treating the back reaction in a systematic way was discussed in @xcite . consider now the theory @xmath63 where we now use @xmath64 units . note that @xmath65 are constants , not functions of @xmath16 like @xmath66 . the field @xmath1 must satisfy the boundary condition @xmath67 as before we attempt to match onto a theory with the new hidden boundary , @xmath68 as in the previous section , we take the logarithmic derivative of this boundary condition , ( [ gwbc ] ) , and use the bulk equation of motion as well as ( [ gwbc ] ) to eliminate any @xmath3-derivatives of @xmath1 . we arrive at the equation @xmath69 we will formally treat the hidden boundary value of the field , @xmath70 , as allowed to take arbitrary values , leading to rg equations @xmath71 where the partial derivatives on the left act on the @xmath28 argument , not on the @xmath53 argument , which appears on the right . clearly solutions to these rg equations will solve ( [ tadandquad ] ) . however it is not actually true that @xmath70 can take on arbitrary values because of the extra boundary conditions imposed by the visible brane . thus we can view our rg equations as the unique ones which are independent of the details of the visible brane , very much like the more familiar mass and vev independent rg flows in energy scales . in the goldberger - wise mechanism the scalar field sets up a stabilizing potential for the radion field the vev of which is @xmath72 . ignoring the gravitational backreaction as we have done gives the leading approximation in newton s constant to the radion potential . we may calculate this potential in the theory defined by ( [ gwaction ] ) as is done in ref . we may alternatively study the potential of the equivalent effective theory with the hidden brane run down to a location @xmath73 near the visible brane . the couplings on the hidden brane will be modified from the theory with hidden brane at @xmath21 as required by the rg flow . we consider a theory with hidden brane couplings close to the fixed point . we use the linearized flow equations . @xmath74 there are flow equations for the coefficients of higher derivative operators , @xmath75 . we do not consider these terms as we wish to find the effective radion potential which is evaluated at zero external momentum . solving the flow equations we have @xmath76 for such a small effective extra dimension we can neglect the bulk action and treat the field @xmath1 as constant across the extra dimension . the effective action then becomes @xmath77 as was found in refs . @xcite a large hierarchy can be generated by a moderately small scalar mass . in this case we will find after radion stabilization that @xmath78 . we have @xmath79 therefore , contributions in the effective potential due to the deviation from @xmath80 will be suppressed by @xmath81 . we may self - consistently neglect this term . the tadpole term in the action indicates a vev for @xmath1 . we find @xmath82 note that this corresponds precisely to the solution for @xmath1 found in ref . @xcite . there , a solution for @xmath1 to first order in @xmath83 and @xmath84 was found as a function of the extra - dimensional space . evaluating this solution at the location of the visible brane gives equation ( [ chivev ] ) . substituting this expression for @xmath85 into the action we obtain an effective potential for the radion . @xmath86 minimizing this potential we find that a hierarchy is established . @xmath87 a large hierarchy is generated for a modest ratio of @xmath88 . we now apply the methods of the previous sections to a more general action . consider interacting theories of the type @xmath89 & = & \iiv dz \sqrt{g } \big\ { \frac{1}{2 } g^{mn } \partial_m \chi \partial_n \chi - v_{bulk}\big ( \chi \big ) \big\ } \nonumber \\ s_{hid}[\chi(x , z_h ) ] & = & \iiv \sqrt{g_h } \ ; l_h ( \chi , \partial_\mu , g_h^{\mu \nu } ) \nonumber \\ s_{vis}[\chi(x , z_v ) ] & = & \iiv \sqrt{g_v } \ ; l_v ( \chi,\partial_\mu , g_v^{\mu \nu } ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the brane localized lagrangians are taken to be local in @xmath1 and its @xmath10-derivatives . we will see that the rg flow preserves this general form . the equations of motion imply the hidden boundary condition z _ z ( x , z ) @xmath90 in the four dimensional variations that remain after integrating over the delta functions in @xmath3 in the equations of motion emerging from brane terms . in analogy to ( [ bca ] ) , we look for a new local action @xmath91 which satisfies the boundary condition [ genbca ] z _ z ( x , z ) |_z = a = we require the boundary condition s_a[(x , z_h ) ] = s_hid[(x , z_h ) ] , and that solutions , @xmath30 , to the original equations of motion solve the effective equations of motion when restricted to @xmath31 . as in previous sections , we calculate the logarithmic @xmath28-derivative of the effective hidden boundary condition , and eliminate first and second @xmath3-derivatives at the effective hidden brane using the boundary condition and the equations of motion . using the obvious result @xmath92 we arrive at @xmath93}{\delta \psi(x)}\bigg|_{\psi(x)=\chi(x , a ) } = \frac{1}{4 ( \sqrt{g})^2 } \int d^4 x^{\prime } \frac{\delta^2 s_a[\psi]}{\delta \psi(x^{\prime } ) \delta \psi(x ) } \bigg|_{\psi(x)=\chi(x , a ) } \times \frac{\delta s_a[\psi]}{\delta \psi(y ) } \bigg|_{\psi(y ) = \chi(x^{\prime},a ) } & & \nonumber \\ - \frac{1}{\sqrt{g } } \int d^4 x^{\prime \prime } \frac{\delta^2 s_a[\psi(x')]}{\delta g^{\mu \nu}(x^{\prime \prime } ) \delta \psi(x ) } \bigg|_{\psi(x)=\chi(x , a ) } g^{\mu \nu}(x^{\prime \prime } ) - \frac{\partial v_{bulk}}{\partial \chi(x , a ) } - g^{\mu \nu } \partial_{\mu } \partial_{\nu } \chi(x , a ) , & & \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the partial @xmath28 derivative on the left is taken to act only on the running couplings of the effective theory . it is important to note that this equation is local in the couplings and the field @xmath94 since it is constructed from the variations of the presumed local action , @xmath91 . thus we have shown that local effective actions flow to local effective actions , and the boundary condition for the flow at @xmath95 is @xmath96 , which is local . to find the @xmath40 functions for each coupling , we expand ( [ chillipepper ] ) in powers of @xmath70 and the independent momenta , @xmath16 and require that each coefficient vanish . as in the previous section , this amounts to treating @xmath70 as free to take on any value in the set of 5d solutions , which is equivalent to choosing an rg flow which is independent of the details of the visible brane . since we have not considered higher - derivative interactions in the bulk , we have still not obtained the greatest generality . there is no obstruction to finding local rg flows in the most general case of higher bulk derivatives , an example of which appears in section [ bulkderivatives ] . as an example of the use of equation ( [ chillipepper ] ) , take the theory with the bulk interaction @xmath97 on the hidden brane we have @xmath98 we can calculate the running of @xmath99 and @xmath100 . equation ( [ chillipepper ] ) gives @xmath101 where we take @xmath102 . our rg flow then follows by treating @xmath103 as a free variable , @xmath104 a central result of this present section is the robust retention of a fixed point in the rg flow in the presence of interactions , which is ir - attractive as long as the bulk mass - squared is positive . to see this recall that we have found in section ii a fixed point for the free theory : @xmath105 using ( [ chillipepper ] ) one can straightforwardly find the linearized @xmath40 functions for flows near this fixed point when brane interactions are permitted , but bulk interactions are still absent . we find @xmath106 the scaling matrix , @xmath107 , is lower triangular ( operators with derivatives only mix with operators with fewer derivatives and @xmath108 and @xmath109 do not mix for @xmath110 ) , so that the eigenvalues are given by the diagonal elements . these eigenvalues are @xmath111 where @xmath112 indicates the number of @xmath1 fields in the operator and @xmath113 indicates the highest number of derivatives in that operator . the scaling dimensions are negative so this fixed point is attractive . we now add bulk interactions . from ( [ chillipepper ] ) one can see that the @xmath40 function will be corrected by a power series in bulk couplings ( actually a linear term at classical order ) . if these couplings are given the formal small parameter @xmath114 they will alter the rg flow by @xmath115 terms , which can not eliminate the fixed point but only shift its position by @xmath115 . the scaling dimensions will also receive an @xmath115 correction . the new fixed point will therefore be attractive for a sufficiently small @xmath114 . the robustness of the fixed point and the anomalous dimensions when interactions are included translates into the robustness of the goldberger - wise mechanism for stabilizing the hierarchy , which we see as follows . as long as our original hidden brane action is sufficiently close to the fixed point action , we are justified in using the linearized rg flow , given by the anomalous dimensions . as long as the strength of bulk couplings is sufficiently small , the @xmath114 mentioned above being at most of order the bulk mass - squared ( in @xmath116 units ) , the spectrum of anomalous dimensions is still given by one coupling with anomalous dimension of order @xmath117 , while the other couplings have anomalous dimensions which are of order @xmath118 or more negative . we will now repeat our goldberger - wise analysis as in the previous section , but now using this interacting rg flow . running the planck brane down to @xmath119 as before we drop derivative terms to find a vacuum potential of the form @xmath120 where the operators @xmath121 have scaling dimension @xmath122 . the functions @xmath123 and @xmath124 have no explicit @xmath125 dependence . we will show self - consistently that @xmath78 . we can then discard all terms suppressed by order one powers of @xmath126 as they are negligible . taking @xmath127 to be of order @xmath128 , only one hidden brane operator is relevant . we have @xmath129 notice that this potential has the form , @xmath130 where @xmath131 indicates a polynomial . for quite generic coefficients this indicates that solutions with @xmath132 minimize this potential . these relations are explicitly confirmed at leading order in @xmath114 in section iii were a large hierarchy is generated . we see that a large hierarchy will also be set including the @xmath115 ( and higher ) corrections . @xmath133 in quantum field theory the quantities of physical interest are the @xmath134-point functions . take the theory of equation ( [ action ] ) with the hidden brane at @xmath4 . we may also consider a theory with the hidden brane at a location @xmath135 . these theories will describe equivalent physics if they give the same @xmath134-point functions . we require @xmath136 where the final subscript denotes the position of the hidden brane , where @xmath137 . this method of matching @xmath134-point functions is done at tree level in this paper and gives an alternate , equivalent way of calculating the flow equations for hidden brane couplings to that of the previous sections . we demonstrate this method through a few examples . its utility is primarily in that the method may be extended to quantum calculations . to evaluate @xmath134-point functions in perturbation theory we must first consider the two - point function . @xmath138 it satisfies @xmath139 explicit solutions for the green s function in ads space have been found in refs . @xcite . simplifying in 4d momentum space this is @xmath140 as usual , this is equivalent to a @xmath21 independent differential equation @xmath141 subject to @xmath21-dependent boundary conditions , @xmath142 in the effective theory with the hidden brane at @xmath28 the 2-point function satisfies the same differential equation and visible boundary condition but with a modified hidden boundary condition . @xmath143 the coupling @xmath144 is chosen so that @xmath145 which implies @xmath146 expanding for infinitesimal @xmath147 , using ( [ gfbulk ] ) to eliminate @xmath148 and the effective hidden boundary condition to eliminate @xmath149 at @xmath150 , leads to @xmath151 this is the same flow described in section [ free ] . what follows are two example flow calculations . the central object will be the free field two point function at the rg fixed point , satisfying the boundary condition @xmath152 the theory will in general not be at this fixed point . we treat contributions to the @xmath134-point function due to bulk interactions and deviations from @xmath80 perturbatively . in our earlier classical analysis we had restricted ourselves for simplicity to bulk interactions of the form of a potential . as an example of a perturbative calculation using the method of matching green s functions consider here the specific bulk derivative coupling @xmath153 with coupling constant @xmath154 take two theories with the hidden brane at @xmath28 and @xmath155 respectively . we require that the 4-point function be independent of the location of the brane , @xmath156 for infinitesimal @xmath147 this is @xmath157 on the hidden brane we need @xmath158 where in this section @xmath159 indicates terms with higher @xmath160 derivatives . in perturbation theory we use the free field propagator at the fixed point @xmath80 , as discussed in the previous subsection . calculating the 4 point function at first order in the couplings gives @xmath161 where @xmath162 indicates a permutation of the @xmath3 dervatives on the propagators . taking the logarithmic derivative with respect to @xmath28 we have @xmath163 using the fact that the two - point functions are at their free - field fixed point values , @xmath164 we obtain @xmath165 in 4-momentum space we may divide by the external propagators and then set external momentum to zero to obtain @xmath166 showing how this bulk derivative interaction modifies the rg flow for a hidden brane coupling . as a second example , illustrating nonlinear effects in the rg , consider the brane interactions @xmath168 these will induce 4-point operators through the diagrams of figure [ fourpoint ] . we require hidden brane `` counterterms '' @xmath169 to maintain invariance of the 4-point function working to second order in @xmath170 . here again @xmath159 indicates higher @xmath171 derivatives . we calculate @xmath172 requiring @xmath157 we use @xmath164 @xmath173 where the delta function term in ( [ disc ] ) is due to the discontinuity in @xmath174 following from ( [ greeneom ] ) . to linear order in @xmath99 it is straightforward to establish @xmath175 substituting these expressions into ( [ fourpointcalc ] ) , transforming to 4-momentum space , dividing by the external propagators and setting external momentum to zero gives @xmath176 this matches the result that is obtained through the methods of section [ interactions ] . this demonstrates how @xmath167 interactions induce running in @xmath100 . note that other nonlinear contributions in the @xmath40 functions may be calculated through the diagrams of figure [ fourint ] . the two main directions for generalizing the above rg formalism are including higher spins and including quantum loops . spins greater than or equal to one raise an interesting subtlety not encountered in this paper . the usual cft interpretation of a bulk rs1 field is that it corresponds to a cft operator _ and _ to a fundamental 4d field coupled to that cft . therefore it is at first sight odd that in our rs1 examples we found exact fixed points without the deviations corresponding to the coupling to a fundamental 4d scalar . however , one can see that the hidden brane fixed point lagrangian found in this paper contains an effective - cutoff sized mass for the bulk scalar . the dual of this is a cft coupled to a cutoff - mass fundamental scalar that is a scalar heavy enough to be completely integrated out of the effective theory leaving the pure cft dynamics . now consider higher spins protected by gauge invariance . for concreteness we will consider gravity in the full rs1 model . we may want to keep the zero mode graviton ( dual to the fundamental 4d graviton coupled to the cft ) . in this case we must accomodate the complication that the effective hidden brane theory must describe `` almost '' fixed point behavior with small deviations arising from weak coupling to the zero mode graviton . quantum loops can be dealt with in a very similar manner to the methods of section vi . the central technical issue is a proof to all orders of the locality of the running effective hidden brane lagrangian . ( we fully expect this locality . ) once this is demonstrated , the rg approach will undoubtedly provide the simplest and most insightful proof of the stability of the rs - goldberger - wise hierarchy to all orders in the effective field theory . the method of proof would be almost identical to the proof of hierarchy robustness given here in section v for the classical interacting theory , which uses only the most general features of the rg flows . the importance of such a proof is easy to understand when one considers that the goldberger - wise effective potential is basically a weak - scale potential for the radius , whereas the rs1 effective theory , has access to planckian mass scales ( especially at the quantum level ) which naively threaten to overwhelm weak - scale effects . understanding how the potential is protected by such effects is a particular case illustrating the more general utility of the rg procedure , which is to identify where large dependences on the warp factor appear within feynman diagrams . another important application would be quantum corrections to the masses and decays of low lying kaluza - klein resonances . l. randall and r. sundrum , phys . lett . * 83 * , 3370 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9905221 ] ; l. randall and r. sundrum , phys . lett . * 83 * , 4690 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9906064 ] . w. d. goldberger and i. z. rothstein , phys . b * 491 * , 339 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0007065 ] ; l. randall and m. d. schwartz , jhep * 0111 * , 003 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0108114 ] ; w. d. goldberger and i. z. rothstein , [ arxiv : hep - th/0204160 ] ; k. agashe , a. delgado and r. sundrum , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0206099 ] ; r. contino , p. creminelli and e. trincherini , [ arxiv : hep - th/0208002 ] . k. w. choi and i. w. kim , [ arxiv : hep - th/0208071 ] . j. m. maldacena , adv . * 2 * , 231 ( 1998 ) [ int . j. theor . phys . * 38 * , 1113 ( 1999 ) ] [ arxiv : hep - th/9711200 ] ; s. s. gubser , i. r. klebanov and a. m. polyakov , phys . b * 428 * , 105 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9802109 ] ; e. witten , adv . * 2 * , 253 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9802150 ] ; l. susskind and e. witten , [ arxiv : hep - th/9805114 ] ; e. t. akhmedov , [ arxiv : hep - th/9806217 ] ; e. alvarez and c. gomez , nucl . b * 541 * , 441 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9807226 ] ; v. balasubramanian and p. kraus , phys . lett . * 83 * , 3605 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9903190 ] ; s. ferrara and m. porrati , phys . b * 458 * , 43 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9903241 ] ; d. z. freedman , s. s. gubser , k. pilch and n. p. warner , jhep * 0007 * , 038 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9906194 ] ; h. verlinde , nucl . b * 580 * , 264 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9906182 ] ; j. maldacena , unpublished remarks ; e. witten , itp santa barbara conference ` new dimensions in field theory and string theory ' , http://www.itp.ucsb.edu/online/susyc99/discussion ; s. s. gubser , phys . d * 63 * , 084017 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9912001 ] ; j. de boer , e. verlinde and h. verlinde , jhep * 0008 * , 003 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9912012 ] ; n. arkani - hamed , m. porrati and l. randall , jhep * 0108 * , 017 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0012148 ] ; r. rattazzi and a. zaffaroni , jhep * 0104 * , 021 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0012248 ] ; m. perez - victoria , jhep * 0105 * , 064 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0105048 ] . c. csaki , j. erlich , t. j. hollowood and j. terning , phys . rev . d * 63 * , 065019 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0003076 ] . m. henningson and k. skenderis , jhep * 9807 * , 023 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9806087 ] . m. henningson and k. skenderis , fortsch . phys . * 48 * , 125 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9812032 ] . s. de haro , s. n. solodukhin and k. skenderis , commun . phys . * 217 * , 595 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0002230 ] . m. bianchi , d. z. freedman and k. skenderis , jhep * 0108 * , 041 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0105276 ] . m. bianchi , d. z. freedman and k. skenderis , nucl . b * 631 * , 159 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0112119 ] . s. de haro , k. skenderis and s. n. solodukhin , class . . grav . * 18 * , 3171 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0011230 ] . o. dewolfe , d. z. freedman , s. s. gubser and a. karch , phys . d * 62 * , 046008 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9909134 ] . a. lewandowski and r. sundrum , phys . d * 65 * , 044003 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0108025 ] . b. grinstein , d. r. nolte and w. skiba , phys . d * 63 * , 105005 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0012074 ] .

we derive a renormalization group formalism for the randall - sundrum scenario , where the renormalization scale is set by a floating compactification radius . while inspired by the ads / cft conjecture , our results are derived concretely within higher - dimensional effective field theory . matching theories with different radii leads to running hidden brane couplings . the hidden brane lagrangian consists of four - dimensional local operators constructed from the induced value of the bulk fields on the brane . we find hidden lagrangians which are non - trivial fixed points of the rg flow . calculations in rs1 can be greatly simplified by `` running down '' the effective theory to a small radius . we demonstrate these simplifications by studying the goldberger - wise stabilization mechanism . in this paper , we focus on the classical and tree - level quantum field theory of bulk scalar fields , which demonstrates the essential features of the rg in the simplest context .

hep-ph0104208

although heavy quark spectroscopy is now a rather mature subject , a number of interesting issues remain . in particular , the detailed properties of the excitation spectrum of heavy - light mesons ( @xmath6 ) and their light hadronic transitions are yet to be fully understood . experimentally , much of this excitation spectrum remains to be observed . only the ground state s - waves and a few of the @xmath7 p - waves are presently well established . however , many of these states will be accessible in the present and future b factories : cleo , babar , belle , cdf , d0 , btev and lhc b. besides furthering our understanding of qcd dynamics , the detailed study of these excited states may have practical benefits . for example , triggering on excited states may provide an efficient method of same side b tagging in hadron colliders . tagging is essential to the study of cp violation in the b system . the theoretical tools available to determine the properties of excited states in heavy - light systems include heavy quark effective theory ( hqet ) and low energy chiral effective theory @xcite . unfortunately , these tools are not sufficient to determine the detailed properties of these states . lattice gauge theory is the only existing technique which allows the systematic study of all the aspects of qcd in heavy - light systems . detailed studies of the p - wave excited heavy - light states within the quenched approximation already exist @xcite . future lattice studies will provide more insight into the nature of qcd dynamics as well as the masses and static properties of heavy - light hadrons . it is clear that a model to estimate the hadronic transitions from excited state to ground states would also be very useful . such a formalism has been developed and applied extensively to transitions in heavy - heavy @xmath8 systems @xcite . however , heavy - light mesons are more difficult because the light quark is subject to the full nonperturbative qcd dynamics . one possible approach to providing a framework for these hadronic transitions is to use the chiral quark model @xcite . this has been suggested by goity and roberts @xcite . in this paper we closely follow the work done in refs . @xcite . to compute the masses and wavefunctions of the excited states we use a dirac equation for the light quark in the potential generated by the heavy quark ( including first order corrections in the heavy quark expansion and mixing effects ) . we then use these masses and wavefunctions to compute the hadronic decay amplitudes of excited heavy mesons in the context of a chiral quark model @xcite . the main differences between the present and preceding works are in the choice for the parameters of the chromoelectric potential and in the inclusion of mixing effects both in the spectrum and in the decay amplitudes . moreover we use our results for the radial wavefunctions of the excited mesons to make a comparison with recent lattice results . from the comparison we extract an estimation for @xmath9 , the effective coupling of the quark to the pseudoscalar mesons . we find @xmath10 we present numerical results for the low - lying spectrum ( excited states up to the 3s states ) . we also compute the pseudoscalar meson hadronic transitions for these states as a function of the chiral quark model effective coupling constant . comparing our results with recent experimental width measurements we estimate this effective coupling @xmath5 . in section 2 , we discuss our determination of the spectrum of excited states . our notation , the choice of the potential , inclusion of mixing and other order @xmath11 corrections are explained . details of the masses and wavefunctions are presented for the low - lying excitation spectrum . comparison is made with present experimental data . our treatment of hadronic decays is described in section 3 . the analytic results are summarized in eqs . ( [ amplitude]-[use_amplitude ] ) . explicit expressions for the coupling coefficients appearing in these equations are given in appendix a. also in section 3 , details of the partial rates for the 1s and 1p states in the @xmath0 and @xmath1 systems are presented . again comparison is made with present experimental data . a complete list of remaining results for masses and partial decay widths is reported in appendix b. the general hamiltonian of the heavy - light system can be expanded in powers of ( @xmath11 ) @xmath12 however , even within the heavy quark limit , the general form of the zeroth order hamiltonian , @xmath13 , still involves the full nonperturbative qcd dynamics for the remaining degrees of freedom ( including light quark pair creation and gluonic degrees of freedom ) . at present it can not be solved analytically . we are forced to resort to use a relativistic potential model for @xmath13 . we model the most general heavy - light meson ( in the @xmath14 family ) , h , as a bound state of a light quark ( @xmath15 ) and a heavy quark ( @xmath16 ) . the heavy quark is treated as a static source of chromoelectric field and the only quantum number associated with it is its spin . the light quark is treated relativistically and its state is described by the wavefunction @xmath17 . in analogy with the hydrogen atom , we introduce the following quantum numbers : * @xmath18 , the number associated with the radial excitations ; * @xmath19 , the orbital angular momentum ; * @xmath20 , the total angular momentum of the light quark ; * @xmath21 , the component of @xmath20 along the @xmath22 axis ; * @xmath23 , the total angular momentum of the system ; * @xmath24 , the component of @xmath23 along the @xmath22 axis ; * @xmath25 , the spin of the heavy quark along the @xmath22 axis ; the parameters of our model are the masses of the light quarks ( @xmath26 for @xmath27 ) , the masses of the heavy quarks ( @xmath28 for @xmath29 ) and the chromoelectric potential of the heavy quark ( @xmath30 ) . the total wavefunction of the system can be decomposed as follows @xmath31 where @xmath32 are the usual clebsh - gordan coefficients and @xmath33 is a two component spinor representing the heavy quark . ( [ notation0 ] ) is a solution of the following eigenvalue problem @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the hamiltonian of the system . the energy levels in eq . ( [ dirac ] ) do not depend on @xmath24 because of rotational invariance . we rewrite eq . ( [ notation0 ] ) introducing the most general parameterization for the four spin components of the light quark wavefunction @xmath36 here @xmath37 are spherical harmonics that encode the angular dependence while @xmath38 , @xmath39 are real functions that encode that radial dependence . @xmath40 and @xmath41 are fixed , up to an overall phase , by imposing a normalization condition . our choice of the phase is such that @xmath42 within our basic framework , @xmath43 is given by the relativistic dirac hamiltonian @xmath44 and the rotational - invariant potential is the sum of a constant factor ( @xmath45 ) , a scalar part ( @xmath46 ) and ( the zeroth component of ) a vector part ( @xmath47 ) @xmath48 the constant @xmath45 is a an overall energy shift that depends on the heavy quark flavor and , in general , it is not equal to @xmath28 , as often assumed in the literature . for this reason we consider @xmath28 and @xmath49 two independent parameters of the model . asymptotic freedom suggests that at short distances the potential is dominated by a vector part that asymptotically approaches a coulomb potential , @xmath50 . on the other hand lattice simulations indicate that at large distances the potential is confining , scalar and asymptotically linear , @xmath51 . the naive assumption about a short distance coulomb - like divergent behavior of the potential is doomed because it gives rise to ultraviolet divergences ( as discussed in ref . @xcite and ref . @xcite ) . it this context the divergence arises in the @xmath11 correction to the energy and it is due to the inconsistency of a static point - like source ( the heavy quark ) within a relativistic framework . one solution is assuming that the heavy quark is static but not point - like , therefore the potential that it generates is a convolution of the coulomb - like potential and the square of the heavy quark wavefunction ( peaked around the center of mass of the system and smeared within some small length scale @xmath52 ) . more generally , one is allowed to cure this divergence by regulating the potential close to the origin ( on a length scale of the order @xmath52 ) . different choices for the regulator are allowed and they do not affect the physics we want to describe , providing that @xmath52 is small enough . the values of the parameters that appear in the hamiltonian , on the contrary , depend on this choice since they run with @xmath53 . in fact , to obtain the same spectrum , different choices for the regulator imply different fitting parameters . we chose to regulate the vector potential by assuming a gaussian shape for the wavefunction of the heavy quark , @xmath54 , and with this choice @xmath55 for the scalar potential we assume a simple linear form @xmath56 we observe that @xmath57 is not a physical parameter since it can be absorbed into the definition of @xmath26 . for this reason @xmath57 will be omitted from now on . summarizing , the nine parameters of our model are @xmath58 where @xmath59 and @xmath60 are mass parameters for the light @xmath61 and @xmath62 quarks respectively , equivalent to constituent quark masses shifted by the constant amount @xmath57 of eq . ( [ potential2 ] ) , which is undetermined in our model . @xmath63 is the mass of the @xmath57 quark with @xmath64 the corresponding energy shift . analogously for the @xmath65 quark . for any given set of input parameters we solve the eigenvalue problem , eq . ( [ dirac ] ) , using the hamiltonian of eq . ( [ dirac2 ] ) and the potential specified by eqs . ( [ potential ] ) , ( [ potential1 ] ) and ( [ potential2 ] ) . in this way we determine the radial wavefunctions @xmath67 and @xmath68 associated to the energy levels @xmath69 . we then compute @xmath11 corrections to the energy levels in first order perturbation theory @xmath70 where , ignoring for the moment the mixing of the states , @xmath71 the analytical expression for @xmath72 has been derived in ref . @xcite using the bethe - salpeter formalism . in terms of the radial wavefunctions ( after the analytical integration of the angular part ) , we rewrite @xmath73 as a sum of three contributions @xmath74 these terms are respectively : * the kinetic energy @xmath75 r^2 \text{d}r \label{i1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath76 . * a shift due to spin - orbit interaction @xmath77 \ ! r^2\text{d}r \label{i2}\ ] ] for @xmath78 , or @xmath79 \ ! r^2\text{d}r \label{i3}\ ] ] + for @xmath80 . * the hyperfine splitting @xmath81 in eqs.([e1 ] ) and ( [ e2 ] ) we assumed that the hamiltonian was diagonal . this is not the case because the @xmath82 interaction term in the hamiltonian mixes states . in general correction terms can mix any states with the same total angular momentum , @xmath23 , and parity , @xmath83 , however , there are only two types of sizable mixings . large mixing can occur for pairs of states @xmath84 and @xmath85 with : ( 1 ) @xmath86 , @xmath87 and @xmath88 ( i.e. mixing within a given @xmath18 and @xmath89 multiplet ) ; or ( 2 ) @xmath90 , @xmath91 and @xmath88 ( e.g. s - d mixing ) . the off - diagonal term in the hamiltonian that mixes such pairs of states has the form @xmath92 \ ! r^2\text{d}r \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and it induces a mixing in the wavefunctions and in the energy levels @xmath93 with @xmath94 . we find that the effect of mixing is generally negligible except for the @xmath83 waves , where the mixing among wavefunctions can be of the order of 10% . in tables [ table_spectrum1]-[table_spectrum4 ] we report the value of @xmath95 for each excited state . it measures , in percent , the contribution of the mixing to the wavefunction . .tabulated spectrum for @xmath96 mesons . @xmath97 denotes the lowest order energies . @xmath98 includes all the order @xmath11 corrections . ( all units in gev ) . the mixings between lowest order states are denoted by @xmath99 . [ table_spectrum1 ] [ cols="<,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] [ a ] theoretical value corrected for phase space observed mass(see table [ tbl : decays ] ) and the @xmath100 branching ratio to @xmath101 @xcite . experimental results depend strongly on model dependent assumptions . within the chiral quark model , the coupling determined from any transition should agree . ( i.e the coupling is independent of particular initial or final heavy - light states . ) table [ tbl : width_exp ] lists the various determinations of @xmath102 from existing data . within the existing large uncertainties the various determinations are consistent . we have computed the spectrum and hadronic decay width of the excited @xmath96 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 and @xmath1 mesons using a relativistic quark model for the masses and wavefunction of the heavy - light mesons . this work is based on that of refs . @xcite but departs from these previous works because we choose a simpler form for the potential and determined its parameters exclusively from fitting the experimental heavy - light spectrum . moreover we computed all corrections within the model to order @xmath11 , including mixing between nearby states with the same @xmath105 . our spectrum results agree very well with the existing data in the @xmath96 and @xmath103 systems . the agreement in the @xmath104 and @xmath1 systems is also fairly good but the experimental situation for the p states is not yet completely resolved . for example , our model predicts a spin - orbit inversion for the excited p - wave states in these systems . this agrees with the recent cleo @xcite results for the @xmath96 mesons ; but is in disagreement with preliminary l3 results @xcite for the @xmath104 mesons . however , in our model we find that the splitting between the @xmath106 p - wave states ( @xmath107 ) more than twice as large as the splitting of the @xmath108 p - wave states ( @xmath109 ) . which is inconsistent with the assumption of equal splitting used by @xmath110 @xcite in their analysis . the information on the spectrum and the wavefunction was used to compute a complete list of allowed hadronic decays for these excited mesons into lower energy states with emission of a light pseudoscalar meson ( @xmath111 , @xmath112 or @xmath113 ) and their relative branching ratios . we also compared our model prediction for @xmath114 with lattice results . we find good agreement between the shapes of the decay amplitudes . we used this comparison to extract a preliminary lattice determination of @xmath9 , the effective coupling of the chiral quark model . we find the value @xmath10 . using this value for @xmath9 to translate the total hadronic decay widths in physical units , we would conclude that the widths of the @xmath96 meson @xmath83 waves are consistently below experimental findings . of course , the lattice results have not yet been extrapolated to the continuum . comparison of our results with a recent experiment measurement of the @xmath115 width @xcite yields @xmath5 . using this value , we find much better overall agreement with experimental findings . finally , there is also a whole set of hadronic decays with emission of light vector mesons which we did not include in our study . for the higher excited states these transitions give an important contribution to the total physical widths . we intend to study these transitions in a future paper . we wish to acknowledge the authors of ref . @xcite from which we extracted the lattice data of fig . [ lattice ] . one of us , d.p . , thanks g. chiodini for stimulating discussions on experimental issues . this work was performed at fermilab , a u.s . department of energy lab ( operated by the university research association , inc . ) under contract de - ac02 - 76cho3000 . in order to be able to factorize the expression for the transition amplitude , eq . ( [ hprimetoh ] ) into radial and angular parts , it is convenient to adopt the following basis for the @xmath116 matrices @xmath117 where @xmath118 is the @xmath119 identity and @xmath120 are the usual pauli matrices . in this basis we obtain simple expressions for the @xmath121 coefficients = \sqrt{(2a_1 + 1) ... (2a_n+1)}\ ] ] ] @xmath122 where @xmath123 for the particular case @xmath124 the angular dependence from the @xmath125 vector disappears and we obtain the following explicit expression @xmath126 with @xmath127\left\ { \begin{array}{lll } \ell _ x & j & j^{\prime } \\ \frac{1}{2 } & j^{\prime } & j \end{array } \right\ } \delta_{k,\ell_x } \\ c_2&=&4\pi ( -i)^{k}(-)^{j^{\prime } -\frac12 + j'-k } [ j k ] \left\ { \begin{array}{lll } \ell _ x & j & j^{\prime } \\ \frac{1}{2 } & j^{\prime } & j \end{array } \right\ } \left ( \begin{array}{lll } 1 & k & \ell _ { \pi } \\ 0 & 0 & 0 \end{array } \right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] explicit expressions for the wigner - ekkart reduced tensors are @xmath128}{\sqrt{4\pi } } ( -)^{j+\ell^{\prime } -\ell+1/2}\left ( \begin{array}{lll } \ell^{\prime } & k & \ell \\ 0 & 0 & 0 \end{array } \right ) \left\ { \begin{array}{lll } k & \ell^{\prime } & \ell \\ \frac{1}{2 } & j & j^{\prime } \end{array } \right\ } \label{reducedy}\ ] ] and @xmath129(-)^{\ell^{\prime } } \left ( \begin{array}{lll } \ell^{\prime } & k & \ell \\ 0 & 0 & 0 \end{array } \right ) \left\ { \begin{array}{lll } \frac{1}{2 } & \ell^{\prime } & j^{\prime } \\ \frac{1}{2 } & \ell & j \\ 1 & k & \ell_x \end{array } \right\}\ ] ] our expression for the spin structure of the decay amplitudes , reported in this appendix , disagree with ref . @xcite in the overall phase factor . this factor does not affect their results but is relevant in case of mixing . in this appendix we list the hadronic transitions @xmath130 for the low - lying excited states not discussed in section 3.2 . the following tables list the transitions in decending order according to : transitions with a branching ratio less than 1% are not reported . some decays are marked with an asterisk . these are decays that apparently do not conserve the heavy quark spin ( @xmath132 ) but , we remind the reader , our initial and final states are physical states and therefore such decays become allowed because of mixing effects . c. michael and j. peisa [ ukqcd collaboration ] , phys . d * 58 * , 034506 ( 1998 ) ; a. ali khan _ et al . _ , d * 62 * , 054505 ( 2000 ) ; joachim hein _ et al . _ , phys . * d62 * , 074503 ( 2000 ) ; r. lewis and r. m. woloshyn , nucl . suppl . * 93 * , 192 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0010013 ]

a detailed study of orbital and radial excited states in @xmath0 and @xmath1 systems is performed . the chiral quark model provides the framework for the calculation of pseudoscalar meson ( @xmath2 ) hadronic transitions among heavy - light excited and ground states . to calculate the excited states masses and wavefunctions , we must resort to a relativistic quark model . our model includes the leading order corrections in @xmath3 ( e.g. mixing ) . numerical results for masses and light hadronic transition rates are compared to existing experimental data . the effective coupling of the chiral quark model can be determined by comparing with independent results from lattice simulations ( @xmath4 ) or fitting to known widths ( @xmath5 ) . fermilab pub-01/033-t + hep - ph/0104208 + april 2001 + + +

1211.6923

galaxy mergers and interactions play a key role in cosmological evolution , affecting galaxy morphology , the star - formation history by triggering intense bursts of star formation @xcite , and active galactic nuclei ( agn ) via the growth of central supermassive black holes @xcite . besides spectacular episodes of star formation , . interacting galaxies , in relatively isolated pairs or galaxy groups containing at least one gas rich member , are ideally suited where such interactions take place in a group , the stripped gas evolves under the influence of the intra - group medium ( igm ) while at the same time contributing to it . studying the stripped gas can reveal information about gas dynamics , star formation , igm enrichment and the formation of tidal dwarf galaxies ( tdgs ) . star formation beyond the galaxy disks and the principles governing it have attracted a lot of recent attention @xcite and the advent of ultraviolet ( uv ) and mid - infrared ( mir ) telescopes like galex and spitzer have enabled major advances in such studies . star formation from tidally stripped gas . atomic and molecular gas observations of such systems provide the conditions under which star formation is triggered in these regions . these entities known as tidal dwarf galaxies ( tdgs ) @xcite . due to active ongoing star formation they normally have characteristic blue colours and high velocity dispersions . typical hi masses of tdgs few times 10@xmath2 m@xmath3 and stellar masses are few times 10@xmath4 m@xmath3 @xcite . besides contributing to the dwarf galaxy population , tdgs provide us with further insights towards understanding galaxy evolution @xcite . in addition to tidally stripped gas and galactic winds @xcite , in situ star formation in tidal debris can be an important source of igm enrichment . @xcite estimate that star - formation rate ( sfr ) as low as 1.5@xmath510@xmath6 m@xmath3 yr@xmath7 maintained for 1 gyr , can raise the igm metallicity by @xmath01@xmath510@xmath6 solar . this value compares well with the metallicity floor " @xmath01.4@xmath510@xmath6 solar in the damped lyman alpha ( dla ) gas , observed over a redshift range of 0.5 to 5 @xcite . in this letter we present one of the most spectacular cases of the impact on hi of a tidal interaction between a pair of spirals , ngc 3212 and ngc 3215 , which make up the arp 181 system and possibly a third small galaxy . ngc 3212 has been classified as an ` s ? ' galaxy at a redshift of 0.0324 , while ngc 3215 has been classified as an ` sb ? ' galaxy at a redshift of 0.0316 @xcite . we adopt a distance of 130 mpc ( assuming h@xmath8=75 ) for the system and at this distance 1 arcmin translates to @xmath0 39.4 kpc . hi in arp 181 was observed with the giant metrewave radio telescope _ ( gmrt ) _ on december 31st , 2008 . details of the observations given in table [ table1 ] . the baseband bandwidth used was 8 mhz for the hi 21-cm line observations giving a velocity resolution of @xmath013 km s@xmath7 . to signal to noise ratio the velocity resolution was smoothed to @xmath026 km s@xmath7 . the gmrt data were reduced using astronomical image processing system ( aips ) software package . bad malfunctioning antennas , antennas with abnormally low gain and/or radio frequency interference ( rfi ) were flagged . the flux densities are on the scale of @xcite , with flux density uncertainties of cubes were produced following continuum subtraction in the uv domain using the aips tasks ` uvsub ' and ` uvlin ' . the task ` imagr ' was used to obtain the final cleaned image cubes . from these cubes the integrated and velocity field maps were extracted using the aips task ` momnt ' ( using a 3@xmath9 cut - off ) . to analyse the structures , we produced image cubes of different resolutions by tapering the data with different uv limits and using uniform weights for the high resolution maps . .gmrt observation details [ cols= " < , < " , ] the lower left panel of figure [ fig1 ] shows the velocity field of the western mass . the lower right panel of shows the high - resolution hi image ( contours ) of a zoom in to the region where most of the hi mass in the system detected . figure [ fig1 ] ( upper panel ) , shows that almost the entire hi mass of the system is detected well beyond the optical disks of ngc3212 and ngc3215 and is connected to ngc3212 by a low density hi bridge . the hi not coincident with the optical tidal tail but runs parallel . the western mass has two distinct intensity maxima at positions 10@xmath10 27@xmath11 37.@xmath121 , 79@xmath13 49@xmath14 36.7@xmath15 and 10@xmath1027@xmath11 25.@xmath121 , 79@xmath13 49@xmath14 16.62@xmath15 , hereafter referred to as hp(n ) and hp(s ) respectively . hp(s ) approximately coincides with a small blue spiral sdss j102726.32 + 794911.9 no published redshift . however information in @xmath16 confirms this galaxy is at similar redshift to the arp 181 system . hp(n ) from ngc 3212 ( figure [ fig1 ] ) . the total hi flux density recovered from this system from the gmrt observations is 3.3 @xmath17 0.2 jy to the single dish value of 2.3 @xmath17 1.5 jy @xcite . using hi map , the hi content of individual galaxies and the western mass was estimated . the two galaxies , ngc3212 and ngc3215 contain 2.7@xmath5 10@xmath4 m@xmath3 and 7.9@xmath5 10@xmath2 m@xmath3 respectively the western hi mass along with the tidal bridge the uncertainty on estimates are @xmath010% . the velocity field of the western hi mass shows no signs of regular rotation at this velocity resolution . however there is a gradient from both east and west , converging near the positions of the intensity maxima , especially hp(n ) . within the limits of current spectroscopic data arp 181 appears to be a fairly isolated system . the nearest similar size neighbour is cgcg 350 - 053 projected at an angular distance of @xmath030.4@xmath18 ( 1.4 mpc ) with a velocity separation of @xmath0 2000 . there are several small galaxies projected close to arp 181 , but they lack spectroscopic data to confirm their distances . thus it is possible arp 181 is a galaxy group dominated by ngc3212 and ngc3215 . the system has been previously observed with spitzer @xcite , galex @xcite and in h@xmath1 ( @xmath16 ) . based on their galex and optical observations , @xcite conclude this system potentially hosts one or more tdgs . they suggested the two objects at positions 10@xmath10 27@xmath11 26.@xmath122 , 79@xmath13 49@xmath14 12.3@xmath15 and 10@xmath10 27@xmath11 40.@xmath121 , 79@xmath13 49@xmath14 45.3@xmath15 their optical spectroscopic observations confirmed the galaxy at position 10@xmath10 27@xmath11 26.@xmath122 , 79@xmath13 49@xmath14 12.3@xmath15 system . this galaxy appears to have spiral features in the sdss images , and extremely blue in nuv g. according to @xcite , this may be a dwarf galaxy which a part of the group or a recently detached tdg . the object at position 10@xmath10 27@xmath11 40.@xmath121 , 79@xmath13 49@xmath14 45.3@xmath15,is their second tdg candidate , although its association with the arp 181 system remains to be confirmed spectroscopically @xcite . the our observations reveal tidal interaction between ngc 3212 , ngc 3215 and sdss j102726.32 + 794911.9 seems to be a likely as there is no nearby neighbour of similar size in similar redshift range within @xmath0 3mpc radius . also both the arp 181 severely hi deficient indicating from the galaxies . to determine gas loss from a spiral is to compare its hi surface density deficiency is log@xmath19 @xcite , where where @xmath20 is the total hi mass of a galaxy and @xmath21 is the optical major isophotal diameter ( in kpc ) measured at or reduced to a surface brightness level m@xmath22 = 25.0 mag / arcsec@xmath23 . while @xcite used the ugc major diameters , we have used the rc3 diameters and used the modified values from @xcite . the expected value of this parameter for an early type spiral ( sb ) is 6.91 @xmath17 0.26 . since morphological sub - classifications are not available for ngc 3212 and ngc 3215 , we compared these galaxies against sb type spirals . the hi surface density values for ngc 3212 and ngc 3215 are hi deficient by a factor of 10 . the tidal bridge connecting ngc3212 to the also supports that this hi mass is a tidal debris from the arp 181 interaction . the small dwarf system , sdss j102726.32 + 794911.9 , may also be participating in the interaction . the high - resolution hi image ( lower right of figure [ fig1 ] ) shows the hp(s ) to be offset by @xmath0 5@xmath15 ( a beam ) from the optical centre of sdss j102726.32 + 794911.9 and its hi extends in the direction of the candidate tdg . however , given its size , the hi mass contributed by this system another scenario . under this scenario hp(s ) is lsb . the sdss images show distinct spiral pattern in sdss j102726.32 + 794911.9 and thus it is possible that only the central bright part of this galaxy is visible . however , two significant this scenario . the hi column density peak value for the high - resolution map reaches a higher value than the low - resolution map , indicating the to be compact and clumpy . the peak values and dimensions of the hi clumps in the high - resolution hi map are similar for hp(n ) and hp(s ) , consistent with both being . also contrary to what is expected of a big lsb spiral , we find no signs of regular rotation in this mass . instead the velocity field of the western mass is chaotic and ( lower panel figure [ fig1 ] ) shows an interesting gradient suggesting infall of gas from the eastern and the western sides towards the central region . thus we find this more like tidal debris than an interacting massive lsb disk . as explained in section 3 , the debris has two peaks , hp(n ) and hp(s ) , and we confirm these peaks coincide , with small offsets ( @xmath0 5@xmath24 , with the two dwarf galaxies described in @xcite , the tdg and sdss j102726.32 + 794911.9 respectively . from the channel images and the gmrt spectrum , we find this is the tdg candidate suggested by @xcite . the in the low - resolution ( @xmath0 30@xmath15 ) map for this object is 6.6@xmath510@xmath25@xmath26 . at a distance of 130 mpc , a 30@xmath15 beam samples @xmath018 kpc . the mass of the debris and the hi column density values are a good match with those found in tdgs @xcite . the high - resolution ( @xmath0 10@xmath15 ) hi map further confirms the hi peak to be associated with the tdg as well as hi extension to the east towards the tidal tail of ngc3212 . hp(s ) on the other hand , coincides with the small , very blue galaxy either a dwarf galaxy or a recently detached tdg . our high - resolution hi image ( lower right of figure [ fig1 ] ) shows an offset ( @xmath0 5@xmath15 ) between the galaxy and the hi peak . from the gmrt spectrum , we find the hi either interacting with the tidal debris the latter option is unlikely as the galaxy is bright in sdss z band suggesting presence of an old stellar population a recently formed tdg . unlike the diffuse structure associated with hp(n ) , bright in the spitzer images implying strong star formation activity , possibly triggered by interaction . massive displacement of hi from the galaxy disk due to tidal interaction has been witnessed in a few other cases also @xcite . of these , the hi distribution of the arp 181 system very closely resembles arp 105 @xcite . in the arp 105 system , bulk of the arp 181 is a system at moderate redshift @xmath0 0.032 . future sensitive hi surveys by telescopes such as australian square kilometre array pathfinder ( askap ) @xcite prove to be very powerful tools for identifying tidal dwarfs at moderate and large redshifts to explore in detail the evolution of dwarf galaxies in the universe . we thank the staff of the _ gmrt _ who have made these observations possible . gmrt _ is operated by the national centre for radio astrophysics of the tata institute of fundamental research . we thank the reviewer for his / her useful comments and suggestions . this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration . 99 baars j. w. m. , genzel r. , pauliny - toth i. i. k. , witzel a. , 1977 , a&a , 61 , 99 barnes joshua e. , hernquist lars , 1992a , nature , 360 , 715 barnes joshua e. , hernquist lars , 1992 , ara&a , 30 , 705 bournaud f. et al , 2007 , science , 316 , 1166 . braine j. , duc p .- a . , lisenfeld u. , charmandaris v. , vallejo o. , leon s. , brinks e. , 2001 , a&a , 378 , 51 de vaucouleurs g. , de vaucouleurs a. , corwin h. g. jr . , buta r. j. , paturel g. , fouque p. , 1992 , 7137 , 0d . deboer et al . , 2009 , ieeep , 97 , 1057 duc p .- a . , brinks e. , springel v. , pichardo b. weilbacher p. , mirabel i. f. , 2000 , aj , 120 , 1238 . duc p .- a . , brinks e. , wink j. e. , mirabel i. f , 1997 , a&a , 326 , 537 duc p .- a . , mirabel i. f. , 1999 , iaus , 186 , 61 duc p .- a . , 2011arxiv1101.4834d haynes m. p. , giovanelli r. , 1984 , aj , 89 , 758 hibbard et al . , 2005 , apj , 619 , 87 hota ananda , saikia d. j. , irwin judith a. , 2007 , mnras , 380 , 1009 johnston et al . , 2008 , exa , 22 , 151 kaviraj sugata , darg daniel , lintott chris , schawinski kevin , silk joseph , 2012 , mnras . 419 , 70 neff s.g . , et al . , 2005 , apj , 619 , l91 rupen m. p. , hibbard j. e. , bunker k. , 2001 , aspc , 240 , 864 ryan - weber et al . , 2004 , aj , 127 , 1431 prochaska j. x. , 2003 , apj , 582 , 49 sengupta chandreyee , balasubramanyam ramesh , 2006 , mnras , 369 , 360 springel , volker ; di matteo , tiziana ; hernquist , lars , 2005 , apj , 620l , 79 smith b. j. , struck c. , hancock m. , appleton p. n. , charmandaris v. , reach w. t. , 2007 , aj , 133 , 791 smith b. j. , giroux m. l. , struck c. , hancock m. , 2010 , aj , 139 , 1212 smith b. j. , giroux m. l. , struck c. , hancock m. , hurlock s. , 2010 , aspc , 423 , 257 sun m. , donahue m. , roediger e. , nulsen p. e. j. , voit g. m. , sarazin c. , forman w. , jones c. , 2010 , apj , 708 , 946 theureau , g. et al . , 1998 , a&as , 130 , 333

we present results from gmrt hi 21 cm line observations of the interacting galaxy pair arp 181 ( ngc3212 and ngc3215 ) at z = 0.032 . we find almost all of the detected hi ( 90% ) displaced well beyond the optical disks of the pair with the highest density hi located @xmath070 kpc west of the pair . an hi bridge between the optical pair and the bulk of the hi strong evidence that hi to the west of the pair has two approximately intensity peaks . the hi intensity maximum furthest to the west coincides with a small companion sdss j102726.32 + 794911.9 which shows enhanced mid infrared ( spitzer ) , uv ( galex ) and h@xmath1 emission indicating intense star forming activity . the hi intensity maximum close to the arp 181 pair , coincides with a diffuse optical cloud detected in uv ( galex ) at the end of the stellar and hi tidal tails originating at ngc3212 , previously proposed a tidal dwarf galaxy in formation . future sensitive hi surveys by telescopes like askap should prove to be powerful tools for identifying tidal dwarfs at moderate to large redshifts to explore in detail the evolution of dwarf galaxies in the universe . [ firstpage ] galaxies : spiral - galaxies : interactions - galaxies : kinematics and dynamics - galaxies : individual : arp 181 - radio lines : galaxies - radio continuum : galaxies

1301.4648

in petroleum reservoirs in order to find the lithology , the well - logging technique has proved adequate for oil exploration and production . parallel to the research of oil and gas fields , some features of petrophysical quantities obtained by well - logging could be analyzed and described in terms of the kind and content of the fluids within the pores . the quantities investigated in this research includes gamma emission ( gr ) , which is a measure of the natural radiation of the formation ; sonic transient time ( dt ) , which is a recording of the time required for a sound wave to travel through a formation ; neutron porosity ( nphi ) , which uses high - energy neutrons that collide with various atoms of both the formation material and fluids , reporting the existence of hydrogen in the pore space @xcite . these help us insight into the spatial heterogeneity of the properties of the large scale porous media , such as porosity , density , and the lithology at distinct length scales @xcite . in geological systems external forces besides internal instabilities cause the system to become a complex system . in order to analyze geological systems the theory of complex systems needs to be implemented . in this theory the probability density function ( pdf ) , entropy , and the degree of non - gaussianity is used . however the working parameter in this study is the entropy which is an important bases in thermodynamics . entropy was introduced in @xmath2 by rudolf julius emmanuel clausius @xcite . later boltzmann showed that entropy could be expressed in terms of the probabilities related to the microscopic structures of the system @xcite . when a system is in contact with a large reservoir , the boltzmann - gibbs entropy is obtained as : @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the probability of the microscopic configuration @xmath5 @xcite , and @xmath6 is the boltzmann constant . so one can conclude that entropy is subject to the probabilities of possibilities in system , reflecting the information upon the physical system @xcite . it is well - known in the classical boltzmann - gibbs ( bg ) statistical mechanics that the gaussian pdf under appropriate constraints , maximizes the bg entropy . bg statistics has been successful in explaining the behavior of systems in which short spatial / temporal interactions are significant @xcite . tsallis in @xmath7 proposed an entropy for systems that may have a multifractal , scale - free or hierarchical structure in the occupancy of their phase space as in the form @xcite @xmath8 which generalizes @xmath9 @xcite . where @xmath10 is nonnegative , concave , experimentally robust ( or lesche - stable @xcite ) and yield a finite entropy production per unit time @xcite . note that the applicability of tsalis entropy becomes important for systems with long - ranged correlations which involve strong interactions , glassy systems , fractal processes , some types of dissipative dynamics and other systems that in some way violate ergodicity . the entropy of expression @xmath11 has been applied to a wide range of science such as physics , biology , chemistry , economics , geophysics @xcite and medicines @xcite and references therein . at depth @xmath12 to @xmath13 of a gas well in southwest of iran.,width=377,height=207 ] we use well log data from a gas well in southwest of iran . these data are gamma ray radioactivity ( gr ) , sonic transient time ( dt ) and neutron porosity ( nphi ) taken every @xmath14 at the depth interval of @xmath15 meters . the logged interval includes asmari formation which is one of the main oil producer formations in iran reservoirs and consists mainly of fractured carbonate , sand stone , shaly sand and a trace of anhydrate . @xmath16 shows gr , dt and nphi data sets from the depth , @xmath17 , of @xmath12 to @xmath18 . our analysis is based on the increment of the petrophysical quantities shown by @xmath19 in various scales , @xmath20 , which @xmath21 . in this article we describe the petrophysical quantities using the pdf and non - gaussian degree , @xmath0 , based on tsallis entropy in section @xmath22 . we explain the connection between entropy ( less of information ) and the non - gaussian factor @xmath23 ( intermittency ) for these data sets in section @xmath24 and the conclusions are stated in section @xmath25 . . these estimations are fulfilled on petrophysical quantities such as gamma emission ( gr ) , sonic transient time ( dt ) and neutron porosity ( nphi ) that measured in space interval @xmath14 from a gas well in southwest of iran . solid lines are theoretical estimation achieved by fitting data sets to eq . since the shannon entropy is the logarithm of the probability , the entropy is extensive . as known the shannon entropy is considering all phenomenon based on the boltzmanian probability distribution function ( pdf ) . while , in general the experimental systems have no reason to obey the boltzmanian distribution . tsallis added a power of @xmath0 to the probability to be able to generalize the shannon entropy to all phenomenon , this causes the entropy not to be extensive . as the value of @xmath0 increases , the effects of the tails become more pronounced . hence , in systems where @xmath0 is greater than unity the minority is more pronounced compared a gaussian ( @xmath28 ) system . in other words having the value of @xmath0 greater than unity , non - gaussianity appears . in order to determine the non - gaussian degree of the system , @xmath0 , it is essential to determine the probability distribution function analytically . following the formalism of @xcite , we obtain the probability distribution function . since the most probable distribution corresponds to the maximum entropy , the variational principle is applied to @xmath27 . the continuous version of @xmath27 is stated as : @xmath29^{q } dx } } { q-1},\ ] ] where @xmath30 is the natural constraint corresponding to the normalization of eq . @xmath31 and @xmath32^{q } } { \int{[p(x)]^{q } dx } } dx}\equiv \langle x \rangle_{q } = \overline{\mu}_{q } , \,\,\,\,\ \int{(x-\overline{\mu}_{q})^{2 } \frac { [ p(x)]^{q } } { \int{[p(x)]^{q } dx } } dx}\equiv \langle ( x-\overline{\mu}_{q})^{2 } \rangle_{q } = \overline{\sigma}_{q},\ ] ] are the natural constraints corresponding to the generalized and mean variance of @xmath33 respectively , see @xcite . , for the @xmath24 data sets . this estimation has been made by determining the pdf based on tsallis entropy then exert @xmath34 test method . right panel : representation of entropy vs. the scales by employing the definition of tsallis entropy eq . @xmath31 for gr ( square ) , dt ( delta ) and nphi ( right triangle).,width=491,height=207 ] implementing the lagrange method in order to find the optimizing distribution under the constraints , we obtain @xcite @xmath35^{\frac { 1 } { 1-q } } \ , \ ( q<3),\ ] ] where @xmath36^{-1}.\ ] ] in order to characterize the non - gaussian degree of the system , @xmath0 , the @xmath34 test method is employed . if @xmath0 is close to @xmath16 , the pdf tends to be gaussian , hence , an uncorrelated series is expected . on the other hand , the large value of the non - gaussian factor @xmath0 , illustrates strong correlations and similarity of neighbors in data sets which affects the behavior of the system . therefore it can be concluded that high @xmath0 is a hallmark of having information about the system . for any @xmath0 a pdf could be plotted as shown in fig . @xmath22 . in fig . @xmath22 the pdf is plotted using eq . @xmath26 ( solid curves ) and the data sets ( symbols ) , showing a satisfactory consistency . to state more specifically , in order to estimate @xmath0 , we use the likelihood method which works by minimizing the parameter @xmath37 which defined as : @xmath38^{2}}{\sigma^{2}_{emperical}(x)+\sigma^{2}_{q}(x)},\ ] ] where @xmath39 is computed directly from the empirical series and @xmath40 is given by eq . @xmath41 is the mean standard deviation of @xmath39 and @xmath42 is associated with the probability density function derived by eq . the global minimum value of @xmath37 corresponds to the best value of @xmath0 . the best estimation of @xmath0 , corresponding to eq . ( 5 ) , yields the pdf which fits well to the empirical pdf . the entropy index @xmath0 versus the scales is shown in fig . @xmath24 ( left panel ) for any specific petrophysical series . note that the system is described by a specific @xmath0 for any scale . taking a close look at fig . @xmath22 and fig . @xmath24 we deduce that the non - gaussian pdf corresponds to large @xmath0 , specially at small scales . this means that @xmath0 is showing the efficiency of non - guassianity . as seen in the three panels of fig . @xmath22 , non - gaussianity of gr is more pronounced in comparison to dt and nphi . hence , powerful correlations and large fluctuations in the series are observed which influence the other quantities and gives an insight to the formation of the system . however , it could be seen in the third panel which is for nphi , that the pdf is non - gaussian at small scales but tends to be gaussian at large scales which corresponds to large and small values of @xmath0 respectively . as the values of @xmath0 in nphi tends to @xmath16 , no correlation exists , hence no information about the porosity would be available @xcite . in the right panel of fig . @xmath24 , the entropy of the data sets are plotted vs. the scales . it is shown that the entropy of gr has its least value at all scales , meaning that we have fine information about the existence of shaly layers detected by gamma ray . hence , the entropy decreases as the scale increases . also it is shown that the entropy of nphi is small at small scales which proves the existence of local correlation , but increases for large scales . this expresses the separated and uncorrelated porosity . comparing fig.@xmath22 and fig . @xmath24 we deduce that small entropy corresponds to non - gaussian pdf . note that this result is always true specially when the scale is small . . solid lines display linear fitting corresponding to the mentioned quantities.,width=340,height=264 ] in order to show the multifractal characteristic of the data sets the tsalis difference information needs to be calculated @xcite @xmath43,\ ] ] where transition is performed between states @xmath44 and @xmath45 . since the generalized entropy @xmath10 ( eq . @xmath11 ) has been introduced based on the concept of multifractals , so the degree of multifractality corresponds to the information evolution . actually , because the phase space of a multifractal geometry is occupied heterogeneously , we expect high information rate in this system . in fig.@xmath25 , it is shown that the difference information received from gr is high and increasing when the scale becomes greater , that is a hallmark of strong multifractality across the scales . on the other hand , the difference information for nphi is rapidly descending , meaning that the information at large scales is lost . note that weak difference information for dt suggests that dt may be nearly monofractal @xcite . to describe the pdf of the velocity difference between two points in fully developed turbulent flows , castaing et al . @xcite introduced the following equation based on a log - normal cascade model @xcite : @xmath46 where @xmath47 , @xmath48 are positive parameters . by taking the limit @xmath49 in eq . @xmath50 , a gaussian distribution is obtained . as verified in @xcite , the shape of @xmath51 is mainly determined by @xmath52 . in fact @xmath23 quantifies how fatal the non - gaussianity of data sets are @xcite . as in the case where @xmath0 determined the non - gaussian property , @xmath53 . in fig.@xmath54 the behavior of the entropy for data sets is plotted vs. @xmath0 and @xmath23 in the left and right panels , respectively . since entropy is a measure of lack of information , the system with low entropy is eager to receive more information potential . this reveals that the non - gaussian factor @xmath23 is a sign of a sudden phase transient in the system . meaning that the system has two phases which is a logical reason to get close to a petroleum reservoir . as seen for gamma ray series in fig.@xmath54 , at high @xmath23 the entropy tends to decrease to show the existence of global correlation with a strong interaction with environment . in fact the increase in the @xmath23 leads to a non - gaussian pdf . this confirms a high @xmath0 which results in having valuable information about the quantity . in contrast , there is high value of entropy at low @xmath23 for nphi which may be due to the gaussian behavior and loss of the information of porosity . there are systems in which long - ranged correlations give rise to strong interactions with environment and violate ergodicity . these systems can not be described by classical bg statistics . thus another definition for entropy which is the basis of statistical mechanics was defined by tsallis in @xmath7 . in this research the statistical mechanics based on the approach introduced by tsallis was applied for analyzing petrophysical quantities which contain gamma emission ( gr ) , sonic transient time ( dt ) and neutron porosity ( nphi ) . based on the tsallis entropy , we fitted the data sets to the probability density function ( pdf ) in order to obtain the non - gaussian degree , @xmath0 of each series which is able to describe any system at any scale . there exist various indicators to analysis the petroleum reservoirs . in this article , we have investigated the non- gaussianity ( uncertainly ) in some indicators which could be appeared near the interface by two environments . then , compared this effect in some indicators in various scales and measures the information contained in each indicators . in fig . @xmath24 we showed that large degree of @xmath0 relates to a fat - tailed pdf in fig . @xmath22 which exhibits global correlation in the formation of the system . for the gr the fat tailed pdf was shown , however , for nphi the fat tailed pdf was observed at small scales . this is due to the fact that the local correlation in nphi exists . hence , for dt and nphi , @xmath0 and the efficiency of non - gaussianity decreases . non - gaussian pdf at large scales gives us information about the criticality in the system which results in the entropy decreases . the extremely increase of entropy for nphi at large scales is due to the gaussian behavior of pdf which causes separated and uncorrelated porosity . the non - gaussian factor ( intermittency ) @xmath23 , which is also another important quantity is obtained from the castaing equation . high @xmath23 is a sign of two phases in the system which corresponds to a fat - tailed pdf or in other words a large @xmath0 . this means that high @xmath23 for gr at all scales gives us valuable information about the existence of global correlation and a sudden phase transition in this series . the difference information of the data sets was shown in fig . we showed that gr has a high difference information specially at large scales . in addition , it was shown that gr exhibits a multifractal property , which is due to the fact that a high information rate in a system is present . while for dt , a monofractal property was exhibited which is due to the low information rate . ) ) for the data sets : gr ( square ) , dt ( delta ) , nphi ( right triangle ) vs. non - gaussian degree , @xmath0 in the right panel and the intermittency @xmath23 defined by castaing equation in log - normal cascade model ( eq . ( @xmath55))in the left panel.,width=472,height=207 ]

the geological systems such as petroleum reservoirs is investigated by the entropy introduced by tsallis and multiplicative hierarchical cascade model . when non - gaussianity appears , it is sign of uncertainty and phase transition , which could be sign of existence of petroleum reservoirs . two important parameters which describe a system at any scale are determined ; the non - gaussian degree , @xmath0 , announced in entropy and the intermittency , @xmath1 , which explains a critical behavior in the system . there exist some petrophysical indicators in order to characterize a reservoir , but there is vacancy to measure scaling information contain in comparison with together , yet . in this article , we compare the non - gaussianity in three selected indicators in various scales . the quantities investigated in this article includes gamma emission ( gr ) , sonic transient time ( dt ) and neutron porosity ( nphi ) . it is observed that gr has a fat tailed pdf at all scales which is a sign of phase transition in the system which indicates high @xmath0 and @xmath1 . this results in the availability of valuable information about this quantity . nphi displays a scale dependence of pdf which converges to a gaussian at large scales . this is a sign of a separated and uncorrelated porosity at large scales . for the dt series , small @xmath1 and @xmath0 at all scales are a hallmark of local correlations in this quantity . keywords : tsallis entropy , non - gaussian degree , intermittency .

astro-ph0002209

the mid infrared emission bands at 3.3 , 6.2 , 7.7 , 8.6 , 11.3 and 12.7 are ubiquitous in the interstellar medium ( ism ) . the coincidence of these bands with characteristic wavelengths of aromatic molecules and attached functional groups ( see e.g. allamandola et al . @xcite ) is sufficiently convincing to call them aromatic infrared bands ( aibs ) . other , more neutral designations are unidentified infrared bands ( uibs ) or infrared emission features ( iefs ) . the designation should stabilize in the future . their carriers are very small grains ( or big molecules ) heated transiently by the absorption of a single uv ( sellgren et al . @xcite ) or visible ( uchida et al . @xcite ; pagani et al . @xcite ) photon . they are often identified with polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons ( pahs ) ( lger & puget @xcite , allamandola et al . duley & williams ( @xcite ) and duley et al . ( @xcite ) have proposed an alternative interpretation in which the carriers of the aibs are not free particles but `` graphitic islands '' ( i.e. akin to pahs ) loosely attached to each other so that the heat conductivity is small . then their thermal behaviour is comparable to that of free particles . similar models have been also proposed by others . the carriers could also be very small particles . in this letter , we will not enter into this debate and will simply call them the _ aib carriers_. the origin of the aib carriers is still unclear . the idea that they are formed in the envelopes of carbon stars is not supported by observation and meets with theoretical difficulties ( e.g. cherchneff et al . they might be formed outside carbon star envelopes from carbonaceous particles condensed previously in these envelopes . schnaiter et al . ( @xcite ) and others have proposed such an evolutionary scheme from carbon stars to planetary nebulae . however the aib carriers formed in this way might not survive the strong uv field of planetary nebulae . for example , cox et al . ( @xcite ) find no aib in the helix nebula , an old carbon rich planetary nebula . another possibility is that they are formed in the ism from carbonaceous grains or carbonaceous mantles covering silicate nuclei . boulanger et al . ( @xcite ) and gry et al . ( @xcite ) have suggested that the strong variations in the iras 12/100 interstellar flux ratio are due to the release of transiently heated particles ( emitting at 12 ) by bigger particles , respectively due to uv irradiation or to shattering by shocks . thanks to the infrared space observatory ( iso ) , we know now that in the general ism the emission in the iras 12 band is dominated by aibs . variations in the ratio of aib carriers to big grains are thus confirmed . laboratory experiments shed some light on this process . scott et al . ( @xcite ) have observed the release of aromatic carbon clusters containing in excess of 30 carbon atoms by solid hydrogenated amorphous carbon ( hac ) irradiated by a strong uv laser pulse . the energy deposited by the laser pulse per unit target area is similar to the energy of a central collision between two grains of 10 nm radius at a velocity of 10 km s@xmath0 . this is an indication for a possible release of aib carriers in interstellar shocks . iso has also shown the existence of variations of aib spectra that may be related to a transformation of carbonaceous grains . recently , uchida et al . ( @xcite ) have observed a broadening of the 6.2 , 7.7 and 8.6 aibs when going from strong to weak radiation field in the reflection nebula vdb17 = ngc1333 . they also notice an increase of the flux ratio @xmath1(5.509.75)/@xmath1(10.2514.0 ) with increasing radiation field in several reflection nebulae . we present mid ir spectrophotometric and co(21 ) line observations of another reflection nebula , ced201 , that shed light into this transformation . section 2 describes briefly the observations and reductions . 3 describes the results , and sect . 4 contains a discussion and the conclusions . the observations have been made with the 32@xmath232 element mid - infrared camera ( isocam ) on board of iso , with the circular variable filters ( cvfs ) ( see cesarsky et al . @xcite for a complete description ) . the observations employed a 6/pixel magnification , yielding a field of view of about 3@xmath23 . full scans of the two cvfs in the long - wave channel of the camera have been performed , covering a wavelength range from 5.15 to 17 . 10 exposures of 2.1s each were added for each step of the cvf , and 20 extra exposures were added at the beginning of each scan in order to limit the effect of the transient response of the detectors . the total observing time was about 1 hour . the raw data were processed as described in cesarsky et al . ( @xcite ) using the cia software ( starck et al . however , the new transient correction described by coulais & abergel ( @xcite ) has been applied , yielding considerable improvements with respect to previous methods . the reflection nebula ced201 is a rather compact object at a distance of 420 pc ( casey @xcite ) , on the edge of a molecular cloud . it is excited by the b9.5v star bd + 69@xmath31231 . witt et al . ( @xcite ) notice that the radial velocity of this star differs from that of the molecular cloud by 11.7 @xmath4 3.0 km s@xmath0 so that ced201 is probably the result of an accidental encounter of the star with the molecular cloud , while for most other reflection nebulae the exciting star was born _ in situ_. an arc - like structure located between the star and the denser parts of the cloud to the north and the north - east at about 18 from the star might represent a shock due to the supersonic motion of the star . it is not very clearly visible on fig . 1 but is well visible on the red poss1 image delivered by aladin ( http://aladin.u-strasbg.fr ) . our cvf observation shows a small source surrounded by a faint extended emission ( fig . the absolute positioning of the isocam images is uncertain due to the lens wheel not always returning to its nominal position ( the maximum error is 2 times the pixel field of view , viz . 12 arcsec here ) and the images have to be recentered on known objects when possible . since we see on the spectra of the pixels corresponding to the strong source a continuum between 5.15 and 5.5 that we attribute to the photospheric emission of the exciting star ( see fig . 3 ) , we have recentered the cvf image at these wavelengths on the nominal simbad position of bd + 69@xmath31231 ( @xmath5(j2000 ) = 22h 13 m 27s , @xmath6(j2000 ) = 70@xmath3 15 18 ) . this resulted in fig . unfortunately the astrometry of bd + 69@xmath31231 is itself somewhat problematic due to the surrounding bright nebulosity and the location of the cvf image on the optical image is correspondingly uncertain . also , the proper motion of the star from the original bd position is unknown . 2 presents a set of co(21 ) spectra of the molecular cloud obtained by us at the caltech submillimeter observatory with 30 hpbw and 30 sampling . these observations are better sampled than the co(21 ) map of kemper et al . ( @xcite ; 21 hpbw , 60 sampling ) but are in good agreement . the line intensity peaks in the direction of the star , probably due to local excitation of co. the higher resolution @xmath7co(21 ) map of kemper et al . ( @xcite ; 21 hpbw , 20 sampling ) shows that this is not the position of maximum column density which peaks well to the ne of the star , confirming this conclusion . the @xmath8co profiles are double peaked in this area , in particular towards the arc , and this makes difficult the search for line wings which would be a signature of a shock . there is however some suggestion of a negative velocity wing near the star , in the same sense as the radial velocity of this star . 3 displays a set of 7@xmath27 cvf spectra on a grid with 6@xmath26 spacing centered on the exciting star . one sees typical aib spectra near the emission peak evolving towards fainter , different spectra 1218 arcseconds away . the spectra near the peak show not only the classical aibs , but also the s(3 ) rotation line of h@xmath9 at 9.6 and the s(5 ) line at 6.91 or the line of [ ] at 6.98 , which can not be separated at our resolution . the 12.7 aib might be contaminated by the [ ] 12.8 line . these spectra are typical for a low excitation photodissociation region ( pdr ) . the aibs are superimposed on a continuum rising towards long wavelengths . this could be the continuum emission of very small grains ( vsgs ) . the aibs are broader and much fainter relative to the continuum . the 11.3 aib is now the strongest one at this location . the 7.7 and 8.6 aibs are merged into a single broad band . the most striking feature is the strong emission plateau extending from 11 to 14 . these spectra resemble class b spectra ( tokunaga @xcite ) ( class a spectra are the usual aib spectra ) . 3 shows a behaviour of the spectrum with radiation field similar to that observed by uchida et al . ( @xcite ) in some other reflection nebulae . we find a trend for the 7.7 aibs to become broader at _ fainter _ radiation fields away from the exciting star , fig . the trend is not clear for the other bands , but we should not forget that there is contamination by the aibs from foreground and background material . we suggests that some carbonaceous material that emits the continuum and broad bands far from the star is processed through the effect of the star that moves through the molecular cloud , producing aib carriers : the continuum is only 2 times fainter 12 from the star than close to the star , demonstrating the partial disappearance of its carriers near the star while the aibs become very strong . the very appearance at relatively large distances from the star ( at least 18 ) of a continuum rising towards long wavelengths is surprising . this continuum must be emitted by vsgs heated by single ( visible ) photons . these grains must be quite smaller than the `` classical '' vsgs which require a strong radiation field to emit in the wavelength range of isocam ( contursi et al . the spectra seen far from the star remind strongly of class b spectra seen in carbon rich proto planetary nebulae ( guillois et al . @xcite ) . in the laboratory , such spectra are produced ( in absorption ) by natural coals rich in aromatic cycles ( guillois et al . @xcite ) or by a - c : h materials produced by laser pyrolysis of hydrocarbons ( herlin et al . @xcite ; schnaiter et al . @xcite ) . in ced201 , these carbonaceous grains must be very small ( radius of the order of 1 nm ) since they are heated transiently by visible photons to the temperatures of @xmath10 250 k necessary to emit the observed mid ir features . since this is also the approximate size of the classical aib carriers it would not be appropriate to say that these particles release these carriers . one should invoke instead chemi physical transformations like aromatization ( ryter @xcite ) . in any case , these small grains were already present before the star penetrated the molecular cloud . they are expected to be present elsewhere in the ism . we find that assuming spherical symmetry the total emissivity per unit volume in the cvf spectral range ( 5.15 to 17 ) decreases approximately as the inverse square root of the distance to the star , independently of the shape of the spectrum . we base the following calculation on the light diffusion model of witt et al . ( @xcite ) , who postulate a uniform density that we find equal to n(h ) = 2n(h@xmath9 ) = 1800 @xmath11 . this density corresponds to a visual extinction of only 0.02 mag . per 6 angular distance . since the integrated mid ir emission is proportional to the stellar radiation density , we can derive an energy conversion efficiency , @xmath12 = 7.5 % ( emitted in 4@xmath13 steradians ) . knowing the density , the radiation field of the b9.5v star , and adopting an absorption cross section per carbon atom of @xmath14 @xmath15 ( allamandola et al . @xcite ) and an interstellar carbon abundance c / h=@xmath16 ( snow & witt @xcite ; see also andrievsky et al . @xcite for carbon abundance in b stars ) , we find that the fraction of carbon locked in the very small particles emitting in the mid ir is 15% . this is in agreement with the independent analysis of kemper et al . ( @xcite ) who find that 10% of the gas phase carbon is locked in particles smaller than 1.5 nm . the _ absorption _ by these particles contributes to 1/4 of the _ extinction _ in the visible , a considerable fraction . we have examined the ratio of the strength of the 6.2 ( a vibration of the aromatic skeleton ) and of the 11.3 aib features ( a c h bending mode ) as a function of distance to the exciting star . no variation has been seen in this ratio within our rather large ( 30 % ) errors . it is interesting to note that witt et al . ( @xcite ) find from uv visible scattering studies of ced201 that the grains responsible for the visible scattering have a narrow size distribution skewed towards big , wavelength sized grains . this is mostly seen within about 20 from the star . on the other hand the very strong 2175 extinction band suggests the presence of many smaller carbon grains . all this is evidence for grain processing by the radiation of the star , or / and by shattering of grains by a shock wave associated with its motion . the very small carbonaceous grains we see in ced201 through their mid ir emission might be responsible for the 2175 band . in summary , we have shown the existence of transformations near a star of very small , hydrogenated carbonaceous grains which are probably present everywhere in the ism . this transformation of carbonaceous grains into aib carriers might be due either to the radiation of a b9.5v star , or to a shock induced by the supersonic motion of the star through the molecular cloud . although the existence of a shock is indicated by an optical arc visible 18 from the star ( and also suspected from our co observations ) , there is no obvious sign of it in the spectra shown in fig . 3 and it may not be the cause of the transformation . the very small grains as well as the aib carriers formed from them are excited by the light of the star . the conversion efficiency between received excitation energy and mid ir emitted energy is of the order of 7.5% for both kinds of particles , and the fraction of carbon locked in these particles is approximately 15% . we thank cecile reynaud and olivier guillois for interesting discussions , kris sellgren for suggesting fig . 4 and the referee adolf n. witt for his useful remarks . the cso is funded by nsf contract ast 96 - 15025 .

we present spectrophotometric imaging mid ir observations of the reflection nebula ced201 . ced201 is a part of a molecular cloud illuminated by a b9.5v star moving through it at more than 12 km s@xmath0 . the spectra of ced201 give evidence for transformation of very small carbonaceous grains into the carriers of the aromatic infrared bands ( aibs ) , due to the radiation field of the illuminating star and/or to shock waves created by its motion . these very small grains emit mainly very broad bands and a continuum . we suggest that they are present everywhere in the interstellar medium but can only be detected in the mid ir under special circumstances such as those prevailing in this reflection nebula . the efficiency of energy conversion of stellar light into mid infrared emission is 7.5% for both the very small grains and the aib carriers , and the fraction of interstellar carbon locked in these emitters is approximately 15% .

0911.4927

this paper continues our effort to use the subaru telescope to search for proper motions among very faint stars . our first paper ( @xcite ) examined a series of images of the subaru deep field ( sdf ) ( @xcite ) , located close to the northern galactic pole ( @xmath1 , @xmath2 ) . we report here on a similar analysis of images of the subaru / xmm - newton deep survey ( sxds ) field ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) , which lies at high galactic latitude in the southern galactic hemisphere ( @xmath3 , @xmath4 ) . as in our earlier work , we are taking advantage of a dataset compiled for the study of very distant extragalactic objects ; the long time coverage necessary to detect supernovae and agn provides us with the baseline needed to measure proper motions for a significant number of stars in our own milky way . we pay special attention to members of the faintest stellar populations , white dwarfs . since we will follow very closely the methods used in our analysis of the sdf , we urge the reader to consult @xcite for a detailed description of some procedures we may mention only briefly here . however , the sxds dataset differs from the sdf dataset in one very important way : it consists of a mixture of images taken through two passbands , the suprime - cam @xmath5 and @xmath6 ( @xcite ) , while the sdf data was all taken through @xmath6 . this inhomogeneity complicates efforts to determine the selection effects which define our sample of moving objects ; therefore , we discuss in depth our tests of the magnitudes and motions to which our analysis of the sxds is reasonably complete . one of our goals in this project is to compare observed sets of moving stars to those predicted by various models of stellar populations in the milky way . we will need a good understanding of the selection effects on the observations in order to compare them fairly to models in a future paper . section 2 describes the observations and the steps we took to convert the raw images into clean , seamless mosaic images . we list in section 3 our procedures for finding and measuring the properties of stars in the images , yielding a list of formal motions for tens of thousands of stars . most of these motions , of course , were not significantly different from zero , and so we discuss in section 4 our techniques for selecting a small subset of stars with significant proper motions . we used artificial stars inserted into our images to estimate the completeness of our sample as a function of magnitude and motion , and , to a limited degree , color . in section 5 , we briefly compare our sample of moving stars with those found in the sdf and predicted in the the besanon model ( @xcite ) . we also highlight one very interesting star , which combines a large proper motion with a very faint apparent magnitude . the subaru / xmm - newton deep survey ( sxds ) involves sensitive measurements across a wide range of wavelengths over a region of about 1.3 square degrees ( @xcite , @xcite ) . since the main goal of the project is to study extragalactic objects , the field is located at relatively high galactic latitude ( @xmath7 ) . we analyze a subset of the optical images taken with the subaru 8.2-meter telescope and suprime - cam camera ( @xcite ) . the regions in the southern ( sxds - s ) and eastern ( sxds - e ) sections of the survey ( see figure [ fig : sxdsregions ] and table [ table : regions ] ) were observed at least 11 times over the period september , 2002 , to january , 2008 . we provide a list of the observations in table [ table : journal ] . note that data taken on september 29 and september 30 , 2002 , were combined to form a single composite image . l c c c c name & min ra & max ra & min dec & max dec + sxds - e & 02:18:55 & 02:20:34 & -05:17:24 & -04:43:12 + sxds - s & 02:16:37 & 02:18:54 & -05:32:22 & -05:06:50 + ( 80mm,80mm)figure1.eps l c c r ut date & julian date - 2,450,000 & filter & exptime ( seconds ) + & sxds - e & & + 2002 sep 29 , 30 & 2548.5 & @xmath6 & 3000 + 2002 nov 1 & 2579.9 & @xmath6 & 3000 + 2002 nov 1 & 2580.0 & @xmath5 & 1500 + 2002 nov 2 & 2580.8 & @xmath6 & 1800 + 2002 nov 9 & 2587.8 & @xmath6 & 2820 + 2002 nov 9 & 2588.0 & @xmath5 & 210 + 2002 nov 29 & 2608.0 & @xmath6 & 1800 + 2003 sep 22 & 2905.0 & @xmath6 & 6000 + 2003 oct 2 & 2915.1 & @xmath6 & 1271 + 2003 oct 21 & 2934.1 & @xmath6 & 1400 + 2005 sep 28 & 3642.0 & @xmath6 & 3600 + 2008 jan 9 & 4474.8 & @xmath5 & 2400 + + & sxds - s & & + 2002 sep 29 , 30 & 2548.4 & @xmath6 & 3000 + 2002 nov 1 & 2579.9 & @xmath6 & 3600 + 2002 nov 1 & 2580.0 & @xmath5 & 2400 + 2002 nov 2 & 2580.8 & @xmath6 & 1800 + 2002 nov 9 & 2587.8 & @xmath6 & 2580 + 2002 nov 9 & 2588.0 & @xmath5 & 2400 + 2002 nov 29 & 2608.0 & @xmath6 & 1500 + 2003 sep 22 & 2905.0 & @xmath6 & 4500 + 2003 oct 2 & 2915.1 & @xmath6 & 2040 + 2005 sep 28 & 3642.0 & @xmath6 & 2040 + 2008 jan 9 & 4474.7 & @xmath5 & 2400 + we followed the procedure described in @xcite to reduce the raw images and combine them to form a single seamless mosaic for each night . the fwhm of the mosaics varied from @xmath8 on the best night to @xmath9 on the worst , but since the plate scale was @xmath10 per pixel , all images were adequately sampled . the limiting magnitude varied slightly , but on average was about @xmath11 ( see section 3 ) . these measurements reach about @xmath12 magnitudes deeper than those reported in @xcite ; combined with the larger sky coverage , this study encompasses a larger volume . we estimate the effective volume for stars of absolute magnitude @xmath13 to be 130000 cubic parsecs , about four times as large as that of @xcite ( the value of 14000 cubic parsecs shown in table 1 of that paper was an error ; the proper value is 28000 cubic parsecs ) . we now describe briefly the steps we took to reduce the clean mosaic images into a list of starlike objects , and then to find objects with significant motions . the reader can find a detailed description of our methods in @xcite . our first step was to identify and measure the properties of starlike objects . we used the `` stars '' program in the _ xvista _ package ( @xcite ) to find objects with @xmath14 . the images taken on september 22 , 2003 , contained the largest number of objects : 79000 in sxds - e and 86000 in sxds - s . we therefore made this the fiducial epoch for matching and astrometry . we broke each image into overlapping subsections roughly @xmath15 on a side and used the _ match _ package ( @xcite ) to transform the subsections in each image to the fiducial s coordinate system . we looked for matches between epochs using a maximum separation of @xmath16 from the fiducial position of each star . this places an upper limit of about @xmath17 per year on the proper motions we could detect , but , as we will show later , this does not have a strong effect on the results . in order to test the completeness of our object detection , we used a set of artificial stars inserted into the images of sxds - s . because this field was observed one fewer time than sxds - e , the limits we derive from it will likely be conservative estimates for sxds - e . the tests are complicated by the mixture of passbands in the dataset : eight in @xmath6 and three in @xmath5 , including the critical final image taken in 2008 . we therefore ran three sets of tests , using artificial stars with colors @xmath18 of @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 magnitudes . for each color , we created 1000 artificial stars and inserted them at locations known to be free of real stars in each image . we then executed our procedures to find and match stars . we required stars to appear in at least five epochs to qualify for further study . figure [ fig : completenesspqr ] indicates that the fraction of artificial stars entering our proper motion study dropped to 50% at @xmath22 regardless of color . ( 80mm,80mm)figure2.eps a large number of objects qualified for the next step by appearing in at least five images : 47589 in sxds - s and 45500 in sxds - e . we considered the row and column positions of each object separately , making a linear fit to each as a function of time . as described in @xcite , we derived the one - dimensional motion in rows and columns , as well as the uncertainty in each motion . figure [ fig : movingresiduals ] indicates that the precision of our measurements of position in the sxds is roughly the same as that of our measurements in the sdf . the median deviation in each direction from the fitted motion ranged from @xmath23 for bright unsaturated stars to @xmath24 for the faintest objects in our sample . we defined statistics @xmath25 and @xmath26 as the ratios of motion to uncertainty in each direction , and computed the overall significance of each object s motion as @xmath27 . we chose a conservative threshold , @xmath28 , to create samples of `` candidates for stars with proper motions . '' only a small number of objects entered these samples : 40 in the sxds - s and 33 in the sxds - e . the fraction of all objects having significant motions was only about @xmath29 , smaller than the @xmath30 found in the sdf . since the uncertainties in individual measurements were roughly the same in both areas , but stars were measured almost twice as frequently in the sdf , a fixed value of @xmath31 corresponds to a smaller absolute motion in the sdf than in the sxds fields . the time sampling of our survey was far from uniform , and there was a three - year gap between the penultimate and final measurement . moreover , that final measurement was made through the @xmath5 filter , rather than the @xmath6 filter used for most of the images . since that final image influences the proper motions strongly , it is possible that there might be some color dependency in our proper motion sample . therefore , we ran a set of tests using three sets of artificial stars : one group had colors @xmath32 , one ( @xmath33 , and one @xmath34 . we generated 1000 stars in each group with @xmath6-band magnitudes @xmath35 and proper motions @xmath36 per year in random directions . we inserted these artificial stars into our images , analyzed them as described above , and counted the number which appeared in our output set of stars detected as moving with significance @xmath28 . as figure [ fig : pmcolor ] shows , the efficiency with which we detect moving stars does depend on color for the faintest stars : we recover faint blue stars at a higher rate than faint red stars . at the bright end , our efficiency drops to 50% for motions less than about @xmath37 per year for stars of all colors . our search in the sxds is slightly less sensitive to stars with small motions than our search in the sdf , due to the smaller number of images over a similar span of time . ( 150mm,240mm)figure4.eps we show in figure [ fig : pmhist ] the distribution of measured proper motions . the upper limit of @xmath17 per year is set by the matching limit of @xmath16 and the time difference between our fiducial epoch ( sept 22 , 2003 ) and the final epoch ( jan 9 , 2008 ) . since all but a single object have motions less than half this value , we conclude that the limit set by our matching procedures does not bias our final results . we will discuss the one object with @xmath38 per year in the next section . ( 80mm,80mm)figure5.eps we examined each candidate visually at several epochs to verify that the motions were real . we found 1 object in the sxds - s and 3 in the sxds - e which had bogus motions due to blends of two stars or a star and a galaxy . discarding those left 39 candidates in the sxds - s and 30 candidates in the sxds - e . we extracted corrected isophotal magnitudes in @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath5 and @xmath6 passbands for each candidate from the catalogs of @xcite and compared them to the visual appearance of the candidate in images taken from the sxds data release 1 . in several cases ( 5 in sxds - s , 4 in sxds - e ) , we noticed an obvious discrepancy , always in the same sense : the catalog magnitude indicated a much brighter object than actually appeared in the images . we suspect that the matching procedure used to create the catalogs may have confused neighboring objects with very different colors . therefore , we corrected the magnitudes of these candidates as follows : we measured instrumental magnitudes of all candidates in the @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath5 and @xmath6 images of the sxds data release 1 using a small aperture , @xmath41 arcsecond in radius . we examined the difference between our instrumental magnitudes and the catalog magnitudes in each passband ; in all cases , we found a nearly constant offset for both bright and faint stars , except for a few outliers . we then applied this offset to the instrumental magnitudes of the outliers . the discrepancies were largest in the @xmath39 and @xmath40 passbands and almost zero in @xmath6 . there is a small region of overlap between the sxds - s and sxds - e , as one can see in figure [ fig : sxdsregions ] . we noticed that two of the candidates in this region were actually the same object , detected and measured independently in each set of images . this object was one of the photometric outliers and serves as a test of our ability to compute accurate magnitudes . the difference in corrected magnitudes was @xmath42 , @xmath43 and @xmath44 mag in @xmath40 , @xmath5 and @xmath6 , respectively . the annual proper motions derived in each set of images agreed very well : @xmath45 versus @xmath46 in ra , and @xmath47 versus @xmath48 in dec . however , when we compared the positions for this object drawn separately from the sxds - e and sxds - s catalogs of @xcite , we found differences of @xmath49 in ra and @xmath50 in dec . this may indicate the accuracy of the positions of the objects shown in table [ table : sample ] . the result is a sample of 68 stars with significant proper motions and good photometry in four passbands . we list these stars in table [ table : sample ] . as a final check on the reality of the motions , we can compare the measured motions to those predicted by the besanon model of stellar populations within the milky way galaxy . figure [ fig : pmsignif ] shows that our measured motions are predominantly in the southeastern direction , agreeing with the model . ( 120mm,120mm)figure6.eps l l l r r r r r r i d & ra & dec & @xmath40@xmath51 & @xmath5@xmath51 & @xmath6@xmath51 & @xmath52@xmath51 & ra pm & dec pm + sxdspm j021651.8 - 053629 & 34.21609 & -5.60829 & 20.099 & 19.287 & 18.322 & 17.401 & 0.048 @xmath53 0.006 & 0.006 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021658.4 - 051453 & 34.24373 & -5.24807 & 20.309 & 20.143 & 20.132 & 20.066 & -0.009 @xmath53 0.008 & -0.037 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021702.0 - 052310 & 34.25844 & -5.38629 & 21.361 & 20.552 & 19.495 & 18.638 & -0.014 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.045 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021705.9 - 053140 & 34.27470 & -5.52778 & 20.960 & 20.232 & 19.390 & 18.657 & 0.054 @xmath53 0.006 & 0.002 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021706.2 - 052737 & 34.27605 & -5.46043 & 22.959 & 22.283 & 21.704 & 21.334 & 0.026 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.000 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021706.6 - 052724 & 34.27770 & -5.45692 & 19.473 & 19.491 & 19.593 & 19.467 & 0.090 @xmath53 0.002 & 0.018 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021707.2 - 052427 & 34.28022 & -5.40771 & 22.629 & 21.713 & 19.924 & 18.797 & -0.010 @xmath53 0.006 & -0.027 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021708.0 - 051419 & 34.28370 & -5.23883 & 21.888 & 21.224 & 20.844 & 20.512 & 0.025 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.009 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021708.6 - 052501 & 34.28613 & -5.41700 & 21.210 & 20.640 & 20.340 & 20.056 & 0.021 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.039 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021709.9 - 052437 & 34.29164 & -5.41042 & 19.359 & 18.949 & 18.765 & 18.121 & 0.006 @xmath53 0.010 & -0.048 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021712.5 - 052133 & 34.30238 & -5.35927 & 25.035 & 23.881 & 22.015 & 21.002 & -0.016 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.021 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021719.9 - 052038 & 34.33308 & -5.34394 & 23.456 & 22.977 & 21.860 & 21.242 & 0.018 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.014 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021720.9 - 053642 & 34.33718 & -5.61191 & 22.624 & 22.024 & 21.111 & 20.589 & 0.038 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.012 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021722.4 - 053136 & 34.34335 & -5.52691 & 25.028 & 23.684 & 21.769 & 20.732 & 0.036 @xmath53 0.006 & 0.017 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021730.6 - 052459 & 34.37758 & -5.41639 & 19.645 & 19.246 & 19.093 & 18.484 & 0.041 @xmath53 0.006 & -0.029 @xmath53 0.012 + sxdspm j021732.2 - 053558 & 34.38418 & -5.59953 & 20.670 & 20.113 & 19.875 & 19.462 & 0.001 @xmath53 0.006 & -0.036 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021734.8 - 051850 & 34.39506 & -5.31412 & 21.303 & 20.604 & 19.945 & 19.372 & -0.007 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.035 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021736.1 - 053647 & 34.40074 & -5.61307 & 22.646 & 22.264 & 22.066 & 21.865 & 0.058 @xmath53 0.004 & 0.016 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021744.6 - 052116 & 34.43611 & -5.35462 & 20.260 & 19.765 & 19.535 & 19.017 & 0.027 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.011 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021745.3 - 053035 & 34.43904 & -5.50984 & 21.983 & 21.348 & 20.487 & 19.975 & 0.020 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.012 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021756.5 - 053530 & 34.48554 & -5.59187 & 22.863 & 22.261 & 21.071 & 20.434 & 0.092 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.052 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021758.2 - 052304 & 34.49284 & -5.38466 & 24.030 & 23.477 & 22.989 & 22.585 & 0.019 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.008 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021805.6 - 053254 & 34.52353 & -5.54855 & 20.584 & 19.971 & 19.668 & 19.177 & 0.046 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.024 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021806.6 - 053612 & 34.52764 & -5.60350 & 22.747 & 22.552 & 22.428 & 22.232 & -0.017 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.041 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021806.8 - 053613 & 34.52869 & -5.60379 & 22.519 & 21.738 & 20.187 & 19.262 & -0.019 @xmath53 0.006 & -0.044 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021809.7 - 052547 & 34.54078 & -5.42992 & 24.105 & 23.070 & 21.488 & 20.653 & 0.032 @xmath53 0.002 & 0.013 @xmath53 0.008 + sxdspm j021818.2 - 052739 & 34.57622 & -5.46110 & 20.333 & 19.746 & 19.515 & 19.002 & 0.007 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.050 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021819.0 - 052129 & 34.57918 & -5.35825 & 21.402 & 20.613 & 19.516 & 18.610 & 0.027 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.024 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021830.8 - 051918 & 34.62859 & -5.32185 & 23.006 & 22.375 & 21.998 & 21.704 & 0.002 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.023 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021833.5 - 052918 & 34.63963 & -5.48858 & 22.841 & 21.973 & 20.409 & 19.523 & 0.056 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.037 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021835.5 - 051734 & 34.64794 & -5.29294 & 22.605 & 21.889 & 21.000 & 20.489 & 0.001 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.063 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021840.0 - 053623 & 34.66670 & -5.60661 & @xmath54 27.3 & 26.085 & 24.381 & 22.618 & 0.184 @xmath53 0.024 & 0.024 @xmath53 0.028 + sxdspm j021850.4 - 053200 & 34.71003 & -5.53342 & 20.818 & 20.126 & 19.467 & 18.740 & 0.023 @xmath53 0.010 & -0.041 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021856.8 - 044522 & 34.73684 & -4.75612 & 22.112 & 21.248 & 19.816 & 19.002 & 0.020 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.025 @xmath53 0.008 + sxdspm j021858.4 - 052439 & 34.74341 & -5.41092 & 21.530 & 20.574 & 19.157 & 18.121 & 0.075 @xmath53 0.004 & 0.040 @xmath53 0.018 + sxdspm j021901.2 - 051403 & 34.75517 & -5.23426 & 24.560 & 23.221 & 21.297 & 20.255 & 0.049 @xmath53 0.006 & -0.011 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021902.7 - 053628 & 34.76158 & -5.60784 & 20.670 & 19.851 & 18.860 & 18.082 & -0.035 @xmath53 0.012 & -0.044 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021903.0 - 053131 & 34.76257 & -5.52552 & 20.963 & 20.194 & 19.293 & 18.482 & -0.022 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.033 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021903.7 - 052540 & 34.76557 & -5.42783 & 22.867 & 22.167 & 20.903 & 20.143 & 0.011 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.019 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021908.5 - 053002 & 34.78549 & -5.50076 & 21.144 & 20.406 & 19.500 & 18.737 & 0.063 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.056 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021911.0 - 045902 & 34.79612 & -4.98411 & 21.049 & 21.244 & 21.398 & 21.520 & -0.015 @xmath53 0.006 & -0.091 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021914.8 - 045312 & 34.81205 & -4.88669 & 22.594 & 21.743 & 20.394 & 19.608 & 0.023 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.001 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021914.8 - 050120 & 34.81208 & -5.02240 & 23.248 & 22.601 & 21.223 & 20.488 & 0.027 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.015 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021918.6 - 045833 & 34.82772 & -4.97598 & 23.953 & 23.643 & 23.461 & 23.240 & 0.041 @xmath53 0.004 & 0.009 @xmath53 0.010 + sxdspm j021925.1 - 051610 & 34.85480 & -5.26966 & 24.550 & 23.320 & 21.791 & 20.888 & 0.023 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.008 @xmath53 0.008 + sxdspm j021925.7 - 050051 & 34.85742 & -5.01442 & 19.927 & 19.363 & 19.074 & 18.511 & 0.019 @xmath53 0.008 & -0.075 @xmath53 0.010 + sxdspm j021929.2 - 045819 & 34.87201 & -4.97220 & 23.146 & 22.281 & 20.512 & 19.556 & 0.061 @xmath53 0.006 & 0.035 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021935.5 - 050422 & 34.89807 & -5.07289 & 22.303 & 21.430 & 20.061 & 19.267 & -0.007 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.035 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021936.0 - 051658 & 34.90005 & -5.28305 & 20.373 & 19.878 & 19.695 & 19.378 & 0.006 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.018 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j021936.2 - 050341 & 34.90105 & -5.06145 & 20.809 & 20.271 & 19.828 & 19.473 & 0.067 @xmath53 0.008 & 0.010 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021938.6 - 045727 & 34.91113 & -4.95770 & 25.630 & 23.841 & 21.845 & 20.383 & 0.076 @xmath53 0.010 & -0.020 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021939.9 - 045216 & 34.91662 & -4.87112 & 22.535 & 21.806 & 20.811 & 20.262 & 0.023 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.018 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021942.3 - 044706 & 34.92665 & -4.78525 & 23.566 & 22.894 & 22.229 & 21.844 & -0.009 @xmath53 0.008 & -0.045 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j021943.9 - 044432 & 34.93307 & -4.74238 & 22.059 & 21.078 & 19.541 & 18.541 & 0.017 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.054 @xmath53 0.008 + sxdspm j021952.2 - 045056 & 34.96781 & -4.84908 & 21.380 & 20.357 & 19.436 & 18.679 & 0.012 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.042 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j021953.9 - 051649 & 34.97485 & -5.28045 & 22.290 & 21.608 & 20.948 & 20.537 & 0.074 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.022 @xmath53 0.008 + sxdspm j021958.4 - 044516 & 34.99338 & -4.75447 & 20.862 & 20.156 & 19.558 & 19.020 & 0.030 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.021 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j022001.8 - 045640 & 35.00766 & -4.94449 & 21.073 & 20.326 & 19.478 & 18.785 & 0.014 @xmath53 0.008 & -0.029 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j022005.0 - 045022 & 35.02086 & -4.83953 & 20.564 & 19.919 & 19.653 & 19.230 & 0.002 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.069 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j022008.8 - 050351 & 35.03694 & -5.06436 & 22.370 & 21.614 & 20.343 & 19.619 & 0.041 @xmath53 0.006 & -0.011 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j022009.5 - 050912 & 35.03992 & -5.15360 & 22.600 & 21.935 & 21.072 & 20.589 & 0.004 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.029 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j022010.3 - 050259 & 35.04295 & -5.04978 & 25.174 & 24.962 & 24.666 & 24.316 & 0.088 @xmath53 0.014 & -0.023 @xmath53 0.018 + sxdspm j022013.1 - 045912 & 35.05474 & -4.98686 & 21.256 & 20.525 & 19.642 & 18.973 & 0.020 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.021 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j022013.7 - 051353 & 35.05711 & -5.23166 & 24.690 & 23.278 & 21.038 & 19.823 & 0.067 @xmath53 0.006 & 0.003 @xmath53 0.006 + sxdspm j022017.4 - 051313 & 35.07290 & -5.22034 & 23.826 & 23.254 & 22.519 & 22.072 & -0.000 @xmath53 0.002 & -0.034 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j022024.0 - 050606 & 35.10031 & -5.10171 & 22.865 & 22.476 & 22.198 & 21.979 & 0.041 @xmath53 0.010 & -0.084 @xmath53 0.004 + sxdspm j022025.7 - 051028 & 35.10718 & -5.17455 & 22.754 & 21.994 & 20.646 & 19.921 & 0.016 @xmath53 0.004 & -0.030 @xmath53 0.002 + sxdspm j022032.5 - 050834 & 35.13545 & -5.14289 & 22.599 & 21.864 & 20.859 & 20.311 & 0.021 @xmath53 0.002 & 0.004 @xmath53 0.004 + following @xcite , we computed the reduced proper motion for the candidates in our sample in order to separate stars belonging to different populations . figure [ fig : reducedpm ] compares stars in our sample to stars in a simulation of the region based on the besanon model . the regions drawn in the diagram are exactly the same as those shown in figures 7 and 8 of @xcite . we adopt their relationship @xmath55 to compare our results to the models . of the 68 objects in our sample , 13 lie within the `` white dwarf '' ( wd ) region of the diagram , 32 within the `` halo '' region , 12 within the `` disk '' region , 10 within the `` halo sd ? '' region , and 1 falls far from all the rest ( we discuss that outlier below ) . the fraction of stars in each region agree reasonably well with the fractions found in our survey of the sdf . although the fraction of objects in the wd region ( 19% ) is somewhat higher than in the sdf ( 9% ) , we do not consider the difference significant , given the small number of objects in each set , and the number of objects lying very close to the somewhat arbitrary boundaries of the wd region in each sample . we performed multiple simulations using the besanon model to generate stars in the sxds over an effective area of two square degrees . we applied the selection criteria derived in section 3 to these simulated catalogs , then scaled the results to the actual area we observed ( 0.48 square degrees ) . we found a total of 12.5 wd in the simulation , which agrees well with the 13 candidates in the wd region of our reduced proper motion diagram . over half ( 56% ) of the wds in the simulation were members of the halo , with most of the remainder ( 34% ) drawn from the thick disk . one of the candidates , sxdspm j021840.0 - 053623 , deserves individual attention . it has the highest proper motion in our sample , @xmath56 per year ( see figures [ fig : candmotiondiag ] and [ fig : candpanels ] ) , and yet is very faint : @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 . the object is very red : our attempt to measure a magnitude at the object s position in the @xmath60-band image yielded a formal value of @xmath61 , but we choose instead to quote a lower limit of @xmath62 based on secure measurements of faint stars nearby . its colors @xmath63 and @xmath64 place it far from the locus of cool main sequence stars . if we use the more reliable @xmath65 color alone , the star might be an m9 dwarf ( @xcite,@xcite ) with an absolute magnitude @xmath66 . however , in that case , the distance to the object would be @xmath67 pc , and the tangential velocity @xmath68 km / s . the @xmath65 color of an l2 dwarf is not very different from our value , and the absolute magnitude of such a star , @xmath69 , would yield a lower velocity , @xmath70 km / s , consistent with the halo population . the residuals from a simple linear fit to the object s motion show no sign of parallax , which indicates that it must be at least @xmath71 pc away from the sun . the proper motions computed in this paper complement those we described in @xcite , since the sxds lies in the southern galactic hemisphere and the sdf in the northern . together , they comprise a set of 167 stars with reliable motions and multicolor photometry . we have characterized the selection effects of both samples as a function of magnitude , proper motion , and ( for the sxds ) color . our next step will be to compare rigorously the properties of the stars in our samples with the predictions made by current models of galactic populations , paying special attention to the objects likely to be white dwarfs . we thank the staff at the subaru telescope for their assistance with the observations used in this project . mwr gratefully acknowledges grant s-03031 from the jsps invitation fellowship for research in japan . tm is financially supported by the japan society for the promotion of science ( jsps ) through the jsps research fellowship . data analysis was in part carried out on the common use data analysis computer system at the astronomy data center , adc , of the national astronomical observatory of japan . droege , t. f. et al . 2006 , , 118 , 1666 furusawa , h. et al . 2008 , , 176 , 1 hawley , s. l. et al . 2002 , , 123 , 3409 kashikawa , n. et al . 2004 , pasj , 56 , 1011 miyazaki , s. et al . 2002 , , 54 , 833 morokuma , t. et al . 2008 , , 676 , 163 robin , a. c. , reyl , c. , derrire , s. , & picaud , s. 2003 , a&a , 409 , 523 richmond , m. w. et al . 2009 , , 61 , 1 sekiguchi , k. et al . 2005 , in multiwavelength mapping of galaxy formation and evolution ( proceedings of the eso workshop held at venice , italy ) , ed . a. renzini & r. bender ( berlin : springer - verlag ) , 82 treffers , r. r. & richmond , m. w. 1989 , pasp , 101 , 725 west , a. a. , walkowicz , l. m. , & hawley , s. l. 2002 , , 117 , 706

we search for stars with proper motions in a set of deep subaru images , covering about 0.48 square degrees to a depth of @xmath0 , taken over a span of five and a half years . we follow the methods described in @xcite to reduce and analyze this dataset . we present a sample of 69 stars with motions of high significance , and discuss briefly the populations from which they are likely drawn . based on photometry and motions alone , we expect that 14 of the candidates may be white dwarfs . our candidate with the largest proper motion is surprisingly faint and likely to prove interesting : its colors and motions suggest that it might be an m dwarf moving at over 500 km / sec or an l dwarf in the halo .

0810.3674

emission at 511 kev , the characteristic signature of positron annihilation , has been observed in the direction of the galactic centre ( gc ) , since the 1970s . apparently diffuse gamma - ray emission at approximately this energy was first detected in 1970 by the balloon - borne experiments of the rice group ( johnson , harnden , & haymes 1972 ; johnson & haymes 1973 ; haymes et al . 1975 ; preliminary indications were also reported in haymes et al . 1969 ) and was confirmed as positron annihilation emission in 1978 by the balloon - borne experiments of the bell - sandia group ( leventhal , maccallum , & stang 1978 ; leventhal et al . high - energy balloon experiments and space observatories through the early 1990s continued to detect the 511 kev emission ; however the relatively low spatial resolution of these detectors prevented determination of the true location and distribution of the emission ( see purcell et al . 1997 , jean et al . 2003 , or teegarden et al . 2005 for a summary of these early observations ) . specifically , from these data it is unclear whether the emission is truly diffuse , or if it originates either from a single discrete source ( _ e.g . _ sgr a * or 1e1740.7 - 2942,``the great annihilator '' ) or from a small number of discrete but unresolved sources . some early detections suggested time variability in the signal , indicating a small number of discrete sources , but these variations were not confirmed in subsequent observations ( _ e.g . _ purcell et al . 1997 ; teegarden et al . 2005 ) . with the advent of space observatories of increasing sensitivity , spectral coverage , and spatial resolution , the resultant improvement in data quality now provides much stronger constraints on the origin of the emission . in particular , observations of the gc by the spi spectrometre on the satellite integral ( the international gamma - ray astrophysicsl laboratory ) have recently produced the most detailed map of the anomalous 511 kev emission to date ( kndlseder et al . 2005 ; weidenspointner et al . 2006 , 2007 ) . the spi / integral map clearly shows this emission arising from the central @xmath01.5 kpc ( @xmath2@xmath3 ) of the galaxy , with a fainter component of 511 kev flux detected from the remainder of the galactic disk . the smoothness of the emission constrains the number of discrete sources responsible to be in excess of @xmath0 8 ( kndlseder et al . 2005 ) , as do point source limits of @xmath4 ph @xmath5 s@xmath6 from searches with the ibis imager on integral ( de cesare et al . most recently , weidenspointner et al . ( 2008 ) have detected a longitudinal asymmetry in the disk component of the emission , which matches the asymmetry in the distribution of the brightest low - mass x - ray binaries ( lmxbs ) detected by the ibis instrument on integral , suggesting that these @xmath7 objects may account for much of the disk component of the 511 kev emission . diffuse emission from the galactic centre , unaccounted for by known sources , has also been observed at several other wavelengths , notably high - frequency radio ( 2163 ghz ) with wmap ( finkbeiner 2004a ) and soft x - rays ( 110 kev ) with _ e.g. _ heao and chandra ( worrall et al . 1982 , muno et al . the origin and nature of the diffuse emission is puzzling in each case . in the case of the diffuse x - ray component , a population of discrete but unresolved point sources was originally postulated as a possible source of the emission ( see _ e.g. _ skibo et al . 1997 , valinia & marshall 1998 ) . with the advent of high - resolution x - ray imaging using chandra , a large new population of low x - ray luminosity sources has indeed been identified in the central 2@[email protected]@xmath3of the gc ( 300@xmath8120 pc at a gc distance of 8.5 kpc ; wang et al . 2002 , muno et al . 2003 , muno et al . 2006 ) . many of these @xmath04200 discrete x - ray sources are likely to be accreting binaries , including high and low mass x - ray binaries and cataclysmic variables . however , it is worth noting that these detected sources only account for 10% of the previously observed diffuse 2 - 10 kev emission ( ebisawa et al . 2001 , muno et al . 2003 ) , so an even larger population of still fainter sources ( with @xmath9@xmath10erg@xmath10s@xmath6 ) could exist at the gc ( but see muno et al . 2004 who argue that the spectral characteristics of the remaining diffuse x - ray emission are inconsistent with a stellar x - ray source origin ) . in any case , it is not clear how much these new populations might contribute to the diffuse flux at lower ( _ e.g . _ wmap ) or higher ( _ e.g . _ integral ) energies . in this paper , we consider the hypothesis that jet outflows from x - ray binary systems ( xrb ) , which are accretion - powered mass - transferring binaries containing a black hole ( bh ) or neutron star ( ns ) , are the main source of the 511 kev emission in the gc . this idea has been explored previously by various authors , notably ramaty & lingenfelter ( 1979 ) , prantzos ( 2004 ) , kndlseder et al . ( 2005 ) , and guessoum et al . these previous studies generally focused on the large - scale discrete jet ejections produced by the class of luminous black hole xrbs known as `` microquasars '' . however , it is now thought that luminous black hole xrbs much more commonly produce lower - luminosity `` steady '' jets , and that these outflows are `` on '' for a substantially greater fraction of the xrb duty cycle than the large - scale ejection events ( gallo et al . we note that neutron star x - ray binaries are , in principle , also possible sources of jet positrons . the fraction of low magnetic field ns xrbs with outflows could be as high as @xmath0 100% ( fender 2006 ; migliari & fender 2006 ) . however , they show a different scaling than black hole xrbs between x - ray luminosity and radio luminosity ( i.e. @xmath11 in bh systems and @xmath12 in ns systems ; miglari & fender 2006 ) . as a result of this scaling , the jets from quiescent neutron star x - ray binaries are likely to be several orders of magnitude weaker than those from quiescent bh x - ray binaries , if one assumes the same scaling relations continue into quiescence . more likely , though , is that the scaling relation becomes even steeper for neutron stars as they fade more deeply into quiescence than the current radio flux limits allow us to probe ; the emission from the faintest neutron star xrbs is generally dominated by thermal crustal emission from cooling neutron stars , rather than by accretion power ( _ e.g . _ rutledge et al . 2001 ) . also , while some luminous high - mass x - ray binaries ( hmxbs ) have been observed to emit jets ( e.g. cyg x-1 , cyg x-3 ) , these systems are predominantly located in the galactic disk ( grimm et al . thus these canonical bh hmxbs of which there are only a few known in the entire milky way are not a class of objects which can cause an excess of high - energy flux in the bulge relative to the galactic disk . recent integral observations have detected a population of lower - luminosity , x - ray hard , high - mass xrbs including highly - obscured hmxbs and `` supergiant fast x - ray transients '' , a number of which are located in the bulge ( chaty et al . however , there is as yet no evidence for jet outflows in these hmxbs . furthermore , the nature of the compact objects in these systems is currently not known ; but we note that of those canonical hmxbs for which the nature of the compact object has been identified , the majority contain neutron stars rather than black holes . finally , in a detailed study of the spatial distribution of integral - detected xrbs ( including the new highly - obscured systems ) , lutovinov et al . ( 2005 ) find that the angular distribution of hmxbs in the inner galaxy is significantly different from that of lmxbs specifically , lmxbs are clearly the dominant population within the bulge , significantly overabundant as compared with the hmxbs in this region . thus while we can not rule out a high - energy flux contribution in the bulge from these newly discovered low - luminosity hmxbs , we will not consider them further here . therefore in this paper we primarily consider jets from low - mass black hole binaries . it seems plausible that steady , low - luminosity outflows from galactic bh xrbs contribute substantially to the annihilation line emission , and possible also to the diffuse emission observed at other wavelengths . the outline of the paper is as follows . in section 2 , we first review the 511 kev observations of the gc and discuss possible sources for the positrons . in section 3 , we outline a simple model for positron production in ( quiescent ) lmxb jets . in section 4 , we briefly examine the unexplained diffuse gc emission observed at microwave and x - ray wavelengths , and consider whether this emission could also originate in outflows from low - luminosity lmxbs . in section 5 , we discuss the recent association of the disk component of the 511 kev emission with bright lmxbs detected by ibis , pointing out some unresolved problems with this association . we conclude by proposing several observational tests that may help elucidate the nature of the population responsible for the 511 kev emission . since its initial discovery almost 40 years ago , our picture of the annihilation emission from the gc has gradually become clearer . the emission amounts to @xmath13 photons @xmath14 s@xmath6 , coming from a region roughly @xmath15 in radius around the gc . assuming the mean distance to the positron sources is the distance to the gc , 8.5 kpc , this flux corresponds to an integrated luminosity of @xmath16 photons / s emitted within a region 1.5 kpc in radius . after initial suggestions of temporal variability in the flux , extensive observations over the 1990s have ruled this out at any substantial level ( see purcell et al . 1997 for a summary of this evidence ) . the detailed spatial distribution of the emission has become much clearer since observations first by osse on cgro , and then more recently by spi on integral . the most recent analyses of 4 years of spi / integral data ( weidenspointner et al . 2008 ) suggest two main components : a central bulge and an asymmetric disk . the bulge component is reasonably well described by a single gaussian with a fwhm of 6@xmath17 , but even better described by a superposition of two gaussians of fwhm of 3@xmath17 and 12@xmath17 , or alternately a compact , symmetric bulge component from @xmath180.5 kpc , and an extended shell of emission from @xmath191.5 kpc . the disk component is now detected at @xmath20 in 4 years of spi , and appears to be be asymmetric at 3.8@xmath21 significance ( weidenspointner et al . 2008 ) , with 1.8 times more emission at negative longitudes than at positive ones . the total flux from the disk is @xmath22 photons @xmath14 s@xmath6 , _ i.e. _ comparable to the bulge flux . there is also marginal evidence for emission more than 1.5 kpc from gc ( kndlseder et al . 2005 ) , possibly extending out as much as 40@xmath17/5 kpc ( bouchet et al . 2008 ) , though detection here is hampered by the very uneven exposure maps of integral away from the gc . on the other hand there has been no significant detection of the emission more than 4050 degrees away from the gc ( teegarden et al . 2005 ; weidenspointner et al . 2007 ) . detailed analysis of the annihilation line profile , the positronium continuum below 511 kev , and the spectrum of the diffuse gamma - ray background at higher energies place further limits on the origin of the line . integral and comptel measurements of the diffuse background at 110 mev indicates that the positrons must be produced at relatively low energy , since otherwise inflight annihilation of relativistic positrons off background electrons would produce a visible bump in the spectrum . this constraint on the injection energy , first identified by agaronyan & atoyan ( 1981 ) , places an upper limit of @xmath03 mev on the mass of a light dark matter candidate producing positrons through annihilation in a neutral medium ( beacom & yksel 2006 ; note that in this case internal bremsstrahlung in the annihilation process also contributes to the high - energy emission ) . allowing for a partially ionized medium ( and for production mechanisms without associated internal bremsstrahlung emission ) , the more general limit on the injection energy is @xmath048.5 mev ( sizun , cass , & schanne 2006 , 2007 ) . furthermore , low - energy positrons rarely annihilate directly ; instead the majority form positronium , a short - lived bound system composed of an electron - positron pair . positronium then decays either from the singlet ( `` para - positronium '' , spins anti - parallel ) state , via the emission of two photons at 511 kev , or from the triplet ( `` ortho - positronium '' , spins parallel ) state by the emission of three photons , leading to a continuum below 511 kev . detailed analysis of the line profile and line - to - continuum ratio can constrain the properties of the medium in which the positrons propagate and annihilate . the recent analyses of churazov et al . ( 2005 ) and jean et al . ( 2006 ) indicate that the dominant emission source can not be located in the very hot or very cold components of the ism , but that annihilation probably occurs in the warm neutral and ionized medium . given these constraints and the expected lifetimes for positrons in different components of the ism , the implication is that positrons are either produced in , and annihilate in , the warm medium , or are produced in the hot medium but propagate further and annihilate in the warm medium at the edge of hot bubbles . in the former case they would travel only 50100 pc ( @xmath23 at gc ) from their source before annihilating , and in even in the latter they would annihilate within @xmath24 pc of their source ( jean et al . thus , in the absence of large - scale magnetic fields ( which could cause the positrons to propagate even further from their sources ; prantzos 2006 ) the spatial extent of the observed emission implies sources distributed over a similar area on the sky . since its discovery , many possible sources have been invoked to explain the 511 kev emission from the galactic centre . a number that were initially consistent with early detections are now disfavoured , given more accurate maps and flux measurements . some sources , _ e.g. _ cosmic rays interacting with the intergalactic medium ( ramaty et al . 1970 ; lingenfelter & ramaty 1982 ) , or populations of young stellar objects such as pulsars ( sturrock 1971 ) , or supernovae or wolf - rayet stars ( via the radioactive nuclei they produce clayton 1973 ; ramaty & lingenfelter 1979 ; signore & vedrenne 1988 ; woosley & pinto 1988 ; lingenfelter & ramaty 1989 ; milne et al . 2002 ) , would produce a more flattened distribution on the sky , inconsistent with the bulge component . some other possible candidates , _ e.g. _ sgr a * ( lingenfelter & ramaty 1982 ; rees 1982 ; ozernoy 1989 ; ramaty et al . 1992 ) , a single grb or hypernova at galactic centre ( lingenfelter & hueter 1984 ) , or a population of classical novae ( purcell et al . 1997 ) , should appear as a single point source and/or show temporal variability ( although models where stronger emission of positrons from sgr a * occured at some time in the past may be possible see cheng , chernyshov & dogiel 2006 and 2007 ; and totani 2006 ) . while some of these sources may account for part of the annihilation flux ( _ e.g . _ the radioactive decay of @xmath25al from young massive stars should account for 20 - 30% of the 511 kev emission in the central part of the galactic disk ; bouchet et al . 2008 ) , the majority of the 511 kev flux now seems most likely to come from a distributed population of faint sources that traces the old stellar bulge . we refer the reader to _ e.g. _ kndlseder et al . ( 2005 ) for further discussion of the alternatives . of sources associated with old stellar populations , type ia sne are too rare to account for much of the flux . hypernovae / grb progenitors ( cass et al . 2004 ) or grbs ( parizot et al . 2005 ; bertone et al . 2006 ) might produce enough positrons , but it is not clear they could necessarily reproduce the smoothly distributed emission seen by spi . another possibility worth mentioning is pulsars . rotationally powered pulsars are well known to produce high energy particles . in recent years , it has become clear through the observation of a synchrotron nebula around the pulsar 1957 + 20 ( stappers et al . 2003 ) that even millisecond pulsars ( msps ) can have significant pair - dominated winds . given their considerably larger numbers compared with young pulsars , especially in regions of old stellar populations like the galactic bulge , the pair flux from msps should dominate the total pair flux from pulsars , and it has been shown that reasonable parameter values for pulsar numbers and pair flux rates can reproduce the observed annihilation line rate ( wang , pun & cheng 2006 ) . thus msps are a plausible source of the 511 kev line emission . however , pulsars are expected to produce very high energy ( @xmath110 mev ) positrons ; but as noted earlier , the integral and comptel measurements of the diffuse 1 - 10 mev background indicate that the positrons responsible for the observed annihilation line must be produced at relatively low energy , as otherwise a visible bump in the spectrum from inflight annihilation of relativistic positrons would be observed ( agaronyan & atoyan 1981 ) . thus we will not consider msps further in this paper . finally , a large number of more exotic possibilities have been suggested to explain the 511 kev emission . they include annihilation of an mev - scale particle , such as `` light '' dark matter ( boehm et al . 2004 ) ; sterile neutrinos or pseudo - scalar relics with masses @xmath26 mev ( picciotto & pospelov 2005 ) ; decays of axions ( hooper & wang 2004 ) , sub - gev scale neutralinos ( gunion et al . 2006 ; bird et al . 2006 ) , or other supersymmetric particles ( takahashi & yanagida 2006 ) ; q - balls ( kasuya and takahashi 2005 ) , mirror matter ( foot & silagadze 2005 ) , moduli ( kawasaki & yanagida 2005 ; kasuya and kawsaki 2006 ) , superconducting cosmic strings ( ferrer & vachaspati ) , droplets of superconducting quark matter ( oaknin & zhitnitsky 2004 ; mcneil , forbes , & zhitnitsky 2008 ) , tev - scale particles with an excitation at the mev scale ( finkbeiner & weiner 2007 ; pospelov & ritz 2007 ) or small , accreting black holes ( titarchuk & chardonnet 2006 ) . over the past decade , multiwavelength observations of x - ray binaries have clearly shown that these systems produce relativistic jet outflows , analogous to those observed in agn and quasars ( see fender 2006 for a review ) . there are known accreting binary populations in the gc , and there is increasing evidence that all accreting sources containing black holes and neutron stars have a _ compact , steady _ jet outflow during their `` hard '' states , when their x - ray luminosity is relatively low ( indeed , there is evidence that these compact jets are also present during the `` quiescent '' state when the source x - ray luminosity is extremely low ; gallo et al . 2006 , 2007 ) . several ( perhaps all ) bh xrbs also have _ transient _ powerful , large - scale , extended jets , which are associated with the transition between the `` hard '' or `` quiescent '' states and the x - ray luminous `` high / soft '' state . these large - scale ejection events are episodic but their duty cycle is poorly known ; however , it is clear that most bh xrbs spend less time in the transitional regime where the large - scale jets are emitted than in the lower x - ray luminosity hard ( or quiescent ) states . we therefore focus here on the low - luminosity steady jets . extending the results of deep x - ray surveys of the central galactic bulge ( wang et al . 2002 , muno et al . 2003 , muno et al . 2006 ) to the entire bulge , we would expect roughly @xmath27 x - ray point sources similar to those detected by the chandra surveys . while a large fraction of these are likely to be cataclysmic variables ( see _ e.g. _ muno et al . 2003 ) , a few percent of the sources are likely to be quiescent low - mass bh x - ray binaries , sources which trace the older stellar population of the galaxy and thus are observed to be concentrated in the inner galaxy . such quiescent systems might be good candidates for the jet positron source , consistent with known point sources down to @xmath28ergs / s . these jets could be sources of high - energy electrons and protons , and also , as they interact with the ism , of positrons . alternatively , this could be done by low energy cosmic ray injection in jets with associated acceleration to high energies in the jet - ism interaction sites ( _ e.g . _ heinz & sunyaev 2003 ; fender , maccarone & van kesteren 2005 ; heinz & grimm 2005 ) . these two distinct components would in turn produce diffuse emission across the electromagnetic spectrum via positron annihilation , synchrotron emission , and perhaps heating of the ism . this solution is preferable to many of the more exotic scenarios , which require fine tuning to avoid constraints on positron production at energies above @xmath010 mev , and can not simultaneously produce both low - energy positrons and high - energy electrons and protons . ( light dark matter , for instance would produce the former , whereas conventional heavy dark matter would generate the latter via pion production . ) the jets in low / hard state or quiescent x - ray binaries are thought to be mildly relativistic ( see gallo , fender , pooley 2003 ) . while there are some arguments that the data on xrbs do allow for higher jet velocities in the low / hard states ( heinz & merloni 2004 ) , additional indirect evidence supports the former assertion . the giant jet ejections that take place at transitions from hard to soft states are well explained by a jet speed that increases as the state transition proceeds , leading to a shock of the faster jet material against the recently ejected slower material ( vadawale et al . 2003 ; fender , belloni & gallo 2004 ) . furthermore , the jets in low luminosity active galactic nuclei are typically two - sided , while those in high luminosity agn are typically one - sided , consistent with the idea that doppler boosting is a more important effect in high luminosity agn than low luminosity ones . we thus take a jet speed of 0.7c , meaning that the kinetic luminosity of the jet is about @xmath29 . this gives @xmath30 g / sec for a jet power of about @xmath31 @xmath10erg@xmath10s@xmath6 , typical in the quiescent systems whose x - ray luminosities are about @xmath32 @xmath10erg@xmath10s@xmath6 . theoretical studies suggest a range of 1000 - 10000 for the number of quiescent bh xrbs in the entire galaxy ( romani 1992 ; portegies zwart , verbunt & ergma 1997 ) . from this range , we derive an estimate of @xmath33 ergs / sec of total kinetic power input into the galactic interstellar medium ( ism ) from quiescent black hole xrbs . since roughly 1/3 of the stellar mass of the milky way is in the bulge , and low mass xrbs are good tracers of stellar populations ( gilfanov 2004 ) , this results in an estimate of @xmath0 3003000 bh in the bulge itself . we can then estimate that the kinetic power injected by quiescent bh x - ray binaries into the bulge is about @xmath34 ergs / s , and that the total mass injected into the bulge ism from these jets is about @xmath35 g / s , yielding a total proton injection rate of about @xmath36 per second . if we see @xmath37 photons / s/@xmath5 , then this means we see @xmath16 511 kev photons per sec . if we assume that 3/4 of the annihilations go through the 3-photon positronium channel , then we need 2@xmath8@xmath16 positrons / s produced to get the @xmath16/s 511 kev photons needed ( 75% produce no 511 , 25% produce two 511 photons ) . we thus need a pair to proton ratio of about 40 - 400 to account for the observed 511 kev luminosity . the best attempts at estimating the pair fractions for jets come from active galactic nuclei . it has been shown by sikora & madejski ( 2000 ) that excessive pair fractions in quasar jets would lead to a strong bump in the soft x - rays due to the bulk compton upscattering of the thermal photons from the accretion disk of the quasar , in constrast to observations . on the other hand , for lower luminosity agn , which are more likely to be analogous to the quiescent bh x - ray binaries discussed here , the situation is less clear these still could be pair - dominated as they do not have strong thermal accretion disks to contribute photons for upscattering . comparisons in m87 between the bulk kinetic power observed from jet - intracluster medium interactions and the synchrotron luminosity argue that there must be a large number of leptons per unit kinetic power , and hence that the pair fraction must be large ( reynolds et al . 1996 ; dunn , fabian & celotti 2006 ) . reynolds et al . ( 2006 ) also find that the pairs in these jets are most likely to be predominantly cold ( i.e. the energy spectrum for the electrons has no low energy cutoff , so that the number density is dominated by electrons with low enough energies to satisfy the constraint discussed in section 2.1 , that high energy pairs would produce excessive emission in @xmath0 mev range via in - flight annihilation ) . guessoum , jean , & prantzos ( 2006 ) have estimated the production rate of positrons in `` canonical '' jet - producing microquasars , based on the energetics and models of these luminous xrbs which have been presented in the literature ; we summarize their results here . they use an average value of 10@xmath38 pairs / sec from a luminous microquasar producing `` steady '' jets ( e.g. in the low / hard state , rather than the large - scale episodic jets ) at @xmath39 0.01 - 0.1@xmath40 . using an estimate of @xmath0100 for the total number of microquasars in the galaxy , together with the galactic positional distribution of observationally - confirmed microquasars , they derive an estimate of @xmath0 4.1@xmath810@xmath41 positrons / s for the rate of annihilating positrons in the bulge . they note that the positron production rate they derive is smaller than what is inferred from the integral 511 kev observations . comparing their results with ours , we see that their calculated positron injection rate from luminous microquasars within the bulge a fairly small population , of order @xmath040 sources is an order of magnitude smaller than the @xmath42 positrons / s we calculate as being produced by quiescent bh xrbs in the bulge a population we estimate to have @xmath03000 members . as such , in the scenario we describe in this paper , the quiescent bh xrbs would be the dominant source of the bulge 511 kev emission , although the luminous microquasars would also make a significant contribution . from one year of integral / spi observations , kndlseder et al . ( 2005 ) found that the spatial distribution of 511 kev luminosity shows a bulge - to - disk ( b / d ) ratio of 3 - 9 , which is higher than the mass of the galaxy in general . subsequently , using two years of integral / spi data , weidenspointner et al . ( 2007 ) revised this ratio downward to a range of 1 - 4 . since there exist mechanisms for producing 511 kev emission in the galactic plane which involve young stars not present in the bulge , any viable mechanism for producing the bulk of the 511 kev emission in the bulge must be one in which a larger amount of annihilation per unit mass comes from the bulge than from the galactic plane . at first glance , this seems to represent a problem for our model , in which we suggest that 1/3 of the quiescent bh xrbs are located in the bulge ; if the remaining 2/3 are simply assumed to be in the galactic disk , then the 511 kev luminosity b / d ratio would be 0.5 , well below the lower end of the range determined by weidenspointner et al . ( 2007 ) . however , this simple calculation neglects two important factors , highlighted by guessoum et al . first , a significant portion of the galactic lmxb population is located in the galactic halo , distinct from the bulge and disk lmxb populations . grimm et al . ( 2002 ) find that 25% of the total number of lmxbs in the galaxy are located in the halo . they also find that 1/3 of bright lmxbs are located in the galactic bulge , consistent with the expectation from the stellar mass distribution of the galaxy discussed above . thus if we assume that the quiescent black hole xrbs described here have a similar distribution to canonical luminous low mass xrbs , we expect @xmath01/3 in the bulge , @xmath01/4 in the halo , and the remainder to be located in the disk . the halo sources are physically located well outside of the bulge and the plane ; thus they will not significantly contribute to the 511 kev luminosity in the spatially - constrained bulge and inner disk areas ( within @xmath43 1.5 kpc of the galactic centre ) over which the 511 kev emission has been detected ( weidenspointner et al . 2008 ) . removing the halo sources results in a b / d luminosity ratio of 0.8 still below the lower limit of weidenspointner et al . ( note that guessoum et al . also made an estimate for the number of luminous microquasars in the halo , and removed those sources before calculating their bulge - to - disk luminosity ratio . ) the second factor , as discussed by kndlseder et al . ( 2005 ) , is that the scale height of xrbs in the galactic disk is about 700 pc ( jonker & nelemans 2004 ) , considerably larger than that of the gas in the galaxy , and that this can have profound effects on the inferred rate of positron production in different parts of the galaxy . if positrons are injected into gas poor parts of the galaxy , they may travel fairly large distances before annihilating , yielding a situation where the distribution of locations for positron annihilation is not the same as the distribution of locations for positron production . the largest effect would be to transfer positrons from production sites several gas scale heights above the galactic plane into the halo or bulge before they undergo annihilation . following guessoum et al . ( 2006 ) , if we estimate that 50% of positrons produced in the disk escape into the halo and/or propagate along field lines towards the bulge , while all positrons produced in the bulge are retained and annihilate therein ( see _ e.g. _ jean et al . 2006 ) , then we must reduce the disk 511 kev luminosity by 1/2 . combining this factor with the bulge and disk population estimates above , we now find a b / d 511 kev luminosity ratio for the quiescent bh xrb population of @xmath01.6 , well within the range for the b / d ratio found by weidenspointner et al . finally , we note that some positrons which escape from the disk may end up annihilating in the bulge , rather than in the halo , resulting in a still larger b / d ratio . therefore , it seems plausible that the 511 kev emission could come from the jets of quiescent ( x - ray faint ) black hole x - ray binaries . the requirements to make this happen _ ( i ) _ that the jets have @xmath44 positrons per proton ; _ ( ii ) _ that there are on the order of 3000 quiescent bh x - ray binaries in the bulge ; and _ ( iii ) _ that the pairs are mostly cold are all within the range of reasonably standard assumptions and well within the range of observational constraints . we first introduce a few standard assumptions about jet kinetic power from accreting binaries , and its relationships with observables such as radio and x - ray luminosities . the kinetic power input into a relativistic jet is assumed to be a constant fraction of the accretion power : @xmath45 this follows in a straightforward manner from the standard mechanisms for producing jets by extracting either the spin energy of the central black hole ( blandford & znajek 1977 ) , or the rotational energy of the accretion disk ( blandford & payne 1982 ) , provided that the height to radius relation for the accretion disk does not change as a function of accretion rate ( _ e.g . _ livio , ogilvie & pringle 1999 ; meier 2001 ) . based on the results of standard synchrotron theory ( _ e.g . _ blandford & knigl 1979 ; falcke & biermann 1995 ; heinz & sunyaev 2003 ) , it is normally assumed that the observed radio luminosity from a jet is proportional to its kinetic luminosity to the 1.4 power : @xmath46 next , it is assumed that black holes at low accretion rates ( in the hard or quiescent states ) are radiatively inefficient , because they can advect energy across their event horizons , leading to a scaling of the bolometric luminosity on the square of the mass accretion rate ( narayan & yi 1994 ) @xmath47 whereas neutron stars , with their solid surfaces , can not advect matter or energy , leading to a linear proportionality between mass transfer rate and luminosity : @xmath48 the resulting expectations are that black holes should have a radio luminosity which depends on the x - ray luminosity to the 0.7 power , assuming that the radio emission comes from the jet , and the x - ray emission comes from an advection - dominated accretion flow : @xmath49 similarly , neutron stars should have a radio luminosity which scales as the x - ray luminosity to the 1.4 power . both these correlations are indeed observed ; see _ e.g. _ corbel et al . ( 2003 ) and gallo , fender & pooley ( 2003 ) for the case of black holes , and migliari and fender ( 2006 ) for the case of neutron stars . the kinetic energy input into the ism from black hole x - ray transients in quiescence can then be estimated based on their x - ray luminosities . the characteristic x - ray luminosities of quiescent bh x - ray transients are @xmath32 ergs / sec . jets are likely to take away a substantial fraction of kinetic power in the low / hard state ( _ e.g . _ malzac , merloni & fabian 2004 ) , but , given that state transitions between the radiatively efficient high / soft state in which little or no jet power is seen , and the radiatively inefficient low / hard state in which there is a steady jet , do not correspond with abrupt luminosity changes , the jet power can not be much greater than the radiated power at the state transition ( maccarone 2005b ) . therefore , the best estimate of the jet kinetic power is that it scales with @xmath50 , as predicted by the model , with the normalization fixed such that the jet power and the x - ray luminosity are equal at the state transition luminosity which is typically about 2% of the eddington luminosity ( maccarone 2003 ) . such arguments have been used to estimate that the total kinetic power input into the ism from _ bright _ xrbs is about @xmath51 ergs / sec ( fender , maccarone & van kesteren 2005 ; heinz & grimm 2006 ) , while the kinetic power input from _ quiescent _ black hole x - ray binaries may be @xmath33 ergs / sec ( as derived in section 3.2 ; see also maccarone 2005a ) . ( note that we use this power estimate based on the theoretical numbers of the bh xrb population rather than using the luminosity function derived from observed bright bh x - ray transients , as the latter option would involve extrapolating the luminosity function to x - ray luminosities 36 orders of magnitude lower than what has been directly measured for the bright sources . ) since the total kinetic power in jets from quiescent bh x - ray binaries is likely to be of the same order as that from the most luminous systems , and the quiescent systems will be more strongly concentrated in the bulge than will the luminous xrbs ( a population which includes hmxbs as well as lmxbs ) , it is to be expected that a substantial fraction of the bulge positrons come from quiescent black hole x - ray binaries . finally , we note two other diffuse components in the galactic centre that may be related to the annihilation radiation . + _ x - ray : _ + in the bulge core , diffuse chandra emission amounts to @xmath52ergs / s , with a spectrum equivalent to an 8 kev thermal plasma over the 17x17 sq . arcmin chandra field ( muno et al . 2004 ) . the observed spectral shape is indicative of a truly diffuse component rather than originating from a collection of unresolved discrete sources . the flux limit of the muno et al . ( 2003 ) x - ray survey is @xmath010@xmath53 ergs / s . normal stars have luminosities of @xmath54ergs / s or less , and so at least @xmath55 normal stars would be needed to account for the diffuse emission component . however , @xmath55 stars are all the ( solar mass ) stars in the bulge , not just those within the central 40 square parsecs covered by the muno et al . chandra survey it has been argued that this plasma can be thermally maintained by low energy cosmic ray heating ( yusef - zadeh et al . could these cosmic rays possibly come from the x - ray binary jets themselves ? the energetics should be adequate . one question is whether this fraction of the energy actually comes out in cosmic rays , rather than just leading to bulk kinetic motions of the gas at the collisional interface of the jets . + _ microwave : _ + wmap finds a likely synchrotron background with an integrated luminosity of about 2@xmath56 ergs / sec in the 23 - 61 ghz frequency range from a region 2030@xmath17 in radius around the galactic centre region ( finkbeiner 2004a ) . the total power emitted at these frequencies is estimated to be between 15@xmath57 erg s@xmath6 . assuming a distance of 8.5 kpc , this corresponds to a flux level between 3000 and 15000 jy . we note that there are large uncertainties in this estimate , given the need to subtract many other contributions , including thermal dust , spinning dust , thermal bremsstrahlung emission and synchrotron from electrons accelerated in sne shocks , from the microwave maps . moreover , use of the wmap internal linear combination ( ilc ) dust extinction template leaves much uncertainty in possible spatial variations of the composition - dependent frequency sensitivity of the dust emissivity . nonetheless , the signal has generated interest given its possible connection to exotic processes such as the annihilation of massive wimps ( finkbeiner 2004b ; hooper , finkbeiner & dobler 2007 ) , or states of ` excited ' dark matter ( finkbeiner & weiner 2007 ) . the reported haze flux level can not be produced from core emission from individual black hole x - ray binaries as previously discussed , no more than about 3000 quiescent bh xrbs are thought to be in the entire gc region ( _ e.g . _ romani 1992 ; portegies zwart , verbunt & ergma 1997 ) , meaning that the flux of the typical source would have to be @xmath01 to several jy . sources above even 100 mjy would be well - known radio sources at lower frequencies ( since they would likely be flat spectrum sources , or sources whose flux density drops with increasing frequency ) , and an excess of such sources would be clear from existing radio surveys . the typical flux of a quiescent low mass x - ray binary in the radio at the galactic centre distance should be @xmath58 1020 @xmath59jy ( see _ e.g. _ gallo et al . 2006 for the faintest known system of this sort ; hynes et al . 2004 for v404 cyg , the brightest one ) . given @xmath03000 bh with an average quiescent radio flux level of @xmath0100 @xmath59jy , the integrated luminosity of those outflows at wmap wavelengths would be far less than that of the wmap gc haze ( even if the haze fluz has been significantly overestimated ) . this may support the interpretation of the haze emission source as relativistic electrons , produced by annihilating 100 gev dark matter particles ( finkbeiner 2004b ; hooper , finkbeiner & dobler 2007 ) . it thus seems reasonable that most or all of the galactic centre 511 kev emission line could come from low luminosity bh x - ray binaries . we note that this scenario is not required , since the positron - to - proton ratios for x - ray binary jets are largely unconstrained by observations . what about the contribution from high luminosity ( `` canonical '' ) xrbs ? we need to estimate the fraction of the overall 511 kev line flux that can be accounted for by the well - studied canonical jet sources , and correspondingly the percentage of the flux which needs to be accounted for by the low luminosity population . however , if we only consider black hole xrbs , since ( as previously discussed ) the ns jet flux is too small , then at any given time there are only a few active luminous hard state black holes which would contribute to the 511 kev emission . but in this case , if a significant fraction of the overall 511 kev flux originated from a handful of sources , and if the positrons do not propagate and annihilate far from their production sites , we would expect to see these individual sources in the 511 kev flux maps - the 511 kev line emission would not appear to be as smooth as it does . there is no convincing evidence for time variability of the 511 kev line . it is clear that the mechanism proposed here summed emission from hundreds to thousands of sources of roughly equal importance should predict low variability levels in the 511 kev emission . it is less clear whether this would be true from many of the other mechanisms proposed which rely more heavily on a smaller number of sources . however , temporal variability is not useful for distinguishing the total number of sources if the characteristic positron lifetime is @xmath27 years as suggested by ferrer & vachaspati ( 2005 ) . only spatial variability would be useful in this case . weidenspointner et al . ( 2008 ) suggest that an asymmetry in the 511 kev emission is correlated with an asymmetry in the lmxb distribution around the inner galaxy . the asymmetry argument is that the disk 511 kev flux is asymmetric , and so is the hard lmxb population , with the same ratio between halves ( positive and negative galactic longitudes ) of the disk . furthermore , the number of objects ( @xmath070 ) times a plausible mean flux per source ( @xmath60 photons/@xmath5/s each ) gives the right total disk flux ( @xmath61 photons/@xmath5/s ) ; thus the luminous hard lmxbs may be the source of the disk flux , if not the ( @xmath13 photons/@xmath5/s ) bulge flux ( note that the latter corresponds to a larger luminosity , since the bulge is further away ; overall it should be 3 - 9 times the disk luminosity ) . while the positional asymmetries in the known luminous x - ray binary distribution do appear to be in the same sense as the asymmetry in the 511 kev emission , it is not clear that the asymmetry in the bulge component of the x - ray binary population is real . the inner 20@xmath3of the galaxy show only a 1.5@xmath21 asymmetry - 30 ( negative longitude ) versus 18 ( positive longitude ) sources . in other words , given a total of 48 sources , the probability of having @xmath6230 sources at negative latitudes is 5.6% . we note that at least eight of the x - ray binaries in the integral catalog ( 5 at negative longitudes , 3 at positive ) used by weidenspointner et al . ( 2008 ) in their determination of the asymmetry are `` foreground '' sources , with known distances which are not consistent with being in the galactic bulge ( jonker & nelemans 2004 ) . if the 511 kev emission is physically associated with the population of hard xrbs , as is suggested by the asymmetry , then the observed enhancement of 511 kev flux in the central region of the galactic plane is simply a projection effect along our line of sight towards the gc , which coincidentally results in an apparent concentration of 511 kev line emission within @xmath63@xmath64@xmath65@xmath3 . thus in this scenario , the 511 kev enhancement is not physically associated with the galactic bulge itself , and the morphology and intensity of the 511 kev map is dependent upon the longitudinal location of bright , hard xrbs . however , we note that grs 1915 + 105 , which is almost certainly the strongest emitter of positrons from jets outside of the innermost region of the bulge , is on the other side of the galaxy ( at positive galactic longitude ) from the bulk of the integral sources and the observed 511 kev enhancement ( which are at negative galactic longitudes ) . the asymmetry interpretation has at least 4 distinct problems : 1 . the lmxb luminosity function is steep near the lower end ; changing the sensitivity limit of the ibis catalog would change the positive / negative longitude number ratio . integrating flux down the luminosity function , the asymmetry also depends on the catalogue limit , in that the total flux asymmetry is actually the reverse of the number asymmetry , at least at high luminosities . a few sources ( e.g. grs 1915 + 105 ) are responsible for much of the flux ; if this is always true , then the numbers of objects in the catalog may not mean much ; a few bright sources could determine how many positrons are produced at any given time ( i.e. the total flux need not correlate with the number of sources over the ibis limit ) . 4 . since lmxb x - ray emission is time - variable , there is no indication that any current asymmetry in numbers or flux would be constant in time . 1a shows the cumulative ( 20 - 100 kev ) luminosity function for all 72 galactic lmxbs within @xmath6410@xmath3 latitude of the plane in the catalogue of bird et al . ( 2007 ) , divided up into objects at positive and at negative longitudes ( solid and dashed lines respectively ) . note this scale height excludes high - latitude luminous lmxbs such as sco x-1 . 1b shows the integrated flux contributed by binaries over a given flux limit for each of these samples . clearly the longitudinal asymmetry in number counts is sensitive to the lower flux limit of the catalogue ; here , this is set to the integral / ibis 20 - 100 kev detection limit . the current integrated flux is dominated by a small number of bright sources , with the majority of the sources in the integral catalogue being just at the flux detection limit . given the recently identified large population of x - ray faint xrbs discussed above , it is clear that there are many lower luminosity sources below the integral detection threshold . the asymmetry in the source number counts could thus easily be an artifact of the flux bias of the integral sample . therefore the source numbers used to determine the positional asymmetry could be greatly changed by a slight change in the flux cutoff ( to either higher or lower luminosities ) . cutting objects below 10 mcrab , for instance , would produce no asymmetry at all , while cutting at a high flux limit would produce more sources at positive longitudes . so overall , the observed positional asymmetry seen in the integral catalogue , with its instrumentally - determined bias towards luminous sources , may not be significant even if the observed current 20 - 100 kev flux were to correlate exactly with the 511 kev flux . furthermore , the integrated flux from lmxbs in the catalogue is dominated by objects at positive longitudes at all flux limits ( fig.1b ) , although admittedly this is mainly due to the strong contribution from the single brightest source , grs 1915 + 105 . thus the asymmetry in the number of sources does not agree with the asymmetry in the total flux from the integral catalogue sources there is more integrated flux where there are fewer sources ( positive longitudes ) , and less integrated flux where there are more sources ( negative longitudes ) . the fact that the current `` snapshot '' distribution of the integrated flux does not match the 511 kev asymmetry may in itself not be problematic for the weidenspointner et al . ( 2008 ) hypothesis , since the timescale for positrons to annihilate and produce 511 kev emission is @xmath66 years . however , we note that a large fraction of the sources observed by integral and used to `` find '' the positional distribution asymmetry are transients . in addition , those x - ray binaries which we call `` persistent '' merely means that the sources have been consistently luminous over the @xmath035 years of observational x - ray astronomy , which provides very little information about the persistence of their luminosity over the @xmath27 year timescale of photon interaction . thus the current apparent positional asymmetry is merely a snapshot in time , and does not constitute evidence that the total absolute numbers of 511 kev - producing binaries in the direction of the inner galaxy including those currently in quiescence , which are likely to be the majority at negative longitudes is larger than at positive longitudes . over the long lifetime of positron interaction , the integrated flux from all sources which become active during that time may indeed be larger at negative longitudes than positive ones , resulting in the observed asymmetry in the 511 kev emission . to determine this , however , we would need to be certain that there is a true asymmetry in the distribution of all positron - producing xrbs in the inner galaxy - not just during the current epoch , when only a small fraction of such xrbs are observed to be active and luminous . we would have to assume that the asymmetric distribution of currently luminous xrbs - a sample of @xmath070 sources - reflects an underlying asymmetry in the overall distribution of all xrbs - on the order of @xmath03000 bh binaries - which would contribute to the 511 kev emission over @xmath67 years . while this is certainly possible , it can not be considered conclusive , as it is dependent upon both the arbitrary lower flux cutoff of the integral catalogue ( set by the instrument sensitivity rather than by any intrinsic property of the sources themselves ) and the arbitrary time of observation ( _ e.g . _ the modern era of high - energy astronomy ) . a much deeper census of the black hole x - ray binary population , which explores down to the quiescent luminosity of these sources ( @xmath68 erg / s ) , is needed in order to search for a true asymmetry in the physical distribution of jet - emitting xrbs in the inner galaxy . such a census would require both a deep x - ray survey and infrared follow - up observations to identify stellar counterparts to a representative sample of the x - ray sources , in order to conclusively determine which sources contain black holes . it would then be possible to assess whether or not the asymmetry in the 511 kev flux is due to an intrinsic spatial asymmetry in the number of xrbs which episodically exhibit large x - ray luminosities integrated over the timescale for 511 kev production . if stellar sources do account for 511 kev emission , it is unlikely that they would show up as point sources at higher spatial resolution at other wavelengths than the x - ray , as the positrons likely propagate a significant distance ( @xmath050 - 250 pc , which is @xmath00.5@xmath3 1.5@xmath3at the gc ; jean et al . 2006 but see also prantzos et al . 2006 , which suggested a larger distance ) before annihilating . for the brightest of the low - luminosity sources ( @xmath31 erg / s ) , we could perhaps detect a flat near - ir spectrum which would not be consistent with the flux of a mass donor star alone , but which instead would denote the presence of another component - _ e.g. _ a jet outflow . it is not clear if there is enough sensitivity in the mid - ir for ground - based observations _ e.g. _ at 4 and 8 microns to detect the flux from these sources . similarly , for sources with this x - ray luminosity , high frequency ( 8.6 ghz ) radio emission might be detectable ( _ e.g . _ with the vla ) to search for the flat spectrum signature associated with the steady jets from hard state x - ray binaries . the authors wish to thank tony bird , sera markoff , and philipp podsiadlowski for helpful discussions . we also thank mark rayner for his preliminary work on extracting osse observations of x - ray binaries from the heasarc archives . we thank the referee for a close reading of the manuscript and useful suggestions . jet gratefully acknowledges support from pparc , the aspen center for physics , the us doe ( grant ast-0307859 ) , the us nsf ( contract de - fg02 - 04er41316 ) , and nserc canada . beacom , j. f. , yksel , h. 2006 , physical review letters , 97 , 071102 bertone , g. , kusenko , a. , palomares - ruiz , s. , pascoli , s. , & semikoz , d. 2006 , physics letters b , 636 , 20 bird , c. , kowalewski , r. , & pospelov , m. 2006 , modern physics letters a , 21 , 457 bouchet , l. , jourdain , e. , roques , j. p. , strong , a. , diehl , r. , lebrun , f. , & terrier , r. 2008 , apj , 679 , 1315 cass , m. , cordier , b. , paul , j. , & schanne , s. 2004 , apj , 602 , l17 chaty , s. , rahoui , f. , foellmi , c. , tomsick , j. a. , rodriguez , j. , & walter , r. 2008 , a&ap , 484 , 783 de cesare , g. , bazzano , a. , capitanio , f. , del santo , m. , lonjou , v. , natalucci , l. , ubertini , p. , & von ballmoos , p. 2006 , advances in space research , 38 , 1457 dobler , g. , & finkbeiner , d. p. 2007 , arxiv e - prints , 712 , arxiv:0712.2238 finkbeiner , d. p. 2004a , apj , 614 , 186 finkbeiner , d. p. 2004b , arxiv astrophysics e - prints , arxiv : astro - ph/0409027 finkbeiner , d. p. , & weiner , n. 2007 , phys . rev . d , 76 , 083519 foot , r. , & silagadze , z. k. 2005 , international journal of modern physics d , 14 , 143 haymes , r. c. , ellis , d. v. , fishman , g. j. , glenn , s. w. , & kurfess , j. d. 1969 , apj , 157 , 1455 haymes , r. c. , walraven , g. d. , meegan , c. a. , hall , r. d. , djuth , f. t. , & shelton , d. h. 1975 , apj , 201 , 593 heinz , s. , & grimm , h. j. 2005 , apj , 633 , 384 jean , p. , et al . 2003 , a&ap , 407 , l55 jean , p. , kndlseder , j. , gillard , w. , guessoum , n. , ferrire , k. , marcowith , a. , lonjou , v. , & roques , j. p. 2006 , a&ap , 445 , 579 johnson , w. n. , iii , & haymes , r. c. 1973 , apj , 184 , 103 johnson , w. n. , iii , harnden , f. r. , jr . , & haymes , r. c. 1972 , apj , 172 , l1 jonker , p. g. , & nelemans , g. 2004 , mnras , 354 , 355 kndlseder , j. , et al . 2005 , a&ap , 441 , 513 leventhal , m. , maccallum , c. j. , & stang , p. d. 1978 , apj , 225 , l11 leventhal , m. , maccallum , c. j. , huters , a. f. , & stang , p. d. 1980 , apj , 240 , 338 lingenfelter , r. e. , & hueter , g. j. 1984 , american institute of physics conference series , 115 , 558

diffuse 511 kev line emission , from the annihilation of cold positrons , has been observed in the direction of the galactic centre for more than 30 years . the latest high - resolution maps of this emission produced by the spi instrument on integral suggest at least one component of the emission is spatially coincident with the distribution of @xmath070 luminous , low - mass x - ray binaries detected in the soft gamma - ray band . the x - ray band , however , is generally a more sensitive probe of x - ray binary populations . recent x - ray surveys of the galactic centre have discovered a much larger population ( @xmath14000 ) of faint , hard x - ray point sources . we investigate the possibility that the positrons observed in the direction of the galactic centre originate in pair - dominated jets generated by this population of _ fainter _ accretion - powered x - ray binaries . we also consider briefly whether such sources could account for unexplained diffuse emission associated with the galactic centre in the microwave ( the wmap ` haze ' ) and at other wavelengths . finally , we point out several unresolved problems in associating galactic centre 511 kev emission with the brightest x - ray binaries . _ dark matter ; compact objects ; x - ray binaries ; galactic centre ; accretion , accretion physics ; jets _

1512.06863

consumer reviews are invaluable as a source of data to help people form opinions on a wide range of products . beyond telling us whether a product is ` good ' or ` bad ' , reviews tell us about a wide range of _ personal experiences _ ; these include objective descriptions of the products properties , subjective qualitative assessments , as well as unique use- ( or failure- ) cases . the value and diversity of these opinions raises two questions of interest to us : ( 1 ) how can we help users navigate massive volumes of consumer opinions in order to find those that are _ relevant _ to their decision ? and ( 2 ) how can we address specific _ queries _ that a user wishes to answer in order to evaluate a product ? to help users answer specific queries , review websites like _ amazon _ offer community - q / a systems that allow users to pose product - specific questions to other consumers . our goal here is to respond to such queries automatically and on - demand . to achieve this we make the basic insight that our two goals above naturally complement each other : given a large volume of community - q / a data ( i.e. , questions and answers ) , and a large volume of reviews , we can automatically _ learn _ what makes a review relevant to a query . we see several reasons why reviews might be a useful source of information to address product - related queries , especially compared to existing work that aims to solve q / a - like tasks by building knowledge bases of facts about the entities in question : * general question - answering is a challenging open problem . it is certainly hard to imagine that a query such as `` will this baby seat fit in the overhead compartment of a 747 ? '' could be answered by building a knowledge - base using current techniques . however it is more plausible that some review of that product will contain information that is relevant to this query . by casting the problem as one of surfacing relevant opinions ( rather than necessarily generating a conclusive answer ) , we can circumvent this difficulty , allowing us to handle complex and arbitrary queries . * fundamentally , many of the questions users ask on review websites will be those that _ ca nt _ be answered using knowledge bases derived from product specifications , but rather their questions will be concerned with subjective personal experiences . reviews are a natural and rich source of data to address such queries . * finally , the massive volume and range of opinions makes review systems difficult to navigate , especially if a user is interested in some niche aspect of a product . thus a system that identifies opinions relevant to a specific query is of fundamental value in helping users to navigate such large corpora of reviews . to make our objectives more concrete , we aim to formalize the problem in terms of the following goal : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ goal : _ given a query about a particular product , we want to determine how relevant each review of that product is to the query , where ` relevance ' is measured in terms of how helpful the review will be in terms of identifying the correct response . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the type of system we produce to address this goal is demonstrated in figure [ fig : examp ] . here we surface opinions that are identified as being ` relevant ' to the query , which can collectively vote ( along with all other opinions , in proportion to their relevance ) to determine the response to the query . * product : * braven brv-1 wireless bluetooth speaker , title="fig : " ] + * query : * `` i want to use this with my ipad air while taking a jacuzzi bath . will the volume be loud enough over the bath jets ? '' + + m0.78>m0.07 & vote : + `` the sound quality is great , especially for the size , and if you place the speaker on a hard surface it acts as a sound board , and the bass really kicks up . '' & yes + + `` if you are looking for a water resistant blue tooth speaker you will be very pleased with this product . '' & yes + + `` however if you are looking for something to throw a small party this just does nt have the sound output . '' & no + + etc . . + + * response : * yes this simple example demonstrates exactly the features that make our problem interesting and difficult : first , the query ( ` is this loud enough ? ' ) is inherently subjective , and depends on personal experience ; it is hard to imagine that any fact - based knowledge repository could provide a satisfactory answer . secondly , it is certainly a ` long - tail ' query it would be hard to find relevant opinions among the ( 300 + ) reviews for this product , so a system to automatically retrieve them is valuable . third , it is linguistically complex few of the important words in the query appear among the most relevant reviews ( e.g. ` jacuzzi bath'/`loud enough')this means that existing solutions based on word - level similarity are unlikely to be effective . this reveals the need to learn a complex definition of ` relevance ' that is capable of accounting for subtle linguistic differences such as synonyms . finally , in the case of figure [ fig : examp ] , our model is able to respond to the query ( in this instance correctly ) with a binary answer . more importantly though , the opinions surfaced allow the user to determine the answer themselves in this way we can extend our model to handle general open - ended queries , where the goal is not to answer the question _ per se _ , but rather to surface relevant opinions that will help the questioner form their own conclusion . it seems then that to address our goal we ll need a system with two components : ( 1 ) a _ relevance _ function , to determine which reviews contain information relevant to a query , and ( 2 ) a prediction function , allowing relevant reviews to ` vote ' on the correct answer . however as we stated , our main goal is _ not _ to answer questions directly but rather to surface relevant opinions that will help the user answer the question themselves ; thus it may seem as though this ` voting ' function is not required . indeed , at _ test _ time , only the relevance function is required this is exactly the feature that shall allow our model to handle arbitrary , open - ended , and subjective queries . however the voting function is critical at _ training _ time , so that with a large corpus of already - answered questions , we can simultaneously learn relevance and voting functions such that ` relevant ' reviews are those that vote for the correct answer . the properties that we want above are captured by a classical machine learning framework known as _ mixtures of experts _ @xcite . mixtures of experts are traditionally used when one wishes to combine a series of ` weak learners'there the goal is to simultaneously estimate ( a ) how ` expert ' each predictor is with respect to a particular input and ( b ) the parameters of the predictors themselves . this is an elegant framework as it allows learners to ` focus ' on inputs that they are good at classifying it does nt matter if they sometimes make incorrect predictions , so long as they correctly classify those instances where they are predicted to be experts . in our setting , individual reviews or opinions are treated as experts that get to vote on the answer to each query ; naturally some opinions will be unrelated to some queries , so we must also learn how relevant ( i.e. , expert ) each opinion is with respect to each query . our prediction ( i.e. , voting ) function and relevance function are then learned simultaneously such that ` relevant ' opinions are precisely those that are likely to vote correctly . at test time , the relevance function can be used directly to surface relevant opinions . we evaluate our model using a novel corpus of questions and answers from _ we consider both binary questions ( such as the example in figure [ fig : examp ] ) , and open - ended questions , where reviews must vote amongst alternative answers . quantitatively , we compare our technique to state - of - the - art methods for relevance ranking , and find that our learned definition of relevance is more capable of resolving queries compared to hand - crafted relevance measures . qualitatively , we evaluate our system by measuring whether human evaluators agree with the notion of ` relevance ' that we learn . this is especially important for open - ended queries , where it is infeasible to answer questions directly , but rather we want to surface opinions that are helpful to the user . we summarize our contributions as follows : first , we develop a new method , _ moqa _ , that is able to uncover opinions that are relevant to product - related queries , and to learn this notion of relevance from training data of previously answered questions . second , we collect a large corpus of 1.4 million answered questions and 13 million reviews on which to train the model . ours is among the first works to combine community q / a and review data in this way , and certainly the first to do it at the scale considered here . third , we evaluate our system against state - of - the - art approaches for relevance ranking , where we demonstrate ( a ) the need to learn the notion of ` relevance ' from training data ; ( b ) the need to handle heterogeneity between questions , reviews , and answers ; and ( c ) the value of opinion data to answer product - related queries , as opposed to other data like product specifications . code and data is available on the first author s webpage . the most closely related branches of work to ours are ( 1 ) those that aim to mine and summarize opinions and facets from documents ( especially from review corpora ) , and ( 2 ) those that study q / a systems in general . to our knowledge our work is among the first at the interface between these two tasks , i.e. , to use consumer reviews as a means of answering general queries about products , though we build upon ideas from several related areas . * document summarization . * perhaps most related to our goal of selecting relevant opinions among large corpora of reviews is the problem of _ multi - document summarization _ @xcite . like ours , this task consists of finding relevant or ` salient ' parts of documents @xcite and intelligently combining them . most related are approaches that apply document summarization techniques to ` evaluative text ' ( i.e. , reviews ) , in order to build an overview of opinions or product features @xcite . in contrast to our contribution , most of the above work is not ` query - focused , ' e.g. the goal is to summarize product features or positive vs. negative opinions , rather than to address specific queries , though we note a few exceptions below . * relevance ranking . * a key component of the above line of work is to learn whether a document ( or a phrase within a document ) is relevant to a given query . ` relevance ' can mean many things , from the ` quality ' of the text @xcite , to its lexical salience @xcite , or its diversity compared to already - selected documents @xcite . in query - focused settings , one needs a query - specific notion of relevance , i.e. , to determine whether a document is relevant in the context of a given query . for this task , simple ( yet effective ) word - level similarity measures have been developed , such as okapi bm25 , a state - of - the - art tf - idf - based relevance ranking measure @xcite . a natural limitation one must overcome though is that queries and documents may be linguistically heterogeneous , so that word - level measures may fail @xcite . this can be addressed by making use of grammatical rules and phrase - level approaches ( e.g. rouge measures @xcite ) , or through probabilistic language models ranging from classical methods @xcite to recent approaches based on deep networks @xcite . we discuss ranking measures more in section [ sec : measures ] . * opinion mining . * studying consumer opinions , especially through rating and review datasets is a broad and varied topic . review text has been used to augment ` traditional ' recommender systems by finding the aspects or facets that are relevant to people s opinions @xcite and , more related to our goal , to find ` helpful ' reviews @xcite or experts on particular topics @xcite . there has also been work on generating summaries of product features @xcite , including work using multi - document summarization as mentioned above @xcite . this work is related in terms of the data used , and the need to learn some notion of ` relevance , ' though the goal is not typically to address general queries as we do here . we are aware of relatively little work that attempts to combine question - answering with opinion mining , though a few exceptions include @xcite , which answers certain types of queries on _ amazon _ data ( e.g. `` find 100 books with over 200 5-star ratings '' ) ; or @xcite which learns to distinguish ` facts ' from subjective opinions ; or @xcite , which tries to solve cold - start problems by finding opinion sentences of old products that will be relevant to new ones . though in none of these cases is the goal to address general queries . * q / a systems . * many of the above ideas from multi - document summarization , relevance ranking , and topical expert - finding have been adapted to build state - of - the - art automated q / a systems . first is ` query - focused ' summarization @xcite , which is similar to our task in that phrases must be selected among documents that match some query , though typically the relevance function is not learned from training data as it is here . next ( as mentioned above ) is the notion that questions , answers , and documents are heterogeneous , meaning that simple bag - of - words type approaches may be insufficient to compare them @xcite , so that instead one must decompose questions @xcite or model their syntax @xcite . also relevant is the problem of identifying experts @xcite or high - quality answers @xcite , or otherwise identifying instances where similar questions have already been answered elsewhere @xcite , though these differ from our paradigm in that the goal is to select among answers ( or answerers ) , rather than to address the questions themselves . naturally also relevant is the large volume of q / a work from the information retrieval community ( e.g. trec q / a ) ; however note first that due to the data involved ( in particular , subjective opinions ) our approach is quite different from systems that build knowledge bases ( e.g. systems like watson @xcite ) , or generally systems whose task is to retrieve a list of objective facts that conclusively answer a query . rather , our goal is to use q / a data as a means of learning a ` useful ' relevance function , and as such our experiments mainly focus on state - of - the - art relevance ranking techniques . though related to the above areas , our work is novel in a variety of ways . our work is among the first at the interface of q / a and opinion mining , and is novel in terms of the combination of data used , and in terms of scale . in contrast to the above work on summarization and relevance ranking , given a large volume of answered queries and a corpus of weakly relevant documents ( i.e. , reviews of the product being queried ) , our goal is to be as agnostic as possible to the definition of `` what makes an opinion relevant to a query ? , '' and to learn this notion automatically from data . this also differentiates our work from traditional q / a systems as our goal is not to answer queries directly ( i.e. , to output ` facts ' or factoids ) , but rather to learn a relevance function that will help users effectively navigate multiple subjective viewpoints and personal experiences . critically , the availability of a large training corpus allows us to learn complex mappings between questions , reviews , and answers , while accounting for the heterogeneity between them . [ tab : notation ] [ cols="<,<",options="header " , ] we also want to evaluate whether review text is a better source of data than other sources , such as product descriptions or specifications . to test this we collected description / specification text for each of the products in our catalogue . from here , we simply interchange reviews with descriptions ( recall that both models operate at the level of sentences ) . we find that while _ moqa _ with descriptions ( i.e. , _ mdqa _ ) performs well ( on par with the strongest baselines ) , it is still substantially outperformed when we use review text . here _ moqa _ yields a 37.5% reduction in error over _ mdqa _ in table [ tab : openended ] ; similarly in figure [ fig : prec ] , for binary queries _ mdqa _ is on par with the strongest baseline but substantially outperformed by _ moqa _ ( again other datasets are similar and not shown for brevity ) . partly , reviews perform better because we want to answer subjective queries that depend on personal experiences , for which reviews are simply a more appropriate source of data . but other than that , reviews are simply more abundant we have on the order of 100 times as many reviews as descriptions ( products with active q / a pages tend to be reasonably popular ones ) ; thus it is partly the sheer volume and diversity of reviews available that makes them effective as a means of answering questions . we discuss these findings in more detail in section [ sec : discussion ] . finally , we evaluate _ qualitatively through a user study . although we have shown _ moqa _ to be effective at correctly resolving binary queries , and at maximizing the auc to select a correct answer among alternatives , what remains to be seen is whether the relevance functions that we learned to do so are aligned with what humans consider to be ` relevant . ' evaluating this aspect is especially important because in a live system our approach would presumably not be used to answer queries directly ( which we have shown to be very difficult , and in general still an open problem ) , but rather to surface relevant reviews that will help the user to evaluate the product themselves . here we use the relevance functions @xmath0 that we learned in the previous section ( i.e. , from table [ tab : openended ] ) to compare which definition of ` relevance ' is best aligned with real users evaluations note that the voting function @xmath1 is not required at this stage . we performed our evaluation using _ amazon s mechanical turk _ , using ` master workers ' to evaluate 100 queries from each of our five largest datasets , as well as one smaller dataset ( _ baby _ ) to assess whether our method still performs well when less data is available for training . workers were presented with a product s title , image , and a randomly selected query ( binary or otherwise ) . we then presented them the top - ranked result from our method , as well as the top - ranked result using okapi - bm25+/rouge measures ( with tuned parameters , i.e. , ro - l from table [ tab : openended ] ) ; this represents a state - of - the - art ` off - the - shelf ' relevance ranking benchmark , with parameters tuned following best practices ; it is also the most competitive baseline from table [ tab : openended ] . results were shown to evaluators in a random order without labels , from which they had to select whichever they considered to be the most relevant . we also asked workers whether they considered a question to be ` subjective ' or not , in order to evaluate whether the subjectivity of the question impacts performance . a screenshot of our interface is shown in figure [ fig : interface ] . results of this evaluation are shown in figure [ fig : user_study ] . on average , _ moqa _ was preferred in 73.1% of instances across the six datasets we considered . this is a significant improvement ; improvements were similar across datasets ( between 66.2% on sports and outdoors and 77.6% on baby ) , and for both subjective and objective queries ( 62.9% vs. 74.1% ) . ultimately _ moqa _ consistently outperforms our strongest baseline in terms of subjective performance , though relative performance seems to be about the same for objective and subjective queries , and across datasets . ) . [ fig : user_study ] ] finally , a few examples of the output produced by _ moqa _ are shown in figure [ fig : examps ] . note that none of these examples were available at training time , and only the question ( along with the product being queried ) are provided as input . these examples demonstrate a few features of _ moqa _ and the data in question : first is the wide variety of products , questions , and opinions that are reflected in the data ; this linguistic variability demonstrates the need for a model that _ learns _ the notion of relevance from data . second , the questions themselves ( like the example from figure [ fig : examp ] ) are quite different from those that could be answered through knowledge bases ; even those that seem objective ( e.g. `` how long does this stay hot ? '' ) are met with a variety of responses representing different ( and sometimes contradictory ) experiences ; thus reviews are the perfect source of data to capture this variety of views . third is the heterogeneity between queries and opinions ; words like `` girl '' and `` tall '' are identified as being relevant to `` daughter '' and `` medium , '' demonstrating the need for a flexible model that is capable of learning complicated semantics in general , and synonyms in particular . also note that while our bilinear model has many thousands of parameters , at test time relevance can be computed extremely efficiently , since in ( eq . [ eq : approxtransform ] ) we can project all reviews via @xmath2 in advance . thus computing relevance takes only @xmath3 ( i.e. , the number of projected dimensions plus the number of words in the query and review ) ; in practice this allows us to answer queries in a few milliseconds , even for products with thousands of reviews . p0.82m0.13 + & + & + + + & + & + surprisingly , performance for open - ended queries ( table [ tab : openended ] ) appears to be better than performance for binary queries ( table [ tab : yn ] ) , both compared to random classification and to our strongest baseline , against our intuition that the latter task might be more difficult . there are a few reasons for this : one is simply that the task of differentiating the true answer from a ( randomly selected ) non - answer is ` easier ' than resolving a binary query ; this explains why outperforming a random baseline is easier , but does not explain the higher relative improvement against baselines . for the latter , note that the main difference between our method and the strongest baseline is the use of a bilinear model ; while a highly flexible model , it has far more parameters than baselines , meaning that a large dataset is required for training . thus what we are seeing may simply be the benefit of having substantially more data available for training when considering open - ended questions . also surprising is that in our user study we obtained roughly equal performance on subjective vs. objective queries . partly this may be because subjective queries are simply ` more difficult ' to address , so that there is less separation between methods , though this would require a larger labeled dataset of subjective vs. objective queries to evaluate quantitatively . in fact , contrary to expectation only around 20% of queries were labeled as being ` subjective ' by workers . however the full story seems more complicated queries such as `` how long does this stay hot ? '' ( figure [ fig : examps ] ) are certainly labeled as being ` objective ' by human evaluators , though the variety of responses shows a more nuanced situation . really , a large fraction of seemingly objective queries are met with contradictory answers representing different user experiences , which is exactly the class of questions that our method is designed to address . we see several potential ways to extend _ moqa_. first , while we have made extensive use of reviews , there is a wealth of additional information available on review websites that could potentially be used to address queries . one is rating information , which could improve performance on certain evaluative queries ( though to an extent we already capture this information as our model is expressive enough to learn the polarity of sentiment words ) . another is user information the identity of the questioner and the reviewer could be used to learn better relevance models , both in terms of whether their opinions are aligned , or even to identify topical experts , as has been done with previous q / a systems @xcite . in categories like electronics , a large fraction of queries are related to compatibility ( e.g. `` will this product work with x ? '' ) . addressing compatibility - related queries with user reviews is another promising avenue of future work again , the massive number of potential product combinations means that large volumes of user reviews are potentially an ideal source of data to address such questions . although our system can already address such queries to some extent , ideally a model of compatibility - related queries would make use of additional information , for instance reviews of _ both _ products being queried , or the fact that compatibility relationships tend to be symmetric , or even co - purchasing statistics as in @xcite . finally , since we are dealing with queries that are often subjective , we would like to handle the possibility that they may have multiple and potentially inconsistent answers . currently we have selected the top - voted answer to each question as an ` authoritative ' response to be used at training time . but handling multiple , inconsistent answers could be valuable in several ways , for instance to automatically identify whether a question is subjective or contentious , or otherwise to generate relevance rankings that support a spectrum of subjective viewpoints . we presented _ moqa _ , a system that automatically responds to product - related queries by surfacing relevant consumer opinions . we achieved this by observing that a large corpus of previously - answered questions can be used to _ learn _ the notion of relevance , in the sense that ` relevant ' opinions are those for which an accurate predictor can be trained to select the correct answer as a function of the question and the opinion . we cast this as a mixture - of - experts learning problem , where each opinion corresponds to an ` expert ' that gets to vote on the correct response , in proportion to its relevance . these relevance and voting functions are learned automatically and evaluated on a large training corpus of questions , answers , and reviews from _ the main findings of our evaluation were as follows : first , reviews proved particularly effective as a source of data for answering product - related queries , outperforming other sources of text like product specifications ; this demonstrates the value of _ personal experiences _ in addressing users queries . second , we demonstrated the need to handle heterogeneity between various text sources ( i.e. , questions , reviews , and answers ) ; our large corpus of training data allowed us to train a flexible bilinear model that it capable of automatically accounting for linguistic differences between text sources , outperforming hand - crafted word- and phrase - level relevance measures . finally , we showed that _ moqa _ is quantitatively able to address both binary and open - ended questions , and qualitatively that human evaluators prefer our learned notion of ` relevance ' over hand - crafted relevance measures . d. ferrucci , e. brown , j. chu - carroll , j. fan , d. gondek , a. a. kalyanpur , a. lally , j. w. murdock , e. nyberg , j. prager , n. schlaefer , and c. welty . building watson : an overview of the deepqa project . in _ ai magazine _ , 2010 . r. gangadharaiah and b. narayanaswamy . natural language query refinement for problem resolution from crowd - sourced semi - structured data . in _ international joint conference on natural language processing _ , 2013 .

online reviews are often our first port of call when considering products and purchases online . when evaluating a potential purchase , we may have a specific query in mind , e.g. ` will this baby seat fit in the overhead compartment of a 747 ? ' or ` will i like this album if i liked taylor swift s _ 1989 _ ? ' . to answer such questions we must either wade through huge volumes of consumer reviews hoping to find one that is relevant , or otherwise pose our question directly to the community via a q / a system . in this paper we hope to fuse these two paradigms : given a large volume of previously answered queries about products , we hope to automatically learn whether a review of a product is relevant to a given query . we formulate this as a machine learning problem using a mixture - of - experts - type framework here each review is an ` expert ' that gets to vote on the response to a particular query ; simultaneously we learn a relevance function such that ` relevant ' reviews are those that vote correctly . at test time this learned relevance function allows us to surface reviews that are relevant to new queries on - demand . we evaluate our system , _ moqa _ , on a novel corpus of 1.4 million questions ( and answers ) and 13 million reviews . we show quantitatively that it is effective at addressing both binary and open - ended queries , and qualitatively that it surfaces reviews that human evaluators consider to be relevant .

astro-ph0407097

our compilation of measured redshifts for clusters from the catalogue of abell , corwin , & olowin ( 1989 , aco ) has been maintained since 1989 ( andernach 1991 ; andernach , tago , & stengler - larrea 1995 ( ats95 ) ; andernach & tago 1998 ( at98 ) ) and is the only such compilation including both a- and s - clusters . different from previous compilations ( e.g. struble & rood 1999 , sr99 , who include a - clusters only ) , we systematically scan the literature for galaxy redshifts . surveys like the lcrs ( shectman et al . 1996 ) , 2df , 6df ( jones et al . 2004 ) , and sdss ( abazajian et al . 2004 ) prove to be rich in aco cluster redshifts . our selection criteria for galaxy redshifts , and the cluster parameters we include in our compilation can be found in ats95 and at98 . the number of references contributing cluster redshifts has increased so much that one of us ( ha ) now compiles all individual galaxy positions and redshifts , so as to ease the merging of different data sources . for clusters with large @xmath4 and _ several _ papers to merge , this work is in progress . our current compilation is based on 685 references , growing by @xmath540 per year . sixty percent of the 3715 mean redshifts , and 86% of the 1875 velocity dispersions are based on our own calculations , using individual galaxy data . over 330 redshifts are based on the merging of galaxy data from four or more references . we do not include any photometric redshifts nor any galaxy velocities with errors @xmath6600kms@xmath2 . in order to merge galaxy data from different sources for the same cluster , we need individual galaxy positions , velocities , and errors . lack of these data prevents the merging of many data sources or calculation of @xmath1 ( e.g. , we list over a dozen clusters with @xmath7 but no @xmath1 reported ) . often publications do not state whether redshifts are geo- , helio- or galactocentric . the fact that the data releases of large projects like 2df , 6df , sdss , etc . , tend to be _ cumulative _ ( i.e. each release contains previous ones , often with reprocessed data ) rather than _ incremental _ , makes the updating of our compilation very tedious . to calculate @xmath8 and @xmath1 for a cluster , we first search for any relative maxima in the redshift distribution of galaxies within the cluster area . around each relative maximum we include into a single cluster component all galaxies within @xmath9kms@xmath2 from that maximum . we use this value also as a minimum velocity gap for subclusters closely spaced along the line of sight . only if subclusters were published with a smaller separation in velocity ( mostly due to components separated in the plane of the sky ) , we adopt them from the literature _ as is_. apart from three known pairs of duplicate clusters in aco , and six further pairs reported by at98 , we propose a3742=s924 as an additional identity . redshifts ( based on at least one galaxy measured ) are now available for 59% of all 4076 a - clusters and for 54% of all 1174 supplementary southern s - clusters , which is an almost 4-fold increase over abell et al . only 2.7% of the redshifts are beyond a factor two from their photometric estimates ( see sect.3 ) . a significant improvement over previous compilations is that 67% ( compared to 43% in sr99 ) of the redshifts are based on @xmath0 measured galaxies , and can thus be considered `` reliable '' . this , as well as the almost 3-fold increase in the number of known velocity dispersions over sr99 , is due to our efforts to merge all available data sources , especially in the regime of low @xmath4 . there are 1245 ( sub)clusters with @xmath1010 , of which 276 have @xmath1050 ( the typical minimum for dynamical studies ) , and 95 ( sub)clusters have @xmath11 . the total number of galaxies involved for all our listed ( sub)clusters is @xmath556,800 ( 9500 of which in s - clusters ) , including some overhead for overlapping clusters for which it is not possible to assign galaxies uniquely to one cluster . we quote @xmath1 for 1353 different abell clusters ( 1080 a- and 273 s - clusters , for a total of 1875 subclusters ) . the median @xmath1 for all 1875 ( sub)clusters is 636kms@xmath2 , and their distribution shows an almost gaussian main peak at @xmath5630kms@xmath2 with a dispersion of @xmath5275kms@xmath2 , followed by a weak tail out to 2000kms@xmath2 ( probably containing some line - of - sight superpositions or mergers ) . for the rich aco clusters ( a - names ) we use the redshift estimate by peacock & west ( 1992 , kindly provided by m.west ) , while for the s - clusters we use a function originally proposed by abell et al.(1989 ) for southern a - clusters , but scaled down by 30% on the basis of 196 s - cluster redshifts ( andernach 1991 ) . now , with three times the number of s - cluster redshifts in hand , we confirm s - clusters to have on average 30% lower @xmath12 than the aco estimate . it is not clear whether this is due to an excess foreground contamination of redshifts , or due to a systematic overestimate of @xmath13 of the clusters caused by background contamination . we do * not * confirm the claim by at98 that s - clusters suffer more from line - of - sight superposition than a - clusters : currently 16% of both a- and s - clusters appear with more than one redshift entry , and it rather seems that deeper and deeper surveys ( like 2df or sdss ) tend to find more clusters along the line of sight . redshifts are now available for all except 60 ( 1.5% ) rich ( a- ) clusters with estimated redshift [email protected] , while 17 s - clusters ( 7% ) with @xmath150.05 ( and 240 , or 32% , with @xmath150.1 ) still lack a measured redshift . there is still plenty of high - galactic - latitude sky with galaxies brighter than @xmath16 unexplored in redshift . however , these gaps are getting smaller : e.g. , we found that only the increment of 6df - fdr ( jones et al . 2004 ) over 6df - edr yields new redshifts for @xmath5250 clusters with no previous @xmath12 , about half of these with @xmath17 . based on now 15 years of compilation experience we anticipate that only in @xmath510 years from now the redshift completeness of the aco catalogue may get close to 100% . the distribution of @xmath1 for the 1875 ( sub)clusters depends strongly on @xmath3 . we find median values of @xmath1 of 556kms@xmath2 for 651 ( sub)clusters with @xmath18 , 616kms@xmath2 for 564 ( sub)clusters with @xmath19 , and 703kms@xmath2 for 597 ( sub)clusters with @xmath20 . these medians are slightly lower than those reported in at98 due to a more careful clipping of outliers . as shown by plionis et al . ( 2004 ) @xmath1 increases with both @xmath3 and with abell count @xmath21 . this correlation may be partly due to an observer s tendency to measure more redshifts in richer clusters and thus the @xmath22 correlation may be a reflection of the known richness dependence of @xmath1 . the morphological classification available for most aco clusters is the `` bautz - morgan '' ( bm ) type . using only subclusters with the highest @xmath3 , we find that the mean and median @xmath1 for 664 ( sub)clusters of `` early '' bmtype ( @xmath23ii ) are _ lower _ by @xmath545kms@xmath2 than for 614 ( sub)clusters of `` late '' bmtype ( @xmath24ii ) . a kolmogorov - smirnov test gives only a 1.8% chance for these samples to be drawn from the same population . the direction of this trend is surprising , as earlier bm types are expected to be more evolved and to have higher x - ray luminosity , and thus to show a higher @xmath1 ( david , forman , & jones 1999 ) . these authors found that x - ray luminosity is correlated with both abell richness class @xmath25 and bm type , but also that @xmath25 may be overestimated in the southern aco . using updated x - ray samples and more cluster parameters , like @xmath26 , we plan to shed more light on the relation between cluster dynamics and bm type . we used our compilation in the past to establish the presently most complete catalogues of superclusters ( scl ) of abell- and x - ray clusters ( e.g. einasto et al . 2001 ) , and showed that x - ray clusters are more strongly clustered into superclusters than are optical clusters . we used the scl catalogue to confirm that the richest superclusters occupy a more or less regular lattice of 120@xmath27mpc grid size ( einasto , et al . 1994 , saar et al . based on the _ current _ compilation we extended our scl catalogue out to @xmath28 . in particular , several very interesting scls were revealed . the most prominent abell supercluster crossed by the northern lcrs slices is scl126 ( @xmath12=0.084 ) in the direction of virgo . four out of a total of seven aco member clusters of this scl lie within a sphere of diameter @xmath29mpc . three clusters in this scl are strong x - ray sources , and four contain radio sources . this makes scl126 one of the most unusual superclusters currently known . the shape ellipsoids , based on abell clusters , on lcrs loose groups ( lclg , tucker et al . 2000 ) , and on lcrs galaxies in scl126 , all have axis ratios of @xmath51:4 , and are located perpendicular to the line of sight ( einasto , m. et al . this may be evidence for a `` squashing effect '' of galaxies falling into scls ( kaiser 1987 ) , accompanied by merging and other processes causing x - ray and radio emission from the clusters . the core of scl126 may have started to collapse ( gramann & suhhonenko 2002 ) . another prominent scl is `` horologium reticulum '' ( scl48 at @xmath300.064 ) , crossed by all southern lcrs slices . this supercluster consists of several concentrations of abell clusters and lclgs which are connected by filaments of galaxies , groups and clusters that surround underdense regions ( einasto , m. et al . 2003b ; einasto , j. et al . 2003b ) . galaxy groups from the lcrs and sdss in high - density environments ( superclusters of abell clusters ) are also richer and more massive than groups in low - density environments ( einasto , m. et al . 2003a , b ; einasto , j. et al . 2003 ) . abazajian , k. , adelman - mccarthy , j. k. , ageros , m. a. , et al . 2004 , aj , 128 , 502 abell g. o. , corwin h. g. jr . , & olowin r. 1989 , , 70 , 1 andernach , h. 1991 , in _ large - scale structures and peculiar motions _ , eds . d. w. latham & l. n. dacosta ) , asp conf . 15 , 279 andernach , h. , tago , e. , & stengler - larrea , e. 1995 , ap.lett . & comm . 31 , 27 andernach , h. , & tago , e. 1998 , in _ large scale structure : tracks and traces _ , + eds . v. mller , et al . , singapore : world scientific , p. 147 ( astro - ph/9710265 ) david , l. p. , forman , w. , & jones , c. 1999 , , 519 , 533 einasto , j. , htsi , g. , einasto , m. , et al . 2003a , , 405 , 425 einasto , j. , einasto , m. , htsi , g. , et al . 2003b , , 410 , 425 einasto , m. , einasto , j. , tago , e. , et al . 1994 , , 269 , 301 einasto , m. , einasto , j. , tago , e. , mller , v. , & andernach , h. 2001 , aj , 122 , 2222 einasto , m. , einasto , j. , mller , v. , et al . 2003a , , 401 , 851 einasto , m. , jaaniste , j. , einasto , j. , et al . 2003b , , 405 , 821 gramann , m. , & suhhonenko , i. 2002 , mnras , 337 , 1417 jones , h. , saunders , w. , colless , m. , et al . 2004 , , in press ( astro - ph/0403501 ) kaiser , n. 1987 , mnras 227 , 1 peacock , j. a. , & west , m. j. 1992 , mnras 259 , 494 plionis , m. , andernach , h. , lpez - cruz , o. , tago , e. , & basilakos , s. 2004 , submitted saar , e. , einasto , j. , toomet , o. , starobinsky , a. a. , et al . 2002 , , 393 , 1

the june 2004 version of our compilation of measured redshifts for clusters in the abell - aco catalogue lists redshifts for 3715 clusters / subclusters in 3033 distinct ( 2396 a- and 637 s- ) clusters , 67% of these with @xmath0 galaxies measured . we provide velocity dispersions ( @xmath1 ) for 1875 ( sub)clusters towards 1353 unique aco clusters . the median @xmath1 is 650kms@xmath2 for a-(sub)clusters and 575kms@xmath2 for s-(sub)clusters , and @xmath1 clearly increases with both , @xmath3 and richness , and also , somewhat surprising , with later bautz - morgan type of the clusters . we show examples of supercluster properties based on these data .

quant-ph0508146

the famous debate between einstein , podolsky , rosen ( epr ) and bohr @xcite , about the nature of quantum correlations of a bi - partite state has played a key role in the investigation of entanglement properties of light in modern quantum optics , and has initiated a new branch of physics called quantum information . epr used in their arguments a wave function that exhibits a perfect correlations between positions and momenta of two massive particles ( labeled @xmath0 and @xmath1 ) . in the position and momentum representations the epr state takes the following forms @xmath2 quantum correlations of the entangled epr state have been implemented experimentally for massless particles : photons . in the case of light , the quantum mechanical position and momentum observables are played by the electric field : phase and amplitude quadratures . the well known two - mode gaussian squeezed states of light are physical realization of the epr state . those states lie at the heart of quantum cryptography @xcite , quantum information @xcite and quantum teleportation @xcite . there are few efficient ways of producing gaussian epr correlated states . one of them uses a kerr nonlinear medium in optical fibers to entangle phase and amplitude quadratures @xcite . however , the nonlinearity has to be relatively small to achieve a gaussian state . the other method uses a beam splitter as a nonlocal operation that creates entanglement . a typical setup consists of two initially separable amplitude squeezed beams which interfere at the 50/50 beam splitter . recent applications of entangled two - mode squeezed states of light in quantum information processing have generated a lot of interest in mixed gaussian states . although there are mathematical criterions for the entangled properties for mixed two - partite gaussian systems @xcite , they are not easy experimentally realizable . it is the purpose of this paper to show that hanbury - brown and twiss ( hbt ) interference can reveal the quantum nature of entanglement of two - particle mixed gaussian states . we show that it is possible to construct a quantum witness operator , closely related to the hbt interference @xcite , that probe entanglement of a mixed epr gaussian state . using hong , ou and mandel ( hom ) interferometry we discuss the entangled properties of time resolved interference of the epr state . we show that the deep in hom interference can provide a useful tool to study quantum separability of continuous - variable gaussian epr states . a non - degenerated optical parametric amplification , involving two modes of the radiation field , provides a physical realization of the epr state ( [ epr ] ) . the quantum state generated in this process has the following form @xmath3 is a thermal distribution with a mean number @xmath4 of photons in each mode . using field quadratures eigenstates : @xmath5 , we obtain that the wave function of such a system ( [ epr2 ] ) is gaussian and has the form @xmath6 in the limit of @xmath7 , the two - mode squeezed state ( [ nopa ] ) becomes the original epr state ( [ epr ] ) . the state ( [ nopa ] ) is not entangled only if @xmath8 . the simplest mixed generalization of the epr state involves a gaussian density operator @xmath9 , being a gaussian operator of the field modes described by the annihilation and creation operators @xmath10 and @xmath11 . this gaussian density operator of the two modes is fully characterized by its second moment expectation values of the modes . in the case of a mixed epr state the only non - vanishing field correlations are @xmath12 where @xmath4 is a mean number of photons in each mode , and @xmath13 correspond to the amount of correlation between the two modes . for @xmath14 , the epr state reduces to the pure state given by ( [ nopa ] ) . as it has been discussed in several papers ( see the tutorial @xcite and references therein ) , this mixed epr state is separable for @xmath15 and its density operator can be expressed in a sum of product states ( werner separability criterion ) @xmath16 where @xmath17 , @xmath18 are the density operators of the two modes and @xmath19 , with @xmath20 . the mixed epr state is entangled and non - separable if @xmath21 second and higher orders of coherence of a light beam can reveal its quantum nature , which can not be observed in young - type interference experiments . second - order interference involving intensity - intensity correlations have been first applied by hanbury - brown and twiss in stellar interferometry @xcite . in modern quantum optics , second - order interference has been used as powerful tool to study nonclassical properties of light @xcite . hanbury - brown and twiss ( hbt ) interference measures a second - order normally ordered intensity - intensity correlation function . in fig . [ fig:2 ] we have depicted a setup for hbt interference that involves two light beams with annihilation operators @xmath0 and @xmath1 interfering at the beam splitter . a correlation between clicks of two detectors corresponds to a normally ordered intensity - intensity correlation function . the hbt interference exhibits a typical pattern of the form : @xmath22 , where @xmath23 and @xmath24 are phase differences between the beams @xmath0 and @xmath1 in front of the detectors . these phases include geometrical phases and phases due to the possible action of the beam splitter . in this setup the two phases can be controlled experimentally . @xmath25 is a second - order interference visibility . for a classical source of light this visibility is always bounded : @xmath26 . this classical limit is violated for single photons , as it has been shown in the pioneering experiments performed by mandel @xcite . @xmath27 we shall apply the hbt setup to study the mixed gaussian epr state . at the detectors ( @xmath28 ) the positive - frequency part of electric field corresponding to modes @xmath29 and @xmath30 ( normalized to the number of photons ) is as follows @xmath31 the corresponding field intensity operator at the screen is equal to @xmath32 from this expression , we obtain that the normally ordered second - order intensity correlation is @xmath33\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the epr beams in a mixed state , with mean @xmath4 photons and correlation @xmath13 described by the relations from eq.([eprcorr ] ) , the fourth - order field correlations needed in the hbt calculations are equal to @xmath34 as a result the hbt intensity correlation function ( [ eq : hbt_correlation ] ) , for a continuous variable mixed epr state , has the following form @xmath35 with the second - order fringe visibility equal to @xmath36 for a separable ( classical ) output state we have : @xmath37 . in the case of no correlation in the output state @xmath38 , the visibility is @xmath39 , as it should be for a thermal state . for entangled states this visibility is quantum i.e. , it violates the classical inequality : @xmath40 . in fig . [ fig : visibility_1 ] and fig . [ fig : visibility_2 ] we have depicted the visibility ( [ eq : visibility_epr ] ) as a function of the correlation parameter @xmath13 for two different values of @xmath41 . based on the above visibility analysis one can introduce a hbt witness operator @xmath42 the mean value of this operator , @xmath43 is positive for separable mixed epr states and negative for entangled mixed epr states . the analysis of second - order interference , can be extended to the case of photon pulses which duration is long compared to the time resolution of photodetector . such single - photon emitters are already in use @xcite . a source produces single photon pulses with a relative delay which interfere at the beam splitter . simple analysis of beam splitter s action on impinging photons shows , that both photons will leave the same outport of the beam splitter . a relative delay is small enough to keep the pulses partially overlapping . even though the overlapping is not complete , its time duration is longer than the time resolution of the detector . therefore , the temporal effects can not be neglected any more when detecting pulses and the time delay @xmath44 between detected pulses at two separate detectors has to taken into account . experiments investigating interference for such pulses with different frequencies have already been performed @xcite . we restrict our description of the single - photon wave packets in the space - time domain to one - mode fields with electric field operators : @xmath45 and @xmath46 . the phases @xmath23 and @xmath24 are included in the mode functions phases . these mode phases contain an additive stochastic component related to the random arrival time of the correlated photons at the beam splitter or detectors . the time dependent electric fields of the two - mode output state is described by the beam splitter transformation ( see eq . ( [ eq : bs_transformation ] ) ) @xmath47 the joint coincidence of detecting photons from mode @xmath29 and @xmath30 at delayed times @xmath48 and @xmath49 can be obtained directly from the following second - order temporal coherence function @xmath50 using the mode functions , with random phases in the output state , we note that the only contributing terms to the second - order coherence function are the following @xmath51\ , \langle a^{\dagger}b^{\dagger } a\ , b\rangle\big\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as an example we shall use in the calculations a special model of phase fluctuations . we will assume that the mode functions have random phases typical for a stationary stochastic phase diffusion model . in this example , the only non - vanishing autocorrelations of the mode functions are @xmath52 in these formulas we have assumed that the statistical correlations are stationary and gaussian with coherence times @xmath53 and @xmath54 . the stationary intensities are : @xmath55 and @xmath56 . applying the above temporal correlations of the mode functions , combined with the epr correlations of a mixed state given by eq . ( [ 4correlations ] ) , we obtain that the second - order coherence function is stationary ( dependents only on time @xmath44 ) and has the form @xmath57 we shall simplify this formula further assuming that the mode intensities are equal : @xmath58 . setting @xmath59 the formula above reduces to @xmath60 with the second - order visibility @xmath25 equal to ( [ eq : visibility_epr ] ) . from this formula we obtain that a joint coincidence probability to detect a photon at time @xmath48 and another photon at time @xmath49 is @xmath61 where @xmath62 is a dimensionless time with @xmath44 expressed in units of @xmath63 . this coincidence probability exhibits a typical hong - ou - mandel deep @xcite . in fig . [ fig : ent_pure_1 ] , we have depicted the joint coincidence probability for a state with @xmath64 . the upper curve ( @xmath64 and @xmath65 ) is a border between separable and nonseparable epr states . the lower curve ( @xmath64 and @xmath66 ) describes hom interference of an entangled pure epr state . the region between the two curves corresponds to nonseparable mixed epr sates . for @xmath64 the minimum value the hom deep for a pure state is achieved at a zero coincident rate and is equal to @xmath67 . for the epr state given by eq . ( [ epr2 ] ) , with a small value of @xmath4 , one can get a significant increase of the the deep . for a weak two - mode pure squeezed state @xmath68 we can approximate the formula ( [ epr2 ] ) by @xmath69 illustrates the hom deep for a state with @xmath70 . the upper curve ( @xmath70 and @xmath71 ) is a border between separable and nonseparable epr states . the lower curve ( @xmath70 and @xmath72 ) describes hom interference of an entangled pure epr state approximated by the state exhibited above . the region between the two curves corresponds to nonseparable mixed epr sates . for @xmath70 the minimum value the hom deep for a pure state is achieved at a zero coincident rate and is equal to @xmath73 . in this paper we have shown that the hanbury - brown and twiss type interference can be used as an experimental test of quantum separability for continuous variable epr states . one can associate with this second - order interference a hbt witness operator quantifying entanglement for pure and mixed gaussian epr states . we have shown that time - resolved coincidence rate of joint photon detection exhibits the hong , ou and mandel deep , that provides a signature of quantum nonseparability for pure and mixed epr states . this work was partially supported by a kbn grant no . pbz - min-008/p03/03 . 99 a. einstein , b. podolsky , n. rosen , phys . rev . * 47 * , 777 , ( 1935 ) . n. bohr , phys . rev . * 48 * , 698 , ( 1935 ) . a. k. ekert , j. g. rarity , p. r. tapster , and g. m. palma , phys . lett . * 69 * , 1293 ( 1992 ) . s. l. braunstein and a. k. pati , ( eds ) , _ quantum information theory with continuous variable _ , ( kulwer , dordrecht , 2002 ) . a. furusawa _ et al . _ , science * 282 * , 706 ( 1998 ) . silberhorn , p.k . lam , o. wei , f. knig , n. korolkova , and g. leuchs , phys . lett . * 86 * , 4267 ( 2001 ) . see for example the tutorial : b .- g . englert and k. wdkiewicz , international journal of quantum information 1 , 153 , ( 2003 ) , and references therein . m. stobiska , k. wdkiewicz , phys . a * 71 * , 032304 ( 2005 ) . r. hanbury - brown and r. q. twiss , nature * 127 * , 27 , ( 1956 ) . m. o. scully and m. s. zubairy , _ quantum optics _ , ( cambridge university press , 2002 ) . l. mandel , rev . phys . * 71 * , 274 , ( 1999 ) . a. kuhn , m. hennrich , g. rempe , phys . lett . * 89 * , 067901 , ( 2002 ) . a. kuhn , m. hennrich , g. rempe , _ quantum information processing _ , ( wiley - vch , berlin 2003 ) . t. legero , t. wilk , m. hennrich , g. rempe , and a. kuhn , phys . lett . * 93 * , 070503 , ( 2004 ) . t. legero , t. wilk , a. kuhn , g. rempe , appl . b , ( 2003 ) . c. k. hong , z. y. ou , l. mandel , phys . rev . lett . * 59 * , 2044 , ( 1987 ) .

the separability of the continuous - variable epr state can be tested with hanbury - brown and twiss type interference . the second - order visibility of such interference can provide an experimental test of entanglement . it is shown that time - resolved interference leads to the hong , ou and mandel deep , that provides a signature of quantum non - separability for pure and mixed epr states . a hanbury - brown and twiss type witness operator can be constructed to test the quantum nature of the epr entanglement .

1102.3206

gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) are the most powerful explosions in the universe , and are thus considered to be a possible source of ultra - high energy ( uhe ) cosmic rays . short - duration bursts are believed to be a result of the collision of two compact objects and long - duration bursts are thought to be beamed emission from the collapse of a high - mass star into a black hole . see @xcite for reviews of the basic theories of grbs . in the widely - accepted fireball shock model , relativistic plasma in a jet collides either with the surrounding material or with the outflow itself , producing the observed gamma - ray prompt emission through synchrotron and inverse compton scattering of electrons @xcite . protons are also thought to be accelerated in these shocks via the fermi mechanism @xcite . these uhe protons then interact with the photons , going through a @xmath10 resonance and producing charged pions which decay , yielding uhe neutrinos @xcite . the first calculations of this prompt uhe neutrino emission use an e@xmath11 proton injection spectrum with energies up to e=@xmath12 gev , and predict an e@xmath13 neutrino spectrum in the uhe regime , with the steepening of the spectrum due to synchrotron cooling of the uhe pions @xcite . the detection of uhe neutrinos from grbs would support their identification as the sources of the highest energy cosmic rays , a longstanding mystery in particle astrophysics . previous searches for neutrino production have been perfomed by the icecube @xcite and rice collaborations @xcite , but this is the first search for uhe neutrinos from grbs above 10@xmath9 gev . a full description of the anita - i instrument can be found in @xcite , and a description of instrument modifications for anita - ii is in @xcite and @xcite . briefly , the anita experiment is a nasa long duration balloon experiment that searches for coherent , impulsive , broadband radio emission ( 200 - 1200 mhz ) from electromagnetic showers induced by uhe neutrinos interacting in the antarctic ice sheet @xcite . the second flight of the anita experiment launched on 2008 december 21 , flew for 31 days , 28.5 of which were live days , and recorded over 26 million triggers . forty quad - ridged , dual - polarization horn antennas search for radio impulses which could be caused by neutrino interactions in the ice sheet . the trigger requires coherent power in neighboring antennas , and the threshold is limited by thermal - noise emission from the ice . over 98.5% of recorded events were fluctuations of thermal noise . the trigger is designed to optimize efficiency on neutrino - like signals : vertically - polarized , broadband impulses . signals from each polarization of each antenna are recorded in a 100 ns window for each triggered event , allowing for directional determination on an event - by - event basis using interferometric techniques , also described at length in @xcite . anita is most sensitive to neutrinos which come from between the horizon and a payload elevation angle ( angle above the horizontal ) of @xmath14 . we are able to construct a more sensitive search for uhe neutrinos from grbs compared to the previously reported diffuse uhe neutrino search with anita - ii @xcite because the short time window given by the burst duration dramatically reduces background in the signal region , allowing us to lower our analysis threshold and look for very weak signals which also have a time and direction correlation with the observed grb . there are two sources of background for an anita neutrino search . the first is thermal - noise fluctuations , which are easily removed with a set of cuts on the strength of waveform correlation among neighboring antennas and the signal strength . the second is man - made noise , which can be removed because it tends to cluster with locations of known human activity and with other events . the details of event reconstruction , thermal - noise rejection , and man - made noise rejection are discussed in @xcite and @xcite . compared to the diffuse neutrino search , we loosen numerical values of thermal - noise cuts . the cuts against man - made noise remain the same . 00 abbasi , r. , _ et al . _ 2010 , apj 710 , 346 - 359 abbasi , r. , _ et al . _ 2011 , arxiv:1101.1448 alvarez - muiz , j. & halzen , f. 1999 , apj 521 , 928 askaryan , g. 1962 , jetp 14 , 441 becker , j. 2008 , phys . 458 , 173 - 246 besson , d. , _ et al . _ 2007 , astropart . 26 , 367 - 377 dermer , c. d. & atoyan , a. 2006 , new j. phys . 8 , 122 gcn : the gamma - ray bursts coordinates network , http://gcn.gsfc.nasa.gov/ gorham , p. , _ et al . _ 2009 , astropart . 32 , 10 gorham , p. , _ et al . _ 2010 , phys . rev . d 82 , 022004 ; arxiv:1011.5004 guetta , d. , _ et al . _ 2004 , astropart . 20 , 429 halzen , f. & hooper , d. 2002 , rept . 65 , 1025 meszaros , p. 2001 , science 291 , 79 meszaros , p. 2002 , ann . 40 , 137 meszaros , p. & rees , m. 1993 , apj 405 , 278 razzaque , s. , _ et al . _ 2003 , phys . rev . d 68 , 083001 vieregg , a. g. 2010 , phd dissertation , university of california , los angeles waxman , e. 2003 , nucl . 118 , 353 waxman , e. & bahcall , j. 1997 , phys . 78 , 2292 waxman , e. & bahcall , j. 1999 , phys . d 59 , 023002 waxman , e. & bahcall , j. 2000 , apj 541 , 707 wick , s. d. , dermer , c. d. , & atoyan , a. 2004 , astropart .

we set the first limits on the ultra - high energy ( uhe ) neutrino fluence at energies greater than @xmath0 gev from gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) based on data from the second flight of the antarctic impulsive transient antenna ( anita ) . during the 31 day flight of anita - ii , 26 grbs were recorded by swift or fermi . of these , we analyzed the 12 grbs which occurred during quiet periods when the payload was away from anthropogenic activity . in a blind analysis , we observe 0 events on a total background of 0.0044 events in the combined prompt window for all 12 low - background bursts . we also observe 0 events from the remaining 14 bursts . we place a 90% confidence level limit on the @xmath1 prompt neutrino fluence between 10@xmath2 gev@xmath3e@xmath310@xmath4 gev of @xmath5=2.5@xmath6 gev@xmath7/@xmath8 from grb090107a . this is the first reported limit on the uhe neutrino fluence from grbs above 10@xmath9 gev , and the strongest limit above 10@xmath2 gev .

1310.0051

strongly - correlated electron systems are currently of great interest in the condensed matter physics and quantum chemistry communities . @xcite despite the differences , for example , between frustrated lattices and chemical bond breaking , the strong - correlation phenomenon in these systems has similar roots which are manifested by the breakdown of the mean - field picture . regardless of the details of the problem at hand , strong - correlation has significant impact on many important aspects of the physics of various systems and can not be ignored . @xcite a low computational cost , qualitatively correct description of strongly - correlated materials would have great impact on the quality of theoretical predictions . hence , the quest for developing novel , as well as improving existing approaches for strong - correlation continues unabated . one of the reasons that robust methods for the treatment of strong - correlation are so elusive is related to the size of the systems of current interest . with increasing number of electronic degrees of freedom , the numerical complexity of exactly solving the problem quickly becomes prohibitively large ; approximate methods must be therefore employed . an ideal approximation should provide a systematic and qualitatively correct description that is computationally accessible and does not deteriorate with system size . such an ideal tool would be therefore applicable to a broad range of problems . from a practical point of view , approximate methods should offer a good compromise between accuracy and computational cost . many methods are available to tackle the strong - correlation problem ; they include quantum and variational monte carlo , @xcite dynamical mean - field theory ( dmft ) , @xcite density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) @xcite , methods based on symmetry breaking and restoration , @xcite and methods based on a gutzwiller variational approach . @xcite this list is not , by any means , exhaustive . the effort to develop new approximations is continuously undertaken . recently , knizia and chan introduced density matrix embedding theory ( dmet ) , @xcite a novel and promising tool as demonstrated by the high quality results obtained on hubbard lattices . dmet has its roots in the embedding dmft framework , where the complexity of the entire system is reduced by partitioning the problem into a fragment plus an entangled bath . together , they constitute an impurity model . as opposed to dmft , the dmet impurity model is frequency - independent and therefore significantly simpler . @xcite dmet is designed to reproduce the entanglement of the impurity rather than its green s function . moreover , the construction of the effective bath is achieved in an algebraic way . in particular , if the impurity hamiltonian is defined in a basis derived from a product state , the complexity of the impurity basis construction amounts to a rather small matrix diagonalization . @xcite density matrix embedding theory has been benchmarked for model 1d and 2d one - band hubbard lattices , @xcite and in chemical systems . @xcite in the present work , we focus on the former in order to further investigate the properties of this novel methodology . in particular , we analyze the convergence criterion employed in the initial study . @xcite we follow the alternative criterion , introduced in ref . and prove that in periodic systems it allows us to gain full control over the lattice filling . additionally , we investigate the impact of the effective bath basis on the quality of results . the formalism here presented allows for spin symmetry breaking in the underlying lattice mean - field solution that is used to construct the key ingredients of the dmet procedure . the only symmetry constraint retained is lattice translational symmetry , although in the present work we understand it in an extended cell formalism . this means that the adopted translational unit cell is identical to the dmet fragment for which the calculations are performed . we also suggest an approximation that substantially reduces the number of parameters to be optimized . in particular , we show that it is sufficient to limit the density matrix fitting to diagonal elements , i.e. , we propose , what we call _ density _ , as opposed to _ density matrix _ embedding . we provide a detailed numerical analysis of the results obtained with this approach . in particular , we benchmark the aforementioned approximation against high quality reference data and exact solutions for energies , two - body correlation functions , and compressibility . the latter allows us to access the mott gap in the hubbard model . @xcite the present section is organized as follows . first , for clarity and to make this work self - contained , we review the basic principles of dmet . we discuss the properties of the embedding basis and sketch the algorithm . we then proceed to discuss the convergence criterion , which is by no means unique . the suggested route to incorporate broken symmetry embedding is described subsequently . in order to outline the key ideas of dmet , let us assume that we are given the exact ground state @xmath0 for the system of interest . then , it is possible to perform a schmidt decomposition of this wavefunction according to @xcite @xmath1 and @xmath2 can be chosen such that the former represents a particular set of lattice site states , which we call the fragment . the latter must then be the complement that spans all the sites excluded from @xmath3 , and we refer to it as the bath . the summation in the above equation is limited by the dimension of the smaller of these two sets . these bases are then used to project the hamiltonian into the schmidt states of the fragment , @xmath3 , and bath , @xmath2 @xcite @xmath4 details of matrix elements of the projected hamiltonian , usually refer to as impurity hamiltonian , are not relevant here . for a discussion regarding the impurity hamiltonian , the reader is referred to ref . . the key point to notice is that the size of the new basis ( though many - body in principle ) can be chosen much smaller than that of the original problem , if formulated in a single particle basis . as discussed in ref . , the original hamiltonian @xmath5 and the impurity hamiltonian @xmath6 share the same ground state @xmath0 ; information about the expectation values of @xmath5 can be extracted by studying @xmath6 . unfortunately , in practical applications , we do not have access to the exact solution . the embedding states have to be approximated . the fundamental simplification of dmet is to replace the exact solution with a mean - field ( here understood as hartree - fock ) wavefunction , which is a simple product wavefunction ansatz . in this case , the schmidt fragment and bath bases can be represented in terms of single particle states . this greatly simplifies the computational treatment of the impurity problem and , as we show in this section , provides an effective truncation of the dimension of single particle basis for the problem at hand . let us follow the procedure more closely on a specific example , a hubbard hamiltonian . in this case , @xmath7 where @xmath8 connects nearest neighbors , @xmath9 is the on - site repulsion parameter , and @xmath10 is an effective one - body potential that we wish to introduce ; the rationale behind this potential will become apparent in the following . at this point , let us just notice that @xmath10 is contained within the fragment and it is periodically replicated over the lattice . in the limit of vanishing potential @xmath10 , the hamiltonian reduces to the standard hubbard model . the first step in dmet is to solve the above problem at the mean - field level . this procedure yields a single slater determinant @xmath11 , where @xmath12 creates a hole ( occupied ) state @xmath13 and @xmath14 is a bare vacuum . the product runs from 1 to the number of electrons . the hole creation operators are defined by the underlying hartree - fock transformation @xmath15 from physical fermions @xmath16 , @xcite @xmath17 the basis @xmath18 takes into account the position and the spin degrees of freedom . in order to construct the fragment and bath states needed to define the impurity hamiltonian , we introduce the operator @xmath19 that projects the hole levels onto the single particle basis contained within the fragment . additionally , we have the complement @xmath20 such that @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the identity operator . following ref . , one can define an overlap matrix @xmath23 , @xmath24 where the indices @xmath25 and @xmath26 run over hole states . this hermitian matrix can be brought to diagonal form by a unitary transformation @xmath27 satisfying @xmath28 , where @xmath29 contains at most @xmath30 nonzero eigenvalues ( here @xmath31 is the number of electrons in the lattice whereas @xmath32 is the size of the single particle fragment basis ) . in the following , we will assume that @xmath33 and that all @xmath32 eigenvalues are different from 1 and 0 ( otherwise , special care has to be taken while constructing the fragment and bath states ) . for each of the nonzero eigenvalues , one may construct a fragment state latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } \label{fstate } and a bath state latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } \label{bstate } the single particle states that correspond to vanishing eigenvalues of @xmath23 are considered as the inert core states @xmath35 . following ref . , the states corresponding to vanishing eigenvalues of @xmath23 denote orbitals with zero probability of being in the fragment space . similarly , one can think of the inert core states as states with vanishing coupling to the fragment states in the mean - field one - particle density matrix . the reader is referred to appendix [ ap : idem ] for more details . in dmet , the inert core single particle states are eliminated from the impurity problem ( _ i.e. _ they are not included while projecting the hamiltonian onto the impurity hamiltonian ) . therefore , dmet retains only a small portion of the large number of single particle states constituting the original hilbert space of the problem . in fact , the total dimension of the single particle basis is just twice the dimension of the single particle basis spanned by the fragment . this is clear from the particular properties of the spectrum of @xmath23 ( eq . [ mmat ] ) for the mean - field wavefunction . in other words , the hilbert space of the impurity model is significantly smaller than that of the original problem . it is also determined by the size of the fragment . armed with fragment and bath single particle states , which we shall refer to as an embedding basis , one can construct an impurity hamiltonian ( henceforth , for brevity of notation , the indices in the impurity hamiltonian denote spin and space coordinates ) , @xmath36 in the above , @xmath37 denotes bath creation operators whereas @xmath38 denotes either fragment or bath ones . the @xmath39 and @xmath40 denote the one- and ( antisymmetrized ) two - body terms of the hubbard hamiltonian projected onto the embedding basis , respectively . similarly , @xmath41 corresponds to the additional effective potential . at this point , we would like to point out that this potential , introduced in eq . [ eq : hubham ] , does not affect directly the one - body part of the impurity hamiltonian in the fragment space . in other words , the fragment part of the impurity hamiltonian corresponds to the physical hamiltonian . as the reader may notice , the dmet impurity hamiltonian derived from the schmidt decomposition of the mean - field wavefunction is expressed in terms of single particle states and corresponding creation and annihilation operators of fragment and bath states . this is to be compared with eq . [ eq : trueimp ] , which is more general and may include many - body states as a basis . the impurity hamiltonian is the central part of the approximation . as the dimension of the embedding basis is significantly reduced ( by means of eliminating the inert core @xmath35 states ) , one is now in a position to employ powerful ground state computational schemes for solving it . in particular , exact diagonalization becomes computationally feasible for modest fragment sizes . the goal of dmet is to find an optimal effective one - body potential @xmath10 by means of minimizing @xmath42 in the above , @xmath43 and @xmath44 are the one - particle density matrix evaluated with the impurity and the mean - field wavefunction , respectively . the precise meaning of the convergence criterion is discussed in the following section . once converged , the energy density @xmath45 for the fragment can be evaluated as @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the two particle density matrix . the index @xmath48 in the above summations implies that at least one of the basis functions has to belong to the fragment space . clearly , the energy expression does not correspond to the expectation value taken with respect to the full lattice hamiltonian . because the above expression is not a true expectation value taken with respect to the full hamiltonian of the system , the dmet energy need not be an upper bound to the exact value . in practice , we have observed a tendency of the procedure to deliver ground state energies that are below the exact ones . the self consistency loop in dmet takes the following form 1 . obtain an initial guess for @xmath10 . 2 . find @xmath15 of eq . [ hartreefock ] and construct fragment and bath states according to eqs . [ mmat]-[bstate ] . 3 . construct the impurity hamiltonian ( eq . [ impham ] ) and solve it . 4 . update @xmath10 by means of eq . [ diffgam ] . if the update is not negligible , replicate the fragment potential @xmath10 over the entire lattice and go to step 2 . dmet provides a very good compromise between accuracy and computational cost for the hubbard hamiltonian . @xcite however , in the original formulation , the authors chose to define a convergence criterion based on an effective one - body potential that minimizes the difference between the correlated and mean - field one - particle density matrices over the _ full _ impurity space , _ i.e. _ , fragment and bath basis . in other words , the effective potential sought satisfies @xmath49 where the indices @xmath50 and @xmath51 run over the fragment and the bath states . this approach , despite its merits , introduces a certain limitation to the model . primarily , as shown in appendix [ ap : idem ] , because the mean - field density matrix in the embedding basis must be idempotent , it is not possible to find @xmath10 such that the fit between the mean - field ( @xmath44 ) and correlated one - particle density matrix ( @xmath43 ) is exact . an accurate impurity solver yields @xmath43 with eigenvalues different from 1 and 0 , except for special cases , like for example , a trivial system of noninteracting particles . one therefore concludes that in general @xmath52 , the total energies for the physical system computed with dmet are determined by the fragment energy . it follows then , that any error in the average number of particles in the fragment affects the predictions for the entire system . this problem can be ameliorated by changing the definition of the converged effective one - body potential . an alternative convergence criterion can be therefore formulated,@xcite @xmath53 henceforth , the block of the density matrix in the embedding basis with two indices located on the fragment is referred to as fragment one - particle density matrix . with the above definition of the effective potential , provided that the minimum corresponds to a perfect match , the average number of electrons per fragment is correct . this statement is particularly important from the viewpoint of periodic systems , where the average particle density per fragment is known . the proof of this statement is presented in appendix [ ap : filling ] . the above considerations narrow the choices for the convergence criterion due to the constraint on the number of particles per fragment . nonetheless , fitting only the fragment one - particle density matrix is not a unique choice . for this reason , our density embedding proposal further simplifies the numerical procedure while imposing control over the lattice filling . as shown in appendix [ ap : filling ] , an exact match between density matrices guarantees that the trace of fragment @xmath43 will have the desired number of particles . since the trace is obviously determined by the diagonal elements of the one - body density matrix , we formulate the convergence criterion as @xmath54 the decrease in the number of parameters that needs to be optimized is accompanied by simplifications of the effective lattice hamiltonian that one should solve , @xmath55 we find that eq . [ eq : dmetcondiag ] greatly facilitates convergence while delivering results quantitatively similar to those obtained with the full method . for the purpose of the present work , we shall denote the results obtained with the convergence criterion defined by eq . [ eq : dmetcondiag ] as density embedding theory ( det ) . in this approach , the effective potential has a clear physical meaning as an effective ( site dependent ) chemical potential . having discussed the convergence criterion in dmet , let us turn our attention to possibilities for optimizing the embedding basis . the initial dmet calculations neglected the effect of two - body interactions in the lattice . @xcite in other words , the two - body interactions were suppressed both in the lattice hamiltonian and bath portions of the impurity hamiltonian . only particles in the fragment states were subjected to the on - site repulsion . since in mean - field the entire system is approximated by a set of non - interacting particles , the hartree - fock transformation constitutes the exact solution ; no symmetry breaking can occur , with some exceptions ( here we do not consider explicit symmetry breaking _ via _ an effective potential symmetry by a spin dependent effective potential introduced in eq . [ eq : hubham ] . this is a possible route for further developments of the model . ] ) . for example , due to lattice discretization into a set of fragments , translational symmetry might be violated ; this , however , would again correspond to a situation where one works in an extended unit cell framework . another possibility is degeneracy of the solution where the wavefunction may be chosen to violate certain symmetries of the hamiltonian . in the present work , we adopt a different procedure . the full lattice hamiltonian corresponds exactly , apart from the effective one - body potential whose role has been already discussed , to the hubbard hamiltonian . the system is then treated with a spin - unrestricted formalism , where the hartree - fock wavefunction need not be an eigenfunction of the @xmath56 operator . this procedure leads to a spin - dependent embedding basis and an impurity hamiltonian that does not need to commute with the @xmath56 operator . in order to retain the simplicity of a spin - restricted formulation , we do not choose the effective one - body potential to be spin - dependent . as a direct consequence , we define the effective one - body potential by @xmath57 here , @xmath58 is the charge density . the fitted one - particle density matrix may be chosen either as dmet or det type . on the other hand , we note that the broken spin symmetry formalism does not easily support fitting of the entire one - particle density matrix in the embedding basis as was done in ref . . let us first stress that the transformation of the bare fermion basis to the embedding basis is a projection and hence can not be inverted ( unless , of course , one chooses to divide the whole system into two equal fragments ) . only the transformation of the fragment states is unitary ( and hence invertible ) . therefore , solely the @xmath59 and @xmath60 fragment density matrices are expressible in the common basis that defines a charge density matrix . for this reason , fitting of the entire one - particle density matrix has no clear physical meaning , though it may be numerically performed . we stress that the arguments outlined above regarding correct filling are directly applicable to the charge density matrix . indeed , in a spin - restricted formalism , the charge density matrix and the one - particle density matrix are equivalent . finally , let us note that away from half - filling , the spin unrestricted mean - field solution can admit charge fluctuations that are beyond the size of the fragment . in order to maintain the mean - field calculations commensurate with the chosen fragment size , we solve the hartree - fock equations in momentum space assuming homogeneity of the fragment superlattice . in the following sections , we benchmark all the embedding schemes discussed above for the 1d hubbard model . for clarity , let us define acronyms that will be used in the rest of this paper . results labeled as ba correspond to the exact bethe ansatz solution . @xcite calculations denoted as dmet(n ) refer to calculations where spin symmetry ( @xmath56 ) in the mean - field solution is allowed to break and fitting of the one - particle density matrix is performed over the entire fragment chosen to include n sites . similarly , det(n ) denotes calculations where the fit is enforced only on the diagonal elements of the fragment one - particle density matrix . in order to better illustrate the performance of the broken symmetry approach , we also include data obtained with embeddings where the two - body interaction is suppressed in the lattice . to be more precise , in these schemes the hamiltonian for which the mean - field solution is obtained corresponds to eq . [ eq : hubham ] with @xmath61 , however , the impurity hamiltonian does include the on - site interaction but only in the fragment space . these , as already discussed , correspond to a non - interacting case and are denoted as ni and ni@xmath62 . the additional subscript @xmath63 ( for `` full '' matrix ) implies fitting of the full impurity one - particle density matrix ( this is the method introduced in ref . ) . for convenience , table [ methods ] includes the key qualities of all studied embedding schemes . .comparison of the key qualities of all studied embedding schemes . [ eq : dmetcono ] , eq . [ eq : dmetcon ] and eq . [ eq : dmetcondiag ] correspond to fitting of full impurity , fragment only , and the diagonal of the fragment one - particle density matrix , respectively . two - body denotes inclusion of these terms in the lattice and the bath portions of the impurity . spin symmetry denotes whether the mean - field solution is required to be an eigenstate of the @xmath56 operator . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ] we have investigated several dmet variants within a broken spin - symmetry formalism which includes two - body interactions in the lattice mean - field . we have shown that the numerical procedure can be simplified and its convergence greatly improved by only fitting the diagonal of the fragment density matrix . the resulting det scheme here introduced shows satisfactory accuracy in hubbard 1d benchmarks . additionally , we have demonstrated that the det scheme is exact when the half - filled hubbard lattice is split into two equal pieces . we deem this property an important guiding principle for defining a robust embedding approximation . our numerical det data for half - filled lattices is in very good agreement with exact results obtained with the bethe ansatz . this is clear not only for total energies but also for the two - body local correlation function @xmath64 . for hole doped systems , det yields good mott gaps and density profiles . moreover , det retains full control over the average number of particles , as opposed to the original formulation of ref . . both procedures have comparable computational cost except that inclusion of lattice two - body interactions requires an iterative procedure for solving the mean - field hamiltonian . as currently formulated , dmet can not accurately describe long - range correlation functions beyond the fragment size ( or , in other words , provide an accurate description of fluctuations beyond the size of the fragment ) . this is an expected shortcoming inherent to approximations defining an impurity model that is shared by dmft . we believe that this deficiency constitutes a major challenge in the development of dmet . further work to improve and address the many shortcomings discussed in this paper seems warranted . nonetheless , we believe that dmet is a valuable and promising quantum embedding tool for studying strongly - correlated systems , offering high quality results at very low computational cost . i.w.b would like to acknowledge dr . rayner rodrguez - guzmn for numerous discussions and help with the dmrg calculations . carlos a. jimnez - hoyos is gratefully acknowledged for providing the bethe ansatz data . this work was supported by the department of energy , office of basic energy sciences , grant no . de - fg02 - 09er16053 . g.e.s . is a welch foundation chair ( c-0036 ) . j.d . acknowledges support from the spanish ministry of economy and competitiveness under grant fis2012 - 34479 . in this appendix , we prove certain properties of the embedding basis obtained via the schmidt decomposition of a single slater determinant . einstein summation convention is used . let us recall that the embedding basis is obtained from the schmidt overlap matrix @xmath23 @xmath65 ( @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the hole states ) which is diagonalized by a unitary matrix @xmath27 @xmath66 where @xmath29 is a diagonal matrix . let us denote the hartree - fock transformation as @xmath15 . then the @xmath50th fragment and bath states , expressed in terms of the lattice basis take the form let us consider the lattice density matrix @xmath44 that has been obtained from the mean - field solution . projected onto the embedding basis , it will take the following form , @xmath69 using eqs . [ ap : eq : basis ] , for the @xmath70 block one obtains , @xmath71 in the above , indices @xmath25 , @xmath26 and @xmath72 runs over hf hole states while @xmath18 and @xmath73 denote the on - site lattice spin - orbital . similarly , one can easily verify that @xmath44 is idempotent in the embedding basis and its trace is equal to the dimension of the fragment single particle basis . on the other hand , the fragment - fragment block of the density matrix need not be idempotent . indeed , keeping in mind that @xmath75 ( ref . ) and , as we show in appendix [ ap : filling ] , @xmath76 is the number of electrons per fragment , this situation is highly unlikely . furthermore , whenever the eigenvalues @xmath29 are either 0 or 1 , one can not construct an orthonormal basis according to eqs . [ ap : eq : basis ] . additionally , let us stress that the inert core states corresponding to the zero eigenvalues of @xmath23 would have vanishing off - diagonal coupling to the fragment states . this is a consequence of the orthogonality of the eigenvectors of @xmath23 . [ [ commutativity - of - the - mean - field - density - matrix - and - fock - matrix - in - the - embedding - basis ] ] commutativity of the mean - field density matrix and fock matrix in the embedding basis ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ let us consider the mean - field fock matrix in the embedding basis @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the lattice fock matrix . since @xmath44 and @xmath48 are hermitian , they commute if and only if their product , @xmath79 is hermitian . since @xmath80 and @xmath48 clearly have the same block structure as @xmath44 ( eq . [ ap : eq : blocks ] ) , one can investigate separately each block of @xmath80 . and so , @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the eigenvalue of @xmath78 . in the above , one uses the relation that @xmath83 . similarly , @xmath84 both of these matrices are manifestly hermitian . finally , @xmath85 and @xmath86 clearly @xmath87 , hence @xmath80 is hermitian and @xmath44 and @xmath48 commute . let us denote the number of bare fermion single particle states as @xmath88 and the number of fragment states as @xmath89 . the fragment basis can be now expressed as @xmath90 which is a @xmath91 matrix with @xmath92 being a @xmath93 matrix . since @xmath94 is a linear transformation that preserves vectors length , it is unitary , @xmath95 the full embedding basis takes the form @xmath96 which satisfies @xmath97 , but @xmath98 unless , of course @xmath99 . we can now transform the embedding basis with a unitary transformation @xmath100 such that @xmath101 is expressed in the fragment bare fermion basis . we note that such unitary transformation does not affect the idempotency of @xmath44 and its commutativity with @xmath48 . finally , let us note that this transformation does not affect the trace of @xmath44 taken over the @xmath70 block . since the fragment basis is now equivalent to the bare fermion basis , we see that the trace of @xmath102 ( hence @xmath76 ) must be equal to the number of electrons per fragment , provided that the mean - field solution does not break translational symmetry ( again , assuming that one works with an extended unit cell chosen as fragment ) . 50ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1146/annurev - physchem-032210 - 103338 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/adma.201202018 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.66.763 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/bf01303701 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1107559 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.36.381 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.71.241103 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.85.045103 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.64.184509 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.62.324 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.69.168 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.69.1236 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.69.1240 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.72.1545 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.104.226402 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.78.115102 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.69.195105 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.68.13 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.69.2863 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.77.259 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.53.r10445 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.87.235129 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3643338 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.4705280 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.85.245130 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.87.115136 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.69.045110 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.85.035133 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.186404 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1021/ct301044e [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) , @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1007/s13538 - 012 - 0074 - 1 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.72.061602 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.83.063632 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.77.045133 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0953-8984/21/i=48/a=485602 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( )

several variants of the recently proposed density matrix embedding theory ( dmet ) [ g. knizia and g. k - l . chan , _ phys . rev . lett . _ * 109 * , 186404 ( 2012 ) ] are formulated and tested . we show that spin symmetry breaking of the lattice mean - field allows precise control of the lattice and fragment filling while providing very good agreement between predicted properties and exact results . we present a rigorous proof that at convergence this method is guaranteed to preserve lattice and fragment filling . differences arising from fitting the fragment one - particle density matrix alone versus fitting fragment plus bath are scrutinized . we argue that it is important to restrict the density matrix fitting to solely the fragment . furthermore , in the proposed broken symmetry formalism , it is possible to substantially simplify the embedding procedure without sacrificing its accuracy by resorting to _ density _ instead of _ density matrix _ fitting . this simplified density embedding theory ( det ) greatly improves the convergence properties of the algorithm .

1309.7463

in recent years , social media networks , vital platforms for sharing contents with others in the era of web 2.0 , such as youtube , facebook , delicious , amazon , flickr and wikipedia , to name just a few , have experienced explosive growth @xcite . these systems record the fingerprints of every user s activity and every item s popularity , providing a wealth of data " to study the dynamics of human activity and item popularity at the global system scale . in particular , it is found that the probability distributions of the activity degree of users , e.g. , editing in wikipedia @xcite , voting in news2 @xcite as well as favorite marking in flickr @xcite , and the popularity degree of items , e.g. , the number of fans a photo has in flickr @xcite , follow a power law . the power law distributions are explained by the rich - get - richer mechanism @xcite , which is also called preferential attachment in the field of complex networks @xcite . however , how these two distributions arise simultaneously due to human activity has yet to be determined . the activity dynamics @xcite and popularity dynamics @xcite have been investigated in the literatures , respectively . however , human activity and item popularity , two perspectives of the cross links between users and items , are interdependent ; therefore , we can not study the dynamics of one aspect alone . in addition , individuals are always embedded in a social network . it is widely believed that information can spread quickly along social links using user - to - user exchanges , also known as `` word - of - mouth '' exchanges ; moreover , the users behaviors are strongly influenced by their neighbors @xcite . in particular , the social degree and the activity degree depend on each other @xcite . hence , it is considered worthwhile studying social networks to obtain deeper insights into the dynamics of human activity and item popularity . until now , there has been no clear picture as to how online human activity and item popularity coevolve , so it is crucial to investigate the evolution of empirical human activity and item popularity as well as the theoretical model to obtain a better understanding of the possible generic laws governing the formation of activity distribution and popularity distribution . in this paper , we first characterize the evolution of human activity and item popularity in the amazon , flickr , delicious and wikipedia networks . it is found that in such social media networks , both relative probabilities of users creating cross links and items acquiring cross links are proportional to the degree of activity and degree of popularity , respectively . in particular , the inactive users are more likely to trace popular items than the active users . based on empirical observations , we then propose an evolving model based on two - step random walk . finally , we justify the validity of our model by comparing the results of model with that of empirical networks . this work could shed light on the understanding of evolution of user activity and item popularity in social media networks , and it also could be helpful in certain applications , such as designing efficient strategies for virtual marketing and network marketing , etc . ) , and the activity degree ( @xmath0 ) ; i4 has the popularity degree ( @xmath1 ) . please note that there is no social links in some cases , such as wikipedia.,width=288 ] * data description and notations . * the delicious data set was downloaded from http://data.dai-la bor.de/corpus/delicious/ , and consists of 132,500,391 bookmarks , 50,221,626 urls ( books ) , and 947,835 users between september , 2003 and december 31 , 2007 @xcite . the amazon user - movie rating data set was obtained from stanford large network dataset collection ( http://snap.stanford.edu/data/web-a mazon.html ) @xcite . the data consists of 7,911,684 ratings , 267,320 movies and 759,899 users between august 1997 and october 2012 . the flickr data set was collected by daily crawling flickr over 2.5 million users from nov 2 , 2006 to dec 3 , 2006 , and again daily from february 3 , 2007 to may 18 , 2007 ( http://socialnetworks.mpi-sws.org/datasets.html)@xcite . here , we only considered the users who had at least one favorite photo . with this constraint , there are 497,937 users , 11,232,836 photos and 34,734,221 favorite - markings in the data . the wikipedia ( english ) data set was download from http://konect.uni- koblenz.de/networks/edit-enwiki . the data set consists of 21,416,395 articles written collaboratively by 3,819,691 volunteers around the world before september , 2010 . the four datasets consist of individuals and items , such as movies in amazon , urls ( books ) in delicious , photos in flickr , and articles in wikipedia . moreover , users are able to show interest in these items using the network feature of rating in amazon , bookmarking in delicious , favorite - marking in flickr , and editing in wikipedia . therefore , these systems are topologically equivalent . for analysis purposes , the user - item data can be mapped into a two - layer network , as shown schematically in fig . this network has two types of nodes : @xmath2 users and @xmath3 items totally . in principle , the individuals are embedded in a social network . for example , flickr and delicious allow users to make friends . therefore , there should be two types of links : the cross links between users and items as well as the social links among users . mathematically , the topology shown in fig . [ fig1 ] can be characterized by two matrices . @xmath4 , an @xmath5 adjacency matrix , represents the social links among users , with element @xmath6 if user @xmath7 declares user @xmath8 as his friend , otherwise @xmath9 . similarly , @xmath10 , an @xmath11 adjacency matrix , characterizes the cross links , with element @xmath12 if user @xmath7 is interested in the item @xmath13 , otherwise @xmath14 . to be specific , we defined the following types of degrees to characterize the multi - relational connections . two degrees are related to the cross links : ( 1 ) the activity degree : @xmath15 , i.e. , the number of items interested by user @xmath7 ; ( 2 ) the popularity degree @xmath16 , i.e. , the number of users who are interested in the item @xmath13 , which reasonably represents the popular extent in the network ; and ( 3 ) the social degree @xmath17 , i.e. , the number of friends for a given user . note , @xmath18 and @xmath19 are two different perspectives of the cross links connecting users and items . * measuring preferential attachment . * here , we explain the method for measuring the phenomenon of preferential attachment on temporal data @xcite . the basic idea is to investigate whether new links are likely to attach to nodes with larger degree ( size ) . we calculate the empirical value of the relative probability @xmath20 that a new cross link formed within a short period @xmath21 connects to a user ( item ) , which has a degree of @xmath22 at the time @xmath23 , as follows , @xmath24 here , @xmath22 is the degree at time @xmath23 . @xmath25 is the number of nodes with exact degree @xmath22 at @xmath23 , but creating ( acquiring ) new cross links within next small interval @xmath21 ( e.g. , one day in this article ) . @xmath26 is the number of users ( items ) with degree @xmath22 at @xmath23 . the preferential attachment hypothesis states that the rate @xmath20 with which a node with @xmath22 links acquires new links is a monotonically increasing function of @xmath22 @xcite , namely @xmath27 . to obtain a smooth curve from noisy data , we take the cumulative function form instead of @xmath20 : @xmath28 in our measurement , @xmath22 can be either degree of activity @xmath18 or degree of popularity @xmath19 . this method has been successfully used to verify the preferential attachment mechanism of ba model @xcite in empirical evolving networks @xcite and theoretical models @xcite . .basic statistics of the data sets constructed for our study . showing the number of users @xmath2 , the number of items @xmath3 , the number of cross links @xmath29 , the average degree of activity @xmath30 and the average degree of popularity @xmath31 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ alpha ] figure [ figure-2 ] shows the cumulative function @xmath32 with respect to the degree of activity and degree of popularity . we see that the relative cumulative probability @xmath33 ( @xmath34 ) for users ( items ) to create ( acquire ) cross links is proportional to the existing degree of activity ( popularity ) . in particular , the cumulative functions @xmath35 approximately follow a straight line on the log - log scale , indicating that the relative cumulative probability of generating new degrees satisfies a power law with respect to the existing degrees , which can be characterized by the positive exponent @xmath36 where @xmath37 with @xmath38 denoting the degree . in table [ alpha ] , we list the characteristic exponents @xmath39 and @xmath40 determined by least - square fitting the @xmath35 functions for small @xmath41 as the curves deviate from the straight line for large @xmath41 due to low statistics . the positive exponents @xmath39 and @xmath40 indicate that the active users ( with a higher degree of activity ) have greater chance to create new cross links than the inactive users ( with a lower degree of activity ) , while the popular items ( with a higher degree of popularity ) have greater chance to attract new cross links . for different groups of users and @xmath33 for different groups of items ( in the insets ) , in amazon(a ) , flickr ( b ) , delicious ( c ) and wikipedia ( d ) . the users and items are classified into different groups according to the degree of activity and the degree of popularity . , width=528 ] as these four systems expand rapidly , we then investigate the formation of cross links between new users ( items ) and existing items ( users ) . in the insets of fig . [ figure-2 ] , @xmath33 characterizes the relative probability that the existing users are interested in new items with respect to the users degree of activity , whereas @xmath42 characterizes the relative probability that the existing items attract the attentions of new users with respect to the items degree of popularity . interestingly , as seen in the insets of fig . [ figure-2 ] , these cumulative functions also follow a power law . the positive exponents @xmath39 and @xmath40 indicate that the newly created items are more likely to attract the attentions of active users , while the new users are more likely to be interested in popular items . the above results suggest that the users are likely to trace popular items overall , and that the active users are more likely to create new cross links than the inactive users . for users with different activity degree . * ( a ) amazon , ( b ) flickr , ( c ) delicious and ( d ) wikipedia . the users are classified into following types according to different degrees of activity , i.e. , @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 . the values of @xmath48 fluctuate significantly for large @xmath19 due to low statistics.,width=528 ] what is the influence of activity ( popularity ) degree on the intensity of users tracing popular items ( items attracting attentions of users ) ? to attack this problem , we classify the users and items into different groups according to their activity degree and popularity degree . then , we investigate the cumulative functions of relative probability @xmath42 and @xmath33 for different group of users and items , respectively . as seen from fig . [ fig3 ] , the slops of inactive users ( with smaller @xmath18 ) tracking items look qualitatively larger than those of active users . for instance , in wikipedia , the slope is 2.2 for @xmath49 , while it is 1.75 for @xmath47 . this indicates that the inactive users more severely trace popular items than the active users . moreover , as seen in the insets of fig . [ fig3 ] , the slops of unpopular items ( with smaller @xmath19 ) attracting users look slightly larger than those of popular items , indicating that the unpopular items attract a greater interest amongst active users . please note that the differences between different groups of users or items are smaller for amazon than for the other three networks . this may be due to the different spreading modes of items such as movies . for instance , a popular movie is similar to the well - known global information in the amazon user - movie network , but there is no such counterpart in the flickr user - photo , delicious user - book and wikipedia author - article networks . to provide an additional evidence for the different intensity of users tracing popular items , we also calculate the relative contribution @xmath50 of users with activity degree @xmath18 , who create some new cross links to items with popularity degree @xmath19 within one day ( see _ materials and methods _ for the detail ) . ideally , if the intensities of users tracing popular items are identical , the relative contribution ratios @xmath48 should be always equal to 1 for all group of users . as seen in fig . [ fig4 ] , the relative contribution of active users ( with larger @xmath18 ) to unpopular items ( with smaller @xmath19 ) is larger than 1 but is smaller than 1 for popular items ( with larger @xmath19 ) , indicating that the active users make higher contributions to unpopular items than average but lower to popular items than average . meanwhile , the inactive users exhibit the opposite behavior with the exception of amazon . especially in flickr and wikipedia , it is obviously found that @xmath48 increases for the most inactive users , while @xmath48 decreases for the most active users with respect to popularity degree . based on eq . ( [ rewrite ] ) , the cumulative function @xmath42 for the inactive users will increase more faster than that for the active users , indicating that the slop for inactive users is larger than that for active users ( as shown in fig . [ fig3 ] ) . furthermore , it is found that medium active users within wikipedia , e.g. , @xmath51 , make almost equivalent contributions to articles having different degree of popularity ( as shown in fig.[fig4 ] ( d ) ) , indicating that they may not care about the article s popularity when they edit them . these results also indicate that the inactive users are more likely to trace popular items than the active users , in agreement with previous observations . to further understand the mechanisms governing the evolution of real networks , we attempt to set up a theoretical model for user - item networks . our primary goal is to qualitatively reproduce the human activity and the item popularity observed in the four empirical networks previously mentioned . in the above numerical analysis , the rich - get - richer phenomenon has been observed in the growth of the user s degree of activity and the item s degree of popularity , i.e. , the active users ( the popular items ) have a higher probability of creating ( acquiring ) new cross links.the mechanism of preferential attachment has successfully explained the rich - get - richer phenomenon in previous works @xcite , but it implicitly requires global information , e.g. degree of all nodes . however , it is impossible for individuals to collect global information in real social systems . therefore , this only gives a macroscopic explanation of how a user s degree of activity and an item s degree of popularity evolve . moreover , the formation of cross links will simultaneously affect the activity degree and popularity degree . this poses an interesting question : what is the microscopic mechanism governing the growth of a user s activity degree and an item s popularity degree while giving rise to the various distribution observed ? there are two crucial questions to be considered . first , how are the users activated to create new cross links ? it is very difficult to formulate the users behaviors because human dynamics are very complicated due to the inherent diversity of real world circumstances . in the empirical analysis , the users with a larger degree of activity are more likely to create cross links . moreover , it is found that the degree of activity is positively correlated to the social degrees @xcite . in addition , the users activities are influenced by their neighbors activities as the information can spread along social links by user - to - user exchanges @xcite . therefore , we believe that the users with more friends are frequently activated as receiving more information from neighbors , and the users interested in more items are easily activated because they are very sensitive to stimuli . hence , we employ the random walk , starting from one user and via either social or cross links , to select users , who will actively create cross links . the users with more friends and more items have a greater chance of being reached by random walk . it is found that random walk might be one possible micro mechanism governing the evolution of social networks@xcite , and is equivalent to preferential attachment from a macro perspective @xcite . and popularity degree @xmath52 . ( a ) amazon , where @xmath53 , @xmath54 and @xmath55 . ( b ) flickr , where @xmath56 , @xmath57 and @xmath58 . ( c ) delicious , where @xmath53 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 . the inset is the distribution of degree of popularity for @xmath61 . ( d ) wikipedia , where @xmath62 , @xmath63 and @xmath64 . the inset is the distribution of degree of popularity for @xmath65.,width=528 ] the second question to consider is : how do the activated users access the items ? in flickr , it has been found that over 80% of new social links are formed between friends friends and over 50% of new cross links are formed between one user and his friends favorite photos @xcite . moreover , the probability of a user favorite - marking one photo increases with the number of his friends who have favorite - marked the photo @xcite , indicating that the user is influenced by his friends and reaches the photo via his friends . we therefore assume that the users access the items via their friends by two - step random walk process . it is also worth noting that the popular items are exposed to more users , so they have a higher probability of being reached by the random walk process than the unpopular items . for simplicity , we made the following assumptions in our model : ( 1 ) the users can befriend other users ( see the example of fig . [ fig1 ] ) , ( 2 ) the activated users are selected by random walk either via social or cross links , and ( 3 ) new links ( except the first links attached to newly added users and items ) are formed between one user and one of his second neighbors ( either users or items ) . in this way , the link growth process can be understand as two - step random walks via the social links or via the cross links . one way to model this network is to select the activated users who will then actively create new links . another is to select the target nodes ( either users or items ) that will passively acquire new links . in our numerical simulation , we employ a two - step random walk for simplicity . numerically , the topology evolves according to the following rules : ( 1 ) the initial network consists of a few users ( @xmath66 ) and items ( @xmath67 ) . the users form a small random social network , while the items are randomly rated by the users . ( 2 ) at each time step , one new user is added into the system and randomly connected to one user and one of items rated by the user that is being connected to . meanwhile , @xmath68 new items are added into the system , each of which is rated by one activated user selected by two - step random walk . ( 3 ) at each time step , @xmath69 users are activated by using a two - step random walk , and each of them connects to his second neighbors by a two - step random walk via common friends or via common items if they are not previously connected . ( 4 ) at each time step , @xmath70 users are activated by a two - step random walk , and each of them connects to one of items rated by his friends by a two - step random walk if he has not previously rated it . and @xmath68 on the distribution of popularity ( a ) as well as the distribution of activity ( b ) . influences of parameter @xmath69 on the distribution of activity ( c ) and the distribution of social degree ( d).,width=528 ] we carried out numerical simulations to validate the model . we set the parameters as follows : @xmath71 and @xmath72 . we then ran the simulation up to @xmath73 . based on the simple assumptions of random walk , the model can reproduce the distributions of activity degree @xmath74 and popularity degree @xmath52 observed in the above four empirical networks . in fig . [ fig5 ] , we compare the degree distributions of the model with those of the empirical networks . it is found that the distributions of the model networks are qualitatively consistent with their counterparts of the empirical networks . though the distributions of popularity degree in the model do not quantitatively match those of empirical networks as shown in figs . [ fig5 ] ( c ) and ( d ) , the slops are consistent with each other . in the insets of figs . [ fig5 ] ( c ) and ( d ) , we compare the distributions of larger degree of popularity of the model with those of the empirical networks . it is observed that they are approximately consistent with each other . these results indicate that our assumptions are reasonable that the users are activated by a two - step random walk , and subsequently find items of interest to them in the same manner . figure [ fig6 ] displays the influences of the parameters on the distributions . from fig . [ fig6 ] ( a ) , we can see that the ratio between the number of new cross links @xmath70 and the number of new items @xmath68 has an obvious influence on the distribution of popularity degree ; however , the distributions of activity degree are greatly affected by the parameter @xmath70 as seen in fig . [ fig6 ] ( b ) . furthermore , the distributions of activity degree depend on the number of new social links @xmath69 to some extent , while the distributions of social degree @xmath75 are almost independent of the number of new cross links @xmath70 and the number of new items @xmath68 . in particular , the distributions of social degree follow a power law , which is qualitatively consistent with that of flickr networks . in this study , we first carried out an empirical analysis to four empirical networks : amazon , flickr , delicious and wikipedia . our study revealed the growth patterns of the users degrees of activity and items degrees of popularity within these networks , both of which follow the law of the rich - get - richer . it was found that the users are likely to trace popular items , but the intensities are different for the users with different activity degrees . for example , the active users make a greater than average contributions to the unpopular items whereas the inactive users make a greater than average contributions to the popular items . motivated by the empirical findings in these four networks , we proposed an evolving model based on a two - step random walk , which is able to qualitatively reproduce the activity and popularity distributions observed in empirical networks . based on both the empirical analysis and the theoretical model , we believe that the information spreading amongst individuals , which is simplified as a two - step random walk in the model , could represent one possible micro mechanism governing the dynamic evolution of human activity and item popularity . of course , the dynamics of human activity and item popularity are very complicated due to the inherent diversity of human behaviors and the varying nature of items . hence , there may be other microscopic mechanisms governing the dynamics of human activity and item popularity . it should be noted that the results of our model are only qualitatively consistent with the empirical results . the quantitative mismatch is due to the simplifications in our model . for example , the users are only activated by a two - step random walk , and then reach the items by another two - step random walk via friends . in reality , the situation could be much more complicated . in the empirical networks , for example , besides the stimulus of neighbors , the occasional events can inspire users to participate in network - relating events . for instance , the users can access photos through various other channels in flickr , such as the list of interesting photos provided by the web site , the search engine , the links between similar photos and so on . furthermore , an item s particular attributes , such as being an award - winning picture , may disproportionally affect how quickly an item s popularity changes . these factors have remarkable influence on the growth of human activity and item popularity . we believe that if we consider more realistic factors in the model , we can improve the performance of our model and obtain more helpful insights in understanding the dynamics of human activity and item popularity . these problems deserve further investigations in the future . this work is supported by the fundamental research funds for the central universities under grant nos . 2012rc0707 and 2012jbm067 , national natural science foundation of china under grant nos . 61174150 , 71101009 and 61374175 , ncet-09 - 0228 and the doctoral fund of the ministry of education ( 20110003110027 ) . cha m , mislove a , gummadi k p ( 2009 ) a measurement - driven analysis of information propagation in the flickr social network . www 09 proceedings of the 18th international conference on world wide web , pp 721 - 730 . mcauley j , leskovec j ( 2013 ) from amateurs to connoisseurs : modeling the evolution of user expertise through online reviews . www 13 proceedings of the 22nd international conference on world wide web , pp 897 - 908 .

social media , regarded as two - layer networks consisting of users and items , turn out to be the most important channels for access to massive information in the era of web 2.0 . the dynamics of human activity and item popularity is a crucial issue in social media networks . in this paper , by analyzing the growth of user activity and item popularity in four empirical social media networks , i.e. , amazon , flickr , delicious and wikipedia , it is found that cross links between users and items are more likely to be created by active users and to be acquired by popular items , where user activity and item popularity are measured by the number of cross links associated with users and items . this indicates that users generally trace popular items , overall . however , it is found that the inactive users more severely trace popular items than the active users . inspired by empirical analysis , we propose an evolving model for such networks , in which the evolution is driven only by two - step random walk . numerical experiments verified that the model can qualitatively reproduce the distributions of user activity and item popularity observed in empirical networks . these results might shed light on the understandings of micro dynamics of activity and popularity in social media networks .

1210.2908

complex networks @xcite may be affected by structural perturbations that modify their behavior or even lead to their collapse . of all potential structural perturbations , the removal of individual nodes has received most attention . it has been found that complex networks are robust to accidental failures , yet fragile to targeted attacks knocking down their most connected nodes @xcite . a similar approach has been applied in biology to metabolic networks which , as compared to other large - scale cellular networks , prove to be of particular interest due to the availability of high quality reconstructions based on complementary sources of experimental data , and due to the possibility of experimentally validating computational predictions @xcite . metabolic networks , modeled as complex networks @xcite , have been tested in terms of robustness in a wide variety of in silico experiments . typical _ in silico _ strategies to quantify _ structural robustness _ of metabolic networks against removal of a single reaction consider the downstream effect of the removal and the size of the resulting cascade . properties of the cascade , e.g. , size or length , could then be considered as proxies for the potential damage inflicted by the removal . finally , one would like to obtain estimates for the statistical significance of the obtained observations , which could be empirically carried out with respect to a well - chosen null model . for instance , by applying this strategy in combination with degree preserving randomization ( see sections 2.2 and 2.3 ) , smart and coworkers @xcite have determined that bacterial organisms may have evolved towards reducing the probability of having large cascades , thus , increasing robustness . recently , more complicated perturbations have also been considered , namely , removal of pairs of reactions and sets of genes @xcite , and the topological significance of the results was evaluated with respect to degree preserving randomization . the employed degree preserving null model has its roots in the configuration model @xcite for bipartite networks @xcite , that results in randomized network variants in which node degrees are preserved . however , such a degree preserving randomization does not account for the most basic physico - chemical constraints , and may lead , in the case of metabolic networks , to consideration of a reaction which is not mass ( i.e. , stoichiometrically ) balanced ( a reaction which does not preserve the same type and number of atoms on its substrate and product sides ) . as a result , the randomized networks may not be chemically feasible . as an alternative , a novel null model called mass - balanced randomization has been recently proposed @xcite to account for this issue . mass - balanced randomization results in randomized network variants in which : ( 1 ) every reaction is mass balanced and ( 2 ) degrees of reactions are unaltered . by comparing the differences between the analyzed property in the original network and in its randomized variant , this null model is able to distinguish between properties which result solely from physico - chemical constraints and those selected for by evolutionary pressure @xcite . here we explore the metabolic networks of _ staphylococcus aureus _ @xcite and _ escherichia coli _ @xcite to determine the extent to which the robustness against the failure of individual reactions and pairs of reactions , as quantified by the number of non - viable reactions caused upon the initial removal(s ) of a single reaction or a pair of reactions , is bounded by structural constraints . to this end , we compare cascades in the original networks with those obtained from the two null models referred above : degree preserving ( dp ) and mass - balanced ( mb ) randomization . we find that the two null models give very different results , which is explained in terms of the properties of the networks obtained by both randomization methods . we use kolmogorov - smirnov tests @xcite to statistically assess whether the null models are enough to explain the resulting damage distributions in the original networks . interestingly , we find that the two organisms exhibit cascades whose properties lie between those expected from the two considered null models , which suggest that factors other than node degrees or physical principles affect the considered features . moreover , our findings point out that , in the analyzed metabolic networks , evolutionary pressure may not have lead towards minimized damage spreading , which opposes earlier findings based solely on degree preserving randomization . our results reinforce the importance of choosing an appropriate null model according to the question at hand , since the null model ultimately affects the interpretation of the findings . we have modeled metabolic networks as bipartite graphs @xcite , whereby the set of nodes is portioned into metabolites and reactions , and there are no links between nodes of the same type . metabolites are connected to the reactions by directed links , which allow differentiating between reactants and products . every reversible reaction is split into two irreversible reaction nodes , so that every reaction node included in the representation corresponds to an irreversible reaction . we use two different bacterial organisms in this study . _ e. coli _ is the most studied prokaryotic organism and it is the bacterial model which is most frequently used due to ease of experimental manipulation . to construct the bipartite representation of the metabolic network of _ @xcite , we use data from the bigg database . the resulting network contains @xmath0 reactions and @xmath1 metabolites . _ s. aureus _ is an anaerobic bacterium which is present world - wide . its bipartite directed network reconstruction was obtained from @xcite , and consists of @xmath2 reactions and @xmath3 metabolites . the networks of the two analyzed species show marked similarities with respect to the cumulative degree distributions . for metabolites , the degree distribution shows a typical power - law form , @xmath4 , with an exponent @xmath5 for _ s. aureus _ and @xmath6 for _ e. coli_. on the contrary , reactions show a peaked distribution centered at the average degree corresponding to each network , having a value of @xmath7 for _ s. aureus _ and a value of @xmath8 for _ e. coli_. a cascading failure algorithm @xcite is applied to spread the initial perturbation through the network and to compute the corresponding damage . crucial to the algorithm are the concepts of viable metabolites and reactions . a metabolite is considered viable if it has at least one incoming and one outgoing connection , so as to prevent depletion or accumulation . this structural condition is a prerequisite for the network as a whole to operate at a positive steady state . on the other hand , reactions are viable if and only if all of the participating metabolites are viable . the algorithm then starts with a network from which an initial set of reactions is removed . in the following step , all reactions and metabolites that , as a consequence , become non - viable are removed , which in its turn results in additional changes of the viability status of the nodes . when only viable reactions and metabolites remain in the network , the damage inflicted by the initial perturbation is quantified as the final number of non - viable reactions ( see figure [ fig:1 ] ) . here , we consider perturbations by initially removing every single reaction and each pair of reactions . and 7 and 8 with @xmath9 depending on whether they are reactants or products of the reversible reaction . the cascade starts when reaction @xmath10 fails . b ) therefore , metabolites 3 and 6 become non - viable . because metabolite 6 is connected to reaction @xmath11 , the later becomes non - viable , turning also metabolite 12 non - viable . notice that metabolite 11 loses one _ in _ connection , but it is still viable , meaning that one of the waves of the cascade stops here . however the other wave keeps spreading . c ) metabolite 5 becomes inviable , causing the reversible reaction @xmath12 to remain viable only towards the production of metabolites 7 and 8 . e ) consequently , metabolite 4 becomes non - viable , and so its associated reactions also become non - viable . the cascade spreads until all metabolites and reactions affected by the cascade remain viable . finally , note that metabolites 1 , 2 , 3 , 13 , and 14 , which initially have no incoming or outgoing connections , are not considered inviable by the algorithm.,scaledwidth=57.0% ] benchmark cascades are computed by first randomizing the original network and then performing the cascade algorithm on the randomized version . for each of the two null models , damage distributions are obtained for a hundred realizations , then averaged , and finally compared to the original damage distribution to assess the statistical significance and quantitative behavior of the observation . the degree preserving randomization method approximates the configuration model for bipartite networks @xcite and works as follows . a pair of links of the network is chosen at random and their targets are swapped , unless this would lead to the repeated occurrence of a metabolite in a reaction . the randomization algorithm is summarized as follows : 1 . pick two links at random : @xmath13 and @xmath14 or @xmath15 and @xmath16 . 2 . swap the end of the links avoiding repeated links and self - production : ( @xmath17 and @xmath18 or @xmath19 and @xmath20 ) . 3 . repeat until we perform @xmath21 swappings , where @xmath22 is the total number of links . 4 . make several realizations of the randomized metabolic network following the three previous steps . the links from reversible reactions are rewired independently of those from irreversible reactions , using the same steps previously mentioned , in order to preserve the degrees of metabolites corresponding to reversible and irreversible reactions , respectively . a scheme showing this algorithm is shown in figure [ fig:2 ] . it is easy to show that the networks obtained using this method preserve the degrees of both metabolites and reactions , as illustrated in figure [ fig:1b ] . mass - balanced randomization generates randomized networks by rewiring the links corresponding to substrate - reaction or product - reaction relationships , while preserving atomic mass balance of the reactions @xcite . given a reaction @xmath23 , its atomic mass balance is given by:@xmath24 where @xmath25 is the set of substrates and @xmath26 the set of products in @xmath23 , @xmath27 are the vectors of sum formulas of @xmath28 and @xmath29 , respectively , and @xmath30 , @xmath31 their stoichiometric coefficients . for instance , consider the reaction @xmath32 , with @xmath33 @xmath34 @xmath35 . then , @xmath36 may be substituted by a compound @xmath37 with @xmath38 from within the network , resulting in the randomized reaction 2 @xmath39 , which satisfies equation [ eq : mass_balance ] since @xmath40 ( figure [ fig:2 ] ) . in addition to substituting individual substrates or products , the method also allows more complex substitutions involving pairs of substrates or products , yielding a large number of possible substitutions . the motivation for preserving atomic mass balance of reactions , a fundamental physico - chemical constraint , is that the resulting null model allows estimating the importance of network properties with respect to evolutionary pressure . as biological systems and their properties evolve under physical constraints and evolutionary pressure , a null model which satisfies physical principles but does not account for evolutionary pressure differs from a metabolic network only in the properties which are affected by evolutionary pressure . thus , a property deemed statistically significant following mass - balanced randomization is beyond basic physical constraints and likely to be a result of evolutionary pressure @xcite . again , a hundred randomized networks are generated from a given metabolic network . the method preserves mass balance and reaction degrees , while the stoichiometric coefficients and metabolite degrees are changed ( figure [ fig:1b]a , b ) . , @xmath41 ) , where @xmath42 is the metabolite / reaction degree in the original network , and @xmath41 the corresponding degree in a randomized network . points fall in the diagonal if degrees are preserved in the randomized networks . a ) mass - balanced randomization ( mb ) . this method gives networks in which the degrees of the reactions are preserved . however , b ) degrees of metabolites are not conserved . c ) degree preserving randomization ( dp ) . this method gives networks with preserved degrees of reactions . d ) degrees of metabolites are also preserved with degree preserving randomization , however at the expense of violating mass balances of reactions.,scaledwidth=85.0% ] first , we study cascades triggered by individual removal of reactions , from @xmath43 to @xmath44 . we define the size of a cascade , @xmath45 , or damage caused by the removal of a reaction @xmath23 as the number of resulting non - viable reactions . the cumulative probability distributions @xmath46 give the probabilities that a damage is at least as large as @xmath45 , and may be interpreted as a measure of the robustness of a network with respect to reaction removal . we determined the cumulative probability distributions of damage in the two metabolic networks under analysis in this study and compared them to the averaged distributions associated to their randomized variants from degree preserving and mass - balanced randomization ( figure [ fig:3 ] ) . all distributions show a similar power - law distribution , with an exponential cut - off indicating possible finite size effects . the detected heterogeneity indicates that the failure of most reactions results in small damage , while some specific reactions affect large parts of the corresponding network , which is in agreement with the robustness previously attributed to metabolic networks @xcite . however , here we observe that the same trend also holds for the randomized networks , both from degree preserving and mass - balanced randomization . thus , the heterogeneous behavior of the damage distributions is a general feature which is not specific to metabolic networks , and thus insufficient to explain robustness of metabolism . instead , when comparing the distributions of damages between the original and randomized networks , we observe that the distributions of the original networks lie in between the distributions of the two null models . particularly , in both organisms , damages are smaller compared to their degree preserving randomizations , but larger when compared to their mass - balanced randomizations . thus , the robustness of the analyzed networks can not be explained by the distribution of degrees or by basic physical constraints . for the dp null model , this finding indicates that robustness is positively influenced by factors which are independent of the degrees . the results from the mb null model suggest that evolutionary pressure leads to larger cascades of non - viable reactions , and thus lower robustness ( see discussion ) . at first glance , the damage distributions of the original networks seem to closely resemble those of the mass - balanced randomized networks . to check whether or not the cumulative probability distributions significantly differ between the original networks and their randomized variants , we perform kolmogorov - smirnov tests @xcite ( table [ fig : t1 ] ) . the null hypothesis is that the two samples are drawn from the same distribution , which is rejected if the obtained @xmath29-value is no greater than the standard significance level @xmath47 . in this case , the compared distributions are considered significantly different . & mb&dp&mb&dp + & @xmath48/@xmath49&@xmath50/@xmath51&@xmath52/@xmath49&@xmath53/@xmath49 + _ e. coli_&@xmath48/@xmath49&@xmath54/@xmath55&@xmath56/@xmath49&@xmath57/@xmath49 + in the following , we analyze failure cascades resulting from the removal of each possible pair of reactions , where both @xmath23 and @xmath58 run from @xmath59 to @xmath60 ( @xmath61 ) . similar to the previous section , we determine the cumulative probability distributions @xmath62 of the damage @xmath63 resulting from the knockout of two reactions @xmath23 and @xmath58 , which provides a measure for the robustness of a network with respect to the failure of reaction pairs ( figure [ fig:3 ] ) . both organisms _ e. coli _ and _ s. aureus _ display again similar results : the distributions of damages in the real networks show a power - law behavior followed by an exponential cut - off . however , in this case the transition is more accentuated . the distributions of the original networks lie again between the distributions of the two null models . consequently , our observations from section 3.1 also hold for the failure of reaction pairs : robustness is positively influenced by factors independent of the degrees , but negatively influenced by evolutionary pressure . kolmogorov - smirnov tests were applied in order to test if the distributions given by the null models differ from those in the original network ( table [ fig : t1 ] ) . as for individual removal of reactions , we chose a threshold value of @xmath47 . again , the distributions of the original networks are significantly different from those of both randomization methods , with @xmath29-values of @xmath49 . the obtained results reveal important findings by comparing the damage caused by the failure of single and pairs of reactions in the original metabolic networks to those measured in the randomized variants . the cascade algorithm produces larger damages in the original networks as compared to those in mass - balanced randomized networks , but smaller cascades as compared to those in degree preserving randomized counterparts . a possible explanation is offered by the difference in global properties of the networks obtained from the two randomization methods @xcite . degree preserving randomization decreases the average path length and increases the clustering coefficient of the randomized network , increasing its small - world property . consequently , such networks are more interconnected , and thus a cascade may in principle propagate further in the network . the opposite holds for mass - balanced randomization , which increases the average path length while decreasing the clustering coefficient of the randomized network , so that the spread of the damage is less likely . although the average path length does not resemble the length of metabolic inter - conversion , the small - world property may still affect the impact of removal of reactions due to its functional importance . in tables [ fig : t1 ] , the significance levels obtained by the kolmogorov - smirnov test show that all distributions obtained from the null models are significantly different from those observed in the original networks . the distributions , though visually similar to the original networks , differ significantly between the original and randomized networks . the fact that the damage distributions of the original networks differ significantly from those in the degree preserved randomized versions allow us to conclude that other properties beyond the degrees are important for determining the size of cascades in the original networks . we also point out that the principle of cascade propagation relies on violation of a structural precondition for a steady - state , namely that all metabolites can be produced and consumed in order to avoid their depletion or accumulation . however , the steady - state assumption is only meaningful for networks which satisfy fundamental physical principles . we therefore also employed mass - balanced randomization , which guarantees preservation of mass - balance , and thus allows us to discern whether the measured property is a result of basic physical principles , or , instead , whether it is affected by evolutionary pressure . since the size of cascades in mass - balanced randomized networks is significantly lower than those in real networks , evolutionary pressure may indeed lead to larger cascades . consequently , this finding indicates that evolutionary pressure may favor lower robustness of metabolic networks with respect to the failure of reactions , seemingly contradicting the general requirement of robustness in biological systems . however , on one hand , this finding may be a result of the evolutionary versatility of metabolic networks , which favors organisms that are able to evolve quickly , i.e. , by few modifications to their metabolic networks . on the other hand , we point out that a cascade may not only be interpreted as the harmful spreading of failure , but also as the ability to regulate metabolism by activating / deactivating reactions , e.g. , by transcriptional regulation @xcite . thus , large cascades , favored by evolutionary pressure , may point at the evolutionary requirement of regulating large parts of metabolism , such as pathways , through the regulation of small sets of enzyme - coding genes . the ability to regulate the activity of metabolic reactions by deactivating competing reactions is a well - known principle of metabolism . our results thus indicate that evolutionary pressure favors the ability of efficient metabolic regulation at the expense of robustness to gene knockouts , pointing at the necessary integration of trade - offs from various cellular functions . this work is supported by micinn projects no . fis2010 - 21924-c02 - 01 and bfu2010 - 21847-c02 - 02 ; generalitat de catalunya grant no . 2009sgr1055 ; the ramn y cajal program of the spanish ministry of science , the fpu grant of the spanish ministry of science , and the max planck society .

complex networks have been shown to be robust against random structural perturbations , but vulnerable against targeted attacks . robustness analysis usually simulates the removal of individual or sets of nodes , followed by the assessment of the inflicted damage . for complex metabolic networks , it has been suggested that evolutionary pressure may favor robustness against reaction removal . however , the removal of a reaction and its impact on the network may as well be interpreted as selective regulation of pathway activities , suggesting a tradeoff between the efficiency of regulation and vulnerability . here , we employ a cascading failure algorithm to simulate the removal of single and pairs of reactions from the metabolic networks of two organisms , and estimate the significance of the results using two different null models : degree preserving and mass - balanced randomization . our analysis suggests that evolutionary pressure promotes larger cascades of non - viable reactions , and thus favors the ability of efficient metabolic regulation at the expense of robustness .

0906.2793

350 has been the subject of many studies in the optical / near infrared and radio regimes and most wavelengths in between . it is highly obscured at short wavelengths and bright at long wavelengths . the object was originally part of the planetary nebulae survey of @xcite , but was later reclassified as an region . @xcite observed 350 at mid infrared wavelengths and showed the optical nebula was offset from the radio source due to a strong gradient in the foreground extinction . @xcite determined precise offsets between the radio , infrared and optical sources which validate the @xcite model . 350 , also known as the galactic radio source g70.31.6 , has been extensively observed at long wavelengths . @xcite provided a high angular resolution map at 2 cm which resolved the ionized gas into a clumpy arc like or shell like structure on scales smaller than 1@xmath1 . @xcite included this object in their catalog of regions , describing it as a core halo type while @xcite observed the larger nebula in the continuum and radio recombination line h76@xmath4 . the radio morphology is extended in two lobes to the nw and se and @xcite found a velocity gradient along the lobes which led them to suggest the structure was an ionized outflow extending 10 s of arcseconds from the center of the region . @xcite presented br@xmath3 and br@xmath4 emission line maps at greater than arcsecond resolution and followed this work @xcite with molecular line maps which they modeled as arising from a large scale molecular torus ( roughly perpendicular to the ionized outflow of * ? ? ? * ) . more recent work has centered on near infrared and mid infrared wavelengths and higher angular resolution data . @xcite observed the nebula in the @xmath0band using speckle techniques to provide an order of magnitude higher angular resolution than previous near infrared work , and @xcite used the subaru 8 m telescpe and mid infrared imager comics to obtain 0.5@xmath1 resolution images and spectra near 10 . in this paper , we present @xmath0band integral field spectroscopy of 350 obtained on the gemini north 8 m telescope with the near infrared integral field spectrograph . these data were taken in conjunction with the facility adaptive optics system and result in the most detailed data cube yet for the core of 350 . in an earlier paper @xcite , we presented similar data for the region [email protected] . in that case , several massive stars were identified by photospheric lines and other objects showed signatures of buried massive young stellar objects . [email protected] clearly harbors a rich cluster . @xcite make similar conclusions based on their eso vlt sinfoni integral field spectrograph observations for the region in the cluster [ dbs2003]8 . previous investigators have suggested the same may be true of 350 : @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . our data identify multiple continuum sources in 350 and support the multiple star model , but we also show that the excitation in the central few arcseconds of 350 is likely dominated by a single object ( the unresolved continuum peak ) . in the following , the distance to the nebula is based on the work of @xcite . the @xcite distance is derived from a compilation of velocities and a rotation model ; harris distance needs to be reduced due to a revised distance to the galactic center ( * ? ? ? * used a distance of 10 kpc ) . adopting a value of 8 kpc gives a reduction by a factor of 0.8 resulting in a distance to the region of about 7 kpc . data were obtained with the near infrared integral field spectrograph ( nifs ) at the cassegrain focus of the gemini north fredrick c. gillett 8m telescope on mauna kea , hawaii on the night of 20 july , 2006 ( hst ) . nifs was used with the facility adaptive optics ( ao ) module altair in natural guide star ( ngs ) mode . nifs is fully described by @xcite ; see also @xcite for a more detailed description of similar observations with nifs as described here . briefly , nifs slices an approximately three arc second by three arc second field into 29 spectral segments of 0.1@xmath1 width ( the `` slit '' width ) and @xmath6 3@xmath1 in length . the scale along the spatial dimension is 0.043@xmath1 pix@xmath7 . the resulting `` spaxels , '' or spatial pixels , are thus 0.043@xmath1 @xmath8 0.1@xmath1 in size , and each contains a full spectrum covering one of the near infrared bands . in the present paper , @xmath0band spectra are presented for the galactic region 350 . the ao guide star used for altair is located 10.2@xmath1 to the south and west of 350 and has an @xmath9 magnitude of 12.7 according to the usno catalog ( source i d : u1200_14213688 ) . there was thin cirrus at the time of the observations , and the seeing ( at 5000 , corrected to zenith ) reported during the observations by altair was approximately 0.45@xmath1 . the observations were obtained at relatively high airmass ( 1.5 ) , and altair was run at 500 hz . the observations consisted of a single coadded frame taken on source and a second frame obtained on a nearby ( @xmath6 50@xmath1 west ) blank field . each frame had a total exposure time of 600 seconds ( 15@xmath840s ) on source and 600 seconds on sky . nifs was oriented with a position ( pa ) of 70 degrees east of north to correspond approximately to the orientation of the large scale ionized flow from 350 @xcite . this pa is aligned with the outflow direction . the spectral resolving power of nifs in the @xmath0band is @xmath10 5160 which results in a linear dispersion of 2.13 / pixel . this dispersion , combined with the large format array gives a full wavelength coverage at @xmath11 of about 4200 accounting for some minor truncation in the final data cube due to the systematic shift of wavelength in each slitlet from the staircase design of the image slicer . the line maps and spectra presented here were obtained using the gemini nifs iraf data reduction package ( version 1.9 ) . the nifs iraf package allows for full reduction to the `` image cube '' stage where a final cube has a roughly 60@xmath862 pixel image plane and a 2040 pixel spectral depth . first , raw images are prepared for reduction by standard gemini procedures that create the fits image variance and data quality extensions . next , the data are sky subtracted , flatfielded , rectified spatially , and wavelength calibrated ( see * ? ? ? * for a full description of these steps ) . the last two steps result in a uniform spatial spectral trace for each image slice row and a linear wavelength scale . it is important to remember that the final iraf data cube resamples each slitlet to two 0.05@xmath1 pixels for convenience ; the angular resolution in this dimension is still 0.1@xmath1 . a lamp image of ar and xe lines was used to determine the dispersion along each slice and as a function of the spatial dimension of each slice . a quadratic polynomial was used in this case which produced typical uncertainties in the position of a spectral line of approximately @xmath2 0.2 ( @xmath6 1/10 pixel ) . final spectra are interpolated to a linear wavelength solution . the spectra were next corrected for telluric absorption by division by the spectrum of an a0 v star ( hip 102568 ) . the spectrum of hip 102568 was corrected for intrinsic br@xmath3 absorption by fitting a voigt profile to the telluric spectrum . particular care was taken in the fit in order to remove this feature from the telluric standard as accurately as possible . the final wavelength calibrated , spatially rectified , and telluric corrected images were transformed into data cubes . the spatial pixel scale was resampled to 0.05@xmath1 in the fine dimension and block replicated to 0.05@xmath1 in the course dimension providing for a uniform scale as described in the previous section . line maps presented below were extracted from these cubes using nfmap . the zero point of the wavelength calibration is confirmed by the positions of oh airglow lines in the sky image . analysis of these lines shows the zero point is accurate to @xmath2 2.5 . the calibration results in an observed blueshift of the nebular lines of approximately 3.8 ( 1.8 pixels or @xmath1253 ) . lines are identified on a spectrum extracted from a 2.5@xmath1 diameter aperture centered on the nifs fov ; see figure [ spec ] . the spectrum is flux calibrated using the results of ( * ? ? ? * see below ) . the line positions and relative strengths compared to br@xmath3 for this integrated spectrum are given in table 1 . an image of the continuum near 21700 is shown in figure [ c217 ] along with the radio continuum image from @xcite . the continuum passband extracted was 9 pixels ( 19.2 ) wide . the appearance of sources in our continuum image is similar to the speckle @xmath0band image presented by @xcite who report an angular resolution of 0.11@xmath1 in their image derived from observations obtaddiained under 1.1@xmath1 seeing . @xcite identify 10 point sources in their image , though some of these appear more extended than others , and this is consistent with the continuum image shown in figure [ c217 ] . the brightest source in figure [ c217 ] is source # 1 of @xcite . the size of the most compact source in our image , source # 8 of @xcite , is about 3.7 pixels in the fine sampling direction suggesting a fwhm of 0.19@xmath1 . source # 1 is more extended than this in the present image ( @xmath6 4.9 pixels ) , but this is due to crowding with nearby blended sources and the intense nebular emission surrounding it . @xcite report source # 1 to be `` point like . '' the 10 sources identified by @xcite are clearly seen in figure [ c217 ] with the possible exception of their source # 2 which is close to source # 1 and not obvious in our image . the @xcite sources are indicated by filled circles in figure [ c217 ] . an additional point source ( named `` 8n '' ) appears near @xmath13 which is indicated by a single contour in figure 2 of @xcite . in addition to these objects , there are other knots or clumps which might contain embedded sources , or may be density enhancements in the region . these clumps appear to match well the morphology in figure 1 of @xcite . an exception is the `` x - like '' structure centered on source # 1 described by @xcite . we see no evidence of this feature in the lower contours of the nebular emission even though similarly bright clumps from the @xcite image do show up in our image . the mid infrared images of @xcite also do not show this feature , though diffraction spikes from the telescope secondary are present in their images . @xcite identified four bright sources in the core region of 350 covered by figure [ c217 ] in 913 images with somewhat lower angular resolution . the three brightest , okym13 , were unresolved as individual point sources . okym3 was associated with source # 1 by @xcite . the source labeled stho1 in figure [ c217 ] is the peak of [ ] emission in the maps of @xcite . these authors suggest stho1 is the location of an embedded massive star . there is no obvious point source in our continuum image or the @xmath0band image of @xcite at this position . the diamonds in figure [ c217 ] indicate the mid infrared sources identified by @xcite . the offsets between these sources ( okym 14 and stho1 ) are taken from @xcite and the postion of okym 3 is assumed to coincide with source # 1 ( also assumed to be the case by * ? ? ? @xcite identified a @xmath0band source with each of these @xcite sources within the positional uncertainties of the mid infrared image . these sources are the obvious ones in figure [ c217 ] near each of the okym sources . the continuum subtracted br@xmath3 emission is shown in figure [ brgmap ] . @xcite present narrow band brackett imaging . their data are seeing limited and do not resolve any of the structure shown in figure [ brgmap ] . @xcite report a br@xmath3 flux of 3.7@xmath810@xmath14 erg @xmath15 s@xmath7 in a 3.4@xmath1 aperture centered on the br@xmath3 peak in their images . this covers approximately the nifs field of view . equating this flux to the total counts in an approximately 2.5@xmath1 aperture results in a peak intensity ( one pixel ) of 5.5@xmath810@xmath16 erg @xmath15 s@xmath7 pix@xmath7 or 2.2@xmath810@xmath14 erg @xmath15 s@xmath7 arcsec@xmath17 . the peak br@xmath3 emission is to the sw of the continuum peak , although there is a second peak nearly as strong and very compact ( point like , superposed on extended emission ) centered on the continuum peak ( source # 1 ) . the @xcite sources # 4#7 are also centered on local br@xmath3 peaks . the rest of the @xcite continuum sources are offset from nearby local br@xmath3 emission peaks . 1 emission follows the br@xmath3 emission closely . the left panel of figure [ ratio ] shows the ratio of to br@xmath3 for the 1 @xmath18p@xmath19@xmath18s line at 21127 . the ratio is remarkably uniform over most of the fov and has a value of approximately 0.04 ( uncorrected for extinction ) . this value , which would be larger in the absence of extinction , already suggests a hot star ( s ) with effective temperature 40000 k @xcite . the stronger 1 line , @xmath20s@xmath20p@xmath19 at 20587 , is not uniform , however , in comparison to br@xmath3 ( see the right panel of figure [ ratio ] and discussion in 5.2.3 ) . figure [ spec ] shows that strong emission from multiply ionized species exist in the region . these include [ ] , [ ] , and [ ] . the first and last are the strongest lines apart from 1 and br@xmath3 . figure [ feiii ] shows the line maps for two of these lines . the [ ] emission is clumpy and peaks on the source okym4 while the [ ] emission is more intense and somewhat more concentrated to the central `` rectangle '' or `` diamond '' . the [ ] emission has a maximum at the continuum peak ( @xmath120.2 , 0.6 ) which is unresolved ( i.e. compact ) . the [ ] emission also has a local maximum at the continuum peak , but it appears to be affected by one or more bad pixels at the very center . these lines ( including [ ] ) appear to be common in ; see @xcite and @xcite . the ionization potentials of , , , , , and are 30.7 , 54.8 , 37.0 , 52.5 , 30.8 , and 42.9 ev , respectively . this suggests that the region with strong [ ] emission corresponds with ( for which there are no identified lines ) . the range of species seen is consistent with the presence of recombination lines ( ionization potential @xmath21 24.4 ev ) and the lack of recombination lines ( ionization potential @xmath21 54.4 ev ) . molecular hydrogen emission is also detected ( see figure [ spec ] and table 1 ) . the strongest line is the v@xmath2110 s(1 ) line at 21218 . a map of the line is shown in figure [ h2 ] with the contours of the br@xmath3 emission overlaid . the projection of the h@xmath22 emission seems to follow the ionized emission with the peak emission coincident with the br@xmath3 peak . there is a local maximum at the position of the continuum peak as well . the location and excitation of the h@xmath22 emission are discussed further in 5.4 . figure [ velmap ] shows the measured br@xmath3 line center velocity ( in ) for the entire fov . the mean observed br@xmath3 velocity of @xmath1250 has been subtracted to show relative velocity differences in this map . this mean corresponds to a velocity with respect to the local standard of rest ( lsr ) @xmath23 @xmath21 @xmath1262.5 @xmath2 5 . the velocities are overplotted with the br@xmath3 emission contours . each spatial pixel in the br@xmath3 map was fit with a gaussian profile over a restricted velocity range of @xmath12250 to 50 . this choice was made so that the 1 line at 21642 ( see table 2 ) did not interfere with the continuum fit . the velocity map shown in figure [ velmap ] was made with a modified version of the euro3d program @xcite produced by one of us ( pjm ) and called nf3d . the br@xmath3 velocity map shows a @xmath6 @xmath2 25 range in velocity centroids . this should be compared with our fwhm velocity resolution of @xmath6 60 . two br@xmath3 emission clumps are apparent in figure [ velmap ] . these are separated by 1@xmath1 @xmath12 2@xmath1 and oriented approximately at a position angle of 45 degrees . a single gaussian provides an adequate fit to the br@xmath3 emission over the entire fov . however , as we show in the following section , there is a broad blue wing to the emission near the continuum peak . in what follows , we call the single gaussian fit to the bright component of the line `` the principal component . '' when two gaussians are fit to spaxels near the continuum peak , the effect is to redshift the principal component by a further @xmath6 5 in this vicinity . the continuum peak is not located near any point of symmetry with respect to the velocity distribution . the nearest possible point source to the apparent center of the velocity distribution ( figure [ c217 ] ) is stho1 which was not detected in our continuum map . this source is only detected in the mid infrared [ ] map of @xcite and not in any continuum image presented here or by @xcite or @xcite . the region k350a exhibits a rich 1 spectrum in the @xmath0band . table 2 lists the 1 lines detected and their properties . using the on line data base compiled by peter van hoofpeter / atomic/ ; the on line database uses data from @xcite . ] ; 13 lines are identified between 20000 and 22300 . other lines redward of 22300 may be blended with the pfund series ( figure [ spec ] ) . multiple lines are present in the region around b@xmath3 . figure [ detail ] shows spectra extracted from individual spaxels at a typical location @xmath6 1.3@xmath1 se of the continuum peak ( figure [ spec ] , left panel ) and a location @xmath6 0.2@xmath1 se of the continuum peak ( figure [ spec ] , right panel ) . five gaussian functions have been fit simultaneously to these features using the spectral analysis program liner . good fits with rms residuals of @xmath24 1@xmath25 have typically been achieved by assuming that all five lines have the same fwhm as br@xmath3 ( figure [ spec ] , left panel ) . poorer fits with rms residuals of @xmath6 3@xmath25 are obtained in the region within @xmath6 0.5@xmath1 of the continuum peak where the br@xmath3 line has a strong blue wing ( e.g. , figure [ spec ] , right panel ) . the gaussian component fit to this wing has a central wavelength ( which is a fit parameter ) that is close to that of the @xmath26 @xmath20f@xmath19@xmath20d , @xmath18f@xmath19@xmath18d 21655 line ( see table 2 ) . however , this line is expected to be too weak to account for the blue wing near the continuum peak . in fact , based on atomic data used in the cloudy photoionization code @xcite , the 21655 line is expected to be weaker than the @xmath27 @xmath20f@xmath19@xmath20 g , @xmath18f@xmath19@xmath18 g 21647 line that is apparent in figure [ spec ] . better fits are obtained for spaxels near the continuum peak if the fwhm of the blue wing component is allowed to vary . rms residuals of @xmath24 1@xmath25 are then obtained with a gaussian fwhm that is about twice as broad as the principal br@xmath3 line . there is no apparent reason why the 21655 line should be anomalously strong and have a width twice that of other lines . we therefore conclude that the blue wing on br@xmath3 is due to a mix of a second kinematic component of br@xmath3 that dominates in a small region near the continuum peak and weaker emission that occurs over most of the fov . it is interesting that neither the peak emission nor the width of this second kinematic component is centered on the continuum peak . instead , this emission forms an arc that is offset se of the continuum peak by @xmath24 0.5@xmath1 . whatever the source of the broad component , the contribution of the lines near 21600 make a significant contribution to the integrated `` br@xmath3 '' flux . for the spaxel shown in figure [ detail ] , the broad line produces 50@xmath25 of the corresponding br@xmath3 flux . @xcite measured the optical , near infrared , and mid infrared positions of 350 with respect to the radio continuum @xcite using background stars as a reference . the @xcite position is consistent with later radio positions including the high angular resolution study of @xcite , and thus , to our knowledge , the @xcite positions are still the best available . more recent studies have assumed the near and mid infrared peaks are coincident with the radio continuum peak @xcite . @xcite find that the 2.2 and 10 peaks are coincident , within the @xmath6 1@xmath1 uncertainties , with the radio continuum peak . the optical and 1.6 peaks are located to the south west of the radio peak , and this is consistent with an extinction gradient across 350 as suggested by @xcite and @xcite and found also by @xcite . @xcite observed 350 in the radio continuum ( 15 ghz ) and in the h76@xmath4 recombination line . the angular resolution of these data is about 1.5@xmath1 . the continuum appears to be extended along an axis with pa ( e from n ) of 160 degrees and there is a strong velocity gradient from nw to se along the extended continuum source ( see also * ? ? ? this has led to the accepted model of an ionized outflow along the 160 degree axis . the nifs continuum is shown superposed with the @xcite radio continuum image in figure [ c217 ] . the two images have been aligned assuming the radio and @xmath0band continuum peaks are coincident . the large difference in scale and angular resolution are apparent . the overlay is instructive for the following discussion , but there are no obvious connections which can be drawn between features in the two maps . molecular line studies have been used to argue that there is a rotating torus of material with major axis roughly coincident with and perpendicular to the radio source . low angular resolution co data and modeling of hco@xmath28 line emission suggests this material may be rotating about an axis parallel to the outflow axis . @xcite first drew attention to a possible link between their ionized outflow and the molecular gas traced by co line emission @xcite , though they cautioned that the low angular resolution of the co data ( 30@xmath1 ) and the marginal evidence for a velocity gradient along its major axis made any link between the two structures `` premature . '' later , @xcite used observations of hco@xmath28 to argue for a rotating torus roughly perpendicular to the ionized outflow . the peak lobes of hco@xmath28 emission are separated by 8@xmath1 , so the scale of the rotating molecular torus is larger than the fov covered by nifs . the velocity difference measured between the peaks of the hco@xmath28 is @xmath6 @xmath2 2 , and the best fit to the velocity profile was found to be proportional to the square root of the radius . higher angular resolution observations were made by @xcite in the mid infrared ( near 10 ) and by @xcite in the @xmath0band ( 2.2 ) . the former observations were diffraction limited based on the 0.4@xmath1 fwhm obtained on standard stars , but the images of 350 do not clearly separate individual objects owing to intense resolved structure / emission and blended point sources . @xcite fit various point sources ( figure [ c217 ] ) to their data . the @xcite images , on the other hand , were obtained with a speckle imaging technique and are of similar angular resolution as the data presented here . the higher angular resolution and lower background emission result in more identifiable point sources within the central few arcseconds of 350 . @xcite and @xcite conclude that 350 contains multiple massive stars ; the former through excitation measurements of mid - infrared ionized lines and the latter based on the detection of multiple point sources in the center of the region . the nifs data confirm various aspects of the earlier work , principally the @xmath0band morphology of the point sources and brighter clumps of emission which are dominated by br@xmath3 . the @xmath0band image of @xcite , the @xcite mid infrared images , and our nifs images all indicate an abrupt cutoff in emission to the north of the bright continuum peak . the gradient is extremely sharp and the emission drops precipitously in 0.5@xmath1 towards the north of the region . the gradient in extinction was noted in earlier work ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) but is seen very clearly in the @xmath29 and @xmath11 images of @xcite . the center of the emission shifts systematically to the south . this geometry has been described as an opening cone with the continuum peak at the cone s apex @xcite and the opening toward the south south east . the dense molecular torus @xcite and other overlying material form the cone structure by obscuring ionized material to the north ; see figure 7 of @xcite . the constraining effect of the torus may be responsible for helping to shape the ionized outflow @xcite . the very strong gradient in emission evident in figure [ c217 ] and the @xmath0band image of @xcite suggest a possible obscuring disk on small scales , but no kinematic or morphological evidence exists to support this picture , and the radio and near infrared peaks are offset from the center of the torus ( see figure 14 of * ? ? ? if the embedded massive star associated with the continuum peak formed from the molecular torus , then it may have separated itself from this `` parental cloud . '' @xcite presented ionic line measurements of collisionally excited , , and at approximately 9 , 11 , and 13 , respectively . ratios of these lines suggest a relatively low excitation , typical of late o type or early b - type stars . the radio continuum @xcite , however , requires more ionizing photons than a single late o type star produces . @xcite thus concluded that multiple stars ionize 350 ( as discussed above for the nifs images , we detect continuum sources , # 1 , # 4#7 at least , which are centered on local peaks of the br@xmath3 emission ) . @xcite made a similar analysis and conclusion for w51 irs2 , also a massive star forming region . but recently , @xcite identified the exciting star of w51 irs2 directly through its near infrared spectrum , and it is much hotter ( approximately o3o4 ) . for [email protected] , @xcite find a best fit nebular model which also has a cooler central source than the observed spectral type @xcite , though their acceptable models do cover a range of which includes the observed spectral type . the nebular emission in [email protected] was consistent with the observed spectral types found by @xcite , but detailed modeling was not done . a grid of ionization models has been run to analyze the near infrared lines presented here in order to further explore the excitation of the region . cloudy was run on a grid of input parameters which sample a range of ionizing flux and of the central source as described by @xcite . a base line model grid was run with density 10@xmath30 @xmath31 and the @xcite atmospheres ( log ( g ) @xmath21 5.0 and z @xmath21 0 ) . the simulations were run until the temperature into the cloud reached 30 k. a model he atom was used with 10 energy levels to better resolve the level populations for the near infrared lines . the `` _ ism '' abundance set available in cloudy was used which has a he abundance by number relative to h of 0.10 . in the following sections , we discuss how the nifs observations constrain inputs to the models and also what can be inferred from a comparison of the models and observations . the density used in the cloudy runs was constrained by the observed ratio of [ ] lines . the ratio of [ ] 22184 to 21457 is sensitive to density @xcite . the observed ratio ( see table 1 ) is 3.12 and corrected for a@xmath32 of 2.17 @xcite leads to a ratio of 2.8 and a density of approximately 10@xmath33 @xmath31 according to the 7000 k model of @xcite or the 10000 k model of @xcite . @xcite give densities for the ratio of [ ] 22427 to 22184 as well , but the observed ratio of 0.5 is on the flat part of their curve and gives a low density of 10@xmath34 @xmath31 . the small reddening correction would push toward even lower density . all three lines are stronger toward the south in the fov and weak near the continuum peak , thus the ratios do not constrain the density near the continuum peak . @xcite derived a density of 10@xmath35 @xmath31 in the central few arcseconds from their 2 cm data ; similar radio data were presented by @xcite who find a density of 4@xmath810@xmath30 @xmath31 . we discuss models for a range of densities below ( see 5.2.2 and 5.2.3 and figure [ density ] ) . the [ ] line ratios to br@xmath3 reported in table 1 are similar to those reported by @xcite in orion . though the emission is relatively strong in the 350 spectrum , it may be consistent with most of the fe being condensed onto dust grains as is the case for orion ; similar ratios and physical conditions in orion are due to a gas phase abundance which is only a percent of the solar iron abundance @xcite . the distribution of and discussed above suggests some of the gas phase iron in 350 must be in , but there are no lines to estimate the abundance in that species ( the upper levels of observable lines are generally too high to be excited in regions @xcite ) . for the models described below which fit the data best for the excitation of the nebula , most of the fe is in and . in some cases , the fraction is @xmath6 90 @xmath25 , but this still requires the bulk of the iron to be condensed on grains if the total abundance is near or above the solar value . the map of the observed ratio of 1 21127 to br@xmath3 is shown in the left panel of figure [ ratio ] . the ratio is approximately uniform across the main emission in the center of the image and has a value of between 0.04 and 0.05 . the highest value is 0.055 near the continuum peak , and regions around the periphery have values in the range 0.0250.03 . the value in the average spectrum of figure [ spec ] is 0.046 ( table 2 ) which includes the effect of the blend of lines near br@xmath3 . these other lines are not included in the model prediction shown in figure [ he1brg ] , although their effect is small . the average ratio of 0.046 is consistent with an o star which has 40000 k @xcite . a small correction for extinction gives an intrinsic ratio of 0.051 if we adopt the observed ratio in table 2 . cloudy models were run for a grid of ionizing flux ( phi , s@xmath7 cm@xmath34 ) versus exciting source . the former parameter was varied from 12.0 to 16.0 dex and the latter varied from 25000 k to 45000 k. the results for our baseline case ( density @xmath21 10@xmath30 @xmath31 and blister geometry ) are given in figure [ he1brg ] . the ratio along a given contour becomes approximately constant above @xmath21 40000 k , but the detailed ratio depends on the ionizing flux as well . in figure [ he1brg ] , the overall emission due to dust compared to the br@xmath3 flux as predicted by cloudy is also plotted ( as _ dashed _ contours ) . the intersection of this contour with the 1 to br@xmath3 contour can give an idea of the true excitation of the nebula under the assumption of a single dominant source ( which might not be the case ) ; see @xcite and @xcite . the dust emission was calculated approximately from the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) shown in figure 2 of @xcite . no attempt was made to correct for the different beam sizes associated with the many distinct data sets which make up the @xcite figure . the most important is the @xmath6 100 point originally reported by @xcite since this is the peak in the sed . the @xcite beam was 50@xmath1 in diameter and included flux from the nearby k350b region . on the other hand , higher angular resolution data at 450 @xcite show a very compact source ( unresolved at the 8@xmath1 beam size ) with a similar flux to the sed presented by @xcite . @xcite report a br@xmath3 flux of 3.2@xmath810@xmath37 ergs @xmath15 s@xmath7 corrected for @xmath38 @xmath21 2.17 mag . we find a integrated dust emission of approximately 1.8@xmath810@xmath39 ergs @xmath15 s@xmath7 from the @xcite sed . thus the lower limit to the ratio is 1.78@xmath810@xmath40 . the intersection of the contours for 1 and dust compared to br@xmath3 suggest a of about 38000 k and log10(phi ) @xmath21 13.8 . since the br@xmath3 to dust ratio is a lower limit according the discussion above , the true would be hotter . the ionization model grid was repeated for a density of 10@xmath35 @xmath31 . the results are similar to those in figure [ he1brg ] with the intersection of the contours for the observed ratios moving to slightly lower and higher ionizing flux , i.e up and to the left in the figure . the formal intersection is at 37000 k and log10(phi)=14.5 . changing the geometry from plane parallel ( open ) to spherical ( closed ) in cloudy requires higher incident ionizing flux due to the radiation field dilution by @xmath41 . in the model grid , the inner radius of the cloud was set to 0.5@xmath1 or 5@xmath810@xmath42 cm . the observed ratios for the spherical case intersect at somewhat higher , 40000 k , and the corresponding ionizing flux is log10(phi ) @xmath21 14.7 to 14.4 . if the dust emission is too high by a factor of two due to beam size mismatches , then the br@xmath3 to dust ratio is too low by a factor of two . in this case , the model could be as high as 45000 k for a spherical geometry . we conclude that the excitation of 350 is consistent with a central star whose is greater than 37000 k and less than 45000 k. this is higher than @xcite derive based on line ratios of collisionally excited ions . a similar result is obtained in w51 irs2 when comparing the results of @xcite for line ratios to the recent spectral type obtained for the star located at the position of irs2 ( whose region is known as w51d ) ; see @xcite . evidence is presented below that the geometry may be more open like , see also][]col91 , depree94 which would lead to values near 40000 k. @xcite report a lyman continuum luminosity , lyc @xmath21 2.1@xmath810@xmath43 s@xmath7 for a distance of 8.7 kpc . adopting 7 kpc ( see 1 ) , results in a reduced number of 1.3@xmath810@xmath43 s@xmath7 . @xcite find lyc @xmath21 1.95@xmath810@xmath43 s@xmath7 for a distance of 8.3 kpc , which scaled to 7 kpc gives a similar number . this lyc luminosity is consistent with a single o type star with effective temperature of approximately 40000 k based on the properties for o stars given by @xcite or 41000 k if the data from @xcite are used . figure [ c217 ] shows there are multiple continuum sources ( especially in the vicinity of the peak emission ) , but the excitation of the nebula based on the nifs spectrum is consistent with a single , dominant star . the strongest 1 line in 350 is the 20587 line ( figure [ spec ] ) . the right panel of figure [ ratio ] shows the line ratio relative to br@xmath3 . comparison to the left panel of figure [ ratio ] indicates the 20587 line emission is more variable across the nebula than is the case for the 21127 emission . the strong degree of uniformity for the latter suggests the 20587 line variations are not due to differential extinction , but instead are due to structure in the nebula . if the variations seen in the right panel of figure [ ratio ] were due only to variations in the line of sight extinction , then this would require a change in a@xmath32 of more than 10 magnitudes . the continuum map morphology is not consistent with this picture , nor is the average extinction found by @xcite in the central few arcseconds ( a@xmath32 @xmath6 2 ) . finally , the br@xmath3 and 1 21127 intensities are near maxima at the position of the continuum peak while the 20587 line itself is weak there . the formation of the 1 20587 line is complicated and depends on the physical conditions in the ionized gas @xcite . a large ratio to br@xmath3 is due primarily to high density @xcite which allows for enhanced collisional population of the 2 @xmath44p@xmath19 level . however , this level population can also depend strongly on l@xmath4 584 resonance fluorescence which is affected by dust absorption of the he l@xmath4 line and ionization of neutral h by the he l@xmath4 line since both processes destroy the photons which would otherwise pump the line @xcite . the biggest changes in 20587 line formation are expected for a range of central star . the @xcite models were for an average over the nebula ; in the present case , the nebula is spatially resolved and clearly is dominated by a point source ( or unresolved sources ) at one end of the fov . in figure [ depth ] , the ratio of 1 to br@xmath3 emissivity with depth into the cloud ( for a blister model ) is plotted for the 21127 and 20587 lines and a central source with @xmath21 38000 k. the 20587 line strength changes sharply from inner ( close to central source ) to outer ( far from the central source ) positions in the cloud . thus , at any given point in the nebula , we would expect a relatively high ratio in the right panel of figure [ ratio ] since the effects shown in figure [ depth ] would be integrated along the line of sight . the range of observed values for the ratio in the right panel of figure [ ratio ] then suggests that real density variations may exist across the field of view ( lower density near the continuum peak ) . a possible exception to this would be if we were looking along a line of sight such that a slab or blister was illuminated with a geometry whose normal to the slab was in the plane of the sky . but this geometry is inconsistent with the molecular hydrogen morphology ( see below , 5.4 ) which suggests a face on blister geometry . in figure [ density ] , the cloudy predictions for the ratios of the 20587 and 21127 lines to br@xmath3 versus density from cloudy are plotted . the latter line has an observed ratio of approximately 0.051 ( corrected for extinction ) and is nearly uniform over the nebula . the former line has an observed ratio ( corrected for extinction ) that varies from about 0.33 to 0.84 . figure [ density ] shows the cloudy prediction for the case of @xmath21 38000 k and log10(phi ) @xmath21 14.0 . these results indicate that the 21127 line ratio is nearly constant over a range in density of 100 to 100000 @xmath31 while the 20587 line changes from 0.38 to nearly 1.0 over the same range . the ratios plotted in figure [ density ] are integrated along the line of sight through the nebula in contrast to the ratios plotted in figure [ depth ] . the kinematics evident in the bright br@xmath3 line ( figure [ velmap ] ) do not fit neatly with any of the previous kinematic data that were obtained at lower angular resolution . figure [ velmap ] shows a double lobed structure , possibly a flow , with a major axis distinct from any of the larger scale components discussed above . furthermore , the ordered red and blue shifted material is not well correlated with much of the strong br@xmath3 emission and the point of symmetry of the indicated flow is not coincident with the continuum peak . a possible explanation for the small scale flow is that it is created by a lower mass protostar in the nascent cluster . this molecular outflow is then ionized by the massive star at the continuum peak . a similar scenario was recently described for the compact high mass star forming region irs2 in w51 @xcite . another possibility is that the large scale ionized flow is related to the inner flow . this would require that the outflow is precessing or that details of the interaction of the out - flowing gas on larger scales than the nifs fov reorient the flow since the axis of the inner flow does not line up with the axis of the large scale ionized flow . the contours of the larger flow do , however , appear to twist @xcite and figure [ c217 ] clearly shows more detailed radio ( kinematic ) observations would be helpful in understanding the transition between the inner scale and larger scale gas kinematics . @xcite argued that the large scale ionized flow might result from the expansion of material coming from within a small ( few arcsecond ) shell . they took as evidence for a shell the high angular resolution 2 cm map of @xcite . the nifs br@xmath3 morphology appears to match well with the 2 cm emission , but does not appear shell like ( * ? ? ? * noted the classification of 350 as shell like was problematic ) . still , the nifs data suggest an outflow originating within this small region which is likely confined or directed by the material around it . the large scale flow has a velocity gradient of about 6 arcsec@xmath7 while the small scale flow gradient evident in figure [ velmap ] is 25 arcsec@xmath7 . the velocity reported for the core of the radio emission is @xmath1233 with respect to the lsr @xcite . the integrated br@xmath3 emission has @xmath23 @xmath21 @xmath1262.5 ( see table 1 ) . the red shifted emission in figure [ velmap ] is at @xmath23 @xmath6 @xmath1230 . this suggests that we may be only seeing part of radio emitting gas in the br@xmath3 map and that the red lobe of the br@xmath3 flow is really tracing the bulk of the radio flow ; that velocity is presumably the systemic velocity of the radio region . in this model , all the rest of the br@xmath3 emission is tracing blue shifted gas outflowing from the central source . the spatially unresolved br@xmath3 emission at the continuum peak ( see figure [ brgmap ] and 5.6 ) also has a @xmath23 @xmath6 @xmath1232 that is close to the systemic velocity defined by the h76@xmath4 emission . in 4.3 , a broad component of emission was identified to the blue of the br@xmath3 line ( see figure [ detail ] ) . the position of the line is consistent with one of the 1 lines from the n@xmath21 74 complex , but the emission is much stronger than expected based on transition probabilities and broader than any other 1 line by about a factor of two . thus , it is more likely a second br@xmath3 component . the line velocity is about 40 blue shifted compared to the background or cloud velocity ( the green regions in figure [ velmap ] ) . this is larger than the blueshifted velocity structure of the principal component of br@xmath3 shown in that figure . the width of the broad component is about twice the width of the principal br@xmath3 component ( 120 compared to 70 ) . the broad component is distributed in an arc to the sse of the continuum source ( @xmath6 0.5@xmath1 in length and offset from the peak by @xmath6 [email protected]@xmath1 ) and is confined to this vicinity of the continuum source . it is not clear how the high velocity , broad component is produced . it may be related to hot gas escaping a tightly constrained volume near the central source . the scale associated with the broad component is small , only 0.0070.010 pc ( for a distance of 7 kpc ) . in champagne flows that are produced as the ionizing radiation from the hot star penetrates into a uniform medium ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , the hot star quickly carves out a larger diameter cavity ( 0.1 pc ) . perhaps shocked gas initially flowing parallel to the plane of the sky and then being redirected along our line of sight could explain the broad component . this putative flow might be related to the central source stellar wind . in any case , gas must escape to the north and eventually form the larger ionized flow seen in the @xcite radio images . the immediate vicinity of the continuum peak may be filled with low density gas , and this gas may surround ( or overlay ) higher density material within the projected `` cone '' which extends to the south of the continuum source . in order to explain the low ratio of 1 20587 to br@xmath3 near the continuum peak , the particular line of sight must contain very little dense ionized gas indicating this area has been cleared away as the hot star emerges from its parent cloud ( which remains mostly to the north ) . the high angular resolution 2 cm image of @xcite and the molecular maps of @xcite are consistent with clearing of high density material in the vicinity of the continuum peak ; both show voids or gaps in the emission . none of the current absolute positions is good enough to place the different wavelength data to better than about 0.5@xmath1 which is the scale of the structure in our data and the 2 cm map . the nebula is seen in projection against h@xmath22 emission , primarily in the lower left quadrant where the br@xmath3 emission is strongest ( figure [ h2 ] ) but also ( unresolved ) at the position of the continuum peak . three prominent lines of molecular hydrogen are listed in table 1 . the average ratios of the two longer wavelength lines to the v@xmath2110 s(1 ) 21218 line ( 0.42 @xmath2 0.1 , 0.23 @xmath2 0.1 for h@xmath22 v@xmath21 10 s(0 ) and h@xmath22 v@xmath21 21 s(1 ) , respectively ) can be compared to the diagnostic diagram given by @xcite which shows these same ratios for a large sample of regions along with several model predictions for shock excited and fluorescent emission . the bulk of the @xcite sample is consistent with dense ( 10@xmath45 @xmath31 ) photo dissociation regions ( pdr ) . the results for 350 place it in the same region of the diagram showing it too is consistent with a dense pdr on the boundary of its ionized nebula . since we see both the ionized gas and molecular emission , it is likely the h@xmath22 emission is behind the ionized gas ( a large column of molecular gas in front would obscure our view ) . if this is the case , then the region may be best described as blister like ; the hot star has emerged from the parent cloud and is ionizing the face of the molecular material to the south . in this case , the `` cone '' is really a flattened structure seen face on and lying on the surface of a dense cloud of molecular gas . as mentioned above , @xcite analyzed [ ] / [ ] and [ ] / [ ] ratios in 350 . the observed ratios are consistent with other regions , but inconsistent with simple ionization models . the models predict stronger [ ] / [ ] than [ ] / [ ] for a given , but the observations show the average ratios are of similar value and the peak ratios have substantially larger [ ] / [ ] than [ ] / [ ] . our grid of models agrees with @xcite in the sense that for a given , the [ ] line ratio is predicted to be stronger . @xcite computed ar , s , and ne abundances for 350 from iso mid infrared spectra and find abundances which differ from the solar values ( and our cloudy models ) . in particular , the ne abundance compared to h is approximately solar , while the ar abundance is a factor of 2 lower than the solar value , and the s abundance is a factor of 10 lower . however , this large reduction in s abundance may be ( in part ) due to the high density in 350 depopulating the upper levels producing the s emission as @xcite point out . detailed models used to derive the s abundance in 350 by @xcite give a value only a factor of two lower than solar . the iso spectra were obtained through large apertures ( @xmath6 20@xmath1 ) , and the line ratios are smaller than the peak ratios in the higher angular resolution @xcite data . the iso line ratios are nearly equal and have a value of approximately 0.25 . this is comparable to the low end of the range of values obtained by @xcite . the observed high peak line ratios of @xcite ( [ ] / [ ] @xmath21 3 , [ ] / [ ] @xmath21 4 ) would appear to require lower s abundance and higher to be consistent with the cloudy ionization models , but the precise line ratios do not converge in our grid of models even when adopting the detailed abundances of @xcite . in particular , reproducing the high line ratio of [ ] / [ ] requires to be @xmath46 45000 k , the limit of the range based on the analysis of the 1 21127 line and the dust emission , and such a model would produce a much too high [ ] / [ ] ratio . earlier work based on kuiper airborne observatory observations @xcite also did not succeed in fitting the ratios of these infrared lines . the @xcite data were obtained through apertures approximately 5@xmath1 in diameter and the line ratios are larger than the iso values ( about unity for both ) and somewhat smaller than the @xcite peak values . @xcite and @xcite have argued that multiple ionizing sources might explain the observations . the nifs data generally ( continuum , 1 lines , resolved nebular structure ) seem to indicate the central few arcseconds are dominated by the continuum peak . figure [ feiii ] shows that the excitation in the nebula is higher toward the continuum peak . the [ ] emission is weak in the vicinity of the continuum peak compared to the [ ] line . the [ ] line is weak as well and this is consistent with its lower ionization potential than the other species present . in the case of okym4 ( figure [ c217 ] ) , there may be some evidence for lower excitation ; @xcite preferred a late o or b star for this source . the left panel of figure [ ratio ] shows a dip in the 21127 to br@xmath3 ratio at the position of okym4 ( the ratio is about 0.025 ) . this source is about 2@xmath1 away from the continuum peak and this is roughly the scale of an associated stromgren sphere for the central star ( figure [ depth ] ) . further , the [ ] emission peaks at the location of this source . indeed , the emission morphology of the line maps suggest the boundary of the region which is principally due to the continuum peak is on this same scale . if this is correct the `` cone '' morphology arises from dust obscuration to the north and the ionization boundary of the nebula to the south . the main nebula is largely excited by the continuum peak , and okym4 may be locally internally excited . the compactness of okym4 then suggests the source is very young and/or highly constrained . lower mass ob stars should not greatly affect the structure within the `` cone , '' however . @xcite and @xcite argued that the low _ average _ [ ] / [ ] and [ ] / [ ] ratios might be due to multiple lower sources ( as may be the case for okym4 ) , but a successful model must also explain the detailed ratios including their very high peak ratios near the continuum peak . while we have not been able to produce such a model , higher ratios are more consistent with hotter stars . in the preceding sections , the structure of the nebula was described , and it was concluded that the central source is a hot star emerging from its natal cocoon . the star is ionizing the cloud to the south in our fov and produces an intense region and associated pdr . it was argued that the density in the nebula may be lower in the vicinity of the continuum peak . the continuum peak ( by definition ) dominates the @xmath0band emission . in addition , br@xmath3 , 1 21127 , [ ] ( the highest ionization line observed ) , and h@xmath22 show unresolved emission peaks ( or near peaks ) at this location . there is clearly a very compact source of emission here which includes stellar continuum ( from multiple sources ) re - radiated by hot dust , and possibly line emission from the circumstellar environment . an ionized circumstellar disc is a possible source of the compact emission . though no kinematic evidence is available to support this possibility . @xcite and @xcite presented kinematic evidence of discs around ( somewhat less ) massive young stars based on the emission profiles of the co v@xmath2120 rotational vibrational bandhead at 22935 . this line is not detected in 350 . whatever its geometry , there must be compact circumstellar material ( partially ) surrounding the central source which is not directly linked ( at least now ) to the larger resolved region covered by the nifs fov . high angular resolution ( @xmath6 0.2@xmath1 ) @xmath0band spectral imaging has been presented for the galactic region 350 . the data were obtained with adaptive optics and the image slicing integral field spectrograph , nifs , at gemini north . the combination of excellent wavelength coverage , moderate spectral resolution ( 5160 ) , and high angular resolution provide the most detailed look to date at this massive young stellar object and its immediate environment . the emission morphology matches well with earlier speckle observations . spatial and ionization structure are resolved in the 3@xmath1 nebula . the 1 emission morphology suggests changes in density across the field which are attributed to the break out and clearing phase of massive star birth . the ratio of 1 20587 to br@xmath3 varies from about 0.3 to 0.8 and requires that the density near the central source be more than a factor 10 less than farther away . the ionization in the nebula can be traced across the nebula by the varying intensity of [ ] and [ ] lines . a grid of ionization models has been run with the code cloudy @xcite , and the results of these calculations were compared to the observed 1 21127 line to br@xmath3 line ratio and dust emission properties . the combination of observed values constrain the nebular excitation to a source with 37000 k. this is somewhat hotter than expected from collisionally excited emission line ratios in the mid infrared @xcite , but those line ratios , particularly their peak values on scales of @xmath6 1@xmath1 , are not explained by our models ( or those of * ? ? ? despite the high angular resolution of these data which enhances the contrast between background and point source emission , no photospheric lines are detected in the spectrum of the bright continuum source ; it remains buried within intense continuum emission . the central source is likely also blended with other point sources as pointed out by other investigators . there is spatially unresolved , bright emission in the lines of br@xmath3 , 1 , and [ ] ( and possibly [ ] ) at the continuum peak position and these are attributed to the circumstellar environment of the massive young stellar object . the nifs data cube reveals a striking kinematic signature in 350 . however , this `` flow '' is not aligned with the large scale ionized out flow reported in earlier radio continuum and recombination line studies ( 10 s of arcseconds in extent ) . the nifs kinematic signature is not symmetric about any detected point source in the nifs image either . it is possible the bipolar kinematics arise from a lower mass protostar associated with the central star of 350 , and the associated material is ionized by the hot central source . a second broad component of br@xmath3 emission is seen within a few tenths of an arcsecond of the continuum peak . this may be hot gas escaping from the cavity resulting from the action of the ionizing radiation on the natal molecular cloud or large scale torus . the authors would like to thank gary ferland , ryan porter , and peter van hoof for useful input regarding cloudy and the 1 model . the authors also thank manuel bautista for useful conversations regarding the line ratios and chris depree for kindly providing the 14.7 ghz fits image used in figure [ c217 ] . the plots and analysis in this article made use of the yorick programing language . this article made use of the simbad database at the cds . based on observations obtained at the gemini observatory ( proposal i d gn-2006a - c-11 ) , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc . , under a cooperative agreement with the nsf on behalf of the gemini partnership : the national science foundation ( united states ) , the science and technology facilities council ( united kingdom ) , the national research council ( canada ) , conicyt ( chile ) , the australian research council ( australia ) , cnpq ( brazil ) and secyt ( argentina ) . ralchenko , yu . , jou , f .- c . , kelleher , d.e . , kramida , a.e . , musgrove , a. , reader , j. , wiese , w.l . , & olsen , k. ( 2007 ) . nist atomic spectra database ( version 3.1.2 ) , [ online ] . available : http://physics.nist.gov/asd3 [ 2007 , august 24 ] . national institute of standards and technology , gaithersburg , md . ( beam pa@xmath2179@xmath19 ) . the contours correspond to the nifs continuum ( _ right _ panel ) where the peak emission in both images is made to match . _ right _ panel : @xmath0band continuum at 21700 ( 19.2 , 9 pixels wide ) shown in grayscale ( log intensity ) and with the same contours plotted in the _ left _ panel . the field center is located at approximately ra(2000)@xmath2120@xmath47 01@xmath48 45.71@xmath49 , dec(2000)@xmath5033@xmath51 32@xmath52 42.1@xmath1 ( see text for a discussion of source position versus wavelength ) . the position angle on the sky was 70(east of north ) ; this image has been rotated so that north is up , and east is left . the _ red _ filled circles are sources from @xcite and the _ yellow _ diamonds are the mid infrared sources of @xcite ; see text . the continuum peak appears as an unresolved point source near 0.2 , 0.6 and is assumed to be source # 1 of @xcite and okym3 of @xcite . the long line starting at source # 1 indicates the approximate direction of the ionizied outflow described by @xcite . the second line is our estimate of the rotation axis of the hco@xmath28 torus described by @xcite ; see text . the torus is centered a few arcseconds n - w of the continuum peak . [ c217],width=6 ] . [ ] 22184 is shown on the left , and [ ] 22867 is shown on the right . the ionization potential of is lower than that for showing that the excitation is higher closer to the continuum peak . the peak surface brightnesses are 6.6@xmath810@xmath53 erg @xmath15 s@xmath7 arcsec@xmath17 and 1.1@xmath810@xmath54 erg @xmath15 s@xmath7 arcsec@xmath17 for [ ] and [ ] , respectively , and the contour intervals are evenly spaced at an interval 10 times less than the peak value . [ feiii],width=6 ] lcccc [ lines ] h@xmath22 v@xmath2110 s(1 ) & 21218 & 21215 & 59 & 0.0076 @xmath2 0.0001 + @xmath55@xmath56 $ ] @xmath18h@xmath18 g & 21457 & 21454 & 71 & 0.0052 @xmath2 0.0001 + br@xmath3 ( 74 ) & 21661 & 21657 & 71 & 1.0000 @xmath2 0.0002 + @xmath55@xmath56 $ ] @xmath18p@xmath57@xmath18p@xmath22 & 21987 & 21983 & 57 & 0.0041 @xmath2 0.0001 + @xmath55@xmath56 $ ] @xmath18h@xmath18 g & 22184 & 22183 & 62 & 0.0164 @xmath2 0.0001 + h@xmath22 v@xmath2110 s(0 ) & 22233 & 22230 & 70 & 0.0034 @xmath2 0.0001 + @xmath55@xmath56 $ ] @xmath18h@xmath18 g & 22427 & 22422 & 54 & 0.0086 @xmath2 0.0001 + h@xmath22 v@xmath2121 s(1 ) & 22477 & 22473 & 55 & 0.0020 @xmath2 0.0001 + @xmath55@xmath56 $ ] @xmath34p@xmath58@xmath34p@xmath59 & 22867 & 22863 & 71 & 0.0291 @xmath2 0.0003 lcccc [ helines ] 1 @xmath60 @xmath18s@xmath18p@xmath19 & 20430 & 20427 & 79 & 0.0055 @xmath2 0.0001 + 1 @xmath61 @xmath20s@xmath20p@xmath19 & 20587 & 20583 & 67 & 0.6778 @xmath2 0.0002 + 1 @xmath62 @xmath18p@xmath19@xmath18d & 20607 & 20603 & 89 & 0.0067 @xmath63 0.0002 + 1 @xmath64 @xmath18p@xmath19@xmath18s & 21127 & 21122 & 70 & 0.0462 @xmath2 0.0001 + 1 @xmath64 @xmath20p@xmath19@xmath20s & 21138 & 21134 & 68 & 0.0110 @xmath2 0.0001 + 1 @xmath65 @xmath18p@xmath19@xmath18s & 21500 & 21497 & 70 & 0.0012 @xmath2 0.0001 + 1 @xmath66 @xmath18d@xmath18f@xmath19 & 21614 & 21609 & 71 & 0.0250 @xmath2 0.0002 + 1 @xmath66 @xmath20d@xmath20f@xmath19 & 21623 & 21620 & 70 & 0.0100 @xmath2 0.0002 + 1 @xmath27 @xmath20f@xmath19@xmath20 g , @xmath18f@xmath19@xmath18 g & 21647 & 21642 & 70 & 0.0508 @xmath2 0.0002 + 1 @xmath26 @xmath20f@xmath19@xmath20d , @xmath18f@xmath19@xmath18d , br@xmath3 ? & 21655 & 21650 & 70 & 0.0670 @xmath2 0.0002 + 1 @xmath67 @xmath18d@xmath18p@xmath19 & 21821 & 21817 & 62 & 0.0044 @xmath2 0.0001 + 1 @xmath62 @xmath20p@xmath19@xmath20d & 21846 & 21842 & 62 & 0.0023 @xmath2 0.0001 + 1 @xmath65 @xmath20p@xmath19@xmath20s & 22291 & 22287 & 78 & 0.0012 @xmath2 0.0001

gemini north adaptive optics imaging spectroscopy is presented for the galactic ultra compact ( ) region k350a . data were obtained in the @xmath0band using the near infrared integral field spectrograph ( nifs ) behind the facility adaptive optics module altair in natural guide star mode . the nifs data cube reveals a complex spatial morphology across the 0.1 pc scale of the 3@xmath1 region . comparison of the nebular emission to cloudy ionization models shows that the central source must have an effective temperature between about 37000 k and 45000 k with preferred values near 40000 k. evidence is presented for sharp density variations in the nebula which are interpreted as a clearing of material nearest the central source . high excitation lines of and show that the ionization of the nebula clearly changes with distance from the central source . a double lobed kinematic signature ( @xmath2 25 ) is evident in the br@xmath3 line map which may be related to the larger scale ionized flow detailed in earlier investigations . this signature and the large scale flow are not co - alighned , but they may still be related . though clearly resolved from the nebula , the central source itself remains buried , and the nifs spectrum shows no evidence of photospheric lines .

cond-mat0611627

an important issue for transport in nanosystems concerns the role of electronic interactions . for one dimensional conductors such as carbon nanotubes , electronic correlations are known to lead to dramatic behavior , such as a zero bias anomaly in the tunneling conductance@xcite . recently , the problem of electron injection in the bulk of a nanotube , which extremities are connected to leads , was examined@xcite . for an infinite carbon nanotube length , it was shown that the measurement of both current auto- and cross - correlations in the current could lead to a diagnosis of the anomalous ( non - electron ) charges arising from collective excitations propagating in the nanotube . this work was followed other studies@xcite where the role of fermi liquid leads connected to the nanotube was investigated in view of detecting anomalous charges . for the injection geometry of ref . , the zero - frequency noise cross - correlations vanish as a result of multiple andreev - like reflections at the contacts : only electrons can be accepted by the right and left contacts . to a first approximation , current and auto - correlation noise were shown to follow the schottky relation@xcite with a fano factor corresponding to the electron charge . the purpose of the present work is to focus on the finite size effects which are manifest in this transport geometry , and is two - fold . first , we wish to reexamine whether this schottky relation is indeed followed for all parameters in this finite size geometry . indeed , there are several frequency scales in this geometry . the inverse of the voltage scale @xmath0 corresponds to the time spread of the electron wave packet entering the nanotube . the inverse of the finite length frequency @xmath1 ( @xmath2 is the interaction parameter of the nanotube , @xmath3 is its length ) corresponds to the time of flight of excitations propagating from one contact to the other . we shall show that in the limit where @xmath4 , the schottky behavior with the electron charge as the proportionality factor is violated , leading to a voltage dependent fano factor . the second part of this study concerns photo - assisted noise : an ac bias is superposed to the dc bias imposed between the scanning tunneling microscope ( stm ) tip which injects the electrons , and the nanotube . experimentally , photo - assisted noise has been measured in diffusive wires@xcite , diffusive junctions@xcite and quantum point contacts@xcite . for normal metals , the noise derivative displays steps at integer values of the ratio @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the ac frequency@xcite . we naturally expect that this behavior is modified by the tunneling density of states exponent of our geometry , leading here to a smoothing of the steps due to electronic correlations . it is the case in the absence of finite size effects . more interestingly , we will show that when finite size effects are present , the noise derivative with respect to voltage has a stepwise behavior , similar to the one obtained for normal metal . indeed , concerning the first part of this study , our previous works on electron injection@xcite did not fully take into account the presence of the leads , in the sense that the tunneling density of states is slightly modified by finite size effects . note that this does not bear any dramatic consequences on our finite frequency noise scheme @xcite which was used to detect anomalous charges in a nanotube connected to fermi liquid leads . in the present zero - frequency noise study , we feel that it is quite interesting to deepen the study of transport because to our knowledge , in most tunneling geometries of mesoscopic physics , the schottky relation is expected to be followed with a voltage independent fano factor . the present numerical study allows to probe to what extends this relation is violated when the voltage is `` low '' , and this violation is rendered more explicit when interactions in the nanotube are strong . the second part of this study deals with photo - assisted noise . photo - assisted transport ( current ) is by no means new : a pioneering work@xcite considered the effect of a microwave fields on the tunnel transfer of electrons between two superconductor films . in mesoscopic devices , photo - assisted noise was first studied theoretically in a normal metal junction , leading , as mentioned above , to a stepwise behavior in the nose derivative@xcite . this latter work was extended to treat normal metal - superconductor junctions@xcite , leading to a diagnosis of the cooper pair charge transferred in an andreev reflection process . it was also applied to the fractional quantum hall effect@xcite where the charge transferred can either be that of a laughlin quasiparticle or that of an electron , depending on whether weak or strong pinching of the point contact placed on a quantum hall bar . so as far as 1d strongly correlated systems are concerned , photo - assisted transport has so far been confined only to chiral luttinger liquids . a further study of photo - assisted transport in non - chiral luttinger liquids is clearly lacking , but most importantly its crucial feature here is to understand how finite size effects of the nanotube modify the `` expected '' behavior . the paper is organized as follows : in sec . ii , we define the geometry which applies to our calculation and we recall the basic assumptions of the model developed in ref . . iii , we concentrate on the calculation of the nanotube current and of the nanotube auto - correlation noise for the numerical study of the voltage dependent fano factor . iv , is devoted to the calculation of photo - assisted transport in a nanotube . we conclude in sec . we consider the following setup : an stm tip close to a carbon nanotube connected to leads at both extremities . a voltage applied between the stm and the nanotube allows electrons to tunnel in the center region of the nanotube . as a result , charge excitations propagate along the nanotube toward the right and left leads . this system is described by the hamiltonian @xmath7 . the nanotube is a non - chiral luttinger liquid@xcite : @xmath8~ , \label{b_ham}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath9 is the position along the nanotube , @xmath10 and @xmath11 are non - chiral bosonic fields and @xmath12 is the coulomb interactions parameter for each charge / spin , total / relative sectors @xmath13 . we put @xmath14 . because of time reversal symmetry , @xmath15 , and we assume that @xmath2 depends on position@xcite as depicted on fig . [ fig1 ] . the velocities satisfy @xmath16 . 8 cm the electrons in the metallic stm tip are assumed to be non - interacting . for convenience@xcite , the electron field @xmath17 in the stm tip can be described in terms of a semi - infinite luttinger liquid with coulomb interactions parameters all equal to one . the tunnel hamiltonian between the stm tip and the nanotube at position @xmath18 is : @xmath19^{(\epsilon)}~ , \label{ham}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath20 corresponds to the branch index , @xmath21 to the mode index and @xmath22 to the spin . the superscript @xmath23 leaves either operator unchanged @xmath24 , or transforms it into its hermitian conjugate @xmath25 . the voltage is taken into account via a time dependence of the tunneling amplitude ( peierls substitution ) @xmath26 where @xmath0 is the voltage frequency . the fermionic fields for electrons in the nanotube and in the stm tip are respectively defined by : @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the ultraviolet cutoff of the luttinger liquid model , @xmath29 and @xmath30 are klein factors , @xmath31 is the fermi momentum and @xmath32 is the momentum mismatch associated with the two modes @xmath21 . for further calculation purposes , it is convenient to rewrite the bosonic field @xmath33 in terms of the non - chiral bosonic fields @xmath11 and @xmath10 : @xmath34~,\ ] ] with coefficients @xmath35 , @xmath36 , @xmath37 and @xmath38 , and bosonic fields obeying the equal time commutation relations @xmath39=-(i/2 ) \delta_{jj^\prime}\delta_{\delta\delta^\prime}\,sgn(x - x^\prime)$ ] . @xmath40 is the chiral bosonic field attached to the stm tip , whose keldysh green s function at @xmath18 is given by @xcite : @xmath41,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath42 denotes the upper / lower branch of the keldysh contour . in this section , we present the calculations of current and zero - frequency shot noise . since we have to treat a non - equilibrium situation due to the application of a voltage bias between the stm tip and the nanotube , we define average values of the current and of the unsymetrized noise in the framework of the keldysh formalism@xcite : @xmath43 where @xmath44 denotes time ordering along the keldysh contour and @xmath45 is the total current operator which can be defined through the bosonic field @xmath46 : @xmath47 . it has been shown in ref . that , up to the second order with the tunnel amplitude @xmath48 , the average current and the zero - frequency fourier transform of the noise can be expressed as : @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the keldysh green s function for the stm tip given by eq . ( [ green ] ) , and @xmath51 is the keldysh green s function for the nanotube bosonic field @xmath10 : @xmath52 similar definitions hold for other combinations of bosonic fields : @xmath53 , @xmath54 and @xmath55 . for @xmath56 , we have@xcite : @xmath57\biggr\}~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath58 is the reflection coefficient at the lead positions @xmath59 . in addition , @xmath60 , and the green s function @xmath61 can be obtained by the substitution @xmath62 in eq . ( [ green_nano ] ) . the integration over @xmath63 in eq . ( [ courant ] ) and over @xmath64 and @xmath65 in eq . ( [ bruit ] ) can be performed . we obtain : @xmath66 where @xmath67 . from eq . ( [ noise ] ) , we immediately see that the zero - frequency cross - correlations @xmath68 cancel at order @xmath69 , as it is the case for a non - interacting three terminals device@xcite . this is because quasiparticle excitations in the nanotube suffer multiple reflections at the contacts , which lead to a recombination of these in the form of an electron entering the contact on either side , but not both . 8 cm by a careful analysis of eqs . ( [ current ] ) and ( [ noise ] ) , we notice , as announced in the introduction , that three characteristic frequencies are involved : the voltage frequency @xmath0 , the nanotube length frequency @xmath1 , which is related to the time @xmath70 that excitations take to reach the leads from the position @xmath18 , and the cutoff frequency @xmath71 of the luttinger liquid model . taking realistic values : @xmath72 ( carbon nanotube diameter ) , @xmath73 ( carbon nanotube length ) and @xmath74 for the fermi velocity@xcite , we obtain the estimations @xmath75 and @xmath76 . we consider that @xmath77 can vary from 0 to @xmath78 ( i.e. , from 0 to @xmath79 ) . in fig . [ fig2 ] , numerical calculations of the current and the noise of eqs . ( [ current ] ) and ( [ noise ] ) are presented as a function of the ratio @xmath80 . these are plotted in units of @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the gamma function . we observe two different regimes . the first one corresponds to the limit @xmath83 for which the spatial extension of the electron wave packet injected in the nanotube is much smaller than the length of the carbon nanotube : @xmath84 . in this limit , the integrals which appear in eqs . ( [ courant ] ) and ( [ noise ] ) can be performed exactly@xcite , and the current and the noise obey the same power law : @xmath85 , in very good agreement with our numerical results ( see inset of fig . [ fig2 ] ) . therefore , the schottky relation@xcite with the electronic charge applies : @xmath86 . as the spatial extension of the electron wave packet is much smaller than the nanotube length , the reflections by the contacts do not play an important role for @xmath83 ( the limit @xmath87 is formally equivalent to the limit @xmath88 where @xmath89 is the reflection coefficient ) . 8 cm a completely different behavior is observed in the limit @xmath90 , for which the wave packet spatial extension of the charge excitations is larger , or comparable to the carbon nanotube length : @xmath91 . in this regime , the wave packet is split into localized quasiparticle excitations which propagate to the right and to the left contacts , subsequently undergoes andreev - like reflections , as depicted in fig . [ fig3 ] . as a consequence , current and noise have distinct behaviors and are not more proportional to each other . the effect of the reflections by the contacts at the nanotube extremities is to attenuate the coulomb interactions effect for the noise : from a power law behavior symptomatic of a zero bias anomaly , we end up here with a quasi - linear noise behavior when either the nanotube length is reduced or , equivalently when the voltage decreases . this quasi - linear variation of the noise is extracted form the log - log plot shown in the inset of fig . notice that this quasi - linear variation is shown on less than a decade because for lower values of @xmath80 , the numerically estimated values of the current and noise become of the order of the numerical error . for this reason , we are not able to charaterize this power law behavior over several decades , as would be suitable in principle . 8 cm the fact that current and noise are not more proportional each other with a coefficient simply equal to @xmath92 is a novel and interesting feature . in order to further characterize this effect , we have plotted on fig . [ fig4 ] the fano factor , defined by @xmath93 , as a function of @xmath80 , for several values of the coulomb interactions parameter @xmath2 which differ from the non - interacting case . we observe three distinct phases : super - poissonian noise ( i.e. , @xmath94 ) for @xmath95 , sub - poissonian noise ( i.e. , @xmath96 ) for @xmath97 and poissonian noise ( i.e. , @xmath98 ) for @xmath99 . non - poissonian noise is observed in the regime where the andreev - type reflections by the contacts play an important role ( i.e. @xmath100 ) . we conclude that finite size effects are responsible for this non - poissonian character . in addition , fig . [ fig4 ] shows that the fano factor converges to the value 1 when @xmath2 increases from 0.15 to 0.4 . this is fully consistent with the value @xmath101 that is obtained in the absence of coulomb interactions ( where @xmath102 ) . the fact that in carbon nanotubes , the fano factor exhibits a voltage dependence has recently been obtained in some regimes , both experimentally and theoretically@xcite . in the present work , the voltage dependent fano factor allows to test the strength of electronic correlations in the nanotube . as shown in the plot of fig . [ fig4 ] , to a good approximation the width @xmath103 of the sub - poissonian phase is equal to @xmath80 . it can therefore be used for an experimental determination of the luttinger liquid coulomb interactions parameter as @xmath104 . we now turn to the response of the system to a voltage ac modulation superposed to the constant dc voltage : @xmath105 . with this voltage , the tunnel amplitude becomes : @xmath106 where @xmath107 the bessel function on order @xmath108 ( even or odd integer ) and @xmath109 . calculations of current and zero - frequency noise are similar to the dc voltage case , except that we have now an infinite sum of bessel functions@xcite . the calculation is thus analogous to the one which applies to the fractional quantum hall effect@xcite , except that here only electrons tunnel in the nanotube . we thus obtain : @xmath110 in sec . iii , we showed that the integrals which appear in eqs . ( [ ac_current ] ) and ( [ ac_noise ] ) behave like a power law @xmath111 when @xmath112.thus , in the presence of an ac voltage modulation , the current and zero - frequency noise give an infinite sum of power laws , which can not be understood straightforwardly as in the preceding section . the `` standard '' way@xcite to display the results for photo - assisted transport is to consider the noise derivative as a function of voltage : in particular , this allows to compare the results with the non - interacting case where the noise derivative exhibits a staircase variation , which corresponds to the normal metal junction of ref . for a fermi liquid . in fig . [ fig5 ] , we plot the numerically computed noise derivative as a function of the ratio @xmath5 in the presence of coulomb interactions ( @xmath113 ) . we see different kinds of behaviors , which again have to do with the finite size effects in the nanotube . for @xmath114 ( full line ) , we are in the limit where the wave packet spatial extension is smaller that the nanotube length . we therefore invoke the same arguments as before , concerning the recombination of electron wave packets into simple electrons : in this regime ( except for a small region close to the origin ) the vast majority of the voltage scale lies in the regime where @xmath115 . the noise derivative differs from the single electron behavior , in the sense that the sharp steps and plateaus expected in this case are absent . instead , because of coulomb interactions effect , the noise derivative is smoothed out , but there is a clear reminiscence of the step positions : the slope of @xmath116 increases abruptly at the location of these steps . we attribute the smoothing to the tunneling density of states on the nanotube which is modified by the coulomb interactions in the nanotube . between the steps , we observe oscillations which are originate from the commensurability between the nanotube length frequency and the ac frequency . for @xmath117 ( dashed line ) , we are in an intermediate regime for which electron wave packets are comparable to the nanotube length . for @xmath118 ( dashed - dotted line ) , we are in the limit where electron wave packets are larger than the nanotube length , and as a consequence , the finite size effects dominate over the coulomb interactions effect and a stepwise behavior in @xmath116 , which is typical of non - interacting metals , can be identified . finally , we notice that for @xmath112 , all the curves converge to the simple expression for the noise derivative given by the sum @xmath119 . the reason is the following one : in this limit , coulomb interactions play an important role and the dc noise has a power law dependency with the voltage ( as shown in section iii ) : @xmath120 which lead to a ac noise of the form : @xmath121 where the exponent @xmath122 is related to the coulomb interactions parameter . to summarize , coulomb interactions affect the height and shape of the steps in the differential noise , and trigger oscillations between these steps when @xmath123 is small . this study has dealt with the finite size effects for electron injection on a nanotube connected to fermi liquid leads , from the point of view of zero - frequency noise as well as for photo - assisted transport . on the first topic , we have shown that at low and intermediate voltages compared to the frequency length scale , the current and noise deviate strongly from the schottky relation , leading first to super - poissonian noise , then to sub - poissonian behavior as compared to tunneling in non - interacting system . the sub - poissonian result can be exploited toward an experimental determination of the luttinger liquid interactions parameter in the nanotube . a qualitative understanding of the deviation from the schottky behavior can be reached by arguing that in the limit @xmath83 , the quasi - particle wave packets which originate from the injected electron are well localized in space : their spatial extension is much smaller that the nanotube length and a recombination as an electron in either lead is possible . on the opposite , @xmath124 `` wide '' wave packets have not enough space on the nanotube length , and the fabry - perot@xcite process for transforming quasiparticle excitations into electrons at the leads is simply not efficient . granted , it is however difficult to explain in detail the transition from super - poissonian noise to sub - poissonian noise : this qualitative argument can so far only predict a deviation from the electron charge in the schottky formula . for photo - assisted transport , generally speaking as stepwise structure is identified , which is similar to that of single electrons , but steps are smoothed out due to the fact that electrons tunnel in a strongly correlated one dimensional system , where electrons are not truly welcome . more interestingly , we identify that when the width of the electron wave packets becomes comparable or exceeds the nanotube length , a stepwise behavior is observed . not surprisingly , this happens precisely in the same regime where the deviation from schottky behavior was observed . note that in contrast to our previous work dedicated to the detection of quasi - particle anomalous charges in a nanotube connected to leads@xcite , here we can make a diagnosis on finite size effects in transport by a relatively simple zero - frequency measurement ( by zero - frequency , in experiments we really mean frequencies which are sufficiently low so that @xmath125 noise does not dominate ) . this is a rather important practical aspect of this work : indeed , for nanotubes length of the order of @xmath126 , the frequency scales needed for the finite - frequency noise cross correlations diagnostic of ref . are of the order of @xmath127 . such frequencies are difficult to detect by conventional techniques , and require an on - chip noise measuring apparatus@xcite . the fact that a low frequency auto - correlation noise measurement is sufficient to probe finite size effects is clearly an advantage here . the present results could be tested experimentally , using essentially the same geometry as in the experiments of ref . . there , electrons were injected by an stm tip on a suspended nanotube , which was placed across a trench composed of highly doped silicon . both sides of the trench were short circuited and connected to the ground . because the contacts were of bad quality , the physics observed in this experiment was that of the coulomb blockade , with additional features in the current voltage characteristics due to the lateral breathing vibration mode . for the purposes of our present findings , only one aspect of this experiment should be modified : the quality of the contacts should be improved to achieve a rather high transparency . the fact that the dekker experiment uses a short - circuited trench is not detrimental for our consideration because the auto - correlation noise provides us with all the information we need , and according to our results the noise measured on either side of the stm tip is the same . upon completion of this manuscript , we noted a preprint @xcite which deals with photo - assisted transport in carbon nanotubes . however , this study does not take into account the effect of coulomb interactions , which is the main focus of our work , and it is confined to the calculation of the conductance as opposed to our noise calculation . 99 c. kane , l. balents , and m. p. a. fisher , phys . lett . * 79 * , 5086 ( 1997 ) . m. brockrath , d.h . cobden , j. lu , a.g . rinzler , r.e . smalley , l. balents , and p. mceuen , nature * 397 * , 598 ( 1999 ) . a. crpieux , r. guyon , p. devillard , and t. martin , phys . b * 67 * , 205408 ( 2003 ) . lebedev , a. crpieux , and t. martin , phys . rev . b * 71 * , 075416 ( 2005 ) . f. dolcini , h. grabert , i. safi , and b. trauzettel , phys . lett . * 91 * , 266402 ( 2003 ) ; b. trauzettel , i. safi , f. dolcini , and h. grabert , phys . rev . lett . * 92 * , 226405 ( 2004 ) ; f. dolcini , b. trauzettel , i. safi , and h. grabert , phys . rev . b * 71 * , 165309 ( 2005 ) . w. schottky , ann . ( leipzig ) * 57 * , 541 ( 1928 ) . r. j. schoelkopf , a. a. kozhevnikov , d. e. prober , and m. j. rooks , phys . * 80 * , 2437 ( 1998 ) . a. a. kozhevnikov , r. j. schoelkopf , and d. e. prober , phys . lett . * 84 * , 3398 ( 2000 ) . l. h. reydellet , p. roche , d. c. glattli , b. etienne , and y. jin , phys . 90 * , 176803 ( 2003 ) . g. b. lesovik and l. s. levitov , phys . lett . * 72 * , 538 ( 1994 ) . p.k . tien and j.p . gordon , phys . rev . * 129 * , 647 ( 1963 ) . g. b. lesovik , t. martin and j. torrs , phys . b * 60 * , 11935 ( 1999 ) ; j. torrs , t. martin , and g. b. lesovik phys . rev . b * 63 * , 134517 ( 2001 ) . a. crpieux , p. devillard , and t. martin , phys . b * 69 * , 205302 ( 2004 ) . r. egger and a. gogolin , eur . j. b * 3 * , 781 ( 1998 ) . i. safi and h. j. schulz , phys . b * 52 * , 17040 ( 1995 ) ; d. l. maslov and m. stone , phys . rev . b * 52 * , 5539 ( 1995 ) ; v. v. ponomarenko , phys . rev . b * 52 * , r8666 ( 1995 ) . c. chamon and d. e. freed , phys . rev . b * 60 * , 1842 ( 1999 ) . keldysh , sov . jetp * 20 * , 1018 ( 1965 ) . t. martin and r. landauer , phys . b * 45 * , 1742 ( 1992 ) ; m. bttiker , phys . rev . lett . * 65 * , 2901 ( 1990 ) ; phys . b * 46 * , 12485 ( 1992 ) . s. g. lemay , j. w. janssen , m. van den hout , m. mooij , m. j. bronikowski , p. a. willis , r. e. smalley , l. p. kouwenhoven , and c. dekker , nature * 412 * , 617 ( 2001 ) . a. thielmann , m. h. hettler , j. knig , and g. schn , phys . b * 71 * , 045341 ( 2005 ) . e. onac , f. balestro , b. trauzettel , c. f. j. lodewijk , and l. p. kouwenhoven , phys . lett . * 96 * , 026803 ( 2006 ) . p. recher , n. y. kim , and y. yamamoto , phys . b * 74 * , 235438 ( 2006 ) . g. platero and r. aguado , phys * 395 * , 1 ( 2004 ) . p. m. billangeon , f. pierre , h. bouchiat , and r. deblock , phys . lett . * 96 * , 136804 ( 2006 ) . b. j. leroy , s. g. lemay , j. kong , and c. dekker , appl . . lett . * 84 * , 4280 ( 2004 ) ; b. j. leroy , s. g. lemay , j. kong , and c. dekker , nature * 432 * , 371 ( 2004 ) ; b. j. leroy , j. kong , v. k. pahilwani , c. dekker , and s. g. lemay , phys . rev . b * 72 * , 075413 ( 2005 ) ; s. sapmaz , p. jarillo - herrero , ya . m. blanter , c. dekker , and h. s. j. van der zant , phys . lett . * 96 * , 026801 ( 2006 ) . a. orellana and m. pacheco , cond - mat/0611378 , unpublished .

the injection of electrons in the bulk of carbon nanotube which is connected to ideal fermi liquid leads is considered . while the presence of the leads gives a cancellation of the noise cross - correlations , the auto - correlation noise has a fano factor which deviates strongly from the schottky behavior at voltages where finite size effects are expected . indeed , as the voltage is increased from zero , the noise is first super - poissonian , then sub - poissonian , and eventually it reaches the schottky limit . these finite size effects are also tested using a diagnosis of photo - assisted transport , where a small ac modulation is superposed to the dc bias voltage between the injection tip and the nanotube . when finite size effects are at play , we obtain a stepwise behavior for the noise derivative , as expected for normal metal systems , whereas in the absence of finite size effects , due to the presence of coulomb interactions , a smoothed staircase is observed . the present work shows that it is possible to explore finite size effects in nanotube transport via a zero - frequency noise measurement .

astro-ph0409626

gx1 + 4 is an x - ray binary system harboring a @xmath4130s pulsar ( [ 13 , 10 , 8 ] ) accreting mass from a red giant companion of class m5 iii ( v2116 ophiuchi ; [ 6,2,4,18 ] ) . among the large x - ray binary zoo , we know so far only another system hosting a neutron star ( ns ) with a red giant companion : 4u 1700 + 24 ( [ 16,9 ] ) . gx1 + 4 shows an unpredictably variable x - ray flux on timescales from hours to decades . at the time of its discovery ( [ 13 ] ) it was one of the brightest object in the x - ray sky and it had the largest spin - up rate recorded for any pulsar at that time . the average spin - up trend reversed inexplicably in 1983 switching to spin - down at approximately the same rate . so far a remarkable number of changes in the sign of the torque has been observed for this source ( [ 3 ] ) . this is somehow a peculiar object among the x - ray binaries not only because of its red giant companion , but also because of the high magnetic field that the ns is believed to have ( @xmath5 g ; [ 7,11,5 ] ) . in fact , the presence of a such high magnetic field in a slowly rotating ns with a red giant companion is an intriguing puzzle for the evolutionary scenario of this system . here we report on the timing and spectral x - ray properties of gx 1 + 4 , in particular on a strange drop in the flux occurred in 2000 november 1st during a _ bepposax _ observation . the _ bepposax _ observatory covered more than three decades of energy , from 0.1200kev . the payload was composed by four co - aligned instruments : the narrow field instruments ( [ 1 ] : lecs , 0.110kev ; mecs , 110kev ; hpgspc , 4100kev ; pds , 15200kev ) and the wide field cameras ( [ 12 ] ) . all the four nfi instruments were on during the @xmath43.5days _ bepposax _ observation carried out around 2000 november 1st . the lightcurve of the x - ray source , in the 0.1200kev energy range , showed a large flux variability ( see fig.1 ) . we searched for coherent pulsations performing a power spectrum analysis followed by a phase - fitting analysis , and we found the spin period value of @xmath6s ( phase zero calculated at tjd 11785.000781 ; errors in the text are at 1@xmath7 confidence level ) . in order to study the possible evolution or changes of the timing properties of the source , we divided the observation in 10 time intervals and looked for pulsations all over each interval in different energy bands . making this division we noticed that outside of the low x - ray flux event , all instruments showed pulsations at the same spin period @xmath8s in the whole _ bepposax _ energy range ( see fig.2 ) , while in interval d no pulsed emission was detected below @xmath47kev . as we can see from fig.2 , the pulse shape was highly variable either in time or in energy . comparing the phase at which the minimum of the pulse occurs among the hpgspc profiles , we found shifts in phase between all curves : e.g. the folded lightcurve in the interval l is shifted in phase by 0.22 + -0.05 with respect to that in the interval d. along with the pulse profile changes , the pulsed fraction also varies . during the event the pulsed fraction below 7kev was consistent with zero ( 6% upper limit ) , while it increases until @xmath9% in the 735kev energy range . in order to fit the spectra of the source in all the intervals , we first tried several simple models such as a bremsstrahlung emission , as a blackbody plus a power - law , or as a multicolour blackbody , but all these models gave a bad chi - square value . noticing then that the source spectrum in the low - flux state was exactly what is expected for a compton - reflection dominated spectrum , we tried to fit all the spectra with an absorbed cut - off power law with a reflection component ( pexrav model in _ xspec _ ; [ 15 ] ) . this was actually the best model for all the time resolved spectra ( @xmath10 ) with a very small relative reflection strength ( [email protected] ) outside the event and being @xmath12 during the low - flux event ( see fig.3 ) . the @xmath13 ranged between 748@xmath14@xmath15 , reaching the maximum values just before and after the event , while at higher energies , the spectrum showed a hardening when the compton scattering component started to dominate , soon after the flux dropped . all time - resolved spectra showed at least one emission line . only one broad ( @xmath160.3kev ) fe emission line was present at @xmath176.55kev outside of the low - flux event , while in the intervals d and e , the reduced persistent flux revealed the presence of two narrow lines at @xmath46.45kev and @xmath47.05kev , with very high equivalent widths ( @xmath42.1 and 0.5kev , respectively ) . the interpretation of all these lines is very difficult and uncertain considering the limited energy resolution of the mecs . thus , we can only speculate on the origin of the lines . our idea is that the broad line at 6.55kev might be the blend of the neutral fe @xmath18 around 6.4kev and the ionized fe xxv at 6.7kev , while during the event only the neutral fe components are present , the @xmath18 and the @xmath19 . we report here on the longest uninterrupted observation of the x - ray binary system gx1 + 4 . the most important results of this analysis are : i ) a compton - reflection component dominates the source spectrum during a low - flux emission event , ii ) the discovery of the line at @xmath47.05kev during such low - intensity event , iii ) during the latter , a pulsed x - ray emission was detected only at energies @xmath20 7kev , vi ) the detection of a highly variable pulse profile and v ) the detection of a shift in phase of the minimum of the high - energy pulse profile during the low - flux event . hereafter we consider a few models for this event taking in account the results of our analysis . our first idea was that the x - ray source entered in a different emission status ( as happen for some x - ray binaries ) , where the flux diminishes and the spectrum changes . however , since one spectral model was able to describe all the spectra and that the spectrum during the low - flux event was compton - reflection dominated , we ruled out this first hypothesis . in fact , the reflection component should be produced by a compton thick material that reprocesses the source photons . this reprocessing occurs through the compton - reflection process , where x - rays and @xmath21-rays emitted by a source impinge upon a slab of material ( e.g. accretion disk ) and re - emerge with a spectrum altered by the compton scattering and the bound - free absorption . this process cause a characteristic hardening in the x - ray spectrum which is due to the onset of the reflected component , which appears at energies @xmath2010kev , as a result of the increased importance of the compton scattering in comparison with the bound - free absorption , which instead dominates at low - energies ( [ 21 , 14 ] ) . at this point , we were then interested to figure out the geometry and the nature of the material responsible for the reflection . concerning the geometry , one possibility is that the ns was simply hidden in a partial eclipse caused by the giant companion . the partial covering might be due to part of the giant star ( a spherical cap ) which temporarily occults the ns direct x - ray emission from our line of sight . although this eclipse scenario is consistent with the source variability , however , a wide solid angle of compton thick material around the source is needed in order to produce such highly reflection dominated spectrum , and this large solide angle can not be produced by the stellar companion wind only . moreover , taking into account the large size of the companion star compared with the 10 km radius of the ns , the occurrence of a @xmath490ks eclipse , requires an ad hoc fine tuning of the line of sight inclination with respect to the orbital plane . another possible geometry might be a torus - like accretion disk around the compact source , due to matter coming from the giant companion . the lobes of the torus become thicker and increase in volume with increasing of the accretion rate . the direct emission of the ns would had been hidden by one side of the torus while the other side of the torus reflected it , causing the drop of the flux and the compton reflected spectrum . this model can explain as well the lack of detection of the low - energy pulsations , as they are too weak to keep their coherence through the scattering in the thick torus material . moreover , during the low - emission event the photons make a different path before reaching the observer , compared to the direct emission phases , and this can be the cause of the shift in the spin - phases revealed in the high - energy pulsations ( see fig.2 right panel ) . this scenario requires an highly variable mass accretion rate , possibly due to a variable mass loss from the red giant companion , which is expected from these stars . thus , note that the accretion rate variability of this source , is well supported by the detections of spin - torque variations in the source timing history ( [ 3 ] ) . this latter model we propose in order to explain the low - flux event , is in analogy with what was proposed for some agn sources and for some of the highly absorbed _ integral _ sources ( [ 20,19,17 ] ) . if this scenario is correct we can imagine that the highly absorbed _ integral _ sources are compact binary systems of this type for which our unlucky line of sight , hides the direct emission of the compact object behind the accretion torus lobes . note that the absorption value reached by gx1 + 4 in some part of the observation is similar of the @xmath13 found for some of this highly absorbed _ integral _ sources , although a compton - reflection component was never unambiguously revealed in these sources so far . boella , g. , et al . 1997 , a&as , 122 , 299 chakrabarty d. , et al . 1997a , a&as , 190 , 450 chakrabarty d. et al . 1997b , apj , 481 , l101 chakrabarty d , et al . 1998 , apj , 497 , l39 cui w. et al . 1997 , apj , 482 , l163 davidsen a. , et al . 1977 , apj , 211 , 866 dotani t. , et al . 1989 , pasj , 41 , 427 galloway d.k . , et al . 2001 , mnras , 325 , 419 galloway d.k . 2002 , apj , 580 , 1065 giles a.b . , 2000 , apj , 529 , 447 greenhill j.g . , 1993 , mnras , 260 , 21 jager r. et al . 1997 , a&as , 125 , 557 lewin w.h.g . , rickter g.r . & mcclintock j.e , 1971 , apj , 169 , l17 lightman a.p . & white t.r . 1988 , apj , 335 , 57 magdziarz p. & zdziarski a.a . 1995 , mnras , 273 , 837 masetti , n. , et al . 2002 , a&a , 382 , 104 matt g. & guainazzi m. , 2003 , mnras , 341 , l13 pereira m.g . , et al . , 1997 , iauc 6698 , 4 revnivtsev m. g. , et al . 2003 , astl , 29 , 587 walter r. , et al .. 2003 , a&a , 411 , l427 white t.r . , lightman a.p . & zdziarski a.a . , 1988 , apj , 331 , 939

we report on a long x - ray observation of the slow - rotating binary pulsar gx1 + 4 . _ bepposax _ observed , in the 0.1200kev energy range , an event in which the source flux dropped for almost a day , and then recovered . during this event only the high - energy emission was found to be pulsed and the pulsations were shifted in phase of @xmath0 . the spectrum during the event was well fitted by a compton - reflection model . a broad iron line at @xmath1kev was present outside of the event , where instead two narrow emission lines at @xmath2kev and @xmath3kev were detected . the pulse profile was highly variable as a function of both energy and time . we interpret this low - flux event as an occultation of the direct x - ray emission , due to the increase of a torus - like accretion disk ; we then discuss similarities between this source and the recently discovered highly absorbed _ integral _ sources . , , , , , and neutron star , pulsar , binary system , gx1 + 4 , compton reflection

quant-ph0603269

entanglement plays a central role in quantum information theory . it is considered a resource for quantum communication and teleportation , as well as for various computational tasks @xcite . the importance of understanding entanglement in a relativistic setting has received considerable attention recently @xcite . such an understanding is certainly relevant from a fundamental point of view , since relativity is an indispensable component of any complete theoretical model . however , it is also important in a number of practical situations , for example , when considering the implementation of quantum information processing tasks performed by observers in arbitrary relative motion . entanglement was shown to be an invariant quantity for observers in uniform relative motion in the sense that , although different inertial observers may see these correlations distributed among several degrees of freedom in different ways , the total amount of entanglement is the same in all inertial frames @xcite . in non - inertial frames , entanglement was first studied indirectly by investigating the fidelity of teleportation between two parties in relative uniform acceleration @xcite . more recently , the observer - dependent character of entanglement was explicitly demonstrated by studying the entanglement between two modes of a free scalar field as viewed by two relatively accelerated observers @xcite . a uniformly accelerated observer is unable to access information about the whole of spacetime since , from his perspective , a communication horizon appears . this can result in a loss of information and a corresponding degradation of entanglement . in essence , the acceleration of the observer effects a kind of `` enviromental decoherence '' , limiting the fidelity of certain quantum information - theoretic processes . a quantitative understanding of such degradation in non - inertial frames is therefore required if one wants to discuss the implementation of certain quantum information processing tasks between accelerated partners . in curved spacetime two nearby inertial observers are relatively accelerated due to the geodesic deviation equation . accordingly , the results of @xcite indicate that in curved spacetime even two inertial observers will disagree on the degree of entanglement in a given bipartite quantum state of some quantum field . indeed , a thorough investigation into entanglement in an expanding curved spacetime shows that entanglement can encode information concerning the underlying spacetime structure @xcite . in this paper we analyze the entanglement between two modes of a dirac field described by relatively accelerated parties in a flat spacetime . we are interested in understanding how both the crucial sign change in fermi - dirac versus bose - einstein distributions , and the finite number of allowed states in fermionic systems due to the pauli exclusion principle ( in contrast to the unbounded excitations that can occur in bosonic systems ) , affect the degradation of entanglement produced by the unruh effect . we find that unlike the bosonic case , where the entanglement degrades completely in the infinite acceleration limit , in the fermionic case the entanglement is never completely destroyed . we analyze the degradation of entanglement in the system by applying the constraints of entanglement sharing @xcite and track the information originally encoded in these quantum correlations by employing a set of multi - qubit complementarity relations @xcite . as in @xcite , our results can be applied to the case that alice falls into a black hole whilst rob barely escapes through eternal uniform acceleration . the remainder of this paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ sec : setting ] we consider two modes of a free dirac field that are maximally entangled from an inertial perspective . two parties , an inertial observer named alice and a uniformly accelerating observer named rob , are each assumed to possess a detector sensitive only to one of the two modes . each measures the field with his / her detector and the results are compared in order to estimate the entanglement between the modes . section [ sec : unruh ] discusses the unruh effect for dirac particles as experienced by rob . if a given dirac mode is in the vacuum state from an inertial perspective , then rob s detector perceives a fermi - dirac distribution of particles . this has a strong effect on the entanglement that exists between alice and rob , and therefore plays an important role in any quantum information task they might perform that uses this entanglement as a resource . in sec . [ sec : ent ] we calculate the entanglement between the modes from the perspectives of both alice and rob . due to the presence of a rindler horizon , rob is forced to trace over a causally disconnected region of spacetime that he can not access . accordingly , his description of the system takes the form of a two - qubit mixed state . we calculate the entanglement using mixed state entanglement measures such as the entanglement of formation @xcite and the logarithmic negativity @xcite . we also estimate the total correlations ( classical plus quantum ) via the mutual information @xcite . our results show that the entanglement of formation does not vanish as it does in the bosonic case , but rather reaches a minimum of @xmath0 in the limit that rob moves with infinite acceleration . since the fermionic system we are considering is accurately described by a pure state of three qubits , we study the constraints placed on the system by the phenomenon of entanglement sharing in sec . [ sec : ent_sharing ] . our analysis shows that no inherently three - body correlations are generated in the quantum state . that is , all of the entanglement in the system is in the form of bipartite correlations , regardless of rob s rate of acceleration . using complementarity relations applicable to an overall pure state of three qubits , as well as to the various two - qubit marginals , we identify the different types of information encoded in the quantum state of our system in sec . [ sec : complementarity ] . this enables us to study how specific subsystem properties depend on rob s rate of acceleration and to explain how some of the entanglement from the inertial frame is able to survive in the fermionic system , even at infinite acceleration . finally , we summarize our results and suggest possible directions for further research in sec . [ sec : conclusions ] . consider a free minkowski dirac field in @xmath1 dimensions @xmath2where @xmath3 is the particle mass , @xmath4 the dirac gamma matrices , and @xmath5 is a spinor wavefunction . minkowski coordinates @xmath6 with @xmath7 are the most suitable to describe the field from an inertial perspective . the field can be expanded in terms of the positive ( fermions ) and negative ( antifermions ) energy solutions of the dirac equation @xmath8 and @xmath9 respectively , since they form a complete orthonormal set of modes , @xmath10 in the above , @xmath11 is a notational shorthand for the wavevector @xmath12 which labels the modes . the positive and negative energy minkowski modes have the form @xmath13 where @xmath14 , and @xmath15 is a constant spinor with @xmath16 indicating spin - up or spin - down along the quantization axis , satisfying the normalization relations @xcite @xmath17 , @xmath18 , with the adjoint spinor given by @xmath19 . the above positive and negative energy solutions satisfy the orthogonormality relations @xmath20 where the dirac inner product for two mode functions is given by @xmath21 the modes @xmath22 are classified as positive and negative frequency with respect to ( the future - directed minkowski killing vector ) @xmath23 for @xmath24 , i.e. @xmath25 the operators @xmath26 and @xmath27 are the creation and annihilation operators for the positive and negative energy solutions of momentum @xmath11 which satisfy the anticonmutation relations @xmath28with all other anticommutators vanishing . the minkowski vacuum state is defined by the absence of any mode excitations in an inertial frame , @xmath29where the @xmath30 superscript on the kets is used to indicate the particle and anti - particle vacua , respectively so that @xmath31 . we will use the notation here , and throughout the rest of the work , that the mode index ( @xmath32 ) will be a subscript affixed to the occupation number inside the ket , and that the absence of a subscript on the outside of the ket indicates a minkowski fock state . since @xmath33 , there are only two allowed states for each mode , @xmath34 and @xmath35 for particles , and similarly for anti - particles . consider two maximally entangled fermionic modes in an inertial frame , @xmath36 and @xmath37 indicate the modes associated with the observers alice and rob , respectively . all other modes of the field are in the vacuum state , and therefore the state can be written as @xmath38 . now assume that alice is stationary and has a detector sensitive only to mode @xmath39 . rob moves with uniform acceleration and takes with him a detector that only detects particles corresponding to mode @xmath40 . we ask the question of what is the entanglement between modes @xmath39 and @xmath40 observed by alice and rob , given that rob undergoes uniform acceleration . note that in order to determine the amount of entanglement , alice and rob perform measurements which are then compared by either party in order to estimate the correlations in the results . due to rob s acceleration , at some point alice s signals will no longer reach rob , but rob s signals will always be available to alice , ( see ) . at this point only alice can compare the measurement results and estimate the entanglement of the state . let us now consider the state observed by rob . consider rob to be uniformly accelerated in the @xmath41 plane ( @xmath42 ) . rindler coordinates @xmath43 are appropriate for describing the viewpoint of an observer moving with uniform acceleration . two different sets of rindler coordinates , which differ from each other by an overall change in sign , are necessary for covering minkowski space @xcite . these sets of coordinates define two rindler regions that are causally disconnected from each other . @xmath44 where @xmath45 denotes rob s proper acceleration . the above set of coordinates both give rise to the same metric @xmath46 where @xmath47 are the same in both minkowski and rindler spacetimes . are hyperbolas and lines of constant proper time @xmath48 for the accelerated observer run through the origin . note that while @xmath48 flows in the direction of @xmath49 in region i , it flows in the direction of @xmath50 in region ii , ( i.e the dashed line rotates counter - clockwise for increasing values of @xmath48 ) . a uniformly accelerated observer rob ( @xmath37 ) with acceleration @xmath45 travels on a hyperbola constrained to region i , while a fictitious observer anti - rob @xmath51 travels on a corresponding hyperbola in region ii given by the negative of rob s coordinates . the horizons @xmath52 are lines of @xmath53 which alice ( @xmath54 ) will cross at finite minkowski times.,width=336,height=240 ] a particle undergoing eternal uniform acceleration remains constrained to either rindler region i or ii and has no access to the opposite region , since these two regions are causally disconnected . figure [ fig1 ] serves to illustrate these ideas , as well as to introduce our labeling scheme , where we refer to the accelerated observer in region i as rob ( r ) and to the corresponding fictitious observer confined to region ii ( whose coordinates are the negative of rob s ) as anti - rob @xmath55 . the coordinates @xmath43 have the ranges @xmath56 separately in region i and in region ii . this implies that region i and ii each admit a separate quantization procedure with corresponding positive and negative energy solutions @xmath57 and @xmath58 . since the rindler metric is static ( independent of @xmath48 ) it will admit solutions of the form @xmath59 , with @xmath60 a spatially dependent spinor @xcite . particles and anti - particles will be classified with respect to the future - directed timelike killing vector in each region . in region i this is given by @xmath61 where @xmath62 which is a boost into the instantaneous comoving frame of rob . thus , mode solutions in region i having time dependence @xmath63 with @xmath64 represent positive frequency solutions since @xmath65 . however , in region ii @xmath61 points in the opposite direction of @xmath66 ( increasing @xmath48 flows in the direction of @xmath50 , see ) . hence in region ii the future - directed timelike killing vector is given by @xmath67 @xcite . thus , a solution in region ii with time dependence @xmath68 with @xmath64 is actually a negative frequency mode since @xmath69 . hence , the positive frequency mode in region ii is given by @xmath70 with @xmath64 satisfying @xmath71 . due to the causally disjoint nature of region i and ii , the modes @xmath72 have support only in region i and vanish in region ii , while the opposite is true for the modes @xmath73 in region ii . the rindler modes satisfy orthonormality relations analogous to the minkowski modes @xcite @xmath74 , and @xmath75 where @xmath76 . in region i , let us denote @xmath77 as the annihilation and creation operators for fermions ( particles ) and @xmath78 as the annihilation and creation operators for anti - fermions ( anti - particles ) . the corresponding particle and anti - particle operators in region ii are denoted as @xmath79 and @xmath80 . these obey the usual dirac anti - commutation relations @xmath81 @xmath82 @xmath83 , with all other anti - commutators , including those between operators in region i and the causally disconnected region ii , equaling zero . taking into account the two sets of modes in each rindler region , the dirac field can be expanded , in analogy to , as @xmath84 and represent the decomposition of the dirac field in minkowski and rindler modes , respectively . we can therefore relate the minkowski and rindler creation and annihilation operators by taking appropriate inner products . using the rindler orthogonality relations and we have @xmath85 . substituting for @xmath86 in this last expression yields c^_k = dk ( ^_kk a_k + ^_kk b^_k ) , \{i , ii } where the bogoliubov coefficients are given by the inner product of the rindler modes wavefunctions with the minkowski positive and negative frequency modes ^_kk = ( ^+_k , ^+_k ) , ^_kk = ( ^+_k , ^-_k ) . a similar calculation for @xmath87 yields the corresponding expression d^_k = dk ( ^_kk b_k + ^_kk a^_k ) , \{i , ii } with the same bogoliubov coefficient as in . in deriving use has been made of the following properties of the dirac inner product : @xmath88 . the calculation of the bogoliubov coefficients is straightforward , though lengthy and an exercise in special functions . details can be found elsewhere @xcite . for our purposes , the end result of such calculations yields a relationship between the minkowski and rindler creation and annihilation operators given by the bogoliubov transformation = , where @xmath89 with @xmath90 , the ratio of the frequency @xmath91 to the only naturally occurring frequency in the problem @xmath92 , and @xmath93 is an unimportant phase that can always be absorbed into the definition of the operators . it is easy to see from and its adjoint that given the anti - commutation relations of the rindler operators , the minkowski anti - commutation relations are preserved . in we have made the @xcite , which is valid if we consider rob s detector as sensitive to a single particle mode in region i such that we can approximate the frequency @xmath94 observed by alice to be the same as the frequency @xmath95 as observed by rob , i.e @xmath96 @xcite . note that this bogoliubov transformation mixes a particle in region i and an anti - particle in region ii . correspondingly , the bogoliubov transformation that mixes an anti - particle mode in region i and a particle in region ii is given by = . since the anti - commutators between particle and anti - particle operators and between region i and region ii rindler operators are zero , it is easy to see that the minkowski operators in anti - commute with the minkowski operators in , as they should ( since @xmath11 and @xmath97 represent two separate modes ) . as stated above , reveals that the minkowski particle annihilation operator is a bogoliubov transformation between a particle in region i of momentum @xmath11 and an anti - particle in region ii of momentum @xmath97 , i.e. a transformation that mixes creation and annihilation operators . we can understand this in terms of our previous discussion of the time dependence of positive frequency rindler modes in regions i and ii . for a massless dirac field a positive frequency rindler mode has the form @xcite @xmath98 ( for the scalar case see @xcite ) and a positive frequency rindler mode in region ii has the form @xmath99 . thus , in order to construct a positive frequency minkowski mode @xmath100 that extends @xmath101 analytically from region i to region ii , we need a linear combination of @xmath101 and @xmath102 so that both have the space and time dependence @xmath103 . this means that the minkowski operator @xmath104 must mix @xmath105 and @xmath106 as in . similarly , to construct a minkowski mode that analytically extends @xmath107 from region ii to region i we must form a linear combination of @xmath107 and @xmath108 so that both have the space and time dependence @xmath109 this corresponds to @xmath110 mixing @xmath111 and @xmath112 as in . for a massive dirac field the time dependence of the rindler modes remains the same , but the spatial dependence is more complicated @xcite . the above argument for the mixing of rindler particles ( anti - particles ) in region i ( ii ) and anti - particles ( particles ) in region ii ( i ) goes through unchanged . having related minkowski and rindler creation and annihilation operators , we now wish to relate the minkowski vacuum to the corresponding rindler vacuum . it is useful to note that can be written as a two - mode squeezing transformation @xcite @xmath113 = s\ , \left [ \begin{array}{c } c^{i}_k \\ d^{ii\dagger}_{-k } \\ \end{array } \right]\ , s^\dagger\ ] ] for the single mode @xmath11 with @xmath114 given by @xmath115.\ ] ] using the relation @xmath116 + [ b,[b , a]]/2 ! + [ b,[b,[b , a]]]/3 ! + \cdots$ ] and the identity @xmath117 = a\,\{b , c\ } - \{a , c\}\,b$ ] we find a_k & = & s c^i_k s^= c^i_k - r e^-id^ii_-k - c^i_k + e^-id^ii_-k + & = & r c^i_k - e^-i r d^ii_-k . and b^_-k & = & s d^ii_-k s^= d^ii_-k + r e^ic^i_k - d^ii_-k - e^ic^i_k + & = & r d^ii_-k + e^-i r c^i_k . now @xmath104 and @xmath118 , respectively , annihilate the single mode particle and anti - particle minkowski vacua @xmath119 and @xmath120 . since @xmath104 mixes particles in region i and anti - particles in region ii , we postulate that the minkowski particle vacuum for mode @xmath11 in terms of rindler fock states is given by |0_k^+ = _ n=0 ^ 1 a_n |n_k^+_i|n_-k^-_ii , where @xcite lll c^i_k |0_k^+_i = 0 & & d^ii_-k |0_-k^-_ii = 0 , + & & + c^i_k |0_k^+_i = |1_k^+_i & & d^ii_-k |0_-k^-_ii = |1_-k^-_ii . + as a comment on notation , the rindler region i and ii fock states carry a subscript i or ii , respectively , on the kets while the minkowski fock states are indicated by the absence of an outside subscript on the kets . momentum mode labels are attached to the fock occupation number , and the @xmath30 ket superscript indicates a particle or anti - particle state , respectively . applying @xmath104 from to , we have 0 & = & a_k |0_k^+ & = & ( r c^i_k - e^-i r d^ii_-k ) _ n=0 ^ 1 a_n e^-ir . @xmath122 yields @xmath123 so that we finally arrive at |0_k^+ & = & r where the second equality in is very useful for keeping track of any possible transposition signs arising from the anti - commuting operators when applying minkowski operators to @xmath124 . as an important example that we will use subsequently , a short calculation of @xmath125 using the adjoint of a_k^= r c^i_k - e^+i r d^ii_-k , acting on the lower expression for @xmath124 in , yields a_k^|0_k^+ & = & ( ^2 r c^i_k - ^2 r d^ii_-kc^i_kd^ii_-k ) |0_k^+_i|0_-k^-_ii , & = & ( ^2 r c^i_k + ^2 r c^i_kd^ii_-kd^ii_-k , ) |0_k^+_i|0_-k^-_ii & = & c^i_k|0_k^+_i|0_-k^-_ii , the anti - commutation relations between @xmath126 and @xmath127 to obtain a minus sign upon transposition , and in the third equality we have used the anti - commutation relations to write @xmath128 , noting that the latter term annihilates the anti - particle vacuum . lastly , one can easily verify that @xmath129 acting on @xmath130 yields zero , a_k^|1_k^+ = ( r c^i_k - e^+i r d^ii_-k ) |1_k^+_i|0_-k^-_ii = 0 , ensuring that @xmath131 . we note that the form of the dirac particle vacuum for mode @xmath11 in , which can be written as @xmath132 , is complementary to the form of the minkowski charged scalar vacuum for mode @xmath11 , which is given by @xcite @xmath133 where in the latter case @xmath134 is defined by @xmath135 . qualitatively , in going from the scalar field to the dirac field , scalar mode functions are replaced by spinors , the infinite number of equally spaced bosonic levels are replaced by two fermionic levels , and the hyperbolic functions in the bogoluibov transformation between minkowski and rindler modes / operators are replaced by the corresponding trigonometric functions ( in essence @xmath136 in going from the scalar to the dirac field ) . the two minkowski states , @xmath124 and @xmath130 , correspond to the particle field of mode @xmath11 observed by alice . on the other hand , an observer moving with uniform acceleration @xmath45 in one of the regions has no access to field modes in the causally disconnected region . therefore , the observer must trace over the inaccessible region , constituting an unavoidable loss of information about the state , which essentially results in the detection of a mixed state . thus , when a minkowski observer detects a vacuum state @xmath137 for mode @xmath11 , an accelerated observer in region i sees a distribution of particles according to the marginal state describing region i , _ k^i & = & tr_ii&= & ^2 r|0_k^+_i^+_i0_k| + ^2 r|1_k^+_i^+_i1_k| . as the region i observer accelerates through the minkowski particle vacuum @xmath124 of mode @xmath11 his detector registers a number of particles given by & = & tr_i= ^2 r ^+_i1_k|c^i_k c^i_k |1_k^+_i & = & ^2 r = where use has been made of @xmath89 with @xmath138 , and we have defined the unruh temperature ( where @xmath139 is boltzmann s constant ) as t = . equation ( [ thermalization ] ) is known as the unruh effect @xcite which shows that the uniformly accelerated observer in region i detects a thermal fermi - dirac ( fd ) distribution of particles as he traverses the minkowski vacuum . qualitatively , we can understand the unruh effect as follows . the constant proper force @xmath140 that acts on a mass @xmath3 ( a detector ) in rob s instantaneous co - moving frame , to keep it under uniform acceleration , can be written as @xmath141 ( which can be integrated as @xmath142 where @xmath143 , @xmath144 , to yield the hyperbolic orbits in ) . the work @xmath145 that is performed on the particle to keep it in uniform acceleration is the product of @xmath140 times a characteristic distance through which the force acts , which we take to be the compton wavelength of the particle @xmath146 . this yields @xmath147 , which is proportional to @xmath148 in . thus , the energy that is supplied to keep @xmath3 under constant acceleration goes into exciting rob s detector , and curiously has a thermal spectrum ( see @xcite ) . in the general relativistic case this energy is supplied by the gravitational field acting on a stationary observer ( rob ) situated outside a black hole , who experiences constant acceleration by nature of his stationarity . a freely falling observer ( alice ) who eventually crosses the event horizon would experience the kruskal vacuum ( the minkowski - like vacuum of ) and thus detect no unruh radiation with a co - moving detector . note that in the case of a scalar field , has a crucial minus sign in the denominator leading to a bose - einstein ( be ) distribution of particles appropriate for bosons . in both the scalar and dirac case , the state of the minkowski vacuum for mode @xmath11 is a two - mode squeezed state ( bosonic and fermionic , respectively ) , which to a uniformly accelerated observer confined entirely to region i , is detected as a thermal state ( be and fd , respectively ) . in the following we investigate how the unruh effect for dirac particles affects the entanglement between various dirac modes . specifically , we study the entangled bell state given by in the case that rob is uniformly accelerated in region i. assuming a detector for rob that is sensitive to a single rindler particle mode ( @xmath149 ) , we decompose rob s single particle minkowski states in into the appropriate rindler particle and anti - particle states utilizing eqs . ( [ vacm ] ) and ( [ 1 m ] ) . we then proceed to evaluate various measures of entanglement . as stated in the introduction , the advantage of utilizing a dirac field over a bosonic scalar field is that due to the finite occupation of the fermionic states , we obtain finite dimensional density matrices that lead to closed form expressions for the entanglement measures that are more easily interpreted than their infinite dimensional bosonic counterparts . in this and subsequent sections we will use the following notation : @xmath54 will indicate the inertial observer alice , i will indicate the uniformly accelerated observer rob ( r ) confined to region i , and ii will indicate the fictitious complementary observer anti - rob ( @xmath150 ) in region ii ( see ) , that arises from the second ( negative ) set of rindler coordinates in . furthermore , since we are in the single mode approximation , we will drop all labels ( @xmath151 ) on states and density matrices indicating the specific mode . thus , the minkowski particle mode @xmath152 for alice will be written @xmath153 , the rindler region i particle mode @xmath154 ( for @xmath155 ) . likewise , we will refer to the minkowski mode for alice " simply as mode @xmath54 " , the rindler particle mode in region i as mode i , " and the rindler anti - particle mode in region ii as mode ii . " the density matrix for the minkowski entangled state in eq . ( [ eq : ent ] ) is , from an inertial perspective @xmath156 in the basis @xmath157 with @xmath158 . here , and only here , we have used the subscript @xmath37 to indicate rob s minkowski fock states in . to describe the entanglement of the state as seen by an inertial alice and a uniformly accelerated rob , we expand the minkowski particle states @xmath159 and @xmath160 into rindler region i and ii particle and anti - particle states using eqs . ( [ vacm ] ) and ( [ 1 m ] ) to obtain @xmath161 which we write in matrix form as @xmath162 in the basis @xmath163 where for notational convenience we have defined @xmath164 . note that the unimportant phase factor @xmath93 discussed in section [ sec : unruh ] has been absorbed into the definition of the creation and annihilation operators . since rob is causally disconnected from region ii , we take the trace over the mode in this region , which results in a mixed density matrix between alice and rob @xmath165 in the basis @xmath157 where @xmath166 . to determine whether or not this state is entangled we use the partial transpose criterion @xcite . this criterion specifies a necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of entanglement in a mixed state of two qubits . if at least one eigenvalue of the partial transpose of the density matrix is negative , then the density matrix is entangled . the partial transpose is obtained by interchanging alice s qubits @xmath167 @xmath168@xmath169 has eigenvalues @xmath170 , the last of which @xmath171 , is always negative for @xmath172 i.e. for @xmath173 . this means that the state is always entangled . quantifying entanglement for mixed states is fairly involved entanglement . a pure state of a bipartite system @xmath45 and @xmath174 can always be written in the schmidt basis , @xmath175 , where the quantum correlations between the states are evident . entanglement between the systems is given by the von - neumann entropy of the reduced density matrix @xmath176 defined as @xmath177 , which is a function of the schmidt coefficients @xmath178 . unfortunately , there is no analog of the schmidt decomposition for mixed states , and the von - neumann entropy is no longer a good measure of mixed state entanglement . a set of conditions that mixed state entanglement measures should satisfy is well known @xcite . there is no unique measure , and several different mixed state entanglement measures have been proposed . among the most popular are those related to the formation and distillation of entangled states . consider the number @xmath3 of maximally entangled pairs needed to create @xmath179 arbitrarily good copies of an arbitrary pure state using only local operations and classical communication . the entanglement of formation is defined as the asymptotic conversion ratio , @xmath180 in the limit of infinitely many copies @xcite , @xmath181where the minimum is taken over all the possible realizations of the state @xmath182 . the opposite process gives rise to the definition of the entanglement of distillation . this is the asymptotic rate of converting non - maximally entangled states into maximally entangled states by means of a purification procedure . the entanglement of distillation is in general smaller than that of formation . this shows that the entanglement conversion is irreversible and is due to a loss of classical information about the decomposition of the state . bound entangled states are a consequence of this : no entanglement can be distilled from them even though they are inseparable . the entanglement of formation can be explicitly calculated for two qubits . it is given by @xmath183 where @xmath184 is the concurrence . the concurrence of a pure state @xmath185 of two qubits is given by @xmath186 where @xmath187 represents the ` spin - flip ' of @xmath185 and * " denotes complex conjugation in the standard basis . the generalization of the concurrence to a mixed state @xmath188 of two qubits follows by minimizing the average concurrence over all possible pure state ensemble decompositions of @xmath188 , defined by a convex combination of pure states @xmath189 , such that @xmath190 . in this way , @xmath191 wootters @xcite succeeded in deriving an analytic solution to this difficult minimization procedure in terms of the quantities @xmath192 defined as the square roots of the eigenvalues ( which are all positive ) of the non - hermitian operator @xmath193 , ordered in decreasing order . the matrix @xmath194 is the spin - flip of the quantum state @xmath195 which not only exchanges the states @xmath196 and @xmath197 , but , in general , also introduces a relative phase . the closed form solution for the concurrence of a mixed state of two qubits is given by @xmath198 unfortunately , the entanglement of distillation can not be explicitly calculated in this case . therefore we will use the logarithmic negativity @xcite which serves as an upper bound on the entanglement of distillation . it is not an entanglement measure because it does not satisfy the requirement of being equal to the von - neuman entropy for pure states . however , it is an entanglement monotone since it satisfies all other criteria to quantify entanglement . it is defined as @xmath199 where @xmath200 is the trace - norm of the partial transpose density matrix @xmath201 i.e. , the sum of the eigenvalues of @xmath202 . since the matrices @xmath203 in this work are symmetric , @xmath204 is simply given by @xmath205 of the sum of the absolute values of the eigenvalues of @xmath201 . to quantify the entanglement of @xmath206 in eq . ( [ eq : state ] ) we compute the spin - flip matrix @xmath207 @xmath208 and find that @xmath209 has eigenvalues @xmath210 . the concurrence is then given by @xmath211 , which is unity at zero acceleration , as expected , and approaches the value @xmath0 for infinite acceleration @xmath212 . the entanglement of formation is @xmath213 and the logarithmic negativity is @xmath214 in an inertial frame , @xmath215 , and the state of the system defined by is maximally entangled . in the limit of infinite acceleration , the logarithmic negativity is @xmath216 , implying that the entanglement in the infinite acceleration limit is finite . this means that the state is always entangled and can be used as a resource for performing certain quantum information processing tasks . this is in strong contrast to the bosonic case @xcite , where it is found that the entanglement goes to zero in this limit . as in @xcite the infinite acceleration limit can be interpreted as alice falling into a black hole while rob hovers outside the black hole , barely escaping the fall . since close to a black hole horizon spacetime is flat , rob must be uniformly accelerated in order to escape the black hole . however , alice falls in as she is an inertial observer . the connection to the present situation is made by recognizing that , according to rob , a communication horizon appears causing him to lose information about the state in the whole of spacetime . as a result , the inertial entanglement is degraded , and there will be a reduction in the fidelity of any information processing task performed by alice and rob using this state . the analogy with the black hole scenario is further strengthened by observing that classical information can only flow from rob to alice after alice has crossed the horizon . we may also calculate the total correlations between any two subsytems of the overall system by using the mutual information @xcite , @xmath217this measure quantifies how much information two correlated observers ( one with access to subsystem @xmath45 and the other with access to subsystem @xmath174 ) possess about one another s state . equivalently , it represents the distance between the actual joint distribution and the product state obtained when all correlations are neglected . calculating the relevant marginal density operators , the mutual information of the state ( [ eq : state ] ) is found to be @xmath218where we have used the fact that the density matrix in region i is @xmath219 $ ] , so that @xmath220similarly , the density matrix of mode @xmath54 is @xmath221 , yielding @xmath222 . finally , using we find that @xmath223 the mutual information is equal to @xmath224 at @xmath215 and goes to unity in the infinite acceleration limit this behavior is reminiscent of that seen in the bosonic case @xcite . to explore entanglement in this system in more detail we consider the tripartite system consisting of the modes @xmath54 , i , and ii . in an inertial frame the system is bipartite , but from a non - inertial perspective an extra set of modes in region ii becomes relevant . we therefore calculate the entanglement in all possible bipartite divisions of the system as well as any tripartite correlations that may exist . we investigate pure state entanglement in three different bipartite divisions of the system . since the overall state of the system is pure , these entanglements are uniquely quantified by the von - neumann entropy . in what follows we make repeated use of the fact that , for a bipartite pure state @xmath225 with subsystems @xmath45 and @xmath174 , @xmath226 and @xmath227 . there are three separate cases to consider . * the entanglement between mode @xmath54 and ( modes i and ii ) is given by @xmath228 . thus , these two subsystems are always maximally entangled , regardless of the value of the parameter @xmath134 . * the entanglement between mode i and ( modes @xmath54 and ii ) is given by eq . ( [ sr1 ] ) since @xmath229 . * finally , the entanglement between mode ii and ( modes @xmath54 and i ) is given by eq . ( [ skr1 ] ) since @xmath230 . figure ( [ fig : entropy ] ) shows the entanglement in each of these bipartite partitions as functions of @xmath134 . [ entropy ] for mixed state entanglement we can consider , besides the entanglement between the minkowski mode @xmath54 and rindler mode i calculated in sec . [ sec : ent ] , two additional bipartite divisions of the subsystems . * the entanglement between mode @xmath54 and mode ii . tracing over the mode in region i , we obtain the density matrix @xmath231the partial transpose of @xmath232 is given by @xmath233which has eigenvalues @xmath234 , the last of which @xmath235 , is less than or equal to zero . at @xmath236 the eigenvalue is zero , which means that there is no entanglement at this point . however , for any @xmath237 entanglement does exist between these two modes according to the partial transpose criterion . the logarithmic negativity in this case is given by @xmath238 . + calculating the spin - flip of @xmath232 @xmath239we find that @xmath240has eigenvalues @xmath241 . thus , the concurrence is given by @xmath242 , which is zero at zero acceleration as expected , and approaches the value @xmath0 for infinite acceleration @xmath212 . the entanglement of formation is @xmath243and the mutual information is@xmath244at @xmath215 the mutual information is zero and approaches unity as the rate of acceleration goes to infinity . * the entanglement between mode i and mode ii . tracing over the modes in @xmath54 , we obtain the density matrix @xmath245the partial transpose of @xmath246 ( obtained by interchanging @xmath247 s qubits ) is given by @xmath248which has eigenvalues @xmath249 , the last of which @xmath250 $ ] is less than or equal to zero . again , at @xmath215 there is no entanglement between these two subsystems . yet , similar to the last case , entanglement does exist between these two modes in non - inertial frames according to the partial transpose criterion . further , the logarithmic negativity @xmath251 is nonzero for all @xmath237 . the spin - flip of @xmath252 is given by @xmath253and the matrix @xmath254has eigenvalues @xmath255 . thus , the concurrence is given by @xmath256 which is zero at zero acceleration , and approaches the value @xmath257 for infinite acceleration @xmath212 . the entanglement of formation in this case is + @xmath258 + and the mutual information is@xmath259 again , we find that the mutual information is zero at @xmath215 , and increases to a finite value ( in this case @xmath260 ) , as the rate of acceleration goes to infinity . the results of the above calculations are shown in figs . ( [ fig : nega ] ) - ( [ fig : mutual ] ) . [ nega ] [ formation ] [ mutual ] entanglement in triparite systems has been studied by coffman , et . al . , @xcite for the case of three qubits . they found that such quantum correlations can not be arbitrarily distributed amongst the subsystems ; the existence of three - body correlations constrains the distribution of the bipartite entanglement which remains after tracing over any one of the qubits . for example , in a ghz - state , @xmath261 , tracing over one qubit results in maximally mixed state containing no entanglement between the remaining two qubits . in constrast , for a w - state , @xmath262 , the average remaining bipartite entanglement is maximal . coffman , et . al . , analyzed this phenomenon of entanglement sharing @xcite , using an entanglement monotone known as the tangle , defined as the square of the concurrence @xmath263 . they also introduced a new quantity , known as the residual tangle , in order to quantify the irreducible tripartite correlations in a system of three qubits ( @xmath45 , @xmath174 , and @xmath264 ) @xcite . the definition is motivated by the observation that the tangle of @xmath45 with @xmath174 plus the tangle of @xmath45 with @xmath264 can not exceed the tangle of @xmath45 with the joint subsystem @xmath265 , i.e. , @xmath266 subtracting the terms on the left hand side of eq . ( [ eq tangle ineq ] ) from that on the right hand side yields a nonnegative quantity referred to as the residual tangle @xmath267 , i.e. , @xmath268 the residual tangle or three tangle is interpreted as quantifying the inherent tripartite entanglement present in a system of three qubits , i.e. , the entanglement that can not be accounted for in terms of the various bipartite tangles . this interpretation is given further support by the observation that the residual tangle is invariant under all possible permutations of the subsystem labels @xcite . to quantify tripartite entanglement in our system we use the residual tangle @xmath269 . this quantity is zero for the situation we are considering , since @xmath270 , @xmath271 and @xmath272)=1 $ ] . thus , the state that we are studying has no tripartite correlations for any value of the acceleration rate . instead , any entanglement existing in the system is necessarily bipartite in nature . the marginal bipartite tangles , plotted in fig . [ fig : tangles ] as functions of @xmath134 , are found to be strongly constrained . for low rates of acceleration , modes @xmath54 and i remain almost maximally entangled while there is very little entanglement between modes i and ii and between modes @xmath54 and ii . as the acceleration grows , the entanglement between modes i and ii and between modes @xmath54 and ii increases , while the entanglement between modes @xmath54 and i is degraded . the main system of interest ( mode @xmath54 plus mode i ) becomes increasingly entangled to mode ii and therefore , after tracing over mode ii , we observe an effect analogous to environmental decoherence in which the modes in region ii play the role of the environment . the distribution of entanglement in the system is non - trivial since entanglement between modes @xmath54 and i is not conserved as it is in the inertial case . we next analyze our system in terms of several complementarity relations designed to identify the different types of information encoded in a quantum state in an attempt to better understand how various subsystem properties depend on rob s rate of acceleration . specifically , we are interested in explaining ( i ) the nonconservative nature of the entanglement discussed in the last section and ( ii ) the fact that not all of the initial entanglement between alice and rob is destroyed , even at infinite acceleration . the latter of these two results corresponds to the most obvious difference between the fermionic case studied here and the bosonic case investigated in @xcite . we begin by making use of the relationship @xcite @xmath273 which shows that an arbitrary state of two qubits ( @xmath45 and @xmath174 ) exhibits a complementary tradeoff between the amounts of separable uncertainty @xmath274 , bipartite entanglement ( as quantified by the tangle ) @xmath48 , and a unitarily invariant measure of information about the single particle properties @xmath275 that it encodes . the separable uncertainty @xmath276 @xmath277 is a measure of the uncertainty or ignorance encoded in the two - qubit mixed state @xmath195 regarding individual subsystem properties that is unrelated to the presence of entanglement between the qubits . in eq . ( [ eq : localcorrelations ] ) , @xmath278 represents the spin - flip of @xmath195 , and @xmath279 is the marginal mixedness of @xmath195 . similarly , @xmath280 is a measure of the information pertaining to a single qubit encoded in the marginal density operator @xmath281 . specifically , @xmath282 $ ] is the average of the squares of the single qubit properties associated with qubit @xmath283 . the first of these properties , the coherence @xmath284 of qubit @xmath11 , quantifies , e.g. , the fringe visibility in the context of a two - state system incident on an interferometer , and is given by @xmath285 where @xmath286 is the raising operator acting on qubit @xmath11 . similarly , the predictability @xmath287 which quantifies the _ a priori _ information regarding whether qubit @xmath11 is in the state @xmath288 or the state @xmath289 , e.g. , whether it is more likely to take the upper or lower path in an interferometer , is given by@xmath290 where @xmath291 and @xmath292 is the plus ( minus ) one eigenvector of @xmath293 . figures [ fig : tangles ] and [ fig : eta ] plot the bipartite components of eq . ( [ eq : complementarity ] ) for the various two - qubit marginals obtained after tracing over any one of the three subsystems ( @xmath54 , i , or ii ) as functions of the parameter @xmath134 , while fig . [ fig : single_part ] does the same for the relevant single particle information measures . the complementary nature of these quantities is illustrated by the pattern / color scheme chosen for the curves , where each pattern ( color ) corresponds to a unique set of properties satisfying eq . ( [ eq : complementarity ] ) . adding together all of the curves that contain a common attribute in figs . [ fig : tangles ] - [ fig : single_part ] yields the constant value one , independent of @xmath134 . [ tangles ] [ eta ] [ single_part ] for example , taking the sum of the two dashed ( red ) curves in figs . [ fig : tangles ] and [ fig : eta ] and the two curves containing dashes ( red ) in fig . [ fig : single_part ] , thick - thin dashed ( blue - red ) and dot - dashed ( green - red ) , corresponds to the equality @xmath294 . note that the curves in fig . [ fig : single_part ] , representing information encoded in the individual qubits , each contribute to exactly two distinct complementarity relations . the tradeoffs expressed by eq . ( [ eq : complementarity ] ) , and illustrated in figs . [ fig : tangles ] - [ fig : single_part ] , show how rob s acceleration determines the distribution of individual and bipartite properties of the system . for example , adding together the thick solid ( blue ) and dotted ( green ) curves in fig . [ fig : tangles ] shows that , although the entanglement in any bipartite subsystem changes with acceleration , the total entanglement between alice and ( the modes in regions i and ii ) is always maximal and constant . further , since rob is forced to trace over the causally disconnected modes in region ii , the entanglement arising between the modes in region i and region ii is ultimately responsible for the unruh radiation that he sees . indeed alice , who has access to the modes in both regions , always sees an undisturbed vacuum . however , our analysis shows that the maximum amount of thermalization that rob can experience ( even at infinite acceleration ) is limited by the amount of entanglement that exists between alice and rob in an inertial frame . one straightforward way to see this is to consider the case in which alice and rob initially share no entanglement ( e.g. an arbitrary product state between alice and rob ) . then , as rob s acceleration approaches infinity , we find that @xmath295 approaches its maximum possible value of one ( see with @xmath296 @xcite ) . this is in contrast to the situation considered here in which the initial entanglement between alice and rob is maximal , constraining @xmath295 to a maximum value of 1/4 . since the overall state of our system is always pure , we may also apply the result @xcite @xmath297 which holds for an arbitrary pure state of three qubits ( @xmath45 , @xmath174 , and @xmath264 ) . the quantity @xmath298 is a measure of the total pairwise entanglement shared between qubit @xmath11 and all other qubits . equation ( [ eq : entsharingrel ] ) quantifies an explicit tradeoff between the inherent three - body correlations in a tripartite system , the total pairwise entanglement of a selected qubit , and the single particle properties of the qubit . because the three tangle is always zero for our system , this pure state complementarity relationship simplifies to @xmath299 it is then straightforward to see that this tradeoff is also captured by the pattern / color scheme used in the above figures . simply adding the sum of any two curves in fig . [ fig : tangles ] to the curve in fig . [ fig : single_part ] that is composed of the same two attributes ( or colors ) again yields the constant value one , regardless of rob s acceleration . in particular , this shows that the entanglement between alice and rob in region i can not vanish at infinite acceleration as it did in the bosonic case . this is because the entanglement @xmath295 generated between regions i and ii ( dashed / red curve in fig . [ fig : tangles ] ) and the single particle properties @xmath300 that manifest for rob ( dashed / red - blue curve in fig . [ fig : single_part ] ) are insufficient to satisfy eq . ( [ eq : entsharingrelsimple ] ) . instead , the contribution from the entanglement @xmath301 between alice and rob ( solid / blue curve in fig . [ fig : tangles ] ) must also be taken into account to ensure that @xmath302 . finally , we note that the various two - qubit marginal density operators for our system have a very specific form ; they are all examples of the maximally entangled states with fixed marginal mixednesses ( memms ) identified in @xcite . indeed , this fact is closely related to the absence of tripartite correlations in our system , which implies that any entanglement that exists in the system must necessarily be bipartite . as shown in @xcite , the memms are characterized by the relationship @xmath303 , i.e. , the marginal mixednesses are equal to the separable uncertainties . thus , our fermionic system encodes the maximum amount of bipartite entanglement consistent with the separable uncertainty in each two - qubit marginal for every possible value of the acceleration rate . we have studied the behavior of the entanglement between two modes of a free dirac field in a non - inertial frame in flat spacetime from the point of view of two observers , alice and rob , in relative uniform acceleration . our results show that entanglement existing between alice and rob in an inertial frame is progressively degraded by the unruh effect as rob s rate of acceleration increases . however , unlike the bosonic case in which the inertial entanglement vanishes in the limit of infinite acceleration , in this case the entanglement achieves a minimum value of @xmath0 for the entanglement of formation ( and of @xmath304 for the tangle ) . this fundamental difference , a consequence of the fact that fermions have access to only two quantum levels vs. the infinite ladder of excitations available to bosons , means that in this case alice and rob always share some entanglement which can in principle be used as a resource for performing certain quantum information processing tasks . further analysis shows that the total ( quantum plus classical ) correlations in the system , as quantified by the mutual information , behaves in a manner reminiscent of the bosonic case , decreasing from 2 for inertial observers to unity in the case of infinite acceleration . considering the ( causally inaccessible to rob ) modes in region ii to be a third subsystem allows us to analyze this system in terms of entanglement sharing . in doing so , we find that the overall tripartite pure state never encodes any inherently three - body correlations , regardless of the rate of acceleration . any entanglement existing in the fermionic system is therefore necessarily bipartite . such entanglement is known to be an invariant quantity for inertial observers , although different inertial observers may see these quantum correlations distributed among multiple degrees of freedom in different ways . however , in this analysis we find no indication that the entanglement in any bipartite subsystem is conserved when rob is allowed to accelerate . in fact , our results show that the presence of the communication horizon , which isolates the modes in region ii from an accelerated observer in region i , plays a key role in degrading the inertial entanglement between alice and rob . further insight into this behavior is gained by applying both pure and mixed state complementarity relations to different divisions of the system into subsystems . the ability of this formalism to identify the different types of information encoded in a quantum state facilitates the study of how various subsystem properties depend on rob s rate of acceleration . for instance , the constraints imposed by these relations illustrate how multi - qubit complementarity prevents the entanglement between alice and rob from vanishing at infinite acceleration as it does in the bosonic case . additionally , we find that the amount of vacuum thermalization ( due to unruh radiation ) that rob experiences at infinite acceleration is constrained by the amount of entanglement that he shares with alice in an inertial frame . one possible avenue for further research along these lines is to study the entanglement between alice and rob in the case that alice has acceleration @xmath305 and rob has acceleration @xmath306 . in this case the density matrix , after tracing over region ii is where @xmath308 and @xmath309 . in this case the logarithmic negativity is @xmath310 . thus , we see that the entanglement is further degraded by having two accelerated observers , but again remains finite , in this case taking on the value @xmath311 in the infinite acceleration limit . another aspect of this problem that deserves further consideration is the nature of the communication that is and is not allowed between observers in different regions . of course , no communication is possible between the left and right rindler wedges ( regions i and ii ) . however , even when two parties are not causally disconnected from one another ( e.g. alice and rob in ) , the presence of a horizon due to the acceleration of an observer imposes a unidirectionality on any classical communication occurring after the inertial observer crosses the horizon . given the connection between the horizons seen by accelerated observers , and the event horizon of a black hole , this in turn suggests the potential for gaining further insight into questions related to the black hole information paradox . czachor , phys . a 55 , 72 ( 1997 ) ; d.r . terno and a. peres , rev . phys . * 76 * , 93 ( 2004 ) ; a. peres , p.f . scudo and d.r . terno , phys . * 88 * , 230402 ( 2002 ) ; czachor , phys . 94 , 078901 ( 2005 ) ; p.m. alsing and g.j . milburn , quant . * 2 * , 487 ( 2002 ) ; r.m . gingrich and c. adami , phys . * 89 * , 270402 ( 2002 ) ; j. pachos and e. solano , _ qic vol . 2 , pp.115 _ ( 2003 ) ; w.t . kim and e.j . son , quant - ph/0408127 ; d. ahn , h.j . lee , y.h . moon , and s.w . hwang , phys . a 67 , 012103 ( 2003 ) . d. ahn , h.j . lee , and s.w . hwang , e - print quant - ph:/0207018 ( 2002 ) ; d. ahn , h.j . lee , s.w . hwang , and m.s . kim , e - print quant - ph:/0207018 ( 2003 ) . h. terashima and m. ueda , int . info . 1 , 93 ( 2003 ) . a.j . bergou , r.m . gingrich , and c. adami , phys . a 68 , 042102 ( 2003 ) . c. soo and c.c.y . lin , int . info . 2 , 183 ( 2003 ) . to cover the minkowski regions iii and iv in one needs to switch @xmath312 in , which changes the rindler metric in these regions to the form @xmath313 @xmath314 @xmath315 . this makes @xmath48 a spacelike coordinate and @xmath316 a timelike coordinate in region iii and iv . we will not require the solutions to the dirac equations in regions iii and iv in order to discuss the entanglment between alice and observers in region i and ii . in this work , we are implicitly assuming that the spin of each mode is along the direction of acceleration , the @xmath317-axis . since this motion is rectilinear , the succesive boosts into rob s instantaneous co - moving frame all commute . hence , the spin does not suffer any thomas precession ( wigner rotation ) and therefore points along the same direction in both the inertial and non - inertial frames . see also @xcite . in an arbitrary metric @xmath318 the dirac inner product is given by @xmath319 where where @xmath320 is a spacelike hypersurface with normal @xmath321 and hyperspatial volume element @xmath322 , and @xmath323 is the adjoint of the dirac spinor wave function @xmath324 . here @xmath325 are the flat spacetime dirac matrices satisfying @xmath326 with the minkowski metric @xmath327 , while the matrices @xmath328 sastify the corresponding anti - commutation relations with the arbitrary metric , i.e. @xmath329 . the inner product @xmath330 is invariant under the choice of the spacelike hypersurface @xmath331 . for the choice @xmath332 corresponding to @xmath333 with @xmath334 in minkowski coordinates , the inner product reduces to the usual flat spacetime form @xmath335 . in rindler coordinates one can also choose to compute the inner product on the hypersurface @xmath336 , although it is often more convenient to perform the computation on the future horizon @xmath337 , ( @xmath338 ) . the minkowski annihilation operator for frequency @xmath94 is related to the rindler region i and region ii operators of frequency @xmath95 more directly through an intermediate set of modes called unruh modes @xcite . the unruh modes analytically extend the rindler region i modes to region ii , and the region ii modes to region i as discussed in the next paragraph . the unruh modes are directly related to the rindler region i and ii modes through a bogoliubov transformations of the form and @xcite . since the unruh modes exist over all minkowski space , they share the same vacuum as the minkowski annihilation operators . a minkowski annihilation operator of frequency @xmath94 ( a frequency which alice detects ) can be written as an integral ( essentially a fourier transform ) over frequencies @xmath95 ( that a rindler observer detects ) involving only unruh annihilation operators with phase factor coefficients ( see@xcite ) . the single mode approximation entails assuming that rob s detector is sensitive to a single particle mode frequency @xmath95 ( an extremely narrow band detector ) and that the previously discussed frequency dependent phase factors are highly peaked about @xmath339 . we can then approximate the minkowski annihilation operator by a single unruh annihilation operator , which is then related to a rindler particle annihilation operator in region i and a rindler anti - particle creation operator in region ii through a bogoliubov transformation ( see the discussion in the last paper in @xcite ) . similar relations exist for the operators @xmath340 and @xmath111 namely , @xmath341 , @xmath342 , @xmath343 , and @xmath344 . however , these operators correspond to the mode @xmath97 , which we have ignored in the single mode approximation . let the intial unaccelerated state between alice and rob be the tensor product of minkowski states @xmath345 where @xmath346 is any state ( possibly mixed ) for alice and @xmath86 is any pure state for rob . since entanglement is invariant under local unitaries , we can always rotate @xmath347 to @xmath124 , the minkowski vacuum for mode @xmath11 given in , without changing the initial entanglement . then the reduced state for rob is just @xmath348 , which has maximal entanglement between i and ii at infinite acceleration .

we analyze the entanglement between two modes of a free dirac field as seen by two relatively accelerated parties . the entanglement is degraded by the unruh effect and asymptotically reaches a non - vanishing minimum value in the infinite acceleration limit . this means that the state always remains entangled to a degree and can be used in quantum information tasks , such as teleportation , between parties in relative uniform acceleration . we analyze our results from the point of view afforded by the phenomenon of entanglement sharing and in terms of recent results in the area of multi - qubit complementarity .

1302.1962

the triple junction ( tj ) is a line where three grain boundaries ( gbs ) meet together . it is commonly believed that tjs greatly influence properties of nanocrystalline materials and can play a significant role during plastic deformation and diffusional creep . @xcite the tjs are much less studied crystalline defects than gbs or dislocations are . experimental investigations of tjs are complicated by many factors , including their high mobility . @xcite experimental measurements indicate that zinc diffusion along tjs in al is three orders of magnitude faster than along gbs . @xcite tjs can also be the sites of preferred solute segregation . @xcite some theoretical models introduce the assumption of fast tj diffusion to explain the anomalous diffusion and deformation behavior of nanocrystalline materials . @xcite however , no reliable experimental information on self - diffusion along tjs is currently available to verify this assumption . due to the recent progress in the development of interatomic potentials capturing basic properties of materials on the quantitative level , @xcite atomistic simulations offer a means of predicting self - diffusion coefficients that would otherwise be very difficult to measure . for example , the gb self - diffusion coefficients in copper predicted by simulations were found to be in very good agreement with experiment . @xcite to the best of our knowledge , tj diffusion has never been studied by atomistic simulations . as in experiments , the tj motion at finite temperatures poses a major challenge to diffusion simulations . in a few studies published so far , the tj motion was prevented by creating high - symmetry configurations @xcite or restricting the simulations to the 0 k temperature . applying these restrictions , the atomic structure of the tjs at 0 k was carefully examined and their excess energy was estimated ; @xcite however , no diffusion coefficients were computed . tj motion by capillary forces at high temperatures has been studied by two - dimensional lennard - jones simulations . @xcite in this work we apply three - dimensional molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations with an embedded - atom potential to compute self - diffusion coefficients along a representative tj and to compare them with self - diffusion coefficient in the adjoining gbs . since self - diffusion is the only type of diffusion studied here , we will be referring to it for brevity as simply `` diffusion '' . in section [ sec : method ] we show how a tj with controlled grain misorientations can be created in the computer and how its motion can be constrained by boundary conditions . we also introduce our methodology for diffusion calculations . our results are presented in section [ sub : results ] , followed by their discussion and conclusions in section [ sec : discussion ] . we chose copper as the model material , with atomic interactions described by the embedded - atom potential developed in ref . . the same potential was used in the recent study of gb diffusion @xcite . the bulk melting point of cu predicted by this potential is @xmath2 k ( the experimental value is 1356 k ) . our procedure for constructing an equilibrium tj is illustrated in figure [ scem ] . first , a symmetrical tilt @xmath0 boundary was created with the tilt axis parallel to the common @xmath3 $ ] direction of both grains . the grain dimensions are @xmath4 @xmath5 , where the third number @xmath6 . the gb was terminated at a free surface perpendicular to the tilt axis . another @xmath7 @xmath5 grain with the orientation shown in fig . [ scem ] was placed on the surface , forming a non - equilibrium tj . the model was equilibrated by a 2 ns long md run at 1100 k with a periodic boundary condition parallel to the tj and fixed boundary conditions at the bottom and the sides of the block ( the top side is exposed to vacuum ) . the fixed layers , shown in fig . [ scem ] in gray , were 10 @xmath8 thick . further details of the md methodology will be discussed later . during the md anneal , the tj quickly ( within the first 0.1 ns ) moved down , causing migration of the two initially horizontal gbs until an equilibrium configuration was reached . the planes of the moving gbs changed in this process , but the grain misorientation remained the same . the new gb planes were symmetrical with respect to the @xmath1 gb by construction , but they did not align with any particular low - index crystal planes in the grains . these new boundaries will be referred to as general gbs ( ggbs ) . once equilibrated , the tj and the gbs did not move except for small thermal fluctuations . note that the @xmath1 gb is pinned by the fixed region at the bottom while the ggbs are pinned by the surface grooves formed in the corners between the third grain and the two initial grains . finally , a cylindrical region with the axis parallel to the tj was cut out of the tricrystal ( fig . [ scem](c ) ) . the atoms within a 10 @xmath8 thick outer shell of the cylinder were made fixed , whereas all atoms inside the shell were allowed to move during the subsequent md simulations . the fixed shell served to pin the gbs and prevent their migration . note that the cross - section of the shell is not perfectly circular : it contains the previously formed surface grooves and a portion of the bottom fixed layer from the original block . the boundary condition parallel to the tj remained periodic . this cylindrical block contained 81,137 atoms and had the length of 66 @xmath5 . it was used as the initial configurations for the diffusion calculations . the md simulations were performed in the @xmath9 ( canonical ) ensemble using a nose - hoover thermostat . the integration of the equations of motion employed the verlet algorithm with the integration time step of 2 fs . the simulations covered the temperature range from 700 k ( the lowest temperature of reliable diffusion calculations accessible with our computational resources ) to 1315 k ( 12 k below @xmath10 ) . prior to an md run , the block was uniformly expanded / contracted according to the thermal expansion factor at the intended simulation temperature , using the thermal expansion factors computed in ref . . the model was then additionally equilibrated by a 1 ns long md run to approach the equilibrium point defect concentrations at the chosen temperature , followed by a 10 ns long production run for diffusion calculations . as a test of equilibration , the total energy of the simulation block was averaged over several time intervals covering the production stage , and it was checked that these average values followed a normal distribution . similar tests were made for the pressure inside the block . an additional proof of sufficient relaxation comes from the observations that ( i ) during the subsequent diffusion runs ( see below ) , the tj displacements were random and very small ( < 5 @xmath5 ) , and ( ii ) the mean - squared atomic displacements accurately followed the einstein relation . snapshots containing the atomic coordinates were saved every 0.02 ns and later post - processed to compute the diffusion coefficients . the diffusion coefficients @xmath11 were calculated from the linear fits of @xmath12 versus @xmath13 plots using the einstein relation @xmath14 . here , @xmath13 is the diffusion time and @xmath15 is the mean - squared displacement of atoms over the time @xmath13 in the @xmath16 direction parallel to the tj . since the atoms are labeled , @xmath15 was computed by comparing the initial and final coordinates of all atoms initially contained within a selected probe region and averaging their squared displacements in @xmath16 over the time interval between @xmath17 and @xmath18 . this obtained value of @xmath12 was additionally averaged over all choices of the reference time @xmath17 by increasing it from zero to @xmath19 , where @xmath20 is the duration of the entire md run ( 10 ns ) . the maximum diffusion time @xmath13 was chosen to be 1 to 2 ns , depending on the temperature . the probe regions selected for gb diffusion were parallelepipeds aligned with the gb planes ( fig . [ scem_reg ] ) , which had the dimensions @xmath21 , where @xmath22 @xmath8 is the cylinder length . the width @xmath23 @xmath8 parallel to the gb was chosen so that to include as large a gb area as possible but avoid the influence of the tj and the fixed regions . since our goal was to evaluate the diffusivity in the gb core area , the half - thickness of the probe region was @xmath24 @xmath8 , which is close to the typical diffusion width of gbs . @xcite for tj diffusion , the probe region was a cylinder with the radius of @xmath25 placed at the diffusion center of the tj ( fig . [ scem_reg ] ) . special care was taken to keep track of the position of the center . to achieve this , a testing md run was made prior to the production run at each temperature and a group of atoms with the largest magnitude of displacements in @xmath16 was identified . such `` fastest '' atoms were invariably found in the tj region , which was already a qualitative proof of its enhanced diffusivity . the average coordinates of the `` fastest '' atoms were used to select the diffusion center of the tj . furthermore , the position of the center was recomputed for each snapshot during the production simulations and it was found to change only by small amounts that did not exceed @xmath25 . this confirmed the hight stability of our tj geometry . however , the position of the center had to be slightly re - adjusted for each temperature since changes in the contact angles of the gbs could produce tj displacements . diffusion coefficients in liquid copper were computed separately from mean - squared displacements of atoms at several temperatures using a large periodic supercell at zero pressure . the tj and gb structures were examined after `` quenching '' from 700 k to 0 k. although the structures contained a number of quenched - in point defects , the were very coherent and had thicknesses on the order of 2 - 3 interatomic distances . these structures remained quite coherent also at finite , but not too high , temperatures . from the dihedral angle of the gbs , the 0 k energy of the ggb is estimated to be approximately 0.9 of the @xmath1 gb energy . this number is very reasonable , given that the @xmath0 gb has the highest energy among all boundaries studied in refs . and is roughly 10% above the energies of typical high - angle gbs . examination of the md snapshots reveals that the gbs and the tj become increasingly disordered with temperature , as illustrated in fig . [ tj_struct ] . ( the visualization employs the coordination - number mode of the atomeye program , @xcite plotting only atoms whose coordination number is smaller than a certain number . ) near the bulk melting point the gbs become increasingly wider , especially in the tj region , and develop a liquid - like structure . at 1315 k the tj essentially turns into a liquid pipe . typical @xmath15 versus time plots are displayed in fig . ( [ msqd ] ) . their linearity demonstrates that the einstein relation is followed accurately , confirming that we have properly sampled the diffusion regime . the slopes of the curves indicate that the tj diffusion is faster than diffusion in the @xmath1 gb , and that both diffusivities increase with temperature . all diffusion coefficients obtained in this work are summarized in the arrhenius diagram in fig . [ arrh ] . observe the encouraging agreement with experimental data for self - diffusion in the bulk liquid @xcite and in high - purity polycrystalline cu , @xcite , by the gb diffusion width @xmath26 @xmath8 . ] lending confidence to our simulation methodology . diffusion along the tj is seen to be faster than diffusion in both gbs at all temperatures tested . also , the @xmath0 gb shows a higher diffusivity than the ggb at all temperatures . the latter observation is consistent with the previous work @xcite , in which diffusion in the @xmath0 gb was found to be faster than in the @xmath27 and @xmath28 gbs . note the gb and tj diffusivities converge at high temperatures and tend the diffusivity of bulk liquid , which is in agreement with the premelting process . to put these data in perspective , the self - diffusion coefficient in the lattice computed with the same eam potential at the bulk melting point is as low as @xmath29 m@xmath30/s , which is beyond the scale of fig . [ arrh ] . despite the significant scatter of the data points , the arrhenius plots in fig . [ arrh ] can be linearized except near the melting point . a fit according to the arrhenius equation @xmath31 ( @xmath32 is the boltzmann factor ) in the temperature interval 700 - 1100 k gives the activation energies @xmath33 and pre - exponential factors @xmath34 summarized in table [ tab : arrhen ] . although these arrhenius parameters slightly depend on the choice of the temperature interval , their ordering remains the same . the activation energy of tj diffusion is always the smallest and close to that of the @xmath1 gb . we have proposed a computational method to create a single equilibrium tj with controlled crystallographic orientations of the grains . the geometric stability of the tj is ensured by the fixed boundary conditions which pin the gbs at three points . an alternative procedure could be to prepare three separate wedge - shaped grains with angles that sum to 180@xmath35and join them together like a cake . besides being much more tedious , this approach does not offer an easy way to eliminate the mismatch stresses that may arise due to possible changes in the translational states of the grains during the relaxation . in addition , the free volumes of the gbs and of the tj would have to be accommodated by elastic stresses . in contrast , in our method the tj forms _ naturally _ , as a result of gb migration at a high temperature ( fig . [ scem](b ) ) . in this process , the equilibrium atomic density in the gbs and in the tj can be reached by atomic diffusion to / from the free surface . although in this paper we have implemented a particular set of grain misorientations , shown in fig . [ scem ] , other grain misorientations could have been created as well . a precise control the gb planes is more difficult , although some control is possible through judicious choices of the dimensions of the initial grains . the md simulations indicate that both the gbs and the tj become increasingly disordered at high temperatures and exhibit a premelting behavior near the bulk melting point ( fig . [ tj_struct ] ) . as the temperature approaches @xmath10 , the premelting first starts at the tj , then extends to the @xmath1 gb , and finally occurs at the ggbs . this sequence of premelting processes suggests that the tj has a higher excess free energy than the gbs studied here . the question of whether tjs carry an excess free energy relative to the adjoining gbs ( `` excess of excesses '' ) has long been debated in the literature . @xcite diffusion simulations have been conducted over a wide temperature range and the diffusion coefficients in the tj and the gbs have been extracted from the mean - squared atomic displacements . it should be mentioned that due to the fixed boundary conditions and conserved number of atoms in the model , the point - defect equilibrium at the diffusion temperature could only be achieved by defect generation and/or absorption at the tj and the gbs . at high temperatures , the tj and the boundaries were premelted or at least highly disordered , making them effective sinks and sources of point defects . even at the lowest temperature studied here ( 700 k ) , the tj region was still fairly disordered and was presumably able to generate and absorb point defects during the pre - diffusion anneal . this was evidenced by the linearity of the mean - square displacements versus time plots at this temperature , as well as by the independence of the diffusion results on the thermal history . for example , an additional low - temperature anneal of the tj prior to carving out the cylinder ( i.e. , when the gbs were still connected to the surface , fig . [ scem](b ) ) did not change the diffusion coefficients within the statistical error . it is important to recognize , however , low - temperature md simulations in closed systems containing of well - ordered gbs or other extended defects can be associated with non - equilibrium point - defect concentrations and can give inaccurate diffusion coefficients . our calculations confirm that diffusion along the tj is faster than diffusion along the gbs at all temperatures ( fig . [ arrh ] ) . our results also suggest that , for diffusion along `` typical '' gbs , such as the ggb tested here , can be orders of magnitude slower than tj diffusion at low temperatures . this conclusion is consistent with recent experimental measurements . @xcite however , diffusion in the highly energetic @xmath0 gb is only a factor of two slower than in the tj . although this small gap tends to slightly increase at low temperatures , fig . [ arrh ] and the arrhenius parameters ( table [ tab : arrhen ] ) clearly indicate that high - diffusivity gbs such as @xmath1 can be more efficient for atomic transport in polycrystals than tjs . the factor of two higher diffusivity of tjs is hardly sufficient for making a significant contribution considering their much smaller cross - sectional area in comparison with gbs . as the temperature approaches the melting point , the tj and gb diffusivities converge to the bulk liquid diffusivity , reflecting the premelting process . a very similar behavior was recently observed for gb diffusion . @xcite the rapid increase of the diffusivity near @xmath10 produces a strong upward curvature of the arrhenius plots and the concept of activation energy loses its physical significance . from the convergence of the diffusivities at high temperatures , it appears unlikely that tjs can make a sensible contribution to diffusional creep at high temperatures , given their relatively small cross - sectional area even in nanocrystalline materials . with most gbs in nanocrystals being of general type , the contribution to the creep rates often attributed to tjs might be overestimated . we are grateful to w. j. boettinger for numerous fruitful discussions . we have benefited greatly from interactions with many colleagues during coordination meetings sponsored by the doe - bes computational materials science network ( cmsn ) program . this work was supported by the us department of energy , office of basic energy sciences . we used the resources of the national energy research scientific computing center supported by the office of science of the us department of energy under contract no . de - ac02 - 05ch11231 . .arrhenius parameters @xmath33 ( activation energy ) and @xmath34 ( pre - exponential factor ) of tj and gb diffusion in cu obtained in this work . the arrhenius parameters of lattice self - diffusion computed with the same interatomic potential are given for comparison . [ tab : arrhen ] [ cols="<,^,^",options="header " , ] calculated for the tj ( @xmath38 ) , the @xmath1 gb ( @xmath39 ) , the ggb ( @xmath40 ) and liquid copper ( @xmath41 ) . the vertical dashed line indicates the melting point of cu with this embedded - atom potential ( 1327 k ) . experimental data for self - diffusion in liquid copper@xcite ( @xmath42 ) and in high - purity copper polycrystals@xcite ( @xmath43 ) are shown for comparison . ]

we propose a computational procedure for creating a stable equilibrium triple junction ( tj ) with controlled grain misorientations . we apply this procedure to construct a tj between a @xmath0 grain boundary ( gb ) and two general high - angle gbs in copper , and calculate the diffusion coefficients along the tj and the gbs using molecular dynamics with an embedded - atom potential . the tj diffusion is only a factor of two faster than diffusion in the @xmath1 gb but significantly faster than diffusion in the general gbs . both the gbs and the tj studied here show a premelting behavior near the bulk melting point , where their diffusivities converge to the diffusivity of bulk liquid . although our results are consistent with the common assumption that tj diffusion is generally faster than gb diffusion , the difference between the two diffusivities does not appear to be large enough to ensure a significant contribution of tjs to diffusional creep in polycrystals at high temperatures .

1105.4546

the observable baryon asymmetry of the universe ( bau ) and the nonzero neutrino masses @xcite provide strong evidences of physics beyond the standard model ( sm ) . the possibility of unification of the gauge interactions is one of the most intriguing guiding principles for building theories beyond the sm , in this case called the grand unified theories ( gut ) . interestingly , one of the most economical realistic guts may explain both bau and neutrino masses . it is well known that @xmath0 is the minimal group that can provide for grand unification . the first and simplest gut , proposed in @xcite , is based on this group . its scalar sector contains only two representations of @xmath4 and @xmath5 , while each generation of matter fields is embedded in two representations of @xmath6 and * 10*. the @xmath0 symmetry is broken down to the sm one by the vacuum expectation value ( vev ) of the scalar singlet in @xmath5 , and the sm higgs belongs to @xmath4 . in spite of its elegance , this model is ruled out since it can not : * unify the measured sm gauge couplings ; * explain nonzero neutrino masses ; * unify the sm yukawa couplings of charged leptons and down quarks at high scale in the renormalizable level ; * explain present experimental lower bound on the proton lifetime of order @xmath7 years . the first two of these problems were solved by adding a new fermionic * 24 * representation @xcite . however a whole set of high dimensional operators was needed to address the third problem . the renormalizable generalization of the model of @xcite with the minimal number of scalar fields contains only one new scalar @xmath8 representation @xcite , so that the electroweak symmetry is broken by both @xmath9 and @xmath10 vevs , providing for realistic yukawas . ultimately , this nonsupersymmetric renormalizable adjoint @xmath0 theory contains scalars in @xmath4 , @xmath5 and @xmath8 , and matter in @xmath11 , @xmath12 ( @xmath13 ) and @xmath14 . ( see appendix [ app : fields ] for the details . ) it is well known @xcite that the neutrino masses may be generated through type i @xcite and type iii @xcite seesaw mechanisms in the renormalizable adjoint @xmath0 model . in addition , the bau may be explained @xcite by generating the lepton asymmetry in the out - of - equilibrium decays of fermion triplets responsible for the type iii seesaw , and converting it to a baryon asymmetry by sphaleron transitions @xcite in the usual baryogenesis @xcite via leptogenesis ( lg ) scenario @xcite . in this paper we investigate a new range of the parameters where neutrino masses get a sizable contribution from the one - loop coloured seesaw besides the tree level type i and iii seesaw mechanisms . however , since the loop term is proportional to a linear combination of type i and iii seesaw yukawas , the lightest neutrino still remains massless . with the new contribution to neutrino mass , the allowed range in the parameter space for successful lg is enlarged . one of the interesting results of this model of the neutrino masses and lg in the framework of adjoint @xmath0 theory is the upper bound on the proton lifetime of order @xmath15 years @xcite , which can be tested in future . we remark that there is a parameter range in adjoint @xmath0 , which is hard to test at the proton decay experiments @xcite . however within this range the observable neutrino masses and bau can not be generated . in the next section we investigate generation of the neutrino masses together with the unification of the couplings in the considered model . in section [ section : nu_masses_exp ] we discuss parametrization of the yukawa couplings in terms of the neutrino experimental data . in section [ section : lg ] we give formulae for lg . we discuss the numerical results in section [ sec : numerics ] and conclude in section [ sec : summary ] . the interactions relevant for the generation of masses of the adjoint fermions are given by @xmath16 with @xmath17 . the masses of the fermions responsible for the neutrino masses are given by @xcite @xmath18 where the scale of grand unification is @xmath19 . the regime of successful unification determines the approximate mass relations @xmath20 with @xmath21 . for the mass spectrum of adjoint su(5 ) , which is allowed by unification , proton decay and lg , see fig . [ fg : spectrum ] with the description in section [ sec : numerics ] . the yukawa interactions needed to generate the neutrino masses are given by @xmath22 which contains @xmath23 where @xmath24 and the definitions used for the representations and multiplets are given in the appendices [ app : fields ] and [ app : multiplets ] . the scalar doublets @xmath25 and @xmath26 are related to the sm higgs @xmath27 and the heavy scalar @xmath28 by the orthogonal transformation @xmath29 with @xcite @xmath30 the vevs of physical fields are @xmath31 gev and @xmath32 . hence the terms relevant for the neutrino masses generation at tree level , shown in fig . [ fig:1:loop : nu : masses ] @xmath33 and @xmath34 , can be written as @xmath35 and interactions relevant for the one - loop contribution to the neutrino masses , shown in fig . [ fig:1:loop : nu : masses ] @xmath36 , can be written as @xmath37 where in and we have defined @xmath38 notice that in eqs . ( [ h3 ] ) and ( [ h0 ] ) we corrected the result of @xcite . the contribution of @xmath39 to the @xmath40 parameter is zero due to mass degeneracy of @xmath41 and @xmath42 , because the contributions to neutral and charged goldstones @xcite cancel each other . only electrically neutral components of @xmath43 enter the mechanisms illustrated in fig . [ fig:1:loop : nu : masses ] . the quadratic coupling @xmath44 arises from several terms in the adjoint @xmath0 lagrangian . here we take it to be arbitrary , bounded only by perturbativity . the resulting neutrino mass matrix is @xmath45 \label{eq : nu_masses}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath46 the first term in eq . ( [ eq : nu_masses ] ) is generated in type iii , the second term in i seesaw , as in @xcite . the third term comes from one - loop coloured seesaw @xcite in the limit of small mass splitting @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is the mass of @xmath49 ( @xmath50 ) @xcite . in @xcite the neutrino masses and lg were studied for @xmath51 and hence the one - loop contribution to neutrino masses was neglected . in this paper we are interested in the case of @xmath52 , in which the fermionic octet is relevant to the generation of neutrino masses . show that the number of light massive neutrinos in the considered model is two , which is equal to the maximal number of nonzero independent vectors in the plane defined by the vectors @xmath53 and @xmath54 . and @xmath55 for the couplings are not allowed , because in this case there would be only one massive neutrino . ] however none of @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 is decoupled from the generation of the neutrino masses due to its heavy mass or small couplings , as in the two right - handed neutrino models @xcite . on the other hand , some of @xmath43 may not enter particular physical processes , e.g. , @xmath3 decouples from lg , see section [ section : lg ] . such decoupling results in new physics effects , which are dependent on the yukawa couplings @xmath56 , in particular , the allowed parameter range of successful lg is enlarged , see section [ sec : numerics ] . we remark that similar relation among the neutrino masses and lg may be derived in theory with two heavy majorana neutrinos and one light sterile neutrino , which has specific mass and mixing terms with other neutrinos parity and contribute to the neutrino masses due to the interaction with inert scalar doublet , see @xcite . ] @xcite . using the linear relation @xmath57 with @xmath58 eq . ( [ eq : nu_masses ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath59 where @xmath60 and @xmath61 with @xmath62 in the limit @xmath63 matrix @xmath64 goes to @xmath65 with @xmath66 . the neutrino mass matrix in eq . ( [ eq : nu_masses2 ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath67 by using the orthogonal transformation @xmath68 where @xmath69 is a real orthogonal matrix and @xmath70 , where @xmath71 are the eigenvalues of @xmath72 . the three neutrino mass spectra allowed by the oscillation data are * normal hierarchical ( nh ) @xmath73 * inverted hierarchical ( ih ) @xmath74 * degenerate , @xmath75 ev ( @xmath76 ) ; where @xmath77 ev@xmath78 and @xmath79 ev@xmath78 are the mass - squared differences of solar and atmospheric neutrino oscillations @xcite . we use the standard casas - ibarra @xcite parametrization of the yukawa couplings @xmath80 as @xmath81 where @xmath82 ; the pmns lepton mixing matrix @xmath83 can be written as @xmath84 where @xmath85 , @xmath86 , with @xmath87 , @xmath88 and @xmath89 @xcite , while the dirac @xmath90 and majorana @xmath91 @xmath92 violation phases are not fixed by the present experiments . finally , the @xmath93 complex matrix can be written as @xcite @xmath94 in the normal and inverted hierarchy , respectively ; @xmath95 . we define the @xmath92 asymmetry as @xmath96}.\ ] ] in the considered model it is given by @xcite @xmath97\ , f(m_{\rho_0}^2/m_{\rho_3}^2),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath98 = -\frac{1}{2\sqrt{x } } + \mathcal{o}(x^{-3/2 } ) \quad \text{for } \quad x\gg1\end{aligned}\ ] ] since the only non - vanishing contribution comes from the vertex correction @xcite . we assume that the couplings of @xmath99 and @xmath100 interactions are small comparing to @xmath44 , so that two - loop effects in the @xmath92 asymmetry can be neglected . using the total decay rate @xmath101 where @xmath102 ( signs of the components of @xmath2 ) , the decay parameter @xmath103 , given by the ratio of the decay width of a single @xmath2 component to the expansion rate when @xmath2 starts to become non - relativistic at @xmath104 , can be written as @xmath105 and rewritten as @xmath106 in terms of the rescaled decay rate @xcite @xmath107 and the rescaled hubble expansion rate ( equilibrium @xmath2 mass ) @xmath108 for nh ( ih ) the strong washout regime requires @xmath109 using eqs . , , and , we have the rescaled decay rate @xmath110,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the total @xmath92 asymmetry @xmath111 \sqrt{m_{1}m_{2}}\ , { \rm im}(s^*c)\right\ } \nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath112 , @xmath113 , and @xmath114 , @xmath115 for nh ( ih ) neutrinos . in the limit @xmath63 we get the standard expressions @xmath116 where in eq . we corrected the result given in @xcite by the factor of 1/2 . boltzmann equations in the unflavoured regime ( @xmath117 gev ) can be written as ( for more details see @xcite and refs . therein ) @xmath118 where @xmath119 , and @xmath120 ( @xmath121 ) is the number density of @xmath122 calculated in a co - moving volume containing one @xmath2 ( all of its three components ) in ultrarelativistic thermal equilibrium : @xmath123 . initially , @xmath124 . the abundance at equilibrium is given by @xmath125 where @xmath126 is a modified bessel function . corresponds to the ` besselk[n , z ] ` function in mathematica . ] the decay factor is @xmath127 where @xmath27 is the hubble rate , and @xmath128 is the thermally averaged dilation factor . the sum @xmath129 , where @xmath130 is the contribution from higgs - mediated scatterings , is given by @xmath131,\ ] ] where @xmath132 is higgs mass and @xmath133 for the gauge scattering of @xmath2 @xcite we use the fit @xcite @xmath134 where @xmath135 gev is the planck mass . the washout can be written as @xmath136 where @xmath137.\ ] ] the contribution of the non - resonant @xmath138 processes to the washout is @xmath139 where @xmath140 ev for nh ( ih ) neutrinos . after solving the boltzmann equations - , we obtain @xmath141 ( in our calculation we use final @xmath142 , where the fit in eq . still applicable @xcite ) , included in the final baryon asymmetry @xmath143 where 3 is the number of @xmath2 components , the dilution factor 86/2387 is calculated assuming standard photon production from the onset of lg till recombination @xcite , and 12/37 is the fraction of @xmath144 asymmetry converted into a @xmath145 asymmetry assuming that sphalerons remain in equilibrium until after the electroweak phase transition @xcite . the result in eq . should be compared with the allowed values @xmath146 which come from the nucleosynthesis predictions and observed abundances of light elements @xcite . gev . dashed line shows the unflavoured and dot - dashed line the flavoured lg bound.,scaledwidth=46.0% ] in the considered model the unification scale and the masses of @xmath147 and @xmath148 are constrained by the proton decay : @xmath149 gev , @xmath150 gev and @xmath151 gev @xcite . the parameter space allowed by the unification at one - loop level for @xmath152 gev is shown in fig . [ fg : unification ] , where the dashed line shows the bound from eq . and the unflavoured lg constraint of @xmath117 gev , and the dot - dashed line shows the flavoured lg bound of @xmath153 gev . the mass spectrum of fermions and scalars in renormalizable adjoint @xmath0 is shown in fig . [ fg : spectrum ] , where the lower light gray belt shows the allowed @xmath148 mass range from unification and proton decay constraints , and the upper light gray belt shows the allowed range for @xmath43 masses from lg . the dark gray belt shows the allowed range for the scale of unification . all the sm particle masses lie near or below @xmath27 mass @xmath132 , while the rest of new particle masses in the theory can be set at the gut scale , besides the mass of @xmath154 field , which favours unification and unflavoured ( flavoured ) lg within the wide region @xmath155 gev , where the lower bound comes from the collider searches . the black lines for @xmath148 and @xmath43 in fig . [ fg : spectrum ] show characteristic values of their masses . vs. @xmath103 in the case of nh ( ih ) . see text for details.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] vs. @xmath103 in the case of nh ( ih ) . see text for details.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] fig . [ fg : be ] shows the allowed ranges for @xmath156 versus @xmath103 for the particular parameter sets of @xmath157 , @xmath158 gev , and @xmath159 , @xmath160 and @xmath51 ( which reproduces the standard case in eqs . ) , where the lighter region corresponds to larger @xmath161 . the results are weakly sensitive to the higgs mass within its expected range , and to @xmath162 due to only logarithmic dependence in eq . . we use @xmath163 gev and @xmath164 gev . the upper bound for @xmath2 mass of @xmath165 gev is derived using eq . and fig . [ fg : unification ] . to get the lower bounds on @xmath156 for every given value of @xmath103 , we maximize the solution of the boltzmann equations with the @xmath92 asymmetry from eq . over the complex angle @xmath166 , and find the minimal value of @xmath156 required to produce the observed baryon asymmetry in eq . ( its lower bound ) . the resulting curves in fig . [ fg : be ] are smoothened and given to few percent accuracy . the allowed region for lg in the case of vanishing loop contribution to the neutrino masses is shown by the darkest regions , which agrees with the result of @xcite . the lighter areas show the new allowed regions for lg for the larger values of @xmath161 up to 1 , when the loop contribution to the neutrino masses is significant . the dashed lines show the lower bounds on @xmath156 for the parameter set @xmath157 , @xmath167 gev and @xmath159 . the vertical lines show the lower bounds on @xmath103 in the strong washout regime . the dot - dashed and dotted curves show limits @xmath168 and @xmath169 , which are derived from eq . using @xmath170 and 4 , respectively . below these curves the couplings @xmath171 remain well perturbative . we notice that the considered unflavored regime of lg is applicable for @xmath172 gev . below this level , shown in fig . [ fg : be ] ( left ) , the flavor effects should be taken into account . we remark that the maximal allowed value of @xmath173 , which is related to the mass of @xmath148 , can be tested at the future proton decay experiments @xcite . we have presented a detailed study of the neutrino masses and the baryogenesis via lg in adjoint @xmath0 , which is a well motivated model since testable by the proton decay experiments . @xmath144 asymmetry is generated by the decays of @xmath174 triplet @xmath2 , with singlet @xmath1 running in the loop , while the neutrino masses are generated at the tree level by @xmath2 and @xmath1 exchanges and in one - loop coloured seesaw with propagating @xmath175 octets @xmath3 and @xmath148 . for the values of the octet scalar @xmath148 to sm higgs @xmath27 coupling @xmath44 of order 1 , the one - loop coloured seesaw is on the same order as the type i and iii seesaw . this new contribution to the neutrino masses relaxes the yukawa couplings for @xmath2 and @xmath1 , and makes the allowed range for unflavored lg significant not only for the normal hierarchy of the neutrino masses , but also for the inverted one , in contrast to the case of small @xmath44 . the lightest neutrino , however , remains massless , because the coloured seesaw loop diagram is proportional to the yukawa couplings of the type i and iii seesaw . for @xmath176 the @xmath92 asymmetry explicitly depends on several more parameters of adjoint @xmath0 , in comparing with the case of @xmath51 , such as : @xmath44 , the vev @xmath177 of the representation @xmath178 , and the ratio @xmath179 of the masses of adjoint fermions @xmath180 and @xmath181 . this increases the predictive power and testability of the model . we remark that some of the new particles , e.g. , @xmath154 and @xmath148 , may be light enough in the considered scenario to be tested at the lhc and the next generation of colliders @xcite . under @xmath182 , the scalar fields are decomposed as @xmath183 and the matter fields are decomposed as @xmath184 where @xmath13 is the generation index , @xmath185 is the sm lepton doublet , @xmath186 are scalar @xmath174 doublets , and we denote @xmath187 , @xmath188 , @xmath189 and @xmath190 , where @xmath191 . the vevs are @xmath192_j^i , \qquad \langle(45_h)\rangle_j^{in}=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath193 , @xmath194 , and relation @xmath195 gev @xcite provides proper masses of @xmath174 gauge bosons . more details on the representations are given in the appendices a of @xcite . the scalar potential was studied in @xcite , and the yukawa couplings were analyzed in @xcite . for the @xmath196 doublets and triplets we use the explicit forms @xmath197 respectively , where @xmath198 , @xmath199 , and @xmath200 are the pauli matrices . the adjoint representation @xmath201 ( @xmath193 ; @xmath202 ) can be written as @xmath203 where @xmath204 are the gell - mann matrices . * 45*@xmath205 is defined by the conditions : @xmath206 and @xmath207 . we omit index @xmath27 of scalar representations in the following . the explicit decomposition into sm multiplets can be deduced by considering the multiplet as the tensor product @xmath208 . below we will write the colour indices with letters from the beginning of the alphabet @xmath209 and the weak indices as @xmath210 . we have @xmath211_{dc } + \epsilon^{abd } [ s_{(\bar{3},1)}]_{dc } , \\ { 45}^{ab}_{r } & = \epsilon^{abc } [ s_{(\bar{3},2)}]_{cr } , \\ { 45}^{ar}_{b } & = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2 } } s_{8}^{ar } [ \lambda^{a}]^{a}_{b } + h_{2}^{r } \delta^{a}_{b } , \\ { 45}^{ar}_{s } & = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2 } } s_{(3,3)}^{ai } [ \sigma^{i}]^{r}_{s } + s_{(3,1)}^{a } \delta^{r}_{s } , \\ { 45}^{rt}_{s } & = -\frac{3}{2 } h_{2}^{t } \delta^{r}_{s},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath212_{ab } = -[s_{(\bar{3},1)}]_{ba}$ ] . we thank riccardo barbieri , anatoly borisov , konstantin stepanyantz , ilja dorsner , enrico bertuzzo and david straub for useful suggestions and comments . this work was supported by the esf mobilitas 2 grant mjd140 , mobilitas 3 grant mtt8 , esf grants 8090 and 8943 , and sf0690030s09 ( kk ) ; and by the eu itn `` unification in the lhc era '' , contract pitn - ga-2009 - 237920 ( unilhc ) and by miur under contract 2006022501 ( dz ) . p. minkowski , _ phys.lett._*b67 * , 421 ( 1977 ) ; t. yanagida , in _ proceedings of the workshop on the unified theory and the baryon number in the universe _ , eds . o. sawada and a. sugamoto ( tsukuba , japan , 1979 ) 95 ; m. gell - mann , p. ramond , and r. slansky , in supergravity , eds . d. z. freedman and p.van nieuwenhuizen ( north holland , amsterdam , 1979 ) 315 ; r. n. mohapatra and g. senjanovic , _ phys.rev.lett._*44 * , 912 ( 1980 ) . r. foot , _ et al . _ , z.phys.*c44 * , 441 ( 1989 ) ; e. ma , phys.rev.lett.*81 * , 1171 - 1174 ( 1998 ) . s. blanchet and p. fileviez perez , jcap*0808 * , 037 ( 2008 ) [ 0807.3740 [ hep - ph ] ] ; mod.phys.lett.*a24 * , 1399 - 1409 ( 2009 ) [ 0810.1301 [ hep - ph ] ] . r. barbieri , l. j. hall and v. s. rychkov , phys.rev.*d74 * , 015007 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0603188 ] . p. fileviez perez and m. b. wise , phys.rev.*d80 * , 053006 ( 2009 ) [ 0906.2950 [ hep - ph ] ] ; p. fileviez perez , aip conf.proc.*1222 * , 3 - 9 ( 2010 ) [ 0909.2698 [ hep - ph ] ] . m. a. luty , phys.rev.*d45 * , 455 ( 1992 ) ; l. covi , e. roulet and f. vissani , phys.lett.*384 * , 169 ( 1996 ) [ peh - ph/9605319 ] . s. davidson , e. nardi and y. nir , phys.rept.*466 * , 105 - 177 ( 2008 ) [ 0802.2962 [ hep - ph ] ] .

investigate baryogenesis via leptogenesis and generation of neutrino masses and mixings through the type i plus type iii seesaw plus an one - loop mechanism in the context of renormalizable adjoint @xmath0 theory . one light neutrino remains massless , because the contributions from three heavy majorana fermions @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 to the neutrino mass matrix are not linearly independent . however none of these heavy fermions is decoupled from the generation of neutrino masses . this opens a new range in parameter space for successful leptogenesis , in particular , allows for inverted hierarchy of the neutrino masses .

hep-ph0504208

the observed neutrino fluxes in solar neutrino experiments @xcite and in atmospheric neutrino experiments @xcite lead to a picture of neutrino oscillations with substantial @xmath1 mixing @xcite . for high energies over astronomical distances , astrophysical sources of @xmath2 and @xmath3 can become sources of @xmath4 as well . one method of detecting @xmath4 from astrophysical sources is to look for the charged particles they produced in or near neutrino telescopes . because of the short lifetime of the tau , @xmath5 regeneration can be an important effect as the @xmath4 passes through a significant column depth through the earth @xcite . this is typically relevant for neutrino energies below @xmath6 gev . at higher energies , one can imagine using the earth as a tau neutrino converter @xcite . because of the relatively short interaction length of the neutrino at high energies , column depths on the order of the distance through a mountain or from small skimming angles relative to the horizon are most important . following the tau neutrino conversion , a tau is detected by its decay e.g. , in ice with icecube , rice or the proposed anita detectors , or after it emerges into the air . the possibility of detectable signals depends on the incident fluxes , of which there are a variety of models @xcite , and on the detectors and their sensitivity to various energy regimes . theoretical calculations often rely on approximating the neutrino interaction and tau energy loss in terms of analytic functions of energy and column depth @xcite . these analytic tools are important in exploring the possibility for tau neutrino signals in a variety of detectors , even though ultimately a full simulation of tau production and energy loss is required . in the energy regime where @xmath7 gev huang , tseng and lin have made an evaluation of the smearing of energy due to tau propagation by doing an approximate stochastic evaluation of electromagnetic energy loss of the tau @xcite . looking at fixed incident neutrino energies , they find that the relative energy fluctuation of the tau can become large at high energies , especially for larger column depths . this has the potential to make interpretation of fluxes difficult at high energies . in this paper , we evaluate tau neutrino and tau propagation using a stochastic evaluation of tau electromagnetic energy loss based on the work of ref . @xcite . we find the approximate evaluation of ref . @xcite reliable . in addition to considering mono - energetic incident neutrinos , we also consider incident neutrino fluxes with a power law behavior , @xmath8 . we compare the flux of taus following propagation through 10 km rock and 100 km rock using the stochastic evaluation with estimates of the emerging flux of taus using analytic approximations . we refine some recent parameterizations of the tau energy loss as a function of tau energy@xcite to better approximate the stochastic result for the flux of emerging taus using analytic approximations . the best parameterization of the electromagnetic energy loss parameter @xmath0 is with a logarithmic dependence on tau energy . in the next section , we describe the models for the high energy neutrino nucleon cross section and the tau energy loss used in our monte carlo simulation . results of the simulation and analytic approximations for the tau energy as a function of distance traveled , for monoenergetic neutrinos , appear in section iii . section iv includes results and analytic approximations for power law incident neutrino spectra . a summary of our results and a comparison with a simplified analytic approach are in the final section . our evaluation of neutrino interactions and tau energy loss is performed using a one - dimensional monte carlo computer simulation . the neutrino charged current and neutral current interactions are calculated based on neutrino - isoscalar nucleon cross sections @xcite using the cteq6 parton distribution functions ( pdfs)@xcite . at ultra - high energies , there is a competing effect in the neutrino - nucleon cross section as a function of @xmath9 , the quantity describing the four - momentum squared of the vector boson . pdfs increase as a function of @xmath10 @xcite , however , the vector boson propagator effectively cuts off the growth in @xmath11 at the vector boson mass . for charged current scattering , this means that the value of parton @xmath12 for nucleon four - momentum @xmath13 is approximately @xmath14 in terms of the incident neutrino energy @xmath15 , nucleon mass @xmath16 and @xmath17 boson mass @xmath18 . for @xmath19 gev , one finds that @xmath20 . the cteq6 pdfs are parameterized for @xmath21 , so one must extrapolate for smaller values of @xmath22 . the pdfs at small values of parton @xmath22 ( @xmath23 ) are extrapolated here using a power law @xmath24 matched to dglap evolved pdfs at @xmath25 : @xmath26 this approach is based on the result @xcite that for @xmath27 , the gluon pdf has the approximate form of @xmath28 , and @xmath29 splitting is responsible for the sea quark distributions that dominate the cross section at ultra - high energies . we show in fig . [ fig : lint ] the neutrino interaction length in rock . other approaches to the small @xmath22 extrapolations for ultra - high energy neutrino cross sections yield similar interaction lengths @xcite , to within a factor of approximately @xmath30 at @xmath31 gev . the differential distribution for neutrino nucleon scattering in terms of the lepton inelasticity @xmath32 , @xmath33 is evaluated similarly . we indicate the energy of the tau at the point of its production by @xmath34 . the neutrino interaction probability and resulting tau energy is evaluated using a one - dimensional monte carlo program . in our analytic approximations described below , we use @xmath35 , which is approximately correct at ultra - high energies @xcite . an indication of this is shown by the solid line in fig . [ fig : eavg ] , which shows the ratio of the average tau energy to the initial neutrino energy , as a function of neutrino energy , in the absence of electromagnetic energy loss corrections . our evaluation of the tau electromagnetic energy loss follows the procedure described in ref . @xcite . based on the scheme outlined by lipari and stanev @xcite and others @xcite , we have incorporated the electromagnetic mechanisms of ionization , bremsstrahlung ( brem ) , @xmath36 pair production ( pair ) and photonuclear ( nuc ) scattering . the tau lifetime is taken into account . the average energy lost per unit distance is commonly described by the formula @xmath37 in this expression , @xmath38 is the distance the tau travels . the quantity @xmath39 gev @xmath40/g accounts for ionization energy loss @xcite . here , @xmath0 is @xmath41 for avogadro s number @xmath42 , atomic mass number @xmath43 , tau inelasticity @xmath32 and @xmath44 and nuc . in our treatment here , as in ref . @xcite we separate @xmath0 into continuous and stochastic terms : @xmath45 we treat the tau propagation stochastically , with a series of electromagnetic interactions occurring according to probabilities based on @xmath46 for @xmath47 and the decay probability . for each distance between interactions in the monte carlo program , the tau energy loss calculated from eq . ( 3 ) is supplemented by eq . ( [ eq : dedx ] ) with the substitution of @xmath48 . by doing it this way , we account for the full electromagnetic energy loss , but we limit computer time spent where the cross section is large , but the energy loss is small ( @xmath49 ) . the detailed formulas for the bremsstrahlung @xcite , pair production @xcite and photonuclear @xcite processes are discussed and collected in ref . @xcite . see also ref . @xcite for the muon case . for the muon , @xmath0 is dominated by pair production and bremsstrahlung for @xmath50 gev . at higher energies , @xmath51 grows slowly with energy due to the photonuclear process which contributes a larger fraction for @xmath52 gev . for the tau , the photonuclear process is comparable to pair production , while the bremsstrahlung contribution is suppressed , leading to an increase in @xmath0 with energy for @xmath53 gev . in the analytic approximations discussed below , we will consider several forms of @xmath0 as a function of @xmath54 , and we will treat @xmath55 to guide our discussion , it is useful to compare the relevant constants and distance scales . first , at @xmath56 gev , @xmath57 is much larger than @xmath58 , so we can essentially ignore @xmath58 . the tau range is then characterized roughly by @xmath59 in standard rock ( @xmath60 g/@xmath61 ) . in fact , the range is somewhat larger than this estimate . the decay length of the tau is @xmath62 it is in the energy regime near @xmath56 gev that the transition from the lifetime dominated to the energy loss dominated range for the tau occurs . we begin our discussion by considering single incident neutrino energies to see the effect of energy loss combined with decay probabilities for two different trajectories : through 10 km rock ( 26.5 km.w.e . ) and through 100 km rock . [ fig : eavg ] shows the average tau energy divided by the incident neutrino energy as a function of incident neutrino energy . the average distance that the tau travels after production which survives to emerge from the rock ( 10 , 50 and 100 km ) is shown in fig . [ fig : dleft ] . for 10 km of rock , above @xmath63 gev , the average distance the tau travels is 5 km . the neutrino interaction probability is equal anywhere in the 10 km path , and the energies are large enough that the decay length is long compared to the path . for 50 km and 100 km , fig . [ fig : dleft ] shows that the last @xmath64 km are the most important for the emerging taus . the standard deviation , normalized by the average tau energy , @xmath65 is shown is fig . [ fig : sd ] . higher energies and larger distances lead to larger fluctuations . huang et al.s results in ref . @xcite correspond to our figs . [ fig : eavg ] and [ fig : sd ] and are in good agreement . we comment that by normalizing the standard deviation to the incident neutrino energy rather than average energy of the emerging tau , one finds a more stable result for the ratio . the standard deviation scales approximately as @xmath66 for 10 km rock over the same energy range as the figure , and with a factor of @xmath67 for 100 km rock . a final result for mono - energetic neutrinos is shown in fig . [ fig : evsz ] . each histogram shows the average energy of the emerging tau as a function of the production point @xmath38 for a total depth of 100 km and at fixed initial neutrino energy . the energies of the incident neutrinos are @xmath68 gev for @xmath69 ( lower to upper curves ) . standard approaches to parameterizing the final energy in terms of the initial energy begin with @xmath70 the solution depends on the energy dependence of @xmath0 . several parameterizations have been used , including a linear dependence on energy @xcite and a logarithmic energy dependence @xcite . we consider three cases : @xmath71\ , { e_0}\cr & \cr & \beta = \beta_0+\beta_1\ln(e/{e_0})\ . } \ ] ] the quantity @xmath72 is the distance traveled by the tau after its production . none of the choices for @xmath0 is entirely satisfactory . case ( iii ) is the best approximation to the energy curves of fig . [ fig : evszcomp ] . for case ( i ) , @xmath73 works moderately well for @xmath74 gev , but poorly for higher and lower energies . we reproduce the histograms of the stochastic results from fig . [ fig : evsz ] showing the last 20 km in fig . [ fig : evszcomp ] together with parameterizations of @xmath0 . in all cases of the parameterized energy , we take @xmath75 . the dot - dashed lines show the parameterization of case ( i ) . case ( ii ) is used by aramo et al . in ref . @xcite with @xmath76 the energy parameterization in this case is shown with the dashed lines in fig . [ fig : evszcomp ] . the parameterization using a logarithmic dependence on energy for @xmath0 does the best at reproducing the energy behavior of the emerging taus . this is shown with solid lines in fig . [ fig : evszcomp ] , with @xmath77 not surprisingly , this energy dependent @xmath0 will give the best representation of the monte carlo simulation results for the emerging tau fluxes from power law incident neutrino fluxes . we note that these values of @xmath0 are larger than what one would extract from the direct calculation of @xmath0 @xcite as in eq . this is because eq . ( 7 ) is only an approximate equality . in this section , we consider cases of incident neutrino fluxes that depend on energy . rather than use specific flux models , we consider power law fluxes @xmath78 , for @xmath79 , to see qualitatively and quantitatively how flux propagation is affected by tau energy loss . in fig . [ fig : em1 ] , we show the results of the stochastic propagation of the incident tau neutrino , which converts to a tau and continues through the depth @xmath80 of rock , for @xmath81 km and 100 km and an incident neutrino flux scaling like @xmath82 . all of the fluxes shown in this section have a sharp cutoff at @xmath19 gev . the two upper dashed curves show the outgoing tau flux to the incoming neutrino flux neglecting tau energy loss and decay . because of the larger column depth for 100 km of rock , the ratio of the tau to neutrino flux is ten times larger than for 10 km . the flux ratio increases with energy to scale with the neutrino cross section . our stochastic propagation including energy loss and decay is shown by the histograms in fig . [ fig : em1 ] . energy loss is much stronger for the 100 km depth , so the ratio of outgoing tau flux to incident neutrino flux is smaller for 100 km than 10 km for @xmath83 gev , despite the increased number of targets for the neutrinos . a qualitative discussion of the results for fig . [ fig : em1 ] is in sec . iv.b . figs . [ fig : em2 ] and [ fig : em3 ] show the ratio of the outgoing tau flux to the incident tau neutrino flux for incident neutrino fluxes scaling as @xmath84 and @xmath85 , respectively . the flux ratios including decay and energy loss at @xmath86 gev for these steeper fluxes can be understood based only on the lifetime , since energy loss is not overwhelming at that energy and there is little pile - up of taus from neutrino interactions at higher energies , followed by tau energy loss . the dashed lines have a factor of @xmath80 to account for the column depth of nucleon targets in the neutrino interaction probability . when decays are included , the relevant distance at @xmath86 gev is @xmath87 , so the neutrino interaction probability is proportional to @xmath88 rather than @xmath80 . neutrino attenuation in 10 km and 100 km of rock at @xmath6 gev is small , so the flux ratios in figs . [ fig : em2 ] and [ fig : em3 ] are the same for the two depths . at higher energies , attenuation and energy loss play a bigger role . our aim here is to compare the stochastic propagation to analytic approaches . in the next section we outline the analytic evaluation of the emerging tau flux and make quantitative comparisons with the histograms in fig . [ fig : em1 ] , [ fig : em2 ] and [ fig : em3 ] . the analytic approximation to the emerging tau flux as a function of tau energy depends on a number of components . we review the discussion of ref . @xcite here , expanded to include two energy dependences of @xmath0 , a linear dependence @xcite and a logarithmic one @xcite . the incident flux @xmath89 is attenuated along its trajectory a distance @xmath38 through the rock with an approximate factor @xmath90 f_\nu(e_\nu,0)\ .\ ] ] in our evaluation here , we are assuming a constant density ( standard rock ) . neutrino regeneration@xcite . from neutral current processes or tau decay is not important over these short distances . the probability for neutrino conversion to taus in the distance interval [ @xmath91 with energy in the interval @xmath92 $ ] is @xmath93 as discussed above , we take @xmath94 : @xmath95 writing the differential cross section this way ensures that the integral over tau energy yields the charged - current ( cc ) cross section . in the infinite lifetime , no energy loss ( @xmath96 , @xmath97 ) limit , the emerging tau flux given incident tau neutrinos is @xmath98 f_\nu(e_\nu,0)\nonumber\\ & \equiv & \int_0^d dz\ \frac{df_\tau^0(e_\tau^i , z)}{dz}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for rock depth @xmath80 . in the case where the energy loss is treated analytically , the lifetime and energy loss are accounted by a factor @xmath99 as the tau travels over the remaining distance from production point @xmath38 to emerge from the rock after distance @xmath80 with outgoing energy @xmath54 . in fact , @xmath34 , @xmath54 and @xmath100 are not all independent , as shown in eq . ( [ eq : cases ] ) . the survival probability as a function of energy comes from the solution to the equation @xmath101 together with the approximate @xmath102 formula of eq . ( [ eq : dedx2 ] ) , leading to @xmath103 the solution depends on the energy dependence of @xmath0 . for constant @xmath0 , the solution is @xmath104\quad { \rm case\ ( i)}\ .\ ] ] the emerging tau flux is @xmath105 the delta function explicitly enforces eq . ( [ eq : cases ] ) rewritten with @xmath34 in terms of @xmath54 and @xmath100 . a factor of @xmath106 accounts for the fact that @xmath107 represents the number of @xmath108 s per tau energy interval , say for @xmath109 . electromagnetic energy loss means that one must sample a much larger interval of initial tau energies , @xmath110 . combining this factor with the delta function leads to the factor of @xmath111 that appears in the literature@xcite for tau neutrino production of taus for a constant beta : @xmath112 in the @xmath97 limit , the emerging tau flux is the expected result , @xmath113 continuing with case ( i ) for non - zero @xmath0 , explicit substitutions give @xmath114\ . \label{eq : ftaubc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] a useful limit to understand our results in fig . [ fig : em1 ] is the case of constant @xmath0 in the long lifetime limit . for simplicity , we set @xmath115 so that @xmath116 @xcite . if we also assume @xmath117 where @xmath118 is the neutrino interaction length , we can simplify eq . ( [ eq : ftaubc ] ) to @xmath119 for @xmath120 approximately constant . the energy integral runs from @xmath121 to @xmath122 gev ) . at low energies and short distances , ( e.g. , @xmath123 gev and @xmath81 km ) , the maximum energy is @xmath124 . for @xmath125 , @xmath126 , while for @xmath78 for @xmath127 , @xmath128 . this means that even with strong energy loss effects , for an @xmath82 flux in the appropriate energy regime , the total distance @xmath80 determines the tau flux rather than the characteristic scale of the energy loss , @xmath129 . in the actual case of the @xmath108 , the tau decay length @xmath130 is comparable to the energy loss scale @xmath131 at @xmath86 gev . for the @xmath82 flux , @xmath80 is still the dominant scale , although the details including both energy loss and decay as well as energy dependent cross sections have an effect , as seen in fig . [ fig : em1 ] . figs . [ fig : em2 ] and [ fig : em3 ] show that this is not the case for @xmath84 and @xmath85 . ( [ eq : master ] ) is the master equation for all three cases discussed here for the three parameterizations of @xmath0 . the argument of the delta function comes from eq . ( [ eq : cases ] ) for the specific cases i - iii . the survival probabilities come from the solution to eq . ( [ eq : surv ] ) for the appropriate energy dependent @xmath0 . this gives ( see ref . @xcite for case ( ii ) ) @xmath132\quad { \rm case\ ( ii)}\nonumber \\ { p_{surv}}(e_\tau , e_\tau^i ) & = & \exp \biggl ( \frac{m_\tau\beta_1}{c\tau\rho\beta_0 ^ 2}\biggl[\frac{1}{e_\tau}(1+\ln \bigl(\frac{e_\tau}{e_0}\bigr)\nonumber \\ & -&\frac{1}{e_\tau^i}\bigl(1+\ln \frac{e_\tau^i}{e_0}\bigr)\biggr]\biggr ) \nonumber \\ & \times & \exp\biggl[-\frac { m_\tau}{c\tau\beta_0\rho}\biggl ( \frac{1}{e_\tau}-\frac{1}{e_\tau^i}\biggr)\biggr]\ { \rm case\ ( iii)}\,.\nonumber \\ & & \label{eq : pmaster}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in case ( iii ) , an expansion in @xmath133 has been made in eq . ( [ eq : surv ] ) . numerically , we have kept terms through @xmath134 , however in eq . ( [ eq : pmaster ] ) , we show the result where only the first term has been kept . none of the parameterizations can completely describe the monte carlo results . based on fig . 6 , it is not surprising that the form of @xmath0 which depends on @xmath135 works the best to describe the outgoing tau flux . in figs . [ fig : hcomp1]-[fig : hcomp3 ] , we show a comparison of the various parameterizations of the outgoing tau flux , normalized to the incident neutrino flux [ fig : hcomp1 ] shows the monte carlo results for 10 km of rock and an incident flux with @xmath82 energy behavior with the histogram and the case ( iii ) parameterization with the dashed line . the case ( i ) parameterization , with constant @xmath0 appears as a dot - dashed line , while the case ( ii ) power law is shown with a dot - dot - dot - dashed line . one sees the turnover in the flux ratio as the change is made from @xmath136 to @xmath137 gev for the @xmath82 flux . the parameterization of @xmath0 as a function of @xmath138 ( case ( iii ) ) gives results for the flux ratio to within about @xmath139% of the monte carlo result . the other two parameterizations do not do as well , underestimating by a factor of @xmath140 for @xmath141 gev and overestimating by @xmath142 for @xmath143 gev . for 100 km of rock , with the same incident flux , the case ( iii ) parameterization compares well ( underestimates by @xmath64% ) the monte carlo result between @xmath144 gev . by comparison , the other two parameterizations for 100 km rock overestimate the tau flux by a factor of @xmath145 and @xmath146 at energies @xmath147 and @xmath148 gev respectively . for the @xmath84 incident neutrino flux , the @xmath149 parameterization of @xmath0 does well for 100 km as seen in fig . [ fig : hcomp2 ] . again , the dot - dashed and dot - dot - dot - dashed lines show cases ( i ) and ( ii ) respectively . for incident neutrino fluxes scaling with @xmath85 , the 10 km result is well represented by the @xmath149 parameterization , as shown in fig . [ fig : hcomp3 ] . the overestimate of the flux for cases i and ii occurs because energy loss is underestimated at high energies with these parameterizations of @xmath0 . we have performed a one - dimensional monte carlo simulation of @xmath4 conversion to @xmath108 and @xmath108 propagation including electromagnetic energy loss over distances of 10 - 100 km in rock . analytic approximations are useful tools in exploring the possibility of detecting a variety of predictions for incident neutrino fluxes @xcite . using mono - energetic sources of tau neutrinos , we modeled the tau energy loss with an energy loss parameter @xmath0 depending on @xmath150 . in an analytic approximation for the outgoing tau flux , this model for energy loss does better at representing the monte carlo results than two other choices for @xmath0 : a constant and a @xmath0 increasing linearly with tau energy . our improved parameterization of @xmath0 will help refine theoretical predictions of tau neutrino induced events in neutrino telescopes . it is not difficult to numerically evaluate the integrals of eq . ( [ eq : master ] ) including the more complicated logarithmic dependence on energy of @xmath0 ( case ( iii ) ) for @xmath151 and @xmath54 , nevertheless , it is interesting to see the impact of the modifications from that energy dependence . although formally inconsistent , one could simply use the flux calculation for constant @xmath0 , eq . ( [ eq : masterconst ] ) , and substitute @xmath152 . this is shown in fig . [ fig : final ] , for @xmath153 km and @xmath82 , with the dot - dashed line . as in figs . [ fig : hcomp1]-[fig : hcomp3 ] , the dashed line comes from the full case iii ( logarithmic dependence ) result , and the histogram represents the monte carlo result . the dot - dashed line is nearly identical to the complete case iii evaluation . the triple dot - dashed line uses the full expression for the energy dependence on distance from eq . ( [ eq : cases ] ) , but it uses the simplified form of the survival probability : @xmath154 $ ] . this does as well in representing the monte carlo result . of the fluxes and rock depths that we have discussed here , fig . [ fig : final ] is representative of the three curves incorporating to varying degrees the logarithmic energy dependence of @xmath0 . in summary , our monte carlo results for tau neutrino interaction and tau propagation through rock suggest that the tau electromagnetic energy loss parameter be parameterized by @xmath155 ( case iii ) , where the parameters @xmath156 and @xmath157 appear in eq . ( 16 ) . using the analytic formula of ref . @xcite , modified to account for the logarithmic energy dependence , a reasonable agreement with the monte carlo results is obtained . using the formulae of ref . @xcite for constant @xmath0 , with the small change of taking @xmath158 but substituting @xmath159 , also is in reasonable agreement with the monte carlo result . we thank i. sarcevic and d. seckel who were collaborators in our initial evaluation of tau electromagnetic energy loss , and t. gaisser , k. gayley , y. meurice and v.g.j . this work is funded in part by the u.s . department of energy contract de - fg02 - 91er40664 . s. n. ahmed _ et al . _ [ sno collaboration ] , phys . * 92 * , 181301 ( 2004 ) . y. ashie _ et al . _ [ super - kamiokande collaboration ] , phys . lett . * 93 * , 101801 ( 2004 ) . m. c. gonzalez - garcia and m. maltoni , hep - ph/0406056 . f. halzen and d. saltzberg , phys . rev . lett . * 81 * , 4305 ( 1998 ) . s. i. dutta , m. h. reno and i. sarcevic , phys . d * 62 * , 123001 ( 2000 ) . f. becattini and s. bottai , proceedings of the international cosmic ray conference , salt lake city 1999 , vol . 249 - 252 and astropart . phys . * 15 * , 323 ( 2001 ) ; s. bottai and s. giurgola , astropart . phys . * 18 * , 539 ( 2003 ) . e. bugaev , t. montaruli , y. shlepin and i. sokalski , astropart . * 21 * , 491 ( 2004 ) . d. fargion , astrophys . j. * 570 * , 909 ( 2002 ) ; astro - ph/9704205 . s. yoshida , r. ishibashi and h. miyamoto , phys . d * 69 * , 103004 ( 2004 ) . k. giesel , j. h. jureit and e. reya , astropart . phys . * 20 * , 335 ( 2003 ) . j. l. feng , p. fisher , f. wilczek and t. m. yu , phys . lett . * 88 * , 161102 ( 2002 ) . c. aramo , a. insolia , a. leonardi , g. miele , l. perrone , o. pisanti and d. v. semikoz , astropart . * 23 * , 65 ( 2005 ) . d. fargion , astro - ph/0412582 , astro - ph/0106239 , hep - ph/0206010 ; d. fargion , p. g. de sanctis lucentini and m. de santis , astrophys . j. * 613 * , 1285 ( 2004 ) and astro - ph/0501033 ; x. bertou , p. billoir , o. deligny , c. lachaud and a. letessier - selvon , astropart . * 17 * , 183 ( 2002 ) . h. athar , g. parente and e. zas , phys . d * 62 * , 093010 ( 2000 ) . j. jones , i. mocioiu , m. h. reno and i. sarcevic , phys . d * 69 * , 033004 ( 2004 ) . p. yeh _ et al . _ [ nutel collaboration ] , mod . a * 19 * , 1117 ( 2004 ) . z. cao , m. a. huang , p. sokolsky and y. hu , astro - ph/0411677 . see , e.g. , f. halzen and d. hooper , rept . * 65 * , 1025 ( 2002 ) and references therein . s. i. dutta , m. h. reno , i. sarcevic and d. seckel , phys . rev . d * 63 * , 094020 ( 2001 ) . r. gandhi , c. quigg , m. h. reno and i. sarcevic , astropart . phys . * 5 * , 81 ( 1996 ) ; g. m. frichter , d. w. mckay and j. p. ralston , phys . lett . * 74 * , 1508 ( 1995 ) [ erratum - ibid . * 77 * , 4107 ( 1996 ) ] . r. gandhi , c. quigg , m. h. reno and i. sarcevic , phys . d * 58 * , 093009 ( 1998 ) . j. pumplin , d. r. stump , j. huston , h. l. lai , p. nadolsky and w. k. tung , jhep * 0207 * , 012 ( 2002 ) . m. gluck , s. kretzer and e. reya , astropart . phys . * 11 * , 327 ( 1999 ) ; j. kwiecinski , a. martin and a. stasto , phys . d * 56 * , 3991 ( 1997 ) ; k. kutak and j. kwiecinski , eur . phys . j. c * 29 * , 521 ( 2003 ) ; r. fiore et al . , phys . rev . d * 68 * , 093010 ( 2003 ) ; m. v. t. machado , phys . d * 70 * , 053008 ( 2004 ) . s. r. kelner , r. p. kokoulin and a. a. petrukhin , phys . nucl . * 60 * , 576 ( 1997 ) [ yad . fiz . * 60 * , 657 ( 1997 ) ] . based on a parameterization of the hera data by h. abramowicz and a. levy , hep - ph/9712415 .

electromagnetic energy loss of tau leptons is an important ingredient for eventual tau neutrino detection from high energy astrophysical sources . proposals have been made to use mountains as neutrino converters , in which the emerging tau decays in an air shower . we use a stochastic evaluation of both tau neutrino conversion to taus and of tau electromagnetic energy loss . we examine the effects of the propagation for mono - energetic incident tau neutrinos as well as for several neutrino power - law spectra . our main result is a parameterization of the tau electromagnetic energy loss parameter @xmath0 . we compare the results from the analytic expression for the tau flux using this @xmath0 with other parameterizations of @xmath0 .

0912.3828

after the measurement of the orbital velocities of galaxies within clusters @xcite , many other evidences point to the existence of a form of matter which is not coupled to the electromagnetic or to the strong interactions . among these it is possible to list : the accurate measurements of the cosmic microwave background ( cmbr ) @xcite ; the the galaxies rotation velocities @xcite,@xcite ; the gravitational lensing @xcite ; the abundances of light elements @xcite ; and the large scale structures @xcite . with the measurements of the cmbr @xcite the 23% of the universe is estimated to be cold dark matter ( dm ) , while only 4% _ ordinary _ baryonic matter . dm is coupled with gravitational interaction , and via this force to the ordinary matter . as a matter of fact n - body simulations predict that dm is arranged in large structures called _ halos _ ( @xcite ) . the dm density in a halo is large at the centre , and decreases with the distance . the density profile in the central part of the halo is not experimentally known and is studied by means of fits of n - body simulations or with analytic approaches @xcite . non - gravitational dm couplings are studied with : * the direct search for dm scattering on ordinary matter ; * the indirect study of dm annihilation via the secondary products , both charged and neutral ( e@xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath0 rays and lower frequency electromagnetic radiation ) . dm particles might produce gamma rays : * if the dm particles self - annihilate in pairs , possibly following the scheme in fig . 1 . this yields a continuum gamma - ray emission , which is produced by hadronization ( or final state radiation ) of the annihilation products and has a cut - off at the dm particle mass . the direct production of two gamma rays as annihilation products is suppressed in many models ( 10@xmath5 - 10@xmath6 of the continuum ) ; * if pseudo - stable dm particles decay in gammas . in this case the gamma - ray flux is proportional to the dm particle density . the dm decay constant is bound to be larger than 10@xmath7 sec and is model dependent @xcite . , @xmath8 , @xmath9 , are favoured as annihilation products . the annihilation into two gamma rays , for some models , is loop - suppressed , with a branching ratio of 10@xmath5 -10@xmath6 . gamma - ray emission is expected after the heavy fermions hadronize . the gamma - ray emission energy spectrum is a continuum with curved shape ( in log - log scale ) and a sharp cut - off at the dm particle mass.,width=313 ] the gamma - ray flux from dm particle annihilation can be decomposed into a particle physics factor and an astrophysical one . the gamma - ray flux from annihilation can be written as : @xmath10 @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the annihilation cross - section , @xmath13 is the relative velocity of the dm particles , @xmath14 is the number of gamma rays emitted per annihilation for each annihilation channel f , b@xmath15 is the branching ratio of the annihilation channel f and m@xmath16 is the mass of the dm particle candidate . @xmath17(l ) is the dm density profile , ie the density of dm as a function of the distance from the halo center . @xmath17(l)@xmath18 is integrated along the observer s line - of - sight ( @xmath19 ) . the gamma - ray flux from decay can be written as : @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the decay constant , @xmath22 is the number of gamma rays emitted for each decay and m@xmath23 is the mass of the dm particle candidate . @xmath24 is the dm density profile . the strong dependence of the emitted @xmath0-ray flux on the dm density profile is evident in the annihilation case , smaller in the decay one . in fact in the decay scenario @xmath17 , not its square , is integrated along the observer s line - of - sight ( @xmath19 , see fig . 2 ) . in order to search for a gamma - ray signal from dm annihilation ( or decay ) , we observe the region from which we expect the largest signals or the best signal - to - noise ratio , where the noise is the gamma - ray background . our galaxy could be embedded in a dm halo with the central density enhancement co - located with the galactic center . as the dm gamma - ray emission is expected to be a function of the dm density profile the galactic center is expected to be the brightest source of gamma rays from dm annihilation ( see fig . 2 and 3 ) . it might be possible to detect the relatively large dm gamma emission ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) , despite the bright gamma - ray emission from astrophysical processes , which is generated both by discrete sources and diffuse backgrounds , in the galactic center region a better ratio between the dark and baryonic matter , and then a weaker gamma - ray background , is foreseen for the dwarf spheroidal galaxies , or in dm sub - structures in the halo @xcite . to the centre of the galaxy for a navarro - frenk - white ( nfw ) halo distribution for decaying dm , solid ( red ) line , compared to the case of self - annihilating dm , dashed ( blue ) line . both signals have been normalised to their values at the galactic poles , @xmath25 = @xmath2690@xmath27 . reproduced from @xcite.,width=332 ] the fermi gamma - ray space telescope is a space observatory for the study of gamma - ray emission from astrophysical sources . it is equipped with two powerful instruments : 1 . the large area telescope ( lat ) , a pair - conversion telescope , composed of a precision silicon - tracker ( 18 double - sided layers ) and a calorimeter ( 8.6 radiation lengths vertical depth ) , each of which consisting of a 4 @xmath28 4 array of 16 modules and surrounded by a segmented anti - coincidence detector ( acd ) . lat is operated as a gamma - ray imager in the energy range between 20 mev to over 300 gev ; 2 . the gamma - ray burst monitor ( gbm ) , a detector covering the 8 kev-40 mev energy range , devoted to the study of the gamma - ray bursts . detailed descriptions of the fermi observatory can be found in @xcite and the lat on - orbit calibration is reported in @xcite . studies of the gamma - ray sources in the energy range between hundreds of mev and tens of gev were performed by means of the sas 2 and cos b satellites in the years 1972 - 1982 and with the energetic gamma - ray experiment telescope ( egret ) onboard of the compton gamma - ray observatory between 1991 and 2000 . egret detected 271 sources @xcite . an half of the egret sources are unidentified , mainly because of the relatively large errors associated with the source locations . the sources detected with egret are mainly members of two classes : active galactic nuclei ( agns ) of fsrq ( flat spectrum radio quasars ) and bl lac types , with powerful relativistic jets of plasma , and pulsars ( spinning neutron stars , with powerful magnetic fields , capable of accelerating particles up to the high energy regime ) . egret was able to detect both discrete sources and diffuse gamma - ray emissions such as the extra - galactic gamma - ray background and the very intense galactic component . the large area telescope has an effective area five times larger , a much better angular resolution , and a sensitivity more than 10 times better than its predecessor egret . the fermi observatory has several scientific objectives , which span many topics of astrophysics and fundamental physics : ( 1 ) the detailed study of pulsars , agns , diffuse emissions and gamma - ray emission from nearby bodies ; ( 2 ) the study of gamma - ray bursts , up to gev energies with the lat and in the better studied kev- mev range by means of the gbm ; ( 3 ) the search for new classes of gamma - ray emitters ; ( 4 ) the possible signals of new physics . the indirect search for dm particles and the investigation of their nature are major research topics for fermi . here we report an update of the indirect search for dm from the galactic center ( gc ) . before the launch of the fermi observatory , the sensitivity of the lat instrument for the indirect search for dm was estimated in @xcite . in this publication many possible targets for the observation of gamma - ray emission from annihilating dm are considered and the possible limits on the velocity - averaged annihilation cross - section ( @xmath29@xmath12v@xmath30 parameter ) are given , as a function of the dm particle mass . for the galactic center , the considered gamma - ray background was the galactic diffuse emission , but not discrete bright gamma - ray sources . the results are obtained by means of @xmath31 analysis . the plot in fig . 4 shows the constraints in @xmath29@xmath12v@xmath30 vs wimp mass for an assumed pure @xmath32 annihilation channel . a likelihood analysis was instead performed in @xcite , on simulations of both annihilating dm gamma - ray emission and gamma - ray background ( both galactic diffuse emission and the known discrete gamma - ray sources ) . with this model it was possible to conclude that the fermi / lat is sensitive to many benchmark realizations of a dm source , under the assumption that the simulation of the gamma - ray background is realistic . for example a dm particle with mass = 50 gev and a @xmath29@xmath12v@xmath30 = 3@xmath2810@xmath33@xmath34s@xmath35 would have provided @xmath36280 events , within a roi of 1.8@xmath27 radius , in 30 ms . in the same time the simulated background would have generated @xmath3620000 events , and a detection at 5@xmath12 would have been possible , with a maximum likelihood analysis , which exploits both the spatial and the spectral information . unfortunately the simulated background did not reproduce the real complexity of the region . @xmath12v@xmath30 parameter between 0.5 and 100@xmath2810@xmath33@xmath34 s@xmath35 . the galactic diffuse emission ( both conventional and optimized galprop models ) was assumed as background , while the sources were not included as background , and a @xmath31 analysis was applied . in fig 3 is reported the region of the @xmath29@xmath12v@xmath30 vs dm mass plane which can be sampled with fermi / lat in 5 years , with the observations of the galactic center . for this plot a pure @xmath32 annihilation channel and a nfw spatial distribution are assumed . , width=302 ] the first release of results on the galactic center region obtained with the fermi / lat instrument , was made with the @xmath37 publication ( @xcite , see table 1 ) . the fermi / lat in 3 months produced a deep and well - resolved map of the @xmath0-ray sky , thus also providing much better localization of the previous known gamma - ray sources . 205 sources were detected during the first 3 months with statistical significance larger than 10 @xmath12 . the minimum flux for detection of this quality changed from the galactic plane regions ( @xmath38(e@xmath30100 mev)=0.4@xmath2810@xmath39@xmath40s@xmath35 ) to the galactic poles ( @xmath38(e@xmath30100 mev)=0.05@xmath2810@xmath39@xmath40s@xmath35 ) , as a function of the intensity of the bright astrophysical gamma - ray background ( mainly the galactic component ) . in @xcite the source 0fgl j1746.0 - 29.00 is the source closest to the dynamical center of the of the galaxy . 0fgl j1746.0 - 2900 was reported to be marginally variable in @xcite , but this result was not confirmed with larger statistics . 0fgl j1746.0 - 2900 is likely associated to 3eg j1746 - 2851 , an unidentified egret source . a re - analysis of the egret data @xcite indicated for this source a steady integral flux @xmath38(@xmath30100 mev)=(118@xmath2673)@xmath2810@xmath41@xmath40s@xmath35 , with a position displaced from the exact galactic center toward positive galactic longitudes . the tev source in the galactic center ( hess j1745 - 290 ) , a bright source above 100 gev , is notably located near 0fgl j1746.0 - 2900 . the energy spectrum measured with h.e.s.s . @xcite over the three years of data taking is compatible with both a power law spectrum with an exponential cut - off ( photon index of [email protected]@xmath420.10@xmath43 and a cut - off energy at [email protected]@xmath44 @xmath262.5@xmath43 tev ) and a broken power law spectrum ( spectral indices of [email protected]@xmath45 0.10@xmath43 and [email protected]@xmath450.10@xmath43 with a break energy at [email protected]@xmath46 0.44@xmath43 tev ) . no significant flux variation was found . the identification of the tev gamma - ray source is still pending , although the dm annihilation hypothesis for the tev emission is not favoured @xcite . furthermore the h.e.s.s . collaboration reported also weaker @xmath47 emission from the central part of the galactic ridge @xcite . .sources of the fermi bright sources list , with -5@xmath48l@xmath295@xmath27 and -5@xmath48b@xmath295@xmath27 . the source identifier , the galactic longitude and latitude , the radius of the 95% source location confidence region and the integral flux between 1 and 100 gev are reported . the bright sources were detected with a statistical significance above 10@xmath12 in 3months . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] during summer 2009 a first preliminary analysis of the galactic center data , for the indirect search for dm , was reported both at the tevpa @xcite and icrc 2009 @xcite international conferences . for those results the likelihood analysis was used : * a region - of - interest ( roi ) of 1@xmath491@xmath27 was considered ; * the roi was centred at the position ra = 266.46@xmath27 , dec=-28.97@xmath27 ; * the data taken during the first 8 months ( 8/2008 - 4/2009 ) have been used ; * the events were selected to have energy between 200 mev and 40 gev ; * only events classified of `` diffuse '' class were selected for the analysis . for that 8 months analysis data were binned into a single spatial bin , then no spatial information was considered . likelihood analysis for the lat data requires a model of the background ( both diffuse emission and known sources ) . at that time a broken power law was assumed as the model of the gamma - ray emission from this small roi , as it was well - describing the observed data . the broken power - law spectrum was found to have integral flux between 100 mev and 100 gev @xmath50 = ( [email protected] ) 10@xmath39 @xmath40s@xmath35 , first spectral index @xmath51= -1.38 @xmath26 0.04 , second spectral index @xmath51= -2.60@xmath26 0.05 , energy break at e@xmath52 = ( [email protected])gev . then a component representing the gamma - ray emission of annihilating dm was added to the likelihood analysis model . a benchmark dm realization with mass = 50 gev and a pure @xmath32 annihilation channel spectrum was considered . with this model it was possible to put an upper limit of [email protected] 10@xmath53 @xmath40s@xmath35 ( 95% confidence level , above 100 mev ) to the integral gamma - ray flux from a dm annihilation source , which was assumed to have a navarro - frenk - white density profile , and the above reported benchmark mass of 50 gev . this gamma - ray flux upper limit implies a limit of 39.8 @xmath28 10@xmath54 @xmath34s@xmath35 to the @xmath29@xmath12v@xmath30 parameter , if a pure @xmath32 annihilation channel is assumed . nevertheless the analysis is to be considered very conservative , because no spatial information was used . 7@xmath27 roi . the residual spectrum suggests that an unmodeled excess is present in the @xmath362 - 5 gev range . the blue area shows the systematic errors on the effective area . these results are preliminary.,width=313,height=158 ] the reported results were obtained with a binned likelihood analysis , performed by means of the tools developed by the fermi / lat collaboration ( gtlike , from the fermi analysis tools @xcite ) . for this analysis : * a roi of 7@xmath497@xmath27 was considered . this roi was used in order to minimize the background contribution and to avoid significant leakage of the gamma - ray signal under study ; * the roi was centred at the position ra = 266.46@xmath27 , dec=-28.97@xmath27 , ie the position of the brightest source ; * the data taken during the first 11 months ( 8/2008 - 7/2009 ) have been used ; * the events were selected to have energy between 400 mev and 100 gev ; * only events classified of _ diffuse _ class and which converted in the _ front _ part of the tracker have been selected for the analysis . the selection in energy , event classification and conversion provided us with events with very well reconstructed incoming direction and data have been binned into a 100@xmath28100 bins map ; * the irf and the events classification are those relative to the pass6v3 version of the fermi / lat analysis software . in order to perform the likelihood analysis for the lat data , a model of the already known sources and the diffuse background should be built . the model in use for the presented analysis contains 11 sources in the fermi 1 year catalog ( to be published ) which are located into the considered roi , or located very close to the roi boundaries and have a significant fraction of their flux leaking within the studied region . these sources have a point - like spatial model and a spectrum in the form of a power - law . the model also contain the diffuse gamma - ray background which is composed by two components : 1 . the galactic diffuse gamma - ray background . the observed galactic diffuse emission was modelled by means of the galprop code @xcite and @xcite , and the realization of the galactic emission named gll@xmath55iem@[email protected] was used . during the likelihood maximization only the normalization of the galprop model is varied , not its components ; 2 . the isotropic background . this component should account for both the extragalactic gamma - ray emission and residual charged particles . it is modelled as an isotropic emission with a template spectrum . the obtained results are illustrated in fig . the bulk of the gamma - ray emission from this region is explained by means of the above described components , but a residual emission is left . the systematic uncertainty of the effective area of the lat is 10% at 100 mev , decreasing to 5% at 560 mev and increasing to 20% at 10 gev . this uncertainty propagates to the model predictions and should be considered in interpreting the residual spectrum in fig 6 . we have reported a preliminary analysis of the fermi / lat observations of the galactic center . this analysis was focused on the indirect search for dm . from this preliminary analysis the following conclusion are obtained : * any attempt to disentangle a potential dm signal from the galactic center region requires deep understanding of the conventional astrophysics background ; * the bulk of the gamma - ray emission from the gc region is explained with the detected sources and the galactic diffuse emission model , but ... * ... a residual gamma - ray emission is left , not accounted for by the above models . improved modelling of the galactic diffuse model as well as the potential contribution from other astrophysical sources ( for instance unresolved point sources ) could provide a better description of the data . analyses are under - way to investigate these possibilities . the @xmath56 lat collaboration acknowledges the generous support of a number of agencies and institutes that have supported the @xmath56 lat collaboration . these include the national aeronautics and space administration and the department of energy in the united states , the commissariat lenergie atomique and the centre national de la recherche scientifique / institut national de physique nuclaire et de physique des particules in france , the agenzia spaziale italiana and the istituto nazionale di fisica nucleare in italy , the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ( mext ) , high energy accelerator research organization ( kek ) and japan aerospace exploration agency ( jaxa ) in japan , and the k. a. wallenberg foundation , the swedish research council and the swedish national space board in sweden . jc is royal swedish academy of sciences research fellow supported by a grant from the k. a. wallenberg foundation . 99 f.zwicky 1933 , helv.phys . acta 6 , 110 d.n . spergel et al . 2007 , astroph.j.suppl . 170 , 377 a.borriello et al . 2001 , mnras 323 , 285 m.persic et al . 1996 , mnras , 281 , 27 - 47 j.a . tyson et al . 1998 , astroph.j . 498 , l107 k.a . olive et al . 2000 , phys.rept . 333 , 389 m.tegmark et al . 2004 , astroph . j. 606 , 702 e. komatsu et . 2009 , astrophys.j.suppl.180 , 330 v.springel at al . nature 456 , 44 a.lapi & a.cavaliere 2009 , apj 692,174 g.bertone et al . 2007 , jcap 11 , 003b e. baltz et al 2008 , jcap 7 , 13 a.morselli et al . 2002 , nucl.ph . b 113b , 213 a.cesarini et al . 2004 , astrop . 21 , 267 , [ astro- ph/0305075 ] a. lapi et al . 2009 arxiv0912.1766l a.abdo et al . 2009 , `` observations of milky way dwarf spheroidal galaxies with the fermi - lat detector and constraints on dm models '' , apj submitted w.b.atwood et al . [ fermi coll . ] apj 697 no 2 ( 2009 june 1 ) 1071 - 1102 [ arxiv:0902.1089 ] a.abdo et al . 2009 , aph 32 , 193a r.c.hartman et al . 1999 , 123,79 v.vitale , for the fermi / lat coll . , 2009 , aipc 1112 , 164v a.abdo et al . 2009 , apjs 183,46 m. pohl 2005 , apj 626,174 f. aharonian et al , 2009,a&a 503 , 817 - 825 f. aharonian et al . 2006,prl 97,221102 f. aharonian et al . 2006 , nature 439 .. 695a c. meurer et al , 2009 , tevpa proc . v.vitale et al , 2009 , 31st icrc proceedings http://fermi.gsfc.nasa.gov/ssc/data/analysis/software/ a.strong et al . , 2004 , apj 613 , 962s a.strong et al . , 2007 annu nucl . part .

the galactic center region is expected to host the largest density of dark matter ( dm ) particles within the milky way . then a relatively large gamma - ray signal would be expected from the possible dm particles annihilation ( or decay ) . we are searching for the dm gamma - ray signal from the galactic center , which is also rich in bright discrete gamma - ray sources . furthermore intense diffuse gamma - ray emission due to cosmic - ray interactions with interstellar gas and radiation is detected from the same direction . a preliminary analysis of the data , taken during the first 11 months of the fermi satellite operations , is reported . the diffuse gamma - ray backgrounds and discrete sources , as we know them today , can account for the large majority of the detected gamma - ray emission from the galactic center . nevertheless a residual emission is left , not accounted for by the above models . an improved model of the galactic diffuse emission and a careful evaluation of new ( possibly unresolved ) sources ( or source populations ) will improve the sensitivity for a dm search .

1301.4182

electronic bilayer systems have recently drawn increasing attention due to new experimental results on electronic transport @xcite as well as due to the discovery of the novel macroscopic ordering driven by quantum effects.@xcite in a generic situation such systems consist of two spacially separated and mutually insulated semiconducting layers which can be individually gated . on the other hand , the interlayer separation is engineered in such a way that the coulomb interaction between majority carriers in both subsystems is still large . this can be achieved by an appropriate choice for the barrier material . @xcite in such a situation the formation of excitons is possible . even a condensation of such electron - hole pairs was predicted @xcite and subsequently observed in several experiments performed on gaas quantum wells using algaas as the insulating barrier at total filling factor @xmath0 in the quantum hall regime . @xcite while the non - linear transport characteristics of such systems have been investigated before @xcite , their noise properties received only little attention . in we tried to close this gap and have calculated the cumulant generating function ( cgf ) of a bilayer system attached to four different electrodes . some very interesting effects were found , which can only be attributed to the non - trivial interactions between the layers . in order to perform the calculations one had to assume that the transport processes at different junctions occur in an incoherent fashion ( sequential tunneling ) . despite this severe restriction the currents in both layers are correlated due to the locality of the bound electron - hole pairs . here we would like to drop this assumption and consider a fully coherent system . the paper is organized as follows . in the next section we introduce the system and give the details of its mathematical implementation . we briefly review the main results of and adapt them to a recent experimental setup presented in . in section [ s3 ] we present a toy model consisting of two short hubbard chains , which are coupled with each other , so that a formation of an interchain electron - hole pair or exciton is adequately described . in the next step we calculate the full counting statistics , compare the predictions of both models , analyze their similarities and discrepancies . we briefly summarize the results in section [ s4 ] . the basic system we study is depicted in fig . [ fig1 ] : a semiconducting bilayer is contacted by four metallic electrodes via tunnel contacts . the hamiltonian of the system reads @xcite @xmath1 where the term @xmath2 describes the four metallic electrodes which are described as fermionic continua written in terms of electron field operators @xmath3 at chemical potentials @xmath4 . @xmath5 refers to the contacts on the left / right side of the respective layer and @xmath6 labels the top and bottom layer , respectively . we assume the leads to be in the wide flat band limit so that their density of states ( dos ) @xmath7 is constant and denote the fermi distribution functions in the respective electrode by @xmath8 . for the phenomena we would like to consider the spin degree of freedom is irrelevant , therefore we work with a spinless system . @xmath9 is the tunneling hamiltonian describing hopping between each layer of the bilayer and the corresponding metallic electrodes @xmath10 using tunneling amplitudes @xmath11 . finally , @xmath12 describes the bilayer using a simple one - dimensional model as in ( we shall discuss generalizations to higher dimensions later ) @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the longitudinal distance between the right and left side of the semiconductor , @xmath15 is the two - layer spinor and @xmath16 describe the electron / hole single particle hamiltonian of the top and bottom layer . we describe the interlayer coulomb interaction by an exciton order parameter @xmath17 , which in general is a space - dependent quantity . @xcite its absolute value @xmath18 in equilibrium represents the excitonic gap and directly gives the exciton coherence length @xmath19 . it can be determined self - consistently from the interlayer interaction as in bcs theory.@xcite + in order to calculate the cumulant generating function ( cgf ) of charge transfer we use a green s function ( gf ) method developed for quantum impurities in . for every electrode present in the system we have to introduce a fictitious measuring field @xmath20 which counts an electron when it crosses the electrode - semiconductor junction in question . in this manner fluctuations , either caused by the discreteness of charge or thermally induced , can be taken care of . the measuring fields are both contour and time - dependent : they are nonzero only during the measurement time @xmath21 and change sign on the @xmath22 and @xmath23 branch of the keldysh contour . this procedure allows for the calculation of the cgf for arbitrary parameters in eq . ( [ htotal ] ) as discussed in and has already been applied to numerous quantum impurity problems ( see e.g. ) . the cgf can be calculated as a generalized keldysh partition function @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the keldysh contour ordering operator and @xmath26 can be derived from the tunnel hamiltonian in eq . ( [ htunnel ] ) using the substitution @xmath27 . in order to calculate the cgf we then rewrite the expression using the adiabatic potential method in the limit of long measurement times @xmath21 as @xmath28 . the adiabatic potential @xmath29 may in turn be rewritten in terms of the bare and exact - in - tunneling gfs of the system described by eq . ( [ htotal ] ) . the hamiltonian in eq . ( [ hec ] ) is very similar to the bcs hamiltonian . indeed , @xmath30 and @xmath31 can be interpreted as pseudospin indices to map this hamiltonian with the additional exchange of @xmath31 holes to electrons onto bcs theory.@xcite also one has to take into account that electrons and holes each have their own chemical potential @xmath32.@xcite consequently we can also rephrase our problem as the calculation of the spin - dependent cgf for a normal - superconductor - normal ( nsn ) junction with different chemical potentials for the spin species . we want to stress that despite the modelling of the condensate as a perfect homogeneous system in describing the tunneling we assume for the dephasing time @xmath33 : @xmath34 ( incoherent tunneling approximation ) . the cgfs for different normal - superconductor hybrid structures have been considered before . @xcite here the task is to work out the spin - dependent case , to take care of the presence of electrons instead of holes in the lower layer and to address the case of a bilayer contacted from two sides . however , the @xmath17-coupling in eq . is formally a tunneling term . since the layers are supposed to be isolated from each other we have to suppress particle current flowing between the layers . this is very conveniently done by adjusting the chemical potentials in the layers self - consistently . a similar procedure was implemented for a normal - superconductor - normal junction in ref . . under such circumstances it is then unimportant whether we count charges on the left side or the right side of the respective bilayer . this means that we can then calculate the cgf only for the left side and obtain the one for the right side by exchanging @xmath35 . we would like to point out that this self - consistency condition is very different from the conventional one inspired by the bcs theory as it defines the _ relative _ position of the exciton chemical potential with respect to the ones in the external electrodes . using the microscopic hamiltonian approach as outlined in ref . we have obtained the complete expression for the temperature and energy dependent cgf , valid for arbitrary values of the model parameters . @xcite the expression , which has been used for our numerical calculations , is quite lengthy and we do not report it here . nevertheless , all relevant ingredients of the cgf already appear in the limits of small bias ( @xmath36 ) and large bias ( @xmath37 ) , where the expression of the cgf greatly simplifies . indeed in these regimes the non - interacting self - energy due to the ec is either real and purely off - diagonal or imaginary and purely diagonal , like in a superconductor @xcite , while the one due to the normal lead is always diagonal . in these regimes the cgf acquires the following expression @xmath38\right\ } \theta\left(\frac{|\omega_\sigma| - \delta}{\delta}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \ln \left\{1 + t_a(\omega ) \left[(e^{i \lambda_{lt } } e^{-i \lambda_{lb } } -1 ) n_{lt } ( 1-n_{lb } ) \right . \nonumber\\ & & \left . + ( e^{i \lambda_{lb } } e^{-i \lambda_{lt } } -1 ) n_{lb } ( 1-n_{lt } ) \right]\right\}\theta\left(\frac{\delta - \max(|\omega_t| , \ ; |\omega_b|)}{\delta}\right)\right ] , \label{cgf}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath39 and the transmission coefficients are given by @xmath40 the energy - dependent dos of the ec affects the hybridisations @xmath41 where @xmath42 , with the dos of the ec given by @xmath43 . @xmath44 refers to a fermi distribution function at chemical potentials @xmath45 characterising the layer of the semiconductor . we use units such that @xmath46 and @xmath47 . the first line of the cgf describes the supra - gap contribution , which is only due to single electron transport in the simplified form given here and characterised by the normal transmission coefficient @xmath48 . the second line describes the sub - gap contribution due to excitonic andreev reflection @xcite in which an electron and a hole ( in different layers ) enter or leave the ec . @xmath45 now have to be chosen such that @xcite @xmath49 for the sake of simplicity we consider the symmetric case @xmath50 and @xmath51 . then the requirement eq . ( [ self ] ) is always fulfilled for @xmath52 if @xmath53 and @xmath54 . this condition also implies that no current is flowing between the upper and lower layer.@xcite it is interesting to use the above formula to test fluctuation theorems . we have done so for the full result but for the sake of simplicity we illustrate the test for eq . ( [ cgf ] ) . one of the most celebrated examples is the cohen - gallavotti relation , which can be directly related to a symmetry of the cgf.@xcite for a single counting field @xmath55 the cgf is expected to obey in the limit of long measurement time @xcite @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the inverse temperature . however , in our case we encounter several complications compared to this simple case . first , the presence of an interlayer coulomb interaction gives rise to the subgap contribution in eq . ( [ cgf ] ) which couples the top and bottom layer and therefore requires to extend the simple relation in eq . ( [ simplecohen ] ) to both @xmath30 and @xmath31 counting fields . additionally different voltages can be applied on the top and bottom layer . finally , we had to mind self - consistency which we satisfy by setting @xmath58 . still , a relation similar to eq . ( [ simplecohen ] ) holds , namely @xcite @xmath59 even though this is a straightforward generalisation of the cohen - gallavotti relation in eq . ( [ simplecohen ] ) the above relation provides an example how correlations affect the fluctuations in quantum systems . in this way we have supplied an example of a system where a generalized cohen - gallavotti fluctuation theorem holds . from the cgf in ( [ cgf ] ) we can read off several interesting transport features . at @xmath60 and @xmath61 the excitonic andreev reflections dominate the charge transport . then we immediately obtain @xmath62 consequently , we correctly predict that the excitonic andreev reflections induce counterpropagating currents in the layers.@xcite depending on the bias choice we observe different transport features . for equal bias in the two layers @xmath63 the magnitude of the current becomes zero ( exciton blockade ) . if only one layer is biased an opposite current in the other layer is induced ( drag ) . if we further increase the bias difference between the layers the counterflowing currents increase.@xcite this resembles the transport features observable under phase bias instead of voltage bias.@xcite so far only experiments in a typical drag configuration have been made . the inset of fig . [ fig2 ] ( a ) shows a sketch of the experiment described in , where two corbino disks are realized in a gaas / algaas double quantum well structure . the experiment is performed in the @xmath64 quantum hall state of the system and we expect exciton formation between the two corbino disks that serve as the top and bottom layer indicated in fig . [ fig1 ] . in the top layer a current can be excited and additionally the induced drag current in the bottom layer is recorded . + we calculate the current from eq . ( [ cgf ] ) and use @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67ev . we observe good qualitative agreement in fig . [ fig2 ] ( a ) . + we only observe a slight deviation in the bottom current for voltages above the exciton gap . we ascribe this discrepancy to a small interlayer tunnel coupling that might still be present in the system and is also suggested from the analysis of the experimental data . the next logical step is to compute the higher cumulants of the fcs . a number of details was already given in ref . . the current cross correlation of the top and bottom current for the setup shown in fig . [ fig2 ] ( a ) is plotted in fig . [ fig2 ] ( b ) using the same parameters . as we see from fig . [ fig2 ] ( b ) one does not observe a positive cross correlation . this is very different from the setup in which a superconductor is contacted to two normal drains , in which one observes a positive cross correlation of the two currents in the normal leads via crossed andreev reflection . @xcite this discrepancy is due to the fact that we observe the correlation of electrons and holes and not correlations of electron pairs as in the case of superconductors . in this case the positive cross - correlation mediated by crossed andreev reflection turns into an anti - correlation . we expect that this negative correlations should be observable in the experiments similar to the one presented in ref . up to now we have considered a 1d system . due to pointlike contacts to bias electrodes all excitations travel as @xmath68-waves even in higher - dimensional systems , in particular in genuine 2d layers . on the other hand , the ground state changes due to @xmath17 coupling between the layers are qualitatively the same in any dimension since the diagonalization procedure is dimension - independent . in connection with the assumption of incoherent tunnelling we conclude that the physical picture obtained above also holds for 2d layered systems . we expect fundamental changes to occur in the case of extended contacts when a number of different transport channels are possible . however , as long as these channels are non - interacting the corresponding fcs would be a simple sum of expressions for individual channels . a very similar procedure was considered in in connection with superconducting contacts . now we would like to abandon restrictions we made in the previous section . an appropriate model would be two non - interacting fermionic continua particle - hole coupled and perfectly clean so that @xmath69 can be safely assumed . such structure is , however , quite difficult to handle . therefore we model the layers by tight - binding chains of finite lengths . it turns out that in order to account for most of the transport physics we only need to keep two sites in each chain . the effective model can then schematically represented as shown in fig . . has been replaced by two pairs of tight binding chains which have an excitonic coupling described by @xmath70.,width=226 ] + the pairs 1,2 and 3,4 represent different layers of the device . the chemical potentials are now replaced by the bare energies of the sites @xmath71 . then the bilayer part of the hamiltonian is given by @xmath72 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath73 is the tunneling amplitude between the sites within the respective chain and @xmath74 is the exciton coupling . @xmath73 corresponds to the fermi velocity of a continuum realization whereas @xmath74 in the equivalent of the exciton coupling @xmath17 ( it is measured in different units though ) . coupling to the electrodes is modeled in a way similar to that of eq . , @xmath75 for simplicity we have chosen all tunneling amplitudes to the electrodes to be of the same magnitude and the dos in each electrode to be @xmath7 . in order to compute the fcs one performs the same transformation as shown in the previous sections in order to generate @xmath76 . after that the cumulant generating function can be evaluated using functional integration . we integrate the electrode degrees of freedom first , thereby obtaining the new effective green s functions for the individual sites of the bilayer , @xmath77 where @xmath78 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 are the respective counting fields . then the cgf is written as @xmath81 \ , e^{-s } \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath82 @xmath83 are superfields defined by @xmath84 here the index @xmath85 denotes the keldysh component of the respective field . after the calculation of the functional integral we finally obtain @xmath86 \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath87 are yet to be appropriately chosen . to fix them we perform the same procedure as in section [ s2 ] . we compute the currents on both junctions of the upper layer and equalize them . on the other hand , from symmetry arguments it turns out that the choice @xmath88 is particularly convenient . one interesting parameter constellation is the situation of no bias in one of the layers ( the upper one for definiteness ) and finite voltage applied symmetrically around @xmath89 in the bottom subsystem . one can produce analytical formulas for the direct current in the bottom layer ( @xmath90 ) as well as for the induced current in the top layer ( @xmath91 ) , valid at all temperatures , @xmath92 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath93 are the fermi distribution functions in the respective electrodes . the effective transmission coefficients @xmath94 have an interesting structure . they are particularly simple under the assumption @xmath95 , @xmath96}{(\gamma^2 + \omega^2 ) [ \gamma^4 + 2\gamma^2 ( \gamma^2 - \omega^2 ) + ( \gamma^2 + \omega^2)^2 ] } \nonumber \\ d_{\rm ind}(\omega ) & = & \frac { \gamma^2 \gamma^2 [ \gamma^2 - ( \gamma^2 + \omega^2)]}{(\gamma^2 + \omega^2 ) [ \gamma^4 + 2 \gamma^2 ( \gamma^2 - \omega^2 ) + ( \gamma^2 + \omega^2)^2 ] } \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] first of all we observe that @xmath97 is a positively definite quantity and has no zeros , as one would expect from a conventional transmission coefficient . being a ` good ' transmission coefficient , its denominator does not have any zeros on the real axis either . the induced current is finite in almost all parameter regimes . however , for @xmath98 @xmath99 changes sign at @xmath100 . as a result two different generic behaviour types can be observed . for weak @xmath101 @xmath102 flows in the direction opposite to @xmath103 . this regime is largely compatible with the exciton blockade case and we shall call it ` exciton ' regime . here the hybridization of the layer states with their ` own ' electrodes is dominant . in the opposite case of large @xmath104 the currents flow in the same direction and one is confronted with the standard drag situation . these two regimes can also be observed also for @xmath105 , see fig . [ fig5](a ) . strong @xmath106 couplings tend to destroy the excitonic state favoring a rearrangement of individual energy levels in such a way that from the point of view of incoming electrons the constriction is a larger quantum dot rather than two individual layers . nonetheless , the particle counterflow might be significant . this is the feature our toy model shares with the system considered in the previous section [ s2 ] . in the next step we compute the cross correlation of currents in the layers . the calculations are as straightforward as in the case of the current . the results for the cross cumulant of the induced and direct currents for representative parameter sets are shown in fig . [ fig5 ] ( b ) . it turns out that the correlations are remarkably strong and as far as their amplitude is concerned their voltage behavior quantitatively follows the results of the incoherent approximation . a fundamental difference is however , the sign of the correlations which never changes sign and is always positive , unlike the situation discussed in section [ s2 ] . as we have seen above , a drag counterflow due to the exciton coupling is present in both models . this is a very remarkable result in view of the fact , that in the first model transport is assumed to be completely incoherent ( @xmath33 is finite and small ) . on the other hand , while the cross cumulant of the induced and direct currents turns out to be positive in the second model , it is negative in the incoherent approximation . from the physical point of view the fundamental difference between the models is the fully developed gap in the excitation spectrum of the incoherent model . it can not be generated in the toy model though . therefore we conclude that for our setups : ( i ) for the observation of the drag counterflow the gap is not necessary while it is necessary for perfect coulomb drag ; ( ii ) in the presence of the exciton coupling the counterflow can be achieved even in disordered systems ; ( iii ) current anticorrelations exist only in the gapped systems . we expect these predictions to be observable in the upcoming experiments . + the authors would like to thank d. breyel , s. maier and f. dolcini for many interesting discussions . the financial support was provided by cqd of the university of heidelberg . 46ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) \doibase doi:10.1038/nature11302 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/14/6/063010 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.78.121401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3638141 [ * * , ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.126.1691 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1186/1556 - 276x-7 - 145 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.68.1383 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.80.1714 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.84.5808 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.93.036801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.93.036802 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.106.236807 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.156401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.104.027004 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase 10.1051/jphys:019820043070106900 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.73.195301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.54.7366 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.84.235408 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.80.041309 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.84.155305 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.87.067006 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.50.3982 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.79.054505 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physe.2011.09.014 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.80.2913 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.56.3296 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.71.2401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.74.2694 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.100601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.81.1665 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.78.115429 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.84.184528 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.63.165314 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.69.140502 [ * * , ( ) ]

we analyze the transport properties of a semiconductor based bilayer system under non - equilibrium conditions with special emphasis on the charge transfer statistics in the regime dominated by the exciton transport . we consider two different models . in one of them the transport occurs incoherently and is dominated by incoherent tunneling processes of individual excitons , while in the other system no disorder is present and transport processes are fully coherent . we find that the strength of cross correlations of currents in different layers is only insignificantly affected by the disorder and shows up similar behaviour in both systems . we discuss possible experimental realizations and make predictions for measurable quantities .

1412.4693

a comprehension of the link between stochastic processes and quantum mechanics can provide a better understanding of the role of space time at a quantum gravity level . indeed , noncommutative geometry , in the way connes , chamseddine and mukhanov provided recently @xcite , seems to fit well the view that a quantized volume yields a link at a deeper level of the connection between stochastic processes and quantum mechanics . this is an important motivation as we could start from a reformulation of quantum mechanics to support or drop proposals to understand quantum gravity and the fabric of space - time . a deep connection exists between brownian motion and binomial coefficients . this can be established by recovering the kernel of the heat equation from the binomial distribution for a random walk ( pascal tartaglia triangle ) and applying the theorem of central limit @xcite . when an even smaller step in the random walk is taken a wiener process is finally approached . so , it is a natural question to ask what would be the analogous of pascal tartaglia triangle in quantum mechanics@xcite . this arises naturally by noting the apparent formal similarity between the heat equation and the schrdinger equation . but this formal analogy is somewhat difficult to understand due to the factor @xmath0 entering into the schrdinger equation . an answer to this question hinges on a deep problem not answered yet : is there a connection between quantum mechanics and stochastic processes ? the formal similarity has prompted attempts to answer as in the pioneering work of edward nelson @xcite and in the subsequent deep analysis by francesco guerra and his group @xcite . they dubbed this reformulation of quantum mechanics as `` stochastic mechanics '' . this approach matches directly a wiener process to the schrdinger equation passing through a bohm - like set of hydrodynamic equations and so , it recovers all the drawbacks of bohm formulation . this view met severe criticisms motivating some researchers to a substantial claim that `` no classical stochastic process underlies quantum mechanics '' @xcite showing contradiction with predictions of quantum mechanics . subsequent attempts to partially or fully recover this view were proposed with non - markovian processes @xcite or repeated measurements @xcite . in this paper we will show that a new set of stochastic processes can be devised that can elucidate such a connection @xcite . we show their existence @xcite and we will determine how spin is needed also in the non - relativistic limit . dirac equation for a free particle is also obtained . these processes are characterized by the presence of a bernoulli process yielding the values @xmath1 and @xmath0 , exactly as expected in the volume quantization in noncommutative geometry . in this latter case , it appears that a stochastic process on a quantized manifold is well represented by a fractional power of an ordinary wiener process when this is properly defined through a technique at discrete time . for our aims we will use the simplest one : the euler maruyama technique . a numerical test will yield the proof of existence for this class of stochastic processes . also , the kernel of the schrdinger equation is numerically obtained through an ordinary brownian motion . the paper is so strctured . in sec . [ sec2_0 ] we discuss noncommutative geometry in informal way , providing a general formula for a stochastic process on a quantized riemannian manifold . in sec . [ sec2 ] , we introduce the fractional powers of a wiener process and we solve the corresponding stochastic equation recovering the wiener process we started from after squaring its square root . in sec . [ sec3 ] , we derive the formula for the square root of a wiener process expressing it through more elementary processes : this shows the need for a clifford algebra and the fokker planck equation is obtained for a free particle . in sec . [ sec4 ] , we show numerically how the kernel of the schrdinger equation is recovered by an ordinary brownian motion just with the extraction of its square root . in sec . [ sec5 ] , we derive the fokker planck equation in presence of a potential and specialize to the case of a harmonic oscillator . in sec . [ sec6 ] , we show how to recover a stochastic process on a noncommutative geometry taking the square root of more wiener processes and using the algebra of the dirac matrices . in sec . [ sec7 ] , we recover the dirac equation as the fokker planck equation for a square root process . finally , in sec . [ sec8 ] conclusions are presented . common wisdom on geometry implies that one has to cope with points and minimum paths between them . indeed , the idea of geometry can be extended without the central concept of points but rather functions and introducing a redefinition of the concept of distance beside the well - known one from a riemannian geometry . this reformulation is due to alain connes @xcite . essentially , one introduces a triple composed by an algebra of functions @xmath2 with an involution operator like complex conjugation , playing the role of coordinates , a hilbert space @xmath3 , that we take the space of the square - summable spinors , and a dirac operator @xmath4 , being @xmath5 a spin connection , representing momenta . the algebra of functions has support on a riemann manifold . when we change the algebra of functions with a noncommutative algebra of operators acting on the given hilbert space , in the same way one quantize a classical theory , one gets a noncommutative geometry . so , a geometry is identified by the triple ( @xmath2,@xmath3,d ) . a function @xmath6 belonging to @xmath2 should satisfy the lipschitz condition on the riemann manifold given by @xmath7 provided the constant @xmath8 exists and @xmath9{\ } { \rm inf}\left(\int_\gamma ds\right)\ ] ] is the usual ( geodesic ) distance on a riemann manifold that coincides with the well - known variational principle of minimum distance between two points . this grants some regularity properties of the functions in @xmath2 and their gradient that is bounded . in this way , we can introduce a new definition of distance dependent just on the algebra of functions @xmath2 and the dirac operator . this is given by @xmath10{\ } { \rm sup}(|f(x)-f(y)| : f\in{\cal a},\lvert df\rvert<1)\ ] ] where the condition on the dirac operator plays a crucial role . in this way , one recovers the ordinary riemann distance between points @xcite . indeed , one has for a spinor @xmath11 @xmath12\psi = i\gamma\cdot\partial f\psi.\ ] ] then we need @xmath13\rvert=\lvert\sqrt{\partial_\mu f\partial^\mu f}\rvert\le 1.\ ] ] this is nothing else than asking the boundedness of the gradient of @xmath6 . we know that @xmath6 is lipshitz on the manifold and so , we can apply the cauchy mean value theorem implying that @xmath14\rvert\le\frac{|f(x)-f(y)|}{d_r(x , y)}\ ] ] because a constant @xmath8 exists that can limit the derivatives on the manifold . now , this implies , due to the condition @xmath15 , that @xmath16 and this means that @xmath17 is the upper extreme as required by our definition of distance . the main conclusion is that the dirac operator plays the role of the inverse of the distance @xmath18 . a noncommutative geometry implies that the volume is quantized with two classes of unity of volume @xmath19 . this has been recently proved by connes , chamseddine and mukhanov@xcite . the two classes of volume arise from the fact that the dirac operator should not be limited to majorana states in the hilbert space and so , we need to associate a charge conjugation operator @xmath20 to our triple @xmath21 . to complete our characterization of our geometry , we recall that the algebra of dirac matrices implies a @xmath22 , the chirality matrix . for an ordinary riemann manifold , the algebra @xmath2 is that of functions and is commuting . remembering that @xmath23=i\gamma\cdot\partial a$ ] , and noting that , in four dimensions , @xmath24 are legal functions of @xmath25 , it is @xmath26[d , x_2][d , x_3][d , x_4]=\gamma^1\gamma^2\gamma^3\gamma^4=-i\gamma^5 $ ] . for generally chosen functions in @xmath25 , @xmath27 , summing over all the possible permutations one has a jacobian , we can define the chirality operator @xmath28\ldots[d , a_d]).\ ] ] so , in four dimension this gives @xmath29 being @xmath20 the jacobian , @xmath30 the vierbein for the riemann manifold and @xmath31 for @xmath32 , a well - known result . we used the fact that @xmath33 , being @xmath34 the metric tensor . so , the definition of the chirality operator is proportional to the factor determining the volume of a riemannian orientable manifold . in order to see if a riemannian manifold can be properly quantized , instead of functions we consider operators @xmath35 belonging to an operator algebra @xmath36 . these operators have the properties @xmath37 this is a set of compact operators playing the role of coordinates as in the heisenberg commutation relations . we have to consider two sets of them @xmath38 and @xmath39 as we expect a conjugation of charge operator @xmath40 to exist such that @xmath41 for a given operator or complex conjugation for a function . this appears naturally out of a dirac algebra of gamma matrices . so , a natural way to write down the operators @xmath35 is by using an algebra of dirac matrices @xmath42 such that @xmath43 with @xmath44 , then @xmath45 we will have two different set of gamma matrices for @xmath38 and @xmath39 that will have independent traces . using the charge conjugation operator @xmath40 , we can define a new coordinate @xmath46 where @xmath47 will project one or the other coordinate . we recognize that the spectrum of @xmath48 is in @xmath19 given eq.([eq : y ] ) . now , we generalize our equation for the chirality operator imposing a trace on @xmath49s both for @xmath38 and @xmath39 , normalized to the number of components , and we will have @xmath50\ldots[d , z]\rangle=\gamma.\ ] ] where we have introduced the average @xmath51 that , in this case , reduces to matrix traces . in order to see the quantization of the volume , let us consider a three dimensional manifold and the sphere @xmath52 . from eq.([eq : z ] ) one has @xmath53\ldots[d , z]\rangle d^3x\ ] ] and doing the traces one has @xmath54 it is easy to see that this will yield@xcite @xmath55 the coordinates @xmath38 and @xmath39 belongs to unitary spheres and the dirac operator has a discrete spectrum , so we are covering all the manifold with a large integer number of these spheres . thus , the volume is quantized as this condition requires . this can be extended to four dimensions with some more work @xcite . differently from an ordinary stochastic process , a wiener process on a quantized manifold will yield the projection of the spectrum @xmath19 of the coordinates on the two kind of spheres @xmath56 . this will depend on the way a particle moves on the manifold taking into account that the distribution of the two kind of unitary volumes is absolutely random . one can construct a process @xmath57 such that , against a toss of a coin , one gets 1 or i as outcome , assuming the distribution of the unitary volumes is uniform . this can be written @xmath58 with @xmath59 a bernoulli process producing the value @xmath60 depending on the unitary volume hit by the particle such that @xmath61 , a deterministic process giving always 1 , and @xmath62 . if we want to consider the brownian motion of the particle on such a manifold we should expect the outcomes to be either @xmath38 or @xmath39 . so , given the set of @xmath49 matrices and the chirality operator @xmath63 , the most general form for a stochastic process on the manifold can be written down ( summation on @xmath64 is implied ) @xmath65 being @xmath66 arbitrary coefficients of this linear combination . the bernoulli processes @xmath67 and the wiener process @xmath68 can not be independent . rather , the sign arising from the bernoulli process is the same of that of the corresponding wiener process . this equation provides the equivalent of the eq.([eq : y ] ) for the coordinates on the manifold . this is exactly the formula we will obtain for the fractional powers of a wiener process . it just represents the motion on a quantized riemannian manifold with two kind of quanta . underlying quantum mechanics there appears to be a noncommutative geometry . we consider an ordinary wiener @xmath69 process describing a brownian motion and define the @xmath70-th power of it . we do a proof of existence by construction using a numerical integration technique of a stochastic differential equations ( sde ) @xcite . we will have the process ( given @xmath71 ) with definition @xmath72 we build it through the euler maruyama definition of a stochastic process @xcite at discrete times @xmath73 this is equivalent to take the power and then a ( cumulative ) sum exactly as done in simulating a wiener process when @xmath74 . for our numerical test we consider the square root process with @xmath75 as it is the one of interest for quantum mechanics . in this case the wiener process has two components : one real and another imaginary . we just compare the original brownian motion with the square of its square root given by numerically solving eq.([eq : e - m ] ) . the result is displayed in fig . [ fig1 ] . ] the results are perfectly identical and our definition by euler maruyama technique just works . the square root process is so shown to exist by construction . we note that the need for a complex valued stochastic process is essential if we aim to recover quantum mechanics . on the other side , taking the square root of values that can have both positive and negative values entails coping with complex numbers . one can always take the power of whatever sequence of numbers as that of a wiener process . using it calculus to express the square root process with more elementary stochastic processes @xcite , @xmath76 , @xmath77 , @xmath78 and @xmath79 for @xmath80 , we could tentatively set @xmath81 being @xmath82 an arbitrary scale factor and @xmath83 a bernoulli process equivalent to a coin tossing that has the property @xmath84 . this process is characterized by the values @xmath1 and @xmath0 and it is like the brownian motion went scattering with two different kinds of small pieces of space , each one contributing either 1 or i to the process , randomly . we have introduced the process @xmath85 that yields just the signs of the corresponding wiener process . eq.([eq : sqrt ] ) is unsatisfactory for a reason , taking the square yields @xmath86 and the original wiener process is not exactly recovered . we find added a process that has the effect to change the scale of the original brownian motion while retaining the shape . we can fix this problem by using pauli matrices . let us consider two pauli matrices @xmath87 with @xmath88 such that @xmath89 . we can rewrite the above identity as @xmath90 and so , @xmath91 as it should , after removing the identity matrix on both sides . this idea generalizes easily to higher dimensions using @xmath63 matrices . in the following we will omit the contribution due to the pauli matrices but it will be implied to remove the unwanted scale changing process . now , let us consider a more general square root process where we assume also a term proportional to @xmath92 . this forces to take @xmath93 when the square is taken , to recover the original stochastic process , and one has @xmath94^\frac{1}{2}= \left[\frac{1}{2}+dw(t)\cdot{\operatorname{sgn}}(dw(t))+(-1+\beta{\operatorname{sgn}}(dw(t)))dt\right]\phi_{\frac{1}{2}}(t).\ ] ] from the bernoulli process @xmath95 we can derive @xmath96 then , we get a double fokker planck equation for a free particle , being the distribution function @xmath97 complex valued , @xmath98 this should be expected as we have a complex stochastic process and then two fokker planck equations are needed to describe it . we have obtained an equation strongly resembling the schrdinger equation for a complex distribution function . we can ask at this point if indeed are recovering quantum mechanics . in the following section we will perform a numerical check of this hypothesis . if really the square root process diffuses as a solution of the schrdinger equation we should be able to recover the corresponding solution for the kernel @xmath99 sampling the square root process . to see this we note that a wick rotation , @xmath100 , turns it into a heat kernel as we get immediately @xmath101 a montecarlo simulation can be easily executed extracting the square root of a brownian motion and , after a wick rotation , to show that a heat kernel is obtained . we have generated 10000 paths of brownian motion and extracted its square root in the way devised in sec . we have evaluated the corresponding distribution after wick rotating the results for the square root . the wick rotation generates real results as it should be expected and a comparison can be performed . the result is given in fig . [ fig2 ] the quality of the fit can be evaluated being @xmath102 with confidence interval @xmath103 $ ] , @xmath104 with confidence interval @xmath105 $ ] for the heat kernel while one has @xmath106 with confidence interval @xmath107 $ ] and @xmath108 with confidence interval @xmath109 $ ] for the schrdinger kernel . both are centered around 0 and there is a factor @xmath110 between standard deviations as expected from eq . ( [ eq : fpsch ] ) . both the fits are exceedingly good . having recovered the schrdinger kernel from brownian motion with the proper scaling factors in mean and standard deviation , we can conclude that we are doing quantum mechanics : _ square root of a brownian motion describes the motion of a quantum particle_. need for pauli matrices , as shown in the preceding section , implies that spin can not be neglected . in order to understand how to introduce a potential within this approach we use the following mapping theorem between the fokker planck and the schrdinger equation @xcite : the fokker planck operator for a gradient flow can be written in the self - adjoint form @xmath111 _ define now @xmath112 . then @xmath113 solves the pde _ @xmath114 on the basis of the given theorem , we can immediately generalize our formulation to the case of a potential . we will have @xmath115^\frac{1}{2}=\left\{\frac{1}{2}+dw\cdot{\operatorname{sgn}}(dw(t))+ ( -1+u(x , t){\operatorname{sgn}}(dw(t)))dt\right\}\phi_{\frac{1}{2}}(t).\ ] ] the corresponding fokker planck equation will be @xmath116-\frac{i}{4}\frac{\partial^2\hat\psi}{\partial x^2}.\ ] ] as an example we consider a harmonic oscillator with @xmath117 @xmath118^\frac{1}{2}=\left\{\frac{1}{2}+dw\cdot{\operatorname{sgn}}(dw(t))+ \left(-1+\frac{k}{2}x^2{\operatorname{sgn}}(dw(t))\right)dt\right\}\phi_{\frac{1}{2}}(t).\ ] ] here @xmath119 is an arbitrary constant and the quantum potential is @xmath120 , using the mapping between the fokker planck and the schrdinger equations . the corresponding schrdinger equation will be @xmath121 with the introduction of @xmath122 as we get what is conventionally a time - reversed quantum evolution . we have seen that , in order to extract the square root of a stochastic process , we needed pauli matrices or , generally speaking , a clifford algebra . this idea was initially put forward by dirac to derive his relativistic equation for fermions . the simplest and non - trivial choice is obtained , as said above , using pauli matrices @xmath123 that satisfy @xmath124 this proves to be insufficient to go to dimensions higher than 1 + 1 for brownian motion . the more general solution is provided by a dirac algebra of @xmath63 matrices @xmath125 such that @xmath126 being @xmath127 the minkowski metric . in this way one can introduce three different brownian motions for each spatial coordinates and three different bernoulli processes for each of them . the definition is now @xmath128 it is now easy to check that @xmath129 the fokker - planck equations have a solution with 4 components , as now the distribution functions are dirac spinors . these are given by @xmath130 being @xmath131 . this implies that , the general formula for the square root process implies immediately spin and antimatter for quantum mechanics that now come out naturally . but this appears just like the non - relativistic limit of the dirac equation and so , having already introduced the @xmath63 matrices at this stage , it should be natural to get a fully covariant dirac equation . in the next section we will show that this indeed the case so that , the metric element of a noncommutative geometry arise naturally as the fokker planck equation of a stochastic process . dirac equation works on a 4-dimensional manifold and so , we will need four wiener processes to derive it . this assures full lorentz invariance but , on the other side , time should be treated as any other space variable . we need a further time variable , a fictitious one ( as happens in stochastic quantization ) , to get fokker planck equations in this case . to accomplish this one has to introduce the @xmath132 matrix , as already seen in noncommutative geometry , in the following way @xmath133 now one has a fictitious time variable @xmath134 but we have a full family of solutions to the fokker - planck equations parametrized by @xmath134 . only the fixed point solutions , the eigenstate with zero eigenvalue , reproduce the klein - gordon equation for a free massless particle with a dirac spinor . @xmath135 this recovers completely dirac theory for a free particle from brownian motions . we recognize in eq.([eq : dirac ] ) the same stochastic process arising in noncommutative geometry in eq.([eq : ncgsp ] ) . we have shown the existence of a class of stochastic processes that can support quantum behavior . a typical one is the square root of a brownian motion from which the schrdinger equation comes out naturally . the case with a potential was also discussed and applied to the harmonic oscillator . finally , we have derived the dirac equation while spin and antimatter are naturally introduced by a stochastic behavior . this formalism could entail a new understanding of quantum mechanics and give serious hints on the properties of space - time for quantum gravity . this yields a deep connection with noncommutative geometry as formulated by alain connes through the more recent proposal of space quantization by connes himself , chamseddine and mukhanov . this quantization of volume entails two kind of quanta implying naturally the unity @xmath19 that arises in the square root of a wiener process . indeed , a general stochastic process for a particle moving on such a quantized volume corresponds to our formula of the square root of a stochastic process on a 4-dimensional manifold . spin appears to be an essential ingredient , already at a formal level , to treat such fractional powers of brownian motion . finally , it should be interesting , and rather straightforward , to generalize this approach to a dirac equation on a generic manifold . the idea would be to recover also einstein equations as a fixed point solution to the fokker - planck equations as already happens in string theory . then they would appear as a the result of a thermodynamic system at the equilibrium based on noncommutative geometry . this is left for further study . i would like to thank alfonso farina for giving me the chance to unveil some original points of view on this dusty corner of quantum physics . 9 a. h. chamseddine , a. connes and v. mukhanov , phys . lett . * 114 * , no . 9 , 091302 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1409.2471 [ hep - th ] ] . a. h. chamseddine , a. connes and v. mukhanov , jhep * 1412 * , 098 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1411.0977 [ hep - th ] ] . g. weiss , _ aspects and applications of the random walk _ ( north - holland , amsterdam , 1994 ) . e. nelson , _ dynamical theories of brownian motion _ ( princeton university press , princeton , 1967 ) . f. guerra _ phys . _ * 77 * , 263 ( 1981 ) . h. grabert , p. hnggi , p. talkner , phys . a * 19 * , 2440 ( 1979 ) . g. a. skorobogatov , s. i. svertilov , phys . a * 58 * , 3426 ( 1998 ) . p. blanchard , s. golin , m. serva . d * 34 * , 3732 ( 1986 ) . m. s. wang , w.k . liang , phys . d * 48 * , 1875 ( 1993 ) . p. blanchard , m. serva , phys . d * 51 * , 3132 ( 1995 ) . a. farina , m. frasca , m. sedehi , signal , image and video processing * 8 * , 27 ( 2014 ) . m. frasca , arxiv:1201.5091 [ math - ph ] ( 2012 ) unpublished . m. frasca , a. farina , arxiv:1403.1075 [ math - ph ] ( 2014 ) ( unpublished ) . a. connes , `` noncommutative geometry , '' ( academic press , boston , 1994 ) . g. bimonte , f. lizzi and g. sparano , phys . b * 341 * , 139 ( 1994 ) [ hep - lat/9404007 ] . d. j. higham _ siam review _ * 43 * , 525 ( 2001 ) . b. k. ksendal , _ stochastic differential equations : an introduction with applications _ ( springer , berlin , 2003 ) , p. 44 . g. a. pavliotis , _ lectures on applied stochastic processes _ ( london : imperial college ) , version of january 16 , see p. 177 ( 2011)(unpublished ) . h. risken , _ the fokker - planck equation methods of solution and applications _ ( springer , berlin , 1984 ) , p. 142 .

the recent analysis on noncommutative geometry , showing quantization of the volume for the riemannian manifold entering the geometry , can support a view of quantum mechanics as arising by a stochastic process on it . a class of stochastic processes can be devised , arising as fractional powers of an ordinary wiener process , that reproduce in a proper way a stochastic process on a noncommutative geometry . these processes are characterized by producing complex values and so , the corresponding fokker planck equation resembles the schrdinger equation . indeed , by a direct numerical check , one can recover the kernel of the schrdinger equation starting by an ordinary brownian motion . this class of stochastic processes needs a clifford algebra to exist . in four dimensions , the full set of dirac matrices is needed and the corresponding stochastic process in a noncommutative geometry is easily recovered as is the dirac equation in the klein gordon form being it the fokker planck equation of the process .

1012.1395

the crab pulsar wind nebula is powered by its central pulsar born from a supernova explosion in 1054 . it is a very luminous source in almost all wavelengths , from radio to the very high energy ( vhe ) @xmath0-ray bands . the broadband non - thermal emission spectrum is well modeled by a synchrotron - inverse compton ( ic ) scenario with the transition from the synchrotron to ic component occurring at a few hundred mev @xcite . the overall emission seems to be steady , so that the crab nebula has been adopted as a standard candle in high energy astrophysics to calibrate observations from different instruments . however , detailed images of the crab nebula in optical and x - ray bands indicated dynamical structures at small scales . observations by the hubble space telescope revealed wisps and knots in the nebula , and resolved some substructures of the highly variable wisps @xcite . x - ray observations by rosat and chandra uncovered a jet - torus structure of the inner nebula @xcite , and the equatorial ring is found moving outwards with a speed of @xmath3 @xcite . at higher energies in the @xmath0-ray band , detailed structures of the nebula generally can not be resolved . however , comptel and egret observations indicated that the synchrotron radiation in @xmath4 mev is variable on a timescale of @xmath5 yr . in september 2010 , agile collaboration reported a @xmath0-ray flare above @xmath6 mev from the direction of the crab nebula , which lasted for about 3 days ( atel # 2855 ; tavani et al . the flux during the flare period is about @xmath7 times higher than the average one . this flare was soon confirmed by the fermi / lat collaboration ( atel # 2861 ) , and archive search of the fermi / lat data revealed another flare in february 2009 @xcite . there were many other simultaneous or follow - up measurements for the flare in september 2010 in x - ray , optical , infrared and radio bands . however , no significant flux enhancement was discovered . in the vhe @xmath0-ray energies , argo - ybj collaboration claimed the detection of a flux enhancement around tev , with a possibly longer duration ( atel # 2921 ) . however , magic and veritas observed the source with a shorter duration during the flare phase and did not reveal any enhancement in flux ( atel # 2967 , # 2968 ) . it was proposed that the flares was due to synchrotron emission of ultra - relativistic electrons with energies up to @xmath2pev @xcite . considering the fact that the rest frame synchrotron radiation in a magnetic field dominated acceleration regime can not exceed @xmath8 mev due to the fast synchrotron cooling of high energy electrons @xcite , the observed gev emission implies doppler shift of the radiation region or other acceleration mechanisms instead of shock acceleration @xcite . @xcite proposed that the @xmath0-ray variability ( flare ) originated from the `` inner knot '' of the crab nebula ( `` knot 1 '' as defined in @xcite ) , with mildly doppler - boosted emission . the instability of the termination shock may cause the variability as revealed by magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) simulations . @xcite suggested that electrons are accelerated in a region behind the shock , and the variability was attributed to changes in the maximum energy of accelerated electrons , electron spectral index or the magnetic field . in this letter we employ a statistical approach to model the @xmath0-ray variability of the nebula . fermi / lat observations have shown that the low - energy synchrotron component is variable on monthly time scale , while the high - energy ic component seems to be stable @xcite . since the synchrotron @xmath0-rays are produced by the highest energy electrons , these observations indicate that fluctuations at the high - energy end of the electron distribution might be responsible for the variability . it is natural to expect that events that can generate the highest energy electrons are rarer , and therefore would lead to the largest fluctuation . therefore the variability and flares in the sub - gev @xmath0-rays can be simply due to the statistical fluctuation of the highest energy electrons achievable in the electron accelerators . lower energy electrons do not suffer from significant fluctuations since many more accelerators can contribute to them simultaneously , which gives rise to a `` steady - state '' emission in both the lower energy synchrotron component and the higher energy ic component . we build a physically possible model to investigate the above picture in more details . we assume that electrons are accelerated in a series of knots with a power - law energy spectrum @xmath9 with the maximum electron energy @xmath10 being proportional to the size of the @xmath11th knotpc , which just corresponds to the size of the emission region as indicated by the day - scale flare . therefore we assume the largest size of the knots is @xmath12 , and for all other knots smaller than @xmath12 the scaling relation between @xmath10 and @xmath13 can well hold . ] . we further assume that the size of knots has a power - law distribution @xmath14 . adding the contribution from all these knots together , noticing that the normalization of the synchrotron spectrum of the knots scales as @xmath15 , we get the total electron spectrum as @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the heaviside step function , @xmath18 is the maximum energy of the largest knot . if @xmath19 , the above integral of the last step is approximately proportinal to @xmath20 given the maximum energy of the largest knot @xmath21 ; if @xmath22 the integral is nearly a constant determined by @xmath18 . therefore the electron spectrum is a power law @xmath23 with power - law index @xmath24 and a cutoff determined by the largest knot . the maximal energy of synchrotron emission in the magnetic field dominated acceleration regime is @xmath8 mev @xcite ( defined by equating the synchrotron cooling time scale to the gyro - period , the minimum of the acceleration time scale ) . for smaller accelerators , the maximum energy is also limited by the size of the accelerator . in order to account for the observations in the @xmath1 mev range , we therefore further employ a mild doppler boost factor . we assume a gaussian distributed lorentz factor of all the knots with a mean value @xmath25 and a standard deviation @xmath26 . such a lorentz factor is consistent with the upper limit of the typical velocity of the jet @xcite . we assume that the angle @xmath27 between the knot motion and the line - of - sight is randomly distributed . the doppler factor @xmath28 ( where @xmath29 is the velocity of the knot in unit of @xmath30 ) therefore is distributed within the range @xmath31 for a @xmath32 distribution of @xmath33 . only knots with large enough size and large enough doppler factor can contribute to high energy synchrotron radiation to account for the flares observed by the fermi / lat . we realize such a picture by a monte - carlo simulation . we directly simulate the synchrotron spectrum in each knot instead of the electron spectrum . the synchrotron spectrum of each knot in its co - moving frame is adopted as @xmath34 , where @xmath35 , @xmath36 is the synchrotron spectral index . where @xmath37 is the power - law index of the overall electron distribution . the magnetic field in each knot is not explicitly used in the calculation . the magnetic field will affect the cooling break of the low energy synchrotron spectrum as well as the high energy cooling time scale . to keep the basic framework of the present study , we may expect the magnetic field not to vary significantly with respect to the knot size . the energy loss of electrons in the knots can be important and needs to be considered . for instantaneous injection of accelerated electrons , the probability of observing electrons at a given energy is proportional to the corresponding synchrotron cooling time @xmath38 . for low energy electrons with cooling time longer than the age of the crab nebula @xmath39 yr , these electrons will survive and accumulate . therefore we can construct a probability function @xmath40 , describing the effect of cooling on the electron spectrum . the cooling time of electrons producing synchrotron photon with energy @xmath41 is @xmath42 yr . for an average magnetic field @xmath43 mg , a mildly doppler factor @xmath44 , electrons producing photons with an energy @xmath45 ev have a cooling time comparable to @xmath46 . the observed spectrum of crab nebula has a break near @xmath47 ev ( see below fig . [ fig : f1 ] ) . in this work we mainly focus on the high energy part of the spectra , e.g. , from x - ray to @xmath0-ray band , then @xmath48 . assuming that the accelerated electrons have a spectrum index @xmath49 , the electron spectrum index in the synchrotron cooling dominated regime is then @xmath50 . here we adopt @xmath51 which corresponds to @xmath52 , as required by fitting the radio - optical data . the maximum value of @xmath53 is taken as @xmath54 mev in the co - moving frame ( corresponding to the largest knot ) . this value is derived according to a fit to the average fermi / lat spectrum of the synchrotron component @xcite , given the lorentz factor distribution . the power - law index of the size distribution is adopted as @xmath55 . adding all the contribution from the knots together we can get a total synchrotron spectrum @xmath56 , which can reproduce the observed optical - mev band data of the crab nebula ( fig . [ fig : f1 ] ) . note that these parameters , i.e. , @xmath33 , @xmath53 , @xmath57 and @xmath58 are not uniquely determined . what we adopt in this work is an illustration of the model . once the data from optical to @xmath0-ray band are reproduced , the discussion below is basically unchanged if a different set of parameters is taken . for each knot we randomly generate an angle @xmath27 and a lorentz factor @xmath33 based on the assumed gaussian distribution , and calculate the doppler factor @xmath59 . then the frequency of synchrotron emission from each knot is shifted from @xmath60 to @xmath61 , and the flux is enhanced to @xmath62 . the contribution from all the knots are summed up to obtain the total emission spectrum . realizations . the thick blue line denote the fit to the multi - wavelength steady state observational data , which can be understood as the average result of many realizations in our model . the black - dashed curve denotes the contribution from a maximum size knot with slightly specific parameters ( see the text ) , which is shown to be able to explain the large flare in september 2010 . the references of the observational data are : radio - optical @xcite , integral @xcite , comptel , fermi / lat @xcite , magic @xcite , hegra @xcite , hess , tibet - as@xmath0 @xcite , and fermi / lat flares @xcite . ] a series of simulated synchrotron spectra are shown in fig . [ fig : f1 ] , which are compared with the observational data of the crab nebula . note that for the integral data we adopt a flux normalization factor @xmath63 in order to be consistent with the extrapolation of comptel data . in a @xmath64 factor was adopted to match the xmm - newton data . the difference of flux normalization may be due to discrepancies in calibration of different detectors . the fact that the integral data may contain emission from the crab pulsar may also contribute to the difference . for comparison we show the fitting results to the broad band data with the blue thick line , with a broken power - law electron spectrum . this result is similar to the model invoking two population electrons as introduced in @xcite and . it is shown that the simulated synchrotron spectra have very small fluctuations in the x - ray energy band , but fluctuate significantly at higher energies ( @xmath65 mev ) . the average of the simulated @xmath0-ray flux would be consistent with the long term fermi / lat and comptel data . the fluctuations can be responsible for the observed variabilities and flares . the very large flare at september 2010 that is not well reproduced by these simulations can be regarded as an event with very small probability . such an event may be due to a large knot with specific parameters different from what used in the model . the black - dashed line in fig . [ fig : f1 ] shows a possible reproduction of the large flare , produced by a knot with maximum size , doppler factor @xmath66 , cutoff energy of synchrotron radiation in its comoving system @xmath67 mev and an additional normalization factor @xmath68 of the flux . detailed modeling of the knot formation and its evolution is expected to better address this issue . we pick out two realizations and show the synchrotron sky - maps at 10 kev ( left ) and 100 mev ( right ) in fig . [ fig : f2 ] , respectively . to generate a sky - map , we designate an @xmath69 plane with @xmath70 pixels . we randomly assign a position for each knot in the @xmath69 plane , with the largest knot having a size of @xmath71 pixels . we then sum up contributions of all the knots located in each pixel and obtain the sky - map . it is shown that in the x - ray band ( left panels ) the skymaps are relatively smooth with some hot spots due to several large knots . these hot spots may correspond to the chandra and hubble knots of the crab nebula ( atel # 2882 , # 2903 ) . the total flux of x - ray emission , however , is statistically steady from time to time . the width of the total x - ray flux distribution at @xmath72 kev is estimated to be of the order @xmath73 , which is consistent with the upper limit of @xmath74 obtained by swift / bat ( atel # 2858 ) . the @xmath1 mev @xmath0-ray sky - map could differ significantly from each other . in some cases , one or several large knots would dominate the total flux . the predicted energy - dependent spatial scales due to fluctuations may not be ready to test with the available high energy telescopes , but higher angular resolution observations in the future will help . -ray flare , while the lower one shows a realization with relatively weak @xmath0-ray emission . ] according to our model , the ic component should not show significant variability except in the high energy regime ( @xmath75 tev ) , depending on the maximal electron energies . for example , for a magnetic field @xmath76 mg , the maximal lorentz factor of electron can be as high as @xmath77 . therefore only the ic photons with energies higher than several hundred tev would have relatively large fluctuations . this conclusion is different from that of @xcite , who suggested that the ic @xmath0-ray spectra also vary significantly at multi - tev energies . the upper panel shows the results with weekly bin and the bottom panel for monthly bin . the vertical axes in each panel indicate the average value of the simulations , which is normalized to the observational value @xmath78 @xmath79 s@xmath80 @xcite . the fermi / lat observational data with monthly bin are also plotted in the lower panel . ] to investigate fluctuations of emission in detail , we show in fig . [ fig : f3 ] the light curves of the simulated synchrotron fluxes in the @xmath1 mev energy band . each bin of the light curves represents an independent realization , and the length of the time bin is proportional to the number of knots . we normalize the time scale so that over a year there is an enhancement in flux by at least a factor of 5 - 6 , which may be responsible for a flare , and plot the weekly and monthly bin lightcurves in the upper and lower panels of fig . [ fig : f3 ] , respectively . for comparison we also plot the fermi / lat observed monthly light curve @xcite in the lower panel of fig . [ fig : f3 ] . it can be seen that the predicted fluctuation level of the simulated results is very similar to that observed by fermi / lat . in order to show this more clearly , we plot the histogram of the monthly bin flux distribution for the simulated results along with that of fermi / lat observation in the left panel of fig . [ fig : f4 ] . these two distributions are indeed similar . in the right panel of fig . [ fig : f4 ] the histogram of flux distribution for weekly bin is also plotted . a concentration toward low - flux is evident , which is distinct from a symmetric distribution around the average value . this is because in the short time scale limit , the distribution of the gamma - ray fluxes is determined by the distributions of the knots ( power - law ) and the doppler factors . only the knots with both large enough sizes and high enough doppler factors can produce large gamma - ray fluxes . therefore the probability to give large fluxes is very small , and the flux distribution concentrates towards low - flux values . in the limit of long time scale , the distribution should be gaussian as a result of central limit theorem . such a prediction can be tested by a detailed analysis of the fermi / lat data . in summary , we propose a statistical picture to explain the observed @xmath0-ray variability and flares of the crab nebula , using the fluctuations of the highest end of the electron spectra . the electrons are thought to be accelerated in a series of knots , with a size distribution @xmath14 and a distribution of the doppler factor . the maximal energy of the electrons in the co - moving frame is assumed to be proportional to the size of the knots . thus the rare knots with large sizes and high doppler boosts may generate electrons up to @xmath2pev , and hence , be responsible for the observed @xmath0-rays flares at fermi / lat . on the other hand , the low energy electrons are generated by many smaller knots . the average effect smooths the fluctuation , so that the low energy synchrotron component and the ic component do not change significantly . this scenario can naturally explain both the variability in the mev - gev band , and the relatively steady emission in lower ( optical , x - ray ) and higher ( tev ) energies . the expected variability of the monthly bin fluxes above 100 mev are well consistent with that observed by fermi / lat . the two large @xmath0-ray flares can also be naturally accounted for without additional assumptions . in the simulation , we do not consider the detailed structure ( e.g. jet , torus ) of the nebula . the knots are assumed to have a uniform and isotropic distribution . considering a more realistic morphology of the nebula would not affect our conclusion noticeably , as long as the distributions of the knot sizes and doppler factors are similar to those introduced here . in more general terms , these knots may be interpreted as individual electron acceleration events distributed throughout the nebula . we point out that at low energies contributions from large amount of knots are equivalent with previous studies that electrons are accelerated continuously inside the whole nebula . although the model does not discuss the absolute time scales of flares and @xmath0-ray fluctuations from the first principle , they may be related to timescales of developing mhd instabilities at different spatial scales . we would like to thank zhuo li , shuang - nan zhang , yi - zhong fan , fang - jun lu and you - jun lu for helpful discussions . this work is partially supported by the natural sciences foundation of china grants 10773011 , 11075169 , 10633040 and 10921063 , the 973 project grants 2010cb833000 and 2009cb824800 , the nsf grant ast-0908362 and nasa grants nnx10ad48 g and nnx10ap53 g at unlv .

a statistical scenario is proposed to explain the @xmath0-ray variability and flares of the crab nebula , which were observed recently by the fermi / lat . in this scenario electrons are accelerated in a series of knots , whose sizes follow a power - law distribution . these knots presumably move outwards from the pulsar and have a distribution in the doppler boost factor . the maximal electron energy is assumed to be proportional to the size of the knot . fluctuations at the highest energy end of the overall electron distribution will result in variable @xmath0-ray emission via the synchrotron process in the @xmath1 mev range . since highly boosted larger knots are rarer than smaller knots , the model predicts that the variability of the synchrotron emission increases with the photon energy . we realize such a scenario with a monte - carlo simulation and find that the model can reproduce both the two @xmath0-ray flares over a period of @xmath2 year and the monthly scale @xmath0-ray flux fluctuations as observed by the fermi / lat . the observed @xmath0-ray spectra in both the steady and flaring states are also well reproduced .

astro-ph0110290

in a recent paper becker et al . analysed spectra of the four highest redshift quasars discovered by sloan survey . the highest redshift ( @xmath1 ) quasar showed almost no transmitted flux just blueward of the quasar ly - alpha emission line , and on this bases becker et al . concluded that reionization took place at a redshift @xmath2 [ a similar claim was also made by djorgovski et al . based on an extrapolation from a lower redshift observations ] . however , one should be cautious before drawing such a conclusion . indeed , the observed decrease in the mean transmitted flux at @xmath3 might simply indicate a decrease in the mean ionizing intensity rather then a real reionization of the universe . thus , without an understanding of the evolution of the universe around the reionization epoch , the ly - alpha absorption data can not be used to constrain the epoch of reionization [ unless damping wings are observed in the absorption profiles , @xcite ] . fortunately , our theoretical understanding of the process of reionization , in part based on numerical simulations , is solid enough so that the evolution of the ionizing intensity at these redshifts can be predicted with a reasonable confidence level . combining simulations with the observational data indeed allows one to come up with a meaningful value for the redshift of reionization . a set of three simulations have been performed with the slh code and are similar to the simulations reported in @xcite . the main difference with previous simulations is that a newly developed and highly accurate optically thin eddington variable tensor ( otvet ) approximation for modeling radiative transfer @xcite is used instead of a crude local optical depth approximation . the new simulations therefore should be sufficiently accurate ( subject to the usual limitations of numerical convergence and phenomenological description of star formation ) to be used meaningfully in comparing with the observational data . .simulation parameters [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] parameters of the three simulations are given in table [ sim ] . all three simulations included @xmath4 dark matter particles , an equal number of baryonic cells on a quasi - lagrangian moving mesh , and about @xmath5 stellar particles that formed continuously during the simulation . the box size was fixed at @xmath6 comoving mpc , and the nominal spatial resolution of the simulation was fixed at @xmath7 comoving kpc , with the real resolution being a factor of two worse . in all cases a flat cosmology was assumed , with @xmath8 , and _ cobe _ normalization was adopted . notice that because of that , a small change in the slope of the primordial power - law spectrum @xmath9 makes a significant effect on the amount of the small - scale power due to a large leverage arm from _ cobe _ scales to the tens - of - kpc scales which are important for reionization . star formation is incorporated in the simulations using a phenomenological schmidt law , which introduces two free parameters : the star formation efficiency @xmath10 [ as defined by eq . ( 6 ) of gnedin ] and the ionizing radiation efficiency @xmath11 ( defined as the energy in ionizing photons per unit of the rest energy of stellar particles ) . these two parameters are listed in the last two columns of table [ sim ] for reference purposes . the star formation efficiency @xmath10 is chosen so as to normalize the global star formation rate in the simulation at @xmath12 to the observed value from steidel et al . , whereas the ultraviolet radiation efficiency @xmath11 is only weakly constrained by the ( highly uncertain ) mean photoionization rate at @xmath13 . the redshift of reionization strongly depends on @xmath11 and is not in fact predicted in a simulation , but can be changed over a reasonable range depending on the assumed value of @xmath11 . i will use this freedom to fit the observational data from becker et al . and instead to constrain the redshift of reionization from the observational data . = 1.0 before one can attempt to measure `` the redshift of reionization '' , we better be sure that such a quantity can be defined . the whole process of reionization is quite extended ( @xmath14 ) , and even the fast process of percolation of ionized bubbles occurs over a sizable redshift interval @xmath15 @xcite . however , one can still define the specific value of the redshift of reionization as the moment which corresponds to the peak rate of increase of the mean free path to ionizing radiation . as can be seen from figure [ figmp ] , the time derivative of the mean free path has a well defined peak , which i use throughout this paper as `` the redshift of reionization '' @xmath16 . = 1.0 figure [ figtz ] shows the mean transmitted flux as a function of redshift for the three simulations described above . in each case the arrow shows the redshift of reionization , and points with error - bars are taken from becker et al . . each point represents an average of up to four quasars , except for the last two points that are derived from a single quasar and thus have no vertical error - bars . it is important to emphasize that the measurement of the mean transmitted flux for each quasar over an interval @xmath17 is quite accurate , with the intrinsic error of only @xmath18 in @xmath19 , but the variation between different lines of sight ( the so - called `` cosmic variance '' ) is much greater , and it is this variation that dominates the vertical error - bar . thus , one ( or better two ) more @xmath20 quasars are required in order to place the vertical error - bars on the open circles . however , because the sharp drop in the mean transmitted flux at @xmath21 is marked by two data points , it is more reliable than simply one point from one quasar . simulations in fig . [ figtz ] differ from the data points in two ways : both the redshift evolution in a simulation and the photoionization rate after reionization ( the amplitude of the curve at low @xmath22 ) are offset relative to the data . as i mentioned above , the free parameter @xmath11 can be used to adjust the simulation to fit the observational data . however , there is no guarantee that with _ one _ parameter i can adjust _ two _ offsets at the same time for a given cosmological model . this fact is extremely important because it allows one to actually put constraints on the cosmological model per se , and i elaborate on this opportunity in the conclusions , but here i am going to ignore this fact and adjust two offsets independently - by sliding the curve both vertically and horizontally - to fit the observational data . because the three curves from three simulations have similar shapes , every simulation can thus be made to fit the data - and , again , in reality , only a narrow range of cosmological models will succeed in doing so . the reason for doing so is to obtain a constraint on the redshift of reionization which does not depend on a ( weakly constrained ) cosmological model . in addition , the simulations presented here are rather small and numerical errors due to incomplete convergence are substantial @xcite . simulations with larger box sizes typically have lower mean transmitted flux after reionization than small box simulation - which implies that amplitudes of three curves are not sufficiently accurate in fig . [ figtz ] . the arbitrary vertical shift of the curves can thus be considered as a `` marginalization '' over the simulation box size . = 1.0 figure [ figta ] shows the fit to the observational data for each of the three simulations . the shaded region also gives an uncertainty of this fit , which can be considered a random uncertainty due to observational errors ( mostly cosmic variance ) . because the last two points have no vertical error - bars , they are only partly used : they only constrain models in the horizontal direction , and their redshift error - bars uncertainty are somewhat arbitrarily increased by a factor of 2 ( to account for the possibility that they can be moved up and down ) . the fact that different cosmological models have slightly different redshifts of reionization when made to fit the observed evolution of the mean transmitted flux illustrates the systematic uncertainty due to unknown cosmological parameters . with these two uncertainties included , i can derive a value for the redshift of reionization in the following form : @xmath23 which is the sole result of this paper . if cosmic variance on the last two points can be estimated , and if it is comparable to the vertical error - bar on the @xmath24 point , then the random error gets reduced from 0.2 to 0.1 . sloan observations of @xmath2 quasars push the frontier of the observable universe right into the epoch of reionization . combined with the most advanced simulations of cosmological reionization to date , the observational data yield a rather precise measurement of the redshift of reionization . this measurement hinges on the assumption that the @xmath1 quasar ( sdssp 1030 + 0524 ) probes an average region of the universe , i.e. that the cosmic variance in the measurement of the mean transmitted flux at @xmath25 is not larger than a factor of 3 - 5 . one or two more @xmath20 quasars are required to confirm or refute this assumption . a strong sensitivity of the redshift of reionization to the amount of small - scale power offers a unique opportunity to place constraints on the slope of the primordial power spectrum - unattainable even with the sloan data on the power spectrum at megaparsec scales . for example , runs b and c in fig . [ figtz ] have similar star formation rates and redshifts of reionization , but differ by a factor of 3 in the mean transmitted flux at @xmath26 only because the slope of the primordial power spectrum @xmath9 differs by mere 0.02 in the two models . sufficiently large simulations that have numerical effects under control are currently feasible and will eventually provide a tight constraint on the amount of small - scale power . becker , r. h. , et al . 2000 , aj , in press ( astro - ph/0108097 ) djorgovski , s. g. , castro , s. m. , stern , d. , mahabal , a. 2001 , apjl , in press ( astro - ph/0108069 ) gnedin , n. y. 2000a , apj , 535 , 530 gnedin , n. y. 2000b , apj , 535 , l75 gnedin , n. y. , abel , t. 2001 , newa , in press ( astro - ph/0106278 ) miralda - escud , j. 1998 , apj , 501 , 15 steidel , c. c. , adelberger , k. l. , ciavalisco , m. , dickinson , m. , pettini , m. 1999 , apj , 519 , 1

comparison of the observed evolution of the ly - alpha transmitted flux in the spectra of four highest redshift quasars discovered by sloan survey with the theoretical prediction for this evolution based on the state - of - the - art numerical simulations of cosmological reionization already allows one to constrain the redshift of reionization to @xmath0 , where systematic and random errors are given respectively . -0.5 in # 1/#1 # 1 [ firstpage ] cosmology : theory - cosmology : large - scale structure of universe - galaxies : formation - galaxies : intergalactic medium

1510.05530

the luminosity function ( lf ) is a very important statistical characteristic of galaxy populations . the lfs provide information about galaxies and their evolution on the cosmological timescale . in this paper we consider the lf of the galaxies with an active star formation in the wave range or emission line in which the lion share of radiation provides by a young stellar population . more exactly we consider the radiation of galaxies shortly after a starburst . these galaxies underwent strong bursts of star formation on a time scale of a few myr . massive young stellar populations , which were formed during the burst , emit plenty of ionising and non - ionising uv radiation . later on , the h@xmath0 and uv luminosities strongly decrease with time after a starburst age @xmath1 myr , when the most massive stars start to fade out . naturally , this is resulted in the changes of the observed lf . this fact affects the lf in the wavelength ranges and emission lines which are good indicators of a star formation , while the lf in the optical range keeps its form . this effect is mostly pronounced for the h@xmath0 , far ultraviolet ( fuv ) , near ultraviolet ( nuv ) and far infrared ( fir ) luminosities . we allow that taking into account the short - term luminosity evolution we can derive a more adequate form of the lf of a sample of star - forming galaxies . the impact of the fading of galaxy luminosities on lf can be quite significant . we describe it for the arbitrary initial luminosity distribution and arbitrary luminosity evolution . to study the impact of the factor under consideration we introduced the initial , the current , the time - averaged , and the sample lfs . in section [ s : lf ] we derive relations between all these lfs in general case of an arbitrary luminosity evolution . as a rule we consider galaxies with a single knot of star formation , but this lf can be applied to galaxies with several knots of star formation , too . in section [ s : lf1 ] we specify these relations for the luminosity evolution of luminous compact galaxies ( lcg ) discussed by @xcite . in the sections [ s : aq ] and [ s : ln ] we use the popular forms of lfs , namely the schechter function and the log - normal one as the initial lfs and derive and analyze the corresponding lfs . our findings are summarised in section [ s : sum ] . the luminosity of the galaxy @xmath2 is maximal one just after a starburst and then decreases due to burning out of short - living massive stellar population : @xmath3 where @xmath4 is time after the starburst and @xmath5 is the luminosity at @xmath6 . the function @xmath7 for the sample of 795 lcgs was derived by @xcite . this sample includes a very extreme population of compact galaxies with very high equivalent widths , representing the high - end tail of the lf of the overall star - forming population . all galaxies in it underwent a burst of star formation less that 6 myr ago . so the radiation caused by the burst - like star formation prevails ( see discussion in * ? ? ? @xcite found that the luminosities in the h@xmath0 emission line , fuv and nuv continuum are described by the relation @xmath8 with @xmath9 myr and different values of the parameter @xmath10 ( see details in * ? ? ? * ) . the same function is valid for the luminosities in the 22 @xmath11 m ir band , calculated using _ wide - field infrared survey explorer _ ( wise ) data and probably for the radio emission at 1.4 ghz @xcite . for generality we start with studying the case of arbitrary @xmath7 . we will specify the relation ( [ e9 ] ) later . we try to determine the effect of the short - term luminosity evolution on the observed lf of some sample of galaxies @xmath12 . in order to do this we need some additional types of lfs . we introduce and consider the initial @xmath13 , the current @xmath14 , the time - averaged @xmath15 , and the sample @xmath12 lfs . we assume that star formation in galaxies from a sample occurs in short bursts separated by large periods without star formation , which are much greater than the lifetimes of stars producing a main part of ionizing uv radiation . then , h@xmath0 , fuv and nuv luminosities greatly decrease before the next consecutive starburst . we also assume for simplicity that all galaxies have only single star - forming region . the initial luminosity distribution @xmath13 describes the distribution of the galaxy luminosities @xmath5 immediately after the termination of the star formation burst . we consider all @xmath5 values for galaxies entering a unit volume and describe their distribution by the function @xmath13 . here @xmath16 is the number of starbursts per unit volume with the initial luminosity in the interval from @xmath5 to @xmath17 . the function @xmath13 would coincide with the luminosity function @xmath15 if there were no temporal luminosity variations . this is a typical situation for the visible wavelength range , in which the radiation from long - lived old stellar populations is dominated . the similar situation occurs in the case of large galaxies with the continuous star formation , when the individual bursts of star formation hardly affect the total luminosity . on the other hand , the h@xmath0 , fuv and nuv luminosities in the lcgs are produced by the radiation of the young stellar population @xcite . therefore they vary on short time scales after the bursts of star formation . after the time interval @xmath4 after the starburst the initial lf @xmath13 turns into the time - dependent current lf @xmath14 because of decrease of galaxy luminosities . roughly speaking , the current lf is what the initial one becomes after time @xmath4 . the lf @xmath18 is the number of galaxies per unit volume in the luminosity interval from @xmath19 to @xmath20 at time @xmath4 after a starburst . the galaxies from the sample are observed at different phases of luminosity evolution , i.e. with different time after the starburst @xmath4 . @xcite have shown that the galaxies from the sample with @xmath21 myr are approximately uniformly distributed over starburst ages @xmath4 . in this case an averaging over the sample corresponds to a time - averaging and therefore the time - averaged current lf @xmath14 coincides with the lf @xmath15 , which we will call the time - averaged lf . here @xmath22 is the number of galaxies per unit volume in the luminosity interval from @xmath19 to @xmath20 . consider the case of monotonous luminosity decrease according to ( [ e1 ] ) with @xmath23 . using the relationship ( [ e1 ] ) we find @xmath24 this current lf should be averaged over the time to find the function @xmath15 : @xmath25 we apply the lf averaging over a time period @xmath26 , which is much larger than the typical starburst age of the lcgs . instead of the time integration we apply an integration over @xmath5 . in the case of constant @xmath19 we obtain the relation @xmath27 from eq . ( [ e1 ] ) , where @xmath28 is the time derivative . thus , @xmath29 where @xmath30 is a time interval during which galaxies with initial luminosities from @xmath5 to @xmath17 have the current luminosity @xmath19 . then @xmath31 here @xmath32 is the maximum initial luminosity of galaxies in the sample . it can be assigned as @xmath33 because @xmath34 is a rapidly decreasing function at large @xmath5 . if a function @xmath7 is constant at @xmath4 @xmath35 @xmath36 and decreases monotonously after @xmath36 , eq . ( [ e5 ] ) is transformed to @xmath37 the number of galaxies from the sample with the luminosity in the interval from @xmath19 to @xmath20 is @xmath38 . here @xmath39 is the number of galaxies entering the sample and @xmath12 is a normalized lf of the sample . to obtain the function @xmath12 we multiply the function @xmath15 by the volume @xmath40 occupied by the sample galaxies with the luminosity @xmath19 the flux - limited sample includes galaxies up to the photometric distance @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the minimal flux , if extinction is not present . considering flat space and neglecting the differences between the photometric distance and other types of distances in cosmology , we obtain that the volume @xmath40 is proportional to @xmath43 and correspondingly to @xmath44 . thus , we assume @xmath45 for flux - limited samples with small redshifts @xmath46 . for the samples with @xmath47 one ought to use the exact expression for @xmath40 from the relativistic cosmology , e.g. from the @xmath48cdm model . nevertheless , the simplified version with @xmath45 has some advantage . its simple form allows to obtain some useful relations like ( [ eq2 ] ) . for the flux - limited samples with small @xmath46 we obtain the sample lf @xmath49 where the constant is derived from the normalisation condition @xmath50 substituting @xmath7 from eq . ( [ e9 ] ) into eq . ( [ e7 ] ) we obtain @xmath51 where @xmath52 and @xmath53 the parameter @xmath54 has a simple astronomical meaning . h@xmath0 and uv luminosities of a galaxy are constant during the period @xmath36 , which is approximately equal to the lifetime of o stars . after that time luminosities decrease by a factor of @xmath55 during every next time period @xmath36 . there are two marginal cases of eq . ( [ e10 ] ) . the luminosity function is reduced to the standard one ( @xmath56 ) if @xmath57 ( constant luminosities ) or @xmath58 ( step , @xmath59 , where @xmath60 is the heaviside step function ) . the first term in brackets in eq . ( [ e10 ] ) vanishes ( @xmath61 ) if @xmath62 ( monotonous decrease without a plateau ) or @xmath63 ( very slow decrease ) . for the h@xmath0 luminosity function @xmath64 myr@xmath65 @xcite and @xmath66 . for the fuv and the nuv luminosity functions the values of @xmath10 are smaller and the values of @xmath54 are larger therefore , the initial and time - averaged h@xmath0 , fuv and nuv luminosity functions for star - forming galaxies are expected to be different . let us denote lfs for these cases as @xmath67 and @xmath68 . the function @xmath69 is the lf of the sample without the luminosity evolution , i.e. in the case of constant galaxy luminosities . taking into account the luminosity evolution we obtain ( [ e10 ] ) , which can be rewritten in the form @xmath70 there is no point in considering the case @xmath71 as a real lf , but we can do this formally to analyze the properties of sample lf at @xmath72 . let us denote the mean value of some quantity @xmath73 over the sample as @xmath74 the relation @xmath75 is valid for @xmath76 if these integrals are convergent , in particular at @xmath77 . as a result we have the equation @xmath78 connecting the sample averages of @xmath79 for lf @xmath80 taken into account affect of short - term luminosity evolution ( [ e9 ] ) and lf @xmath81 for the sample with invariable luminosities . ( [ eq3 ] ) at @xmath82 connects the sample average luminosities . at @xmath83 it helps in calculation variance , skewness , kurtosis , etc . let us try two popular functions often used as a functional form of lf as a function @xmath69 in ( [ eq1 ] ) . the first one is the schechter function @xcite , which is also known in the mathematical statistics as the gamma distribution @xmath84 parameters @xmath0 and @xmath85 are determined from the shape of this function . the slope in the @xmath86 ) plane is equal to @xmath0 for @xmath87 and changes rapidly at @xmath88 . according to @xcite , a much better fit for lf of galaxy and mass assembly ( gama ) galaxies with @xmath89 is provided by the saunders distribution @xcite @xmath90 here @xmath91 is the decimal logarithm and @xmath92 . note that @xcite used the notation @xmath85 in ( [ saund ] ) . we add the subscript s to distinguish this quantity from the @xmath85 in ( [ sc ] ) . if the optimal value of @xmath93 in ( [ saund ] ) is small and the majority of the sample galaxies have luminosities @xmath94 , this distribution can be simplified . actually any value @xmath95 is acceptable . in this case we can drop the unity in the @xmath96 term in eq . ( [ saund ] ) and we yield the two - parametric log - normal distribution @xmath97 here @xmath98 in the marginal case @xmath94 the set of three parameters ( @xmath99 ) can be redused to the the set of two parameters ( @xmath100 ) . only the combination of @xmath93 and @xmath101 gives the authentic parameter @xmath102 . from ( [ e7 ] ) and ( [ e8 ] ) we can obtain the lfs for the sample of star - forming galaxies with initial luminosities distributed according to the schechter ( [ sc ] ) and log - normal ( [ en1 ] ) functions . assume the initial lf is described by the pure schechter function @xmath103 we denote the ratio @xmath104 and substitute eq . ( [ e12 ] ) into eq . ( [ e10 ] ) . the integral in eq . ( [ e10 ] ) becomes the incomplete gamma - function , ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * ) @xmath105 the constant @xmath106 is obtained from the condition eq . ( [ e8 ] ) . the final form of the distribution eq . ( [ e10 ] ) with the condition eq . ( [ e12 ] ) is @xmath107 it has three parameters @xmath54 , @xmath0 and @xmath85 . the relation ( [ eq3 ] ) is also useful for calculation of the moments of this distribution , e.g. its mean value @xmath108 variance , skewness , kurtosis , etc . note that the mean value decreases with increasing @xmath54 , as well as @xmath109 the example of this lf one can see in fig . we plot the graphs of dependence of @xmath12 ( solid line ) , @xmath81 ( short - dashed line ) and @xmath110 ( long - dashed line ) vs @xmath19 for two sets of parameters . thick grey lines correspond to the set @xmath111 , @xmath112 erg s@xmath65 , @xmath113 and thin black ones to the set @xmath114 , @xmath115 erg s@xmath65 , @xmath116 . these sets are obtained by fitting the lf of the sample of about 800 lcg , used by @xcite . ( solid line ) and the summands in ( [ eq1 ] ) ( dashed lines with short and long dashes ) for distribution ( [ e15 ] ) with two sets of parameters . thick grey lines correspond to the set @xmath111 , @xmath117 erg s@xmath65 , @xmath113 and thin black ones to the set @xmath114 , @xmath118 erg s@xmath65 , @xmath116 . solid lines practically coincide . as a result , lf can be fitted by the functions ( [ e15 ] ) with two different sets of parameters . this fact complicates the approximation of lfs by this function ] we see that these two different sets provide practically the same lfs @xmath12 . naturally , this fact causes some problems for fitting the lf obtain from observations by function ( [ e15 ] ) . let us show that this situation is typical . suppose we know the values of @xmath119 , @xmath120 and @xmath121 for the function ( [ e15 ] ) . we can obtain the set of parameters @xmath54 , @xmath0 and @xmath85 for this case . from ( [ e16 ] ) we have @xmath122 and from ( [ e16]),([e16a ] ) we have @xmath123 @xmath124 equating these formulas we obtain two equations with two unknown quantities @xmath54 and @xmath0 . combining them we obtain an equation of fourth degree for @xmath54 . if some set of parameters @xmath125 , @xmath126 and @xmath127 provides a suitable fit of sample lf by function ( [ e15 ] ) one can calculate the values of @xmath119 , @xmath120 and @xmath121 for this function and these parameters according to ( [ eq1a ] ) and derive an equation for @xmath54 . this equation of fourth degree must have at least one other solution with the exception of special case of multiple root . so , this solution provides other set of parameters @xmath128 , @xmath129 and @xmath130 with the same @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath121 and near the same values of higher moments of a frequency distribution . if @xmath131 then this set also provides a good fit of the sample lf . both distributions are practically coincident , despite the fact that they are characterised by considerably different sets of parameters . naturally , if the distance between roots is small this leads to a complex form of the 1@xmath132 confidence region in the three - dimensional parameter space and the strong correlation between the parameters for all methods of fitting , i.e. the maximum likelihood method ( mlm ) @xcite . the marginal errors of these parameters obtained from the orthogonal projection on ( @xmath133 ) plane are also large . therefore , the mlm and other methods of fitting are almost useless to find all three parameters of the luminosity function ( [ e15 ] ) in the case of two positive roots of equation for @xmath54 . this situation occurs in processing the luminosity data for the sample of lcg used by @xcite . however , if the value of @xmath54 is fixed e.g. by the condition ( [ e11 ] ) the mlm reproduces quite well the values of other two parameters . note that as a by - product we obtain the method of estimating the values of parameters @xmath54 , @xmath0 and @xmath85 that fit the sample lf by function ( [ e15 ] ) . one can calculate the values of @xmath119 , @xmath120 and @xmath121 for the sample and use them in eqs . ( [ eq4]-[eq6 ] ) . ( solid line ) and the summands in ( [ eq1 ] ) ( dashed lines with short and long dashes ) for distribution ( [ enn ] ) with parameters @xmath111 , @xmath134 erg s@xmath65 and @xmath135 are drawn by thin black lines . the solid thick grey line corresponds to the distribution ( [ e15 ] ) with @xmath111 , @xmath117 erg s@xmath65 , @xmath113 plotted in the fig . both distributions provides the best fit of lf of the sample of 795 lcgs by different functions ] after substituting ( [ en1 ] ) into ( [ eq1 ] ) one can find the sample lf with log - normal initial lf @xmath136.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath137 in fig . [ f2 ] this function and its summands are plotted for the set of the parameters @xmath134 erg s@xmath65 , @xmath135 , providing the best fit of lf of the sample of 795 lcgs . the best fit by the function ( [ e15 ] ) with ( [ e11 ] ) is shown by thick grey line . the first summand corresponds to the log - normal distribution ( [ en1 ] ) . the sample average values of @xmath79 are @xmath138 from ( [ enn2 ] ) we get @xmath139 @xmath140 @xmath141 dividing the product of ( [ enn3 ] ) and ( [ enn5 ] ) by the square of ( [ enn4 ] ) we obtain an equation of fourth degree for @xmath54 @xmath142 it would seem that one can repeat the mention above argument . if there exists a set of parameters @xmath143 , @xmath144 and @xmath125 providing a good fit a lf of sample by function ( [ enn ] ) there have to exist other set of parameters @xmath145 , @xmath146 and @xmath128 also providing the same grade of fitting . nevertheless , this situation never occurs for fitting by function ( [ enn ] ) . for real luminosities the value of @xmath147 is near 1 . for example for the sample of about 800 lcgs from @xcite we have @xmath148 . in this case one root of ( [ enn5 ] ) is negative @xmath149 and it does not interfere the fitting . other root is positive at @xmath150 and negative at @xmath151 . for the sample of 795 lcgs we get @xmath152 this is less that the formula ( [ e11 ] ) predicts . but @xmath153 means that the function ( [ enn ] ) yields a better fit compared to the case of ( [ enn ] ) at @xmath154 i.e. the log - normal distribution ( [ en1 ] ) . there is no problem to use mlm or other methods of fitting to obtain a set of parameters of ( [ enn ] ) . the luminosity evolution affects the lf in the wavelength ranges and lines which are good indicators of the star formation , i.e. h@xmath0 emission line , the uv continuum and ir radiation because of the fading of galaxy luminosities on the time scale of several myr after a starburst . we introduce and consider the initial luminosity function @xmath155 , the current luminosity function @xmath14 , the time - averaged luminosity function @xmath15 and the sample lf @xmath12 . for the typical time - dependence ( [ e1 ] ) we yield the relations ( [ e2 ] ) and ( [ e6 ] ) between them . we specify this relation for the luminosity evolution in the form ( [ e9 ] ) and analyze the obtained formula ( [ e10 ] ) . we consider the sample lf for the case when the initial lf is described by the gamma - distribution also known as the schechter function ( [ e12 ] ) . the sample lf is described by the distribution ( [ e15 ] ) . there is a problem with this distribution , which complicates an approximation of the real data by the formula ( [ e15 ] ) . the distribution ( [ e15 ] ) is quite similar for the different sets of parameters @xmath54 , @xmath0 and @xmath85 with the essentially different individual parameters . this fact obstructs the usage of the maximal likelihood method or other methods of approximation . the confidence region in the parameter space can be very prolate . in the case of initial log - normal distribution ( [ en1 ] ) we obtain the sample lf in the form ( [ enn ] ) . there is no problem to use mlm or other methods of fitting to obtain a set of parameters of this function . thus , we get two new types of lfs ( [ e15 ] ) and ( [ enn ] ) to fit the lf of a sample of star - forming galaxies . one can used it to fit the lf of a sample of star - forming galaxies . these distributions have been used to fit the sample lf of lcgs studied by @xcite . the results will be present in the next paper with an extended author list .

an evolution of luminosity of galaxies in emission lines or wavelength ranges in which they are sensitive to the star formation process is caused by burning out of the most massive o - class stars during a few million years after a starburst . we study the impact of this effect on the luminosity function ( lf ) of a sample of star - forming galaxies . we introduce several types of lfs : an initial lf after a starburst , current , time - averaged and sample ones . we find the relations between them in general and specify them in the case of the luminosity evolution law proposed for the luminous compact galaxies . we obtain the sample lf for the cases the initial one is described by the pure schechter function or the log - normal distribution and analyze the properties of these lfs . as a result we get two new types of lfs to fit the lf of a sample of star - forming galaxies .

cond-mat9911490

the role of inelastic scattering in electron transport through mesoscopic systems is a topic of current theoretical and experimental interest . recent experiments have revealed the importance of the electron - phonon interaction in transport measurements performed on certain mesoscopic systems . in particular inelastic scattering effects have been observed directly in stm measurements of the differential conductance of molecules adsorbed on metallic substrates.@xcite theoretically the effects of inelastic scattering on electron transport through mesoscopic semiconductor devices have been investigated by a variety of methods ranging from green s function techniques@xcite to the fermi golden rule.@xcite some theoretical models have also been proposed to elucidate the effects of molecular vibrations on electron tunneling through molecules contacted by an stm.@xcite recent work has provided a method for calculating the electronic current at finite temperatures for electrons tunneling through a one - dimensional conductor in the presence of phonons.@xcite these approaches have yielded valuable insights into the behavior of specific systems . in the absence of inelastic scattering and electron correlations , landauer theory@xcite provides a general framework for calculations of the electronic current through mesoscopic conductors that are coupled to ideal single- or multi - channel quasi - one - dimensional leads . it relates the electronic current to the transmission probability for an electron incident from the source lead to scatter elastically through the conductor and into the drain . the transmission probability is found by solving the single - electron quantum scattering problem . when inelastic processes such as phonon emission and absorption are considered , electron scattering becomes a many - body phenomenon involving electrons and the various excited phonon states of the system . a non - perturbative approach has been proposed by bon@xmath0a and trugman for treating this scattering problem for a system consisting of a mesoscopic conductor ( which supports the phonon modes ) coupled to two single - channel ideal leads that act as the electron source and drain.@xcite their method approximates the many - body problem by a multi - channel single - electron scattering problem which can be solved exactly . here each channel corresponds to a different vibrational quantum state of the mesoscopic conductor . using their approach it is possible to determine the transmission and reflection probabilities for all inelastic and elastic scattering events that an electron may suffer in the conductor as it goes from the source to the drain . this method has been applied to study the effects of phonons on electron transmission through one - dimensional conductors where the electron - phonon coupling has been modelled using the holstein hamiltonian@xcite and the su - schrieffer - heeger ( ssh ) hamiltonian@xcite . the present article is complementary to the above theoretical work . its purpose is to generalize the landauer theory of electrical conduction to mesoscopic systems with electron - phonon scattering , assuming that the latter is described accurately within the multi - channel single - electron scattering approach of bon@xmath0a and trugman@xcite . i.e. , given the bon@xmath0a - trugman@xcite solution of the inelastic scattering problem , our objective is to calculate the electric current by appropriately generalizing landauer theory . when transport in a many - electron system is described in terms of one - electron scattering processes , the pauli exclusion principle needs to be considered since in general electrons involved in different transitions may compete to occupy the same final state . in treatments of transport based on the boltzmann equation , if the electron scattering is elastic , this competition has no effect because of a mutual cancellation of terms.@xcite however such a cancellation does not occur when scattering is inelastic.@xcite in landauer theory scattering is assumed to be elastic and the electronic current is carried by electrons which occupy single - particle scattering states that extend across the mesoscopic conductor from the source to the drain . these scattering states are orthogonal to each other.@xcite because of this orthogonality , if an electron populates one of these scattering states it does not compete with any of the other filled scattering states . thus in landauer theory ( as in the elastic case of the boltzmann equation ) the pauli exclusion principle for the final states in the scattering processes does not play a role in the determination of the electronic current . in our generalization of landauer theory that includes inelastic scattering , this is no longer true : different scattering processes can send electrons to the same outgoing state and the pauli principle plays an important role in determining the occupations of the outgoing channels . in the boltzman treatment of inelastic scattering the pauli principle is applied to the non - equilibrium one - electron distribution function for the system since transport is an inherently non - equilibrium phenomenon . here we apply an analogous principle : in our extension of landauer theory the pauli exclusion principle is applied to the non - equilibrium electron distributions in the _ outgoing _ channels of the scattering process and these distributions must be determined self - consistently . since some processes may be excluded because of the pauli principle , overall particle conservation is another consideration that must be taken into account when trying to generalize landauer theory to include inelastic scattering . we have developed a practical method for determining these non - equilibrium electron distributions for a class of mesoscopic systems . these systems are similar to those considered by bon@xmath0a and trugman@xcite in that they consists of a mesoscopic conductor which is attached to two single mode ideal leads which act as a source and drain , and phonons are assumed to be present only on the conductor and not on the ideal leads . we consider scattering processes which change the conductor s phonon state or leave it unchanged . each of these processes contributes to the non - equilibrium electron distribution . we determine each contribution self - consistently ( i.e. , in the presence of the other processes that can occur ) in terms of the transmission and reflection probabilities for the given process and the fermi functions that describe the incoming electron distributions in the left and right leads . included in this self - consistent method is the constraint of particle conservation . we do not however include cumulative effects of the current on the phonon distribution in the conductor ; i.e. , we assume that the conductor is in contact with a heat bath . with the non - equilibrium electron distribution determined we then evaluate the current flowing through this system for finite temperatures and bias voltages . as an application of the above theoretical approach we calculate the electronic current as a function of voltage for a two site molecule . the molecule has two single - particle molecular energy levels through which electrons from the leads can resonantly tunnel . it also has two longitudinal phonon modes which can be excited . a ssh hamiltonian is used to represent the electron - phonon coupling . for our model system one of the phonon modes is chosen to have an energy equal to the gap between the two electronic energy levels . because of this , electrons which are resonant with the higher energy level can emit a phonon and be resonant with the lower level . such a process is found to be highly transmitting . when the voltage is high enough that there is a sufficient number of electrons in the left lead that can undergo this process , we find that the current in the right lead due to elastically scattered electrons is reduced significantly due to competition with these inelastically scattered electrons . thus we find that the mutual exclusion between the scattered electrons that make up the non - equilibrium distribution in the drain lead can have important consequences for the electronic current flowing through the molecule . in sec . ii we describe the class of systems that we study and explain how the scattering states are calculated . in sec . iii we present our generalization of the landauer theory and our method for calculating the non - equilibrium the electron distribution and associated electronic currents . we then apply our methodology to a simple model for a two site molecular chain and calculate its current - voltage characteristics in sec . our conclusions are summarized in sec . in the absence of inelastic scattering and electron correlations , electron transport through a mesoscopic conductor can be described in terms of the probability @xmath1 that a single electron with energy @xmath2 scatters through the conductor from the source to the drain at an applied bias voltage @xmath3.@xcite when phonons ( or vibrational modes ) of the conductor are considered , an electron entering from the source can suffer inelastic collisions by absorbing or creating phonons before entering the drain . each of these processes can be described by its own transmission probability . if we assume that the source and drain are single mode leads which are free from phonons , we can characterize the above single electron scattering process by a transmission probability @xmath4 . this describes an electron that enters from the left lead @xmath5 with energy @xmath2 , suffers inelastic collisions on the conductor which change the phonon population on the conductor from @xmath6 to @xmath7 , and then scatters into the right lead @xmath8 with energy @xmath9 . similarly , an electron incident from the left lead can suffer a collision and be reflected back into the left lead . this is characterized by a reflection probability @xmath10 . elastic scattering processes are included with @xmath7 being equal to @xmath6 . for all processes the total energy is conserved , so @xmath9 plus the net energy of all of the created and destroyed phonons is equal to @xmath2 . we now describe a method for calculating these transmission and reflection probabilities for a mesoscopic structure . a schematic of our model for the mesoscopic conductor , which consists of a source ( left ) and a drain ( right ) lead attached to a one - dimensional conductor / wire is depicted in fig . we assume that the leads are ideal and that they only have one electronic channel . phonons are considered to be only on the conductor and not on the ideal leads . an electron flows through the wire under an applied bias @xmath3 . we assume that the voltage drop only occurs at the interface between the wire and the leads with the left lead held at @xmath11 and the right lead held at @xmath12 . we solve the transport problem by solving schrdinger s equation for the many - body wavefunction of the electron - phonon system from which we extract the transmission and reflection coefficients mentioned above . these will be used in the calculation of the non - equilibrium electron distributions and the current which follows in the next section . the hamiltonian @xmath13 of this system can be split up into the hamiltonians for the isolated systems consisting of the left lead @xmath14 , the right lead @xmath15 , and the conductor @xmath16 . it also includes the coupling between the wire and the left and right leads , @xmath17 and @xmath18 respectively . thus we write , @xmath19 we treat each of the above hamiltonians in the tight binding approximation . we model the wire using a set of orthogonal atomic orbitals @xmath20 . each atomic state has an energy @xmath21 with a corresponding creation operator @xmath22 which creates an electron in that state . in our hamiltonian for the wire an electron can hop from orbital @xmath23 to all nearest neighbor orbitals @xmath24 , and this is governed by the hopping parameter @xmath25 for the equilibrium configuration of atoms . the wire also has a discrete set of vibrational modes , each characterized by a frequency @xmath26 . the phonons on the wire are described by the state @xmath27 is created by the operator @xmath28 . to first order in phonon creation / destruction operators the electron - phonon interaction is given by @xmath29 , and this governs the process of an electron hopping from site @xmath23 to site @xmath24 and exciting or de - exciting a phonon in mode @xmath30 . the hamiltonian of the @xmath31-site wire that we consider is , @xmath32 the leads are modelled as a chain of atoms each with a single atomic orbital @xmath33 , where @xmath34 labels the site . for the left lead @xmath34 ranges from @xmath35 to @xmath36 . on the right lead @xmath34 ranges from @xmath37 to @xmath38 . on the left lead an electron is created on site @xmath34 by the operator @xmath39 . the site energy is given by @xmath40 . electrons can hop to nearest neighbor sites and this is controlled by the hopping parameter @xmath41 . similarly on the right lead an electron can exist on site @xmath34 in an orbital with energy @xmath42 . the nearest neighbor hopping is controlled by the parameter @xmath43 . since we assume that there are no phonons on the leads the hamiltonians for the left and right leads are given by @xmath44 the wire is coupled to the leads via @xmath17 and @xmath18 . we assume that only the sites on the leads directly adjacent to the wire are coupled to the wire . electrons can hop from these lead sites to any site @xmath24 on the wire and this is governed by @xmath45 for the left lead and @xmath46 for the right lead . we take the electron - phonon interaction between the leads and the wire to first order . this allows for electrons from the leads to hop onto the wire and excite a phonon in mode @xmath30 . this electron - phonon interaction is given by @xmath47 for the left lead and @xmath48 for the right lead . thus the coupling potentials are , @xmath49 we now determine the scattering wavefunction from schroedinger s equation , latexmath:[$h |\psi^{\alpha}\rangle = e phonon state on the conducting wire . the wavefunction describes the many body system consisting of a single electron and the phonons . as shown by bon@xmath0a and trugman , the scattering process can be represented graphically.@xcite the power of this representation is in that the many - body problem can be viewed as a multi - channel single - electron scattering problem . the @xmath7 channel in either the left or the right leads corresponds to an electron propagating in the single electron mode of that lead with the wire being in its @xmath7 phonon state . a scattering process which changes the phonon state from @xmath51 to @xmath52 can then be represented graphically as an electron incident from the @xmath6 channel and then scattering into the @xmath7 channel . [ fig2 ] shows a graphical representation of the scattering channels for a simple single site wire described by the above hamiltonian . an electron incident in the @xmath6 channel in the left lead can scatter elastically or inelastically into any of the outgoing channels in the left and right lead . channels are connected horizontally by the electron hopping part of the hamiltonian whereas they are connected vertically by the electron - phonon interaction . with this picture in mind , we now write explicit forms for the wavefunction on the left lead ( l ) , right lead ( r ) and the wire conductor ( c ) . we assume that the wire is initially in the phonon state @xmath53 and that there is a rightward propagating electron in a bloch mode latexmath:[$\sum_n e^{i n y^{\alpha } } can then be reflected elastically or inelastically into any of the other channels in the left lead and propagate in a new bloch mode with energy @xmath9 in the left lead with the wire in a new phonon state @xmath55 . thus , the wavefunction on the left lead will consist of the initial state plus a sum over all possible reflected states with some unknown coefficients @xmath56 . on the wire the wavefunction will be a linear combination of the product of the atomic orbitals with all of the different phonon states . on the right lead the electron can be transmitted into any of the outgoing channels and propagate in a bloch state with an energy @xmath9 , leaving the wire in a phonon state @xmath55 . thus the wavefunction on the right lead will be a sum over all transmitted states with coefficients @xmath57 to be determined . thus we have @xmath58 with @xmath59 the total energy of the system is conserved , so @xmath60 , where @xmath9 is the energy of the scattered electron . @xmath61 corresponds to the reduced wavevector of an electron propagating with energy @xmath9 and is determined from the condition @xmath62 depending on whether it is in the left or right lead . inserting the above wavefunction into schrdinger s equation @xmath63 yields a system of linear equations which can be solved numerically for the @xmath57 , @xmath56 , and the @xmath64 at each energy @xmath2 . for our particular model based on single channel leads we then determine the transmission and reflection coefficients for each inelastic channel using , @xmath65 where @xmath66 and @xmath67 are the velocity of the electron in the @xmath7 channel of the left or right lead respectively . we then solve the corresponding problem for electrons incident from the right lead to determine @xmath68 and @xmath69 . we now proceed to show how these quantities are used to calculate the non - equilibrium electron distribution and current for the above system . as mentioned in the introduction , when calculating the current using landauer theory the pauli exclusion principle for final states does not play a role ; scattered electrons do not compete with each other . a complication that arises when inelastic scattering processes are considered is that electrons can now compete with other electrons that are scattered to the same final state ; the pauli principle becomes important . for instance , for the system discussed in sec . ii , an electron which suffers an inelastic collision that puts it into a final state with energy @xmath9 in the drain competes with all other scattered electrons that can occupy that final state ( as shown in fig . [ fig3 ] ) . the likelihood that this state is unoccupied in the drain is @xmath70 , where @xmath71 is the non - equilibrium electron distribution function in the drain . using the equilibrium electron distribution ( fermi function ) here is not correct since we are discussing transport , an inherently non - equilibrium phenomenon . we will now explain how to determine this non - equilibrium distribution for the model presented in sec . [ fig3 ] depicts the processes we are considering for electrons that scatter from various initial states with differing energies @xmath2 to the same final state at energy @xmath9 in the right lead . some assumptions must be made about which processes can compete with each other . to be consistent with landauer theory we assume that elastic scattering processes do not compete with other elastic scattering processes ( these correspond to those processes which both begin and end at energy @xmath9 labelled a1 and b1 in fig . [ fig3 ] ) . with this assumption an electron which is elastically scattered from the source to the drain at energy @xmath9 does not compete with an electron which is elastically reflected back into the drain at the same energy ( process b1 ) . however , elastically scattered electrons can compete with all electrons that can be inelastically scattered to the same final state . the inelastically scattered electrons correspond to those electrons which start at various energies @xmath2 labelled a2 , a3 and b2 in fig . we also assume that inelastically scattered electrons compete with all other scattered electrons that start in a different initial electron state ( i.e. electrons undergoing process a2 compete with electrons suffering processes a1 , a3 , b1 and b2 ) . at a given final scattered energy @xmath9 , we consider the following contributions to the non - equilibrium rightward moving electron distribution in the right lead : elastically scattered electrons transmitted from the left lead @xmath72 , inelastically scattered electrons transmitted from the left lead @xmath73 ( the final phonon state is @xmath7 ) , elastically scattered electrons which originate in the right lead and are reflected back into the right lead @xmath74 , and inelastically scattered electrons which start in the right lead and are reflected back into the right lead @xmath75 . ( the @xmath76 denotes transmitted electrons , the @xmath77 reflected electrons and the @xmath78 signifies that these are the distributions in the right lead ) . to determine the contribution to the non - equilibrium distribution in the right lead _ that is due to transmitted electrons _ we must first consider the distribution of electrons incident from the left lead . as in landauer theory , we assume that this distribution is given by the equilibrium electron distribution function which exists deep in the left lead . this is the fermi function for the left lead @xmath79 where the electro - chemical potential is @xmath80 with @xmath81 being the common fermi energy of the two leads and @xmath3 the applied bias voltage . an electron incident with energy @xmath2 from the left lead can then scatter elastically or inelastically into the final state with energy @xmath9 with a transmission probability @xmath4 . ( elastic scattering corresponds to @xmath82 and @xmath83 ) . because we now have a number of processes which can place electrons into this same final state the pauli exclusion principle must be considered . to incorporate this into our determination of the distribution function we must then consider the probability that this state is unoccupied by competing electrons in the drain . for the distribution due to elastically scattered electrons , this probability will be determined by the non - equilibrium electron distributions of the inelastically transmitted and reflected electrons , according to the above assumptions . it is given by @xmath84 . for the distribution of a specific inelastic transmitting process , the probability that the state in the right lead is unoccupied by competing electrons is determined by the distributions due to all other scattering processes . it is given by @xmath85 . the transmitted electron distributions will be proportional to the product of the above probabilities with @xmath86 and with the respective transmission probability @xmath87 . we define the appropriate proportionality constant for electrons incident from the left lead with energy @xmath2 , to be @xmath88 . this proportionality constant will be determined by imposing the constraint of particle conservation . combining the above considerations we arrive at the following expressions for the contributions to the non - equilibrium electron distribution due to elastically and inelastically transmitted electrons : @xmath89 @xmath90 similarly for the contributions to the non - equilibrium electron distribution in the right lead due to elastically and inelastically _ reflected _ electrons , we must consider the distribution of incident electrons given by the fermi function @xmath91 for the right lead where @xmath92 . those electrons which are incident with energy @xmath2 can be inelastically or elastically reflected into the final state with energy @xmath9 with a probability @xmath69 . again we take into account the competition for the occupation of this state using the pauli principle . for elastically reflected electrons the probability that this state is unoccupied is the same as that for elastically transmitted electrons . for inelastically reflected electrons the probability that the state is unoccupied is determined by all distributions due to different scattering processes . it is given by @xmath93 . again , the reflected electron distribution will be proportional to the product of the above probabilities with r and @xmath94 . for electrons incident from the right lead with energy @xmath2 , the proportionality constant is @xmath95 . based on these considerations we write the non - equilibrium distributions in the right lead due to elastically and inelastically scattered electrons as @xmath96 @xmath97 similarly a system of equations is set up for the non - equilibrium electron distributions in the left lead , @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 , and @xmath101 . ( here , @xmath76 signifies transmitted electrons from the right lead to left lead , @xmath77 refers to reflected electrons in the left lead , and @xmath5 denotes that all these distributions are in the left lead ) . the last consideration we must impose is particle conservation . particle conservation requires that the total incoming current be equal to the sum of the total transmitted current plus the total reflected current . this will allow us to determine the constants of proportionality for both the left and right leads . for the left lead we apply the following equality , @xmath102 this equality expresses that the incident electron distribution is equal to the sum over all transmitted and reflected electron distributions that arise from that incident channel . since all of the transmitted and reflected distributions originated from the same incident channel , they all involve the same proportionality constant @xmath88 . inserting the expressions for the @xmath103 s into equation ( [ eqn : equality ] ) allows us to solve for @xmath88 . this yields , @xmath104 where @xmath105 similarly , @xmath95 can be determined by applying a similar equality for the distributions originating from the right lead . this yields , @xmath106 where @xmath107 the above self - consistent system of non - linear equations must be solved iteratively to determine the unknown distributions @xmath103 , and the unknown proportionality constants @xmath88 and @xmath95 . for an initial trial solution , we let the @xmath103 s take on the following values , @xmath108 using this initial guess for the @xmath103 s , we evaluate the constants of proportionality @xmath88 and @xmath95 from equations [ eqn : c ] and [ eqn : d ] . with these determined , we then evaluate a new set of @xmath103 s from equations [ eqn:8]-[eqn:11 ] using these @xmath109 s and @xmath110 s and the old @xmath103 s . we then iterate until the @xmath103 s have converged . with the non - equilibrium electron distributions thus determined we proceed to evaluate the electronic current flowing through the wire for an applied voltage @xmath3 and at a given temperature @xmath87 . at a given energy @xmath2 the current , @xmath111 , flowing in an energy interval @xmath112 due to rightward propagating transmitted electrons in the right lead is given by the charge @xmath113 times the velocity @xmath114 , times the density of states @xmath115 , times the electron distribution for transmitted rightward propagating electrons in the right lead @xmath116 . thus we can write ( including a factor of 2 for spin ) @xmath117 where in one dimension the density of states cancels the velocity factor . the total current due to rightward propagating transmitted electrons in the right lead is found by integrating equation [ eqn : di ] , yielding , @xmath118 similarly , the total current in the left lead due to transmitted leftward propagating electrons is given by , @xmath119 where @xmath120 . the net current flowing through the mesoscopic conductor is then @xmath121 we now proceed to apply the above formalism to a simple molecular wire system . it consists of two identical 1d leads which are attached to the left and right ends of a two atom chain . [ fig4 ] shows a schematic of our system . each atom making up the molecule has just one atomic orbital , so the isolated two atom molecule has two discrete electronic energy levels . when this molecule is coupled to the leads , incident electrons with energies that roughly coincide with the energy of either of these two states will be favourably transmitted . in the absence of phonons we expect two strong peaks in the transmission spectrum at the energies of the two molecular levels . when longitudinal phonons on the molecule are considered we expect interesting physics to occur when one of the phonon energies corresponds to the energy gap between the two energy levels of the molecule . when an electron is incident at an energy corresponding to the higher molecular level it can emit a phonon and drop to the lower electronic energy level . this process should have a significant transmission probability because the electron will be resonant with the higher energy level and then also with the lower energy level . ( processes where phonons are created and the electron is not resonant with either of the two molecular energy levels will not be strongly transmitting ) . if we assume that the leads fermi energy lies between the two molecular energy levels , we expect the following behavior for the non - equilibrium electron distributions : for low voltages and temperatures , the non - equilibrium electron distribution in the drain will be dominated by resonant electrons elastically scattered through the lower energy level and elastically reflected electrons . as the voltage increases the electro - chemical potential in the left lead rises while it decreases in the right lead . eventually , at sufficiently high voltages there will be electrons in the left lead with enough energy to undergo the inelastic scattering process mentioned above . the non - equilibrium electron distribution in the drain will then have a significant contribution due to these inelastically scattered electrons . these inelastically scattered electrons will compete with elastically scattered electrons that are transmitted through the lower energy state . this competition between electrons due to the pauli principle will play an important role in determining the current of this two site system at higher voltages . we have chosen the following set of tight - binding parameters for the system described above . on the leads , the site energy is @xmath122 ev and the nearest neighbor hopping energy is @xmath123 ev . for the molecule , the two atoms have the same site energy @xmath124 ev and the hopping energy is @xmath125 ev . the coupling of the left lead to the first molecular site is @xmath126 ev and the coupling of the second molecular site to the right lead is @xmath127 ev . we use the ssh hamiltonian to model the vibrational modes of the molecule and electron - phonon coupling as is discussed in the appendix : our vibrational model of the molecule has two longitudinal phonon modes with energies @xmath128 ev and @xmath129 ev . the electron - phonon ( e - p ) couplings on the chain are @xmath130 ev and @xmath131 ev . the e - p couplings between the leads and the chain are @xmath132 ev , @xmath133 ev , @xmath134 ev and @xmath135 ev . we assume that the system is at a temperature of @xmath136 k. for the transport calculation , the initial phonon state @xmath137 is taken to be the average phonon distribution on the chain for temperature @xmath87 , with @xmath138 . we approximate each average mode occupation number @xmath139 by the nearest integer . at the temperature of interest , @xmath140 . the other phonon states that we include in the calculation are those obtained by taking all @xmath141 where @xmath142 . in fig . [ fig5]a , the total transmission probability found by summing over all outgoing channels ( solid line ) is shown along with the transmission probability in the absence of phonons ( dashed line ) . ( these transmission probabilities were calculated for 0 @xmath3 applied across the molecule . we emphasize that they are the _ one - electron _ transmission probabilities defined in section ii and do not reflect the effects of the pauli principle discussed in section iii . the latter is taken into account in the calculated non - equilibrium distributions and currents presented later in this section ) . in the absence of phonons the two strong resonant tunnelling peaks are seen . with the inclusion of phonons , there are extra peaks due to the creation of phonons . the two resonant peaks are shifted because the inclusion of vibrations alters the hopping between sites which in turn shifts the energies at which electrons are resonant . in fig . [ fig5]b the transmission probability for elastically scattered electrons is shown . the elastic spectrum show two strong peaks at the molecular energy levels . it also has other smaller peaks which are due to the interaction of the electrons with virtual phonons . [ fig6 ] shows the inelastic one - electron transmission probability for three of the inelastic channels vs. the energy @xmath2 of the incident electron state . the first graph , fig . [ fig6]a is for the process where a phonon with @xmath143 ev is created on the molecule . the peak labelled a corresponds to an electron emitting this phonon and dropping into the lower resonant molecular energy level at -10.26 ev . the peak labelled b corresponds to resonant tunnelling through the higher molecular energy level after the creation of this phonon . the two tunnelling peaks c and d at the energies of the molecular resonant states correspond to an electron entering the resonant molecular energy levels prior to emitting the same phonon . the second graph , fig . [ fig6]b corresponds to the creation of a single excitation of the second phonon mode with energy @xmath129 ev , equal to the molecular energy level gap . as discussed previously , we expect electrons with energies incident on the higher energy molecular state to be strongly transmitting and this process corresponds to the peak labelled a in this graph . graph ( c ) is for the process where a single excitation is created in both phonon modes . the transmission probability of this process is essentially the superposition of fig . [ fig6]a and b , with an overall reduction in amplitude because this corresponds to a higher order process . we now proceed to calculate the non - equilibrium electron distributions from the calculated one - electron transmission and reflection coefficients using the method presented in sec . we take the fermi energy of the leads to be @xmath144 ev . the non - equilibrium distributions play an important role in the calculation of the current because of the pauli principle . for instance , the presence of inelastically transmitted or back - scattered electrons can result in a significant suppression of the elastically transmitted current . in this system , as mentioned above , the process whereby an electron creates a phonon with energy @xmath145 and is then at resonance with the lower electronic resonant tunnelling state , is strongly transmitting in the inelastic spectrum at @xmath146ev . at low voltages there are not very many of these particular inelastic processes occurring since there are not many electrons with this energy incident from the left lead , and the final electron states for the transitions are almost fully occupied by competing elastic processes . at higher voltages ( greater than 0.55 v ) there is a significant number of these processes and the non - equilibrium distribution @xmath147 where @xmath7 corresponds to the phonon state @xmath148 is significant . as the voltage increases further , the total distribution due to inelastically scattered electrons continues to grow as more processes become energetically favourable . the total non - equilibrium fermi distribution for all of the transmitted elastically scattered electrons is shown in fig . [ fig7]a for 0.5 v ( solid line ) and 1 v ( dashed line ) . fig . [ fig7]b shows the corresponding distribution for inelastically transmitted electrons . it highlights how this distribution function increases as more inelastic processes become energetically favourable . it also shows that there is a significant presence of inelastically scattered electrons in the drain for energies around -10.25 ev . at this energy , elastically scattered electrons are also particularly strongly transmitting and the dip in the distribution of the inelastically scattered electrons at this energy is due to the presence of these elastically scattered electrons in the drain . this is labelled `` a '' in fig . [ fig7]b . these non - equilibrium distributions are now used to evaluate the current flowing through the two atom molecule . in fig . [ fig8]a , b we show the total rightward flowing current that is elastically and inelastically transmitted through the molecule , evaluated using our method . we also show ( dotted lines ) the corresponding currents evaluated assuming instead that the non - equilibrium distribution of electrons in the drain that appears in the pauli exclusion factor is replaced simply by the equilibrium fermi function in the right lead . for transmitted elastically scattered electrons this simplified expression for the current is @xmath149 for models that do _ not _ include electron - phonon interactions , the _ net _ current through the molecule obtained in this way is the same@xcite as is obtained from landauer theory , although the factor @xmath150 does not appear in the latter as was explained in the introduction . however if electron - phonon interactions are present , approximating the effects of the pauli principle in this way does not account for competition between elastic and inelastic processes which ( at higher voltages ) inject electrons into states that are unoccupied according to the equilibrium distribution . this approximation ( even at low voltages ) also violates particle conservation when electron - phonon interactions are present . by using the non - equilibrium distributions described in section iii these effects are properly taken into account and current is conserved . all of this is reflected in the graphs : in fig . [ fig8]a initially the solid curve ( the present result ) shows significantly more elastic current ( as expected from landauer theory ) , and then eventually the elastic current is reduced due to the presence of transmitted inelastically scattered electrons in the normally unoccupied states of the drain . the total current flowing through the molecule as a function of voltage is shown in fig . the larger total current exhibited by the solid curve is a manifestation of current conservation in the present formalism . the dashed curve falls below the solid curve because the approximations used to calculate it do not conserve current . we have shown that to generalize landauer theory to include the effects of inelastic scattering , it is necessary to calculate self - consistently the non - equilibrium contributions to the electron distribution in the source and the drain leads . we have developed a method for determining these non - equilibrium distributions and applied it to a simple model . the model was based on single - channel ideal leads attached to a mesoscopic conductor . phonons were only considered on the conductor . the non - equilibrium distributions were determined solely in terms of the fermi functions of the left and right leads and the transmission and reflection probabilities for the various one - electron elastic and inelastic scattering processes considered . we showed how to properly take account of the pauli exclusion principle and particle conservation in the calculation of the non - equilibrium electron distribution . we applied our approach to a two site molecule . one of the phonons had an energy that corresponded to the molecular energy level gap . for this system we found that the details of the non - equilibrium electron distribution had an important role in the determination of the current . at higher voltages we found that the distribution in the right lead due to inelastically scattered electrons began to compete significantly with elastically scattered electrons because of the pauli exclusion principle . we found that this competition resulted in a reduction of the elastically scattered current at higher voltages . this work was supported by nserc . to find the vibrational modes of a molecule the atoms and bonds may be modelled by a set of balls and springs . for our model , we consider chain - like molecules , and represent the chain as a set of balls with effective springs connecting nearest neighbor atoms . the longitudinal displacement from equilibrium of the @xmath151 atom with mass @xmath152 in the molecule is given by the coordinate @xmath153 . we assume that each atom only interacts with its nearest neighbours via an effective spring coupling @xmath154 . the molecule has a discrete set of longitudinal normal modes which vibrate with a particular frequency @xmath26 and have atomic displacements given by @xmath155 . these normal modes satisfy the familiar eigenvalue problem , @xmath156 where for our model , the sum over @xmath24 is just over the nearest neighbors of atom @xmath23 . solving this equation yields the eigen - frequencies and eigen - vectors for the longitudinal normal modes . the problem is canonically quantized by assuming @xmath157=i \hbar \delta_{i , j}$ ] , where @xmath158 is the conjugate momentum to @xmath159 . we transform into normal mode operators @xmath160 and @xmath161 by writing @xmath162 and @xmath163 . it is easily verified that @xmath164= i\hbar \delta_{k , k'}$ ] . performing second quantization on these operators gives , @xmath165 where @xmath166 and @xmath167 are creation and destruction operators for the normal mode ( or phonon ) with frequency @xmath26 respectively . the effects of longitudinal vibrations on the electronic properties of the molecule can be taken into account by using the su - schreiffer - hieger ( ssh ) model.@xcite in it , the nearest neighbor hopping parameter @xmath168 between two neighboring atomic sites is expanded to linear order in terms of their atomic displacements from equilibrium . this gives , @xmath169 where @xmath25 is the hopping parameter at @xmath170 and @xmath171 . ( note @xmath172 ) . by using the above expression for @xmath153 in terms of the @xmath160 s , and writing them in their second quantized form , this gives @xmath168 as , @xmath173 this defines the mode dependent electron - phonon coupling , @xmath174 as , @xmath175 in terms of the known quantities @xmath176 , @xmath26 and the @xmath177 s . we now proceed to evaluate the eigen - frequencies and eigen - vectors of the longitudinal modes for our two atom molecule attached to two semi - infinite leads . the atoms in the leads are assumed fixed in their static positions . the effective spring coupling between the leads and the nearest neighbor atoms on the molecule is given by @xmath178 . the effective spring coupling between the two atoms of the molecule is @xmath179 . each atom of the molecule has a mass @xmath180 a.m.u .. solving the eigenvalue problem using the above parameters we find two phonon modes with energies of @xmath128 ev and @xmath181 ev . the corresponding eigen - vectors are @xmath182 , @xmath183 and @xmath184 , @xmath185 . in the ssh model the electrons are coupled to the phonons via the parameter @xmath176 . the nearest neighbor coupling between the leads and the molecule and between the two sites on the molecule is assumed to be @xmath186 ev / for @xmath23 to the right of @xmath24 . this gives the couplings between the first site on the molecule and the left lead as @xmath187 . the couplings between the right lead and the second site on the molecule are @xmath188 and @xmath189 . the electron - phonon couplings on the molecule are @xmath190 and @xmath191 . b. c. stipe , m. a. rezaei and w. ho , phys . * 81 * , 1263 ( 1998 ) . b. c. stipe , m. a. rezaei and w. ho , science * 280 * , 1732 ( 1998 ) . b. c. stipe , m. a. rezaei , w. ho , s. gao , m. persson , and b. i. lundqvist , phys . 78 * , 4410 ( 1997 ) . n. s. wingreen , k. w. jacobsen , and j. w. wilkins , phys . lett . * 61 * , 1396 ( 1988 ) . b. y. gelfand , s. schmitt - rink and a. f. j. levi , phys . 62 * , 1683 ( 1989 ) . j. a. st@xmath192vneng , h. hauge , p. lipavsky , and v. @xmath193pi@xmath0ka , phys . b * 44 * , 13595 ( 1991 ) . p. j. turley and s. w. teitsworth , phys . b. * 44 * , 3199 ( 1991 ) . b. n. j. persson and a. baratoff , phys . 59 * , 339 ( 1987 ) . g. binnig , n. garcia , and h. rohrer , phys . b * 32 * , 1336 ( 1985 ) . m. a. gata and p. r. antoniewicz , phys b * 47 * , 13797 ( 1993 ) . k. haule and j. bon@xmath0a , phys . b * 59 * , 13087 ( 1998 ) . r. landauer , ibm j. res . * 1 * , 223 ( 1957 ) ; r. landauer , phys . lett . * 85a * , 91 ( 1981 ) . for recent reviews of landauer theory see y. imry , introduction to mesoscopic physics , " oxford university press , 1997 , s. datta , electronic transport in mesoscopic systems , " cambridge university press , 1995 . j. bon@xmath0a and s. a. trugman , phys . * 75 * , 2566 ( 1995 ) . t. holstein , ann . ( n.y . ) * 8 * , 325 ( 1959 ) ; * 8 * , 343 ( 1959 ) . j. bon@xmath0a and s. a. trugman , phys . rev . lett . * 79 * , 4874 ( 1997 ) . w. p. su , j. r. schrieffer and a. j. heeger , phys . lett . * 42 * , 1698 ( 1979 ) . h. ness and a. j. fisher , phys . lett . * 83 * , 452 ( 1999 ) . see r. e. peierls , quantum theory of solids , " p.116 , oxford university press ( 1964 ) . p.127 . for a general proof see l. e. ballentine , quantum mechanics , " p.332 , prentice - hall ( 1990 ) .

in this paper we address the topic of inelastic electron scattering in mesoscopic quantum transport . for systems where only elastic scattering is present , landauer theory provides an adequate description of transport that relates the electronic current to single - particle transmission and reflection probabilities . a formalism proposed recently by bon@xmath0a and trugman facilitates the calculation of the one - electron transmission and reflection probabilities for _ inelastic _ processes in mesoscopic conductors connected to one - dimensional ideal leads . building on their work , we have developed a self - consistent procedure for the evaluation of the non - equilibrium electron distributions in ideal leads connecting such mesoscopic conductors to electron reservoirs at finite temperatures and voltages . we evaluate the net electronic current flowing through the mesoscopic device by utilizing these non - equilibrium distributions . our approach is a generalization of landauer theory that takes account of the pauli exclusion principle for the various competing elastic and inelastic processes while satisfying the requirement of particle conservation . as an application we examine the influence of elastic and inelastic scattering on conduction through a two site molecular wire with longitudinal phonons using the su - schrieffer - heeger model of electron - phonon coupling .

0705.3498

in fluid mechanics , the non - slip boundary condition ( nsbc ) states that fluid at the interface between a fluid and a solid surface is stationary with respect to that surface . surface slip arises when there is non - zero relative motion between the interfacial fluid and the solid surface , in which case the nsbc does not apply . in the vast majority of experiments described historically , the nsbc has been an adequate boundary condition @xcite . however , finite surface slip has been the subject of much recent interest and promises to play a significant role in the current and future development of micro- and nanofluidic devices @xcite . navier @xcite first described surface slip as early as the 1820s and his mathematical definition of the slip length has been widely used , for example in recent reviews @xcite and analyses of slip - dependent flow @xcite . slip is a well - studied phenomenon in non - newtonian fluids such as polymer solutions @xcite . for slip of newtonian fluids ( newtonian slip ) , theory is well developed @xcite , but interpretation of experiments has been much more controversial . newtonian slip is important because technologies can usefully be applied to newtonian fluids , but also because understanding of newtonian slip will provide a more profound understanding of fundamental slip mechanics . the physical mechanisms governing slip are affected by variables that include surface chemistry , shear rate , surface structure , newtonian viscosity , non - newtonian behaviour at the molecular scale and combinations of each of these variables @xcite . nanoengineered superhydrophobic surfaces trap gas between the fluid and the surface , producing large slip lengths of the order @xmath410 @xmath5 m @xcite . experimentally , newtonian slip has been investigated using a variety of methods @xcite . the most widely used and precise technique involves measurement of the drainage forces between closely - spaced surfaces in an atomic force microscope ( afm ) or surface force apparatus ( sfa ) and applying an analysis based on reynolds theory of lubrication @xcite . robust , non - zero values of @xmath0 for newtonian fluids at relatively smooth surfaces are typically of the order 10 - 100 nm @xcite . experiments have not established firm quantitative correlations between slip and major experimental variables , such as contact angle @xcite . recently , it has emerged with some clarity that in afm or sfa experiments , the nsbc can be expected to hold on smooth hydrophilic surfaces @xcite , while finite slip lengths of order 10 - 20 nm have been measured on some hydrophobic surfaces @xcite . additionally , the long - held idea that surface roughness should inhibit slip @xcite is now supported by reasonable experimental evidence @xcite . shear - mode oscillations can be used to drive fluid flow , and such systems pose scientific questions that are distinct from those relating to the study of steady fluid flows . oscillating piezoelectric components are likely to prove very useful in future applications . ultrasonic oscillators , well established as important tools for investigating thin films and bulk fluids , can also be used to probe the interfacial forces that are relevant in the study of slip . kanazawa and gordon @xcite analytically coupled a half - space of newtonian fluid to a piezoelectric quartz crystal microbalance ( qcm ) , in which a solid interface oscillates in shear mode , using the nsbc . further reports have presented experiments @xcite and analysis @xcite describing slip of a newtonian fluid adjacent to an oscillating surface . a relatively large set of slip lengths measured using a qcm was obtained by ellis and hayward @xcite . torsional quartz crystal oscillators operating at khz frequencies were initially developed and used for viscoelasticity measurements @xcite and have been used to measure the complex and viscoelastic behaviour of polymer solutions . more recent work has investigated dispersions of colloidal @xcite and micellar @xcite spheres . the shear rates accessible using torsional oscillators are considered advantageously high for such rheological measurements @xcite . a particular configuration , the composite torsional ultrasonic oscillator , was developed and analysed by robinson et al . @xcite and robinson and smedley @xcite , who also derived an equivalent circuit . recently , the first experimental results investigating newtonian slip at a smooth surface using such a device have been reported @xcite , for oscillations at 40 khz . there has been some confusion relating to fundamental aspects of slip , perhaps best characterised by neto et al . @xcite , who noted that dialogue between the qcm community and other researchers interested in slip has been scarce . in order to address this issue , navier s definition of the slip length is used consistently in the current work . an intuitive , consistent and general methodology for slip measurement at an oscillating surface is presented . analytic inconsistencies in the literature are identified and clarified , especially those concerning an oscillating interface . the composite torsional oscillator is introduced along with a full analysis for measurement of newtonian slip using this device . preliminary experiments are presented to demonstrate how this device is used to probe interfacial forces in oscillatory flow . we discuss the interpretation of measurements and the analytical assumptions on which they are based . finally , methods of slip measurement are compared and the advantages of using the composite torsional oscillator are explained . by definition , viscosity @xmath6 is constant and independent of shear rate throughout a newtonian fluid . the velocity field @xmath7 of an incompressible newtonian fluid of density @xmath8 in the presence of pressure gradient @xmath9 and body force @xmath10 can be determined by solving the navier - stokes equation , @xmath11 microfluidic flows have characteristically low reynolds numbers , so the convective derivative @xmath12 is insignificant when compared with the viscous term @xmath13 . solutions to the navier - stokes equation are dependent on flow geometry and boundary conditions . the relevant solution for the current paper concerns a smooth surface oscillating in shear mode in contact with a fluid half - space . in the absence of significant body forces or pressure differentials , the equation of the shear wave induced in the fluid is @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the fluid velocity in the direction of the surface oscillations , @xmath16 is the cartesian direction perpendicular to the solid surface and @xmath17 . the value of @xmath15 at the interface is @xmath18 , which depends on the fluid - surface boundary condition . the time dependence of @xmath15 and @xmath18 is @xmath19 , where the frequency of oscillation is @xmath20 and @xmath21 is time . this solution is relevant for ultrasonic oscillators . boundary slip occurs when the nsbc is contravened , so that there is finite relative motion between a solid surface and an adjacent fluid . navier @xcite characterised the slip boundary condition by defining the slip length @xmath0 . for flow adjacent to a planar , impermeable solid surface , @xmath22 here @xmath23 is the shear velocity relative to and parallel with the surface and @xmath24 is the value of @xmath23 at @xmath25 . navier s definition of slip has been widely used over a long period and has a strong physical basis relating to viscous force at the interface . the fluid shear rate at the interface that appears in eq . [ eq : gen slip length ] also determines the viscous force , @xmath26 slip therefore determines the shear stress at the interface , which is analogous to friction in character . the coefficient @xmath27 , defined as @xmath28 is finite only when there is slip . using eqs . [ eq : gen slip length ] , [ eq : gen viscous stress ] and [ eq : friction define ] , we find @xmath29 it is noted that the nsbc and boundary slip are , respectively , analogous to the regimes of static and sliding solid - solid friction . extending the analogy , we might expect a wide variety of material and interfacial properties to determine the onset and magnitude of solid - liquid friction . if slip length depends on shear rate , eq . [ eq : gen slip length ] becomes non - linear and rate - dependent formulations of slip ( e.g. @xcite ) become relevant . currently , there is conflicting experimental evidence relating to possible shear rate dependence of @xmath0 @xcite . a different physical interpretation of slip length relates @xmath0 to the distance into the solid over which the tangent to the flow profile at the surface must be extrapolated for the velocity to reach zero . in this context , navier s slip length has correctly been described as a fictional distance @xcite and is labelled in fig . [ fig : slip definition ] . the definition of slip length used in some recent slip studies @xcite , and formalised by ellis and hayward @xcite as ( their notation ) @xmath30 , or @xmath31 is distinct from navier s definition in eq . [ eq : gen slip length ] . ellis and hayward s definition corresponds to extrapolation of the flow profile a distance @xmath32 ( fig . [ fig : slip definition ] ) relative to the surface when slip occurs . the value of @xmath32 is equal to @xmath0 only in the case of a linear velocity flow profile . an often - used schematic diagram @xcite , which uses a linear flow profile to depict slip length , appears to have been an important factor in the emergence of eq . [ eq : b_1 ] . we wish to point out that when the flow of a newtonian fluid is driven by an oscillating surface ( as introduced above ) , the shear rate introduces non - zero phase into the value of @xmath0 , which is defined using @xmath23 ( eq . [ eq : gen slip length ] ) . the existence of this phase highlights the limitations of direct quantitative comparison of measurements of @xmath0 using different experimental techniques . when measuring slip at an oscillating surface , it is both intuitive and useful to use the dimensionless complex parameter @xmath33 . this parameter , which simply quantifies the velocity discontinuity between the solid surface and the first liquid layer , simplifies the algebra describing the effect of damping on the equivalent circuit of a piezoelectric oscillator . it is defined by interfacial properties and does not depend on the flow profile , @xmath34 the velocity of the solid surface is @xmath35 and the fluid oscillation is assumed to be dominated by a sinusoidal oscillation of angular frequency equal to that of the solid surface . under this assumption , @xmath36 is equivalent to parameters introduced by ferrante et al . @xcite and used elsewhere @xcite for modelling of slip at an oscillating surface ; to our knowledge , it has not previously been applied to experimental measurements with full consideration of phase dependence . more generally , @xmath36 can be decomposed into fourier components , an approach that has been used when modelling nanobubble - induced slip @xcite . the nsbc is consistent with the values @xmath37 and @xmath38 . for an oscillating surface , flow is relative to surface motion , so @xmath39 the magnitude and phase of @xmath40 relative to @xmath35 are plotted in fig . [ fig : slip phasor ] , for both slip and non - slip cases . figure [ fig : c ] shows that the relative amplitude of oscillation is uniformly non - zero at the surface when slip is present , but varies significantly near the interface ( @xmath41 ) depending on the values of @xmath42 and @xmath43 . further from the surface ( @xmath44 ) , the relative amplitude tends towards a stable value close to 1 but dependent on @xmath42 . the relative phase follows a similar trend in fig . [ fig : d ] , showing strong dependence on the combination of @xmath42 and @xmath43 near the interface . there is a phase discontinuity at @xmath45 for the cases in which @xmath46 . the plane of discontinuous phase is consistent with a negative slip length ( fig . [ fig : alpha vs b ] ) and could , for example , be interpreted as the edge of a stagnant boundary layer . further from the surface ( @xmath44 ) , the relative phase converges towards the nsbc value , which tends towards zero a long way from the interface . using this flow profile , slip length can be directly related to @xmath36 ( eqs . [ eq : gen fluid wave ] , [ eq : gen slip length ] , [ eq : gen alpha define ] and [ eq : gen osc flow profile ] ) : @xmath47 equation [ eq : gen alpha equals ] is plotted in fig . [ fig : alpha vs b ] using the notation @xmath48 . figure [ fig : alpha_b_amp ] shows that @xmath42 decreases when @xmath49 is within @xmath50 of @xmath51 , so that the slip length @xmath0 is positive . the phase plot ( fig . [ fig : alpha_b_phase ] ) demonstrates that @xmath52 when the fluid oscillates in phase with the surface ( @xmath53 ) . for the nsbc , @xmath54 , so @xmath49 can take any value . the maximum size of the phase shift @xmath43 is limited by slip length magnitude . the complicated nature of the flow profile near the interface supports the use of the parameter @xmath36 , which does not depend on the flow other than at the interface itself , in contrast to @xmath0 . however , calculation of the shear rate using the flow profile is still necessary for derivation of @xmath36 from surface force experiments . the damping force on an oscillating surface is equal and opposite to the viscous force in the adjacent newtonian fluid . when slip occurs , the damping stress is ( eqs . [ eq : gen fluid wave ] , [ eq : gen viscous stress ] and [ eq : gen osc flow profile ] ) , @xmath55 analysis of ultrasonic oscillators is greatly simplified by using the equivalent circuit analogy , in which mechanical components are replaced by their electronic equivalents . we now incorporate the damping stress into the analysis of a mechanical circuit . the stress at the interface ( eq . [ eq : gen interface stress ] ) , which has components both in phase and out of phase with surface velocity , can be written as @xmath56 the impedance of the system is @xmath57 , as previously applied to a torsional oscillator by bergenholtz et al . @xcite , who used the nsbc . this impedance is dependent on the liquid , the surface , and the interaction between them . the real part of the impedance ( @xmath58 ) determines the stress opposing , and in phase with , the surface velocity , @xmath59 this impedance is viscous in nature and dissipative of energy . in an equivalent circuit , velocity is analogous to current and @xmath58 is like a resistance . energy dissipation is determined by the quality factor of the oscillation . the inertial term ( @xmath60 ) gives the stress that is in phase with the acceleration of the surface , @xmath61 an increase in the inertial term is equivalent to the addition of mass to the surface of the oscillator . in the equivalent circuit , the time derivative of current is analogous to acceleration ( modified by a factor of @xmath20 ) , so @xmath60 is an inductance . a change in @xmath60 is measured by considering the change in the period of oscillation . under the nsbc , @xmath58 and @xmath60 are equal for newtonian fluid damping . slip - induced change in the relative sizes of these terms indicates a finite value of @xmath43 . the theory that has been presented implicitly addresses two conceptual pitfalls that have caused confusion and misinterpretation in a range of previous work . the first pitfall concerns the variant slip length @xmath32 , defined in eq . [ eq : b_1 ] , which is only equal to @xmath0 in the limit of a linear flow profile . this limit is generally not applicable for slip measurements . the difference between @xmath0 and @xmath32 is greater than 10% for typical slip measurements using afm , sfa or ultrasonic oscillation methods . we further note that ellis and hayward s definition has been used inconsistently ; both with and without considering a taylor expansion @xcite . navier s slip length @xmath0 should be used at the present time due to its strong physical basis and to promote consistency across experimental studies . the second conceptual pitfall relates to those experimental studies of slip at oscillating surfaces which have imposed a restriction on the phase of slip @xcite , especially the assumption that the slip length @xmath0 is real - valued . it is equivalent to assume that @xmath27 or its reciprocal @xmath62 is real - valued , or more generally , that the damping force is in phase with the surface velocity ( eq . [ eq : b friction ] ) . several lines of reasoning lead us to emphasize that @xmath0 must be allowed to have non - zero phase . we have shown that , because the slip length is defined using the shear rate ( eq . [ eq : gen slip length ] ) , the @xmath16-dependence of the fluid velocity ( a complex exponential , eq . [ eq : gen fluid wave ] ) introduces phase to the value of @xmath0 . the usual ( nsbc ) form of solid - fluid friction force is viscous ( eq . [ eq : gen interface stress ] ) and therefore @xmath63 out of phase with the velocity above an oscillating surface . figure [ fig : alpha vs b ] shows that the phase of @xmath0 in the limit approaching the nsbc is non - zero and that both magnitude and phase must be determined for either @xmath0 or @xmath36 to be fully described . restricting @xmath0 to real values is equivalent to restricting @xmath36 to one degree of freedom in eq . [ eq : gen alpha equals ] . furthermore , experiments @xcite have indicated that a fluid can be expected to oscillate in phase with , or slightly lag , the surface oscillation . neither interpretation is consistent with a real value of @xmath0 . having established that @xmath0 must be considered complex , we address specific arguments made in previous studies in support of a real - valued @xmath0 . firstly , there has been a direct assumption @xcite that the value of @xmath27 ( or @xmath62 ) should not be phase dependent . this assumption has been based on rodahl and kasemo s argument @xcite , which links @xmath27 to the ratio of force to velocity for low reynolds number drag on small bodies ( e.g. stokes drag ) , in which case @xmath27 is a real constant . this argument ignores the fact that important factors in the determination of stokes drag include the contribution of pressure surrounding the particle , the requirement for steady non - oscillatory flow and use of the nsbc . we note that friction and drag parameters are usually real because they are not used to describe oscillatory flow . in conjunction with this point , we note that the term coefficient of friction , which has frequently been used to describe @xmath27 in slip studies , is distinct from the usual parameter of that name , which relates the shear force to the normal force in the case of solid - solid sliding friction . secondly , an argument for phase restriction @xcite has drawn on the correlation between bond strength and bond length , which should determine magnitude and phase of slip respectively . such an argument does not explain why the phase should take one particular value , or why such a correlation between magnitude and phase should not be experimentally investigated . non - zero phase is not significant in previous work relating to lower - frequency oscillations in afm or sfa devices @xcite , in which @xmath64100 @xmath5 m for 39 hz oscillations in water , as opposed to @xmath4500 nm for a 1 mhz oscillator . similarly , periodically patterned microchannels @xcite are adequately described by a real - valued slip length when the ratio of the flow velocity to the pattern wavelength does not exceed @xmath41 khz , corresponding to patterns of extremely short spatial wavelength . the previous discussion of slip is now applied to the composite torsional ultrasonic oscillator ( fig . [ fig : to_schematic ] ) . the damping torque when the specimen rod is submerged in a newtonian fluid was derived by robinson et al . @xcite under the nsbc , using an equivalent circuit analysis . in that derivation , the shear damping stress on a flat surface is integrated over the surface of the specimen rod . appendix a , in this paper , gives the same derivation with slip included and appendix b discusses an assumption that is used . similar derivations have considered damping of other torsional oscillators by viscoelastic fluids under the nsbc , yielding similar functional forms @xcite . for the oscillator of specimen rod radius @xmath65 described by fig . [ fig : to_schematic ] , the total torque for @xmath66 or @xmath67 immersed flat surfaces is @xmath68 where the subscript max refers to the value at the antinode of the standing wave , which has wavelength @xmath69 . when a specimen rod is immersed , the resistance and inductance added to the equivalent circuit are @xmath70 and @xmath71 respectively , so @xmath72 equation [ eq : to t equivalent ] is directly analogous to eq . [ eq : components of interface stress ] for this specific configuration if we substitute notations @xmath73 and @xmath74 , consistent with the resistive and inductive descriptions of these parameters . comparing eqs . [ eq : to nsbc t ] and [ eq : to t equivalent ] and introducing a constant @xmath75 , we find @xmath76 the equivalent circuit reduces to a series lcr circuit @xcite . @xmath71 is therefore related to the change in period upon immersion @xmath77 and the resonant period @xmath78 , using @xmath79 the inverse quality factor of the oscillation @xmath80 is given by the total resistance of the composite oscillator @xmath81 and the total inductance @xmath82 : @xmath83 @xmath70 is calculated by assuming that @xmath82 is dominated by the mechanical inductance ( moment of inertia ) of the rods @xcite , so that ( @xmath84 ) @xmath85 @xmath86 is the change in @xmath80 upon immersion . when piezoelectric elements are incorporated , the equivalent circuit for the torsional oscillator gives the inverse quality factor , @xmath87 where @xmath88 and @xmath89 are voltages applied to the drive and gauge crystals respectively , and @xmath90 is a calibrated constant for a particular oscillator arrangement @xcite . the quality factor is also given by @xmath91 where @xmath78 is the resonant period and @xmath92 and @xmath93 are measurements of the period when @xmath88 is double the resonance value with @xmath89 held constant . by plotting the right hand side of eq . [ eq : to q^-1c ] against the ratio @xmath88/@xmath89 , eq . [ eq : to q^-1 ] can be checked and the value of @xmath90 determined . @xmath90 is independent of specimen rod damping , but it is dependent on the rigid moment of inertia of the specimen rod , so changes if mass is added to the specimen rod . we now consider comparison of a base case ( subscript 0 ) in which the nsbc holds ( @xmath94 , @xmath38 ) , with a case in which slip is present ( subscript 1 ) . in practice , it is difficult to determine whether there is slip in the base case , so @xmath36 can be used to measure the relative amplitude and phase of slip between two cases investigated . @xmath75 remains constant between measurements as long as @xmath95 , @xmath69 , @xmath6 , @xmath8 and @xmath20 are constant , so using eqs . [ eq : r_eta ] , [ eq : to nsbc tor ] and [ eq : to r_eta ] , we define @xmath96 and @xmath97 as @xmath98 and @xmath99 rearranging eqs . [ eq : r_foralpha ] and [ eq : l_eta ] , @xmath36 is calculated directly from measurement : @xmath100 and @xmath101 equations [ eq : alpha measure mag ] and [ eq : alpha measure phase ] are plotted in fig . [ fig : alpha from measurement ] . figure [ fig : alpha amp ] shows that @xmath42 increases with both @xmath96 and @xmath97 , indicating that if mass is decoupled from the surface , the amplitude of fluid oscillation will decrease unless more power is applied . figure [ fig : alpha phase ] shows that to retain the nsbc value of phase ( @xmath38 ) , @xmath96 must decrease if @xmath97 decreases . therefore , an oscillation generating relatively low power will tend to produce a value of @xmath102 ( fluid oscillation leading ) unless there is some decoupling of mass from the surface , and therefore reduced inertia . similarly , if more power is generated , the fluid will lag unless balanced by greater inertia . considered together , fig . [ fig : alpha amp ] and fig . [ fig : alpha phase ] show that a non - zero measurement of either @xmath96 or @xmath97 necessarily indicates a departure from @xmath37 , or @xmath38 or both . the introduction of a slip length is mathematically equivalent to considering a viscoelastic fluid . by inspection of eq . [ eq : gen interface stress ] , and remembering that @xmath103 , we find that instead of using @xmath36 , we can introduce a complex viscosity @xmath104 to replace the newtonian viscosity @xmath6 such that @xmath105 . due to coupling to the decaying wave in the fluid , we have @xmath106 , where @xmath107 is the complex shear modulus . we find that the storage modulus @xmath108 and the loss modulus @xmath109 are given by combinations of the inertial and dissipative terms in the oscillation @xcite , @xmath110 and @xmath111 it is therefore misleading to use the viscoelastic description of storage and loss moduli for the current situation . it is also misleading to describe a newtonian fluid as viscoelastic until there is experimental evidence for viscoelastic behaviour rather than some other cause of slip . some previous qcm work based on fully phase - dependent equivalent circuit analyses @xcite has considered slip in conjunction with a viscoelastic fluid and layering , thereby confusing possible newtonian slip with other effects ; for further effects of layering see the discussion ( below ) . such an approach may be motivated by layering of a qcm electrode substrate , that is not present when using a torsional oscillator . one previous investigation @xcite has noted the equivalence of viscoelasticity and slip in interpretation of slip measurements . to demonstrate investigation of slip using a torsional oscillator , preliminary experiments have been carried out using a 40 khz oscillator , as described by fig . [ fig : to_schematic ] . the fused quartz specimen rod was uniformly ground using al@xmath112o@xmath113 grits to remove surface features of magnitude @xmath1145 @xmath5 m , and polished using cerium oxide powder . polishing debris was removed by sonication in acetone , isopropanol , 10% nitric acid and ethanol . any remaining organic material was removed using piranha solution ( 70 vol% sulphuric acid , 30 vol% hydrogen peroxide ) . the rod was then thoroughly washed in deionised water ( 0.2 @xmath5 m filtered , 18.2 m@xmath115 cm ) and lightly flame - polished to minimize surface roughness . the slip case was configured by coating the specimen rod with a hydrophobic fluoropolymer surfactant ( rs components ) , evenly dispensed from an aerosol can . the base case was retrieved by dissolving the surfactant in isopropanol prior to re - cleaning the rod using piranha solution and washing with deionised water and ethanol . a pre - optically polished , flame - polished piece of fused quartz has rms roughness @xmath116 nm and peak to trough roughness @xmath117 nm , as measured over several widely - distributed areas of size 5 @xmath5m@xmath118 using afm . previously @xcite , scanning electron microscopy ( sem ) revealed peak to trough roughness of 24 @xmath5 m on rods left unpolished following grinding using al@xmath112o@xmath113 , with no significant alteration of the texture following the addition of the surfactant . however , a flame - polished surface coated with the surfactant has additional texture characterised by features of spacing @xmath119 @xmath5 m with rms roughness 24 nm and peak to trough roughness @xmath120 nm , observed using optical microscopy and afm . the advanced static contact angle of deionised water on fused quartz is @xmath121 . the advanced contact angle on the same surface coated with the surfactant is @xmath122 . the texture of the coating causes some hysteresis , and the receded contact angle is @xmath123 . contact angles were measured using the sessile drop method ( cam 200 , ksv instruments ) . prior to each immersion run , the specimen rod was washed in deionised water and dried in air . for the base case , the uncoated rod was also rinsed with ethanol prior to drying . deionised water was used as the test fluid in all experiments . the oscillator was contained in an insulated bell jar standing on a plate maintained at 303 @xmath124 1 k and situated on a large mechanically damped pad usually used for a transmission electron microscope . measurements from recent work are presented alongside previously reported experiments @xcite in table [ tab : results ] and explained in this section . the data points for @xmath96 and @xmath97 are each the result of several immersion events in each of the base and slip cases . the specimen rod was immersed by slowly raising a filled vessel to the rod . a value of @xmath86 or @xmath77 for any particular immersion run is the difference between the dry value and the value when the water was in contact with the node of the standing wave , adjusted to account for any background drift . the fluid meniscus was aligned with the vertical mid - point of a rubber o - ring that was fitted half way along the specimen rod . the o - ring , which fixes the position of the node , was located at a point where surface motion is zero or minimised , and is considered rigid during calibration . each immersion was carried out after the oscillator had been left for at least 90 minutes , so that instrumental drift per second was @xmath125 for @xmath88/@xmath89 and @xmath126 s for @xmath78 , as measured over 10 minute intervals . the standard error of the mean measurement was combined with error ascribed to drift to give the total experimental error in @xmath86 and @xmath77 in each case . uncertainty is dominated by variation between different immersion events , probably due to the extreme thermal and mechanical sensitivity of the instrument . the lesser contribution due to instrumental drift is accounted for by assuming that the mean drift correction is a random error . earlier experiments @xcite have established that uncertainty due to surface tension effects and location of the node is small relative to the standard error in the mean value , because very little damping occurs at or near the node . in order to calculate @xmath86 from measured voltages , the half width of the oscillation was measured directly following each immersion . equations [ eq : to q^-1 ] and [ eq : to q^-1c ] were then used to calculate a precise value of @xmath90 . it has been shown @xcite that a plot having gradient @xmath90 is typically linear ( @xmath127 for all fits ) and independent of temperature , the immersion level and the presence of surfactant . the two former variables are held constant during immersions , but the slip case experiments were calibrated separately from the base case in the most recent experiments . the value of @xmath90 is slightly lower for the slip case , as expected from the first principles analysis @xcite in which @xmath90 is inversely proportional to the oscillator s moment of inertia . the maximum error in @xmath90 , conservatively estimated as the difference between the slip case and the base case , is not significant in comparison with the experimental error of @xmath36 . @xmath90 changes when the torsional oscillator is mechanically altered , but was constant for each individual shear rate presented in fig [ fig : alpha_expt ] . for the nsbc , it is expected that @xmath128/@xmath78 @xcite . this relation was followed to within 5% for the majority of immersions . even accounting for the possibility of slip , immersion events with @xmath11410% deviation clearly indicate a significant instability in the oscillation and such data were discarded . experiments have been performed at shear rate amplitudes @xmath129 between 230 and 6840 s@xmath3 , corresponding to linear displacement amplitudes of 3.2 and 96 nm at the antinode . the linear amplitude of the oscillation is equal to @xmath130/@xmath20 . the shear rate at the surface of the rod is calculated as described by robinson et al . @xcite . for this calculation , rod diameters and masses were measured using a micrometer screw gauge and a mettler ae 200 mass balance , respectively . for each strain rate , intrinsic gauge capacitance @xmath131 was measured to better than @xmath132 by finding the gradient of straight line plots ( @xmath133 ) of the fractional change in resonant period as a function of total gauge capacitance @xcite . the transformer ratio linking the electronic and mechanical parts of the equivalent circuit was calculated using @xmath90 . the alternative calculation ( from first principles ) incorporates large error relating to the electrode separation angle 2@xmath134 ( fig . [ fig : to_schematic ] , @xcite ) . the final uncertainty in shear rate amplitude is @xmath135 . however , the uncertainty in each value relative to the others depends only on @xmath89 , which is precise to better than @xmath136 . the results for the five experiments in table [ tab : results ] are plotted as slip parameters in fig . [ fig : alpha_expt ] . figures [ fig : ex alpha amp ] and [ fig : ex alpha phase ] appear similar because , for all five data points , mean values of @xmath137 and @xmath138 have the same sign . all data lie within experimental uncertainty of the nsbc . for the three data points from ref . @xcite , the consistency of mean values ( @xmath139 , @xmath140 ) previously led to the conclusion that finite slip had likely been observed . although the newer results are not directly comparable due to differences in surface preparation , the mean values are now scattered around @xmath37 , @xmath38 , suggesting that the nsbc is observed with a high degree of accuracy . the most recent experiments have covered a greater range of strain rates and afforded greater precision due to improved stability of the oscillation and better thermal and mechanical isolation . the corresponding mean values of @xmath141 are now less than 30 nm , and the upper limits bounded by experimental uncertainty are less than 60 nm . for each data point , the lower error bar of @xmath142 is at zero because the nsbc falls within experimental uncertainty . because of the phase discontinuity at the nsbc ( fig . [ fig : alpha vs b ] ) , any value of @xmath49 is possible for near - nsbc combinations of the measured variables . previously , qcm measurements @xcite have obtained values of @xmath0 of similar precision , although in that case finite slip lengths of magnitudes between 10 and 80 nm were observed on bare as well as a range of hydrophobic surfaces . as discussed previously , the analysis used to derive these values contains inconsistencies . when considering other results in the literature , we emphasize that comparisons are drawn from data sets taken from measurements of very different flows ( see discussion ) and that the current data are observed over a well - defined , wide range of shear rates . it is therefore remarkable that the data is consistent with emerging trends from high - precision afm studies . namely , slip at a hydrophobic smooth surface occurs on scales @xmath143 nm , if at all ; and surface roughness such as that observed for the slip case in the current work may play a part in suppressing any slip at a hydrophobic surface . in order to discuss the interpretation of experimental slip measurements , we first clarify the terminology used in the discussion . lauga et al.s definitions @xcite of indirect measurement , apparent slip and effective slip are used , although we extend the definition of effective slip to include temporal as well as spatial averaging . true slip is an oft - used term not defined by lauga et al . we define it here as the case when the mean tangential velocity component of fluid is different from that of a solid surface immediately in contact with it . experimental methods are predominantly indirect at present . even the most direct optical methods of slip measurement have been labelled indirect @xcite , in the sense that the velocity of tracers rather than the fluid itself is measured . in the case of the oscillator , the measured damping force is not necessarily consistent with the idealised analysis presented in the theory section . in any surface force measurement , the flow profile is inferred rather than explicitly determined . under these conditions , slip parameters @xmath0 and @xmath36 only describe the slip dynamics in full when rate - independent , true slip occurs and the fluid is entirely newtonian . caution is required when analytically linking postulated mechanisms to apparent or effective slip measurements . for example , it often appears convenient to assume the presence of layering at or near the slip interface @xcite . typically , layers of unknown thickness and interfacial properties only introduce more modelling parameters . as discussed previously , introduced viscoelasticity is indistinguishable from slip . in two studies employing @xmath36 @xcite , multiple viscoelastic layers with multiple boundary conditions were modelled and several parameters were fitted . the resulting magnitudes of @xmath36 ( ranging from @xmath144 to @xmath145 ) were larger than reasonable for a newtonian fluid . at present , mechanisms of apparent slip are poorly characterized , so empirical measurement of slip parameters remains the most important step . newtonian fluids should be considered newtonian right up to the interface to avoid introducing error . sfa and afm techniques are currently the most well developed and widely - employed methods of measuring surface slip , and can reach resolution of better than @xmath146 nm for @xmath0 @xcite . optical methods such as the fluorescent recovery after photobleaching ( frap ) @xcite and particle image velocimetry ( piv ) @xcite techniques allow resolution of @xmath124100 nm , limited by diffraction and tracer particle size . recently , a nano - piv system has reportedly resolved true slip lengths of less than 100 nm with uncertainty less than @xmath12420 nm @xcite . several groups have measured slip using capillary techniques @xcite , but accuracy has been limited by capillary fabrication issues , the difficulty of controlling surface chemistry within a capillary and ( in some cases ) the effects of electro - osmotic flow . a recently - developed technique derives slip from measurement of thermal motion of confined colloidal particles @xcite . a slip length of 18 @xmath124 5 nm has been reported at near - zero shear rate . torsional oscillator experiments presented in the current work confirmed the nsbc to within @xmath147 for @xmath42 , @xmath148 for @xmath43 and to within 60 nm of @xmath2 . we stress that there are no significant limitations on the precision of the oscillator other than control of atmospheric conditions , vibration and electrical noise . further , the technique offers advantages and points of difference when compared with other techniques . a particular advantage of the torsional oscillator is characterization of experimental shear rate . the shear rate amplitude is easily varied by adjusting the applied gauge voltage and can at least cover the range @xmath149 to @xmath150 s@xmath3 . a major reason for use of torsional oscillators in rheological experiments is the large and difficult - to - reproduce range of accessible shear rates @xcite . in contrast , the variable velocity distribution across a qcm causes analytic complications @xcite . in the afm and sfa techniques @xcite , the shear rate varies with respect to surface separation and distance from an axis passing through the centres of the approaching curved surfaces . the shear rate is maximized away from this axis and also depends on the approach or withdrawal rate of the two spheres @xcite . the second major advantage of the torsional oscillator is versatility . surface treatments can easily be applied to the specimen rod , either while remote from the oscillator or attached to it . if the specimen rod is detached , the response of the oscillator is easily recalibrated . electronic voltage and period measurements are captured near - instantaneously , so time - dependent trends can be measured . the oscillator is perfectly suited to measurement of in - situ changes of surface chemistry or other parameters , and experimental precision would be significantly enhanced for such experiments . the oscillator can readily be used at variable temperatures and even variable pressures . although it is best suited to differential measurements ( similarly to optical techniques ) , the zero - slip response can be determined by careful calibration of all the parameters described in the original equivalent circuit analysis @xcite . in contrast , use of qcms and other torsional oscillator designs @xcite for slip measurement presents difficulties with regard to surface modification and incorporating piezoelectric equations into an equivalent circuit analysis . an important distinction between damping - oscillation methods and other techniques is that the shear damping force is measured . sfa and afm methods measure drainage forces caused by pressure in the flow around curved surfaces ; viscous forces are not significant . another difference is that , when using the torsional oscillator , slip occurs over a relatively large fluid - solid interface , so measurement of molecular - scale effects is limited by surface homogeneity . however , measurement of effective slip will give more accuracy and precision than a value derived from a small system . it is not true that measurements of effective slip must take place on a scale @xmath151 in order to have a measurable impact @xcite , because any fundamental slip mechanism should be consistent over the whole interface . regardless , we note that the linear displacement amplitude for the torsional oscillator is of comparable magnitude to the slip length , so molecular - scale interactions are certainly probed using this device . in this paper , we have drawn particular attention to the occurrence of slip at an oscillating interface . the ultrasonic composite torsional oscillator is a versatile instrument for measurement of viscous damping forces , and therefore slip . in order to fully characterize this device for slip measurements , we have revisited fundamental aspects of the slip analysis . the analysis has then been applied at a generalised oscillating surface , followed by the surface of the oscillator s specimen rod in particular . preliminary experiments at shear rates between 230 and 6800 s@xmath3 have probed slip at a hydrophobic surface of rms roughness 24 nm , obtaining resolution better than @xmath147 for @xmath42 , @xmath148 for @xmath43 and within 60 nm of @xmath2 . navier s slip parameter , while retaining the units of length , is best suited to interpretation as a surface force effect . measurement of surface forces has played an important role in developing the understanding of slip to date , while applications are likely to utilise the lubricating effect at a slipping surface . the actual velocity discontinuity at an oscillating interface , as encapsulated by the parameter @xmath36 for oscillating surfaces , is being directly observed with increasing precision using optical methods . the link between a velocity discontinuity and a surface force necessarily utilizes the spatial gradient of an analytical flow profile , unless both types of experiment can be performed on the same system . ongoing experiments will aim to significantly develop the stock of published slip measurements at oscillating surfaces . particular experimental topics will be the influence of shear rate , hydrophobicity and surface texture , while the development and in - situ characterisation of surfaces or fluids with switchable properties will also be a priority . thanks are due to dr . shen chong for assistance with setting up the apparatus described here and used previously @xcite . in this section , the damping torque on a composite torsional ultrasonic oscillator rod , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : to_schematic ] , is calculated . we follow robinson and smedley @xcite and incorporate the case in which there is finite slip , as introduced in the theory section . using the cylindrical polar co - ordinate system defined in fig . [ fig : to_schematic ] , the velocity in the azimuthal ( @xmath152 ) direction is given by @xmath153 where the subscript max refers to the value at @xmath154 and at the antinode of the standing wave , which has wavelength @xmath69 . there is a velocity gradient in the fluid in both the @xmath155- and @xmath16-directions . viscous forces in the fluid exert azimuthal shear stresses on the rod , which dampen the torsional oscillation . forces due to the @xmath16-gradient are neglected ( appendix b ) . the total damping torque is derived by integrating the tangential stress ( eq . [ eq : gen interface stress ] ) along the immersed , curved length of the rod @xmath156 . it is assumed that the fluid surface coincides with a node and the free end is an antinode , so that @xmath157 . the torque is @xmath158 the torque on the oscillating flat end of a rod is derived similarly . the surface velocity at radius @xmath155 from the cylindrical axis is given by @xmath159 and the torque is then integrated over the surface of the free end , so that @xmath160 neglecting edge effects between the flat end and the curved surfaces , the total torque for @xmath161 immersed flat surfaces is @xmath162 the velocity flow field around the torsional rod has gradients in both the @xmath155- ( radial ) and @xmath16- ( axial ) directions . the azimuthal stress due to these gradients are given by and @xmath32 defined in the text , with the shaded area representing solid material . navier s slip length @xmath0 ( eq . [ eq : gen slip length ] ) is only equal to the variable @xmath32 ( eq . [ eq : b_1 ] ) when the velocity profile is linear . the labels @xmath166 and @xmath16 denote cartesian coordinate axes.,width=321 ]

the composite torsional ultrasonic oscillator , a versatile experimental system , can be used to investigate slip of newtonian fluid at a smooth surface . a rigorous analysis of slip - dependent damping for the oscillator is presented . initially , the phenomenon of finite surface slip and the slip length are considered for a half - space of newtonian fluid in contact with a smooth , oscillating solid surface . definitions are revisited and clarified in light of inconsistencies in the literature . we point out that , in general oscillating flows , navier s slip length @xmath0 is a complex number . an intuitive velocity discontinuity parameter of unrestricted phase is used to describe the effect of slip on measurement of viscous shear damping . the analysis is applied to the composite oscillator and preliminary experimental work for a 40 khz oscillator is presented . the non - slip boundary condition ( nsbc ) has been verified for a hydrophobic surface in water to within @xmath1 nm of @xmath2 nm . experiments were carried out at shear rate amplitudes between 230 and 6800 s@xmath3 , corresponding to linear displacement amplitudes between 3.2 and 96 nm . + + + + + + + receipt date : 6 september 2007 + pacs numbers : 83.50.lh , 47.80.-v , 68.08.-p +

0709.2302

in calphad ( calculation of phase diagrams ) modeling@xcite , thermodynamic properties of a solution phase in a ternary or higher - order system are usually obtained through combining those of its constitutive binary systems and occasionally with ternary interaction parameters . since the most dominant interatomic reaction in a multicomponent system is that of the binaries , accurate thermodynamic descriptions which are capable of reproducing the characteristics of binary solution phases are prerequisites to a successful multicomponent thermodynamic modeling . in this regard , considerable efforts have been made to develop models for combining thermodynamic descriptions for binary solution phases to be used in higher - order systems@xcite . in typical thermodynamic modelings , ternary interaction parameters for solid solution phases are not introduced since their thermochemical data , such as mixing enthalpy , which are needed in the parameter evaluation are very difficult to measure . in fact , obtaining accurate thermochemical data for solid solution phases is challenging even for binaries due to sluggish kinetics at low temperatures so that it is hard to reach a complete thermodynamic equilibrium . furthermore , the existence of intermediate phases narrows the experimentally accessible composition range for thermochemical properties of solid solution phases . as the number of elements increases in a multicomponent system , the complexity of acquiring reliable data also increases . consequently , interaction parameters for the excess gibbs energy of binary solid solution phases are usually evaluated only from phase equilibrium data and those of ternary are usually omitted due to the lack of data . fortunately , the dearth of experimental data for solid solution phases can be overcome by atomic level calculations , such as first - principles calculations . specially designed supercells , so - called special quasirandom structures ( sqs ) suggested by @xcite , whose lattice sites are occupied by constituent atoms so as to reproduce the average correlation functions of a completely random solution , are one of the representative methods . sqss can be completely relaxed within density functional theory ( dft ) codes to consider the effect of local relaxation and can also be applied to any other system by changing the atoms because they are structural templates . a limitation is that sqss of a unit cell size that is manageable with present dft codes can only be obtained at certain compositions , e.g. @xmath3=0.25 , 0.5 , and 0.75 in the substitutional @xmath4 binary alloys . nevertheless , first - principles study of sqss at those three compositions permit accurate predictions of various properties of solid solutions . it has already been successfully applied to calculate thermodynamic properties of binary solid solution phases for fcc , bcc and hcp phases@xcite . two ternary fcc sqss in an a - b - c system , which can be applied to four different compositions at @xmath5 ; @xmath6 , @xmath7 ; @xmath8 , @xmath6 , @xmath9 ; and @xmath10 , @xmath11 , are developed to investigate the mixing enthalpies for ternary fcc solid solution phases in the present work . the organization of this paper is as follows : the impact of ternary interaction parameters on a ternary solution phase in the calphad approach is briefly reviewed . then the generated ternary fcc sqss are characterized in terms of their atomic arrangements to reproduce the pair and multi - site correlation functions of completely random fcc solid solutions . finally , the generated sqss are applied to the ca - sr - yb system which presumably has fcc solid solution phases throughout the entire composition range in all three binaries and ternary . the gibbs energy of a ternary solution phase , @xmath12 , is expressed as@xcite @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the mole fraction of element @xmath15 , @xmath16 is the gibbs energy of @xmath12 phase of pure element @xmath15 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the excess gibbs energies of the constitutive binary and ternary systems , respectively . the excess gibbs energies for binary and ternary systems can be further described as @xmath19 @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the @xmath22-th order interaction parameter@xcite in a binary and normally described as @xmath23 where @xmath24 and @xmath25 are model parameters evaluated from experimental information . ternary parameter of element @xmath15 , @xmath26 , in eqn . [ eqn : xs2_tern ] also have the form of eqn . [ eqn : xs2_interaction ] . if all three @xmath27-parameters in eqn . [ eqn : xs2_tern ] are identical , as in a ternary regular solution@xcite , @xmath28 then the ternary excess gibbs energy shown in eqn . [ eqn : xs2_tern ] can be further simplified to @xmath29 since @xmath30 in a ternary . thermodynamic properties of solid solution phases can be calculated in several ways ( e.g. , see refs . @xcite ) . a popular approach is to use a database of first - principles calculations to determine the so - called effective cluster interactions ( eci ) that describe the energetics of the alloy system of interest . these interactions are then used as an input for efficient statistical mechanics methods , such as the cluster variation method or monte carlo simulations . while this general approach is able to model ordered phases ( with potential point defects ) and disordered ( with potential short - range order ) within a unified framework , it can be computationally demanding . fortunately , in cases where the sole objective is obtain a reliable thermodynamic model for disordered phases that can be reasonably assumed to lack significant short - range order , the use of sqs provides a considerably more straightforward and computationally efficient approach . as discussed in section [ sec : intro ] , first - principles study of sqs can effectively consider the limitations discussed above , and it has been demonstrated that binary sqss can be applied to calculate thermodynamic properties of binary solid solutions , such as mixing enthalpy , for fcc , bcc , and hcp structures@xcite . it is thus anticipated that first - principles calculations of ternary sqss should be able to reproduce thermodynamic properties of ternary solid solutions if their atomic configurations , which are represented as correlation functions , are very close to those of ternary solid solutions . correlation functions of solid solution phases are well derived in @xcite . in the following section , the correlation functions for binary and ternary systems are briefly summarized . the normalized correlation functions , @xmath31 , in crystalline structures are defined as @xmath32 where the sum is over all the distinctive @xmath33-site clusters , which are geometrically equivalent , in the @xmath34 lattice sites structure . when @xmath33=1 , 2 , 3 , @xmath35 , then @xmath33-site clusters are point , pair , triplets , and so forth . site occupation variables are denoted as @xmath36 , where the subscript @xmath33 indicates that the @xmath33-th constituent located in the corresponding site . the superscript @xmath37 takes values 2 , 3 , @xmath38 , @xmath39 , with @xmath39 as the number of constituents , which represents a constituent @xmath37 at a given lattice site . for binary systems when @xmath40 , conventional values of the site occupation variables @xmath36 are @xmath411 depending on whether a lattice site is occupied by a or b atoms . according to eqn . [ eqn : correlation_function ] , the normalized point correlation function for the second constituent site ( b atom sites ) is given as @xmath42 with @xmath43 = 1 or -1 . it is worth noting that the atom sites do not need to be distinguished in a binary system since they are switchable . with the mole fractions of a and b being @xmath44 and @xmath45 , respectively , ( @xmath46 ) then @xmath47 . for a @xmath33-site cluster , the normalized correlation functions for the binary solid solution is formulated as @xmath48 similarly , for ternary systems when @xmath49 , the values of the site occupation variables @xmath36 conventionally take + 1 , 0 , or -1 if a lattice site is occupied by a , b , or c atoms , respectively . the normalized point correlation function for the second constituent site ( b atom sites ) is given as @xmath42 with @xmath50 + 1 , 0 , or , -1 . for the third constituent site ( c atom sites ) , the correlation function can be given as @xmath51 with @xmath50 + 1 , 0 , or , -1 . with the mole fractions of a , b , and c being @xmath44 , @xmath45 , and @xmath52 , respectively ( @xmath53 ) , then @xmath54 and @xmath55 . the vanishing of @xmath45 is due to its site occupation variable being 0 . for a @xmath33-site cluster with @xmath56 b atom sites and @xmath57 c atom sites ( @xmath58 ) , the normalized correlation functions for the ternary solid solution is denoted as @xmath59 in the present work , two different ternary fcc sqss are generated . the first sqs is at the equimolar composition where @xmath0 and the second is at @xmath1 , @xmath2 . by switching the occupation of the @xmath60 atoms in the second sqs with either @xmath61 or @xmath39 atoms , two other sqss can be obtained where @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 , @xmath66 . therefore , mixing enthalpy at four different compositions in a ternary system can be determined from first - principles total energy calculations of ternary fcc sqss by @xmath67 where @xmath68 represents the total energy of each structure , and the reference states for all pure elements are fcc . when the number of atoms in the ternary sqs is less than 24 , the alloy theoretic automated toolkit ( atat)@xcite has been used to generate ternary fcc sqss . since the atat enumerates all the atomic configurations within each supercell and then checks its correlation functions , the time needed to find sqss increases exponentially as the size of a supercell increases . for the sake of efficiency , to find sqss bigger than 24-lattice sites , a monte - carlo - like scheme@xcite has been used . in each supercell with different lattice vectors , atom positions are randomly exchanged between the atoms and correlation functions of a supercell are calculated after every alternation . if the correlation functions of a new state are getting closer to those of random solutions , then the new configuration is accepted . otherwise the new state is discarded and another configuration will be generated from the previous one . this process continues until the atomic arrangement of a supercell converges to the closest correlation functions of the random solution . in both methods , direct search via atat and monte - carlo - like scheme , a supercell whose correlation functions matches best with that of a completely random structure is chosen as the sqs at a given number of lattice sites . the selected sqss at two different compositions , sqs-24 when @xmath0 and sqs-32 when @xmath1 and @xmath2 , are shown in fig . [ fig : t_sqs ] . these two sqss are selected for later calculations because they are adequate with respect to their size and correlation functions at each concentration @xmath69 . ] . the space groups of both structures are @xmath70 with all the atoms at their ideal fcc sites . the correlation functions of the generated two sqss are given in tables [ tbl : cfternabc ] and [ tbl : cfterna2bc ] , respectively . lcdddddddd & + & random & 3 & 6 & 9 & 15 & 18 & 24 & 36 & 48 + @xmath71[6 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath71[12 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath71[6 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath72[3 ] & 0 & 0.25 & -0.125 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath72[6 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath72[3 ] & 0 & 0.25 & -0.125 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath73[12 ] & 0 & -0.25 & -0.0625 & -0.0625 & 0 & -0.01042 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath73[24 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath73[12 ] & 0 & -0.25 & -0.0625 & -0.0625 & -0.06667 & -0.01042 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath74[6 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & -0.075 & 0 & 0 & -0.04167 & 0 + @xmath74[12 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & -0.01443 & 0.0842 & 0 & 0 & -0.02255 + @xmath74[6 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & -0.05833 & 0.09722 & 0.04167 & -0.04167 & 0.09896 + @xmath75[8 ] & 0 & 0.125 & -0.01563 & 0.03125 & 0.04063 & 0.03125 & 0.01953 & -0.00391 & 0.01953 + @xmath75[24 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & -0.03789 & 0 & 0.01353 & 0.00226 & 0.00338 + @xmath75[24 ] & 0 & -0.125 & 0.01563 & -0.03125 & 0.00938 & -0.03125 & -0.00391 & -0.02734 & 0 + @xmath75[8 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & -0.00541 & 0 & 0.01353 & -0.00226 & 0.01691 + @xmath76[12 ] & 0 & -0.125 & 0.0625 & 0 & -0.025 & 0 & -0.01562 & 0 & -0.00391 + @xmath76[24 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.2165 & 0.01804 & 0 & 0.00902 & 0 + @xmath76[12 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & -0.03608 & 0.02706 & -0.01804 & 0.00677 + @xmath76[24 ] & 0 & 0.125 & -0.0625 & 0 & -0.0125 & 0.01042 & 0.01563 & 0.01563 & -0.00781 + @xmath76[12 ] & 0 & 0.125 & -0.0625 & 0 & -0.025 & -0.02083 & -0.01562 & -0.01042 & -0.02734 + @xmath76[12 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.00902 & 0 & 0.00226 + lcddddddddd & + & random & 4 & 8 & 16 & 24 & 32 & 48 & 64 + @xmath71[6 ] & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 + @xmath71[12 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath71[6 ] & 0 & -0.0625 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath72[3 ] & 0.0625 & -0.125 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & -0.0625 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 + @xmath72[6 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.09021 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath72[3 ] & 0 & 0.125 & 0.0625 & -0.0625 & 0.08333 & 0 & 0 & 0 + @xmath73[12 ] & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & -0.00781 & 0.074219 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & 0.05957 + @xmath73[24 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.006766 & 0.02255 & 0 & -0.002255 & 0.003383 + @xmath73[12 ] & 0 & -0.0625 & -0.10156 & 0.011719 & 0.02604 & 0 & -0.002604 & -0.006836 + @xmath74[6 ] & 0.0625 & -0.125 & 0.015625 & 0.085938 & 0.15625 & 0.0625 & 0.0625 & 0.361328 + @xmath74[12 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & -0.040595 & 0 & -0.05413 & 0.009021 & -0.010149 + @xmath74[6 ] & 0 & 0.125 & -0.046875 & -0.023437 & 0.07292 & 0 & -0.03125 & 0.193359 + @xmath75[8 ] & -0.015625 & -0.015625 & 0.089844 & -0.068359 & -0.015625 & -0.05518 & 0.001953 & -0.015625 + @xmath75[24 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.010149 & -0.013532 & 0.00254 & -0.003383 & 0.010149 + @xmath75[24 ] & 0 & 0.015625 & -0.058594 & 0.005859 & -0.015625 & 0.01025 & -0.005859 & 0.008789 + @xmath75[8 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & -0.010149 & 0.013532 & 0.00761 & 0.02368 & 0.005074 + @xmath76[12 ] & -0.015625 & 0.03125 & -0.015625 & 0.019531 & 0.015625 & -0.05078 & -0.033203 & -0.050781 + @xmath76[24 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.010149 & -0.036084 & -0.01015 & 0 & -0.025372 + @xmath76[12 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & -0.040595 & -0.027063 & -0.02030 & -0.003383 & 0.030446 + @xmath76[24 ] & 0 & -0.03125 & 0.046875 & 0.005859 & 0.007813 & 0 & 0.003906 & -0.008789 + @xmath76[12 ] & 0 & -0.03125 & 0.078125 & 0.007813 & -0.036458 & -0.01172 & 0.013672 & -0.017578 + @xmath76[12 ] & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.006766 & 0 & 0 & 0.001128 & -0.020297 + the vienna _ ab initio _ simulation package ( vasp)@xcite was used to perform the density functional theory ( dft ) electronic structure calculations . the projector augmented wave ( paw ) method@xcite was chosen and the generalized gradient approximation ( gga)@xcite was used to take into account exchange and correlation contributions to the hamiltonian of the ion - electron system . an energy cutoff of 364 @xmath77 was used to calculate the electronic structures of all the sqss . 5,000 _ k_-points per reciprocal atom based on the monkhorst - pack scheme for the brillouin - zone sampling was used . in all first - principles calculations of binary and ternary sqss in the present work , structures are relaxed in two ways : full relaxation and volume relaxation to preserve the fcc symmetry . it should be emphasized here that the preserved symmetry is that of sqs when all the atoms are substituted into a single element , which is the underlying fcc symmetry . for the full relaxation of sqs , structures are completely relaxed with respect to all degrees of freedom i.e. cell shape , volume , and ionic positions , while the symmetry - preserving relaxation only allows to change the cell volume for cubic structures , such as fcc and bcc . in calculating hcp sqss , however , relaxing only the volume will fix the @xmath78 ratio of the underlying hcp symmetry@xcite . therefore , the shape of sqss has to be relaxed as well as the volume in hcp sqss calculations . since the present work focuses on the calculations of fcc sqss , symmetry - preserving relaxation is equivalent to volume relaxation . for symmetry - preserved calculations , all the atoms are still at the lattice sites of fcc s and only the _ effective _ lattice parameter of fcc changes with this constrained relaxation scheme . however , the local relaxation due to the like- and dislike - bondings can not be taken into account . further discussion with regard to the different relaxation schemes of sqss can be found in ref . the mixing enthalpy derived from first - principles calculations of ternary fcc sqss should be compared to relevant experimental measurements . however , there are always ordering effects at low temperatures where the fcc solid solutions show complete solubility in binaries , such as cu - au and au - pd systems . due to such ordering in binaries , it is almost impossible to reliably determine the mixing enthalpy for ternary fcc solid solutions from experiments . in this work , the ca - sr - yb system has been selected to apply the generated ternary fcc sqss which presumably has complete solubility in the fcc phase for all binaries and ternary without any reported order / disorder transition . both the ca - sr and ca - yb systems show complete solubility for both fcc and bcc phases at low and high temperatures respectively without the formation of any intermetallic compounds@xcite . there is no reported phase diagram for the sr - yb system , however , from the similarity of the two binary systems , ca - sr and ca - yb , it can be postulated that sr - yb also would have complete solubility for both fcc and bcc phases . consequently , it may cautiously be expected that the combined ternary , the ca - sr - yb system , would have the fcc solid solution phase throughout the entire composition range at low temperatures . prior to applying the ternary sqss to the ca - sr - yb system , the mixing behavior of the fcc phase in its constitutive three binaries was investigated through 8-atom binary fcc sqss at three different compositions , namely @xmath3=0.25 , 0.5 , and 0.75 in @xmath4 alloys . calculated mixing enthalpies from binary fcc sqss are combined with experimental data from the literature@xcite to evaluate interaction parameters in eqn . [ eqn : xs2_interaction ] for each binary . for the sake of simplicity , parameters for bcc have been modeled as identical to those of fcc . binary bcc sqss also have been calculated and included in the parameter evaluation process . [ fig : casryb_bin ] shows that the formation energies of binary bcc and fcc sqss very close to each other in all cases . the congruent melting of bcc is observed in both the ca - sr and yb - ca systems , thus the sr - yb system has been modeled to have it as well on the assumption that sr - yb would behave similarly . calculated mixing enthalpies for fcc and bcc phases of the three binaries are shown in fig . [ fig : casryb_bin ] with first - principles calculations of binary fcc and bcc sqss . mixing enthalpy of the liquid phase in ca - sr is also calculated and compared with experimental measurement@xcite . structural analysis of binary sqs calculations shows that the local relaxation effect in both fcc and bcc sqss is small after the full relaxation and the difference between fully relaxed and symmetry preserved structures are at most @xmath791 kj / mol . it is intriguing to see that only the yb - ca system has the mixing enthalpy close to zero among three binaries in fig . [ fig : casryb_bin ] , which implies that yb - ca is likely to have ideal mixing in both fcc and bcc phases . the ideal mixing of yb and ca is attributed to their similar lattice parameters . the other two systems , ca - sr and sr - yb , have rather positive ( @xmath792 kj / mol ) mixing enthalpies and significant lattice parameter differences ( @xmath80 ) , which can be the reason for the non - ideal mixing behavior , unlike yb - ca . + the bond length analysis for the fully relaxed sqss in fig . [ fig : bondlength_bin ] shows that first nearest - neighbor average bond lengths follow vegard s law closely in all calculations . this observation indicates that the lattice parameter of the fcc solid solution varies linearly with the composition change and there is no significant geometrical distortion . sqs bond lengths for three binaries , ca - sr , yb - sr , and yb - ca . error bars correspond to the standard deviation of the bond length distributions . , title="fig:",width=288 ] + first - principles calculations of ternary fcc sqss at four different compositions in the ca - sr - yb system , namely @xmath81 ; @xmath82 , @xmath83 ; @xmath84 , @xmath85 ; and @xmath86 , @xmath87 , have been considered to investigate the ternary interactions . three isoplethal sections , connecting the equimolar composition and three other compositions when @xmath88 , @xmath89 , are selected to examine the mixing enthalpy for the ca - sr - yb ternary system . calculated mixing enthalpies for the fcc phase in the ca - sr - yb system with first - principles calculations results of ternary sqss in three pseudo - binaries , ca - sryb , sr - ybca , and yb - casr . extrapolated mixing enthalpy for the fcc phase from three binaries is compared with the ones with ternary interaction parameters . open and closed symbols represent symmetry preserved and fully relaxed sqs calculations , respectively . , title="fig:",width=288 ] + calculated enthalpies of mixing from ternary fcc sqss are shown in fig . [ fig : casryb_tern ] , including extrapolated results from the three binaries and improved enthalpies of mixing to reproduce ternary fcc sqss results by introducing ternary interaction parameters . all the fully relaxed ternary sqss show that the effect of local relaxation is also small as in its constitutive binaries , thus the energy differences between the symmetry preserved and fully relaxed calculations are quite small . [ fig : rdfcasryb ] shows the radial distribution analysis of the fully relaxed sqs at the equimolar composition . the narrow distribution along each of the bond - lengths indicates that the effect of local relaxation is small . as shown in fig . [ fig : casryb_tern ] , energy differences between fully relaxed and symmetry preserved calculations are small(@xmath79 0.5 kj / mol ) . + as can be seen in fig . [ fig : casryb_tern ] , the mixing enthalpy extrapolated from the three binaries is slightly lower than that derived from first - principles calculations of ternary fcc sqss . thus , ternary interaction parameters are introduced to improve the ternary mixing enthalpy . according to eqn . [ eqn : xs2_tern ] , the contribution from the ternary excess gibbs energy for the fcc phase in the ca - sr - yb system can be denoted as @xmath90 or @xmath91 as simplified in eqn . [ eqn : xs_simple ] when the ternary fcc is considered as a regular solution . when three independent ternary interaction parameters ( @xmath92 , @xmath93 , and @xmath94 j / mol ) are used , slightly better agreement with ternary sqss was made than with a single regular interaction parameter ( @xmath95 j / mol ) . the calculated mixing enthalpy at the equimolar composition are evaluated as the same value regardless of the interaction parameters since all the data are equally weighted . six different bond lengths , three like - bondings and three dislike - bondings , of four fully relaxed sqss have been analyzed . in fig . [ fig : tern_bond ] the bond lengths corresponding to the first nearest neighbors for all sqss are presented . in all sqs calculations , the sr - sr bonding is always the longest and this is attributed to the biggest lattice parameter of sr among the three elements . as a final analysis of the ability of the generated sqss to reproduce the properties of ternary fcc solid solutions , fig . [ fig : dos ] shows the alloying effects on the electronic dos in the ca - sr - yb system . three pseudo - binaries , connecting a pure element and equimolar composition of the other two elements , have been selected . since all three elements have the same number of valence electrons , significant changes in the electronic dos were not observed . instead , the electronic dos of the outer states gradually transformed into that of the pure element as the composition changed towards the pure element . the peak around @xmath79 9 @xmath77 of sryb in fig . [ fig : cados ] flattens out as ca increases , and the peaks around @xmath79 8 @xmath77 and @xmath79 7 @xmath77 are become more pronounced as the content of sr and yb increases as shown in figs . [ fig : srdos ] and [ fig : ybdos ] , respectively . in the present work , two ternary fcc sqss at different compositions , @xmath0 and @xmath1 , @xmath2 , are generated and their correlation functions are satisfactorily close to those of random fcc solid solutions . the generated sqss are applied to the ca - sr - yb system which presumably has a complete solubility range without order / disorder transitions in ternary fcc solid solutions . mixing enthalpies for the fcc phase in three binaries are evaluated from first - principles calculations of fcc and bcc sqss and available experimental data with the calphad approach . it is found that the local relaxation effect of fcc and bcc phases are very small and mixing enthalpies are slightly positive in all cases . evaluated mixing enthalpies for the fcc phase in three binaries are then extrapolated to the ternary system . first - principles results of four ternary sqss at @xmath81 ; @xmath82 , @xmath83 ; @xmath84 , @xmath85 ; and @xmath86 , @xmath87 show that the local relaxation effect is also very small in the ternary system . extrapolated mixing enthalpy from its constitutive binaries are slightly lower than those from first - principles calculations of ternary fcc sqss . thus ternary interaction parameters for fcc solid solution phases are introduced to further improve the ternary mixing enthalpy . it can be concluded that the generated ternary fcc sqss are able to reproduce thermodynamic properties of ternary fcc solid solutions and can readily be applied to other systems . this work is funded by the national science foundation ( nsf ) through grant no . first - principles calculations were carried out on the lion clusters at the pennsylvania state university supported in part by the nsf grants ( dmr-9983532 , dmr-0122638 , and dmr-0205232 ) and in part by the materials simulation center and the graduate education and research services at the pennsylvania state university . interaction parameters for the liquid and solid solution phases ( fcc and bcc ) in the three binaries of the ca - sr - yb system as evaluated from the calphad modeling in the present work are listed in table [ tbl : parameters ] . notations are explained in eqn . [ eqn : xs2_bin ] . .[tbl : parameters]evaluated binary interaction parameters for the ca - sr - yb system ( all in s.i . gibbs energies for pure elements are from the sgte pure element database@xcite . [ cols="^,^,<",options="header " , ]

in the present work , ternary special quasirandom structures ( sqss ) for a fcc solid solution phase are generated at different compositions , @xmath0 and @xmath1 , @xmath2 , whose correlation functions are satisfactorily close to those of a random fcc solution . the generated sqss are used to calculate the mixing enthalpy of the fcc phase in the ca - sr - yb system . it is observed that first - principles calculations of all the binary and ternary sqss in the ca - sr - yb system exhibit very small local relaxation . it is concluded that the fcc ternary sqss can provide valuable information about the mixing behavior of the fcc ternary solid solution phase . the sqss presented in this work can be widely used to study the behavior of ternary fcc solid solutions .

1309.2711

the quantum mechanics without probability amplitude was proposed @xcite , leading to the possibility of quantum information processing more directly in terms of probability i.e discrete wigner function @xcite . in the same vein , it is exciting to explore quantum key generation @xcite with polarization correlation function or expectation value of two observers . in general , two observers @xmath0 and @xmath1 will have eigenvalues @xmath2 corresponding to photon detection at the transmitted or reflected port of their analyzers . the correlation function shared by them is @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the joint probability of detecting a photon in observer @xmath0 and @xmath1 with their analyzers at @xmath5 and @xmath6 , respectively . the maximum / minimum values of @xmath7 are corresponding to correlated / anti - correlated outcomes of @xmath0 and @xmath1 such that the @xmath8 and the @xmath9 . there are totally four correlation functions @xmath10 , where n = 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , available from intrinsic polarization correlation of weak coherent states @xcite , coherent light mixed with random noise field @xcite and coherent light fields @xcite . these four correlation functions have been demonstrated and used to perform bits correlations between two parties over a distance of 10 km , through a transmission fiber by using weak coherent states in ref.5 . one can predict the outcome of the other by guessing the @xmath11 through their projection angles and photon detection . the secure key bits between two observers @xmath0 and @xmath1 are then generated through sharing four bi - partite correlation functions and photon counting . the essence of the paper is to propose a new scheme for key generation based on single photons bi - partite correlation functions . the proposed experiment setting is similar to simplified epr protocol ( bbm92 ) @xcite , where the epr pairs are replaced with two weak coherent states prepared from a light source in the middle of alice and bob . the light source is two modes ( x , y ) weak coherent states combined through a beam splitter producing two spatially separated quantum channels . we have the product states at the input of the beam splitter such that @xmath12 along the y - direction and @xmath13 . the density matrix of the output state from the beam splitter is dependant on the integration over the phase space of p representation for the input product state . since the @xmath14 and @xmath15 are intrinsically correlated from the same laser , the integration over the phase spaces of @xmath14 and @xmath15 can produce the output state that is intrinsically entangled @xcite . one can see that , the beam splitter transforms the input state @xmath16 into inseparable output state @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is random modulated phase . the inseparable output state can provide four types of bi - partite correlation functions @xmath19 by manipulating the linear phase shifters in box 1 of alice . the security of this scheme is guaranteed by the fact that the nonorthogonality of the product coherent states , which can not be identified by a single measurement . the protocol is strictly depended on equal mean photon number in the mode ( x , y ) i.e. @xmath20 . we will discuss how this condition can restrict more than one photon in a coherent pulse in this protocol and hence to prevent the photon - number splitting attack . the single photons sent to alice and bob are called ancilla photon and signal photon , respectively . the scheme requires coincidence detection of ancilla photon at alice and signal photon at bob . the ancilla photon passes through / reflects from an analyzer at alice is registered as bit 1/0. the signal photon passes through / reflects from an analyzer at bob is denoted as yes/no of his guess on alice s key bit . yes did not mean that bob will have bit 1. it can be bit 0. alice and bob generate key bits through secure communication in the sense that the bit information is encoded on the @xmath21 not the state . we will discuss how the protocol is robust against intercept - resend attack . the security analysis of this scheme may well be different from current weak light protocols @xcite . in this paper , we first outline the sequence of steps for implementing key generation between alice and bob . then , we discuss the physics and experimental detail of each step . finally , we briefly discuss how the protocol can prevent the photon - number splitting and intercept - resend attacks . the proposed experiment setup is shown in fig.1 . the setting is similar to the bbm92 protocol , where the epr pairs are replaced with two mode and phase - modulated weak coherent states , which are intrinsic - correlated from a laser source in the middle of alice and bob . the two weak coherent states are distributed through two pulses within a bit period , which is phase modulated in an asymmetric mach - zehnder interferometer ( mzi ) . four bi - partite correlation functions @xmath22 are assigned into two groups @xmath23 , where @xmath24 and @xmath25 . alice will have the key bit 0 and 1 for the correlation functions @xmath26 and @xmath27 , respectively . alice can randomly choose the correlation function @xmath21 and then her key bits . bob guesses the correlation function based on his polarization angle of his analyzer and records the outcome of his measurement i.e. yes or no of his guess . after the signal transmission , alice then tells bob through classical channel about the sequence of groups @xmath28 that she has randomly chosen . bob can then know alice s key bit by the outcome of his measurement regardless he made a right or wrong guess , so doubling the raw key generation rate . to illustrate the scheme more systematically , we will discuss an example of the key generation as shown in fig.2 . @xmath29 : alice randomly chooses the @xmath30 or @xmath31 by choosing the waveplates combination in box 1 as shown in fig.1 . ( alice randomly chooses the @xmath11 is analog to choosing a random basis in bb84 . ) @xmath32 : alice fixes her polarizer at angle @xmath33 and records the valid detections of the ancilla photon in + spd3 and - spd4 as bit 1 or 0. @xmath34 : bob guesses on the @xmath11 by projecting his polarizer at angles @xmath35 . the @xmath36 means bob s guess on @xmath37 . the @xmath38 means bob s guess on @xmath39 . ( alice only chooses one polarization angle @xmath33 and bob chooses two polarization angles @xmath35 because of the shared @xmath11 . we do not need to perform the violation of bell inequality in ekert s protocol . and also , not like bbm92 , alice and bob do not need to measure the basis @xmath40 , @xmath41 of the incoming photon . ) @xmath42 : the outcomes of bob s guess through the valid detections of signal photon . yes means that the+ spd1 click or his guess is right . no means that the - spd2 click or his guess is wrong . however , bob did not know the alice s key bit yet . ( alternative : alice and bob can detect the presence of eve by broadcasting part of the results obtained by bob in step 3 and 4 . they did not leak any bit information to eve because alice will not announces the group information in step 5 for the exposed data . note that in bb84 , alice and bob announce their choice of bases , and bob never broadcast his result which is the key bit . ) @xmath43 : after the signal transmission , alice announces to bob through classical channel about the group of her choice @xmath44 , not revealing her choice of correlation function . @xmath45 : bob knows alice s key bit after he received the group information and verified with the record of his valid detection . to illustrate this , let s say for the first column , alice announces to bob that the group is @xmath46 . bob s guess on the group @xmath46 is @xmath47 , which is corresponding to bit 1. however , he knows that the guess is wrong through his valid detection in step 4 . from here , he knows alice s key bit is bit 0. ( the random choices of @xmath11 in alice and projection angle @xmath35 in bob did not need to discard half of the raw keys compared to bb84 where alice and bob have the wrong bases . ) we believe that this scheme can provide the raw key generation rate a factor of 2 higher than the bb84 @xcite and b92 @xcite , and double the communication distance as in the simplified epr ( bbm92 ) @xcite and the original ekert s protocol @xcite . we would outline the detail explanation of each step . the light source is located in the middle of alice and bob . a pulsed , @xmath48-polarized laser light with a polarizing beam splitter ( pbs ) is used to provide a weak coherent state @xmath49 with horizontal polarization and another weak coherent state @xmath15 with vertical polarization in an asymmetric mach - zehnder interferometer ( mzi ) . these coherent states are located at two time slots and combined through a perfect 50/50 beam splitter ( bs1 ) , producing two spatially separated beams , i.e. , beam 1 and beam 2 . the input state of the beam splitter is a product state of two mode weak coherent states @xmath50 , which is the prepared state for this protocol . the annihilation operators @xmath51 and @xmath52 are the input field operators for the beam splitter ( bs1 ) and for the coherent states @xmath14 and @xmath15 . the operator @xmath52 is phase - modulated with the phase @xmath53 as @xmath54 , where @xmath55 , and @xmath56 is randomly chosen . the @xmath57 is produced by a phase modulator at the short arm of the mzi . the annihilation operators @xmath58 and @xmath59 are the output field operators for the bs1 , which are sent through beam 2 to bob and beam 1 to alice , respectively . to distribute the operators @xmath60 and @xmath61 to alice and bob , we first place a polarizer at @xmath48 at each output of the bs1 so that two pulses are co - polarized within a bit period . the reason is two orthogonal polarized pulses may be vulnerable to eve attacks . to create single photon quantum channel between the source and bob , the beam 2 is attenuated to single photon level with the mean photon number per pulse @xmath62 . similarly , the beam 1 is further attenuated to single photon level with mean photon number per pulse @xmath62 . the co - polarized two pulses are sent through transmission fibers to alice s and bob s mzi , where the phase demodulators at the short arms induced a phase of @xmath63 . four pulses ( 2 in the x - mode and 2 in the y - mode ) are created within one bit period . the x - y mode ( @xmath64 ) in the middle time slot are used for key generation . the phase ( @xmath65 ) can be accomplished by making use of the phase coding @xmath66 system@xcite , which is proven to be more efficient secure encryption system over long distances . note that we apply phase coding @xmath66 system on a single photon level instead of mesoscopic coherent state . the random phase @xmath18 is unknown to bob and alice . with the assumption of low mean photon numbers for @xmath67 and @xmath68 , the two weak coherent states can be treated as @xmath69 $ ] , where we have considered the vacuum and one photon number state in mode x or y. the phase @xmath18 is not included here because we have treated the @xmath70 in the annihilation operator @xmath71 . four types of intrinsic bi - partite correlation functions @xmath72 and @xmath73 can be established through the combination of wave plates as shown in the dotted boxes ( box 1 and box 2 ) in fig.1 . the half - wave plates ( hwp3 and hwp5 ) before the polarizing beam splitters ( pbs1 and pbs2 ) at bob and alice are used for projecting polarization angles @xmath74 and @xmath75 , respectively , so that the maximum correlation @xmath76 is obtained . the annihilation operator @xmath60 at beam 1 is transformed through the combination of waveplates in box 1 and a polarization analyzer consists of a half waveplate ( hwp5 ) and a polarizing beam splitter ( pbs2 ) . alice can randomly choose the @xmath11 , n=1,2,3,4 through the settings of qwp2 and hwp1 as shown in the box 1 . for the correlation functions @xmath77 , the photon number operator @xmath78 at alice is given by , @xmath79 . \label{eq:01}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expectation values for the correlation @xmath80 are given by , @xmath81\nonumber\\ \mathcal{c}_{2}\rightarrow \langle \tilde{\alpha \beta}| \hat{d'}^{\dagger}\hat{d'}|\tilde{\alpha \beta}\rangle \propto [ n_{x}+n_{y}+ 2\sqrt{n_{x}n_{y}}cos ( 2\theta_{1}- \phi_{m } ) ] , \label{eq:02}\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively . while the expectation values for the correlation @xmath82 are given by , @xmath83\nonumber\\ \mathcal{c}_{4}\rightarrow \langle \tilde{\alpha \beta}| \hat{d'}^{\dagger}\hat{d'}|\tilde{\alpha \beta}\rangle \propto[n_{x}+n_{y}+ 2\sqrt{n_{x}n_{y}}cos ( 2\theta_{1}+ \phi_{m } ) ] , \label{eq:03}\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively . we have neglected the @xmath84 and higher photon number states for the simplicity of the following discussions . note that the condition @xmath85 ( perfect beam splitter ) has made the higher photon number states having the same form of interference terms . alice will observe the interference term of @xmath86 for the @xmath87 , @xmath88 for the @xmath89 , @xmath90 for the @xmath91 , and @xmath92 for the @xmath47 . for example , if alice chooses @xmath87 , she has the interference term of @xmath93 . for the mean photon number per pulse @xmath94 . the expectation value @xmath95 will have the maximum value of @xmath96 and minimum value of 0 . the maximum value of @xmath97 is corresponding to the interference term with value + 1 and the minimum value ( 0 ) of @xmath97 is corresponding to the interference term with value -1 . in other words , the interference term with value + 1 indicates that the ancilla photon passed through a pbs2 . while the interference term with value -1 indicates that the ancilla photon reflected from a pbs2 . the interference term with the value + 1 ( -1 ) is corresponding to the detection of the ancilla photon at alice s detector +spd3 ( -spd4 ) or bit 1 ( bit 0 ) . note that we are not going to multiply alice s and bob s interference term and measure the mean value of the multiplied interference intensity as previously demonstrated in ref @xcite , i.e. , @xmath98 , where the phase term @xmath70 is varied from @xmath99 . the annihilation operator @xmath61 at beam 2 is transformed through a quarter waveplate ( qwp4 ) at @xmath48 and a polarization analyzer ( hwp3 and pbs1 ) . the photon number operator at bob is given by , @xmath100,\label{eq:04}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and then the expectation value is given by @xmath101.\label{eq:05}\end{aligned}\ ] ] bob has the same interference term @xmath102 for all the @xmath11 because the qwp4 is projected at the fixed angle @xmath103 in box 2 . at bob , if the single photon detector ( spd ) at + or - port detects the signal photon , he then assigned the valid detection as yes or no for his guesses on @xmath104 . in this scheme , the @xmath33 at alice let s discuss the ideal situation where alice chooses the @xmath21 with the right @xmath18 and bob guesses the right @xmath21 with his projection angle @xmath75 . for example , if alice chooses @xmath105 with the @xmath106 , the interference term in alice has the value -1 indicating her - spd4 will click. she records the detection as bit 0. while interference term in bob with his projection angle @xmath36 has the value + 1 indicating his + spd1 will click(yes ) . this means that his guess on @xmath107 is right . if alice chooses @xmath108 with the @xmath109 , her interference term indicates that her + spd3 will click or bit 1 is registered . the interference term in bob with the @xmath38 has the value + 1 or his + spd1 will click(yes ) . this means that his guess on @xmath110 is right . similarly , if alice chooses @xmath111 with the @xmath109 and @xmath112 with the @xmath106 , she will register bit 0 and 1 , respectively . bob will have the right guess on @xmath113 with his projection angles @xmath114 , respectively . we formulated the above discussion by assigning the @xmath115 into two groups i.e. @xmath116 and @xmath117 . then , we can denote the groups @xmath28 as a function of the @xmath11 , projection angle @xmath118 , and random phase @xmath18 for alice and bob to generate the shared key bits . if alice and bob share the group @xmath119 which is corresponding to bit 0 , then the - spd4 in alice will detect the ancilla photon and bob s + spd1 will detect the signal photon meaning yes. similarly , for @xmath120 , @xmath121 , @xmath122 . since each group @xmath28 has bit 0 and 1 associated with its correlation function @xmath11 and depended on random phase @xmath18 , then how alice knows her choice of @xmath11 and valid detection in her detectors can generate key bit in agreement with bob s guess on @xmath11 through his projection angle and valid detection in his detectors . the beauty of this scheme is alice and bob can generate the shared key bits through the shared correlation functions without requiring any information about the random phase @xmath18 in the source located in the middle between them . to understand this more clearly , let s consider the case where the phase @xmath123 in the source . alice chooses the @xmath124 , alice has the interference term @xmath125 or - spd4 will click registering bit 0. bob has no idea about what alice s choice on the @xmath21 and the phase @xmath123 . bob has the interference term @xmath102 . bob can only project the hwp3 to @xmath35 . bob chooses the @xmath36(@xmath38 ) for his guess on @xmath126 or @xmath127 ( @xmath128 or @xmath129 ) . bob knows his guess is right or wrong through the valid detection in his detector + spd1 or - spd2 , respectively . bob did not know the key bit until alice announces which group @xmath28 in step 5 . let s say , bob chooses @xmath36 , the interference term @xmath130 meaning his + spd1 will click(yes ) or his guess on @xmath131 or @xmath132 is right . after the signal transmission , alice announces the group @xmath133 of her choice ( step 5 ) . bob knows the @xmath87 is right . then , alice and bob share the key bit 0 ( step 6 ) . if bob chooses @xmath38 , the interference term @xmath134 meaning his - spd2 will click or his guess on @xmath135 or @xmath136 is wrong . after the signal transmission , alice announces the group @xmath133 of her choice ( step 5 ) . bob knew that his guess on @xmath137 or bit 1 is wrong . bob knows the bit is 0 , then alice and bob will share the key bit 0 ( step 6 ) . bob knows the key bits of alice regardless his guess is right or wrong . the above scenario is alice s choice of @xmath87 with right phase @xmath123 . the most intriguing part of this scheme is alice knows her key bit regardless her choice of @xmath11 in agreement with the phase @xmath18 . to discuss this , let s consider the case where the phase @xmath138 , alice still chooses the @xmath139 or bit 0 , the interference term in alice @xmath140 meaning that the + spd3 will click or bit 1. alice knew then her choice of @xmath87 is wrong . she also knew that the phase @xmath138 was meant for the @xmath141 , so she records the bit 1 as registered by her valid detection . amazingly , bob will have the bit 1. as discussed above , if bob chooses @xmath36 , the interference term @xmath142 meaning that his - spd2 will click or no on his guess . after alice announces the group @xmath133 , bob knew that his guess on @xmath87 or bit 0 is wrong , so he knows that alice has bit 1. the similar description is applied for the other @xmath137 , @xmath143 , and @xmath144 . weak coherent state is usually vulnerable to photon - number splitting attack i.e eve can tap one signal photon from beam 2 and perform the same measurement as bob did . in this protocol , we make use of the phase coding @xmath66 system @xcite to secure beam 1 and beam 2 from eve attacks . one can also use differential phase shifted method to distribute operators @xmath61 and @xmath60 at the output of the bs1 . the protocol can prevent more than one photon in a coherent pulse by applying the condition @xmath145 . for example , 2 photons in beam 2 can be attributed to higher photon number in ( x , y ) mode such that @xmath146 as given by @xmath147 . it is more sensitive to the condition @xmath85 or it will introduce more errors on bob if the condition @xmath85 is not fulfilled , even though its contribution is in the order of mean photon number @xmath148 less than the one photon number case ( @xmath149 and @xmath150 ) . in other words , the existence of multiple photons will introduce the percentage of errors in bob even without the presence of eve . the percentage will also be the amount information leaking to eve in the photon - number splitting attack . in intercept - resend attacks , eve knows that the bit information is not encoded in the state . he can perform the same measurement as bob did . even though we assume that eve break the security of the @xmath66 , eve can not resend a perfect copy of the original signal photon because the input product of two mode weak coherent states is a nonorthogonal state . for example , the input product state @xmath151 of the beam splitter ( bs1 ) will have the output product state @xmath17 , where the state @xmath152 is sent to bob . the non - orthogonality of coherent states and the @xmath18 can not be measured in a single measurement . bob will reveal the present of eve by sending part of his observations ( step 3 and 4 ) to alice . let s say in the second column in fig.2 , alice knows that bob is supposed to observe yes with his guess through his projected angle @xmath36 . because of the imperfect copy from eve , bob might observe no with the @xmath36 , so alice will aware of the error and stop the transmission . there is no leakage of information to eve because alice has not implemented step 5 yet . in conclusion , we have presented unique feature of a new scheme based on intrinsic quantum correlation of weak coherent states for generating key bits between alice and bob through high level communication language . the scheme preserve the randomness of the light source for doubling the communication distance , and also increase the success rate of raw key generation compared to ekert s protocol , and double the sift key rate compared to weak coherent light protocol . , `` quantum mechanics without probability amplitudes , '' * * , ( ) ; `` a wigner - function formulation of finite - state quantum mechanics , '' * * , ( ) ; , , , `` discrete phase space based on finite fields , '' * * , ( ) . , , , , , , `` interpretation of tomography and spectroscopy as dual forms of quantum computation , '' * * , ( ) ; , `` picturing qubits in phase space , '' ( ) ; , , , `` quantum computers in phase space , '' * * , ( ) ; , , , , `` discrete wigner functions and the phase space representation of quantum computers , '' * * , ( )

a new conceptual key generation scheme is presented by using intrinsic quantum correlations of single photons between alice and bob . the intrinsic bi - partite correlation functions allow key bit to be generated through high level communication language i.e. a key bit is directly encoded to shared correlation functions not to the state and detection of a photon at bob does not mean key bit . these make the scheme robust against intercept - resend attack because alice and bob can always check the errors in their measurements and reveal the presence of eve in their channel without leaking any key bit information . the scheme is strictly relied on the perfect beam splitter and mean photon number less than 1 , where more than one photon in a coherent pulse will introduce more errors in bob even without the presence of eve . from the percentage of errors in bob , we can estimate the amount of information will be leaked to eve in the photon - number splitting attack . this scheme can preserve the randomness of phase - randomized light source for doubling the communication distance as in original ekert s protocol and providing the raw key generation rate a factor of 2 higher than weak coherent light protocols .

1604.07795

weak lensing of the large scale structure ( cosmic shear ) is one of the most powerful methods for constraining the cosmological model and is sensitive to both the growth of structure and to the expansion history of the universe ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . however , so far weak lensing data has been available for only small regions of the sky ( @xmath3200 deg@xmath4 ) surveys that will produce large weak lensing data sets have begun ( dark energy survey(des ) , hyper suprime - cam(hsc ) , panoramic survey telescope and rapid response system(panstarrs ) , the kilo - degree survey(kids ) ) or are being built ( lsst , euclid , the wide - field infrared survey telescope ( wfirst ) ) . the statistical power of forthcoming weak lensing data sets , which will cover thousands or tens of thousands of square degrees , makes it necessary to consider the effect of systematic errors that could previously be ignored . the cosmic shear analysis relies on the accurate measurement of shapes of as many as tens of billions of background galaxies , to statistically estimate the small distortion ( about @xmath5 ) caused by weak gravitational lensing . to fully benefit from the increased statistical power of the new surveys , systematic errors must not significantly degrade the cosmological parameter errors . some imperfections in ccds become apparent when they record a uniform illumination ( flat fields ) . structure in the images reveals several patterns that are not due exclusively to quantum efficiency variations . concentric arcs , called tree rings ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) are due to impurity gradients in the ccds which cause electric fields transverse to the surface of the ccd . patterns aligned with the rows and columns of the pixels are due to periodic pixel - size variation caused by errors in the masks used in the step - and - repeat process manufacturing ( @xcite ) . both these effects can change the shape of galaxy images . for weak lensing analyses , we quantify the shape changes as spurious shear or spurious convergence . for the tree rings , we show how to calculate the spurious shear and spurious convergence from the flat field images . for the pixel - size variation , we calculate the spurious convergence which is directly related to the size of the pixel . the primary statistics for inferring cosmology from weak lensing surveys is the 2-point correlation function of shear or convergence , and its fourier transform , the power spectrum . the 2-point correlation function of spurious shear must be much smaller than that due to cosmological shear if cosmological parameters are to be accurately inferred . the biases in cosmological parameters are determined by calculating how much the inferred parameters change when the spurious convergence is added to the lensing convergence ( @xcite ) . this paper is organized as follows : in section 2 we give an overview of how we compute the bias in cosmological parameters from the spurious convergence . in section 3 , we describe the measurement of tree rings , the spurious 2-point correlation function it causes , and the parameter bias it induces . in section 4 , we describe the measurement of pixel - size variation , the 2-point correlation function of the spurious convergence and the parameter bias it induces . we summarize our findings and discuss further work in section 5 . weak gravitational lensing causes changes in the apparent position of point sources . for a source at @xmath6 observed at displaced position @xmath7 due to lensing , the shift is described by a 2@xmath82 transformation matrix ( @xcite ) @xmath9 where @xmath10 , the convergence , describes the isotropic distortion ( magnification ) of an extended source , and @xmath11 , @xmath12 , the shears , describe anisotropic distortions of the image . detector imperfections can cause distortions of the images of galaxies resulting in spurious shear and convergence , biasing the cosmological parameter determination . previous work has described biases due to the atmosphere , telescope and detector in terms of spurious shear ( @xcite ) . however the convergence and the shear are alternative descriptions of lensing , the convergence is related to shear ( up to a uniform mass sheet degeneracy ) through a non - local kaiser - squires inversion ( @xcite ) . the power spectrum of convergence is equal to the power spectrum of e - mode shear . we point out here that spurious convergence is in some cases a more convenient description of ccd imperfections than spurious shear . the spurious convergence due to pixel - size variation is easily calculated from the change in the pixel area from its nominal value . since for lensing , convergence is proportional to the mass surface density , it is clear that if we consider an area composed of many pixels , the convergence is just the average of the convergence of the constituent pixels . the bias calculation is performed using a fisher formalism ( see for example @xcite . let @xmath13 be the convergence from weak lensing in a field of view of size @xmath14 , and let @xmath15 be its power spectrum defined as @xmath16 we used the superscript 0 to denote the convergence measured from a pure lensing signal , not including systematic effects . in this equation , and in the remainder of this section , the hat ( @xmath17 ) on a quantity @xmath18 means that the quantity is an estimator and we use the tilde @xmath19 to denote the fourier transform of @xmath18 . the subscripts @xmath20 are shorthands for the multipole moments @xmath21 . we also indicate the dirac delta function and the kronecker delta symbol as @xmath22 respectively . in the limit in which @xmath13 is a gaussian field , the power spectrum estimator @xmath23 has an expectation value @xmath24 and a variance @xmath25 , where the mode number @xmath26 is computed as see @xcite @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the width of the multipole bins used in the analysis . because the convergence field is statistically isotropic , the power spectrum measured at a multipole @xmath29 depends on the magnitude @xmath30 of the two dimensional multipole moment @xmath29 . now let @xmath31 the derivative of @xmath32 with respect to cosmological parameter @xmath33 and @xmath34 the @xmath23 estimator covariance matrix , which we approximate as diagonal @xmath35 defining @xmath36 we can estimate the bias @xmath37 in the cosmological parameters @xmath38 when fitting a field of view with spurious convergence added @xmath39 as @xmath40 where the superscripts @xmath41 , 0 refer to the power spectrum measured from a field of view with and without spurious convergence added ( @xcite ) . the same fisher formalism can be used to estimate the marginalized errors @xmath42 on the parameters when using a single field of view @xmath43 we note that when using the full survey data rather than a single field of view , parameter errors can be much smaller since @xmath44 . for lsst , @xmath45 and @xmath46 . equation ( [ biasexpr ] ) can be further expanded as @xmath47 = m_{\alpha i}\left(p^{sp}_i + \frac{\hat{\tilde{\kappa}}_i^0\tilde{\kappa}_i^{sp,*}+\hat{\tilde{\kappa}}_i^{0,*}\tilde{\kappa}_i^{sp}}{(2\pi)^2}\right)\ ] ] the spurious convergence @xmath48 is calculated from laboratory measurement of the ccds . since the imperfections are fixed on the ccd focal plane , there is only one realization of the spurious convergence and it spans the field of view of the telescope . because of this , the spurious convergence @xmath49 becomes a non stochastic quantity ( and hence written without the hat ) . we can compute the expectation value and standard deviation of the bias estimator ( [ biasestimator ] ) and get @xmath50 @xmath51 since the spurious convergence is non stochastic , the standard deviation of the bias estimator ( [ varbias ] ) is proportional to the standard deviation of @xmath52 , which scales as @xmath53 . these results are correct for a single field of view , when the analysis is scaled to the full survey side the expectation value of the bias does not change , but the standard deviation of @xmath52 gets reduced by a factor of @xmath54 . the same reduction applies to the bias variance in ( [ varbias ] ) . we note that the stochasticity in the bias is due to the cross term in ( [ biasestimator ] ) and is a result of cosmic variance in the lensing convergence field . @xmath55 can be quite large compared to @xmath56 even for @xmath57 . the estimated survey bias is @xmath58 . we will quote the larger of the two values as the estimated survey bias . to compute @xmath59 in the fiducial cosmological model with @xmath60 , as well as the derivatives @xmath31 , we make use of the public code nicaea ( @xcite ) which gives good accuracy for the lensing power spectra in the parameter range we are considering . we assume a redshift distribution of galaxies concentrated in single redshift @xmath61 . in the lensing convergence power spectrum @xmath23 we include the effects of galaxy shape for the assumed @xmath62 galaxies/@xmath63 . an approximate scaling relation of the bias with the galaxy density can be obtained noting that , in the limit in which shape noise dominates , @xmath64 scales as @xmath65 . because the derivatives @xmath66 and the spurious power @xmath67 do not depend on @xmath68 , the bias expectation value does not change with @xmath68 , but its standard deviation roughly scales with @xmath69 . tree rings are due to impurity gradients in the silicon of which ccds are made . the high - purity , high - resistivity silicon used in recent astronomical ccds grows cylindrically from molten state . time variations in temperature , composition , etc . produce radial impurity gradients which result in resistivity gradients . ccds made from slices of the cylindrical boule have electric fields transverse to the main field due to the resistivity gradients leading to the displacement of photo - generated charge . thick ccds used for increased near ir ( @xmath3 1 micron ) sensitivity suffer greater charge displacement due to longer path length . though the tree rings are observed in flat field images , they do not correspond to quantum efficiency variations . instead , they induce a displacement of the collected charge that propagates into astrometric and photometric biases . in this section we describe how to calculate the spurious shear and spurious convergence due to tree rings from the flat - field images and apply the method to the lsst candidate sensors . we then calculate the 2pcf and bias of cosmological parameters . in practice , it is possible to directly measure the astrometric displacement @xmath70 as function of scalar radius @xmath71 , caused by the tree rings by using sets of several dithered exposures of star fields in different photometric bands and constructing star flat " images ( @xcite , @xcite ) . the displacement is defined from differences between the original position @xmath72 and the displaced position by the tree - ring effect @xmath73 ; it is defined as @xmath74 however , this is not an easy task given that the displacement is small ( of the order of subpixels ) . however , it is easy to measure flux modulation @xmath75 due to tree - ring , defined as @xmath76 where @xmath77 is average flux at radius @xmath71 and @xmath78 is average flux of all pixels . @xcite demonstrated that , to first order , there exists a relationship between the tree - rings flux modulation @xmath75 as measured by the flat fields ( which have higher s / n compared to the one provided by the limited number of stars in the star flats ) and the astrometric displacement @xmath70 , given by @xmath79 note the sign convention here differs from that in @xcite . because the displacements caused by tree rings have only radial components , shape changes are measured easily by considering the change in radial length and tangential length of images . consider the effect of the displacement field on an infinitesimal image between radius @xmath73 and @xmath80 and @xmath81 and @xmath82 in polar coordinates , where the origin of the coordinate system is set to the center of the concentric displacement . thus , the image is mapped from the original position @xmath72 and @xmath83 and @xmath84 and @xmath85 by the tree ring displacement field , which is written as a function @xmath86 . figure [ fig : cd ] shows the relation between the images . the extent of the image in the @xmath71 direction relate to each other as in equation [ eq : tr_d ] and @xmath87 the shape change can be obtained by taking the ratio of the length of the images in both the radial and tangential direction . thus , the radial size change is given by @xmath88 and the tangential size change is given by @xmath89 for convenience , and without loss of generality , let us consider a situation where @xmath90 . then we can arrange equation [ eq : cdist_r ] and [ eq : cdist_t ] in matrix form , obtaining @xmath91 where @xmath92 and @xmath93 are the convergence and shear due to the tree - rings displacement , defined as @xmath94 where @xmath95 is positive for radial shear and negative for tangential shear . thus , the two components of the shear , @xmath11 and @xmath12 , at @xmath96 can be written as @xmath97 by using equation [ eq : tr_d_f ] , [ eq : tr_conv_d ] and [ eq : tr_shear_d ] can be written in terms of the flux modulation @xmath98 where the last approximation is valid when the displacement is much smaller than the radius . the typical spatial scales of the displacements are of the order of subpixels , and the radii of the order of 100@xmath991000 pixels , so the approximation is valid . this means that the convergence and shear due to the tree rings are approximately half the value of the flux modulation . for shear @xmath100 at @xmath96 in polar coordinates relative to a fixed origin , the radial and cross shear are given by @xmath101 . the tangential shear is obtained as @xmath102 . . ] we measured the tree - ring patterns of two different lsst candidate ccds . here we discuss only one ccd type , since results for the other were similar . we used flat - field images from a uniform light source of @xmath103 nm wavelength . the ccds have approximately 4000@xmath84000 pixels , each one with a physical size of 10 microns @xmath8 10 microns . the ccds are 100 microns thick for near ir sensitivity . we have 25 flat field images , and each image has approximately 62500 mean electron counts per pixel . first we corrected the flat field images to eliminate other effects by following steps : * masked regions near the edge of the detectors and shadows due to dust particles in the optics . * the light source in this test was not completely uniform , so fit the slow variation with a 7th order polynomial for each readout channels , then normalized by the polynomial . * stacked the normalized 25 flat images . * measured the laser annealing pattern and pixel variation pattern , then simply divided the flat fields by the patterns . * removed other large scale fluctuation in fourier space . though pixel - size variation also will result in its own pattern of spurious distortion , for the tree - ring analysis we removed both pixel - size variation and laser annealing effects by scaling the image . we discuss pixel - size variation in detail in the next section . we determine the center of the tree ring profiles in each ccd by selecting points on several rings and then fitting for their common center . the center of the rings lies near of the corner of the ccd , but slightly offset from it ( see figure [ fig : sstr_2dim ] ) . figure [ fig : sstr_1dim ] shows the measured tree - ring profiles . before measuring the profiles , the images were smoothed by a gaussian kernel with a 5-pixel standard deviation . since the width scale of the tree rings peaks is about @xmath104 pixels , the smoothing should not reduce their amplitude by much . the typical amplitude of the flux modulation is approximately @xmath105 , about 50 times smaller than that on the decam ccds reported by @xcite . the tangential spurious shear is calculated from the flux modulations by using equation [ eq : tr_shear_f ] ( the spurious shear is about half value of flux modulation ) . the typical amplitude of the spurious shear is of about @xmath106% . the displacement is calculated by using equation [ eq : tr_d_f ] . the typical amplitude of the astrometric displacement is about @xmath107 pixels @xmath108 arcseconds . this means the displacement caused by tree - ring effect does not cause significant missregistrations . here we calculate the 2-point correlation function ( 2pcf ) of the spurious shear induced by tree rings on the lsst ccds . first , we calculate the spurious shear pattern on each individual ccd from the observed flux modulation ( figure [ fig : sstr_2dim_color ] left panel ) . the spurious shear 2pcf is calculated from @xmath109 and @xmath110 ( see for example @xcite ) @xmath111 a typical galaxy used for lsst weak lensing analysis subtends 1 arcsec , comparable to the 0.7 arcsec psf . each pixel subtends 0.2 arcsec . so a typical galaxy image covers @xmath112 pixels . the scale on which tree - ring shear varies is approximately 100 pixels , so the spurious shear does not change significantly over a galaxy image . thus the spurious shear for a galaxy is approximately equal to the spurious shear at any pixel within the galaxy image . the lsst focal plane is composed of 21 rafts , each raft composed of 9 ccds . we assume that all ccds in the raft have the same tree ring profile but with random orientations differing by 90 degree rotations . the right panel of figure [ fig : sstr_2dim_color ] shows the spurious shear pattern for a single raft . we assemble a virtual lsst focal plane out of 25 rafts arranged in square applying random 90 degree rotations to each raft . figure [ fig : sstr_2cor_ccd_log ] upper panel shows the 2pcf of spurious shear due to tree rings for a single lsst ccd . the typical value is about @xmath113 . at very short spatial scales we can see a slightly larger peak . this value is much smaller than the square of the typical amplitude of the spurious shear , @xmath114 . the smallness of the 2pcf results from a cancellation between alternate signs of spurious shear in its calculation . the 2pcf averages over pairs of galaxies at a fixed separation . the sign of the spurious shear due to tree rings alternates on the tree ring scale as is seen in figure [ fig : sstr_2dim_color ] . with 30 galaxies per square arcmin , each ccd will record @xmath1155@xmath116 galaxies per pointing , and @xmath117 galaxies for the @xmath1152@xmath116 pointing over the course of the survey . dithering will further reduce the effect of the imperfections we consider . thus there are a huge number of pairs of galaxies at similar separations but with differing sign of spurious shear . there is less of a cancellation on scales comparable to the ccd size , due to the smaller number of pairs at that separation . at scales less than the 100 pixel tree ring scale , both points may lie on the same tree ring . of spurious shear caused by tree rings on lsst ccds . absolute values are shown ; the values oscillate around zero . upper panel is for a single ccd . lower panel is for the full lsst focal plane . ] [ fig : sstr_2cor_ccd_log ] lower panel shows the 2pcf of the spurious shear on an area equivalent to the full field of view of the lsst camera with a @xmath104 pixel sampling scale . the typical scale for the amplitude decreases to @xmath118 due to further averaging down for the reasons described above . in comparison , the lensing 2pcf @xmath119 predicted by nicaea ( @xcite ) for the fiducial cosmology with a lsst - like galaxy distribution varies monotonically from @xmath120 at 1 arcsec separation ( 5 pixels ) to @xmath121 at @xmath122 arcsec separation ( 20,000 pixels ) . the fact that the spurious shear two point function is much smaller than the weak lensing signal is encouraging , but is not sufficient by itself to say that the bias on the cosmological parameters is negligible . to quantify the former bias , we need to isolate the features of the two point function that are most sensitive to cosmology , and study how the spurious power in this feature space affects our parameter estimates . we quantify the bias on the cosmological parameters in the following section . the bias in cosmological parameters caused by tree rings can be calculated from the spurious convergence as described in section 3 . figure [ fig : pl_tr ] shows the spurious convergence power spectrum @xmath123 used to calculate the bias caused by tree rings . the spurious power fluctuates randomly around @xmath124 and does not show a systematic trend with @xmath125 . the spurious power spectrum was calculated on a grid with each element of the grid 30@xmath830 pixels and the convergence averaged over the grid element . table [ tab : bias_tr ] shows the amplitude of the bias due to tree rings . the biases shown in table [ tab : bias_tr ] are very much smaller than the expected marginalized errors @xmath126 for lsst which are are 0.00232 for @xmath1 , 0.02434 for @xmath0 and 0.00427 for @xmath2 , calculated as described in section 3 assuming 30 galaxies per square arcminute at z=2 . the marginalized errors will be somewhat smaller if tomography is used . .[tab : bias_tr ] bias of the cosmological parameters ( @xmath127 ) caused by tree rings . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] we describe in detail all the steps necessary to go from flat - field images to spurious shear and convergence , then to 2-point correlation functions and spurious power , and finally to bias in cosmological parameters . for tree rings , we use new formulae developed here to calculate the spurious shear and convergence from the astrometric displacements , and a model developed by @xcite to estimate the astrometric displacement from the flux modulations measured in flat - field images . for the lsst ccds , the typical value of flux modulation due to tree rings is @xmath105 , about 50 times smaller than that for the decam ccds . the typical amplitude of spurious shear is @xmath128 the typical amplitude of the 2-point correlation function over the lsst focal plane is about @xmath129 . the 2pcf is much smaller than the square of the typical amplitude of the spurious shear due to cancelations of tangential and radial shears in the calculation . the 2pcf is much smaller than the lensing 2pcf suggesting , but not proving that it can be ignored . we go further and calculate the bias to cosmological parameters and find it to be negligible . we point out that spurious convergence is the natural way to describe the effect of pixel - size variation , and calculate the spurious convergence , which is directly related to the size of the pixel , from the counts in individual pixels in flat - field images . the width of rows and columns thus determined varies in a periodic way . for the lsst ccds the typical magnitude of the flux modulation due to periodic pixel - size variation is @xmath130 , five times larger than for tree rings . this translates into a @xmath131 2pcf over the lsst focal plane , much smaller than the lensing 2pcf . we calculate the bias to cosmological parameters due to pixel - size variation and find it to be larger than for tree rings , but still negligible compared to the marginalized errors . in this study we have only considered the impact of tree rings and pixel size variation on cosmological parameters derived from the lensing power spectrum . we plan to extend our analysis to other sensor imperfections . we note that as much as a factor of 2 additional information about cosmology is contained in non - gaussian lensing statistics beyond the power spectrum , we plan to extend our analysis to consider the impact of sensor imperfections on cosmological parameters derived from non - gaussian lensing statistics . we thank g. bernstein and p. oconnor for useful comments and discussions , and the instrumentation division of brookhaven for data taking . this work was supported in part by the u.s . department of energy under contract no . de - ac02 - 98ch10886 and contract no . de - sc0012704 . aap is also supported by jpl , which is run under a contract for nasa by caltech . 9 chang c. , kahn s. m. , jernigan j. g. , peterson j. r. , alsayyad y. , ahmad z. , bankert j. , bard d. , con- nolly a. , gibson r. r. , gilmore k. , grace e. , hannel m. , hodge m. a. , jee m. j. , jones l. , krughoff s. , lorenz s. , marshall p. j. , marshall s. , meert a. , nagarajan s. , peng e. , rasmussen a. p. , shmakova m. , sylvestre n. , todd n. , and young m. , mnras 428 , 2695 ( 2013 ) . diehl h. t. , physics procedia , proceedings of the 2nd international conference on technology and instrumentation in particle physics ( tipp 2011 ) , v37 pp 1332 - 1340 dodelson scott , modern cosmology , academic press , 2003 hamana t. and mellier y. , numerical study of the statistical properties of the lensing excursion angles mnras , 2001 , 327 , 169h holland s. e. , bebek c. j. , kolbe w. f. and lee j. s. , _ physics of fully depleted ccds _ , ( 2014 ) , jinst 9 c03057 jarvis m. , _ challenges for precision shape measurements _ , ( 2014 ) , jinst 9 c03017 jarvis m. , sheldon e. , zuntz j. , kacprzak t. , bridle s. l. , amara a. , armstrong r. , becker m. r. , bernstein g. m. et al . , arxiv:1507.05603(2015 ) . kaiser n. , squires g. mapping the dark matter with weak gravitational lensing , apj , 1993 , part 1 , vol . 2 , p. 441 - 450 kaiser n , wilson g and luppino g 2000 , arxiv : astro - ph/0003338 kilbinger m. , benabed k. , guy j. , astier p. , tereno i. , fu l. , wraith d. , coupon j. , mellier y. , balland c. , bouchet f. r. , hamana t. , hardin d. , mccracken h. j. , pain r. , regnault n. , schultheis m. , and yahagi h. , astron . 497 , 677 ( 2009 ) . kilbinger m : arxiv:1411.0115 lewis , a. , challinor a. and lasenby a , efficient computation of cmb anisotropies in closed frw models " , apj , 2000 , 538 , 473 lupton r. , _ consequences of thick ccds on image processing _ , ( 2014 ) , jinst 9 c04023 manfroid j. , _ on ccd standard stars and flat - field calibration , ( 1995 ) _ a&as , 113 , 587 miller , l. , et al . , 2007 , mnras , 382 185 munshi , d. , valagesas p. , van waerbeke , l. & heavens , a. , 2008 , phys . rept . 462 , 67 petri a. , may m. , haiman z. and kratochvil j. m. , impact of spurious shear on cosmological parameter estimates from weak lensing observables physical review , 2014 , d , volume 90 , issue 12 , id.123015 plazas a. a. et al . , publications of the astronomical society of the pacific , 2014 , volume 126 , issue 942 , pp.750 - 760 rasmussen a. , _ use of sensor characterization data to tune electrostatic model parameters for lsst sensors _ , ( 2015 ) , jinst 10 c05028 schneider , 2006 , part 1 : introduction to gravitational lensing and cosmology , isbn : 3 - 540 - 30309-x smith r. and rahmer g. , _ pixel area variation in ccds and implications for precision photometry _ , ( 2008 ) , proc . spie 7021 , 70212a-1 springel v. , the cosmological simulation code gadget-2 , mnras , 2005 , 364 , 1105s stubbs c. , _ precision astronomy with imperfect fully depleted ccds : an introduction and a suggested lexicon , ( 2014 ) , jinst 9 c03032 _ arxiv:1312.2313 tucker d. et al . , the future of photometric , spectrophotometric and polarimetric standardization , asp conference series , vol . 364 , proceedings of a conference held 8 - 11 may , 2006 in blankenberge , belgium . edited by c. sterken . san francisco : astronomical society of the pacific , 2007 . , p.187 wittman d. m. , tyson j. a. , kirkman d. , dellantonio , i. and bernstein , g. 2000 , nature , 405 , 143 - 148 .

weak gravitational lensing causes subtle changes in the apparent shapes of galaxies due to the bending of light by the gravity of foreground masses . by measuring the shapes of large numbers of galaxies ( millions in recent surveys , up to tens of billions in future surveys ) we can infer the parameters that determine cosmology . imperfections in the detectors used to record images of the sky can introduce changes in the apparent shape of galaxies , which in turn can bias the inferred cosmological parameters . in this paper we consider the effect of two widely discussed sensor imperfections : tree - rings , due to impurity gradients which cause transverse electric fields in the charge - coupled devices ( ccd ) , and pixel - size variation , due to periodic ccd fabrication errors . these imperfections can be observed when the detectors are subject to uniform illumination ( flat field images ) . we develop methods to determine the spurious shear and convergence ( due to the imperfections ) from the flat - field images . we calculate how the spurious shear when added to the lensing shear will bias the determination of cosmological parameters . we apply our methods to candidate sensors of the large synoptic survey telescope ( lsst ) as a timely and important example , analyzing flat field images recorded with lsst prototype ccds in the laboratory . we find that tree - rings and periodic pixel - size variation present in the lsst ccds will introduce negligible bias to cosmological parameters determined from the lensing power spectrum , specifically @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 .

0912.5139

the influence of boundaries on the vacuum state of a quantum field leads to interesting physical consequences . well known example is the casimir effect @xcite , when the modification of the zero - point fluctuations spectrum by the presence of boundaries induces vacuum forces acting on the boundaries . it may have important implications on all scales , from cosmological to subnuclear . the particular features of the resulting vacuum forces depend on the nature of the quantum field , the type of spacetime manifold , the boundary geometries and the specific boundary conditions imposed on the field . the casimir effect can be viewed as a polarization of vacuum by boundary conditions . another type of vacuum polarization arises in the case of an external gravitational field . in this paper , we study an exactly solvable problem with both types of sources for the polarization . namely , we consider the vacuum expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor for both scalar and electromagnetic fields induced by a curved boundary in background of robertson - walker ( rw ) spacetime with negative spatial curvature . in order to generate the vacuum densities we use the well known relation between the vacuum expectation values in conformally related problems ( see , for instance , @xcite ) and the corresponding results for an infinite plane boundary moving with uniform acceleration through the fulling rindler vacuum . the latter problem for conformally coupled dirichlet and neumann massless scalar fields and for the electromagnetic field in four dimensional rindler spacetime was considered by candelas and deutsch @xcite . these authors consider the region of the right rindler wedge to the right of the barrier . in @xcite , we have investigated the wightman function and the vacuum expectation values of the energy momentum tensor for a massive scalar field with general curvature coupling parameter , satisfying the robin boundary condition on the infinite plane in an arbitrary number of spacetime dimensions and for the electromagnetic field . we have considered both regions , including the one between the barrier and rindler horizon . the corresponding surface densities induced on the plate have been considered in @xcite . the vacuum expectation values of the energy momentum tensors for scalar and electromagnetic fields for the geometry of two parallel plates moving by uniform acceleration are investigated in avag02 . in particular , the vacuum forces acting on the boundaries are evaluated . in @xcite the casimir energy is evaluated for massless scalar fields under dirichlet or neumann boundary conditions , and for the electromagnetic field with perfect conductor boundary conditions on one and two infinite parallel plates moving by uniform proper acceleration through the fulling rindler vacuum in an arbitrary number of spacetime dimension . a closely related problem for the evaluation of the energy - momentum tensor of a casimir apparatus in a weak gravitational field recently has been considered in @xcite . in particular , it has been shown that the casimir energy for a configuration of parallel plates gravitates according to the equivalence principle . in @xcite the conformal relation between de sitter and rindler spacetimes is used to generate the vacuum expectation values of the energy momentum tensor for a conformally coupled scalar field in de sitter spacetime in the presence of a curved brane on which the field obeys the robin boundary condition with coordinate dependent coefficients . the casimir densities for spherical branes in rindler - like spacetimes have been investigated in @xcite . the organization of the present paper is as follows . in the next section we consider the conformal relation between the problems in the rw spacetime with negative spatial curvature and rindler spacetime . the geometry of the boundary is specified . in section [ sec : scalar ] the vacuum expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor is investigated for a scalar filed with robin boundary condition . the casimir densities in the case of the electromagnetic field with perfect conductor boundary conditions on the plate are discussed in section [ sec : elmag ] . the main results are summarized in section [ sec : conc ] . as a background geometry we shall consider the @xmath0 rw spacetime with the line element@xmath1where @xmath2 and @xmath3 is the line element on the @xmath4-dimensional unit sphere in euclidean space . first of all let us present the rw line element in the form conformally related to the rindler metric . with this aim we make the coordinate transformation@xmath5 with @xmath6 , defined by the relations ( see ref . @xcite for the case @xmath7)@xmath8where @xmath9 is a constant with the dimension of length and we use the notation@xmath10under this transformation the rw line element takes the form@xmath11 in this form the rw metric is manifestly conformally related to the metric in the rindler spacetime with the line element @xmath12:@xmath13 by using the standard transformation formula for the vacuum expectation values of the energy momentum tensor in conformally related problems ( see , for instance , @xcite ) , we can generate the results for the rw spacetime from the corresponding results in the rindler spacetime . first we shall consider the corresponding quantities in the coordinates @xmath14 with the line element ( [ dsrw1 ] ) . these quantities are found by using the transformation formula for conformally related problems : @xmath15 |0_{% \mathrm{rw}}\rangle = [ \xi /a(\eta ) ] ^{d+1}\langle 0_{\mathrm{r}}|t_{i}^{k}% \left [ g_{lm}^{\mathrm{r}},\varphi _ { \mathrm{r}}\right ] |0_{\mathrm{r}% } \rangle + \langle t_{i}^{k}\left [ g_{lm}^{\prime } , \varphi \right ] \rangle ^{% \mathrm{(an ) } } , \label{conftransemt}\]]where the second term on the right is determined by the trace anomaly . in odd spacetime dimensions the conformal anomaly is absent and the corresponding part vanishes : @xmath16 \rangle ^{\mathrm{(an)}}=0 $ ] for even @xmath17 . the vacuum expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor in coordinates ( [ dsrw ] ) is obtained by the standard coordinate transformation formulae . for a second rank tensor @xmath18 , which is diagonal in coordinates @xmath19 , the transformation to coordinates @xmath20 has the form @xmath21 in this paper , as a rindler counterpart we shall take the vacuum energy momentum tensor induced by an infinite plate moving by uniform proper acceleration through the fulling rindler vacuum . we shall assume that the plate is located in the right rindler wedge and has the coordinate @xmath22 . in coordinates @xmath23 the boundary @xmath24 is presented by the hypersurface@xmath25the corresponding normal has the components@xmath26we consider the cases of scalar and electromagnetic fields separately . in this section we consider a conformally coupled massless scalar field @xmath27 on background of spacetime with the line element ( [ dsrw ] ) . the corresponding field equation has the form @xmath28where @xmath29 is the ricci scalar for the rw spacetime . we assume that the field satisfies the robin boundary condition @xmath30on the hypersurface ( [ boundeq ] ) . the expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor induced by the presence of an infinite plane boundary moving with uniform acceleration through the fulling rindler vacuum was investigated in @xcite . for a scalar field @xmath31 it is presented in the decomposed form : @xmath32|0_{\mathrm{r}}\rangle = \langle \tilde{0}_{\mathrm{r}}|t_{i}^{k}[g_{lm}^{% \mathrm{r}},\varphi _ { \mathrm{r}}]|\tilde{0}_{\mathrm{r}}\rangle + \langle t_{% \mathrm{(r)}i}^{k}\rangle ^{\mathrm{(b)}}. \label{tikr}\]]in this formula , @xmath33 are @xmath34 are the vacuum states for the rindler spacetime in presence and absence of the plate respectively and @xmath35 is the part of the vacuum energy - momentum tensor induced by the plate . for the part without boundaries one has @xmath36|\tilde{0}_{\mathrm{r}}\rangle = \frac{a_{d}\xi ^{-d-1}}{% 2^{d-1}\pi ^{d/2}\gamma ( d/2)}\mathrm{diag}\left ( -1,1/d,\ldots , 1/d\right ) , \label{tikr0}\]]with the notation @xmath37 , \label{ad}\]]where @xmath38 for even @xmath39 and @xmath40 for odd @xmath41 , and the value for the product over @xmath42 is equal to 1 for @xmath43 . for a scalar field @xmath31 satisfying the robin boundary condition @xmath44with constant coefficients @xmath45 and @xmath46 , the boundary induced part in the region @xmath47 is given by the formula saha02 @xmath48 . \label{tikrb}\]]here the functions @xmath49 $ ] have the form @xmath50 & = & g^{\prime 2}(z)+\frac{d-1}{z}g(z)g^{\prime } ( z)+\left [ 1-(2d-1)\frac{\omega ^{2}}{z^{2}}\right ] g^{2}(z ) , \notag \\ f^{(1)}[g(z ) ] & = & -dg^{\prime 2}(z)-\frac{d-1}{z}g(z)g^{\prime } ( z)+d\left ( 1+% \frac{\omega ^{2}}{z^{2}}\right ) g^{2}(z ) , \label{figz } \\ f^{(i)}[g(z ) ] & = & g^{\prime 2}(z)+\left ( \frac{\omega ^{2}}{z^{2}}-\frac{d+1}{% d-1}\right ) g^{2}(z),\quad i=2,\ldots , d. \notag\end{aligned}\]]in eq . ( [ tikrb ] ) , @xmath51 and @xmath52 are the modified bessel functions and for a given function @xmath53 we use the notation @xmath54the expression for the boundary part of the vacuum energy - momentum tensor in the region @xmath55 is obtained from formula ( [ tikrb ] ) by the replacements @xmath56 . the formulae given above allow us to present the rw vacuum expectation value in coordinates @xmath57 in the form similar to ( [ tikr ] ) : @xmath15 |0_{% \mathrm{rw}}\rangle = \langle \tilde{0}_{\mathrm{rw}}|t_{i}^{k}\left [ g_{lm}^{\prime } , \varphi \right ] |\tilde{0}_{\mathrm{rw}}\rangle + \langle t_{i}^{k}\left [ g_{lm}^{\prime } , \varphi \right ] \rangle ^{\mathrm{(b ) } } , \label{tikds}\]]where @xmath58 |\tilde{0}_{\mathrm{rw}}\rangle $ ] is the vacuum expectation value in the rw spacetime without boundaries and the part @xmath59 \rangle ^{\mathrm{% ( b)}}$ ] is induced by the boundary ( [ boundeq ] ) . conformally transforming the rindler results one finds @xmath60 |\tilde{0}_{\mathrm{rw}}\rangle & = & [ \xi /a(\eta ) ] ^{d+1}\langle \tilde{0}_{\mathrm{r}}|t_{i}^{k}[g_{lm}^{\mathrm{r}},\varphi _ { \mathrm{r}}]|% \tilde{0}_{\mathrm{r}}\rangle + \langle t_{i}^{k}\left [ g_{lm}^{\prime } , \varphi \right ] \rangle ^{\mathrm{(an ) } } , \label{tikds0 } t_{i}^{k}\left [ g_{lm}^{\prime } , \varphi \right ] \rangle ^{\mathrm{% ( b ) } } & = & [ \xi /a(\eta ) ] ^{d+1}\langle t_{\mathrm{(r)}i}^{k}\rangle ^{\mathrm{% ( b)}}. \label{tikdsb}\end{aligned}\]]under the conformal transformation @xmath61^{2}g_{ik}^{\mathrm{r}}$ ] , the field @xmath62 is changed by the rule @xmath63^{(d-1)/2}\varphi _ { \mathrm{r}% } ( x^{\prime } ) . \label{fieldtrans}\]]now by comparing boundary conditions ( [ bc ] ) , ( [ boundrind ] ) and taking into account eq . ( [ fieldtrans ] ) , one obtains the relation between the coefficients in the boundary conditions : @xmath64as it is seen from this relation , the dirichlet boundary condition in the problem on the rw bulk ( @xmath65 ) corresponds to the dirichlet boundary condition in the conformally related problem for the rindler spacetime . for the case of the neumann boundary condition in the rw bulk ( @xmath66 ) the corresponding problem in the rindler spacetime is of the robin type with @xmath67 . as before , we shall present the corresponding components in coordinates @xmath68 in the form of the sum of purely rw and boundary parts : @xmath69 |0_{\mathrm{rw% } } \rangle = \langle \tilde{0}_{\mathrm{rw}}|t_{i}^{k}\left [ g_{lm},\varphi % \right ] |\tilde{0}_{\mathrm{rw}}\rangle + \langle t_{i}^{k}\rangle ^{\mathrm{% ( b)}}. \label{tikds1}\]]by using the relations ( [ a21 ] ) for the purely rw part one finds ( for the vacuum polarization in rw spacetimes see @xcite and references therein ) @xmath70 |% \tilde{0}_{\mathrm{rw}}\rangle = \frac{2a_{d}[a(\eta ) ] ^{-d-1}}{(4\pi ) ^{d/2}\gamma ( d/2)}\mathrm{diag}\left ( -1,1/d,\ldots , 1/d\right ) + \langle t_{i}^{k}\left [ g_{lm},\varphi \right ] \rangle ^{\mathrm{(an)}}. \label{tik0dsst}\]]in particular , for @xmath7 we have @xcite@xmath71 \rangle ^{\mathrm{(an)}}=% \frac{^{(3)}h_{i}^{k}-^{(1)}h_{i}^{k}/6}{2880\pi ^{2 } } , \label{tikan}\]]where the expressions for the tensors @xmath72 are given in birrell . now it can be easily checked that for the static case , @xmath73 , one has @xmath74 |\tilde{0}_{\mathrm{rw}}\rangle = 0 $ ] . in the special case of the power - law expansion , @xmath75 , with @xmath76 being the synchronous time coordinate , we find@xmath70 |% \tilde{0}_{\mathrm{rw}}\rangle = \frac{c(c^{2}-6c+3)\left ( 3c-4\right ) } { % 2880\pi ^{2}t^{4}}\mathrm{diag}(\frac{3c}{3c-4},1,1,1 ) . \label{tikrwd3}\]]the corresponding energy density is negative for @xmath77 . for the boundary induced energy - momentum tensor in coordinates @xmath57 the spatial part is not isotropic and the corresponding part in coordinates @xmath68 is more complicated ( no summation over @xmath42 ) : @xmath78^{d+1}\langle t_{% \mathrm{(r)}l}^{l}\rangle ^{\mathrm{(b)}},\;l=0,3,\ldots , d , \notag \\ \langle t_{l}^{l}\rangle ^{\mathrm{(b ) } } & = & [ \xi /a(\eta ) ] ^{d+1}\left [ \langle t_{\mathrm{(r)}l}^{l}\rangle ^{\mathrm{(b)}}+(-1)^{l}\omega ^{2}\sin ^{2}\theta ( \langle t_{\mathrm{(r)}1}^{1}\rangle ^{\mathrm{(b)}}-\langle t_{% \mathrm{(r)}2}^{2}\rangle ^{\mathrm{(b)}})\right ] , \;l=1,2 , \label{tik0dsstb } \\ \langle t_{1}^{2}\rangle ^{\mathrm{(b ) } } & = & [ \xi /a(\eta ) ] ^{d+1}\omega ^{2}\sin \theta \frac{\cos \theta -r\gamma } { r}(\langle t_{\mathrm{(r)}% 2}^{2}\rangle ^{\mathrm{(b)}}-\langle t_{\mathrm{(r)}1}^{1}\rangle ^{\mathrm{% ( b ) } } ) . \notag\end{aligned}\]]as we see the resulting energy - momentum tensor is non - diagonal . note that for the case of the power - law expansion the ratio of the boundary induced and boundary free parts at a given spatial point behaves as @xmath79 in the model with @xmath7 . hence , at early stages of the cosmological expansion the boundary induced part dominates for @xmath80 . in figure [ fig1 ] we have plotted the boundary induced parts in the vacuum energy density ( @xmath81 ) and @xmath82-stress ( @xmath83 ) as functions of the ratio @xmath84 for @xmath7 scalar field with dirichlet boundary condition . the corresponding energy density is positive in the region @xmath85 and negative for @xmath86 . in the case of robin condition the energy density can be either negative or positive in dependence of the coefficient in the boundary condition . the electromagnetic field is conformally invariant in @xmath7 . the vacuum expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor induced by the presence of conducting plate moving with uniform acceleration through the fulling rindler vacuum is investigated in refs . we will assume that the plate is a perfect conductor with the standard boundary conditions of vanishing of the normal component of the magnetic field and the tangential components of the electric field , evaluated at the local inertial frame in which the conductor is instantaneously at rest . as in the case of a scalar field , the expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor is presented in the form ( [ tikr ] ) , where the boundary free part is given by the formula@xmath36|\tilde{0}_{\mathrm{r}}\rangle = \frac{11}{240\pi ^{2}\xi ^{4}}% \mathrm{diag}\left ( -1,1/3,1/3,1/3\right ) . \label{tikrel}\]]in the region @xmath86 for the boundary induced part one has the expression @xcite @xmath87 f_{\mathrm{em}}^{(i)}[k_{\omega } ( x\xi /b ) ] , \label{tikbel}\]]with the notations@xmath88 & = & ( -1)^{i}g^{\prime 2}(z)+[1-(-1)^{i}\omega ^{2}/z^{2}]g^{2}(z),\;i=0,1 , \notag \\ f_{\mathrm{em}}^{(2)}[g(z ) ] & = & f_{\mathrm{em}}^{(3)}[g(z)]=-g^{2}(z ) . \label{fiem}\end{aligned}\]]the corresponding formula in the region @xmath85 is obtained from ( tikbel ) by the replacements @xmath56 . by taking into account that @xmath89^{\prime } < 0 $ ] , we see that @xmath90 for @xmath91 and @xmath92 for @xmath93 . for the perpendicular stress one has @xmath94 in both regions . the boundary induced energy density is positive / negative in the region @xmath85/@xmath86 . the vacuum expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor in the rw bulk is presented in the form ( [ tikds1 ] ) , where the boundary free part is given by the expression@xmath70 |% \tilde{0}_{\mathrm{rw}}\rangle = \frac{11a^{-4}(\eta ) } { 240\pi ^{2}}\mathrm{% diag}\left ( -1,1/3,1/3,1/3\right ) + \frac{62^{(3)}h_{i}^{k}+3^{(1)}h_{i}^{k}}{% 2880\pi ^{2}}. \label{tikelfree}\]]as in the case for a scalar field , this expectation value vanishes for the static rw spacetime . for the power - law expansion , @xmath75 , from ( [ tikelfree ] ) we find@xmath95 |% \tilde{0}_{\mathrm{rw}}\rangle & = & \frac{c(31c^{2}+54c-27)(3c-4)}{1440\pi ^{2}t^{4}}\mathrm{diag}(\frac{3c}{3c-4},1,1,1 ) \notag \\ & & -\frac{c(c-2)}{18\pi ^{2}a^{2}(t)t^{2}}\mathrm{diag}(\frac{3c}{c-2},1,1,1 ) . \label{tikrw3del}\end{aligned}\]]for @xmath96 the second term on the right of this formula dominates at late stages of the cosmological expansion and the corresponding energy density is negative . for the boundary induced part we have formulae ( [ tik0dsstb ] ) with @xmath7 and with @xmath97 given by ( [ tikbel ] ) for the region @xmath86 . for points near the boundary the leading terms in the asymptotic expansions for the components of the energy - momentum tensor have the form@xmath98 in the asymptotic term for the off - diagonal component @xmath99 and @xmath100 are related by ( [ boundeq ] ) . near the boundary the total energy - momentum tensor is dominated by the boundary - induced part . in the limit @xmath101 we have the following asymptotic formulae ( no summation over @xmath42)@xmath102this limit corresponds to large values of the coordinate @xmath99 with the relation @xmath103^{-1}$ ] . now we turn to the limit @xmath104 . in terms of the coordinates @xmath105 and @xmath100 , this limit corresponds to large values of @xmath99 and small values of @xmath100 with @xmath106 . to the leading order for the boundary induced part we have@xmath107 in this limit the total energy - momentum tensor is dominated by the boundary free part ( [ tikelfree ] ) . in the investigations of the casimir effect the calculation of the local densities of the vacuum characteristics is of special interest . in particular , these include the vacuum expectation value of the energy momentum tensor . in addition to describing the physical structure of the quantum field at a given point , the energy momentum tensor acts as the source of gravity in the einstein equations . it therefore plays an important role in modelling a self - consistent dynamics involving the gravitational field . in the present paper we have investigated the vacuum expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor for scalar and electromagnetic fields induced by the boundary , defined by eq . ( [ boundeq ] ) , on background of rw spacetime with negative spatial curvature . for a scalar field the robin boundary condition is imposed and for the electromagnetic field we have assumed that the boundary is a perfect conductor . in order to obtain the vacuum expectation values we have used the corresponding results for a plate moving with constant proper acceleration through the fulling rindler vacuum and the conformal relation between the @xmath0 rw and rindler spacetimes . for the general case of the scale factor we have presented the vacuum energy - momentum tensor as the sum of the boundary free and boundary induced parts . the boundary free parts are given by the standard formulae ( tik0dsst ) , ( [ tikan ] ) for a scalar field and by ( [ tikelfree ] ) for the electromagnetic field . in the special case of the power - law scale factor the corresponding expressions take the forms ( [ tikrwd3 ] ) and ( tikrw3del ) , respectively . the boundary induced part in the vacuum expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor is non - diagonal and is given by the expressions ( [ tik0dsstb ] ) with @xmath35 defined by formulae ( [ tikrb ] ) and ( tikbel ) for scalar and electromagnetic fields in the region @xmath86 . the corresponding formulae for the region @xmath85 are obtained by the replacements @xmath56 . in the case of the electromagnetic field the boundary induced energy density is positive ( negative ) in the region @xmath85 ( @xmath86 ) . for the power - law expansion with @xmath108 , @xmath80 , at a given spatial point the ratio of the boundary induced and boundary free parts in the vacuum energy - momentum tensor behaves as @xmath79 in the model with @xmath7 and at early stages of the cosmological expansion the boundary induced part dominates . a.a.s . was supported by the armenian ministry of education and science grant no . 119 . g. esposito , g. m. napolitano , l. rosa , phys . d * 77 * , 105011 ( 2008 ) ; g. bimonte , g. esposito , l. rosa , phys . rev . d * 78 * , 024010 ( 2008 ) ; g. m. napolitano , g. esposito , l. rosa , phys . rev . d * 78 * , 107701 ( 2008 ) .

for scalar and electromagnetic fields we evaluate the vacuum expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor induced by a curved boundary in the robertson walker spacetime with negative spatial curvature . in order to generate the vacuum densities we use the conformal relation between the robertson walker and rindler spacetimes and the corresponding results for a plate moving by uniform proper acceleration through the fulling rindler vacuum . for the general case of the scale factor the vacuum energy - momentum tensor is presented as the sum of the boundary free and boundary induced parts .

astro-ph9602156

polarimetry of sn 1987a was obtained from 2262 days after explosion ( jeffery 1991a , and references therein ) . several groups ( jeffery 1991b ; hflich 1991 ) modelled the observations in terms of scattering by the supernova atmosphere ( sutherland & shapiro 1982 ; mccall 1984 ) . the degree of polarization predicted by these models is generally a decreasing function of time after explosion , as can be anticipated from the fact that the atmosphere gets progressively optically thin as the supernova atmosphere expands . eventually electron scattering becomes unimportant and no polarization can be produced . these models are capable of reproducing the observations prior to day 100 after explosion ( hflich 1991 ; jeffery 1991b ) . the observed degree of polarization , however , increased sharply from 0.2% to about 1.6% at around day 100 ( jeffery 1991a ; barret 1988 ) . this behavior is difficult to reconcile in terms of the photospheric scattering model . correction for interstellar polarization ( isp ) is crucial , but is unfortunately quite uncertain . we base our study on the polarimetric data compiled and corrected for isp by jeffery ( 1991a ) , where the isp is estimated from unpublished observations made at la plata observatory at around day 600 . the data show that the degree of polarization increased from about 0.1% at day 2 to about 1% at @xmath0 day 250 . the polarization position angle remains fairly constant during all these observations . the time variability of the polarization indicates that the observed polarization is intrinsically related to the supernova event , regardless of the isp in the direction to the supernova . we show here that dust scattering plays an important role in producing the polarized light of sn 1987a . in 2.1 the survival of dust particles in the vicinity of the supernova is discussed . the dust scattering process and how that leads to the observed polarization is presented in 2.2 . 3 compares the model with various observations . conclusions and a brief discussion are given in 4 . the dust particles in the vicinity of the supernova are destroyed mainly by the intense initial ultraviolet ( uv ) flash of the supernova after the shock breakout . lundqvist & fransson ( 1991 ) , and luo ( 1991 ) inferred that an initial uv flash with net energy @xmath1 ergs and effective temperatures @xmath2k is required to fit the observed light curves of the various nebular emission lines of the circumstellar loops . the luminosities and radiation temperatures they used were taken from models 10h and 10l of woosley ( 1988 ) , and 11e1y6 of shigeyama , nomoto & hashimoto ( 1988 ) . these models and also those by arnett ( 1988 ) give peak luminosities of @xmath3and peak effective temperatures of @xmath4 k. more detailed models by ensman & burrows ( 1992 ) give peak luminosities @xmath5 and @xmath6 k. the distance at which the dust achieves equilibrium temperature @xmath7 is @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the effective temperature of the supernova radiation , @xmath10 is the dust absorption efficiency averaged over wavelength and is a function of the effective temperature @xmath11 of the radiation field , and @xmath12 is the luminosity . evaporation of dust particles occurs when @xmath7 is above the evaporation temperature which is typically around 2000 k. as felten & dwek ( 1989 ) noticed , however , the evaporation / sublimation time scale may be _ longer _ than the duration of the uv flash , and hence , dust can survive at a substantially smaller distance from the progenitor than given in equation ( 1 ) . the time scale for dust evaporation at a temperature @xmath7 , is ( voit 1992 ; guhathakurta & draine , 1989 ) @xmath13 , \eqno(2)\ ] ] where @xmath14 is the binding energy of the dust particles , and @xmath15 is the radius of the dust particle . guhathakurta & drain ( 1989 ) give @xmath16 k for graphite and @xmath17 k for silicate . at @xmath18 k , @xmath19 is @xmath20 s , considerably larger than the duration of the uv flash which is @xmath21 s. only grains heated up to a temperature at which the corresponding evaporation time is shorter than the duration of the uv flash will evaporate . the real temperature above which the dust particles will be destroyed is therefore given by equating @xmath22 and @xmath23 . the radius beyond which the dust particles will survive as a function of the size of the dust particle is plotted in fig . 1 for different models of the supernova explosions . this defines theoretically the minimum distance dust particles can survive the initial uv flash . we define first a polar coordinate system of which the z - axis is along the line of sight and the x - axis is on the plane of sky and defines the zero point of the polarization position angle . the supernova is located at the origin . the number density of csm dust is given by @xmath24 . the scattered light depends sensitively on the shape of the supernova light curve . consider first the case for which the supernova emits natural light at a luminosity per unit frequency @xmath25 over a time @xmath26 . assuming single scattering and @xmath27 , the flux of the scattered light @xmath28 is derived by chevalier ( 1986 ) . the stokes parameters @xmath29 and @xmath30 can be found in a similar and straight forward way . the equations are @xmath31 where the integration is over the plane of the sky , @xmath32 is the grain scattering efficiency , @xmath33 is the geometric cross section of the grain , @xmath34 is the distance to the supernova , and @xmath35 and @xmath36 are elements of the dust scattering matrix ( chandrasekhar 1960 ) as a function of @xmath37 . the scattering phase function @xmath35 can be found in henvey & greenstein ( 1941 ) , and the polarization function @xmath36 approximates the rayleigh function ( white 1979 ) . for the more general case that the supernova light curve is given by @xmath38 , the fluxes and stokes parameters can be obtained by convolving @xmath38 with @xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath41 ( cf chevalier , 1986 ) . scattered light contributes also to the observed luminosity , but is only a second order effect in the optically thin case . the net polarization of the supernova is therefore calculated by multiplying the polarization of the scattered light by the ratio of the scattered light to the luminosity of the supernova . our most favored model is achieved by a dust blob of radius 1.2 @xmath42 cm located on the plane of the sky passing through the supernova , at a distance 5.7 @xmath42 cm away from the supernova and a position angle of @xmath43 . the parameters governing dust scattering are : albedo @xmath44 , and peak linear polarization @xmath45 . the optical depth of the blob is 0.36 . in the following this model is compared with observations . we show in fig . 2(a ) the v band polarimetry together with the polarimetry curve calculated using equation ( 3 ) . the v - band light curve is from hamuy & suntzeff ( 1990 ) . the polarimetry data are from jeffery ( 1991a ) . the degree of polarization scales linearly in the adopted optically thin approximation , and satisfactory fits were obtained for @xmath46 , depending sensitively on the distance to the supernova . the dust scattering asymmetry parameter is @xmath47 = 0.3 ( henvey & greenstein 1941 ) . the overall shape of the time evolution of the polarization is well reproduced . the increase of polarization before day 30 is due to the increase of the flux of the highly polarized scattered light as a result of light travel effects . the model predicts an increase at around day 100 when the supernova evolves down from its second optical maximum . this behavior is again due to the fact that the fraction of scattered light increases as the supernova falls below its maximum . the broad spectral features in the polarization spectra which correspond to various absorption and emission lines of the supernova were taken as evidences againest circumstellar scattering . we show here that this is incorrect . the observed polarization depends on both the intrinsic supernova light curve and the scattering process in a complicated way as shown in equations ( 3 ) . because the luminosities at different wavelengths evolve differently , the net polarization at different wavelengths will also be different , especially across strong p - cygni lines . it can be anticipated that broad polarized spectral features can be produced . and indeed , as an example , fig . 2(b ) shows the model polarization spectra on day 100 obtained by using the set of spectroscopic observations of sn 1987a from the ctio archive ( phillips et al . the model polarization spectrum agrees well with the polarization spectra corrected for isp by jeffery ( 1991a ) , considering the fact that the polarization spectra depends sensitively on the corrections for isp . the dust particles responsible for the scattering and polarization emit also in the infrared . the infrared light curve is calculated by assuming @xmath48 for the dust scattering phase function . 3 shows the model results together with the luminosity of the ir component obtained by fitting two black bodies to the early photometric observations ( bouchet et al . although bouchet et al . ( 1989 ) argue that the infrared emissions may come from free free emission of the supernova ejecta , the present model correctly fits the light curve of the infrared emission , in particular the time delay of its maximum compared with the observed light curve . note that the temperature of the dust particles varies with the distance to the supernova , so their emission can not be exactly that of a black body . a self - consistent analysis requires detailed modeling of the dust emission and the early observations which is beyond the scope of this paper . it is encouraging that such a simple analysis already yields surprisingly satisfactory model fits . the polarimetry of sn 1987a can be modeled in terms of scattering by a dusty blob . both the polarimetry curve and the early infrared light curve can be successfully fitted by a csm dust scattering blob . this analysis is , however , far from complete . substantial improvements can be achieved by more detailed modeling . in particular , the polarization position angle also shows clear changes across spectral lines . this suggests that a single scattering blob can not account for all the observed polarization . two or more blobs may improve the model . another possibility is that the observed polarization is a combination of the atmospheric scattering model and the csm dust scattering model presented here . the hypothesized dust blob may be related with the mystery spot discovered in earlier speckle observations ( cropper et al . they are located at almost identical position angles of @xmath49 . further analysis may provide some interesting tests for the authenticity of the speckle sources ( nisenson et al . 1988 ; meikle et al . 1987 ) . our recent observations show that polarization @xmath50 may be a common phenomena in type ii supernovae ( wang et al . a correct picture for the origin of the polarization is therefore critical for the understanding of supernova explosion mechanisms in general , and also in establishing type ii supernovae as extra galactic distance indicators using the expanding photosphere method . if dust scattering is really important in producing polarization , the present study suggests that type ii supernovae are more likely to be associated with csm dust than type ia . it is especially likely that dust scattering plays a role in sn 1993j which was strongly polarized and has a substantial csm . polarization measurement can thus set strong constraint on the enviroment of supernovae ( wang & wheeler 1996 ) . arnett , w.d . 1988 , apj 331 , 377 barret , p. 1988 , mnras , 234 , 937 bode , m. f. , & evans , a. 1980 , mnras , 193 , 21p bouchet , p. , moneti , a. , slezak , t. le , & manfroid , j. 1989 , a&as , 80 , 379 chandrasekhar , s. 1950 , radiative transfer ( oxford university press ) chevalier , r. a. 1986 , apj , 308 , 225 draine , b. , & lee , h. m. 1984 , apj , 285 , 89 dwek , e. 1983 , apj , 274 , 175 ensman , l. , & burrows , a. 1992 , apj , 393 , 742 felten , j. e. , & dwek , e. 1989 , apj , 340 , 943 guhathakurta , p. & draine , b. t. 1989 , apj , 345 , 230 hamuy , m. , & suntzeff , n. b. 1990 , aj , 99 , 1146 henvey , l. g. , & greenstein , j. l. 1941 , apj , 93 , 70 hfflich , p. 1991 , a&a , 246 , 481 jeffery , d. j. 1991a , apjs , 77 , 405 jeffery , d. j. 1991b , apj , 375 , 264 lundqvist , p. , & fransson , c. 1991 , apj , 380 , 575 luo , d. 1991 , ph.d . thesis , univ . colorado , boulder mccall , m. l. 1984 , mnras , 210 , 829 meikle , w. p. s. , matcher , s. j. , & morgan , b. l. 1987 nat , 329 , 608 nisenson , p. , papaliolios , c. , karovska , m. , & noyes , r. 1987 , apj , 320 , l15 phillips , m. m. , heathecote , s. r. , hamuy , m. , & navarrete , m. 1988 , aj , 95 , 1087 shapiro , p. r. , & sutherland , p. g. 1982 , apj , 263 , 902 shigeyama , t. , nomoto , k. , & hashimoto , m. 1988 , a&a , 196 , 141 voit , g. m. 1992 , apj , 399 , 495 wang , l. , & wheeler , j. c. , li , z. w. , & clocchiatti , a. 1996 , apj , in press wang , l. , & wheeler , j. c. 1996 , in preparation white , r. l. 1979 , apj , 229 , 954 woosley , s.e . 1988 , apj , 330 , 218 * figure captions * + * fig . 1 * dust survival radius for different supernova explosion models . the luminosities ( in units of @xmath51 erg / sec ) and durations ( in seconds ) of the out - burst were approximated as : 5 , 20 ( 500full1 ) , 2.3 , 200 ( 11e1y6 ) , and 0.35 , 2400 ( 10h ) , respectively . the effective temperature of the out - burst was taken as 5.0@xmath52 k for all of the models . the dust absorption coefficients were taken from draine & lee ( 1984 ) . + * fig . 2 * ( a ) v band polarimetry of sn 1987a ; ( b ) polarization spectrum at day 100 . + 3 * early infrared observations . the bolometric luminosity was scaled down by a factor of 10 for clarity .

the conventional picture for the origin of the polarization of a supernova is based on a model of thomson or resonance scattering of photons traveling through an aspherical supernova atmosphere . positive detection of intrinsic polarization in sn 1987a is then interpretated as evidence of an asymmetrical supernova atmosphere . we show here a different view based on the scattering of the supernova light by a dusty circumstellar material ( csm ) , or the `` light echo '' effect . at a given epoch after the explosion , the observed photons consist of both those propagating directly from the supernova and those scattered by dust particles in the csm . polarized light can be produced if the distribution of the dust particles is aspherical . the model can reproduce both the time evolution of the observed broad band polarization of sn 1987a and major features of the polarization spectra . it is also successful in providing a natural model for the early infrared light curve , in particular the observed 30 day delay of the ir maximum compared to the maximum of the bolometric light curve . 1f(^,^ ) plus 2pt

astro-ph0406185

two types of galaxies account for the vast majority of star formation at @xmath2 : the lyman break galaxies ( lbgs ; steidel et al . 1996 , 2003 ) , and the ultra / hyperluminous infrared galaxies detected at submillimeter and millimeter wavelengths ( blain et al . 2002 and references therein ; bertoldi et al . as both selections identify strong star formation , it is tempting to assume they are sampling a common population . however , current observations do not show a large overlap between the two samples . only a small percentage of lbgs are detected with scuba , even though their high star formation rates predict they should be far - infrared ( fir ) luminous ( chapman et al . 2000 ; peacock et al . the reverse is true as well the majority of ultraluminous infrared sources ( ulirgs ; @xmath3 ) are so highly extincted that they would be missed in rest - frame uv - selected surveys for high redshift galaxies like the lbgs ( meurer et al . 1999 ; goldader et al . this difference may imply that the two methods select galaxies at different stages of evolution , or with intrinsically different physical characteristics . the spitzer space telescope gives us the first opportunity to study both populations across a wide range of mid - infrared ( mir ) wavelengths . recently , six extremely bright lbgs were discovered in sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) spectra ( bentz , osmer , & weinberg 2004 ; hereafter bow ) . the spectra of the six sources are typical of lbgs , with bright rest - frame uv continua and clearly detected stellar and interstellar absorption lines . they appear 2 - 3 magnitudes brighter than the most luminous lbgs in the steidel et al . sample . none of the six show spectral features that would be expected for agn , such as broad or high ionization emission lines . bow find no morphological or environmental indicators which suggest lensing . by contrast , the only comparably bright known lbg is ms1512-cb58 ( yee et al . 1996 ; hereafter cb58 ) ; it is strongly lensed by a dense foreground cluster ( seitz et al . 1998 ) , and has an obvious arclike shape which is discernible from the ground . in this paper , we present the first spitzer detection of an lbg at 16 with the spitzer infrared spectrograph ( irs ; houck et al . 2004 ) `` blue '' peak up filter which is centered at 16 . `` blue '' peak up array . one of the sdss lbgs , j134026.44 + 634433.2 ( hereafter s - lbg-1 ) , was selected as a science verification target for spitzer . the object has a spectroscopic redshift of z=2.79 . throughout the paper , we will adopt a flat , @xmath4-dominated universe ( @xmath5 km s@xmath6 mpc@xmath6 , @xmath7 ) . we obtained 16 imaging of s - lbg-1 on 14 november 2003 with the irs onboard the spitzer space telescope . between exposures , we moved the telescope in a four point dither pattern , with separations of 4 . at each point in the pattern , two nod positions were observed , and two cycles were taken at each nod position . a total of 16 exposures were taken , with integration times of one minute each . the data were reduced using the irs pipeline at the spitzer science center ( see chapter 7 of the spitzer observer s manual ) . individual frames were registered based on the reconstructed pointing ( accurate to better than 1 ) and refined with centroiding of objects . bad pixels were masked before mosaicing . we have not removed the small ( @xmath8% ) geometric distortion in the images . we have several times redundancy for each pixel on the sky , and we remove faint latent images caused by bright sources in pu observations prior to our program . photometric calibration utilized routine observations of a bright standard . we measured the flux in 16 images of hd 46190 to calculate the zeropoint by comparison with template spectra based on normalized kurucz ( 1993 ) models ( cohen et al . a curve of growth was used to estimate total flux for a point source from aperture photometry . we also obtained supporting near - infrared ( nir ) data in the j- and k - bands with the wirc instrument ( wilson et al . 2003 ) on the hale 200-inch telescope . the observations were taken on 27 january 2004 . the field was observed for five dithered exposures in each filter . j - band exposures were two coadds of one minute each , and k - band were two coadds of 30 seconds each . the night was not photometric , but conditions were stable over the few minutes of the observations . the wirc field of view contains @xmath9 2mass stars , which we used to calibrate the photometry and estimate the extinction . the final , registered 16 image ( figure 1 ) has an rms noise of 15 @xmath10jy in an aperture with 5 radius , and 25 @xmath10jy in an aperture of 9 radius . s - lbg-1 is detected , with a flux of @xmath1 mjy . seven other objects are detected ( @xmath11 or more ) in the field , one of which is very bright in the mir and quite faint at optical wavelengths . of these , two have no counterpart in the sdss or wirc imaging . five additional sources are marginally detected ( @xmath12 ) , without optical counterparts . however , given the faintness of these sources it is not surprising that deeper optical / nir data will be needed to identify them . the reddest object , j134025.02 + 634358.3 ( hereafter red-1 ) , is discussed further in section [ sec : ero ] . photometric data from irs and wirc are given in table 1 . the wirc imaging shows no objects in the field that were not detected in sdss . there is no indication that s - lbg-1 is resolved , but it is not expected to be . the 16 imaging is diffraction limited , and the point spread function ( psf ) has a full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of 4 . s - lbg-1 is compact in both the sdss and wirc imaging , which have fwhm of @xmath13 and @xmath14 , respectively . at the redshift of s - lbg-1 , z=2.79 , one arcsecond corresponds to @xmath15 kpc . the 16 filter extends from 13.3 to 18.6 at fwhm , or 3.5 to 4.9 in the rest frame . this wavelength range encompasses br@xmath16 but does not include the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon ( pah ) feature centered at 3.3 ( tokunaga et al . the filter samples the rayleigh - jeans tail of the stellar photospheric continuum emission emission , which can be considerable if the galaxy contains a substantial population of old stars . alternatively , 4 marks the beginning of the rise in emission from warm dust , heated either by very young stars or by an active nucleus . the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) of s - lbg-1 is consistent with a strongly starbursting galaxy ( figure 2 ) . in the figure we show a direct comparison with the spectrum of ngc 5253 ( wu et al . 2002 ) , a `` benchmark starburst '' ( calzetti et al . 1999 ) with regions that have undergone intense star formation in the last 100 myr ( see calzetti et al . 1997 and the reference therein ) , and a substantial older stellar population . it has mir emission from dust heated by massive , young stars ( crowther et al . the sed of s - lbg-1 is redder than ngc 5253 in the uv , but the two match quite well if one magnitude of additional extinction is applied . the rest - frame optical color of s - lbg-1 ( the observed j- and k - band ) is bluer than that of ngc 5253 , perhaps implying a lower fraction of old stars . ellingson et al . ( 1996 ) showed that the optical / nir sed of cb58 could be fit with a recent ( 10 myr ) secondary burst of star - formation added to a large ( 85% by mass ) stellar population with an age of @xmath17 gyr . the young age of the source was later confirmed by uv absorption line studies ( pettini et al . 2002 ) . a marginal detection of cb58 with isocam ( bechtold et al . 1998 ) , at rest - frame 1.8 and 3 , favored a higher percentage of younger stars . taken at face value , the cb58 sed is not consistent with s - lbg-1 unless cb58 rises steeply beyond the rest - frame k - band . the inconsistency could result from a higher dust content in s - lbg-1 and likely a dissimilar spatial distribution of dust , which may not be surprising given the different star formation states of the sources . the intrinsic ( corrected for lensing magnification ) sfr of cb58 is @xmath9 ( teplitz et al . 2000 ) , compared to the @xmath18 in s - lbg-1 ( without correcting for extinction ) . the s - lbg-1 sed is also consistent with a relatively dust - free seyfert galaxy ( figure 2 ) . however , bow see no high excitation lines in the uv . it is also possible that the observed 16 flux of s - lbg-1 indicates a `` buried '' agn that is not seen in the uv . bow discuss the possibility that the s - lbg s are bal qso s , but conclude that they would be unique amongst that class of objects if they were . nonetheless , the luminosity of s - lbg-1 may favor the possibility of agn activity dominating the mir flux . in addition , shorter wavelength spitzer observations of s - lbg-1 are needed to conclusively rule out a very steep mir slope , given the low rest - frame 3 flux of cb58 . laurent et al . ( 2000 ) show that the presence of an agn is revealed in the mir by an excess of emission in the 3 - 6 range . this has been attributed to hot dust emission heated to near sublimation temperatures ( @xmath18 k for silicates and @xmath19 k for graphite ) by the accretion disk . the presence of this continuum has been detected in a number of nearby galaxies hosting an active agn including ngc1068 and ngc4151 ( le floch et al . 2000 , alonso - hererro et al . 2003 ) , as well as centaurus a ( mirabel et al . 1999 ) . however , such excess usually has a positive slope in the 3 - 6 range , making it challenging to identify in distant systems because the old stellar population of the bulge of the galaxy may be missinterpreted as an excess of thermal emission . furthermore , there has been evidence that as the luminosity of dust enshrouded ir galaxies increases beyond @xmath20 , so does the probability that an agn contributes substantially to the heating of the dust ( sanders et al . 1988 ; veilleux , kim , & sanders 1999 ; tran et al . 2001 ) . if the brightest lbgs harbor buried agn , it might indicate that the typical percentage of agn in lbg searches , @xmath21% ( steidel et al . 2002 ) , is underestimated . in that case , the inferred of lbg systems , and thus the large correction to their inferred contribution to the global density of star formation , would be overestimated . the prodigious star formation rates of s - lbg-1 ( @xmath22 ; bow ) implies that it must be generating enough uv radiation to put it in the same luminosity class as ulirgs ( @xmath23 ) and perhaps enough to be comparable to the hyper - lirgs found among the scuba galaxies ( @xmath24 ; blain et al . it is not certain , however , how much of this radiation is absorbed and reradiated by dust . the optical to mid - infrared sed of s - lbg-1 is not consistent with arp 220 , given the latter s high extinction in the uv . however , the sed over our sampled wavelength provides only a tenuous indication of the bolometric luminosity . if the s - lbgs in general are not fundamentally different than ulirgs , then one must ask why is nt their large uv luminosity absorbed and reradiated by dust . lbgs are found to be 5 - 20 times underluminous ( less dusty ) in the ir for their uv slopes ( baker et al . 2001 ; van der werf et al . 2001 ) , while ulirgs are equally overluminous ( goldader et al . one possibility is that they are at a different stage of evolution . star formation in @xmath25 ulirgs is triggered by merger activity ( flores et al . 1999 ) . in such systems , the dust is dynamically mixed throughout and can easily absorb most of the uv radiation emitted from actively star - forming hii regions . if the lbgs have a less homogeneous distribution of dust , more uv radiation may escape . another possibility is that the extreme uv radiation field of the most luminous lbgs heats the dust to higher temperatures than in typical starbursts , suppressing the fir emission relative to the uv ( baker et al . this would have the effect of shifting the peak of the reradiated luminosity closer to the spitzer wavelengths . finally , a significantly lower dust content either the result of extremely low metallicity , or the destruction of grains by the uv radiation field ( as suggested by bow ) would allow greater uv brightness . in the sdss image , bow find no evidence to suggest strong lensing . one might expect that if the lens were highly extincted , it could be detected in the near- or mid - ir . however , we find no evidence of a massive source close in projection to s - lbg-1 that could be identified as a gravitational lens . the 16 psf does not allow us to identify close ( @xmath26 ) companions , but such objects would likely have been seen in the k - band if they were present . the critical radius is a few arcseconds even for a massive elliptical ( blandford & narayan 1992 ; eisenhardt et al . the brightest mir source in the field , red-1 , lies 30 away . red-1 is somewhat unusual in both brightness and color . it has a flux density of 3 mjy at 16 , but is faint in the optical ( @xmath27 ) . the surface density of such sources is quite low . iso observations of the elais field detected @xmath28 sources down to 3 mjy per square degree , or one per @xmath29 pu fields ( la franca et al . down to 1 mjy , the source counts are only ten times higher ( elbaz et al . 1999 and the reference therein ) . few 3 mjy sources are as red as red-1 . la franca et al . find only 18% of 15 sources brighter than 1 mjy have @xmath30 magnitudes fainter than 23 . the morphology of red-1 is hard to quantify . it is faint and has low surface brightness in both the optical and nir . it is detected only at the limit of the wirc and sdss images . it shows no central central concentration and is clearly extended , covering several square arcseconds . the 16 filter samples the @xmath31 pah feature and very small grain continuum emission at @xmath32 and the @xmath33 pah features at @xmath34 . at the higher redshift , red-1 would fall into the hyper - lirg luminosity class , but at @xmath32 it would be only @xmath35 ( chary & elbaz 2001 ) . in addition , the object is not extremely red in r - k as would be expected for a @xmath34 ulirg . we have detected an extremely luminous lyman break galaxy in the first spitzer 16 image of a uv - selected source at high redshift . the mir data point is consistent with the large star formation rate inferred from the uv continuum . the sed confirms that the star formation is likely not extincted enough for the object to be considered a ulirg . we find no evidence for a strong lens in the field . future spitzer observations will be crucial to understanding the connection between vigorously star forming lbgs and ulirgs . deep imaging with irac ( fazio et al . 2004 ) and mips ( rieke et al . 2004 ) will potentially detect moderate luminosities lbgs . the 16 imaging capability of the irs is a powerful additional mode for the study of these objects . the detection of mir emission in s - lbg-1 demonstrates that the brightest lbgs will be observable by irs spectroscopy , allowing more detailed studies of their dust properties . such observations will open a new window onto a class of objects that may be different from the infrared luminous sources that will be more commonly studied with spitzer . we thank l. yan , d. frayer , and j. colbert for helpful suggestions . this work is based in part on observations made with the spitzer space telescope , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under nasa contract 1407 . support for this work was provided by nasa through an award issued by jpl / caltech . bechtold , j. , elston , r. , yee , h. k. c. , ellingson , e. , & cutri , r. m. 1998 , in `` the young universe : galaxy formation and evolution at intermediate and high redshift '' . eds s. dodorico , a. fontana , and e. giallongo . asp conference series ; vol . 146 , p.241

we present the first rest - frame @xmath0 detection of a lyman break galaxy . the data were obtained using the 16 imaging capability of the spitzer infrared spectrograph . the target object , j134026.44 + 634433.2 , is an extremely luminous lyman break galaxy at z=2.79 first identified in sloan digital sky survey spectra ( bentz , osmer , & weinberg 2004 ) . the source is strongly detected with a flux of @xmath1 mjy . combining spitzer and sdss photometry with supporting ground - based j- and k - band data , we show that the spectral energy distribution is consistent with an actively star - forming galaxy . we also detect other objects in the spitzer field of view , including a very red mir source . we find no evidence of a strong lens amongst the mir sources .

astro-ph0201008

in an effort to better constrain the morphology , kinematics , and origin of the warm ionized gas on the outskirts of galaxies we have obtained deep emission - line images of several nearby starburst and active galaxies using the taurus tunable filter ( ttf ) on the 3.9 m anglo - australian and 4.2 m william herschel telescopes ( see veilleux 2001 for more detail ) . in the course of this study , we discovered a remarkable emission - line structure in the early - type spiral galaxy ngc 1482 . this galaxy has so far received relatively little attention in the literature . it is classified as a peculiar sa0/a in the revised 3rd catalogue ( de vaucouleurs et al . 1991 ) based primarily on the presence of a dust lane across the disk of the galaxy . located at a distance of 19.6 mpc ( tully 1988 ) , it is an infrared - bright galaxy with log[l@xmath5/l@xmath6 = 10.5 ( e.g. , soifer et al . 1989 ; sanders , scoville , & soifer 1991 ) , which is rich in molecular gas and dust ( e.g. , sanders et al . 1991 ; young et al . 1995 ; chini et al . 1996 ) and is undergoing vigorous star formation ( e.g. , moshir et al . 1990 ; devereux & hameed 1997 ; thornley et al . 2000 ) . in a recent emission - line imaging survey of early - type spirals , hameed & devereux ( 1999 ) noticed the presence in ngc 1482 of `` filaments and/or chimneys of ionized gas extending perpendicular to the disk . '' the present study expands on the results of hameed & devereux , using deeper emission - line maps at h@xmath1 and [ n ii ] @xmath06583 and complementary long - slit spectra . we find that the [ n ii]/h@xmath1 excitation map of this galaxy is particularly useful at distinguishing between the star - forming disk and the entrained , shock - excited wind material . this excitation signature could be used in the future to more efficiently identify powerful galactic winds in the local and distant universe . ngc 1482 was observed on the night of 2000 december 16 using the `` blue '' taurus tunable filter ( ttf ; bland - hawthorn & jones 1998 ) at the anglo - australian telescope ( aat ) . this instrument was used in the `` charge shuffling / band switching '' mode to maximize sensitivity to faint flux levels . the basic idea is to move charge up and down within the detector at the same time as switching between two discrete wavelengths with the tunable filter . in this way , the on - band image is obtained nearly simultaneously as the off - band ( continuum ) image . for our observations , the charges were moved every minute and the chip was read out after a total integration time of 32 minutes ( i.e. 16 minutes on - band and 16 minutes off - band ) . four sets of observations were obtained of ngc 1482 : two centered on redshifted h@xmath1 for a total on - band integration time of 32 minutes , and two centered on redshifted [ n ii ] @xmath06583 for the same duration . the continuum images for each set of observations were obtained in a straddle mode , where the off - band image is made up of a pair of images that `` straddle '' the on - band image in wavelength ; this greatly improves the accuracy of the continuum removal since it corrects for slopes in the continuum and underlying absorption features ( see also maloney & bland - hawthorn 2001 ) . the wavelength calibration was checked before and after each pair of observations and was found to be stable . the bandpass of the ttf was set to 14.6 throughout the observations . this bandpass was chosen to separate h@xmath1 @xmath06563 emission from [ n ii ] @xmath76548 , 6583 emission , while still producing a monochromatic field of view of several arcminutes , much larger than the total extent of ngc 1482 . phase effects due to the angular fabry - perot interferometer response can therefore be safely ignored in the rest of the discussion . the mitll2a ccd was used for these observations , providing a pixel scale of 0@xmath837 pixel@xmath2 and a field of view of 10@xmath9 @xmath3 10@xmath9 . the observations were obtained under photometric and @xmath10 1@xmath85 seeing conditions . on 2001 september 19 21 , several complementary long - slit spectra were obtained of ngc 1482 . the dual - beam spectrograph ( dbs ) on the mssso 2.3 m telescope was used at the nasmyth f/17.9 focus with the 1200b and 1200r gratings . the ccd was a site 1752 @xmath3 532 @xmath3 15@xmath11 pixel device . at a plate scale 091 pix@xmath2 , a 2 slit gave a resolution of 1.2 fwhm and a wavelength coverage of 4400 5400 and 6100 7050 . on one occasion , the slit was aligned along the minor axis of the galaxy ( p.a . @xmath12 13@xmath13 ; de vaucouleurs et al . 1991 ) passing through the nucleus . in all other cases , the slit was positioned along 103@xmath13 and offset from 0 to @xmath14 16 from the major axis of the galaxy . the exposure times were typically 1200 seconds . figure 1 shows the distribution of the h@xmath1 and [ n ii ] @xmath06583 emission in ngc 1482 . strong h@xmath1 and [ n ii ] emission is detected along the plane of the host galaxy ( p.a . @xmath12 103@xmath15 ) . in addition , an hourglass - shaped structure is seen in both h@xmath1 and [ n ii ] @xmath06583 , extending along the minor axis of the galaxy at least @xmath10 1.5 kpc above and below the galactic plane . this structure is more easily visible in [ n ii ] @xmath06583 than in h@xmath1 . this is particularly apparent in the lower left panel of figure 1 , where we present a [ n ii]/h@xmath1 ratio map of this object . the [ n ii ] @xmath06583/h@xmath1 ratios measured in the disk of the galaxy [ @xmath12 0.3 ( outer disk ) 0.6 ( inner disk ) ] are typical of photoionization by stars in h ii regions , but the ratios in the hourglass structure are 3 7 times larger ( [ n ii ] @xmath06583/h@xmath1 @xmath12 1.0 2.3 ) . this ratio of a collisionally excited line to a recombination line is fundamentally a measure of the relative importance of heating and ionization ( e.g. , osterbrock 1989 ) . [ n ii]/h@xmath1 ratios enhanced relative to h ii regions are often observed in the extraplanar material of normal disk galaxies , including our own ( e.g. , rand , kulkarni , & hester 1990 ; veilleux et al . 1995a ; reynolds , haffner , & tufte 1999 ; hoopes , walterbos , & rand 1999 ; rossa & dettmar 2000 ; collins & rand 2001 ; miller 2002 ) . although photoionization by the hardened and diluted radiation field from ob stars in the disk is partially responsible for these peculiar line ratios ( e.g. , sokolowski 1992 ; bland - hawthorn , freeman , & quinn 1997 ) , a secondary source of ionization or heating is often needed to explain in detail the runs of line ratios in these galaxies ( e.g. , reynolds et al . 1999 ; collins & rand 2001 ; miller 2002 ) . the extreme [ n ii ] @xmath06583/h@xmath1 ratios in the hourglass structure of ngc 1482 also require an additional source of heating . ruling out photoionization by an agn based on the lack of evidence for genuine nuclear activity in ngc 1482 ( e.g. , kewley et al . 2000 ) , the most likely explanation for these unusual line ratios is shock ionization . interaction of an energetic large - scale outflow with the ambient material of a gas - rich host galaxy will cause shock waves with velocities of 100 500 km s@xmath2 . the shocks will produce a strong flux of euv and soft x - ray radiation which may be absorbed in the shock precursor h ii region ( e.g. , dopita & sutherland 1995 ) . arguably one of the best examples known of shock - excited nebulae associated with large - scale galactic winds is the kpc - scale superbubble in the galaxy ngc 3079 ( e.g. , filippenko & sargent 1992 ; veilleux et al . 1994 ; cecil et al . large [ n ii ] @xmath06583/h@xmath1 ratios are observed throughout the bubble , reaching values of @xmath10 3 at the base of the bubble where the widths of the emission lines exceeds 400 km s@xmath2 . h ii region - like line ratios are observed everywhere else in the disk ( veilleux et al . 1995a ) . the kinematics of the line - emitting gas derived from our long - slit spectroscopy of ngc 1482 confirm that the hourglass structure is due to a large - scale galactic wind and that the extreme line ratios are produced through shocks . figure 2 shows the disturbed kinematics in the extraplanar material . line splitting of up to @xmath10 250 km s@xmath2 is detected along the axis of the hourglass structure out to at least 16 ( 1.5 kpc ) above and below the galaxy disk . normal galactic rotation dominates the kinematics of the gas within 5 6 ( @xmath10 500 pc ) from the disk . maximum line splitting often coincides with regions of low emission - line surface brightness . these results can be explained if the extraplanar emission - line material forms a biconical edge - brightened structure which is undergoing outward motion away from the central disk . in this case , the blueshifted ( redshifted ) emission - line component corresponds to the front ( back ) surface of the bicone . the lack of obvious velocity gradient in the centroid of the line emission suggests that the main axis of the bicone lies close to the plane of the sky . the fact that the amplitude of the line splitting does not decrease significantly with distance from the galaxy indicates that the entrained material is not experiencing significant deceleration ( i.e. , it is a blown - out wind ) . the mass involved in this wind can be estimated from the total h@xmath1 emission outside of the disk . defining the wind material as having [ n ii ] @xmath06583/h@xmath1 @xmath16 1 , we get a wind h@xmath1 flux ( luminosity ) of @xmath10 1.7 @xmath3 10@xmath17 erg s@xmath2 @xmath18 ( @xmath10 8.0 @xmath3 10@xmath19 erg s@xmath2 ) with an uncertainty of about @xmath14 25 30% . the [ s ii ] @xmath06731/@xmath06716 line ratios measured from our long - slit spectra indicate that the entrained material has a density @xmath20 @xmath21 . the mass in entrained line - emitting material is therefore @xmath22 3.6 @xmath3 10@xmath23 @xmath24 m@xmath25 where @xmath26 is normalized to 100 @xmath21 ( assuming case b recombination and an effective recombination coefficient for h@xmath1 of 8.6 @xmath3 10@xmath27 @xmath21 s@xmath2 ; osterbrock 1989 ) . a correction for possible dust extinction intrinsic to ngc 1482 will further increase this number ( note that the extinction due to our galaxy , e(b v ) = 0.04 , is negligible ; schlegel et al . a simple kinematic model can be used to estimate a few key wind parameters . the bisymmetric morphology and kinematics of the wind nebula in ngc 1482 suggest that the entrained material lies on the surface of a cylindrically symmetric bicone . if most of the gas motion is tangential to the surface of the bicone and given that the axis of the bicone lies approximately in the plane of the sky , the radial outflow velocity @xmath28 = @xmath29 / ( 2 @xmath30 sin @xmath31 ) , where @xmath29 is the observed maximum line splitting and @xmath31 is the angle between the surface and the main axis of the bicone . taking @xmath29 @xmath12 250 km s@xmath2 and @xmath31 @xmath12 30@xmath13 based on the morphology of the wind ( fig . 1 ) , we get @xmath28 @xmath12 250 km s@xmath2 . given that @xmath29 and @xmath31 are observed to be approximately constant throughout the wind nebula , the total kinetic energy involved in the outflow is @xmath22 2 @xmath3 10@xmath4 @xmath24 ergs . the dynamical timescale of the outflow can be estimated from the outflow velocity and radial extent : @xmath32 years . combining the dynamical timescale and kinetic energy of the outflow , we derive a time - averaged kinetic energy injection rate of @xmath22 1 @xmath3 10@xmath19 @xmath24 ergs s@xmath2 . this can be compared with the energy injection rate from star formation in ngc 1482 of @xmath10 7 @xmath3 10@xmath33 @xmath34 l@xmath35 @xmath12 2 @xmath3 10@xmath33 @xmath36 erg s@xmath2 , where l@xmath37 is the infrared luminosity in units of 10@xmath38 l@xmath25 and @xmath36 is the fraction of the star - forming disk which is contributing to the outflow ( veilleux et al . 1994 , eqn . the broad base of the wind nebula near the galaxy disk ( fig . 1 ) suggests that the source of energy for the wind is distributed over a region of @xmath10 2 kpc , i.e. @xmath36 @xmath12 50% of the total extent of the star - forming ( h@xmath1-emitting ) portion of the disk . the starburst at the base of the wind nebula in ngc 1482 is therefore powerful enough to drive the outflow as long as @xmath39 @xmath22 0.1 @xmath21 . the traditional method of identifying galaxy - scale winds in starburst galaxies is to look for the kinematic signature ( e.g. , line splitting ) of the wind along the minor axis of the host galaxy disk . edge - on disk orientation reduces contamination of the wind emission by the underlying disk material and facilitates the identification . this method is time - consuming since it requires deep spectroscopy of each candidate wind galaxy with spectral resolution of @xmath40 100 km s@xmath2 . line ratio maps like the one shown in figure 1 represent a promising new way to detect galactic winds in starburst galaxies . the line ratio method only requires taking narrow - band images of candidate wind galaxies centered on two ( or more ) key diagnostic emission lines which emphasize the contrast in the excitation properties between the shocked wind material and the star - forming disk of the host galaxy . [ n ii ] @xmath06583/h@xmath1 , [ s ii ] @xmath76716 , 6731/h@xmath1 , and [ o i ] @xmath06300/h@xmath1 are the optical line ratios of choice for @xmath41 galaxies ( these ratios are enhanced in the wind of ngc 1482 ) , while [ o ii ] @xmath03727/h@xmath42 and [ o ii ] @xmath03727/[o iii ] @xmath05007 could be used for objects at larger redshifts . the spatial resolution of these images must be sufficient to distinguish the galaxy disk from the wind material . using ngc 1482 as a template , we find that high-[n ii]/h@xmath1 winds in edge - on starburst galaxies would still be easily detected out to a distance of @xmath10 200 mpc under 1resolution . imagers equipped with adaptive optics systems should be able to extend the range of these searches by an order of magnitude . this method relies on the dominance of shock excitation in the optical line - emitting wind component . surveys of local powerful wind galaxies ( e.g. , heckman , armus , & miley 1990 ; bland - hawthorn 1995 ; veilleux et al . 1995b ; lehnert & heckman 1996 ; veilleux 2001 ) confirm that shocks generally are the dominant source of excitation in the wind material . these shock - dominated wind nebulae present line ratios which are markedly different from the star - forming disks of the host galaxies . the case of the superbubble in ngc 3079 has already been discussed in 3 . at the other end of the excitation spectrum is the wind in m 82 . the [ n ii]/h@xmath1 map of the southern wind lobe of m 82 ( fig . 4 of shopbell & bland - hawthorn 1998 ) presents two distinct fan - like structures with h ii region - like ratios originating from the two bright star - forming regions in the disk of this galaxy . the line ratio technique would not be able to distinguish between line emission from this type of photoionization - dominated wind nebulae and contamination from a star - forming disk seen nearly face - on . blind searches for galactic winds based on the excitation contrast between the disk and wind components would therefore favor the detection of winds in edge - on hosts where the wind component is not projected onto the disk component . this orientation bias would need to be taken into account to get a complete census of starburst - driven wind galaxies . agn - driven winds may also contaminate samples selected from excitation maps if the spatial resolution is not sufficient to separate the active nucleus from the disk material . the authors wish to thank r. b. tully who brought to our attention the peculiar properties of ngc 1482 . we also thank j. bland - hawthorn for help in using the taurus tunable filter and for entertaining discussions . the authors acknowledge partial support of this research by a cottrell scholarship awarded by the research corporation , nasa / ltsa grant nag 56547 , and nsf / career grant ast-9874973 . bland - hawthorn , j. 1995 , pasa , 12 , 190 bland - hawthorn , j. , freeman , k. c. , & quinn , p. j. 1997 , , 490 , 143 bland - hawthorn , j. , & jones , d. h. 1998 , pasa , 15 , 44 cecil , g. , bland - hawthorn , j. , veilleux , s. , & filippenko , a. v. 2001 , , 555 , 338 chini , r. , kruegel , e. , & lemke , r. 1996 , a&as , 118 , 47 collins , j. a. , & rand , r. j. 2001 , , 551 , 57 de vaucouleurs , g. , et al . 1991 , third reference catalogue of bright galaxies ( new york , springer - verlag ) devereux , n. a. , & hameed , s. 1997 , , 113 , 559 dopita , m.a . , & sutherland , r.s . 1995 , , 455 , 468 filippenko , a. v. , & sargent , w. l. w. 1992 , , 103 , 28 hameed , s. , & devereux , n. 1999 , , 118 , 730 heckman , t. m. , armus , l. , & miley , g. k. 1990 , , 74 , 833 hoopes , c. g. , walterbos , r. a. m. , & rand , r. j. 1999 , , 522 , 669 kewley , l. j. , et al . 2000 , apj , 530 , 704 lehnert , m. d. , & heckman , t. m. 1996 , , 462 , 651 maloney , p. r. , & bland - hawthorn , j. 2001 , , 553 , l129 miller , s. t. 2002 , ph . d. thesis , university of maryland moshir , m. , et al . 1990 , the faint source catalog , version 2.0 osterbrock , d. e. 1989 , astrophysics of gaseous nebulae and active galactic nuclei , university science books rand , r. j. , kulkarni , s. r. , & hester , j. j. 1990 , , 351 , l1 reynolds , r. j. , haffner , l. m. , & tufte , s. l. 1999 , , 525 , l21 rossa , j. , & dettmar , r .- j . 2000 , , 359 , 433 sanders , d. b. , scoville , n. z. , & soifer , b. t. 1991 , , 370 , 158 schlegel , d. j. , finkbeiner , d. p. , & davis , m. 1998 , , 500 , 525 shopbell , p. l. , & bland - hawthorn , j. 1998 , , 493 , 129 soifer , b. t. , boehmer , l. , neugebauer , g. , sanders , d. b. 1989 , , 98 , 766 sokolowski , j. 1992 , ph . d. thesis , rice university thornley , m. d. , frster schreiber , n. m. , lutz , d. , genzel , r. , spoon , h. w. w. , & kunze , d. 2000 , , 539 , 641 tully , r. b. 1988 , nearby galaxies catalog ( cambridge : cambridge university press ) veilleux , s. 2001 , `` warm ionized material on the outskirts of nearby galaxes '' , proceedings of the workshop on `` extragalactic gas at low redshift '' held in pasadena in april 2001 , eds . j. mulchaey and j. stocke , in press ( astro - ph/0108184 ) veilleux , s. , bland - hawthorn , j. , & cecil , g. 1995a , , 445 , 152 veilleux , s. , cecil , g. , bland - hawthorn , j. , tully , r. b. , filippenko , a. v. , & sarger , w. l. w. 1994 , , 433 , 48 veilleux , s. , kim , d .- c . , & sanders , d. b. , mazzarella , j. m. , & soifer , b. t. 1995b , , 98 , 171 young , j. s. , et al . 1995 , , 98 , 219

multi - line imaging of the nearby disk galaxy ngc 1482 with the taurus tunable filter ( ttf ) on the anglo - australian telescope reveals a remarkable hourglass - shaped [ n ii ] @xmath06583/h@xmath1 excitation structure suggestive of a galactic wind extending at least 1.5 kpc above and below the disk of the host galaxy . long - slit spectroscopy confirms the existence of a large - scale outflow in this galaxy . the entrained wind material has [ n ii ] @xmath06583/h@xmath1 ratios in excess of unity while the disk material is characterized by h ii region - like line ratios indicative of a starburst . expansion velocities of order 250 km s@xmath2 are detected in the wind material , and a lower limit of 2 @xmath3 10@xmath4 ergs is derived for the kinetic energy of the outflow based on the gas kinematics and the amount of ionized material entrained in the outflow . this is the first time to our knowledge that a galactic wind is discovered using excitation maps . this line ratio technique represents a promising new way to identify wind galaxy candidates before undergoing more time - consuming spectroscopic follow - ups . this method of selection may be particularly useful for samples of galaxies at moderate redshifts .

1207.1936

in the scenario of _ secure network coding _ introduced by cai et al . @xcite , a source node transmits @xmath0 packets from @xmath0 outgoing links to sink nodes through a network that implements network coding @xcite , and each sink node receives @xmath0 packets from @xmath0 incoming links . in the network , there is a wiretapper who observes @xmath1 links . the problem is how to encode a secret message into @xmath0 transmitted packets at the source node , in such a way that the wiretapper obtain no information about the message in the sense of information theoretic security . as shown in @xcite , secure network coding can be seen as a generalization of the wiretap channel ii @xcite or secret sharing schemes based on linear codes @xcite for network coding . hence , in secure network coding , the secrecy is realized by introducing the randomness into @xmath0 transmitted packets as follows . suppose the message is represented by @xmath2 packets @xmath3 @xmath4 . then , the source node encodes @xmath5 together with @xmath6 random packets by linear codes , and generates @xmath0 transmitted packets @xcite . silva et al . @xcite proposed the _ universal secure network coding _ that is based on maximum rank distance ( mrd ) codes @xcite . their scheme was universal in the sense that their scheme guarantees that over _ any _ underlying network code , no information about @xmath7 leaks out even if any @xmath6 links are observed by a wiretapper . as shown in @xcite , their scheme with mrd codes is optimal in terms of security and communication rate . however , there exists some restrictions in universal secure network coding with mrd codes . in their scheme , the network must transport packets of size @xmath8 . the mrd code used in the scheme is defined over an @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is an @xmath11-degree field extension of a field @xmath12 with order @xmath13 . thus , the size of the field @xmath10 increases exponentially with @xmath11 , and the restriction of mrd codes with @xmath8 invokes the large computational cost for encoding and decoding of mrd codes if @xmath0 is large . it is undesirable especially in resource constraint environments . considering secure network coding without such a restriction , ngai et al . @xcite , and later zhang et al . @xcite , investigated the security performance of secure network coding based on general linear codes . they introduced a new parameter of linear codes , called the _ relative network generalized hamming weight _ ( rnghw ) , and revealed that the security performance is expressed in terms of the rnghw . the rnghw depends on the set of coding vectors of the underlying network code . hence , the rnghw is not universal . the aim of this paper is to investigate the security performance of universal secure network coding based on general linear codes , which is always guaranteed over _ any _ underlying network code , even over random network code . this paper defines the universal security performance by the following two criteria . one is called the _ universal equivocation _ @xmath14 that is the minimum uncertainty of the message under observation of @xmath1 links , guaranteed independently of the underlying network code . the other is called the _ universal @xmath15-strong security _ , where @xmath15 is a performance measure such that no part of the secret message is deterministically revealed even if at most @xmath15 links are observed . the paper @xcite proposed a specific construction of the secure network coding that attains the universal @xmath16-strong security , and such a scheme is called universal strongly secure network coding @xcite . namely , the definition of universal @xmath15-strong security given in this paper is a generalization of universal strongly secure network coding considered in @xcite for the number of tapped links . in order to express @xmath14 and @xmath15 in terms of code parameters , this paper introduces two parameters of linear codes , called the _ relative dimension / intersection profile _ ( rdip ) and the _ relative generalized rank weight _ ( rgrw ) . the rgrw is a generalization of the minimum rank distance @xcite of a code . we reveal that @xmath14 and @xmath15 can be expressed in terms of the rdip and the rgrw of the codes . duursma et al . @xcite first observed that the _ relative generalized hamming weight _ @xcite exactly expresses the security performance and the error correction capability of secret sharing . our definitions of rgrw and rdip are motivated by their result @xcite . assume that the attacker is able not only to eavesdrop but also to inject erroneous packets anywhere in the network . also assume that the network may suffer from the rank deficiency of the transfer matrix at a sink node . silva et al.s scheme based on mrd codes @xcite enables to correct such errors and rank deficiency at each sink node , where its error correction capability is guaranteed over any underlying network code , universal . this paper also generalizes their result and reveals that the universal error correction capability of secure network coding based on arbitrary linear codes can be expressed in terms of the rgrw of the codes . the remainder of this paper is organized as follows . presents basic notations , and introduces linear network coding . defines the universal security performance and universal error correction capability of secure network coding over wiretap network . defines the rdip and rgrw of linear codes , and introduces their basic properties . in , the universal security performance is expressed in terms of the rdip and rgrw . the security of existing schemes @xcite is also analyzed as applications of the rdip and rgrw in examples [ ex1 ] and [ ex2 ] . gives the expression of the universal error correction capability in terms of the rgrw , and also analyze the error correction of @xcite by the rgrw in example [ ex3 ] . let @xmath17 be the shannon entropy for a random variable @xmath18 , @xmath19 be the conditional entropy of @xmath18 given @xmath20 , and @xmath21 be the mutual information between @xmath18 and @xmath20 @xcite . we write @xmath22 as the cardinality of a set @xmath23 . the entropy and the mutual information are always computed by using @xmath24 . let @xmath12 stand for a finite field containing @xmath13 elements and @xmath10 be an @xmath11-degree field extension of @xmath25 ( @xmath26 ) . let @xmath27 denote an @xmath0-dimensional row vector space over @xmath12 . similarly , @xmath9 stands for an @xmath0-dimensional row vector space over @xmath10 . unless otherwise stated , we consider subspaces , ranks , dimensions , etc , over the field extension @xmath10 instead of the base field @xmath12 . an @xmath28 $ ] linear code @xmath29 over @xmath9 is a @xmath30-dimensional subspace of @xmath9 . let @xmath31 denote a _ dual code _ of a code @xmath29 . a subspace of a code is called a _ subcode _ for @xmath32 , we denote by @xmath33 a _ subfield subcode _ of @xmath29 over @xmath12 @xcite . observe that @xmath34 means the dimension of @xmath29 as a vector space over @xmath10 whereas @xmath35 is the dimension of @xmath36 over @xmath12 . for a vector @xmath37\in\f_{q^m}^n$ ] and a subspace @xmath38 , we denote @xmath39 $ ] and @xmath40 . define a family of subspaces @xmath41 satisfying @xmath42 by @xmath43 . also define @xmath44 . for a subspace @xmath45 , the followings are equivalent : 1 ) @xmath46 ; 2 ) @xmath47 ( * ? ? ? * lemma 1 ) . as in @xcite , we consider a multicast communication network represented by a directed multigraph with unit capacity links , a single source node , and multiple sink nodes . we assume that _ linear network coding _ @xcite is employed over the network . elements of a column vector space @xmath48 are called _ packets_. assume that each link in the network can carry a single @xmath12-symbol per one time slot , and that each link transports a single packet over @xmath11 time slots without delays , erasures , or errors . the source node produces @xmath0 packets @xmath49 , , @xmath50 and transmits @xmath49 , , @xmath51 on @xmath0 outgoing links over @xmath11 consecutive time slots . define the @xmath52 matrix @xmath53 $ ] . the data flow on any link can be represented as an @xmath12-linear combination of packets @xmath54 . namely , the information transmitted on a link @xmath55 can be denoted as @xmath56 , where @xmath57 is called a _ global coding vector _ ( gcv ) of @xmath55 . suppose that a sink node has @xmath58 incoming links . then , the information received at a sink node can be represented as an @xmath59 matrix @xmath60 , where @xmath61 is the transfer matrix constructed by gathering the gcv s of @xmath58 incoming links . the network code is called _ feasible _ if every transfer matrix to a sink node has rank @xmath0 over @xmath12 . the system is called _ coherent _ if @xmath62 is known to each sink node ; otherwise , called _ this section introduces the wiretap network model with packet errors and the nested coset coding scheme in secure network coding @xcite . then , we define the universal security performance in terms of the _ universal equivocation _ and the _ universal @xmath15-strong security _ on the wiretap network model . we also define the universal error correction capability of secure network coding . from now on , only one sink node is assumed without loss of generality . in addition , we focus on the fundamental case of coherent systems in this paper due to the space constraint . but , as in @xcite , all analysis in this paper can be easily adapted to the case of noncoherent systems . following @xcite , assume that in the setup of , there is a wiretapper who has access to packets transmitted on any @xmath63 links . let @xmath64 be the set of @xmath65 links observed by the wiretapper . then the packets observed by the wiretapper are given by @xmath66 , where rows of @xmath67 are the gcv s associated with the links in @xmath64 . in the scenario @xcite , the source node first regards an @xmath11-dimensional column vector space @xmath48 as @xmath10 , and fix @xmath2 for @xmath68 . let @xmath69 \!\in\ ! \f_{q^m}^l$ ] be the secret message , and assume that @xmath3 are uniformly distributed over @xmath70 and mutually independent . under the wiretapper s observation , the source node wants to transmit @xmath7 without information leakage to the wiretapper . to protect @xmath7 from the wiretapper , the source node encodes @xmath7 to a transmitted vector @xmath71\!\in\!\f_{q^m}^n$ ] of @xmath0 packets by applying the _ nested coset coding scheme @xcite on @xmath7 . in @xcite , its special case is called a _ secret sharing scheme based on linear codes_. [ def : nestedcoding ] let @xmath72 be a linear code over @xmath10 ( @xmath26 ) , and @xmath73 be its subcode with dimension @xmath74 over @xmath10 . let @xmath75 be an arbitrary isomorphism . for a secret message @xmath76 , we choose @xmath18 from a coset @xmath77 uniformly at random and independently of @xmath7 . then , the source node finally transmit @xmath18 over the network coded network . includes the ozarow - wyner coset coding scheme @xcite as a special case with @xmath78 . hence , when we set @xmath78 , this is the secure network coding based on ozarow - wyner coset coding scheme @xcite . corresponding to @xmath18 transmitted from the source node , the sink node receives a vector of @xmath58 packets @xmath79 . here we extend the basic network model described in to incorporate packet errors and rank deficiency of the transfer matrix @xmath80 of the sink node . suppose that at most @xmath81 errors can occur in any of links , causing the corresponding packets to become corrupted . then , as @xcite , @xmath20 can be expressed by @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the @xmath81 error packets , and @xmath84 is the transfer matrix of @xmath85 . we define @xmath86 as the rank deficiency of @xmath62 . in this setup , we want to decode @xmath7 correctly from @xmath20 . if the network is free of errors and the network code used is feasible , @xmath18 can be always reconstructed from @xmath87 as described in . then , the coset @xmath88 , and hence @xmath7 , is uniquely determined from @xmath18 from . the security performance of secure network coding in the above model was measured by the following criterion @xcite . [ def : nonuniversalperformance ] the minimum uncertainty @xmath89 of @xmath7 given @xmath90 for all possible @xmath64 s ( @xmath65 ) in the network is called _ equivocation _ , defined as @xmath91 . as defined in , @xmath89 depends on the underlying network code . in @xcite , @xmath89 for @xmath92 was expressed in terms of the relative network generalized hamming weight ( rnghw ) of @xmath93 and @xmath94 . the rnghw is the value determined according to gcv s of all links in the network . hence , the rnghw can not determine the equivocation over random linear network code @xcite . here , we extend by requiring the independence of the underlying network code , as follows . [ def : universalperformance ] the _ universal equivocation _ @xmath14 is the minimum uncertainty of @xmath7 given @xmath95 for all @xmath96 , defined as @xmath97 as defined in , @xmath14 does not depend on the set of @xmath64 s in the network . silva et al.s universal secure network coding scheme based on mrd codes @xcite achieves @xmath98 in provided @xmath8 . defines the security for the whole components of a message @xmath99 $ ] . here we focus on the security for every part of @xmath7 , and give the following definition . [ def : universalalpha ] let @xmath100 be a tuple for a subset @xmath101 . we say that a secure network coding scheme attains the _ universal @xmath15-strong security _ if we have @xmath102 as @xcite , a scheme with universal @xmath15-strong security does not leak any @xmath103 components of @xmath7 even if at most @xmath104 links are observed by the wiretapper . moreover , this guarantee holds over any underlying network code as @xmath14 . we note that if a scheme achieves the @xmath15-strong security , the universal equivocation @xmath14 for @xmath105 must be @xmath106 as shown in . however , the converse does not always hold . the scheme in @xcite achieves @xmath107 provided @xmath108 by nested coset coding with mrd codes . the universal strongly security in @xcite is a special case of with @xmath109 . in the model described in , the error correction capability of secure network coding , guaranteed over any underlying network code , is defined as follows . a secure network coding scheme is called _ universally @xmath81-error-@xmath110-erasure - correcting _ , if @xmath111 @xmath7 can be uniquely determined from @xmath20 against @xmath81 errors over any underlying network code with at most @xmath110 rank deficiency . silva et al.s scheme ( * ? ? ? * section vi ) is universally @xmath81-error-@xmath110-erasure - correcting when the minimum rank distance @xcite of @xmath93 is greater than @xmath112 . this section introduce the _ relative dimension / intersection profile _ ( rdip ) and the _ relative generalized rank weight _ ( rgrw ) of linear codes . in the following sections , these parameters are used to characterize the universal security performance and the universal error correction capability of secure network coding . we first define the _ relative dimension / intersection profile _ ( rdip ) of linear codes as follows . [ def : rdip ] let @xmath72 be a linear code and @xmath113 be its subcode . then , the @xmath114-th relative dimension / intersection profile ( rdip ) of @xmath93 and @xmath94 is the greatest difference between dimensions over @xmath10 of intersections , defined as @xmath115 for @xmath116 . next , we define the _ relative generalized rank weight _ ( rgrw ) of linear codes as follows . [ def : rgrw ] let @xmath72 be a linear code and @xmath113 be its subcode . then , the @xmath114-th relative generalized rank weight ( rgrw ) of @xmath93 and @xmath94 is defined by @xmath117 for @xmath118 . the relative dimension / length profile and the relative generalized hamming weight introduced in @xcite are equivalent to and ( [ eq : defrgrw ] ) with @xmath119 and @xmath120 replaced by suitable smaller sets , respectively . this subsection introduces some basic properties of the rdip and the rgrw , and also shows the relation between the rgrw and the rank distance @xcite . these will be used for expressions of the universal security performance and the universal error correction capability of secure network coding . first , we introduce the following theorem and lemma about the rdip and the rgrw . [ thm : monotonerdip ] let @xmath72 be a linear code and @xmath73 be its subcode . then , the @xmath114-th rdip @xmath121 is nondecreasing with @xmath114 from @xmath122 to @xmath123 , and @xmath124 holds . @xmath122 and @xmath123 , are obvious from . recall that @xmath125 for @xmath126 from ( * ? ? ? * lemma 1 ) . this implies that for any subspace @xmath127 , there always exist some @xmath128 s satisfying @xmath129 and @xmath130 . this yields @xmath131 . next we show that the increment at each step is at most @xmath132 . consider arbitrary subspaces @xmath133 such that @xmath134 and @xmath135 . let @xmath136 ; @xmath137 . since @xmath138 and @xmath73 , we have @xmath139 and hence @xmath140 . [ lma : rgrw ] let @xmath72 be a linear code and @xmath73 be its subcode . then , the @xmath114-th rgrw @xmath141 is strictly increasing with @xmath114 . moreover , @xmath142 and @xmath143 where @xmath144 . first we have @xmath145 from , we have @xmath146 . we thus have @xmath147 therefore the rgrw is strictly increasing with @xmath114 and thus @xmath148 is established . next , we show the relation between the rank distance @xcite and the rgrw . let @xmath149 be an @xmath12-linear isomorphism that expands an element of @xmath10 as a column vector over @xmath12 with respect to some fixed basis for @xmath10 over @xmath12 . then , we define the _ rank over @xmath12 _ of a vector @xmath150 \in \f_{q^m}^n$ ] , denoted by @xmath151 , as the rank of @xmath52 matrix @xmath152 $ ] over @xmath12 . the rank distance @xcite between two vectors @xmath153 is given by @xmath154 . the minimum rank distance @xcite of a code @xmath29 is given as @xmath155 . for a subspace @xmath41 , we define by @xmath156 the sum of subspaces @xmath157 . [ lma : xxxx ] for a subspace @xmath38 with @xmath158 , we have @xmath159 . let @xmath160 \!\in\ ! v$ ] be a nonzero vector , which implies @xmath161 . let @xmath162_{i , j=1}^{m , n } \!\in\ ! \f_{q^m}^{m \times n}$ ] , @xmath163 . each vector in @xmath164 is represented by an @xmath10-linear combination of @xmath165 , and hence @xmath166 . for @xmath167 , @xmath168 , we have @xmath169 . this implies that there always exists some @xmath170 with @xmath171 satisfying @xmath172 \!\in\ ! \f_{q^m}^n , g_j \!\neq\ ! 0 , \label{eq : transform}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath173 are linearly independent over @xmath12 , and note that @xmath174 represents the elementary column operation on @xmath175 $ ] . also for @xmath176 , @xmath177 , we have @xmath178 ( @xmath179 ) . hence , for @xmath170 satisfying , we also have @xmath180 \!\in\ ! \f_{q^m}^n$ ] for all @xmath181 . thus , by the elementary column operation on @xmath182 over @xmath12 , represented by @xmath174 , we get @xmath183 . by eliminating zero columns from @xmath183 , we obtain a matrix @xmath184_{i , j=1}^{m , d_r(v)}$ ] , @xmath185 , where @xmath186 . let @xmath187 @xmath188 be the submatrix consisting of the first @xmath30 rows of @xmath189 . since @xmath190 and @xmath173 are linearly independent , @xmath191 is the generator matrix of @xmath192 $ ] gabidulin code and @xmath193 @xcite . thus , @xmath194 is nonsingular , and hence we have @xmath195 . therefore , @xmath196 . [ lma : rankdistance ] for a code @xmath72 and its subcode @xmath73 , the first rgrw can be represented as @xmath197 . @xmath198 can be represented as @xmath199 for any subspace @xmath38 with @xmath200 , there always exists some @xmath201 satisfying @xmath202 , because we have @xmath203 and @xmath204 . also , for subspaces @xmath205 and @xmath206 with @xmath200 , if @xmath205 is the smallest space in @xmath120 including @xmath207 , then @xmath208 @xcite . thus can be rewritten as @xmath209 where the last equality of is obtained by @xmath210 , and @xmath211 from @xmath212 . for subspaces @xmath207 and @xmath213 , we have @xmath214 . therefore , can be rewritten as follows . @xmath215 + immediately yields the following corollary . [ coro : rankdistance ] for a linear code @xmath29 , @xmath216 holds . this shows that @xmath217 is a generalization of @xmath218 . now we present the following proposition that generalizes the singleton - type bound of the rank distance @xcite . [ prop : generalizedsingleton ] let @xmath72 be a linear code and @xmath73 be its subcode . then , the rgrw of @xmath93 and @xmath94 is upper bounded by @xmath219 for @xmath220 . we can consider that @xmath94 is a systematic code without loss of generality . that is , the first @xmath221 coordinates of each basis of @xmath94 is one of canonical bases of @xmath222 . let @xmath223 be a linear code such that @xmath93 is a direct sum of @xmath94 and @xmath224 . then , after suitable permutation of coordinates , a basis of @xmath224 can be chosen such that its first @xmath221 coordinates are zero . then , the effective length @xcite of a code @xmath224 is less than or equal to @xmath225 . hence we have @xmath226 from the singleton - type bound for rank metric @xcite . here we write @xmath227 for the sake of simplicity . recall that @xmath228 from , and @xmath229 holds from . we shall use the mathematical induction on @xmath81 . we see that is true for @xmath230 . assume that for some @xmath231 , @xmath232 is true . then , by the monotonicity shown in , @xmath233 holds . thus , it is proved by mathematical induction that holds for @xmath234 . lastly , we prove by the above discussion about the rgrw of @xmath224 and @xmath235 . for an arbitrary fixed subspace @xmath38 , we have @xmath236 , because @xmath93 is a direct sum of @xmath224 and @xmath94 . hence , @xmath237 holds , and we have @xmath238 for @xmath239 from . therefore , from the foregoing proof , we have @xmath240 for @xmath239 , and the proposition is proved . immediately yields the following corollary . [ coro : mrdrgrw ] for a linear code @xmath32 , @xmath241 for @xmath242 . the equality holds for all @xmath114 if and only if @xmath29 is an mrd code . in this section , we express @xmath14 and @xmath15 given in in terms of the rdip and rgrw . from now on , we use the following definition . for @xmath243 , we define @xmath244 . recall that if an @xmath10-linear space @xmath38 admits a basis in @xmath245 then @xmath246 @xcite , which implies @xmath247 first , we give the following theorem for the universal equivocation @xmath14 given in [ thm : equivocation ] consider the nested coset coding in . then , the universal equivocation @xmath14 of @xmath248 is given by @xmath249 let @xmath250 be an arbitrary matrix . by the chain rule @xcite , we have the following equation for the conditional entropy of @xmath7 given @xmath95 : @xmath251 then , from ( * ? ? ? * proof of lemma 4.2 ) , we have @xmath252 by substituting these equations into , we have @xmath253 by we have @xmath254 thus , by and , the universal equivocation @xmath14 is given as follows . @xmath255 + [ ex1 ] the existing schemes @xcite used mrd codes as @xmath256 and @xmath257 , where @xmath8 . by , we have @xmath258 for any @xmath259 . this implies @xmath260 for @xmath261 . on the other hand , @xmath262 by . since @xmath263 for any @xmath264 by , we have @xmath265 . by , @xmath266 , @xmath267 for @xmath268 . by , we see that @xmath269 for @xmath270 in the schemes @xcite . we then have the following corollary by the rgrw . shows that the wiretapper obtain no information of @xmath7 from any @xmath271 links . [ prop : perfectsecrecy ] consider the nested coset coding in . then , the wiretapper must observe at least @xmath272 links to obtain the mutual information @xmath273 ( @xmath274 ) between @xmath7 and observed packets . from , the smallest number @xmath63 of tapped links satisfying @xmath275 @xmath276 is @xmath277 from ( * ? ? * lemma 1 ) and , this equation can be rewritten as follows . @xmath278 + although the message @xmath7 has been assumed to be uniformly distributed over @xmath70 in , the following proposition reveals that the wiretapper still obtain no information of @xmath7 from any @xmath271 links even if @xmath7 is arbitrarily distributed . [ coro : distribution ] fix the transfer matrix @xmath279 to the wiretapper . suppose that the wiretapper obtain no information of @xmath7 from @xmath95 when @xmath7 is uniformly distributed over @xmath70 as described in . then , even if @xmath7 is chosen according to an arbitrary distribution over @xmath70 , the wiretapper still obtain no information of @xmath7 from @xmath95 , that is , @xmath280 . when we assume that @xmath7 is arbitrarily distributed over @xmath70 , @xmath281 is upper bounded as follows from ( * ? ? ? * proof of lemma 6 ) and ( * ? ? ? * proof of lemma 4.2 ) . @xmath282 also , since @xmath18 is uniformly distributed over a coset @xmath283 for fixed @xmath7 , we have @xmath284 . for the dimension of a subspace @xmath285 , we have @xmath286 where @xmath287 is a generator matrix of @xmath93 . hence we have @xmath288 . we thus have @xmath289 for any distribution of @xmath7 . by @xmath290 and we can see that the equality holds if @xmath7 is uniformly distributed . therefore , for fixed @xmath279 , if @xmath280 holds for uniformly distributed @xmath7 , then the right hand side of is zero , which implies that @xmath280 also holds for arbitrarily distributed @xmath7 from the nonnegativity of mutual information @xcite . lastly , we express @xmath15 in in terms of the rgrw . for a subset @xmath291 and a vector @xmath292\in\f_{q^m}^n$ ] , let @xmath293 be a vector of length @xmath294 over @xmath10 , obtained by removing the @xmath81-th components @xmath295 for @xmath296 . for example for @xmath297 and @xmath298 $ ] ( @xmath299 ) , we have @xmath300 $ ] . the _ punctured code _ @xmath301 of a code @xmath302 is given by @xmath303 . the _ shortened code _ @xmath304 of a code @xmath305 is defined by @xmath306 \in \c , c_i = 0 \text { for } i \notin \mathcal{j } \right\}$ ] . for example for @xmath307,[1,1,0],[1,0,1],[0,1,1]\}$ ] ( @xmath308 ) and @xmath309 , we have @xmath310,[1,1]\}$ ] . we then have the following theorem for the universal @xmath15-strong security defined in . [ thm : universalalpha ] let @xmath311 . fix @xmath93 , @xmath94 and @xmath312 in and consider the corresponding nested coset coding scheme in . by using @xmath93 , @xmath94 and @xmath312 , define @xmath313 : s \in \f_{q^m}^l\text { and } x\in\psi(s)\right\ } \subseteq \f_{q^m}^{l+n}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for each index @xmath314 , we define a punctured code @xmath315 of @xmath316 as @xmath317 , and a shortened code @xmath318 of @xmath316 as @xmath319 . then , the value @xmath15 in is given by @xmath320 define @xmath321 : \vec{c}_2 \in \c_2\}\subseteq\f_{q^m}^{l+n}$ ] . since @xmath73 , @xmath322 is also a subcode of @xmath316 . thus , in terms of @xmath316 and @xmath322 , we can see that the vector @xmath323\in\f_{q^m}^{l+n}$ ] is generated by a nested coset coding scheme of @xmath316 and @xmath322 from @xmath7 . then , from the definition of @xmath316 and @xmath322 , we can see that @xmath318 is a subcode of @xmath315 with dimension @xmath324 over @xmath10 for each @xmath325 . let @xmath326 and @xmath327 $ ] for each @xmath328 . for @xmath329 define a coset @xmath330 : s_{\mathcal{l}\backslash\{i\ } } \in\f_{q^m}^{l-1 } \text { and } x \in \psi(s)\right\ } \in\d_{1,i}/\d_{2,i}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we define @xmath331)= [ s_{\mathcal{l}\backslash\{i\}},x ] \in \d_{1,i}$ ] . recall that @xmath3 are mutually independent and uniformly distributed over @xmath10 . thus , considering a nested coset coding scheme that generates @xmath332 from a secret message @xmath333 with @xmath334 , we can see that @xmath335 is chosen uniformly at random from @xmath336 . therefore , we have @xmath337 for any @xmath338 whenever @xmath339 from . for an arbitrary subset @xmath340 , define a matrix @xmath341 that consists of @xmath342 rows of an @xmath343 identity matrix , satisfying @xmath344^{\rm t } \!=\ ! f_\mathcal{r } s_{\mathcal{l}\backslash\{i\}}^{\rm t}$ ] . for an arbitrary matrix @xmath345 ( @xmath346 ) , set @xmath347 $ ] . then , from the foregoing proof , we have @xmath348 whenever @xmath349 . since @xmath350 is equivalent to from ( * ? ? ? * prop.5 ) , we have by selecting the minimum value of @xmath351 for @xmath352 . [ ex2 ] the scheme proposed in @xcite used a systematic mrd code as @xmath316 ( not @xmath93 ) , where @xmath108 . we proved @xmath353 in ( * ? ? ? * proof of theorem 4 ) . by , we see that the scheme @xcite attains the universal @xmath16-strong security in the sense of , while @xcite proved it by adapting the proof argument in @xcite . as shown in , no information of @xmath7 is leaked from less than @xmath354 tapped links even if @xmath7 is arbitrarily distributed . in contrast , @xmath7 must be uniformly distributed over @xmath70 to establish . this is because elements of @xmath7 need to be treated as extra random packets , as in strongly secure network coding schemes @xcite . this section derives the universal error correction capability by the approach of ( * ? ? ? * section iii ) . recall that the received packets @xmath20 is given by @xmath355 in the setup of , and that @xmath18 is chosen from the coset @xmath283 corresponding to @xmath7 by the nested coset coding in . from now on , we write @xmath356 for the sake of simplicity . first , we define the _ discrepancy _ @xcite between @xmath23 and @xmath20 by @xmath357 where the second equality is derived from ( * ? ? ? * lemma 4 ) . this definition of @xmath358 represents the minimum number @xmath359 of error packets @xmath85 required to be injected in order to transform at least one element of @xmath23 into @xmath20 , as ( * ? ? ? * eq.(9 ) ) . let @xmath363 and let @xmath374 . then , @xmath375 from . let @xmath376 and @xmath377 be vectors satisfying @xmath378 . from the proof of ( * theorem 6 ) , we can always find two vectors @xmath379 such that @xmath380 , @xmath381 and @xmath382 . taking @xmath383 , we have @xmath384 and @xmath385 . we thus obtain @xmath386 and @xmath387 from . on the other hand , since @xmath388 , we have @xmath389 for any @xmath390 from from . therefore , @xmath391 and @xmath392 hold . [ prop : deltacorrection ] a nested coset coding scheme with @xmath248 is guaranteed to determine the unique coset @xmath23 against any @xmath81 packet errors for any fixed @xmath62 if and only if @xmath395 . [ thm : errorcorrectioncap ] consider the nested coset coding in . then , the scheme is a universally ( simultaneously for all @xmath80 with rank deficiency at most @xmath110 ) @xmath81-error-@xmath110-erasure - correcting secure network coding if and only if @xmath398 . for the rank deficiency @xmath399 , we have @xmath400 , and there always exists @xmath401 depending on @xmath402 such that the equality holds . thus , from , we have @xmath403 & \!=\ ! \min \left\ { d_r(x,\vec{0 } ) : x \in \c_1 , x \notin \c_2 \right\}-\rho\\ & \!=\ ! m_{r,1}(\c_1,\c_2 ) -\rho . \quad \text{(by \lma{lma : rankdistance})}\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , we have @xmath404 for @xmath405 , and hence we obtain @xmath406 @xmath407 . [ ex3 ] the existing scheme @xcite used mrd codes as @xmath248 , where @xmath8 . then , by , we have @xmath408 . since @xmath409 for any @xmath410 by and @xmath411 , we have @xmath412 . thus , by and , the scheme is universally @xmath81-error-@xmath110-erasure - correcting when @xmath413 , as shown in ( * ? ? ? * theorem 11 ) . h. chen , r. cramer , s. goldwasser , r. de haan , and v. vaikuntanathan , `` secure computation from random error correcting codes , '' in _ proc . eurocrypt 2007 _ , ser . lecture notes in computer science , vol . 4515.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emspringer - verlag , 2007 , pp . 291310 . t. ho , m. mdard , r. koetter , d. r. karger , m. effros , j. shi , and b. leong , `` a random linear network coding approach to multicast , '' _ ieee trans . inf . theory _ , 52 , no . 10 , pp . 44134430 , oct .

the universal secure network coding presented by silva et al . realizes secure and reliable transmission of a secret message over any underlying network code , by using maximum rank distance codes . inspired by their result , this paper considers the secure network coding based on arbitrary linear codes , and investigates its security performance and error correction capability that are guaranteed independently of the underlying network code . the security performance and error correction capability are said to be _ universal _ when they are independent of underlying network codes . this paper introduces new code parameters , the relative dimension / intersection profile ( rdip ) and the relative generalized rank weight ( rgrw ) of linear codes . we reveal that the universal security performance and universal error correction capability of secure network coding are expressed in terms of the rdip and rgrw of linear codes . the security and error correction of existing schemes are also analyzed as applications of the rdip and rgrw .

1203.0883

duality between gravity and gauge theory in spacetime with different dimensionalities has been discovered by maldacena in 1998 @xcite . the type - iib string theory in ads@xmath0 is conjectured to be dual to a gauge theory in four dimensional minkowski spacetime ( @xmath1 ) at the boundary of the ads space . the correspondence can be used as a complementary method to study the strongly coupled gauge theory in four dimensional minkowski spacetime , a cousin of quantum chromodynamics , by avoiding the uncontrollable non - perturbative calculation via the application of weak - strong duality . we can deal with this problem by alternatively performing calculations in the tractable weakly interacting string theory in five ( plus five compact dimensions which provide details that are not relevant here ) dimensional anti de sitter space ( ads@xmath2 ) . the duality is extended to a finite temperature situation by adding a horizon in the radial coordinate @xcite . the string theory in an ads space with black hole horizon in the radial direction is proposed to be dual to a gauge theory at finite temperature . the duality is made quantitative in the sense that the hawking temperature in the bulk theory corresponds to the temperature of the gauge theory on the boundary . the ads / cft correspondence provides the first string - theoretic example of the underlying generic principle of the holographic duality ( i.e. the holographic principle ) . the idea of holographic duality was originally proposed by t hooft @xcite in a generic quantum gravity situation involving a gravitational horizon . the precise string theoretic version was given by susskind @xcite . when an object falls into a black hole , it will be stretched , torn apart into bits and eventually the bits will be smeared out over the horizon . consequently , all of the bulk information is spread over the horizonal surface resulting in an effective boundary description of the bulk theory . the bulk world is holographically encoded on the boundary . connection between ads space and holography was further clarified by witten @xcite after discovery of the ads / cft correspondence . given an ads space , the weakly - coupled bulk gravity theory corresponds to a strongly - coupled boundary gauge theory . adding a black hole to the ads space , the dual gauge theory on the boundary becomes thermal with the temperature equal to the corresponding hawking - page temperature of the background @xcite . it is thus interesting to investigate the intermediate situation where there exists a massive object before gravitational collapse into a black hole in the ads space and search for the dual description in the gauge theory side . it is argued in ref . @xcite that the degenerate fermions in the ads correspond to the composite multitrace operator constructed from product of single trace operators in the large central charge limit on the boundary . it is not unreasonable to think of this free " fermionic operator as the conformal cousin of a qcd nucleon such as neutron and proton . these free fermions " , however , still interact with each other by the colour - singlet interaction of order @xmath3 assuming negligible in the large @xmath4 limit . the colour - singlet ( glueball ) exchange on the boundary corresponds holographically to the gravitational interaction in the bulk . while gravity pulls the bulk mass together causing the gravitational collapse , the colour - singlet interaction should be responsible for the deconfinement phase transition of the injected mass in the dual picture . arguably , the gravitational collapse of the star in the ads would correspond to a thermalization process of the dual gauge matter on the boundary @xcite . consideration of the mass limit of the fermionic star in the ads bulk could reveal certain details of the pre - thermalization process in the dual gauge picture . the mass limit of the ads star corresponds to the minimum amount of injected mass required in order for the boundary gauge matter to start the thermalization process ( since the bulk gravitational collapse starts when injected mass exceeds the mass limit ) . specifically , it is also interesting to ask what the dual object of the bulk temperature is on the boundary world before black hole formation ? should it correspond to some parameter characterizing the superheated phase of gauge matter before the start of the thermalization ? moreover , what is the exact nature of the colour - singlet ( glueball exchange ) interaction responsible for the deconfinement of the dual gauge matter into the thermalized deconfined plasma ( which is the dual picture of the gravitational collapse caused by gravity ) ? the heavy - ion collision experiments at rhic and cern s lhc ( large hadron collider ) smash two charged ions at extreme energies , producing dense and hot nuclear matter with properties of the strongly coupled plasma . in the vicinity of the collision point , the induced magnetic field could be enormous @xcite . understanding the physics of dense hot nuclear plasma under such circumstances requires nonperturbative treatments of the strong interaction and the holographic method is one option . one holographic dual of the magnetized nuclear matter at finite temperature is proposed to be a magnetized black brane in the ads space @xcite . it was found that the entropy density of the magnetized brane in the ads obeys the third law of thermodynamics with entropy @xmath5 ( temperature ) for small temperature . in this article , we consider a fermionic star in the holographic ads@xmath2 background in the presence of external magnetic field at finite bulk temperature . the mass limit and other properties of the star is studied with respect to the changes in the magnetic field and bulk temperature . even though there is no complete understanding of the dual description in the gauge theory side of this situation , we argue certain aspects of the duality . in section ii , the tolman - oppenheimer - volkoff ( tov ) equation @xcite in the background ads@xmath2 is calculated starting from the general dimensionality . the energy levels of the bulk charged fermions in the presence of the magnetic field are calculated in the flat space approximation . the pressure and density of the bulk fermions at finite field and temperature are subsequently derived . section iii presents analytic and numerical results for each case of finite temperature and field . the mass limits depend crucially on the field and bulk temperature . the mass - radius relations for each case are discussed in section iv . the bulk adiabatic index and sound speed of the fermions inside the ads star are discussed in section v. the entropy density and total entropy in the bulk are also computed . section vi investigates the dependence of mass limit on the ads radius . section vii contains further discussions and summary of our results the study of the magnetized star in the ads space consists of two main calculations . first , the pressure and energy density need to be calculated for the system of charged fermions in the magnetic field at arbitrary temperature . the star will be assumed electrically neutral and we will focus only on the effect of magnetic field to the charged particles . at zero temperature , the energy states of the charged fermions in the magnetic field are separated naturally into landau levels . the partition function in the macrocanonical ensemble of these energy levels will provide the generic expression for the pressure and energy density of the fermionic system at finite temperature . the pressure and energy density are subsequently used in the equation of state required by the tov equation in the 5-dimensional ads spacetime . even though we will focus on interpreting the results of the bulk ads star in terms of the dual gauge theory , the calculations in the bulk picture are self - consistent and satisfactorily describe a real magnetized fermionic star in the 5-dimensional ads spacetime . in order to study the behaviour of a degenerate star in @xmath6-dimensional ads spacetime , we derive the spherical symmetric tov equation in @xmath6 dimensions as given in appendix [ appa ] . in the presence of external magnetic field , the pressure of the fermionic matter in the star is actually anisotropic due to the quantization of the energy levels . however , in the classical limit where the momentum in the direction of the magnetic field is much larger than the square root of the magnetic field , @xmath7 , the pressure becomes isotropic @xcite and the spherical symmetric tov equation is applicable . the resulting equations of motion describing the ads star in the spherical symmetric approximation are @xmath8 for the temperature @xmath9 , and @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the ads radius , @xmath12 is the area of @xmath13 and @xmath14 . to solve the equations of motion , we need the equation of state or the explicit expression of @xmath15 in terms of the chemical potential @xmath16 . standard evaluation of the partition function requires the layout of energy states of the fermionic system which can be obtained in the following subsection . we now solve the dirac equation to find the relativistic energy level of a charged fermion in the presence of external magnetic field in the 5 dimensional spacetime . as an approximation , we will ignore the effect of curvature on the energy levels of the fermions . the effects of gravity and the ads curvature will be considered only through the einstein equations stated in the previous subsection . starting from the dirac equation in flat space @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the mass of the fermion . the gamma matrices are chosen to be in the dirac representation as the following @xmath19 where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are @xmath22 identity matrix and pauli matrices respectively . we will consider only the positive energy solution since we are interested in the particle not the antiparticle . the positive energy solution @xmath23 satisfies the equation @xmath24 . let @xmath25 and consider a particle in an external magnetic field , the effect of the magnetic field can be taken into account by adding the field momentum , @xmath26 . we will choose the magnetic field to point in the @xmath27 direction and uniformly distributed over the entire @xmath28 space . the equation of motion of the fermion in 5 dimensional space becomes @xmath29 the momentum component in the extra dimension is represented by @xmath30 corresponding to the coordinate @xmath31 . we have assumed the solution in the form @xmath32 and neglect the effect of the ads curvature to the momentum component @xmath30 . this is a good approximation as long as the ads radius of curvature is large compared to the wavelength of the bulk fermions . the energy condition from the equation of motion is given by @xmath33 if we let @xmath34 , then we have @xmath35 from equation ( [ landau energy level 1 ] ) and ( [ landau energy level 2 ] ) , energy is quantized in the @xmath36 plane and contains certain degeneracy of states , _ i.e. _ , there are several states with the same one - particle energy . the number of states @xmath37 of a discrete energy level @xmath38 is @xmath39 where @xmath40(@xmath41 ) is a spin degeneracy independent of @xmath38 . the degeneracy is proportional to the field and vanishes for @xmath42 . the discrete energies from the degrees of freedom of the plane perpendicular to the magnetic field is called the landau levels , characterizing the statistical properties of the fermionic system . extension to finite temperature situation can be done by considering the corresponding partition function . thermodynamical pressure and energy density of the magnetized fermion gas can be calculated from the grand canonical partition function given by @xmath43 use the euler - maclaurin formula ( see appendix [ appb ] ) and certain tricks of integration , we finally have the pressure in the asymptotically approximated form @xmath44 - \left(\frac{2\pi^{2}m^{2}\mu_{b}^{2}b^{2}}{3h^{4}}\right)\bigg[\left(\mu - mc^{2}\right ) \nonumber \\ & & -~k_{b}t\int_{0}^{\frac{\mu - mc^{2}}{k_{b}t}}\frac{dy}{e^{y } + 1 } + k_{b}t\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{dy}{e^{y } + 1}\bigg ] . \label{pressure in ads space under external magnetic field at finite temperature}\end{aligned}\ ] ] likewise the energy density is given by @xmath45 again , use the euler - maclaurin formula and tricks of integration , so that @xmath46 becomes @xmath47 + \left(\frac{2g_{s}\pi^{2}m^{2}\mu_{b}^{2}b^{2}}{3h^{4}}\right)\bigg [ ( \mu - mc^{2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & - k_{b}t\int_{0}^{\frac{\mu - mc^{2}}{k_{b}t } } \frac{dy}{\left(e^{y } + 1\right ) } + k_{b}t\int_{0}^{\infty } \frac{dy}{\left(e^{y } + 1\right ) } - \int_{mc^{2}}^{\mu}\frac{\epsilon e^{\frac{\epsilon-\mu}{k_{b}t}}}{k_{b}t}d\epsilon - 2\int_{0}^{\frac{\mu - mc^{2}}{k_{b}t}}\frac{\left ( \mu - k_{b}t y \right)e^{-y}}{\left ( e^{y } + 1\right)}dy \nonumber \\ & & + \int_{0}^{\frac{\mu - mc^{2}}{k_{b}t}}\frac{\left(\mu - k_{b}ty\right)e^{-y}}{\left(e^{y } + 1\right)^{2}}dy + \int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{\left(\mu + k_{b}ty\right)e^{y}}{\left(e^{y } + 1\right)^{2}}dy \bigg ] . \label{energy density in ads space under external magnetic field at finite temperature}\end{aligned}\ ] ] both expressions for the pressure and energy density are in the remarkable form with the dependence on @xmath48 separated out in simple quadratic functions . the integrations can be cast into logarithmic and polylogarithmic functions depending only on the temperature ( and not the field ) as are shown in the next section . in this section , the equations of motion , eqn . ( [ eom of m]),([eom of mu ] ) will be solved numerically . to emphasize effects of both temperature and external magnetic field , the physical properties of the degenerate star in the ads@xmath2 under the influence of both temperature and external magnetic field are investigated by dividing into 4 cases ; 1 . ) @xmath49 , 2 . ) @xmath50 , 3 . ) @xmath51 , and 4 . ) @xmath52 . before going into the details of each case , we integrate equations ( [ pressure in ads space under external magnetic field at finite temperature ] ) and ( [ energy density in ads space under external magnetic field at finite temperature ] ) to obtain @xmath53 , \label{pressure in simulation } \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath54 + \left(\frac{4m^{2}\pi^{2}\mu_{b}^{2}b^{2}}{3h^{4}}\right ) \nonumber \\ & & \bigg[\frac{mc^{2}}{1 + e^{\frac{\mu(r)-mc^{2}}{k_{b}t } } } - \mu(r ) - k_{b}t\ln\left(1 + e^{\frac{mc^{2}-\mu(r)}{k_{b}t}}\right ) + k_{b}t\ln\left(1 + e^{\frac{\mu(r)-mc^{2}}{k_{b}t}}\right ) \bigg ] , \label{energy density in simulation } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath55 is a polylogarithm function . for numerical analysis , we set @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 . we can transform the numerical results to the si unit by using the table of dimensional translation given in appendix [ appc ] . the coupled equations of motion between mass and chemical potential ( eqn . ( [ eom of m ] ) , ( [ eom of mu ] ) ) are numerically solved to find the chemical potential and the accumulated mass within the star . the density and pressure profiles can be subsequently obtained . the boundary conditions at the center of star are chosen to be @xmath59 and @xmath60 for every case . this is the condition of degenerate star in ads@xmath2 considered in ref . the fermions degenerate into the lowest possible energy states filling the energy levels up until the fermi energy in 5 dimensions . in this limit , the pressure and the energy density , eqn . ( [ pressure in simulation ] ) , ( [ energy density in simulation ] ) , reduce to @xmath61 first , the surface of the star can be defined at the radial distance , @xmath62 , where the pressure becomes zero . apparently from eqn . ( [ pressure in simulation at t=0 , b=0 ] ) , the pressure is zero when @xmath63 . on the other hand , from eqn . ( [ energy density in simulation at t=0 , b=0 ] ) , the density vanishes when @xmath64 . therefore in this case , both the pressure and energy density become zero at the radius @xmath62 where @xmath65 . the accumulated mass , the chemical potential , the density and the pressure distribution of the star versus the radius are presented in figure [ t=0,b=0mmuvsr ] and [ t=0,b=0rhopvsr ] . relations between the total mass and the central chemical potential / density of the degenerate star are shown in figure [ t=0,b=0masslimitmu ] . + + + from the numerical solution , the edge of the degenerate star is at @xmath66 where the pressure drops to zero . in figure [ t=0,b=0mmuvsr](a ) , the accumulated mass grows rapidly , in particular for the interval between @xmath67 and @xmath68 . beyond the central region , the accumulated mass increases less rapidly and becomes steady . the behavior of the accumulated mass is determined by the density and the pressure distribution within the star . initially , both the energy density and pressure in figure [ t=0,b=0rhopvsr ] , decrease rapidly then they drop to zero more gradually at larger distance . the chemical potential also behaves similarly(figure [ t=0,b=0mmuvsr](b ) ) . it is clear that the matter in the star becomes extremely dense in the region near the core . figure [ t=0,b=0masslimitmu ] shows the mass curve of the degenerate star as a function of the central chemical potential and density . from numerical analysis , the maximum mass is found to be @xmath69 for the central chemical potential equal to @xmath70 or at the central energy density equal to @xmath71 . this maximal mass can be interpreted to be the mass limit above which gravitational collapse occurs . a mass injection into an empty ads space until the accumulated mass exceeds the mass limit would result in a gravitational collapse in the bulk . the collapse corresponds to a thermalization process to finite temperature of the dual gauge matter . therefore , the mass limit corresponds to the minimum injected mass required by the dual gauge matter to start the thermalization process into the thermal equilibrium . after deconfinement thermalization , the dual gauge matter is in thermal equilibrium at the hawking temperature at this mass limit , i.e. @xmath72 with @xcite @xmath73 where the horizon radius @xmath74 for ads@xmath2 . note that the mass dependence of the hawking - page temperature in the limit of large ( @xmath75 ) and small ( @xmath76 ) black hole in the ads is @xmath77 respectively . it is interesting to note that for @xmath78 ( small black hole with negative specific heat after the gravitational collapse ) , the higher the mass limit , the smaller temperature the dual gauge matter would thermalize to . this corresponds to @xmath79(for @xmath80 , approximately 0.8836 ) . the mass limit of our ads star for @xmath81 is roughly @xmath82 and therefore the black hole at the end of gravitational collapse for ads star at this mass limit is a small black hole with small negative specific heat . for this case , the magnetic field is turned on and the mass limit and other properties at zero temperature are studied by comparing to the results of case i. since the changes from case i is small , we will present the results using the numerical differences between the two cases . starting from the pressure and energy density for nonzero magnetic field @xmath83 observe that the pressure of the star has almost the same form as the pressure in case i. the correction term to the pressure from the magnetic field contains the factor @xmath84 . the density appears to be smaller due to the contribution from the term @xmath85 . since the pressure vanishes at @xmath86 as in case i , the surface of the star is defined in the similar way , at @xmath65 . interestingly at this radius , the density becomes negative @xmath87 due to the interaction energy between the fermion s magnetic moment and the external field . interestingly , there is a critical field strength where the density becomes zero , @xmath88 where @xmath89 is a rescaled chemical potential . for magnetic field stronger than this critical value , the energy density becomes negative and there is no star formation or black hole in the bulk . since there is no horizon in the bulk , the dual gauge matter is at zero temperature under extremely strong magnetic field . likewise , there is a critical field where the pressure becomes zero , @xmath90 for @xmath91 , @xmath92 is always smaller than @xmath93 , therefore the pressure becomes negative before the density as the field is increased . at @xmath94 , both @xmath93 and @xmath92 are zero . + for numerical study , the magnetic field strength is chosen to be @xmath95 and @xmath96 for our consideration . fig . [ mixedatt=0masslimitmu ] show that the mass limit , comparing to case i , decreases when the magnetic field increases . the maximum mass for @xmath97 is appreciably smaller than the maximum mass at @xmath98 . consider the equation of state in the energy density part ( eqn . ( [ energy density in simulation at t=0 ] ) ) . since the coupled equations of motion between mass and chemical potential of the star ( eqn . ( [ eom of m ] ) and ( [ eom of mu ] ) ) involve the energy density , decreasing the energy density leads to the decrease of mass and the chemical potential of the star comparing to case i. the increase of the chemical potential subsequently leads to the decrease in the pressure of the star . numerical analysis confirms these behaviour as are shown in fig . [ otherpropertiesatt=0mvsr ] . note that in the core region ( @xmath99 ) , the density increases due to the increase of the chemical potential . however , in the outer region of the star , the effect of the magnetic field becomes dominant resulting in the decrease of the density . accumulated mass eventually becomes smaller than the mass in case i. the maximal mass or the mass limit of the ads star when the magnetic field is turned on is smaller than the mass limit in case i. therefore the dual gauge matter under magnetic field thermalizes to larger temperature when the accumulated mass exceeds the mass limit even though it requires smaller injected mass in order to start the thermalization . gravitational collapse of an ads star under strong magnetic field corresponds to thermalization of the magnetized gauge matter from zero to finite temperature . remarkably , the thermalized temperature ( at the mass limit ) is _ larger _ than when the field is absent previously discussed in case i. the magnetized gauge matter thermalizes more easily by requiring smaller injected mass , and also becomes hotter after the deconfinement thermalization . for finite bulk temperature , the bulk fermions become thermal in the ads space . since the kinetic energy of the particles increases , the pressure becomes larger and the star grows bigger . again , we study the small changes in the mass limit and other properties of the star by comparing the results to the zero temperature case . the pressure and energy density , eqn . ( [ pressure in simulation]),([energy density in simulation ] ) in this case reduce to @xmath100 , \label{pressure in simulation at b=0 } \\ \rho c^{2 } & = & \left(\frac{g_{s}2\pi^{2}}{15c^{4}h^{4}}\right)\bigg[3\mu(r)^{5 } - 5m^{2}c^{4}\mu(r)^{3 } + 2m^{5}c^{10 } - 5k_{b}^{2}t^{2}m^{2}c^{4}\pi^{2}\mu(r ) + 7k_{b}^{4}t^{4}\pi^{4}\mu(r ) \nonumber \\ & & + ~10k_{b}^{2}t^{2}\pi^{2}\mu(r)^{3 } + 30k_{b}^{2}t^{2}m^{3}c^{6}li_{2}\left(-e^{\frac{mc^{2}-\mu(r)}{k_{b}t}}\right ) - 150k_{b}^{3}t^{3}m^{2}c^{4}li_{3}\left(-e^{\frac{mc^{2}-\mu(r)}{k_{b}t}}\right ) \nonumber \\ & & + ~360k_{b}^{4}t^{4}mc^{2}li_{4}\left(-e^{\frac{mc^{2}-\mu(r)}{k_{b}t}}\right ) - 360k_{b}^{5}t^{5}li_{5}\left(-e^{\frac{mc^{2}-\mu(r)}{k_{b}t}}\right)\bigg ] . \label{energy density in simulation at b=0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is interesting to investigate the large temperature limit , @xmath101 . in this limit , the polylogarithmic function becomes a zeta function @xmath102 and thus @xmath103 if we assume the star to be in a uniform temperature , this implies that the thermal fermions are not confined within a finite - size star when the temperature is sufficiently large , i.e. @xmath101 . the result is not surprising , any particles with sufficiently large kinetic energy will escape the gravitational influence of the star . we set temperature values in the simulation unit to be @xmath104 . figure [ mixedatb=0masslimitmu ] show that temperature increasing hardly affects the mass limit . for this case , the surface of star is defined at @xmath105 since the density and pressure do not necessarily reduce to zero . the maximum masses increase with the bulk temperature . this is because the small increase in the temperature affects the fermi - dirac distribution very slightly . most particles are still in the same quantum states , mostly degenerate , and a very small part of the particles occupy higher energies than the fermi energy and exert more pressure . increasing temperature thus results in a small increase of pressure and energy density . consequently , when temperature increases , the maximum mass also grows . for @xmath106 , the energy density and chemical potential reduce to zero at much larger radii as shown in fig . [ otherpropertiesatb=0rhovsr ] . for sufficiently large temperature , even though the chemical potential reduces to @xmath107 at smaller radii , the pressure does not reduce to zero . in other words , the thermal bulk fermions refuse to be confined within a finite - size star above a critical temperature . + to interpret the results in the dual gauge picture , caution has to be made regarding the bulk temperature . during the thermalization process corresponding to the gravitational collapse in the gravity picture , the gauge matter is not in thermal equilibrium until a black hole is formed when the mass injection exceeds the mass limit . a zero - bulk - temperature ads star collapsing into a black hole becomes thermal at nonzero hawking temperature due to the emergence of a horizon . therefore , the bulk temperature does not correspond to any sort of temperature of the gauge matter on the boundary world . one of the effects of the bulk temperature of the fermions in the ads star is the increase of mass limit . once a black hole is formed from gravitational collapse of the warm ads star , the corresponding hawking temperature is always smaller than the the zero bulk temperature case . after thermalization process , the dual gauge matter will be in thermal equilibrium at _ lower _ temperature than the case of zero bulk temperature collapse . however , the total injected energy is larger than the zero bulk temperature case . the bulk temperature thus serves as a parameter which delays the onset of the thermalization process as well as reducing the temperature of the resulting thermal equilibrium . certainly , the dual gauge matter at exactly the same temperature can be alternatively achieved by injecting mass into a black hole in ads space , increasing its mass and reducing the corresponding hawking temperature ( however , if we keep increasing the black hole mass , it will finally become large black hole with positive specific heat and the temperature will start to increase with the mass ) . this choice would correspond to in - equilibrium thermalization where the gauge matter is always kept at thermal equilibrium as temperature decreases . the final thermal equilibrium at certain temperature can always be achieved by infinitely many different thermalization processes . we now consider effects from both the finite bulk temperature and nonzero magnetic field to the mass limit and other properties of the star . the equations of state have the full form according to eqn . ( [ pressure in simulation ] ) and ( [ energy density in simulation ] ) . and @xmath108 in comparison to the mass limit curve at @xmath109.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] again , it is interesting to consider the extreme limit of large temperature in the presence of the magnetic field . for nonzero field , the pressure in this limit becomes @xmath110 provided that the field @xmath48 is also comparably large . from eqn . ( [ largebtp ] ) , the star will have definite surface at finite radius when @xmath111 . sufficiently hot star requires sufficiently strong field to confine its fermionic content . we see the similar behaviour as in case ii and iii , temperature increase leads to the increase of the mass limit whereas the effect of the magnetic field is the opposite . in fig . [ mixed ] , when we set the field @xmath112 , the temperature @xmath113 has stronger effect on the profile of the star . the mass limit becomes larger than the mass limit in the case of the zero temperature and magnetic field . similar to case iii , when the temperature increases , the mass limit grows larger ( the upper line in the fig . [ mixed ] ) . however , if the magnetic field is enhanced further to @xmath114 , the mass limit becomes smaller than the zero - field zero - temperature mass limit . namely , the influence of the magnetic field has overcome those of the temperature when it is sufficiently large . let us summarize implications for the thermalization of the dual gauge matter from the results in this mixed situation with @xmath115 . generically , turning on the bulk temperature results in a larger mass limit in the ads space while finite magnetic field leads to a smaller mass limit . if the injected mass exceeds the mass limit , gravitational collapse will occur and we end up with a black hole . the injected mass at the mass limit is also the minimum mass required for the dual gauge matter to start the thermalization . the hawking temperature of the black hole can be identified with the temperature of the dual gauge matter at thermal equilibrium after the non - equilibrium thermalization process corresponding to the collapse , it is larger ( smaller ) for finite field ( bulk temperature ) than the collapse with @xmath116 . the field and the bulk temperature compete with opposite effects . for zero - field finite temperature collapse , the final black hole has higher mass and thus corresponds to small temperature of the gauge matter . the final equilibrium at the same temperature can be achieved via in - equilibrium process by injecting mass into a black hole resulted from gravitational collapse of an ads star with @xmath116 ( case i ) . on the contrary , when the field is turned on , we need to extract mass from a magnetized black hole , reducing its mass and increasing its hawking temperature in order to achieve the thermal equilibrium at the same temperature and magnetic field . the black hole immersed in the constant magnetic field in 4 dimensions was originally investigated in ref . extension to the magnetized black hole in ads@xmath2 spacetime is required to fully understand the holographic description of the strongly coupled magnetized gauge matter , one such solution ( magnetic brane ) is discussed in ref . it is found that the entropy density of the black brane in ads@xmath2 is proportional to @xmath117 for small @xmath117 and has a @xmath118 dependence for higher temperatures . we will calculate the entropy density of the ads star and compare to the case of magnetic brane in section v. however , as stated above , we have assumed the field is not sufficiently strong that it affects the spacetime of the background and our analyses are thus limited to the moderate magnetic field situation . the mass sequences diagram of the ads star for each case can be presented by the mass - radius plot of the star as shown in fig . [ mrrelation ] . figure [ mrrelation](a ) is the mass - radius sequence for case i with zero temperature and zero magnetic field . the stars in this case have larger radius than case ii ( zero temperature , finite field ) in fig . [ mrrelation](b ) but smaller radius than case iii ( zero field , finite temperature ) in fig . [ mrrelation](c ) . interesting competition between temperature and magnetic field can be seen in fig . [ mrrelation](d ) , a sufficiently large field helps to confine the fermions within a finite - size star even for relatively higher temperatures comparing to case iii . for sufficiently high temperature , the mass - radius curve can change the way it spirals to the attractor fixed point at @xmath119 . for @xmath120 in fig . [ mrrelation](c ) , the curve with @xmath121 oscillates down " to the fixed point from the small radii instead of the typical anticlockwise spiralling . this is because at this temperature the radius of the star is an increasing function of @xmath122 with no oscillation as we can see from fig . [ mixedatb=0masslimitmu](b ) . for @xmath98 in fig . [ mrrelation](d ) , the curve with @xmath121 , oscillates down " to the fixed point from the large radii without spiralling . it should be remarked that for case i and iii ( zero field ) , the mass at the attractor fixed point for @xmath119 is around 0.7 . for case ii and iv at @xmath98 , the fixed point mass for @xmath119 is around 0.68 . the radius of the ads star at the fixed point decreases with the field but does not depend very sensitively on the temperature . many interesting physical properties of the fermions squeezed within the ads star by its own gravity can be illustrated by certain thermodynamic and transport quantities . in this section , we consider two transport coefficients , the adiabatic index and sound speed of the ads fermionic matter for each limiting case . the entropy density and total entropy of the ads star are discussed subsequently . generically the adiabatic index , @xmath123 , and the sound speed , @xmath124 , of a medium are defined as @xmath125 which can be calculated through the dependence on the chemical potential @xmath126 of both @xmath127 and @xmath128 . the general expressions for both quantities are very lengthy but they are simplified for the zero - temperature limit . @xmath129 , @xmath130 where @xmath89 is the rescaled chemical potential and @xmath131 is the rescaled magnetic energy of the fermions . @xmath132 , @xmath133 a number of remarks are in order for the zero - temperature limit . from eqn . ( [ cs ] ) and ( [ csb0 ] ) , the sound speed for the nonzero field case ( @xmath134 ) is shown to be larger than the case with @xmath120 . for @xmath120 since @xmath135 , the sound speed is always real and the upper limit of @xmath124 is always smaller than @xmath136 or half the speed of light . for nonzero field , reality condition of @xmath124 leads to the constraint @xmath137 . namely , for a given @xmath138 , the upper limit on the magnetic field for ordinarily - compressible fermionic matter is @xmath139 on the other hand , the upper limit from the light speed @xmath140 is satisfied trivially for any value of @xmath48 . numerical results for each case are presented in fig . the @xmath141 and @xmath142 label represents the curve with @xmath143 and @xmath144 respectively . the @xmath115 label represents the curve with @xmath145 . when a thermodynamical system is injected with energy until it reaches a thermal equilibrium , the total energy density , pressure and number density are related to the entropy density by the relation @xmath146 where the entropy density in our case can be computed via @xmath147 from the gibbs - duhem relation . using eqn . ( [ pressure in simulation ] ) , the entropy density of the fermionic content of the ads star at finite temperature can be calculated to be @xmath148 . \label{sd}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the entropy density of the fermion gas approaches zero as @xmath149 , a typical behaviour from a quantum ensemble satisfying the third law of thermodynamics . in the low temperature limit , the last two terms of eqn . ( [ sd ] ) remain dominant and thus @xmath150.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is interesting to compare the @xmath117-dependence of our entropy density with the magnetized black hole studied in ref . @xcite where @xmath151 for small temperatures and @xmath152 for larger temperatures . in our case of the fermions in the ads star , the origin of the temperature dependence is the typical behaviour of free relativistic fermi gas persisting in any dimensions . for the magnetized ads black hole , the entropy is determined from the central charge of the ads@xmath153 subspace of ads@xmath154 interpolating with the ads@xmath2 . however , it must be aware that the bulk temperature of the ads star and the hawking temperature of the black hole are two distinct kinds of temperature . only the latter corresponds to the temperature of dual gauge matter at a thermal equilibrium . the entropy density of the magnetized fermion gas given by eqn . ( [ sd ] ) also depends on the magnetic field @xmath155 . the dependence nevertheless vanishes in the @xmath149 limit . however , this formula is the result of the euler - maclaurin formula which is a good approximation for @xmath156 , i.e. sufficiently high temperature . for smaller temperatures , starting with eqn . ( [ parf ] ) , the zeroth mode becomes dominant and the field - dependence becomes @xmath157 . this is also similar to the behaviour of the magnetized black brane @xcite . the entropy density from two numerical solutions are shown in fig . [ figsd ] . since @xmath158 is an increasing function of @xmath117 , the star at relatively small temperatures will have smaller entropy density . for small temperatures or small entropy density , we can approximate @xmath159 leading to @xmath160 . label represents @xmath145 curve and the @xmath161 label represents @xmath162 curve respectively.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] and @xmath163.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] and @xmath163.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] ( from left to right ) and @xmath163 ( from right to left).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] ( from left to right ) and @xmath163 ( from right to left).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] next we calculate the total entropy of the ads star which should be equivalent to the entropy of the dual gauge matter before the thermalization . the total entropy of the star should be the lower bound of the total entropy of the black hole at the end of gravitational collapse when the mass of the ads star exceeds the mass limit . this black hole entropy in turn corresponds to the total entropy of the dual gauge matter at the end of thermalization . in @xmath6 dimensions , the total entropy is given by @xmath164 where the volume factor @xmath165 becomes @xmath166 for @xmath167 . figure [ figs ] shows the total entropy of the ads star for @xmath168 at temperature @xmath169 and for @xmath170 under field @xmath171 . the total entropy is an increasing function of the temperature and a decreasing function of the magnetic field . from small radii , the total entropy is an increasing function of the star radius . this is a similar behaviour to the accumulated mass which is also a global quantity . remarkably , the total entropy converges to zero in the attractor fixed point @xmath119 limit . as the central density grows , the content of the ads star concentrates more in the central region resulting in the decrease of total entropy towards zero ( the volume weighing factor @xmath172 enhances contribution in the outer region in contrast to the core ) . the black hole at the end of gravitational collapse should possess at least the same amount of total entropy as the initial ads star above the mass limit . the second law of thermodynamic demands that the entropy of the ads star above the mass limit is always less than the black hole entropy after the collapse @xcite . the entropy increase could continue until it reaches the maximum when a black hole is formed @xcite . unfortunately , the time evolution of the entropy during the gravitational collapse is not completely known . partially because the thermal entropy is ill - defined during off - equilibrium processes and partially due to the geometric nature of black hole entropy at the end of the collapse . there are other kinds of entropy that can be assigned to the ads star and the black hole . the entanglement entropy quantifies how much we do not know about the region behind the horizon and it is consistent with the geometric nature of the bekenstein - hawking entropy of the black hole . entanglement entropy is found to increase in a different manner from the kolmogorov - sinai entropy @xcite during the collapse . however , all kinds of entropy are found to increase approximately linearly during the initial state of the gravitational collapse and saturate to a constant value at the end . each maximum of the @xmath173-@xmath174 curve in fig . [ figs1 ] corresponds holographically to the entropy of the dual gauge matter at the beginning of the thermalization process . it is also proportional to entropy of the black hole after gravitational collapse assuming the linear progression to the saturated bekenstein - hawking entropy mentioned above . arguably , the increase of entropy of the dual gauge matter from the injected mass state to the thermal equilibrium should also be the linear progression following by saturation as well . note that the entropy is not maximal at the maximal mass nor the maximal radius as we can see from fig . [ figs ] , [ figs1 ] . we vary the curvature radius of the ads space , @xmath175 , and study the changes in the profile of the star in this section . for simplicity , we will set the temperature and the external magnetic field to be zero . we let the curvature radius to be @xmath176 and @xmath177 , and observe considerable changes in the mass limit of the star as are shown in fig . [ mixed3 ] . .,scaledwidth=50.0% ] the mass limit of the degenerate star increases evidently when we raise the curvature radius of the ads space . moreover , the peak of the mass limit curve shifts to the lower central density side . note that increasing @xmath175 corresponds to decreasing the bulk cosmological constant @xmath178 . for @xmath179 , the maximum mass is @xmath180 for the central chemical potential @xmath181 or the central energy density @xmath182 . for @xmath183 , the maximum mass is @xmath184 for the central chemical potential @xmath185 or the central energy density @xmath186 . for @xmath187 , the maximum mass is @xmath188 for the central chemical potential @xmath189 or the central energy density @xmath190 . in this work we have found that both temperature and external magnetic field affect the mass limit and other physical properties of the fermionic ads star . the increase of bulk temperature enables the pressure and energy density of the star to increase . consequently , the mass limit becomes slightly greater due to the larger pressure . this is the typical behavior of the fermi gas at finite temperature . too large temperature results in the the fermions refusing to be confined within a finite - size star , they will leak to the space inevitably . in the presence of external magnetic field , the mass limit decreases when the magnetic field increases . as we can see from eqn . ( [ pressure in simulation ] ) and ( [ energy density in simulation ] ) , an increase in the magnetic field results in a smaller energy and pressure density as well as a smaller chemical potential . the mass limit becomes smaller naturally . there is an interesting competition between the temperature and the magnetic field to the density profile and mass limit of the star . extremely strong magnetic field tends to make the bulk fermions stay in the landau states with lower energies whilst the temperature causes the particles to flee the star . the radius of curvature of the ads space also affects the mass limit evidently . when the radius of curvature increases , the mass limit increases substantially as are shown in fig . [ mixed3 ] . interestingly , the peak of the mass limit curve shifts to the lower central density side . gravitational collapse in the ads space has holographic dual in terms of the non - equilibrium thermalization of the gauge matter on the boundary . even though the hawking temperature of the black hole at the end of the gravitational collapse can be matched with the temperature at thermal equilibrium of the gauge matter at the end of thermalization , the bulk temperature of the ads star does not seem to have such a straightforward relationship with the dual gauge matter . the hawking temperature of the resulting black hole is not directly related to the temperature of the fermionic star before the collapse but inversely proportional to the mass of the star . therefore it is the mass limit studied in our work which corresponds to the temperature of the gauge matter at the thermal equilibrium after thermalization , i.e. @xmath191 ( the black hole formed at our mass limit is small ads black hole with negative specific heat , the precise relationship is given in eqn . ( [ thm ] ) ) , for a given mass injection @xmath192 in the dual gauge picture . the mass limit also plays the role of the minimum injected mass required for the dual gauge matter to undergo the thermalization into the thermal equilibrium . larger mass limit means that it requires more injected energy to thermalize , and once it thermalizes , the gauge matter will be at lower hawking temperature . it should be remarked that the ads black holes formed at the end of the gravitational collapse of the ads stars at our mass limits are small black holes with negative specific heat . they are previously thought to be less thermodynamically preferred than the ads vacuum in the context of the ads / cft correspondence and only the large ads black hole with positive specific heat was considered relevant for the dual of the thermal gauge matter . however , inevitable collapse at the mass limits corresponding to small ads black holes suggest that there might exist the phase of thermal gauge matter with negative specific heat dual to these black holes at the end of the gravitational collapse . injecting more mass would make these ads black holes and their gauge duals eventually become thermodynamically stable with positive specific heat . entropy density of the ads star under uniform magnetic field is found to show interesting behaviour ; @xmath151 for small and @xmath152 for higher _ bulk _ temperatures . such @xmath117-dependence is typical for free fermion gas ( modulo the magnetic field existence ) and it is amusingly similar to the @xmath117-dependence of the magnetic black brane entropy in the ads @xcite even though the latter is the hawking - page temperature of the brane , not the bulk temperature of the material making up the brane itself . nevertheless , the correspondence between the bulk and boundary exists throughout the gravitational collapse as long as the background is the ads . the holographic duality suggests that the hilbert spaces of both the gravity and gauge theory as well as their partition functions are equivalent . a global probe for the number of degrees of freedom on both sides of the duality is the entropy . the total entropy of the ads star above the mass limit , which indicates the lower bound of the black hole entropy at the end of gravitational collapse , should also be the lower bound of the total entropy of the gauge matter at the end of thermalization in the dual picture , @xmath193 . we found that the entropy ( at the mass limit ) of the ads star is an increasing ( decreasing ) function of the temperature ( magnetic field ) , similar behaviour to the mass limit . the remaining unanswered question is the exact correspondence between the gravitational collapse in the bulk and non - equilibrium deconfinement thermalization of the dual gauge matter . if bulk gravity is dual to colour - singlet glueball interaction and it causes the gravitational collapse in the ads , how could the glueball exchange describe the deconfinement thermalization in the dual gauge picture ? should there exist the critical glueball density corresponding to the mass limit in the bulk which determines the deconfinement phase transition on the gauge theory side ? what is the boundary ( cft ) gauge description of the tov equation and more generically the einstein equation in the ( ads ) bulk ? what are the duals of bulk temperature and other thermodynamic and transport quantities such as the adiabatic index and sound speed of the ads star in the gauge theory side ? t.c . would like to thank sirachak panpanich for valuable helps . is supported in part by the thailand research fund ( trf ) and commission on higher education ( che ) under grant rmu5380048 and also by the thailand center of excellence in physics ( thep ) . is supported in part by the thailand research fund ( trf ) and commission on higher education ( che ) under grant rmu5380048 . we solve the einstein equation in @xmath6-dimensional spacetime in this section . starting from the einstein equation , @xmath194 where @xmath195 , @xmath196 , @xmath62 , @xmath197 , @xmath12 , @xmath198 are ricci tensor , metric tensor , ricci scalar , energy - momentum tensor , the area of @xmath13 and constant @xmath199 respectively . assuming a perfect fluid , the energy - momentum tensor is given by @xmath200 where we use a spherically symmetric metric in @xmath6 dimensions in the polar coordinates @xcite @xmath201 the lagrangian of this metric is then given by @xmath202 we will use the euler - lagrange equation to find the equations of motion and read off the connections , @xmath203 consider @xmath204 component , the equation of motion is @xmath205 and the connections are @xmath206 the equation of motion in the @xmath207 component reads @xmath208 and the connections in the @xmath207 component are @xmath209 likewise , the equation of motion in the @xmath210 component is @xmath211 and the connections in the @xmath210 component are @xmath212 where @xmath213 . similarly , the equation of motion in the @xmath214 component is @xmath215 and the relevant connections are @xmath216 where @xmath217 . the equation of motion in the @xmath218 component is @xmath219 and the connections in @xmath220 component are @xmath221 where @xmath222 and @xmath223 . the ricci tensor and ricci scalar can be calculated from @xmath224 after some calculations , we have @xmath225 consider @xmath226 , then @xmath227 @xmath228 if we consider an ads space(with a negative cosmological constant , @xmath178 ) , then the einstein equation reads @xmath229 and equation ( [ result of gtt ] ) becomes @xmath230 change @xmath231 , so that @xmath232 the solution to this equation is @xmath233 let @xmath234 , then @xmath235 also the accumulated mass can be defined to be @xmath236 consider @xmath237 , then @xmath238 use equation ( [ 1 st result of gtt ] ) from @xmath239 and multiply by @xmath240 , @xmath241 change @xmath242 , @xmath231 , equation ( [ gtt grr 2 ] ) becomes @xmath243 solve this equation to find relations between @xmath244 and @xmath48 , @xmath245 where @xmath246 finally we obtain the coupled equations of motion from equation ( [ equation of motion of mass ] ) and ( [ equation of motion of chi ] ) @xmath247 moreover , when we consider the energy momentum conservation @xmath248 by letting @xmath249 and @xmath250 , @xmath242 , it leads to the tov equation in @xmath6-dimension , @xmath251 next we want to rewrite this equation in the form containing thermodynamic quantities such as the chemical potential , the entropy , and the temperature of matter within the spherically symmetric star . from thermodynamic relations involving the entropy density @xmath158 ; @xmath252 the tov equation can be rewritten as @xmath253 implying two equations to be satisfied simultaneously @xmath254 the temperature equation can be solved to obtain the redshifted temperature profile within the star @xmath255 where @xmath256 and @xmath257 is the temperature at the star center . the chemical potential equation similarly gives @xmath258 the coupled equations of motion can then be written in terms of the accumulated mass and chemical potential as the following @xmath259 a slowly converging series can be evaluated effectively by using an integral as in the euler - maclaurin formula @xmath260 in this article , the partition function sum over landau states is approximated using this conventional method by letting @xmath261 where @xmath262 . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] j. m. maldacena , `` the large n limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity , '' _ adv . phys . _ * 2 * , 231 ( 1998 ) [ _ int . j. theor . phys . _ * 38 * , 1113 ( 1999 ) ] [ arxiv : hep - th/9711200 ] . edward witten , anti - de sitter space , thermal phase transition , and confinement in gauge theories , " _ adv . * 2 * ( 1998 ) 505 , [ arxiv : hep - th/9803131 ] . g. t hooft , `` dimensional reduction in quantum gravity , '' arxiv : gr - qc/9310026 . l. susskind , `` the world as a hologram , '' _ j. math . phys . _ * 36 * , 6377 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9409089 ] . edward witten , anti - de sitter space and holography , " _ adv . _ * 2 * ( 1998 ) 253 - 291 , [ arxiv : hep - th:9802150 ] . j. de boer , k. papadodimas and e. verlinde , `` holographic neutron stars , '' _ jhep _ * 1010 * , 020 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0907.2695 [ hep - th ] ] . x. arsiwalla , j. de boer , k. papadodimas and e. verlinde , `` degenerate stars and gravitational collapse in ads / cft , '' _ jhep _ * 1101 * , 144 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1010.5784 [ hep - th ] ] . u. h. danielsson , e. keski - vakkuri and m. kruczenski , spherically collapsin matter in ads , holography , and shellons , " _ nucl . b _ * 563 * , 279 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9905227 ] . s. lin and e. shuryak , toward the ads / cft gravity dual for high energy collisions . 3 . gravitationally collapsing shell and quasiequilibrium , " _ phys . d _ * 78 * , 125018 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0808.0910[hep - th ] ] . v. balasubramanian , a. bernamonti , j. de boer , n. copland , b. craps , e. keski - vakkuri , b. muller , a. schafer , m. shigemori , and w. staessens , thermalization of strongly coupled field theories , " _ phys . lett . _ * 106 * , 191601 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1012.4753[hep - th ] ] . v. balasubramanian , a. bernamonti , j. de boer , n. copland , b. craps , e. keski - vakkuri , b. muller , a. schafer , m. shigemori , and w. staessens , holographic thermalization , " _ phys . rev . _ * d84 * , 026010 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1103.2683[hep - th ] ] . kharzeev , l.d . mclerran , and h.j . warringa , the effects of topological charge change in heavy ion collisions:event by event p and cp violation , " _ nucl . phys . a _ * 803 * ( 2008 ) 227 , [ arxiv:0711.0950 , hep - th ] . r. c. tolman , `` static solutions of einstein s field equations for spheres of fluid , '' _ phys . rev . _ * 55 * , 364 ( 1939 ) . j. r. oppenheimer and g. m. volkoff , `` on massive neutron cores , '' _ phys _ * 55 * , 374 ( 1939 ) . v. canuto and h. y. chiu , quantum theory of an electron had in intense magnetic fields , " _ phys . rev . _ * 173 * , 1210 ( 1968 ) . l. e. blumenson , `` a derivation of n - dimensional spherical coordinates , '' _ the american mathematical monthly _ * 67 * , 1 ( jan 1960 ) . jacob d. bekenstein , entropy bounds and black hole remnants , " _ phys . rev . _ * d49 * , 1912 - 1921 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/9307035 ] .

a warm fermionic ads star under a homogeneous magnetic field is explored . we obtain the relativistic landau levels by using dirac equation and use the tolman - oppenheimer - volkoff ( tov ) equation to study the physical profiles of the star . bulk properties such as sound speed , adiabatic index , and entropy density within the star are calculated analytically and numerically . bulk temperature increases the mass limit of the ads star but external magnetic field has the opposite effect . the results are partially interpreted in terms of the pre - thermalization process of the gauge matter at the ads boundary after the mass injection . the entropy density is found to demonstrate similar temperature dependence as the magnetic black brane in the ads in certain limits regardless of the different nature of the bulk and hawking temperatures . total entropy of the ads star is also found to be an increasing function of the bulk temperature and a decreasing function of the magnetic field , similar behaviour to the mass limit . since both total entropy and mass limit are global quantities , they could provide some hints to the value of entropy and energy of the dual gauge matter before and during the thermalization . keywords : holographic principle , ads star , mass limit , thermalization

hep-th0503076

consistent unification of relativity and quantum mechanics remains an unsolved theoretical problem in spite of many efforts applied to its solution in the 20th century . the fundamental difference between relativistic and non - relativistic physics follows from the famous einstein s formula @xmath1 . this formula , in particular , implies that if a system of particles has sufficient energy @xmath2 of their relative motion , then this energy may be converted to the mass @xmath3 of newly created particles . generally , there is no limit on how many particles can be created in collisions , so any realistic quantum mechanical description of high - energy systems should involve states with any number of particles from zero to infinity . the number of particles is not conserved during time evolution . the most familiar example of such a behavior is the emission and absorption of light ( photons ) in electrodynamics . first attempts to describe relativistic quantum systems were undertaken immediately after creation of the formalism of quantum mechanics in 1920 s . a quantum theory of the electromagnetic field was constructed by quantization of the classical maxwell electrodynamics . in lowest perturbation orders , this theory agreed well with experimental results . however , perturbative calculations for the @xmath0-matrix did not work in higher orders , in particular , due to ultraviolet divergences . the way to calculate the @xmath0-matrix in qft accurately in all orders was provided by the renormalized qed formulated by feynman , schwinger , and tomonaga in the late 1940 s . however this approach created a host of other problems . according to the prevailing interpretation , the creation and annihilation operators present in the hamiltonian and lagrangian of qed correspond to _ bare _ particles having infinite masses and charges . however , the bare particles have never been directly observed in experiments . they are believed to be surrounded by clouds of virtual photons and electron - positron pairs , thus forming complex objects called _ dressed _ particles . the dressed particles are supposed to be the eigenstates of the full hamiltonian . they have finite experimentally observable masses and charges . the problem is that the bare particle hamiltonian of qft is formally infinite . although , these infinities cancel out when the @xmath0-matrix is calculated , the hamiltonian is useless if one wants to calculate the time evolution or to find wavefunctions of bound states via diagonalization procedure . two lines of research were initiated to cope with these problems . the _ dressed particle _ approach was suggested by greenberg and schweber @xcite . their goal was to get rid of the bare particles and to express the entire formalism of qft through observable dressed particles only . the operators for dressed particles were sought as unitary transforms of bare particle operators . from another direction , gazek and wilson @xcite introduced the _ similarity renormalization _ formalism . the idea was to apply a unitary transformation to the hamiltonian in order to ensure that interaction potentials rapidly fall off as functions of energy differences , and to guarantee that all loop integrals are convergent . the similarity and dressing transformations are strikingly similar . they can be combined into one unitary _ similarity - dressing _ transformation which achieves two goals at once : the theory can be expressed in terms of real dressed particles and the hamiltonian can be made finite in all perturbation orders . at the same time , the accurate and well - tested @xmath0-matrix of the renormalized theory remains intact . this combined approach was developed in refs . @xcite and dubbed the relativistic quantum dynamics , or rqd . in this paper we will discuss the reasons why the renormalization difficulties ( e.g. , the absence of a well - defined hamiltonian and unsatisfactory treatment of the time evolution ) persist in current relativistic quantum field theories . to avoid unnecessary mathematical complications , we will be working with a simple model theory which , nevertheless , shares some important features with qed . in section 9 we will explain how the similarity - dressing transformation of this model theory leads to a well defined ( perturbatively ) finite hamiltonian that can be used for all kinds of quantum mechanical calculations ( @xmath0-matrix , bound states , time evolution , etc . ) without the need for renormalization . in addition , the rqd formalism does not use the dubious notions of bare and virtual particles . in this paper we will be concerned with three types of phenomena that are normally studied in physical experiments : bound states , time evolution , and scattering . these three areas account for the most of experimental information available about fundamental particles and their interactions . the key theoretical quantity involved in quantum mechanical description of these phenomena is the hamilton operator @xmath4 . the energies @xmath5 and state vectors @xmath6 of bound states can be found as eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the hamiltonian @xmath7 the development of the state vector @xmath8 from time @xmath9 to time @xmath10 is described by the _ time evolution operator _ @xmath11 @xmath12 if the eigenvalues @xmath5 and eigenvectors @xmath13 of the hamiltonian are known and the initial state is represented as a sum ( and/or integral ) over the basis states @xmath14 unfortunately , in most cases , the full spectrum of the hamiltonian is not known , and the time evolution is difficult to predict . this difficulty , however , is not that disappointing , because experimental observations of the time evolution in subatomic world are even more difficult than calculations . most experiments in high energy physics are performed by preparing free particles or their bound states ( like hydrogen atoms or deuterons ) , bringing them into collision , and studying the properties of free particles or bound states leaving the region of collision . in these experiments , it is not possible to observe the time evolution during interaction : particle reactions occur almost instantaneously and one can only register the reactants and products which move freely before and after the collision . this gives a lucky break for theoreticians : in such situations the theory is not required to describe the detailed dynamics of particles during the short interval of collision . it is sufficient to provide a mapping of free states before interaction onto the free states after the interaction . to describe scattering experiments , one needs only the formula for the time evolution from the remote past @xmath15 to the distant future @xmath16 @xmath17 where the @xmath0__-operator _ _ [ s - oper ] is defined by @xmath18 one can read the right hand side of eq . ( [ eq : s - oper ] ) from right to left as a sequence of three steps : ( i ) the non - interaction evolution of the system from time @xmath9 in the past to 0 ; ( ii ) the sudden jump at @xmath19 described by the @xmath0-operator ; ( iii ) the free evolution from @xmath19 to the future time @xmath10 . the most effective technique available for calculations of the @xmath0-operator is the perturbation theory which can be written in many equivalent forms . the dyson time - ordered expansion provides the most economical expressions that can be encoded in familiar feynman diagrams . however , for the discussion in this paper , we found more useful two other perturbative expressions which differ from the dyson s formula only by re - shuffling the terms . the `` old - fashioned '' formula for the @xmath0-operator is @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the interaction part of the total hamiltonian @xmath22 , @xmath23 and the factor latexmath:[$e^{-\epsilon switching the interaction on and off . operators with @xmath10-dependence determined by the free hamiltonian @xmath25 as in eq . ( [ eq:8.67 ] ) will be called _ regular_. using convenient symbols for @xmath10-integrals [ underline ] @xmath26 formula ( [ eq:8.68 ] ) can be written compactly as @xmath27 where @xmath28 another equivalent expression for @xmath0 was suggested by magnus @xcite @xmath29 here the hermitian operator @xmath30 can be represented as a series of multiple commutators with @xmath10-integrations @xmath31 -\frac{1}{6}[\underline{\underline{v(t)},[v(t)},v(t ) ] ] -\frac{1}{6}[\underline{[\underline{v(t)},v(t)]},v(t ) ] \nonumber \\ & \mbox { } & + \frac{i}{12}[\underline{\underline{\underline{v(t)},[[v(t)},v(t)]},v(t ) ] ] \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{i}{12}[\underline{[\underline{\underline{v(t)},[v(t)},v(t)]]},v(t ) ] + \frac{i}{12}[\underline{\underline{[\underline{v(t)},v(t)]},[v(t)},v(t ) ] ] + \ldots \label{eq:8.72}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one important advantage of this representation is that the @xmath0-operator ( [ eq:8.71 ] ) is manifestly unitary . it follows from equations ( [ eq:8.69 ] ) and ( [ eq:8.71 ] ) that operators @xmath32 and @xmath30 are related to each other @xmath33 so finding @xmath30 or @xmath32 are equivalent tasks . the @xmath0-operator and the hamiltonian provide two different ways to describe dynamics . the @xmath0-operator represents only `` integrated '' time evolution from the remote past to the distant future . the knowledge of the @xmath0-operator is sufficient to calculate the scattering cross - sections as well as energies and lifetimes of stable and metastable bound states .- operator on the complex energy plane . ] however , in order to describe the time evolution and the wavefunctions of bound states the full interacting hamiltonian @xmath4 is required . it can be shown @xcite that two hamiltonians @xmath34 and @xmath35 related to each other by a unitary transformation @xmath36 @xmath37 yield the same scattering @xmath38 as long as condition @xmath39 is satisfied . such hamiltonians @xmath4 and @xmath40 are called _ scattering - equivalent_. the energy spectra of two scattering equivalent hamiltonians are identical . however , the eigenvectors are different and , according to eq . ( [ eq:8.61a ] ) , the corresponding descriptions of dynamics are different as well . therefore scattering - equivalent theories may be not _ physically _ equivalent . calculations of bound states , time evolution and scattering is a routine practice in non - relativistic quantum mechanics . however , the situation is less certain in relativistic quantum field theories . as mentioned in introduction , the hamiltonian of renormalized qft is infinite . therefore , it is not immediately clear if the above formulas ( [ eq:1 ] ) - ( [ eq:8.74 ] ) remain valid for the high energy relativistic phenomena , and what modifications , if any , should be introduced in quantum theory to take into account the variable number of particles . in this paper we illustrate the difficulties encountered in quantum field theories by analyzing a simple model theory with variable number of particles . we will demonstrate that the hamiltonian can be redefined so that there is no need for renormalization and usual quantum mechanical techniques remain applicable even in the relativistic case . our model theory describes two kinds of particles . these are massive spinless fermions which will be called _ electrons _ and massless bosons with zero helicity , which will be called _ photons_. here we disregard the spin and polarization degrees of freedom as they are not so important for the discussion of renormalization . to allow for creation and annihilation of particles , the system is described in the fock space which is built as a direct sum of sectors with various numbers of particles . for example , if we denote @xmath41 the no - particle vacuum state , @xmath42 the one - electron hilbert space and @xmath43 the one - photon hilbert space , then the fock space can be written as an infinite direct sum @xmath44 the anticommutation and commutation relations for particle creation and annihilation operators ( @xmath45 , @xmath46 for electrons and @xmath47 , @xmath48 for photons , respectively ) are , as usual , @xmath49 @xmath50 & = & \delta ( \mathbf{p}-\mathbf{p } ' ) \label{eq : cc}\\ \{a_{\mathbf{p}},a_{\mathbf{p}'}\ } & = & \{a^{\dag}_{\mathbf{p}},a^{\dag}_{\mathbf{p}'}\ } = 0 \label{eq : aa2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath51 = [ c^{\dag}_{\mathbf{k}},c^{\dag}_{\mathbf{k } ' } ] = 0 \label{eq : cc2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath52&= & [ a^{\dag}_{\mathbf{p}},c_{\mathbf{k } } ] = [ a_{\mathbf{p}},c^{\dag}_{\mathbf{k } } ] = [ a_{\mathbf{p}},c_{\mathbf{k } } ] = 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the full hamiltonian @xmath53 is the sum of the free hamiltonian @xmath54 ( where @xmath55 and @xmath56 are one - particle energies of electrons and photons , respectively ) and the interaction , which we choose in the following form @xmath57 the coupling constant @xmath58 is the absolute value of the electron charge . here and in what follows the _ perturbation order _ [ pert - order ] of an operator (= the power of the coupling constant @xmath58 ) is shown by the subscript . for example , the free hamiltonian @xmath25 does not depend on @xmath58 , so it is of zero perturbation order ; @xmath59 is of the first perturbation order , etc . the number of electrons is conserved by the interaction ( [ eq:9.69 ] ) , but the number of photons is not conserved . so , this theory is capable of describing important processes of the emission and absorption of photons . in this paper we will discuss ultraviolet divergences associated with the interaction ( [ eq:9.69 ] ) . however , we will skip completely the discussion of `` infrared divergences '' which are related to the zero mass of photons and singularities @xmath60 in ( [ eq:9.69 ] ) . the easiest way to avoid infrared problems in practical calculations is to assign a small non - zero mass to photons . in section [ ss : e - e - scatt ] we are going to calculate the scattering operator ( [ eq:8.69 ] ) with the above hamiltonian . before doing that , some remarks are in order . the operator @xmath0 is obtained as a sum of products ( [ eq:8.70 ] ) ( or commutators ( [ eq:8.72 ] ) ) of interactions @xmath61 with @xmath10-integrations . each term in these expressions can be written as a normally ordered product of @xmath62 creation operators @xmath63 and @xmath64 annihilation operators @xmath65 . and @xmath65 refer to generic creation and annihilation operators without specifying the type of the particle . the pair of integers @xmath66 will be referred to as the _ index _ [ index ] of the term @xmath67 . ] @xmath68 d_{nm}[\mathbf{q } ] e^{ite_{nm}[\mathbf{q } ] } \delta ( \mathbf{p}_{nm}[\mathbf{q } ] ) \alpha^{\dag}_{\mathbf{q}'_1 } \ldots \alpha^{\dag}_{\mathbf{q}'_n } \alpha _ { \mathbf{q}_1 } \ldots \alpha_{\mathbf{q}_m } \label{eq:9.49}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where integration is carried over momenta of all created and annihilated particles @xmath69 $ ] . the momentum conservation law is guaranteed by the delta function in ( [ eq:9.49 ] ) whose argument is the sum of momenta of created particles minus the sum of momenta of annihilated particles @xmath70 usually , we will perform explicit integration over one momentum @xmath71 which removes the delta function and expresses @xmath71 as a linear function of other momenta . the argument of the exponent in ( [ eq:9.49 ] ) contains the _ energy function _ @xmath72 which is the difference of energies of particles created and annihilated by @xmath67 . @xmath73 is a numerical _ coefficient function_. suppose that a term @xmath67 has coefficient function @xmath73 , then we introduce a useful notation [ circ ] @xmath74 for the operator whose coefficient function @xmath75 is a product of @xmath73 and a function @xmath76 of the same arguments @xmath77 & = & d_{nm}[\mathbf{q } ] \zeta [ \mathbf{q}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , a @xmath10-dependent regular term @xmath78 can be written as @xmath79 and its definite @xmath10-integral is @xmath80 eq . ( [ eq:9.52 ] ) means that each term in @xmath81 is non - zero only on the hypersurface of solutions of the equation @xmath82 if such solutions exist . this hypersurface in the momentum space is called the _ energy shell _ [ energy - shell ] of the term @xmath78 . note that the scattering operator ( [ eq:8.69 ] ) is non - trivial only on the energy shell , i.e. , where the energy conservation condition holds . in this section we would like to get a further insight into the nature of operators in the fock space by dividing them into three groups depending on their index @xmath66 . we will call these types of operators _ renorm _ , _ phys _ , and _ unphys_. * renorm operators * [ oper - renorm ] have either index ( 0,0 ) ( a numerical constant @xmath83 ) or index ( 1,1 ) in which case the same type of particle is created and annihilated . the most general form of a renorm operator in our theory is omitting all numerical factors , indices , integration and summation signs . note also that the interaction operator ( [ eq:9.69 ] ) commutes with the operator of charge @xmath84 , so any product or commutator of terms derived from @xmath59 should also commute with @xmath85 . this is not true for terms like @xmath86 and @xmath87 , so they are not allowed in the theory . ] @xmath88 the free hamiltonian ( [ eq : free - h0 ] ) is an example of a renorm operator . the class of renorm operators is characterized by the property that the energy function ( [ eq:9.51 ] ) is identically zero . so , renorm operators always have an non - empty energy shell where they do not vanish . regular renorm operators do not depend on @xmath10 . * phys operators * [ oper - phys ] have at least two creation operators and at least two destruction operators ( index @xmath66 with @xmath89 and @xmath90 ) . in this case the energy shell is non - empty . for example , the energy shell for phys operator @xmath91 is given by the set of solutions of equation @xmath92 which is not empty . * unphys operators * [ oper - unph ] have index @xmath93 or @xmath94 . it can be shown that the energy shell is empty for unphys operators . for example , the interactions ( [ eq:9.69 ] ) are unphys . the energy shell equation for these two terms @xmath95 does not have a solution , because there are no photon states with zero momentum . renorm , phys , and unphys operators exhaust all possibilities in our theory , therefore any regular operator @xmath21 must have a unique decomposition @xmath96 the rules for calculations of commutators , derivatives and @xmath10-integrals with different operator types are summarized in table 9.2 . for example , the @xmath10-integrals of phys and unphys operators are given by formula @xmath97 @ccccccc type of operator & & & & & & @xmath98 & @xmath99 $ ] & @xmath100 $ ] & @xmath101 $ ] & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & & & & & & p & p & p+u & p & p & p & p u & p+u & p+u+r & u & u & u & 0 r & p & u & r & 0 & nr & @xmath105 our goal in this section is to introduce the diagram technique which greatly facilitates perturbative calculations of scattering operators ( [ eq:8.70 ] ) and ( [ eq:8.72 ] ) . let us graphically represent each term in the interaction operator ( [ eq:9.69 ] ) as a _ ( see fig . 1 ) . [ diagram ] each particle operator in ( [ eq:9.69 ] ) is represented as an oriented _ line _ [ line ] or arrow . the line corresponding to the annihilation operator enters the vertex , and the line corresponding to the creation operator leaves the vertex . electron lines are shown by full arcs and photon lines are shown by broken arrows . each line is marked by the momentum label of the corresponding particle operator . free ends of the electron lines are attached to the vertical `` order bar '' on the left hand side of the diagram . the order of these _ external lines _ [ extern ] ( from bottom to top of the diagram ) corresponds to the order of particle operators in the interaction term ( from right to left ) . an additional numerical factor is indicated in the upper left corner of the diagram . the @xmath10-integral @xmath106 differs from @xmath107 only by the factor @xmath108 ( see eq . ( [ eq:9.56 ] ) ) which is represented in the diagram by drawing a box that crosses all external lines . a line entering ( leaving ) the box contributes its energy with the negative ( positive ) sign to the energy function @xmath109 . the diagram representation of the integral @xmath110 is shown in fig . the product of two operators @xmath111 is represented by simply placing diagram @xmath112 below diagram @xmath98 and attaching the external electron lines of both diagrams to the same order bar . for example , the diagram for the product of the second term in ( [ eq:9.69 ] ) ( fig . 1(b ) ) and the first term in ( [ eq:9.70 ] ) ( fig . 2(a ) ) @xmath113 is shown in fig . this product should be further converted to the normal form , i.e. , all incoming lines should be positioned below the outgoing lines . due to the relations ( [ eq : aa ] ) - ( [ eq : cc2 ] ) each exchange of positions of the electron particle operators ( full external lines on the diagram ) changes the total sign of the expression . each permutation of annihilation and creation operators ( incoming and outgoing lines ) of similar particles creates an additional expression and a new diagram in which the swapped lines are joined together . using these rules we first move the photon operators in ( [ eq:9.71 ] ) to the rightmost positions , move the operator @xmath114 to the leftmost position , and add another term due to the anticommutator @xmath115 . @xmath116 this expression is represented by two diagrams 3(b ) and 3(c ) . in the diagram 3(b ) the electron line marked @xmath117 has been moved to the top of the order bar . in the diagram 3(c ) the product @xmath118 and the integration by @xmath117 are represented by merging or _ pairing _ the incoming electron line carrying momentum @xmath119 with the outgoing electron line carrying momentum @xmath117 . this produces the _ internal electron line _ [ intern ] carrying momentum @xmath119 between two vertices . in the expression ( [ eq:9.72 ] ) , the electron operators are in the normal order , however , the photon operators are not . the next step is to bring the photon operators to the normal order @xmath120 according to equation ( [ eq : cc ] ) , the normal ordering of photon operators in 3(b ) yields diagrams 3(d ) and 3(e ) . diagrams 3(f ) and 3(g ) are obtained from 3(c ) in a similar manner . using diagrams , with some practice , one can perform calculations of scattering operators ( [ eq:8.70 ] ) and ( [ eq:8.72 ] ) much easier than in the usual algebraic way . during these diagram manipulations we , actually , do not need to keep momentum labels of lines . the algebraic expression of the result can be easily restored from an unlabeled diagram by following these steps : * assign a distinct momentum label to each external line , except one , whose momentum is obtained from the momentum conservation condition . * assign momentum labels to internal lines so that the momentum conservation law is satisfied at each vertex . if there are _ loops _ , [ loop ] one needs to introduce additional independent _ loop momenta_. is the loop momentum . ] * read external lines from top to bottom of the order bar and write corresponding particle operators from left to right . * for each box , write a factor @xmath121 , where @xmath122 is the sum of energies of particles going out of the box and @xmath123 is the sum of energies of particles coming into the box . * write a factor @xmath124 , where @xmath125 is the energy function of the diagram which is the sum of energies of all outgoing external lines minus the sum of energies of all incoming external lines . * for each vertex introduce a factor @xmath126 , where @xmath127 is the momentum of the photon line attached to this vertex . * integrate the obtained expression by all independent external and loop momenta . let us now try to extract some physical information from the above theory . we will calculate low order terms in the perturbation expansion ( [ eq:8.70 ] ) for the @xmath0-operator . @xmath128 to obtain the corresponding contributions to the @xmath0-operator we need to take @xmath10-integrals of these expressions @xmath129 note that the right hand side of ( [ eq:9.73 ] ) and the first term on the right hand side of ( [ eq:9.74 ] ) are unphys . their energy shell is empty , so , according to table 1 , they do not contribute to the @xmath0-operator . operator @xmath130 on the right hand side of eq . ( [ eq:9.74 ] ) has two terms corresponding to two types of scattering processes allowed in the 2nd perturbation order . the term of the type @xmath131 ( see , e.g. , fig . 3(f ) ) annihilates an electron and a photon in the initial state and recreates them ( with different momenta ) in the final state . so , this term describes the electron - photon ( compton ) scattering . [ compton2 ] in this paper we will focus on the other term which describes the electron - electron scattering . let us consider in more detail the second - order contribution to this process ( see fig . 3(e ) ) @xmath132 & = & 2 \pi \int d \mathbf{p } d \mathbf{q } d \mathbf{k } \delta ( \omega_{\mathbf{p - k } } + \omega_{\mathbf{q+k } } -\omega_{\mathbf{q}}- \omega_{\mathbf{p } } ) d_2(\mathbf{p},\mathbf{q } , \mathbf{k } ) a^{\dag}_{\mathbf{p - k } } a^{\dag}_{\mathbf{q+k } } a_{\mathbf{q}}a_{\mathbf{p } } \label{eq:9.76}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the coefficient function in ( [ eq:9.76 ] ) can be read from the diagram , according to the rules ( i ) - ( vii ) , @xmath133 in the non - relativistic approximation ( @xmath134 ) , the coefficient function @xmath135 has singularity @xmath136 which is characteristic for scattering of two electrons interacting via repulsive coulomb potential [ coulomb1 ] @xmath137 so , our model theory is quite realistic . next consider the third term on the right hand side of eq . ( [ eq:9.74 ] ) . it is given by the diagram in fig . according to rules ( i ) - ( vii ) this diagram is represented by the expression @xmath138 there are serious problems with this term . first , the loop integral by @xmath127 is divergent because the integrand in ( [ eq:9.88 ] ) has asymptotic behavior @xmath139 at large @xmath140 . however , even if the integral were convergent , the presence of a renorm contribution in the operator @xmath32 is unacceptable , because , according to table 1 , the @xmath10-integral of any renorm term is infinite . so , the scattering phase in the second order @xmath141 is infinite , which is absurd . moreover , if we continued calculations ( [ eq:9.73 ] ) - ( [ eq:9.74 ] ) to higher perturbation orders we would find out that even phys terms in @xmath32 become infinite due to divergent loop integrals , so the theory with the hamiltonian ( [ eq : free - h0 ] ) - ( [ eq:9.69 ] ) is seriously flawed . in a consistent theory we must require that @xmath142 therefore , operator @xmath143 must be purely phys @xmath144 it was shown in ref . @xcite that condition ( [ eq:11.43 ] ) is equivalent to requiring that the @xmath0-operator leaves the vacuum and one - particle states invariant @xmath145 this is the _ mass renormalization condition _ of the traditional renormalization theory . to satisfy this condition , we must modify the hamiltonian ( [ eq : free - h0 ] ) - ( [ eq:9.69 ] ) by adding certain unphys @xmath146 and renorm @xmath147 _ counterterms _ to the interaction operator @xmath59 . in other words , we are saying that the original hamiltonian @xmath148 is not correct , and the modified hamiltonian with renormalization counterterms @xmath149 better describes interactions between particles . to comply with eq . ( [ eq:11.43 ] ) , we must choose the counterterms in such a way that operator @xmath150 does not contain renorm terms . from table 1 , it is clear that renorm terms in @xmath151 may appear due to the presence of renorm and unphys terms in @xmath152 and their products . so , in order to satisfy eq . ( [ eq:11.42 ] ) , there should be such a balance between unphysical and renorm terms in @xmath153 that all renorm terms in @xmath151 cancel out in all orders of the perturbation theory . the mass renormalization is achieved by adding renorm counterterms in even orders : @xmath154 , @xmath155 , etc . the charge renormalization procedure will be discussed in section [ ss : charge - renorm ] . it requires addition of unphys counterterms in odd orders @xmath156 , @xmath157 , etc . we take these considerations into account by writing the general expression for the hamiltonian of the renormalized theory - independent hamiltonian @xmath158 . although , at intermediate calculation steps it is convenient to keep all operators @xmath10-dependent , as in eq . ( [ eq:8.67 ] ) , in the end we should set @xmath19 . ] @xmath159 where @xmath160 we obtain formulas for @xmath161 ( @xmath162 ) by inserting interaction ( [ eq : inter ] ) in ( [ eq:8.70 ] ) and collecting terms of equal order . @xmath163 where we denoted @xmath164 now we go order - by - order and choose counterterms @xmath165 so that renorm terms are eliminated from the left hand sides of eqs ( [ eq:11.47 ] ) - ( [ eq:11.50 ] ) . the first - order term ( [ eq:11.47 ] ) is unphys , so there is no need for renormalization in the first order . to ensure that @xmath166 does not have a renorm part we choose the counterterm @xmath167 ( see diagram 3(g ) ) . with this choice , we can rewrite the contributions to the @xmath0-operator in the 4 lowest orders @xmath168 where @xmath169 and the superscript @xmath170 denotes the sum of phys and unphys terms . the term on the right hand side of ( [ eq:11.51 ] ) has odd number of particle operators , hence it is free of renorm parts ( which have either zero or two particle operators ) . therefore , no renorm counterterms should be added there . just as we did in the 2nd order , we can choose a renorm counterterm @xmath155 which simply cancels all renorm terms which may be present in the first three terms on the right hand side of ( [ eq:11.52 ] ) . with the above choices , the operator @xmath151 does not contain renorm terms up to the 4th order , as required by the mass renormalization condition , ) and in more realistic theories , such as qed , qcd , and standard model . products or commutators of such terms in ( [ eq:8.70 ] ) or ( [ eq:8.72 ] ) give rise to renorm terms in the @xmath0-operator which should be compensated by adding renorm terms to the hamiltonian . the operator structure of these terms is the same as in @xmath25 ( [ eq : free - h0 ] ) . this results in the difference of masses of bare and dressed particles , as discussed at the end of section [ ss : charge - renorm ] . ] and the expression for @xmath171 simplifies @xmath172 using the diagram technique we find that the @xmath173 part of the first two terms on the right hand side of eq . ( [ eq:11.55 ] ) is represented by 7 diagrams shown in fig . 4 . from diagram rules ( i ) - ( vii ) , we obtain the contribution of diagrams 4(a ) - 4(b ) to the coefficient function @xmath174 for the electron - electron scattering on the energy shell . @xmath175 where @xmath176 , @xmath177 , @xmath178 , and @xmath179 . unfortunately , this contribution is infinite ( at large values of @xmath180 the integrand behaves as @xmath181 ) . thus we conclude that the mass renormalization procedure described above has not removed all divergences . to solve this problem we need to perform the second renormalization step known as the charge renormalization procedure . this step is explained in the next section . first note that the divergent terms ( [ eq:11.58 ] ) have a singularity @xmath182 at @xmath183 . as we know from section [ ss : e - e - scatt ] , such a singularity is responsible for the low - energy electron - electron scattering at large distances . from classical physics we also know that long - distance interactions between charged particles depend on @xmath184 ( in our language , they are of the second perturbation order ) and they are accurately described by the 2nd order term ( [ eq : d2 ] ) . non - zero terms @xmath185 mean that the charge of the electron is modified by the interaction . actually , this modification is infinite , but even finite values of the terms like ( [ eq:11.58 ] ) are inconsistent with the classical limit . so , we will postulate that in orders higher that 2nd , singular coefficient functions like ( [ eq:11.58 ] ) should not be present at all , whether they are infinite or finite . this is the _ charge renormalization condition_. to eliminate the divergent contribution ( [ eq:11.58 ] ) we can choose unphys 3rd order counterterms @xmath186 . two diagrams describing these counterterms are shown in fig . 5(a ) and 5(b ) . as expected , they are infinite , and expressions @xmath187 in ( [ eq:11.52 ] ) exactly cancel unwanted infinite diagrams 4(a ) and 4(b ) on the energy shell . surviving diagrams 4(c ) - 4(g ) are the 4th order _ radiative corrections _ [ rad - corr ] to the electron - electron scattering . on the energy shell they yield the following contribution to the coefficient function of @xmath32 @xmath188 where @xmath189 the integrand in ( [ eq:11.59 ] ) is proportional to @xmath190 , and the integral is convergent at large values of the loop momentum @xmath180 . therefore @xmath191 is finite on the energy shell . so , in the renormalized theory the electron - electron scattering is represented by a finite @xmath0-operator which up to the 4th order is described by the coefficient function @xmath192 where @xmath193 is given by eq . ( [ eq : d2 ] ) and @xmath194 is given by eq . ( [ eq:11.59 ] ) . [ charge - end ] the renormalization technique presented above has not been applied to realistic theories , such as qed , yet . however , the close analogy between renormalization issues encountered in our toy model and in qed allows us to speculate that similar renormalization steps can be repeated in all perturbation orders in qed , so that finite and accurate values for various scattering amplitudes can be obtained . note that in our approach the counterterms in the hamiltonian ( [ eq : ren - ham ] ) have the same operator structure as the terms in the original hamiltonian ( [ eq : org - ham ] ) . in relativistic renormalizable theories , like qed , even stronger statements can be made : the mass renormalization counterterms differ from the one - particle energy terms in @xmath25 only by a constant ( but infinite ) factor , and the charge renormalization counterterms are equal to the interaction term @xmath21 in the original hamiltonian multiplied by a constant infinite factor . this conclusion is true in all perturbation orders . thus , if the original hamiltonian depends on finite masses @xmath195 , @xmath196 and coupling constants ( charges ) @xmath197 , @xmath198 @xmath199 then the addition of renormalization counterterms is equivalent to simply modifying ( making them infinite ) the values of masses and charges . the hamiltonian @xmath158 after renormalization has the same functional form as @xmath4 where parameters @xmath195 , @xmath196 and @xmath197 , @xmath198 substituted by renormalized ( infinite ) values @xmath200 , @xmath201 and @xmath202 , @xmath203 @xmath204 the traditional approach offers the following physical interpretation of these results . the creation and annihilation operators present in the theory describe so - called bare particles having infinite masses and charges . the interaction between bare particles drastically change their properties . for example , bare electrons constantly emit and re - absorb virtual photons and electron - positron pairs . so , bare electrons are surrounded by a coat of virtual particles . the mass of this coat is infinite , thus compensating the infinite mass of the bare particle . the virtual particles in the coat shield the true ( infinite ) charge of the bare electron . the resulting mass and charge of the dressed particle is finite and exactly equal to the parameters measured in experiment . in experiment , we never see the bare particles and their virtual coats , we only see the dressed particles . the hamiltonian @xmath158 is formally infinite , but these infinities cancel when the @xmath0-operator is calculated by formula ( [ eq:8.68 ] ) , and accurate results are obtained for scattering amplitudes and energies of bound states . however , the infinities do not cancel when one tries to find the eigenvectors of the hamiltonian @xmath158 or calculate the time evolution operator @xmath205 . direct application of this formula would lead to unphysical results . for example , if we calculated the time evolution of the simplest one - electron state we would obtain that this states dissociates into a complex linear combination of states over time @xmath206 moreover the coefficients multiplying the terms in ( [ eq : ihct ] ) are given by divergent integrals . therefore , with the infinite hamiltonian @xmath158 the basic formulas of quantum theory ( [ eq:1 ] ) and ( [ eq:8.60 ] ) become useless for practical calculations . however , in most cases this is not a cause of trouble . as discussed in section [ sc : bound - states ] , most experiments in high energy physics are concerned either with bound state energies or with scattering cross - sections . to calculate these properties , the knowledge of the @xmath0-operator is sufficient and the renormalized theory works fine . for approximate description of the time evolution in low energy , e.g. , atomic , systems , one can use heuristic approaches , such as those based on the dirac - fock hamiltonian . we see two fundamental problems with the traditional renormalization theory presented above . first , from the practical point of view , the absence of a well - defined finite hamiltonian does not allow one to study the time evolution of interacting states . one can expect that with advancement of experimental tools , the time - dependent information from the region of interaction will soon become available . however , accurate analysis of this information is not possible with ill - defined hamiltonians of renormalized quantum field theories . ) . ] second , from the theoretical point of view , the traditional approach operates with notions of bare and virtual particles that are , in principle , non - observable . it is desirable to have a theory formulated directly in terms of dressed particles and their interactions without mentioning the non - observable bare and virtual particles at all . this idea was first realized in the dressed particle formalism by greenberg and schweber @xcite . in the rest of this paper we will discuss the rqd approach @xcite which combines the similarity renormalization and dressed particle ideas . rqd is capable to fix the both problems of the traditional renormalization formalism mentioned above . let us first focus on the dressing part of rqd . there are two approaches to dressing with different interpretations but equivalent physical results . one approach @xcite tries to find an explicit unitary ( dressing ) transformation connecting creation and annihilation operators of bare particles ( @xmath207 , and @xmath208 ) with creation and annihilation operators of dressed particles ( @xmath209 , and @xmath83 ) and find a function @xmath210 which expresses the hamiltonian @xmath158 of the renormalized theory through dressed operators @xmath211 another approach @xcite is to pretend that operators @xmath207 , and @xmath208 already describe the dressed particles and try to find a new finite hamiltonian @xmath212 whose functional dependence on bare particle operators is given by the same function @xmath210 which expresses the dependence of @xmath158 on the dressed operators @xmath213 we will stick to the second approach in this paper . there are two ways to proceed . first , we can try to find @xmath212 by applying a unitary dressing transformation to @xmath158 . this way was described in ref . @xcite . in this paper we are choosing another route : we will simply fit the hamiltonian @xmath212 to the finite scattering operator @xmath214 known from the renormalized theory . there are three requirements that we want to satisfy when looking for the `` dressed particle '' hamiltonian @xmath215 . * @xmath212 is _ scattering - equivalent _ to @xmath158 . * @xmath216 is _ finite_. * @xmath216 is _ phys_. the condition ( a ) is understandable as we know that the @xmath0-operator of renormalized theories ( qed , standard model ) agrees well with experiments , and we would like to preserve this agreement in a theory with the new hamiltonian @xmath212 . using eqs . ( [ eq:8.71 ] ) and ( [ eq:8.72 ] ) we can write @xmath217 } \ldots \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] then we see that condition ( a ) implies the following infinite set of relations between @xmath218 and @xmath219 on the energy shell is preferable to the old - fashioned or dyson s formulas , because the right hand sides of eqs . ( [ eq:12.4 ] ) - ( [ eq:12.7 ] ) are expressed through commutators , so they are manifestly hermitian . in addition , this approach automatically generates cluster separable interactions @xmath220 ( see ref . @xcite ) . ] @xmath221 } \label{eq:12.6}\\ \underbrace{v_i^d(t ) } & = & \underbrace{f_i^c(t ) } + \underbrace{q_i(t ) } , \mbox { } i > 4 \label{eq:12.7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath222 denotes a sum of multiple commutators of @xmath223 from lower orders ( @xmath224 ) with @xmath10-integrations . we have expressions for operators @xmath225 and @xmath191 in the renormalized theory ( eqs . ( [ eq : d2 ] ) and ( [ eq:11.59 ] ) ) . clearly , we can perform similar calculations for operators @xmath219 whose values on the energy shell are present on the right hand sides of eqs . ( [ eq:12.4 ] ) - ( [ eq:12.7 ] ) . alternatively , we can express @xmath226 through @xmath151 using relationship ( [ eq:8.74 ] ) . operators @xmath219 are , of course , finite . this immediately implies that @xmath227 and @xmath228 are finite on the energy shell . moreover , from eqs . ( [ eq:8.74 ] ) and ( [ eq:11.43 ] ) it follows that @xmath229 and @xmath230 are phys on the energy shell . therefore , @xmath231 and @xmath232 can be also chosen phys on the energy shell . this proves that conditions ( b ) and ( c ) are satisfied on the energy shell up to the 3rd order . however , eqs . ( [ eq:12.4 ] ) - ( [ eq:12.7 ] ) tell us nothing about the behavior of @xmath227 and @xmath228 off the energy shell . the same is true for interactions in higher orders : the interaction operators @xmath220 off the energy shell remain undetermined by our condition ( a ) . this freedom in choosing interactions simply means that different choices of the coefficient functions of @xmath220 off the energy shell result in scattering equivalent hamiltonians . since our experimental knowledge about interactions in high energy physics is limited to their effects on scattering , we are allowed to freely choose the behavior of @xmath220 off the energy shell without any danger to get into contradiction with experiment . this freedom is exactly what is needed to satisfy conditions ( b ) and ( c ) in all orders . as we will see shortly , it is important to choose the behavior of @xmath218 such that their coefficient functions fall off rapidly when the arguments move away from the energy shell . is diagonal , this condition is equivalent to bringing the matrix of the hamiltonian to the band - diagonal form , which is the central idea of the similarity renormalization method @xcite . ] for example , we can choose the coefficient functions being proportional to @xmath233 where @xmath234 is a positive constant and @xmath2 is the energy function . to infinity . in this case , the coefficient functions of interaction operators @xmath235 become non - differentiable . this means that interaction is not separable @xcite , and the scattering theory formalism from section [ sc : bound - states ] is no longer applicable . ] then the electron - electron interaction in the second order takes the form @xmath236^{ph } \circ \zeta_2 \nonumber \\ & = & \frac { e^2 } { ( 2 \pi ) ^3 } \int d \mathbf{p } d \mathbf{q } d \mathbf{k } \frac { e^{- \gamma e^2}e^{-it e } } { |\mathbf{k}|(|\mathbf{k}| + \omega_{\mathbf{p - k } } - \omega_{\mathbf{p } } ) } a^{\dag}_{\mathbf{p - k } } a^{\dag}_{\mathbf{q+k } } a_{\mathbf{q}}a_{\mathbf{p } } \label{eq : el - el}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath237 is the energy function . there are no terms of the type @xmath173 in the 3rd order term @xmath238 . therefore the lowest ( 4th ) order radiative correction to the electron - electron interaction ( [ eq : el - el ] ) should be obtained from eq . ( [ eq:12.6 ] ) . as discussed above , the value of @xmath239 on the energy shell is finite . let us now consider the term @xmath240 } \label{eq:12.10}\end{aligned}\ ] ] on the right hand side of eq . ( [ eq:12.6 ] ) . first , we note that , according to table 1 , this commutator is phys . second , as we agreed above , the coefficient functions of @xmath227 fall off rapidly outside the energy shell . without this condition , the loop integrals encountered in calculations of ( [ eq:12.10 ] ) could be divergent . in our case these integrals are convergent : when the loop integration momentum goes to infinity , the @xmath227 factors in the integrand go away from the energy shell , i.e. , rapidly fall off . this guarantees that interaction @xmath241 is phys and finite on the energy shell . its coefficient function off the energy shell should be again chosen to decay rapidly to ensure the convergence of loop integrals in higher order operators @xmath222 , where @xmath241 may contribute . these arguments can be repeated in higher orders , which proves that the dressed particle hamiltonian @xmath212 is free of ultraviolet divergences . the contribution @xmath242 on the right hand side of eq . ( [ eq:12.6 ] ) is well - defined near the energy shell , but this is not true for the contribution @xmath243 $ ] . this commutator depends on the behavior of @xmath244 everywhere in the momentum space . so , it substantially depends on our choice of @xmath245 off the energy shell . there is a great freedom in this choice which is reflected in the uncertainty of @xmath246 even on the energy shell . it is interesting to note that although the off - shell behavior of the 2nd order interaction and the on - shell behavior of the 4th order interaction can not be separately determined in our theory , they are connected to each other in such a way that the ambiguity of the interaction does not affect the @xmath0-matrix for the electron - electron scattering . the above construction does not allow us to obtain full information about @xmath216 : the off - shell behavior of interactions is rather arbitrary , and the on - shell behavior can be determined only for lowest order terms . however , this uncertainty is perfectly understandable : it simply reflects the one - to - many correspondence between the @xmath0-operator and hamiltonians ( see section [ sc : bound - states ] ) . it means that there is a class of finite phys interactions @xmath247 all of which satisfy our requirements ( a ) - ( c ) and can be used for @xmath0-matrix calculations without encountering divergent integrals . in order to find the unique hamiltonian correctly describing the dynamics of particles , the theoretical predictions should be compared with time - resolved experimental data . however , our model theory is not sufficiently accurate to be comparable with experiment , and further efforts in this direction require building the dressed particle formulation of the full - blown quantum electrodynamics @xcite . @lll operator & physical meaning & perturbation & & orders & * elastic potentials & @xmath173 & electron - electron & @xmath248 @xmath249 & electron - photon ( compton ) & @xmath250 @xmath251 & 3-electron potential & @xmath252 & * inelastic potentials & @xmath253 & bremsstrahlung in electron - electron collisions & @xmath254@xmath255 & photon absorption in electron - electron collisions & @xmath254 * * in contrast to the original hamiltonian ( [ eq : org - ham ] ) , there seems to be no way to write the dressed particle hamiltonian @xmath212 in a closed form . from the derivation outlined above it is clear that in higher perturbation orders there are more and more terms with increasing complexity in the interaction operator @xmath216 . @xmath256 some of them are shown in table 2 . however , all these high order terms directly reflect real interactions and processes observable in nature . for example , the term @xmath253 ( _ bremsstrahlung _ ) [ bremsstr ] describes creation of a photon in electron - electron collisions . in the language of classical electrodynamics , this can be interpreted as radiation due to the acceleration during interaction of charged particles and is often referred to as the _ radiation reaction _ [ rad - res ] force . the hermitian - conjugated term @xmath255 describes absorption of a photon by a colliding pair of charged particles . note that in contrast to the traditional renormalization approach in which the mass renormalization condition ( [ eq:11.42 ] ) was ensured by maintaining a balance between unphys and renorm terms in the interaction , in the rqd hamiltonian these terms are absent altogether . the interaction operator @xmath216 is purely phys which guarantees that scattering operators @xmath257 and @xmath258 are phys too . the phys character of the interaction @xmath216 means that it yields zero when acting on the vacuum and one - particle states . interaction @xmath216 acts only when there are two or more dressed particles present . this is equivalent to saying that self - interaction effects are not present in the dressed particle approach . naturally , there should be no dressing in our theory , because we are working with particles which are already fully dressed . in this paper , we considered a model theory which provides a simplified description of interactions between electrons and photons , similar to exact interactions in qed . we found that in order to get sensible results for the @xmath0-matrix , the theory should be renormalized , just as qed , by adding infinite counterterms to the hamiltonian . we also demonstrated that the renormalized version of the theory can be reformulated entirely in terms of dressed particles and their interactions without affecting predictions of the theory about scattering cross - sections or bound state energies . the dressed particle hamiltonian @xmath212 is finite , thus , the ultraviolet divergences are not present anymore . there are no bare and virtual particles in the dressed particle approach . this simplifies substantially the physical interpretation of the theory . from the operator form of the dressed particle hamiltonian ( [ eq : dress ] ) it is clear that dressed particles interact with each other via instantaneous forces that generally do not conserve the number of photons i am thankful to drs . igor khavkine , arnold neumaier , and dan solomon for helpful comments , discussions , and criticism and to dr . arnold neumaier for drawing my attention to ref . @xcite and related works . w. magnus , _ on the exponential solution of differential equations for a linear operator _ , commun . pure appl . math . * 7 * ( 1954 ) , 649 ; p. pechukas and j. c. light , _ on the exponential form of time - displacement operators in quantum mechanics _ , j. chem * 44 * ( 1966 ) , 3897 . a. krger and w. glckle , _ one - nucleon effective generators of the poncar group derived from a field theory : mass renormalization _ , phys . c * 60 * ( 1999 ) , 024004 ; m. i. shirokov , _ mass renormalization using noncovariant perturbation theory _ , preprint jinr p2 - 2000 - 277 , dubna ( 2000 ) . a. v. shebeko and m. i. shirokov , _ unitary transformations in quantum field theory and bound states _ , fiz . yadra * 32 * ( 2001 ) , 31 [ english translation in phys . part . * 32 * ( 2001 ) , 15 ] , nucl - th/0102037 .

we illustrate the mass and charge renormalization procedures in quantum field theory using , as an example , a simple model of interacting electrons and photons . it is shown how addition of infinite renormalization counterterms to the hamiltonian helps to obtain finite and accurate results for the @xmath0-matrix . in order to remove the ultraviolet divergences from the hamiltonian , we apply the greenberg - schweber `` dressing transformation '' and the gazek - wilson `` similarity renormalization '' . the resulting `` dressed particle '' hamiltonian is finite in all orders of the perturbation theory and yields accurate @xmath0-matrix and bound state energies . the bare and virtual particles are removed from the theory , and physical dressed particles interact via direct action - at - a - distance .

astro-ph0102212

a year ago , there were a number of pieces of evidence that pointed to a connection between grbs ( gamma - ray bursts ) and snae ( supernovae ) ( see @xcite for a review ) . the positions of grbs in galaxies , near star forming regions , were consistent with a massive star origin . in addition to the association of grb 980425 with sn 1998bw , two distant grb afterglows showed evidence for supernovae in their light curves and spectra . in some cases , the afterglow evolution suggested interaction with a freely expanding stellar wind , as expected in the immediate vicinity of a massive star . although the evidence for an association with star forming regions has held up @xcite , the other topics have not provided further support . there have been no further convincing associations of supernovae with grb afterglows . dust echos have been proposed as the mechanism for the two apparent distant supernova cases that have been observed @xcite . the two best observed recent afterglows , grb 991208 and grb 000301c , have been interpreted in terms of expansion in a constant density medium , with jet effects @xcite . all these points weaken the case for a grb sn connection . here , i discuss these recent developments in the context of studies of supernovae and grb afterglows . the shock interactions of supernovae with circumstellar matter can be observed through radio synchrotron emission ( analogous to the synchrotron emission in grb afterglows ) and through x - ray thermal radiation . the radio light curves are characterized by an initial rise followed by a power law decline . a plot of the time of the light curve peak vs. the peak luminosity at that time sorts the observed supernovae into various types @xcite . these properties are related to the density of the gas into which the shock wave is propagating . except for sn 1987a , type ii supernovae are thought to have red supergiant progenitors , which have wind velocities of @xmath1 km s@xmath2 . the inferred mass loss rate from the progenitor of sn 1999em , a recently detected radio supernova @xcite , is @xmath3 . this may be typical of sn ii progenitors ; the well - observed type ii radio supernovae are probably at the upper end of a distribution of circumstellar densities . the most luminous radio supernovae are inferred to have @xmath4 . although some deviation from standard evolution has been found in radio supernovae with red supergiant progenitors @xcite the variations are small compared to those in sn 1987a . the well - known equatorial ring is at a radius of @xmath5 cm , but moderately dense gas probably extends in from this radius because of photoionization by the progenitor star @xcite . the radio luminosity was initially low compared to the red supergiant case because of interaction with the low density progenitor wind , but started to increase in 1990 and rapidly rose to @xmath6 times an extrapolation of the early decline @xcite . during the last few years , the supernova shock wave has started to interact with parts of the equatorial ring that are closest to the supernova @xcite . the changes in radio flux , which are more dramatic than any observed for other type ii supernovae , show what happens when a supernova shock wave runs into dense gas from an earlier evolutionary stage . at the present time , sn 1987a remains unique among the sn iiae and the precise causes for the progenitor evolution to the blue are not clear ; they may have to do with binary evolution . except for sn 1998bw , the sn ib / c that have been observed in the radio have similar properties @xcite . if they are able to efficiently radiate synchrotron emission , the radio flux is approximately in accord with @xmath7 and @xmath8 km s@xmath2 , as expected for a wolf - rayet star @xcite . except for sn 1998bw , the radio light curves show a smooth evolution , although the data are sparse . in the case of sn 1998bw , the observed rise in flux between days 20 and 30 @xcite is more likely to be due to an increase in the energy of the explosion than to an encounter with denser gas @xcite . the evolution is consistent with interaction with a @xmath0 wind extending out to at least @xmath9 cm . if grbs have massive star progenitors , they are likely to be wolf - rayet stars . arguments in favor of this assumption include : ( 1 ) sn 1998bw , the best case of a sn grb association ( grb 980425 ) , was of type ic , with a probable wolf - rayet progenitor . ( 2 ) the high energy of grbs suggest that a moderately massive black hole is involved , which , in turn , requires a massive , @xmath10 , progenitor @xcite . these stars are likely to be wolf - rayet stars at the end of their lives @xcite . ( 3 ) the relativistic flow from a central object may be able to penetrate a relatively compact wolf - rayet star , but probably can not penetrate an extended red supergiant star @xcite . none of these arguments is definitive , but they are suggestive . the grb rate is a small fraction of the sn rate so that a peculiar kind of star with an unusual surroundings could be involved . for example , a binary merger may be needed so that the central black hole has a large rotational energy . the merger process may be associated with a strong equatorial outflow of the stellar envelope . however , the relativistic flow is likely to be along the polar axis , where the mass loss properties may be normal . the best tests for afterglow models are sources with extensive data ; radio data are especially useful because they give information on the absorption frequency and the peak flux and its frequency . the extensive radio data @xcite on grb 970508 can be fitted by a model afterglow interacting with an @xmath11 wind , extending out to @xmath12 cm @xcite . frail et al . @xcite fit the same data by jet expansion in a uniform medium . in their model , jet effects become important at day 25 and there is a transition to spherical nonrelativistic flow at day 100 . the radio data on grbs 991208 and 000301c can also be approximately fitted by a wind model @xcite , but in these cases a broken power law spectrum is needed for the particles in order to fit the higher energy light curves . the jet in a uniform medium models for these objects can assume a single power law spectrum ; however , the evolution of grb 991208 is taken to be in the jet transition phase during the period of observation ( @xmath13 days ) @xcite , whereas grb 000301c is taken to have a sharp transition to asymptotic jet evolution on day 7.3 @xcite . a problem with the jet models is that the evolution is not well defined . the broken power law , wind models can be tested by late observations because different time dependences are expected at radio and optical wavelengths . the wind interaction models @xcite have not included jet effects , although a collimated flow is expected if it must escape from the center of a star . to some extent , this can be justified by the slow apparent evolution of a jet in a wind @xcite . the facts that many afterglows can be fitted by model evolution in a constant density medium and that massive stars are attractive progenitors have led to the suggestion @xcite that the expansion is into the constant density medium that is expected downstream from the termination shock of the massive star wind @xcite . the outer radius of such a region is @xmath14 times the inner radius when the fast wind from a wolf - rayet star runs into a slow wind from a previous evolutionary stage @xcite . models and observations of galactic wolf - rayet stars show that the swept - up shell of red supergiant material at the outer radius is at a distance @xmath15 pc from the star @xcite . this radius is sufficiently large that interaction with the free @xmath0 wind is expected over the typical period of observation of afterglows . the time for the wind to reach the termination shock is relatively short ( @xmath16 years to reach @xmath17 cm ) , so that the assumption of constant wind properties is plausible . in a massive star progenitor model , a high density in the immediate vicinity of the explosion is expected even if the wind passes through a termination shock at a relatively small radius . the prompt optical emission from a grb gives the opportunity to investigate the immediate surroundings ; in the case of grb 990123 , low density ( interstellar medium ) interaction gives a better explanation for the observations @xcite . despite the plausibility of free wind interaction , the uncertainty in the evolution of massive stars leaves open the possibility of interaction with denser material at early times ; ramirez - ruiz et al . @xcite have investigated such a case . the interaction of a grb flow with a dense shell could have different properties compared to a supernova , as exemplified by sn 1987a . in the supernova case , the shock front is continually driven by the lower velocity supernova ejecta with most of the kinetic energy . most grb afterglow models have constant energy , so that although an initial overpressure can be expected upon a collision with a shell , it is not as marked as in the supernova case . in addition , the grb flow is likely to be in a jet , unlike the supernova case . when the beamed flow interacts with a large density jump , it is rapidly decelerated and lateral spreading can occur . the afterglow could make a rapid transition to the asymptotic behavior for a jet flow @xcite . the afterglow of grb 000301c did show a bump followed by a transition to a steeper decline that could be lateral jet expansion , although the bump can be interpreted as a microlensing event @xcite . the possibility of circumstellar dust echos arises naturally for type ii supernovae with red supergiant progenitors because their cool winds are known to contain dust . for the higher estimated mass loss rates , e.g. , @xmath18 for sn 1979c , the progenitor star is expected to be entirely enshrouded in dust . yet when we observe type ii supernovae , there is little evidence for dust absorption in the spectra of the supernovae , including sn 1979c . the probable solution is that the dust near the star is evaporated by the radiation from the supernova and the remaining dust does not have a large optical depth . the radius at which dust becomes so hot that it is evaporated , @xmath19 , occurs at @xmath20 cm for typical supernova and dust parameters @xcite . the circumstellar dust beyond @xmath19 can give rise to infrared and scattered light echos . both sn 1979c and sn 1980k showed evidence for infrared excesses that might be attributable to dust echos @xcite . the late optical light from these supernovae appeared to be dominated by emission from the circumstellar shock wave interactions and did not show dust scattering effects @xcite . roscherr and schaefer @xcite have recently examined the emission from sn iin to search for scattered light echos , but again found that the late emission is dominated by circumstellar shock interactions . circumstellar scattered light echos have been observed around sn 1987a @xcite because it was possible to spatially resolve the echos away from the supernova ; it would not have been possible to observe the echos for a supernova at a typical distance . no evidence for circumstellar dust echos has been found in type ib / c supernovae , which is not surprising considering their presumed wolf - rayet star progenitors . wolf - rayet stars atmospheres are too hot for dust formation . despite this , circumstellar dust has been found in a small fraction of these stars . the source appears to be the compressed interaction region where the wolf - rayet star wind collides with the wind from a close companion , as indicated by the pinwheel dust patterns observed around two wolf - rayet stars @xcite . dust may be more commonly present in circumstellar shells at radii @xmath15 pc , but such shells would have only a small dust optical depth . circumstellar dust echos have been of recent interest for grb afterglows because of the possibility that they could explain the excess emission observed in two sources at ages @xmath21 days without the need for a supernova @xcite . an echo from thermal re - radiation by dust is too red to explain the observations , so the scattered light explanation is considered here @xcite . the timescale for the emission sets the dust at a radial distance of @xmath22 cm and its color requires an optical depth at 3000 of 7 @xcite . the required dust mass is @xmath23 or @xmath24 total mass in the shell . if the gas is moving out as part of the stellar wind , special timing is needed to have much of the envelope mass end up at the appropriate radial distance . thus , on the basis of the fact that the most plausible massive star progenitors for grbs ( wolf - rayet stars ) do not typically have dusty winds plus the special conditions that are needed for the dust if present , the supernova hypothesis appears to be a more natural explanation for the excess light than a dust echo . reichart @xcite has recently examined detailed models for circumstellar echos and found that the colors of the excess light of grb 970228 are inconsistent with an echo . even if the excess light could be explained as a scattered light echo , the implication would be that the progenitor object was a massive star which was a red supergiant at the time of the explosion or soon before the explosion . in addition to circumstellar dust echos , dust in interstellar clouds can give rise to echo phenomena . in the supernova case , the well - known rings around sn 1987a are due to clouds that are 100 pc or more in front of the supernova @xcite . similar scattered light echos have been observed around the type ia supernovae sn 1991 t and sn 1998bu @xcite . the echo phenomenon is characterized by a flattening of the supernova light curve , a late spectrum related to the spectrum near maximum light , and a significant spatial size related to the distance of the interstellar cloud in front of the supernova . if the peak luminosity , @xmath25 , of the supernova or grb lasts for a time @xmath26 , the ratio of the echo luminosity to @xmath25 is @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is the dust optical depth , @xmath29 is the speed of light , @xmath30 is the phase function ( forward scattering is expected ) , @xmath31 is the distance of the cloud in front of the explosion , and single scattering is assumed @xcite . this can explain the @xmath32 magnitude decline from peak to flattening of the light curve in the 3 observed echos . grb 990123 has the best defined afterglow optical light curve ; it peaked at @xmath33 mag . and subsequently declined more rapidly than @xmath34 so that most of the radiated energy appeared near the peak . if a similar cloud were placed in front of grb 990123 to those in front of snae 1991 t and 1998bu , the fact that @xmath35 sec for grb 990123 , but is @xmath36 days for the supernovae would make the luminosity @xmath37 fainter compared to the peak luminosity this would give an echo magnitude @xmath38 , which is undetectable . the angular radius of the echo from the explosion is @xmath39 rad , which could be outside the beamed emission from a grb , further reducing the echo brightness . it is only for a relatively nearby grb with a favorable distribution of dust that there is any chance of detecting an echo . the best candidates for an echo would be sources that show evidence for dust in the host galaxy , e.g. , grb 000418 @xcite . such a detection would be of interest in that it would give information on the very early optical luminosity of the burst . s. r. kulkarni , e. berger , et al . : ` the afterglows of gamma - ray bursts ' . in : _ gamma - ray bursts : 5th huntsville symposium_. ed . by r.m . kippen , r.s . mallozzi , g.j . fishman ( aip , new york 2000 ) pp .

although observations of circumstellar shock interactions around supernovae are generally consistent with a @xmath0 wind surrounding the progenitor star , this is not true for grb ( gamma - ray burst ) afterglows . however , grb 991208 and grb 000301c may be consistent with wind interaction if the injection particle spectrum is a broken power law . circumstellar dust echos can place constraints on supernova and grb progenitors , but have been clearly observed only around sn 1987a . excess emission observed in two grb afterglows is more likely to have a supernova origin . an interstellar dust echo , causing the light curve to flatten out , is a possibility for grb afterglows , but is not likely to be observable .

1609.01693

we propose an eulerian approach towards motion representation learning . the main difference between lagrangian and eulerian motion is that lagrangian motion ( optical flow ) focuses on individual points and analyzes their change in location over time . therefore , lagrangian motion performs tracking of points over time and for this it requires a unique matching method between point or patches . on the other hand , eulerian motion considers a set of locations in the image and analyzes the changes at these locations over time . thus , eulerian motion does not estimate where a given point moves to , instead , it measures flux properties . figure [ fig : eulerian ] depicts this difference between eulerian and lagrangian motion . as a specific instance of the eulerian model , we consider phase - based motion . the phase variations over time of the coefficients of the complex - steerable pyramid are indicatives of motion @xcite and form the basis for learning motion representations . the gain of an eulerian motion approach is that it avoids the need for hand - crafted optical flow constructions . phase is an innate property of the image , it does not need to be estimated from explicit patch correspondences . we propose a general - purpose phase - based motion description learning setup that can be used in any task relying on motion . here we explore four use cases : ( i ) action recognition , ( ii ) motion prediction in static images , ( iii ) motion transfer in static images and , ( iv ) motion transfer in video . note that phase - based motion representations are readily applicably to other motion - related task as well , including : human gait analysis , object tracking , action localization , etc . eulerian motion modeling has shown remarkable results for motion magnification @xcite where a phase - based approach significantly improves the quality @xcite and broadens its application @xcite . a phase - based video interpolation is proposed in @xcite and a phase - based optical flow estimation is proposed in @xcite . inspired by the these work , we advocate the use of the eulerian model as exemplified by phase for learning motion representations . optical flow - based motion features have been extensively employed for action recognition in works such as @xcite . these works , use hand crafted features extracted from the optical flow . instead , we propose to input phase - based motion measurements to a cnn to reap the benefits of deep feature representation learning methods . a natural extension of going beyond a single frame in a deep net is by using 3@xmath0 space - time convolutions @xcite . 3@xmath0 convolutions learn appearance and motion jointly . while elegant , it makes it difficult to add the wealth of information that is available for appearance - only datasets through pre - training . in our method , we keep the benefit of pre - training by separating the appearance and the phase - based motion streams . using pre - trained networks is possible in the two - stream network approaches proposed in @xcite . this combines a multi - frame optical flow network stream with an appearance stream and obtains competitive results in practice . the appearance stream can employ a pretrained network . similarly , we also consider the combination of appearance and motion in a two - stream fashion , but with innate phase information rather than using a hand - crafted optical flow . the temporal frame ordering is exploited in @xcite , where the parameters of a ranking machine are used for video description . while in @xcite recurrent neural networks are proposed for improving action recognition . in this paper we also model the temporal aspect , although we add the benefit of a two - stream approach by separating appearance and phase variation over time . in @xcite , optical flow motion is learned from videos and predicted in static images in a structured regression formulation . in @xcite the authors propose predicting optical flow in a cnn from input static images . where these works predict optical flow , we propose to predict the motion through phase changes , which does not depend on pixel tracking . predicting the future rgb frame from the current rgb frame is proposed in @xcite in the context of action prediction . similar to this work , we also start from an input appearance and obtain an output appearance image , however in our case the learning part learns the mapping from input phase information to future phase . animating a static image by transferring the motion from an input video is related to the notion of artistic style transfer @xcite . the style transfer aims at changing an input image or video such that the artistic style matches the one of a provided target image . here , instead , we consider the motion transfer given an input image , transfer the phase - based motion from the video to the image . additionally , we also consider video - to - video transfer where the style of performing a certain action is transferred from a target video to the input video . in @xcite the authors allow the users to change the video by adding plausible object manipulations in the video . similar to this work , we also want to change the video motion after the recording is done , by adjusting the style of the action being performed . the local phase and amplitude of an image are measured by complex oriented filters of the form : @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the filter orientation and @xmath3 the filter scale @xcite , @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the local phase at scale @xmath3 and orientation @xmath2 , and @xmath6 the amplitude , @xmath7 is the image brightness / input channel , and @xmath8 the convolution operator , and @xmath9 are image coordinates . the filters have multiple scales and orientations , forming a complex steerable pyramid @xcite which captures various levels of image resolution . there is a direct relation between motion and the change measured in phase over time . the fourier shift theorem makes the connection between the variation in phase of the subbands over time and the global image motion . rather than estimating global motion , using a steerable pyramid we can decompose the image into localized subbands and thus , recover the local motion in the phase variations over time . from the above decomposition only the phase , not the amplitude , corresponds to motion . in @xcite the authors show that the temporal gradient of phase computed from a spatially bandpassed video over time , directly relates to the motion field . therefore , here , we focus on local phase at multiple scales and orientations to represent motion . we propose using phase to learn motion representations for solving general motion - related tasks in a deep net . we add phase as an additional motion input channel to a standard appearance ( rgb ) convolutional deep neural network . figure [ fig : idea ] shows our proposed general - purpose phase - based pipeline . the input video frame is decomposed using the complex steerable pyramid into amplitude and phase . both phase and amplitude have multiple corresponding orientations and scales . since the phase is an indicative of motion , we ignore the amplitude and we use the input phase for the motion representation learning . we treat the orientations as input channels while the scales represent different streams of the network , similar to @xcite who use this setup for a different image pyramid . we explore phase - based motion representation learning in four practical use cases . while a thorough in - depth experimental investigation is out of scope , we detail the setup of motion representation learning for each use case . [ cols="^,^ " , ] separating appearance and motion in two - streams is effective for action recognition @xcite . for the appearance stream we follow @xcite and use the input rgb frame , which offers the advantage of pre - training features on static images . however , where @xcite uses hand - crafted optical flow features , we propose to use eulerian motion for the second stream with oriented phase over multiple scales , as depicted in figure [ fig : action ] . for evaluating action recognition , a comparison of our two - stream phase - based motion with the two - stream optical - flow approach of @xcite on the two datasets used in their paper hmdb51 and ucf101 is needed . we expect benefits from a phase - based motion representation because it does not depend on a specific hand - crafted optical flow implementation and does not rely on pixel tracking . the benefit of eulerian motion for motion prediction is that the prediction locations are fixed over time . this contrasts sharply with lagrangian motion , as pixels tracked by optical flow may be lost as they move in or out of the frame , or move to the same spatial location . such lost pixels make it hard to recover long - term relations beyond just the next frame . the fixed prediction locations of a eulerian motion representation do not suffer from this and offer long - term relation predictions of several frames . we propose to learn from a given input rgb the output future rgb , by recovering from the rgb the phase scales and orientations , then predicting the multi - scale future phase - orientations and transforming them back into future rgb frames as in figure [ fig : phase_prediction].(a ) . for long - term motion prediction we propose an rnn ( recurrent neural network ) version of this phase - based frame prediction , as depicted in figure [ fig : phase_prediction].(b ) . thus , predicting motion @xmath10 timesteps away from the input . for evaluating motion prediction we use the same datasets as in @xcite hmdb51 and ucf101 , where the authors aim at predicting optical - flow based motion in single images . to evaluate the difference between the predicted motion and the actual video motion , we use pixel accuracy , as in our method we recover the appearance of the future frame . for comparison with @xcite which reports epe ( end point errors ) , we use their chosen optical flow estimation algorithm to recover optical flow from our predicted rgb . similar to @xcite , where the style of a given target painting is transferred to another image , we propose to transfer the short motion of a given video sequence to an input static image . in @xcite a combination of two losses is optimized : content loss which ensures that the objects present in the newly generated image remain recognizable and correspond to the ones in the input image , and a style loss which imposes that the artistic style of the new image is similar to the one of the provided target painting . for motion transfer we have an additional requirement , namely that parts of the image that are similar e.g. horses , people , should move similar . for this we use two pretrained network streams , an rgb stream and a phase stream and consider certain convolutional layers along these streams for estimation rgb / phase responses . therefore , we first estimate an element - wise correlation between the responses at a given convolutional network layer of the input rgb values of the static image and the target video frame : @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the number of channels in the layer @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 the responses at layer @xmath13 for the input image and video frame , respectively . following @xcite , we subsequently define our motion - style loss by weighting the feature maps in the gram matrix computation by the appearance correlation . the motion transfer is obtained by enforcing that the phase of objects over time in the input image , should be similar to the phase over time of the same objects present in the target video . the motion - style loss optimization is performed per phase - scale . @xmath16 & = \sum_k^{m_l } \mathcal{k}^l_k f^l_\sigma[ik ] f^l_\sigma[kj],\text { } i , j\in \{1, .. n_l\},\\ a^l_\sigma[ij ] & = \sum_k^{m_l } \mathcal{k}^l_k p^l_\sigma[ik ] p^l_\sigma[kj],\text { } i , j\in \{1, .. n_l\},\\ \mathcal{l}_l & = \sum_\sigma \frac{1}{n_l^2 m_l^2}\sum_{i , j}^{n_l } \mathcal{k}^l_j ( g^l_\sigma[ij ] - a^l_\sigma[ij])^2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath17 is the number of elements in one channel of layer @xmath13 , @xmath3 indicates the phase - scale , and @xmath18 is the weighted gram matrix of the phase - image to be generated , while @xmath19 is the weighted gram matrix of the current video frame and , @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the responses of the phase - image to be generated and the phase - image of the input video frame , respectively . because we want the find similar looking objects by using the element - wise correlations , we expect that the higher convolutional levels of the network will perform better . we additionally also add the content loss term of @xcite to avoid large distortions of the image appearance . due to the input being a static image , only short video motions can be transferred in this case . for evaluating motion transfer , we perform a two - step evaluation . in the first step , we select an existing video frame and transfer the video motion to the selected frame and compare the transferred motion with the actual video motion . for this we use videos from hmdb51 and ucf101 . the second evaluation is transferring the motion to actual static images . for this we select images from the static willow dataset @xcite and transfer the motion of corresponding videos from the hmdb51 and ucf101 datasets containing the same objects . for this we provide the static images animated with the transferred video motion . + we use as a starting point the work of @xcite , where artistic style is transferred to video . however in our case , the motion of one given video is transferred to another input video . the gain in so doing , is that we can transfer the style of performing a certain action . for example an amateur performing the moonwalk can be lifted to the expert level by transferring the motion of michael jackson himself . the idea of transferring motion in videos is similar to the idea of transferring motion in static images , with the additional constraint that the motion must be temporally coherent . for this , similar to @xcite , we add a temporal loss term to the motion transfer loss discussed in section [ ssec : transfer_im ] . for performing motion transfer between videos , we use a set of target videos : the walk of charlie chaplin , the moonwalk of michael jackson , and the walk of a runway model . we transfer these walking styles to a set of input videos of people walking , and provide the results as a qualitative form of evaluation . here . ] , we show a very simple proof of concept for phase - based motion transfer . we animate a static image by transfering the motion of another semantic related video . correctly aligning the moving entities between the video frames and the static image is essential for this task . for this proof of concept the alignment was not very good and no learning was used whatsoever . misalignment errors show up as artifacts in the results and we expect that adding ( deep ) learning will improve results . we propose an eulerian phase - based approach to motion representation learning . we argue for the intrinsic stability offered by the phase - based motion description . a phase - based approach does not require pixel tracking and directly encodes flux . phase is an innate property of an image and does not rely on hand - crafted optical - flow algorithms . we explore a set of motion learning tasks in an eulerian setting : ( a ) action recognition , ( b ) motion prediction in static images , ( c ) motion transfer from a video to a static image and ( d ) motion transfer in videos . for each one of these tasks we propose a phase - based approach and provide a small proof of concept . we do not offer in - depth experimental results but instead make a case for a brave new motion representation with phase .

this work advocates eulerian motion representation learning over the current standard lagrangian optical flow model . eulerian motion is well captured by using phase , as obtained by decomposing the image through a complex - steerable pyramid . we discuss the gain of eulerian motion in a set of practical use cases : ( i ) action recognition , ( ii ) motion prediction in static images , ( iii ) motion transfer in static images and , ( iv ) motion transfer in video . for each task we motivate the phase - based direction and provide a possible approach .

1101.3731

understanding the behavior of low - dimensional electronic systems has been one of the main challenges of experimental and theoretical physics in the last years . these systems are important not only as the basic building blocks of nanoelectronic devices , but also for the intricate strongly - correlated phenomena they exhibit . an important subclass is that of metallic ( gapless ) one - dimensional systems , whose low energy dynamics is governed not by fermi liquid theory , but instead by the luttinger liquid ( ll ) paradigm @xcite . this description applies to a wide variety of experimental realizations , including narrow quantum wires in semiconducting heterostructures , metallic nanowires , and carbon nanotubes . closely related are chiral lls , formed at the edges of fractional quantum hall effect ( fqhe ) systems @xcite , and helical lls , the edges of spin quantum hall insulators @xcite . the effect of impurities on these systems is interesting from both the applicative and fundamental points of view . these impurities could also be intentionally introduced , in the form of , e.g. , quantum dots and anti - dots . hence , there is no wonder that such questions have attracted much effort recently . however , most of these studies were restricted to investigation of transport phenomena @xcite , while other effects received much less attention @xcite . in this work we study probably the most basic example of such a system , namely , a single level in the vicinity of a fractional quantum hall edge , or , equivalently @xcite , a level attached to the end of a single ll wire @xcite . we will refer to the two components ( in both systems ) as `` dot '' and `` lead '' respectively . we include in our treatment the effects of short range dot - lead interaction , as well as the influence of an ohmic dissipative bath ( e.g. , electromagnetic fluctuations in gate electrodes ) @xcite . in a recent work @xcite we have studied the thermodynamic properties of the model ( e.g. , the level population , entropy , and specific heat ) , and found that they are _ universal _ , in the sense that they depend on the various interactions in the model ( intra - lead , dot - lead , and dot - bath ) only through a single parameter , the fermi edge singularity exponent . thus , thermodynamics can neither be used to identify non - fermi liquid behavior , nor to extract ll parameters . in this work we proceed to study , both analytically and numerically , the level density of states ( ldos ) , which may be probed by tunneling or absorption spectroscopies . we find that the ldos is sensitive to ll physics , even though its integral ( times the fermi function ) gives the level occupancy , which is universal in the above sense . as we show below , the ldos features power - law behavior near the fermi energy . for not too strong interactions the exponent in this power - law is actually determined by ll physics alone , and is independent of the level - lead and level - bath interactions . this and many other results derived below can not be achieved using perturbative calculations @xcite . the rest of this paper is organized as follows : in sec . [ sec : model_cg ] we present our model , and apply to it the anderson - yuval coulomb - gas ( cg ) expansion @xcite . we then proceed to analytic treatment of the ldos in sec . [ sec : analysis ] , and to numerical calculations in sec . [ sec : numerics ] . finally , we summarize our findings in sec . [ sec : conclude ] . the system is described by the hamiltonian @xmath0 . the first term is the dot hamiltonian @xmath1 , with @xmath2 and @xmath3 the level creation and annihilation operators , respectively , and @xmath4 the level energy . the second term is the lead hamiltonian . it can be written in the form @xmath5 ^ 2 dx,\ ] ] using _ chiral _ bosonic field @xmath6 obeying the commutation relation @xmath7 = i \pi \text{sgn}(x - y)$ ] , where @xmath8 is the velocity of excitations @xcite . the level and the lead are coupled by : @xmath9 the two terms in this equation describe , respectively , dot - lead hopping ( with @xmath10 the tunneling matrix element ) , and local dot - lead interaction whose strength is @xmath11 . the electronic annihilation operator at the end of the lead can be written as @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is a majorana operator , @xmath14 is a short distance cutoff ( e.g. , the lattice spacing ) , and @xmath15 is the ll interaction parameter ( @xmath16 for repulsion , @xmath17 for attraction ) . for a fqhe system with filling @xmath18 , @xmath19 for electron tunneling ( i.e. , a dot outside the fqhe bar ) . finally , the level is coupled to a bath of harmonic oscillators @xcite ( describing , e.g. , electromagnetic fluctuations in control gates ) , governed by @xmath20 . the dot - bath coupling can be written as @xmath21 . we assume ohmic dissipation , i.e. , linear low - frequency behavior of the bath spectral function : @xmath22 . we examine this model employing the anderson - yuval cg expansion @xcite . in this approach , any quantity of interest is expanded to all orders in @xmath10 . this results in a series of correlation functions , which need to be evaluated for vanishing @xmath10.@xcite the level - lead interaction gives rise to a potential at the end of the lead , which alternates between @xmath23 and @xmath24 whenever an electron tunnels in or out of the level . similarly , the @xmath25th bath oscillators experience a shift in its equilibrium position , proportional to @xmath26 . we thus have a sequence of fermi edge singularity events @xcite . the solution of this latter problem enables the calculation of all the terms in the series of correlation functions . recently @xcite we have studied in this way the partition function @xmath27 of the model , whose derivatives with respect to the parameters of the system ( for example , the level energy @xmath4 and the temperature @xmath28 ) give us the thermodynamic properties ( e.g. , the level population , entropy , and specific heat ) . we were able to rewrite the series expansion for @xmath27 in the form of a grand canonical partition function of a classical system of particles . these represent hopping events generated by @xmath10 , and thus reside on the imaginary time axis of the original quantum model , which is a circle with circumference @xmath29 . each particle is assigned a positive ( negative ) charge if it represents tunneling of an electron from the lead to the dot ( from the dot to the lead ) . hence , there must be an even number of charges , which have to appear in alternating order of signs . the position of the @xmath30th particle is @xmath31 , and the sign of the charge of the first particle is denoted by @xmath32 . the partition function then reads : @xmath33 the charges have a fugacity @xmath34 , where @xmath35 is the noninteracting level width [ @xmath36 is the corresponding lead local density of states ] , and @xmath37 is a short - time cutoff . the cg action is given by : @xmath38 } \right\ } v_{c } ( \tau_j-\tau_i ) + \\ \varepsilon_0 \left [ \frac{1-s}{2 t } + s \sum_{i=1}^{2n } ( -1)^i \tau_i \right].\end{gathered}\ ] ] the first term of this classical hamiltonian describes an interaction between the particles , with @xmath39 \}$ ] . this interaction is similar in form to 2d coulomb interaction , and is the origin of the name `` cg expansion '' . the charges are two component vectors , where the two components correspond to the effects of the coupling with the lead and the bath , respectively . they are given by @xmath40 , where the squared - magnitude of the charges , to be denoted by @xmath41 , is the fermi edge singularity exponent of the model . it is defined by behavior of the zero - temperature correlator of @xmath42 with its hermitian conjugate , calculated at @xmath43 . this correlator decays as @xmath44 for long time @xmath45 . in our system we have found that @xmath46 , where @xmath47 is the effective phase shift in the lead due to the dot - lead coupling @xcite . it is equal to @xmath48 in straightforward bosonization , but is more complicated in general . it may be extracted from , e.g. , finite - size energy differences , which could be calculated either numerically or analytically ( via the bethe ansatz ) @xcite . the other part of the cg action accounts for the energetic cost of @xmath4 per unit imaginary time for each interval in which the level is populated . its form is analogous to an electric field applied to the classical system of charges . a typical configuration is depicted in fig . [ fig : cg](a ) . a similar treatment can be given to the ldos , which we shall denote by @xmath49 . it is equal to the imaginary part of the level retarded green function ( multiplied by @xmath50 ) . the retarded green function is in turn the result of analytic continuation of the matsubara green function from the upper half of the complex frequency plane @xcite . the latter green function is defined by @xmath51 , where @xmath52 is the imaginary time ordering operator . following the same methods as above , the numerator of this expression can also be given a cg representation . this cg has the same form as eqs . ( [ eqn : cg_z1])([eqn : cg_z2 ] ) , with two additional charges of sizes @xmath53 , @xmath54 , inserted at @xmath55 and @xmath56 , respectively . these charges correspond to the level creation and annihilation operators appearing in the definition of the green function . in the following we will refer to these as `` d - charges '' , to distinguish them form the other `` @xmath10-charges '' , which originate from the @xmath10 term . the contribution of each such configuration is to be multiplied by @xmath57 to account for the fermi statistics . thus , for @xmath58 the full cg expression for the dot green function is : @xmath59 e^{- s_{cg , d } ( s , \tau , \tau^\prime , \ { \tau_i \ } ) } , \end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath60 . the first @xmath61 @xmath10-charges occupy the interval @xmath62 $ ] , the following @xmath63 charges reside in the interval @xmath64 $ ] , and the last @xmath65 @xmath10-charges are in the interval @xmath66 $ ] . the classical action is given by : @xmath67 - |\vec{e}_d|^2 v_c ( \tau-\tau^\prime ) + \\ \varepsilon_0 \left [ \frac{1-s}{2 t } - \sum_{i=1}^{2n } s_i \tau_i + \tau - \tau^\prime \right],\end{gathered}\ ] ] where the sign of the @xmath30th @xmath10-charge is @xmath68 . a typical configuration is shown in fig . [ fig : cg](b ) . similar expressions hold for @xmath69 . comparing the two cg expansions , the following observation emerges : the cg expansion for the partition function contains only three parameters : @xmath70 , @xmath4 , and @xmath71 , while expansion for the green function depends on @xmath15 too ( through @xmath72 ) . hence , the different interaction types ( i.e. , interactions in the wire , the dot - wire interaction , and the dot - bath coupling ) affect the partition function through a single parameter , the fermi edge singularity exponent @xmath71 . thus , thermodynamic measurements can not be used to distinguish between the different interaction types . in other words , one can construct very different models , whose interactions differ in strength and even in sign , which will have the same thermodynamic properties , provided @xmath70 , @xmath4 , and @xmath71 are indeed the same @xcite . on the other hand , the ldos , which depends _ explicitly _ on @xmath15 , will exhibit different behavior for these different systems . hence , it can be used to extract the strength of intra - wire interactions , as we show below . as noted in our earlier work @xcite , the cg obtained here is identical to the original anderson - yuval expansion @xcite for the anisotropic single - channel kondo model @xcite , demonstrating that the models are equivalent @xcite . under this mapping the level population becomes the magnetization of the kondo spin ( plus one half ) . hence , @xmath4 is analogous to a local magnetic field . similarly , @xmath73 is related to @xmath70 , and @xmath74 to @xmath71 . the cg parameters obey the famous kondo renormalization group ( rg ) equations @xcite , which read , in our notations : @xmath75 thus , the system considered can be in one of two phases , a strong coupling ( antiferromagnetic - kondo like ) phase and a weak coupling ( ferromagnetic - kondo like ) phase . the transition occurs , for small @xmath70 , at @xmath76 . in the weak - coupling phase the coulomb charges form tightly - bound pairs . the level is thus effectively decoupled at low energies , resulting in its population being discontinuous as a function of @xmath4 at zero temperature @xcite . in the strong - coupling phase free coulomb charges proliferate . the impurity is well - coupled with the lead , so the level population is analytic in @xmath4 , and could be extracted from the bethe ansatz solution of the kondo problem @xcite . in particular , for small values of @xmath4 one has @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the kondo temperature ( effective level width , reducing to @xmath70 in the noninteracting case ) @xcite . hence , in this phase the population does not exhibit any nontrivial power - law dependence on @xmath4 or @xmath28 . the same applies to other thermodynamic quantities . what are the implications of this on the ldos ? as we now show , we typically find that at zero temperature we have a power - law behavior @xmath79 in the vicinity of the fermi energy , i.e. , when @xmath80 is much smaller than @xmath81 in the strong - coupling phase , and than the bandwidth @xmath82 in the weak - coupling phase . the values of @xmath83 in the different regimes are summarized in table [ tbl : rho_d ] . it should be noted that when @xmath84 , or when the lead length @xmath85 is finite , such power - law singularity will be smeared and become @xmath86^\delta$ ] . we will now consider each phase separately . . [ tbl : rho_d ] summary of the analysis of sec . [ sec : analysis ] . in the vicinity of the fermi energy ( when @xmath80 and @xmath28 are much smaller than @xmath81 in the strong - coupling phase , and than the bandwidth @xmath82 in the weak - coupling phase ) we have @xmath87^\delta$ ] , with the values of the exponent @xmath83 in the different regimes denoted in the table below . when two values are given , the smaller one will give the dominant contribution @xcite . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] similar considerations apply to the screened d - charges contribution [ fig . [ fig : cg_gp](a ) ] when @xmath88 . for @xmath89 and/or @xmath90 , two corrections are due . the first correction takes into account the factors coming from the interaction between each d - charge and the neighboring @xmath10-charge , which are power - laws in the time domain . since the d-@xmath10 charges form tightly - bound pairs , we can take the limits of integration over their separation to infinity . they thus yield factors of @xmath91 where @xmath92 is the gamma function @xcite , and @xmath93 . the correction is then the ratio between this expression and its value at @xmath94 . apart from this constant factor , one must compensate for the fact that the inter - pair interaction of these two d-@xmath10 pairs gives the green function a factor which varies as @xmath95 ( since @xmath96 ) , instead of the @xmath97 dependence used in the calculation of @xmath98 . hence , @xmath99 should be convoluted here with @xmath100 . for @xmath88 the ldos will thus retain the @xmath101 behavior of the strong - coupling phase . to conclude the discussion of this niba - type approximation , a general expression for the ldos which interpolates between large and small @xmath102 limits @xcite is of the form of eq . ( [ eqn : niba ] ) , but with @xmath103 replaced by @xmath104 all the low - energy results of this section are summarized in table [ tbl : rho_d ] . in this section we present the results of numerical calculations , verifying the conclusions of our previous analysis , i.e. , that the ldos at low energies features a power - law behavior with the power determined by ll physics only ( in the strong coupling phase ) , although , as we have shown before @xcite , its integral ( the level population ) is universal , and can not be used to extract ll parameters . to calculate the ldos we used classical monte - carlo ( mc ) simulations on the cg expansion of dot green function @xcite . the mc update procedure used is similar to the one employed recently for the closely - related continuous time quantum mc algorithm @xcite . after obtaining the imaginary - time green function it was fourier - transformed to matsubara frequencies , followed by analytic continuation to real frequencies using the pad approximant technique @xcite . this yields the retarded green function , whose imaginary part is proportional to the ldos @xcite . below we present data in the non - perturbative strong - coupling region , which confirms the results of our previous analysis . actually , in the weak - coupling phase ( which is accessible analytically through the niba - like approximation ) mc simulations are not efficient , since there cg charges are rare and averaging very slow . in this sense , our analysis and numerical calculations are complementary . the results presented in the different panels fig . [ fig : ldos].the values of @xmath15 , @xmath11 and @xmath105 are varied , in a way which keeps @xmath71 constant at a value of @xmath106 . hence , the occupancies as functions of @xmath4 are the same , as we also verify below ( actually , the cg representation would predict exactly identical occupations ) . the ldos curves are , however , markedly different : depending on whether @xmath17 , @xmath16 , or @xmath107 , they have a maximum , a minimum , or no special feature near the fermi energy , respectively . in the inset we demonstrate that in all cases the ldos at the fermi energy exhibits power - law dependence on temperature , @xmath108 , as found in the previous section ( cf . table [ tbl : rho_d ] ) . for the sake of completeness , we will repeat here some of our previous data on the level occupancy @xcite . since the mc simulation is based on the cg , to have an independent check of the universality of the level population we employed the density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) @xcite algorithm , using block - sizes of up to @xmath109 . dmrg is also better suited to ground state calculations , and thus complements the necessarily finite - temperature mc in this respect . the model used is a half - filled tight binding chain with nearest - neighbor interactions . it is described by the hamiltonian : @xmath110 % \\\ ] ] where @xmath111 ( @xmath112 ) is the electronic creation ( annihilation ) operator at the @xmath30th site of the wire ( @xmath113 , with @xmath114 ) , and @xmath115 and @xmath116 are , respectively , nearest - neighbor hopping amplitude and interaction strength . the low energy physics of this model is known to be governed by ll theory for not too large interactions ( i.e. , @xmath117),@xcite with @xmath118 $ ] and @xmath119 $ ] . the dot is still governed by the same @xmath120 , and is coupled to the lead through : @xmath121 @xmath122 , @xmath123 are related to the corresponding parameters of the continuum version eq . ( [ eqn : hdl ] ) by @xmath124 , and @xmath125 , @xmath14 being the lattice spacing . we have previously shown that boundary conformal field theory arguments and the bethe ansatz solution yield that here @xmath126 . @xcite the level population is plotted in fig . [ fig : nlevel ] as a function of @xmath4 . different curves correspond to different values of @xmath71 , as indicated in the legend . on each such curve there are three types of symbols , denoting dmrg data on three different models : ( i ) @xmath107 ( i.e. , @xmath127 ) but nonzero @xmath123 ; ( ii ) @xmath128 ( nonzero @xmath116 ) but @xmath129 ; ( iii ) both @xmath116 and @xmath123 are nonzero . all the models are without coupling to the bath ( @xmath130 ) . the values of @xmath116 and @xmath123 in each model were chosen so as to give the same value of @xmath71 for each curve . for model ( iii ) we used @xmath131 , with sign opposite to that of model ( ii ) . in all cases we chose @xmath122 to get @xmath132 and used @xmath133 sites . the results clearly show that the occupancy is indeed universal , depending only on @xmath71 , and not on the strengths or signs of the interactions ( @xmath116 and @xmath123 ) . it should be noted that the widest curve has similar parameters to those used in the mc simulations ( fig . [ fig : ldos ] ) . to summarize , we have studied , both analytically and numerically , the ldos of a level coupled to a ll and to an ohmic bath over the entire parameter space . we have found that in general it exhibits a power - law dependence at low energies . in large parts of the phase space this is just the power - law behavior of the tunneling density of states at the end of a ll wire . thus , a measurement of the ldos there can be used to extract the value of the ll interaction parameter @xmath15 . in other regions it is also affected by level - lead and level - bath interactions . in any case the ldos is explicitly sensitive to the value of the ll parameter @xmath15 , although the ldos determines the level population , which was found before to be universal @xcite , and thus not to feature any ll - specific power - law . we would like to thank y. weiss for his invaluable help with the dmrg calculations , a. schiller for many useful suggestions , and y. gefen for discussions . is supported by the adams foundation of the israel academy of sciences and humanities . financial aid from the israel science foundation ( grant 569/07 ) is gratefully acknowledged . gogolin , a.a . nersesyan , and a.m. tsvelik , _ bosonization and strongly correlated systems _ , ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1998 ) ; t. giamarchi , _ quantum physics in one dimension _ , ( oxford university press , oxford , 2003 ) . fiete , w. bishara , c. nayak , * 101 * , 176801 ( 2008 ) ; * 82 * , 035301 ( 2010 ) . m. goldstein , y. weiss , and r. berkovits , europhys . lett . * 86 * , 67012 ( 2009 ) ; proceedings of fqmt 08 , physica e * 42 * , 610 ( 2010 ) . a. kamenev and y. gefen , * 54 * , 5428 ( 1996 ) ; arxiv : cond - mat/9708109 . anderson and g. yuval , * 23 * , 89 ( 1969 ) ; g. yuval and p.w . anderson , * 1 * , 1522 ( 1970 ) ; p.w . anderson , g. yuval , and d.r . hamann , _ ibid . _ * 1 * , 4464 ( 1970 ) . when @xmath134 ( i.e. , in the presence of strong dot - lead and/or dot - bath interactions ) , interaction between d - charges is large enough to make the screened d - charges contribution [ fig . [ fig : cg_gp](a ) ] dominant even for small @xmath135 . using similar methods one can show that then the ldos will vary as @xmath101 , just like for @xmath88 .

we examine the local density of states of an impurity level or a quantum dot coupled to a fractional quantum hall edge , or to the end of a single one - dimensional luttinger - liquid lead . effects of an ohmic dissipative bath are also taken into account . using both analytical and numerical techniques we show that , in general , the density of states exhibits power - law frequency dependence near the fermi energy . in a substantial region of the parameter space it simply reflects the behavior of the tunneling density of states at the end of a luttinger - liquid , and is insensitive either to the value of the dot - lead interaction or to the strength of dissipation ; otherwise it depends on these couplings too . this behavior should be contrasted with the thermodynamic properties of the level , in particular , its occupancy , which were previously shown to depend on the various interactions in the system only through the corresponding fermi edge singularity exponent , and thus can not display any luttinger - liquid specific power - law . hence , we can construct different models , some with and some without interactions in the wire ( but with equal fermi edge singularity exponents ) , which would have very different level densities of states , although they all result in the same level population vs. energy curves .

0910.1330

the search for star clusters in the galaxy is of a great interest for investigators in the recent years . on the one hand , the usage of new methods and instruments in observations allows scientists to involve clusters in solving a larger number of astrophysical problems and raises many new ones , such as : the processes of formation and evolution of young massive clusters , the nature of nuclear star clusters , the presence of multiple populations in globular clusters . on the other hand , the availability of new multiband all - sky surveys stimulates us to search them for new clusters and build a homogeneous catalog of parameters of both newly discovered and already known clusters . in paper i ( koposov et al . 2008 ) , we described the new method of an automated search for star clusters as a density peaks in huge stellar catalogs . it is based on the convolution of density maps with a special 2-d filter , which is the difference between two 2-d gaussian profiles and has zero integral . if convolved with this special filter , the areas of flat or slowly changing background would produce zero signal , whereas the areas of star concentrations would exhibit a high signal . using this method , we analyzed the distribution of stars in two micron all sky survey ( 2mass ) in the field of @xmath3 degrees towards the galactic anticenter and found 15 new open clusters . to verify the reality of detected clusters , we developed a method , which is based on the assumption that probable cluster members lying along the same isochrone on the color - magnitude diagram ( cmd ) should also form the spatial density peak , whereas the background stars should have a flat distribution . the other benefit of this method is that it not only allows to verify a cluster candidate , but at the same time estimates the cluster s main parameters distance , age , and color excess . we employed this method to derive parameters of 12 new and 13 known , but poorly studied clusters , which were also detected in the field of interest , using the technique of @xmath4 and @xmath5 diagrams built with the data from 2mass catalog . later , @xmath6 magnitudes of the stars in three new clusters were measured using ccd images taken at 104-cm telescope of aryabhatta research institute of observational sciences ( aries , india ) . the isochrones fitted to these data using another color - magnitude diagrams , and derived clusters parameters ( glushkova et al . 2009 ) show good agreement with those obtained from @xmath4 and @xmath5 2mass diagrams and therefore independently confirm the reality of clusters found by koposov et al . ( 2008 ) and the correctness of the method of new cluster verification . the aims of this study are : ( 1 ) search for overdensities in the galactic plane in the range of the galactic latitude @xmath7 using 2mass data ; ( 2 ) verification of some of them as a real clusters ; ( 3 ) estimate of their physical parameters using proven technique we have developed earlier . for the new clusters search and verification procedures we made use of http://vo.astronet.ru , the virtual observatory ( vo ) resource of the sternberg astronomical institute ( koposov et al . 2007 ) , which provides fast remote access to 2mass catalog data through the standard vo - compliant interfaces . we detected 11186 overdensities with the significance level of more than @xmath8 in the region of the milky way within the interval of the galactic latitude @xmath1 . since the open clusters subsystem concentrates to the galactic plane where the interstellar extinction reaches maximum and the background changes rapidly , the most from 11186 overdensities should be attributed to the fluctuations of interstellar dust especially towards the galactic center , where the density fluctuations are maximal . we undertook a visual inspection of all detected overdensities by images from digitized sky survey ( dss ) and 2mass catalogs to recognize real density concentrations against these background fluctuations . we selected 962 candidates to clusters and matched them to the online catalogs by dias et al . ( 2002 ) and harris ( 2003 ) . this match demonstrated that 565 candidates are known open clusters , 114 are known globular clusters , whereas 283 overdensities should be examined in detail as a new cluster candidates , some of which may only be attributed to random star concentrations . we ran all these 283 overdensities through our verification procedure , which includes the analysis of their hess - diagrams , color - magnitude diagrams and radial density distributions in accordance with the technique by koposov et al . 149 candidates were decided to be the real star clusters . however , a part of non - selected overdensities may also be real clusters , which we were unable to verify , because they were detected at the sensitivity limit of 2mass catalog . if we extend our data pattern with the data from the sources with a higher limit in @xmath9 magnitudes , then some other overdensities may manifest themselves as real clusters , and their parameters can also be determined . we tested this idea by using galactic plane survey of ukirt infrared deep sky survey , data release 3 ( ukidss gps dr3 , warren et al . 2007 ) as an additional data source . the average 2mass sensitivity in @xmath10 is @xmath11 , whereas in ukidss gps , the magnitude limit for @xmath12-band is as high as @xmath13 . 22 cluster candidates found in 2mass were studied by @xmath4 and @xmath14 diagrams and radial density distributions built using data from ukidss gps . we verified 9 star clusters and determined their distance moduli , ages and color excesses . among these nine objects , four ( sai 50 , sai 131 , sai 133 , and sai 141 in table 1 ) did not reveal themselves as star clusters when only 2mass catalog data were employed , because the upper part of their main sequences and/or red giant branches is only seen on cmd and hess - diagrams . for example , left panel of fig . 1 displays @xmath4 diagram of cluster sai 50 built by data from ukidss gps . one can only see here the red - giant branch limited to the stars fainter than @xmath15 . if we build such a cmd for this cluster with 2mass data only , we would not detect the cluster at all , because the limiting magnitude for @xmath16-band in this catalog is exactly @xmath17 . in fig . 1 , the isochrone is fitted to give the lower estimate of the distance to the cluster . thus , after involving ukidss gps data , the number of confirmed clusters reached 153 . for 130 clusters we automatically obtained main physical parameters : ages , distances and color excesses using the data from 2mass or ukidss gps and isochrones of solar metallicity by girardi et al . @xmath9 magnitudes were taken from the deeper ukidss gps for the nine clusters , whose centers fall into this survey : sai 50 , sai 74 , sai 75 , sai 130 , sai 131 , sai 133 , sai 141 , sai 142 , sai 145 . the center coordinates , diameters , color excesses @xmath2 , distance moduli and ages as @xmath18 are listed in table 1 . we consider the position of the maximum in a density peak as the center of a cluster on the density map . the cluster radius is such a distance from its center , at which the star density becomes flat on the radial density distribution plot . the errors in color excesses , distance moduli and ages were estimated as described by koposov et al . ( 2008 ) : from the differences in the parameters derived by @xmath4 and @xmath5 diagrams . we used the relations @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 from the paper by dutra et al . ( 2002 ) to derive the distance modulus and color excess @xmath2 , and the relation @xmath22 from the paper by he et al . ( 1995 ) for @xmath12 magnitudes from ukidss gps . for some clusters , we are able to estimate the upper limit of the age only , in particular , when their color - magnitude diagrams do not contain red - giant stars . besides the cluster name sai ( _ _ s__ternberg _ _ a__stronomical _ _ i__nstitute ) , other names from papers by kronberger et al . ( 2006 ) and by froebrich et al . ( 2007 ) are used in table 1 . as mentioned by koposov et al . ( 2008 ) , the authors of both papers published the list of probable cluster candidates where further investigation is necessary to clarify their nature . some of the overdensities independently found by us coincide with the cluster candidates from papers by kronberger et al . ( 2006 ) and froebrich et al . ( 2007 ) . we performed a thorough analysis of these matching candidates and confirmed some of them as the real clusters . however , remaining candidates turned to be mere random star concentrations or background fluctuations ( we do not publish this list here ) . all clusters from table 1 having the other name according to kronberger et al . ( 2006 ) or froebrich et al . ( 2007 ) , are listed neither in the database of open clusters ( webda ) by paunzen , mermilliod ( 2009 ) , nor in the catalog by dias et al . that is why we consider them as a new clusters . special attention should be given to the cluster sai 92 from table 1 . this cluster is situated @xmath23 to the south - east of ngc 2645 , and both clusters feature approximately the same values of parameters . according to webda , the distance from sun to ngc 2645 equals to 1668 pc ; we estimate the distance to the cluster sai 92 to be @xmath24 pc . color excess @xmath2 in the direction to ngc 2645 is @xmath25 , and to sai 92 , @xmath26 . both clusters are pretty young , but differ in @xmath18 by 0.72 : webda estimates the age of ngc 2645 as 7.283 , whereas the present study gives @xmath27 for sai 92 . however , 0.05 is the formal error , which , as mentioned earlier , should be attributed to the difference in the ages determined by @xmath4 and @xmath5 diagrams . a real error for age estimate by 2mass is not less than 0.3 for clusters which do not contain stars on the red - giant branch . if we build the @xmath28 diagram of ngc 2645 using data from webda and fit them by the isochrone of solar metallicity by girardi et al . ( 2002 ) using the distance and color excess also from webda , then the lower limit for the age is 7.6 in @xmath18 . therefore , the age of both clusters can be considered approximately the same taking into account the real errors of its estimate . apparently , ngc 2645 and sai 92 form a double cluster then . 2 shows the image of @xmath29 x @xmath29 from dss where both clusters fall into . diameters of clusters ( @xmath30 and @xmath31 ) are represented by circles . sai 50 looks like a globular cluster by its age and cmd built using data from ukidss gps , although the errors in parameters are large , because the isochrone was fitted to the red - giant branch only . the left panel of fig . 1 represents @xmath4 diagram with fitted isochrone ; the radial density distribution corresponding to this fitted isochrone is displayed in the right panel . solid circles denote the cluster members that are the stars deviating from the isochrone by less than @xmath32 in color ; open circles denote background stars , that are all other stars . it can clearly be seen that the members of the cluster are concentrated to its center , whereas field stars exhibit flat distribution with small density fluctuations . besides 130 clusters which are listed in table 1 , we found 23 new embedded clusters . they are detected as density peaks and are clearly visible on 2mass images and hess - diagrams . but such a clusters reveal themselves as a cloud on the cmd @xmath4 and @xmath5 ; therefore , it was impossible to fit isochrones and find their parameters . coordinates and diameters of these clusters are presented in table 2 . [ meansp ] l|l|c|c|c|c|c|c & other name & @xmath33 & @xmath34 & d & e(b - v ) & @xmath35 & age + & & @xmath36 @xmath37 @xmath38 & @xmath39 @xmath40 @xmath41 & @xmath40 & mag & mag & @xmath18 + sai 1 & & 00:08:20.4 & + 51:43:15 & 4 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + sai 2 & & 00:12:28.4 & + 76:14:06 & 5 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath437.70 + sai 3 & fsr 480 & 00:14:49.6 & + 61:28:36 & 6 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 9.20@xmath42 0.05 + sai 4 & & 00:23:40.0 & + 62:42:14 & 4 & 0.27@xmath42 0.18 & 11.02@xmath42 0.36 & @xmath438.70 + sai 5 & fsr 494 & 00:25:37.8 & + 63:45:40 & 4 & 0.60@xmath42 0.08 & 12.70@xmath42 0.07 & 9.10@xmath42 0.05 + sai 6 & & 00:27:52.6 & + 60:41:21 & 5 & 0.89@xmath42 0.09 & 12.17@xmath42 0.01 & @xmath438.50 + sai 7 & fsr 503 & 00:29:11.3 & + 68:56:11 & 7 & 0.82@xmath42 0.12 & 11.88@xmath42 0.38 & 9.40@xmath42 0.05 + sai 8 & fsr 505 & 00:40:08.8 & + 61:34:03 & 3 & 0.30@xmath42 0.11 & 14.28@xmath42 0.20 & 9.15@xmath42 0.10 + sai 9 & fsr 508 & 00:41:51.9 & + 64:58:51 & 4 & 0.66@xmath42 0.17 & 14.42@xmath42 0.20 & 9.10@xmath42 0.10 + sai 11 & fsr 524 & 00:57:12.4 & + 62:06:18 & 8 & 0.51@xmath42 0.13 & 10.70@xmath42 0.29 & 9.10@xmath42 0.05 + sai 12 & & 01:04:24.1 & + 45:36:25 & 4 & 1.13@xmath42 0.30 & 12.06@xmath42 0.02 & @xmath438.15 + sai 13 & fsr 536 & 01:19:37.6 & + 63:03:20 & 8 & 1.27@xmath42 0.23 & 12.38@xmath42 0.17 & @xmath438.20 + sai 14 & & 01:26:00.3 & + 62:37:33 & 4 & 0.55@xmath42 0.03 & 14.05@xmath42 0.03 & 9.10@xmath42 0.05 + sai 16 & & 02:05:29.6 & + 62:15:54 & 5 & 0.70@xmath42 0.01 & 14.42@xmath42 0.20 & 9.15@xmath42 0.05 + sai 17 & & 02:20:48.3 & + 59:11:06 & 2 & 0.98@xmath42 0.17 & 12.88@xmath42 0.10 & 8.90 @xmath42 0.05 + sai 21 & & 02:34:45.4 & + 62:34:22 & 3 & 0.58@xmath42 0.01 & 11.35@xmath42 0.10 & @xmath438.50 + sai 25 & & 03:00:26.7 & + 57:16:02 & 7 & 0.84@xmath42 0.13 & 11.80@xmath42 0.09 & 9.15@xmath42 0.05 + sai 26 & & 03:09:30.8 & + 56:47:26 & 3 & 1.47@xmath42 0.29 & 11.79@xmath42 0.51 & @xmath438.20 + sai 27 & & 03:11:21.9 & + 68:54:01 & 5 & 0.62@xmath42 0.04 & 10.48@xmath42 0.28 & 9.25@xmath42 0.10 + sai 29 & fsr 634 & 03:40:21.5 & + 59:24:52 & 5 & 0.84@xmath42 0.01 & 12.24@xmath42 0.07 & 9.00@xmath42 0.05 + sai 30 & & 03:40:22.2 & + 82:13:60 & 3 & 1.25@xmath42 0.44 & 12.46@xmath42 0.05 & @xmath438.00 + sai 31 & & 03:51:15.4 & + 58:46:08 & 6 & 0.16@xmath42 0.22 & 12.12@xmath42 0.02 & 9.60@xmath42 0.05 + sai 33 & juchert 19 & 04:02:20.2 & + 52:26:39 & 2 & 0.28@xmath42 0.01 & 10.64@xmath42 0.02 & @xmath439.30 + sai 34 & fsr 660 & 04:02:37.8 & + 51:55:50 & 5 & 1.20@xmath42 0.12 & 13.78@xmath42 0.03 & 9.10@xmath42 0.05 + sai 35 & juchert 20 & 04:10:47.0 & + 46:52:01 & 5 & 0.70@xmath42 0.18 & 11.92@xmath42 0.02 & @xmath438.55 + sai 36 & & 04:16:50.4 & + 41:04:00 & 3 & 0.55@xmath42 0.05 & 12.36@xmath42 0.19 & 9.10@xmath42 0.05 + sai 37 & fsr 687 & 04:39:27.1 & + 48:12:23 & 4 & 0.77@xmath42 0.03 & 14.30@xmath42 0.04 & 9.15@xmath42 0.05 + sai 40 & & 05:00:56.9 & + 41:14:02 & 8 & 0.35@xmath42 0.12 & 13.29@xmath42 0.05 & 8.75@xmath42 0.05 + sai 41 & & 05:07:05.4 & + 38:25:05 & 2 & 0.51@xmath42 0.18 & 13.58@xmath42 0.23 & 9.30@xmath42 0.05 + sai 42 & juchert 23 & 05:07:39.7 & + 17:36:00 & 8 & 0.62@xmath42 0.18 & 11.67@xmath42 0.09 & 8.70@xmath42 0.05 + sai 43 & & 05:08:16.6 & + 49:52:08 & 2 & 0.18@xmath42 0.03 & 12.92@xmath42 0.07 & 8.95@xmath42 0.05 + sai 44 & fsr 716 & 05:11:07.4 & + 45:43:09 & 5 & 0.24@xmath42 0.01 & 12.64@xmath42 0.06 & 8.95@xmath42 0.05 + sai 45 & fsr 727 & 05:16:35.0 & + 45:34:56 & 6 & 0.25@xmath42 0.02 & 10.55@xmath42 0.17 & 9.20@xmath42 0.05 + sai 46 & & 05:19:37.0 & + 36:30:32 & 3 & 0.78@xmath42 0.01 & 13.16@xmath42 0.12 & 9.45@xmath42 0.05 + sai 47 & & 05:23:58.0 & + 42:18:52 & 3 & 0.60@xmath42 0.01 & 12.93@xmath42 0.05 & 8.50@xmath42 0.05 + sai 48 & & 05:24:16.8 & + 33:30:02 & 4 & 0.31@xmath42 0.07 & 11.30@xmath42 0.20 & 9.35@xmath42 0.05 + sai 49 & & 05:26:24.9 & + 50:47:03 & 6 & 0.47@xmath42 0.01 & 12.17@xmath42 0.17 & 9.05@xmath42 0.05 + sai 50 & & 05:28:38.9 & + 35:01:19 & 3 & 0.60@xmath42 0.30 & 16.70@xmath42 0.50 & 9.70@xmath42 0.20 + sai 51 & & 05:30:01.9 & + 33:25:31 & 3 & 0.62@xmath42 0.18 & 9.54@xmath42 0.20 & @xmath43 9.30 + sai 56 & fsr 852 & 05:53:30.6 & + 25:10:41 & 8 & 0.43@xmath42 0.07 & 11.82@xmath42 0.04 & 8.90@xmath42 0.05 + sai 57 & fsr 932 & 06:04:21.5 & + 14:34:22 & 5 & 0.39@xmath42 0.07 & 10.18@xmath42 0.10 & 8.90@xmath42 0.10 + sai 58 & fsr 921 & 06:05:09.4 & + 16:41:03 & 5 & 1.33@xmath42 0.33 & 11.80@xmath42 0.20 & 8.50@xmath42 0.05 + sai 59 & fsr 942 & 06:05:59.2 & + 13:39:52 & 8 & 0.59@xmath42 0.01 & 11.51@xmath42 0.25 & 9.00@xmath42 0.05 + sai 60 & & 06:06:38.6 & + 15:56:51 & 4 & 0.90@xmath42 0.01 & 14.50@xmath42 0.05 & 9.05@xmath42 0.05 + sai 61 & fsr 904 & 06:06:55.2 & + 19:00:26 & 8 & 0.14@xmath42 0.16 & 10.51@xmath42 0.02 & 8.80@xmath42 0.05 + sai 62 & fsr 985 & 06:11:49.0 & + 07:01:22 & 3 & 0.55@xmath42 0.02 & 12.10@xmath42 0.09 & @xmath43 8.60 + sai 63 & fsr 987 & 06:13:44.5 & + 06:56:58 & 4 & 0.37@xmath42 0.13 & 11.40@xmath42 0.09 & 8.65@xmath42 0.05 + sai 64 & fsr 948 & 06:25:55.9 & + 15:51:39 & 4 & 0.08@xmath42 0.13 & 11.84@xmath42 0.17 & 9.00@xmath42 0.05 + sai 65 & fsr 979 & 06:31:16.2 & + 11:04:38 & 3 & 1.17@xmath42 0.17 & 11.65@xmath42 0.05 & 8.45@xmath42 0.05 + sai 66 & fsr 1063 & 06:34:37.9 & -00:16:01 & 5 & 0.58@xmath42 0.01 & 11.47@xmath42 0.14&@xmath43 8.60 + sai 67 & teutsch59 & 06:43:49.0 & -00:52:60 & 6 & 0.57@xmath42 0.14 & 12.34@xmath42 0.04 & @xmath43 8.90 + sai 68 & patchick 90 & 06:44:42.7 & -00:32:22 & 3 & 0.41@xmath42 0.09 & 14.00@xmath42 0.20 & 8.95@xmath42 0.05 + sai 69 & & 06:45:27.8 & -11:47:40 & 3 & 0.35@xmath42 0.07 & 14.27@xmath42 0.10 & 9.10@xmath42 0.05 + sai 70 & fsr 1125 & 06:50:26.6 & -05:26:08 & 4 & 0.39@xmath42 0.01 & 13.99@xmath42 0.09 & @xmath439.10 + sai 71 & fsr 1085 & 06:53:11.2 & -00:11:31 & 4 & 0.08@xmath42 0.09 & 10.62@xmath42 0.19 & @xmath438.60 + sai 72 & & 06:55:48.4 & + 00:13:37 & 5 & 0.82@xmath42 0.06 & 12.49@xmath42 0.05 & 8.50@xmath42 0.20 + sai 73 & fsr 1171 & 07:00:13.1 & -10:19:14 & 2 & 0.65@xmath42 0.07 & 13.07@xmath42 0.29 & 9.50@xmath42 0.05 + sai 74 & fsr 1150 & 07:04:36.6 & -06:36:38 & 3 & 0.94@xmath42 0.06 & 13.60@xmath42 0.26 & @xmath438.30 + sai 75 & patchick 79 & 07:15:22.5 & -07:25:20 & 4 & 0.23@xmath42 0.03 & 12.24@xmath42 0.24 & @xmath438.60 + sai 76 & fsr 1253 & 07:26:17.4 & -18:25:55 & 6 & 0.62@xmath42 0.01 & 12.11@xmath42 0.24 & 8.40@xmath42 0.05 + sai 77 & fsr 1275 & 07:28:06.2 & -21:47:46 & 4 & 0.60@xmath42 0.10 & 12.87@xmath42 0.12 & 9.40@xmath42 0.05 + sai 78 & teutsch 61 & 07:34:39.8 & -19:47:23 & 3 & 0.55@xmath42 0.02 & 11.42@xmath42 0.10 & 6.95@xmath42 0.05 + sai 79 & fsr 1347 & 07:48:03.4 & -33:42:35 & 6 & 1.09@xmath42 0.15 & 11.95@xmath42 0.07 & @xmath438.80 + sai 80 & teutsch 25 & 07:48:26.7 & -27:54:51 & 5 & 0.57@xmath42 0.12 & 11.48@xmath42 0.16 & @xmath439.00 + + [ meansp ] l|l|c|c|c|c|c|c & other name & @xmath33 & @xmath34 & d & e(b - v ) & @xmath35 & age + & & @xmath36 @xmath37 @xmath38 & @xmath39 @xmath40 @xmath41 & @xmath40 & mag & mag & @xmath18 + sai 81 & & 07:52:07.2 & -28:07:21 & 7 & 0.40@xmath42 0.02 & 12.21@xmath42 0.19 & @xmath43 9.20 + sai 82 & & 07:52:14.4 & -33:02:27 & 3 & 0.39@xmath42 0.07 & 10.30@xmath42 0.05 & 8.65 @xmath42 0.05 + sai 83 & & 07:53:20.1 & -32:33:30 & 3 & 1.00@xmath42 0.15 & 12.96@xmath42 0.34 & 8.85@xmath42 0.05 + sai 84&kronberger 85 & 07:58:21.6 & -34:46:09 & 2 & 1.17@xmath42 0.19 & 14.65@xmath42 0.11 & 8.80@xmath42 0.05 + sai 85 & fsr 1378 & 08:01:11.5 & -40:40:41 & 6 & 1.21@xmath42 0.25 & 11.74@xmath42 0.13 & 8.80@xmath42 0.05 + sai 86 & & 08:08:15.0 & -36:36:33 & 6 & 0.69@xmath42 0.09 & 12.41@xmath42 0.16 & 8.60@xmath42 0.05 + sai 87 & fsr 1380 & 08:11:05.0 & -39:59:51 & 4 & 1.28@xmath42 0.30 & 11.80@xmath42 0.19 & @xmath438.65 + sai 88 & & 08:12:57.6 & -41:53:01 & 2 & 0.92@xmath42 0.02 & 14.58@xmath42 0.25 & 9.00@xmath42 0.05 + sai 89 & fsr 1387 & 08:24:25.3 & -39:56:11 & 3 & 1.19@xmath42 0.11 & 11.82@xmath42 0.18 & @xmath438.80 + sai 90 & & 08:27:58.9 & -41:46:10 & 7 & 1.02@xmath42 0.21 & 12.19@xmath42 0.11 & 9.05@xmath42 0.05 + sai 91 & & 08:37:03.4 & -50:03:52 & 4 & 0.51@xmath42 0.02 & 12.45@xmath42 0.16 & 8.80@xmath42 0.05 + sai 92 & fsr 1436 & 08:39:34.5 & -46:17:54 & 5 & 0.39@xmath42 0.10 & 10.99@xmath42 0.17 & 8.00@xmath42 0.05 + sai 93 & fsr 1415 & 08:40:21.9 & -44:44:01 & 3 & 1.87@xmath42 0.35 & 12.74@xmath42 0.06 & 9.25@xmath42 0.05 + sai 94 & & 08:44:39.8 & -46:17:46 & 5 & 0.48@xmath42 0.05 & 12.96@xmath42 0.29 & 9.10@xmath42 0.10 + sai 95 & fsr 1454 & 08:51:00.6 & -48:27:37 & 5 & 0.57@xmath42 0.03 & 13.96@xmath42 0.05 & 9.15@xmath42 0.05 + sai 96 & fsr 1430 & 08:51:49.4 & -44:15:47 & 4 & 2.50@xmath42 0.33 & 12.27@xmath42 0.33 & 8.85@xmath42 0.05 + sai 98 & fsr 1435 & 08:57:03.0 & -43:45:40 & 6 & 1.06@xmath42 0.06 & 10.27@xmath42 0.30 & 9.75@xmath42 0.10 + sai 99 & & 08:58:04.4 & -43:24:38 & 5 & 1.84@xmath42 0.49 & 12.60@xmath42 0.04 & 8.95@xmath42 0.05 + sai 100 & fsr 1450 & 08:58:12.2 & -46:17:19 & 3 & 1.62@xmath42 0.08 & 13.65@xmath42 0.08 & 9.10@xmath42 0.15 + sai 101 & & 08:58:22.4 & -43:07:35 & 5 & 1.56@xmath42 0.04 & 11.09@xmath42 0.05 & @xmath439.00 + sai 102 & fsr 1402 & 09:05:43.2 & -37:52:05 & 4 & 0.08@xmath42 0.04 & 12.03@xmath42 0.29 & 9.60@xmath42 0.05 + sai 103 & fsr 1460 & 09:07:38.5 & -47:50:01 & 7 & 1.31@xmath42 0.20 & 11.30@xmath42 0.70 & 9.30@xmath42 0.70 + sai 104 & & 09:09:54.8 & -48:51:03 & 3 & 1.17@xmath42 0.11 & 9.59@xmath42 0.14 & @xmath438.90 + sai 105 & & 09:10:24.5 & -49:54:46 & 4 & 1.91@xmath42 0.31 & 12.35@xmath42 0.13 & 9.05@xmath42 0.05 + sai 106 & & 09:17:59.4 & -51:01:46 & 5 & 1.02@xmath42 0.02 & 13.56@xmath42 0.10 & 9.35@xmath42 0.05 + sai 107 & teutsch 103 & 09:28:35.8 & -46:35:60 & 3 & 0.62@xmath42 0.06 & 12.23@xmath42 0.38&@xmath43 8.75 + sai 108 & & 09:38:52.9 & -52:57:28 & 6 & 0.66@xmath42 0.02 & 12.32@xmath42 0.08 & 8.50@xmath42 0.05 + sai 109 & & 09:43:34.4 & -50:47:33 & 5 & 0.23@xmath42 0.04 & 14.43@xmath42 0.50 & 9.20@xmath42 0.20 + sai 110 & fsr 1509 & 09:48:00.8 & -55:04:01 & 2 & 1.17@xmath42 0.13 & 11.59@xmath42 0.05 & 8.75@xmath42 0.05 + sai 111 & fsr 1521 & 09:55:22.6 & -56:36:15 & 8 & 0.90@xmath42 0.17 & 13.00@xmath42 0.30 & 9.45@xmath42 0.10 + sai 112 & & 10:21:24.9 & -59:05:34 & 2 & 1.00@xmath42 0.02 & 14.30@xmath42 0.15 & 9.10@xmath42 0.10 + sai 114 & fsr 1555 & 10:48:55.7 & -59:02:58 & 3 & 0.76@xmath42 0.05 & 13.40@xmath42 0.30 & 9.25@xmath42 0.10 + sai 115 & fsr 1586 & 11:22:44.9 & -62:19:06 & 5 & 1.60@xmath42 0.29 & 11.92@xmath42 0.20 & 8.65@xmath42 0.10 + sai 116 & & 11:49:18.0 & -62:13:47 & 5 & 0.98@xmath42 0.08 & 11.72@xmath42 0.17 & 8.60@xmath42 0.05 + sai 117 & fsr 1663 & 13:41:04.5 & -60:12:27 & 4 & 1.01@xmath42 0.16 & 11.66@xmath42 0.25 & 8.90@xmath42 0.05 + sai 118 & & 13:43:03.8 & -63:09:53 & 8 & 0.17@xmath42 0.21 & 10.28@xmath42 0.62 & 9.75@xmath42 0.25 + sai 120 & & 13:58:42.0 & -61:40:08 & 2 & 1.99@xmath42 0.30 & 12.03@xmath42 0.21 & 8.75@xmath42 0.10 + sai 121 & fsr 1686 & 14:40:06.8 & -60:23:13 & 5 & 1.48@xmath42 0.23 & 13.02@xmath42 0.16 & 8.95@xmath42 0.05 + sai 122 & & 15:00:03.9 & -58:48:13 & 8 & 2.26@xmath42 0.43 & 11.12@xmath42 0.04 & 8.25@xmath42 0.15 + sai 123 & & 16:08:17.4 & -50:32:06 & 7 & 1.35@xmath42 0.18 & 11.35@xmath42 0.18 & 9.20@xmath42 0.05 + sai 124 & fsr 1744 & 16:51:35.8 & -42:25:47 & 3 & 2.58@xmath42 0.34 & 12.48@xmath42 0.26 & 8.85@xmath42 0.20 + sai 127 & fsr 124 & 19:06:52.8 & + 13:14:44 & 4 & 0.98@xmath42 0.12 & 11.56@xmath42 0.41 & 9.10@xmath42 0.05 + sai 128 & fsr 133 & 19:29:46.9 & + 15:33:51 & 6 & 2.26@xmath42 0.45 & 11.59@xmath42 0.12 & 8.35@xmath42 0.05 + sai 129 & fsr 160 & 19:44:44.3 & + 26:54:08 & 3 & 1.42@xmath42 0.05 & 14.38@xmath42 0.30 & 8.95@xmath42 0.05 + sai 130 & fsr 158 & 19:47:58.1 & + 26:01:55 & 8 & 1.17@xmath42 0.04 & 12.78@xmath42 0.11 & @xmath43 8.30 + sai 131 & fsr 154 & 19:48:00.8 & + 23:20:53 & 3 & 0.70@xmath42 0.13 & 12.23@xmath42 0.05 & 9.05@xmath42 0.05 + sai 132 & & 19:57:01.5 & + 31:36:31 & 8 & 0.94@xmath42 0.09 & 12.28@xmath42 0.06 & 8.75@xmath42 0.05 + sai 133 & & 20:01:58.7 & + 31:26:18 & 4 & 1.80@xmath42 0.05 & 13.94@xmath42 0.16 & 7.85@xmath42 0.05 + sai 135 & & 20:02:55.9 & + 24:33:17 & 5 & 1.34@xmath42 0.29 & 12.89@xmath42 0.06 & 9.10@xmath42 0.05 + sai 136&kronberger 36&20:04:35.7 & + 35:13:03 & 6 & 0.76@xmath42 0.18 & 11.40@xmath42 0.26 & @xmath438.40 + sai 137 & & 20:49:52.6 & + 41:15:18 & 6 & 0.89@xmath42 0.08 & 10.12@xmath42 0.24 & @xmath438.70 + sai 138 & fsr 275 & 20:56:43.0 & + 46:53:15 & 10 & 0.76@xmath42 0.05 & 11.98@xmath42 0.11 & 9.25@xmath42 0.05 + sai 139 & teutsch 22 & 21:01:40.8 & + 44:06:43 & 2 & 0.86@xmath42 0.13 & 12.16@xmath42 0.33 & 8.55@xmath42 0.05 + sai 140 & fsr 282 & 21:02:20.1 & + 48:06:26 & 4 & 0.78@xmath42 0.01 & 11.79@xmath42 0.12 & 9.05@xmath42 0.05 + sai 141 & & 21:03:46.9 & + 46:58:50 & 3 & 0.94@xmath42 0.04 & 13.47@xmath42 0.16 & 8.60@xmath42 0.05 + sai 142 & teutsch 156 & 21:03:46.7 & + 47:12:54 & 3 & 0.94@xmath42 0.04 & 12.97@xmath42 0.22 & 8.95@xmath42 0.05 + sai 143 & & 21:10:51.4 & + 50:18:31 & 3 & 1.72@xmath42 0.24 & 14.07@xmath42 0.17 & 9.25@xmath42 0.05 + sai 144 & teutsch 74 & 21:45:43.6 & + 58:05:03 & 4 & 1.05@xmath42 0.17 & 12.12@xmath42 0.53 & 9.05@xmath42 0.05 + sai 145 & fsr 336 & 21:50:47.5 & + 55:16:31 & 8 & 0.55@xmath42 0.09 & 11.67@xmath42 0.37 & 8.90@xmath42 0.05 + sai 146 & fsr 342 & 22:07:38.6 & + 53:06:09 & 8 & 0.27@xmath42 0.01 & 11.52@xmath42 0.47 & 9.05@xmath42 0.05 + sai 147 & fsr 394 & 22:55:04.8 & + 58:42:53 & 5 & 0.70@xmath42 0.04 & 13.73@xmath42 0.21 & 9.40@xmath42 0.05 + sai 148 & fsr 430 & 23:15:29.5 & + 64:09:58 & 5 & 1.08@xmath42 0.20 & 11.93@xmath42 0.05 & 8.05@xmath42 0.05 + sai 149 & & 23:38:01.7 & + 60:32:57 & 7 & 1.29@xmath42 0.30 & 11.87@xmath42 0.07 & @xmath438.20 + sai 150 & fsr 441 & 23:41:58.8 & + 58:32:29 & 5 & 0.78@xmath42 0.14 & 11.84@xmath42 0.04 & 8.55@xmath42 0.05 + sai 151 & fsr 465 & 23:50:54.5 & + 66:10:49 & 5 & 0.78@xmath42 0.04 & 13.60@xmath42 0.10 & 9.20@xmath42 0.05 + sai 153 & fsr 460 & 23:59:07.0 & + 60:40:40 & 7 & 0.86@xmath42 0.19 & 13.45@xmath42 0.09 & 9.20@xmath42 0.05 + + [ meansp ] l|l|c|c|c & other name & @xmath33&@xmath34 & d + & & @xmath36 @xmath37 @xmath38 & @xmath39 @xmath40 @xmath41 & @xmath40 + sai 10 & & 00:43:03.2 & + 41:37:21 & 3 + sai 15 & & 01:49:52.6 & + 53:54:34 & 2 + sai 18 & & 02:21:55.9 & + 61:07:21 & 3 + sai 19 & & 02:26:31.9 & + 61:59:33 & 6 + sai 20 & fsr 584 & 02:27:04.8 & + 61:37:40 & 6 + sai 22 & & 02:48:58.1 & + 60:44:34 & 5 + sai 23 & & 02:54:05.0 & + 60:39:52 & 2 + sai 24 & & 02:59:25.4 & + 60:33:58 & 6 + sai 28 & & 03:39:16.7 & + 55:58:24 & 3 + sai 32 & fsr 655 & 03:56:11.8 & + 53:52:09 & 1 + sai 38 & fsr 699 & 04:56:05.6 & + 47:23:25 & 2 + sai 39 & fsr 696 & 04:58:31.6 & + 47:59:03 & 1 + sai 52 & fsr 812 & 05:38:09.1 & + 31:44:16 & 3 + sai 53 & fsr 874 & 05:40:58.3 & + 20:21:18 & 3 + sai 54 & fsr 855 & 05:42:22.4 & + 22:50:04 & 3 + sai 55 & fsr 826 & 05:42:51.2 & + 28:56:43 & 3 + sai 97 & fsr 1432 & 08:52:53.3 & -44:12:06 & 4 + sai 113 & & 10:22:43.6 & -59:30:20 & 2 + sai 119 & fsr 1662 & 13:44:14.2 & -62:04:03 & 2 + sai 125 & fsr 31 & 18:06:27.8 & -21:23:27 & 5 + sai 126 & & 18:13:26.7 & -17:52:49 & 3 + sai 134 & fsr 198 & 20:02:26.8 & + 35:40:34 & 4 + sai 152 & fsr 469 & 23:57:04.4 & + 65:24:52 & 1 + + table 3 lists the coordinates , diameters , color excesses @xmath2 , distance moduli , distances in pc , and @xmath18 of known , but yet - unstudied clusters . we detected and investigated all clusters by our methods , which simultaneously allowed us to improve the accuracy of the center coordinates . for instance , one of the overdensities was attributed to the open cluster berkeley 53 , although it is situated @xmath44 away to the west from the coordinates contained in the catalog by dias et al . webda gives the same position and the dss image shows no star concentration there . hence , be 53 was not studied previously . webda misses all @xmath45 clusters , whereas the dias catalog lists their coordinates and diameters only . @xmath45 311 - 21 is marked by dias et al . ( 2002 ) as `` doubtful '' , and @xmath45 211 - 03 , as `` not found '' . diameter of cluster @xmath45 368 - 11 is @xmath46 according to dias et al . ( 2002 ) , but we found it to be @xmath47 . diameters of other known clusters are also less then that in dias catalog as compared to the data from table 3 in this paper . this difference can be explained by the fact that all these clusters are barely perceptible on dss images , but well noticeable on images from 2mass . diameters presented in table 3 were derived from radial density distribution plots in the same manner as for newly discovered clusters . dias catalog and webda only give the coordinates and underestimated diameters for all @xmath48 clusters from table 3 . open cluster @xmath49 131 is marked as `` doubtful '' by dias et al . ( 2002 ) , @xmath50 19 has no data in the literature available . koposov et al . ( 2008 ) published the coordinates and diameters only for cluster @xmath51 7 , whereas in present work we determined its age , distance and color excess using the data from ukidss gps . [ meansp ] l|l|c|c|c|c|l|c & @xmath33 & @xmath34 & d & e(b - v ) & @xmath35 & distance & age + & @xmath36 @xmath37 @xmath38 & @xmath39 @xmath40 @xmath41 & @xmath40 & @xmath52 & @xmath52 & pc & @xmath18 + koposov 7 & 05:40:44.1 & + 35:55:25 & 6 & 3.75@xmath42 0.37 & 13.39@xmath42 0.35 & 4760@xmath42 830 & 8.20@xmath42 0.05 + eso 368 - 11&07:44:22.2 & -34:37:07 & 6 & 0.06@xmath42 0.10 & 10.86@xmath42 0.41 & 1490@xmath42 310 & 9.00@xmath42 0.05 + eso 311 - 21 & 08:01:41.6 & -41:35:57 & 5 & 0.49@xmath42 0.02 & 11.84@xmath42 0.08 & 2330@xmath42 90 & 10.10@xmath42 0.05 + ru 48 & 08:02:42.5 & -32:03:02 & 3 & 0.29@xmath42 0.04 & 12.41@xmath42 0.05 & 3030 @xmath42 70 & @xmath438.60 + ru 54 & 08:11:21.7 & -31:56:37 & 2 & 0.35@xmath42 0.04 & 12.71@xmath42 0.27 & 3480 @xmath42 460 & 8.45@xmath42 0.05 + ru 60 & 08:24:23.0 & -47:12:37 & 4 & 0.57@xmath42 0.06 & 12.84@xmath42 0.11 & 3700 @xmath42 190 & @xmath438.65 + eso 312 - 03 & 08:24:26.1 & -41:17:52 & 6 & 0.52@xmath42 0.10 & 11.68@xmath42 0.57 & 2170 @xmath42 650 & @xmath438.90 + eso 312 - 04 & 08:26:51.2 & -41:14:39 & 2 & 0.49@xmath42 0.01 & 11.91@xmath42 0.11 & 2410 @xmath42 130 & @xmath438.75 + ru 63 & 08:32:41.4 & -48:18:21 & 6 & 0.54@xmath42 0.04 & 12.13@xmath42 0.08 & 2670 @xmath42 100 & @xmath438.50 + ru 68 & 08:44:34.5 & -35:54:00 & 10 & 0.39@xmath42 0.05 & 11.49@xmath42 0.08 & 1990 @xmath42 80 & 9.15@xmath42 0.05 + eso 211 - 03 & 08:51:34.3 & -50:14:43 & 5 & 0.90@xmath42 0.07 & 12.88@xmath42 0.04 & 3770 @xmath42 70 & 9.05@xmath42 0.10 + tr 19 & 11:14:20.2 & -57:33:04 & 14 & 0.08@xmath42 0.01 & 11.40@xmath42 0.05 & 1900 @xmath42 50 & 9.65@xmath42 0.05 + bh 131 & 12:26:13.7 & -63:24:50 & 5 & 0.62@xmath42 0.04 & 13.98@xmath42 0.22 & 6250 @xmath42 670 & 9.10@xmath42 0.10 + be 53 & 20:55:55.3 & + 51:02:54 & 10 & 1.31@xmath42 0.20 & 12.74@xmath42 0.13 & 3530 @xmath42 220 & 9.15@xmath42 0.05 + + to facilitate dissemination and scientific usage of the results of the present study and data from koposov et al . ( 2008 ) , we have developed a standardized tool for continuous publication of the results of ongoing catalog compilation on the web , available as a dedicated web - site at http://ocl.sai.msu.ru . besides the standard access via a web browser to the catalog of individual cluster pages with hess - diagrams , color - magnitude diagrams , 2mass or dss cluster images , and catalogs of photometric data ( for clusters with ccd observations ) , the web - site offers the catalog exported to csv , dat , and votable formats as well and implements a standard virtual observatory programmatic access interface for positional queries called _ conesearch_. moreover , it is possible to start the vo client software , such as topcat or cds aladin , by a single click in a web browser with the catalog preloaded for quick - look analysis of the whole sample and all accompanying data we provide for individual clusters . main results are available as a single table at centre de donnees astronomiques de strasbourg at http://vizier.u-strasbg.fr/viz-bin/vizier?-source=v/132 and also within standalone vo client applications running on any workstation connected to the internet , e.g. mentioned topcat and cds aladin tools , using query to search for the catalogs by key words or by authors of this publication . using @xmath0 photometric data available in 2mass catalog , we have performed an automated search for the star overdensities in the galactic plane for the latitudes ranged within @xmath7 and detected 11186 density peaks . a short list of 283 new cluster candidates has been compiled after we excluded the overdensities attributed to the background fluctuations or star concentrations coinciding with already known clusters . employing our method described earlier ( koposov et al . , 2008 ) , we have studied these 283 candidates and verified 149 of them to be real clusters . having involved the ukidss gps survey in our investigation as an additional data source , we studied 22 more cluster candidates and found four new open clusters . therefore , the number of new clusters found in the frame of the present paper is 153 . for 130 clusters of them , we have determined their main physical parameters : distance , age , and color excess . together with the clusters published in koposov et al . ( 2008 ) , we have found 168 new open clusters in total , and determined parameters for 142 of them . besides that , we confirmed the existence of 14 known , but yet - unstudied clusters and determined their accurate coordinates and other parameters . 3 shows the distribution of 143 open clusters projected onto the galactic plane . the crosses denote all clusters , except for sai 50 , whose distances are determined in this paper ( 129 new and 14 known clusters ) . we excluded cluster sai 50 from this pattern because of large errors in its parameters . solid circle represents the sun . it can be clearly seen from this figure that no new clusters were discovered in the direction towards the galactic center , because this area features maximum extinction and level of background fluctuations , which makes the detection of clusters more difficult . the major part of new clusters have been found within the radius of 2.5 kpc from the sun , because of a relatively low limiting values of @xmath53 in the 2mass catalog . we have not discovered any new clusters closer than 500 pc ; however , we did not attempt to search for them specifically in this range of the distance , because the open cluster sample there is believed to be complete . for this reason , we used the filter allowing to detect clusters with the diameter of @xmath44 and less , whereas for the close clusters this value is typically greater . some new rich clusters can only be seen at the ir wavelengths . for example , sai 122 is well noticeable on the image from 2mass data ( fig . 4 ) and is fully invisible on the dss images , because the color excess in the direction toward this cluster amounts to @xmath54 . among the clusters discovered by us , there are few , which reveal themselves on the dss images as a very faint objects ; however , it is normally impossible to estimate their parameters . the majority of new objects are either poorly populated clusters , or rich ones , yet imperceptible against a dense background : for example , sai 132 ( see fig . 5 ) . in both these cases , an object can not be detected while visually inspecting 2mass images . thus , the application of our automated method of searching infrared data for density peaks has provided us with the tool capable of detecting these 168 open clusters . this publication makes use of data products from the two micron all sky survey , which is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and the infrared processing and analysis center / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration and the national science foundation . this publication has made use of the digitized sky surveys which were produced at the space telescope science institute under u.s . government grant nag w-2166 . the images of these surveys are based on photographic data obtained using the oschin schmidt telescope on palomar mountain and the uk schmidt telescope .

automated search for star clusters in @xmath0 data from 2mass catalog has been performed using the method developed by koposov et . al ( 2008 ) . we have found and verified 153 new clusters in the interval of the galactic latitude @xmath1 . color excesses @xmath2 , distance moduli and ages were determined for 130 new and 14 yet - unstudied known clusters . in this paper , we publish a catalog of coordinates , diameters , and main parameters of all the clusters under study . a special web - site available at http://ocl.sai.msu.ru has been developed to facilitate dissemination and scientific usage of the results . [ 000 ]

1603.04792

ever since databases have been able to store basket data , many techniques have been proposed to extract useful insights for analysts . one of the first , association rule mining @xcite , also remains one of the most intuitive . association rules are often used to summarize consumer trends in a transaction set or as input to a classifier @xcite . the problem is the very high number of rules , typically in the order of millions . that is exacerbated by the lack of thorough studies of which of the many interestingness measures for ranking rules @xcite is most appropriate for which application domain . we present , a framework to compare the outcome of different interestingness measures applied to association rules generated in the food retail domain . relies on a flexible architecture and on @xcite , our parallel and distributed pattern mining algorithm that runs on mapreduce . the use of real datasets and a close collaboration with experienced domain experts from intermarch , one of the largest retailers in france , has led us to selecting the most relevant measures to rank association rules in the food retail domain . our dataset contains @xmath0 million receipts from stores in all of france , gathered over one year , 2013 . mining this data results in a huge number of rules . for example , using a minimum support of mines frequent rules of the form _ customer segment _ _ product category_. out of these , have a confidence of @xmath2 or higher . table [ tab : eyecatcher ] shows a ranking of the top-10 rules according to 3 different interestingness measures proposed in @xcite . if we denote rules as @xmath3 , _ confidence _ is the probability to observe @xmath4 given that we observed @xmath5 , i.e. , @xmath6 . _ piatetsky - shapiro _ @xcite combines how @xmath5 and @xmath4 occur together with how they would if they were independent , i.e. , @xmath7 . _ pearson s _ @xmath8 , measures how unlikely observations of @xmath5 and @xmath4 are independent . this very small example already shows that these measures result in different rule rankings . [ cols= " > , < , > , < , > , < " , ] + we now report the results of a user study with domain experts from intermarch . the goal of this study is to assess the ability of interestingness measures to rank association rules according to the needs of an analyst . as explained in section [ sec : xp : empirical ] , we identified 6 families of measures , and selected a representative of each group for the user study ( table [ tab : groupsummary ] ) . we rely on the expertise of our industrial partner to determine , for each analysis scenario , which family produces the most interesting results . this experiment involved 2 experienced analysts from the marketing department of intermarch . we setup and let analysts select targets multiple times in order to populate the web application s database with association rules ( section [ sec : exploitation ] ) . we let our analysts interact with without any time restriction , and collect their feedback in a free text form . each analyst firstly has to pick a mining scenario among ` demo_assoc ` , ` prod_assoc_t ` , or ` prod_assoc_c ` . then she picks a target category or a target product in the taxonomy . in ` prod_assoc_t ` and ` prod_assoc_c ` , she also has the option to filter out rules whose antecedent products are not from the same category as the target . finally , she chooses one of our 6 ranking measures to sort association rules . neither the name of the measure nor its computed values for association rules are revealed , because we wanted analysts to evaluate rankings without knowing how they were produced . resulting association rules are ranked according to a selected measure . each rule is displayed with its support , confidence and recall , such that analysts can evaluate it at a glance . for each scenario , our analysts are asked which representative measure highlights the most interesting results ( as detailed below , in all cases a few of them were chosen ) . once the analyst selects a target , _ all _ matching rules are returned . the initial motivation of this choice was to determine how many results are worth displaying and are actually examined by the analysts . according to the follow - up interview with the analysts , they carefully considered the first ten results , and screened up to a hundred more . interestingly , analysts mentioned that they also scrolled down to the bottom of the list in order to see which customer segments are not akin to buying the selected category . for example , when browsing demographic association rules , they expected to find \{_50 - 64 _ } @xmath1 _ pet food _ among top results , but also expected \{_<35 , paris _ } @xmath1 _ pet food _ among bottom results . this confirms that all rules should remain accessible . this also indicates that while interestingness measures favor strong associations , it would also be interesting to highlight _ anti_-rules , as those can also convey useful information . we let marketing experts explore all 3 scenarios and express their preference towards groups of measures . in the ` demo_assoc`case , @xmath9 and @xmath10 were both highly appreciated . @xmath9 favors rules such as @xmath11 oise@xmath12 _ flat and carbonated drinks_. these rules are very specific and thus have a very high confidence ( 31,58 % in this particular case ) . however , this comes at the cost of recall ( 0,08 % ) . experts value _ confidence _ much more than _ recall _ , as their priority is finding rules that they consider reliable . a low support is not necessarily an issue , and can lead to the discovery of surprising niche rules that can be exploited nonetheless . as discussed in section [ sec : annotation ] , @xmath10 offers a more balanced trade - off between confidence and recall , and prioritizes rules such as @xmath13 < 35 , * , * @xmath12 _ baby food _ ( confidence 8,57 % , recall 37,61% ) . these rules are interesting because they capture a large fraction of the sales of a given category , but are less reliable and generally less surprising . @xmath14 and @xmath15 were considered as less interesting than @xmath9 and @xmath10 respectively . their results offer similar trade - offs , but with lower confidence each time . @xmath16 and @xmath17 were considered unusable because of their very low confidence . when experimenting with ` prod_assoc ` , we observed a slightly different behavior . by default , the analysts favored @xmath9 and @xmath14 because of the confidence of their results . then , we offered the analysts the possibility of filtering the rules to only keep the ones in which the antecedent contains products from the same category as the target . this led to analysts favoring @xmath10 and @xmath16 . this difference is caused by an important but implicit criterion : the ability of a measure to filter out very popular products . for example , the rule \{_vanilla cream , emmental_}@xmath1 _ chocolate cream _ usually appears just above its shorter version \{_vanilla cream_}@xmath1 _ chocolate cream _ , because the first one has a confidence of @xmath18 and the second @xmath19 . however , experts prefer the second one , because _ emmental _ ( cheese ) is among the heavy hitters in stores . its addition to the rule is hence considered insignificant . this `` noise '' generally increases with _ recall_. hence , when no filtering is available , @xmath9 is selected , but analysts prefer the _ recall _ and _ confidence _ trade - off provided by @xmath10 and @xmath16 . again , @xmath15 suffered from its proximity to @xmath10 with lower confidence , while @xmath17 s confidence was too low . in all cases , analysts mentioned @xmath17 as uninteresting overall because it selects rules of low _ confidence_. in general , sorting by decreasing _ lift _ ( which is close to sorting by decreasing _ confidence _ ) is the preferred choice . combined with the minimum support threshold used in the mining phase , this ranking promotes rules that are considered reliable . however , the preference of the analysts changes when filters are available to narrow down the set of rules to specific product categories . in this case , they favor the compromise between _ confidence _ and _ support _ offered , for instance , by the _ piatetsky - shapiro _ s measure @xcite . to the best of our knowledge , targets datasets which are orders of magnitude bigger ( and sparser ) than those tested in existing work on ranking association rules . this paper is also the first to complement an algorithmic comparative analysis with a user study involving domain experts . the definition of quality of association rules is a well - studied topic in statistics and data mining , summarized in @xcite . in this survey , geng _ et al . _ review as many as 38 measures for association and classification rules . they also discuss 4 sets of properties like symmetry or monotony , and how each of them highlights different meanings of `` rule quality '' , such as novelty and generality . however , we observe no correlation between these properties and the groups of measures discovered using . these 38 measures are compared in @xcite . authors consider the case of extracting and ranking temporal rules ( _ _ event a__@xmath1_event b _ ) from the execution traces of java programs . each measure is evaluated in its ability to rank highly rules known from a ground truth ( java library specification ) . we observe that the measures scoring the highest are all from the groups identified in this work as @xmath9 and @xmath10 , which were also favored by our analysts . there are however some counterexamples , with measures from @xmath9 scoring poorly . the authors then use a statistical approach to build a partial ordering of measures quality . this results in the formation of measure equivalence classes . however , the semantic of these classes is based on the principle of dominance in the evaluation , and not on the comparison of the rankings themselves . hence , the equivalence classes obtained do not match our groups . the main difference between and @xcite is the absence of a ground truth of interesting rules for our dataset . consequently , our evaluation of measures is first comparative , with 4 correlations measures covering both the top of the ranking and the entire ranked list . we then build groups of measures to reduce the number of options presented to expert analysts in the user study . the differences in the results obtained also highlight the importance of performing domain - specific studies , as the properties of data and the expectations of analysts vary significantly . the closest work to ours is herbs @xcite . herbs relies on a different and smaller set of measures to cluster rule rankings . authors perform an analysis of the properties of measures , in addition to an experimental study . the datasets used are from the health and astronomy domains . each of them contains at most transactions and leads to the extraction of 49 to rules . rankings are then compared between all pairs of measures using kendall s @xmath20 correlation measure averaged over all datasets . the largest group of measures identified , which includes confidence , is quite similar to @xmath9 . however , there are also significant differences . for instance , we find @xmath14 and @xmath17 to be very different , while @xcite considers the measures of this group similar . the authors observe a weak resemblance between the theoretical and experimental analysis of the measures . the main similarity between @xcite and is the reliance on a pairwise correlation measure followed by a hierarchical clustering to detect groups of measures . is entirely focused on retail data , which has different properties and contains millions of transactions and rules . is also more exhaustive in the analysis of measures : we consider more interestingness measures , and 4 different ranking correlation measures instead of 1 . this allows us to discover more subtle differences in a more specific domain . finally , we perform a user study to assess the quality of each group according to experts from the retail industry . our use of the _ p - value _ ( via _ pearson s @xmath8 test _ ) in the evaluation of rule interestingness is borrowed from @xcite . a low _ p - value _ shows a correlation between a rule s antecedent and consequent . the use of _ fisher _ s exact test on association rules is inspired by @xcite . both of these works aim at finding highly - correlated itemsets , which requires the analyst to set a threshold on the @xmath21-value . this is common practice in biology , but less meaningful in the retail industry . in @xcite , also propose an exploration framework where rules are grouped by consequent , then traversed by progressively adding items to the antecedent . the framework provides hints to help guess how each additional item would make a difference . such a framework is suitable to some of the scenarios we consider and could be integrated in a future version of . in this paper , we present , a framework for mining association rules from large - scale retail data . we defined 3 mining scenarios allowing analysts to extract associations between user segments and product categories , or products themselves . given a scenario , builds a dataset of transactions and mines in parallel association rules containing targets selected by the analysts . our main contribution is the study of 34 interestingness measures for association rules . we first performed an analytical and an empirical comparison between different rule rankings and grouped measures into 6 families . resulting groups were then evaluated in a user study involving retail experts . we concluded that _ lift _ and _ piatetsky - shapiro _ best fit the needs of the analysts , as they ensure a high confidence . we foresee 3 directions of improvement for . the first one is related to the architecture . is currently implemented using batch processing and on - disk storage . while mining is already fast , i / o operations introduces some latency between the definition of a mining scenario and the display of results . we are currently migrating to an in - memory dataset representation , using spark @xcite , to allow faster target selection and lower response time . a second improvement is the extraction of negative results ( _ anti_-rules ) . that is particularly true for rules containing customer segments . we hence need to determine how negative rules should be ranked in order to properly adjust their proportion in the outcome . finally , while quality measures are crucial to select the most interesting results for the analysts , we would like to introduce diversity in displaying rules and study its impact on analysts satisfaction . p. suganthan g.c . , c. sun , k. gayatri k. , h. zhang , f. yang , n. rampalli , s. prasad , e. arcaute , g. krishnan , r. deep , v. raghavendra , a. doan why big data industrial systems need rules and what we can do about it . in _ proc . sigmod _ , pages 265276 , 2015 . v. k. vavilapalli , a. c. murthy , c. douglas , s. agarwal , m. konar , r. evans , t. graves , j. lowe , h. shah , s. seth , b. saha , c. curino , o. omalley , s. radia , b. reed , and e. baldeschwieler . apache hadoop yarn : yet another resource negotiator . in _ proc . socc _ , pages 5:15:16 , 2013 .

understanding customer buying patterns is of great interest to the retail industry and has shown to benefit a wide variety of goals ranging from managing stocks to implementing loyalty programs . association rule mining is a common technique for extracting correlations such as _ people in the south of france buy ros wine _ or _ customers who buy pat also buy salted butter and sour bread . _ unfortunately , sifting through a high number of buying patterns is not useful in practice , because of the predominance of popular products in the top rules . as a result , a number of `` interestingness '' measures ( over 30 ) have been proposed to rank rules . however , there is no agreement on which measures are more appropriate for retail data . moreover , since pattern mining algorithms output thousands of association rules for each product , the ability for an analyst to rely on ranking measures to identify the most interesting ones is crucial . in this paper , we develop ( comparative analysis of patterns ) , a framework that provides analysts with the ability to compare the outcome of interestingness measures applied to buying patterns in the retail industry . we report on how we used to compare 34 measures applied to over 1,800 stores of intermarch , one of the largest food retailers in france .

1508.06461

establishing the hardware for a quantum network is a challenging task . a source of indistinguishable single photons is required along with a means to store the single photons at each node . single semiconductor quantum dots are excellent sources of single photons : they are bright , robust and fast emitters @xcite . a single quantum dot mimics a two - level atom closely such that single photons can be generated either by spontaneous emission from the upper level @xcite or by coherent scattering of a resonant laser @xcite . subsequently emitted photons are close to indistinguishable @xcite . however , achieving the lifetime - limit has been an elusive goal @xcite , and the wavelength coverage is limited . independently , atomic ensembles have developed into one of the best platforms for optical quantum memories @xcite . the combination of strong absorption and long ground state hyperfine coherence has allowed storage times of miliseconds and efficiencies higher than 75% to be achieved in these systems @xcite . moreover , schemes for broadband operation with single photons at the ghz level have been proposed @xcite and also demonstrated experimentally @xcite ; single photons emitted by a single atom were stored in a bose - einstein condensate of the same species and used to produce entanglement between the two remote systems @xcite . a semiconductor - cold atom quantum hybrid would combine the advantage of the semiconductor ( straightforward single photon generation , large oscillator strength ) with the advantage of the cold atoms ( slow decoherence ) whilst avoiding the disadvantage of the semiconductor ( fast decoherence @xcite ) and the disadvantage of the cold atoms ( complex single photon generation @xcite ) . this would constitute an implementation of a quantum repeater using single photon sources and memories @xcite . unfortunately , the workhorse systems are mismatched in frequency : self - assembled ingaas quantum dots emit typically around 950 nm ; the d1 and d2 transitions of the rb atoms lie at 795 and 780 nm . we note that a frequency match has been achieved with cs @xcite ; a link has also been established with a transition of the yb@xmath0 ion @xcite ; a trapped molecule produces single photons at the na frequency @xcite ; and a new quantum dot growth procedure has led to a first hybrid experiment with rb @xcite . a high quality semiconductor source of single photons frequency - matched to the rb transitions is highly desirable . we present here a close - to - ideal semiconductor source of single photons at the rb d2 wavelength . the emission frequency can be tuned through all the d2-hyperfine lines . we demonstrate lifetime - limited quantum dot linewidths . this points to negligible upper level dephasing and allows us to create photons by coherent rayleigh scattering with weak , resonant excitation . we find that all our experiments ( spectral analysis , intensity autocorrelation , decay dynamics ) can be described in terms of a two - level atom with a common set of parameters . the only significant source of noise is slow relative to radiative emission and results in a telegraph - like blinking behavior . apart from this the system behaves in an ideal way despite the complexity of the solid - state environment . our solid - state source of single photons , fig . [ fig1 ] , consists of a gaas / algaas quantum dot ( qd ) obtained by filling al - droplet - etched nanoholes with gaas @xcite . the holes are formed by depositing 0.5 mono - layer ( ml ) of aluminium at a growth rate of 0.5 ml / s and at a temperature of 600 c on a al@xmath1ga@xmath2as surface . this is followed by a 5 minute annealing step in arsenic ambiance . the holes are then filled with gaas grown at 0.1 ml / s and capped again with al@xmath1ga@xmath2as resulting in strain - free gaas qds . the photoluminescence ( pl ) from the ensemble is adjusted to @xmath3 nm , the wavelength of the rb d2-line , by controlling the exact amount of deposited gaas . [ fig1]b shows a typical pl spectrum from a single qd recorded at @xmath4 k with non - resonant excitation at 633 nm . we observe several lines in the pl spectrum . we identify in particular the neutral exciton ( x ) and a red - detuned charged exciton ( cx ) . the other lines are related to other exciton states , as yet unidentified . to fine tune the qd frequency with respect to the rb transition lines , the sample is glued onto a piezo - electric transducer which induces uniaxial strain in the sample @xcite , fig . [ fig1]a . by scanning the piezo - voltage , reversible tuning over @xmath5 ghz is achieved with very little creep from the piezo - electric elements , see fig . in fact , the emission frequencies of the pl lines are stable over the course of a day such that a stabilization scheme was not necessary in these experiments . w / m@xmath6 ) . we identify the neutral exciton ( x ) and a charged exciton ( cx ) which display narrow linewidths , limited here by the @xmath7 ghz spectrometer resolution . c ) sketch of the qd layer and an afm picture of the nano - holes obtained with in - situ etching @xcite.,width=321 ] we first report resonance fluorescence on a single gaas qd , the artificial rb atom . for this , we use the dark - field microscope sketched in fig . a resonant laser beam is focussed onto the sample with linear polarization ; resonance fluorescence from the qd is detected in the orthogonal polarization @xcite . careful control of the polarization suppresses the back - scattered laser light by 80 db . we find that very weak non - resonant laser light ( @xmath8 nm , @xmath9 nw/@xmath10m@xmath6 ) is a necessary condition to observe resonance fluorescence on cx . this non - resonant excitation quenches the excitation of the neutral x and therefore acts as an optical gate " @xcite . this result was reproducibly observed on all five qds that we tested . nw/@xmath10m@xmath11 ) . the laser background ( @xmath12 cts / s over the @xmath13 ghz scanning range ) is indicated in green . b ) resonance fluorescence intensity and fwhm as a function of resonant laser power . c ) frequency tuning of cx showing a linear response to the applied voltage with very little creep over the course of several days . the d2 transitions of rb are indicated as dashed lines : ( i ) @xmath14rb @xmath15 , ( ii ) @xmath16rb @xmath17 , ( iii ) @xmath16rb @xmath18 and ( iv ) @xmath14rb @xmath17 . d ) second order correlation of the resonance fluorescence signal . in blue , the detectors response function ( arbitrary units for the y - axis ) measured with ultra - short laser pulses ( @xmath19 ps ) at the qd frequency . the red line results from a fit using eq . [ g2tls ] convoluted with the detectors response function . all data are obtained in the presence of an additional weak , constant non - resonant laser excitation of @xmath20 nw / m@xmath11 . the background associated with the non - resonant excitation is smaller than the detectors dark counts.,width=321 ] to record resonance fluorescence spectra , we monitor the count rate on a ccd camera as we sweep the laser frequency across the qd transition , as illustrated in fig . [ fig2]a for the cx transition of qd1 . the spectrum is fitted with a lorentzian profile , and displays a signal - to - background ratio @xmath21 at the resonance . in the low power regime , the linewidth is @xmath22 ghz , see fig . we confirm the anti - bunched nature of the emitted photons by performing second - order correlation measurements on the resonance fluorescence signal , fig . there is a small bunching on the normalized data ( @xmath23 for @xmath24 ns ) which results from a slow blinking process , discussed below . for @xmath25s , the exact blinking dynamics can be ignored and the data are fitted to the product of a constant pre - factor , which accounts for the qd dead - time ( i.e. the blinking ) , and the second - order correlation function of a resonantly driven two - level system @xcite @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the spontaneous radiative emission rate , @xmath28 corresponds to the pure dephasing rate and @xmath29 , with @xmath30 the rabi frequency of the resonant drive . taking the experimentally measured response of the detectors into account , we find a very nice agreement and thus a coincidence detection probability consistent with zero at zero delay , the signature of pure single photon emission . we now turn to the spectroscopy of the rb atomic ensemble using qd photons . we insert a room temperature @xmath31 mm long rb vapor cell in the detection line . the cell contains both @xmath16rb and @xmath14rb in natural abundance ( @xmath32 and @xmath33 , respectively ) . in a first experiment , qd1 is excited with the non - resonant pump only with @xmath34 w / m@xmath6 , fig . transmission through the atomic cloud is recorded as the piezo - voltage is increased thus tuning the qd emission frequency . as the cx transition is scanned from @xmath35 thz to @xmath36 thz , we observe several dips in the transmission corresponding to the hyperfine structure of the two rubidium isotopes , fig . [ fig2]c . in order to distinguish between the qd and the atomic contributions to the linewidth , we perform a calibration measurement on the vapor cell by measuring the transmission with the laser only ( fwhm @xmath37 mhz @100@xmath10s ) . the result , shown in the appendix ( see fig . [ fig : vaporabsorptionspectrum ] ) , is fitted to the theoretical rb transmission spectrum , where the only unknown is the vapor cell temperature . excellent agreement is found for @xmath38 c , corresponding to a doppler broadening of @xmath39 mhz . to describe the transmission spectrum recorded with qd photons , we then convolve the rb spectrum with a lorentzian profile of width @xmath40 , the qd linewidth under non - resonant excitation . best agreement between the resulting function and the data is obtained for @xmath41 ghz . the modest depth of the transmission peaks reflects the mismatch between the qd linewidth and the atomic spectral width . a lifetime - limited linewidth implies a negligible rate of exciton dephasing in the qd . in turn , this opens the possibility of generating single photons by coherent rayleigh scattering . the resonance fluorescence can be divided into a coherent part , the rayleigh scattering of the incoming laser light , and an incoherent part , resulting from an absorption and re - emission cycle . including pure dephasing , the fraction of coherently scattered photons is given by @xmath42 ( see appendix [ apdx_theory_qdres ] for a complete description of the resonant spectrum . ) the ratio is maximum in the low power regime ( @xmath43 ) , the rayleigh regime , and approaches unity should @xmath44 become negligible compared to @xmath27 . the last point highlights the importance of achieving a small dephasing rate . conversely , the ratio decreases at high power where the strong excitation leads to inelastic scattering ( mollow triplet ) . we explore the possibility of coherent rayleigh scattering in a second experiment where we drive the qd resonantly in the low power limit ( @xmath45 nw/@xmath10m@xmath6 ) . the resulting rb transmission spectrum is shown in fig . [ fig3]b . for a given driving laser frequency , we tune the qd into resonance via the piezo - voltage , and we measure the resonance fluorescence signal transmitted through the rb vapor cell . this is then repeated for different laser frequencies . the transmission data are normalized using a linear baseline defined by points recorded when the qd is detuned from the rb transitions . in fig . [ fig3]b , the four dips corresponding to the d2-transitions of @xmath16rb and @xmath14rb can now clearly be resolved , showing negligible broadening of the atomic transitions beyond that of the atomic vapor itself . this implies that the spectrum of the light scattered by the qd has been narrowed down significantly below the lifetime limit , a clear evidence of coherent scattering from the qd @xcite . to fit the measured spectrum in the rayleigh regime , we compute the convolution between the atomic spectrum and the resonant emission spectrum , with @xmath27 , @xmath44 and @xmath30 as free parameters . in order to determine a value for each parameter with the highest accuracy , we perform a global fit on both the transmission spectrum ( fig . [ fig3]b ) and the second - order correlation measurement ( fig . [ fig2]d ) . from this combined analysis we determine @xmath46 ghz , @xmath47 ghz and @xmath48 ghz , which corresponds to a fraction of coherently scattered photons as high as @xmath49 ( see details in appendix [ apdx_theory_qdres ] ) . these results are further supported by recording a decay curve following non - resonant pulsed excitation . the data , which , incidentally , point to an unusually slow relaxation mechanism for transferring carriers from high energy continuum states into the qd , result in @xmath50 ghz , consistent with the spectroscopy analysis ( see fig . [ fig : lifetime_pulsed_nr ] from appendix [ apdx_nrdecay ] ) . we note also the excellent agreement with the power broadening experiment where the resonance fluorescence linewidth is described within the two - level system framework , with @xmath27 and @xmath44 as input parameters , fig . [ fig2]b . these results allow us to make an important conclusion , namely that we achieve lifetime - limited emission with our artificial atom . we thus combine , in a solid - state environment , a high single photon flux with negligible dephasing , a key result for further quantum optics experiments , for instance the generation of indistinguishable photons . in addition , this conclusion applies not only under resonant excitation ( resonance fluorescence ) , but also under non - resonant excitation ( photoluminescence ) . this is a surprising result in the context of ingaas qds where the transform limit has been achieved only with resonant excitation and for very specific conditions @xcite ; in the best case with non - resonant excitation the linewidth is about a factor of two larger than the transform limit @xcite and is typically much larger still . these exceptional results on gaas qds reflect the high quality of the epitaxial material combined with the short radiative lifetime and possibly an unknown semiconductor advantage of strain - free qds over highly - strained qds . the solid - state environment results in negligible dephasing of the qd single photon source . however , the effects of the solid - state environment are not completely suppressed : fig . [ fig4 ] shows a correlation measurement under resonant excitation on a second qd for three different values of non - resonant power . the data are normalized to the average count per time bin for a poissonian source , @xmath51 , with @xmath52 and @xmath53 the count rates on each avalanche photo - diode , @xmath54 the time - resolution of the experiment and @xmath55 the total integration time . in addition to the anti - bunching at zero delay already outlined in fig . [ fig2]c , we observe a strong bunching peak at short delays ( @xmath56 as high as @xmath57 ) . this corresponds to the signature of blinking in the qd emission @xcite : the presence of dead times in the qd fluorescence produces packets of single photons separated in time . assuming a simple boolean statistics for the blinking process @xcite , ergodic and statistically independent of the two - level radiative decay , the second - order correlation function of the qd signal can be expressed as @xmath58 where @xmath59 corresponds to the fraction of time in which the qd is in an on " state , and @xmath60 to the correlation time of the blinking process . the first term ( left bracket ) accounts for telegraph noise associated with the blinking , the second term for the dynamics of the resonantly driven two - level system , cf . ( [ g2tls ] ) . from the fit of the data , we extract @xmath61 , a less favorable situation for the charged exciton in qd2 as compared to qd1 ( @xmath62 , see fig . [ fig2]d and fig . [ g2_qd1_longtimes ] from appendix [ apdx_g2qd1long ] ) . the blinking dynamics are strongly modified as we increase the non - resonant power . we find that @xmath60 varies by several orders of magnitude over the available range of power with @xmath59 remaining approximately constant . this result was reproducibly observed on all qds we tested and reflects the general nature of the solid - state environment . it shows how the non - resonant laser power offers some control over the environment , here in all likelihood fluctuations in charge ( either in the qd or in the immediate vicinity of the qd ) which bring the qd in and out of resonance in a telegraph fashion with the fixed frequency laser . we note that @xmath60 is in all cases considerably larger than the radiative lifetime ( 90 ps ) such that the blinking contribution to the qd linewidth is small : the telegraph noise is consistent with the claim of a lifetime - limited qd linewidth . also , we note that the simple on : off model does not capture all the details of the blinking dynamics . at high resonant power , the decrease in resonance fluorescence peak signal at the highest resonant powers ( fig . [ fig2]b ) is probably related to an increase in the qd dead - time . nw / m@xmath6 ) . solid red lines are fits obtained from eq . ( [ eq : g2blink]).,width=321 ] in conclusion , we report here a quantum hybrid system consisting of a frequency - matched solid - state source of single photons , a single quantum dot , and a rb atomic vapor . the quantum dots exhibit lifetime - limited linewidths , even under non - resonant excitation . resonance fluorescence in the rayleigh scattering regime is used to address the bandwidth mismatch between the two quantum systems . the most significant solid - state noise is at @xmath63 mhz frequencies and results in telegraph noise in the emission reflecting qd blinking . we demonstrate some control over this correlation time , useful in the context of decoupling the qd from its complex environment . further work should address this noise and also engineering of the photonic environment in order to achieve a higher qd single photon collection efficiency . implementation of quantum memory protocols can then be attempted @xcite . we acknowledge financial support from nccr qsit and the european union seventh framework programme 209 ( fp7/2007 - 2013 ) under grant agreement no . 601126 210 ( hanas ) , and thank m. rakher and n. sangouard for fruitful discussions . , m.m . and l.b . made equal contributions to this work . + + max width=0.99 [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] we derive here the absorption spectrum of the rb vapor cell , following the method described in ref . . for weak probe intensity , the transmission of a monochromatic wave of angular frequency @xmath64 through an atomic vapor with uniform density is given by @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the length of the vapor cell and @xmath67 is the absorption coefficient of the atomic vapor , which is only dependent on the temperature @xmath55 . our cell contains @xmath68 and @xmath69 in natural abundance ( @xmath70% and @xmath71% ) so that the total absorption reads @xmath72 . for each isotope , we consider the six allowed electric dipole hyperfine transitions shown in fig . [ fig : d2properties]a , which leads to the following expression for the absorption of isotope @xmath73 @xmath74 where @xmath75 ( with @xmath76 the bohr radius ) is the reduced dipole matrix element computed for the d2 line , @xmath77 is the total strength coefficient of the degenerate hyperfine transition @xmath78 ( tabulated in fig . [ fig : d2properties]b for linear incident polarization ) and @xmath79 $ ] is the isotope atomic density per zeeman sublevel . @xmath68 and @xmath69 have nuclear spins @xmath80 and @xmath81 and their relative density @xmath82 is obtained from the ideal gas law where the vapor pressure @xmath83 is given by equations ( a.1 ) and ( a.2 ) of ref . @xcite . finally , the lineshape factor @xmath84 corresponds to the doppler broadened profile of the atomic transition @xmath78 . we take the lorentzian profile of the atom with natural linewidth @xmath85 mhz ( the experimentally measured decay rate of the @xmath86 atomic state @xcite ) integrated over the gaussian distribution of atomic velocities parallel to the probe beam , with @xmath87 width @xmath88 ( @xmath89 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath90 is the isotope atomic mass ) . at @xmath91c , the thermal longitudinal motion of the atom leads to a full - width half maximum ( fwhm ) doppler broadening @xmath92 ghz for the d2 line at 780 nm . [ fig : vaporabsorptionspectrum ] shows an experimental transmission spectrum of a 75 mm rubidium vapor cell measured using a tunable 780 nm external cavity diode laser ( short term [ @xmath93s ] fwhm @xmath94 mhz ) with linear incident polarization . the data are fitted using equations ( [ eq : vaportransmission ] ) , ( [ eq : absorptioncoefficient ] ) and ( [ eq : voigtprofilenorm ] ) , where the vapor temperature is the only free parameter . excellent agreement is obtained for @xmath95c ( see solid line ) . ) , ( [ eq : absorptioncoefficient ] ) and ( [ eq : voigtprofilenorm ] ) with @xmath96c.,width=321 ] we aim at describing the resonance fluorescence ( rf ) power spectrum @xmath98 of a qd excited resonantly . to do so , we assume that the qd behaves as a two - level system . we follow the approach of mollow@xcite and extend it to include the additional pure dephasing associated to the extra coupling to the qd solid - state environment . we first evaluate the first order coherence @xmath99 of the field scattered by the qd , from which we can easily derive its power spectrum . the two - level system has a ground state @xmath100 , excited state @xmath101 ( decay rate @xmath102 ) , and a transition angular frequency @xmath103 . neglecting retardation effects , the first - order coherence reads @xmath104 @xmath105 where @xmath106 are the density matrix elements of the two - level system , and @xmath107 and @xmath108 are atomic transition operators . the dynamics under coherent illumination are described by the optical bloch equations@xcite . the steady - state expectation values of the transition operators are computed in the interaction picture using the quantum regression theorem . the decay rates are @xmath109 for the populations , and @xmath110 for the coherences . following the derivation of ref . we obtain the steady - state expression @xmath111 , which , in the resonant case @xmath112 , is given by @xmath113 , \label{eq : firstordercoherence2}\end{gathered}\ ] ] with @xmath114 p & = & \dfrac{2\omega^2-\gamma_{\rm sp}+2\gamma^*\gamma_{\rm sp}}{2\omega^2+\gamma_{\rm sp}+2\gamma^*\gamma_{\rm sp } } \\[\bigskipamount ] q & = & \dfrac{\omega^2(5\gamma_{\rm sp}-2\gamma^ * ) - 2\gamma^{*2}\gamma_{\rm sp } + 2\gamma^*\gamma_{\rm sp}^2-\gamma_{\rm sp}^3/2}{2\lambda ( 2\omega^2+\gamma_{\rm sp}+2\gamma^*\gamma_{\rm sp})}. \end{array } \right . \end{array } \label{eq : firstordercoherence3}\ ] ] the fourier transform of @xmath97 gives the expression for the rf power spectrum @xmath115 which depends on three parameters only : the driving rabi frequency @xmath30 , the radiative decay rate of the excited state @xmath102 , and the pure dephasing rate @xmath28 . experimental rf spectra result from the convolution of ( [ eq : rfspectrum ] ) with the emission spectrum of the resonant laser . in practice , we use a highly coherent 780 nm external cavity diode laser , that we model by a gaussian profile with a full width at half maximum of 1mhz . within the two - level system model ( tls ) , the second order coherence of the field scattered by the qd is given by @xmath117 as before , it is derived in the interaction picture using the quantum regression theorem . using the same notations , we find @xmath118 which depends on the same three parameters @xmath30 , @xmath102 , and @xmath28 . in order to evaluate the qd spontaneous emission rate and dephasing rate , we perform a simultaneous fit ( @xmath119-minimization ) of 1 ) the rb vapor transmission spectrum measured with single photons from the resonantly excited qd , and 2 ) the intensity correlation measurements ( respectively fig . 3b and fig . as we used the same resonant laser intensity @xmath120nw / m@xmath6 in both experiments , the two data sets are fitted by a common set of the three parameters @xmath30 , @xmath102 , and @xmath28 ( see previous section ) . for each data set , the vertical error bars used in the @xmath119-minimization result from shot noise in the number of detected photons per time bin . we find @xmath121ghz , @xmath122ghz , and @xmath123ghz , where the error bars correspond to one standard deviation . to appreciate the fit sensitivity , we plot in fig . [ fig : comparisonpanel ] the theoretical predictions corresponding to values of the fitting parameters differing by three standard deviations . * the first column shows the predictions of the model obtained with the parameters from the best fit : @xmath124ghz , @xmath125ghz , and @xmath126ghz . * the second column draws attention to the case of a non - zero pure dephasing @xmath127ghz ( + 3@xmath128 value ) , with the constraint @xmath1291.42ghz ( total fwhm measured in fig . 2a of the article ) . in this case , the coherent fraction of the scattered light decreases to @xmath130 , such that the absorption peaks on the transmission spectrum become broader and shallower . * the last column shows the predictions of the model with larger rabi frequency @xmath131ghz ( + 3@xmath128-value ) , keeping @xmath102 and @xmath44 at optimal values . a close examination shows that the absorption peaks on the transmission spectrum also become broader and shallower , and the rise time at the dip of the intensity auto - correlation becomes slightly shorter . as an additionnal consistency check , we can fit the dependence of the fwhm of the rf spectrum @xmath132 ( fig . 2b ) with laser intensity using the expression @xmath133 , with the value of @xmath102 obtained above and an adjustable coefficient @xmath134 . best agreement is obtained for @xmath135(rad / s)@xmath11/(nw / m@xmath6 ) . from this fit , the rabi frequency corresponding to the operating resonant intensity @xmath136nw / m@xmath6 that we extract is @xmath1370.35ghz , in excellent agreement with the value obtained from the previous analysis . ) convoluted by the measured instrument response ( @xmath138ps , see inset ) and scaled to the signal amplitude , with @xmath139ghz and @xmath140mhz.,width=321 ] in order to confirm the value for the spontaneous emission rate of the qd upper level , we perform decay - time measurements with a non - resonant pulsed laser ( @xmath141 nm , @xmath142ps pulses , 80mhz repetition rate ) . the dynamics of the population @xmath143 are well described by einstein rate equations with two distinct rates : @xmath144 , the relaxation from the continuum to the qd excitonic state , and @xmath102 , the radiative decay rate to the qd ground state ( see fig . [ fig : lifetime_pulsed_nr]a ) . assuming that the system is initially excited in the continuum , the population of the state @xmath145 takes the form @xmath146 the result from our measurements is shown in fig . [ fig : lifetime_pulsed_nr]b for low excitation power . the fit of the data yields a high rate ( small lifetime ) of @xmath147ghz ( @xmath148ps ) and a slow rate ( long lifetime ) of @xmath149mhz ( @xmath150ps ) . this is completely consistent with the rb cell spectroscopy and g@xmath151 results provided the high rate is associated to radiative decay , and the slow rate to relaxation , an association which we have confirmed with pulsed resonant excitation ( data not shown ) . the relationship of the relaxation and decay rates is contrary to the standard interpretation for ingaas qds , for which relaxation is much faster than radiative decay . we speculate that the presence of a tunnel barrier between the qds and the nearby wetting layer ( the ring - shaped algaas mound , cf . [ fig1 ] ) , combined with the indirect bandgap in the al - rich algaas surrounding matrix are responsible for the unusually slow relaxation dynamics . of course , the decay curves determines the total decay rate not necessarily the radiative decay rate . however , we are working here with mbe - grown gaas of very high quality at low temperature where it is safe to assume that non - radiative decay processes are weak such that spontaneous emission represents the dominant decay process . the radiative lifetime is rather short and corresponds to an oscillator strength of @xmath152 . the oscillator strength is around 10 in the strong confinement regime @xcite ( quantization energy much larger than the coulomb energy ) rising to well above 100 in the weak confinement regime @xcite . in this case the result , similar in fact to that of interface fluctuation quantum dots @xcite , shows that the quantum dot is in the intermediate confinement regime . for the correlation measurements , we position a hemispherical solid - immersion lens on the surface of the sample , thereby increasing the count rates by a factor of @xmath153 . [ g2_qd1_longtimes ] extends the data shown in fig . 2d to longer delays . we clearly observe a bunching dynamics with a correlation time on the order of @xmath154 ns . the count rate for this experiment was @xmath155 cts / s , so that we can exclude any artefact from the detector@xcite . [ suppl - influence_nr_pump ] shows the effect of an increasing non - resonant contribution on the resonance fluorescence intensity of the neutral and charged excitons . the data is recorded on qd2 and the data points correspond to the same non - resonant intensities as used in fig . we note that the values reported here are calculated assuming a perfectly focused beam . our objective lens is however mono - chromatic and its focus adjusted to maximize collection efficiency at @xmath158 nm . 43ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1038/nphoton.2007.46 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1038/nnano.2012.262 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.93.217401 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphoton.2009.231 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1080/09500340.2013.856482 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphys2324 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.083601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.112.033601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.88.053834 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/1367-2630/17/i=4/a=043006 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.106.210503 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.76.050301 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1063/1.2204843 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.3653804 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.92.166104 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.057401 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1038/ncomms9204 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.65.041308 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1721637 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 4075/41/15/155004 [ * * , ( ) ] http://steck.us/alkalidata/ [ ( ) ] http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrev.188.1969 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.58.16221 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.60.13276 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.65.241310 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( )

we report results important for the creation of a best - of - both - worlds quantum hybrid system consisting of a solid - state source of single photons and an atomic ensemble as quantum memory . we generate single photons from a gaas quantum dot ( qd ) frequency - matched to the rb d2-transitions and then use the rb transitions to analyze spectrally the quantum dot photons . we demonstrate lifetime - limited qd linewidths ( 1.42 ghz ) with both resonant and non - resonant excitation . the qd resonance fluorescence in the low power regime is dominated by rayleigh scattering , a route to match quantum dot and rb atom linewidths and to shape the temporal wave packet of the qd photons . noise in the solid - state environment is relatively benign : there is a blinking of the resonance fluorescence at mhz rates but negligible dephasing of the qd excitonic transition . we therefore demonstrate significant progress towards the realization of an ideal solid - state source of single photons at a key wavelength for quantum technologies .

cond-mat0102225

the surface - force apparatus developed by tabor and winterton ( 1969 ) and further refined by israelachvili and adams ( 1978 ) , klein ( 1983 ) and parker _ et al . _ ( 1989 , ) has proven useful for the measurement of colloidal forces between atomically smooth transparent surfaces in liquid and gases at molecular scale . in these classical apparatii the distance between the surfaces is measured by the interferometry of white light fringes ( fringes of equal chromatic order , feco ) . this technique allows to measure steady or slowly varying distances , with a resolution of a few @xmath1 . chan ( 1985 ) has employed videocameras to record rapidly changing position of the surfaces with a time resolution about @xmath2 , during the drainage of a fluid out of the contact region . recently , this interferometric method has been improved ( grunewaled ( 1996 ) ) by using expensive high speed video treatments . the first method proposed for doing a dynamical measurement was to use a piezoelectric bimorph ( van alsten ( 1988 ) , israelachvili ( 1989 ) , peachey ( 1991 ) ) , which has also the advantage of allowing opaque surfaces to be used . although parker ( 1992 ) showed that a bimorph can be used to take a measurement from less than a tenth of a second to several minutes , these devices are unsuitable for measurements that take place over many minutes or hours . furthermore , the single - cantilever construction of the bimorph implies that a displacement of his head results also in an angular rotation . the resulting shear motion makes it unsuitable for the measurement of adhesive forces . recently the use of a capacitor dilatometry attachment for the conventional surface - force apparatus has been proposed by stewart ( 1992 ) for statics measurements with a resolution of @xmath3 . ( 1988 , 1989 ) described a surface forces apparatus in which they used capacitors to obtain both the distance and the interaction force between a sphere and a plane . this apparatus is suitable for non tranparent surfaces and dynamical study of confined liquids . in this paper , we propose a new method for measuring displacement at the nanometer scale in surface force apparatus , based on a capacitor included in an oscillator . unlike the capacitive sensor proposed by steward ( 2000 ) or franz et al . ( 1996,1997 ) , our method for the capacitance measurement is a low cost method which does not require the use of a lock - in amplifier , without loss in resolution or dynamic performances . from the point of view of surface forces measurements , the method has the advantages of being linear on a large scale , of allowing mesasurements between non transparent surfaces , and is suitable for dynamical measurements . when used in conjunction with an interferometric technique ( crassous _ in preparation _ ) for the purpose of calibration , this sensor can be used to perform nanorheological measurements or contact forces measurements between the surfaces . a schematic diagram of the surface forces apparatus is given in figure [ fig : sfa_plan ] . this apparatus has several features which distinguish it from the common sfa . first of all , the surfaces are not necessary transparent , since the sfa does not use the feco technique . the surfaces are usually a sphere and a plane . the plane surface is mounted on the left - hand double - cantilever @xmath4 of stiffness @xmath5 . an optical interferometer measures the deflection of @xmath4 to obtain directly the force measurements . the sphere is mounted on the right - hand double - cantilever @xmath6 and can be moved in the direction normal to the plane . the cantilever @xmath6 prevents the rolling of the surfaces . the sphere motion is controlled by three actuactors . the first one is a motorized microscrew driven by a stepping motor . it allows a displacement of @xmath7 nm to @xmath8 cm and is used for a rough positionning of the sphere . the second actuator is a piezoelectric actuator which allows a continuous approach of the two surfaces with a velocity range of @xmath9 to @xmath10 nm.s@xmath11 . the last piezoelectric actuator is designed to add a small sinusoidal motion in to study the dynamic behavior of the sphere - plane interactions . the relative displacement between the sphere and the plane , @xmath12 , is determined by the capacitive sensor described in this article . finally , in order to calibrate the capacitive sensor , a permanent magnet mounted on the cantilever @xmath4 is located in the magnetic field gradient produced by a little coil of copper wire . this setup allows to calibrate the sensor over a large range of displacement ( @xmath13 @xmath14 m ) . all these devices are controlled by a hewlett packard vxi 743 computer equiped with a e1421a 16 channels a / d and d / a converters . a more complete description of this apparatus will be given in a forthcoming publication . the measurement capacitor consists of two duraluminium discs with a radius @xmath15 and a thickness @xmath16 . the typical distance between the plates is typically @xmath17 @xmath18 and the surfaces have been polished to have a roughness smaller than the sistance between the two plates of the capacitor . one plate is fixed on the cantilever supporting the plane @xmath4 , and the other on the cantilever supporting the sphere @xmath6 so that when the surfaces are brought together , the plates of the capacitor do also . parallel alignment of the plates is obtained with a mechanical ball - and - socket joint which is rigidly screwed after the plates have been pushed in contact to obtain the parallelism . the terminals of the capacitor plates are connected to the oscillator with thin copper leads whose compliance is much higher than the one of the cantilever . to decrease the viscous drag induced by the air flow between the plates of the capacitor , some holes are drilled in the moving plate . the weight of the capacitor , which is important for the resonant frequency of our surface force apparatus is roughly @xmath19 . the capacitance @xmath20 of this sensor is typically @xmath21 pf and its serial resistance about @xmath22 . in order to measure the capacitance variations of this sensor , we include it in an oscillator . we use a clapp oscillator containing two fixed capacitor @xmath23 , the variable capacitor @xmath20 , and an inductance @xmath24 ( figure [ fig : oscillateur ] ) . the clapp oscillator is known to have a good stability and to be easy to build ( audouin ( 1991 ) ) . neglecting the leads capacitances and straight capacitances , the frequency of the oscillations of the clapp oscillator is : @xmath25 this formula can be used to have an estimation of the nominal frequency and of the sensitivity of the sensor . using the typical values @xmath26 , @xmath27 pf and @xmath28h , we have a typical frequency of @xmath29 mhz and a typical sensitivity of the order of @xmath13 hz / . this shows that in order to have a precision of @xmath30 nm on the displacement measurement , we have to read frequency variations of @xmath31 hz . for this purpose , we use a hewlett packard hp53132a counter which reaches this precision with an acquisition time of less than @xmath9 s. we emphasize that reading one part in @xmath32 is really easy in a frequency measurement but is difficult and expensive in voltage measurements . the conventional way to make a distance measurement with this device is first to fix the distance between the capacitor s plates at a distance comprised between @xmath33 and @xmath34 and to calibrate the sensitivity for small displacements around this distance . indeed we do not use equation ( [ equ : freq ] ) to determine the sensitivity of the sensor , since this latter depends slightly on the angular parallelism of the capacitors plates . in order to calibrate the sensor , we use an interferometer , which is mounted on our sfa ( schonenberger ( 1989 ) ) and allows to perform easy calibrations . the detailed procedure is as follows : the rhs cantilever @xmath6 is fixed , a force is applied on the cantilever @xmath4 by the mean of the coil / magnet system . the deflection of @xmath4 results in a displacement @xmath35 of the sensor s plate . fixed on @xmath4 , as well as of the mirror . the interferometer gives access to the absolute value of @xmath35 , and the calibration is done by plotting @xmath36 , the frequency of the oscillator as a function of @xmath35 . in order to reduce the noise ( see paragraph [ sec : noise ] ) , we usually integrate the frequency signal over a time of @xmath13 s. fig . [ fig : f_x ] shows the calibration over a displacement range of @xmath37 nm . one can see that the capacitive sensor is very linear . the typical maximum deviation to linearity over this scale is lower than @xmath38 of the total excursion range . the measured sensitivity is : 7.70 hz.@xmath11 . this is closed to the estimated value deduce from equation ( [ equ : freq ] ) but take into account all the straight capacitances . the capacitance measuring circuit is in fact sensitive to stray capacitance between the upper sensing electrode and ground . therefore the value @xmath20 of the capacitance in equation ( 1 ) includes not only the sensor capacitance , but also the value of stray capacitances , the larger of which is the capacitance of the screen cable connecting the sensor to the circuit . the order of magnitude of those stray capacitances can be estimated by increasing the distance between the capacitor electrodes up to the point where it does not affect anymore the frequency of the oscillator . the overall value of the stray capacitance can be as large as @xmath39 . during the typical time of an experiment in a sfa ( typically 30 mn ) and with the environment conditions required by the sfa itself ( the sfa is located in a separated closed room where nobody enters during an experiment ; signal acquisition and experiment control are performed from another room ) , it turns out that the overall stray capacitance does not change significantly except for smooth drifts which can not be distinguished from the thermal drift of the measuring circuit itself ( see hereafter ) . significant change of the stray capacitance occur usually other large period of time ( one day ) or when a change is made on the sensor ( tuning of the distance or orientation of the electrodes , change in the location of the oscillator ) . therefore , the sensitivity of the sensor is periodically calibrated with the interferometer , in order to take in account the changes in sensitivity induced by the modification of the value of the stray capacitance . without any displacement imposed on the cantilevers , we can measure the noise and the thermal drift in a typical situation . those quantities will limit the static performance of our apparatus and the thermal drift must be corrected to obtain an accurate measurement of the relative displacement of the surfaces . figure [ fig : vibration_noise_freq ] shows a typical record of the signal given by the counter converted in displacement . the noise is less @xmath9 nm peak to peak . this is due to the mechanical vibrations on the cantilever @xmath4 . with a simple plexiglass cover over the entire instrument and without any temperature control we find a drift rate smaller than @xmath40 nm / s . this drift is of the same order as the drift reported in other articles ( schonenberger ( 1989 ) ) . it is worthwhile to inquire about the electrostatic attractive forces between the charged plates of this plane capacitor . in general the force is given by : @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the average of the square voltage between the capacitor s plates , @xmath43 the plates area and @xmath44 the dielectric permittivity of vacuum . the force is @xmath45 @xmath14n for typical values @xmath17 @xmath14 m and @xmath46 v. this force is nearly constant over one experiment since the relative displacement of the plates is always much smaller than @xmath47 . a piezoelectric crystal is used to add a sinusoidal motion ( tonck ( 1988 ) ) of small amplitude on cantilever @xmath6 in order to determine the dynamic behaviour of the sphere - plane interaction . the distance between the surfaces is thus @xmath12 with @xmath12 being the sum of two components : @xmath48 where @xmath49 is a slowly varying function of time ( @xmath50 nm / s ) . this results in a modulation of the frequency of the capacitive sensor . this harmonic frequency modulation can not be read with the counter when @xmath51 is larger than @xmath13 hz . we built a high - resolution frequency to voltage converter to read this distance modulation between the surfaces . the diagram of this converter is drawn on figure [ fig : pll ] . the principle of the operation is as follows : the high frequency signal ( frequency @xmath52 ) is multiplied by a reference signal generated by a stable function generator hp31320a ( frequency @xmath53 ) . the output signal is a combination of signals at @xmath54 and higher frequency signals . it is first passed through a low - pass filter then directed to a frequency to voltage converter built with a digital phase - lock - loop with a range of @xmath55 hz and a sensitivity of @xmath56 v.hz@xmath11 . this frequency - shift technique allows to obtain a high sensitivity in the conversion which could not be directly obtained with a phase lock loop . the final sensitivity on the @xmath57 displacement is @xmath58 v.nm@xmath11 . the output voltage is connected on a digital two - phase lock - in amplifier ( standford research system sr830 dsp lock in amplifier ) whose reference signal is the signal used to drive the piezoelectric element ( see figure [ fig : ftov_principle ] ) . the dynamical response of the displacement sensor can be obtained with the same procedure as the static calibration . a white noise excitation containing all the frequencies in the range @xmath0 hz is applied on the cantilever @xmath4 by the mean of the coil / magnet system . the frequency response of the capacitive sensor is calibrated by the frequency response of the interferometer mounted on @xmath4 , whose response is flat in amplitude and frequency . this also allows a dynamical calibration of the displacement sensor . the electrical noise of the capacitive sensor converted in distance is less than @xmath13 pm.hz@xmath59 in the range 0 - 100 hz , except in the range @xmath60 hz , where the noise of the electronics is bigger than a few pm.hz@xmath59 . since the dynamic experiments are usually made at a given frequency , this frequency must be chosen not to close to the line frequency . the mechanical noise on the displacement sensor ( figure [ fig : vibration_spectrum ] is due to the mechanical vibrations on the cantilever @xmath4 and are much more important than the electronic noise . in this experiments , we use a sphere of @xmath61 mm in diameter and a plane made of pyrex . the surfaces are washed in an ultrasound bath with distilled water and a detergent soap for more than an hour . the surfaces are then rinsed with propanol purified at @xmath62 . finally the surfaces are passed in a flame in order to burn out the last amount of pollution and to flatten the surfaces . the total roughness of this surfaces measured by an atomic force microscope is less than @xmath63 nm rms on a 1 @xmath14m@xmath64 square . the surfaces are quickly mounted on the apparatus . a small drop of an organic liquid : @xmath65-dodecane obtained from acros organics , is placed between the surfaces . dodecane is a simple , newtonian , non polar liquid . the length of this molecule obtained by x - ray diffraction is tabulated as @xmath66 nm . the liquid has a purety better than @xmath62 . the viscosity of the liquid is given as @xmath67 mpl in the handbook at @xmath68 . the experiments are carried out at ambient temperature , _ i.e. _ @xmath69c . the apparatus is placed in a plexiglass box which reduces sound vibrations , and contains some desiccant ( silicagel ) to dry the atmosphere and prevent the dissolution of water in dodecane . the experiment starts with the surfaces being separated by a distance of @xmath70 nm . a voltage increasing linearly in time is applied to one of the piezoelectric actuator , so that the sphere moves toward the plane at constant speed . in the same time , we impose a small oscillation of the sphere @xmath71 , with @xmath72 nm at a frequency @xmath73 hz . in the lubrication approximation , the viscous force between the two surfaces gives the well - known expression ( georges ( 1993 ) ) : @xmath74 in our experiments , the viscous force on @xmath4 is : @xmath75 we can read the displacement @xmath76 induced on the cantilever @xmath4 by the viscous flow between the sphere and the plane . since @xmath77 hz , the value of the excitation frequency , is above the resonant frequency of the cantilever @xmath4 , the real viscous force @xmath78 is obtained by multiplying @xmath79 by the mechanical transfert function of the mass - cantilever system . first of all , we find that the measured force is out of phase the displacement excitation ( @xmath80 ) which means that a purely dissipative force is measured . on figure [ dodecane ] , the inverse of the damping coefficient @xmath81 is plotted as a function of the distance @xmath12 between the surfaces . this curve clearly shows the a good agreement of the lubrication theory for all the distances greater than @xmath82 nm which corresponds to 5 molecular length of dodecane . the origin @xmath83 is obtained by the linear extrapolation of the best linear fit of the experimental data and the origin of the axis @xmath84 . the slope of this curve combined with equation ( [ equ : damp_eq2 ] ) , gives the viscosity of dodecane . we find @xmath85 pl which can be compared to the tabulated value ( see handbook ) @xmath86 pl at @xmath69c . this result agrees well those of tonck _ et al . _ ( 1989 ) on the same liquid . we have presented a new capacitive sensor for surface forces measurements allowing both static and dynamic measurements between non transparent surfaces . this sensor does not not need any lock - in amplifier for the statics measurements and has a very low cost . in the static regime , this sensor has a sensitivity of @xmath9 nm with an integration time of @xmath13 s. in the dynamic regime , combined with a frequency to voltage converter , this sensor has a sensitivity better than @xmath13 pm.hz@xmath59 . we have used this sensor for surface force measurements between pyrex surfaces separated by a small meniscus of dodecane . away from the contact between the surfaces , we have confirmed previous results showing that the bulk viscosity of the liquid is not affected by the confinement . at a distance between the surfaces smaller than a few molecular length , the dissipation increases . we thank j.p . zaygel for his help in electronics design , c. cottin - bizone for his experimental help . we have benefited from discussions with j .- l . loubet and a. tonck . we are happy to thank j .- . combes for technical help . this work has been supported by the region rhnes - alpes contact number 98b0316 and the dlgation gnrale de larmement . audouin c , bernard m y , besson , r , gagnepain j j , groslambert j , granveaud m , neau j c , olivier m and rutman j 1991 _ la mesure de la frquence des oscillateurs _ masson

we present a new capacitive sensor for displacement measurement in a surface forces apparatus ( sfa ) which allows dynamical measurements in the range of @xmath0 hz . this sensor measures the relative displacement between two macroscopic opaque surfaces over periods of time ranging from milliseconds to in principle an indefinite period , at a very low price and down to atomic resolution . it consists of a plane capacitor , a high frequency oscillator , and a high sensitivity frequency to voltage conversion . we use this sensor to study the nanorheological properties of dodecane confined between glass surfaces . * keywords :* surface forces apparatus , capacitive sensor , nanorheology

1302.3746

since the first reports on the successful isolation of a stable monolayer of graphene @xcite special efforts have been invested in the exploration of similar materials with novel properties resulting from their ultra - thin two - dimensional nature . those alternative materials have the potential to bypass some of the obstacles existing in the usage of graphene in contemporary electronics i.e. , incompatibility with present day silicon technology and lack of an energy bandgap which is essential for all semiconductor devices . for graphene itself further modification is inevitable in order to tailor its electronic properties . a broad range of chemical decoration @xcite and substitutional doping @xcite have been investigated to open and tune the band gap of graphene . particular attention was given to boron and nitrogen as the first choice elements because of their chemical propinquity to carbon as well as to silicon . @xcite the second row elements have not been omitted , al , si and p doping induce band gap opening in monolayer graphene . @xcite theoretical studies of functionalization of graphene have later been supported by the experimental realization of substitutional doping with b and n atoms via arc discharge using graphite electrodes in the presence of hydrogen and b or n atom incorporating molecules ( pyridine , amonia , @xmath0),@xcite thermal annealing of graphene in the presence of boron oxide @xcite or nitrogen plasma treatment of graphene.@xcite recently , the monolayer honeycomb structure of silicon , silicene , has emerged as a potential few - atom - thick material to replace graphene . as was reported by early theoretical works , silicene is a semimetal with linearly crossing bands and a zero electronic band gap similar to graphene . @xcite furthermore , similar to graphene , electrons propagating through the monolayer crystal structure of silicene are predicted to show massless fermion behavior in the vicinity of the dirac point . additionally , some unique features of monolayer silicene such as quantum spin hall effect,@xcite a large spin - orbit interaction,@xcite a mechanically tunable bandgap@xcite and a valley - polarized metallic phase@xcite have been reported by theoretical studies . moreover , the recent experimental observations and synthesis of silicene @xcite have opened a new path for nanoscale materials which might be easily functionalized chemically or mechanically and incorporated within electronics as we know it today.@xcite very recently we reported the adsorption characteristics of alkali , alkaline earth and transition metal atoms on monolayer silicene.@xcite differing from graphene , one can expect the substitution of b , n , al or p atoms to be more likely on the silicene surface ( fig . [ fig - silicene](a ) ) , as it is more reactive due to its @xmath1-like lattice structure . ( color online ) ( a ) structural parameters for silicene and ( b ) possible adsorption sites on the silicene lattice . ( c ) electronic band dispersion and partial density of states for perfect silicene . the energies are relative to the fermi level ( i.e. , @xmath2 ) . the inset ( d ) displays the calculated spin - orbit gap of 1.47 mev . , width=321 ] in this paper , motivated by the route undertaken with graphene and the recent synthesis of silicene , we investigate the adsorption and absorption of b , n , al and p atoms on the surface of pristine free - standing silicene together with their substitutional doping . our interest is pointed towards the compounds structure , binding energies of the most stable structures and their electronic , magnetic and phonon properties . we find that the adsorbed b , n and p atoms are strongly bonded to the underlying silicene , attached to its surface but also penetrated into the silicon lattice . weaker bonding and immersion is observed for the al atom . these observations differ from the general chemical functionalization of graphene which is highly dependent on the presence of defects and crystal boundaries.@xcite the stability of the ground state structures has also been addressed by using _ ab initio _ molecular dynamics and phonon calculations . our present investigation of the chemical modification of silicene employs density functional theory ( dft ) as implemented in the vasp package.@xcite we have made use of the spin polarized local - density approximation ( lda ) @xcite for the exchange - correlation functional , the projector augmented wave method @xcite and a plane - wave basis set with an energy cutoff of 500 ev . the sampling of the brillouin zone was done for the supercell with the equivalent of a @xmath3 monkhorst - pack @xmath4-point grid for a silicene unit cell ( containing 2 silicon atoms ) . the partial occupancies in the electronic ground state calculation were treated using the tetrahedron methodology with blchl corrections @xcite . for the purpose of the calculation of the density of states a gaussian smearing of the energy levels was applied with standard deviation set to 0.1 ev . to eliminate the interaction emerging from periodic boundary conditions in all three dimensions a @xmath5 supercell was used with the height of 15 to include enough vacuum , and dipole corrections were used . all reported quantitative results of the charge transfer were obtained by usage of the bader charge population analysis @xcite , and the iterative modified hirshfeld charge population analysis . @xcite the relaxation of the atomic positions was performed with forces smaller than 0.01 ev@xmath6 . to reduce the strain induced by the adsorbates / substituents , the lattice parameters were optimized properly . the phonon frequencies for adatom adsorbed / substituted silicene were calculated using the small displacement method.@xcite _ ab initio _ molecular dynamics simulations ( md ) were performed with use of the non - spin polarized local - density approximation ( lda ) @xcite for the exchange - correlation functional , the projector augmented wave method @xcite and a plane - wave basis set with an energy cutoff of 500 ev . the sampling of the brillouin zone was done for the supercell with the equivalent of a @xmath7 monkhorst - pack @xmath4-point grid for a silicene unit cell . the integration of newton s equations of motion was performed using the verlet algorithm where harris corrections were used in order to correct the forces . the simulations were performed within the micro - canonical ( nve ) ensemble with velocities assigned according to the maxwell - boltzmann distribution at the temperature of 500 k during the entire calculation . to avoid large temperature fluctuations velocities were normalized every 40 steps . the total duration of the simulation was 2 ps with the time step equal to 1 fs . first , we consider the adsorption of a single atom on a silicene surface . in contrast to the completely flat one - atom - thick surface of graphene , silicene is buckled as can be seen in fig . [ fig - silicene](a ) and we can expect higher reactivity due to this @xmath1-like lattice structure . similar to graphene , silicene is a semimetal with linearly crossing bands at the fermi level with a zero electronic band gap ( fig . [ fig - silicene](c ) ) . however , effect of spin - orbit coupling , that yields 1.47 mev spin - orbit gap ( fig . [ fig - silicene](d ) ) , is much larger than that of graphenes.@xcite we define the binding energy for adsorption as : @xmath8 . there are three possible adsorption sites on graphene , while as a consequence of the buckled hexagonal lattice structure of silicene has now four different adsorption sites as shown in fig . [ fig - silicene](b ) : above the center of the hexagonal silicon rings ( hollow site ) , on top of the upper silicon atoms ( hill - site ) , on top of the lower silicon atoms ( valley - site ) and on top of the si - si bond ( bridge site ) . ( color online ) diffusion characteristics of b , n , al and p adsorbates . the energies are relative to the binding energy of the most preferable adsorption site . spatial distance is plotted on x axis , the intermediate positions between high symmetry points were obtained by restricting the adatoms movement perpendicular to the silicene surface . the local minima in diffusion energy plots outside of the four high symmetry adsorption sites do not provide stable binding without aforementioned restrictions . , width=321 ] the possible diffusion paths were determined from the energetics of the adatoms on the different lattice points . as shown in fig . [ fig2 ] , each n adsorbate has to overcome an energy barrier of @xmath90.7 ev for diffusion from one bridge site to a neighboring one via a valley site . b adsorbates , because of their stronger binding energy compared to n atoms , see larger migration barriers . diffusion of a b atom from one valley site to another one can occur via a hollow site by overcoming the energy barrier of @xmath92.0 ev . the p adatom has to overcome an energy barrier of @xmath90.9 ev when diffusing between neighboring hill sites via the bridge and valley sites . for the al adatoms the energy barrier is @xmath90.4 ev between two neighboring valley sites . after unconstrained relaxation , the four adsorption sites provide stable or metastable binding , albeit with different binding energy . only the adsorption of an al atom on a bridge site is found to be unstable . for the graphene surface the bridge site was found to be the most favorable adsorption site for both b and n adsorbates.@xcite however , we find that the most favorable adsorption sites on the silicene surface are the valley and bridge sites for b and n adsorbates , respectively . while the adsorption of the b ( n ) atom occurs with a -1.8 ( -4.6 ) ev binding energy on graphene,@xcite for silicene the bonding between b ( n ) and the silicene lattice is stronger with a binding energy of -5.85 ( -5.54 ) ev . the al and p atom preferential adsorption sites were found to be the valley site with a binding energy of -2.87 ev and the hill site with an adsorption energy of -5.28 ev , respectively . we found the adatoms to considerably distort the underlying silicene layer . a b adsorbate is almost completely immersed into the silicene layer and pushes the underling si atom down from its original position . the b adatom average distance from the underlying si layer is only 0.71 as can be seen in table [ table_main ] . n atom adsorption on the bridge site results in si - si bond breakage . a similar effect as with the b adsorption occurs for p and al adatoms , albeit with lower intensity and with up to two times larger average distances from the underlying si layer as can be seen in table [ table_main ] . next we investigate the absorption , i.e. , the substitution of a single si atom with a b , n , al or p atom . the binding energies for substitutional doping are -6.21 , -5.64 , -2.28 and -4.84 ev , for a b , n , al and p atom , respectively . this binding energy for substutution is calculated as follows : @xmath10 . b - si and n - si bonds are shorter than the intrinsic si - si bond lengths , the p - si bond is also slightly shorter but the al - si bond lenght is larger by 0.1 in comparison to the si - si bond length as can be seen in table [ table_main ] ( comparabable to n and b substituted graphene @xcite ) . the b , n and al substituent atom bonds with neighboring si atoms are more flat , reducing local buckling . the p substituent atom exhibits comparable buckling as the si atoms , the angle @xmath11 ( 111.3@xmath12 ) is even smaller compared to @xmath13 ( 116.3@xmath12 ) of pure silicene . with increased distance from the b , n , al or p atom the buckling of silicene is quickly restored . all the substituents except b atom exhibit a small displacement from the containing si layer . as already mentioned , the b atom adsorption on the valley site ( to some degree p atom adsorption on the hill as well ) results in structures resembling substitution structures , with the si atom pushed out of the silicene plane and adsorbate immersion into the plane . this can be a potential route for chemical doping of silicene via chemical decoration . the calculated values for the binding energies show that substitutional doping is energetically more favorable for b and n atoms , whereas it is less favorable for al and p atoms compared to adsorption . this behavior of the binding energy causes a lower amount of immersion for the al and p atoms as compared to the b and n atoms . we find the adsorbed as well as substituent al atom to have notable lower absolute value for its binding energy in comparison to the other investigated atoms . the reason for this different behavior can be explained from a chemical point of view . the al atom is the only one , due to its lower electronegativity compared to the si atom , that looses electrons in favor of the neighboring si atoms . the induced depopulation of bonding orbitals increases the length of the si - al bond ( @xmath14 ) and weakens it . .[table_main ] calculated parameters for b , n , al and p adsorbed / substituted silicene : lattice constant ( @xmath15 ) ; adsorbate - si bond distance ( @xmath16 ) ; average distance to low - lying si layer ( @xmath17 ) ; magnetic moment ( @xmath18 ) ; binding energy per adatom / substituent(@xmath19 ) ; work function ( @xmath20 , for the adsorbtion the value correspond to the value measured from the side of the adsorbate ) ; charge located on adatom / substituent obtained with bader charge analysis ( @xmath21 ) , or iterative hirshfeld method ( @xmath22 ) and dipole moment ( @xmath23 ) . the adsorbate and substituent concentration was one to 32 and 31 si atoms , respectively . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] in table [ table_main ] , the electronic properties of b , n , al or p adsorbed silicene are also presented . both b and al atoms adsorbed on the valley site as well as the n atom adsorbed on the bridge site turn the semimetallic silicene into a nonmagnetic metal . adsorption of p atom on the hill site introduces matallicity with a net magnetic moment of @xmath24 . the work function ( measured at the side of the adsorbate ) is slightly lowered to 4.73 ev for b and 4.66 ev for al adsorption from 4.77 ev for intrinsic silicene . on the other hand , adsorption of a n or p atom increases the workfunction to 5.02 ev and 4.89 ev , respectively . we also present the partial density of states analysis for b , n , al and p in figs . [ fig3](a - d ) . for b adsorption , the metallic bands crossing the fermi level are formed by the hybridization of the b-@xmath25 peaks with the si-@xmath25 and the si-@xmath26 states . however , since the adsorption of n occurs on top of a si - si bond , mixing of n states with the silicene states is more complex . it appears from fig . [ fig3](b ) that while the main contribution originates mainly from the hybridization of si-@xmath26 and n-@xmath26 bands , tails of @xmath27 and @xmath25 states of both silicene and n play a role in the metallic behavior . it is also seen that the linearly crossing @xmath23 bands of silicene at the k symmetry point are disturbed because of the interaction with the n-@xmath26 states albeit not completely removed as for b adsorption . the electronic band dispersion character of al adsorption is qualitatively identical to the one of the b adsorption , caused by the similar adsorption site and valence electron configuration . the last case of p adsorption shows the metallic bands predominantly formed by the hybridization of the p-@xmath25 states with the si-@xmath25 and the si-@xmath26 states and partially produced from silicene @xmath27 states . the linear crossing of @xmath23 bands of silicene at the k symmetry point is again completely removed . on a graphene lattice , upon b adsorption , 0.4 e is transferred to graphene and upon n adsorption 0.7 e is transferred from graphene to n.@xcite however , due to its @xmath1-like lattice structure , silicene has a highly reactive surface and therefore some different adsorption characteristics can be expected . the charge transfer occurs from silicene to the adsorbate for the b , n and p adatoms . the opposite charge transfer is observed for the al adatom . the net charge located on b , n , al and p adatom has a value of -1.6 , -2.0 , 1.0 and -0.9 e , respectively . moreover , in order to examine the reliability of these results , we have also performed a charge population analysis with the iterative modified hirshfeld method . @xcite we found that all the methods provide the same qualitative insight and support for the conclusion that the character of the charge transfer is driven by the differences of electronegativity among the atoms . silicene donates / accepts electrons to / from adsorbates with higher / smaller electronegativity . substitutional doping of silicene induces an opposite change of the work function as compared to adsorption . b or al substitution increase and n or p substitution slightly decrease the work function . the electronic band structure together with the density of states are shown in figs . [ fig3](e - h ) . the dirac cone composed of @xmath26-bands is preserved for b , al and p substitution . it has been shifted above the fermi level for b and al substituents and below the fermi level for a p atom . it is not altered by the @xmath25 states of the foreign atom which are present as deep bands in the final electronic structure . the character of substitution with a n atom is of a different nature , the linear crossing of @xmath23-bands is destroyed and the metallic bands in the electronic structure are produced from both @xmath23 and @xmath27 states located on n and the surrounding si atoms . these states originate from unoccupied states of the free n atom and align with the fermi level in doped silicene . the calculated charge transfers for the substitutional doping are of the same magnitude as for adsorption , with 1.4 , 2.1 , -1.6 and 1.2 e transferred from silicene to a b , n , al and p atom , respectively . only n - doped silicene becomes ferromagnetic with a net magnetic moment of 0.9 @xmath28 . the size of the gap as well as the character of the electronic dispersion bands may be altered by the adsorption or substitution of foreign atoms with the applied spin - orbit interaction as in the case of graphene decorated by 5d transition - metal adatoms @xcite . we performed calculations with spin - orbit coupling included in order to investigate its effect in all the studied systems and found no significant differences in the electronic band dispersion . the variances were found to be in the order of 1 mev and virtually vanishing around the fermi level . therefore , we do not report these results in fig . the cause of such negligible coupling is the small diameter of the adsorbate / substituent atoms and the small or not existing net magnetic moment of the aforementioned structures.@xcite ( color online ) phonon dispersion for adsorption and substitution cases of b , n , al and p on silicene . total dos of the structures is shown by the filled area ( orange color ) . projected dos belonging to foreign atoms are represented by lines ( red ) . @xmath29 point vibrational motions are also depicted . , width=321 ] characterization and analysis of the surfaces , crystal structures and molecules can be done by various spectroscopy techniques . among these particularly raman spectroscopy allows highly accurate detection and analysis of the vibrational properties of structures even at the nanoscale . therefore , one can deduce the stability and characteristic vibrational properties of a foreign atom adsorbed / substituted silicene layers via their phonon spectrum . [ fig - phonons ] shows the evolution of the phonon density of states of pristine silicene with adsorption and substitution of b , n , al and p atoms . pristine silicene s phonon dos comprises three main peaks originating from the @xmath29 atomic motions : an acoustic mode at @xmath9100 cm@xmath6 , an out - of - plane optical mode at @xmath9175 cm@xmath6 and a degenerate in - plane optical mode at @xmath9571 cm@xmath6 . note that the peaks at 396 , 472 and 535 cm@xmath6 , are due to the flat slope of the optical branch at the m - k , m and m symmetry points , respectively . we also present adsorbate / substituent - projected phonon dos and related vibrational motions at the @xmath29 point in fig . [ fig - phonons ] . adsorption / substitution of first - row elements b and n do not result in a significant change of the dos . due to the coupling of b and n adsorbates / substituents to the acoustical phonon branch of pristine silicene several sharp peaks appear between 200 and 300 cm@xmath6 . obviously , among the two adsorbates , b and n , the bridge - site - bonded n adatom is more likely to mix with silicene s acoustic branch . in addition to these , high frequency adsorbate / substituent induced modes appear between 700 and 1200 cm@xmath6 . our eigenvector analysis reveals that these high energy modes correspond to in - plane bond - stretching motion of the adatom and the neighboring silicon atoms . consistent with the binding energies calculated in the previous section , the high frequency in - plane phonon mode of b - substituted silicene takes a higher value than that of the b - adsorbed one . however , such a comparison is not possible for the n atom because of the different geometries of the adsorption and substitution cases . since the adsorption of a n atom occurs on the bridge site of two silicon atoms , one can expect vibrational characteristics different from those of n - doped graphene . while there is no clear n - induced peak observed in graphene , upon adsorption ( substitution ) of n to silicene well separated phonon modes ( mode ) at @xmath9800 cm@xmath6 and @xmath91150 ( only at 700 ) cm@xmath6 appear . furthermore , compared with b - substitution , n substituted silicene s high - frequency mode is softer because of the larger atomic mass of n. these modes correspond to in - plane and out - of - plane motion of the n atom and the nearest two si atoms . contributions of second and third nearest neighbor si atoms are negligible for these high - frequency modes . because of their bond - stretching nature , adsorbate- and substituent - originated optical branches can be expected to be raman - active modes . the experimentally reported atomic weights ( covalent atomic radii ) of si , b , n , al and p are 28.09 , 10.81 , 14.01 , 26.98 and 30.97 amu ( 111 , 84 , 71 , 121 and 107 pm ) and therefore due to the similar properties of second row elements to si atoms , for the adsorption / substitution of al and p atoms different effects on the vibrational spectra can be expected . we report a common characteristic for second row elements , that is the absence of high - frequency bond stretching modes . due to the quite similar atomic weight and radii of si , al and p atoms , their effect on the phonon dos is almost negligible and may not be observed by experimental tools . a widely broadened phonon dos of al and p adsorbed silicene , which is different from the narrow peaks in the b and n adsorption case , indicates the larger coupling of al atoms to the silicene lattice . similarly , the substitution of al and p does not result in the presence of high energy modes . it is also seen that while substituent b and n atoms do not couple with optical modes of silicene , al and p atoms entirely contribute to both acoustic and optical modes . the discussed structures , that are found to be stable in terms of the total energy optimization and phonon calculations , may not be stable at high temperatures . to address questions regarding thermal stability of a b and n atom adsorbed / substituted silicene monolayers we consider the effect of temperature by employing _ ab initio _ md calculations . md simulations were performed at a temperature of 500 k for the structures initially optimized at @xmath31 k. in fig . [ fig - md ] geometric structures are presented for the initial and final state of the md calculations . the simulation of b adsorption , as can be seen in fig . [ fig - md](a ) , shows that the b atom stays incorporated within the honeycomb structure but the si atom , that has been initially pushed down from its position , has started to move towards the neighboring sites . during the 2 ps of md simulations it is attached predominantly on the hollow and the top sites . however , the adsorbed b atom remains stable . similarly , the substituent b atom ( fig . [ fig - md](e ) ) continues to be bonded to the three si atoms for the whole simulation period . although the adsorption geometry for the n atom is different from b - adsorbed silicene , it remains stable after 2 ps at 500 k. even the characteristic out - of - plane motion of the n atom ( from one side to the other one ) , that can be clearly seen in fig . [ fig - md](b ) , is not able to break the strong si - n - si bonds . similar to the b - substitution case , the n - substituted silicene , depicted in fig . [ fig - md](f ) , remains in - plane bonded to the three neighboring silicon atoms after more than 2 ps at 500 k. simulation of al and p adsorption ( figs . [ fig - md](c ) and [ fig - md](d ) ) as well as al and p substitution ( figs . [ fig - md](g ) and [ fig - md](h ) ) shows high stability of the adsorbate / substituent atom with no reconfiguration of the si lattice in the vicinity of the foreign atoms . in summary , we performed an _ ab initio _ study of atom adsorption and absorption of b , n , al and p atoms on silicene and we obtained the geometric , electronic and vibrational properties . all the final systems show metallic behavior . the adatoms are strongly bonded with silicene revealing different preferential adsorption sites for b or n adatoms as compared to graphene . we find the charge transfer to be consistent with the effects ascribed to the element electronegativity . b , n and p atoms behave like acceptors and the al atom as donor for silicene . analysis of the vibrational modes shows that adatoms and substituents slightly alter the phonon spectrum of silicene and several adatom / substituent - induced characteristic branches appear , which may be probed by raman measurements . finally , we showed the stability of b , n , al and p adsorbed / substituted silicene layers even at high temperatures . our work reveals that silicene has a very reactive and functionalizable surface and it can serve as an important and novel playground for silicene based novel nanoscale materials . this work was supported by the flemish science foundation ( fwo - vl ) and the methusalem foundation of the flemish government . computational resources were provided by tubitak ulakbim , high performance and grid computing center ( tr - grid e - infrastructure ) , and hpc infrastructure of the university of antwerp ( calcua ) a division of the flemish supercomputer center ( vsc ) , which is funded by the hercules foundation . h. s. is supported by a fwo pegasus marie curie fellowship .

_ ab initio _ calculations within the density - functional theory formalism are performed to investigate the chemical functionalization of a graphene - like monolayer of silicon silicene with b , n , al or p atoms . the structural , electronic , magnetic and vibrational properties are reported . the most preferable adsorption sites are found to be valley , bridge , valley and hill site for b , n , al and p adatoms , respectively . all the relaxed systems with adsorbed / substituted atoms exhibit metallic behaviour with strongly bonded b , n , al , and p atoms accompanied by an appreciable electron transfer from silicene to the b , n and p adatom / substituent . the al atoms exhibit opposite charge transfer , with n - type doping of silicene and weaker bonding . the adatoms / substituents induce characteristic branches in the phonon spectrum of silicene , which can be probed by raman measurements . using molecular dynamics we found that the systems under study are stable up to at least t = 500 k. our results demonstrate that silicene has a very reactive and functionalizable surface .

1204.4356

area - minimizing interfaces , such as soap films and elastic membranes without bending and torsional stiffness , are found in a wide variety of man - made and biological structures , and in processes such as liquid confinement in microgravity and enhanced oil recovery . the ability to predict their shape , strength and/or integrity is therefore important . that soap films are not indefinitely stable is clear from the well - known case of the catenoidal film formed between two closely - spaced parallel rings of radius @xmath0 @xcite . as the two rings are pulled apart , the neck gradually thins . this does not continue indefinitely , and at a critical ring separation @xmath1 the surface becomes unstable and jumps to two discoidal films , one in each ring . a related instability is the stretching of a cylindrical bubble between parallel walls @xcite . above a certain wall separation , @xmath2 , the bubble undergoes a `` wine - bottle '' @xcite , or rayleigh - plateau , instability , bulging at one end and thinning at the other . as the stretching continues , the bubble detaches from one wall , and takes a hemispherical shape @xcite . other soap - bubble instabilities are reviewed by @xcite ( @xcite ) . they make the implicit assumption , as we shall do throughout the following , that the amount of surfactant present is sufficiently great that a film does not collapse because its tension becomes too high and that instabilities are not driven by gradients in surface tension . this assumption is certainly valid in our experiments , described below . we first consider the stability of a single planar film . a single rectangular soap film confined between parallel walls , with its ends held by two wires perpendicular to the walls , can be stretched indefinitely by pulling the anchoring wires apart . however , if the film is confined in a cylinder , oriented parallel to the axis and such that the anchoring wires are parallel diameters of the cylinder , we find that this cylindrical constraint induces a surface - tension - driven instability in sufficiently long films . once this instability is triggered , at some critical aspect ratio , the film rapidly deforms and collapses . if the film is twisted , taking the shape of a helicoid , then the instability occurs when the aspect ratio is lower . -shaped wires at each end , meet each other at @xmath3 , and are again free to move on the cylinder wall . the upper y - shaped arrangement of anchoring wires is rotated at fixed aspect ratio , or pulled upwards at fixed @xmath4 ( not shown ) . ( c ) arrangement of four elastic membranes in a cylinder ( simulation only ) . ] most physical systems , however , consist of more than one soap film . in more complex arrangements of multiple soap films , a consequence of area minimization is that these films meet in threes at equal angles of @xmath3 @xcite in what are known as plateau borders . thus , it is important in predicting the stability of foams , which are used in many processes including froth flotation and ore separation @xcite , to determine the degree to which this three - fold arrangement of soap films is susceptible to the same surface - tension - driven instability . we therefore add more soap films parallel to the axis of the cylinder , in both simulation and experiment , and show that these configurations confer no greater stability on the system . the three systems investigated here are shown in figure [ fig : one ] . we used a 10% solution of the commercial detergent fairy liquid to create a single soap film between two parallel pieces of pipe - cleaner ( referred to here as wires ) placed perpendicular to the axis of a perspex cylinder of fixed radius @xmath5 mm and length 300 mm ( as in figure [ fig : one](a ) ) . the upper wire is held in place with a thin perspex ring attached to a handle that allows its position to be controlled . note that there is no volume constraint on the gas neighbouring the film . the film was then slowly stretched by increasing the distance @xmath6 between the wires in small steps from zero ( the point at which the film is formed ) . we define the aspect ratio of the film to be @xmath7 ( rather than the more conventional definition , which is half this ) for consistency with the experiments described below with multiple films . the critical aspect ratio at which the film becomes unstable was found to be @xmath8 . the instability becomes apparent when the film starts to bow outwards while remaining attached to the wires at top and bottom , as shown in figure [ fig : expt ] . the midpoints of the vertical sides of the film move around the cylinder wall until they meet . the film then pinches off into two parts , each of which retract towards the ends of the cylinder . the final state consists of two semicircular films between a wire and the cylinder wall , one at each end of the cylinder . this whole process , from initial bowing of the film to the final collapsed state , can take several tens of seconds due to friction at the wall . we next formed a film and stretched it to a small value of @xmath6 , then twisted it into a helicoid by slowly moving the upper constraint clockwise up to an angle @xmath4 . we then again stretched the film by increasing @xmath6 and recorded the value of @xmath9 at which the film became unstable and collapsed . the critical aspect ratio _ decreased _ with increasing @xmath4 in the manner shown in figure [ fig : plot ] . equivalently , at given aspect ratio @xmath10 , the film can only be twisted up to a certain angle until it becomes unstable and then collapses as before . for aspect ratio , @xmath11 for angle ; simulation @xmath12 for aspect ratio , @xmath13 for angle . the theoretical prediction at @xmath14 , @xmath15 is shown as an asterisk on the horizontal axis.,scaledwidth=90.0% ] both stretching and twisting experiments were repeated with a y - shaped frame , again made from pipe - cleaners ( see figure [ fig : one](b ) ) , to generate data for the collapse of the three - fold film arrangement . each film is a helicoid , and the instability is first apparent when the triple line along the axis of the cylinder ( i.e. the plateau border ) deforms . the critical values of the aspect ratio and twist angle are also shown in figure [ fig : plot ] : they are close to those for the single film case , suggesting that the same mechanism for instability is involved , but are at slightly lower aspect ratio for given twist angle . we used the surface evolver @xcite to determine the shape of a single film at a minimum of surface area . we set @xmath16 and then tessellated the film with about 2000 triangles ( three levels of refinement ) . the edges that lie along the diameters at the end of the cylinder were fixed , and the sides of the film were constrained to move on the curved walls of the cylinder . on stretching the film , in steps of @xmath17 , we found that an eigenvalue of the hessian of energy @xcite first become negative at @xmath18 , close to the value found in the experiments . starting from a small value of @xmath6 , we then twisted the film in increments of one - tenth of a radian before stretching , as in the experiments . in other words , we searched for the instability by increasing @xmath10 at fixed @xmath4 ; this turns out to be equivalent to fixing @xmath10 and increasing @xmath4 . we again recorded the value of @xmath10 at which an eigenvalue of the hessian became negative , as a measure of the triggering of the instability . the critical value of @xmath10 decreased with increasing twist angle , as shown in figure [ fig : plot ] and in broad agreement with the experiments . continuing the simulation after the instability occurs allowed us to produce illustrative snapshots of the collapse of the film ( figure [ fig : two ] ) , although these should be viewed with caution because we have not attempted to model the dynamics of the film . three - fold films were examined in the same way as in the experiments : we placed a y - shaped constraint at each end of the cylinder , with three films between them , and slowly pulled and/or rotated the constraint at one end of the film . each film is again tessellated with about 2000 triangles . the bowing of the central plateau border observed in the experiments during the collapse of the films is repeated in the simulations . figure [ fig : three ] shows how this happens : under stretching two of the three films distort in the same way that the single film does ( figure [ fig : two](a ) ) while under twisting all films respond in the same way and the central plateau border becomes distorted and no longer follows the axis of the cylinder . the critical aspect ratios and twist angles , shown in figure [ fig : plot ] , are almost indistinguishable from the simulations of the single film , indicating that the number of films present does not affect the triggering of the instability . the discrepancy between the experimental and simulation results may be due to the finite size of the wires and the ring supporting the upper wires , which cause deviations in the shape of the films particularly close to the cylinder , and the effects of gravity - driven liquid drainage , which causes the films to be thicker towards their base . both effects are more significant at the highest twist angles . ) . ( b ) mode of instability under twisting for @xmath19.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.0% ] ) . ( b ) mode of instability under twisting for @xmath19.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.0% ] twisting any of the simulated soap film configurations up to an angle of @xmath20 leads to instability at a very small height , but note that @xmath20 is not an upper limit to the possible twist angle . we are able to twist the three - fold film up to @xmath21 . plateau s rules preclude the possibility of more than three films meeting along a line . four films , for example , would undergo an immediate topological transition , introducing a new rectangular film between two parallel triple lines . in the case of elastic membranes , there is no such restriction , and to illustrate that this instability is not limited to soap films , we simulated an arrangement of four `` fins '' ( figure [ fig : one](c ) ) . this gives the same critical values for aspect ratio and twist angle ( figure [ fig : plot ] ) . we explain this effect by examining the way in which the single rectangular film collapses . it could be expected that perturbing the film would induce an increase in area , but the presence of the cylinder walls allows the film to reduce its area due to this perturbation . beyond a critical aspect ratio , the increase in film area due to the perturbation is more than compensated for by the reduction in area as the film slides round the walls of the cylinder at its midpoint ( figure [ fig : two](b ) ) . to estimate the critical aspect ratio , we will assume a certain form for the deformed shape using the coordinate system defined in figure [ fig : one](a ) , with @xmath22 a coordinate perpendicular to the planar , undeformed , film , @xmath23 parallel to the anchoring wires at the ends , and @xmath24 vertically upwards . any soap film without a pressure difference across it is a surface of zero mean curvature , so that @xmath25 should satisfy laplace s equation approximately . we therefore assume the perturbation @xmath26 , where @xmath27 is a small parameter and the positive integer @xmath28 labels the possible modes of instability , with wavelengths @xmath29 . this form for @xmath25 ignores the condition that the film should meet the cylinder walls at @xmath30 , although in their study of a structural transition of an ordered foam in a cylinder @xcite ( @xcite ) noted that this condition , while the hardest to solve for , did not affect their results at small aspect ratios . the area of the film can then be written @xmath31 with the upper limit of the @xmath23 integration representing the lateral pinching of the film due to the cylinder walls . to second order in @xmath32 this becomes @xmath33 \nonumber \\ & \approx & 2r \int_0^h { \rm d}z \left [ 1 - \frac{\varepsilon^2}{2 r^2 } \sin^2 \left ( \frac{n \pi z}{h } \right ) \cosh^2 \left ( \frac{n \pi r}{h } \right ) \right ] + \nonumber \\ & & \quad \varepsilon^2 \left(\frac{n \pi}{h } \right)^2 \left [ \int_0^h \sin^2 \left ( \frac{n \pi z}{h } \right ) { \rm d}z \int_0^{r } \sinh^2 \left ( \frac{n \pi x}{h } \right ) { \rm d}x + \right . \nonumber \\ & & \quad \qquad \qquad \left . \int_0^h \cos^2 \left ( \frac{n \pi z}{h } \right ) { \rm d}z \int_0^{r } \cosh^2 \left ( \frac{n \pi x}{h } \right ) { \rm d}x \right ] \nonumber \\ & \approx & 2 r h - \varepsilon^2 \frac{h}{2r } \cosh^2\left ( \frac{n \pi r}{h } \right ) + \varepsilon^2 \left(\frac{n \pi}{h } \right)^2 \left [ \frac{h^2}{4 \pi n } \sinh\left ( \frac{2 n \pi r}{h } \right ) \right ] \nonumber \\ & = & 2 r h + \frac{1}{2 } \varepsilon^2 \cosh\left ( \frac{n \pi r}{h } \right ) \left [ n \pi \sinh\left ( \frac{n \pi r}{h } \right ) - \frac{h}{r } \cosh\left ( \frac{n \pi r}{h } \right ) \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the term multiplying @xmath34 shows the balance between the increase of surface area due to the perturbation and the decrease of surface area due to the curvature of the cylinder wall ; it goes from positive to negative , indicating a reduction in area and therefore the initiation of the instability , when @xmath35 this equation has solution @xmath36 . the fundamental mode of instability , with @xmath37 , is the first to be triggered as the aspect ratio increases , giving @xmath14 , shown as an asterisk on figure [ fig : plot ] and within the error bars of the simulations . we have demonstrated that any soap film or flexible membrane , such as can be found in foams and biological tissues , is susceptible to an instability that leads to its breakdown when stretched and/or twisted in a cylindrical tube . simulations , experiments on soap films , and a simple theoretical analysis all confirm the critical value of the aspect ratio : with zero twist the critical aspect ratio of the film is @xmath38 , and this threshold decreases with increasing twist . this implies that there is a fundamental limit to the size of an area - minimizing film or membrane that can exist in a cylinder . thus , for example , a tube or capillary of diameter @xmath39 m can not support a soap film or a planar membrane along its axis of greater than about @xmath40 m in length . that the simulations are in broad agreement with the experiments suggests that the liquid present in the central plateau border and in the meniscus around the films in the experiments has little effect on the triggering of the instability . simulations of a three - fold film arrangement with a central plateau border of finite size suggest that the presence of liquid has little effect on its stability . another avenue for further research is the effect on this instability of the central plateau border having a negative line tension @xcite or bending stiffness : do these only affect the dynamics of collapse or do they change the point of instability itself ? our theoretical argument for the critical aspect ratio is straightforward to extend to an elliptical tube in the case of pure stretching , by changing the upper limit in the integral in eq . ( [ eq : theory1 ] ) , but predicting the critical twist angles again presents a challenging problem for future work . finally , we note that if the region between the single film and the cylinder wall has a volume constraint , i.e. bubbles ( or cells ) are present , then this could be accommodated by considering the perturbation @xmath41 , resulting in _ twice _ the critical aspect ratio , @xmath42 , and therefore greater stability . note that this argument is related to the well - known rayleigh - plateau instability of fluid jets , which can also be couched in terms of area minimization @xcite . we are grateful to the late manuel fortes for suggesting this problem . we thank d. binding , f. graner , a. korobkin , g. mishuris , a. mughal , d. weaire and s. wilson for discussions and suggestions , epsrc ( ep / d071127/1 ) and the epsrc - p&g strategic partnership ( ep / f000049/1 ) for funding , and the anonymous referees for useful comments .

a soap film , or a flexible membrane without bending and torsional stiffness , that is confined in a cylinder is shown to be susceptible to a surface - tension - driven instability when it is stretched or twisted . this leads to its breakdown and places an upper limit on the aspect ratio of such structures . a simple analysis confirms the values for the critical aspect ratio of the stretched film found in both simulations and experiments on soap films , and this threshold decreases with increasing twist of the film .

hep-th0004051

the response of vacuum to classical external fields or constraints has been studied since more than fifty years . the manifestation of this response are macroscopic forces exerted on boundaries or surfaces where the potential is concentrated . the most famous example is the casimir effect @xcite , which has been recently measured in laboratory with a precision of nearly @xmath0 @xcite . notwithstanding the large size of theoretical work and the experimental efforts many question remain still open . we have in fact by this far no exact knowledge of the law governing the sign of the casimir energy , how exactly the features of the boundary and its geometry influence the response of vacuum . an investigation on the cylindrical geometry has begun in @xcite after the suggestion that a cylinder , as a kind of intermediate shape between the parallel plates and the sphere , could possess a zero casimir stress @xcite . however paper @xcite showed that a perfectly conducting cylinder in the electromagnetic vacuum has a negative casimir energy . a study of the dielectric cylinder has been recently carried out in @xcite and in @xcite , with the interesting result of a vanishing vacuum energy in the dilute case . some light could be further shed into the problem with the study of other quantum fields and other types of background potentials . in this paper we investigate a cylindrical shell with radius @xmath1 , having a delta function @xmath2 as a potential profile . a delta function is an idealization of a strongly concentrated potential . unlike the case of dirichlet boundary conditions the field is continuous on the surface of the shell , therefore the delta function represents a model for a boundary which is not completely hard , but which becomes transparent at high frequencies . this model can be considered as the `` scalar '' version of the dielectric background . a non singular potential would be , of course , more realistic under the physical point of view , but the calculations would be considerably more complicated . a calculation with the delta function has been already carried out for a spherical shell @xcite and for a magnetic flux tube in the vacuum of spinor and scalar fields @xcite . we hope that our work can contribute in the understanding of vacuum as a fundamental aspect of quantum field theory . the cylindrical shell could , besides , find physical applications in the calculation of the quantum corrections to vortices in qcd or in the electroweak theory . another interesting perspective is in the recent discovery of the so called nanotubes @xcite , @xcite , which are large carbon molecules generated in laboratory offering the intriguing possibility of measuring quantum effects on small cylindrical objects . it is also of interest the comparison of the problem of the cylindrical shell with the analogous problem of the magnetic flux tube @xcite . the organization of this paper is as follow : in the next section we collect the basic formulas necessary for the calculation and we present the renormalization procedure , in section 3 and 4 the major part of the analytical calculation is performed . in section 5 the numerical results are given and in section 6 these results are briefly discussed . let us work with a real massive scalar field @xmath3 with mass @xmath4 and let us quantize it in the background of a cylindrical potential . the field equation in cylindrical coordinates @xmath5 , after separation of the variables , reads @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the momentum four vector being @xmath8 its component along the longitudinal axis of the cylinder and @xmath9 is the angular momentum quantum number . @xmath10 is the background potential given by @xmath11 it represents an infinitely thin cylindrical shell whose profile is a delta function . the shell has a circular section of radius @xmath1 and it extends from @xmath12 to @xmath13 in the @xmath14 direction . @xmath15 is a dimensionless parameter giving the strength of the potential . considering eq.(1 ) as a scattering problem , we choose the `` regular solution '' which is given by @xmath16 where @xmath17 , @xmath18 is a bessel function of the first kind , @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the hankel functions of the first and of the second kind and the coefficients @xmath21 and @xmath22 are a jost function and its complex conjugate respectively . @xmath23 is a theta function . the field is therefore free in the regions @xmath24 and @xmath25 . at @xmath26 the field is continuous and we have the following matching conditions @xmath27 where the prime indicates derivative with respect to @xmath28 . + the quantum field is in its vacuum state , its energy is given by half of the sum over all possible eigenvalues @xmath29 of the hamilton operator related with the wave equation ( 1 ) . we define a regularized vacuum energy @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the regularization parameter which we will put to zero after the renormalization , @xmath32 is a mass parameter introduced for dimensional reasons and @xmath33 includes all possible quantum numbers . we will calculate the energy density per unit length of the cylinder given by @xmath34 where @xmath35 are the eigenvalues of the operator contained in ( 1 ) without @xmath8 and with @xmath36 . we carry out the integration over @xmath8 and we arrive at @xmath37 following a well known procedure we transform the sum in ( 7 ) into a contour integral and , dropping the minkowski space contribution , we find @xmath38 where @xmath39 and @xmath40 is the jost function defined in ( 3 ) on the imaginary axis . it contains all the information about the background potential under examination . we will find @xmath41 explicitly in the following section . the energy defined in ( 8) is renormalized by direct subtraction of its divergent part @xmath42 with the normalization condition demanding that the vacuum fluctuations vanish for a field of infinite mass @xmath43 this normalization condition fixes the arbitrariness of the mass parameter @xmath32 ( for more details see @xcite . the condition does not apply to massless fields ) . the isolation of @xmath44 is done with the use the heat - kernel expansion of the ground state energy @xmath45 where the @xmath46 are the heat kernel coefficients related to the background . then we define @xmath47 which includes all the pole terms and all the terms proportional to non - negative powers of the mass . in order to perform the analytical continuation @xmath48 we split the renormalized vacuum energy ( 9 ) into two parts @xmath49 with @xmath50^{1-s } \frac{\partial}{\partial k } [ \ln f_l(ik)- \ln f^{as}_l(ik)]\ ] ] and @xmath51^{1 -s } \frac{\partial}{\partial k } \ln f^{as}_l(ik)-{\cal e}_{div } .\ ] ] here @xmath52 is a portion of the uniform asymptotic expansion of the jost function which must include as many orders in @xmath9 as it is necessary to have @xmath53 in the limit @xmath54 , @xmath55 with fixed @xmath56 , which is sufficient to let the sum and the integral in ( 14 ) converge at @xmath57 . the splitting proposed in ( 13 ) leaves the quantity @xmath58 unchanged , while it permits the substitution @xmath57 in the finite part @xmath59 . we insert solution ( 3 ) into ( 4 ) and we find @xmath60 \nonumber \\ \left(\frac 12 \partial_r \left[f_l(k ) h^{(2)}_l(kr)+f^{\star}_l(k ) h^{(1)}_l(kr)\right ] \right)|_{r = r } = \frac{\alpha}{r } j_{l}(kr ) + \left ( \partial_r j_{l}(kr)\right)|_{r = r}\ . \end{array } \right.\ ] ] the system can be solved for @xmath21 , with the help of the wronskian determinant of the hankel functions @xcite , the result is @xmath61 the corresponding jost function on the imaginary axis can be written in terms of the modified bessel i and k functions , again with the help of @xcite @xmath62 from the jost function ( 19 ) one arrives at the uniform asymptotic expansions @xmath63 for positive @xmath9 and @xmath64 for negative @xmath9 and at the asymptotic expansion @xmath65 for @xmath66 , with the help of the asymptotics of the bessel i and k functions for large indices and large arguments available on @xcite . since the asymptotic jost function consists of three different contributions , the sum over @xmath9 appearing in ( 14 ) and ( 15 ) must also be distinguished in three contributions : a sum over negative @xmath9 , a sum over positive @xmath9 and a contribution coming from @xmath66 . the first two contributions can be summed up analytically in the following way @xmath67 where the dots represent , for simplicity , the rest of the functions in ( 14 ) and ( 15 ) . then , eq.(14 ) and ( 15 ) are rewritten in the form @xmath68^{1 -s } \frac{\partial}{\partial k } \ln f^{as\pm}_l(ik ) \nonumber \\ & & -\frac 14 c_s \int^\infty_m dk [ k^2 -m^2]^{1 -s } \frac{\partial}{\partial k } \ln f^{as}_0(ik ) -{\cal e}_{div } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath69 \frac{\partial}{\partial k } \left(2\ln f_l(ik)-\ \ln f^{as\pm}_l(ik)\right ) \nonumber\\ & & -\frac{1}{8\pi } \int^\infty_m dk [ k^2 -m^2 ] \frac{\partial}{\partial k } \left(\ln f_0 ( ik)-\ln f^{as}_0(ik)\right)\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath70 and we have used the property @xmath71 of eq.(19 ) . taking the logarithm of the uniform asymptotics of the modified bessel functions and re - expanding in negative powers of the variable @xmath9 ( see @xcite for details on this procedure , see also appendix a ) we find @xmath72 @xmath73 where @xmath74 and the non - vanishing coefficients are @xmath75 in this definition we have included 3 orders in @xmath9 which are sufficient to satisfy condition ( 16 ) . substituting ( 23 ) and ( 24 ) in ( 21 ) and ( 22 ) we find @xmath68^{1 -s } \frac{\partial}{\partial k } \left(\sum_{n=1}^3\sum_jx_{n , j}\frac{t^j}{l^n}\right ) \nonumber \\ & & -\frac 14 c_s \int^\infty_m dk [ k^2 -m^2]^{1 -s } \frac{\partial}{\partial k } \left(\frac{\alpha}{2kr}\ -\ \frac{\alpha^2}{8k^2r^2}\right ) -{\cal e}_{div } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath69 \frac{\partial}{\partial k } \left(2\ln f_l(ik)-\sum_{n=1}^3\sum_jx_{n , j}\frac{t^j}{l^n } \right ) \nonumber\\ & & -\frac{1}{8\pi } \int^\infty_m dk [ k^2 -m^2 ] \frac{\partial}{\partial k } \left(\ln f_0 ( ik)-\frac{\alpha}{2kr}\ -\ \frac{\alpha^2}{8k^2r^2 } \right)\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we call the first addend in ( 27 ) @xmath76 and the second @xmath77 , that is @xmath78 . we go forward with an analytical simplification of ( 26 ) . we call the second addend in ( 26 ) @xmath79 , it can be immediately calculated , giving @xmath80 a simplification of the first addend in ( 26 ) can be achieved with the abel - plana formula ( appendix b ) which transforms the sum over @xmath9 into an integral . then , the first addend in ( 26 ) turns out to be the sum of three contributions @xmath81 @xmath82 @xmath83 where the functions @xmath84 are convergent integrals over @xmath9 given explicitly in appendix b. in appendix b the reader can also find more details about the derivation of the three contributions ( 29 ) , ( 30 ) and ( 31 ) . @xmath85 and @xmath86 contain all the pole terms ( all the divergences of the vacuum energy ) plus the terms proportional to non - negative powers of the mass ( which do not satisfy the normalization condition ) . all these terms are subtracted and are used to calculate the heat - kernel coefficients by means of definition ( 12 ) for @xmath44 . below we give the heat kernel coefficients which we calculated up to the coefficient @xmath87 ( adding four more orders in @xmath88 ) , in the hope that they will be of use for future investigations on the same background @xmath89 one can note how all the integer heat - kernel coefficients depend on odd powers of the coupling constant , while the half - integer coefficients depend on even powers of @xmath15 . the same feature is present in the heat kernel coefficients of a @xmath90-potential spherical shell @xcite . we perform the subtraction of the divergent portion and we obtain the final result @xmath91 the quantity ( 27 ) can not be analytically simplified . we integrate @xmath92 and @xmath77 by parts and make the substitution @xmath93 to get an explicit dependence on @xmath1 @xmath94 for small values of @xmath1 , @xmath95 behaves like @xmath96 , while @xmath77 has a logarithmic behaviour @xmath97 we note that in the limit @xmath98 , the logarithm of the jost function @xmath40 can be expanded in powers of @xmath15 , giving ( from eq.(19 ) ) @xmath99 then , the summation over @xmath9 of the leading term of this expansion could be analytically performed following a method recently proposed in @xcite . this would give us a first order approximation of @xmath100 . however we will restrict us here to a numerical calculation of the sum in ( 34 ) , which can be performed for small as well as for large values of @xmath15 . to find the asymptotic behaviour of @xmath101 we rewrite eq.(33 ) in the following form @xmath102\ , \ ] ] where the functions @xmath103 , @xmath104 and @xmath105 are given by @xmath106 as mentioned above , the functions @xmath84 are quickly converging integrals . the behaviour of @xmath107 is governed by the functions @xmath108 and by the value of @xmath15 . for @xmath109 we find @xmath110 thus , for small values of the radius , @xmath107 is proportional to @xmath111 . summing the contribution coming from ( 35 ) and ( 38 ) , we find that the leading term of the renormalized energy , for @xmath109 , is @xmath112 this result is in agreement with the prediction ( section ii of paper @xcite ) @xmath113 in the limit @xmath114 the behaviour of the renormalized energy is determined by the first non - vanishing heat kernel coefficient after @xmath115 . from ( 32 ) and eq.(11 ) we arrive at @xmath116 we have numerically evaluated the quantities @xmath107 , @xmath95 , @xmath117 and @xmath58 as functions of @xmath1 , fixing the values of the mass to @xmath118 . it turned out to be necessary to sum 20 terms in the variable @xmath9 and to integrate up to 1000 in the variable @xmath119 to obtain `` stable '' numerical values for the energy . below we give the plots of the various contributions to the vacuum energy and the complete renormalized energy for different values of the potential strength . for @xmath120 we found the renormalized vacuum energy to posses a small imaginary part becoming larger when @xmath15 approaches @xmath12 . particle creation accounts for this contribution . it starts when the attractive potential of the shell becomes over - critical , that is when @xmath121 , where @xmath122 is the energy of the bound state ; in this case the effective action of the system acquires an imaginary part , however a detailed discussion of this aspect of the theory is beyond the purpose of the present paper . it should only be said that in the plots traced for negative values of @xmath15 ( fig . 4 and 5 ) the energy is to be intended as real part of . we calculated the vacuum energy of a scalar field in the background of a cylindrical semi - transparent shell . the formulas for the energy density per unit length of the shell are given by equations ( 33 ) and ( 34 ) . the heat kernel coefficients ( 32 ) for a cylindrical potential containing a delta function , are also a relevant part of the results . a discussion of the sign of the vacuum energy is possible by means of the data given in the numerical section of this paper . the energy is found to be negative in the background of repulsive potentials ( @xmath123 ) for every finite value of the radius ( fig . 3 ) . this conclusion sets a closeness between the model studied here and that of a conducting cylinder @xcite and of a dielectric cylinder @xcite in the electromagnetic vacuum . the latter models possess also a negative casimir energy . there is also a resemblance with the @xmath90-potential spherical shell investigated in paper @xcite , where a negative energy was observed for large repulsive potentials . in the background of attractive potentials ( @xmath124 ) the energy is negative on almost all the @xmath1-axis . as we see in fig . 5 , the energy becomes positive for very small values of the radius . this happens when the logarithmic term in ( 39 ) compensates for the term proportional to @xmath125 in ( 41 ) which is dominant for small values of @xmath15 in the region @xmath126 . the thin region of positive asymptotically increasing energy appearing in fig . 5 is reasonably out of physical applicability . for both repulsive and attractive potentials the renormalized vacuum energy of the semi - transparent cylinder goes logarithmically to @xmath127 in the limit @xmath109 this logarithmic behaviour was also found in the semi - transparent spherical shell @xcite , however it was not found in the @xmath90-potential flux tube @xcite , which has many feature in common with the background investigated here . this can be explained by means of the heat - kernel coefficient @xmath115 , which is a non zero coefficient here as well as in @xcite . it is also interesting to note how in expression ( 32 ) for the coefficient @xmath115 the contributions proportional to @xmath15 and @xmath128 have cancelled and only a term proportional to @xmath129 is present . the cancellation of the lower powers of the potential strength was also observed in @xcite and in paper @xcite , where a theta function profile in a dielectric spherical shell is examined . it confirms the observation that singular profiles show weaker divergences than smoother , less singular profiles . i thank m. bordag for advice . the expansion in negative powers of the parameter @xmath9 ( eq . ( 24 ) ) is obtained from the following expansions @xmath130 @xmath131 where @xmath132 takes the values @xmath118 and @xmath133 and the functions @xmath134 and @xmath135 up to the third order are given by @xmath136\ , \nonumber \\ s_i(3,a , t ) & = & \frac { 1}{128}(((25 - 104a^2 + 16a^4 ) t^3)/3 + 16 a ( -7 + 4a^2 ) t^4\nonumber\\ & & - ( 531/5 - 224a^2 + 16a^4)t^5 - ( 32a ( -33 + 8a^2 ) t^6)/3\nonumber \\ & & - ( -221 + 200a^2 ) t^7 - 240a t^8 - ( 1105 t^9)/9)\ ; \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath137\ , \nonumber \\ s_k(3,a , t ) & = & -\frac { 1}{128}((25 - 104a^2 + 16a^4 ) t^3)/3 + 16 a ( -7 + 4a^2 ) t^4\nonumber\\ & & - ( -531/5 + 224a^2 - 16a^4)t^5- ( 32a ( -33 + 8a^2 ) t^6)/3\nonumber\\ & & - ( 221 - 200a^2 ) t^7 - 240a t^8 + ( 1105 t^9)/9\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath138 . the transformation of the summation over @xmath9 in ( 26 ) into an integral is done with the abel - plana formula in our case the function @xmath140 is @xmath141 to the first addend of eq.(46 ) corresponds the contribution @xmath85 to the second addend the contribution @xmath86 ant to the third the contribution @xmath142 . in @xmath85 the integrations over @xmath119 and @xmath9 are performed by means of the following formula @xmath143 giving directly result ( 29 ) . for the integration over @xmath119 in @xmath86 and @xmath142 the following formula has been used @xmath144 which , applied to @xmath86 , leads directly to result ( 30 ) . in @xmath142 the integrand is more complicated and the integrals over @xmath9 can not be analytically calculated . result ( 31 ) represents the maximum possible simplification , which we reached after several partial integrations . the functions @xmath84 are @xmath145 99 h. b. g. casimir , proc . akad . wet . * 51 * , 793 ( 1948 ) . anushree roy , chiung - yuan lin , u. mohideen , phys . rev . d*60 * 111101 ( 1999 ) . r. balian , r. duplantier , ann . phys . * 112 * , 165 ( 1978 ) . l. l. deraad , jr . , k. a. milton , ann . phys . * 136 * , 229 ( 1981 ) . nesterenko , i.g . pirozhenko , phys . d * 60 * , 125007 ( 1999 ) . i. klich , a. romeo , phys . b*476 * , 369 ( 2000 ) . m. scandurra , j.phys . a : math . gen . * 32 * , 5679 ( 1999 ) . m. scandurra , _ vacuum energy in the presence of a magnetic string with delta function profile _ , hep - th/0003143 , submitted to phys . d. x. blase , lorin x. benedict , eric l. shirley , and steven g. louie , phys . . lett . * 72 * , 1878 ( 1994 ) . riichiro saito , mitsutaka fujita , g. dresselhaus , and m. s. dresselhaus , phys . b * 72 * , 1804 ( 1992 ) . m. bordag , k. kirsten , phys . d * 53 * , 5753 ( 1996 ) . m. bordag _ ground state energy for massive fields and renormalization _ , hep - th/9804103 , to appear in comments on atomic and molecular physics . m. abramowitz , i.a . stegun , _ handbook of mathematical functions _ , new york : dover reprinted 1972 . m. bordag , k. kirsten , phys.rev . d * 60 * , 105019 ( 1999 ) . j. schwinger , phys . rev . * 82 * , 914 ( 1951 ) . m. bordag , k. kirsten , m. hellmund , phys . d * 61 * , 085008 ( 2000 ) . m. bordag , k. kirsten , d. vassilevich , phys.rev . d * 59 * , 085011 ( 1999 ) .

we compute the ground state energy of a massive scalar field in the background of a cylindrical shell whose potential is given by a delta function . the zero point energy is expressed in terms of the jost function of the related scattering problem , the renormalization is performed with the help of the heat kernel expansion . the energy is found to be negative for attractive and for repulsive backgrounds as well .

hep-lat9812022

discretized models of @xmath2dimensional euclidean quantum gravity , known as simplicial gravity or dynamical triangulations , have been extensively studied in the past decade . the two dimensional model was proposed quite some time ago in ref . @xcite , and generalized to three and four dimensions in ref . the model is defined by the grand - canonical partition function @xmath4 where @xmath5 and @xmath6 are the discrete cosmological and inverse newton s constants , @xmath7 is the number of @xmath2dimensional simplices , and @xmath8 is the canonical partition function @xmath9 the micro - canonical partition function , @xmath10 , is defined as @xmath11 where the sum is over an ensemble of combinatorial triangulations @xmath12 with a spherical topology and with @xmath13 vertices and @xmath7 @xmath2simplices . for @xmath14 these two numbers are independent . the symmetry factor @xmath15 of a triangulation @xmath16 is given by the number of equivalent labeling of the vertices . including this factor is equivalent to summing over all _ labeled _ triangulations @xmath17 . as a statistical system simplicial gravity displays a wealth of intriguing features . in @xmath14 it exhibits a geometric phase transition separating a strong - coupling _ crumpled _ phase , where the internal geometry of the triangulations collapses , from a weak - coupling _ elongated _ phase characterized by triangulations consisting of `` bubbles '' glued together into a tree - like structure or branched polymers @xcite . both in three @xcite and four dimensions @xcite this transition is discontinuous . in the absence of a continuous phase transition with a divergent correlation length any sensible continuum limit where a theory of gravity might be defined appears to be ruled out this has led to the studies of modified models of simplicial gravity , e.g. by changing the relative weight of the triangulations with a modified measure @xcite , or by coupling matter fields to the theory @xcite . suitable modified the phase structure of the model changes ; the polymerization of the geometry in the weak - coupling limit the elongated phase is suppressed and a new _ crinkled _ phase appears @xcite . the crinkled phase is separated from the other two phases by lines of either a soft continuous phase transitions , or possible a cross - over ( a divergent specific heat is not observed ) . qualitatively the same phase structure , shown schematically in figure 1 , is observed both in three and four dimensions . both in the elongated and in the crinkled phase the canonical partition function is seen to have the asymptotic behavior @xmath18 which defines the string susceptibility exponent @xmath19 . in the crumpled phase , on the other hand , the sub - leading behavior is exponential , corresponding to @xmath20 . many of the properties of the model eq . ( [ part.grand ] ) , in the weak - coupling regime @xmath21 , are reflected by triangulations close to the upper kinematic bound @xmath22 . this is evident both from monte carlo ( mc ) simulations and from the analysis of a strong - coupling expansion ( sce ) of the partition function . for combinatorial triangulations , where each simplex is uniquely defined by a set of @xmath23 distinct vertices , the upper kinematic bound is @xmath24 . although this bound is only saturated in the thermodynamic limit , @xmath25 , for each finite volume there exist triangulations with a well - defined maximal number of vertexes @xmath26 . the ensemble of these triangulations , the _ maximal _ ensemble @xmath27 , defines the micro - canonical partition function @xmath28 in this paper we investigate the properties of the maximal ensemble , mostly restricted to three dimensions , using both mc simulations and a sce , i.e. a direct enumeration of the micro - canonical partition function eq . ( [ part.max ] ) . this investigation is separated into two parts . in the first part we study the pure ( un - modified ) ensemble and show that @xmath29 effectively separates into _ three _ distinct series ( or two series in @xmath30 ) as in general there are several different volumes @xmath7 corresponding to a given @xmath31 . one of those series is an ensemble of _ stacked spheres _ , a particular simple class of triangulations which can be enumerated exactly . this we do in section 3 . the other two series can be considered as `` almost '' stacked spheres , i.e. with one , or two , _ defects _ respectively . heuristic arguments , supported by numerical evidence , show that although the leading asymptotic behavior of the three series is identical , the effect of inserting a defect increases the exponent @xmath19 by @xmath32 ( or @xmath33 ) compared to stacked spheres . this is discussed in section 4 . in the second part of the paper , section 5 , we study the model eq . ( [ part.max ] ) with a modified measure , @xmath34 here @xmath35 is the _ order _ of a vertex @xmath36 , i.e. the number of simplices incident to that vertex . as the measure is modified , varying @xmath37 , we observe a soft geometric phase transition from the elongated phase to a crinkled phase for @xmath38 , in agreement with the phase diagram figure 1 . moreover , a scaling analysis of the transition is consistent with a third order transition ( @xmath39 ) . in the crinkled phase the fractal structure is dominated by a gas of sub - singular vertices , i.e. vertices whose order grows sub - linearly with the volume . the intrinsic fractal structure is characterized by a set of critical exponents : ( i ) a negative string susceptibility exponent @xmath19 , which decreases with @xmath37 . ( ii ) a hausdorff dimension which is either @xmath40 , or @xmath41 ( as @xmath42 ) , depending on whether it is measured on the triangulation itself or its dual graph . ( iii ) a spectral dimension , measured on the dual graph , which increases smoothly from a branched polymer value @xmath43 , at @xmath44 , to @xmath45 at @xmath46 . we have collected some of the more technical issues in two appendixes : in appendix a we list the sce of the three different series , and in appendix b we describe some complications in extracting @xmath19 from measurements of minbu distributions on maximal triangulations . a maximal triangulation is a triangulation which for given volume @xmath7 has the maximal allowed number of vertices @xmath13 . for a combinatorial triangulation this implies : @xmath47 here @xmath48 denotes the floor function , i.e. the biggest integer not greater than @xmath49 . from this definition it follows that in general more then one volume will correspond to a given maximal vertex number . in @xmath50 this defines three different _ series _ , labeled by the @xmath51pairs : @xmath52 the first series @xmath53 has the smallest volume for a given number of vertices and we will call it the _ minimal _ series . likewise , in @xmath30 there are in principle four different series . however , as only combinatorial four - triangulations of _ even _ volume are allowed this reduces to only two : @xmath54 in the space of all triangulations , the different series are related through a set of ( topology preserving ) geometric changes , the @xmath55moves . in a @xmath55move , where @xmath56 , a ( @xmath57)sub - simplex is replaced by its dual ( @xmath58)sub - simplex , provided no manifold constraint is violated . these moves are used in the mc simulations and are ergodic for @xmath59 , i.e. any two triangulations are related through a finite sequence of moves @xcite . = 5.0 in in three dimensions there are two sets of moves : move @xmath60 inserts a vertex into a tetrahedra and its inverse , move @xmath61 , deletes a vertex of order four . in move @xmath62 a triangle separating two adjacent tetrahedra is replaced by a link connecting the opposite vertices . this is shown in figure [ fig.move3d ] . these moves change the number of different @xmath2simplices in the following way : @xmath63 note that only the first set of moves changes both the volume and the number of vertices , and when applied to a maximal triangulation we stay within the particular series , i.e. the different series are internally connected _ via _ this move . the different series are connected , for fixed @xmath13 , by the @xmath62 and the @xmath64moves . however , as it is not possible to apply move @xmath64 to the series @xmath53 ( as triangulations in this series have the minimal volume for a given @xmath13 ) , the only connection which the maximal ensemble has with the rest of the triangulation space is _ via _ move @xmath62 applied to the series @xmath65 . the relations between the different series , _ via _ the @xmath55moves , are shown in figure 3 . [ r][r]@xmath66 [ c][c]@xmath66 maximal ensemble , @xmath53 , @xmath67 and @xmath65 , _ via _ the @xmath55moves.,title="fig:",width=377 ] [ moves ] a @xmath2dimensional _ stacked sphere_. however , in @xmath68 this does not define a maximal ensemble as @xmath69 for every ( spherical ) triangulation . ] is a triangulation constructed by successivelly gluing together smallest @xmath2spheres made out of @xmath70 , @xmath2dimensional regular simplexes@xcite . gluing is defined as cutting away one @xmath2simplex in each triangulation and joining the two triangulations by the resulting boundary . gluing a @xmath2sphere corresponds to applying the ( @xmath71)move . from the definitions of stacked spheres and the maximal ensemble it follows that stacked spheres belong to the minimal series @xmath53 . the inverse statement , although less trivial , is also true . this was proven , in three and four dimensions , in two theorems due to walkup @xcite : for any combinatorial triangulation of a 3sphere the inequality @xmath72 holds with equality if and only if it is a stacked sphere . for any combinatorial triangulation of a 4sphere the inequality @xmath73 holds with equality if and only if it is a stacked sphere . from those theorems follows a non - trivial statement : the move @xmath74 , and it inverse @xmath75 , is ergodic when applied to the ensemble of stacked spheres . in contrast , for the non - minimal series this statement is not true . there exist triangulations , @xmath76 , @xmath77 , that can not be reduced to the minimal configuration of the corresponding series by a repeated application of the move @xmath78 . this we have verified numerically . as stacked spheres have a simple tree - like structure , it is possible to calculate the partition function restricted to this ensemble explicitly . in this section we present algorithms for doing so , both for _ labeled _ triangulations ( which enter the mc simulations ) and for the number of _ distinct _ or _ unlabeled _ triangulations . we also show how to generalize the algorithm for counting labeled triangulations to include a modified measure eq . ( [ part.measure ] ) . all the results in this section are based on ref . @xcite which deals with the enumeration of _ simplicial clusters_. a ( @xmath70)dimensional simplicial cluster is a simplicial complex obtained by gluing together @xmath79dimensional regular simplices along their @xmath2dimensional faces . comparing this to the definition of stacked spheres one sees that a @xmath2dimensional stacked sphere is the boundary of a @xmath79dimensional simplicial cluster where the outer faces of the simplicial cluster correspond to the simplices of the stacked sphere . so number of @xmath80dimensional clusters with @xmath81 @xmath79simplices corresponds to the number of stacked spheres with @xmath82 vertices , i.e. @xmath83 simplices . the basic `` building block '' is the expression for the number of @xmath79dimensional simplicial clusters build out of @xmath84simplices rooted at a marked outer face . denoting this number by @xmath85 we have the following recursive relation @xcite , @xmath86 introducing the counting series , @xmath87 from lagrange s inversion formula ( see for example @xcite page 147 ) it follows that @xmath88 to calculate the number of labeled simplicial clusters we note that once the outer face has been labeled , the remaining @xmath89 vertices can be labeled in @xmath90 distinct ways . the four labels on the marked face can be chosen in one of @xmath91 ways . including the @xmath92 factor from eq . ( [ part.micro ] ) , a normalization factor @xmath93 ( as used in ref . @xcite ) , and dividing by @xmath7 to adjust for the fact that we count rooted configurations , we arrive at the micro - canonical partition function for stacked spheres , @xmath94 the first 20 terms in the above series are listed in tables 2 and 3 in appendix a for @xmath95 and 4 . this corresponds to the enumeration of all stacked spheres of volume @xmath96 and @xmath97 , respectively . to investigate the leading behavior of the above series , we perform an asymptotic expansion of eq . ( [ wd ] ) in powers of @xmath98 . for @xmath95 and 4 this gives : @xmath99 in both cases , the leading asymptotic behavior is of the form eq . ( [ def.gamma ] ) with @xmath100 . moreover , for both series the corrections to the leading order are analytic in @xmath98 , i.e. there are no confluent singularities . this behavior is essential for applying the particular variant of the ratio method we use to analyze the series in next section . in contrast , the enumeration of the unlabeled triangulations the number of distinct graphs is much harder as the symmetry factor of each triangulation has to be canceled . this is the main subject of ref . @xcite which provides an algorithm to construct the generating function @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the number of distinct ( @xmath2 + 1)dimensional simplicial clusters build out of @xmath103 simplices . we list the functions @xmath104 and @xmath105 in appendix a together with the first 20 terms ( tables 2 and 3 ) . it is interesting to note that although the series of unlabeled triangulations has the same asymptotic behavior as the labeled one , i.e. the same @xmath106 and @xmath19 , the sub - leading corrections are not analytic in this case . this is evident from an analysis of the singularities of the functions @xmath104 and @xmath105 . as a consequence , for unlabeled triangulations it is is impossible to extract the leading behavior using a series extrapolation method such as the ratio method ( as is demonstrated in figure [ fig.zeta_c ] ) . it is possible to extend the above algorithm for enumerating labeled stacked spheres to accommodate the measure term @xmath107 . the additional complication is to keep track of the order of each of the vertices on the marked face . here we present a recursive algorithm to do this . however , for simplicity we consider only @xmath50 stacked spheres , i.e. @xmath30 simplicial clusters . we denote by @xmath108 the sum over all triangulations rooted at a marked outer face , where @xmath109 is the order of the vertices at the root . each triangulation is weighted by a factor @xmath110 where the product is over all vertices _ not _ belonging to the marked face . thus the number of rooted simplicial clusters becomes @xmath111 & \hspace{30pt } \times\bigl ( a_4+b_4+c_4+d_4 - 4 \bigr ) ^{\beta } \\[4pt ] \nonumber & \hspace{-55pt}\times\delta_{a_1 + b_1 + c_1 -2 , q_1}\ ; \delta_{d_1 + a_2 + b_2 -2 , q_2 } \ ; \delta_{c_2 + d_2 + a_3 -2 , q_3}\ ; \delta_{b_3 + c_3 + d_3 -2 , q_4}\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the normalization @xmath112 we have to sum over all possible vertex orders of the marked face , @xmath113 to obtain the micro - canonical partition function @xmath114 where @xmath115 is the weight of the smallest triangulation . although a solution of eq . ( [ enrecmes ] ) is not known in a closed form , it is possible to calculate the series @xmath116 recursively . a simple program written in fortran 90 using quadruple precision takes about 7 hours of cpu time on a 600mhz alpha station to compute @xmath116 for @xmath117 @xmath118 . each additional term in the series requires four times the amount of computation as the previous one . compared to a method of directly identifying distinct triangulations in mc simulations , discussed in next section , using the algorithm presented above it is possible to calculate more terms in the sce . however , method presented above is limited to the enumeration of stacked spheres , i.e. to a sub - class of the maximal ensemble , and moreover the series has to be calculated separately for each value of @xmath37 . we will start our exploration of the maximal ensemble with the pure ( unmodified ) case @xmath44 . as stated , the partition function eq . ( [ part.max ] ) effectively separates into three distinct series , @xmath53 , @xmath67 and @xmath65 , corresponding to regions of the triangulation - space only loosely connected _ via _ the ( @xmath119)moves . in this section we would like to explore in more details the difference between those series , in particular their asymptotic behavior . the following heuristic argument gives some idea of what asymptotic behavior we can expect . the series @xmath67 and @xmath65 , which are close to but do not saturate the upper bound in walkup s theorem eq ( [ walk3 ] ) , can be considered as stacked spheres with one , or two , defects , respectively . a defect is defined as an one application of the move ( @xmath120 ) , i.e. replacing a triangle by a link . for a sufficiently large triangulation one naively expects that the number of ways such a defect can be inserted should grow linearly with the volume ( inserting defects into two distinct non - symmetric stacked spheres does not lead to identical triangulations ) . this implies that although the leading exponential behavior of the three series might be the same , the sub - leading behavior is should be multiplied by @xmath121 ( or @xmath122 ) , hence @xmath123 ( or @xmath124 ) , with @xmath19 defined in eq . ( [ def.gamma ] ) . to investigate the asymptotic behavior , and to verify the statement above , we have performed several numerical experiments . in figure [ fig.free ] we show the micro - canonical partition function for the three series measured numerically for @xmath125 . we have divided out the leading behavior of the partition functions , i.e. we plot @xmath126 where @xmath127 is some convenient normalization and we assume the exact values @xmath128 the behavior in figure [ fig.free ] is indeed compatible with this assumption . if the series had different @xmath129 the curves should approach a straight line with a non - zero slope . likewise , a different value of @xmath130 would manifest itself in a very slow convergence . neither behavior is observed , all three curves in figure [ fig.free ] converge rapidly on a horizontal line . it should be noted , however , that the two non - minimal series appear to have larger finite - size corrections . a more precise determination of the critical parameters , @xmath129 and @xmath130 , comes from the sce of the micro - canonical partition function eq . ( [ part.max ] ) . in section 3 we presented a algorithm for calculating the sce restricted to the minimal series @xmath53 . a corresponding recursive algorithm for constructing the two non - minimal series is , however , not available . in fact , it is not clear that such algorithm exist . unlike @xmath131 , the non - minimal series can not be constructed from some ( different ) minimal configuration by a successive application of move ( @xmath132 ) . we thus resort to an alternative method to enumerate the two non - minimal series . this method , based on a direct identification of all distinct triangulations in mc simulations , has previously been applied in four dimensions to identify all distinct triangulations of volume @xmath133 @xcite . the two main ingrediences of the method are : ( i ) a sufficiently complicated hash function @xmath134 that uniquely identifies combinatorially distinct triangulations . ( ii ) a calculation of the corresponding symmetry factors , @xmath15 , by an explicit permutation of the vertex labels . the sce s for @xmath135 and @xmath136 are shown in table 4 in appendix a. as the two non - minimal series grow much faster than the minimal one , this method is limited to volume @xmath137 . this corresponds to 10 and 8 terms respectively . to calculate the next term would require the identification , and storing , of @xmath138 distinct triangulations a formidable task with the computer resources available . to analyze the sce and to extract the asymptotic behavior we apply an appropriate series extrapolation method . for these particular series the most powerful method is a variant of the ratio method , a neville - aitken extrapolation , in which successive correction terms to the partition function are eliminated by a suitable sequence extrapolation technique @xcite . for the minimal series this method yields impressively accurate estimates of the critical parameters . applied to the first 20 terms in table 2 we get @xmath139 compared to the exact values @xmath140 and @xmath141 the quoted errors indicate how the estimate change as the last term in the series is excluded . for the non - minimal series the finite - size corrections are larger and , in addition , we have less terms available . the estimates of the critical parameters are correspondingly less accurate , especially for @xmath65 : @xmath142 these values are though consistent with the conjecture that @xmath106 is the same for all the three series , but that @xmath143 . the same behavior is observed for the two series of the maximal ensemble in @xmath30 . the first 20 terms in table 3 yield equally impressive agreement with the exact values : @xmath144{3125/256 } \approx 0.625503\ldots$ ] and @xmath140 . and the first 7 terms in the non - minimal series @xmath67 , given in ref . @xcite , give @xmath145 and @xmath146 . some final comments regarding the non - minimal series . although an exact enumeration algorithm is not available it is possible to obtain a lower bound on the series @xmath67 and @xmath65 by assuming that all non - minimal triangulations can be constructed by move @xmath60 from the appropriate minimal configuration . the resulting sce has , for both series this assumes that the two defects are connected , thus excludes triangulations with two randomly distributed defects . this results in a lower estimate @xmath147 , instead of @xmath148 which we expect for @xmath65 . ] , the same @xmath106 and @xmath147 . the different asymptotic behavior for the three series is very pronounced when one considers the distribution of minimal neck baby universes ( minbu s ) measured on maximal triangulations . a minbu is a part of a triangulation connected to the rest _ via _ a minimal neck on a three dimensional combinatorial triangulation a minimal neck consists of four triangles glued along their edges to form a closed surface ( a tetrahedra ) . by counting in how many ways a `` baby '' of size @xmath149 can be connected to a `` mother '' of size @xmath150 , the distribution of minbu s can be expressed in terms of the canonical partition functions of the corresponding volumes @xcite . for a maximal triangulation the situation is more complicated as the baby , the mother , and the `` universe '' can belong to any one of the different series @xmath151 . it is not even obvious that if a maximal triangulation is split along a minimal neck the two parts belong to the maximal ensemble at all . this is though easy to verify and @xmath152 , the result only belongs to the maximal ensemble provided @xmath153 . ] . in general the distribution of baby universes measured on maximal triangulations becomes @xmath154 & \sim & b^{\gamma(k_b)-2 } \ ; ( n_3-b+2)^{\gamma(k_m)-2}\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the indices @xmath155 , @xmath156 , and @xmath157 refer to the baby , the mother , and the universe , the factors @xmath149 and @xmath158 count the possible locations of the neck , and @xmath159 is a _ contact _ term due to interactions on the neck . the contact term is discussed further in appendix b ; for pure simplicial gravity this is just a trivial constant . in the last step we have used the expected asymptotic behavior of the series eq . ( [ def.gamma ] ) . in principle , eq . ( [ babymax ] ) defines nine different distributions , however the additional restriction , @xmath160 , reduces the number of possible combinations to six . two of those , @xmath161 and @xmath162 , both corresponding to @xmath163 , are plotted in figure [ fig.baby3d ] . both distributions are measured on triangulations with @xmath164 , but on different volumes , @xmath165 , and 502 . the former distribution , @xmath161 , which is composed solely of the minimal series , has remarkably small finite - size effects . a fit to eq . ( [ babymax ] ) , including minbu s @xmath166 , gives @xmath167 . in contrast , for an acceptable fit to the distribution @xmath162 a lower cut - off , @xmath168 , had to be imposed . the result , @xmath169 , is consistent with our previous estimate . the remaining four distributions in eq . ( [ babymax ] ) correspond to a baby and a mother belonging to different series . however , the mixture of different @xmath19 s and large finite - size effects makes a reliable estimate of @xmath130 very difficult from these distributions . we now turn to the maximal ensemble modified by varying the measure eq . ( [ part.measure ] ) for @xmath170 . for most part we restricted our investigation to the ensemble of stacked spheres where we expect less finite - size effects . this provides the additional benefit that the mc simulations are much simplified as only move @xmath60 , and its inverse , are required for the updating process to be ergodic . however , we also did extensive simulations of the full model ( including finite values of @xmath6 ) to verify that this did not introduce any bias in the measurement process . typically we collected about 10 to 50 thousand independent measurements at each value of @xmath37 and on different volumes @xmath171 to 8000 . as the fluctuations in the vertex orders are enhanced by modifying the measure , i.e. by decreasing @xmath37 , the internal geometry changes . the polymerization of the triangulations is suppressed and the model enters a new phase akin to the crinkled phase observed in four dimensions @xcite . the nature of the internal geometry in the crinkled phase is discussed in section 5.2 , here we present what evidence we have for the existence of a continuous phase transition at a critical value @xmath172 . in figure [ fig.trans]_a _ we show the fluctuations in the energy density , @xmath173 , as we vary @xmath37 . this is for @xmath174 to 8000 and we define @xmath175 . we observe on all volumes a peak in @xmath176 consistent with the existence of a phase transitions at @xmath177 . the peak value appears to saturate as the volume is increased ; this makes it difficult to distinguish between a soft continuous phase transition and a cross - over behavior . the scaling of the peak value is , however , consistent with a third order phase transition . this is shown in figure [ fig.cvmax ] where we fit the maximal value to the scaling behavior : @xmath178 . the fit yields @xmath179 , with a @xmath180 . assuming hyper - scaling , @xmath181 , is valid this implies a specific heat exponent @xmath182 . additional evidence for a transition is provided by other geometric observables such as the maximal vertex order @xmath183 whose value jumps at the transition . as discussed in the introduction , and is quantified in the section 5.2 , the crinkled phase is characterized by a gas of sub - singular vertices , i.e. vertices whose local volume grows like @xmath184 , @xmath185 . as a consequence both the fluctuations in the maximal vertex order , @xmath186 , and its energy derivative , @xmath187 , diverge at the transition . an example of the former is shown in figure [ fig.trans]_b_. in fact , the susceptibility @xmath188 appears to diverge in the whole crinkled phase in contrast to its behavior in the elongated phase . note that some of the data in figure [ fig.trans ] are measured on non - minimal triangulations ( e.g. @xmath189 and 4000 ) . this shows that the phase transition is a generic behavior of the maximal ensemble , not just of the minimal series . the same is true for the nature of the crinkled phase explored in the next section . to investigate the nature of the internal geometry in the crinkled phase , and to compare it to the elongated phase , we have measured several aspects of the fractal structure : the distribution of vertex orders @xmath190 , the string susceptibility exponent @xmath19 , and both the fractal and spectral dimensions @xmath191 and @xmath192 . the shape of the vertex order distribution @xmath190 is a good indicator for the nature of the internal geometry in the different phases . in the elongated phase the vertex orders are more or less equdistributed and the maximal vertex order grows logarithmically with the system size , @xmath193 . in the crinkled phase , on the other hand , vertices of large order are favored and the maximal vertex order grows sub - linearly , @xmath194 . estimates of @xmath195 , from finite - size scaling including volume @xmath171 to 8000 , indicate that @xmath196 for sufficiently large negative @xmath37 . examples of the vertex order distribution in the two phases are shown in figure [ fig.vord ] for @xmath197 and @xmath46 . in the crinkled phase the distribution @xmath190 developes a `` bump '' in the tail , corresponding to a condensation of vertices of large order . the bump persists as the volume is increased , i.e. it captures a finite fraction of the volume as @xmath198 . this suggests that the crinkled phase can be characterized as a _ gas _ of sub - singular vertices . when the ensemble of triangulations in eq . ( [ part.micro ] ) includes degenerate triangulations @xcite . however , in @xmath30 the bump is disconnected from the rest of the distribution this justifies the nomenclature _ singular structure_. ] to measure the string susceptibility exponent for various values of @xmath37 , and restricted to the minimal series , we have used several methods : _ the pseudo - critical cosmological constant _ , @xmath199 + assuming the asymptotic behavior eq . ( [ def.gamma ] ) , a saddle - point approximation of the grand - canonical partition function gives : @xmath200 by measuring @xmath199 with high accuracy on volumes @xmath201 to 2400 , and for @xmath202 , -2 , -3 , and -4 , we determined @xmath19 by a fit to eq . ( [ eq.mu_pseudo ] ) . _ the minbu distribution _ , @xmath203 + we measured the minbu distribution on volume @xmath204 and for the same values of @xmath37 . however , in contrast to the elongated phase , in the crinkled phase the contact term @xmath159 has a non - trivial dependence on @xmath149 and has to be eliminated prior to extracting @xmath19 from the ( corrected ) distribution @xmath205 by a fit to eq . ( [ babymax ] ) . _ the strong - coupling expansion _ i + using the enumeration methods for a non - zero @xmath37 , presented in section 3.2 , we calculated the first 17 terms of the sce of stacked spheres for few values of @xmath37 . from this sce we extracted @xmath19 using the ratio method . _ the strong - coupling expansion _ ii + by explicitly identifying all distinct triangulations of volume @xmath206 , and calculating the corresponding measure term , we calculate the first 12 terms in the sce for an arbitrary value of @xmath37 . [ tab.gamma ] .estimates of the exponent @xmath19 , for @xmath202 , @xmath207 , @xmath208 , and @xmath209 ; ( a ) from a fit to @xmath199 , eq . ( [ eq.mu_pseudo ] ) , ( with [ @xmath210 ) ; ( b ) from the minbu distribution , eq . ( [ babymax ] ) , both including and excluding the contact term , @xmath161 and @xmath205 ; and ( c ) from the first 17 terms in the sce . [ cols="^ , < , < , < , < , < " , ] as discussed in section 5.2 , for minbu s on maximal triangulations , the interactions at neck the _ contact _ term play a ( unusually ) big and non - trivial role in the crinkled phase . it is essential to take these interactions into account when estimating @xmath19 from a fit to the measured minbu distributions . in this appendix we analyze the behavior of the contact term and explain why it plays such an important role for this particular ensemble . in the nomenclature of section 3 we can write the minbu distribution , eq . ( [ babymax ] ) , for @xmath197 and measured on a stacked sphere of size @xmath103 , as @xmath211 however , for @xmath212 the situation is different . we must take into account the different possible distributions of vertex orders , @xmath213 and @xmath214 , on the marked simplex ( the neck ) , both on the baby and on the mother . the distribution is then @xmath215 defining @xmath216 we can rewrite eq . ( [ bab ] ) as @xmath217 & \equiv & { \cal b}_n(b;\beta)\cdot { \cal c}_n(b;\beta)\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we define @xmath218 as the _ contact _ term .. the following argument gives some idea of the relevance of the contact term in the different phases . if we assume that the distribution @xmath219 factorizes , @xmath220 then the distribution @xmath221 is related to the vertex order distribution @xmath190 , i.e. the probability of finding a vertex with given order @xmath222 , through @xmath223 in the elongated phase the distribution @xmath221 decays exponentially , whereas in the crinkled phase vertices of large order are favored and the distribution has a power - law decay ( figure [ fig.vord ] ) . an exponential decay of @xmath221 effectively introduces a cut - off in the sum over vertex orders in eq . ( [ ct ] ) . hence , for sufficiently large triangulations the contact term becomes independent of the volume . in contrast , in the crinkled phase there is no such cut - off and we can expect a strong volume dependence . this is demonstrated by numerical measurements of the contact term , shown in figure [ fig.cont ] . in the elongated phase , @xmath224 , the contact term @xmath225 is more or less constant for @xmath226 , whereas for @xmath46 the contact term @xmath227 depends strongly on @xmath149 . although this effect can be expected for any ensemble modified by the measure eq . ( [ part.measure ] ) , the particular construction of maximal triangulations , by a repeated application of move @xmath228 , enhances the role of the contact term . for every time move @xmath228 is applied one minimal neck is generated , hence for a maximal triangulation the number of minbu s is fixed . thus the minbu distributions , measured on @xmath53 , is more constrained than measured on a general ensemble where triangulations with fewer minbu s are favored as @xmath229 . how does all this affect the measurements of @xmath230 ? the standard method for extracting @xmath19 from a minbu distribution is to impose a lower cut - off @xmath231 on the minbu size included in the fit to eq . ( [ babymax ] ) . the cut - off is then increased until a stable estimate of @xmath232 is obtained @xcite . in the elongated phase , and in general for most models of simplicial gravity , this methods works fine . however , for stacked spheres this method fails in the crinkled phase . unless the contact term is eliminated , i.e.divided out of the minbu distribution in the measurement process , a stable plateau in @xmath232 is not observed . an example of this is shown in figure [ fig.cont ] for @xmath46 .

in the weak - coupling limit , @xmath0 , the partition function of simplicial quantum gravity is dominated by an ensemble of triangulations with the ratio @xmath1 close to the upper kinematic limit . for a combinatorial triangulation of the @xmath2sphere this limit is @xmath3 . defining an ensemble of _ maximal _ triangulations , i.e. triangulations that have the maximal possible number of vertices for a given volume , we investigate the properties of this ensemble in three dimensions using both monte carlo simulations and a strong - coupling expansion of the partition function , both for pure simplicial gravity and a with a suitable modified measure . for the latter we observe a continuous phase transition to a _ crinkled _ phase and we investigate the fractal properties of this phase . bi / th-98/38 + december 1998 _ g. thorleifsson , p. bialas and b. petersson _ + facultt fr physik , universitt bielefeld d-33615 , bielefeld , germany +

quant-ph0210165

the optical properties of the semiconductor structures have been the subject of intensive experimental and theoretical investigation during recent years . technical progress in the semiconductor crystal growth has made it possible to control semiconductor structures in all three spatial dimensions . experimentally , physicists can fabricate the quantum wells , in which a thin semiconductor film is sandwiched between different materials via heterojunctions so that the motion of carriers is confined in the two dimensional thin - film plane . this confinement of carriers to two dimensions gives rise to new quantum effect not observed in bulk materials , for example , an electric field - induced energy shift of the resonance which is called the quantum confined stark effect @xcite . multi - dimensional quantum confined structure , such as quantum wires and quantum dots , are expected to further improve the quantum effect of the optical devices . experiments have shown that the confinement of carriers in these low dimensional semiconductor structures ( ldss s ) can result in novel optical - electronic effects which may lead to fabrication of new optical components . some new fascinating achievements in the areas , such as semiconductor microcavity ( smc ) quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) , quantum dot microlaser and turnstile device @xcite , quantum computer with quantum dot @xcite , and semiconductor random laser @xcite etc . , encourage the study of optical - electronic properties of these micro - structures . the present trend toward smaller - scale nanostructures and the continuous development of new and improved materials have started a steady progress towards fabrication of more ideal optical microcavities . if an ldss is placed in an smc , the optical mode structure of the smc will change around the ldss . using this effect many interesting phenomena , such as tailoring the spontaneous radiation pattern and rate @xcite , the coupled exciton - photon mode splitting in a semiconductor quantum microcavity @xcite , have been demonstrated . therefore the investigation of optical properties of an ldss placed into a semiconductor cavity is very important and necessary for theoretical and experimental physicists . it is known that the interaction between the light and these micro - systems occurs via exciton @xcite which is an electron - hole pair bound by the coulomb attraction . the radiation of exciton exhibits the superradiant character . the initial theoretical @xcite and experimental @xcite studies were focused on the superradiance of the wannier excitons in semiconductor micro - crystallites . then , the superradiance of the frenkel excitons was observed in j aggregates at low temperature @xcite . in 1995 , the superradiance of high density frenkel excitons in a r - phycoerythrin(r - pe ) single crystal was observed at room temperature for the first time @xcite . we have studied the spontaneous radiation of the frenkel excitons in a crystal slab under the condition of low excitation with an exactly solvable model and shown its superradiance nature @xcite . we have also discussed the quantum statistical properties of the output field and the semiconductor qed for the high density excitons in a semiconductor microcavity @xcite . in the former works , our main interest was the resonant interaction between the excitons and the cavity field . but we know that the detuning between the cavity field and exciton always affects the radiation properties of the exciton in the quantum well @xcite . so in this paper we will discuss a general model of the interaction between the high density excitons in a quantum well and a single - mode cavity field . in section ii , we give a general theoretical model of the non - resonant interaction between a single - mode cavity field and the exctions . by virtue of the schwinger s representation of the angular momentum using two boson modes , we approximately obtain the analytical solution of the system . in section iii , the stationary physical spectrum of the excitons , which are initially in the number state or the superposed state of two different number states is presented . a comparison of these results with those of the resonant cases will be also given . finally , a brief summary and conclusion are presented in section iv . in this section , we present a theoretical model to study the interaction between a quantum well and a single - mode cavity field . we assume that the cavity and the quantum well are ideal , and they are in an extremely low temperature circumstance . the quantum well interacts with cavity field via exciton , which is an electron - hole pair bound by the coulomb attraction . at extremely low temperatures , the thermal momentum of the excitons is so small that the thermalized excitons can be neglected . then there are only excitons with zero in - plane momentum . it is well known that when the density of the excitons becomes high , the ideal bosonic model of the excitons is no longer adequate ( in the case of a gaas quantum well , the ideal bosonic model becomes inadequate when the density of the excitons exceeds @xmath0 @xmath1 @xcite ) for a theoretical study . however , we can describe exciton operators as hypothetical bosonic operators . in order to deal with the deviation of the exciton operators from the ideal bosonic operators , we introduce an effective non - linear interaction between these hypothetical ideal bosons to correct the high excitons density effect @xcite . these considerations lead to the following hamiltonian after the rotating - wave approximation is made @xcite : @xmath2 with @xmath3 where @xmath4 are creation ( annihilation ) operators of the excitons with frequency @xmath5 , and @xmath6 are the creation ( annihilation ) operators of the cavity field with frequency @xmath7 . we assume that both of them obey the bosonic commutation relation @xmath8=[a , a^{\dagger}]=1 $ ] . @xmath9 stands for the interaction strength between the cavity field and the excitons . @xmath10 represents an effective interaction constant between the excitons . @xmath10 is assumed as a positive real number , which means that the bi - excitons are not stable in this system of the quantum well . so , it is reasonable to consider that only excitons are present in the quantum well . @xmath11 is a positive real number which describes the phase space filling factor . the ratio of the phase space filling factor to the interaction constant of the excitons is about @xmath12 @xcite . for the sake of simplicity , we assume that the parameters @xmath10 and @xmath11 are of the same order , or @xmath13 . in that case , it is convenient to give the solution of eq.([eq : h0 ] ) using the schwinger s representation of the angular momentum for two - mode bosonic operators @xcite . angular momentum operators can be constructed as @xmath14 and total number operator as @xmath15 using the ladder operators @xmath16 of the cavity field and the exciton operators @xmath17 . it is obvious that @xmath18 is the constant of motion with respect to the hamiltonian ( [ eq : h ] ) . then the total angular momentum operator can be expressed as @xmath19 for any fixed total particle number @xmath20 , the common eigen - states of @xmath21 and @xmath22 are @xmath23 , where @xmath24 are the fock states with @xmath25 photons in the cavity and @xmath26 excitons in the quantum well , respectively . although @xmath27 must be integers , @xmath28 and @xmath29 can both be integers or both be half - odd integers . if we define @xmath30 then eq.([eq : h0 ] ) can be simplified into @xmath31 in terms of an @xmath32 rotation @xmath33 of @xmath34 with @xmath35 and @xmath36 . the eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of hamiltonian ( [ eq : sh ] ) are , respectively , @xmath37 it is clear that eigenfunction @xmath38 represents a dressed exciton state or a polariton state . based on eq.([eq : pp ] ) , using perturbation theory and keeping @xmath10 and @xmath11 parameters up to their first - order , we obtain the eigenvalues of the hamiltonian ( [ eq : h ] ) as : @xmath39 and @xmath40 in order to obtain @xmath41 and @xmath42 , we first calculate the matrix elements of the perturbation term as follows @xmath43 ( j - m-1)(j - m)\delta_{n , m}+\hbar[a(\sin\theta)^{2}-\nu \sin 2\theta ] ( j^{2}-m^{2})\delta_{n , m } \nonumber \\ & & + \hbar[a(\cos\frac{\theta}{2})^{2}\sin \theta -\nu \cos\theta ( \cos\frac{\theta}{2})^2+\frac{\nu}{2}(\sin\theta)^2 ] ( j - m)\sqrt{(j+m)(j - m+1)}\delta_{n , m-1 } \nonumber\\ & & + \hbar[\frac{a}{4}(\sin\theta)^{2 } -\frac{\nu}{4}\sin 2\theta ] \sqrt{(j+m)(j+m-1)}\sqrt{(j - m+1)(j - m+2)}\delta_{n , m-2 } \nonumber \\ & & + \hbar[a\sin\theta ( \cos\frac{\theta}{2})^{2}-\nu \cos\theta ( \cos\frac{\theta}{2})^2+\frac{\nu}{2 } ( \sin \theta)^2 ] \sqrt{(j - m)(j+m+1)}(j - m-1)\delta_{n , m+1 } \nonumber \\ & & + \hbar[a\sin\theta(\sin\frac{\theta}{2})^{2}-\nu \cos\theta ( \sin\frac{\theta}{2})^2-\frac{\nu}{2}(\sin\theta)^2 ] \sqrt{(j+m)(j - m+1)}(j+m-1)\delta_{n , m-1 } \nonumber \\ & & + \hbar[a\sin\theta(\sin\frac{\theta}{2})^{2}-\nu \cos\theta ( \sin\frac{\theta}{2})^2-\frac{\nu}{2}(\sin\theta)^2 ] \sqrt{(j - m)(j+m+1)}(j+m)\delta_{n , m+1}\nonumber \\ & & + \hbar[\frac{a}{4}(\sin\theta)^{2}-\frac{\nu}{4}\sin 2\theta ] \sqrt{(j+m+1)(j+m+2)}\sqrt{(j - m)(j - m-1)}\delta_{n , m+2}\nonumber \\ & & + \hbar[a(\sin\frac{\theta}{2})^{4}-\nu \sin\theta(\sin\frac{\theta}{2})^2](j+m)(j+m-1)\delta_{n , m } , \label{eq : pp1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] 2and then write the eigenvalues of the hamiltonian ( [ eq : h])as : @xmath44 ( j^{2}-m^{2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & + \hbar[a(\cos\frac{\theta}{2})^{4}+\nu \sin\theta ( \cos\frac{\theta}{2})^2 ] ( j - m-1)(j - m ) \nonumber \\ & & + \hbar[a(\sin\frac{\theta}{2})^{4}-\nu \sin\theta(\sin\frac{\theta}{2})^2](j+m)(j+m-1).\end{aligned}\ ] ] all the eigenfunctions of the hamiltonian ( [ eq : h ] ) can be easily obtained using eq.([eq : ee ] ) and eqs.([eq : pp],[eq : pp1 ] ) . then the time evolution operators of the system can be written as @xmath45 consequently , for any initial state @xmath46 , the time - dependent wave function can be obtained as @xmath47 . under the condition of ideal cavity , ideal quantum well , and extremely low temperature , both the excitons and the cavity field have zero linewidth . assumption of ideal quantum well is important to eliminate the linewidth of excitons which may be caused by the fluctuations of the quantum well . so the only broadening mechanism comes from the detecting spectrometer for which the physical spectrum can be defined as @xcite @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the half - bandwidth of the spectrometer , and @xmath50 is the time length of the excitation in the cavity . @xmath51 represents the dipole correlation function of the excitons and is defined as @xmath52 with the initial state @xmath46 of the system , and @xmath53 @xmath54 where the second term comes from the correction of the phase space filling effect @xcite . taking into account the fact that @xmath55 , we can obtain the correlation @xmath51 as @xmath56 with @xmath57 and @xmath58 . it is evident that @xmath28 is determined only by the initial state @xmath46 . then the stationary physical spectrum can be written as @xmath59 , both @xmath60 and @xmath61 must be satistied . according to the above selection rule , eq.([eq : s ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath62 the eigenvalues determine the position of the spectral component and @xmath63 determine the intensity of the spectral lines . the above spectral formula is similar to that of reference @xcite . in the following , we will consider that the system is initially prepared in the bare exciton state using the resonant femtosecond pulse pumping method @xcite . for simplicity , we assume that @xmath64 , so that all frequency quantities have a unit of energy . moreover , we impose that initially there are no photons in the cavity . then for a system , which is initially prepared in the single exciton state , the physical spectrum from @xmath65 to @xmath66 can be simplified into @xmath67 which has double peaks located at @xmath68 and @xmath69 . it is clear that the phase space filling factor and the interaction between the excitons , which are the results of the multi - exciton presence , do nt affect the physical spectrum of this system . = 7.0 cm figure @xmath70 depicts the effect of detuning @xmath71 on the relative heights and the positions of the two peaks in the spectrum of the system described by eq . ( [ eq : sp ] ) . the difference between the heights of the two peaks in the physical spectrum is zero when @xmath72 ( resonance case ) . this profile line is observed for two - level atomic systems , too . in the non - resonant case , peaks have different heights and the frequency difference between them become larger due to detuning effect . with the increase of @xmath71 , the height of the peak locating at @xmath68 reduces gradually , whereas the height of the peak at @xmath69 increases . from eq . ( [ eq : sp ] ) and the condition @xmath73 , it can be derived that if @xmath71 and the coupling constant @xmath9 satisfy the condition @xmath74 , then @xmath75 , which means the physical spectrum has approximately one peak . it is seen in fig . @xmath70 that when @xmath76 , the difference between the heights of the peaks becomes constant . a further analysis will reveal that at those values of @xmath71 , the height of the peak located at @xmath68 becomes very close to zero , therefore the spectrum can be interpreted as having a single peak . with the increase of the pumping power , the emission spectrum of the system becomes complex . the simplest non - trivial example , for which the non - linear terms play a role in the physical spectrum , is obtained when the quantum well has initially two excitons and there is no photon in the cavity . in that case , the physical spectrum from @xmath77 to @xmath65 becomes @xmath78 with @xmath79 . we know that there are three and two dressed exciton states for @xmath77 and @xmath65 , respectively . according to the selection rule , there should be six peaks in the physical spectrum ( [ eq : pppp ] ) . figure @xmath80 , which is drawn using eq.([eq : pppp ] ) , depicts the radiation spectrum @xmath81 of the excitons as a function of the frequency difference @xmath82 under the resonant condition with or without considering the phase space filling factor . in order to give a clear picture , the natural logarithm of the physical spectrum is plotted in fig.@xmath80 ( in figs.@xmath83 and @xmath84 , as well ) . it is understood that the phase filling factor does not affect the line profile of the spectrum , but changes the heights and the positions of the peaks . so in the following numerical results , we have neglected the phase space filling effect . figure 3 clarifies that the detuning between the cavity field and the excitons changes not only the positions of the peaks , but also reduces their heights . the larger the detuning is , the stronger its effect on the physical spectrum is . as it is seen in fig.@xmath83 , @xmath85 mev only slightly changes the position and heights of the peaks keeping their number constant . however , with increasing detuning up to @xmath86 mev , the number of the peaks in the spectrum gradually decreases because ( i ) the heights of some peaks become so small when compared to main peak that they can be neglected , and ( ii ) some peaks are shifted so close to each other that they can not be resolved . = 8 cm = 8 cm the variation of the positions of the six peaks ( labeled as @xmath87 , @xmath88 in the spectrum of fig.@xmath89 ) of eq.([eq : pppp ] ) is plotted as a function of detuning @xmath71 in figure @xmath90 . it is seen that with the increase in detuning , the difference between @xmath91 and @xmath92 becomes almost zero so that they can not be resolved . peaks @xmath87 and @xmath93 , respectively , shifts to more positive and negative sides of the spectrum . the positions of @xmath94 and @xmath95 are interchanged with increasing @xmath71 , and after this interchange their relative positions are kept the same . = 8 cm it is also observed that when the half - bandwidth of the spectrometer @xmath49 and the coupling constant between the cavity field and the excitons are of the same order , the number of the peaks in the physical spectrum ( [ eq : pppp ] ) becomes two . this is because the spectrometer can not resolve the position of some of the peaks . figure @xmath96 shows that under the conditions of the weak interaction between the excitons , the heights of the peaks in spectrum are equal if the cavity field resonates with the excitons . however for the non - resonant case , the heights of the two peaks are not equal due to the detuning between the frequencies of the cavity field and that of the excitons even if there is weak interaction between the excitons . superposition of two different exciton states is yet another interesting case to investigate . if we consider the excitons are initially in the state @xmath97 and the cavity field is in the vacuum state @xmath98 , then the physical spectrum can be written as @xmath99 from which it can be found that there are eight peaks in the emission spectrum of the excitons . figure @xmath84 depicts the line profile of the physical spectrum @xmath81 as a function of the frequency difference @xmath82 under the resonant condition . = 6.5 cm it is seen from fig.@xmath84 that the physical spectrum is a simple sum of one and two exciton spectra . at first sight , it seems that it is a normal and expected result . however , if the half - bandwidth of the spectrometer gradually increases , the peaks of the physical spectrum given by eq.([eq : two ] ) reduces from eight to one . in this study , the interaction between the high - density excitons in a quantum well and the cavity field is investigated under both the resonant and non - resonant conditions . the model and the discussions presented in this paper are valid only when the excitons and cavity field have zero linewidth . an analytical expression of the physical spectrum of the excitons is obtained . a discussion of the physical spectrum of the excitons which are initially prepared in the number state or the superposed state of the two different number states is presented . it is observed that for a system having a single exciton state initially , the resonant interaction between the cavity field and the excitons gives the results similar to those of the two - level atomic system for which the two peaks in the physical spectrum have equal heights . however , non - resonant interaction results in the detuning which will change both the amplitudes of peaks and the frequency difference between them . it is understood that the phase space filling effect does not affect the line profile of the physical spectrum , but it adjusts the heights and positions of the physical spectrum . it is also shown that the number of the peaks in the physical spectrum is reduced with increase in either the detuning quantity or the half - bandwidth of the spectrometer . under the conditions of the low exciton density and the resonant interaction between the cavity field and the excitons , if the half - bandwidth of the spectrometer has the same order as the coupling constant between the cavity field and excitons , then spectrum has two peaks with equal heights . but in the case of higher exciton density or the non - resonant interaction , even if the the half - bandwidth of the spectrometer has the same order as the coupling constant between the cavity field and excitons , the two peaks have different heights due to the interaction between the excitons or the detuning effect . when the system is initially in the superposed state of a single exciton state and two exctions state , the resultant physical spectrum is a simple sum of the spectra of the components of the superposition states . the authors thank m. koashi , a. miranowicz and t. yamamoto for helpful and simulating discussions . yu - xi liu is supported by japan society for the promotion of science ( jsps ) . c. p. sun is supported by nsf of china . this work also is supported by grant - in - aid for scientific research ( b ) ( grant no . 12440111 ) by japan society for the promotion of science . 99 d. a. b. miller , d. s. chemla , d. j. eilenberger , p. w. smith , a. c. gossard , and w. t. tsang , appl . 41 , 679(1982 ) . j. kim , o. benson , h. kan , y. yamamoto , nature 397 , 500(1999 ) a. imamoglu , d. d. awschalom , g. burkard , d. p. divincenzo , d. loss , m. scherwin , a. small , phys . 83 , 4204(1999 ) , m. s. sherwin , a. imamoglu and t. montroy , phys . a60 , 3508(1999 ) daniel loss and david p. divincenzo , phys . a57 , 120(1998 ) , guido burkard , daniel loss , and david p. divincenzo , phys . b59 , 2070(1999 ) . z. wang , x. g. zheng , f. l. zhao , z. l. gao , and z. x. yu , phys . 82 , 2278(1999 ) . j. frenkel , phys . 37 , 17(1931 ) , 1276(1931 ) . g. h. wannier , phys . 52 , 191(1937 ) . k. nishioka , k. tanaka , i. nakamura , y. lee , and m. yaminishi , appl . phys . lett . 63 , 2944(1993 ) . y. yamamoto , s. machida , and g. bjork , phys . a44 , 657(1991 ) . e. burstein and c. weisbuch , confined electrons and photons : new physics and application ( plenum , new york , 1995 ) . c. weibuch , m. nishioka , a. ishikawa , and y. arakawa , phys . 69 , 3314(1992 ) . e. hanamura , phys . rev . 1228(1988 ) . t.itoh , t. ikehara , y. iwabuchi , j. lumin . 45 , 29(1990 ) . s. d. bore and d. a. wiersma , chem . 165 , 45(1990 ) . h. fidder , j. knoester , d. a. wiersma , chem . 171 , 529(1990 ) . h. z. wang , x. g. zheng , l. zhao , z. l. gao , and z. x. yu , phys . 74 , 4079(1995 ) . chang - qi cao , h. cao , yu - xi liu , phys . b62 , 16453(2000);chang - qi cao , hui cao , yu - xi liu , phys . b63 , 199901(2001 ) . yu - xi liu , changqi cao , optics communication , 165 , 53(1999 ) . yu - xi liu , c. p. sun , and s.x . yu , phys . a63 , 023802(2001 ) . g. khitrova , h. m. gibbs , f. jahnke , m. kira , and s. w. koch , rev . 71 , 1571(1999 ) . s. schmitt - rink , d. s. chemla , d. a. b. miller , phys . b32 , 6601(1985 ) e. hanamura , j. inoue , f. yura , j. nonlinear opt . 4 , 13(1995 ) , e. hanamura , j. phys . soc . 29 , 50(1970 ) . e. hanamura and h. haug , phys . rep . * 33 * , 209(1977 ) . jun - ichi inoue , tobias brandes , and akira shimizu , phys . b * 61 * , 2863(2000 ) . l. c. beidenharn and j. d. louch , angular momentum in quantum physics ( addison - wesley , london , 1981 ) . r. j. glauber , phys . 131 , 2766(1963 ) . j. h. eberly , and k. wodkiewice , j. opt . am.67 , 1252(1977 ) . tohya hiroshima , phys . rev . b*40 * , 3862(1989 ) . y. yamamoto , j. jacobson , s. pau , h. cao , and g. bjork , in quantum coherence and decoherence , edited by k. fujikawa and y. a. ono , ( elsevier science , amsterdam , 1996 ) , pp . 331 - 334 .

the non - resonant interaction between the high - density excitons in a quantum well and a single mode cavity field is investigated . an analytical expression for the physical spectrum of the excitons is obtained . the spectral properties of the excitons , which are initially prepared in the number states or the superposed states of the two different number states by the resonant femtosecond pulse pumping experiment , are studied . numerical study of the physical spectrum is carried out and a discussion of the detuning effect is presented . 2

1509.03596

loss of fidelity and decoherence are the twin obstacles to successful applications of quantum information devices . theoreticians like to consider the two separately , while in practical situations both will have destructive effects on quantum information flow . in this spirit it is important to propose a functional definition for the fidelity or better the fidelity amplitude of an open system . to achieve this we shall build on previous work . almost 20 years ago a measurement of the fidelity amplitude in a quantum system was proposed @xcite , though the word itself was not mentioned . a more detailed presentation for a kicked rotor followed years later @xcite , simultaneously with an extensive discussion of the theoretical framework @xcite . the experiment for the kicked rotor was performed successfully in ref . the basic idea is that pure dephasing between a qubit and some system will cause the off diagonal elements or coherences of the density matrix of a pure superposition state of the qubit decay like the fidelity amplitude of the remaining system . our proposition is to follow exactly the same reasoning in the case where the remaining system is open , and thus interpret the decaying coherences as a generalized fidelity amplitude of the intermediate system . for this purpose we have to consider a situation discussed in a previous paper @xcite , where a central system coupled to two nested environments is analyzed to determine the effect of a far environment on the coherence of a central system not interacting directly with the far environment . the intermediate system or `` near environment '' would then be the open system we are analyzing using the qubit as a probe and as the source of the perturbation causing the fidelity decay in the absence of the far environment . our paper will thus fulfill a double purpose : on the one hand we shall introduce a generalized fidelity amplitude and study its behaviour in a `` quantum chaotic '' setting . on the other we shall deepen the understanding of the stabilizing effect on the central system of the coupling of the near environment to a far environment . note that in a previous paper @xcite we introduced pure dephasing between the central system and the near environment , as a simplifying approximation to facilitate calculations , but for the present context this is an essential feature needed in order to establish the relation to fidelity decay of a closed system . considering near and far environment as one closed system , the fidelity amplitude may be expressed as the expectation value of an echo operator @xcite , which describes the forward and backward evolution of an initial state with somewhat different hamiltonians . in the present paper we shall derive a master equation which describes this echo dynamics reduced to the near environment alone . this master equation has the typical structure of master equations of kosakowski - sudarshan - lindblad form @xcite ( henceforth referred to as lindblad equation ) and reduce to lindblad form when the coupling to the central system becomes zero . we then consider the random matrix model already used in ref . @xcite . in that case , the master equation becomes very simple , and allows to obtain a closed integral equation for the generalized fidelity amplitude . we compare the solution of the integral equation with the generalized fidelity amplitude obtained from numerical simulations , and thereby show that the new integral equation applies for a very broad range of coupling strengths between near and far environment . while the random matrix model used here , is much simpler than the one used in ref . @xcite , its effect on the fidelity amplitude is typically indistinguishable . in the next section we shall fix notations and obtain the general master equation for describing the reduced echo dynamics in the near environment . at the end of this section , we derive the master equation for the random matrix model , which is largely equivalent to the model considered in @xcite . in sec . [ n ] we compare the generalized fidelity amplitude obtained from the new integral equation with numerical simulations , and in the last section we draw conclusions . in this section we describe the model in general . the full system consists of three parts , the central system , the near environment and a far environment . in the following section ( sec . [ mh ] ) we start from a hamiltonian formulation , and perform partial traces in order to obtain the reduced dynamics either in the central system or in the near environment . assuming a dephasing coupling between central system and near environment , we can obtain the temporal evolution of the reduced density matrix in the central system , in terms of an asymmetric unitary evolution ( perturbed echo dynamics ) in the composite environment . in sec . [ mm ] we then use the standard born - markov approximation to trace out the far environment , and thereby arrive at a master equation for the reduced echo dynamics in the near environment alone . for the coupling between central system and near environment , we assume that it is of the dephasing type , i.e. that it is given by a single product term , where the factor acting in the central system commutes with the hamiltonian describing the dynamics in the central system . thus , the hamiltonian for this part is given as @xmath0= 0 \ ; . \label{mh : hlambda}\ ] ] this leads to the following expression for the time evolution of the reduced density matrix in the central system @xcite @xmath1 \ ; , \ ] ] which yields for its individual matrix elements ( coherences ) @xmath2 \ ; . \label{mh : fidamp0}\ ] ] here , we use the common eigenbasis of @xmath3 and @xmath4 to express @xmath5 , and therefore the energies @xmath6 and @xmath7 are simply the corresponding eigenvalues of @xmath3 . in what follows we will focus on only one such matrix element , and therefore suppress the indices @xmath8 from now on . we thus set @xmath9 which implies that @xmath10 . this shows that under dephasing coupling , the decoherence in the central system is given by the decay of the fidelity or lohschmidt echo in the near environment . turning the argument the other way around , this shows that it is possible to measure fidelity amplitudes , by coupling the system of interest ( i.e. the near environment ) to a probe system , which at the same time provides the perturbation . such experiments have been proposed and recently realized in different settings using atom interferometry @xcite . [ [ including - the - far - environment ] ] including the far environment + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we now extend the model to include a far environment . we assume the far environment to be as simple as possible and that it allows to be taken into account implicitly in the form of a quantum master equation . hence , we write for the hamiltonian of the full tripartite system : @xmath11 where @xmath12 . here , @xmath13 and @xmath14 are normalized in such a way that @xmath15 gives the magnitude squared of a typical matrix element of the coupling term between near and far environment . with @xmath16 being the average level spacing ( i.e. the inverse level density ) in the spectrum of @xmath17 , we see that @xmath18 is just @xmath19 times the corresponding fermi golden rule transition rate @xcite . finally , @xmath18 itself is related to the decoherence rate for a superposition of @xmath19 states in the near environment . in the simplest case ( see sec . [ n ] ) , @xmath20 is precisely the decay rate of the purity in the intermediate system , in the case where the coupling to the central system is set to zero . within the hamiltonian model described by @xmath21 , the coupling to the far environment requires the following modification to the expression for the fidelity amplitude given in eq . ( [ mh : fidamp0 ] ) : @xmath22 \ ; . \label{mh : fidampgen}\ ] ] differing from the standard formalism , the unitary operators on the left and on the right hand side of the initial state are different . this is why the trace may decrease in time , leading to the loss of coherence for superposition states in the central system @xcite . we follow the standard derivation of the born - markov approximation , e.g. sec . 3.3 of ref . however , due to the asymmetric unitary transformation implied in eq . ( [ mh : fidampgen ] ) , the following derivation requires some care . let us denote the solution in the hilbert space of near and far environment as @xmath23 and thereby introduce @xmath24 as the solution in the interaction picture with respect to the coupling between near and far environment . from the von neumann equation for @xmath25 , @xmath26 we obtain@xmath27 \ ; , \qquad \tilde v_\lambda(t)= { { \rm e}}^{{{\rm i}}h_{\lambda,0}\ , t/\hbar}\ ; v_{{\rm e}}'\otimes v_{\rm f}\ ; { { \rm e}}^{{{\rm i}}h_{0,0}\ , t/\hbar } \ ; . \label{mm : xevolve}\ ] ] the aim of the born - markov approximation ( to be worked out next ) consists in obtaining a master equation for the reduced dynamics in the near environment alone . that is , an evolution equation for @xmath28 $ ] which may not be considered a real quantum state , since for the reasons discussed above , @xmath29 is neither hermitian nor trace - preserving . this quasi - density operator is related to @xmath24 as follows : @xmath30 = { \rm tr}_{\rm f}\big [ u_\lambda(t)\otimes u_{\rm f}(t)\ ; x(t)\ ; u_0(t)^\dagger\otimes u_{\rm f}(t)^\dagger\ , \big ] \ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath31 and @xmath32 , since @xmath33 and @xmath34 are both separable operators . using the identities @xmath35 = a\ ; { \rm tr}_{\rm f } [ x\ , ] \ ; , \quad { \rm tr}_{\rm f}\big [ x\ ; b\otimes\one\ , \big ] = { \rm tr}_{\rm f } [ x\ , ] \ ; b \notag\\ & { \rm tr}_{\rm f}\big [ \one\otimes a\ ; x\ , \big ] = { \rm tr}_{\rm f}\big [ x\ ; \one\otimes a\ , \big ] \ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we find @xmath36\ ; . \label{mm : rhoetilde}\ ] ] [ [ born - markov - approximation ] ] born - markov approximation + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + now , we will formally integrate the differential equation for @xmath24 , eq . ( [ mm : xevolve ] ) , and plug the result back into its right hand side : @xmath37 \notag\\ & \qquad - \gamma\ ; \big [ \ , \varrho_{\rm e , f}(0 ) - \frac{{{\rm i}}\gamma}{\hbar}\int_0^t{{\rm d}}\tau\ ; \big ( \ , \tilde v_\lambda(\tau)\ , x(\tau ) - x(\tau)\ , \tilde v_0(\tau)\ , \big ) \ , \big ] \ ; \tilde v_0(t ) \notag\\ & = \gamma\ ; \big [ \ , \tilde v_\lambda(t)\ ; \varrho_{\rm e , f}(0 ) - \varrho_{\rm e , f}(0)\ ; \tilde v_0(t)\ , \big ] - \frac{{{\rm i}}\gamma^2}{\hbar}\int_0^t{{\rm d}}\tau\ ; \big [ \ , \tilde v_\lambda(t)\ ; \big ( \ , \tilde v_\lambda(\tau)\ , x(\tau ) - x(\tau)\ , \tilde v_0(\tau ) \ , \big ) \notag\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad - \big ( \ , \tilde v_\lambda(\tau)\ , x(\tau ) - x(\tau)\ , \tilde v_0(\tau)\ , \big ) \ ; \tilde v_0(t)\ ; \big ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] the next step consists in taking the partial trace with respect to the far environment . in doing so , we will assume that the first term , which comes before the integral over @xmath38 , will not contribute , i.e. @xmath39 = 0 $ ] . while this is true in the random matrix model , in general it might be necessary to take this term into account . even then it does not present any difficulty , since the term is known before hand . with @xmath40 $ ] , we find @xmath41 \ ; .\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we perform the two crucial approximations : ( i ) the born approximation , which assumes that the influence of the near environment on the state of the far environment is negligible : @xmath42 , and ( ii ) the markov approximation , that the state of the near environment @xmath43 is changing slowly on the time scale of the correlation function @xmath44 . we finally assume that the @xmath44 quickly approaches zero as @xmath45 increases , so that @xmath46 \notag\\ & \qquad = -\ , \frac{\gamma^2}{\hbar^2 } \int_0^\infty{{\rm d}}s\ ; { \rm tr}_{\rm f}\big [ \tilde v_\lambda(t)\ ; \big ( \ , \tilde v_\lambda(t - s)\ , \tilde\varrho_{{\rm e}}(t)\otimes \varrho_{\rm f}(0 ) - \tilde\varrho_{{\rm e}}(t)\otimes \varrho_{\rm f}(0)\ , \tilde v_0(t - s ) \ , \big ) \notag\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad - \big ( \ , \tilde v_\lambda(t - s)\ , \tilde\varrho_{{\rm e}}(t)\otimes \varrho_{\rm f}(0 ) - \tilde\varrho_{{\rm e}}(t)\otimes \varrho_{\rm f}(0)\ , \tilde v_0(t - s)\ , \big ) \ ; \tilde v_0(t)\ ; \big ] \ ; .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this equation is the equivalent of the so called redfield equation @xcite . next , we will consider each term separately and take advantage of the fact that @xmath47 is a tensor product operator with respect to the near and the far environment : @xmath48 such that due to @xmath49 = a\ ; { \rm tr}_{\rm f}[b]$ ] . it is now natural to assume @xmath50 to be diagonal in the eigenbasis of @xmath17 , i.e. @xmath51 = 0 $ ] ( such would be the case for a thermal state ) . then we find @xmath52 with the real function @xmath53 $ ] . going back to the schr " odinger picture , we obtain @xmath54 where @xmath55 in the simplest case , @xmath56 may be approximated by a delta function , such that @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is the area under the function @xmath56 , and the factor @xmath59 comes from the fact that the integral goes only over the positive half axis . in this case , the master equation ( [ mm : mastereqgen ] ) is of lindblad form with the hermitian lindblad operator @xmath60 . note however , that there are many interesting cases , where @xmath56 has a different functional behavior , which then yields a rather unusual dissipation term . [ [ rmt - model ] ] rmt model + + + + + + + + + we here use the approach of constructing the average density matrix proposed in @xcite rather then calculating properties for each member of the ensemble and averaging these properties afterwards . for details see @xcite . let us assume the master equation derived above is of lindblad form with a single lindblad operator @xmath61 . then , we may choose @xmath62 without restriction . let us further assume that @xmath61 is a fixed member of the gaussian orthogonal ( goe ) or unitary ensemble ( gue ) . this may be justified for an environment dominated by chaotic dynamics or disorder . the born - markov approximation used above implies some coarse - graining in time , i.e. averaging over a small time interval . assuming ergodicity , this averaging may be replaced by averaging over the random matrix ensemble . in the case of the gaussian ensembles , it is then enough to use the fact that @xmath63 ( gue ) or @xmath64 ( goe ) , to arrive at the following very simple master equation : @xmath65 the dissipation term of this equation had been obtained previously for a random matrix model where the coupling matrix is a full random matrix in the product hilbert space of near and far environment @xcite . note that eq . ( [ mm : rhoetilde ] ) implies @xmath66 \ ; , \qquad m_\lambda(t)= u_0(t)^\dagger\ , u_\lambda(t ) \ ; .\ ] ] to solve the master equation ( [ mm : rmtmastereq ] ) , we return to the interaction picture and separate off the exponential decay from the solution : @xmath67 \ ; .\ ] ] we now consider the corresponding integral equation @xmath68 \ ; , \ ] ] and define @xmath69 \quad\text{such that}\quad f_{\lambda,\gamma}(t ) = { { \rm e}}^{-\gamma t}\ ; \phi_{\lambda,\gamma}(t ) \ ; .\ ] ] eventually , we are only interested in the generalized fidelity amplitude @xmath70 . it is then convenient to derive an evolution equation for @xmath71 directly . to this end , we multiply the above integral equation with @xmath72 , and take the trace . this yields @xmath73 + \frac{\gamma}{n_{{\rm e}}}\int_0^t{{\rm d}}\tau\ ; { \rm tr}_{{\rm e}}\big [ \ , m_\lambda(t-\tau)\ , \big ] \ ; \phi_{\lambda,\gamma}(\tau)\ ] ] the first term of the rhs is just the fidelity amplitude in the near environment without coupling to the far environment . we will denote this function as @xmath74 . the term @xmath75 $ ] is the same type of fidelity amplitude , just that here the initial state is the maximally mixed state @xmath76 . that function we will denote with @xmath77 . in the numerical simulations in sec . [ n ] we will assume that @xmath78 is the same maximally mixed state , such that @xmath79 . thus , we may write @xmath80 since the integral in this expression is precisely equal to the convolution of the functions @xmath77 and @xmath71 , the equation can be solved formally by a laplace transformation @xcite . it leads to @xmath81 and similarly for @xmath82 . in this expression , the ratio @xmath83^{-1}$ ] can be formally expanded into a power series in @xmath18 , where the inverse laplace transform of powers of @xmath84 and @xmath82 yield iterated convolutions of the original fidelity amplitudes . terminating the series at first order in @xmath18 leads to the approximate expression for @xmath70 derived in @xcite . in practice , it is more convenient to solve the integral equation directly using a numerical equal - stepsize integration scheme . the theoretical curves compared to random matrix calculations in the following section , are obtained via the trapezoidal rule . we noticed that the larger @xmath18 the smaller the required stepsize , which does not allow a straight forward exploration of the large @xmath18 limit . in this section , we verify the integral equation ( [ me : genfidampinteq ] ) for the generalized fidelity amplitude , when the coupling to the far environment can be described by an unitarily invariant dissipation term , see eq . ( [ mm : rmtmastereq ] ) . we have shown that this situation occurs when the dynamics in the near environment can be described by a random matrix ensemble , for instance in the case when the quantum chaos conjecture applies . for the numerical simulations , we use the methodology of ref . @xcite , writing the evolution equation for @xmath29 in super - vector and super - matrix form , and solving the resulting system of differential equations by diagonalization . since the number of equations is of order @xmath85 , we are restricted to relatively small dimensions , @xmath86 . for each case , we perform three independent numerical averages over @xmath87 realizations . this allows to estimate ( roughly ) the statistical uncertainty of the numerical results . to obtain a solution of the integral equation , we employ the method explained at the end of the previous section , which is , as far as precision and computer workload are concerned , equivalent to direct numerical integration . hence , for not to large values of @xmath18 , we can obtain highly accurate results in very short computation times . for the model considered , the fidelity amplitude @xmath88 without far environment , would be given by the universal random matrix result first derived in ref . however , for simplicity we use the exponentiated linear response formula from ref . @xcite . below , we consider two different strengths of the dephasing coupling . in fig . [ fig2-n50-l05 ] this is @xmath89 which corresponds to the cross - over regime where the decay of @xmath88 is intermediate between exponential and gaussian decay . in fig . [ fig3-n50-l01 ] , @xmath90 which corresponds to the perturbative regime where the decay of @xmath88 is dominantly gaussian . in both figures , the time scales are chosen such that the heisenberg time is at @xmath91 . in order to compare the theoretical prediction with the numerical simulations on a finer scale , we will plot the difference between the generalized fidelity amplitude @xmath70 and the fidelity amplitude @xmath74 without coupling to the far environment . subtracted by @xmath92 for @xmath93 and different values of @xmath18 : @xmath94 ( solid line ) , @xmath95 ( dashed line ) , @xmath96 ( dotted line ) , and @xmath97 ( dashed - dotted line ) . the lines show the solutions of eq.([me : genfidampinteq ] ) and the points show the corresponding numerical simulations.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] in fig . [ fig2-n50-l05 ] we can clearly see the influence of the coupling to the far environment , on the coherence measured in the central system . the effect scales with @xmath98 , which , in this figure ranges from @xmath99 to @xmath100 . since the difference plotted is positive and increasing with @xmath101 , we confirm the effect discussed in ref . @xcite , that increasing the coupling to the far environment , stabilizes the coherence in the central system . we also observe , that the theory obtained from eq . ( [ me : genfidampinteq ] ) agrees very well with the numerical simulations for all values of @xmath101 and for all times . subtracted by @xmath92 for @xmath102 and different values of @xmath18 : @xmath103 ( solid line ) @xmath104 ( dashed line ) @xmath105 ( dashed - dotted line ) and @xmath97 ( dashed - dashed - dotted - dotted line ) . the dashed lines show the solutions of eq.([me : genfidampinteq ] ) and the points show the corresponding numerical simulations.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] in fig . [ fig3-n50-l01 ] we repeat the comparison but for the case of @xmath106 , which is well in the perturbative regime , where @xmath88 shows a gaussian decay . again we compare numerical simulations with the theoretical prediction from eq . ( [ me : genfidampinteq ] ) , for different values of @xmath101 . here , these values range from @xmath107 up to @xmath108 . in this range , the stabilizing effect of the coupling to the far environment is even stronger . however , we also observe that the theoretical prediction systematically overestimates the effect , the larger @xmath101 the larger the deviation . we suspect that these deviations might be a finite @xmath19 effect . we have presented a generalized fidelity amplitude , which starts out from the only direct measurement scheme for the fidelity amplitude @xcite , which uses a central system as a probe for the echo dynamics in the environment . we open the system to be probed to an additional outer environment and consider the decay of coherences of the probe . this we define to be proportional to the generalized fidelity amplitude . while this ensures that the quantity is measurable , it remains to be investigated how it relates to other generalizations of fidelity to open systems , such as the one by josza @xcite . we obtain a more general master equation , eq . ( [ mm : mastereqgen ] ) , which may be applied to integrable and non - integrable models for open quantum systems . the random matrix model considered here to illustrate our results , is slightly different from the model considered in @xcite , since there we considered the far environment to be a bath of harmonic oscillators described by the caldeira - leggett model of random brownian motion @xcite . nevertheless , its effect on the near environment is equivalent and can be described by the same unique parameter @xmath18 . we derived a new exact integral equation for the generalized fidelity amplitude , which constitutes significant progress comparing to previous work . expanding this equation to lowest order in @xmath18 leads to the approximate analytical formula obtained in @xcite . in sec . [ n ] , we find that its solution agrees with numerical simulations over a broad range of coupling strengths . this confirms the general experience , that increasing the coupling between near and far environment protects the coherence in the central system . we thank c. pineda and h .- j . stckmann for helpful discussions , and acknowledge the hospitality of the centro internacional de ciencias , where these discussions took place . finally , we acknowledge financial support from conacyt through the grants cb-2009/129309 and 154586 as well as unam / dgapa / papiit ig 101113 . gardiner sa , cirac ji , zoller p. 1997 . quantum chaos in an ion trap : the delta - kicked harmonic oscillator . lett . _ * 79 * , 47904793 . http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.79.4790[doi:10.1103/physrevlett.79.4790 ] . haug f , bienert m , schleich wp , seligman th , raizen mg . motional stability of the quantum kicked rotor : a fidelity approach . a _ * 71 * , 043803 . http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physreva.71.043803[doi:10.1103/physreva.71.043803 ] . gorin t , prosen t , seligman th , strunz wt . connection between decoherence and fidelity decay in echo dynamics . rev . a _ * 70 * , 042105 . http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physreva.70.042105[doi:10.1103/physreva.70.042105 ] . wu s , tonyushkin a , prentiss mg . observation of saturation of fidelity decay with an atom interferometer . lett . _ * 103 * , 034101 . http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.103.034101[doi:10.1103/physrevlett.103.034101 ] . gorin t , prosen t , seligman th , nidari m. 2006 . dynamics of loschmidt echoes and fidelity decay . rep . _ * 435 * , 33156 . http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2006.09.003[doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2006.09.003 ] . andersen mf , kaplan a , davidson n. 2003 . echo spectroscopy and quantum stability of trapped atoms . _ phys . lett . _ * 90 * , 023001 . http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.90.023001[doi:10.1103/physrevlett.90.023001 ] . gorin t , pineda c , kohler h , seligman th . 2008 . a random matrix theory of decoherence . _ new j. phys . _ * 10 * , 115016 . http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/10/11/115016[doi:10.1088/1367-2630/10/11/115016 ] .

we consider a central system which is coupled via dephasing to an open system , i.e. an intermediate system which in turn is coupled to another environment . considering intermediate and far environment as one composite system , the coherences in the central system are given in the form of fidelity amplitudes for a certain perturbed echo dynamics in the composite environment . on the basis of the born - markov approximation , we derive a master equation for the reduction of that dynamics to the intermediate system alone . in distinction to an earlier paper [ arxiv : 1502.04143 ( 2015 ) ] where we discussed the stabilizing effect of the far environment on the decoherence in the central system , we focus here on the possibility to use the measurable coherences in the central system for probing the open quantum dynamics in the intermediate system . we illustrate our results for the case of chaotic dynamics in the near environment , where we compare random matrix simulations with our analytical result . [ [ keywords ] ] keywords + + + + + + + + quantum loschmidt echo , fidelity , open quantum system , master equation , random matrix theory

1512.06553

materials with correlated electrons exhibit some of the most intriguing quantum states in condensed matter physics @xcite . since the number of electric charge carriers essentially determines such states , external electric or light field can be applied for controllable manipulations . stability of electric field or light induced states has been demonstrated in some novel systems , where switching occurs between neighboring equilibrium thermodynamic states @xcite . this powerful characteristic can be applied in electric devices such as transistors and memories , which are of great importance to not only the fundamental physics research but also the information processing technology @xcite . correlated materials with a rich set of quantum states delicately balanced on a similar energy scale will be promising platforms to realize such devices . ( a ) crystal structure of @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . ( b ) top view of ta - ta plane of @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . the unit cells of conventional @xmath0 structure and low temperature ccdw structure are denoted with green solid and dashed lines , respectively . the black hexagrams are the so - called `` david star '' pattern in ccdw phase . ( c ) schematic diagrams of `` david star '' ( left ) , ccdw ( middle ) , and nccdw ( right ) in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . ] the transition metal dichalcogenide ( tmd ) @xmath0-tas@xmath1 is one of the promising candidate due to the multiple competing ground states in it @xcite . as shown in fig . [ fig_1_structure ] ( a ) , @xmath0-tas@xmath1 shows a cdi@xmath1-type layered crystal structure with ta atoms octahedrally coordinated by s atoms . a unit layer consists of one ta layer sandwiched between two s layers . at low temperatures , strong @xmath4-dependent electron - phonon coupling induced periodic lattice distortion makes a @xmath5 superlattice @xcite , in which ta atoms displace to make `` david star '' clusters ( fig . [ fig_1_structure ] ( b ) ) . the outer twelve atoms within each star move slightly towards the atom at the center , leading to the commensurate charge - density - wave ( ccdw ) ground state . in particular , in ccdw state , the correlation effect of @xmath6 electrons of ta atoms turns the system into mott insulating state @xcite . upon heating to 225 k , it undergoes a sequence of first order phase transition to a nearly commensurate ( nc ) cdw . the nccdw phase is composed of metallic incommensurate ( ic ) network and mott insulating ccdw domains . the ccdw domains shrink upon heating and finally disappear at 355 k , while the system transforms to iccdw state . the standard metallic @xmath0 structure appears above 535 k. moreover , when ccdw state is suppressed , superconductivity emerges in this system @xcite . one can expect that the controllable switching between those states will be helpful for figuring out the mechanism of cdw and superconductivity , and realizing the high performance memory and transistor in future technology . to meet this goal , many groups performed investigations on this novel material . yu et al . reported a gate - controlled li ion intercalation can suppress ccdw and introduce superconducivity @xcite . tsen et al . @xcite , hollander et al . @xcite , yoshida et al . @xcite , and mihailovic et al . @xcite reported the in - plane electric field induced transition from ccdw state to nccdw or some metastable hidden state . cho et al . applied perpendicular electric pulse on @xmath0-tas@xmath1 and found positive electric pulse can introduce ic network to suppress mott state at low temperature @xcite . moreover , zhang et al . @xcite , mihailovic et al . @xcite , and han et al . @xcite suggested that light can introduce a transition from ccdw state to nccdw or hidden state as well . in all those manipulations , the transitions are considered to be determined by the charge carrier doping . however , the mechanisms of such transitions are not fully clear yet . in this work , we simulated by first - principles calculations the charge carrier doping effect on cdw in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . we found that ccdw is stable upon electron doping , while hole doping significantly suppresses ccdw instability , implying different mechanisms of recently reported electric and photoelectric manipulations of cdw in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . we figured out such mechanism by analysis of carrier doping effects . furthermore , we show that superconductivity with @xmath2 about @xmath3 k can be introduced by hole doping in the system . the density functional theory ( dft ) calculations were carried out using quantum espresso package @xcite with ultrasoft pseudopotentials . the exchange - correlation interaction was treated with the generalized gradient approximation ( gga ) with pw91 parametrization @xcite . the energy cutoff for the plane - wave basis set was 35 ry . the marzari - vanderbilt fermi smearing method @xcite with a smearing parameter of @xmath7 ry was used for the calculations of the total energy and electron charge density . to simulate the monolayer , a vacuum layer more than 15 @xmath8 was introduced . for the bulk sample , brillouin zone sampling is performed on the monkhorst - pack ( mp ) mesh @xcite of @xmath9 , while a denser @xmath10 grid was used in the electron phonon coupling calculations . phonon dispersions were calculated using density functional perturbation theory ( dfpt ) @xcite with an @xmath11 mesh of @xmath12-points . for the monolayer sample , @xmath13-points grids of @xmath14 and @xmath15 and @xmath12-points grids of @xmath16 are used . since the frequency and stability of soft phonon modes were found to be very sensitive to the plane - wave cutoff for the charge density , a large cutoff of 1500 ry was used for the charge density in the phonon calculations @xcite . all the calculation parameters were well tested . in the investigation of carrier doping effects , the electron / hole doping was simulated by increasing / decreasing the total electron numbers of the system , together with a compensating uniform positive / negative background to maintain the charge neutrality . the crystal structure of each doped sample was optimized with respect to lattice parameters and atomic positions . for comparisons , we also calculated some doped samples by using the lattice parameters of pristine tas@xmath1 and relaxing the atomic positions , as described later . the low symmetry cdw structure is usually considered as the high symmetry phase with distortion introduced by some instability . therefore , we firstly investigated carrier doping effects in the bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . the electronic structures and phonon properties for the samples with different doping level were calculated . as examples , figure [ fig_2_bulk ] shows the calculated band structures and fermi surfaces of the pristine bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 , the doped bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with the doping level of @xmath17 electrons / f.u . , and the doped bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 holes / f.u . as expected , electron doping increases the lattice parameters and hole doping shrinks the lattice ( figs . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( j ) and ( k ) ) . for the pristine tas@xmath1 , our results are of good agreement with the previous calculations @xcite . there is a gap of @xmath18 ev below fermi energy ( @xmath19 ) ( fig . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( b ) ) . in the @xmath20-@xmath21 direction , the two bands around the gap are nearly flat due to the quasi-2d nature of the layered structure . the band above the gap crosses fermi energy ( @xmath19 ) , forming a 2d electron pocket around @xmath22 point ( figs . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( b ) and ( e ) ) . such gap increases upon electron doping and decreases upon hole doping ( figs . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( a ) and ( c ) ) . electron doping increases @xmath19 . as shown in figs . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( a ) and ( d ) , for the doped bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 electrons / f.u . the rise of @xmath19 expands and opens up the original electron pockets around @xmath22 , leaving hole pockets centered at @xmath23 point . besides the original band crossing @xmath19 , a band with higher energy starts to cross @xmath19 , forming a 2d cylinder - like electron pocket around the zone center . on the contrary , the hole doping enhances the dispersion in the @xmath20-@xmath21 direction and weakens the quasi-2d nature by shrinking the lattice and decreasing the interlayer distance . as shown in figs . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( c ) and ( f ) , for the doped bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 holes / f.u . , the bands close to @xmath19 are not flat anymore . hole doping reduces @xmath19 . the decrease of @xmath19 shrinks the original electron pockets around m point . moreover , a lower energy band starts to cross @xmath19 , forming a 3d hole pocket around @xmath20 point . the phonon instability of the high symmetry structure is considered to be directly related to the cdw distortion : at high temperatures , the phonon of the high symmetry structure softens at cdw vector ( @xmath24 ) . above the transition temperature the phonon frequency near @xmath24 drops but does not go to zero . just below the transition temperature the phonon frequency near @xmath24 is imaginary , meaning there is a restructuring of lattice with a superlattice vector of @xmath24 @xcite . therefore , phonon dispersion without imaginary frequency implies that the structure is stable compared to cdw structure . the phonon calculation is proved to be an effective method to simulate the cdw instability : the calculated phonon dispersions show instability just locating at @xmath24 of some tmds @xcite . more specially , for the present @xmath0-tas@xmath1 , experimental report showed cdw can be suppressed by pressure @xcite , which is correctly simulated by liu s phonon calculation @xcite . in this work we also performed the phonon calculations on each sample . for the pristine @xmath0-tas@xmath1 , our calculation is of good agreement with liu s calculation ( fig . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( h ) ) . the phonon dispersion show instability very close to the ccdw vector @xmath25 . this instability persists at all values of @xmath26 , as shown in inset of fig . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( h ) . for the electron doped sample , the acoustic branches become more unstable . as shown in fig . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( g ) , the unstable modes in the doped bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with with @xmath17 electrons / f.u . appear in @xmath23-@xmath22 and @xmath23-@xmath20 directions , indicating the area of instability are largely expanded . on the contrary , the hole doping significantly stabilizes lattice . as shown in fig . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( i ) , no unstable mode can be found in the phonon dispersion of the doped bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 holes / f.u . since the lowest mode in the pristine tas@xmath1 locates near @xmath27 , we used such mode as an indicator of doping effect on ccdw in tas@xmath1 . the frequency variation of such mode under doping is shown in fig . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( l ) . one can note that upon electron doping the mode is always unstable in bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 , while hole doping significantly suppresses the instability . according to our calculation , the lattice becomes completely stable when the doping level is higher than @xmath28 electrons / f.u . since hole doping shrinks the lattice as the high pressure does , we should figure out the suppression of ccdw under hole doping is majorly attributed to whether the lattice compression or to the pure doping effect . we calculated a hypothetic doped @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with n=0.3 holes / f.u . , in which the lattice parameters are fixed to those of the undoped pristine @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . as shown in fig . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( l ) , ccdw can be suppressed by just doping holes into @xmath0-tas@xmath1 without changing its lattice volume . that demonstrates the suppression of ccdw in the present case is predominately by the hole doping effect . furthermore , we investigated the doping induced energy and the distortion variations in the ccdw state for the pristine tas@xmath1 , the doped tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 electrons / f.u . , and the doped tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 holes / f.u . we defined the ccdw formation energy @xmath29 as @xmath30 where @xmath31 and @xmath32 are the total energies of the relaxed ccdw structure and the @xmath0 structure . the distortion rations @xmath33 can be expressed as @xmath34 and @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the in - plane lattice parameter of the undistorted @xmath0 structure , @xmath37 and @xmath37 are radius of the inner and outer circles of `` david star '' , as shown in fig . 3 ( b ) . for @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with ccdw structure , the layers stacking order is not clear yet . therefore , we simply construct the @xmath38 supercell with 39 atoms to simulate the ccdw structure . we relaxed the atomic positions using the lattice parameters @xmath39 and @xmath40 , where @xmath36 and @xmath40 are from figs . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( j ) and ( k ) , respectively . in the relaxed ccdw structures , we found that for the pristine tas@xmath1 and the doped tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 electrons / f.u . [ fig_3_charge ] ( b ) and ( a ) ) , the distortion ratios are large , while the formation energies of those are negative . on the other hand , the distortion ratios of the doped tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 holes / f.u . are nearly zero ( fig . [ fig_3_charge ] ( c ) ) , and the energy difference between the relaxed supercell and the @xmath0 unit cell is very small ( @xmath41 mev ) , i.e. the ccdw structure relaxes to high symmetry @xmath0 structure . we also relaxed the atomic positions with @xmath36 and @xmath40 fixed to those in the pristine tas@xmath42 to prevent the volume variation . with the lattice parameters of the pristine tas@xmath42 , the doped tas@xmath42 with @xmath17 electrons / f.u can be seen as under pressure . however , the ccdw is still stable . on the other hand , without doping introduced volume shrinking , in the doped tas@xmath42 with @xmath17 holes / f.u . the ccdw is still not favorable in energy . such results of the ccdw supercell coincide well with our deductions based on the analysis of the phonon instabilities of the @xmath0 unit cell . if we simply consider that the roles of electron / hole doping on the electronic structures are to increase / decrease @xmath19 , we can estimate the population of the added / removed electrons when electron / hole doping and understand the calculated results more clearly . figure [ fig_3_charge ] ( d ) shows the density of states ( dos ) near @xmath19 of the pristine tas@xmath42 in the ccdw structure calculated directly by dft . based on the integrations of the dos upwards / downwards from @xmath19 , we can see that if one electron is doped into a `` david star '' ( the doping level is equal to @xmath43 electron / f.u . ) , it will be mainly added into the center of the `` david star '' . obviously , it will enhance the clustering of the charge density . therefore , ccdw is stable upon electron doping . on the contrary , doping one hole into a `` david star '' will notably decrease the charge density at the center and inner atoms of the `` david star '' , which will weaken the charge density clustering . therefore , ccdw is suppressed upon hole doping . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the doping effects in the bulk tas@xmath1 investigated using the low symmetry ccdw structure . ( a ) , ( b ) , and ( c ) are the charge density in ta - ta plane of the doped tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 electrons / f.u . , pristine tas@xmath1 , and the doped tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 holes / f.u . , respectively . ( d ) dos of the pristine tas@xmath1 directly calculated in ccdw structure . the colored areas below and above @xmath19 denote the electron density which can be integrated to one electron . the related electron charge densities are plotted in the insets of ( d ) . ] the doping effects in monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . for the doped tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 electrons / f.u . , pristine tas@xmath1 , and the doped tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 holes / f.u . , ( a ) , ( b ) , and ( c ) are the band dispersions of those samples , ( d ) , ( e ) , and ( f ) are the fermi surfaces , and ( g ) , ( h ) , and ( i ) are the phonon dispersions , respectively . the red dashed lines show the phonon dispersion of undoped monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with tensile strain of 5% . ] schematic picture of suppression of ccdw by hole doping . ( a ) the situation of tas@xmath1 in the ccdw state when holes are doped locally . the solid orange `` david stars '' are the area under ccdw distortion . the hollow orange `` david stars '' are the area in which only one hole per a `` david star '' is doped , which are still under ccdw distortion . the dashed light orange `` david stars '' are the area with more doped holes , in which the ccdw distortion is fully suppressed . the black arrows denote the diffusion of the doped holes . ( b ) the schematic band structure of tas@xmath1 with ccdw distortion . ( c ) the schematic band structure of tas@xmath1 with ccdw distortion when one hole per `` david star '' is doped . ( d ) the schematic band structure of tas@xmath1 in @xmath0 structure . ] we also investigate the doping effect in monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . as examples , fig . [ fig_4_monolayer ] shows the calculated electronic structures and phonon properties of the monolayer pristine tas@xmath1 , the doped tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 electrons / f.u . , and the doped tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 holes / f.u in @xmath0 structure . for the undoped pristine monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 , the band structure is similar to that of pristine bulk sample . one band crosses @xmath19 , forming a 2d electron pocket around @xmath22 point ( figs . [ fig_4_monolayer ] ( b ) and ( e ) ) . there is a gap of 0.8 ev below the band crossing @xmath19 . in the electrons and holes doped monolayer samples , the gap slightly changes , which is different from the case of bulk samples . for the doped monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 electrons / f.u . , the band structure is slightly different from that of the doped bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 electrons / f.u . [ fig_4_monolayer ] ( a ) ) . although @xmath19 changes with electron doping , there is still only one band crossing @xmath19 . the 2d cylinder - like electron pocket in the doped bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 electrons / f.u . does not appear in monolayer sample ( fig . [ fig_4_monolayer ] ( d ) ) . for the doped monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath17 holes / f.u . , there is only one band crossing @xmath19 ( fig . [ fig_4_monolayer ] ( c ) ) . similar to the case of bulk samples , the phonon calculation shows that the cdw instability in the monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 can not be suppressed by electron doping ( fig . [ fig_4_monolayer ] ( g ) ) , while it can be suppressed under hole doping ( fig . [ fig_4_monolayer ] ( i ) ) . the result indicates the suppression of ccdw in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 is not due to the hole doping enhanced band dispersion along @xmath20-@xmath21 direction ( figs . [ fig_2_bulk ] ( c ) and ( f ) ) . the suppression should be attributed to the weakening of the electron - phonon coupling at @xmath24 upon hole doping . besides , one may note in the monolayer sample , a small instability near @xmath20 can be found in the phonon dispersion ( fig . [ fig_4_monolayer ] ( h ) ) . in a very recent calculation of phonon dispersion of monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 by zhang et al . @xcite , there is a similar instability near @xmath20 . such instability is consistent with the instability against long - wavelength transversal waves @xcite . this instability is suggest to be fixed by defects , such as ripples or grain boundaries , which do not allow these waves by limiting the size @xcite . furthermore , we found tensile strain can suppress such instability near @xmath20 , which can be easily applied to monolayer materials @xcite . as an example , in fig . [ fig_4_monolayer ] ( h ) , the red dashed lines show the phonon dispersion of @xmath0-tas@xmath1 under a tensile strain of 5% , in which the instability near @xmath20 is suppressed . the observation indicates that the application of tensile strain is helpful for stabilizing the experimentally exfoliated monolayer or fewlayer @xmath0-tas@xmath42 . based on our calculations of phonon properties in @xmath0 structure , ccdw formation energies and distortion ratios in ccdw structure , we can conclude that when the doping level is above @xmath28 holes / f.u . ( 2.6 holes per a `` david stars '' ) , ccdw can be completely suppressed in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 for bulk and monolayer , i.e. all the `` david stars '' should be melted . experimentally , holes can directly be introduced by a positive electric field perpendicular to the sample @xcite , or by light @xcite . one can expect that in reality the doped holes will firstly distribute in a local area and gradually diffuse out , i.e. even the doping level might be much lower than 0.2 holes / f.u . , in the local area , the doping level could be high enough to melt the `` david stars '' in this area and destroy the long - range ccdw , as shown in fig . [ fig_5_hole_mechanism ] ( a ) . we describe the possible picture of such process here : in @xmath0 structure , the electronic structure near @xmath19 are formed predominantly from a single ta @xmath44 band , which splits into subbands by the formation of ccdw state . six of these subbands are fulfilled with 12 electrons per new ccdw unit cell , forming a manifold of occupied states . the 13th leftover electron is localized on the central ta atom of the `` david stars '' , forming a half - filled subband at @xmath19 . this half - filled subband further splits by the coulomb interaction into upper and lower hubbard bands ( uhb and lhb ) , as shown in fig . [ fig_5_hole_mechanism ] ( b ) . light or positive perpendicular electric filed can firstly excite one electron from lhb to uhb , and create one hole in lhb ( fig . [ fig_5_hole_mechanism ] ( c ) ) . in real space , the hole doped by light or positive perpendicular electric filed locates at the center of the `` david stars '' , leaving a polaron with an excess charge . the other 12 electrons in this polaron are still star - shaped around the central , thus screening the excess charge . when more holes are doped into the `` david stars '' , the ccdw distortion is suppressed locally , the structure transforms into @xmath0 in the doping area . the splitting subbands merge to a single band again ( fig . [ fig_5_hole_mechanism ] ( d ) ) . in this case , the `` david stars '' shaped clusters are annihilated and can not screen the holes any more . so the holes diffuse into neighboring `` david stars '' . therefore , upon hole doping in @xmath0-tas@xmath42 in ccdw phase , ccdw should firstly transform to a nccdw or metastable phase composed of ccdw domains and iccdw network . for example , cho et al . @xcite applied a very small positive perpendicular voltage pulse on @xmath0-tas@xmath1 single crystal sample within a typical scanning tunneling microscope ( stm ) set - up . since local hole concentration under the stm tip is largely enhanced , a pulse creates a textured cdw domain of a few tens of nanometers with an irregular domain wall network inside . they considered that such network is consistent with those in the thermally excited nccdw phase @xcite . besides , di / dv measured implies the weakening and broadening of the hubbard states together with the reduction of the mott gap inside the textured cdw domain induced by positive perpendicular electric filed @xcite . that is corresponding to our picture : holes diffuse from the domain wall into the neighboring area inside the domain . although the concentration of the diffused holes is not high enough to suppress ccdw distortion inside the domain , it can create the hole - electron pair in lhb and uhb to reduce the mott gap . moreover , the photoexcitation of electrons can be considered as directly doping holes into system . mihailovic s group found a laser pulse can introduce a transition from ccdw to a hidden state in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 thin flake @xcite . the raman spectrum of such hidden state is completely different from that in ccdw and nccdw phases @xcite . such hidden state is demonstrated to be a metastable phase , which is different from nccdw , but should be composed of ccdw domains and iccdw network as well @xcite . han et al . observed the electron diffraction spots varies from ccdw case to iccdw case when applying laser to tas@xmath1 in ccdw phase @xcite . very recently , zhang et al . showed laser can introduce a ccdw - nccdw transition in bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 single crystal @xcite . on the other hand , in experiments upon hole doping in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 in high temperature phase , the ccdw transition temperature is significantly lowered @xcite . both the two kinds of structural evidences can be well explained by our calculation . for the sake of illustration we draw , we drew a schematic diagram to describe the mechanism of the hole doping induced ccdw - nccdw / metastable phase transition , as shown in figs . [ fig_6_mechanism ] ( a ) , ( b ) and ( c ) . in the pristine @xmath0-tas@xmath1 , ccdw phase has the lowest energy ( fig . [ fig_6_mechanism ] ( a ) ) . the hole doping by perpendicular field or by light can stabilize lattice and largely increase the energy of ccdw phase . in this case , the system transforms to nccdw or other metastable phase ( figs . [ fig_6_mechanism ] ( b ) and ( c ) ) . on the other hand , according to our calculation , ccdw lattice distortion is stable upon electron doping . according to the report by cho et al . , negative perpendicular voltage pulses could not make change in ccdw state @xcite , which is consistent with our estimation . however , some recent experimental works suggest the opposite results . doped electron into @xmath0-tas@xmath1 by intercalation of li ions and found ccdw can be suppressed @xcite . the intercalated ions can not only carry electrons , but also strongly influence the lattice structures and induce disorder , which can suppress cdw in tmds @xcite . therefore , one can not simply attribute the suppression to the electron doping . to demonstrate the pure electron doping effect on cdw , more direct doping experiments by negative perpendicular electric field or liquid - gated method should perform . some works reported the suppression of ccdw by in - plane electric field @xcite . by measuring the temperature dependence of resistivity ( @xmath45 ) , yoshida et al . found the in - plane field can not affect the nccdw / iccdw transition in @xmath45 curve , but can introduce a metastable state with very low resistivity at low temperatures @xcite . if we consider that the @xmath45 in ccdw , nccdw , and iccdw reflects the related structural characteristics , one can infer that the in - plane field induced the metastable state with different structural characteristics , i.e. the in - plane field can suppress ccdw distortion as well . the suppressions of ccdw by the in - plane field are usually explained as electron injection effect @xcite . however , according to our calculation , ccdw could be stable upon electron doping . therefore , the effect of in - plane field should be more complex . we consider some potential mechanisms of the suppressions by in - plane field : besides the pure charge carrier injection , one can expect that the in - plane electric field can also force the electrons in the `` david star '' to be delocalized . moreover , the in - plane electric field might depinning the cdw , which is suggested in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 bulk single crystals @xcite . the suppression of ccdw by in - plane electric field might also be due to the thermal activation by local joule heating as current flows through the material . the real mechanism of the suppression of ccdw by in - plane field needs to be figured out by more experimental and theoretical works . here we only offer a general description of such process : although ccdw state might still have the lower energy , the in - plane electric field can drive the system to cross over the energy barrier from ccdw to nccdw or other metastable phase , as shown in the schematic diagram in fig . [ fig_6_mechanism ] ( d ) . eliashberg function ( left ) and the integrated electron - phonon coupling strength ( right ) for ( a ) the doped bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath46 holes / f.u . and ( b ) the doped monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath47 holes / f.u . under a tensile strain of 2.5% , respectively . ] as described above , once long range ccdw is suppressed , the transition between mott insulating state to metallic state can be observed : when ccdw is suppressed , domain walls show up , which can be seen as conducting channels to induce metallic state @xcite . in the ccdw area near the domain walls , the hubbard states are weakening and broadening and the mott gap is reduced . @xcite . furthermore , superconductivity can emerge in percolated metallic ic network @xcite . while we are not able to directly model the textured ic phase , we can still estimate the superconductivity using @xmath0 structure qualitatively . approximately using the high symmetry doped bulk @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath46 holes / f.u . and the doped monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 with @xmath47 holes / f.u . under a tensile strain of 2.5% , for which all the phonon instabilities are just suppressed , we estimated the potential carrier doping induced superconductivity by the electron - phonon coupling calculation . figure [ fig_7_a2f ] shows the calculated eliashberg spectral function @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the density of states at @xmath19 , @xmath50 is phonon frequency , @xmath51 is electronic energy , and @xmath52 is electron - phonon coupling matrix element . the total electron - phonon coupling strength is then @xmath53 the calculated @xmath54 for the two samples are 0.81 and 0.96 , respectively . we estimated @xmath2 based on the modified mcmillan formula @xcite : @xmath55 where the coulomb pseudopotential @xmath56 is set to a typical value of @xmath57 . the logarithmically averaged characteristic phonon frequency @xmath58 is defined as @xmath59 the calculated @xmath58 for the two samples are 136.7 and 98.4 k , respectively . using those parameters , we can estimate that the superconductivity with @xmath2 of @xmath3 k can emerge in the hole doped @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . to observe the superconductivity we predicted , the doping induced metallic network between ccdw domain in nccdw or other metastable phase must be percolated , which requires experimental devices with ability to dope more holes . recently , suda et al . suggested a high level hole doping technique using photoactive electric double layer @xcite , which might be applied to verify our prediction . in conclusion , based on the first - principles calculation , we simulated the carrier doping effect in the bulk and monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . we found that ccdw is stable upon electron doping , while hole doping can notably suppress the ccdw . according to our analysis , the different mechanisms of the reported electric and photoelectric manipulations of ccdw in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 are figured out : light or positive perpendicular electric field induced hole doping significantly increases the energy of ccdw , so that the system transforms to nccdw or similar metastable state . although the ccdw distortion is more stable upon the in - plane electric field induced electron injection , some accompanied effects can drive the system to cross over the energy barrier from ccdw to nccdw or similar metastable state . we also estimated that a potential superconductivity with @xmath2 of @xmath3 k can be introduced by hole doping in the system . by tuning the carrier density , controllable switching of different states such as ccdw / mott insulating state , metallic state , and even the superconducting state can be realized in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 , which makes the novel material have a very promising application in the future electronic devices . we thank prof . z. g. sheng and dr . y. z. zhang for helpful discussion . this work was supported by the national key research and development program under contract no . 2016yfa0300404 , the national nature science foundation of china ( grant no . 11674326 , 11304320 , 11274311 , 11404340 , 1408085ma11 , and u1232139 ) . 10 m. imada , a. fujimori , and y. tokura , rev . 70 , 1039 ( 1998 ) . e. dagotto , rev . 66 , 763 ( 1994 ) . p. a. lee , n. nagaosa , and x. -g . wen , rev . 78 , 17 ( 2006 ) . h. ohno , d. chiba , f. matsukura , t. omiya , e. abe , t. dietl , y. ohno , and k. ohtani , nature 408 , 944 ( 2000 ) . y. yamada , k. ueno , t. fukumura , h. t. yuan , h. shimotani , y. iwasa , l. gu , s. tsukimoto , y. ikuhara , and m. kawasaki , science 332 , 1065 ( 2011 ) . r. e. glover , iii and m. d. sherrill , phys . lett . 5 , 248 ( 1960 ) . n. takubo , y. ogimoto , m. nakamura , h. tamaru , m. izumi , and k. miyano , phys . 95 , 017404 ( 2005 ) . a. zakery , s. r. elliott , optical nonlinearities in chalcogenide glasses and their applications ( springer , new york , 2007 ) . m. nakano , k. shibuya , d. okuyama , t. hatano , s. ono , m. kawasaki , y. iwasa , and y. tokura , nature 487 , 459 ( 2012 ) . j. a. wilson , f. j. di salvo , and s. mahajan , adv . 24 , 117 ( 1975 ) . a. y. liu , phy . b 79 , 220515(r ) ( 2009 ) . y. ge and amy y. liu , phy . rev . 155133 ( 2010 ) . y. liu , d. f. shao , l. j. li , w. j. lu , x. d. zhu , p. tong , r. c. xiao , l. s. ling , c. y. xi , l. pi , h. f. tian , h. x. yang , j. q. li , w. h. song , x. b. zhu , y. p. sun , phys . b 94 , 045131 ( 2016 ) . p. darancet , a. j. millis , and c.a . marianetti , phys . b 90 , 045134 ( 2014 ) . r. ang , y. tanaka , e. ieki , k. nakayama , t. sato , l. j. li , w. j. lu , y. p. sun , and t. takahashi , phys . 109 , 176403 ( 2012 ) . r. ang , y. miyata , e. ieki , k. nakayama , t. sato , y. liu , w. j. lu , y. p. sun , and t. takahashi , phys . b 88 , 115145 ( 2013 ) . b. sipos , a. f. kusmartseva , a. akrap , h. berger , l. forr , and e. tuti , nature mater . 7 , 960 ( 2008 ) . y. liu , r. ang , w. j. lu , w. h. song , l. j. li , and y. p. sun , appl . 102 , 192602 ( 2013 ) . l. j. li , w. j. lu , x. d. zhu , l. s. ling , z. qu , and y. p. sun , europhys . 97 , 67005 ( 2012 ) . y. yu , f. yang , x. f. lu , y. j. yan , y. -h . cho , l. ma , x. niu , s. kim , y. -w . son , d. feng , s. li , s. -w . cheong , x. h. chen , and y. zhang , nat . 10 , 270 ( 2015 ) . a. w. tsen , r. hovden , d. wang , y. d. kim , j. okamoto , k. a. spoth , y. liu , w. j. lu , y. p. sun , j. hone , l. f. kourkoutis , p. kim , and a. n. pasupathy , pnas 8 , 15054(2015 ) . m. j. hollander , y. liu , w. j. lu , l. j. li , y. p. sun , j. a. robinson , and s. datta , nano lett . 15 , 1861 ( 2015 ) . masaro yoshida , ryuji suzuki , yijin zhang , masaki nakano , and yoshihiro iwasa , sci . adv . 1 , e1500606 ( 2015 ) . i. vaskivskyi , i. a. mihailovic , s. brazovskii , j. gospodaric , t. mertelj , d. svetin , p. sutar and d. mihailovic , arxiv:1409,3794 ( 2014 ) . i. vaskivskyi , j. gospodaric , s. brazovskii , d. svetin , p , sutar , e. goreshnik , i. a. mihailovic , t. mertelj , and d. mihailovic , sci . adv . 1 , e1500168 ( 2015 ) . d. cho , s. cheon , k. -s . kim , s. -h . lee , y. -h . cho , s. -w . cheong , and h. w. yeom , nature comm . 7 , 10453 ( 2016 ) . y. z. zhang , z. g. sheng , et al . , private communication . l. stojchevska , i. vaskivskyi , t. mertelj , p. kusar , d. svetin , s. brazovskii , and d. mihailovic , science 344 , 177 ( 2014 ) . t. -r . t. han , f.zhou , c. d. malliakas , p. m. duxbury , s. d. mahanti , m. g. kanatzidis , and c. -y . ruan , sci . adv . 1 , e1400173 ( 2015 ) . p. giannozzi , et al . , j. phys . : condens . matter 21 , 395502 ( 2009 ) . j. p. perdew , j. a. chevary , s. h. vosko , k. a. jackson , m. r. pederson , d. j. singh , and c. fiolhais , phys . rev . b 46 , 6671 ( 1992 ) . n. marzari , d. vanderbilt , a. de vita , and m. c. payne , phys . 82 , 3296 ( 1999 ) . h. j. monkhorst and j. d. pack , phys . b 13 , 5188 ( 1976 ) . s. baroni , s. de gironcoli , a. dal corso , and p. giannozi , rev . 73 , 515 ( 2001 ) . m. d. johannes , i. i. mazin , and c. a. howells , phys . rev . b 73 , 205102 ( 2006 ) . c. battaglia , h. cercellier , f. clerc , l. despont , m. g. garnier , c. koitzsch , p. aebi , h. berger , l. forr , and c. ambrosch - draxl , phys . b 72 , 195114 ( 2005 ) . r. bianco , m. calandra and f. mauri , phys . b 92 , 094107 ( 2015 ) . q. zhang , l. -y . gan , y. cheng , and u. schwingenschlcgl , phys . b 90 , 081103(r ) ( 2014 ) . s. cahangirov , m. topsakal , e. aktrk , h. ahin , and s. ciraci , phys . 102 , 236804 ( 2009 ) . h.ahin , s. cahangirov , m. topsakal , e. bekaroglu , e. akturk , r. t. senger , and s. ciraci , phys . b 80 , 155453 ( 2009 ) . a. j. mannix , x. -f . zhou , b. kiraly , j. d. wood , d. alducin , b. d. myers , x. liu , b. l. fisher , u. santiago , j. r. guest , m. jose yacaman , a. ponce , a. r. oganov , m. c. hersam , and n. p. guisinger , science 350 , 1513 ( 2015 ) . m. a. bissett , s. konabe , s. okada , m. tsuji , and h. ago , acs nano 7 , 10335 ( 2013 ) . s. -i . park , j. -h . ahn , x. feng , s. wang , y. huang , and j. a. rogers , adv . 18 , 2673 ( 2008 ) . e. morosan , h. w. zandbergen , b. s. dennis , j. w. g. bos , y. onose , t. klimczuk , a. p. ramirez , n. p. ong and r. j. cava , nature phys . 2 , 544 ( 2006 ) . k. e. wagner , e. morosan , y. s. hor , j. tao , y. zhu , t. sanders , t. m. mcqueen , h. w. zandbergen , a. j. williams , d. v. west , and r. j. cava , phys . b 78 , 104520 ( 2008 ) .

the transition metal dichalcogenide ( tmd ) @xmath0-tas@xmath1 exhibits a rich set of charge density wave ( cdw ) orders . recent investigations suggested that using light or electric field can manipulate the commensurate ( c ) cdw ground state . such manipulations are considered to be determined by the charge carrier doping . here we simulate by first - principles calculations the carrier doping effect on ccdw in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 . we investigate the charge doping effects on the electronic structures and phonon instabilities of @xmath0 structure and analyze the doping induced energy and distortion ratio variations in ccdw structure . we found that both in bulk and monolayer @xmath0-tas@xmath1 , ccdw is stable upon electron doping , while hole doping can significantly suppress the ccdw , implying different mechanisms of such reported manipulations . light or positive perpendicular electric field induced hole doping increases the energy of ccdw , so that the system transforms to nccdw or similar metastable state . on the other hand , even the ccdw distortion is more stable upon in - plain electric field induced electron injection , some accompanied effects can drive the system to cross over the energy barrier from ccdw to nearly commensurate ( nc ) cdw or similar metastable state . we also estimate that hole doping can introduce potential superconductivity with @xmath2 of @xmath3 k. controllable switching of different states such as ccdw / mott insulating state , metallic state , and even the superconducting state can be realized in @xmath0-tas@xmath1 , which makes the novel material have very promising applications in the future electronic devices .

nucl-th0201042

the in - medium properties of the vector mesons ( @xmath1 and @xmath0 ) in hot and dense matter have an important role to play in the low mass dilepton production resulting from heavy ion collision experiments . this has , hence , been a topic of great interest in the recent past , both experimentally @xcite and theoretically @xcite . the experimental observation of enhanced dilepton production @xcite in the low invariant mass regime could be due to a reduction in the vector meson masses in the medium . brown and rho suggested the hypothesis that the vector meson masses drop in the medium according to a simple ( br ) scaling law @xcite , given as @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the pion decay constant and asterisk refers to in - medium quantities . in the framework of quantum hadrodynamics ( qhd ) as a description of the hot hadronic matter , it is seen that the dropping of the vector meson masses has its dominant contribution arising from the vacuum polarisation effects from the baryon sector @xcite , which is not observed in the mean field approximation . this means that the quantum effects do play an important role in the medium modification of vector meson properties . there have also been approaches based on qcd sum rules @xcite which confirm a scaling hypothesis @xcite as suggested by brown and rho , with a saturation scheme that leads to a delta function at the vector meson pole and a continuum for higher energies for the hadronic spectral function . it is , however , seen that such a simple saturation scheme for finite densities does not work and a more realistic description for the hadronic spectral function is called for @xcite . using an effective lagrangian model to calculate the hadronic spectral function , it is seen that such a universal scaling law is not suggested for in - medium vector meson masses @xcite . the medium modifications of the vector mesons have been thus a subject of several investigations . it has been emphasized in the literature @xcite that the properties of the hadrons are modified due to their interactions with the thermal bath , and such modifications are reflected in the dilepton and photon spectra emitted from a hot and dense matter @xcite . dileptons are interesting probes for the study of evolving matter arising from relativistic heavy ion collisions since they do not interact strongly and escape unthermalized from the hot and dense matter at all stages of the evolution . the temperature @xcite and density @xcite modifications of the dileptons from hot hadronic matter as well as from a quark gluon plasma ( qgp ) resulting from heavy ion collisions have been a subject of extensive investigations in the recent past . broadly , two types of modifications for the hadrons in the medium are expected : shift in the pole position for the hadron propagator , giving rise to a modification of the mass , and broadening of the spectral function . in the present work , we shall attempt to study the medium modification of vector meson masses and decay widths in the hot hadronic matter within the framework of quantum hadrodynamics ( qhd ) taking the vacuum polarisation effects into account , and their subsequent effect on the dilepton spectra . in the conventional hadronic models @xcite , the masses of the vector mesons stay constant or increase slightly , in the mean field approximation , i.e. , when the polarization from the dirac sea is neglected @xcite . with the inclusion of quantum corrections from the baryonic sector , however , in the walecka model one observes a drop in the vector meson masses in the medium @xcite . this medium modification of the vector meson masses plays an important role in the enhanced dilepton yield @xcite for masses below the @xmath1 resonance in the heavy ion collision experiments @xcite . it has been emphasized recently that the dirac sea contribution ( taken into account through summing over baryonic tadpole diagrams in the relativistic hartree approximation ( rha ) ) dominates over the fermi sea contribution and @xmath4 is caused by a large dressing of @xmath5 cloud in the medium @xcite . further quantum effects arising from the scalar mesons have been considered @xcite along with the rha for the baryon sector in the context of vector meson mass modifications in strange hadronic matter @xcite . the present method is a step in that direction of studying medium modifications of the vector meson properties including such quantum effects from the scalar mesons in a self consistent manner , along with those arising from the baryon sector . it was earlier demonstrated in a nonperturbative formalism that a realignment of the ground state with baryon - antibaryon condensates is equivalent to the relativistic hartree approximation @xcite . the ground state for the nuclear matter was extended to include sigma condensates to take into account the quantum correction effects from the scalar meson sector @xcite . such a formalism includes multiloop effects and is self consistent @xcite . the methodology was then generalized to consider hot nuclear matter @xcite as well as to the situation of hyperon - rich dense matter @xcite relevant for neutron stars . the effect of vacuum polarisations on the vector meson masses has also been recently studied @xcite . in the present work , we study the effect of such quantum corrections on the in - medium vector meson properties . this apart , for studying @xmath1 meson properties , we take into account the @xmath1-@xmath6-@xmath6 interactions , and their effects on the dilepton production in the low invariant mass regime . the pionic interactions are seen to modify the @xmath1 meson mass only marginally , as already stated in the literature @xcite . due to scalar meson contributions , there is broadening in the @xmath0 and @xmath1 peaks , as compared to rha . this is seen to be quite pronounced for the @xmath0 meson , which leads to smearing and ultimate disappearance of the @xmath0 peak at finite densities @xcite . we organize the paper as follows . we first briefly recapitulate the nonperturbative framework used for studying the quantum correction effects in hot nuclear matter in section ii . the medium modification of the @xmath0 and @xmath1 meson masses and decay widths are considered in section iii . we discuss the effect of these medium modifications on the low mass dilepton spectra in section iv . in section v , we summarize the results of the present work and give an outlook . we briefly recapitulate here the vacuum polarisation effects arising from the nucleon and scalar meson fields in hot nuclear matter in a nonperturbative variational framework @xcite . the method of thermofield dynamics ( tfd ) @xcite is used here to study the ground state " ( the state with minimum thermodynamic potential ) at finite temperature and density within the walecka model with a quartic scalar self interaction . the temperature and density dependent baryon and sigma masses are also calculated in a self - consistent manner in the formalism . the ansatz functions involved in such an approach are determined through functional minimisation of the thermodynamic potential . the lagrangian density in the walecka model is given as @xmath7 in the above , @xmath8 , @xmath9 , and @xmath10 are the fields for the nucleon , @xmath9 , and @xmath0 mesons with masses @xmath11 , @xmath12 , and @xmath13 respectively . since we are interested in symmetric nuclear matter , the isovector rho meson does not contribute . the quartic coupling term in @xmath9 is necessary for the sigma condensates to exist , through a vacuum realignment @xcite . our calculations thus include the quantum effects arising from the sigma meson in addition to the mean field contribution from the the quartic self interaction of the scalar meson . we retain the quantum nature of both the nucleon and the scalar meson fields , whereas the vector @xmath0 meson is treated as a classical field , using the mean field approximation for the @xmath0 meson , given as @xmath14 . the reason is that without higher order term for the @xmath0 meson , the quantum effects generated due to the @xmath0 meson through the present variational ansatz turn out to be zero . we then write down the expressions for the thermodynamic quantities including the quantum effects . the details regarding the formalism can be found in earlier references @xcite . the energy density , after carrying out the renormalisation procedures for the baryonic and scalar meson sectors @xcite , is obtained as @xmath15 with @xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath18 @xmath19 as the mean field result , contribution from the dirac sea , and contributions from the @xmath0 and @xmath9 mesons , respectively . we might note here that the quantum effects arising here from the scalar meson sector through @xmath9 meson condensates amounts to a sum over a class of multiloop diagrams and , does not correspond to the one meson loop approximation for scalar meson quantum effects considered earlier @xcite . in the above , @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the thermal distribution functions for the baryons and antibaryons , given in terms of the effective energy , @xmath22 , and the effective chemical potential , @xmath23 . @xmath24 is the effective nucleon mass and @xmath25 is the baryon number density after subtracting out the vacuum contribution . the spin - isospin degeneracy factor is @xmath26 for symmetric nuclear matter . in the expression for the energy density arising from the scalar meson sector , the field dependent effective sigma mass , @xmath27 , satisfies the gap equation in terms of the renormalised parameters as @xmath28 where @xmath29 where @xmath30 . the effective meson mass @xmath31 is determined through a self consistent solution of eq . ( [ mm2 ] ) . in eq . ( [ vph0 ] ) , @xmath32 and @xmath33 are the expressions as given by eqs . ( [ mm2 ] ) and ( [ if ] ) with @xmath34 . we might note here that the gap equation given by eq . ( [ mm2 ] ) is identical to that obtained through resumming the daisy and superdaisy graphs @xcite and hence includes higher order corrections from the scalar meson field in a self - consistent manner . extremisation of the thermodynamic potential , @xmath35 , with respect to the meson fields @xmath36 and @xmath37 yields the self consistency conditions for @xmath36 ( and hence for the effective nucleon mass @xmath38 ) and for the vector meson field @xmath37 . we now examine the medium modification to the masses and decay widths of the @xmath0 and @xmath1 mesons including the quantum correction effects in hot nuclear matter in the relativistic random phase approximation . the interaction vertices for these mesons with nucleons are given as @xmath39 where @xmath40 or @xmath41 , @xmath42 is the free nucleon mass , @xmath8 is the nucleon field and @xmath43 or @xmath44 , @xmath45 being the pauli matrices . @xmath46 and @xmath47 correspond to the couplings due to the vector and tensor interactions for the corresponding vector mesons to the nucleon fields . the vector meson self energy is expressed in terms of the nucleon propagator , @xmath48 modified by the quantum effects . this is given as @xmath49,\ ] ] where @xmath50 is the isospin degeneracy factor for nuclear matter , and @xmath51 represents the meson - nucleon vertex function . the vector meson self energy can be written as the sum of two parts @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the contribution arising from the vacuum polarisation effects , described by the coupling to the @xmath54 excitations and @xmath55 is the density dependent contribution to the vector self energy . for the @xmath0 meson , the tensor coupling is generally small as compared to the vector coupling to the nucleons @xcite , and is neglected in the present work . the feynman part of the self energy , @xmath56 is divergent and needs renormalization . we use dimensional regularization to separate the divergent parts and the renormalization condition @xmath57 . because of the tensor interaction , the vacuum self energy for the @xmath1 meson is not renormalizable . we employ a phenomenological subtraction procedure @xcite to extract the finite part using the renormalization condition @xmath58 , with ( @xmath59 ) . the effective mass of the vector meson is obtained by solving the equation , with @xmath60 , @xmath61 the decay width for the process @xmath62 is calculated from the imaginary part of the self energy using the cutkosky rule , and in the rest frame of the @xmath1 meson is given by @xmath63 \label { gmrho}\ ] ] where , @xmath64^{-1}$ ] is the bose - einstein distribution function . the first and the second terms in the equation ( [ gmrho ] ) represent the decay and the formation of the resonance , @xmath1 . the medium effects have been shown to play a very important role for the @xmath1 meson decay width . in the calculation for the @xmath1 decay width , the pion has been treated as free , and any modification of the pion propagator due to effects such as delta - nucleon hole excitation @xcite to yield a finite decay width for the pion , have not been taken into account . the coupling @xmath65 is fixed from the decay width of @xmath1 meson in vacuum ( @xmath66=151 mev ) decaying to two pions . for the nucleon - rho couplings , we use the vector and tensor couplings as obtained from the n - n forward dispersion relation @xcite . with the couplings as described above , we consider the temperature and density dependence of the @xmath0 and @xmath1 meson properties in the hot nuclear matter due to quantum correction effects . to calculate the decay width for the @xmath0 meson , we write down the effective lagrangian for the @xmath0 meson as @xcite @xmath67 in the above , the first term refers to the direct coupling of the vector meson @xmath0 to the photon , and hence to the dilepton pairs , as given by the vector dominance model . the decay width of the @xmath0 meson in vacuum is dominated by the channel @xmath68 . in the medium , the decay width for @xmath69 is given as @xmath70,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath71 , @xmath72 and @xmath73 s are 4-momenta and energies for the pions , and @xmath74 s are their thermal distributions . the matrix element @xmath75 has contributions from the channels @xmath76 ( described by the second term in ( [ lomg ] ) ) and the direct decay @xmath69 resulting from the contact interaction ( last term in ( [ lomg ] ) ) @xcite . for the @xmath77 coupling we take the value @xmath78 = 2 according to ref . @xcite , which is similar in value to the coupling taken in @xcite . we fix the point interaction coupling @xmath79 by fitting the partial decay width @xmath68 in vacuum ( 7.49 mev ) to be 0.24 . the contribution arising from the direct decay is upto around 15 % which is comparable to the results of @xcite . with the modifications of the vector meson masses in the hot and dense medium , a new channel becomes accessible , i.e. , the decay mode @xmath80 for @xmath81 , which is not possible in the vacuum ( since @xmath82 ) . the in - medium decay width for this process is found from the cutting rules at finite temperature to be @xmath83\ ] ] where @xmath84 arises from phase space considerations , and @xmath85 s are the thermal distribution functions for the pions and @xmath1 mesons . the first and second terms refer to the emission and absorption of pion and @xmath1 meson . the pion annihilation ( @xmath86 ) dominates dilepton production in the low invariant mass region . the dropping of the vector meson masses in the hot and dense matter also gives rise to substantial contribution to the dilepton yield from the direct decays of the vector mesons into dileptons ( @xmath87 , @xmath88 ) . the thermal production rate per unit four volume for lepton pairs is related to the imaginary part of the one particle irreducible photon self energy by @xcite @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the 4-momentum of the virtual photon , and @xmath91 is the fine structure constant . the invariant mass distribution for the lepton pairs from pion annihilation is given by @xmath92 where , @xmath93 , @xmath94 . in the above , @xmath95 is the cross section for the pion annihilation , and is given by @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the electromagnetic form factor of the pion . the photon can also couple to the hadrons through vector mesons , which is the basis of the vector dominance model @xcite . the photon can thus interact with the pions through a vector meson , which must be an isovector and is taken to be the @xmath1 meson . the effective lagrangian for the photon - pion - rho interaction can then be written as @xcite @xmath98 where @xmath99 is the field tensor for the @xmath1 field and @xmath100 . the coupling @xmath65 in the above can be determined from the decay @xmath62 , and the direct photon - rho coupling @xmath101 is determined from the process @xmath102 @xcite . these , including a finite decay width for the @xmath1 meson , then lead to the @xmath1-dominated pion form factor as @xmath103 in the rest frame of the @xmath1 meson , the invariant mass distribution of the lepton pair of invariant mass @xmath11 from pion annihilation is given as @xmath104 with the cross section @xmath105 for the pion annihilation , given in terms of the pion form factor at @xmath106 . the summation over @xmath107 arises from the bose - einstein distribution function for the @xmath1 meson . since we are mostly in the regime @xmath108 , the first term in the series , corresponding to the boltzmannian distribution function is dominant , with quantum corrections being of the order of upto 10 % . a vector meson @xmath109 in a thermal bath can decay into leptons and photons , described by the final state @xmath110 say , which escape the bath without thermalization . with @xmath111 as the four momentum of the nonhadronic state @xmath110 , a resonance peak should appear in the invariant mass ( @xmath11 ) plot for the number of lepton pair events , versus @xmath106 at @xmath112 , where @xmath113 is the mass of the resonance in the thermal bath . hence , the medium modifications of the vector mesons get reflected in the dilepton spectra through the shift and broadening of the peaks . the invariant mass distribution of lepton pairs from the decays of vector mesons is given by a generalization of the breit wigner formula as @xcite @xmath114 in the above , @xmath115 is the number of lepton pair events , say in the space time and four momentum element @xmath116 , @xmath117 being the spin of the resonance , @xmath118 is the formation width , @xmath119 is the total width and @xmath120 is the partial decay width for the off - shell @xmath109 ( i.e. of mass @xmath11 ) to go into the nonhadronic state @xmath110 . the total width @xmath121 is the rate at which the particles equilibriate and relax to chemical equilibrium . the invariant mass distribution of the lepton pairs from decays of vector mesons propagating with a momentum @xmath122 is obtained from equation ( [ gbw ] ) as @xmath123 q_0 \gamma _ { v \rightarrow e^+ e^-}^{\rm vac}\ ] ] in the rest frame of the vector meson , this reduces to @xmath124 in the above , @xmath125 is the partial width for the leptonic decay for the off - shell vector meson @xmath109 with mass @xmath11 , and is given as @xmath126 the coupling @xmath46 refers to the direct coupling of the vector meson @xmath109 to the photon as given in the equations ( [ lomg ] ) and ( [ lrho ] ) for the @xmath0 and @xmath1 mesons respectively . the coupling of @xmath0 to the photon taken to be one third of the coupling of @xmath1 to the photon gives reasonable agreement with the ratio of the observed partial widths @xmath127 @xcite . in the following we present numerical results on the influence of vacuum effects on hadronic masses , decay widths of vector mesons , and dilepton emission from hot hadronic matter . as described in the previous sections , the study is based entirely on a hadronic scenario and makes use of the original walecka model , extended by a nonlinear sigma self coupling . in this work we concentrate on one particular aspect , namely on the role of scalar vacuum effects . for each quantity studied , we compare the results of the relativistic hartree approximation ( rha ) , which was already treated in ref . @xcite , with those additional effects arising from a scalar vacuum condensate . the quartic self coupling @xmath128 is taken as a free parameter ; we have used @xmath129 and @xmath130 as representative values . the values of the incompressibility corresponding to these self couplings are 401 mev ( for @xmath128=1.8 ) and 329 mev ( for @xmath128=5 ) . these values are smaller than the mean field result of 545 mev as well as the relativistic hartree result ( @xmath128=0 ) of 450 mev . this is because an increase of @xmath128 leads to weaker potentials of the @xmath9 and @xmath0 mesons and to a softening of the equation of state . the parameters of the model are adjusted to fit nuclear matter , corresponding to a saturation density of @xmath131 = 0.193/@xmath132 . the fitted values for the scaled coupling constants are @xmath133 183.3 , 167.5 and 137.9 , and @xmath134 114.7 , 96.45 , and 63.7 for @xmath135 ( i.e. , rha ) , 1.8 , and 5 , respectively . when discussing dilepton production , we do not attempt to give a realistic description of specific experimental results . for this , the dynamic space - time evolution for the hot hadronic matter in the course of a nuclear collision would have to be addressed and additional effects contributing to the dilepton spectrum would have to be included . however , our study should help to elucidate , in which way in - medium vacuum effects can have an influence on experimentally observable quantities . we first discuss the effect of quantum corrections on the in - medium nucleonic properties for hot nuclear matter @xcite . in fig . 1a , we plot the temperature dependence of the nucleon mass for the baryon density @xmath136 and the nuclear matter density @xmath137 . the quantum corrections arising from the sigma field have the effect of softening the equation of state , and produce a higher value for the effective nucleon mass as compared to the rha . the effective nucleon mass was seen to increase with the vacuum polarisation effects arising from the baryons as compared to the mft calculations @xcite . though for @xmath136 , the effective nucleon mass decreases monotonically with temperature , for @xmath138 , the nucleon mass first increases and then decreases as a function of temperature , which has also been observed earlier to be the trend for higher densities @xcite . the variation in the nucleon mass is very slow up to a temperature @xmath139 150 mev , beyond which there is a fast decrease . though qualitative features are similar for the in - medium mass with inclusion of quantum effects from the scalar meson sector , it is observed that such effects lead to a higher value for the nucleon mass . we next study the temperature and density dependence of the vector mesons in hot nuclear matter . the @xmath0 meson mass as a function of the temperature for @xmath140=0 and @xmath131 , is plotted in fig . 1b . in the walecka model , the dirac sea has been shown to have a significant contribution over the fermi sea , leading to a substantial drop in the omega meson mass in nuclear matter @xcite . specifically , at saturation density and at zero temperature , the decrease in the omega meson mass from the vacuum value , is around 150 mev in rha , whereas with sigma quantum effects , the drop in the mass reduces to around 117 mev or 61 mev for the two values of @xmath128 studied . a similar reduction in the mass drop , as compared to the rha was also observed when scalar field quantum corrections were included within a one loop approximation @xcite , unlike the approximation adopted here , which is self - consistent and includes multi - loop effects . this indicates that the quantum corrections do play an important role in the medium modification of the vector meson masses . in the present work , it is seen that the quantum corrections from the scalar mesons , over those arising from the baryonic sector , have the effect of giving rise to a higher value for the @xmath0 meson mass . this again is related to the fact that the effective nucleon mass is higher when such quantum effects are taken into account . in figure [ figf2 m ] , we illustrate the medium modification for the @xmath1 meson mass with the vector and tensor couplings to the nucleons being fixed from the nn forward dispersion relation @xcite . the values for these couplings are given as @xmath141=0.55 and @xmath142=6.1 . we notice that the decrease in the @xmath1 meson mass with increase in temperature is much sharper than that of the @xmath0 meson . such a behaviour of the @xmath1 meson undergoing a much larger medium modification was also observed earlier @xcite within the relativistic hartree approximation for the nucleons . this indicates that the tensor coupling , which is negligible for the @xmath0 meson , plays a significant role for the @xmath1 meson . with inclusion of quantum corrections from the scalar meson , the qualitative comparison between the @xmath0 and @xmath1 vector mesons remains the same , though these effects are generally seen to lead to larger values for the vector meson masses . we have also calculated the contribution to the @xmath1 meson mass arising from pion loops through the @xmath143 coupling , but this was found to lead to a marginal increase of at most 1% , in agreement with @xcite . in figure [ figf3 m ] , the decay widths for the @xmath1 meson with and without the scalar quantum corrections , over the relativistic hartree approximation , are considered . such quantum effects lead to an appreciable increase in the decay widths , which , as we shall see , is observed as a broadening of the @xmath1-peak in the dilepton spectra . in figure [ figf4 m ] , the decay width for the @xmath0 meson is seen to have a positive contribution arising from the @xmath9-meson quantum effect as compared to rha . the decay width is calculated as arising from the processes @xmath69 as well as @xmath80 , a channel which becomes possible with the mass modifications of the vector mesons in the medium . it is seen that the channel @xmath144 opens for temperature greater than around 180 mev for @xmath136 , whereas it is observed even at zero temperature at nuclear matter saturation density . we might note that the collisional modification to the @xmath0 width , arising from the process @xmath145 @xcite , has not been taken into account in the present calculations . the dilepton spectra for the low invariant mass regime , at t=200 mev are shown in figures [ figf5 m ] and [ figf6 m ] calculated for densities @xmath136 and @xmath138 . the total dilepton spectra along with contributions arising from pion annihilation and direct decays of the @xmath1 and @xmath0 mesons , are displayed in figures 5a and 6a . the effect of sigma condensates shifts the peak position for the vector mesons to higher values as compared to rha , and also results in a broadening of the peaks in the dilepton spectra as can be seen from figures 5b and 6b . the @xmath1 and @xmath0 peaks are well separated due to the fact that the @xmath1 meson mass gets much larger medium modification as compared to the @xmath0 meson , which would not be the case in the absence of medium effects . the omega peak is seen to be smeared due to scalar meson quantum corrections . the broadening of the @xmath0 peak due to @xmath9-quantum effects is more clearly visible for @xmath138 than for zero density , in the dilepton spectra . the dominant contributions to the dilepton enhancement are from pion annihilation and @xmath1 meson decay , which are plotted in figures 5c and 6c in comparison with the rha results . the effect of @xmath9 condensates leads to a higher value for the peak position as well as broadening of the @xmath1-peak . the dilepton production rates due to the @xmath0 meson decay are displayed in figures 5d and 6d . it is observed that the broadening of the @xmath0 peak due to scalar quantum corrections is larger for @xmath131 than for zero density . this is a reflection of the fact that there is a larger modification of the omega width due to scalar quantum effects for higher densities . there have been various mechanisms under discussion which can lead to an increase in the @xmath0 width . it has been argued that the @xmath0 decay width can increase by an order of magnitude due to the reduction in the pion decay constant related with chiral symmetry restoration @xcite . the medium modification due to scalar meson quantum effects giving rise to higher values for the @xmath1 meson mass and decay width are reflected in the dilepton spectra . the medium modification for the vector meson masses depend more sensitively on the density than on temperature . this can give rise to an enhancement of the dilepton production rate when matter is highly compressed at the initial stage of a heavy ion collision . in the dls experiments for a - a collisions at 1 agev , there have been models that focus on density induced change for the @xmath1 meson mass to describe the dilepton pair production for invariant mass of dilepton pair , @xmath146gev @xcite . even though there is dilepton enhancement arising from the density modified @xmath1 mass , the results still underestimate the dls data by a factor of 2 - 3 @xcite . the mass modifications for the vector meson masses with density are plotted in figure [ figf7 ] , for temperature t= 100 mev . the trend is a sharp decrease of the masses with density up to @xmath147 , and then a rise for higher values of @xmath140 . the observed trend is due to the competing effects of vacuum polarisation which leads to a reduction in the mass , and the density dependent dressing for the vector self energy causing an increase in the meson mass . such a behaviour of the vector meson mass for the @xmath0 meson was also observed earlier @xcite . a higher value of the scalar self interaction coupling , @xmath128 , leads to a higher value for the vector meson masses . the change in the @xmath1 meson mass for higher densities is seen to be rather slow which means that there is a delicate cancellation between the feynman and the density dependent parts of the vector self energy . as depicted in figure [ figf7 ] , the @xmath0 meson mass seems to be more dominated by the density dependent contributions for higher densities . the decay widths are plotted in figure [ figf8 ] . the slow change in @xmath1 meson mass for higher densities is reflected in the in - medium @xmath1-decay width , while the @xmath0 decay width @xmath148 grows strongly with density and gets strongly enhanced by quantum effects from the @xmath9 meson . the dilepton spectra for @xmath149 mev and @xmath150 are plotted in figures [ figf91 ] and [ figf92 ] . these values should be typical for the compression zone of a nuclear collision at energies of a few gev per nucleon . for example , for inclusive ca+ca collisions at 1 agev studied by the dls collaboration @xcite , maximum temperatures and densities in this range were extracted from a transport model @xcite . in figure 9a , the total dilepton spectrum is plotted , for @xmath128=1.8 , displaying the individual contributions . figure 9b shows that the sigma quantum corrections lead to a broadening of the peaks in the dilepton spectra , which is seen to be more appreciable for the higher value of the scalar self coupling , @xmath128 . the individual contributions to the dilepton spectra , plotted in figure [ figf92 ] , illustrate the effect of @xmath9 quantum corrections . finally , the density dependence for the dilepton spectra is shown for temperature @xmath149 mev in figures [ figf101 ] and [ figf102 ] for couplings @xmath128 as 1.8 and 5 , respectively , in comparison with the rha results . the vector meson masses decreasing with density up to around twice the nuclear matter density and then slowly increasing or staying constant , are reflected in the dilepton spectra through the peak positions . one might notice that the broadening of the peaks due to @xmath9- quantum effects is larger for higher densities and is more pronounced for the @xmath0 peak . the curves for densities twice and four times nuclear matter density in figure [ figf102 ] are coincident up to a value of the invariant mass of about 0.6 gev . this is due to the fact that the rho meson properties whose effects are relevant for that mass region , remain almost constant for @xmath128=5 . beyond that however , they are different around the invariant mass region for the omega meson . due to substantial increase in the decay width of the @xmath0 meson with density the @xmath0 peak is almost smeared out even at nuclear matter density and the omega loses its quasi particle nature . the corrections from the scalar meson quantum effects are thus seen to be appreciable . to summarize , we have considered in the present paper , the modifications of the vector meson ( @xmath1 and @xmath0 ) properties due to quantum correction effects in hot and dense nuclear matter and their effect on dilepton spectra . the baryonic properties , as modified due to such effects , subsequently determine the vector meson masses and decay widths in the hot and dense hadronic matter . it has been recently emphasized that the dirac sea contribution dominates over the fermi sea , thus implying that the vacuum polarisation effects arising from the baryonic sector do play an important role in the vector meson properties in a medium . we consider the hadronic properties as modified arising due to the quantum effects from the baryon and scalar meson sectors and investigate their effect on the dilepton production rate . the effect of the scalar meson quantum corrections leads to an increase in the vector meson masses and decay widths . the effect on the omega meson decay width is particularly more pronounced at higher densities , than in the rha . the value for @xmath149 mev is modified from 67 mev ( for rha ) to 125 mev ( for @xmath128=1.8 ) and 251 mev ( for @xmath128=5 ) for @xmath151=2 , and for @xmath151=4 the rha value of 101 mev is modified to 175 mev and 370 mev , for @xmath128=1.8 and 5 , respectively . in the present work , we have studied the effect of quantum corrections arising from the scalar meson over those resulting from the baryon sector ( given through the summing over baryonic tadpole diagrams in the relativistic hartree approximation ) . the quantum corrections from the @xmath9-meson give rise to a higher value for the vector meson masses as compared to keeping only quantum effects from the baryons . there is also an appreciable increase in the decay widths in the presence of these quantum corrections , and this is reflected in the invariant mass plot for dilepton spectra through the broadening of the peaks . for the @xmath0 meson , an appreciable broadening arising due to sigma meson quantum effects leads to the disappearance of the peak from the spectra for high densities when @xmath0 ceases to be exist as a quasi particle . the density dependence of in - medium properties of the vector mesons and their subsequent effects on the dilepton spectra have been studied , which will be relevant for highly compressed matter at the early stage of a heavy ion collision . one of the authors ( am ) acknowledges financial support from alexander von humboldt foundation when the work was initiated . am would like to thank s. scherer , h. weber , d. dietrich for discussions , and would like to acknowledge the institut fr theoretische physik for warm hospitality and dfg ( sto 161/8 - 1 ) for financial support . 99 n. masera for the helios-3 collaboration , nucl . phys . * a 590 * , 93c ( 1995 ) . g. agakichiev et al ( ceres collaboration ) , phys . rev . lett . * 75 * , 1272 ( 1995 ) ; g. agakichiev et al ( ceres collaboration ) , phys . lett . * b 422 * , 405 ( 1998 ) ; g. agakichiev et al ( ceres collaboration ) , nucl . phys . * a 661 * , 23c ( 1999 ) . r. j. porter et al ( dls collaboration ) , phys . . lett . * 79 * , 1229 ( 1997 ) ; w. k. wilson et al ( dls collaboration ) , phys . c 57 , 1865 ( 1998 ) . d. p. morrison ( phenix collaboration ) , nucl . phys . * a 638 * , 565c ( 1998 ) . j. stroth ( hades collaboration ) , advances nuclear dynamics * 5 * , 311 ( 1999 ) . g. e. brown and m. rho , phys . lett . * 66 * , 2720 ( 1991 ) . t. hatsuda and su h. lee , phys . rev . * c 46 * , r34 ( 1992 ) ; t. hatsuda , s. h. lee and h. shiomi , phys . rev . * c 52 * , 3364 ( 1995 ) . x. jin and d. b. leinweber , phys . * c 52 * , 3344 ( 1995 ) ; t. d. cohen , r. d. furnstahl , d. k. griegel and x. jin , prog . * 35 * , 221 ( 1995 ) ; r. hofmann , th . gutsche , a. faessler , eur . j. * c 17 * , 651 ( 2000 ) ; s. mallik and k. mukherjee , phys . rev . * d 58 * , 096011 ( 1998 ) . s. mallik and a. nyffeler , phys . rev . * c 63 * , 065204 ( 2001 ) . f. klingl , n. kaiser , w. weise , nucl . phys . * a 624 * , 527 ( 1997 ) . c. ernst , s. a. bass , m. belkacem , h. stcker and w. greiner , phys * c 58 * , 447 ( 1998 ) . h. shiomi and t. hatsuda , phys . b 334 * , 281 ( 1994 ) . t. hatsuda , h. shiomi and h. kuwabara , prog . . phys . * 95 * , 1009 ( 1996 ) . jeans , j. piekarewicz and a. g. williams , phys . rev . * c 49 * , 1981 ( 1994 ) ; k. saito , k. tsushima , a. w. thomas , a. g. williams , phys . * b 433 * , 243 ( 1998 ) . jan - e alam , s. sarkar , p. roy , b. dutta - roy and b. sinha , phys . rev . * c 59 * , 905 ( 1999 ) . r. rapp and j. wambach , adv . phys . * 25 * , 1 ( 2000 ) . c. m. ko , v. koch and g. q. li , ann . * 47 * , 505 ( 1997 ) . jan - e alam , p. roy , s. sarkar and b. sinha , nucl - th/0106038 ; jan - e alam , s. sarkar , p. roy , t. hatsuda and b. sinha , ann . phys . * 286 * , 159 ( 2000 ) ; f. karsch , e. laermann , p. petreczky , s. stickan , i. wetzorke , hep - lat/0110208 . k. redlich , j. cleymans , v. v. goloviznin , in proceedings on nato advanced workshop on hot hadronic matter : theory and experiment , n.y . plenum press , 1995 , 562p ; a. dumitru , d. h. rischke , th . schnfeld , l. winckelmann , h. stcker and w. greiner , phys . lett . * 70 * , 2860 ( 1993 ) ; p. jaikumar , r. rapp and i. zahed , hep - ph/0112308 ; song gao , ru - keng su , xue- qian li , comm . * 28 * , 207 ( 1997 ) ; d. dutta , k. kumar , a. k. mohanty , r. k. choudhury , phys . rev . * c 60 * , 014905 , 1999 . b. d. serot and j. d. walecka , adv . nucl . phys . * 16 * , 1 ( 1986 ) . s. a. chin , ann . phys . * 108 * , 301 ( 1977 ) ; m. asakawa , c. m. ko , p. levai and x. j. qiu , phys . rev . * c 46 * , r1159 ( 1992 ) . s. pal , song gao , h. stcker and w. greiner , phys * b 465 * , 282 ( 1999 ) . a. mishra , p. k. panda , s. schramm , j. reinhardt and w. greiner , phys . * c 56 * , 1380 ( 1997 ) . a. mishra and h. mishra , j. phys . * g 23 * , 143 ( 1997 ) . s.y . pi and m. samiullah , phys . rev . * d 36 * , 3121 ( 1987 ) ; g. a. camelia and s.y . pi , phys . rev . * d 47 * , 2356 ( 1993 ) . a. mishra , p. k. panda and w. greiner , jour . g 27 * , 1561 ( 2001 ) . a. mishra , p. k. panda and w. greiner , jour . * g 28 * , 67 ( 2002 ) . a. mishra , j. c. parikh and w. greiner , jour . * g 28 * , 151 ( 2002 ) . c. gale and j. i. kapusta , nucl . * b 357 * , 65 ( 1991 ) . r. a. schneider , t. renk and w. weise , nucl . * a 698 * , 428 ( 2002 ) ; t. renk , r. a. schneider and w. weise , phys . rev . * c 66 * , 014902 ( 2002 ) . h. umezawa , h. matsumoto and m. tachiki , _ thermofield dynamics and condensed states _ ( north - holland , amsterdam , 1982 ) . m. asakawa , c. m. ko , p. levai and x. j. qiu , phys . rev . * c 46 * , r1159 ( 1992 ) ; m. herrmann , b. l. friman and w. nrenberg , nucl . phys . * a 560 * , 411 ( 1993 ) ; g. chanfray and p. shuck , nucl . phys . * a 545 * , 271c ( 1992 ) . w. grein , nucl . * b 131 * , 255 ( 1977 ) ; w. grein and p. kroll , nucl . phys . * a 338 * , 332 ( 1980 ) . j. j. sakurai , _ currents and mesons _ ( the university od chicago press , chicago , 1969 ) . m. gell - mann , d. sharp , and w. d. wagner , phys . rev . lett . * 8 * , 261 ( 1962 ) . b. a. li , phys . rev . * d 52 * , 5165 ( 1995 ) . f. klingl , n. kaiser and w. weise , z. phys . * a 356 * , 193 ( 1996 ) . . kaymakcalan , s. rajeev and i. schechter , phys . rev . * d 30 * , 594 ( 1984 ) . m. le bellac , _ thermal field theory _ ( cambridge university press , new york , 1996 ) . h. b. connell , b. c. pearce , a. w. thomas and a. g. williams , prog . . phys . * 39 * , 201 ( 1997 ) . h. a. weldon , ann . ( n. y. ) * 228 * , 43 ( 1993 ) . g. q. li , c. m. ko , g. e. brown , nucl . phys . * a 606 * , 568 ( 1996 ) . s. sarkar , jan - e alam , p. roy , a.k . dutt - mazumder , b. dutta - roy and b. sinha , nucl . phys . * a 634 * , 206 ( 1998 ) . r. d. pisarski , hep - ph/9503330 . g. chanfrey and p. schuck , nucl . phys . * a 555 * , 329 ( 1993 ) ; g. q. li and c. m. ko , nucl . phys . * a 582 * , 731 ( 1995 ) . e. l. bratkovskaya , w. cassing , r. rapp and j. wambach , nucl . phys . * a 634 * , 168 ( 1998 ) . j. zhang and c. gale , phys . rev . * c 50 * , 1617 ( 1994 ) .

the in - medium properties of the vector mesons are known to be modified significantly in hot and dense hadronic matter due to vacuum polarisation effects from the baryon sector in the walecka model . the vector meson mass drops significantly in the medium due to the effects of the dirac sea . in the variational approach adopted in the present paper , these effects are taken into account through a realignment of the ground state with baryon condensates . such a realignment of the ground state becomes equivalent to summing of the baryonic tadpole diagrams in the relativistic hartree approximation ( rha ) . the approximation scheme adopted here goes beyond rha to include quantum effects from the scalar meson and is nonperturbative and self consistent . it includes multiloop effects , thus corresponding to a different approximation as compared to the one loop approximation of including scalar field quantum corrections . in the present work , we study the properties of the vector mesons in the hot and dense matter as modified due to such quantum correction effects from the baryon as well as scalar meson sectors . these medium modifications of the properties of the vector mesons are reflected , through the shifting and broadening of the respective peaks , in the low mass dilepton spectra . there is broadening of the peaks due to corrections from scalar meson quantum effects as compared to the relativistic hartree approximation . it is seen to be rather prominent for the @xmath0 meson in the invariant mass plot . # 1

astro-ph0212090

when the high energy photons emitted by the x - ray source arrive to the earth , they have been scattered by the interstellar dust grains . therefore many galactic x - ray sources are observed to have faint and diffuse halos . this effect and its possible application was first discussed by overbeck ( 1965 ) , and the x - ray halo was first detected with einstein observatory ( rolf 1983 , catura 1983 ) . the investigation of the shape and strength of the haloes was done by several authors ( e.g. mauche & gorenstein 1986 , predehl & schmitt 1995 ) based on the data of einstein and rosat . as the photons in the halo travel through longer paths than the photons in the point source , any intensity variation in the the source induces a delayed signal in the halo . it has been suggested by trmper and schnfelder ( 1973 , hereafter ts1973 ) that this effect can be uesd to determine the distance of variable galactic x - ray sources . although the method is very simple , the first successful application was realized by predehl ( 2000 ) for a x - ray binary cyg x-3 almost 30 years later . they obtained the distance of @xmath0 kpc to the source . the difficulty of the method is that it is hard to distinguish the halo from the image induced by the point spread function of the instrument until the chandra x - ray observatory provides us the high resolution image of x - ray sources . the shape and strength of the halo depend on the distance to the x - ray source , the geometric distribution and the physical properties of the interstellar dust grains ( hayakawa ( 1970 ) , mathis & lee ( 1991 ) , and predehl & klose ( 1996 ) ) . the differential scattering cross section of x - ray photons in interstellar dust is ( predehl , 2000 ) @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the size of the dust grains ( in @xmath3 m ) , @xmath4 is the energy of x - ray ( in kev ) , and @xmath5 is the scattering angle ( in arc min ) . following ts1973 , we obtain the time delay of a scattered photon compared with an unscattered photon is ( see fig . 1 ) @xmath6 where @xmath7 is given in kpc , @xmath8 in arcsec . given the dust density distribution along the line of sight @xmath9 , the time delay distribution function @xmath10 can be calculated . as pointed by predehl & schmitt ( 1995 ) , we can assume @xmath9 is a constant . thus @xmath11 ^ 2})}{t+1.15d\theta^2}{\rm d}t{\rm d}\theta\ ] ] for a viable point source with light - curve @xmath12 , the normalized light - curve in the halo is @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the possible maximal time delay . in ts1973 , @xmath12 and @xmath15 are compared directly to determine distance . suppose the light - curve @xmath16 of the point source and the light - curve @xmath17 of the halo at @xmath18 radius are stationary random signals , @xmath19 and @xmath20 are their fourier transformation respectively . it is easy to show that @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the normalized integral transformation of the signal arrival time distribution function @xmath10 . denote the power density spectrum of the point source and the halo as @xmath23 and @xmath24 , we get @xmath25 given the power density spectra of the point source and the halo at different radius , @xmath26 and @xmath27 are easy to know , and @xmath7 can thus be determined by fitting equation ( 3 ) . 1.8 in now we apply this method to the chandra data of x - ray binary cyg x-3 . cyg x-3 is an eclipsing x - ray binary with an orbital period of 4.8 hours ( brinkman et al . cyg x-3 was observed with the high energy transmission grating spectrometer ( hetgs ) on board of chandra on october 20 , 1999 , with a total time of 12.3 ksec , starting at 01:11:38 ut . the observation covered the binary phases from -0.3 to + 0.4 . we only use the zeroth order data in this study . because the image of the point source is severely damaged by the pileup effect , we can only campare the power density spectra at different and radius . the theoretical difference of the power density spectrum of the halo at 2 arcsec and 4 arcsec in 5.0 - 7.0 kev energy band are shown in fig . then we calculate @xmath28)/h^2(\omega,\theta=[2^{\prime\prime},4^{\prime\prime}])$ ] in 5.0 - 7.0 kev energy band , the result shows in fig . 3 . because the error bar of the data in fig . 3 is very big , it is hard to fit the data with theoretical curves . for simplicity , we fit the data with a exponential curve . the turning point of the fitting curve lies at about 0.001 hz , and the corresponding value of @xmath7 is 9 kpc . according to fig . 3 , it seems the real turning point should small than 0.002 hz , so we estimate @xmath7 is at least 5 kpc . 1.7 in our result is consistent with previous estimate on the distance of cyg x-3 . predehl et al . ( 2000 ) used ts1973 method and obtained @xmath0 kpc , dickey ( 1983 ) found a lower limit of 9.2 kpc 1 using 21 cm wavelength absorption data , predehl & schmitt ( 1995 ) derived 8 kpc as distance through the galactic dust layer from their comparison of x - ray scattering and absorption . our method and ts1973 method both determine the geometric distance instead of physical distance . the physical distance depend on the estimation of many physical parameters , i.e. , absorption optical depth . the uncertainties of the geometric distance determination come mainly from the dust density distribution along the line of sight . in principle , it can be solved by carefully fitting the shape and strength of the halo . in ts1973 method the x - ray source must have relatively obvious variations in the time interval comparable to the delay time ( see fig . 4 . in predehl et al . 2000 ) . but in our method this requirement is not needed . although the chandra observatory has high resolution , its effective area is relatively small , therefore the count rate of the cyg x-3 halo is not high enough for good statistical study with our method . the future x - ray satellites such as _ constellation - x _ will provide us with high count rate data , and our method can be applied to many more galactic variable x - ray sources . * acknowledgement : * this study is supported in part by the special funds for major state basic research projects and by the national natural science foundation of china . snz also acknowledges supports by nasa s marshall space flight center and through nasa s long term space astrophysics program . 10 brinkman , a.c . , _ _ iau circ . _ * 2446 * ( 1972 ) catura , r. c. , _ astrophys . j. _ * 275 * , 645 ( 1983 ) dickey , j.m . , _ astrophys . j. _ * 273 * , l71 ( 1983 ) hayakawa , s. , _ prog . _ * 43 * , 1224 ( 1970 ) mathis , j.s . , lee c .- w . , _ astrophys . j. _ * 376 * , 490 ( 1991 ) mauche , c.w , gorenstein p. , _ astrophys . j. _ * 302 * , 371 ( 1986 ) overbeck , j. w. , _ astrophys . j. _ * 141 * , 864 ( 1965 ) predehl , p. , schmitt , j.h.m.m . , _ _ * 293 * , 889 ( 1995 ) predehl , p. , klose , s. , _ astro . astrophys . _ * 306 * , 283 ( 1996 ) predehl , p. , burwitz , v. , paerels f. , trmper j. , _ astro . _ * 357 * , l25 ( 2000 ) rolf , d. p. , _ nature _ * 302 * , 46 ( 1983 ) trmper , j. , schnfelder , v. , _ astro . astrophys . _ * 25 * , 445 ( 1973 )

we have developed a timing analysis method to determine the distances of variable galactic x - ray sources based on the method advanced by trmper and schnfelder in 1973 . the light - curve of the halo produced by the scattering of x - rays off the interstellar dust is delayed and smeared by the dust grains . this method utilizes the differences between the power density spectra of the point source and the halo . we present the details of this method and our first applications of this method to the chandra data of x - ray binary cyg x-3 . x - ray source distance , ism , scattering

cond-mat9809256

stable compounds@xcite formed by fe and n , such as @xmath1-fe@xmath2n and @xmath3-fe@xmath4n , or quasi - stable@xcite like @xmath5-fe@xmath6n have been known for some time . on the other hand , almost nothing was reported about fen until the work of heiman _ et al._@xcite , where for the first time , they synthesized fe@xmath7n@xmath8 with 0.4 @xmath9 0.75 . in this work fen was found to be ferromagnetic . successive studies found fen in nacl - type crystal structure@xcite , and non - ferromagnetic at room temperature@xcite . more recent works are in contradiction with the earlier ones : morita _ et al._@xcite reported fen antiferromagnet at temperatures below 100 k. moreover , suzuki _ et al._@xcite determined the fen structure to be of zns fcc type . they also found their sample to exhibit a mictomagnetic character that was suggested be related to the antiferromagnetism of fen . regarding the structure , it seems clear that fen can assume both zincblende and rocksalt structure , depending on the sample history , and both of them may contain some deficiencies of n atoms . regarding magnetic properties , recent mssbauer spectroscopy measurements suggested that nacl - type fen is antiferromagnetic@xcite , with nel temperature around room temperature . however , mssbauer spectroscopy is not able to determine completely magnetic ordering . for both structural and magnetic properties ab initio calculations are suited to furnish a prediction about the ground state of fen , and to help guide understanding of experimental results . here we investigate the relative stability of paramagnetic ( pm ) , ferromagnetic ( fm ) and some possible antiferromagnetic ( afm ) phases of nacl - type fen that have been observed or suggested for other transition - metal nitride ( or oxide or carbide ) compounds . compared to other transition - metal nitrides ( tmns ) , it has been noticed@xcite that nacl - type fen shows electronic properties close to those of crn that we recently investigated@xcite , e.g. the fermi energy falls exactly on a pronounced peak of the density of states , mainly formed by fe @xmath10-like flat bands . in ref . the authors come to the conclusion , on the basis of the rigid band model to evaluate the dos and the stoner condition of ferromagnetism , that only crn , fen and con in rocksalt phase are likely to be stabilized by magnetic ordering . comparison with crn is particularly interesting because it undergoes a cubic - to - orthorhombic transition accompanying the pm to afm ordering at a nel temperature close to the room temperature , with afm phase formed by double ferromagnetic sheets compensating along the [ 110 ] direction**???**. the structural distortion is decisive in determining the most stable among the different afm phases , and stress relief is likely to be the ultimate driving force towards distortion . if such an involved mechanism of magnetic - ordering is driven by the high dos at fermi level , it could be argued that a similar magnetic ordering occurs for fen as well . thus , for possible afm phases , we decide to consider here the [ 110]-double and single sheet afm arrangements ( indicated as afm@xmath11}$ ] and afm@xmath12}$ ] , respectively and described fully in ref.@xcite ) , as well as the afm@xmath13}$ ] phase ( very common for nacl - type transition metal oxides ) , consisting of single ferromagnetic sheets alternating along the [ 111 ] direction . equilibrium lattice constants , energies , and magnetic moments are presented for all the considered phases . also , band structures and density of states ( dos s ) are presented for pm and fm phases . our local - spin - density calculations are performed in a plane - wave and ultrasoft pseudopotential framework@xcite . use of ultrasoft pseudopotentials allow us to obtain well converged results for a cutoff energy equal to 30 ryd . we used sets of 10 to 110 special k - points ( depending on the structure ) for the self - consistent calculations , up to 280 k - points to evaluate the dos . experimentally it was found for the lattice constant of fen in rocksalt and zincblende phase @xmath14=8.5 bohr@xcite and @xmath15=8.1 - 8.2 bohr @xcite , respectively . this result is somewhat surprising ; indeed , assuming the same anion - cation bond length in the two phases , the relation between lattice constants would be @xmath16 . although this crude approximation considerably overestimates the actual difference between the two structures , it is generally true that in most cases the rocksalt phase have larger volume . doubts about the measurements are confirmed by a recent theoretical work@xcite where structural properties for transition metal nitrides are calculated . they found for @xmath15 a value in good agreement with experiments , but a much smaller @xmath17 7.5 bohr in the paramagnetic phase . the discrepancy with experiment is so large that it seems unlikely it could be due to different magnetic orderings . also , in ref . the equilibrium lattice constant for other phases ( ferromagnetic and a couple of antiferromagnetic phases ) was evaluated , but no relevant changes on @xmath14 were found . finally , the value @xmath17 7.5 bohr is consistent with that of other rocksalt tmn structures . for instance , experiments assign to afm crn a value @xmath17 7.8 bohr , and we should expect for fen a somewhat smaller lattice constant . to try to explain the disagreement with experiments we consider here other afm phases . in particular , among the afm phases examined in ref . , the afm@xmath18}$ ] was not taken into account . the pm to afm@xmath11}$ ] transition is found to produce , for crn , a large increase of lattice constant@xcite ( @xmath19 2% ) , although not large enough to account for the discrepancy with experiments of fen , and the largest energy gain with respect to the pm phase . in table [ struct ] we report our calculated values of @xmath14 for the corresponding magnetic orderings . evidently , contrary to what happens for crn , the structure of fen is basically unaffected by magnetic ordering , and only a 0.4% increase of @xmath14 is found in the fm phase with respect to the pm . our results are in substantial agreement with ref . ( they found @xmath20=7.47 and 7.54 for pm and afm phases , respectively ) . from our calculations , it results that nacl - type fen is ferromagnetic . the energy gain of fm phase with respect to the pm is less than 0.1 ev per formula unit , i.e. significantly smaller than in case of crn . also , the competition between fm and the examined afm phases is very close ( energy differences are few hundredths of ev ) . to be confident about the precision of our calculations , we evaluated the fm - afm energy differences by performing fm calculations in the same symmetry of all the afm structures considered , and tested the differences for sets of special k - points of increasing size . we conclude that , among the afm phases , the lowest in energy is afm@xmath12}$ ] , also the lowest among the cubic phases of crn@xcite . in that case , the orthorhombic [ 110 ] shear distortion of crn produces a further energy gain for the afm@xmath11}$ ] structure ( anisotropic in the ( 100 ) plane due to magnetic ordering ) that causes the latter to be the most stable phase overall . to investigate the effect of planar distortion on fen we applied the same distortion experimentally observed for crn ( i.e. a @xmath192% reduction of the bisection angle at the squared base of the tetragonal cell . surprisingly , we find very little change in the energy with respect to the cubic afm@xmath11}$ ] phase ( the increase is just @xmath19 2 mev ) . thus , notwithstanding the similarity of dos at fermi level , crn and fen are stabilized by very different magnetic order and structure . in table [ struct ] we report the magnetization @xmath21 ( per formula unit , i.e. per couple fe - n ) for the considered phases of fen . the fm phase has the highest magnetization ( 1.65 @xmath22 ) , of which @xmath19 0.15 @xmath22 comes from polarization of n , and @xmath19 1.5 @xmath22 from polarization of fe . for crn the magnetization is more that 2 @xmath22 per formula unit . also , the charge transfer is different . for fen it is equal to about one electron , so that the approximate ionic configuration fe@xmath23n@xmath24 can be deduced , i.e. fe is near a @xmath25 configuration . in case of crn , the charge transfer is larger ( close to 2 electrons ) , due to the higher electronegativity of fe with respect to cr . i.e. to the smaller electronegativity difference with n. the higher covalency of fen contributes to it having a smaller lattice constant , whereas crn has larger ionicity and polarization . in ref . it is argued that for crn the energy gain from the planar distortion is due to a relief of tensile stress stored in the bonds between metal atoms with antiparallel spins . this stress can be conveniently defined as the excess stress produced by a transition from the afm@xmath12}$ ] phase ( where there is no stress by symmetry ) and the afm@xmath11}$ ] cubic phase with the same lattice constant . the transition produces a planar anisotropic stress , whose component @xmath26}$ ] is tensile , i.e. the spin - antiparallel metal atoms tend to get closer each other . in light of our results for fen , we speculate that this magnetic order - derived stress is sensitive to the magnitude of magnetization . of course , the different bond length ( slightly larger for crn than for fen ) plays a role as well and could justify in itself a different behavior . in figure [ dos_pm ] the dos for the pm phase of fen is shown . in this energy region , the total dos ( top panel ) is almost completely made up by d states of fe and p states of n ( bottom panel ) . the d - like dos shows two high peaks close to the fermi energy ( e@xmath27 ) . the lowest in energy is completely occupied and is composed by a mixture of 75% @xmath0-type and 25% @xmath28-type character . it is this peak which falls at e@xmath27 in paramagnetic crn@xcite ( a rigid band model works well for the pm phase of this system ) . the second peak in the d dos is entirely @xmath0 in character , and is centered at e@xmath27 . the peaks located between -8 ev and -4 ev are mostly n p , with a mixture of @xmath0-type and ( predominantly ) @xmath28-type states . the n p - like dos gives an appreciable contribution to the dos at the fermi energy as well , unlike crn for which only d - type states contribute . this dos peak at e@xmath27 arises from a strong @xmath29 antibonding band . the effect of fm ordering is easily visible in figure [ dos_fm ] . now the fe d - like dos ( middle panel ) is shown decomposed in @xmath0 and @xmath28 states . the two d - type peaks are now split by an exchange splitting of roughly 1.6 ev . after this splitting both peaks in the spin up channels are completely occupied , whereas the upper peak of the spin down channel is empty . thus , 3 electrons per fe atom saturate almost completely three @xmath30 states , and @xmath19 1.5 electron charge of mostly @xmath0 type remains unpaired . consistently with a cation to anion charge transfer of @xmath19 1 electron , i.e. with a @xmath25 configuration for fe , there are 2.5 electrons occuping nearly paired @xmath28 states . the n p character in the dos contributes to the magnetization , reflecting the n moment of @xmath19 0.15 @xmath22 . the same features can be seen in the band structure . in figure [ band_pm ] the pm fen band structure is presented . it is easy to distinguish the very flat @xmath0-type band crossing the fermi level through @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 directions , that produces the half - occupied peak of pm dos shown in figure [ dos_pm ] . after fm ordering ( figure [ band_fm ] ) , the band is split , in such a way that the up band ( left panel ) is shifted @xmath191.5 - 2 ev down to the fermi energy , and the down band rises up slightly , but still remains partially occupied . evidently , much of the minority dos peak at @xmath190.8 ev arises from regions away from the symmetry lines plotted in figure [ band_fm ] . a feature observable in figure [ band_fm ] is that the spin splitting for some bands is strongly k - dependent , unlike the stoner picture in which the splitting is rigid . for example , all bands at @xmath34 are clustered within 1 ev in the paramagnetic case and remain so in the minority bands , whereas in the majority bands they span a range of nearly 2 ev . such non - rigid behavior has been observed in other transition metal compounds , and reflects a combination of ( i ) an anisotropic exchange potential ( around the fe atom ) and ( ii ) hybridization between d orbitals on a strongly magnetic atom ( fe ) and p orbitals on a weakly magnetic atom ( n ) . in this paper the structure of nacl - type fen has been investigated by ab initio calculations . the ferromagnetic phase is found to be stable against the paramagnetic and all the antiferromagnetic phases here considered . however , the energy differences between the magnetic phases are within few hundredths of ev , and this fact , coupled with sensitivity of the magnetism to stoichiometry , could explain the experimental variations reported in the literature . in order to get insights into the magnetic ordering mechanisms , a comparison with crn was made . although for both compounds a sharp @xmath10-like peak is present at e@xmath27 , the differences in charge transfer , magnetization and differing wavefunction character at e@xmath27 lead to very different magnetic properties . in particular , the orthorhombic distortion that is able to stabilize afm crn has no effect on fen . since the distortion indicates the presence of tensile stress stored on bonds between metal atoms with antiparallel spins , we suspect that the stress could depend sensitively on the magnitude of magnetization . the relief of stress is now accepted to be an important factor in the structure and properties of surfaces and interfaces . our results strongly suggest that the stress relief may be instrumental in determining the magnetic order in compounds such as fen . this work was supported by national science foundation grant no . computations were carried out at the san diego supercomputing center and at the maui high performance computing center . . equilibrium lattice constant @xmath20 ( in bohr ) , energy @xmath35 ( in ev / formula unit ) and magnetic moment @xmath21 ( in @xmath22/metal atom ) of nacl - type fen calculated for different magnetic phases . energies are referred to the lowest one , i.e. that of fm phase . [ struct ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]

ab initio results for structural and electronic properties of nacl - type fen are presented . calculations are performed within a plane - wave and ultrasoft pseudopotential framework . competition among paramagnetic , ferromagnetic and some possible antiferromagnetic phases is examined . we find the ferromagnetic phase stable overall as observed . stabilization over the unpolarized phase is obtained by splitting one flat @xmath0-type band crossing the fermi energy . comparison with crn reveals that the magnetic ordering of crn , which consists of double - ferromagnetic sheets compensating along the [ 110 ] direction of the cubic cell and stabilized by the distortion of the squared symmetry on ( 100 ) plane , is not effective for fen . the different behavior of fen and crn can be traced back to the smaller ionicity and magnetization of the former .

1008.1063

most of the games represent simplified real - life situations and help us to find an optimum decision ( action ) . due to the simplifications the players have only a few options to choose and the corresponding incomes are quantified by a payoff matrix allowing us to apply the tools of mathematics . the theory of games has been used successfully both in economics and political decisions since the pioneering work of von neumann and morgenstern @xcite . subsequently the concept of payoff matrix is adopted by biologists to quantify the effect of interactions of species on their fitness ( characterizing the capability to create offspring ) in the mathematical models of darwinian evolution @xcite . since that time the evolutionary game theory provides a general mathematical framework for the investigation of multi - agent systems used widely in economy and other social sciences where imitation is substituted for the offspring creation @xcite . in traditional game theory selfish and intelligent individuals try to maximize their own payoff irrespective of others . in evolutionary game theory players repeat the games and sometimes imitate ( adopt ) the neighbor s strategy if the neighbor received a higher score . it turned out that assuming local interactions among players the imitation supports the maintenance of altruistic behavior even for prisoner s dilemma games where the individual interest is in conflict with the common one and the selfish individual behavior drives the well - mixed community into a state ( called `` tragedy of the commons '' ) with players exploiting ( instead of helping ) each other @xcite . in parallel with theoretical investigations game theory is also used to study human and animal behaviors experimentally @xcite . these experiments have motivated the extension of evolutionary games to study the effect of different types of mutual help , e.g. , charity @xcite , inequality ( inequity ) aversion @xcite , emotions @xcite including juvenile - adult interactions @xcite . in generally , the modelling of human decision dynamics is one of the most important open problems in the behavioral sciences @xcite . the examples mentioned raise the possibility that a player tries to optimize not only personal but her local neighborhood s payoff as well . motivated by this option we consider the simplest case and introduce a collective pairwise strategy update rule providing that two randomly chosen neighbors upgrade their strategy simultaneously in order to increase their summarized payoff each coming from games with all their neighbors on the spatial system . this way of strategy update can be considered as an extension of cooperative games toward the spatial evolutionary games . originally , in cooperative games groups of players ( coalitions ) may perform coordinated behavior within the group to enhance the group s payoff . on the other hand , the present model implies a connection between the theory of kin selection @xcite and spatial models of viscous population of altruistic relatives helping each other @xcite . as a consequence of the proposed strategy update rule , it will be shown that the previously mentioned tragedy of the commons state can be avoided even in the hard condition of prisoner s dilemma game . in the latter case both analytical and numerical approaches indicate the existence of an ordered structure of cooperator and defector players on square lattice at sufficiently low noise level . ( this arrangement of alternative strategies resembles the sublattice ordering of anti - ferromagnetic ising model . ) it is worth mentioning that similar formation of strategies was also reported by bonabeau _ _ @xcite and by weisbuch and stauffer @xcite within the framework of social models . to explore and identify the exclusive consequence of the proposed strategy update rule , we will compare the results with the outcomes of two previously applied dynamical rules . these are the imitation of a better neighbor and the so - called myopic strategy update rules . the present work is structured as follows . in sec . [ sec : models ] we define the spatial evolutionary games with the mentioned dynamical rules . the main results for these types of dynamical rules are compared for the anti - coordination game in sec . [ sec : acg ] . subsequently we will discuss the weak prisoner s dilemma games with using monte carlo ( mc ) simulations and mean - field analysis . in sec . [ sec : robus ] we present and compare the mc results for the three dynamical rules within a relevant region of payoff parameters describing social dilemmas @xcite . as the dynamical rules influence significantly the sublattice ordering process therefore some aspects of domain growth are considered numerically in sec . [ sec : domgr ] . finally we summarize the main results in sec . [ sec : conc ] . in the studied models each player follows one of the pure cooperate or defect ( @xmath1 or @xmath2 ) strategies . according to pairwise interaction a player s payoff is calculated by means of @xmath3 payoff matrix . for a given pair of equivalent players the possible strategy dependent payoffs are given by the payoff matrix as @xmath4 where @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) is received by the @xmath1 ( @xmath2 ) player if her co - player follows the same strategy . on the other hand , if the players choose opposite strategies the @xmath1 players receive @xmath7 while @xmath2s are rewarded by @xmath8 . the anti - coordination ( ac ) game will be considered when @xmath9 and @xmath10 . in this case the players receive the maximum payoff if they choose opposite strategies . for the social dilemmas we also use a rescaled payoff matrix @xcite in such a way that @xmath11 and @xmath12 , that is , the mutual choice of @xmath1 is better for both players . despite it the players can favor the choice of @xmath2 if either @xmath13 or @xmath14 where @xmath15 refers to the temptation to choose defection and @xmath16 is the sucker s payoff . for the prisoner s dilemma ( pd ) both conditions are satisfied and the players are enforced to choose @xmath2 yielding the second lowest individual income for them . the hawk - dove , in short hd ( also called as snowdrift or chicken ) game describes the situation when @xmath17 and @xmath18 while the stag - hunt ( sh ) game corresponds to the case @xmath19 and @xmath20 . the fourth quadrant of the @xmath21 parameter plane is represented by the harmony ( h ) game where mutual @xmath1 is the best solution for the players . in the mentioned four quadrants of the @xmath21 plane the two - person one - shoot games have different set of nash equilibria @xcite . in the present spatial models players are located on the sites @xmath22 of a square lattice consisting of @xmath23 nodes under periodic boundary conditions . initially each player follows an @xmath24 or @xmath2 strategy chosen at random . the payoff @xmath25 is collected from the mentioned matrix games with her four nearest neighbors . according to the proposed pairwise collective strategy update the evolution of strategy distribution is based on the following protocol . first , we choose two neighboring players ( @xmath22 and @xmath26 ) at random and we evaluate their payoff ( @xmath25 and @xmath27 ) depending on their own @xmath28 , @xmath29 , and also on the neighboring strategies . subsequently we evaluate the payoff @xmath30 and @xmath31 assuming that the given players follow randomly chosen @xmath32 and @xmath33 strategies while the neighborhood remains unchanged . as a consequence of randomly chosen @xmath32 , @xmath33 strategy pair , there are cases when only one ( or none ) of the two players will modify her strategy . notice , however , that this strategy choice allows the pair of players to select all the possible four strategy pairs . finally the strategy pair , @xmath32 and @xmath33 , is accepted simultaneously with a probability @xmath34}\ ; , \label{eq : pwc}\ ] ] where @xmath35 characterizes the average amplitude of noise disturbing the players rational decision . the results of the above evolutionary process will be contrasted with the consequence of two other dynamical rules used frequently in previous studies @xcite . if the evolution is controlled by stochastic imitation of the more successful neighbor then player @xmath22 adopts the neighboring strategy @xmath29 with a probability @xmath36}\ \label{eq : imit}\ ] ] dependent on the current payoff difference between players @xmath22 and @xmath26 . besides it , we also study a so - called myopic strategy update when a randomly chosen player @xmath22 changes her strategy @xmath28 to a random strategy @xmath32 with a probability @xmath37}\ \ , \label{eq : myop}\ ] ] where @xmath25 and @xmath30 are the income of player @xmath22 when playing @xmath28 and @xmath32 for the given neighborhood . notice that the latter strategy update is analogous to the glauber dynamics used in the kinetic ising models @xcite . consequently , for symmetric payoff matrices , @xmath38 , ( or potential games ) the myopic strategy update drives the spatial system into a thermal equilibrium ( at temperature @xmath35 ) that can be described by the boltzmann statistics @xcite . this means that an anti - ferromagnetic ordering process is expected for the ac games with myopic strategy update when decreasing the noise parameter @xmath35 . motivated by the above mentioned connection to the ising model , we first consider the anti - coordination game and study the consequences of different strategy update rules . the presented results of mc simulations were obtained typically for @xmath39 size but we used significantly larger system size in the vicinity of the critical transitions to suppress undesired fluctuations . during the evolution we have determined the average portion @xmath40 of players following the @xmath1 strategy in the stationary state . to describe the expected anti - ferromagnetic ordering the square lattice is divided into two sublattices ( @xmath41 and @xmath42 ) on the analogy of white and black boxes on the chessboard . in fact two equivalent types of completely ordered structure exist in the limit @xmath43 . for both cases the @xmath1 and @xmath2 strategies are present with the same frequency ( @xmath44 ) . in the first ( second ) case all the @xmath1 strategies are located on the sites of sublattice @xmath41 ( @xmath42 ) . the sublattice ordering will be characterized by an order parameter @xmath45 where @xmath46 and @xmath47 denote the portion of @xmath1 strategy in the sublattices @xmath41 and @xmath42 . in a finite system the sublattice ordering develops throughout a domain growing process within a transient time . starting with myopic strategy update , defined by eq . [ eq : myop ] , the mc data coincide with the exact results of ising model @xcite if the noise parameter ( temperature in the latter case ) is rescaled by a factor of 2 . accordingly , a long - range ordered state appears in the zero noise limit where cooperator and defector players form a chessboard - like pattern . the order parameter @xmath48 varies from 1 to 0 if @xmath35 is increased from 0 to @xmath49 and @xmath50 if @xmath51 , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : ising ] . when considering the analogy between the kinetic ising spin systems and evolutionary ac games one should keep in mind that the glauber dynamics @xcite favors spin flips decreasing the total energy and the opposite flips are generated by the external noise ( temperature ) . on the contrary , for the evolutionary games the myopic individuals wish to increase their own payoff and the opposite decision is caused by noisy effects . the necessity of the temperature rescaling is related to the fact that in the kinetic ising model for glauber dynamics the individual spin flips are controlled by the total energy difference while for the evolutionary games the changes are influenced by the individual payoff increase ( @xmath52 ) that is half of the total payoff increase ( if the payoff matrix is symmetric ) because the co - players share the income equally . in the following we study the evolutionary ac game with pairwise collective strategy update rule defined by eq . ( [ eq : pwc ] ) . in agreement with our expectation this strategy update is capable to find the optimal global state and the long - range sublattice ordering is established again when varying the amplitude of noise . figure [ fig : ising ] indicates a striking qualitative similarity between the behaviors controlled by the myopic and pairwise collective strategy updates . the slight difference between the outputs is related to the fact how payoffs change due to different update processes . as we already mentioned , the change of individual payoff is half of the global change for myopic rule . this is not necessarily true for pairwise collective rule because neighboring players receive nothing from the game played between the focal @xmath22 and @xmath26 players . in a special case , when focal players adopt each others strategies simultaneously , the exact relation between the changes of individual and global payoffs is restored . this special process , when @xmath53 and @xmath54 , resembles the kawasaki spin - exchange of statistical mechanics . as a consequence , this `` limited '' pairwise collective dynamics reproduces the results of myopic update . to close this section , we should stress that the application of the third type pairwise imitation strategy update is unable to find the optimal solution when cooperator and defector players form a long - range ordered state . in the following we will study the consequences of different updating rules when the payoff matrix is not symmetric . we start with a simple and popular parametrization of the weak pd game when ( @xmath55 ) . if we fix the noise level , the only free parameter is the @xmath15 temptation to defect payoff element . in the rest of the paper we use @xmath56 noise value , that is proved to offer an almost optimal cooperation level in case of pairwise imitation strategy update model @xcite . the pairwise imitation strategy update rule was already investigated by means of mean - field theory ( for a brief survey see @xcite and further references therein ) . within this approach the stationary state is characterized by the average fraction @xmath40 of cooperators that drops suddenly ( at @xmath57 ) from 1 to 0 if @xmath15 is increased for arbitrary values of @xmath35 . for completeness , we note that the results for arbitrary values of @xmath16 are surveyed in a recent review @xcite using replicator dynamics in the imitation of the better strategies , too . as expected , the application of the other two strategy update rules , such as myopic and pairwise collective , may allow the possibility of sublattice ordering . to catch this behavior we extend the mean - field analysis and introduce two sublattices ( @xmath41 and @xmath42 ) where the fraction of cooperators can be different ( @xmath46 and @xmath47 , respectively ) . using the general payoff parameters given by eq . ( [ eq : pom ] ) the average payoff of cooperator and defector players in the sublattices @xmath41 and @xmath42 can be approximated as @xmath58 , \nonumber \\ p_a^{(d ) } & = & 4 [ c \rho_b + d ( 1-\rho_b ) ] , \nonumber \\ p_b^{(c ) } & = & 4 [ a \rho_a + b ( 1-\rho_a ) ] , \nonumber \\ p_b^{(d ) } & = & 4 [ c \rho_a + d ( 1-\rho_a ) ] , \ ; \label{eq : us}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the present connectivity structure where each player in sublattice @xmath41 has four neighboring players belonging to sublattice @xmath42 and vice versa . for the myopic strategy update [ defined by eq . ( [ eq : myop ] ) ] the time derivative of cooperator frequency @xmath46 can be expressed as : @xmath59 } \nonumber \\ & + & ( 1-\rho_a ) \frac{1}{1+\exp[(p_a^{(d)}-p_a^{(c)})/k ] } \ ; , \label{eq : rhoevol}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and a similar expression can be derived for @xmath60 by substituting @xmath42 for the sublattice index @xmath41 . inserting the expressions ( [ eq : us ] ) into ( [ eq : rhoevol ] ) after some mathematical manipulations one finds @xmath61/k \ } } - \rho_a \ ; , \nonumber \\ \label{eq : rhoabeq}\\ \dot{\rho}_b & = & \frac{1}{1+\exp \ { 4 [ ( b+c - a - d)\rho_a - b+d]/k \ } } - \rho_b \nonumber \;. \end{aligned}\ ] ] the stationary values of cooperator densities @xmath46 and @xmath47 can be determined numerically from eq . ( [ eq : rhoabeq ] ) when @xmath62 . for the case of the weak pd ( @xmath11 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath12 ) the @xmath15-dependence of the stationary solution exhibits two types of behaviors as illustrated by green lines in the upper plot of fig . [ fig : rho_wpd ] . below a threshold value ( depending on @xmath35 ) the distribution of cooperators is homogeneous , that is , @xmath65 . above the threshold temptation value the mean - field solution predicts a ( twofold degenerated ) sublattice ordering . for one of the ordered structure ( at sufficiently high values of @xmath15 ) sublattice @xmath41 is occupied dominantly by defectors and in sublattice @xmath42 the players alternate their strategies between cooperation and defection ( i.e. , @xmath66 ) because both strategies yield the same payoff for them ( notice that @xmath67 if @xmath68 ) . for the second ( equivalent ) ordered structure the role of sublattices @xmath41 and @xmath42 is exchanged . we should mention that there is an unstable symmetric solution without sublattice ordering ( @xmath65 ) for high @xmath15 values as illustrated by spaced dashed green line in the upper plot of fig . [ fig : rho_wpd ] . the mean - field analysis can also be performed for the pairwise collective strategy update although the corresponding formulae become more complicated because of the larger number of elementary events ( single and simultaneous two - site strategy flips for two neighboring players ) . neglecting the technical details now we only present the numerical results by blue lines in the upper plot of fig . [ fig : rho_wpd ] . similarly to the myopic case , the stable solution is a homogeneous state for low @xmath15 values and a sublattice ordering appears above a threshold temptation . in the latter case , one of the sublattices is occupied dominantly by cooperators while the other sublattice is occupied by defectors . naturally , this solution is twofold degenerate if we substitute the role of sublattices @xmath41 and @xmath42 . an unstable symmetric solution also exists at high @xmath15 values that is marked by spaced dotted blue line in the upper plot of fig . [ fig : rho_wpd ] . in the following we will check the predictions of mean - field theory by using mc simulations . similarly to the ac model , the typical system size was @xmath39 during the simulations . in the vicinity of phase transition point , however , we had to use larger systems ( up to @xmath69 ) to gain the sufficient accuracy . the results for different strategy update are summarized in the lower panel of fig . [ fig : rho_wpd ] . for completeness , we quote here the known mc results of pairwise imitation update @xcite . these results are marked by red open circles in the plot . in contrast to mean - field prediction , @xmath1 and @xmath2 strategies can coexist if @xmath70 ( where @xmath71 and @xmath72 for @xmath56 ) . for lower values of @xmath15 only the @xmath1 strategy can remain alive in the final stationary state while @xmath1 becomes extinct if @xmath73 . in case of myopic strategy update , qualitatively similar behavior was found ( marked by green open squares in the lower plot of fig . [ fig : rho_wpd ] ) . the only difference is a relatively high portion of cooperator players in the high @xmath15 region . the survival of the @xmath1 strategy is caused by appearance of solitary @xmath1s in the sea of @xmath2s because this event does not modify the payoff of the given individual if @xmath74 . evidently , the probability of the mentioned process decreases if @xmath16 becomes negative , as it happens in the real pd situations . in contrast to the prediction of mean - field calculation the mc simulations do not justify the presence of long - range ordering . instead of it the simulations give @xmath75 if @xmath15 is sufficiently high . it is worth mentioning that the more sophisticated pair approximation ( the results are not indicated in the figure ) reproduces the absence of sublattice ordering in the case of @xmath74 . for slightly higher values of @xmath16 ( in the region of hd game ) , however , the prediction of mean - field calculation becomes qualitatively correct because mc simulations indicate sublattice ordering as detailed later on . closing by pairwise collective update , mc data ( blue closed squares ) fully support the prediction of mean - field calculations and show a similar sublattice ordering as we observed for ac game previously . namely , the portion of @xmath1 strategy is distinguishable in the sublattices @xmath41 and @xmath42 , if @xmath76 . notice furthermore , that the average density of @xmath1s is significantly higher for this strategy update in comparison with those provided by the pairwise imitation and myopic rules . the pairwise collective strategy update promotes the chessboard - like arrangement of cooperators and defectors because this constellation provides the highest total income for the neighboring co - players ( as well as for the whole community ) if @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the total payoff of a cooperator pair . this feature can be clearly recognized for the weak pd game where the ordered structure is disturbed rarely by point defects if @xmath79 and the average payoff increases linearly with @xmath15 as illustrated in fig . [ fig : apo ] . it is well known that the traditional game theory @xcite suggests the players to alternate @xmath1 and @xmath2 in opposite phase to receive @xmath80 on average for the repeated two - person games . the sublattice ordering in the spatial evolutionary game can be considered as an alternative solution to achieve the maximum average payoff . from the view point of the pair of players ( or the whole society ) the chessboard - like arrangement of cooperation and defection has an advantage over the state of the homogeneous defection favored by several dynamical rules within a wide payoff region of pd . as a result , the ordered structure is observable in the spatial strategy distribution even for @xmath81 for the weak pd . below a threshold value of @xmath15 , however , the long - range ordered strategy distribution is destroyed by the noise and both types of ordered structures are present within small domains . simultaneously , the further decrease of @xmath15 increases the frequency of cooperators approaching to the saturation value @xmath82 . the quantitative analysis of the pair s payoff ( @xmath83 ) shows that the homogeneous cooperation remains stable against the appearance of a solitary @xmath2 if @xmath84 for the case of weak pd . similarly , in the perfect sublattice ordered state ( @xmath85 and @xmath86 ) the appearance of an additional cooperator is preferred if @xmath84 . at the same time the homogeneous defection is not stable because any new cooperator increases the income of her neighbors ( and also the income of pairs she belongs to ) . from the above features one can conclude a sharp transition at @xmath87 from the homogeneous @xmath1 state ( @xmath88 ) to one of the chessboard - like structure ( e.g. , @xmath85 and @xmath86 ) if @xmath15 is increased in the limit @xmath43 . this expectation is confirmed by mc simulations performed for several low values of noise @xmath35 . in the following we extend the payoff parametrization to general social dilemmas and explore how robust the observed long - range ordering in the whole @xmath21 plane . to reveal the possible sublattice ordering we carried out series of mc simulations for different @xmath16 values by using the same @xmath56 noise level . the results are summarized by consecutive curves in fig . [ fig : rho_st ] allowing us to compare the territories of @xmath21 parameters where cooperators , defectors , or sublattice ordering prevail the stationary state for the three dynamical rules we studied . it can be clearly seen , for example , that the defectors dominated area of @xmath21 region shrank significantly if the evolution is controlled by pairwise collective strategy update . for this dynamical rule players favor to choose cooperation in the sea of defectors if @xmath89 . this is the reason why the fraction of cooperators is sufficiently high in the case of weak pd . notice furthermore that the pairwise collective strategy update provides the best condition for the cooperators to prevail the system within the region of sh game . referring to the previously discussed connection between ac model and anti - ferromagnetic ising model , sh game allows comparison with ferromagnetic ordering . the application of pairwise collective update reveals this possibility and highly extend the @xmath1-dominated phase in the sh quadrant . the upper ( a ) plot of fig . [ fig : rho_st ] illustrates that sublattice ordering occurs over a large region of @xmath21 payoff parameters within the territory of hd and pd games if the evolution is controlled by pairwise collective strategy update . the critical temptation parameter @xmath90 varies monotonously with the sucker s payoff @xmath16 . for myopic strategy update the sublattice ordering can be observed only within the hd region of the payoff parameters as shown in the middle ( b ) plot of fig . [ fig : rho_st ] . it is emphasized that this behavior is predicted by the mean - field calculation for the case of weak pd , that is at the boundary separating the territories of hd and pd ( see the lower plot of fig . [ fig : rho_wpd ] ) . comparing the @xmath91 surfaces of fig . [ fig : rho_st]a&b , it is worth noting that myopic update does not support cooperation in the sh quadrant as effectively as it is done by pairwise collective update . finally , fig . [ fig : rho_st]c indicates clearly that the imitation of the nearest neighbors on a square lattice does not support the emergence chessboard - like sublattice ordering . on the other hand , the upper and lower plateaus ( at @xmath92 and 1 ) represent absorbing states and the continuous transitions to these homogeneous states belong to the directed percolation universality class @xcite . within the stag hunt region the system exhibits a first - order phase transition for all the three rules . evidently , the sublattice ordering is prevented if the noise level @xmath35 becomes sufficiently high for any values of @xmath15 and @xmath16 . simultaneously , the region of disordered coexistence of @xmath1 and @xmath2 strategies ( where e.g. , @xmath93 and @xmath94 ) increases with @xmath35 . the above simulations justified the appearance sublattice ordering for two of three dynamical rules we studied . it is emphasized , however , that many versions of similar spatial social dilemmas were investigated previously without reporting long - range ordering . most of these investigations are based on imitation @xcite preventing the formation of this type of ordered strategy distribution as mentioned above . the sublattice ordering is observable within small domains in the snapshots published previously by several authors @xcite . sysi - aho _ et al . _ studied hd game with myopic agents on a square lattice with first- and second - neighbor interactions @xcite . in the latter model the randomly chosen agents are allowed to modify their strategy only if this action increases their own payoff ( in contrary to the present stochastic myopic rule ( eq . [ eq : myop ] ) allowing players to use of unfavored strategy with a low probability ) . similar ( short - range ordered ) patterns were reported by wang _ @xcite who used a more complicated synchronized strategy update . in order to clarify the importance of possible disadvantageous strategy change in the framework of myopic update , we compare the domain growth processes for two different cases . in the first case the evolution is controlled by the myopic rule as defined by eq . [ eq : myop ] . in the second case we used the same strategy adoption probability ( [ eq : myop ] ) but only if the new strategy increases the player s income [ @xmath95 otherwise the adoption of the new strategy @xmath32 is forbidden . in other words , the second rule can be considered as a restriction of the first one when strategy change with payoff increment is allowed only . the visualization of the time - dependent strategy distribution indicated clearly that after a short ordering process the evolution is ended in a frozen pattern in the ( restricted ) second case if the simulation is started from a random initial state within the region of hd game . the difference between the time evolutions can be demonstrated if we compare the time - dependence of average payoffs @xmath96 for both cases . as figure [ fig : ut ] shows , the evolution of @xmath96 stops very early ( at about 15 mc steps ) in the second case . in the first case , however , when disadvantageous strategy change is also allowed , @xmath96 evolves continuously and saturates at @xmath97 that corresponds to a mono - domain ( long - range ordered ) state . regarding the restricted feature of the second update rule , a frozen pattern of strategy distribution can be considered as a state where every player is satisfied with her own strategy . in other words , a frozen state is analogous to a nash equilibrium in the sense that the unilateral deviation from this strategy profile would reduce the income of the given player . as we demonstrated , a frozen state , that is the composition of two types of ( equivalent ) small ordered domains , can be avoided by applying the first rule because irrational strategy change along the interfaces helps to find global optimum . the above discussed phenomenon has inspired us to investigate what happens for the pairwise collective strategy update ( defined by eq.[eq : pwc ] ) if the disadvantageous strategy adoptions are prohibited as earlier for myopic update . surprisingly , the restriction of pairwise collective update does not block the domain growth process . the visualization of the evolution of strategy distribution indicates that strategies are not changed in the bulk of ordered domains but vary exclusively along the boundaries separating the ordered regions . consequently , as fig . [ fig : ut ] illustrates , @xmath96 can increase continuously until reaching the value @xmath98 whether the strategy change is restricted to payoff increment cases or not . during the domain growth process the deficiency of average payoff is located along the boundaries separating the ordered regions therefore @xmath99 decreases proportionally to the total length of interfaces . this behavior resembles to the domain growth of solid - state physics systems where the growth kinetics is driven by reducing interfacial energy . in the latter , so - called curvature - driven growth the excess domain - boundary energy decays algebraically with @xmath100 exponent @xcite . the time evolution of payoff difference in fig . [ fig : uta ] supports our argument and shows algebraic decay with the mentioned exponent whether myopic or pairwise collective update was applied . figure [ fig : uta ] illustrates that the deficiency of average payoffs vanishes algebraically , that is , @xmath101 for all the three cases exhibiting growing domains . the speed ( pre - factor @xmath102 ) of ordering decreases fast with the noise level @xmath35 because the disadvantageous strategy updates become rarer and rarer for sufficiently low values of noise . in the opposite case , when @xmath35 approaches its critical value @xmath103 dependent on the payoff parameters ( ordering exists only if @xmath104 ) , the domain growth also slows down due to the diverging fluctuations . in the quantitative comparison of domain growth for different dynamical rules the mentioned effects are compensated by doubling the value of @xmath35 for the pairwise collective strategy update plotted in figs . [ fig : ut ] and [ fig : uta ] . surprisingly , for the latter dynamical rules the blocking of the disadvantageous strategy adoptions makes the domain growth faster ( this phenomenon might have been related to the reduced noise effects along the interfaces ) . finally we mention that the preliminary simulations have confirmed the appearance of sublattice ordering for the models with nearest- and next - nearest interactions . more precisely , in the latter case one can observe a four - sublattice ordering process with many different types of ordered structures resembling those periodic structures described by a two - dimensional ising model with first- and second - neighbor interactions @xcite . the poly - domain versions of most of these ordered structures were reported previously by several authors who studied the evolutionary hd games with a myopic strategy update when prohibiting the acceptance of those strategies yielding a lower individual payoff @xcite . we have checked what happens if the present myopic evolutionary rule [ given by eq . ( [ eq : myop ] ) ] is applied only if @xmath105 . in the latter case the domain growing process is also blocked in a ( frozen ) poly - domain state as it is described above . in this work we have introduced a pairwise collective strategy update and studied its impact on anti - coordination and social dilemma games . our proposal was motivated by real - life experiences when players act to increase not only personal but their local neighborhoods payoff , too . as a starting effort along this avenue we have chosen pairs of players . to identify and quantify the consequence of this strategy update , we have also studied two frequently applied strategy updates , such as myopic and pairwise imitation . our results highlight the emergence of a spatially ordered distribution of strategies on the analogy to anti - ferromagnetic ordering in spin systems . in contrary to the traditional imitations both the myopic and pairwise collective strategy updates support the formation of ordered strategy distribution favored within a wide range of social dilemmas . this ordered arrangement of cooperators and defectors can provide the maximum total payoff in a wide range of payoff parameters for the social dilemmas and it seems to be a general behavior on regular networks characterizing connections between the players . within the context of social sciences the appearance of mentioned state can be interpreted as a possibility for the community to avoid the `` tragedy of the common '' ( when all the agents choose @xmath2 and receive nothing ) by sharing the two possible roles ( strategies ) with a spatially ordered ( rigid ) structure . the systematic comparison of the level of cooperations ( @xmath40 ) for the three different evolutionary rules has justified that the pairwise collective strategy update provides the highest total ( average ) income for the whole spatial community in most of the region of payoff parameters . we have also studied the kinetics of ordering and found further similarities with physics motivated systems . this investigation highlighted the importance of irrational decisions as a way to avoid trapped ( frozen ) states . there are two main directions to extend the present work . firstly , as we already noted , other type of interaction graphs can also be considered . our preliminary results confirm that the positive impact of the pairwise collective strategy update is not restricted to square lattice with nearest neighbor interaction . a similar ordering can emerge locally for a wide range of interaction graphs . secondly , the size of the group in which players favor the group interest ( instead of personal payoff ) can be also increased . in this case further improvement of cooperation is expected .

evolutionary @xmath0 games are studied with players located on a square lattice . during the evolution the randomly chosen neighboring players try to maximize their collective income by adopting a random strategy pair with a probability dependent on the difference of their summed payoffs between the final and initial state assuming quenched strategies in their neighborhood . in the case of the anti - coordination game this system behaves alike an anti - ferromagnetic kinetic ising model . within a wide region of social dilemmas this dynamical rule supports the formation of similar spatial arrangement of the cooperators and defectors ensuring the optimum total payoff if the temptation to choose defection exceeds a threshold value dependent on the sucker s payoff . the comparison of the results with those achieved for pairwise imitation and myopic strategy updates has indicated the relevant advantage of pairwise collective strategy update in the maintenance of cooperation .

1007.3981

since its discovery by stephenson ( 1986 ) , the remarkable field star bp psc (= sth@xmath3 202 ) has been classified as a classical t tauri star ( ctts ) on the basis of its strong h@xmath3 and forbidden line emission . the discovery by zuckerman et al . ( 2008 ; hereafter zms08 ) of an orbiting , dusty circumstellar disk and an enormous ( pc - scale ) system of highly collimated outflows ( jets ) would appear , at first glance , to provide strong support for such a ctts classification . however , as noted by zms08 , it is not at all clear that bp psc is a pre - main sequence ( pre - ms ) star . first , although its jet system resembles those of cloud - embedded young stellar objects , bp psc is located at high galactic latitude , far from any known star forming cloud . furthermore , unlike the rare ( though increasingly scrutinized ) `` isolated , '' ctts systems within @xmath4 pc ( torres et al . 2008 ) the best - known examples being tw hya ( kastner et al . 1997 ; zuckerman & song 2004 ; and references therein ) and v4046 sgr ( kastner et al . 2008b ; rodriguez et al . 2010 ; and references therein ) bp psc is not associated with any known sparse group of young stars ( zms08 ) . second , its photospheric li abundance appears to be anomalously weak for a k - type pre - ms star of age @xmath5 myr , and its gravity - sensitive photospheric absorption lines also call into question such a classification ( zms08 ) . third , the mm - wave molecular spectrum of its circumstellar disk specifically , its weak cn and hco@xmath6 emission is atypical of the disks of low - mass , pre - ms stars ( kastner et al . 2008a ) . in light of the first two considerations , zms08 proposed that bp psc is most likely a first - ascent giant at a distance @xmath7 pc . they speculated that the bp psc disk / jet system might therefore be the result of a recent , catastrophic interaction in which a low - mass companion star ( or perhaps giant planet ) had been consumed by bp psc . though somewhat exotic , a similar ( companion engulfment ) scenario may also apply to the first - ascent giant star tyc 4144 329 2 ( melis et al . 2009 ) : the post - ms nature of tyc 4144 329 2 is well - established , yet ( like bp psc ) this star is evidently actively accreting gas from a dusty circumstellar disk . low - mass , pre - ms stars are highly luminous x - ray sources , with typical ( 0.38.0 kev ) x - ray luminosities @xmath8 \stackrel{>}{\sim } 29.5 $ ] and x - ray to bolometric luminosity ratios in the range @xmath9 to @xmath10 ( e.g. , preibisch & feigelson 2005 ; gdel et al . hence , x - ray observations are diagnostic of stellar youth . furthermore , in rare cases , tts jet systems may yield shocks energetic enough to produce x - rays , yielding insight into physical conditions within the jets ( e.g. , kastner et al . 2005 ; guedel et al . 2005 , 2007b ) . here , we report the results of _ chandra _ x - ray observatory observations of bp psc intended to determine whether bp psc and/or its jet system emit x - rays and , thereby , to better understand the nature of this unusual system . _ chandra _ observed bp psc in 2009 january , with the advanced ccd imaging spectrometer ( acis ) as the detector . due to spacecraft thermal constraints , the observation was obtained in two pieces of duration 10.15 and 65.4 ks ( obsids 8900 and 10856 , respectively , on 2009 jan.12 and 13 ) , for a total exposure time of 75.5 ks . data were obtained with acis ccds s1 , s2 , s3 , s4 , i2 , and i3 active . each ccd has a @xmath11 field of view with 0.49@xmath12 pixels , and is sensitive to photons in the energy range 0.58.0 kev ( with some additional sensitivity down to 0.3 kev , for back - illuminated ccd s3 ) . the telescope was pointed such that bp psc was positioned at the nominal aimpoint of ccd s3 , @xmath13 from the s2-s3 chip boundary . the merged event data from the two exposures were subject to standard processing , filtering , and calibration ( via _ chandra _ x - ray center ( cxc ) acis pipeline v7.6.1 and caldb v3.5.1 ) . we ran the cxc ( ciao ) source detection tool ` celldetect ` on the filtered event list , restricted to ccds s2 and s3 ( the other active ccds lie far off the best focal surface ) . we find 26 sources , including bp psc itself ( 3.1 ) , were detected at a significance @xmath14 ( using poisson statistics ) on these two ccds ( fig . [ fig : bppscimage ] , right ) . four of these s2 and s3 sources lie within @xmath15 of denis near - ir sources ; two of the four ( bp psc itself and an x - ray source detected on ccd s2 ; 3.3 ) are also 2mass sources . based on the @xmath16 x - ray sources that lie within @xmath15 of guide star catalog stars ( not including the bp psc source ) , we estimate the absolute astrometric accuracy of the two - part _ chandra _ pointing to be @xmath17 . in fig . [ fig : bppscimage ] we display the wide - field h@xmath3 image originally published in zms08 alongside the broad - band ( 0.58.0 kev ) _ chandra_/acis image of the same field surrounding bp psc . the comparison reveals that _ chandra _ has detected a faint , point - like x - ray source at the position of bp psc . source detection indicates a background - subtracted count rate of [email protected] ks@xmath19 for this source , or @xmath20 source photons detected during the @xmath21 ks exposure . the bp psc x - ray source lies at j2000 coordinates @xmath2223:22:24.72 , @xmath2302:13:41.66 , with a positional uncertainty that is dominated by the estimated astrometric accuracy ( @xmath180.2@xmath12 ) . given the uncertainties , this x - ray position is precisely coincident with that of the 2mass position of bp psc ( @xmath2223:22:24.70 , @xmath2302:13:41.40 ) as well as with the centroid of submillimeter continuum emission from bp psc ( @xmath2223:22:[email protected] , @xmath2302:13:[email protected] ; zms08 ) . analysis of photon arrival times ( via a kuiper test against a poisson process ; press et al . 1992 ) yields no evidence that the bp psc source is variable , although we are unable to rule out source variability . given the small number of photons detected , it is not reasonable to attempt to deduce the characteristic source temperature @xmath24 and line - of - sight absorbing column @xmath25 and , hence , intrinsic source flux @xmath26 via standard x - ray spectral analysis . however , useful constraints on @xmath25 and @xmath26 can be obtained via the median energy of the detected source photons . specifically , feigelson et al . ( 2005 ) demonstrated that orion nebula cluster ( onc ) pre - ms star x - ray sources detected by _ chandra_/acis - i display a relatively tight correlation between median x - ray energy and @xmath25 . getman et al . ( 2010 ) refined and further generalized the feigelson et al . ( 2005 ) results , demonstrating ( via spectral simulations ) that the relationship between median x - ray energy and @xmath25 should in principle apply to any source that can be modeled in terms of two - temperature optically thin thermal plasma emission suffering intervening absorption , and is applicable over a wide range of intrinsic source luminosity ( i.e. , for @xmath27 from @xmath28 to @xmath29 erg s@xmath30 ) . as the getman et al . analysis was carried out for sources detected on the front - illuminated acis ccds ( i0-i3 ) , which have lower qe than ccd s3 at low energy ( i.e. , photon energies @xmath31 kev ) , application of the getman et al.methods might result in an underestimate in the value of @xmath25 obtained via the median photon energy of a source on s3 . this is unlikely to be an important effect for a source as hard as that detected toward bp psc in 2009 , however , especially given the overall degradation in the soft ( @xmath32 kev ) x - ray sensitivity of acis in the decade since _ chandra _ s launch , to determine the median detected photon energy for the bp psc source , we applied the ( ae ) software package ( broos et al . 2010 ) to extract and analyze the source photons . doing so , we find the median background - subtracted photon energy of the bp psc source in the 0.58.0 kev energy band is [email protected] kev . this median energy corresponds to an absorbing column @xmath33 = 22.9\pm0.2 $ ] , based on the `` best model family '' determined from the getman et al . ( 2010 ) statistical spectral analysis method ( we display the ae - extracted x - ray spectral energy distribution of bp psc , overlaid with the getman et al . `` best model family '' spectral model , in fig . [ fig : bppsc_spec ] ) . the getman et al . ( 2010 ) method yields an estimated apparent ( measured ) broad - band flux of @xmath34 erg @xmath35 s@xmath19 ( 0.58.0 kev ) , corresponding to an intrinsic flux @xmath36 erg @xmath35 s@xmath19 . the measured and intrinsic hard - band ( 2.08.0 kev ) fluxes are @xmath37 erg @xmath35 s@xmath19 and @xmath38 erg @xmath35 s@xmath19 , respectively . although the statistical error on the broad - band intrinsic flux ( @xmath26 ) is small ( @xmath39% ) , the value of @xmath26 is uncertain by almost a factor of 5 ( and the hard - band intrinsic flux is uncertain by a factor @xmath402 ) , due to systematic uncertainties in determining the generic spectral model that best describes the bp psc source ( see getman et al . 2010 , their fig . 1 ) . however , the foregoing estimates for apparent and intrinsic flux are consistent with those we obtained via simple simulations to match the bp psc source acis - s3 count rate using absorbed thermal plasma models ranging in temperature from @xmath41 to 3.0 kev a range typical of coronal sources with median photon energies similar to that of bp psc ( feigelson et al . 2005 ; also see 4 ) assuming @xmath42 @xmath35 . from the preceding results for @xmath25 and @xmath26 , we estimate that the x - ray luminosity of the bp psc source is @xmath43 erg s@xmath19 where @xmath44 is the distance in pc . adopting a bolometric luminosity @xmath45 erg s@xmath19 for the star ( zms08 ) , and allowing for the ( large ) systematic errors in @xmath26 obtained via the getman et al . ( 2010 ) method , we conservatively conclude that @xmath0 lies in the range @xmath1 to @xmath2 , with a best estimate of @xmath46 . as is apparent from inspection of fig . 1 , no diffuse x - ray emission is associated with the jets and bow - shock - like herbig - haro ( hh ) objects emanating from the position of bp psc . this result is not particularly surprising , considering such emission should be very soft ; indeed , there are few examples of shock - generated x - ray emission among pre - ms jet / hh systems , and the handful that have been detected to date generally display low x - ray luminosities ( e.g. , hh 210 in the onc , with observed @xmath47 erg s@xmath19 ; grosso et al.2006 ) . we estimated an upper limit on the surface brightness of such diffuse x - ray emission from the bp psc jet system by counting background events within regions centered on the h@xmath3 emission near the tips of the bow shocks seen in optical emission lines . the resulting limit is @xmath48 erg @xmath35 s@xmath19 arcsec@xmath49 . this corresponds to an upper limit on emergent x - ray luminosity of @xmath50 erg s@xmath19 for any compact ( @xmath15 ) x - ray - emitting knots in the bp psc jet system . if bp psc is a nearby ( @xmath51 pc ) , `` isolated '' classical t tauri star akin to tw hya or v4046 sgr ( e.g. , kastner et al . 2008b and references therein ) , then it could be a member of a sparse group of young ( age @xmath52 myr ) stars whose members are quite x - ray luminous relative to the field star population ( zuckerman & song 2004 ; torres et al . 2008 ; and references therein ) . if so , there would be a small chance that the @xmath53 square degree field imaged by _ [ fig : bppscimage ] ) contains one or more low - mass members of this putative `` bp psc association . '' such young stars , being close to earth , should be sufficiently luminous in x - rays as to be readily detectable in our @xmath21 ks _ chandra _ exposure and should be bright near - ir sources ( bp psc itself , though occulted by its disk and not directly detected in the near - ir , has @xmath54 ) . as already noted , however , only one of the roughly dozen x - ray sources detected on ccd s3 bp psc itself is also a 2mass source . an additional dozen , relatively bright ( @xmath55 count ) x - ray sources are detected on s2 ( the ccd abutting s3 ) , although some of these sources suffer from poor image quality due to a combination of large off - axis angle and non - optimal detector geometry with respect to the focal surface of the _ chandra _ mirror assembly . of these s2 sources only one , at @xmath2223:22:41.4 , @xmath56=-02:21:23 ( j2000 ) the bright x - ray source at the extreme southeast corner of the image in the righthand panel of fig . [ fig : bppscimage ] can be readily associated with a bright ( @xmath57 ) star ( usno - b1 08760839011 ) . given its usno and 2mass catalog magnitudes ( @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 , and @xmath62 ) this x - ray - bright object is indeed a candidate young ( age @xmath16 myr ) , late - type ( k3 - 4 ) star ; but as such it would lie at a distance @xmath63 pc . furthermore , its proper motion ( @xmath64 = [ 48 , 28 ] mas yr@xmath19 ; usno - b1 ) is signicantly different from that measured for bp psc ( [ 44.4 , @xmath6526.3 ] mas yr@xmath19 ; tycho-2 ) . hence usno - b1 08760839011 is not associated with bp psc , whether or not bp psc is a young star at @xmath51 pc . our _ chandra _ observation of bp psc has yielded a detection of a faint x - ray point source that is coincident with the bright optical / near - ir and submillimeter emission associated with this unusual field star . the nature of this x - ray emission source is difficult to ascertain , given the small number of photons detected . however , the median energy ( @xmath66 kev ) and , hence , the resulting inferred absorbing column density ( @xmath67 @xmath35 ) appear typical of pre - ms star x - ray sources detected within dusty circumstellar disks that are viewed nearly edge - on ( kastner et al . 2005 ) . the large value we infer for @xmath25 , which corresponds to a @xmath68 band extinction of @xmath4 magnitudes ( vuong et al . 2003 ) , is consistent with the fact that the photosphere of bp psc is thus far only detected indirectly via scattering off circumstellar dust in the visible and near - ir ( zms08 ) . given that the median detected photon energy is @xmath66 kev , it would appear that the x - rays detected from bp psc are too hard to be attributed to internal shocks associated with its jet - launching regions in contrast to cases in which soft ( @xmath32 kev ) x - rays have been detected at the bases of optical jets associated with certain classical t tauri stars ( kastner et al . 2005 ; guedel et al . 2005 , 2007b ) . indeed , the bp psc x - ray source spectral energy distribution ( fig [ fig : bppsc_spec ] ) reveals no evidence for such a soft x - ray `` excess . '' instead , the x - ray photons we have detected would appear to be associated with magnetic reconnection activity near the star . such magnetic activity , in turn , could be due either to a stellar corona or to star - disk interactions . in either case given that the stellar photosphere is evidently obscured from direct view , even at near - ir wavelengths ( zms08 ) it would appear that the x - ray source at bp psc likely represents the first direct detection of radiation from within a few stellar radii of bp psc itself , and that the x - ray - based value of @xmath25 we have obtained is therefore the only presently available measurement of the extinction toward the star ( @xmath69 ) . the values of x - ray luminosity and @xmath0 ( 3.1 ) inferred from the _ chandra _ detection would appear to place bp psc at the extreme low end of the ( well - determined ) x - ray luminosity distributions of t tauri stars in the onc ( preibisch & feigelson 2005 ) and in taurus ( guedel et al . specifically , the value of @xmath70 we estimate for bp psc , @xmath71 erg s@xmath19 , places bp psc well below the median value of @xmath70 for @xmath72 onc stars in the 320 myr age range ( the relevant range if bp psc is pre - main sequence ; zms08 ) . only @xmath73% of onc stars display @xmath74 erg s@xmath19 ( preibisch & feigelson 2005 ) . in contrast , the inferred range of @xmath0 , @xmath1 to @xmath2 , would place bp psc well within the ( rather broad ) @xmath0 distribution of the class of rapidly rotating ( fk com - like ) g giants . the dozen or so members of this class range from @xmath75 to @xmath76 , with a median of @xmath77 ( gondoin 2005 ) . hence , the _ chandra _ identification of a weak x - ray source at the position of bp psc appears to throw some weight behind a post - main sequence classification for this star and supports a model in which the detected x - rays most likely arise from coronal activity , as a consequence of its rapid rotation rate ( see zms08 ) . the large angular momentum required to sustain such rapid rotation , in turn , would seem to be consistent with the notion that bp psc has recently consumed a companion star ( as proposed by zms08 ) , and is therefore an fk com - type star `` in the making '' ( as speculated by kastner et al . we have used the _ chandra _ x - ray observatory to detect a weak x - ray point source that is coincident with the centroids of optical / ir and submillimeter continuum emission from the disk - enshrouded , jet - driving field star bp psc . as the star s photosphere is obscured throughout the visible and near - infrared , the _ chandra _ x - ray source appears to represent the first detection of bp psc itself . chandra _ x - ray image yields no detection of the bp psc jet system , nor evidence that bp psc is associated with a young stellar group or cluster . from the median energy of the detected bp psc source photons ( @xmath66 kev ) , we infer an absorbing column @xmath33 = 22.9\pm0.2 $ ] and an x - ray luminosity @xmath78 erg s@xmath19 ) , with @xmath0 in the range @xmath1 to @xmath2 . the rather large median x - ray energy indicates that the x - rays most likely originate with magnetic activity , as opposed to shocks near the star , and hence are produced either in a stellar corona or in star - disk magnetospheric interaction regions . the inferred values of @xmath70 and @xmath79 are 12 orders of magnitude smaller than those typical of low - mass , pre - main sequence stars , but are well within the range observed for rapidly - rotating ( fk com - type ) g giant stars . hence , the _ chandra _ results favor an exotic model wherein the disk / jet system of bp psc is the result of its very recently engulfing a companion star or giant planet , as the primary star ascended the giant branch . image of bp psc and surrounding field , showing the jet system associated with bp psc ( adapted from zuckerman et al . right : _ broad - band ( 0.58.0 kev ) 75.5 ks exposure _ chandra_/acis image of the same field . only x - rays detected by acis ccds s2 ( lower region ) and s3 ( upper region ) are displayed ; the field of view is @xmath80 . the circles on each image indicate the positions of _ chandra _ x - ray sources , with radius proportional to signal - to - noise ratio ( specifically , radii [ arcsec ] are set to 2@xmath81 the source signal - to - noise ratio ; the smallest circles correspond to 3@xmath82 detections ) . in each image , north is up and east is to the left , and the position of bp psc is indicated by an arrow.,width=576 ]

bp psc is a remarkable emission - line field star that is orbited by a dusty disk and drives a parsec - scale system of jets . we report the detection by the _ chandra _ x - ray observatory of a weak x - ray point source coincident with the centroids of optical / ir and submillimeter continuum emission at bp psc . as the star s photosphere is obscured throughout the visible and near - infrared , the _ chandra _ x - ray source likely represents the first detection of bp psc itself . the x - rays most likely originate with magnetic activity at bp psc and hence can be attributed either to a stellar corona or to star - disk interactions . the log of the ratio of x - ray to bolometric luminosity , @xmath0 , lies in the range @xmath1 to @xmath2 . this is smaller than @xmath0 ratios typical of low - mass , pre - main sequence stars , but is well within the @xmath0 range observed for rapidly - rotating ( fk com - type ) g giant stars . hence , the _ chandra _ results favor an exotic model wherein the disk / jet system of bp psc is the result of its very recently engulfing a companion star or giant planet , as the primary star ascended the giant branch .

astro-ph0211101

more than thirty years after the discovery of radio pulsars , the problem of understanding the properties of condensed matter in the interior of neutron stars ( nss ) has remained largely unsolved . a promising way to obtain constraints on the equation of state of nss is represented by the study of thermal radiation ( peaking at x - ray energies ) from their surfaces . the observed spectra are expected to show , as a characteristic signature of radiative transfer effects induced by the atmosphere surrounding the ns , several absorption features . these , if correctly deciphered , could unveil the ns physics . however , no such features were ever detected in the x - ray spectrum of a neutron star until recently , when chandra and xmm - newton observed the radio - quiet ns 1e 1207.45209 . this peculiar source ( bignami et al.1992 ; mereghetti et al.1996 ) , located close to the center of the high galactic latitude ( @xmath0 ) supernova remnant g296.5 + 10.0 , was securely identified as a ns when fast pulsations ( p@xmath1424 ms ) were detected by chandra ( zavlin et al.2000 ) ; a second chandra observation led to the discovery of two broad absorption features in its x - ray spectrum ( sanwal et al . 2002 ) . here we report on an xmm - newton observation ( 30 ksec ) performed on 2001 , december . the high throughput of the epic instrument allowed for a deeper study of the phenomenology of 1e 1207.45209 . see mereghetti et al.(2002 ) for more details . we measured a period of [email protected] ms , implying a surprisingly low value of the period derivative , @xmath3=([email protected])@xmath410@xmath5 s s@xmath6 , in agreement with ( but more accurate than ) the chandra estimate ( pavlov et al . 2002 ) . the pulse shape does not present any significant energy dependence ( see fig.1 ) , at variance with the findings of pavlov et al.(2002 ) , who reported some evidence for a phase shift of [email protected] between the energy bands 0.3 - 1.0 and 1.0 - 1.7 kev . if the latter result is confirmed , it might imply a time - variable light curve . the spectrum of 1e 1207.4 - 5209 is characterized by two broad absorption features at 0.7 and 1.4 kev ( sanwal et al.2002 ) . figure 2 presents the results of the analysis of the epic pn spectrum by showing the residuals obtained with different models . * panel 1 : a simple blackbody fits is clearly inadequate * panel 2 : the weakly - magnetized hydrogen atmosphere model by zavlin et al.(1996 ) , although possibly inappropriate to the case of 1e 1207.4 - 5209 ( inferred b@xmath8 g ) , gives residuals very similar to the blackbody fit . * panel 3 : models of ns atmospheres with solar abundance ( gnsicke et al.2002 ) give unacceptable fits , since the predicted features are much narrower than the observed ones . the same is true for fe composition . * panel 4 : acceptable fits required the inclusion of two absorption lines , that we modeled for simplicity as gaussian lines : here we give the residuals to a blackbody@xmath9lines fit . * panel 5 : a further improvement was obtained by adding a power law : we believe that this reflects the shortcomings of other models alone to reproduce the low - energy part of this complex spectrum , rather than being evidence for a distinct non - thermal component . * panel 6 : for completeness , the residuals to an hydrogen atmosphere@xmath9lines fit are shown here . the plots in panels 4@xmath76 show that the broad feature at 0.7 kev is not well described by a single gaussian line . significant substructures suggest that the feature may be due to the blending of several narrower lines . the epic pn data were divided in four subsets corresponding to the phase intervals shown in fig.1 . the resulting spectra provide striking evidence of pulse - phase variations of the spectral features . this is clearly shown in fig.3 : we have fitted a blackbody+power law model after excluding the energy bands corresponding to the features . the residuals on the overall energy range show that the line at 1.4 kev is more pronounced during the minimum and the rising part of the pulse profile , while it is almost unvisible during the pulse peak . the feature below 1 kev presents a significant variation in shape , possibly due to different contributions of several narrower lines during the various phase intervals . our xmm - epic observation of 1e 1207.4 - 5209 has shown new , crucial details of the phenomenology of this puzzling source . the timing analysis yielded a very low value for the period derivative . the resulting characteristic age , @xmath10 kyrs , turns out to be much higher than the age of the host supernova remnant,@xmath11 10 kyears . this discrepancy can be settled by supposing that the ns was born with a spin period very similar to the observed one . most important , the spectral analysis has revealed that the absorption features have significant substructure and are phase - dependent . this strongly supports an interpretation in terms of atomic transitions in the neutron star atmosphere , different regions with different physical conditions being responsible for the emission visible at different phases . the actual chemical composition of the atmosphere is an open problem : sanwal et al.(2002 ) proposed once ionized helium in a superstrong magnetic field ( @xmath12 g , hardly conciliable with the value inferred from the pulsar spin parameters ) ; we prefer an interpretation in terms of heavier elements in a more conventional ( @xmath13 g ) magnetic field . indeed , hailey & mori ( 2002 ) suggested that the lines could be produced by he - like oxigen or neon , predicting the presence of substructures in the broad features . a second , very deep ( 250 ksec ) xmm observation of 1e 1207.4 - 5209 has now been successfully performed ( august 2002 ) . the new data will allow for a more detailed analysis of phase - resolved spectra . this will yield important and maybe conclusive information on the atmosphere composition , hopefully providing firm constraints on the other neutron star parameters . bignami g.f . , caraveo p.a . & mereghetti s. 1992 , apj 389 , l67 . gnsicke b.t . , braje t.m . & romani r.w . 2002 , a&a , 386 , 1001 . hailey c. j. & mori k. , 2002 , apjl accepted , astro - ph/0207590 mereghetti s. , bignami g.f . & caraveo p.a . 1996 , apj 464 , 842 . mereghetti s. , de luca , a. , caraveo , p.a . , mignani , r.p . , beker , w. and bignami , g.f . , 2002 , apj accepted , astro - ph/0207296 pavlov g.g . 2002 , apj 569 , l95 . sanwal d. , pavlov g.g . , zavlin v.e & teter m.a . 2002 , apj 574 , l61 . zavlin v.e . , pavlov g.g . & shibanov yu.a . 1996 , a&a 315 , 141 .

we have observed the radio - quiet x - ray pulsar 1e 1207.45209 with the high throughput epic cameras onboard xmm - newton . the spectrum of this peculiar source is characterized by two broad absorption features which present significant substructures and show a clear phase - dependence . we believe that these features represent a strong evidence for the presence of a magnetized atmosphere containing heavy elements . # 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in

1105.3151

most spiral galaxies have rather sharp edges in their stellar disks . the situation for the milky way is unclear . the disk of our galaxy is well represented by an exponential density profile @xcite , with some evidence for a stellar disk cut - off at a radius of @xmath1 kpc towards the anticentre region @xcite , but other claims for a warped and flaring stellar disk out to 23 kpc . based upon the scaling relation established by other galaxies , the radial cut off should be between 10 and 25 kpc @xcite . here we report observations of `` clump red giant '' stars , which are good distance indicators @xcite , along 10 lines of sight in the disk of the milky way . the data reveal an edge to the disk at @xmath2 kpc . why there should be a sharp edge to the stars , while the gas profile is much more extended and does not show such an edge , remains unclear , but a critical test would be the measurement of the gas and star density in situ @xcite . there are two new deep surveys of the milky way disk in the near - infrared : the ukidss galactic plane survey ( gps ) , that is mapping the northern disk @xcite , and the vista variables in the _ va lctea _ ( vvv ) survey , that is mapping 520 square degrees in the southern disk and bulge of our galaxy @xcite . while previous observations in the galactic plane have been limited by crowding , source dimness , and interstellar extinction , these new public surveys allow us to pierce through the whole disk , reaching red giants in the horizontal branch ( clump giants ) located at the other side of our galaxy for the first time in different near - ir pass - bands . the vvv survey observes in the @xmath3 ( 0.87 microns ) , @xmath4 ( 1.02 microns ) , @xmath5 ( 1.25 microns ) , @xmath6 ( 1.64 microns ) , and @xmath7 ( 2.14 microns ) bands , while the ukidss - gps is observing in the @xmath5 ( 1.25 microns ) , @xmath6 ( 1.64 microns ) , and @xmath8 ( 2.14 microns ) bands ; with the photometry uniformly calibrated in the 2mass system @xcite . clump giants are excellent tools to study the structure of our galaxy because of two main reasons , discussed below : ( i ) they are good distance indicators , and ( ii ) they are good tracers of the mass in the disks of galaxies . the ukidss - gps and vvv surveys give the largest homogeneous census of clump giants out to well beyond the extent of the milky way stellar disk . the limiting dophot @xcite magnitude of single epoch vvv images processed by the cambridge astronomical survey unit ( casu ) pipeline v1.0 is @xmath9 in the disk fields , and the dophot photometry on the combined epochs allow to reach approximately @xmath10 mag , and @xmath11 mag ( fig . [ cmd ] ) , slightly fainter than the ukidss - gps , and much fainter than the near - ir surveys 2mass and denis , for which the limit is @xmath12 mag @xcite . the distance probed along the line of sight depends on the reddening of the fields . for example , in disk fields with low extinction ( @xmath13 mag ) the ukidss - gps and vvv surveys would see clump giants beyond 50 kpc . therefore we can search for the edge of the disk of our galaxy using well calibrated standard candles . the clump giants with known parallaxes measured by the hipparcos satellite are the best collectively calibrated standard candles @xcite . figure [ cmd ] shows a colour - colour and colour - diagram magnitude for the vvv field d003 . in order to select the giant stars a colour cut was applied in the @xmath7 @xmath14 ( @xmath15 ) , as shown in left - hand and central panels of fig . not all selected stars are clump giants , but the presence of sub - giant branch and red - giant branch stars , or even main - sequence stars at fainter magnitudes , contribute to the smooth underlying background . these different population do not affect the location of any sharp edges of the stellar distribution , which can however be well defined by the clump giants . the effect of reddening in the selection of clump giants was also tested using different selection criteria both in the colour - magnitude and colour - colour diagrams , finding consistent results . an accurate @xmath8-band calibration of the red clump giant luminosity was obtained and applied to the red giant clump of the galactic bulge @xcite , and of the large magellanic cloud @xcite . our magnitudes are in the 2mass magnitude system , and we transformed the @xmath8-band magnitudes of clump giants of hipparcos @xcite to @xmath7 magnitudes using @xmath16 . the resulting zero point differences should be less than 0.02 magnitudes @xcite . for the ks photometry , the distance modulus to a red clump giant in the outer disk would be : @xmath17-m_{k_{\rm s}}\]]where we adopted @xmath18 , @xmath19 and @xmath20 as the mean values for the red clump giants of the milky way disk @xcite . there should be negligible metallicity dependence of these mean values because we are looking at a stellar population of the milky way disk that should be similar to that of the solar neighbourhood where hipparcos distances of clump giants were calibrated . adopting these means magnitudes and colours , and the reddening coefficients @xcite yields : @xmath21 using this equation we computed the distance modulus ( and distance in kpc ) for every single clump giant candidate in the fields . for the ukidss - gps @xmath8-band data the computations are the same , but with @xmath22 , @xmath23 and @xmath24 . in order to determine the disk edge we computed the distribution in distance for the clump giants in each field . thus we coadded the distance distribution of fields located above and below the plane at same galactic longitude . the coadded distance distribution for each longitude was analyzed non - parametrically using the local likelihood density estimation method @xcite . finally , the derivative method was applied for the distribution curve . this method is simple and robust , and can be used to detect the structures in the distance distribution . we defined as the disk edge the outermost point of minimum derivative in each case . the uncertainties were calculated with a monte carlo procedure , assuming poisson errors . the uncertainties due to the photometric errors do not produce any trend in the calculations and are much smaller than the statistical error . the resulting distance distributions along different lines of sight are shown in fig . [ dist ] . in all fields there is a density drop in the clump giant distribution at a corresponding galactocentric distance of about 13.9 kpc ( assuming @xmath25 kpc ) , as listed in table [ table ] . we first noticed the sharp termination of the clump giant distribution in the color - magnitude diagram of the vvv field d001 ( @xmath26 ) , a very heavily reddened area located in the outskirts of the carina star forming region @xcite . similar behavior is also found in ukidss - gps data for different galactic longitudes @xcite . we studied low - extinction fields across the milky way disk ( see table [ table ] ) . when these were available , we selected pairs of fields located above and below the plane at the same galactic longitude , in order to account for the galactic warp , because if the disk is warped , the line of sight can leave the stellar disk before this ends . for example , at @xmath27 the mean warp location is @xmath28 below the plane @xcite , so the selected vvv field d003 is conveniently located to probe the full extent of the disk . at most other longitudes explored here the warp is absent , with the mean plane being at @xmath29 ( fig . [ map ] ) . we have also explored a few other ukidss - gps fields located at inner longitudes that yield lower distances . these fields with @xmath30 were discarded because they are heavily reddened and crowded , and the photometry is not as deep as the rest , presumably due to enhanced contamination from the near - side of the inner bar . systematic errors such as variations of the reddening law have not been included . it is important to note that the present results are independent of models . they rely on basic assumptions such as that the hipparcos stellar sample is representative of the entire the milky way disk , and that clump giants are reliable distance indicators and tracers of the old and intermediate age populations . however , the besanon galactic model with a scale - length of 2.4 kpc , including a flaring and warped outer disk , with a disk cutoff at @xmath31 kpc seems to reproduce well the observed distance distributions ( see fig.[model ] ) . data and model show the same features , with a sharp increase , the peak around 5 kpc and the exponential decrease . the edge is detected in the data and model at the expected place within the errors [ @xmath32 kpc ( corresponding to @xmath33 kpc ) , and @xmath34 kpc ( @xmath35 kpc ) , respectively ] . a few studies have discussed the edge of the milky way towards the anticentre region previously . the old galactic disk apparently does not extend beyond 14 kpc on the basis of optical @xmath36 vs. @xmath37 colour - magnitude diagrams and star counts @xcite , which does not contradict the presence of other more distant young stars . models of the cobe - dirbe infrared emission maps yield that the edge of the disk is at 4 kpc from the sun ( assuming @xmath38 kpc , * ? ? ? denis star counts reveal the cut off of the stellar disk at a galactocentric distance of @xmath39 kpc . in contrast , star counts from 2mass reveal no radial disk truncation at 14 kpc . again , the depth of 2mass is not enough to reach large distances , which is possible with the vvv and ukidss - gps survey that reach 3 - 4 magnitudes fainter . more recently , it was found that the 2mass star counts are best fit if the external disk is truncated at 12 - 14 kpc , while early a - type stars in the anticentre from the iphas survey reveal an exponential disk out to 13 kpc , with a steeper decline beyond that distance @xcite . most of the previous evidence for cutoffs in the stellar distribution has been acquired at the anticentre fields . the present deep exploration of different fields in three galactic quadrants finds consistent results . even though we interpret this termination of the clump giant distribution as a truncation , we note that a break in the slope of the distribution would also be consistent with the data . it is difficult to measure the sharpness of the cutoff , because the number of stars drop rapidly with distance , but as the surveys progress , we will have more fields in order to explore this issue . this does not mean that one could not find other young stellar sources beyond the distance that we measure . there are stars detected beyond the edge of the old stellar disk . for example , there is a population of distant young stars at @xmath40 kpc , in two fields located in the third quadrant , slightly above the plane ( at @xmath41 and @xmath42 ) , based on @xmath43 photometry @xcite . we see no evidence of a large population of clump giants at that distance in our fields . @xmath8-band light traces mass in the disks of spiral galaxies @xcite , and the integrated @xmath8-band luminosity is dominated by red giants . thus the clump giants are ideal tracers to define overall features and structural parameters of our milky way , like the edge of its disk . the red clump giants trace the old and intermediate age populations , which are more uniformly distributed than young stars , following the mass of the galactic disk . however , thick disk and halo giants are expected to be located beyond the edge of the stellar thin disk , as have been detected by the segue project @xcite , contributing to the background that we see in all fields beyond a galactocentric distance of 13.9 kpc . a similar result has been recently obtained independently by the glimpse team ( benjamin et al . 2011 , in preparation ) . finally , we are able to determine not only the extension but also the shape of the stellar disk of our galaxy for the first time . asymmetric features such as lopsidedness are common in spiral galaxies @xcite . however , the results shown in fig . [ map ] suggest that the stellar disk of the milky way is not significantly lopsided . we acknowledge support by the fondap center for astrophysics , basal cata center for astrophysics and associated technologies , milenio milky way millennium nucleus from mideplan , fondecyt from conicyt , and the european southern observatory . rs acknowledges financial support from conicyt through gemini project nr . we gratefully acknowledge use of data from the vista telescope , and data products from the cambridge astronomical survey unit , and the two micron all sky survey ( 2mass ) , which is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and ipac / caltech , funded by nasa and nsf .

we use the clump giants of the disk as standard candles calibrated from hipparcos parallaxes in order to map their distribution with two new near - ir surveys of the galactic plane : ukidss - gps and vvv . we explore different selection cuts of clump giants . we conclude that there is an edge of the stellar disk of the milky way at @xmath0 kpc along various lines of sight across the galaxy . the effect of the warp is considered , taking fields at different longitudes and above and below the plane . we demonstrate that the edge of the stellar disk of the milky way can now be mapped in the near infrared in order to test different models , and to establish our own place within the galaxy .

0709.4100

in an informative display of supernovae light curves ( fig.1 in physics today , july 2007 , p 17 ) it was clear that sn2006gy was about `` 10 times brighter than the peak luminosity of type ia '' . implied was a total radiated energy `` two orders of magnitude '' greater than ordinary supernovae . the first question that naturally arises is : with what certainty is its distance from the observer known ? the smith et al . paper@xmath0 mentions that the galaxy in which sn2006 appears is a `` minor member of the perseus cluster '' . indeed it is , ngc 1260 , with a redshift of 5703 km / sec . but readers who are familiar with the sky recognize this as the perseus - pisces cluster which extends over large regions of the sky . in fact it extends in filaments over about 90 degrees in angle which would require a structure of startlingly large size at its redshift distance of 74 mega parsecs . detailed information on this large region is available from the long term cataloguing work done by fritz zwicky and his associates . the galaxies in this large region down to the classification limit of the palomar 18-inch schmidt are shown in arp@xmath1 figs . the strongest line of galaxies , however , consists mostly of e s and s0 s originating from the large sb ( ngc 891 ) and ending on ngc 1260 and the supernova sn2006gy . all the galaxies with redshifts @xmath2 as given in ned are shown here in figure 1 . in the eastern end of the perseus - pisces filament ( from the ned catalogue courtesy d. carosati ) . note that the subclusters are elongated along the filament and the filament appears to start at ngc 891 . [ fig1],width=566 ] although the galaxies in the line originating in ngc 891 are predominantly in the 5300 to 5700 km / sec range of redshift , the redshift of ngc891 itself is only cz = 528 km / sec . it is intriguing to note that it would imply a distance closer by a factor 10 and luminosity smaller by about a factor of 100 for the supernova if its progenitor had been ejected out of ngc 891 along with some of the higher redshift material . in fact there are 13 smaller galaxies within 5 deg of ngc 891 with redshifts @xmath3 . one could take the least radical position that sn2006gy ocurred in such a companion that was faint enough to escape spectroscopic measurement . the near proximity ( 1 ) to ngc 1260 would then be an accident . but i believe there is enough evidence that large galaxies like ngc 891 eject material which becomes higher redshift companions that i would argue for the ejection of the supernova progenitor in that process . that ngc 891 could have ejected the extremely active radio , x - ray , infra red galaxy perseus a ( ngc 1275 ) is suggested by the elongation of the perseus a cluster back along the line to ngc 891 . moreover the ngc 891 minor axis is only about 18 deg . off the line to per a. of course the low redshift material which gave rise to the supernova would have had to have been entrained along with the ejection of the higher redshift cluster galaxies . that companion galaxies have an ejection origin along the minor axes of edge on disk galaxies was first pointed out by holmberg@xmath4 whose observations demonstrated in 1969 preferential alignment along minor axes of disk galaxies . it was then demonstrated by arp@xmath5 and lpez corredoira and gutirrez@xmath6 that companions came out in a cone with half opening angle about 35 degrees and quasars within @xmath7 degrees . as mentioned , the minor axis of ngc 891 is aligned with the nearest galaxies in fig 1 and to within about 18 deg . of the perseus cluster to the east . as for entraining low redshift material from the parent there are now a number of cases where smaller dwarfs are considered to be physical companions which have arisen as fragments from disturbed regions of parent galaxies . a good example of this is ngc 5985 in fig.2 where this seyfert galaxy has ejected a quasar but only 2.4 arcsec from it is attached a dwarf with the same small redshift as the big , low redshift , parent galaxy . , width=529 ] but perhaps the strongest argument for the ejection origin of the perseus cluster extending eastward from ngc 891 is the study of the 20 brightest galaxies in apparent magnitude north of declination = 0 deg . of the 14 that are uncrowded by nearby bright galaxies , a total of 13 have well marked lines and concentrations of fainter , higher redshift galaxies@xmath1 . figure 3 shows the range in redshift of the lines of fainter galaxies which are strongly associated with almost every bright galaxy in the sky . this 1990 study was followed by a 2001 study of 14 examples of higher redshift abell clusters which were paired and aligned across bright apparent magnitude galaxies@xmath8 . , width=491 ] if such strong ejections take place it is reasonable to expect some of the material of the ejecting galaxy to be carried along with it . along with ejected gas and plasma which is observed we only need to include a few old stars or groups of stars among which to find the very occasional supernova . supernovae of type ia are much discussed today because of their interpretation in terms of a universe that is expanding faster now than in the past - in other words , dark energy. but if their luminosity is over estimated the sole reason for this radical postulate falls . if the distance to sn2006gy is strongly overestimated this may also effect to some extent the models of supernovae on which dark energy has been hypothesized . generally one could reason that objects at appreciably large distances tend to be younger because of the look - back time . younger objects tend have built up less metal abundance which in turn lowers the luminosity of objects like cepheid variables . if intrinsic redshifts of younger material is operative , galaxies like the perseus cluster would need low particle masses@xmath5 to explain their apparent association with ngc 891 . the smaller elementary particle masses would give smaller luminosities of objects in those galaxies . all of these effects would combine in the direction of making the hubble constant appear lower in the past and lead to the impression that it was speeding up at present . ironically , if we move sn2006gy to this closer distance it could reinstate supernovae i as , at least , approximate distance indicators . n. smith et al . j. and http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0612617 ( version 3 ) .

a recent supernova has been reported as exceeding `` the light output of an ordinary supernova by at least two orders of magnitude '' . it is noted that it falls in a minor galaxy in the perseus cluster . some evidence indicating a ten times closer distance for the perseus cluster than its redshift distance is discussed here .

astro-ph0002065

stars at the very bottom of the main sequence have been a very popular topic of research during the last few years , including in studies of stellar activity . fleming , schmitt , & giampapa ( 1995 ) demonstrated that fully - convective m dwarfs , i.e. those with masses less than 0.3 m@xmath3 , exhibit high levels of coronal activity , although at that time , virtually no x - ray detections had been made of stars less massive than vb 8 and lhs 3003 ( both type m7 . ) the star vb 10 ( a.k.a . gl 752 b , lhs 474 ; type m8 ) appeared to have been marginally detected once by the einstein high resolution imager and was catalogued by barbera et al . then linsky et al . ( 1995 ) reported the detection of a large amplitude flare on vb 10 in the far uv using the goddard high resolution spectrograph . more recently , neuhauser & comron ( 1998 ) have detected x - ray emission from a very young brown dwarf in chameleon . this confirms that activity does exist for the very lowest mass stellar ( or substellar ) configurations . we have used the rosat high resolution imager ( hri ) to reobserve vb 10 , which was not detected by the rosat position sensitive proportional counter ( pspc ) during either the all - sky survey or a 7.3-ksec pointed observation ( fleming et al . 1993 ) . by obtaining a deeper exposure , we hoped to discover the nature of the vb 10 corona , detect its quiescent x - ray luminosity , and compare its level of coronal activity to that of the more massive m dwarfs . we have succeded in detecting x - ray emission from vb 10 , but only during a brief flare similar to the one observed by linsky et al . ( 1995 ) at ultraviolet wavelengths . in this paper , we present the latest rosat data on vb 10 . section 2 contains a description of the observations and data analysis . in section 3 , we discuss a hypothesis to account for the stark contrast between the flare and non - flare x - ray flux values , including the possibility of a total lack of @xmath2 k coronal plasma about vb 10 . the star vb 10 was observed during the period of 1997 october 27 - 31 for a total of 21,992 sec with the rosat hri ( zombeck et al . 1990 ) . the total image is shown in fig . 1a . the one obvious x - ray source seen in fig . 1 is positionally coincident with the star wolf 1055 ( type m3.5 ve ) , which has a common proper motion with vb 10 . at the position of vb 10 , which is marked in fig . 1a , there is only a marginal detection . however , when the data are separated into their individual observation intervals ( obis ) , we find that all of the photons in the vb 10 detection are contained within one single obi ( figs . 1b and 1c ) . this particular obi , which began on ut 1997 october 29 at 3:05:24 and ended at 3:25:43 , had an effective total exposure time of 1,138 sec . within an extraction radius of @xmath4 around the optical position of vb 10 , 11 photons were detected . by examining the rest of the image , we determined that the density of background photons for this obi was 0.0024 cts arcs@xmath5 . the solid angle of our extraction circle about vb 10 was 452.4 arcs@xmath6 , which means that we would expect one photon in the extraction circle to be from the background . therefore , with 10 source photons , the mean count rate over the entire obi is @xmath7 cts s@xmath1 ( this includes a deadtime and vignetting correction factor of 1.017 . ) of course , to get a better idea of the flare duration and flux , one needs to look at the temporal distribution of the source photons throughout the observation . in fig 2 , we show a histogram in arrival time for the 11 photons contained within the source extraction radius . remember , we do not know which one is the background photon . the histogram is binned in 3-minute ( 180 sec ) intervals over the nearly 20-minute observation . one can see that 5 photons arrived in the first 3 minutes of the observation , 5 photons arrived during the last 8 minutes , with the remaining photon arriving in between . the data are consistent with there being only one flare which is tailing off during our observation . in this case , the flare duration is at least 20 minutes and @xmath8 cts s@xmath1 ( 5 photons in 3 minutes ) represents a lower limit to the peak count rate . in order to get the x - ray luminosity , we adopt a conversion factor of @xmath9 ergs cm@xmath5 cnt@xmath1 . this comes from table 10 of david et al . ( 1999 ) , the rosat hri calibration report ( cambridge : sao ) ] , for a raymond - smith spectrum of 0.5 kev and negligible interstellar absorption . this yields an apparent energy flux , @xmath11 ergs cm@xmath5 s@xmath1 for the mean count rate . at a distance of 5.74 pc , this gives us a luminosity , @xmath12 ergs s@xmath1 . again , this is just a mean luminosity for the observation . the peak flare luminosity would be at least @xmath13 ergs s@xmath1 . we have also analyzed the remaining 20,854 sec of our hri observation , in which no x - ray source was detected at the position of vb 10 . using the non - detection analysis software in midas / exsas , we have calculated a @xmath14 ( i.e. 99.7% confidence ) upper limit of @xmath15 cts s@xmath1 . this translates into @xmath14 upper limits on the apparent x - ray flux and x - ray luminosity of @xmath16 ergs cm@xmath5 s@xmath1 and @xmath17 ergs s@xmath1 , respectively , for vb 10 outside of flare . these are upper limits on any quiescent emission , if it exists . all of the numbers presented in this section have been tabulated in table 1 . lclllr flare ( mean ) & 1.14 & @xmath18 & @xmath19 & @xmath20 & @xmath21 flare ( peak ) & 0.18 & @xmath22 & @xmath23 & @xmath24 & @xmath25 non - flare & 20.85 & @xmath26 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 & @xmath29 this x - ray flare on vb 10 is reminiscent of the far - uv flare which was detected on vb 10 by linsky et al . these authors observed c ii , iv and si iv emission lines only during the last five minutes of an hour - long exposure taken with the ghrs onboard hst . they concluded that the flare which they had observed indicated increased magnetic heating rates for low - mass stars near the hydrogen - burning mass limit . in both the uv and rosat x - ray observations , quiescent ( i.e. non - flare ) emission was never detected from vb 10 . for the uv flare , the emission line fluxes were an order of magnitude greater than the upper limits placed on the non - flare emission by linsky et al . ( 1995 ) . for this most recent x - ray flare , the contrast is even greater . the peak flare luminosity is _ at least _ more than two orders of magnitude greater than the non - flare value . for ease of comparison to more massive m dwarfs , we will normalize l@xmath30 by l@xmath31 , which for vb 10 is @xmath32 ergs s@xmath1 based on the absolute k magnitude measured by leggett ( 1992 ) and the bolometric correction of veeder ( 1974 ) . this gives us log ( l@xmath30/l@xmath33 for the peak of the flare and log ( l@xmath30/l@xmath34 outside of flare . using the data of fleming et al . ( 1995 ) for the late ( later than m5 ) , presumably fully - convective m dwarfs within 7 pc of the sun , we find that these star have values of log ( l@xmath30/l@xmath31 ) which are typically @xmath35 . but during flares ( e.g. az cnc ; fleming et al . 1993 ) , these stars can reach values of ( l@xmath30/l@xmath36 to @xmath37 . therefore , the magnitude of the flare on vb 10 is completely consistent with that of flares on more massive m dwarfs . in fig . 3 we display a plot of normalized x - ray luminosity versus absolute visual magnitude for all known m dwarfs within 7 pc that are later than m5 , based on data from a volume - limited survey by fleming et al . inspection of fig . 3 reveals the sharp contrast between the upper limit to the non - flare x - ray emission in vb 10 and the x - ray emission levels of other late dme stars . in particular , the upper limit for vb 10 is 1 - 2 orders of magnitude less than that detected in the late dme stars . it is comparable to the upper limit for gj1002 in fig . 3 , a quiescent dm5.5 star that does not exhibit h@xmath38 emission nor any reported flare activity . by contrast , vb 10 is a known flare star with ( variable ) h@xmath38 line emission in its spectrum . while one can not build a theory based on one observation , we can not help but speculate that our result for vb 10 does indeed reflect a decline in coronal heating efficency near the h - burning mass limit . but somehow these stars are still able to flare . we do not understand in detail the mechanisms that give rise to energetic , transient outbursts identified as `` flares '' in the sun and late - type stars . however , flares do appear to be the result of instabilities that return stressed systems toward configurations that are characterized by lower potential energy ( rosner & vaiana 1978 ) . since we do not have an x - ray spectrum , we can not verify through modeling that the observed emission in vb 10 is consistent with the presence of loop - like magnetic structures . however , the energetics of the event suggest the possible occurrence of a large volume of flare plasma , implying the presence of large - scale magnetic structures in the atmosphere . in particular , we can crudely estimate the plausible range of spatial scales that characterize the flare event in the following manner . in the absence of an actual energy spectrum ( such as the pulse - height spectra that were produced by the now - defunct rosat pspc ) , we assume some plausible flare plasma parameters . based on x - ray observations of other flare events on m dwarfs , we adopt a flaring temperature of @xmath39 10@xmath40 k. we note that a large flare event recorded by the rosat pspc on a late m dwarf star was well - described by a thermal plasma model fit characterized by a temperature of 2 4 @xmath41 10@xmath40 k ( sun et al . 1999 ) . utilizing the xspec analysis package combined with the observed flux from the hri and the adopted temperature yields a differential emission measure at the flare maximum of em @xmath42 @xmath43 . the corresponding volume emission measure is @xmath44 where r@xmath45 = 0.102 r@xmath46 ( linsky et al . 1995 ) . given this estimate of volume emission measure along with electron densities in the range of @xmath47 10@xmath48 @xmath49 to 10@xmath50 @xmath49 , we find characteristic linear dimensions for the flare in the range of 0.003 r@xmath45 to 0.30 r@xmath45 . thus , the flaring plasma covers a large fraction of the stellar surface if @xmath47 10@xmath48 @xmath49 , but only a small fraction if @xmath51 10@xmath50 @xmath49 . we note that the distance traveled by a sound wave in a 10@xmath40 k plasma in the 3 minute duration of the flare maximum is about 0.7 r@xmath45 . these estimates , while not conclusive , are consistent with the likely occurrence of large - scale magnetic structures associated with the flare event on vb 10 . the enormous contrast between the x - ray flare luminosity and the upper limit to quiescent emission invites further consideration , especially in view of the likely existence of significant surface magnetic flux and large magnetic structures in vb 10 . we note that if vb10 is characterized by quiescent x - ray emission at a level which is typical for the sun at the maximum in its activity cycle , i.e. , log(@xmath52 -6.3 ( following schmitt 1997 ) , then we would still not have had sufficient sensitivity to detect it . the upper limit for non - flare x - ray emission in vb 10 is more comparable to the levels of emission seen in earlier , more massive m dwarfs ( non - dme flare stars ) which are themselves characterized by x - ray emission levels that are in excess of solar , or log(@xmath53 -6 to -5 ( following fleming , schmitt & giampapa 1995 ) . we thus can not exclude the possibility that vb 10 does indeed have undetected , quiescent x - ray emission at the level of the sun or that of earlier , quiescent dwarf m stars . however , inspection of fig . 3 suggests that the low level of non - flare x - ray emission in vb 10 is unusual with respect to other late - type , active dme flare stars . we will therefore briefly consider a hypothesis that may account for the extremely low , or even the possible absence of , steady , quiescent heating in this very cool dwarf . while there is no comprehensive theory for coronal heating even in the case of the sun a common feature of current theories is that the origin of the nonradiative heating of the corona involves the interaction between turbulent convective motions in the photosphere and the footpoints of magnetic loops ( parker 1972 , 1983a , b , 1986 ; van ballegooijen 1986 and references therein ) . in this context , our observations of vb 10 may imply that at the photosphere there is simply not enough in the way of random motions at the loop footpoints to jostle the magnetic fields and , in turn , provide sufficient dynamical stresses to lead to detectable plasma heating to coronal ( @xmath54 10@xmath55 k ) temperatures . for example , a high magnetic field strength may suppress convective motions , analogous to the situation in sunspots which are also x - ray quiet . we further note that the very cool and dense photosphere of vb 10 is dominated in content by molecular hydrogen combined with neutral metals bound in molecules . thus , there are few ions to couple the magnetic field with the photospheric gas . we estimate by extrapolation from m dwarf model photospheres ( mould 1976 ) to the effective temperature of vb 10 ( t@xmath56 = 2600 k ; linsky et al . 1995 ) that the ionization fraction , @xmath57 , in the dense , upper photosphere of vb 10 is @xmath58 10@xmath59 . by contrast , @xmath58 10@xmath60 in the upper photosphere of the quiet sun ( vernazza , avrett , & loeser 1976 ) . in early m dwarfs we have that @xmath58 10@xmath61 ( following mould 1976 ) . hence , for stars in the temperature - density regime of vb 10 , the upper photospheres are characterized by ionization fractions that are 2 orders of magnitude less than that of earlier m dwarfs and 3 orders of magnitude below that of the sun . consequently , the interaction between the field and the ambient gas occurs deeper in the photosphere where the ionization fraction is higher but where sufficient energy to produce significant coronal heating is unable to propagate outward . the consequences for coronal heating of the occurrence of magnetic structures in very cool dwarfs such as vb 10 is summarized in the following argument due to f. meyer ( 1999 , private communication ; see also meyer & meyer - hofmeister 1999 ) . given that the gas pressure in the corona is typically negligible compared to the magnetic stresses , we must have that the magnetic field configuration , or `` loop '' , is force - free , or @xmath62 = 0 . thus , the electric currents must flow along the magnetic field lines . since for steady magnetic phenomena the current density is divergence - free ( @xmath63 = 0 ) , currents must also flow through the magnetic footpoints in the photosphere . in the cool and dense photosphere of stars such as vb 10 , the electrical conductivity is so low that any current system rapidly decays . from this it follows that the magnetic equilibrium must be current - free everywhere . that is , @xmath64 = 0 so that @xmath65 = 0 , and @xmath66 . given that the potential field is a minimum energy configuration , any further build - up and storage of magnetic field energy is excluded , implying no ( or only a relatively low degree ) of magnetic field - related heating of the atmosphere . at the very least , the decay rate of energy at the footpoints must be faster than any energy input derived from the interaction between motions in the upper photosphere and the magnetic loops , effectively quenching any non - radiative heating that might otherwise have occurred . clearly , the above picture as outlined can not explain flare events . instead , the transient or flare outbursts observed in these very cool stars must arise from more complex magnetic topologies where the storage of magnetic field energy occurs , but which do not have footpoints in the cool , dense underlying photosphere . in summary , we have confirmed that the m8 dwarf vb 10 ( gl 752 b ) does indeed emit x - rays . it is the lowest mass star on the main sequence which is known to do so . this emission , however , appears to be only transient in nature . the contrast between the flare x - ray flux and any possible non - flare ( i.e. , quiescent ) x - ray emission is at least two orders of magnitude . we note that x - ray emission in vb 10 at solar levels or even at the levels seen in earlier dwarf m ( non - dme ) stars would not be detected at our sensitivity limits . in comparison to dme stars later than m5 , the upper limit to the non - flare x - ray emission in vb 10 is unusually low . we have considered a hypothesis that the low ionization fraction and , hence , low conductivity , in the photosphere of vb 10 inhibits coronal heating to the point where quiescent , @xmath2 k coronal plasma may not even exist . in this scenario , the transient , presumably @xmath67 k coronal plasma which gives rise to the observed x - ray flare would then be associated with topologically complex magnetic field structures that do not have footpoints in the cool photosphere which is , in turn , dominated by neutral atomic and molecular species . should this scenario prove to be correct , then there may indeed be a drop in coronal activity at the bottom of the main sequence : not at the mass where stars become fully convective , as was once suggested , but at the hydrogen - burning mass limit itself . we acknowledge insightful discussions with f. meyer , b. durney and a. van ballegooijen whose ideas materially contributed to this work . taf acknowledges support from nasa grant nagw-3160 . msg also acknowledges support from nasa under the rosat guest observer program . the rosat project is supported by the german bundesministerium fr forschung und technologie ( bmft / dara ) and the max planck gesellschaft . barbera , m. , micela , g. , sciortino , s. , harnden , f.r . , jr . , & rosner , r. 1993 , , 414 , 846 fleming , t.a . , schmitt , j.h.m.m . , & giampapa , m.s . 1995 , , 450 , 401 fleming , t.a . , giampapa , m.s . , schmitt , j.h.m.m . , & bookbinder , j.a . 1993 , , 410 , 387 giampapa , m.s . , rosner , r. , kashyap , v. , fleming , t.a . , schmitt , j.h.m.m . , & bookbinder , j.a . 1996 , , 463 , 707 leggett , s.k . 1992 , , 82 , 351 linsky , j.l . , wood , b.e . , brown , a. , giampapa , m.s . , & ambruster , c. 1995 , , 455 , 670 meyer , e. & meyer - hofmeister , e. 1999 , , 341 , l23 mould , j. r. 1976 , , 48 , 443 neuhauser , r. & comeron , f. 1998 , science , 282 , 83 parker , e. n. 1972 , , 174 , 499 parker , e. n. 1983a , , 264 , 635 parker , e. n. 1983b , , 264 , 642 parker , e. n. 1986 , in proc . trieste workshop series , relations between chromospheric - coronal heating and mass loss in stars , ed . j. b. zirker and r. stalio ( sunspot : sacramento peak observatory ) , p. 199 peres , g. , orlando , s. , reale , f. , rosner , r. , & hudson , h. 1999 , , in press rosner , r. & vaiana , g. s. 1978 , , 222 , 1104 sun , x. , fenimore , e. e. , li , h. , wei , j. , hu , j. , zhao , y. 1999 , , submitted van ballegooijen , a. a. 1986 , , 311 , 1001 veeder , g.j . 1974 , , 79 , 1056 vernazza , j. e. , avrett , e. h. & loeser , r. 1976 , , 30 , 1 zombeck , m.v . , conroy , m. , harnden , f.r . , roy , a. , bruninger , h. , burkert , w. , hasinger , g. , & predehl , p. 1990 , , 1344 , 267

we have detected an x - ray flare on the very low mass star vb 10 ( gl 752 b ; m8 v ) using the rosat high resolution imager . vb 10 is the latest type ( lowest mass ) main sequence star known to exhibit coronal activity . x - rays were detected from the star during a single 1.1-ksec segment of an observation which lasted 22 ksec in total . the energy released by this flare is on the order of @xmath0 ergs s@xmath1 . this is at least two orders of magnitude greater than the quiescent x - ray luminosity of vb 10 , which has yet to be measured . this x - ray flare is very similar in nature to the far ultraviolet flare which was observed by linsky et al . ( 1995 ) using the goddard high resolution spectrograph onboard the hubble space telescope . we discuss reasons for the extreme difference between the flare and quiescent x - ray luminosities , including the possibility that vb 10 has no quiescent ( @xmath2 k ) coronal plasma at all .

astro-ph0308023

in recent months the wmap satellite has provided the clearest picture of temperature fluctuations in cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) to date @xcite . the power spectrum of these fluctuations is a sensitive function of the cosmological parameters , such as the total energy density , matter density , baryon density , hubble constant and others . the emerging model was convincingly confirmed : the universe is spatially flat , consisting mostly of `` dark energy '' that behaves like a cosmological constant , about 23% dark matter , and about 4% baryons . the sum of the neutrino masses is limited to be less than 0.7 ev , much more strict than the bound from terrestrial laboratories . the compton scattering optical depth implies an early reionization at redshift @xmath0 . these results will improve , as the wmap team plans to take at least 4 years of data . several profound questions arise from these results . to start , the nature of the dark matter and the dark energy are completely unknown . we understand the 4% in baryons , but the other 96% is a mystery . furthermore , there is an indication of a deficit of power on the largest scales ( in e.g. the quadrupole and octupole moments ) , but the meaning of this unclear . a finite universe is one among many unlikely possibilities . the snap satellite@xcite has been proposed to study the nature of the dark energy by measuring the hubble diagram ( redshift distance relation ) using type ia supernovae ( snia ) as standard candles , as has been done from the ground . ground based measurements of this kind have already shown that there is a large density of dark energy . the snap team hopes to study the equation of state @xmath1 of this material . a satellite is required to significantly extend the ground based results , as a large number of snia with redshifts @xmath2 is required : this tests the universe in its decelerating phase . the wavelengths of interest are redshifted into the infrared , thus the necessity of a space based instrument . furthermore , the exact nature of the progenitors of snia is unknown . a large sample can be split into many subsamples to study systematic effects . snap is fundamentally a large survey telescope , and should have a broad science reach . big bang nucleosynthesis ( bbn)@xcite tries to explain the primordial abundances of light elements , in particular the stable isotopes of hydrogen , helium and lithium . as a function of only the baryon to photon ratio , these abundances can be calculated by tracking the network of nuclear reactions in the hot big bang . the primordial abundance of deuterium depends sensitively on the one free parameter , thus deuterium measurements can provide an accurate assessment of the cosmological baryon density . lyman-@xmath3 clouds obscuring distant quasars presumably consist of predominantly unprocessed gas , and thus reflect primordial abundances . with the right column depth of hydrogen ( not so small that deuterium is unobservable , and not so large so that the damping wings of hydrogen cover the deuterium line ) , the primordial deuterium abundance is measured . at present , the implied baryon density is fully consistent with the wmap value , with comparable errors . to go further , many more such systems would be needed . suitable systems are currently found at the rate of one per year , so for now progress on the baryon density will come from cmb measurements . cosmological observations have the potential to probe planck - scale physics@xcite . inflationary theories usually predict that observable wavelengths ( e.g. galaxy and cluster scales ) originated during inflation as sub - planck fluctuations . thus , inflation can in principle probe quantum theories of gravity such as superstring theory . with not overly optimistic assumptions , a 1% modulation of the cmb fluctuations might be produced by planck - scale physics during inflation , detectable in the next decade or two . the standard cosmological model requires that 23% of the energy density in the universe is some form of non baryonic nearly collisionless clustering matter . a new stable particle would fit the bill , as has been known for several decades . in this regard the dark matter problem is more tractable than the dark energy problem dark matter `` looks like '' something we understand , while dark energy is completely mysterious . two possible candidates for dark matter have survived numerous tests and remain viable . the first is the lightest superpartner in supersymmetric extensions to the standard model , which is naturally stable , weakly interacting , and electrically neutral . the second is the axion , arising in a compelling solution to the strong cp problem . weakly interacting massive particles ( wimps ) , such as those in supersymmetric models can be detected in sensitive low background experiments by their rare scattering from atomic nuclei . the nuclear recoil deposits energy , which in principle is detectable . two such detectors currently running are cdms and dama . cdms@xcite uses germanium and silicon detectors . these are sensitive to both phonons and ionization . the ratio of these two signals powerfully discriminates against background , as nuclear recoils exhibit much lower ionization that most backgrounds ( electrons and gamma rays ) . cdms - i ran in a shallow site at stanford , and the final wimp exclusion results are now available . cdms - ii is currently running in the soudan mine , with new results anticipated by the end of 2003 . the dama@xcite detector uses nai scintillators . they do not have the background rejection capabilities of cdms , but instead rely on the annual modulation of the wimp signal : as the earth orbits the sun , its relative velocity with respect to the wimp `` wind '' is modulated by several tens of km s@xmath4 , leaving a rate modulation of a few percent . in the 4-year data such a modulation is seen , though the implied mass and cross section are nearly ruled out by other experiments ( cdms , edelweiss , zeplin ) . three more years of data have been released since the conference , and the modulation signal is strengthened . furthermore , the successor experiment libra is being installed now . the future of wimp searches requires that ton - scale detectors be constructed . the xenon proposal@xcite to use a two - phase detector for both scintillation light and ionization is a promising possibility for scalability to a one ton target mass . background can again be rejected by the lower levels of ionization from nuclear recoils relative to electronic processes . small prototypes are currently being tested . the construction of a 10 kg prototype is well underway . the goal is to build a 100 kg module ; with this a ton - scale detector could feasibly be built in the next decade . axions in the range micro- to milli - ev remain a viable dark matter candidate . they require a vastly different experimental approach : conversion to microwave photons in a magnetic field . these photons are then detected with with what is essentially a very sensitive radio receiver . the axion dark matter experiment admx is ongoing , already scanning deep in the allowed model range@xcite . upgraded receivers using squid amplifiers are on the way . as light pseudoscalars , axions have a bounded parameter space , as their interactions are essentially the same as neutral pions . the lowest allowed axion - photon couplings are within reach . energetic cosmic ray nuclei are an important probe of high energy processes in astrophysics@xcite . supernova blast waves are capable of accelerating protons to energies of 10@xmath5 ev , the `` knee '' in the spectrum where the power law shifts to a steeper value . very puzzling are the ultra high energy cosmic rays with energies in excess of 10@xmath6 ev . various acceleration mechanisms have been proposed , involving fr ii galaxies , interacting galaxies , jets in radio sources ( with lorentz factor 10 ) , gamma ray bursts ( with lorentz factor 300 ) , and others . top - down models have also been considered : uhecrs may arise in the decay chains of supermassive particles . whichever mechanism produces uhecrs , they must originate cosmologically nearby , within roughly 100 mpc . the gzk cutoff operates for nuclei above 10@xmath6 ev / a , where the threshold for pion photoproduction on the cmb is exceeded . uhe photons have a similar cutoff at lower energy , at the pair production threshold . the nature of the observed events above 10@xmath6 ev is unknown , and difficult to determine experimentally . nuclei such as iron , protons , photons , and neutrinos are all possibilities . the experimental situation in uhecrs is quite promising . the hires experiment@xcite consists of two air fluorescence detectors situated 12.6 km apart , allowing stereoscopic viewing of the air showers induced in the atmosphere . the dataset exhibits the gzk cutoff , though at low significance . the data are in agreement with agasa , the japanese particle detector , and the agasa data does not exhibit the cutoff . the relative calibration between air fluorescence and particle detectors is uncertain ; the flash collaboration@xcite at slac expects to measure this to better than 10% accuracy . hires does not see the clustering visible in the agasa data , though again the experiments are consistent . this of course dilutes the agasa evidence for clustering . the collaboration expects three more years of data to be taken , which may clear up the situation . the plan for the pierre auger project@xcite is to use both particle detectors ( with 100% duty cycle ) and air fluorescence detectors ( with 10% duty cycle ) . the project promises greatly enhanced statistics and cross - correlation between the two methods . two sites are planned : one in argentina to be fully operational in 2004 , and one in the northern hemisphere . 3000 events per year per site above 10@xmath7 ev are expected , with 30 per year per site above @xmath8 ev . the comparison of the two detector types will allow more accurate energy measurements , and furthermore the identification of the primary will be more certain ( e.g. proton vs. fe ) . at the southern site , a mountain range will act as a neutrino converter for low altitude primaries , so uhe neutrinos can be studied as well . at energies below 1 tev , the alpha magnetic spectrometer ( ams)@xcite will measure the spectra of cosmic ray species with higher accuracy that has been possible . of particular interest are several exotic possibilities , including antinuclei , dark matter , and quark matter `` strangelets '' . ams-01 , which flew on the space shuttle , placed limits on the antihelium to helium ratio of @xmath9 . ams-02 will be installed on the international space station as early as 2005 . with three years of data , the sensitivity to antihelium will be improved to @xmath10 . ams is sensitive to dark matter since annihilations in the galactic halo may produce anomalous levels of antiprotons and positrons at low to moderate energies , though very low energy particles are difficult to study because of the geomagnetic cutoff . ams will have some sensitivity to photons in the sub - tev range as well . a final possibility is the search for stable strangelets . they would be easily identified by their anomalous charge to mass ratios . overall , ams is a high statistics cosmic ray experiment , and will advance our knowledge considerably . the advent of large neutrino telescopes is exciting for high energy astrophysics . agns , grbs , microquasars , and dark matter annihilations are all interesting possible sources of neutrinos at gev energies and higher . the amanda array@xcite at the south pole uses strings of photomultipliers ( pmts ) deep in the ice to detect the tracks from ( primarily muon ) neutrinos . at 200 m in diameter and 400 m tall , it detects about 4 neutrinos per day , primarily atmospheric . from the 2000 dataset , no point sources were detected , but the photon flux limit was reached ( based on the expected relationship between photon and neutrino fluxes from hadronic processes ) . with timing information , grbs are within a single order of magnitude of detectability . over the next decade , amanda will be upgraded to icecube , with 80 strings totaling 4800 pmts , with an effective volume of a cubic km . neutrino energies from 50 gev to more than a pev will be studied . at high enough energies , the three neutrino flavors can be disentangled : electron from the shower characteristics , and tau from the `` double bang '' signature of the the recoil track and subsequent decay . icecube will be installed starting in 2004 , with completion expected in 2010 . antares@xcite is a complementary neutrino telescope to be built at the floor of the mediterranean . 12 cables totaling 1000 pmts will cover 0.1 km@xmath11 , spaced at intervals of 60 m . seawater has a longer scattering length but a shorter absorption length than ice . thus , the pmts must be closer together , but the angular resolution is superior : above 10 tev , a resolution of @xmath12 is expected . between amanda / icecube and antares , most of the sky will be covered . one string is currently running , and completion is planned for 2005 . the design for a km@xmath13 upgrade is also underway . the super kamiokande@xcite neutrino detector has also begun to do extra - solar neutrino astronomy . a search for the diffuse neutrino background from supernovae has been performed , and interesting limits have already been set . the future of nuclear and particle astrophysics looks bright . we have a standard cosmological model , but we understand very little about its matter and energy contents . we have observed very high energy processes , beyond the reach of terrestrial accelerators , but the results are puzzling . several programs of extra - solar neutrino astronomy are underway . the level of experimental activity is very encouraging . we fully expect many new and interesting results to be reported at cipanp 2006 . we thank all of the speakers in the nuclear and particle astrophysics session of cipanp 2003 for such interesting and informative talks , and we thank the organizers for putting on such a good conference . 99 spergel , d. n. et al . , astrophys . j. , in press ( 2003 ) . burles , s. , nollett , k. m. , & turner , m. s. , astrophys . j. lett . * 552 * , l1 ( 2001 ) . easther , r. , greene , b. r. , kinney w. h. , and shiu , g. , phys . d * 64 * , 103502 ( 2001 ) . akerib , d. s. , et al . , hep - ex/0306001 bernabei r. , et al . phys . lett . b * 480 * , 23 ( 2000 ) ; bernabei r. , et al . n. cim . * 26 * , 1 ( 2003 ) . aprile , e. , et al . , astro - ph/0207670 asztalos , s. j. , et al . , astrophys . j. * 571 * , l27 ( 2002 ) . gaisser , t. k. , and stanev , t. , `` cosmic rays , '' phys.rev . d * 66 * , 010001 ( 2002 ) . abu - zayyad , t. , et al . , astro - ph/0208301 malek , m. , et al . lett . * 90 * , 061101 ( 2003 ) .

in the nuclear and particle astrophysics session of cipanp 2003 we heard talks on a number of topics , focused for the most part into four broad areas . here we outline the discussions of the standard cosmological model , dark matter searches , cosmic rays , and neutrino astrophysics . the robustness of theoretical and experimental programs in all of these areas is very encouraging , and we expect to have many questions answered , and new ones asked , in time for cipanp 2006 . address = iscap , columbia astrophysics laboratory , mc 5247 , 550 w 120th st . , new york , ny 10027 , altaddress = kipac , slac , m / s 78 , 2575 sand hill rd . , menlo park , ca 94025 ( from sept . 2003 ) address = physics department , boston university , room 255 , 590 commonwealth ave . , boston , ma 02215

0910.1890

exact duality transformations for statistical mechanical systems with many degrees of freedom have provided a rich source of insights and alternative computational methods over the years @xcite . as lattice regularized quantum theories share much of the essential structure of lattice statistical mechanical models , it is natural to investigate analogous duality transformations . indeed , applications of duality to quantum fields on the lattice continues to grow ; recent examples include @xcite . in the present work , we shall focus on pure yang - mills theory as we expect it will be instructive to construct dual algorithms in this case before proceeding to dynamical fermions in the dual . for lattice gauge theory ( lgt ) with abelian groups such as @xmath6 and @xmath7 , it is well understood how to construct dual models useful for practical computations @xcite . however , dual simulations with non - abelian gauge groups have presented a greater challenge . the main difficulties have been the definition of the dual model in terms of practically computable amplitudes and the construction of an ergodic set of moves that can be used with a markov chain monte carlo method ( e.g. the metropolis algorithm ) . following some initial results on amplitudes for non - abelian lattice models in the specific case of @xmath8 and @xmath9 in @xcite , a procedure for obtaining non - abelian dual models in four and higher dimensions on the lattice was given by halliday and suranyi @xcite . more recently , a new mathematical framework for understanding the non - abelian dual transformation was constructed , the lattice spin foam formulation @xcite . with regard to numerical simulations , the spin foam approach is helpful for computing amplitudes ( particularly in the four - dimensional case @xcite ) as it gives an explicit prescription for the dual amplitudes in terms of spin networks . these spin networks can in turn be reduced in complexity from their initial definition by the use of diagrammatic recoupling methods @xcite , thus avoiding the typically explosive proliferation of tensorial algebra that would otherwise ensue . the spin foam construction also makes more transparent the distinction between irrep labels associated to plaquettes and intertwiner labels that are naturally associated to edges , as well as the admissibility constraints between these quantities necessary for a non - zero amplitude . in @xcite , these features were applied to the three dimensional case with @xmath9 , resulting in an explicit algorithm that was validated against conventional results . further details on the development and current status of this area can be found in @xcite . the present work may be viewed as a follow - up in four dimensions to the previous results in three dimensions that includes @xcite as well as earlier work by hari dass _ et al . _ @xcite . in the three - dimensional case , an explicit amplitude was known from @xcite and the primary challenge was finding an ergodic set of moves . in the present case , the four - dimensional ( hyper - cubic ) vertex amplitude is a non - trivial function of 48 spin variables , and it was nt until recently that a practical algorithm for this vertex amplitude @xcite was available . in this paper , we construct a set of ergodic moves ( detailed in the appendix ) which when combined with the amplitude of @xcite allow us to perform the first metropolis algorithm simulations of dual @xmath0 in four dimensions . we emphasize that the primary purpose of the present work was to validate the dual algorithm and its implementation against a conventional algorithm , in order to understand its performance over a range of couplings and to evaluate the severity of the sign problem in a simple setting . efforts to extend the methods to more observables such as wilson or polyakov loops are presently underway by the author . this paper is organized as follows . in section 2 , we briefly summarize the form of the dual model for an @xmath0 lattice gauge theory and define the observable to be computed . in section 3 , we describe how a conventional lattice code was constructed and used to compute expectation values of an appropriately chosen effective observable . section 4 summarizes the results obtained with the dual algorithm . the paper is concluded with some discussion of the sign problem and other features of the dual algorithm in section 5 . details of the moves that define the dual algorithm are provided in the appendix . in the present section we shall briefly review some essential features of the dual spin foam model in order to describe the simulations performed and results obtained . the reader is referred to @xcite for a derivation of spin foam duality motivated by simulations with @xmath9 in three dimensions ; its adaption to the present case of four dimensions can be found in @xcite . a general derivation of spin foam models can be found in @xcite . in a dual spin foam model , the continuous group - valued variables of the conventional theory are replaced by discrete labels . the plaquettes of the lattice are labelled by irreducible unitary representations of @xmath0 , typically taken as the half - integers ( although whole integers are sometimes used in diagrammatic methods ) . for a given plaquette labelling , each edge carries an intertwiner label , corresponding to one of a complete basis of maps that intertwine the irreps on plaquettes that intersect the edge . if an appropriate set of conditions is satisfied , than a particular labelling of plaquettes by irreps and edges by intertwiner labels is said to form an _ admissible _ spin foam . further details on these variables and the admissibility constraints among them are given in the appendix . as our present motivation is to evaluate the correctness and efficiency of the dual algorithm relative to the conventional formulation , we chose an observable that is particularly simple to compute in the dual model . such an observable is provided by the average value of the spin at a plaquette @xmath10 : @xmath11 where @xmath12 are the admissible spin foams , and @xmath13 is the dual amplitude , as reviewed in appendix [ sec : alg_append ] . the observable @xmath14 is the spin label assigned by spin foam @xmath15 to plaquette @xmath16 . the subscript @xmath17 on the lhs indicates evaluation of the observable against the dual ( as opposed to conventional ) amplitude @xmath13 . in section [ sec : conventional ] , we will describe how to define and compute the same observable within the conventional lgt framework . for concreteness , we define here precisely which amplitudes were used to generate the results given in section [ sec : results ] . in terms of the spin foam amplitude @xmath13 defined in equation ( [ eqn : partfun ] ) of the appendix , the vertex and edge amplitudes @xmath18 and @xmath19 are those defined in @xcite . the plaquette amplitude @xmath20 used comes from the _ heat kernel _ action , defined as follows : [ defn : heatkernel ] let @xmath21 and @xmath22 . let @xmath23 be the solution to the differential equation @xmath24 at @xmath25 , with initial condition @xmath26 . then the action @xmath27 defined implicitly by @xmath28 is known as the heat kernel action @xcite . it can be shown that the character expansion of the heat kernel action for @xmath0 is of the form @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the quadratic casimir eigenvalue associated to the @xmath31th representation ; for @xmath0 , @xmath32 . as the @xmath33 are absorbed into the vertex and edge amplitudes of the dual model , by inspection of ( [ eqn : hk_expansion ] ) the plaquette amplitude @xmath20 in equation ( [ eqn : partfun ] ) associated with the heat kernel action is thus @xmath34 ; the reader is referred to @xcite for further details . as we are working with a mathematically exact transformation between the conventional and dual forms of the lattice gauge theory , it is possible to validate the correctness of the dual algorithm by computing the same expectation value on both sides of the duality . we believe it is important to do so for several reasons . the dual vertex amplitude we make use of is relatively complex in both its derivation and final form @xcite . assuming that a dual amplitude has been correctly derived and implemented , one would also like to verify that the algorithm constructed ( see the appendix ) is in fact ergodic and capable of realizing convergence of expectation values with comparable time and resources to that of a conventional code . agreement within statistical error of conventional and dual results , while not constituting proof of a correct dual algorithm , strongly indicates its correctness . such testing is particularly valuable as the dual code is further optimized . given an observable and its expectation value defined in terms of the dual model , one can derive the effective observable whose expectation value is equal when evaluated with respect to the original conventional model . explicitly , we seek a function @xmath35 such that @xmath36 where we have introduced a character expansion in the second line to better show the relation with the dual observable . we next recall from section [ sec : spinfoamsims ] the dual observable of interest @xmath37 based on the above we introduce the following proposal for @xmath38 : @xmath39 the above can be checked by substituting into the second line of equation ( [ eqn : effectdef ] ) and comparing to the second line of equation ( [ eqn : charsumj ] ) . given the above , it is useful to be able to readily compute the character expansion components @xmath40 of the action in order to compute the `` re - weighted '' numerator of ( [ eqn : effectformula ] ) . the heat kernel action used in the present simulations has a simple form ( see definition [ defn : heatkernel ] ) in which character coefficients can be rapidly evaluated . we note in passing that the division by part of the original amplitude as is done in ( [ eqn : effectformula ] ) in general may produce numerical problems , as convergence is better when observables are well correlated with the amplitude . in practice , for this particular case we have found good convergence ( low variation of independent runs ) of simulations for this effective observable . several sets of computations were performed in order to confirm the correctness of the algorithm and evaluate the computational performance of the dual simulations as currently implemented . these are described in the subsections below ; we first make some general comments . prior to computing the observable @xmath41 , the conventional code was validated against published curves appearing in @xcite , which we selected because those simulations used the same heat kernel action employed in the present work . due to the computational cost of the vertex amplitude at higher spins , for the simulations described below the series appearing in ( [ eqn : effectdef ] ) are cut off at a relatively low spin @xmath42 ; however , because the cut - off is applied to both conventional ( as a truncation of the character expansion ) and dual forms , a direct comparison can still be made , and posible errors in the ( considerably more complex ) dual code can be detected . while low cut - off simulations can be quite accurate in the strong coupling regime , they begin to break down at the weaker coupling scales of interest . further optimizations of the vertex amplitude underway by the author should allow for higher spin cut - offs . we now turn to a description of the numerical simulations performed on both sides of the duality that establish the correctness ( within statistical error ) of the dual algorithm . error bars of @xmath43 are shown , where @xmath44 is the standard deviation based on the average and variance of over the different simulation runs . our first simulations were done on four - dimensional hypercubic lattice of @xmath45 vertices and a cutoff of @xmath46 ( in units of half - integer spin ) . the very small lattice size and low cut - off allowed relatively rapid simulations on both sides of the duality in order to establish agreement . for the conventional simulation , updating was done in `` sweeps '' in which each edge of the lattice was updated in sequence . a total of @xmath47 sweeps were done at each value of @xmath3 . for the dual simulations , a total of @xmath48 moves were applied ; these moves are described in the appendix . lattice at @xmath46 ] further comparisons of dual and conventional simulations were made at increased spin cut - offs of @xmath49 and @xmath50 . at these cut - offs , @xmath51 samples were used in the dual simulations on the minimal ( @xmath45 ) lattice . the results are shown in figure [ fig : compare_l2_j3 ] and again confirm the correctness of the dual algorithm to within statistical error of the equivalent conventional algorithm . error bars at weak coupling are larger at weak coupling , likely due to the smaller number of samples relative to the lower variance results obtained for @xmath46 . lattice at @xmath49 ] the dual algorithm was also investigated on larger lattice having dimensions @xmath2 at a spin cut - off of @xmath46 . at stronger coupling ( @xmath52 and lower ) the dual simulations have high quality estimates with little relative error . however , for @xmath3 and greater than @xmath53 considerably larger errors begin to appear , rendering the results essentially unusable . as expected , one clear source of error is in the expectation value of the sign , which at higher beta tends to smaller values . the error at @xmath4 on the @xmath2 lattice was 22% and the sign expectation was of order @xmath54 . for comparison , on the @xmath45 lattice the error at a comparable @xmath3 was 3% and the sign expectation value was of the order @xmath55 . we have described the construction of a dual algorithm for @xmath0 yang - mills in @xmath56 , based on a set of ergodic moves ( suitable for use with a metropolis or other algorithm ) defined in the appendix , and an efficient form for the vertex amplitude , derived in @xcite . using a @xmath45 lattice as a simple test case , this algorithm was validated for a range of @xmath3 at spin cut - offs of @xmath57 and @xmath58 . in this low - spin , small - lattice , intermediate coupling regime our algorithm exhibits statistical agreement with conventionally obtained results . while this is clearly an impractically small size , it represents a milestone as the first dual simulation of its kind in four space - time dimensions for a non - abelian gauge theory . towards strong coupling ( @xmath3 of order unity ) , accurate results are possible even with the low cut - offs used ( as large spins are penalized heavily by the amplitude in this regime ) . however towards weak coupling an increased spin cut - off is required as configurations with larger spin begin to dominate . because the computational cost of the dual vertex amplitude used increases with higher spins , raising the cut - off has the effect of slowing the rate at which samples are accumulated . thus , a way of more efficiently obtaining high accuracy results at weaker coupling would be to speed up the vertex amplitude at high @xmath31 , either through an improved algorithm , improved implementation , or some combination of both . note that , as demonstrated in the @xmath8 case @xcite , different choices of intertwiner bases and reductions of the spin network via recoupling moves lead to algorithms of different performance . therefore exploring these different choices is a natural way to seek out more efficient vertex amplitude algorithms . intelligent caching of often used intermediate calculations and the use of recursion relations that exist for @xmath59 symbols are also being investigated by the author . a serious challenge for the new algorithm was encountered in increasing the lattice to @xmath2 in size . for this lattice size the sign expectation value had a considerably more rapid fall - off with increased @xmath3 . as the overall sign of amplitude is the product of sign factors local vertex amplitudes , a decrease in the sign expectation value for any given @xmath3 can be generically expected as the lattice size becomes large , as was discussed in by dass et al . in @xcite . the rapid increased in error on data points for @xmath4 and greater exhibits has allowed us to measure for the first time the extent of the sign problem for the four - dimensional case ( within our current approach ) . a number of approaches are being pursued by the author to mitigate the problem of fluctuating signs . one general approach would be to replace the @xmath59 symbols that appear in the amplitude by their approximation ( valid at large spins ) in the form of well - known the ponzano - regge asymptotic formula @xcite . while the ponzano - regge approximation itself contains fluctuating signs , because the expressions are in closed form they may useful as predictors of sign for the original @xmath59 symbols and specifically to form a stationary phase approximations , in which configurations of stationary phase are used rather than the full ensemble @xcite . a possible problem with this approach is that the regime where asymptotic formulae for spins may correspond to unrealistically large @xmath3 . another approach to sign problems ( that could work directly with the original vertex amplitude ) is to identify a sector of the original theory in which some form of cancellation occurs in a controlled fashion ( leading to a positive or at least better behaved sector for simulation ) . this has been achieved for certain types of fermion models , under the rubric of _ meron cluster _ and related methods ; in some cases , configurations with exactly equal weight and opposite sign can be identified and removed _ a priori _ from the simulation and the remaining ensemble sampled in an efficient manner @xcite . a general lesson for the sign problem is that while general methods that work in all instances do nt exist in tractable form @xcite , by using details of how differently signed configuration occur , it is possible to alleviate and in some casees completely remove the problem in a particular theory . a final point to make is that a useful solution does not necessarily have to work for arbitrarily high @xmath3 , but rather mitigate the sign problem to the point of being practical for @xmath3 used to study length scales of particular interest . in summary , the present work has demonstrated for the first time that dual simulations of yang - mills in four space - time dimensions are feasible and provides a concrete , tested algorithm for carrying them out . the main barriers to extending this approach to large lattice sizes and weaker coupling are the emergence of a sign problem ( the severity of which depends on lattice size ) and the computational expense of evaluating the vertex amplitude ; some possible approaches to addressing these were identified . the author would like to thank dan christensen for valuable discussion influencing this work . this work was made possible by the facilities of the shared hierarchical academic research computing network ( sharcnet ) as in the conventional framework of lgt , the setting for the present algorithm is a hypercubic lattice with periodic boundary conditions such that the lattice has the topology of a 4-torus ( @xmath60 ) . the partition function for the theory can be expressed as a sum over dual amplitudes as follows : @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the set of lattice spin foam configurations ( discussed further below ) . each configuration labels a plaquette or edge by a quantum number . as can be seen from equation ( [ eqn : partfun ] ) , the amplitude assigned to each spin foam factors into a product of contributions from local amplitudes associated to vertices , edges , and plaquettes of the lattice . recently , an explicit numerical algorithm was given in @xcite for each of these amplitudes in @xmath56 . for the practical evaluation of expectation values using numerical methods , it is often necessary to employ markov chain monte carlo techniques @xcite such as the metropolis algorithm . for such methods it is necessary to find a set of moves that are ergodic where any configuration can be transformed into any other by an appropriate sequence of the moves . for the present case , it can be non - trivial to find such moves due to the constrained nature of the dual configurations . to describe the ergodic moves constructed for the present work , we must first identify the variables present at each vertex and edge , and the nature of the constraints they obey . each plaquette carries a variable whose values are quantum numbers ( we shall refer to them as `` spins '' ) that label the irreducible unitary representations of the group @xmath63 . each edge carries an intertwiner : a @xmath63-invariant map between the irreducible representations assigned to the incident plaquettes . in the present case of a four - dimensional hypercubic lattice , we have six incident plaquettes , and hence the intertwiner must be an invariant map from a six - fold tensor product to the trivial representation . due to the self - duality of @xmath0 irreps , this is equivalent to an invariant map between a three - fold tensor product of irreps to a three - fold tensor product of irreps . intertwiners of this type form a three - dimensional vector space , and thus require three spin labels to resolve . the basis of intertwiners used can be represented diagrammatically as a splitting of the six - valent vertex into a larger network with four three - valent vertices and three `` internal '' edges . we note that there is some choice in how this splitting is carried out ( equivalent to changing the basis of intertwiners ) . as we are using the vertex amplitude described in @xcite , we shall adopt the corresponding choice of splitting , which is shown below in figure [ fig : splitting ] . the three spin labels appear as @xmath64 , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 in figure [ fig : splitting ] . the reader can readily check that these form an orthogonal basis by taking the inner product of two different labellings of the diagram by @xmath67 . on a four - dimensional hypercubic lattice , there are 24 plaquettes incident to each vertex and 8 edges . this leads to a vertex amplitude that depends on 24 spin labels coming from the plaquettes and @xmath68 spin labels coming from the edges , in total a function of 48 spins . the approach of fixing a basis and explicitly carrying out a tensor contraction would be extraordinarily difficult to compute , with the cost scaling prohibitively with the spin @xcite . however , as mentioned above , an algorithm that scales as @xmath1 has recently been given in @xcite . having described the nature of the variables , it remains to define a set of ergodic moves . to provide ergodicity , several distinct types of moves are applied . as with the @xmath8 algorithm for @xmath0 constructed in @xcite , these fall into three distinct classes homology moves , edge moves , and cube moves . select a plane of plaquettes that spans the entire lattice ( and thus forms a closed surface due to the periodic boundary conditions ) . with equal probability , choose to decrease or increase a fundamental unit of spin and apply this change to every plaquette in the plane . due to the periodic boundary conditions , these planes form closed surfaces that wrap the 4-torus . all admissible deformations of these surfaces with the same globally wrapped topology are generated by the plaquette and edge moves . the present algorithm uses a new approach to edge and plaquette moves that generally improves the acceptance ratio compared to that of @xcite . recall that given any plaquette labelling , the allowed intertwiner labels at each edge vary within a fixed range ( non - empty if the plaquette labelling is admissible ) . rather than storing and applying moves to the intertwiner label itself , we store the offset of the intertwiner relative to the minimum value in the admissible range . specifically , given an edge splitting and labelling of incident plaquette spins @xmath69 , the admissible intertwiner labellings @xmath67 are given by the intersection of the ranges defined by the triangle inequalities . for example , @xmath70 $ ] . for each edge , a relative intertwiner label @xmath71 for each of the three intertwiners is stored . in computing the amplitude of the configuration , the intertwiner used is @xmath72 is used , where @xmath73 is the smallest admissible intertwiner label . we mention in passing that for certain special configurations , the amplitude may be zero despite the fact that all admissibility conditions are satisfied . as was the case for the @xmath8 form of this algorithm @xcite , we assume such configurations are sufficiently isolated from each other that they do not divide the configuration space into disconnected regions that ca nt be traversed by the moves . a fundamental 3-cube of the lattice is selected at random . for each plaquette in the boundary of this cube , a random choice is made to either increase or decrease the spin by a single fundamental unit of charge . unlike the cube moves in @xcite , no direct changes to the intertwiner labels is needed for compatibility . the intertwiners labels are implicitly changed `` automatically '' by virtue of the admissible ranges being modified by the change in plaquette label . except when the spin is at the top of the admissible range and the plaquette moves reduce this range , a change in plaquette labels will implicitly give a new intertwiner labelling that is admissible . another benefit of this approach is that it is actually easier to implement , as the algorithm does nt have keep track of the different ways in which intertwiners sit inside cubes ( as was done in @xcite ) , but simply which internal edges are connected to which plaquettes . in summary , the operation of the algorithm can be described as follows . an edge , cube , or homology move type is selected at random and the proposed move is applied . the contribution to the amplitude from those vertices , edges , and plaquettes effected by the move is computed before and after the move and the ratio of these local amplitudes is used to determine acceptance or rejection of the move by the standard metropolis decision procedure .

we present numerical results for pure @xmath0 yang - mills theory in four space - time dimensions using a novel algorithm based on dually transformed variables . the simulation makes use of a recently derived @xmath1 algorithm for the dual vertex amplitude and a dual metropolis algorithm that generalizes the one recently developed for three dimensions . the dual algorithm is validated against the equivalent model using conventional variables over a range of couplings , spin cut - offs , and lattice sizes . we consider a lattice size up to @xmath2 , where the problem of negative amplitudes renders the simulation results excessively noisy even at a relatively low @xmath3 ( starting at about @xmath4 ) . in conclusion , we survey some approaches to addressing the sign problem and increasing the efficiency of dual computations . @xmath5department of mathematics , university of western ontario , london , ontario , canada

astro-ph9901008

a giant x - ray outburst of ngc5905 was discovered during the ( trmper 1983 ) survey observation ( bade , komossa & dahlem 1996 ) . ngc5905 showed a high countrate during this first observation . the countrate then declined by at least a factor of several within months and was down by a factor @xmath0100 two years later . the x - ray spectrum during the outburst was very soft ( with photon index @xmath1 when fit by a powerlaw ) . during quiescence , the spectrum is flatter ( @xmath2 ) . the outburst luminosity is of the order of @xmath3 several @xmath4 erg / s ; much _ higher _ than observed in _ non - active _ spiral galaxies ( e.g. , fabbiano 1989 , vogler 1997 ) . new hri data were taken in 1996 with an exposure time of 76 ksec . these show a further decline by a factor @xmath02 in flux with respect to the last pspc observation . the long - term x - ray lightcurve is displayed in fig optical observations are an important supplement to the x - ray data . the two most important questions are ( i ) is there a simultaneous optical outburst , and ( ii ) does the optical spectrum of ngc5905 show any signs of seyfert activity ? we have used photographic plates taken at _ sternwarte sonneberg _ to produce a long - term optical lightcurve ( between years 1962 and 1995 ) of the nucleus of ngc5905 and searched the plates taken quasi-_simultaneously _ to the x - ray outburst for a correlated optical outburst . the factor @xmath0100 variability seen in x - rays would corresponds to 5@xmath5 in the optical spectral region in the variable component . the optical brightness of ngc5905 is found to be _ constant _ within the errors on long terms as well as near the x - ray outburst ( fig . 2 ) , placing strong constraints on outburst scenarios . we have taken high - resolution post - outburst optical spectra ( about 6 years after the x - ray outburst ) at the 3.5 m telescope of calar alto . these show the same spectral characteristics as the pre - outburst spectrum of ho et al . ( 1995 ) and classify the galaxy as hii - type . if a high - ionization emission - line component was present during outburst , it had already declined below detectability . we carefully searched for other signs of _ permanent _ seyfert activity none are revealed . this is another important constraint for outburst models and , at present , makes ngc5905 the only non - active galaxy among the x - ray outbursting ones . the major characteristics to be explained by outburst models are * short duration , extremely soft spectrum , giant amplitude ( a factor @xmath6 100 ) and huge peak luminosity of the x - ray outburst * no detected simultaneous change in optical brightness * the optical spectrum is that of an hii - type galaxy with _ no _ signs of _ permanent _ seyfert activity we in turn discuss several outburst scenarios ( for details see komossa & bade 1998 ) . the outburst x - ray luminosity by far exceeds that of individual supernovae . those observed in x - rays range between @xmath7 and a few @xmath8 erg / s ( e.g. , schlegel 1995 , immler & pietsch 1998 ) ; the x - ray brightest reached @xmath9 erg / s ( fabian & terlevich 1996 ) . the possibility of ` buried ' supernovae ( sn ) in _ dense _ molecular gas was studied by shull ( 1980 ) and wheeler et al . ( 1980 ) . in this scenario , x - ray emission originates from the shock , produced by the expansion of the sn ejecta into the ambient interstellar gas of high density . since high luminosities can be reached this way , and the evolutionary time is considerably speeded up , an sn in a dense medium may be an explanation for the observed x - ray outburst in ngc5905 . assuming the observed outburst luminosity of ngc5905 to be the peak luminosity and using the analytical estimates of shull and wheeler et al . for the evolution of temperature , radius and luminosity of the shock , @xmath10 @xmath11 @xmath12 results in a density of the ambient medium of @xmath13 but is inconsistent with the observed softness of the spectrum : the expected temperature is @xmath14 k , compared to the observed one of @xmath15 k. therefore , an sn in dense medium is an unlikely explanation of the observed x - ray outburst . additionally , fine - tuning in the column density of the surrounding medium would be required in this scenario in order to prevent the snr from being completely self - absorbed . large magnification factors of the source brightness can be reached by gravitational lensing ( gl ) if the observer , lens , and source ly nearly exactly on a line . lensing was , e.g. , discussed as a possibility to explain the observed variability in bl lac objects ( e.g. , ostriker & vietri 1985 ) . being independent of photon energy , gl predicts the same magnification factor at optical wavelengths as in x - rays . given the non - detection of optical variability simultaneous to the x - ray outburst the gl scenario is very unlikely . as to the question of whether the observations may have represented the x - ray afterglow of a gamma - ray burst ( grb ) , we note that no grb has been detected in the time around the x - ray outburst ( july 1215 , 1990 ) of ngc5905 ( the 2 reported grbs nearest in time , of july 8 , 1990 , have different positions ; castro - tirado 1994 on the basis of granat / watch data ) . the possibility remains that the grb escaped detection or that it was not beamed towards us and only the isotropic afterglow was seen . if a massive bh _ with an accretion disk _ exists in the center of ngc5905 , it usually has to accrete with low accretion rate or radiate with low efficiency , to account for the comparatively low x - ray luminosity of ngc5905 in quiescence . an accretion disk instability may then provide an explanation for the observed x - ray outburst . thermally unstable slim accretion disks were studied by honma et al . ( 1991 ) , who find the disk to exhibit burst - like oscillations for the case of the standard @xmath16 viscosity description and for certain values of accretion rate . using the estimate for the duration of the high - luminosity state ( honma et al . ; 4.8 ) , and a duration of the outburst of less than 5 months ( the time difference between the first two observations of ngc5905 ) , a central black hole of mass in the range @xmath17 could account for the observations . the burst - like oscillations are found by honma et al . only for certain values of the initial accretion rate . a more detailed quantitative comparison with the observed outburst in ngc5905 is difficult , since the behavior of the disk is quite model dependent , and further detailed modeling would be needed . the idea of tidal disruption of stars by a supermassive black hole ( smbh ) was originally studied as a possibility to fuel agn ( hills 1975 ) , but was dismissed later . peterson & ferland ( 1986 ) suggested this mechanism as possible explanation for the transient brightening of the heii line observed in a seyfert galaxy . tidal disruption was invoked by eracleous et al . ( 1995 ) in a model to explain the uv properties of liners , and was suggested as possible outburst mechanism for ic3599 ( brandt et al . 1995 , grupe et al . 1995 ) . rees ( 1988 , 1990 ) proposed to use individual such events as tracers of smbhs in nearby _ non - active _ galaxies . the debris of the disrupted star is accreted by the bh . this produces a flare , lasting of the order of months , with the peak luminosity in the opt - uv , euv or soft x - ray spectral region . the luminosity emitted if the bh is accreting at its eddington luminosity can be estimated by @xmath18 erg / s . in case of ngc5905 , a bh mass of at least @xmath19 m@xmath20 would be required to produce the observed @xmath21 , and a higher mass if @xmath21 was not observed at its peak value . the decline in luminosity after the maximum in the tidal disruption scenario scales as @xmath22 ( rees 1990 ) . the observed long - term x - ray lightcurve of ngc5905 is given in fig we favour the scenario of tidal disruption of a star because it can account for the high outburst luminosity , seems to require least fine - tuning , and the long - term x - ray lightcurve shows a continuous fading of the source over the whole measured time interval . however , we also caution that many theoretical details of the tidal disruption process are still rather unclear . we performed a search for further cases of strong x - ray variability ( komossa 1997 ) using the sample of nearby galaxies of ho et al . ( 1995 ) and survey and archived pointed observations . we do not find another object with a factor @xmath0100 amplitude , but several sources are discovered to be strongly variable ( with maximal factors ranging between @xmath010 and 20 in the mean countrates ) : ngc3227 , ngc4051 , and ngc3516 . it is a pleasure to thank the _ sternwarte sonneberg _ for the kind hospitality and g. richter additionally for valuable help in the assessment of the photographic plates . st.k . acknowledges support from the verbundforschung under grant no . the project is supported by the german bundesministerium fr bildung , wissenschaft , forschung und technologie ( bmbf / dlr ) and the max - planck - society . bade n. , komossa s. , dahlem m. , 1996 , a&a 309 , l35 brandt w.n . , pounds k.a . , fink h. , 1995 , mnras 273 , l47 castro - tirado a. , 1994 , thesis , copenhagen univ . eracleous m. , livio m. , binette l. , 1995 , apj 445 , l1 fabbiano g. , 1989 , ara&a 27 , 87 fabian a.c . , terlevich r. , 1996 , mnras 280 , l5 grupe d. et al . , 1995a , b , a&a 299 , l5 and a&a 300 , l21 hills j.g . , 1975 , nature 254 , 295 ho l.c . , filippenko a.v . , sargent w.l.w . , 1995 , apjs 98 , 477 honma f. , matsumoto r. , kato s. , 1991 , pasj 43 , 147 immler s. , pietsch w. , 1998 , astron 319 , 27 komossa s. , 1997 , thesis , lmu mnchen komossa s. , fink h. , 1997 , in _ accretion disks new aspects _ , e. meyer - hofmeister , h. spruit ( eds ) , lecture notes in physics 487 , 250 komossa s. , bade n. , 1998 , a&a , subm . ostriker j.p . , vietri m. , 1985 , nature 318 , 446 peterson b. , ferland g.j . , 1986 , nature 324 , 345 piro l. et al . , 1988 , apj 325 , l25 rees m. , 1988 , nature 333 , 523 rees m. , 1990 , science 247 , 817 schlegel e.m . , 1995 , . phys . 58 , 1375 shull j.m . , 1980 , apj 237 , 769 trmper j. , 1983 , adv . space res . 2 , 241 vogler a. , 1997 , thesis , tu mnchen wheeler j.c . , mazurek t.j . , sivaramakrishnan a. , 1980 , apj 237 , 781

ngc5905 is one of the very few galaxies that underwent a giant x - ray outburst , with a change in photon countrate of a factor @xmath0100 . the outburst spectrum is both , very soft and luminous ( bade , komossa & dahlem 1996 ) . our high - resolution follow - up optical spectroscopy of ngc5905 does not reveal any signs of seyfert activity . at present , this makes ngc 5905 the _ only _ non - active galaxy among the x - ray outbursting ones . we discuss several scenarios to account for the exceptional properties of ngc5905 , including a supernova in dense medium , an accretion - disk instability , an event of extreme gravitational lensing , and the x - ray afterglow of a grb to account for the x - ray outburst . we find that the most likely model to explain the observations seems to be tidal disruption of a star by a central smbh , a scenario proposed by rees ( 1988 ) as a tracer of smbhs in nearby non - active galaxies . the x - ray outburst in this hii galaxy then lends further support to the scenario that _ all _ galaxies passed through an active phase , leaving unfed smbhs in their centers .

1604.06187

evolutionary algorithms ( eas ) have been successfully used in the areas of music and art @xcite . in this application area the primary aim is to evolve artistic and creative outputs through an evolutionary process @xcite . the use of evolutionary algorithms for the generation of art has attracted strong research interest . different representations have been used to create works of greater complexity in 2d and 3d @xcite , and in image animation @xcite . the great majority of this work relates to using evolution to produce a final artistic product in the form of a picture , sculpture or animation . the focus of study in this paper is how ea processes can be mirrored in image transitions . past work studying the use of eas for image transitions includes work by sims @xcite which described methods for cross - dissolving of images by changes in an expression genotype . furthermore , deep neural networks have recently been used to create artistic images @xcite . banzhaf @xcite used interactive evolution to help determine parameters for image morphing . furthermore , karungaru @xcite used an evolutionary algorithm to automatically identify features for morphing faces . our work differs from previously mentioned work in our focus on the direct link between the evolutionary process and image transitions they produce . we use well - known random processes for the evolutionary image transition process . the key idea in this work is to use the evolutionary process _ itself _ in an artistic way . ( sydney opera house ) and target image @xmath0 ( eiffel tower),title="fig : " ] ( sydney opera house ) and target image @xmath0 ( eiffel tower),title="fig : " ] the transition process used in this work consists of evolving a given starting image @xmath1 into a given target image @xmath0 by random decisions . considering an error function which assigns to a given current image @xmath2 the number of pixels where it agrees with @xmath0 and maximizes this function boils down to the classical onemax problem for which numerous theoretical results on the runtime behaviour of evolutionary algorithms are available @xcite . we use the insights obtained in such studies and show how different processes have an influence on evolutionary image transition . furthermore , we are optimistic that the visualization of evolutionary algorithms through image transition may be of independent interest to researchers working on evolutionary computation as it provides a new mechanism of visualizing an evolutionary process . using mutations where in each step exactly one uniformly at random chosen pixel may flip to the target , leads to the coupon collector process @xcite which significantly slows down when being close to the target . it has been shown in @xcite that an asymmetric mutation operator moves at a constant speed towards the target and thereby avoids the slow - down due to the coupon collector s effect . we use a simple ( 1 + 1 ) ea together with this asymmetric mutation operator as our baseline algorithm for evolutionary image transition . another important topic related to the theory of evolutionary algorithms are random walks @xcite . we consider random walks on images where each time the walk visits a pixel its value is set to the value of the given target image . by biasing the random walk towards pixels that are similar to the current pixel we can study the effect of such biases which might be more interesting from an artistic perspective . after observing these two basic random processes for image transition , we study how they can be combined to give the evolutionary process additional interesting new properties . we study the effect of running random walks for short periods of time as part of a mutation operator in a ( 1 + 1 ) ea . furthermore , we consider the effect of alternating different mutation operators over time . our results show that the area of evolutionary image transition based on different well studied random process provides a rich source of artistic possibilities with strong potential for further exploration . the outline of the paper is as follows . in section [ sec2 ] , we introduce the evolutionary transition process and examine the behaviour of simple evolutionary algorithms for image transition in section [ sec : asym ] . section [ sec3 ] studies how variants of random walks can be used for the image transition process . in section [ sec4 ] , we examine the use of random walks as part of mutation operators and study their combinations with pixel - based mutations during the evolutionary process . finally , we finish with some concluding remarks . * let @xmath1 be the starting image and @xmath0 be the target image . * set x:=s . * evaluate @xmath3 . * while ( not termination condition ) * * obtain image @xmath4 from @xmath2 by mutation . * * evaluate @xmath5 * * if @xmath6 , set @xmath7 . we consider an evolutionary transition process that transforms a given image @xmath2 of size @xmath8 into a given target image @xmath0 of size @xmath8 . our goal is to study different ways of carrying out this evolutionary transformation based on random processes from an artistic perspective . we start our process with a starting image @xmath9 . our algorithms evolve @xmath1 towards @xmath0 and has at each point in time an image @xmath2 where @xmath10 . we say that pixel @xmath11 is in state @xmath12 if @xmath13 , and @xmath11 is in state @xmath14 if @xmath15 . for our process we assume that @xmath16 as pixels with @xmath17 can not change values and therefore do not have to be considered in the evolutionary process . to illustrate the effect of the different methods presented in this paper , we consider the sydney opera house as the starting image and the eiffel tower as the target image ( see figure [ fig : opera ] ) . the fitness function of an evolutionary algorithm guides its search process and determines on how to move between images . therefore , the fitness function itself has a strong influence on the artistic behaviour of the evolutionary image transition process . an important property for evolutionary image transition should be that images close to the target image get a higher fitness score . we measure the fitness of an image @xmath2 as the number of pixels where @xmath2 and @xmath0 agree . this fitness function is isomorphic to that of the onemax problem when interpreting the pixels of @xmath1 as @xmath18 s and the pixels of @xmath0 as @xmath19 s . formally , we define the fitness of @xmath2 with respect to @xmath0 as @xmath20 we consider simple variants of the classical ( 1 + 1 ) ea in the context of image transition . the algorithm is using mutation only and accepts an offspring if it is at least as good as its parent according to the fitness function . the approach is given in algorithm [ alg : ea ] . using this algorithm has the advantage that parents and offspring do not differ too much in terms of pixel which ensures a smooth process for transitioning the starting image into the target . furthermore , we can interpret each step of the random walks flipping a visited pixel to the target outlined in section [ sec3 ] as a mutation step which according to the fitness function is always accepted . we consider a simple evolutionary algorithm that have been well studied in the area of runtime analysis , namely variants of the classical ( 1 + 1 ) ea . as already mentioned , our setting for the image transition process is equivalent to the optimization process for the classical benchmark function onemax . our aim is to demonstrate how the progress of these processes are mirrored in the transition of images . the standard variant of the ( 1 + 1 ) ea flips each pixel with probability @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the total number of pixels in the given image . using this mutation operator , the algorithm encounters the well - known coupon collector s effect which means that additive progress towards the target image when having @xmath23 missing target pixels is @xmath24 @xcite . * obtain @xmath4 from @xmath2 by flipping each pixel @xmath11 of @xmath2 independently of the others with probability @xmath25 if @xmath26 , and flip @xmath11 with probability @xmath27 if @xmath15 , where @xmath28 and @xmath29 are constants . in order to avoid the coupon collector s effect , we use the asymmetric mutation operator introduced and theoretically analyszed in @xcite . jansen and sudholt @xcite have shown that the ( 1 + 1 ) ea using asymmetric mutation optimizes onemax in time @xmath30 which improves upon the usual bound of @xmath31 when using standard bit mutations . in order to apply this asymmetric mutation to our image transition process we make the process of flipping pixels dependent on the number of pixels of @xmath2 that are in the same state as @xmath11 . we denote by @xmath32 the number of pixels where @xmath2 and @xmath0 agree . similarly , we denote by @xmath33 the number of pixels where @xmath2 and @xmath1 agree . each pixel is starting state @xmath12 is flipped with probability @xmath25 and each pixel in target state @xmath14 is flipped with probability @xmath27 . the mutation operator is shown in algorithm [ alg : asym ] . the mutation operator differs from the one given in @xcite by the two constants @xmath34 and @xmath35 which allows the determination of the expected number of new pixels from the starting image and the target image , respectively . the choice of @xmath34 and @xmath35 determines the expected number of pixel in the starting state and target state to be flipped . to be precise , the expected number of pixel currently in starting state @xmath12 to be flipped is @xmath36 and the number of pixels in target state @xmath14 to be flipped is @xmath37 as long as the current solution @xmath2 contains at least that many pixel of the corresponding type . in @xcite the case @xmath38 has been investigated which ensures at each point in time an additive drift of @xmath39 . using different values for @xmath34 and @xmath35 allows us to change the speed of transition as well as the relation of the number of pixels switching from the starting image to the target and vice versa while still ensuring that there is constant progress towards the target . all experimental results in this paper are shown for the process of moving from the starting image to the target image given in figure [ fig : opera ] where the images are of size @xmath40 . the algorithms have been implemented in matlab . in order to visualize the process , we show the images obtained when the evolutionary process reaches 12.5% , 37.5% , 62.5% and 87.5% pixels of target image for the first time . we should mention that all processes except the use of the biased random walk are independent of the starting and target image which implies that the use of other starting and target images would show the same effects in terms of the way that target pixels are displayed during the transition process . for our experiments with ( 1 + 1 ) ea@xmath41 , we set @xmath42 and @xmath43 which allows both a decent speed for the image transition process and enough exchanges of pixels for an interesting evolutionary process . we should mention that obtaining the last pixels of the target image may take a long time compared to the other progress steps when using large values of @xmath35 . however , for image transition , this only effects steps when the are at most @xmath37 source pixels remaining in the image . from a practical perspective , this means that the evolutionary process has almost converged towards the target image and setting the remaining missing target pixels to their target values provides an easy solution . in figure [ fig:2 ] we show the experimental results of the asymmetric mutation approach . firstly , we can see the image with lightly stippling dots in randomly chosen areas of the target image @xmath0 . consequently the area of the white sydney opera house disappears and the eiffel tower appears . meanwhile the sky has adopted a dot pattern , where a nuance of dark and light develops steadily . in the last image we barely see the sydney opera house , the target image @xmath0 appearing permanently with the sky becoming darker , whereby the stippling effect shown in the middle two frames decreases . , title="fig : " ] , title="fig : " ] , title="fig : " ] , title="fig : " ] + * let @xmath11 be the starting pixel for the random walk . * set @xmath44 . * while ( not termination condition ) * * choose @xmath45 . * * set @xmath46 , @xmath47 , and @xmath44 . we study random walk algorithms for image transition which moves , at each step , from a current pixel @xmath11 to one pixel in its neighbourhood . we define the neighbourhood @xmath48 of @xmath11 as @xmath49 where we work modulo the dimensions of the image in the case that the values leave the pixel ranges , @xmath50 , @xmath51 . this implies that from a current pixel , we can move up , down , left , or right . furthermore , we wrap around when exceeding the boundary of the image . the classical random walk chooses an element @xmath45 uniformly at random . we call this the _ uniform random walk _ in the following . the cover time of the uniform random walk on a @xmath52 torus is upper bounded by @xmath53 @xcite which implies that the expected number of steps of the uniform random walk until the target image is obtained ( assuming @xmath54 ) is upper bounded by @xmath55 . we also consider a _ biased random walk _ where the probability of choosing the element @xmath56 is dependent on the difference in rgb - values for @xmath57 and @xmath58 . weighted random walks have been used in a similar way in the context of image segmentation @xcite . we denote by @xmath59 , @xmath60 , the @xmath61th rgb value of @xmath57 and define @xmath62 the probability of moving from @xmath11 to an element @xmath63 is then given by @xmath64 the biased random walk is the only method that is dependent on the target image when carrying out mutation or random walk steps . introducing the bias in terms of pixels that are similar , the bias can take the evolutionary image transition process to take exponentially long as the walk might encounter effects similar to the gambler s ruin process @xcite . for our combined approaches described in the next section , we use the random walks as mutation components which ensures that the evolutionary image transition is carried out efficiently . + in figure [ fig:3 ] we show the experimental results of the uniform random walk and biased random walk . at the beginning , we can observe the image with the characteristic random walk pathway appearing as a patch in the starting image @xmath1 . through the transition process , the clearly recognisable patches on the target image @xmath0 emerge . in the advanced stages the darker patches from the sky of the target image dominate . the effect in animation is that the source image is scratched away in a random fashion to reveal an underlying target image . the four images of the biased random walk are clearly different to the images of the uniform random walk . during the course of the transition , the difference becomes more prominent , especially in the sky , where at 87.5% pixels of the target image there is nearly an absolute transition to the darker sky . in strong contrast , the lower part of the images stay nearly untouched , so that we see a layer of ocean under the eiffel tower . in this image the tower itself is also very incomplete with much of the source picture showing through . these effects arise from biased probabilities in the random walk which makes it difficult for the walk to penetrate areas of high contrast to the current pixel location . the asymmetric mutation operator and the random walk algorithms have quite different behaviour when applied to image transition . we now study the effect of combining the approaches for evolutionary image transition into order to obtain a more artistic evolutionary process . firstly , we explore the use of random walks as mutation operators and call this a _ random walk mutation_. the _ uniform random walk mutation _ selects the position of a pixel @xmath11 uniformly at random and runs the uniform random walk for @xmath65 steps . we call the resulting algorithm ea - uniformwalk . similarly , the _ biased random walk mutation _ selects the position of a pixel @xmath11 uniformly at random and runs the biased random walk for @xmath65 steps . this algorithm is called ea - biasedwalk . for our experiments , we set @xmath66 . figure [ fig:4 ] shows the results of the experiments for ea - uniformwalkand ea - biasedwalk . the transitions produced were significantly different from the previous ones . in both experiments we can see the target image emerging through a series of small patches at first , then steadily changing through a more chaotic phase where elements of the source and target image appear with roughly equal frequency . on the last image of each experiment we can see most details of the target image . the images from ea - biasedwalkappear similar to those in ea - uniformwalkin the beginning but differences emerge at the final stages of transition where , in ea - biasedwalk , elements of the source image still show through in areas of high contrast in the target image , which the biased random walk has difficulty traversing . this mirrors , at a more local scale the effects of bias in the earlier random walk experiments . at a global scale it can be seen that the sky , which is a low contrast area , is slightly more complete in the final frame of ea - biasedwalkthan the same frame in ea - uniformwalk . furthermore , we explore the combination of the asymmetric mutation operator and random walk mutation . here , we run the asymmetric mutation operator as described in algorithm [ alg : asym ] and a random walk mutation every @xmath67 generations . we explore two combinations , namely the combination of the asymmetric mutation operator with the uniform random walk mutation ( leading to the algorithm ea - asymuniformwalk ) as well as the combination of the asymmetric mutation operator with the biased random walk mutation ( leading to the algorithm ea - asymbiasedwalk ) . we set @xmath68 and @xmath69 which means that the process is alternating between asymmetric mutation and random walk mutation where each random walk mutation carries out @xmath70 steps . figure [ fig:5 ] shows the results of ea - asymuniformwalkand ea - asymbiasedwalk . from a visual perspective both experiments combine the stippled effect of the ( 1 + 1 ) ea@xmath41with the patches of the random walk . in ea - asymbiasedwalkthere is a lower tendency for patches generated by random walks to deviate into areas of high contrast . as the experiment progresses , the pixel transitions caused by ( 1 + 1 ) ea@xmath41steps , which have a tendency to degrade contrast barriers , influence this effect . however , even in the final frames there is clearly more sky from the target image in ea - asymbiasedwalkthan in ea - asymuniformwalk . moreover , there are more remaining patches of the source image near the edges of the base of the tower , creating interesting effects . + + we have investigated how evolutionary algorithms and related random processes can be used for image transition based on some fundamental insights from the areas of runtime analysis and random walks . we have shown how the asymmetric mutation operator introduced originally for the optimization of onemax can be applied to our problem . furthermore , we have investigated the use of random walk algorithms for image transition and have shown how they can be used as mutation operators in this context . investigating the combinations of the different approaches , we have presented various ways of having interesting evolutionary image transition processes . all our investigations are based on a fitness function that is equivalent to the well - known onemax problem . for future research it would be interesting to study more complex fitness functions and their impact on the artistic behaviour of evolutionary image transition . d. a. hart . toward greater artistic control for interactive evolution of images and animation . in _ applications of evolutionary computing , evoworkshops 2007 _ , volume 4448 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 527536 . springer , 2007 . l. lovsz . random walks on graphs : a survey . in d. mikls , v. t. ss , and t. sznyi , editors , _ combinatorics , paul erds is eighty _ , volume 2 , pages 353398 . jnos bolyai mathematical society , budapest , 1996 . k. sims . artificial evolution for computer graphics . in j. j. thomas , editor , _ proceedings of the 18th annual conference on computer graphics and interactive techniques , siggraph 1991 _ , pages 319328 . acm , 1991 . a. vinhas , f. assuno , j. correia , a. ekrt , and p. machado . fitness and novelty in evolutionary art . in _ evolutionary and biologically inspired music , sound , art and design - 5th international conference , evomusart 2016 _ , volume 9596 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 225240 . springer , 2016 .

evolutionary algorithms have been widely studied from a theoretical perspective . in particular , the area of runtime analysis has contributed significantly to a theoretical understanding and provided insights into the working behaviour of these algorithms . we study how these insights into evolutionary processes can be used for evolutionary art . we introduce the notion of evolutionary image transition which transfers a given starting image into a target image through an evolutionary process . combining standard mutation effects known from the optimization of the classical benchmark function onemax and different variants of random walks , we present ways of performing evolutionary image transition with different artistic effects .

1310.5970

one of the spectacular predictions of quantum electrodynamics is the emergence of forces that arise purely from quantum fluctuations of the electromagnetic vacuum @xcite . also known as london - van der waals @xcite or casimir forces @xcite in different regimes , these forces are often dominant at short distances and can give rise to undesirable effects in nanoscale systems , such as nanomechanical stiction @xcite . these forces have also attracted increasing attention in the fields of atomic physics and quantum optics . in particular , significant efforts have been made in recent years to interface cold atoms with the evanescent fields of dielectric micro- and nano - photonic systems @xcite . these systems are expected to facilitate strong , tunable interactions between individual atoms and photons for applications such as quantum information processing @xcite and the investigation of quantum many - body physics @xcite . in practice , efficient atomic coupling to the evanescent fields of the nanophotonic systems requires that atoms be trapped within sub - wavelength distances of these structures . at these scales , quantum vacuum forces can overwhelm the forces associated with conventional optical dipole traps , typically resulting in a loss of trap stability at distances @xmath0 nm from dielectric surfaces . given the ability to engineer the properties of nanophotonic structures , an interesting question arises as to whether such systems could be used to significantly modify vacuum forces , perhaps changing their sign from being attractive to repulsive , or even creating local potential minima . the strength of nanoscale vacuum forces should lead to unprecedented energy and length scales for atomic traps , which would find use beyond nanophotonic interfaces , such as in quantum simulation protocols based upon ultracold atoms @xcite and control of inter - atomic interactions @xcite . here we propose a novel mechanism in which engineered vacuum forces can enable the formation of a nanoscale atomic trap . while a recent no - go theorem @xcite forbids a vacuum trap for atoms in their electronic ground states , tailored nanophotonic systems can yield strong repulsive potentials for atomic excited states . we show that a weak external optical field can give rise to an overall trapping potential for a dressed state . remarkably , absent fundamental limits on the losses of the surrounding dielectric structure , the fraction of excited - state population in the dressed state can become infinitesimal , which greatly enhances the trapping lifetime and stability . we identify and carefully analyze the actual limiting mechanisms . while we present calculations on a simple model where analytical results can be obtained , we also discuss the generality of our protocol to realistic systems such as photonic crystal structures . the no - go theorem for non - magnetic media states that a dielectric object in vacuum can not be stably trapped with vacuum forces for any surrounding configuration of dielectric objects , provided that the system is in thermal equilibrium @xcite . in analogy with earnshaw s theorem , which prohibits trapping of charged objects with static electric potentials , at best one can create a saddle - point potential ( see , _ e.g. _ , ref . @xcite involving metal particles and ref . @xcite for a hybrid vacuum / optical trap for atoms ) . for dielectric objects , potential loopholes involve embedding the system in a high - index fluid @xcite , or using blackbody radiation pressure associated with strong temperature gradients @xcite . applied to atoms , this theorem essentially forbids stable vacuum trapping near a dielectric structure when the atom is in its electronic ground state . no such constraint exists for atoms in their excited states @xcite , although the robustness of any possible trap would be limited by the excited state lifetime . here , we show that an atom only weakly dressed by its excited state can be trapped by properly tailoring the dispersion of the underlying structure . we begin by briefly reviewing how quantum vacuum fluctuations give rise to forces on the ground and excited states . within an effective two - level approximation of an isotropic atom with ground and excited states @xmath1 ( see appendix for description of how isotropy is incorporated into the model ) , the interaction between the electromagnetic field and an atom at position @xmath2 is given by the dipole hamiltonian @xmath3 . following a complete decomposition of the electric field into its normal modes @xmath4 , one can write @xmath5 , where @xmath6 . the energy non - conserving terms ( @xmath7 and @xmath8 ) enable an atom in its ground state @xmath9 to couple virtually to the excited state and create a photon , @xmath10 , which is subsequently re - absorbed . the corresponding frequency shift for the ground state within second - order perturbation theory is @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the unperturbed atomic transition frequency . this shift results in a mechanical `` vacuum '' potential when translational symmetry is broken due to dielectric surfaces . using a quantization technique for electrodynamics in the presence of dispersive dielectric media , the shift can be expressed in terms of the scattered component of the dyadic electromagnetic green s function evaluated at imaginary frequencies @xmath13 @xcite ( see appendix ) , _ g()=_0^dug_(,,iu ) , where @xmath14 is the free - space spontaneous emission rate of the atom . a similar process can occur for an atom in its excited state @xmath15 , in which the atom virtually emits and re - absorbs an off - resonant photon ( @xmath16 ) . however , the excited state is unique in that it can also emit a resonant photon . the total excited state shift is given by @xcite _ e()=--g_(,,_0).[eq : omegae ] the first term on the right arises from off - resonant processes , while the second term can be interpreted as the interaction between the atom and its own resonantly emitted photon . naturally , the dielectric environment can modify the spontaneous emission rate as well , ( ) = _ 0+g_(,,_0).[eq : gamma ] note that the modified emission and resonant shifts are complementary in that they emerge from different quadratures of the green s function . the versatility of micro- and nanophotonic systems has already been exploited to greatly modify emission rates of atoms and molecules in a variety of contexts @xcite . we propose that these same systems can be used to tailor excited - state potentials in order to facilitate vacuum trapping . of course , the excited - state shift can be affected by coupling to even higher electronic levels . however , since our goal is to engineer giant resonant shifts of @xmath17 , the off - resonant couplings to higher - lying states yield only minor corrections and consequently are ignored here . in what follows , we present a simple model system that enables one - dimensional trapping in a plane parallel to a semi - infinite dielectric slab , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : schematic ] . the use of a homogeneous dielectric ( as opposed to , _ e.g. _ , a photonic crystal ) greatly simplifies the calculation and enables one to understand the relevant trap properties analytically , although we later argue why the qualitative features should still hold in more complex geometries . in the dielectric slab model , dispersion engineering will be realized via the frequency - dependent electric permittivity @xmath18 . while this particular system achieves a one - dimensional trap along @xmath19 , our electrodynamic calculations are performed in three dimensions . enables large repulsion in the excited state @xmath20 , in contrast to the attractive vacuum potential experienced by an atom in its ground state . an overall trapping potential normal to the surface ( along @xmath19 ) can be generated by driving the atom with an external laser of frequency @xmath21 , which is greater than the natural resonance frequency @xmath12 of the atom . the laser comes into local resonance with the atom at @xmath22 . an atom far from @xmath22 is unaffected by the largely detuned field and feels an attractive force @xmath23 toward the dielectric interface . b ) the atom comes closer to local resonance with the laser as @xmath24 . this creates an atomic dressed state , whose excited state component yields a net repulsive force on the atom . c ) a slowly moving atom experiences the adiabatic dressed state potential @xmath25 shown in red , which characterizes the position - dependent mixing between ground and excited states . the minimum of the dressed potential is located at @xmath26.[fig : schematic],width=491 ] a short - distance expansion of the green s function , valid for sub - wavelength scales , shows that the excited - state emission rate @xmath27 and resonant contribution @xmath28 to the shift are given by & & ( ) , [ eq : gammageneral ] + & & -(),[eq : omegaegeneral ] where the permittivity @xmath29 is evaluated at the atomic resonance frequency , @xmath19 is the distance from the surface , and @xmath30 is the resonant free - space wavevector . a large repulsive potential is generated when @xmath31 , which is analogous to the interaction between a classical dipole at position @xmath19 and its large induced image dipole in the dielectric . the modified spontaneous emission rate originates from the absorption or quenching of the atomic emission due to material losses . we choose a drude model , @xmath32 , as a simple dielectric function . note that this function satisfies kramers - kronig relations ( causality ) , as a choice of a non - causal function could result in an apparent violation of the no - go theorem @xcite as well . in the limit of vanishing material loss parameter @xmath33 , the system passes through @xmath34 at the plasmon resonance frequency @xmath35 . the system is conveniently parameterized by the quality factor @xmath36 and a dimensionless detuning @xmath37 . then , for large @xmath38 and @xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath41 . the dispersion and dissipation scale like @xmath42 and @xmath43 , respectively . thus , for high @xmath38 , it is possible to choose detunings where the atom still sees significant repulsive forces , but where spontaneous emission into the material is not significantly enhanced ( in addition to material - induced emission of eq . ( [ eq : gammageneral ] ) , there still is emission into free - space at a rate @xmath44 ) . this scaling behavior is in close analogy with conventional optical trapping of atoms , where simultaneously using large trapping intensity and detuning maintains reasonable trap depths but suppresses unwanted photon scattering . the ground - state shift for atomic frequencies @xmath45 and in the near - field is given by @xmath46 . we now describe how a trap can form for an atom subject to these potentials , and in the presence of a weak driving laser of frequency @xmath21 and rabi frequency @xmath47 ( see fig . [ fig : schematic ] ) . for conceptual simplicity , we choose the rabi frequency to be spatially uniform , such that all atomic forces are attributable to the vacuum potentials alone . qualitatively , the strong position dependence of the ground and excited state frequencies causes the laser to come into resonance with the atom at a single , tunable point @xmath48 . under certain conditions ( described in detail later ) , an atom starting at position @xmath49 will be far detuned , such that it is essentially in the ground state and is attracted by the pure ground - state potential . however , moving closer to @xmath22 brings the atom closer to resonance . the dressing of the atom with a small fraction of excited state population causes a repulsive barrier to form near @xmath50 , yielding a metastable trap . significantly , our approach does not attempt to directly counteract the attractive ground - state potential with large external optical potentials , in sharp contrast with other trapping schemes near dielectric surfaces @xcite . the order of our calculation of the trap properties is as follows . we first find the adiabatic potential experienced by a slowly - moving atom . we derive relevant properties around the location of the trap minimum @xmath51 ( fig . [ fig : schematic ] ) . in particular , we show that absent material constraints ( arbitrarily high @xmath38 ) , the dressed state can in principle have infinitesimal excited state population and scattering . we then quantize the motion to find the motional eigenstates , binding energy , and position uncertainty @xmath52 . finally , we analyze the mechanisms that limit the trap lifetime . first treating the motion classically , the force experienced by the atom is given by @xmath53 , while the internal atomic dynamics satisfies the usual bloch equations , _ e.g. _ , = ( i_a(z)-(z)/2)_ge+i(_ee-_gg)[eq : bloch ] . here @xmath54 is the detuning between the laser and the local atomic resonance frequency . when the atom moves slowly on the time scales of the internal dynamics , the atomic coherence can be adiabatically eliminated , @xmath55 , such that the atomic populations are functions of position alone , @xmath56 . we are primarily interested in the regime where the atom is weakly driven , @xmath57 . a more careful calculation reveals that the green s function @xmath58 for the excited state resonant shift and emission rate in eqs . ( [ eq : omegae ] ) and ( [ eq : gamma ] ) must in fact be evaluated at the laser frequency in this regime , which reflects that the atom primarily acts as a rayleigh scatterer ( see appendix ) . consequently , @xmath59 in eqs . ( [ eq : gammageneral ] ) and ( [ eq : omegaegeneral ] ) is replaced with @xmath60 . the adiabatic potential seen by a slowly - moving atom is @xmath61 . three independent frequencies characterize the system ( @xmath62 , and @xmath63 ) , and two relative frequencies must be specified . one is determined by selecting the trap barrier position , determined by the relation @xmath64 . a second is the dimensionless detuning between the plasmon resonance and laser , @xmath65 , which we treat as a free parameter that determines the relative strengths of the excited state shift and dissipation . in the near - field , the excited state repulsion exceeds the ground state attraction by a factor @xmath66 . the population at @xmath22 must then exceed the inverse of this quantity , @xmath67 , in order to provide a classical barrier in the adiabatic potential , which translates to a minimum rabi frequency @xmath68 . since @xmath69 , this scheme potentially enables atom trapping near surfaces with greatly reduced intensities as compared to conventional trapping . in the latter case , an optical dipole potential requires a minimum driving field of @xmath70 to overcome the attractive ground state potential . the excited - state population at the trap minimum is fixed by the ratio of ground to excited state forces , @xmath71 , and is surprisingly independent of @xmath47 ( provided that @xmath72 ) . an increasing rabi frequency has the effect of increasing the local detuning @xmath73 to preserve the same population . this manifests itself as a `` self - selection '' of the trapping position and an increasing distance from the barrier , ( ^2 - 1)^1/2 , where we have defined the dimensionless rabi frequency @xmath74 . the photon scattering rate at the trap position , @xmath75 , leads to lifetime limitations of our trapping scheme . fixing other parameters , the detuning @xmath76 from the plasmon resonance can be optimized to yield the minimum scattering rate , @xmath77 . thus , absent fundamental limitations to the magnitude of @xmath38 , the photon scattering rate can in principle be suppressed to an arbitrary degree . this implies that an `` infinitesimal '' violation of the assumptions underlying the no - go theorem can in fact allow for trapping . in a conventional optical dipole trap , the potential @xmath78 seen by an atom depends on the local field intensity and is proportional to a spatially - constant atomic polarizability evaluated at the laser frequency . in contrast , here we exploit a novel mechanism arising from strong spatial variations in the polarizability itself , induced through the vacuum level shifts . this creates a back - action effect analogous to that producing a dynamical `` optical spring '' in opto - mechanical systems @xcite , and enables extremely steep trap barriers around @xmath22 ( as in fig . [ fig : schematic]c ) . in particular , the repulsive force is given by @xmath79 , where @xmath80 is engineered to be large . however , the excited state population @xmath81 itself varies strongly with position through the spatially - dependent detuning ( for simplicity , here we omit the varying linewidth @xmath27 ) . this provides an overall repulsive force that scales like @xmath82 , f~-()^2 . and an infinite barrier at @xmath48 . the maximum depth of the potential is denoted by @xmath83 . the quantum wave - function amplitudes @xmath84 ( in arbitrary units ) for the two lowest eigenstates are illustrated in red , while the binding energy @xmath85 and position uncertainty @xmath52 of the ground state are depicted as well . b ) properties of the ideal trapping potential versus barrier position @xmath22 , for the case of a cesium atom . the blue solid and dashed curves give the potential depth at the barrier position , @xmath86 , and the ground - state binding energy @xmath85 , respectively . the green curve depicts the ground - state uncertainty @xmath52 . c ) for the non - ideal trapping potential , the depth of the classical potential @xmath87 is numerically calculated . here we plot it normalized by the maximum possible value @xmath83 , versus detuning parameter @xmath76 and normalized rabi freuqency @xmath88 . d ) the trapping potential , ground - state binding energy @xmath85 , and wave - function amplitude @xmath84 for the parameter sets a , b , as illustrated in c ) . the color coding is the same as in a).[fig : properties],width=566 ] given the possible steepness of this barrier , an `` ideal '' limit for the overall potential is shown in fig . [ fig : properties]a . the attractive part consists of the pure ground - state potential and arises from quantum fluctuations , while an infinite `` hard wall '' is created at @xmath48 due to the combination of strong resonant excited - state shifts ( originating from the interaction of the atom with a `` classical '' image dipole ) and opto - mechanical back - action . this idealized model enables one to understand the best possible scaling of the trap properties . in particular , the trap depth @xmath87 ( the energy required for a classical particle to become unbound ) can not exceed the value of the ground - state potential at @xmath22 , @xmath89 ( _ e.g. _ , @xmath90 mk when @xmath91 nm for a cesium atom ) . this trapping potential can be easily quantized numerically . in fig . [ fig : properties]b , we plot the quantum binding energy @xmath85 ( where @xmath92 ) and position uncertainty @xmath52 for the motional ground - state wave function . for the numerical results in figs . [ fig : properties ] and [ fig : lifetime ] , we use atomic properties corresponding to cesium ( @xmath93 nm , @xmath94 mhz , recoil frequency @xmath95 ) . the strength of the vacuum potentials is reflected in the strong confinement of the wave - functions ( _ e.g. _ , @xmath96 nm for distances @xmath97 nm ) , which are an order of magnitude smaller than in conventional optical traps . to contrast our results for cesium with those of a less massive atom , we have considered lithium as well . results for li similar to those for cs in fig . [ fig : properties]a , b show that at @xmath91 nm , the potential depth is smaller by roughly a factor of two , while the confinement @xmath52 sees roughly a five - fold increase . generally , within the wkb approximation and to lowest order in @xmath52 , the ground - state localization scales like @xmath98 , while the binding energy @xmath99 can be nearly the entire classical potential depth . this ideal model describes qualitatively well the actual potentials over a large parameter regime . in fig . [ fig : properties]c , we plot the ratio of the numerically obtained trap depth to the theoretical maximum , @xmath100 , as functions of @xmath76 and dimensionless driving amplitude @xmath101 . here , we have chosen a quality factor of @xmath102 and a barrier position of @xmath91 nm . although we have provided near - field approximations for the energy shifts above , the plots in figs . [ fig : properties]c , d and fig . [ fig : lifetime ] are calculated using the full green s functions . a trap depth comparable to @xmath86 is achievable over a large range of values . for low values of @xmath101 , the trap depth is weakened due to escape over the potential barrier , while for large values , the trap position becomes shallow as @xmath51 is pulled away from @xmath22 ( as discussed previously ) . two representative trap potentials , along with the ground - state wave functions and confinement @xmath52 are illustrated in fig . [ fig : properties]d . we have identified four sources of motional heating recoil heating , non - adiabatic motion of the atom within the trap , fluctuations of the atomic coherence , and tunneling over the finite - height potential barrier that limit the trap lifetime in absence of external cooling mechanisms . tunneling is exponentially suppressed with barrier height and thus is easily suppressed with increasing rabi frequency . this calculation can be found in the appendix , while we discuss the more important mechanisms here . as in conventional optical trapping , the random momentum recoil imparted on the atom by scattered photons yields an increase in motional energy at the rate @xmath103 . two qualitative differences emerge relative to free space , however . first , the photon scattering rate @xmath104 is modified in the presence of dielectric surfaces . second , the effective momentum @xmath105 imparted by a photon is enhanced compared to the free - space momentum . this momentum scales at close distances like @xmath106 ( see appendix ) , due to emission into high - wavevector photons in the dielectric . starting from the motional ground state , this heating causes the atom to become unbound over a time scale @xmath107 . it should be noted that the heating rate @xmath108 does not depend on the atom confinement ( _ i.e. _ , whether we operate in the lamb - dicke limit ) , as the suppression of motional jumps in tight traps is compensated by the increase in energy gained per jump @xcite . our derivation of the atomic potential assumes that the atomic coherence adjusts rapidly to the local trap properties , @xmath109 , which results in a purely conservative potential . as we now show , non - adiabatic corrections result in a momentum - dependent force , @xmath110 ( anti - damping ) . we can solve eq . ( [ eq : bloch ] ) for the atomic motion perturbatively by writing @xmath111 , where @xmath112 is the adiabatic solution . it depends only on the instantaneous position and is given by @xmath113 in the weak saturation limit . here , @xmath114 is the complex detuning . substituting this solution into eq . ( [ eq : bloch ] ) yields a velocity - dependent correction to the coherence , @xmath115 . this in turn yields a new contribution to the force , @xmath116 , where the anti - damping rate is given by @xmath117 $ ] evaluated at the trap position @xmath51 . intuitively , the atom is anti - damped ( @xmath118 ) because the laser frequency is blue - detuned relative to the atomic frequency at @xmath51 , giving rise to preferential stokes scattering over anti - stokes . aside from the term proportional to @xmath119 , the heating rate is exactly analogous to that occurring in an opto - mechanical system in the blue - detuned regime @xcite . we define a characteristic time @xmath120 needed for the energy increase produced by anti - damping to equal the ground - state binding energy @xmath85 . thus far , we have focused on the motion of the atomic dressed state , in which a trap emerges due to weak mixing with the excited state potential . following a spontaneous emission event , however , the atom returns to the ground state and sees the pure ground - state potential for a transient time @xmath121 until the atomic coherence is restored , during which the atomic wave - packet accelerates toward the surface and gains energy . while a simulation of the full dynamics of the atom ( including the spatial and internal degrees of freedom ) is quite challenging , here we estimate the heating rate from these transient processes . in particular , we first find the spatial propagator under the pure ground - state potential , @xmath122 ( see appendix ) . then , assuming that a spontaneous emission event occurs at @xmath123 with the atom initially in the motional ground - state @xmath124 , the new wave - function that emerges once the coherence equilibrates is given by @xmath125 . the probability of atom loss @xmath126 per spontaneous emission event is estimated from the overlap between the initial and final states , @xmath127 , with a corresponding trap lifetime of @xmath128 . in fig . [ fig : lifetime ] , we plot the overall trap lifetime , which is obtained by adding the individual lifetimes in parallel , @xmath129 . the overall trap lifetime exhibits a complicated dependence on rabi frequency @xmath47 and detuning @xmath76 due to the different scalings of the constituent heating mechanisms . as an example , however , for external parameters @xmath130 and @xmath131 for atomic cs , one achieves a lifetime of @xmath132 ms , ground - state confinement @xmath133 nm , trap depth @xmath134 mk , and trap distance @xmath135 nm . versus dimensionless rabi frequency @xmath74 and detuning @xmath76 . here we have assumed a plamson resonance quality factor of @xmath102 and atomic properties corresponding to cesium . [ fig : lifetime],width=302 ] we have described a protocol for an atomic trap based upon engineered vacuum forces , and have analyzed in detail a model case of one - dimensional trapping near a drude material , where analytical results are possible to obtain . the drude response approximates well a number of metals , such as silver and gold , in the optical domain @xcite . in practice , however , these metals are limited by their low quality factors ( @xmath136 ) , and the thermal fluctuations of such conducting materials can give rise to strong noise - induced trap heating and decoherence @xcite . on the other hand , photonic crystal structures enable engineering of resonances through geometry , and quality factors approaching @xmath137 have been observed @xcite . while the field profiles of such structures are more complex , we anticipate that our trapping protocol could be quite generally applied , and the resulting trap behavior would qualitatively remain the same . in particular , the scaling of the engineered excited - state shift ( @xmath138 ) and dissipation ( @xmath139 ) are generic to coupling between an atom and resonator , and only the spatial dependence is determined by the field profiles . photonic crystals should thus offer great flexibility in tailoring the properties of vacuum traps ( such as dimensionality ) , which we plan to investigate in detail in future work . we note that related efforts have already been made to design realistic hybrid atom traps in photonic crystal structures , where a combination of vacuum forces and optical forces are required to stabilize the trap in all dimensions @xcite . in addition , while we have focused on trapping of atoms weakly dressed by an external laser , it should also be possible to achieve laser - free traps by using atoms pumped into metastable electronic levels and engineering resonant shifts . the ability to create atomic traps with parameter sets ( such as depth , confinement , and proximity to surfaces ) that are not possible in conventional traps ( whether optical , electrical , or magnetic ) should lead to a number of intriguing applications . for example , it has been proposed that the trapping of atoms near dielectric surfaces with nano - scale features ( such as a sub - wavelength lattice ) would facilitate large interaction strengths and long - range interactions for ultracold atoms @xcite . however , the major limitation of optical trapping is the divergent intensity needed to overcome the ground - state vacuum forces of these structures . the use of resonantly - enhanced excited state repulsion to create a trap could significantly reduce the power requirements and enable smaller lattice constants . furthermore , traps with localization on the nanometer scale can induce inter - atomic forces that are of comparable strength to molecular van der waals forces , which enables novel opportunities to control ultracold atomic collisions @xcite and realize exotic interactions such as @xmath140-wave scattering of fermions @xcite . atoms trapped near surfaces could also act as exquisite nanoscale probes of surface physics , including the precision measurement of vacuum forces themselves . the authors thank n. stern and o. painter for helpful discussions . dec acknowledges support from fundaci privada cellex barcelona . ks was funded by the nsf physics frontier center at the jqi . jmt acknowledges funding from the nsf physics frontier center at the jqi and the us army research office muri award w911nf0910406 . hjk acknowledges funding from the iqim , an nsf physics frontier center with support of the moore foundation , by the afosr qumpass muri , by the dod nsseff program , and by nsf phy-1205729 . in this section we briefly describe the quantization scheme of the electromagnetic field in the presence of arbitrary linear dielectric media , which follows that of ref . the free field is characterized by a set of bosonic modes with frequencies @xmath141 and annihilation operators @xmath142 ( @xmath143 ) , with a corresponding hamiltonian h_f = _ jd _ j^(,)_j ( , ) . the bosonic operators satisfy canonical commutation relations @xmath144=\delta_{jk}\delta(\bfr-\bfr')\delta(\omega-\omega')$ ] and are physically associated with noise polarization sources in the material . the electric field operator at frequency @xmath141 is driven by the sources at the same frequency and is given in the coulomb gauge by @xcite e_i(,)= i_0 ^2 d g_ij(,,)_j(,).[eq : e ] here and in the following , it is assumed that all repeated vector or tensor indices are summed over , _ e.g. _ , @xmath145 . @xmath146 is the frequency - dependent permittivity at position @xmath2 , and @xmath147 is the dyadic green s function which is the ( gauge - invariant ) solution to g(,,)=(-)i.[eq : greeneq ] the total electric field is @xmath148 similarly , the magnetic field is @xmath149 . it can be verified that these expressions preserve the same field commutation relations as in free - space field quantization . in the following , we consider a two - level atom at position @xmath150 and with ground and excited states @xmath151,@xmath17 interacting with the electromagnetic field within the electric dipole approximation . the interaction hamiltonian is given by h _ & = & -*d*(_a ) + & = & -_i(_ege_i(_a)+h.c.),[eq : haf ] where @xmath152 is the atomic dipole matrix element . our system of interest consists of an atom in a region of vacuum with nearby dielectric objects . in general , for @xmath153 in the vacuum region , one can express the green s function as a sum @xmath154 , where the free component is the solution in uniform vacuum ( @xmath155 ) and the scattered component physically describes waves scattered from the dielectric objects . in a planar geometry such as that considered in the main text , the green s function can be evaluated exactly using a plane wave expansion . specifically , suppose that we have an interface with vacuum in the region @xmath156 and a dielectric with permittivity @xmath18 in the region @xmath157 . the free and scattered components of the dyadic green s function in the region @xmath158 are then given by g _ & = & -d _ e^i_(-),[eq : gfree ] + g _ & = & d_e^i_(- ) e^i(z+z ) .[eq : gsc ] here @xmath159 and @xmath160 are the wavevector and position along the direction parallel to the interface , @xmath161 , @xmath162 , and @xmath163 and @xmath164 are the fresnel reflection coefficients for @xmath165 and @xmath140 polarized waves , respectively . the interaction hamiltonian @xmath166 couples the ground state of the bare system @xmath9 ( consisting of the atomic ground state and vacuum ) to states @xmath167 . within second - order perturbation theory , this interaction induces a shift of the bare ground state energy by an amount _ g(_a)=-_jdd , where @xmath12 is the bare resonance frequency of the atom . substituting eqs . ( [ eq : e ] ) and ( [ eq : haf ] ) into the expression above , and using analyticity of the integrand to rotate the frequency integral onto the positive imaginary axis @xmath13 , one finds @xcite _ g(_a ) = _ 0^ du _ i g_,ij(_a,_a , iu ) _ j.[eq : omegag ] here we have only included the scattered component of the green s function , as the free component gives a contribution that is independent of position . while we have considered a two - level atom for simplicity , a more realistic model of an isotropic atom consists of multiple excited states and equal polarizabilities in each direction ( _ i.e. _ , the ground state can emit virtual photons of any polarization with equal strength ) . since the contribution to the ground - state shift from each excited state transition is additive , eq . ( [ eq : omegag ] ) can be modified to account for this by setting @xmath168 for all @xmath169 and associating @xmath170 with the free - space spontaneous emission rate of any excited state . this yields eq . ( 1 ) in the main text . in this section , because we want to focus exclusively on the effect of vacuum interactions with the excited state , it is sufficient to include only energy - conserving terms in the atom - field interaction hamiltonian @xmath166 ( _ i.e. _ , allowing a transition from the excited to ground state accompanied by creation of a photon from vacuum ) . we also want to consider the specific case where the atom is weakly driven by a classical field of frequency @xmath21 , which motivates working in a rotating frame where the free atomic evolution is given by @xmath171 and @xmath172 is the detuning between the laser frequency and atomic resonance frequency @xmath12 . as will be seen , the inclusion of the laser frequency in the free hamiltonian causes the effective excited state shift and decay rates to depend on the green s function evaluated at @xmath21 once the vacuum modes are eliminated . physically , this describes the effect of the weakly driven atom ( which primarily acts as a rayleigh scatterer ) interacting with its own rayleigh - scattered field , which can be altered due to the presence of nearby dielectric surfaces . the standard technique to derive the excited - state shift and decay rate follows that of appendix [ sec : ground ] for the ground state and uses time - independent second - order perturbation theory @xcite . in this approach , however , one can not find the jump operator associated with photon emission , which is needed in order to calculate the effect of emission on atomic motion ( _ e.g. _ , recoil heating ) . to rectify this , we employ an alternative approach based on deriving an atomic master equation within the born - markov approximation @xcite . in particular , the equation of motion for the reduced atomic density matrix @xmath173 is given by _ a = _ f_0^,[eq : rhodot ] where @xmath174 is the interaction hamiltonian in the interaction picture ( with respect to the free hamiltonian @xmath175 ) and @xmath176 is the electromagnetic vacuum state . any exponential of time appearing in the integral can be evaluated using the relation @xmath177 . using the field expansion of eq . ( [ eq : e ] ) in @xmath174 and following some manipulation , eq . ( [ eq : rhodot ] ) can be written in the form _ a=-(i/)[h_,_a]+[_a ] . the effective hamiltonian describes coherent interactions between the atom and vacuum field and takes the form h_=_e(_a)_ee , which can be interpreted as a position - dependent energy shift of the excited state . a realistic model of an atom allows for the possibility for an excited state to emit photons of different polarizations and transition into different states in a ground - state manifold . the different clebsch - gordan coefficients of these transitions , along with the symmetry breaking introduced by the nearby dielectric structure , imply that different excited states can experience different shifts absent some special engineering . to arrive at a simpler two - level atomic model that captures the essential physics of our trapping mechanism , we assume that the excited state is equally coupled to all polarizations ( but still with total emission rate @xmath14 ) , such that one should average over all dipole orientations . in this case , the excited - state shift is given by _ e(_a)=-_0^dug_(_a,_a , iu)-g_(_a,_a,_l),[eq : omegaeappendix ] as stated in the main text . the liouvillian term @xmath178 $ ] can be written in a lindblad form [ _ a]=_jd _ j_a _ j^-(_j^_j_a+_a_j^_j ) . the jump operators take the form _ i g^_ij(_a,,_l)_ge.[eq : ojump ] the excited - state spontaneous emission rate is in turn given through the relation @xmath179 , or ( _ a ) = _ 0+g_(_a,_a,_l).[eq : gammaappendix ] eq . ( [ eq : gammaappendix ] ) again averages over dipole orientations and reproduces the expression for the emission rate provided in the main text . to derive this , we have used the identity d ( ( , ) ) g_ij(,,)g_jk^(,,)=g_ik(, , ) . the expressions for the excited - state emission rate @xmath180 and level shift @xmath181 agree with previous derivations @xcite , if the laser frequency @xmath21 is replaced by the atomic resonance frequency @xmath12 . the appearance of the laser frequency here is associated with the restriction to the weak - driving limit , which was not considered in earlier derivations . the main new result obtained here , however , is an explicit expression for the jump operator associated with photon emission , which we will use to calculate photon recoil heating in appendix [ sec : recoil ] . here we derive in more detail the equations relating to heating of the atomic motion around the minimum of the vacuum force trap . recoil heating can be calculated by treating the atomic position @xmath150 in eq . ( [ eq : ojump ] ) as an operator . for notational simplicity , we shall consider recoil heating only along one direction , say @xmath19 , although our results can be easily generalized . in the main text , @xmath19 corresponds to the direction in which the atom is trapped ( normal to the dielectric surface ) . the increase in momentum uncertainty due to photon scattering is given by = ( p_z^2 _ a ) . here we will focus solely on the liouvillian term in the density matrix evolution ( _ i.e. _ , momentum incurred from spontaneous emission ) . it can be shown that the liouvillian term produces no net force , _ i.e. _ , @xmath182 . using the fact that @xmath183=-i\hbar\frac{\partial f}{\partial z_a}$ ] for any function @xmath184 , one can derive the following general expression for the recoil heating rate in terms of green s functions , = _ 0_l^2 _ i _ j ( _ 1 ^ 2 + 2_1_2-_2 ^ 2).[eq : recoil ] here , the derivatives @xmath185 and @xmath186 act on the first and second spatial arguments of the green s functions , respectively , and we have suppressed the atomic spatial variables in the directions that are not of interest . we further assume that the internal and spatial degrees of freedom can be de - correlated , @xmath187 . formally , we can write the above equation in the convenient form = ( k_)^2 ( _ a ) p_e , where @xmath188 is the excited - state population . this form is intuitive as it describes the momentum increase arising from a random walk process , where the atom experiences random momentum kicks of size @xmath189 at a rate @xmath190 ( _ i.e. _ , the photon scattering rate ) . @xmath191 is a derived quantity that thus characterizes the effective momentum associated with scattered photons in the vicinity of a dielectric surface . as a simple example , we can consider an atom in free space polarized parallel to the surface ( say along @xmath192 ) . evaluating eq . ( [ eq : recoil ] ) with the free - space green s function @xmath193 from eq . ( [ eq : gfree ] ) yields @xmath194 ( and @xmath195 ) , recovering the known result @xcite . this recoil momentum is smaller than the full momentum @xmath196 of the scattered photon because the atom emits in a dipole pattern , but only the projection of the photon momentum along @xmath19 contributes to motional heating in that direction . as a more complicated example , we can consider the recoil heating near a surface in the trapping scheme considered in the main text . for the drude model and at small distances between the atom and surface , we find that the scattered component of the green s function dominates the recoil heating , leading to the asymptotic expansion of @xmath197 given in the main text . in all of our numerical calculations , the full green s function is used rather than asymptotic results . as described in the main text , following a spontaneous emission event , the spatial wave - function of the atom is temporarily untrapped and evolves under the pure ground - state potential for a characteristic time @xmath198 before the internal dynamics equilibrates . here we discuss how to calculate an approximate propagator @xmath122 for the wave - function evolving under the ground - state potential . the problem significantly simplifies if the ground - state potential @xmath199 is linearized around the atom trapping position @xmath200 , h+u_g(z_t)+mg(z - z_t ) , where @xmath201 . this linearization is justified in our regime of interest where the atom is tightly trapped and the wave - function undergoes little evolution in the time @xmath198 . for simplicity , here we will ignore the constant energy and position offsets and consider the simplified hamiltonian @xmath202 , which corresponds to a mass accelerating under a constant gravitational force . this observation enables one to solve for the propagator by utilizing the equivalence principle , that the system of interest is equivalent to that of a free particle viewed in an accelerating frame . one finds that the propagator is given by u(z_f , z_i , t,0)=u_(z_f , z_i , t)(--),[eq : prop ] where @xmath203 is the well - known propagator for a free particle in an inertial frame @xcite . in our simulations , the ground state wave - function for an arbitrary trapping potential is obtained numerically on a lattice , and so the propagator must be spatially discretized as well . in particular , while the exponential term in eq . ( [ eq : prop ] ) is well - behaved on a lattice , the free propagation @xmath204 is not at short times . we instead replace @xmath204 with the propagator @xmath205 for the free discrete schrodinger equation , = i(_n+1(t)-2_n(t)+_n-1(t ) ) , where @xmath206 , @xmath207 is the lattice site index , and @xmath208 is the lattice constant . the propagator for this equation ( defined as the matrix satisfying @xmath209 ) is given by d_mn(t)=i^m - nj_m - n(2t)e^-2it , where @xmath210 is the @xmath207-th order bessel function . the escape rate of an atom from the metastable potential formed by the vacuum trapping scheme due to quantum tunneling is calculated in the wkb approximation in two steps . first , we find an approximation to the real part of the bound state energy @xmath211 . this is implemented by replacing the actual metastable dressed - state potential @xmath25 with a stable one , @xmath212 , according to the formula ( also see fig . [ fig : wkb ] ) u_s(z ) & = & u_d(z ) ( z > z _ ) , + & = & u_d(z _ ) ( zz _ ) . here , @xmath213 is the position corresponding to the maximum of the metastable barrier . the ground - state energy of @xmath212 is solved numerically . once the approximate ground - state binding energy is obtained , the tunneling probability @xmath214 for a particle hitting the metastable barrier is calculated using the wkb approximation , p_t=4(-2_z_1^z_2 dz ) . here @xmath215 are the solutions to @xmath216 and are thus the classical turning points of a particle with energy @xmath211 . the rate that the trapped atom collides with the barrier is approximated by @xmath217 , where the position and momentum uncertainties are obtained from the numerical ground - state solution . thus we estimate the inverse of the tunneling - limited lifetime to be @xmath218 . ( in arbitrary units ) seen by the atom . the maximum of the metastable barrier is located at @xmath213 . red curve : stable potential @xmath212 used to approximately calculate the binding energy @xmath211 ( blue line ) of the atom in the trap . the classical turning points @xmath215 of a particle with this energy , which are used to evaluate the tunneling rate in the wkb approximation , are labeled as well.[fig : wkb],width=264 ]

quantum vacuum forces dictate the interaction between individual atoms and dielectric surfaces at nanoscale distances . for example , their large strengths typically overwhelm externally applied forces , which makes it challenging to controllably interface cold atoms with nearby nanophotonic systems . here , we show that it is possible to tailor the vacuum forces themselves to provide strong trapping potentials . the trapping scheme takes advantage of the attractive ground state potential and adiabatic dressing with an excited state whose potential is engineered to be resonantly enhanced and repulsive . this procedure yields a strong metastable trap , with the fraction of excited state population scaling inversely with the quality factor of the resonance of the dielectric structure . we analyze realistic limitations to the trap lifetime and discuss possible applications that might emerge from the large trap depths and nanoscale confinement .

1607.07558

simultaneous planning localization and mapping ( splam ) or active slam has been a popular area of research over the years @xcite . the main theme is to compute a set of control actions for the mobile robot such that either the uncertainty of the robot or the combined uncertainty of robot and map states are bounded . traditionally , splam frameworks have been approached through either model predictive control @xcite or information gain @xcite paradigms . in recent times , belief space planning paradigms have tended to compute the control law in continuous domain @xcite taking a leaf out of slam frameworks that model it as a least squares problem @xcite . however , all of the above works assume the availability of immediate range data and uncertainty estimates for the map . some of them , such as @xcite , also assume the availability of dense range data transposed to an occupancy grid map . in contrast , in a monocular slam setting , the following complexities get accrued : * sparse depth estimates , which are highly inaccurate in textureless or low texture scenes * degeneracies in camera motion estimation such as in planar scenes or for in - place rotation of the camera * highly non linear nature of the camera projection operation since a monocular camera is not a depth sensor but a projective sensor [ cols= " < , < " , ] in this paper , we proposed a reinforcement learning based slam - safe navigational planner that learns to identify robot motions that can lead to failures in slam pose estimation and avoid such motions during trajectory planning . the method was expected to generate trajectories that have minimal failures and pose estimation errors over varying maps . through various experiments we have proven the effectiveness of a slam - safe planner that predicts failures and executes recovery actions to continue the navigation task . in terms of learning slam - safe behaviour , our method showed an increase in performance by about 50% as compared to supervised learning methods . in terms of slam recovery during trajectory planning , our methods showed about 70% improvement in comparison with a state - of - the - art trajectory planner and about 45% in comparison with supervised learning based planners . autonomous navigation with a monocular camera has always been challenging due to reasons mentioned earlier . this paper establishes that a rl framework is able to learn precisely those actions resorted by humans when they use a handheld camera or teleoperate a robot for slam . for example this involves slow transitions to newer scenes avoiding sharp turns by repeated back and forth motions , which was well captured by the learning framework . leung , cindy , shoudong huang , and gamini dissanayake . `` active slam using model predictive control and attractor based exploration . '' _ in intelligent robots and systems , 2006 ieee / rsj international conference on , pp . 5026 - 5031 . ieee , 2006 . _ leung , cindy , shoudong huang , ngai kwok , and gamini dissanayake . `` planning under uncertainty using model predictive control for information gathering . '' _ robotics and autonomous systems 54 , no . 11 ( 2006 ) : 898 - 910 . _ harvard indelman , vadim , luca carlone , and frank dellaert . `` planning in the continuous domain : a generalized belief space approach for autonomous navigation in unknown environments . '' _ the international journal of robotics research 34 , no . 7 ( 2015 ) : 849 - 882 . _ charrow , benjamin , gregory kahn , sachin patil , sikang liu , ken goldberg , pieter abbeel , nathan michael , and vijay kumar . `` information - theoretic planning with trajectory optimization for dense 3d mapping . '' _ proceedings of the robotics : science and system ( rss ) ( 2015 ) . _ klein , georg , and david murray . `` parallel tracking and mapping for small ar workspaces . '' _ in mixed and augmented reality , 2007 . ismar 2007 . 6th ieee and acm international symposium on , pp . 225 - 234 . ieee , 2007 . _ gopalakrishnan , balasubramanian , arun kumar singh , and k. madhava krishna . `` time scaled collision cone based trajectory optimization approach for reactive planning in dynamic environments . '' _ in intelligent robots and systems ( iros 2014 ) , 2014 ieee / rsj international conference on , pp . 4169 - 4176 . ieee , 2014 . _ koenig , nathan , and andrew howard . `` design and use paradigms for gazebo , an open - source multi - robot simulator . '' intelligent robots and systems , 2004.(iros 2004 ) . proceedings . 2004 ieee / rsj international conference on . 3 . ieee , 2004 .

effective slam using a single monocular camera is highly preferred due to its simplicity . however , when compared to trajectory planning methods using depth - based slam , monocular slam in loop does need additional considerations . one main reason being that for the optimization , in the form of bundle adjustment ( ba ) , to be robust , the slam system needs to scan the area for a reasonable duration . most monocular slam systems do not tolerate large camera rotations between successive views and tend to breakdown . other reasons for monocular slam failure include ambiguities in decomposition of the essential matrix , feature - sparse scenes and more layers of non linear optimization apart from ba . this paper presents a novel formulation based on reinforcement learning ( rl ) that generates fail safe trajectories wherein the slam generated outputs ( scene structure and camera motion ) do not deviate largely from their true values . quintessentially , the rl framework successfully learns the otherwise complex relation between motor actions and perceptual inputs that result in trajectories that do not cause failure of slam , which are almost intractable to capture in an obvious mathematical formulation . we show systematically in simulations how the quality of the slam map and trajectory dramatically improves when trajectories are computed by using rl .

0711.0725

symbiotic stars are binary systems in which a compact object accretes from red giant , the wind of which forms a dense nebula around the binary . the nebula is ionized by the hot compact source , which is usually a white dwarf @xcite . among the known symbiotic stars @xcite , four objects have shown recurrent nova ( rn ) eruptions : t crb , rs oph , v3890 sgr and v745 sco . these eruptions are triggered by a thermonuclear runaway on the white dwarf ( wd ) surface after accretion of a critical amount of h rich material from the companion . @xcite suggested that during quiescence , the x - ray emission from rn could originate in the boundary layer of an accretion disc that was reconstructed around the wd after the outburst . therefore , x - ray observations should allow one to determine a lower limit for the accretion rate . the low x - ray luminosity measured in 350 novae and recurrent novae in quiescence @xcite imply a low accretion rate , inconsistent with the observed recurrence times . for example , in the case of rs oph @xcite , the short recurrence time of @xmath120 years requires an accretion rate of @xmath110@xmath2 m@xmath3/yr , inconsistent with measured x - ray fluxes . this inconsistency is known as the missing boundary layer problem " . t crb is a well known recurrent nova with recorded outbursts in 1866 and 1946 . its quiescent - state hard x - ray emission ( e@xmath4 @xmath1 100 kev ) was first revealed during a 9 month @xmath5 survey @xcite . two additional @xmath5/xrt observations were analyzed by @xcite , who reported highly absorbed emission that was well fit with a cooling flow model with @xmath6=23.1 kev . the absorber consisted of components that both fully covered and partially covered the hard x - ray source . here we describe suzaku x - ray imaging spectrometer ( xis ) and hard x - ray detector ( hxd ) observations of the recurrent nova t crb performed on september 6 , 2006 . on september 6th 2006 , the astro - e2/suzaku x - ray observatory performed a 46 ks ( go ) observation of t crb ( obsid 401043010 start time 22:44:21 ut ) . we reduced the data according to standard procedures using the software package heasoft 6.2 . after determining the xis background count rate from a nearby blank region , we extracted spectra and light curves for the xis and hxd detectors . we extracted two sets of light curves for each detector one with a bin size of 360 s ( used to search for stochastic bright variations ) and the other grouping photons every 8 s. we used the light curve with the smaller time bins for power spectrum analysis . visual inspection of the extracted spectrum showed prominent fe lines around @xmath16.5 kev . as these lines are an indication of the presence of thermal emission from a plasma with temperatures @xmath110@xmath7 k , we first attempted to fit the spectrum with a single - temperature plasma plus neutral absorption . but no satisfactory fit was obtained . even using more complex absorbers , such as an absorber that only partially covers the source , or absorption from an ionized plasma , did not produce acceptable fits . we did , however , find acceptable fits ( @xmath8=1.07 ) for a multi - temperature , cooling flow plasma model ( @xmath9 ) . the model required a complex absorber consisting of one absorbing system that fully covered the source [ n@xmath10 @xmath11 , which includes interstellar absorption of 0.047@xmath12@xmath11 ] and and another that only partially covered the source [ n@xmath14 @xmath1510@xmath16 @xmath11 , partial covering fraction of 0.68@xmath17 . the minimum temperature of the cooling - flow model is consistent with the smallest value allowed by the _ mkcflow _ model ( @xmath18=0.0808 kev ) , and the maximum temperature is @xmath18=57.4@xmath19 kev . we also added a gaussian emission - line profile to the model to account for the fe k@xmath20 fluorescence line . figure [ fig : spectrum ] shows the spectra from the xis and hxd detectors , with the cooling - flow model overplotted . to estimate the parameters for the fe lines , we used a simple powerlaw fit to establish the continuum level , and then fit the fe k@xmath20 , fe xxv and fe xxvi emission lines with three gaussian profiles ( see fig . [ fig : spectrum ] , right panel ) . the equivalent widths obtained were 185@xmath21 , 135@xmath22 and 151@xmath23 ev respectively . we examined the xis time series binned at 360 s ( figure 2 ) and found significant stochastic variability above the level expected from poisson noise . the fractional amplitude of the stochastic variations , represented as the ratio between the measured rms variation , @xmath24 , and that expected from poisson fluctuations alone , @xmath25 , is 3.75 . in the case of hxd light curve , no stochastic variations were found above the poisson level . although by eye there appears to be a periodic ( or quasi - periodic ) variation in the light curve at a period of around 100 minutes , we did not detect a statistically significant oscillation at this period in our preliminary lomb - scargle analysis ( taking into account the underlying broadband continuum power ) of the xis and hxd light curves . hard x - ray emission with energy up to 100 kev is observed from the dwarf nova ss cyg in quiescence @xcite . dwarf novae observed with xmm-@xmath26 in quiescence also display spectra with energies up to @xmath112 kev @xcite . for low accretion rates ( @xmath27 3@xmath1510@xmath28 m@xmath3/yr ) , @xcite showed that the most internal part of an accretion disc around a 1 m@xmath3 wd , the boundary layer , radiates as an optically thin plasma at @xmath1 10 kev . the hardness of the x - ray emission detected from t crb strongly suggest that it comes from the accretion region closest to the wd . from the spectral model fitted , the accretion rate is @xmath29 @xmath14.2@xmath1510@xmath28 m@xmath3 yr@xmath30 ( @xmath31/1 kpc)@xmath32 . the detection of rapid flickering , which typically emanates from regions close to the wd , supports an accretion origin for the detected emission . moreover , the cooling - flow spectral model , as with boundary layer emission from non - magnetic cataclysmic variables ( cvs ; * ? ? ? * ) and other accreting high - mass white dwarfs @xcite , provides a natural context for the flickering . the ew of the neutral fe k@xmath20 line suggests that the x - ray source is surrounded by large amounts of neutral material @xcite . reflection of radiation off of the wd surface can also contribute to the formation of this line . from @xcite , the ew of the fe k@xmath20 line when a 2@xmath33 source reflects bremsstrahlung photons with @xmath110 kev is 100 - 200 ev . therefore the intense fe k@xmath20 line is consistent either with large amounts of neutral material , as with rt cru and cd -57 3057 @xcite , or with reflection from the surface of the wd . using the suzaku x - ray satellite , we observed hard - x - ray emission from the recurrent nova t crb in quiescence . assuming that a more detailed timing analysis confirms the lack of periodic variations , the presence of flickering on a timescale of minutes and the cooling - flow type spectrum suggest that the accretion onto the wd proceeds through a disc with an optically thin boundary layer . t crb is the first recurrent nova to show hard - x - ray emission from a boundary layer during quiescence . barlow e. j. , knigge c. , bird a. j. , dean a. , clark d. j. , hill a. b. , molina m. , sguera v. , 2006 , mnras , 372 , 224 belczysky , k , mikoajewska , j. , munari , u. , ivison , r.j . and friedjung , m. , 2000 , a&as,@xmath34,407 george i. , fabian a. , 1991 , mnras , 249 , 352 hachisu i. & kato m. , 2001 , apj , 558 , 323 hachisu , i. , kato , m. , luna , g. j. m. , 2007 , apjl , inoue h. , 1985 , sp . , 40 , 317 kennea , j. & mukai , k. , sokoloski j. , 2007 in prep . kenyon , s. j. , _ the symbiotic stars _ , 1986 , cambridge university press luna , g. j. m. & sokoloski j. l. , 2007 , apj , _ in press _ mukai k. , kinkhabwala a. , peterson j. r. , kahn s. m. , paerels f. , 2003 , apj , 586 , 77 narayan r. & popham r. , 1993 , nature , 362 , 820 nelson t. , orio m. , cassinelli j. , still m. , leibowitz e. , mucciarelli p. , 2007 , apj , in press orio m. , 1993 , a&a , 274 , l41 orio m. , covington j. , gelman h. , 2001 , a&a , 373 , 542 pandel d. , crdova f. a. , mason k. o. , priedhorsky w. c. , 2005 , apj , 626 , 396 smith r. , mushotzki r. , mukai k. , kallman t. , markwardt c. , tueller j. , 2007 , pasj , _ submetido _ sokoloski , j. l. , luna , g. j. m. , mukai , k. , kenyon , s. j. , 2006 , nature , 442,276 tueller , j. , barthelmy , s. , burrows , d. , falcone , a. , gehrels , n. , grupe , d. , kennea , j. , markwardt , c. b. , mushotzky , r. f. , skinner , g. k. , _ the astronomer s telegram _ , 669

we present suzaku x - ray observations of the recurrent nova t crb in quiescence . t crb is the first recurrent nova to be detected in the hard - x - ray band ( @xmath0 kev ) during quiescence . the x - ray spectrum is consistent with cooling - flow emission emanating from an optically thin region in the boundary layer of an accretion disk around the white dwarf . the detection of strong stochastic flux variations in the light curve supports the interpretation of the hard x - ray emission as emanating from a boundary layer .

astro-ph9912259

it has long been recognized that highly luminous ( @xmath0 erg s@xmath1 ) x - ray sources in the cores of globular clusters are grossly overrepresented with respect to the general galactic population ( katz 1975 ; clark 1975 ) : clusters contain @xmath2 of the galaxy s mass , but @xmath3 of the low - mass x - ray binary ( lmxb ) sources . a variety of lines of evidence tell us that these objects are neutron stars in very close binary systems , but the precise mechanisms which enhance their formation in clusters , and protect them from disruption thereafter , are obscure . essentially all of the bright cluster sources are also x - ray bursters , frequently emitting @xmath4 in just a few seconds . close binaries also have a profound effect on cluster dynamics : just a few such objects in a cluster have a store of orbital kinetic energy which can equal or exceed the orbital energy of all @xmath5 single cluster stars . thus the study of these rare and odd objects also has important macroscopic implications for the dynamical evolution of clusters ( elson et al . 1987 , hut et al . 1992 ) . considerable recent progress in the understanding of the intense bursting x - ray sources in globular cluster cores is in large part due to _ hubble space telescope _ ( _ hst _ ) identifications and follow - on studies of optical / uv counterparts , and to the realization that at least two of the cluster sources are exotic , ultra - short period double - degenerate binary systems : @xmath6 min for x1820303 in ngc6624 ( stella et al . 1987 ; anderson et al . 1997 ) and @xmath7 min for x1850087 in ngc6712 ( homer et al . 1996 ) . the optical / uv studies with _ hst _ have in one sense proven highly successful : a plausible optical counterpart has been identified and/or studied in detail in each of the clusters carefully scrutinized thus far . however , the diversity in properties of the six counterparts now identified is enormous , with optical luminosities ranging from @xmath8=6 to @xmath8=1 , and confirmed binary orbital periods ranging from 11 min to 17 hr . the only optical counterpart candidate thus far for x1832330 in ngc6652 was advanced by deutsch et al . ( 1998b ; hereafter paper i ) . the object , denoted star 49 , exhibits a uv excess in the _ hst _ data similar to other known lmxb optical counterparts , and similar absolute magnitude to the optical counterpart of the lmxb in ngc1851 . however , the region surveyed in paper i does not completely cover the _ rosat _ x - ray error circle derived in that work , and the images are not very deep . furthermore , the position of star 49 is discrepant at the @xmath9 level with the x - ray coordinates . for these reasons , paper i suggests that while star 49 is the best candidate for the optical counterpart , its identification remains tentative . since the initial search for the optical counterpart and discovery of star 49 in paper i , additional wfpc2 observations have become available in the _ hubble data archive_. here we discuss three orbits of f555w ( v ) and f814w ( i ) imaging data obtained on 1997 september 5 , as well as one orbit of f555w , f439w ( b ) , and f218w imaging data obtained on 1995 september 13 . in the former observation , seventeen @xmath1020 s f555w and f814w exposures were taken on the first orbit , twelve 160 s f555w exposures on the second orbit , and twelve 160 s f814w exposures on the third . for the latter observation , fine lock was not achieved and the stellar images are elongated , the cluster is miscentered on the ccds , and the f218w exposures failed completely . the retake data for this failed observation were successful , and are discussed in paper i , but did not include the proposed optical counterpart . the early , poor quality data , however , do actually include star 49 , are usable , and will be briefly discussed here as they were overlooked in paper i. all these data were acquired during unrelated programs to study the cluster ngc6652 itself . despite the suboptimal sampling of the wfpc2 _ wide field _ ccds , on which the optical counterpart falls in these observations , the cluster is sufficiently sparse and star 49 sufficiently unblended that aperture photometry is entirely adequate to measure magnitudes for this object and a set of nearby comparison stars . aperture corrections are taken from table 2(a ) in holtzman et al . ( 1995b ) . the photometric measurements have not been corrected for geometric distortions , nor is any correction for charge transfer efficiency losses ( holtzman et al . 1995b ) applied ; for most of the images , these effects should contribute errors of only a few percent . we use the photometric zero points for the stmag system from table 9 ( @xmath11 ) in holtzman et al . ( 1995a ) . systematic errors for all magnitudes due to uncertainties in detector performance and absolute calibration are @xmath105% . five nearby reference stars also photometered show no variability to the limit of the derived uncertainties ; three of the five are of comparable brightness of star 49 . for star 49 itself , variability is suggested in the 1995 epoch observations , and large amplitude variability is clearly evident in the 1997 epoch observations . this large - amplitude variability , when coupled with the uv excess demonstrated in paper i , lends considerable confidence that this object is the correct identification of the optical counterpart to x1832330 . from the three orbits of f555w and f814w observations , we find @xmath12 and @xmath13 . to create a single light curve of all the data , we subtract 0.4 mag from @xmath14 to create approximately filter - independent magnitudes . this result is searched for periodic components using algorithms described in horne & baliunas ( 1986 ) . in fig . 1a we show the fourier transform with the clean algorithm ( roberts et al . 1987 ) applied to remove the effects of the window function . we find the strong peak seen at @xmath15 min to have 99.5% significance , based on the original ( i.e. prior to cleaning ) periodogram , using methods in horne & baliunas ( 1986 ) . in fig . 1b we show the entire light curve ( @xmath16 , @xmath17 ) for the three orbit observation . uncertainty bars are provided for each datapoint , although they are sometimes smaller than the symbols themselves . a non - linear least squares fitting algorithm is used to determine the best fit sinusoid , which is overplotted on the light curve . the result is a best - fit period @xmath18 min , semi - amplitude @xmath19 mag , and mean magnitude @xmath20 . the sinusoid does describe the broad trends in the data quite well , but clearly a large amount of aperiodic flickering is also evident . in fig . 1c we show the light curve averaged into 10 phase bins . photometric uncertainties are smaller than the symbols . a few points deviate significantly from the sinusoid fit , most likely due to the strong flickering and small amount of data . during 1998 november 2830 , we obtained @xmath21 ks of x - ray observation on x1832330 with _ rossi x - ray timing explorer_. the data are processed through the standard _ ftools _ package to obtain a calibrated light curve . two type i x - ray burst events are evident , confirming the bursting nature of this source first reported by in t zand et al . ( 1998 ) with _ bepposax _ observations . after background subtraction , we measure a persistent countrate @xmath22 s@xmath1 , which is @xmath23 mcrab , similar to fluxes reported previously for this object . a search of the background - subtracted light curve reveals no significant periodicities , except for some power at half the _ rxte _ orbital period , apparently induced by the calculated background model . in particular , there does not appear to be any significant power at the 43.6 min optical period . the rms scatter in the x - ray light curve is consistent with poisson noise ; we find no evidence for flickering , which might be expected based on our optical observations . however , as the x - ray and optical observations were made over a year apart , no firm conclusions can be drawn from the lack of x - ray flickering . a further analysis of the light curve , spectra , and bursts in these x - ray data will be discussed elsewhere . mukai & smale ( 2000 ) present an x - ray observation of x1832330 from a 1996 _ asca _ observation . they also find no periodic x - ray modulation , but they do provide evidence for x - ray variability with a similar timescale as the flickering seen in our optical light curve . the peak in the periodogram of the optical data has 99.5% significance , indicating that it is quite improbable that uncorrelated , gaussian noise would randomly generate such a strong periodic signal . however , the evident scatter in the photometry is not due to measurement uncertainties , but rather an inherent flickering in the source , and this behavior is likely to produce significantly correlated `` noise '' . thus the formal significance calculation for the periodicity may overestimate the actual confidence . our derived period is close to , but statistically different from , half the _ hst _ orbital period . two further tests increase our confidence that this behavior is not an artifact of the _ hst _ orbit . as noted in 2.1 , several stars near to and of similar magnitude to star 49 have been measured from the same data , and show no variability at this or other periods . we have also randomized the association of observation times versus magnitudes for star 49 and rereduced the data . although periods due to incomplete removal of the window function should then remain , as the observing times are identical in these randomized data and in the original observations , the resulting periodograms show no significant power at 43 min . we find that only @xmath24 of 10000 trials show a peak at any frequency as high as the 43 min one . although the marked variability we report here adds confidence to the identification of star 49 with the x - ray source , the mediocre agreement of the x - ray position with the object still leaves some uncertainty . this issue will almost surely be settled by a scheduled observation by the _ chandra x - ray observatory _ , which should yield a highly accurate position . however , if we accept that our observed optical variations in star 49 are indeed periodic , there are few alternatives to identifying this object as a lmxb , given its measured characteristics , irrespective of the issues of the x - ray position . the most extreme sx phe stars , for example , have periods less than 1 hr , but do not display the marked flickering we observe , so stellar pulsation seems implausible . if the period is instead orbital , the flickering implies a mass - transfer system . however , no classical cataclysmic variables ( cvs ) are known with periods less than 1 hr , and although cvs share the colors and flickering of star 49 , they are typically 34 mag less luminous than our object in any case . the he - rich am cvn stars have the appropriate colors , flickering and period range , but are thought to have @xmath25 ( warner 1995 ) , so would be @xmath26 fainter than star 49 . thus , given the measured period , luminosity , colors , and flickering of this object , one would likely conclude it is an lmxb even without knowledge of the fact that there is indeed a bright x - ray source observed in the region . we summarize a variety of parameters for all of the globular cluster lmxb sources and their host clusters in table 1 . cluster data are primarily compiled from djorgovski ( 1993 ) and other references in the same volume . column 8 lists @xmath27 values , which we derive by taking a mean of the _ rxte _ asm flux measurements since 1996 , and applying a simple correction to convert approximately to @xmath28jy . in column 9 , we apply the distance correction and give an approximate x - ray luminosity in @xmath29 erg s@xmath1 for the 210 kev asm band . the absolute calibration is only an estimate and should be treated with caution , but the relative values are likely reliable . finally , in column 10 we list @xmath30 , the parameter used by van paradijs & mcclintock ( 1995 ) to characterize the ratio of x - ray to optical flux . that the optical luminosity should depend upon the x - ray luminosity and the size of the accretion disk has been quantified by van paradijs & mcclintock ( 1994 ; hereafter vpm94 ) . they define the parameter @xmath31 and find a strong correlation , such that m@xmath32 . in fig . [ periodrel ] we show a similar figure as in vpm94 , but we use m@xmath33 instead of m@xmath34 , which is likely to be reasonable as vpm94 find an average @xmath35 for field lmxbs . the data for globular cluster lmxbs are derived here and from deutsch et al . ( 1998a ) , and are plotted with large diamonds , approximately indicating the entire known range of optical and x - ray luminosity . the solid line indicates the best fit to all lmxbs by vpm94 . the dotted lines denote the apparent full range of possible values ( using vpm94 s best fit slope ) . for ngc1851 , no orbital period is known , but the optical and x - ray luminosities are measured . we therefore draw a dashed line which is likely to encompass the probable range of orbital periods , @xmath36 hr , where the lower bound is taken to be the shortest orbital period known and the upper value is the maximum period implied by our dotted line bounds . we thus predict that the orbital period of x0512401 will prove to be less than 1 hr . based on model accretion disks , deutsch et al . ( 2000 ) also infer that x0512401 must have orbital period less than one hour . as listed in table 1 , an eclipse period of 12.4 hr was recently reported by in t zand et al . ( 2000 ) for the lmxb in the globular cluster terzan 6 . using behavior exhibited by the gc lmxb sources in fig . 2 , we can now infer that the optical counterpart of that source ( for which there has not yet been a search ) will have @xmath37 . the high inclination ( @xmath38 ) inferred from the eclipse behavior by in t zand et al . ( 2000 ) suggests that the luminosity may well be at the fainter end of the above range , and thus similar to the optical counterpart in ngc6441 . however , the high reddening to terzan 6 will making discovery of the optical counterpart by conventional means ( _ hst _ observations of uv - excess ) extremely difficult ( deutsch et al . 1998b ) . a search for eclipses with infrared imaging of the x - ray error circle may be the easiest method of isolating the optical / ir counterpart of this source . the ultraviolet - excess candidate for the optical counterpart of the intense x - ray source in ngc6652 suggested by deutsch et al . ( 1998b ) is found to be highly photometrically variable . although the data are of limited length , the evidence is strong that a significant component of the variability is periodic , with @xmath39 min , most likely the orbital period of the system . regardless of whether or not the variability is periodic , the marked amplitude of the variations significantly strengthens the case for the identification of the object with the bursting x - ray source . somewhat tempering this conclusion is the poor positional agreement of the object with the only extant x - ray data , although _ chandra x - ray observatory _ observations will almost surely settle this issue . the lack of similar x - ray variability is inconclusive . star 49 is clearly unusual regardless of its association with the x - ray source , but the probability of two such unrelated objects falling within a few arcseconds of each other is presumably modest , so we favor the identification of the star and the x - ray burster , pending the _ chandra _ data . we examine a homogeneous set of _ hst _ data on globular cluster x - ray source counterparts , including star 49 in ngc6652 , and find that they fit well with the correlation of optical luminosity , x - ray luminosity , and accretion disk size previously discussed by vpm94 . even if the 43 min period is not confirmed , the orbital period of x1832330 must still be less than @xmath40 hr if it is to follow the relation of this diagram . using a somewhat different argument , mukai & smale ( 2000 ) also infer that x1832330 in ngc6652 is a short period system . the correlation in this diagram also strongly implies that the x - ray source in ngc1851 must have orbital period @xmath41 hr as well . a similar conclusion is reached by deutsch et al . ( 2000 ) via an independent argument , through examination of the spectral energy distribution of that object . thus four of the seven central globular cluster x - ray sources where orbital periods are constrained or known are inferred to be ultracompact , a fraction considerably in excess of that for field low mass x - ray binaries ; only @xmath42% of field lmxbs with known periods have @xmath41 hr in the compilation of van paradijs ( 1995 ) . in fact , if ultracompact systems in gc lmxbs were as rare as in the field , then the binomial probability that at least four out of seven systems are by chance found to be ultracompact is only @xmath43 . one can readily imagine multiple explanations for this significant overabundance of compact systems , although the unique dynamic environment of cluster cores is certainly a most tempting factor to invoke . it is not clear whether the same explanation applies even to all members of this small sample ( the double - degenerate systems in ngc6624 and ngc6712 may be unique ) , or that observational selection may be at work . _ rxte _ asm data products were provided by the asm / rxte teams at mit and at the _ rxte _ sof and gof at nasa s gsfc . support for this work was provided by nasa through grants nag5 - 7330 and nag5 - 7932 , as well as grant ar-07990.01 from the stsci , which is operated by aura , inc . llccrrrrrr 6.8 in x0512@xmath44401 & ngc 1851 & 0.02 & 15.43 & @xmath45 & @xmath46 & 5.60 & 5.5 & 1.9 & 22.88x1724@xmath44307 & terzan 2 & 1.42 & 14.37 & @xmath47 & & & 33.6 & 4.3 & x1730@xmath44335 & liller 1 & 3.00 & 14.68 & @xmath48 & & & 12.8 & 2.2 & x1732@xmath44304 & terzan 1 & 1.64 & 13.85 & @xmath49 & & & 6.4 & 0.5 & x1745@xmath44203 & ngc 6440 & 1.00 & 14.64 & @xmath50 & & & 5.5 & 0.9 & x1745@xmath44248 & terzan 5 & 1.87 & 14.50 & @xmath51 & & & & & x1746@xmath44370 & ngc 6441 & 0.45 & 15.15 & @xmath52 & 5.70 & 2.43 & 28.8 & 7.6 & 21.22x1747@xmath44313 & terzan 6 & 2.04 & 14.16 & @xmath53 & 12.36 & & 31.8 & 3.4 & x1820@xmath44303 & ngc 6624 & 0.27 & 14.54 & @xmath54 & 0.19 & 2.99 & 269.5 & 40.6 & 23.61x1832@xmath44330 & ngc 6652 & 0.10 & 14.85 & @xmath55 & 0.73 & 5.59 & 10.9 & 2.2 & 23.03x1850@xmath44087 & ngc 6712 & 0.46 & 14.16 & @xmath56 & 0.33 & 4.48 & 7.8 & 0.8 & 20.87x2127 + 119 & ngc 7078 & 0.09 & 15.11 & @xmath57 & 17.10 & 0.66 & 13.9 & 3.5 & 18.63

evidence is emerging that the luminous x - ray sources in the cores of globular clusters may often consist of , or perhaps even as a class be dominated by , ultracompact ( p1 hr ) binary stars . to the two such systems already known , in ngc6624 and ngc6712 , we now add evidence for two more . we detect large amplitude variability in the candidate optical counterpart for the x - ray source in the core of ngc6652 . although the available observations are relatively brief , the existing _ hubble space telescope _ data indicate a strong 43.6 min periodic modulation of the visible flux of semi - amplitude 30% . further , although the orbital period of the source in ngc1851 is not yet explicitly measured , we demonstrate that previous correlations of optical luminosity with x - ray luminosity and accretion disk size , strengthened by recent data , strongly imply that the period of that system is also less than 1 hr . thus currently there is evidence that 4 of the 7 globular cluster x - ray sources with constrained periods are ultracompact , a fraction far greater than that found in x - ray binaries the field . -0.5 in 9.20 in 0.216 in accepted for publication in the astrophysical journal letters + _ received 1999 november 5 ; accepted 1999 december 13 _

1209.0346

the spin orbit coupling ( soc ) , which describes the interaction between the spin and orbit degrees of freedom of a particle , has not only generated many interesting quantum phenomena in modern physics ranging from the nuclear physics to condensed - matter physics , and but also become an important resource for realizing fault - tolerant topological quantum computing @xcite . by controlling the external lasers , the different kinds of socs have been proposed to be simulated in the trapped bose - einstein condensates ( becs ) with the neutral atoms @xcite . especially , in recent experiment at nist , the equal rashba and dresselhaus socs has been realized successfully in the ultracold @xmath0rb atoms by a couple of raman lasers @xcite . attributed to this pioneer experiment , the investigation of soc - driven becs has attracted much attentions . moreover , rich many - body phenomena with no analogy in condensed - matter physics ( in becs , all ultracold atoms can occupy the same quantum state ) have been predicted by considering the ground - state properties larson2009,wc , wu , yip2011,yp , yp2,ss , xxu , zhu , hu , zhangdw , zhangdw2,ozawa , deng , weizheng2012,zhai2012,shenoy2012,zfxu , fialko , jr2012 . for example , in the presence of the equal rashba and dresselhaus socs , the bec is made up of two non - orthogonal dressed atom spin states carrying different momenta . furthermore , the interaction between these spin states are modified , driving a quantum phase transition from a spin - mixed state to a phase - separated state @xcite . in fact , even if the effective atom interaction governed by both the inter- and intra- spin interactions is not taken into account , a quantum phase transition from a separate phase ( sp ) to a single minimum phase ( smp ) can also occur @xcite . in very recent experiment , this new quantum phase transition has been observed by measuring the amplitude ratio of spin and momentum oscillation @xcite . it has been known that quantum phase transitions governed by the ground - state energies occur at absolute zero temperature @xcite . however , it is unattainable experimentally due to the third law of thermodynamics , i.e. , any system must work at a finite temperature . thus , it is crucially important to investigate the thermodynamic properties to fully understand the fundamental physics for a given system . for instance , in the framework of finite - temperature theory , the system s real evaluation can be described more accurately and some important physical quantities such as the specific heat , the entropy and the free energy , which have no zero temperature correspondence , can be explored . more importantly , some exotic phenomena driven only by thermal fluctuations can be revealed @xcite . motivated by the experimental developments and the third law of thermodynamics , we , for the first time , develop a quantum field approach to reveal the thermodynamic properties of the trapped bec with the equal rashba and dresselhaus socs . our main results are given as follows : ( i ) in the experimentally - feasible regime , the phase transition from the sp to the smp can be driven by the tunable temperature . moreover , the corresponding critical temperature is derived exactly and is independent of the trapped potential . ( ii ) we find that the specific heat has a large jump at the critical temperature . this step behavior is quite different from that of the atom population , which varies smoothly when crossing the critical point . it implies that the temperature - driven phase transition can be well detected by measuring the specific heat . ( iii ) in the different phases , the analytical expressions for the specific heat and the entropy are also given . in the smp , the specific heat as well as the entropy are governed only by the rabi frequency . however , in the sp , the strong soc modifies the energy structure and thus the thermodynamic statistics . at lower temperature , we find that the specific heat and the entropy in such phase are determined only by the soc strength . ( iv ) finally , the effect of the effective atom interaction is also addressed . in the smp , no collective excitations can be found in soc - driven bec and thus the effective atom interaction does not affect the thermodynamic properties . however , in the sp with soc - induced macroscopic excitations , this effective atom interaction affects dramatically on the critical temperature as well as the other thermodynamic quantities . for example , for the repulsive atom interaction , the critical temperature decreases , and vice versa . figure 1 shows the experimental scheme about how to create soc in the trapped bec with the ultracold @xmath0rb atoms at nist @xcite . in their experiment , the bec is trapped in the @xmath1 plane through a strong confinement with frequency @xmath2 along the @xmath3 direction . in the large detuning @xmath4 , the momentum - sensitive coupling between two hyperfine ground states @xmath5 and @xmath6 is constructed by a pair of raman lasers with rabi frequencies @xmath7 and @xmath8 incident at a @xmath9 angle from the @xmath10 axis , as illustrated in fig . 1(a ) . in the dressed - state basis @xmath11 and @xmath12 , where @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the wavevectors of the raman lasers , an effective soc , which is identical to the one - dimensional equal rashba and dresselhaus socs in condensed - matter physics , can be achieved . moreover , the corresponding hamiltonian with the atom - atom collision interaction can be written from the coupled gross - pitaevskii equations as @xcite @xmath15here , @xmath16 is a harmonic trap mode with @xmath17 and @xmath18 being the atom mass . @xmath19 reflects the experimentally - measurable population between the different spin components . @xmath20 is the trapped frequency in the @xmath10 direction . @xmath21 is the effective rabi frequency . @xmath22 with @xmath23 being the soc strength , where @xmath24 is the wavelength of the raman laser . the effective atom interaction @xmath25 is proportional to @xmath26 , where @xmath27 and @xmath28 are the inter- and intra- spin interaction constants with @xmath29 and @xmath30 being the _ s_-wave scattering lengths and @xmath31 . @xmath32 is the total atom number . if defining the number - dependent trapped frequency @xmath33 and the effective soc strength @xmath34 , hamiltonian ( [ h1 ] ) can be rewritten in the rotating frame as ( @xmath35 henceforth)@xmath36 in the following discussion , we focus mainly on hamiltonian ( [ h2 ] ) , in which @xmath37stands for the atom population . before proceeding , we estimate the relative parameters under current experimental conditions @xcite . in the experiment of nist , the tunable trapped frequency @xmath20 is of the order of 10 hz , and correspondingly , the number - dependent trapped frequency @xmath38 is of the order of mhz for @xmath39 . parameter @xmath40 is of the order of khz for @xmath41 nm . the effective rabi frequency @xmath42 can range from zero to the order of mhz . in addition , since @xmath43 @xmath44 and @xmath45 @xmath46 with @xmath46 being the bohr radius , we have @xmath47 and thus @xmath48 . it means that the effective atom interaction need not be taken into account in the nist s experiment . it should be pointed out that this effective atom interaction can be well controlled through feshbach resonance @xcite . moreover , its magnitude can reach the order of mhz near the feshbach resonant point . finally , we will take @xmath49 , which is of the order of khz , as the natural unit of the energy for simplicity . a key step to extract the thermodynamic properties of the soc - driven becs is to obtain the partition function of hamiltonian ( [ h2 ] ) @xcite . here we develop a quantum field approach , i.e. , an imaginary - time ( @xmath50 ) functional path - integral technique , to arrive at the target . we first rewrite the collective spin operators in the representation of the grassmann fermi fields , namely , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 , where the fermi operators @xmath53 and @xmath54 satisfy the anticommutator relations @xmath55 . furthermore , we transform the harmonic trap mode @xmath56 into a single mode bosonic field @xmath57 . as a consequence , the partition function is obtained by@xmath58 \exp \left [ -a(\tau ) \right ] . \label{pfc}\]]in eq . ( [ pfc ] ) , @xmath59=d[\psi , \psi ^{\ast } , \mu , \mu ^{\ast } , \nu , \nu ^{\ast } ] $ ] is the path integral measure . the euclidean action is given by @xmath60 , \label{aa}\]]where @xmath61 , @xmath62 with @xmath63 being the boltzmann constant and @xmath64 being the system s temperature , and @xmath65 . \label{hf}\ ] ] since hamiltonian ( [ h2 ] ) has two degrees of freedom including the spin and orbit cases , it is very difficult to directly discuss the partition function to extract its fundamental thermodynamic properties . the usual method is that we eliminate one degree of freedom by integrating the euclidean action @xmath66 @xcite . without the effective atom interaction ( @xmath67 ) , the euclidean action @xmath66 is a quadric term and the corresponding integral is gaussian . it means that in this case we can integrate over the grassmann fermi fields and then obtain the partition function of the bosonic mode . however , for nonzero @xmath25 ( @xmath68 ) , the integral in the euclidean action @xmath66 is not gaussian and thus the corresponding integral is hard to be solved directly . here we introduce an auxiliary field @xmath10 to circumvent this difficult . based on this auxiliary field @xmath10 , we have @xcite @xmath69\propto \int \left [ d\eta \right ] \exp \{\int_{0}^{\beta } d\tau \lbrack \frac{1}{q}x^{\ast } x-\sqrt{\frac{1}{n}}% \sum_{i=1}^{n}(x+x^{\ast } ) ( \mu _ { i}^{\ast } \mu _ { i}-\nu _ { i}^{\ast } \nu _ { i})]\}. \label{me}\ ] ] in analogy of the mean field approximation , the value of auxiliary field @xmath10 determines @xmath70 , as will be shown . substituting the formula about the auxiliary field @xmath10 into the euclidean action @xmath66 yields@xmath71where @xmath72@xmath73 , \label{az}\]]and @xmath74 \label{green}\]]with @xmath75 for the effective euclidean action @xmath66 in eq . ( [ action ] ) , we can integrate over the grassmann fermi fields , i.e. , the degree of freedom for the spin , and then obtain @xmath76 , \label{fact}\]]where @xmath77 and @xmath78 . finally , by means of the standard stationary phase approximation , namely , @xmath79 and @xmath80 , the required @xmath81 and @xmath82 , which play a crucial role in determining thermodynamic properties of hamiltonian ( [ h2 ] ) , can be obtained by @xmath83where @xmath84it should be noticed that in the derivation of eq . ( [ eeq ] ) we focus on the constant path that @xmath81 is not influenced by @xmath85 , namely , @xmath86 @xcite . according to eq . ( [ eeq ] ) we have@xmath87equation ( [ main1 ] ) shows clearly that there exist a trivial solution @xmath88 , and the nontrivial solutions @xmath89 and @xmath90 when @xmath91 . moreover , these nontrivial solutions are governed by the nonlinear equation @xmath92=\tanh ( \beta \zeta _ { 0}/2)$ ] , where @xmath93 . with the help of the stable condition at the equilibrium points , we can obtain the required solutions of both @xmath81 and @xmath82 and thus reveal the thermodynamics of hamiltonian ( [ h2 ] ) @xcite . and the temperature @xmath64 without the effective atom interaction ( @xmath67 ) , where the effective trapped frequency @xmath94 and the effective rabi frequency @xmath95 . the red dashed line given by eq . ( [ crt ] ) determines the critical boundary . inset : the scaled atom population @xmath96 as a function of the temperature @xmath64 with the effective soc strength @xmath97.,width=264 ] we first address the case of @xmath67 , which has been realized at nist lin . at zero temperature ( @xmath98 ) , @xmath99 and thus , eq . ( [ main1 ] ) becomes @xmath100 , which leads to solutions of @xmath101 for @xmath102 and @xmath103 and @xmath104 for @xmath105 . these zero - temperature solutions agree well with the direct numerical simulation of the soc - driven gross - pitaevskii equations @xcite . the nontrivial variations of both @xmath81 ( atom momentum ) and @xmath106 ( atom population ) show that a quantum phase transition occurs by adjusting the effective soc strength @xmath107 . moreover , we can call @xmath101 as the single minimum phase ( smp ) with no collective excitations , and @xmath108 and @xmath109 as the separate phase ( sp ) with the macroscopic excitations @xcite . with the increasing of the temperature @xmath64 , the order parameter @xmath81 or @xmath70 will be destroyed by thermal fluctuation . in particular , when @xmath110 , the system enters into the smp from the sp . by means of @xmath111 , the critical temperature can be obtained exactly by @xmath112eq . ( [ crt ] ) shows that the phase transition from the sp to the smp can be driven by the tunable temperature . moreover , the corresponding critical temperature obtained exactly is independent of the trapped potential @xmath113 . when @xmath114 and @xmath115 , the critical temperature is evaluated as * * * * @xmath116 nk , which is feasible in experiments about soc - driven becs . ( red lines ) as well as the entropy @xmath117 ( blue dashed lines ) as a function of the temperature @xmath64 without the effective atom interaction ( @xmath67 ) . the plotted parameters are given by @xmath118 , @xmath119 , and @xmath120 . these lines and the circles ( squares ) denote the numerical simulation ( ns ) and the analytical result ( ar ) , respectively . inset : the first - order derivative of @xmath121 versus the temperature @xmath64 ( blue dash - dotted line).,width=302 ] having obtaining the critical temperature , we discuss the experimentally - measurable atom population at finite temperature . in terms of the thermodynamic equilibrium equation ( [ main1 ] ) , the partition function is given in the smp with @xmath122 by @xmath123\ } , \label{psmp}\]]whereas it becomes @xmath124\ } \label{psp}\]]in the sp with @xmath125 . thus , the atom population can be derived from the formula@xmath126by @xmath127 in the smp and @xmath128 in the sp . in general , @xmath129 shoud be determined numerically by solving the nonlinear equation ( [ main1 ] ) . however , when @xmath98 , eqs . ( [ apt1 ] ) and ( [ apt2 ] ) reduce to the known analytical results @xcite . in fig . [ fig2 ] , we plot the scaled atom population @xmath130 as the functions of the effective soc strength @xmath107 and the temperature @xmath64 . this figure shows that thermal fluctuations destroy the collective excitations . as a result , the system finally enters into the smp from the sp . as a function of the effective soc strength @xmath131 for the different effective atom interactions @xmath132 ( black solid line ) , @xmath133 ( red dashed line ) and @xmath134 ( blue dash - dotted line ) . inset : the critical temperature versus the effective atom interaction @xmath25 with the different effective soc strength @xmath135 ( black solid line ) and @xmath136 ( red dotted line ) . in these figures , the other plotted parameters are given by @xmath118 and @xmath137.,width=264 ] for a full understanding of the temperature - driven phase transition , it is very important to discuss the thermodynamic quantities in the different phases . here we consider the specific heat per atom and the entropy per atom . the other thermodynamic quantities can be calculated using the same procedure . by means of the formula @xmath138with @xmath139 being the total energy , the specific heat per atom in the smp is obtained exactly by @xmath140which is independent of both the trapped frequency @xmath38 and the effective soc strength @xmath107 . in the sp , the specific heat per atom is evaluated as @xmath141 , \label{cvsp}\ ] ] where @xmath142 , @xmath143 , and @xmath144 with @xmath145 \right\ } $ ] and @xmath146\psi ^{2}\psi ^{\prime 2}+\gamma ^{2}\zeta % \mathop{\rm sech}^{2}(\beta \zeta /2)\tanh ( \beta \zeta /2)(\zeta ^{2}+4\beta \gamma ^{2}\omega \psi \psi ^{\prime } ) ^{2}+4\gamma ^{2}\omega \zeta ^{2}[1-\beta \gamma ^{2}\mathop{\rm sech}^{2}(\beta \zeta /2)]\psi ^{\prime 2}-8\gamma ^{4}\omega \zeta ^{2}\mathop{\rm sech}^{2}(\beta \psi ^{\prime } \}/\{-4\gamma ^{2}\omega \zeta ^{2}[1-\beta \gamma ^{2}\mathop{\rm sech}^{2}(\beta \zeta /2)]\psi \}$ ] . the specific heat @xmath147 implies that the strong soc can modify the energy structure of hamiltonian ( [ h2 ] ) and thus the thermodynamic statistics , as expected . as a function of the temperature @xmath64 for the different effective atom interactions @xmath132 ( black solid line ) , @xmath148 ( red dashed line ) and @xmath134 ( blue dash - dotted line ) . the other plotted parameters are given by @xmath149 , @xmath95 and @xmath150 , respectively.,width=264 ] it is very hard to directly extract the fundamental properties of the specific heat @xmath151 from the complicate expression ( cvsp ) . in fig . [ fig3 ] , we plot the specific heat @xmath152 ( red lines ) as a function of the temperature @xmath64 . this figure shows two interesting features . ( i ) the specific heat @xmath152 has a large jump at the critical point @xmath153 , separating the sp from the smp . this step behavior is quite different from that of the atom population @xmath106 in fig . [ fig2 ] , which varies smoothly when crossing the critical point . it implies that the temperature - driven phase transition can be well detected by measuring the specific heat @xmath152 . ( ii ) at lower temperature , we have approximately @xmath154 . thus , the specific heat in the sp can be obtained analytically by @xmath155which agrees well with the direct numerical simulations , as shown the red lines of fig . ( [ cv ] ) shows , in contrast to the behavior of the specific heat @xmath156 , the specific heat @xmath147 is governed only by the effective soc strength @xmath157 , i.e. , it is independent of both the trapped potential @xmath38 and the effective rabi frequency @xmath42 . another important thermodynamic quantity discussed in this paper is the entropy , which can be derived from the formula @xmath158 with @xmath159 being the gibbs function . in the smp , the entropy per atom is obtained exactly by @xmath160 -\frac{\omega } { t}\tanh \left ( \frac{\omega } { 2k_{b}t}\right ) , \label{ent1}\]]whereas it becomes @xmath161 { -}\frac{{1}}{t}{\tanh } \left ( { % \frac{{\zeta } } { 2k_{b}t}}\right ) \left ( { \zeta + } \frac{{{\zeta ^{\prime } } } } { % k_{b}t}\right ) { + } \frac{{2}}{k_{b}t^{2}}{\omega \psi \psi ^{\prime } } \label{ent2}\ ] ] in the sp . at lower temperature , the entropy can be evaluated approximately as @xmath162 \!-\!% \frac{{\gamma ^{2}}}{k_{b}t}{\tanh \!\ ! \left(\!\frac{{\gamma^{2}}}{k_{b}t}% \!\right)}\!\!\right\ } . \label{entroys}\ ] ] similar to the behaviors of the specific heat @xmath152 , the entropy @xmath117 in the smp is governed only by the effective rabi frequency @xmath42 , whereas it is determined only by the effective soc strength @xmath163 in the sp with lower temperature . however , its step behavior at the critical point @xmath164 is very small , as shown the blue lines of fig . [ fig3 ] . as a function of the temperature @xmath64 for the different effective atom interactions @xmath165 ( black solid line ) , @xmath166 ( red dashed line ) and @xmath167 ( blue dash - dotted line ) . the other plotted parameters are given by @xmath168 , @xmath119 and @xmath169 , respectively . the three gray lines indicate the critical temperatures in the different cases.,width=264 ] in this section , we illustrate the effect induced by the effective atom interaction , which is indeed controlled by the feshbach resonant technique in experiments . with the effective atom interaction ( @xmath68 ) , the critical temperature can be also obtained exactly by @xmath170}. \label{ctq}\]]in fig . [ fig4 ] we plot the critical temperature @xmath153 as a function of the effective soc strength @xmath107 for the different effective atom interactions . this figure shows clearly that for the attractive interaction ( @xmath171 ) , the critical temperature @xmath153 increases for a fixed soc strength @xmath157 , and vice versa . it means that in experiments we can manipulate the effective atom interaction @xmath25 to arrive at the experimentally - required critical temperature @xmath153 , where the thermodynamic phase transition from the sp to the smp occurs . on the other hand , in the smp , no collective excitations can be found in soc - driven bec and thus the effective atom interaction does not change the energy structure . it implies that the partition function in the smp is the same as eq . ( [ psmp ] ) , i.e. , it is independent of the effective soc strength @xmath107 , the trapped frequency @xmath38 and the effective atom interaction @xmath25 . however , in the sp the strong soc leads to the system s collective excitations with nonzero atom population . as a result , the term @xmath172 in hamiltonian ( [ h2 ] ) plays a crucial role in system s energy structure and thus the thermodynamic statistics . in such case , the partition function becomes @xmath173\ } , \label{pspq}\]]where @xmath174 , @xmath81 and @xmath175 can be obtained from the nonlinear equation ( [ main1 ] ) with the effective atom interaction @xmath25 . based on the obtained partition function , the experimentally - measurable atom population is given by @xmath176 and @xmath177 , which are plotted in fig . it is clearly that in the presence of the attractive interaction ( @xmath171 ) , the critical temperature increases and the system is more inclined to locate at the sp , and vice versa . this conclusion is identical to the result of fig . [ fig4 ] ( along the gray dotted line @xmath178 there ) . in addition , in the smp , the specific heat @xmath152 and the entropy @xmath117 are also identical to the results of @xmath67 . whereas , in the sp they become @xmath179 $ ] and @xmath180-\beta ( \zeta + \beta \zeta ^{\prime } ) \tanh ( \beta \zeta /2)+2\beta ^{2}\omega ( 1-q/\gamma ^{2})\psi \psi ^{\prime } \}$ ] , where @xmath181 , @xmath182 @xmath183 , @xmath184 \psi \}$ ] , and @xmath185\psi ^{2}\psi ^{\prime 2}+\delta \zeta { \mathop{\rm sech}}^{2}\left ( \beta \zeta /2\right ) \tanh \left ( \beta \zeta /2\right ) [ \zeta ^{2}+4\beta \eta ^{2}\omega \psi \psi ^{^{\prime } } ] ^{2}+4\eta ^{2}\omega \zeta ^{2}[1-\beta \delta { \mathop{\rm sech}}% ^{2}\left ( \beta \zeta /2\right ) ] \psi ^{\prime 2}-8\gamma \eta ^{3}\omega \zeta ^{2}{\mathop{\rm sech}}^{2}\left ( \beta \zeta /2\right ) \psi \psi ^{\prime } \}/\{-4\omega \eta ^{2}\zeta ^{2}[1-\beta \delta { \mathop{\rm sech}% } ^{2}\left ( \beta \zeta /2\right ) ] \psi \}$ ] with @xmath186 . when @xmath187 , they reduce to the forms @xmath188and @xmath189 -\lambda \tanh \left ( \lambda \right ) \right\ } , \label{entq}\]]where @xmath190 . in fig . [ fig6 ] , the specific heat @xmath152 as a function of the temperature @xmath64 for the different effective atom interactions is plotted . this figure shows that the fundamental properties of temperature - driven phase transition remain in the framework of the effective atom interaction . however , for the repulsive interaction ( @xmath191 ) , the critical temperature @xmath153 can decrease . moreover , the step amplitude at the critical point also decreases . for the attractive interaction ( @xmath171 ) , the opposite results exist . the similar behaviors of the entropy @xmath117 can be also found . in summary , we have explored the thermodynamic properties of the trapped bec with the equal rashba and dresselhaus socs , which has been realized in experiments . the thermodynamic phase transition from the sp to the smp as well as the critical temperature has been revealed . we have also discussed the important thermodynamic quantities such as the specific heat and the entropy and obtained their analytical expressions in the different phases . at the critical point , the specific heat has a large jump and can be thus regarded as a promising physical quantity to detect this temperature - driven phase transition . finally , we have illustrated the effect of the effective atom interaction , which can be well controlled by the experimentally - feasible feshbach resonant technique . especially , we have found that in the sp this effective atom interaction affects dramatically on the critical temperature and the corresponding thermodynamic properties for the soc - driven bec . before ending up this paper , we briefly make two remarks . firstly , our analysis is mainly based on the imaginary - time functional path - integral approach , in which the fluctuation of the space - dependent physical quantity ( such as the density ) is usually hidden or averaged out @xcite . as a consequence , the important stripe phase predicted before @xcite can not be distinguished from the sp effectively . secondly , without soc ( @xmath192 ) , hamiltonian ( h2 ) turns into @xmath193 . in this case , the relation @xmath90 becomes invalid . however , we can use the same procedure ( introducing the auxiliary field in path - integral technique ) to discuss the corresponding thermodynamics . we thank prof . chuanwei zhang and dr . yongping zhang for their helpful discussions this work was supported partly by the 973 program under grant no . 2012cb921603 ; the nnsfc under grants no . 10934004 , no . 60978018 , no . 11074154 , no . 11075099 , no . 61008012 , no . 11275118 , and no . 61275211 ; nnsfc project for excellent research team under grant no . 61121064 ; and international science and technology cooperation program of china under grant no.2001dfa12490 .

in this paper we develop a quantum field approach to reveal the thermodynamic properties of the trapped bec with the equal rashba and dresselhaus spin - orbit couplings . in the experimentally - feasible regime , the phase transition from the separate phase to the single minimum phase can be well driven by the tunable temperature . moreover , the critical temperature , which is independent of the trapped potential , can be derived exactly . at the critical point , the specific heat has a large jump and can be thus regarded as a promising candidate to detect this temperature - driven phase transition . in addition , we obtain the analytical expressions for the specific heat and the entropy in the different phases . in the single minimum phase , the specific heat as well as the entropy are governed only by the rabi frequency . however , in the separate phase with lower temperature , we find that they are determined only by the strength of spin - orbit coupling . finally , the effect of the effective atom interaction is also addressed . in the separate phase , this effective atom interaction affects dramatically on the critical temperature and the corresponding thermodynamic properties .

1306.5201

coin flipping had been already known to ancient romans as a way to decide an outcome @xcite . more recently , scientists inspired by this old question , how unbiased the real ( physical ) coin is , have been studying coin dynamics , see e.g. @xcite . previous studies have mainly focused on the dynamics of the flying coin assuming that it does not bounce and finding the effects of angular momentum on the final orientation . partial analysis in combination with numerical simulations of the bouncing effects has been done by vulovic and prange @xcite . it appears that this is the only reference that addressed the effect of bouncing on coin tossing . on the other hand , there is a well developed theory of mathematical billiards : classical dynamics of a particle moving inside a bounded domain . the particle moves along straight line until it hits the boundary . next , the particle reflects from the boundary according to the fermat s law . the billiard problem originally appeared in the context of boltzman ergodic hypothesis @xcite to verify physical assumptions about ergodicity of a gas of elastic spheres . however , various techniques in billiard dynamics turned out to be useful beyond the original physical problem . the so - called unfolding technique ( which is used in this paper ) allows one to obtain estimates on the maximal number of bounces of a particle in a wedge . one could expect that the bouncing coin dynamics could be interpreted as a billiard ball problem . in this paper we consider a simpler system ( with fewer degrees of freedom ) which we call the dumbbell . the bouncing coin on a flat surface , restricted to have axis of rotation pointing in the same direction , can be modeled as a system of two masses connected with a weightless rod . the dumbbell dynamics that is studied in this article is a useful model to initiate investigation of this potentially useful relation . another motivation for the dumbbell dynamics comes from robotics exploratory problems , see _ e.g. _ @xcite . consider an automated system that moves in a bounded domain and interacts with the boundary according to some simple laws . in many applications , it is important to cover the whole region as _ e.g. _ in automated vacuum cleaners such as roomba . then , a natural question arises : _ what simple mechanical system can generate a dense coverage of a certain subset of the given configuration space_. the dumbbell , compared to a material point , has an extra degree of freedom which can generate more chaotic behavior as _ e.g. _ in sinai billiards . indeed , a rapidly rotating dumbbell will quickly `` forget '' its initial orientation before the next encounter with the boundary raising some hope for stronger ergodicity . in this paper , we study the interaction of a dumbbell with the flat boundary . this is an important first step before understanding the full dynamics of the dumbbell in some simple domains . by appropriately rescaling the variables , we obtain an associated single particle billiard problem with the boundary corresponding to the collision curve ( which is piecewise smooth ) in the configuration space . the number of collisions of the dumbbell with the boundary before scattering out depends on the mass ratio @xmath0 . if this ratio is far from 1 , then the notion of adiabatic invariance can be introduced as there is sufficient time scales separation . we prove an adiabatic invariant type theorem and we describe under what conditions it can be used . finally , we estimate the maximal number of bounces of the dumbbell with the flat boundary . + * notation : * we use some standard notation when dealing with asymptotic expansions in order to avoid cumbersome use of implicit constants . + @xmath1 for some @xmath2 + @xmath3 + @xmath4 + let us consider a dumbbell - like system , which consists of two point masses @xmath5 , @xmath6 , connected by weightless rigid rod of length @xmath7 in the two - dimensional space with coordinates @xmath8 . the coordinates of @xmath5 , @xmath6 , and the center of mass of the system are given by @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 , respectively . let @xmath12 be the angle measured in the counterclockwise direction from the base line through @xmath5 and to the rod . we also define the mass ratios @xmath13 and @xmath14 which correspond to the distance from the center of mass to @xmath6 and to @xmath5 , respectively . the dumbbell moves freely in the space until it hits the floor . in this system , the velocity of the center of mass in @xmath15 direction is constant since there is no force acting on the system in @xmath15 direction . thus , we may assume without loss of generality that the center of mass does not move in @xmath15 direction . with this reduction , the dumbbell configuration space is two dimensional with the natural choice of coordinates @xmath16 . the moment of inertia of the dumbbell is given by @xmath17 introducing the total mass @xmath18 , we can write the kinetic energy of the system as @xmath19 using the relations , @xmath20 @xmath21 we find the velocities of each mass @xmath22 @xmath23 by rescaling @xmath24 , we rewrite the kinetic energy @xmath25 by hamilton s principle of least action , true orbits extremize @xmath26 since the kinetic energy is equal to the that of the free particle , the trajectories are straight lines between two collisions . when the dumbbell hits the boundary , the collision law is the same as in the classical billiard since in @xmath27 coordinates the action is the same . using the relations @xmath28 we find the boundaries for the dumbbell dynamics in the @xmath29-@xmath12 plane : @xmath30 @xmath31 the dumbbell hits the floor if one of the above inequalities becomes an equality . therefore , we take the maximum of two equations to get the boundaries : @xmath32 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that this boundary has non - smooth corner at @xmath33 . this is the case when the dumbbell s two masses hit the floor at the same time . we will not consider this degenerate case in our paper . now we will derive the collision law for the case when only @xmath5 hits the boundary . we recall that given vector @xmath34 and a unit vector @xmath35 the reflection of @xmath34 across @xmath35 is given by @xmath36 here and in the remainder of the paper , @xmath37 are defined as the corresponding values right before the collision and @xmath38 are defined as the corresponding values right before the next collision . according to the collision law , the angle of reflection is equal to the angle of incidence . in our case , @xmath35 is the normal vector to the boundary @xmath39 so that @xmath40\\ \vv_-&= \left[\yd_- , \pdm\right]=\left[\sqrt{m / i } \ , \ydm , \pdm\right].\end{split}\ ] ] then , using ( [ eq : ref ] ) , we compute @xmath41 $ ] . in this way , we express the translational and the angular velocities after the collision in terms of the velocities before @xmath5 hits the floor . changing back to the original coordinates , we have @xmath42 the bouncing law for the other case , when @xmath6 hits the boundary can be obtained in a similar manner : we switch @xmath43 and @xmath44 , replace @xmath45 and @xmath46 with @xmath47 and @xmath48 , and replace @xmath49 with @xmath50 . consider the case when @xmath51 and @xmath5 rotates around @xmath6 with high angular velocity @xmath52 and assume that the center of mass has slow downward velocity compared to @xmath52 . since multiplying velocities @xmath53 by a constant does not change the orbit , we normalize @xmath54 to be of order 1 , then @xmath55 is small . consider such dumbbell slowly approaching the floor , rotating with angular velocity of order 1 , _ i.e. _ @xmath56 . at some moment the small mass @xmath5 will hit the floor . if the angle @xmath57 ( or sufficiently close to it ) , then the dumbbell will bounce away without experiencing any more collisions . this situation is rather exceptional . a simple calculation shows that @xmath58 will be generically of order @xmath59 for our limit @xmath60 . in this section we assume this favorable scenario . for the corresponding set of initial conditions , we obtain an adiabatic invariant ( nearly conserved quantity ) . we start by deriving approximate map between two consecutive bounces . [ fig2 ] [ lemma_bounce ] let @xmath61 , @xmath62 and assume @xmath5 bounces off the floor and hits the floor next before @xmath6 does . then there exist sufficiently small @xmath63 such that if @xmath64 and @xmath65 , the collision map is given by @xmath66 @xmath67 we prove ( [ eq : phi ] ) in two steps . we first show that @xmath68 using the expression for @xmath69 in ( [ eq : law ] ) . we have , @xmath70 for sufficiently small @xmath71 , @xmath72 implies @xmath73 . it follows that @xmath74 observe from the figure 2 that @xmath75 . thus , @xmath76 where @xmath77 using that @xmath78 , we obtain @xmath79 combining the results , we have @xmath80 this completes the proof for ( [ eq : phi ] ) . + let @xmath81 be the time between the two consecutive collisions of @xmath5 . then @xmath82 . the angular distance that @xmath5 traveled is given by @xmath83 where @xmath84 and @xmath85 are the error estimates for the taylor series expansion and are given explicitly by @xmath86 since @xmath5 can travel at most @xmath87 between two collisions , @xmath81 is bounded by @xmath88 . also note that @xmath84 and @xmath85 contain the factor @xmath89 and @xmath43 respectively . we finish the proof for ( [ eq : dist ] ) by computing , @xmath90 under the same assumptions as in lemma [ lemma_bounce ] with the exception @xmath91 for @xmath92 and @xmath93 , the variables after the collision are given by the similar equations to ( [ eq : phi ] ) and ( [ eq : dist ] ) but with different error terms . @xmath94 @xmath95 when computing the error terms , use @xmath96 . now , we can state the adiabatic invariance theorem for the special case when the light mass hits the floor and the dumbbell is far away from the vertical position : @xmath97 . [ ai_theo ] suppose right before the collision @xmath98 and @xmath99 . then there is @xmath100 such that if @xmath101 , @xmath102 , then there exists an adiabatic invariant of the dumbbell system , given by @xmath103 , where @xmath104 . in other words , @xmath105 after @xmath106 collisions . we prove this by finding @xmath107 that satisfies @xmath108 when @xmath109 and @xmath71 is sufficiently small , it follows from ( [ eq : dist ] ) that , @xmath110 then , we have @xmath111 therefore , @xmath107 satisfies @xmath112 provided @xmath113 the solution of the above equation is given by @xmath114 let @xmath115 and let @xmath116 and @xmath117 be the angular velocity and the distance after @xmath118 collision . then , we have @xmath119 adiabatic invariant has a natural geometric meaning : angular velocity times the distance traveled by the light mass between two consecutive collisions . now , we state the theorem for a realistic scenario when a rapidly rotating dumbbell scatters off the floor . let the dumbbell approach the floor from infinity with . there exists @xmath120 such that if @xmath121 , @xmath122 , @xmath123 then , after @xmath124 bounces the dumbbell will leave the floor after the final bounce by @xmath5 with @xmath125 . the adiabatic invariant is defined as above @xmath126 . the condition on the angle @xmath127 comes naturally from the following argument . if @xmath128 , the dumbbell approaching from infinity will naturally hit the floor when @xmath129 . since @xmath71 is small , this implies @xmath130 . if @xmath131 happens to be too close to @xmath132 , then there is no hope to obtain adiabatic invariant and we exclude such set of initial conditions . in the limit @xmath133 the relative measure of the set where @xmath134 tends to zero . we will split the iterations ( bounces ) into two parts : before the @xmath135 iteration and after it , where @xmath136 $ ] and @xmath137 is sufficiently small ( to be defined later ) . we claim that after @xmath138 bounces , @xmath139\de$ ] . to prove this claim , we use energy conservation of the dumbbell system ( [ eq : egy ] ) , and ( [ eq : phi ] ) . we have @xmath140 next , @xmath141 by our assumptions , @xmath142 so it follows that @xmath143 after @xmath144 bounces , @xmath145 if @xmath137 is sufficiently small and we still have the vertical velocity of same order , _ i.e. _ @xmath146 . then , at the @xmath135 collision , the center of mass will be located at @xmath147 , which will imply @xmath139\de$ ] . now using lemma 3.1 , corollary 3.2 , and theorem 3.3 , we compute the error term of the adiabatic invariant under the assumption that the total number of collisions is bounded by @xmath148 and the heavy mass does not hit the floor . @xmath149 by the theorem proved in the next section there is indeed a uniform bound on the number of bounces . if the heavy mass does hit the floor it can do so only once as shown in the next section . we claim that the corresponding change in the adiabatic invariant will be only of order @xmath150 . indeed , using formula and the comment after that , we obtain @xmath151 where subscripts @xmath152 denote the variables just after and before the larger mass hits the floor . let the pairs @xmath153 @xmath154 denote the corresponding values of @xmath155 when the light mass hits the floor right before and after the large mass hits the floor . then , since @xmath156 , we find that @xmath157 and @xmath158 . as a consequence , @xmath159 and the change in adiabatic invariant due to large mass hitting the floor is sufficiently small @xmath160 . in this section , we estimate the maximal number of collisions of the dumbbell with the floor as a function of the mass ratios . as we have seen in section 2.2 , on @xmath161 plane , the dumbbell reduces to a mass point that has unit velocity and elastic reflection . we use the classical billiard result which states that the number of collisions inside a straight wedge with the inner angle @xmath162 is given by @xmath163 , see e.g. @xcite . first , we discuss the properties of the boundaries of the dumbbell system on @xmath164 plane . + when @xmath165 , we have the mass ratios @xmath166 . recall from ( [ bd ] ) that the boundaries are given by @xmath167 \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the angle between the two sine waves is @xmath168 . + when @xmath169 , it follows from ( [ bd ] ) that the boundaries consist of two sine curves with different heights . we will assume @xmath170 , since the case @xmath171 is symmetric . it is easy to see that generically in the limit @xmath172 most of repeated collisions will occur between two peaks of ( [ bd1 ] ) . in section 4.2 , we will find the upper bound for the number of collisions of the mass point to the boundaries . to start the proof , let us consider the straight wedge formed by the tangent lines to ( [ bd1 ] ) at @xmath173 and @xmath174 . we call these tangent lines @xmath175 and @xmath176 respectively , and denote the angle of the straight wedge by @xmath177 , see figure 3 . let us denote the wedge created by the union of the sine waves when @xmath178 and the tangent lines @xmath175 and @xmath176 when @xmath179 as the hybrid wedge . plane.,width=240 ] we first introduce some notations . denote the trajectory bouncing from the hybrid wedge by @xmath180 , and let the approximating trajectory bouncing from the straight wedge by the double - prime symbols @xmath181 . when @xmath180 or @xmath181 is written with the subscript @xmath182 , it denotes the segment of the corresponding trajectory between the @xmath182-th bounce and the @xmath183-st bounce . let @xmath184 be the angle from the straight wedge to @xmath185 , and @xmath186 denote the angle from the straight wedge to @xmath187 after the @xmath182-th collision . define @xmath188 as the angle difference between the straight wedge and the curved wedge at @xmath182-th collision of @xmath185 . the trajectory will terminate when the sequence of angles terminates ( due to the absence of the next bounce ) , or when there will be no more intersections with the straight wedge . this will happen when the angle of intersection , @xmath189 , @xmath190 and @xmath191 , with the tangent line is less than or equal to @xmath177 . consider the hybrid wedge and the straight wedge described above . the sequence of angles @xmath192 will terminate after or at the same index as the sequence of angles @xmath193 . suppose that the initial segment @xmath194 ( of the full trajectory ) crosses the straight wedge before it hits the hybrid wedge , as shown on the right panel of figure 4.1 . then @xmath195 when the initial segment @xmath194 hits the hybrid wedge before crossing the straight wedge , as shown on the left panel , then set @xmath196 . now we can proceed by induction if @xmath197 and @xmath198 and the sequence @xmath184 has not terminated . @xmath199 which implies that @xmath200 . + since @xmath201 , then @xmath180 will terminate at the same time or before @xmath181 . define the bridge as the smaller sine wave created by @xmath202 when @xmath203 from @xmath173 to @xmath204 . the union of the bridge with the hybrid wedge will create the boundary as it is actually defined by the dumbbell dynamics . the presence of the bridge in the hybrid wedge will increase the number of collisions of the dumbbell by at most one from the number of collisions of the dumbbell to the hybrid wedge . consider the true trajectory ( denoted by @xmath205 ) that `` sees '' the bridge . recall the definition of angle @xmath184 , which is the angle from the straight wedge to @xmath206 . similarly , we let @xmath207 be the angle to @xmath208 . before @xmath205 intersects the bridge , by lemma 4.1 we have @xmath209 now define @xmath210 to be the angle measured from the horizontal line to the tangent line at the point where @xmath205 hits the bridge . note that @xmath210 takes a positive value if the dumbbell hits the left half of the bridge , and @xmath210 takes a negative value if @xmath205 hits the right half of the bridge . we express @xmath211 after the bounce from the bridge in terms of @xmath207 . by this convention , the bounce from the bridge does not increase the index count but we will have to add @xmath212 in the end . + then , we have @xmath213 we may assume that @xmath205 hits the bridge with non - positive velocity in @xmath29 . if the dumbbell hits the bridge with positive velocity in @xmath29 , it will continue to move in the positive @xmath29 direction after reflection from the bridge . then , we consider the reverse trajectory to bound the number of collisions . this allows us to restrict @xmath207 . moreover , @xmath208 naturally hits the upper part of hybrid wedge than @xmath206 . we also assume that @xmath205 hits the left half of the bridge . otherwise , we can reflect the orbit around the vertical line passing through the middle point of the bridge . utilizing the above arguments , we have the inequalities @xmath214 it is straightforward to verify that ( [ 8 ] ) and ( [ 9 ] ) imply @xmath215 . from the @xmath216-nd bounce , if @xmath207 has not terminated , we can apply induction argument similar to the proof in lemma 4.1 . we have the base case @xmath217 note that @xmath218 s indicate the relative position of a collision point in the hybrid wedge . that is , if @xmath219 , then the starting point of @xmath220 is located at or above that of @xmath208 . since @xmath215 and @xmath220 starts above @xmath221 , we know @xmath222 will start on the hybrid wedge higher than @xmath223 . this implies @xmath224 then using the recursive relationship , @xmath225 we obtain @xmath226 . by induction @xmath227 for all @xmath182 . taking into account the bounce on the bridge , we conclude that the number of bounces of @xmath205 will increase at most by one relative to that of @xmath180 . note that in most cases , the number of bounces of @xmath205 will be less than the number of bounces of @xmath180 . now we are ready to prove the main theorem . the number of collisions of the dumbbell is bounded above by @xmath228 , where @xmath229 . when @xmath230 , as we have found in the previous section 4.1 , the boundaries form identical hybrid wedges which intersect at @xmath231 . using lemma 4.1 , we conclude that the upper bound for the number of collisions is @xmath232 , which is less than @xmath233 . + when @xmath170 , we consider the true boundaries which consist of a hybrid wedge with the bridge . using lemma 4.1 and lemma 4.2 , we conclude that the the maximal number of collisions to the true boundary is bounded above by @xmath234 . since @xmath235 , this completes the proof . the authors acknowledge support from national science foundation grant dms 08 - 38434 emsw21-mctp : research experience for graduate students . " ymb and vz were also partially supported by nsf grant dms-0807897 . the authors would also like to thank mark levi for a helpful discussion . 100 r. alleyne ( december 31 , 2009 ) . `` coin tossing through the ages '' . the telegraph . l. bobadilla , f. martinez , e. gobst , k. gossman , and s. m. lavalle , controlling wild mobile robots using virtual gates and discrete transitions . in american control conference , 2012 . p. diaconis , s. holmes , r. montgomery , dynamical bias in the coin toss , siam review , 49(2 ) , 211 - 235 , 2007 . j.b . keller , the probability of heads , amer . monthly 93 , 191 , 1986 . l. mahadevan , e.h . yong , probability , physics , and a coin toss , physics today , july 2011 . j. sinai , introduction to ergodic theory , math . notes , 18 . princeton univ . press , princeton , n.j . s. tabachnikov , geometry and billiards , geometry and billiards . 30 , ams , 2005 . vulovic , r.e . prange , randomness of a true coin toss , phys . a 33 , 576 - 582 , 1986 .

a system of two masses connected with a weightless rod ( called dumbbell in this paper ) interacting with a flat boundary is considered . the sharp bound on the number of collisions with the boundary is found using billiard techniques . in case , the ratio of masses is large and the dumbbell rotates fast , an adiabatic invariant is obtained .

0706.3376

the preparation of many - particle entangled states is becoming a fundamental task in modern quantum physics . entanglement lies at the heart of quantum communication and quantum information and is also a fundamental resource in precision spectroscopy . with recent advances in the manipulation of trapped ions and neutral atoms , there has been significant progress in the preparation of many - body entanglement states in atomic gases @xcite . such systems therefore offer rich opportunities to investigate new physics with both practical and fundamental applications . here we propose an interferometric method that uses the entanglement that emerges during the many - body dynamics between interacting spinor atoms to perform precision measurements of their interatomic interaction strength , usually parameterized by the @xmath3-wave scattering length . our method is a many - body generalization of the technique reported in ref . @xcite , where information of the scattering properties was obtained by using the entanglement dynamics in pairs of atoms trapped in the ground state of a potential well . a precise determination of the scattering properties has broad and important applications beyond atomic physics . for example , ref . @xcite shows that such type of measurements might be useful for fundamental physics , as by monitoring the scattering length on the @xmath4 level one could detect variation in the electron to proton mass ratio on the level of @xmath5 . standard ramsey spectroscopy starts with a system of @xmath0 non - interacting spin @xmath1 particles initially prepared in the same internal state . subsequently , a ramsey pulse prepares it in a coherent superposition of the two internal states and the system is let to evolve freely for a time during which a relative phase accumulates , @xmath6 , due to the energy splitting between the two states . the latter is then decoded by using a second ramsey pulse which maps the phase onto a population difference , thus allowing to perform precision measurements of the atomic transition frequency . the statistical fluctuations associated with a finite sampling yields a lower limit in the phase accuracy @xmath7 called the shot noise limit @xcite . the heisenberg uncertainty principle , however , allows for phase accuracies consistent with the basic principles of quantum mechanics , as low as @xmath8 , called the heisenberg limit . the latter can be achieved by using initially entangled atoms instead of a polarized sample @xcite . here we propose a spectroscopy technique which aims to measure the atomic interaction parameters arising form two - body collisions by using similar ramsey spectroscopic ideas , but applied to interacting atoms instead of non - interacting ones . the many - body interactions during the free evolution build in quantum mechanical correlations between the atoms and generates a large amount of entanglement even from an initially uncorrelated sample @xcite . this scheme provides a resolution which is fundamentally limited to @xmath2 , a factor of @xmath0 smaller than the heisenberg limit achievable with non - interacting atoms . moreover , for initially uncorrelated atoms the sensitivity scales as @xmath9 , implying a gain in resolution by a factor of @xmath10 with respect to the classical shot noise resolution . a more general analysis of beyond - heisenberg scaling for multi - body collisions or tensor - field interactions has been derived in ref . @xcite . many - particle entangled states , however , are difficult to prepare and maintain since they are extremely fragile : in practice , noise and decoherence rapidly collapse entangled states into classical statistical mixtures . for example in standard ramsey spectroscopy decoherence destroys the potential gain provided by entanglement , and , when it is taken into account both initially uncorrelated and maximally entangled states provide the same shot noise resolution @xcite . here we show that decoherence degrades the sensitivity of our method to @xmath11 for initially entangled atoms and to @xmath12 for initially uncorrelated ones . this scaling is interesting as it demonstrates that the entanglement build up by the many - body interactions helps , even with decoherence , to keep the sensitivity achievable with initially squeezed atoms above the maximally achievable with initially uncorrelated particles . we also discuss physical implementation of our scheme using a ) spinor bose- einstein condensates and b ) fermionic atoms loaded in optical lattices and compare and contrast the advantage and disadvantages of these two possible set - ups . the paper is organized as follows . in sec . ii we present our interferometry method based on the many - body collective dynamics . in sec . iii we apply it to initially uncorrelated states and derive the type of initially entangled states that lead to heisenberg - limited sensitivity . in this section we also propose a way to generate such states . in sec . iv we include the effect of decoherence . in sec . v we discuss the experimental implementation of the interferometry method using spinor condensates and cold fermionic atoms in optical lattices and discuss possible technical limitations . finally we conclude in sec . vi . let us consider a collection of @xmath0 spin-1/2 interacting particles described by the hamiltonian @xmath13 we used @xmath14 to denote the collective spin operators of the @xmath0 atoms : @xmath15 , where @xmath16 and @xmath17 is a pauli operator acting on the @xmath18 atom . we set @xmath19 . our interferometric technique follows the same ideas used in standard ramsey spectroscopy , but replaces the free evolution of the atoms by evolution with @xmath20 and the goal is to estimate @xmath21 as accurately as possible . we start with the initial state @xmath22 and apply a @xmath23 rotation to all particles about the y axis , @xmath24 . after letting the system evolve for time @xmath25 under @xmath20 , @xmath26 , a second @xmath27 pulse is applied , @xmath28 . finally the collective spin is measured @xmath29 . if this scheme is repeated during a total time @xmath30 the achievable sensitivity is given by @xmath31 with variance @xmath32 . in contrast to standard ramsey spectroscopy , which is fundamentally limited by the heisenberg exclusion principle to @xmath33@xcite per realization , the fundamental limit of this scheme is @xmath34 . this follows from an application of the time - energy uncertainty principle : @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the variance of the hamiltonian and @xmath37 is the variance in estimating time from a measurement on the system . can be used to determine time with an uncertainty @xmath38 the time - energy uncertainty can be reexpressed as @xmath39 , where @xmath40 . we can establish an upper limit @xmath41 from @xmath42 is @xmath43 . this implies @xmath44 and therefore a fundamental uncertainty in determining @xmath45 after a time @xmath25 of : @xmath46 spectroscopy ------------ let us start by outlining the basic properties of @xmath20 . it commutes with @xmath47 and @xmath48 , so a good basis to describe the dynamics is the one spanned by the collective angular momentum eigenstates . in the @xmath49 dimensional hilbert space , there are @xmath50 orthogonal fully symmetric states which we denote by @xmath51 that satisfy : @xmath52 , and @xmath53 with @xmath54 . we refer to the @xmath55 states as the @xmath56 manifold . the quantum numbers @xmath57 and @xmath58 are conserved during the dynamics , and therefore , if the initial state @xmath59 belongs to @xmath56 , then the subsequent evolution of the system only takes place within @xmath56 . first , consider the case when the initial state is fully polarized along @xmath60 : @xmath61 . after the first @xmath23 pulse it becomes @xmath62 . the effect of @xmath20 on the state is to imprint a phase @xmath63 to each @xmath64 component . in the limit of many atoms @xmath65 we may approximate the sums by integrals assuming @xmath66 is a continuous variable and to replace the binomial coefficient by a gaussian distribution with the same width . in this limit @xmath67 and @xmath68 become @xmath69 where we used the notation @xmath70 . the time evolution of the signal is a series of equally spaced gaussian pulses ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) . as the system evolves , at first the different accumulated phases lead to a collapse of @xmath71 . for the initial coherent state in consideration . the collapse time , which depends on its variance , is @xmath72 . the evolution continues and at @xmath73 all the different components rephase inducing a perfect revival of the initial state , now with opposite polarization:@xmath74 . using eqs . ( [ jz ] ) and ( [ jz2 ] ) one can show that the optimal sensitivity is reached at the points with maximal signal intensity , @xmath75 . it scales as @xmath9 ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) : @xmath76 entangled atomic states ( e.g. spin squeezed states ) potentially allow to significantly improve the sensitivity in precision measurements . for example , consider the initial state@xmath77 \right ) } { \sqrt{1+a^{2 } } } . \label{inisquee}\ ] ] here @xmath78 is a real number of order unity and @xmath0 is assumed to be even and large . the probability distribution of @xmath79 in the @xmath80 basis is plotted in the inset of fig.[fig2 ] . for even @xmath58 values , the amplitudes are almost constant ( except for those with @xmath81 close to @xmath82 ) , and for odd @xmath58 values they are proportional to @xmath83 . @xmath84 is a highly squeezed state with reduced variance in the @xmath60 direction : @xmath85 . using properties of the wigner rotation functions , it is possible to show that : @xmath86}{n ( \chi t-\pi/2 + k\pi ) } , \label{jzs } \\ \langle \hat{j}_x^2\rangle_\psi^a & = & n^2a\sum_{k=0 } \left(\frac{% j_1[2n(\chi t- k \pi/2]}{(2n ( \chi t- k\pi/2))}\right ) + b , \label{jz2s}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath87 and @xmath88 . as shown in fig . [ fig2 ] the system starts at @xmath89 with @xmath90 , and during the time evolution @xmath91 grows while oscillating . at @xmath92 the signal reaches a maximum and vanishes again at @xmath93 . then it evolves with opposite polarization until it returns to the initial state at @xmath94 . using eqs . ( [ jzs ] ) and ( [ jz2s ] ) , the optimal sensitivity can be shown to be reached at @xmath95 , with @xmath96 an odd integer ( see fig.[fig3 ] ) : @xmath97 these states lead to @xmath98 sensitivity . the best accuracy is obtained for @xmath99 , in which case @xmath100 . note , however , that estimating @xmath101 by measuring @xmath102 might be experimentally impractical due to the fact that not only the signal vanishes at @xmath95 ( regardless of the value of @xmath78 ) but also @xmath103 is very sharply peaked at @xmath95 and hence very sensitive to small variations of @xmath104 . to overcome this limitation we propose , following the ideas exposed in ref . @xcite , to measure @xmath105 instead of @xmath102 . in contrast to @xmath102 , the average square signal does not vanishes for finite @xmath78 ( it goes like @xmath106 ) and , as shown in fig . [ fig3 ] , measuring @xmath101 by means of @xmath107 provides the same @xmath2 accuracy with the advantage of a broader profile around the optimal value which becomes slightly shifted from @xmath108 . we calculated @xmath103 numerically according to eq . ( [ sig ] ) but replacing @xmath102 by @xmath109 . this idea , however , has the drawback that @xmath110 diverges exactly at @xmath108 . nevertheless as shown in fig . 3 this is a extremely narrow divergency and almost a one point behavior . let us now discuss how to generate states of the form given by eq.([inisquee ] ) . these states are highly squeezed , and a robust method to generate them can have also applications in heisenberg limited phase detection @xcite . the idea is to adiabatically convert @xmath111 into @xmath112 by gradually increasing @xmath113 from @xmath114 to @xmath115 in the following time dependent hamiltonian@xcite : @xmath116the first term proportional to @xmath117 is required to keep the system within @xmath56 . as shown in fig . 4 , there is always a finite gap between the ( non - degenerate ) ground state . ] and the lowest excited state , so the adiabatic passage can be satisfied . the experimental implementation eq.([hadiabatic ] ) will be discussed in sec.vb once @xmath118 is obtained , the @xmath119 components can be generated by evolving @xmath118 with the hamiltonian @xmath120 . as proposed in ref . @xcite , @xmath121 can be implemented by using two laser beams with frequency difference twice the hyperfine level splitting which coherently flips pairs of aligned spins . comparable to unity , excitations to states with @xmath122 , should also be considered . ] in realistic experiments decoherence effects are inevitably present . the main type of decoherence is dephasing due to processes that cause random changes in the relative phase of the quantum states , while preserving the total atomic population in the atomic levels . among the mechanisms that result in dephasing effects one can consider collisions , stray fields , and laser instabilities . we model the phase decoherence by adding a term to the hamiltonian given by @xmath123 where @xmath124 are independent random gaussian variables with zero mean and white noise correlation functions @xmath125 that represent couplings with the environment . here the bar denotes averaging over the different outcomes of the random variables . this model is equivalent to considering the time evolution of the reduced density operator for a single ion @xmath126 as given by the master equation @xmath127-\gamma /2(\sigma _ { z}\hat{\rho}\sigma _ { z}-\hat{\rho})$ ] . to include the effect of decoherence it is simpler to go to the uncoupled basis which diagonalizes both @xmath128 and @xmath20 . each state in this basis can be label as @xmath129 , where @xmath130 and @xmath131 . using the uncorrelated nature of the @xmath132 variables one can show by straightforward calculations that @xcite @xmath133 with @xmath134 and@xmath135 . note that these equations are valid for an arbitrary initial state . the noise induces an exponential decay of the average signal and its higher moments . however , unlike the average signal the higher moments are also affected by the presence of diffusion terms . if we assume an initially coherent state with @xmath136 and @xmath137 given by eqs . ( [ jz ] ) and ( [ jz2 ] ) , one can calculate from eqs . ( [ dec1 ] ) and ( [ dec2])the sensitivity in the presence of decoherence . in contrast to the ideal dynamics where the longer the interrogation time @xmath25 the better is the phase accuracy , when decoherence is accounted for , one has to optimize with respect to both @xmath25 and @xmath104 , in order to obtain the best sensitivity . provided that @xmath138 , standard minimization yields : @xmath139 at @xmath140{\frac{2}{n^3 } ( e^{\tau_{opt}}-1)}$ ] and @xmath141 . note that even with initially uncorrelated atoms decoherence reduces the sensitivity by a factor of @xmath142 . this has to be contrasted with standard ramsey spectroscopy done with non - interacting atoms , where the phase resolution with initially uncorrelated atoms has the same classical shot noise resolution so is not too much affected by decoherence . the reason of the different behavior is the fact that @xmath143 builds up particle correlations during the evolution and transforms uncorrelated states into highly squeezed ones which are vulnerable to decoherence . more specifically , as shown in ref . @xcite , @xmath143 ideally transforms initially coherent states into maximally correlated @xmath0-particle ghz states @xcite after a period of evolution of @xmath144 . these states are very fragile and decohere @xmath0 times faster than uncorrelated particles . let us now consider the case when the initial state is @xmath145 . using eqs . ( [ jzs ] ) and ( [ jz2s ] ) in eqs . ( [ dec1 ] ) and ( [ dec2 ] ) , one gets an optimal sensitivity , provided @xmath146 , given by : @xmath147 at @xmath148 , and @xmath149 . ( [ signdecma ] ) is very interesting as it demonstrates that by using many - body interactions , entangled states can outperform the signal to noise limit of classically unentangled states even in the presence of decoherence . the sensitivity of the squeezed states is a factor @xmath150 larger than the maximal achievable with uncorrelated atoms , see eq.([soptd ] ) . in fig . 3 we plot the optimal sensitivity in the presence of decoherence both by measuring @xmath102 and @xmath109 . for practical reasons , as the ones discussed above , measuring @xmath109 instead of @xmath102 might be experimentally convenient also with decoherence . moreover , note that while states with @xmath151 provide the best accuracy in the ideal dynamics , states with @xmath152 are optimal with decoherence . @xmath153 describes the spin dynamics of a @xmath154 bose einstein condensate , if one associates the internal @xmath155 hyperfine states of the atoms as the two states of an effective spin-1/2 particle ( the @xmath156 state can be decoupled by introducing a detuning much larger than the chemical potential ) @xcite . in this system the coupling strength @xmath21 is proportional to @xmath157 with @xmath158 the s wave scattering length between particles of type @xmath159 and @xmath160 , @xmath161 the atom mass and @xmath162 the volume . due to the dependence of @xmath101 on the elastic scattering length difference , @xmath163 , using an inter - state feshbach resonance @xcite , such as the one predicted between the @xmath164 and @xmath154 states in @xmath165 atoms , one could widely tune @xmath101 by varying an external magnetic field . close to the feshbach resonance there is a singularity in the scattering length , @xmath166 with @xmath167 being the resonance width , @xmath168 the zero energy resonance and @xmath169 the background scattering length . this singularity is due to the near degeneracy of the collision energy of the atoms with the binding energy of an extremely loose diatomic molecular state . one can use our spectroscopy technique to measure @xmath170 in such system . however , in order for the method to work , it is important to reduce two and three body particle losses across the resonance , as they can considerably affect the sensitivity . we estimate for example the effect of two - body losses by solving the following master equation : @xmath171-\gamma /2(\hat{c}^\dagger \hat{c } \hat{\rho}+ \hat{\rho } \hat{c}^\dagger \hat{c}- 2\hat{c}^\dagger \hat{\rho } \hat{c } ) , \ ] ] with @xmath172 the operator that destroys a pair atoms in different spin states and which account for inelastic spin relaxation processes across the resonance . here the constant @xmath173 is related to the two body loss rate density , @xmath174 , which satisfies the relation @xmath175 @xmath176 depends on the imaginary part of @xmath177 as @xmath178 and @xmath179 varies with the applied magnetic field , the difference in magnetic moment between the feshbach resonance state and a pair of atoms in the entrance channel , @xmath180 and the inverse molecular lifetime , @xmath181 , as @xcite : @xmath182 ^ 2}.\ ] ] in fig.5 we summarize our numerical solutions by plotting the scaling exponent @xmath183 of the optimal sensitivity with the initial number of atoms , @xmath184 = - b \log[n(t=0 ) ] + { \rm const}$ ] , versus @xmath185 for both initially uncorrelated atoms and initially squeezed atoms . the plot demonstrates the drastic reduction of the sensitivity with @xmath173 . for both initially uncorrelated atoms and initially squeezed atoms one requires to limit @xmath186 to have at least shot noise resolution , i.e @xmath187 . experimentally both two and three body particle losses contribute . as three body losses scale as the four power of the scattering length @xcite they decrease faster than two - body losses away from the resonance . as such , the sensitivity of the method can be optimized by , on one hand , tuning the magnetic field far enough from the resonance so that mainly two - body losses are relevant and , on the other , by reducing @xmath176 by using a very narrow feshbach resonance , and by considering species of atoms that belong to the lowest magnetic manifold so they posses long relaxation times . recently the dynamics of bosonic atoms with two relevant internal states loaded in a deep optical lattice has been used to perform precision measurements of atomic scattering properties @xcite . explicitly , the experiment detected the modification in the ramsey fringes caused by frequency shifts induced by interatomic interactions in wells occupied with two atoms , and used it to measure the elastic scattering length difference . as the various wells in the optical lattice behave as independent wells due to the suppressed tunneling between them , the experimental phase sensitivity was limited to the shot noise resolution associated to statistical fluctuations in a finite number of wells . in practice however , the sensitivity was much lower due to the two - body losses close to the feshbach resonance in the double occupied wells . we now discuss how to generalize these ideas by using the collective spin dynamics ( instead of the single well one ) of fermionic atoms in an optical lattice loaded with one atom per site . specifically we demonstrate how to engineer an effective @xmath188 hamiltonian in such systems . the latter can be used to perform measurements of the scattering properties via the entanglement dynamics but without the limitation of particle losses at the resonance . the effective dynamics of a system of spinor ultra - cold atoms confined in a unit filled lattice , deep in the mott insulator regime @xcite can be described in terms of effective spin operators , @xmath189 , @xmath190 , where @xmath191 are the annihilation operator of a particle of type @xmath192 at site @xmath193 , and @xmath194 are number operators . in such spin variables the effective hamiltonian maps to a spin xxz hamiltonian @xcite : @xmath195 here @xmath196 means that the sum is over nearest neighbors , @xmath197 are spin - dependent tunneling energies and @xmath198 are on - site interaction energies proportional to the s - wave scattering lengths between the various components . for fermions @xmath199 due to the pauli exclusion principle . the heisenberg , @xmath200 , and ising @xmath201 , coupling constants are given by @xmath202 where the upper and lower signs are for fermionic and bosonic atoms respectively . using spin dependent optical potentials one can tune the various coupling constants and in particular one can engineer the condition @xmath203 . in this limit , we may treat the effect of the ising term , @xmath201 , by means of perturbation theory . assuming that at @xmath89 the initial state is prepared within the @xmath55 manifold , @xmath56 , a perturbative analysis predicts that for times @xmath25 such that @xmath204 , @xmath205 confines the dynamics to @xmath56 and transitions outside it can be neglected . as a consequence , only the projection of @xmath206 on it , which corresponds to @xmath207 is effective and @xmath208 acts as a long range hamiltonian @xcite . in eq . ( [ impl ] ) @xmath60 is the number of nearest neighbors . with this effective hamiltonian the spectroscopic method described above can be applied in lattice systems to measure interactions . moreover , due to the fact that the large heisenberg term restricts the dynamics to the @xmath56 manifold , @xmath200 acts as an effective @xmath209 . therefore , by adding a @xmath210 term via a raman transition with effective two - photon rabi frequency @xmath211 @xcite one can also implement in such lattice systems eq . ( [ hadiabatic ] ) . this hamiltonian allows , as described above , for the squeezed state preparation . the realization of @xmath212 in unit filled optical lattices has the strong advantage that two and three body losses are suppressed and thus they are not longer a limitation in these systems . it is important to note , however , that only fermionic atoms can be used if @xmath101 is going to be tuned by means of a feshbach resonance . the reason is that for bosons , as @xmath213 grows , @xmath101 also grows and at some point the condition @xmath203 is violated . on the other hand , for fermions , as @xmath213 grows , the ratio @xmath214 remains constant . the drawback of the lattice implementation is the factor of @xmath0 in the denominator of the effective @xmath101 , because the slower dynamics limits the sensitivity of our method . typical experiments that use lattices deep enough for the effective spin model to be valid , work in a parameter regime where @xmath215 . using spin dependent optical lattices @xcite one can control the tunneling rates and set @xmath216 . additionally close to the resonance @xmath217 can be enhanced up to about @xmath218 times its off resonance value @xcite . therefore the revival time in these set - ups varies with the magnetic field between @xmath219 ( @xmath218 ms - @xmath220ms ) . thus , in order to keep the measurement time in a reasonable experimental time scale , one should limit the experiment to 1d lattice systems which have of the order of @xmath221 atoms per tube @xcite . the scalability problem certainly limits the achievable sensitivity . nevertheless , even with these reduced number of atoms , if initially squeezed atoms are used , the phase accuracy @xmath222 is within the @xmath223 sensitivity required to test the proton - electron mass ratio variation on the level of @xmath224 , in a narrow feshbach resonance ( @xmath225 mg)@xcite . in summary , here we proposed an inteferometric method that relays on the quantum dynamics of interacting spins to perform precision measurements of the scattering properties with a resolution fundamentally limited to @xmath2 . we discussed the class of squeezed states that are required to achieve heisenberg sensitivity and proposed a method for its generation . we studied the effect of decoherence and showed that it affects the achievable sensitivity even with initially uncorrelated atoms as they become vulnerable due the many - particle entanglement builded during the many - body dynamics . we also showed that the dynamically induced quantum correlations help to keep the sensitivity of initially squeezed states above the uncorrelated atom threshold even with decoherence . this has to be contrasted with standard ramsey spectroscopy with non - interacting atoms where all the potential gain in sensitivity due to initial quantum correlation is lost in the presence of decoherence . finally we discussed possible physical implementation of the proposed spectroscopy using spinor condensates and fermions in unit filled optical lattices . we showed that particle losses close to the feshbach resonance limits the sensitivity in the bec implementation , and thus the use of very narrow feshbach resonances and atomic species with a large spin relaxation time are required to optimize the sensitivity of the method . our implementation of the scheme in optical lattice set - ups is insensitive to atomic losses but on the other is limited by the slow dynamics . regardless of such problems , the proposed spectroscopy is a new scheme that takes advantages of many - particle entanglement to perform high precision measurements of the interaction parameters in spin mixtures . we are optimistic that emerging technology in optical and magnetic feshbach resonances might overcome the current experimental limitations in such systems or that new developments in the field might provide alternative set - ups for the experimental application of the presented method and make of it an useful spectroscopic technique . this work was supported by itamp , nsf ( career program ) , afosr and the david and lucille packard foundation .

we propose a method to perform precision measurements of the interaction parameters in systems of @xmath0 ultra - cold spin @xmath1 atoms . the spectroscopy is realized by first creating a coherent spin superposition of the two relevant internal states of each atom and then letting the atoms evolve under a squeezing hamiltonian . the non - linear nature of the hamiltonian decreases the fundamental limit imposed by the heisenberg uncertainty principle to @xmath2 , a factor of @xmath0 smaller than the fundamental limit achievable with non - interacting atoms . we study the effect of decoherence and show that even with decoherence , entangled states can outperform the signal to noise limit of non - entangled states . we present two possible experimental implementations of the method using bose - einstein spinor condensates and fermionic atoms loaded in optical lattices and discuss their advantages and disadvantages .

astro-ph0608397

rr lyrae , as well as classical cepheids , are considered standard candles for estimating stellar distances in the milky way and to local group galaxies . they are produced in old stellar populations , and hence they provide important information for an understanding of the age , structure and formation of their parent stellar systems . as typical population ii stars , rr lyrae are abundant in globular clusters and have been the subject of a huge number of studies for more than a century . although the pulsation theory explains quite well the connection between most of the involved physical quantities ( van albada & baker 1971 ; caputo , marconi & santolamazza 1998 ) , the dependence of intrinsic luminosity on metal content has been the subject of debate for nearly three decades ( see smith 1995 for a review ) . only recently the slope of the luminosity - metallicity relation m@xmath2-[fe / h ] seems to be converging towards a value @xmath30.20 - 0.23 that appears to be `` universal '' as supported by the most accurate studies of field rr lyrae stars in the milky way ( fernley et al . 1998 ; chaboyer 1999 ) and in the large magellanic cloud ( lmc , gratton et al . 2004 ) , and globular clusters in m31 ( rich et al . 2005 ) . near infrared observations of variable stars present several advantages over optical investigations : a smaller dependence on interstellar extinction and metallicity , a smaller pulsational amplitude and more symmetrical light curves , and hence good mean magnitudes . in the last 20 years the calibration of the rr lyrae period - ir luminosity relation ( pl@xmath0 ) has been the subject of several empirical and theoretical investigations ( see sect . [ method ] ) , but there still remains some degree of uncertainty on the dependence of @xmath4 on period and metallicity . to solve the problem of the dependence of @xmath4(rr ) on these physical quantities , a large sample of rr lyrae stars is needed , spanning a wide range of [ fe / h ] , for which accurate k and [ fe / h ] measurements are available . in this paper we present an accurate analysis of the infrared photometric properties of 538 rr lyrae variables ( 376 rrab and 162 rrc ) in 16 globular clusters ( gc ) with @xmath5<-0.9 $ ] . this more than doubles the number of stars used in the previous largest study of this type ( nemec , linnell nemec & lutz 1994 ) . by means of such a large database we calibrated the pl@xmath0 relation constraining its dependence on period and metallicity on a strictly observational basis . in 2 we describe the sample of rr lyrae stars and the used photometric ir datasets . 3 is devoted to the description of the adopted method to calibrate the pl@xmath0 relation . in 4 we use the derived pl@xmath0 relation to estimate the distance to the calibrator gcs and to a sample of field rr lyrae stars in the lmc , and compare the results with the previous determinations in literature . finally , we summarize our results in 5 . the data used in the present analysis consist of k photometry for the central regions of 9 gcs ( m4 , m5 , m15 , m55 , m68 , m92 , m107 and @xmath6 cen ) derived from a set of images secured at the telescopio nazionale galileo ( tng , canary islands ) , using the near - ir cameras arnica , and at the european southern observatory ( eso , la silla ) , using the near - ir camera irac-2 and sofi . a detailed description of the data reduction and calibration procedure can be found in ferraro et al . ( 2000 ) , valenti et al . ( 2004 ) , valenti , ferraro & origlia ( 2004 ) and sollima et al . all measured instrumental magnitudes were transformed into the two - micron all - sky survey ( 2mass ) photometric system . to extend our analysis to the outer regions of these clusters , we correlated our catalogs with the database obtained by 2mass that extends to a wide area up to 15 from the cluster centers . the 2mass k photometry for 5 additional gcs ( m22 , ngc 3201 , ngc 5897 , ngc 6362 and ngc 6584 ) was also considered . for each cluster we identified a large number of variable stars by cross - correlating the ir catalog with the most comprehensive catalog of gc variable stars available in literature ( clement et al . . since the adopted k magnitudes are the average of repeated exposures and the k light curves of rr lyrae variables have a fairly sinusoidal low amplitude shape , we assumed our k magnitudes as the mean magnitudes of the identified variables . note that the individual k values from different datasets generally agree within less than 0.1 mag . so , we assumed @xmath70.1 mag as a plausible error to attach to the mean k magnitudes used in the following analysis . in addition , we considered the k photometry of rr lyrae stars taken by longmore et al . ( 1990 , for variables in the clusters m3 , m4 , m5 , m15 , m107 and ngc 3201 ) , storm et al . ( 2004 , ic4499 ) , butler ( 2003 , m3 ) , dallora et al . ( 2004 , reticulum ) and del principe et al . ( 2005 , m92 ) . all magnitudes were reported to the homogeneous photometric system of 2mass using the transformation equations provided by carpenter ( 2001 ) . table 1 lists for each calibrator gc the metallicity ( in the carretta & gratton 1997 scale ) and the reddening coefficient e(b - v ) from ferraro et al . ( 1999 ) together with the number of rr lyrae considered in the present analysis . [ summ ] .the sample of calibrator gcs . metallicities are in the cg scale . [ cols="<,^,^,^,>",options="header " , ] from an accurate analysis of 538 rr lyrae variables in 16 gcs using infrared ( k - band ) photometry we derive a pl@xmath0 relation based on purely observational constraints . the derived dependences of the k magnitude on period and metallicity are in good agreement with those estimated by previous empirical studies . we confirm that the metallicity coefficient is about 2 - 3 times smaller than that predicted by theoretical models , as it was found in all previous empirical analyses . the zero point of the calibration has been tied to the trigonometric parallax of rr lyr measured with hst by benedict et al . this calibration has been used to derive the distances to the 16 calibrator gcs considered in this analysis . as a further check , this relation has been applied to rr lyrae stars in a few central fields in the lmc yielding a distance modulus @xmath8 , in good agreement with the most recent determinations based on cepheid variables ( persson et al . , 2004 ; gieren et al . , 2005 ) . this research was supported by the ministero dellistruzione , universit e ricerca . we warmly thank paolo montegriffo for assistance during catalogs cross - correlation . we also thank santino cassisi and the anonymous referee for their helpful comments and suggestions . benedict g. f. et al . , 2002 , apj , 581 , 115 bono g. , caputo f. , castellani v. , marconi m. , 2001 , mnras , 326 , 1183 bono g. , caputo f. , castellani v. , marconi m. , storm j. , deglinnocenti s. , 2003 , mnras , 344 , 1097 borissova j. , minniti d. , rejkuba m. , alves d. , cook k. h. , freeman k. c. , 2004 , a&a , 423 , 97 butler d. j. , 2003 , a&a , 405 , 981 caputo f. , marconi m. , santolamazza p. , 1998 , mnras , 293 , 364 carney b. w. , storm j. , jones r. v , 1992 , apj , 386 , 663 carpenter j. m. , 2001 , aj , 121 , 2851 carretta e. , gratton r. g. , 1997 , a&as , 121 , 95 carretta e. , gratton r. g. , clementini g. , fusi pecci f. , 2000 , apj , 533 , 215 catelan m. , pritzl b. j. , smith h. , a. , 2004 , apj suppl . ser . , 154 , 633 chaboyer b. , 1999 in `` post - hipparcos cosmic candles '' , kluwer ac . , a. heck , f. caputo eds . , 237 , 111 clement c. et al . , 2001 , aj , 122 , 2587 clementini g. , carretta e. , gratton r. , merighi r. , mould j. r. , mccarthy j. k. , 1995 , aj , 110 , 2319 clementini g. , gratton r. , bragaglia a. , carretta e. , di fabrizio l. , maio m. , 2003 , aj , 125 , 1309 dallora m. et al . , 2004 , apj , 610 , 269 del principe m. , piersimoni a. m. , bono g. , di paola a. , dolci m. , marconi m. , 2005 , aj , 109 , 2714 detre l. , szeidl b. , 1973 , ibvs , 764 fernley j. , skillen i. , burki g. , 1993 , a&as , 97 , 815 fernley j. , skillen i. , carney b. w. , cacciari c. , janes k. , 1998 , mnras , 293 , 61 ferraro f. r. , messineo m. , fusi pecci f. , de palo m. a. , straniero o. , chieffi a. , limongi m. , 1999 aj , 118 , 1738 ferraro f. r. , montegriffo p. , origlia l. , fusi pecci f. , 2000 , aj , 119 , 1282 frolov m. s. , samus n. n. , 1998 , astl , 24 , 171 gieren w. , storm j. b. , thomas g. iii , fouqu p. , pietrzyski g. , kienzle f. , 2005 , apj , 627 , 224 gratton r. g. , bragaglia a. , clementini g. , carretta e. , di fabrizio l. , maio m. , taribello e. , 2004 , a&a , 421 , 937 gratton r. g. , bragaglia a. , carretta e. , clementini g. , desidera s. , grundahl f. , lucatello s. , 2003 , a&a , 408 , 529 jones r. v. , carney b. w. , latham d. w. , 1988 , apj , 332 , 206 jones r. v. , carney b. w. , storm j. , latham d. w. , 1992 , apj , 386 , 646 jones r. v. , carney b. w. , fulbright j. p. , 1996 , pasp , 108 , 877 kazarovets e. v. , samus n. n. , durlevich o. v. , 2001 , inf . bull . variable stars , 5135 , 1 liu t. , janes k. a. , 1990 , apj , 354 , 273 longmore a. j. , dixon r. , skillen i. , jameson r. f. , fernley j. a. , 1990 , mnras , 247 , 684 nemec j. m. , linnell nemec a. f. , lutz t. e. , 1994 , aj , 108 , 222 persson s. e. , madore b. f. , krzemiski w. , freedman w. l. , roth m. , murphy d. c. , 2004 , aj , 128 , 2239 rey s. c. , lee y. w. , joo j. m. , walker a. , baird s. , 2000 , aj , 119 , 1824 rich r. m. , corsi c. e. , cacciari c. , federici l. , fusi pecci f. , djorgovski s. g. , freedman w. l. , 2005 , aj , 129 , 2670 savage b. d. , mathis j. s. , 1979 , ara&a 17 , 73 skillen i. , fernley j. a. , stobie r. s. , jameson r. f. , 1993 , mnras , 265 , 301 skrutskie m. f. et al . , aj , 131 , 1163 smith h. a. , 1990 in `` rr lyrae stars '' , cambridge university press sollima a. , ferraro f. r. , origlia l. , pancino e. , bellazzini m. , 2004 , a&a , 420 , 173 storm j. , 2004 , a&a , 415 , 987 valenti e. , ferraro f. r. , perina s. , origlia l. , 2004 , a&a , 419 , 139 valenti e. , ferraro f. r. , origlia l. , 2004 , mnras , 351 , 1204 van albada t. s. , baker n. , 1971 , apj , 169 , 311 zinn r. , west m. j. , 1984 , apjs , 55 , 45

the period - metallicity - k band luminosity ( pl@xmath0 ) relation for rr lyrae stars in 15 galactic globular clusters and in the lmc globular cluster reticulum has been derived . it is based on accurate near infrared ( k ) photometry combined with 2mass and other literature data . the pl@xmath0 relation has been calibrated and compared with the previous empirical and theoretical determinations in literature . the zero point of the absolute calibration has been obtained from the k magnitude of rr lyr whose distance modulus has been measured via trigonometric parallax with hst . using this relation we obtain a distance modulus to the lmc of @xmath1 mag , in good agreement with recent determinations based on the analysis of cepheid variable stars . [ firstpage ] methods : observational techniques : photometric stars : distances stars : variables : rr lyrae infrared : stars

0712.2054

in this paper , we propose a simple distributed scheduling algorithm that provides weighted fairness in ieee 802.11 @xcite wireless networks , despite the unpredictability of the 802.11 mac layer and physical channels . in 802.11 wireless networks , mac - layer contention , dynamics and bandwidth allocation are hard to predict . for such networks , the fixed - point model in @xcite gives a method for computing the long - term throughput of the binary exponential backoff ( beb ) algorithm @xcite . however , the short - term dynamics and unfairness are quite unpredictable . in a certain period , a station may randomly backoff more than others , and therefore have a smaller chance of winning the channel , which in turn makes that station backoff even more . meanwhile , the beb amplifies the unfairness caused by the impairments of the wireless channels . this aggravation is an unintentional side effect of beb that was designed to reduce collisions , not to guarantee fairness . the following two effects cause the unfairness : * _ capture : _ capture occurs when the signals from different transmitters have very different strengths at a receiver @xcite . for instance , a ratio of 2 in distances from the stations to the ap can lead to approximately a ratio of 16 in received signal strengths . when more than one station transmit packets to the ap at the same time , the ap may be able to capture and correctly decode the packet from the closer station , while ignoring the other packets . this effect increases the aggregate throughput since the ap receives one packet even when multiple transmissions overlap in time . however , capture may result in unfairness since the stations that are further away backoff more with the beb algorithm , and consequently obtain much less throughput than closer stations @xcite . * _ channel errors : _ in addition to packet collisions , channel errors are another important cause of packet loss . a more lossy channel to the ap drops more packets because of channel errors . the transmitting station interprets all packet losses as collisions and doubles its contention window . accordingly , the beb algorithm magnifies the asymmetry of the lossy channels . to alleviate this problem , reference @xcite describes a way to differentiate the two kinds of packet losses ( due to collisions or channel errors ) . the algorithm proposed in this paper provides a simpler solution . with a more complicated mac , ieee 802.11e @xcite provides differentiated service ( diffserv ) , by adopting different minimum contention windows ( @xmath0 ) and inter - frame spaces ( ifs ) for different service classes such as voice , video and data . this protocol provides relative performance differentiation among different classes : the classes with smaller @xmath0 and ifs have a relative priority over others . to evaluate the performance of 802.11e , reference @xcite provides a simulation study ; while reference @xcite uses an analytical model ( a markov chain ) to find the saturated throughput of 802.11e . however , the model there is quite complicated , indicating that the `` amount '' of relative priority is hard to quantify and control . for instance , it is not clear how much more bandwidth the protocol gives to video with a particular setting of @xmath0 and ifs , nor how to adjust the amount of priority by varying these parameters . in this paper , we describe a simple , easy to implement , distributed fair scheduling algorithm that we call vls , for``variable - length scheduling , '' to cope with the above problems . vls provides exact weighted fairness despite the unpredictability of the 802.11 mac layer and physical channels . in this section , we assume that there is only one collision domain . that is , each station can sense the transmissions of other stations . ( we consider the case of multiple collision domains in section [ sec : vls - in - multiple - cd ] . ) there are two versions of the scheduling algorithm : without and with an access point ( ap ) . the latter is an adaptation of the former that utilizes the ap to simplify the algorithm . the algorithm is based on the concept of `` virtual slot . '' by definition , a station sees a virtual slot when it senses a collision , a burst of transmissions ( i.e. , one data - ack exchange , or a series of data - ack exchanges separated by sifs ) , or when it transmits a burst of packets itself . mini - slots are not counted as virtual slots . in other words , a station counts a virtual slot whenever if senses the channel as `` idle '' for an interval equal to difs ( difs@xmath1sifs @xcite ) and is involved in a contention process ( i.e. , when the station s backoff counter goes down until it transmits a packet or senses other transmissions ) . in fig . [ fig : virtual - slots ] , for example , there are 3 virtual slots . `` virtual slots '' are similar to `` busy slots '' except that a burst of transmissions is counted as one `` virtual slot . '' virtual slots . ( there are 3 virtual slots in this figure.),width=316 ] the notion of `` virtual slot '' is particularly useful because every station in a single collision domain sees the same number of virtual slots , assuming that the stations are always backlogged . ( if not , the station starts the algorithm only when it has a backlog and stops it when its backlog is cleared . ) therefore , virtual slots can serve as a `` clock '' for scheduling . we design the distributed algorithm as follows . * each station @xmath2 is assigned a `` weight '' @xmath3 @xcite . ( if there are multiple flows outgoing from station @xmath2 , then let @xmath3 be the sum of the weights of all individual flows . ) and each station @xmath2 keeps track of a value @xmath4 that is initially equal to 1 . * if station @xmath2 gets an ack after it transmits a packet , it keeps transmitting a burst of @xmath5 packets separated by sifs and then resets @xmath4 to the value 1 . * if it does not get an ack after it transmits a packet , or if it does not get to transmit ( i.e. , it does not win a contention ) , station @xmath2 increments @xmath4 by one whenever it sees a virtual slot . for example , fig . [ fig : vls_2sta ] shows the process with 2 stations with weights @xmath6 and @xmath7 respectively . in the figure , each block represents a virtual slot ( aligned across different stations ) . the number in each block indicates the transmission length in that virtual slot . ( note that the size of a block here does not reflect the actual length of the virtual slot . ) assume station 1 starts transmission with the 1st virtual slot , while station 2 starts transmission with the 2nd . variable - length scheduling . ( @xmath6 , @xmath7 are the weights . each block represents a variable - length virtual slot . the number in a block indicates the transmission length.),width=316 ] in a time period when station @xmath2 is backlogged , we can see that the total number of packets it has transmitted is equal to the number of virtual slots it has seen so far times the weight @xmath8 . ( so station @xmath2 _ virtually _ transmits @xmath8 packets per slot . this is why we use the name `` virtual slot '' . ) since all stations see the same virtual slots , the bandwidth allocation is weighted fair . that is @xmath9 is the same for all the stations where @xmath10 is the average rate of packets that station @xmath2 transmits . note that vls guarantees the weighted fairness , no matter what happens in the mac and physical layers . thus , vls automatically adjusts for the randomness of the mac protocol and the asymmetry of the physical channels . in a wireless lan with an ap , the above algorithm can be adapted so that the client stations need not count the virtual slots . in this variation , the ap counts the virtual slots for the stations and piggybacks that count in the mac - layer acks to the stations . the algorithm works as follows . * the ap keeps counting the virtual slots . it increments the count ( @xmath11 ) for each virtual slot . * a station can start and stop the algorithm at any time . when station @xmath2 starts , it contends for the channel and sends the first @xmath8 packets to the ap . in one ack , the ap piggybacks the current value of @xmath12 , denoted as @xmath13 . the next time station @xmath2 wins the channel , it sends @xmath8 packets first . the ap , again , piggybacks the current value of @xmath12 , denoted as @xmath14 . then , the station sends @xmath15 more packets in the burst . since @xmath16 , station @xmath2 sends at least @xmath8 packets per burst . suppose that , at each virtual slot , every station @xmath17 has a probability @xmath18 of winning the channel . then on average , station @xmath17 accumulates @xmath19 units of `` credit '' before it wins the channel ( since the average number of virtual slots it waits for is @xmath20 ) . it can then spent the credits by transmitting ( on average ) @xmath19 packets . when the number of active stations @xmath21 increases in a wireless networks , @xmath18 decreases ( approximately @xmath22 ) . as a result , the average burst length increases , thus causing more delays for all the stations . to avoid this effect , we define a system - wide parameter @xmath23 , called `` _ speed of the clock _ '' , and we modify the protocol as follows : * instead of transmitting @xmath24 packets in a burst as in subsection [ sub : distributed - algorithm ] , station @xmath2 transmits @xmath25 packets . if @xmath25 is not an integer , then it transmits @xmath26 packets , and saves the extra credits @xmath27 for the next time . essentially , @xmath28 controls the speed of clock in the whole network . ( therefore , the delay is proportional to @xmath28 . ) * the stations can adjust the value of parameter @xmath28 in several different ways : * * if station @xmath2 knows the number of backlogged stations @xmath21 , then it can choose @xmath29 and broadcast @xmath30 to the network . the other stations will then follow the parameter . * * common tcp flows are usually not sensitive to the burst length and delay . but if a station ( say , station @xmath2 ) has delay - sensitive flows and some other stations burst lengths are causing too much delay to it , it computes a new value of @xmath30 and broadcasts it to the network . ( assume the current average delay for station @xmath2 is @xmath31 , and its targeted delay is @xmath32 , then set @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the current parameter of the system . ) * * if the network has an ap , the ap can act as a controller to adjust @xmath28 . * * if there are more than one stations broadcasting @xmath30 , each station follow the lowest @xmath30 it has received ( i.e. , @xmath35 ) . * further details about the implementation of broadcasting : * * station @xmath2 embeds @xmath30 in a packet ( or piggybacked in a usual data packet ) , along with its id / address . * * to increase reliability , this packet can be repeated multiple times . also , although stations in a single collision domain may `` carrier - sense '' each other , they may not be able to `` decode '' the packets of each other . therefore , the packets containing @xmath30 are transmitted with a higher power , or a lower data rate , than usual packets . * * if a station has broadcast a @xmath30 before and wants to update it , it simply broadcasts the new @xmath30 . since other stations know the i d of the sender , they update the old parameter of the same sender , and follow the lowest @xmath30 in their records . in addition , we can impose a limit on the burst length , @xmath36 , of each station @xmath2 . in this case , station @xmath2 can transmit up to @xmath37 packets in a burst ( and the remaining credit is left for future transmissions ) . this mechanism smooths out the randomness of the burst lengths , which may otherwise be ( randomly ) long or short , even if the network has a proper value of @xmath28 . but in this situation , @xmath28 needs to be small enough to avoid the instability of credits ( i.e. , the remaining credits should not go to infinity ) . in particular , a simple inequality needs to be satisfied . we discuss this issue in section [ sec : stability ] . as mentioned before , virtual slots act as a clock for scheduling . using this synchronization mechanism , vls has the flexibility to achieve many forms of fairness . the scheduler above uses the number of packets as a fairness metric . vls can also provide weighted fairness in terms of the number of bits or the `` air - time '' occupied by different stations . if different stations use very different data rates ( e.g. , 1mbps vs. 11mbps ) in a shared - medium wireless network , providing fairness in terms of bits leads to very low efficiency ( throughput ) of the whole network @xcite . in this case , @xcite shows that allocating equal air - time to different stations strikes a good balance between fairness and efficiency , and is actually equivalent to achieving proportional fairness @xcite . in a wireless lan , or an ad - hoc network with a single collision domain , the long - term saturated throughput should the same for all stations , by symmetry @xcite . however , the collisions and the dynamics of contention windows ( with beb ) are quite unpredictable , leading to fluctuations of short - term throughput ( fig . [ fig : short - term](a ) ) . also , the volumes of data that different stations send drift away from each other ( fig . [ fig : short - term](a ) ) . this means that , although the average throughput of the different stations are equal in the long term , the average throughputs may differ over a considerable time window ( 20 sec in the figure ) . with vls , short - term and long - term fairness have been clearly improved ( fig . [ fig : short - term](b ) ) . without vls , weighted fairness may be implemented by using different @xmath0 s . approximately , the throughput of an individual station is inversely proportional to its minimum cw , assuming that each station has the same average packet size and use the same ifs ( fig . [ fig : weighted - fairness](a ) ) . however , the approximation is not accurate ( especially when @xmath0 s are small ) , and one can expect it to be vulnerable to physical layer factors such as capture effect and channel errors . with vls , the weighted fairness is exact , and easy to adjust and control ( fig . [ fig : weighted - fairness](b ) ) . besides improving short - term fairness and providing weighted fairness , our algorithm can readily solve many other unfairness problems in wireless networks . in a wlan , different stations may have very different distances from the ap . also , the channel qualities between stations and the ap may differ greatly even if the distances are similar , for instance because of multipath or obstructions . the above effects result in different signal strengths from different stations as received by the ap . when more than one stations transmit packets to the ap at the same time , so that these transmissions collide , the ap may still be able to capture and correctly decode the packet with the strongest signal , and send back an ack . this feature is helpful in terms of the aggregate throughput since one packet is received even in the event of a collision , but may exacerbate the unfairness . the weaker stations tend to backoff more with the beb algorithm , and therefore obtain much less throughput than stronger ones ( see fig . [ fig : capture](a ) ) . if our vls algorithm is enabled , it can overcome the unfairness problem , as well as _ retaining the throughput benefit _ provided by capture . since both strong and weak stations share the same view of the virtual slots , they share the bandwidth in a fair way ( see fig . [ fig : capture](b ) ) . in wireless networks , in addition to packet collisions , channel errors are another important cause of packet losses . if a station has a lossy channel to the ap , its packets are dropped with higher probability because of channel errors . similarly to the capture effect , these losses also result in an asymmetry among different stations , and therefore in unfairness , aggravated by the beb algorithm . this effect is shown in fig . [ fig : channel error](a ) where only station 1 suffers from a loss probability @xmath38 caused by channel errors . a simple model of a time - varying wireless channel is a markov chain with two states : `` good '' and `` bad '' . for simplicity , we assume that in the `` good '' state all packets can be received and that in the `` bad '' state all packets are dropped . each state has an exponentially - distributed duration before it transits to the other state . [ fig : markov - channel - model ] shows the state transition diagram . in the scenario simulated , only station 1 has such a noisy channel , with @xmath39 , @xmath40 ( therefore the average loss probability is @xmath38 ) ; and other stations have perfect channels ( @xmath41 ) . it turns out that our algorithm not only maintains fairness , but also utilize the channel `` _ _ opportunistically _ _ '' to get a high throughput : when the weak station wins a contention , but meets the `` bad '' state , it transmits a packet , without receiving the ack , and relinquishes the channel immediately . when it wins a contention and meets the `` good '' state , it can transmit a burst of packets . since the channel is likely to stay in the `` good '' state for some time , the station has the opportunity to compensate for its past losses . if at some point the state goes back to `` bad '' , the station stops immediately and waits for the next opportunity ( see fig . [ fig : channel error](b ) ) . in other words , the weak station transmits more when the channel is good , and less when the channel is bad , thus utilizing the noisy channel more efficiently . as a result , the total throughput in fig . [ fig : channel error](b ) is only slightly less than that in fig . [ fig : channel error](c ) , where the channels are perfect for all stations . markov channel model , width=144 ] it is evident that if the average duration of the `` good '' state is too short , the weak station may still receive unfair throughput . we can derive the condition under which fairness is guaranteed ( see section [ sec : stability ] ) . nevertheless , vls always improves the fairness . when the channel of one station is significantly worse than that of the others , providing throughput - fairness to different stations may drag down the total throughput of the network . ( this is a tradeoff between fairness and efficiency . ) in that case , providing time - fairness would be more suitable . vls has the flexibility to provide time - fairness , as mentioned in subsection [ sub : generalized - fair - scheduling ] . in the above , we have assumed that the stations do not know the state of the channel before transmitting . if the channel state information is known in advance , the station can avoid transmitting in the `` bad '' state . in that case , the throughput performance is further improved . in vls , each active station keeps accumulating and spending credit , where the accumulated credit is proportional to a station s weight , the number of virtual slots it has observed , and the speed of clock @xmath28 . in this section , we consider whether the credits are stable , that is , whether the credits of some stations keep increasing and go to infinity . if that happens , the bandwidth allocation may not be fair , since the extra credits of some stations are not spent . first , if there is no limit on the length of transmission at each burst , the credits must be stable , given that each station has non - zero probability of winning the channel . suppose at each virtual slot , a station @xmath17 has a probability of @xmath18 of winning the channel , then on average , it has accumulated @xmath42 units of credit . it then spent all of them . in fact , the probability that the credits reach @xmath43 ( before it is spent ) is approximately @xmath44 . therefore @xmath45 . but if there is a pre - defined limit of the burst length @xmath46 for station @xmath17 , then instability is possible . in particular , if @xmath47 , the credits of station @xmath17 go to infinity . this can be readily proved by law of large numbers . also , this inequality tells us how to avoid instability : ensuring @xmath48 for implementation , each station monitors its @xmath18 ( average over a period of time ) . if the inequality is violated , it computes a proper value of @xmath28 and broadcasts it to the network . then every station uses the new value of @xmath28 . another simple implementation is to monitor the credits . if the credits of station @xmath17 keep increasing , it knows a smaller @xmath28 is needed to stabilize its credit . the above analysis can be extended to the case of capture effect or channel errors . 1 . capture effect . capture effect will affect the values of the @xmath18 s . the weaker stations have smaller @xmath18 s , which , in turn , may entail adjustment of @xmath28 . 2 . channel errors . here , we define @xmath18 as station @xmath17 s probability of winning the contention and meet the `` good '' state of channel @xmath17 , in a given virtual slot . accordingly , channel errors clearly affect the @xmath18 s . the stations with noisy channels have smaller @xmath18 s ( due to both channel errors and beb ) . also , the time - variation of channel quality imposes another limit on the burst length . denote the length of the `` good '' period of channel @xmath17 as @xmath49 , which is a random variable . then the following inequality is required:@xmath50>w_{i}\cdot c / p_{i},\forall i\label{eq : stability with channel errors}\ ] ] to analyze the values of @xmath18 s , one can adapt bianchi s fixed point model @xcite . in practice , the stations do not need to compute @xmath18 s . they only need to adjust @xmath28 according to their extra credits . if a wireless network has multiple collision domains , a station may not be able to hear all the other stations transmissions . therefore , different stations may have different views of the virtual slots , which makes virtual - slot - based scheduling more difficult . ( two stations have the same view of virtual slots only if they can hear the same set of stations . ) in ieee 802.11 , this may cause severe unfairness problem ( as will be shown later ) . so , in this case , we devise a variable - length scheduling algorithm based on the realized throughputs , instead of the number of virtual slots . the basic idea is similar to @xcite@xcite . ( there , the minimum contention windows , @xmath0 s , are dynamically adjusted . ) say we have a set of @xmath51 stations , with respective weights @xmath52 . the weights can be pre - determined by optimizing some global objective of the network . for example , they can be the solution of the utility optimization problem @xcite@xcite @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the concave `` utility function '' of station @xmath2 , and each set @xmath55 is a `` clique '' ( in a clique , only one station can transmit at a time ) . note that with the constraints , we have assumed that the contention graph is a `` perfect graph '' @xcite ( otherwise , another set of constraints based on `` independent set '' should be used @xcite ) . we have also omitted some details such as packet collisions . this optimization problem can be solved in a distributed manner , similar to wired network @xcite . a `` clique '' here is analogous to a `` link '' in wired network , therefore to solve the problem , some communication among stations in the same clique is needed . in this vls algorithm , each station @xmath2 monitors the aggregate throughput of its neighbors @xmath56 ( i.e , @xmath57 ) , as well as its own throughput @xmath58 . ( this can be done in several ways : ( a ) station @xmath2 can overhear the packets sent by its neighbors , if possible ; ( b ) otherwise , stations can explicitly exchange information about their throughput with their neighbors periodically . ) then , it adjusts the burst length as follows.@xmath59 where @xmath60 denotes the burst length of station @xmath2 at time @xmath61 , and @xmath62 is the step size . clearly , @xmath63 converges when the actual ratio of throughputs is equal to the target ratio of weights . in the following simulation , we compare the throughput allocation with fixed - length scheduling and vls . in vls , we use a discrete version of the above algorithm : each node adjusts its transmission length every 4ms , and the throughput @xmath58 is an average over the last 40ms . in the network simulated , stations 1 , 2 , 3 belong to collision domain 1 , while stations 3 , 4 , 5 belong to collision domain 2 , as shown in fig . [ fig : vls - in - multiple](a ) . note that station 3 faces contentions from both domains . the destinations of the flows from node 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 are assumed to be node 2 , 1 , 2 , 5 , 4 , respectively . the data rate is 11mbps , and the initial transmission length is 1ms for all stations . without vls , station 3 s throughput is very low compared to others ( fig . [ fig : vls - in - multiple](b ) ) . the reason is that at most of the time , station 3 senses the medium as busy , due to the transmissions in both collision domains . therefore it does not have much chance to transmit its packets . then , we use vls , and require the weights of all stations to be 1/3 . as shown in fig . [ fig : vls - in - multiple](c ) , after a short period of time in the beginning ( for convergence ) , the target weights are achieved . on average , station 3 transmission length is 1.54ms , while others are about 0.5ms after convergence . in this paper , we have proposed a distributed algorithm , vls , for fair scheduling in 802.11 wireless networks . we have shown that , by varying the transmission lengths of different stations , it is feasible to provide fairness without careful modeling of mac - layer contention , physical channel variations , and the effect of multiple collision domains . many existing fairness problems in 802.11 networks are therefore overcome , including short - term unfairness , unfairness introduced by physical channel s asymmetry , such as capture effect and channel errors . it makes the throughput of each station more smooth , which is appealing to real - time service such as video and voice . it can easily provide weighted fairness for different services . for networks with multiple collision domains , vls gives a way to avoid the starvation of those stations that are in several collision domains . since vls can avoid excessively long transmissions by tuning the parameter @xmath28 , we should be able to achieve certain objectives on packet delay . however , this problem has not been studied thoroughly in this paper , and is a subject for further study . since vls can be used in 802.11e networks , the advantages of both protocols can be achieved : vls can provide weighted fairness ( a prioritization ) in terms of throughput , while 802.11e can provide prioritization in terms of delay , by using different @xmath0 s and ifs s ( inter - frame spaces ) . therefore , throughputs and delays can be controlled separately by two protocols , instead of being coupled in a complicated way as in 802.11e @xcite . more analytical / experimental study of this issue is interesting for future research . information technology- telecommunications and information exchange between systems- local and metropolitan area networks- specific requirements- part 11 : wireless lan medium access control ( mac ) and physical layer ( phy ) specifications . , pages i513 , 2003 . unapproved draft amendment standard for information technology telecommunications and information exchange between systems lan / man specific requirements part 11 wireless medium access control ( mac ) and physical layer ( phy ) specifications : medium access control ( mac ) quality of service ( qos ) enhancements ( replaced by approved draft 802.11e / d13.0 ) . , 2005 . b. bensaou , wang yu , and ko chi chung . fair medium access in 802.11 based wireless ad - hoc networks . in _ mobile and ad hoc networking and computing , 2000 . 2000 first annual workshop on _ , pages 99106 , 2000 . rajarshi gupta and jean walrand . . `` advances in control , communication networks , and transportation systems , '' e.h . abed ( ed . ) , systems and control : foundations and applications series , springer - birkhauser , boston . july 2005 . a. kochut , a. vasan , a. u. shankar , and a. agrawala . sniffing out the correct physical layer capture model in 802.11b . in _ network protocols , 2004 . icnp 2004 . proceedings of the 12th ieee international conference on _ , pages 252261 , 2004 . jiang li bin and liew soung chang . proportional fairness in wireless lans and ad hoc networks . in _ wireless communications and networking conference , 2005 ieee _ , volume 3 , pages 15511556 vol . 3 , 2005 . choi sunghyun , j. del prado , n. sai shankar , and s. mangold . `` ieee 802.11 e contention - based channel access ( edcf ) performance evaluation '' . in _ communications , 2003 . ieee international conference on _ , volume 2 , pages 11511156 vol.2 , 2003 .

the fairness of ieee 802.11 wireless networks ( including wireless lan and ad - hoc networks ) is hard to predict and control because of the randomness and complexity of the mac contentions and dynamics . moreover , asymmetric channel conditions such as those caused by capture and channel errors often lead to severe unfairness among stations . in this paper we propose a novel distributed scheduling algorithm that we call vls , for `` _ variable - length scheduling _ '' , that provides weighted fairness to all stations despite the imperfections of the mac layer and physical channels . distinct features of vls include the use of variable transmission lengths based on distributed observations , compatibility with 802.11 s contention window algorithm , opportunistic scheduling to achieve high throughput in time - varying wireless environments , and flexibility and ease of implementation . also , vls makes the throughput of each station more smooth , which is appealing to real - time applications such as video and voice . although the paper mostly assumes 802.11 protocol , the idea generally applies to wireless networks based on csma ( carrier sensing multiple access ) . distributed fair scheduling , variable transmission lengths , carrier sensing multiple access , ieee 802.11 , wireless channel

astro-ph0101021

the identification and study of very cool white dwarf ( wd ) stars is important for understanding the evolution of wds , their luminosity function , their space density , and their total formation rate . this study is particularly important for wds in the galactic halo , because they are sufficiently old that most are expected to have cooled to very low temperatures @xcite . until recently , the coolest wds known had temperatures @xmath04000 k ( bergeron et al . 1997 ; leggett et al . the discovery @xcite of two wds that definitely have temperatures below 4000 k has shown that such cool wds do exist and has added impetus for further searches . very cool wds will have molecular hydrogen in their atmospheres if any hydrogen is present . in these high - density atmospheres , collisions can induce a temporary electric dipole moment in the hydrogen molecules . calculations predict ( borosow et al . 1989 ; lenzuini et al . 1991 ; saumon et al . 1994 ; borosow et al . 1997 ) a high opacity at infrared wavelengths , referred to as collision - induced absorption ( cia ) . this opacity produces a spectral energy distribution with greatly depressed red / infrared flux that should result in distinctive colors ( bergeron et al . 1995a ; bergeron et al . 1997 ; hansen & phinney 1998 ; hansen 1998 ; hansen 1999 ; saumon & jacobson 1999 ; chabrier 1999 ) . the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) @xcite should be especially effective at identifying such stars @xcite . this survey is obtaining deep ccd images of 10,000 deg@xmath1 of the north galactic cap in five photometric bands ( @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath5 , and @xmath6 ) to a limiting magnitude @xmath7 see fukugita et al . ( 1996 ) and appendix a of fan et al . ( 2001 ) for details of the photometric system . this paper describes the first such star found by sdss in its commissioning data . this star appears to have stronger cia and , therefore , is probably cooler than the two previously known sub-4000 k wds . in addition , the rediscovery of lhs 3250 , previously the wd with strongest cia , is reported . both ( re)discoveries indicate that sdss can find other similar stars . imaging data from the sdss 2.5 m telescope and its survey camera @xcite now include most of the equatorial stripe with @xmath8 and outside of the galactic plane , as well as a number of scans away from the equator . the two stars reported here are a new white dwarf , sdssp j133739.40 + 000142.8 ( hereafter referred to as sdss 1337 + 00 ; `` p '' indicates that the coordinates are preliminary ) , and lhs 3250 @xcite . they were imaged on 1999 march 21 and 2000 april 04 , respectively . their positions , proper motions , and magnitudes are given in table 1 magnitudes are on the ab system ( lupton et al . 1999 ) , and errors are internal . only preliminary colors and magnitudes are available , until the sdss photometric system has been established ; @xmath9 and @xmath10 are used to designate these preliminary values . final magnitudes and colors are not likely to change by much more than a few hundredths . note , the difference between @xmath11 magnitudes and traditional logarithmic magnitudes is negligible at these magnitudes well above the survey limits . ] . a finding chart for sdss 1337 + 00 is shown in figure 1 . the proper motion is derived from the sdss position and the position in the usno - a2.0 catalog @xcite measured on the palomar observatory sky survey o and e plates taken in 1952 . for comparison , table 1 also includes data taken from the literature @xcite for the cool wd wd0346 + 246 . magnitudes in the sdss system and in the johnson / cousins / cit system are included in table 1 , where some of the values not observed directly have been transformed from the other system using predicted relations for normal stars @xcite . these estimated values are probably accurate to better than 0.1 mag . the @xmath12 magnitude limit for sdss 1337 + 00 was kindly obtained by f. vrba with the usno 1.55 m telescope and aladdin insb array detector . the colors of sdss 1337 + 00 and lhs 3250 are highly unusual , as shown in figure 2 . they are plotted along with a sample of normal wds with synthesized sdss colors @xcite , and with observed j magnitudes @xcite . the two curves show the colors of h and he wd model atmospheres @xcite with log @xmath13 ( kindly calculated and made available to us by pierre bergeron ) . the deviation of the spectral energy distributions of these two stars from normal white dwarfs and non - degenerate stars is dramatic . 1337 + 00 has colors in figure 2(b ) and 2(c ) even more extreme than those for lhs 3250 . spectroscopic `` plates '' ( exposures with fiber configurations covering the 3-degree field of view ) are taken by sdss after imaging data are available objects ( primarily galaxies and qso candidates ) are selected for observation based on their image morphology and colors . qsos with redshift @xmath14 have @xmath15 colors @xcite similar to those predicted for very cool wds . objects with such colors will be selected as high - redshift qso candidates , and those brighter than @xmath16 will be given high priority for spectroscopic observation as qso targets . they also will be selected as cool - wd candidates , but given lower priority for spectra . both sdss 1337 + 00 and lhs 3250 were allocated fibers as qso candidates . the two sdss fiber spectrographs cover 3800 - 9200 at a spectral resolution of 1800 . the exposure time is 45 min under optimum observing conditions , or more as necessary to reach a target s / n . the spectra are extracted and calibrated with an automated software pipeline ( frieman et al . 2001 , in preparation ) . the spectra of sdss 1337 + 00 and lhs 3250 were taken on 2000 may 07 ( plate 0299 , 75 min exposure ) and 2000 may 28 ( plate 0349 , 90 min exposure ) , respectively . they have been smoothed to 6 resolution , and are shown in figure 3 . the spectrum of lhs 3250 has been scaled to match that of sdss 1337 + 00 for ease of comparison ; it agrees quite well with the spectrum previously published @xcite . there are no significant features in the spectrum of either star . the spectra show that sdss 1337 + 00 has relatively less flux at red - infrared wavelengths , consistent with the colors shown in figure 2 . the low flux at red - infrared wavelengths in sdss 1337 + 00 appears similar to that in lhs 3250 but more pronounced . the most viable explanation is that we are seeing cia from molecular hydrogen @xcite . less extreme cia is also seen in wd0346 + 246 @xcite , and possibly in lhs 1126 @xcite and f351 - 50 @xcite . the discovery of cia in these stars represents a striking confirmation of the qualitative trends expected from theoretical model atmospheres @xcite . figure 4 compares the spectrum of sdss 1337 + 00 with models of pure hydrogen atmospheres at three cool temperatures . the discrepancy between the models and the observed spectrum is most likely the result of missing opacities in the theoretical models , as well as the likelihood of the admixture of helium into the hydrogen atmosphere to provide additional h@xmath17-he cia @xcite . improvements to both the atmosphere models and the theoretical opacity inputs are underway . for example , new models with low temperatures and mixed ( helium - dominated ) composition @xcite show the sensitivity of cia and the output spectrum to the input assumptions . however , these new models only explore a few compositions out of many plausible possibilities ; they still do not give improved fits to the spectra in figure 2 . until further improved models are available , we can only deduce broad constraints on the effective temperature . the fact that the h@xmath17 cia is strong suggests the objects are somewhat cooler than 4000 k. while temperatures below 3000 k can not be ruled out , such low temperatures imply cooling ages for some ranges of mass that exceed reasonable estimates for the age of the galaxy ( see section 4 ) , so a temperature range 3000 - 4000 k is suggested . much recent attention has been devoted to the existence of halo wds , motivated by microlensing @xcite and optical @xcite observations , and a few wds are known to be halo stars @xcite . are these two very cool wds part of the halo population ? the proper motion and distance of wd0346 + 246 give a tangential velocity of 175 km s@xmath18 , indicating that star is indeed a halo object @xcite . however , the proper motion of lhs 3250 is smaller ( v@xmath19 = 81 km s@xmath18 ) and is consistent with membership in either the disk or the halo ; meanwhile , its luminosity is not as low as expected for a presumably very old halo wd . the proper motion of sdss 1337 + 00 is smaller yet . if it has an absolute magnitude similar to that of lhs 3250 ( @xmath20 = 15.7 ) , then its distance will be about 54 pc and v@xmath19 will be 46 km s@xmath18 . alternatively , if it has the lower luminosity ( @xmath21 ) expected for a conventional , 0.6-@xmath22 wd cooling to a temperature where cia becomes strong , then its distance will be about 20 pc and v@xmath19 will be only 17 km s@xmath18 . in either case ( pending a parallax measurement ) , these two coolest wds do not have the properties expected for halo stars . to properly constrain the nature of these objects , we must consider not only wds with conventional c / o cores , but also the known population of low mass ( @xmath23 or less ) helium core wds found in binaries @xcite . such objects are the result of truncated stellar evolution in close binaries @xcite and cool more slowly ( for similar masses ) as a result of the increased heat capacity of the helium core . figure 5 shows the cooling time for wds with hydrogen atmospheres ( hansen 1999 ; see also benvenuto & althaus 1999 , chabrier et al . 2000 , salaris et al . conventional wds ( @xmath24 ) require ages @xmath258.5 gyr to cool to 4000 k. wds more massive than average can cool somewhat faster at late times due to the earlier onset of core crystallization . the aforementioned low mass helium core wds can potentially cool below 4000 k much faster . a 0.23 @xmath22 helium core wd may cool below 4000 k in @xmath06 gyr . ( note that very low mass wds may possess thick hydrogen envelopes and thus will cool more slowly , with a contribution to their luminosity from residual hydrogen burning @xcite . if true , this will cause the curves shown in figure 5 to turn upwards again below @xmath26 . ) further progress requires that we determine a temperature or a radius , because the luminosity is known ( or soon will be , after the parallax of sdss 1337 + 00 is measured ) . the radius varies from @xmath27 cm for the @xmath28 model , to @xmath29 cm for the @xmath30 model , so the luminosity at fixed temperature varies by a factor of 7 between these two possibilities . fitting the spectrum with models may give very accurate temperatures when the models are improved ( section 3 ) . the absolute magnitude of lhs 3250 ( @xmath31 ) suggests a low mass , helium core wd as the most likely of the above options . in many respects sdss 1337 + 00 is similar the proper motion and apparent magnitude are both consistent with it being an lhs 3250 analog , but slightly cooler , at two to three times the distance . both stars are more likely to belong to the old disk or thick disk populations than to the halo . most wds have masses @xmath24 . both low mass and high mass wds are minority constituents . thus it seems surprising that such potentially anomalous wds are among the first cool wds found in the sdss survey . this may , in part , be due to the strong color selection involved . wds are only selected for spectroscopic follow - up if they appear to lie outside the main stellar locus in the @xmath32 passbands . thus , the accelerated evolution to low temperatures at the high- and low - mass ends of the distribution may favor their detection . identifying cool wds with temperatures about 3500 - 4500 k that do not have such strong cia is more difficult . transition stars like wd0346 + 246 may be found using a combination of visible and near - infrared colors , or using an intermediate - band filter to find stars with no mgh absorption feature @xcite , and then doing follow - up spectroscopy . with spectroscopic plates taken and examined covering roughly 400 square degrees of sky , we have found two cool wds ( one previously known ) . thus we might expect to find at least several tens in the full sdss survey . we are grateful to f. vrba for obtaining the j magnitude limit of sdss 1337 + 00 . the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) is a joint project of the university of chicago , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , the johns hopkins university , the max - planck - institut fr astronomie , new mexico state university , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington . apache point observatory , site of the sdss , is operated by the astrophysical research consortium . funding for the project has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the sdss member institutions , the national aeronautics and space administration , the national science foundation , the u.s . department of energy , monbusho , and the max planck society . the sdss world wide web site is http://www.sdss.org/. support for this work was provided by nasa through hubble fellowship grant # hf-01120.01 - 99a from the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc . under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 . alcock , c. , et al . 1997 , , 486 , 697 benvenuto , o.g . , & althaus , l.g . 1999 , , 303 , 30 bergeron , p. , ruiz , m.t . , & leggett , s.k . 1997 , , 108 , 339 bergeron , p. , ruiz , m.t . , leggett , s.k . , saumon , d. , & wesemael , f. 1994 , , 423 , 456 bergeron , p. , saffer , r.a . , & liebert , j. 1992 , , 394 , 228 bergeron , p. , saumon , d. , & wesemael , f. 1995a , , 443 , 764 bergeron , p. , wesemael , f. , & beauchamp , a. 1995b , , 107 , 1047 borosow , a. , frommhold , l. , & moraldi , m. 1989 , , 336 , 495 borosow , a. , frommhold , l. , & moraldi , m. 1997 , , 324 , 185 chabrier , g. 1999 , , 513 , l103 chabrier , g. , brassard , p. , fontaine , g. , & saumon , d. 2000 , , 543 , 216 claver , c. 1995 , ph.d . dissertation , univ . of texas driebe , t. , schnberner , d. , blcker , t. , & herwig , f. 1998 , , 339 , 123 fan , x. 1999 , , 117 , 2528 fan , x. , et al . 2001 , , in press , astro - ph/0008122 fukugita , m. , ichikawa , t. , gunn , j.e . , doi , m. , shimasaku , k. , & schneider , d.p . 1996 , , 111 , 1748 gunn , j.e . , et al . 1998 , , 116 , 3040 hambly , n.c . , smartt , s.j . , hodgkin , s.t . , jameson , r.f . , kemp , s.n . , rolleston , w.r.j , & steele , i.a . 1999 , , 309 , l33 hansen , b.m.s . 1998 , , 394 , 860 hansen , b.m.s . 1999 , , 520 , 680 hansen , b.m.s . 2000 , in asp conf . ser.xxx , microlensing 2000 : a new era of microlensing astrophysics , ed . menzies & p.d . sackett ( san francisco , asp ) , in press . hansen , b.m.s . , & phinney , e.s . 1998 , , 294 , 557 harris , h.c . , dahn , c.c . , vrba , f.j . , henden , a.a . , liebert , j. , schmidt , g.d . , & reid , i.n . 1999 , , 524 , 1000 hodgkin , s.t . , oppenheimer , b.r . , hambly , n.c . , jameson , r.f . , smartt , s.j . , & steele , i.a . 2000 , , 405 , 57 ibata , r. , richer , h.b . , gilliland , r.l . , & scott , d. 1999 , , 524 , l95 ibata , r. , irwin , m. , bienaym , o. , scholz , r. , & guibert , j. 2000 , , 532 , l41 isern , j. , garcia - berro , e. , hernanz , m. , mochkovitch , r. , & torres , s. 1998 , , 503 , 239 jrgensen , u.g . , hammer , d. , borysow , a. , & falkesgaard , j. 2000 , , in press kippenhahn , r. , kohl , k. & wiegert , a. 1967 , zeit . , 66 , 58 leggett , s.k . , ruiz , m.t . , & bergeron , p. 1998 , , 497 , 294 lenz , d.d . , newberg , h.j . , rosner , r. , richards , g.t . , & stoughton , c. 1998 , , 119 , 121 lenzuini , p. , chernoff , d.f . , & salpeter , e.e . 1991 , , 76 , 759 liebert , j. , dahn , c.c . , & monet , d.g . 1989 , in white dwarfs , iau colloq . g. wegner ( berlin , springer ) , 15 lupton , r.h . , gunn , j.e . , & szalay , a. 1999 , , 118 , 1406 luyten , w.j . 1976 , a catalogue of stars with proper motions exceeding 0.5@xmath33 annually ( minneapolis : univ . minnesota press ) ( lhs ) marsh , t.r . , dhillon , v.s . , & duck , s.r . 1995 , , 275 , 828 metcalfe , t.s . , mukadam , a. , winget , d.e . , fan , x. , strauss , m.a . , and claver , c. 2000 , in asp conf . ser . 203 , the impact of large - scale surveys on pulsating star research , ed . l. szabados & d. kurtz ( san francisco : asp ) , 514 monet , d.g . , et al . 1998 , the usno - a2.0 catalog ( washington , u.s . naval observatory ) salaris , m. , garcia - berro , e. , hernanz , m. , isern , j. , & saumon , d. 2000 , , 544 , 1036 saumon , d. , bergeron , p. , lunine , j.i . , hubbard , w.b . , & burrows , a. 1994 , , 424 , 333 saumon , d. , & jacobson , s.b . 1999 , , 511 , l107 york , d.g . , 2000 , , 120 , 1579 llll ra & 13 37 39.4 & 16 54 01.3 & 03 46 46.5 + dec & 00 01 43 & 62 53 55 & 24 56 04 + @xmath34 ( mas yr@xmath18 ) & 182@xmath3510 & 566 & 1302 + pa ( degrees ) & 185@xmath353 & 286 & 155 + @xmath36 & [email protected] & [email protected] & + @xmath37 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 19.7 + @xmath38 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 18.5 + @xmath39 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 18.0 + @xmath10 & [email protected] & [email protected] & + @xmath40 & 19.8 & [email protected] & @xmath2520.4 + @xmath41 & 19.3 & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath42 & 19.1 & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath43 & 19.2 & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath12 & @xmath2519.9 & [email protected] & [email protected] +

early data taken during commissioning of the sdss have resulted in the discovery of a very cool white dwarf . it appears to have stronger collision induced absorption from molecular hydrogen than any other known white dwarf , suggesting it has a cooler temperature than any other . while its distance is presently unknown , it has a surprisingly small proper motion , making it unlikely to be a halo star . an analysis of white dwarf cooling times suggests that this object may be a low - mass star with a helium core . the sdss imaging and spectroscopy also recovered lhs 3250 , the coolest previously known white dwarf , indicating that the sdss will be an effective tool for identifying these extreme objects .

1608.08245

sequence https://oeis.org/a000975[a000975 ] in the online encyclopedia of integer sequences ( oeis ) @xcite starts out 1 , 2 , 5 , 10 , 21 , 42 , 85 , . throughout this paper we denote this sequence as sequence @xmath0 and the @xmath1th term of this sequence as @xmath2 , written in function notation . the oeis defines this sequence recursively as follows . * characterization 1 : * \1 . @xmath3 , \2 . @xmath4 , and \3 . @xmath5 . thus to get the next term we either double the preceding value or double it and add 1 . but doubling is the same as appending a 0 in base 2 , while doubling and adding 1 is the same as appending a 1 in base 2 . this provides a second characterization . * characterization 2 : * for @xmath6 , @xmath2 is the number whose binary representation has length @xmath1 and consists of alternating ones and zeros . we illustrate this characterization in table 1 . @xmath7 if we add @xmath2 to @xmath8 , the binary representation of the sum is a string of @xmath1 ones , with value @xmath9 . this gives us our third characterization . * characterization 3 : * \1 . @xmath3 , and \2 . @xmath10 for @xmath11 . alternatively , if we subtract @xmath12 from @xmath2 , most of the ones in the binary representations cancel , leaving @xmath13 . this gives us yet another characterization . * characterization 4 : * \1 . @xmath14 , \2 . @xmath15 , and \3 . @xmath16 for @xmath17 . there are several standard methods for obtaining a closed form expression for @xmath2 . we present a rather unusual derivation . recall that the binary representation of the fraction @xmath18 is @xmath19 multiplying this value by @xmath20 moves the binary point @xmath1 places to the right . rounding down then truncates this expression , yielding @xmath2 , according to characterization 2 , and giving us our next characterization . * characterization 5 : * @xmath21 for all @xmath22 . other expressions are @xmath23{0pt}{10pt}}{\textstyle 3 \rule{0pt}{9pt}}&\mbox{if $ n$ odd}\\ \ \\ \frac{\textstyle 2^{n+1 } -2 \rule[-3pt]{0pt}{10pt}}{\textstyle 3 \rule{0pt}{9pt}}&\mbox{if $ n$ even } \end{array } \right.\\ \ \\ \ \\ & = & \frac{2^{n+2 } - 3 - ( -1)^n}{6}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is an easy exercise to prove that all these characterizations of @xmath2 are equivalent . we observe that @xmath2 is even or odd exactly when @xmath1 is even or odd , respectively . why do we care about a particular sequence ? often it is because the sequence occurs as the answer to some counting problem . the oeis lists several places where the values in sequence https://oeis.org/a000975[a000975 ] occur . here are some of the more interesting . * occurrence 1 : * @xmath2 is the number of moves needed to solve the @xmath1-ring chinese rings puzzle ( baguenaudier ) if the rings are moved one at a time . see , for example , ( * ? ? ? * chapter 1 ) . figure [ rings ] shows the state graph for the 4-ring puzzle . the 16 vertices represent the possible states of the puzzle , and two vertices are joined by an edge if the two corresponding states are one move apart . the labels on the vertices denote the positions of the 4 rings in that state , with 0 representing a ring that is off the sliding bar and 1 a ring that is on . it is easy to confirm that the state graph for the @xmath1-ring puzzle is a path of length @xmath24 from the state labeled @xmath25 to the state labeled @xmath26 . the sub - path from state @xmath25 to state @xmath27 constitutes an optimal solution of the @xmath1-ring puzzle , while the sub - path from state @xmath27 to state @xmath26 represents an optimal solution of the @xmath28-ring puzzle . the number of moves in an optimal solution to this puzzle thus satisfies characterization 3 of sequence @xmath0 . figure [ rings ] also illustrates a related occurrence of our sequence . * occurrence 2 : * @xmath2 is the distance between a string of @xmath1 zeros and a string of @xmath1 ones in the standard @xmath1-bit binary gray code . again , see , for example , ( * ? ? ? * chapter 1 ) . a special case of a problem posed by donald knuth @xcite and solved by o. p. lossers @xcite provides our next occurrence * occurrence 3 : * @xmath2 is the number of ways to partition a set of @xmath29 people sitting around a circular table into three affinity groups with no two members of a group seated next to each other . we illustrate this occurrence in figure [ dk ] , showing the @xmath30 partitions of six people into three affinity groups . for concreteness we assign the names a and b to the affinity groups of the people at the bottom left and bottom right , respectively . following @xcite , we note that there are @xmath9 strings of length @xmath29 that start with ab , contain all the letters a , b , and c , and have no two adjacent letters the same . if such a string ends in either b or c , it can be wrapped into a circle to represent an affinity partition of @xmath29 people . if such a string ends in a , the a can be deleted and the shortened string will represent an affinity partition of @xmath31 people . the number of affinity partitions of @xmath29 people is thus another problem that satisfies characterization 3 of sequence @xmath0 . equivalently , @xmath2 is the number of different 3-colorings for the vertices of all triangulated @xmath32-gons if the colors of the two base vertices are fixed . antti karttunen has suggested that our sequence https://oeis.org/a000975[a000975 ] serves as a link between sequences https://oeis.org/a0000217[a0000217 ] ( the triangular numbers ) and https://oeis.org/a048702[a048702 ] ( the even length binary palindromes divided by 3 ) in the oeis . the triangular numbers , which we represent by @xmath33 , are well - known : @xmath34 . the even length binary palindromes , denoted @xmath35 , ( sequence https://oeis.org/a048701[a048701 ] in the oeis ) , are less well known . we illustrate the sequence @xmath36 in table [ pal ] . @xmath37 the proposal of karttunen is that the values @xmath38 serve as the indices @xmath1 where @xmath33 and @xmath36 agree , as illustrated in table [ blue ] . @xmath39{0pt}{15pt}\\ \hline t(n)&{\bf \color{blue}1}&{\bf \color{blue } 3}&6&10&{\bf \color{blue } 15}&21&28&36&45&{\bf \color{blue } 55}&66&78&91&105&120 \rule[-5pt]{0pt}{15pt}\\ \hline p(n)/3&{\bf \color{blue } 1}&{\bf \color{blue } 3}&5&11&{\bf \color{blue } 15}&17&21&43&51&{\bf \color{blue } 55}&63&65&73&77&85 \rule[-5pt]{0pt}{15pt } \end{array}\ ] ] for any positive integer @xmath1 let @xmath40 . then the binary representation of @xmath1 is @xmath41 bits long , and @xmath35 satisfies @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the binary reversal of @xmath1 ( sequence https://oeis.org/a030101[@xmath44 in the oeis ) . for example , when @xmath45 we have @xmath46 and @xmath47 , so @xmath48 this lemma follows immediately from the definition of @xmath35 . for all @xmath6 , we have @xmath49 if and only if @xmath50 for some positive integer @xmath41 . first suppose @xmath50 where @xmath41 is odd . then we know that @xmath51 @xmath1 is @xmath41 bits long , and @xmath52 . we have @xmath53 now suppose @xmath50 where @xmath41 is even . then we know that @xmath54 @xmath1 is @xmath41 bits long , and @xmath55 . we have @xmath56 next suppose @xmath57 . then @xmath1 is @xmath41 bits long , and @xmath58 finally , suppose @xmath59 . then @xmath1 is @xmath41 bits long , and @xmath60 reinhard zumkeller has conjectured that our sequence @xmath0 is related to the sequence https://oeis.org/a265158[a265158 ] in the oeis . we denote this sequence as @xmath61 and its @xmath1th term as @xmath62 . the sequence is defined by \1 . @xmath63 , \2 . @xmath64 for @xmath22 , and \3 . @xmath65 for @xmath22 . the first few values of this sequence are displayed in table [ b ] . @xmath66{0pt}{12pt}\\ \hline 1&1\;&9&2\;&17&4\;&25&0\;\rule{0pt}{11pt}\\ 2&2\;&10&2\;&18&4\;&26&0\;\\ 3&0\;&11&0\;&19&1\;&27&0\;\\ 4&4\;&12&0\;&20&4\;&28&0\;\\ 5&1\;&13&0\;&21&1\;&29&0\;\\ 6&0\;&14&0\;&22&0\;&30&0\;\\ 7&0\;&15&0\;&23&0\;&31&0\;\\ 8&8\;&16&16\;&24&0\;&32&32\ ; \end{array}\ ] ] a notable property of this sequence is that it contains long runs of zeros . zumkeller conjectures that the lengths of the record runs of zeros in sequence @xmath61 are exactly the values found in sequence @xmath0 . the run lengths themselves form sequence https://oeis.org/a264784[a264784 ] , with values * 1 * , * 2 * , * 5 * , * 10 * , 1 , * 21 * , 2 , * 42 * , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , * 85 * , 2 , 2 , 10 , 2 , * 170 * , 1 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , 21 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , * 341 * , 2 , 2 , 2 , 10 , 2 , 2 , 10 , 2 , 42 , 2 , 2 , 10 , 2 , * 682 * , 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , 21 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , 21 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , 85 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , 21 , 1 , 1 , 5 , 1 , * 1365 * , . we will refer to this sequence of run lengths as sequence @xmath67 , with entries @xmath43 . we confirm a few facts about sequence @xmath61 . @xmath68{0pt}{5pt}\\ 2 & \mbox { if $ k$ is even}\rule{0pt}{15pt } \end{array}\right.\ ] ] the proof is by induction on @xmath41 . for @xmath69 we have @xmath70 let @xmath41 be an even positive integer , and suppose that the lemma is true for smaller values of @xmath41 . we have @xmath71 now let @xmath72 be an odd integer , and suppose that the lemma is true for smaller values of @xmath41 . we have @xmath73 @xmath74 for @xmath75 . for @xmath41 even we have @xmath76 once the case @xmath41 even is established , the case @xmath41 odd follows . @xmath77 note that lemmas 4.1 and 4.2 together imply that for all @xmath75 there is a run of zeros in sequence @xmath61 beginning at index @xmath78 . @xmath79 for all @xmath80 . the proof is by induction on @xmath41 . for @xmath81 we have @xmath82 . now assuming the lemma is true for all values smaller than some @xmath83 , we have @xmath84 for every @xmath75 we have @xmath85 for @xmath86 . these values form a run of zeros of length @xmath87 in @xmath62 , and these are the runs of record length . we again use induction on @xmath41 . for @xmath88 we consider @xmath1 such that @xmath89 , or @xmath90 . now @xmath91 so the claim is true in this case . we now consider the claim for some @xmath92 and assume the claim is true for smaller values of @xmath41 . we know from lemma 4.2 that @xmath93 for @xmath94 , so we need consider only those @xmath1 such that @xmath95 . if @xmath1 is even , this implies @xmath96 , so by the induction hypothesis we have @xmath97 if @xmath1 is odd , it can still be shown that @xmath98 , so the induction hypothesis yields @xmath99 for all @xmath75 , then , we have a run of zeros in sequence @xmath62 starting at @xmath100 and ending at @xmath101 , of length @xmath102 . that these are precisely the runs of record length follows from the fact that @xmath103 for all @xmath80 and that each of these runs covers two - thirds of the entries between consecutive powers of 2 . we can say more about the number and lengths of runs of zeros in @xmath61 if we write the index @xmath1 in binary . using @xmath104 to denote an arbitrary word , or string , over the alphabet @xmath105 , we can restate the definition of @xmath62 as follows : \1 . @xmath106 , \2 . @xmath107 ' '' '' , and \3 . @xmath108 . with this characterization , we can compute the value of @xmath62 by reading the bits of the binary form of the index @xmath1 from left to right . the initial 1 in the index tells us to start with an initial value of 1 . each time we encounter the bit 0 we double our current value ; each time we encounter a 1 we halve the current value , unless the current value is 1 , in which case the value becomes and remains 0 . for example , suppose @xmath109 . the left - most bit is 1 , and we start with an initial value of 1 ; @xmath106 . the next bit is 0 , so we double our current value to 2 ; @xmath110 . the next bit is again 0 , so we again double our current value to 4 ; @xmath111 . the next bit is 1 , so we halve our current value back to 2 ; @xmath112 . the final bit is again 0 , so our current value is doubled to our final value of 4 ; @xmath113 . on the other hand , for @xmath114 , our current value starts at 1 and progresses to 2 , back to 1 , and then to 0 , where it remains ; @xmath115 for any bit string @xmath104 . the above observation provides us with a useful way of identifying the indices where @xmath93 . @xmath93 if and only if , when reading the bits of the binary representation of @xmath1 from left to right , we at some point have encountered more ones than zeros , not counting the initial 1 . we will call a word @xmath104 of length @xmath116 over @xmath117 a _ catalan _ word if it consists of @xmath1 ones and @xmath1 zeros , and at no point , reading from left to right , does it contain more ones than zeros . the first few catalan words are @xmath118 ( the null word ) , 01 , 0011 , 0101 , 000111 , 001011 , 001101 , 010011 , and 010101 . it is well known that the number of catalan words of length @xmath116 is the @xmath1th catalan number @xmath119{0pt}{8pt}$ ] for all @xmath120 . these catalan numbers , which we denote @xmath121 , form sequence https://oeis.org/a000108[a000108 ] in the oeis . there is a run of zeros in sequence @xmath61 beginning at index @xmath1 if any only if the binary representation of @xmath1 has the form @xmath122 or @xmath123 , where @xmath104 is a @xmath124perhaps null@xmath125 catalan word . according to this lemma , the first few indices where runs of zeros begin are @xmath126,@xmath127,@xmath128,@xmath129,@xmath130 , and @xmath131 . this sequence is not currently in the oeis . suppose @xmath132 , with @xmath104 a catalan word . then @xmath133 . by lemma 4.6 we have @xmath93 and @xmath134 . likewise , if @xmath135 then @xmath136 , and again we have @xmath93 and @xmath134 . in both cases , then , a run of zeros starts at index @xmath1 . now suppose @xmath1 is an index where @xmath93 but @xmath1 is not of the above form . there are three cases to consider . @xmath137 where @xmath104 is a catalan word . then @xmath138 , so @xmath139 . @xmath140 where @xmath104 is a catalan word and @xmath141 is a word of length at least 2 , not all zeros . then @xmath142 , where @xmath143 . again , @xmath144 . @xmath140 where @xmath104 is a catalan word and @xmath141 is a string of zeros of length at least 2 . then @xmath145 where @xmath146 is a string of ones of length at least 2 . once again , @xmath144 . in all three cases , then , @xmath147 but is not the start of a run of zeros . we conclude that for @xmath148 , where the binary representation of @xmath1 contains @xmath149 bits , there are exactly @xmath150 runs of zeros in sequence @xmath61 , corresponding to the @xmath150 catalan sequences of length @xmath151 . the longest run of zeros in this range is the last one , of length @xmath38 . there are an additional @xmath150 runs when @xmath152 and @xmath1 is @xmath153 bits long . the longest run here is also the last one , of length @xmath154 . the record - length runs of zeros in @xmath61 are thus runs number @xmath155 , @xmath156 , @xmath157 , @xmath158 , @xmath159 , @xmath160 , @xmath161 , @xmath162 , and so on . these numbers form sequence https://oeis.org/a155051[a155051 ] in the oeis , starting with @xmath163 . this implies the second form of zumkeller s conjecture . the @xmath1th record - length run of zeros in sequence @xmath61 has length @xmath2 and is run number @xmath164 . more concisely , @xmath165 . continuing in the oeis listing for sequence @xmath0 ( sequence a0000975 ) there is a link to an electronic paper http://arxiv.org/abs/1310.4521[enveloping operads and bicoloured noncrossing configuration ] @xcite by f. chapoton and s. giraudo . in table 2 of that paper the sequence 1 , 2 , 5 , 10 , 21 , 42 , 85 is listed twice . in the oeis sloane asks `` is the sequence in table 2 this sequence [ i.e. , sequence @xmath0 ] ? '' . in this section we demonstrate that the answer to this question is `` yes . '' in the somewhat peculiar language of @xcite , these numbers are the first few coefficients of the colored hilbert series giving the number of bubbles of increasing arity , first based and then nonbased , of the 2-colored suboperad @xmath167 of the 2-colored operad bubble generated by these two generators of arity 2 . in more simple languge , a _ bubble _ is a polygon consisting of a base edge and two or more nonbase edges , with each edge either colored blue or left uncolored . the bubble is _ based _ if and only if the base edge is blue . the _ border _ of a bubble is its set of nonbase edges . the _ arity _ of a bubble is the number of edges in its border . the based bubbles in the 2-colored suboperad of interest start with a triangle of blue edges . new bubbles are generated by either replacing a blue border edge with two consecutive uncolored edges , or by replacing an uncolored border edge with two consecutive blue edges . unbased bubbles in this suboperad are the same , but with blue and uncolored interchanged . see figure [ bubble ] for the based bubbles of arity 2 , 3 , and 4 in this suboperad . 1 . the number of blue edges in the border is congruent to @xmath168 ( and the number of uncolored edges in the border is thus congruent to @xmath169 ) ; and 2 . there exist 2 consecutive edges in the border that are either both blue or both uncolored . in addition , the paper @xcite gives 2-variable generating functions ( or colored hilbert series ) for based and unbased bubbles in this suboperad . unfortunately these generating functions are flawed : the numerator of the second term in the first generating function should be @xmath170 , not @xmath171 , and the numerator of the second term in the second generating function should be @xmath171 , not @xmath170 . we now produce our own count of these bubbles . let @xmath172 denote the number of strings of length @xmath1 over the alphablet @xmath173 such that the number of occurrances of the character @xmath174 is congruent to @xmath175 . then @xmath176 . exactly one of these strings consists of alternating @xmath174 characters and @xmath177 characters . clearly the number of strings of length @xmath1 with @xmath41 occurrences of the character @xmath174 is @xmath178 . so we have @xmath179 the restrictions on the number of @xmath174 characters and @xmath177 characters in a string imply that these counts can not be equal , so an alternating string must be of odd length . if @xmath180 the number of @xmath174 characters must be congruent to @xmath181 and the number of @xmath177 characters must be congruent to @xmath182 , so there is a unique alternating string of length @xmath1 , consisting of @xmath41 occurrences of the character @xmath174 and @xmath183 occurrences of the character @xmath177 . every based bubble in our suboperad can be constructed from a blue base and a border colored according to a string described in lemma 4 . there is one based bubble of arity 2 , and the number of based bubbles of arity @xmath1 plus the number of based bubbles of arity @xmath31 is @xmath24 . thus the number of based bubbles satisfies characterization 3 from section 1 . we conclude by illustrating an alternative approach to this counting problem : a one - to - one correspondence between the number of partitions into affinity groups described in section 2 and the based bubbles described here . to construct a bubble from an affinity group partition , we traverse the diagram of the affinity group partition counter - clockwise . if an a is followed by a b , a b by a c , or a c by an a , we color the corresponding edge of the bubble blue . if an a is followed by a c , or a b by an a , or a c by a b , we leave the corresponding edge of the bubble uncolored . the correspondence between the 10 affinity group partitions for 6 people and the 10 bubbles of arity 5 is illustrated in figure [ corr ] . 9 chapoton , frdric , and giraudo , samuele , http://arxiv.org/abs/1310.4521[enveloping operads and bicoloured noncrossing configuration ] , arxiv preprint arxiv:1310.4521 , 2013 . downloaded july 1 , 2016 . hinz , a. m. , klavar , s. , milutinovi , u. , and petr , c. , _ the tower of hanoi myths and maths . _ springer , basel , 2013 . knuth , donald e. , `` problem 11151 , '' _ american mathematical monthly _ * 112 * ( 2005 ) , 367 . lossers , o. p. , `` solution to problem 11151 : partitions of a circular set , '' _ american mathematical monthly _ * 114 * ( 2007 ) , 265266 . oeis foundation inc . , the on - line encyclopedia of integer sequences , https://oeis.org . downloads are current as of july 1 , 2016 .

sequence a000975 in the online encyclopedia of integer sequences ( oeis ) starts out 1 , 2 , 5 , 10 , 21 , 42 , 85 , . as of july 1 , 2016 , the description in the oeis lists several characterizations of this sequence and numerous examples of instances where this sequence occurs . it also presents a `` not yet proved '' result , a conjecture , and an unanswered question concerning this sequence . in this paper we show that all of these proposed results are in fact true .

hep-th0301094

the last seven years have been a very exciting time for string theory . a new understanding of nonperturbative features of string theory , such as d - branes , has led to exciting new developments relating string theory to physically interesting systems such as black holes and supersymmetric gauge field theories , as well as to a new understanding of the relationship between yang - mills theories and quantum theories of gravity . despite remarkable progress in these directions , however , a consistent nonperturbative background - independent formulation of string theory is still lacking . this situation makes it impossible at this point , even in principle , to directly address cosmological questions using string theory . string field theory is a nonperturbative approach to string theory which holds some promise towards providing a background - independent definition of the theory . these lecture notes give an introduction to string field theory and review some recent work which incorporates d - branes into the framework of string field theory . this work shows that string field theory is a sufficiently robust framework that distinct string backgrounds can arise as disconnected solutions of the theory , at least for open strings . it remains to be seen whether this success can be replicated in the closed string sector . in this section we review briefly the situation in string theory as a whole , and summarize the goals of this set of lectures . in section 2 we review some basic aspects of d - branes . in section 3 , we describe a particular d - brane configuration which exhibits a tachyonic instability . this tachyon can be seen in the low - energy super yang - mills description of the d - brane geometry . this field theory tachyon provides a simple model which embodies much of the physics of the more complicated string field theory tachyon discussed in the later lectures . in section 4 we give an introduction to witten s cubic bosonic open string field theory and summarize the conjectures made by sen in 1999 , which suggested that the tachyonic instability of the open bosonic string can be interpreted in terms of an unstable space - filling d - brane , and that this system can be analytically described through open string field theory . section 5 gives a more detailed analytic description of witten s cubic string field theory . in section 6 we summarize evidence from string field theory for sen s conjectures . section 7 contains a brief review of some more recent developments . section 8 contains concluding remarks and lists some open problems . much new work has been done in this area since these lectures were presented at valdivia in january 2002 . except for a few references to more recent developments in footnotes and in the last two sections , these lecture notes primarily cover work done before january 2002 . previous articles reviewing related work include those of ohmori @xcite , de smet @xcite , and arefeva _ et al . an expanded set of lecture notes , based on lectures given by the author and barton zwiebach at tasi 01 , will appear in @xcite ; the larger set of notes will include further details on a number of topics . to understand the significance of developments over the last seven years , it is useful to recall the situation of string theory as it was in early 1995 . at that time it was clearly understood that there were 5 distinct ways in which a supersymmetric closed string could be quantized to give a microscopic definition of a theory of quantum gravity in ten dimensions . each of these approaches to quantizing the string gives a set of rules for calculating scattering amplitudes between on - shell string states which describe gravitational quanta as well as an infinite family of massive particles in a ten - dimensional spacetime . these five string theories are known as the type iia , iib , i , heterotic @xmath0 , and heterotic @xmath1 superstring theories . while these string theories give perturbative descriptions of quantum gravity , in 1995 there was little understanding of nonperturbative aspects of these theories . in the years between 1995 and 2000 , several new ideas dramatically transformed our understanding of string theory . we now briefly summarize these ideas and mention some aspects of these developments relevant to the main topic of these lectures . * dualities : * the five different perturbative formulations of superstring theory are all related to one another through duality symmetries @xcite , whereby the degrees of freedom in one theory can be described through a duality transformation in terms of the degrees of freedom of another theory . some of these duality symmetries are nonperturbative , in the sense that the string coupling @xmath2 in one theory is related to the inverse string coupling @xmath3 in a dual theory . the web of dualities relating the different theories gives a picture in which , rather than describing five distinct possibilities for a fundamental theory , each of the perturbative superstring theories appears to be a particular perturbative limit of some other , as yet unknown , underlying theoretical structure . * m - theory : * in addition to the five perturbative string theories , the web of dualities also seems to include a limit which describes a quantum theory of gravity in eleven dimensions . this new theory has been dubbed `` m - theory '' . although no covariant definition for m - theory has been given , this theory can be related to type iia and heterotic @xmath1 string theories through compactification on a circle @xmath4 and the space @xmath5 respectively @xcite . for example , in relating to the type iia theory , the compactification radius @xmath6 of m - theory becomes the product @xmath7 of the string coupling and string length in the 10d iia theory . thus , m - theory in flat space , which arises in the limit @xmath8 , can be thought of as the strong coupling limit of type iia string theory . it is also suspected that m - theory may be describable as a quantum theory of membranes in 11 dimensions @xcite , although a covariant formulation of such a theory is still lacking . * branes : * in addition to strings , all five superstring theories , as well as m - theory , contain extended objects of higher dimensionality known as `` branes '' . m - theory has m2-branes and m5-branes , which have two and five dimensions of spatial extent ( whereas a string has one ) . the different superstring theories each have different complements of d - branes as well as the fundamental string and neveu - schwarz 5-brane ; in particular , the iia / iib superstring theories contain d - branes of all even / odd dimensions . the branes of one theory can be related to the branes of another through the duality transformations mentioned above . through an appropriate sequence of dualities , any brane can be mapped to any other brane , including the string itself . this suggests that none of these objects are really any more fundamental than any others ; this idea is known as `` brane democracy '' . * m(atrix ) theory and ads / cft : * one of the most remarkable results of the developments just mentioned is the realization that in certain space - time backgrounds , m - theory and string theory can be completely described through simple supersymmetric quantum mechanics and field theory models related to the low - energy description of systems of branes . the m(atrix ) model of m - theory is a simple supersymmetric matrix quantum mechanics which is believed to capture all of the physics of m - theory in asymptotically flat spacetime ( in light - cone coordinates ) . a closely related set of higher - dimensional supersymmetric yang - mills theories are related to string theory in backgrounds described by the product of anti - de sitter space and a sphere through the ads / cft correspondence . it is believed that these models of m - theory and string theory give true nonperturbative descriptions of quantum gravity in space - time backgrounds which have the asymptotic geometry relevant to each model . for reviews of m(atrix ) theory and ads / cft , see @xcite . the set of ideas just summarized have greatly increased our understanding of nonperturbative aspects of string theory . in particular , through m(atrix ) theory and the ads / cft correspondences we now have nonperturbative definitions of m - theory and string theory in certain asymptotic space - time backgrounds which could , in principle , be used to calculate any local result in quantum gravity . while these new insights are very powerful , however , we are still lacking a truly background - independent formulation of string theory . the goal of these lectures is to describe progress towards a nonperturbative background - independent formulation of string theory . such a formulation is needed to address fundamental questions such as : what is string theory / m - theory ? how is the vacuum of string theory selected ? i.e. _ , why can the observable low - energy universe be accurately described by the standard model of particle physics in four space - time dimensions with an apparently small but nonzero positive cosmological constant ? ) , and other questions of a cosmological nature . obviously , aspiring to address these questions is an ambitious undertaking , but we believe that attaining a better understanding of string field theory is a useful step in this direction . more concretely , in these lectures we will describe recent progress on open string field theory . it may be useful here to recall some basic aspects of open and closed strings and the relationship between them . closed strings , which are topologically equivalent to a circle @xmath4 , give rise upon quantization to a massless set of spacetime fields associated with the graviton @xmath9 , the dilaton @xmath10 , and the antisymmetric two - form @xmath11 , as well as an infinite family of massive fields . for the supersymmetric closed string , further massless fields associated with the graviton supermultiplet appear these are the ramond - ramond @xmath12-form fields @xmath13 and the gravitini @xmath14 . thus , the quantum theory of closed strings is naturally associated with a theory of gravity in space - time . on the other hand , open strings , which are topologically equivalent to an interval @xmath15 $ ] , give rise under quantization to a massless gauge field @xmath16 in space - time . the supersymmetric open string also has a massless gaugino field @xmath17 . it is now understood that generally open strings should be thought of as ending on a dirichlet @xmath12-brane ( d@xmath12-brane ) , and that the massless open string fields describe the fluctuations of the d - brane and the gauge field living on the world - volume of the d - brane . it may seem , therefore , that open and closed strings are quite distinct , and describe disjoint aspects of the physics in a fixed background space - time containing some family of d - branes . at tree level , the closed strings indeed describe gravitational physics in the bulk space - time , while the open strings describe the d - brane dynamics . at the quantum level , however , the physics of open and closed strings are deeply connected . indeed , historically open strings were discovered first through the form of their scattering amplitudes @xcite . looking at one - loop processes for open strings led to the first discovery of closed strings , which appeared as _ poles _ in nonplanar one - loop open string diagrams @xcite . the fact that open string diagrams naturally contain closed string intermediate states indicates that in some sense all closed string interactions are implicitly defined through the complete set of open string diagrams . this connection underlies many of the important recent developments in string theory . in particular , the m(atrix ) theory and ads / cft correspondences between gauge theories and quantum gravity are essentially limits in which closed string physics in a fixed space - time background is captured by a simple limiting yang - mills description of an open string theory on a family of branes ( d0-branes for m(atrix ) theory , d3-branes for the cft describing ads@xmath18 , etc . ) the fact that , in certain fixed space - time backgrounds , quantum gravity theories can be encoded in terms of open string degrees of freedom through the m(atrix ) and ads / cft correspondences leads to the question of how a global change of the space - time background would appear in the quantum field theory describing the appropriate limit of the open string model in question . if such a change of background could be described in the context of m(atrix ) theory or ads / cft , it would indicate that these models could be generalized to a background - independent framework . unfortunately , however , such a change in the background involves adding nonrenormalizable interactions to the field theories in question . at this point in time we do not have the technology to understand generically how a sensible quantum field theory can be described when an infinite number of nonrenormalizable interaction terms are added to the lagrangian . one example of a special case where this can be done is the addition of a constant background @xmath19 field in space - time . in the associated yang - mills theory , such as that on a system of @xmath20 d3-branes in the case of the simplest ads / cft correspondence , this change in the background field corresponds to replacing products of open string fields with a noncommutative star - product . the resulting theory is a noncommutative yang - mills theory . such noncommutative theories are the only well - understood example of a situation where adding an infinite number of apparently nonrenormalizable terms to a field theory action leads to a sensible modification of quantum field theory ( for a review of noncommutative field theory and its connection to string theory , see @xcite ) . string field theory is a nonperturbative formulation in target space of an interacting string theory , in which the infinite family of fields associated with string excitations are described by a space - time field theory action . for open strings , this field theory is a natural extension of the low - energy yang - mills action describing a system of d - branes , where the entire hierarchy of massive string fields is included in addition to the massless gauge field on the d - brane . integrating out all the massive fields from the string field theory action gives rise to a nonabelian born - infeld action for the d - branes , including an infinite set of higher - order terms arising from string theory corrections to the simple yang - mills action . like the case of noncommutative field theory discussed above , the new terms appearing in this action are apparently nonrenormalizable , but the combination of terms must work together to form a sensible theory . in the 1980 s , a great deal of work was done on formulating string field theory for open and closed , bosonic and supersymmetric string theories . most of these string field theories are quite complicated . for the open bosonic string , however , witten @xcite constructed an extremely elegant string field theory based on the chern - simons action . this cubic bosonic open string field theory ( osft ) is the primary focus of the work described in these lectures . although witten s osft can be described in a simple abstract language , practical computations with this theory rapidly become extremely complicated . despite a substantial amount of work on this theory , little insight was gained in the 1980 s regarding how this theory could be used to go beyond standard perturbative string methods . work on this subject stalled out in the late 80 s , and little further attention was paid to osft until several years ago . one simple feature of the 26-dimensional bosonic string has been problematic since the early days of string theory : both the open and closed bosonic strings have tachyons in their spectra , indicating that the usual perturbative vacua used for these theories are unstable . in 1999 , ashoke sen had a remarkable insight into the nature of the open bosonic string tachyon @xcite . he observed that the open bosonic string should be thought of as ending on a space - filling d25-brane . he pointed out that this d - brane is unstable in the bosonic theory , as it does not carry any conserved charge , and he suggested that the open bosonic string tachyon should be interpreted as the instability mode of the d25-brane . this led him to conjecture that witten s open string field theory could be used to precisely determine a new vacuum for the open string , namely one in which the d25-brane is annihilated through condensation of the tachyonic unstable mode . sen made several precise conjectures regarding the details of the string field theory description of this new open string vacuum . as we describe in these lectures , there is now overwhelming evidence that sen s picture is correct , demonstrating that string field theory accurately describes the nonperturbative physics of d - branes . this new nonperturbative application of string field theory has sparked a new wave of work on witten s cubic open string field theory , revealing many remarkable new structures . in particular , string field theory now provides a concrete framework in which disconnected string backgrounds can emerge from the equations of motion of a single underlying theory . although so far this can only be shown explicitly in the open string context , this work paves the way for a deeper understanding of background - independence in quantum theories of gravity . in this section we briefly review some basic features of d - branes . the concepts developed here will be useful in describing tachyonic d - brane configurations in the following section . for more detailed reviews of d - branes , see @xcite . d - branes can be understood in two ways : _ a _ ) as extended extremal black brane solutions of supergravity carrying conserved charges , and _ b _ ) as hypersurfaces on which strings have dirichlet boundary conditions . _ a _ ) the ten - dimensional type iia and iib supergravity theories each have a set of @xmath21-form fields @xmath22 in the supergraviton multiplet , with @xmath12 even / odd for type iia / iib supergravity . these are the ramond - ramond fields in the massless superstring spectrum . for each of these @xmath21-form fields , there is a solution of the supergravity field equations which has @xmath21-dimensional lorentz invariance , and which has the form of an extremal black hole solution in the orthogonal @xmath23 space directions plus time ( for a review see @xcite ) . these `` black @xmath12-brane '' solutions carry charge under the r - r fields @xmath24 , and are bps states in the supergravity theory , preserving half the supersymmetries of the theory . _ b _ ) in type iia and iib string theory , it is possible to consider open strings with dirichlet boundary conditions on some number @xmath23 of the spatial coordinates @xmath25 . the locus of points defined by such dirichlet boundary conditions defines a @xmath21-dimensional hypersurface @xmath26 in the ten - dimensional spacetime . when @xmath12 is even / odd in type iia / iib string theory , the spectrum of the resulting quantum open string theory contains a massless set of fields @xmath27 and @xmath28 . these fields can be associated with a gauge field living on the hypersurface @xmath26 , and a set of degrees of freedom describing the transverse fluctuations of this hypersurface in spacetime . thus , the quantum fluctuations of the open string describe a fluctuating @xmath21-dimensional hypersurface in spacetime a dirichlet - brane , or `` d - brane '' . the remarkable insight of polchinski in 1995 @xcite was the observation that dirichlet - branes carry ramond - ramond charges , and therefore should be described in the low - energy supergravity limit of string theory by precisely the black @xmath12-branes discussed in _ a _ ) . this connection between the string and supergravity descriptions of these nonperturbative objects paved the way to a dramatic series of new developments in string theory , including connections between string theory and supersymmetric gauge theories , string constructions of black holes , and new approaches to string phenomenology . in this subsection we briefly review the low - energy super yang - mills description of the dynamics of one or more d - branes . as discussed in the previous subsection , the massless open string modes on a d@xmath12-brane in type iia or iib superstring theory describe a @xmath29-component gauge field @xmath30 , @xmath23 transverse scalar fields @xmath31 , and a set of massless fermionic gaugino fields . the scalar fields @xmath31 describe small fluctuations of the d - brane around a flat hypersurface . if the d - brane geometry is sufficiently far from flat , it is useful to describe the d - brane configuration by a general embedding @xmath32 , where @xmath33 are @xmath34 coordinates on the d@xmath12-brane world - volume @xmath35 , and @xmath36 are ten functions giving a map from @xmath35 into the space - time manifold @xmath37 . just as the einstein equations governing the geometry of spacetime arise from the condition that the one - loop contribution to the closed string beta function vanish , a set of equations of motion for a general d@xmath12-brane geometry and associated world - volume gauge field can be derived from a calculation of the one - loop open string beta function @xcite . these equations of motion arise from the classical born - infeld action @xmath38 where @xmath39 , @xmath19 and @xmath10 are the pullbacks of the 10d metric , antisymmetric tensor and dilaton to the d - brane world - volume , while @xmath40 is the field strength of the world - volume @xmath41 gauge field @xmath42 . @xmath43 represents a set of chern - simons terms which will be discussed in the following subsection . this action can be verified by a perturbative string calculation @xcite , which also gives a precise expression for the brane tension @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the string coupling , equal to the exponential of the dilaton expectation value . a particular limit of the born - infeld action ( [ eq : dbi ] ) is useful for describing many low - energy aspects of d - brane dynamics . take the background space - time @xmath46 to be flat , and all other supergravity fields ( @xmath47 ) to vanish . we then assume that the d - brane is approximately flat , and is close to the hypersurface @xmath48 , so that we may make the static gauge choice @xmath49 . we furthermore assume that @xmath50 and @xmath51 are small and of the same order . in this limit , the action ( [ eq : dbi ] ) can be expanded as @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the @xmath12-brane world - volume and the coupling @xmath54 is given by @xmath55 including fermionic terms , the second term in ( [ eq : action - expansion ] ) is simply the dimensional reduction to @xmath21 dimensions of the 10d @xmath56 super yang - mills action @xmath57 where for @xmath58 , @xmath59 is the world - volume u(1 ) field strength , and for @xmath60 , @xmath61 ( setting @xmath62 ) . when multiple d@xmath12-branes are present , the d - brane action is modified in a fairly simple fashion @xcite . consider a system of @xmath20 coincident d - branes . for every pair of branes @xmath63 there is a set of massless fields @xmath64 associated with strings stretching from the @xmath65th brane to the @xmath66th brane ; the indices @xmath67 are known as chan - paton indices . treating the fields ( [ eq : nonabelian - fields ] ) as matrices , the analogue for multiple branes of the born - infeld action ( [ eq : dbi ] ) takes the form @xmath68 this action is known as the nonabelian born - infeld action ( nbi ) . in order to give a rigorous definition to the nonabelian born - infeld action , it is necessary to resolve ordering ambiguities in the expression ( [ eq : nbi ] ) . since the spacetime coordinates @xmath31 associated with the d - brane positions in space - time become themselves matrix - valued , even evaluating the pullbacks @xmath69 involves resolving ordering issues . much work has been done recently to resolve these ordering ambiguities ( see @xcite for some recent papers in this direction which contain further references to the literature ) , but there is still no consistent definition of the nonabelian born - infeld theory ( [ eq : nbi ] ) which is valid to all orders . the nonabelian born - infeld action ( [ eq : nbi ] ) becomes much simpler in the low - energy limit when the background space - time is flat . in the same limit discussed above for the single d - brane , where we find a low - energy limit giving the u(1 ) super yang - mills theory in @xmath34 dimensions , the inclusion of multiple d - branes simply leads in the low - energy limit to the nonabelian u(n ) super yang - mills action in @xmath70 dimensions . this action is the dimensional reduction of the 10d u(n ) super yang - mills action ( analogous to ( [ eq : sym1 ] ) , but with an overall trace ) to @xmath34 dimensions . in this reduction , as before , for @xmath58 , @xmath59 is the world - volume u(1 ) field strength , and for @xmath60 , @xmath61 , where now @xmath71 and @xmath59 are @xmath72 matrices . we furthermore have , for @xmath73 , @xmath74 $ ] in the dimensional reduction . the low - energy description of a system of @xmath20 coincident flat d - branes is thus given by @xmath75 super yang - mills theory in the appropriate dimension . this connection between d - brane actions in string theory and super yang - mills theory has led to many new developments , including new insights into supersymmetric field theories , the m(atrix ) theory and ads / cft correspondences , and brane world scenarios . in this subsection we describe a remarkable feature of d - brane systems , namely a mechanism by which one or more d - branes of a fixed dimension can be used to construct additional d - branes of higher or lower dimension . in our discussion of the d - brane action ( [ eq : dbi ] ) above , we mentioned a group of terms @xmath43 which we did not describe explicitly . for a single d@xmath12-brane , these chern - simons terms can be combined into a single expression of the form @xmath76 where @xmath77 represents a formal sum over all the ramond - ramond fields @xmath78 of various dimensions . in this integral , for each term @xmath78 , the nonvanishing contribution to ( [ eq : chern - simons ] ) is given by expanding the exponential of @xmath79 to order @xmath80 , where the dimension of the resulting form saturates the dimension of the brane . for example , on a d@xmath12-brane , there is a coupling of the form @xmath81 this coupling implies that the u(1 ) field strength on the d@xmath12-brane couples to the r - r field associated with @xmath82-branes . thus , we can associate magnetic fields on a d@xmath12-brane with dissolved @xmath82-branes living on the d@xmath12-brane . this result generalizes to a system of multiple d@xmath12-branes by simply performing a trace on the rhs of ( [ eq : chern - simons ] ) for example , on @xmath20 compact d@xmath12-branes , the charge @xmath83 which is the first chern class of the u(n ) bundle described by the gauge field on the @xmath20 branes , is quantized and measures the number of units of d@xmath82-brane charge living on the d@xmath12-branes , which are encoded in the field strength @xmath59 . similarly , @xmath84 encodes d@xmath85-brane charge on the d@xmath12-branes . just as lower - dimensional branes can be described in terms of the degrees of freedom associated with a system of @xmath20 d@xmath12-branes through the field strength @xmath59 , higher - dimensional branes can be described by a system of @xmath20 d@xmath12-branes in terms of the commutators of the matrix - valued scalar fields @xmath31 . just as @xmath86 measures @xmath82-brane charge , the matrix @xmath87 \label{eq : up - charge}\ ] ] measures @xmath88-brane charge @xcite . the charge ( [ eq : up - charge ] ) should be interpreted as a form of local charge density . the fact that the trace of ( [ eq : up - charge ] ) vanishes for finite sized matrices corresponds to the fact that the net d@xmath12-brane charge of a finite - size brane configuration in flat spacetime vanishes . a simple example of the mechanism by which a system of multiple d@xmath12-branes form a higher - dimensional brane is given by the matrix sphere . if we take a system of d0-branes with scalar matrices @xmath31 given by @xmath89 where @xmath90 are the generators of su(2 ) in the @xmath20-dimensional representation , then we have a configuration corresponding to the `` matrix sphere '' . this is a d2-brane of spherical geometry living on the locus of points satisfying @xmath91 . the `` local '' d2-brane charge of this brane is given by ( [ eq : up - charge ] ) . the d2-brane configuration given by ( [ eq : matrix - sphere ] ) is rotationally invariant ( up to a gauge transformation ) . the restriction of the brane to the desired locus of points can be seen from the relation @xmath92 . we conclude our discussion of d - branes with a brief description of t - duality . t - duality is a perturbative symmetry which relates the type iia and type iib string theories . this duality symmetry was in fact crucial in the original discovery of d - branes @xcite . a more detailed discussion of t - duality can be found in the textbook by polchinski @xcite . using t - duality , we construct an explicit example of a brane within a brane encoded in super yang - mills theory , illustrating the ideas of the previous subsection . this example will be used in the following section to construct an analogous configuration with a tachyon . consider type iia string theory on a spacetime of the form @xmath93 where @xmath94 is a generic 9-manifold of lorentz signature , and @xmath4 is a circle of radius @xmath95 . t - duality is the statement that this theory is precisely equivalent , at the perturbative level , to type iib string theory on the spacetime @xmath96 , where @xmath97 is a circle of radius @xmath98 . t - duality is most easily understood in terms of closed strings , where it amounts to an exchange of winding and momentum modes of the string . the string winding modes on @xmath4 have energy @xmath99 , where @xmath100 is the winding number . the t - dual momentum modes on @xmath97 have @xmath101 ; it is straightforward to check that the spectrum of closed string states is unchanged under t - duality . t - duality can also be understood in terms of open strings . under t - duality , an open string with neumann boundary conditions on @xmath4 is mapped to an open string with dirichlet boundary conditions on @xmath97 , and vice versa . thus , a dirichlet @xmath12-brane which is wrapped around the circle @xmath4 is mapped under t - duality to a dirichlet @xmath102-brane of one lower dimension which is localized to a point on the circle @xmath97 . at the level of the low - energy theory on the d - brane , the @xmath29-dimensional yang - mills theory on the @xmath12-brane is replaced under t - duality with the @xmath12-dimensional yang - mills theory on the dual @xmath102-brane . mathematically , the covariant derivative operator in the direction @xmath4 is replaced under t - duality with an adjoint scalar field @xmath31 . formally , this adjoint scalar field is an infinite size matrix , containing information about the open strings wrapped an arbitrary number of times around the compact direction @xmath97 . we can summarize the relevant mappings under t - duality in the following table [ cols=">,^ , > " , ] these numerical calculations indicate that level truncation of string field theory leads to a good systematic approximation scheme for computing the nonperturbative tachyon vacuum . up to level 12 , at level ( 14 , 42 ) the energy becomes @xmath103 , and that the energy continues to decrease , reaching @xmath104 at level ( 18 , 54 ) . in @xcite , it was shown that this calculation could be theoretically extrapolated to higher levels using the result found in @xcite that perturbative amplitudes converge in level truncation with errors described by a power series in @xmath105 . this extrapolation suggests that the energy turns around again near @xmath106 , and then increases again , asymptotically approaching @xmath107 as @xmath108 . further analysis supporting this conclusion was given in @xcite , where the effective tachyon potential was extrapolated to higher order using results calculated up to level 18 . ] it is interesting to consider the tachyon condensation problem from the point of view of the effective tachyon potential . if instead of trying to solve the quadratic equations for all @xmath20 of the fields appearing in ( [ eq : scalar - potential ] ) , we instead fix the tachyon field @xmath109 and solve the quadratic equations for the remaining @xmath110 fields , we can determine a effective potential @xmath111 for the tachyon field . this was done numerically up to level @xmath112 in @xcite@xmath113 . at each level , the tachyon effective potential smoothly interpolates between the perturbative vacuum and the nonperturbative vacuum near @xmath114 . for example , the tachyon effective potential at level ( 2 , 6 ) is graphed in figure [ f : potential ] . in all level truncations other than ( 0 , 0 ) and ( 2 , 4 ) , the tachyon effective potential has two branch point singularities at which the continuous solution for the other fields breaks down ; for the level ( 2 , 6 ) truncation , these branch points occur at @xmath115 and @xmath116 ; the lower branch point is denoted by a solid circle in figure [ f : potential ] . as a result of these branch points , the tachyon effective potential is only valid for a finite range of @xmath109 , ranging between approximately @xmath117 and @xmath118 . in @xcite it was demonstrated numerically that the branch points in the tachyon effective potential arise because the trajectory in field space associated with this potential encounters the boundary of the region of feynman - siegel gauge validity . as mentioned earlier , feynman - siegel gauge is only valid in a finite - size region around the perturbative vacuum . it seems almost to be a fortunate accident that the nonperturbative vacuum lies within the region of validity of this gauge choice . it is also worth mentioning here that in the `` background - independent '' formulation of sft , the tachyon potential can be computed exactly @xcite . in this formulation , there is no branch point in the effective potential , which is unbounded below for negative values of the tachyon . on the other hand , the nontrivial vacuum in the background - independent approach arises only as the tachyon field goes to infinity , so it is harder to study the physics of the stable vacuum from this point of view . another interesting perspective on the tachyon effective potential is found by performing a perturbative computation of the coefficients in this effective potential in the level - truncated theory . this gives a power series expansion of the effective tachyon potential @xmath119 in @xcite , the coefficients up to @xmath120 were computed in the level truncations up to ( 10 , 20 ) . because of the branch point singularity near @xmath121 , this series has a radius of convergence much smaller than the value of @xmath109 at the nonperturbative vacuum . thus , the energy at the stable vacuum lies outside the naive range of perturbation theory . thus , the stable vacuum is in some sense accessible from purely perturbative calculations . ] . we have seen that numerical results from level - truncated string field theory strongly suggest the existence of a classically stable vacuum solution @xmath122 to the string field theory equation of motion ( [ eq : sft - eom ] ) . the state @xmath122 , while still unknown analytically , has been determined numerically to a high degree of precision . this state seems like a very well - behaved string field configuration . while there is no positive - definite inner product on the string field fock space , the state @xmath122 certainly has finite norm under the natural inner product @xmath123 , and is even better behaved under the product @xmath124 . thus , it is natural to assume that @xmath122 defines a classically stable vacuum for the theory , around which we can expand the action to find a new `` vacuum string field theory '' . expanding @xmath125 we get the action @xmath126 where @xmath127 this string field theory around the stable vacuum has precisely the same form as witten s original cubic string field theory , only with a different brst operator @xmath128 , which so far is only determined numerically . note that this formulation of vacuum string field theory is distinct from the vsft model of rastelli , sen , and zwiebach ( rsz ) @xcite . these authors make an ansatz that the brst operator takes a pure ghost form , along the lines of @xmath129 , and they conjecture that the theory with such a brst operator is equivalent to the vsft model given by the brst operator ( [ eq : vsft - q ] ) . we discuss the rsz model again briefly in the next section . sen s third conjecture states that there should be no open string excitations of the theory around @xmath130 . this implies that there should be no solutions of the linearized equation @xmath131 in the vsft ( [ eq : vsft - action ] ) other than pure gauge states of the form @xmath132 . in this subsection we discuss evidence for this conjecture . it may seem surprising to imagine that _ all _ the perturbative open string degrees of freedom will vanish at a particular point in field space , since these are all the degrees of freedom available in the theory . this is not a familiar phenomenon from quantum field theory . to understand how the open strings can decouple , it may be helpful to begin by considering the simple example of the ( 0 , 0 ) level - truncated theory . in this theory , the quadratic terms in the action become @xmath133 \phi ( p ) \ , . \ ] ] taking @xmath134 , we find that the quadratic term is a transcendental expression which does not vanish for any real value of @xmath135 . thus , this theory has no poles , and the tachyon has decoupled from the theory . of course , this is not the full story , as there are still finite complex poles . it does , however suggest a mechanism by which the nonlocal parts of the action ( encoded in the exponential of @xmath135 ) can remove physical poles . to get the full story , it is necessary to continue the analysis to higher level . at level 2 , there are 7 scalar fields , the tachyon and the 6 fields associated with the fock space states @xmath136 note that in this analysis we can not fix feynman - siegel gauge , as we only believe that this gauge is valid for the zero - modes of the scalar fields in the vacuum @xmath122 . an attempt at analyzing the spectrum of the theory in feynman - siegel gauge using level truncation was made in @xcite , with no sensible results . diagonalizing the quadratic term in the action on the full set of 7 fields of level @xmath137 , we find that poles develop at @xmath138 and @xmath139 ( in string units , where the tachyon has @xmath140 ) @xcite . these poles correspond to states satisfying @xmath141 . the question now is , are these states physical ? if they are exact states , of the form @xmath132 , then they are simply gauge degrees of freedom . if not , however , then they are states in the cohomology of @xmath128 and should be associated with physical degrees of freedom . unfortunately , we can not precisely determine whether the poles we find in level truncation are due to exact states , as the level - truncation procedure breaks the condition @xmath142 . thus , we can only measure _ approximately _ whether a state is exact . a detailed analysis of this question was carried out in @xcite . in this paper , all terms in the sft action of the form @xmath143 were determined , where @xmath144 is a scalar zero - mode , and @xmath145 are nonzero - momentum scalars . in addition , all gauge transformations involving at least one zero - momentum field were computed up to level ( 6 , 12 ) . at each level up to @xmath146 , the ghost number 1 states in the kernel @xmath147 were computed . the extent to which each of these states lies in the exact subspace was measured using the formula @xmath148 where @xmath149 are an orthonormal basis for @xmath150 , the image of @xmath128 acting on the space of ghost number 0 states in the appropriate level truncation . ( note that this measure involves a choice of inner product on the fock space ; several natural inner products were tried , giving roughly equivalent results ) . the result of this analysis was that up to the mass scale of the level truncation , @xmath151 , all the states in the kernel of @xmath152 were @xmath153 within the exact subspace , for @xmath154 . this result seems to give very strong evidence for sen s third conjecture that there are no perturbative open string excitations around the stable classical vacuum @xmath122 . this analysis was only carried out for even level scalar fields ; it would be nice to check that a similar result holds for odd - level fields and for tensor fields of arbitrary rank . another more abstract argument that there are no open string states in the stable vacuum was given by ellwood , feng , he and moeller @xcite . these authors argued that in the stable vacuum , the identity state @xmath155 in the sft star algebra , which satisfies @xmath156 for a very general class of string fields @xmath157 , seems to be an exact state , @xmath158 if indeed the identity is exact , then it follows immediately that the cohomology of @xmath128 is empty , since @xmath159 then implies that @xmath160 so to prove that the cohomology of @xmath128 is trivial , it suffices to show that @xmath161 . while there are some subtleties involved with the identity string field , ellwood _ et al . _ found a very elegant expression for this field , @xmath162 ( recall that @xmath163 . ) they then looked numerically for a state @xmath164 satisfying ( [ eq : i - exact ] ) . for example , truncating at level @xmath165 , @xmath166 while the only candidate for @xmath167 is @xmath168 for some constant @xmath169 . the authors of @xcite showed that the state ( [ eq : identity-2 ] ) is best approximated as exact when @xmath170 ; for this value , their measure of exactness becomes @xmath171 which the authors interpreted as a @xmath172 deviation from exactness . generalizing this analysis to higher levels , they found at levels 5 , 7 , and 9 , a deviation from exactness of @xmath173 and @xmath174 respectively . at level 9 , for example , the identity field has 118 components , and there are only 43 gauge parameters , so this is a highly nontrivial check on the exactness of the identity . like the results of @xcite , these results strongly support the conclusion that the cohomology of the theory is trivial in the stable vacuum . in this case , the result applies to fields of all spins and all ghost numbers . given that the witten string field theory seems to have a classical solution with no perturbative open string excitations , in accordance with sen s conjectures , it is quite interesting to ask what the physics of the vacuum string field theory ( [ eq : vsft - action ] ) should describe . one natural assumption might be that this theory should include closed string states in its quantum spectrum . unfortunately , addressing this question requires performing calculations in the quantum theory around the stable vacuum . such calculations are quite difficult ( although progress in this direction has been made in the @xmath12-adic version of the theory @xcite ) . even in the perturbative vacuum , it is difficult to systematically study closed strings in the quantum string from theory . we discuss the question again briefly in the final section . in this section we review briefly some further developments which we do not have time to explore in great detail in these lectures . in subsection 7.1 we discuss the pure ghost brst operator ansatz of rsz ( rastelli , sen , and zwiebach ) for vacuum string field theory . in subsection 7.2 we discuss `` sliver '' states and related states ; these states are projectors in the sft star algebra , and are closely related to d - branes in the rsz vsft model . these topics will be discussed in further detail in @xcite in @xcite , rastelli , sen , and zwiebach made an intriguing proposal regarding the form of witten s string field theory around the stable tachyon vacuum . since the exact form of the brst operator @xmath128 given by ( [ eq : vsft - q ] ) is not known analytically , and is difficult to work with numerically , these authors suggested that it might be possible to `` guess '' an appropriate form for this operator ( after suitable field redefinition ) , using the properties expected of the brst operator in any vacuum . they suggested a simple class of brst operators @xmath175 which satisfy the properties ( a - c ) described in section 4.2 ( actually , they impose the slightly weaker but still sufficient condition @xmath176 instead of condition ( b ) ) . in particular , they propose that after a field redefinition , the brst operator of the string field theory in the classically stable vacuum should be an operator @xmath175 expressable purely in terms of ghost operators . for example , the simplest operator in the class they suggest is @xmath177 , which clearly satisfies @xmath178 , and which also satisfies condition ( c ) and the weaker form of condition ( b ) mentioned above . the rsz model of vacuum string field theory has a number of attractive features . * this model satisfies all the axioms of string field theory , and has a brst operator with vanishing cohomology . * in the rsz model , the equation of motion factorizes into the usual equation of motion @xmath179 for the ghost part of the field , and a projection equation @xmath180 for the matter part of the field , where the full string field is given by @xmath181 thus , finding a solution of the equation of motion reduces to the problem of solving the equation of motion in the ghost sector and identifying projection operators in the string field star algebra . it was also recently shown @xcite that by taking the brst operator @xmath175 to be given by a ghost insertion localized at the string midpoint , the ghost equation also has essentially the form of the projection equation . thus , this seems to be a very natural choice for the brst operator of the rsz model . * a number of projection operators have been identified in the string field star algebra . these projection operators have many of the properties desired of d - branes . we will briefly review some aspects of these projection operators in the next subsection . * given the projection operators just mentioned , the ratio of tensions between d - branes of different dimensionality can be computed and has the correct value @xcite . despite the successes of the rsz model , there are some difficult technical aspects of this picture . first , it seems very difficult to actually prove that this model is related to the vsft around the stable vacuum in the witten model , not least because we lack any analytic control over the witten theory . second , the rsz model seems to have a somewhat singular structure in several respects . formally , the action on any well - behaved fock space state satisfying the equation of motion will vanish @xcite . further , the natural solutions of the projection equation corresponding to the matter sector of the equation of motion have rather singular properties @xcite . some of these singular properties are related to the fact that some of the physics in the rsz model seems to have been `` pushed '' into the midpoint of the string . in the witten model , the condition that , for example , @xmath182 involves a fairly subtle anomaly cancellation between the matter and ghost sectors at the midpoint . in the rsz model , the matter and ghost sectors are essentially decoupled , so that the theory seems to have separate singularities in each sector , which cancel when the sectors are combined . these are all indications of a theory with problematic singularities . while the witten theory seems to be free of singularities of this type , it remains to be seen whether resolving the singularities of the rsz model or finding an analytic approach to the witten theory will be a more difficult problem to solve . from the point of view of the rsz model of vsft just discussed , projection operators in the matter sector of the star algebra play a crucial role in constructing solutions of the equations of motion . such projection operators may also be useful in understanding solutions in the original witten theory . quite a bit of work has been done on constructing and analyzing projectors in the star algebra since the rsz model was originally proposed . without going into the technical details , we now briefly review some of the important features of matter projectors . the first matter projector which was explicitly constructed is the `` sliver '' state . this state was identified in conformal field theory in @xcite , and then constructed explicitly using matter oscillators in @xcite . the sliver state takes the form of a squeezed state @xmath183| 0 \rangle \ , . \label{eq : sliver - squeezed}\ ] ] by requiring that such a state satisfy the projection equation @xmath184 , and by making some further assumptions about the nature of the state , an explicit formula for the matrix @xmath185 was found in @xcite . projectors like the sliver have many properties which are reminiscent of d - branes . this relationship between projection operators and d - branes is familiar from noncommutative field theory , where projectors also play the role of d - brane solitons @xcite ( for a review of noncommutative field theory , see @xcite ) . in the rsz model , by tensoring an arbitrary matter projector with a fixed ghost state satisfying the ghost equation of motion ( [ eq : eom - ghosts ] ) , states corresponding to an arbitrary configuration of d - branes can be constructed . particular projectors like the sliver can be constructed which are localized in any number of space - time dimensions , corresponding to the codimension of a d - brane . under gauge transformations , a rank 1 projector can be rotated into an orthogonal rank 1 projector , so that configurations containing multiple branes can be constructed as higher rank projectors formed from the sum of orthogonal rank one projectors @xcite . this gives a very suggestive picture of how arbitrary d - brane configurations can be constructed in string field theory . while this picture is quite compelling , however , there are a number of technical obstacles which make this still a somewhat incomplete story . as mentioned above , in the rsz model , many singularities appear due to the separation of the matter and ghost sectors . in the context of the matter projectors , these singularities manifest as singular properties of the projectors . for example , the sliver state described above has a matrix @xmath185 which has eigenvalues of @xmath186 for any dimension of d - brane @xcite . such eigenvalues cause the state to be nonnormalizable elements of the matter fock space . in the dirichlet directions , this lack of normalizability occurs because the state is essentially localized to a point and is analogous to a delta function . in the neumann directions , the singularity manifests as a `` breaking '' of the strings composing the d - brane , so that the functional describing the projector state is a product of a function of the string configurations on the left and right halves of the string , with no connection mediated through the midpoint . these geometric singularities seem to be generic features of matter projectors , not just of the sliver state @xcite . these singular geometric features are one of the things which makes direct calculation in the rsz model somewhat complicated , as all these singularities must be sensibly regulated . these singularities do not seem to appear in the witten theory , where the brst operator and numerically calculated solutions seem to behave smoothly at the string midpoint . on the other hand , it may be that further study of the matter projection operators and their cousins in the ghost sector which satisfy ( [ eq : eom - ghosts ] ) will lead to analytic progress on the witten theory . the work described in these lectures has brought our understanding of string field theory to a new level . we now have fairly conclusive evidence that open string field theory can successfully describe distinct vacua with very different geometrical properties , which are not related to one another through a marginal deformation . the resulting picture , in which a complicated set of degrees of freedom defined primarily through an algebraic structure , can produce different geometrical backgrounds at different solutions of the equations of motion , represents an important step beyond perturbative string theory . such an approach , where different backgrounds with different low - energy degrees of freedom arise from a single underlying formalism , is clearly necessary to discuss questions of a cosmological nature in string theory . it is clearly essential , however , to generalize from the work described here in which the theory describes distinct _ open _ string backgrounds , to a formalism where different _ closed _ string backgrounds appear as solutions to an equation of motion for a single set of degrees of freedom . clearly , it is an important goal to have a formulation of string / m - theory in which all the currently understood vacua can arise in terms of a single well - defined set of degrees of freedom . it is not yet clear , however , how far it is possible go towards this goal using the current formulations of string field theory . it may be that the correct lesson to take from the work described here is simply that there _ are _ nonperturbative formulations in which distinct vacua can be brought together as solutions of a single classical theory , and that one should search for some deeper fundamental algebraic formulation where geometry , and even the dimension of space - time emerge from the fundamental degrees of freedom in the same way that d - brane geometry emerges from the degrees of freedom of witten s open string field theory . a more conservative scenario , however , might be that we could perhaps use the current framework of string field theory , or some limited refinement thereof , to achieve this goal of providing a universal nonperturbative definition of string theory and m - theory . following this latter scenario , we propose here a series of questions aimed at continuing the recent developments in open string field theory as far as possible towards this ultimate goal . it is not certain that this research program can be carried to its conclusion , but it will be very interesting to see how far open string field theory can go in reproducing important nonperturbative aspects of string theory . some open problems : 1 . the first important unsolved problem in this area is to find an analytic description of the tachyonic vacuum . despite several years of work on this problem , great success with numerical approximations , and some insight from the rsz vacuum string field theory model , we still have no good analytic understanding of the difference between the d - brane vacuum and the empty vacuum in witten s open cubic string field theory . it seems almost unbelievable that there is not some elegant analytic solution to this problem . finding such an analytic solution would almost certainly greatly enhance our understanding of this theory , and would probably lead to other significant advances . 2 . another interesting and important unsolved problem is to find , either analytically or numerically , a solution of the witten theory describing _ two _ d25-branes . if open string field theory is truly a background - independent theory , at least in the open string sense , it should be just as feasible to go from a vacuum with one d - brane to a vacuum with two d - branes as it is to go from a vacuum with one d - brane to the empty vacuum ( or from the vacuum with two d - branes to the vacuum with one d - brane , which is essentially the same problem as going from one to none ) . despite some work on this problem @xcite , there is as yet no evidence that a double d - brane solution exists for the witten theory on a single d - brane . several approaches which have been tried ( and will be described in more detail in @xcite ) include : _ i _ ) following a positive mass field upward , looking for a stable point ; this method seems to fail because of gauge - fixing problems the effective potential often develops a singularity before reaching the energy @xmath187 , _ ii _ ) following the intuition of the rsz model and constructing a gauge transform of the original d - brane solution which is @xmath188orthogonal to the original d - brane vacuum . it can be shown formally that such a state , when added to the original d - brane vacuum gives a new solution with the correct energy for a double d - brane ; unfortunately , however , we have been unable to identify such a state numerically in level truncation . + there are several other problems closely related to the double d - brane problem . one related problem is the problem of studying a d0-brane lump solution from the tachyon field on a d1-brane wrapped on a small circle . when the circle is sufficiently small , the mass of the d0-brane is larger than that of the wrapped d1-brane . in this case , it seems much more difficult to construct the d0-brane lump solution than it is when the d0-brane has mass smaller than the d1-brane @xcite . another possibly related problem is the problem of translating a single d - brane of less than maximal dimension in a transverse direction . it was shown by sen and zwiebach @xcite ( in a t - dual picture ) that after moving a d - brane a finite distance of order of the string length in a transverse direction , the level - truncated string field theory equations develop a singularity . thus , in level truncation it does not seem possible to move a d - brane a macroscopic distance in a transverse direction . in this case , a toy model @xcite suggests that the problem is that the infinitesimal marginal parameter for the brane translation ceases to parameterize the marginal trajectory in field space after a finite distance , just as the coordinate @xmath189 ceases to parameterize the circle @xmath190 near @xmath191 . this is similar in spirit to the breakdown of feynman - siegel gauge along the tachyon potential discussed in section 6.1 . + to show that open string field theory is sufficiently general to address arbitrary questions involving different vacua , it is clearly necessary to show that the formalism is powerful enough to describe multiple brane vacua , the d0-brane lump on an arbitrary radius circle , and translated brane vacua . it is currently unclear whether the obstacles to finding these vacua are conceptual or technical . it may be that the level - truncation approach is not well - suited to finding these vacua . if this is true , however , we may need a clearer mathematical formalism for describing the theory . there is currently some ambiguity in the definition of the theory , in terms of precisely which states are allowed in the string field . level - truncation in some sense gives a regularization of , and a concrete definition to , the theory . without level truncation , we would need some more definitive mathematical tools for analyzing various features of the theory , such as the other vacua mentioned here . another open question involves the role that closed strings play in open string field theory . as has been known since the earliest days of the subject , closed strings appear as poles in perturbative open string scattering amplitudes . this was shown explicitly for witten s sft in @xcite , where it was shown that closed string poles arise in the one - loop 2-point function . if witten s theory is well - defined as a quantum theory , it would follow from unitarity that the closed string states should also arise in some natural sense as asymptotic states of the quantum open string field theory . it is currently rather unclear , however , whether , and if so how , this might be realized . there are subtleties in the quantum formulation of the theory which have never completely been resolved @xcite . both older sft literature @xcite and recent work @xcite have suggested ways in which closed strings might be incorporated into the open string field theory formalism , but a definitive resolution of this question is still not available . if it is indeed possible to encode closed string degrees of freedom in some way in the quantum open string field theory , it suggests that one could use the witten formalism in principle to not only compute general closed string scattering amplitudes , but perhaps even to address questions of closed string vacua . this is clearly an optimistic scenario , but one can imagine that the open string theory might really contain all of closed string physics as well as open string physics . this scenario is perhaps not so farfetched , as it really represents simply a lifting to the level of string field theory of the ads / cft story , where the massive as well as the massless modes are included . furthermore , the fact that , as discussed in section 5.5 , the open string diagrams precisely cover the moduli space of riemann surfaces with an arbitrary number of handles ( and at least one boundary ) , suggests that by shrinking the boundaries to closed strings , one might neatly describe all perturbative closed string amplitudes in the open string language . on the other hand , it seems quite possible that the closed string sector of the theory is encoded in a singular fashion ( like the encoding of the d - brane in the rsz vsft model ) , so that extracting the closed string physics from the open string field theory may involve such complicated manipulations that one is better off directly working with a closed string formalism . it would certainly be nice to have a clearer picture of how far one can go in this direction purely from the open string point of view . another obvious , but crucial , question is how this whole story can be generalized to superstrings . the naive witten cubic superstring field theory has technical problems arising from contact terms between picture - changing operators @xcite . it has been suggested that these problems can be resolved directly in the cubic theory @xcite . berkovits has also suggested a new non - polynomial string field theory framework which seems to deal successfully with the contact term problem , at least in the ns - ns sector @xcite . some preliminary work indicates that numerical calculations on the tachyon condensation problem for the open superstring can be carried out in the berkovits model with analogous results to those described here for the bosonic open string , although the results to date for the superstring are much more limited @xcite . it would be nice to have a more complete picture for the superstring , and some sense of how issues like the closed string question would work in the supersymmetric framework . perhaps the most important lesson we have learned from the body of work discussed in these lectures is that open string field theory is a consistent framework in which geometrically distinct open string backgrounds can arise as classical solutions of a single theory . a fundamental outstanding problem in string theory is to find a framework in which different closed string backgrounds arise in a similar fashion from some fixed set of degrees of freedom within a single well - defined theory . in principle , we would hope that all the different closed string backgrounds would arise as solutions of the equations of motion for the fundamental underlying degrees of freedom of string field theory , either by incorporating closed strings into the open string field theory framework as described above , or by working directly in some formulation of closed string field theory . it is quite challenging to imagine a single set of degrees of freedom which would encode , in different phases , all the possible string backgrounds we are familiar with . a particularly pressing case is that of m - theory . in principle , a nonperturbative background - independent formulation of type ii string theory should allow one to take the string coupling to infinity in such a way that the fundamental degrees of freedom of the theory are still actually at some finite point in their configuration space in the limit . this would lead to the vacuum associated with m - theory in flat space - time . it would be quite remarkable if this can be achieved in the framework of string field theory . given the nontrivial relationship between string fields and low - energy effective degrees of freedom , however , such a result can not be ruled out . if this picture could be successfully implemented , it would give a very satisfying understanding of how the complicated network of dualities of string and m - theory could be represented in terms of a single underlying set of degrees of freedom . i would like to thank cecs and the organizers of the school on quantum gravity for their support and hospitality , and for an extremely enjoyable summer school experience . thanks to erasmo coletti , ian ellwood , david gross , nicolas moeller , joe minahan , greg moore , leonardo rastelli , martin schnabl , ashoke sen , jessie shelton , ilya sigalov , and barton zwiebach , for many discussions and collaborations which provided the material for these lectures . thanks also to tasi 01 , where some of this material was presented prior to this school . particular thanks to barton zwiebach for suggestions and contributions to these lecture notes , which have substantial overlap with a more extensive set of lecture notes based on lectures by zwiebach and myself at tasi 01 , which will appear presently @xcite . this work was supported by the doe through contract # de - fc02 - 94er40818 . w. taylor and m. van raamsdonk , `` multiple d0-branes in weakly curved backgrounds , '' _ phys . lett . _ * b558 * ( 1999 ) , 63 , hep - th/9904095 ; `` multiple dp - branes in weak background fields , '' _ nucl . phys . _ * b573 * , 703 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/9910052 . n. berkovits , `` super - poincare invariant superstring field theory , '' _ nucl . phys . _ * b450 * ( 1995 ) , 90 , hep - th/9503099 ; `` review of open superstring field theory , '' hep - th/0105230 ; `` the ramond sector of open superstring field theory , '' jhep * 0111 * , 047 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0109100 . s. b. giddings , e. j. martinec and e. witten , `` modular invariance in string field theory , '' phys . b * 176 * , 362 ( 1986 ) . b. zwiebach , `` a proof that witten s open string theory gives a single cover of moduli space , '' commun . phys . * 142 * , 193 ( 1991 ) . d. z. freedman , s. b. giddings , j. a. shapiro and c. b. thorn , `` the nonplanar one loop amplitude in witten s string field theory , '' nucl . b * 298 * , 253 ( 1988 ) . j. a. harvey and p. kraus , `` d - branes as unstable lumps in bosonic open string field theory , '' jhep * 0004 * , 012 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/0002117 ; a. a. gerasimov and s. l. shatashvili , `` on exact tachyon potential in open string field theory , '' jhep * 0010 * , 034 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/0009103 ; d. kutasov , m. marino and g. moore , `` some exact results on tachyon condensation in string field theory , '' jhep * 0010 * , 045 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/0009148 ; d. ghoshal and a. sen , normalisation of the background independent open string field jhep * 0011 * , 021 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/0009191 ; d. kutasov , m. marino and g. moore , d. kutasov , m. marino and g. w. moore , `` remarks on tachyon condensation in superstring field theory , '' , hep - th/0010108 ; s. moriyama and s. nakamura , descent relation of tachyon condensation from boundary string phys . b * 506 * , 161 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0011002 ; a. a. gerasimov and s. l. shatashvili , `` stringy higgs mechanism and the fate of open strings , '' jhep * 0101 * , 019 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0011009 ; i. y. arefeva , a. s. koshelev , d. m. belov and p. b. medvedev , `` tachyon condensation in cubic superstring field theory , '' nucl . b * 638 * , 3 ( 2002 ) , hep - th/0011117 ; p. kraus and f. larsen , `` boundary string field theory of the d d - bar system , '' phys . d * 63 * , 106004 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0012198 ; m. alishahiha , h. ita and y. oz , `` on superconnections and the tachyon effective action , '' phys . lett . b * 503 * , 181 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0012222 ; g. chalmers , `` open string decoupling and tachyon condensation , '' jhep * 0106 * , 012 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0103056 ; m. marino , `` on the bv formulation of boundary superstring field theory , '' jhep * 0106 * , 059 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0103089 ; v. niarchos and n. prezas , `` boundary superstring field theory , '' nucl . phys . b * 619 * , 51 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0103102 ; k. s. viswanathan and y. yang , `` tachyon condensation and background independent superstring field theory , '' phys . d * 64 * , 106007 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0104099 ; m. alishahiha , `` one - loop correction of the tachyon action in boundary superstring field theory , '' phys . b * 510 * , 285 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0104164 . m. schnabl , `` wedge states in string field theory , '' jhep * 0301 * , 004 ( 2003 ) , hep - th/0201095 ; `` anomalous reparametrizations and butterfly states in string field theory , '' nucl . b * 649 * , 101 ( 2003 ) , ep - th/0202139 . j. kluson , `` marginal deformations in the open bosonic string field theory for n d0-branes , '' hep - th/0203089 ; `` exact solutions in open bosonic string field theory and marginal deformation in cft , '' hep - th/0209255 . j. a. shapiro and c. b. thorn , `` brst invariant transitions between open and closed strings , '' _ phys . _ * d36 * 432 ( 1987 ) ; `` closed string - open string transitions in witten s string field theory , '' phys . b * 194 * , 43 ( 1987 ) . p. de smet and j. raeymaekers , level four approximation to the tachyon potential in superstring jhep * 0005 * , 051 ( 2000 ) , hep - th/0003220 ; a. iqbal and a. naqvi , `` tachyon condensation on a non - bps d - brane , '' , hep - th/0004015 ;

these lectures provide an introduction to the subject of tachyon condensation in the open bosonic string . the problem of tachyon condensation is first described in the context of the low - energy yang - mills description of a system of multiple d - branes , and then using the language of string field theory . an introduction is given to witten s cubic open bosonic string field theory . the sen conjectures on tachyon condensation in open bosonic string field theory are introduced , and evidence confirming these conjectures is reviewed . mit - ctp-3341 + hep - th/0301094 * lectures on d - branes , tachyon condensation , and string field theory + * notes on lectures presented at the cecs school on quantum gravity , + valdivia , chile , january 2002 washington taylor + _ mit , bldg . 6 - 308 _ + _ cambridge , ma 02139 , u.s.a . _ + [email protected] + november 2002

hep-ph9911243

the universe is not matter - antimatter symmetric ; as shown by primordial nucleosynthesis measurements , the baryon density to entropy density ratio @xmath1 is constrained to be about @xmath2 @xcite . the necessary ingredients for a theory to explain this asymmetry are the sakharov criteria : baryon number violation , c and cp violation and non - equilibrium conditions @xcite . electroweak baryogenesis is an attractive mechanism with the best chance of verification through traditional collider experiments @xcite . the central feature of electroweak baryogenesis is spontaneous symmetry breaking . at high temperatures , the vaccum expectation value of the higgs field is zero but as the universe cools down over time , a second minimum appears in the potential at @xmath3 . the universe undergoes a phase transition , from a `` symmetric '' phase where @xmath4 to the `` broken '' phase where @xmath3 . if the phase transition is second order , which means that no potential barrier exists , then the universe is approximately in equilibrium throughout the transition and no baryogenesis can result ( since the third sakharov criterion is violated ) . if the phase transition is first order , then the phase transition occurs through quantum tunneling . as the universe cools , the probability of making a transition from symmetric to broken phase grows and when the transition occurs at a certain point in space , a bubble of broken phase forms and expands . because of its first order nature , the phase transition does not occur throughout the whole universe at the same time , resulting in non - equilibrium conditions . the baryon asymmetry is generated as the wall of the expanding bubble passes through points in space . particles in the unbroken phase close to the wall interact with the changing higgs field profile in the wall and the presence of cp - violating couplings produces source terms for participating particles . different chiralities couple with different strength when cp is violated and a difference occurs in the reflection and transmission probabilities for the two different chiralities . due to rapid gauge , yukawa and strong sphaleron interactions , the cp - violating source terms are translated into a net left handed weak doublet quark density which is finally converted into a baryon asymmetry by weak sphaleron decays . the asymmetry then diffuses through the bubble wall into the broken phase where the weak sphaleron interactions are exponentially suppressed . subsequent washout of the baryon asymmetry can therefore be kept under control provided the first order phase transition is strong enough . the standard model satisfies the three sakharov criteria , but it can not generate the required value of @xmath1 . this is because the only source of cp violation in the sm comes from the phase @xmath5 in the ckm quark mixing matrix . the baryon asymmetry is @xmath6 , but this value is suppressed by flavor mixing factors @xcite and the resulting asymmetry can not be too large . therefore , the phase transition has to be strongly first order to avoid washing out the produced baryon number , which translates into the criterion @xmath7 @xcite . however , in the standard model , the phase transition is too weakly first order to prevent washout , unless the sm higgs mass is less than 50 gev , far below the present experimental limit @xcite . the situation can be improved in the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) as the light right handed top squark contribution to the temperature dependent effective potential can push the value of @xmath8 up to acceptable values even for light higgs masses allowed by experimental searches @xcite . also , supersymmetric extensions of the sm include additional sources , which in general can further enhance the possibilty of baryon asymmetry production during the electroweak phase transition . as a result , a specific region in the mssm parameter space corresponding to a heavy cp - odd higgs boson , a light cp - even higgs boson , a light right - handed stop and a heavy left - handed stop can provide a plausible framework for electroweak baryogenesis . the cp - violating interactions in the mssm arise in the complex phases of the soft supersymmetry breaking terms in the lagrangian and in the phase of @xmath9 . since the largest contributions come from charginos and neutralinos @xcite and less importantly from the right handed stops , only the gaugino mass phases @xmath10 , @xmath11 and @xmath12 , the phase of @xmath9 and the phase of the stop trilinear parameter @xmath13 are relevant for baryogenesis . these phases have to be small , typically @xmath14 , if they are considered individually with sparticle masses @xmath15(tev ) , otherwise they induce contributions to the electric dipole moments ( edms ) of the neutron and electron exceeding experimental limits @xcite . however , these constraints can be avoided if relations among soft breaking parameters ensure cancellations of individual contributions to the edms @xcite . in the most general case this possibility leads to models with light superpartner spectra and cp - violating phases of @xmath15(1 ) @xcite . remarkably , string motivated scenarios with non - universal gaugino masses can be described where such edm cancellations occur naturally as a result of the sm embedding on five - branes @xcite . different methods of calculating the baryon asymmetry , using both classical and quantum boltzmann equations , have produced the required asymmetry , provided that @xmath16 @xcite in agreement with the experimental limits on the edms of the electron and neutron , when the other mssm phases are taken to be zero . in this paper we assume that large phases are allowed by the cancellation mechanism and at the same time the right handed stop is light enough to significantly modify the finite temperature higgs potential . all other sfermions are heavier and their contribution to the higgs potential is boltzmann suppressed . we briefly review the generation of the baryon asymmetry and the phase dependence factorization emphasizing the significance of the @xmath17 phase combination . in the large phase scenario it is then possible that the amount of baryon asymmetry generated at the phase transition is @xmath18 larger than what is observed . we solve the full quantum boltzmann equations to extract the cp violating source terms which also provides enhancement compared to classical boltzmann equations due to quantum memory effects @xcite . it is necessary to wash out some of the asymmetry ; therefore the constraint @xmath7 can be relaxed . we reevaluate the washout calculation using the effects of requiring some washout to occur and derive our limits for the light higgs mass and the right handed stop based on electroweak baryogenesis . we are able to show that even in the one - loop approximation for the temperature dependent effective higgs potential the light higgs mass upper limit can be pushed up to 115 gev without invoking negative values of the right handed stop soft breaking mass parameter @xmath19 , which can lead to color - breaking global minima and scalar potential instability @xcite . in order to calculate the baryon asymmetry of the universe , one has to start with a self - consistent computation of the cp - violating sources resulting from particle interactions with the changing higgs profile in the bubble wall . we follow the procedure of reference @xcite , which uses the closed - time - path formalism of finite - temperature field theory to derive quantum boltzmann equations for higgsinos and stops . quantum memory effects resulting from correct treatment of particle propagation in the plasma strengthen the non - equilibrium character of the the particle scattering off the bubble wall and produce larger source terms . the dominant sources of cp - violation that are relevant to the electroweak baryogenesis scenario comes from the interactions of the higgs fields with charginos and neutralinos . these interactions couple the higgsino and gaugino components of charginos and neutralinos and involve potentially large cp - violating phases originating from the mixing . for the charginos , the cp - violating lagrangian in the symmetric phase is @xmath20 the cp - violating phases @xmath21 and @xmath11 are introduced by switching to the basis of mass eigenstates in the broken phase ( see appendix ) . following the steps in @xcite to generate the cp - violating source term in the boltzmann equation , we obtain for any point @xmath22 inside the bubble wall @xmath23 where @xmath24 and @xmath25 characterizes the temporal variation of the higgs profile @xmath26 as the wall passes through point @xmath22 . @xmath27 is a temperature dependent phase - space integral ( the explicit form can be found in @xcite ) and includes information about thermal behavior of the winos and higgsinos in the high temperature plasma . the neutralino cp - violating interactions are @xmath28 + h.c.\ ] ] following the same steps as in the chargino case , we find the source term @xmath29 we can combine the source terms for the charginos and neutralinos to obtain the total source term for higgsinos @xmath30 where @xmath31 . here we emphasize that the source dependends on the full physical ( reparametrization invariant ) combinations of the phases @xmath32 and @xmath33 which factorize from the rest of the source term . in this sense our considerations are independent of the particular details going into the calculation of the higgsino thermal production rate . the phase space integrals @xmath27 and @xmath34 exhibit strong resonant behavior leading to a maximum for @xmath35 ( @xmath36 ) @xcite . in terms of the soft breaking parameters the enhancement occurs when the gaugino masses @xmath37 or @xmath38 are close in value to the higgsino mass parameter @xmath9 . for similar reasons it is easy to understand why the right handed stop contribution to the cp - violating source is always subdominant . the corresponding phase - space integral @xmath39 is typically far away from its maximum as @xmath40 in our framework and the stop source can therefore be neglected . the baryon asymmetry can be directly related to the higgsino source by solving a set of coupled diffusion equations for the higgs and higgsino , top and stop , and the first two generation quark and squark densities @xcite . we assume that strong sphaleron transitions and interactions induced by the top yukawa coupling are very fast , allowing us to reduce the number of relevant equations to the diffusion equations for higgses and higgsinos and baryon number . they can be solved analytically , with the result @xmath41 where @xmath42 is an effective diffusion constant , @xmath43 is the weak sphaleron transition rate , and @xmath44 is the velocity of the bubble wall . the coefficient @xmath45 is determined by boundary conditions to be @xmath46 where @xmath47 and @xmath48 is an effective decay constant . once the phase transition has occurred , weak sphaleron transitions tend to erase any asymmetry that has been created . in the broken phase , the weak sphaleron rate is @xcite @xmath49 where @xmath50 and @xmath51 @xmath52 is a constant in the range @xmath53 . the differential equation satisfied by @xmath54 in the broken phase is @xmath55 where c is a number of @xmath15(1 ) @xcite and we take @xmath56 absorbing the uncertainty into the uncertainty of @xmath52 and @xmath57 . solving ( 14 ) we get @xmath58 the traditional bound is found by assuming that all of the washout happens at @xmath59 , which amounts to saying that the integral in equation ( 3.5 ) is equal to the value of the integrand at @xmath59 . however , we want to evaluate the integral more carefully , and in the process derive a new bound . since we do not have an analytic formula for @xmath60 , we need to examine the integrand to see if we can make any simplifying assumptions . the sphaleron rate is proportional to @xmath61 , and we know that @xmath62 . if we approximate that @xmath63 throughout this period , then the washout rate is negligible when @xmath64 . since @xmath60 changes by about a factor of 2.5 in the temperature range from ( 0 - 100 ) gev , treating @xmath60 as a constant is a good approximation ; it is also conservative , because it will actually overestimate the washout slightly . we can make a change of variables to @xmath65 by using the relation between time and temperature , @xmath66 the integral we now have to do is @xmath67 because @xmath68 , the @xmath69 term will dominate all of the other terms . ( again , dropping the smaller terms is a conservative approximation . ) then @xmath70 inserting this expression into equation ( 15 ) , we now have an approximate expression for the observed @xmath1 : @xmath71 from which we can obtain @xmath72 by choosing a certain value for @xmath52 and @xmath73 , this equation can be solved numerically . we will do this in the next section after we have presented our numerical result for @xmath73 . once this is done , we can use the relation @xmath74 to find the lower bound on @xmath8 . this lower bound on @xmath8 can be translated into an upper bound on the light higgs mass . the one - loop finite - temperature effective potential has a form @xcite @xmath75 + { 1\over 8 } \lambda ( t ) \varphi^4.\ ] ] for the mssm with heavy decoupled stops , the potential becomes sm - like and one has @xcite @xmath76 where @xmath77 using @xmath78 , equation becomes @xmath79 the other extreme is a light right - handed stop whose temperature dependent self energy , responsible for screening of the stop interactions in the plasma , is balanced by a negative soft squared mass term @xmath80 t^2 $ ] . in such a case @xmath81 is @xcite @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the stop left - right mixing parameter . then @xmath84 when screening is present ( @xmath85 ) the temperature dependent higgs potential can be analyzed numerically . for the calculation of the baryon asymmetry , we have to adopt a model for the electroweak phase transition and evaluate @xmath86 and @xmath87 . these functions have been calculated numerically using the two - loop finite - temperature effective potential in @xcite . however , we have instead chosen to use the model of @xcite which lends itself more easily to our computation : @xmath88[\theta(x ) -\theta(x - l_w ) ] + v(l_w)\theta(x - l_w ) , \\ \beta ( x ) & = & \delta \beta [ 1 - cos({x\pi \over l_w})][\theta(x ) -\theta(x - l_w ) ] + \beta(x = 0 ) + \delta \beta \theta(x - l_w).\end{aligned}\ ] ] we have tested that the answer only weakly depends on the model used for the phase transition , so the results should be of at least the right order of magnitude . we chose the value @xmath89 = .001 which is suggested by the results of @xcite , and a value @xmath90 . the width of the wall is chosen to be @xmath91 @xcite and the typical velocity of the bubble wall is expected to be @xmath92 . for the averaged diffusion coefficient we use @xmath93 0.8 ge@xmath94 and @xmath95 1.7 gev as in @xcite . all of these parameters enter the calculation of the baryon asymmetry , however , the scaling dependence of @xmath54 on these quantities is straightforward and does not interfere with cp - violation effects . = 4.75 in figure 1 shows the baryon asymmetry @xmath1 generated as a function of @xmath96 for several combinations of @xmath21 and @xmath97 and @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 , @xmath101 . the asymmetry @xmath1 can be as large as @xmath102 for @xmath103 . let us note in passing that the signs of @xmath97 and most importantly of @xmath21 ( as it appears in both chargino and neutralino matrices ) determines the sign of @xmath54 . this fact is also demonstrated in fig . 1 since @xmath54 is positive for @xmath104 with the exception of case * e * and @xmath105 where @xmath54 turns negative being dominated by the neutralino contribution to the higgsino source . experimental determination of the magnitude _ and _ sign of the soft phases is therefore essential if the feasibility of the supersymmetric electroweak baryogenesis is to be verified . alternatively , the observed sign of @xmath54 could be used to determine the sign of @xmath21 until it can be measured other ways . = 4.75 in in order to calculate the lower bound on @xmath106 , we have to specify the the sphaleron parameters @xmath57 and @xmath52 . the non - perturbative scaling factor @xmath57 comes from numerical minimization of the sphaleron energy and was evaluated for the mssm in @xcite . the usual range depending on the coupling strengths is @xmath107 with a typical median of 1.87 . the value of @xmath52 is obtained as a functional determinant associated with fluctuations about the sphaleron and was estimated to be @xmath108 @xcite . however , when the higgs propagator uncertainty is absorbed the allowed range for kappa is @xmath109 . the required value of @xmath8 depends on the amount of dilution of the baryon number produced during the electroweak phase transition that can be allowed in order to explain the observed value of @xmath1 . inclusion of both large cp - violating soft phases and quantum memory effects leads to a substantial enhancement in the value of the produced asymmetry @xmath110 . consequently , the constraints on the strength of the first order phase transition can be softened as a function of @xmath111 . this decrease of @xmath8 is ilustrated in fig . 2 for several values of @xmath52 . the enhancement in @xmath112 coming from quantum effects ( about a factor of @xmath113 @xcite ) for typical order of magnitude values of @xmath114 is demonstrated by the intervals with the position of the left ( right ) arrow corresponding to no ( full ) quantum enhancemnent respectively . the minimal value of @xmath114 required in order to generate @xmath115 ( negligible washout ) without including the quantum effects in the sources is about @xmath116 which is in agreement with the values obtained in ref . @xcite . since we are looking for an absolute lower bound on @xmath8 , we will take @xmath73 to have its maximum value , @xmath102 . for @xmath117 , the numerical solution gives @xmath118 while the solution for @xmath119 yields @xmath120 this translates into a bound on @xmath8 of @xmath121 using the bound for @xmath119 , we can find the upper bound on the light higgs mass . for heavy stops , the upper bound is @xmath122 for light stops with no thermal screening and negligible mixing ( @xmath123 ) the upper bound is @xmath124 in figure 3 we show a plot of the upper higgs mass limit as a function of the right handed stop mass calculated in our framework . the stop mass range corresponds to variation of the right handed stop soft mass parameter @xmath125 from @xmath126 ( no thermal screening ) to @xmath127 ( strong thermal screening ) . the wide band corresponds to variation of @xmath57 and @xmath52 within their full range and the narrow central band shows the set of curves resulting from taking @xmath128 and varying @xmath52 in the full range . = 4.75 in it is important to stress that the role of large cp - violating phases is crucial in this context . if the baryon asymmetry is overproduced during the electroweak phase transition due to @xmath15(1 ) values of @xmath21 and/or @xmath97 the washout conditions ( 35 ) and ( 36 ) are less stringent then if the phases are constrained to be @xmath129 . as a result , the upper bound on the higgs mass can be as much as 15 gev higher compared to the situation where @xmath130 and no washout is allowed . it is obvious from our results that inclusion of large cp - violating phases in the calculation of the baryon asymmetry relaxes the stringent constraints on the strength of the first order transition and consequently the light higgs masses can be pushed towards larger values . even for stop masses @xmath131 gev resulting from positive values of the soft breaking parameter @xmath19 the upper bound on the higgs mass can be as high as 115 gev . our considerations are based on the one loop temperature dependent effective higgs potential evaluation . two loop corrections are known to significantly enhance the strength of the first order phase transition @xcite and further relax the upper bound on the higgs mass . in this respect our results represent a conservative estimate of the upper higgs mass limit and it is likely to be moved upward when two loop corrections are included . the upper bound on the higgs mass which still allows electroweak baryogenesis is an important issue which is becoming relevant as the higgs mass experimental lower limits are approaching 100 gev . the baryon asymmetry produced during the electroweak phase transition can succesfully explain the observed value provided there are additional degrees of freedom contributing to the finite temperature higgs potential . supersymmetric models with a light right handed stop are a very good candidate for a theory that can provide these degrees of freedom . also , the cp - violating phases appearing in the soft breaking terms of the lagrangian can supplement ( or entirely replace ) the effects of a cp - violating phase in the ckm matrix . previously it has been thought that based on the electron and neutron edm experimental limits the supersymmetric cp - violating phases have to be small and consequently there is no room for washout of the produced baryon asymmetry . this translates into stringent constraints on the higgs and right handed stop masses , often leading to problems with color breaking minima and potential stability . we have shown that once there is a possibility of cancellations among individual contributions to the edms and the cp - violating phases are allowed to be @xmath15(1 ) , the produced baryon asymmetry exceeds the observed value and the baryon density can be allowed to be diluted by a factor of @xmath132 or more . in such a case the upper higgs mass bound is increased and depending on the right handed squark mass it can go beyond 115 - 120 gev while at the same time the scalar potential is stable . this scenario opens new possibile implications for supersymmetric phenomenology . as pointed out in @xcite it is important to independently measure the cp - violating phases to correctly interpret experimental observables . if the phases are small the window for supersymmetric electroweak baryogenesis will get increasingly smaller as the lep and tevatron experiments will be pushing up the lower higgs mass limit . it is natural to expect that in the case of small phases the experimentally determined higgs mass should not be too far above 100 gev if electroweak baryogenesis is expected to work . on the other hand , if the higgs is not discovered at lep nor at the tevatron , one can expect that the cp - violating phases of the mssm are of @xmath15(1 ) if baryogenesis occurs at the electroweak phase transition , and they should be measurable if the superpartners are discovered . of course , finding a light higgs boson at lep or fermilab is consistent with having large supersymmetric soft phases . we thank jim cline for valuable discussions , a. riotto for helpful clarifications , and l. everett for suggestions and comments on the manuscript . we also thank m. quiros for correspondence . above the electroweak scale , the chargino mass matrix is @xmath133 this matrix is made real and diagonal by two complex matrices , @xmath134 where we can take @xmath135 if we switch to a basis of two - component weyl spinors , @xmath136 @xmath137 where @xmath138 are two - component spinors . in terms of @xmath138 , the interaction becomes @xmath139 above the electroweak scale , the neutralino mass matrix is @xmath140 it is made real and diagonal by the complex matrix @xmath141 , @xmath142 where we can take @xmath143 switching to the two - component spinor basis , we have @xmath144 @xmath145 @xmath146 @xmath147 resulting in the interaction @xmath148 + h.c . \nonumber\\ & + & { g^2_1 \over 2\sqrt{2 } } e^{-i(\varphi_1 + \varphi_{\mu } ) \over 2 } [ -ih^0_1 \bar{\tilde{\psi^0_3 } } p_l \tilde{\psi^0_1 } + h^0_1 \bar{\tilde{\psi^0_4 } } p_l \tilde{\psi^0_1 } - ih^0_2 \bar{\tilde{\psi^0_1 } } p_l \tilde{\psi^0_3 } - h^0_2 \bar{\tilde{\psi^0_1 } } p_l \tilde{\psi^0_4 } ] + h.c.\end{aligned}\ ] ] # 1#2#3 * b#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_nucl . * b#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_phys . _ * b#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_phys . * d#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_phys . _ * # 1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_phys . rep . _ * # 1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_mod . lett . _ * a#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_int . j. mod . phys . _ * a#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_nuovo cimento _ * # 1a * ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_rept . phys . _ * # 1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 some helpful review articles are a.g . cohen , d.b . kaplan and a.e . nelson , ann . nucl . part . science * 43 * ( 1993 ) ; m. trodden , hep - ph/9803479 ( to appear in rev . phys . , oct . 1999 ) ; a. riotto and m. trodden , hep - ph/9901362 ( to appear in ann . rev . science , dec . 1999 ) . gavela , p. hernndez , j. orloff , o. pne and c. quimbay , mod . phys . lett . * a9 * ( 1994 ) 795 ; m.b . gavela , p. hernndez , j. orloff , o. pne and c. quimbay , nucl . phys . * b430 * ( 1994 ) 382 . p. huet and e. sather , phys . rev . * d51 * ( 1995 ) 379 . kuzmin , v.a . rubakov and m.e . shaposhnikov , phys . * b155 * , 36 ( 1985 ) . k. farakos , k. kajantie , k. rummukainen and m.e . shaposhnikov , phys . lett . * b336 * ( 1994 ) 494 ; z. fodor , j. hein , k. jansen , a. jaster and i. montvay , nucl . phys . * b439 * ( 1995 ) 147 ; k. kajantie , m. laine , k. rummukainen and m.e . shaposhnikov , nucl . phys . * b466 * ( 1996 ) 189 . j.m . cline and k. kainulainen , b482 * ( 1996 ) 73 ; nucl . phys . * b510 * ( 1998 ) 88 . moreno , d.h . oaknin and m. quirs , nucl . phys . * b483 * ( 1997 ) 267 ; phys . * b395 * ( 1997 ) 234 . m. dine , p. huet and r. singleton , npb375926625 . m. losada , phys . rev . * d56 * ( 1997 ) 2893 ; g. farrar and m. losada , phys . lett . * b406 * ( 1997 ) 60 ; m. losada , hep - ph/9905441 . d. bodeker , p. john , m. laine and m.g . schmidt , nucl . phys . * b497 * ( 1997 ) 387 . b. de carlos and j.r . espinosa , nucl . b503 * ( 1997 ) 24 . m. laine and k. rummukainen , phys lett . * 80 * ( 1993 ) 5259 ; nucl . phys . * b535 * ( 1998 ) 423 . j.m . cline and g.d . moore , phys . rev . lett . * 81 * ( 1998 ) 3315 . m. carena , m. quirs , a. riotto , i. vilja and c.e.m . wagner , nucl . * b503 * , 387 ( 1997 ) . m. aoki , n. oshimo and a. sugamoto , progr . thoer . phys . * 98 * ( 1997 ) 1179 ; ibid . * 98 * ( 1997 ) 1325 . cline , m. joyce and k. kainulainen , phys . b417 * , 79 ( 1998 ) . a. riotto , nucl . phys . * b518 * , 339 ( 1998 ) ; a. riotto , phys . rev . * d58 * , 95009 ( 1998 ) . n. rius and v. sanz , hep - ph/9907460 . m. brhlik , g.j . good and g.l . kane , phys . rev . * d59 * , 115004 ( 1999 ) . moreno , m. quirs and m. seco , nucl . b526 * , 489 ( 1998 ) .

we revisit the results of recent electroweak baryogenesis calculations and include all allowed large cp - violating supersymmetric phases . if the phases are large , the resulting baryon asymmetry can be considerably larger than the observed value @xmath0 . much of the asymmetry must therefore be washed out , and we argue that the upper bound on the light higgs mass is larger than the value reported in previous work . # 1#1 # 1(#1 )

1307.3897

the bogoliubov de gennes ( bdg ) equation and the gap equation describe spatially inhomogeneous states in various kinds of condensed matter systems , such as superconductors@xcite , polyacetylene@xcite , and ultracold atomic fermi gases . the equivalent equations also appear in the mean field theory of the nambu jona - lasinio ( njl ) or the chiral gross neveu ( gn ) model in high - energy physics@xcite . + it is generally a difficult problem to obtain a self - consistent exact solution satisfying not only the bdg equation but also the gap equation , and only a few analytic examples were known so far such as the one- and two - kink ( polaron in polyacetylene ) solutions @xcite and the real@xcite and complex@xcite kink - crystals . recently , the present authors have determined the most general self - consistent solutions under uniform boundary conditions@xcite . the solutions describe @xmath0-soliton states , in which their positions are arbitrary but their phase shifts must be discretized . more recently , these solutions have been generalized to the time - dependent case@xcite . in this paper , we show several complementary results , which were absent in the previous our work . first , we prove _ directly from the gap equation _ that the self - consistent soliton solutions need to have reflectionless potentials , using the form of jost solutions derived from the riemann - hilbert approach@xcite . in the preceding works , this fact was proved by the functional derivative with respect to the reflection coefficient@xcite . our derivation will be more comprehensive because we can see directly how the reflection coefficient vanishes . next , we give the self - consistent condition of the system consisting of only right - movers , which is more used in high - energy physics . the resultant condition is consistent with the time - independent case of the recent work@xcite . ( color online ) schematic of the andreev approximation . the left ( right ) figure shows the dispersion relation before ( after ) the andreev approximation . the red dashed line represents the dispersion relation of free particles and holes and the blue solid line represents the dispersion relation of quasiparticles in the gapped system . ] the one - dimensional bdg system is given by the bdg equation and the gap equation as a self - consistent condition @xmath1 where @xmath2 with a fermi momentum @xmath3 and a magnetic field @xmath4 . in this paper we only consider the case @xmath5 . following the andreev approximation , we linearize the dispersion relation around the fermi points by substituting @xmath6 near the right and left fermi point @xmath7 and ignoring second - order derivatives ( see fig . [ fig : andapp ] ) . moving to the new unit with @xmath8 , we obtain the bdg equation for the right- and left - movers @xmath9 and the gap equation @xmath10 if we consider the system consisting of only right - movers , the fundamental equations are given by @xmath11 which corresponds to the njl or the chiral gn model@xcite . + henceforth , when we cite eq . ( x ) from our letter @xcite , we write it as eq . similarly , eq . ( y ) in the supplemental material of our letter @xcite is written as eq . we assume that the gap function @xmath12 satisfies the finite - density boundary condition ( s.2 ) . since the solution of the bdg equation for left - movers is expressed by the one for right - movers [ eq . ( l.21 ) ] , we can write down the gap equation only using the quantities of right - movers , and we always do so and omit the subscript r hereafter . + we use the same definitions of right and left jost solutions @xmath13 and the transition coefficients @xmath14 and @xmath15 in ( s.10)-(s.17 ) , where @xmath16 is a uniformizing variable defined by @xmath17 and @xmath18 [ eq . ( l.10 ) ] . in order to fit the notations with ref . @xcite , we define the scattering states @xmath19 and bound states @xmath20 using the left jost solution as follows : @xmath21 where @xmath22 is a discrete eigenvalue satisfying @xmath23 , and @xmath24 is a normalization constant of the @xmath25-th bound state ( see ref . @xcite for more detail ) . we also write @xmath26 and @xmath27 . if @xmath12 is a reflectionless potential , they reduce to ( l.18 ) and ( l.19 ) with the linear equation ( l.13 ) , or equivalently , ( s.83 ) and ( s.84 ) with ( s.79 ) . the asymptotic form of scattering states are given by @xmath28 s^{-1}\end{pmatrix}\mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}k(s)x } & \!\!(x\rightarrow-\infty ) \\ \mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}\theta\sigma_3}\left[a(s)^ * \begin{pmatrix } 1 \\[-0.75ex ] s^{-1}\end{pmatrix}\mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}k(s)x}-b(s)\begin{pmatrix}s^{-1 } \\[-0.75ex ] 1 \end{pmatrix}\mathrm{e}^{-\mathrm{i}k(s)x}\right]&\!\!(x\rightarrow+\infty ) . \end{cases } \label{eq : reful301 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the transmission and reflection coefficients are defined by @xmath29 and @xmath30 . + for a system with both right- and left - movers described by eqs . ( [ eq : bdglr01 ] ) and ( [ eq : bdglr02 ] ) , we consider the same occupation state considered in ref . @xcite . as we derive in the next section , the gap equation in the infinite - length limit is given by @xmath31\frac{\mathrm{d}s}{2\pi}\left ( \frac{m}{2}\left ( u(x , s)v(x , s)^*+r(s)^*u(x , s)^2 \right)-\frac{\delta(x)}{2s } \right)\ ! , \label{eq : gapeqforlr } \end{aligned}\ ] ] which gives the generalization of eq . ( l.27 ) with a non - vanishing reflection coefficient @xmath32 . for a system with only right - movers described by eq . ( [ eq : bdgr01 ] ) , we also consider the similar occupation state , in which the negative - energy scattering states are completely filled and positive ones are empty , and the bound states are filled partially . writing the filling rate of the @xmath33-th bound state as @xmath34 , we obtain the following gap equation in the next section : @xmath35 in this section , we derive the gap equation in the infinite - volume limit . in order to avoid the mathematical difficulty of infinite systems , we first treat the finite system with the length @xmath36 in the interval @xmath37 $ ] , and take the limit @xmath38 . to include the effect of solitons phase shifts , we consider the following `` twisted '' periodic boundary condition : @xmath39 we note , however , that the final expression eq . ( [ eq : gapssinf01 ] ) below does not depend on the detail of the boundary condition . we assume that @xmath36 is sufficiently large and hence the asymptotic form of the left jost solution ( [ eq : reful301 ] ) can be used in the substitution at @xmath40 . then , after a straightforward calculation , we obtain a set of discretized scattering eigenstates satisfying the boundary condition ( [ eq : reful303 ] ) , which is given by @xmath41 with the discretization condition @xmath42 now we move to the derivation of the gap equation in the infinite - length limit . since @xmath43 , the relation , @xmath44 , follows . when @xmath36 is sufficiently large , the wavenumbers of discretized eigenstates are given by @xmath45 with an integer @xmath0 . therefore the sum is replaced by @xmath46 thus , the contribution of positive- ( negative- ) energy scattering states to the gap equation can be evaluated as @xmath47 to obtain the last line , we have used eq . ( [ eq : reful203 ] ) and the relations @xmath48 and @xmath49 , which can be shown using the relations @xmath50 and @xmath51 valid for real @xmath52 . using the expression ( [ eq : gapssinf01 ] ) , and following the same discussion in ref . @xcite , we obtain the gap equation ( [ eq : gapeqforlr ] ) . by a similar procedure , we also obtain eq . ( [ eq : gapeqforr ] ) for a system with only right - movers . the gelfand - levitan - marchenko ( glm ) equation , which determines the kernel @xmath53 of the integral representation for the left jost solution [ eq . ( s.40 ) ] , is given by eqs . ( s.59)-(s.62 ) . if we rewrite them in the matrix form using the relation ( s.43 ) , we obtain @xmath54 with @xmath55 . following the result of the riemann - hilbert approach @xcite , the kernel @xmath53 can be written as @xmath56 by substituting eq . ( [ eq : rhk01 ] ) into the integral representation of @xmath57 [ eq . ( s.40 ) ] , and recalling the notations for scattering and bound states introduced in eq . ( [ eq : reful401 ] ) , we obtain @xmath58\mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}k(s)x } \label{eq : rhscat001 } \\ \intertext{and } \begin{pmatrix } f_j(x ) \\ s_jf_j(x)^ * \end{pmatrix}&=-\left [ \begin{pmatrix } 1 \\ s_j \end{pmatrix}+\int_{-\infty-\mathrm{i}0}^{\infty-\mathrm{i}0}\frac{\mathrm{d}\zeta}{2\pi\mathrm{i } } r(\zeta)^*\begin{pmatrix } u(x,\zeta ) \\ v(x,\zeta ) \end{pmatrix}\frac{\mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}k(\zeta)x}}{(1-\zeta s_j^{-1})}\right . \nonumber \\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad \left . + \frac{2\mathrm{i}}{m}\sum_l\begin{pmatrix}f_l(x ) \\ s_lf_l(x)^*\end{pmatrix}\frac{e_l(x)}{s_l - s_j^{-1 } } \right]e_j(x ) . \label{eq : rhbound001 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we have used the relation @xmath59 for real @xmath60 . note that eqs . ( [ eq : rhscat001 ] ) and ( [ eq : rhbound001 ] ) provide a closed set of equations for left jost solutions expressed without using the kernel @xmath53 . using the relation @xmath61 ( prop . 2 of supplemental material of ref . @xcite ) and eq . ( [ eq : rhk01 ] ) with changing variable @xmath62 , we obtain @xmath63 when @xmath64 , eqs . ( [ eq : rhscat001 ] ) , ( [ eq : rhbound001 ] ) and ( [ eq : rhgap01 ] ) reduce to eqs . ( l.19 ) , ( l.13 ) , and ( l.14 ) . using the first components of eqs . ( [ eq : rhscat001 ] ) and ( [ eq : rhbound001 ] ) and eq . ( [ eq : rhgap01 ] ) , after a little long calculation , we obtain @xmath65 for real @xmath16 . here @xmath66 is defined by @xmath67 ( see ref . @xcite for more detail ) . using eq . ( [ eq : afterlong01 ] ) and the formulae @xmath68,\quad \int\frac{(1-\zeta^2)\mathrm{d}s}{(s-\zeta)(1-\zeta s)}=\log\frac{s-\zeta}{1-\zeta s } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we obtain @xmath69+\frac{m}{2}\int_{-\infty}^\infty\frac{\mathrm{d}s}{2\pi}r(s)^*u(x , s)^2\left [ \frac{\log s^2}{\mathrm{i}\pi}-\operatorname{sgn}s \right ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] because of linear independence of @xmath70 s and @xmath71 s , we finally obtain @xmath72 for @xmath73 and any real @xmath16 , and we thus conclude the reflectionless property @xmath74 . on the other hand , for the system with only right - movers , the gap equation [ eq . ( [ eq : gapeqforr ] ) ] becomes @xmath75+\frac{m}{2}\int_{-\infty}^\infty\frac{\mathrm{d}s}{2\pi}r(s)^*u(x , s)^2\left [ \frac{\log s^2}{2\mathrm{i}\pi}+h(-s ) \right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath76 is the heaviside step function . thus the self - consistent condition is given by @xmath77 for @xmath73 and any real @xmath16 . the result @xmath78 is consistent with the recent work@xcite . in this paper , we have proved that the self - consistent soliton solutions must have reflectionless potentials . combining this paper and our previous work@xcite , we can provide the fully self - contained derivation of static self - consistent solutions under the uniform boundary condition . one of future problems is to generalize the solutions with modulated background , using the solution recently obtained in ref . @xcite . p. g. de gennes , _ superconductivity of metals and alloys _ ( westview , 1999 ) . h. takayama , y. r. lin - liu , and k. maki , phys . b * 21 * , 2388 ( 1980 ) . y. nambu and g. jona - lasinio , phys . rev . * 122 * , 345 ( 1961 ) . d. j. gross and a. neveu , phys . d * 10 * , 3235 ( 1974 ) . r. f. dashen , b. hasslacher , and a. neveu , phys . d * 12 * , 2443 ( 1975 ) . s .- s . shei , phys . rev . d * 14 * , 535 ( 1976 ) . s. okuno and y. onodera , j. phys . . jpn . * 52 * , 3495 ( 1983 ) . j. feinberg , phys . b * 569 * , 204 ( 2003 ) . s. a. brazovskii , s. a. gordyunin , and n. n. kirova , jetp lett . * 31 * , 456 ( 1980 ) . b. horovitz , phys . * 46 * , 742 ( 1981 ) . g. baar and g. v. dunne , phys . * 100 * , 200404 ( 2008 ) . d. a. takahashi and m. nitta , phys . 110 * , 131601 ( 2013 ) . g. v. dunne and m. thies , arxiv:1306.4007 . m. j. ablowitz and h. segur , _ solitons and the inverse scattering transform _ ( siam , 1981 ) . d. a. takahashi , arxiv:1304.7567 .

recently the most general static self - consistent multi - soliton solutions in bogoliubov - de gennes and chiral gross - neveu systems are derived by the present authors [ d. a. takahashi and m. nitta , phys . rev . lett . * 110 * , 131601 ( 2013 ) ] . here we show a few complementary results , which were absent in the previous our work . we prove _ directly from the gap equation _ that the self - consistent solutions need to have reflectionless potentials . we also give the self - consistent condition for the system consisting of only right - movers , which is more used in high - energy physics . pacs numbers : 03.75.ss , 67.85.-d , 74.20.-z , 11.10.kk

0910.0847

atlas ( _ a toroidal large acceptance spectrometer _ ) is one of two multi - purpose particle detector experiments designed to explore physics produced at the energy frontier with colliding proton beams at the lhc . built around one of the crossing points for lhc beams , atlas utilizes a highly granular , multi - layered detector construction , based on nearly hermetic @xmath0 geometry with respect to the collision region . the inner tracking volume , immersed in a 2 t solenoidal magnetic field , begins just a few centimeters away from the proton beam axis , extends to a radius of 1.1 meters , and is seven meters in length along the beam pipe . its basic function is to track charged particles by detecting their interactions with the detecting media at discrete points with high precision , revealing detailed information about the type of particle and its momentum . the inner tracker is comprised of three sub - detector layers , nested from the interaction point to the periphery : a silicon pixel detector , a semi - conductor tracker , and a transition radiation tracker . the operational conditions impose stringent requirements on the overall pixel detector design . the expected dose for the innermost layer is assumed to reach 500 kgy within approximately five years of lhc operation . minimum amounts of materials are used for all elements of the pixel detector in order to reduce multiple scattering and secondary interactions . being the innermost tracking sub - system , the pixel detector provides excellent impact parameter resolution and low occupancy per readout channel . its design defines the ability of atlas to identify and reconstruct secondary vertices from the decay of long - lived particles containing heavy quarks , or for flavor - tagging of jets with extremely high overall track multiplicity per event . in addition , the pixel detector provides excellent spatial resolution for reconstructing primary vertices close to the proton - proton interaction region within the detector , with multiple interactions being common at full lhc design luminosity of @xmath1 . the atlas silicon pixel detector ( fig.[fig:01_pixel_overview ] ) contains approximately 80 million readout channels in total . the mechanical detector layout consists of three concentric cylindrical layers located respectively at radii of @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 from the beam axis , and two symmetrical end caps with three disks in each , attached to both sides of the barrel region . such layout ensures the design requirement of having at least three pixel hits in the pseudorapidity range of @xmath5 . the 1744 identical pixel modules , each measuring roughly as two centimeters by six centimeters , provide a total sensitive area of @xmath6 . the modules are located on lightweight carbon support structures , with integrated @xmath7 active bi - phase evaporative cooling in place , in order to keep modules at the desired operational temperature of about @xmath8c to minimize irradiation effects and noise . the identical mechanical supports in the barrel layers are called staves . the three barrel layers are built respectively with 22 , 38 , and 52 staves , each holding 13 pixel modules . the disks are made up of sector structures , with each sector holding six modules . each complete disk is comprised of eight sectors . fully assembled , the pixel detector is sized @xmath9 in diameter by 1.3 m in longitude , weighting only 4.5 kg . a more detailed description of the atlas pixel detector can be found in @xcite,@xcite . the basic building block of the active part of the pixel detector is a pixel module ( fig.[fig:02_pixel_module ] ) that is composed of silicon sensors , front - end electronics , and flex - hybrids with integrated control circuits @xcite . all modules are functionally identical at the sensor and at the integrated circuit levels , but differ somewhat in design of the connection points for barrel modules and for disk modules . in order to achieve the nominal design specifications on impact parameter resolution of @xmath10 in the @xmath11 direction , the nominal pixel size is 50 microns in the @xmath12 direction and 400 microns in @xmath13 ( barrel region , along the beam axis ) or @xmath14 ( disk region ) . there are 46,080 pixel electronics channels in each module , being read out by 16 front - end ( _ fe _ ) chips , arranged in 2 columns of 8 chips , which are attached to the sensor pixels by either in or pbsn bump bonds . approximately 13% of the 47232 physical pixels on each sensor have slightly larger dimensions of @xmath15 to allow for a contiguous sensitive area between the fe chip boundaries in the longitudinal pixel direction . in the transverse direction , @xmath16 pixels under each of the two adjacent chips can not be covered by active pixel circuitry . these special pixels are interconnected , or _ ganged _ by the conductive traces on the sensor , with one of @xmath17 neighboring electronics pixels on top of the columns , as is illustrated in fig.[fig:03_ganging ] . the resulting hit ambiguity is resolved by the off - line pattern recognition algorithm @xcite . sensors are the sensitive part of the pixel detector used for charged particle detection , and their function can be loosely compared to microscopic solid - state ionization chambers . the atlas pixel sensors are arrays of bipolar diodes placed on a high resistivity , @xmath18 thick @xmath19-type bulk , with @xmath20 implants on the readout side , and a @xmath21 junctions on the other side of the sensor . the oxygen - enhanced silicon , so - called _ diffusion - oxygenated float zone _ ( _ dofz _ ) , is used , as it has been proven to provide more tolerance to irradiation than the standard float - zone silicon @xcite . the sensors are operated in reverse bias , with full depletion voltages ranging from @xmath22 to @xmath23 , depending on the @xmath21 junction conditions , determined by the irradiation damage . each of the fe readout chips of the atlas pixel detector contains 2880 individual readout cells . there is an analog and a digital circuitry in every pixel cell . the charge created in a pixel by a traversing charged particle is collected and amplified by in - cell charge - sensitive preamplifier in the analog part of a cell s electronics . to reduce the data volume transferred out of the detector , only those hits that produce a charge above an individually adjustable predefined threshold , are read out . the individual threshold level is set in a discriminator at the output of each cell s preamplifier . the hits above threshold are digitized before they are collected in a memory buffer at the front - end chip periphery , including the hit address , the signal s leading and trailing edge time - stamps , and the collected charge measurement determined by the _ time - over - threshold _ ( _ tot _ ) , and stored there for up to @xmath24 . pixel cells are being read - out in columns , with each double - column operated by a separate _ controller end - of - column _ ( _ ceu _ ) unit . the readout buffers with 64-hit capacity are available within each ceu . if the time - stamp of the hit matches with a level-1 trigger signal , the hit is flagged for readout and sent to the _ module controller chip _ ( _ mcc _ ) , located on a flex - hybrid printed circuit board , glued to the back of the sensor . the mcc manages _ timing , trigger and control _ ( _ ttc _ ) signals to the front end chips . the mcc can replicate a trigger signal up to 15 times , which allows for readout windows of up to @xmath25 . the flex - hybrid circuit of the pixel sensor also houses the decoupling capacitors and the _ negative thermal coefficient _ ( _ ntc _ ) sensor for temperature measurement . the barrel modules possess an additional flexible layer - a _ pigtail _ , with a connector for a low - mass cable . this low - mass cable connects modules to the _ patch panel _ ( _ pp _ ) , while the disk modules are connected without using the pigtails @xcite . in the atlas pixel detector , optical communication links are used to pass on data and control signals between modules and off - detector readout electronics . the overall schematics of the optical readout communication links is presented in fig.[fig:04_optolinks ] . the optical links are custom made , and are implemented using commercial - grade , expitaxial silicon - based pin diodes for the optical receivers as well as _ vertical cavity surface emitting laser _ ( _ vcsel _ ) arrays bare die , with custom - designed integrated readout control circuits . on - detector optical communication is realized by means of the optical link boards ( the @xmath26 ) , and via the _ back of crate _ ( _ boc _ ) communication cards on the off - detector end . the transmission of the signals from the detector modules to the opto - boards uses _ low voltage differential signaling _ ( _ lvds _ ) electrical connections . these serial connections link the mcc with the _ vcsel driver chips _ ( _ vdc_s ) and the _ digital optical receiver integrated circuits _ ( _ doric_s ) , instrumented on the opto - board pcbs made with beryllium oxide . the communication with each detector module uses individual fibers : one for the downlink and one ( or two for the b - layer boards ) for the uplinks . about @xmath27 of radiation - resilient clear optical fibers interconnect 132 boc cards located in racks inside the atlas cavern , and 272 opto - boards on the detector side . the number of connections per boc depends on the readout speed , which at the full lhc luminosity is designed to be @xmath28 for the b - layer , @xmath29 for the layer-1 and the disks , and @xmath30 for the layer-2 modules . trigger , clock , commands and configuration data travel on the downlink , while event data and configuration read - back data travel on the uplink(s ) . on the downlink , a _ bi - phase mark _ ( _ bpm _ ) encoding is used to send a @xmath30 control stream on the same channel as the @xmath31 bunch crossing clock . decoding of the bpm channel within the doric recovers both the data stream and the clock signal . the use of individual links for every module permits the adjustment of the timing used to associate the hit to a bunch crossing . the timing adjustment is accomplished by changing the delay of the transmitted signal with respect to the phase of the lhc machine reference clock received in the boc @xcite . the differential data output of the module is converted into single - ended current signals in the vdc , driving each vcsel array . output power of the laser arrays is controlled by the @xmath32 voltage , which has the same value for all channels on each opto - board . data are received by the rx plug - in of the boc on the off - detector side , where the phase between the data and the sampling clock are being adjusted for every communications channel @xcite . it was found that the opto - boards require to be maintained at a certain operating temperature for stable , error - free operation . a special system of opto - heaters was designed and integrated on - detector for that purpose . the pixel detector data are processed by 132 _ readout drivers _ ( _ rod_s ) , each being a counterpart to the bocs in the readout crates . each of the total of nine readout crates additionally houses one _ single board computer _ ( _ sbc _ ) and one _ ttc interface module _ ( _ tim _ ) that interfaces a ttc crate . this crate , organized into three partitions ( corresponding to the b - layer , the layer 1 and the layer 2 combined , and the disks ) distributes the ttc signals from the _ central trigger processor _ ( _ ctp _ ) and collects the busy signal from the rods , which , being transmitted to the ctp , can stop global atlas data acquisition . the core of each partition is a _ local trigger processor _ ( _ ltp _ ) , which can also generate the ttc signals locally . this capability is used in standalone data - taking runs . the readout of the pixel detector can be operated in the data - taking mode or in the calibration mode . in the data - taking mode , the rods receive level-1 triggers from the ttc crate and build local events from the received raw pixel hits data . these events are sent through the s - link to the _ readout system _ ( _ ros _ ) , where , depending on the level-2 trigger decision , they will be either included into the atlas event or discarded @xcite,@xcite . in the calibration mode , trigger and control signals are generated in the rods , and module events are sent through the vme bus to the sbc for further processing . since the amount of data generated in calibration procedures is ample , _ digital signal processors _ ( _ dsp_s ) are employed on the rods @xcite . the typical dsp processing tasks are histogramming , averaging and fitting the acquired module data , thus decreasing considerably the time that the calibration procedures require @xcite . the assembly of the pixel detector package was completed in spring 2007 , and the package was inserted into the center of the atlas inner detector at the end of june 2007 @xcite . the package included the completed pixel detector along with its service connections , mounted around the central section of the atlas beryllium beam pipe . shortly thereafter , physical access to the pixel detector assembly became extremely limited due to other commissioning tasks on the inner detector . during the following six months , all of the supplementary electrical services were routed and installed . a series of tests were performed to ensure proper functionality of the opto - heater control system . all the necessary electronic components for opto - board temperature control have been assembled and tuned using custom - built dummy loads . in winter of 2007/08 , the pixel opto - heater system was tested in an environment closely replicating the combined pixel operation conditions by means of using the test setup located in the experimental area nearby the atlas cavern . at the same time , in fall 2007 , the off - detector readout electronics were installed in the counting rooms in the cavern . initial connection of the pixel detector package to the cooling and electrical services , and to the off - detector readout electronics began in february 2008 , after finalizing the connections of the other atlas sub - detectors . full connection , accompanied by a series of connectivity and performance checks , was accomplished by april 2008 . a photograph of the _ patch panel 1 _ ( _ pp1 _ ) area ( only 0.5 m in diameter ) after the connections were made is shown in fig.[fig:05_pp1 ] . during the sign - off period , the cooling loops were commissioned by a variation of the heat load , using special module configurations . some loops showed instabilities when the detector was switched off ; however , after several modifications of the cooling regulation , the cooling system has been working more reliably . in the course of spring 2008 , the opto - board heater system has been deployed , connected , and tested , along with the cooling system . a cooling plant failure happened on may 1 , 2008 , which prevented the timely sign - off of the detector . three out of six compressors that generate pressure to liquefy the cooling gas did not startup correctly after a sudden stop of the plant . the magnetic mechanical couplers between the motor and the pump kept slipping for several hours , causing subsequent overheating and failure . as cracks developed in the seals of the magnetic couplers , contamination of the @xmath7 coolant with pump oil occurred , however no substantial contamination was found in the pixel detector s structures . to lower the risk of similar failures , after the incident the compressors were equipped with auxiliary sensors and in - line coolant filters @xcite . commissioning of the cooling plant was completed by the end of august 2008 , with all 88 cooling loops being operable . three cooling loops in the pixel detector end caps were found to be leaky and , after re - calibrating the respective modules , were switched off until the winter 2008/09 shutdown . further leak rate measurements were made during the shutdown . the problematic cooling loops have been repaired and were put back in operation in may 2009 . to ensure stable operation of the pixel detector , reliable and error - free optical communication has to be established with all of the pixel modules . the optical communication tuning procedure has three parts : confirmation of the downlink , verification of the uplink , and tuning of the uplink @xcite . confirmation of the downlink is accomplished by sending light from the tx plug - in to the off - detector boc card through the downlink fiber , and measuring the current of the pin diode on the opto - board . verification of the uplink is done by issuing a command to the modules to send a @xmath33 clock test pattern through the uplink fibers to the boc . at the boc , the signal is received and measured by the pin diode in the rx plug - in . tuning of the optical uplink includes adjusting threshold and delay of the rx plug - in , as well as varying the output power of the vcsels on the opto - boards . the pixel modules are called to send out a @xmath33 clock pattern to the boc . the threshold and delay values at the boc are adjusted until the clock pattern is correctly recognized ( fig.[fig:06_bocscan ] ) . the power of the emitting vcsel is required to stay within the limits set by the off - detector threshold range , at the same time providing a stable signal . certain channels , especially those in which the vcsels are exhibiting _ slow turn - on behavior _ to reach full output power . ] , require a repeated pass of tuning . in this second pass , the modules are required to send back a pseudo - random test data pattern , which is received by the rx plug - in inside the boc . new values for threshold and delay are chosen within the error - free region for these problematic channels . the on - detector vcsel power can be readjusted as well to obtain optimal link configuration . to confirm the success of the optical tuning procedure and to verify the functionality of the digital part of the fe chip , a digital pulse is injected into each readout channel after the discriminator via the integrated in - cell charge generator . if such simulated hit is correctly registered by the boc , it concludes the optical tuning procedure , as well as ensures the correct digital response of the fe chip . as it has been established in the course of tests performed in 2006 , amongst the critical parameters in reliable operation of the optical readout links is the temperature of the opto - board @xcite . thus , the additional environmental control system was introduced to keep the favorable temperature conditions of the opto - boards during detector operation in the actively cooled pixel detector surroundings . the total of 48 miniature resistive heater strips , paired with the ntc sensors , were attached to the opto - boards to keep their temperature constant in the course of operation and ensure the stability of the communication link parameters . it is desirable to keep the temperature of the opto - boards and adjacent components as low as possible in order to reduce adverse irradiation effects . therefore as soon as the active cooling became available , optical links were tuned at @xmath34c . since several channels have exhibited a slow turn - on behavior , it was decided to increase the operating temperature of all opto - boards to @xmath35c @xcite . at the moment , about 97% of the optical connections are being tuned using the above calibration procedure , while a few remaining links require individual approach @xcite . the analogue performance of a pixel is measured using an injection circuit , which injects a series of pulses of known charge into the preamplifier via in - cell integrated circuitry . by repeating the injection and scanning the range of applied charge , one can measure the discriminator threshold and the noise level of the channel . this so - called _ threshold scan _ , is also employed for validation of the threshold tuning @xcite . the current tuning algorithm injects a charge exactly at the aimed threshold and then alters the settings of the readout channel in the front - end chip until the occupancy of that pixel is 50% . while the most probable charge deposition in a pixel from a _ minimally ionizing particle _ ( _ mip _ ) is @xmath36 , the thresholds are being tuned pixel by pixel to the target value of @xmath37 . the resulting turn - on curve is convoluted with the noise in the pixel , which is approximated by a gaussian distribution , and then the resulting dependence is fitted to an error function . the mean of the fitted curve corresponds to the threshold value of @xmath38 , and the curve width reflects the noise . with the present threshold - tuning algorithm , it is possible to tune over 95% of the detector , having a threshold dispersion of just @xmath39 ( fig.[fig:07_thresholds ] ) . the threshold - to - noise ratio was measured to be close to 24 for most of the pixels for the target threshold of @xmath37 , whereas for the few pixels in the inter - chip region it was approximately 13 , with twice as much noise observed in them , resulting from having higher input capacitance due to being interconnected , or _ ganged _ @xcite,@xcite . after having balanced the noise threshold setting of the discriminator , another part of tuning procedure adjusts the preamplifier gain in order to respond uniformly to a certain input charge by regulating the preamplifier feedback current . the preamplifier uses a programmable current in the feedback loop so that the tot is a nearly linear function of the deposited charge . for each hit above threshold , the time - stamp of when the leading and falling edges of the signal cross the threshold are registered , in units of bunch crossings . the difference between the time - stamps of the falling and the leading edges is defined as time over threshold . the leading edge time stamp defines the bunch crossing a hit is registered in . by injecting the @xmath40 mip - like charge into the preamplifier , the pixel response is tuned to correspond to tot of 30 bcs @xcite,@xcite,@xcite . noise occupancy is measured by reading out the pixel detector randomly , with no reconstructed tracks observed . for this purpose , stand - alone data taking runs with a trigger frequency of a few khz are used . after stable data taking is achieved and data samples recorded , noise occupancy per pixel is calculated and the noisy pixels map , containing only the pixels , which had occupancy greater than @xmath41 , is created . presently , the map contains less than 5000 of these hot " pixels , which are being masked . after the masking , the noise occupancy dropped by a factor of 20 , as shown in fig.[fig:08_masking ] , to about 0.5 hits per event per beam crossing for the entire pixel detector @xcite . this corresponds to about @xmath42 noise occupancy per pixel per bc for the whole detector , or less than one noise hit per event in @xmath43 channels . the reduction of noise by applying the noise mask , and the stability of the results over time confirms the fact that most of the noise comes from the same pixels . the noise mask is being updated on a regular basis , and after masking only 0.006% of the pixels , the noise level is very low the pixel detector was included in combined data taking with the rest of atlas for the first time on september @xmath44 @xcite . upon the initial adjustment of trigger timing , first cosmic muon tracks through the pixel volume were recorded . when single beam was first injected into the lhc on september @xmath45 , the pixel detector did not collect data , as it was operated with hv turned off and the preamplifiers disabled to protect the fe chips from possible large charge depositions due to unstable beam configuration conditions . after the lhc incident of september @xmath46 , taking data with cosmic muons became the first priority and the only source for physics data suitable for further detector calibration and alignment . the results presented in this paper are based on a data sample collected during combined atlas cosmic running in fall of 2008 . during this running period , over 400,000 cosmic muon tracks passing through the pixel detector have been recorded . cosmic data have been collected with the solenoidal magnetic field switched on and off . the collected dataset was used to finalize the commissioning of the pixel detector as well as to improve the detector alignment . the number of tracks with at least one pixel hit as a function of time , as well as the fraction of pixel modules included in data taking , is shown in fig.[fig:09_running ] . the level-1 triggers for the pixel detector were provided by the _ resistive plate chambers _ ( _ rpc_s ) of the atlas muon spectrometer . once a trigger was being received from the ctp , a wide readout window of @xmath47 ( or 8 bc ) was used by the pixel modules to ensure the readout of the entire detector , even if some parts of it were not timed correctly . in order to increase the dynamic range of the signal , the maximum front - end readout latency of 255 bc was used , which required delaying of the trigger signals from the ctp . before the leaky cooling loops were disabled , about 96% of the detector modules were being operated in the data - taking mode . the commissioning of the level-2 trigger allowed for the track rate through the pixel volume to reach 0.3 hz @xcite . figure [ fig:10_trackrate ] shows the rate of tracks with at least one pixel hit as a function of day for the running between september @xmath48 and october @xmath49 , 2008 . the rate was increased substantially in early october , mostly due to significant improvements in the rpc trigger timing and the use of the track triggers at the level-2 . in november , a new l1 trigger of the trt was developed , improving the track rate further to about @xmath50 , which is consistent with the anticipated rate of tracks crossing the detector . precision direction , comparing the aligned detector geometry to the unaligned production geometry . while the result is statistically limited , the aligned geometry approaches the ideal , simulated alignment.,width=302 ] alignment is a crucial task for ensuring the correct interpretation of detector readout , which is important for successful data collection . the general approach to the alignment procedure on the most basic level is concerned with the minimization of the residuals , which are the differences between the real detector geometry with respect to the ideal designed geometry . these differences are caused by slight production imperfections and assembly tolerances , and have to be properly accounted for . one of the most characteristic plots pertaining to pixel detector alignment ( fig.[fig:11_resolution ] ) illustrates one of the latest results of the alignment applied to the barrel of the pixel detector , showing that the obtained aligned geometry is getting very close to the simulated idealistic prediction with respect to the uncorrected physical detector , while the mean of the residual misalignment is consistent with zero . the obtained spatial resolution result of @xmath51 in the @xmath11 precision direction is statistically limited by the present size of the cosmic data sample . detailed studies of the pixel barrel geometry are ongoing , in the course of which a significant bowing effect with a _ sagitta _ parameter of up to @xmath52 has been found in a few staves , and has been correctly accounted for in the detector offline profile @xcite . currently , there are several algorithms in place to provide calculation and correction for the pixel detector mis - alignment . the particulars of various alignment procedures deserve much more scrupulous attention , and are reviewed in more detail elsewhere @xcite . the cosmic ray data sample is being extensively analyzed to produce additional calibration measurements . in particular , the alignment improvements reflect on the overall physics performance of pixel detector . the efficiency of attaching hits on tracks in all active modules in the pixel barrels is shown in fig.[fig:12_track_efficiency ] . it is measured to be about 99.8% in all three layers using the official alignment algorithm . the disabled modules are not being included in the denominator of the efficiency calculation ratio . another measurement essential to performance validation is the measurement of the lorentz angle . the lorentz effect produces a systematic shift between the position of the signal induced on the electrodes and the position of the track . while this shift is practically absorbed by the alignment correction , the knowledge of the lorentz angle will help understanding the alignment corrections and their time dependence . in addition , the lorentz effect is expected to change the angular dependence of the spatial resolution . figure [ fig:13_lorentz_angle ] presents the plot of the pixel cluster width versus the incidence angle of the track , corresponding to the two different values of the solenoidal magnetic field . the minima of these distributions occur at the lorentz angle , which depicts the deflection of the charge carriers in the magnetic field . this angle is consistent with zero when the magnetic field is off , and is about @xmath53 for the full magnetic field strength of @xmath54 . this result is consistent with the simulated expectation within 5% @xcite . after an intensive commissioning effort and cosmic - ray data taking period over the year 2008 , ( more than 96% of ) the atlas pixel detector is now tuned and calibrated . the cosmic - ray data sample is being used for further improvement in calibration , fine - tuning of the most recent simulations , and ongoing studies of the detector performance . after the successful upgrade and additional commissioning work done on the cooling system , the entire detector has been re - calibrated . starting june @xmath46 , 2009 , more cosmic - ray data are being collected . with a pixel hit efficiency over 99.7% in the enabled modules , noise occupancy at the level of @xmath55 , and reaching towards a spatial hit resolution on the order of @xmath56 in the @xmath11 precision direction in the barrel layers , the atlas silicon pixel detector is performing well up to the expectations . the pixel detector is ready to collect physics data produced by beam collisions in the lhc , to be delivered by the end of 2009 . the presented material and this article are the result of numerous individual contributions made by many members of the atlas pixel detector collaboration and the atlas inner detector group . i would like to kindly thank all of them . 10 m. s. alam _ et al . _ [ atlas collaboration ] , `` atlas pixel detector : technical design report , '' cern - lhcc-98 - 13 ( 1998 ) . g. aad _ et al . _ [ atlas collaboration ] , `` atlas pixel detector electronics and sensors , '' jinst * 3 * , p07007 ( 2008 ) .

the atlas pixel detector is the innermost detector of the atlas experiment at the large hadron collider at cern . with approximately 80 million readout channels , the atlas silicon pixel detector is a high - acceptance , high - resolution , low - noise tracking device . providing the desired refinement in charged track pattern recognition capability in order to meet the stringent track reconstruction requirements , the pixel detector largely defines the ability of atlas to effectively resolve primary and secondary vertices and perform efficient flavor tagging essential for discovery of new physics . being the last sub - system installed in atlas by july 2007 , the pixel detector was successfully connected , commissioned , and tested _ in situ _ while meeting an extremely tight schedule , and was ready to take data upon the projected turn - on of the lhc . since fall 2008 , the pixel detector has been included in the combined atlas detector operation , collecting cosmic muon data . details from the pixel detector installation and commissioning , as well as details on calibration procedures and the results obtained with collected cosmic data , are presented along with a summary of the detector status .

astro-ph9811311

the cosmic microwave background explorer ( cobe ) detection of large angle cmb anisotropy ( smoot et al . 1992 ) has sparked a drive to measure the anisotropy on smaller angular scales with the goal of determining crucial information about the density and expansion rate of the universe , the nature of dark matter , and the spectrum of primordial density perturbations . cobe dmr observations were basically unaffected by extragalactic foreground sources ( banday et al . 1996 , kogut et al . 1994 ) due to the large beam size ( @xmath1 fwhm ) . because the contribution of a point source increases with the inverse of the beam area , observations at higher angular resolution are more sensitive to extragalactic foregrounds , including radio galaxies , bright infrared galaxies ( gawiser & smoot 1997 ) , high - redshift infrared galaxies ( blain et al . 1998 , gawiser , jaffe , & silk 1998 , hereafter gjs ) , and the sunyaev - zeldovich effect from galaxy clusters ( aghanim et al . 1997 ) . estimates of extragalactic foreground confusion are critical as many ground - based , balloon - borne , and satellite experiments ( map , planck surveyor ) plan to study cmb anisotropies at angular scales from 5@xmath2 to @xmath3 , and preliminary results are already available ( e.g. netterfield et al . 1997 , scott et al . 1996 ) . to evaluate the impact of known radio sources on cmb anisotropy observations , we use flux data from a variety of catalogs ( see @xmath42 ) , including recent measurements , to construct models of source spectra as a function of frequency . we analyze simulated skymaps at frequencies from 10 to 300 ghz to determine the expected contribution of radio galaxies to foreground confusion of cmb temperature anisotropy . this information will be useful when choosing frequencies and regions of the sky to observe cmb fluctuations on small angular scales . this work represents a significant improvement over previous efforts ( toffolatti et al . 1995 , 1998 , franceschini et al . 1989 ) which depended upon galactic evolution models to predict the contribution of simulated radio sources at microwave frequencies . our catalog contains detailed observations of known sources and hence can be used to make a spatial template for masking out their emission , and we believe that this phenomenological approach will lead to greater accuracy in predicting source counts and the overall level of foreground anisotropy . the discrete radio sources used in this project were compiled from a number of separate catalogs . our current catalog includes flux measurements and their corresponding errors at multiple frequencies for 2207 sources . we have focused our attention on obtaining all available radio observations at millimeter and sub - millimeter wavelengths , resulting in 5766 observations of 758 different sources at 90 ghz , 890 observations of 229 different sources from 100 - 200 ghz , and 2628 observations of 309 different sources at frequencies above 200 ghz . the sources are roughly isotropic in distribution , except for a significantly greater number of sources in the northern celestial hemisphere due to the anisotropic distribution of radio telescopes on earth . in addition , there are noticeably fewer observations within @xmath5 of the galactic plane and the celestial north pole due to the difficulty of observing extragalactic radio sources in those locations . our catalog includes the full - sky 5 ghz - selected 1 jy sample of khr et al . we add high - frequency ( @xmath6 ghz ) measurements ( steppe et al . 1988 , 1992 , 1995 ; tornikoski et al . 1996 ; kreysa 1998 ; antonucci , barvainis , & alloin 1990 ; beichman et al . 1981 ; chini et al . 1989 ; gear et al . 1994 ; edelson 1987 ; holdaway , owen , & rupen 1994 ; knapp & patten 1991 ; landau et al . 1980 , 1983 , 1986 ; lawrence et al . 1991 ; nartallo et al . 1997 ; owen et al . 1978 ; owen , spangler , & cotton 1980 ; stevens , robson , & holland 1996 ; chandler 1995 ; vla memo#193 ) and centimeter - wavelength observations ( herbig and readhead 1992 ; patnaik 1992 ; wiren et al . 1992 ; stanghellini et al . 1997 ; perley 1982 ; cotton 1980 ; aller et al . 1985 ; vla calibrator manual ) . an updated version of the catalog with more detail will be described by gawiser , sokasian , & smoot ( 1998 , hereafter gss ) . some extragalactic radio sources have complex spectra which can not be approximated by simple functional forms due to emission from both compact and extended structures which dominate at different frequencies . in most radio galaxies , the emission comes from radio lobes located symmetrically around the core . the dominant emission mechanism , synchrotron , can be well approximated by a simple power law , @xmath7 with a flux spectral index , @xmath8 , typically between 0.5 and 1.0 ( platania et al . 1997 ) . some radio sources have compact active nuclei which generate flat - spectrum radio emission . the spectra of these sources can be inverted ( @xmath9 ) for most of the radio frequency range due to self - absorption of the lower frequency emission . attempts to fit the observational data have yielded a variety of results . the central engine of a typical active galaxy may consist of a supermassive black hole surrounded by an accretion disk and accelerating a jet of relativistic particles perpendicular to the disk plane ( e.g. urry & padovani 1991 ) . bttcher et al . ( 1997 ) proposed a model in which the inverted spectrum of ngc 3031 is assumed to be the emission of a jet component , becoming optically thin to the radio emission of a monoenergetic pair plasma at decreasing frequencies as it moves outward and expands . for sources which lack direct high - frequency observations , we avoid trying to determine the nature of the emission mechanism instead , we use a phenomenological approach based on the expectation that the spectra of most radio sources approach power law behavior at frequencies higher than @xmath10 ghz ( verschuur & kellerman 1988 ) . this power law may then be used to extrapolate the spectrum to typical cmb observation frequencies . a previous phenomenological approach ( tegmark & efstathiou 1996 ) extrapolated 1.4 ghz source counts by assuming flat - spectrum emission for all sources . our method has the advantages of using the actual source locations , which can be turned into templates for masking the brightest pixels on the sky . to determine if there is any spectral index clustering , we use sources that have been measured near 1.4 , 10 , and 90 ghz and plot each source s spectral index from 1.4 ghz to 10 ghz versus its index from 10 ghz to 90 ghz in figure 1 . there is a vague clustering of bright sources ( circles ) consistent with the notion that the brightest sources selected at low frequencies tend to have steep spectra . the overall scatter of source spectra in figure 1 shows that it is wrong to categorize radio sources into template spectra or a narrow spectral index range . this motivates us to fit the spectra of each source individually . to determine the frequency beyond which a power law ( a line on a log - log plot ) can be fitted to the spectra of a given source , we use an iterative model which starts with the best - fit line to the three highest frequency data points and repeatedly includes the next highest frequency data point to the set to which it fits a line . the fitting stops when the reduced @xmath11 starts to get worse or becomes acceptable ( @xmath12 ) . there is little evidence that inverted spectra are common past 30 ghz ( steppe et al . 1995 , stanghellini et al . 1997 ) , so we set the few inverted ( @xmath13 ) high - frequency spectra in the catalog to flat ( @xmath14 ) spectra . these inverted spectra appear to result from variable sources being observed at different epochs at different frequencies , and we find that most of the sources with @xmath15 in figure 1 based on their mean 10 and 90 ghz fluxes are better fit by an @xmath13 power - law when all observations are taken into account . the average high - frequency spectral index was 0.5 with 27% of the sources in our catalog having steep spectra ( @xmath16 ) , and 37% having flat spectra ( @xmath17 ) . to check the accuracy of this technique , we ran our extrapolation method on sources with observations at 90 , 150 , and 230 ghz while ignoring the observations above certain frequencies and then compared the measured fluxes with the extrapolated fluxes . the results ( table 1 ) show that the extrapolation method works best when there is at least one measurement at 20 ghz or greater , as expected since many spectra become power - law past 5 ghz . table 1 shows that on average we overpredict the flux at 90 ghz by a factor of 1.6 , even when measurements above 20 ghz are used . however , the median such error factor is only a factor of 1.1 overestimate , so we have roughly an equal number of over- and under - estimates . this is no longer the case at 230 ghz , where even the median error factor is 1.9 ; our extrapolation method is overestimating the typical flux due to flat spectra falling off to more typical synchrotron spectra at frequencies around 100 ghz ( gear et al . it is difficult to predict how far this fall - off will last , as thermal emission from low levels of dust in these radio - bright galaxies are expected to dominate their spectra by 500 ghz , except for the bl lacs which have flat spectra up to infrared wavelengths ( knapp & patten 1991 , chini et al . 1989 , landau et al . we therefore only trust our extrapolation in the range that has been tested , up to a maximum frequency of 300 ghz . as the radio sources that have been observed at 30 - 300 ghz were selected at lower frequencies for brightness and flat spectra , our errors are only good estimates for this type of radio sources . this selection effect is not a great concern , however , as those are exactly the type of radio sources that threaten cmb anisotropy observations . when interpolation is required , we use a cubic spline which passes through the mean fluxes at the observed frequencies . we visually inspected all 2207 sources to check the algorithm and eliminate any serious errors or outliers . for planned cmb anisotropy experiments , an additional concern is that the flat - spectrum radio sources can vary by up to a factor of ten in flux since their emission comes from a compact , active core . typical variations occur on timescales of one month to one year , although the overall spectrum shape is often preserved for a decade or longer ( tornikoski et al . we use the scatter in the observed fluxes of a source at each frequency to estimate the typical range of variability , which yields an error bar on the source s flux at that frequency about the mean of all observations . because the variations are not periodic , there is little more that can be done , unless sources are observed nearly simultaneously at higher resolution and nearby frequencies . gss looks at the issue of variability in detail , including the possibility of extrapolating long - term drifts in source flux to the next epoch of observation . radio sources are typically 4 - 7% polarized , and this polarization is variable ( nartallo et al . 1997 ) , so radio - source foreground subtraction will be an important consideration for cmb polarization observations as well . we use the fitted spectra to predict the microwave flux of each radio galaxy in jy ( @xmath18 jy @xmath19 w / m@xmath20/hz ) . to convert from flux @xmath21 to antenna temperature @xmath22 , we use @xmath23 where @xmath24 is boltzmann s constant , @xmath25 is the wavelength , and @xmath26 is the effective beam size of the observing instrument . the antenna temperature of the cosmic microwave background radiation , which has a thermodynamic temperature of t@xmath27k , is given at frequency @xmath28 by @xmath29 defining @xmath30 . fluctuations in antenna temperature caused by point sources will appear as thermodynamic temperature fluctuations in the cmb according to @xmath31 the intrinsic @xmath32 of the cmb found by cobe is @xmath33 and is expected to vary between that and @xmath34 at the angular resolutions considered here . an analysis of source counts indicates that the northern celestial hemisphere subset of our catalog appears to be complete down to an extrapolated flux of 1.0 jy at 90 ghz while the southern hemisphere is incomplete below 2.0 jy at 90 ghz . for the purposes of statistical analysis we have concentrated on the northern hemisphere where we appear to have measurements of the 200 brightest sources in the hemisphere . we can not rule out the existence of an unrelated population of sources peaking around 90 ghz which are not bright at lower frequencies , as 90 ghz observations have only been made for sources selected at frequencies below 10 ghz ( this hypothetical source population is limited by gjs ) . the brightest sources will dominate the anisotropy unless they are masked , because uncertainty in their exact fluxes makes subtraction highly inaccurate . after masking , the brightest remaining sources will dominate unless non - poissonian clustering becomes appreciable . toffolatti et al . ( 1998 ) have shown that non - poissonian clustering is not expected to make an important contribution to the foreground anisotropy from radio sources . to simulate observations , we convolve all sources on pixelized sky maps ( twice oversampled ) of resolution varying from @xmath35 to @xmath5 at frequencies between 10 and 300 ghz . the information contained in these sky maps can be used to choose regions for observation ( smoot 1995 ) and pixels to be masked during data analysis . figure 2 shows a 30@xmath36 resolution skymap at 100 ghz ; pixels at the maximum of the color table should be masked . to avoid underestimating the anisotropy and to reduce the possibility of residual galactic contamination , we use only the portion of each skymap which covers galactic latitudes @xmath37 and corresponds to the northern celestial hemisphere to produce estimates of @xmath32 . figure 3 shows a summary of our results for several relevant instrument resolutions . the inverse relationship between anisotropy and fwhm arises due to the combined effects of beam convolving and pixelization . the exact level of oversampling causes a small change in the measured anisotropy , but the 1/fwhm behavior should hold for extrapolation to smaller resolutions ( see gjs ) . we also analyze @xmath38 in the northern hemisphere based on only the 758 sources with 90 ghz measurements . the resulting rms @xmath38 at 90 ghz with a fwhm of @xmath39 is @xmath40 which dominates the anisotropy since the rms @xmath38 from extrapolating the spectra of the other 1449 sources amounts to only @xmath41 . this indicates that we have flux measurements for the vast majority of bright 90 ghz radio sources . refregier , spergel , & herbig ( 1998 ) find that the @xmath42 source detection limit for @xmath43 map pixels will be 2 jy at 90 ghz . we have 108 sources in our catalog which have been observed to be brighter than 2 jy at 90 ghz at least once , but only 42 sources have a weighted average flux that high , and a total of 52 sources are predicted to be brighter than 2 jy at 90 ghz . we estimate that there will be 40 - 50 radio sources on the sky brighter than 2 jy at 90 ghz . at the 0.4 jy level , toffolatti et al . ( 1998 ) predict roughly twice as many sources as we do , but our prediction falls within their range of uncertainty . as the source counts we predict at this level based on the northern celestial hemisphere should be nearly complete , we recommend a slight recalibration of the galaxy evolution models used by toffolatti et al . , although a factor of two represents remarkable agreement for such different approaches . table 2 lists the expected level of anisotropy and the number of detected radio sources in map and planck channels if this type of straightforward @xmath42 source detection and subtraction is performed . since the 90 ghz map channel will have a resolution close to @xmath44 we expect a @xmath42 source detection limit of 1 jy at 90 ghz . these detected sources represent a list of the few hundred brightest radio sources in the sky at each frequency . the anisotropy levels are shown in figure 3 . the level of source confusion drops if the brightest sources ( @xmath45 ) are subtracted . table 3 shows how the expected level of temperature anisotropy from radio sources varies with cutoff level , where we use our catalog to obtain prior information on which pixels are expected to contain sources at a given flux level and then mask those pixels . while all @xmath42 pixels can be masked without such prior information if the cmb anisotropies are assumed to follow a gaussian distribution , it is impossible to remove all @xmath46 pixels without crippling the analysis . the actual improvements from masking all pixels expected to contain @xmath46 sources may be less than indicated , unfortunately , due to the effect of incompleteness in our catalog . gss attempt to fill in this incompleteness using full - sky catalogs at 5 ghz . if we were to settle for making the southern celestial hemisphere as complete as the northern is now , we could create a mask for all sources expected to contribute at the 3@xmath47 level , which is enough to make a significant reduction in radio source contamination versus 5@xmath47 subtraction alone . spectral analysis of bright radio sources indicates that their spectra are complex and can not in general be categorized into template spectra or single power - laws . the results from our analysis of extrapolation errors suggest that our phenomenological approach of fitting a power law to the high - frequency end of each spectrum is a reasonable model to use to extrapolate radio sources to microwave frequencies . although subject to systematic errors on a galaxy - by - galaxy basis , we expect our overall extrapolation results to be accurate to within a factor of two at 90 ghz . our analysis of foreground confusion from extragalactic radio sources indicates that they contribute negligibly to cobe resolution observations of the cmb , consistent with the conclusion of banday et al . however , they do become problematic at higher resolution . our results set a lower limit on the anisotropy and provide a list of the brightest sources in the sky which can be used to mask pixels in future high - resolution cmb observations . the contribution of extragalactic radio sources to cmb anisotropy is comparable at 200 ghz to that of bright extragalactic infrared sources ( gawiser & smoot 1997 , toffolatti et al . our current results indicate a valley at around 200 ghz where the anisotropy from radio sources is a minimum ; adding in the contribution from infrared - bright galaxies should move that valley towards 150 ghz . the results of this investigation motivate an expansion of our catalog so that sources which will contribute to anisotropies on the 1@xmath47 level can be masked . it is clear that the current generation of cmb anisotropy experiments must pay close attention to the possibility of radio point source contamination at all frequencies . masking pixels which contain bright radio galaxies should reduce this foreground to a manageable level . we thank cameron murray and chris witebsky for their diligent work in compiling the radio catalog , jon aymon for writing idl display routines , tom herbig and chris witebsky for providing us with useful software , ernst kreysa , harri terasranta , merja tornikoski , and esko valtaoja for providing us with recent data pre - publication , mark holdaway for helping us obtain the mma memo , and bruce partridge , malcolm bremer , david spergel , alex refregier , alastair edge , andrew blain , jason stevens , doug finkbeiner , and jose luis sanz for helpful conversations . a.s . acknowledges the support of an lbnl summer research fellowship . e.g. acknowledges the support of an nsf graduate fellowship . this work is supported in part by the doe contract no . de - aco3 - 76sf00098 through lawrence berkeley national laboratory and nasa long term space astrophysics grant no . 014 - 97ltsa award # nag5 - 6552 . frequency tested & frequencies ignored & avg . extrapolation error & avg . error factor + 90 ghz & @xmath48 2 ghz & 209 % & 2.5 + 90 & @xmath48 10 & 148 & 2.3 + 90 & @xmath48 20 & 133 & 2.0 + 90 & @xmath48 90 & 92 & 1.6 + 150 & @xmath48 90 & 94 & 1.5 + 230 & @xmath48 90 & 250 & 3.2 + frequency ( ghz ) & fwhm & source detection limit & # detected & @xmath49 + map 20 & 56@xmath36 & 1.4 jy & 186 & @xmath50 + 30 & 41 & 1.2 & 216 & @xmath51 + 40 & 28 & 0.9 & 265 & @xmath52 + 60 & 21 & 1.1 & 168 & @xmath53 + 90 & 13 & 1.0 & 161 & @xmath54 + planck 30 & 33 & 0.9 & 290 & @xmath55 + 44 & 23 & 0.8 & 285 & @xmath52 + 70 & 14 & 0.6 & 360 & @xmath53 + 100 & 10 & 0.6 & 304 & @xmath56 + 143 & 7 & 0.6 & 323 & @xmath57 + 217 & 5 & 0.3 & 533 & @xmath58 + 353 & 4.5 & 0.2 & 644 & @xmath57 + 545 & 4.5 & 0.4 & 289 & @xmath50 + 857 & 4.5 & 0.7 & 125 & @xmath59 + threshold ( jy ) & # sources above threshold & @xmath32 + none & 0 & @xmath60 + 2 ( 10 @xmath47 ) & 49 & @xmath61 + 1 ( @xmath42 ) & 161 & @xmath62 + 0.6 ( @xmath63 ) & 346 & @xmath64 + 0.2 ( @xmath46 ) & 940 & @xmath65 +

we estimate the contribution of extragalactic radio sources to fluctuations in sky temperature over the range of frequencies ( 10 - 300 ghz ) used for cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) anisotropy measurements . cmb anisotropy observations at high resolution and low frequencies are especially sensitive to this foreground . we have compiled a catalog of 2207 bright radio sources , including 758 sources with flux measurements at 90 ghz . we develop a method to extrapolate the source spectra and predict skymaps of extragalactic radio sources at instrument resolutions of @xmath0 fwhm . our results indicate that the brightest radio sources will dominate microwave anisotropy for a wide range of resolutions and frequencies . our skymaps predict the location and flux of the brightest radio sources at each frequency , making it straightforward to develop a template for masking the pixels containing them . this masking should be sufficient to protect high resolution cmb anisotropy observations from unacceptable radio source confusion . epsf.sty submitted to the _ astrophysical journal _

quant-ph9502020

the only known method to exchange secret information through a communication channel in a proven secure way , is to use the so - called one - time pad ( for a good review of both classical and quantum cryptography , see @xcite ) . in this technique , the data , which is represented by a string of bits , is combined with a random string of bits of equal length called the key , and is then sent through the communication channel . the randomness of the key ensures that the encoded message is also completely random and as such totally unintelligible to a potential eavesdropper . the safety of the transmission is thus entirely dependent on the safety of the key , which has to be secret and shared just by both legitimate users . moreover , safety can be guaranteed only if the key is used once , and then discarded . the problem is therefore how to distribute the random key between users in a secure way . classically , the only possibility is either through personal meetings , or through a trusted courier , which makes the technique rather expensive , and not practical for many applications . therefore , most practical cryptographic systems nowadays rely on different principles @xcite . however , these can not really _ guarantee _ the safety of the transmission , but rely on a weaker property of the system , namely that it is _ computationally _ safe . this means that the system can be broken in principle , but that the computation time required to do so is too long to pose a real threat . the main problem with this approach is that its safety could be destroyed by technological progress ( faster computers ) or mathematical advances ( faster algorithms or future theoretical progress in computation theory ) . another technique , whose safety does not rely on computing abilities , and which was only recently developed , is quantum cryptography ( for an introduction , see @xcite ) . in quantum cryptography , the two users , generally referred to as alice ( the sender ) and bob ( the receiver ) , have two kinds of communication channels at their disposal . one is a classical public channel , which can be overheard by anybody , but can not be modified ; and the second is a quantum channel , whose main characteristic is that any attempt at eavesdropping will create errors in the transmission . the quantum channel will be used to transmit the secret key , and the classical public channel will be used to exchange information and to send the encoded message . in principle , this is sufficient to ensure the safety of a transmission : alice and bob exchange a series of bits over the quantum channel , and then use part of the transmission to test for eavesdropping . if they find any discrepancy between their strings , they can infer that an eavesdropper , usually referred to as eve , was listening and that their transmission is not secret . if they detect no errors , they can assume that the key is safe . by testing a large proportion of their initial string , they can attain any safety level they wish . unfortunately , quantum channels are very sensitive devices , and due to the imperfections of the channels and of the detectors , some errors will always be unavoidable . the problem facing alice and bob is therefore , for a given error rate , to estimate the amount of information that may have leaked to eve , and decide on the safety of the transmission . this of course depends on both the particular system used by alice and bob , and on the eavesdropping strategy adopted by eve . a safer system is a system for which the amount of information that may have leaked to eve is lower . if the information leaked to eve is not too high , alice and bob can use classical information processing techniques to reduce it to approximately zero , at the expense of shortening their strings @xcite . at present , there exist three different quantum cryptographic systems . the first one relies on the transmission of single photons randomly polarized along four directions @xcite . as single photons are difficult to produce experimentally , a slight modification of this system , using weak pulses instead of single photons , was the first one to be implemented in practice @xcite . the second system , which is conceptually the simplest , uses only two non - orthogonal quantum states @xcite . its implementation relies on weak coherent pulses , with a phase difference between them @xcite . the third system is based on the creation of pairs of epr correlated photons @xcite . one of its potential advantages is that the correlations are between single photons and not weak pulses , which can be a great advantage , as we shall emphasize later . however , creation and transmission over long distances of epr correlated pairs is technologically more difficult , and it is not clear yet whether this will prove practical @xcite . in this work , we focus on quantum cryptographic schemes implemented with weak pulses of coherent light . we compare the safety of the first and the second of these quantum cryptographic systems , and present a new system , which is a symbiosis of both , and for which the safety can be significantly increased . in section [ 4 ] , we analyze the first system , referred to as 4-states system . in section [ 2 ] , we turn to the second one , named 2-states system , and present a new implementation . we introduce our new 4 + 2 system in section [ 4 + 2 ] , and show that it is more sensitive to eavesdropping than the two previous ones . in section [ lossy ] , we show the dangers associated with a lossy transmission line , and conclude in section [ conclusion ] . this protocol was developed by bennett et al . the sender , alice , chooses at random one out of four states , e.g. for polarized photons : , , or , and sends it to the receiver , bob . the two states and stand for bit value ` 0 ' , while the other two , and , stand for ` 1 ' . bob chooses , also at random , a basis , or , in which he measures the polarization . when his basis corresponds to alice s , his bit should be perfectly correlated with hers , whereas when his basis is the conjugate , there is no correlation between his result and alice s original choice . by discussing over the public channel , alice and bob agree to discard all the instances where they did not use the same basis ( half of the total on average ) . the result is what we call the sifted key , which should be two perfectly correlated strings , but which may contain errors . the two fundamental properties of this protocol are : * the choice of basis is completely hidden from the other protagonist ( the two bases correspond to the same density matrix ) , as well as from any mischievous eavesdropper , eve ; * when alice and bob use different bases , there is no correlation between their bits . the first one , ( i ) , ensures that , as the eavesdropper eve can not know which basis was used , she will unavoidably introduce errors . the second one , ( ii ) , is not really necessary , but is preferable , as it reduces the information available to eve to a minimum @xcite ( 25 % for each photon on which she eavesdropped ) . there have been various works analyzing eavesdropping strategies , calculating the information available to eve as a function of the error rate and developing information processing techniques to reduce it to any required level @xcite . one technical difficulty with this scheme is that in principle it should be implemented by means of single photons @xcite . as these are difficult to generate experimentally , existing schemes rely on weak pulses of coherent or thermal light , with much less than one photon per pulse on average @xcite . this ensures that the probability of having two or more photons in a pulse remains very small . this strategy reduces the transmission rate ( recent experiments use about one tenth of a photon per pulse ) , while providing no advantage to an honest participant . more precisely , if alice and bob use coherent pulses @xmath0 , the transmission rate @xmath1 is given by : @xmath2 where the factor @xmath3 comes from the fact that half of the transmissions had to be discarded ( when alice and bob used different bases ) . in fact , even for these weak pulses , the probability of having two or more photons per pulse may not always be neglected ( for the above pulses , one out of twenty non - zero pulses will have two photons ) . we shall show in section [ lossy ] how to take this into account . in order to get quantitative results , we shall assume that eve uses the intercept / resend strategy : she intercepts the pulses , attempts to gain as much information as possible , and sends to bob a new pulse , prepared according to the information she obtained . moreover , we shall assume that she eavesdrops in the bases used by alice and bob , or . this is the intercept / resend strategy which provides her with the most information on the sifted key @xcite . however , it is not yet known whether this is the optimal strategy . it is easy to see that , when eve eavesdrops on a fraction @xmath4 of the transmissions , the error rate created is @xmath5 ( when eve uses the correct basis , she does not introduce any error , while she creates a 50% error rate when she uses the wrong basis ) , and that the information she obtained is @xmath6 ( she has total information when she used the correct basis , and none when she used the wrong one ) . moreover , the scheme is completely symmetric , so that eve shares the same information with alice and with bob . therefore , we can write the mutual information shared by alice and eve and shared by eve and bob as a function of the error rate @xmath7 : @xmath8 in this system , the intensity of the weak pulses , or equivalently the transmission rate @xmath1 defined in ( [ t4 ] ) has no influence . in the following , we will compare ( [ i4 ] ) to the information obtained by eve for the other two systems . in this protocol @xcite , alice chooses between only two non - orthogonal states , and sends one to bob . as these are not orthogonal , there is no way for bob to decode them deterministically . however , by means of a generalized measurement , also known as _ positive operator valued measure _ or povm @xcite , he can perform a test which will sometimes fail to give an answer , and at all other times give the correct one . in essence , instead of having a binary test ( with results 0 or 1 ) , which will unavoidably create errors when the two states are not orthogonal , bob has a ternary system , with possible results : 0 , 1 , or ? ( with ? corresponding to inconclusive results ) . for example , if alice sends a 0 , bob may get either a 0 or an inconclusive result , but he will never get a 1 . we present a practical implementation of such a povm in the next section ( for a theoretical description see @xcite ) . as with the previous system , alice and bob use their public channel to discard all the inconclusive results . they should now have two perfectly correlated strings , except for possible errors . the safety of the protocol against eavesdropping is ensured by the fact that eve can not get deterministic results either . she may attempt to get as much information as possible by projecting the states onto an orthogonal basis . this is discussed in section [ safety2 ] , where we show that this will unavoidably create errors . another possibility for eve is to mimic bob s measurement , and obtain deterministic results on a fraction of the bits . however , in this case , she will have to guess alice s choice on the remaining bits , and this will provide her with less information than the previous strategy . let us emphasize that , as we want eve s guesses to result in errors on bob s side , this scheme should not be implemented with weak pulses only . in this case , eve could simply intercept the transmission , resend a pulse to bob only when she managed to obtain the bit sent by alice ( i.e. 0 or 1 ) , and send nothing when she obtained an inconclusive result . the signature of eavesdropping would then just be a reduction in the transmission rate . in the original proposal , this is overcome by using phase encoding of a weak pulse ( the two states are @xmath9 , with overlap @xmath10 ) , which is sent together with a strong pulse , used also as a phase reference @xcite . when eve fails to obtain information , she still has to send the strong pulse , which will create errors in the reception . ekert et al . @xcite recently analyzed various eavesdropping strategies related to this system . here , we shall restrict ourselves to the intercept / resend strategy and compare the safety of various schemes . let us now suggest a new implementation of the 2-states system , which will be later extended to our new 4 + 2 protocol . we shall call it _ parallel reference _ implementation , to distinguish it from the _ sequential reference _ implementation of @xcite . alice uses weak coherent states , with phase encoding 0 or @xmath11 with respect to a strong coherent state . we denote the weak states by @xmath9 and the strong state by @xmath12 . the overlap between the two states is given by : @xmath13 instead of sending the two states one after the other , alice uses two orthogonal polarizations : @xmath14 , say , will have vertical polarization , and @xmath15 will have horizontal polarization . the decoding on bob s side is schematized in fig . [ detection ] . the two states are separated by a polarization beam splitter ( pbs ) . @xmath15 is rotated to vertical polarization and sent through a mainly transmitting beam splitter ( bs1 ) to detector d1 . a small fraction of @xmath12 , equal to @xmath0 , is sent to interfere with @xmath9 at bs2 , and towards two detectors d2 and d3 . a count in d2 , say , corresponds to phase zero , while a count in d3 corresponds to @xmath11 . no count in both d2 and d3 is of course an inconclusive result . it is easy to calculate the probability of such a result : @xmath16 which is equal to the overlap between the two states . it was shown that ( [ prob ? ] ) represents the optimum for separating deterministically two non - orthogonal states @xcite . since all the cases corresponding to inconclusive results have to be discarded , the transmission rate of the channel is given by : @xmath17 detector d1 should always fire , and can therefore be used as a trigger for the other two , enabling them only for a short time corresponding to the length of the pulse ( this will reduce the dark counts ) . moreover , an eavesdropper with an inconclusive result would still have to send @xmath18 , which will result in random counts in d2 and d3 . a small modification of the above will be used for our 4 + 2 protocol . as in section [ 4 ] , we assume that eve performs an intercept / resend strategy , and attempts to get as much information as possible on the state sent by alice . this is obtained by projecting it onto the orthogonal basis @xmath19 as shown in fig . [ projection ] @xcite , and provides eve with probabilistic information only . another method for eve would be to use the same povm as bob . this would provide her with a smaller amount of deterministic information . the error rate introduced by eve is equal to the probability of making the wrong reading , e.g. the probability of obtaining @xmath20 when the input was in fact @xmath0 : @xmath21 where @xmath22 is defined in ( [ overlap ] ) and shown in fig . [ projection ] . with this particular eavesdropping strategy , the transmission channel alice - eve is known as a binary symmetric channel , and is fully characterized by the error rate @xmath23 @xcite . the mutual information shared by alice and eve is equal to the channel capacity and is given by @xcite : @xmath24 ( @xmath25 is the maximum information that can be extracted from two states with overlap @xmath26 ) . on the other hand , after bob discards all his inconclusive results , the transmission channel eve - bob is perfect . therefore the mutual information eve - bob is : @xmath27 this strategy , where eve eavesdrops on all the transmitted photons , will create a high error rate . in order to reduce it , eve shall only eavesdrop on a fraction @xmath4 of the transmissions , thus creating an error rate @xmath28 it is now easy to obtain the mutual information between alice and eve , @xmath29 and between eve and bob , @xmath30 , as a function of the error rate @xmath7 and the angle @xmath22 between the states : @xmath31 using ( [ overlap ] ) and ( [ trans2 ] ) , we can also write the mutual information as a function of the transmission rate for each value of the error rate . these functions are plotted in fig [ graph ] , where the information gained for the 4-states system is used as a reference . the basic idea behind this protocol is that the 4-states scheme does not require the two states in each basis to be orthogonal . the safety of this scheme relies entirely on the two points ( i ) and ( ii ) mentioned in section [ 4 ] . any scheme using two pairs of states ( each pair corresponding to one non - orthonormal basis ) satisfying both ( i ) and ( ii ) is an equally good candidate for a 4-states protocol . moreover , by choosing non - orthogonal states in each pair , we will get the additional advantage of the 2-states protocol , namely that eve can not differentiate deterministically between the two states in each basis . as we show in the following , this will make the scheme more sensitive to eavesdropping . a second advantage , shared with the 2-states system , is that this scheme will be more resilient in the case of a lossy transmission line . this aspect will be discussed in section [ lossy ] . a graphic comparison between the different systems is given in fig [ poincare ] , where we plot the various states on the poincar sphere . let us apply this to our previous parallel reference phase encoding scheme . the first pair will correspond to 0 and @xmath11 phase shifts , while the second pair will correspond to @xmath32 and @xmath33 . explicitly , the four states are : @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 . let us emphasize that these states satisfy condition ( i ) only when the intensity is low enough , since pulses containing two or more photons do not satisfy it . indeed , if we take into account the two photon number state , it is easy to see that the two pairs : @xmath38 and @xmath39 are not even in the same 2d hilbert space , and therefore can not correspond to the same density matrix . in the following , we shall assume that this condition is verified . we shall however lift this restriction in section [ lossy ] , where we present an analysis for a lossy transmission line . the detection system is similar to the one explained in section [ 2 ] , with the addition of an optional @xmath32 phase shifter in one arm of the interferometer ( see fig . [ detection ] ) . when bob wants to measure in the first basis , he does not put the phase shift , and his detection scheme will therefore differentiate between @xmath40 and @xmath41 . when he wants to measure in the second basis , he puts the @xmath32 phase shift , so that his detection scheme will now differentiate between @xmath42 and @xmath43 . of course , when bob uses the wrong basis ( say alice sent state @xmath0 and bob puts the @xmath32 phase shift ) , bob s result is totally uncorrelated with alice s choice . in many instances bob wo nt get any count in his detectors d2 and d3 , which correspond to inconclusive results , and will be discarded . the problems facing eve are now twofold : she does nt know the basis used by alice ( as in the 4-states method ) , which means that even when she has a conclusive result , she can not be sure that it is relevant . moreover , as the states are not orthogonal , she is faced with two possibilities : either to try to get deterministic results , which means that in many instances she will get no information at all , but will still have to make a decision on which state to send to bob ; or try to get probabilistic information , in which case she will know very little on each bit . in both cases , she will introduce errors , before she even start to deal with the basis . this is the main difference with the usual 4-states scheme : alice and bob make use of the fact that they send weak pulses and not single photons to enhance the safety . in order to compare the various schemes , we first need to calculate the transmission rate . since in half of the cases , alice and bob will use different bases , and therefore will have to discard the transmission , we easily get : @xmath44 as in section [ 4 ] , we now assume that eve eavesdrops on a fraction @xmath4 of the transmissions , and uses the intercept / resend strategy in the bases used by alice and bob . when she uses the wrong basis , which happens on a fraction @xmath6 , she does not get any information , but still creates an error rate @xmath3 as in the 4-states system . when she uses the correct bases , again on a fraction @xmath6 , the system reduces to the 2-states system . following section [ 2 ] , we assume that eve attempts to get as much probabilistic information as possible . the error rate is thus given by ( [ ermax2 ] ) and the information gain by ( [ imax2 ] ) . the overall error rate is therefore @xmath45 and the information gained by eve @xmath46 the comparison between the three systems is given in fig [ graph ] , where we plot the various information as functions of the transmission rate , and use the 4-states system as a reference . note that , as the transmission rate is different for the 2-states system and the 4 + 2 system , we compare systems with different values of @xmath47 ( or equivalently with different values of the overlap @xmath26 ) . with the type of eavesdropping strategy considered here , the information available to eve grows linearly with the error rate for all the systems . therefore , as the plot is normalized with respect to the 4-states system , there is no dependence on @xmath7 . fig [ graph ] shows a clear advantage for the 2-states system with respect to the 4-states system at very low transmission rates . however , the information leaked to eve increases rapidly with the transmission rate . in contrast , the 4 + 2 system is always preferable to both other systems . let us emphasize that our analysis is in principle correct for any value of the overlap @xmath26 between the states , if the various states remain in a 2d hilbert space . however , this is not the case for the suggested implementation with weak coherent states . in this case , the analysis is only appropriate for very weak states , where the probability of having more than one photon is sufficiently small , and therefore where the overlap between the states is always close to one . this is likely to be correct in practical applications , but it is still important to present the corrections to the analysis when two - photon states become relevant . this is the task of section[lossy ] . in the above work , we have analyzed the relative sensitivity of various schemes to eavesdropping , under the assumption that there was at most one photon per pulse . however , when we use pulses of coherent or thermal light , there is a non - zero probability to have more than one photon in a pulse , even for very weak pulses . when the transmission line between alice and bob is approximately lossless , the fact that a few pulses may have more than one photon is not too damaging , but only gives some free information to an eavesdropper . however , when the transmission line is lossy , using weak pulses can prove disastrous for alice and bob . let us assume that the transmission line is a silica optical fiber , which is always slightly lossy ( about 0.2 db / km ) . if we want to use the cryptographic system over reasonable distances , say up to 50 km , transmission losses will be as high as 10 db , or about 90% . an eavesdropper with superior technology could replace the fiber by a perfectly transparent one , and use the excess power for her mischievous purposes . for the 4-states system based on polarization ( section [ 4 ] ) , this can be very damaging . indeed , as polarization and photon number are independent variables , there is no problem in principle to select the few pulses with two or more photons and separate them into two one - photon pulses , without changing the polarization . eve could then send one of the two pulses to bob , while keeping the other one . she would measure her signal only after alice and bob have disclosed their bases , which means that she will get complete information on these pulses . if the pulses sent by alice are coherent and contain on average 1/10 photon , eve would obtain about one such pulse out of 200 , and would send all of these to bob without attenuation . remembering that bob only expect to receive one photon out of 100 pulses sent by alice , we see that eve can know the polarization of half of the pulses received by bob , without creating any error . for thermal light , where the photon distribution is wider ( one pulse out of 100 would contain more than one photon ) , eve would actually know the polarization of all the pulses . this can of course be reduced by using even weaker pulses , but this in turn would lower the transmission rate and the signal to noise ratio ( mainly because of the dark counts of the detectors ) . this shows that a combination of weak pulses with high channel loss is a deadly combination for this cryptographic system . if the losses are high enough , eve can get full information on the transmission , and this without causing a single error . let us emphasize however that any system using only single photons would be insensitive to the above attack . in contrast to the 4-states system , both the 2-states systems based on phase encoding ( section [ 2 ] ) , and our new protocol ( section [ 4 + 2 ] ) will be more resilient against this attack . the main reason is that as phase and number are conjugate variables , any attempt by eve to select the two - photon pulses will unavoidably randomize the phase of the pulse . therefore , the best eve can do is to split the incoming pulses , and send to bob the weaker pulses through a lossless fiber . for the 90 % losses mentioned above , eve can therefore split 90 % of the pulses . bob of course has no way of discovering that the losses are now due to eve . the malicious eve can now keep her pulses , wait for alice and bob to disclose the basis they used , and then try to extract the maximum information > from them . in contrast to the 4-states system , her information is limited by the fact that the states are not orthogonal . in fact , the maximum information that she can extract is given by @xmath25 defined in ( [ imax2 ] ) . for the above example , with 1/10 photon per pulse on average and 90 % losses , eve has pulses with 0.09 photons at her disposal . the maximum information that she can extract is then about 0.23 bits . in a practical scheme , this would have to be added to the information available to eve as a function of the error rate . let us emphasize that eve can adopt this beam splitting strategy , even in the case of 4-states systems with weak pulses . however , as was shown in the previous paragraph , in this case she can also use the independence of polarization and photon number to get more information . the rule of the game in quantum cryptography is that the honest participants are limited by the available technology , while the mischievous eavesdropper is only confined by the laws of quantum mechanics . this is in order to ensure that the safety of the schemes does not depend on future technological advances , no matter how unlikely . at present , one of the main technological limitations is the difficulty of generating single photons . for this reason , most existing schemes rely on weak pulses , which are easy to generate . however , in practical implementations @xcite , this fact was considered to be only a limitation . the fact that the pulses had a strong vacuum component , or equivalently the fact that the two pulses in the same basis were not orthogonal , was not utilized by the users . in this work , we presented a new system which made use of this vacuum component to enhance the safety of the transmission . the reason why the task of the eavesdropper is made more difficult with this system , is that it combines the strengths of the two systems it is built from : as in the 4-states system , eve does not know the basis used by alice and bob ; as in the 2-states system , she can not distinguish with certainty between the two non - orthogonal states . it is worth noting that the usual implementation of the 4-states system with weak pulses actually satisfies these two criteria . the weak pulses with orthogonal polarizations are _ not _ orthogonal in the hilbert space , due to their common vacuum component . the ingredient which is missing from these system is the use of a strong reference pulse in the detection , which ensures that eve has to send a signal to bob , even when she could not get any information on the signal sent by alice . when this is added to the system , the use of weak pulses becomes an advantage for the legitimate users . indeed , one experimental realisation of quantum cryptography based on an interferometric scheme @xcite , is somewhat similar to our suggested implementation ( see fig [ detection ] ) . the main difference between the two schemes is that @xcite do not use a strong reference pulse ( in their set - up , @xmath48 , and the beam splitter bs1 is replaced by a mirror ) . therefore , as emphasized above , their scheme does not take advantage of the non - orthogonality of the weak pulses . whenever she obtains an unsatisfactory result in her attempt to eavesdrop , eve may simply block the transmission and send nothing to bob . a slight modification of the existing experiment could therefore provide a much safer scheme . unfortunately , even very weak pulses have a non - zero probability of having more than one photon . this creates the most acute problem when the two legitimate users have a lossy transmission line . in this case , we showed that the usual polarization - based scheme appears to be unpractical , as too much information may leak to an eavesdropper , without causing any error . the two other schemes , which combine non - orthogonal states , phase encoding and a reference pulse , appear to be less sensitive to this problem , as eve can not get total information , no matter what the losses are . however , following the results of section [ lossy ] , it is clear that , when the transmission line between alice and bob is very lossy , single photon transmission would be preferable . g. brassard , _ modern cryptology : a tutorial _ , lecture notes in computer science , vol . 325 ( springer , 1988 ) . bennett , g. brassard , and a.k . ekert in _ scientific american _ , pp.50 - 57 , ( october 1992 ) . c. h. bennett , f. bessette , g. brassard , l. salvail , and j. smolin , _ journal of cryptology _ * 5 * , 3 ( 1992 ) . bennett , g. brassard and j - m . siam j. comput _ , * 17 * , 210 ( 1988 ) . b. huttner and a. k. ekert , _ j. mod . opt . _ ( to be published ) . c. h. bennett and g. brassard , in _ proceedings of ieee international conference on computers , systems and signal processing , bangalore , india _ ( ieee , new york , 1984 ) p. 175 . d. townsend , j. g. rarity , and p. r. tapster , _ electronics letters _ * 29*,1291 ( 1993 ) . a. muller , j. breguet , and n. gisin , _ europhysics letters _ , * 23 * , 383 ( 1993 ) . c. h. bennett , _ phys . lett . _ * 68 * , 3121 ( 1992 ) . p. d. townsend , j. g. rarity , and p. r. tapster , _ electronics letters _ * 29 * , 634 ( 1993 ) . a. k. ekert , _ phys . _ * 67 * , 661 ( 1991 ) . a. k. ekert , j. g. rarity , p. r. tapster , and g. m. palma , _ phys . lett . _ * 69 * , 1293 ( 1992 ) . s.j.d . phoenix , _ phys . a _ * 48 * , 100 ( 1993 ) . s. m. barnett and s. j. d. phoenix , _ phys . a _ * 48 * , r5 ( 1993 ) ; s.m . barnett , b. huttner and s.j.d . phoenix , _ j. mod _ * 40 * , 2501 ( 1993 ) . a. peres , _ quantum theory : concepts and methods _ , kluwer , dordrecht ( 1993 ) , chapt . ekert , b. huttner , g.m . palma , and a. peres , _ phys a _ * 50 * , 1047 ( 1994 ) . i. d. ivanovic , _ phys . a _ * 123 * , 257 ( 1987 ) ; a. peres , _ phys . a _ * 128 * , 19 ( 1988 ) . r. b. ash , _ information theory _ , dover , new york ( 1990 ) ; t. m. cover and j. a thomas , _ elements of information theory _ , wiley , new york ( 1991 ) .

the safety of a quantum key distribution system relies on the fact that any eavesdropping attempt on the quantum channel creates errors in the transmission . for a given error rate , the amount of information that may have leaked to the eavesdropper depends on both the particular system and the eavesdropping strategy . in this work , we discuss quantum cryptographic protocols based on the transmission of weak coherent states and present a new system , based on a symbiosis of two existing ones , and for which the information available to the eavesdropper is significantly reduced . this system is therefore safer than the two previous ones . we also suggest a possible experimental implementation .

0907.3251

as the paradigmatic discrete - time realization of brownian motion and diffusive processes , whose theory was formulated in the pioneering work by einstein @xcite and smoluchowski @xcite published in beginning of the last century , random walks have received a considerable amount of attention @xcite , uncovering their wide range of distinct applications . thus far , random walks are still an active area of research @xcite . however , due to the complexity and variety of real media , theory of random walks on general graphs ( networks ) is not yet available . for this reason , studying random walks occurring on simple structures is a matter of exceptional importance . fractal structures , in particular deterministic fractals , are valuable media in this content @xcite , because their properties can be exactly studied . among various deterministic fractals @xcite , the t - fractal ( t - graph ) @xcite is a typical candidate for exactly solvable model , and a plethora of issues for random walks on this fractal have been studied @xcite . a simple analytical approach was proposed in @xcite , showing that random walks on the t - graph can be mapped onto diffusion on a comb structure . the asymptotic behavior of the moments of the first - passage time and survival probability for random walks on the t - graph was computed in @xcite . particularly , random walks performed on the t - graph with a single trap were extensively studied by many groups @xcite , revealing some scaling relations and dominating behavior . despite the fact that these investigations uncovered many unusual and exotic features of the t - graph , providing useful insight into understanding random walks on this fractal , they did not give a complete picture of random - walk dynamics on the t - fractal , since in these studies , only one special trap was considered . it was shown that in some real networks , any node may be looked as a trap , and the location of traps strongly affects the behavior of random walks @xcite . irrespective of its obvious importance and ubiquity , this issue has not been addressed for the t - graph . in this paper , using the connection between the random walks and electrical networks @xcite , we investigate random walks on the t - graph . the random walk process addressed here may be considered as the trapping problem with the perfect trap uniformly located at all nodes . we derive analytically an exact formula for the mean first - passage time ( mfpt ) averaged all pairs of nodes , which characterizes the efficiency of random walks on the t - graph . we show that the location of trap has no qualitative effect on the scaling for mfpt . we expect that our analytical method can be applied to some other deterministic media , and that our results can lead to deeper insights to random walks on the t - graph . the t - graph is built in an iterative way @xcite . we denote by @xmath0 ( @xmath1 ) the t - graph after @xmath2 iterations . note that henceforth we will also call the number of iterations as generation of the t - graph . the construction of the t - graph starts from ( @xmath3 ) two nodes connected by an edge , which corresponds to @xmath4 . for @xmath5 , @xmath0 is obtained from @xmath6 by performing the operation illustrated in fig . [ cons ] . according to the construction algorithm , at each generation , the number of edges in the system increases by a factor of @xmath7 . thus , we can easily obtain that at generation @xmath2 , the total number of edges in @xmath0 is @xmath8 . since the t - graph is a tree , the total number of nodes in @xmath0 is @xmath9 . figure [ net ] shows schematically the structure of @xmath10 . the t - graph is a fractal with the fractal dimension and random walk dimension being @xmath11 and @xmath12 , respectively . the spectral dimension of the t - graph is @xmath13 . note that for a general connected graph , the spectral dimension governs the longtime behavior of a random walk on the graph at a deep level . for example , when a walker originating at a given node @xmath14 of the graph , the probability @xmath15 for returning back to @xmath14 , at long time @xmath16 , obeys the relation @xmath17 @xcite . again for instance , for an infinite graph with the spectral dimension @xmath18 , a walker starting from a given node will return back to the node almost surely over the course of time . the phenomenon of a random walk on such a graph is called persistence " . since the spectral dimension @xmath19 for the t - graph , a random walk on such a graph is persistent . to facilitate the description in what follows , we define the central node in fig . [ net ] as the innermost node , and we call those nodes farthest from the central node as outermost nodes . then , the t - graph can be alteratively constructed in another method , see fig . [ copy ] . given the generation @xmath2 , @xmath20 may be obtained by joining three copies of @xmath0 , denoted as @xmath21 , @xmath22 , and @xmath23 , respectively . in other words , to get @xmath20 one can merge together separate outermost nodes of the three replicas of @xmath0 . in the process of joining , the three outermost nodes are emerged into a single new node , which becomes the innermost node of @xmath20 . , which is obtained by joining three copies of @xmath0 , consecutively represented as @xmath21 , @xmath22 , and @xmath23 , respectively . in this section , we investigate a minimal model for discrete - time random walks of a particle on the t - graph @xmath0 . at each time step , the walker moves from its current location to any of its nearest neighbors with equal probability . a key quantity characterizing such a random walk is the first - passage time ( fpt ) , in terms of which many other quantities can be expressed . we are interested in the mean first - passage time ( mfpt ) between two distinct nodes , averaged over all pairs . it is well - known that the random walks addressed here can be described by the processes of markov chains @xcite , the fundamental matrices corresponding to which can be used to express the fpt between any pair of nodes . however , the fundamental matrix method for computing the mfpt in @xmath0 requires computing the inversion of @xmath24 matrices of size @xmath25 , making it prohibitively difficult to calculate the quantity concerned for all but small networks . to bring down the high computational demands the fundamental matrix method makes , one can apply the method of the pseudoinverse of the laplacian matrix @xcite for the graph @xmath0 that random walks are performed on , which allows to compute the fpt between two arbitrary nodes directly from the network topology and requires inversion of a single @xmath26 matrix . the elements @xmath27 of the laplacian matrix @xmath28 for graph @xmath0 are defined as follows : @xmath29 if the pair of two different nodes @xmath14 and @xmath30 is connected by a link , otherwise @xmath31 ; while @xmath32 ( i.e. , degree of node @xmath14 ) . then , the pseudoinverse of the laplacian matrix @xmath28 is @xcite @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the @xmath35-dimensional one " vector , i.e. , @xmath36 . let @xmath37 denote the fpt for a walker in the t - graph @xmath0 , starting from node @xmath14 , to arrive at node @xmath30 for the first time . since the graph @xmath0 is connected , the pseudoinverse matrix @xmath38 is well defined and the entries @xmath39 can be applied to express the fpt @xmath37 as follows @xcite : @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the @xmath42 entry of the diagonal of the laplacian matrix @xmath28 as defined above . then the sum , @xmath43 , for the fpt between two nodes over all node pairs in graph @xmath0 reads @xmath44 and the mfpt , @xmath45 , is @xmath46 the quantity of mfpt @xmath45 is very important since it measures the efficiency of the random walks on @xmath0 : the smaller the value @xmath45 , the higher the efficiency , and vice versa . equations ( [ hitting01 ] ) and ( [ hitting03 ] ) show that the problem of calculating @xmath47 is reduced to determining the elements of the pseudoinverse matrix @xmath38 , whose complexity is that of inverting an @xmath48 matrix , it can be easily obtained by utilizing a standard software package , mathematica 5.0 . however , since @xmath35 increases exponentially with @xmath2 , for large @xmath2 , it becomes difficult to obtain @xmath45 through direct calculation using the pseudoinverse matrix , because of the limitations of time and computer memory . therefore , one can compute directly the mfpt only for the first generations , see fig . fortunately , the particular construction of the t - graph and the connection @xcite between effective resistance and first - passage time allow us to calculate analytically the mfpt to obtain an explicit formula . details will be given below . ( color online ) mean first - passage time @xmath45 as a function of the iteration @xmath2 on a semilogarithmic scale . the red squares are the numerical results obtained by direct calculation from eqs . ( [ hitting01 ] ) and ( [ hitting03 ] ) , while the full blue squares represent the exact values from eq . ( [ hitting07 ] ) , both of which agree with each other . ] in the following text , we will use the connection between the electrical networks and random walks to derive the closed - form expression for mfpt @xmath45 , avoiding the computation process for inverting any matrix . given a graph , the underlying electrical network @xcite can be obtained by replacing each edge of the original graph with a unit resistor . the effective resistance between any node pair @xmath14 and @xmath30 is defined as the voltage when a unit current enters one node and leaves the other . it has been proved that the effective resistance is a distance measure , so the quantity is also called resistance distance @xcite . thus , we can view @xmath0 as a resistor network by considering all edges of @xmath0 to be unit resistors . previous work @xcite showed that many problems on a resistor network are closed related to the classic random walks on the original graph . for example , the computation of effective resistance between two nodes in a resistor network can be expressed by the fpt between the two nodes on the corresponding network : for an arbitrary connected graph , the effective resistance @xmath49 between a pair of nodes @xmath14 and @xmath30 is equal to @xmath50 , where @xmath51 is the total number of edges in the graph , and @xmath52 is the expected time for a walker starting at node @xmath14 to first reach @xmath30 . in fact , @xmath53 is the average time that a walker , originating at node @xmath14 , will take to hit node @xmath30 and go back to @xmath14 , and it is often called commute time @xcite between @xmath14 and @xmath30 denoted as @xmath54 , i.e. , @xmath55 . according to the close relation between commute time and effective resistance , we have that for @xmath0 , the effective resistance @xmath56 between a pair of nodes @xmath14 and @xmath30 is @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is the commute time between @xmath14 and @xmath30 . thus @xmath59 . then , eq . ( [ hitting02 ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath60 and eq . ( [ hitting03 ] ) can be recast as @xmath61 equation ( [ hitting05 ] ) shows that if we know how to determine the effective resistances , then we have the way to find the mfpt . for a general graph with order @xmath62 , the complexity of resistance computation is that of inverting an @xmath63 matrix , identical to that of calculating mfpt . however , for a treelike graph , the effective resistance between two nodes is exactly the usual shortest - path distance ( also called geodesic distance ) between the corresponding nodes . since the t - graph has a treelike structure and it is self - similar at the same time , we can use these properties to find its geodesic distance , obtaining a rigorous expression . after reducing the determination of mfpt to finding the average geodesic distance , the next step is to explicitly determine the latter quantity . to this end , we represent all the shortest - path distance of @xmath0 as a matrix @xcite , where the entry @xmath64 is the shortest distance from node @xmath14 to node @xmath30 , which is the minimum length for the path connecting the two nodes . the maximum value @xmath65 of @xmath64 is called the diameter of @xmath0 . then , the average geodesic distance of @xmath0 is defined as the mean of shortest - path distances over all pairs of nodes : @xmath66 where @xmath67 denotes the sum of the geodesic distances between two nodes over all pairs . note that in eq . ( [ total01 ] ) , for two nodes @xmath14 and @xmath30 ( @xmath68 ) , we only count @xmath64 or @xmath69 , not both . we continue by exhibiting the procedure of the determination of the total shortest - path distance and present the recurrence formula , which allows us to obtain @xmath70 of the @xmath71 generation from @xmath72 of the @xmath2 generation . according to the second construction method , we can easily see that the t - graph is self - similar . this obvious self - similar structure allows to calculate @xmath73 analytically . it is not difficult to find that the total shortest - path distance @xmath70 satisfies the recursion relation@xmath74 where @xmath75 is the sum over all shortest - path distances whose end - points are not in the same @xmath0 branch . the solution of eq . ( [ total02 ] ) is @xmath76.\ ] ] thus , all that is left to obtain @xmath73 is to compute @xmath77 . the paths that contribute to @xmath75 must all go through the innermost node ( e.g. , @xmath78 in fig . [ copy ] ) of @xmath20 . to find @xmath75 , we denote @xmath79 as the sum of all shortest paths with end - points in @xmath80 and @xmath81 , respectively . notice that @xmath79 rules out the paths where end - point is the node shared by @xmath80 and @xmath81 . by symmetry , @xmath82 . then , the total sum @xmath75 is given by @xmath83 in order to calculate the path length @xmath84 , we give the following notation . let @xmath85 be the geodesic distance of a outermost node of @xmath0 @xcite , which is defined as the sum of geodesic distances between the outermost node and all nodes of @xmath0 , including the outermost node itself . prior to determining @xmath85 , we first compute the diameter @xmath65 of @xmath0 . actually , the diameter @xmath65 is equal to the path length between arbitrary pair of the outermost nodes previously belong to two different @xmath86 branches . obviously , the following recursive relation holds : @xmath87 considering the initial condition @xmath88 , eq . ( [ diam01 ] ) is solved inductively to obtain @xmath89 we now calculate the quantity @xmath90 . let @xmath91 denote an outermost node of @xmath20 , which is in the branch @xmath21 ( see fig . [ copy ] ) . by definition , @xmath90 can be given by the sum @xmath92 where we have made use of @xmath93 , which is obvious from the symmetry . we denote the second term in eq . ( [ dist01 ] ) by @xmath94 . then , @xmath95 . the quantity @xmath96 is evaluated as follows : @xmath97\nonumber \\ & = & s_g+(n_{g}-1)d_{g}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath98 was used . hence , eq . ( [ dist01 ] ) becomes @xmath99 using @xmath100 , @xmath101 , and @xmath102 , eq . ( [ dist03 ] ) is resolved by induction @xmath103 with above obtained results , we can determine @xmath84 , which can be expressed in terms of the previously explicitly determined quantities . by definition , @xmath84 is given by the sum @xmath104\nonumber \\ & = & ( n_g-1)\,\sum_{\stackrel{i \in \mathbb{t}_{g}^{(1)}}{i \ne x } } d_{ix}(g+1)+(n_g-1)\,\sum_{\stackrel{j \in \mathbb{t}_{g}^{(2)}}{j \ne x } } d_{xj}(g+1)\nonumber \\&= & 2\,(n_g-1)\,s_g \nonumber \\&=&2\times3^{2g-1}(2^{g+1}+1)\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the equivalence relation @xmath105 . inserting eq . ( [ cross02 ] ) into eq . ( [ cross01 ] ) , we have @xmath106 substituting eq . ( [ cross04 ] ) into eq . ( [ total03 ] ) and using the initial value @xmath107 , we can obtain the exact expression for the total distance @xmath108 then the analytic expression for mean geodesic distance can be obtained as @xmath109 since for @xmath0 , the shortest - path distance is equivalent to the resistance distance , i.e. , @xmath110 , according to the above obtained results shown in eqs . ( [ sg ] ) and ( [ apl02 ] ) , we can easily get that the total of fpt between all @xmath111 pairs of nodes and the mfpt are @xmath112 and @xmath113 respectively . we have checked our analytical formula against numerical values , see fig . [ time ] . for the range of @xmath114 , the values obtained from eq . ( [ hitting07 ] ) are in complete agreement with those numerical results on the basis of the direct calculation through the method of pseudoinverse matrix discussed in section [ sec03 ] . this agreement serves as an independent test of our theoretical formula . note that the result provided in eq . ( [ hitting07 ] ) is consistent with the recent proposal by condamin _ et al . _ @xcite for a very general scaling form for fpt , @xmath115 , of a random walk as a function of the distance , @xmath116 , between the origin and the trap location . _ proved that , for complex invariant networks with @xmath117 , the leading behavior of fpt behaves as @xmath118 . for the t - graph , @xmath119 , according to the conclusion of condamin _ et al . _ , one has @xmath120 as found in eq . ( [ hitting07 ] ) . next we will express the mfpt @xmath45 as a function of network order @xmath35 , in order to obtain the scaling between these two quantities . from the relation @xmath121 , we have @xmath122 and @xmath123 . thereby , we can rewrite eq . ( [ hitting07 ] ) as @xmath124 which provides explicit dependence of @xmath45 on network order @xmath35 . in the infinite network order , namely @xmath125 , @xmath126 thus , for the large t - graph , the mfpt grows as a power law function of network order with the exponent larger than 1 and less than 2 , implying that the mfpt increases superlinearly with the number of network nodes . equation ( [ hitting09 ] ) encodes the speed of the random walks on @xmath0 , which may be quantified by the coverage @xmath127 , standing for the mean number of different nodes visited by a walker at time @xmath16 , averaged for distinct walks initially starting from different sources @xcite . as @xmath128 , the leading asymptotic behavior for @xmath127 is @xmath129 which may be established from the following heuristic argument @xcite . since the random walker will visit all nodes of @xmath0 with probability one in the longtime limit , irrespective of its starting location , @xmath35 plays the role of @xmath127 , and @xmath45 is like @xmath16 ( step number of the walker ) . then , inverting the relation in eq . ( [ coverage01 ] ) leads to asymptotic scaling @xmath130 , as found above and given by eq . ( [ hitting09 ] ) , which also provides the exact coefficient of proportionality . notice that in ref . @xcite agliari studied the trapping problem with an immobile trap located at the innermost ( central ) node , and showed that in the asymptotic limit , the average trapping time ( att ) to first reach the trap , averaged over all nodes except the absorbing node itself , exhibiting a similar behavior ( the same exponent ) as that of eq . ( [ hitting09 ] ) , but has a different prefactor . note that , due to the symmetry , the att in this case corresponds to the mean time for random walks with a fixed trap situated at an outmost node in the t - graph of generation @xmath131 @xcite . that is to say , random walks of these two extreme cases show almost the same behavior of att . on the other hand , the random walks discussed here may be considered as the trapping issue with the trap uniformly distributed throughout all nodes on the t - graph . thus , we can conclude that the trap s location has no qualitative impact on the leading behavior of the att for random walks on the t - graph , which is in sharp contrast to trapping problem on some scale - free networks @xcite , where the att depends on the trap position : it is much smaller for the case when trap is located at a large - degree node than that for the case when the trap is uniformly placed . in this paper , we have studied the standard discrete - time random walks on the t - graph . by making use of the link between the electric networks and random walks , we have studied analytically the mfpt averaged over all pairs of nodes , based on the recursive relations derived from the self - similar structure of the t - graph . we have determined the rigorous solution for the mfpt , which in the large limit of graph order , increases algebraically with the number of nodes . we showed that trap location has little influence on the scaling of mfpt for random walks on the t - graph . we expect that by providing a paradigm for computing the mfpt , our analytical technique could guide and shed light on related studies of random walks on other deterministic media , especially to some scale - free fractals @xcite that has received much recent contention @xcite . we also expect that our work , especially the exact solution , could prompt the studies of diffusion process on random fractals , other stochastic graphs , and even complex networks @xcite , by giving a guide to and a test of approximate methods for random media . this research was supported by the national basic research program of china under grant no . 2007cb310806 , the national natural science foundation of china under grant nos . 60704044 , 60873040 and 60873070 , shanghai leading academic discipline project no . b114 , and the program for new century excellent talents in university of china ( ncet-06 - 0376 ) .

for random walks on networks ( graphs ) , it is a theoretical challenge to explicitly determine the mean first - passage time ( mfpt ) between two nodes averaged over all pairs . in this paper , we study the mfpt of random walks in the famous t - graph , linking this important quantity to the resistance distance in electronic networks . we obtain an exact formula for the mfpt that is confirmed by extensive numerical calculations . the interesting quantity is derived through the recurrence relations resulting from the self - similar structure of the t - graph . the obtained closed - form expression exhibits that the mfpt approximately increases as a power - law function of the number of nodes , with the exponent lying between 1 and 2 . our research may shed light on the deeper understanding of random walks on the t - graph .

1112.5604

living organisms are not passive objects which filter out blindly the modifications of the environment in which they live . on the contrary , both unicellular and multicellular organisms are biochemical systems that receive information from different environmental sources , process this information , and consequently make decisions . these actions allow them to adapt their behavior to the information received . the existence of different input signals thus explains why cells with identical genetic content may sometimes behave differently . the net effect of this information - relay process is the activation or inhibition of key regulatory elements that commit the cell to perform specific tasks , such as taking nutrients , secreting chemicals , proliferating , or communicating with other cells in a tissue . in this way , the cellular signaling machinery @xcite acts as a decision - making device that maps the large number of inputs signals to a reduced set of behaviors characterized by specific outputs @xcite . all these physiological processes are implemented in the cell by signal transduction networks composed of large numbers of interacting proteins . many of these networks receive information about conditions outside the cell , which activate receptor proteins located at the membrane ( see fig . [ fig : celldiagram ] ) . the activation of these receptors triggers a cascade of downstream biochemical reactions that ultimately modify the state of the cell , by controlling both dna expression and protein levels . hence , signaling pathways integrate the signals coming from the environment , and define the response of the cell to the particular external situation in which it is living . these signaling routes have traditionally been studied as isolated cascades which do not interact with each other very strongly . however , it is well known that the different signaling pathways are interconnected , and recent studies have shown that this feature can not be neglected @xcite . in other words , one ought to refer to signaling networks , rather than signaling pathways . the fact that cells process information using an entire network of protein interactions means that the dynamical behavior can be much richer than the one obtained if signaling paths were uncoupled @xcite . , scaledwidth=41.0% ] these complex signal transduction processes must work reliably even in the presence of a substantial amount of environmental noise . indeed , the level of extracellular molecules representing a given external signal is likely to fluctuate in time . more fundamentally , non - saturating levels of external signals will induce stochastic activation of their receptors , leading to random fluctuations that are transmitted down the signaling network and are bound to interfere with its information - processing tasks . the question then arises , whether signaling networks have evolved to filter out the unavoidable levels of noise existing in the extracellular milieu @xcite , or to use it in a constructive manner @xcite . in fact , a large body of evidence has been gathered in the last decades within the fields of statistical and nonlinear physics , showing that random fluctuations can be a source of order ( both temporal and spatial ) in nonlinear systems @xcite . a well - established example of such a constructive influence of noise is _ stochastic resonance _ , a process through which an information - carrying signal ( periodic or non - periodic ) is amplified by an optimal amount of noise acting on the system ( internally or externally ) @xcite . this mechanism was initially proposed by @xcite as an explanation of the occurrence of ice ages in earth s climate ( where the signal to be amplified corresponds to periodic variations in the amount of energy received by the earth from the sun , and the noise arises from all other contributions to climate fluctuations ) . after successful experimental demonstrations in lasers @xcite and in chemical systems @xcite , interest in this phenomenon grew and extended to biological systems , namely sensory neurons , where the phenomenon was amply demonstrated @xcite . stochastic resonance arises in neuronal systems due to their excitable character @xcite . specifically , the noise - induced enhancement originates from the fact that neurons are threshold devices , and noise helps a time - varying ( or space - varying ) signal to surpass this threshold in a manner that is correlated with the signal itself @xcite . this mechanism can act even if there is no external input signal acting upon the system , with noise extracting instead an internal temporal ( or spatial ) scale existing within the system s dynamics . this latter mechanism is called _ stochastic coherence _ @xcite , or more commonly _ coherence resonance _ @xcite , and has been suggested to exist in genetic oscillators @xcite . there are other examples of the constructive effects of noise beyond stochastic resonance and stochastic coherence . most notably , noise has been seen to induce transitions , both in time @xcite and in space ( in that case one speaks of noise - induced _ phase _ transitions ) @xcite . in those situations , the statistical properties of the system change when noise is varied beyond a certain critical threshold , so that new states appear as a result of random fluctuations . experimental preliminar evidence of this type of behavior in genetic systems has been presented by @xcite , but there is still much work to do in this direction . in the context of cellular signaling , it is appealing to think that environmental noise might be used by the cell in a constructive manner , similarly to what happens in stochastic resonance , to detect and amplify information - carrying signals . preliminary theoretical evidence in this direction has been recently presented @xcite . however , the implication of this type of mechanism on signal integration processes is still an open question . in fact , despite the effort made during decades , signal integration is far from being completely understood . one of the reasons behind this problem is that a detailed theoretical description of a cell is proving difficult , because cells are extremely complex objects . the chemistry of cells operates at multiple levels , spanning for instance signaling interactions , genetic expression , and metabolism , and each of these levels of operation is mediated by many chemical species that interact in a strongly nonlinear manner , forming highly complex dynamical webs . in this paper , we discuss work that moves away from classical signaling studies that focus on only one ligand , and examine instead the effects of multiple ligands upon the same cell , in the presence of external noise . in particular , we consider whether the ability of cells to integrate signals from one or more sources of information is altered when other input signals provide a chattering environment . to study this problem , we consider a dynamic description of the signaling network of a typical human cell a fibroblast in terms of a previously derived boolean model @xcite . boolean models describe the activity of the different proteins involved in the network in a binary way , as being on or off , and are iterated in order to update the protein activity states according to logical rules acting in each node . even though there is no well defined time scale in this type of model , boolean models have been shown to reproduce ordered sequences of cellular events @xcite . the model we use was constructed manually by @xcite using the large body of scientific literature available for this type of cell , and it represents one of the largest signaling network models currently available . despite representing a simplified view of the real network , it offers a good balance between a realistic description and a model simple enough to be studied theoretically . indeed , this model was shown to reproduce experimental results satisfactorily @xcite . using this model , we explore systematically , by means of numerical simulations , the effect of a chattering environment in the integration of input signals . as described above , we use a boolean model of signal transduction to study signal integration in varying environments . this choice is appropriate for our purposes , since it defines the level of activity of the molecules that compose the signaling network . boolean networks ( bn hereafter ) were introduced by @xcite as sets of dynamical units , called _ nodes _ , which are connected with each other by interaction _ edges_. the state of every node @xmath0 at each discrete time @xmath1 , @xmath2 , is either on ( @xmath3 ) or off ( @xmath4 ) , and all nodes are updated according to a set of node - specific logic rules that define the dynamics of the system . for signaling networks , the state of each node corresponds to the level of activity of a specific protein , and edges represent their interactions . we will consider two types of nodes , determined by their definition : _ input _ nodes and _ internal _ nodes . on the one hand , the state of _ input _ nodes is independent from the state of other nodes of the network and determined externally . these nodes represent signals outside the cell ( i.e. the external environment ) , and may evolve deterministically ( for instance , being maintained to a fixed value of activity or oscillating at a specific periodicity ) or stochastically . here we set these states using random value sequences . on the other hand , every _ internal _ node @xmath0 has an associated logic rule , @xmath5 , which determines the new state @xmath2 at time @xmath1 from the states of its @xmath6 incident nodes at time @xmath7 ( note that @xmath8 may include the node @xmath0 itself ) : @xmath9 [ fig : network ] the fibroblast signal transduction network analyzed in this paper @xcite consists of nine input nodes and 130 internal nodes interconnected by a dense web of interactions ( see fig . [ fig : network]a ) . the input layer contains cytokines ( il1/tnf-@xmath10 ) , growth factors ( egf ) , extracellular matrix components ( ecm ) , oxidative stress , a calcium pump and different g protein - coupled receptor ligands . @xcite chose six of the 130 internal nodes to be _ outputs _ of the network ( the proteins akt , erk , rac , cdc42 , sapk and p38 ) . the motivation for choosing these six output species was their role in regulating specific cellular processes : apoptosis ( akt ) , gene transcription ( erk ) , cytoskeletal regulation ( rac and cdc42 ) , and cellular stress ( sapk and p38 ) . the activity of every input node @xmath0 has been implemented as a stochastic sequence in which each state ( 0 or 1 ) derives from an independent draw of a bernoulli distribution with success probability equal to @xmath11 ( where @xmath11 is held constant within each run ) . in this way , the parameter @xmath11 is what we define as the _ chatter level _ for node @xmath0 . the produced sequences of states , @xmath2 , show an intrinsic variability , which is maximal at @xmath12 , and decreases monotonically when @xmath11 approaches to 0 and 1 . here we calculate the bernoulli draws with a standard mersenne twister pseudo - random number generator @xcite . we are interested in the average activity of each node @xmath13 over time and over multiple realizations ( which might correspond to different cells in a population ) : @xmath14 note that , for input nodes and sufficiently long dynamical evolutions , @xmath15 . to illustrate this procedure , the upper panel in fig . [ fig : network]b shows the average activity @xmath16 of 30 network nodes ( including inputs , outputs , and internal nodes ) and the corresponding sequence of states is shown in the lower panel . the time evolution of the system has been obtained using a custom - made python implementation of a bn simulator , available at http://code.google.com/p/bnsim . despite the simplicity of the boolean aproximation , the network model described in the preceding section shows interesting behavior in terms of the dynamical integration of input signals . for instance , when the system receives constant inputs it falls in periodic orbits within a distribution of transient times peaked at one specific length , but with a long - tailed decay in the form of a power law @xcite . this characteristic transient scale , which may be relevant for the operational response of the cell to changes in the environment , is maintained in the presence of noisy environments characterized by a chatter level , @xmath17 . thus , even though chatter destroys the periodic orbits , it maintains the fixed transient response at the population level ( considering the average activity of different realizations of the dynamics ) . besides , the average activity of the outputs also depends on the chatter level @xcite this property is a result of the structure of the biologically network studied here ( its topology and its logic rules ) because it is not observed in randomized versions of the network with the same topological properties but with different logic rules for the nodes . in other words , the biologically realistic network responds in a nontrivial manner to input signals with constant level of background chatter , and it is the distribution of logic rules of the network nodes and their particular placement within the network what determines the responsiveness . background chatter also enhances the network response to periodic stimulation @xcite . again , this dynamical behavior is not shown for randomized versions of the network . this dynamical response is related with the characteristic time response of the network @xcite . in fact , the network responds differently to different stimulation frequencies for specific input nodes . the average activity of the output nodes shows low - pass , high - pass or band - pass frequency filtering responses depending on the node . indeed , noise intensity , as introduced by chatter levels in the input signals , seems to be a key factor in determining the paths for which information flows from periodically stimulated input nodes to output nodes @xcite . altogether , these results reveal that the dynamical response to external modulation is , at the same time , versatile and robust to noise . the extremely rich dynamical behavior observed in this model , consistent with the diversity of responses observed in cellular organisms , is the result of the complex processing information ability of the network . the ability to combine the information from different input sources to produce a coherent output response is possible only if the different signaling pathways can interact within the network . in fact , @xcite introduced the term `` interaction agent '' to refer to the network circuits that couple different signaling pathways . we are interested in understanding how noise affects pathway interaction and thus signal integration . the above - described ability of chatter to select the information route going from the ( periodically driven ) input node to the output nodes stresses once more that the complex network is not a passive object that merely transmits information , but it also processes this information , modifying it , when going from the emitting ( input ) node to the receiver ( output ) node . this phenomenology leads us to ask if the background chatter level @xmath18 modifies the activity of the network not only when one node is perturbed periodically , but also when this node is maintained at a specific ( different ) chatter level @xmath19 . in other words , we ask if the routing ability of chatter revealed in the dynamical context of one periodic input also exists in a more static situation , when that node is maintained at a specific chatter level @xmath19 , different from the fixed background chatter level @xmath18 that affects all other input nodes . in that direction , we now systematically study the average activity of the output nodes when changing the specific chatter level , @xmath19 , of a given input node , under different values of the global background chatter , @xmath18 . that is , we scan the model in two dimensions for each input @xmath0 : for @xmath11 ranging from 0 to 1 ( in 0.10 steps ) , and a common @xmath18 equal for the remaining 8 inputs , also ranging from 0 to 1 . we compute the average activity of the output nodes at steady state over different realizations , arising from 200 different initial conditions and realizations of the stochastic variables . the quantitative behavior of the network outputs is specific for each of the considered inputs . furthermore , in most cases the dependence of the activity of output nodes on @xmath11 changes when the common background chatter @xmath18 is varied . this can be seen for instance in fig . [ fig : q1 ] , which for the sake of simplicity shows only the case when the chatter of the input node il1/tnf-@xmath10 , @xmath19 , is modified . these results confirm the fact that the integration of one signal depends on the rest of input signals . different output nodes in fig . [ fig : q1 ] display different behaviors : for instance , the monotonic increase of erk with @xmath19 is basically unchanged when increasing the global background activity @xmath18 . the opposite situation is shown for sapk and p38 , which swap their monotonically increasing dependence with @xmath19 at lower @xmath18 to a monotonically decreasing dependence at high @xmath18 . these two examples highlight the dramatic influence of the background signaling upon the processing of one specific ligand . in this case , a low activity of the background signals would enhance the activity of sapk and p38 when il1/tnf-@xmath10 increases , but would inhibit their output activity with il1/tnf-@xmath10 when the background chatter is larger . the average activities of akt , rac and cdc42 are independent of the degree of activity of il1/tnf-@xmath10 , but grow when the global background chatter level increases . thus , these output nodes are not sensitive to il1/tnf-@xmath10 but they are activated by the background chatter . qualitatively similar changes with @xmath18 are observed for other inputs . the results of fig . [ fig : q1 ] support the idea that the integration of one single input can not be studied in isolation from the activity of the other inputs received by the cell . these results are consistent with the dependence of the average activity of some output nodes on background chatter level , and with the effect on the integration of periodic signals shown recently by @xcite . continuing in this direction , we now examine the effect of background chatter when two different input nodes are activated with two different and specific chatter levels , @xmath19 and @xmath20 , respectively . to that end , we perform a comprehensive set of numerical simulations combining all the possible pairs of inputs , with the values for the @xmath18 common to the remaining seven inputs ranging from 0 to 1 , and averaging over 200 different initial conditions and realizations of the random variables . four examples of the outcome of these simulations are presented in fig . [ fig : q1q2 ] , which shows the average activity ( in color code ) of the different output nodes when integrating the levels of various pairs of input nodes , for increasing background chatter levels , as indicated . the output activity surfaces obtained in this way , or _ integration maps _ , change as the background chatter level increases . in particular , in the case of il1/tnf-@xmath10 and egf as inputs [ figs . [ fig : q1q2](a - f ) ] , both inputs have to be on at low background chatter to activate p38 , whereas at high background chatter egf has to be on and il1/tnf-@xmath10 has to be off for p38 to be turned on . in other cases the network goes from being sensitive only to input @xmath19 [ figs . [ fig : q1q2](g , s ) ] ) to integrate the two inputs in different ways [ figs . [ fig : q1q2](l , x ) ] ) , as the background chatter increases . the network can also transition from being completely insensitive to both inputs [ figs . [ fig : q1q2](m ) ] to develop an integration capability in the presence of noise [ figs . [ fig : q1q2](n - r ) ] . other combinations of input pairs and outputs exhibit nontrivial changes in their integration maps as chatter varies . the transitions observed in fig . [ fig : q1q2 ] are very relevant for cellular behavior . their existence suggests that the net effect of the network is to act as a switch mechanism which selects the type of @xmath19/@xmath20 integration as a function of the different background chatter levels . this behavior may be interpreted in terms of simple logic gates with two inputs . figure [ fig : logicmaps ] shows the integration maps corresponding to all possible two - input logic gates : two of these ( invariant on and invariant off ) are independent of the inputs , four of them are sensitive to only one of the inputs ( x , not x , y and not y ) , and the rest ( ten gates ) integrate the information from both inputs in order to produce the output . . [ fig : logicmaps ] , scaledwidth=40.0% ] these integration maps can be computed analytically , assuming that the gates are supplied with two independent and binary random processes , @xmath21 and @xmath22 , with average values @xmath19 and @xmath20 . the result of this calculation is given in table [ ta : logicmaps ] . if we compare the surfaces shown , for instance , in figs . [ fig : q1q2](a ) and ( f ) to the aforementioned 16 basic gates , we observe that those two limit cases are very similar to the x and y and y nimp x gates . hence , despite the complexity of the network under study , we observe that some output nodes behave as functions of simple two - input logic gates . importantly , the level of background chatter selects the effective logic gate that will operate at any given condition . .definition of the 16 integration rules with two inputs shown in fig . [ fig : logicmaps ] . [ ta : logicmaps ] [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] to compare the input - output transfer function of the network at different background chatter levels , @xmath23 , with the simple integration patterns given by the two - input logic functions , @xmath24 , we use the _ mean absolute difference _ measure , @xmath25 , defined as : @xmath26 where @xmath0 runs over the 16 gates ( see table [ ta : logicmaps ] ) . we consider all the combinations of pairs of input nodes , under the full range of background chatter values . a diversity of behaviors is observed : in some cases , the behavior obtained from the dynamical evolution of the network can not be attributed to any single logic gate . instead , it displays a combination of gates at some specific background chatter level ( see for instance all cases in fig . [ fig : q1q2 ] in which the responses 0 black and 1 yellow are absent ) . in other cases , such as the one corresponding to the top row in fig . [ fig : q1q2 ] , the situation is simpler and a somewhat clearer transition between simple logical gates is observed as background chatter is modified . this transition is quantified in terms of @xmath25 and shown in fig . [ fig : transition](a ) . other , somewhat less clear , transitions between simple logic gates are shown in figs . [ fig : transition](b - d ) . , for increasing background chatter @xmath18 , for the four cases of fig . [ fig : q1q2 ] . only the logic gates for which the mean absolute difference is smaller than a given threshold ( here taken equal to 0.14 without loss of generality ) for any value of @xmath18 are shown . the meanings of the different lines given in the legends follow the notation of table [ ta : logicmaps ] . [ fig : transition],title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.0% ] + the transitions between simple binary logic gates are , to some extent , a generalization of the results obtained for the integration between a single input and background chatter . the generalization to interactions obtained for an increasing number of input signals may define a hierarchy of simple behaviors which somehow classifies widely varying input signal combinations into a set of simple biological responses @xcite . these results show that the combination of the topology of the network and the specific logic functions defined at each node or , in other words , the full set of protein - protein interactions of the signaling network , have to be carefully chosen . the network has to be constructed in such a way that this hierarchy of integration levels , which classify the output response of the cell , end up in a well - defined pattern of robust responses that are biologically useful . given the many examples existing in the physical sciences of the constructive influence of random fluctuations , it is appealing to think that signaling networks have been tailored by evolution to make use of the unavoidable noise to which cells are subject , in particular from its environment . here we have addressed the issue of how background noise affects the signal integration capabilities of the signaling network of a typical human cell , namely a fibroblast . using a boolean model of this network , we have analyzed the integration of one or more signals for different levels of background chatter affecting the rest of inputs of the network . we have observed that : ( i ) the response to an input signal depends on the level of background chatter affecting all other input nodes , ( ii ) even though the network is highly complex , the outputs respond in a very simple way to pairs of interacting input signals , and ( iii ) variation of the chatter level causes transitions between these simple pattern responses . this type of behavior has been observed experimentally @xcite and might suggest that the cell adapts its information processing machinery according to the environment . this work has been financially supported by the spanish network of multiple sclerosis ( reem , instituto de salud carlos iii ) , the fundacin mutua madrilea ( spain ) , the ministerio de ciencia e innovacin ( project fis2009 - 13360 ) , and the generalitat de catalunya ( project 2009sgr1168 ) . p.r . acknowledges financial support from the generalitat de catalunya . j.g.o . also acknowledges financial support from the icrea foundation . al - shyoukh , i. , yu , f. , feng , j. , yan , k. , dubinett , s. , ho , c .- m . , shamma , j. s. , sun , r. , 2011 . systematic quantitative characterization of cellular responses induced by multiple signals . bmc systems biology 5 , 88 . hsueh , r. c. , natarajan , m. , fraser , i. , pond , b. , liu , j. , mumby , s. , han , h. , jiang , l. i. , simon , m. i. , taussig , r. , sternweis , p. c. , 2009 . deciphering signaling outcomes from a system of complex networks . science signaling 2 ( 71 ) , ra22 . janes , k. a. , albeck , j. g. , gaudet , s. , sorger , p. k. , lauffenburger , d. a. , yaffe , m. b. , 12 2005 . a systems model of signaling identifies a molecular basis set for cytokine - induced apoptosis . science 310 ( 5754 ) , 16461653 .

cells are constantly exposed to fluctuating environmental conditions . external signals are sensed , processed and integrated by cellular signal transduction networks , which translate input signals into specific cellular responses by means of biochemical reactions . these networks have a complex nature , and we are still far from having a complete characterization of the process through which they integrate information , specially given the noisy environment in which that information is embedded . guided by the many instances of constructive influences of noise that have been reported in the physical sciences in the last decades , here we explore how multiple signals are integrated in an eukaryotic cell in the presence of background noise , or chatter . to that end , we use a boolean model of a typical human signal transduction network . despite its complexity , we find that the network is able to display simple patterns of signal integration . furthermore , our computational analysis shows that these integration patterns depend on the levels of fluctuating background activity carried by other cell inputs . taken together , our results indicate that signal integration is sensitive to environmental fluctuations , and that this background noise effectively determines the information integration capabilities of the cell . signal integration , chatter , boolean network , logic gate , cellular noise

1204.3723

this review article is concerned with fermionic property of heavy ions ( many - nucleon systems with the size up to several 10-femtometers ) colliding at the energy of a few mev per nucleon . in the following , we refer to those collisions as low - energy heavy - ion collisions . fusion is not necessarily achieved in the low - energy heavy - ion collisions , neither is fragmentation . reaction dynamics and the resulting products can be drastically different depending on the impact parameter , the mass of colliding ions , and so on . therefore , the reaction mechanism of low - energy heavy - ion collisions is worth investigating to understand the production of chemical elements . this is deeply concerned with an open problem as for the existence and the origin of chemical elements including their production mechanism . charge equilibrium in heavy - ion reactions means the states with the proton - neutron ratio corresponding to the average of the two colliding ions , and charge equilibration is the process leading towards charge equilibrium . the chemical property of final products can be different depending on whether charge equilibration appears or not , being determined by the number of protons . there is a relatively long research history for the charge equilibration . in fact many experiments of low - energy heavy - ion collisions were carried out in the 1960 s . in those experiments most of the final products were reported to be in charge equilibrium , even when the fragmentation takes place @xcite . there should not be any restrictions to the proton - neutron ratio of the final products if the final product forms a kind of stable bound system , so that these experimental results can not be trivially understood . one of the most important features of charge equilibration is its rapidness taking as much as a few 10@xmath0 s @xcite . this time scale is actually short in the order of magnitude compared with the typical reaction time of low - energy heavy - ion collisions ( 1000 fm / c @xmath1 10@xmath2 s ) , so that charge equilibration has been recognized as an inevitable and dominant process in low - energy heavy - ion reactions . the relation between charge equilibration and the isovector giant dipole resonance has been studied relatively well because of the correspondence in their time scales , but no decisive conclusion has ever been obtained . indeed , including the question of `` when does charge equilibration take place ? '' , many things could not be explained merely by the isovector giant dipole resonance . for the theoretical research on the relation between charge equilibration and the isovector giant dipole resonance , the importance of dipole mode to charge distribution of a fissioning nucleus was pointed out by hill - wheeler @xcite in the 1950 s . research on charge equilibration using time - dependent mean field calculations were started in the 1970 s ( bonche - ng @xcite ) . recently research based on three - dimensional time - dependent mean field calculations was carried out by simenel - chomaz - de france @xcite . in this article , based on ref . @xcite , the unknown relation between charge equilibration and the zero sound propagation is presented . it leads to a rather universal recognition of zero sound propagation in femto - scale quantum liquids , which can not necessarily be reduced to the giant dipole resonance . let us denote a many - particle wave function by @xmath3 . it is assumed to satisfy @xmath4 where @xmath5 denotes the hamiltonian operator . the solution can be represented by @xmath6 under a suitable boundary condition , if @xmath5 does not depend on @xmath3 . let the corresponding probability density be @xmath7 , and begin with the classic theory of sound propagation inside gases . readers may wonder why sound propagation is related to charge equilibration , it will be clarified step by step . let the equilibrium probability density be @xmath8 . if the fluctuation is added to the equilibrium : @xmath9 a force arises from the gradient pressure . here the essential property of sound propagation is extracted from the simplified linearized analysis . the equation of motion is given by @xmath10 where @xmath11 and @xmath12 denote the velocity and the pressure , respectively . the pressure @xmath12 depends on both @xmath13 and the entropy @xmath14 . on the other hand , the equation of continuity is given by @xmath15 the right hand side is approximated by @xmath16 to the lowest order . after differentiating this equation by @xmath17 , an equality is derived together with the divergence of eq . ( [ eq2 - 1 ] ) . if we further assume that @xmath12 is expanded with respect to @xmath18 at a fixed entropy , the lowest order contribution brings about @xmath19 this is a wave equation for @xmath18 , where @xmath20 represents the propagation speed of the density . for example , @xmath20 is given by @xmath21 for the perfect fermi gas in its ground state ( @xmath22 ) , where @xmath23 means the fermi velocity . this type of propagation is called first sound , which provides a picture for particles propagating with changing density . on the other hand , we should pay attention to the propagation of particle without changing density . this type of propagation is called zero sound , which has a finite frequency even when the wave number is equal to zero ( cf . zero point vibration ) . to understand zero sound , the linear response is considered for a given external field @xmath24 : @xmath25 where @xmath26 denotes the number density operator . in particular , if we restrict ourselves to the impulsive perturbation @xmath27 , the linear response is @xmath28^{-1 } -1 \right ) , \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath29 denotes the retarded generalized dielectric function . the resonance frequency can be calculated by the pole of the integrand of the right hand side . eventually we assume the phonon dispersion relation ( @xmath30 ) , which reproduces the frequency of propagating wave , and is nonzero even when the wave number is equal to zero : @xmath31 then the resonance frequency is obtained . consequently the dispersion relation at long wave length becomes @xmath32 where @xmath33 ; @xmath34 and @xmath35 denote the mass and the fermi wave number , respectively . note that this relation is the representation in momentum space . the lower - limit of the velocity for zero sound is the fermi velocity , because the non - damping mode can only exist when @xmath36 ( see the denominator inside the logarithmic function ) . if @xmath37 is assumed in the limit @xmath38 , the left hand side becomes @xmath39 , and the propagation velocity of zero sound is represented using @xmath40 . for the weak - coupling limit ( @xmath41 ) : @xmath42 and for the strong - coupling limit ( @xmath43 ) : @xmath44 this shows that the propagation velocity of zero sound is almost equal to @xmath23 in the weak - coupling limit . it is just @xmath45 times faster than the previously seen first sound velocity of the perfect fermi gas . a rather general discussion shows that zero sound is faster than first sound @xcite . roughly speaking , the matter waves without changing density propagate more easily than those with changing density , because the change in density possibly leads to the appearance of larger restoring force . zero sound provides a picture of particle exchange within a quite short time ( but not instantaneous ) . two different sound propagations in fermi liquids have been discussed in terms of whether they entail the density change or not . in particular there exists zero sound in fermionic many - body system , which is different from and faster than the ordinary sound . zero sound has been known to arise from the collective dynamics of the fermionic many - body systems . all the collective dynamics is actually based on the propagation of zero sound , while there are various representations ( various modes ) for the collective dynamics . one distinct difference between zero and first sounds is their relation to collisions between particles . first sound appears when the states are in local thermal equilibrium . this corresponds to the situation when the mean interparticle collision time is sufficiently smaller than the oscillation period of the propagating wave . meanwhile zero sound is associated with the collective excitation mode , which disappears when there are many collisions between particles . this corresponds to the situation when the mean interparticle collision time is larger than the oscillation period of the propagating wave . although such a collisionless energy regime is expected to be realized due to the pauli principle , its validity should be confirmed for an individual physical system . consequently zero sound is expected to be important to low - energy phenomena , while first sound becomes effective at higher energies . for the usage of the terminology low and high energies , we had better note that both sounds are scaled by @xmath23 ( i.e. fermi energy ) . for more details of sound propagation , see sec . 5 of ref . @xcite . as a theoretical research on the zero sound in fermionic many - body systems , landau s fermi liquid theory @xcite is well known , where zero sound propagation was actually seen in liquid @xmath46he @xcite . however , there is no guarantee that such a sound plays a role in heavy - ion reactions . there are two essential differences between heavy - ion reactions and the @xmath47he case ; the physical system consists of finite numbers of nucleons , and the event is accomplished within a finite time interval . that is to say , both size and time are highly restricted in heavy - ion reactions . indeed , in the context of many - nucleon systems , the main interest of zero sound propagation was not in heavy - ion reactions but in nuclear vibrations ( for example , see ref . @xcite ) . in the following the mechanism of charge equilibration is discussed with respect to whether it is achieved by nucleon propagation with or without changing density . as an example of fermionic many - body systems , we consider a many - nucleon system . there are two types of nucleons , that is , protons and neutrons . charge equilibration is the mixing of protons and neutrons due to the time evolution , therefore it is a kind of chemical mixing . apart from such a chemical equilibration , there are several kinds of equilibration in heavy - ion reactions , that is , mass equilibration , momentum equilibration , and thermal equilibration . among them charge equilibration ( chemical equilibration ) has drawn special attention because of its crucial role in the synthesis of chemical elements . let us consider the collision of two ions . the existence of an upper energy limit for charge equilibration has been pointed out by iwata - otsuka - maruhn - itagaki @xcite for the first time . the limit is presented by a formula explaining both experiments and numerical calculations based on microscopic three - dimensional time - dependent mean - field theory . furthermore , the upper energy limit has been concluded to be determined by the fermi energy . @xmath48 } % \vspace{2.5 mm } \nonumber \\ \displaystyle \frac{e_{lab}}{a } = \frac{\hbar^2 ( 3 \pi^2 \rho_{\rm min})^{2/3}}{2 m } + \frac{e^2 z_1 z_2}{4 \pi \epsilon_0 r_0 } \frac{a_1 + a_2 } { a_1 a_2 ( a_1^{1/3}+a_2^{1/3 } ) } , \end{array}\ ] ] @xmath49 where @xmath50 identifies the two colliding ions , and @xmath51 means the energy in the laboratory frame . @xmath52 and @xmath53 , which satisfy @xmath54 , @xmath55 and @xmath56 , denote the masses of the two colliding ions , where @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 denote the proton and the neutron numbers of each colliding ion ( labeled by @xmath61 ) , respectively . @xmath62 and @xmath63 are parameters introduced based on ref . this formula provides an upper energy limit of charge equilibration , which arises from the nucleons propagating at the fermi velocity . in heavy - ion collisions , there are four different fermi velocities ( fermi energies ) , because there are two different kinds of nucleons and two colliding ions . the first term on the right hand side of eq . ( [ eq1 ] ) calculates those four fermi velocities . in particular , for the many - nucleon system , special structures such as skin and halo exist , and those structures change the fermi energy . these effects are taken into account in @xmath62 and @xmath63 in eq . ( [ eq1d ] ) . for the nucleon wave associated with each fermi energy to propagate throughout both colliding ions after touching , the minimum is taken in eq . ( [ eq1d ] ) . this treatment does not seem to be so important at a glance , but it contributes to derive the fact that different reactions having exactly the same composite nucleus can result in a different upper energy limit ( for the difference of upper energy limit , see fig.2 of ref . if it is not for such a treatment , we can not explain both numerical calculations and experiments . furthermore , for a correct comparison , it is necessary to estimate the relative velocity at contact time . the most considerable effect here is the deceleration due to the coulomb repulsion , which becomes prominent for cases when the masses of the colliding ions are larger . this effect is considered in the second term on the right hand side of eq.([eq1 ] ) . consequently it was confirmed in ref . @xcite that the final fragments achieving charge equilibrium drastically decrease at an incident energy higher than the energy shown in the formula . the nucleons propagating at the fermi velocity , which is represented by eqs . ( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eq1d ] ) , correspond to the propagation of zero sound . indeed , according to the calculation of the mean free path of nucleons inside nuclear matter @xcite , collisions between nucleons were shown to appear and increase rapidly if the incident energy of heavy - ion collisions becomes a few 10 % larger than the fermi energy ( of the composite nucleus ) . in such situations , zero sound itself disappears . the possible propagation speed of zero sound is not not different from the amplitude of the fermi velocity . this fact explains the reason why eqs . ( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eq1d ] are related to zero sound propagation . figure [ fig1 ] visualizes the propagation of charge equilibrating flow : neutron - rich flow from @xmath64ca ( n / z = 32/20 ) to @xmath65ca ( n / z = 16/20 ) . note here that , because this heavy - ion reaction is classified to class ii of the classification shown in fig . 1 of @xcite and the `` n / z= 1''-line is located between the initial points of @xmath64ca and @xmath65ca on the n - z plane , its charge equilibration dynamics can be measured only by the flow of neutrons . cases with two different impact parameters and two different energies are compared . the final product are different , where only the case with @xmath66 fm and @xmath671.0 mev results in fragmentation , while the other cases result in fusion . despite such significant differences in final products , the propagation speed of charge equilibrating flow is almost the same . it can be confirmed by the time evolutions of 0.75@xmath6810@xmath0 s after the neck formation ( the neck is formed at 6.0@xmath6810@xmath0 s for @xmath671.0 mev cases and 3.0@xmath6810@xmath0 s for @xmath672.0 mev cases ) . it shows that the propagation speed of charge equilibrating flow is mostly independent of the incident energy ( the relative velocity of collision ) and the impact parameter , while the total contained neutrons in neutron - rich flow depends highly on the incident energy . in particular the propagation speed of charge equilibrating flow is faster than the relative velocity of collision ( table [ tab1 ] ) . [ cols="<,^,^",options="header " , ] with respect to zero sound , what was clarified in ref . @xcite can be summarized in the following three points . first , zero sound propagation plays a role in heavy - ion collisions . second , the fast charge equilibration , which is achieved within the order of @xmath69 s , is realized as nucleon propagation without changing density . third , there exists an upper energy limit for the fast charge equilibration , which corresponds to the energy limit at which zero sound can survive . for the terminology of `` fast '' charge equilibration , it takes into account the existence of another kind of charge equilibration that has nothing to do with zero sound propagation . such charge equilibration , which appears at higher energies , is more related to the first sound . therefore its process is relatively slow compared to the fast charge equilibration , and insufficient to lead to fusion or to charge equilibrium for most fragments . charge equilibration at higher energies was also studied well ( for example , see references [ 8 - 10 , 20 - 23 ] of ref . @xcite ) . as a remark , the previous research on charge equilibration with respect to the collective dynamics is mentioned . as is discussed , charge equilibration was studied in association with the isovector giant dipole resonance . charge equilibration is sometimes related to the isovector dipole resonance , but not in all cases ; i.e. the concept of resonance is too restrictive to explain charge equilibration . nevertheless isovector giant dipole resonance means that the modes related to the composite nucleus play a role , it can not explain the different upper energy limits for different reactions having exactly the same composite nucleus . in addition , an isovector mode different from the isovector giant dipole resonance sometimes appears ( see fig . 4 of ref . although it is always true that the fast charge equilibration is achieved by the collective dynamics , the fast charge equilibration is not necessarily achieved by the isovector giant dipole resonance . apart from how and when charge equilibration takes place , here we see the reason why charge equilibration takes place . first of all , the propagation of zero sound is expected to be efficient to any kind of nucleon propagations and vibrations . the answer is obtained by clarifying the origin of charge equilibration . when the two ions have a contact during the heavy - ion collisions , large fluctuations appear in the shape and the internal structure . zero sound is expected to contribute to stabilization by changing both the shape and the internal structure , which can be understood by the contribution of each term included in the bethe - weizscker mass formula @xcite : @xmath70 where the coefficients are given by @xmath71 mev , @xmath72 mev , @xmath73 mev and @xmath74 mev , respectively @xcite . after contact , the first and second terms contribute to stabilization by changing the shape such as the volume and surface area , while the third and forth terms contribute mainly to stabilization by changing the internal structure . it is reasonable that the shape change ( including vibration ) due to zero sound propagation leads to stabilization , and we do not go further into detail . here we focus on stabilization by changing the internal structure . the effect due to the symmetry energy ( the forth term ) should play a principal role , because the coulomb energy ( the third term ) is actually small except for the collisions between very heavy ions . this symmetry energy is the principal driving force of the stabilization by changing the internal structure , and its effect acting on zero sound propagation is fast charge equilibration . the propagation of charge equilibrating flow has been visualized , and a physical interpretation has been given to the fast charge equilibration ; i.e. , the fast charge equilibration is realized by zero sound propagation . this means that the collective dynamics of the many - nucleon system and thus its fermionic statistical properties are essential to the fast charge equilibration . in this context the upper energy limit for the fast charge equilibration corresponds to the limit energy for zero sound propagation to be effective . consequently charge equilibration should be regarded as the exchange of nucleons ( charge exchange ) , because zero sound does not necessarily entail density change . as is discussed , fast charge equilibration is not a process appearing only at a certain energy . fast charge equilibration universally appears in low - energy heavy - ion reactions at energies lower than the upper energy limit , instead . here note that the fast charge equilibration process becomes operational only if the two colliding ions interact by the nuclear force . the correspondence of zero sound propagation in femto - scale systems is not only the giant dipole resonance , but also the flow propagating at the fermi velocity . indeed , the similarity between neutron - rich flow shown in fig . [ fig1 ] and the isovector giant dipole resonance is quite limited . it is suggested that a prominent role of zero sound in femto - scale systems can be experimentally detected by the appearance of the fast charge equilibration ; whether most of the final products of heavy - ion reactions are in charge equilibrium of not . + this work is based on the collaboration with profs . t. otsuka , j. a. maruhn , and n. itagaki , and supported by the helmholtz alliance ha216/emmi . the author thanks to prof . maruhn for reading the manuscript carefully . encouragement from dr . c. simenel at the initial stage of this research is acknowledged . c. simenel , ph . chomaz , and g. de france , `` quantum calculation of the dipole excitation in fusion reactions '' , phys . 86 , 2001 , pp . 2971 - 2974 ; c. simenel , ph . chomaz , and g. de france , `` fusion process studied with preequilibrium giant dipole resonance in time dependent hartree - fock theory '' , phys . c , vol . 76 , 2007 , pp . 024609 - 024622 . l. d. landau , the theory of a fermi liquid , zh . , vol . 30 , 1956 , 1058 [ soviet phys . jetp vol . 3 , 1957 , 920 ] ; `` oscillations in a fermi liquid , '' zh . eksp . 32 , 1957 , 59 [ soviet phys . jetp vol . 5 , 1959 , 101 ] . a. j. leggett , `` a theoretical description of the new phases of liquid 3he '' , rev . mod . 47 , 1975 , pp . 331 - 414 ; w. r. abel , a. c. anderson , and j. c. wheatley , `` propagation of zero sound in liquid he3 at low temperatures '' , phys rev . lett . , 1966 , vol . 74 - 78 . w. d. myers and w. j. swiatecki , `` average nuclear properties '' , ann . 55 , 1969 , pp/ 395 - 505 ; w. d. myers , `` droplet model isotope shifts and the neutron skin '' , phys . , vol . 30b , 1969 , pp . 451 - 454 . h. a. bethe and f. bacher , `` nuclear physics i. stationary states of nuclei '' , rev . mod . 36 , 1936 , pp . 82 - 229 ; c. f. von weizscker , `` zur theorie der kernmassen '' , z. physik , vol . 96 , 1935 , pp . 431 - 458 .

charge equilibration has been recognized as a dominant process at the early stage of low - energy heavy - ion reactions . the production of exotic nuclei is suppressed under the appearance of charge equilibration , in which the proton - neutron ratios of the final reaction products are inevitably averaged . therefore charge equilibration plays one of the most crucial roles in the synthesis of chemical elements . focusing on how and when the charge equilibration takes place , the zero - sound propagation in femto - scale quantum liquids is explained .

1307.6607

thermodynamics is an integral cornerstone of our understanding of the physical world , where the core principles are based on the existence of a thermal equilibrium . for systems driven out - of - equilibrium , the governing principles are much less understood ; see _ e.g. _ @xcite . it is extremely difficult to address such questions in a strongly coupled quantum system . first , given a microscopic description , conventional perturbative techniques are inadequate at strong coupling . second , conceptual insights that may lead to an effective description are also lacking . in recent years , the ads / cft correspondence@xcite , more generally the gauge - gravity duality@xcite , has emerged to be an extremely powerful tool to address aspects of strongly coupled physics . string theory provides a large class of concrete examples where this correspondence is precise . many of these examples correspond to a strongly coupled conformal or a scale - invariant field theory and is naturally equipped in describing quantum criticality . however , criticality is not necessary . the duality works for generic large-@xmath0 gauge theories with a running coupling constant@xcite , or a confining gauge theory@xcite . in this article , we will use the gauge - gravity duality to explore an emerging principle for a system driven out - of - equilibrium . we will consider a non - equilibrium steady - state ( ness ) situation within a probe sector which is kept in contact with a large background at some given temperature @xmath1 . the ness in the probe sector is induced by introducing a constant external electric field @xmath2 that drives a constant current . we will argue that _ all modes _ in this probe sector experience an effective temperature , denoted by @xmath3 , with respect to which it has a purely thermal behaviour . we will also argue that for conformal systems this effective temperature is always larger than the background temperature : @xmath4 . by virtue of the probe limit , the heat flow between the probe sector and the background is suppressed . for critical systems , @xmath3 depends only on three ingredients : ( i ) dimensionality @xmath5 , ( ii ) the global symmetry group @xmath6 and ( iii ) how ness is induced , _ i.e. _ , @xmath2 . for gapped systems , or systems with a running coupling constant , there may be additional dependences on the beta function of the gauge coupling or other dimensionful parameters in the system . the existence of the unique effective temperature @xmath3 is , nonetheless , ubiquitous . in generic situations one can verify that @xmath7 . however , there may be special cases when this is not true , see _ e.g. _ the consequences of this are rather profound : it allows us to define thermodynamics with an effective entropy , obtain a fluctuation - dissipation relation and recover an _ otherwise thermal _ physics for the ness . in this article , we will discuss the main results for a broader perspective and a technically detailed account will appear elsewhere@xcite . in the most familiar example of the ads / cft correspondence @xmath8 for a boundary theory in @xmath5 spacetime dimensions@xcite . in all known examples , the gravity description emerges from the closed string sector . this is typically described by a @xmath9-dimensional geometry of the freund - rubin type : _ e.g. _ ads@xmath10 , where ads@xmath11 denotes the anti - de sitter space in @xmath12-dimensions and @xmath13 denotes a compact manifold . the symbol @xmath14 denotes a warped product geometry . this geometry and the various matter fields are sourced by a collection of a large number of branes , which equivalently gives rise to the adjoint sector of the dual large-@xmath0 , @xmath15 gauge theory . a finite non - zero temperature is realized as the presence of an event horizon in the geometry . the corresponding hawking temperature can be obtained by demanding regularity of the euclidean metric with a compact time direction . we introduce probe degrees of freedom in the background of a thermal adjoint sector , which transform under the fundamental representation of the @xmath15 gauge group . in the full @xmath9-dimensional geometry , this can be achieved by introducing probe branes of appropriate dimensions , which amounts to introducing open string degrees of freedom in the closed - string background . the details of the probe embedding depend primarily on three factors : ( i ) dimensionality , ( ii ) stability of the embedding and ( iii ) the physics we want to realize . this was pioneered in @xcite . clearly , the full details of the @xmath9-dimensional background play a crucial role in such embeddings and each case needs to be studied individually . for simplicity , however , we will abstract away from this detailed constructions and focus on a _ reduced _ description for the probes@xcite . let us begin with a background @xmath12-dimensional metric , in the string frame , of the general form @xmath16 where we assume that the metric functions depend on only one co - ordinate @xmath17 , which is the radial direction . in our convention , @xmath18 is the boundary of the bulk spacetime . the dual field theory lives in the @xmath19-plane . furthermore , we collectively represent the compact manifold by @xmath20 . in this background we introduce @xmath21 number of probe d@xmath22-branes which wrap @xmath23 and @xmath24 of the remaining space - directions ( along with @xmath25 of the compact directions ) . the dynamics of these probes is determined by the dirac - born - infeld ( dbi ) action@xcite @xmath26 + f \right]\right)^{1/2 } , \label{dbi } \\ & = & - n_f t_p \int d^{p+1 } \xi \ , l_{\rm dbi } \ , \\ { \rm with } \quad 1 & = & \left(2 \pi \alpha'\right ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath27 denotes the tension of the d@xmath22-brane , @xmath28 denotes the collective coordinates on the brane worldvolume ( including the compact directions ) , @xmath29 is the dilaton field , @xmath30 $ ] denotes the pull - back of the background metric : @xmath31_{ab } = \frac{\partial x^\mu}{\partial \xi^a } \frac{\partial x^\nu}{\partial \xi^b } \ , g_{\mu\nu } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath32 represents a gauge field on the probe worldvolume . for simplicity , we will assume that @xmath30 $ ] is trivial , _ @xmath33 = g \right |_{\rm worldvolume}$ ] , which means that we assume @xmath34 minimizes the probe worldvolume . here , the subscript @xmath35 denotes the classical profile . note that we have implicitly assumed that the background has vanishing ns - ns two - form . this is chosen for convenience , and a non - vanishing ns - ns two - form will not modify the qualitative physics which we will discuss in this article . the steady - state physics can be induced by having a gauge field on the worldvolume @xmath36 where @xmath2 denotes the electric field along @xmath37-direction and @xmath38 is a function that needs to be determined from the equation of motion . since the dbi lagrangian depends only on @xmath32 , it is a functional of @xmath39 only . thus we immediately get an integral of motion , which we call @xmath40 @xmath41 the above definition of @xmath40 yields the equation of motion for @xmath42 , which can be solved to obtain @xmath43 evidently , the solution for @xmath42 has a sign ambiguity . this can be fixed by demanding an ingoing " boundary condition at the horizon@xcite , which means that the energy - momentum flows into the horizon . using this , the on - shell dbi lagrangian is obtained to be @xmath44^{1/2 } .\label{lagon}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in general , because of the square - root expressions , the on - shell dbi lagrangian may not be real - valued for all values of @xmath17 . the reality condition demands that the numerator and the denominator change sign at the same radial location @xmath45 . these conditions in turn determine the constant @xmath40 as a function of @xmath45 : @xmath46 here @xmath45 is obtained by solving ( [ ustar ] ) and , as observed by the bulk geometry , is a completely unremarkable position . we will see that this @xmath45 will play the key role for the open string degrees of freedom . following @xcite it can be shown that the constant @xmath40 is proportional to the boundary current driven by @xmath2 and consequently we can define a conductivity , @xmath47@xcite . so far we have discussed the classical profile of the probe brane . let us now discuss the physics of the fluctuation modes on the probe . from the perspective of the dual field theory , these fluctuations are of three kinds : ( i ) scalar , ( ii ) vector and ( iii ) spinor . the scalar fluctuations are the transverse fluctuations of the probe brane embedding : @xmath48 where @xmath49 denotes the classical profile of the probe and @xmath50 represents the collective transverse fluctuations . the vector fluctuations correspond to the fluctuations of the classical gauge field on the probe @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the classical gauge field on the probe in equation ( [ classgauge ] ) . finally , the spinors come from a supersymmetric counter - part of the dbi action in ( [ dbi ] ) , which schematically consists of a standard volkov - akulov type term @xmath53\right)^{1/2 } , \label{dbi2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath54 + f$ ] and the @xmath55 matrices satisfy anti - commutation relation with respect to @xmath30 $ ] : @xmath56_{ab } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] more precisely , the quadratic fluctuation term on a given d@xmath22-probe brane can be read of from @xcite . the computation of fluctuation modes around a particular classical brane configuration will involve inverting the matrix @xmath57 , which can then be decomposed into a symmetric and an anti - symmetric part : @xmath58 + f^{(0 ) } \right)^{-1 } \right)^{ab}= \s^{ab } + \a^{ab } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] it can be showed that@xcite @xmath59 + f^{(0 ) } } \cdot p[g ] \cdot \frac{1}{p[g]-f^{(0)}}\right)^{ab } \ , \label{osmmet } \\ \s_{ab } & = & p[g]_{ab } - \left ( f^{(0 ) } \cdot p[g]^{-1 } \cdot f^{(0 ) } \right)_{ab } \ , \\ \a^{ab } & = & - \left(\frac{1}{p[g]+ f^{(0 ) } } \cdot f^{(0 ) } \cdot \frac{1}{p[g]-f^{(0)}}\right)^{ab } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the indices are now raised and lowered with respect to the effective metric denoted by @xmath60 , which also determines the kinetic terms for the corresponding fluctuation modes . thus , the fluctuations are governed by lagrangians which take the following schematic form : @xmath61 in @xmath62 we have redefined the gamma matrices by : @xmath63 also in ( [ fscalar])-([fspinor ] ) , @xmath64 denotes an overall constant , the details of which is not relevant for us . the fields @xmath50 , @xmath65 and @xmath66 represent the various fluctuation modes and the indices @xmath67 represent the worldvolume coordinates on the probe . we have shown only the kinetic parts of the fluctuation lagrangian ; since other potential terms will not affect our conclusions . the key observation is that all these modes perceive an effective metric , denoted by @xmath60 , which is different from both the background metric @xmath68 and the induced metric @xmath30 $ ] . this is the so called _ open string metric_@xcite , which governs the dynamics of open string degrees of freedom propagating in a background geometry with an anti - symmetric @xmath69-form . the open string data , in terms of the closed string data , is given by@xcite @xmath70_{ab } - \left(f^{(0 ) } \cdot p[g]^{-1 } \cdot f^{(0 ) } \right)_{ab } , \label{osm } \\ & & \g_s = g_s \left[\frac{- { \rm det } \left(p[g ] + f^{(0)}\right)}{- { \rm det } p[g ] } \right]^{1/2 } \label{osg } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath60 and @xmath71 denote the open string metric and the open string coupling ; @xmath68 and @xmath72 denote the closed string metric and the closed string coupling . the structure of the fluctuations suggests an _ open string equivalence principle_@xcite . for the background in ( [ metgen ] ) , the embedding in ( [ embed ] ) and the gauge field in ( [ gaugeelectric ] ) , the open string metric is given by @xmath73 where we are suppressing the compact part on purpose . the various components can be given in terms of the background metric and the gauge field as @xmath74 clearly , the open string metric is non - diagonal in the @xmath75-plane . we can diagonalize this block by introducing a new coordinate system @xmath76 , which is defined as @xmath77 with this , the open string metric takes the following form @xmath78 the zeroes of @xmath79 will now determine the location of an event - horizon of the open string metric . from the definition of @xmath79 in ( [ stt ] ) , we observe that the electric field results in an event horizon of the open string metric at the location @xmath80 , which is obtained by solving ( [ ustar ] ) . subsequently , the open string equivalence principle implies an universal effective temperature in the probe sector . we can read off this temperature by requiring regularity of the euclidean open string metric and compactifying the @xmath81-direction . note that , we can not make euclidean @xmath68 and euclidean @xmath60 regular simultaneously since their respective horizons do not coincide , which implies that the background and the probe sector are not in a thermal equilibrium . carrying out the usual procedure of euclideanization of the osm , periodically identifying the imaginary time - direction and then demanding regularity yields the following formula for the effective temperature @xmath82 \right|_{u = u _ * } \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath83 . assuming an @xmath84 symmetry along the @xmath85 directions in the boundary theory , we can choose @xmath86 . in that case , this effective temperature , given in terms of the background data @xmath87 , can be recast in the following general form @xmath88^{1/2 } \right|_{u = u _ * } \label{teff}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath89 represents the beta function corresponding to the running dilaton . assuming @xmath90 , from ( [ teff ] ) it is clear that the sufficient condition to violate @xmath91 is to have @xmath92 , which will violate weak energy condition for the matter field on the classical probe profile . this is expected intuitively , since maintaining the steady - state continually pumps energy into the system and the resulting @xmath3 should be greater than @xmath1 . in the presence of a non - trivial @xmath93 , this inequality @xmath7 is not always true@xcite . the propagation of fluctuations in a dbi - background can be analyzed using the method of boillat ( see _ e.g. _ @xcite and @xcite for a more recent discussion ) . subsequently , it can be shown that the open string causal structure is determined by the boillat metric , which belongs to the same conformal class as the open string metric . typically , the boillat light - cone lies inside the einstein light - cone as long as an weak energy condition is satisfied by the matter field on the probe@xcite . this light cone structure is another manifestation of the @xmath91 inequality . this effective temperature is accompanied by an effective entropy as well . in @xcite the helmholtz free energy for such an ness probe system was conjectured for a particular system . before we generalize the proposal in @xcite , let us offer some comments regarding the validity of our analysis . the basic statement of gauge - gravity duality can be succinctly phrased as below : @xmath94 where @xmath95 corresponds to the _ bulk gravity path integral _ and @xmath96 is the field theory path integral . the quantity @xmath95 is defined as @xmath97 here @xmath98 is the @xmath9 or @xmath99-dimensional supergravity action which gives rise to the metric solution in ( [ metgen ] ) . generically , form fields of various ranks will also be present in the background . however , as we have mentioned before , these form fields will not affect our conclusions . on the other hand , @xmath100 represents the action of the probe in ( [ dbi ] ) . in terms of the gravitational description , @xmath101 since it originates from the closed string sector , whereas @xmath102 , which originates from the open string sector . clearly , the total path integral factorizes into the gravitational part and the probe part . following @xcite , or more recently @xcite , it can be argued that stringy physics can be decoupled from a purely ( super)gravity one in which one can use the gauge - gravity duality safely , as long as the curvature scale is sufficiently small compared to the string scale and the local string coupling is small enough . it is also argued in @xcite , that in the limit the local string coupling grows , one may be able to use an s - dual description or an m - theory uplift and subsequently use the corresponding gravitational description to explore the strongly coupled regime of the dual field theory . at any rate , there exists a range of energy , for which a classical gravity dual description is valid . now , as long as we have a classical gravitational description , we can certainly probe the geometry provided @xmath103 . however this condition may be too naive . in reality , in order for a brane to be a legitimate probe of a background , one needs to compute the stress - energy tensor coming from the probe , denoted by @xmath104 , to the einstein tensor of the background , denoted by @xmath105 and impose : @xmath106 the non - trivial ingredient that enters the relation in ( [ probecond ] ) is the radial - scale of the background geometry , which can override the @xmath103 limit . now , it can also be checked , _ e.g. _ if we place @xmath21 number of d@xmath107-brane probe in the near horizon geometry of a stack of d@xmath22-branes@xcite , the condition in ( [ probecond ] ) is satisfied , at least in a non - vanishing range of the energy scale ( a detailed account will appear in @xcite ) . this essentially means that we can use the purely classical gravitational description and the probe sector _ path integral _ is completely determined by the classical dirac - born - infeld contribution ( there may be wess - zumino term , but it would not change our conclusions ) . by now , this has become a common practice in gauge - gravity duality , see _ e.g. _ @xcite . now , let us comment on @xmath96 . gauge - gravity duality states that the gravitational part is dual to the adjoint sector of the large @xmath108-gauge theory and the probe sector corresponds to the fundamental flavour that has been introduced in the probe limit . likewise , we have @xmath109 here , typically @xmath110 and corresponds to the adjoint sector , while @xmath111 corresponds to the fundamental sector . at this point , one can expect that the fundamental sector is a legitimate probe in the limit @xmath103 , however , the legitimacy of the probe limit can depend on the energy - scale of the theory . recall , that the t hooft coupling is generally dimensionful , so it can set the energy - scale where back - reaction by the flavour sector becomes important . this is precisely the dual realization of the more stringent condition in ( [ probecond ] ) . and , as we have argued just below equation ( [ probecond ] ) , for a large class of examples , there exists at least a non - vanishing energy - range for which the probe limit is perfectly legitimate . for such cases , the qft path integral also factorizes between the adjoint sector and the fundamental sector . now we can introduce the standard trick of thermal field theory : first euclideanize the time direction and then compactify on it . finally the path integral is identified with the partition function and the period of the resulting @xmath112 is identified with the inverse temperature of the system . note , here we can impose two different periodicities for the adjoint and the fundamental sector , respectively . these two periodicities correspond to regularity condition of the euclidean closed - string metric in ( [ metgen ] ) and the regularity of the open string metric in ( [ osmmet ] ) . since the modes in ( [ fscalar])-([fspinor ] ) on the probe perceive the open string metric , we will focus on the latter . now we are ready to discuss the resulting _ thermodynamic _ description for the probe . we can generalize the proposal of @xcite for the current situation . let us work with the euclidean action , which we denote by @xmath113 : @xmath114 which can be obtained from ( [ dbi ] ) after substituting the ansatz for the gauge field in ( [ classgauge ] ) and then euclideanizing the resulting action . note that , all other constants and volume factors have been absorbed in the constant @xmath115 . evidently , variation of this action yields @xmath116 \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where horizon " and boundary " respectively stand for the osm horizon and the conformal boundary . generically , we can impose @xmath117 , and subsequently we need to subtract off the boundary contribution coming from @xmath118 . the boundary - terms - subtracted on - shell euclidean action is then given by @xmath119 \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the definition of @xmath40 from ( [ defj ] ) . thus the general proposal for the corresponding helmholtz free energy is given by @xmath120 where @xmath121 is given in ( [ lagon ] ) . we have evidently written down the expression in the full @xmath9-dimensional geometry . it can be noted that the conjectured free energy is essentially a legendre transformation of the on - shell euclidean probe action . the associated effective entropy is now given by @xmath122 note that , the boundary term in ( [ thermosteady ] ) contributes non - trivially in the entropy of the system . before leaving this section , let us ponder over an interesting observation . assuming that @xmath123 has a simple zero , where the closed string event horizon is located , it can be verified that @xmath124 where @xmath125 denotes the closed string event horizon , @xmath81 is a typical time - scale and @xmath126 . this time - scale which has a logarithmic divergence can be identified with the time light rays take to travel from the conformal boundary to the background event horizon . intriguingly , this time - scale appears in an ohmic dissipation term when the boundary term in ( [ thermosteady ] ) is evaluated at the closed string horizon . by evaluating this boundary term at the osm horizon , we are ir - safe in ( [ thermosteady ] ) . on the other hand , there is a natural candidate for a bekenstein - hawking type area formula involving the open string data @xmath127 . recall that a probe action scales as @xmath128 , where @xmath72 is the closed string coupling . thus , the natural area - law candidate is given by @xmath129 where @xmath130 is an undetermined constant and @xmath131 denotes the area of the open string metric event horizon . also note that both @xmath71 and @xmath131 are functions of the radial coordinate @xmath17 . for a conformal theory beyond @xmath132 , the bekenstein - hawking area formula indeed is proportional to the thermodynamic entropy obtained from ( [ thermosteady ] ) . this , however , is a simple consequence of conformal invariance . in general , ( [ ose ] ) does not yield the thermodynamic entropy obtained from ( [ thermosteady ] ) . in fact it has a different scaling behaviour with respect to the temperature . it will be very interesting to explore and understand the physical significance of ( [ ose ] ) in these general situations . let us now discuss some special cases . ( i ) for a system with @xmath133 , where ( [ seff ] ) and ( [ ose ] ) are proportional to each other , the effective entropy is observed to obey a simple relation with the conductivity @xmath134 the above relation holds for @xmath135 . \(ii ) if we assume that the dual field theory is lorentz invariant , _ @xmath136 then in the limit of strong electric field ( _ i.e. _ @xmath137 , where @xmath1 is the background closed - string metric temperature ) , we will get @xmath138 and subsequently the effective temperature takes a very generic form @xmath139^{1/2 } \ . \label{gen2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in obtaining the above relation in ( [ gen2 ] ) , we have used the conductivity obtained from ( [ ustar ] ) and ( [ current ] ) . for a given physical system obeying such relations perhaps bears the possibility of a holographic dual description . let us now briefly discuss some more specific class of backgrounds . an ads@xmath11-schwarzschild background is given by @xmath140 where @xmath141 is the radius of the ads - space . the dilaton vanishes for this background . the closed - string - background temperature is obtained to be : @xmath142 in the large and small electric field limits , which can be obtained by setting @xmath143 and @xmath144 , we get : @xmath145 interestingly , both expressions above are independent of @xmath5 . the effective temperature in the intermediate regime is given by an interpolating function which can be analytically determined from ( [ teff ] ) . the limiting scaling behaviours are simple consequences of the underlying conformal symmetry of the system . note that , the effective temperature obtained from ( [ teff ] ) by setting @xmath146 , @xmath147 and @xmath133 , we recover the results discussed in @xcite . lifshitz geometry is another special class of geometries that corresponds to a dual field theory with non - relativistic scale invariance under @xmath148 , @xmath149 . here @xmath150 is known as the dynamical exponent of the system . such geometries can be viewed as infrared fixed points that describe low energy quantum criticality , which may be relevant for condensed matter systems . as @xmath151 , the metric components take the form @xmath152 where , for convenience , the radius of the background is set to unity . for such a geometry , in the limit @xmath153 , the location of the osm event horizon obeys @xmath154 and the analogue of the relation in ( [ gen2 ] ) takes the following form @xmath155^{1/2 } . \label{gen2lif } \end{aligned}\ ] ] for an exact lifshitz geometry , where the entire bulk is defined by ( [ lifback ] ) , the effective temperature is given by @xmath156 a generalization of the lifshitz background is the so called hyper - scaling violation geometry , for which similar relations can be obtained as well . one of the profound consequences of the open string equivalence principle is the existence of a fluctuation - dissipation relation involving the effective temperature . in a system at thermal equilibrium , fluctuation - dissipation relations connect the linear relaxation response of the system to a small perturbation around the equilibrium configuration . in @xcite such a relation was obtained for the current noise in a @xmath157-dimensional theory in a steady - state . because of the open string equivalence principle , here we argue that _ all open string degrees of freedom _ in a holographic theory obey such a relation with respect to @xmath3 . this claim can be explicitly verified by calculating the boundary schwinger - keldysh two - time correlator using the holographic description , as outlined in @xcite . in a quantum field theory , the schwinger - keldysh propagator corresponds to the contour - ordered correlation function . following the notations in @xcite , we get @xmath158 here @xmath159 denotes time - ordering and @xmath160 denotes reverse time - ordering . the subscripts @xmath161 correspond to the minkowski part of the contour . on the other hand , the advanced and the retarded green s functions are also related to the schwinger - keldysh correlators _ via _ \rangle \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] from the above definitions it follows that @xmath163 where @xmath1 is the corresponding temperature . taking @xmath164 limit we obtain the fluctuation dissipation relation , which gives @xmath165 where the lhs represents the fluctuation and the bracket - ed term in the rhs represents the dissipation . in ads / cft the relation in ( [ flucdissholo ] ) emerges from the schwinger - keldysh formalism , as demonstrated in @xcite . the schwinger - keldysh computations consist of analyzing analyticity properties of various modes on the kruskal patch of the corresponding bulk spacetime . for a typical black hole geometry , fluctuation - dissipation relations physically arise from the underlying black hole thermodynamics . for the modes in ( [ fscalar])-([fspinor ] ) , this underlying thermodynamics is governed by the open string metric event horizon and thus a corresponding fluctuation - dissipation result is imminent , where the temperature in ( [ flucdissholo ] ) is replaced by the effective temperature @xmath3 . in this article , we have argued that for the holographic probe systems at ness the physics remains thermal with an effective temperature . the corresponding particle distribution functions @xmath166 at an energy @xmath167 are expected to be given by a bose - einstein or a fermi - dirac statistics involving this effective temperature . the governing principles are the existence of an open string metric event horizon and an open string equivalence principle . the origin of this effective temperature is rooted in the combined effect of thermal fluctuation from the background and a schwinger pair production which sets off the ness . we further note that the thermal nature of a similar system was noticed earlier in @xcite in describing phase transitions , and in @xcite , where it was argued that the charge transport properties on the probe can be obtained from a membrane - paradigm - type description on the open string metric event horizon , further adding to the claim of the theme of this article . in @xcite similar conclusions were arrived at using probe branes rotating along the compact directions , which inherits an event horizon on the worldvolume . it is known that for probe brane systems , t - duality symmetry of string theory transforms a spatial boost of the brane to a gauge field on the worldvolume . thus , our ness is qualitatively a t - dual description of @xcite . it is interesting to note that an underlying thermodynamic principle relates two seemingly unrelated systems by translating the induced metric horizon to an open string metric horizon . this perhaps also insinuates the deep connection between geometry and thermodynamics@xcite that may go beyond einstein gravity . for a recent article involving both an electric field and a rotation on the worldvolume , see @xcite . on the other hand , our analysis suggests that for systems out - of - equilibrium and at least in a steady - state , an effective thermal description emerges rather universally . this is evidently true for a probe sector in a large-@xmath0 gauge theory with a holographic dual , irrespective of any further details of the system . interestingly , a thermal nature for an inherently nonequilibrium process has also been observed elsewhere : earlier in @xcite-@xcite , in quantum critical systems , _ @xcite , or in aging glass system@xcite . these observations perhaps suggest a more ubiquitous presence of an effective thermodynamic description for systems out - of - equilibrium , even outside the lore of gauge - gravity duality . by construction , our holographic analysis is applicable for a fundamental probe sector in a large-@xmath0 @xmath15 gauge theory . more recent progress on holography has made it possible to understand gravitational dual descriptions for @xmath168-type gauge theories , which was originally proposed in @xcite . it is an intriguing question whether such an effective thermodynamics persists for an analogous ness situation there . our discussions have also been limited to the probe limit . beyond this limit , the probe ( fundamental ) sector and the background ( adjoint ) undergoes heat exchange since @xmath7 . eventually , after the electric field is turned off , they will reach a thermal equilibrium . this should be realized as the open string equivalence principle merging with the closed string equivalence principle and having the same event horizon in the end . it will be very interesting to explicitly construct such a time - dependent geometric example where this physics is manifest , perhaps along the lines of @xcite . we are grateful to sumit das , jacques distler , willy fischler , vadim kaplunovsky , hong liu , gautam mandal , bala sathiapalan and julian sonner for useful discussions and encouragements about this work . this material is based upon work supported by the national science foundation under grant number phy-0969020 and by texas cosmology center , which is supported by the college of natural sciences and the department of astronomy at the university of texas at austin and the mcdonald observatory . ak is also supported by a simons postdoctoral fellowship awarded by the simons foundation . j. m. maldacena , adv . * 2 * , 231 ( 1998 ) l. susskind , j. math . phys . * 36 * , 6377 ( 1995 ) n. itzhaki , j. m. maldacena , j. sonnenschein and s. yankielowicz , phys . d * 58 * , 046004 ( 1998 ) i. r. klebanov and m. j. strassler , jhep * 0008 * , 052 ( 2000 ) in recent years , interests have grown in examples where @xmath6 is the lie group with lifshitz symmetry@xcite , schrodinger symmetry@xcite or hyper - scaling violation@xcite symmetry . in all these cases , the duality also comes equipped with a bulk - to - boundary correspondence which is essential to translate the computation from one description to another . by _ reduced description _ we mean implicitly _ integrating out _ the compact directions . the underlying assumption is that such _ reduced _ or _ effective _ descriptions can be embedded in the full @xmath9-dimensional geometry . more details on this issue will be provided in @xcite . m. s. alam , v. s. kaplunovsky and a. kundu , jhep * 1204 * , 111 ( 2012 ) a. karch and a. obannon , jhep * 0709 * , 024 ( 2007 ) note that this definition is up to a constant which we are not elaborating on . for our purposes , this constant is not relevant . e. antonyan , j. a. harvey , s. jensen and d. kutasov , hep - th/0604017 . m. kruczenski , d. mateos , r. c. myers and d. j. winters , jhep * 0405 * , 041 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0311270 ] . d. mateos , r. c. myers and r. m. thomson , jhep * 0705 * , 067 ( 2007 ) [ hep - th/0701132 ] . j. sonner and a. g. green , phys . lett . * 109 * , 091601 ( 2012 ) c. p. herzog and d. t. son , jhep * 0303 * , 046 ( 2003 ) t. albash , v. g. filev , c. v. johnson and a. kundu , jhep * 0808 * , 092 ( 2008 ) j. erdmenger , r. meyer and j. p. shock , jhep * 0712 * , 091 ( 2007 ) k. -y . kim , j. p. shock and j. tarrio , jhep * 1106 * , 017 ( 2011 ) s. r. das , t. nishioka and t. takayanagi , jhep * 1007 * , 071 ( 2010 ) t. jacobson , phys . rev . lett . * 75 * , 1260 ( 1995 ) m. ali - akbari , h. ebrahim and z. rezaei , arxiv:1307.5629 [ hep - th ] . a. g. green and s. l. sondhi , phys . lett . * 95 * , 267001 ( 2005 ) .

using the gauge - gravity duality , we argue that for a certain class of out - of - equilibrium steady - state systems in contact with a thermal background at a given temperature , the macroscopic physics can be captured by an effective thermodynamic description . the steady - state is obtained by applying a constant electric field that results in a stationary current flow . within holography , we consider generic probe systems where an open string equivalence principle and an open string metric govern the effective thermodynamics . this description comes equipped with an effective temperature , which is larger than the background temperature , and a corresponding effective entropy . for conformal or scale - invariant theories , certain scaling behaviours follow immediately . in general , in the large electric field limit , this effective temperature is also observed to obey generic relations with various physical parameters in the system .

1702.02094

it is now well accepted that the giant planets of the solar system did not have the current orbits when the gas was removed from the protoplanetary disk . the first work showing that the planets had to migrate while interacting with the remaining planetesimal disk was @xcite . this work demonstrated that , in the planetesimal scattering process , on average saturn , uranus , and neptune gain angular momentum and thus migrate outwards , while jupiter loses angular momentum and moves inwards . since then , the process of planetesimal - driven migration was considered to be a fundamental one in shaping the current structure of the solar system . @xcite showed that planetesimal - driven migration can explain the origin of the orbit of pluto and of the resonant populations of kuiper belt objects . however , it appeared soon that planetesimal - driven migration alone is a process too smooth to explain several aspects of the kuiper belt s orbital distribution , e.g. the orbital excitation of the non - resonant objects . @xcite was the first paper showing that a dynamical instability of the giant planets could lead to a global orbital excitation of the kuiper belt , while delivering the giant planets on final orbits roughly similar to the current ones . building on these results , the so - called _ nice model _ @xcite combined the processes of planetesimal - driven migration and dynamical instability into a new global scenario . it suggested that the planets jupiter , saturn , uranus , and neptune formed in a compact configuration with jupiter around 5.45 au , saturn slightly interior to the 2:1 mean motion resonance ( mmr ) with jupiter ( @xmath3 @xmath4 8.65 au ) , and the initial semimajor axes of the ice giants ( uranus and neptune ) in the ranges 1113 au and 13.517 au . the planets were surrounded by a disk of leftover planetesimals , accounting for a total of about 35 @xmath5 , from @xmath016 to 30 au ( where @xmath6 is the mass of the earth ) . in this model the planets interacted with the planetesimal disk and , by planetesimal - driven migration , their mutual separations slowly increased . when jupiter and saturn crossed their mutual 2:1 mmr the full system of the giant planets became unstable and spread further through mutual close encounters . in particular , uranus and neptune were scattered onto orbits with relatively large eccentricities and semimajor axes , which crossed the original trans - neptunian disk . then , following a phase of dynamical friction caused by their interaction with the disk , the orbits of uranus and neptune damped in eccentricity and inclination . a residual planetesimal - driven migration placed the planets on orbits fairly similar to the current ones @xcite . the nice model had great success in explaining many features of our solar system , as : the capture of jupiter s trojans @xcite , the capture of the irregular satellites of the giant planets @xcite , the absence of regular moons beyond oberon s orbit at uranus @xcite , to cite a few . moreover , it was shown that , provided the inner edge of the trans - neptunian disk was at an appropriate distance from the original orbit of neptune , the giant planet instability could have occurred after hundreds of my of evolution , potentially explaining the origin of the so - called late heavy bombardment ( lhb ) of the terrestrial planets @xcite . however , the original version of the nice model presented a major problem ; the initial configuration of the planets was chosen in an ad hoc manner . @xcite performed hydrodynamical simulations of the evolution of the giant planets when they were still embedded in a disk of gas and found that the planets should have acquired a fully resonant configuration , with jupiter and saturn preferentially locked in their mutual 3:2 mmr with jupiter at @xmath05.4 au , saturn and uranus ( ice i ) in the 3:2 mmr , and uranus ( ice i ) and neptune ( ice ii ) in the 4:3 mmr ( although other resonant configurations are also possible ) . the authors also concluded that such a multi - resonant system is compatible with a subsequent evolution similar to that described in @xcite , although the instability in this case happens when a pair of planets leave the original resonant configuration , rather than when jupiter and saturn cross their 2:1 mmr . @xcite investigated whether , under some conditions , this initial multi - resonant configuration could still lead to a _ late _ giant planet instability , in order to explain the putative lhb as in the original @xcite paper . they found that late instabilities are possible , provided that the inner edge of the disk is several au s beyond the outermost planet and about 1,000 pluto - sized planetesimals are embedded in the disk , so to produce an important dynamical self - stirring of the planetesimals population . during the dynamical instability of the giant planets , several dynamical paths are possible , even when restricting the evolutions to those leading to final planetary orbits similar to the current ones . the actual dynamical evolution of the giant planets at the instability time can be constrained by investigating the consequences on the other components of the solar system : the terrestrial planets and the small body populations . the terrestrial planets and the asteroid belt give similar constraints , as investigated in @xcite and @xcite . if the orbits of jupiter and saturn migrate away from each other smoothly and slowly , as in planetesimal - driven migration , the @xmath7 secular frequency ( dominant in the precession of jupiter s longitude of perihelion ) decreases slowly in value and becomes very similar for some time to the @xmath8 secular frequency , dominant in the precession of mercury s perihelion . as a consequence , the orbit of mercury is destabilized @xcite . similarly , the @xmath9 secular frequency , dominant in the precession of saturn s perihelion , as it slows down becomes equal to the frequencies characterizing the precession of the asteroids at low inclination in the inner asteroid belt , so that this region becomes severely depleted @xcite . both papers concluded that the ratio of the orbital periods of jupiter and saturn @xmath10 had to evolve almost discontinuously from @xmath11 to @xmath12 ( the current value is @xmath13 ) . this happens if jupiter and saturn encounter another planet ( uranus or neptune or a third planet of comparable mass ) . the sequence of encounters causes a divergent jump in the semimajor axes of the orbits of jupiter and saturn , and therefore a jump in the @xmath14 ratio . this scenario is commonly known as the _ jumping - jupiter _ model . notice that if the giant planet instability occurred early , the terrestrial planets were possibly not yet fully formed and therefore the constraint on the evolution of @xmath7 relative to @xmath8 does not apply @xcite . however , the constraint set by the asteroid belt is still valid , supporting the need for a _ jumping - jupiter _ evolution regardless of the time of the instability @xcite . given that in a _ jumping - jupiter _ evolution the planet that encounters jupiter is often ejected onto a hyperbolic orbit , @xcite and @xcite suggested that the solar system had originally a third ice giant planet with a mass comparable to uranus or neptune . this scenario increases the probability that a _ jumping - jupiter _ evolution ends with four planets near their current orbits , once the putative fifth planet is ejected after its encounter with jupiter . then , @xcite considered many different initial multi - resonant configurations for jupiter , saturn , uranus , neptune , and the rogue fifth planet , and determined for each of them the probability that the @xmath14 ratio had a jump across the 2.12.3 range and the final planets reached orbits compatible with those of our current solar system . the successful simulations of @xcite have then been used to investigate again the capture of the trojans of jupiter @xcite , the capture of irregular satellites at jupiter @xcite , the excitation of the inclination of the moon iapetus at saturn @xcite , the evolution of the asteroid main belt and of its collisional families @xcite . they have also been shown to be compatible with the survival of the galileans satellites @xcite , despite of the encounters of jupiter with the ejected planet . however , when investigating the dynamical sculpting of the kuiper belt , @xcite and @xcite realized that , of all possible evolutions of neptune consistent with the five - planet _ jumping - jupiter _ model , only some are consistent with the current orbital structure of the trans - neptunian population . in order to get the correct inclinations of the hot population of the kuiper belt objects ( kbo ) , @xcite found that neptune should have migrated more that 5 au from its original resonance by planetesimal - driven migration before that the planets became unstable . this migration should have occurred on a timescale @xmath15 @xmath16 10 my , with the planet on a quasi - circular planar orbit ( @xmath17 0.1 and @xmath18 ) to avoid excessive orbital excitation of the cold classical belt , in the @xmath04245 au region . the planetary instability should have happened when neptune was already at 28 au @xcite in order to explain the so - called _ kernel _ of the cold kuiper - belt ( a clump of objects around 44 au ; @xcite ) . in this case the _ kernel _ would have formed from objects transported outwards in the 2:1 mmr with neptune and released from the resonance when neptune s orbit had a jump of about 0.5 au in semimajor axis , due to a close encounter with another planet . finally , in order to reproduce the observed ratio between the resonant and non - resonant kuiper belt populations , @xcite concluded that the planetesimal - driven migration of neptune should have been characterized by several small amplitude jumps , as those caused by a population of 1,0004,000 pluto - size objects in the disk . the brief review reported above , sets the context that motivated the study reported in this paper . it is clear that the work by @xcite needs to be revisited to test which initial resonant configurations are the most compatible with the new constraints on the dynamical evolution of neptune . this is done in the first part of the paper ( section [ early ] ) . in the second part of the paper ( section [ late ] ) we investigate whether the initial configurations selected in the first part of the work can lead to a _ late _ planetary instability , while still showing an evolution of neptune consistent with kuiper belt constraints . the possibility of a _ late _ instability is far from trivial . in fact , in order to exhibit a long - range planetesimal - driven migration before the planet instability , neptune needs to be embedded in the planetesimal disk . but in this case , neptune would start migrating away from the other planets from the very beginning of the simulation ( corresponding to the gas - removal time ) . this is likely to lead to an instability after just a few 10s of my . if instead the planetesimal disk is relatively far from neptune , the planet can be extracted from its initial resonance at a _ late _ time as in @xcite , but the instability is likely to happen as soon as the initial resonant configuration is broken , i.e. before that neptune can migrate far away . for this problem we will introduce a new concept : that of dust - driven migration , i.e. , migration due to the gravitational interaction of a planet with the dust produced in a distant planetesimal disk , spiraling inward by poyning - robertson drag . we will study the evolution of the system as a function of the dust properties and the numerical resolution used in modeling the planetesimal disk . finally , our results are summarized and discussed in section [ conclusions ] . @xcite characterized the evolution of the giant planets from several possible initial resonant configurations . they assumed that the solar system could have formed with 4 , 5 , or 6 giant planets . the additional planets had a total mass comparable to that of uranus or neptune . they analyzed the rate of success of each configuration by measuring the fraction of the planetary orbital evolutions that fulfilled a set of constraints , namely : the final planetary system is made of four giant planets ( criterion a ) , the orbits of the 4 remnant planets resemble the present ones ( criterion b ) , the proper mode of jupiter s eccentricity ( @xmath19 ) is greater than 0.022 in the final system , i.e. , at least half of its current value ( criterion c ) , and the ratio @xmath14 evolves from @xmath11 to @xmath12 in less than 1 my ( criterion d ) . criterion c is important because it is found that , although encounters between jupiter and an ice giant can excite @xmath19 , not all of them can do it as much as needed . criterion d is important because it is linked with the evolution of the terrestrial planets and of the asteroid belt @xcite . if jupiter and saturn migrate too slowly through the period ratio 2.12.3 , the @xmath20 and @xmath21 resonances sweep through the terrestrial planet region and the inner asteroid belt , resulting in orbital distributions inconsistent with those observed . then , from the success rates , @xcite concluded that a planetary system initially having 5 planets should be preferred . here , we revisit the @xcite work , adding a new constraint on the orbital evolution of neptune from the work of @xcite , namely that neptune should have migrated to @xmath028 au before the onset of the planetary instability . the works by @xcite and @xcite also give other constraints on the migration timescale of neptune and its eccentricity and inclination before the instability . the eccentricity and inclination constraints are met fairly easily because in this scenario neptune evolves in a planetesimal - driven migration without planetary close encounters until the instability phase . as for the migration timescale , @xcite claims that before the planetary instability , once out of resonance , neptune can migrate according to @xmath22 10 my for disks with 20 @xmath5 and according to @xmath22 50 my for disks with 15 @xmath5 . considering that those disks have the same extension , this exemplifies how sensitive the migration timescale can be with respect to the density of the disk . therefore , we decide not to consider the migration timescale as an important parameter at this point , because getting a correct timescale of the migration is probably only a matter of tuning the density and profile of the planetesimal disk . thus we add just one new criterion ( criterion e ) : at the time of the instability @xmath23 has to be in the interval 2729 au . while criteria a to d indicate that the initial solar system most probably hosted five giant planets @xcite , criterion e is a very important criterion that can be used to constrain in which resonant chain these five planets likely were at the end of the gas - disk phase . for simplicity , we consider only the cases of @xcite that involved 5 planets . we also always considered jupiter initially @xmath05.4 au , a distance between the outermost ice giant and the inner edge of the planetesimal disk @xmath24 1 and 2 au and extending to 30 au @xcite , composed by 1,000 planetesimals ( which is the resolution considered by @xcite ) , and two values of surface density ( @xmath25 ) equal to 0.02 and 0.03 @xmath26 . such configuration implies that the mass of the planetesimal disk ranges from @xmath013 @xmath5 ( in the more relaxed configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 2:1 5:4 au , and the three equal - mass ice - giant planets placed beyond them ] , with @xmath27 2 au and @xmath28 0.02 @xmath26 ) to @xmath065 @xmath5 ( in the more compact configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 5:4 , with @xmath27 1 au and @xmath28 0.03 @xmath26 ) . to perform our simulations , we used the hybrid integrator in the _ mercury - package _ @xcite , with a time step of half an year . table [ table1 ] gives in column 6 the rate of success for our new criterion e , after 20 runs of each initial configuration from ( * ? ? ? * table 6 in their paper ) . those 20 simulations were composed by 5 simulations for each pair @xmath29 [ 1,2 ] au , and @xmath28 [ 0.02 - 0.03 ] @xmath26 . although we have used two different values of surface density and two values of @xmath30 for the planetesimal disk , we decided to compress the results of all 20 simulations , for each configuration , in table [ table1 ] , column 6 . this is because , concerning our criterion e , only minor differences were observed with these changes . thus , when important , those minor differences will be reported . for completeness and to increase statistics , table [ table1 ] also reports the average of the rate of success for the other criteria taken from ( * ? ? ? * table 6 in their paper ) . because the simulations performed in this work are essentially the same of @xcite , the success rate for criteria a to d are consistent ( within the small number statistics ) with those reported in @xcite thus , we did not report our own results for the criteria a , b , c , and d. rather than that , we decided to check only the success rate relative to the new criterion e , and then , combine our findings with those of @xcite , which have much higher statistics , in order to determine which of the initial planetary configurations are the most compatible with the constraint on the dynamical evolution of neptune , unveiled in @xcite . lccccc 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 5:4 & 24 & 12 & 0 & 2 & 5 + 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 & 30 & 15 & 2 & 5 & 15 + 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 4:3 & 47 & 23 & 3 & 3 & 5 + * 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 * & * 32 * & * 13 * & * 4 * & * 7 * & * 65 * + 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 2:1 & 38 & 18 & 4 & 4 & 25 + 2:1 , 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 & 53 & 40 & 2 & 18 & 0 + 2:1 , 4:3 , 3:2 , 3:2 & 73 & 33 & 0 & 18 & 40 + our results can be interpreted as follows : : in these configurations , as it also appears in ( * ? ? ? 16 ) , it is possible that neptune leaves the resonant configuration and migrates ahead the other planets , but not always in the way required in @xcite . indeed , a configuration with initial resonances 2:1 , 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 never lead to an instability that fulfilled criterion e in our 20 simulations . the evolutions from the 2:1 , 4:3 , 3:2 , 3:2 configuration , on the other hand , had one of the largest rate of success for criterion e. however , such configurations present other major problem , mostly concerning the final orbital separation between jupiter and saturn , which is typically too big . the point is that , because the ratio @xmath14 has to change less than 0.5 if jupiter and saturn are initially in the 2:1 mmr , the mass of the fifth planet should be @xmath01/2 of the mass of neptune . instead , we assumed for this planet a mass equal to that of uranus - neptune , as in @xcite . a smaller mass planet , however , would not excite jupiter s eccentricity enough , so that the criterion c would not be fulfilled . moreover , hydrodynamical simulations @xcite show that in a massive gas - disk , jupiter and saturn would be locked in their mutual 3:2 mmr , rather than 2:1 . the grand tack model @xcite also implies that jupiter and saturn were in their 3:2 mmr at the disappearance of the disk of gas . so , we do nt consider that configurations with jupiter and saturn in the 2:1 mmr are very realistic . : these two configurations are too compact . only one out of 20 simulations for each configuration fulfilled criterion e. usually , the evolution of the planetary system is as in ( * ? ? ? 7 ) , where the instability takes place as soon as one planet goes out of resonance . as a result , no large - range planetesimal - driven migration occurs before the planetary instability . instead , the instability is violent and the evolution of neptune is largely different from that constrained in @xcite ( figure [ fig1 ] top left , in this work ) . nevertheless , although they are low , none of the success rates reported in table [ table1 ] for the configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 4:3 are null . thus , even being very unlikely , due to the reasons presented , this configuration can not be ruled out . : this configuration is too loose . @xcite already pointed out that neptune stops farther than 30 au for whatever reasonable disk s parameters starting for this configuration . here , we found that even with the planetesimal disk of lowest mass ( @xmath31 [ 1324 ] @xmath5 ) , ranging from @xmath32 [ 25(26)30 ] au , neptune goes out of resonance and usually migrates all the way up to 30 au or more , before that the planetary instability happens ( figure [ fig1 ] top right ) . however , sometimes the instability can also occur before neptune reaches 30 au , say at @xmath028 au . therefore , although this configuration may also present some problems with the extension of the planetesimal disk , as it will be discussed in the following sections , it does have a good rate of success in fitting criterion e ( 25% success rate ) . : this configuration allows neptune to migrate away from the other planets before the instability , but usually not enough . the instability commonly happen when neptune is around 20 au ( see * ? ? ? * figs 8 and 9 , and figure [ fig1 ] bottom left in this work ) . only for high density disks neptune can migrate fast enough and reach @xmath028 au before the planetary instability . if the disk s density is low , neptune migrates slowly and ca nt go too far into the planetesimal disk . so , this configuration has a low , but non - negligible , success rate of 15% and can not be ruled out . : this is the configuration that presents the highest rate of success , considering all criteria together , so that it is highlighted in bold in table [ table1 ] . this is also the most successful configuration relative to criterion e , with a success rate of 65% independently of the disk setup . the evolution of neptune and of the rest of the planetary system is usually similar to that shown in ( * ? ? ? * figs 12 , 13 , and 14 ) , and satisfies the constraint identified in @xcite ( figure [ fig1 ] bottom right in this work ) . figure [ fig1 ] shows examples of the evolution of the systems corresponding to the descriptions given for each of the resonant chains discussed above ( with the exception of the 2:1 jupiter - saturn resonance , due to the considerations previously made ) . almost all evolutions depicted in figure [ fig1 ] fulfill the criteria a , b , c , and d. criterion c was not fulfilled only for the configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 4:3 ( top left ) , where , although the eccentricity of jupiter was excited during the instability , it was quickly damped afterwards ( @xmath33 0.0075 ) due to the strong dynamical friction provided by the planetesimal disk . only the configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 ( bottom right ) fulfilled all constraint together , including our new criterion e. summarizing , when the new constraints on the evolution of neptune from @xcite are considered , the most probable initial configuration of the giant planets was 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 . the configurations 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 2:1 , and 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 , or 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 4;3 also appear possible , but less probable . this seems to be a consequence of the more relaxed orbital separation between the first and second ice giants . therefore , one would expect that any configuration having the first and the second ice giant in distance from the sun in a 2:1 mmr or similarly relaxed could perhaps also work . however , for simplicity , we decide to restrict ourselves only to the cases of @xcite , which we know the rate of success in filling criteria a , b , c , and d. the analysis performed in this section does not take into account the timing of the planetary instability . with the location of the inner edge of the disk that we adopted , all evolutions are relatively fast , and lead to instabilities after a few 10s my . in the next section we analyze whether it is possible to get a late instability out of the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 configuration , under some assumption on the geometry of the disk , still satisfying criterion e on the evolution of neptune . since @xcite presented the _ nice model _ , the existence of a late heavy bombardment of the terrestrial planets has been associated to the possibility that the giant planet instability occurred after hundreds of my of evolution @xcite . actually , the nice model , both in its initial version and from generic initial resonant configurations @xcite , is compatible with both early and late instabilities , depending on the distance of the inner edge of the original trans - neptunian disk and other disk properties ( mass , excitation , etc . ) . thus , the nice model does not prove the existence of a late instability . the timing of the instability can only be determined by looking at other constraints , such as the lunar impact chronology . unfortunately , the latter is still under debate . however , it is not obvious that the nice model can still be compatible with a late instability , if we fix a specific initial resonant configuration and impose a specific evolution of neptune . as explained in the introduction , if the disk is sufficiently close to neptune at the beginning , it is relatively easy that neptune migrates several au away before that the instability happens , but in this case the full dynamical evolution is rapid , as in the previous section . if the initial location of the disk is sufficiently far from neptune , the instability may happen late , but neptune is unlikely to migrate significantly before that the instability happens . moreover , in the case of the most relaxed resonant configurations ( e.g. 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 2:1 , which has neptune initially around @xmath024.5 au ) , the requirement that the inner edge of the disk is several au beyond neptune while the outer edge is at @xmath030 au reduces the disk to a ring . this seems implausible , particularly when considering the constraint that the disk should have hosted 1,000 - 4,000 pluto - size bodies @xcite , which would probably be problematic for the late instability as well , because the spreading of the narrow disk would not permit a delay . if one could show that the most developed and constrained version of the nice model is incompatible with a late instability , this would be very important to clarify the chronology of events in the solar system . thus , in this section we try hard to find whether the instability could have happened late and under which conditions . we let the reader judge whether these conditions are realistic or plausible , with our considerations summarized in sect . [ conclusions ] . for this goal , we proceed in steps . first , in sect . [ dr ] , we determine two critical values for the distance of the inner edge of the disk from neptune . one , @xmath34 , is the maximal distance that allows neptune to have a long - range planetesimal - driven migration away from the other planets , as in the previous section . the other one , @xmath35 is the minimal distance of the disk for which the five - planet system remains stable in resonance for all times . clearly @xmath36 and @xmath34 is larger than or equal to the neptune - disk distances considered in the previous section . the problem is that both @xmath35 and @xmath34 depend on disk resolution ( number of planetesimals and individual masses that are used to model the disk ) and that realistic values can not be used in practical simulations . so , we need to estimate trends to evaluate the values of the critical distances . in a second step , in sect [ de ] , we study how a flux of dust from the planetesimal disk , due to collisional planetesimal grinding and poynting - robertson drag , influences planet migration . this depends on total mass flux and individual dust size . the idea is that , under an appropriate dust - flux , neptune may migrate away from its initial location , so that its distance from the planetesimal disk decreases from @xmath37 to @xmath38 . at this point planetesimal - driven migration starts , as in the previous section . if the dust - driven migration is slow enough , the planet instability can occur late , even though it occurs only a few millions of years after the beginning of planetesimal - driven migration . this concept is then proven in section [ dde ] , where we combine in a single simulation dust - driven migration and planetesimal - driven migration , and we obtain an instability after 300 my , with neptune s evolution satisfying criterion e. this simulation is of course performed with an unrealistically low disk - resolution , but is a proof of concept that , for whatever disk resolution , an appropriate dust flux can be found . we finally discuss what a realistic dust flux could be in sect . [ dgl ] the interaction of a planetary system with a planetesimal disk can be very resolution - dependent , i.e. , sensitive on the number of planetesimals used to described the disk in the simulation and to their individual mass . in some cases , as in those of section [ early ] , this problem of sensitivity on disk - resolution is not strong because the distance between the outermost planet and the inner edge of the disk is small , so that there are from the very beginning many planetesimals on unstable orbits that encounter the planet , force its migration and , consequently , bring many new planetesimals to planet - crossing orbit . this is the reason for which @xcite found similar results for test simulations conducted with 100 , 300 , 1,000 , 3,000 , and 10,000 planetesimals in the disk ( same total disk masses ) , so that they decided to use only 1,000 planetesimals in their final simulations . of course , even in these cases , the disk resolution has an influence on how grainy or smooth the planet migration will be , but does nt have a major influence on the amplitude and the timescale of the migration . on the other hand , the resolution of the planetesimal disk becomes a real issue when the inner edge of the disk is far enough from the outermost planet . in this situation , the fraction of the disk that is unstable is small , mostly limited to the volume of the strongest mean motion resonances with the planet . the resonant planetesimals develop planet - crossing eccentricities and , with close encounters , force the planet to move a bit outwards . this moves outwards the resonances as well , destabilizing new planetesimals ( those which were not in resonance at the beginning but are swept by the resonant motion ) . depending on whether the mass of the new unstable planetesimals is larger or smaller than the mass of the original unstable planetesimals , the planet migration will accelerate or damp @xcite . in the damped migration mode , the planet eventually stops migrating while the resonances become empty . if the number of planetesimals is small , the planetesimals are individually more massive to represent a disk with the same total mass . thus , the migration of the planet is more grainy because each encounter between the planet and a planetesimal causes a larger jump in the planet s semimajor axis . of course , there are fewer jumps , so that the planet migrates , on average , by the same amount . but the more jumpy migration of the planet causes the resonances to jump around as well , thus destabilizing more mass from the disk than in the case of a smoother planet migration with the same averaged range . because more mass is transferred from the disk to planet - crossing orbit , the migration of the planet can change , in some cases , from the damped to the accelerated mode . with this issue in mind , we proceed in our study looking for two critical disk distances , for a series of disk resolutions . first , we look for the minimum distance ( @xmath1 ) that the inner edge of the planetesimal disk has to have from neptune ( the outermost planet for our case ) in order to maintain the planets stable for at least 400 my . second , we search for the maximal distance ( @xmath2 ) that neptune can have from the inner edge of the planetesimal disk to evolve as in section [ early ] . from these results we will extrapolate the values of @xmath1 and @xmath2 to realistic almost infinite resolution . once again we consider disks with fixed surface densities ( scaling as @xmath40 ) , because in this case we guarantee always the same amount of mass in the planets mmrs , independently of the resolution of the disk ( apart from stochastic sampling ) . the initial distribution of eccentricity and inclination of the disk was such that @xmath41 and @xmath42 ( the same initial distribution for all disks considered in this work ) . this is the simplest configuration that represents a cold planetesimal disk emerging from the end of the dissipation of the gas nebula . even if the disk was initially more dynamical excited not much differences in the overall evolution are expected because the mmrs inside the disk are very efficient in exciting the disk s eccentricities to planet - crosser values . so , in a very short timescale an initially cold disk would appear like an initially excited one . finally , we consider disks with resolution of 1,000 , 5,000 , 10,000 , 15,000 , and 20,000 planetesimals . the outer edge of the disk is fixed at 30 au . the distance @xmath30 between the inner edge of the disk and the planet ranges from 1 to 7 au , with increments of 1 au . given the great demand of cpu - time required to simulate high - resolution disks , we only considered the most successful initial configuration in section [ early ] , with planets in the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 and 3:2 mmrs . for this configuration , neptune is initially @xmath020 au . for each value of @xmath30 , we considered six different values of @xmath43 . .@xmath1 as a function of @xmath43 for the less resolved planetesimal disk ( 1,000 planetesimals ) . @xmath1 : minimum distance that the inner edge of the planetesimal disk has to have from neptune ( the outermost planet for our case ) in order to maintain the planets stable for at least 400 my . @xmath43 : density of the planetesimal disk , scaled as @xmath40 . the mass of the planetesimal disk , @xmath44 , in earth masses , for each pair @xmath43@xmath1 for the initial configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 , with neptune at @xmath020 au and outer disk edge at 30 au is also shown for reference . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the results of the proof of concept " simulation are shown in figures [ fig4 ] and [ fig5 ] . figure [ fig4 ] shows the evolution of the semimajor axis ( @xmath45 ) , the perihelion distance ( @xmath46 ) and the aphelion distance ( @xmath47 ) for all planets as a function of the time . figure [ fig5 ] brings snapshots of the ( @xmath45 @xmath39 @xmath48 ) and ( @xmath45 @xmath39 @xmath49 ) of the whole system for different times of the evolution ] . the evolution shown in these figures has an instability after about 300 my and the evolution of the planets is in a considerably good agreement with that deduced in @xcite from kuiper belt constraints . particularly , the instability happens when neptune is at @xmath50 au as required . moreover , as we can see from these figures , the evolution of neptune before the onset of the instability , follows closely the assumptions / predictions of tables [ table2 ] and [ table3 ] , and the dust mechanism of section [ de ] . the instability did not happen precisely at the time we targeted , due to the approximations inherent in our linear combination of different processes , which in reality have a non - linear interplay . nevertheless , the instability happens late enough to suggest that the association between a planetary instability and the trigger of the late heavy bombardment is indeed possible . to assess whether the dust fluxes that are needed to migrate neptune into the disk ( see table [ table3 ] ) are reasonable , we turned to the simulation presented in the supplementary material ( s4 ) of @xcite . that simulation considered a disk with initially 60 earth masses , extended from 21 to 34 au the disk was quite excited in eccentricity and inclination within 27 au and dynamically cold beyond it . the planetesimals were assumed to have a size - frequency distribution ( sfd ) similar to that of the hot kuiper belt population in the inner part of the disk ( r @xmath4 27 au ) and similar to that of the cold kuiper belt population beyond it . both sfds were scaled up in number so that the masses in the inner disk and outer disk were respectively 1/3 and 2/3 of the total . the collision probabilities and impact velocities within particles in the inner part of the disk , the outer part or in different parts were evaluated to be @xmath51 km@xmath52y@xmath53 and 0.83 km / s , @xmath54 km@xmath52y@xmath53 and 0.25 km / s , @xmath55 km@xmath52y@xmath53 and 0.68 km / s , respectively . the collisional evolution simulations were conducted with the code boulder , developed in @xcite . the specific impact energy for collisional disruption was assumed to be 1/3 of that of strong ice @xcite . according to these simulations , the disk produced 32 earth masses of dust in 400 my . a total mass of 32 earth masses is big compared to the numbers in table [ table3 ] . on the other hand , not all this dust would survive all the way to neptune - crossing orbit , because the collisional cascade in the dust population comminute grains until they reach the ejection limit @xmath56 . this part of the collisional cascade is not modeled in the boulder code . also , the total amount of dust produced could be reduced by truncating the initial sfd to objects larger than some limit size ; in a new simulation where we retained only bodies with @xmath57 km in the initial sfd the total dust production is reduced to 15 earth masses . another possibility is to increase the specific energy of disruption for the bodies . in fact , @xcite revised the previous estimates of @xcite and concluded that the specific energy for disruption should be similar to that for strong ice in @xcite . a simulation with an initial truncated sfd but with a specific disruption energy 3 times larger produced only 7 earth masses of dust . even more simply , reducing the initial population in the disk would reduce the amount of dust produced , given that the dust production scales as the square of the number of planetesimals in the disk . in conclusion , we think that the dust fluxes listed in table [ table3 ] , required to cause a significant migration of neptune , are reasonable and in the good ballpark of what a massive planetesimal disk can produce . a more relevant problem is the dust production timeline . in the boulder experiments described above , the dust production decays as @xmath58 . in the boulder simulations , the collisional evolution of the dust is not tracked . but the dust collisional lifetime should scale as the square root of the dust production . consequently , the total amount of dust of a given size ( or @xmath59 ) should evolve with time as @xmath60 . because the migration of the planet is linear in the amount of dust that it encounters , the evolution of its semimajor axis should be proportional to @xmath61 . this means that , of the total migration range spanned in -say- 400 my , 1/2 of it is covered in the first 100 my and 13% in the last 100 my . in other words , the time to reach @xmath2 is proportional to @xmath62 , instead of being proportional to @xmath63 as in the case of a linear evolution ( where @xmath64 is @xmath65 au ) . thus , small changes in the flux can make the curve @xmath66 to reach @xmath2 distance early or very late . obtaining a late instability around 400 my requires a more delicate tuning of the dust production than that done in sect . [ dde ] , where we considered that the dust production is constant and the collisional lifetime of dust infinite . it is very likely that , at the disappearance of the protoplanetary disk of gas , the giant planets of the solar system were all in mean motion resonances with each other , because this is the typical outcome of gas - driven planet migration @xcite . @xcite investigated which resonant configurations are more likely to reproduce the current orbital configuration of the giant planets via a phase of dynamical instability , as that described in the nice model . they considered four criteria of success and found a number of initial configurations that meet all of them in a non - negligible fraction of the simulations . all these configurations require the existence of a fifth giant planet , with a mass comparable to those of uranus or neptune , eventually ejected during the instability . more recently , @xcite showed that explaining and reproducing the current orbital structure of the kuiper belt requires that neptune had a specific evolution , reaching a heliocentric distance of @xmath028 au by planetesimal - driven migration before that the instability happened . thus , in section [ early ] of this paper , we have revisited the work of @xcite , adding a new criterion of success from the results of @xcite . of the configurations selected by @xcite , the one denoted 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 ( each integer ratio referring to the mean motion resonance between a pair of adjacent planets ) stands out as the more likely to fulfill the new criterion of success . other configurations ( the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 2:1 , the 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 , and the 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 4:3 ) can not be excluded , but their success rate relative to the new criterion is significantly lower . an open issue with the nice model is the timing of the giant planet instability . if one wants to explain the late heavy bombardment of the moon as a spike in the impact crater rate @xcite , the instability has to have happened late @xcite , unlike in the simulations of section [ early ] , in which the instability occurred after a few 10s of my . it is not obvious that a 5-planet resonant configuration can remain stable for long time and become unstable then , particularly with a specific evolution of neptune as that required to sculpt the kuiper belt . thus , in section [ late ] we investigated whether a late instability from the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 is possible and under which conditions . first , we looked for characteristics of the planetesimal disk that can maintain the planets in stable orbits for 400 my . we found that the evolution and stability of the planets are very sensitive to the resolution of the planetesimal disk . thus , we determined the minimum distance that the inner edge of the planetesimal disk has be away from neptune to keep the planets in stable orbit for 400 my as a function of the surface density of the disk and its numerical resolution . we named this distance @xmath1 ( table [ table2 ] ) . in a second step , we found a characteristic neptune - disk distance , which we named @xmath2 , from where neptune starts a long - range planetesimal - driven migration . thus , for the system to exhibit a late instability together with an evolution of neptune like the one that is needed to sculpt the kuiper belt , neptune needs to be extracted from the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 resonance chain , and to migrate outwards over hundreds of mys until it reaches the distance @xmath2 . to understand how this could be possible , we introduced the concept of dust - driven migration , i.e. , migration due to the gravitational interaction of a planet with the dust produced in a distant planetesimal disk , spiraling inward by poyning - robertson drag . we have shown that a late instability can be achieved when considering a flux of dust ( @xmath67 ) ranging from 7 to 22 @xmath5 per 400 my , depending on the value of @xmath1 ( table [ table3 ] ) . continuing , in section [ dgl ] we evaluated how much dust could be produced from the disk - like configurations that we assumed and found good agreement with the dust flux described above . indeed , we found that the total amount of dust produced in 400 my may vary from @xmath07 @xmath5 to a maximum of about 32 @xmath5 depending on the size frequency distribution ( sfd ) and catastrophic disruption energies assumed for the planetesimal disk and its constituents . finally , we also found that the dust production rate expected for a self - grinding disk is not constant , but it decays as @xmath58 . the abundance of dust , which is also limited by the dust collisional lifetime , should decay as @xmath60 . thus , because the migration of the planet is linear in the amount of dust that it encounters , the evolution of its semimajor axis should be proportional to @xmath61 , which implies that small changes in the flux of dust can result in neptune reaching @xmath2 distance early or very late . therefore , obtaining a late instability around 400 my requires a more delicate tuning of the dust production . summarizing , based on the work of @xcite , and considering the evolution of neptune required to explain the structure of the kuiper belt @xcite , our results indicate that the preferred initial configuration of the giant planets at the time of the dissipation of the gas nebula is the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 , and that , although an early instability reproduces more easily the evolution of neptune required to explain the structure of the kuiper belt , such evolution is also compatible with a late instability . we thank an anonymous reviewer for useful comments and suggestions on the submitted manuscript . r.d . acknowledges support provided by grants @xmath682015/18682 - 6 and @xmath682014/02013 - 5 , so paulo research foundation ( fapesp ) and capes . a.m. acknowledges support by the french anr , project number anr-1313-bs05 - 0003 - 01 projet mojo ( modeling the origin of jovian planets ) . r.s.g . acknowledges his grant no . 307009/2014 - 9 from cnpq , conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico , brazil . the work of d.n . was supported by the nasa emerging worlds program . 99 batygin , k. , brown , m. e. , & betts , h. 2012 , , 744 , l3 benz , w. , & asphaug , e. 1999 , , 142 , 5 bottke , w. f. , vokrouhlick , d. , minton , d. , et al . 2012 , , 485 , 78 brasil , p. i. o. , roig , f. , nesvorn , d. , et al . 2016 , , 266 , 142 brasser , r. , morbidelli , a. , gomes , r. , tsiganis , k. , & levison , f. h. 2009 , 134 , 1790 burns , j. a. , lamy , p. l. , & soter , s. 1979 , , 40 , 1 chambers , j. e. 1999 , , 304 , 793 deienno , r. , yokoyama , t. , nogueira , e. c. , callegari , n. jr . , & santos , m. t. 2011 , , 536 , a57 deienno , r. , nesvorn , d. , vokrouhlick , d. , & yokoyama , t. 2014 , , 148 , 25 deienno , r. , gomes , r. s. , walsh , k. j. , morbidelli , a. , & nesvorn , d. 2016 , , 272 , 114 fernandez , j. a. , & ip , w .- h . 1984 , , 58 , 109 fernandez , j. a. , & ip , w. h. , 1996 , , 44 , 431 gomes , r. s. , morbidelli , a. , & levison , h. f. 2004 , , 170 , 492 gomes , r. s. , tsiganis , k. , morbidelli , a. , & levison , h. f. 2005 , , 435 , 466 izidoro , a. , morbidelli , a. , raymond , s. n. , hersant , f. , & pierens , a. 2015 , , 582 , a99 kaib , n. a. , & chambers , j. e. 2016 , , 455 , 3561 leinhardt , z. m. , & stewart , s. t. 2009 , , 199 , 542 leinhardt , z. m. , & stewart , s. t. 2012 , , 745 , 79 levison , h. f. , morbidelli , a. , gomes , r. , & backman , d. 2007 , protostars and planets v , 669 levison , h. f. , morbidelli , a. , vanlaerhoven , c. , gomes , r. , & tsiganis , k. 2008 , , 196 , 258 levison , h. f. , bottke , w. f. , gounelle , m. , et al . 2009 , , 460 , 364 levison , h. f. , morbidelli , a. , tsiganis , k. , nesvorn , d. , & gomes , r. 2011 , , 142 , 152 nesvorn , d. , vokrouhlick , d. , & morbidelli , a. 2007 , , 133 , 1962 nesvorn , d. 2011 , , 742 , 22 nesvorn , n. & morbidelli , a. 2012 , , 144 , 117 nesvorn , d. , vokrouhlick , d. , & morbidelli , a. 2013 , , 768 , 45 nesvorn , d. , vokrouhlick , d. , & deienno , r. 2014 , , 784 , 22 nesvorn , d. , vokrouhlick , d. , deienno , r. , & walsh , k. j. 2014 , , 148 , 52 nesvorn , d. 2015 , , 150 , 73 nesvorn , d. 2015 , , 150 , 68 nesvorn , d. , & vokrouhlick , d. 2016 , , 825 , 94 malhotra , r. 1993 , , 365 , 819 malhotra , r. 1995 , , 110 , 420 morbidelli , a. , levison , h. f. , tsiganis , k. , & gomes , r. 2005 , , 435 , 462 morbidelli , a. , tsiganis , k. , crida , a. , levison , f. h. , & gomes , r. 2007 , , 134 , 1790 morbidelli , a. , bottke , w. f. , nesvorn , d. , & levison , h. f. 2009 , , 204 , 558 morbidelli , a. , brasser , r. , gomes , r. , levison , h. f. , & tsiganis , k. 2010 , , 140 , 1391 moro - martin , a. 2013 , planets , stars and stellar systems . volume 3 : solar and stellar planetary systems , 431 petit , j .- m . , kavelaars , j. j. , gladman , b. j. , et al . 2011 , , 142 , 131 . pierens , a. , & nelson , r. p. 2008 , , 482 , 333 roig , f. , & nesvorn , d. 2015 , , 150 , 186 tera , f. , papanastassiou , d. a. , & wasserburg , g. j. 1974 , earth and planetary science letters , 22 , 1 thommes , e. w. , duncan , m. j. , & levison , h. f. 1999 , , 402 , 635 toliou , a. , morbidelli , a. , & tsiganis , k. 2016 , , 592 , a72 tsiganis , k. , gomes , r. s. , morbidelli , a. , & levison , h. f. 2005 , , 435 , 459 walsh , k. j. , & morbidelli , a. 2011 , , 526 , a126 walsh , k. j. , morbidelli , a. , raymond , s. n. , obrien , d. p. & mandell , a. m. 2011 , , 475 , 206

recent works on planetary migration show that the orbital structure of the kuiper belt can be very well reproduced if before the onset of the planetary instability neptune underwent a long - range planetesimal - driven migration up to @xmath028 au . however , considering that all giant planets should have been captured in mean motion resonances among themselves during the gas - disk phase , it is not clear whether such a very specific evolution for neptune is possible , nor whether the instability could have happened at late times . here , we first investigate which initial resonant configuration of the giant planets can be compatible with neptune being extracted from the resonant chain and migrating to @xmath028 au before that the planetary instability happened . we address the late instability issue by investigating the conditions where the planets can stay in resonance for about 400 my . our results indicate that this can happen only in the case where the planetesimal disk is beyond a specific minimum distance @xmath1 from neptune . then , if there is a sufficient amount of dust produced in the planetesimal disk , that drifts inwards , neptune can enter in a slow dust - driven migration phase for hundreds of mys until it reaches a critical distance @xmath2 from the disk . from that point , faster planetesimal - driven migration takes over and neptune continues migrating outward until the instability happens . we conclude that , although an early instability reproduces more easily the evolution of neptune required to explain the structure of the kuiper belt , such evolution is also compatible with a late instability .

1507.04930

the recent appearance of tags in large online datasets represents a significant innovation in categorisation @xcite . tags allow multiple categories for each item , and tagging can be done in a bottom - up approach , in a parallel manner , by several users simultaneously @xcite . this feature allows the tagging of huge datasets in a reasonable time . in contrast , traditional hierarchical categorisation typically allows one category per item , and it is done by a few experts , slowing down the process . also , available categories are restricted in traditional expert - made hierarchies , while user given tags are usually allowed to take any expression deemed relevant by the user . although there is no prescribed structure between the tags , it is a reasonable assumption that tags are attached to objects according to hidden hierarchical relations , e.g. , `` poodle '' is usually considered as a special case of `` dog '' . consequently , it is an interesting non - trivial task to extract this implicit hierarchy from the co - appearance of tags solely . indeed , a number of different methods have already been proposed in the literature , such as aggregation of user - defined shallow hierarchies for obtaining a global hierarchy @xcite , integration of information from as many sources as possible @xcite , using a probabilistic criterion to define parent - child relations @xcite , applying pairwise similarities to centrality - ordered tags @xcite , or building up the hierarchy from bottom up based on the z - score between the tags @xcite . beside the organisation of different keywords or categories describing a given topic , signs of hierarchy are prevalent in a very wide range of systems . among others , the transcriptional regulatory network of escherichia coli @xcite , the dominant - subordinate hierarchy among crayfish @xcite , the leader - follower network of pigeon flocks @xcite , the rhesus macaque kingdoms @xcite , neural networks @xcite , technological networks @xcite , social interactions @xcite , urban planning @xcite , ecological systems @xcite , and evolution @xcite all show signs of hierarchical organisation . different approaches were introduced to uncover hierarchy in networks , including the introduction of hierarchy measures @xcite , statistical inference of hierarchy @xcite and construction of hierarchical network models @xcite . here we analyse the hierarchies obtained for the scientific keywords from the web of science @xcite by applying a recent generalisation of the method given in ref.@xcite presented in @xcite . we treat the set of author given tags and the set of repository given tags separately , resulting in two alternative hierarchies . these are compared to each other and also to the 3-level classification of categories given by the web of science . the organisation of the paper is the following : in sect . [ s : pre ] we introduce the tag hierarchy construction methodology and describe the datasets to which it is applied . the obtained hierarchies are presented in sect . [ s : results ] , while the results are discussed in sect . [ s : concl ] . in order to obtain a tag hierarchy , we will follow the method described in @xcite and @xcite , for which a quick overview is provided here . given a set of objects and each object having a set of tags , the goal is to construct a hierarchy , i.e. , a directed acyclic graph ( dag ) of the tags , where links are directed from more general concepts to more special ones . our method constructs a hierarchy in two steps : first the tags are ordered , defining which tag should be placed higher in the hierarchy and which lower , then for each tag an appropriate parent is chosen . note , that in the second step here we allow to choose more than one parent for a tag , hence the resulting hierarchy can be more complex than a simple tree . for the reader who is not familiar with the method @xcite we briefly summarize the main steps below . first we rank first the tags according to the eigenvector centrality of the tag - coappearence graph . nodes in the co - appearance graph correspond to the tags , and links represent the co - appearances of the tags on the same object . the weights of the links are given by the number of co - appearances . however , when calculating the eigenvector centrality , links having a z - score below a certain threshold value are neglected . the z - score is calculated as the observed number of objects where the two tags co - appear minus the expected number co - occurrences when tags are randomly shuffled . the z - score is normalized by the standard deviation of random co - occurrences , @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the number of times tags @xmath2 and @xmath3 co - appear , @xmath4 and @xmath5 are the expected value and standard deviation , respectively , for randomly reshuffled tags . in the second step the hierarchy is built according to a bottom - up approach , i.e. , we look for parents at each tag @xmath2 in ascending order of their eigenvector centrality . we choose a tag to be the first parent of @xmath2 , when it has higher eigenvector centrality than @xmath2 and has maximal score among possible parents . the score here is the sum of the z - scores of the links between the candidate parent and the descendants of @xmath2 , and between @xmath2 itself . note , that by aggregating the descendants z - scores , we take into account much more information than any pairwise similarity metric can provide . finally , we allow further parents if they have links to @xmath2 with at least as high z - score as the first parent . we study the keywords of scientific papers between 1975 and 2011 obtained from the web of science . the dataset contains 35 371 214 papers , which are tagged by three type of tags . the first type ( heading ) gives a very broad categorisation of the paper , there are only 5 tags of this type : ` arts & humanities ` , ` life sciences & biomedicine ` , ` multidisciplinary science & technology ` , + ` physical sciences ` and ` social sciences ` . the second type ( category ) has 251 more fine - grained scientific areas like ` chemistry , analytical ` or ` engineering , geological ` . tags of the third type are chosen from two sets of specific phrases . one set is composed from the keywords which originated from the authors of the papers . the other set is given by the web of science service , and targeted as complementary to the author - given keywords . we will refer to the first keywords as _ authorkeywords _ and to the other as _ woskeywords_. there are a huge number of third - type - tags : the _ woskeywords _ set contains 2 245 143 phrases and the _ authorkeywords _ set contains 6 891 089 , which are very specific , like ` zygapophyseal arthritis ` or ` h-3 -r - alpha - methylhistamine binding ` . although these keywords are aimed to be complementary on the level of individual papers , still 883 836 of them appear both in the set of _ woskeywords _ and _ authorkeywords_. finally , we note that the web of science does not define any hierarchical relations between the tags , i.e. , the ancestors or descendants of the tags are not given in the data set , only the categorization into the three major types is provided . the aim here is to apply the methodology of sec . [ s : pre_meth ] to the data described in sec . [ s : pre_data ] , in order to study the differences and similarities of hierarchies resulting from tags given by independent individuals and from tags given by a repository . in the first case the input of the hierarchy reconstruction is given by heading , category and _ authorkeyword _ tags , while in the second case the heading , category and _ woskeywords _ tags . note that the general and intermediately general type tags are common in both datasets , and these tags are given by the repository management system . the difference between the independent tagging and centrally managed tagging comes from the most numerous third level tags . we compare below the hierarchies of the two taggings . first we compare the upper most part of the reconstructed dags . then the hierarchy level occupation statistics of the dags are compared for each tag types . finally the horizontal ( branching ) structures of the dags are analysed . in the reconstructed hierarchies obtained from our method both dags had 4 dominant roots at the highest level of the hierarchy , being the ancestors of @xmath6-@xmath7 of the available tags . the dags contain several other non - dominant roots , corresponding to tiny connected components which cover only @xmath8-@xmath9 of the tags . the four dominant roots coincide with the heading type tags except ` multidisciplinary science & technology ` , which appears as a child of ` physical sciences ` . next , we compare the vertical structures of the two dags by analysing the hierarchy level distribution of different tag types . a technical difficulty arises from the fact that a tag may belong to more roots , thus it can have more level values depending on the root from which it is counted . here we classify tags to hierarchy levels according to their closest root , i.e. , from the possible level numbers we associate the highest possible level to each tag . the resulting level distributions are shown on fig . [ f : levels ] . they indicate that the position in the dag correlates strongly with the heading - category-(author / wos)keyword classification , i.e. , the reconstruction is consistent with the a priori classification of the tags in this respect . however , it is interesting to note , that while tags from different types mostly appear below each other in the expected order , tags from the _ same _ type also appear below each other the reconstruction finds structure within the types . the third aspect is the horizontal similarity of the dags . here we analyse whether common members of the dags are in similar horizontal position , i.e. , having similar descendant subgraphs . since the dags are constructed from the same header and category type tags and the two different keyword tags , we compare the horizontal structure of the two dags in two ways : i ) first we restrict the analysis only for those tags , that are common in the two dags ( header , category and common keywords ) ii ) secondly we restrict the analysis even more , considering only the header and category type tags , that are common by definition of the dags . for the first case , where we compare the horizontal position of the common keywords / categories / headers of the two dags , we calculated the linearised mutual information - based similarity of @xcite . the result shows huge dissimilarity with @xmath10 for the mutual information . a sample of the dags is shown on fig . [ f : reduced2common ] , around `` vegetation response '' . in both dags , related tags appear below the chosen tag , however , according to fig . [ f : reduced2common ] , descendants in one dag differ from descendants in the other . these results are in accordance with the complementary nature of the _ authorkeywords _ and _ woskeywords_. 0.5 cm if we restrict the calculation of the mutual information to the header and category tags only , the similarity jumps to @xmath11 , showing that the relations between general tags are quite robust , indeed , the hierarchies are built bottom - up , where the bottom parts are very different . samples of these reduced dags are visualised on fig . [ f : reduced2hc ] . they display a few branches below ` life sciences & biomedicine ` , like ` biochemistry & molecular biology ` , ` cardiac & cardiovascular systems ` or ` plant ` ` sciences ` . the two sub - figures show that ` neurosciences , plant sciences , biophysics ` and ` agronomy ` have more children in the _ woskeyword _ dag , while ` hematology ` is also connected to ` transplantation ` in the _ authorkeyword _ dag . + note that the reconstruction strongly depends on the descendants of each tag , especially for tags having several descendants , thus the difference between the _ authorkeywords _ and _ woskeywords _ could have led to very different structure at the top of the dag @xcite . the very high similarity at the top of the hierarchy compared to the low similarity for the first case indicates , that the differences between the _ authorkeywords _ and the _ woskeywords _ result differences on the low levels of the hierarchy , while this difference does not propagate to the highest levels . tag - based categorisation of large online datasets is becoming increasingly widespread . they allow free word tagging , multiple categories for items and user - based processing in a parallel manner instead of centralised expert - based processing . although the tags have no predefined relations , it is reasonable to assume that users think to an extent in hierarchical relations between tags , i.e. , using some tags as special cases of other , more general tags . here we applied a recently introduced hierarchy construction method to keywords of scientific papers from the web of science . tags were pre - organised by the web of science into 3 types , from the very general to the very special . for the most special type , 2 different sets of keywords were obtained , author - given and repository - given . accordingly , two different hierarchies were constructed , each time using one of these sets as the special type , accompanied by the more general tags . first , the structures of the obtained hierarchies were compared to the 3 predefined tag types . good correspondence was found here . for the most general type , 4 out of the 5 member tags appeared as level 1 roots in the constructed hierarchies ( ` arts & humanities ` , ` life sciences & biomedicine ` , ` physical sciences ` and ` social sciences ` ) , the fifth one being an immediate child of one of them ( ` multidisciplinary science & technology ` ) . the intermediate type tags populated the next levels in the hierarchies , and members of the most specific type were at the lowest levels . an interesting observation is that the tags were organised to significantly more levels than three , indicating that there is structure within the predefined types . second , the two constructed hierarchies , using two different set of special keywords , were compared to each other . the hierarchies were reduced to the tags common in both of them , in order to make direct comparison possible . it was found that the organisation of the tags are very different , their similarity scoring @xmath10 on a [ 0,1 ] scale . this is in accordance with their purpose , i.e. , for each individual paper _ woskeywords _ are aimed to be complementary to the _ authorkeywords _ @xcite . on the other hand , when reducing the hierarchies only to the general and intermediately general type tags , a much higher @xmath11 similarity was obtained , in spite of the fact that the hierarchies were constructed bottom up , allowing different lower levels resulting in different high levels . interestingly , while the lower parts of the hierarchies were different , the more general tags were organised in a significantly similar way . the research was partially supported by the european union and the european social fund through project futurict.hu ( grant no.:tamop-4.2.2.c-11/1/konv-2012 - 0013 ) and by the hungarian national science fund ( otka k105447 ) . the funders had no role in study design , data collection and analysis , decision to publish , or preparation of the manuscript . the authors declare no conflict of interest . plangprasopchok a , lerman k , getoor l ( 2011 ) a probabilistic approach for learning folksonomies from structured data . in : _ fourth acm international conference on web search and data mining ( wsdm ) _ pp . 555564 .

folksonomies large databases arising from collaborative tagging of items by independent users - are becoming an increasingly important way of categorizing information . in these systems users can tag items with free words , resulting in a tripartite item - tag - user network . although there are no prescribed relations between tags , the way users think about the different categories presumably has some built in hierarchy , in which more special concepts are descendants of some more general categories . several applications would benefit from the knowledge of this hierarchy . here we apply a recent method to check the differences and similarities of hierarchies resulting from tags given by independent individuals and from tags given by a centrally managed repository system . the results from our method showed substantial differences between the lower part of the hierarchies , and in contrast , a relatively high similarity at the top of the hierarchies . keywords : tag , hierarchy , ontology reconstruction , folksonomy , knowledge mapping

1109.5107

macroscopic objects in contact with an ionized gas acquire a negative charge because the influx of electrons from the plasma outruns the influx of ions . the collection of electrons at the wall ( boundary of the object ) gives rise to a repulsive coulomb potential which reduces the electron influx until the wall charge reaches a quasi - stationary value . as a consequence of the electron accumulation at the wall an electron depleted region , the plasma sheath , is formed adjacent to the wall . most of the voltage driving the discharge drops across the sheath . wall charges may however not only affect the spatial structure of the plasma but also surface - supported elementary process such as electron - ion recombination and secondary electron emission , which are particularly important in dusty plasmas,@xcite dielectric barrier discharges,@xcite and solid - state based micro - discharges.@xcite a macroscopic description of the plasma - induced wall charge , sufficient for the modeling of the plasma sheath , @xcite is clearly insufficient for quantifying the effect wall charges might have on these processes . a microscopic description of the plasma - induced wall charge and the potential across the plasma - wall interface it leads to is required . traditionally , plasma walls are treated as perfect absorbers.@xcite irrespective of the microscopic interaction , all electrons and ions impinging on the wall are assumed to recombine instantly . from this model only the wall potential just outside the wall can be obtained . this is the potential that balances the electron and ion influx at the wall . a first , qualitative step going beyond this model was taken by emeleus and coulter,@xcite who envisaged the wall charge as a two - dimensional surface plasma coupled to the bulk plasma via electron - ion wall recombination . no attempt was however made to put this appealing idea onto a formal basis . later the notion of a two - dimensional surface charge was developed further by behnke and coworkers@xcite utilizing phenomenological rate equations for the electron and ion surface densities . in these equations , the microphysics at the wall is encapsulated in surface parameters , such as , electron and ion sticking coefficients , electron and ion desorption times , and an electron - ion wall recombination coefficient . in principle these parameters can be calculated . assuming , for instance , plasma electrons to ad- and desorb in the long - range image potential of the wall we calculated in our previous work electron sticking coefficients and electron desorption times for uncharged metallic @xcite and dielectric surfaces . @xcite we also made a first attempt to estimate these two quantities for charged dielectric plasma walls @xcite and proposed a physisorption - inspired microscopic charging model for dust particles in a gas discharge . @xcite in this work , we shift gears and focus on the potential and charge distribution across the plasma - wall interface after the quasi - stationary wall charge ( electron adsorbate in the notation of our previous work @xcite ) has been established . in other words , we extend the modeling of the plasma sheath @xcite to the region inside the solid and calculate the plasma - induced modifications of the potential and charge distribution of the surface . although knowing the potential and charge distribution across the interface may not be of particular importance for present day technological plasmas , it is of fundamental interest from an interface physics point of view . in addition , considering the plasma wall as an integral part of the plasma sheath may become critical when the miniaturization of solid - state based plasma devices @xcite continues . in the model outlined below we specifically consider a dielectric wall and treat the plasma - induced quasi - stationary wall charge , that is , the surplus charge on top of the charge distribution of the bare , free - standing surface , as an electron surface layer of a certain extent , which is trapped by and in thermal equilibrium with the wall . in order to determine the chemical potential , width , and spatial position ( relative to the crystallographic interface ) of the electron surface layer , which depend on surface as well as plasma parameters , we employ a one - dimensional model for a graded interface between a collisionless plasma sheath and a dielectric surface which is assumed to be a perfect absorber , that is , the wall potential balances at a certain distance from the crystallographic interface the electron and the ion influx from the plasma . the model of a graded interface encompasses two important ingredients : the surface dipole of the bare surface responsible for the offset of the conduction band minimum to the potential just outside the dielectric and the long - range image potential . the former accounts for the charge re - distribution of the free - standing , uncharged surface arising from the truncation of the crystal and the latter supports polarization - induced external surface states ( image states ) , first predicted for liquid helium @xcite and later studied for metallic and dielectric surface with negative electron affinity @xcite , which may trap the electron surface layer in front of the crystallographic interface . originally proposed by stern for the interface between two dielectrics,@xcite and later on used by others for semiconductor heterojunctions @xcite and electron trapping in nanopores,@xcite the graded interface model also guarantees continuity of the electrostatic potential across the plasma - wall interface . the model thus allows us to study the spatial distribution of the plasma - induced wall charge across the interface . to insert the surplus charge into the interface we follow tkharev and danilyuk @xcite and minimize , in the spirit of density functional theory , @xcite the grand canonical potential of wall - thermalized excess electrons we also investigate how the electron surface layer merges with the neutral bulk of the dielectric which we describe with the model of an intrinsic semiconductor . various improvements of the model are conceivable but the increased mathematical complexity would mask the general ideas we would like to convey . for instance , the model of a collisionless sheath could be replaced by more realistic models . @xcite going beyond the perfect absorber model , on the other hand , is an unsolved problem . it would require the inclusion of electron desorption , electron sticking , and electron - ion recombination , with the respective coefficients to be self - consistently calculated for the quasi - stationary electron adsorbate at the wall . replacing the graded interface by an ab - initio theory for the surface , for instance , along the lines given in refs . @xcite , possibly taking ad - layers of the host gas atoms or molecules as well as impurities and imperfections into account , is desirable but at the present stage of the investigation impractical . it would require an expensive atomistic characterization of the plasma - wall interface , either experimentally via various surface diagnostics or theoretically via ab - initio simulations . as long as the atomistic details affect however only the off - sets of the dielectric constant , the electron affinity , and the effective mass , the graded interface model already incorporates these details by a suitable parameterization . what is not well described is the non - universal region a few atomic units below and above the crystallographic interface . in particular , intrinsic surface states ( shockley and tamm states @xcite ) and additional surface states which may arise from the short - range surface potential due to impurities , imperfections , and ad - layers are not included . if unoccupied these states could trap the electron surface layer in the vicinity of the interface even for surfaces with positive electron affinity where image states are absent and can not trap the surplus charge in front of the surface . the remaining paper is structured as follows . in sec . [ electron surface layermain ] we first construct a crude model for the plasma - induced electron surface layer at the interface between a plasma and a dielectric wall . it does not account for the merging of the electron surface layer with the bulk of the dielectric . as long as the primary interest is in the region close to the crystallographic interface and the band gap of the dielectric is large enough , the crude model is sufficient . section [ negativescr ] describes a refinement of the model which enables one to also investigate the cross - over of the electron surface layer to the bulk of the dielectric . this is particularly important for dielectrics with small energy gaps . numerical results for the potential and the electron distribution are given in section [ results ] and a short summary is formulated in sec . [ summary ] . as depicted in fig . [ figure1 ] , we consider an ideal , planar interface at @xmath2 with the dielectric occupying the half - space @xmath3 and the discharge occupying the half - space @xmath4 . chemical contamination and structural damage due to the burning gas discharge are discarded . at the moment we focus on the physical principles controlling the electronic properties of the plasma - wall interface . in the model we propose the plasma - induced wall charge to be treated as an electron surface layer ( esl ) which is an interface specific electron distribution on top of the charge re - distribution due to the truncation of the solid . the esl is assumed to be thermalized with the solid and to stretch from the plasma sheath over the crystallographic interface to the bulk of the dielectric . the boundary between the esl and the plasma sheath is located in front of the surface at @xmath5 . it is the position where the attractive force due to the surface potential @xmath6 and the repulsive force due to the sheath potential @xmath7 balance each other . thus , @xmath8 is given by @xmath9 it gives the position of an effective wall for plasma electrons and ions at which , for instance , the flux balance condition of the perfect absorber model , @xmath10 , with @xmath11 and @xmath12 , respectively , the electron and ion flux towards the dielectric surface , has to be fulfilled . for @xmath13 an electron is attracted to the surface and thus contained in the esl while for @xmath14 it is repelled back into the plasma . on the solid side , for @xmath3 , the esl is bounded because of the shallow potential well formed by the restoring force from the positive charge in the plasma sheath . in this section we will outline the essential building blocks of the esl model . putting together concepts from plasma as well as surface physics a detailed , self - contained account seems to be helpful . in the traditional view , electrons missing in the positive space charge region in front of the plasma wall accumulate on the wall and give rise to a wall potential . for the construction of our one - dimensional interface model we need the total number per unit area of missing sheath electrons ( that is , the total surface density of missing sheath electrons ) as a function of the wall potential because it is this number of electrons which can be distributed across the esl . hence , we require a model for the plasma sheath . for simplicity , we use a collisionless sheath @xcite , more realistic sheath models @xcite make no difference in principle . in the collisionless sheath electrons are thermalized , that is , the electron density @xmath15 , with @xmath16 the potential , @xmath17 the plasma density and @xmath18 the electron temperature . the ions enter the sheath with a directed velocity @xmath19 and satisfy a source - free continuity equation , @xmath20 , implying @xmath21 , and an equation of motion @xmath22 , with @xmath23 the ion density , and @xmath24 the ion mass . the potential @xmath16 satisfies poisson s equation @xmath25 . thus , the governing equations for the collisionless plasma sheath are @xcite @xmath26 \text { . } \label{sheath2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using dimensionless variables @xmath27 where @xmath28 equations ( [ sheath1 ] ) and ( [ sheath2 ] ) become @xmath29 in the esl model the plasma occupies not the whole half space @xmath4 but only the portion @xmath14 ( see fig.[figure1 ] ) . the integration of the first equation gives , where @xmath30 is the reduced velocity of ions entering the sheath , so that the second equation becomes @xmath31 using the boundary condition that the potential and the field vanish far inside the plasma , that is , @xmath32 and @xmath33 for @xmath34 , eq . ( [ clsheatheq ] ) can be integrated once and we obtain @xmath35 for ions entering the sheath with the bohm velocity @xmath36 . the field at the wall as a function of the wall potential @xmath37 is then given by @xmath38 the total surface density of electrons in the esl equals the total surface density of missing sheath electrons , in other words , the total surplus surface density of positive ions in the sheath @xmath39 which can be calculated from the electric field at the wall . integrating poisson s equation yields @xmath40 combing eqs . ( [ neq ] ) and ( [ etawprime ] ) gives the total surface density of electrons to be inserted into the esl as a function of the wall potential . the wall potential itself is determined by the flux balance condition , @xmath10 , which , in the esl model , is assumed to be fulfilled at @xmath5 . using the bohm flux for the ions and the thermal flux for the electrons , @xmath41 the wall potential is given by @xcite @xmath42 that is , @xmath43 in the collisionless sheath model the wall potential depends only on the electron temperature and the ion to electron mass ratio . we now turn to the interface region in which the missing sheath electrons will be inserted . this region is absent in the traditional modeling of plasma walls . in our model it is an extended region surrounding an ideal dielectric surface . in comparison to the electrons responsible for the chemical binding within the dielectric the additional electrons coming from the plasma are only a few . the electronic structure of the surface , in particular , the charge re - distribution due to truncation of the solid and the offset of the energy bands in the bulk with respect to the potential outside the dielectric will not be changed significantly by the presence of the surplus electrons comprising the wall charge . in order to quantify the above statement let us first consider the electrostatic potential and the electronic structure of a free - standing , uncharged dielectric surface . according to tung,@xcite it has to minimize the thermodynamical potential and satisfy poisson s equation implying that the potential is continuous across the surface . strictly speaking , the continuity of the potential only applies to the microscopic crystal potential which has to merge continuously with the surface potential outside the crystal . the averaged long - range potential , in contrast , can be discontinuous at the interface . it is this offset which is encoded in the surface dipole . the energy of an electronic state in the bulk of the dielectric can be referenced to the vacuum level @xmath44 , that is , the potential far outside the crystal , in the following way,@xcite @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the quantum - mechanical contribution to the energy , @xmath47 is the averaged potential of a cell due to the charge distribution within the same cell , and @xmath48 is the long range potential due to the surface dipole , space charges , and external fields . in the simple two - band model depicted in fig . [ figure1 ] , @xmath49 . @xmath50 contains the surface dipole arising from the truncation of the solid and responsible for the potential offset at the surface and a slowly varying component due to external fields and internal and plasma - induced space charges . external fields and internal space charges will be neglected in the following and plasma - induced space charges will be accounted for by poisson s equation ( see below ) . in order to judge whether the surplus charge arising from the plasma affects the surface dipole it is useful to consider first the typical strength of the surface dipole of a free - standing , uncharged dielectric surface . it results from a charge double - layer in immediate proximity to the surface . depending on the material it can have various origins . for an ionic crystal , for example , it is the lattice relaxation at the surface which makes anions or cations to protrude and the other species to retract ( e.g. protruding oxygen and retracted cations for magnesium oxide@xcite ) , while for semiconductors it is the regrouping of covalent bonds which leads to charge re - distribution at the surface . even in the absence of these effects the minimization of the thermodynamic potential of the surface s electrons leads already to an electron density leaking out into the vacuum . this is particularly important for metals . as a result a charge double - layer is formed over a length on the order of a lattice constant . the dipole layer is usually characterized by a dipole strength @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the limit of the long range potential just inside the crystal at the surface position @xmath53 and @xmath54 is the limit of the potential at that position just outside the surface . usually these two potentials , which characterize the discontinuity of the long - range potential at the surface , are termed the potential just inside and the potential just outside , respectively.@xcite here , just outside denotes a distance small compared to variations of the long - range potential due to external fields or space charges but large compared with the width of the charge double - layer . note also that in the definition of the potential just outside the image potential is assumed to have already decreased to zero . @xcite this point will be important later . the strength of the dipole layer is a microscopic property of the surface which is relatively insensitive against the additional charges from the plasma . the reason for this lies in the small number of additional electrons from the plasma compared to the number of displaced electrons involved in the formation of the dipole layer . to prove this statement we give a simple estimate . typical surface dipoles @xmath55 are on the order of electron volts . for a double - layer of one @xmath56 to each side of the crystallographic interface a potential difference of one volt requires a surface charge density of @xmath57 . the surface charge density at the wall of a helium discharge with plasma density @xmath58 and electron temperature @xmath59 amounts , however , only to @xmath60 . for typical plasma densities , the number of additional electrons is thus far too small to lead to a change of the surface dipole . even for semiconductor - based microdischarges @xcite , which can have much higher plasma densities , we expect the surface dipole of the plasma wall not to be modified by the plasma . in view of the just given estimate , we have to revise an assumption in our previous work,@xcite where we assumed the surface charge accumulating on the wall would increase the dipole energy @xmath55 by @xmath61 , leading to the image states being pushed from the band gap into the energy region of the conduction band . the numbers given in the previous paragraph indicate , however , that the band line - up of the conduction band and the potential just outside the solid , will not be affected much by the wall charge . hence , if a negative electron affinity supports image states in front of the uncharged surface , these states remain in the band gap for the charged surface . electron trapping as investigated in refs . @xcite is thus even possible for charged plasma walls . instead of the dipole strength @xmath55 which can not be measured directly , it is more convenient to characterize the dipole layer by the electron affinity @xmath62 which is a measurable quantity for a dielectric surface . @xcite the electron affinity is the energy released when an electron is moved from just outside the surface to the bottom of the conduction band . it accounts for charge re - distribution in the vicinity of the surface due to the truncation of the crystal . while many surfaces have positive electron affinity such as al@xmath0o@xmath1 or sio@xmath0 , there are also materials with negative electron affinity , for instance , diamond @xcite , boron nitride@xcite , or the alkaline earth oxides . @xcite the electron affinity depends also on ad - atoms . in some cases this is even used to control the electron affinity of a surface . terminating , for instance , a surface with weakly electronegative elements such as hydrogen induces a negative electron affinity , @xcite while termination with strongly electronegative elements can lead to a positive electron affinity . @xcite from eq . ( [ energyreference ] ) it is clear that @xmath62 equals @xmath55 plus a bulk contribution , @xmath63 where @xmath64 denotes the minimum of the conduction band . we can thus use @xmath62 to characterize the potential offset at the surface . there is however a caveat . the long - range potential inside the solid is only specified up to a constant.@xcite typical choices are the cell - averaged potential or the inter - sphere potential of the muffin - tin approximation . for our purpose it will be however more convenient to take the conduction band minimum as the long - range potential inside the solid . this choice is motivated as follows . we are considering a dielectric with a large energy gap . the valence band is thus fully occupied and the conduction band is essentially empty . hence , only the conduction band can be populated by additional electrons coming from the plasma and referencing the electrostatic potential inside the solid to the conduction band minimum allows us to relate the total surplus electron density in the interface region to the potential in the interface region in analogy to what we have done for the plasma sheath in the previous subsection . adopting the above discussion to the one - dimensional model shown in fig . [ figure1 ] and assuming a quadratic dispersion for the conduction band , the energy of an electron in the conduction band is given by @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the total surface potential to be determined in the next subsection and the offset of the electrostatic potential at the surface , @xmath67 encompasses the surface dipole as well as the unspecified bulk contribution . the surface potential of the bare , uncharged surface comprises at least the surface dipole and a long - range contribution , the image potential , resulting from the mismatch of the dielectric constants at the surface . far away from the surface the image potential is given by@xcite @xmath68 but this expression can not be employed for our purpose because the singularity at @xmath2 prohibits a smooth electron distribution across the interface . in reality the image potential has to continuously merge with the crystal potential . equation ( [ imageclassical ] ) is thus also unphysical . to obtain a realistic image potential without performing an atomistically accurate calculation we employ the model of a graded interface . it also has the virtue to be parameterizable with experimentally measured values for the electron affinity , the dielectric mismatch , and the mismatch between effective electron masses . the model incorporates therefore important properties of a surface , most importantly , it accounts for the charge re - distribution due to the truncation of the solid . initially proposed by stern @xcite to remove the unphysical singularity of the image potential at the interface of two dielectrics , the graded interface model assumes the dielectric constant @xmath69 to vary over a distance on the order of a lattice constant . later the model was extended to variations of other physical quantities and applied to semiconductor heterostructures and nanopores . @xcite clearly , because of the interpolation the model can not account for effects associated with intrinsic surface states ( shockley and tamm states @xcite ) and additional surface states which may arise from the short - range surface potential . nevertheless , the graded interface model is a reasonable description of a surface . in the spirit of a graded interface , we assume the dielectric constant @xmath69 , the electron mass @xmath70 , and the potential offset at the surface to vary smoothly according to the grading function @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the half width of the graded interface and @xmath73 stands for the quantity that varies across the interface . we use the value @xmath74 which is an estimate used in previous applications of the graded interface.@xcite while the grading parameter @xmath72 is not based on definite experimental or theoretical results it is motivated by the assumption that the bonding and the electron density at the surface change over one to two lattice constants implying a transition layer for the effective potential and the dielectric constant that is somewhat larger . hence , across the interface the electron mass , the dielectric constant and the offset potential are given by @xmath75 and @xmath76 respectively , with @xmath77 the effective mass of the conduction band . within the model of the graded interface , the image potential is the change in the selfenergy of an electron due to the proximity of the dielectric mismatch . positioning the electron at @xmath78 it is given by @xcite @xmath79~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath80 is the potential in the medium with dielectric mismatch arising from the electron at @xmath78 and @xmath81 is the same quantity in a homogeneous medium with dielectric constant @xmath82 . hence , @xmath80 is the solution of @xmath83 while @xmath81 is the solution of @xmath84 to solve eqs . ( [ potmismatch ] ) and ( [ potnomismatch ] ) we follow stern@xcite and make the ansatz @xmath85 placing the electron on the @xmath86 axis , @xmath87 which implies @xmath88 and @xmath89 for @xmath90 . hence , we need to keep only the @xmath91 term , so that @xmath92 where @xmath93 is given by @xmath94 and @xmath95 is the solution of @xmath96 which has to be obtained numerically . the image potential is then given by @xmath97 in contrast to eq . ( [ imageclassical ] ) it is now smoothly varying across the interface with a deep well on the low-@xmath69 side and a small bump on the high-@xmath69 side . the total surface potential comprises the graded offset potential ( [ gradedoffsetpotential ] ) and the graded image potential . hence , @xmath98 it is continuous across the crystallographic interface at @xmath2 and enables us thereby to also calculate a smoothly varying electron distribution in the esl . the band structure and the total surface potential at the graded interface are visualized in the lower panel of fig . [ figure1 ] . using eq . ( [ z0condition ] ) we can now determine the position @xmath8 of the effective wall , that is , the maximum extent of the esl on the plasma side . the derivative of the bare surface potential is @xmath99 . due to the relatively weak field in the sheath compared to the image force , the boundary @xmath8 will be so far away from the interface that @xmath100 vanishes and the image potential obeys ( [ imageclassical ] ) . thus , the boundary between the esl and the plasma sheath is given by @xmath101 with @xmath102 and @xmath103 given by ( [ etawprime ] ) . the plasma - induced wall charge is assumed to be in thermal equilibrium with the wall . hence , the distribution of the excess electrons in the esl has to minimize the excess electron s grand canonical potential in the external potential due to the surface . the coupling to the sheath is maintained by the constraint that only as many electrons can be filled into the esl as are missing in the sheath and the boundary conditions to the poisson equation which links the electron distribution in the esl to the ( internal ) electrostatic potential . to minimize the grand canonical potential of the surplus electrons we follow tkharev and danilyuk @xcite and apply density functional theory @xcite to the graded interface . while more refined schemes of density functional theory@xcite could , in principle , be employed , we will use for the purpose of this exploratory calculation density functional theory in the local approximation . quite generally , the grand canonical potential of an electron system in an external potential @xmath104 is given in the local approximation by @xmath105- \mu \int n(\vec{r } ) \mathrm{d}\vec{r } \text { , } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath106 $ ] is the grand canonical potential of the homogeneous system with density @xmath107 and the coulomb potential is determined by @xmath108 the ground state electron density minimizes @xmath109 , that is , it satisfies @xmath110 where @xmath111/\delta n$ ] is the chemical potential for the homogeneous system . specifically for the excess electrons in the one - dimensional graded interface eq . ( [ dft ] ) reduces to @xmath112 where @xmath113 and the electrostatic potential , @xmath114 consists of the potential of the bare surface given by eq . ( [ totalphi ] ) and the internal coulomb potential which satisfies poisson s equation , @xmath115 with the graded dielectric constant @xmath116 given by eq . ( [ graded1 ] ) and the boundary conditions @xmath117 and @xmath118 to guarantee continuity of the potential at @xmath8 and to include the restoring force from the positive charge in the sheath . note that the coulomb potential derived from this equation includes the attraction of an electron to the image of the charge distribution . for the functional relation @xmath113 we take the expression adequate for a homogeneous , non - interacting , non - degenerate electron gas , @xmath119 this is justified because the density of the excess electrons is rather low and the temperature of the surface is rather high , typically a few hundred kelvins . in order to calculate the quasi - stationary distribution of the surplus electrons , eqs . ( [ vareq ] ) and ( [ poiseq ] ) have to be solved self - consistently with the additional constraint that the total electron surface density in the esl equals the total surface density of electrons missing in the sheath , that is , @xmath120 with @xmath39 given by eq . ( [ neq ] ) . in the above equation we introduced a cut - off @xmath121 at which the esl terminates inside the dielectric . as long as @xmath122 is chosen large enough it does not affect the numerical results close to the surface . an improved treatment of the esl , avoiding the ad - hoc cut - off , is given in the next section . within the crude esl model developed in this section the computation is performed iteratively in the interval @xmath123 according to the following scheme : ( i ) we start with the potential of the empty surface given by eq . ( [ potdft ] ) with @xmath124 obtained from eq . ( [ poiseq ] ) with @xmath125 but with the boundary conditions at @xmath8 as specified . ( ii ) we integrate both sides of eq . ( [ neq ] ) over @xmath86 with @xmath126 given by eq . ( [ vareq ] ) . enforcing the constraint ( [ nconstraint ] ) determines @xmath127 . ( iii ) using @xmath127 we calculate from eq . ( [ vareq ] ) a new @xmath126 which gives with eq . ( [ neq ] ) a new electron density @xmath128 . lastly , we determine from eq . ( [ poiseq ] ) the electrostatic potential associated with the up - dated @xmath128 . steps ( ii ) - ( iv ) are iterated until @xmath127 , which is far below the conduction band edge because of the non - degeneracy of the excess electrons , converges . in the previous section we have taken into account only the electron concentration in the conduction band of the dielectric due to the electrons coming from the plasma . for wide band gap materials this is justified , especially near the surface , as their concentration is much larger than the intrinsic carrier concentration . deep inside the dielectric , however , charge neutrality is not enabled by a vanishing electron density , but by the electron density decreasing to its intrinsic value , which is then balanced by the intrinsic hole concentration in the valence band . to take this effect into account , which is particularly important when the additional electrons accumulate deep inside the bulk of the dielectric , we divide the esl into two regions : a very narrow interface - specific region ( isr ) and a wide space charge region ( scr ) in the bulk of the dielectric . the parameter @xmath129 denotes now no longer an ad - hoc cut - off but the boundary between the two regions . it has to be chosen so that the isr includes the major effect of the image potential in the dielectric implying @xmath130 . the electron distribution and the potential in the isr are calculated using the density functional approach outlined in the previous section . in the scr we use for simplicity the model of an intrinsic semiconductor to describe electron and hole densities as well as the long - range potential . as the energy bands in the dielectric follow the long - range potential the refined esl also captures the band bending which might be induced by the presence of the wall charge . it is however only significant when most of the excess electrons are trapped in the scr and not in the isr . figure [ figure1a ] schematically shows the electron and hole densities for the refined esl model . the boundary between the plasma sheath and the esl is still located at @xmath8 . as our model does not encompass the electron and ion flux from the plasma for @xmath13 , the densities @xmath131 and @xmath23 are discontinuous at @xmath8 . this is obvious for the ions which are not allowed to enter the solid . the discontinuity of the electron density , in contrast , arises because we ensure only the total number of missing sheath electrons per unit area to be conserved . this global constraint can not guarantee continuity of the electron density at @xmath8 . at the boundary between the isr ( @xmath123 ) and the scr ( @xmath132 ) the electron density and the potential are continuous . in principle , also the hole density @xmath133 should be continuous . as @xmath134 for the materials we are considering , we can however neglect holes in the isr . for the modeling of the scr it is convenient to use @xmath135 for the long range potential , which vanishes for charge neutrality in the bulk . here , @xmath136 ( see below for an explicit relation for @xmath137 ) . then , poisson s equation is given by , @xmath138 where the electron and hole densities for an intrinsic semiconductor with parabolic bands whose extremal points are , respectively , @xmath139 and @xmath140 are given by @xcite @xmath141 from a comparison of the exponents in eq . ( [ compneq ] ) and eq . ( [ neq ] ) , where @xmath142 is given by eq . ( [ vareq ] ) we find @xmath143 far from the surface , @xmath144 and @xmath145 . this gives the chemical potential @xmath146 and the bulk carrier concentration @xmath147 @xmath148 where @xmath149 . hence , poisson s equation becomes @xmath150 and using dimensionless variables @xmath151 with @xmath152 we obtain @xmath153 this equation can be integrated once , which gives @xmath154 the boundary conditions in the bulk @xmath155 and @xmath156 for @xmath157 imply @xmath158 so that eq . ( [ first_integral ] ) becomes @xmath159 integration with the boundary condition at @xmath129 , that is , at @xmath160 , @xmath161 and requiring @xmath32 for @xmath162 gives @xmath163 \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath164 \text { , } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the upper sign is for @xmath165 and the lower sign for @xmath166 . in analogy to what we have done at the boundary of the esl with the plasma sheath at @xmath5 we relate the potential @xmath167 to the total electron surface density in the space charge region . from poisson s equation we obtain for the total electron surface density in the scr @xmath168 where @xmath169 is given by eq . ( [ etaprime ] ) , so that @xmath170 or , @xmath171 for a negative space charge @xmath165 , so that the potential is given by @xmath172 and the electron and hole densities are given by @xmath173 and @xmath174 , respectively . the relation between @xmath175 and @xmath16 is given by @xmath176 . since @xmath177 we obtain @xmath178 . now , quite generally , the excess electrons in the esl are distributed over the isr and scr according to @xmath179 where @xmath180 is the surface density of electrons in the isr , @xmath127 is the chemical potential in both regions , and @xmath39 is the total surface density of missing sheath electrons given by eq . ( [ neq ] ) . the total surface density in the isr is given by @xmath181 , where @xmath128 is calculated with the density functional approach for the graded interface . requiring continuity of the electron density at @xmath129 , @xmath182 gives @xmath167 as a function of @xmath127 . from @xmath167 we finally obtain using eq . ( [ nsc ] ) @xmath183 . for the calculation of the electron distribution and the potential in the refined esl we use the iteration cycle described in the last section with one modification . in step ( ii ) we solve eq . ( [ ndistrib ] ) instead of eq . ( [ nconstraint ] ) to fix @xmath127 . from @xmath127 we obtain using eq . ( [ ncontatzs ] ) @xmath167 which in turn determines the electron distribution and the potential in the scr . this gives for each iteration step a continuous potential and electron distribution at @xmath129 . as before , the steps ( ii ) -(iv ) are iterated until @xmath127 converges . at the end of this section let us finally mention two simplifications of the refined esl model which could be used , respectively , for large band gap dielectrics irrespective of the electron affinity and dielectrics with small band gap and positive electron affinity . in the former case the intrinsic carrier concentration @xmath147 is very low and the merger with the bulk occurs very deep in the dielectric . almost all surplus electrons are however much closer to the surface where the holes can be neglected . this can be seen from the differential equation for @xmath184 . for small @xmath147 eq . ( [ et0eq ] ) gives a large @xmath167 . as @xmath184 satisfies a highly nonlinear differential equation ( [ diffeqetabb ] ) , a large @xmath167 implies a steeper gradient of @xmath184 near the surface so that almost all electrons are concentrated close to the surface where neglecting the holes has little effect . hence , for large band gap dielectrics surplus electrons can be filled into a sufficiently large isr for which the crude esl model of the previous section will be sufficient provided the cut - off @xmath129 is large enough . the merger with the bulk is of course not correctly captured by such an approach . for dielectrics or semiconductors with small energy gaps and positive electron affinity , on the other hand , almost all surplus electrons are deep inside the material . it is thus a good approximation to neglect the isr and to fill all electrons in a scr . neglecting the surface potential has little effect in this case and using the scr already for @xmath185 gives a good description of the electron distribution inside the esl . the electron density and potential at the surface and in front of it can of course not be captured by such an approach . as before @xmath186 with @xmath187 where @xmath188 is now the limit of the long range potential just inside the dielectric given by @xmath189 . .material parameters for the dielectrics considered in this work : dielectric constant @xmath190 , electron affinity @xmath62 , conduction band effective mass @xmath77 , valence band effective mass @xmath191 , band gap @xmath192 . [ cols="<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] [ kttable ] let us now turn to the discussion of the influence of the electron temperature @xmath193 and the plasma density @xmath17 on the properties of the esl . these two parameters enter through the total surface density of electrons @xmath39 depleting the sheath and accumulating in the esl . how @xmath193 and @xmath17 affect the interface depends therefore on the sheath model and the model used for the interaction between plasma particles and the surface . for simplicity we have used a collisionless sheath model and assumed the surface to be a perfect absorber for plasma electrons and ions . the results for the properties of the esl as a function of the plasma parameters are thus to be taken only indicative . at a sio@xmath0 surface in contact with a helium discharge as a function of the electron temperature ( upper panel , @xmath194 ) and the plasma density ( lower panel , @xmath59 ) for @xmath195 . the refined esl model without an isr was employed to produce the data . ] the effect of a variation of @xmath17 and @xmath196 is most significant for surfaces with positive electron affinity . n0table ] shows the effect of the plasma density @xmath17 for a sio@xmath0 surface . if @xmath17 increases , the boundary @xmath8 between sheath and esl moves closer to the surface this , however , does not affect the charge distribution much as most of the electrons occupy the scr inside the dielectric ( as shown in fig . [ figure3 ] for al@xmath0o@xmath1 ) . more important is that an increase in @xmath17 leads to an increase of the total surface electron density @xmath39 . this entails a stronger restoring force from the plasma sheath so that the potential well confining the space charge inside the dielectric becomes steeper and the electrons in the scr of the esl are shifted towards the surface , in other words , the @xmath197 value increases with @xmath17 . mathematically , the steeple - like shape of the electron distribution arises because a larger @xmath39 leads through eq . ( [ et0eq ] ) to a larger @xmath167 which makes the potential steeper at the surface so that the electron distribution is more peaked there . this trend can be seen in the lower panel for fig . [ figure4 ] . and @xmath59 ) . the data were obtained from the crude esl model . ] a variation of the electron temperature @xmath193 has similar effects as the variation of the plasma density . if @xmath196 increases , the total surface density of electrons increases also , as can be seen from table [ kttable ] . as shown in the upper panel of fig . [ figure4 ] , this leads again to a steeple - like electron distribution which is the more concentrated at the surface the higher the electron temperature is . for a surface with negative electron affinity ( mgo ) the surplus electrons are strongly bound in the image potential . while a variation of @xmath196 or @xmath17 changes the total number of surplus electrons per unit area in the same way as for a surface with positive electron affinity , the distribution of the surplus electrons within the esl is not affected significantly because of the strong image interaction . so far we have shown the potential and the electron distribution in the esl . now , we will compare potential and charge distribution in the esl with the ones in the plasma sheath . the electron distribution at the interface is the quasi - stationary electron gas on top of the charge re - distribution due to the truncation of the solid that guarantees flux equality at the sheath - esl boundary @xmath8 . as already mentioned not included in this simple model is the flux of plasma electrons and ions in the esl before the electrons are trapped at the surface and the ions recombine with the negative wall charge . the electron and ion densities in this model are thus discontinuous at @xmath8 . the potential , however , which has been obtained from the integration of poisson s equation is continuous and differentiable everywhere . between the well of the image potential and @xmath8 the electron and ion flux from the sheath would be important . the neglect of the charge densities associated with these fluxes does however not affect the potential because they are too small to have a significant effect . surface in contact with a helium discharge ( @xmath194 and @xmath59 ) . the refined esl model without an isr was employed to produce the data . ] figure [ figure6 ] shows the esl and the plasma sheath in front of a mgo surface . due to the negative electron affinity , the plasma - supplied surface electrons are bound by the image potential in front of the surface . in fig . [ figure6 ] , we plot the electron and ion density ( upper panel ) , as well as the electric potential ( lower panel ) over the distance from the surface @xmath86 . far from the surface , the potential approaches the bulk plasma value chosen to be zero . in the sheath the potential develops a coulomb barrier and reaches the wall potential @xmath198 at @xmath8 , the distance where the sheath merges with the surface layer ( vertical dotted line ) . the wall potential is the potential just outside to which the energies of the bulk states are referenced . closer to the surface the potential follows the attractive image potential while at the surface the repulsive potential due to the negative electron affinity prevents the electron from entering the dielectric ( only scarcely seen on the scale of the figure ) . in fig . [ figure6a ] we finally plot the electron and ion densities ( upper panel ) as well as the electric potential ( lower panel ) for sio@xmath0 . note the linear z - axis in contrast to the logarithmic z - axis of fig . [ figure6 ] . due to the positive electron affinity , the excess electrons constituting the wall charge penetrate deep into the dielectric and occupy therefore the scr of the esl . compared to the variation of the electric potential in the sheath the band bending in the dielectric induced by the wall charge is rather small as indicated by the variation of @xmath16 inside the dielectric . this is because @xmath69 is large and the width of the scr is narrow on the scale of the sheath . only on the scale of the isr ( a vertical line at @xmath2 ) the scr of the esl is wide . we have studied the potential and the charge distribution across the interface of a plasma and a dielectric wall treating the plasma - induced wall charge as a quasi - stationary electron gas trapped by and in thermal equilibrium with the dielectric . our approach is based on a model for a graded surface including the offset between the potential just outside the dielectric and the conduction band minimum arising from the re - distribution of charge due to the truncation of the solid as well as the image potential due to the dielectric mismatch at the boundary . the missing electrons from the sheath populate the interface potential and thereby form an electron surface layer ( esl ) which minimizes the grand canonical potential of wall - thermalized excess electrons and satisfies poisson s equation . within this model the boundary between the plasma sheath and the esl is given by the distance from the crystallographic interface where the potential for the excess electrons turns from the repulsive sheath potential into the attractive surface potential . this distance is typically on the order of a micron . it gives the position of an effective wall for plasma electrons and ions and thus the portion of the esl which lays in front of the surface . most of the surplus electrons trapped in the esl , that is , the plasma - induced wall charge , will be , however , much closer to the surface or even inside the dielectric depending on the electron affinity . we presented numerical results for the potential and the distribution of the plasma - supplied surplus electrons at the interface between a helium discharge and the surfaces of mgo , al@xmath0o@xmath1 , and sio@xmath0 , respectively . the electron distribution within the esl strongly depends on the electron affinity . for negative electron affinity , the conduction band minimum is above the potential just outside the dielectric . hence , it is energetically unfavorable for electrons to penetrate into the bulk and the surface electrons are bound in the image potential in front of the surface . in this case , their spatial profile changes little over a variation of the surface temperature or the plasma parameters . for positive electron affinity the conduction band minimum is below the potential just outside the dielectric and the surface - bound electrons accumulate inside the wall . the space charge in the bulk broadens if the surface temperature is increased and becomes more peaked if the total surface density of the electrons missing in the sheath is raised through either an increase in the plasma density or the electron temperature . separating the esl into an interface specific and a space charge region and modeling the bulk of the dielectric as an intrinsic semiconductor we also investigated how the esl merges with the bulk of the dielectric . this is particularly important for dielectrics with small energy gaps and positive electron affinities where excess electrons coming from the sheath accumulate not in the image potential in front of the surface but deep inside the wall . in this case the wall charge may also induce a significant band bending . whereas the crude esl model we proposed neglects the space charge deep inside the bulk of the wall and is thus only applicable to large band gap dielectrics with negative electron affinity where basically the whole plasma - induced wall charge is trapped in the image potential in front of the surface , the refined esl model keeping the interface specific as well as the space charge region of the esl provides a quantitative description of the whole spatial structure of the extended charge double - layer which forms at a dielectric plasma wall as a result of the electrons in the esl and the positive space charge in the plasma sheath . the esl can be regarded as that part of the plasma sheath which is inside the plasma wall . it is thus the ultimate boundary of a bounded gas discharge and constitutes , depending on the electron affinity either a quasi two - dimensional electron plasma in front of the wall or an electron(-hole ) plasma inside the wall .

we study the plasma - induced modifications of the potential and charge distribution across the interface of a plasma and a dielectric wall . for this purpose , the wall - bound surplus charge arising from the plasma is modelled as a quasi - stationary electron surface layer in thermal equilibrium with the wall . it satisfies poisson s equation and minimizes the grand canonical potential of wall - thermalized excess electrons . based on an effective model for a graded interface taking into account the image potential and the offset of the conduction band to the potential just outside the dielectric , we specifically calculate the modification of the potential and the distribution of the surplus electrons for mgo , sio@xmath0 and al@xmath0o@xmath1 surfaces in contact with a helium discharge . depending on the electron affinity of the surface , we find two vastly different behaviors . for negative electron affinity , electrons do not penetrate into the wall and a quasi - two - dimensional electron gas is formed in the image potential , while for positive electron affinity , electrons penetrate into the wall and a negative space charge layer develops in the interior of the dielectric . we also investigate how the non - neutral electron surface layer which can be understood as the ultimate boundary of a bounded gas discharge merges with the neutral bulk of the dielectric .

0707.4096

the observation of a valley of stability and the search for mass formulae belong to the oldest subjects studied in nuclear physics @xcite and continue to be of great interest today @xcite . given the neutron and proton numbers @xmath6 and @xmath7 as independent variables and the corresponding atomic number , @xmath8 terms such as volume energy @xmath9 , surface tension @xmath10 coulomb energy @xmath11 symmetry energy @xmath12 _ etc . _ , flourish in the literature , and a great deal of attention has been dedicated to the consideration of finer corrections , such as , for instance , terms @xmath13 and @xmath14 that account for shell and pairing effects , respectively , and further correlations . this work is motivated by the observation that the dominant terms , such as @xmath15 @xmath16 and @xmath17 , define a notoriously _ concave _ energy surface . upper and lower bounds to nuclear binding energies can be deduced from such a concavity , provided that deviations from concavity , possibly induced by subdominant terms like @xmath10 @xmath18 @xmath19 _ etc . _ , can be corrected . for the sake of simplicity this paper first considers only sequences of isotopes and , thus , takes advantage of concavity with respect to @xmath6 only ; @xmath7 is frozen . in section 2 we begin with a theory at zero temperature and show how elementary , invertible transformations of data can generate truly concave patterns . this is obtained by an analysis of the table of second differences between binding energies , then by a removal of the pairing energy , and finally by an _ ad hoc _ , but minimal , parabolic term added to the nuclear energies , if necessary . since concavity is also a property of several thermodynamical functions , an extension of the zero temperature analysis to finite temperatures is in order . in section 3 we discuss properties of that grand potential , @xmath20 which can be deduced from the experimental data after their tuning . other thermodynamical functions are also considered , and their concavity is tested . bounds are found , and an error bar for predictions is estimated . a generalization to concavity with respect to both @xmath6 and @xmath7 is briefly studied in section 4 . an additional motivation for our investigation of concavity properties is the need , in density functional theories , of concavity , if the universality @xcite of a density functional must be obtained . a solution will be shown . finally , a discussion and conclusion are given in section 5 . our argument is best illustrated numerically , by using a sequence of isotopic ground - state binding energies , @xmath21 we choose to work with the tin isotopes ( sn ) , because they provide a large number of known isotopes for testing our method . in addition , in section 3 , we will extend our approach to finite temperatures using a grand potential , which requires that a sufficiently large number of excited states are also known . for instance , a table of @xmath22 ground - state bindings for the tin isotopes from @xmath23sn to @xmath24sn reads , in kev , \ { 934571 , 942744 , 953531 , 961274 , 971574 , 979120 , 988684 , 995627 , 1004954 , 1011438 , 1020546 , 1026716 , 1035529 , 1041475 , 1049963 , 1055696 , 1063889 , 1069439 , 1077345 , 1082676 , 1090293 , 1095540 , 1102851 , 1105320 , 1109239}. despite a standard linear trend because of a `` not too much fluctuating average energy per nucleon '' , this list is not making a smooth pattern , even less of a concave one . the full line in fig . 1 , where , for graphical convenience , we have added to each @xmath25 a constant term , @xmath26 mev and a linear term , @xmath27 mev , shows the amount of irregularity in the pattern . the main source of irregularity is , obviously , the pairing effect . if it can be removed , concavity emerges . concavity for a sequence of isotones is not a surprise , because of the @xmath28 nature of the coulomb term . for a sequence of isotopes , however , there is no such obviously quadratic term available , notwithstanding the empirical modelization of a symmetry energy @xmath29 our choice of sn , because of its long isotope sequence , illustrates this concavity more dramatically . most energies stated in this paper are in units of kev . our data come from ref . @xcite . see also @xcite . these sources usually quote the binding energy per nucleon instead of the total binding energy itself and such values per nucleon are given to varying numbers of significant figures , from six to seven for the sn isotopes @xcite that we consider . consequently , we quote and use all our binding energies to six or seven significant figures . our values are generally accurate to the order of two to three kev near the center of the sequence , and tens of kev at both ends for the sn isotopes . see , in particular , @xcite for error bars . the staggering effect is clear from the @xmath30 first differences , @xmath31 \{-673 , -3287 , -243 , -2800 , -46 , -2064 , 557 , -1827 , 1016 , -1608 , 1330 , -1313 , 1554 , -988 , 1767 , -693 , 1950 , -406 , 2169 , -117 , 2253 , 189 , 5031 , 3581 } , see fig . the list of @xmath32 second differences ( sds ) , @xmath33 \{-2614 , 3044 , -2557 , 2754 , -2018 , 2621 , -2384 , 2843 , -2624 , 2938 , -2643 , 2867 , -2542 , 2755 , -2460 , 2643 , -2356 , 2575 , -2286 , 2370 , -2064 , 4842 , -1450 } , is insensitive to the constant and linear terms we used for graphical convenience . it gives estimates of the `` curvatures '' of the pattern . it turns out to be far from containing only positive numbers . the nonconnected points shown in fig . 3 represent this pattern of sds . a systematic oscillation , reflecting the staggering effect , is found . alternating signs are obviously due to the gains of binding for even sn nuclei because of pairing . the oscillation between sds centered at odd and even nuclei has , roughly speaking , a constant amplitude . notice , however , the maximum in the list , @xmath34 due to the shell closure at @xmath35sn . add now to each _ even _ nucleus energy a fixed number , for example @xmath36 kev , to tentatively suppress the increase of binding due to pairing . the resulting list of sds is attenuated by an amount equal to @xmath37 , as illustrated by the full line in fig . the attenuated list reads , \{-114 , 544 , -57 , 254 , 482 , 121 , 116 , 343 , -124 , 438 , -143 , 367 , -42 , 255 , 40 , 143 , 144 , 75 , 214 , -130 , 436 , 2342 , 1050}. all numbers are now significantly smaller than their partners in the previous list of sds , except for the smaller , but still large maximum at @xmath35sn . this maximum is positive , however , and causes no difficulty for concavity . the interesting point is rather the most negative number in the list , namely @xmath38 kev . all negative curvatures can be converted into positive ones if we add to every energy an artificial , parabolic correction , @xmath39 with @xmath40 kev . incidentally , the lowest point , @xmath41 of the `` added parabola '' is arbitrary , because sds will increase by just a constant , namely twice the coefficient @xmath42 of the @xmath43 term . after this @xmath44 kev shift , the whole sequence of sds becomes positive , \{36 , 694 , 93 , 404 , 632 , 271 , 266 , 493 , 26 , 588 , 7 , 517 , 108 , 405 , 190 , 293 , 294 , 225 , 364 , 20 , 586 , 2492 , 1200 } , see the dashed line shown in fig . 3 . in short , a `` concavity ensuring '' manipulation for the isotope energies consists in replacing each energy @xmath25 by @xmath45 + p \times ( a - a_0)^2 + 115000 + 7500\ , a.$ ] ( we recall that the terms which we have added are here just for graphical , and later , numerical convenience ; they do not influence the theory . ) with @xmath46 @xmath40 and @xmath41 the list of such tuned energies @xmath47 ( shown by the nonconnected dots in fig . 1 ) reads , \{17479 , 13831 , 10219 , 7301 , 4476 , 2055 , 266 , -1252 , -2504 , -3263 , -3996 , -4141 , -4279 , -3900 , -3413 , -2521 , -1439 , -64 , 1605 , 3499 , 5757 , 8035 , 10899 , 16255 , 22811}. the choice of the two parameters , p=1250 kev and p=75 kev , is empirical : one looks for a pairing correction leading to a modest , if not minimal , parabolic correction inducing concavity . other choices for @xmath48 are possible , but , obviously , within a small range around @xmath49 and @xmath50 furthermore , such parameters must be readjusted for different regions of the table of nuclei , but it is again obvious that readjustments will be moderate ; for instance , the order of magnitude for pairing will always be around @xmath51 to @xmath52 mev . analyzing short sequences obviously leaves fewer negative sds to be compensated by the artificial , parabolic term , and , hence should induce smaller values of @xmath53 for this reason , we would expect short sequences to give often better extrapolations . once concavity is obtained , it is straightforward that extrapolations from two points on the concave pattern allow predictions of lower bounds to nuclear energies and interpolations give upper bounds . then , from such bounds for energies @xmath54 one recovers bounds , of strictly the same quality , for the physical energies @xmath55 this obtains by subtracting from each @xmath56 bound its `` tuning term '' . assume now that @xmath23sn were unknown and one had done a brute force extrapolation , @xmath57 compared with @xmath58 this prediction underbinds @xmath23sn by @xmath59 kev . consider rather @xmath60 to be compared with @xmath61 a slight overbinding , by 36 kev , is found . although this small error is likely accidental , it is clear that systematic lower bounds will be found . naturally , once a value for @xmath47 is predicted , one recovers as good an estimate for @xmath25 after removing the `` concavity manipulation terms '' , which are known explicitly . in the present case , the tuning of the data added @xmath62 to @xmath63 the same @xmath62 must be subtracted from that value , @xmath60 extrapolated from the concave pattern , yielding a final result of @xmath64 to be compared with @xmath58 which obviously exhibits the same slight overbinding , @xmath65 kev . based on the data in @xcite , the experimentally measured energy for @xmath23sn has an error bar @xmath66 kev ; hence , in this case , the experimental error bar and the uncertainty in our theoretical value have the same order of magnitude . if @xmath35sn were unknown , the brute force extrapolation gives , @xmath67 to be compared with @xmath68 showing an underbinding equal to @xmath69 kev , clearly failing to reproduce the shell closure effect . now , from the concave pattern , we obtain @xmath70 to be compared with @xmath71 producing an overbinding by @xmath72 kev . the same overbinding is obviously found if one subtracts from @xmath70 the tuning difference , @xmath73 with the result , @xmath74 to be compared with @xmath75 see fig . 4 , which also illustrates an extrapolation using @xmath76 and @xmath77 and an interpolation using @xmath78 and @xmath76 . let us now also compare for an odd rather than even isotope , _ e.g. _ , @xmath79sn , two extrapolations and one interpolation from raw data and concave data , respectively . with our choice of parameters , the tuning difference , @xmath80 is @xmath81 with @xmath82 extrapolations from lower masses give , @xmath83 and @xmath84 hence , overbindings of @xmath85 and @xmath86 respectively . extrapolations from higher masses give , @xmath87 and @xmath88 leading to overbindings of @xmath89 and @xmath90 respectively . interpolations from the nearest nuclei give , @xmath91 and @xmath92 with now overbinding of @xmath93 and underbinding of @xmath94 respectively . the poor results from raw data stress the importance of pairing corrections . the much better results from the concave pattern do take this pairing into account , but , furthermore , they again make it trivial that extrapolations give overbindings , while interpolations give underbindings . for the sake of completeness , we now consider a case with a two - step extrapolation . if the tuned pattern followed a perfect parabolic form , @xmath95 the formula , @xmath96 predicts , for the lower bound , an error which is a little larger than desirable . this is because of the coefficient , @xmath97 and the fact that the `` curvature parameter '' , @xmath98 has here an order of magnitude in the few hundred kev range , see those residual second differences used for the dashed curve in fig . this indicates that further stages of the theory , with polynoms at least , are worthy of consideration . however , to remain within the `` linear '' scope of the present paper , we give the results obtained for @xmath99sn , @xmath100 and @xmath101sn , @xmath102 when we use the lower bound estimates from the formula , @xmath103 from ref . @xcite , the predictions , which are based on neighbor nuclei with the same @xmath7 and @xmath6 parities , are @xmath104 and @xmath105 respectively , with error bars of @xmath106 mev . we do find a lower bound for @xmath99sn , with apparently a severe , but mostly expected , error of a couple of mevs . for @xmath101sn , we apparently fail to generate a lower bound , but by so small a difference that our results stay well inside the error bars . to summarize section 2 , when concavity occurs , one concludes that extrapolations from two points on the concave pattern allow predictions of lower bounds to nuclear energies . in the same way , interpolations provide upper bounds . the quality of such `` concavity bounds '' from zero temperature data is found to be good ; interpolations and extrapolations from the raw , nonconcave pattern , are clearly less satisfactory . but there is a more profound reason why a concave pattern is necessary . indeed , several thermodynamical functions , governed by theorems proving their concavity , have a notoriously singular limit at zero temperature : they become nonanalytical and are just piecewise continuous . their limit plots are made of segments ; derivatives are discontinuous at turning points . because of the staggering effect , the _ concave envelope _ of the raw pattern of @xmath25 s would contain only the even isotopes . concavity is , thus , _ necessary _ for a theory that must accommodate both odd and even nuclei . therefore , the thermodynamical functions studied in section 3 preferably use concave energies @xmath47 and the corresponding excited state energies @xmath107 consider the particle number operator @xmath108 and a familiar nuclear hamiltonian @xmath109 where @xmath110 @xmath111 and @xmath112 are the mass number , one - body kinetic energy and two - body interaction , respectively . nuclear data tables @xcite give precise values for a large number of lowest - lying eigenvalues @xmath113 of @xmath114 for many nuclei . one may , thus , reasonably estimate the grand partition function , @xmath115 = \sum_{na } ( 2 j_{na}+1 ) \exp\left [ \beta \left ( \mu a - e_{na } \right ) \right ] , \label{definz}\ ] ] provided that i ) the temperature , @xmath116 is low enough to allow a truncation of the spectrum to include only those states provided by the tables and ii ) the chemical potential , @xmath117 selects mainly those nuclei in which we are interested . let @xmath118 denote , as usual , a statistical average . the ( equilibrium ! ) density operator in fock space , @xmath119,$ ] ensures that the following grand potential , @xmath120 is minimal in the space of many - body density matrices with unit trace , since , by definition , @xmath121 @xmath122 with the entropy , @xmath123 we shall rather use @xmath124 in the following , to make upcoming proofs of concavity slightly easier . this grand potential also reads , @xmath125 \right\},\ ] ] simple manipulations then give the relevant statistical averages @xmath118 of particle numbers and energies , together with their derivatives and fluctuations , @xmath126 , \label{avrgnmb}\ ] ] and @xmath127 then @xmath128 or as well , @xmath129 . \label{avrgnrg}\ ] ] furthermore , @xmath130 , \label{flucb}\ ] ] and @xmath131 . \label{crossab}\ ] ] for our investigations , we will freeze @xmath132 as real and consider functions of a real @xmath3 it is then well known that @xmath124 is a concave function of @xmath133 and @xmath134 in turn , the double legendre transform , with respect to both @xmath133 and @xmath135 @xmath136 shows that @xmath137 is a concave function of both @xmath138 and @xmath139 the conjugate variables of @xmath133 and @xmath135 respectively . in the following , we do not perform the full , double legendre transform . we rather retain an intermediate representation , with @xmath138 and either @xmath140 or @xmath141 we stay with real variables and functions . we stress that , while @xmath108 has a discrete spectrum , @xmath138 is continuous , a monotonically increasing function of @xmath117 smooth provided @xmath132 is finite . the monotonicity results from eq . ( [ fluca ] ) . actually , at low temperatures , strong derivatives signal the onset of discrete jumps due to the integer spectrum of @xmath142 but we may stay away from this `` jumpy '' regime in the following , at least temporarily . anyhow , at any fixed , finite @xmath143 the smoothness and monotonicity of @xmath138 with respect to @xmath133 allows a reasonably easy numerical calculation of the inverse function @xmath144 thus , a main argument of this section is that at fixed temperatures we will use @xmath138 as a continuous variable and attempt extrapolations towards unknown nuclei . for this , given a value of @xmath135 we keep track of @xmath138 and @xmath137 as functions of @xmath3 since the functional inversion from @xmath145 to @xmath146 is reasonably easy , we can plot @xmath137 in terms of @xmath138 and attempt an extrapolation for further values of @xmath5 this extrapolation can be considered as a `` candidate '' for a mass formula , at that finite temperature @xmath134 according to eq . ( [ flucb ] ) , the average , constrained energy , @xmath147 is a monotonically decreasing function of @xmath141 furthermore , at least for negative chemical potentials @xmath133 , and , more generally , if @xmath0 has an upper bound , the operator , @xmath148 is bounded from below . therefore , there is a convergence of the process consisting in i ) extrapolating with respect to @xmath133 both @xmath149 and @xmath138 for fixed values of @xmath143 then ii ) eliminating @xmath133 to generate the @xmath132-parametrized `` mass formula '' @xmath150 and finally iii ) considering the limit of this mass formula when @xmath151 alternately , it is equivalent , and maybe more efficient , to first eliminate @xmath133 and then extrapolate the `` mass formula '' @xmath150 first with respect to @xmath152 then with respect to @xmath141 is there concavity in this intermediate representation ? clearly , a simple legendre transform of @xmath153 with respect to @xmath133 only , returns a free energy , @xmath154 as a concave function of @xmath138 and @xmath134 if @xmath140 is low enough to allow the product @xmath155 to be neglected , then , at fixed @xmath135 one may accept that @xmath137 is an `` almost '' concave function of @xmath5 this assumption will be tested by the numerical results which follow . incidentally , a straightforward calculation of @xmath156 yields , @xmath157 with a positive factor , @xmath158 more simply , @xmath159 if one uses the centered operators , @xmath160 and @xmath161 from eq . ( [ secderisimpl ] ) , concavity for @xmath137 is unclear ; we shall have to test it numerically . the results , which follow , use @xcite for the excited - state energies of the sn isotopes . using the first @xmath162 levels of @xmath23sn to @xmath35sn , hence a maximum excitation of , typically , @xmath163 mev for odd isotopes and twice as much for even ones , we calculate @xmath164 see eq . ( [ definz ] ) . for those rare cases , where the spin @xmath165 is ambiguous , we choose the lowest of the suggested spins . if the spin is completely unknown , we set it to be either @xmath166 or @xmath167 , according to @xmath168 these tactics minimize the statistical influence of such rare cases . the highest excited levels that we use have an excitation energy of order a few mev ; hence , we restrict our thermodynamical analysis to temperatures of order @xmath169 kev at most . it should be noted that we use the concavity tuned energies , @xmath170 + 75\ , ( a-122)^2.$ ] consequently , all our calculated quantities , @xmath171 @xmath172 @xmath173 _ etc . _ , derived from eqs . ( [ avrgnmb ] ) , ( [ ntrp ] ) , and ( [ avrgnrg ] ) , for instance , carry a prime superscript . we want to stress that the spurious exponential factor created by the constant , @xmath174 appears in the same way in numerators and denominators and , hence , cancels out ; it only helps the graphics and numerics . similarly , the linear term , @xmath175 means but a change of reference for the chemical potential . only the pairing and parabolic tuning terms make the primed quantities truly distinct from those `` raw '' , unprimed ones , obtained with the untuned energies @xmath176 as an example of our results we choose for fig . 5 the sequence of six isotopes from @xmath177sn to @xmath178sn , because of its still severely contrasted list of second differences , @xmath179 after tuning . this produces a serious geometrical constraint on the plots of @xmath180 and @xmath181 , as they reach their zero temperature limit , and better validates our approach . the upper curves in fig . 5 are the plots of the function @xmath182 when @xmath183 kev ( lower full curve ) and @xmath184 kev ( upper full curve ) , respectively . the increase of @xmath173 when @xmath140 increases is transparent . the striking result is the apparent concavity of both curves . it is also found that the lower temperature , @xmath185 kev , is low enough to allow @xmath180 to run , in practice , almost through the ground - state energies of both even and odd nuclei . as a check of our results , we repeated our calculations using the untuned energies , i.e. , those which lack concavity . we then found that the low temperature limit of the @xmath137 curve went through the _ even _ nuclei only , namely , the limit curve follows the _ concave envelope _ of the experimental pattern . for graphical and pedagogical convenience , fig . 5 shows the plots for six nuclei only , but the same observations hold for full plots , with @xmath186 as a test , we also calculated @xmath180 and its low temperature limit when the levels of @xmath35sn are omitted from the trace sum , eq . ( [ definz ] ) . in that case , the concave envelope goes through the dots representing the two odd nuclei , @xmath187sn and @xmath188sn , and ignores the dot representing @xmath35sn . similar verifications of other concave envelopes were obtained by removing other nuclei . to verify whether concave envelopes and concavity for @xmath180 result from negligible values of the entropy term in the free energy , or , more precisely , negligible values of its second derivative , a calculation of @xmath189 is in order . figure 6 shows the difference , @xmath190 between the energy and the free energy , as a function of @xmath171 for @xmath183 and @xmath191 kev , respectively . at the higher temperature , @xmath191 kev , wiggling effects seem to be small enough to allow for the concavity of @xmath192 at the lower temperature , @xmath185 kev , the wiggling is stronger . as a consequence of such a strong wiggling , possibly translating into strong second derivatives , it is not excluded that sds coming from @xmath189 might prevent @xmath180 from having the proven concavity property of the free energy . we must , therefore , numerically calculate second derivatives , see eq . ( [ secderisimpl ] ) . in fig . 7 we show , for tuned data , plots of the rhs of eq . ( [ secderisimpl ] ) , divided by @xmath193 this quantity must remain positive if @xmath180 shows concavity . the full line represents the situation when @xmath183 kev , the dashed line corresponds to @xmath184 kev . we see that the second derivative , @xmath194 remains positive almost always . for low temperatures , however , negative values may appear . for instance , the full curve , corresponding to @xmath183 kev , indicates small , but definitely negative values around @xmath177sn . numerical tests , which are not easy because of a difference effect between the two terms present in eq . ( [ secderisimpl ] ) , show that the occurrence of such negative , actually moderate , values for lower temperatures might be somewhat frequent , while not systematic . furthermore , such `` negativity accidents '' turn out to be worse when we use untuned data , maybe because the untuned data lack concavity in the first place . a likely reason for the negativity accidents with tuned data might be that the fluctuation of @xmath108 is not large enough to justify our use of @xmath195 as a continuous variable . since it interpolates between integers , a fluctuation of order @xmath196 or at least @xmath197 might be necessary . as shown by the plots in fig . 8 , corresponding to @xmath183 kev and @xmath191 kev for the lower and upper curves , respectively , a minimum temperature of order @xmath198 kev is needed to avoid too small a fluctuation of the particle number . indeed , for , e.g. @xmath199 kev , we found that the fluctuation is smaller than @xmath200 for almost half of the calculated values of @xmath201 at this stage , the situation can be summarized as follows . on the one hand , the tuned pattern of experimental energies shows concavity , but the concavity of @xmath180 as a function of @xmath195 is not sure , although it seems to occur most of the time . on the other hand , we have a theorem proving concavity for the free energy , either @xmath202 or @xmath203 as functions of @xmath140 and @xmath138 or @xmath171 respectively . for instance , elementary derivations show that , in that representation where @xmath138 ( or @xmath195 ) and @xmath132 are the primary variables , @xmath204 to summarize this discussion , we see that the removal of the entropy term , leading from the free energy to just the energy , can sometimes destroy the concavity depending upon the temperature , but only weakly , _ e.g. , _ see fig . 7 . a compromise may be found so that @xmath140 is low enough to make @xmath205 small with respect to @xmath181 and high enough to ensure both sufficient values of @xmath206 and a tolerable oscillating of @xmath207 our rationale will be that @xmath173 even though it might deviate from concavity , will stay close enough to the concave @xmath208 their difference , @xmath209 a positive quantity , will define an error bar between a lower bound @xmath181 and an upper bound @xmath180 for ground - state tuned energies . consider again fig . 5 . there is no need to stress how , given @xmath135 the energy and free energy curves make a band defining upper and lower bounds for the experimental energies . moreover , a similar , but narrower band is obtained if @xmath140 decreases . figs . 5 , 6 and 8 suggests @xmath210 kev for an error bar @xmath169 kev between energy and free energy , a smooth enough entropy energy and a sufficient fluctuation of the particle number . this order of magnitude for @xmath140 is compatible with the average level splitting , of order @xmath211 kev , that is observed from the first 10 levels of @xmath23sn , ... , @xmath35sn used in our calculations . the following properties , i ) the average energy and the free energy are increasing and decreasing , respectively , functions of increasing @xmath135 ii ) the energy is larger than the free energy and iii ) the entropy term by which they differ vanishes when @xmath140 vanishes , are not big surprises . it can be concluded that , in so far as thermodynamical functions can be calculated at low enough temperatures , precise `` accuracy bands '' may be available . their , hopefully analytic , continuation for higher and/or lower values of @xmath0 than those available in nuclear tables provides a prediction scheme for exotic nuclei . an estimate of the entropy term is now useful . given @xmath133 and a _ @xmath143 let @xmath212 and @xmath213 correspond to that nucleus whose ground - state energy maximizes the exponential , @xmath214.$ ] consider now the first subdominant exponential . it might be generated by the first excited state of the same nucleus , or by the ground - state of one of its neighbors . let @xmath215 and @xmath216 be its parameters and define @xmath217 concavity guarantees that @xmath218 whenever @xmath132 is large enough , it is trivial to reduce the grand canonical ensemble to a two state ensemble , and the entropy then boils down to @xmath219 hence , the product , @xmath220 vanishes exponentially fast when @xmath221 the rate of decrease is governed by that scale defined by @xmath222 to be extracted from the tuned data . then one can estimate an order of magnitude for the difference between the free energy and the energy . this estimate can be viewed as an error bar for the prediction of exotic nuclei via the present `` concavity method '' . we have applied the approach to several other isotopic regions , such as sm , hg , pb . in all cases , making the switch to the concave shape improves our ability to make extrapolations and interpolations for unknown bindings . however , estimating the free energy and the average value of @xmath114 to set narrow upper and lower bounds on these binding energies , remains more difficult in drip line regions , because of the lack of experimental data on excited states in such regions . very simple linear extrapolations still provide , nonetheless , error bars with an order of magnitude @xmath223 kev , similar to the best `` band '' seen in fig . a few examples of the kind of results that we can obtain from this thermodynamical error - bar analysis , when using the method described in sec . 2 , are these conservative estimates of the bindings of @xmath224hg , @xmath225hg and @xmath226hg , namely @xmath227 mev @xmath228 kev , @xmath229 mev @xmath228 kev and @xmath230 mev @xmath228 kev , respectively . we now want to consider binding - energy systematics in two dimensions , _ i.e. , _ n and z. the second differences studied in this section are , @xmath231 @xmath232 @xmath233 and @xmath234 if @xmath6 and @xmath7 were continuous , and , furthermore , if @xmath235 were a smooth function of @xmath6 and @xmath236 the numbers , @xmath237 @xmath238 @xmath239 and @xmath240 might be interpreted as estimates of second derivatives of the function @xmath241 in the neutron , proton , constant @xmath242 and constant @xmath0 directions , respectively . their connections with neutron , proton and p - n pairings and with a symmetry energy are also transparent . setting aside what we consider to be `` light '' nuclei , namely those of the s- , p- , sd- and f@xmath243 shells , we calculated these four sds for the rest of the known nuclear table . their maxima and minima are found to be of order @xmath244 kev , respectively . the lhs parts of figs . 9 - 12 show , in scattered plots with respect to @xmath110 the patterns of those sd values . the negative sds , contradicting concavity , are due mainly to pairing effects . an extension of the correction done in sec . 2 is in order . let @xmath245 be a mass dependent @xcite estimate of pairing . diminish the binding of doubly even nuclei by @xmath245 , increase the binding of doubly odd ones by @xmath246 and leave odd nuclei untouched . we set , empirically , @xmath247 there is no doubt that better parametrizations of @xmath245 are possible @xcite , but the present linear decrease suffices for our demonstration . with this correction , the worst sds become @xmath248 kev , respectively . as expected , this is a large reduction of both positive and negative amplitudes . this is shown by the rhs parts of figs . 9 - 12 , respectively . while the pairing correction has not completely suppressed negative sds , note the worst minimum is still of order @xmath249 kev , concavity has been improved significantly and extrapolations are likely made more secure . similar to our one - dimensional analysis in sec . 2 , one can now add to the energies a paraboloid term , of the form , @xmath250 in order to get rid of the residual , negative sds . ( we recall that sds do not depend on @xmath251 and @xmath252 which are only parameters for graphical and/or numerical convenience . ) notice from fig . 12 , and the corresponding worse minimum , of order @xmath253 kev , that the direction where @xmath0 is constant does not deviate much from concavity . the dominant term in the paraboloid must , therefore , indicate a direction approximately orthogonal , and also take into account the bend of the global stability valley towards neutron excess . there is , furthermore , no doubt that the two - dimensional free energy , now a function of both @xmath6 and @xmath7 made continuous by a grand canonical ensemble , remains a concave function , available for lower bounds . this is a theorem , which can be proven in a straightforward manner following the previous derivation for one dimension . simultaneously , it is likely that the mean energy will be again `` almost concave '' , to yield upper bounds , in which case the same error bar that was estimated in sec . 3 remains valid . a systematic use of such properties throughout the nuclear table is way beyond the scope of the present paper . rather , we want to discuss the relation of concavity with the derivation of a nuclear density functional . recall that , given an arbitrary many - body density matrix @xmath254 in fock space , the density functional derives from the definition @xcite , @xmath255={\rm inf}_{{\cal m } \rightarrow \rho_p,\rho_n } { \rm tr}\ , { \bf h}\ , { \cal m}.\ ] ] here the symbol , @xmath256 means that a minimization of the energy is performed upon density matrices having the same neutron and proton profiles @xmath257 a nucleus is identified by the integrals , @xmath258 and @xmath259 and a later minimization is performed with respect to the profiles @xmath260 under such identification constraints , @xmath261.\ ] ] the functional @xmath262 should be universal , in the nuclear physics sense . namely , it should not depend on @xmath6 and @xmath263 ( in atomic and molecular physics , universality of the df has a different meaning ; it refers to arbitrary external potentials . ) while bcs and hartree - bogoliubov calculations allow a distinction between even and odd particle numbers , universality in density profile space does not allow such a separate treatment . observe , furthermore , that , because of the fact that there are many convexities in the pattern of raw energies , there exist many cases where , for instance , three nuclei , @xmath264 are such that @xmath265 and @xmath266 and @xmath267 then , in a search for @xmath268 the mixture density matrix , @xmath269 but an absurd energy , lower than @xmath270 concavity is a _ mandatory condition _ for the universality of @xmath271 one way to simultaneously implement pairing corrections and use a minimal paraboloid term consists in adding to the physical @xmath272 terms such as , @xmath273 + u\ , { \bf n}^2 + 2v\ , { \bf n}\ , { \bf z } + w\ , { \bf z}^2.$ ] ( notice how the cosines take advantage of the continuous nature of @xmath274 and @xmath275 at finite temperatures . ) concavity is achieved if @xmath276 are tuned to compensate for the worst tuned sd minima listed above , namely @xmath277 a rough solution consists in taking @xmath278 and a `` circular '' ansatz , @xmath279 with @xmath280 but less brutal solutions are obviously worthy of consideration , in order to minimize this tampering with the hamiltonian . in any case , we stress that the operators , @xmath281 and @xmath282 commute with @xmath272 , and , therefore , that the present counterterms do not perturb nuclear dynamics . once again we emphasize that this approach _ unifies _ the treatment of odd and even nuclei . the fact that the nuclear density functional needs to originate from a hamiltonian , completed by such counterterms , illustrates how important concavity is for making predictions for nuclei far from stability , _ i.e. , _ for the so - called exotic nuclei . we have demonstrated how a list of ground - state energies for a sequence of isotopes can be turned into a concave pattern . this involves simple manipulations ; for instance , an explicit term , accounting for pairing in even nuclei , can be subtracted from the bindings . this unifies the treatment of odd and even nuclei , a notoriously difficult problem . if needed , a small quadratic correction can also be added to guarantee concavity at all points along the sequence . similar arguments leading to concavity clearly hold for isotones as well , and , furthermore , for any other sequence of neighboring nuclei in any direction across the nuclear table . once this empirical tuning has been implemented , linear ( or more general ) extra- and interpolations of the concave pattern can provide surprisingly accurate and robust estimates of , or bounds for , binding energies . these tuning terms , which are added to induce concavity , are , of course , subtracted _ in fine_. this work then defined a more ambitious extra- and interpolation scheme , involving thermodynamical functions from a grand canonical ensemble , because such functions may have rigorous concavity properties . theorems are , indeed , available to prove such properties . for instance , the free energy is a concave function of the average particle number and is also a decreasing function of the temperature . we also found strong numerical evidences concerning the average energy . this average energy at nonzero temperature turns out , in general , to be a concave function of the average particle number , except for `` minor accidents , '' which depend upon the temperature . for every given , finite temperature , we found that the average energy and the free energy , as functions of the average particle number , give upper and lower bounds , respectively , for the concave envelope of the ground - state energies . when the temperature vanishes , both bounds converge to the exact results . at this vanishing temperature , however , the analyticity of such thermodynamical functions is lost , because their limit is only piecewise continuous . it is , therefore , necessary to retain a minimum temperature if one wants to obtain practical extrapolations for the prediction of exotic nuclei . a minimum amount of particle number fluctuation is necessary to validate the conversion of particle number , an initially discrete quantity , into a continuous variable . we , therefore , implemented numerical estimates of several thermodynamical functions at moderate temperatures , a few hundred kev at most . this yields a first result , namely a `` band '' , enclosing ground - state energies between the average energy and the free energy . the width of the band defines an error bar which can be trusted when extrapolations are made . a difficulty arises , however , because of an insufficient number of excited states for nuclei at both ends of any sequence of isotopes . these excited - state energies are essential for calculating a meaningful value of the average energy for any value of a. more often , only the ground - state energy is known for such neutron very rich or neutron very poor nuclei . the calculation of the average and free energies is , thus , possible only in an interval smaller than the interval of masses where ground states are known . two tactics are then available , namely i ) an extrapolation only of the sequence of ground - state energies and ii ) an extrapolation of the thermodynamical functions , starting from a smaller interval . we found that the first tactic , namely at zero temperature , is reliable , especially when completed by the error bar derived from the finite temperature considerations . this work also tested the second tactic , with some success but with the limitation due to the lack of known excited states . the lack leads to edge effects in the calculation of thermodynamical functions . therefore , if linear , or polynomial , or more general analytical fits of such thermodynamical functions are attempted , it is better to restrict them from a slightly smaller mass interval . then , extrapolations should be reliable within one and maybe two mass units towards drip lines . we can make the strong conclusion that the combination of concavity and extrapolations of thermodynamical functions gives a systematic set of upper and lower bounds for the prediction of ground - state energies . our last , and perhaps most important result , is the connection between concavity and the universality of the density functional . in a two - dimensional analysis , we showed that a paraboloid term with respect to the proton and neutron number operators _ must _ be added to the hamiltonian , so as to guarantee obtaining consistent energy minima everywhere in density space . this term can be made minimal if counterterms for pairing are also added . : we thank i. allison for helpful discussions and assistance with the management of the data sets . it is a pleasure for b. r. b. and b. g. g. to thank triumf , vancouver , b. c. , canada , where part of this work was done , for its hospitality . the natural science and engineering research council of canada is thanked for financial support . triumf receives federal funding via a contribution agreement through the national research council of canada . b. r. b. also thanks institut de physique thorique , saclay , france , for its hospitality , where another part of this work was carried out , and the gesellschaft fr schwerionenforschung ( gsi ) , darmstadt , germany , for its hospitality during the preparation of this manuscript , and acknowledges partial support from nsf grant phy0555396 and from the alexander von humboldt stiftung . eisenberg and w. greiner , _ nuclear models _ ( north holland / american elsevier , amsterdam , 1975 ) ; k.s . krane , _ introductory nuclear physics _ , ( wiley , new york , 1988 ) ; c.h . dasso and m.j . gallardo , phys . c * 74 * , 014307 ( 2006 )

sequences of experimental ground - state energies for both odd and even @xmath0 are mapped onto concave patterns cured from convexities due to pairing and/or shell effects . the same patterns , completed by a list of excitation energies , give numerical estimates of the grand potential @xmath1 for a mixture of nuclei at low or moderate temperatures @xmath2 and at many chemical potentials @xmath3 the average nucleon number @xmath4 then becomes a continuous variable , allowing extrapolations towards nuclear masses closer to drip lines . we study the possible concavity of several thermodynamical functions , such as the free energy and the average energy , as functions of @xmath5 concavity , which always occurs for the free energy and is usually present for the average energy , allows easy interpolations and extrapolations providing upper and lower bounds , respectively , to binding energies . such bounds define an error bar for the prediction of binding energies . finally we show how concavity and universality are related in the theory of the nuclear density functional . * pacs : * 21.10.dr , 21.10.-k , 21.60.-n , 24.10.pa

cond-mat0410379

many networks in nature and technology are sparse , _ i.e. _ , the average node degree is much smaller than the total number of nodes @xmath0 @xcite . widely studied classes of networks , such as regular grids , random graphs , and scale - free networks , are maximally sparse , as the average node degree remains finite as @xmath1 . however , in other examples of real sparse networks , such as the internet , the average node degree grows , albeit very slowly , with system size . motivated by this observation , we introduce a simple network growth mechanism of copying that naturally generates sparse networks in which the average node degree diverges logarithmically with system size . we dub these log - networks . related results appear in previous investigations of related models @xcite , while models where a slowly increasing ratio of links to nodes is imposed externally have also been considered @xcite . to motivate the copying mechanism for log - networks let us recall the growing network with redirection ( gnr ) @xcite . the gnr is built by adding nodes according to the following simple rule . each new node initially selects an earlier `` target '' node at random . with a specified probability a link from the new node to the target node is created ; with a complementary probability , the link is re - directed to the ancestor node of the target . although the target node is chosen randomly , the redirection mechanism generates an effective preferential attachment because a high - degree node is more likely to be the ancestor of a randomly - selected node . by this feature , redirection leads to a power - law degree distribution for the network . the gnr thus provides an appealingly simple mechanism for preferential attachment , as well as an extremely efficient way to simulate large scale - free networks @xcite . the growing network with redirection is a simplification of a previous model @xcite which was proposed to mimic the copying of links in the world - wide web . in this web model , a new node links to a randomly - chosen target node and also to its ancestor nodes ( subject to a constraint on the maximum number of links created ) . in the context of citations , copying is ( regrettably ) even more natural , as it is easier merely to copy the references of a cited paper , rather than to look at the original references @xcite . as the literature grows , the copying mechanism will necessarily lead to later publications having more references than earlier publications . in the following sections , we analyze a growing network model with copying ( gnc ) . we consider a model with no global bound on the number of links emanating from a new node . we shall see that this simple copying mechanism generates log - networks . we will use the master equation approach to derive basic geometric properties of the network . we then compare our prediction about the logarithmic growth of the average degree with data from physical review citations . we now define the gnc model precisely . the network grows by adding nodes one at a time . a newly - introduced node randomly selects a target node and links to it , as well as to all ancestor nodes of the target node ( fig . [ c ] ) . if the target node is the initial root node , no additional links are generated by the copying mechanism . if the newly - introduced node were to always choose the root node as the target , a star graph would be generated . on the other hand , if the target node is always the most recent one in the network , all previous nodes are ancestors of the target and the copying mechanism would give a complete graph . correspondingly , the total number of links @xmath2 in a network of @xmath0 nodes can range from @xmath3 ( star graph ) to @xmath4 ( complete graph ) . notice also that the number of outgoing links from each new node ( the out - degree ) can range between 1 and the current number of nodes . we now study geometric properties of the gnc model by the master equation approach . we determine how the total number of links @xmath5 grows with @xmath0 , as well as the in - degree , out - degree , and the joint in / out - degree distributions . let @xmath6 be the average value of the total number of links in a network of @xmath0 nodes . if a newly - introduced node selects a target node with @xmath7 ancestors , then the number of links added to the network will be @xmath8 . therefore the average total number of links satisfies @xmath9 the factor @xmath10 in the first line assures that a target node @xmath11 is selected uniformly from among all @xmath0 nodes , and we obtain the second line by employing the sum rule @xmath12 . dividing eq . ( [ ln ] ) by @xmath13 gives @xmath14 and then summing both sides from 1 to @xmath3 gives the solution @xmath15 here @xmath16 is the harmonic number . ( for concreteness , we assume that the network starts with a single node , so that @xmath17 . ) using the asymptotics of the harmonic numbers @xcite we find @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the euler constant . the leading asymptotic behavior of @xmath20 can also be obtained more easily from eq . ( [ ln ] ) by taking the continuum approximation and solving the resulting differential equation . for @xmath21 realizations of a gnc of @xmath22 sites . shown are both the raw data and the result of averaging the data over a 1% range . for this value of @xmath0 , the mean number of links is 6485.56 , while eq . ( [ ln - sol - asymp ] ) gives 6485.47 . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] thus we conclude that the average degree of the network grows logarithmically with the system size ; that is , the copying mechanism generates a log - network . this simple phenomenon is one of our major results . we now briefly discuss the probability distribution of the total number of links @xmath23 for a network of @xmath0 nodes . simulations show that the distribution is asymmetric and quite broad ( fig . [ pl ] ) . to understand the origin of the asymmetry , notice that both the extreme cases of the star graph ( @xmath24 ) and the complete graph ( @xmath25 ) each occur with probability @xmath26 because each new node must select one specific target node . therefore the distribution of the total number of links vanishes much more sharply near the lower cutoff . near the peak however , the distribution @xmath23 is symmetric about the average . more precisely , when the deviation from the average @xmath27 is of the order of @xmath28 ^ 2\,p_n(l)}$ ] , the distribution approaches a symmetric gaussian shape . the value of the standard deviation as @xmath1 is @xmath29 as derived in appendix [ ap ] . the relative width of the distribution is measured by the standard deviation @xmath30 divided by the average @xmath6 ; this ratio approaches zero as @xmath31 when @xmath1 , so that fluctuations die out slowly . this slow decay of fluctuations explains why the distribution ( fig . [ pl ] ) remains wide for large @xmath0 and why it looks asymmetric near the peak . the gnc model can be extended to allow for wider copying variability . for example , instead of linking to one initial random target node , we can link to @xmath32 random initial targets . further , we can link to each target node with probability @xmath33 and to each of the corresponding ancestors with probability @xmath34 . for this general @xmath35 model , the analog of eq . ( [ ln ] ) is @xcite @xmath36 which reduces to @xmath37 in the continuum approximation . the asymptotic growth of the average total number of links crucially depends on the parameter @xmath38 : @xmath39 thus incomplete copying leads to an average node degree that is independent of @xmath0 when @xmath40 , while marginal logarithmic dependence is recovered when @xmath41 . there is also a pathology for @xmath42 , as the number of links in the network would exceed that of a complete graph with the same number of nodes . in this case , it is not possible to accommodate all the links specified by the copying rule without having a multigraph , _ i.e. _ , allowing for more than one link between a given pair of nodes . we now present empirical data from the citation network of physical review to test whether the average degree of these networks grows with time , and if so , whether the growth is consistent with log - networks . data from all issues of physical review journals is available , encompassing a time span of 110 years @xcite . from this data , we have the following evidence that citations may be described as a log - network . specifically , the average number of references in the reference list of each physical review paper grows systematically with time and is consistent with a linear increase ( fig . [ ref - compare ] ) . additionally , the number of physical review papers published in a given year roughly grows exponentially with time @xcite . thus the cumulative number of physical review papers up to a given year also grows exponentially . as a result , the number of references should grow logarithmically with the total number of available papers . this behavior is reasonably consistent with the data of fig . [ ref - compare ] . ) . also shown as a smooth curve is the logarithm of the cumulative number of physical review papers that were published up to each year . the value 5 is subtracted from the latter data to make the two datasets lie in the same range.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] in a related vein , the average number of coauthors per paper has grown slowly with time , due in part , to the growing trend for collaborative research and the continuing ease of long - distance scientific interaction . while co - authorship and other collaboration networks have recently been investigated ( see , _ e.g. _ , @xcite ) , the analysis has primarily been on network properties at a fixed time . there is , however , one study of the number of mathematics papers with 1 , 2 , and more authors since 1940 @xcite . this data shows that the fraction of singly - authored papers is decreasing systematically , while the number of multiple - authored papers is steadily growing . thus it should be interesting to track the time dependence of the number of co - authors in scientific publications from the current studies of collaboration networks . interestingly , the internet and the world wide web exhibit certain similarities with log - networks . for example , the total number of links exceeds the total number of nodes in the world wide web by about an order of magnitude @xcite . similarly for the internet , specifically for the autonomous systems ( as ) graph , the average number of links per node is also growing slowly but systematically with time @xcite . qualitatively these behaviors are consistent with our expectations from log - networks . it is not still possible to reach definitive conclusions about the precise growth rate on @xmath0 since the available data for the as graph @xcite covers a time period when the total number of ases has increased only by a factor of 4 ( from @xmath43 in 1997 to @xmath44 in 2001 ) . by its very construction , the links of the gnc network are directed and thus there is an in - degree @xmath45 and an out - degree @xmath7 for each node ( fig . [ degrees ] ) , and thus two distinct corresponding degree distributions . in this subsection , we study the in - degree distribution . let @xmath46 be the average number of nodes with in - degree @xmath45 in a network consisting of @xmath0 total nodes . this distribution satisfies @xmath47 the loss term accounts for the following two processes : ( a ) either a node of in - degree @xmath45 , or ( b ) any of its @xmath45 daughter nodes was chosen as the target . either of these processes leads to the loss of a node with in - degree @xmath45 . the total loss rate of @xmath46 is thus @xmath48 . the gain term is explained similarly , and the last term on the right - hand side of eq . ( [ pi ] ) describes the effect of the introduction of a new node with no incoming links . finally , notice that eqs . ( [ pi ] ) hold for @xmath49 . when @xmath50 , there is no longer a loss term and the master equation reduces to @xmath51 . this accounts for the fact that the root node is necessarily linked to all other nodes and therefore there is one node with degree @xmath3 in a network of @xmath0 nodes . we compute the in - degree distribution by induction . solving for the first few @xmath46 for small @xmath45 directly , we find a simple form for the general case that we then check solves the master equation ( [ pi ] ) . we thus find @xmath52 while @xmath53 for @xmath54 . the asymptotic @xmath55 decay agrees with the logarithmic divergence for the average node degree from the previous section , and perhaps explains the proliferation of exponent values close to 2 for the in - degree distribution that are observed in empirical studies of collaboration networks @xcite and in the world wide web @xcite . in particular , a comprehensive study by by broder et al . @xcite reports an exponent value 2.09 , while a recent work by donato et al . @xcite ( relying on the webbase project at stanford @xcite ) quotes an exponent value 2.1 . , with nodes arranged in layers left to right according to their out - degree . the initial layer contains only the root node . the number of nodes in subsequent layers increases as the network grows . the initial links are shown as solid arrows and the copied links as dashed arrows.,scaledwidth=32.5% ] to determine the out - degree distribution , it is helpful to think of the network as a genealogical tree , as illustrated in fig . [ out ] ( see also @xcite for this construction ) . initially the network consists of one root node . subsequent nodes that attach to the root node will have out - degree 1 and lie in the first layer . similarly , a new node that attaches to a node with out - degree 1 lies in the second layer . by the copying mechanism , nodes in this second layer also link to the root and therefore have out - degree 2 . nodes in the @xmath56 layer directly attach to a node in the @xmath57 layer and , by virtue of copying , also attach to one node in every previous layer . thus @xmath56 layer nodes have out - degree @xmath58 . we now use this genealogical tree picture to determine the out - degree distribution of the network . let @xmath59 be the average number of nodes with out - degree @xmath7 in a network consisting of @xmath0 nodes . by definition @xmath60 . on the other hand , the number of nodes with out - degree @xmath61 grows each time a node with out - degree @xmath62 is selected as the target node . the out - degree distribution thus satisfies the master equation @xmath63 this equation applies even for @xmath64 if we set . using the recursive nature of these equations , we first solve for @xmath65 , then @xmath66 , _ etc _ , and ultimately the out - degree distribution for all @xmath7 . this procedure gives @xmath67 equivalently , we can recast the @xmath7-fold sums into simple sums , although the results look less neat . for example , @xmath68\ ] ] where @xmath69 . the asymptotic behaviors of @xmath70 , @xmath71 , and other generalized harmonic numbers are known @xcite , and the resulting asymptotics of the out - degree distribution are @xmath72+\ldots\end{aligned}\ ] ] and analogous results hold for @xmath59 for larger @xmath7 . if we merely want to establish the leading asymptotic behavior , we can replace the summation in ( [ qj - sol ] ) by integration . this then leads to the simple result @xmath73 alternatively , we can derive this result within a continuum approach by replacing finite differences by derivatives in the large-@xmath0 limit of eq . ( [ qj ] ) . the procedure recasts the discrete master equations into the differential equations @xmath74 whose solution is indeed ( [ qj - sol - cont ] ) . the poisson form of the out - degree distribution contradicts the commonly presumed power - law form . there is previous literature by broder _ that suggested that the out - degree distribution has a power - law tail , with exponent close to 2.7 @xcite . however , this work also noted that a power - law is not a good fit to the data and that the out - degree distribution may possibly follow a poisson distribution . in fact , the analysis of ref . @xcite that is based on more recent data on the structure of the web @xcite convincingly shows that a power law does not fit the out - degree distribution . we define the joint degree distribution @xmath75 as the average number of nodes with in - degree @xmath45 and out - degree @xmath7 in a network of @xmath0 nodes . the in- and out - degree distributions can then be distilled from the joint distribution via @xmath76 and @xmath77 . furthermore , the average number of nodes with total degree @xmath78 is simply given by @xmath79 . the joint degree distribution satisfies @xmath80 which is an obvious generalization of the governing equations ( [ pi ] ) and ( [ qj ] ) for the separate in- and out - degree distributions . because of the presence of the last out - degree term on the right - hand side of equation ( [ nij ] ) , the scaling of the joint degree distribution with system size does not hold . therefore we can not reduce ( [ nij ] ) to an @xmath0-independent recursion . nevertheless , eqs . ( [ nij ] ) still have the important simplifying feature of being recursive and thus soluble in an inductive fashion . thus , for example , for @xmath82 we have @xmath83 from which @xmath84 for @xmath85 , we rewrite eqs . ( [ nij ] ) in the form @xmath86 now the substitution @xmath87 reduces ( [ nij1 ] ) to the constant - coefficient recursion @xmath88 that allows us to express @xmath89 via @xmath90 : @xmath91 from ( [ aij - def ] ) we find @xmath92 which , in conjunction with ( [ n0j ] ) , gives @xmath93 therefore starting with @xmath94 from eq . ( [ a0j ] ) , we find all the @xmath89 via eq . ( [ aij ] ) . the final result is @xmath95 equations ( [ qj - sol ] ) , ( [ aij - def ] ) , ( [ aij - sol ] ) give the full solution for the joint degree distribution . while the complete solution is cumbersome , it can be simplified as @xmath1 . in this limit , we can first replace the factor @xmath96 by @xmath97 in eq . ( [ aij - def ] ) . additionally , we can replace the summation in eq . ( [ aij - sol ] ) by integration . these two replacements are justified when @xmath98 . finally , using ( [ qj - sol - cont ] ) and after some algebra , we find the leading behavior @xmath99 and more generally @xmath100^{i+1}.\ ] ] because the poisson form the out - degree distribution holds only when @xmath101 , the generalized poisson form ( [ qj - sol - cont ] ) for the joint degree distribution is also valid only for @xmath102 . finally , although the total degree distribution @xmath103 does not satisfy a closed equation , we can obtain this distribution indirectly . when @xmath78 is of the order of @xmath104 or smaller , we can use ( [ nij - sol - cont ] ) to find @xmath103 . the situation in the range @xmath105 is even simpler : in this region , the total degree distribution essentially coincides with the in - degree distribution and therefore @xmath106 ( fig . [ deg - dist ] ) . we introduced a growing network model that is based on node addition plus a simple copying mechanism the gnc that leads to an average node degree growing logarithmically with the total number of nodes @xmath0 . this feature may account for the intriguing phenomenon observed in many real networks that the number of links increases slightly faster than the number of nodes . copying arises naturally in the context of citations ; a not untypical scenario is that an author will be familiar with a few primary references , but may simply copy secondary references from primary ones . we solved the underlying master equations for the gnc model and showed that the in - degree distribution is a power - law over its entire range , while the out - degree distribution is asymptotically poissonian . the total degree distribution is consequently a hybrid of the power - law and poisson forms . there is , on average , one node with total degree equal to 1 , and there is always one node the root that has in - degree equal to @xmath3 . thus the node degree ranges from one to @xmath3 . since the distribution of @xmath5 has a width that scales linearly with @xmath0 while @xmath6 grows as @xmath20 , fluctuations in node degree are appreciable even for very large networks . finally , each node is connected to the root , so that the network diameter equals 2 , independent of @xmath0 . from long - term physical review publication data , the average number of references per paper ( the out degree ) grows slowly with the total literature size , consistent with the logarithmic growth predicted by the gnc model . however , this growth in the gnc model is not robust when parameters that quantify the extent of copying are varied . the apparent logarithmic growth for the average number of references per paper in the physical review is thus a bit surprising and it will be worthwhile to test whether logarithmic growth arises in a wider range of empirical networks . in this appendix , we find the variance in the distribution of the number of links @xmath23 . we start by computing the first two moments of the out - degree distribution , @xmath107 and @xmath108 . we then use these results to derive the variance of @xmath23 . to determine @xmath109 and @xmath110 , we can in principle use eq . ( [ qj - sol ] ) . however , a direct approach is more useful . starting with @xmath111 , we find that adding a new node leads to the recursion relation @xmath112 which is nothing but eq . ( [ ln ] ) . in a similar manner , we derive a recursion relation for @xmath113 @xmath114 which reduces to @xmath115 the variance @xmath116 therefore satisfies @xmath117 from this simple recursion we get @xmath118 the relative magnitude of fluctuations die out slowly , as the standard deviation , @xmath119 divided by the average @xmath120 , approaches zero as @xmath121 . consider now the average number of links in the network @xmath122 and the corresponding second moment @xmath123 . after the addition of a new node , the second moment changes according to @xmath124 now we use @xmath125 to write the square of eq . ( [ un ] ) in the form @xmath126 and then subtracting this from the previous equation , the variance @xmath127 satisfies @xmath128 the homogeneous part of ( [ sn ] ) suggests seeking a solution of the form @xmath129 . this substitution recasts ( [ sn ] ) into @xmath130^{-1}\sigma^2(n)$ ] . this is an exact discrete first derivative for @xmath131 . hence @xmath131 equals @xmath132^{-1}\sigma^2(m)$ ] . thus the variance is @xmath133 finally , by substituting @xmath134 from ( [ sn - sol ] ) into ( [ sn - sol ] ) , and changing the order of the two sums , we find that @xmath135 as @xmath1 . this leads to the asymptotic expression for the standard deviation given in eq . ( [ sn - sol - asymp ] ) . s. n. dorogovtsev and j. f. f. mendes , _ evolution of networks : from biological nets to the internet and www _ ( oxford university press , oxford , 2003 ) ; r. pastor - satorras and a. vespignani , _ evolution and structure of the internet : a statistical physics approach _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 2004 ) . s. n. dorogovtsev and j. f. f. mendes , in _ handbook of graphs and networks : from the genome to the internet _ , eds . s. bornholdt and h.g . schuster ( wiley - vch , berlin , 2002 ) . p. sen , phys . e * 69 * , 046107 ( 2004 ) ; cond - mat/0409154 . j. kleinberg , r. kumar , p. raghavan , s. rajagopalan , and a. tomkins , in : _ proceedings of the international conference on combinatorics and computing _ , lecture notes in computer science , vol . 1627 , pp . 1 - 18 ( springer - verlag , berlin , 1999 ) . in writing eq . ( [ ln - mpq ] ) we ignore that for @xmath136 ( i ) the same node can be chosen twice as the target , and ( ii ) the same node can be chosen as the ancestor of target nodes . as long as @xmath137 our results are asymptotically exact .

we introduce a growing network model in which a new node attaches to a randomly - selected node , as well as to all ancestors of the target node . this mechanism produces a sparse , ultra - small network where the average node degree grows logarithmically with network size while the network diameter equals 2 . we determine basic geometrical network properties , such as the size dependence of the number of links and the in- and out - degree distributions . we also compare our predictions with real networks where the node degree also grows slowly with time the internet and the citation network of all physical review papers .

gr-qc0304047

the quantization of polarized gravitational cylindrical waves has received a lot of attention in recent years @xcite . this is partly due to the fact that this system provides a tractable , yet non - trivial , reduction of full general relativity and hence is an ideal framework to explore several issues involved in the quantization of gravity . some intriguing phenomena , related to the existence of large quantum gravity effects , have been discussed by studying precisely this model @xcite . it has also been argued that some manifestations of quantum gravity , such as the smearing of light cones are , indeed , present and can be understood in this simplified setting @xcite . one of the interesting points behind the obtained results is the realization of the fact that the physical hamiltonian is a function of the free field hamiltonian for a 2 + 1 dimensional , axially symmetric , massless scalar field evolving in an auxiliary minkowski background @xcite . as we show in the first section of the paper , this free hamiltonian naturally appears when one linearizes the system , thus suggesting that , in a precise sense , it can be considered as the free part of an interacting model . however the full interacting hamiltonian is obtained by adding a very specific type of terms to the free part , namely , just functions of it . here we plan to explore the consequences of this functional relation between the two physically relevant hamiltonians for the system and explore how this affects the causal structure of quantum spacetime . to this end we will pay attention to the smearing of the light cones due to quantum gravity effects within the framework of linearly polarized cylindrical waves . instead of considering the full information encoded in the metric tensor we will concentrate on the causal structure provided by light cones . an interesting , albeit somewhat indirect way , to look at this structure is to study the commutators of field operators at different spacetime points . these are the basic objects to discuss the commutativity of observables and the microcausality of the model ; conventionally , a physical model should be such that observables commute for space - like intervals . this has been discussed in the standard perturbative quantum field theory framework for simple examples such as scalar or fermion fields ( see e.g. @xcite ) . in fact , microcausality is one of the key conditions to prove such important results as the spin - statistics theorem @xcite . here we will use the commutator of the scalar field that describes linearly polarized cylindrical waves as a way to get information about the causal structure of quantum spacetime . as we show later it is possible to give exact expressions for this commutator both for the evolution provided by the free and the full physical hamiltonians . we will use these expressions to study in a quantitative way the smearing of the light cones as a function of the three - dimensional gravitational constant and explore some physical issues , in particular the appearance of singularities as a consequence of having a hamiltonian bounded from above @xcite . the rest of the paper is structured as follows . in sec . [ lingrav ] we discuss how the free hamiltonian is derived from the linearized cylindrical wave model . [ evolutions ] deals with the classical and quantum dynamics of cylindrical gravitational waves under the evolution provided both by the free hamiltonian and the physical hamiltonian . we will pause here to discuss and compare on a familiar example ( the harmonic oscillator ) the main features of the time evolution defined by functionally related hamiltonians , both from the classical and the quantum points of view . this will provide valuable insights for the problem considered in this work . [ microcausality ] is devoted to the study of microcausality . we will look at the main features of the field commutators and study the smearing of the light cones due to quantum gravitational effects . we end the paper with a discussion of the main results and perspectives for future work . linearly polarized cylindrical waves in general relativity can be described by the spacetime metric @xcite : @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the coordinate of the symmetry axis and @xmath2 is the three - metric @xmath3 from this three - dimensional point of view , @xmath4 and @xmath5 correspond to polar coordinates , @xmath6 is the radial component of the shift vector and @xmath7 is the lapse function . all metric functions ( @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath7 , and @xmath6 ) depend only on the time and radial coordinates , @xmath10 and @xmath11 . unless otherwise stated , we adopt a system of units such that @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the speed of light , @xmath14 is planck constant , and @xmath15 is the effective newton constant per unit length in the direction of the symmetry axis @xcite . in these units , the gravitational action of the system has the form @xcite @xmath16,\ ] ] where the dot denotes the derivative with respect to @xmath10 , the @xmath17 s are the momenta canonically conjugate to the metric variables and @xmath18 is the total hamiltonian @xmath19.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term is a boundary contribution at infinity [ @xmath20 and the second term is a linear combination of the hamiltonian constraint @xmath21 and the ( radial ) diffeomorphisms constraint @xmath22 : @xmath23 , \nonumber\\ c^r&=&e^{-\gamma}\left(-2p^{\prime}_{\gamma}+ p_{\gamma}\gamma^{\prime}+p_rr^{\:\prime}+p_{\psi}\psi^{\prime } \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the prime denotes the derivative with respect to @xmath11 . the gauge freedom associated with these constraints can be removed by imposing , respectively , the gauge fixing conditions @xcite @xmath24 on the other hand , the lagrangian form of the action can be obtained from the relations between momenta and time derivatives of the metric provided by the hamilton equations , @xmath25 from a three - dimensional perspective , the system describes an axially symmetric model consisting of a scalar field @xmath26 coupled to gravity @xcite , the line element being ( [ 3met ] ) . a particular classical solution is a vanishing scalar field in three - dimensional minkowski spacetime or , equivalently , minkowski spacetime in four dimensions . in this solution , @xmath27 and @xmath28 , whereas the rest of metric fields and momenta vanish ( i.e. @xmath29 ) . in this section , we will consider this solution as a background and discuss first - order perturbations around it . in other words , we will analyze the linearized theory of gravity around this minkowski spacetime , as it is usually done in the perturbative , quantum field theory approach to gravity . in order to expand the metric fields around the classical solution , let us call @xmath30 up to first - order terms in the fields , the expression of the three - metric becomes @xmath31 while the four - dimensional metric is given by @xmath32 here , it is understood that the product of @xmath26 with any other metric field vanishes in the perturbative order considered . on the other hand , regularity on the axis of symmetry imposes the following conditions : @xmath33 in order to discuss the linearized gravitational system , we must keep up to quadratic terms in the fields in the action ( [ act ] ) . a straightforward calculation leads to the result @xmath34,\nonumber\\ \bar{\cal h}&=&\int_0^\infty dr \left [ \frac{p_{\psi}^2}{2r}+\frac{r\,(\psi^{\prime})^2}{2}-p_{\gamma } p_{\bar{r}}+\bar{n}\bar{c}+n^r\bar{c}^r\right]\nonumber\\ & & + ( 2-\gamma_{\infty})\,\bar{r}^{\,\prime}(r\rightarrow\infty).\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath35 is the momentum canonically conjugate to @xmath36 , and the linearized constraints are : @xmath37 the diffeomorphisms gauge freedom can be fixed just like in the cylindrical reduction of general relativity , namely , by demanding that @xmath38 coincides with the radial coordinate @xcite . we thus impose the gauge fixing condition @xmath39 . it is easily checked that the poisson brackets @xmath40 of this condition with the linearized constraint do not vanish , so that the gauge fixing is admissible . dynamical consistency of the gauge fixing procedure requires , in addition , @xmath41 hence , the shift must be chosen as @xmath42 . finally , the momentum conjugate to @xmath36 is fixed by solving the diffeomorphisms constraint : @xmath43 . in this way , the canonical pair @xmath44 is removed from the set of degrees of freedom . the action of the resulting reduced model is @xmath45.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath46 is the hamiltonian constraint of the reduced linearized system , and @xmath47.\ ] ] remarkably , the condition employed to eliminate the hamiltonian gauge freedom in full cylindrical gravity @xcite can be used as well to fix the corresponding gauge in the linearized theory . the gauge fixing @xmath48 is acceptable , because the poisson brackets of @xmath49 and @xmath50 differ from zero . in addition , consistency of the chosen gauge demands the vanishing of @xmath51 therefore , @xmath52 has to be independent of the radial coordinate . actually , we can set @xmath53 by demanding that the total lapse equals the unity at spatial infinity . on the other hand , taking into account the regularity condition ( [ reg ] ) , the solution to the hamiltonian constraint is simply @xmath54 . this allows us to remove the canonical pair @xmath55 from the system and arrive at a constraint - free model in linearized gravity . the degrees of freedom of this system are the field @xmath26 and its momentum . the reduced action is @xmath56.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath57 , given in eq . ( [ ham0 ] ) , is the hamiltonian of a massless scalar field with axial symmetry in three - dimensions . furthermore , in the gauge that we have selected , the three - dimensional metric of the linearized gravitational theory is exactly that of minkowski spacetime and contains no physical degrees of freedom . the scalar field @xmath26 determines the norm of the killing vector @xmath58 , and appears in the four - dimensional metric of the gauge - fixed , linearized model in the form ( [ metlin ] ) , but with @xmath59 substituted by the flat metric @xmath60 where we have renamed @xmath61 the time coordinate of the reduced system . summarizing , the perturbative description provided in linearized gravity for cylindrical waves with linear polarization around four - dimensional minkowski spacetime is equivalent to a massless scalar field with axial symmetry in a three - dimensional flat background . the dynamics of this field is dictated by the free hamiltonian @xmath57 , which generates the evolution in the minkowskian time @xmath61 . it is worth noticing that the action and metric of the gauge - fixed model in linearized gravity reproduce in fact the results that one would obtain from the gauge - fixed model in full cylindrical gravity by working just in the first perturbative order , i.e. , by keeping in the action and metric , respectively , up to quadratic and linear terms in the field @xmath26 and its momentum . in this sense , the gauge fixing and linearization procedures commute . one of the significant features of gravitational cylindrical waves is the existence of two distinct , physically relevant hamiltonians ( or equivalently two distinct time coordinates ) to define both the classical and quantum evolution . one is the hamiltonian @xmath57 [ given in eq . ( [ ham0 ] ) ] that generates the dynamics in the linearized gravitational theory ; the other is the hamiltonian @xmath62 that provides the energy per unit length along the symmetry axis in general relativity @xcite . in fact , they are functionally dependent , since @xmath63 . in order to gain insight into the relation that can be established between the dynamics associated with these two different hamiltonians , we open this section by discussing a similar situation in a very simple example provided by the harmonic oscillator . the usual description of the harmonic oscillator in a phase space coordinatized by @xmath64 comes from its standard hamiltonian @xmath65 . the dynamics is given by the hamilton equations @xmath66 the general solution can be written as @xmath67 where @xmath68 and its complex conjugate @xmath69 are fixed by the initial conditions . consider next a phase space @xmath70 with hamiltonian @xmath71 , i.e. a function of the standard hamiltonian for the harmonic oscillator . for instance , the case @xmath72 arises in the context of quantum optics , in relation with the propagation of light in non - linear kerr media @xcite . the equations of motion now read @xmath73 where @xmath74 denotes the derivative of @xmath75 with respect to its argument . these new equations can be easily solved by means of a change of time . specifically , making use of the time independence of the hamiltonian @xmath76 ( @xmath77 on solutions to the equations of motion ) , we can introduce the new time parameter @xmath78 . then , the functions @xmath79 $ ] , @xmath80 $ ] and the new time @xmath61 serve us to transform the hamilton equations into the standard ones corresponding to the harmonic oscillator . so , the classical solutions are @xmath81\!=\!\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\omega}}\!\left[ae^{\ ! -i\omega f'(\omega a^\dagger\!a)t}\!+\!a^\dagger e^{i\omega f'(\omega a^\dagger\!a)t}\right]\!,\\ p(t)\!=\!p_0[t(t)]\!=\!\frac{-i\omega}{\sqrt{2\omega}}\ ! \left[ae^{\!-i\omega f'(\omega a^\dagger\!a)t}\!-a^\dagger e^{i\omega f'(\omega a^\dagger\!a)t}\right]\!.\end{aligned}\ ] ] what we find is an energy dependent redefinition of time that induces a different time change for each solution to the equations of motion . the situation in the quantum theory is quite different . the reason lies on the fact than in quantum mechanics a physical state does not need to have a definite energy . then , a `` change of time '' of the form @xmath82 has non - trivial consequences for the dynamics . the usual quantum theory for the harmonic oscillator can be described by introducing a fock space with creation and annihilation operators @xmath69 , @xmath68 . every initial state can be expressed as @xmath83 , where @xmath84 are fourier coefficients ( with the convenient normalization ) and @xmath85 are energy eigenvectors ( that is , @xmath86 ) . in the schrdinger picture , evolving with @xmath87 , we find @xmath88 however , if the same state @xmath89 evolves in time according to the evolution generated by @xmath90 , we get and @xmath90 act on the same hilbert space . moreover , if we demand the function @xmath75 to have a unique absolute minimum at @xmath91 , the two hamiltonians have also the same vacuum . ] @xmath92 hence we do not recover an analogous situation to that found in the classical system by replacing ( formally ) the time @xmath61 in @xmath93 with @xmath82 , because @xmath94 except for linear homogeneous functions @xmath75 . moreover , the properties of the states @xmath93 and @xmath95 are quite different . for example , if we consider the bounded hamiltonian @xmath96 it is obvious that the high energy contributions to @xmath95 are essentially frozen in time with respect to the evolution of the low energy ones , in the sense that the phase of the former type of contributions remains practically coherent in time . let us turn now to the discussion of our gravitational system . we will deal with the einstein - rosen family of linearly polarized gravitational waves @xcite . these waves display the so - called whole cylindrical symmetry @xcite , namely , they correspond to topologically trivial spacetimes which possess two linearly independent , commuting , spacelike , and hypersurface orthogonal killing vector fields . it is well known @xcite that these spacetimes admit coordinates @xmath97 such that the metric is given by @xmath98 where @xmath26 and @xmath8 are functions of only @xmath11 and @xmath61 . when the einstein equations are imposed , @xmath26 encodes the physical degrees of freedom and satisfies the usual wave equation for an axially symmetric massless scalar field in three - dimensions : @xmath99 the metric function @xmath8 can be expressed in terms of this field on the classical solutions @xcite . one gets @xmath100,\nonumber\\ \label{gaminf } \gamma_\infty&=&\frac{1}{2}\int^\infty_0 dr\ , r\ , \left [ ( \partial_t\psi)^2+(\partial_r\psi)^2\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath101 and @xmath102 are the energy of the scalar field in a ball of radius @xmath11 and in the whole of the two - dimensional flat space , respectively . furthermore , @xmath103 coincides with the hamiltonian @xmath57 given in eq . ( [ ham0 ] ) @xcite . nevertheless , to reach a unit asymptotic timelike killing vector field in the actual four - dimensional spacetime , with respect to which one can truly introduce a physical notion of energy ( per unit length ) @xcite , one must make use of a different system of coordinates , namely @xmath104 where @xmath105 . in these new coordinates the metric has the form @xmath106 assuming as a boundary condition that the metric function @xmath26 falls off sufficiently fast as @xmath107 , the above metric describes asymptotically flat spacetimes with a , generally non - zero , deficit angle . in this asymptotic region @xmath108 is a unit timelike vector . the einstein field equations can be obtained from a hamiltonian action principle @xcite where the on - shell hamiltonian is given in terms of that for the free scalar field by @xmath109 owing to these reasons , in the following we will refer to @xmath10 as the physical time and to @xmath62 as the physical hamiltonian . when we use the @xmath61-time and impose regularity at the origin @xmath110 @xcite , the classical solutions for the field @xmath26 can be expanded in the form @xmath111.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath112 and @xmath113 are fixed by the initial conditions and are complex conjugate to each other , because @xmath26 and @xmath114 ( the zeroth - order bessel function of the first kind ) are real . from eq . ( [ gaminf ] ) , we then obtain @xmath115 using this formula , we can express the field in the @xmath10-frame as @xmath116.\;\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that @xmath117 . in principle , the quantization of the field @xmath26 can be carried out in a standard way . we can introduce a fock space in which @xmath118 , the quantum counterpart of @xmath119 , is an operator - valued distribution @xcite . its action is determined by those of @xmath120 and @xmath121 , the usual annihilation and creation operators , whose only non - vanishing commutators are @xmath122=\delta(k_1,k_2).\ ] ] explicitly , @xmath123\!. \label{psi0}\ ] ] in the schrdinger picture , operators do not evolve , and the problem of the time evolution is transferred to the physical states . we will return later to this issue . in the heisenberg picture , on the contrary , operators change in time and states remain fixed . in this case , the value of the quantum field @xmath124 at any time can be obtained from its value at @xmath125 , evolving in one of the two times that we have at hand . one is the physical time @xmath10 , with associated hamiltonian @xmath62 given in eq . ( [ newham ] ) . the other is the time @xmath61 of the auxiliary three - dimensional minkowski spacetime , its hamiltonian being that of a massless scalar field , @xmath57 . from our discussion in sec . ii , this time can be identified with the perturbative time ( denoted also by @xmath61 ) that arises in the study of the einstein - rosen waves in linearized gravity . in the perturbative time @xmath61 , the evolution is provided by the unitary operator @xmath126 where @xmath127 is the quantum hamiltonian of an axially symmetric scalar field in three dimensions . then @xmath128\!. \hspace*{.3cm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the quantization procedure in this case is very simple : we have substituted the initial conditions @xmath112 and @xmath113 in the classical solution by the corresponding quantum operators . the situation changes when we choose the physical time @xmath10 as the time parameter . the quantum hamiltonian can be defined as @xmath129 . we can then reach a unitary evolution by means of @xmath130 . this leads to the following time evolved operators @xmath131\!\hat{a}(k),\nonumber\\ \label{crean } \hat{a}_e^\dagger(k , t)\!\!&=&\!\hat{a}^\dagger(k)\,\exp\!\left[ite(k ) e^{-\hat{h}_0/2}\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath132 . it is important to realize that the quantum evolution in the physical @xmath10-frame is not obtained by changing @xmath112 , @xmath113 , and @xmath103 by their direct quantum counterparts . in fact , by restoring the value of the dimensionful constants @xmath14 and @xmath15 , we can write @xmath133 with @xmath134 , so that @xmath135 and we can expand @xmath136 and @xmath137 in powers of @xmath14 , @xmath138 ( here , we have expressed @xmath139 with dimensions of an inverse length ) setting again @xmath140 , the expansion above clearly shows that the quantum evolution of the creation and annihilation variables in the physical time differs from the classical evolution " in higher - order quantum corrections . this unusual behavior can be partially corrected in the sense that one can actually find an operator for @xmath62 such that the quantum evolution in the @xmath10-time is similar to the classical one . in fact , if one considers the normal ordered hamiltonian @xmath141 and its associated unitary evolution operator @xmath142 , it is easy to prove that @xmath143 therefore , the quantum evolution in @xmath10 given by @xmath144 parallels that encountered in the classical picture . unfortunately , there is a severe problem with this quantum dynamics that renders it physically unacceptable : the hamiltonian @xmath144 is unbounded both from above and below @xcite . obviously , the different possibilities for the unitary time evolution of the field @xmath124 considered here are closely related . specifically , there exists a unitary mapping between both types of evolution . this is a consequence of the fact that they are both unitary and coincide with the identity in the same hilbert space at @xmath125 . so , if we denote the operators evolved from @xmath145 in the times @xmath61 and @xmath10 by @xmath146 and @xmath147 , respectively , we obtain @xmath148 then , we can go from one evolution to the other by means of the unitary operator @xmath149 . let us close this section with a few comments about the fock space on which the field @xmath124 acts . in the heisenberg picture the states do not depend on time . they are constructed by successive actions of the time independent creation operators on the vacuum of the theory . it is important to point out that both @xmath139 and @xmath150 act on the same hilbert space and have the same vacuum , that will be referred to as @xmath151 . explicitly , given any square integrable complex function @xmath152 ( with the convenient normalization ) we can write a @xmath153-particle state in the form @xmath154 according to the usual interpretation of quantum mechanics , the measurable physical quantities correspond to expectation values of observables . we can go over to the schrdinger picture by assigning the time evolution to the quantum states @xmath155 defining @xmath156 , @xmath157 , and noticing that the @xmath158-operators satisfy @xmath159 it is straightforward to see that the evolved states are solutions to the schrdinger equations @xmath160 as in the heisenberg picture , the unitary operator @xmath161 provides the bridge between the two kinds of quantum evolution , @xmath162 particularizing the above results to the case of @xmath153-particle states we readily get that , for the @xmath61-time , @xmath163 where @xmath164 . notice that @xmath165 is a superposition of eigenvectors of @xmath139 with eigenvalues equal to @xmath166 . on the other hand , if we evolve the states with @xmath167 , it is not difficult to check that @xmath168 in other words , @xmath169 is a superposition of eigenvectors of @xmath150 , each of them with energy @xmath170 . finally , it is worth pointing out that the @xmath150-energy is not additive : @xmath171 this property is directly related to the existence of an upper bound for the physical hamiltonian . microcausality plays a crucial role in perturbative quantum field theory ; in fact it is a crucial ingredient in such important issues as the spin - statistics theorem @xcite . the point of view that we will develop in this section is the idea that field commutators of the scalar field that encodes the physical information in linearly polarized cylindrical waves can be used as an alternative to the metric operator to extract physical information about quantum spacetime . some relevant information may be lost , but the availability of explicit exact expressions for commutators [ even under the evolution given by the hamiltonian ( [ newham ] ) ] opens up the possibility of getting precise information about the quantum causal structure of spacetime . in particular we will see how the light cones get smeared by quantum corrections in a precise and quantitative way . as is well known , the study of causality in perturbative quantum field theory requires the consideration of measurements of observables at different spacetime points and their mutual influence . the key question is whether measurements taken at spatial separations commute or not . the relevant commutators can be seen to be proportional to those of the quantum fields at two different spacetime points @xmath172 and @xmath173 . for a free massless scalar field described by the standard lagrangian , this commutator is a ( c - number ) function of @xmath172 and @xmath173 that is exactly zero when @xmath174 is space - like @xcite . this means that observables at points separated by spatial intervals commute . something similar happens for fermions described by the usual lagrangians if , instead of commutators , one takes anticommutators of the fields ( observables for fermion fields can be written as even powers of them and the relevant commutators can be written in terms of anticommutators of the basic fields ) @xcite . in the case that we are considering in this work the only physical local degree of freedom that we have is given by the scalar field @xmath26 . what we will do in the following is discussing microcausality by considering the different time evolutions introduced in the first part of the paper . we start by computing @xmath175 $ ] for the field operators ( [ hpsit ] ) obtained in the heisenberg picture by evolving the field at time @xmath176 with the hamiltonian @xmath139 given in eq . ( [ qham0 ] ) . it is straightforward to get ( see @xcite for a somewhat related computation ) @xmath177=\hspace{4.cm}\nonumber\\ \label{s2 - 004 } i\int_0^\infty\!\!\!dk j_0(r_1k)j_0(r_2k ) \sin[(t_2-t_1 ) k ] .\hspace*{.3cm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] let us discuss the main features of this commutation function , that we will refer to in the following as the @xmath57-commutator . to begin with we can easily see that , as it happens for the familiar free field theories , the commutator ( [ s2 - 004 ] ) is a c - number , i.e. it is proportional to the identity in the fock space . in addition , for @xmath178 fixed , let us call regions i , ii , and iii the regions of the @xmath179 plane defined , respectively , by @xmath180 , @xmath181 , and @xmath182 . then , it can be shown that the @xmath57-commutator vanishes in region i , whereas in region ii it can be written as @xcite @xmath177=\hspace*{4.4 cm } & & \nonumber \\ \label{propii } \frac{i}{\pi}\frac{1}{\sqrt { r_1 r_2}}\,k\left(\sqrt{\frac{(t_2\!-\!t_1)^2\!-\!(r_2\!-\!r_1)^2 } { 4r_1r_2}}\right).\hspace*{1.cm}&&\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , its value in region iii is @xcite @xmath183}}&&\hspace*{-.4 cm } k\!\!\left(\!\!\sqrt{\!\frac{4r_1r_2}{(t_2\!-\!\!t_1)^2\!\!- \!(r_2\!-\!\!r_1)^2}}\right)\!.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath184 denotes the complete elliptic integral of the first kind , @xmath185 ( alternatively , the integral in eq . ( [ s2 - 004 ] ) can be written in terms of the associated legendre functions @xmath186 and @xmath187 @xcite ) . plane for the @xmath57-commutator . region i corresponds to @xmath188 , region ii to @xmath181 , and region iii to @xmath189 . the singularity of the @xmath57-commutation function lies in the boundary between regions ii and iii , whereas the singularity for the @xmath190-commutator appears for @xmath191.,width=321 ] several plots of the absolute value of this function ( in fact , of its imaginary part ) for fixed values of @xmath178 and @xmath192 are shown in fig . [ fig : freeprop2 ] , and a three - dimensional plot for a fixed value of @xmath178 can be found in fig . [ fig : freeprop ] . of the commutator of the scalar field @xmath175 $ ] for @xmath193 and several values of @xmath192 as a function of @xmath194.,width=321 ] of the commutator of the scalar field @xmath175 $ ] for @xmath193 as a function of @xmath194 and @xmath192 . the light cone structure and the singularity at @xmath195 can be readily seen . the plot for negative values of @xmath194 is obtained by reflecting with respect to the @xmath192 axis.,width=321 ] some interesting properties can be read off from the previous expressions . first of all we see that the commutator is in fact identically zero in the region labeled i ; outside it differs from zero . second we see that it is singular in the line @xmath195 . it is easy to check that the singularity is logarithmic by using the explicit form of the propagator ( [ propii ] ) and expanding around @xmath195 . this singularity can be understood as a consequence of the presence of the symmetry axis ; this is supported by the fact that the @xmath57-commutation function satisfies @xmath196=0\,,\nonumber\\ & & \left(\!\partial_t^2-\frac{1}{r}\partial_r(r\partial_r)\!\right)\!\cdot \theta(t - t_2)[\hat{\psi}(r , t),\hat{\psi}(r_2,t_2)]=\nonumber\\ & & \hspace{3.cm}\frac{i}{r_2}\delta^{(2)}\!(r - r_2,t - t_2)\,,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] which shows that the full commutator is an axially symmetric solution to the 2 + 1 dimensional wave equation and the future part of it ( obtained by multiplying by a step function ) is an axially symmetric green function for the same equation . it is important to point out that even though there is a minkowskian background metric , the presence of a center of symmetry breaks lorentz invariance ; in fact , the only symmetries of the 2 + 1 axially symmetric wave equation @xmath197 that transform solutions @xmath198 into solutions are \i ) translations @xmath199 \ii ) dilatations @xmath200 \iii ) inversions @xmath201 } { \sqrt{1\!-\!2t\epsilon\!+\!(t^2\!-\!r^2)\epsilon^2}}\!\quad(\epsilon\textrm { small enough})\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath202 these can be obtained systematically by using the general theory of symmetry groups for partial differential equations ( see @xcite ) . let us consider now the commutator of the field operators obtained in the heisenberg picture with the quantum hamiltonian @xmath203 . here @xmath204 , and we have restored the values of the planck constant and the three - dimensional gravitational constant ( but kept @xmath205 ) to have the possibility of discussing the semiclassical limit . recall that the hamiltonian @xmath139 is given by eq . ( [ qham0 ] ) , where we choose the normalization of the creation and annihilation operators so that the commutation relation ( [ comma ] ) is satisfied ( with no @xmath14 in the r.h.s . ) . notice that , with this convention , @xmath120 , @xmath139 , and @xmath150 have formally the same dimensions as @xmath206 ( or @xmath207 ) , @xmath208 , and @xmath209 ( or @xmath210 ) , respectively . to distinguish the field operators evolved with the new hamiltonian @xmath150 , we will denote them by @xmath211 . in order to compute the commutator @xmath212 $ ] , we make use of the expressions ( [ crean ] ) for the creation and annihilation operators evolved in @xmath10 , which can also be written as @xmath213 , \nonumber\\ \label{crean2 } \hat{a}^\dagger_e(k , t)\!&=&\!\hat{a}^\dagger(k)\exp\left[it \left(e(\hat{h}_0+k)-e(\hat{h}_0)\right)\right].\hspace*{.9cm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting then the relation @xmath214,\end{aligned}\ ] ] we get the relevant field commutator @xmath215\!\!=\!\!\ ! \int_0^\infty\!\!\!\!\!\!\!dk_1\!\!\int_0^\infty\!\!\!\ ! \!\!\!dk_2j_0(r_1k_1)j_0(r_2k_2)\\ \times 4\bar{g } \bigg\{\!\big[\hat{a}_e(k_1,\!t_1),\hat{a}_e(k_2,\!t_2)\big]\!+\ ! \big[\hat{a}^\dagger_e(k_1,\!t_1),\hat{a}^\dagger_e(k_2,\!t_2)\big ] \\ + \big[\hat{a}_e(k_1,\!t_1),\hat{a}^\dagger_e(k_2,\!t_2)\big]\!+\ ! \big[\hat{a}^\dagger_e(k_1,\!t_1),\hat{a}_e(k_2,\!t_2)\big ] \bigg\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the commutators involving @xmath136 and @xmath216 can be found in appendix [ a1 ] . note that , in contrast with the evolution given by @xmath57 , for which the commutation function is a c - number , the situation now is more complicated because @xmath217 $ ] is an operator , as it happens in interacting theories . we will analyze two types of matrix elements for it , namely , the expectation value on the vacuum and on one - particle states . in addition , we will briefly comment on the expectation value on coherent states . @xmath218 vacuum expectation value . @xmath219\,|0\rangle=\hspace*{3.3 cm } & & \nonumber\\ i8\bar{g}\!\!\int_0^{\infty}\!\!\!\!\!\!dk\,j_0(r_1 k)j_0(r_2 k)\sin\left[\frac{t_2-t_1}{4\bar{g}}(1\!-\!e^{-4\bar{g}k})\right]\!. \hspace*{.4cm}&&\label{s2 - 005}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the following we will discuss the differences and similarities of this matrix element and the @xmath57-commutation function . ) of the @xmath57-commutator and the vacuum expectation value of the @xmath190-commutator for two different values of @xmath220 , plotted for @xmath193.,width=321 ] we point out that the factor @xmath221 $ ] that appears in the integrand of the @xmath57-commutator is substituted now by @xmath222 $ ] . they coincide for @xmath223 , but the former of these functions oscillates for all values of @xmath208 whereas the latter approaches a constant value when @xmath224 . this changes the convergence properties of the integral . in particular it is straightforward to see that the integral ( [ s2 - 005 ] ) diverges whenever @xmath191 ( except if @xmath225=0 $ ] ) but converges otherwise . therefore , the vacuum expectation value has a singularity structure that differs from the one given by eq . ( [ s2 - 004 ] ) . this has some interesting physical consequences . first we see that the singularity that originates in the axis in the @xmath57 case is not present when the evolution is dictated by @xmath190 ; this can be interpreted as a blurring of the axis due to quantum corrections . second we see that a completely different kind of singularity pops up when the evolution is generated by @xmath190 . from a mathematical point of view its origin is clearly related to the fact that the energy is bounded from above and , hence , for large values of @xmath208 the integrand is just a product of two @xmath114 bessel functions ( which give a divergent integral if their arguments coincide ) . physically , the emergence of the singularity can be understood in an intuitive manner by writing a state as a superposition of vectors of the form @xmath226 , @xmath227 and projecting onto @xmath228 . the @xmath229 factor ( for @xmath230 or 2 ) goes to a phase that depends only on @xmath231 as @xmath224 . so , if @xmath191 , the coefficients of the linear superposition defining , respectively , @xmath232 and @xmath233 differ only by a constant phase for large values of @xmath208 . this means that , in the sector of large @xmath208 , these two states have coherent phases and therefore a constructive interference . since each of them has an infinite norm , their scalar product diverges . a similar effect can be found in the quantum dynamics of a free particle with an energy given by a function @xmath234 with @xmath235 as @xmath224 . if one builds a wave packet as @xmath236},\ ] ] with @xmath237 peaked around a large value of @xmath208 , @xmath238 , the group velocity becomes almost zero and @xmath239 stays essentially the same at every @xmath172 for long periods of time . the integral in eq . ( [ s2 - 005 ] ) can be written explicitly as a convergent series ( when @xmath240 ) by expanding the sine function as a power series of @xmath241 and computing the resulting integrals involving two bessel functions and an exponential @xcite @xmath219\,|0\rangle= \hspace*{3.3cm}&&\nonumber \label{s2 - 006}\\ \frac{i8\bar{g}}{\pi\sqrt{r_1r_2}}\left\{\!\sin(\delta t)\!\!\sum_{n=0}^{\infty } \!\frac{\!(-1)^n(\delta t)^{2n}\!\ ! } { ( 2n)!}q_{-1/2}\left[\sigma_{2n}(r_1,r_2)\right]\right . & & \nonumber\\ -\left.\!\cos(\delta t)\!\sum_{n=0}^{\infty } \!\frac{\!(-1)^n(\delta t)^{2n+1}\!\!\ ! } { ( 2n+1)!}q_{-1/2}\!\left[\sigma_{2n+1}(r_1,r_2)\right]\!\right\}\!. \hspace*{.3cm}&&\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we have introduced the notation @xmath242 besides , @xmath243 [ with @xmath244 is the associated legendre function of the second kind @xcite . we recall that the function @xmath245 grows without bound as the argument approaches @xmath246 and falls off to zero as @xmath247 when @xmath248 . when @xmath191 the singularity in eq . ( [ s2 - 006 ] ) comes just from the @xmath249 term in the first series of the expansion , that is given by @xmath250 a series of plots of @xmath251 $ ] and @xmath252 \,|0\rangle$ ] ( both over @xmath253 ) is shown in fig . [ fig4:compare ] for fixed values of @xmath178 and @xmath254 as a function of @xmath192 , with several choices for @xmath220 . we choose @xmath254 small enough to guarantee the rapid convergence of the series in eq . ( [ s2 - 006 ] ) and leave a discussion of the behavior of the integral ( [ s2 - 005 ] ) when @xmath255 for future work . as we can see @xmath256\,|0\rangle$ ] seems to approach @xmath251 $ ] at least in a certain average sense when @xmath220 is sufficiently small ( though not vanishing ) . it falls off to zero quite quickly outside the light cone defined by the free commutator and the auxiliary minkowski metric , and displays an oscillatory behavior within this light cone . the characteristic length of this oscillation decreases with @xmath220 , as well as close to the @xmath191 singularity . the approximation obtained by truncating the series expansion ( [ s2 - 006 ] ) , keeping a sufficiently large number of terms , compares well with the results of numerically computing expression ( [ s2 - 005 ] ) , at least for low enough values of @xmath254 . @xmath218 expectation value on one - particle states . we consider now states of the form @xmath257 where the function @xmath258 satisfies @xmath259 . we then have @xmath260 } \cos{\left[\omega_f(k_1,k_2)\right ] } \nonumber\\ & & -j_0(r_2k_1)|f(k_2)|^2\sin{\left[(t_2-t_1)e(k_1 ) e^{-4\bar{g}k_2 } \right]}\bigg\},\hspace*{.9 cm } \label{s2 - 007}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath261 a complete discussion of the meaning of the previous expression is beyond the scope of this paper . nevertheless , some features already present in the vacuum expectation value are also present here ; in particular the @xmath191 singularity . this can be seen by considering the last term in eq . ( [ s2 - 007 ] ) : the integral in @xmath262 is @xmath263},\ ] ] which takes in general a non - vanishing constant value ( depending on @xmath254 and @xmath220 ) as @xmath264 , thus rendering the remaining integral in @xmath265 divergent . as the first term in eq . ( [ s2 - 007 ] ) leads to a convergent integral , we conclude that the expectation value is singular when @xmath191 . it is not difficult to obtain as well an explicit expression for the expectation value of the @xmath190-commutator on the coherent states of the field @xmath26 . these diagonal matrix elements are calculated in appendix b. for our discussion in this work , let us only comment that the result is actually divergent when @xmath191 . this supplies further support to the claim that the considered singularity is indeed a generic feature of the system . linearly polarized cylindrical waves can be studied in great detail both from the classical and quantum points of view . as we have seen , there are two relevant hamiltonians for the study of the system . we have shown that the action and the metric of the gauge - fixed model in linearized gravity reproduce the results obtained by considering full cylindrical gravity and working to the first perturbative order . we get in this way a free hamiltonian . the hamiltonian governing the dynamics of the full system , on the other hand , is different from the free one , but turns out to be a function of it and presents certain features with deep physical consequences , like e.g. the existence of an upper bound . we have studied the similarities and differences of these two admissible kinds of evolution ; in particular , we have discussed how the emergence of an upper bound for the energy affects the causal structure of the model and the spreading of the light cones . the field commutator for the free hamiltonian is a c - number and shows the typical light cone structure found in standard perturbative quantum field theories . the commutator for the physical hamiltonian , as it usually happens for interacting theories , is no longer a c - number , so one has to consider its matrix elements . by concentrating on the vacuum expectation value we have been able to see several interesting phenomena : a spreading of the light cone as a function of the gravitational constant , the disappearance of the singularity present in the free case due to the smearing of the symmetry axis and the appearance of a new type of singularity associated with the fact that the energy is bounded from above . this new singularity is also present in the other expectation values discussed in the paper , namely for one - particle states and coherent states , and appears to be a generic feature of the model . there are several open questions that we plan to address in future work . in particular , it would be desirable to reach a better understanding of the behavior of the field commutator in the limit in which the length scale provided by @xmath220 goes to zero . the expectation values of the @xmath190-commutator discussed here resemble those derived from the free hamiltonian @xmath57 at least in a certain average sense . however it is not obvious how precisely and up to what extent they actually relate to each other . this is partly so because of the different singularity structure found in both cases . further research on this subject will concentrate on the properties of the model in the semiclassical limit @xmath266 . we will also pay detailed attention to matrix elements of the field commutator other than the vacuum expectation value , with the aim at discussing how the smearing of the light cones depends on the energy . in this appendix , we compute the commutators of the creation and annihilation operators @xmath136 and @xmath216 , obtained from the corresponding operators @xmath120 and @xmath267 via the unitary evolution generated by @xmath268 , where @xmath269 . employing relations ( [ crean2 ] ) and the basic commutators ( [ comma ] ) , it is possible to show that @xmath270&= & \hat{a}(k_1)\hat{a}(k_2 ) \exp\left[it_1e(\hat{h}_0-k_1-k_2)+i(t_2-t_1)e(\hat{h}_0-k_2 ) -it_2e(\hat{h}_0)\right ] \\&-&\hat{a}(k_1)\hat{a}(k_2)\exp\left[it_2e(\hat{h}_0-k_1-k_2 ) + i(t_1-t_2)e(\hat{h}_0-k_1)-it_1e(\hat{h}_0)\right]\ , , \\ \bullet \ , \big[\hat{a}^\dagger_e(k_1,t_1),\hat{a}^\dagger_e(k_2,t_2)\big]&= & \hat{a}^\dagger(k_1)\hat{a}^\dagger(k_2 ) \exp\left[it_1e(\hat{h}_0+k_1+k_2)+i(t_2-t_1)e(\hat{h}_0+k_2 ) -it_2e(\hat{h}_0)\right ] \\ & -&\hat{a}^\dagger(k_1)\hat{a}^\dagger(k_2 ) \exp\left[it_2e(\hat{h}_0+k_1+k_2)+i(t_1-t_2)e(\hat{h}_0+k_1 ) -it_1e(\hat{h}_0)\right]\ , , \\ \bullet \ , \big[\hat{a}_e(k_1,t_1),\hat{a}^\dagger_e(k_2,t_2)\big]&= & \hat{a}(k_1)\hat{a}^\dagger(k_2 ) \exp\left[it_1e(\hat{h}_0+k_2-k_1)+i(t_2-t_1)e(\hat{h}_0+k_2 ) -it_2e(\hat{h}_0)\right ] \\&-&\hat{a}^\dagger(k_2)\hat{a}(k_1)\exp\left[it_2 e(\hat{h}_0+k_2-k_1 ) + i(t_1-t_2)e(\hat{h}_0-k_1)-it_1e(\hat{h}_0)\right]\ , , \\ \bullet \ , \big[\hat{a}^\dagger_e(k_1,t_1),a_e(k_2,t_2)\big]&= & \hat{a}^\dagger(k_1)\hat{a}(k_2 ) \exp\left[it_1e(\hat{h}_0+k_1-k_2)+i(t_2-t_1)e(\hat{h}_0-k_2 ) -it_2e(\hat{h}_0)\right]\\&-&\hat{a}(k_2)\hat{a}^\dagger(k_1 ) \exp\left[it_2e(\hat{h}_0+k_1-k_2 ) + i(t_1-t_2)e(\hat{h}_0+k_1)-it_1e(\hat{h}_0)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] we consider coherent states of the field @xmath26 , given by @xmath271 where @xmath237 is a square integrable function and @xmath272 is a normalization constant satisfying @xmath273 the expectation value of the @xmath190-commutator is @xmath274 \int_0^\infty\!\frac{dk_1}{2}\!\!\int_0^\infty \!\!\!\!\!\!dk_2 j_0(r_1k_1)j_0(r_2k_2)\sum_{s=0}^\infty\frac{i_s(c ) } { s!}g_s(k_1,k_2),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath275^s \!\!-\![b(k_2,-k_1)]^s\!\bigg\}\\+ \overline{c}(k_2)c(k_1)\bigg\{[b(k_1,-k_2)]^s\!- \![b(-k_2,k_1)]^s\bigg\}e^{-4\bar{g}s k_1}\hspace*{.2cm}\\ + \overline{c}(k_1)c(k_2)\bigg\{[b(-k_1,k_2)]^s\ ! -\![b(k_2,-k_1)]^s\bigg\}e^{-4\bar{g}s k_2}\hspace*{.2 cm } \\ + c(k_1)c(k_2 ) \bigg\{[b(k_1,k_2)]^s\!-\![b(k_2,k_1)]^s\bigg\}e^{-4\bar{g}s ( k_1+k_2 ) } \\ + \overline{c}(k_1)\overline{c}(k_2 ) \bigg\{[b(-k_1,-k_2)]^s\!-\![b(-k_2,-k_1)]^s\bigg\ } , \hspace*{.7cm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and we have employed the notation @xmath276.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that , when @xmath191 , the delta in the expression of @xmath277 leads to the divergent integral @xmath278^{\!2s+1}\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the authors wish to thank a. ashtekar , g. date , and l. garay for interesting discussions . they are especially grateful to m. varadarajan for suggesting the subject and sharing enlightening conversations and insight . is supported by a spanish ministry of education and culture fellowship co - financed by the european social fund . this work was supported by the spanish mcyt under the research projects bfm2001 - 0213 and bfm2002 - 04031-c02 - 02 .

we study several issues related to the different choices of time available for the classical and quantum treatment of linearly polarized cylindrical gravitational waves . we pay especial attention to the time evolution of creation and annihilation operators and the definition of fock spaces for the different choices of time involved . we discuss also the issue of microcausality and the use of field commutators to extract information about the causal properties of quantum spacetime .

cond-mat0404581

the tunability in size , shape , and electron number of semiconductor quantum dots ( qd ) provides numerous technological applications as well as interesting many - electron physics . @xcite in actual qd devices , the effects induced by impurities or donor scattering centers may be remarkable . in most cases , irregularities in samples have only an indirect influence on the many - body structure , complicating the identification of the origin behind the peculiar behavior in the measured characteristics of qd s . a clean quantum dot typically shows single - electron energy levels reminiscent of the well - known fock - darwin ( fd ) energy spectrum corresponding to a parabolic confining potential . @xcite adding external impurities into the qd breaks the circular symmetry of the system , leading to avoided crossings and liftings of the degeneracies in the single - electron energy spectrum . this was demonstrated by halonen _ et al . _ , @xcite who studied theoretically qd s distorted by repulsive gaussian scattering centers . however , even if clear traces of the fd spectrum have been obtained experimentally in both lateral @xcite and vertical @xcite quantum dots , there is , to the best of our knowledge , no direct experimental evidence of repulsive impurities present in qd structures . instead , states bound to hydrogenic impurities , probably arising from si dopant atoms in the gaas quantum well , were found already by ashoori and co - workers @xcite in their pioneering single - electron tunneling experiment . these impurities have been suggested to be sources of pair - tunneling states , theoretically analyzed with a superimposed attractive @xmath0-type potential . @xcite theoretically , the distortion of the circular symmetry makes the many - electron problem particularly complex to solve , especially in the presence of an external magnetic field . in the above - mentioned study , halonen _ et al . _ @xcite applied exact diagonalization up to three electrons and focused on the effects of impurities on the energy levels and optical absorption spectra . recently , gl and co - workers @xcite performed diffusion quantum monte carlo ( dmc ) calculations on qd s distorted by randomly distributed gaussian scatterers and studied the energetics up to ten electrons . they found that in these systems the transitions between the many - body states are considerably less pronounced than in clean dots . hirose and wingreen @xcite have used the spin - density - functional theory ( sdft ) to examine the energies and spin states in disordered qd s as a function of the interaction strength in zero magnetic field . besides additional scatterers , non - circular qd s have attracted general interest in connection with the chaotic properties @xcite or the behavior in the high magnetic field limit . @xcite in this paper we present a measured single - electron transport spectrum where avoided crossings and lifted degeneracies are clearly observable . we reproduce the spectrum with an appropriate model potential , showing that the unexpected effects in the spectrum result from a negatively charged coulombic impurity located near the qd . the many - electron properties studied by the sdft reflect the strongly distorted single - electron spectrum . the variation of the impurity location shows the stability of the maximum - density droplet ( mdd ) and the screening of the impurity by electrons . the outline of this paper is as follows . in sec . [ sec1 ] we briefly describe the fabrication of the sample and report the transport measurement . in sec . [ sec2 ] the theoretical model describing the physical system is given and the single - electron calculations are compared to the experiment . in sec . [ sec4 ] the many - electron properties , i.e. , chemical potentials , mdd stability , and total magnetization are studied with the sdft . the paper is summarized in sec . the heterostructure consists of a 10 nm wide gaas quantum well sandwiched between two al@xmath1ga@xmath2as - tunneling barriers of @xmath3 and @xmath4 nm , see fig . [ sample ] . the contacts are formed by @xmath5 @xmath6 m thick gaas layers highly doped with si up to @xmath7 @xmath8 and separated from the active region by 7 nm thin spacer layers of undoped gaas . our sample was defined as a mesa of 40 @xmath6 m size . we carried out direct - current measurements of the current - voltage ( i - v ) characteristics in a he@xmath9-refrigerator at 350 mk base temperature in magnetic fields up to @xmath10 t. figure [ exp_spectrum ] t.,width=321 ] shows the resulting transport spectrum of a quantum dot formed in a local potential minimum . the black lines @xmath11 correspond to high differential conductance @xmath12 . they trace the position of the single - electron energy states @xmath13 of the spectrum according to a relation @xmath14 where the energy - voltage conversion factor @xmath15 equals 0.4 , determined from measurements of the broadening of the step edge with temperature , and the onset voltage is fitted to be @xmath16 mv . the energy levels @xmath11 in the transport spectrum can be interpreted as single - particle levels of a local , presumably a grown - induced potential minimum in the gaas quantum well of our device . the lowest fd band is clearly visible , and one can also observe higher excited states . in contrast to ordinary fd energy levels , we are able to observe broken energy degeneracies at @xmath17 t and strong anticrossing effects in the spectrum . we expect the quantum well confined in the gaas layer to have a negligible degree of freedom for electrons in the vertical direction . our model system is thus strictly two - dimensional and defined to be located on the @xmath18 plane . the single - electron hamiltonian is written as @xmath19 ^ 2 + v_{\rm conf}({\mathbf r})+v_{\rm imp}({\mathbf r}),\ ] ] where we use the effective - mass approximation with @xmath20 , which is the typical value for electrons moving in gaas . in a symmetric gauge the vector potential reads as @xmath21 , giving the external magnetic field @xmath22 perpendicular to the qd plane . the zeeman energy is omitted in eq . ( [ hami1 ] ) since the spin splitting @xcite is not visible in the energy levels shown in fig . [ exp_spectrum ] for the magnetic fields applied . the confining potential @xmath23 is expected to be parabolic near the center of the dot . however , we soften the edges of the dot by changing the sign of the paraboloid at a certain cusp radius @xmath24 , giving @xmath25 , & r > r_c , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] where the parameter @xmath26 defines the strength of the rounding term . as shown below , the softening of the confinement is crucial in obtaining a good agreement with the experimental energy spectrum . we expect the impurity to be described by a negatively charged particle located in the vicinity of the quantum well . the impurity potential can thus be written in a coulombic form as @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the ( negative ) charge of the impurity particle , @xmath29 describes the `` dielectricity '' between the impurity and the electrons in the qd , and @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the lateral and vertical distances of the impurity from the qd center , respectively . figure [ vex ] shows the total external confinement of the model system , @xmath32 , and a sketch of the expected configuration . to calculate the single - electron spectrum , we solve the discretized eigenvalue problem @xmath33 ( @xmath34 ) numerically on a 2d point grid using a rayleigh quotient multigrid method . @xcite figure [ spectra ] shows the ) of a gaas / algaas qd and the calculated single - electron energies ( dashed lines ) corresponding to the model potential shown in fig . [ vex](a).,width=302 ] resulting spectrum ( dashed lines ) compared to the experimental data ( repeated from fig . [ exp_spectrum ] ) . the energies are converted to voltages according to eq . ( [ conv ] ) , and the model parameters are adjusted ( see the discussion below ) until the agreement between the experiment and the model is as good as possible . the simulation places the avoided crossings between the energy levels very close to the correct positions . there are still considerable deviations in the 5th and 6th levels but , for example , the 7th level agrees almost perfectly through the magnetic - field regime presented . the differences at high fields between the experimental data and the simulation result from the shift of the chemical potential of the emitter to higher energies with increasing magnetic field . in calculating the energy spectrum shown in fig . [ spectra ] , we optimize the potential parameters corresponding to the best possible fit to the experimental data . the confinement is then defined by @xmath35 mev , @xmath36 nm , and @xmath37 , and the impurity parameters are given by @xmath38 , @xmath39 nm , and @xmath40 nm . there is naturally some uncertainty in the parameters . however , for this particular sample we find the following characteristic features in the model potential : ( i ) the @xmath29-reduced impurity charge is so large that it indicates a multiple charged particle distorting the qd . ( ii ) the impurity is located very close to the qd plane , probably lying in the 10 nm thick gaas layer ( see fig . [ sample ] ) . ( iii ) the confining potential is approximately three times larger than the values typically used ( @xmath41 mev ) for modeling parabolic qd s . this is due to the grown - induced formation of the qd in the absence of gates around the sample . ( iv ) for the same reason , the confinement becomes softer toward the edges of the dot . hence , the rounding at @xmath42 in @xmath43 is required to compress the highest states in agreement with the experimental spectrum . to clarify the sensitivity of the single - electron spectrum on the shape of the model potential , we compare in fig . [ single ] the eigenenergies given by the chosen model ( thick lines ) to those of a model qd without the rounded edges ( thin lines ) and to those of a corresponding clean model dot without @xmath44 but with the rounding term ( dashed lines ) . the level repulsion is clearly induced by the coulombic impurity that breaks the circular symmetry of the qd and mixes the fd levels of different orbital quantum numbers . a statistical analysis of the energy - level spacings would enlighten the quantum chaotic properties @xcite of the system but it is not included in this study . in the high - field limit , however , the system becomes integrable and the eigenstates condense into landau levels . the rounding term in @xmath43 has the strongest influence on the levels with the highest angular momenta , and the cusp at @xmath24 induces also a weak decoupling of the degeneracies at @xmath17 t. we remark that the eigenenergies for the clean case are lifted in fig . [ single ] by @xmath10 mev for clarity . the coulombic impurity in the vicinity of the qd thus has a strong effect on the eigenenergies . this tendency is also apparent in the many - electron properties studied below . next we study situations that the quantum dot described by the best fitting parameters above contains up to six interacting electrons . even if the many - electron case has not yet been experimentally realized for this particular qd , we find it important to predict how the increasing electron number changes the effects of the impurity on the ground - state properties . the problem is now described by the @xmath45-electron hamiltonian @xmath46 + + \sum^n_{i < j}\frac{e^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0\epsilon|{\mathbf r}_i-{\mathbf r}_j| } , \label{hami}\ ] ] where the single - electron part @xmath47 is given by eq . ( [ hami1 ] ) and the zeeman energy is taken into account with @xmath48 for the effective gyromagnetic ratio in gaas . this has been measured to be a realistic value for a similar system . @xcite we have @xmath49 for the dielectric constant in the coulomb interaction between the electrons . we apply the sdft according to the self - consistent kohn - sham ( ks ) scheme to obtain the total energies and spin densities of the system . the local spin - density approximation used for the exchange - correlation energy is based on the magnetic - field - independent formulation by attaccalite _ @xcite according to our experience , it is the most accurate parametrization for finite two - dimensional electron systems in the zero - field limit . @xcite we solve the discretized ks equations in real space without implicit symmetry restrictions , which allows us a total freedom in shaping the external potential . the numerical process of solving the effective single - electron schrdinger equation is accelerated with the rayleigh quotient multigrid method . @xcite our earlier calculations for rectangular @xcite and parabolic @xcite qd s show that our sdft scheme produces energies in a good accordance with the quantum monte carlo results . we have also noticed that the current - spin - density - functional theory ( csdft ) does not represent a qualitative improvement over the sdft in small quantum - dot systems . a detailed comparison between the sdft and csdft for a six - electron qd can be found in ref . . figure [ chem ] shows the chemial potentials mev for clarity ) and impurity - containing ( solid lines ) quantum dot up to six electrons . the dotted lines denote the borders for the full spin polarization . the other spin - state domains are also marked above and below the curves corresponding to the clean and impurity - containing cases , respectively.,width=283 ] @xmath50 , calculated in clean ( dashed lines ) and impurity - containing ( solid lines ) qd s up to six electrons . due to the spin - degeneracy , the chemical potentials shift generally in adjacent pairs with increasing @xmath51 corresponding to the well - known even - odd effect of experimental current peaks . @xcite in the clean case , however , occasional pairing of @xmath52 and @xmath53 is clearly observable , e.g. , with @xmath54 and @xmath3 , and with @xmath55 and @xmath56 at @xmath57 t. this is caused by hund s rule , i.e. , near a degenerate point it is energetically favorable to have parallel spins between the electrons due to the exchange interaction . this leads to partial spin polarization ( @xmath58 ) in the clean dot with @xmath55 and @xmath59 at @xmath60 t and @xmath61 , respectively . in the impurity - containing dot those states are missing due to the avoided level crossings in the single - electron spectrum ( see fig . [ single ] ) generally , the impurity smoothes the behavior of the chemical potential , reflecting the flattening of the single - electron energies studied above . this is in agreement with the results by gl _ et al . _ @xcite for randomly distributed impurities . as seen in fig . [ chem ] the impurity does not affect considerably the onset for the full spin polarization ( dotted lines ) . as @xmath45 increases , however , this point in the clean qd shifts to higher @xmath51 than in the impurity - containing dot . simultaneously , the @xmath6 spacings decrease relatively more rapidly in the latter case than in the clean dot . the reason is the fact that the impurity pushes the electrons to the soft - confinement region near the edges , whereas the clean dot represents a more compact state with higher addition energies . in the description above , the impurity is kept in a fixed position at @xmath39 nm laterally from the dot center . next , we consider changes in the total angular momentum as @xmath30 is varied ( while @xmath31 is kept constant ) in magnetic fields corresponding to the mdd state . in a circularly symmetric qd , the mdd has the occupation on the single - particle states with angular momentum eigenvalues @xmath62 , giving @xmath63 for the total angular momentum . @xcite in the case of a broken circular symmetry , the onset for the mdd can be defined from the last cusp in the chemical potential indicating the full spin polarization ( see fig . [ chem ] ) . this is consistent with the experimental identification of the mdd phase by measuring the magnetic field evolution of the coulomb blockade peaks . @xcite since the angular momentum @xmath64 is not a good quantum number for a non - circular confinement , we compute @xmath65 in the following as a sum of the expectation values for the single - electron angular momentum operator , @xmath66 $ ] . the summation is over all the occupied ks states . in fig . [ lzdens ] and @xmath67 t , respectively.,width=302 ] we present how the six - electron mdd at @xmath68 t is affected by the impurity shifted through the whole qd region . except for the kink at @xmath69 nm , corresponding to the radius at which the impurity penetrates the edge of the qd , @xmath70 increases smoothly from @xmath71 to @xmath72 , i.e. , from the mdd to a quantum ring with @xmath73 states occupied . the stability is also visualized in the density insets of fig . [ lzdens ] corresponding to different impurity locations . the dashed line shows the equivalent evolution at @xmath74 t , still corresponding to the mdd region in the clean dot . as @xmath75 , however , we find a transition to the next quantum - ring state with @xmath76 states occupied . the rounded edges of the qd clearly make the ring - like states sensitive to the magnetic field . in contrast , the mdd remains as a rather compact state spread across the highly - confined central region as the magnetic field is varied . finally , we investigate the tendency of the many - electron structure to screen the external impurity . for that purpose , we consider the total magnetization , defined at zero temperature as @xmath77 . in fig . [ magnet ] we plot @xmath78 ( plus markers ) and @xmath3 nm ( cross markers ) with ( solid curves ) and without ( dashed curves ) the electron - electron interactions . the effective bohr magneton @xmath79.,width=302 ] as a function of @xmath51 for six - electron , fully - polarized qd s in both noninteracting and interacting cases and with the impurity locations @xmath80 and @xmath3 nm laterally from the qd center . the noninteracting energy is computed directly as a sum of the six lowest single - electron energies . as the impurity is shifted off the dot center , the lowest single - electron states decouple ( see fig . 1 in ref . ) , leading to a considerably smaller @xmath81 and disappearance of the transition at @xmath82 t in the noninteracting systems . on the other hand , the interacting systems show frequent oscillations due to the entanglement of the energy levels , i.e. , periodic changes in the fully - polarized ground state . @xcite the qd s with different impurity locations behave similarly , indicating that the circular properties are preserved also when the impurity is off - center . this verifies the screening of the impurity by the electrons . the importance of screening is evident also from the work by halonen _ et al . _ @xcite who considered impurity - containing qd s with two and three electrons . the same tendency was also found in the magnetization of the two - electron square qd s studied by sheng and zu . @xcite in our forthcoming studies , we will examine the high magnetic field regime as a function of the impurity parameters in more detail . we have reported a transport measurement of a vertical quantum dot , giving single - electron energies strongly deviating from the fock - darwin spectrum . we have found a realistic model for the sample dot by including a coulombic impurity in the external parabolic potential that has soft edges . the parameters obtained for the model potential indicate a strong confinement resulting from the grown - induced formation of the qd , and a repulsive , multiple charged impurity particle shifted both laterally and vertically from the qd center . using the model and the spin - density - functional theory , we have studied the energetics and structural properties of the corresponding many - electron problem . the impurity evens out the state alternation as a function of the magnetic field by lifting the degeneracies , but it does not affect remarkably the onset of the full spin polarization . the stability of both the maximum - density droplet and the magnetization verify that the many - electron structure reduces the distortion apparent in the single - electron properties . the future experiments may illustrate the damping of the irregular behavior in actual quantum - dot devices as the number of electrons increases . this research was supported by the academy of finland through its centers of excellence program ( 2000 - 2005 ) . is also grateful for magnus ehrnrooth foundation for financial support and a. harju and a. d. gl for useful discussions . the group in hannover acknowledges sample growth by v. avrutin and a. waag and financial support by bmbf . p. l. mceuen , e. b. foxman , u. meirav , m. a. kastner , y. meir , n. s. wingreen , and s. j. wind , phys . 66 * , 1926 ( 1991 ) ; j. weis , r. j. haug , k. v. klitzing , and k. ploog , phys . b * 46 * , 12837 ( 1992 ) . t. schmidt , m. tewordt , r. h. blick , r. j. haug , d. pfannkuche , k. v. klitzing , a. frster , and h. lth , phys . b * 51 * , 5570 ( 1995 ) ; j. knemann , d. k. maude , v. avrutin , a. waag , and r. j. haug , physica e * 22 * , 434 ( 2004 ) .

we have studied the single - electron transport spectrum of a quantum dot in gaas / algaas resonant tunneling device . the measured spectrum has irregularities indicating a broken circular symmetry . we model the system with an external potential consisting of a parabolic confinement and a negatively charged coulombic impurity placed in the vicinity of the quantum dot . the model leads to a good agreement between the calculated single - electron eigenenergies and the experimental spectrum . furthermore , we use the spin - density - functional theory to study the energies and angular momenta when the system contains many interacting electrons . in the high magnetic field regime the increasing electron number is shown to reduce the distortion induced by the impurity .

astro-ph9902311

one of the most remarkable observational results in the last three decades in cosmology is the lack of the gunn peterson trough in the spectra of high redshift quasars and galaxies . this finding implies that the intergalactic medium ( igm ) is highly ionized at least out to @xmath5 , the redshift of the most distant known quasars and galaxies ly@xmath6 emission lines , implying @xmath7 ( see discussion below ) . ] . since the primeval plasma recombined at @xmath8 , its subsequent ionization requires some form of energy injection into the igm , naturally attributable to astrophysical sources . the two most popular examples of such sources are an early generation of stars , residing in sub galactic size clusters ( hereafter `` mini galaxies '' ) , or accreting massive ( @xmath9 ) black holes in small ( @xmath10 ) halos ( hereafter `` mini quasars '' ) . reionization is interesting for a variety of reasons . first , the most fundamental questions are still unanswered : what type of sources caused reionization , and around what redshift did it occur ? how were the reionizing sources distributed relative to the gas ? what was the size , geometry , and topology of the ionized zones , and how did these properties evolve ? second , and more directly relevant to the topic of this review , reionization leaves distinctive signatures on the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) through the interaction between the cmb photons and free electrons . although it may complicate the extraction of cosmological parameters from cmb data , this `` contamination '' could yield important information on the ionization history of the igm . through reionization , the cmb is a useful probe of nonlinear processes in the high redshift universe . thomson scattering from free electrons affects the cmb in several ways . because the scattering leads to a blending of photons from initially different lines of sight , there is a damping of the _ primary _ temperature anisotropy . on the other hand , a new _ secondary _ anisotropy is generated by what can be thought of as a doppler effect : as photons scatter off free electrons , they pick up some of their peculiar momentum . finally , the polarization dependence of the thomson cross section creates new polarization from the initially anisotropic photon field . the inhomogeneity of reionization affects these processes in two different ways . first , the inhomogeneity of the medium affects how the _ mean _ ionization fraction evolves with time . this is important since the damping , doppler and polarization effects all occur even in the idealized case of spatially homogeneous reionization . secondly , the spatial fluctuations in the ionization fraction can greatly enhance the contribution from the doppler effect at small angular scales . polarization and damping are much less influenced by the inhomogeneity , as we will see below . the aim of the present review is to summarize our current knowledge of reionization , describe the possible connections to the cmb , and assess what we can hope to learn about the high redshift igm from forthcoming observations of the cmb anisotropies . if the igm was neutral , its optical depth to ly@xmath6 absorption would be exceedingly high : + @xmath11^{3/2}$ ] , wiping out the flux from any source at observed wavelengths shorter than @xmath12 . the spectra of high redshift quasars and galaxies reveal ly@xmath6 absorption by numerous discrete ly@xmath6 forest clouds , separated in redshift , rather than the continuous gunn peterson ( gp ) trough expected from a neutral igm . the detection of the continuum flux in between the ly@xmath6 clouds implies that @xmath13 is at most of order unity , or , equivalently , an upper limit on the average neutral fraction of @xmath14 . the intergalactic medium is therefore highly ionized . note that there is no sharp physical distinction between the intergalactic medium and the low column density ( @xmath15 ) ly@xmath6 forest ( reisenegger & miralda - escud 1995 ) . these ly@xmath6 clouds fill most of the volume of the universe , are highly ionized , and account for most of the baryons ( implied by big bang nucleosynthesis ) at high redshift ( weinberg et al . 1997 ; rauch et al . 1997 ) . the energy requirement of reionization can easily be satisfied either by the first mini galaxies or mini quasars . nuclear burning inside stars releases several mev per hydrogen atom , and thin disk accretion onto a schwarzschild black hole releases ten times more energy , while the ionization of a hydrogen atom requires only 13.6 ev . it is therefore sufficient to convert a fraction of @xmath16 of the baryonic mass into either stars or black holes in order to ionize the rest of the baryons in the universe . in a homogeneous universe , the ratio of recombination time to hubble time in the igm is @xmath17^{-3/2}$ ] so that each h atom would only recombine a few times at most until the present time . unless reionization occurred at @xmath18 , recombinations therefore would not change the above conclusion , and the number of ionizing photons required per atom would be of order unity . based on three - dimensional simulations , gnedin & ostriker ( 1997 ) argued that the clumpiness of the gas increases the average global recombination rate by a factor @xmath19 ( the averages are taken over the simulation box ) . this would imply a corresponding increase in the necessary number of ionizing photons per atom . however , in a more detailed picture of reionization in an inhomogeneous universe ( gnedin 1998 , miralda - escud et al . 1999 ) , the high - density regions are ionized at a significantly later time than the low density regions . if this picture is correct , then one ionizing photon per atom would suffice to reionize most of the volume ( filled by the low - density gas ) ; recombinations from the high - density regions would only contribute to the average recombination rate at a later redshift . the reionization redshift can be estimated from first principles . in the simplest picture [ first discussed by arons & wingert ( 1972 ) in the context of quasars ] , a homogeneous neutral igm is percolated by the individual hii regions growing around each isolated uv source . the universe is reionized when the ionized bubbles overlap , i.e. when the filling factor of hii regions reaches unity . several authors studied this problem ( carr et al . 1984 , couchman & rees 1986 , fukugita & kawasaki 1994 , meiksin & madau 1993 ; shapiro et al . 1994 , tegmark et al . 1994 ; aghanim et al . 1996 ; haiman & loeb 1997 ) . specifically , haiman & loeb ( 1998a ) have used the press schechter formalism to describe the formation of halos that potentially host ionizing sources , in order to estimate the redshift at which overlap occurs . in this study , star and quasar black hole formation was allowed only inside halos that can cool efficiently via atomic hydrogen , since molecular hydrogen would be photodissociated earlier , as argued by haiman , abel & rees ( 1999 ) and haiman , rees & loeb ( 1997 ) . this requirement translates to a minimum virial temperature of @xmath20k , or halo masses above @xmath21^{-3/2}$ ] ( see fig . [ fig : bubbles ] ) . for both types of sources , the total amount of light they produce was calibrated using data from redshifts @xmath22 . the efficiency of early star formation can be estimated from the observed metallicity of the intergalactic medium ( songaila & cowie 1996 , tytler et al . 1995 ) , utilizing the fact that these metals and the reionizing photons likely originate from the same stellar population . similarly , the efficiency of black hole formation inside early mini quasars can be constrained to match the subsequent evolution of the quasar luminosity function at redshifts @xmath22 ( pei 1995 ) . these assumptions generically lead to a reionization redshift @xmath23 . the uncertainty in the redshift reflects a range of cosmological parameters ( @xmath24 ) , cdm power spectra ( @xmath25 , @xmath26 ) , and efficiency parameters for the production and escape fraction of ionizing photons . in the stellar reionization scenario , the predicted redshift could be above or below this range , if the initial mass function was strongly biased ( relative to scalo 1986 ) towards massive or low - mass stars . although the naive picture of overlapping hii spheres may give a good estimate for the `` overlap redshift '' , it is likely to be a crude and incomplete description of the real process of reionization . the ionizing sources are expected to be located in the highly overdense regions that form the complex large scale structure of the universe - along filaments or sheets , or at their intersections ( see fig . [ fig:3d ] ) . the ionizing radiation will have to cross the local dense structures before propagating into the igm , which itself has significant density fluctuations . several important consequences of these inhomogeneities can be noted . first , reionization could occur `` outside - in '' ( miralda - escud et al . 1999 ) , if the radiation from a typical source escapes through a relatively narrow solid angle from its host , without causing significant local ionization . in this case , the low density regions could be ionized significantly earlier than the high density regions . an important effect in this case could be the shadowing of ionizing radiation by the dense concentrations within the igm . the same type of shadowing effect was found to be important at low redshift . based on the number of ly@xmath6 absorbers , madau , haardt & rees ( 1998 ) have concluded that as much as @xmath27% of the uv flux is absorbed by these systems . the redshift at which the igm becomes optically thin to the ionizing continuum is therefore significantly delayed relative to the overlap epoch , when the ionized zones first percolate . an alternative possibility is that the ionizing sources are densely spaced along filaments , and their radiation ionizes most of the dense filament before escaping into the igm . in this `` inside - out '' case , the description of ionized zones surrounding their host source would be more applicable . an important feedback during and after reionization is that the newly established uv background can photo evaporate the gas from small ( @xmath28 ) halos ( shapiro , raga & mellema 1997 ; barkana & loeb 1999 ) . a related point , important for the detection of the gp trough , is that at the time of overlap of the hii zones , each individual hii region could still have a non negligible ly@xmath6 optical depth , due to its residual hi fraction . the gp trough therefore disappears only from the spectra of individual sources located below the later redshift when the average ly@xmath6 optical depth of the igm drops below unity ( haiman & loeb 1998b ; miralda - escud et al . 1999 ; shapiro et al . finally , the inhomogeneity of the reionized igm leads to generation of anisotropies in the cmb which are strongly suppressed in the homogeneous case , as we shall see below . reionization is now also being addressed by three - dimensional simulations , which can eventually shed light on some of the above issues . the first such studies approximated radiative transfer by assuming an isotropic radiation field , but were able to take into account the inhomogeneities in the gas distribution ( ostriker & gnedin 1996 ; gnedin & ostriker 1997 ) . the resulting reionization redshift of @xmath29 in a @xmath30cdm model is in good agreement with the semi analytical estimates , given the differences in the assumed cosmology , power spectra , and star formation efficiency . however , an isotropic radiation field is necessarily a crude approximation , at least in the beginning stages of reionization , when each source still has its own isolated ionized zone . in order to understand the progressive overlap of ionized zones , including effects such as self - shielding and shadowing by dense clumps , it is necessary to incorporate radiative transfer into three dimensional simulations ( norman et al . 1998 ) . the numerical algorithms for the first such attempts are described in abel , norman & madau ( 1998 ) and razoumov & scott ( 1998 ) . results from an approximate treatment ( gnedin 1998 ) also support the outside in picture of reionization described above . several authors have emphasized that the known population of quasars or galaxies provide @xmath3110 times fewer ionizing photons than necessary to reionize the universe ( see , e.g. shapiro et al . 1994 , or madau et al . 1999 , and references therein ) . the two most natural candidates for undetected ionizing sources are the mini galaxies and mini quasars expected to be associated with small ( @xmath32 ) dark halos at @xmath33 . as there are no compelling _ ab initio _ theoretical arguments to strongly favor one type of source over the other , the best hope is to distinguish these two possibilities from observations . one expects at least three major differences between mini galaxies and mini quasars : their spectra , their absolute brightness ( or , alternatively , space density ) , and the angular size of their luminous regions . the flux from stellar populations drops rapidly with frequency above the ionization threshold of hydrogen , while the spectra of mini quasars are expected to be harder and extend into the x ray regime . stars could therefore not reionize heii , while quasars with typical spectra ( elvis et al . 1994 ) would reionize heii at approximately the same redshift as h ( haiman & loeb 1998a ) . however , recent high - resolution spectra of @xmath34 quasars have shown a widely fluctuating heii / hi optical depth ( reimers et al . the authors interpreted this observation as evidence for heiii regions embedded in an otherwise heii medium , i.e. a detection of the heii reionization epoch ( see also wadsley et al . if this interpretation is verified by future data , it would constrain the number of mini quasars with hard spectra extending to x rays at high redshifts ( haiman & loeb 1998b ; miralda - escud 1998 ; miralda - escud & rees 1994 ) . at present , a plausible alternative interpretation of the heii observations is that the observed heii optical depth fluctuations are caused by statistical fluctuations in the igm density or the ionizing background flux ( miralda - escud et al . 1999 ) , rather than by the patchy structure of heii / heiii zones . the x ray background ( xrb ; miyaji et al . 1998 ; fabian & barcons 1992 ) might provide another useful constraint on mini quasar models with hard spectra ( haiman & loeb 1998c ) . these models overpredict the _ unresolved flux _ by a factor of @xmath35 in the 0.11 kev range . if an even larger fraction of the xrb will be resolved into low redshift agns in the future , then the xrb could be used to place more stringent constraints on the x - ray spectrum or the abundance of the mini quasars . a second distinction between galaxies and quasars can be made based on their absolute luminosity and space density . on average , based on their @xmath36 counterparts , high redshift mini quasars are expected to be roughly @xmath37 times brighter , but @xmath38 times more rare , than galaxies . at the overlap epoch , hii regions from mini quasars would therefore be larger but fewer than those from mini galaxies . the typical size and abundance of hii regions has at least three important implications . first , it affects the cmb anisotropies ; the larger the hii regions , the larger the effect on the cmb ( gruzinov and hu 1998 , knox et al . 1998 ) , as we will see below . second , large enough hii regions ( @xmath39mpc ) would allow gaps to open up in the gp trough ; the flux transmitted through such gaps around very bright quasars could be detectable ( miralda - escud et al . third , if sources form inside the rare , high-@xmath40 peaks , they would be strongly clustered ( knox et al . this clustering would increase the effective luminosity of each source , and would enhance both of the effects above . finally , a constraint on the number of mini quasars at @xmath41 can be derived from the hubble deep field ( hdf ) . quasars are expected to appear as faint point sources in the hdf , unless their underlying extended host galaxies are resolved . the properties of faint _ extended _ sources found in the hubble deep field ( hdf ) agree with detailed semi analytic models of galaxy formation ( baugh et al . 1998 ) . on the other hand , the hdf has revealed only a handful of faint _ unresolved _ sources , and none with the colors expected for high redshift quasars ( conti et al . 1999 ) . the simplest mini quasar models predict the existence of @xmath42 b band `` dropouts '' in the hdf , inconsistent with the lack of detection of such dropouts up to the @xmath43 completeness limit at @xmath44 . to reconcile the models with the data , a mechanism is needed that suppresses the formation of quasars in halos with circular velocities @xmath45 ( haiman , madau & loeb 1999 ) . this suppression naturally arises due to the photo - ionization heating of the intergalactic gas by the uv background after reionization . forthcoming data on point sources from nicmos observations of the hdf ( see thompson et al . 1998 ) could further improve these constraints . as described above , theoretical expectations place the reionization redshift at @xmath46 . what about observations ? at present , the best _ lower _ limit in the reionization redshift comes from the detection of high redshift ly@xmath6 emitters ( hu et al . 1998 ; weymann et al . 1998 ) . as argued by miralda - escud ( 1998 ) , the damping wing of ly@xmath6 absorption by a neutral igm has a large residual optical depth that would severely damp any ly@xmath6 emission line . currently the highest redshift at which a ly@xmath6 emitter is seen is @xmath47 ; the existence of this object implies that reionization occurred prior to this redshift ( see haiman & spaans 1998 ) . note that hii regions around individual sources , excepting only the brightest quasars , would be too small to allow the escape of ly@xmath6 photons , because the damping wings of the gp troughs around the hii region would still overlap . the best _ upper _ limit on the reionization redshift can be obtained from the cmb anisotropy data . several experiments have revealed a rise in the power on small angular scales , and a drop at even smaller scales ( e.g. , bond 1999 ) , showing evidence for the first doppler peak expected from acoustic oscillations in the baryon - photon fluid prior to recombination ( e.g. , hu & sugiyama 1994 ) . these observations can also be used to set limits on the electron scattering optical depth ( or the corresponding reionization redshift ) that would suppress the doppler peak . from a compilation of all the existing measurements , griffiths et al . ( 1998 ) have derived the stringent ( although model - dependent ) constraint @xmath48 on the reionization redshift if reionization occurred earlier , the electron scattering optical depth would have reduced the amplitude of the anisotropies below the observed level . note that another upper limit results from the spectral distortion of the cmb caused by scattering on the reionized igm , which is constrained by the upper limit on the compton @xmath49parameter measured by cobe . the inferred upper limit on the reionization redshift , however , is much weaker , @xmath50 for typical parameters in a low density universe ( griffiths et al . 1998 , see also stebbins & silk 1986 ) . in summary , present observations have narrowed down the possible redshift of the reionization epoch to @xmath51 , a relatively narrow range that is in good agreement with the theoretical predictions described above . further observational progress in probing the reionization epoch could come either from the _ next generation space telescope _ ( _ ngst _ ) , or from more precise measurements of the cmb anisotropies by _ map _ and _ planck_. _ ngst _ , scheduled for launch in 2007 , is expected to reach the @xmath52njy sensitivity required to detect individual sources to @xmath33 , and to perform medium resolution spectroscopy to @xmath53 . if reionization occurred close to the low end of the allowed redshift range , @xmath54 , then it may be possible to infer the redshift directly from the spectra of bright sources . one specific method relies on the spectrum of a bright source just beyond the reionization redshift , so that the individual ly@xmath6 , ly@xmath55 , and other gp troughs do not overlap in frequency , leaving gaps of transmitted flux ( haiman & loeb 1998b ) . the measurement of this transmitted flux would be possible with _ ngst _ , despite absorption by the high redshift ly@xmath6 forest , as long as the number density of absorbers does not rise much more steeply with redshift than an extrapolation of the current @xmath36 data would imply ( fardal et al . if reionization is gradual , rather than abrupt , than this method would measure the redshift at which the gp optical depth drops to near unity , i.e. the final stages of the reionization epoch . an alternative signature to look for would be the precise shape of the damping wing of ly@xmath6 absorption from the neutral igm along the line of sight to the source ( miralda - escud 1998 ) . the shape , if measured by high resolution spectroscopy , could be used to determine the total optical depth of the igm . the caveat of this method is the inability to distinguish the neutral igm from a damped ly@xmath6 absorber along the line of sight , close to the source . an alternative signature is the background ly@xmath6 emission from the reionization epoch . recombinations are slow both at high redshifts , when the igm is still neutral , and at low redshifts when the igm density is low . as shown by simulations ( gnedin & ostriker 1997 ) , the global recombination rate has a pronounced peak around the reionization epoch . the resulting recombinant ly@xmath6 emission has been computed by baltz , gnedin & silk ( 1998 ) , and a detailed detectability study has shown that this signal could be measured by _ ngst _ , or perhaps even by _ hst _ ( shaver et al . 1999 ) . yet another signature could result from the 21 cm hyperfine transitions in the igm before reionization . prior to reionization , the excitation of the 21 cm line in neutral hi atoms depends on the spin temperature . the coupling of the spin temperature to that of the cmb is determined by the local gas density , temperature , and the radiation background from the first mini galaxies and mini quasars . in general , the 21 cm line could be seen either in absorption or emission against the cmb , and could serve as a tomographic tool to diagnose the density and temperature of the high redshift neutral gas ( see , e.g. madau et al . 1997 ; scott & rees 1990 ) . if reionization occurred at @xmath56 , the redshifted 21 cm signals would be detectable by the giant metrewave radio telescope ; a study of the effect at higher redshifts would be possible with next generation instruments such as the thousand element array , or the square kilometer array ( shaver et al . 1999 ) . the reionization redshift could turn out to be closer to the high end of the allowed range , @xmath57 , rendering direct detection of emission from the reionization epoch implausible ( except perhaps the 21 cm signal ) . there is , however , a fortunate `` complementarity '' , since the electron scattering optical depth increases with reionization redshift . due to the effect on the polarization power spectrum on large angular scales , _ map _ and _ planck _ may be able to discern an electron scattering optical depth as small as a few percent ( zaldarriaga et al . 1997 , eisenstein et al . 1998 , prunet et al . 1998 ) . by temperature anisotropy data alone , they may be able to determine an optical depth as small as @xmath58 due to the damping effect mentioned earlier and to be discussed in more detail later . the reionizing sources may also change the spectral shape of the cmb . the dust that is inevitably produced by the first type ii supernovae , absorbs the uv emission from early stars and mini quasars and re - emits this energy at longer wavelengths . loeb & haiman ( 1997 ) have quantified the resulting spectral distortion in press schechter type models , assuming that each type ii supernova in a scalo imf yields @xmath59 of dust with the wavelength - dependent opacity of galactic dust , uniformly distributed throughout the intergalactic medium . under these assumptions , the dust remains cold ( close to the cmb temperature ) , and its emission peaks near the cmb peak . the resulting spectral distortion can be expressed as a compton @xmath49parameter @xmath60 , near the upper limit derived from measurement of the cmb spectrum by cobe ( fixsen et al . 1996 ) . a substantial fraction ( @xmath61@xmath62% ) of this total @xmath49parameter results simply from the direct far - infrared emission by early mini quasars and could be present even in the absence of any intergalactic dust . inhomogeneities in the dust distribution could change these conclusions . instead of being homogeneously mixed into the igm , the high redshift dust may remain concentrated inside or around the galaxies where it is produced . in this case , the average dust particle would see a higher flux than assumed in loeb & haiman ( 1997 ) , so that the dust temperature would be higher , and dust emission would peak at a shorter wavelength . the magnitude of the spectral distortion would be enhanced , and may account for the recently discovered cosmic infrared background ( puget et al . 1996 , schlegel et al . 1998 , fixsen et al . 1998 , hauser et al . 1998 ) as shown by the semi analytic models of baugh et al . an angular fluctuation in the magnitude of the distortion would also be expected in this case , reflecting the discrete nature of the sources contributing to the effect . as seen above , reionization has several consequences ; in the rest of this review we focus on the connection to the cmb , and the effects of inhomogeneities . in this section , we give an in - depth treatment of the effects on the cmb photons of thomson - scattering off of the free electrons produced by reionization . after defining the optical depth and giving its dependence on the redshift of reionization and cosmological parameters , we discuss the three separate effects : damping , doppler and polarization generation . then we derive the evolution equations from the boltzmann equation , argue that the doppler effect is the most important _ inhomogeneous _ effect , and calculate the resulting power spectrum for several simple models of inhomogeneous reionization ( ihr ) . the probability of a photon scattering in the time interval from some initial time @xmath63 to the present , @xmath64 is given by @xmath65 where ( t_0 ) _ t n_e(t ) dt is the optical depth to thomson scattering and @xmath66 is the thomson cross - section . if one assumes a step - function transition from a neutral to an ionized igm at a redshift of @xmath67 , the mean optical depth is given by ( e.g. , griffiths et al . , 1998 ) [ eqn : depthofzion ] ( z_ion ) = ^*/_0where ^ * = h_0 _ b _ t 4 g m_p ( 1-y/2 ) 0.033 _ b h , @xmath68 and @xmath69 are the density of baryonic matter and of all matter respectively , in units of the critical density today , @xmath70 is the hubble constant , + @xmath71 , @xmath72 is newton s constant , @xmath73 is the proton mass and @xmath74 is the mass fraction of baryons in helium . the final equality assumes @xmath75 . to get equation [ eqn : depthofzion ] , we assumed that @xmath76 , and adopted the line element , @xmath77 , of a spatially flat universe with only non - relativistic matter and a cosmological constant . note that for @xmath78 ( the observational lower bound ) , @xmath79 and @xmath80 , we get @xmath81 for @xmath82 and @xmath83 for @xmath84 . for @xmath67 only slightly larger than this limiting value , it is a good approximation to rewrite equation [ eqn : depthofzion ] as ( z_ion ) = 0.037/ ( 1+z_ion 11)^3/2 ( _ b h^2 0.02 ) ( 0.65 h ) . thus we see that the fraction of cmb photons that have been scattered may be very small , but that this fraction grows fairly rapidly with increasing redshift . the increase in optical depth for fixed @xmath67 with increasing @xmath85 is due to the fact that the proper time from the present to @xmath67 increases as the cosmological constant increases . here we give simple arguments about the nature of the damping , doppler and polarization effects . before doing so , it is useful to define the two - point correlation function , @xmath86 which is perhaps the most important statistical property of the cmb fluctuations : c ( ) ( _ 1,*x*,_0 ) ( _ 2,*x*,_0 ) ; _ 1 _ 2 where @xmath87 denotes ensemble average . the same information is contained in its legendre transform , the angular power spectrum , @xmath88 : c()= _ c_p _ ( ) . roughly speaking , @xmath89 is the power in modes with wavelength @xmath90 so that @xmath91 corresponds to about a degree . if the fluctuations are gaussian - distributed and statistically isotropic , all other statistics can be derived from @xmath89 . for an initially homogeneous and isotropic photon field , there is just as much probability to scatter into a line of sight as there is to scatter out of it . therefore , the optical depth to scattering produces no net effect . if , however , there is initial anisotropy , then this anisotropy is damped . consider a line of sight along which the temperature differs by @xmath92 from the mean @xmath93 in the absence of damping . if damping is present , then the temperature is changed to [ eqn : simpledamping ] |t + t & & ( |t + t ) - ( |t+t)(1-e^- ) + |t(1-e^- ) + & & |t + t e^- this equation expresses the fact that the final temperature is given by the initial temperature , reduced by the photons that have been lost , and increased by the photons that have been scattered in from other lines of sight . since the photons that have been scattered in come from many different lines of sight , their average temperature is very nearly the global average an assumption made in equation [ eqn : simpledamping ] . the net result is that @xmath94 and therefore @xmath95 or @xmath96 . this simple calculation would imply that the damping is independent of scale , which is not exactly true . our assumption that the average @xmath97 along lines of sight that scattered in equals the global average holds only when the distance _ between _ the scattering surfaces is much larger than the length scale of interest . at very large angular scales , the damping does not occur , as one would expect from simple causality considerations . more precisely , the damping factor is @xmath98-dependent and , defined via @xmath99 , is given by the fitting formula of hu & white 1997 : r_l^2 = 1-(-2 ) a+c_1 x + c_2 x^2 + c_3 x^3 + c_4 x^4 + ( -2 ) , with @xmath100 and @xmath101 and @xmath102 . the characteristic angular scale @xmath103 is roughly the angular scale subtended by the horizon at the new last - scattering surface and is given approximately by ( griffiths et al . 1998 , hu & white 1997 ) : l_r = ( 1+z_ion)^1/2(1 + 0.84_0)-1 . if not for the @xmath98-dependence , the damping effect would be completely degenerate with the amplitude of the primary power spectrum ; i.e. , their effects would be indistinguishable . the similar response to amplitude and @xmath104 over a large range of @xmath98 makes them approximately degenerate and is the reason why the optical depth can only be determined to about 10% ( zaldarriaga et al . 1997 ) or possibly worse ( eisenstein et al . 1998 ) based on temperature anisotropy alone . the thomson scattering _ differential _ cross - section is polarization - dependent , and therefore the scattered radiation may be polarized even if the incident radiation is not . however , by symmetry considerations alone one can see that initially isotropic radiation will not become polarized . in fact , it is easy to show that the particular anisotropy required for the creation of polarization is a quadrupole moment . this is essentially due to the @xmath105 dependence of the differential cross - section . the fourier analogue of the angle - distance relation can be written as @xmath106 where @xmath107 is the comoving wave - number that projects from conformal time @xmath108 into multipole moment @xmath109 at conformal time @xmath110 . conformal time is related to proper time by @xmath111 where @xmath112 is the scale factor of the expansion . applying this relationship twice , and using the fact that polarization is generated by the quadrupole moment , @xmath113 , p ~(_0 - _ ion)(2 _ ion- _ lss ) 2 ( -1 ) . for the last equality , we assumed a matter - dominated universe and that @xmath114 . thus we expect a peak in the polarization power spectrum near @xmath115 . determining the location of this peak allows one to determine the epoch of reionization . the amplitude of the peak is proportional to the optical depth , and thus also helps in determining @xmath67 . unfortunately , the signal is very weak and present only at large angular scales , e.g. , @xmath116 for @xmath117 . since there are only @xmath118 independent modes from which to determine @xmath89 , sample variance is worst at low @xmath98 . also , the large - scale features of polarization maps reconstructed from time - ordered data are likely to be those most sensitive to systematic errors . finally , polarized galactic foregrounds ( dust and synchrotron ) are expected to be most troublesome at small @xmath98 ( bouchet et al . 1998 , knox 1998 ) . however , a benefit of the low-@xmath109 location of this signature is that if it can be measured , its interpretation will not be complicated by the inhomogeneity of the reionization , which is a much smaller - scale phenomenon . if the systematic errors are negligible , the reionization feature in the polarization power spectrum can be used to discern very small optical depths . forecasts of parameter determination by eisenstein et al . ( 1998 ) using both the temperature anisotropy and polarization data are for one sigma errors on @xmath104 of 0.022 for _ map _ and @xmath119 for _ planck_. also see zaldarriaga et al . ( 1997 ) for similar results . note that these sensitivities , especially in the case of _ planck _ , are high enough to detect the effects of reionization _ at any epoch _ given that we know it happened prior to @xmath47 . the contribution to @xmath120 at location @xmath121 , in direction @xmath122 , at conformal time @xmath123 ( today ) is given by [ eqn : doppler ] t t(*x*_0,,_0 ) = _ t__ion^_0 dn_e(*x*)_e(*x * ) a where @xmath124 . as one might expect , it is proportional to the line - of - sight integral of the parallel component of electron velocity , @xmath125 times the number density of scatterers , @xmath126 . as sunyaev ( 1978 ) and kaiser ( 1984 ) pointed out , in the homogeneous case this contribution to @xmath127 is suppressed by cancellations due to oscillations in @xmath125 . one way to think of these cancellations is that photons get nearly opposite doppler shifts on different sides of a density peak , which is a consequence of potential flows generated by gravitational instability . the cancellations are less complete at large angular scales ( @xmath128 ) and there is a measurable effect which is exactly taken into account in boltzmann codes such as cmbfast . if speed is critical , the fitting formulae of griffiths et al . ( 1998 ) can be employed for an approximate treatment . the cancellations at small scales can be greatly reduced by the modulation of the number density of free electrons which we can write as @xmath129 where @xmath130 is the ionization fraction and @xmath131 is the number density of all protons , including those in h and he . this modulation occurs even in the case of homogeneous reionization ( spatially constant @xmath130 ) due to spatial variations in @xmath131 . because @xmath132 is zero to zeroth order , and @xmath131 is uniform to zeroth order , this is a second - order effect . that this second order effect could dominate the first - order one ( which is small due to cancellations ) was pointed out by ostriker and vishniac and is known as the ostriker - vishniac effect ( ostriker & vishniac 1986 , vishniac 1987 ) . subsequent systematic study of all 2nd order contributions have shown that it is the dominant second - order contribution as well ( hu et al . 1994 , dodelson & jubas 1995 ) . another source of modulation of the number density of free electrons is spatial variations in @xmath130 , i.e. , ihr . as a photon streams towards us from the last - scattering surface , it may pick up a doppler `` up kick '' on one side of an overdensity , but avoid the canceling `` down kick '' on the other because the igm there is still neutral . how effectively the cancellation is avoided depends on the matching between the typical sizes of the ionized domains and the correlation length of the velocity field , as we will discuss below . we now derive equation [ eqn : doppler ] , as well as a more general expression which includes the contribution from damping as well . more complete treatments of the evolution of a photon distribution function in an expanding , inhomogeneous universe can be found in , e.g. , ma & bertschinger ( 1995 ) . the boltzmann equation governing the evolution of the photon phase - space distribution function , @xmath133 , is simply @xmath134 , where @xmath135 takes into account the effect of collisions in this case with electrons via thomson scattering . the thomson scattering cross - section is independent of frequency and therefore does not induce spectral distortions ; the effect on the distribution function can be fully described by the change in brightness . thus we use the brightness perturbation variable defined by @xmath136 where @xmath137 is the comoving photon momentum , and the phase - space distribution function has been partitioned into a homogeneous and inhomogeneous part , @xmath138 . for a planckian @xmath133 with thermal fluctuations , @xmath92 , about a mean temperature of @xmath97 , @xmath139 . expanding the total derivative on @xmath133 , keeping terms to first order in the perturbation variables and fourier transforming the result , the boltzmann equation becomes : [ eqn : boltz ] ( , , ) + ik(,,)+ 23h ( , ) & & + + 23 ( 3h_33(,)-h(,))p_2 ( ) & = & + d^3x e^i*k * ( * x*,)s(*x * , , ) & & where @xmath140 is the fourier transform of the brightness perturbation , @xmath141 is the direction of the photon momentum , @xmath142 , the dot indicates differentiation with respect to conformal time and @xmath143 and @xmath144 are the 3,3 component and trace of the synchronous gauge metric perturbation , respectively , in the coordinate system defined by @xmath145 . on the right - hand side of equation ( [ eqn : boltz ] ) we have explicitly separated out the dependence of the collision term on the differential optical depth , @xmath146 . the quantity @xmath147 is a function of the brightness perturbation and the electron velocity . to first order in the perturbation variables its fourier transform is ( neglecting the polarization dependence of the thomson cross - section ) [ eqn : s ] s(*k * , , ) = -+ _ 0 + 4 _ e - 12_2 p_2 ( ) where @xmath148 . if we were to allow both @xmath149 and @xmath147 to depend on @xmath150 , the fourier modes would no longer evolve independently . to avoid this complication , we use an expansion in small @xmath149 . let @xmath151 be the solution for @xmath152 and let @xmath153 . then to first order in @xmath149 : ^(1)(*k * ) + ik^(1)(*k * ) = d^3x e^i*k * ( * x*)s^(0)(*x * , ) . which has the solution in real space : [ eqn : delta ] ^(1)(,*x*,_0)= _ _ i^_0 d^(*x^ * ) s^(0)(*x*^ , ) where @xmath154 . this solution can be derived with a green function approach or simply verified by substitution . it can be taken to higher order , if desired , by getting @xmath155 from @xmath156 , etc . note that for the doppler effect equation [ eqn : delta ] is exact because @xmath132 ( unlike , e.g. , @xmath157 ) receives no corrections due to the optical depth . we can now argue that the doppler effect , due to the @xmath125 term in equation [ eqn : delta ] , is the most important inhomogeneous effect . the dominance of this effect is due to the fact that by the time of reionization , velocities have grown substantially as they react to the gravitational field . on the relevant length scales , the rms peculiar velocities are about @xmath158 . in contrast , the damping of the anisotropy is due to the @xmath159 term in @xmath147 , which has not grown from its primordial value of @xmath160 . similarly , polarization is sourced by the quadrupole moment which is also still at the @xmath160 level at the epoch of reionization . therefore we expect these contributions to be down by two orders of magnitude in amplitude , or four in power . if we break up the correlation function into components according to the expansion in optical depth : c ( ) = c^(0)()+2c^(01)()+c^(1 ) ( ) where @xmath161 , @xmath162 and @xmath163 are the correlations between the two zeroth order terms , between the two first order corrections and between the first order and zeroth order terms , respectively . for the doppler effect , the ( exact ) correction to the homogeneous case comes entirely from the @xmath162 term which is equal to [ eqn : cdoppler ] c^(1 ) ( ) = _ _ i^_0d_1 _ _ i^_0 d_2 ( _ 1 ) _ 1 ( _ 2 ) _ 2 where the numeric subscript on the quantities in parentheses means evaluate at , e.g. , @xmath164 . from equation [ eqn : cdoppler ] we see that the relevant quantity for the cmb 2-point autocorrelation function , is the two - point function of the product , @xmath165 , integrated over the lines of sight . as pointed out by knox et al . ( 1998 ) it is this latter 2-point function which must be calculated from either simulations or analytical models of the reionization process . a very simple toy model was used by gruzinov and hu ( 1998 , hereafter gh ) and by knox et al . ( 1998 , hereafter ksd ) for investigating the effect of ihr on the power spectrum . in this model , independent sources turn on randomly and instantaneously ionize a sphere with comoving radius @xmath166 , which then remains ionized . the rate of source creation is such that the mean ionization fraction is zero prior to @xmath167 and then rises linearly with redshift to unity at @xmath67 . gh derived the following approximate expression for the resulting power spectrum : [ eqn : gh ] l^2 c_l 2 & = & a l^2 _ 0 ^ 2 e^-l^2 _ 0 ^ 2/2 , + _ 0 & & r _ 0 - _ ion , + a & = & 36 _ 0 ^ 2 < v^2 > r/_0 z ( 1+z_ion)^3/2 where @xmath168 is the variance of peculiar velocities and @xmath169 and @xmath170 is the number density of free electrons today . the qualitative shape of this power spectrum is simple to understand . on large scales it is the shape of a white noise power spectrum ( @xmath171 constant ) , due to the lack of correlations between the patches . at small scales there is an exponential cutoff corresponding to the angular extent of the patches themselves , since they have no internal structure . the exact calculations for this model by ksd result in a very similar shape but with the power reduced by a factor of two and the location of the peak shifted to larger @xmath98 by 30% . thus we can write down very simple , and accurate , equations for the location of the maximum , which are those of gh with the prefactors modified to fit the results of ksd : [ eqn : dopplermax ] ( l^2 c_l 2)_max & = & 36e _ 0 ^ 2 < v^2 > r/_0 z ( 1+z_ion)^3/2 , and + l_max & = & 1.8 _ 0 r . note that for sufficiently large @xmath166 , velocities are not coherent within a patch and equations [ eqn : gh ] and [ eqn : dopplermax ] break down ; cancellations once again become important . however , this only happens for @xmath172 mpc since the velocity correlation function only becomes negative for separations greater than about @xmath173 mpc ( ksd ) . as long a @xmath166 is less than 10 s of mpc , the power scales linearly with @xmath166 . aghanim et al . ( 1996 , hereafter `` a96 '' ) used a slightly more complicated model in which there was a distribution of patch sizes due to an assumed distribution of mini quasar luminosities . the larger patches dominate at low @xmath98 and the cutoff at higher @xmath98 is much softer than in the single patch case , due to the existence of the smaller patches . for an order - of - magnitude calculation , their largest patches have @xmath174 mpc and reionization proceeds from @xmath175 to @xmath176 . for this simplification of the a96 model we find the curve in figure [ fig : pspec ] which has @xmath177 and @xmath178 . this amplitude is just large enough to possibly be a source of systematic error in the determination of cosmological parameters from _ map _ data , which has sensitivity out to @xmath179 . to be more precise , _ map _ can determine the power in a broad band centered on @xmath180 with width @xmath181 to about 0.5 % . thus , given the primary signal assumed in the figure , we may expect signals on the order of @xmath182 to be significant contaminants . this ihr signal from a 10 mpc patch would be an even more noticeable effect in the _ planck _ data since _ planck _ has sensitivity out to about @xmath183 and can determine the power in a broad band centered on @xmath184 with width @xmath185 to about 0.2 % . the quasar luminosity function ( qlf ) is relatively well measured in the optical below redshift @xmath36 , with a typical average optical luminosity of @xmath186 . in order to estimate the expected typical hii patch size around the observed quasars , one needs to know their lifetime ( or `` duty cycle '' ) . taking the lifetime of quasars to be universal , and near the eddington time ( @xmath187 yr ) , and further ignoring recombinations , one obtains a comoving radius of @xmath311020mpc . as seen above , this would be large enough for its effects on the cmb to be detectable by _ planck _ and maybe _ map_. we emphasize however , that the typical quasar luminosity at @xmath188 can be much lower than at @xmath189 . in hierarchical structure formation models , the nonlinear mass scale is @xmath190 orders of magnitude smaller at @xmath188 than at @xmath34 . with a linear scaling between quasar luminosity and halo mass , this would reduce the average patch size by a factor of @xmath61 . in addition , the duty cycles of quasars are not well established . in theoretical models where the qlf is derived by associating quasars with collapsed dark halos ( in the press schechter formalism ) , a typical lifetime of @xmath187 yr would generically lead to an overestimate of the number of observed quasars ( e.g. small & blandford 1992 ) . to avoid these overpredictions , one needs to assume that either ( 1 ) the quasar shines at a small fraction of the eddington luminosity , or ( 2 ) the efficiency of black hole formation , expressed as @xmath191 , is 2 orders of magnitude lower than suggested by nearby galaxies ( magorrian et al . 1998 ) , or ( 3 ) the black hole masses grow in an optically inactive phase ( e.g. haehnelt , natarajan & rees 1998 ) . alternatively , one can fit the observed qlf by assuming that the quasar lifetime is @xmath31100 times shorter than the eddington time ( haiman & loeb 1997 ) . in the latter case , the hii patch sizes would be reduced to @xmath192 mpc ( i.e. reionization would correspond to a larger number of smaller patches ) . according to equation [ eqn : dopplermax ] , patches smaller than a few mpc result in power spectra with smaller maxima at values of @xmath98 that are too high , and well outside the range of sensitivity of _ map _ and _ planck_. even for patches as large as 1 mpc , one can see that , at least for reionization at the extreme low end of the redshift range , their effect is negligible ( see figure [ fig : pspec ] ) . a detection of an ihr signal in the cmb with a peak could have important implications for quasar evolution theories , e.g. by ruling out models that lead to short duty cycles and small patch sizes . a detection might also prove that reionization was caused by mini quasars , rather than mini galaxies , since for the mini - galaxy models , the patch sizes are expected to be only a few hundred kpc . however , in light of the small expected patch sizes , it seems unlikely that _ map _ or _ planck _ reaches the required angular resolution for such a detection . the above calculations of the ihr power spectrum all assumed that the ionized regions are uncorrelated . however , the pattern of density fluctuations will affect the pattern of ionized regions and therefore correlations in the density field should give rise to correlations in the ionization fraction field . determining what these correlations should be is complicated by the fact that the density field affects the ionization field in two different ways : by the fact that the sources are most likely located in high density regions and the fact that the recombination rates are highest in the densest regions . to take the former effect into account , kds gave the ionization field the same correlation structure as that of the `` high - peaks '' of the density field . these high - peaks are regions where the fractional density perturbation , @xmath193 , smoothed on the appropriate scale , exceeds the critical value for spherical collapse . the smoothing scale was taken to be that corresponding to @xmath194^{-3/2}$ ] , since objects below this size will not be able to cool sufficiently to fragment and form stars ( haiman , rees & loeb 1997 ) . one further assumption was that the sources ionized a region @xmath195 times larger than that from which they collapsed where the efficiency factor is time - dependent and given by ( haiman & loeb 1997 , haiman & loeb 1998a ) @xmath196 . for this rather high choice for the efficiency , reionization is complete at @xmath197 . the resulting spectrum is shown as the dashed line in figure [ fig : pspec ] . the correlations between the patches which are individually only hundreds of kiloparsecs in radius drastically alter the low @xmath98 shape . even given the high redshift of reionization in this scenario , the corresponding uncorrelated model of equation [ eqn : gh ] would predict orders of magnitude less power at @xmath198 to @xmath199 . if this signal were in the data , but not in ones model of the data , it would lead to a bias in the determination of cosmological parameters . ksd estimated the bias that would occur in a nine parameter fit , assuming the primary signal was that of standard cold dark matter . for planck , the systematic in the estimate of the baryon density was equal to the statistical error . for all the other parameters the systematic error was less than the statistical error . if the mini quasar scenario is correct , with bright , long - lived quasars , then the doppler effect will lead to a significant contamination of the _ planck _ data and possibly a marginally important one for _ map _ data . for the more likely mini galaxy scenario , if one ignores the correlations in the ionized patches , the contamination is completely irrelevant for both _ map _ and _ planck_. however , correlations may indeed be important , and in one attempt to take them into account , we have seen that for an extreme mini galaxy scenario , the contamination is marginally significant for _ planck_. work by oh ( 1999 ) supports the idea that the ionized patches should be correlated . oh has modeled the ionizing sources as characterized by a mean separation ( given by press - schechter theory ) , an isotropic attenuation length which specifies how far the ionizing radiation propagates , and a power - law correlation function ( appropriate for these highly - biased objects ) . placing sources in a box and working out the resulting flux densities he can then calculate the correlation function of the flux density . it is indeed correlated , with significant ( 0.2 ) correlation at a comoving separations of 10 mpc . although a clumping factor for the igm from gnedin & ostriker ( 1997 ) is used to estimate the attenuation length , all propagation from the sources is taken to be isotropic , and hence this work does not yet include the influence of shielding and shadowing . as one can see in fig . [ fig : pspec ] , the contribution from ihr may be sub - dominant to that from the ostriker - vishniac ( o - v ) effect , as it is for all three models of ihr shown . the o - v contribution here is calculated using the formalism of jaffe & kamionkowski ( 1998 , hereafter `` jk98 '' ) . one must keep in mind that as a second - order effect , it is highly sensitive to the normalization . the curve here is cobe - normalized ( @xmath200 ) ; a cluster normalization of @xmath201 would reduce the @xmath89 by a factor of 16 . it is also calculated for the very early reionization redshift ( and resulting high optical depth ) of @xmath202 . however , the amplitude is not very sensitive to @xmath104 because much of the effect actually comes from more recent times the dropping number density of electrons must compete with the growth in the density contrasts and peculiar velocities(hu & white 1995 , jk98 ) . of course , the separation into ihr and o - v is artificial , and efforts to understand the contribution from reionization are surely going to benefit from treating them simultaneously . indeed , the 2-point function of @xmath203 , measured from a simulation , would include both effects . gravity is the only other late - time , frequency - independent , influence on the cmb photons , causing lensing and the rees - sciama effect ( rees & sciama 1968 ) . the angular - power spectrum from the rees - sciama effect has been calculated by seljak ( 1995 ) and is substantially sub - dominant to either the primary spectrum or the o - v effect at all angular scales . gravitational lensing results in a smearing of the primary cmb angular power spectrum and has also been calculated by seljak ( 1996 ) . uncertainties in this calculation may indeed be important for any attempt to recover the contribution from the ihr and ostriker - vishniac effects . the principal unanswered questions about reionization are : what type of sources caused it , and at what redshift did it occur ? these questions have been addressed both theoretically and observationally . from a theoretical point of view , the two leading candidate sources are an early generation of stars ( `` mini galaxies '' ) , or massive black holes in small halos ( `` mini quasars '' ) . it is possible to estimate the efficiencies with which objects form in the earliest collapsed halos : from the metals in the ly@xmath6 forest , and from the evolution of the quasar luminosity function at @xmath36 , respectively . however , the uncertainties in these efficiencies are still too large to allow definite predictions . the expected reionization redshift , depending on the type of source , cosmology , power spectrum , and a combination of the efficiency factors , is between @xmath204 in homogeneous models . a further complication is the inhomogeneous nature of reionization : the sources of ionizing radiation are likely clustered , and embedded in complex dense regions , such as the filaments and sheets seen in 3d simulations . at the same time , the gas to be ionized likely has significant density fluctuations . further theoretical progress on the problem will likely come from 3d simulations . such simulations must be able to follow the propagation of a non - spherical ionization front into a medium that has large density fluctuations , as well as opaque clumps of absorbing material . in a homogeneous medium populated by randomly distributed sources , the background radiation would have negligible fluctuations ( e.g. zuo 1992 ) . however , because the density inhomogeneities absorb the uv flux of the ionizing sources , and re - emit diffuse ionizing photons as they recombine , the ionizing background will likely become significantly inhomogeneous and anisotropic ( norman et al . 1998 ) . the first numerical algorithms to deal in full detail with these problems have been proposed by abel , norman & madau ( 1998 ) and razoumov & scott ( 1998 ) ( see also gnedin 1998 ) . the reionization redshift can also be constrained observationally , with a resulting uncertainty that is comparable to the theoretical range : @xmath205 . on both ends of this redshift range , observational progress is likely in the near feature . if new ly@xmath6 emitters are discovered at higher redshifts , this would improve the lower bound . conversely , as the cmb data are collected , the constraint on the electron scattering optical depth will improve , tightening the upper bound . we have seen how the optical depth to thomson - scattering , and hence the epoch of reionization , can be constrained by determining the amount of damping in the cmb temperature anisotropy and by detection of the polarization contribution at very large angular scales . the spatial inhomogeneity of the reionization process gives us a further opportunity to probe in more detail the epoch of reionization . for this probe to become reality , further development of theoretical predictions is required , as well as more sensitive measurements at arc minute and smaller angular scales . fortunately , the inhomogeneity of reionization is unlikely to spoil our ability to interpret the primary cmb anisotropy , to be measured with exquisite precision over the next decade , although this may not be the case if reionization did indeed occur via mini quasars . for the mini galaxy models , even when reionization occurs at the very high end of the allowed redshift range , very little signal is produced at the relevant angular scales . further progress in these predictions is likely to be motivated by the desire to understand the spectrum at @xmath206 as a means of probing the end of the dark ages , rather than at @xmath207 , as a possible contaminant of the primary signal . we are grateful to our collaborators s. dodelson , a. loeb , m. rees , and r. scoccimarro for contributing to our understanding of this subject , to a. jaffe for supplying the `` o - v '' effect curve in fig . [ fig : pspec ] , and to m. norman for supplying fig . zh was supported at fermilab by the doe and the nasa grant nag 5 - 7092 . gnedin , n. y. 1998 , in proc . of 19@xmath208 texas symposium on relativistic astrophysics and cosmology , held in paris , france , dec . 14 - 18 , 1998 , eds . j. paul , t. montmerle , and e. aubourg ( cea saclay ) , in press haiman , z. , & loeb , a. 1998c , invited contribution to the proceedings of 9@xmath208 annual october astrophysics conference , _ after the dark ages : when galaxies were young _ , october 1998 , college park , md , preprint astro - ph/9811395 norman , m. l. , paschos , p. , & abel , t. 1998 , in proc . of _ @xmath209 in the early universe _ , workshop held in florence , italy , eds . e. corbelli , d. galli , and f. palla , memorie della societa astronomica italiana , p. 455 shapiro , p. r. , raga , a. c. , & mellema , g. 1997 , in _ structure and evolution of the igm from qso absorption line systems _ , 13@xmath208 iap colloquium , eds . p. petitjean and s. charlot ( paris : editions frontiere ) , in press , preprint astro - ph/9710210 wadsley , j. w. , hogan , c. j. , anderson , s. f. 1998 , to appear in the proceedings of `` after the dark ages : when galaxies were young ( the universe at @xmath210 ) '' , 9th annual october astrophysics conference in maryland , preprint astro - ph/9812239

the bulk of the hydrogen in the universe transformed from neutral to ionized somewhere in the redshift interval @xmath0 , most likely due to ionizing photons produced by an early generation of stars or mini quasars . the resulting free electrons , interacting with the cmb photons via thomson - scattering , are a mixed blessing , providing both a probe of the epoch of the first stars and a contaminant to the pristine primary anisotropy . here we review our current knowledge of reionization with emphasis on inhomogeneities and describe the possible connections to cmb anisotropy . epsf # 1= 0.8 # 1= 0.7 # 1#2#3#4#5#6#7 to#2 ' '' '' # 1 7.3 in = -0.4 in # 1@xmath1#1 # 1@xmath2 2cm^-2 2cm^2 3cm^-3 3gcm^-3 # 1#1 # 1#23.6pt # 1@xmath3 # 1#1 # 1#1 # 1#1 # 1#1 c 3mp@xmath4 m # 1#23.6pt = cmmib10 u v

1308.5775

physics in extremely high energy regions is particularly of interest to particle physicists . one of the promising idea in the realm of high energy physics is the idea of supersymmetry ( susy ) ( see for instance [ 1 ] and references therein ) . this is a symmetry that relates or mixes ( unites ) fermions and bosons . supersymmetry has the potential to solve some outstanding mysteries in particle physics . one important problem that stands out is called the _ hierarchy problem_. it is believed that the mass of the higgs boson , @xmath2 , is much smaller than the fundamental planck mass , @xmath3 gev/@xmath4 . on the other hand , when we discuss gravity in the context of the quantum field theory , it is expected that there is a minimal measurable length that restricts resolution of adjacent spacetime points up to the planck length . this is actually a common address of all quantum gravity candidates ( see [ 2 ] and references therein ) . incorporation of this idea in quantum field theory provides a theory that is naturally regularized in the ultra - violate regime [ 3,4,5 ] . recently in the context of the doubly special relativity it has been revealed that a test particle s momentum can not be arbitrarily imprecise leading nontrivially to the result that there is a maximal momentum for test particles [ 6 ] . this idea can be explained also through modified dispersion relations as a phenomenological outcome of foam - like structure of spacetime at the planck scale [ 7,8 ] . string theory which has a characteristic scale @xmath5 , is one of the most successful theoretical framework which overcomes the difficulty of ultra - violet divergence in quantum theory of gravity . therefore , if we construct a field theory which captures some stringy nature and/or includes stringy corrections , it would play a pivotal role in investigating physics in high energy regions even near the planck scale . one way to discuss these corrections is deforming the standard heisenberg uncertainty principle to a generalized uncertainty principle ( gup ) . a gup that predicts a minimal observable length can be written as follows @xmath6 this gup leads to the following algebraic structure @xmath7=i\hbar(1+\beta^{2}p^{2})\ ] ] where @xmath8 . if gup is realized in a certain string theory context , @xmath9 takes a value of the order of the string scale , @xmath10 . in the presence of both minimal length and maximal momentum , the gup can be given as follows @xmath11 in this framework the following algebraic structure can be deduced [ 9 ] @xmath12=i\hbar(1-\beta p+2\beta^2 p^2)\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this context , we can define the generalized momentum operator as @xmath13 with these preliminaries , in this paper we construct a quantum theory of free fermion fields based on the deformed heisenberg algebra ( 4 ) . we respect the supersymmetry in this context as a guiding principle . this is because string theory contains this symmetry and it provides a useful tool to understand physics in ultra - violet regime . because of existence of natural cutoffs as minimal length and maximal momentum , the supersymmetry is deformed in this context . from the fermionic part of the system , we propose an action of fermionic field based on the gup in a spacetime with arbitrary number of dimensions . we construct the deformed supersymmetric algebra in this context . finally , we compute some scattering amplitudes such as the pair annihilation amplitude to see how these important quantities can be calculated in the presence of natural cutoffs . we note that experimental limits and the general phenomenology perspective on this issue are not discussed here . one can see ref . [ 10 ] for this purpose . we note also that while the study of susy in relation to gup is a relatively young subject , a bit more has been done for other quantum - spacetime intuitions . for instance , in ref . [ 11 ] the authors have studied the basic twist quantization of @xmath14 and kappa - deformation of @xmath15 superconformal mechanics . the organization of the paper is as follows : in section 2 we construct a scalar field theory based on the gup ( 4 ) . section 3 is devoted to the issue of supersymmetry in the presence of natural cutoffs as minimal length and maximal momentum . in section 4 we compute scattering amplitude of the pair annihilation in the presence of natural cutoffs . the paper follows by a summary and conclusion in section 5 . generalization of the heisenberg algebra to @xmath16-dimensions , where rotational symmetry is preserved and there are both a minimal length and maximal momentum as natural cutoffs , is as follows @xmath17}=i\hbar ( 1-\beta \textbf{p}+2\beta^2 \textbf{p}^2)\delta_{ij } } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath18 and @xmath19 run from @xmath20 to @xmath16 , where in three dimensions @xmath21 that @xmath22 , @xmath23 and @xmath24 are unit vectors of cartesian coordinates and @xmath25 . hereafter , we use indices @xmath18 and @xmath19 for spatial coordinates and @xmath26 and @xmath27 for all spacetime coordinates . now the jacobi identity determines the full algebra of the theory which is given as follows ( see the work by k. nozari and a. etemadi in ref . [ 6 ] ) @xmath17}=i\hbar ( 1-\beta \textbf{p}+2\beta^2 \textbf{p}^2)\delta_{ij } } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath28=0},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath29 = -i \beta \hbar\ ( 4 \beta - \frac{1}{\textbf{p}})\ ( 1 - \beta \textbf{p } + 2\beta^2 \textbf{p}^2)\ \textbf{l}_{ij}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the presence of the @xmath30 is a trace of the existence of the maximal momentum in this setup . note also that eq . ( 9 ) reflects the noncommutative nature of the spacetime manifold in planck scale . here @xmath31 are angular momentum like operators defined as @xmath32 since operators @xmath33 s commute with each other and we have not assumed the existence of a minimal uncertainty in momentum ( see ref . [ 12 ] for possible extension in this regard ) , we can construct our theory in momentum space representation . in momentum space representation , momentum operators are diagonalized simultaneously and we do not distinguish eigenvalues of momentum @xmath34 from operator @xmath35 . in which follows , we set @xmath36 for simplicity . the lagrangian in @xmath37 dimensional spacetime and in the presence of a minimal observable length and a maximal momentum can be written as follows @xmath38\phi(\textbf{p},t)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath39 note that the difference from ordinary quantum field theory is the extra prefactor @xmath40 in the lagrangian . using the bjorken - johnson - low prescription , from behavior of @xmath41-product through the following relations @xmath42 @xmath43 where @xmath44 we obtain @xmath45 = i\hbar(1-\beta \textbf{p}+2\beta^2 \textbf{p}^2 ) \delta(\textbf{p}+\textbf{p}')}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath46 in this relation , @xmath47 where @xmath48 is an arbitrary even function whose explicit form has no influence on the arguments . one can see from equation ( 13 ) that a deformation prefactor , @xmath49 , of heisenberg algebra in the first quantization ( 6 ) also appears in canonical commutation relation of the second quantized field theory . in the fermion field case , we encounter a difficulty in the construction of the second quantized hilbert space which dose not appear in a scalar field system . in which follows we use the idea of supersymmetry to construct a quantized field theory of fermions . in fact , we construct a quantum field theory of fermions , which is consistent with the above scalar field theory , and by using supersymmetry prescription with a minimal length and maximal momentum scale . supersymmetric quantum field theory with minimal length has been studied by shibusa [ 13 ] . in which follows , we generalize the pioneer work of shibusa to the more general case that there are both minimal length and maximal momentum as natural cutoffs . as we have mentioned in the introduction , supersymmetry proposes that to each fermion there exists a boson and vice versa . thus in two and three - dimensional spacetime , a system with a real scalar and a majorana fermion has a special symmetry between a boson and a fermion , namely susy . following ref . [ 13 ] , our notation for two and three - dimensional spacetime is as follows : in those dimensional spacetime ( with signature @xmath50 or @xmath51 ) the lorantz group has a real ( majorana ) two - component spinor representation @xmath52 . for instance , in three - dimensional spacetime , we define a representation of gamma matrices by pauli matrices as follows [ 13 ] : @xmath53 @xmath54 we note that the spinor indices in this case are lowered or raised by charge conjugation matrix @xmath55 and its inverse matrix @xmath56 . the generalized supersymmetric algebra in the presence of a minimal length and a maximal momentum and its action on a scalar field @xmath57 , a majorana fermion @xmath58 and an auxiliary field @xmath59 with parameter @xmath60 is as follows @xmath61=2\upsilon\bar{\epsilon}_1\gamma^a\epsilon_2p_a,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath62 @xmath63 @xmath64\psi(p , t)},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath65 and @xmath66 are functions of gup deformation parameter @xmath9 and momentum . these factors reduce to unity in the limit of @xmath67 and will be determined later by consistency condition . the closeness of algebra requires @xmath68 now the supersymmetric lagrangian can be written as a sum of separate lagrangians , that is , @xmath69 where @xmath70 , @xmath71 and @xmath72 are bosonic , fermionic and auxiliary fields lagrangian respectively . following [ 13 ] , we generalize the lagrangian by introduction of factors @xmath73 , which are functions of deforming parameter @xmath9 and momentum . these functions can be determined as follows . starting with lagrangian @xmath74 where @xmath16 is the number of the spatial coordinates . by integrating out the field @xmath59 , we obtain the lagrangian for the scalar and majorana fields as follows @xmath75 on the other hand , the invariance of the lagrangian ( 21 ) under supersymmetry variation ( 17)-(19 ) in the presence of the minimal length and maximal momentum leads to @xmath76 @xmath77 @xmath78 using the conditions ( 20 ) and ( 23 ) , only @xmath79 and @xmath80 need to be determined . note also that factor @xmath81 can be absorbed into normalization of @xmath59 . in which follows we set @xmath82 for @xmath59 to be an auxiliary field . noether s current for supersymmetric lagrangian ( 22 ) can be calculated and the supersymmetric charge is obtained to be @xmath83 now the hamiltonian of this system can be written as follows @xmath84 using the bjorken - johnson - low prescription , from behaviors of @xmath85-product between fields , as has been explained in the previous section , we obtain canonical relations as follows @xmath86=i{\zeta_1}^{-1}\delta(p+q),}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath87 therefore , the hamiltonian ( 25 ) now can be written as follows @xmath88 where @xmath89 and @xmath90 . there is another condition that can be used to determine @xmath91 and @xmath92 and comes from the free energy of the supersymmetric vacuum . from algebra ( 16 ) , the supersymmetric state has zero energy @xmath93- \frac{1}{4}{tr}_f\ln \big[\zeta_1(e^2+\textbf{p}^2+m^2)\big],}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath94 and @xmath95 represent trace in bosonic and fermionic hilbert space respectively . this relation leads to the following condition @xmath96 finally we can write @xmath97 as one can read from ( 11 ) . thus we have @xmath98 @xmath99 @xmath100 therefore , we have constructed the quantized field of fermions as follows @xmath101 in consequence , the supersymmetric algebra in the presence of both minimal length and maximal momentum is deformed from the usual one as follows @xmath102=2(1-\beta \textbf{p}+2\beta^2 \textbf{p}^2)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\bar{\epsilon}_1\gamma^a\epsilon_2p_a.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] these results can be generalized to higher dimensions easily . finally we note that the lagrangian now takes the following form @xmath103\psi(p , t)\big \}.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we see that in the presence of quantum gravity effects ( as minimal length and maximal momentum ) there is an extra , universal prefactor @xmath104 in comparison with the usual fermion action , regardless of existence or absence of supersymmetry . we note that the major difference between our framework and the formalism presented in ref . [ 13 ] is the difference in the mentioned prefactor . our prefactor contains both minimal length and maximal momentum simultaneously . otherwise , the algebraic structure of the two supersymmetric algebras are the same . in a perturbative expansion one usually refines the calculations using corrections that are becoming smaller and smaller . the reduction in importance is quantified by the power of the perturbation parameter , which is usually the coupling strength . at some point we are adding refinements that are too small to be measured and we know we can stop adding refinements . in a perturbation expansion , the amplitude @xmath105 for a given process can be computed using an expansion of the type [ 14 ] @xmath106 where @xmath107 is the coupling constant . in which follows we are going to see the effect of minimal length and maximal momentum as natural cutoffs on the scattering amplitude of the annihilation - creation process with spin-0 boson . in the presence of just a minimal measurable length as ultra - violet cutoff , momentum generalizes to @xmath108 . so we have @xmath109}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we have discard the remaining delta function which is @xmath110 that @xmath111 are defined in the geometry of the process as shown in figure 1 . simplifying relation ( 38 ) , we find @xmath112 by solving the integral , we obtain @xmath113}\nonumber\\ + \frac{1}{{m_{b}}\beta^{2}}\big[{{\ln(1+\beta p ) } } -\frac{\tanh^{-1}(\frac{2\beta p+1}{\sqrt{4{m_{b}\beta}+1}})}{\sqrt{4{m_{b}\beta}+1 } } -\frac{1}{2}{\ln(\beta^{2}p^{2}+\beta p-{m_{b}}\beta)}\big]\bigg\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the probability for the process to occur is given by @xmath114 . now we calculate the scattering amplitude in the presence of both minimal length and maximal momentum . in this case , @xmath115 and we have @xmath116(1-\beta p+2\beta^2 p^2)}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which can be simplified to find @xmath117 by solving this integral , we find the following result for scattering amplitude in the presence of both minimal length and maximal momentum @xmath118 where by definition @xmath119 is the root of @xmath120 . now the probability for the process to occur in the presence of these natural cutoffs is given by @xmath114 . in this paper we have constructed a quantum theory of free fermion fields based on the deformed heisenberg algebra that contains both a minimal measurable length and a maximal momentum for test particles . our strategy was to respect the supersymmetry in this context as a guiding principle . this is because string theory contains this symmetry and it provides a useful tool to understand physics in ultra - violet regime . due to existence of natural cutoffs as minimal length and maximal momentum , the supersymmetry is deformed in this context . from the fermionic part of the system , we proposed an action of fermionic field based on the gup in a spacetime with arbitrary number of dimensions . we have constructed the deformed supersymmetric algebra in this context . finally , we have computed the scattering amplitude for pair annihilation to see how these important quantities can be calculated in the presence of natural cutoffs as minimal length and maximal momentum . 100 a. bilal , _ introduction to supersymmetry _ , [ arxiv : hep - th/0101055 ] . g. amelino - camelia , _ relativity in space - times with short - distance structure governed by an observer - independent ( planckian ) length scale _ , d * 11 * , 35 ( 2002 ) + g. amelino - camelia , _ doubly special relativity _ , nature * 418 * , 34 ( 2002 ) + g. amelino - camelia , _ doubly - special relativity : first results and key open problems _ , int . d * 11 * , 1643 ( 2002 ) + r. aloisio , a. galante , a. f. grillo , e. luzio and f. mendez , _ approaching space time through velocity in doubly special relativity _ , d * 70 * , 125012 ( 2004 ) + g. amelino - camelia , j. kowalski - glikman , g. mandanici and a. procaccini , _ phenomenology of doubly special relativity _ , int a * 20 * , 6007 ( 2005 ) + k. nozari and a. etemadi , _ minimal length , maximal momentum and hilbert space representation of quantum mechanics _ , phys . d * 85 * , 104029 ( 2012 ) + p. pedram , k. nozari and s. h. taheri , _ the effects of minimal length and maximal momentum on the transition rate of ultra cold neutrons in gravitational field _ , jhep * 1103 * , 093 ( 2011 ) . g. amelino - camelia , d. benedetti , f. dandrea and a. procaccini , _ comparison of relativity theories with observer - independent scales of both velocity and length / mass _ , class . . grav . * 20 * , 5353 ( 2003 ) .

we consider a real scalar field and a majorana fermion field to construct a supersymmetric quantum theory of free fermion fields based on the deformed heisenberg algebra @xmath0=i\hbar\big(1-\beta p+2\beta^{2}p^{2}\big)$ ] , where @xmath1 is a deformation parameter . we present a deformed supersymmetric algebra in the presence of minimal length and maximal momentum . + * key words * : quantum gravity phenomenology , quantum field theory , supersymmetry

1606.00048

protein aggregation is linked to neuro - degenerative afflictions such as alzheimer s and parkinson s disease . @xcite another classic example of a linearly self - assembling system is the polymerization of actin fibrils and microtubules in living cells that help cells to control their mechanics . @xcite it is the importance of the aggregation of proteins in a wider biological context that has motivated many theoreticians and experimentalits to study equilibrium @xcite and kinetic aspects of it . @xcite although decades of theoretical and experimental investigation has contributed to deeper understanding of how proteins self - assemble into polymer - like objects _ in vitro _ , relatively little is known as to what happens _ in vivo _ , that is , at the cellular scale . almost all of the theoretical work is restricted to using deterministic rate equations to study the kinetics of linear self - assembly . even experimentally , studying stochasticity in protein aggregation turns out to be challenging . @xcite this is because given the mesoscopic nature of the biology of the cell , the stochasticity is arguably mainly due to statistical number fluctuations of assemblies of a certain size . as cells are small in volume ( pico litre to femto litre ) , the number of molecules aggregating is also relatively small , that is , on the scale of typical _ in vitro _ experiments , causing fluctuations to play a significant role in the kinetics as well as in equilibrium . the latter expresses itself in large deviations from mean length distributions . @xcite the kinetics of self - assembly of protein monomers into polydisperse polymer - like objects , i.e. , the time evolution of the polymer length distribution , can take place via a host of different molecular pathways . examples include _ monomer addition and removal _ , _ scission and recombination _ , _ secondary nucleation _ and so on , see fig @xcite in principle , all these pathways are active during the time course of aggregation , but the predominance of one or more pathways may depend on the specific chemistry of a particular system . due to the highly nonlinear nature of the dynamical equations that describe these pathways , it is extremely difficult to study the kinetics of even a single pathway analytically , let alone a combination of several of them . to study the _ stochastic _ nature of self - assembly , one would be required to include the effects of thermal noise that might depend on a plethora of rate constants and thermodynamic parameters . @xcite deducing the properties of the noise from microscopic rate equations , i.e. , by making use of the fluctuation - dissipation theorem , is not trivial , again due to the complexity of the involvement of multiple molecular pathways . all of the above - mentioned challenges limits the applicability of analytical tools available to study the kinetics of protein aggregation . @xcite given the challenges and limitations of the rate - equations approach , we study in this work the kinetics of nucleated linear self - assembly using the method of kinetic monte carlo , hereafter referred to as kmc . kmc is a computer simulation technique used to study markov processes . @xcite protein aggregation can be cast in to the form of a markov process , where a monomer becomes a dimer , a dimer becomes a trimer , and so on . this is exactly the same principle on which rate - equation approaches are based upon . the advantage of kmc is that it is inherently stochastic and hence we do not need to know the nature of thermal noise _ a priori_. in fact , the results obtained from this technique can be used to characterise this kind of noise and its dependence on the model parameters . stochastic simulation techniques have been widely employed to study colloidal aggregation kinetics . @xcite colloidal aggregation resembles protein self - assembly closely in terms of the governing rate equations . the characteristic feature of a lag phase present in nucleated self - assembly has also been found in computational studies of reversible colloidal aggregation . @xcite in this paper we explore the stochastic nature of the kinetics of protein polymerization in small volumes , and study the effect of statistical number fluctuations . we study the aggregation kinetics for small volumes not for one pathway but for no fewer than nine of them discussed in more detail in section ii . the pathways we consider are _ end evaporation and addition _ @xcite , _ scission and recombination _ @xcite , _ secondary nucleation _ @xcite , _ two - stage nucleation _ @xcite , and combination thereof . for the _ scission and recombination _ molecular pathway , the forward and backward rate constants in principle depend on the length of the polymer chains . hence , to probe the impact of length - dependent rate constants , we use hill s model . @xcite although hill s model is valid only for long rigid rod like polymers , we neverthless use it to study if any kind of length dependence of the rate constants can alter the scaling of the lag time with system volume . to quantify the stochastic behavior of the polymerization kinetics , we focus specifically on the lag time associated with the time evolution of the polymerized mass fraction . we provide the simulation details in section iii . in section iv , by doing an exhaustive study for various combinations of molecular pathway , we show that the lag time for the polymerized mass fraction is inversely proportional to the system size in the limit of large volumes albeit that there are corrections to that , that do depend on the specific assembly pathway . @xcite finally , in section v , we conclude the article and discuss our main findings . the molecular pathway determines the relevant time scales in reversible polymerization kinetics . @xcite hence , if we are interested in the stochastic kinetics of the protein aggregation , it makes sense to study the system size dependence of a variety of molecular pathways . in this work we choose the most widely accepted and dominant kinetic pathways as far as the study of protein polymerization is concerned . @xcite we focus on ( i ) _ end evaporation and addition _ , ( ii ) _ scission and recombination _ , ( iii ) _ monomer - dependent secondary nucleation _ , and ( iv ) _ two - stage nucleation _ , and combinations of these pathways . in our description , all these reaction pathways have two things in common , which is that they all are nucleated with nucleus size @xmath0 and that they are _ reversible_. primary nucleation is thought of as the coming together of a minimum of @xmath0 monomers to form the smallest stable polymer . of these pathways seemingly the most obvious to consider is that of _ end evaporation and addition _ , given the linear structure of the aggregates of proteins . in it , growth or shrinkage of an aggregate is possible only by adding or removing a single monomer from either end . @xcite although _ end evaporation and addition _ is the most plausible choice to describe the kinetics of the evolution of length distributions of aggregates , fragmentation and recombination of polymers must be important if the self - assembly is nucleated . for a nucleated self - assembling system , the _ end evaporation and addition _ pathway requires each polymer formed to cross a nucleation barrier , which slows down the assembly process significantly . instead , in _ scission and recombination _ kinetics the polymers can bypass the nucleation barrier by breaking already existing filaments and creating new nucleation centers that then can grow . hence , it is sensible to study scission - recombination in combination with end evaporation and addition , which is why this is one of the combined schemes that we investigate . the forward and backward rate constants for all pathways could be length dependent , in particular for the scission - recombination pathway . indeed , shorter polymers should recombine faster than longer ones if the reaction is diffusion limited , and longer ones plausibly have a higher probability of breaking within a certain amount of time than shorter ones . we do take into account the length dependence of the rate constants for the _ scission and recombination _ pathway by invoking hill s rate constants . @xcite hill derived the forward and backward rate constants in the limit of diffusion - limited aggregation that are valid only for long rigid rods . hill s rate constants are not entirely consistent with the thermodynamics of nucleated self - assembly , and alternative ones have been derived in the context of the radical polymerization with more accurate length dependent rate constants these seem to suffer from the same problem . @xcite as our aim is to find out if any kind of length dependence of the rate constants alters the dominant scaling of the lag time as a function of system volume , we make an arbitrary choice of using hill s model . we study both kinds of scission - recombination pathway , i.e. , with and without length dependence of the rate constants . the pathways of _ end evaporation and addition _ and of _ scission and recombination _ have proven to apply to the polymerisation of actin and tubulin filaments , but the time scales obtained from these pathways can not explain other types of protein aggregation , such as that of sickle hemoglobin . @xcite sickle cell hemoglobin shows relatively rapid polymerization kinetics in comparison to predictions from _ end evaporation and addition _ and _ scission and recombination _ kinetics . to successfully explain the rapid polymerization observed in sickle cell hemoglobin , surface - catalysed or secondary nucleation has been included in several studies . @xcite secondary nucleation is also found to be relevant in the context of amyloid fibrillation . @xcite recalling that primary nucleation concerns the conversion of a cluster of monomers into a stable polymer of shortest length , @xcite in secondary nucleation a critical number @xmath0 of monomers may first form an unstable cluster that next transforms into a stable cluster , which in turn facilitates the elongation process . clearly , molecules may polymerize via a combination of molecular pathways . in this work we perform an exhaustive study of stochastic aggregation kinetics allowing for several combinations of pathway , and study how the resulting kinetics are affected by the system size . the pathways we study are listed in table i. mathematically , reversible polymerization can be represented by an infinite set of rate equations for all allowed chemical reactions . indeed , a monomer reacts with a monomer to form a dimer , a dimer reacts with a monomer to form a trimer and so on . let us first translate each pathway of table i into a set of chemical reactions and write the corresponding rate equation for the polymers as state given the present state @xmath1 & reaction rate + primary nucleation & & .possible molecular aggregation steps by which a polymer length distribution can change , considered in this work . assuming the present state to be @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the number of monomers and @xmath4 the number of polymers of length @xmath5 , the states following the corresponding reactions are indicated . notice that for secondary nucleation we do not have a backward reaction . this is because @xmath6 is a polymer of size greater than the stable nucleus of size @xmath0 , that then can disintegrate via monomer removal or scission . also note that for two - stage nucleation we also have to track the evolution of unstable aggregate @xmath7 . [ cols="^ " , ] & 0.02 + in this work we study by means of kinetic monte carlo simulation the stochastic nature of nucleated linearly self - assembling molecular building blocks in dilute solution . one of the models that we invoke is the thermodynamically consistent _ end evaporation and addition _ , also known as the oosawa model for self - assembly . @xcite another also includes _ scission and recombination _ , with and without allowing for explicit length dependent rate constants . @xcite we in addition allow for ( i ) monomolecular primary nucleation , ( ii ) bimolecular primary nucleation , ( iii ) secondary nucleation of monomers on already existing fibers and ( iv ) two - stage nucleation . @xcite in combination , nine different sets of pathways are studied . we show that irrespective of the combination of pathways we study , to leading order the stochastic component of the lag time is inversely proportional to the system volume . this scaling remains unchanged even when hill s length dependent rate constants , valid for rigid long polymer chains , are adapted in kinetic pathways . the first order correction that depends logarithmically on the volume turns out strongly pathway dependent . by comparing our lag time with the corresponding nucleation time to form the first nucleus , we show that for all tested pathways the stochastic component of the lag time must be a combination of a nucleation time and an elongation time . the nucleation time , unlike the lag time , is rather precisely inversely proportional to the system volume . we find it to be exponentially distributed for all system volumes , which is not the case for the lag time . the elongation time , on the other hand , strongly depends on whether the pathway involves only _ end evaporation and addition _ or in addition _ scission and recombination _ kinetics . this leads us to infer that a contribution from the elongation time is the cause of the non - universal correction to the leading order stochastic lag time . finally , we find that in the thermodynamic limit the mean lag time is non - zero whilst the mean nucleation time seems to vanish . consequently , for linearly self - assembling systems , the rate limiting step in the lag phase in that limit must be found in the elongation phase , not in the nucleation phase . we thank thomas michaels ( university of cambridge ) for stimulating discussions . this work was supported by the nederlandse organisatie voor wetenschappelijk onderzoek through project no . we invoke the gillespie algorithm to simulate our system of linearly self - assembling particles . @xcite let us consider a state of the system as @xmath8 , where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are the numbers of monomers and of polymer of length @xmath9 respectively . the self - assembly as described by the molecular aggregation pathways shown in table i , can be seen as a markov process . in a markov process the transition from the current state to the next state via one of the reactions shown in table i depends on the current state of the system , and not on the states before that . as a first step towards implementing the gillespie algorithm to study reaction kinetics is to list out all the possible reactions , given the current state of the system with their corresponding reaction rates . given the current state of the system @xmath8 , the gillespie algorithm in essence requires two quantities : i ) from all possible reactions listed in table i , given the current state of the system , determine the next reaction that is going to take place in the time bracket from @xmath10 to @xmath11 . ii ) calculate @xmath12 the time that one of the reactions from table i will happen for the first time . to find next possible reaction , we first have to transform the reaction rates for each reaction of table i into the corresponding probability . let us define the rate to leave the present state , i.e. , @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the reaction rate for each individual reaction @xmath15 . the probability of reaction @xmath15 with reaction rate @xmath14 is given by @xmath16 . next , we generate a uniformly distributed random number , @xmath17 , in the interval @xmath18 and find the next possible reaction @xmath15 , such that , @xmath19 , where @xmath15 is the reaction that is going to happen next . the second quantity , i.e. , the time @xmath12 for next reaction to happen turns out to be exponentially distributed , typical of first passage processes . @xcite this then by simple transformation can be related to a uniform distribution . to calculate @xmath12 we can then generate a uniformly distributed random number @xmath20 , in the interval @xmath18 and using the relation @xmath21 . this way , at every instance we know the next micro - state of the system and the time it will take for transition from the current to the next state of the system . this combination gives us the time evolution of the length distribution of the polymer self - assembly . by generating appropriate random numbers we also take into account the stochasticity coming from the mesoscopic number fluctuations . hence , the gillespie algorithm provides us with a tool to study stochastic kinetics arising from the reaction rate kinetics of self - assembling systems . we obtain closed - form differential equations for the first two moments of a generalized pathway consisting of _ primary nucleation _ , _ end evaporation and addition _ and _ scission and recombination_. similar equations have also been obtained previously by michaels and knowles . @xcite using eq . ( 1 ) for the special case of length independent scission and recombination rate constants , we obtain for the polymers & = & 2 k_e^+ x(t ) y_i-1(t ) - 2 k_e^+ x(t ) y_i(t ) + 2 k_e^- y_i+1(t ) - 2 k_e^- y_i(t ) - k_f^- ( i- 2 n_c + 1 ) y_i(t ) + & + & 2 k_f^- _ j = i+n_c^ y_j(t ) + k_f^+ _ k+l = i y_k(t ) y_l(t ) - 2 k_f^+ y_i ( t ) _ j = n_c^ y_j + k_n^+ x(t)^n_c _ i , n_c , and for the monomers = - ( _ i = n_c^ i y_i(t ) ) . note the factor of @xmath22 in the fifth term on the right hand side , accounts for the number of bonds allowed to break so that the fragmenting filaments are larger than @xmath0 . next , we define first two moments of the full length distribution as p(t)=_i = n_c^ y_i(t ) m(t)=_i = n_c^ i y_i(t ) , where , @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the number of polymers and the polymerized monomeric mass respectively . upon rearranging terms , we can write the time - evolution equation for @xmath23 as & = & 2 k_e^+ x(t ) _ i = n_c^ + 2 k_e^- _ i = n_c^ - k_f^- _ i = n_c^ ( i- 2 n_c + 1 ) y_i ( t ) + & & + 2 k_f^- _ i = n_c^ _ j = i+nc^ y_j + k_f^+ _ i = n_c^ _ k+l = i^ y_k(t ) y_l(t ) - 2 k_f^+ _ i = n_c^ y_i ( t ) _ j = n_c^ y_j ( t ) + k_n x(t)^n_c _ i = n_c^ _ i , n_c . note that the first and second term on the right hand side of eq . ( b4 ) , coming from end evaporation and addition , cancel each other and hence do not contribute to the dynamics or equilibrium of first moment , @xmath25 . next , we rewrite the third and the fourth term , coming from polymer scission , in terms of the theta function , & & - _ i = n_c^ ( i- 2 n_c + 1 ) y_i(t ) + 2 _ i = n_c^ _ j = n_c^ y_j(t ) ( i - j - n_c ) + & = & m(t)-(2 n_c -1 ) p(t ) . the contribution from polymer recombination , represented by terms five and six , can be written as , & & _ i = n_c^ _ k+l = i^ y_k(t ) y_l(t ) - 2 _ i = n_c^ y_i(t ) _ j = n_c^ y_j(t ) + & = & _ k = n_c^ _ l = n_c^ y_k(t ) y_l(t ) - 2 _ i = n_c^ y_i(t ) _ j = n_c^ y_j(t ) + & = & -p(t)^2 . the dynamical equation for total polymerized mass , @xmath24 , can be obtained by multiplying eq . ( b1 ) by @xmath9 and summing over it , & = & 2 k_e^+ x(t ) _ i = n_c^ i + 2 k_e^- _ i = n_c^ i - k_f^- _ i = n_c^ i ( i- 2 n_c + 1 ) y_i ( t ) + & & + 2 k_f^- _ i = n_c^ _ j = i+nc^ i y_j(t ) + k_f^+ _ i = n_c^ _ k+l = i^ i y_k(t ) y_l(t ) - 2 k_f^+ _ i = n_c^ i y_i ( t ) _ j = n_c^ y_j ( t ) + k_n^+ x(t)^n_c _ i = n_c^ i _ i , n_c . here , the first term , associated with elongation , can be simplified to x(t ) _ i = n_c^ i [ y_i-1(t)-y_i(t ) = _ i = n_c-1^ ( i+1 ) y_i(t ) - _ i = n_c^ i y_i(t ) = p(t ) , and the second ( evaporation ) term gives _ i = n_c^ i = _ i = n_c+1^ ( i-1 ) y_i ( t)- _ i = n_c^ i y_i(t ) = -p(t ) - n_c y_n_c(t ) . here , we neglect the contribution , @xmath26 , and obtain dynamical equation for second moment , @xmath24 . we can safely neglect the term @xmath26 , because for sufficiently cooperative self - assembly , the number of nuclei are really small in comparison with the total number of polymers @xmath23 . using a similar algebraic manipulation as we did in eqs . ( b5 ) and ( b6 ) , we find that the terms originating from scission and recombination in eq . ( b7 ) vanish . this is to be expected , as we apply the scission and recombination pathway to the polymers only . again , @xmath27 and @xmath28 can not influence the exchange of material between polymers and monomers . this leads us to the dynamical equations for the first two moments of the length distribution , & = & - k_f^+ p(t)^2 + k_f^- ( m(t)-(2 n_c -1 ) p(t ) ) + k_n x(t)^n_c + & = & 2 ( x(t ) k_e^+ p(t ) - k_e^- p(t ) ) + n_c k_n^+ x(t)^n_c . analytical solution of the above equations has eluded us and hence we resort to a numerical evaluation , the results of which we compare in fig . ( 6 ) with those from our monte carlo simulations . for a comparison we took a system volume of @xmath29pl , which is very much larger than the volumes at which we see stochastic behavior . stochastic behavior we find for our set of parameters to occur at volumes below approximately below @xmath30pl . ( 1 ) . m. takalo , a. salminen , h. soininen , m. hiltunen and a. haapasalo , am . j. neurodegener . , 2 , 1 - 14 ( 2013 ) . l. blanchoin , r. b. paterski , c. sykes and j. plastino , physiol . rev . 94 , 235 - 263 ( 2014 ) . d. boal , _ mechanics of the cell _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge 2002 ) a. ciferri ( ed . ) , _ supramolecular polymers _ , 2nd edition ( taylor and frances , boca raton , 2005 ) s. katen and a. zlotnick , methods enzymol . , 455 , 395 - 417 ( 2009 ) c. m. marques , m. s. turner and m. e. cates , journal of non - crystalline solids , 172 - 173 , 1168 - 1172 ( 1994 ) . f. oosawa and s. asakura , _ thermodynamics of the polymerization of protein _ ( academic press , new york , 1975 ) . s. i. a. cohen , m. vendruscolo , c. m. dobson , e. m. terentjev , and t. p. j. knowles , j. chem . 135 , 065105 ( 2011 ) . z. cao and f. a. ferrone , biophysical j. , 72 , 343 - 352 ( 1997 ) . t. p. j. knowles , d. a. white , a. r. abate , j. j. agresti , s. i. a. cohen , r. a. sperling , e. j. de genst , c. m. dobson and d. a. weitz , pnas , 108 , 14746 - 14751 ( 2011 ) . j. c. wheeler and p. pfeuty , phys . a , 24 , 1050 - 1061 ( 1981 ) . m. e. cates and s. j. candau , j. phys . condens . matter , 2 , 6869 - 6892 ( 1990 ) . m. e. cates , macromolecules , 20 , 2289 - 2296 ( 1987 ) . m. s. turner and m. e. cates , j.phys.france , 51 , 307 - 316 ( 1990 ) . c. m. marques , m. s. turner and m. e. cates , j. chem . phys . , 99 , 7260 ( 1993 ) . d. t. gillespie , j. phys . , 81 ( 25 ) , 2340 - 2361 ( 1977 ) . m. s. turner , c. marques and m. e. cates , langmuir , 9 , 695 - 701 ( 1993 ) . g. a. garcia , s. i. a. cohen , c. m. dobson and t. p. j. knowles , phys . e , 89 , 032712 ( 2014 ) a. szabo , j. mol . bio . , 199 , 539 - 542 ( 1988 ) . j. szavits - nossan , k. edem , r. j. morris , c. e. macphee , m. r. evans and r. j. allen , phys . 113 , 098101 ( 2014 ) . m. thorn and m. seesselberg , phys . 72 , 3622 ( 1994 ) . m. thorn , m. l. broide and m. seesselberg , phys . e , 51 , 4089 ( 1995 ) . g. odriozola , a. moncho - jorda , a. schmitt , j. callejas - fernandez , r. martinez - garcia and r. hidalgo - alvarez , europhys . 53 , 797 ( 2001 ) . g. odriozola , a. schmitt , a. moncho - jorda , j. callejas - fernandez , r. martinez - garcia , r. leone and r. hidalgo - alvarez , phys . e , 65 , 031405 ( 2002 ) . a. m. puertas and g. odriozola , j. phys . b , 111 , 5564 ( 2007 ) . t. l. hill , j. , 44 , 285 - 288 ( 1983 ) . m. buback and g. t. russell , _ encyclopedia of radicals in chemistry , biology and materials _ , john wiley & sons , ltd , ( 2012 ) a. n. nikitin and a. v. evseev , macromol . theory simul . , 8 , 296308 ( 1999 ) j. hofrichter , p. d. ross , and w. a. eaton , proc . , 71 , 4864 ( 1974 ) . m. f. bishop and f. a. ferrone , biophys . , j. 46 , 631 ( 1984 ) . f. a. ferrone , j. hofrichter , and w. a. eaton , j. mol . 183 , 611 ( 1985 ) . f. a. ferrone , j. hofrichter , h. r. sunshine , and w. a. eaton , biophys . j. , 32 , 361 ( 1980 ) . a. m. ruschak and a. d. miranker , proc . 104 , 12341 ( 2007 ) . n. cremades , s. i. a. cohen , e. deas , a. y. abramov , a. y. chen , a. orte , m. sandal , r. w. clarke , p. dunne , f. a. aprile , c. w. bertoncini , n. w. wood , t. p. j. knowles , c. m. dobson , and d. klenerman , cell 149 , 1048 ( 2012 ) . j. lee , e. k. culyba , e. t. powers , and j. w. kelly , nat . biol . 7 , 602 ( 2011 ) . a. vitalis and r. v. pappu , biophys . 159 , 14 ( 2011 ) . f. mavelli and m. maestro , j. chem . phys . , 111 , 4310 ( 1999 ) . t. poschel , n. v. brilliantov and c. frommel , biophys . j. , 85 , 3460 - 3474 ( 2003 ) . the python codes implementing the reaction schemes discussed in the main text , are available upon request . l. hong and w. yong , biophys . j. , 104 , 533 - 540 ( 2013 ) . p. arosio , t. p. j. knowles and s. linse , phys . , 17 , 7606 - 7618 ( 2015 ) . e. hellstrand , b. boland , d. m. walsh , and s. linse , acs chem . neurosci . , 1 , 13 - 18 ( 2010 ) . a. m. morris , m. a. watzky and r. g. finke , biochim biophys acta , 1794(3 ) , 375 - 97 ( 2009 ) . r. yvinec , m. r. dorsogna , and t. chou , j. chem . phys . , 137 , 244107 ( 2012 ) . n. g. van kampen , _ stochastic processes in physics and chemistry _ ( north - holland , amsterdam , 1981 ) . t. c. t. michaels and t. p. j. knowles , int . b , 29 ( 2 ) ( 2015 )

protein aggregation is of great importance in biology , e.g. , in amyloid fibrillation . the aggregation processes that occur at the cellular scale must be highly stochastic in nature because of the statistical number fluctuations that arise on account of the small system size at the cellular scale . we study the nucleated reversible self - assembly of monomeric building blocks into polymer - like aggregates using the method of kinetic monte carlo . kinetic monte carlo , being inherently stochastic , allows us to study the impact of fluctuations on the polymerisation reactions . one of the most important characteristic features in this kind of problem is the existence of a lag phase before self - assembly takes off , which is what we focus attention on . we study the associated lag time as a function of the system size and kinetic pathway . we find that the leading order stochastic contribution to the lag time before polymerisation commences is inversely proportional to the system volume for large - enough system size for all nine reaction pathways tested . finite - size corrections to this do depend on the kinetic pathway .