Datasets:

giuliadc

/

arxiv-filtered-978rows

like 0

1402.3066

justification logic is a family of logics of justified beliefs . where epistemic modal logic treats formulas of the form @xmath1 with the intended meaning that an agent knows / believes @xmath2 , in justification logic we consider formulas of the form @xmath3 with the intended meaning that @xmath4 is a justification for @xmath2 - or that the agent has justification @xmath4 for @xmath2 . the first justification logic was lp , the logic of proofs , and appeared in @xcite by artemov , but it has since developed in a wide system of explicit epistemic logics with notable complexity properties that significantly differ from the corresponding modal logics : while every single - agent justification logic whose complexity has been studied has its derivability problem in @xmath5 ( the second level of the polynomial hierarchy ) , the corresponding modal logics have -complete derivability problems . furthermore certain significant fragments of these justification logics have an even lower complexity- , or even in some cases . for an overview of justification logic see @xcite . for an overview of complexity results of ( single - agent ) justification logic , see @xcite . in epistemic situations we often have multiple agents , so as it is the case with modal logic , there is a need for a multi - agent justification logic . in @xcite , yavorskaya presents two - agent variations of lp . these logics feature interactions between the two agents justifications : for @xmath6 , for instance , every justification for agent 1 can be converted to a justification for agent 2 for the same fact and we have the axiom @xmath7 , while @xmath8 comes with the extra axiom @xmath9 , so agent 2 is aware of agent 1 s justifications . in @xcite , we extended yavorskaya s logics to two - agent variations of other justification logics , as well as to combinations of two different justification logics . we then gave tableau procedures to prove that most of these logics were in the second step of the polynomial hierarchy , an expected result which mimics the ones for single - agent justification logics from @xcite . for some cases , however , we were able to prove -completeness , which was a new phenomenon for justification logic . in this paper we continue our work from @xcite . we provide a general family of multi - agent logics . each member of this family we call @xmath10 , where @xmath11 are parameters of the logic . for @xmath10 we consider @xmath12 agents and the interactions between the agents justifications are described by binary relations on agents , @xmath13 and @xmath14 . furthermore , not all agents are equally reliable : @xmath15 and @xmath16 are sets of agents , all agents in @xmath15 have consistent beliefs and all agents in @xmath16 have true beliefs . these concepts are made precise in section [ multidefinitions ] . it is our goal to provide a flexible system capable of modelling situations of many diverse agents , or diverse types of justifications , allowing for reasonably general interactions among their justifications . for this family of logics we provide semantics and a general tableau procedure and then we make observations on the complexity of the derivation problem for its members . in particular , we demonstrate that all logics in this family have their satisfiability problem in - under reasonable assumptions . this family demonstrates significant variety , as it also includes - and -complete members , while of course some of its members have their satisfiability problem in @xmath17 . this is a somewhat surprising result , as all single - agent justification logics whose complexity is known have their satisfiability problem in @xmath17 . this paper is organised as follows . in section [ multidefinitions ] , we give the base definitions of the syntax , axioms and semantics for each logic in the family . then we reintroduce the star calculus , an invaluable tool , and our first complexity results , mirroring the ones for single - agent justification logic ( see @xcite ) . the version of the star calculus we provide is somewhat different than the usual ones in that it is based on a given frame . if the frame includes a single world , we get the usual , more familiar version . in section [ tableaux ] we give general tableau rules for each of our logics . naturally , the rules are parameterized by the logic s parameters , including the interactions between the agents , so special attention is given in that section to these interactions . we then go on and further optimize the tableau procedure with respect to the number of world - prefixes it produces ; this results in a @xmath17 upper bound for the satisfiability of a general class of logics . in this section we present the system we study in this paper , its semantics and the basic tools we will need later on . most of the proofs for the claims here can be adjusted from the one- or two- agent versions of justification logic . the reader can see @xcite or @xcite for an overview of single - agent justification logic and @xcite for a two - agent version of this system . in this paper , if @xmath18 , @xmath19 $ ] will be the set @xmath20 . for every @xmath21 , the justification terms of the language @xmath22 will include all constants @xmath23 and variables @xmath24 and if @xmath25 and @xmath26 are terms , then the following are also terms : @xmath27 , [ t_1\cdot t_2 ] , ! t_1 $ ] . the set of terms will be referred to as @xmath28 . we also use a set @xmath29 of propositional variables , or sentence letters . these will usually be @xmath30 . formulas of the language @xmath22 include all propositional variables and if @xmath31 are formulas , @xmath32 $ ] and @xmath4 is a term , then the following are also formulas of @xmath22 : @xmath33 . the remaining propositional connectives , whenever needed , are treated as constructed from @xmath34 and @xmath35 in the usual way . the operators @xmath36 and @xmath37 are explained by the following axioms . intuitively , @xmath38 applies a justification for a statement @xmath39 to a justification for @xmath40 and gives a justification for @xmath41 . using @xmath42 we can combine two justifications and have a justification for anything that can be justified by any of the two initial terms - much like the concatenation of two proofs . finally , @xmath37 is a unary operator called the proof checker . given a justification @xmath4 for @xmath2 , @xmath43 justifies the fact that @xmath4 is a justification for @xmath2 . let @xmath18 , @xmath44 $ ] and @xmath45^{2}$ ] . the logic @xmath46 is the logic with modus ponens as a derivation rule and the following axioms : propositional axioms : : : finitely many schemes of classical propositional logic ; application : : : @xmath47 \colon_{i } \ ! } \psi)$ ] ; concatenation : : : @xmath48 \colon_{i } \ ! } \phi$ ] , @xmath49 \colon_{i } \ ! } \phi$ ] ; @xmath16-factivity : : : for every @xmath50 , @xmath51 ; @xmath15-consistency : : : for every @xmath52 , @xmath53 ; @xmath13-verification : : : for every @xmath54 , @xmath55 ; @xmath14-conversion : : : for every @xmath56 , @xmath57 , where in the above , @xmath2 and @xmath58 are formulas in @xmath22 , @xmath59 are terms and @xmath60 $ ] . @xmath16-factivity and @xmath15-consistency are the usual factivity and consistency axioms for every agent in @xmath16 and @xmath15 respectively . positive introspection is seen as a special case of @xmath13-verification - in this context , if agent @xmath61 has positive introspection , then @xmath62 . a constant specification for @xmath63 is any set @xmath64\}.\ ] ] we say that axiom @xmath40 is justified by a constant @xmath65 for agent @xmath61 , when @xmath66 . a constant specification is : _ axiomatically appropriate with respect to @xmath67 $ ] _ if for every @xmath68 , each axiom is justified by at least one constant , _ schematic _ if every constant justifies only a certain number of schemes from the ones above ( as a result , if @xmath65 justifies @xmath40 for @xmath61 and @xmath41 results from @xmath40 and substitution , then @xmath65 justifies @xmath41 for @xmath61 ) and _ schematically injective _ if it is schematic and every constant justifies at most one scheme . let @xmath69 be the smallest set such that @xmath70 and for every @xmath71 , it is the case that for every @xmath72 $ ] , @xmath73 . @xmath74 is @xmath75 , where @xmath76 just outputs all elements of @xmath69 . @xmath77 is consistent : just map each formula to the propositional formula that is the result of removing all terms from the original one ; then , all axioms are mapped to propositional tautologies and modus ponens preserves this mapping . we now introduce models for our logic . in the single - agent cases , m - models ( introduced in @xcite ) and f - models ( introduced in @xcite ) are used ( also in @xcite for two - agent logics ) and they are both important in the study of complexity issues . in this paper we are mostly interested in f - models , which we will usually just call models . these are essentially kripke models with an additional machinery to accommodate justification terms . let @xmath78 . then , an f - model @xmath79 for @xmath80 is a quadruple @xmath81 } , ( { { \mathcal{a}}}_i)_{i \in [ n]},{\mathcal{v}})$ ] , where @xmath82 is a set , for every @xmath83 $ ] , @xmath84 is a binary relation on @xmath85 , @xmath86 and for every @xmath83 $ ] , @xmath87 . @xmath85 is called the _ universe _ of @xmath79 and its elements are the worlds or states of the model . @xmath88 assigns a subset of @xmath85 to each propositional variable , @xmath89 , and @xmath90 assigns a subset of @xmath85 to each pair of a justification term and a formula . furthermore , @xmath91}$ ] will often be seen and referred to as @xmath92\times tm \times l_n { \longrightarrow}2^{w}$ ] and @xmath93 is called an admissible evidence function . additionally , @xmath93 must satisfy the following conditions : application closure : for any @xmath83 $ ] , formulas @xmath31 , and justification terms @xmath94 , + @xmath95 sum closure : for any @xmath83 $ ] , formula @xmath2 , and justification terms @xmath94 , + @xmath96 @xmath97-closure : for any formula @xmath71 , @xmath98 . @xmath13-verification closure : if @xmath54 , then @xmath99 @xmath14-conversion closure : if @xmath56 , then @xmath100 @xmath13-distribution : for any formula @xmath2 , justification term @xmath4 , @xmath54 and @xmath101 , if @xmath102 and @xmath103 , then @xmath104 . the accessibility relations , @xmath105 , must satisfy the following conditions : * if @xmath106 , then @xmath105 must be reflexive . * if @xmath107 , then @xmath105 must be serial ( @xmath108 ) . * if @xmath109 , then for any @xmath110 , if @xmath111 , we also have @xmath112 . has positive introspection ( i.e. @xmath113 ) , then @xmath105 is transitive . ] * for any @xmath56 , @xmath114 . truth in the model is defined in the following way , given a state @xmath115 : * @xmath116 and if @xmath89 is a propositional variable , then @xmath117 iff @xmath118 . * if @xmath31 are formulas , then @xmath119 if and only if @xmath120 , or @xmath121 . * if @xmath2 is a formula and @xmath4 a term , then @xmath122 if and only if @xmath103 and @xmath123 for all @xmath124 such that @xmath125 . a formula @xmath126 is called satisfiable if there are some @xmath127 ; we then say that @xmath79 satisfies @xmath2 in @xmath115 . if @xmath97 is axiomatically appropriate with respect to @xmath15 , then @xmath77 is sound and complete with respect to its models ; it is also sound and complete with respect to its models that have the _ strong evidence property : _ @xmath122 iff @xmath128 _ _ ; furthermore , if @xmath2 is satisfiable , then it is satisfied by a model @xmath79 of at most @xmath129 states - and in fact , it is satisfied by a model @xmath79 of at most @xmath129 states that has the strong evidence property ( see @xcite for proofs of all the above that can be easily adjusted for this general case ) . a pair @xmath130})$ ] as above is called a frame for @xmath77 . we present the @xmath131-calculi for @xmath77 . the @xmath131-calculi for the single - agent justification logics have proven to be an invaluable tool in the study of the complexity of these logics . this concept and results were adapted to the two - agent setting in @xcite and here we extend them to the general multi - agent setting . although the calculi have significant similarities to the ones of the single - agent justification logics , there are differences , notably that each calculus depends upon a frame and operates upon @xmath131-expressions ( defined below ) prefixed by states of the frame . a @xmath131-calculus was first introduced in @xcite , but its origins can be found in @xcite . if @xmath4 is a term , @xmath2 is a formula , and @xmath83 $ ] , then @xmath132 is a star - expression ( @xmath131-expression ) . given a frame @xmath133})$ ] and @xmath134 ^ 2 $ ] and constant specification @xmath97 , the @xmath135 calculus on the frame @xmath136 is a calculus on @xmath131-expressions prefixed by worlds from @xmath85 with the axioms and rules that are shown in figure [ fig : starcalc ] . + [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] notice that the calculus rules correspond to the closure conditions of the admissible evidence functions . in fact and because of this , given a frame @xmath137 and a set @xmath138 of @xmath131-expressions prefixed by states of the frame , the function @xmath93 such that @xmath139 is an admissible evidence function and in fact it is the minimal admissible evidence function such that for every @xmath140 , @xmath141 in the sense that always @xmath142 for any other admissible evidence function @xmath143 such that for every @xmath140 , @xmath144 . therefore , given a frame @xmath137 and two set @xmath145 of @xmath131-expressions prefixed by states of the frame there is an admissible evidence function @xmath93 on @xmath146 such that for every @xmath147 , @xmath141 and for every @xmath148 , @xmath149 , if and only if there is no @xmath150 such that @xmath151 . this observation yields the following . [ prp : proofbystarcalc ] for any holds , but to prove it we need to introduce m - models , but we do not use m - models anywhere else . thus , the reader can see @xcite , or @xcite for a proof of proposition [ prp : proofbystarcalc ] for all constant specifications . ] constant specification @xmath97 , frame @xmath146 with universe @xmath85 and @xmath152 , @xmath153 . [ thm : calccompnew ] let @xmath154 be a schematic constant specification in @xmath155 and @xmath134 ^ 2 $ ] . then , the following problem is in @xmath156 : given a finite frame @xmath157})$ ] and a finite set @xmath138 of @xmath131-expressions prefixed by worlds from @xmath85 , a formula @xmath2 , a term @xmath4 , a @xmath158 and @xmath32 $ ] , is it the case that @xmath159 the proof of this proposition is very similar to the one that can be found in @xcite . what is different here is the additional assignment of a state set to each node of the derivation tree , which does not change things a lot . for this proof and every @xmath160 $ ] , let @xmath161 , s.t . for every @xmath162 , @xmath163 . * nondeterministically construct a rooted tree with pairs of the form @xmath164 , where @xmath160 $ ] and @xmath165 is a subterm of @xmath4 , as nodes , such that @xmath166 is the root and the following conditions are met . node @xmath164 can be the parent of @xmath167 or of both @xmath167 and @xmath168 as long as there is a rule @xmath169 or @xmath170 , respectively , of the @xmath131-calculus and as long as @xmath171 . to keep this structure a tree , we can ensure at this step that there are no cycles , which would correspond to consecutive applications of @xmath131c@xmath172 and which would be redundant . * nondeterministically assign to each leaf , @xmath173 , either * * some formula @xmath58 and the closure under @xmath174 of some set @xmath175 , s.t . for every @xmath176 , @xmath177 or , * * as long as @xmath178 is of the form @xmath179 , where @xmath65 a constant , @xmath180 , then we can also assign some @xmath181 and @xmath182 , where @xmath40 an axiom scheme , s.t . @xmath183 . * if for some node @xmath184 all its children , say @xmath185 have been assigned some scheme or formula @xmath186 and world sets @xmath187 , assign to @xmath188 some scheme or formula @xmath189 , such that @xmath190 can be unified to @xmath191 such that @xmath192 is a rule in the @xmath193-calculus and world set @xmath13 , where @xmath13 is the closure of @xmath194 under @xmath174 . apply this step until the root of the tree has been assigned some scheme or formula and a @xmath195 subset of @xmath85 . * unify @xmath2 with the formula assigned to @xmath166 and verify that @xmath196 if some step is impossible , the algorithm rejects . otherwise , it accepts . using efficient representations of schemes using dags and robinson s unification algorithm , the algorithm runs in polynomial time . we can see that as the tree is constructed , if @xmath197 is assigned scheme @xmath189 and set @xmath13 , then the construction effectively describes a valid derivation of any expression of the form @xmath198 , where @xmath199 and @xmath58 an instance of @xmath189 . therefore , if the algorithm accepts , there exists a valid @xmath200-calculus derivation of @xmath201 . on the other hand if there is some @xmath200-calculus derivation for @xmath202 from @xmath138 , then the algorithm in the first two steps can essentially describe this derivation by producing the derivation tree and the formulas / schemes by which the derivation starts . therefore , the algorithm accepts if and only if there is a @xmath200-calculus derivation for @xmath202 from @xmath138 . see @xcite and @xcite for a more detailed analysis . the number of nondeterministic choices made by the algorithm in the proof of proposition [ thm : calccompnew ] is bounded by @xmath203 , where @xmath204 . therefore , if there is some formula @xmath58 such that @xmath205 is a subformula of @xmath58 and for every @xmath206 , @xmath207 is a subformula of @xmath58 , then @xmath208 and therefore we can simulate all nondeterministic choices in time @xmath209 . thus the algorithm can be turned into a deterministic one running in time @xmath210 . this observation , the fact that a satisfiable @xmath2 can be satisfied by a model of at most @xmath129 states ( see the previous subsection ) and the previous two propositions give the following results : let @xmath211 , where @xmath212 is schematic . then , 1 . deciding for @xmath205 that @xmath213 is in . 2 . if @xmath97 is axiomatically appropriate with respect to @xmath15 , then the satisfiability problem for @xmath80 is in . additionally notice that if the term @xmath4 has no @xmath42 , @xmath97 is schematically injective and @xmath214 , we have essentially eliminated nondeterministic choices from the procedure above . thus , we conclude ( for the original result , see @xcite ) : let @xmath211 , where @xmath212 is schematically injective . then , deciding for @xmath205 , where @xmath4 has no ` @xmath42 ' , that @xmath213 is in . in this section we give a general tableau procedure for every logic which varies according to each logic s parameters . we can then use the tableau for a particular logic and make observations on its complexity , as we do in the following section . a version of the tableau which is more efficient for some cases follows after . to develop the tableau procedure we need to examine the relations on the agents more carefully than we have so far . for this section and the following one fix some @xmath215 and we assume @xmath97 is axiomatically appropriate with respect to @xmath15 and schematic . if @xmath216 are binary relations on the same set , then @xmath217 is the binary relation on the same set , such that @xmath218 if and only if there are @xmath219 in the set , such that @xmath220 . if @xmath40 is a binary relation , then @xmath221 is the reflexive , transitive closure of @xmath40 ; if @xmath40 is a set ( but not a set of pairs ) , then @xmath221 is the set of strings from @xmath40 . we also use the following relation on strings : @xmath222 iff there is some string @xmath65 such that @xmath223 . we define the following subsets of and relations on @xmath19 $ ] . @xmath224 : : @xmath225 | ( \exists j \in d \cup f ) \ i c^ * j \}$ ] attempts to capture exactly those agents that require a serial accessibility relation ; from now and on these agents monopolize our attention ; @xmath226 : : @xmath225 | ( \exists j \in f ) \ i c^ * j \}$ ] attempts to capture exactly those agents that require a reflexive accessibility relation ; @xmath227 : : @xmath228 notice that if @xmath229 , and @xmath230 , then @xmath231 ; in @xmath232 is to indicate that @xmath232 is a variation of @xmath14 influenced by the agents in @xmath16 , not that it is available with other subscripts ] @xmath233 : : @xmath234 : if @xmath235 , then @xmath61 s justifications somehow affect @xmath236 s justifications ; conversely , @xmath236 s accesibility relations somehow affect @xmath61 s accessibility relations ; @xmath237 : : @xmath238 : @xmath239 if and only if @xmath240 and @xmath241 ; we can easily see that @xmath242 is an equivalence relation and that if @xmath243 , then @xmath61 and @xmath236 have the same accessibility relations ; similarly , for the above equivalence relations we can define equivalence classes on @xmath138 , @xmath244 . @xmath245 is the equivalence class @xmath246 s.t . we can define relations @xmath248 and @xmath249 on @xmath250 in the following way : @xmath251 iff @xmath252 s.t . @xmath253 and @xmath254 iff @xmath252 s.t . @xmath255 . also , @xmath256 iff @xmath257 and @xmath258 and similarly for @xmath259 . then , define @xmath260 iff there are @xmath261 and @xmath262 s.t . @xmath263 , that is , there are @xmath264 , where @xmath265 . @xmath266 iff @xmath260 and @xmath267 . let @xmath32 $ ] . then , @xmath268 and @xmath269 s.t . @xmath270 . the formulas used in the tableau will have the form @xmath271 , where @xmath272 or is a @xmath131-expression , @xmath273 ( the world prefixes are strings of equivalence classes of agents ) , @xmath274 is ( either the empty string or ) of the form @xmath275 , @xmath276 $ ] , and @xmath277 . furthermore , @xmath278 will be called a world - prefix or state - prefix , @xmath165 a truth - prefix and world prefixes will be denoted as @xmath279 , instead of @xmath280 , where for all @xmath281 $ ] , @xmath282 . a tableau branch is a set of formulas of the form @xmath283 , as above . a branch is complete if it is closed under the tableau rules ( they follow ) . it is propositionally closed if @xmath284 and @xmath285 are both in the branch . we say that a tableau branch is constructed by the tableau rules from @xmath2 , if it is a closure of @xmath286 under the rules . for every @xmath287 , @xmath288 if there are some @xmath289 such that @xmath290 , @xmath291 and @xmath292 . the tableau rules will include certain classical rules to cover propositional cases of formulas , as well as the ones that follow : @xmath293{\sigma\ t\ { t \colon_{i } \!}\psi}{\sigma\ t\ * _ i(t,\psi ) \\\\ \sigma\ t\ \box_i\psi } \ ] ] if @xmath294 ; @xmath295{\sigma\ t\ { t \colon_{i } \!}\psi } { \sigma.\chi(j)\ f\ \bot } \ ] ] if @xmath294 , @xmath296 , and @xmath297 ; @xmath298{\sigma\ t\ { t \colon_{i } \!}\psi}{\sigma\ t\ * _ i(t,\psi)}\ ] ] if @xmath299 ; @xmath300{\sigma\ f\ { t \colon_{i } \!}\psi}{\sigma\ f\ * _ i(t,\psi)}\ ] ] @xmath301{\sigma.\chi(j ) \ f \ \bot } { \sigma.\chi(j).\chi(i ) \ f \ \bot}\ ] ] if @xmath288 ; @xmath302{\sigma\ t\ \box_{i}\psi}{\sigma.\chi(i)\ t\ \psi}\ ] ] if @xmath303 has already appeared ; @xmath304{\sigma\ t\ \box_{i}\psi}{\sigma\ t\ \psi}\ ] ] if @xmath106 ; @xmath305{\sigma\ t\ \box_{i}\psi}{\sigma\ t\ \box_{j}\psi}\ ] ] if @xmath306 ; @xmath307{\sigma\ t\ \box_{i}\psi}{\sigma\ t\ \box_{j}\box_i\psi}\ ] ] if @xmath308 . we do not explicitly mention it anywhere else , but of course , we need a set of rules to cover propositional cases as well . in particular we can use + @xmath309 and @xmath310 the separator @xmath311 indicates a nondeterministic choice between the two options it separates . if @xmath312 is a tableau branch , then here and wherever else it may appear is the set @xmath313 . ] @xmath314 let @xmath315}$ ] be such that for every @xmath32 $ ] , @xmath316 then @xmath317})$ ] , where @xmath318}$ ] is the closure of @xmath319}$ ] under the conditions of frames for the accessibility relations , except for seriality . @xmath318}$ ] is constructed in the following way : for every @xmath32 $ ] , let @xmath320 and for every @xmath321 , @xmath322 and then , @xmath323})$ ] . finally , let @xmath324 and @xmath325 . a branch @xmath312 of the tableau is rejecting when it is propositionally closed or there is some @xmath326 such that @xmath327 . otherwise it is an accepting branch . by induction on the construction of @xmath328 , it is not hard to see that for every @xmath329 , it must be the case that @xmath240 or that @xmath330 and @xmath331 . by induction on the frame construction we can see that if @xmath332 appears in @xmath312 and @xmath333 , then @xmath334 appears in @xmath312 . [ prp : tableaucomplete ] if there is a complete accepting tableau branch @xmath335 , then the formula @xmath2 is satisfiable by a model for @xmath336 . let @xmath337 } , { { \mathcal{a } } } , { \mathcal{v}})$ ] , where @xmath130 } ) = { \mathcal{f}}(b)$ ] , @xmath338 , and @xmath339 . let @xmath340},({{\mathcal{a}}}_i)_{i\in[n]},{\mathcal{v}})$ ] , where for every @xmath32 $ ] , if @xmath294 , then @xmath341 s.t . @xmath342 and @xmath343 , otherwise . @xmath344 is an f - model for @xmath336 : @xmath345}$ ] easily satisfy the appropriate conditions , as the extra pairs of the accessibility relations do not affect the @xmath131-calculus derivation , and we can prove the same for @xmath346}$ ] . if @xmath347 and @xmath348 , if @xmath349 , then @xmath350 and thus @xmath351 . if @xmath352 , then , from rule s , there must be some @xmath353 , so @xmath354 and thus , @xmath355 . if @xmath356 and @xmath357 , then , trivially , whether @xmath352 or not , @xmath358 . by induction on @xmath359 , we prove that for every formula @xmath359 and @xmath360 , if @xmath361 , then @xmath362 and if @xmath363 , then @xmath364 . propositional cases are easy . if @xmath365 and @xmath363 , then @xmath366 , so @xmath367 . on the other hand , if @xmath368 , then @xmath369 and by rule trd , for every @xmath370 such that @xmath240 , there is some @xmath371 . therefore , for every @xmath372 , it is the case that @xmath373 , so by rule trb , a previous observation about formulas of the form @xmath374 , and the inductive hypothesis , for every @xmath375 , @xmath376 and therefore , @xmath377 . now we can prove the following proposition . [ prp : tableaux ] let @xmath126 . @xmath2 is @xmath77-satisfiable if and only if there is a complete tableau branch @xmath312 that is produced from @xmath378 , such that * for all @xmath379 , not both @xmath380 and @xmath381 appear in @xmath312 and * for any @xmath382 , @xmath383 . the `` if '' direction was handled by proposition [ prp : tableaucomplete ] . we will prove the `` only if '' in the following . let @xmath79 be an f - model , @xmath384},({{\mathcal{a}}}_i)_{i\in [ n]},{\mathcal{v}})$ ] that has the strong evidence property and a state @xmath385 such that @xmath386 . furthermore , fix some @xmath387 , such that @xmath388 and the following conditions are met . for any @xmath389 , @xmath390 is some element of @xmath85 s.t . @xmath391 . let @xmath392 \}$ ] . given a state @xmath115 of the model , and @xmath393 , @xmath394 has the usual , modal interpretation , @xmath394 iff for every @xmath352 , @xmath395 we can see in a straightforward way and by induction on the tableau derivation that there is a branch , such that if @xmath396 appears in the branch and @xmath397 , then @xmath398 , if @xmath399 appears in the branch and @xmath397 , then @xmath400 , if @xmath401 appears in the branch , then @xmath402 and if @xmath403 appears in the branch , then @xmath404 . the proposition follows . by taking a closer look at the interactions between the agents we can further improve the efficiency of our tableau procedure and we do that in this section . we use this improvement to prove an upper bound on the complexity of a general class of logics . we need the following definitions and lemma [ lem : clusters ] , which is a generalization of a result from @xcite and has appeared in simpler forms in @xcite . first we define an additional equivalence relation : @xmath405 . as an equivalence relation , this one too gives equivalence classes on @xmath138 and they are @xmath406 . notice that as @xmath407 , @xmath408 and therefore @xmath250 is a refinement of @xmath409 . we ll call @xmath410 . furthermore , notice that for any @xmath411 , either @xmath412 s.t . @xmath413 , or @xmath246 . in the first case , @xmath414 will be called a _ v - class _ of agents and in the second case it will be called a _ c - class _ of agents . for each agent @xmath32 $ ] , @xmath415 will be the equivalence class @xmath411 s.t . @xmath247 and to help keep the relationship between the sets of equivalence classes in mind , notice that @xmath416 $ ] . furthermore , we can extend relations @xmath248 and @xmath249 on @xmath189 in the same way they were defined on @xmath250 . [ lem : clusters ] let @xmath337 } , ( { { \mathcal{a}}}_i)_{i\in [ n ] } , { \mathcal{v}})$ ] be a @xmath77 f - model of at most @xmath129 states , @xmath417 a v - class of agents , and @xmath418 . then , there are states of @xmath85 , @xmath419 , such that 1 . for any @xmath420 , @xmath421 . 2 . for any @xmath422 , @xmath423 , if @xmath424 , then @xmath425 . @xmath419 will be called _ a @xmath426-cluster for @xmath427_. for this proof we need to define the following . let @xmath32 $ ] , @xmath428 . _ an @xmath429-path ending at @xmath61 _ ( and starting at @xmath430 ) from @xmath431 to @xmath432 is a finite sequence @xmath433 , such that for some @xmath434 $ ] , @xmath435 , where for some @xmath436 $ ] @xmath437 and @xmath438 ( and @xmath439 ) , for every @xmath440 $ ] , @xmath441 and if @xmath442 , then @xmath443 , while if @xmath444 , then @xmath445 and @xmath446 , @xmath447 , @xmath448 . the @xmath429-path _ covers _ a set @xmath449 $ ] if @xmath450 . for this path and @xmath451 $ ] , @xmath452 is a @xmath453-state . notice that if there is an @xmath429 path ending at @xmath61 from @xmath431 to @xmath432 and some @xmath454 and @xmath455 such that the path covers @xmath165 and @xmath456 , it must also be the case that @xmath457 . let @xmath458 { \longrightarrow}p_a$ ] be such that @xmath459 , @xmath460 = p_a$ ] and for every @xmath461 $ ] , either @xmath462 or @xmath463 and there is some @xmath461 $ ] such that @xmath463 . for any @xmath385 , @xmath464 let @xmath465 be the following : @xmath466 , for all @xmath467 $ ] , @xmath468 will be such that there is an @xmath429 path ending at @xmath469 from @xmath165 to @xmath468 and covering @xmath426 and if @xmath470 , @xmath471 is such that @xmath472 is an @xmath429 path ending at @xmath473 . let @xmath474 , x\in { \ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}},(a^x_i)_{i \in [ m ] , x\in { \ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}$ ] be defined in the following way . for every @xmath475 $ ] , @xmath476 and for every @xmath464 , @xmath477 . finally , for @xmath478 , @xmath474}$ ] is defined in the following way . if there are some @xmath479 , @xmath422 , such that @xmath480 , @xmath481 and not @xmath482 , then for all @xmath420 , @xmath483 . otherwise , @xmath484 . by induction on @xmath485 , we can see that for every @xmath486 , @xmath420 , if @xmath487 , then @xmath488 . since the model has a finite number of states , there is some @xmath464 such that for every @xmath489 , @xmath490 . therefore , we can pick appropriate @xmath419 among @xmath491 that satisfy conditions 1 , 2 . we recursively define relation @xmath34 on @xmath492 : * if @xmath493 then @xmath494 ; * if @xmath348 , then @xmath495 ; * if @xmath496 , then @xmath497 . @xmath498 is the reflexive , transitive closure of @xmath34 . @xmath498 tries to capture the closure of the conditions on the accessibility relations of a frame . this is made explicit by observing that if for some frame @xmath130})$ ] , @xmath499 and @xmath500 , then @xmath501 . furthermore , if , in addition , @xmath502 , then for every @xmath503 $ ] , @xmath504 . for every agent @xmath294 , we introduce a new agent , @xmath505 and we extend @xmath498 , so that when @xmath415 a v - class , then @xmath506 for every @xmath507 such that @xmath508 . for each @xmath246 , we fix some @xmath509 and @xmath510 . furthermore , if @xmath511 , then @xmath512 @xmath513 . this extended definition of @xmath498 tries to capture the closure of the conditions on the accessibility relations of a frame like the ones that will result from a tableau procedure as defined in the following . let @xmath411 and @xmath514 be a finite string of elements from @xmath250 . then , @xmath414 is _ visible _ from @xmath278 if and only if there is some @xmath515 , some @xmath516 and some @xmath517 such that @xmath518 and @xmath519 ; @xmath520 is then called the @xmath414-view from @xmath514 . notice that there is a similarity between this definition and the statement of lemma [ lem : clusters ] - this will be made explicit later on . then we adjust the tableau by altering rules trd and s and introduce rule svb : @xmath295{\sigma\ t\ { t \colon_{i } \!}\psi } { \sigma.\chi(j)\ f\ \bot } \ ] ] if @xmath294 , @xmath296 , @xmath297 , and @xmath521 is not a @xmath13-class visible from @xmath514 ; @xmath301{\sigma.\chi(j ) \ f \ \bot } { \sigma.\chi(j).\chi(i ) \ f \ \bot}\ ] ] if @xmath288 and it is not the case that @xmath415 is a @xmath13-class visible from @xmath522 ; @xmath523{\sigma\ t\ \box_{i}\psi}{\tau.\chi(i)\ t\ \psi}\ ] ] if @xmath524 a @xmath13-class , visible from @xmath514 , @xmath525 is the @xmath415-view from @xmath514 and @xmath520 has already appeared in the tableau . then we have to redefine the frame @xmath328 . let @xmath315}$ ] be such that for every @xmath32 $ ] , @xmath316 @xmath526 @xmath527 and @xmath317})$ ] , where @xmath318}$ ] is the closure of @xmath319}$ ] as it was defined before . proposition [ prp : tableaucomplete ] and its proof remain the same . to prove proposition [ prp : tableaux ] for this version of the rules , follow the same proof , but for every @xmath360 and v - class @xmath414 fix some @xmath414-cluster for @xmath115 and if @xmath415 is a @xmath13-class , then for @xmath528 , the fixed @xmath414-cluster for @xmath529 , @xmath530 - and observe that if @xmath415 a @xmath13-class , visible from @xmath514 and @xmath525 is the @xmath415-view from @xmath514 , then in model @xmath79 there is some @xmath432 such that @xmath531 , which by the definition of clusters in turn means that @xmath532 . the remaining proof is the same . notice that if for every appearing world - prefix @xmath303 , @xmath61 is always in the same v - class @xmath414 , then all prefixes are of the form @xmath533 , where @xmath534 . in that case we can simplify the box rules and in particular just ignore rule v and end up with the following result . [ cor : easycasesinpi2 ] when there is some v - class @xmath414 such that for every @xmath535 there is some @xmath536 such that @xmath537 , then @xmath77-satisfiability is in @xmath17 . in this section we look into some more specific cases of multi - agent justification logics and demonstrate certain jumps in the complexity of the satisfiability problem for these logics . we first revisit the two - agent logics from @xcite . like in the previous sections , we assume our constant specifications are schematic and axiomatically appropriate ( and in for upper bounds ) . our definition here of @xmath77 allows for more two - agent logics than the ones that were studied in @xcite . it is not hard , though , to extend those results to all two - agent cases of @xmath77 : when there are @xmath538 $ ] , @xmath539 , @xmath540 , @xmath541 , and @xmath542 , then @xmath543-satisfiability is -complete ; otherwise it is in @xmath17 ( see @xcite ) . we will further examine the following two cases . @xmath544 are defined in the following way . @xmath545 ; @xmath546 ; @xmath547 ; @xmath548 , @xmath549 ; @xmath550 ; finally , for @xmath551 $ ] , @xmath552 , where @xmath553 is some axiomatically appropriate and schematic constant specification . by an adjustment of the reductions in @xcite , as it was done in @xcite , it is not hard to prove that @xmath554 is -hard and @xmath555 is -hard . would correspond to what is defined in @xcite as @xmath556 and @xmath557 to @xmath558 . then we can pick a justification variable @xmath485 and we can either use the same reductions and substitute @xmath559 by @xmath560 , or we can just translate each diamond - free fragment to the corresponding justification logic in the same way . it is not hard to see then that the original modal formula behaves exactly the same way as the result of its translation with respect to satisfiability - just consider f - models where always @xmath98 . ] notice that the way we prove @xmath561-hardness for @xmath562 is different in character from the way we prove the same result for the two - agent logics in @xcite . for @xmath562 we use the way the tableau prefixes for it branch , while for @xmath563 the prefixes do not branch , but they increase to exponential size . in fact , we can see that @xmath562 is -complete , while @xmath557 is -complete . the respective tableau rules as they turn out for each logic are - notice that neither logic has any @xmath564-maximal v - classes : notice that the maximum length of a world prefix is at most @xmath566 , since the depth ( nesting of terms ) of the formulas decrease whenever we move from @xmath514 to @xmath565 . also notice that when we run the @xmath131-calculus , there is no use for rule @xmath131v - dis , so we can simply run the calculus on one world - prefix at the time , without needing the whole frame . therefore , we can turn the tableau into an alternating polynomial time procedure , which uses a nondeterministic choice when the tableau would make a nondeterministic choice ( when we apply the propositional rules ) and uses a universal choice to choose whether to increase prefix @xmath514 to @xmath567 or to @xmath568 . this means that @xmath562-satisfiability is -complete . for the tableau procedure of @xmath557 we have no such bound on the size of the largest world - prefix , so we can not have an alternating polynomial time procedure . as before , though , the @xmath131-calculus does not use rule @xmath131v - dis , so again we can run the calculus on one world - prefix at the time . furthermore , for every prefix @xmath431 , @xmath569 is polynomially bounded ( observe that we do not need more than two boxes in front of any formula ) , so in turn we have an alternating polynomial space procedure . therefore , @xmath557-satisfiability is -complete . antonis achilleos . a complexity question in justification logic . in _ proceedings of the 18th international conference on logic , language , information and computation _ , wollic11 , pages 819 , berlin , heidelberg , 2011 . springer - verlag . roman kuznets . on the complexity of explicit modal logics . in peter clote and helmut schwichtenberg , editors , _ csl _ , volume 1862 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 371383 . springer , 2000 . errata concerning the explicit counterparts of @xmath570 and @xmath571 are published as @xcite . roman kuznets . complexity through tableaux in justification logic . in _ plenary talks , tutorials , special sessions , contributed talks of logic colloquium ( lc 2008 ) , bern , switzerland _ , pages 3839 , 2008 . roman kuznets . self - referentiality of justified knowledge . in edward a. hirsch , alexander a. razborov , alexei l. semenov , and anatol slissenko , editors , _ csr _ , volume 5010 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 228239 . springer , 2008 . alexey mkrtychev . models for the logic of proofs . in sergei adian and anil nerode , editors , _ logical foundations of computer science , 4th international symposium , lfcs97 , yaroslavl , russia , july 612 , 1997 , proceedings _ , volume 1234 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 266275 . springer , 1997 .

the logic of proofs , lp , and its successor , justification logic , is a refinement of the modal logic approach to epistemology in which proofs / justifications are taken into account . in 2000 kuznets showed that satisfiability for lp is in the second level of the polynomial hierarchy , a result which has been successfully repeated for all other one - agent justification logics whose complexity is known . we introduce a family of multi - agent justification logics with interactions between the agents justifications , by extending and generalizing the two - agent versions of the logic of proofs introduced by yavorskaya in 2008 . known concepts and tools from the single - agent justification setting are adjusted for this multiple agent case . we present tableau rules and some preliminary complexity results . in several cases the satisfiability problem for these logics remains in the second level of the polynomial hierarchy , while for others it is or -hard . furthermore , this problem becomes -hard even for certain two - agent logics , while there are @xmath0-hard logics of three agents .

cond-mat0112246

single molecule biomechanical experiments allow to measure the forces generated by biomolecules and their response to applied forces @xcite . for `` passive '' biopolymers , that do not produce active movement against load , the resulting force - extension curves provide a probe of the nonlinear elasticity of the chains and its relationship to configurational changes . such studies were carried out for single stranded and double stranded dna @xcite , for the muscle protein titin @xcite , the extracellular matrix protein tenascin @xcite , the polysaccharides dextran @xcite and xanthan @xcite , as well as the synthetic polymer poly(ethylene - glycol ) @xcite . theoretical modeling of the elastic behavior of these polymers is often hampered by lack of detailed knowledge concerning the configurations involved and the relevant interactions . a direct and detailed confrontation between experiment and theory is however possible for the case of homopolypeptides capable of forming an @xmath4-helix . in this case the molecular configurations are well understood . furthermore , one can relate the elastic force law to the known zimm - bragg parameters that characterize the helix - coil transition of the free polypeptides . as we shall discuss , the extension force law of a long polypeptide just above the melting temperature of the helix , @xmath0 , exhibits two plateaus . both are associated with a coexistence of helical and coil domains . the low - tension plateau is due to helix formation induced by the chain extension and the accompanying loss of configurational entropy . the second , high - tension plateau is due to the extension induced melting of the helices when the end - to - end length exceeds the length of the fully helical chain . for @xmath5 only the second plateau survives but the force law for weak extensions exhibits a `` quasi plateau '' _ i.e. , _ a regime with a weak slope that is not associated with a coexistence . this last regime is due to the facile alignment of the long persistent regions in the helix . in the following we analyze the force laws , their dependence on temperature and the corresponding population distribution of helical and coil segments . while we are unaware of single molecule experiments on this system , similar behavior was observed experimentally on fibers of collagen during the 1950s @xcite . two different treatments of this problem were recently advanced @xcite . in the present article we present a unified analysis of the problem , tracing the physical origins of the disagreements between the force laws obtained in the two earlier publications and analyzing their range of validity . our treatment is distinctive in that it is based on free energy argument instead of the customary transfer matrix approach @xcite . this free energy argument allows to recover the results of the transfer matrix method but is physically transparent and relatively simple mathematically . within this approach we consider the extension of a very long homopolypeptide capable of forming @xmath4-helices . the discussion is limited to quasi - static extension assuming that the rate of equilibration of the configurations of the chain is much faster than the rate of extension . two models are explored . in one , the helical domains are viewed as rigid rods while in the second , they are modeled as semiflexible chains . for each model we present a rigorous derivation of the corresponding force law allowing for the polydispersity of the helical and coil domains and the associated mixing entropy ( see fig . [ multi ] ) . in addition , we explore two useful approximations allowing for simplified calculations of the force law . in one approximation , the mixing entropy of the helices and domains is neglected and the plateau is associated with coexistence of one helical domain with one coil domain ( see fig . [ phases ] ) . within this `` diblock '' or `` @xmath6 '' approximation the coexistence regimes involve a first order phase transition . in spite of this erroneous conclusion , this approximation correctly identifies the important length and force scales in the problem . the second , mean field approximation , neglects the direct coupling of the distribution of domains sizes and the applied tension . as we shall see , this approximation is actually exact when the helical domains are modeled as long semiflexible chains . the problem and the analysis are of interest from a number of perspectives . homopolypeptides are the simplest representatives of helicogenic molecules . in this case it is not necessary to allow for the sequence heterogeneity which affects the elasticity of heteropolypeptides . nor is it necessary to consider the long range interaction that occur in multiple helices . as a result , the number of parameters invoked in the theory is smaller and the mathematical analysis is simpler . the force laws obtained are determined by known zimm - bragg parameters with no adjustable parameters . accordingly this system enables a direct comparison between experiment and theory . in this juncture it is important to note the availability of synthetic methods for producing long polypeptides with a well defined architecture @xcite . furthermore , the formalism described provides a convenient basis for the analysis of more complex helicogenic polymers such as dna and collagen . from a polymer science point of view the elasticity of homopolypeptides is of interest because it reflects the effects of internal degrees of freedom arising from intrachain self - assembly . the study of these systems enables the exploration of the distinctive non - linear force laws that are the signatures of such intrachain self - assembly . finally , this elasticity plays a role in the stabilization of the helical state of grafted polypeptides @xcite . in turn this is of importance for the function of fusogenic polypeptides and the design of surfaces that favor spreading and growth of cells @xcite . the paper is organized as follows . in section ii we introduce the free energy argument _ via _ an analysis of the helix - coil transition in free , undeformed homopolypeptides . a semiquantitative analysis of the effect of extension is presented in section iii . two approaches are used . one focuses on the intersections of the free energy curves of a pure coil and a pure helix as a function of the end - to - end distance , @xmath2 . as we shall see , each intersection is a rough diagnostic for a transition between the two configurations and for the occurrence of a plateau in the force law . the second , more quantitative approach is the diblock or @xmath6 approximation . within this approximation the homopolypeptide is assumed to consist of two domains , a helix and a coil , and the mixing entropy associated with the polydispersity of the helical and coil domains is set to zero , @xmath6 . finally , in section iv we present a rigorous analysis of the force laws allowing for the polydispersity of the coexisting helices and coil domains . as stated earlier , we implement this analysis for two models . in one the helical domains are viewed as rigid rods and in the second as semiflexible chains described by the worm like chain ( wlc ) model . in this section we also examine the validity of the mean field approximation introduced in @xcite . within this approximation , the explicit coupling between the tension and the distribution of domain sizes is ignored . as we shall see , it recovers the exact result when the helices are semiflexible _ i.e. , _ when the persistence length of the helices is finite and the helical domains are large . the analysis of the rigid helices model recovers the results obtained by tamashiro and pincus @xcite using a transfer matrix formalism . a comparison between the two models and an outline of some open problems are presented in the discussion . it is helpful to first summarize the main features of the helix - coil transition of free polypeptides in the absence of imposed extension . we will consider only homopolypeptides , consisting of a single type of amino acid residues , in order to avoid complications introduced by sequence of different residues found in heteropolypeptides . our discussion focuses on the case of long chains where the degree of polymerization of the polymer @xmath7 is large , @xmath8 . to this end we first discuss the zimm - brag parameters and then introduce the free energy analysis of the transition . as we shall see , this is equivalent to the transfer matrix formalism @xcite that is traditionally used to analyze the transition @xcite . our discussion focuses on helicogenic polypeptides that are capable of assuming two configurations : a random coil and an @xmath4-helix . in the coil state the monomers are free to rotate thus leading to a small kuhn length with typical value of @xmath9 corresponding to the length of few monomers . for simplicity we will identify the kuhn length with the span of a single monomer , @xmath10 . the helical configuration involves hydrogen bonds between residues @xmath11 and @xmath12 . this constrains the orientation of the three intermediate monomers . as a result the persistence length @xmath13 of the helical configuration is large , of order @xmath14 . at the same time the projected length of a monomer along the axis of the helix decreases to @xmath15 . the length of the polypeptide in a helical configuration is thus smaller than the span of a fully extended coil by a factor of @xmath16 @xcite . the homopolypeptides are modeled as a two state system . each monomer can exist either in a helical or a coil state . choosing the coil state as a reference state , the excess free energy @xmath17 of a monomer within a helical domain reflects two contributions . first is the change in enthalpy upon formation of an intrachain @xmath18-bond , @xmath19 . the second is associated with the loss of configurational entropy , @xmath20 , in the helical state . altogether @xmath21 the enthalpy term favors the helical state while the entropy term favors the coil state . thus , at low temperatures the free energy @xmath17 is negative and the helical configuration is preferred while at high temperatures @xmath17 is positive and the coil state is dominant . the two terms are comparable at @xmath22 when @xmath23 . @xmath0 provides an approximate value for the melting temperature of the @xmath4-helix . an additional parameter is needed to describe the helix - coil transition . the number of @xmath18-bonds in a helical domain consisting of @xmath24 monomers is @xmath25 . it is thus necessary to allow for the special state of the terminal monomers of the helical domain . these two monomers lose their configurational entropy with no gain due to the formation of @xmath18-bonds . each of the terminal bonds is thus assigned an excess free energy of @xmath26 with respect to the coil state . in the following we will use @xmath27 measured with respect to the helical state , that is @xmath28 as we shall discuss later , this definition is consistent with the known experimental results . clearly , this definition is consistent with the traditional one when the coil state is used as a reference . @xmath27 plays the role of an interfacial free energy associated with the boundary between helix and coil domains . this term makes the helix - coil transition cooperative since it favors the formation of large domains . it is customary to describe the helix - coil transition in terms of the zimm - bragg parameters @xcite : @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the boltzmann constant . the @xmath31 dependent @xmath32 represents the boltzmann factor associated with adding one monomer to a helical domain . @xmath33 at the transition temperature @xmath0 while @xmath34 for @xmath5 and @xmath35 for @xmath36 . @xmath37 corresponds to the boltzmann factor associated with the creation of a helical domain . the definition of @xmath27 as @xmath38 suggests that @xmath37 is independent of @xmath31 . the definition of @xmath27 as @xmath39 does not predict that @xmath37 is independent of @xmath31 but it yields an identical estimate for the numerical value of @xmath37 @xcite . the experimentally measured @xmath37 , as obtained from plots of the helical content _ vs. _ @xmath31 , are in the range of @xmath40 , depending on the residue , and exhibit a weak @xmath31 dependence . as stated earlier , in the following we will use @xmath41 . as we shall discuss , a plot of the helical content _ vs. _ @xmath32 exhibits a sigmoid behavior and the width of the transition scales with @xmath42 . thus , the transition becomes sharper , more cooperative , as @xmath37 decreases . having defined the relevant molecular parameters , @xmath17 and @xmath43 or equivalently @xmath32 and @xmath44 , we are in a position to analyze the helix - coil transition as it occurs in free chains upon changing the temperature @xmath31 . the minimal description of the transition requires the specification of two properties , the total number of monomers in a helical configuration , @xmath45 and the number of helical domains , @xmath46 . while @xmath47 and @xmath48 are sufficient for a discussion of the helix - coil transition of free chains , the analysis of the effect of extension requires additional information . in particular , the probability distribution of helical domains , @xmath49 , and of coil domains , @xmath50 , comprising of @xmath24 monomers . in order to determine these parameters we minimize the appropriate phenomenological free energy . this method recovers the results obtained by the transfer matrix approach and is easily generalized to allow for the effect of applied tension . the free energy allows for two principal contributions : ( i ) the free energy of the monomers . all @xmath51 helical monomers , including the terminal monomers of the domains are assigned an excess free energy of @xmath17 . the @xmath52 terminal monomers are assigned an additional free energy of @xmath53 . as a result their excess free energy with respect to the coil state is @xmath54 . ( ii ) a mixing entropy term associated with the different possible placements of @xmath51 helical monomers and @xmath52 terminal monomers constituting the domain boundaries . since the helical and coil domains alternate , there is no entropy due to their mixing . rather , the mixing entropy arises because of the polydispersity of the domains _ i.e. _ , helical and coil domains of different size @xmath24 are considered distinguishable . since there are @xmath46 helical and @xmath46 coil domains the mixing entropy is @xmath55 the free energy per monomer in the unperturbed chain is thus @xmath56 the lagrange multipliers , @xmath57 and @xmath58 , ensure the normalization @xmath59 and @xmath60 . the two remaining lagrange multipliers , @xmath61 and @xmath62 , impose the average sizes @xmath63 and @xmath64 of the helical and coil domains . this description corresponds to a simplified version of the transfer matrix method involving a two by two matrix . in both cases there is no constraint ensuring that helical domains incorporate at least three monomers @xcite . since we focus on the case of @xmath65 and @xmath8 the weight of small domains is negligible and this description yields the correct results . the probabilities @xmath49 and @xmath50 are determined by minimization of @xmath66 with respect to @xmath49 and @xmath50 ( appendix a ) leading to @xmath67 note that @xmath49 and @xmath50 decay exponentially with decay constants @xmath68 and @xmath69 $ ] . thus , @xmath49 and @xmath50 are not sharply peaked at the mean values @xmath63 and @xmath70 . in particular , there is a significant population of small helices even when the average size of the helical domain @xmath63 is large . in this limit , @xmath71 . similarly , when @xmath70 is large @xmath72 . upon substituting @xmath49 and @xmath50 in @xmath73 as given by ( [ eq_free2 ] ) , we obtain @xmath66 as a function of @xmath47 and @xmath48 only @xcite : @xmath74 the equilibrium conditions @xmath75 and @xmath76 then lead to @xmath77 in turn , these yield ( appendix b ) the expression for the equilibrium values of @xmath78 and @xmath48 @xmath79^{-1/2}}{s+1 + \sqrt{(s-1)^{2}+4\,\sigma s}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] these expressions are identical to the ones obtained _ via _ the transfer matrix method @xcite . the behavior of @xmath47 and @xmath48 as a function of @xmath32 and @xmath37 is plotted in fig . [ theta0 ] . when @xmath80 we recover the boltzmann distribution for independent two - level systems : @xmath81 . in marked contrast when @xmath82 , the fraction of helical monomers is steplike : @xmath83 for @xmath34 and @xmath84 for @xmath35 . the chain is either a pure helix or a pure coil . for intermediate values of @xmath37 , the plot of @xmath47 _ vs. _ @xmath32 yields a sigmoid curve with a transition region of width @xmath85 centered around @xmath86 . the number of domains is maximal in the vicinity of @xmath33 and it decreases with @xmath37 . the parameter @xmath87 serves as a measure of the temperature , @xmath31 . for low temperatures , @xmath88 and the polymer is mainly in a helical state . at high temperatures , @xmath89 and the polymer is mostly in a coil state . the crossover occurs at @xmath90 for which @xmath86 . near this crossover , @xmath91 and the width of the crossover regime is @xmath92 . the most notable feature of the force laws of homopolypeptides are the plateaus . in this section we present qualitative and semiquantitative analysis of the plateaus . each plateau in the force law corresponds to a coexistence between two states , a helix and a coil . the situation is somewhat analogous to a liquid - gas transition which leads to a plateau in the pressure - volume diagram . in our case , the tension @xmath1 plays the role of the pressure and the end - to - end distance @xmath2 is analogous to the volume . this analogy is however of limited validity since the homopolypeptides are one - dimensional systems with short range interactions and thus incapable of undergoing a first order phase transition . in such systems the boundary free energy is independent of the size of the domain . as a result , a first order phase transition involving a coexistence of two domains is prevented by the mixing entropy @xcite . accordingly , the average domain sizes @xmath64 and @xmath93 , as obtained in the previous section , are independent of the size of the chain , @xmath7 . nevertheless , the main features of the system can be recovered if one ignores the role of the mixing entropy . as expected , within this rough approximation the plateaus are erroneously associated with first order phase transitions . in spite of this deficiency , this approximation recovers the correct length and force scales but the force laws obtained are wrong in detail . before we present this approximation we investigate the crossing of the free energy curves associated with the `` pure '' helix and coil states . this is a rough diagnostic for first order phase transitions . in our case it provides an insight concerning the physical origin of the plateaus as well as a reasonable estimate for some of the length and force scales involved . the occurrence of the plateaus is signaled by the crossing of the free energy curves of the pure helix and the pure coil as a function of @xmath2 . each crossing point signals a coexistence between the two `` phases '' and thus a plateau in the force law . with the unperturbed coil as a reference state , the free energy of the coil is simply its elastic free energy . in this section , we will utilize the fixed @xmath2 ensemble and we thus denote the elastic free energy by @xmath94 . to allow for the finite extensibility of the chain we use the freely jointed chain ( fjc ) model ( appendix c ) for @xmath94 and the free energy per monomer is @xmath95 where @xmath96 $ ] , @xmath97 is the reduced end - to - end distance of the polymer and @xmath98 is the reduced force . @xmath99 and @xmath100 are related _ via _ @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the langevin function . the free energy of the helix reflects two contributions . first is the excess free energy of a helix , @xmath103 . in the limit of an infinite chain , when the contribution of the terminal monomers is negligible , the free energy per monomer is @xmath104 . at this stage we assume that the persistence length of the helix is infinite and that it may be viewed as a perfectly rigid and unextendable rod . within this view , extending the helix beyond its natural length is associated with an infinite free energy penalty . this penalty is important because the helix is shorter than the fully extended coil . as noted earlier , the contribution of each helical monomer to the overall length of the helix is @xmath105 . altogether , @xmath104 so long as @xmath106 while in the range @xmath107 it is @xmath108 . three scenarios are now possible ( fig . [ crossing ] ) . at low temperatures , @xmath109 and @xmath34 . accordingly , @xmath110 while @xmath111 . in this regime the helix is more stable than the coil . when @xmath107 the free energy of the helix diverges and the coil state becomes preferable . this curve crossing corresponds to a plateau involving the breakdown of the helix due to the applied tension . above the melting temperature , for @xmath112 and @xmath113 the unstretched polypeptide is in a coil state . upon stretching @xmath114 increases and eventually intersects with @xmath115 this intersection signals a plateau in the force law due to the formation of helical domains . at @xmath116 the free energies @xmath114 and @xmath115 cross again because of the infinite free energy of a helix with @xmath107 . this second intersection signals a second plateau involving the melting of the helix and the formation of coil domains . finally , for sufficiently high temperatures , @xmath117 , no intersections occur and the polypeptide remains in a coil state for all @xmath99 values . the threshold temperature for this regime , @xmath118 , is defined by the equality @xmath119 where @xmath120 is the free energy of a stretched coil with @xmath116 . the intersection of the free energy curves provides a rough indicator for the occurrence of plateaus in the force law . however , it does not allow to calculate an explicit force - extension diagram . a simple approach yielding the main features of the force law is the @xmath6 or diblock approximation @xcite . within this approximation the force law is calculated for a diblock copolymer with one helical domain and one coil domain . the size of the annealed domains varies with the extension and is determined by the equilibrium conditions . as is implied by its name , in this approximation @xmath121 is neglected . as expected , setting @xmath6 leads to a first order phase transition associated with a coexistence of two `` phases '' . consequently , some features of the force law are wrong . in particular , this approximation yields a perfect plateau with @xmath122 while in reality @xmath1 increases weakly with @xmath2 . these features notwithstanding , this simple approximation does recover the correct length and force scales . within this discussion we will also briefly examine the effect of the persistence length of the helical domains . in particular we compare the behavior of a helix endowed with an infinite persistence length to that of a helix with a finite one . within the @xmath6 or diblock approximation the free energy @xmath123 of the chain is @xmath124 here , the first term allows for the excess free energy of the helical monomers . since @xmath6 the helical and coil phases separate into two domains . the `` interfacial '' free energy of the single helical domain gives rise to the second , constant term . these two terms are supplemented by an elastic free energy @xmath125 that depends on @xmath47 , @xmath126 and the end - to - end distance , @xmath2 . different versions of the @xmath6 are possible , depending on the choice of @xmath125 . in the following we focus on the simplest version where @xmath125 is given by the gaussian elasticity of an ideal random coil in the fixed @xmath2 ensemble . two additional assumptions are invoked : ( i ) the helical domain is perfectly rigid and unextendable and ( ii ) the helical domain is perfectly aligned with the applied force . these assumptions specify the elastic free energy per monomer @xmath127 this simple version of the diblock approximation permits an explicit analytical solution for the force law . the corresponding equilibrium condition is @xmath128 within this approximation the equilibrium condition @xmath129 is an identity yielding no additional information . the solution of this quadratic equation in @xmath130 is @xmath131 . this defines a critical @xmath17 @xmath132 corresponding to a critical @xmath133 or @xmath118 . while @xmath134 , the equilibrium condition can not be satisfied , that is , the polypeptide remains in a coil state irrespective of the imposed tension . a critical point occurs for @xmath135 . when @xmath136 two solutions exist , each defining a plateau in the force _ vs. _ extension curve . the solution @xmath137 corresponds to the lower plateau , obtained for @xmath138 , where @xmath139 this first regime disappears for @xmath140 or @xmath5 . the condition @xmath84 defines a lower boundary of the plateau , @xmath141 @xmath142 increases as @xmath17 increases until @xmath143 for @xmath135 . for @xmath144 the fraction of helices is @xmath84 and the chain is in a purely coil form . the upper boundary of this plateau occurs at @xmath145 when the chain is fully helical , @xmath83 . at intermediate extensions , @xmath146 the fraction of helical bonds increases as @xmath147 and @xmath148 occurs at the midpoint of the plateau @xmath149 . the equilibrium free energy of the chain for @xmath144 is @xmath150 while for @xmath151 it is @xmath152 the second plateau , is described by the solution , @xmath153 , leading to @xmath154 the lower boundary of this plateau occurs at @xmath155 when @xmath83 . the upper boundary , when @xmath84 , occurs at @xmath156 for @xmath157 the fraction of helical monomers decreases as @xmath158 and @xmath148 occurs at the midpoint of the plateau @xmath159 . notice that the width of the two plateaus shrinks as @xmath160 or @xmath161 . for @xmath162 the fraction of monomers in a helical state is again @xmath84 and the corresponding free energy is @xmath150 . the equilibrium free energy of the chain in the range @xmath163 is @xmath164 note that only the lower plateau is obtained if @xmath165 is assumed@xcite . the @xmath6 approximation allowed us to obtain rough force laws corresponding to the three scenarios identified by the curve crossing argument . thus , for @xmath134 or @xmath117 , the polypeptide remains in a coil configuration for the whole range of extension . the `` two plateau scenario '' occurs for @xmath136 corresponding to @xmath166 or @xmath167 . in this case we can distinguish five regimes ( fig . [ phases ] ) : ( i ) for low extensions the chain is in a coil state , @xmath84 , and the elastic behavior is gaussian leading to @xmath168 . ( ii ) in the range @xmath146 helix and coil domains coexist according to the lever rule @xmath169 . this coexistence is associated with a plateau with a constant tension @xmath170 ( iii ) at @xmath171 the force curve exhibits a discontinuity associated with a step like increase to a second plateau . the magnitude of the step , @xmath172 is @xmath173 ( iv ) in the range @xmath157 helix and coil domains coexist according to the lever rule @xmath174 . this coexistence is associated with a second plateau with a constant tension @xmath175 ( v ) finally , for @xmath176 the chain is in a strongly stretched coil state obeying @xmath168 . when @xmath177 or @xmath178 the unperturbed chain is in a helical state . consequently , the lower plateau disappears . it is replaced by a `` quasi plateau '' which is not associated with a helix - coil coexistence . rather , it is due to the facile orientation of the helical chain which is modeled as a rigid rod . at @xmath116 a jump occurs to the upper plateau . the analysis presented above utilized the gaussian elastic free energy in the fixed @xmath2 ensemble to describe the coil . while this allows us to obtain explicit expressions for all the characteristics of the force curve , it also introduces errors . clearly , this choice of @xmath125 does not capture the behavior of the coil in the high extension regime , where finite extensibility begins to play a role . as a result , the values of @xmath179 are overestimated . this has two consequences . first , within this approximation the span of the two plateaus are equal @xmath180 while for more realistic choice of @xmath125 the higher plateau is narrower . a second more important pathology is the disappearance of regime ( v ) in the @xmath181 case . to allow for the finite extensibility it is necessary to use the freely jointed chain model ( fjc ) for the coil segment @xcite . it is important to note that so long as @xmath182 and @xmath183 the discrepancies between the two schemes are rather small ( fig . [ force_db ] ) . another ingredient of our simplified analysis is the modeling of the helices as rigid and unextendable rods . an alternative description of the elastic properties of helices models them as worm like chains _ i.e. , _ semiflexible chains capable of undergoing undulations ( see appendix d ) @xcite . as we shall see later , this semiflexible approximation of the helices has a qualitative effect on the results of the rigorous analysis of the system . however , in the context of the @xmath6 approximation for @xmath183 , it mainly affects the transition between the two plateaus ( fig . [ force_db ] ) . when the helix is modeled as a rigid rod the transition occurs as a jump that takes place at @xmath116 . on the other hand , when the wlc model is used the jump , while abrupt , takes place over a finite interval _ @xmath184 is replaced by @xmath185 . for the @xmath140 ( fig . [ force_db2 ] ) the transition at the upper boundary of the `` quasi plateau '' is more gradual when the elasticity of the semiflexible helix is allowed for . finally , note that the diblock approximation is recovered from the more rigorous treatments presented below when the @xmath186 limit is taken before the @xmath187 limit . when @xmath188 limit is approached for a finite chain it leads to a single domain . the analysis presented in the previous section fails to allow for a number of important ingredients . the most important is the mixing free energy , @xmath189 , associated with the polydispersity of the domains . in this section we present an analysis that allows for the role of this mixing entropy . because of @xmath121 the helix - coil transitions no longer take place as first order phase transitions . in turn this has two important consequences : ( i ) the `` perfect '' plateaus , with constant forces @xmath190 and @xmath191 are replaced by `` imperfect '' plateaus with a finite slope . ( ii ) the crossovers between the plateaus and the neighboring regimes become smoother . the analysis is based on a generalization of the approach described in section ii that is , all chain characteristics , @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath78 and @xmath48 are obtained from the minimization of the appropriate free energy _ i.e. _ , the equilibrium conditions . as in section iii , the free energy is of the form @xmath192 where , @xmath66 is the free energy of the unperturbed free chain and @xmath125 , accounts for the elasticity of the chain . however , in the following we utilize different expressions for these two terms . since we aim to obtain @xmath49 and @xmath50 it is necessary to utilize @xmath66 as given by equation ( [ eq_free2 ] ) . the handling of the elastic free energy is significantly different . in section iii we used the gaussian elasticity to describe the deformation behavior of the coils and assumed that the helices contribute to the elastic behavior as a geometric constraint . while this rough description is sufficient at the level of the @xmath6 approximation , a more refined treatment is needed for the detailed analysis to be undertaken below . in particular , it is necessary to allow for two additional features : ( i ) the finite extensibility of the chain and ( ii ) the gradual alignment of the helical domains with the applied tension . the freely jointed chain ( fjc ) model allows us to incorporate the finite extensibility of the coil domains . with regard to the helices we will explore two different descriptions that impose finite extensibility on the helices . first we will model the helical domains as rigid and unextendable rods and allow for their length dependent alignment by using the fjc model _ i.e. , _ the helical domains are considered as freely jointed rigid rods forming a chain . this amounts to the assumption of an infinite persistence length for each helical domain . this picture is reasonable so long as the size of the helical domains is small compared to the persistence length , @xmath13 . in the second approach , each of the helical domains is viewed as worm like chain ( wlc ) that is , semiflexible chain characterized by a finite persistence length and capable of undergoing undulations . it is assumed that the domains are large in comparison to @xmath13 . an important difference between the fjc and the wlc models is that in the later the persistence length depends on the applied tension . our approach utilizes the analysis of marko and siggia of the extension elasticity of the wlc @xcite . the utilization of these models makes the constant @xmath1 ensemble mathematically convenient . this choice of ensemble is also preferable because it corresponds better to the experimental situation encountered in single molecule measurements . in each case , we first obtain the equilibrium values of @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath47 and @xmath48 of a chain subject to a given tension , @xmath1 , by minimizing @xmath193 with respect to @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath47 and @xmath48 . this allows us to determine the equilibrium @xmath193 thus enabling us to calculate the @xmath3 diagram by using @xmath194 when the helical domains are viewed as rigid rods and the fjc is invoked , the reduced end - to - end distance @xmath97 of the polypeptide is @xmath195 where @xmath98 is the reduced tension . the first part of this expression corresponds to the projection of the coil monomers along the direction of the tension . the second part reflects to the contribution of the helical domains to @xmath99 . because the individual monomers within the coil domains are aligned independently , the domain size does not play a role . the extension of each coil domain is extensive with respect to the number of monomers , @xmath24 . consequently , this contribution may be expressed in terms of the first moment of the probability distribution @xmath196 . as a result the full probability @xmath50 is irrelevant . in marked contrast , the monomers within the helical domains are not aligned individually but as part of the rod - like domains . the non - linearity introduced by the @xmath197 term in the expression for @xmath99 couples @xmath1 and @xmath49 . as a consequence , @xmath49 will be explicitly modified by the applied tension while @xmath50 depends on @xmath1 only implicitly , _ via _ @xmath47 and @xmath48 . eliminating @xmath50 from ( [ r_rigid ] ) , we obtain @xmath198 this expression for @xmath199 enables us to obtain the corresponding elastic free energy @xmath200 ( appendix c ) @xmath201 where @xmath96 $ ] . altogether the free energy per monomer is thus @xmath202 since the @xmath1 dependence of @xmath123 is due only to @xmath125 , ( [ rdef ] ) yields @xmath2 as given by ( [ rdef2 ] ) . as before , @xmath49 and @xmath50 are determined by minimizing @xmath193 with respect to these probabilities subject to two constraints : ( i ) the normalization of the probabilities @xmath49 and @xmath50 and ( ii ) the average sizes @xmath64 and @xmath93 of the coil and helical domains . upon substituting the resulting @xmath49 and @xmath50 in @xmath123 we obtain @xmath193 as a function of @xmath47 and @xmath48 . @xmath78 and @xmath48 are then determined by the equilibrium conditions @xmath203 . the details of the calculation involved are described in appendix e. @xmath47 and @xmath48 for a given tension @xmath1 are @xmath204 where @xmath205 the probabilities @xmath50 and @xmath49 are @xmath206 @xmath49 , as @xmath50 , is essentially an exponentially decaying function . however , the characteristic decay constants are now dependent on @xmath1 . the dependence is explicit for @xmath49 while for @xmath50 the @xmath1 dependence is implicit , _ via _ @xmath47 and @xmath48 . in fig . [ theta2 ] , the equilibrium @xmath47 and @xmath48 , are plotted as functions of @xmath98 for different values of @xmath37 . clearly , the results of the @xmath6 or diblock approximation are approached in the limit of strong cooperativity , @xmath188 . in particular , @xmath48 approaches zero while @xmath47 exhibits a step like behavior . thus , @xmath207 outside the plateaus range , @xmath208 and @xmath209 , while within the plateaus range , @xmath210 we find @xmath211 and @xmath212 . consequently , the mean size of the helical domains , @xmath93 , becomes very large compared to @xmath13 . in turn , this suggests that the validity of the model of helical domains as rigid rods is questionable . clearly , the rigid helices model is meaningful only while the persistence length is much larger than @xmath213 . once the equilibrium characteristics of the chain for a given @xmath1 are found , it is possible to obtain the force - extension diagram . the reduced end - to - end distance , @xmath99 , as a function of the reduced tension , @xmath100 , is ( appendix e ) @xmath214 .\ ] ] the corresponding force - extension diagram is plotted in fig . [ force ] . again , the results of the @xmath6 or diblock approximation are approached in the @xmath188 limit . note the `` jump '' in the force at @xmath215 @xcite . at this point , between the two plateaus , the polypeptide is in a `` purely '' helical state , @xmath211 and @xmath212 . this jump is another indication of difficulties due to the approximation of the helices as rigid rods . as we shall see in the next section , this unphysical feature disappears when the finite persistence length of the helices is allowed for . it is of interest to compare the exact solution of the model to the mean field approximation ( mf ) @xcite . the mf approximation involves the removal of the explicit coupling between @xmath50 , @xmath49 and @xmath1 . as noted earlier , this decoupling is exact for @xmath50 . for @xmath49 the decoupling is achieved by replacing @xmath216 in ( [ rdef2 ] ) by @xmath217 . in effect , all helical domains are assigned an equal size of @xmath93 and the effect of their polydispersity on @xmath125 is ignored . the corresponding free energy is @xmath218 the equilibrium conditions @xmath219 @xmath220 lead to @xmath221 , \\ & & \frac{y^{2}}{(\theta -y)(1-\theta -y ) } = \\ \nonumber & & \hskip 0.4 cm = \frac{\sigma y}{\theta \gamma x } \sinh \left ( \frac{\theta \gamma x}{y}\right ) \exp \left [ -\frac{\theta \gamma x}{y}{\cal l}\left ( \frac{\theta \gamma x}{y}\right ) \right ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the overall features of the mf solution are rather similar to the exact solution ( fig . [ force ] ) . the two primary differences are : ( i ) the mf solution indicates that the transition between the plateaus involves a second order phase transition @xcite in marked distinction to the exact solution . ( ii ) because of ( i ) the plateaus do not exhibit an inflection point and the characteristic value of the slope , at @xmath116 , scales as @xmath222@xcite . the assumption of perfectly rigid helical sequences implies an infinite persistence length . this assumption is reasonable so long as the size of the helical domains is small compared to the known values of their persistence length , @xmath13 : a typical value is @xmath223 corresponding to @xmath224 monomers . as we have seen , the rigid rod approximation for an infinite chain leads to helical domains that are larger . in turn , this leads to an unphysical jump , located at @xmath225 , in the force - extension curve . two approaches allow to circumvent this difficulty . one approach treats each helical monomer as an extendable spring _ i.e. _ , it introduces an elastic penalty associated with the deviation of the length of the helical monomer from its equilibrium length @xmath226 . this approach was utilized in the analysis of the extension behavior of dna @xcite and of poly-(ethylene glycol ) @xcite . in the following we adopt a different approach that proved successful in fitting the force curves of dna . within this approach the helical domains are considered as worm like chains ( wlc ) instead of rigid rods ( appendix d ) . in the wlc model the helical domains are viewed as semiflexible chains undergoing undulations . the angular correlations along the chain decay because of the thermal undulations . within this model the decay length of the angular correlations , @xmath227 depends on the tension , @xmath228 for weakly stretched chains @xmath229 is identical to the persistence length , @xmath13 , of the unperturbed chain , @xmath230 while for stronger tensions @xmath231 and the correlations decay faster . a long helical domain of length @xmath232 may thus be considered as a fjc of @xmath233 `` rigid '' segments of length @xmath234 and the reduced end - to - end distance is @xmath235 where @xmath102 is the langevin function and @xmath236 @xcite . as before , the expression for @xmath99 reflects two contributions . the first term corresponds to the alignment of the coil monomers with the applied tension using the fjc model . the second term describes the alignment of the semiflexible helical domains . in the following we assume that the helical domains are larger than @xmath237 that is , @xmath238 . the error introduced by this assumption diminishes as @xmath1 increases and @xmath237 decreases . within this approximation each @xmath234 segment in a helical domain is aligned independently . this is in marked contrast to the rigid helices model where all the monomers within a helical domain align as a unit . as a result we may utilize @xmath239 in order to obtain @xmath240 . consequently , @xmath99 is independent of the probabilities @xmath50 and @xmath49 . expression ( [ dist_flex ] ) for @xmath199 enables us to obtain ( appendix d ) the corresponding elastic free energy @xmath200 @xmath241 in marked distinction to the `` rigid helices '' scenario , this elastic free energy is independent of the probabilities @xmath49 and @xmath50 . accordingly , @xmath49 and @xmath50 are not modified explicitly by the extension and obey ( [ proba_h ] ) and ( [ proba_c ] ) . in other words , the mean field approximation provides an exact solution of the problem . altogether , the free energy of a polypeptide , using the wlc model for the helical domains , is @xmath242{\cal l}(\alpha ) . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] this expression is similar to @xmath123 for a free , undeformed chain ( [ eq_free1 ] ) . the two free energies differ in two respects : ( i ) ( [ eq_free_flex ] ) contains an additive term @xmath243 which is independent of @xmath47 and @xmath48 . ( ii ) the force independent @xmath32 in ( [ eq_free1 ] ) is replaced by a force dependent @xmath244 @xmath245 . \label{stilde}\ ] ] consequently , the equilibrium conditions @xmath203 lead to expressions of the same form as those found for the free chains but with @xmath246 replacing @xmath32 @xmath247 ^{-1/2}}{\tilde{s}+1+\sqrt{(\tilde{s}-1)^{2}+4\,\sigma \tilde{s}}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] substitution of the equilibrium values of @xmath47 and @xmath48 for a given @xmath100 in ( [ dist_flex ] ) yields the corresponding equilibrium end - to - end distance . plots of @xmath47 _ vs. _ @xmath248 and @xmath248 _ vs. _ @xmath249 , as obtained for the `` semiflexible helices '' scenario for different @xmath37 , are depicted in fig . [ thetawlc ] . the replacement of the `` rigid helices '' by semiflexible ones leads to the disappearance of the `` jump '' in the force law . another difference with respect to fig . [ theta2]a is that @xmath83 is never attained . again , we recover the appropriate diblock approximation in the limit of @xmath188 . all the force - extension curves in fig . [ thetawlc]b cross at three different points . the external points correspond to a reduced force @xmath250 satisfying @xmath251 . in turn , this condition is equivalent to the equilibrium condition @xmath252 for @xmath123 corresponding to the appropriate diblock approximation in which the coil is modeled as fjc and the helix as a wlc @xcite . in particular , @xmath250 correspond to points in the plateaus where @xmath148 , @xmath253 /2 $ ] and @xmath254 . the inner crossing point corresponds to @xmath255 for which @xmath244 is maximal . @xmath255 satisfies the condition @xmath256 $ ] _ i.e. _ , to an equality between the projected length of the coil and the helical monomers along the force . from ( [ dist_flex ] ) and ( [ stilde ] ) , it is apparent that this condition is independent of @xmath37 . the plateaus depicted in fig . [ thetawlc]b exhibit a small but finite slope . its characteristic value , at the inflection points @xmath250 , scales with @xmath257 @xcite . our analysis of the extension behavior of polypeptides utilized two models . the two differ in the description of the helical domains . in one model , the helical domains are viewed as perfectly rigid and unextendable rods . the `` rigid helices '' model is reasonable so long as the length of the helical domains is small compared to the persistence length . in the second approach the helical domains are treated as long semiflexible polymers within the worm like chain ( wlc ) model . this approach is preferable when the length of the helical domains is larger than the force dependent decay length @xmath258 . for each of the models , we presented a rigorous solution and two approximations . within the diblock approximation one neglects the mixing entropy associated with the polydispersity of the domains . in the mean field approximation there is no direct coupling between the distribution of sizes of the domains and the applied tension . in all cases considered , our analysis is based on the minimization of a phenomenological free energy . this approach is equivalent to the transfer matrix method but it is physically transparent and mathematically simple . the general features of the extension behavior of the polypeptides are independent of the model and the approximation scheme . three different scenarios are possible for the extension of long polypeptides : ( a ) for @xmath117 the polypeptide remains in a coil configuration for all extensions . ( b ) in the range @xmath167 the chain is initially in a coil state but it undergoes a helix - coil transition upon extension . the helical domains eventually melt upon stronger extension . consequently , the force law exhibits two plateaus associated with a helix - coil coexistence . ( c ) for @xmath5 the unstretched polypeptide is a helix which melts upon stretching thus leading to a force law with a single plateau . in the second scenario , @xmath167 , it is possible to distinguish between five regimes : ( i ) for weak extensions the polypeptide behaves as a random coil exhibiting a linear response . ( ii ) stronger extensions , and the associated loss of configurational entropy , favor the formation of helical domains . the associated coexistence of helical and coil domains gives rise to a lower plateau . ( iii ) a steep crossover corresponding to the stretching of a stiff , mainly helical , polymer leads to ( iv ) a second , higher plateau due to the break - up of the helices when the imposed end - to - end distance is larger then the length of a fully helical chain . this plateau is also associated with helix - coil coexistence . ( v ) when the helical content is reduced to zero the chain exhibits a strong extension behavior of a random coil , with deviations from the linear response behavior due to finite extensibility effects . in the third scenario , @xmath5 , the regimes ( i ) and ( ii ) disappear and regime ( iii ) extends down to @xmath259 . the small slope of the force law in this regime ( fig . [ f_s1.1 ] ) is reminiscent of a plateau . however , this quasi - plateau is not associated with a helix - coil coexistence . rather , it is due to the easy alignment of the persistent segments in the helix . the two models , `` rigid '' and `` semiflexible '' helices , differ with regard to the precise details of the force diagram . thus , region ( iii ) occurs as a `` jump '' within the `` rigid helices '' model but is a steep yet gradual increase in the `` semi - flexible helices '' model . the slope of the plateaus within the rigid helices model scales as @xmath260 ^{2}$ ] @xcite while in the `` semi - flexible helices '' model it scales as @xmath257 . overall , the crossovers between the various regimes are sharper in the `` rigid helices '' model . the diblock approximation , with the appropriate elastic term , allows to recover the main features , length and force scales , of each model . however , within this @xmath6 approximation the transition takes place as a first order phase transition . as a result it yields perfect plateaus , @xmath261 or @xmath262 , and sharp crossovers . the mean field approximation , where the polydispersity is decoupled from the tension is exact for the `` semiflexible helices '' model . in the case of the `` rigid helices '' model this approximation , while it captures the overall features of the force law also gives rise to a number of artifacts @xcite . neither of the models considered captures the physics completely . the `` rigid helices '' model fails to describe the behavior of helical domain that are long compared to the persistence length . within the `` semiflexible helices '' model all helical domains are assumed to be long in comparison to @xmath237 . accordingly , this model is likely to mishandle short helical domains that do behave as rigid rods . the importance of this deficiency diminishes however as @xmath1 increases and @xmath237 decreases . a full description of the system requires a model combining the positive features of the two models described above . while our analysis focused on the case of homopolypeptides forming @xmath263 -helices , our approach can be extended to more complicated systems . in the case of heteropolypeptides it is necessary to allow for the residue dependence of @xmath17 . for double stranded dna it is necessary to allow for long range interactions as given by the stockmayer formula for @xmath44 @xcite . we would like to thank m. n. tamashiro and p. pincus as well as i. rouzina and v. a. bloomfield for providing us with their results prior to publication . the work of ab was supported by the marie curie fellowship hpmf - ct-1999 - 00328 . the minimization of the free energy ( [ eq_free2 ] ) with respect to the probabilities @xmath49 and @xmath50 yields @xmath264 these are solved by @xmath265 and @xmath266 where @xmath267 the parameters @xmath268 , @xmath269 , @xmath270 and @xmath271 are determined using the constraints @xmath272 yielding @xmath273 , @xmath274 , @xmath275 and @xmath276 thus leading to the expressions ( [ proba_h ] ) for @xmath49 and ( [ proba_c ] ) for @xmath50 . the equilibrium conditions @xmath277 with @xmath66 given by ( [ eq_free1 ] ) lead to @xmath278 from ( [ appendixa2 ] ) , we obtain @xmath279\ ] ] or @xmath280 where @xmath281 . the second condition ( [ appendixa1 ] ) yields @xmath282 combining these two equations allows us to eliminate @xmath48 and obtain an equation for @xmath78 as a function of @xmath32 and @xmath44 , @xmath283 leading to @xmath284 the freely jointed chain model may be considered as the macromolecular analog of the langevin theory of paramagnetism @xcite . a flexible chain comprising @xmath7 monomers is the counterpart of @xmath7 non interacting magnetic dipoles . the monomer length @xmath285 is the analog of the magnetic moment @xmath286 , the applied tension @xmath287 plays the role of the magnetic field @xmath288 and the induced magnetic moment , @xmath289 is the analog of the end to end distance @xmath290 each monomer is assigned an orientational energy @xmath291 where @xmath292 is the angle between the force and the segment . the reduced end - to - end distance @xmath249 of the polymer , at a temperature @xmath31 , is the mean value of @xmath293 : @xmath294 where @xmath98 is the reduced force and @xmath295 is the langevin function . the corresponding elastic free energy in the fixed @xmath1 ensemble , as given by @xmath296 , leads to the following free energy per monomer : @xmath297 where @xmath298 $ ] , is the integrated langevin function . the elastic free energy in the fixed @xmath2 ensemble @xmath299 is the legendre transform of @xmath300 where @xmath97 and @xmath100 are related by @xmath301 . for weak extensions @xmath94 reduces to the familiar gaussian form @xmath302 while for strong extensions it diverges as @xmath303 . within the wormlike chain model ( wlc ) the polymer is viewed as a bendable rod @xcite . in the following we consider the case of a chain of constant contour length @xmath304 and a single bending modulus @xmath305 where @xmath13 is the persistence length of the unperturbed chain . the chain trajectory is described by the position of a point on the chain , @xmath306 at the contour length @xmath307 the unit tangent vector @xmath308 specifies the local orientation of the chain . a straight rod corresponds to @xmath309 or @xmath310 accordingly , the bending energy is a quadratic function of @xmath311 . since @xmath312 , the only quadratic form is @xmath313 and the conformational distribution of the chain , its partition function , up to a contour length @xmath32 , is @xmath314\ ] ] where @xmath315 is a function of @xmath316 and @xmath317 _ i.e , _ this describes a gaussian process with the constraint @xmath319 . as such it is analogous to rotational diffusion and obeys @xmath320 where @xmath321 is the rotational operator that is related to the angular momentum operator in quantum mechanics , @xmath322 , as @xmath323 . the correlations along the unperturbed chain decay as @xmath324 when the chain is subjected to an external field @xmath325 the expression for @xmath326 becomes @xmath327\ ] ] the effect of tension @xmath287 is specified by @xmath328 thus leading to @xmath329 it is possible to find eigenstate satisfying @xmath330 . for a long chain the free energy is extensive and the eigenfunction expansion of @xmath331 involves terms of the form @xmath332 where @xmath333 is the free energy per unit length due to the bending fluctuations . an analytical solution of equation ( [ eq_psi ] ) is not available . marko and siggia @xcite argued that the wlc free energy is determined by the lowest @xmath334 in the spectrum and utilized a variational approach in order to determine @xmath334 . the force law is then recovered from @xmath335 . to this end they chose the trial function @xmath336 $ ] where @xmath4 is a variational parameter and @xmath337 is the angle between @xmath338 and @xmath287 . as we shall see later , @xmath339 where @xmath340 is a force dependent decay length that replaces @xmath13 in characterizing the decay of @xmath341 . assuming @xmath342 @xmath343 this leads to @xcite @xmath344 where @xmath295 is the langevin function and @xmath98 is the reduced force . the argument @xmath345 that minimizes @xmath334 is specified by @xmath346 which leads to : @xmath347{\cal l}^{\prime } ( \alpha ) .\ ] ] where @xmath348 . here the end - to - end distance is simply deduced from : @xmath350 this end - to - end distance is identical to the one obtained from the fjc model if the reduced force @xmath351 @xcite is replaced by @xmath352 . for small forces , when @xmath353 and @xmath354 ( [ eq_alpha ] ) leads to @xmath355 or @xmath356 . for high tension @xmath4 increases more slowly . in this limit @xmath357 while @xmath358 and ( [ eq_alpha ] ) yields @xmath359 or @xmath360 . the difference between the variational approximation and the exact solution of the wlc model is less than @xmath361 over the whole range of forces . the associated elastic free energy , @xmath362 is @xmath363 since @xmath364 and where @xmath334 corresponds to the explicit expression in ( [ eq_g ] ) with @xmath365 according to ( [ eq_alpha ] ) . in eq . ( [ eq_fel ] ) this elastic free energy is used for a helical domain of length @xmath366 with @xmath24 monomers . in this appendix we determine the probabilities @xmath367 and @xmath368 of a coil and a helical segment with @xmath24 monomers as well as the fractions of helical monomers @xmath78 and of helices @xmath48 . the probability @xmath49 is modified by the stretching and is more difficult to obtain . to do so we consider the two remaining equilibrium conditions @xmath374 and @xmath375 after substitution of the equilibrium form of @xmath50 as given by ( [ prob_pc ] ) to obtain the end - to - end distance @xmath2 as a function of the tension @xmath1 we use @xmath393 which leads to @xmath394 the second term may be tackled exactly using the definition @xmath395 : @xmath396 to be precise , this approach is equivalent to a transfer matrix description utilizing a second order transfer matrix . in turn , this description is sufficient for the analysis of the helix - coil transition in an infinite chain . the final expression for the mixing entropy for the free chain can be calculated directly @xcite . @xmath406 where @xmath407 is the product of two factors : @xmath408 the number of possible placements of @xmath46 boundaries to separate @xmath409 helical bonds into @xmath46 helical domains and @xmath410 the number of ways to place @xmath46 boundaries to separate @xmath411 coil bonds into @xmath46 coil domains . using the sterling formula @xmath412 we obtain @xmath413 $ ] where @xmath414 stands for @xmath415 . in the fixed @xmath1 ensemble , the free energy is @xmath416 where @xmath96 $ ] ( see appendix c ) and the boundaries of the plateau are specified by the equilibrium condition @xmath417 while the end - to - end distance is : @xmath418 $ ] . in this case the @xmath6 approximation leads to ( see appendix d and section ivb ) @xmath419 { \cal l}(\alpha)$ ] . the domain boundaries are specified by @xmath420{\cal l } ( \alpha _ { \pm } ) /4n_{h}$ ] with @xmath421 and the end - to - end distance is : @xmath422 $ ] . to characterize the slope we expand @xmath244 around @xmath250 where @xmath251 . in the immediate vicinity of @xmath250 we have @xmath426 where @xmath427 is a constant . accordingly , @xmath428 $ ] and @xmath429\right\}$ ] leading to @xmath430 . the variational eigenstate @xmath431 $ ] where @xmath289 is the normalization factor . with @xmath432 , the normalization condition @xmath433 yields @xmath434 . since there is no @xmath435 dependence @xmath436 where @xmath437 is the appropriate unit vector . consequently ( [ eq_psi ] ) leads to @xmath438

the force laws governing the extension behavior of homopolypeptides are obtained from a phenomenological free energy capable of describing the helix - coil transition . just above the melting temperature of the free chains , @xmath0 , the plot of force , @xmath1 , _ vs. _ end - to - end distance , @xmath2 , exhibits two plateaus associated with coexistence of helical and coil domains . the lower plateau is due to tension induced onset of helix - coil transition . the higher plateau corresponds to the melting of the helices by overextension . just below @xmath0 the @xmath3 plot exhibits only the upper plateau . the @xmath3 plots , the helical fraction , the number of domains and their polydispersity are calculated for two models : in one the helical domains are viewed as rigid rods while in the second they are treated as worm like chains . 2

1307.7981

we are concerned with the problem of speaker detection , where an automatic speaker recognizer is used to decide whether or not the voice of a designated target speaker is present in a given speech segment . current speaker recognition algorithms output uncalibrated _ scores _ , which have to be processed through a calibration stage before cost effective decisions can be made . this paper deals with the problem of designing the calibration stage . we implement the calibration stage in the form of a discriminative model , say @xmath0 , which outputs a posterior probability that the target speaker spoke the speech segment : @xmath1 . the trial score , @xmath2 , is computed by the speaker recognizer as a function of the target speaker and the speech segment . this posterior can be used in a straight - forward , standard way to make minimum - expected - cost bayes decisions . we shall take as the baseline discriminative model prior - weighted logistic regression @xcite , which has become a standard recipe for calibration in speaker recognition , with implementations available in the focal @xcite and bosaris @xcite toolkits . logistic regression is the minimization of the expected value of a special cost function , known as the _ logarithmic proper scoring rule_. we are interested here in generalizing this recipe by modifying the cost function . our motivation derives from @xcite , where it was demonstrated that a modified logistic regression that ignores scores below a suitable threshold can benefit applications with low false - alarm rate requirements . in this work we limit ourselves to cost functions which are _ proper scoring rules _ @xcite . we expand on our previous work @xcite , to demonstrate theoretically and experimentally that we can tailor proper scoring rules to target the low false - alarm region . given a database of supervised trials , the sum over trials of a proper scoring rule forms an objective function that can be used to simply evaluate the goodness of a recognizer with probabilistic output , and indeed also to facilitate discriminative training of such recognizers . we restrict ourselves to _ binary _ proper scoring rules , a family of special cost functions of the form @xmath3 , which evaluates the goodness of the recognizer output @xmath4 , for a trial where hypothesis @xmath5 is true . we use the notation @xmath6 for a trial where the target speaker spoke and @xmath7 for one where some other speaker spoke . in what follows it will be convenient to work with recognizer outputs in the form of posterior probabilities : @xmath8 , where @xmath2 is the uncalibrated trial score and @xmath0 is the calibration model . later we show how to adapt this to recognizer outputs in likelihood - ratio form . a binary proper scoring can be seen as a _ model of an application _ of a detector or more generally , a mixture of such applications . an application , @xmath9 , is represented by a cost function @xmath10 , which maps outcomes to real - valued consequences . the outcome is composed of the decision , @xmath11 , and the true hypothesis , @xmath12 . the sets from which decisions are chosen may differ between applications , for example @xmath13 , or @xmath14 , and so on . our application model assumes that the detector output , @xmath4 , is used to make a minimum - expected - cost bayes decision : @xmath15 the associated _ proper scoring rule _ is defined as the cost of this decision @xcite : @xmath16 a convex combination of proper scoring rules is still a proper scoring rule , in the sense that it can be derived via from a suitably constructed cost function that represents a mixture of different applications @xcite . although applications may be defined via a large variety of cost functions , all of this variety can be conveniently represented in a surprisingly simple form @xcite . all binary proper scoring rules can be expressed in the form : @xmath17 where @xmath18 , @xmath19 and @xmath20 . the constants @xmath21 do nt play any useful role in the bayes decision framework and may be set to @xmath22 and @xmath23 without loss of generality @xcite . the weighting distribution @xmath24 can be very general , including smooth functions , step functions or even impulses . the impulse @xmath25 represents a single , _ simple application _ , with binary decisions in @xmath13 , a cost function with penalties @xmath26 and @xmath27 and the bayes decision threshold at @xmath28 . a sum of impulses represents a discrete mixture of applications , while a smooth function represents a continuous mixture over a continuous spectrum of applications . the important point here is that all bayes decision applications ( or mixtures of applications ) can be represented by via a suitable choice of @xmath24 . here we build an objective function , for training or evaluation , out of a proper scoring rule , @xmath29 . the proper scoring rule models the cost of making a bayes decision in a single detection trial . to turn this into an objective function , we take the _ expected _ cost over a whole supervised database . we form this expectation via two hypothesis conditional averages , weighted by a synthetic class prior ( usually different from the database proportions ) , of the form @xmath30 , @xmath31 . the expected cost is : @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the recognizer s posterior for trial @xmath34 ; @xmath35 is a set of @xmath36 target trial indices ; and @xmath37 a set of @xmath38 non - target indices . now , we relieve the calibrator of the ( implicit ) responsibility to have a hypothesis prior and to produce posteriors . instead , we require it to output _ log - likelihood - ratios _ , denoted @xmath39 . since the prior is already fixed as a parameter of the objective , the recognizer s posterior is given by bayes rule as : as the ratio of two generative likelihoods adds no value . instead should be taken as the definition of @xmath39 . ] @xmath40 where @xmath41 is prior log odds and @xmath42 is the logistic sigmoid : @xmath43 after some manipulation , we can express the functions of @xmath33 in as functions of @xmath39 instead : @xmath44 where @xmath45 is a translated and modulated version of @xmath24 , where the modulation factor : @xmath46 is a raised and scaled sigmoid . if @xmath24 is normalized , then @xmath47 is normalizable in the sense : @xmath48 . the integrals in can be interpreted as averaging over all possible cost functions , where @xmath24 determines the relative importance of different cost functions . in our construction of the objective function , we inherit this averaging over cost functions , but we seem to have fixed the prior at @xmath49 . since different applications of a speaker detector can be expected to have different priors , should we not also average over @xmath49 ? we can , but it adds no generality , because this would effectively just replace @xmath47 in by some other normalized / normalizable weighting distribution , say @xmath50 . we can now reformulate our objective function in its most general form as : @xmath51 where @xmath52 we now have a general objective function , parametrized by @xmath50 , which effectively determines the relative weighting over a mixture of different applications , each of which can have a different cost function and target prior . notice that @xmath53 is just the log - likelihood - ratio threshold . simple @xmath54/@xmath55 applications use a single threshold , while more complex applications ( or mixtures ) have multiple thresholds . thus , the combination of application costs in is accomplished via representing applications by their thresholds . here we introduce a practical choice for the weighting distribution , @xmath50 and show how it is used for calibration . since calibration involves optimization , smooth differentiable distributions are easier to work with . it is also desirable that the integrals have closed - form solutions . to this end , we adopt a 2-parameter ( here @xmath56 ) family of proper scoring rules proposed in @xcite . this family is effectively augmented by a third parameter , @xmath57 , via the prior - weighting in . this gives @xmath58 : @xmath59 where @xmath60 ; @xmath61 is defined in ; @xmath62 ensures the distribution is normalized ; and @xmath63 is the beta distribution , transformed to log - odds domain : @xmath64 and @xmath65 is the beta function . when @xmath66 , then using @xmath67 in gives closed - form solutions , which can be plugged into , with @xmath68 and @xmath69 . while this recipe is practically realized via and , a theoretical interpretation is given by and , because for this parametrization we have @xmath70 . we exploit this in figure [ fig : omega ] , where we plot for several values of the parameters . parameters @xmath56 control left and right tails respectively when they are increased tails become thinner and the distributions become narrower ( higher modes ) . location is indirectly controlled by @xmath41 , but this depends on @xmath56 . for the case @xmath71 , the distribution is _ invariant _ to @xmath41 . for @xmath72 , the mode shifts only as far as @xmath73 , while the distribution is considerably widened . however , when @xmath74 , the mode shifts close to @xmath75 and the widening is less dramatic . we show in our experiments below that when we target applications with high thresholds ( low false - alarm rate ) , then the effective shifting allowed by @xmath74 leads to better performance than the halfway shifted and stretched version given by the baseline logistic regression solution with @xmath72 . here we list some solutions for the integrals in , which we used in our experiments . the _ boosting rule _ @xcite , with @xmath71 : @xmath76 the _ logarithmic rule _ , with @xmath72 , forms the objective function for logistic regression and is our baseline : @xmath77 the parametrization @xmath78 gives ( up to scaling ) , the objective @xmath79 , proposed in @xcite for the evaluation of goodness of recognizers with likelihood - ratio output . the _ brier rule _ @xcite , with @xmath80 : @xmath81 an _ asymmetric _ rule , with @xmath82 : @xmath83 we assume that our recognizers output uncalibrated scores . let the score for a trial @xmath34 be denoted @xmath84 . we then apply a parametric ( affine ) calibration transformation : @xmath85 the calibration parameters @xmath86 need to be trained on a calibration training database . for training purposes , we choose and fix the parameters @xmath87 and then minimize the objective w.r.t . @xmath86 . in the special case @xmath72 such training is known as logistic regression . since the objective and the calibration transformation are differentiable , one can obtain the gradient w.r.t . @xmath86 by backpropagation and then use any of a variety of well - known unconstrained numerical optimization algorithms . for this work , we used bfgs @xcite . we performed calibration experiments on scores from a single speaker recognizer ( an i - vector plda system ) , which was part of the abc submission @xcite to the nist sre12 speaker recognition evaluation . several calibration transformations of the form were trained ( separately for males and females ) on a large development set with multiple microphone and telephone speech segments of 2019 speakers from sre04 , 05 , 06 , 08 and 10 . this gave about 120 million scores for calibration training . the different calibration transformations were obtained by using different objective function parameters , @xmath87 . we tested the goodness of these calibrators on the nist sre12 extended trial set @xcite , where we pooled males and females and all 5 common evaluation conditions , giving about 80 million trials . our evaluation criterion was @xmath88 , with @xmath89 , as defined in @xcite . it should be noted that this criterion can _ also _ be interpreted as an example of our objective function , since @xmath90 , if we choose @xmath91 , defined as : @xmath92 which is concentrated in two impulses ] at the log - likelihood - ratio threshold values of @xmath93 and @xmath94 . this criterion was chosen by nist to be calibration - sensitive , but only in the ` low false - alarm region ' around these operating points . our experimental results are summarized in figure [ fig : results ] , where we plotted @xmath88 obtained by using the calibrators formed by three representative proper scoring rules against the prior - weighting parameter , @xmath57 . our baseline ( blue triangles ) is logistic regression ( @xmath72 ) . the other two rules with @xmath74 ( red circles , green asterisks ) , gave better performance in the sense of having lower , wider minima . the boosting rule ( @xmath71 ) performed very poorly , at @xmath95 , and is not shown on the graph . its thick tails makes it vulnerable to outliers . the reason why different proper scoring rules perform differently is that the affine calibration transformation is limiting . it can not satisfy the requirement of good calibration at all operating points simultaneously . we have to choose , via @xmath50 , which operating points are important and which can be ignored . this is illustrated in figure [ fig : pav ] , where we compare the log - likelihood - ratios produced for sre12 by two of the proper scoring rule calibrations ( horizontal axis ) , against ideal , reference log - likelihood - ratios ( vertical axis ) . ideally these plots should lie along the identity transform ( the black diagonal through the origin ) . but the affine calibration transformation can only try to fit these curves to the ideal straight line via scaling and shifting the curves along the horizontal axis . the logistic regression ( @xmath72 ) places more weight at lower threshold values and indeed manages to be closer to the ideal there , to the detriment of calibration at the higher @xmath96 operating points . on the other hand , the brier rule ( @xmath80 ) , which places more weight at the @xmath96 operating points , does better there , but pays for this by doing worse at lower threshold values . the ideal reference along the vertical axis of figure [ fig : pav ] is achieved via an optimization algorithm known as _ pool adjacent violators _ ( pav)@xcite . this algorithm finds the optimal log - likelihood - ratio value for every trial non - parametrically , subject only to the constraint that when sorted along the real line , the order of the optimized values must be the same as the sorted order of the original uncalibrated scores . this is equivalent to constraining the calibration transformation to be monotonically rising . the pav output is optimal in the sense that it simultaneously optimizes all binary proper scoring rules at all values of the prior weighting @xcite . the pav solution can be optimal everywhere because the non - parametric monotonicity constraint is less strict than the parametric affine transformation available to the proper scoring rule calibrators . it is important to note however that the true sre12 class labels were used to perform the pav optimization , while the proper scoring rule calibrations were optimized on the independent development data . if the pav had been optimized on the development data , it would no longer have this optimality on the evaluation data . very similar to the best proper scoring rule results shown in figure [ fig : results ] . the details are out of scope for this paper . ] conclusions from our experimental results should not be extrapolated without caution . the superiority demonstrated here of rules with @xmath97 may not hold for : ( i ) small calibration training databases ; ( ii ) other recognizers ; ( iii ) applications with thresholds in other operating regions . the objective function family presented here could be more generally applied , not just for calibration . these objectives could be used for fusion of multiple recognizers , or indeed for more general discriminative training of speaker recognizers in the manner of @xcite . however for more complex recognizers , the risk of overtraining is greater and this risk may be compounded by more narrowly focussed objectives , such as the brier rule . in contrast , the wider focus of the logarithmic rule has a regularizing effect , which combats overtraining . 10 niko brmmer et al . `` fusion of heterogeneous speaker recognition systems in the stbu submission for the nist speaker recognition evaluation 2006 '' , ieee transactions on audio , speech , and language processing , september 2007 . niko brmmer and johan du preez , `` application - independent evaluation of speaker detection '' , computer speech and language , 2006 . niko brmmer and edward de villiers , `` the bosaris toolkit : theory , algorithms and code for surviving the new dcf '' , nist sre11 analysis workshop , atlanta , december 2011 . online : http://sites.google.com/site/bosaristoolkit . george doddington , `` the role of score calibration in speaker recognition '' , interspeech , portland , september 2012 . tilmann gneiting and adrian e. raftery , `` strictly proper scoring rules , prediction , and estimation '' , journal of the american statistical association , vol . 359378 , march 2007 . niko brmmer , `` the role of proper scoring rules in training and evaluating probabilistic speaker and language recognizers '' , invited talk , odyssey 2012 : the speaker and language recognition workshop , singapore , 2012 . online : http://www.odyssey2012.org/plenary.html . morris h. degroot , _ optimal statistical decisions _ , mcgraw - hill , 1970 . niko brmmer , `` measuring , refining and calibrating speaker and language information extracted from speech '' , ph.d . dissertation , university of stellenbosch , december 2010 . andreas buja , werner stuetzle , and yi shen , `` loss functions for binary class probability estimation and classification : structure and applications '' , technical report , statistics department , the wharton school , university of pennsylvania , november 2005 . glenn w. brier , `` verification of forecasts expressed in terms of probability '' , monthly weather review , vol.78 , no.1 , pp . 13 , january 1950 . jorge nocedal and stephen j. wright , _ numerical optimization _ , 2nd edition , springer 2006 . agnitio , but , crim , `` abc sre12 presentation '' , nist sre 2012 workshop , orlando , december 2012 . `` the nist year 2012 speaker recognition evaluation plan '' 2012 . online : http://www.nist.gov/itl/iad/mig/upload/nist_sre12_evalplan-v17-r1.pdf . bianca zadrozny and charles elkan , `` transforming classifier scores into accurate multiclass probability estimates '' , in proceedings of the eighth international conference on knowledge discovery and data mining , edmonton , alberta , canada , 2002 , pp . burget , l. et al . , `` discriminatively trained probabilistic linear discriminant analysis for speaker verification '' , ieee icassp , prague , 2011 .

prior - weighted logistic regression has become a standard tool for calibration in speaker recognition . logistic regression is the optimization of the expected value of the logarithmic scoring rule . we generalize this via a parametric family of proper scoring rules . our theoretical analysis shows how different members of this family induce different relative weightings over a spectrum of applications of which the decision thresholds range from low to high . special attention is given to the interaction between prior weighting and proper scoring rule parameters . experiments on nist sre12 suggest that for applications with low false - alarm rate requirements , scoring rules tailored to emphasize higher score thresholds may give better accuracy than logistic regression . * index terms * : speaker recognition , calibration , proper scoring rule

1205.2395

stripped supernovae ( sne ) and long - duration gamma - ray bursts ( long grbs ) are nature s most powerful explosions from massive stars . they energize and enrich the interstellar medium , and , like beacons , they are visible over large cosmological distances . however , the mass and metallicity range of their progenitors is not known , nor the detailed physics of the explosion ( see reviews by @xcite and @xcite ) . stripped - envelope sne ( i.e , sne of types iib , ib , and ic , e.g. , @xcite ) are core - collapse events whose massive progenitors have been stripped of progressively larger amounts of their outermost h and he envelopes ( fig . [ fig1 ] ) . in particular , broad - lined sne ic ( sne ic - bl ) are sne ic whose line widths approach 20,000@xmath030,000 @xmath1 around maximum light ( see below ) and whose optical spectra show no trace of h and he . for the last 15 years , the exciting connection between long grbs and sne ic - bl , the only type of sne observed accompanying long grbs ( for reviews , see @xcite ) , and the existence of many more sne ic - bl _ without _ grbs raises the question of what distinguishes sn - grb progenitors from those of ordinary sne ic - bl without grbs . viewing angle effects are probably not the reason why those sne ic - bl did not show an accompanied grbs @xcite and based the same radio upper - limits , only @xmath2 1% of sne ib / c appear to be accompanied by grbs @xcite . one promising line of attack is to investigate what sets apart sne ib / c * with * grbs from those * without * grbs to elucidate the conditions and progenitors of these two types of explosions . while of course there are numerous possible avenues ( for a recent review see e.g. , @xcite ) , i will here adopt a two - thronged approach , given the short amount of time : first , i focus on comparing the optical spectra of sne ib / c with and without grbs , since early - time optical spectra are used for identifying the spectral features of different explosions and probe the bulk of the ejected stellar material , in particular the outermost layers . secondly , i present a meta - analysis of published measured metallicities at the explosion site of sne ib / c with and without grbs . metallicity is expected to strongly impact the lives and deaths of stars due to the metallicity dependence of mass loss ( e.g. , @xcite ) and its subsequent link to rotation and angular momentum content of the stellar core . the main thrust of my talk is that now a number of different groups , including ours , have contributed to gathering large data - sets , whose analysis can to lead to robust statistical conclusions and interesting insights into different populations of sne with and without grbs . while the observational hallmark of a sn ic - bl is , by the definition , its high expansion velocity ( which , when modeled in combination with light curves , yields high energies , sometimes above @xmath3 erg , i.e. 10 times more than the canonical ccsn , and thus motivated some to call them `` hypernovae '' ) , there are debates within the community whether such sne ic - bl can be robustly distinguished from `` normal '' sne ic and whether there are systematic differences between sne ic - bl with and without grbs . prior work involving synthetic models based on monte carlo radiative transfer codes ( @xcite and reference therein ) , while important , has included only a few normal sne ic and a few sn ic - bl without grbs , thus not yet providing a large sample . here we are using the spectra from the cfa sample of stripped sne ( modjaz et al . in prep ) , as well as those from the literature ( see references in modjaz et al . in prep ) to compare the absorption velocities as traced by fe ii @xmath45169 of different kinds of sne ic . spectral synthesis studies have shown that this and other fe lines are good tracers of the photospheric velocity , since they do not saturate @xcite . with the largest sample of spectra to date , we find that sn ic - bl * with * grbs have the * highest * absorption velocities ( 25,000@xmath035,000 @xmath1 at maximum v - light ) , while sne ic - bl * without * grbs have * lower * velocities ( between 15,000@xmath025,000 @xmath1 at maximum v - light ) , and normal sn ic have the lowest absorption velocities ( 8,000@xmath015,000 @xmath1 ) . of course , we caution that because of sever blending , specifically in sne ic - bl , the fe ii @xmath45169 line could be blended with other nearby lines in a manner such that it may compromise the velocity measurements . however other , more isolated , lines ( e.g. si ii ) also indicate high velocities for sn ic - bl . = 8.9 ( levesque et al . 2010a ) . , width=345 ] since direct sn ib / c progenitor detection attempts via deep pre - explosion images have not been successful @xcite and are impossible for grbs , we employ a complimentary approach : we study the host galaxy environments in order to discern any systematic trends as a function explosion type that may characterize their stellar progenitors . specifically , massive stars at different metallicities are expected to live and die differently , due to the metallicity dependence of mass loss and its subsequent link to rotation and angular momentum content of the stellar core ( e.g. , @xcite ) . since the early work on grb host metallicities and their comparison with sdss galaxies as well as with sn galaxies , the field of environmental metallicity studies has experienced a tremendous growth ( see discussions in e.g. , levesque et al . 2010a , @xcite and references therein , as well as contributions in this volume ) . here , we outline the recipe for state - of - the - art metallicity analysis , specifically of the oxygen abundance from nebular hii region emission lines , first formalized in @xcite : 1 ) in order to probe the natal oxygen abundance , obtain spectra at the position of the sn or grb ( because of metallicity gradients in spiral galaxies ) ; 2 ) include only sne with secure sn i d ( i.e. , ideally from multi - epoch sn spectra to monitor for any potential classification changes ) and also ( only ) from untargetted surveys in order to mitigate any selection effects ; 3 ) employ spectrographs with a large wavelength range in order to observe emission lines ( from [ oii ] @xmath43727 to h@xmath5 and [ nii ] @xmath46584 ) as to compute abundances in different diagnostics , since there are systematic differences between different diagnostics @xcite ; 4 ) remove stellar absorption in spectra when necessary , and 5 ) obtain good handle on uncertainty budget and propagate line flux and reddening uncertainties into abundance measurement errors via monte carlo simulations . while recently different groups have arrived at different conclusions about whether there is a statistically significant trend of metallicity with stripped sn subtype ( @xcite , see also proceedings by anderson , leloudas in this volume ) , not all measured metallicities reported in the anderson and leloudas et al samples are at the position of the sne . thus , we conducted a meta - analysis of all samples @xcite with the best - possible quality - control and following the above state - of - the - art recipe , now that we have larger samples to draw from : we only included oxygen abundance measurements at the exact sn explosion sites ( within the slit ) of sne with solid ids and also from untargeted surveys , to have the best handle possible on the natal metallicity estimates of sne with well - determined sn types over a large metallicity baseline , the ultimate goal of the study . figure [ oxyfig ] shows the result of our metal - analysis , namely the cumulative distributions of local metallicities for different types of stripped ccsne ( sne ib , ic , ic - bl without grbs , sne ic - bl with grbs ) from the combined samples . we find that with a combined and large sample size , the sites of sne ic do indeed have higher oxygen abundances than sne ib , and with a higher statistical significance than in the individual samples . there is only a 0.1% ( 2% ) probability in the pp04-n2 ( pp04-o3n2 ) scale that the oxygen abundances of the 19 ( 17 ) sne ib and of 20 ( 18 ) sne ic are drawn from the same parent population , which are different on average by @xmath20.2 dex . here we have taken advantage of the power of statistics by combining the hard work of three different groups . in addition , sn ic - bl with grbs still prefer , on average , more metal - poor environments than those without grbs ( see fig . 2 in @xcite ) , with the grb metallicity - luminosity relation offset to lower metallicities , but without a cut - off metallicity above which grb production would be suppressed ( levesque et al . 2010b ) . since the host galaxies of both samples span similar range in galaxy luminosity ( i.e , . even to luminous grb host galaxies of @xmath6 mag ) , dust effects are most likely not the reason for the offset to low metallicity . however , while these results are intriguing , the next step is to conduct a thorough and extensive host galaxy study with a large single - survey , untargeted , spectroscopically classified , and homogeneous collection of stripped sne , something we are currently undertaking with the palomar transient factory ( ptf ) . m.m . acknowledges current support from the nyu advance women - in - science travel grant funded by the nsf advance - paid award number hrd-0820202 and prior support from hubble fellowship grant hst - hf-51277.01-a .

while the connection between long gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) and type ib / c supernovae ( sne ib / c ) from stripped stars has been well - established , one key outstanding question is what conditions and factors lead to each kind of explosion in massive stripped stars . one promising line of attack is to investigate what sets apart sne ib / c * with * grbs from those * without * grbs . here , i briefly present two observational studies that probe the sn properties and the environmental metallicities of sne ib / c ( specifically broad - lined sne ic ) with and without grbs . i present an analysis of expansion velocities based on published spectra and on the homogeneous spectroscopic cfa data set of over 70 sne of types iib , ib , ic and ic - bl , which triples the world supply of well - observed stripped sne . moreover , i demonstrate that a meta - analysis of the three published sn ib / c metallicity data sets , when including only values at the sn positions to probe natal oxygen abundances , indicates at very high significance that indeed sne ic erupt from more metal - rich environments than sne ib , while sne ic - bl with grbs still prefer , on average , more metal - poor sites than those without grbs .

astro-ph9909001

the transformation of photometric observations from one filter system to another is rarely a trivial task . this is especially true for observations of cool giants at near - ir wavelengths because of the presence of very deep molecular absorption bands both in the stars themselves ( eg . co and h@xmath2o ) and in the earth s atmosphere ( eg . co@xmath2 and h@xmath2o ) . examples of such transformations may be found in bessell & brett ( 1988 ) and elias et _ al . _ ( 1983 ) . because of these molecular bands the transformation equations can be dependent not only on stellar color , but also on absolute luminosity and stellar metallicity . for the hubble space telescope ( hst ) near infrared camera and multi - object spectrograph ( nicmos ) filters on camera 2 ( nic2 ; @xcite ) that have been used as pseudo-@xmath3 filters , the transformation to a standard ground - based system presents a particularly difficult case . this is because the commonly used nic2 filters ( f110w for @xmath4 , f160w for @xmath5 , and f222 m for @xmath6 ) differ significantly from the commonly used ground - based filters ( @xcite ) ; also there are no telluric absorption features in hst observations . nonetheless , many scientific programs , including our own , will require accurate ( uncertainties no worse than a few percent ) knowledge of these transformations . in order to derive accurate color transformations , we devoted two orbits of one of our observing programs ( go-7826 ) to gathering observations of cool , metal rich giants that have extensive ground - based observations on the cit / ctio system . these giants are all in the baade s window field of the galactic bulge . the brighter ones and a few of the fainter ones had previously been observed with the same single channel photometric system that was used to establish the cit / ctio grid of southern standards ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . the remainder of the fainter stars had previously been observed with a nicmos array by tiede et _ al . _ ( 1995 ) . this paper presents our hst - nicmos observations of these previously observed bulge giants which span the color range of @xmath0 . section two outlines our observations ; the reduction procedures are discussed in section three . a comparison with ground - based measurements and the color transformations are in section four . the final section is a brief summary . the targets were originally observed on 1998 , august 19 with hst , but problems encountered while traversing the south atlantic anomaly caused a loss of tracking . thanks to the gracious reallotment of time by the telescope time review board ( ttrb ) , our fields were reobserved on 1998 , october 28 . of the first observation attempt , we were only able to confidently salvage the observations of the first target , thus our quoted bw1 measurements are actually the average of measurements made on both visits . our observations consist of eight pointings in baade s window ( henceforth referred to as bw1-bw8 ) , from which we have obtained measurements of 19 stars previously observed from the ground . we will refer to these stars as `` standard '' stars . the first field ( bw1 ) is a small part of the `` bw4b '' field observed by @xcite ( see fig . this field is fairly rich , and includes 12 stars observed by tiede et _ al . _ ( 1995 ) . the remaining 7 fields ( bw2-bw8 ) are of single stars observed previously by frogel & whitford ( 1987 ) . the coordinates of each field are given in table 1 . our observations were taken with the nicmos camera 2 ( nic2 ) which has a plate scale of @xmath7 00757 pixel@xmath8 giving nic2 a field of view of 194 on a side ( 376 arcsec@xmath9 ) . the nicmos focus was set at the compromise position 1 - 2 , which optimizes the focus for simultaneous observations with cameras 1 and 2 . each field was observed in three filters : f110w ( @xmath10 ) , f160w ( @xmath11 ) , and f222 m ( @xmath12 ) , using a spiral dither pattern with 4 positions ( see section 4 for a discussion of the filters ) . we used 04 steps on bw1 to maximize the size of the overlapping field , and 5 0 steps on bw2-bw8 to minimize the effects of residual images from the bright stars . all of our observations used the multiaccum mode ( @xcite ) because of its optimization of the detector s dynamic range and cosmic ray rejection . the bw1 field used the predefined sample sequences step2 , step8 and step16 with 12 , 11 , and 14 samples in @xmath4 , @xmath5 , and @xmath6 respectively , yielding exposure times of 18 , 48 , and 128 seconds . fields bw2-bw8 implemented the multiaccum sample sequence scamrr , designed for fast temporal sampling with a single camera , which performs a nondestructive read every 0.203 seconds , yielding typical exposure times of 0.41 seconds for each of the four dither positions . table 1 lists the total exposure times in each filter for all targets . cosmic ray ( cr ) rejection using the multiaccum mode requires many intermediate reads . since most of our targets are of bright stars , our required exposure times were very short with only two to four intermediate reads during each exposure , an inadequate number for effective cr rejection . we therefore rely on the four dither positions for cr and bad - pixel rejection . c c c r r r bw1 & 18 03 49.9 & -30 02 06.6 & 71.76 & 191.80 & 511.68 + bw2 & 18 03 52.6 & -30 01 23.1 & 1.64 & 1.64 & 1.64 + bw3 & 18 03 46.1 & -29 59 12.5 & 1.64 & 1.64 & 1.64 + bw4 & 18 03 34.1 & -29 59 58.5 & 2.44 & 1.64 & 1.64 + bw5 & 18 03 46.1 & -30 02 23.6 & 1.64 & 1.64 & 1.64 + bw6 & 18 03 44.3 & -30 03 41.7 & 3.24 & 1.64 & 1.64 + bw7 & 18 03 43.7 & -30 05 15.8 & 3.24 & 1.64 & 1.64 + bw8 & 18 03 33.3 & -30 05 21.4 & 1.64 & 1.64 & 1.64 + our data were reduced using three different techniques . the first technique was the standard stsci pipeline . afterwards we performed our own reductions with the nicred v. 1.8 package dated 01/29/99 ( @xcite , @xcite ) , and with the stsci pipeline using the iraf nicproto package ( may 1999 ) to eliminate any residual pedestal . all the reductions use flat fields and dark frames provided by stsci , although we generated our own bad pixel masks for the nicred and nicproto reductions . not too surprisingly , all of these methods give similar photometric results , with no apparent systematic deviations and typical dispersions of @xmath13 magnitudes . although the images produced by nicred appear cleaner in terms of crs and bad pixels , all of our photometric measurements have been made off the frames reduced with the stsci pipeline and iraf nicproto package . aperture photometry was performed according to the guidelines set down by stsci ` ( http://www.stsci.edu/ftp/instrument_news/nicmos/nicmos_doc_phot.html ) ` for point - sources observed with nic2 . in our case we used the iraf phot routine with a 05 aperture and a @xmath14 sky annulus placed directly outside the aperture , assuming a nic2 plate scale of 00757 pixel@xmath8 . the measured count rate of each star was multiplied by 1.15 to correct to an infinite aperture , and then converted to flux using the nicmos photometric keywords released december 1 , 1998 , obtained from ` http://www.stsci.edu/ftp/instrument_news/nicmos/nicmos_phot/keywords.html ` , and listed in table 2 . finally the fluxes were converted to magnitudes using the parameters shown in table 2 . ( note that the photzpts in table 2 are _ not _ those given by stsci , but have been calculated to force the transformation to the cit / ctio system to be zero at zero ( @xmath15 ) color , as can be seen in eqn . one should also note that there are several methods of converting dn to magnitudes . two ways are to use either photflam & photzpt or photfnu & zp(vega ) , which are not equivalent and give different magnitudes ( because of a zero - point shift ) . we present our nicmos magnitudes ( ie . @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 ) as obtained using photfnu & zp(vega ) so that we can directly compare our observations with the stsci standards ( see table 4 ) , but we have calculated the transformations for both methods ( eqns . 4 - 7 ) . another method , and the easiest of these presented , is to use our transformations to go directly from instrumental magnitudes to cit / ctio magnitudes ( see eqns . 8 - 9 ) . c c c c c f110w & 4.292364e-19 & 23.566 & 1.823290e-6 & 1898 + f160w & 2.406112e-19 & 24.546 & 2.070057e-6 & 1113 + f222 m & 3.217631e-19 & 26.131 & 5.280848e-6 & 653 + our measurements of the faint stars in our bw1 field are compared with the observations of tiede et _ al . _ ( 1995 ) . their observations were made on the 2.5 m dupont telescope at las campanas observatory with the ircam ( @xcite ) , which used a @xmath19 hgcdte nicmos 3 detector with a plate scale of 0.348 arcseconds pixel@xmath8 . their measurements were calibrated from 11 stars measured previously with single - channel photometry ( @xcite the same system used for the ground - based measurements of the stars in bw2-bw8 ) to the cit / ctio system ( @xcite , 1983 ) . these measurements have reported average errors given in fig . 3 of @xcite ( @xmath20 ) , and calibration errors of @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 magnitudes . our measurements of the single stars in fields bw2-bw8 are compared with the measurements of frogel & whitford ( 1987 ) . these were obtained on the ctio 4 m and the d3 insb system , and transformed to the cit / ctio standard system . note that their published table 1 is corrected for reddening and extinction by @xmath24 , @xmath25 , and @xmath26 , while our values are uncorrected . in figure 2 we have plotted the difference between the ground - based measurements and our nicmos photfnu & zp(vega ) calibrated measurements against color for each filter . these plots show that a color term is required to bring the nicmos data into agreement with ground - based observations . by applying a linear fit to the data , giving stars fainter than @xmath27 half weight ( points with @xmath28 ) , we have calculated the appropriate transformations ( eqns . 4 - 9 ) . as discussed in section 3 , stsci supplies two sets of keywords for converting count rates to magnitudes . to eliminate confusion , equations 1 - 3 explicitly state how the magnitudes used in calculating our transformations were determined . @xmath29 where cr@xmath30 is the count rate measured in a 05 aperture . using the photfnu & zp(vega ) keywords to calculate @xmath31 : @xmath32 @xmath33 using the photflam & _ our _ photzpt ( from table 2 ) to calculate @xmath31 : @xmath34 @xmath35 going directly from raw instrumental nicmos magnitudes : @xmath36 @xmath37 these transformations are required due to the differences between cit / ctio and nicmos filter bandpasses . the nicmos f110w filter is more than twice as wide as the @xmath4 filter and extends 0.3 bluer . the f160w filter is about 35% wider than the @xmath5 filter and extends 0.1 bluer , while the f222 m filter is about half as wide as the @xmath6 filter . since nicmos observations are sensitive to wavelengths at which radiation is completely absorbed by the earth s atmosphere , any transformation between nicmos and ground - based systems will only be valid for stars with similar spectral features . we therefore must emphasize that our transformations are only for late - type stars with molecular absorption bands , especially h@xmath2o and co , and would not accurately transform heavily reddened blue stars for example . stsci has observed six stars with nicmos in order to establish a transformation between the f110w , f160w , and f222 m filters and their ground - based counterparts @xmath38 . only five of these stars have accurate @xmath38 ground - based measurements available ( table 4 ) ; these are over - plotted in figure 3 . the nicmos measurements have been calibrated on the zp(vega ) system . the one star which lies in our color range is in excellent agreement with our observations and the other four allow us to estimate an extension of our transformation beyond the color limits of our sample . the one potential problem with considering the stsci stars outside our color range is that they are not all late - type stars with significant molecular absorption bands . the two stars blue - ward of our sample are both g stars , and except for the @xmath5 band , are consistent with our derived transformation . the two stars red - ward of our sample consist of a heavily reddened b star and an m3 star , which seem to indicate that a change in slope occurs around @xmath39 , at which point the transformation slopes drop to zero , maintaining a constant offset . these offsets are approximately -0.68 , -0.19 , and -0.01 for @xmath4,@xmath5 , and @xmath6 respectively . low - resolution infrared spectra of six late - type stars with colors in the range @xmath40 and @xmath41 cma ( a1 v ) were taken above the atmosphere with a balloon - borne telescope ( @xcite ) . convolving these spectra with the band - passes of the hst filters and instrument throughput , we simulate nicmos photometric observations . simulated ground - based photometry was produced by convolving the same spectra with @xmath3 filter band - passes and a transmission profile of the earth s atmosphere . this analysis yields slopes similar to the ones we derived above using actual photometric observations ( figure 3 ) , in that the f110w and f160w filters give magnitudes too faint for redder stars , while the f222 m filter gives magnitudes too bright for redder stars . in figure 3 the late - type stars are represented by filled circles and are the only points used for the linear least - squares fit . it is important to note that slopes obtained from the simulation are close to those of our transformations given in eqn . 4 ( the intercepts are merely zero - point shifts and are irrelevant in this analysis ) . the main uncertainty comes from the need to extrapolate the woolf et _ al . _ ( 1960 ) spectra which only go down to @xmath42 to the lower transmission limit of the nicmos f110w filter at @xmath43 . in order to simulate the heavily reddened b star in the stsci standards , we have artificially reddened the a star @xmath41 cma with @xmath44 of 3.5 and 4.0 , using the nir extinction law from mathis ( 1990 ) of @xmath45 . these are the two open circles which lie at @xmath46 of @xmath7 2.7 and 3.1 . this a star seems to confirm that the transformation is valid much bluer than our sample for earlier type stars , while the reddened a star also shows the same change in slope which was indicated by the stsci sample . thus the reddened a star validates our technique of simulating photometry in that we can reproduce what was observed not only for the late - type stars but for the stsci reddened b star as well . l r r r r | l r r r r r r r bw4b & 135 & 14.899 & 14.264 & 14.092 & bw1 & 25 & 15.278 & 0.029 & 14.372 & 0.027 & 14.136 & 0.050 + bw4b & 138 & 14.920 & 14.395 & 14.144 & bw1 & 43 & 15.319 & 0.030 & 14.400 & 0.027 & 14.171 & 0.051 + bw4b & 241 & 16.028 & 0.000 & 15.343 & bw1 & 64 & 16.420 & 0.050 & 15.595 & 0.047 & 15.378 & 0.089 + bw4b & 406 & 17.017 & 16.506 & 16.217 & bw1 & 66 & 17.438 & 0.080 & 16.523 & 0.072 & 16.267 & 0.134 + bw4b & 475 & 17.223 & 0.000 & 16.462 & bw1 & 72 & 17.810 & 0.098 & 16.810 & 0.082 & 16.625 & 0.158 + bw4b & 349 & 16.544 & 16.292 & 15.985 & bw1 & 135 & 17.048 & 0.066 & 16.238 & 0.063 & 16.026 & 0.120 + bw4b & 385 & 16.744 & 0.000 & 16.157 & bw1 & 162 & 17.087 & 0.068 & 16.179 & 0.061 & 15.989 & 0.117 + bw4b & 358 & 16.824 & 16.391 & 16.012 & bw1 & 187 & 17.131 & 0.069 & 16.256 & 0.064 & 16.042 & 0.121 + bw4b & 115 & 14.718 & 14.084 & 13.805 & bw1 & 197 & 15.108 & 0.027 & 14.126 & 0.024 & 13.839 & 0.043 + bw4b & 460 & 17.262 & 16.831 & 16.380 & bw1 & 226 & 17.689 & 0.090 & 16.817 & 0.083 & 16.581 & 0.155 + bw4b & 413 & 17.121 & 0.000 & 16.229 & bw1 & 276 & 17.394 & 0.078 & 16.440 & 0.069 & 16.228 & 0.131 + bw4b & 181 & 15.602 & 15.053 & 14.764 & bw1 & 284 & 16.126 & 0.043 & 15.161 & 0.038 & 14.902 & 0.071 + bmb & 200 & 10.340 & 9.390 & 9.090 & bw2 & 6 & 10.765 & 0.007 & 9.497 & 0.005 & 9.066 & 0.010 + bmb & 179 & 8.600 & 7.510 & 7.010 & bw3 & 3 & 9.194 & 0.003 & 7.668 & 0.002 & 6.909 & 0.003 + bmb & 142 & 8.575 & 7.523 & 7.040 & bw4 & 6 & 9.276 & 0.003 & 7.695 & 0.002 & 6.991 & 0.003 + bmb & 176 & 8.690 & 7.700 & 7.310 & bw5 & 7 & 9.229 & 0.003 & 7.873 & 0.002 & 7.286 & 0.003 + bmb & 170 & 10.260 & 9.270 & 8.920 & bw6 & 9 & 10.806 & 0.007 & 9.485 & 0.004 & 8.948 & 0.007 + bmb & 165 & 9.680 & 8.660 & 8.220 & bw7 & 7 & 10.256 & 0.005 & 8.806 & 0.003 & 8.244 & 0.005 + bmb & 134 & 9.630 & 8.610 & 8.200 & bw8 & 10 & 10.250 & 0.005 & 8.873 & 0.003 & 8.262 & 0.006 + l c c c c c c c c c c c p330e & g & 11.816 & 0.007 & 11.479 & 0.005 & 11.419 & 0.007 & 12.01 & 11.57 & 11.49 & 0.02 + p177d & g & 12.258 & 0.012 & 11.924 & 0.008 & 11.857 & 0.013 & 12.47 & 12.02 & 11.93 & 0.02 + bri 0021 & m9.5 & 11.835 & 0.008 & 11.086 & 0.007 & 10.552 & 0.010 & 12.45 & 11.28 & 10.48 & 0.02 + oph - s1 & b & 8.800 & 0.015 & 7.270 & 0.015 & 6.330 & 0.015 & 9.48 & 7.44 & 6.36 & 0.02 + cskd-12 & m3 & 11.585 & 0.007 & 9.506 & 0.005 & 8.617 & 0.007 & 12.26 & 9.73 & 8.61 & 0.02 + l c c @xmath41 cma & a1 v & -0.202 + @xmath47 per & m4 ii - iii & 1.077 + @xmath41 ori & m2 - 3 iab & 1.208 + @xmath41 tau & k5 iii & 1.422 + @xmath48 gem & m3 iii & 1.558 + r leo & m8 & 1.823 + o cet & m9 & 2.192 + reddened cma & a1 v ( @xmath49 ) & 2.723 + reddened cma & a1 v ( @xmath50 ) & 3.075 + our observations reveal that a color correction is required to transform hst nicmos measurements to the cit / ctio photometric system . the photometric keywords are listed in table 2 , and the transformations are given in section 4 . the validity of the transformation is confirmed with photometry simulated by convolution of filter transmission curves with late - type stellar spectra taken above the atmosphere . the transformations we have derived are directly applicable only to nic2 because of differences in detectors , filters , and optics . they may serve as a guide for observations with nic1 and nic3 , but for precise photometry with these two cameras , a procedure similar to what we have done would need to be carried out . these transformations are also only valid for late - type stars with molecular absorption bands because nicmos is sensitive to wavelengths which never reach ground - based observatories . we would again like to thank the ttrb for granting us time to reacquire the observations lost to the south atlantic anomaly . support for this work was provided by nasa through grant number go-7826 from the space telescope science institute . daniela calzetti , antonella nota , and alfred schultz at stsci provided help in understanding our data . we would also like to thank glenn tiede for supplying us with the data for the bw4b field , brian mcleod for his help in using nicred , marcia rieke for her discussion on the stsci standards , and paul martini for helpful comments .

this paper presents color transformations for hst nicmos camera 2 observations to the ground - based cit / ctio photometric system , using observations of nineteen moderately bright , red stars in baade s window in the color range @xmath0 . we estimate an extension of the transformation to @xmath1 with five standards observed by stsci . convolving near - ir spectra taken above the atmosphere with different filter transmission profiles , we simulate both nicmos and ground - based photometry , obtaining results which are consistent with our transformation and its extension .

1208.1767

based on studies of the morphology - density relation in clusters ( dressler 1980 ) and groups ( wilman et al . 2009 ) , it has been suggested that lenticular ( s0 ) galaxies may be the descendants of spirals that have undergone some evolutionary process ( e.g. ram pressure stripping , galaxy harrassment , gas starvation and/or mergers ) . recent investigations of s0s have studied their metallicity gradients ( bedregal et al . 2011 ) , tully - fisher relation ( bedregal , aragon - salamanca & merrifield 2006 ) and stellar populations ( aragon - salamanca , bedregal & merrifield 2006 ) . however , the origin of s0s is still a subject of much debate ( e.g. kormendy & bender 2012 ) . the internal kinematics of galaxies are a key tool to understanding their structure and formation histories , and s0s are no exception . for example , the kinematics will be largely unaffected if s0s were formerly spirals that have been simply stripped of gas or if they were involved in a relatively minor merger . although half of the stellar mass within a galaxy lies within one effective radius ( r@xmath3 ) , more than 90% of the _ total _ mass and angular momentum does not ( romanowsky & fall 2012 ) . thus in order to examine the internal kinematics and total mass of early - type galaxies one must probe well beyond 1 r@xmath3 . elliptical and s0 ( early - type ) galaxies often lack the significant quantities of extended hi gas commonly found in spirals , so the kinematic tracers are the galaxy starlight itself , planetary nebulae ( pne ) and globular clusters ( gcs ) . using the underlying starlight of a galaxy to probe its stellar kinematics is perhaps the preferred method , however the surface brightness of a galaxy declines rapidly with increasing radius so it is very difficult to obtain high quality spectra beyond a few effective radii without a large investment of 8m - class telescope time ( coccato et al . 2010 ) or using deep single pointings ( weijmans et al . pne and gcs have the advantage that they are ubiquitous in the halos of early - type galaxies out to large galactocentric radii ( 510 r@xmath3 ) . although there have been several studies of pne and gc system kinematics in early - type galaxies , very few studies have directly compared them to each other , or to results from galaxy starlight over a common radial range . luminous pne are the end product of low mass stars . however , there is still debate as to whether they arise from normal single - star evolutionary processes or from mass transfer in a binary star system ( ciardullo et al . 2005 ) in the former case , the pne observed in early - type galaxies would have an age of @xmath01.5 gyr , and in the latter case they could be as old as 10 gyr . coccato et al . ( 2009 ) showed that the radial surface density of pne follows the galaxy starlight in early - type galaxies and that they are useful probes of galaxy kinematics . however , ellipticals with embedded thick disks and s0 galaxies may contain two subpopulations of pne , one associated with the disk and one with the bulge , as seen for spiral galaxies ( nolthenius & ford 1987 ; hurley - keller et al . 2004 ) . not accounting for the different kinematics of these distinct pne subpopulations could lead to misleading results as illustrated recently by cortesi et al . ( 2011 ) for the lenticular galaxy ngc 1023 . furthermore , dekel et al . ( 2005 ) suggested that an intermediate - aged population of pne may have ` contaminated ' the pne velocity dispersions of some galaxies in the early - type sample of romanowsky et al . ( 2003 ) and hence impacted the resulting mass analysis . the globular cluster ( gc ) systems of all large galaxies , irrespective of hubble type , generally consist of two subpopulations blue ( or metal - poor ) and red ( or metal - rich ) . both of these subpopulations are thought to have ages @xmath4 10 gyr and hence trace old stellar populations ( for a review of gc system properties see brodie & strader 2006 ) . the blue subpopulation is associated with galaxy halos ( forte et al . 2005 ; forbes et al . 2012 ) whereas the red subpopulation has been shown to share many properties with the spheroid / bulge stars of early - type galaxies ( strader et al . 2011 ; forbes et al . 2012 ) , including their kinematics ( pota et al . we note that the association of red gcs with the bulge and not with a thin disk component extends to spiral galaxies , including our own ( minniti 1995 ; cote 1999 ) and the sombrero ( forbes , brodie & larsen 2001 ) . to better understand the issues discussed above it is important to directly compare different kinematic tracers for the same galaxy . here we combine starlight , pne and gc data for an archetype lenticular galaxy ngc 2768 and directly compare these different kinematic tracers in the same galaxy . the galaxy is a nearby , near edge - on s0 ( sandage , tammann & van den bergh 1981 ) , although we note that it was originally classified as an e6 in the rc3 catalogue . according to wikland et al . ( 1995 ) is it an isolated galaxy however it has also been classified as part of the lyon group of galaxies ( lgg ) 167 ( garcia 1993 ) . it reveals ionised gas and a minor axis dust lane ( kim 1989 ) . the central ionised gas and stars are known to have different kinematics ( fried & illingworth 1994 ) suggesting an external origin for the gas . ngc 2768 is a rare example of an early - type galaxy with detectable co emission ( wikland et al . 1995 ) and the host of a calcium - rich supernova type ib ( filippenko & chornock 2000 ) . the effective radius of the galaxy is 1.06 arcmin ( proctor et al . 2009 ; cappellari et al . 2011 ) . for a distance of 21.8 mpc ( cappellari et al . 2011 ) , this corresponds to 6.7 kpc . using a new technique to extract integrated kinematic information of the underlying galaxy starlight from a multi - slit spectrograph , proctor et al . ( 2009 ) presented 2d stellar kinematics for ngc 2768 out to @xmath03 r@xmath3 . here we have carried out a re - analysis of the proctor et al . galaxy data after re - defining the sky scaling index continuum passbands to avoid any strong spectral features associated with the galaxy , as well as any skylines in order to refine the sky subtraction ( see foster et al . 2009 for more details ) . the resulting velocity and velocity dispersion profiles are similar to those published in proctor et al . ( 2009 ) . the total number of positions with stellar kinematics available are 104 and our full dataset is given in table 1 of the appendix . velocity data for 315 pne in ngc 2768 were acquired using the pn.s spectrograph ( douglas et al . 2002 ) in 2007 and are available at : www.strw.leidenuniv.nl/pns/ details of the data reduction procedure and analysis can be found in cortesi et al . ( 2011 , 2012 in prep . ) . following coccato et al . ( 2009 ) , a uniform magnitude cut has been applied and radial incompleteness tests carried out . thus each bin of the pne surface density distribution is complete to a given magnitude and has been statistically corrected for any radial incompleteness . all are spectroscopically confirmed . the pne data reach out to @xmath05r@xmath3 . the radial surface density distribution and velocity data for gcs comes from the imaging and spectroscopy of pota et al . briefly , imaging from hst allows us to model and subtract the galaxy light , and hence detect gcs in the galaxy inner regions with little or no radial incompleteness . the resulting surface density distribution for over 500 gcs is a combination of hst data in the inner regions and subaru data in the outer regions , with a background level subtracted . blue and red gcs were separated according to the local minimum of their bimodal colour distribution , i.e. at r z = 0.56 ( pota et al . 2012 ) . follow - up keck spectroscopy returned 112 kinematically - confirmed blue and red gcs ( pota et al . the blue gcs , associated with galaxy halos ( forbes et al . 2012 ) , were found not to rotate ( pota et al . 2012 ) . here we only consider further the 62 gcs from the red subpopulation . for these gcs the mean velocity is 1353 @xmath5 3 kms @xmath6 in excellent agreement with the galaxy systemic velocity of 1353 km s @xmath6 ( cappellari et al . the red gcs reach out to @xmath04 r@xmath3 and we henceforth assume they are all associated with the bulge of the galaxy .

there are only a few tracers available to probe the kinematics of individual early - type galaxies beyond one effective radius . here we directly compare a sample of planetary nebulae ( pne ) , globular clusters ( gcs ) and galaxy starlight velocities out to @xmath04 effective radii , in the s0 galaxy ngc 2768 . using a bulge - to - disk decomposition of a k - band image we assign pne and starlight to either the disk or the bulge . we show that the bulge pne and bulge starlight follow the same radial density distribution as the red subpopulation of gcs , whereas the disk pne and disk starlight are distinct components . we find good kinematic agreement between the three tracers to several effective radii ( and with stellar data in the inner regions ) . further support for the distinct nature of the two galaxy components come from our kinematic analysis . after separating the tracers into bulge and disk components we find the bulge to be a slowly rotating pressure - supported system , whereas the disk reveals a rapidly rising rotation curve with a declining velocity dispersion profile . the resulting v@xmath1/@xmath2 ratio for the disk resembles that of a spiral galaxy and hints at an origin for ngc 2768 as a transformed late - type galaxy . a two - component kinematic analysis for a sample of s0s will help to elucidate the nature of this class of galaxy . [ firstpage ] globular clusters planetary nebulae galaxies : individual ( ngc 2768 )

1306.0363

the control and detection of single spins is of considerable recent interest . a particularly interesting method of detecting a single spin on a surface is possible by a scanning tunneling microscope ( stm ) @xcite . the technique has been initiated and developed by y. manassen and various collaborators @xcite . it is based on monitoring the noise , i.e. the stm current - current correlations , and observing a signal at the expected larmor frequency , a signal that is sharp even at room temperature . the larmor frequency is also seen in an electron spin resonance ( esr ) experiment with many spins , in contrast , the esr - stm method observes a single spin and furthermore , the system is static , no oscillating field is applied as in esr . the observed frequency is found to vary linearly with the applied magnetic field , confirming that the stm has detected an isolated spin on the surface . this phenomenon was first demonstrated on oxidized si(111 ) surface @xcite and then on fe atoms @xcite on si(111 ) as well as on a variety of organic molecules on a graphite surface @xcite and on au(111 ) surfaces @xcite . recent extensions have resolved two resonance peaks on oxidized si(111 ) @xmath0 surface corresponding to site specific @xmath1 factors @xcite as well as to observation of hyperfine coupling @xcite . we further note that the spatial dependence of the signal shows a non - monotonic contour plot , i.e. the signal is elongated and is maximal at @xmath2 nm on either side of a minimum point @xcite . the theoretical understanding of the esr - stm effect is not settled @xcite . the emergence of a finite frequency in a steady state stationary situation is a non - trivial phenomenon . an obvious mechanism for coupling the charge current to the spin precession is spin - orbit coupling @xcite . it was shown that an esr signal is present in the noise with spin - orbit coupling when the leads are polarized , either for a strong coulomb interaction @xcite or for the non - interacting case @xcite , and even in linear response @xcite . however , the experimental data @xcite involves a small field of @xmath3 g corresponding to a larmor frequency of @xmath4mhz , i.e. @xmath5 relative to a lead s bandwidth . it was found in these spin - orbit models @xcite that the signal vanishes when the lead polarization vanishes , or when the lead and dot polarization are parallel , as for a uniform magnetic field . it was argued that an effective spin polarization is realized as a fluctuation effect either for a small number of electrons that pass the localized spin in one cycle @xcite or due to 1/f magnetic noise of the tunneling current @xcite . it was further shown that spin - orbit coupling in an asymmetric dot can yield an oscillating electric dipole , possibly affecting the stm current @xcite . in the present work we follow a recently proposed model that allows for an esr - stm phenomena with non - polarized leads @xcite . the model assumes an additional direct tunneling between the tip and the substrate in parallel to tunneling via the dot s states , i.e. a nanoscopic interferometer . the numerical study @xcite shows that the interference of the direct current and that via the spin has an esr signal in the noise , a signal that increases with the direct tunneling . this model is motivated by studies of quantum dots with spin - orbit @xcite and by stm studies of a two - impurity kondo system that shows a significant direct coupling between the tip and substrate states @xcite . similar models including a aharonov - bohm phase have been studied @xcite . the nanoscopic interferometer model is consistent with the unusual non - monotonic contour plot @xcite , i.e. the signal is maximized when the stm tip is not directly on the spin center but slightly away , so as to maximize an overlap with a surface state of the substrate . in the present work we consider non - polarized leads , as relevant to the experimental setup , and evaluate the noise analytically in the stationary system , in accord with the numerical results for this case . the analytic results clarify the physical processes of the resonance phenomenon and allow us to discuss the esr - stm effect for a broad range of parameters , as in the conclusion section below . the paper is organized as follows . in sec.ii we introduce the hamiltonian of the system and present the results for direct tunneling : effective action , the current and the current noise power spectrum . sec . iii contains the effective action of the dot and the expression for the current flow through dot . iv reflects our principal result : the resonance part of the current spectral density . the results are illustrated by figs 1,2 . finally our conclusions are contained in sec.v . the appendices a , b , c give various details of the calculations . the hamiltonian of the system describes direct tunneling through the dot between left ( l ) and right ( r ) leads as well as l - r tunneling via the dot states , @xmath6 where the lead hamiltonians are @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 is the spin and @xmath10 are the continuum states . the dot hamiltonian is @xmath11 with @xmath12 , @xmath13 is the mean position of the dot levels and @xmath14 is the applied magnetic field that includes the @xmath1 factor and the bohr magneton . we assume that the dispersions @xmath15 of the lead electrons are spin independent , justified by the small ratio @xmath5 of the larmor frequency and a typical electron bandwidth . a general spin - orbit coupling involves unitary matrices that can be parameterized @xcite by two angles @xmath16 . the angle @xmath17 appears in the hamiltonian for the direct tunneling @xmath18 the spin dependent form in @xmath19 is required by time reversal . the angle @xmath20 appears in the tunneling via the dot as a spin rotation in the @xmath21 lead , while the @xmath22 lead is diagonal in spin @xmath23+h.c.\ ] ] where @xmath24 we note that special cases of this parameterization have been used in related models @xcite . to calculate the current and the noise we use the keldysh formalism @xcite and include in the action a quantum source field @xmath25 that couples to the total current . the source term has the form @xmath26 where @xmath27 is a pauli matrix in the rotated keldysh space . the total action is @xmath28 where @xmath29 corresponds to @xmath30 , i.e. tunneling via the dot @xmath31 and @xmath32 is the action of the dot @xmath33 @xmath34 is the green s function ( gf ) of the noninteracting dot in the rotated keldysh representation that has the form @xmath35 with retarded ( @xmath21 ) , advanced ( @xmath36 ) and keldysh ( @xmath37 ) indices as superscripts . the current via the dot @xmath38 is chosen as a symmetric combination of the current from the left lead to the dot @xmath39 and that from the dot to the right lead @xmath40 . in general a linear combination of these currents is needed , depending on various capacitances @xcite . we expect that the resonance effect is dominated by single occupancy of the dot and the latter two currents are equal . indeed we check below that our results for the resonance term do not depend on which linear combination is used . furthermore , the numerical study @xcite used @xmath39 for the noise evaluation with results consistent with our analytic ones . here and below the dot electron operator @xmath41 becomes a vector in spin space ( and keldysh space ) . the gf @xmath42 are diagonal in spin space and in terms of a fourier energy variable @xmath43 are given by @xmath44 with the limit @xmath45 . the part of the action @xmath46 which contains the leads and the direct lr tunneling is @xmath47\,.\label{sw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath48 , @xmath49 are vectors and pauli matrices , respectively , in lr ( left - right ) space , the gfs of the leads @xmath50 are diagonal in lr space and @xmath51 present a constant matrix in momentum k , k space . fermion operators and gf as well the quantum source field @xmath52 acts in the rotated keldysh space . the voltage @xmath53 between the leads is assumed small relative to the bandwidths , hence the density of states @xmath54 are taken as constants . the gf @xmath55 has the structure of eq . ( [ g0 ] ) and its momentum integrated forms @xmath56 are @xmath57 where @xmath53 is the voltage difference between the lr leads and @xmath58 . to cope with scattering of electrons due to the tunneling we shift the operators @xmath48 so as to cancel the linear coupling to @xmath59 in eq . ( [ st ] ) . this adds a term of the form @xmath60 to the dot action and then the effective action separates into two independent parts @xmath61 . the total generating functional @xmath62 , as a function of the source field , is therefore factorized into @xmath63 . we consider now the @xmath46 part of the effective action . inverting @xmath64 by using blockwise matrix inversion we obtain @xmath65 here @xmath66 , @xmath67 and the coupling parameter @xmath68 the electron transport and noise calculations involve only the integrated gf of eq . ( [ g ] ) . direct integration over electron operators @xmath69 yields @xmath70=\exp[\tr\ln g^{-1}]$ ] . the direct current @xmath71 and related noise power are defined as derivatives with respect to the source field ( taking @xmath72 after derivatives is implied ) @xmath73 we obtain the textbook results @xcite for noise and transport current through a contact with transmission probability @xcite @xmath74 and reflection coefficient @xmath75 ( details in appendix a ) , the conductance is then @xmath76 . the effective action of the dot includes the @xmath77 term from the integration over the lead fermions . it is expressed ( in keldysh space ) in terms of various gfs @xmath78 as listed in eq . ( [ gbar ] ) and in terms of the noninteracting dot gf eq . ( [ g0 ] ) as @xmath79\label{q}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the matrix @xmath80 is @xmath81=@xmath82 where @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath85 are pauli matrices in spin space . here we introduce the tunneling widths : @xmath86 . taking @xmath72 and inverting @xmath87 we find the gfs of the dot interacting with the leads ( see appendix a ) . as we find below , the resonance contribution to the noise is related to terms that involve the matrices @xmath88 ( or @xmath89 in eq . ( [ c5 ] ) ) . we note therefore that the result for the resonance term does not depend on which combination of currents @xmath39 and @xmath40 ( determining the source terms @xmath90 in ( [ q ] ) ) are used . integrating out the dot fermions @xmath41 with the action ( [ sd ] ) we arrive at the generating functional @xmath91 $ ] which depends on the vertex function @xmath77 . similar to ( [ dz ] ) the current through the dot is @xmath92\label{id}\end{aligned}\ ] ] performing calculations for the case of equal tunneling widths @xmath93 ( see appendix b ) we obtain the current : @xmath94 where @xmath95 \delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon}\label{jd3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath96 and @xmath97 . the trace in the last equation ( [ jd3 ] ) is @xmath98 & = & \sum_{\sigma}[-\frac{\sin^2\phi \cos^2\theta/2}{\bar{\gamma } } img^r_{\sigma}(\epsilon)+\nonumber\\ & & \sin^2(\theta/2 ) g^r_{\sigma } g^a_{-\sigma}]\label{tr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] presents two different scattering processes . the first term with @xmath99 appears also for an aharonov - bohm phase and for @xmath100 the corresponding current coincides with that in ref . ; this term does not depend on the sign of phase @xmath17 meantaining the relation @xmath101 for conductance in closed system ( two - terminal setup ) . we note that for @xmath100 the two spin states decouple and a resonance phenomena at the larmor frequency is not possible . there are still interference effects due to the phase @xmath17 , though these are unrelated to the resonance . the second term of eq . ( [ tr ] ) describes the spin orbit effect and reflects tunneling transitions accompanied by spin flips . the phase @xmath20 is therefore controlling the esr effect . the current noise power @xmath102 is given by formula ( [ ddz ] ) in which @xmath103 is replaced by @xmath104 . the total noise function can be written as a sum of two terms @xmath105 @xmath106\\ s_{d2}(t , t')&=&-\tr[g\frac{\delta q}{\delta \alpha(t)}g\frac{\delta q}{\delta \alpha(t')}]\label{stt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we calculate the current spectral density to lowest order in @xmath107 , these terms have a resonance contribution at larmor frequency . details of the derivation are given in appendix c. we write the frequency dependent noise @xmath108 and @xmath109 as an expansion in @xmath110 : @xmath111 the spin flip transport which is responsible for the resonance occurs due to the spin - orbit interacting vertices . this effect takes place at least in the terms linear in @xmath112 ( @xmath113 ) which are presented below ( all other contributions to the noise power are given explicitly in appendix c ) . the first term depends weakly on frequency @xmath114\delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second term @xmath115 contains three contributions @xmath116 where @xmath117 @xmath118\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath119\ } \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath120\nonumber\\ \hat{m}&=&\im g^r(\epsilon-\omega/2)\vec{n}\vec{\tau } img^r(\epsilon+\omega/2)\vec{n}\vec{\tau}\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath121 . the resonance behavior at @xmath122 that we find is related to @xmath123 . we note first , as it is easy to check , that the total noise power ( at @xmath124 ) @xmath125 in each order in @xmath107 if @xmath126 and @xmath127 . this observation serves as additional test for our calculations . separating the resonance contributions in the expression for @xmath123 yields at the principal result of our work : @xmath128 where @xmath129 @xmath130 \label{f } \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath131\label{sr2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] there is a potentially singular contribution that also in @xmath132 @xmath133\delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon}\end{aligned}\ ] ] however , it can be seen that this term depends weakly on frequency and therefore it does not have a resonance at the larmor frequency . in the experiments @xcite the parameters satisfy @xmath134 . therefore , if the mean level position @xmath13 is in between the two chemical potentials @xmath135 and is not too close to @xmath136 , i.e. @xmath137 , then we have @xmath138 and @xmath139 . we show in particular the function @xmath140 of eq . ( [ f ] ) , neglecting @xmath141 and @xmath14 terms , in fig . 1 . [ ! ht ] , the function @xmath140 in eq . ( [ f ] ) neglecting @xmath142 terms ( i.e. valid for @xmath137 ) . the voltage and temperature ratio is @xmath143.,title="fig : " ] taking @xmath138 and @xmath144 and using eq . ( [ img ] ) the integrals are simply evaluated @xmath145 @xmath146}{[({\mbox{\small $ \frac{1}{2}$}}\omega+\sigma h)^2+\bar{\gamma}^2](\bar{\gamma}^2+\omega^2)}\nonumber\\\label{sing2 } \ ] ] in standard units the @xmath147 in the denominators are replaced by @xmath148 . thus the last equations ( [ sing1 ] ) and ( [ sing2 ] ) show the resonance behavior of the noise power at @xmath149 . [ ! ht ] in fig . 2 we plot the noise power @xmath150 , eqs . ( [ sing1 ] ) and ( [ sing2 ] ) , normalized by @xmath151 as function of frequency . for a sharp resonance , as seen experimentally @xcite @xmath152 since @xmath153 determines the resonance width . therefore the ratio @xmath154 is small and @xmath155 with the lorenzian shape dominates . in the wide range where @xmath156 ( fig . 1 ) we have therefore for the signal amplitude at resonance @xmath157 we note also that at @xmath158 where @xmath159 another term causes a cancellation of this one ( appendix c ) and the signal vanishes at large @xmath112 . we expect then that the signal is maximal at @xmath160 , in accord with numerical data @xcite . we have considered a general spin - orbit scattering mechanism in a setup of a nanoscopic interferometer and have shown that the interference of the two transmission paths leads to a resonance contribution to the current correlation spectral density at the larmor frequency . in particular we find that the effect takes place in the absence of lead polarizations , consistent with esr - stm experiments . our model also accounts for several unusual features of the data : ( i ) a sharp resonance even at high temperatures @xmath161 , ( ii ) insensitivity to the details of the spin defect , i.e. to the positions of its levels between the tip and substrate chemical potentials , ( iii ) contour plots @xcite showing that the signal is maximal at @xmath2 nm from a center , hence a significant direct coupling @xmath107 bypassing the spin can be achieved . here we have neglected the coulomb interaction @xmath162 between charges on the dot . however , for experimentally interesting case of a large applied voltage @xmath53 , the coulomb repulsion is expected to satisfy @xmath163 . the levels therefore remain between the two chemical potentials and we expect that the resonance part of the noise is weakly affected by @xmath162 . a similar conclusion was reached for the case with polarized leads @xcite . we note also that the insensitivity of the resonance term to the choice of @xmath39 or @xmath40 to represent the current via the dot implies that the charge occupancy of the dot is constant , i.e. singly occupied . therefore , the coulomb interaction on the dot is not expected to affect the resonance term . our key result eq . ( [ sing1 ] ) shows that the signal amplitude is @xmath164 . the signal should vanish at @xmath165 on general grounds @xcite , yet the @xmath166 form is unexpected . some of our other results can be obtained for small @xmath167 by simple estimates : the resonance linewidth follows from a golden rule @xmath168 ; the dc current via the dot @xmath169 for @xmath170 ( eq . ( [ id1 ] ) is the dominant term ) corresponds to a transition rate @xmath171 from either reservoir to the dot , hence @xmath169 given the dot s two states . the direct transport of @xmath172 is also a golden rule @xmath173 times the final number of states @xmath174 , hence @xmath175 ( for @xmath176 ) while the corresponding background noise is a classical shot noise @xmath177 , eq . ( [ sw ] ) . the noise of the dot current is , however , much reduced from that of a shot noise since @xmath178 , eq . ( [ s0 ] ) . to analyze the experimental data we first estimate the relevant parameters . the resonance linewidth is @xmath2mhz @xmath179 ( for @xmath176 ) . assuming a metallic @xmath180ev ) yields @xmath181 . considering next the dc current @xmath182na at @xmath2v : the dot current for @xmath176 @xmath183a is too small , hence the dc current is dominated by the direct coupling @xmath107 with @xmath184 , hence @xmath185 and @xmath186 . the background noise due to the dot current is @xmath187 while that from @xmath107 is @xmath188 , hence @xmath189\ll 1 $ ] , i.e. the background noise is dominated by @xmath190 . we note that the background noise is not measured in the experiment since the modulation technique @xcite measures the derivative of the noise spectra . furthermore , the signal intensity is under study @xcite as it is highly sensitive to uncertainties in the feedback and impedance matching circuits . we find that the signal to background intensity for @xmath176 is @xmath191 , i.e. of order @xmath192 . in conclusion , our model presents an analytic solution to a long standing puzzle , paving the way for more controlled single spin detection via esr - stm . we thank for stimulating discussions with y. manassen , o. entin - wohlman , s. a. gurvitz , a. janossy , l. s. levitov , i. martin , m. y. simmons , f. simon , e. i. rashba , s. rogge , a. shnirman , g. zrand and a. yazdani . this research was supported by the israel science foundation ( bikura ) ( grant no . 1302/11 ) and by the israel - taiwanese scientific research cooperation of the israeli ministry of science and technology . the gfs integrated over momentum are obtained by inverting the inverse green function in eq . ( [ sw ] ) , as shown for the diagonal terms in eq . ( [ ll ] ) . here we write the whole list of these functions : @xmath193 explicitly for @xmath72 we can write @xmath194 changing r to l yields @xmath195 . the off - diagonal functions acquire a form @xmath196 with the help of these functions we find the direct tunneling current and the corresponding noise power which acquire standard forms ( below @xmath197 are pauli matrices that act in keldysh space ) @xmath198 \\ j_w & = & 2et_b\int \frac{d\epsilon}{2\pi}\delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath199 \nonumber \\ s_w ( 0)&= & \frac{4e^2}{2\pi}[ev t_b(1-t_b)\coth\frac{v}{2t}+2t_b^2t]\label{sw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the noise @xmath200 is well known @xcite and coincides with eq . ( [ sw ] ) for small @xmath141 , @xmath201 . the effective action of the dot is given by eq . ( [ sd ] ) . in the limit of vanishing source terms the corresponding gfs are obtained by inverting @xmath87 ( @xmath72 ) @xmath202 @xmath203 + \nonumber\\ & & 2i\frac{\sqrt{x \gamma_l\gamma_r}}{(1+x)^2}\delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon}g^r(\epsilon)\vec{n } \vec{\tau}g^a(\epsilon)\label{g6}\end{aligned}\ ] ] next we calculate the transmission through the dot which is presented by eq . ( [ i d ] ) . the superscripts in the following correspond to matrix elements in keldysh space , @xmath204\nonumber\\ \frac{\delta q(\alpha)}{\delta \alpha(t ) } & = & \frac{1}{4}[-\gamma_l(\sigma_x \hat{g}_{ll}(t\bar{t})(1+\frac{\hat{\alpha}}{2})\nonumber\\ & & -(1-\frac{\hat{\alpha}}{2})\hat{g}_{ll}(\bar{t}t)\sigma_x)+\nonumber\\ & & \gamma_r(\sigma_x \hat{g}_{rr}(t\bar{t})(1-\frac{\hat{\alpha}}{2})-(1+\frac{\hat{\alpha}}{2 } ) \hat{g}_{rr}(\bar{t}t)\sigma_x)+\nonumber\\ & & 2\sqrt{x \gamma_l \gamma_r } ( \sigma_x m^{\dagger}\hat{g}_{rl}(1+\frac{\hat{\alpha}}{2})+\nonumber\\ & & ( 1+\frac{\hat{\alpha}}{2 } ) m^{\dagger}\hat{g}_{rl}\sigma_x-\nonumber\\ & & \sigma_x \hat{g}_{lr}m(1-\frac{\hat{\alpha}}{2})- ( 1-\frac{\hat{\alpha}}{2})\hat{g}_{lr}m\sigma_x)]+\nonumber\\ & & \gamma_l\frac{\delta \hat{g}_{ll}(t_1t_2)}{\delta \alpha(t)}+\gamma_r\frac{\delta \hat{g}_{rr}(t_1t_2)}{\delta \alpha(t)}+\nonumber\\ & & 2\sqrt{x \gamma_l \gamma_r}[\frac{\delta \hat{g}_{lr}(t_1t_2)}{\delta \alpha(t)}m+m^{\dagger}\frac{\delta \hat{g}_{rl}(t_1t_2)}{\delta \alpha(t)}]\nonumber\\ \label{dq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the current takes the form @xmath205+\nonumber\\ & & \gamma_l \delta \hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon,\omega)+\gamma_r\delta \hat{g}_{rr}(\epsilon,\omega)+\nonumber\\ & & 2\sqrt{x \gamma_l \gamma_r}(\delta \hat{g}_{lr}(\epsilon,\omega)m+m^{\dagger}\delta \hat{g}_{rl}(\epsilon,\omega)\}\}\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the variations of the gfs are given as a fourier transform , @xmath206 \hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon ) \nonumber\\ \delta \hat{g}_{rr}(\epsilon,\omega ) & = & -4x \hat{g}_{rr}(\epsilon-\omega)[\sigma_x \bar{g}_l ( \epsilon)- \nonumber\\ & & \bar{g}_l ( \epsilon-\omega)\sigma_x ] \hat{g}_{rr}(\epsilon)\nonumber\\ \delta \hat{g}_{lr}(\epsilon,\omega ) & = & \hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon-\omega)\sigma_x\bar{g}_r(\epsilon)+\nonumber\\ & & \delta g_{ll}(\epsilon,\omega)(1+\hat{\alpha})\bar{g}_r ( \epsilon)\nonumber\\ \delta \hat{g}_{rl}(\epsilon,\omega ) & = & - \bar{g}_r ( \epsilon-\omega)\sigma_x\hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon ) + \nonumber\\ & & \bar{g}_r ( \epsilon-\omega)(1-\hat{\alpha})\delta g_{ll}(\epsilon,\omega)\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] performing the trace in keldysh space and using the explicit form of the lead gfs eqs . ( [ g1]-[g4 ] ) as well the dot gfs eqs . ( [ g5]-[g6 ] ) we arrive at eqs . ( [ id1]-[jd3 ] ) . we consider the current noise power for equal tunneling widths @xmath93 to order @xmath112 . at first we present the derivation of @xmath207 . this part of the noise power depends on the second variation of the vertex function @xmath208 . their fourier transformed keldysh components acquire a form @xmath209\nonumber \\ ( \delta^2q)^{22}_{\omega}&=&\frac{\bar{\gamma}}{4}[i-4\sqrt{x}\nu f_{1\omega}+\frac{i\sqrt{x}\vec{n}\vec{\tau}}{1+x}f_{2\omega}-\nonumber\\ & & \frac{2ix}{1+x}(4-f_3+f_4)]\nonumber\\ ( \delta^2 q)^{21}_{\omega}&=&\frac{i\bar{\gamma}}{16}[(\delta^{(+)}_{\epsilon-\omega}+ \delta^{(+)}_{\epsilon+\omega})+ 6\frac{\sqrt{x}\vec{n}\vec{\tau}}{1+x}(\delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon-\omega}+ \delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon+\omega } ) ] \label{dds1}\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath210+(\omega\rightarrow-\omega)\}\nonumber\\ f_4&= & \sqrt{r_b}\delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon}(\delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon+\omega}+\delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon-\omega})\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath211 . after tracing keldysh space we obtain @xmath212\ ] ] using the explicit forms for vertices ( [ dds1 ] ) ( see also first eq . ( [ std ] ) ) we arrive at @xmath213\}\label{s0 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath214-\nonumber\\ & & 4\nu f_{1\omega}reg^r(\epsilon)- \frac{\bar{\gamma}}{4}g^r(\epsilon)\vec{n}\vec{\tau}g^a(\epsilon)\times\nonumber\\ & & \delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon}(\delta^{(+)}_{\epsilon-\omega}+ \delta^{(+)}_{\epsilon+\omega})\}\label{sk}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the formula for @xmath132 is given in the main text eq . ( [ s2 ] ) . the other part of the current spectral density @xmath215 ( see eq.([stt ] ) ) is defined by fourier transformed gfs and vertices @xmath216\nonumber\\ 2\delta q(\omega)&=&a(\epsilon+\frac{\omega}{2})+b(\epsilon-\frac{\omega}{2})+\nonumber\\ & & c(\epsilon-\frac{\omega}{2},\epsilon+\frac{\omega}{2})+ 4xd(\epsilon-\frac{\omega}{2},\epsilon+\frac{\omega}{2})+\nonumber\\ & & 8x\sqrt{x}e(\epsilon-\frac{\omega}{2},\epsilon+\frac{\omega}{2})\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath217\}\nonumber\\ b(\epsilon)&=&\frac{\gamma}{2}\{\hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon)- \hat{g}_{rr}(\epsilon)+\nonumber\\ & & 2\sqrt{x } [ m^{\dagger}g_r(\epsilon)\hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon)- \hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon)g_r(\epsilon)m]\}\sigma_x\nonumber\\ c(\epsilon,\epsilon')&=&2\sqrt{x } \gamma[\hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon)\sigma_x g_r(\epsilon')m - m^{\dagger}g_r(\epsilon)\sigma_x\hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon')]\nonumber\\ d(\epsilon,\epsilon')&= & \gamma[\hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon)(\sigma_x g_r(\epsilon')-g_r(\epsilon)\sigma_x)\hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon')]\nonumber\\ & & -(l\leftrightarrow r)\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath218 where @xmath219\hat{g}_{ll}(\epsilon+\frac{\omega}{2})\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] indeed the vertex function @xmath220 is irrelevant for spin flip processes and may be ignored . explicit form for keldysh components of @xmath221 to linear order in @xmath112 can be simply find @xmath222\nonumber\\ \delta q^{22}(\omega ) & = & \frac{\bar{\gamma}\sqrt{r_b}}{4}i\delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon+\omega/2}- \frac{\bar{\gamma}\sqrt{x}}{2(1+x)}[(2\nu\delta^{(-)}_{\epsilon+\omega}-\nonumber\\ & & 2i\vec{n}\vec{\tau}(xf_r(\epsilon+\omega/2)+\frac{1}{2}\delta^{(+)}_{\epsilon+\omega/2})]\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath223\nonumber\\ & & -\nu[f_r(\epsilon+\omega/2 ) f_l(\epsilon-\omega/2)-(\omega\rightarrow -\omega)]\}\nonumber \ ] ] these formulas for @xmath221 can be applied for all @xmath112 if modifications which come from @xmath220 and @xmath224 vertices are included . @xmath225 introduces a factor @xmath226 into the first term in expressions for @xmath227 and @xmath228 . there is also a contribution to @xmath229 : @xmath230 . all these additions do not influence the resonance part of the tunneling . if we consider the limit of large @xmath112 the vertex @xmath224 is important . in this case we can directly obtain that to main order in @xmath112 it councils all terms in vertex @xmath231 which are responsible for resonant spin orbit scattering . with the help of these vertex functions we calculate all parts of the @xmath232 noise power ( see eq.([std ] ) ) : @xmath233 @xmath234\label{k1 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath235 \}\label{rr1}\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath236 here @xmath237 and @xmath238 label the retarded , advanced or keldysh gfs : @xmath239 . in ( [ k1 ] ) to order @xmath240 we can take @xmath241 . the linear in @xmath112 singular contribution @xmath242 of @xmath232 is presented in the main text eq.([s2 ] ) . 99 a. v. balatsky , m. nishijima and y. manassen , adv . phys . * 61 * , 117 ( 2012 ) y. manassen , r.j . hamers , j.e . demuth , and a.j . castellano jr . , phys rev . lett . * 62 * , 2531 ( 1989 ) . y. manassen , e. ter - ovanesyan , d. shachal , and s. richter , phys . b * 48 * , 4887 ( 1993 ) . y. manassen , i. mukhopadhyay , and n. ramesh rao , phys . rev . b * 61 * , 16223 ( 2000 ) . c.durkan and m. e. welland , appl . phys . lett . * 80 * , 458 ( 2002 ) . p. messina , m. mannini , a. caneschi , d. gatteschi , l. sorace , p. sigalotti , c. sandrin , p. pittana and y manassen , j. appl . * 101 * , 053916 ( 2007 ) . m. mannini , p. messina , l. sorace , l. gorini , m. fabrizioli , a. caneschi , y. manassen , p. sigalotti , p. pittana and d. gatteschi , inorganica chimica acta * 360 * , 3837 ( 2007 ) . v. mugnaini , m. fabrizioli , i. ratera , m. mannini , a.caneschi , d. gatteschi , y. manassen and j. veciana , sol . sci . * 11 * , 956 ( 2009 ) . t. komeda and y. manassen , appl . lett . * 92 * , 212506 ( 2008 ) . y. sainoo , h. isshiki , s.m.f . shahed , t. takaoka and t. komeda , appl . . lett . * 95 * , 082504 ( 2009 ) . d. mozyrsky , l. fedichkin , s. a. gurvitz and g. p. berman , phys . b*66 * 161313 ( 2002 ) . l. n. bulaevskii , m. hruska and g. ortiz , phys . rev . b*68 * , 125415 ( 2003 ) . s. a. gurvitz , d. mozyrsky and g. p. berman , phys . rev . b*72 * , 205341 ( 2005 ) . m. braun , j. knig , and j. martinek , phys . * b74 * , 075328 ( 2006 ) . o. entin - wohlman , y. imry , s. a. gurvitz , and a. aharony , phys . b * 75 * , 193308 ( 2007 ) . a. v. balatsky , y. manassen and r. salem , phil . mag . b * 82 * , 1291 ( 2002 ) ; phys . rev . b , 66 195416 ( 2002 ) . y. manassen and a. v. balatsky , special issue on single molecule spectroscopy : israel journal of chemistry * 44 * , 401 ( 2004 ) [ cond - mat/0402460 ] . l. s. levitov and e. i. rashba , phys . rev . b*67 * 115324 ( 2003 ) . l. arrachea , a. caso and b. horovitz , [ arxiv:1305.6477 ] . r. lpez , d. snchez and l. serra , phys . rev . b*76 * , 035307 ( 2007 ) . j. bork , y. zhang , l. diekhner , l. borda , p. simon , j. kroha , p. wahl and k. kern , nature phys . * 7 * , 901 ( 2011 ) . w. hofstetter , j. knig , and h. schoeller , prl * 87 * , 156803 ( 2001 ) . jong soo lim , mircea crisan , david sanchez , rosa lpez , and ioan grosu phys . * b81 * , 235309 ( 2010 ) a. golub and y. avishai phys . rev . b 69 , 165325 ( 2004 ) . j. knig and y. gefen , phys . rev . b 65 , 045316 ( 2004 ) . e. m. lifshitz , l. p. pitaevskii , _ physical kinetics , course of theoretical physics _ ( pergamon press , oxford 1981 ) . a. kamenev , a. levchenko , advances in physics 58 , 197 ( 2009 ) ya . blanter and m. bttiker , phys . rep . * 336 * , 1 ( 2000 ) y. manassen , m. averbukh and m. morgenstern ( unpublished ) ; and y. manassen , private communication .

we study a model for the observed phenomenon of electron spin resonance ( esr ) at the zeeman frequency as seen by a scanning tunneling microscope ( stm ) via its current noise . the model for this esr - stm phenomenon allows the stm current to flow in two arms of a nanoscopic interferometer , one arm has direct tunneling from the tip to the substrate while the second arm has tunneling through two spin states . we evaluate analytically the noise spectrum for non - polarized leads , as relevant to the experimental setup . we show that spin - orbit interactions allow for an interference of two tunneling paths resulting in a resonance effect .

0907.1225

classical globular clusters are prominent objects with respect to the surrounding fields . in recent years , however , low luminosity globular clusters have been identified or discovered in the galaxy . these include obscured or field contaminated objects , or a combination of these factors ( e.g. @xcite , and references therein ) . @xcite recently found glimpse - c02 , an extremely obscured and metal rich globular cluster , * which was almost simultaneously detected by @xcite . * pfleiderer2 was found by @xcite and has been also referred to as pwm2 . the cluster center is located at ( j2000 ) @xmath3 , @xmath4 , with galactic coordinates @xmath5 , @xmath6 . the angular size is @xmath7 , as seen on dss / xdss images . in sect . [ obs ] the observations and reductions are described . in sect . [ decont ] we describe the decontamination procedures . colour magnitude diagrams ( cmd ) are presented and fundamental parameters derived in sect . the cluster structure is studied in sect . [ struc ] . concluding remarks are given in sect . [ conclu ] . pfleiderer2 was observed on 2008 june 5 , 6 , with the 3.58 m galileo telescope ( tng ) at la palma , equipped with the dolores spectrograph focal reducer . a eev 4260 ccd detector with @xmath8 pixels , of pixel size 13 @xmath9 m was used . a pixel corresponds to @xmath10 on the sky , and the full field of the camera is @xmath11 . the log of observations is provided in table 1 . in fig . [ fig1 ] is shown a 420 sec full field @xmath12 image of pfleiderer2 , showing a rather prominent cluster . rrrrrrrrr v & 5 - 6/06/2008 & 600 & 1.1 & 1.2 & + i & & 30 & 1.2 & 1.2 & + i & & 420 & 1.1 & 1.2 & + v & 6 - 7/06/2008 & 30 & 1.6 & 1.7 & + v & & 900 & 1.6 & 1.6 & + b & & 60 & 1.5 & 1.5 & + b & & 20 & 1.4 & 1.5 & + b & & 900 & 1.4 & 1.4 & + b & & 60 & 1.4 & 1.4 & + the calibration was performed using 3 different landolt ( 1983 , 1992 ) standard fields observed in bvi , the first night ( pg1633 + 099 , sa 113337 , pg 2213 - 06 ) with different exposure times and in different positions . we checked shutter time dependence and zero point variations across the field . in the second night ( june 6th ) five additional @xcite fields have been observed ( pg 1323 - 086 , pg1528 + 062 , pg1633 + 099 , sa113 337 , pg 2213 - 06 ) . the airmass corrections of 0.15 in v , 0.25 in b and 0.07 in i , have been done using the standard values given for la palma in clear nights ( with no dust in the atmosphere ) , available at the dolores [email protected] ] the derived calibration equations are : v = 28.44 - 0.06(v - i)+v i = 28.28 - 0.07(v - i)+i b = 28.59 + 0.12(b - v)+b v = 28.43 - 0.06(b - v)+v where the zero points are calculated for 10s exposures at 1.15 airmasses , with an aperture of @xmath14 . the bvi are instrumental magnitudes ( counts in adus , gain 1 e-/adu ) . bvi are the calibrated magnitudes . the zero points were remarkably stable and identical in the two nights . no shutter time effects have been detected at the 0.01 mag . level in the exposure range of our images ( from 1 to 30 s ) . in the @xmath15 pixels central area the standard stars showed a very good uniformity , but their flux rapidly decreased at the frame corners . the repeated measurements of the standard stars across the field have been used to separate the contribution of the sky concentration from the flat field , including the decrease of sensitivity of the system ( possibly due to some vignetting ) at the edge . measurements performed with different apertures excluded the possibility that the loss of light at the edges was due to degradation of the psf . the ccd frame reductions were performed using a slightly more complex procedure than the standard flat field division . this was needed due to the analysis of the standard star fluxes across the field , compared to the background brightness , and showed a sky flux excess in an area roughly corresponding to the central 500 pixels . this excess is interpreted as the effect called `` sky concentration '' ( @xcitecalibration.ps ] ) . this is known to be caused by internal reflections and it is color dependent . in our images it reached about 6% in i , 5% in v ( fig . [ fig2 ] ) and it was almost negligible in b. if the light concentration is not removed from the flatfields , it causes a systematic photometric error across the field of the same amount . the light loss at the edges was instead almost constant with the colors , up to 5% from center to corner . the flatfielding ( after bias correction ) was performed in four main steps : ( 1 ) a map of sky concentration was prepared using the standard stars , compared to the sky level ; ( 2 ) the contribution of the light concentration was extracted from the flatfields and smoothed ( fig . [ fig2 ] ) ; ( 3 ) the light concentration was scaled to the value of the sky images and subtracted ; ( 4 ) the flatfield obtained after removing the light concentration was used to correct the high frequencies and sensitivity variations ( including vignetting ) . the corrected images have been processed using daophot ii and allstars ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . the software is available in midas for the instrumental photometry of individual stars , and it was converted into the standard johnson - cousins system , defined from the landolt stars , using the above calibration equations . the conversion from the instrumental ( psf convolved ) magnitudes to the calibrated ones revealed an additional problem related to the image quality variation across the field . this produces a variable aperture correction , changing with time and filter . in pfleiderer2 images it was of the order of 0.02 magnitudes , with a peak around 0.04 magnitudes at the extreme corners . for this reason we adopted the aperture correction established from stars located in the central 200 pixels which is representative of most of the image within about 1% to 2% . the resulting calibration accuracy , taking into account the uncertainties in the calibration equations ( @xmath160.01 mag ) , the flatfield procedure ( an additional 0.01 - 0.02 mag ) and the aperture corrections ( 0.02 mag ) , is estimated to be within @xmath17 in a single filter . the relative photometric errors have been derived from short exposures ( 15s in v and 10s in i ) frame to frame images . the errors are 0.03 mag for 14 @xmath18 v @xmath18 16.5 , increasing to about 0.2mag at v=20.5 . in order to have the errors for our deep 600s exposures , they must be scaled to the corresponding magnitudes . the 600 sec images imply a factor 40 larger in exposure times , and the corresponding error values can be estimated from the ones given above . field - stars are an important contaminant of cmds in rich fields , especially near the disk and bulge . the decontamination algorithm employed here is based on a three - dimensional routine designed for the wide - field photometry of 2mass data , as developed in @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . in the present case we adapted the original algorithm to work with photometry obtained with a large telescope and a single color . for clarity , we recall the basic procedures . the algorithm divides the whole magnitude and color ranges into a grid of cmd cells . for a given cluster extraction and comparison field , it estimates the relative number densities of probable field and cluster stars present in each cell . the estimated number of field stars is subsequently subtracted from each cell . * decontamination results for different cluster / field contrasts are given and discussed in the above cited papers . the reference cell dimensions are @xmath19 and @xmath20 . however , to minimize spurious results , several runs of the decontamination procedure are used , with different input parameters . * in the present paper , different cell sizes are considered , with @xmath21 and @xmath22 taken from 0.5 , 1.0 and 2.0 times the reference values . also , the cell grid is shifted by -1/3 , 0 and + 1/3 of the respective cell size in both the colour and magnitude axes . taking together all the grid / cell size setups , we are left with 81 different and independent decontamination combinations . stars are ranked according to the number of times they survive each run . finally , only the highest ranked stars are considered as cluster members and transposed to the respective decontaminated cmd . in the case of pfleiderer2 , the decontaminated stars have a survival frequency above @xmath23 . we note that the two bright and red stars ( figs . [ fig6 ] and [ fig7 ] ) are among those with @xmath24 , which implies that the observed field is scarcely populated of stars with similar colour and magnitude . in fig . [ fig3 ] we investigate the surface density ( @xmath25 , in units of @xmath26 ) distribution of pfleiderer2 both with the observed ( left panels ) and decontaminated ( right ) photometry . we also include the respective isopleth surface maps ( bottom panels ) , which show a rather circular geometry in the stellar distribution around the center of pfleiderer2 . as expected , the cluster is much more contrasted in the decontaminated data . fig . [ fig4 ] shows the @xmath27 vs. @xmath28 cmd of essentially the full field ( r @xmath18 1000 pixels , or r @xmath18 4.2 ) * around pfleiderer2 , reaching the photometric limit of @xmath29 . as anticipated in sect . [ decont ] , field contamination is dominant in this direction . a few bright and red stars show up at @xmath30 and @xmath31 , which might suggest a metal - rich cluster . * the fit of padova isochrones ( @xcite ) to the v vs. v - i cmd of pfleiderer2 is shown in figs . [ fig5]a , b for extractions of r @xmath18 10 and 30 . a tilted red giant branch ( rgb ) is seen , together with a clump of stars at @xmath32 and @xmath33 , compatible with a red horizontal branch ( hb ) . a tilted rgb is indicative of a high metallicity as discussed in @xcite . we also note that the spread across the diagram is due to differential reddening . the fit of the isochrones to the cluster sequences in these figs . required a high metallicity of z=0.019 ( [ fe / h]@xmath340.0 ) . it might be one of the most metal - rich globular clusters in the galaxy . the age estimated is 10@xmath12 gyr , compatible with a globular cluster . this leads to a reddening of e(v - i)=1.34 . assuming e(v - i)/e(b - v)=1.33 ( @xcite ) , we get e(b - v)[email protected] , which corresponds to a@xmath35 = 3.13 . this reddening value is compatible with the dust emission maps by @xcite , of e(b - v)=1.15 . we derive an observed distance modulus of ( m - m)@xmath35 = 19.2 , an absolute distance modulus of ( m - m)@xmath36 = 16.07 , and a distance from the sun d@xmath0 = 16.4@xmath12 kpc . assuming the conservative distance of the sun to the galaxy center to be r@xmath0 = 8.0 kpc ( @xcite ) , the galactocentric coordinates are x = 7.0 kpc ( x @xmath37 0 is on the other side of the galaxy ) , y = 6.1 kpc and z = 2.7 kpc , and the distance to the galactic center is r@xmath2 = @xmath38kpc . a metal - rich globular cluster located far from the center is not a unique case . terzan7 with a 47 tuc - like metallicity , in the sagittarius dwarf , is even farther from the galactic center at r@xmath2 = 15.9 kpc ( @xcite ) . however , pfleiderer2 is apparently not related to any dwarf galaxy and is more metal - rich . the metal - rich cluster palomar8 has [ fe / h]=-0.48 and r@xmath2 = 5.6 kpc ( h96 ) , whereas palomar11 has [ fe / h]=-0.39 ( h96 ) and r@xmath2 = 9 kpc ( @xcite ) . therefore , pfleiderer2 has at least two other analog metal - rich globular clusters located far from the bulge . in case there is no relation to a dwarf galaxy , it might be that these clusters are at apogalacticon , possibly tracing such limit for the bulge . we applied the decontamination tools to the tng photometry , * as described in sect . [ decont ] . * a mosaic of cmds extracted within 120 pixels ( r @xmath18 30 ) is given in fig . the upper panels show the observed v vs. v - i and i vs. v - i cmds , while the respective equal area sky extraction is given in the middle panels . the lower panels show the statistically decontaminated cmds , derived according to sect . [ decont ] using as comparison field the wide ring located within @xmath39 ( @xmath40 ) . an rgb , the red hb and a populous turn - off are seen , features that are clearer in the decontaminated plot . these features are also seen in the v vs b - v subtracted diagram , although not as deep as in v vs. v - i ( fig . [ fig6 ] ) . * at this point it is important to recall that the two bright and red stars ( @xmath31 , @xmath41 ) have a survival frequency of 100% , with respect to the decontamination procedure ( sect . [ decont ] ) . besides , the redder one is located at about 14 from the cluster center , while the other at about 29 . taken together , these arguments imply a high probability of both being cluster members , and suggest a metal - rich cluster . * the cmd sequences seen in these decontaminated diagrams are similar to those obtained from central extractions ( fig . [ fig5]a , b ) . * as a caveat we note that the above isochrone solutions place the turnoff at @xmath42 and @xmath43 , which corresponds to about 1 mag brighter than the photometric limit , and probably close to the completeness limit . however , the comparison with the field cmd ( fig . [ fig6 ] ) shows that the excess of stars at @xmath44 is real . * finally , in fig . [ fig7 ] we test alternative isochrone solutions that explore a range of ages and metallicities . we test isochrones of 6 , 8 , 10 and 12gyr , both of solar and 1/3 solar metallicity . * assuming that the two bright and red stars are members , the metallicity turns out clearly constrained to nearly solar , since lower metallicities would require brighter gb stars . the 6gyr isochrones , although producing a reasonable fit of the turnoff and rgb , fail to describe both bright and red stars simultaneously . * although we adopted 10gyr as the best age solution , a spread of @xmath45gyr is acceptable . in the case of 8gyr , pfleiderer2 might be one of those young globular clusters such as palomar1 ( @xcite ) . in fig . [ fig8 ] we give the cluster stellar radial density distribution ( rdp ) . the central parts of the cluster show evidence of a post - core collapse , as seen in a number of other globular clusters , especially in the bulge ( @xcite ) . otherwise a smooth fit with the 3-parameter king profile is obtained throughout the rest of the cluster . this tentative fit provides a core radius of r@xmath46 ( @xmath47pc ) and a tidal radius r@xmath48 ( @xmath49pc ) . @xcite determined tidal radii of globular clusters as a function of the estimated perigalacticon distances . pfleiderer2 compared to their sample appears to be among the intrinsically smallest globulars , only comparable with the central bulge clusters ngc6522 and ngc6528 . in case the tidal radius is essentially determined by the perigalacticon tidal forces , the small size of this cluster suggests that it may reach the outer bulge ( see equation 4 in @xcite ) . on the other hand , the total absolute magnitude , obtained by adding the stellar fluxes for the stars brighter than v=24 present in the decontaminated cmd extracted within 700 pixels , amounts to m@xmath35= -2.5 . this value would place pfleiderer2 among the least luminous globular clusters in the galaxy , like palomarclusters . therefore , if its mass is as low as that of palomarclusters such as palomar12 and palomar13 ( @xcite ; @xcite ) , estimated to be of @xmath50 to @xmath51 m@xmath0 , then a perigalacticon distance of 5 to 10 kpc is inferred . in this case , it might be a low mass globular cluster that has been losing mass , or be an old open cluster , with a nearly circular orbit . to put pfleiderer2 into perspective , in fig . [ fig9 ] we compare some of the astrophysical parameters derived in this paper with those of the globular clusters in h96 ( updated in 2003 - h03 ) , together with the mass ( panel d ) taken from @xcite . as anticipated above , pfleiderer2 is located in the low - luminosity tail of the globular cluster distribution ( panel a ) and not far from the galactic center ( b ) . the king tidal radius ( c ) is relatively small , consistent with its location in the galaxy , while the king core ( d ) , which encompasses the collapsed core ( fig . [ fig8 ] ) , is clearly an upper limit . disregarding the collapsed core , its king concentration parameter would suggest a relatively loose cluster ( e ) . undoubtedly , pfleiderer2 is a low - mass cluster ( f ) . the present observations deal with a faint star cluster that we identified as a globular cluster . previously , pfleiderer2 was classified as an open cluster . it is obscured in the optical , with @xmath52 , and affected by differential reddening . deep photometry was collected with the 3.58 m tng telescope , which revealed the cluster nature , although deeper photometry would still be necessary for a final conclusion . isochrone fits are compatible with a nearly solar metallicity star cluster with age within the range 8 - 12gyr , which thus puts pfleiderer2 among the few metal - rich globular clusters in the galaxy . larger apertures would be important to get deeper imaging , as well as high resolution spectroscopy to better derive its metallicity , abundance ratios , and orbital properties . we thank an anonymous referee for suggestions . we acknowledge partial financial support from the brazilian agencies cnpq and fapesp , and ministero delluniversit e della ricerca scientifica e tecnologica ( murst ) , italy .

* we provide evidence that indicate the star cluster pfleiderer2 , which is projected in a rich field , as a newly identified galactic globular cluster . * since it is located in a crowded field , core extraction and decontamination tools were applied to reveal the cluster sequences in b , v and i color - magnitude diagrams ( cmds ) . the main cmd features of pfleiderer2 are a tilted red giant branch , and a red horizontal branch , indicating a high metallicity around solar . the reddening is e(b - v)=1.01 . the globular cluster is located at a distance from the sun d@xmath0 = 16@xmath12 kpc . the cluster is located at 2.7 kpc above the galactic plane and at a distance from the galactic center of r@xmath2=9.7kpc , which is unusual for a metal - rich globular cluster .

0710.3745

two - photon states with specific continuous variable - entanglement properties are required for a number of quantum - information - processing applications . in particular , pure - state single photons , crucial for applications relying on interference between independently prepared single photons , such as quantum computing with linear optics @xcite , entanglement swapping @xcite , and teleportation @xcite , can be heralded only from _ factorable _ photon pairs , where no correlations exist between the constituent single photons @xcite . let us note that factorability may be imposed by postselecting an appropriate subensemble of photon pairs through spectral and/or spatial filtering ; this can be done only at the cost of a typically drastic reduction in count rate and source brightness . scalable quantum - information processing requires the elimination of this type of postselection . it has furthermore been shown that , for quantum - information applications involving multiple - pair generation resulting from high - gain parametric down - conversion , spectral or spatial filtering is likewise ineffectual . @xcite . in addition , the coexistence of factorability and a large generated bandwidth is important for some applications , such as the generation of ultrashort fourier - transform - limited heralded single photons @xcite . the process of spontaneous parametric down - conversion represents a well - established method for the generation of photon pairs , leading to unparalleled flexibility in the resulting continuous - variable entanglement properties . indeed , the nonlinear crystal dispersion characteristics in conjunction with temporal and spatial structure in the pump beam may be exploited to engineer the type and degree of correlations present in spectral and transverse wave - vector degrees of freedom _ at the source _ , thus eliminating the need for photon pair filtering . the use of a broadband pump is essential in the context of the generation of photon pairs with spectrally engineered properties ; indeed , a monochromatic pump can access only a one - dimensional subspace of signal - idler frequency space , which precludes certain states of interest . previous work has established the central role that is played by group velocity mismatch terms between the three fields involved in parametric down - conversion ( pump , signal , and idler ) in the determination of the resulting photon pair properties . thus , in ref . @xcite , it was shown that if the pump pulse propagates at a higher group velocity than one of the generated photons but lower than the conjugate generated photon , then it becomes possible to emit factorable photon pairs . an important limitation of this technique is that the group velocity condition which must be satisfied occurs only for specific materials , at specific spectral ranges @xcite , typically in the infrared where single - photon detection is unfortunately not well developed . a number of techniques have been proposed and in some cases implemented which enable effective control over the photon pair entanglement properties in the spectral domain unconstrained by material dispersion . in one such technique , the effective group velocities experienced by the three fields involved are modified by a pair of diffraction gratings placed before and after the nonlinear crystal so as to generate photon pairs with tunable spectral characteristics @xcite . alternatively , the spectral content of two photon states may be restricted to the modes supported by a nonlinear cavity which leads , for a short , high - finesse cavity , to factorable , narrowband photon pair generation @xcite . likewise , on the one hand a transversely pumped source where signal and idler photons are emitted in a counterpropagating waveguided geometry @xcite and on the other hand noncollinear parametric down - conversion ( pdc ) where a specific relationship between transverse and longitudinal phase matching is attained @xcite can both lead to states with spectrally engineered properties . another route is the use of crystal superlattices , where the dispersion in short crystal segments is compensated by birrefringent compensators , permitting two - photon states with a wide range of possible spectral entanglement characteristics @xcite . previous theoretical work has explored the use of non linear photonic crystals in the context of the process of spontaneous parametric down - conversion . in particular , refs . @xcite study the potential of semiconductor - based nonlinear one - dimensional photonic crystals to yield phase - matching properties appropriate for the generation of polarization - entangled photon pairs . likewise , it has been shown that even a short one - dimensional photonic crystal is capable of generating a considerable photon pair flux due to field localization in such structures @xcite . in this paper we study the potential of exploiting the properties of one - dimensional nonlinear photonic crystals in order to generate photon pairs with engineered spectral entanglement properties . we concentrate on type - ii , frequency degenerate , collinear pdc . collinear operation is important because it permits pdc in a waveguided geometry , which leads to larger generation rates as well as to effective control over the transverse spatial structure of the emitted light , crucial for efficient single - mode fiber coupling and for spatial mode matching in interference experiments @xcite . type - ii operation for which the signal and idler photons are orthogonally polarized is important because it enables efficient photon pair splitting . we show that a weak index of refraction modulation present in an otherwise standard birefringent nonlinear crystal can be exploited to attain the group velocity conditions , in addition to basic phase matching , required for factorable photon pair generation . in this paper we analyze the generation of photon pairs by the process of parametric down - conversion in a @xmath0 material characterized by a spatial periodicity in its linear optical properties . in particular , we study pdc produced by a nonlinear photonic crystal ( nlpc ) based on a standard bulk nonlinear crystal with uniaxial birefringence which has been modified from its natural state by an appropriate physical mechanism so as to yield a periodic variation of the index of refraction for both polarizations , while maintaining the nonlinearity constant throughout the crystal thickness . concretely , within one period of the resulting bragg grating , we assume that the index of refraction for the ordinary ( @xmath1 ) and the extraordinary ray ( @xmath2 ) are given by @xmath3 this unit cell is assumed to be replicated throughout the crystal length . here , @xmath4 represents the bragg period and @xmath5 is the duty cycle . we refer to such a material as a one - dimensional nonlinear photonic crystal . figure [ fig : bragg ] shows a crystal schematic where @xmath6 indicates zones characterized by indices of refraction @xmath7 and @xmath8 and @xmath9 indicates zones characterized by indices of refraction @xmath10 and @xmath11 . we assume that in zones @xmath6 the crystal has been left in its natural state , while in zones @xmath9 it has undergone index change . for simplicity , we assume that zones @xmath6 and @xmath9 are of equal length ( leading to an @xmath12 duty cycle ) and we likewise assume that the permittivity contrast @xmath13 , equivalent to the index square contrast , is frequency independent , . [ fig : bragg],width=288 ] @xmath14}{\epsilon_{\mu1}(\omega)+\epsilon_{\mu2}(\omega ) } = \frac{n_{\mu 1}(\omega)^2-n_{\mu 2}(\omega)^2}{\overline{n}_\mu(\omega)^2},\ ] ] where @xmath15/2.\ ] ] with @xmath16 . throughout this paper we will assume that propagation of the three fields involved is normal to each of the interfaces between zones @xmath6 and @xmath9 . under these conditions , such a material can exhibit , for each of the polarizations , a so - called photonic band gap centered at each of the bragg wavelengths @xmath17 where @xmath18 , and where @xmath16 . within each band gap , for a sufficient crystal thickness , light is efficiently reflected , while for frequencies outside the band gap , light propagates in the form of so - called bloch waves which can be written as @xmath19\}.\ ] ] here , @xmath20 is the bloch envelope , which exhibits a spatial periodicity matching that of the material , i.e. , @xmath21 , while @xmath22 represents the bloch wave number . note that , for a continuous material without bragg grating , the bloch envelope reduces to a constant , and therefore the bloch wave reduces to a plane wave . following a coupled - mode analysis where the spatial periodicity in the permittivity is assumed to be well represented by a weak perturbation to the material permittivity , it can be shown that the bloch wave number in the vicinity of @xmath23 can be expressed as @xcite @xmath24 here , @xmath25 represents the coupling coefficient between the forward and backward waves @xmath26\alpha \overline{k}_\mu(\omega)/ ( 4 \pi m),\ ] ] and @xmath27 represents the bragg phase mismatch between these two waves , @xmath28 where @xmath29 characterizes the underlying material dispersion ; note that eq.([ec : lambda_bragg ] ) follows from the condition @xmath30 . a photonic band gap appears when @xmath31 and its effects become appreciable for @xmath32 . the band gap boundaries @xmath33 and @xmath34 are obtained by solving for the frequencies such that the argument of the square root in eq.([ec : wavenumber ] ) vanishes . for a forward - propagating wave , the minus sign in front of the square root in eq.([ec : wavenumber ] ) should be used for @xmath35 while the plus sign should be used for @xmath36 . let us note that for a @xmath37 duty cycle , eq.([ec : couple_coef ] ) tells us that , even order band gaps ( @xmath38 ) are suppressed . in what follows , we will concentrate on first order ( @xmath39 ) band gaps , though the analysis below could be employed for any order . in particular , for practical implementations it may be challenging to fabricate the required bragg gratings with periods in the region of hundreds of nanometers compatible with modified dispersive characteristics in the visible ; alternatively , it is possible to use longer periods , together with higher - order band gaps . the dispersive properties of nplcs are characterized by the function @xmath22 , where from this point we omit the order superscript . for propagating waves at frequencies in the vicinity of the band gap boundaries , @xmath22 can differ substantially from the underlying material dispersion relation @xmath40 . in particular , group velocities can be strongly reduced , while group velocity dispersion terms ( as well as higher - order frequency derivatives of the wavenumber ) can increase markedly , from their values associated with material - only dispersion . in order to illustrate these effects , let us consider a specific example of a one - dimensional nlpc , based on a @xmath41-barium - borate ( bbo ) crystal . we assume that the bragg period is given by @xmath42 nm with a @xmath12 duty cycle , the angle subtended by the pump and the optic axis ( to be referred to as the propagation angle ) is @xmath43 , and the permittivity contrast is @xmath44 . figure [ fig : dispersion ] shows the resulting dispersive properties . figure [ fig : dispersion ] ( a ) shows , for each of the two polarizations , a plot of the bloch wave number @xmath22 , showing clearly a band gap for each of the polarizations , within which @xmath22 becomes complex - valued . figure [ fig : dispersion ] ( b ) shows a plot of the group velocities for each of the two polarizations , exhibiting a marked reduction near the band gap boundaries . figure [ fig : dispersion ] ( c ) shows the first frequency derivative of @xmath22 , or the reciprocal group velocity . finally , figure [ fig : dispersion ] ( d ) shows a plot of the group velocity dispersion ( gvd ) term for each of the polarizations . it is apparent from the plot that gvd can be greatly enhanced near the band gap boundaries , and likewise that it is possible to obtain both positive and negative gvd . following a standard perturbative approach , the quantum state describing photon pairs produced by parametric down - conversion in the spontaneous limit may be expressed as @xmath45|\textrm{vac}\rangle,\ ] ] where @xmath46 denotes the vacuum and @xmath47 is the interaction hamiltonian @xmath48 here , @xmath49 is the illuminated volume in the nonlinear medium , @xmath50 is the second - order nonlinearity , and @xmath51 ( @xmath52 ) represents the electric field operators associated with each of the interacting fields . in a nonlinear photonic crystal , each of these fields is described by a bloch wave . thus , if we assume that the pump field is classical , it can be expressed as @xmath53\right\},\ ] ] in terms of the bloch wavenumber @xmath54 , bloch envelope @xmath55 , and the spectral amplitude @xmath56 . it is convenient to express the bloch envelope as a fourier series , @xmath57 in terms of the spatial harmonics @xmath58 . the signal and idler fields are quantized ; their positive - frequency part can be expressed as @xmath59 z-\omega t\right\}\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] in terms of the bloch wave number @xmath60 , envelope @xmath61 and the bloch envelope fourier series coefficients @xmath62 . here , @xmath63}$ ] , where @xmath64 is the first frequency derivative of @xmath65 , @xmath66 is the annihilation operator for the signal(@xmath67 ) or idler(@xmath68 ) modes , @xmath69 is the permittivity in the nonlinear medium , and @xmath70 is the transverse beam area . it can be shown that the resulting two - photon component of the state may be written for specific directions of propagation ( throughout this paper assumed to be collinear with the pump beam ) as @xmath71 may be factored as @xmath72 . here , @xmath73 represents the pump spectral envelope function , while @xmath74 is a function which describes the phase - matching properties of the nonlinear photonic crystal and can be expressed as @xmath75 in terms of the frequency - dependent phase mismatch @xmath76 adjusted by the momentum contribution due to the photonic crystal structure , @xmath77 where @xmath78 . the term proportional to @xmath79 is similar to that which appears for quasi - phase - matched interactions and has the effect of shifting the spectral range where phase - matching is attained . thus , the phase - matching contributions for different values of @xmath80 , if they exist ( i.e. , if @xmath81 ) , will tend to be spectrally distinct from each other . note , however , that in general terms , for photonic crystal periods in the hundreds of nanometers , contributions with @xmath82 result in a term proportional to @xmath83 which will tend to be larger than the wave numbers for each of the three interacting fields , and will therefore also be larger than @xmath84 ; this makes it difficult to achieve @xmath85 for @xmath82 . let us now consider the bloch wave characteristics at @xmath86 nm and @xmath87 nm ( which could represent pump and pdc wavelengths ) in a material with the parameters specified at the end of the previous section . figure [ fig : dfourier ] shows the modulus of the leading fourier series coefficients [ see eqs.([ec : bloch_fourier_pump ] ) and ( [ ec : modefield ] ) ] , calculated from the bloch envelope in turn determined by the eigenvectors of the translation matrix which characterizes the periodic material@xcite . figure [ fig : dfourier](a ) shows the fourier coefficients for an extraordinary wave at @xmath86 nm , fig . [ fig : dfourier](b ) shows the fourier coefficients for an extraordinary wave at @xmath87 nm , and fig . [ fig : dfourier](c ) shows the fourier coefficients for an ordinary wave at @xmath87 nm . let us note that a wave at @xmath86 nm behaves essentially like a plane wave with negligible @xmath88 terms . this is due to the fact for this specific material there is no band gap in the vicinity of @xmath86 nm ; in particular , the second order band gap is suppressed by employing a @xmath12 duty cycle . this specific material exhibits a band gap centered at @xmath89 nm for the ordinary wave and at @xmath90 nm for the extraordinary wave . a wave of either polarization at @xmath87 nm is sufficiently near to the corresponding band gap so that the resulting dispersion relation is significantly modified ( see fig . [ fig : dispersion ] ) , yet as observed in figs . [ fig : dfourier](b ) and ( c small @xmath39 ( i.e. , reflected wave ) contribution and where other contributions are negligible . in what follows , we will study the generation of pdc where the emission frequency is in sufficient proximity to the band gap boundaries so that dispersion is strongly modified , though sufficiently removed so that the fraction of light appearing in modes other than the fundamental mode ( determined by the values @xmath91 ) is small ; see figs . [ fig : dispersion ] and [ fig : dfourier ] . in this regime the signal and idler photons propagate essentially as plane waves , yet with a modified dispersion relation with respect to an equivalent source without a photonic crystal structure . from eq.([ec : couple_coef ] ) there is no second - order band gap for a 0.5 duty cycle , which implies that the effect of the photonic crystal tends to be insignificant for the pump field , thus suppressing contributions with @xmath92 . thus , in this paper , we will concentrate on the contribution @xmath93 , which corresponds to the fundamental , forward - propagating mode for the three interacting fields . in order to carry out an analysis of the relationship between the various experimental parameters and the resulting spectral entanglement properties , it is convenient to express the phase mismatch as a power series in the frequency detunings @xmath94 , where @xmath95 is the degenerate frequency and @xmath96 is the crystal length @xmath97\nu_s \nu_i+\vartheta(5).\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath98 represents fifth , and higher order terms in the detunings while @xmath99 represents the frequency - independent term , which vanishes when perfect phase matching occurs at @xmath95 , @xmath100 equation([ec : taylor1 ] ) is written in terms of the mismatch in the @xmath101th frequency derivative of the wave number between the pump and the signal and idler wave packets @xmath102 , and a term proportional to the @xmath101th frequency derivative of the pump wave number @xmath103 , @xmath104 in terms of @xmath105 let us note that for type - ii pdc in standard nonlinear crystals it is typically sufficient to consider a power series expansion of the phase mismatch up to the group velocity terms . however , for nlpcs with the signal and idler frequencies in proximity to one of the band gap boundaries , gvd and higher - order dispersion terms are strongly enhanced with respect to an equivalent source without a photonic crystal structure . thus , it becomes necessary to consider higher - order terms ; here we have considered up to quartic order in the frequency detunings . in order to facilitate an analysis of the conditions under which it is possible to generate two - photon states that are close to factorable , we write down the joint spectral amplitude in terms of gaussian functions this can be achieved by modeling the pump envelope function as a gaussian function , @xmath106,\ ] ] and by approximating the sinc function in the phasematching function as a gaussian funciton i.e. @xmath107 with @xmath108 . under these approximations , the joint spectral amplitude can be expressed as @xmath109 \nonumber\\ & & \ \ \ \ \ \ + i l \delta k/2 \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] by writing @xmath110 in eq.([ec : jsa1 ] ) as its power series expansion [ eq.([ec : taylor1 ] ) ] , and keeping terms up to fourth order while assuming that @xmath111 , the joint spectral amplitude becomes @xmath112\right\}\ ] ] where @xmath113\nu^2 + 2 \tau_\mu^{(1)}\tau_\mu^{(2 ) } \nu^3\nonumber\\ & + [ ( \tau_\mu^{(2)})^2 + 2\tau_\mu^{(1)}\tau_\mu^{(3)}]\nu^4-i ( 2/\gamma)\sum\limits_{j=1}^4 \tau_\mu^{(j)}\nu^j\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath114\nu_i^2 \nonumber \\ & + [ 2 ( \tau_p^{(2)})^2+\tau_s^{(2)}\tau_i^{(2)}+3\tau _ p^{(3)}(\tau_s^{(1)}+\tau_i^{(1 ) } ) ] \nu_s \nu_i \nonumber \\ & -i(2/\gamma)[\ { \tau_p^{(2)}+(3/2 ) \tau_p^{(3 ) } ( \nu_s+\nu_i ) + \nonumber \\ & \tau_p^{(4)}(2 \nu_s^2 + 3 \nu_s \nu_i+2 \nu_i^2)\ } ] . \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] while @xmath115 ( with @xmath116 ) represents the contributions that depend only on one of the two frequencies , @xmath117 depends on both frequencies , and gives rise to correlations in the two - photon state ; factorability is attained if @xmath118 . it is apparent from eqs.([ec : jsa3 ] ) and ( [ ec : exp1 ] ) that the dominant terms which govern the phase matching behavior are the group velocity mismatch terms , proportional to @xmath119 . let us consider the effect of making both of these group velocity mismatch terms vanish , i.e. , @xmath120 in this case , for which the pump , signal , and idler propagate at the same group velocity , the expression for the joint spectral amplitude greatly simplifies , and in particular many of the mixed terms giving rise to correlations are suppressed . the modulus of the joint spectral amplitude becomes @xmath121 \nonumber\\ & \times \exp[\ { -\nu_i^2/\sigma^2 -\gamma(\tau_i^{(2)})^2 \nu_i^4/4\ } ] \nonumber\\ & \times\exp\{-2\nu_s\nu_i/\sigma^2+\gamma\tau_p^{(2)}(\tau_s^{(2 ) } \nu_s^3\nu_i+\tau_i^{(2 ) } \nu_s\nu_i^3)\nonumber\\ & + \gamma[(\tau_p^{(2)})^2+\tau_s^{(2)}\tau_i^{(2)}/2]\nu_s^2\nu_i^2\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] while the argument becomes @xmath122\approx ( 1/2)\sum\limits_{j=2}^4 ( \tau_s^{(j)}\nu_s^j+\tau_i^{(j)}\nu_i^j)+\nu_s\nu_i[\tau_p^{(2)}\nonumber \\ & + 3 \tau_p^{(3 ) } ( \nu_s+\nu_i ) + 2\tau_p^{(4)}(2 \nu_s^2 + 3 \nu_s . \nu_i+2 \nu_i^2)].\end{aligned}\ ] ] equation ( [ ec : jsa_approx1 ] ) is written as a product of three exponentials , where the first two represent the factorable components and the third term describes spectral ( modulus ) correlations between the signal and idler photons . likewise , in eq.([ec : argumento ] ) it is the second term , with a @xmath123 overall multiplicative factor , which describes spectral phase correlations between the signal and idler photons . let us now in addition suppose that the signal and idler photons experience much stronger dispersion than the pump . in particular , let us assume that @xmath101th - order pump dispersion coefficients @xmath124 may be neglected with respect to the signal and idler @xmath101th - order dispersion coefficients @xmath102 , i.e. , @xmath125 ) with @xmath126 is satisfied , the fourth order mixed terms in eq.([ec : jsa_approx1 ] ) proportional to @xmath127 may be neglected . similarly , if the condition in eq.([ec : weak_pump ] ) with @xmath128 is satisfied , the mixed terms in the argument of the joint amplitude [ eq.([ec : argumento ] ) ] may be neglected . imposing this weak pump dispersion condition , the expression for the joint spectral amplitude is thus further simplified . the modulus may now be written as @xmath129\end{aligned}\ ] ] while the argument may be written as @xmath130\approx ( 1/2)\sum\limits_{j=2}^4 ( \tau_s^{(j)}\nu_s^j+\tau_i^{(j)}\nu_i^j]).\ ] ] let us note that while the modulus contains mixed terms proportional to @xmath123 and to @xmath131 , the argument does not contain mixed terms . let us now assume , in addition to group velocity matching [ see eq.([ec : gvm ] ) ] and weak pump dispersion ( see eq.([ec : weak_pump ] ) ] that the pump is broadband . it may be shown from eq.([ec : jsa_approx2 ] ) that the joint spectral amplitude exhibits no dependence on the pump bandwidth if @xmath132 thus , for a sufficiently broadband pump [ so that eq.([ec : pump ] ) is satisfied ] , the modulus of the joint spectral amplitude reduces to @xmath133.\ ] ] we have seen that when the following three conditions are satisfied : ( 1 ) complete group velocity matching [ see eq.([ec : gvm ] ) ] , ( 2 ) weak pump dispersion [ see eq.([ec : weak_pump ] ) ] , and ( 3 ) sufficiently broadband pump [ see eq.([ec : pump ] ) ] , the joint spectral amplitude attains a particularly simple form in which there is a single mixed term , proportional to @xmath134 up to fourth order in @xmath135 . for the specific cases we analyzed ( see the next section ) , while conditions 1 and 3 must be satisfied in order to attain nearly factorable two - photon states , the effect of the mixed terms controlled by condition 2 is comparatively small . in the next section , we will show that the properties of one - dimensional nonlinear photonic crystals , may be exploited for the fulfilment of conditions 1 and 3 , and partial fulfilment of condition 2 . our strategy for controlling the spectral properties of pdc photon pairs generated by one - dimensional nlpcs is based on the observation that the group velocity is sharply reduced for frequencies in the vicinity of the band gap boundaries , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : dispersion ] ( b ) . it is possible to exploit the properties of photonic crystals to compensate for material dispersion and to impose specific conditions on the group velocities of the three interacting fields . indeed , while for a standard optical material the pump will tend to propagate at a lower group velocity than the generated light , it is possible to design a nlpc so that the group velocities of the signal and idler photons in proximity to one of the band gap boundaries , are reduced sufficiently to make them equal to the pump group velocity . the former can be achieved while maintaining essentially a plane - wave character for the corresponding signal and idler bloch waves . likewise , the nlpc can be designed so that the pump frequency is far from band gaps , so that the pump field is essentially unaffected by the photonic crystal structure . indeed , nlpcs make it possible to attain , even in a type - ii geometry where each of the three fields experiences different dispersion characteristics , complete group velocity matching where @xmath136 , or in the notation of the previous section @xmath137 . in order to simplify our analysis of realistic nlpcs , we first limit the parameter space ; we assume that the crystal is operated at room temperature and assume a duty cycle @xmath12 throughout . likewise , we regard the degenerate pdc frequency @xmath95 as a fixed parameter . it is indeed remarkable that , in general , nearly factorable pdc photon pair sources based on nlpcs permit the specification of an arbitrary central emission wavelength , and for that matter an arbitrary material , constrained only by the ability to fabricate the crystal with the required periodic index of refraction variation . thus , for degenerate collinear pdc at a given freely specified central frequency , we are left with the following experimental parameters : bragg period ( @xmath4 ) , permittivity contrast ( @xmath13 ) , crystal propagation angle ( @xmath138 ) , crystal length ( @xmath96 ) , and pump bandwidth ( @xmath139 ) . in what follows we present a numerical analysis for the simultaneous fulfilment of basic phase matching [ @xmath111 ; see eq.([ec : pm ] ) ] and complete group velocity matching [ see eq.([ec : gvm ] ) ] for a one - dimensional nlpc based on a bbo crystal . let us note that these conditions are independent of crystal length and pump bandwidth . thus , we have three variables : bragg period ( @xmath4 ) , permittivity contrast ( @xmath13 ) , and crystal propagation angle ( @xmath138 ) with which to satisfy three conditions : ( i ) @xmath111 ( ii ) @xmath140 , and ( iii ) @xmath141 ( where the pump frequency derivatives are evaluated at @xmath142 while signal and idler frequency derivatives are evaluated at @xmath95 ) . figure [ fig : vg_empcompleto](a ) shows in @xmath143 space , for three different values of @xmath4 , the contour defined by the condition @xmath111 together with the contour defined by the condition @xmath140 . note that both contours shift as the bragg period @xmath4 is modified . similarly , fig . [ fig : vg_empcompleto](b ) shows , for the same three values of @xmath4 , the contour defined by the condition @xmath111 together with the contour defined by the condition @xmath141 . there exists a specific value of the bragg period @xmath4 for which the three contours meet a single point on @xmath143 space , yielding the specific values of the three parameters ( @xmath13 , @xmath138 , and @xmath4 ) which satisfy simultaneously phase matching and complete group velocity matching . assuming @xmath144 nm ( which we stress may be freely specified ) , these values are @xmath145 , @xmath146 , and @xmath147 nm , obtained numerically from the intersection of the three resulting contours [ see fig . [ fig : vg_empcompleto](c ) ] . for this choice of parameters , [ fig : vg_empcompleto](d ) shows a plot of the group velocities for the ordinary and extraordinary waves . in this plot we indicate that , for a type - ii interaction where the pump is an extraordinary wave and the signal and idler are extraordinary and ordinary , respectively , we indeed obtain identical group velocities for the three fields . let us note that to our knowledge no other reported technique permits complete group velocity matching in a collinear , type - ii nonlinear parametric interaction . according to the conditions derived in the previous section , in order to guarantee factorability we require the fulfilment of the weak dispersion condition [ see eq.([ec : weak_pump ] ) ] , in addition to complete group velocity matching . in particular , if this condition is satisfied for @xmath126 , then three of the four remaining mixed terms in the joint spectral amplitude ( to fourth order in the detunings ) may be suppressed . as illustrated by fig . [ fig : dispersion ] , when the signal and idler frequencies are in proximity to one of the band gap boundaries while the pump experiences essentially only the material dispersion , group velocity dispersion and higher order terms associated with the generated light will be greatly enhanced with respect to corresponding pump quantities . thus , for the specific experimental parameters yielding complete group velocity matching ( see the previous paragraph ) , the resulting second order dispersion coefficients are @xmath148fs@xmath149 , @xmath150fs@xmath149 and @xmath151fs@xmath149 . the condition @xmath152 will be more accurately satisfied the closer the degenerate pdc frequency is to the band gap boundaries for each polarization . however , note that , because the band gap boundaries for the two polarizations are spectrally distinct , the weak pump dispersion condition can not be satisfied to the same degree for both photons . thus , for this specific choice of parameters , while the three mixed terms proportional to @xmath127 are reduced , they are not suppressed perfectly . the third condition for factorability derived in the previous section , apart from complete group velocity matching and weak pump dispersion , is that the pump should be sufficiently broadband [ see eq.([ec : jsa3 ] ) ] . note that while the bragg period , permittivity contrast and crystal propagation angle must have specific values in order to guarantee complete group velocity matching , the pump bandwidth and crystal length must fulfil a comparatively soft condition given as the inequality in eq.([ec : pump ] ) . figure [ fig : estado_completo ] represents the resulting joint spectral intensity @xmath153 , for a pump centered at @xmath154 nm with a full width at half maximum bandwidth of @xmath155 nm , with crystal length @xmath156 mm and where the rest of the parameters are as specified above , in the context of fig . [ fig : vg_empcompleto ] . note that in this plot we have taken into account the complete dispersion ( rather than a truncated power series approach ) and have not used the gaussian approximation . while these approximations were essential for our analysis , it is important to verify the degree of factorability in a two - photon state produced by a realistic source . figure [ fig : estado_completo](a ) shows the pump spectral envelope @xmath73 as given by eq.([ec : pump_function ] ) , fig . [ fig : estado_completo](b ) shows the phasematching function @xmath157 as given by eq.([ec : pmf ] ) , and fig . [ fig : estado_completo](c ) shows the joint spectral intensity . it is apparent from the figure that the resulting two - photon state is nearly factorable . indeed , a numerical schmidt decomposition @xcite yields a schmidt number of @xmath158 ( which could be reduced further by moderate spectral filtering ) . as has already been discussed , the effective control over group velocity properties permitted by photonic crystal structures , which may be exploited to obtain nearly factorable two - photon states , enhances higher - order dispersion terms . this has the effect that , when complete group velocity matching is not fulfilled , the contours of equal amplitude of the phase matching function in @xmath159 space tend to be highly curved . therefore , the technique presented here is not naturally suited for the generation of states exhibiting strict correlation or anticorrelation in frequency , unless the bandwidth of interest is small enough that the curvature of the phase matching function may be neglected . for practical implementations of this technique , it is important to analyze the required tolerances for the experimental parameters , in order to ensure factorizability . figure [ fig : tolerances ] shows a plot of the schmidt number @xmath160 as a function of the three parameters which must satisfy a strict condition in order to attain complete group velocity matching . we plot the schmidt number as a function of each of these parameters , while maintaining all others equal to their nominal values ( which yield the minimum value of @xmath160 ) . thus , fig . [ fig : tolerances](a ) shows @xmath160 vs the bragg period @xmath4 , fig . [ fig : tolerances](b ) shows @xmath160 vs the permittivity contrast @xmath13 , and fig . [ fig : tolerances](c ) shows @xmath160 vs the crystal propagation angle @xmath138 . we define the tolerance in variable @xmath161 as @xmath162 where @xmath163 ( with @xmath164 ) are the values where @xmath160 rises to @xmath165 in terms of the value of the schmidt number attained when all variables are equal to their nominal values @xmath166 . thus , we obtain @xmath167 nm , @xmath168 , and @xmath169 . we have studied the generation of photon pairs by spontaneous parametric down - conversion in a one - dimensional nonlinear photonic crystal , with a broadband pump . we have considered a nlpc based on a standard @xmath170 crystal with uniaxial birefringence where the dispersion for both polarizations has been altered from its natural state so that , throughout the length of the resulting crystal , the index of refraction for each polarization alternately takes the value consistent with material - only dispersion and a value that is larger than the former , consistent with a small permittivity contrast . we have developed a set of conditions that must be satisfied in order to guarantee a nearly factorable two photon state . these conditions are : ( i ) complete group velocity matching , where the pump pulse and the signal and idler photons propagate at the same group velocity [ see eq.([ec : gvm ] ) ] , ( ii ) weak pump dispersion [ characterized by coefficients @xmath124 , see eq.([ec : taylor_terms ] ) ] , relative to signal and idler dispersion [ characterized by coefficients @xmath102 , see eq.([ec : weak_pump ] ) ] , and ( iii ) sufficient pump bandwidth [ see eq.([ec : pump ] ) ] . we have shown that the strongly - modified dispersion in the spectral vicinity of the bandgap boundaries in a nlpc may be exploited in order to fulfil condition ( i ) , and to partially fulfil condition ( ii ) . the essential advantage of this technique is that for an arbitrary nonlinear material operated at an arbitrary spectral range it is in principle possible to design a photonic - crystal structure which counteracts the material dispersion so as to permit the generation of factorable photon pairs in a type - ii degenerate , collinear geometry which is compatible with wave guiding and which permits high efficiency photon pair splitting . it is , however , anticipated that the fabrication of the appropriate photonic - crystal structure may pose the main technical challenge in practical implementations . longer bragg periods , potentially more easily fabricated , could be exploited through higher - order bandgaps . it is expected that this work may be important for the development of optimized nonclassical light sources for quantum information processing .

we study the joint spectral properties of photon pairs generated by spontaneous parametric down - conversion in a one - dimensional nonlinear photonic crystal in a collinear , degenerate , type - ii geometry . we show that the photonic crystal properties may be exploited to compensate for material dispersion and obtain photon pairs that are nearly factorable , in principle , for arbitrary materials and spectral regions , limited by the ability to fabricate the nonlinear crystal with the required periodic variation in the refractive indices for the ordinary and extraordinary waves .

0812.3869

the theoretical framework of physics has evolved enormously since the time of newton , but one notable invariant , so pervasive as to be effectively invisible , is the one - dimensionality of time . while time and space have been amalgamated into a composite known as _ spacetime _ in the wake of relativity theory , and while modern superstring theories follow the kaluza - klein theory in postulating more than three _ space _ dimensions , time itself has remained one - dimensional . indeed , very little work has been devoted to the study of multiple time dimensions . yet one might like to know more about physics with multiple times for at least two reasons : * it s not at all clear we can be confident that our world has a single time dimension unless we know what a world with multiple times looks like . kant thought such a world was inconceivable . but kant also thought that space must be three - dimensional and euclidean @xcite . * problems connected with the interpretation of quantum mechanics , the construction and interpretation of a quantum theory of gravity , and the origin of cosmological time asymmetry all suggest the need for a new conceptual framework . these questions motivate recent work of walter craig and myself @xcite , work which explores , from a mathematical perspective , the features one might expect in a theory with multiple time dimensions . the results are surprising , undermining as they do the conventional wisdom that such theories are plagued by instabilities @xcite or are hopelessly unpredictive @xcite . as i ll show , theories in multiple time dimensions allow a meaningful sense of determinism , while giving rise to intriguingly nonlocal constraints on initial data . furthermore , the way in which these sorts of constraints arise , from a reconception of the structure of the spacetime background , suggests heretofore unexplored ways of extending physical theory . the special theory of relativity brought with it the relativity of simultaneity , which in turn prompted a reimagining of space and time as _ spacetime _ , a four - dimensional manifold of points @xmath0 equipped with a metric @xmath1 , the latter giving the distance between pairs of nearby points . if the square of the distance is positive , then the distance is spatial , and if it s negative , the distance is temporal . we say that the _ signature _ of the metric on a 4-dimensional manifold @xmath2 metric is @xmath3 if three of the directions are spatial and one is temporal .. ] the signature of a 5-dimensional metric with four space dimensions and one time dimension is thus @xmath4 , whereas a metric with three space and two time dimensions has signature @xmath5 . thus it is straightforward to characterize spacetimes with any given number of space and time dimensions . matter generally takes the form of either particles or fields , though extended objects such as strings and membranes are also possible . the focus here will be on fields , in particular the massless scalar field @xmath6 described by the ` wave equation ' @xmath7 this is a simple equation in three space dimensions and one time dimension which describes many phenomena of interest , most notably the propagation of the components of the electromagnetic field ( thus the behavior of light ) . there is a ` well - posed ' initial value problem for this equation . what this means is that if we are given sufficient information about the field at a given time , a stable solution of the equation exists , and it is unique . in other words , the initial data completely determine the data at all other times , and do so in such a way that small errors in the specification of the initial data do not lead to uncontrollable errors in the solution . in the usual case , in which the initial data lies on a hypersurface of codimension one ( meaning a hypersurface of dimension one less than the total dimension of spacetime ) , the initial value problem is called the cauchy problem . because the equation contains only second derivatives , the appropriate initial data for the cauchy problem consist of the field and its first normal derivative at each point . ( the ` normal ' derivative is the derivative perpendicular to the hypersurface , which is the derivative in the time direction . ) this is given by the functions @xmath8 ( where @xmath9 stands for @xmath10 ) . the statement that the cauchy problem for the wave equation is well - posed means that , given appropriately differentiable functions @xmath11 and @xmath1 representing the relevant properties of the field at some time , a unique , stable solution exists for all times . the generalization of the wave equation to a spacetime with @xmath12 space dimensions and @xmath13 time dimensions is the ` ultrahyperbolic ' equation@xmath14 where @xmath15 and @xmath16 and where both @xmath12 and @xmath13 are greater than @xmath17 . let s now investigate the status of the initial value _ problems _ for this equation , where i say problems rather than problem in recognition of the fact that the meaning of initial is up for grabs in the presence of more than one time dimension . it has long been known ( to those who know it ) that the ordinary cauchy problem for equation ( [ ultra])the initial value problem on a surface of codimension one , i.e. dimension @xmath19 is not well - posed . it was shown by courant @xcite , using the mean - value theorem of asgeirsson , that solutions of the equation do not exist for arbitrary choices of initial data@xmath20 where @xmath21 and @xmath15 as before . this is perhaps unsurprising , given that the initial hypersurface is a ` mixed ' hypersurface@xmath22 , extended not only in @xmath12 space dimensions but also in @xmath23 time dimensions . therefore , it is traversed by lightlike lines , so - called ` characteristics ' along which one expects disturbances in the field to propagate . initial.png + initial data on a mixed hypersurface ( dashed lines represent lightlike lines ) . it might be thought that there is an additional obstacle to well - posedness , that just as ( global ) solutions do not exist at all for some initial data , other data are consistent with _ multiple _ solutions , conflicting with the uniqueness requirement . however , this is not the case : the holmgren - john uniqueness theorem guarantees that cauchy data on our mixed hypersurface uniquely determine the solution everywhere , as long as that initial data is consistent with _ some _ solution . indeed , it tells us that domains of dependence and influence are compact , so that we only need to know the solution on a compact region @xmath24 of the cauchy surface in order to determine the solution at a given point @xmath25 off the surface . tlike3.png + data in @xmath24 on a mixed hypersurface determines data out to @xmath25 . this holds true even for mixed surfaces in ordinary spacetime ( replace @xmath9 with @xmath26 @xmath27 @xmath28 with @xmath29 , and @xmath30 with @xmath31 in the figure above ) . the absence of a well - posed initial value problem is tantamount to a lack of any sort of practical predictability , and it has been argued that observers _ qua _ information processors could not even exist in such a universe , as they would be unable to engage in any meaningful action in response to information gleaned about their environment . thus it has been argued that universes with more than one time dimension are not meaningful possibilities @xcite . however , recent work of walter craig and myself @xcite shows that this judgment is too hasty . imposition of a constraint on the initial data yields a well posed cauchy problem after all . for those unfamiliar with the notion of a constraint , consider maxwell s theory of electromagnetism . the values of the electric and magnetic fields at a given time uniquely determine the evolution of the field . but given arbitrary initial data , which is to say arbitrary electric and magnetic fields at some time , a solution to the maxwell equations of motion will not , in general , exist . fortunately , maxwell s theory comes with two constraints , gauss s law for electricity @xmath32 and for magnetism @xmath33 . initial @xmath25 ( electric ) and @xmath34 ( magnetic ) fields satisfying these constraints _ do _ give rise to unique global solutions . with the imposition of the constraints , the initial value problem is indeed well - posed . the situation turns out to be similar for the ultrahyperbolic equation . there is a constraint on the initial data such that all and only data satisfying the constraint lead to a ( stable ) solution . the constraint is most straightforwardly specified in terms of the fourier transforms of the initial data @xmath35 and @xmath36 . it consists simply of the requirement that the domains of @xmath37 and @xmath38 be restricted to the region @xmath39 the inverse fourier transforms @xmath40 of such functions then correspond to the allowable sets of initial data . with the imposition of the constraint ( [ constraint ] ) , the problem is well - posed . the constraint ( [ constraint ] ) has an interesting property : it is nonlocal , in that it establishes nontrivial correlations between the values of the field at different points on the hypersurface . below we have an illustration of this on a surface spanned by one space and one time dimension : courant @xcite shows that the field in @xmath41 uniquely determines the field in @xmath24 . tlike3d.png + @xmath41 determines @xmath24 . the nonlocality here is causally benign , since there is no sense in which changes in one region bring about instantaneous changes in the larger region ; it is a version of what i refer to in @xcite as nonlocality without nonlocality . i ll have more to say about the potential physical significance of such nonlocal constraints toward the conclusion of this essay . we ve seen , then , that many of the features one physics with one time dimension remain in the transition to multiple time dimensions , when the initial value problem is understood as a cauchy problem . * the initial value problem is well - posed , albeit in the company of a novel , nonlocal constraint . * the domains of dependence are compact , as shown by the holmgren - john uniqueness theorem . * furthermore , there is a well - defined energy functional a hamiltonian which is conserved with respect to the chosen time . let s now move on and look at other versions of the initial value problem , corresponding to other notions of initial in the presence of multiple times . in ordinary physics with a single time dimension , determinism means that the state of the system at one time determines the state at other times . for a field theory , the initial data are naturally given on a hypersurface of codimension one , meaning one fewer dimension than the entire spacetime . the construction of the cauchy problem in the previous section simply carries this over to a spacetime with multiple times , giving data again on a hypersurface of codimension one , the difference being that the hypersurface is mixed , rather than purely spacelike . but one might suppose that a more natural way to give initial data in a theory with multiple times is to give it on a surface of codimension @xmath13 ( where @xmath13 , again , corresponds to the number of time dimensions . ) in other words , instead of giving data at @xmath18 , we give it on a purely spacelike hypersurface @xmath42 ( which stands for @xmath43 ) . now on the one hand , one might think that the higher codimension problem is intractable , because there is simply too little information on a surface of higher codimension to uniquely determine the evolution of the field . after all , in ordinary physics , we do not expect that giving the values of a field on a high - codimension surface e.g . the @xmath44 plane ( i.e. , the @xmath45 plane)will suffice to determine the evolution for all times @xmath31 . not even close ! on the other hand , one might think that the presence of a constraint could help , since one can not fill out the rest of the codimension one hypersurface arbitrarily : one must satisfy the constraint . it turns out that the constraint is not sufficient to give a unique solution . craig and i @xcite show that the extension of data on @xmath46 to @xmath47 and then to general @xmath48 is highly nonunique , no matter how much initial data is given on the initial hypersurface . even if one gives not just the value of the field and its first normal derivatives ( in the various time directions ) , but an arbitrary number of additional normal derivatives , the solution is highly nonunique . so the higher codimenson problem is , in fact , intractable . suppose that instead of giving initial data _ on _ the hypersurface @xmath42 , one gives it both on the hypersurface and in an arbitrarily small timelike neighborhood @xmath49 of the hypersurface . the result of courant @xcite discussed earlier has as a consequence that if the data in this neighborhood are compatible with a solution if a solution exists for these data then the solution is uniquely determined in the entire spacetime . courant remarks : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ [ w]e are dealing with the remarkable phenomenon of functions which are not necessarily analytic , yet whose values in an arbitrarily small region determine the function in a substantially bigger domain . ( @xcite , 760 ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ so moving from data _ on _ the higher - codimension hypersurface to data in the immediate region of the hypersurface changes the nature of the problem in an essential way . for data on @xmath42 , a solution always exists , but is highly underdetermined , while for data in an arbitrarily small neighborhood @xmath49 of that point , a solution may not exist , but if it does , it is _ unique_. this almost - initial - value problem is not well - posed , since arbitrarily small changes may take initial data which are compatible with a solution to initial data which are not compatible . nevertheless we have a strong form of determinism . note that this phenomenon is not limited to multiple time scenarios . just as one can start with almost - initial data on all of space ( all points @xmath9 ) in the immediate neighborhood of @xmath42 , one can start with data on all of time ( all points @xmath31 ) in the neighborhood of some point in space @xmath50 . thus in ordinary spacetime , with a single time dimension , the field in an arbitrary small volume of space @xmath51 specified at all times @xmath31 determines the field _ everywhere _ in the entire spacetime . again , one can not pose arbitrary data on such a timelike worldtube . but if a solution does exist for the data given , then it is uniquely determined by the data in the worldtube . an observer sitting at one point in space for all time would in a sense have information about the entire , infinite spacetime . we ve looked at three sorts of initial value problem for a single , multi - time theory . the initial value problem on hypersurfaces of higher codimension is such that one has neither existence nor uniqueness of solution for arbitrary data , whereas a slight thickening of the higher codimension hypersurfaces _ does _ give something closer to a well - posed problem , since solutions are unique , if they exist at all . when we consider the cauchy problem , though , where our initial data is specified on mixed ( space and time ) hypersurfaces of codimension one , we finally get something which is remarkably close to ordinary physics . here we have a well - posed initial value problem , compact domains of dependence , and a conserved energy . let us focus , then , on the codimension one problem , the cauchy problem . certainly one might wonder about what it means to specify initial data on a hypersurface which is extended in space and time . but there is no reason _ a priori _ why an observer would not just treat the time dimension or dimensions on the surface as additional spatial dimensions , rewriting for example @xmath52 as@xmath53 leaving aside the question of where and how the observer obtains her time orientation , let us assume that to some observer , @xmath28 looks like time , whereas @xmath30 looks like just another space dimension , albeit one which enters with a different sign in the equations of motion . from this perspective , the primary difference between this and the ordinary wave equation is just the anisotropy of space , where the scare - quotes indicate that we are referring to the mixed hypersurface coordinatized by @xmath54 , and @xmath30 . a further difference is that the initial value problem is well - posed only for data satisfying the constraint ( [ constraint ] ) , as we ve already noted . from these two features , the presence of a negative sign in the equations of motion and the consequent requirement of a constraint to ensure the existence of global ( nonsingular ) solutions , the observer might infer one of two things : 1 . the world may have begun a finite time ago , as a singularity may lie in the past , or the end of the world may be nigh , as a singularity may lie in the future . 2 . the additional , nonlocal constraint is a feature of the laws of nature , a feature which guarantees that the evolution is nonsingular , having no beginning or end . i say may for ( 1 ) since , just as with the wave equation in ordinary spacetime , the observer can not predict arbitrarily far into the future or the past without access to data on the entire cauchy surface . on the other hand , the observer might take a different attitude toward the constraint , and settle on ( 3 ) in the belief that nature abhors a singularity , or in the ( related ) belief that a finite universe is absurd . this observer takes the view that the constraint is an additional law of nature , one which guarantees meaningful nonsingular , global evolution . one can imagine an argument amongst theorists in this world as to whether the constraint amounts to an _ ad hoc _ addition to their laws . one group looks at the laws and notices that they lead to singularities for arbitrary data and concludes that there must be an additional law constraining the data . the other group looks at the laws and from the same evidence concludes that there may be a singularity in the past or the future : the laws break down . this is an interesting and suggestive scenario from the perspective of present - day physics , since the laws that govern the evolution of spacetime do lead to singularities for arbitrary initial data @xcite . at the same time , there is evidence of nonlocality in the large and in the small . in the large , cosmology is dotted with disturbingly _ ad hoc _ constraints on the states of the universe , particularly the low entropy and near - homogeneity of the early universe . ( these are addressed but not resolved by inflation , which requires its own set of fine - tuned parameters @xcite . ) in the small , quantum mechanics predicts nonlocal entanglement between the properties of a given field at various locations in space . it would certainly be worthwhile to explore whether nonlocal constraints might explain any of these phenomena , perhaps in conjunction with a modification of the dynamical laws . the sort of constraint explored in this essay , one arising from the presence of extra time dimensions , exhibits one sort of nonlocality , but there are other sorts as well , given by constraints with different functional forms . what they have in common is that they embody what i have called nonlocality without nonlocality , meaning nonlocal correlations without nonlocal causation . the study of multiple time dimensions here is rather preliminary . i have not discussed gauge fields or other massive fields , and on a conceptual level i have not tackled what may be the most difficult question of all , how to characterize observers and observation in such a theory . what i have shown , i hope , is that theories with multiple time dimensions are a live conceptual possibility , and that if nothing else , they serve to stretch our minds as to what may be physically possible .

the possibility of physics in multiple time dimensions is investigated . drawing on recent work by walter craig and myself @xcite , i show that , contrary to conventional wisdom , there is a well - posed initial value problem deterministic , stable evolution for theories in multiple time dimensions . though similar in many ways to ordinary , single - time theories , multi - time theories have some rather intriguing properties which suggest new directions for the understanding of fundamental physics .

0808.0400

the subject of deformed quantum field theories has attracted renewed attention in recent years due to their natural appearance in string theory . initial studies were devoted to theories on non - commutative spacetime in which the commutator of the spacetime co - ordinates becomes non - zero . more recently@xcite-@xcite , non - anticommutative supersymmetric theories have been constructed by deforming the anticommutators of the grassmann co - ordinates @xmath1 ( while leaving the anticommutators of the @xmath2 unaltered ) . consequently , the anticommutators of the supersymmetry generators @xmath3 are deformed while those of the @xmath4 are unchanged . non - anticommutative versions of the wess - zumino model and supersymmetric gauge theories have been formulated in four dimensions@xcite and their renormalisability discussed@xcite-@xcite , with explicit computations up to two loops@xcite for the wess - zumino model and one loop for gauge theories@xcite@xcite . more recently still , non - anticommutative theories in two dimensions have been considered . on the one hand , non - anticommutative versions of particular non - linear @xmath5-models have been constructed ( by dimensional reduction from four dimensions)@xcite and the one - loop corrections computed@xcite ; on the other hand , a non - anticommutative version of the general @xmath6 khler @xmath5-model has been constructed directly in two dimensions , initially in refs . @xcite but then given an elegant reformulation in refs . the one - loop divergences for this model were computed in ref . @xcite , where it was found convenient to introduce differential operators implementing the deformed supersymmetry algebra acting on the component fields . in this article we return to a closer examination of the non - anticommutative wess - zumino model in four dimensions . firstly , we show how analogues of the differential operators introduced in ref . @xcite may easily be constructed to implement the non - anticommutative supersymmetry algebra for this model in its component formulation . next we re - examine the two - loop calculation first performed in ref . @xcite , showing that to correctly obtain results for the theory where the auxiliary fields have been eliminated from those for the uneliminated theory , it is necessary to include in the classical action separate couplings for all the terms which may be generated by the renormalisation process . we show that ( at least up to two - loop order ) the results obtained when we eliminate the auxiliary field after renormalisation are equivalent to those obtained when we eliminate the auxiliary fields before quantisation . we follow the analysis of ref . @xcite in determining differential operators which represent the supersymmetry algebra in the undeformed and deformed cases . the supersymmetry charges are q_=,_= -+2i^ _ , where _ & = & ^ _ , y^&=&x^+i^^ _ ^. [ eq : ydef ] they satisfy the algebra \{q_,q_}=0 , & & \ { _ , _ } = 0,\{_,q_}&=&2i_.[eq : undefcom ] the superfields have expansions in terms of component fields given by & = & + 2+^2 f , + & = & + 2 - 2i^_+^2 , [ compexp ] where the component fields are functions of @xmath7 , as defined in eq . ( [ eq : ydef ] ) . it is useful to represent the charges @xmath4 , @xmath3 by differential operators @xmath8 , @xmath9 acting on the fields , i.e. & = & q_,&=&^0_[eq : undefopa ] ( with similar expressions for @xmath10 ) where q_&= & _ + f -i[_]+i [ _ ^ ] , [ eq : undefopba ] + 1_^0&= & _ - -i [ _ ] -i[_^ ] . [ eq : undefopbb ] the superscript `` 0 '' is in anticipation of a different form for @xmath11 in the deformed case ; while @xmath8 , on the other hand , will be unchanged . our convention will be that a derivative or other operator acts on everything to its right , unless enclosed in square brackets . ( by the way , note that _ = - . ) in this section we repeat the analysis of the previous section for the case of deformed supersymmetry . for the deformed version we take \{^,^}=0 , \{^,^}=c^. the charges then satisfy the algebra \{q_,q_}=0 , & & \ { _ , _ } = -4c^ _ _ , \{_,q_}&=&2i_.[eq : acomm ] the non - anticommutativity is implemented at the level of superfields by introducing the moyal @xmath12-product , which satisfies ^*^&=&-12^^2 + 12c^,^*^2&=&c^_,^2*^2&=&-c . we now wish to construct differential operators @xmath11 representing the effects of @xmath3 in the deformed case in a similar manner to eq . ( [ eq : undefopa ] ) , extending @xmath9 given in eq . ( [ eq : undefopbb ] ) for the undeformed case . ( as mentioned before , the operators @xmath8 are unchanged by the deformation . ) we start by examining the effects of @xmath3 on powers of @xmath13 alone , since mixed products of @xmath13 and @xmath10 present additional complications . defining i_r^(n)(,f)=_-12 ^ 12d()^r ( + f)^n it is straightforward to show using the methods of ref . @xcite that ^n_*= ( 1+q -14 ^ 2 q^2)(i_0^(n)-q^2i_1^(n ) ) , [ suppot ] where @xmath14 denotes the @xmath12-product of @xmath15 @xmath13 s . then acting on @xmath14 , @xmath3 is represented by ^_=^0 _ -i(qc)_+4i ( -q^2[_q^]+_q^+ [ _ q^ ] ) . [ eq : fullq ] here i_0^(n)&=&i_1^(n),i_1^(n)&= & i_2^(n)-i_0^(n).[eq : orels ] these properties are guaranteed by the following definitions : & = & _ r=1^a_r ( ) ^r ( 4f)^2r-1,&=&_r=1^(2r-1)a_r ( ) ^r ( 4f)^2r-2,where the @xmath16 must satisfy for each @xmath17@xcite _ r=0^n-1= , the first few being given by a_1= , a_2=-,a_3=. to check that the operators in eq . ( [ eq : fullq ] ) do indeed represent the operators @xmath3 according to _ * = ^_^n _ * ( where @xmath18_*$ ] represents the commutator evaluated using @xmath12-products ) we need to use eqs . ( [ eq : orels ] ) in conjunction with _ ^0i_r^(n ) = -i [ _ q^]i_r+1^(n).[eq : idsa ] of course it is not sufficient to reproduce the effects of @xmath3 on @xmath12-products of @xmath13 alone ; we saw in the two - dimensional case that it was necessary to consider the effect on deformed versions of general polynomials in @xmath13 and @xmath10 , such as the khler potential . in the case of the four - dimensional wess - zumino model , to investigate the divergence structure it would be sufficient to consider only the effects of @xmath3 on cubic superpotentials in either @xmath13 or @xmath10 , or on @xmath19 . however , in general , if one were interested in contributions to the effective action , one would need once again to consider deformed versions of general polynomials ; and so we shall again take the khler potential as an example . for an undeformed khler potential k[,]=_n , mk_n , m^n^m , the natural definition of the deformed khler potential is k_*[,]=_n , mk_n , m[^n^m ] _ * , where @xmath20_*$ ] represents the symmetrised @xmath12-product of @xmath15 @xmath13 s and @xmath21 @xmath10 s . it can be shown that k_*[,]&= & ( 1+q-14 ^ 2 q^2)&&&&-^2 q^2()^2 k_0(,f , ) , [ kstar ] where k_m(,f,)=_-12 ^ 12d()^m k(+ f , ) . here a prime denotes the part of the operator containing derivatives with respect to the chiral ( but not the anti - chiral ) fields , and correspondingly a double prime denotes the part of the operator containing derivatives with respect to the anti - chiral ( but not the chiral ) fields . moreover , _ = [ _ ] + [ _ _ ] + [ _ ] , with a similar expression for @xmath22 . the corresponding version of the operator representing @xmath3 is @xmath11 defined by _ & = & ^0 _ -i(qc)_- ( _ q^q^2 + _q^q^2)&&+4i ( -q^2[_q^]+_q^+ [ _q^ ] ) . [ eq : fullqa ] we can verify that these operators do indeed implement the operators @xmath3 according to _ * = _ k _ * , using the analogue of eq . ( [ eq : orels ] ) for the khler potential , k_0&=&k_1,k_1&= & k_2-k_0[eq : orelsa ] together with the analogue of eq . ( [ eq : idsa ] ) , _ ^0k_r =- i[_q^ ] k_r+1,q^_k_0=q^_k_1=0 . moreover , it is easy to check that the operators @xmath8 in eq . ( [ eq : undefopba ] ) and @xmath11 in eq . ( [ eq : fullqa ] ) satisfy the anticommutation relations of eq . ( [ eq : acomm ] ) , using = -i[_q^ ] ( which implies [ _ ^0 , ] = -i[_q^ ] ) . the kinetic part of the standard wess - zumino model may be obtained as in ref . @xcite from eq . ( [ kstar ] ) taking simply @xmath23=\phi\phibar$ ] , s_kin&=&d^4xd^2d^2 = d^4x q^2 ^ 2&=&d^4x ( ^_+i^ _ + f ) , [ inva ] so we see that the kinetic terms are undeformed . we see from eq . ( [ suppot ] ) that the holomorphic potential terms are given by s_w = -d^4xd^2 [ 12 m _ * ^2 + 16y_*^3 ] = 14d^4x q^2[12mi_0^(2)+16yi_0^(3 ) ] [ invb ] which leads to s_w = d^4x [ 12m(^2-f)+12y(^2-f^2)+ 16y(c ) f^3 ] . since @xmath24 , the antiholomorphic potential terms are given by s_w = -d^4xd^2 [ 12 ^ 2 + 16 ^ 3 ] = 14d^4x ^2[12 ^ 2 + 16 ^ 3 ] [ invc ] which leads to s_w= d^4x [ 12(^2-)+12(^2 -^2 ) ] , with no deformation ( the deformed part of @xmath25 in eq . ( [ eq : fullqa ] ) having no effect on a function of @xmath26 ) . the full classical @xmath27 action is therefore s&=&d^4x ( ^_+i^ _ + f -gf-&&+12y^2 + 12 ^ 2 + 12m^2 + 12 ^ 2 + 16 y(c ) f^3 ) , [ defact ] where @xmath28 . this action was first derived in ref . @xcite by taking the standard undeformed ( @xmath29 ) action in superfields and replacing ordinary products by moyal @xmath12-products . in the undeformed case , expressions like those in eqs . ( [ inva ] ) , ( [ invb ] ) and ( [ invc ] ) in terms of @xmath8 and @xmath30 encapsulate the supersymmetry of the undeformed action @xmath31 due to the nilpotency of @xmath8 , @xmath11 and the fact that @xmath8 , @xmath9 annihilate functions of @xmath26 , @xmath32 , respectively , leading to q_s_0=^0_s_0=0 . in the deformed case , although q_s_kin= _ s_kin = q_s_w= q_s_w = _ s_w=0 , it is not the case that @xmath33 ; indeed it is no longer the case that @xmath34 either . it is only the tranformations generated by @xmath4 that are a symmetry of the deformed action with potential . it is worth mentioning that in the two - dimensional case ( where we considered only the kinetic part of the action derived from the khler potential ) , despite our classical action being annihilated by @xmath35 and @xmath25 , the divergent quantum corrections were only annihilated by @xmath35 . in fact it is only for simple linear field transformations that one can prove that an invariance of the classical action results in a similar invariance of the quantum corrections ; for non - linear gauge transformations the quantum invariance is encapsulated in ward identities , and for transformations such as our deformed @xmath11 some other formulation may be possible . in this section we discuss the renormalisation of the non - anticommutative wess - zumino model up to two loops . two - loop calculations for this model were first performed by grisaru et al@xcite ; here we extend their calculation by including from the outset the full set of terms which can be generated by renormalisation . we shall postpone until later a detailed comparison of our results with theirs . the only effect of the non - anticommutativity in the component action of eq . ( [ defact ] ) is the final @xmath36 term . as we emphasised at the end of the last section , the deformed action is only invariant under the transformations generated by @xmath4 . this term is in fact separately invariant under these residual @xmath27 transformations and so there is no reason for the coefficient to evolve in the same manner as the yukawa coupling in the @xmath29 part of the action ; and therefore we are at liberty ( possibly even obliged ) to introduce this term with its own separate coefficient . in fact , this term generates one - loop divergences whose cancellation requires @xmath37 and @xmath38 terms in the action ; and these terms in turn generate further @xmath39 divergences together with other new terms . all these terms should be included in the classical action with their own coefficients in order to guarantee renormalisability . it is easy to see which additional terms can be generated@xcite . ( for a complete analysis in the general , gauged case , see ref . the action has a `` pseudo r - symmetry '' under e^-i , fe^if , c^e^-2ic^,ye^iy , [ psea ] @xmath40 , @xmath26 and @xmath41 transforming with opposite charges to @xmath42 , @xmath32 and @xmath43 respectively , and @xmath44 , @xmath45 being neutral ; and also a `` pseudo - chiral symmetry '' under e^i , me^-2im , ye^-3iy , [ pseb ] @xmath42 and @xmath44 transforming in a similar fashion to @xmath32 and barred quantities transforming with opposite charges . the divergent terms which can arise subject to these invariances have been enumerated@xcite and consist ( for the ungauged case ) of ^-1(c ) f^3 , & & ^-1(c ) f^2 , ^-1(c ) f^2 , ^-1(c ) ^3 , & & ^-2 ^ 2(c ) f^2 , ^-2 ^ 2(c ) f , ^-2 ^ 2(c ) ^2 , & & ^-3 ^ 4 ( c ) f , ^-3 ^ 4(c ) . [ terms ] we have anticipated here the fact , adumbrated in ref . @xcite and proved in ref . @xcite , that the divergences form combinations of @xmath42 and @xmath46 ; so that we need only a single coupling to remove divergences in ( for instance ) @xmath47 and @xmath48 . we have included in ( [ terms ] ) the appropriate factors of @xmath41 for invariance under the pseudo - chiral symmetry . these factors are not uniquely determined since @xmath49 is invariant under this symmetry ; the choice we have made is both concise and motivated by later considerations . each of these terms is separately @xmath27 invariant and so there is nothing in the classical theory to determine their coefficients ; but we shall investigate whether renormalisability has anything to tell us about their values . in fact , some of the terms listed in ( [ terms ] ) could be omitted and still leave a renormalisable theory ( at least up to two - loop order ) ; but nevertheless for completeness we shall include all the above terms in our classical action . ( as pointed out in ref . @xcite , terms of the form @xmath50 and @xmath51 are possible ; but not in the present ungauged case with only one chiral field . ) we are therefore led to the action s&=&d^4x ( ^ _ + i^_+f - gf-&&+12y^2 + 12 ^ 2 + 12m^2 + 12 ^ 2&&+^-1&&+12 ^ -2 ^ 2 + ^-3 ^ 4[k_8f+k_9 ] ) . [ sunel ] here the @xmath36 has been absorbed into the coefficients @xmath52 . we note that we have no way to determine the renormalisation of @xmath36 separately , only that of the coefficients @xmath52 . we write the divergent contributions to the deformed part of the effective action in the form ^pole_c&=&-d^4x [ ^-1(_1f^3+_2f^2+_3f^2+_4 ^ 3)&&+^-2 ^ 2(_5f^2+_6f+_7 ^ 2 ) + ^-3 ^ 4(_8f+_9 ) ] . [ divdef ] ( note the overall minus sign , introduced to avoid a proliferation of negative signs later on . ) note also that @xmath53 will be assumed to contain no finite parts . the divergent diagrams contributing to @xmath53 can be divided into groups , each group containing diagrams which have the same internal lines and numbers of vertices and also the same number of external @xmath42 lines ; thus only differing in the numbers of external @xmath26 lines and attendant @xmath41 or @xmath54 couplings at the vertices . the divergent contributions within each group can be expressed purely in terms of @xmath42 and @xmath46 . in fig . [ fig1 ] are depicted examples of each group at one loop ( the one with the maximal number of external @xmath26 lines ) . their divergent contributions are shown diagram by diagram in table [ taba ] and given in total by _ 1^(1)&=&12k_2,_2^(1)&=&(2k_1 + 4k_2 + 3k_3),_3^(1)&=&(2k_2 + 4k_3 + 52k_4),_4^(1)&=&0,_5^(1)&=&(k_1 + 2k_2+k_3 + k_6),_6^(1)&=&(k_2 + 2k_3+k_4 + 2k_5 + 4k_6 + 3k_7),_7^(1)&=&0,_8^(1)&=&(k_5 + 2k_6+k_7+k_9),_9^(1)&=&0 , [ zonea ] where l=. .[taba ] divergent contributions from fig . [ fig1 ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the total two - loop divergences are given by _ 1^(2)&=&\{k_1+[12i+2]k_2 + 32k_3},_2^(2)&=&\ { 4[2i+1]k_1+[16i+15]k_2 + 9[i+2]k_3+k_4},_3^(2)&=&\ { [ 4k_1 + 20k_2 + 28k_3+k_4]i},_4^(2)&=&0,_5^(2)&=&\ { 2([2i+1]k_1 + k_2 + 2[i+2]k_3 + 32k_4)&&+k_5+[i+2]k_6 + 32k_7},_6^(2)&=&\ { 2(2k_1 + 8k_2 + 10k_3 + 4k_4 ) + 8k_5 + 16k_6 + 9k_7}i,_7^(2)&=&0,_8^(2)&=&\ { k_1 + 3k_2 + 3k_3+k_4 + 4(k_5 + 2k_6+k_7 ) + k_9}i,_9^(2)&=&0 . [ ztwoa ] the two - loop contributions to the bare couplings are given ( from the bare form of eq . ( [ sunel ] ) and using eqs . ( [ nonren ] ) , ( [ gren ] ) ) by k_1b^(2)&=&6_1^(2)-3z^(2)k_1 - 3(z^(1))^2k_1 -3z^(1)(k^(1)_1b+3r^(1)_b)-3r^(2)_b , k_2b^(2)&=&2_2^(2)-2z^(2)k_2 -(z^(1))^2k_2 - 2z^(1)(k^(1)_2b - r^(1)_b + 2s^(1)_b)+r^(2)_b-2s^(2)_b , k_3b^(2)&=&2_3^(2)-z^(2)k_3 -z^(1)(k^(1)_3b-2s^(1)_b+t^(1)_b)+2s^(2)_b -t^(2)_b , k_4b^(2)&=&6_4^(2)+3t^(2)_b , k_5b^(2)&=&2_5^(2)-2z^(2)k_5-(z^(1))^2k_5 -2z^(1)(k_5b^(1)+2u^(1)_b)-2u^(2)_b , k_6b^(2)&=&_6^(2)-z^(2)k_6 -z^(1)(k_6b^(1)-u^(1)_1b+v^(1)_b ) + u^(2)_b - v^(2)_b , k_7b^(2)&=&2_7^(2)+2v^(2)_b , k_8b^(2)&=&_8^(2)-z^(2)k_8-z^(1)(k_8b^(1 ) + w^(1)_b)-w^(2)_b , k_9b^(2)&=&_9^(2)+w^(2)_b , [ ktwoa ] which yields , using eqs . ( [ eq1 ] ) , ( [ eq2 ] ) , ( [ ztwo ] ) , ( [ ztwoa ] ) , k_1b^(2)&=&[3(i+4)k_1 + 3(i+7)k_2 + 9k_3]-3r^(2)_b , k_2b^(2)&=&[16(i+1)k_1+(34i+49)k_2 + 6(3i+8)k_3 + 15k_4 ] + r^(2)_b-2s^(2)_b , k_3b^(2)&=&[8ik_1 + 4(10i+1)k_2 + 3(19i+3)k_3 + 5(5i+1)k_4 ] + 2s^(2)_b - t^(2)_b , k_4b^(2)&=&3t^(2)_b , k_5b^(2)&=&[8(i+1)k_1 + 2(8i+11)k_2 + 4(2i+5)k_3 + 6k_4+(2i+5)k_5 + 2(i+4)k_6 + 3k_7]&&-2u^(2)_b , k_6b^(2)&=&[4ik_1+(16i+1)k_2 + 2(10i+1)k_3+(8i+1)k_4 + 2(4i+1)k_5&&+(17i+5)k_6 + 3(3i+1)k_7]+u^(2)_b - v^(2)_b , k_7b^(2)&=&2v^(2)_b , k_8b^(2)&=&[i(k_1 + 3k_2 + 3k_3+k_4)+(4i+1)(k_5 + 2k_6+k_7)+(i+1)(k_8+k_9 ) ] -w^(2)_b , k_9b^(2)&=&w^(2)_b . [ ktwo ] as at one loop , requiring that @xmath55 as given by eqs . ( [ eq1 ] ) , ( [ eq1a ] ) be @xmath56-independent gives _ i^(2)=2^(2,1 ) [ betatwo ] together with the consistency conditions for the two - loop double poles , 2(16 ^ 2)_1^(2,2)&=&3(^(1,1)_1+^(1,1)_2)y+3(_y^(1)+y_^(1))(k_1+k_2),2(16 ^ 2)_2^(2,2)&=&2(2^(1,1)_1 + 5^(1,1)_2 + 3^(1,1)_3)y&&+2(_y^(1)+y_^(1))(2k_1 + 5k_2 + 3k_3 ) , [ constwo ] from eqs . ( [ eq1 ] ) , ( [ eq1a ] ) , ( [ ktwo ] ) , ( [ betatwo ] ) , the two - loop @xmath57-functions are hence given by _ 1^(2)&=&-3(k_1+k_2 + 2r_2)l^2,_2^(2)&=&-2(8k_1 + 17k_2 + 9k_3-r_2 + 2s_2)l^2,_3^(2)&=&-(8k_1 + 40k_2 + 57k_3 + 25k_4 - 4s_2 + 2t_2)l^2,_4^(2)&=&6t_2l^2,_5^(2)&=&-2(4[k_1 + 2k_2+k_3]+k_5+k_6 + 2u_2)l^2,_6^(2)&=&-(4k_1 + 16k_2 + 20k_3 + 8k_4 + 8k_5 + 17k_6 + 9k_7 - 2u_2 + 2v_2)l^2,_7^(2)&=&4v_2l^2,_8^(2)&=&-(k_1 + 3k_2 + 3k_3+k_4 + 4[k_5 + 2k_6+k_7]+k_8+k_9 + 2w_2)l^2,_9^(2)&=&2w_2l^2 , ( writing @xmath58 , etc ) , and we can check using eqs . ( [ eq1 ] ) , ( [ eq1a ] ) , ( [ betaone ] ) , ( [ eq2 ] ) , ( [ ktwo ] ) , that eq . ( [ constwo ] ) is satisfied , provided we take r^(2,2)&=&(r_1+s_1)l^2,s^(2,2)&=&12(r_1 + 5s_1 + 3t_1)l^2,t^(2,2)&=&0,u^(2,2)&=&12(r_1 + 2s_1+t_1+u_1+v_1)l^2,v^(2,2)&=&0,w^(2,2)&=&0 . of course due to the arbitrariness of the non - linear renormalisations of @xmath40 there is no obvious way of verifying these double pole relations by direct calculation . examples of the classes of two - loop diagrams in the eliminated case are depicted in fig . [ fig5 ] , and the corresponding divergent contributions are listed in table [ tabe ] . we find y_1^(2)&=&_1,y_2^(2)&=&,y_3^(2)&=&\ { i_1+_2+_3 } , [ ytwo ] as usual , requiring @xmath56-independence of @xmath59 in eq . ( [ eq3 ] ) leads to _ _ i^(2)=2l_i^(2,1 ) and the consistency conditions for two - loop double poles 2(16 ^ 2)l_1^(2,2)&=&15,2(16 ^ 2)l_2^(2,2)&=&(2l_1^(1,1)+6l_2^(1,1))y+(_y^(1)+y_^(1))(2_1 + 6_2),2(16 ^ 2)l_3^(2,2)&=&(l_2^(1,1)+l_3^(1,1))y+(_y^(1 ) + y_^(1))(_2+_3 ) . [ consista ] this leads ( via eqs . ( [ lamdef ] ) , ( [ eq3 ] ) , ( [ eq3a ] ) , ( [ ytwo ] ) ) to @xmath57-functions ^(2)__1&=&-75_1l^2,^(2)__2&=&-2(8_1 + 9_2)l^2,^(2)__3&=&-(_1 + 4_2+_3)l^2 , [ elimbettwo ] and we can check using eqs . ( [ betaone ] ) , ( [ lamdef ] ) , ( [ eq3 ] ) , ( [ eq3a ] ) , ( [ eq4 ] ) , ( [ ytwo ] ) , that eq . ( [ consista ] ) is satisfied . as at one loop , eq . ( [ consistb ] ) is crucial for consistency between the uneliminated and eliminated formalisms , and leads to ( using eqs . ( [ kone ] ) , ( [ lamdef ] ) , ( [ ktwoa ] ) ) ^(2)_1+^(2)_2+^(2)_3+^(2)_4 - 12z^(2)(k_1 + 2k_2+k_3)&-z^(1)(3_1^(1)+2_2^(1)+_3^(1 ) ) + 12(z^(1))^2(2k_1 + 3k_2+k_3)&=&16^(2)_1b,^(2)_5+^(2)_6+^(2)_7-z^(2)(k_5+k_6 ) -z^(1)(2_5^(1)+_6^(1))&+12(z^(1))^2(3k_5 + 2k_6 ) & = & 12^(2)_2b,_8^(2)+_9^(2)-z^(2)k_8-z^(1)_8^(1 ) + ( z^(1))^2k_8&=&_3b^(2 ) . [ consist ] it is easy to check with the aid of eqs . ( [ zone ] ) , ( [ zonea ] ) , ( [ ztwo ] ) , ( [ ztwoa ] ) , ( [ ytwo ] ) , that this is satisfied . as at one loop , if we solve eq . ( [ eq9 ] ) we find consistency conditions , in this case ( 75 + 3)_1&=&016_1+(18 + 3)_2&=&0,_1 + 4_2+(1 + 3)_3&=&0 . once again we see that these conditions are equivalent to the equations we would have derived using eqs . ( [ elimbettwo ] ) if we had sought a similar rg - invariant solution in the eliminated form of the theory . moreover , although as emphasised previously these are the only constraints on @xmath52 , @xmath60 , @xmath5 and @xmath61 , we see using eq . ( [ betaytwo ] ) that if we impose either eq . ( [ eq7 ] ) or eq . ( [ eq8 ] ) then eq . ( [ eq9 ] ) is once again satisfied at two loops with @xmath62 . it it intriguing that the values in eqs . ( [ eq7 ] ) , ( [ eq8 ] ) are singled out at both one and two loops . finally a few words about the differences between our calculation and that of ref . the authors of ref . @xcite identify the coefficient of @xmath39 with the yukawa coupling ( which they denote as @xmath63 ) , since that is the result of casting the deformed classical superspace action into its component form . they also introduce @xmath64 and @xmath65 terms ( we have added the prime to distinguish from our own @xmath66 , @xmath67 which have a different meaning ) . therefore , we should be able to read off their results for individual diagrams from tables [ taba]-[tabd ] by writing k_12g(c ) , & & k_58 ^ 2k_2(c ) , k_88 ^ 3k_1(c ) , 2 , & & y2g,2[subst ] ( including appropriate adjustments for our differing conventions ) , setting the remaining @xmath68 to zero , and remembering the factors of @xmath41 in eq . ( [ divdef ] ) . indeed , our results then agree precisely with those from their eq . however , the difference between our results and theirs appears in the two - loop @xmath57-functions . both we and they eventually derive results in which @xmath42 and @xmath46 are effectively identified . taking account of the differences in our definitions , we might expect that our eliminated results would be equivalent to theirs under _ 1 g , [ comp ] where their @xmath69 is a dimensionless coupling associated with @xmath70 . however , it is clear that the @xmath57-functions for our @xmath71 and their @xmath69 are in agreement at one loop but not at two loops . of course it is well - known that @xmath57-functions are scheme - dependent ( i.e. dependent on the renormalisation used ) beyond one loop in general . the change from one scheme to another may be effected by a redefinition of the couplings of the theory . nevertheless , we do not believe that the difference betwen our two - loop @xmath57-function and that of ref . @xcite is a consequence of using different renormalisation schemes ; both we and they are using dimensional regularisation and indeed as we mentioned , our results for individual diagrams agree precisely with theirs , confirming that they correspond to the same renormalisation scheme . in fact , the difference resides in the precise way of identifying @xmath42 and @xmath46 . in our case this is through eliminating @xmath42 and @xmath40 via their equations of motion eq . ( [ felim ] ) . one might worry that this equation is only valid at the classical level ; but we have shown in detail that we get the same results by eliminating @xmath42 and @xmath40 at the classical level ( hence using the classical version of eq . ( [ felim ] ) ) and then renormalising the eliminated theory ; or renormalising the uneliminated theory and then eliminating @xmath42 and @xmath40 in the renormalised theory ( hence using the bare version of eq . ( [ felim ] ) ) . this equivalence is expressed by eq . ( [ consistb ] ) . there seems little doubt therefore that our procedure is consistent . moreover there is ample evidence in the literature ( at least in the undeformed case ) that the same results ( for renormalisation constants , @xmath57-functions etc ) hold in the eliminated theory obtained by applying the classical equations of motion , as for the uneliminated theory ( where calculations are usually performed in superfields of course ) . the renormalisation eq . ( [ fren ] ) could be regarded as leading to a quantum modification of the equations of motion for @xmath42 , but we have seen that it has no effect upon the eliminated theory . on the other hand , the authors of ref . @xcite identify @xmath46 and @xmath42 through a different , and inequivalent , process , which involves reassessing the identification diagrammatically at each loop level . it seems possible that both approaches are internally consistent , but that the eliminated theories thereby obtained are simply different at the quantum level . both approaches lead to consistent two - loop double poles , at least as far as has been computed ; it is only the simple poles ( and hence the @xmath57-functions ) which differ . let us explain in detail how this happens ( and from now on for ease of comparison we shall describe the procedure of ref . @xcite using our own notation ) . since these authors identify @xmath42 and @xmath46 immediately , they do not introduce separate couplings for ( for instance ) @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 in order to cancel all the different divergent terms ; instead they identify all these terms with @xmath75 ( up to factors ) and omit @xmath76 . the subtlety is that they identify @xmath77 with @xmath78 ( and presumably @xmath74 with @xmath79 ) . this means that they effectively make the replacement _ 1 & & _ 1+_2 + 12_3 + 16_4,_i&&0 , i=2,3,4,k_i&&0 , i=2,3,4 . [ substa ] now in the `` eliminated '' case , both we and they agree that the double poles in @xmath80 are as given by eq . ( [ consista ] ) ( equivalent to their eq . ( 6.5 ) ) . on the other hand , since they are starting from the uneliminated calculation , they are deriving @xmath80 by assuming eq . ( [ consistb ] ) , and therefore their double poles in @xmath80 are given ( as are ours ) according to eq . ( [ consist ] ) ( but in their case , after applying eq . ( [ substa ] ) ) . how can we and they obtain the same double poles despite using different @xmath81 in eq . ( [ consist ] ) ? it happens as follows : effectively , through eq . ( [ substa ] ) they have reduced @xmath82 in eq . ( [ consist ] ) by @xmath83 ( @xmath84 is zero in this comparison since we are setting @xmath85 ) ; and meanwhile the @xmath86 from @xmath87 in eq . ( [ zonea ] ) ( @xmath88 , @xmath89 being zero for @xmath85 ) is effectively transferred to @xmath90 which , crucially , has a different factor in eq . ( [ consist ] ) from @xmath87 . it turns out that these two alterations have no effect on the double pole in @xmath80 , but change the simple pole and hence the two - loop @xmath57-function for @xmath71 ( or equivalently @xmath69 ) . however it should be said that their different means of identifying @xmath42 and @xmath46 at higher loops means that the identification of @xmath71 and @xmath69 is perhaps problematic at higher loops ; and there is therefore no clear translation between our results and theirs beyond one loop . we have performed a complete analysis up to two loops of the renormalisation of the non - anticommutative wess - zumino model . we have shown that in the uneliminated case it is necessary to include all the possible terms which can be generated by renormalisation with their own couplings , and that this leads to results equivalent to those obtained in the eliminated theory . in particular , if one seeks renormalisation - group invariant trajectories for the couplings in the uneliminated theory , one obtains essentially the same solutions as in the eliminated theory ; although there are two interesting special solutions for which the uneliminated action adopts a simple form and which require no non - linear renormalisation of the auxiliary fields , at least up to two loops . it would be interesting to see if this behaviour persists to all orders ; and also to perform a similar analysis for a gauged model . in the wider context , some of the earliest investigations of supersymmetry were motivated by the hope that theories might be found which were non - renormalisable by naive power counting and yet nevertheless renormalisable in requiring only a finite number of local counter - terms to create a uv - finite effective action . thanks to the pseudo - symmetries eqs . ( [ psea ] ) , ( [ pseb ] ) the theory studied here ( and indeed its generalisation to a gauge theory ) provides an explicit realisation of this phenomenon . it is tempting ( but presumably fanciful ) to speculate on a connection with the recent suggestions@xcite that @xmath91 supergravity ( similarly naively non - renormalisable ) might in fact be finite . in any event we believe these theories deserve further investigation . * acknowledgements * + rp was supported by stfc through a graduate studentship . drtj was visiting the aspen center for physics and cern while part of this work was carried out , and gratefully acknowledges financial support from cern .

we discuss the non - anticommutative ( @xmath0 ) supersymmetric wess - zumino model in four dimensions . firstly we introduce differential operators which implement the non - anticommutative supersymmetry algebra acting on the component fields and action . then we perform the renormalisation of the model up to two - loop order , including the complete set of terms necessary for renormalisability . we show that ( at least up to this order ) the results obtained when we eliminate the auxiliary field after renormalisation are equivalent to those obtained when we eliminate the auxiliary fields before quantisation . lth799 + the non - anticommutative supersymmetric wess - zumino model + * i. jack , d.r.t . jones and r. purdy * + dept . of mathematical sciences , university of liverpool , liverpool l69 3bx , uk +

hep-ex0610017

qcd processes provide signals to test theoretical calculations and models and contribute major backgrounds to many measurements . thus , their detailed understanding and modeling is of crucial importance . production of isolated photons at large @xmath0 provides one of the cleanest and most accurate tests of perturbative qcd ( pqcd ) . such photons originate primarily from hard collisions of partons ( quark - gluon or quark - antiquark ) and are thus sensitive to the parton distribution functions ( pdfs ) . consequently , they can help constrain pdfs ( especially the large-@xmath1 gluon distribution ) independently of the high-@xmath0 jet production . such constraints can reduce ambiguities in interpreting results on high-@xmath0jet production in terms of new physics . isolated photon samples also provide indispensable calibration of the recoiling jets . d0 presented the first measurement of the inclusive isolated photon cross section in run 2 of the tevatron @xcite . the photon spectrum , obtained using 326 pb@xmath2 , spans @xmath0= 23300 gev/@xmath3 and @xmath4 , significantly extending the reach observed in run 1 . the measurement agrees well with next - to - leading order ( nlo ) pqcd calculation @xcite over six orders of magnitude , fig . [ fig : d0-photons](left ) . the data / theory ratio , presented in the right panel , shows that the theoretical scale dependence and pdf uncertainties are comparable to the experimental error bars . further improvements in theoretical predictions are desired to reduce the level of sensitivity to the choice of pqcd scales in order to fully exploit the potential of this measurement for constraining pdfs with the help of much larger data samples already available . = 2.5 in = 2.5 in measurements of the inclusive jet cross section provide tests of pqcd and sensitivity to new physics by probing distances down to @xmath5 m. results at large rapidities are particularly important for constraining pdfs in a kinematic region where no effects from new physics are expected . cdf obtained the first measurement in run 2 of inclusive jet cross section in five rapidity regions using the longitudinally - invariant @xmath6 algorithm and @xmath7 fb@xmath2 of data @xcite . figure [ fig : cdf - kt](left ) shows the results for the size parameter @xmath8 for jets with @xmath0@xmath9 gev/@xmath3 and @xmath10 . the right panel shows the data ratio to nlo theory @xcite and displays the experimental and theoretical uncertainties . the former are dominated by the jet energy calibration and the latter by the qcd scale and pdf variations . the theoretical calculations include corrections for non - perturbative effects related to the underlying event and hadronization process . these corrections are essential to obtain good agreement between data and theory . similar level of agreement has been found for central jets ( @xmath11 ) using values of @xmath12 and 1.0 and the corresponding corrections . these results demonstrate veracity of the @xmath6 algorithm in the hadron - collider environment within the range of the measurement . for the most forward rapidity bin ( @xmath13 ) the experimental uncertainty is smaller than the one due to pdfs , hence this measurement is expected to further constrain large-@xmath1 pdfs in future global fits . similar conclusions have been reached by cdf and d0 for the inclusive jet cross section measurements using the midpoint cone algorithm ( not shown ) . here corrections for soft effects are smaller than for @xmath6 algorithm but non - negligible at the current level of precision . = 2.in correlations in the azimuthal angle @xmath14 between the two leading jets in an event provide a clean and simple probe of radiation effects . in the absence of radiation @xmath14= @xmath15 . soft radiation causes small deviations from @xmath15 while @xmath14 significantly lower than @xmath15 indicates the presence of hard radiation , such as additional jets with high @xmath0 . the proper description of multi - parton radiation is crucial for a wide range of precision measurements as well as for searches for new physical phenomena at tevatron and lhc . d0 results @xcite for @xmath14 correlations between central jets ( @xmath16 ) are presented in fig . [ fig : d0-deltaphi ] in four ranges of leading - jet @xmath0 . since the data are sensitive to a range of jet multiplicities , they provide a test of recent monte carlo approaches that combine exact lo pqcd matrix elements for multi - parton production with parton - shower models and of the associated `` matching '' prescriptions imposed to avoid double - counting of equivalent parton configurations . two such generators , alpgen @xcite ( not shown ) and sherpa @xcite , are in good agreement with data , thus enhancing confidence in their applications to other processes . the data are also well described by nlo pqcd for three - jet production @xcite , and by herwig @xcite with default parameters . distributions from pythia @xcite are sensitive to the value of a parameter which controls the maximum allowed virtuality in the initial - state shower . the shaded bands in fig . [ fig : d0-deltaphi](right ) show the range of predictions when this parameter is varied by a factor of four . the optimal value of 2.5 has been incorporated in the recent tunes dw and dwt of pythia parameters @xcite . = 2.in = 2.in production of w and z bosons in association with jets constitutes an important background to top - quark production and in the searches for new physics , including production of the higgs boson and supersymmetric particles . thus an accurate modeling of this process is essential . the presence of w / z ensures high @xmath17 and facilitates tests of pqcd and monte carlo tools for configurations with multiple soft jets . d0 compared predictions from pythia and sherpa to various distributions in z/@xmath18+jets events using 950 pb@xmath2of data @xcite . data selection required two electrons with @xmath0@xmath19 gev/@xmath3 and @xmath20 within a di - electron mass window of 70100 gev , and jets with @xmath0@xmath21 gev/@xmath3 . pythia was found to underestimate the production rate of higher jet multiplicities , fig . [ fig : d0-zjets](left ) . sherpa provides a good description of jet multiplicity ( right panel ) , and all kinematic distributions studied , including @xmath0 distributions of the z and of 1@xmath22 , 2@xmath23 and 3@xmath24 leading jets , as well as @xmath14 and @xmath25 angular distributions between the jets . significant differences with data have been observed for pythia distributions . = 2.5 in = 2.5 in using 320 pb@xmath2 of data cdf performed @xcite shape comparisons between w+jets production ( up to four jets ) with predictions from alpgen interfaced to pythia for showering and hadronization . jets were corrected to hadron level and kinematic cuts imposed to reduce model dependence on acceptance and efficiency . data selection required a good - quality electron candidate with @xmath0@xmath26 gev/@xmath3 , missing transverse energy @xmath27 gev , and @xmath28 cone jets with @xmath0@xmath29 gev/@xmath3 and @xmath30 . reasonable agreement is observed for the jet @xmath0 distributions ( fig . [ fig : cdf - wjets](left ) ) , @xmath31 between jets in w+2jets sample ( fig . [ fig : cdf - wjets](right ) ) , and dijet invariant mass ( not shown ) . = 2.5 in = 2.5 in ten years after its discovery top quark is intensely studied at the tevatron . its surprisingly large mass makes it the only fermion having the yukawa coupling near unity implying its large contribution to the radiative corrections to the higgs mass . this leads to speculation that electroweak symmetry breaking mechanism may be probed through studies of its production and properties . consequently , every aspect of top - quark physics experimentally accessible is vigorously scrutinized at the tevatron . the standard model ( sm ) predicts that at the tevatron top quarks are primarily produced in pairs through the strong force by @xmath32 annihilation 85% of the time and by gg fusion 15% of the time . the predicted cross section is @xmath33 pb for @xmath34 gev @xcite . in sm , top quarks decay @xmath35100% to wb , and hence t@xmath36 events are classified according to the decay modes of the w s . in dilepton events both w s decay into e or @xmath37 . this channel has a low branching fraction ( @xmath38% ) but is very clean . a recent extension of the dilepton analysis selects candidate events requiring an isolated track instead of one of the leptons . this improves selection efficiency and enlarges the event sample at the cost of additional backgrounds . the channel when one w decays to e or @xmath37 and the other to quarks is called lepton+jets . it has a higher branching fraction ( @xmath39% ) but also receives higher backgrounds . since it provides a large but still fairly pure sample of top quarks , it facilitates some of the best measurements in top physics . decays of both w s to quarks result in the all - hadronic channel , which has the largest branching fraction ( @xmath40% ) but also the highest background from qcd multi - jet production . the b - tagging information is essential for background suppression in this channel . it also helps to reduce backgrounds in the lepton+jets channel . analyses based on decay modes involving @xmath41 leptons are especially difficult and are only now becoming developed . due to the presence of w s and jets in top decays , good understanding and simulation of qcd w / z+jets and multijet production is indispensable in top - quark measurements . one of the best measurements of t@xmath36 cross section has been obtained by cdf using the lepton+jets channel and 695 pb@xmath2 of data @xcite . while the traditional analyses in this channel have used selections based on topological variables to enhance t@xmath36 signal , this measurement employs b - tag information to reduce backgrounds . events are required to have one isolated electron or @xmath37 with @xmath0@xmath26 gev/@xmath3 and @xmath26 gev , at least three jets with @xmath0@xmath21 gev/@xmath3 within @xmath30 and the total scalar sum of transverse energies of all objects in the event @xmath42 gev ( including jets with @xmath0@xmath43 gev/@xmath3 and @xmath44 ) . the last requirement is dropped for the double - tagged sample . as illustrated in fig . [ fig : cdf - ttxs - lj](left ) , the events in the `` w+3 jet '' and `` w+@xmath454jet '' bins are relatively background free and dominated by t@xmath36 contribution when one b - tag is required . the resulting cross section is @xmath46 pb . the uncertainty is dominated by systematics , and its largest component comes from b - tagging . when two b - tags are required , the sample statistics is reduced but t@xmath36purity improves even further . it is noteworthy that the cross section measurement using the double - tagged sample alone has achieved a @xmath47 significance : @xmath48 pb . = 2.3 in = 2.3 in cdf and d0 are developing a variety of techniques to examine t@xmath36 decays into the all - hadronic final state . a novel analysis from d0 @xcite , based on 360 pb@xmath2 , selects six - jet events with at least 2 jets having @xmath0@xmath49 gev/@xmath3 and tagged as b - jets with a secondary - vertex tagging algorithm . the remaining jets are required not to be b - tagged , two of them to have @xmath0@xmath50 gev/@xmath3 and the rest @xmath0@xmath51 gev/@xmath3 . all jets are required to be within @xmath52 . as no events have been rejected based on the presence of high-@xmath0 leptons or , this sample includes contributions from the all - hadronic channel , the @xmath41 channel with hadronic @xmath41 decays , and the other t@xmath36 decay channels when additional jets are produced . the double b - tag requirement is essential for suppressing the qcd backgrounds . the inclusive dijet mass distribution for non b - tagged jets ( jj ) , and the three - jet mass distribution for one b - tagged and two non - tagged jets ( bjj ) exhibit visible excess of events above a smooth background . this enhancement is interpreted as due to w and top production ( fig . [ fig : d0-ttxs - alljets ] ) . a method has been developed to derive the non - t@xmath36 background directly from the data . after background subtraction the jj and bjj mass distributions agree well with expectations for w and top decays into jets based on pythia and simulation of detector effects . the resulting t@xmath36 cross section of @xmath53 pb ( for @xmath54 gev ) is consistent with sm predictions . its accuracy is expected to be significantly improved when larger data samples are analyzed and the technique is furter developed . the direct observation of resonant w and top mass peaks in the hadronic mode is reassuring in anticipation of the lhc data . = 2.2 in = 2.2 in figure [ fig : ttxs - summary ] shows a summary of recent t@xmath36cross section measurements by d0 and cdf . the accuracy of the combined result is approaching 10% . with further increase of the data sets , it is becoming possible to test compatibility of the cross sections obtained from different channels . = 2.6 in = 1.8 in the top quark mass is a fundamental parameter of the sm and should be measured to the highest possible accuracy . with large data samples now available the measurements are no longer statistically limited . it is therefore important to understand systematic uncertainties in detail and to minimize their impact on the determination of @xmath55 . since the dominant source of systematic uncertainty has been the jet energy scale ( jes ) , recent analyses employ the _ in situ _ jet calibration by imposing the well known mass of the w in the reconstruction of the w@xmath56jj decays in the t@xmath36samples . this allows to further constrain the overall jes in a simultaneous fit to @xmath55 and @xmath57 . cdf and d0 applied several sophisticated techniques in measurements of @xmath55 . the major methods are `` template '' and `` matrix element '' approaches . cdf performed the template analysis using lepton+jets channel and 680 pb@xmath2 @xcite . the event sample has been selected using requirements similar to those described above for their cross section measurement ( with jet @xmath0 cuts depending on the b - tagging category of each event ) . a kinematic fit is used to decide the best value of @xmath55 for each event after considering all parton - to - jet assignments and constraining the fitted w mass to the book value . the resulting @xmath55 distribution is then compared to monte carlo @xmath55 templates simulated for various top masses as illustrated in fig . [ fig : cdf - top - mass - template](left ) . the final reconstructed top mass is determined from a simultaneous fit of the templates to the observed distribution , as function of @xmath55 and a shift in the jet energy scale , @xmath58 , fig . [ fig : cdf - top - mass - template](right ) . the fit yields a top - quark mass of @xmath59 gev . the _ in situ _ calibration is consistent with the standard calibration but reduces the jes - related uncertainty by @xmath60% . = 2.2 in = 2.8 in d0 developed the matrix element ( me ) method in run 1 and applied it to 370 pb@xmath2 of run 2 data @xcite . in this method the probabilities for an event to be t@xmath36 signal or the dominant w+jets background are calculated using the corresponding lo matrix elements . the probabilities of all events are combined into a final likelihood , which is then maximized as a function of @xmath55 and an overall jes factor ( in the run 2 implementation ) . the likelihood distributions for both parameters are shown in fig . [ fig : d0-top - mass - me ] . the result using the b - tagging information is @xmath61 gev . = 2.5 in = 2.5 in figure [ fig : top - mass - summary](left ) summarizes the best independent top - quark mass measurements from cdf and d0 @xcite . the combination of published run 1 measurements with the recent preliminary run 2 results using up to 1 fb@xmath2 of data yields a preliminary world average mass of the top quark @xmath62 gev . the top - quark mass is now known with a precision of 1.2% . the precise measurements of the top and w masses can be used to constrain the value of @xmath63 , as illustrated in the right panel . they suggest a low value of the mass of the higgs boson setting the stage for an exciting race between tevatron and lhc experiments towards its discovery . = 1.6 in = 2.3 in d0 and cdf have searched for a narrow - width heavy resonance x decaying into top - quark pairs @xcite . such resonant t@xmath36 production is expected eg . in various `` topcolor '' models . the t@xmath36 invariant mass spectrum from d0 is shown in fig . [ fig : d0-tt - resonance](left ) . this analysis is based on lepton+jets channel using a lifetime tag to identify b - quarks in 370 pb@xmath2of data . no evidence for a t@xmath36 resonance x was found by either collaboration and upper limits on @xmath64 have been derived as a function of @xmath65 ( fig . [ fig : d0-tt - resonance](right ) for d0 results ) . for a topcolor z model @xcite , the existence of a leptophobic z boson with mass @xmath66 ( 725 ) gev has been excluded by d0 ( cdf ) at 95% cl , for @xmath67 . = 2.5 in = 2.5 in using 320 pb@xmath2 , cdf searched @xcite for the w@xmath68w@xmath69b@xmath70b@xmath70 signature of the associated t@xmath36h production . this process is expected to help the discovery of a light higgs and provide a determination of the t - h coupling at the lhc . the cdf analysis required a @xmath0@xmath26 gev/@xmath3 e or @xmath37 candidate , five or more jets with @xmath71 gev and @xmath72 , three or more b - tagged jets , and @xmath73 gev . one candidate event was found ( fig . [ fig : cdf - tth](left ) ) , consistent with the total expected background of @xmath74 events . the major contributions to background were from mistagging a light - quark jet as a b - jet , qcd multijet events where a jet fakes a lepton , and irreducible backgrounds from sm sources ( including t@xmath36b@xmath70 , t@xmath36c@xmath75 etc . ) . cdf obtained the first experimental limit on @xmath76 of 660 fb , weakly depending on @xmath63 ( fig . [ fig : cdf - tth](right ) ) . the expected t@xmath36h signal is @xmath77 events for @xmath78 gev . = 2.in = 2.7 in tevatron measurements advance the understanding of `` soft '' and `` hard '' aspects of qcd including higher - order processes and multi - jet radiation ; facilitate development and tuning of perturbative and monte carlo tools ; improve understanding of pdfs , jet algorithms and calibrations . building upon this progress and using large data samples that have become available in run 2 , top - quark studies have entered a precision era , providing determination of t@xmath36 cross section approaching 10% precision and of the top mass nearing 1% . advanced analysis methods have been developed and tried in the hadron - collider environment . the experience from the tevatron is an extremely valuable resource and it can greatly benefit the `` rediscovery '' of the standard model and searches for new physics at the lhc .

selected recent qcd and top - quark results from the tevatron are reviewed , aiming to illustrate progression from basic studies of qcd processes to verification of perturbative calculations and monte carlo simulation tools , and to their applications in more novel and complex cases , like top - quark studies and searches for new physics .

0904.4220

in his classical paper on quantisation of magnetic poles dirac ( 1931 ) remarked that `` non - euclidean geometry and non - commutative algebra , which were at one time considered to be purely fictions of the mind and pastimes for logical thinkers , have now been found to be very necessary for the description of general facts of the physical world . it seems likely that this process of increasing abstraction will continue in the future and that advance in physics is to be associated with a continual modification and generalisation of the axioms at the base of the mathematics rather than with a logical development of any one mathematical scheme on a fixed foundation . '' in accordance with this principle , the present paper further extends the work of dirac by exploring the ` dequantisation ' of magnetic poles . diverse and numerous versions of the magnetic pole construction and the associated charge quantisation condition of dirac ( 1931 , 1948 ) have appeared in the literature , but the basic model can be most concisely and accurately formulated in terms of the hopf fibration ( wu & yang 1975 ; trautman 1977 ; yang 1977 ) . from a mathematical viewpoint , the rationale is as follows . the monopole potential is modelled as a connection @xmath0 on a nontrivial principal @xmath1-bundle @xmath2 over a subset of minkowski space . a charged matter field interacting with the monopole is accordingly modelled as a section of a vector bundle @xmath3 associated with @xmath2 via the representation @xmath4 of @xmath1 on a complex vector space . since @xmath0 then induces the connection @xmath5 on @xmath3 , the integer @xmath6 can be identified with the electric charge of the matter field ( see urbantke 2003 for a detailed account of the description of a magnetic monopole in the language of the hopf fibration ) . however , following the spirit of dirac , if we describe the monopole by a more general mathematical scheme , then the interaction of matter fields and magnetic poles _ with arbitrary real charges _ can also be modelled in a consistent manner . the present paper introduces a new sheaf - theoretic framework permitting an explicit construction of arbitrarily charged magnetic monopoles . this framework is likewise applied to generic @xmath1-bundles and also yields , as a by - product , the notion of a quasispin structure defined on arbitrary space - times . the results suggest that topological quantisation in general can be viewed from a more flexible perspective . although magnetic monopoles have not been observed experimentally , one important physical consequence of the present model is that their detection would not necessarily imply the quantisation of electric charge . likewise , an observed violation of charge quantisation would not necessarily imply the nonexistence of magnetic monopoles . furthermore , grand unified theories require the existence of magnetic monopoles , and , according to conventional field theory described in terms of manifolds this necessarily implies charge quantisation , hence , the detection of nonintegral electric charge would indicate that the present scheme , based on sheaves rather than manifolds , may be physically more realistic . also , a sheaf construction permits the global description of fermion fields on lorentzian manifolds possessing no conventional spin structure , as an alternative to the cumbersome machinery of khler fermions . the paper is organised as follows . in [ sec:2 ] we present a very brief sketch of sheaf theory for the benefit of readers less acquainted with the subject . this is intended to provide the bare minimum of information necessary for following the ensuing discussion ; for further details on sheaf theory , see , e.g. , bredon ( 1997 ) , kultze ( 1970 ) , or wells ( 2008 ) . in [ sec:3 ] we develop the basic mathematical machinery used in later sections . the key idea here is the construction of a principal @xmath7-sheaf bundle which generalises the conventional notion of a principal bundle . in [ sec:4 ] we prove that equivalence classes of principal @xmath8-bundles can , under certain hypotheses , be mapped injectively into equivalence classes of @xmath7-sheaf bundles . this implies that the dirac sheaf bundle constructed in [ sec:5 ] does indeed constitute a generalisation of the conventional dirac monopole . the spherically symmetrical connection and curvature of the dirac sheaf bundle are constructed in [ sec:6 ] , demonstrating that the magnetic charge of this model can assume arbitrary real values . the interaction of the generalised monopole with a charged matter field is considered in [ sec:7 ] . dequantisation of more general @xmath1 bundles is considered in [ sec:8 ] , with particular attention to gravitational and electromagnetic instantons . in [ sec:9 ] the basic machinery developed earlier is applied to spin structures and dirac operators . in [ sec:10 ] the paper concludes with a brief discussion of possible implications in diverse areas of physics . the concept of a sheaf over a manifold @xmath9 provides a way of interpolating local data and global data on x. we begin with the definition of a presheaf . a _ presheaf _ @xmath10 on @xmath9 is a functor assigning , to each open @xmath11 , a group @xmath12 , abelian or otherwise , such that for each @xmath13 the restriction map @xmath14 , @xmath15 , defines a homomorphism and such that @xmath16 for @xmath17 . an element @xmath18 is referred to as a _ section _ of @xmath12 over @xmath19 . the restriction of @xmath20 on @xmath13 is thus given by @xmath21 . the sections @xmath18 and @xmath22 are said to be _ equivalent _ at @xmath23 if there is a neighbourhood @xmath24 of @xmath25 such that @xmath26 . the equivalence class containing @xmath18 is called the _ germ _ of @xmath27 at @xmath25 , and the set of all such germs for any fixed @xmath25 is denoted by @xmath28 . the disjoint union @xmath29 of all the sets @xmath28 provides local information about the structure of @xmath10 . however , information concerning global structure has been lost , since we have discarded relations between the @xmath28 for varying @xmath25 . to retrieve some global structure , we introduce a topology in the following manner . for a fixed @xmath18 the set of all germs @xmath30 for @xmath31 is taken to be an open set in @xmath29 , and the topology of @xmath32 is defined as that generated by these open sets . the projection @xmath33 mapping @xmath28 into @xmath25 has the property that for any point @xmath34 with @xmath35 there is a neighbourhood @xmath36 for @xmath18 and @xmath37 such that the restriction @xmath38 is a homeomorphism onto a neighbourhood of @xmath39 . these ideas can be summarised as follows : a _ sheaf _ of groups on @xmath9 is a pair @xmath40 such that * @xmath29 is a topological space ( in general , not hausdorff ) ; * @xmath41 is a local homeomorphism of @xmath29 onto @xmath9 ; * each @xmath42 , @xmath43 , is a group called the _ stalk _ of @xmath29 at @xmath25 ; and * the group operations are continuous with respect to the relative topology on the subset @xmath44 of @xmath45 . [ def:1 ] for @xmath11 , a continuous map @xmath46 such that @xmath47 is called a _ section _ of @xmath32 over @xmath19 . the totality of such @xmath27 will be denoted @xmath48 . note that every element of the group @xmath12 specified by the presheaf functor naturally determines an element of @xmath48 , but the converse is only true locally . some of the key properties of a sheaf are as follows . if @xmath49 is an open covering of an open set @xmath50 , and if @xmath51 are such that @xmath52 . furthermore , if @xmath53 are such that latexmath:[$\sigma_\alpha|_{u_\alpha\cap u_\beta } = \sigma_\beta there exists an element @xmath18 with @xmath55 for all @xmath56 . the first property implies that if the restrictions of a pair of sections always agree , then the two sections are identical thus a section over @xmath19 is determined by the totality of its restrictions to subsets of @xmath19 . the second property , somewhat complementary to the first , implies that if pairs of sections always agree on their overlapping regions then global section can be constructed from the local data thus a section over @xmath19 may be assembled from consistent local sections on subsets of @xmath19 . a sheaf @xmath29 contains localised information concerning the topological space @xmath9 . global information about @xmath9 can then be extracted from @xmath29 by consideration of exact sequences , quotients , and so on . given two sheaves @xmath29 and @xmath57 over @xmath9 , a sheaf homomorphism @xmath58 is a continuous map such that the stalk map @xmath59 is a homomorphism of @xmath60 into @xmath61 for each @xmath43 . a sequence of sheaf homomorphisms of the form @xmath62 such that the corresponding sequence of stalk maps is exact for all @xmath43 is called a short exact sequence of sheaves . evidently , exactness is a local property . given a short exact sequence of sheaves , the induced sequence @xmath63 is exact at @xmath64 and @xmath65 , but in general not at @xmath66 . that is to say , the local exactness of a sequence does not imply exactness with respect to the global sections over @xmath9 . the measure of inexactness at @xmath66 can then be characterised by cohomology . recall that in the cohomology theories of @xmath9 one computes @xmath67 where @xmath8 is an abelian group . in sheaf cohomology the coefficients are not elements of a fixed group @xmath8 but are , rather , local sections of some sheaf @xmath29 over @xmath9 . more precisely , let @xmath68 be an open covering of @xmath9 . for any @xmath69 such that @xmath70 , we define the set of @xmath71-cochains by @xmath72 . for any @xmath73 define the coboundary operator @xmath74 by @xmath75 where @xmath76 and @xmath77 is the sheaf restriction map . these coboundary operators define a complex @xmath78 and the cohomology groups of this complex are then defined in the usual manner : @xmath79 passing to a direct limit over progressively finer coverings , we obtain the sheaf cohomology groups @xmath80 . the reader will notice that the definitions in this section run parallel , _ mutatis mutandis _ , to the conventional definitions in the theory of fibre bundles . the @xmath7-sheaf plays the role of a trivial and the @xmath7-sheaf bundle that of a generally nontrivial fibre bundle . let @xmath9 and @xmath81 be topological spaces and @xmath82 a sheaf of groups over @xmath9 . @xmath7-sheaf _ over @xmath9 is a triple @xmath83 such that * @xmath41 is a local homeomorphism of @xmath81 onto @xmath9 ; * for each @xmath84 , the stalk @xmath85 operates ( by left action ) upon @xmath86 ; and * if @xmath87 is equipped with the relative topology in @xmath88 , then the mapping @xmath89 defined by @xmath90 is continuous . [ def:2 ] for any subset @xmath91 , the obvious restriction maps define a @xmath92-sheaf @xmath93 over @xmath0 . in the sequel , when @xmath0 is clearly understood , we shall , for brevity , use the term @xmath7-sheaf in place of @xmath94-sheaf . we call @xmath29 a _ principal @xmath7-sheaf _ if @xmath95 and @xmath7 operates by left translation . given two @xmath7-sheaves @xmath96 and @xmath97 over @xmath9 , a continuous map @xmath98 will be called a _ @xmath7-sheaf map _ of @xmath29 into @xmath57 provided * @xmath99 ; and * for each @xmath84 , the induced map @xmath100 satisfies @xmath101 for all @xmath102 and @xmath103 . [ def:3 ] again , if @xmath104 , then a @xmath105-sheaf map will , for brevity , be called a @xmath7-sheaf map when the restriction is clearly understood . a _ @xmath7-sheaf isomorphism _ is a bijective @xmath7-sheaf map . a _ @xmath7-sheaf bundle _ @xmath106 over a topological space @xmath9 is defined by the following data : * an open covering @xmath107 of @xmath9 ; * for each @xmath108 , a @xmath7-sheaf @xmath109 over @xmath110 ; and * for each nonempty intersection @xmath111 , a @xmath7-sheaf isomorphism @xmath112 such that the cocycle condition @xmath113 is satisfied on @xmath114 . [ def:4 ] we call @xmath106 a _ principal @xmath7-sheaf bundle _ if each @xmath109 is a principal @xmath115-sheaf . two @xmath7-sheaf bundles @xmath106 and @xmath116 over @xmath9 , defined in terms of the respective open coverings @xmath117 and @xmath118 , are _ equivalent _ provided that the @xmath7-sheaf bundles @xmath119 and @xmath120 induced by the respective restriction maps on some common refinement @xmath121 of @xmath117 and @xmath122 are such that there exist @xmath7-sheaf isomorphisms @xmath123 for each @xmath108 satisfying @xmath124 for all @xmath125 . remark : of academic interest is the fact that , given a @xmath115-sheaf bundle @xmath106 , one can , from the presheaf defined by local sections of @xmath106 , define a @xmath7-sheaf @xmath126 which in turn uniquely determines the structure of @xmath106 up to equivalence ( kashiwara & schapira 2006 ) . however , this fact will not be required in the sequel . [ def:5 ] let @xmath9 be a smooth manifold , @xmath8 a lie group , and @xmath127 a closed central subgroup of @xmath8 . for each open subset @xmath19 of @xmath9 , let @xmath128 denote the totality of smooth maps @xmath129 , which forms a group under pointwise multiplication , i.e. @xmath130 . let @xmath131 denote the totality of constant maps @xmath132 , which forms a central subgroup of @xmath128 . assign to each open @xmath133 the quotient group @xmath134 with the obvious restriction maps , this defines a presheaf ; denote by @xmath135 the corresponding sheaf of groups over @xmath9 , regarded as a principal @xmath136-sheaf , and its restriction to a subset @xmath0 of @xmath9 by @xmath137 . a principal @xmath7-sheaf bundle over @xmath9 such that @xmath138 for some open covering @xmath139 of @xmath9 will , for brevity , be called a _ @xmath140-bundle_. _ example 1_. with the notation of definition [ def:4 ] , let @xmath141 be a principal @xmath8-bundle , and @xmath142 an open covering of @xmath9 by trivialising neighbourhoods . on each nonempty intersection @xmath143 the bundle transition function @xmath144 defines an element of @xmath145 and hence a continuous section @xmath146 of the sheaf @xmath147 . the germs of @xmath148 , acting by right multiplication , provide a @xmath7-sheaf map @xmath149 , which is obviously bijective , i.e. is a @xmath115-sheaf isomorphism . moreover , the cocycle condition ( [ eq:3.3 ] ) follows immediately from the corresponding cocycle condition for the bundle transition functions . thus , we obtain a @xmath140-bundle @xmath150 over @xmath9 . the following result shows that under a certain simple hypothesis the conventional principal @xmath8-bundles may be identified with a subset of the @xmath140-bundles over @xmath9 . throughout the sequel , we shall assume that @xmath9 is paracompact , i.e. that every open covering of @xmath9 has a locally finite subcovering . [ prop:1 ] for fixed @xmath127 , the correspondence @xmath151 induces an injective map of equivalence classes of principal @xmath8-bundles into equivalence classes of @xmath7-sheaf bundles over @xmath9 , provided that the ech cohomology group @xmath152 . we first prove three lemmata . [ lem:2.2 ] let @xmath8 be an arbitrary group . a mapping @xmath153 which commutes with all left translations is a right translation . proof . given that @xmath154 for all @xmath155 , let @xmath156 . then @xmath157 for all @xmath158 . @xmath159 recall that @xmath160 denotes the totality of continuous sections of a sheaf @xmath29 over a subset @xmath161 . [ lem:2.3 ] let @xmath19 be an open subset of the topological space @xmath9 , @xmath8 a group , @xmath29 a principal @xmath7-sheaf over @xmath9 and @xmath162 a @xmath7-sheaf isomorphism . then , for each point @xmath163 , there exists a neighbourhood @xmath164 of @xmath25 in @xmath19 and a @xmath165 such that @xmath166 for every section @xmath167 and all @xmath168 . proof . by lemma [ lem:2.2 ] and condition ii ) of definition [ def:3 ] , for each @xmath163 there exists a @xmath169 such that @xmath170 for all @xmath171 . now , fix @xmath172 , and choose any @xmath173 and any section @xmath174 with @xmath175 open in @xmath19 , @xmath176 and @xmath177 . since @xmath178 is continuous and stalk - preserving , @xmath179 ( @xmath180 ) defines a continuous section of @xmath29 , and by the continuity of the group operations @xmath181 @xmath182 is also a continuous section . for any other section @xmath183 , writing @xmath184 we have @xmath185 . hence , @xmath186 has the desired property . @xmath159 [ lem:2.4 ] let @xmath187 and @xmath188 be sheaves , @xmath189 an epimorphic sheaf map and @xmath190 . then , for any @xmath84 , there exists a neighbourhood @xmath164 of @xmath25 and a @xmath191 such that @xmath192 . this is an elementary fact of sheaf theory ( kultze 1970 , hilfsatz 3.4 ) . @xmath159 proof of proposition [ prop:1 ] . clearly , equivalent principal bundles give rise to equivalent sheaf bundles . conversely , let @xmath193 and @xmath194 be principal @xmath8-bundles defined in terms of trivialising open coverings @xmath117 and @xmath122 , respectively . choosing , if necessary , a common refinement , we may suppose that @xmath195 . then , with the foregoing notation , @xmath196 iff there exist @xmath7-sheaf isomorphisms @xmath197 , @xmath108 , such that @xmath198 on @xmath199 ( @xmath125 ) . the @xmath7-sheaves @xmath200 and @xmath201 are identical , both arising from the presheaf functor @xmath202 , @xmath203 open in @xmath204 . let @xmath205 denote the sheaf over @xmath110 defined by the presheaf functor @xmath206 . then , the presheaf epimorphism @xmath207 induces an epimorphic sheaf map @xmath208 , hence , by lemmata [ lem:2.3 ] and [ lem:2.4 ] , for each @xmath209 there exists a neighbourhood @xmath210 and a section @xmath211 such that @xmath212 = [ \sigma_{\alpha}][g_{\alpha}^{x } ] = [ \sigma_{\alpha}g_{\alpha}^{x}]$ ] for all @xmath213 , where the square brackets denote cosets in @xmath214 , regarded as continuous sections in @xmath215 . then , choosing the covering @xmath216 sufficiently fine , we may , by paracompactness , omit the superscript @xmath25 and simply write @xmath212= [ \sigma_{\alpha}g_{\alpha}]$ ] for all @xmath217 , with square brackets denoting cosets in @xmath218 , again regarded as elements of @xmath219 . hence , recalling the definition of the @xmath220 in example 1 , relation ( [ eq:4.1 ] ) implies that @xmath221 = [ \sigma_{\alpha}g_{\beta}^{-1 } g_{\alpha\beta } g_\alpha ] \label{eq:4.2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] on @xmath222 . since @xmath223 is arbitrary , this clearly means that @xmath224 for certain constant functions @xmath225 applying the cocycle condition for principal bundles to both members of ( [ eq:4.3 ] ) , we deduce that the constants @xmath226 also satisfy the cocycle condition , and therefore define an element of @xmath227 . hence , if the covering @xmath228 is chosen sufficiently fine , then , by hypothesis , there exists a 0-cochain @xmath229 such that @xmath230 . defining @xmath231 we find that ( [ eq:4.3 ] ) becomes @xmath232 which is the condition for equivalence of @xmath2 and @xmath233 . @xmath159 as used in the foregoing proof , lemmata [ lem:2.3 ] and [ lem:2.4 ] show that for a sufficiently fine covering @xmath234 the transition sheaf isomorphisms of a @xmath140-bundle are of the form @xmath235 for fixed @xmath236 and arbitrary @xmath237 . likewise , the @xmath7-sheaf isomorphisms @xmath238 in the definition of @xmath7-sheaf bundle equivalence are of the form @xmath239 for fixed @xmath240 and arbitrary @xmath241 . a standard theorem states that equivalence classes of principal @xmath8-bundles over @xmath9 correspond biuniquely to elements of the sheaf cohomology set @xmath242 . in view of ( [ eq:4.6 ] ) , the argument used in proving this theorem ( see , e.g. , lawson & michelsohn 1989 , appendix a ) can also be applied in a straightforward manner to yield the following result . the equivalence classes of @xmath140-bundles over @xmath9 correspond biuniquely to elements of the sheaf cohomology set @xmath243 . for @xmath244 , this correspondence reduces to the standard theorem cited above . [ cor:4.05 ] if @xmath8 is abelian , then proposition [ prop:1 ] follows more directly from standard results as follows . let @xmath245 denote the sheaf arising from the constant presheaf defined by @xmath246 . the short exact sequence @xmath247 induces a sequence of sheaf maps @xmath248 which is easily seen to be exact . this in turn induces a long exact cohomology sequence which includes , in particular , the segment @xmath249 for a paracompact @xmath8-manifold @xmath9 the sheaf cohomology group @xmath250 is known to be isomorphic to the ech cohomology group @xmath251 as well as the singular cohomology group @xmath252 with coefficients in @xmath127 ( spanier 1994 , chapter 6 ) . hence , if @xmath253 , then the exactness of the above sequence implies that @xmath254 is injective . denoting the totality of equivalence classes of principal @xmath8-bundles ( resp . @xmath140-bundles ) by @xmath255 ( resp . @xmath256 ) , we note that the diagram @xmath257 where the upper arrow represents the correspondence @xmath258 and the vertical arrows the biunique correspondence of corollary [ cor:4.05 ] , is commutative . the result follows . relations ( [ eq:4.6 ] ) and ( [ eq:4.7 ] ) also imply : for the special case @xmath259 ( the identity of @xmath8 ) , the @xmath140-bundles can be identified with conventional principal @xmath8-bundles , and @xmath7-sheaf equivalence is merely conventional bundle equivalence . [ cor:4.5 ] thus , for @xmath259 the present theory yields nothing new . however , for @xmath260 and @xmath261 we obtain a nontrivial extension of the conventional theory of principal bundles , as we shall see , in particular , from the example in the next section , wherein @xmath262 . note that the set of data @xmath263 ( see definition [ def:5 ] and ( [ eq:4.6 ] ) ) , subsequently referred to as a _ presentation _ of the @xmath140-bundle under consideration , plays a role analogous to that of a system of local trivialisations in the conventional theory of principal bundles . if @xmath118 is a refinement of @xmath264 , then @xmath265 induces , in the obvious manner , a presentation @xmath266 associated with @xmath118 . recalling the definition of @xmath7-sheaf equivalence ( see ( [ eq:3.4 ] ) ) , relations ( [ eq:4.6 ] ) and ( [ eq:4.7 ] ) imply that two presentations @xmath265 and @xmath266 associated with the same covering @xmath267 define equivalent @xmath140-bundles iff there exist elements @xmath268 such that the respective transition elements @xmath236 and @xmath269 satisfy @xmath270 for all @xmath271 and @xmath272 . if the associated open coverings @xmath117 and @xmath118 are different , then the condition for equivalence is given by ( [ eq:4.8 ] ) with respect to some common refinement @xmath273 of @xmath117 and @xmath118 . another immediate consequence of ( [ eq:4.6 ] ) is the fact that @xmath140-bundles , like conventional @xmath8-bundles , are functorial , i.e. a @xmath140-bundle @xmath274 over @xmath9 and a continuous map @xmath275 naturally induce a @xmath140-bundle @xmath276 over @xmath277 , since the transition sections @xmath236 on @xmath9 pull back to sections on @xmath277 which obviously satisfy the cocycle condition . moreover , one can prove that if @xmath9 and @xmath277 are compact hausdorff spaces and the maps @xmath278 and @xmath279 are homotopic , then @xmath276 and @xmath280 are equivalent ( cf . lawson & michelsohn 1990 , appendix a ) . let @xmath281 and @xmath282 . we represent @xmath283 by the unit sphere in @xmath284 , with spherical polar coordinates @xmath285 , ( @xmath286 , @xmath287 ) , and @xmath1 by @xmath288 . for the open covering @xmath289 of @xmath283 , we have @xmath290 . let @xmath7 be the sheaf of smooth @xmath1-valued functions over @xmath283 . let @xmath10 denote the presheaf over @xmath283 defined for each open @xmath203 by @xmath291 @xmath29 the associated @xmath7-sheaf , and @xmath292 @xmath293 . if @xmath294 is an arbitrary real number , define a @xmath7-sheaf isomorphism @xmath295 by @xmath296 for @xmath297 , where @xmath298 is the section of @xmath299 defined locally by @xmath300 . \label{eq:5.5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here the square brackets indicate the equivalence class modulo constant sections @xmath301 . denote the @xmath140-bundle so defined by @xmath302 . if @xmath303 is an integer , then @xmath304 is just the principal @xmath115-sheaf bundle @xmath305 arising from the conventional @xmath1-bundle @xmath306 of charge @xmath307 ( in the appropriate units ) , in accordance with the construction of example 1 . in general , for an arbitrary abelian group @xmath127 , the ech cohomology groups are given by @xmath308 ( see , e.g. , spanier 1994 ) . in particular , we have @xmath309 . hence , by proposition [ prop:1 ] , the sheaf bundles @xmath304 are mutually inequivalent . that @xmath310 implies @xmath311 for arbitrary real @xmath294 and @xmath312 will be proved in [ sec:6 ] below . from the foregoing construction , the truth of the following proposition should be evident . [ prop:5.1 ] let @xmath313 be the transition functions for some trivialising atlas of a principal @xmath1-bundle @xmath2 over the base space @xmath9 . then , for any real number @xmath294 , the powers @xmath314 define the transition isomorphisms of a @xmath315-bundle @xmath316 over @xmath9 . if the ech cohomology group @xmath317 , then the principal @xmath1-bundles @xmath306 defined by the transition functions @xmath318 , if mutually inequivalent , correspond bi - uniquely with mutually inequivalent @xmath315-bundles @xmath319 . the final assertion is merely an application of proposition [ prop:1 ] . the lie algebra of @xmath8 will be denoted by @xmath320 and the algebra of smooth @xmath320-valued differential forms on a manifold @xmath321 by @xmath322 . a _ connection _ @xmath323 on a @xmath140-bundle @xmath29 given in terms of a presentation @xmath324 is specified by a family of @xmath320-valued 1-forms @xmath325 satisfying is a matrix group . ] @xmath326 for all @xmath327 and @xmath328 . [ def:6 ] both terms on the right side of ( [ eq:6.1 ] ) are unambiguously defined as follows . the value of @xmath236 at @xmath329 is an element of @xmath330 , represented by @xmath331 for some neighbourhood @xmath164 of @xmath25 , and @xmath332 is in turn represented by a section @xmath333 . the first term on the right side of ( [ eq:6.1 ] ) is then defined by @xmath334 , and the second by @xmath335 . any two possible choices @xmath313 differ only by a constant factor in @xmath127 , which affects neither term . two such connections @xmath323 and @xmath336 defined in terms of the respective presentations @xmath265 and @xmath266 are _ equivalent _ , provided that , for some common refinement @xmath267 of the two respectively associated open coverings @xmath117 and @xmath118 with ( cf . ( [ eq:4.8 ] ) ) @xmath337 the relation @xmath338 holds for all @xmath339 and @xmath340 . here the right side of ( [ eq:6.3 ] ) is interpreted in the same manner as that of ( [ eq:6.1 ] ) . by choosing a sufficiently fine covering , the above - mentioned neighbourhoods @xmath164 may , by paracompactness , be identified with the trivialising neighbourhoods @xmath110 , so that the representative sections @xmath341 and @xmath342 may be regarded as elements of @xmath343 and @xmath344 , respectively . the @xmath341 then satisfy the cocycle condition modulo locally constant sections in @xmath127 , which suffices to ensure the mutual consistency of the relations ( 6.1 ) as the indices @xmath56 and @xmath345 vary over @xmath346 . the _ curvature _ of such a connection is defined in the conventional manner , i.e. for each @xmath110 we have @xmath347 . \label{eq:6.4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] by the same calculation as that used for conventional principal bundles , one finds , using ( 6.1 ) , that @xmath348 for @xmath328 . furthermore , if @xmath349 and @xmath350 are related by ( [ eq:6.3 ] ) , then @xmath351 if @xmath193 is a principal @xmath8-bundle and @xmath127 a central closed subgroup of @xmath8 , then an ordinary connection @xmath0 on @xmath2 clearly gives rise to a connection @xmath323 on @xmath352 in the sense of definition [ def:6 ] , and the conventional local curvature forms then coincide with those of @xmath323 as defined in ( [ eq:6.4 ] ) . by virtue of the relations ( [ eq:6.5 ] ) and ( [ eq:6.6 ] ) , characteristic classes of @xmath140-bundles can be defined and shown to be independent of the choice of the presentation and the choice of the connection @xmath323 , as for conventional principal bundles . we now define a connection on the dirac sheaf bundle @xmath353 ( @xmath354 ) . using the notation of [ sec:5 ] , let @xmath355 denote the presentation @xmath356 , and let @xmath357 \rd\phi \in \lambda^1(u_\alpha , { \mathfrak u}(1 ) ) \label{eq:6.7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] be the corresponding local 1-forms . on @xmath358 we have @xmath359 in accordance with ( [ eq:6.1 ] ) . the curvature is given by @xmath360 and hence the first chen class is @xmath361 , where @xmath362 is the area form on the unit 2-sphere . this shows that the sheaf bundles @xmath302 for distinct @xmath294 are inequivalent , as claimed above . for simplicity of exposition and to emphasise the analogy with the conventional hopf fibration @xmath363 , the dirac sheaf bundle and the corresponding monopole connection have been constructed over @xmath364 as base space . however , with a view to physical applications , the same construction applies verbatim if the base space is the subset of minkowski space defined by @xmath365 . again , expressing @xmath366 by spherical polar coordinates , formulae ( 5.1 ) , ( 5.2 ) and ( 5.6 ) remain unchanged . thus , for arbitrary real @xmath294 , one obtains a @xmath315-bundle over @xmath367 with field strength ( [ eq:6.9 ] ) . remark : according to the conventional bundle picture , there are no singularity - free gauge potentials @xmath368 with the properties that ( i ) their curls are equal to the field , and that ( ii ) they are related by gauge transformations on the overlapping region @xmath358 , unless electromagnetic charges are quantised ( wu & yang 1975 , theorem 3 ) . the above result demonstrates that this conclusion is not valid in the present generalised model . let @xmath8 be a lie group , @xmath127 a closed subgroup of @xmath8 , and @xmath369 a representation of @xmath8 on a ( real or complex ) vector space @xmath370 . let @xmath9 be a smooth paracompact manifold , and for each open @xmath371 , let @xmath372 denote the totality of smooth maps @xmath373 . if @xmath374 and @xmath375 , define @xmath376 by @xmath377 . denote by @xmath378 the quotient space of @xmath379 under this action of @xmath127 . if @xmath380 , then the restriction of @xmath379 to @xmath381 obviously commutes with the action of @xmath127 , and thus one obtains a restriction map @xmath382 . if @xmath383 , then @xmath384 , hence the system @xmath385 defines a presheaf @xmath386 , and a corresponding sheaf @xmath387 are to be interpreted with groups replaced by vector spaces and homomorphisms by linear transformations . ] next , for @xmath84 , define a left action of the stalk @xmath388 of the sheaf @xmath389 ( see definition 5 ) upon @xmath390 as follows . for some neighbourhood @xmath19 of @xmath25 , the germ @xmath391 is represented by an element @xmath392 and @xmath393 in turn by a section @xmath394 , while @xmath395 is represented by an element @xmath395 of @xmath378 and @xmath395 in turn by a section @xmath396 . define @xmath397 as the element of @xmath390 represented by the section @xmath398 . one can readily check that this is independent of the choices of @xmath399 and @xmath400 . let @xmath401 be a @xmath140-bundle defined by a presentation @xmath402 . a _ particle field _ is a system of sections @xmath403 satisfying the condition @xmath404 for every @xmath271 and @xmath272 . the totality of such particle fields will be denoted by @xmath405 . [ def:7 ] inspection of the foregoing construction clearly shows that for @xmath406 this definition effectively reduces to that of a conventional particle field ( cf . corollary [ cor:4.5 ] ) , i.e. a section of the associated bundle @xmath407 defined by a principal @xmath8-bundle and a representation @xmath408 . also , note that if @xmath409 , then @xmath405 is _ not _ a vector space . nevertheless , one can define covariant derivatives on @xmath410 , as is shown by the ensuing examples 2 and 3 . let @xmath411 be the local potentials of a connection @xmath323 with respect to some presentation @xmath265 , as in definition 6 . consider a point @xmath412 , and choose local coordinates @xmath413 in a neighbourhood @xmath414 of @xmath25 so that @xmath415 with @xmath416 . let @xmath417 and choose a section @xmath418 representing @xmath419 in some neighbourhood @xmath420 of @xmath25 , with @xmath421 . then define @xmath422(x ) = ( ( \partial_\mu - a_{\alpha\mu})v_\alpha)_x , \label{eq:7.2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath423 acts upon @xmath424 in accordance with the lie algebra representation induced by @xmath425 . this germ is clearly independent of the choice of @xmath400 , and thus one obtains a well - defined section of @xmath426 . moreover , for @xmath427 , @xmath428 that is , if @xmath419 and @xmath429 are related by ( [ eq:7.1 ] ) , then so are their covariant derivatives . to establish ( [ eq:7.3 ] ) note that both sides of the equation are well - defined local sections of @xmath430 . hence we may choose arbitrary representatives @xmath424 , @xmath431 , and @xmath313 of @xmath419 , @xmath432 , and @xmath236 , respectively , to perform the calculation . we choose representatives satisfying the relation @xmath433 , and by a routine computation , as for conventional minimal coupling , we verify that @xmath434 which implies ( [ eq:7.3 ] ) . choosing a sufficiently fine open covering , we may , by paracompactness , identify the aforesaid open sets @xmath420 with the @xmath110 , and hence assume that @xmath435 . accordingly , we let @xmath436 denote the element of @xmath437 determined by ( [ eq:7.3 ] ) . for each @xmath56 one can define a 1-form @xmath438 on @xmath110 assuming values in the sheaf @xmath439 , and ( [ eq:7.3 ] ) shows that these combine to provide a global @xmath439-valued form @xmath440 on @xmath9 . the quantisation of the gauge and particle fields described above will be investigated elsewhere . accordingly , we shall not attempt to define lagrangians in the present paper . rather , we shall merely postulate that the equations of motion derived in conventional gauge field theory are also valid in the present context . _ example 2_. _ generalised interaction of dirac monopole with charged scalar field_. consider the fundamental representation of @xmath1 , that is , @xmath441 for @xmath442 . we consider the dirac sheaf bundle @xmath302 and connection below , @xmath443 , where @xmath0 is the connection form for the conventional dirac monopole . ] @xmath444 defined over the subset @xmath445 of minkowski space , as described in 6 . let @xmath446 be a particle field associated with @xmath302 by the representation @xmath425 , as in definition [ def:7 ] . the classical equation of motion for a spin-0 charged particle interacting with an electromagnetic potential @xmath0 on minkowski space is @xmath447 where the charge factor @xmath448 has been absorbed into @xmath0 . if @xmath449 is replaced by @xmath450 , then , by virtue of relation ( [ eq:7.3 ] ) , both sides of the equation @xmath451 are well - defined elements of @xmath452 . remark : a solution of ( [ eq:7.7 ] ) might be physically described as a ` wave function ' determined only up to a locally constant phase factor . current dogma holds that a globally constant phase factor is undetectable , but the detectability of a locally constant phase factor using a physical measuring apparatus also seems problematical . hence , the model described in the present example appears to be physically plausible . the use of induced bundles to describe conventional interactions between gauge fields and particle fields initially defined in terms of different principal bundles ( see bleecker 1981 ) can be extended to @xmath140-bundles in a straightforward manner . if @xmath29 and @xmath57 are , respectively , @xmath140- and @xmath453-bundles defined over the same base space @xmath9 , then , passing to a common refinement if necessary , we may assume that @xmath29 and @xmath57 are given in terms of presentations @xmath265 and @xmath266 over the same system of trivialising neighbourhoods @xmath139 with transition isomorphisms determined by @xmath236 and @xmath269 , respectively . then , the pairs @xmath454 define a @xmath455-bundle @xmath456 over @xmath9 , with a presentation @xmath457 . furthermore , if @xmath458 and @xmath459 are the local 1-forms of connections @xmath323 and @xmath336 relative to the presentations @xmath265 and @xmath266 , respectively , then the local 1-forms @xmath460 determine a connection on @xmath461 relative to the presentation @xmath462 . now , let @xmath408 and @xmath463 be linear representations on a vector space @xmath370 such that @xmath464 for all @xmath465 . then @xmath466 defines a linear representation @xmath467 . the elements of @xmath468 represent particle fields which interact with potentials defined on @xmath29 as well as those defined on @xmath57 . _ example 3_. _ generalised interaction of dirac monopole and spinor field_. let @xmath425 denote the representation of @xmath1 on @xmath469 defined by scalar multiplication @xmath470 , and let @xmath471 , where @xmath472 and @xmath473 . then @xmath425 and @xmath474 obviously commute in the foregoing sense , hence @xmath475 defines a representation of @xmath476 on @xmath469 . let @xmath302 be the dirac @xmath315-bundle over @xmath477 , with connection forms @xmath478 ( @xmath479 ) relative to the presentation @xmath355 , as in ( [ eq:6.7 ] ) , extended from @xmath283 to @xmath477 in the obvious manner , as described in [ sec:6 ] . let @xmath57 be the trivial @xmath480-bundle over @xmath477 , or essentially @xmath481 , with trivial connection forms @xmath482 corresponding to the trivial presentation @xmath483 . thus , in this case the local 1-forms @xmath484 so the action of @xmath485 upon the local section @xmath486 is simply pointwise multiplication by the imaginary number @xmath487 . the conventional dirac equation in the presence of an electromagnetic potential , transcribed in the present context , becomes @xmath488 again , by virtue of ( [ eq:7.3 ] ) , both sides of ( [ eq:7.8 ] ) represent well - defined elements of @xmath489 . as indicated by the remarks in [ sec:1 ] , the mechanism of charge quantisation _ a la _ dirac is not an exclusive feature of the classical dirac monopole alone . the essential ingredient is a _ nontrivial _ @xmath1 bundle over some spacetime .. ] therefore , consideration of various other examples could be theoretically instructive as well as suggesting possible examples of applications to physical phenomena . the foregoing ansatz for construction of the dirac sheaf bundle can likewise be applied to cases where the underlying manifold @xmath9 is not a two - sphere . recall that given a principal bundle @xmath2 with abelian structure group @xmath8 and transition functions @xmath313 for some trivialising atlas @xmath117 , the powers @xmath490 for integral @xmath6 are the transition functions of a principal @xmath8-bundle @xmath306 with respect to the same atlas . moreover , if @xmath491 are the local 1-forms of a connection @xmath0 on @xmath2 , then one can easily check that @xmath492 provide the local 1-forms of a connection @xmath493 on @xmath306 . furthermore , if @xmath494 , then @xmath495 for the curvature ( field strength ) of @xmath493 . this means that if @xmath496 is a characteristic class of @xmath2 , then the corresponding class of @xmath306 is just @xmath497 . in particular , this applies to the chen classes . now , in accordance with the discussion in [ sec:6 ] , we can proceed similarly in the context of @xmath315-bundles , replacing the integer @xmath6 by the arbitrary real number @xmath294 , and deduce that if @xmath498 is the @xmath499th chen class of the circle bundle @xmath2 , then @xmath500 is the corresponding chen class of the @xmath315-bundle @xmath316 . to illustrate , consider the canonical connection on a circle bundle over the complex projective plane , which defines a gravitational and electromagnetic instanton . as local minima of the riemannian hilbert - maxwell action , such instantons provide significant contributions to the partition function in the joint path integral quantisation of the gravitational and electromagnetic fields , thus playing a role analogous to that of the usual instantons in the pure yang - mills theory ( cf . gibbons & hawking 1979 ; eguchi & hanson 1979 ) . _ example 4_. _ gravitational and electromagnetic instanton_. let @xmath501 and consider the canonical @xmath1 bundle over @xmath9 . the complex projective plane @xmath502 with coordinates @xmath503 satisfying @xmath504 is the quotient space of the five - sphere @xmath505 by the circle action @xmath506 . we regard @xmath505 as a subspace of @xmath507 : @xmath508 is defined by @xmath509 . parameterising @xmath505 by @xmath510 where @xmath511 $ ] , @xmath512 , formula ( 8.2 ) becomes @xmath513 as trivialising neighbourhoods , let @xmath514 . writing @xmath515 for the inhomogeneous coordinates on @xmath516 , a section @xmath517 over @xmath516 is given by @xmath518 similarly , we have @xmath519 for sections over @xmath520 and @xmath521 , respectively . by virtue of the relation @xmath522 the transition function of the @xmath1 bundle on , say , @xmath523 is given by @xmath524 . similarly , we have @xmath525 and @xmath526 . thus the generic transition function is simply @xmath527 . the canonical connection on the bundle is given by the hermitian inner product @xmath528 . in terms of the local coordinates on @xmath516 , given by @xmath529 and @xmath530 the local connection form is @xmath531 $ ] . a similar calculation shows that the local connection form on @xmath532 reads @xmath533 $ ] and @xmath534 $ ] . using the relation @xmath535 , we see at once that the local connection forms are related by the gauge transformation @xmath536 , where @xmath537 . similarly we have @xmath538 with @xmath539 and @xmath540 with @xmath541 . calculating the field strength @xmath542 on @xmath516 , say , we obtain @xmath543 . \label{eq:8.9}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this expression for @xmath81 in ( [ eq:8.9 ] ) agrees with the one obtained by trautman ( 1977 ) ; an alternative expression is given by gibbons & pope ( 1978 ) using different local coordinates . the field @xmath81 is self - dual with vanishing energy - momentum tensor , and thus , along with the fubini - study metric on @xmath544 , solves the einstein - maxwell equation with cosmological constant . at this point , one can merely speculate upon the possible incorporation of the corresponding @xmath315-bundles @xmath316 into the above - mentioned path integral formalism . _ example 5_. the field @xmath81 defined on @xmath545 induces solutions to the maxwell equation on analytic submanifolds of @xmath545 . trautman ( 1977 ) considered an example given by the veronese embedding ( cf . brody & hughston 2001 ) of @xmath546 in @xmath545 . for @xmath547 this is the embedding @xmath548 , which defines a conic @xmath549 in @xmath544 . a short calculation shows that , in terms of the spherical polar coordinates @xmath285 of @xmath550 , the local connection forms of the bundle on the two hemispheres @xmath532 are given by @xmath551 . comparison with ( [ eq:6.7 ] ) for @xmath552 shows that @xmath553 . thus , the electromagnetic field induced on @xmath283 corresponds to a magnetic pole of unit strength , which might appropriately be called the _ trautman monopole_. another elementary example is the solution to the maxwell equation arising from the segr embedding of @xmath554 in @xmath555 ; this defines a quadric @xmath556 in @xmath555 . in terms of the spherical polar coordinates @xmath557 of @xmath556 one finds at once that the local connection forms on @xmath556 are given by @xmath558 $ ] in the respective trivialising neighbourhoods @xmath532 . thus , we obtain a pair of disjoint dirac monopoles . the potential physical significance of the extensions to nonintegral charges @xmath294 would , of course , be similar to that of the simple dirac sheaf bundles described in [ sec:5 ] . remark : a nontrivial example of a new solution to the maxwell equation on a torus @xmath559 can be constructed by pulling the field @xmath81 back to @xmath559 via the elliptic curve @xmath560 in @xmath544 . here , @xmath561 is the complex coordinate of the torus and @xmath562 denotes the weierstra @xmath563-function . remark : since the equivalence classes of principal @xmath1-bundles over @xmath9 are indexed by @xmath564 ( see lawson & michelsohn 1990 , appendix a ) , any realisation of the usual hypothesis of charge quantisation through a topological mechanism is excluded in cosmological models over a contractible base , such as the schwarzschild universe ( see also trautman 1979 ) . this constitutes an apparent contradiction with certain grand unified theories which require the existence of monopoles ( t hooft 1974 ) . the author is not aware of any ansatz whereby this apparent contradiction could be resolved . consider the short exact sequence of lie groups @xmath565 with @xmath127 closed and central in @xmath8 . as described in example 1 , a principal @xmath8-bundle @xmath193 canonically determines a @xmath140-bundle @xmath566 over @xmath9 . in the special case where @xmath127 is discrete , a principal @xmath567-bundle @xmath568 canonically determines a @xmath140-bundle over @xmath9 as follows . let @xmath569 denote the transition functions of @xmath570 relative to a trivialising open covering @xmath571 of @xmath9 . since @xmath127 is discrete , the above epimorphism @xmath572 is a local homeomorphism , hence , for any @xmath328 , there exists a neighbourhood @xmath164 of @xmath25 , with @xmath573 , and a smooth mapping @xmath574 such that @xmath575 , and any two such @xmath576 and @xmath577 are related by @xmath578 for some constant @xmath579 . therefore , @xmath576 uniquely defines an element @xmath580 of @xmath214 ( see ( [ eq:3.5 ] ) ) and hence a continuous section @xmath581 of the sheaf @xmath582 . for @xmath583 we have @xmath584 hence , @xmath585 , and since @xmath127 is discrete , this product must be constant in some neighbourhood @xmath586 of @xmath25 . thus , @xmath587 in @xmath588 , and we replace @xmath164 by @xmath420 . passing to a suitable refinement of @xmath117 , we may , by paracompactness , identify the @xmath420 with the intersections @xmath589 , discard the superscripts @xmath25 from the @xmath590 , and thereby obtain , as in example 1 , transition sheaf isomorphisms @xmath591 where @xmath592 , which satisfy the cocycle condition by virtue of ( [ eq:9.2 ] ) . we denote the resulting @xmath140-bundle by @xmath593 . in particular , if @xmath2 is a principal @xmath8-bundle covering @xmath570 in the sense that the transition functions @xmath313 of @xmath2 with respect to some common trivialising open covering for @xmath2 and @xmath570 satisfy the relation @xmath594 then we may select @xmath595 in the foregoing construction , and thus @xmath593 coincides with the @xmath140-bundle @xmath150 described in example 1 . let @xmath596 denote the lie algebra of @xmath567 , and let @xmath0 be a conventional connection on @xmath570 . relative to a given system of local trivialisations over the open covering @xmath597 , with transition functions @xmath598 , @xmath0 is determined by a family of @xmath599-valued 1-forms @xmath600 satisfying @xmath601 for all @xmath328 . relative to another system of local trivialisations over @xmath117 , with transition functions @xmath602 , the same connection @xmath0 is represented by the 1-forms @xmath603 for a sufficiently fine covering , we can choose sections @xmath604 and @xmath605 such that @xmath606 and , as above , @xmath607 . these choices are unique modulo constant multiplicative factors in @xmath608 and @xmath609 , respectively . furthermore , the covering map @xmath449 induces a lie algebra isomophism @xmath610 . applying @xmath611 to ( [ eq:9.5 ] ) and ( [ eq:9.6 ] ) , we obtain @xmath612 and @xmath613 let @xmath236 and @xmath614 denote the sections of @xmath615 and @xmath616 determined by @xmath313 and @xmath617 , respectively , and write @xmath618 , @xmath619 . then ( [ eq:9.7 ] ) and ( [ eq:9.8 ] ) imply the relations @xmath620 and @xmath621 in accordance with the explanatory remarks following ( [ eq:6.1 ] ) and ( [ eq:6.3 ] ) . thus , the family of 1-forms @xmath622 , corresponding to the presentation @xmath623 , where , as usual , @xmath624 , determines a connection @xmath323 on the @xmath140-bundle @xmath593 in the sense of definition [ def:6 ] . of particular physical interest is the case where @xmath625 , @xmath626 ( the superscript @xmath627 denoting the component of the identity ) and @xmath449 is the canonical homomorphism with kernel @xmath628 . given a principal @xmath567-bundle @xmath570 over @xmath9 , a well - known theorem ( lawson & michelsohn 1990 , friedrich 2000 ) states that @xmath570 is covered by some principal @xmath8-bundle @xmath2 in the above sense iff the second stiefel class @xmath629 vanishes , and then the equivalence classes ( i.e. bundle equivalence compatible with the covering map onto @xmath570 ) of such coverings @xmath2 ( known as _ spin structures _ ) are parameterised by the elements of @xmath630 . inequivalent spin structures may ( or may not ) be inequivalent as abstract @xmath8-bundles over @xmath9 . nevertheless , this can entail no inconsistency with proposition [ prop:1 ] , since , if the hypothesis of that proposition is satisfied , then , by the above - cited theorem , there exists at most one spin structure @xmath2 over @xmath570 , and hence at most one @xmath150 , which , if existent , coincides with @xmath593 . however , the _ quasispin structure _ @xmath593 exists in any case , even if @xmath150 does not . specifically , let @xmath9 be a smooth lorentzian manifold and @xmath570 the orthonormal frame bundle of @xmath9 . the levi - civita connection @xmath631 on @xmath570 then determines , as above , a connection @xmath632 on @xmath593 , and the spin representation @xmath633 , where @xmath634 denotes the spin module , gives rise to a space @xmath635 of particle fields ( see definition [ def:7 ] ) . covariant differentiation in @xmath439 is then well - defined , just as was indicated , using local coordinates , in examples 2 and 3 . relative to a given trivialisation over @xmath110 in a sufficiently fine open covering , a quasispinor field @xmath636 is represented by a smooth section @xmath637 , determined up to a constant factor @xmath638 , that is , up to a sign @xmath639 . using the local 1-form @xmath640 relative to the given trivialisation , one obtains a conventional dirac operator @xmath641 over each @xmath110 , which , applied to @xmath642 , yields a section @xmath643 , likewise defined up to a sign . let @xmath644 denote the element of @xmath645 determined by @xmath642 . since the dirac operator behaves covariantly with respect to gauge transformations @xmath646 , the relations ( [ eq:7.1 ] ) , with @xmath647 , imply corresponding relations for the sections @xmath643 , which thus combine to yield an element @xmath648 . according to a well - known theorem of geroch ( 1968 ) , the orthonormal frame bundle of a noncompact lorentzian manifold @xmath9 possesses a spin structure iff @xmath9 is parallelisable . a specific example of a noncompact lorentzian manifold not admitting a spin structure is described , e.g. , in clarke ( 1971 ) . the present formalism permits the global description of fermionic fields on such spacetimes , and the local properties of quasispinor fields and quasi - dirac operators in this context are clearly identical with those of their conventional counterparts . the foregoing considerations are likewise applicable to the construction of quasispinor fields and quasi - dirac operators on oriented riemannian manifolds , with @xmath649 , @xmath650 and @xmath628 . in the conventional theory , the index of the dirac operator on a ` spinnable ' manifold @xmath9 is expressible , by the atiyah - singer index formula , in terms of the chen classes of @xmath9 ( lawson & michelsohn 1990 ; berline _ et al_. 1992 ) . even if @xmath9 is not spinnable , this expression is still well - defined . on the other hand , since @xmath439 is not a vector space , the index of the quasi - dirac operator @xmath651 can not be defined in the conventional manner . of course , one could , by fiat , simply define the index of the quasi - dirac operator as the value of the atiyah - singer expression . however , a more interesting approach would consist in providing a general geometrical definition of the index for differential operators on @xmath439 , and proving that its value for the quasi - dirac operator is given by the atiyah - singer formula . this appears to pose a not entirely trivial problem . in the pseudoriemannian case , if @xmath9 is not space and time orientable , then one deals with pin structures ( see chamblin and gibbons 1997 for a discussion of physical applications ) . since the homomorphism @xmath652 is also a double covering , the foregoing construction is directly applicable , and one thus obtains _ quasipin structures _ , even if true pin structures fail to exist . @xmath653-structures can also be generalised in a similar vein , but since in this case the central subgroup @xmath654 is not discrete , the situation is somewhat more complicated and will be dealt with elsewhere . mathematically sophisticated expositions of gauge theory tend to define connections and curvature _ ab initio _ on the total space of a principal bundle before pulling these quantities down to the base space via local trivialisations . some readers may , perhaps , inquire why we have not adopted this more elegant approach . the reason is that our sheaf bundles are not hausdorff spaces , hence not manifolds , so the tangent spaces are undefined . consequently , we must adopt the orthodox physical practice of working in terms of local sections . in the relevant literature one occasionally observes heuristic statements to the effect that topological solitons already display certain quantal effects at the classical level . since charge renormalisation and running coupling constants can only result from field quantisation in the conventional theory , one could , in a similar vein , assert that the generalised solitons described above already display quantum field theoretic effects at the classical level . the coupling constants can walk even before they begin to run . we have constructed a family of generalised dirac monopoles @xmath302 which include the conventional @xmath304 as special cases . the @xmath304 interact with conventional wave functions @xmath655 , i.e. sections of the associated vector bundles , and likewise , mathematical consistency in the description of interactions involving the @xmath302 requires the introduction of generalised wave functions @xmath656 which are sections of certain sheaves . every conventional @xmath655 defines a @xmath656 , but there also exist @xmath656 that do not arise from any @xmath655 . for example , consider normalised wave functions defined over the circle @xmath657 . in the conventional model , these include , e.g. , @xmath658 for integral @xmath6 , but not @xmath659 for arbitrary real @xmath294 . in our model , however , the @xmath660 ( and more generally , @xmath661 , where @xmath662 is an ordinary normalised complex - valued function on @xmath663 ) represent well - defined sections of the sheaf @xmath664 , where @xmath282 . thus , rather than demanding knowledge of a global function on @xmath9 , determined only up to a globally constant phase factor , we merely demand , for any point @xmath84 , the knowledge of a function on some neighbourhood @xmath19 of @xmath25 , and determined only up to a constant phase factor on @xmath19 . the probabilistic interpretation of such a generalised wave function remains the same as in the conventional theory . moreover , differentiation with respect to @xmath25 and multiplication by ordinary functions @xmath665 are well - defined , so we can apply hamiltonian operators such as @xmath666 . magnetic monopoles , of either integral charge or otherwise , have not yet been encountered in experimental studies ( see , e.g. , milton 2006 for the current status of the experimental limits ) . the discovery of either nonintegral magnetic monopoles or nonintegral electric charges would tend to indicate that the above - described model is not merely more general mathematically but also more realistic physically than the conventional principal bundle model . such a discovery might therefore cast doubt upon the long - standing assumption that the venues for physical phenomena are necessarily manifolds , and suggest that sheaves , which provide a more local description , constitute the appropriate arenas for physical models . the sheaf - theoretic dequantisation of solitons and instantons for nonabelian gauge groups constitutes a challenging topic for research , and might have implications for grand unified theories . the above treatment of the dirac sheaf bundle can be adapted to cases where the dirac monopole is embedded within a nonabelian principal bundle , such as the t hooft monopole . the validity of the model constructed above would have certain obvious physical consequences . firstly , the detection of a magnetic monopole would not necessarily imply the quantisation of electromagnetic charges . conversely , an observed violation of charge quantisation would not necessarily imply the nonexistence of magnetic monopoles . a definite conclusion concerning the actual physical quantisation of electric charges remains elusive . for example , explosions of electron bubbles in liquid helium have been observed in the laboratory , suggesting that fractionally charged particles can possibly exist in isolation ( konstantinov & maris 2003 ) , although the interpretation of such experiments is controversial ( jackiw _ et al_. 2001 ; bender _ et al_. 2005 ) . other physical observations apparently consistent with nonintegral charges include the fractional quantum hall effect ( laughlin 1983 ) and geometric phase measurements in anisotropic spin systems ( bruno 2004 ) . the possible variability of the fine structure constant over the cosmological timescale ( bekenstein 1982 ) and the postulated fractional charges of the quarks in the deconfinement phase could also be relevant to this issue . a sheaf - theoretic formulation of the underlying quantum theory along the foregoing lines might conceivably clarify some of these diverse phenomena . the author hereby expresses his gratitude to c. m. bender , e. j. brody , g. w. gibbons , t. w. b. kibble , b. muratori , and r. p. w. thomas for stimulating and informative discussions in connection with the foregoing material .

magnetic monopole ; sheaf cohomology ; + topological quantisation ; spin structure ; dirac operator using a sheaf - theoretic extension of conventional principal bundle theory , the dirac monopole is formulated as a spherically symmetric model free of singularities outside the origin such that the charge may assume arbitrary real values . for integral charges , the construction effectively coincides with the usual model . spin structures and dirac operators are also generalised by the same technique .

cond-mat0404562

the model of quantum lattice bose gas has a long history and has been suggested initially for conventional superconductors @xcite , quantum crystals such as @xmath4he where superfluidity coexists with a crystalline order.@xcite afterwards , the bose - hubbard ( bh ) model has been studied as a model of the superconductor - insulator transition in materials with local bosons , bipolarons , or preformed cooper pairs.@xcite two - dimensional bh models have been addressed as relevant to describe the superconducting films and josephson junction arrays . the most recent interest to the system of hard - core bosons comes from the delightful results on bose - einstein ( be ) condensed atomic systems produced by trapping bosonic neutral atoms in an optical lattice . @xcite the progress in boson physics generates an especial interest around nonlinear topological excitations ( skyrmions , vortices ) which play an increasingly significant role in physics . one of the fundamental hot debated problems in bosonic physics concerns the evolution of the charge ordered ( co ) ground state of 2d hard - core bh model ( hc - bh ) with a doping away from half - filling . numerous model studies steadily confirmed the emergence of `` supersolid '' phases with simultaneous diagonal and off - diagonal long range order while penrose and onsager @xcite were the first showing as early as 1956 that supersolid phases do not occur . the most recent quantum monte - carlo ( qmc ) simulations @xcite found two significant features of the 2d bose - hubbard model with a screened coulomb repulsion : the absence of supersolid phase at half - filling , and a growing tendency to phase separation ( co+bs ) upon doping away from half - filling . moreover , batrouni and scalettar @xcite studied quantum phase transitions in the ground state of the 2d hard - core boson hubbard hamiltonian and have shown numerically that , contrary to the generally held belief , the most commonly discussed `` checkerboard '' supersolid is thermodynamically unstable and phase separates into solid and superfluid phases . the physics of the co+bs phase separation in bose - hubbard model is associated with a rapid increase of the energy of a homogeneous co state with doping away from half - filling due to a large `` pseudo - spin - flip '' energy cost . hence , it appears to be energetically more favorable to `` extract '' extra bosons ( holes ) from the co state and arrange them into finite clusters with a relatively small number of particles . such a droplet scenario is believed to minimize the long - range coulomb repulsion . however , immediately there arise several questions . whether a simple mean - field approximation ( mfa ) and classical continuum model can predict such a behavior ? what is the detailed structure of the co+bs phase separated state ? what are the main factors governing the essential low - energy and long - wavelength physics ? is it possible to make use of simple toy models ? are there the analogies with fermion hubbard model ? the behavior of the latter under doping away from half - filling is extensively studied in last decade in frames of stripe scenario which implies that doping may proceed through the formation of stripes , or charged domain walls being specific topological solitons in nel antiferromagnets . in particular , emery and kivelson @xcite argued that the phase separation reflects a universal tendency of the correlated antiferromagnet to expel the doped holes . white and scalapino @xcite showed that the pure 2d t - j model , in the small - j / t regime and with dopings near @xmath5 , has a striped ground state . in general , the topological phase separation is believed to be a generic property of 2d fermion hubbard model . in the paper we present a topological scenario of co+bs phase separation in 2d hc - bh model with inter - site repulsion . the extra bosons / holes doped to a checkerboard co phase of 2d boson system are believed to be confined in the ring - shaped domain wall of the skyrmion - like topological defect which looks like a bubble domain in an easy - axis antiferromagnet . this allows us to propose the mechanism of 2d _ topological _ co+bs _ phase separation _ when the doping of the bare checkerboard co phase results in the formation of a multi - center topological defect , which simplified pseudo - spin pattern looks like a system of bubble co domains with bose superfluid confined in charged ring - shaped domain walls . the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in sec.ii we give a short overview of the conventional hc - bh model in frames of a pseudo - spin formalism and mfa description . in sec.iii we show that the doping in 2d hc - bh system can be accompanied by the formation of a topological defect like a single or multi - center skyrmion . we present the scenario of the essential low - energy physics for the topologically doped hc - bh system . in sec.iv we address a simple model of nanoscopic bubble - like domain in a checkerboard co phase for a discrete square lattice that allows us to demonstrate a subtle microscopic structure of such a center with a multi - component order parameter . the hamiltonian of hard - core bose gas on a lattice can be written in a standard form as follows : @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the projection operator which removes double occupancy of any site , @xmath8 , @xmath9 the chemical potential determined from the condition of fixed full number of bosons @xmath10 or concentration @xmath11 $ ] . the @xmath12 denotes an effective transfer integral , @xmath13 is an intersite interaction between the bosons . here @xmath14 are the pauli creation ( annihilation ) operators which are bose - like commuting for different sites @xmath15=0,$ ] if @xmath16 @xmath17=1 - 2n_i$ ] , @xmath18 ; @xmath19 is a full number of sites . it is worth noting that near half - filling ( @xmath20 ) one might introduce the renormalization @xmath21 , or neutralizing background , that immediately provides the particle - hole symmetry . the model of hard - core bose - gas with an intersite repulsion is equivalent to a system of spins @xmath22 exposed to an external magnetic field in the @xmath23-direction . for the system with neutralizing background we arrive at an effective pseudo - spin hamiltonian @xmath24 where @xmath25 , @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 . in a linear approximation the hamiltonian for the coupling with an electromagnetic field reads as follows @xmath29_{z}-\frac{1}{2}(\phi _ { j}-\phi _ { i})^{2}({\hat { \bf s}_{i}}\cdot { \hat { \bf s}_{j}}));\ ] ] @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the vector - potential , and integration runs over line binding the @xmath32 and @xmath33 sites ; @xmath34_{z}=\frac{i}{2}(\hat b_{i}^{\dagger}\hat b_{j}-\hat b_{i}\hat b_{j}^{\dagger}),\ ] ] however , the pseudo - spins are assumed to lie in @xmath35 plane . then the boson current density operator one may represent to be a sum of the paramagnetic @xmath36_{z},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and diamagnetic @xmath37 terms , respectively . below we make use of a conventional two - sublattice mfa approach . for the description of the pseudospin ordering to be more physically clear one may introduce two vectors , the ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic ones : @xmath38 where @xmath39 . for the plane where these vectors lie one may introduce two - parametric angular description : @xmath40 . the hard - core boson system in a two - sublattice approximation is described by two diagonal order parameters @xmath41 and two complex off - diagonal order parameters @xmath42 and @xmath43 . the complex superfluid order parameter @xmath44 is determined by the in - plane components of ferromagnetic vector : @xmath45 , @xmath46 being the length of the in - plane component of ferromagnetic vector . so , for a local condensate density we get @xmath47 . it is of interest to note that in fact all the conventional uniform @xmath48 states with nonzero @xmath49 imply simultaneous long - range order both for modulus @xmath50 and phase @xmath51 . the in - plane components of antiferromagnetic vector @xmath52 describe a staggered off - diagonal order . it is worth noting that by default one usually considers the negative sign of the transfer integral @xmath12 , that implies the ferromagnetic in - plane pseudospin ordering . the model exhibits many fascinating quantum phases and phase transitions . early investigations predict at @xmath48 charge order ( co ) , bose superfluid ( bs ) and mixed ( co+bs ) supersolid uniform phases with an ising - type melting transition ( co - no ) and kosterlitz - thouless - type ( bs - no ) phase transitions to a non - ordered normal fluid ( no).@xcite the detailed mean - field and spin - wave analysis of the uniform phases of 2d hc - bh model is given by pich and frey.@xcite mfa yields for the conventional uniform supersolid phase @xcite @xmath53 with a constant chemical potential @xmath54 . it should be noted that the supersolid phase appears to be unstable with regard to small perturbations in the hamiltonian . the mean - field energy per site of the uniform supersolid phase is written as follows : @xmath55 where @xmath56 . the cost of doping both for co and co+bs phase appears to be rather high as compared with an easy - plane bs phase at half - filling where the chemical potential turns into zero.@xcite magnetic analogy allows us to make unambiguous predictions as regards the doping of bh system away from half - filling . indeed , the boson / hole doping of checkerboard co phase corresponds to the magnetization of an antiferromagnet in @xmath23-direction . in the uniform easy - axis @xmath57-phase of anisotropic antiferromagnet the local spin - flip energy cost is rather big . in other words , the energy cost for boson / hole doping into checkerboard co phase appears to be big due to a large contribution of boson - boson repulsion . however , the magnetization of the anisotropic antiferromagnet in an easy axis direction may proceed as a first order phase transition with a `` topological phase separation '' due to the existence of antiphase domains.@xcite the antiphase domain walls provide the natural nucleation centers for a spin - flop phase having enhanced magnetic susceptibility as compared with small if any longitudinal susceptibility thus providing the advantage of the field energy . namely domain walls would specify the inhomogeneous magnetization pattern for such an anisotropic easy - axis antiferromagnet in relatively weak external magnetic field . as concerns the domain type in quasi - two - dimensional antiferromagnet one should emphasize the specific role played by the cylindrical , or bubble domains which have finite energy and size . these topological solitons have the vortex - like in - plane spin structure and often named `` skyrmions '' . the classical , or belavin - polyakov ( bp ) skyrmion @xcite describes the solutions of a non - linear @xmath58-model with a classical isotropic 2d heisenberg hamiltonian and represents one of the generic toy model spin textures . it is of primary importance to note that skyrmion - like bubble domains in easy - axis layered antiferromagnets were actually observed in the experiments performed by waldner,@xcite that were supported later by different authors ( see , e.g. refs . ) . although some questions were not completely clarified and remain open until now , @xcite the classical and quantum @xcite skyrmion - like topological defects are believed to be a genuine element of essential physics both of ferro- and antiferromagnetic 2d easy - axis systems . the magnetic analogy seems to be a little bit naive , however , it catches the essential physics of doping the hc - bh system . as regards the checkerboard co phase of such a system , namely a finite energy skyrmion - like bubble domain @xcite seems to be the most preferable candidate for the domain with antiphase domain wall providing the natural reservoir for extra bosons . the classical description of nonlinear excitations in hc - bh model includes the skyrmionic solution given @xmath59 . @xcite the skyrmion spin texture consists of a vortex - like arrangement of the in - plane components of ferromagnetic @xmath60 vector with the @xmath57-component reversed in the centre of the skyrmion and gradually increasing to match the homogeneous background at infinity . the simplest spin distribution within classical skyrmion is given as follows @xmath61 @xmath62 where @xmath63 is a global phase ( @xmath64 order parameter ) , @xmath65 skyrmion radius . the skyrmion spin texture describes the coexistence and competition of the staggered charge order parameter @xmath57 and bs order parameter @xmath46 ( see fig.[fig1 ] ) that reflects a complex spatial interplay of potential and kinetic energies . ; b ) the radial distribution of the modulus of the superfluid order parameter @xmath66 ; c ) the radial distribution of the charge density @xmath67 for the charged skyrmion ; d ) the orientation of the superfluid order parameter @xmath66 given two values of the phase order parameter @xmath68 : @xmath69 , respectively . rings in all the pictures correspond to the skyrmion ( bubble domain ) wall , the dashed circle being its center.,width=321 ] the skyrmion looks like a bubble domain in an easy - axis magnet . it should be noted that the domain wall in such a bubble domain somehow created in the checkerboard co phase of 2d hc - bh system represents an effective ring - shaped reservoir both for bose - superfluid and extra boson / hole . indeed , the soliton energy depends quadratically on the number @xmath70 of bosons bound in domain wall,@xcite similarly to that of homogeneous bs phase.@xcite in other words , one might say about a zero value of the effective boson / hole chemical potential for the co bubble domain configuration , provided it were a ground state . the numerical calculations performed in frames of a classical continuous model @xcite show that the doped bosons appear to be trapped inside the bubble domain wall . the spatial distribution of the doped boson / hole density ( @xmath71 ) in the charged skyrmion is shown schematically in fig . skyrmions are characterized by the magnitude and sign of its topological charge , by its size ( radius ) , and by the global orientation of the spin . the scale invariance of classical bp skyrmionic solution reflects in that its energy does not depend on radius , and global phase . an interesting example of topological inhomogeneity is provided by a multi - center bp skyrmion @xcite which energy does not depend on the position of the centers . the latter are believed to be addressed as an additional degree of freedom , or positional order parameter . in the continuous model the classical bp skyrmion is a topological excitation and can not dissipate . however , the classical static skyrmion is unstable with regard to an external field or anisotropic interactions both of easy - plane and easy - axis type . small easy - axis anisotropy or external field are sufficient to shrink skyrmion to a nanoscopic size when magnetic length @xmath72 : @xmath73 is of the order of several lattice parameters , and the continuous approximation fails to correctly describe excitations . nonetheless , abanov and pokrovsky @xcite have shown that the easy - axis anisotropy together with fourth - order exchange term can stabilize skyrmion with radius @xmath74 a skyrmionic scenario in hc - bh model allows us to make several important predictions . away from half - filling one may anticipate the nucleation of a topological defect in the unconventional form of the multi - center skyrmion - like object with ring - shaped bose superfluid regions positioned in an antiphase domain wall separating the co core and co outside of the single skyrmion . the specific spatial separation of bs and co order parameters that avoid each other reflects the competition of kinetic and potential energy . such a _ topological _ ( co+bs ) _ phase separation _ is believed to provide a minimization of the total energy as compared with its uniform supersolid counterpart . thus , the parent checkerboard co phase may gradually lose its stability under boson / hole doping , while a novel topological self - organized texture is believed to become stable . the most probable possibility is that every domain wall accumulates single boson , or boson hole . then , the number of centers in a multi - center skyrmion nucleated with doping has to be equal to the number of bosons / holes . in such a case , we anticipate the near - linear dependence of the total bs volume fraction on the doping . generally speaking , one may assume scenario when the nucleation of a multi - center skyrmion occurs spontaneously with no doping . in such a case we should anticipate the existence of neutral multi - center skyrmion - like object with equal number of positively and negatively charged single skyrmions . however , in practice , namely the boson / hole doping is likely to be a physically clear driving force for a nucleation of a single , or multi - center skyrmion - like self - organized collective mode in the form of multi - center charged topological defect which may be ( not strictly correctly ) referred to as multi - skyrmion system akin in a quantum hall ferromagnetic state of a two - dimensional electron gas.@xcite in such a case , we may characterize an individual skyrmion by its position ( i.e. , the center of skyrmionic texture ) , its size ( i.e. , the radius of domain wall ) , and the orientation of the in - plane components of pseudo - spin ( u(1 ) degree of freedom ) . an isolated skyrmion is described by the inhomogeneous distribution of the co parameter , or staggered boson density @xmath57 , order parameter @xmath75 characterizing the deviation from the half - filling , and @xmath46 that corresponds only to the modulus of the superfluid order parameter . it seems likely that for a light doping any doped particle ( boson / holes ) results in a nucleation of a new single - skyrmion state , hence its density changes gradually with particle doping . therefore , as long as the separation between skyrmionic centers is sufficiently large so that the inter - skyrmion interaction is negligible , the energy of the system per particle remains almost constant . this means that the chemical potential of a boson or hole remains unchanged with doping and hence apparently remains fixed . the multi - skyrmionic system in contrast with uniform ones can form the structures with inhomogeneous long - range ordering of the modulus of the superfluid order parameter accompanied by the non - ordered global phases of single skyrmions . such a situation resembles in part that of granular superconductivity . in the long - wavelength limit the off - diagonal ordering can be described by an effective hamiltonian in terms of u(1 ) ( phase ) degree of freedom associated with each skyrmion . such a hamiltonian contains a repulsive , long - range coulomb part and a short - range contribution related to the phase degree of freedom . the latter term can be written out in the standard for the @xmath76 model form of a so - called josephson coupling @xmath77 where @xmath78 are global phases for skyrmions centered at points @xmath79 , respectively , @xmath80 josephson coupling parameter . namely the josephson coupling gives rise to the long - range ordering of the phase of the superfluid order parameter in a multi - center skyrmion . such a hamiltonian represents a starting point for the analysis of disordered superconductors , granular superconductivity , insulator - superconductor transition with @xmath81 array of superconducting islands with phases @xmath82 . calculating the phase - dependent part of skyrmion - skyrmion interaction timm _ et al._@xcite arrived at @xmath83 sign of @xmath80 that favors antiparallel alignment of the u(1 ) pseudospins . in other words , two skyrmions are believed to form a peculiar josephson @xmath84 micro - junction . there are a number of interesting implications that follow directly from this result:@xcite the spontaneous breaking of time - reversal symmetry with non - zero supercurrents and magnetic fluxes in the ground state , long - time tails in the dynamics of the system , unconventional aharonov - bohm period @xmath85 , negative magnetoresistence . to account for coulomb interaction and allow for quantum corrections we should introduce into effective hamiltonian the charging energy @xcite @xmath86 where @xmath87 is a boson number operator for bosons bound in @xmath32-th skyrmion ; it is quantum - mechanically conjugated to @xmath51 : @xmath88 , @xmath89 stands for the capacitance matrix , @xmath90 for bosonic charge . the classical ground state energy of skyrmion lattice for all reasonable two - dimensional lattice structures was minimized by timm _ _ taking the u(1 ) order into account . @xcite besides the expected triangular lattice with frustrated antiferromagnetic u(1 ) order and square lattice with nel u(1 ) order the authors have also obtained ground - state energies for all 2d bravais lattices . such a system appears to reveal a tremendously rich quantum - critical structure . in the absence of disorder , the @xmath48 phase diagram of the multi - skyrmion system implies either triangular , or square crystalline arrangements ( skyrmion , or bubble crystal ) with possible melting transition to a skyrmion ( bubble ) liquid . the melting of skyrmion lattice is successfully described applying the berezinsky - kosterlitz - thouless ( bkt ) theory to dislocations and disclinations of the lattice and proceeds in two steps . the first implies the transition to a liquid - crystal phase with short - range translational order , the second does the transition to isotropic liquid . disorder pins the skyrmion lattice and also causes the crystalline order to have a finite correlation length . for such a system provided the skyrmion positions fixed at all temperatures , the long - wave - length physics would be described by an @xmath76 model with expectable bkt transition and gapless @xmath76 spin - wave mode . the classical phase diagram of skyrmion lattice is quite rich . depending on the relation between coulomb and josephson coupling , and density one may arrive at different lattice structures with continuous or first order phase transitions . as regards the superfluid properties the skyrmionic system reveals unconventional behavior with two critical temperatures @xmath91 and @xmath92 , @xmath93 being the temperature of the ordering of the modulus and @xmath94 that of the phase of order parameter @xmath95 . the low temperature physics in skyrmion crystals is governed by an interplay of two bkt transitions , for the u(1 ) phase and positional degrees of freedom , respectively . @xcite dislocations in most skyrmion lattice types lead to a mismatch in the u(1 ) degree of freedom , which makes the dislocations bind fractional vortices and lead to a coupling of translational and phase excitations . both bkt temperatures either coincide ( square lattice ) or the melting one is higher ( triangular lattice).@xcite quantum fluctuations can substantially affect these results . quantum melting can destroy u(1 ) order at sufficiently low densities where the josephson coupling becomes exponentially small . similar situation is expected to take place in the vicinity of structural transitions in skyrmion crystal . with increasing the skyrmion density the quantum effects result in a significant lowering of the melting temperature as compared with classical square - root dependence . the resulting melting temperature can reveal an oscilating behavior as a function of particle density with zeros at the critical ( magic ) densities associated with structural phase transitions . in terms of our model , the positional order corresponds to an incommensurate charge density wave , while the u(1 ) order does to a superconductivity . in other words , we arrive at a subtle interplay between two orders . the superconducting state evolves from a charge order with @xmath96 , where @xmath97 is the temperature of a melting transition which could be termed as a temperature of the opening of the insulating gap ( pseudo - gap ! ? ) . the normal modes of a dilute skyrmion system ( multi - center skyrmion ) include the pseudo - spin waves propagating in - between the skyrmions , the positional fluctuations , or phonon modes of the skyrmions which are gapless in a pure system , but gapped when the lattice is pinned , and , finally , fluctuations in the skyrmionic in - plane orientation and size . the latter two types of fluctuation are intimitely connected , since the @xmath23-component of spin and orientation are conjugate coordinates because of commutation relations of quantum angular momentum operators . so , rotating a skyrmion changes its size . the orientational fluctuations of the multi - skyrmion system are governed by the gapless @xmath76 model.@xcite the relevant model description is most familiar as an effective theory of the josephson junction array . an important feature of the model is that it displays a quantum - critical point . the low - energy collective excitations of skyrmion liquid includes an usual longitudinal acoustic phonon branch . the liquid crystal phases differ from the isotropic liquid in that they have massive topological excitations , _ i.e. _ , the disclinations . one should note that the liquids do not support transverse modes , these could survive in a liquid state only as overdamped modes . so that it is reasonable to assume that solidification of the skyrmion lattice would be accompanied by a stabilization of transverse modes with its sharpening below melting transition . in other words an instability of transverse phonon modes signals the onset of melting . a generic property of the positionally ordered skyrmion configuration is the sliding mode which is usually pinned by the disorder . the depinning of sliding mode(s ) can be detected in a low - frequency and low - temperature optical response . our speculations as regards the topological phase separation and long wave - length physics of 2d hc - bh model are summarized in a qualitative @xmath98-t ( @xmath99 ) phase diagram in fig.[fig3 ] . first of all , the phase diagram implies a scenario in which the topological phase separation state evolves with a minimal doping , though it is worth noting that the ideal checkerboard co phase can not be a nominal @xmath100 limit of any topologically phase separated phase . despite the qualitative character of phase diagram we took into account some quantitative results of quantum monte - carlo calculations for the 2d hc - bh model with nearest neighbor coulomb repulsion.@xcite first , it concerns the doping range of additive , or near - linear concentration behavior of bose - condensate density @xmath101 and co structure factor @xmath102 . the superfluid density increases approximately linearly with doping except for the most overdoped point @xmath103 , where it turns down again . diagonal long - range charge order is characterized by the equal time structure factor at the ordering vector @xmath104 , @xmath105 in the presence of long - range order @xmath102 will diverge with the system size @xmath106 for a given ordering momentum @xmath107 , which characterizes the ordered phase . for the checkerboard order @xmath108 . in the concentration range @xmath109 , where both quantities vary linearly with @xmath110,@xcite we may approximate the topological defect to be a system of @xmath111 interacting single - charged skyrmions . it should be noted that the both co and bs order parameters coexist in a rather narrow doping concentration interval : @xmath112 . beyond this `` overdoping '' region we deal with an inhomogeneous boson liquid which pseudo - spin picture implies a strongly frustrated singlet - triplet system that resembles the spin glass , and maybe termed as a dynamical `` singlet - triplet '' pseudo - spin glass . such a system can be characterized by a dynamical short - range diagonal and off - diagonal ordering with a wide distribution of respective correlation lengths and relaxation rates . interestingly , that in frames of a continuous model this phase is still described to be a strongly correlated multi - center topological defect . however , such a model fails obviously to describe the real system where the inter - center spacing is comparable with the lattice parameter . the temperature evolution of hc - bh system with large inter - site boson repulsion implies the highest critical temperature @xmath113 separating the high - temperature non - ordered no phase ( boson liquid ) and a low - temperature quasi - co phase with a disordered system of skyrmions . the next critical temperature @xmath114 points to the first order phase transition with a formation of inhomogeneous bose condensate in a single skyrmion with the vortex - like texture of the quasi - local order parameter @xmath115 . in other words , it is a temperature of the topological co+bs phase separation ( tps ) . in frames of our scenario such tps state emerges with a minimal doping , and @xmath116 is likely to be nearly constant in a linear doping regime ( @xmath117 ) . the low - temperature part of the phase diagram , which is schematically shown in fig . [ fig3 ] , describes the gradual skyrmionic solidification and may include the isotropic skyrmion(bubble ) liquid phase , the skyrmion liquid - crystal phase , the incommensurate skyrmion crystal phase , and u(1 ) ordering , or superfluid phase , restricted by the temperatures of the proper bkt transitions . for a small deviation from half - filling ( `` under - doping '' ) the temperatures of bubble crystallization / melting are seemingly to obey the square root concentration law @xmath118 with a strongly developed quantum melting effect when approaching an `` overdoped '' regime or concentrations limiting the linear regime . the superfluid phase in fig.[fig3 ] is arbitrarily chosen to lie inside the skyrmion solid phase . one should emphasize the specific role played by quantum fluctuations : these lead to the melting of the bubble crystal at high densities and orientational disordering @xcite at low densities . both effects are of primary importance in the overdoped and heavily underdoped regions of the phase diagram , respectively . moreover , quantum melting effect may strongly affect the phase diagram near the `` magic '' doping level , where the skyrmion lattice undergoes the structural phase transition . for illustration , in the right hand side panel in fig . [ fig3 ] we present the possible phase diagram for a hc - bh system with a quantum melting effect near the `` magic '' doping level @xmath119 . in all the cases , the critical doping level for the superfluid formation is determined by the magnitude of the josephson coupling constant . it is worth noting that the bubble crystallization is accompanied by different ( pseudo)gap effects . our interpretation of the phase transition at @xmath120 differs from that in ref .. this temperature is governed by the magnitude of transfer integral , and believed to be a temperature of the emergence of the nonzero magnitude of the modulus of the superconducting order parameter rather than a critical temperature for an insulator to superconductor transition as it is stated in ref .. this conclusion seems to be a result of finite size effects and boundary conditions in qmc calculations despite the authors make use of the most efficient qmc strategy . such problems seem to be typical for a finite - size simulation of many phase transitions . in addition , we should note that mc calculations need substantial increase in lattice size to reproduce quantitatively the long - wavelength physics because the size of skyrmion and skyrmion lattice parameter appear to be new characteristic lengths . the close inspection of the phase diagram in fig.[fig3 ] , where @xmath121 , does not provide the optimistic expectations as regards the high - temperature superconductivity in 2d hc - bh systems , even if the magnitude of the local boson transfer integral were as large as @xmath122 k. nevertheless , the attractively large temperatures @xmath120 of the topological phase separation with the emergence of nonzero local condensate density engender different reasonable speculations as regards its practical realization . the making use of the mean - field approximation together with simplified classical continuous models can hardly provide the quantitative description of a quantum lattice boson system . both quantum effects and the discreteness of skyrmion texture can result in substantial deviations from the predictions of classical model . the continuous model is relevant for discrete lattices only if we deal with long - wave length inhomogeneities when their size is much bigger than the lattice spacing . in the discrete lattice the very notion of topological excitation seems to be inconsistent . at the same time , the discreteness of the lattice itself does not prohibit from considering the nanoscale ( pseudo)spin textures whose topology and spin arrangement is that of a skyrmion.@xcite naturally , the typical continuous models fail to describe properly such short - wave length nanoscopic inhomogeneities . hereafter , we discuss a simple model which seems to catch the main effects of discreteness and quantization . what is the lattice counterpart of the small skyrmion - like bubble domain ? fig . [ fig4 ] presents the schematic view of such a smallest skyrmion - like bubble domain in a checkerboard co phase for 2d square lattice with an effective size of 4 lattice spacings . the domain wall is believed to include as a minimum eight sites forming a ring - shaped system of four dimers each composed of two sites . there are two types of such domains which differ by a rotation by @xmath123 . the formation of such a center seems not to require a big energy . indeed , the simple estimate of a change in potential energy : @xmath124 points to a near cancelation of @xmath0 and @xmath1 contributions . the remarkable feature of the domain is in a rather small magnitude both of scalar potential and electric field inside the 8-site domain wall ( see fig . [ fig4 ] ) . the flip - energy for the dimer dipole moment is estimated to be @xmath125 , compared with that for bare checkerboard co phase ( @xmath126 ) that implies rather subtle competition between @xmath0 and @xmath1 couplings . however , the difference @xmath127 is believed to be always positive and large . in other words , the flip - energy for the dimer dipole may be relatively small . respective dipole fluctuations would result in an effective screening of electrostatic repulsion energy thus providing a stabilization of a bubble - like defect . an important additional mechanism of the domain stabilization in the hc - bh systems with local bosons composed from electron pairs may arise from the electron and lattice polarization effects.@xcite as is well known , the respective energies are comparable in value with the intersite coulomb interaction . probably , namely both these effects might strongly contribute to the domain stabilization energy . on the other hand , the bubble geometry implies the formation of the electrostatic potential well inside the domain wall both for positive and negative charges . it means that the doping into a domain wall stabilizes the domain configuration . such a doping maybe energy costless , while the energy cost of the pseudo - spin - flip in a checkerboard co phase is rather high : @xmath128 , if the neutralizing background is taken into account . with taking into account the kinetic energy ( quantum tunneling ) only inside the 8-site domain wall we shall consider it as a quantum system in an external electrostatic potential field assuming a rigid checkerboard co ordering overall beyond the domain wall . further , taking into account the reasonable relation : @xmath129 , we shall consider the domain wall to be a system of four dimers , or pairs of nearest neighboring sites forming a quantum cluster . transfer integral . the arrows mark the dipole - allowed transitions ( see text for details).,width=321 ] we anticipate the model though being simplified would be very instructive analyzing the role played both by quantum and discreteness effects . let first address a simple two - site , or a dimer system . the effective pseudo - spin - hamiltonian for such a cluster , or a single dimer hamiltonian can be written as follows @xmath130\,+d { \hat s}_{z}^2\ , -\,h_s\,{\hat s}_{z}-\,h_t\,{\hat t}_{z } , \label{h}\ ] ] where @xmath131 is the total pseudo - spin momentum , @xmath132 is an operator that changes pseudo - spin multiplicity , @xmath133 , @xmath134 , @xmath135 . the first two terms in this effective pseudo - spin hamiltonian describe the intra - dimer interactions , while the last two ones describe its coupling with the off - domain - wall surroundings . it is worth noting that the condition @xmath134 means that the effective magnetic field produced by this surroundings turns into zero that provides the particle - hole symmetry of the dimer physics , in particular , for the domain wall doping . actually , we arrive at an effective singlet - triplet model.@xcite both @xmath136 and @xmath137 operators have a rather simple physical sense : the former corresponds to the total `` quantum '' charge of the dimer , while the latter does to the total `` quantum '' dipole moment . strictly speaking , the diagonal order parameters @xmath138 and @xmath139 describe the charge and dipole density , while the off - diagonal order parameters @xmath140 and @xmath141 describe the corresponding phase ordering . it is of primary importance to note that these order parameters are not independent because the respective operators obey the kinematic constraint : @xmath142 stemmed from a simple spin algebra . it should be noted that there are two operators : @xmath143 and @xmath144 $ ] that change the pseudo - spin multiplicity with their matrices being symmetric and antisymmetric , respectively : @xmath145 @xmath146 the hamiltonian ( [ h ] ) points to the competition of s- and t - orders in the ring - shaped domain wall . fig.[fig5 ] shows a step - by - step formation of the energy spectrum of such a two - site cluster , or dimer . the arrows mark the dipole - allowed transitions that could be revealed in optical spectra . the tunnel states @xmath147 and @xmath148 describing purely `` half - filled '' dimer states are mixed due to the electric field with the mixing level governed by the ratio @xmath149 . if @xmath150 , we arrive at classical nel - like `` up - and - down '' dimer state . hereafter , to describe our singlet - triplet quantum pseudo - spin system we start with trial functions @xmath151 where the spin functions @xmath152 in cartesian basis are used : @xmath153 and @xmath154 . the conventional spin operator is represented on this basis by a simple matrix : @xmath155 and for the order parameters one easily obtains : @xmath156 , \langle\{\hat{s}_i\hat{s}_j\}\rangle=2(\delta_{ij}-a_ia_j - b_ib_j ) \label{med}\ ] ] given the normalization constraint @xmath157 . thus , for the case of spin-1 system the order parameters are determined by two classical vectors ( two real components of one complex vector @xmath158 from ( [ wf1 ] ) ) . the two vectors are coupled , so the minimal number of dynamic variables describing the @xmath159 spin system appears to be equal to four . for the dimer as the singlet - triplet center we have additional unconventional t , j - order parameters . for the respective averages we can easily obtain @xmath160 given the real value of @xmath161 parameter we arrive at a simple form:@xmath162 , and @xmath163 . now we may proceed with the inter - dimer coupling in the domain wall . introducing the symmetrized superpositions of s and t vectors , we can write the pseudo - spin hamiltonian of the inter - dimer interaction as follows @xmath164 @xmath165 + \frac{1}{2}(v_{nnn}-t_{nnn})[s_{z}^{2}(a_{1g})- s_{z}^{2}(b_{1 g } ) + \ ] ] @xmath166,\ ] ] where @xmath167 @xmath168 @xmath169 @xmath170 @xmath171 @xmath172 @xmath173 @xmath174 ( see fig.[fig4 ] ) . the chemical potential @xmath175 for the system of four dimers in a domain wall is determined now by the condition : @xmath176 for undoped and singly - doped ( boson / hole ) domain wall , respectively . the respective mean values we can address to be order parameters that describe the subtle structure of a domain wall : as regards the diagonal order @xmath177 specifies the full charge ; @xmath178 and @xmath179 do the electric dipole moments , @xmath180 the component of the quadrupole momentum , and one might introduce the higher order multipole moments . as regards the off - diagonal order we should , in general , proceed with the three types ( @xmath181 , or @xmath182 ) of the s - order , and three types ( @xmath183 , or @xmath184 ) of the t - order , which can be defined as follows : @xmath185 noteworthy to mention the kinematic constraint that couples different order parameters . in the absense of an external magnetic field the energy does not depend on @xmath186 vector , it is restricted only to lie in @xmath35-plane . in other words , we deal with the uncertainty of j - order parameter . the mean - field domain - wall ground state corresponds to the coexistent @xmath187 modes given the negative sign of the transfer integral @xmath188 or @xmath189 modes given the positive sign of the transfer integral @xmath188 . the relation between s- and t - mode weight is specified by the relationship between the @xmath0 transfer integral @xmath190 and electric field @xmath191 . if we assume @xmath192 , then given @xmath193 the dimers have purely @xmath159 ground state , and we arrive at s - type off - diagonal order . in contrast , given @xmath194 we arrive at t - type off - diagonal order . in general , neglecting the st - mixing term leads to two independent phase order parameters . generally speaking , the interference dipole - dipole st - term would result in st - mixing accompanied by the constraint on the phase order parameters with an appearance of a noncollinearity effect . thus we arrive at the conclusion that the symmetry of the order parameter distribution in the domain wall would be specified only by the sign of the transfer integral . in addition , we see that the problem of the order parameter associated with our bubble domain is much more complicated than in conventional bcs - like approach @xcite due to its multicomponent nature . moreover , we deal with a system with different symmetry of low - lying excited states and competing order parameters that implies their possible ambiguous manifestation in either properties . the low - symmetry crystalline electric fields or crystal distortions would result in a mixing of the order parameters with different symmetry . the bubble domain ( fig.[fig4 ] ) yields a simple and instructive toy model to describe such effects . it is worth noting that the flux quantization effects for the bubble domain , in particular , the localizing effect of the magnetic field on the moving bosons , are expected to be observed only for rather large fields . indeed , nanoscopic atomic systems such as a square plaquette with a size of around 10 @xmath195 require a field of @xmath196 tesla for a half flux quantum per plaquette . above we have concerned a simple one - center topological defect . however , in general one has to make use of more complicated topological excitation like a multi - center bp skyrmion.@xcite the question arises , whether such an entity may be described as a system of weakly coupled individual one - center defects ? in practice , it seems to be a rather reasonable approach only for slight deviation from half - filling , when the mean separation between doped particles is much larger than the effective domain size . the bubble domain may be addressed to be well isolated only if its environment does not contain another domain(s ) which could be involved to a `` dangerous '' nearest - neighbor inter - dimer coupling . each domain in fig.[fig4 ] has @xmath197 of such neighbors . hence the concentration of well isolated domains can be written as follows : @xmath198 where @xmath23 is a number of `` dangerous '' neighbors , @xmath199 the boson concentration . the @xmath200 maximum is reached at @xmath201 . in our case @xmath202 , or @xmath203 . with increasing doping the deviation of @xmath200 from the linear law rises . on the other hand , knowing the effective domain area @xmath204 we can roughly estimate the limiting concentration of the single - domain model description to be @xmath205 , @xmath206 . the inter - domain coupling includes both long - range ss- and short - range tt - terms . we should emphasize a strong anisotropy of this coupling . for nearest neighbors along [ 1,0 ] and [ 0,1 ] directions namely the short - range ( dipole - dipole ) tt - coupling would result in an effective suppression of the main s ordering ( see fig.[fig4 ] ) , in contrast with [ 11 ] direction . thus we may conclude that the above mentioned simple continuous model for josephson junction arrays should be strongly modified to describe the multi - domain configurations in 2d quantum hc - bh lattices , both as regards the subtle internal domain structure , the competition of different order parameter , and the anisotropy of josephson coupling . in conclusion , the boson / hole doping of the hard - core boson system away from half - filling is assumed to be a driving force for a nucleation of a multi - center skyrmion - like self - organized collective mode that resembles a system of co bubble domains with a bose superfluid and extra bosons both confined in domain walls . such a _ topological _ co+bs _ phase separation _ , rather than an uniform mixed co+bs supersolid phase , is believed to describe the evolution of hc - bh model away from half - filling . starting from the classical model we predict the properties of the respective quantum system . in frames of our scenario we may anticipate for the hc - bh model the emergence of an inhomogeneous bs condensate for superhigh temperatures @xmath207 , and 3d superconductivity for rather high temperatures @xmath208 . the system is believed to reveal many properties typical for granular superconductors , cdw materials , wigner crystals , and multi - skyrmion system akin in a quantum hall ferromagnetic state of a 2d electron gas . topological inhomogeneity is believed to be a generic property of 2d hard - core boson systems away from half - filling . such a behavior represents a boson counterpart of the so - called _ topological doping _ being a general feature of mott - insulator or 2d fermion hubbard model.@xcite despite all shortcomings , mfa and continuous approximation are expected to provide a physically clear semiquantitative picture of rather complex transformations taking place in bare co system with doping , and can be instructive as a starting point to analyze possible scenarios . first of all , the mfa analysis allow us to consider the antiphase domain wall in co phase to be a very efficient ring - shaped potential well for the localization of a single extra boson ( hole ) thus forming a novel type of a topological defect with a single - charged domain wall . such a defect can be addressed as a charged skyrmion - like quasiparticle which energy can be approximated by its classical value for co bubble domain . it is of great importance to note that domain wall simultaneously represents a ring - shaped reservoir for bose superfluid . unfortunately , we have no experience to deal with multi - center skyrmions as regards its structure , energetics , and stability . it should be noted that such a texture with strongly polarizable centers is believed to provide an effective screening of long - range boson - boson repulsion thus resulting in an additional self - stabilization . nucleation of topological phase is likely to proceed in the way typical for the first order phase transitions . the role played by quantum effects and lattice discreteness has been illustrated in frames of the simplest nanoscopic counterpart of the bubble domain in a checkerboard co phase of 2d hc - bh square lattice . it is shown that the relative magnitude and symmetry of multi - component order parameter are mainly determined by the sign of the @xmath0 and @xmath1 transfer integrals . the topologically inhomogeneous phase of the hc - bh system away from the half - filling can exhibit the signatures both of @xmath2 , and @xmath3 symmetry of the off - diagonal order . the model allows us to study the subtle microscopic details of the order parameter distribution including its symmetry in a real rather than momentum space , though the problem of the structure and stability of nanoscale domain configurations remains to be solved . the present paper establishes only the framework for analyzing the subtleties of the phase separation in a lattice hc - bh model away from half - filling . much work remains to be done both in a macroscopic and microscopic approaches . i acknowledge stimulating discussions with c. timm , s .- l . drechsler , t. mishonov , and the support by smwk grant , intas grant no . 01 - 0654 , crdf grant no . rec-005 , rme grant no . e 02 - 3.4 - 392 and no . ur.01.01.062 , rfbr grant no . 04 - 02 - 96077 . i would like to thank leibniz - institut fr festkrper- und werkstoffforschung dresden where part of this work was made for hospitality . special thanks are to referees for their remarks improving the manuscript . it is worth noting that in frames of bcs - like scenario the symmetry of the order parameter is strictly defined in a momentum space albeit the discussion of different experimental data has usually been performed with a real - space distributed order parameter .

we suppose that the doping of the 2d hard - core boson system away from half - filling may result in the formation of multi - center topological inhomogeneity ( defect ) such as charge order ( co ) bubble domain(s ) with bose superfluid ( bs ) and extra bosons both localized in domain wall(s ) , or a _ topological _ co+bs _ phase separation _ , rather than an uniform mixed co+bs supersolid phase . starting from the classical model we predict the properties of the respective quantum system . the long - wavelength behavior of the system is believed to remind that of granular superconductors , cdw materials , wigner crystals , and multi - skyrmion system akin in a quantum hall ferromagnetic state of a 2d electron gas . to elucidate the role played by quantum effects and that of the lattice discreteness we have addressed the simplest nanoscopic counterpart of the bubble domain in a checkerboard co phase of 2d hc - bh square lattice . it is shown that the relative magnitude and symmetry of multi - component order parameter are mainly determined by the sign of the @xmath0 and @xmath1 transfer integrals . in general , the topologically inhomogeneous phase of the hc - bh system away from the half - filling can exhibit the signatures both of @xmath2 , and @xmath3 symmetry of the off - diagonal order .

0705.0578

recently , we have shown that layered sine - gordon type models are probably not suitable for the description of josephson - coupled layered superconductors , because the linear , confining potential that binds the vortices together can not be obtained from the interaction of the topological excitations of the model , no matter how the interlayer interaction term is chosen @xcite . on the other hand , vortex dominated properties of high @xmath0 layered superconductors and other types of layered materials , e.g. superconducting sandwiches , have already received a considerable amount of attention ( see , e.g. , refs . @xcite ) , and the intuitively obvious connection of sine - gordon models to these materials makes one wonder if at least , a restricted applicability of the layered , field - theoretical model persists . we also observe that recently , there is an increasing interest in the literature @xcite in constructing sine gordon type field theoretical models in order to understand better the vortex dynamics in layered superconducting systems . our aim in this paper to follow this route by constructing a two - dimensional multi - layer sine - gordon type model which can be used to describe the vortex behaviour of magnetically as opposed to josephson - coupled layered superconductors , and to contrast and enhance our recent investigation @xcite . in a two - dimensional ( 2d ) isolated superconducting thin film , the pearl vortices @xcite are naturally identified as the topological excitations and can be considered as the charged analogues of the vortices in a 2d superfluid which generate the kosterlitz thouless berezinski ( ktb ) phase transition @xcite . the logarithmic interaction between the vortices of the superfluid extends to infinity and as a consequence they remain bound below the finite ktb transition temperature ( @xmath1 ) and dissociate above it @xcite . since the pearl vortices carry electric charge , they always remain unbound due to the screening length @xmath2 generated by the electromagnetic field which cuts off the logarithmic interaction @xcite and leads to the absence of any ktb phase transition . however , for realistic finite 2d superconducting films where the lateral dimension of the film can be smaller then the screening length @xmath3 the ktb transition can be restored @xcite . this constitutes an intrinsic finite size effect . in layered materials , the interlayer coupling modifies the 2d picture and leads to new types of topological defects . if the layers are coupled by josephson coupling ( like for many htsc materials ) , the vortex - antivortex pairs on the same layer interact with each other via a logarithmic term for small distances but they feel a linear confining potential for large distances ( see e.g. @xcite and references therein ) . the vortices in neighboring layers always interact via a linear potential which can couple them by forming vortex loops , rings , or vortex `` strings '' piercing all layers . if the layers are coupled by purely magnetic interaction ( e.g. in artificially produced superlattices where the cooper pair tunneling between the superconducting layers is suppressed by relatively large insulating layers ) the topological defects for a system which consists of infinitely many layers are pancake vortices @xcite which undergo a ktb phase transition at @xmath1 . as explained e.g. in ref . @xcite , the josephson coupling can be essentially neglected when the confinement length , i.e. the length scale at which the linear confining potential due to the josephson coupling dominates over the logarithmic interaction due to magnetic effects , is pushed beyond the effective screening length for the logarithmic interaction among vortices . this situation is present when the tunneling between the superconducting layers is suppressed by relatively large insulating layers , and a proposal for a experimental realization has recently been given @xcite . for a finite number @xmath4 of magnetically coupled layers , the pearl type vortex stack @xcite is broken up into a number of coupled pancake vortices of fractional flux @xcite , and this configuration undergoes a ktb - type phase transition at a layer - dependent temperature @xmath5 which is connected with the dissociation of the stack . this result has been obtained on the basis of the entropy method first introduced in the ground - breaking work @xcite . recently , a real space renormalization - group ( rg ) analysis of the case @xmath6 has been performed in ref . @xcite using the dilute gas approximation . a priori , it appears to be rather difficult to generalize this rg analysis for @xmath7 layers . in general , the ginzburg landau ( gl ) theory @xcite provides us with a good theoretical framework in which to investigate the vortex dynamics in thin films and in layered materials . several equivalent models , like field - theoretical , statistical spin models and a gas of topological defects have also been used to consider the vortex properties of films and layered systems . the 2d - gl , 2d - xy and the 2d coulomb gas models ( see e.g. @xcite and references therein ) are considered as the appropriate theoretical background for the vortex dynamics of superfluid films . the field theoretical counterpart is the 2d sine - gordon ( sg ) model @xcite . both kinds of these models belong to the same universality class and produce the ktb phase transition . for superconducting films one has to consider the 2d - gl model in the presence of electromagnetic interactions @xcite or the equivalent gas of topological excitations , the 2d yukawa gas @xcite . the corresponding field theory is the 2d - sg model with an explicit mass term , the massive 2d - sg model @xcite . for josephson - coupled layered superconductors in the case of very large anisotropy one should investigate the layered gl model including the josephson coupling between the layers @xcite ( i.e. the lawrence - doniach model @xcite ) . in case of not too large anisotropy on can use the anisotropic , continuous gl theory @xcite which can be mapped onto the isotropic gl model by an appropriate rescaling method @xcite . the corresponding spin model is the 3d - xy model @xcite and the equivalent gases of topological excitations are the layered vortex @xcite or vortex - loop @xcite gases . there are attempts in the literature to construct the field theoretical countpart of the isotropic model @xcite . in case of strong anisotropy , the layered sine gordon ( sg ) model @xcite has been proposed as a candidate model where the interlayer interaction between the topological defects has been described by a mass matrix which couples the sg fields @xmath8 where @xmath9 and @xmath10 ( n=1, ... ,n ) are one component scalar fields . recently , we showed in ref . @xcite that the layered sg model with the above mass matrix is not apropriate for the description of vortex dynamics of josephson coupled layered superconductors . in case of purely magnetically coupled layered systems , the layered gl model has to be used but excluding the josephson coupling . although the interaction potentials between the topological defects of magnetically coupled layered systems are given in refs . @xcite , no field theoretical model has been proposed for the description of vortex dynamics in a finite system of magnetically coupled superconductors . here , our aim is to open a new platform for considering the vortex dynamics of magnetically coupled layered systems by constructing a multi - layer sine gordon ( mlsg ) type field theoretical model where the two - dimensional sine gordon ( 2dsg ) fields characterizing the layers are coupled by an appropriate general mass matrix , @xmath11 by the exact mapping of the mlsg model onto an equivalent gas of topological defects , we recover the interaction potential given in refs . @xcite and , hence , prove the applicability of the model . we analyse the phase structure of the mlsg model by a differential renormalization group ( rg ) method performed in momentum space , which is in general easier to perform than that in real space , and determine the layer - dependence of @xmath12 . in our field theoretical rg approach , the rg flow can be calculated in one step for an arbitrary number of layers , and the study of the intrinsic finite size effect of thin film superconductors @xcite and of finite layered systems is facilitated . this paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ sec2 ] , we define the multi - layer sine gordon model and show by its exact mapping onto the equivalent gas of topological excitations that it is suitable to describe the vortex dominated properties of magnetically coupled layered superconductors . in sec . [ sec3 ] , a renormalization group analysis of the multi - layer sine gordon model is performed within the framework of the wegner houghton renormalization group method , in momentum space for general @xmath4 , and with a solution that spans the entire domain from the ultraviolet ( uv ) to the infrared ( ir ) . the layer - number dependence of the critical temperature of the multi - layer sine gordon model is determined by using the mass - corrected linearized rg flow . conclusions are reserved for sec . the multi - layer sine gordon ( mlsg ) model consists of @xmath4 coupled two - dimensional sine gordon ( 2d - sg ) models of identical `` frequency '' @xmath13 , each of which corresponds to a single layer described by the scalar fields @xmath10 @xmath14 . its euclidean bare action ( we imply here the sum over @xmath15 ) @xmath16 = \int { \rm d}^2 r \biggl [ { \frac{1}{2}}(\partial_{\mu } \underline\varphi)^{\rm t } ( \partial_{\mu } \underline\varphi ) + v ( \underline\varphi ) \biggr ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] contains the interaction terms @xmath17 with the @xmath18 multiplet @xmath19 . we can choose the fugacities @xmath20 without loss of generality , ensuring that the zero - field configuration is a local minimum of the action ( see chap . 31 of ref . the mass - matrix describes the interaction between the layers and is chosen here to be of the form @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the strength of the interlayer interactions , and the @xmath23 are free parameters . as will be explained below , any choice with @xmath24 for all @xmath25 reproduces exactly the same layer - dependence of @xmath12 as found in refs . @xcite . in this case , the layers can be assumed to be equivalent and , as a consequence , the fugacity @xmath26 for @xmath27 . the most obvious choice fulfilling @xmath24 , namely @xmath28 for all @xmath25 , reproduces the interlayer interaction between pancake vortices given , e.g. , in eq . ( 89 ) of ref . @xcite , and we will restrict our attention to this choice in the following . the mlsg model has a discrete symmetry under the shift of the field variable @xmath29 with @xmath30 where the `` last '' integer @xmath31 is fixed but all the other integers @xmath32 ( @xmath33 ) can be chosen freely ( to see this , one just diagonalizes the mass - matrix ) . the single non - vanishing mass eigenvalue is @xmath34 , and hence the model possesses @xmath35 massless 2d - sg fields and a single massive 2d - sg field . after the diagonalization of the mass matrix by a suitable rotation of the fields , the model thus is invariant under the independent separate shifts of @xmath35 massless fields , but the explicit mass term of the single massive mode breaks the periodicity in the `` massive '' direction of the @xmath4-dimensional internal space . one crucial observation is that the partition function of the mlsg model , whose path - integral formulation reads @xmath36 \exp{\left(-s[\underline{\varphi}]\right)},\ ] ] can be identically rewritten in terms of an equivalent gas of topological excitations ( vortices ) , whose interaction potentials are exactly equivalent to those of refs . @xcite . this finding constitutes a generalization of known connections of the @xmath37-dimensional globally neutral coulomb gas and the @xmath37-dimensional sine gordon model , as discussed in chap . 32 of ref . @xcite , and can be seen as follows . in eq . ( [ mlsg ] ) , one artifically introduces the vectors @xmath38 as projection operators to rewrite @xmath39 , one expands the periodic piece of the partition function ( [ z_mlsg ] ) in a taylor series , and one introduces the integer - valued charges @xmath40 of the topological defects which are subject to the neutrality condition @xmath41 . this leads to the intermediate result , @xmath42 \exp{\left[-\int\!\ ! { \rm d}^2 r \ , \frac{1}{2 } \underline\varphi^{\rm t } \ , ( -\partial^2 + { \underline{\underline m}}^2 ) \underline\varphi + { \rm i } \ , b \ , { \underline\rho}^{\rm t } \ , \underline\varphi \right ] } , \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath43 , and @xmath44 we have thus placed the @xmath45 vortices , labeled by the index @xmath46 , onto the @xmath4 layers , with vortex @xmath46 being placed onto the layer @xmath47 . the gaussian integration in eq . ( [ step1 ] ) can now be performed easily , and the inversion of the matrix @xmath48 can be accomplished by going to momentum space . via a subsequent back - transformation to coordinate space , we finally arrive at the result @xmath49 } \ , , \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath50 represents the kronecker - delta . equation ( [ gte ] ) implies that the parameter @xmath51 in eq . ( [ pepot ] ) can naturally be identified as being proportional to the inverse of the temperature of the gas , @xmath52 . the potentials @xmath53 and @xmath54 are the intralayer and interlayer interaction potentials , respectively . they read [ pot_limit ] @xmath55 \nonumber\\[2ex ] = & \left\ { \begin{array}{cc } -\frac{1}{2\pi } \ln\left(\frac{r_{\alpha \gamma}}{a}\right ) & \quad ( r_{\alpha \gamma } \ll \lambda_{\rm eff } ) \\[2ex ] -\frac{1}{2\pi } \left[\frac{n-1}{n } \ln\left(\frac{r_{\alpha \gamma}}{\lambda_{\rm eff}}\right ) -\ln\left(\frac{\lambda_{\rm eff}}{a}\right)\right ] & \quad ( r_{\alpha \gamma } \gg \lambda_{\rm eff } ) \end{array } \right . \ ] ] where @xmath56 , and @xmath57 \right ) \nonumber\\[2ex ] = & \left\ { \begin{array}{cc } 0 & \quad ( r_{\alpha \gamma } \ll \lambda_{\rm eff } ) \\[2ex ] \frac{1}{2\pi } \frac{1}{n } \ln\left(\frac{r_{\alpha \gamma}}{\lambda_{\rm eff}}\right ) & \quad ( r_{\alpha \gamma } \gg \lambda_{\rm eff } ) \end{array } \right . . \ ] ] @xmath58 stands for the modified bessel function of the second kind , @xmath59 is the lattice spacing which serves as an uv cutoff and an effective screening length @xmath2 is introduced which is related inversely to the non - zero mass eigenvalue of the mass matrix ( [ mass_matrix ] ) , @xmath60 . the relation @xmath61 has been used in the derivation of the asymptotic short- and long - range forms in eqs . ( [ a ] ) and ( [ b ] ) , and only the leading logarithmic terms are indicated ( @xmath62 is euler s constant ) . the interaction potentials ( [ pot_limit ] ) have the same asymptotic behavior as the vortices of magnetically coupled superconducting layers @xcite [ for the intralayer and interlayer interactions see eqs . ( 86 ) and ( 89 ) of ref . @xcite , under the substitution @xmath63 . this observation shows that the mlsg field theory is suitable to describe the vortex dynamics in magnetically coupled layered systems . a few remarks are now in order . ( i ) the prefactor @xmath64 appearing in the intralayer interaction indicates the existence of vortices with fractional flux in the mlsg model . ( ii ) for small distances @xmath65 , the interlayer interaction @xmath66 disappears and the intralayer potential @xmath67 has the same logarithmic behaviour with full flux as that of the pure 2d - sg model ( which belongs to the same universality class as the 2d - xy model and the 2d coulomb gas ) . therefore , the mlsg model for small distances behaves as an uncoupled system of 2d - sg models . ( iii ) for the case @xmath68 , there exists no interlayer interaction , and the intralayer potential is logarithmic for small distances and vanishes for large distances . consequently , there are always free , non - interacting vortices in the model which push the ktb transition temperature to zero . the mlsg model for a single layer reduces to the massive 2d - sg model discussed in refs . @xcite where the periodicity in the internal space is broken and the ktb transition is absent . ( iv ) in the bulk limit @xmath69 , the effective screening length and the interlayer interaction disappear ( @xmath70 , @xmath71 ) , and the intralayer potential has a logarithmic behaviour with full flux , thus the mlsg model predicts the same behaviour as that of the pure 2dsg model with @xmath72 . alternatively , one may observe that for @xmath73 , the effect of the infinitely many zero - mass modes dominates over the effect of the single remaining massive mode entirely , leading to a constant limit for the transition temperature as @xmath74 . for @xmath6 layers , the mlsg model [ with the choice @xmath75 has been proposed to describe the vortex properties of josephson coupled layered superconductors @xcite . however , the above discussed mapping indicates that any layered sine gordon model , whatever be the mass matrix , can be mapped onto an equivalent gas of topological excitations , whose interaction potentials are determined by the inversion of a two - dimensional propagator of the form @xmath76 . any such propagator , upon backtransformation to coordinate space , can only lead to a logarithmic behaviour for the vortex interactions at small and large distances , and consequently , can not possibly reproduce the confining linear long - range intralayer interaction given in eq . ( 8.42 ) of ref . @xcite and in ref . the candidate @xcite for a mass matrix @xmath77 has also been discussed in refs . this candidate interaction is inspired by a discretization of the anisotropic 3d - sg model @xcite , but it can not reproduce the linear confining potential needed for the description of the josephson - coupled case @xcite . the layer - dependent transition temperature of this model is @xmath78 and decreases with the number of layers , and for general @xmath4 , the mass matrix @xmath79 also leads to different short- and long - range intralayer potentials as compared to eq . ( [ pot_limit ] ) and can not be used for the description of magnetically coupled @xmath4-layer systems , either @xcite . finally , let us note that a suitable model for the josephson coupled layered system could probably be constructed if the interlayer interaction term is represented by a compact variable , i.e. , one couple the phase ( compact ) fields between the 2d planes @xcite and not the the dual fields . the above statements on the mlsg model are based on the bare action where the coupling parameters of the theory are fixed . however , only a rigorous rg analysis enables one to construct the phase diagram in a reliable manner . for @xmath6 layers , the phase structure and the vortex properties of the magnetically coupled layered system have already been considered with a real space rg approach @xcite using a two - stage procedure , and a momentum space rg method @xcite on the basis of the dilute gas approximation has also been used . here , we apply a generalized multi - layer , multi - field wegner houghton ( wh ) rg analysis developed by us for the layered sg type models @xcite to the mlsg model with an arbitrary numbers of layers . in the construction of the wh rg equation , the blocking transformations @xcite are realized by a successive elimination of the field fluctuations in the direction of decreasing momenta , in infinitesimal momentum shells , about the moving sharp momentum cutoff @xmath80 ( see ref . the physical effects of the eliminated modes are transferred to the scale - dependences of the coupling constants [ e.g. , @xmath81 . the wh - rg equation in the local potential approximation ( lpa ) for the mlsg model with @xmath4 layers reads @xmath82,\ ] ] where we have defined the dimensionless blocked potential as @xmath83 . we make the following ansatz for the blocked potential , @xmath84 where the scale - dependence is encoded in the dimensionless coupling constants @xmath85 and @xmath86 which are all related to their dimensionful ( no tilde ) counterparts by a relative factor @xmath87 . inserting the ansatz ( [ ansatz ] ) into eq . ( [ wh_rg_n ] ) , the right hand side becomes periodic , while the left - hand side contains both periodic and non - periodic parts @xcite . in order to go beyond the dilute - gas approximation , we calculate a mass - corrected uv approximation of eq . ( [ wh_rg_n ] ) by expanding the logarithm of the determinant in the right hand side of eq . ( [ wh_rg_n ] ) in powers of the periodic part of the blocked potential . because this procedure has been discussed at length in refs . @xcite , we immediately state the result [ cf . ( 43 ) of ref . @xcite ] , @xmath88 with the initial value @xmath89 at the uv cutoff @xmath90 . let us note that in our rg approach the dimensionful @xmath22 and @xmath51 are scale - independent constants . we can immediately read off from eq . ( [ sol ] ) the critical value @xmath91 and the corresponding ktb temperature @xmath92 . the fugacity @xmath93 is irrelevant ( decreasing ) for @xmath94 and relevant ( increasing ) for @xmath95 for decreasing scale @xmath80 ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) . our rg approach provides a consistent scheme to calculate higher order corrections to the linearization in the periodic part of the blocked potential , which is equivalent to higher - order corrections to the dilute - gas approximation . for @xmath68 , the mass - corrected uv scaling law ( [ sol ] ) , obtained for the massive sg model , recovers the scaling obtained in refs . @xcite ( no phase transition ) . in conclusion , we propose the multi - layer sine gordon ( mlsg ) lagrangian as a quantum field theoretical model for the vortex properties of magnetically coupled layered superconductors . note that the mlsg model can not be assumed to belong to the same universality class as the layered ginzburg landau model @xcite , which entails a discretization of the ginzburg landau model in one of the spatial directions . the mapping of the mlsg model onto the gas of topological defects is used to clarify the suitability of the mlsg model to magnetically coupled layered systems . we investigate the scaling laws for the mlsg model using a functional formulation of the wegner - houghton rg approach in the local potential approximation . the linearization of the rg flow in the periodic part of the blocked potential ( and not in the full potential ) enables us to incorporate the effect of the interlayer interaction into the mass - corrected uv scaling laws , which improve the dilute gas approximation . the mass - corrected wegner houghton uv scaling laws indicate that for general interlayer interactions of the type of eqs . ( [ mass_matrix ] ) , one finds two phases separated by the critical value @xmath96 , where @xmath4 is the number of layers . this determines the layer - dependence of the ktb transition temperature @xmath97 in full agreement with refs . perhaps , further investigations of the mlsg model ( e.g. , beyond the local potential approximation ) and other generalizations of the momentum - space rg studies presented here could enrich our understanding of the layered structures . the authors acknowledge insightful discussions with professor j. zinn justin and thank professor j. r. clem for valuable remarks . i.n . would like to acknowledge the kind hospitality of max planck institut , heidelberg on the occasion of a number of guest researcher appointments , and u.d.j . acknowledges support from the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft with the heisenberg program ( contract je285/31 ) . s.n . ackowledges support via the oveges program of the national office for research and technology of hungary and the support by the univesritas foundation , debrecen .

in this paper , we propose a quantum field theoretical renormalization group approach to the vortex dynamics of magnetically coupled layered superconductors , to supplement our earlier investigations on the josephson - coupled case . we construct a two - dimensional multi - layer sine - gordon type model which we map onto a gas of topological excitations . with a special choice of the mass matrix for our field theoretical model , vortex dominated properties of magnetically coupled layered superconductors can be described . the well known interaction potentials of fractional flux vortices are consistently obtained from our field - theoretical analysis , and the physical parameters ( vortex fugacity and temperature parameter ) are also identified . we analyse the phase structure of the multi - layer sine gordon model by a differential renormalization group method for the magnetically coupled case from first principles . the dependence of the transition temperature on the number of layers is found to be in agreement with known results based on other methods .

cond-mat0210255

almost a century ago , schottky pointed out that if electrons are emitted as discrete particles independently of each other , current fluctuations are to be expected with the noise power : @xmath0 , with @xmath1 the elementary charge and @xmath2 the mean current . @xcite this phenomenon , called the `` shot effect '' by schottky , was later observed in vacuum tubes @xcite in nice agreement with his prediction . during the last two decades , the shot effect ( now called shot noise ) has been discovered and intensively studied in mesoscopic phase - coherent conductors . @xcite in a quantum point contact ( qpc ) , for instance , the current - noise power was found to be @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the transmission probability ( for one - channel transmission ) . in this formula , the noise is suppressed by the factor @xmath5 relative to the schottky result , thereby predicting zero noise for perfect transmission ( see experimental evidence @xcite ) . in both cases , in qpcs and vacuum tubes , the granularity of charge is manifested in the shot noise , although the source of randomness is different : @xcite in qpc , the randomness appears in the transmission process due to the quantum partitioning between the incoming and outgoing states ( the incoming carriers are noiseless ) . in contrast , in vacuum tubes , the randomness is an inherent property of the emitter caused by thermal fluctuations . an interesting question then arises : is it possible to observe the quantum partition noise in electron emission , in the same way as in qpcs , with the noise power suppressed below the @xmath6 value ? the related question whether the shot noise in schottky s vacuum tube is classical has been addressed recently by schnenberger , oberholzer , sukhorukov , and grabert . @xcite the authors showed that for the vacuum tube parameters typical for the earlier stages of development of vacuum electronics , @xcite the quantum partitioning in electron emission is absent , and consequently the shot noise observed in schottky s vacuum tubes is classical . in this paper we show that in new generation electron emitters , scaled down to the nanometer dimensions , shot noise much smaller than the schottky noise , due to a quantum partitioning effect , is observable . moreover , two different sources of randomness thermal agitations and quantum partitioning may act together governing the electron emission noise . @xcite a rapidly growing field of nanoscale electronics suggests to us various examples of electron emitters in which this phenomenon may be tested : the nanotube field emitters , @xcite the composite emitters coated by wide - band - gap , low - work - function , and/or negative - electron - affinity materials , @xcite diamondlike emitters , @xcite among others . we start by considering the electron emission as a quantum scattering problem within the landauer - bttiker framework . the transverse and longitudinal motion of electrons are assumed to be separable , so that one can specify the quantum channels associated with transverse modes , and define the scattering states . the equation for the mean current in a phase - coherent conductor attached to two electron reservoirs with different chemical potentials reads @xcite @xmath7 where @xmath8 are the energy distribution functions at the left ( @xmath9 ) and right ( @xmath10 ) reservoirs , @xmath11 is the matrix of the transmission amplitudes , @xcite and the trace is taken over all the transmission channels at energy @xmath12 . for definiteness , the left reservoir is considered as an emitter , and the right reservoir , to which an external positive bias is applied , as a collector . we assume that the `` quantum conductor '' between the two reservoirs could also be a vacuum gap . at the surface of the emitter between the emitter - vacuum or emitter - semiconductor interface a potential barrier exists , which limits the current and scatters the emitted electrons ( only elastic scattering is assumed ) . thus the transmission matrix @xmath11 is referred to the scattering on the potential barrier . the zero - frequency current - noise power for a two - terminal quantum conductor is given by @xcite @xmath13 \ , { \rm tr}({\bf t}^{\dag}{\bf t}{\bf t}^{\dag}{\bf t } ) \\ + [ f_l ( 1 - f_r ) + f_r ( 1 - f_l ) ] \ , [ { \rm tr}({\bf t}^{\dag}{\bf t } ) - { \rm tr}({\bf t}^{\dag}{\bf t}{\bf t}^{\dag}{\bf t } ) ] \},\end{gathered}\ ] ] with @xmath14 the unit of conductance . for sufficiently high biases , all the states in the collector at energies corresponding to the occupied states at the emitter ( that contribute to the emission ) . hence one can take @xmath15 . in this case , the steady - state emission current in the basis of eigen - channels becomes @xmath16 where @xmath17 are the transmission probabilities associated with @xmath18 quantum channels at energy @xmath12 . hereafter , we drop the subindex @xmath9 at the occupation numbers @xmath19 , since only the emitter contact contributes to the current and noise . the noise power ( [ stwo2 ] ) for the unidirectional injection becomes @xmath20 \nonumber \\ & \equiv s_i^{\rm em } + s_i^{\rm part}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this formula describes the spectral density of current fluctuations of an electron emitter . it unifies two sources of randomness : ( i ) the probabilistic occupation of states in the emitter ( through the function @xmath19 ) and ( ii ) the probabilistic reflection and transmission at the interface barrier ( through the probabilities @xmath21 ) . the first source of randomness is intimately related to intrinsic thermal agitations of the emitter and can be associated with the first term in eq . ( [ sone ] ) . since @xmath22 , this term is related to a thermal broadening of the occupation numbers at the fermi level . note that it vanishes at zero temperature , but dominates in the absence of partitioning when all transmission coefficients @xmath21 are either @xmath23 or @xmath24 , and hence can be interpreted as the _ emission shot noise_. the second source of randomness associated with the last term in eq . ( [ sone ] ) is caused by quantum partitioning and the fact that charge is carried by discrete portions ( shot effect ) . it only contributes for transmission probabilities @xmath25 , it does not vanish at zero temperature , and can be called the _ partition shot noise_. it is clear that both noise sources act together and can not be separated , in general . @xcite for future analysis , it is convenient , however , to introduce the notations for the emission noise @xmath26 and the partition noise @xmath27 according to the above discussion . equation ( [ sone ] ) can be used to calculate the noise power of the emitter with an arbitrary number of quantum channels . the problem can be simplified by assuming that the interface of the emitter is plane and its transversal area is large compared with wavelength ( a large number of channels ) . then , the summation over the transverse channels can be replaced by integration over the transversal energy @xmath28 , which can be performed giving @xmath29\ , \ln[1+e^{(e_f - e)/k_bt}]\ , de \right\},\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath30 is the sharvin conductance , @xmath31 is the fermi energy , @xmath32 is the cross sectional area , and @xmath33 is the transmission probability at the longitudinal energy @xmath34 . now , we can verify eqs . ( [ sone ] ) and ( [ si_fd ] ) for two practical cases : thermionic emission and field emission . when the potential barrier is wide on the scale of the wavelength , one can neglect tunneling . in this case , an appreciable emission current can be achieved , for instance , by heating the emitter , so that thermally excited electrons escape above the barrier . the transmission probability takes the values 1 for @xmath35 and 0 for @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is the barrier height ( quantum reflection for overbarrier electrons is negligible for a sufficiently smooth potential ) . thus the partition term vanishes and the noise contains only the emission ( thermionic ) contribution : @xmath38 where the summation is taken for open channels only . for wide multichannel emitters with equilibrium fermi - dirac electrons [ see eq . ( [ si_fd ] ) ] , eq . ( [ sone_em ] ) is reduced to @xmath39.\ ] ] this formula gives the @xmath6 schottky value , whenever @xmath40 , which is a condition for a nondegenerate maxwell - boltzmann injection ( richardson - laue - dushman regime of thermionic emission @xcite ) . for a degenerate injection , @xmath41 , the noise is suppressed below the schottky value by the factor @xcite @xmath42 , where @xmath43 , and @xmath44 is the fermi - dirac integral of index @xmath45 . this suppression is caused by fermi correlations imposed by the pauli exclusion principle ( see ref . for the details ) . note that for metallic cathodes used in vacuum tubes , @xcite the work function is about 4 ev , which is much larger with respect to @xmath46 , so that only nondegenerate injection with the full shot noise is possible , @xcite as was observed in the experiment . @xcite the potential barrier at the emitter can be narrowed by applying a strong electric field , so that electrons can be pulled out from the cold emitter via quantum tunneling . @xcite in this case , the partition noise is expected to be the dominating source of noise : @xmath47 by applying this formula again to fermi - dirac electrons in a wide emitter under the condition @xmath48 , we obtain the noise which is independent of temperature , @xmath49\ , \left(1-\frac{e}{e_f}\right)\ , de.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the fowler - nordheim regime of field emission , @xcite when the fermi energy of the emitter is much below the barrier top , the transmission probability for electrons at the fermi level ( which mostly contribute to the emission ) is small , @xcite @xmath50 . it can be verified that in this regime , eq . ( [ si_fd0 ] ) gives the schottky @xmath6 law . summarizing these two examples , one can conclude that the schottky noise , which is the noise produced by independently injected electrons ( poissonian process ) , may occur under two physically different conditions : @xcite ( i ) the low occupation numbers , @xmath51 , when electrons are initially poissonian and remain poissonian after passing the barrier with whatever probability ; ( ii ) the low transmission probability , @xmath50 , when the incoming electrons may be initially noiseless , but after tunneling through the barrier , the outgoing flow becomes diluted and obeys a poissonian statistics . although in both cases , the noise power is given by the schottky law @xmath0 , in the former case its value is sensitive to the temperature , while in the latter case it is not . this fact may be used in the experiment to distinguish these two mechanisms . now it is clear under which conditions one should expect a deviation from the @xmath6 law . it is the case when both the occupation numbers @xmath19 and the transmission probabilities @xmath4 are not small with respect to 1 . this is precisely the situation that may occur in novel field emitters . the requirements of strong electric currents under low voltages led research interests towards low - work - function materials ( low potential barriers ) and sharp emitter tips ( narrow potential barriers ) . for instance , extremely high electric fields @xmath52 are achieved in nanotube emitters due to a geometric field enhancement in high - aspect - ratio tips . @xcite for combinations of work function , field , and temperature parameters in many of these emitters , an appreciable part of electron emission originates from energy levels in the vicinity ( below and above ) of the potential barrier . to estimate the noise in this case , one should use general formulas given by eq . ( [ sone ] ) or ( [ si_fd ] ) , in which the transmission coefficients must be known in a wide energy range , below and above the barrier . in this paper , we consider the model that consists of a simplified triangular representation of the barrier with only two parameters : the height of the barrier @xmath37 and the slope determined by the electric field @xmath53 : @xmath54 the potential barrier height @xmath37 is equal to the electron affinity for semiconductors , and for metals it is a sum of the work function and the chemical potential . @xcite we neglect the rounding off the barrier due to the image interaction . although this may cause some quantitative error , such a consideration enables the exact solution of the schrdinger equation in terms of airy functions and thus an exact evaluation of the electron transmission probability in the whole energy range including the barrier top , which is not allowed in the wkb scheme . @xcite the transmission probability @xmath33 for an arbitrary incident energy @xmath55 ( below and above the barrier top ) can be represented by a unique analytical formula ( see the appendix ) . = 8.0 cm to illustrate the results for the current emission noise , consider the emitter at @xmath56=300 k with @xmath57 in which , for simplicity , the electron effective mass for the emitter and the barrier is the same . the noise spectral densities @xmath58 calculated from eq . ( [ si_fd ] ) are plotted in fig . [ fsi - f ] as functions of the electric field @xmath53 for different barrier heights ( work functions ) @xmath59 . the zero - field limit @xmath60 corresponds to the emission over a rectangular - step barrier with no tunneling , for which @xmath61 . in this limit , the noise power is determined by the relative position of the fermi level with respect to the barrier top . for @xmath62 ev , the injection is nondegenerate and , consequently , @xmath63 and @xmath64 . their sum gives the full schottky noise : @xmath65 . since the transmission probabilities are not exactly equal to 1 for all the energies @xmath35 ( there is a finite reflection due to a sharp potential change ) , both terms contribute to the noise . it is also seen from fig . [ fsi - f ] that for @xmath66 ev , the noise at low fields is expected to be smaller than the schottky value . this is the case of a degenerate injection , for which the quadratic terms @xmath67 in the two contributions do not cancel , in contrast to the previous case of a nondegenerate injection . the noise suppression effect here originates from the fermi statistical correlations under the condition of current partitioning . although the case @xmath68 ev for the field emitters is likely to occur , @xcite the most typical case in practice is the opposite condition @xmath69 ev . in this case , at low fields , the current noise is the full schottky noise . our prediction is that when the electric field increases , there exists a threshold value , at which the noise starts to drop down the schottky value ( see fig . [ fsi - f ] ) . it can be explained by the fact that as the electric field increases , the barrier becomes thinner , the transmission probability increases , and the noise starts to drop down due to the @xmath5 factor [ see eq . ( [ si_fd0 ] ) ] . it is worth noting that this drop is a quantum phenomenon . the quantum uncertainty of whether the electron has been transmitted through or reflected by the barrier is a source of randomness which produces the partition noise @xmath70 . for pure classical transmission , when the probabilities of transmission at different energies are either 0 or 1 , the quantum partition noise does not appear and the noise of the emitted electrons is governed by the first term on the right - hand side of eq . ( [ si_fd ] ) which gives the @xmath6 law with no drop . we would like to highlight that the suppression effect caused by quantum partitioning is independent of the degeneracy of electrons . even for a fully degenerate case at zero temperature , for which electrons initially are noiseless , after passing the barrier they acquire a partition noise with a suppression level sensitive to the transmission coefficient . the threshold value for the electric field , for which the shot - noise suppression becomes clearly visible , may be roughly estimated from eq . ( [ te ] ) by taking the value for the tunneling probability at the fermi energy to be @xmath71 . it is seen from fig . [ fsi - f ] that for the work function 4 ev , this threshold field is about @xmath72 , for the work function 3 ev , it is @xmath73 , and for 2 ev , it is @xmath74 , values that do not seem unrealistic . @xcite the threshold field may also be decreased by choosing the emitter with a high effective mass of electrons ( e.g. , of heavy - fermion materials ) , since the transmission probability ( [ te ] ) is sensitive to the ratio of the effective masses . the barrier lowering due to a self - consistent potential redistribution may also decrease the threshold field value . note that for negative affinity materials , the quantum suppression of shot noise should be observed for arbitrarily small fields . in conclusion , we have calculated the shot noise power of electron emission under the action of strong applied electric fields . within the landauer - bttiker scheme , we have shown that the emission noise is governed by two different stochastic processes acting together thermal agitations and quantum partitioning . the analytical formula for the noise power , which unifies these two sources of randomness , has been analyzed . this formula , in the limit of a wide potential barrier ( no tunneling ) , describes the shot noise of thermionic emission , which may be either poissonian for a nondegenerate injection ( richardson - laue - dushman regime ) , or non - poissonian for a degenerate injection . under field - emission conditions , the noise recovers the full schottky noise in the fowler - nordheim regime . our results indicate that in order to observe the shot - noise suppression in field emitters below the schottky level , there are at least two possibilities : ( i ) by lowering the work function @xmath75 ; then , the noise starts to be sub - poissonian below some value @xmath75 at arbitrarily small fields ; ( ii ) for high - work - function materials , by increasing the electric field @xmath53 at the emitter tip , e.g. , by employing the nanotube emitters ; then , the noise starts to be sub - poissonian above some threshold value @xmath53 . note that precisely in the regime when the shot noise deviates from the schottky law , the fowler - nordheim plots [ @xmath76 vs @xmath77 no longer follow the straight lines . @xcite the measurements of the noise suppression value ( with respect to the poissonian value ) may provide additional data on the work function and the electric field at the emitter tip important information not available from the current - voltage characteristics alone ( especially for new unknown materials ) . @xcite since the noise is sensitive to the injection energy profile , @xcite the noise measurements may serve as a substitution for direct field - emission energy profile measurements . it is clear why the quantum partitioning has not been observed in noise measurements on metal - cathode vacuum tubes a long time ago , at the earlier stages of the development of vacuum electronics . @xcite in those experiments , the electric - field values at the emitter were no more than 0.003 v / nm , which is too low to see the effect on 4 ev work function materials . we are not aware of shot - noise measurements under field emission at stronger fields . the typical values obtained from old literature @xcite indicate fields of about 25 v / nm , and in novel nanotube field emitters they are even greater . @xcite we believe that in such conditions , the quantum suppression of shot noise is observable . besides the nanotube emitters , the suitable candidates to observe the shot - noise suppression could be the composite emitters coated by wide - band - gap , low - work - function , and/or negative - electron - affinity materials , @xcite or diamond - like emitters . @xcite we thank eugene sukhorukov for valuable discussions . this work has been partially supported by the ministerio de ciencia y tecnologa of spain through the `` ramn y cajal '' program , and by the dgicyt and feder under grant no . bfm2002 - 01267 . the transmission coefficient can be found as a solution of the scattering problem for a one - dimensional potential barrier , since it depends only on the energy of the longitudinal motion @xmath55 . the time - independent schrdinger equation is given by @xmath78 in which the potential @xmath79 is defined by eq . ( [ vx ] ) . we assume that , in general , the electron effective mass @xmath80 in eq . ( [ schrod ] ) may differ for the emitter and the barrier : @xmath81 for @xmath82 and @xmath83 for @xmath84 . the solutions of the schrdinger equation for the constant potential are the plain waves , while for the linear potential the solutions are given by the airy functions : @xmath85 + i\,{\rm ai}\ , [ k_a(w - x ) ] \right\ } , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath86 is the momentum of the incident electron , @xmath87 is the characteristic momentum in the arguments of the airy functions dependent on the field , and @xmath88 is the coordinate where the airy functions change from monotonic to oscillatory behavior ( for positive values , @xmath89 is just the barrier width at energy @xmath55 ) . since we calculate the transmission , the solution @xmath90 corresponds to the outgoing wave at @xmath91 . @xcite from the continuity of the wave function and the current conservation at the interface , we obtain the transmission amplitude @xmath92},\ ] ] where @xmath93 and the prime on the airy functions indicates a derivative with respect to the argument @xmath94 . the incident and transmitted current densities corresponding to the wave functions ( [ psi ] ) are found as @xmath95 and @xmath96 . therefore , the transmission coefficient for a given incident momentum @xmath45 is @xmath97 , which finally gives the emission noise can also be suppressed by long - range coulomb correlations induced by the space charge , as was also observed in vacuum tubes ( ref . ) . we do not address this effect in this paper . for the case when the partitioning is absent , the theory of the noise suppression by coulomb correlations has been developed in : o.m . bulashenko , j.m . rub , and v.a . kochelap , phys . b * 61 * , 5511 ( 2000 ) , * 62 * , 8184 ( 2000 ) ; o.m . bulashenko and j.m . rub , phys . rev . b * 66 * , 045310 ( 2002 ) . it should be noted that the wkb evaluation of the transmission coefficient , traditionally used to calculate the emission currents , is not suitable for the calculation of the partition noise . the wkb gives an appreciable error in the vicinity of the classical turning points , in particular , for electron energies near the barrier top ( see ref . ) . strictly speaking , in order to avoid contradiction with the definition of the scattering states , the boundary conditions for the airy functions must also be specified at the collector . it is assumed , however , that the applied bias is sufficiently high , so that the potential details at the collector do not affect the electron tunneling at the emitter .

we have analyzed the shot noise of electron emission under strong applied electric fields within the landauer - bttiker scheme . in contrast to the previous studies of vacuum - tube emitters , we show that in new generation electron emitters , scaled down to the nanometer dimensions , shot noise much smaller than the schottky noise is observable . carbon nanotube field emitters are among possible candidates to observe the effect of shot - noise suppression caused by quantum partitioning .

hep-th9702166

in the late 70 s , montonen and olive discovered that a given four dimensional gauge theory might be described using different sets of elementary fields @xcite . the fields in one of this set create the standard perturbative spectrum of the theory ( photon , w bosons , quarks , ) , while the fields in the `` dual '' set correspond to the solitonic states ( dyons ) . an example of such a phenomenon was observed even before in some two dimensional theories @xcite . since then , a natural and exciting question arose : can we find theories where the description in terms of the solitonic states is the same ( same field content and symmetries in the lagrangian ) as the description in terms of the perturbative states ? answering this question requires to understand the strong coupling behaviour of the gauge theories under study , since exchanging electrically charged perturbative states with magnetically charged solitonic states amounts to inverting the gauge coupling constant due to the dirac quantization condition . this was out of reach in the 70 s , though some important progress was made . first , it was realized that the natural arena for electric - magnetic duality was yang - mills theories with extended supersymmetries @xcite . second , it was pointed out that in order to have dyons of spin 1 , which could be the dual of the w bosons , @xmath1 supersymmetry seemed to be required @xcite . actually , an exact electric - magnetic duality , combined with the dirac quantization condition , implies that the @xmath8 function must vanish . this is indeed the only case where the electric coupling @xmath9 and the magnetic coupling @xmath10 , being constant , have the same behaviour under the renormalization group flow . the @xmath1 theory is known to be conformally invariant at the quantum level , perturbatively @xcite as well as non - perturbatively @xcite . at the perturbative level , this property is shared with some @xmath2 theories @xcite , which are believed to be finite even non - perturbatively at least when the rank of the gauge group is one . the latter theories are strongly believed to have , together with the @xmath1 theory , an exact electric - magnetic duality symmetry ; we will study them below . there are various ways to test these duality conjectures . one of them , advocated in @xcite , consists of looking at the ( hyper)elliptic curve from which the low energy physics can be deduced , and check whether some sensible duality transformations can be defined in order to insure exact electric - magnetic duality symmetry . another approach has been to look at the free energy @xcite . but the most popular test certainly is to determine the content of a particular sector of the hilbert space , the bps sector , and to check whether it is compatible with duality @xcite . to study solely the bps states is not too restrictive . actually , all the perturbative and known stable solitonic states are bps states . moreover , this is in general a very accurate test . for instance , it is well known that the bps spectra of the asymptotically free @xmath2 theories certainly do not have the same symmetries as the associated ( hyper)elliptic curve . there are also some technical reasons to study the bps spectra . an exact quantum mass formula is known for these states , stemming from the fact that they lie in small representations of the supersymmetry algebra and thus saturate the bogomolnyi bound @xcite . the semiclassical quantization can give reliable results when one can go continuously from weak coupling to strong coupling without altering the stability of the states , which is the case for instance in the @xmath1 theory . and , what is maybe their most intriguing property , it seems that the bps spectra can be computed completely once one knows the low energy structure of the theory , that is all the information about these spectra seems to be contained , in a very hidden way , in the ( hyper)elliptic curve . in this paper , i will study in detail the bps spectra of two @xmath2 theories having zero @xmath8 function . the first one will be the so(3 ) gauge theory with one flavour of bare mass @xmath11 , which reduces to the @xmath1 theory when @xmath12 , and the second one will be the su(2 ) gauge theory with four hypermultiplets whose bare masses will be taken to be @xmath13 , @xmath14 . the fact that these seemingly very different theories can be treated in parallel stems from the fact that their low energy effective action are formally identical . i will use a method whose spirit originated in @xcite and which is completely understandable in the framework of non perturbative field theory la seiberg - witten @xcite . this will lead to a natural and rigorous proof that the spectra of both the @xmath1 and the @xmath2 theories are self - dual when the bare masses are zero . we will also see how the duality can still work in the massive theories though , as it will be shown , the spectra are no longer in general self - dual _ at a given point _ in the moduli space . the plan of the paper is as follows . in section 2 some generalities on the theories under study are recalled . particular emphasis is put on the quantum numbers carried by the solitonic states , as suggested by a semiclassical analysis , and it is explained why they are compatible with an exact duality symmetry . in section 3 , after a short presentation of the seiberg - witten curves whose exactitude will be our unique , very mild hypothesis , some of the physical ideas which are at the basis of the present work are presented . this leads to a limpid understanding of _ why _ states having any magnetic charges must exist in the theory , and also gives a flavour of what the spectra in the massive cases look like . it appears that in some regime , the magnetic charge is quantized much as if it were a periodic variable , while only one value of the electric charge is allowed . though the spectrum does not appear in general as being self - dual at a given point in moduli space , it is argued that it is nevertheless perfectly compatible with an exact s duality of the massive theories . it is also pointed out that semiclassical reasonings might be able to account for the curious disappearance of all but very few states in some regions of moduli space , a phenomenon first discovered in @xcite at strong coupling . in order to prove the complete sl@xmath15 invariance of the spectra , the consideration of theories with non zero bare @xmath16 angle is needed . this is done in section 4 . we also discuss the appearance of superconformal points in some particular theories . in section 5 , the uniqueness of the states is proven , as required by duality . in section 6 , a general presentation of the curves of marginal stability , across which the bps spectra may be discontinuous , these curves are then used in section 7 to rigorously establish the existence of all the @xmath0 states , for @xmath3 and @xmath4 relatively prime integers , in the massless theories . finally , in section 8 , a general physical argument is presented which shows that the theories under study must have at least an exact @xmath5 duality symmetry . in particular , the bps spectra of the _ massless _ theories must be invariant under the monodromy group @xmath5 of the _ massive _ theories . we then deduce that the vector @xmath6 states exist in the massless @xmath7 theory . in appendix a , the computation of the seiberg - witten periods is presented , and in appendix b the curves of marginal stability are used to prove the existence of some particular states required by duality in the massive theories . as already noted in the introduction , one easy way to check whether a given theory may be , or can not be , self - dual , is to look at the quantum numbers carried by the states which are supposed to be transformed into each other by an electric - magnetic rotation . for example , the w bosons must be the dual of a charged particle having spin one in the one monopole sector . the very existence of such a spin one solitonic state is already a non trivial test of duality and was proven in @xcite . the main goal of this paper will be to extend this kind of result to all the electric and magnetic quantum numbers . in addition to the electric and magnetic charges , there is another abelian quantum number , which we will call the @xmath17 charge , which plays an important r^ ole , since it also appears in the central charge of the supersymmetry algebra and thus in the bps mass formula . the aim of this section is to explain the relations that may exist between these quantum numbers , and also to discuss the way one should compute the @xmath17 charges . the theory whose matter content is one @xmath2 adjoint `` quark '' hypermultiplet will be called hereafter the so(3 ) theory . this matter multiplet consists in two chiral @xmath18 superfields @xmath19 , which correspond in terms of ordinary fields to one dirac spinor @xmath20 and two complex scalars @xmath4 and @xmath21 in the adjoint representation of the gauge group . the microscopic lagrangian also contains one yang - mills @xmath2 multiplet ( one vector field @xmath22 , two majorana spinors @xmath23 and @xmath24 and one complex scalar @xmath25 ) . when the bare mass @xmath11 of the matter multiplet is zero , we recover the @xmath1 theory . when @xmath26 , the moduli space of vacua is a coulomb branch where the gauge symmetry is spontaneously broken down to u(1 ) by a non zero higgs vacuum expectation value , @xmath27 . when @xmath12 and @xmath1 , we have other equivalent coulomb branches , permutted by the su(4)@xmath28 symmetry , corresponding to the other scalar fields having a vev . in addition to the u(1)s associated to the electric @xmath29 and magnetic @xmath30 charges , the theory has an abelian u(1 ) global symmetry @xmath31 , @xmath32 , with corresponding charge @xmath17 . classically , the central charge of the supersymmetry algebra is @xmath33 where @xmath9 is the gauge coupling constant . semiclassically , the electric charge @xmath29 is @xmath34 , @xmath35 integer , up to terms coming from cp violation ( like a standard witten term proportional to the bare @xmath16 angle ) . the magnetic charge is given by the dirac quantization condition , @xmath36 for an integer @xmath37 . we will loosely call in the following the integers @xmath35 and @xmath37 the electric and magnetic charges . the mass of a bps state @xmath38 will then be @xmath39 for instance , an elementary quark @xmath40 has a tree level mass @xmath41 . the exact quantum formula for @xmath42 can be found . it was shown in @xcite that it can be cast in the form @xmath43 here @xmath44 is the dual variable of @xmath45 and can be , at least in principle , computed very explicitly as a function of a gauge invariant coordinate @xmath46 on the moduli space ( @xmath46 is @xmath47 up to a constant ) @xcite . at the tree level , we have @xmath48 , where @xmath49 is a very convenient combination of the gauge coupling @xmath9 and the theta angle @xmath16 which has a simple transformation law under s duality . note that @xmath50 is not renormalized since the @xmath8 function is zero . together with the mass @xmath11 and the coordinate on the moduli space @xmath46 , it is the only parameter in the theory . the constants @xmath51 in ( [ cc ] ) are only indirectly related to the physical @xmath17 charges @xcite , but can be computed very explicitly , see below . this theory differs from the preceding one by its matter content . now we have four @xmath2 hypermultiplets @xmath52 , @xmath53 , transforming in the fundamental representation of the gauge group su(2 ) . we will limit ourselves , for reasons that will become clear in section 3 , to the case where two of these hypermultiplets are massless , say @xmath14 , and the other two have identical masses @xmath13 . the global non abelian symmetry of the theory is then @xmath54 ( concerning the occurence of the universal cover spin(4 ) of so(4 ) instead of so(4 ) itself for the symmetry associated with the two massless hypermultiplet , see the next subsection ) . this shows that some states are likely to come in doublets in this theory , as we will see later . the moduli space of vacua has again a coulomb branch where dyons can exist , in addition to higgs branches which we will not study . the formula ( [ cccl ] ) is still valid along the coulomb branch , but now we will have in general @xmath55 , @xmath35 integer , instead of @xmath56 , because the gauge group is really su(2 ) and no longer so(3 ) in this theory . the elementary quarks have @xmath57 for instance . moreover , the @xmath17 charge will correspond to the transformations @xmath58 , @xmath59 for the quarks @xmath60 and @xmath61 simultaneously . at a given point on the moduli space of vacua , the parameters of the theory will be @xmath11 and a generalized unrenormalized gauge coupling @xmath62 . note the difference between this definition and the corresponding one in the so(3 ) theory . the advantage of this choices will become apparent in section 3 . moreover , in order to keep the formula ( [ cc ] ) in the same form in the two theories , we will define here the parameter @xmath45 by @xmath63 . these different sets of conventions were already used in @xcite and allow to make the formal similarity between the two theories under study very explicit , see section 3 . from the semiclassical point of view , the solitonic states appear as bound states of a supersymmetric quantum mechanics describing the low energy dynamics of interacting dyons @xcite . the dynamical variables of this supersymmetric quantum mechanics correspond to zero modes of the elementary fields of the quantum field theory . in a @xmath37 monopole configuration , there are @xmath64 real bosonic zero modes . the four zero modes that are present for all @xmath65 correspond to the center of mass motion ( three modes ) and to the global electric charge ( one periodic mode ) . the other @xmath66 zero modes describe the relative motions and electric charges . to these bosonic zero modes are associated some fermionic one . from callias index theorem @xcite we know that the two adjoint majorana spinors of the @xmath2 vector multiplet will give @xmath67 complex zero modes @xmath68 , @xmath69 , carrying spin @xmath70 . the other fermionic zero modes come from the matter fermions and differ in the so(3 ) and @xmath7 theory . there , the adjoint fermions in the matter multiplet will yield @xmath67 additional complex fermionic zero modes @xmath71 . these zero modes carry spin @xmath70 and @xmath17 charge @xmath72 . the quantization of the four @xmath73 and @xmath20 fermionic zero modes corresponding to @xmath74 yields to a spectrum of @xmath75 states . when @xmath12 , this correspond to a full short @xmath1 multiplet . this shows that monopoles @xmath76 may be the dual of the w bosons . when @xmath77 , there are some additional zero modes . however it will become clear in the following sections that the @xmath77 stable bound states that exist in the theories under study all have the same quantum numbers as the @xmath76 monopoles ( in some sense , they can be generated by a continuous deformation of the @xmath76 monopoles or of the elementary excitations ) . this means that for the stable states , the additional zero modes play no rle , and thus we will discard them in the following . when the mass @xmath11 is set to a non zero value , the @xmath1 multiplet splits into three parts corresponding to states having the same @xmath17 charge and thus the same mass . more precisely , from the sixteen states of the @xmath1 multiplet we get : eight states corresponding to one @xmath2 vector multiplet , which may be the dual to the @xmath2 w bosons @xmath78 ; four states corresponding to one - half of a cpt self conjugate @xmath2 hypermultiplet ( the other half is obtained by quantization in the @xmath79 monopole sector ) , which may be the dual of one component of the adjoint elementary quark , say @xmath80 ; and four states which may be the dual to @xmath81 . this is summarized in table 1 . [ states1 ] .the sixteen states of a @xmath1 multiplet , with their spin and @xmath17 charge . @xmath82 is the a priori unknown @xmath17 charge of the state @xmath83 . the @xmath2 content of the @xmath1 multiplet is also indicated . [ cols="<,<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] in the bps mass formula ( [ bpsmass],[cc ] ) appears , in addition to the electric and magnetic quantum numbers @xmath35 and @xmath37 , a term @xmath84 proportional to the mass . the computation of @xmath51 for each bps state is crucial in order to have quantitative predictions for the physical masses , as we will need in the following . however , the meaning of the constant @xmath51 is not clear at first sight . it can not be identified with the physical @xmath17 charge , because the latter has a non trivial dependence on the higgs expectation value due to the spontaneous breaking of cp invariance . this is , for the @xmath17 charge , a similar effect as the witten phenomenon for the electric charge @xcite , and was discussed in @xcite . there it was shown that the non trivial part of the physical @xmath17 charge is actually automatically included in the periods @xmath45 and @xmath44 , and is responsible for the constant shifts these variables can undergo under duality transformations . this possibility is related to the fact that @xmath45 and @xmath44 are period integrals of a meromorphic one form having poles with non zero residus @xcite , see appendix a. the constants @xmath51 are thus simply a constant part of @xmath17 not already included in @xmath44 and @xmath45 . they can always be determined by consistency considerations , see section 4.4 and the discussion in section 5 . in this section , some arguments are presented which lead to a clear physical understanding of _ why _ states with any magnetic charges must exist in the theories we are studying , in the context of quantum field theory alone . we will heavily rely on the seiberg - witten low energy effective action , encoded in the elliptic curve presented in @xcite . thus this section begins with a brief review of this result , emphasizing that it is by now established at a high level of rigour , and above all _ does not _ rely on any duality assumption . this short survey will also serve to set our notations . because of @xmath2 supersymmetry , the variables @xmath86 and @xmath45 , which not only completely determine the form of the low energy effective action ( up to two derivatives and four fermion terms ) , but also enter the bps mass formula ( [ bpsmass ] ) , must be analytic functions of the gauge invariant coordinate @xmath46 on the coulomb branch @xcite . these analytic functions have branch cuts and sl@xmath15 monodromies due to singularities caused by charged particles becoming massless for some values of @xmath46 . the number and type of singularities occuring on the coulomb branch can most easily be found by analyzing the theory in a limit where the mass @xmath11 is very large compared to some scale @xmath87 which represents the dynamically generated scale of the asymptotically free theory we obtain after integrating out the supermassive hyper(s ) . quantitatively , this limit corresponds to @xmath88 with @xmath89 let us focus for concreteness on the so(3 ) theory . in this regime , and at scales of order @xmath87 , the theory must look like the pure gauge theory , since the ultra - massive quarks must decouple . the singularity structure of the pure gauge theory was already greatly deduced in @xcite , and it was recently studied at an even higher degree of rigour @xcite . the result is that , without making any duality assumption , one can prove that we have two singularities at strong coupling whose monodromy matrices are conjugate to @xmath90 . moreover , we must have at scales of order @xmath11 , where a tree level analysis must be valid when @xmath91 , an additional singularity coming from an elementary quark becoming massless . the monodromy matrix is here again conjugate to @xmath90 , as can be deduced with the help of the @xmath8 function of the low energy theory @xcite , or even directly in the microscopic theory @xcite . actually , the monodromy transformation for @xmath92 around a singularity at @xmath93 due to a state @xmath94 becoming massless is @xmath95 where @xmath96 searching for an elliptic curve of the form @xmath97 , where @xmath98 is a polynomial of degree three , whose moduli space will reproduce the singularity structure described above , is then a fairly simple mathematical exercice . the solution is unique and given by @xcite @xmath99 where @xmath100 and @xmath101 the discussion above was for the so(3 ) theory , but as noted in @xcite , the singularity structure and thus the curve is exactly the same in the @xmath102 theory , provided one chooses bare masses @xmath103 and @xmath104 for the matter hypermultiplets , uses the different sets of convention introduced in section 2.1 , and expresses the curve in terms of a dimensionless constant @xmath50 which is @xmath105 only at the tree level but receives one loop as well as non perturbative corrections @xcite . though this useful relation will allow us to study the so(3 ) and the @xmath102 theories in parallel , be careful that it is only a formal one . for instance , only even , @xmath106-instantons corrections exist in the @xmath102 theory , whereas all @xmath107-instantons contribute in the @xmath108 theory . with our conventions , these corrections will both be proportional to @xmath109 . there are also important differences at the level of the spectra . one of them is that in the so(3 ) theory , a state @xmath110 may correspond to a vector multiplet ( w bosons ) , whereas in the @xmath102 theory the ws are labeled as @xmath111 . moreover , due to the flavour symmetry , the singularities in the @xmath7 theory are produced by su(2 ) doublets of hypermultiplets becoming massless . the general form of the monodromy matrices ( [ monomat ] ) remains valid since if the solution for the periods is noted @xmath112 for the so(3 ) theory , it will be @xmath113 for the @xmath7 theory . the parameter @xmath46 appearing in ( [ curve ] ) is a good gauge invariant coordinate on the coulomb branch , which is related to the physical expectation value @xmath114 by a formula of the form @xmath115 the @xmath116 correspond to instanton corrections @xcite . we conventionally extracted the combination @xmath117 because it tends towards the physical parameter @xmath118 under the renormalization group flow towards the pure gauge theory or the @xmath119 massless theory ( [ rg ] ) . the transformation properties of the parameters @xmath120 of the theories under s duality can easily be read from the curve ( [ curve ] ) . under a general sl@xmath15 transformation given by a matrix @xmath121 we have @xmath122 the fact that these strong - weak coupling transformations can be coherently implemented on the curve ( [ curve ] ) is already a non - trivial evidence that the theories may be self - dual @xcite . below , we will investigate the transformation properties of the variables @xmath86 and @xmath45 ( or equivalently of the electric @xmath123 and magnetic @xmath124 charges ) . this will give rise to predictions on the bps spectra . checking that these predictions are indeed true will be the main goal of the forecoming sections . in the remainder of section 3 , we will set the bare @xmath16 angle to zero . the very interesting physics associated with the possibility of having a varying real part in @xmath50 will be considered in section 4 . to guess what the analytic structure ( position of the singularities and of the branch cuts ) looks like , it is simplest to choose the parameters so that we are not far away from the pure gauge theory ( or massless @xmath125 ) , where we easily control what is going on . at strong coupling , we have two singularities on the real axis , at points @xmath126 and @xmath127 such that @xmath128 , with an analytic structure already worked out in @xcite . moreover , at weak coupling , we have a quark becoming massless at @xmath129 , with the following asymptotics for @xmath86 and @xmath45 : @xmath130 the exact location of the singularities @xmath131 can be found by setting the discriminant of the curve ( [ curve ] ) to zero , @xmath132 [ figure1 ] = 14.7 cm we have @xmath133 . we choose the position of the branch cut for the logarithm appearing in the asymptotics ( [ asympq ] ) in such a way that it does not disturb the analytic structure of the pure gauge theory . this is the most natural choice , since the existence of a singularity at a scale @xmath134 can not influence the physics at scale @xmath87 . in figure 1 are also indicated the quantum numbers of the particles becoming massless . note that due to a `` democracy '' between the dyons @xcite , the most general choices for the electric and magnetic charges of these states are @xmath135 where @xmath136 corresponds to the singularity @xmath137 and @xmath35 is any integer . our choice is @xmath138 . note also that due to the cuts , the particle becoming massless at @xmath126 is described by two different sets of integers , @xmath139 or @xmath140 , depending on whether one looks from the @xmath141 or @xmath142 half - plane . this shows that one must introduce two different monodromy matrices at @xmath126 , @xmath143 the other monodromy matrices are @xmath144 it is now possible to study the transformation properties of @xmath112 ( or equivalently of @xmath145 ) under duality . the naive guess would be that @xmath92 transforms exactly according to the corresponding sl@xmath15 matrix @xmath146 acting on the parameters of the microscopic theory as in ( [ dualt ] ) . however , we will see that this is not true in general . we must introduce an sl@xmath15 matrix @xmath147 which acts on the low energy effective action ( i.e. @xmath44 and @xmath45 ) while @xmath146 acts on the microscopic parameters . this subtlelty stems from the fact that the monodromy group associated with the curve ( [ curve ] ) is @xmath5 , the subgroup of sl@xmath15 consisting in the matrices congruent to the identity modulo 2 . the only straightforward and correct statement that can be done is thus that @xmath148 mod 2 . moreover , in the massive theories , @xmath44 and @xmath45 can also pick up some constants under a duality transformation . this is allowed by the form of the bps mass formula ( [ bpsmass],[cc ] ) , since a shift in @xmath44 or ( and ) @xmath45 can be reabsorbed in a shift of @xmath51 . a very similar and related phenomenon occurs when one is studying the duality transformations of the low energy theory @xcite , but one must keep in mind that by now we are studying duality transformations of the whole , microscopic , theory . let us be more concrete . what we want to deduce is a formula relating the dual theory solution characterised by the parameters @xmath149 given by ( [ dualt ] ) and whose periods are @xmath150 to the original solution described by @xmath151 . let us focuss in this section on the transformation @xmath152 . the analytic structure of @xmath153 can be readily deduced from the one of @xmath112 depicted in figure 1 . indeed , as @xmath154 , @xmath155 and @xmath156 , the effect of the duality transformation will simply be to exchange the singularities at @xmath129 and @xmath126 while the singularity at @xmath127 remains fixed . the dual theory thus has singularities at exactly the same points as the original theory ( a direct consequence of the self - duality of the curve ( [ curve ] ) ) , but the quantum numbers of the states becoming massless at a given point , as well as the position of the branch cuts , are changed , see figure 2 . [ figure2 ] = 14.7 cm this is enough to deduce that @xmath157 the shifts by @xmath158 come from the fact that a dyon is exchanged with a quark , and these two states have different @xmath51 . moreover , the s duality transformation does not simply exchange @xmath45 and @xmath44 ( up to a sign , and up to the shifts ) . this is not surprising since the state becoming massless at @xmath159 is @xmath160 in both formulations , and this state is not self - dual ( is not an eigenvector of s ) . second , to eliminate the cut between @xmath159 and @xmath161 in the dual formulation ( and thus recover the same structure for the cuts as in the original formulation ) , it is necessary to perform an sl@xmath15 transformation , given on one side of the cut by the monodromy @xmath162 . this also explains why the transformation law depends on the sign of @xmath163 . we are by now in a position to state precisely what the duality @xmath85 implies for the dyon spectrum . these predictions will be tested in the following . at a very general level , suppose you postulate that the theories described by the variables @xmath112 and @xmath164 are equivalent . if @xmath165 where @xmath166 is an sl@xmath15 matrix and @xmath167 and @xmath168 are @xmath169-valued constant sections ( this is the most general transformation law we will encounter ) , then the existence of a state @xmath170 of charge @xmath51 in the theory @xmath112 will imply the existence of a state @xmath171 of charge @xmath172 in the theory @xmath164 with @xmath173 the @xmath174 product denotes the standard symplectic product , @xmath175 the formula ( [ galtrans2 ] ) is a straighforward consequence of the bps mass formula ( [ bpsmass ] ) . let us apply ( [ galtrans2 ] ) to the s transformation @xmath176 described by ( [ periodstrans ] ) . suppose that you have a state @xmath145 in the theory at given @xmath46 , @xmath50 and @xmath11 . this state may be a vector or a hyper multiplet of @xmath2 supersymmetry , and lie in a given representation of the flavour group . then s duality gives a prediction for the spectrum of the theory whose parameters are @xmath177 . if @xmath142 , we must have there a state @xmath178 , in a similar @xmath2 multiplet as the original state . the flavour quantum numbers may be changed as discussed in section 2.2 . if @xmath141 , the state predicted by duality will be @xmath179 . it is very important to realize that these predictions of duality relate theories having different parameters , even at the self - dual point @xmath180 . thus a priori they say nothing about the dyon spectrum of a given theory ( i.e. , at fixed @xmath46 , @xmath50 and @xmath11 ) . one may be tempted to argue that , due to the stability of the bps states , the parameters can be varied continuously without changing the spectrum . this means that a state which exists in the theory @xmath177 will also exist in the theory @xmath120 . this reasoning is indeed correct when @xmath12 , but is wrong in the massive case , due to the presence there of curves of marginal stability , accross which otherwise stable bps states become degenerate in mass with multiparticle states . on these curves , the decay of bps states is possible . we will investigate these decays in the following . their mere existence implies that _ the self - duality of a general @xmath2 theory does not entail that the spectrum of bps states is self - dual at a given point on the moduli space . _ let us now penetrate at the heart of our problem : is there an easy way to understand why the spectra of the massless theories should be self - dual ? can we readily imagine what the spectrum of the massive theories look like ? there is a regime where the second question can be easily answered , at least partially . by choosing the parameters as indicated in ( [ rg ] ) , we can integrate out the quarks having a bare mass , and we are thus left with the pure gauge theory ( for so(3 ) ) or with the su(2 ) theory with two massless flavours . the spectra of these theories are well - known @xcite . discarding for the moment the states having @xmath181 , which can have arbitrarily high physical masses when @xmath182 , two regions in the coulomb branch must be distinguished . indeed , to the possible decays of @xmath183 states into other @xmath183 states corresponds a unique curve of marginal stability is associated a whole family of curves . ] @xmath184 which looks like an ellipse and contains the singularities @xmath185 and @xmath159 @xcite , see figure 3 . [ figure3 ] = 14.7 cm it can be shown that inside the curve ( in the strong coupling region @xmath186 ) only the two bps states which become massless at @xmath126 or at @xmath127 can be present @xcite . these are @xmath187 and @xmath188 ( for this latter state , two different descriptions in terms of electric and magnetic quantum numbers are necessary , due to the non trivial analytic structure @xcite ) . outside the curve , in what we call the weak coupling region @xmath189 , the bps spectrum can be understood in different ways . the most natural certainly is to perform a semiclassical analysis , which is valid here because of asymptotic freedom ( in the context of the full , finite , theory , this means that we are considering a region of the coulomb branch where @xmath190 ) . this analysis first tells you that the perturbative states , created by the fundamental fields , must be present . in the so(3 ) theory , we have the w bosons @xmath191 and the photon @xmath192 which lie in vector multiplets . in the @xmath119 theory we again have the w bosons , now represented as @xmath193 , the photon , but also the elementary quarks @xmath194 and @xmath195 . beyond this perturbative spectrum , we have a solitonic spectrum . in the one monopole sector , we can construct all the states @xmath196 . the fact that all the integers @xmath123 are realized simply comes from the quantization of the periodic zero mode associated with electric charge rotations . statements about higher magnetic charges would be much harder to do . it was shown in @xcite that no state with @xmath197 exists , but a complete analysis for @xmath198 seems by now impossible , for the explicit form of the multimonopole metric is not known in general in these cases . however , there is another method , initiated in @xcite , which consists in remarking first that the spectum in @xmath199 must be invariant under the transformation @xmath200 this can be shown by transporting the state @xmath201 along a closed path encircling the two singularities and which does not cross @xmath202 , so that the state remains stable ( see figure 3 ) . in this operation , we cross the cut @xmath203 and thus should perform an analytic continuation of the periods @xmath86 and @xmath45 in order to insure that the physical mass of the state varies continuously . an analytic continuation @xmath204 across a cut will in general be related to the main solution @xmath92 by a relation of the form ( [ galtrans1 ] ) ( @xmath168 is indeed @xmath169-valued because the residues of the seiberg - witten differential form are @xmath205 , see appendix a ) . this shows that a state represented by @xmath94 on the one side of the cut will be represented by @xmath206 on the other side , see ( [ galtrans2 ] ) . for the cut @xmath203 , we will have @xmath207 and @xmath208 ( or the inverse matrix depending on whether we turn clockwise or counterclockwise ) , which indeed generates the transformation ( [ scinv ] ) . since the states @xmath160 and @xmath209 must be present ( they are responsible for the singularities ) , we immediately deduce that all the states @xmath196 are also present , for any integer @xmath123 . the reader might think that this is really a roundabout mean to show that electric charge is quantized . however , this reasoning also provides a statement about the @xmath210 sectors , powerful enough to show that no state with @xmath210 can exist . indeed , if such a state @xmath201 would exist , it would be associated with the whole tower of states @xmath211 , for any integer @xmath212 , angle shifts by mean of which you can not show that all these states exist at the same time . ] and _ one of these states will inevitably becomes massless _ somewhere on the curve @xmath202 since @xmath213 takes all real values between 0 and 2 on this curve @xcite . this would produce an additional singularity on the coulomb branch which does not exist . the greatest virtue of this kind of reasoning is that one can generalize it to other cases . we have just studied the rg flow ( [ rg ] ) towards the pure gauge ( or @xmath119 ) theory . it would be as natural to study the s dual of this rg flow , which would correspond to @xmath214 where @xmath215 this is inherently a strong coupling limit where the semiclassical method can not be applied . the solution for the dual pure gauge ( or massless @xmath119 ) theory is given by @xmath216 , and its analytic structure has already been worked out , see figure 2 . it is of course very tempting to try to repeat the analysis already made for the original theory . however , we can not generalize the reasoning at once because the position of the branch cuts are now completely different . the fact that we will nevertheless obtain a spectrum in complete accordance with duality is a nice evidence that s duality is indeed correct . the aim of this subsection is to work out the bps spectra implied by the analytic structure depicted in figure 2 . it is convenient to use , instead of @xmath216 , the periods @xmath217 this simply amounts to setting @xmath51 to zero for the two states @xmath110 and @xmath160 becoming massless . we will note with an uppercase @xmath146 the @xmath51 charge computed with the new variables , @xmath218 we have again a curve of marginal stability @xmath219 , which coincides with @xmath202 because of ( [ periodstrans ] ) . [ figure4 ] = 14.7 cm the coulomb branch is thus separated into two regions . the one inside the curve will be called in this context the weak coupling region @xmath220 and is the dual of the strong coupling region @xmath221 one had previously . outside the curve , we will have the strong coupling region @xmath222 . these names deserve some comments . in any case , one should keep in mind that the bare gauge coupling of the whole ( finite ) theory is very large in the limit ( [ rgdual ] ) . thus , by strong or weak coupling , we only refer to the effective coupling which governs the low energy physics . moreover , even in @xmath220 for instance , the effective theory may be strongly coupled ( it is near @xmath159 since there a magnetically charged particle is massless ) . the point is that the regions in @xmath220 where the coupling is strong can always be joined to other regions in @xmath220 where the coupling is weak , the dyon spectrum remaining unchanged . indeed , the _ electric _ effective coupling is zero at @xmath161 where the quark is massless . this suggests that the bps spectrum might be probed in the vicinity of @xmath161 by using standard , `` semiclassical , '' approximation schemes , since we do have in this region a small parameter in the original , `` electric , '' theory . actually , if duality is correct ( and we will prove that its predictions indeed are concerning the dyon spectrum ) , the physics should be the same in the weakly coupled region surrounding @xmath161 in figure 4 as in the strongly coupled region surrounding @xmath185 in figure 3 , and we should be able to account for the `` strong coupling '' jumps of the bps spectrum seen in @xcite by using such methods . however , we will not try to do that here . let us rather apply our method to the weak coupling spectrum @xmath223 . it contains of course the states @xmath160 and @xmath110 , which are responsible for the singularities and thus exist on both sides of the curve . we will now show that no other state , having @xmath224 , can exist . this can be understood by studying the variations of @xmath225 along the curve @xmath226 . @xmath225 is related to @xmath213 by the formulas ( [ newsol ] ) and ( [ periodstrans ] ) , and @xmath213 varies monotonically from 0 to 2 when one follows @xmath226 clockwise starting from and ending at the singularity where @xmath110 is massless . this immediately implies that @xmath225 takes all values between @xmath227 and 1 in the upper half plane , and all values between 1 and @xmath228 in the lower half plane . thus any state @xmath201 existing in @xmath229 will become massless somewhere on @xmath226 , at the point where @xmath230 , and then must be either @xmath110 or @xmath160 . this is in perfect agreement with s duality . when looking at the strong coupling spectrum , the complications come from the fact that one must consider analytic continuations across the cuts @xmath231 and @xmath232 . we then need to introduce two different descriptions @xmath233 and @xmath234 in terms of electric and magnetic quantum numbers of the _ same _ physical spectrum @xmath235 , depending on whether we are in the upper or lower half plane . this is satisfactory from the point of view of duality , see section 3.3 . quantitatively , a state @xmath201 in @xmath236 will be @xmath237 after crossing the cut @xmath232 and @xmath238 after crossing the cut @xmath231 . by looping around the curve of marginal stability , taking care of remaining in @xmath239 , we thus immediately deduce that @xmath234 must be invariant under the subgroup of sl@xmath15 generated by @xmath240 : @xmath241 applying this transformation to the states @xmath110 and @xmath160 , which we know must exist , will then generate states having _ any _ magnetic charge : @xmath242 actually , this shows that all the states dual to the @xmath196 states of the original theory will be present . moreover , to each state @xmath196 corresponds one and only one state in the dual theory , since there the states are in one to one correspondence with states becoming massless . are there any other states with @xmath224 ? if so , let @xmath201 be such a state in @xmath243 . if @xmath244 , it is the state @xmath110 which indeed exists for it is responsible for one of the singularity . , @xmath245 can exist since they would modify the structure of the singularity at @xmath161 . ] otherwise , let us consider the ratio @xmath246 . this ratio necessarily is in the interval @xmath247-\infty , 1[$ ] , since otherwise the corresponding state would become massless somewhere on the curve @xmath226 ( note that we are working in the lower half plane and thus we see only half of the curve ) . as explained above , in the upper half plane the same state is described by other electric and magnetic quantum numbers . crossing the cut @xmath248 , we will obtain another ratio @xmath249 , which must be in the interval @xmath2471,+\infty [ $ ] unless the particle becomes massless somewhere on the coulomb branch . one can return in the lower half plane by crossing the cut @xmath250 , and obtain again a new ratio @xmath251 . by repeating this operation , we obtain two homographic sequences @xmath252 and @xmath253 , @xmath254 with the following important property : if , for some @xmath255 , are obtained by looping counterclockwise around @xmath226 . ] @xmath256 or @xmath257-\infty , 1]$ ] , then the state @xmath201 we started from must be one of the states already obtained above ( see ( [ provspec ] ) ) . it is elementary to check that this is always the case , except if @xmath258 . this case corresponds , in the so(3 ) theory , to the dual of the w bosons , and is represented by @xmath259 in @xmath236 and by @xmath260 in @xmath261 . in the @xmath102 theory , we would again have , in @xmath236 , the state @xmath259 , now interpreted as being the dual of the elementary quarks , and also @xmath262 , interpreted as being the dual of the w. up to now , we did not take into account eventual decays of @xmath245 states into @xmath263 states along the path depicted in figure 4 , although this path can cross curves of marginal stability corresponding to such decays . however , the states @xmath264 have a mass of order @xmath11 , whereas the states @xmath224 are likely to have a mass of order @xmath87 in the region surrounding the singularities @xmath127 and @xmath129 we are considering . since in the rg flow , @xmath182 while @xmath87 is fixed , the decays are impossible and the curves of marginal stability simply indicate that the inverse decay reaction from a @xmath264 to a @xmath224 state is possible . one might put forward the fact that states having @xmath264 but arbitrarily high electric and magnetic charges could have a mass of order @xmath87 due to a subtle compensation of the terms @xmath265 and @xmath266 in the bps mass formula . however such fine tuning , which is indeed possible , can only occur for some very special values of @xmath123 and @xmath124 and in some very special and small regions in the @xmath46-plane . nothing prevents us to avoid these special points and to cross the curve of marginal stability nearby , where the @xmath264 state again have a mass of order @xmath11 . i wish here to point out that , though we have considered the possibility of these `` fine tuning '' points , they are very likely to be unphysical . indeed , if states producing these `` fine tuning '' points would exist , the theory would not have a well defined field theory limit under the ( dual ) rg flow . we have thus obtained the following results : states with any magnetic charges , dual to the dyons @xmath267 , indeed exist , with the correct multiplicities . thus , though the positions of the branch cuts are completely different in the original and in the dual theories , the deduced spectra are perfectly compatible with duality . however , we have not yet proven that the states corresponding to @xmath268 are really present ; we simply know that they may be . this point will be investigated in appendix b. in the preceding section , we have shown using simple arguments that stable states having any magnetic charge , which are required by s duality , indeed exist . we were studying theories with non zero bare masses , but it is very tempting to think that these states can be continuously deformed while remaining stable when @xmath269 and thus are at the origin of the existence of states having any magnetic charge in the massless theories as well . however , we will not obtain in this process all the states required by duality in the massless theories . for instance in the so(3 ) ( @xmath1 ) theory s duality implies the existence of all the states @xmath201 with @xmath123 and @xmath124 relatively prime . up to now , we only have the states @xmath270 with @xmath271 , and it is not difficult to realize in the context of the semiclassical approach @xcite that once you have one of these states , then you will also have all the other states @xmath272 , for any integer @xmath212 . actually , the missing states should come from configurations where states having any @xmath35 and @xmath37 relatively prime are massless at the singularities . the fact that such configurations must exist is clearly a necessary condition for the self - duality of the theories , and does not follow straightforwardly from the sl@xmath15 invariance of the curve ( [ curve ] ) . we saw above that for any imaginary value of @xmath50 ( @xmath273 ) , the singularities are produced by states having @xmath274 or @xmath275 alone . one must then study cases where @xmath276 and find a mechanism to understand how the quantum numbers at the singularities can change . this is similar to a phenomenon which is known to occur for instance in the massive su(2 ) asymptotically free theories , where semiclassical quarks must `` transmute '' into monopoles in order to account for the singularity structure at strong coupling @xcite . however , there can be an important difference between this kind of transmutation and the one we will see at work below . we will realize that two kinds of transmutations can occur . in the first kind , the quantum numbers of the state are changed according to a matrix of the form ( 8) . we will see in the next subsections that this is the only kind of transmutation that can occur in the theories under study in this paper , because singularities in the moduli space never coincide , see ( [ singpos ] ) . in the second kind of transmutation , the state transforms according to a matrix which is not of the form ( 8) ( note that , in any case , there are many of them , since the matrices ( 8) are all conjugate to some power of @xmath277 ) . these transmutations of the second kind are directly related to the necessity for two ( or more ) singularities to coincide for some special values of the parameters @xcite . these special points are known to lead to superconformal theories @xcite . let us come back to our problem . we will soon show that the quantum numbers at the singularities can only be changed by matrices belonging to the _ monodromy _ group @xmath278 ( in the cases under study , we will see that any matrix of @xmath279 can be generated ) . it is also clear that a necessary condition for the theories to be self - dual is that any state , related to the original states becoming massless by a _ duality _ group transformation , must become massless for some value of the coupling . if the @xmath136 denote the electric and magnetic quantum numbers of the particles becoming massless in the original configuration , we see that the theory can be self - dual only if @xmath280 where @xmath281 denotes the _ duality _ group . for our purposes , @xmath282 , @xmath283 , @xmath284 and @xmath285 . we thus have to check whether any @xmath0 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 relatively prime , can be generated by acting with a @xmath5 matrix on one of the three states @xmath209 , @xmath160 or @xmath286 . this is indeed true because sl@xmath287 and that @xmath288 is generated by three transpositions whose corresponding matrices ( already described mod 2 in section 2.2.2 ) can be chosen in order to map a `` fundamental '' state , say @xmath110 , exactly into the three states @xmath110 , @xmath160 and @xmath286 we have at our disposal . let us start from a configuration , characterized by a certain value of the bare coupling @xmath290 and of the bare mass @xmath11 , and whose analytic structure is of the same type as the one described in figure 1 . we will allow the monodromy matrices @xmath291 to be of the most general form , provided they satisfy the fundamental consistency conditions @xmath292 to these monodromy matrices correspond states becoming massless , characterized by their electric and magnetic quantum numbers @xmath293 and @xmath51-charge @xmath294 . note that ( [ consistency ] ) implies via ( [ monomat ] ) , amongst other relations of the same type , @xmath295 actually , as we will only consider configurations which are sl@xmath15 transforms of the original one depicted in figure 1 , sl@xmath15 symplectic invariant relations can be checked or deduced using @xmath296 , @xmath297 , @xmath298 and @xmath299 . some useful ones are @xmath300 we must also have @xmath301 now , let us vary continuously @xmath50 from @xmath290 to @xmath302 . during this operation , the singularities , and with them the branch cuts , will move on the coulomb branch , as depicted in figure 5 . [ figure5 ] = 14.7 cm unavoidably , the singularity at @xmath161 will cross the cut @xmath303 $ ] ; at this moment its quantum numbers are changed . according to ( [ mono],[galtrans2 ] ) , we will have @xmath304 the cut originating at @xmath161 will also sweep up one of the two singularities , and then change the quantum numbers there . we choose to change the singularity at @xmath185 ( see figure 5 ) because it is the only case which leads to an analytic structure at @xmath305 which is perfectly similar to the one at @xmath290 , and this is convenient for our purposes . the ambiguity associated with the position of the branch cut originating at @xmath161 is further discussed in the next subsection . as @xmath139 sees the original cut produced by @xmath306 , whereas @xmath140 sees the cut produced by @xmath307 , we will have @xmath308 finally , by using the consistency relations ( [ consistency],[consistency2],[consistency3 ] ) , we see that at @xmath309 we are in essentially the same configuration as at @xmath310 , up to a @xmath311 transformation and to a rotation and dilatation in the @xmath46 plane . quantitatively we have @xmath312 thus we have shown that we can change the quantum numbers of the singularities with the matrix @xmath311 ( the @xmath51 charges being also changed according to ( [ galtrans2 ] ) ) . performing @xmath311 transformations is not enough to prove sl@xmath15 invariance . we need an additional transformation , which can be found by studying the analytic continuation @xmath314 exactly along the lines of the preceding subsection . we will not repeat this argument here , but we will rather introduce another idea , which is maybe more heuristic , but has the merit of showing that the structure of the low energy effective action can imply the _ equivalence _ of theories related by some transformations of the monodromy group . we will elaborate more on this kind of argument in section 8 . the point is that by sweeping up the @xmath46 plane with the branch cut originating at @xmath161 , as shown in figure 6 , we can generate the transformation : would generate @xmath315 which is equivalent to @xmath316 due to the relations ( [ consistency ] ) . ] @xmath317 [ figure6 ] = 14.7 cm doing this on the original configuration of figure 1 is innocent since it will generate a trivial @xmath318 transformation , which is interpreted as an unphysical relabelling of the electric quantum numbers @xmath35 . it simply corresponds to a shift in the @xmath16 angle , which when combined with the change in @xmath35 will leave the physical electric charge and other physical observables unchanged . this shows that the position of the branch cut originating at @xmath161 is purely conventional when @xmath319 , and by continuity this ambiguity should be preserved even when the @xmath316 matrix is general ( we will see in the next subsection that any @xmath316 conjugated to @xmath318 by a @xmath5 matrix can be generated by analytic continuation ) . note that we performed the transformation at _ fixed _ @xmath46 , @xmath50 and @xmath11 . in the original configuration where @xmath319 , this renders very explicit the fact that the transformation @xmath320 is unphysical . is unphysical . however , this is not that obvious in this framework , and we will limit ourselves to transformations of the type of @xmath318 . ] this also shows that the physical interpretation of the parameter @xmath50 is no longer the same after analytic continuation : if we choose to still use @xmath50 even after the @xmath16 angle shift , the real part of @xmath50 clearly will no longer be @xmath321 ( or @xmath322 ) . this is even more striking when @xmath316 is general . then , the transformation mixes the electric and magnetic charges in a non trivial way , still at fixed @xmath50 . this is not contradictory to the dirac quantization condition . again , this shows that the duality transformation associated with @xmath316 links together two theories which are physically equivalent and thus can be labelled by the same parameters . of course , the physical interpretation of @xmath50 in the two equivalent theories will not be the same . similar remarks also apply to @xmath46 . to close this discussion , note that the ambiguity in the interpretation of @xmath50 we deal with in this subsection is related to the fact already mentioned in subsection 3.2 that the sl@xmath323 matrix @xmath147 which acts on @xmath112 coincides with the sl@xmath15 matrix @xmath146 which acts on @xmath50 and @xmath46 , _ only up to monodromy transformations . _ this suggests that @xmath50 can only be defined modulo @xmath5 and thus that the structure of the low energy effective action implies that the theory has at least an exact @xmath5 duality symmetry . we will see in section 8 that this can be understood on physical grounds , at least heuristically . let us come back to our original problem : can we generate any @xmath5 transformation ( up to a sign ) by combining the two elementary transformations ( [ m3trans],[m1trans ] ) described in the previous subsections and that we will denote abstractly @xmath324 and @xmath325 ? suppose that we execute the following sequence of transformations , @xmath326 starting from the configuration where the monodromy matrices are given by ( [ matrices],[matrices2 ] ) . one must take care of the fact that , after each step , the monodromy matrices are conjugated by the corresponding transformation . for instance , the transformation @xmath327 will indeed generate a @xmath328 transformation on the variables @xmath86 and @xmath45 . however , the @xmath329 transformation that follows will be implemented by the matrix @xmath330 , since the monodromy at @xmath127 is no longer @xmath331 but @xmath332 . the effect of conjugating the matrices at each step is simply to reverse the order of the transformations in ( [ seq1 ] ) to which correspond , up to a sign , the sl@xmath15 matrix @xmath333 here @xmath334 and @xmath331 are fixed matrices given by ( [ matrices],[matrices2 ] ) . we are thus able to obtain any matrix of the subgroup of sl@xmath15 generated by @xmath334 and @xmath331 . this is just @xmath5 as we need to prove the self duality of the spectrum , as explained at the end of section 4.1 . the @xmath51 charges of the @xmath335 states obtained above can also be easily computed , by evaluating the product ( [ seq2 ] ) where the monodromy matrices @xmath316 and @xmath311 are replaced by the corresponding elements of the full monodromy group , which is the semi - direct product @xmath336 ( see ( [ m1trans ] ) and ( [ m3trans ] ) ) : @xmath337 if @xmath338 then @xmath339 for @xmath60 or 3 , @xmath340 for @xmath61 and @xmath341 for @xmath342 . in order to put the present work into some perspective , i will briefly discuss below some relations with other approaches . let me first explain how our line of reasoning can shed light on some aspects of the semiclassical quantization . i will illustrate this point on the following example . it is well known in the context of the semiclassical approach @xcite that the existence of dyon - monopole bound states with @xmath343 in the pure @xmath2 gauge theory would violate the self - duality of the @xmath1 theory . this is due to the fact that such bound states are in one to one correspondence with the cohomology classes of _ holomorphic _ differentials on the reduced ( @xmath66 dimensional ) multimonopole moduli space in the case of the pure gauge theory , while the differentials only need to be harmonic in the case of @xmath1 . this means that any @xmath343 bound state of the pure gauge theory corresponds to @xmath344 bound states in the @xmath1 theory , the second state corresponding to the antiholomorphic partner of the original holomorphic differential form . this is in contradiction with @xmath17 duality which predicts the existence of one and only one bound state of given @xmath35 and @xmath37 . from our point of view , this seemingly purely technical relation between the two theories comes from the fact that they can be joined together by continuously varying the bare mass and the coupling and using the renormalization group flow . stable states in the pure gauge theory will then yield stable states in the @xmath1 theory , by continuous deformation . moreover , we do not want any additional @xmath343 state in the @xmath1 theory coming from the pure gauge theory , since we know that such states originate from the existence of dual pure gauge theories configurations . i wish now to point out one surprising aspect of our derivation , and trace its profound origin in superstring dualities . all our reasoning is based on a careful study of the low energy effective action of the theories . though it is well known that the latter contains a lot of information about the _ massive _ states ( encoded in the bps mass formula ( [ bpsmass ] ) ) in the context of @xmath2 supersymmetric theories , it might seem astonishing that it also governs the _ formation _ of all the stable bound states ( coming in short multiplets ) . nevertheless , this fact , which appears for the first time in @xcite , is supported by increasing evidence . i hope that the present paper will convince the reader that it is both understandable ( if not natural ) and quite general in the field theory framework . however , a deeper understanding of this phenomenon comes from string theory . there , in the framework of the heterotic - type ii duality conjecture @xcite , you can argue that the bps states of @xmath2 supersymmetric yang - mills theories correspond to a self - dual non - critical string in six dimensions wrapped along geodesics around the corresponding seiberg - wittern curve @xcite . the metric on the curve is directly related to a particular seiberg - witten differential , which can in principle be computed unambiguously . as all these geometric data are contained in the low energy effective action , we understand why it completely determines the bps spectrum . in the case of @xmath1 , the low energy theory as well as the metric are trivial and the self - duality of the spectrum follows easily @xcite from the assumption that the type iib string gives rise to the @xmath1 gauge theory in some limit . the cases of some su(2 ) theories , including also very recently the so(3 ) theory studied in this paper , were addressed in @xcite . the case of @xmath7 should also be within the stringy approach capabilities . our results thus constitute non trivial tests of the string - string duality hypothesis . we will mainly focus in this section on the @xmath1 theory , in order to avoid tiresome repetitions . in subsection 5.3 , we will nevertheless briefly point out the peculiarities of the @xmath7 theory , which do not yield any new difficulties . as there is only _ one _ multiplet in the hilbert space of states corresponding to the fundamental @xmath1 multiplet @xmath110 , s duality predicts the existence of only _ one _ @xmath1 multiplet @xmath0 . as indicated in the table 1 of section 2 , such an @xmath1 multiplet can be decomposed into three parts characterized by their physical s charges @xmath82 , @xmath345 and @xmath346 . when @xmath12 , we can use cp invariance to show that the existence of a state having @xmath17 implies the existence of another state having @xmath347 , and that in a given monopole sector @xmath348 , @xmath349 . angle does not influence the physical @xmath17 charge @xcite . ] uniqueness of the @xmath0 state would therefore imply that @xmath350 , and the three values of @xmath17 that should be realized correspond to the cp invariant combination @xmath351 . state in the semiclassical picture must be self - dual or anti self - dual . ] the extremal values @xmath352 and @xmath353 correspond to states belonging to a @xmath2 hypermultiplet , while @xmath354 corresponds to a @xmath2 vector multiplet . the @xmath0 states we have generated in section 4 in the massive theory correspond to @xmath2 hypermultiplets , having a given charge @xmath355 . because of @xmath1 supersymmetry in the @xmath269 limit , these hypermultiplets will be associated to other states to form whole @xmath1 multiplets @xmath356 or @xmath357 . the physical @xmath17 charges of a state @xmath358 must be related to the constants @xmath51 appearing in the central charge of the supersymmetry algebra by a relation of the form @xcite @xmath359 where @xmath360 . to determine @xmath361 , one can proceed as follows . when @xmath12 , the solution for @xmath86 and @xmath45 is given by @xmath362 where @xmath363 is the sign of @xmath163 . the ( unphysical ) cut for @xmath86 comes from the choice we did in section 3 for the position of the branch cut originating at @xmath129 when @xmath364 . when @xmath364 , we will have @xmath365 however , if @xmath366 , the physical @xmath17 charge contributes to @xmath86 and @xmath45 , even at infinity , by an amount determined by @xmath361 in such a way that @xmath367 @xmath361 can then be computed straightforwardly by using the formulas for @xmath86 and @xmath45 given in appendix a. one must note , however , that the sign of @xmath361 remains arbitrary , since it can be changed by performing a weyl gauge transformation . this is related to the fact that one can choose equivalently @xmath368 or @xmath369 to be massless at @xmath129 in the configuration of figure 1 . the convention we will choose hereafter is the following : @xmath368 will be chosen to be massless at @xmath129 when @xmath370 and @xmath369 when @xmath371 ( we will only consider real values of @xmath11 ) . these conventions will allow us to use the gauge invariance in a convenient way . finally , we have @xmath372 where @xmath373 is the sign of @xmath11 . this formula implies in particular that the dyons found in section 3 by studying the dual rg flow ( [ rgdual ] ) all have @xmath374 as expected . it is not disturbing that @xmath17 may undergo a discontinuity from @xmath375 to @xmath376 . this discontinuity simply reflects the ambiguity associated with cp invariance when @xmath46 or @xmath377 are real . to be concrete , we will hereafter consider a particular configuration , obtained from the original configuration depicted in figure 1 by performing the transformation @xmath378 ( see section 4 ) , and which is described in figure 7 . this amounts to changing @xmath86 into @xmath379 and @xmath45 into @xmath380 . [ figure7 ] = 14.7 cm this choice is completely arbitrary : _ all our reasonings will be sl@xmath15 invariant and thus completely general . _ however , we think that it is more eloquent to deal with states having magnetic charges three , four or seven than simply one , for in this latter case unicity of the states is trivial from the semiclassical point of view . we already know that the @xmath1 multiplet corresponding to a state @xmath381 becoming massles is unique since the singularities are produced by only one hypermultiplet . thus , what we need to show is that , for instance , the only allowed values of @xmath51 for a state @xmath382 should be @xmath383 ( charge of the hypermultiplet becoming massless ) together with @xmath384 and @xmath385 ( this would correspond to the case where the physical @xmath17 charge of @xmath386 would be @xmath72 ) or with @xmath387 and @xmath353 ( when @xmath388 ) . suppose that a state @xmath389 exists in the @xmath1 theory . when a real mass @xmath11 is turned on , @xmath389 must produce a singularity at any point on the coulomb branch where it is massless , that is where @xmath390 which in the original variables reads @xmath391 to study this equation , at least in the large @xmath392 limit , one can use the asymptotics ( [ limite ] ) for @xmath45 at large @xmath393 . this suggest that ( [ uni1 ] ) might have solutions only when @xmath394 when @xmath370 and only when @xmath395 when @xmath371 at points @xmath396 more rigorously , using ( [ cptrans ] ) and the monodromy @xmath316 , one can show that @xmath397 for @xmath398 . moreover , one can easily show using the explicit formulas of @xmath45 and its derivative @xmath399 given in appendix a that , in the case @xmath370 , @xmath45 is a monotonically increasing function for @xmath400 , with @xmath401 ( this latter value is reached at @xmath402 ) , and @xmath403 when @xmath404 . strictly similar results are true when @xmath371 , which proves that the simple analysis using the asymptotics is valid except concerning @xmath405 , as one may have expected . as the @xmath406 exist for any @xmath370 when @xmath407 and for any @xmath371 when @xmath408 , a singularity must be associated in the massive theories to any state @xmath389 existing in the massless one , provided @xmath407 ( if @xmath370 ) or @xmath408 ( if @xmath371 ) . from this we deduce that when @xmath370 , which corresponds to the case depicted in figure 7 , the state becoming massless at @xmath161 , having @xmath409 , must have a physical @xmath17 charge @xmath72 ( it is thus associated with states having @xmath405 and @xmath410 when @xmath12 ) , and that no other @xmath389 state having @xmath411 can exist when @xmath12 . when @xmath371 , the state becoming massless at @xmath161 will have @xmath410 and @xmath388 multiplet ( see table 1 in section 2 ) which becomes massless is changed when @xmath11 changes sign with our conventions . ] and we see that no other @xmath389 state having @xmath412 can exist when @xmath12 . this proves the unicity . exactly the same reasoning can be applied to the states @xmath413 . the equation to study is in this case @xmath414 by using again ( [ limite ] ) , we can convince ourselves , and then show rigorously , that when @xmath142 ( [ uni2 ] ) will have solutions when @xmath415 ( for @xmath370 ) or when @xmath411 ( for @xmath371 ) . this is again perfectly consistent with our previous analysis of the @xmath51 and @xmath17 charges . when @xmath370 , it is the state having @xmath388 which is massless , and we showed that no state @xmath416 with @xmath417 can exist ; when @xmath371 it is the state having @xmath418 which is massless , and we showed that no state with @xmath419 can exist . thus the @xmath1 multiplet @xmath416 is indeed unique and realizes the values @xmath388 , @xmath354 and @xmath420 as it should . finally , note that the case of the states @xmath421 and @xmath422 can be easily handled for instance by using the previous results and the @xmath176 type duality transformation ( [ periodstrans ] ) , or by repeating the same analysis as above . of course , the reasoning will not change whatever configuration of the theory you may choose , and thus we have proven the unicity of the states @xmath0 for any @xmath3 and @xmath4 relatively prime . in this theory , the solution is given by @xmath423 and @xmath424 , and the bare masses of the first and second flavours are equal to @xmath425 . the uniqueness of the @xmath0 states can then be proven exactly as for the @xmath1 theory . in particular , a @xmath426 hypermultiplet becoming massless when @xmath364 will again be associated to two other sets of states having physical charges @xmath427 and @xmath428 , or @xmath429 and @xmath430 when @xmath12 , the spin(8 ) flavour symmetry playing the same rle in this theory as @xmath1 supersymmetry in the previous case . the main novelty is that one also has to study the uniqueness of the vector @xmath6 states . again one can repeat the arguments of the preceding subsection . equation ( [ uni1 ] ) will be replaced by @xmath431 from the analysis of the preceding subsection it follows that this equation has solutions for any @xmath51 such that @xmath432 . moreover , by using the formula for @xmath45 given in appendix a , one can show that @xmath433 when @xmath434 and thus the equation ( [ uni3 ] ) will also have solutions for @xmath435 at least for some values of @xmath50 . thus , the only @xmath6 states , @xmath436 mod 2 , that might exist in the @xmath12 theory must have @xmath354 , as expected . the same reasoning works for the state @xmath6 such that @xmath437 mod 2 . however , when @xmath438 mod 2 , one can not exclude directly the states having a physical @xmath17 charge @xmath439 . this seems to be a peculiarity of the vector particles : at fixed @xmath50 , these vector particles , if they existed , would not necessarily lead to an unphysical singularity , and hence their existence can not be ruled out by this argument alone . of course , this is not really an obstacle for us . by changing @xmath50 to @xmath440 in the original configuration , we exchange @xmath185 and @xmath159 and thus states @xmath437 mod 2 with states @xmath438 mod 2 , and we can then deduce that necessarily @xmath354 for the latter states . to prove the unicity , we still have to check whether only one state exists at given @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath51 . the argument which worked for the @xmath0 states relied on the fact that any of these states can be related to a singularity appearing on the coulomb branch for some values of the coupling , and that we know the multiplicity of the states producing singularities . this clearly does not work for the @xmath6 states , which are never massless ( when @xmath364 ) and thus never produce a singularity . as an alternative , we will rely on a semiclassical analysis . in @xcite was shown that the states @xmath6 indeed exist and are unique _ for @xmath441 . _ the uniqueness of the @xmath442 states for _ any _ @xmath3 and @xmath4 relatively prime will then follow from the @xmath5 invariance of the theory , see section 8 . due to the bps mass formula ( [ bpsmass ] ) , a bps state is generically stable . central charge as well as mass conservation indeed impose tights constraints . to see this , suppose that a bps state of central charge @xmath42 decay into @xmath3 states of central charges @xmath443 . this is possible only if @xmath444 and @xmath445 of the @xmath3 relations ( [ cms1 ] ) , only @xmath446 are independent once one takes into account ( [ firstc ] ) , and thus they define a hypersurface of real codimension @xmath446 included in the coulomb branch . in our case where the gauge group is of rank one and thus the coulomb branch of real dimension two , this means that decays into two distinct particles can only occur along real curves , decays into three distinct particles at special points , and decays into four or more distinct particles are likely to be impossible . suppose we are studying the decay of a state @xmath447 into two states , one of them being @xmath448 . instead of using the original variables @xmath449 , it is convenient to use shifted variables @xmath450 such that @xmath183 . the equation for the curve of marginal stability can then be cast in the following sl@xmath15 invariant form : @xmath451 the left hand side of ( [ cmseq ] ) does not depend on the final state @xmath448 , and the right hand side is an a priori arbitrary rational number which we will denote by @xmath452 . we thus see that to a given particle @xmath447 is associated a whole family of curves of marginal stability , @xmath453 , indexed by a rational number @xmath452 . it is useful at this stage to summarize what we need to show in order to complete our goal , which is to demonstrate that the spectrum of bps states is in perfect agreement with @xmath17 duality both in the @xmath1 and massless @xmath102 theory , and also to prove the existence of the required states in the massive cases studied in section 3 . + we need to show that the states @xmath0 , where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are relatively prime integers , which we have generated by analytic continuation in the _ massive _ theories ( section 4 ) , still exist in the _ massless _ one . this will be established in section 7 using the curves of marginal stability . + we need to show that the states @xmath6 exist in the @xmath102 theory , since they represent the duals of the w bosons in this case . we did not give any argument in favour of the existence of such states up to now , since they are not associated with any singularity on the coulomb branch . however , one can establish their existence by using the general argument presented in section 8 , _ and _ by relying on the non trivial semiclassical results obtained in @xcite for states of magnetic charge 2 . + finally , we need to show that the dual of the w bosons ( and of the elementary quarks in the @xmath102 theory ) does exist in the dual theory studied in section 3.5 . there it was only shown that the existence of these states does not lead to any inconsistency . actually , these dual states exist in the massless theories , and in appendix b we will explain why they must still exist when the bare mass is increased and we follow the rg flow ( [ rgdual ] ) toward the dual pure gauge ( or massless @xmath119 ) theory . let us end this section by mentioning the formula @xmath454 which corresponds to a cp transformation . note that though this is _ not _ a duality transformation , it is still perfectly compatible with the bps mass formula ( [ bpsmass ] ) . this relation is useful to study the symmetries and some particular points of the curves of marginal stability . in this section , @xmath3 and @xmath4 are two relatively prime integers . in section 4 , strong evidence in favour of the existence of the states @xmath0 in the massless theories was given : depending on the value of the coupling @xmath50 , when the bare mass is turned on , the singularities on the coulomb branch may be due to any of these states . however , strictly speaking , the existence of the states was proven only when @xmath364 and @xmath455 . when @xmath12 and the singularities merge at @xmath456 , all the @xmath0 states become massless and thus degenerate in mass . though a brutal discontinuity in the spectrum between @xmath364 and @xmath12 seems very unlikely on physical grounds , we would like to argue that the @xmath0 states not only exist at the singularities they are responsible for , but also at other points in the @xmath46 plane . one way of doing this is to consider a configuration where the @xmath0 state becomes massless , and to study the family of curves of marginal stability associated with the decay of this state . if @xmath436 mod 2 , we have a family @xmath457 defined by ( cf ( [ cmseq ] ) ) @xmath458 and if @xmath438 mod 2 we have a family @xmath459 , @xmath460 the case of @xmath437 mod 2 is completely similar to the case @xmath436 mod 2 due to ( [ periodstrans ] ) . we have computed the curves @xmath461 numerically , using the analytic formulas for the periods presented in appendix a , and the result is depicted in figure 8 . [ figure8 ] = 14.7 cm it is easy to established , particularly in using ( [ cptrans ] ) , that the curves @xmath459 all intersect at @xmath127 and are symmetric with respect to the real @xmath46 axis , while the curves @xmath457 all intersect at @xmath129 and @xmath127 and @xmath462 . more important , these curves do not intersect at any other points than the particular ones mentioned above and form a dense set in the whole @xmath46 plane . this is not prohibitive : the complementary set , generated by the curves @xmath463 for _ irrational _ values of @xmath464 , is also a dense subset of the coulomb branch , where the corresponding state is stable . this shows that for any positive real number @xmath465 , there is always a point @xmath46 such that @xmath466 and which can be joined to the singularity @xmath131 by a curve @xmath463 where @xmath464 is taken to be irrational . as the state becoming massless at @xmath131 can not decay along such a curve , it must exist at @xmath46 . as @xmath465 can be chosen independently of @xmath11 , @xmath0 must exist in the @xmath12 theory for some @xmath466 and thus for any @xmath46 . to end this section , i wish to point out that the preceding analysis suggests that states which can not exist in the @xmath12 theory can not exist anymore in the @xmath364 theory . to understand this , assume that to the unwanted state @xmath467 is associated a point @xmath93 on the coulomb branch such that @xmath468 for any given @xmath50 and @xmath11 . , though it seems to be true numerically . ] . the family of curves of marginal stability @xmath469 associated with @xmath467 looks like the families depicted in figure 8 , except that all the curves will intersect at @xmath93 . now suppose that @xmath467 exist at a point on a curve @xmath470 with @xmath464 irrational ( such curves cover a dense subset @xmath471 of the coulomb branch ) . then move @xmath467 along this curve , reach @xmath93 where it is massless and find an inconsistency since @xmath93 is not a singular point . thus @xmath467 can not exist in the dense set @xmath471 : this means that it will never be a trully stable state in the theory . thus , if our hypothesis ( [ unsing ] ) is correct , the number of curves of marginal stability one must consider to study eventual decays in the massive theories is considerably decreased . we will use this fact in appendix b , see also [ 32 ] . in this section , we wish to address a very general problem : when can we expect the monodromy group of a given theory to correspond to an exact duality symmetry ? of course , this a priori naive statement is not always true , as seiberg and witten already pointed out in their original paper @xcite on the pure gauge theory . however , we would like it to be correct in the particular cases of the finite theories studied in this paper . we will give in the following some general physical arguments showing that this property can be understood simply by looking at some very general features of the structure of the low energy effective action . though we will restrict ourselves to very few examples , in the framework of su(2 ) gauge theories , and chosen in order to illuminate the cases of su(2 ) @xmath1 and @xmath2 , @xmath102 , the line of reasoning could a priori be applied to any @xmath2 theory . first , let us consider a theory with only one singularity on the coulomb branch . it could be the massless theories studied above . let us see why in this simple case , the monodromy @xmath166 associated with this singularity must correspond to an exact duality symmetry of the theory . to the singularity is associated a branch cut which extends to infinity and whose orientation clearly is arbitrary . by sweeping up the @xmath46 plane with such a branch cut , _ while keeping all the parameters fixed , _ we show that necessarily two theories connected by the transformation @xmath166 must be physically equivalent . this kind of argument was already presented in subsection 4.3 . in the case of @xmath1 or @xmath2 with four massless flavours , @xmath472 and the `` duality '' transformation is nothing but a gauge transformation . let us now go to a more interesting situation , suited for instance for the pure gauge theory , where two singularities are present at @xmath129 and @xmath126 with monodromies @xmath334 and @xmath473 . the theory now has an intrinsic scale @xmath87 such that @xmath474 . two scenarios can be imagined in this case . in the first one , for some reasons the naive arguments are true , and thus the monodromy group generated by @xmath334 and @xmath473 corresponds to an exact duality symmetry . in the second scenario , the two singularities combine : we choose the branch cut originating at @xmath161 to go through @xmath185 and then to coincide with the branch cut originating at @xmath185 . far away from the singularities , we thus only see a branch cut associated with a monodromy matrix @xmath475 which is the product of the two matrices @xmath316 and @xmath476 . of course the position of this branch cut extending to infinity can be chosen arbitrarily , and thus an exact duality symmetry must be associated with @xmath477 , at least when @xmath478 . in the case of the pure gauge theory , @xmath475 expresses the asymptotic freedom and is associated with the invariance of the theory under @xmath16 angle shifts . finally , let us study the case where three singularities @xmath137 are present on the coulomb branch , with monodromy matrices @xmath291 . the theory may now have one , two , or three intrinsic scales , corresponding to the distances @xmath479 between the singularities . in the @xmath2 theory with one flavour of quark , we have three singularities at equal distances from each other because of a @xmath480 symmetry acting on the coulomb branch @xcite . thus we have only one scale @xmath87 at our disposal . the same scenario as the one which prevailed for the pure gauge theory occurs , and we do not have any particular duality symmetry in this theory . now , the finite theories we are studying in this paper also have three singularities in the coulomb branch , but with the most important property that two independent scales can be introduced and _ any one of the three singularities can be chosen to be arbitrarily far from the other two . _ typically , we are studying a dual rg flow as in ( [ rgdual ] ) , and two of the three singularities ( say @xmath161 and @xmath185 ) are separated by an almost fixed distance @xmath481 while the third singularity ( @xmath159 ) runs to infinity with @xmath11 at a distance @xmath482 , where @xmath11 is the bare mass in the theory . in such a configuration , as in the case where only two singularities are present , we can not know a priori whether the monodromies @xmath316 and @xmath476 associated with the singularities at scale @xmath87 will correspond to an exact duality symmetry . however , the situation is different for the isolated singularity at scale @xmath11 . the latter can only be `` screened '' by the singularities at scale @xmath87 . we think that this is impossible , because it seems very unlikely that the low energy physics at scale @xmath87 could be influenced by a singularity at scale @xmath11 , produced by a particle which is ultra massive at scale @xmath87 ( if it exists ) , and vice - versa . one might argue that the branch cuts of the three singularities could merge at a new intrinsic scale @xmath483 . however , the physical origin of this new scale would be very unclear and we will rule out this possibility . we thus see that the only natural way to interpret the singularity structure is to admit that @xmath311 corresponds to an exact duality symmetry of the theory at least in the configuration where @xmath484 and @xmath485 with @xmath486 . from the point of view of the massless theory , which corresponds to @xmath487 , we have thus an invariance with respect to @xmath311 . the rle of the three singularities can of course be exchanged due to the sl@xmath15 invariance of the seiberg - witten curve ( [ curve ] ) , and we deduce that the @xmath12 theories have an exact duality group which contains @xmath5 . in particular , the existence of all the @xmath6 states in the @xmath7 theory will then follow from the existence of the three states @xmath111 ( the w ) , @xmath488 and @xmath489 , which were shown to exist in @xcite using the semiclassical method . in this paper , we proved rigorously that all the @xmath0 dyon states , where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are relatively prime integers , exist in the @xmath1 as well as in the @xmath2 , @xmath7 gauge theories with gauge group su(2 ) . these states were obtained by analytic continuation of the @xmath490 states which become massless at some points of the coulomb branch when the bare @xmath16 angle is zero . in the process of analytic continuation , we saw explicitly that the quantum numbers at the singularities can change according to a monodromy transformation . we also proved the unicity of the dyon states , in perfect agreement with an exact sl@xmath15 duality symmetry . we also provided a very general physical argument showing that @xmath1 and @xmath2 with four massless flavours must have an exact duality symmetry group which contains the monodromy group of the corresponding massive theories . this fact together with already known semiclassical results implies the existence of all the @xmath6 vector states in the @xmath7 theory . the line of reasoning used in this work , particularly the arguments of subsections 4.1 and 8 , is likely to be generalizable to theories having any gauge group , for instance to the case of su(n ) with @xmath491 . this may answer the open questions in these cases @xcite . from a very general point of view , our method may be seen as the physical counterpart of the string theory results based on the heterotic - type ii duality conjecture @xcite . it would be very interesting to prove the equivalence of the two approaches . in our approach , one is seeking for non singular points @xmath46 on the coulomb branch and for cycles @xmath492 on the seiberg - witten curve @xmath493 such that @xmath494 where @xmath495 is the seiberg - witten differential form , see appendix a. states @xmath0 corresponding to such a cycle @xmath496 can not exist , and any other ( hypermultiplet ) states are very likely to exist . in the string approach , stable states are associated with geodesics on @xmath497 endowed with the metric @xmath498 where @xmath73 is a particular element in the cohomology class of @xmath495 . for states lying in a @xmath2 hypermultiplet , these geodesics must begin and end at the branching points @xmath499 ( see ( [ roots ] ) in appendix a ) . a link between the two points of view is the following : it is clearly impossible to have a non - null geodesic with the required properties for a state @xmath496 satisfying ( [ conc1 ] ) , since the geodesic would have zero length and this requires its endpoints to coincide , that is to have a singularity . more important , the existence of a particular point @xmath46 such that ( [ conc1 ] ) is true is likely to prevent the existence of the corresponding geodesic for `` any '' @xmath46 , by continuity . of course subtleties are associated with the curves of marginal stability , and the vector particles may have a particular status . in any case , we believe that a complete understanding of the relationship between the two approaches is likely to provide a deeper understanding of @xmath2 theories . it is a pleasure to thank adel bilal for his permanent encouragements and many interesting discussions . his critical reading of the manuscript was also at the origin of many improvements . i also thank adam schwimmer for a useful discussion , and aurlia who kindly processed the figures . i present below some general formulas from the theory of elliptic integrals ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) in a form well suited for our purposes . by well suited , i mean first that they can be used straighforwardly to obtain the analytic solution for @xmath86 and @xmath45 actually , the same general formulas can be used to evaluate the periods of the asymptotically free theories having @xmath500 as well @xcite . second , i mean that they can easily be implemented on a computer system , and thus can be used to determine numerically the curves of marginal stability . let us consider a torus whose equation is @xmath501 in our particular case , it will be convenient to cast ( [ curve ] ) into this form by performing the change of variable @xmath502 we will then have @xmath503 the fundamental cycles on the torus ( [ curvebis ] ) are chosen as indicated in figure a.1 . [ figure9 ] = 14.7 cm to this choice for the homology basis , we associate the usual variables @xmath212 and @xmath504 : @xmath505 the fundamental periods are then given by @xmath506 where @xmath507 is the standard complete elliptic integral of the first kind . we will also need a formula involving elliptic integrals of the third kind . maybe the most convenient form for this formula is the following : @xmath508 where @xmath496 is any complex number which is different from the roots @xmath499 and @xmath509 is an integer . the @xmath510 are given by @xmath511 in terms of the complete elliptic integrals of the first and second kinds @xmath507 and @xmath512 . , @xmath513 . ] @xmath514 and @xmath515 are straightforward generalizations ( note that @xmath516 here ) of the weirstrass @xmath514 and @xmath515 functions , and may be expressed in terms of the standard jacobian and @xmath16 elliptic functions @xcite as @xmath517 finally , @xmath518 is such that @xmath519 , that is @xmath520.\ ] ] the indeterminate constant @xmath509 comes from the fact that the differential form @xmath521 has poles with residues @xmath522 . if , under a continuous deformation , the integration contour crosses such a pole , @xmath509 will be shifted by one unit . note also that the ambiguity that exists in the definition of @xmath518 , which stems from the fact that @xmath523 is a doubly periodic , even function of @xmath524 , can be absorbed in a redefinition of @xmath509 by using legendre s relation @xmath525 and the fact that @xmath526 for any integers @xmath527 and @xmath528 . it should be clear that such integrals can only appear in theories with non zero bare masses , since it is only here that jumps in @xmath86 and @xmath45 are allowed @xcite . changing @xmath509 will then simply amount to shifting the @xmath51 charge . we are now equipped to compute the seiberg - witten periods @xmath86 and @xmath45 rather straighforwardly . however , two points remain to be discussed . first , when applying the above formulas , we are not certain to obtain a solution with the correct analytic structure in the @xmath46 plane . this is explained in the next subsection where the effective coupling @xmath529 is computed . second , we must find the seiberg - witten differential , if possible in a form where the canonical decomposition in terms of the building blocks treated above is simple . this is done in subsection 5.3 . the solution is then given in 5.4 . the effective coupling @xmath530 is nothing but the modular parameter of the torus ( [ curve ] ) , and would thus naively be given by @xmath531 . however , this formula is a priori valid only modulo sl@xmath15 transformations , and some additional constraints must be found from physics . the first constraint comes from the evaluation of @xmath530 in the limit @xmath404 where it should coincide with @xmath50 , modulo @xmath16 angle redefinitions which correspond to trivial shifts of the electric charge . this constraint is indeed satisfied with our choices for the homology cycles @xmath532 and @xmath533 . the second constraint comes from the analytic structure of @xmath530 as a function of @xmath46 , which was described in section 3 in the case of a trivial bare @xmath16 angle . this analytic structure is most easily studied when one uses the explicit formulas @xmath534 and @xmath535 where the @xmath137 correspond to the positions of the singularities ( [ singpos ] ) . we then obtain a unique solution , given when @xmath273 by @xmath536 @xmath537 and @xmath399 are also very directly related to the fundamental periods @xmath538 and @xmath539 . before writing explicit formulas , one must note that though having the same monodromies , the solution for the so(3 ) and @xmath7 theories will differ by a global factor of @xmath540 which directly comes from the analysis of the massless theories . in the following , we will reserve the notation @xmath112 for the solution of the so(3 ) theory , and for @xmath7 we will have @xmath541 . with these conventions , @xmath542 and @xmath543 we now wish to integrate the relations ( [ solda],[soldad ] ) in order to obtain @xmath44 and @xmath45 . to do this , the standard method is to find a one form @xmath73 ( the so - called seiberg - witten differential ) so that @xmath544 up to an exact form . we will then compute @xmath44 and @xmath45 by mean of the formulas @xmath545 the simplest way to find @xmath73 certainly is to use , instead of the variables @xmath546 , the rescaled variables @xmath547 ) . we perform it in order to simplify the expressions . on the contrary , the use of @xmath548 instead of @xmath549 amounts to adding a non trivial exact differential to @xmath73 , which simplifies its form nicely . ] in terms of which the curve takes the form @xmath550 with @xmath551 by multiple integration by part we then obtain @xmath552 a very convenient and simple form for @xmath73 will then be @xmath553 we end our computation by writing @xmath73 in the form @xmath554 by noting that @xmath555 we can easily compute @xmath556 with @xmath557 and then apply ( [ fundperiods ] , [ i3 ] ) to find the desired solution : @xmath558,\ ] ] and @xmath559 \quad { \mathrm for}\enspace \im z\geq 0.\\ { \displaystyle\sqrt{2}\over\displaystyle\pi } \bigl [ \bigl ( z - z_{1 } \bigr)\ , ( \omega _ { 2}+2\omega _ { 1 } ) + { i\over 4}m\ , \bigl ( 2(\omega _ { 2}+2\omega _ { 1})\zeta ( u_{c } ) -4(\eta _ { 2}+2\eta _ { 1})u_{c } \bigr ) \bigr]\\ \end{array}\right.\nonumber\\ & & \hskip 8 cm { \mathrm for}\enspace \im z < 0.\\ \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the different prescriptions for @xmath560 or for @xmath561 correspond of course to a zero @xmath16 angle . the generalization to any @xmath16 angle should be clear in view of the discussion in section 4 . [ figure10 ] = 14.7 cm in this appendix , we complete the proof of section 3 and show that the spectrum of the dual pure gauge theory ( or dual @xmath125 massless theory ) is in perfect agreement with duality . in section 3 , we already showed that the duals of the @xmath275 monopoles indeed exist outside the curve of marginal stability @xmath562 represented in figure 4 in the theory @xmath177 . in addition to these states , duality predicts the existence of the duals of the w bosons , and also of the elementary quarks in the case of the @xmath7 theory . more precisely , we need to prove that in the so(3 ) theory the state @xmath563 indeed exists for @xmath141 outside the curve @xmath562 or equivalently that @xmath564 exists for @xmath142 . in the @xmath7 theory , in addition to the preceding state ( now interpreted as being the dual of the quarks of the massless @xmath125 theory ) , we must have the @xmath565 ( or @xmath566 ) state interpreted as being the dual of the w. our strategy will be the following : as we already know that all these states exist when @xmath12 , we will simply show that they can not decay outside the curve @xmath562 when the mass is turned on and we follow the rg flow ( [ rgdual ] ) toward the dual pure gauge ( or @xmath125 ) theory . to do this , remark first that the family of curves of marginal stability associated with @xmath563 coincides with the one for @xmath565 , and that the family for @xmath567 is the symmetric of the family for @xmath563 with respect to the real @xmath46 axis . thus , we need to study only one family of curves , whose defining equations deduced from ( [ cmseq ] ) can be cast in the form @xmath568 in this equation , @xmath569 represents the physical @xmath17 charge a state produced in the decay reaction would have when @xmath12 , and @xmath570 represents the electric charge of the same state . as argued in section 7 , we will consider only @xmath569 such that @xmath571 and thus @xmath572 or @xmath573 where @xmath107 is any integer . the corresponding curves are represented in figure b.1 . as there is no curve outside @xmath562 in the lower half - plane , the state @xmath563 ( or @xmath565 ) can not decay in this region . this completes the proof .

it is shown that all the @xmath0 dyon bound states exist and are unique in @xmath1 and @xmath2 with four massless flavours supersymmetric su(2 ) yang - mills theories , where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are any relatively prime integers . the proof can be understood in the context of field theory alone , and does _ not _ rely on any duality assumption . we also give a general physical argument showing that these theories should have at least an exact @xmath5 duality symmetry , and then deduce in particular the existence of the @xmath6 vector multiplets in the @xmath7 theory . the corresponding massive theories are studied in parallel , and it is shown that though in these cases the spectrum is no longer self - dual at a given point on the moduli space , it is still in perfect agreement with an exact s duality . we also discuss the interplay between our results and both the semiclassical quantization and the heterotic - type ii string - string duality conjecture . epsf = bbm12 = bbm9 = bbm7 = = = 1= 2= 3= specialpagefalse oddhead-1.2cm3 evenheadoddhead

quant-ph0611058

the storage and transmission of quantum states in a decohering environment is unavoidable in quantum computation and quantum communication @xcite . the conceptual device of a quantum channel is very useful in addressing the issues of such a transmission @xcite and to analyze decoherence related questions in quantum cryptography @xcite and quantum teleportation @xcite . a general quantum operation on an @xmath1-dimensional quantum system is a completely positive map . such a map defines a quantum channel for the given system and can be formally represented by its operator sum representation @xcite . one can also look at this general quantum evolution using affine transformations for the channel @xcite . in an explicit model for this evolution , the system is considered as a part of a larger closed system undergoing unitary evolution . the part of this larger system that we are not interested in can be thought of as the environment , which when traced over , gives us the dynamics of the effective sub - system . the environment can in general be very large . however , it turns out that in order to achieve the most general evolution for a system with an @xmath1-dimensional hilbert space , we need an environment which is of dimensions @xmath2 ( if we allow the most general unitary evolution of the total system and assume that the initial state of the environment is pure ) @xcite . therefore , to simulate the most general evolution of a single qubit , at least a four - dimensional ( two - qubit ) environment is required . however if we allow the initial state of the environment to be a mixed state , there is a possibility of achieving such a simulation by employing a smaller environment . this reduction in the dimension of the hilbert space is desirable for performing actual simulations of open quantum systems @xcite . along these lines , an argument based on counting the number of independent parameters suggests that a one - qubit mixed state environment might be sufficient to simulate the most general quantum evolution of a single qubit @xcite . further investigations in this direction have revealed that there are counter - examples to the above conjecture , and there are single qubit channels which can not be simulated by one qubit in the environment @xcite . we investigate this question in detail via a different route and compute the set of affine transformations for this class of channels analytically , employing the canonical form for two - qubit unitary operators @xcite . restricting ourselves to generalized depolarizing channels , we show that a sizable volume ( namely @xmath3 ) of these channels can not be simulated by a one - qubit mixed state environment . further , we show that the counter example of the two - pauli channel found by terhal et . al . is a special case of our results . the material in this paper is arranged as follows : in section [ one - qubit - channel ] , we explain how a one - qubit mixed state environment can be considered for the simulation of a single qubit channel and the significance of modeling the channel using such an environment . we consider the two - qubit unitary required for the simulation of such a channel and discuss how this class of channels could be a candidate that could occupy a sizable volume in the space of single - qubit channels . at the end of this section , the expression for the affine transformation for a general single qubit channel modeled using a one - qubit mixed state environment is obtained . in section [ depolarizing - channel ] we take up the special case of generalized depolarizing channels . the affine transformation for this case is obtained by setting the shift of the bloch sphere origin to zero in the general expression for affine transformation developed in section [ one - qubit - channel ] . these channels are classified by computing their singular values . from the structure of these singular values and the analysis of all the possible cases the volume occupied by the generalized depolarizing channels simulated by a one - qubit mixed state environment is computed and compared to the total volume of generalized depolarizing channels . the section concludes with a discussion of the two - pauli channel considered as a special case of generalized depolarizing channels and it is shown that it can not be simulated by a one - qubit mixed state environment . section [ conclusions ] contains some concluding remarks . in the model for the one - qubit channel that we consider , we allow the qubit of interest to interact with only one environment qubit . the interaction unitary is allowed to be the most general two - qubit unitary and the environment qubit is a general mixed state . this channel is schematically depicted in figure ( [ channel ] ) . for the purpose of characterizing the channel , we consider the system qubit to be in a general pure state ( a point on the bloch sphere ) given by @xmath4 where @xmath5 varies from 0 to @xmath6 and @xmath7 varies from 0 to 2@xmath6 . the environment qubit is assumed to be in a general mixed state for which we choose a particular parameterization as follows : @xmath8 where @xmath9 corresponds to a maximally mixed state and @xmath10 corresponds to a general pure state given by @xmath11 where @xmath12 varies from @xmath13 to @xmath6 and @xmath14 varies from @xmath13 to @xmath15 . therefore , the environment state can be thought of as a mixture of a completely mixed state and a pure state . the parameter @xmath16 indicates the degree to which the state is mixed . by varying @xmath17 from @xmath18 to @xmath13 , we can go from a pure to a maximally mixed state of the environment . implementation of a one - qubit channel using a single qubit mixed state environment . the system is taken to be in a pure initial state @xmath19 while the environment is in a mixed state @xmath20 . the interaction takes place via the two - qubit unitary @xmath21 and the environment qubit is discarded after the interaction . ] the interaction that takes place between the system qubit and the environment qubit corresponds to a general unitary operator in the four - dimensional ( two - qubit ) hilbert space . this most general unitary which is an @xmath22 transformation has fifteen independent parameters . however , it has been shown that an arbitrary two - qubit unitary can be decomposed into local unitaries on each qubit sandwiching a non - trivial interaction unitary . this interaction unitary @xmath21 belongs to a three - parameter family of transformations @xcite . @xmath23 this is pictorially shown in figure [ u4-fig ] . this three - parameter family of interaction unitaries has the power to entangle or unentangle the qubits involved . this family finds a simple diagonal representation in the special bell basis , namely @xmath24 where @xmath25 for @xmath26 are the special bell basis vectors @xcite . the number of independent parameters @xmath27 can be reduced to three by a global phase change . this transformation matrix can be readily transformed into the product basis @xmath28 to obtain @xmath29 where @xmath30 we are considering a quantum channel for a single qubit with another qubit acting as the environment and a general unitary transformation ( described above ) providing the interaction between the two qubits . it is easy to see that the properties of the channel do not change with the local unitary transformations @xmath31 and @xmath32 . therefore , for the analysis of the family of such channels , the interaction unitary that needs to be considered is the three - parameter family given in ( [ ch9_t ] ) . the final output state of the system @xmath33 emerging from the channel after the action of @xmath21 is obtained by tracing over the environment qubit . schematic diagram for a two - qubit unitary . the local unitaries @xmath34 together with @xmath21 , which is diagonal in the special bell basis , provide a decomposition of a general @xmath22 transformation . ] mathematically , a one - qubit channel can be described in a number of ways , and we find it useful to picture it in terms of an affine transformation of the bloch sphere . the quantum states of a single qubit on the bloch sphere can be represented as follows : @xmath35 where the @xmath36 s are pauli matrices , and @xmath37 is a 3-component real vector . for pure states @xmath38 , and for mixed states @xmath39 . any arbitrary trace - preserving quantum operation on ( [ ch1_t ] ) is given by a map of the form @xmath40 , with the new vector determining @xmath41 given by @xmath42 where @xmath43 are the nine components of a @xmath44 real matrix @xmath45 and @xmath46 are the three components of a constant real column vector @xmath47 . this map , called the affine map , maps the bloch sphere ( including its interior ) onto a shifted ellipsoid with its major axis less than @xmath48 @xcite , the total number of independent parameters defining this map are twelve . the matrix @xmath45 amounts to a combination of proper rotations and contractions in different directions of the vectors on the bloch sphere . the vector @xmath47 corresponds to a shift in the origin of the bloch sphere . two channels which differ from each other by a unitary transformation of the qubit before and after the action of the channel are identical . thus , we can utilize this freedom of performing arbitrary proper rotations of the bloch sphere before and after the channel action to simplify the affine transformations for the channel . this converts the matrix @xmath45 into a ` singular - value ' form with singular values appearing along the diagonal . @xmath49 where @xmath50 and @xmath51 are real orthogonal matrices with unit determinant and @xmath52 is a diagonal matrix with the squares of its three diagonal elements given by the eigen values of the positive semi - definite matrix @xmath53 . the shift vector @xmath47 is mapped onto another such vector under these two proper rotations . after utilizing this freedom through the action of @xmath50 and @xmath51 , the number of independent parameters for single qubit channels is clearly six : namely the three singular values of the matrix @xmath52 , plus the three components of the vector @xmath47 . there is a further restriction of complete positivity on the allowed affine transformations ; however , that does not reduce the number of independent parameters @xcite . these affine transformations provide us with a complete description of one - qubit channels . we now turn to an explicit calculation to obtain the affine transformation given in equation ( [ ch2_t ] ) for the class of channels simulatable by a one - qubit mixed state environment described in figure ( [ channel ] ) ( taking a general initial system state @xmath54 to @xmath55 ) . for this purpose , we consider six points on the input bloch sphere corresponding to the eigen states of the operators @xmath56 and @xmath57 and calculate the output density matrix for each of these points . at the end of this lengthy algebraic calculation , the affine transformation turns out to be @xmath58 the corresponding shift is @xmath59 this affine transformation gives a parameterization of all the channels simulated by a one - qubit mixed state environment . we have thus obtained a closed form expression for the complete class of channels for a single qubit simulated by a one - qubit environment . this class of channels is a six - parameter family with the six parameters being @xmath60 and @xmath17 . we obtained this form by computing the action of the channel explicitly on several test states until the transformation is uniquely determined . as we have observed , the number of independent parameters for a single qubit channel simulated using this mixed state environment also turns out to be six . it had thus been conjectured that all single qubit channels may be simulatable using a single qubit mixed state as the environment @xcite . despite counter - examples like the two - pauli channel , the possibility that the set of single qubit channels simulated using a mixed state environment may occupy a sizable volume in the space of single qubit channels remains open , and it may turn out that the counter examples are a set of measure zero in the channel space . this is precisely the question that will be explored and resolved in the following section , using the closed form expression given in equations ( [ ch17_t ] ) and ( [ ch18_t ] ) . the general expression for the family of channels obtained in the previous section is very useful , and several special cases are of particular interest . we consider the case of generalized depolarizing channels defined as the ones for which the origin of the bloch sphere is not shifted . this class is simple and we know that it contains non - trivial examples which can not be implemented using a one - qubit pure state environment . we therefore analyze this sub - class in some detail . the operator sum representation of this class is given by @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the identity matrix and for @xmath63 we have @xmath64 and we have @xmath65 . the corresponding affine transformation is @xmath66 the shift @xmath47 is zero indicating that it is indeed a generalized depolarizing channel . the three diagonal entries of the matrix @xmath67 take values such that this family of generalized depolarizing channels is geometrically represented by a tetrahedron volume with vertices given by @xmath68 @xmath69 @xmath70 @xmath71 . each value of @xmath72 which lies inside this volume is an allowed set of diagonal elements for the affine transformation @xmath73 for the generalized depolarizing channel @xcite . the volume of this tetrahedron is @xmath74 . the vertices of the tetrahedron represent a unitary map for which we require only one operator in the operator sum representation . the edges represent the two operator maps and the faces represent three operators maps while the points inside the tetrahedron require all the four operators for their realization . the families of two - pauli channels which will be discussed in the next sub - section are represented on the faces of the tetrahedron ( not including the edges ) . the affine transformation corresponding to one - qubit generalized depolarizing channels , with a single qubit as the environment , can be obtained by setting the shift vector @xmath47 to zero and thereby simplifying the equation ( [ ch18_t ] ) . it turns out that this can be achieved in eleven different ways , leading to eleven different cases . for each case , we compute the singular values of the affine transformation which suffice to characterize the channel . although the algebra is a little involved , the final result in each case turns out to be rather simple . in each case the affine transformation can be brought to the following form , by local unitaries before and after the channel action : @xmath75 where @xmath76 @xmath77 depend upon the six parameters of the channel namely @xmath78 , and @xmath17 . one can immediately see that the normal depolarizing channel which maps the entire bloch sphere onto the origin , and which can not be simulated using a one - qubit pure state environment , is contained here . it corresponds to any pair from @xmath79 taking values @xmath80 . however , the important question we would like to address is how many generalized depolarizing channels are contained in the affine transformation ( [ gdpol - affine ] ) . we are interested in finding the volume inside the tetrahedron occupied by the affine transformation represented by equation ( [ gdpol - affine ] ) . this will help us explore the fraction of depolarizing channels simulatable using a one - qubit mixed state environment . the constraints which are imposed by the structure of equation ( [ gdpol - affine ] ) can be analytically worked out and turn out to be @xmath81 where @xmath82 and @xmath83 . the volume constrained by these conditions is shown in figure ( [ channel - volume-1 ] ) . all the vertices and the edges of the tetrahedron are touched . however no point on any of the faces is contained . it can be visualized as if each face of the tetrahedron has been scooped out and the depth of this scoop extends all the way to the centroid . the volume enclosed by this shape can be computed and it turns out to be @xmath18 . this implies that only @xmath0 of the generalized depolarizing channels can be simulated by a one - qubit mixed state environment . to give a more visual feel for this volume we depict its cross sections for different @xmath84 values in figure ( [ channel - volume-2 ] ) . at each value of @xmath84 the tetrahedron cross section is a rectangle and the darkened area is the cross section of the volume depicted in figure ( [ channel - volume-1 ] ) ( cross sectional views for constant @xmath85 and @xmath86 will look identical ) . cross sections of the volume depicted in figure [ channel - volume-1 ] for different values of @xmath84 from @xmath87 to @xmath88 . for each value of @xmath84 the rectangle is the cross section of the tetrahedron and the shaded area is the fraction simulatable with a one - qubit mixed state environment . the shaded fraction approaches zero as @xmath89 approaches @xmath13 and it approaches one as @xmath89 approaches @xmath18 . in between for a given @xmath90 the darkened area is bounded by hyperbola @xmath91 and lines @xmath92 and @xmath93 . ] we now turn to an interesting sub - family of depolarizing channels , namely , the two - pauli channel . two - pauli channels are the ones for which only one of @xmath94 is zero and they are represented on the faces of the tetrahedron ( leaving out the edges ) . further , for simplicity we restrict ourselves to a special case of a one - parameter sub - family of two - pauli channels for which the nonzero elements are given by @xmath95 and @xmath96 and @xmath97 . with @xmath98 . the affine transformation for the two - pauli channel can be easily computed and is given by @xmath99 this is a special case of the generalized depolarizing channels which is represented by a line on the face of the tetrahedron joining the vertex @xmath71 to the mid point of the edge below it . we take this particular case because it has been discussed in detail in the literature . we will directly argue that the affine transformation ( [ two - pauli - affine ] ) is not a special case of the affine transformation ( [ gdpol - affine ] ) for some values of @xmath100 , @xmath101 and @xmath77 . for the matrix ( [ gdpol - affine ] ) to take the form ( [ two - pauli - affine ] ) , two of its entries should become equal ; let us assume that first two are equal . this forces @xmath102 and this further implies that @xmath103 is a factor of all the singular values . however , the affine transformation ( [ two - pauli - affine ] ) does not have a non - trivial factor and hence the only possibility is @xmath104 . now we impose the relationship between the equal and unequal singular values leading to @xmath105 which implies that @xmath106 . a similar result is obtained if we begin by equating any other pair of singular values in equation ( [ gdpol - affine ] ) . the above analysis shows that the only place where the two - pauli affine transformation can match the affine transformation ( [ gdpol - affine ] ) is when @xmath107 , at which point the two - pauli channel disappears and one is left with the identity transformation . thus we conclude that the two - pauli channel is not a special case of ( [ gdpol - affine ] ) . this result has been obtained earlier , where it was shown that the two - pauli channel is a counter - example to the conjecture that a one - qubit mixed state environment can simulate all one - qubit quantum channels . our demonstration is simpler and analytical , since we have obtained the explicit expression for the affine transformation . it is not difficult to generalize this argument for the other two - pauli channels . results about the points on the face of the tetrahedron not modelable using a one - qubit mixed state environment , are actually contained in the volume analysis of the previous section . we have presented the case of two - pauli channels in detail due to the simplicity of the argument and the fact that two - pauli channels have been discussed in the literature @xcite . we have obtained a canonical form corresponding to single qubit channels with a one - qubit mixed state modeling the environment . this parameterization has been obtained analytically by computing the affine transformation corresponding to this class of channels . applying our results to the sub - class of depolarizing channels , we found that although a sizable volume ( @xmath0 of the total volume ) is modeled by a one - qubit mixed state environment , there is a finite volume in the channel space ( @xmath3 of the total volume ) which can not be modeled in this fashion . the special case of the two - pauli channel discussed in the literature has been shown to be in this missing volume and hence is not simulatable via a one - qubit mixed state environment . the results were achieved by starting with the general expression for the affine transformation , restricting it to the case with zero shift , and computing the singular values . it turns out that we can arrive at the precise constraints on the volume analytically , thereby producing a picture of the subset of generalized depolarizing channels simulatable by a one - qubit mixed state in the environment . the affine transformation which we obtain is general and one can also explore channels other than the depolarizing channels . the analysis of the volume occupied by such channels in the entire channel space for one qubit is an involved problem and will be taken up elsewhere . we note that a similar conclusion about the two - pauli channel from a very different perspective has been obtained in @xcite .

we analyze the class of single qubit channels with the environment modeled by a one - qubit mixed state . the set of affine transformations for this class of channels is computed analytically , employing the canonical form for the two - qubit unitary operator . we demonstrate that , @xmath0 of the generalized depolarizing channels can be simulated by the one - qubit mixed state environment by explicitly obtaining the shape of the volume occupied by this class of channels within the tetrahedron representing the generalized depolarizing channels . further , as a special case , we show that the two - pauli channel can not be simulated by a one - qubit mixed state environment .

astro-ph0411613

according to the standard big bang nucleosynthesis ( sbbn ) , the most abundant elements in the aftermath of the big bang were hydrogen and helium with very small traces of deuterium and lithium . these elements make up the so called pop iii or _ primordial _ chemical composition . all the heavier elements present today had to be produced in the course of the evolution of several generations of stars . in order to understand the physics of the early universe , there is a need of having appropriate and accurate material functions at hand , in particular opacities for a sbbn chemical compositions . there is a large body of literature available with opacity calculations for metal - free ( z=0 ) h / he mixtures , starting with the paczynski i - vi mixtures ( * ? ? ? * hereafter ) , the calculations of ( * ? ? ? * hereafter ) and ( * ? ? ? * hereafter ) , and more recently ( * ? ? ? * hereafter ) . these calculations were restricted to temperatures between @xmath3 and @xmath4 . specific metal - free opacity sets have been calculated by the op project ( * ? ? ? * @xmath5 ) and opal ( * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * @xmath6 ) . more recently , opal calculations have been extended @xcite to @xmath7 and densities is a parameter which replaces the density in order to keep opacity tables in rectangular format when spanning many decades in temperature ( for more details see appendix [ sect : tblfmt ] ) ; @xmath8 @xmath9 with the main application for cno enhanced opacities in stellar evolution . all these opacity calculations , however , only considered pure hydrogen / helium mixtures with no metals ( mass fraction @xmath10 ) , but different ratios @xmath11 of the mass fractions of hydrogen ( @xmath12 ) and helium ( @xmath13 ) . it has been argued that due to the assumed very small abundances of deuterium and lithium these element do not play any significant role in the opacities and thus in the evolution of pop iii objects . moreover , while there are good low - temperature opacities available for a solar chemical composition ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) , zero - metallicity opacity tabulations have been restricted to temperatures above @xmath14 so far . in this paper we present calculations of both , rosseland and planck mean opacities for primordial matter including all the three elements ( hydrogen , helium , and lithium ) including deuterium isotope and present their absorption properties . in sect . [ sect : matter ] we discuss the quantitative composition of primordial matter at a given temperature and density . we then describe the relevant absorption processes ( sect.[sect : absproc ] ) and present our rosseland and planck mean opacities ( sect . [ sect : rossplanck ] ) . here , we also assess the influence of lithium on the opacity for different lithium contents . before we compare our results to previous tabulations ( sect.[sect : compare ] ) , we give analytic calculations for the molecule formation timescale in sect . [ sect : chemequilibrium ] in order to estimate the time needed to reach chemical equilibrium which is one of the underlying assumptions in our calculations . finally , we summarize our conclusions in sect . [ sect : conclusion ] . primordial matter as created in the sbbn consists of hydrogen ( h ) , helium ( he ) , deuterium ( d ) , and lithium ( li ) . before wmap@xcite , the observed abundances of these elements have been used to constrain the baryon - to - photon ratio . in the framework of a @xmath15cdm cosmology wmap provided the value this parameter with high accuracy . while the abundances of h and he were fairly well known for some time , the uncertainties in the determination of the abundances of d and li were significantly reduced . now , the d abundance as derived from cosmological parameters is consistent with direct observations , while the observed li abundance still lacks a factor of 3 compared to the sbbn results . this may indicate either systematic effects in the observations or new physics ( for an in - depth discussion of this issue , see * ? ? ? we summarize the resultant abundances according to sbbn and wmap in table [ tbl : abundances ] ( after * ? ? ? * ) and take them as our _ fiducial _ pop iii mixture . for later comparison purposes we define also a li - free mixture in table [ tbl : abundances ] . .sbbn concordance abundances @xcite from first - year wmap results [ cols="<,^,^",options="header " , ] the match with the opacities ( fig . [ fig : comparisons]a ) is good as long as @xmath16 is the dominant absorption mechanism . for low temperatures , the deviations are due to the use of cia data of @xcite and @xcite while we use the more recent borysow data . the deviations at higher temperatures and densities are due to the influence of the stark broadening of h lines which have been neglected in the calculation . the comparison with @xcite is done for both rosseland and planck means ( fig . [ fig : comparisons]b&c ) . at higher temperatures and densities the deviations in the rosseland mean are again due to stark broadened h lines . for lower temperatures the deviations are only in the 20 - 30 % range , much smaller than with respect to . this is due to their use of the partially newly available cia data of @xmath17 and @xmath18 collisions for the roto - vibrational and roto - translational transitions while still having to use extrapolations for the overtones ( using data by * ? ? ? * ) . for the planck means the differences are considerably higher . this is due to the linearity of planck averaging which prefers peaks in the opacity ( cia at low temperatures , h lines at higher temperatures and lower densities ) . the comparison to the opal opacities for the grevesse & noel chemical composition at z=0 shows a much better concordance over a larger temperature range ( fig . [ fig : comparisons]d&e ) . in the high - temperature limit ( @xmath19 ) the rosseland mean opacities are consistent at the 10% level ( stark broadening ) . for the very highest temperatures , deviations are due to the approximation of the statistical weight of h by the ground state which no longer is true . at lower temperatures we again have a 10 - 20% deviation due to cia . while the inclusion of stark broadening for the rosseland means shows a good consistence with the opal data , there are deviations in the planck means . these differences are due to our coarse frequency grid which does not correctly trace all the peaks of the hydrogen lines . the comparison to the data in fig . [ fig : comparisons]f shows an overall good agreement with our data . the discussion is analogous to the opal comparison . except that now we are consistent at the 10% level accuracy for lower temperatures due to their use of @xmath20 , @xmath21 and more recent @xmath17 and @xmath18 cia data . at densities @xmath22 and temperatures @xmath23 there are , however , important differences . these are due to s use of two different approaches to calculate the @xmath24 abundance in order to overcome machine accuracy problems . in their @xmath25 dominated regime , they take a dissociation energy of @xmath26 whereas we take @xmath27 ( following * ? ? ? * ) . in our calculations , we do not find any problems regarding machine accuracy . the second reason for the deviations is probably due to the difference in @xmath28 absorption coefficients where we use the @xcite data while they use @xcite . rosseland and planck mean opacities for primordial matter have been calculated using the most recent available data for the absorption mechanisms . we tabulate the opacity data in tables e1 , e2 and e3 , for a temperature range @xmath29 and @xmath30 for our pop iii matter composition ( cf . table [ tbl : abundances ] ) . these are the first pop iii opacity tables for temperatures @xmath31 . in order to make application as easy as possible , we provide two sets of planck opacities : planck means including only continuum absorption and those including molecular lines . higher resolution tables including routines for bicubic interpolation tables are available from the authors upon request . it has been shown ( see sect . [ sect : rossplanck ] and [ sect : quantlithium ] ) that the small number fraction of li leads to a significant change in the opacity values at temperatures @xmath32k compared to a pure h / he mixture . the differences can reach up to 2 orders of magnitudes . there are four processes which change the opacity : as an alkali metal , li gets ionized at comparatively low temperatures . it therefore increases the number of available electrons considerably . they increase the thomson scattering contribution to the rosseland mean at low densities while increasing the @xmath33 absorption at higher densities . for both the planck continuum and line case only the @xmath33 absorption at low densities ( no scattering ) is enhanced . in the presence of metals ( e.g. lithium ) @xmath34 is being destroyed . as @xmath34 is the most abundant positive ion at temperatures around @xmath35 and densities @xmath36 it influences the opacity indirectly in changing the chemical equilibrium when being destroyed . furthermore , in part it shows up directly via bound - bound transitions of @xmath34 at intermediate densities . for higher densities this is being drowned by the indirect increase of the @xmath33-absorption . the planck means including line absorption are changed due to absorption by atomic li and molecular lih . for atomic li the most important transition is the @xmath37 feature . the planck function , however , is most sensible to features at @xmath37 for temperatures of approx . @xmath38 , a temperature at which li is ionized , at the latest . absorption via this transition is still important at temperatures around @xmath39 because the corresponding einstein coefficient is very large compared to the quadrupole transitions of molecular and atomic h. at temperatures @xmath40 the influence of @xmath25 is ceasing as the lowest lying transition of @xmath25 has an equivalent temperature of @xmath41 . for lower temperatures either @xmath42 or @xmath43 contribute to the opacities . , however , has got a larger dipole moment and thus has got much larger einstein coefficients and transitions at much lower temperatures ( as low as @xmath44 ) . a critical point in primordial chemistry is the formation of molecules . formation times have been calculated for @xmath25 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 . for densities @xmath45 molecule formation proceeds within one free - fall time ( except @xmath42 , which does not play any significant role in the pop iii case ) . hence the calculation is valid for densities larger than that , provided the free - fall time scale being the shortest timescale relevant , other than the chemical . we give values for densities as low as @xmath46 for numerical convenience . in comparison to previous calculations we find a good agreement of our results when neglecting the newly added absorption mechanisms and the contributions of li . based on our new opacities the influence of li on the different stages of pop iii star formation and evolution can now be assessed . the authors acknowledge support from the _ deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft , dfg _ through grant _ sfb 439 ( a7)_. part of this work was carried out while one of the authors ( mm ) stayed as an eara marie curie fellow at the institute of astronomy , university of cambridge , uk . the hospitality of the ioa , and of prof . pringle in particular , is gratefully acknowledged . the authors thank profs . wehrse and gail for valuable discussions on the subject of this paper , we are grateful to dr . evelyne roueff for providing the hd transition probabilities . this work has made extensive use of nasa s astrophysics data system . t. , anninos p. , zhang y. , norman m. l. , 1997 , new astronomy , 2 , 181 h. , roueff e. , viala y. , 1982 , , 50 , 505 d. r. , ferguson j. w. , 1994 , , 437 , 879 bell k. l. , 1980 , journal of physics b : atomic and molecular physics , 13 , 1859 bell k. l. , berrington k. a. , 1987 , journal of physics b : atomic and molecular physics , 20 , 801 p. , leggett s. k. , 2002 , , 580 , 1070 g. , borysow a. , orton g. s. , 1996 , icarus , 123 , 4 g. , cohen e. r. , 1976 , canadian journal of physics , 54 , 593 a. , 2002 , , 390 , 779 a. , frommhold l. , 1989 , , 341 , 549 a. , frommhold l. , moraldi m. , 1989 , , 336 , 495 a. , jorgensen u. g. , fu y. , 2001 , , 68 , 235 a. , jorgensen u. g. , zheng c. , 1997 , , 324 , 185 j. , frommhold l. , birnbaum g. , 1988 , , 326 , 509 j. , trafton l. , frommhold l. , birnbaum g. , 1985 , , 296 , 644 a. frommhold l. , meyer w. , 1988 , , 88 , 4855 e. , galli d. , 1997 , , 288 , 638 v. , loeb a. , 2004 , new astronomy , 9 , 353 s. , gaur v. p. , pande m. c. , 1991 , , 45 , 57 a. , vangioni - flam e. , descouvemont p. , adahchour a. , angulo c. , 2004 , , 600 , 544 a. n. , 2000 , allen s astrophysical quantities . allen s astrophysical quantities , 4th ed . publisher : new york : aip press ; springer , 2000 . editedy by arthur n. cox . isbn : 0387987460 a. n. , tabor j. e. , 1976 , , 31 , 271 ( = ct76 ) a. , kirby k. , stancil p. c. , 1998 , , 458 , 397 a. , williams d. a. , 1962 , , 136 , 690 j. j. , tout c. a. , 2004 , , 348 , 201 d. , palla f. , 1998 , , 335 , 403 d. , palla f. , 2002 , , 50 , 1197 s. c. o. , 2003 , , 584 , 331 d. f. , 1992 , the observation and analysis of stellar photospheres . cambridge ; new york : cambridge university press , 1992 . 2nd ed . m. , frommhold l. , 2001a , , 546 , 1168 m. , frommhold l. , 2001b , , 115 , 5427 m. , frommhold l. , 2003 , , 400 , 1161 g. j. , lynas - gray a. e. , miller s. , tennyson j. , 2004 , , 600 , 1025 ( = hlmt04 ) k. p. , herzberg g. , 1979 , molecular spectra and molecular structure : iv . constants of diatomic molecules , 1st edn . van nostrand reinhold company k. , van blerkom d. , 1967 , zeitschrift fr astrophysik , 66 , 185 c. a. , rogers f. j. , 1996 , , 464 , 943 t. l. , 1988 , , 193 , 189 t. l. , 1994 , , 269 , 871 u. g. , hammer d. , borysow a. , falkesgaard j. , 2000 , , 361 , 283 w. j. , latter r. , 1961 , , 6 , 167 l. , 2000 , radiation physics and chemistry , 59 , 185 v. s. , presnyakov l. p. , sobelman i. i. , 2000 , astronomy reports , 44 , 338 p. , chernoff d. f. , salpeter e. e. , 1991 , , 76 , 759 ( = len91 ) s. h. , stancil p. c. , dalgarno a. , 2002 , journal of physics b atomic molecular physics , 35 , 57 j. l. , 1969 , , 156 , 989 w. c. , fuhr j. r. , musgrove a. , sugar j. , wiese j. l. , 1999 , nist atomic spectra database ( nist standard reference database 78 ) 2.0 . nist m. r. , 1961 , observatory , 81 , 240 w. , frommhold l. , birnbaum g. , 1989 , , 39 , 2434 d. , 1967 , , 149 , 169 d. , 1978 , stellar atmospheres , 2 edn . san francisco , w. h. freeman and co. , 1978 . 650 p. l. , miller s. , tennyson j. , 1996 , , 464 , 516 l. , tennyson j. , 1995 , , 454 , l169 f. , salpeter e. e. , stahler s. w. , 1983 , , 271 , 632 r. w. , 1968 , , 49 r. w. , 1971 , , 11 , 1331 g. , saraph h. e. , seaton m. j. , 1988 , journal of physics b atomic molecular physics , 21 , 3669 p. j. e. , dicke r. h. , 1968 , , 154 , 891 g. b. , lightman a. p. , 1979 , radiative processes in astrophysics . new york , wiley - interscience , 1979 . 393 p. w. c. , zipoy d. , 1967 , nature , 216 , 967 m. j. , yan y. , mihalas d. , pradhan a. k. , 1994 , , 266 , 805 d. , henning t. , helling c. , ilgner m. , sedlmayr e. , 2003 , , 410 , 611 z. , read w. g. , 1993 , , 50 , 635 k. s. , miller s. , tennyson j. , 1992 , , 255 , 453 d. n. , verde l. , peiris h. v. , komatsu e. , nolta m. r. , bennett c. l. , halpern m. , hinshaw g. , jarosik n. , kogut a. , limon m. , meyer s. s. , page l. , tucker g. s. , weiland j. l. , wollack e. , wright e. l. , 2003 , , 148 , 175 s. w. , palla f. , salpeter e. e. , 1986 , , 302 , 590 ( = sps86 ) p. , 1994a , , 51 , 655 p. , 1996 , , 54 , 849 p. c. , 1994b , , 430 , 360 p. c. , dalgarno a. , 1997 , , 490 , 76 p. c. , lepp s. , dalgarno a. , 1996 , , 458 , 401 c. , hutcheon r. , 1999 , , 140 , 93 r. s. , 1998 , , 300 , 321 j. b. , 1966 , publications of the dominion astrophysical observatory victoria , 13 , 1 j. , sutcliffe b. t. , 1984 , mol . , 51 , 887 j. , 1957a , physica , 23 , 825 j. , 1957b , physica , 24 , 347 j. , kiss z. j. , 1959 , canadian j. phys . , 37 , 1187 w. l. , smith m. w. , glennon b. m. , 1966 , atomic transition probabilities . vol . : hydrogen through neon . a critical data compilation . nsrds - nbs 4 , washington , d.c . : us department of commerce , national buereau of standards , 1966 a. w. , 1979 , , 187 , 59p l. , simbotin i. , dalgarno a. , 1998 , , 115 , 293 m. , sadeghpour h. r. , dalgarno a. , 1998 , , 496 , 1044 m. , sadeghpour h. r. , dalgarno a. , 2001 , , 559 , 1194 w. t. , stwalley w. c. , 1980 , , 73 , 5584 primordial matter is assumed to consist of a number fraction @xmath47 of element e. depending on the density , we define the number densities of the involved elements @xmath48 we need 4 equations ( [ eq : h][eq : li ] ) to describe the conservation of the number densities of the elements ( mass conservation ) and an additional one ( [ eq : charge ] ) to take care of charge neutrality . the number density of species x is called @xmath49 $ ] . @xmath50}}}+{{{\left[}{\textup{h}}{\right ] } } } + { { { \left[}{\textup{h}}^+ { \right ] } } } + 3{{{\left[}{\textup{h}}_3^+ { \right]}}}+ 2\left ( { { { \left[}{\textup{h}}_2 { \right ] } } } + { { { \left[}{\textup{h}}_2^+ { \right]}}}\right ) & = & n_{\textup{h}}\label{eq : h}\\ { { { \left[}{\textup{he}}{\right]}}}+{{{\left[}{\textup{he}}^+ { \right ] } } } + { { { \left[}{\textup{he}}^{++ } { \right]}}}+2{{{\left[}{\textup{he}}_2^+ { \right ] } } } & = & n_{{\textup{he}}}\\ { { { \left[}{\textup{hd}}{\right]}}}+{{{\left[}{\textup{d}}{\right]}}}+{{{\left[}{\textup{d}}^+ { \right ] } } } + { { { \left[}{\textup{h}}_2{\textup{d}}^+ { \right]}}}&= & n_{{\textup{d } } } \\ { { { \left[}{\textup{lih}}{\right]}}}+{{{\left[}{\textup{li}}{\right]}}}+{{{\left[}{\textup{li}}^+ { \right]}}}+{{{\left[}{\textup{li}}^{++ } { \right ] } } } & = & n_{{\textup{li } } } \label{eq : li}\\ { { { \left[}{\textup{e}^-}{\right]}}}+{{{\left[}{\textup{h}}^- { \right]}}}-{{{\left[}{\textup{h}}^+ { \right]}}}-{{{\left[}{\textup{h}}_2^+ { \right]}}}-{{{\left[}{\textup{h}}_3^+ { \right]}}}-{{{\left[}{\textup{he}}^+ { \right ] } } } & & \notag\\ -2{{{\left[}{\textup{he}}_2^+ { \right ] } } } - { { { \left[}{\textup{d}}^+ { \right ] } } } - { { { \left[}{\textup{h}}_2{\textup{d}}^+ { \right ] } } } - { { { \left[}{\textup{li}}^+ { \right ] } } } - { { { \left[}{\textup{li}}^{++ } { \right ] } } } & = & \label{eq : charge}0\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that we neglect the h contribution of the d and l species in the h sum . given the relative number fraction of d and li with respect to h this assumption is satisfied . the equilibrium constants are given in table [ tbl : eqconst ] . for the a @xmath51 b+c saha equilibria we use equations of the form @xmath52 with @xmath53 and @xmath54 . @xmath55 is the characteristic energy for ionisation or dissociation , @xmath56 the partition function of the contributing species . for @xmath25-dissociation we use @xmath57 and correct the equilibrium constant with the symmetry factor for a homonuclear molecule @xcite . for the solution of the system of equations we define a critical temperature @xmath58 above which we solve the full system including the charge neutrality condition . we call this the _ ionic limit_. below @xmath59 we neglect all ions and solve ( [ eq : h]-[eq : li ] ) in the molecular limit . in the ionic limit , we start with an initial guess of @xmath60}}}$ ] , solve eqns . ( [ eq : h]-[eq : li ] ) to derive a new @xmath60}}}$ ] from the neutrality condition eq . ( [ eq : charge ] ) . iteration is done with @xmath60}}}\rightarrow \sqrt{{{{\left[}{\textup{e}^-}{\right]}}}_\mathrm{new } { { { \left[}{\textup{e}^-}{\right]}}}_\mathrm{old}}$ ] . after 20 - 50 iterations convergence is reached . the solution of eqns . ( [ eq : h]-[eq : li ] ) is done analytically and would involve a cubic equation in the case of eq . ( [ eq : h ] ) , otherwise only quadratic equations are involved . the cubic term in the h species equation arises due the inclusion of the @xmath24 abundance . as this species never is the main contributor to the number density , we neglect it in the number density conservation . note that we also neglect the h containing d and li species in the h conservation equation . since we have @xmath61 and @xmath62 this assumption is justified . in the molecular limit we have to solve analytically only eqns . ( [ eq : h]-[eq : li ] ) neglecting ions . the absorption coefficient @xmath63 @xmath64 $ ] for the @xmath65 transition can be written as @xmath66 where @xmath67 the profile function , @xmath68 is the number density of atoms in state 1 , @xmath69 the einstein coefficient and @xmath70 the transition frequency . in relation to the ground state we have @xmath71 where @xmath72 and @xmath73 are the energies of the states relative to the ground state . in terms of the total number density @xmath74 @xmath75 via @xmath76 we easily can transform to the usually used einstein coefficient for spontaneous emission , @xmath77 . evaluating @xmath78 yields ( @xmath79 ) the integrated absorption coefficient @xmath80 @xmath81 $ ] @xmath82 where we made use of the approximation @xmath83 across the line . for planck averaging we furthermore assume @xmath84 across the line . then the line contribution of the @xmath65 transition is @xmath85 where we introduced the wavenumber @xmath86 corresponding to the @xmath87 transition . multiplied with @xmath88 , the last expression only depends on the temperature . calculated once for each species summing up all the lines for the temperature grid chosen , it can be added directly to the planck mean with the density weight @xmath89 . note that we make use of the einstein coefficient @xmath69 , which is related to the einstein coefficient for spontaneous emission @xmath77 through the einstein relation @xmath90 . we have fitted the equilibrium constant @xmath92 to the 6 parameter function ( @xmath93 ) @xmath94 with the coefficients @xmath95 this fit causes maximum deviations of 4 @xmath96 of @xmath97 for @xmath98 , whereas the maximum deviation never exceeds 8 @xmath96 below @xmath99 . @xmath100 correspond to the enthalpy of @xmath101 for the reaction @xmath102 , divided by the @xmath103 factor due to basis conversion . opacity mean values are usually tabulated in the @xmath104-plane , where @xmath105 . @xmath106 is the temperature in units of @xmath107 k , @xmath108 the density . using this @xmath109-parameter , the tables remain rectangular over large temperature ranges . we have the gas ( @xmath110 ) and radiation ( @xmath111 ) pressure ( here in the optically thick case ) @xmath112 calculating the ratio and taking the logarithm we have @xmath113 subtracting the logarithmized definition of @xmath114 , we have @xmath115 for @xmath116 gas and radiation pressure are equal . as the range of @xmath117 usually tabulated is @xmath118 ( opal , op project ) , @xmath119 is in the middle of this coordinate range . the physical meaning of introducing @xmath117 is that one remains in the physical regime where gas and radiation pressure compete with each other . too large departures from this equality require changes in the eos . therefore the each column of opacity tables in the style of opal & op represent different gas / radiation pressure ratios . sample tables for rosseland and planck means are given in tables e1 , e2 and e3 ( will be available in the accepted version ) .

we present newly calculated low - temperature opacities for gas with a primordial chemical composition . in contrast to earlier calculations which took a pure metal - free hydrogen / helium mixture , we take into account the small fractions of deuterium and lithium as resulting from standard big bang nucleosynthesis . our opacity tables cover the density range @xmath0 < -2 $ ] and temperature range of @xmath1 < 4.6 $ ] , while previous tables were usually restricted to @xmath2 . we find that , while the presence of deuterium does not significantly alter the opacity values , the presence of lithium gives rise to major modifications of the opacities , at some points increasing it by approximately 2 orders of magnitude relative to pure hydrogen / helium opacities . [ firstpage ] nuclear reactions , nucleosynthesis , abundances cosmology : early universe atomic data molecular data

astro-ph9909283

the nature of anomalous x - ray pulsars ( axps ) has been a mystery since the discovery of the first example ( 1e 2259 + 586 ) nearly 20 years ago ( @xcite ) . the properties of axps can be summarized as follows ( see also @xcite ) : they exhibit x - ray pulsations in the range @xmath4512 s ; they have pulsed x - ray luminosities in the range @xmath5 erg s@xmath2 ; they spin down regularly within the limited timing observations available , with some exceptions ; their x - ray luminosities are much greater than the rate of loss of rotational kinetic energy inferred from the observed spin - down ; they have spectra that are characterized by thermal emission with @xmath6 kev , with evidence for a hard tail in some sources ; they are found in the plane of the galaxy ; and two of the six certain members of the class appear to be located at the geometric centers of apparent supernova remnants ( @xcite ) . soft gamma repeaters also exhibit axp - like pulsations in quiescence ( e.g. @xcite ) . mereghetti & stella ( 1995 ) suggested that axps are accreting from a low mass companion . however increasingly this model has become difficult to reconcile with observations . the absence of doppler shifts even on short time scales ( e.g. @xcite ) , the absence of a detectable optical / ir companion or accretion disk ( see @xcite ) , the apparent associations with supernova remnants , the apparent steady spin down within the limits of current observations ( e.g. @xcite ) , and axp spectra that are very different from those of known accreting sources , all argue against an accretion origin for the x - rays . recently , it has been argued that the axps are young , isolated , highly magnetized neutron stars or `` magnetars '' ( @xcite ) . evidence for this is primarily the inferred strength of the surface dipolar magnetic field required to slow the pulsar down _ in vacuo _ : @xmath7 g. the spin - down ages in this model , inferred assuming small birth spin periods , are in the range of @xmath48200 kyr . this suggested youth is supported by the two apparent supernova remnant associations . additional circumstantial supporting evidence comes from axps location close to the galactic plane , consistent with their being isolated neutron stars near their birth place , as well as from interpreting apparent deviations from spin - down as glitches ( @xcite ) similar to those seen in radio pulsars ( e.g. @xcite ) . recently , deviations from simple spin - down have been suggested , under the magnetar hypothesis , to be due to radiative precession , originating in the asphericity of the neutron star produced by the strong magnetic field ( @xcite ) . one way to test both the magnetar and accretion models is through timing observations . the spin down of some axps has been monitored by considering the measured frequency at individual epochs ( e.g. @xcite ) . however those measurements have been sparse and are only marginally sensitive to spin irregularities on time scales of weeks to months , relevant to glitches or accretion torque fluctuations . further , high - precision determination of the spin evolution over a long baseline is necessary to look for `` timing noise '' as is seen in many young radio pulsars ( e.g. @xcite ) , to obtain a reliable measurement of a braking index , and to search for precession ( @xcite ) . whether such high precision is possible to achieve with axp timing has not , until now , been established . here we report on x - ray monitoring observations made with the _ rossi x - ray timing explorer _ ( _ rxte _ ) in which , for the first time , we determine high - precision spin parameters using long - term phase - coherent timing of two axps . the sources , 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910(@xcite ) and 1e 2259 + 586 ( @xcite ) have periods of 11 s and 7 s , respectively . the _ rxte _ axp monitoring project is part of a larger effort to time coherently several axps . results for other sources will be presented elsewhere . our observations were made using the _ rxte _ proportional counter array ( pca ) ( @xcite ) . the detector consists of five identical multi - anode proportional counter units ( pcus ) each containing a front propane anticoincidence layer followed by several xenon / methane layers . the detector operates in the 260 kev range , with a total effective area of @xmath46500 @xmath8 and a 1@xmath9 field of view . in addition to the standard data modes , data were collected in the goodxenonwithpropane mode , which records the arrival time ( 1 @xmath10s resolution ) and energy ( 256-channel resolution ) of every unrejected xenon event as well as all of the propane layer events . to maximize the sensitivity to the targets , which have soft spectra , we restricted the analysis to unrejected events in the top xenon layer of each pcu and chose an optimal energy range for each source : absolute channels 614 ( 2.55.4 kev ) for 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 and absolute channels 624 ( 2.59.1 kev ) for 1e 2259 + 586 . the observations were reduced using mit - developed software for handling raw spacecraft telemetry packet data . data from the different pcus were merged and binned at 62.5 ms and 31.25 ms resolution for 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 and 1e 2259 + 586 , respectively . the data were then reduced to barycentric dynamical time ( tdb ) at the solar system barycenter using the source positions in table 1 and the jpl de200 solar system ephemeris ( @xcite ) and stored on disk as one time series per observing epoch . our strategy for attempting phase - coherent timing of these sources made use of standard radio pulsar techniques . pulse phase at any time @xmath11 can be expressed as @xmath12 where @xmath13 is a reference epoch , and @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the spin frequency and its time derivative . phase - coherent timing amounts to counting all pulses over the entire observing span . to achieve this , uncertainties in the first - gues spin parameters @xmath14 and @xmath15 must be sufficiently small that the discrepancy between observed and predicted arrival time differ by only a fraction of the period . to achieve this goal , we observed each source at two closely spaced epochs ( i.e. within one day ) , then at a third epoch several days later . this spacing was chosen to determine an initial @xmath14 , by absolute pulse numbering , of sufficient precision to predict @xmath16 for the next observation roughly one month later . subsequent monitoring was done at roughly one month intervals . once phase connection was achieved with the @xmath46 months of monitoring data , we also included public _ rxte _ archival data . for 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 , the total data set consists of 19 arrival times obtained between 1998 january 13 and 1999 may 26 . for 1e 2259 + 586 , we have 33 arrival times obtained between 1996 september 29 and 1999 may 12 . our procedure included the following steps . the first barycentered , binned time series for the closely spaced set of three observations were folded at the best - estimate period determined via fourier transform , using a unique reference epoch . the folded pulse profiles were cross - correlated with a high - signal - to - noise template in the fourier domain and the phase offsets were recorded . we suppressed high - order harmonics in the pulse profile using a frequency - domain filter to avoid contamination by bin - to - bin poisson fluctuations . a precise @xmath14 was then determined by demanding that an integer number of pulses occur between each observation . profiles were then re - folded , still with respect to a fixed epoch , using the improved @xmath14 . after each new observation , this process was repeated , also including the effect of @xmath15 . phase residuals were examined to verify that there were no missed pulses , then fit with a quadratic function to determine the optimal @xmath14 and @xmath15 . uncertainties on measured pulse phases were determined using monte carlo simulations . we verified this procedure and its results by extracting absolute average pulse arrival times in tdb at the solar system barycenter from the optimally folded profiles , and using the tempo pulsar timing software package ( http://pulsar.princeton.edu/tempo ) , in common use in radio pulsar timing . best fit @xmath14 and @xmath15 for each source are given in table [ ta : parms ] . these values were measured with @xmath17 fixed at zero . corresponding arrival time residuals are shown in figures 1 and 2 . in both cases , the rms residual is @xmath40.01@xmath18 , where @xmath19 . we also tried fitting for @xmath17 ; the results are given in table [ ta : parms ] . for 1e 2259 + 586 , the fitted @xmath17 is consistent with zero ; we provide a @xmath20 upper limit . for 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 , the fitted @xmath17 is marginally significant at the 4@xmath21 level ; however , a fit omitting only the first point reduces the significance to 2.6@xmath21 . we therefore quote the current best - fit value in parentheses only ; further timing observations will decide if the observed @xmath17 is truly significant . using a very simple spin - down model , we have maintained phase coherence for1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 and 1e 2259 + 586 with phase residuals of only @xmath41% , comparable to or smaller than those measured for most radio pulsars ( e.g. @xcite ) . this demonstrates that these axps are extremely stable rotators . this stability is consistent with the magnetar hypothesis because isolated rotating neutron stars are expected to spin - down with great regularity , as is seen in the radio pulsar population . we can compare our pulse ephemerides with past period measurements to see whether there have been a deviation from a simple spin - down law . for 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 , only two previous period measurements have been reported ( @xcite ) . the pulse parameters listed in table [ ta : parms ] , extrapolated to the epochs of the previous observations , agree with the published values within uncertainties . thus , the spin - down has been regular for at least 1.4 yr prior to the commencement of our observations . for 1e 2259 + 586 , spin frequencies have been measured occasionally since 1978 ( see baykal & swank 1996 and references therein ) . figure [ fig : freq2259 ] shows the differences between previously measured spin frequencies and those predicted by our timing ephemeris ( table [ ta : parms ] ) . the error bars represent the published one standard deviation measurement uncertainties . our measured @xmath15 is not consistent with the long - term @xmath15 : all observed frequencies were significantly larger than predicted by the extrapolation of the current @xmath14 and @xmath15 . a least squares fit to the data shown in figure [ fig : freq2259 ] gives @xmath22 hz s@xmath2 , though the linear fit is poor because of apparent short - time - scale fluctuations . thus , the current value of @xmath15 , measured over the past 2.6 yr , is smaller than that of the long - term trend by @xmath23% . melatos ( 1999 ) suggests that the large magnetic field inferred in the magnetar model should result in significant deviations from sphericity of the neutron star , with the principle axis misaligned with the spin axis . under such circumstances , the star undergoes radiative precession with period @xmath410 yr . given the epoch and duration of our observations of 1e 2259 + 586 , the manifestation of such precession is completely covariant with @xmath15 . however , the implied deviation of @xmath15 from the long - term trend is consistent with the melatos ( 1999 ) prediction , though smaller by a factor @xmath43.5 . an unambiguous test of this model can be provided by periodic timing residuals on a time scale of a decade . note that the change in @xmath15 that we observe for 1e 2259 + 586 relative to the long - term trend is not consistent with those observed after glitches in radio pulsars , in which the absolute magnitude of the post - glitch @xmath15 is larger than the pre - glitch value ( @xcite ) . radio pulsars , especially young ones , exhibit deviations from simple spin - down laws which appear to be a result of random processes ( @xcite ) . these deviations are not physically understood and are commonly referred to as `` timing noise '' ( see @xcite for a review ) . the measured @xmath17 s for 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 and 1e 2259 + 586(table [ ta : parms ] ) can be compared with those of radio pulsars . noise level has been quantified by arzoumanian et al . ( 1994 ) by the statistic @xmath24 and @xmath25 for 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 and 1e 2259 + 586 , respectively . these values place these objects clearly among the radio pulsar population on the @xmath26@xmath27 plot of arzoumanian et al . ( 1994 ) , as was suggested for 1e 2259 + 586 and 1e 1048.1@xmath05937 by heyl & hernquist ( 1997 ) on the basis of sparser , incoherent data . torque noise in the accreting pulsar population would generally predict much larger values of @xmath17 ( @xcite , although see also @xcite ) . one caveat is that the 8 s accreting x - ray pulsar 4u 1626@xmath067 is known to be in a close binary orbit with a low - mass companion , with orbital period 42 min ( @xcite ) . the x - ray pulsations show no doppler shifts ( @xcite ) , implying that we are viewing the orbit nearly face - on . timing observations of 4u 1626@xmath067 over @xmath48 yr permit phase - coherent timing , except near one epoch where the spin - down rate abruptly changed sign ( @xcite ) . the apparent change in spin - down rate we have detected for 1e 2259 + 586 is plausible as a change in accretion torque . however , if the x - rays observed for the two axps considered here had an accretion origin , the orbits must both be viewed face - on as well , which is unlikely . furthermore the much harder x - ray spectrum of 4u 1626@xmath067 ( @xcite ) , which is consistent with other accreting sources , is very different from those of any of the known axps , including 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 and 1e 2259 + 586 . an alternative model for axps , that they are massive white dwarfs , also predicts regular spin down ( @xcite ) . in this model , the larger moment of inertia hence larger spin - down luminosity accounts for the observed @xmath28 . however , if the observed x - rays have a thermal origin , e.g. emission from hot gas heated by positrons near the polar cap ( @xcite ) , the implied hot spot is implausibly small ( @xcite ) . also , data obtained with the egret instrument aboard the _ compton gamma - ray observatory _ show ( d. thompson , personal communication ) that the high - energy @xmath29-ray flux from 1e 2259 + 586 is smaller than predicted in the white dwarf model ( @xcite ) . furthermore , an observable supernova remnant , as is seen surrounding 1e 2259 + 586 ( ctb 109 ) , is not expected for a white dwarf . note that the absence of a possibly associated supernova remnant is not evidence against an axp being a young neutron star , given the limited observability of some remnants associated with very young pulsars ( e.g. @xcite ) . with the stability of the rotation of 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 and 1e 2259 + 586 established , the door is now open for unambiguously testing the magnetar model . in particular , although neither source has glitched during our observations , which implies glitch activity lower than in some comparably young radio pulsars ( e.g. @xcite ) , future glitches will be easily identified . also , for 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 , a braking index of 3 , expected if the source is spinning down due to magnetic dipole radiation , should be measurable in another year , although its measurement could be complicated by timing noise , precessional effects and/or glitches . the periodic precession predicted by melatos ( 1999 ) could be clearly confirmed or ruled out in the next few years of _ rxte_monitoring , particularly if earlier observations made with other observatories can be incorporated . we thank e. morgan , j. lackey and g. weinberg for help with software , a. melatos for useful conversations , and d. thompson for the egret analysis . vmk acknowledges use of nasa ltsa grant number nag5 - 8063 . this work was also supported in part by nasa grant nag5 - 4114 to dc . standish , e. m. , newall , x. x. , williams , j. g. , & yeomans , d. k. 1992 , in explanatory supplement to the astronomical almanac , ed . k. seidelmann , ( mill valley , california : university science books ) , 279 ccc r.a . ( j2000 ) & 17@xmath30 08@xmath31 47@xmath32 & 23@xmath30 01@xmath31 [email protected] + dec ( j2000 ) & @xmath33 08@xmath34 51@xmath35 & + 58@xmath36 52@xmath34 46@xmath35 + first observing epoch ( mjd ) & 50826 & 50355 + last observing epoch ( mjd ) & 51324 & 51310 + total number of observations & 19 & 33 + @xmath14 ( hz ) & 0.0909169331(5 ) & 0.1432880613(2 ) + @xmath15 ( @xmath37 hz s@xmath2 ) & @xmath015.687(4 ) & @xmath01.0026(7 ) + @xmath38 ( @xmath39 hz s@xmath40 ) & [ 29(7 ) ] & [ 2.3(1.0 ) ] + @xmath18 ( s ) & 10.99905117(6 ) & 6.97894850(1 ) + @xmath27 ( @xmath41 ) & 189.78(5 ) & 4.883(3 ) + epoch of @xmath14 ( mjd ) & 51215.931 & 51195.583 + r.m.s . residual ( ms ) & 129 & 61 + [ ta : parms ]

we report on long - term x - ray timing of two anomalous x - ray pulsars , 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 and 1e 2259 + 586 , using the _ rossi x - ray timing explorer . _ in monthly observations made over 1.4 yr and 2.6 yr for the two pulsars , respectively , we have obtained phase - coherent timing solutions which imply that these objects have been rotating with great stability throughout the course of our observations . for 1rxs j170849.0@xmath0400910 , we find a rotation frequency of 0.0909169331(5 ) hz and frequency derivative @xmath1 hz s@xmath2 , for epoch mjd 51215.931 . for 1e 2259 + 586 , we find a rotation frequency of 0.1432880613(2 ) hz , and frequency derivative @xmath3 hz s@xmath2 , for epoch mjd 51195.583 . rms phase residuals from these simple models are only @xmath40.01 cycles for both sources . we show that the frequency derivative for 1e 2259 + 586 is inconsistent with that inferred from incoherent frequency observations made over the last 20 yr . our observations are consistent with the magnetar hypothesis and make binary accretion scenarios appear unlikely . to appear in the astrophysical journal letters

1505.00872

the outbreak of ebola virus disease ( evd ) in west africa 2014 revealed many challenges in predicting and controlling the spread of infectious diseases . these challenges are partly related to the mathematical modeling of the dynamics of the epidemic . providing accurate predictions appeared to be extremely difficult . to address these challenges , several new models have been suggested each providing quite different results , for example @xcite . we also note that different aspects of possible control have been intensively studied in the literature including distribution strategies for vaccination and antibiotic programs @xcite as well as travel restrictions @xcite . in this paper we concentrate on the development of models that are well suited to the control of an outbreak . the most commonly studied models in this area deal with temporal networks @xcite where several different models have been suggested . in @xcite the 1995 ebola outbreak in congo is considered using an seir model whereby control intervention , performed at time @xmath0 is described by the transmission coefficient @xmath1 defined by @xmath2 if @xmath3 and @xmath4 for @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the initial transmission rate that would remain stable without the intervention . our paper models and studies an alternative control mechanism to decrease in the transmission of infection based on the model developed in @xcite where the transmission of infection depends mainly on two parameters : the transmission rate @xmath6 and the average time of isolation @xmath7 in contrast to @xcite we assume that the transmission rate @xmath6 does not change over the whole period under consideration . the main dynamic parameter in our model is @xmath8 and all the intervention measures are directed at decreasing @xmath8 and consequently reducing the spread of infection . the average time to hospitalization can be used for the average time of isolation @xmath9 although the isolation of infectious population is not exactly the same as hospitalization " . clearly , as the disease progresses hospitals become short on beds ( as well as staff and supplies ) required to isolate and treat all newly infected individuals . as a result , the number of infected population can grow exponentially . this was the case for the ebola virus epidemic in west africa ( guinea , sierra leone and liberia ) where the spread of infection was highly dangerous during june - november 2014 when the capacity for treating ebola patients was insufficient . it was reported @xcite that during this period ... many clinics and hospitals in all three of the countries worst hit by ebola have effectively been shut down " . after rapidly building new infrastructure and increasing the capacity of beds the outbreak slowed down significantly . starting from january 2015 , the epidemic has moved to the ending phase that involves ensuring capacity for case finding , case management , safe burials and community engagement " ( @xcite - who , ebola situation report , 28 jan 2015 ) . note that in @xcite the hospitalization rate was the parameter showing the greatest change . addressing these issues , this paper suggests new mathematical models that can be used to increase the efficiency of available resources . the main goal here is to keep the model as simple as possible and , at the same time , to have measurable control variables . note that there are many useful control measures that have been intensively studied by introducing more detailed " mathematical models , however such models have less predictive capabilities ( due to overfitting ) . prediction is crucial when considering future planning periods . the main component in the suggested model is the optimal distribution of bed capabilities across countries / regions . this is a very important and difficult problem that requires an accurate prediction of the dynamics of infected population in each region . for example , evaluating the situation of the ebola outbreak , who s ebola situation report on 14 jan 2015 @xcite notes that each of the intense - transmission countries has sufficient capacity to isolate and treat patients , with more than 2 treatment beds per reported confirmed and probable case . however , the uneven geographical distribution of beds and cases , and the under - reporting of cases , means that not all evd cases are isolated in several areas . " in @xcite a new model is introduced to study the dynamics of epidemics by considering the average time for isolation ( denoted by @xmath8 ) of infectious population as a time - dependent parameter . this model is derived from the well studied @xmath10 ( susceptible - infectious - recovery ) model ( e.g. @xcite ) and is similar to models based on transmission rates from infectious population at different generations ( e.g. @xcite ) . the use of time - dependent parameter @xmath8 enables the analysis of future scenarios by considering possible changes in @xmath7 in this paper we extend this approach by developing practical and efficient optimal control models . we denote by @xmath11 the number of infected cases at @xmath12 ( in days ) . assuming that the natural death rate of population ( @xmath13 ) is zero , the equation for @xmath11 is as follows ( see @xcite for more details ) @xmath14 here @xmath15 is the death rate due to disease ; @xmath16 is the average latent period ( in days ) for infected individuals to become infectious ; @xmath8 is the average infectiousness period ( in days ) ; it is the average time required for isolation ( time to hospitalization ) ; and @xmath6 is the transmission rate . moreover , @xmath17 is a gamma ( cumulative ) distribution function ( with p.d.f - @xmath18 ) for deaths due to disease . the fraction @xmath19 in this case represents the proportion of remaining infected cases @xmath20 after @xmath21 days . the sum @xmath22 defines the number of `` active '' infectious population at time @xmath23 it represents the number of infectious population that are not yet isolated and therefore it is the only source of secondary infections . ( for the sake of simplicity we do not consider infections in hospitals and death ceremonies ) . then by setting @xmath24 we obtain model ( 1 ) in @xcite where @xmath13 ( the natural death rate ) in our case is zero . the basic reproduction number @xmath25 is calculated by considering the stationary states in ( [ x ] ) : @xmath26.\ ] ] there are three main parameters in ( [ x ] ) - @xmath27 and @xmath7 the results obtained in @xcite show that this model provides quite good approximation to the total number infected cases and deaths during the current ebola epidemic if @xmath8 is a piecewise constant function ( in fact , constant over consequent subintervals with durations 2 - 3 months ) and the parameters @xmath15 and @xmath6 are constant over the whole period . these results help us to predict the dynamics of an infected population at future time intervals by keeping the values of @xmath15 and @xmath6 unchanged ( estimated from the previous period ) and considering different possible changes in @xmath7 in this case the major strategy of preventive intervention is the achievement of some decrease in @xmath8 that according to ( [ r ] ) is equivalent to decreasing the effective reproduction number . this approach is implemented below by introducing an optimal control models where the average time to hospitalization @xmath8 is the key variable . according to the results of data fitting mentioned above , it is sufficient to let @xmath8 be constant on quite long time intervals ( months ) . + * control @xmath28 . * therefore , we define @xmath29 as a control variable by assuming that it is piece - wise constant with integer values ( days ) . for the sake of simplicity let @xmath30 , ~ j = 1 , 2 , \cdots , p.\ ] ] it is reasonable to assume that @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the minimal number of days required to isolate infectious population . + * trajectory @xmath33 . * given control @xmath28 we define trajectory @xmath34 as follows @xmath35 in this formula the sum @xmath36 represents the number of infectious individuals that are not yet isolated . considering the average length of hospital stay ( in days ) , the number of hospitalized cases at @xmath37 can be calculated as @xmath38 note that , recent studies ( see for example @xcite ) show that @xmath39 is around 6.5 days . in this section we provide some numerical experiments based on data from guinea , sierra - leon and liberia . we consider the cumulative number of infectious cases and deaths denoted by @xmath40 and @xmath41 respectively . they can be calculated as here @xmath44 is the death rate of infectious population in generation @xmath45 and @xmath46 is a large number . parameters of the gamma distribution function @xmath47 are taken from @xcite where @xmath48 with mean value 7.5 . moreover , we set @xmath49 and @xmath50 as in @xcite . in the considered model ( [ xrt ] ) there are only three parameters @xmath15 and @xmath6 ( constants ) and a piece - wise constant control function @xmath29 that need to be optimized to fit data - the total number of infectious population and deaths . the aim here is to show that there exists a control @xmath29 such that the corresponding trajectory @xmath11 fits data well . + we consider three consequent intervals @xmath51 $ ] @xmath52 for each country and find optimal values @xmath53 @xmath6 and @xmath54 @xmath52 where @xmath55 the results are presented in table [ table_r_k ] . the last time point @xmath56 is 01-mar-2015 . the values of @xmath57 are as follows : 22-march , 23-may , 20-july and 04-dec-2014 for guinea ; 27-may , 20-june , 20-august and 04-dec-2014 for sierra leone ; and 16-june , 20-july , 07-sept and 04-dec-2014 for liberia . each interval @xmath58 has its own reproduction number @xmath59 that defines the shape of the best fits presented in figure [ fig02 ] . data were retrieved from the who website @xcite for the cumulative numbers of clinical cases ( confirmed , probable and suspected ) collected till 1 march 2015 . the global optimization algorithm dso in global and non - smooth optimization ( ganso ) library @xcite is applied for solving optimization problems in this section as well as in section [ example ] . .results of best fits : the ( effective ) reproduction numbers @xmath59 and average times to hospitalization @xmath54 ( in days ) for different intervals @xmath60 @xmath61 the optimal values for @xmath15 and @xmath6 are also provided ; they are constant for a whole period [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] 99 c.l . althaus . estimating the reproduction number of ebola virus ( ebov ) during the 2014 outbreak in west africa . , 2014 ( http://currents.plos.org/outbreaks/article/estimating-the-reproduction-number-of-zaire-ebolavirus-ebov-during-the-2014-outbreak-in-west-africa/ ) . g. chowell , n. w hengartner , c. castillo - chavez , p.w . fenimore , and j.m . the basic reproductive number of ebola and the effects of public health measures : the cases of congo and uganda . , 229(1):119126 , 2004 .

this paper introduces a new optimal control model to describe and control the dynamics of infectious diseases . in the present model , the average time of isolation ( i.e. hospitalization ) of infectious population is the main time - dependent parameter that defines the spread of infection . all the preventive measures aim to decrease the average time of isolation under given constraints .

math0601650

active magnetic bearings ( ambs ) are being employed in a variety of rotating machines ( e.g. , compressors , milling spindles , and flywheels ) in place of conventional mechanical bearings . due to the non - contact nature of the magnetic bearings and rotor , ambs have the unique ability to suspend loads with no friction , operate rotors at higher speeds , and operate in applications where the use of lubricants is prohibited . since ambs can be actively controlled , they offer other potential advantages over mechanical bearings , viz . , the elimination of vibration through active damping , the adjustment of the stiffness of the suspended load , and the automatic balancing of rotors . ambs are normally operated with all electromagnets active at all times . an alternative mode of operation is to activate only one electromagnet along each direction at any given time . although posing more difficulty to the control design , this switching operation prevents opposing electromagnets from producing counteracting forces , and thus helps reduce power consumption . typically , an amb is operated by introducing a sufficiently high , fixed magnetic flux in each electromagnet , which is referred to as the _ bias flux_. the bias value is normally set to a fraction of the saturation flux of the electromagnet . this procedure facilitates the design of the amb ` control ' flux , which is superimposed on the bias flux . specifically , this conservative practice allows the system to be modeled by a controllable linear system , thus , enabling the use of linear control design techniques ; see for example @xcite . although the bias flux facilitates the control synthesis , it increases electric power losses in the amb system , causing rotor heating and affecting the machine efficiency . while lowering or eliminating the bias flux is desirable in order to minimize power losses , it enhances the amb system nonlinearities and may lead to a control saturation or singularity . due to these conflicting objectives , the design of amb controllers with reduced power loss is a challenging problem . in this paper , we consider the problem of low - bias control of ambs operating in the switching mode with the constraint that the input voltages are amplitude limited . this problem was previously addressed in @xcite using the nested saturation design method of teel @xcite . in addition , an optimal solution was sought to the power - loss minimization problem under voltage saturation in @xcite . ( a comprehensive literature review of low- , asymptotic - zero- , and zero - bias amb controllers _ without _ voltage saturation can be found in @xcite . ) here , we pursue a different approach to stabilizing the amb model of @xcite . namely , we use a _ forwarding - like _ method @xcite to design a control law of arbitrarily small amplitude that renders the amb system globally asymptotically stable ( gas ) to the origin . the main differences between our approach and @xcite are : ( i ) we allow the use of different saturation functions ( both ` hard ' and ` soft ' ) , thus providing more flexibility in the control implementation , and ( ii ) we provide an explicit construction for a ` global ' control lyapunov function ( clf ) for the system . this contrasts with the result of @xcite , which relies on the standard ` hard ' saturation and whose lyapunov - like function is only an ` asymptotic ' clf for the system , i.e. , a clf only when the system operates in a certain region of the state space . the rest of this paper is organized as follows . in section [ model ] , we introduce the amb model and motivate our stabilization problem . in section [ sec3 ] , we prove a lemma that constructs a stabilizing controller of arbitrarily small amplitude and a clf for a three - dimensional chain of integrators . in section [ sec4 ] , we use our lemma to construct a clf and corresponding stabilizing feedback for the amb model . we provide a numerical example in section [ sec5 ] , and we close in section [ sec6 ] with a summary of our work . the original nonlinear electromechanical model of the one degree - of - freedom amb system shown in figure 1 below can be subdivided into the mechanical subsystem dynamics , the magnetic force equation , and the electrical subsystem dynamics . the mechanical subsystem is governed by @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the rotor mass , @xmath2 represents the position of the rotor center , @xmath3 is the magnetic flux in the @xmath4th electromagnet , @xmath5 denotes the force produced by the @xmath4th electromagnet , given by @xcite @xmath6 @xmath7 is the permeability of air , and @xmath8 is the cross - sectional area of the electromagnet . the electrical subsystem is governed by the equations @xcite @xmath9 where @xmath10 denotes the number of coil turns in the electromagnet , @xmath11 is the resistance of the @xmath4th electromagnet coil , @xmath12 is the input control voltage of the @xmath4th electromagnet , @xmath13 is the current in the @xmath4th electromagnet which is related to the flux according to @xcite @xmath14 and @xmath15 is the nominal air gap . in this paper , we use the new form proposed in @xcite for the amb dynamics in the switching mode of operation . we only outline the model derivation here , and refer the reader to @xcite for the details and justification . consider that the flux is given by @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the constant _ bias _ flux and @xmath18 is the _ control _ flux . generalized _ control flux be defined as @xmath19 and consider the voltage switching strategy @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the _ generalized _ control voltage . based on ( [ flux])-([switch ] ) , the amb model ( [ mech])-([elec ] ) has the equivalent form @xmath22 where @xmath23 and the coil resistance was neglected for simplicity . now , consider that the input voltages to the original amb model are amplitude limited , i.e. , @xmath24 , @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the known limit . defining the states @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath29 and the change of input @xmath30 , the above model becomes @xmath31 where @xmath32 and @xmath33 , with the input constraint @xmath34 . our goal in this work is to design a feedback control law @xmath35 , satisfying the above saturation constraint , such that @xmath36 is gas where @xmath37 . the gas property means there is a continuously differentiable ( @xmath38 ) function @xmath39 that is radially unbounded and zero only at the origin , and for which the derivative @xmath40 along all trajectories of the system in closed - loop with the controller @xmath35 is negative definite . a function @xmath41 satisfying these requirements for some feedback @xmath35 is called a clf for ( [ xdot amb ] ) @xcite . see @xcite for a discussion on the relation between the global asymptotic stability of @xmath42 and the stability of the original amb states . in the following lemma , we use a forwarding - like approach based on @xcite to construct a clf and corresponding stabilizing state feedback of arbitrarily small amplitude for a three - dimensional chain of integrators . we let @xmath43 denote the standard saturation projecting @xmath44 onto @xmath45 $ ] , i.e. , @xmath46 when @xmath47 and @xmath48 otherwise . however , see remark 1 below for a version of our construction where the hard saturation @xmath43 is replaced by a smoother function . [ mainlemma ] consider the chain of integrators @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the control input . let @xmath51 be given and @xmath52 define the change of variables @xmath53 and the functions @xmath54 g(z_{1},z_{2},z_{3 } ) & = & \frac{\delta } { c_{1}}\sigma ( z_{1})+4\left ( 1+u(z_{2},z_{3})\right ) \nonumber \\ & & \times \left ( z_{3}+\sigma ( z_{2})\right ) -\frac{\delta } { 2}\left ( z_{2}+z_{3}\right ) . \label{g}\end{aligned}\ ] ] then the function @xmath55 is a clf for ( [ chain ] ) since its derivative along the trajectories of system ( [ chain ] ) in closed loop with the control @xmath56 is negative definite . in particular , the bounded control ( [ ubar ] ) renders ( [ chain ] ) gas to the origin . the saturation function @xmath43 from lemma [ mainlemma ] is lipschitz continuous but not continuously differentiable . we chose this hard saturation for simplicity of analysis . however , one can prove a similar result with smoother saturation functions . for example , if one instead chooses the @xmath57 function @xmath58 \\ \mathrm{sign}(s)\left [ 1+\frac{1}{\pi } \tan ^{-1}\left ( \pi \left ( \left| s\right| -1\right ) \right ) \right ] \quad \mathrm{if}\;|s|>1 , \end{array } \right . \label{sigma}\]]then the only change in the statement of lemma [ mainlemma ] is to the right - hand side of the inequality ( [ delta cond ] ) . the proof for this saturation is similar to the proof we give below . condition ( [ delta cond ] ) in lemma [ mainlemma ] allows cases where @xmath59 is arbitrarily large and @xmath60 is as small as desired , as well as cases where @xmath61 is arbitrarily small , including the case where @xmath62 $ ] . we use ( [ z ] ) and @xmath63 , where @xmath64 is the new control input , to transform ( [ chain ] ) into @xmath65 we first perform a lyapunov - type analysis on the @xmath66-subsystem using the function @xmath67 where @xmath68 was defined in ( [ uu ] ) . by separately considering the cases where @xmath69 and @xmath70 , one can easily verify that ( [ v1 ] ) is positive - definite and radially unbounded for @xmath71 . in fact , if @xmath70 , then @xmath72 on the other hand , if @xmath69 , then @xmath73 , so @xmath74 the time derivative of ( [ v1 ] ) along the trajectories of the @xmath66-subsystem is given by @xmath75 \alpha . \label{v1dot1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath76 and @xmath77 @xmath78 give @xmath79 ( [ v1dot1 ] ) becomes @xmath80 \alpha . \label{v1dot2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now distinguish between two cases : 1 . then @xmath81 , @xmath82 , and since @xmath83 , we get @xmath84 \alpha . \label{v1dot3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] 2 . then @xmath85 sign@xmath86 , @xmath87 , and @xmath88 + since @xmath83 , applying ( [ integral ] ) to ( [ v1dot2 ] ) again yields ( [ v1dot3 ] ) . thus ( [ v1dot3 ] ) holds for all @xmath89 . finally , we perform a lyapunov - type analysis on the whole system ( [ zdot ] ) using the positive definite radially unbounded function @xmath41 from ( [ clf ] ) . since @xmath90 , where @xmath91 was defined in ( [ v1 ] ) , it follows from ( [ v1dot3 ] ) that the time derivative of ( [ clf ] ) along the system trajectories satisfies @xmath92 \alpha . \label{vdot1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we again distinguish between two cases : 1 . then @xmath93 , so ( [ vdot1 ] ) gives @xmath94 \alpha . \label{vdot2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] 2 . . then ( [ integral ] ) holds and since @xmath95 and @xmath96 , we again get ( [ vdot2 ] ) . thus , ( [ vdot2 ] ) holds for all @xmath89 . using @xmath97 and ( [ g ] ) , ( [ vdot2 ] ) becomes @xmath98 by separately considering the cases @xmath99 @xmath100 and @xmath101 , i.e. , @xmath40 is negative definite . one can easily verify that the origin is a unique equilibrium point of ( [ zdot ] ) in closed loop with @xmath102 . thus , @xmath103 is gas @xcite . it follows from ( [ z ] ) that @xmath104 is gas , and that ( [ clf ] ) is a clf for ( [ chain ] ) . we are now ready to state our main result on the global asymptotic stabilization of ( [ xdot amb ] ) with control saturation . [ mainthm ] the control law @xmath105 where @xmath106 was defined in ( [ ubar ] ) and @xmath107 in closed loop with ( [ xdot amb ] ) ensures @xmath36 is gas , and has arbitrarily small amplitude . moreover , with the choice ( [ clf ] ) , the function @xmath108 is a clf for ( [ xdot amb ] ) . we use the change of variable ( [ x3 ] ) and the change of input ( [ u ] ) to transform ( [ xdot amb ] ) into the chain of integrators @xmath109 after setting @xmath110 to ( [ ubar ] ) with @xmath111 , @xmath112 , and @xmath113 , we can invoke lemma [ mainlemma ] to conclude @xmath114 is gas for ( [ chain int ] ) . it then follows from ( [ x3 ] ) that @xmath36 is gas for the system ( [ xdot amb ] ) in closed loop with the feedback ( [ u])-([x3 ] ) . the fact that @xmath115 @xmath116 is a clf for the amb dynamics follows from the proof of lemma [ mainlemma ] . notice that the control law ( [ u ] ) has arbitrarily small amplitude since along the closed - loop trajectories , @xmath117 thus , one can choose @xmath118 such that @xmath119 to ensure the amb voltages satisfy the voltage constraint @xmath120 , @xmath25 @xmath121 . from ( [ c12 cond ] ) , one can also see that the control gains can be adjusted to accommodate sufficiently small bias levels due to the direct dependency of @xmath122 on the bias flux @xmath123 ( i.e. , a low - bias control ) . however , one can not set @xmath124 since the control may have a singularity . it is worth comparing our construction from theorem [ mainthm ] with the amb controller from section vi of @xcite , where the stabilizing controller took the form of nested hard saturations . in @xcite , the proof that the control stabilizes the amb system is based on the method of @xcite , which uses the hardness of the saturation @xmath43 in an essential way . the argument shows that the nested hard saturations cause the amb dynamics ( [ xdot amb ] ) to assume a simplified form after sufficiently large time . then one shows that this new system of ` asymptotic ' equations is gas using a lyapunov - like analysis . unfortunately , the lyapunov function used in the analysis of @xcite is not a clf for the amb dynamics ( [ xdot amb ] ) . on the other hand , our construction is not restricted to the standard hard saturation as explained in remark 1 , and thus can lead to smoother stabilizing controllers . also , the lyapunov function from theorem [ mainthm ] is negative definite along the closed - loop amb trajectories with the feedback ( [ u ] ) _ for all time _ , and thus is a clf for the amb dynamics ( [ xdot amb ] ) . knowing a global clf @xmath125 and corresponding globally stabilizing feedback @xmath35 for the amb dynamics , we can construct a feedback @xmath126 that renders the system input - to - state stable ( iss ) to exogenous disturbances @xcite . choosing @xmath125 and @xmath35 from our theorem , and letting @xmath127 denote the open - loop amb dynamics , it follows from [ 9 , theorem 1 ] that the system @xmath128 @xmath129 is iss relative to relative to any measurable locally essentially bounded ( e.g. , locally bounded piecewise continuous ) , exogenous disturbance @xmath130 under the combined feedback @xmath131 . this is because the term @xmath132 in the feedback is the lie derivative of @xmath41 in the direction of the constant vector field @xmath133 that multiplies the input in the amb dynamics . note that in this case the feedback @xmath126 is not necessarily saturated . this is because if @xmath126 were any saturated feedback rendering @xmath134 iss , and if @xmath135 were a positive global bound on @xmath126 , then the third component of the dynamic @xmath136 would have unbounded trajectories when the disturbance is for example @xmath137 , thus violating the iss requirement . hence , there is no globally saturated feedback that renders the amb dynamics iss to exogenous disturbances . moreover , the clf allows us to construct a feedback @xmath138 rendering the noisy system @xmath128 @xmath139 iss with respect to the disturbance @xmath140 for small measurement errors @xmath141 in the controller @xcite . in the context of ambs , @xmath140 could represent rotor unbalance or vibrations transmitted through the bearing foundation while @xmath142 could represent inaccuracies in sensing displacement , velocity , and/or flux . the proposed control law from theorem [ mainthm ] above was simulated on the same high - fidelity model of the one degree - of - freedom magnetic levitation system @xcite used in @xcite . the model includes flux leakage , magnetic material saturation , coil resistance , voltage saturation , and flexible modes , and thus is a fairly accurate representation of the actual system test rig @xcite . we refer the reader to @xcite for a complete description of the system model . as in @xcite , the system was simulated with @xmath143 @xmath110wb , @xmath144 v , and initial conditions set to @xmath145 mrad , @xmath146 mrad / s , @xmath147 @xmath110wb , and @xmath148 @xmath110wb . the above flux values are for the _ total _ flux in the magnetic levitation system , i.e. , including gap flux and flux leakage . the control parameters @xmath149 were selected according to ( [ c12 cond ] ) and ( [ delta cond ] ) to yield the fastest convergence possible for the state @xmath150 . this resulted in the following parameter values : @xmath151 , @xmath152 , and @xmath153 . the simulation results for the system states @xmath150 , @xmath154 , and @xmath155 ( @xmath25 ) , and for the control voltages @xmath156 ( @xmath25 ) are shown in figure 2 below , where @xmath155 denotes the gap flux . when compared with the simulation of the controller from section vi of @xcite ( see figure 8 of @xcite ) , the our control yields similar closed - loop performance although it can be tuned to produce a faster response as seen from figure 2 . we constructed a stabilizing controller and control - lyapunov function for low - bias active magnetic bearings ( ambs ) with voltage saturation . the amb dynamics used in the construction is borrowed from a recently - developed model for ambs operating with only one electromagnet active at any given time . our construction is based on a new forwarding - like approach to stabilizing a three - dimensional chain of integrators with input saturation . the proposed amb control law has arbitrarily small amplitude and the flexibility of being implemented with different saturation - like functions . sontag , `` input - to - state stability : basic concepts and results , '' in _ nonlinear and optimal control theory _ , springer lecture notes in mathematics , to appear , http://www.math.rutgers.edu/ @xmath157sontag / papers.html .

we study the low - bias stabilization of active magnetic bearings ( ambs ) subject to voltage saturation based on a recently proposed model for the amb switching mode of operation . using a forwarding - like approach , we construct a stabilizing controller of arbitrarily small amplitude and a control - lyapunov function for the amb dynamics . we illustrate our construction using a numerical example .

1510.02206

in this article we extend previous work which combined the two fields of quantum information and ultra - cold bosons to propose a method for the fabrication of spatially isolated entangled atomic populations @xcite . we do this by comparing the performance of a three - well bose - hubbard system @xcite to that of an optical beamsplitter for the production of spatially separated output modes , using well - known criteria @xcite . in particular , we consider the quadrature based criteria @xcite which were not considered in the earlier paper . the field of ultra - cold bosons has seen much experimental and theoretical investigation since the successful bose condensation of bosonic atoms . for atoms trapped in an optical lattice , one investigative technique uses the bose - hubbard model . this model , from condensed matter physics , was originally shown by jaksch @xcite to provide an accurate description of bosonic atoms trapped in a deep optical lattice . in this work we use a three well bose - hubbard model to propose and analyse the entangling properties of a quantum atom optical mode splitter and recombiner . we show that this can split an initial condensate in the central well into two separated entangled condensates , with the detection of the entanglement being sensitive to both the initial quantum state of the condensate in the central well , and to the actual criteria used . we then examine and compare a quantum optical beamsplitter with one vacuum input with regard to the same correlations and input quantum states . the area of continuous - variable entanglement is very active @xcite , with many criteria having been developed to signify the presence of inseparability and entanglement , especially in bipartite systems . many of these only apply fully to gaussian systems and gaussian measurements . the most commonly used measurements are those developed by duan @xcite and simon @xcite , using combinations of quadrature variances . more recently , teh and reid have shown the degree of violation of these inequalities that is necessary to demonstrate not just inseparability , but genuine entanglement @xcite , as these are only necessarily the same property for pure states . the criteria we use in this work fall into two categories . those in the first category were developed by hillery and zubairy @xcite and expanded on by cavalcanti @xcite to cover multipartite entanglement , steering , and violations of bell inequalities . as shown by he @xcite , the hillery and zubairy criteria are well suited to number conserving processes such as those of interest here . the second category are quadrature based criteria , originally developed by duan @xcite and simon @xcite for inseparability and entanglement , and by reid @xcite for demonstrations of the einstein - podolsky - rosen ( epr ) paradox @xcite . multi - mode entanglement in bose - einstein condensates ( bec ) has been predicted and examined in the processes of molecular dissociation @xcite , four - wave mixing in an optical lattice @xcite , and in the bose - hubbard model @xcite . in the latter case the separation of the modes is produced by the tunneling between wells , in both the continuous @xcite and pulsed tunneling configurations @xcite . the quantum correlations necessary to detect entanglement can in principle be measured using the interaction with light @xcite , or by homodyning with other atomic modes @xcite . we note here that the entanglement we are examining is a collective property between atomic modes which are spatially separated , and is not between individual atoms @xcite . this point , which is unavoidable for indistinguishable bosons , has previously been raised by chianca and olsen @xcite , and was recently put on a formal basis , using the language of quantum information theory , by killoran @xcite . we will follow the approach taken by milburn @xcite , generalising this to three wells @xcite , and solving either the heisenberg equations of motion or the fully quantum positive - p phase space representation @xcite equations , depending on whether there is a collisional interaction present or not . we consider these to be the most suitable approaches here because they are both exact , allow for an easy representation of mesoscopic numbers of atoms , can be used to calculate quantum correlations , and can simulate different quantum initial states @xcite . just as importantly , both calculations scale linearly with the number of sites and can in principle deal with any number of atoms . one disadvantage of the positive - p representation is that the integration can show a tendency to diverge at short times for high collisional nonlinearities @xcite . as long as the procedures followed to derive the fokker - planck equation for the positive - p function are valid @xcite , the stochastic solutions are guaranteed to be accurate wherever the integration converges . with all the results shown here , the solutions were found without any signs of divergences . the system is very simple , with three potential wells in a linear configuration . each of these can contain a single atomic mode , which we will treat as being in the lowest energy level . atoms in each of the wells can tunnel into the nearest neighbour potential , with tunneling between wells @xmath1 and @xmath2 , and @xmath2 and @xmath3 . with all the population initially in the middle well , the system acts as a time dependent mode splitter and recombiner . with the @xmath4 as bosonic annihilation operators for atoms in mode @xmath5 , @xmath6 representing the coupling between the wells , and @xmath7 as the collisional nonlinearity , we may now write our hamiltonian . following the usual procedures @xcite , we find @xmath8 for the case where the collisional interaction between the atoms is set to zero , we find that an analytical solution of the heisenberg equations of motion for the system operators is possible . the heisenberg equations of motion are found as @xmath9 = \left[\begin{array}{cccccc } 0 & 0 & -ij & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0 & ij & 0 & 0 \\ -ij & 0 & 0 & 0 & -ij & 0 \\ 0 & ij & 0 & 0 & 0 & ij \\ 0 & 0 & -ij & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0 & ij & 0 & 0 \end{array}\right ] \times \left [ \begin{array}{c } \hat{a}_{1}(0 ) \\ \hat{a}_{1}^{\dag}(0 ) \\ \hat{a}_{2}(0 ) \\ \hat{a}_{2}^{\dag}(0 ) \\ \hat{a}_{3}(0 ) \\ \hat{a}_{3}^{\dag}(0 ) \end{array } \right ] . \label{eq : heisenberg}\ ] ] this set of linear operator equations is readily solved , having the solutions @xmath10 where we have made the substitution @xmath11 for reasons of notational elegance . these equations allow us to find analytical expressions for all the correlations of interest , as we shall do further on in the article . we can also solve the heisenberg equations in terms of @xmath12 and @xmath13 , the quadrature operators . setting @xmath14 we find @xmath15 which then allow us to find solutions for any correlations written in terms of these quadratures . examples of these are the quadrature squeezing @xcite and reid epr correlations @xcite . in this case ( @xmath16 ) , it is not obvious how to solve the equations of motion analytically . we will therefore use the positive - p representation @xcite , which allows for exact solutions of the dynamics arising from the hamiltonian of eq . [ eq : ham ] , in the limit of the average of an infinite number of trajectories of the stochastic differential equations in a doubled phase - space . in practice we obviously can not integrate an infinite number of trajectories , but have used numbers large enough that the sampling error is within the line thicknesses of our plotted results . following the standard methods @xcite , the set of it stochastic differential equations @xcite are found as @xmath17 where the @xmath18 are standard gaussian noises with @xmath19 and @xmath20 . as always , averages of the positive - p variables represent normally ordered operator moments , such that , for example , @xmath21 . we also note that @xmath22 only after taking averages , and it is this freedom that allows classical variables to represent quantum operators . as well as the populations in each well , we can also calculate any type of operator products that we desire , analytically in the case without interactions . beginning with only the middle well occupied , we find the analytic non - interacting solutions for the numbers in each well , @xmath23 on the scale of fig . [ fig : populations ] , which shows numerical solutions , the above are indistinguishable from the stochastic solutions for @xmath16 . , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 , with @xmath26 . the atoms in the centre well begin in a fock state , although an initial coherent state leads to indistinguishable results . the results shown are the average of @xmath27 stochastic trajectories . the non - interacting analytical results are indistinguishable on this scale . the quantities plotted in this and subsequent plots are dimensionless . ] the next class of correlations we calculate are the number variances , including the number difference between the populations of wells @xmath1 and @xmath3 . in terms of the operators , these are @xmath28 in the non - interacting case and with only the middle well initially occupied , we find @xmath29 these results , for initial fock and coherent states in the middle well , are shown in fig . [ fig : erwinvar1 ] and fig . [ fig : erwinvar2 ] . , for an initial fock state of @xmath30 atoms in the middle well . we see that all variances are periodic in the non - interacting case . ] , for an initial coherent state of @xmath30 atoms in the middle well . we see that the maximum variances are much larger than in fig . [ fig : erwinvar1 ] , and that all variances are periodic in the non - interacting case . ] the second correlation is an entanglement measure adapted from an inequality developed by hillery and zubairy , who showed that , considering two separable modes denoted by @xmath31 and @xmath5 @xcite , @xmath32 with the equality holding for coherent states . the violation of this inequality is thus an indication of the inseparability of , and entanglement between , the two modes . cavalcanti @xcite have extended this inequality to provide indicators of epr steering @xcite and bell violations @xcite . we now define the correlation function @xmath33 for which a positive value reveals entanglement between modes @xmath1 and @xmath3 . we easily see that @xmath34 gives a value of zero for two independent coherent states and a negative result for two independent fock states . this inequality , and the epr - steering development of it , have been shown to detect both inseparability and asymmetric steering in a three - well bose - hubbard model under the process of coherent transfer of atomic population ( ctap ) @xcite . in our non - interacting case , with all population initially in well @xmath2 , we find the analytic result @xmath35 , \label{eq : hzanalytic}\ ] ] so that this measure detects entanglement whenever the initial population in the middle well is in a sub - poissonian state , with the measure being maximised for a number state . the signature of entanglement identically vanishes for an initial coherent state , which is to be expected since our system is somewhat analogous to a beamsplitter , with linear couplings between the modes @xcite . cavalcanti @xcite further developed the work of hillery and zubairy to find inequalities for which the violation denotes the possibility of epr - steering and bell states . the epr - steering inequality for two modes is written as @xmath36 while the bell state inequality is written as @xmath37 calling on the overworked alice and bob , if alice measures mode @xmath31 and bob measures mode @xmath5 a violation of the inequality ( [ eq : ericepr ] ) signifies that bob would be able to steer alice , and vice versa for a swapping of the modes . these inequalities allow us to define a correlation function which signifies the presence of epr - steering when it has a value of greater than zero , @xmath38 and another for which a positive value signifies the presence of bell correlations , @xmath39 for the epr - steering correlation , we can solve the heisenberg equations to find @xmath40 which is readily seen to have a maximum value of zero . therefore this measure does not detect any possibility of epr - steering for this system . there will also obviously be no signature of a continuous variable bell state of the two modes . one other common method of detecting entanglement in continuous variable systems involves using quadrature correlations @xcite . the single - mode quadrature variances for the non - interacting case can be found as @xmath41 in experimental quantum optics , these quadrature variances are measured via homodyne detection , which is not as simple for massive particles , although at least two methods have been proposed @xcite . we now investigate the duan - simon correlations between wells @xmath1 and @xmath3 , with inseparability being detected when @xmath42 where for simplicity of expression we have dropped the time variable . to express these particular correlations , we also need the quadrature covariances , which are found as @xmath43+\frac{1}{2}\sin^{2}\omega t\:v(\hat{y}_{2}(0 ) ) , \\ \hspace{-1 cm } v(\hat{y}_{1},\hat{y}_{3 } ) = \frac{1}{4}\left(\cos^{2}\omega t-1\right)\left[v(\hat{y}_{1}(0))+v(\hat{y}_{3}(0))\right]+\frac{1}{2}\sin^{2}\omega t\:v(\hat{x}_{2}(0 ) ) . } \label{eq : covariances}\end{aligned}\ ] ] setting @xmath44 , we find @xmath45 + 2\sin^{2}\omega t\ : v(\hat{y}_{2}(0 ) ) , \\ \hspace{-2 cm } ds_{- } = v(\hat{x}_{1}(0))+v(\hat{x}_{3}(0))+\cos^{2}\omega t\left[v(\hat{y}_{1}(0))+v(\hat{y}_{3}(0))\right]+2\sin^{2}\omega t\ : v(\hat{x}_{2}(0 ) ) , } \label{eq : dsresults}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which can then be minimised with respect to time . we find that the minimum for either correlation is at @xmath46 , so that inseparability for our initial conditions is not found by this measure , irrespective of the initial quantum state of the atoms in well @xmath2 . we also found that the reid epr inequalities @xcite showed no evidence of the epr paradox . this is despite the fact that entanglement is present according to the hillery - zubairy criteria @xcite , and emphasises the importance of using the correct correlations to detect continuous - variable entanglement in a given system . , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 in a fock state , with @xmath26 . the results shown are the average of @xmath47 stochastic trajectories . the non - interacting analytical results are only the same at short times and we see that the amplitudes of the oscillations grow with time , despite the fact that a @xmath0 nonlinearity preserves the number statistics in an isolated well . ] in the interacting case , our method of choice is to use numerical stochastic integration to find solutions of the full positive - p representation equations @xcite . this allows us to calculate the expectation values of any operator moments that can be written in normal order . taking into account the normal ordering , the number variances are written as @xmath48 all of these give values of zero for uncorrelated fock states or vacuum . whenever one of the variances is less than the mean population of the corresponding mode , we have suppression of number fluctuations below the poissonian coherent state level . the individual quadrature variances are found as @xmath49 with the combined quadrature variances and covariances needed for the duan - simon and reid correlations being the obvious extensions of these . , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 in initial fock state and coherent states , with @xmath26 . the results shown for the initial fock state are the average of @xmath47 stochastic trajectories and those for the initial coherent state are averaged over @xmath50 trajectories . the non - interacting analytical results are only the same at short times and we see that the correlations degrade with time , with the coherent state correlation showing no entanglement at any time . ] for our results in the interacting case , we have chosen a nonlinearity of @xmath24 , again with either a fock or coherent state with an average of @xmath30 atoms in the middle well . these different quantum states are simulated using the methods found in olsen and bradley @xcite . we have simulated results for the numbers in each well ( fig . [ fig : populations ] ) , the number variances ( fig . [ fig : ppvars ] ) , the hillery - zubairy criteria ( fig . [ fig : hzpp ] ) and some of the various quadrature variance correlations canonically used to detect continuous - variable entanglement and epr - steering . those we present here are the duan - simon criteria @xcite of eq . [ eq : dsformula ] and the reid epr inequalities @xcite . , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 in a coherent states , with @xmath26 . the solid line is @xmath51 and the dash - dotted line is @xmath52 we see that inseparability is only indicated for short times and that the violation of the inequality is not large . these results are the average of @xmath53 trajectories . ] the number variances for an initial fock state are shown in fig . [ fig : ppvars ] , from which we can see that they take the same periodic form as in the non - interacting case of fig . [ fig : erwinvar1 ] , but the amplitude of the oscillations grows in time . the results for an initial coherent state follow the same pattern as in fig . [ fig : erwinvar2 ] , but again with the maxima of the oscillations increasing with time . the increase in these variances is purely a result of the linear coupling between the wells , since the collisional nonlinearity in an isolated mode preserves the number statistics . although of the same strengths , the coupling between the wells is independent , so that we see the statistics of @xmath54 are initially poissonian . the interaction of the collisional nonlinearity and the couplings causes the statistics to become super - poissonian with increasing interaction time . in fig . [ fig : hzpp ] we show the hillery - zubairy criterion @xmath34 for the detection of entanglement between wells @xmath1 and @xmath3 . we see that an initial fock state in the centre well means that this correlation becomes periodically positive at early times , but that the entanglement signal is degraded over time . for an initial coherent state , this measure gives no indication of entanglement . this is in contradiction with the results of fig . [ fig : dscoherent ] where consider an initial coherent state and find a violation of duan - simon inequalities at short times . we note that using time dependent quadrature angles can maximise the violations , as shown previously for kerr - squeezed optical states mixed on a beamsplitter @xcite , but we have not considered this here since the inseparability signal for the canonical quadratures is so weak . in any case , even an optimisation of the quadrature angles still finds no violation of the inequalities after a short time . we also calculated the reid epr criteria between wells @xmath1 and @xmath2 and @xmath1 and @xmath3 , and found no evidence that epr - steering is present in this system . in this case , the quadrature measures agree with the phase - independent measures of eq . [ eq : ericepr ] . since our three well system , with one input mode and two output modes with linear couplings , can loosely be compared to a beamsplitter with one non - zero input , it is informative to compare the performance of a standard optical beamsplitter using the same correlations . the equations relating the inputs and outputs of a lossless beamsplitter can be written as @xmath55 where @xmath56 is the amplitude reflectivity . for reasons of simplicity , we will treat only a balanced beamsplitter , with @xmath57 and @xmath58 . it is then trivial to see that total number is conserved , as it must be , and as happens for our three well system . one obvious difference is that the beamsplitter has two inputs and two outputs and the transmission is not time dependent , but our main interest here is in the linear coupling . this is present in both systems . examining firstly the correlation of eq.[eq : xi13 ] , we find that the left hand side is @xmath59 and the right hand side of the expression is @xmath60 . \label{eq : nanbbs}\ ] ] combining these , we find @xmath61 , \label{eq : xiabbs}\ ] ] which , apart from the time dependence , is the same as the result of eq . [ eq : hzanalytic ] . this again shows that this measure will detect entanglement for any input state @xmath62 for which the number fluctuations are less than poissonian . two coherent states will give a value of zero , and therefore will not lead to entangled outputs . the two possible equivalents of eq . [ eq : ericepr ] for the beamsplitter give @xmath63 which can obviously never be positive , so that these measures do not detect epr - steering . we can also consider the duan - simon quadrature correlations @xcite using the same approach . we write the output quadratures in terms of the inputs as @xmath64 which alllows us to calculate the necessary quadrature moments analytically . again for simplicity , we set @xmath57 , and find @xmath65 , \\ v(\hat{y}_{a}^{out}\mp \hat{y}_{b}^{out } ) = v(\hat{y}_{a}^{in})+v(\hat{y}_{b}^{in})\mp\left[v(\hat{y}_{b}^{in})-v(\hat{y}_{a}^{in } ) \right ] , } \label{eq : vxypm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] so that the duan - simon correlations are @xmath66 , \\ v(\hat{x}_{a}^{out}- \hat{x}_{b}^{out } ) + v(\hat{y}_{a}^{out}+ \hat{y}_{b}^{out } ) = 2\left[v(\hat{x}_{a}^{in})+v(\hat{y}_{b}^{in})\right ] . } \label{eq : bsduansimon}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for a squeezed amplitude input in mode @xmath62 with variance @xmath67 and vacuum in @xmath68 , the second of these gives a value of @xmath69 , therefore demonstrating inseparability . however , for an input fock state in mode @xmath62 and vacuum in @xmath68 , these correlations predict a value of @xmath70 , immediately contradicting the prediction of eq . [ eq : xiabbs ] , showing once again the importance of using the correct inequalities for a given system . using these analytic results , we can also find values for the reid epr correlations @xcite , for which @xmath71 signifies a demonstration of the epr paradox @xcite . calling the product of the inferred variances @xmath72 , we find for inputs of a squeezed state and vacuum , @xmath73 showing that the paradox is demonstrated and steering is possible as soon as we have a squeezed input . on the other hand , for inputs of a fock state @xmath74 and vacuum , we find @xmath75 which has a minimum value of @xmath1 . we therefore see that the reid measure does not signify the presence of the epr paradox in this case , in agreement with eq . [ eq : absigma ] . we have shown that our three - well bose hubbard system produces entanglement between the atoms in two non - adjacent wells , but not at a sufficient level to demonstrate the epr paradox via the measures we have investigated here . as we have demonstrated , different measures can lead to different indications as to whether inseparability and entanglement are present . those based on the hillery - zubairy results perform better for an initial fock state than for an initial coherent state in the middle well , for which the quadrature based correlations have a superior performance . this is in agreement with the claim that the hillery - zubairy measures are superior for processes which conserve number . due to the sufficient but not necessary nature of the inequalities used , we can not say that a demonstration of epr - steering is impossible with this system , only that we have not found evidence for one . this is an ongoing problem with continuous - variable quantum information , with no single method adequately capturing all the quantum correlations that may exist in a given system . we have also compared the performance of our system to an optical beamsplitter with one vacuum input , finding some similarities and some differences . the hillery - zubairy criteria again predict entanglement for an input fock state into the bright input , but no epr - steering . the quadrature correlations predict neither entanglement nor epr - steering for an initial fock state , but predict both for squeezed states . the biggest difference is that the beamsplitter outputs do not depend on time , at least for continuous inputs , while the atomic system experiences either periodic or almost periodic behaviour , depending on the presence or otherwise of atomic collisions . as long as the interactions are not too strong , our system is a good proposal for the manufacture of entangled bosonic modes of separated atoms .

we compare and contrast the entangling properties of a three - well bose - hubbard model and an optical beamsplitter . the coupling between the different modes is linear in both cases , and we may identify two output modes . obvious differences are that our bose - hubbard model , with only the middle well initially occupied , does not have a vacuum input port , there is no equivalent of a collisional , @xmath0 nonlinearity with the beamsplitter , and the results of the bose - hubbard model show a time - dependence . in the non - interacting case , we obtain analytic solutions and show that , like a beamsplitter , the bose - hubbard system will not produce entanglement for classical initial states . we also show that whether inseparability or entanglement are detected depends sensitively on the criteria measured , with different criteria giving contradictory predictions .

1301.1809

the quantum dynamics of photosynthesis have , quite naturally , attracted a lot of attention recently . understanding if and how nature exploits quantum ( de)coherence would have tremendous scientific and technological impact . for what follows , photosynthesis can be simply visualized as a two - step process : ( i ) light harvesting and ( ii ) photochemical processing . light harvesting molecules absorb the incident photon and guide the subsequent excitation to the photosynthetic reaction center ( rc ) . it is there where the photochemistry takes place , transforming the initial electronic excitation in a transmembrane proton pump that further drives the life - sustaining chemistry . regarding step ( i ) , quantum coherence effects in light harvesting complexes ( time scale of 1 - 500 fs ) have been addressed theoretically and experimentally @xcite . we will here focus on step ( ii ) , i.e. on reaction center quantum dynamics ( time scale of 1ps - 10 @xmath1s ) schematically depicted in figure [ cidnp](a ) . photosynthetic reaction centers exhibit a cascade of electron transfer reactions , starting from a photo - excited donor - acceptor dyad pi ( chlorophyl - type molecules ) and shelving the electron further apart to quinones ( q@xmath2 , q@xmath3 ) , producing a long - lived charge - separated state driving the transmembrane proton pump . in each of those steps there is a radical - ion pair formed , further perplexing the dynamics , as radical - ion pairs ( rps ) exhibit intricate magnetic field effects @xcite . radical - ion pairs @xcite are biomolecular ions created from the photo - excited dyad @xmath4pi . they have two unpaired electrons ( denoted by the two dots in figure [ cidnp ] ) and any number of magnetic nuclei . the magnetic nuclei of the donor and acceptor molecular ions couple to the ion s unpaired electron via the hyperfine interaction . this coupling , along with several other intra - molecule magnetic interactions , leads to singlet - triplet ( s - t ) mixing , i.e. a coherent oscillation of the total electronic spin , also affected by the electrons zeeman interaction with the external magnetic field . a spin - dependent charge recombination terminates the coherent s - t mixing and leads to the reaction products , either the original neutral dyad pi ( singlet product ) or a triplet intermediate ( @xmath5pi ) . as shown in figure [ cidnp](b ) , singlet ( triplet ) radical pairs recombine at the singlet ( triplet ) recombination rate , denoted by @xmath6 ( @xmath7 ) . triplet products may close the reaction cycle by intersystem - crossing into the singlet diamagnetic ground state at a rate @xmath8 . , of the two unpaired electrons with each - other , the magnetic nuclei and the external magnetic field . these magnetic interactions in long - lived charge - separated states ( where the long lifetime is either due to the absence of quinones or due to the large spatial separation of secondary radical - pairs ) give rise to singlet - triplet conversion and spin - dependent recombination , further perplexing the dynamics of the whole reaction . figure adapted from @xcite.,width=8 ] it is apparent from figure [ cidnp ] that when the lifetime of the charge - separated states ( which increases with separation ) is long enough that magnetic - field effects ( with typical timescale of e.g. s - t mixing on the order of 0.1 - 1 @xmath1s ) have time to build up , radical - pair spin dynamics get convolved into the reaction center dynamics . one aspect of this interrelation pervading a large number of photosynthetic reaction centers is chemically induced dynamic nuclear polarization [ 13 - 20 ] , the enhancement ( by several orders of magnitude ) of the ground state ( pi ) nuclear spin polarization resulting from the rp spin dynamics . cidnp has emerged as a rather universal signature of spin order in photosynthetic reaction centers @xcite and its possible operational significance for photosynthesis is still an open fundamental question . cidnp is based on nuclear spin sorting , to be shortly explained , taking place in radical - pair reactions . regarding solid - state cidnp in particular , three main mechanisms have so far been known to produce cidnp signals , the three - spin - mixing ( tsm ) @xcite , the differential decay ( dd ) and the differential relaxation ( dr ) mechanism @xcite . the first is a coherent mechanism resulting from particular magnetic interactions within the rp , while the second is about a nuclear spin imbalance brought about by different recombination rates @xmath9 . the last mechanism ( dr ) will not be relevant for the following discussion . we will here demonstrate that there is yet another , completely unanticipated mechanism at work _ at the fundamental quantum dynamical level of rp reactions_. it is due to the inherent quantum measurement of the rp s spin state continuously going on in the rp as part of its very charge recombination process . the decoherence caused by this `` internal '' quantum measurement is responsible for a new kind of nuclear spin sorting , particularly efficient at low fields , and completely unrelated to other low - field cidnp studies @xcite . this new mechanism is ubiquitous , as it is largely independent of the particular magnetic interactions in the radical pairs , and thus opens a new venue towards exploring the biological significance of cidnp - induced spin order in natural ( earth s field ) photosynthesis . in the following we will ( i ) briefly explain the basics of cidnp signal generation for the general reader and ( ii ) recapitulate the recent progress in understanding the fundamental quantum dynamics of radical - ion - pair reactions . combining ( i ) and ( ii ) , we will then explain the quantum measurement corrections to cidnp . before proceeding , we just mention a classical analog of the effect to be discussed , shown in figure [ analog ] . we consider an ensemble of coupled pendulums oscillating in the anti - symmetric mode . the ensemble average of the sum of their displacements is @xmath10 at all times . however , if the `` environment '' perturbs the system , e.g. with random kicks , while the ensemble population decays we will observe a non - zero total displacement rising to a maximum and decaying to zero , following suit with the population decay . this displacement is the analog of the radical - pair nuclear spin to be discussed in the following . the non - zero value of the nuclear spin stems from the particular `` environment '' pertaining to radical - pairs , singlet - triplet dephasing , which produces a nuclear spin imbalance along the reaction . coupled pendulums oscillating out of phase ( anti - symmetric mode ) . the number of such systems @xmath11 is a decaying function of time . while they oscillate , the pendulums are perturbed by the `` environment '' , which is here assumed to produce dephasing kicks at random times . ( b ) for the particular stochastic simulation shown here , every kick from the environment was taken to initialize the amplitude of pendulum 1 to unity and of pendulum 2 to zero . in the absence of the perturbation , all coupled pendulums would be continuously oscillating out of phase , and the ensemble average of the sum of their displacements away from equilibrium , @xmath12 , would be constantly zero . in the presence of the dephasing kicks , however , a non - zero displacement is shown to build up , to later on decay to zero due to the total population decay.,width=8 ] consider radical - ion pairs with just one nucleus coupled to the electron of e.g. the donor . at time @xmath13 the radical - ion pairs start out in the electronic singlet state , while the nuclear spins are thermally polarized , which for protons at earth s field corresponds to a polarization of about @xmath14 , practically taken to equal zero . thus , in the ensemble of radical - ion pairs half will have the nuclear spin in the @xmath15 state , while in the other half the nuclear spin will initially be in the @xmath16 state . the local magnetic field seen by the donor electron will be the external field plus the nuclear magnetic field , while the acceptor electron will only experience the external magnetic field . it is this difference in local magnetic fields experienced by the two electrons that results in a difference in their larmor frequencies , and hence induces the coherent singlet - triplet conversion . consequently , in the first half radical pairs ( with a @xmath15 nuclear spin ) the larmor precession frequency of the donor electron , and thus the s - t mixing frequency , will be slightly higher than in the other half ( due to the opposite contribution of the nuclear spin ) , hence the coherently formed triplet radical pairs will have their nuclear spins predominantly in the @xmath15 state , leaving the singlet radical pairs with an opposite nuclear polarization . while the nuclear spins are thus sorted among singlet and triplet rps , and unless there is a coherent mechanism like tsm producing net nuclear polarization , the expectation value @xmath17 of the z - component of the single nuclear spin under consideration is still zero . here @xmath18 is the spin density matrix of the radical pair , describing the electron and nuclear spin degrees of freedom altogether , and @xmath19 is the direction of the external magnetic field . according to the traditional understanding of the radical - pair mechanism and the concomitant cidnp signal generation , for this nuclear spin sorting to result in a diamagnetic ground state with net nuclear polarization , and in the absence of any coherent mechanism like tsm , the differential decay mechanism ( dd ) should be at play in order to observe nonzero cidnp signals . in the following we will indeed consider a magnetic hamiltonian that _ does not _ exhibit the tsm mechanism , and we will also take @xmath20 , so that the dd mechanism is not operational . hence according to the traditional theory of rp spin dynamics , no cidnp signal should be expected . we are then going to show that the opposite is actually true . to illustrate the above considerations , we consider a radical pair with one spin-1/2 nucleus _ isotropically _ coupled to the donor electron . in figure [ traces](a ) we display the undisturbed spin state evolution brought about _ just _ by the magnetic hamiltonian @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the electron spin larmor precession frequency in the external magnetic field defining the z - axis and @xmath23 the donor - electron hyperfine coupling with the donor nuclear spin ( in units of frequency ) . what is plotted in figure [ traces](a ) is the spin state s singlet character , given by the expectation value of the singlet projection operator , @xmath24 , and assuming an rp with infinite lifetime ( in other words so far we take the recombination rates to be @xmath25 ) . what figure [ traces](a ) displays are the singlet - triplet oscillations brought about by @xmath26 . the nuclear spin , @xmath27 , of singlet and triplet rps is given by @xmath28 and @xmath29 , respectively , and displayed in figure [ traces](b ) . the previous considerations regarding nuclear spin sorting are easily visualized by noting in figure [ traces](b ) that although @xmath30 and @xmath31 , the nuclear spin oscillations in the singlet and triplet subspace are exactly out of phase , so the net rp nuclear polarization @xmath32 . in case it is not obvious , we prove that @xmath33 in appendix 1 . we can also show formally that for this particular hamiltonian @xmath26 it will be @xmath34 , as expected since @xmath26 does not qualify for the tsm mechanism @xcite . the proof can be found in appendix 2 . and ( b ) the nuclear spin of singlet rps @xmath28 ( green line ) and the nuclear spin of triplet rps @xmath29 ( pink line ) , when the radical - pair spin state undergoes unceasing coherent s - t mixing driven by @xmath35 $ ] , where @xmath21 . for this particular example it was @xmath36 . the nuclear spin of singlet rps is exactly out of phase with the nuclear spin of triplet rps , so that their sum @xmath37.,width=8 ] now , besides the coherent rp dynamics producing the oscillations in figure [ traces ] , which are driven by @xmath35 $ ] as discussed in the previous paragraph , the spin - selective charge recombination of rps has to be accounted for . this is done by a master equation of the form @xmath35+{\cal l}(\rho)$ ] , where @xmath38 is the reaction super - operator , written in terms of the singlet and triplet projection operators , @xmath39 and @xmath40 , and the singlet and triplet recombination rates , @xmath6 and @xmath7 , respectively . recently , quantum measurement theory has been shown @xcite to fundamentally describe the reaction dynamics of rps , resulting in a new form of @xmath38 , conceptually departing from the traditional theory used until now @xcite . the main physical point of departure is the fact that the very charge recombination process of rps damps their coherent s - t mixing , i.e. it brings about an unavoidable intra - molecule decoherence in their spin state evolution . the traditional theory for the reaction operator of rps , although successful in accounting for a large volume of experimental data , does not embody this decoherence process , neglecting which leads to several conceptual problems @xcite . in any case , in the example treated above , if the nuclear spin expectation value is evaluated according to the full master equation of the traditional theory , taking @xmath20 , it is found to be identically equal to zero , exactly as it is if only the hamiltonian evolution is taken into account . this is formally shown in appendix 3 . according to the common wisdom , this should be perceived as an obvious result , since , with @xmath20 the differential decay mechanism ( dd ) can not lead to any net nuclear polarization . to recapitulate , the statement that @xmath34 at all times when considering _ just _ the hamiltonian evolution remains true _ according to the traditional master equation of spin chemistry _ , that is , if we _ also _ take into account the recombination reaction which gradually diminishes the radical - pair population to zero . the counter - intuitive new result presented here is this : according to the new master equation describing the fundamental quantum dynamics of rp reactions @xcite , there actually is a non - zero rp nuclear spin polarization , depicted in figure [ result ] . a similar result , different by just a factor of 2 , follows from another variant of the quantum - measurement - based stochastic liouville equation @xcite . in this particular example , this nuclear polarization is about @xmath0 times higher than the thermal equilibrium proton polarization ( left y - axis of figure [ result ] ) and roughly independent of @xmath22 as long as @xmath22 is relatively small ( to be further discussed later ) . what is the source of this new kind of cidnp signal ? we will now go beyond the particular example considered above and provide the explanation for the general case of this new channel for photochemically enhancing nuclear polarizations _ at earth s field _ : the fundamental singlet - triplet decoherence underlying the radical - pair mechanism . according to the full density matrix equation of kominis @xcite , with @xmath41 . the absolute value of the nuclear polarization is shown in the right y - axis , while its enhancement relative to the thermal equilibrium polarization , on the order of @xmath0 , is shown in the left y - axis . qualitatively the same result ( only higher by about a factor of 2 ) is obtained from the jones - hore theory @xcite . in contrast , the traditional theory predicts @xmath34 , exactly the same as the sum of the two traces in figure [ traces](b ) that applies to the case of no recombination reaction . note the different time scales in this figure from figure [ traces ] : since @xmath42 , the build - up of @xmath43 in this plot takes place at the very beginning of the s - t mixing oscillations shown in figures [ traces](a ) and [ traces](b).,width=8 ] to visualize this mechanism , suppose that at time @xmath44 the single - nuclear - spin rp ensemble is described by the density matrix @xmath18 . assuming a magnetic hamiltonian _ not _ supporting any coherent generation of _ net _ rp nuclear polarization , as in the example considered previously , it will be @xmath45 . this , as already mentioned , implies that @xmath46 . the idea behind the new kind of cidnp signal generation is the following . the intramolecule s - t decoherence is equivalent to some rps being _ projected _ to either the singlet or the triplet rp manifold of states , exactly due to the continuous quantum measurement of @xmath47 induced by the rp recombination dynamics , the measurement rate being @xmath48 @xcite . the result of this measurement is either @xmath49 , i.e. the rp is projected to the singlet manifold , or @xmath50 , i.e. the rp is projected to the triplet manifold . the probability for a singlet or a triplet projection is @xmath51 or @xmath52 , respectively . hence , at time @xmath53 the state of the radical - pairs will be ( ignoring the rps that recombine into neutral products during @xmath54 ) a new mixture comprised of ( a ) radical pairs in the state @xmath55 , with @xmath56 $ ] , plus ( b ) the singlet - projected radical pairs described by @xmath57 , plus ( c ) triplet - projected radical pairs described by @xmath58 . the nuclear polarization of states ( a ) will still be zero , since again , the hamiltonian @xmath26 does not generate _ net _ nuclear polarization . the combined nuclear polarization of projected states ( b ) and ( c ) , denoted by @xmath59 , will be the _ weighted _ sum of singlet rp nuclear polarization , @xmath60 , and triplet rp nuclear polarization , @xmath61 , the sum being weighted by the respective projection probabilities , i.e. @xmath62 taking into account that @xmath63 and using the completeness relation @xmath64 , it follows that @xmath65 thus , if @xmath66 , more ( when @xmath67 ) or less ( when @xmath68 ) projections will take place to the singlet state than to the triplet , and @xmath69 will be non - zero , if of course @xmath60 is non - zero . to recapitulate the physics of this new effect , the singlet - triplet dephasing inherent in the radical - pair quantum dynamic evolution randomly projects radical - pairs into either the singlet or the triplet subspace . the projection probability at time @xmath44 depends on the singlet ( or triplet ) character of the electronic spin state , hence the projections will be asymmetric if @xmath70 . nuclear spin sorting , i.e. the fact that @xmath71 , combined with the asymmetric projections produces a non - zero nuclear spin expectation value . we can now theoretically estimate the quantum measurement corrections to cidnp , to be denoted by @xmath43 , shown in figure [ result ] . letting @xmath72 , the rate of singlet or triplet projections ( the `` quantum measurement '' rate ) is just @xmath73 . we will focus on low magnetic fields and assume , as is the case most often , that @xmath74 . towards the estimate , consider the following three steps : ( 1 ) as the rps start out in the singlet state , and the s - t mixing frequency @xmath75 , in the short reaction time of @xmath76 the singlet character will not have enough time to change appreciably , so it will be @xmath77 . this means that the rps will be projected predominantly to the singlet state . ( 2 ) the electron spin of the donor molecule , which contains the one and only nuclear spin of the rp under consideration , will precess at frequency @xmath78 when the nuclear spin is in the @xmath79 state . so at time @xmath44 , the number of singlet rps with the nuclear spin in the @xmath79 state will be @xmath80 ^ 2 $ ] . the nuclear polarization of singlet rps at time @xmath81 will thus be @xmath82 , easily seen to be @xmath83 and ( 3 ) , s - t projections taking place at the rate @xmath84 will be a source term for @xmath85 . the source term , proportional to @xmath59 , starts at @xmath13 from zero and oscillates at a rate @xmath86 while it is drained at a rate @xmath84 , thus @xmath87 , yielding at time @xmath88 that @xmath89 . putting everything together and using equation ( [ eq : izpr ] ) , we finally arrive at @xmath90 for the particular example depicted in figure [ traces ] it is @xmath91 , hence according to the estimate of equation ( [ estm ] ) it is @xmath92 , in good agreement with the exact value shown in the right y - axis of figure [ result ] . furthermore , the result of equation ( [ estm ] ) can be recast in terms of the thermal polarization @xmath93 ( the expression for @xmath94 is valid for @xmath95 ) , where @xmath96 is the electron larmor frequency in the external magnetic field @xmath97 , with @xmath98 2.8mhz / g being the electron gyromagnetic ratio and @xmath99 is the ratio of electron - to - proton magnetic moment . the enhancement factor @xmath100 is thus seen to be independent of @xmath22 and equal to @xmath101 for ease of use , in the previous expression we provided the enhancement factor in terms of the s - t mixing frequency @xmath86 ( in units of @xmath102 ) , the hyperfine coupling @xmath23 ( in units of @xmath103 ) and the recombination rate @xmath84 ( in units of @xmath104 ) . for typical hyperfine couplings of about 10 gauss and recombination times on the order of 1 ns , it is seen that the quantum measurement corrections to chemically induced dynamic nuclear polarization amount to a significant enhancement of at least four orders of magnitude over the thermal polarization . we note for the reader who would worry about angular momentum conservation that the rp s nuclear spin polarization is exactly balanced by an opposite and equal electronic spin polarization , i.e. the sum @xmath105 at all times , as it should be , since it is zero at time @xmath13 ( the initial state is @xmath106 , which is a singlet state with zero nuclear polarization ) . the non - zero electronic spin polarization necessarily involves the admixture of the @xmath107 and @xmath108 triplet states , therefore this new cidnp mechanism is a low - magnetic - field effect , because at high fields the @xmath109 states are out of reach from the singlet state @xmath110 . how low a magnetic field depends on the recombination rate @xmath84 , since the triplet rp decay broadens the triplet energy levels by about @xmath84 , hence the mechanism is appreciable for magnetic fields @xmath97 such that @xmath111 , i.e. when the zeeman energy separation of @xmath109 is within the broadening @xmath84 . for @xmath112 , the effect is appreciable for fields @xmath113 . in closing , the following comments should be made : we stress that the new cidnp signal is a fundamental phenomenon attributed to the inherent quantum dynamics of radical - ion pairs . kaptein s rules provide a compact relation of the main features of the cidnp signal to the system s parameters . for this case , the sign of the effect , i.e. whether it is emissive ( + ) or absorptive ( - ) is the same as the sign of the hyperfine coupling @xmath23 . the new cidnp effect reported here does not require any particular combination or fine - tuning of magnetic interactions , like the coherent tsm low - field effect analyzed in @xcite , but is rather general and shows up whenever there is a non - zero nuclear spin polarization of singlet rps , @xmath60 , as in figure [ traces](b ) . the rather general requirement for this to happen is that the oscillation frequencies @xmath114 of the non - zero matrix elements @xmath115_{mn}=\langle m|q_{s}|n\rangle$ ] must have terms linear in the hyperfine couplings . here @xmath116 and @xmath117 are the eigenvectors and eigenvalues of @xmath26 , with @xmath118 , where @xmath119 is the nuclear spin multiplicity of the radical - pair . regarding experimental detection of the new cidnp effect we note the following . while nmr measurements at low fields suffer loss of sensitivity , recent methods of ultra - sensitive magnetometry using squids @xcite or atomic magnetometers @xcite have demonstrated the ability to sensitively detect nmr signals at near - zero magnetic fields . to provide a rough estimate of the magnetic field @xmath120 produced by the polarized nuclear spins , we note that in the solid phase the concentration of reaction centers can be as large as 1 mm . assuming just a single proton spin per rc ( which will heavily underestimate the magnitude of the effect ) , choosing a magnetic field of 1 g and taking into account that the considered enhancement will boost the thermal nuclear polarization by a factor @xmath0 , we find that the magnetic field just outside a spherical volume will be @xmath121 $ ] where @xmath122 $ ] is the reaction center concentration . at 1 g the thermal polarization is @xmath123 , hence @xmath124 , already 200 times higher than what state - of - the - art atomic magnetometers can do @xcite . in fact , this seems to be yet another exciting application of ultra - sensitive magnetometry in the biological realm @xcite . although we considered the special case @xmath20 , the new kind of cidnp signal we predict will ubiquitously affect all sorts of radical pairs , including of course the ones with asymmetric recombination rates @xmath9 , which predominantly occur in photosynthetic reaction centers @xcite . we have chosen to deal with the special case @xmath20 and a magnetic hamiltonian unable to support coherent generation of cidnp signals in order to be able to focus exclusively on this fundamentally new cidnp process . establishing how this mechanism attributed to s - t decoherence affects , qualitatively and quantitatively , the cases where _ there exists _ a cidnp signal according to the mechanism s traditional understanding ( e.g tsm , dd or dr scenarios ) is more involved an exercise that will be undertaken elsewhere . we have considered the cidnp signal in the rp state , and not in the diamagnetic ground state of the molecule in a closed reaction cycle as the one shown in figure [ cidnp](b ) . in other words in figure [ result ] we depicted the transient nuclear polarization of the radical - ion pairs in between their creation at time @xmath13 and the time their population has decayed to zero due to charge recombination . however , it is easily seen that the same results hold true for the diamagnetic ground state in the steady state under continuous excitation ( i.e. continuous illumination ) and a closed reaction cycle , as long as the intersystem crossing rate @xmath8 ( see figure [ cidnp]b ) is fast enough . concluding , this is the first step of a very promising research program , namely what are the particular repercussions of the recently unraveled fundamental quantum dynamics of the radical pair mechanism for understanding the dynamics of photosynthetic reaction centers . we have extended the fundamental understanding of cidnp by pointing to a new and qualitatively different way to obtaining enhanced nuclear spin polarization . interestingly , this polarization _ naturally _ turns out to be significant at low magnetic fields pertinent to natural photosynthesis . it stems from the random singlet or triplet projections _ naturally _ taking place during the quantum evolution of radical pairs and leading to spin decoherence . thus , an intriguing question raised is if and how the quantum mechanical process of spin decoherence affects the biological workings of photosynthetic reaction centers . in other words , what is the biological significance of earth - field cidnp produced by s - t decoherence ? since @xmath125 commutes with the electron spins @xmath126 and @xmath127 , it also commutes with @xmath128 and with @xmath129 . thus , since the two projection operators are orthogonal , i.e. @xmath130 , it will be @xmath131 . furthermore , since @xmath132 , it will be @xmath133 , and by using the previous relations it follows that indeed @xmath33 . since @xmath125 commutes with @xmath126 and @xmath134=ii_{y } , [ i_{z},i_{y}]=-ii_{x}$ ] , it follows that @xmath135=ia(s_{1x}i_{y}-s_{1y}i_{x})$ ] . then , heisenberg s equation of motion @xmath136 $ ] leads to @xmath137 the most general pure spin state of the rp can be written as @xmath138 , where @xmath139 are the four electron - spin s - t basis states and @xmath140 is a nuclear spin state . it is straightforward to show that @xmath141 , therefore @xmath142 at all times . the same holds true for any mixture of pure states . since at time @xmath13 we have an rp mixture with zero nuclear polarization , at all times it will be @xmath143\rangle=0 $ ] . the traditional master equation is @xmath35-k_{s}(q_{s}\rho+\rho q_{s})/2-k_{t}(q_{t}\rho+\rho q_{t})/2 $ ] . for the case under study @xmath144 , and taking into account that @xmath132 , the traditional master equation becomes @xmath35-k\rho$ ] . after multiplying with @xmath125 and taking the trace , it follows that according to the traditional theory it will be @xmath145i_{z}\}-k\langle i_{z}\rangle$ ] . but @xmath146i_{z}\}=-\tr\{[{\cal h},i_{z}]\rho\}=-\langle[{\cal h},i_{z}]\rangle$ ] , which was shown to equal zero in appendix 2 . therefore @xmath147 . since at @xmath13 it is @xmath34 , the same is true at all times . i warmly acknowledge helpful comments from profs . gunnar jeschke and ulrich steiner , and several comments clarifying cidnp - related issues from prof . jrg matysik . chin a w , huelga s f , plenio m b 2012 coherence and decoherence in biological systems : principles of noise - assisted transport and the origin of long - lived coherences _ phil . trans . act . soc . _ * 370 * 3638 daviso e _ et al _ 2009 the electronic structure of the primary electron donor of reaction centers of purple bacteria at atomic resolution as observed by photo - cidnp 13c nmr _ proc . usa _ * 106 * 22281

chemically induced dynamic nuclear polarization is a signature of spin order appearing in many photosynthetic reaction centers . such polarization , significantly enhanced above thermal equilibrium , is known to result from the nuclear spin sorting inherent in the radical pair mechanism underlying long - lived charge - separated states in photosynthetic reaction centers . we will here show that the recently understood fundamental quantum dynamics of radical - ion - pair reactions open up a new and completely unexpected venue towards obtaining cidnp signals . the fundamental decoherence mechanism inherent in the recombination process of radical pairs is shown to produce nuclear spin polarizations on the order of @xmath0 times or more higher than the thermal equilibrium value at earth s magnetic field relevant to natural photosynthesis . this opens up the possibility of a fundamentally new exploration of the biological significance of high nuclear polarizations in photosynthesis .

1001.0106

due to its use in thin film transistor ( tft ) applications pentacene is continuing to enjoy being the subject of extensive research . since most tft s employ sio@xmath2 as the dielectric layer , initial studies on pentacene focused mainly on gaining a thorough understanding of structural @xcite and electronic @xcite properties of thin films of this molecule on sio@xmath2 surfaces and in turn achieving the best device performance by optimizing @xcite these properties . as a result of this heavy research effort in the last decade , fabricating pentacene tft s with hole mobilities of more than 1 @xmath3/vs have become an almost routine process @xcite . nevertheless there are still , fundamental issues to be resolved such as the dependence of the charge mobility on the film thickness @xcite and areas open to improvement like modification of the substrate surfaces with buffer layers @xcite or the pentacene itself with functional groups @xcite . another very critical but relatively less well understood subject is the growth mechanism of pentacene films on metal substrates . understanding the pentacene film growth on gold and silver surfaces is particularly important since these metals constitute the electrode material in most tft s and the device performance is directly related to the charge transfer efficiency between the electrodes and the organic film . though both experimental @xcite and theoretical @xcite research in this field has been recently intensified , there are contradictory results in the literature and the growth modes of pentacene thin films on au(111 ) and ag(111 ) surfaces are continuing to be a matter of debate . this is mostly due to the relatively strong ( when compared with sio@xmath2 ) interaction of the metal surfaces with the pentacene molecule . as a result of this strong interaction pentacene adopts many different monolayer and multilayer phases on metal surfaces which are energetically and structurally very close to each other . for example on au(111 ) several different low density monolayer phases and an identical full coverage phase have been reported by different groups @xcite . however , in case of the multilayers while kang et al . @xcite report a layer by layer growth of lying down pentacene molecules , beernink et al . @xcite report strong dewetting starting from the second layer and growth of bulk like pentacene crystals . for pentacene films on ag(111 ) surfaces , while eremtchenko et al . @xcite and dougherty et al . @xcite report a bilayer film formation , where an ordered ( second ) layer ( which follows the symmetry of the ag(111 ) surface ) forms on top of a disordered ( 2d gas phase ) first layer at room temperature , kfer et al . @xcite report the formation of bulk - like pentacene structures immediately after the first monolayer . so on both surfaces the growth mechanism of pentacene films is still not completely clear . in addition , if the above mentioned 2d gas phase mechanism for ag(111 ) is really correct then questions like `` why does pentacene behave completely differently on seemingly similar surfaces , ag(111 ) and au(111 ) ? '' and `` how does the symmetry of the substrate affect the bilayer film structure ? '' arise . in spite of this richness of experimental studies and points in need of clarification , pentacene films on ag(111 ) or au(111 ) surfaces have not , yet , been studied theoretically . theoretical work regarding pentacene films were mostly performed on other metal surfaces , such as cu(001 ) @xcite , cu(110 ) @xcite , ag(110 ) @xcite , at semi - empiric level and al(100 ) @xcite , cu(100 ) @xcite , cu(119 ) @xcite , fe(100 ) @xcite , au(001 ) @xcite at dft level . these studies in general addressed two points concerning the first layer of pentacene film / molecule : ( 1 ) determination of the most stable adsorption site / geometry , and ( 2 ) determination of the strength of electronic interaction / coupling between the substrate and the molecule . in these studies either the most stable configuration was found to be pentacene lying flat on the surface @xcite or the calculations were started with this assumption . in terms of the electronic interactions , the dft studies performed using gga functionals found considerable aromatic-@xmath4-system metal substrate interaction @xcite on cu surfaces , hinting at chemisorption . on au(111 ) @xcite and al(100 ) @xcite however , while lda functionals resulted in strong interactions , in the form of broadening and splitting of @xmath4-molecular orbitals , gga functionals are reported to result in much weaker interactions , in accord with a physisorption mechanism . theoretical studies concerning the further stages of pentacene film growth on metal surfaces , however , like second layer structure / energetics or the thin film crystal / electronic structure , are very few and at semi - empiric level @xcite . instead , theoretical works regarding pentacene films are primarily focused on the electronic structure of different pentacene polymorphs observed mainly on sio@xmath2 surfaces , one being the famous `` thin film phase '' @xcite . hence , a theoretical study of growth mechanism and electronic properties of pentacene films on ag(111 ) and au(111 ) may , ( 1 ) help resolve the experimental contradictions mentioned above and ( 2 ) fill a gap in the theoretical literature and enable a comparison of these systems with other pentacene films . as a first attempt to this end , here we present the results of our work on the structural and electronic properties of monolayer and multilayer films of pentacene on ag(111 ) at dft level . first we discuss full coverage monolayer film in the light of experimental results . we compare the adsorption geometries and the corresponding density of states we found with the experimental results reported so far . then we present our results regarding two and three monolayers of pentacene film and discuss how the crystal and electronic structure of the ag(111)/pentacene interface and the film evolves with coverage . we conclude with an overall summary and discussion of the results . we performed total energy density functional theory ( dft ) calculations using the projector - augmented wave ( paw ) method @xcite within the generalized gradient approximation ( gga ) by employing the perdew ernzerhoff ( pbe ) @xcite exchange correlation energy functional as implemented in the vienna ab initio simulation package ( vasp ) @xcite . for consistency , we used a kinetic energy cutoff of 370 ev for the plane wave expansion of single particle wavefunctions in all the calculations . electronic ground states has been determined by requiring a total - energy convergence up to a tolerance value smaller than 0.1 mev . we used a conjugate - gradient algorithm , in all geometry optimization calculations , based on the reduction in the hellman feynman forces on each constituent atom to less than 10 mev / . we examined two previously known polymorphs of pn lattice : the bulk @xcite and the thin film @xcite phases . bulk phase corresponds to a triclinic unit cell which contains two c@xmath5 formulae with a set of parameters : @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 @xcite . our calculated values of @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath12 , @xmath10 , and @xmath13 shows a very good agrement with the experimental results of campbell _ et al . _ for the thin film phase , we obtained an orthorhombic unit cell with @xmath14 , @xmath15 , and @xmath16 . these parameters agree with parisse _ @xcite theoretical results of @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 except for the last one , corresponding to the longitudinal size of the unit cell . we calculated the length of an isolated molecule to be 14.5 . therefore , the disagreement , in this phase , stems from the pn pn separation in the multilayers . in order to compare the predictions of different dft functionals with the experimental results for key structural and electronic parameters like the lattice constants and binding energies , we repeated our calculations using pw91 @xcite parametrization within both generalized gradient and local density approximations ( lda ) . we calculated the lattice parameter of the silver _ ccp _ bulk structure in @xmath20 symmetry group to be 4.00 , 4.15 , and 4.17 using lda - pw91 , gga - pw91 , and gga - pbe functionals respectively . these compare well with the experimental @xcite value of 4.09 , slightly better than the previous theoretical @xcite result of 4.20 . the ag(111 ) surface has been modeled in a four - layer slab geometry separated from their periodic images by @xmath2115 of a vacuum space and 3@xmath226@xmath221 grid for the cases of 1ml to 4ml deposition , whereas in the cases of isolated pn adsorption a larger cell is needed and therefore a three - layer - slab geometry for the ag(111 ) surface and 1@xmath222@xmath221 grid was used . for this metallic system , the number of layers has been found to be sufficiently large to represent the ag(111 ) surface structure such that the geometry optimization calculations do not disturb the subsurface layer atoms from their bulk lattice positions . in order to study the formation of ordered pn layers on ag(111 ) we first considered a single pn on the surface . isolation of the molecules was achieved by using a 8@xmath225 silver surface unit cell which sets 9.5 tip - to - tip and 7.9 side - to - side separations between the periodic images . we determined the minimum energy pn / ag(111 ) geometry by investigating all possible adsorption sites with a number of orientations , compatible with the lattice symmetry , at each site as shown in [ fig1 ] . ( labeling conventions are described in figure caption . ) in addition to these planar cases we also investigated the possibility of standing - up adsorption configurations which appeared to be around 0.15 ev less favorable than the planar ones . in geometry optimization calculations pn develops a weak interaction with ag(111 ) wherever it is initially placed on the surface . in fact , as presented in [ table1 ] , the comparison of the total energies of these adsorption cases show differences which are no greater than 36 mev from each other . the flatness of the potential energy surface ( pes ) is indicated by the existence of such small barriers which might make pn diffusion over the surface possible in agreement with the experimental observations that the contact layer pn molecules are mobile at the pn / ag(111 ) interface @xcite . similarly , during image acquisition stm tip has been observed to drag pn molecules which are physisorbed on au(111 ) @xcite . .calculated values for geometrical and electronic structure of pn / ag(111 ) systems shown in [ fig1 ] . the lateral height of isolated pn molecule from the ag(111 ) surface @xmath23 in , the binding energy @xmath24 and the relative total energy @xmath25 in ev . [ cols="<,^,^,^ " , ] the flat and tilted pentacene configurations above the first layer has also been considered for the 3ml and 4ml initial structures . the difference in the total energies has been calculated to be 0.127 ev and 0.125 ev in favor of the tilted molecules on the first layer for 3ml and 4ml cases , respectively . therefore , bulk - like pentacene formation on ag(111 ) surface above the contact layer is more preferable than flat lying multilayers . in the case of multilayers , the separation of the top layer from the layer underneath is 3.6 and all the inner interlayer distances become 3.5 while the height of the contact layer converges to a value of 3.7 after the third ml . in addition , our calculations show a decrease in the misalignment of pentacenes above the contact layer as new layers deposited on ag(111 ) surface up to 4ml . all multilayer geometries can be seen through [ fig3]b d , which only show views of the 4ml structure , since the interlayer distances and angles do not change significantly as new layers added . we also present the corresponding electronic density contour plot of pentacene ag(111 ) interface at 4ml in [ fig4 ] which indicates charge localization around pentacene molecules and in the substrate suggesting weak binding of the contact layer . consequently , the thin film formation starting from the second ml indicates that the intermolecular interactions are relatively stronger than the pentacene silver interaction . substantiatively , the misalignment of pentacenes above the contact layer can also be attributed to the weakness of pn ag(111 ) interaction . in fact , this observation is in parallel with the experimental observations of danisman et al . @xcite whereupon desorption of the pentacene multilayers on a stepped ag(111 ) surface a new monolayer phase was observed . in addition , tilted second layer structure was also reported by both eremthcenko et al.@xcite and kfer et al . @xcite furthermore , molecular rearrangements involving such topological phase transformations from flat to buckled pentacene multilayers mimicking thin film formation on ag(111 ) can be expected to give the same order of energy differences as that of thin film and the bulk pentacene phases . one final point to be stressed here is that , although ( i ) our results may be helpful for the comparison of stability of flat and tilted multilayers , and ( ii ) the more stable multilayer configurations we found resemble the experimentally observed pentacene phases@xcite ( i.e. , the tilt angles are very close to that of pentacene bulk and thin film phases ) , a direct comparison of our results with the experimentally observed structures may not be very meaningful . this is because the multilayer and monolayer in - plane unit - cell dimensions which are actually different had to be chosen the same due to computational restrictions . in order to investigate the coupling of the frontier molecular orbitals of pentacene to the silver substrate states , we obtained the stm pictures by using tersoff hamann approximation @xcite . the calculated stm images for the applied voltages of @xmath26 v and @xmath27 v in [ fig5 ] resemble to the homo and lumo charge densities of an isolated pn similar to lee _ et al . _ s result @xcite . our results also agree well with the recent differential conductance images obtained with low - temperature stm experiments for seemingly similar physisorption system of pentacene / au(111 ) @xcite . these stm images in [ fig5 ] are consistent and are also apparent from the pdos of 1ml pn / ag(111 ) presented in [ fig6 ] . the first pdos peak of the pn layer about 0.5 ev below the fermi energy comes from the homo s of the molecules . the sharpness of this peak substantiates that the frontier orbitals of the pn molecules mixes very weakly with the @xmath28 states of the surface ag atoms . hence , stm calculation covering an energy range of 0.9 ev below the fermi level shows homo charge density for pn layer over the slab as shown in [ fig5 ] where the small ag @xmath28 contribution was suppressed for visual convenience . similarly , the first peak due to pn layer about 0.7 ev above the fermi energy corresponds to the lumo s of the molecules which are also weakly mixing with the valence bands of ag(111 ) . at this point , in order to comment on the reliability of our method , we compare the experimental and theoretical results of pn ferretti et al . @xcite , on this system , have found a significant broadening of pentacene homo lumo bands and mixing with the substrate levels using the same computational procedure . this , in combination with the experimental results , were interpreted as an interaction close to chemisorption . in pn ag(111 ) case , however , it is clear from our results that the picture is more close to physisorption . the bottom panel of [ fig6 ] shows the calculated dos for the flat pentacene layer which is obtained by removing the silver substrate from 1ml / ag(111 ) ( [ fig3]a c ) structure . the sharp peaks , having less structure , rather look like an energy level diagram due to very low overlap between molecular orbitals through tip to tip pentacene contacts over the layer . metallic nature of the bare ag(111 ) surface is also presented in the succeeding panel of [ fig6 ] where fermi level is set as the origin of the energy axis . the dos structure corresponding to full pentacene monolayer on ag(111 ) is shown in the third panel from the bottom in [ fig6 ] . dos peaks stemming from pentacene show no shift in energy with respect to those of the flat pn layer in the absence of the metal substrate . in addition , the broadening of each peak is localized over a small number of silver states indicating weak semiconductor metal coupling . as a result of this weak interaction , the contact layer shows bulk - like homo lumo contributions to the total dos around the fermi energy . therefore , stm experiments capture these frontier molecular orbitals . as new pentacene layers deposited on the first full monolayer the corresponding pdos contribution starts to form localized satellite structures at around flat pn layer peak positions . their broadening is larger than the broadening in pdos peaks obtained for 1ml / ag(111 ) . this indicates that the interlayer molecular orbital overlap is relatively stronger than the coupling between the contact layer and the metal substrate . moreover , these pdos satellites match perfectly with the bulk pentacene dos which is presented in the top panel of [ fig6 ] . therefore , energetically preferable thin film pentacene phase on ag(111 ) up to 4ml possesses bulk - like dos properties . our dos calculations show that pentacene has no electronic contribution at the fermi energy . evidently , highly ordered pentacene multilayers on ag(111 ) , considered in this study , does not exhibit band transport . in addition , these multilayers occur in bulk - like phase where the overlap of the molecular orbitals between nearest neighbor pentacenes yield large @xmath4-conjugation length along the molecular axis . therefore , our results suggest a hopping mechanism between the localized states for the carrier transport . in conclusion , we have investigated the geometric and electronic structure of pentacene on ag(111 ) surface up to 4 ml coverage at the dft level where gga functionals perform better . at the most stable configuration a single isolated pentacene lies flat at 3.9 above ag(111 ) surface on the so called bridge-60 position with a weak binding energy of @xmath290.155 ev . for the full monolayer coverage , molecules align perfectly with the silver rows on the surface while the ml height extends slightly to 4.1 due to intermolecular interactions . calculated binding energies as well as stm and pdos structures indicate weak pentacene substrate coupling . pentacenes above the contact layer favor the thin film multilayer structure over the planar configuration with a slight energy difference which can be addressed to the small energy barriers between different phases of pentacene . moreover , the slight misalignment of pentacene molecules above the first layer from the surface silver rows indicate that a bulk - like thin film phase starting from the second layer is adsorbed on the ag(111 ) surface through a contact layer at the interface .

the structural profiles and electronic properties of pentacene ( c@xmath0h@xmath1 ) multilayers on ag(111 ) surface has been studied within the density functional theory ( dft ) framework . we have performed first - principle total energy calculations based on the projector augmented wave ( paw ) method to investigate the initial growth patterns of pentacene ( pn ) on ag(111 ) surface . in its bulk phase , pentacene crystallizes with a triclinic symmetry while a thin film phase having an orthorhombic unit cell is energetically less favorable by 0.12 ev / cell . pentacene prefers to stay planar on ag(111 ) surface and aligns perfectly along silver rows without any molecular deformation at a height of 3.9 . at one monolayer ( ml ) coverage the separation between the molecular layer and the surface plane extends to 4.1 due to intermolecular interactions weakening surface pentacene attraction . while the first ml remains flat , the molecules on a second full pentacene layer deposited on the surface rearrange so that they become skewed with respect to each other . this adsorption mode is energetically more preferable than the one for which the molecules form a flat pentacene layer by an energy difference similar to that obtained for bulk and thin film phases . moreover , as new layers added , pentacenes assemble to maintain this tilting for 3 and 4 ml similar to its bulk phase while the contact layer always remains planar . therefore , our calculations indicate bulk - like initial stages for the growth pattern .

cond-mat0011450

granular materials constitute the raw materials in a huge number of human activities as in agriculture , the mining industry , pharmaceutics and are at the heart of the matter in several ecological concerns as desertification by eolian erosion or avalanches . therefore , explaining a few current granular processes , such as storage , transport , or collapse , is a real economical challenge . furthermore , packings of spheres which is the simplest model for granular medium , have a great fundamental interest for physicists : hard sphere systems are indeed a common description of simple liquids @xcite ; moreover grains can behave , according to the external conditions , more or less like a solid , a liquid or a gas @xcite . this great variety of behaviors for a banal heap of grains makes granular mechanics a rich area of investigation only partially clarified at the moment . it is now a well - known result @xcite ( although there is no theoretical explanation for it ) that a disordered static packing of equal hard spheres can cover a large range of volume fraction , approximately from 56 @xmath0 , the random loose packing ( r.l.p . ) , to 64 @xmath0 , the random close packing ( r.c.p . ) . for a regular arrangement , the packing fraction can reach up to 74 @xmath0 which corresponds to the densest structures , namely the hexagonal compact ( h.c . ) and the face - centered cubic ( f.c.c . ) crystals . + as thermal energy ( @xmath1 t ) plays no role , because it is insignificant compared to the gravitational energy of a macroscopic grain , each packing of spheres is a metastable configuration which can persist as long as there is no external excitation . in this frame , the issues of compaction of grains under vertical taps are a practical way to study the succession of jumps from a metastable equilibrium to another one . the initial packing is quite loose and can progressively reach a nearly stationary configuration ( steady state ) evaluated through its average volume fraction . some experiments done in chicago @xcite have studied the influence of the tapping intensity on the steady - state value and the dynamics of the compaction , which is approximately inverse of the logarithm of the number of taps . the experimental set - up is a thin tube of diameter d=1.88 cm filled to about an 80 cm height with monodisperse , spherical soda - lime glass beads ( of diameter d=1 , 2 or 3 mm ) . the tube is shaken by an electromagnetic exciter delivering vertical taps , each of them consisting of an entire cycle of a sine - wave of frequency f = 30 hz . the excitation strength is parameterized by @xmath2 , the ratio between the measured acceleration peak and the gravitational acceleration g. moreover , several numerical and theoretical works @xcite , most of them dealing with the notions of free volume and geometric constraint , found the same kind of behavior as obtained experimentally and some of them @xcite have pointed out structural ageing effects , as typically observed in glassy systems . so a parallel might exist between this granular compaction and the dynamics of out - of - equilibrium systems as glasses . + in this work , we used a simple model to simulate the compaction of a packing of monosize spheres submitted to vertical taps . we did not try to make a realistic description of the quite complex succession of collisions in a shaken packing : we have kept as the only ingredient of the model the geometric constraint between hard spheres , which is believed to be the principal origin of the compaction . despite the fact that we deliberately forgot the mechanical dimension of the problem , the model is able to reproduce qualitatively the experimental results of the chicago group and some further results in agreement with different numerical and theoretical studies . as the model seems to capture the physics of the problem , it is then possible to go beyond a global analysis . indeed , as a three - dimensional packing of hard spheres , our description has the quite interesting asset that it is very close to a real granular medium . so , contrary to almost all the previous works which deal only with a macroscopic probe ( i.e. the average density in all or part of the packing ) , our model can provide us with realistic information on the local structure of a packing and its evolution under compaction by taps . + the paper is organized as follows . a detailed description of the model is presented in section ii . section iii is devoted to the global analysis of compaction ( logarithmic dynamics , hysteresis effect , and ageing behaviors ) . in section iv , the local analysis of the packings is described with the use of density profiles and size and volume distributions of the pores . our conclusions and perspectives end the paper in section v. the model proposed here is purely geometric and deals only with the steric constraint , neither friction nor contact law between the spheres or with the walls is introduced . + the different sequences of tapping were initialized from a relatively loose packing obtained by a steepest - descent algorithm simulating a sequential gravitational deposition @xcite . we worked with packings of 4096 spheres of radius r piled up in a square - box of dimension l = 32r . concerning the vertical walls , we used both periodic boundary conditions ( p.b.c . ) and fixed boundary conditions ( f.b.c . ) i.e. impassable vertical planes . the top of the box is open whereas the bottom is a fixed impassable plane . + a tap is decomposed in two stages : first a vertical dilation and then a gravitational redeposition . + the first stage corresponds to the external excitation which will enable the packing to move from a metastable equilibrium to another one . we used the simplest way to simulate the tap by applying an uniform dilation @xmath3 to the whole packing ( z @xmath4 z(1+@xmath3 ) ) . this reduction is certainly far from a real tap but we assume that the way of dilating the packing is less important than the result of the dilation : a significant increase of the average free - volume of the spheres which will allow collective rearrangements during the second stage , the redeposition of the packing . + this redeposition procedure must be non - sequential in order to permit such collective behaviors ; so we use a monte - carlo algorithm to discretise the motion of the spheres : a great number of small displacements are computed . an individual movement procedure is structured as follows : a sphere , randomly chosen , is submitted to a small random displacement ; if this displacement creates no interpenetration with another sphere or with the walls ( according to the boundary conditions ) , it is accepted otherwise it is rejected . because of this binary schema , two neighboring spheres can not be exactly in contact but , after a sufficient time , they get very close to contact . figure [ algorithm ] shows a typical displacement : the values of the polar angle @xmath5 and of the displacement d are strictly randomly chosen respectively between 0 and 2@xmath6 and between 0 and @xmath7 , whereas the choice of the angle @xmath8 follows a random distribution centered on zero to mimic the effect of gravity . we used the following gaussian distribution of width @xmath9 truncated beyond @xmath6/2 in order to orientate all the displacements down to the bottom of the box . @xmath10 the choice of the distribution does not seem to be restrictive : some attempts with a poissonian and a linear distribution give qualitatively the same phenomenology ; the pertinent parameter is the width @xmath9 . + with such an algorithm , agitation will persist indefinitely . so we regularly test the packing during the redeposition process . the variable checked is @xmath11z@xmath12 , the average altitude of the packing that is the average potential energy of the spheres . the redeposition is stopped when the relative variation of @xmath11z@xmath12 becomes smaller than a threshold @xmath13 . the choice of @xmath11z@xmath12 is motivated by its easy evaluation during the process and by its possible link with a statistical mechanics approach . + this simulation is rather close to the one proposed by barker and mehta @xcite but with some differences especially concerning the way of introducing gravity and the end of the redeposition stage . + + the model uses four parameters : @xmath7 , @xmath13 , @xmath9 and @xmath3 . the two first ones have a direct effect on the simulation time . the smaller @xmath13 , the longer the simulation time ; still , @xmath13 must be small enough if we want the redeposition to be nearly completed . the parameter @xmath7 has to be optimised . a very small value of @xmath7 allows almost all of the displacements to be accepted but the effect on the redeposition is very slight and the packing is therefore nearly frozen . on the contrary , for a large value of @xmath7 , almost of all the displacements are refused and , once again , the packing evolves very slowly . in this study , we used the intermediate value @xmath7 = r/5 . + @xmath9 has a significant effect on the packing behavior : a very small @xmath9 induces a decompaction whereas a large value decreases the efficiency of the compaction . we found @xmath9 = @xmath6/4 as the optimised value giving rise to the maximal compaction rate . + the last parameter , @xmath3 , corresponds to the external excitation induced in the packing . this is our control parameter . the value of @xmath3 can be estimated from experimental results concerning the dilation of a vertically shaken sand heap @xcite : @xmath3 = @xmath14h / h @xmath15 5/500 @xmath16 . we can also try to link roughly @xmath3 to the experimental control parameter , the dimensionless acceleration @xmath2 = a@xmath17/g where a and @xmath18 are , respectively , the amplitude and the frequency imposed to the bottom of the heap . in first approximation , if we neglect the loss of energy in the packing , a particle at the top of the heap ( z(0 ) = h ) acquires an initial speed @xmath18a and achieves a ballistic flight . its maximal altitude is @xmath19 and then it comes : @xmath20 as @xmath21 is linked to @xmath2 , we will use it as our control parameter to quantify the strength of the tapping process . + with this , it is possible to compare the results of our model with the experimental work of the chicago group and with other numerical and theoretical models , almost all of them dealing only with a global description of the granular system . this global analysis is achieved with different average values . we did not use a direct evaluation of the packing fraction from the number of spheres in a reference volume because wether boundary effects are significant or , for a smaller volume , the statistics become too poor . moreover , the choice of the reference volume is not unique : it can be , for example , the space that contains all the spheres or the smaller one that contains only the centers of the spheres . to avoid being partial , we evaluate the packing fraction by averaging the surface packing fraction , @xmath22 , calculated on many horizontal cuts . this measure is permissible because of the following stereologic result : the average surface fraction of any cut in a packing is equal to the volume fraction of the packing @xcite ; with horizontal cuts , this calculus is just a spatial integration which gives the exact volume fraction . the quantity @xmath23 is calculated in this way at the bottom of the packing between the heights 0 and 4r ; @xmath24 comes from a similar calculation on approximately 90 @xmath0 of the packing and is corrected near the bottom wall by a perturbated zone model @xcite . this model uses a corrective factor for the average density of a packing near a wall ( between 0 and r ) with regard of a packing not perturbated by any wall . for the case of spheres near a plane , this factor is estimated to 16/11 . it is also interesting to study @xmath11z@xmath12 , the average potential energy of the whole system , which is quite pertinent in a statistical mechanics description . the densification of the packing is observed through the temporal evolution of the preceding mean values ; here the time is the number of taps and what we call dynamics of the compaction is , in fact , the succession of metastable equilibrium , each jump from one to another being induced by the taps . figure [ fig - dynamics ] shows compaction laws obtained with fixed boundaries ( f.b.c . ) and three different excitation rates . this excitation intensity @xmath21 has a decided effect on the compaction dynamics ( see section [ sec : hysteresis ] ) . the simulation curves are in good agreement with the experimental data and compatible with the following fit previously proposed @xcite : @xmath25 with x = @xmath23 or @xmath24 . for @xmath11z@xmath12 , a nearly similar fit can be proposed : @xmath26 we have noticed that a sum of two exponentials can also fit @xmath11z@xmath12(t ) reasonably well . + the dependance of these parameters on @xmath3 is difficult to characterize . we simply note that the parameter b is consistent with an exponential dependance on @xmath21 ( i.e. @xmath2 ) . + this compaction dynamics is quite particular : as the packing progressively densifies , the compaction efficiency decreases . so the dynamics reduces speed and the system evolves to a steady - state without never really reaching it . this slowing down is particularly remarkable for the smallest values of @xmath21 . this specific dynamics requires the study of the densification on a logarithmic time scale . + it is also interesting to analyse the fluctuations of the curves , especially when the packing becomes close to its asymptotic or steady - state ( ss ) limit . the power spectrum of the fluctuations x - x@xmath27 as a function of the frequency , i.e. the inverse of the taps number , shows more or less a simple power - law in a log - log diagram ( with a slope in the range 1 to 1.5 ) . the effect of @xmath3 is noticable only for the high frequencies . moreover , the simple standard deviation of the fluctuations , @xmath28 = @xmath29 , seems to be directly proportional to @xmath21 or @xmath2 . these results , calculated for @xmath30z@xmath12 , are presented in figure [ fig - fluctuations ] . + furthermore , we have noticed that the periodic boundary conditions do not qualitatively affect these observations ; the same remark can be made concerning the results of the following section . the next stage consists on studying the influence of the excitation parameter @xmath21 on the maximal value of the packing fraction . for this purpose , we carried out a succession of simulations with a sequence of 4000 taps . the steady - state value is estimated by averaging the packing fraction on the 1000 last taps or directly through the last value . the smaller is @xmath21 and the larger is the difference between this steady - state value and the asymptotic value @xmath31 given by the fit . moreover , in this small excitations range , @xmath31 can get over the r.c.p . limit and @xmath32 , the characteristic time of the fit , increases spectacularly . in fact , the fit becomes more and more uncertain in so far as the triplet ( @xmath31 , b , @xmath32 ) is no longer unique , and depends strongly on the range of taps over which the data fitting is performed . this deviation between the steady - state value and an uncertain asymptotic limit has also been noticed in the experimental work of the chicago group @xcite and in some theoretical studies @xcite . the dependance of @xmath24 on @xmath21 is shown in figure [ fig - hyst ] ( solid black squares ) . the different packings are obtained after 4000 taps of strength @xmath3 , starting from the same initial packing . the curve has a bell shape with a maximum between 0.1 and 0.2 . + + if we now compute a unique tapping sequence with a progressive increase of the excitation @xmath21 after every 4000 taps ( constant excitation increment : @xmath33 ) , we obtain nearly the same curve for @xmath24 , as can be seen in figure [ fig - hyst ] ( open circles ) . when carrying out the same process in the opposite way i.e. with a progressive decrease of @xmath21 ( @xmath34 ) , two things can happen : + if , while increasing , @xmath21 went beyond a critical value of @xmath35 @xmath36 , the final packing fraction @xmath24 does not decrease but increases a bit more to a maximum value . if we compute another increase process ( @xmath33 ) , we cover approximately the same values . this last upper branch , including the part above @xmath35 is represented on figure [ fig - hyst ] ( up and down open triangles ) . as it is relatively well reproductible , it is called `` reversible '' . we can also notice on this reversible branch that @xmath24 decreases with @xmath21 . + on the contrary , if @xmath21 stayed below @xmath35 during the increase stage , the steady - state values do not evolve significantly ; they are nearly frozen , and it is hard to estimate whether there is a compaction or a decompaction process , because the dynamics is very slow . this last branch is called `` irreversible '' and reflects the great metastability of the corresponding packings . + to summarize , there is a strong hysteresis effect which allows the maximum compaction rate to be reached by an @xmath21 increase - decrease sequence . these observations are in very good agreement with the results of nowak @xmath37 al @xcite . in particular , figure [ fig - hyst ] is to be compared to the experimental data obtained with 1 mm diameter beads , corresponding to an aspect - ratio of nearly 19 , close to that used in our simulation ( l/2r = 16 ) . surprisingly , for an aspect - ratio of 9 , the experimental results show a much larger increase of the packing fraction on the reversible branch , up to nearly 66 @xmath0 ( i.e. more than the r.c.p . limit which may indicate a commensurability between the cylinder and the beads @xcite ) . however , for a still smaller aspect - ratio of 6 , the reversible branch is more similar to the first case , with a moderate increase to a maximal value below the 64 @xmath0 limit . in these kind of systems in slow evolution to a final equilibrium , it is possible to demonstrate ageing effects by comparing the system at different ages . this comparison can be made by use of temporal correlation functions of global values ( @xmath38,@xmath11z@xmath12 , ... ) between the initial packing and the same packing after an evolution time @xmath39 ( waiting time ) . in this study we work with the following function : @xmath40 here , @xmath41 indicates the statistical average of x ; that is , the mean value calculated for a certain number of realizations of the same experiment . the results have been averaged on only 10 realizations because of the limitation due to the calculation time . the statistics are , therefore , rather poor , that is why we use solely @xmath11z@xmath12 , which fluctuates quite less than the other global values . in figure [ fig - ageing ] are drawn the curves of a(t , t@xmath42 ) obtained for different values of t@xmath42 . there is obviously a scaling law ; a similar fit as in section [ sec : dynamics ] , with the three parameters @xmath43 ( the asymptotic limit ) , @xmath44 and @xmath45 , is quite compatible with the data : @xmath46 the same kind of ageing effects have already been pointed out in previous numerical studies @xcite . these effects confirms the great similarity between granular compaction or more generally slow granular rheology and glassy systems submitted to time - dependent driving forces ( see for instance @xcite ) . + + to conclude with the global analysis of the compaction , it is satisfying to note that our simulation reproduces qualitatively well the previous results obtained both experimentally and theoretically . this model seems to capture most of the physics of the problem . because it gives a very realistic description of a granular system as a three - dimensional packing of hard spheres , it can be a quite useful and interesting tool to go beyond a global description to a local analysis of the packings structure during the compaction process . to study locally the packings of spheres more or less compacted , we use two kind of descriptions : packing fraction ( or density ) profiles are calculated vertically and transversly to the box , and size and volume distributions of the pores in a packing are evaluated and then analysed . using the surface packing fraction calculated by stereological cuts ( as in the evaluation of @xmath47 and @xmath24 ) , we can have access to vertical ( horizontal cuts ) and transverse ( vertical cuts ) density profiles . + some examples of vertical profiles are shown in figure [ vert - prof ] . these have been obtained with fixed boundary conditions ( f.b.c . ) , but the use of periodic boundaries ( p.b.c . ) induces no significant differences . the profiles are characterised in particular by a negative vertical gradient @xmath48 and by large peaks near the bottom of the box . these peaks reflect a partially ordered packing due to the wall and are very close to previous experimental observations @xcite . the gradient can be roughly estimated in an intermediate zone ( 5 @xmath49 z / r @xmath49 22 for f.b.c . and 5 @xmath49 z / r @xmath49 26 for p.b.c . ) after smoothing the profile . this gradient , directly linked to @xmath3 , is qualitatively different from previous numerical results @xcite , where a local densification is obtained at the interface . it could be objected that this gradient comes directly from the modeling of the tap through an uniform dilation . nevertheless , despite the fact that @xmath48 is difficult to estimate very precisely , it does not seem to be monotonic with @xmath21 , but has more or less the same kind of bell - shaped dependance as the other steady - state values . this behavior can not be caused only by the dilation . but , in contrast to the other average values , it seems that @xmath48 presents no hysteresis effect which denotes a relatively different behavior . in conclusion , the origin of the anisotropy of the packing , observed through this gradient @xmath48 , is not well understood . it may come from both the uniform dilation of the system and its specific redeposition under the simulated particle motion under gravity . + being inspired by a fermi level profile @xcite , we can propose the following average fit for a typical vertical profile : @xmath50 figure [ trans - prof ] presents a few transverse profiles in fixed boundaries ; they are qualitatively close to experimental profiles @xcite . here again , some peaks indicate a local organisation in layers due to the walls ; this effect has approximately a three layers range . the average lateral density increase ( at a distance less than 7r from the walls corresponding roughly to this wall effects range ) is noted @xmath51 as is the central increase @xmath52 . the last one is systematically smaller than the other . both of them are calculated in comparison with the initial profiles and reflect the spatial repartition of the bulk compaction . these profiles with periodic boundaries reveal no peak , due to the absence of walls . the central zone is a bit larger but keeps the same qualitative shape and densifies as well during a tapping sequence . this observation of an obvious compaction even in p.b.c . ensures that compaction is not , or at least not principally , due to wall effects . this was not evident considering the small aspect ratio used in the experience of the chicago group . quantitatively , the absolute value of the packing fraction is larger in the periodic conditions but its increase due to compaction is a bit smaller . + as global values , @xmath51 and @xmath52 have the same dependence on @xmath21 ( bell shaped curves ) than the others . it is also possible to study their evolution with the number of taps . the results , presented in figure [ increases ] , point out , once again , the nearly frozen dynamics for small values of @xmath21 . + moreover , we can remark that the initial packing in f.b.c . presents a great metastability . this one is particularly noticeable on the transverse profile ( see fig . [ trans - prof ] ) with an `` under - population '' of the spheres near the walls . this explains the significant compaction of @xmath51 caused by the first tap ( see fig . [ increases ] ) . this metastability is due to the construction of the initial packing : it was built by a gravitational algorithm [ 16 ] with periodic conditions , and a slight agitation was then induced in the packing to adapt it to fixed boundary conditions ( f.b.c . ) . this last stage was not sufficiently efficient . another way to analyse a packing of particules is to study the interstitial voids . this void - space is more difficult to apprehend because , in contrast to a particle , a cavity has no geometric limit . we then introduce the notion of pore as the `` void '' between four neighboring spheres . previous studies have already been made on this issue , both theoretically and experimentally . gotoh @xcite introduced the pore size distribution @xmath53 as the probability for a randomly positioned sphere of radius r to intercept no particle center . he proposed a theoretical expression for @xmath53 derived from the percus - yevick approximation which agrees well with previous results on random close packings @xcite : @xmath54 \label{gotoh distribution}\end{aligned}\ ] ] + where @xmath55 is the ratio r/r ( r is the radius of the hard spheres ) and @xmath22 is the average volume fraction . figure [ fig - gotoh ] confronts this expression with the distribution calculated in one of the packing obtained after a compaction sequence of 4000 taps ( @xmath56 ) and with periodic boundaries . the distribution calculated in the initial packing ( @xmath57 ) is also represented and is quite close to the other . this slight difference means that the distribution @xmath53 is insufficiently sensitive to small structural changes as compaction . + + hence we find that it is more efficient to work with a direct statistical analysis on the size of the pores . to do this , we use the vorono tesselation of a packing @xcite : a vorono polyhedon around a sphere is the region of space in which all the points are closer to this given sphere than to any other . two neighbors correspond to two vorono polyhedra that share a face . each vertex is equidistant from the center of four neighboring spheres and therefore constitutes a pore . more precisely , we define the pore as the virtual sphere in contact with these four neighboring spheres which interpenetrates none of them . the size of the pore is then the radius of this `` void- sphere '' . the volume of this sphere reflects partially the total void - volume situated inside the tetrahedron formed by the centers of the four neighboring spheres . in a packing , it is possible to calculate the size distribution of the pores @xmath58 , where @xmath59 with r the radius of a pore and r the radius of the hard spheres . the normalisation of the distribution gives @xmath60 , the total number of pores in the measurement volume . this distribution is linked to gotoh s one . thus , @xmath61 is more or less the sum of the pores of size greater than r. therefore @xmath53 is a cumulative distribution in comparison with @xmath62 , which is expected to be more sensitive to the local structure . a rather similar analysis by use of the size distribution of the pores was previously sketched out by barker and mehta @xcite . + if we now use directly the normalized volume @xmath63 as new variable , the corresponding statistical density is @xmath64 ( here the `` volume '' of a pore is reduced to @xmath65 ) . the distribution @xmath66 reflects the contribution of the pores to the total porosity according to their size ; this last distribution seems to be the more pertinent in problems of free volume and compaction . we have noted that , by integrating @xmath66 , a new global value is obtained and corresponds to the average normalized volume of a spherical pore : @xmath67 , where @xmath68 is the average volume of a pore , v is the volume of the hard spheres , and @xmath69 is the number of pores . the average pore volume @xmath70 has the same dynamics and the same kind of reversible - irreversible behavior as described in section [ sec : hysteresis ] . figure [ fig - dist ] a ) shows the distributions @xmath66 for a given packing at different stages of its compaction ( in f.b.c . and with an excitation strength @xmath71 ) . the statistics are calculated in a smaller box of height 18r located at a distance 2r from the walls to avoid some boundary problems . in this measurement volume , @xmath69 varies approximately from 9550 to 10250 for the different packings analysed . these different volume distributions @xmath66 are slightly affected by the taps in the small pore domain , whereas the variation of the packing fraction clearly appears in the progressive reduction of the tail of the distribution in the large pore zone . so , there is more or less a persistence of the distribution for the values of v approximately limited by the volume of an octohedral site ( @xmath72 and @xmath73 ) . the distribution @xmath66 is bell - shaped with an over - population for the largest pores ( the tail ) and with a minimum size of the pores corresponding to a tetrahedral site ( @xmath74 and @xmath75 ) . with respect to the small pores , this is in contradiction with a poisson distribution proposed in a previous theorical model for logarithmic dynamics @xcite . but , in figure [ fig - dist ] b ) , we note that , in the range of volume corresponding to the tail of the distribution , @xmath76 is compatible with a poisson law : @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is directly linked to @xmath70 , the average normalized volume already defined , or to @xmath24 , the average packing fraction . + + these results must be compared with previous work on the issue . first , bernal @xcite analyzed the arrangements of spheres by characterizing the cavities between the spheres . to do this , he studied the different polyhedra formed by the sphere centers as corner . he found five canonical holes . table [ tab1 ] @xcite presents his results obtained on a mechanical model of hard spheres and concerning the statistical weight ( in number and in volume ) and the @xmath79-value corresponding to each hole . in fact , these canonical holes are more or less distorted ( otherwise @xmath58 would be an addition of dirac peaks ) and the @xmath79-value corresponding to the regular hole is therefore a lower limit . so we can note that the tetrahedron and the tetragonal dodecahedron correspond to the smallest values of @xmath79 for which we have shown that the volume distribution @xmath66 is not greatly affected by the tapping process . in contrast , the octahedron , the trigonal prism and the archimedian antiprism ( the two last in very low proportions ) appear in the large pores range and are consequently more sensitive to the compaction state of the packing . so , according to this bernal s classification on the structure of the pores , we can suggest that compaction is principally due to rearrangements of the three largest canonical pores . a simple model of hard spheres under vertical taps based solely on geometric constraint is sufficient to qualitatively describe previous experimental and numerical results : the same kind of compaction dynamics , hysteresis effect on the steady - state values , and ageing behaviors . the originality of this model , i.e. a realistic description of a granular system as a three - dimensional packing of hard spheres , permits a structural analysis of the packings . a semi - local study on density profiles suggests the existence of a negative vertical gradient in the packings but with no clear hysteresis effect . it also confirms a compaction in the bulk which can not be caused only by wall effects , which are particularly noticeable with fixed boundaries ( f.b.c . ) . a more local analysis on the void space of the packings shows , in a model of spherical pores , a volume distribution sensitive to the packing fraction for the large pores and nearly stationary for the small ones . compaction could then be principally explained by collective rearrangements of the largest pores . + further to this numerical work , an experimental study of the compaction induced by vertical taps is being carried out . the packing fraction is deduced from a measure of absorption of a horizontal gamma - rays beam . in addition to the average volume fraction in the bulk , our set - up permits the evaluation of the vertical density profile in the packing ; these measurements would be crucial in order to test the results of our numerical model , especially concerning the existence of a negative vertical gradient . furthermore , compaction is studied in quite different experimental conditions than in the previous work of the chicago group . in this later one , the set - up is a tube of height 80 cm and with an approximate diameter of 2 cm filled with 1 mm diameter soda lime glass beads . so , transverse wall effects are very significant and the vertical pressure on the packing is saturated for almost all of the height of the heap , the overload being completely held up by the walls . inversely , the cylinder used in our set - up has a diameter of 10 cm and a height of 15 cm ; about 80 percent of it is filed with 1 mm diameter glass beads . here , the wall effects become negligible and the vertical pressure is definitely not saturated in the packing . it will be interesting to see to which extent these differences can qualitatively and quantitatively affect the compaction under vertical tapping . we are very grateful to r. jullien for his support in numerical questions especially concerning his gravitational deposition algorithm . we also wish to thank p. richard who has constructed the program of size distribution of the pores and j. jenkins who nicely read this manuscript and ran a spelling check of it .

a simple numerical model is used to simulate the effect of vertical taps on a packing of monodisperse hard spheres . our results are in good agreement with an experimental work done in chicago and with other previous models , especially concerning the dynamics of the compaction , the influence of the excitation strength on the compaction efficiency , and some ageing effects . the principal asset of the model is that it allows a local analysis of the packings . vertical and transverse density profiles are used as well as size and volume distributions of the pores . an interesting result concerns the appearance of a vertical gradient in the density profiles during compaction . furthermore , the volume distribution of the pores suggests that the smallest pores , ranging in size between a tetrahedral and an octahedral site , are not strongly affected by the tapping process , in contrast to the largest pores which are more sensitive to the compaction of the packing . 2

astro-ph0502007

the radio - loud gravitational lenses b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 were discovered in the cosmic lens all sky survey @xcite . b1608 + 656 was also discovered independently by @xcite . b1600 + 434 is a two image system separated by 14 with source redshift @xmath9 @xcite . the lens galaxy of b1600 + 434 is an edge - on early - type spiral galaxy at @xmath10 @xcite . b1608 + 656 is a four image system about 21 across with a source redshift at @xmath11 @xcite and a lens redshift at @xmath12 @xcite . the lens of b1608 + 656 consists of two interacting elliptical galaxies within the einstein ring . in addition , _ hst _ observations have detected extended images of the agn host galaxies in both systems @xcite . one of the important applications of gravitational lenses is to constrain the hubble constant @xcite or alternatively , the dark matter distribution in the lens galaxy , through time - delay measurements between the lensed images . the time - delays in both b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 have been measured @xcite . modeling of the two gravitational lenses has been carried out by several studies ( e.g. , koopmans & fassnacht 1999 ; koopmans et al . 2003 ; kochanek 2002 , 2003 ) . in most studies , there are model degeneracy problems in that a number of models can reproduce the limited number of constraints and predict different hubble constant values based on each time delay measurement . therefore , it is important to map the mass distribution close to the lens galaxy with other independent methods to better constrain the lens models . in many lenses , galaxy groups or clusters close to the lenses provide non - negligible contribution to the lens potential @xcite . x - ray observations are particularly important in this respect because they can accurately constrain the positions and masses of the galaxy groups or clusters . in particular , the centroid of the x - ray emission from the intracluster gas provides a more accurate measurement of the cluster s position than optical studies . x - ray clusters or groups have been observed in the lenses rx j0911.4 + 0551 , q0957 + 561 , b1422 + 231 , and pg 1115 + 080 @xcite . the superb angular resolution of _ chandra _ also allows us to resolve the lensed quasar images if they are separated by more than 05 . thus , besides constraining the properties of galaxy groups or clusters , x - ray observations of gravitational lenses can also be used to constrain the sizes of quasar x - ray emission regions @xcite , to measure ultra - short time delays between lensed images @xcite , and to study the interstellar medium of the lens galaxies ( e.g. , dai et al . in addition , the flux magnification provided by gravitational lensing facilitates studies of objects that are intrinsically x - ray faint , such as broad absorption line quasars @xcite and high redshift quasars @xcite . in this paper , we present results from _ chandra _ observations of b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 . we discuss the data acquisition and processing in @xmath132 , the spectral properties of the lensed quasars in @xmath133 , our limits on the presence of x - ray luminous groups or clusters in @xmath134 , and the serendipitous sources in the fields in @xmath135 . we assume cosmology with @xmath14 , @xmath15 , and @xmath16 throughout the paper . we observed b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 with the advanced ccd imaging spectrometer ( acis ; garmire et al . 2003 ) onboard _ chandra _ @xcite for @xmath17 ks and @xmath18 ks on 2003 october 7 , and 2003 september 21 , respectively . the data were taken continuously with no interruptions during each observation , and there were no significant background flares during the observations . both gravitational lenses were placed on the back - illuminated acis - s3 chip , where the aim points of the observations are located , and the data were taken in the timed / vfaint mode . b1600 + 434 was placed near the aim point of the observation ( @xmath198 off - axis ) and b1608 + 656 was placed much further from the aim point about @xmath1975 off - axis . the latter lens was shifted off - axis to ensure a galaxy clump in the _ hst _ images would stay in the field . this configuration was used to maximize the sensitivity for detecting nearby galaxy groups or clusters that might contribute to the lensing and affect estimates of the hubble constant . the data were reduced with the ` ciao 3.1 ` software tools provided by the _ chandra x - ray center _ ( cxc ) . we improved the image quality of the data by removing the pixel randomization applied to the event positions in the cxc processing and by applying a subpixel resolution technique @xcite . in the data analysis , only events with standard _ asca _ grades of 0 , 2 , 3 , 4 , and 6 were used . we first discuss the x - ray properties of the lensed quasars in both lens systems . the imaging and spectral analysis are discussed in @xmath13[sec : img ] and @xmath13[sec : spec ] and the x - ray flux ratios of the lensed images are estimated in @xmath13[sec : fr ] . we analyzed images limited to the 0.28 kev band where we detected a total of 332 and 84 net events for b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 , respectively . the raw and smoothed _ chandra _ images of b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 are shown in figure [ fig : img ] . both of the raw images are binned with a bin size of 015 . the smoothed images are generated by binning the images with a bin size of 01 for both lenses and then were smoothed with gaussians of width @xmath20 02 and @xmath20 03 for b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 , respectively . in b1600 + 434 we detected both lensed images . the measured image separation ( 135@xmath21005 ) is consistent with the separation measured in the cfa - arizona space telescope lens survey ( castles ) _ hst _ observations . the situation is more complicated in b1608 + 656 due to the large number of images with smaller minimum separations , but also because the count rate of the lens is lower . the relatively larger off - axis angle does not degrade the point spread function ( psf ) very much . we simulated the psf using the ` chart ` @xcite and ` marx ` @xcite tools and found the 50% encircled energy contour is of @xmath1905 radius as opposed to @xmath1904 on axis . three out of four lensed images are clearly detected . image b is well separated , but images a and c are merged . we fit the image assuming there are three point images of a , b , and c constraining the relative quasar position to match the castles @xmath22-band relative position and using the above mentioned psf model . however , we are unable to obtain a stable solution . this may be due to the low count - rate of the source or it may indicate that the images are not point sources . we note that there are some x - ray events about 1 northwest to image a and we are unable to determine whether these events belong to image a or from other unidentified sources . the _ hst _ images do not show any source at the corresponding position other than part of the einstein ring image of the host galaxy . image d is not detected by the _ chandra _ observation . the non - detection of image d could be caused by small number statistics additional absorption is not required to mask the image . we extracted spectra for each quasar using the ` ciao ` tool ` psextract ` and fit them using ` xspec v11.3.1 ` @xcite within the 0.48 kev observed energy range . we note that in ` ciao 3.1 ` the recently observed decline in the low energy quantum efficiency of acis , possibly caused by molecular contamination of the acis filters , is already accounted for by the ` psextract ` tool . therefore , we did not perform any other corrections beyond that . we extracted both the combined spectrum of both images within a circle with 5 radius about the centroid of the combined image and individual spectra of images within 07 radius circles about the centroids of images a and b , respectively . we extracted the background spectrum within an annulus with inner and outer radii of 10 and 30 . we fitted the spectra of b1600 + 434 with a series of models summarized in table [ tab : spec ] . we first modeled the spectrum as a power - law modified by galactic absorption . this model gives a reasonable fit with @xmath23 for 18 degrees of freedom ( dof ) . however , the column density obtained for galactic absorption , @xmath24 @xmath25 , is much higher than the expected @xmath26 @xmath25 @xcite . this exercise indicates that additional absorption components are needed to interpret the spectrum . these additional absorption components can be either intrinsic to the quasar , located in the quasar host galaxy , or in the lens galaxy . we found that adding a neutral absorption component at the redshift of either the quasar or the lens can produce an acceptable fit with @xmath27 for 18 dof and @xmath28 for 18 dof , respectively , for absorption at the quasar and lens redshifts . the absorption column densities obtained are @xmath29 @xmath25 and @xmath30 @xmath25 for absorption at the quasar or lens redshift , respectively . the combined spectrum and the best fit model with absorption at the lens redshift are shown in figure [ fig : spec]a . the estimate of the intrinsic photon index is around @xmath31 for both models with observed 0.48 kev band flux of @xmath3210@xmath33 , and lensed , unabsorbed x - ray luminosities in the 210 kev and 120 kev band rest frame of @xmath3410@xmath35 and @xmath410@xmath5 , respectively . we note that the lensing magnification must be included in order to obtain the unlensed luminosity . @xcite interpreted the wavelength dependence of the image flux ratios as due to @xmath8 of differential extinction obscuring image b. we also see in the spectra of the image that image b has proportionally less soft x - ray emission so that differential absorption must be intrinsic to the lens . to estimate this differential absorption we simultaneously fit the individual spectra of images a and b constrained to have the same intrinsic power - law photon index and galactic absorption column density but allowed to have different absorption column densities at the redshift of the lens . the best fit model is shown in figure [ fig : spec]b . this model also results in acceptable fit with a @xmath36 for 12 dof as compared to @xmath37 for 13 dof if we do not allow for differential absorption . the improvement of the fit by allowing for differential absorption is significant at the 90% confidence level according to the f - test indicating that the x - ray data are consistent with , but do not require , column density variations . the photon index obtained in this fit is slightly steeper than for the previous fits in part because the small extraction regions used to obtain individual spectra of the images to the loss of some hard x - ray photons . the absorption column densities at the lens for images a and b are @xmath38 @xmath25 and @xmath39 @xmath25 , respectively , and the differential absorption between the two images is @xmath7 as shown in figure [ fig : con ] . this indicates that the determined from the two spectra are different at the 90% confidence level with higher for image b. this is consistent with the lens configuration , where the lens galaxy is much closer to image b than to image a. comparing with the estimated differential extinction of @xmath8 mag between images a and b @xcite , we obtained a dust - to - gas ratio of @xmath40 within a factor of five from the galactic value , @xmath41 @xcite . we extracted the combined spectrum of all the images of b1608 + 656 within a 5 radius circle centered on the source . we extracted the background spectrum within an annulus with inner and outer radii of 10 and 18 . the background subtracted spectrum consists of only 86 net events with a count - rate of 2.9@xmath4210@xmath43 count s@xmath44 , making a spectral analysis of the individual images impossible . we modeled the spectrum with a power - law modified by galactic absorption . this simple model fits the spectrum quite well , with @xmath45 for 3 dof . the parameters are presented in table [ tab : spec ] and the spectrum and the best fit model are shown in figure [ fig : spec]c . the power - law photon index and galactic are constrained to be @xmath3 and @xmath46 @xmath25 consistent with the expected galactic column density of @xmath47 @xmath25 @xcite . if we fix the galactic absorption to this value the fits are consistent with no additional absorption at either the lens or quasar redshift with upper limits on absorption column of @xmath48 and @xmath49 @xmath25 at the redshift of lens or quasar , respectively . there is differential extinction in b1608 + 656 as well , but it is most significant for image d which we failed to detect . our upper limit on the flux of d is not strong enough to estimate a dust - to - gas ratio . the x - ray flux in the observed 0.48 kev band is @xmath5010@xmath33 , and the lensed , unabsorbed x - ray luminosities in the 2 - 10 kev and 119 kev band rest frame are @xmath5110@xmath35 and @xmath5210@xmath35 , respectively . cccccccc 1 & b1600 + 434 & total & @xmath53 & @xmath54 & & @xmath55 & 16.3(18 ) + 2 & b1600 + 434 & total & @xmath56 & 1.29 ( fixed ) & @xmath57 @xmath58 & @xmath59 & 16.1(18 ) + 3 & b1600 + 434 & total & @xmath56 & 1.29 ( fixed ) & @xmath60 @xmath61 & @xmath62 & 15.8(18 ) + 4 & b1600 + 434 & a & @xmath63 & 1.29 ( fixed ) & @xmath64 @xmath61 & @xmath65 & 13.1(12 ) + & & b & & & @xmath66 @xmath61 & @xmath67 & + 5 & b1608 + 656 & total & @xmath68 & @xmath69 & & @xmath70 & 3.3(3 ) + we estimated the absorption corrected flux ratio between images a and b of b1600 + 434 using ` xspec ` in the 0.48 kev band and obtained a flux ratio of b / a = @xmath71 . we compare this to the time delay corrected flux ratios obtained for the optical and radio bands @xcite in table [ tab : frzero ] . for b1608 + 656 we estimated the flux ratios based on the image count rates because of the low s / n of individual images . in addition , we estimated the count rate of combined images a and c since it is difficult to resolve the two images . the result for b1608 + 656 is listed in table [ tab : freight ] . the flux ratios in x - rays are consistent with the time delay corrected flux ratio in the radio band in b1608 + 656 @xcite . cc x - ray ( 0.48 kev ) & @xmath71 + optical ( i ) & 0.67 + radio ( 8.5 ghz ) & 0.825 + ccc x - ray ( 0.48 kev ) & @xmath72 & @xmath73 + radio ( 8.5 ghz ) & 0.325 & 0.114 + it is important to constrain the mass and central location of any nearby groups or clusters to construct a better lens model . we performed source detection on the two _ chandra _ observations over the full acis fields using the ` ciao ` tool ` wavdetect ` @xcite provided by cxc and did not find significant extended x - ray emission in either field . we also smoothed the image with the ` csmooth ` @xcite software tool to detect any extended sources within 4 of the lens galaxies in the acis - s3 and s2 fields in both observations . we removed the point sources detected by ` wavdetect ` before the smoothing process . however , the smoothed images do not show significant ( above @xmath74 ) extended emission close to the lens galaxies in either field . we also smoothed the soft x - ray band images between ( 0.42 kev ) to increase the signal - to - noise ratio , as the x - ray emission from the cluster or group is expected to be stronger in the soft x - ray band , and did not find significant extended emission above @xmath74 . we note that there are two low significance extended sources ( about @xmath75 ) present close the lenses at r.a . = 16@xmath76 1@xmath77 359 and decl . = 43 17 27 ( j2000 ) with a @xmath78 contour radius of @xmath1911 in the field of b1600 + 434 , and at r.a . = 16@xmath76 9@xmath77 113 and decl . = 65 32 7 ( j2000 ) with a @xmath78 contour radius of @xmath195 in the field of b1608 + 656 . however , these sources have low signal - to - noise ratios and could be simply be background fluctuations . in addition , many events in these peaks have energies below 0.4 kev where the calibration uncertainty is large . a longer observation would be required to have any confidence in their existence , so we proceed on the assumption that they are background fluctuations . we used the background count rates to estimate upper limits on the fluxes of any group / cluster in the two fields . we assumed gas temperature of @xmath191 kev when converting from count rates to flux . this temperature consistent with the upper limits of x - ray luminosities obtained from our analysis . the background count rate in the 0.42 kev band for b1600 + 434 is @xmath79 . in the analysis , we used an aperture size of 100 kpc radius to limit the effects of any systematic errors in the background estimate . this aperture size is large enough for the groups with luminosities below @xmath80 @xcite . for a 100 kpc radius at the redshift of the lens ( @xmath10 ) , the @xmath74 upper limit of the x - ray flux is @xmath81 , which corresponds to an x - ray luminosity of @xmath82 the background flux in the 0.42 kev band for b1608 + 656 is @xmath83 . for a 100 kpc radius at the redshift of the lens ( @xmath12 ) , the @xmath74 upper limit of the x - ray flux is @xmath84 , which corresponds to an x - ray luminosity of @xmath85 we used the standard @xmath86@xmath87 , @xmath88@xmath87 , and @xmath88@xmath86 relations ( e.g. , girardi et al . 1996 ; helsdon & ponman 2000 ; xue & wu 2000 ; mahdavi & geller 2001 ; kochanek et al . 2003 ; osmond & ponman 2004 ) for groups and clusters to estimate upper limits for the velocity dispersion of any cluster of @xmath89 and @xmath90 for b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 respectively . the large scatter of the relations were considered when estimating the upper limits . considering a singular isothermal sphere model for the group or cluster , the lens potential , @xmath91 , from the group / cluster is @xmath92 where @xmath93 and @xmath94 are angular diameter distances from the lens to source and observer to source , and @xmath95 is the angular distance from the lens to the group / cluster . thus , the lens strength , b , is constrained to have upper limits of @xmath9630 and @xmath9732 for b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 respectively . we also cataloged the serendipitous point sources in the two fields using the ` ciao ` tool ` wavdetect ` . the source detection was performed on each ccd separately with a detection threshold of @xmath98 . the detection threshold was set as the inverse of the total number of pixels in the binned images . we detected 75 and 82 serendipitous sources in the b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 fields , respectively . the detection threshold corresponds to a flux limit of roughly @xmath99 and the numbers of sources are consistent with standard estimates for the source numbers at this flux limit ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * and references there in ) . the _ chandra _ field of b1600 + 434 is included in dr3 of the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss , * ? ? ? we searched for optical counterparts of the x - ray sources within a 2 radius , which corresponds to the largest error bars for the _ chandra _ positions , and allows the inclusion of counterparts that have slight offsets between the optical and x - ray centroids , such as the ultra - luminous x - ray sources seen in nearby galaxies . we found counterparts for 27 of the 75 x - ray sources , 13 of which are flagged as quasar candidates in the sdss catalogs . the properties of the serendipitous sources and the optical counterparts are listed in table [ tab : szero ] . b1608 + 656 field is not covered by sdss , and so we used the palomar digital sky survey ( dposs , * ? ? ? * ) survey to identify the counterparts . the lens position in the _ chandra _ and dposs images are offset by approximately 15 , so we used a slightly larger radius to identify optical counterparts . we found 27 optical counterparts out of the 82 x - ray sources . the properties of the serendipitous sources and the optical counterparts in b1608 + 656 field are listed in table [ tab : seight ] . we present results from _ chandra _ observations of the gravitational lenses b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 . we resolved the two lensed images in b1600 + 434 and three of four images in b1608 + 656 . we did not detect the faintest image d in b1608 + 656 . the analysis of b1608 + 656 was complicated by the small minimum image separation and the low count - rate of the lensed image d. we could not find a stable solution for the x - ray flux ratios even if we fixed the image positions to those inferred from _ hst _ observations . a longer observation would be needed to constrain the flux ratios of the individual x - ray images of b1608 + 656 . we also performed a spectral analysis of the lensed quasar images and detected differential absorption column density of @xmath7 between the two images of b1600 + 434 . the improvement of the fit by allowing differential absorption is significant at the 90% confidence level indicating that the x - ray data are consistent with , but do not require , column density variations . comparing with the estimated differential extinction of @xmath8 mag between images a and b @xcite , we obtained a dust - to - gas ratio of @xmath40 within a factor of five from the galactic value . considering the patchiness of the interstellar medium , a factor of five difference may not be significant enough to conclude that the dust - to - gas ratio of the lens galaxy in b1600 + 434 is higher than that of the milky way . however , this trend is consistent with the cases in b0218 + 357 ( @xmath100 ) and pks 1830211 ( @xmath101 , * ? ? ? * ) , where the estimated dust - to - gas ratios in the lens galaxies were higher than the galactic value . it is , however , the opposite of the situation found in q2237 + 0305 ( @xmath102 , * ? ? ? a larger sample is needed to investigate the average dust - to - gas ratios in high redshift ( @xmath103 ) galaxies . there is differential extinction in b1608 + 656 as well , but it is most significant for image d which we failed to detect . our upper limit on the flux of d is not significant enough to estimate a limit on the dust - to - gas ratio . the differential absorption measured between different images in gravitational lenses may serve as a convenient probe to study the gas content in high redshift galaxies since it can separate the absorbing column originated from the lens galaxy and those intrinsic to quasars . we did not detect significant x - ray emission from nearby galaxy groups or clusters associated with the lens galaxies . we found upper limits on the x - ray luminosity of any cluster at the lens redshift and within 4 from the lenses of @xmath0 and @xmath1 for b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 , respectively . considering standard cluster relations between x - ray luminosity , temperature , and velocity dispersion and assuming a singular isothermal sphere model for the group / cluster , we obtained upper limits of the lens strength parameter , @xmath104 , of 30 and 32 for b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 respectively . with such a tight limit , only the poor groups to which each lens belongs could be contributing to the lens potential . cccccccccccc cxo j160022.5 + 431521 & 240.09376 & 43.256002 & 0.7 & 0.5 & 152@xmath21 16 & 13.6 & & & & & + cxo j160041.2 + 431544 & 240.17168 & 43.262303 & 1.0 & 0.8 & 10@xmath21 4 & 2.8 & & & & & + cxo j160044.4 + 430842 & 240.18509 & 43.145258 & 0.6 & 0.2 & 26@xmath21 7 & 4.4 & & & & & + cxo j160045.3 + 431433 & 240.18909 & 43.242736 & 1.1 & 0.8 & 13@xmath21 4 & 3.8 & 240.18867 & 43.242565 & 1.3 & 22.7490 & `` + cxo j160047.0 + 431354 & 240.19615 & 43.231796 & 0.5 & 0.6 & 7@xmath21 3 & 2.4 & & & & & + cxo j160049.2 + 431433 & 240.20518 & 43.242667 & 0.4 & 1.0 & 10@xmath21 4 & 3.3 & & & & & + cxo j160051.2 + 431431 & 240.21355 & 43.242076 & 1.0 & 0.7 & 26@xmath21 6 & 6.3 & & & & & + cxo j160053.8 + 430932 & 240.22429 & 43.159003 & 1.2 & 0.7 & 28@xmath21 7 & 5.3 & & & & & + cxo j160054.8 + 431528 & 240.22854 & 43.258031 & 0.9 & 0.4 & 14@xmath21 4 & 4.6 & 240.22871 & 43.257572 & 1.7 & 15.9220 & `` + cxo j160055.4 + 431052 & 240.23113 & 43.181337 & 0.8 & 0.5 & 6@xmath21 3 & 2.4 & & & & & + cxo j160056.4 + 431151 & 240.23515 & 43.197578 & 1.0 & 0.4 & 9@xmath21 3 & 3.1 & & & & & + cxo j160100.8 + 431055 & 240.25354 & 43.182145 & 0.7 & 0.6 & 11@xmath21 4 & 3.5 & & & & & + cxo j160101.6 + 430108 & 240.25677 & 43.019044 & 2.0 & 0.8 & 12@xmath21 4 & 3.5 & & & & & + cxo j160104.8 + 431115 & 240.27041 & 43.187527 & 0.9 & 0.3 & 8@xmath21 3 & 2.9 & & & & & + cxo j160105.0 + 431850 & 240.27114 & 43.314013 & 0.5 & 0.9 & 4@xmath21 2 & 1.7 & & & & & + cxo j160110.8 + 431139 & 240.29526 & 43.194329 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 299@xmath21 18 & 51.1 & 240.29534 & 43.193954 & 1.4 & 17.1220 & ` target_galaxy ` + cxo j160113.2 + 431803 & 240.30505 & 43.300870 & 0.3 & 0.2 & 8@xmath21 3 & 3.4 & & & & & + cxo j160114.4 + 430717 & 240.31025 & 43.121493 & 0.8 & 0.9 & 9@xmath21 4 & 2.7 & & & & & + cxo j160116.3 + 431740 & 240.31819 & 43.294634 & 0.4 & 0.2 & 11@xmath21 3 & 4.3 & & & & & + cxo j160116.8 + 431834 & 240.32011 & 43.309628 & 0.2 & 0.3 & 14@xmath21 4 & 5.7 & & & & & + cxo j160116.9 + 431949 & 240.32073 & 43.330454 & 0.5 & 0.2 & 10@xmath21 3 & 4.1 & 240.32050 & 43.330372 & 0.7 & 21.8080 & `` + cxo j160117.1 + 432129 & 240.32156 & 43.358059 & 0.4 & 0.2 & 53@xmath21 8 & 14.9 & & & & & + cxo j160120.8 + 431827 & 240.33669 & 43.307585 & 0.1 & 0.1 & 59@xmath21 8 & 22.9 & 240.33658 & 43.307536 & 0.3 & 20.2470 & ` target_qso_faint ` + cxo j160121.0 + 430936 & 240.33777 & 43.160101 & 0.3 & 0.5 & 5@xmath21 2 & 2.1 & & & & & + cxo j160122.8 + 431522 & 240.34521 & 43.256365 & 0.3 & 0.2 & 6@xmath21 2 & 2.7 & & & & & + cxo j160125.6 + 431337 & 240.35703 & 43.227171 & 0.2 & 0.2 & 3@xmath21 2 & 1.5 & & & & & + cxo j160125.9 + 431832 & 240.35828 & 43.308986 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 24@xmath21 5 & 11.4 & 240.35824 & 43.308991 & 0.1 & 21.6330 & `` + cxo j160126.5 + 431704 & 240.36068 & 43.284556 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 8@xmath21 3 & 3.9 & & & & & + cxo j160126.6 + 431313 & 240.36091 & 43.220496 & 0.3 & 0.2 & 11@xmath21 3 & 5.0 & & & & & + cxo j160128.9 + 430519 & 240.37078 & 43.088780 & 1.0 & 0.6 & 11@xmath21 4 & 3.4 & & & & & + cxo j160129.2 + 430748 & 240.37185 & 43.130045 & 0.7 & 0.5 & 17@xmath21 4 & 5.9 & & & & & + cxo j160129.5 + 431940 & 240.37294 & 43.327784 & 0.2 & 0.2 & 7@xmath21 3 & 3.4 & 240.37304 & 43.327680 & 0.5 & 14.1040 & `` + cxo j160129.8 + 431533 & 240.37433 & 43.259386 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 9@xmath21 3 & 4.3 & & & & & + cxo j160130.3 + 431711 & 240.37637 & 43.286424 & 0.0 & 0.2 & 2@xmath21 1 & 1.0 & & & & & + cxo j160131.1 + 431814 & 240.37993 & 43.304018 & 0.2 & 0.2 & 9@xmath21 3 & 4.1 & & & & & + cxo j160132.7 + 431309 & 240.38644 & 43.219338 & 0.1 & 0.2 & 5@xmath21 2 & 2.4 & 240.38645 & 43.219297 & 0.2 & 22.9010 & `` + cxo j160135.3 + 431333 & 240.39740 & 43.226067 & 0.1 & 0.0 & 330@xmath21 18 & 114.4 & 240.39737 & 43.226019 & 0.2 & 20.4010 & ` target_qso_faint ` + cxo j160136.2 + 431353 & 240.40113 & 43.231525 & 0.1 & 0.3 & 4@xmath21 2 & 2.0 & & & & & + cxo j160136.4 + 432107 & 240.40199 & 43.352020 & 0.1 & 0.1 & 71@xmath21 9 & 28.2 & 240.40162 & 43.352124 & 1.0 & 22.3800 & ` target_qso_reject ` + cxo j160137.2 + 431609 & 240.40509 & 43.269321 & 0.1 & 0.0 & 39@xmath21 6 & 18.5 & & & & & + cxo j160137.3 + 432236 & 240.40543 & 43.376842 & 0.2 & 0.2 & 23@xmath21 5 & 8.5 & & & & & + cxo j160138.6 + 432204 & 240.41088 & 43.367895 & 0.4 & 0.3 & 6@xmath21 3 & 2.6 & & & & & + cxo j160141.8 + 431453 & 240.42440 & 43.248288 & 0.4 & 0.1 & 5@xmath21 2 & 2.5 & 240.42461 & 43.248106 & 0.9 & 20.9150 & ` target_qso_faint ` + cxo j160141.9 + 431453 & 240.42459 & 43.248073 & 0.1 & 0.1 & 23@xmath21 5 & 11.8 & 240.42458 & 43.248080 & 0.0 & 20.9290 & ` target_qso_faint ` + cxo j160143.5 + 431858 & 240.43147 & 43.316195 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 7@xmath21 3 & 3.3 & 240.43154 & 43.316113 & 0.4 & 25.7410 & `` + cxo j160143.7 + 431126 & 240.43234 & 43.190683 & 0.3 & 0.4 & 18@xmath21 4 & 7.1 & 240.43238 & 43.190730 & 0.2 & 23.3230 & `` + cxo j160144.6 + 431936 & 240.43594 & 43.326831 & 0.1 & 0.1 & 9@xmath21 3 & 4.4 & & & & & + cxo j160146.4 + 431419 & 240.44346 & 43.238879 & 0.2 & 0.3 & 7@xmath21 3 & 3.5 & & & & & + cxo j160146.8 + 431334 & 240.44529 & 43.226177 & 0.1 & 0.1 & 223@xmath21 15 & 79.9 & 240.44533 & 43.226154 & 0.1 & 21.1140 & `` + cxo j160147.5 + 430907 & 240.44803 & 43.152111 & 0.6 & 0.9 & 12@xmath21 4 & 3.7 & & & & & + cxo j160147.9 + 432006 & 240.44998 & 43.335108 & 0.1 & 0.1 & 19@xmath21 4 & 8.8 & & & & & + cxo j160149.6 + 430836 & 240.45684 & 43.143382 & 0.6 & 0.3 & 24@xmath21 5 & 7.0 & & & & & + cxo j160152.6 + 430915 & 240.46947 & 43.154196 & 0.5 & 0.5 & 49@xmath21 8 & 10.9 & 240.46913 & 43.153922 & 1.3 & 20.5530 & ` target_qso_faint ` + cxo j160153.7 + 431817 & 240.47391 & 43.304920 & 0.0 & 0.0 & 510@xmath21 23 & 173.3 & 240.47392 & 43.304845 & 0.3 & 18.8240 & ` target_qso_faint ` + cxo j160154.5 + 431519 & 240.47735 & 43.255280 & 0.3 & 0.1 & 3@xmath21 2 & 1.5 & 240.47692 & 43.255471 & 1.3 & 20.6500 & ` target_qso_faint ` + cxo j160154.6 + 431147 & 240.47791 & 43.196539 & 0.5 & 0.5 & 6@xmath21 3 & 2.5 & & & & & + cxo j160154.7 + 431019 & 240.47811 & 43.172163 & 0.2 & 0.6 & 3@xmath21 2 & 1.6 & 240.47841 & 43.172037 & 0.9 & 22.8610 & `` + cxo j160156.8 + 431125 & 240.48683 & 43.190556 & 0.2 & 0.2 & 128@xmath21 12 & 32.4 & 240.48681 & 43.190463 & 0.3 & 19.7180 & ` target_qso_faint ` + cxo j160158.0 + 431145 & 240.49198 & 43.195840 & 0.5 & 0.4 & 13@xmath21 4 & 5.3 & & & & & + cxo j160200.1 + 431228 & 240.50070 & 43.207905 & 0.5 & 0.3 & 7@xmath21 3 & 3.3 & & & & & + cxo j160203.4 + 431808 & 240.51433 & 43.302496 & 0.2 & 0.3 & 3@xmath21 2 & 1.5 & & & & & + cxo j160203.9 + 431733 & 240.51654 & 43.292745 & 0.2 & 0.3 & 6@xmath21 2 & 3.0 & & & & & + cxo j160204.2 + 431558 & 240.51789 & 43.266260 & 0.2 & 0.2 & 41@xmath21 6 & 16.8 & 240.51805 & 43.265916 & 1.3 & 20.7600 & `` + cxo j160204.3 + 431556 & 240.51823 & 43.265618 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 26@xmath21 5 & 12.2 & 240.51809 & 43.265900 & 1.1 & 20.9400 & `` + cxo j160208.0 + 431357 & 240.53357 & 43.232582 & 0.4 & 0.3 & 9@xmath21 3 & 4.1 & & & & & + cxo j160209.8 + 431208 & 240.54096 & 43.202248 & 0.5 & 0.5 & 9@xmath21 3 & 3.3 & & & & & + cxo j160210.8 + 430500 & 240.54508 & 43.083499 & 0.7 & 0.6 & 96@xmath21 15 & 7.5 & 240.54492 & 43.083590 & 0.5 & 21.1700 & ` target_qso_faint ` + cxo j160213.0 + 431212 & 240.55434 & 43.203367 & 0.7 & 0.5 & 19@xmath21 5 & 5.4 & 240.55386 & 43.203749 & 1.9 & 21.2800 & ` target_qso_faint ` + cxo j160217.9 + 430659 & 240.57464 & 43.116569 & 0.5 & 0.4 & 62@xmath21 12 & 6.4 & & & & & + cxo j160218.1 + 430928 & 240.57562 & 43.157988 & 0.8 & 0.6 & 62@xmath21 9 & 11.5 & & & & & + cxo j160221.4 + 430800 & 240.58931 & 43.133401 & 0.7 & 0.6 & 58@xmath21 12 & 5.9 & 240.58890 & 43.133187 & 1.3 & 22.0480 & `` + cxo j160221.5 + 431227 & 240.58993 & 43.207556 & 0.8 & 0.6 & 21@xmath21 5 & 5.9 & & & & & + cxo j160221.6 + 430319 & 240.59001 & 43.055445 & 0.3 & 0.2 & 903@xmath21 41 & 30.6 & 240.59003 & 43.054918 & 1.9 & 17.2630 & ` target_galaxy target_qso_cap ` + cxo j160232.1 + 431039 & 240.63379 & 43.177725 & 0.9 & 0.6 & 24@xmath21 7 & 4.0 & & & & & + cxo j160235.5 + 430813 & 240.64792 & 43.136956 & 0.6 & 0.5 & 162@xmath21 20 & 9.9 & 240.64794 & 43.137232 & 1.0 & 20.8500 & ` target_qso_faint ` + ccccccccccc cxo j160713.3 + 652929 & 241.80581 & 65.491391 & 2.0 & 0.9 & 32@xmath21 8 & 4.4 & 241.80481 & 65.491737 & 1.9 & 21.67 + cxo j160719.3 + 652459 & 241.83052 & 65.416517 & 0.9 & 0.4 & 311@xmath21 22 & 22.3 & 241.83031 & 65.416038 & 1.8 & 19.44 + cxo j160727.2 + 653314 & 241.86370 & 65.553915 & 1.9 & 1.0 & 21@xmath21 6 & 4.2 & & & & + cxo j160739.8 + 652040 & 241.91592 & 65.344505 & 2.2 & 1.1 & 20@xmath21 6 & 3.9 & & & & + cxo j160740.4 + 652817 & 241.91870 & 65.471505 & 0.9 & 0.4 & 121@xmath21 12 & 19.8 & 241.91879 & 65.470879 & 2.3 & 21.82 + cxo j160741.5 + 653017 & 241.92300 & 65.504803 & 2.0 & 0.6 & 14@xmath21 5 & 3.6 & & & & + cxo j160747.1 + 652610 & 241.94660 & 65.436200 & 3.1 & 0.8 & 26@xmath21 7 & 5.0 & 241.94743 & 65.435570 & 2.6 & 21.08 + cxo j160803.3 + 652522 & 242.01387 & 65.422904 & 1.5 & 0.3 & 7@xmath21 3 & 2.4 & & & & + cxo j160804.4 + 652540 & 242.01872 & 65.427796 & 2.0 & 0.6 & 14@xmath21 5 & 3.8 & & & & + cxo j160806.5 + 652204 & 242.02720 & 65.367868 & 2.3 & 0.4 & 15@xmath21 5 & 4.2 & & & & + cxo j160807.6 + 652828 & 242.03167 & 65.474558 & 0.4 & 0.2 & 7@xmath21 3 & 2.7 & & & & + cxo j160812.0 + 652054 & 242.05015 & 65.348453 & 1.7 & 0.6 & 12@xmath21 4 & 3.7 & 242.05020 & 65.347809 & 2.3 & + cxo j160813.0 + 652319 & 242.05442 & 65.388855 & 1.8 & 0.6 & 16@xmath21 5 & 4.8 & 242.05438 & 65.389442 & 2.1 & 21.08 + cxo j160816.7 + 652528 & 242.06963 & 65.424496 & 1.3 & 0.7 & 13@xmath21 4 & 4.1 & & & & + cxo j160816.9 + 652453 & 242.07071 & 65.414763 & 1.7 & 0.9 & 10@xmath21 4 & 3.3 & & & & + cxo j160822.0 + 652245 & 242.09175 & 65.379180 & 1.6 & 0.7 & 20@xmath21 5 & 5.2 & & & & + cxo j160823.1 + 652328 & 242.09637 & 65.391192 & 1.2 & 0.4 & 35@xmath21 7 & 8.3 & 242.09776 & 65.390694 & 2.8 & + cxo j160826.7 + 653546 & 242.11160 & 65.596178 & 1.0 & 0.2 & 46@xmath21 8 & 10.5 & 242.11134 & 65.595993 & 0.8 & 21.84 + cxo j160827.3 + 652445 & 242.11378 & 65.412762 & 0.5 & 0.2 & 8@xmath21 3 & 3.4 & & & & + cxo j160831.3 + 652423 & 242.13047 & 65.406416 & 1.2 & 0.7 & 16@xmath21 4 & 5.2 & & & & + cxo j160832.8 + 652255 & 242.13706 & 65.381987 & 1.3 & 0.5 & 11@xmath21 4 & 3.6 & & & & + cxo j160835.1 + 653605 & 242.14658 & 65.601453 & 0.7 & 0.3 & 11@xmath21 4 & 3.9 & & & & + cxo j160835.8 + 653137 & 242.14931 & 65.527038 & 0.7 & 0.2 & 6@xmath21 2 & 2.7 & 242.15018 & 65.527252 & 1.5 & 16.37 + cxo j160836.5 + 652236 & 242.15214 & 65.376812 & 1.2 & 0.7 & 12@xmath21 4 & 3.9 & & & & + cxo j160840.9 + 653523 & 242.17070 & 65.589992 & 0.7 & 0.3 & 9@xmath21 3 & 3.3 & & & & + cxo j160843.8 + 653245 & 242.18292 & 65.546039 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 89@xmath21 10 & 35.4 & 242.18413 & 65.545868 & 1.9 & 19.86 + cxo j160844.1 + 653246 & 242.18413 & 65.546163 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 95@xmath21 10 & 39.3 & 242.18413 & 65.545868 & 1.1 & 19.86 + cxo j160849.1 + 653358 & 242.20462 & 65.566266 & 0.3 & 0.1 & 30@xmath21 6 & 13.4 & & & & + cxo j160850.7 + 653707 & 242.21163 & 65.618791 & 0.8 & 0.4 & 8@xmath21 3 & 3.4 & & & & + cxo j160850.8 + 653220 & 242.21187 & 65.539142 & 0.1 & 0.0 & 617@xmath21 25 & 207.9 & 242.21214 & 65.538887 & 1.0 & 19.78 + cxo j160854.0 + 653338 & 242.22506 & 65.560669 & 0.4 & 0.1 & 12@xmath21 3 & 5.7 & & & & + cxo j160855.0 + 652738 & 242.22933 & 65.460712 & 0.3 & 0.3 & 3@xmath21 2 & 1.5 & & & & + cxo j160858.9 + 652816 & 242.24561 & 65.471199 & 0.6 & 0.2 & 9@xmath21 3 & 4.5 & & & & + cxo j160859.4 + 653225 & 242.24789 & 65.540349 & 0.2 & 0.0 & 69@xmath21 8 & 30.0 & 242.24838 & 65.540154 & 1.0 & 21.07 + cxo j160900.4 + 653445 & 242.25186 & 65.579230 & 0.4 & 0.1 & 19@xmath21 4 & 8.7 & & & & + cxo j160901.6 + 653744 & 242.25685 & 65.629054 & 1.3 & 0.3 & 21@xmath21 5 & 6.5 & & & & + cxo j160902.1 + 653216 & 242.25881 & 65.537796 & 0.7 & 0.1 & 4@xmath21 2 & 1.9 & & & & + cxo j160903.9 + 653040 & 242.26625 & 65.511286 & 0.4 & 0.2 & 8@xmath21 3 & 3.6 & & & & + cxo j160904.8 + 652737 & 242.27018 & 65.460319 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 25@xmath21 5 & 11.8 & & & & + cxo j160905.2 + 653655 & 242.27176 & 65.615366 & 1.0 & 0.2 & 13@xmath21 4 & 4.6 & & & & + cxo j160905.5 + 652400 & 242.27325 & 65.400242 & 1.6 & 0.4 & 6@xmath21 3 & 2.3 & & & & + cxo j160906.1 + 652700 & 242.27560 & 65.450274 & 0.7 & 0.4 & 14@xmath21 4 & 5.7 & & & & + cxo j160907.1 + 653126 & 242.27985 & 65.524103 & 0.3 & 0.0 & 6@xmath21 2 & 2.9 & 242.28047 & 65.523933 & 1.1 & 20.14 + cxo j160907.9 + 652626 & 242.28297 & 65.440657 & 0.5 & 0.3 & 16@xmath21 4 & 7.0 & 242.28284 & 65.440109 & 2.0 & 21.62 + cxo j160909.1 + 652559 & 242.28817 & 65.433131 & 0.8 & 0.3 & 6@xmath21 2 & 2.7 & & & & + cxo j160909.6 + 653252 & 242.29026 & 65.547984 & 0.3 & 0.1 & 17@xmath21 4 & 8.1 & & & & + cxo j160911.0 + 653008 & 242.29611 & 65.502295 & 0.4 & 0.1 & 5@xmath21 2 & 2.4 & & & & + cxo j160913.0 + 653432 & 242.30456 & 65.575761 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 92@xmath21 10 & 38.9 & 242.30478 & 65.575493 & 1.0 & + cxo j160913.1 + 652457 & 242.30483 & 65.415846 & 1.3 & 0.3 & 5@xmath21 2 & 2.3 & & & & + cxo j160913.1 + 653020 & 242.30487 & 65.505795 & 0.3 & 0.2 & 6@xmath21 2 & 2.8 & & & & + cxo j160913.4 + 652827 & 242.30590 & 65.474394 & 0.1 & 0.1 & 82@xmath21 9 & 36.7 & 242.30664 & 65.474052 & 1.7 & 20.42 + cxo j160914.1 + 653700 & 242.30883 & 65.616860 & 0.7 & 0.3 & 18@xmath21 5 & 6.5 & & & & + cxo j160914.4 + 653206 & 242.31012 & 65.535131 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 39@xmath21 6 & 17.8 & 242.31021 & 65.534958 & 0.6 & + cxo j160916.8 + 652852 & 242.32012 & 65.481128 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 8@xmath21 3 & 4.1 & & & & + cxo j160917.4 + 653021 & 242.32254 & 65.506092 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 29@xmath21 5 & 13.9 & & & & + cxo j160917.4 + 652925 & 242.32268 & 65.490353 & 0.0 & 0.0 & 2@xmath21 1 & 1.0 & & & & + cxo j160917.7 + 653104 & 242.32390 & 65.517999 & 0.3 & 0.1 & 7@xmath21 3 & 3.4 & & & & + cxo j160919.6 + 652915 & 242.33176 & 65.487717 & 0.5 & 0.1 & 7@xmath21 3 & 3.5 & 242.33199 & 65.487556 & 0.7 & 18.87 + cxo j160919.9 + 653552 & 242.33310 & 65.597953 & 0.4 & 0.1 & 29@xmath21 6 & 11.2 & & & & + cxo j160921.4 + 652243 & 242.33930 & 65.378676 & 1.4 & 0.6 & 11@xmath21 4 & 3.4 & 242.34024 & 65.378616 & 1.4 & 17.14 + cxo j160925.2 + 653421 & 242.35506 & 65.572583 & 0.1 & 0.1 & 36@xmath21 6 & 17.0 & & & & + cxo j160926.6 + 653844 & 242.36086 & 65.645732 & 0.6 & 0.2 & 180@xmath21 14 & 32.6 & 242.36060 & 65.645737 & 0.4 & 20.59 + cxo j160927.2 + 653247 & 242.36361 & 65.546655 & 0.3 & 0.1 & 5@xmath21 2 & 2.4 & 242.36388 & 65.546600 & 0.4 & 21.39 + cxo j160930.8 + 652810 & 242.37839 & 65.469570 & 0.3 & 0.0 & 4@xmath21 2 & 2.1 & & & & + cxo j160936.4 + 652906 & 242.40200 & 65.485094 & 0.3 & 0.1 & 6@xmath21 2 & 3.0 & & & & + cxo j160938.3 + 653447 & 242.40970 & 65.579868 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 79@xmath21 9 & 30.2 & 242.40987 & 65.579842 & 0.3 & 20.33 + cxo j160939.7 + 653235 & 242.41543 & 65.543118 & 0.1 & 0.1 & 105@xmath21 10 & 44.3 & 242.41559 & 65.542908 & 0.8 & 20.73 + cxo j160940.1 + 653313 & 242.41720 & 65.553738 & 0.3 & 0.0 & 4@xmath21 2 & 1.9 & & & & + cxo j160941.5 + 652813 & 242.42317 & 65.470465 & 0.4 & 0.3 & 7@xmath21 3 & 3.3 & & & & + cxo j160943.6 + 653317 & 242.43203 & 65.554966 & 0.4 & 0.2 & 16@xmath21 4 & 7.6 & 242.43243 & 65.554749 & 1.0 & + cxo j160943.8 + 652700 & 242.43287 & 65.450271 & 0.8 & 0.0 & 2@xmath21 1 & 1.0 & & & & + cxo j160948.2 + 653330 & 242.45110 & 65.558338 & 0.6 & 0.1 & 6@xmath21 2 & 2.7 & & & & + cxo j160950.9 + 652922 & 242.46227 & 65.489607 & 0.3 & 0.0 & 4@xmath21 2 & 2.0 & & & & + cxo j160953.0 + 653155 & 242.47116 & 65.531966 & 0.4 & 0.2 & 4@xmath21 2 & 1.8 & & & & + cxo j160956.5 + 652824 & 242.48574 & 65.473340 & 0.9 & 0.1 & 7@xmath21 3 & 3.1 & & & & + cxo j160957.6 + 652129 & 242.49040 & 65.358242 & 0.6 & 0.2 & 18@xmath21 7 & 2.8 & & & & + cxo j161001.4 + 652845 & 242.50600 & 65.479256 & 0.4 & 0.2 & 71@xmath21 9 & 24.3 & 242.50522 & 65.479378 & 1.3 & 18.89 + cxo j161004.8 + 652454 & 242.52003 & 65.415231 & 0.6 & 0.9 & 3@xmath21 2 & 1.5 & & & & + cxo j161010.8 + 652719 & 242.54515 & 65.455479 & 0.4 & 0.0 & 5@xmath21 2 & 2.1 & & & & + cxo j161016.6 + 652354 & 242.56936 & 65.398384 & 1.6 & 0.8 & 8@xmath21 3 & 2.7 & & & & + cxo j161029.9 + 652405 & 242.62477 & 65.401536 & 0.9 & 0.5 & 142@xmath21 14 & 17.7 & 242.62561 & 65.401230 & 1.7 & 20.03 + cxo j161052.3 + 651833 & 242.71824 & 65.309300 & 1.2 & 0.8 & 83@xmath21 14 & 7.5 & & & & + chartas , g. , dai , x. , & garmire , g. p. 2004 , in measuring and modeling the universe , edited by w. l. freedman ( pasadena : carnegie obs . ) , http://www.ociw.edu/ociw/symposia/series/symposium2/proceedings.html jackson , n. , de bruyn , a. g. , myers , s. , bremer , m. n. , miley , g. k. , schilizzi , r. t. , browne , i. w. a. , nair , s. , wilkinson , p. n. , blandford , r. d. , pearson , t. j. , & readhead , a. c. s. 1995 , , 274 , l25 kochanek , c. s. , falco , e. e. , impey , c. d. , lehr , j. , mcleod , b. a. , & rix , h .- w . 1999 , in aip conf . 470 , after the dark ages : when galaxies were young ( the universe at @xmath105 ) , ed . s. holt & e. smith ( new york : aip ) , 163 mori , k. , tsunemi , h. , miyata , e. , baluta , c. , burrows , d. n. , garmire , g. p. , & chartas , g. 2001 , in asp conf . 251 , new century of x - ray astronomy , ed . h. inoue & h. kunieda ( san francisco : asp ) , 576 myers , s. t. , fassnacht , c. d. , djorgovski , s. g. , blandford , r. d. , matthews , k. , neugebauer , g. , pearson , t. j. , readhead , a. c. s. , smith , j. d. , thompson , d. j. , womble , d. s. , browne , i. w. a. , wilkinson , p. n. , nair , s. , jackson , n. , snellen , i. a. g. , miley , g. k. , de bruyn , a. g. , & schilizzi , r. t. 1995 , , 447 , l5

we observed b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 with cxo / acis , detecting both quasar images in b1600 + 434 and three of four images in b1608 + 656 . we did not detect significant x - ray emission from nearby galaxy groups or clusters associated with each lens galaxy . the upper limits on the x - ray luminosity of any cluster within 4 of each lens and at each lens redshift are of @xmath0 and @xmath1 for b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 , respectively . the radio - loud source quasars have power - law photon indices of @xmath2 and @xmath3 and x - ray luminosities of @xmath410@xmath5 and @xmath6 for b1600 + 434 and b1608 + 656 , respectively before correcting for the magnification . we detected a differential absorption column density of @xmath7 between the two images of b1600 + 434 , roughly consistent with expectations from differential extinction estimates of @xmath8 mag and a standard dust - to - gas ratio . the differential absorption observed in gravitational lenses may serve as an important probe to study the gas content in high redshift galaxies since it can separate the absorbing column originating from the lens galaxy and those intrinsic to quasars . we also detected 157 serendipitous x - ray sources in the two _ chandra _ fields and identified the brighter optical counterparts using the sdss and dposs surveys .

cond-mat0606140

recently we have shown that spontaneous symmetry breaking imposes a fundamental limit for the time that a large spin system can stay quantum coherent . this universal time - scale is @xmath0 , given in terms of the number of microscopic degrees of freedom @xmath1 , temperature @xmath2 , and the constants of planck ( @xmath3 ) and boltzmann ( @xmath4 ) @xcite . we analyzed this quantum decoherence process in terms of the exactly solvable lieb - mattis spin model , which is known to describe a symmetry broken macroscopic antiferromagnet in equilibrium . within this spin model we investigated the dynamical reduction of quantum physics to classical behavior via spontaneous symmetry breaking . the goal of this paper is to present a self - contained , detailed description and explanation of the decoherence process caused by spontaneous symmetry breaking . the fact that spontaneous symmetry breaking can lead to decoherence on a time scale @xmath5 might come as a surprise . for a macroscopic body at room temperature , @xmath6 is of order @xmath7 seconds , which is quite a short time . however , multiplying with avogadro s number @xmath8 , yields @xmath9 seconds , corresponding to a couple of centuries . given all other sources of decoherence for such a large macroscopic body , this is surely not a relevant timescale . however , the mesoscopic quantum qubits of contemporary interest are typically much smaller and the intrinsic coherence time might be reached in the near future . the counterintuitive feature of this intrinsic decoherence mechanism linked to classical equilibrium is that it starts to matter when systems become small . the many - particle qubits that motivate us to study decoherence due to spontaneous symmetry breaking are realized in a number of mesoscopic solid state systems . for instance , by engineering aluminum on a sub - micron length scale , superconducting flux qubits and cooper pair boxes can be manufactured . the flux qubit is a josephson device that can be brought into a quantum superposition of two electrical currents : a left and a right circulating current @xcite . typically this current is carried by @xmath10 cooper pairs . a cooper pair box on the other hand is a superconducting island , containing @xmath11 electrons , which can be brought in superposition of two states with a different number of cooper pairs @xcite . magnetic many - particle qubits are for instance realized in molecular nanomagnets . molecules with large magnetic moments can be brought into a superposition of directions of magnetization . a well studied example is mn@xmath12 acetate , a molecule that contains 12 manganese atoms , coupled together to form a total spin of @xmath13 . the molecule can be brought into a superposition of states with @xmath14 and @xmath15 and coherent rabi - oscillations of the magnetization are observed @xcite . an even larger molecule is ferritin , that contains about 4500 fe@xmath16 ions @xcite . if the total magnetic moment of a ferritin molecule is brought into a coherent superposition , this corresponds to a superposition of @xmath17 spins . for these mesoscopic superconducting and magnetic qubits the limit in coherence due to spontaneous symmetry breaking is relevant . this paper is organized as follows . we first introduce the general notion of spontaneous symmetry breaking and the thin spectrum . we illustrate these concepts by the elementary example of a harmonic crystal that breaks translational symmetry . we then show how the presence of a thin spectrum can cause decoherence . again we clarify the concept by describing a theoretical setup in which we use the crystal as a qubit . after that we switch to the more involved example of the ( non - abelian ) antiferromagnet . we first recapitulate the properties of the lieb - mattis model @xcite and determine its symmetric and symmetry - broken eigenstates . subsequently we will use the model to determine the effect of spontaneous symmetry breaking on quantum coherence . for this purpose we devise a generic gedanken experiment by coupling a two spin singlet state to the macroscopic lieb - mattis antiferromagnet . we calculate the exact time evolution of this many - body quantum superposition . our main result on decoherence follows from the evaluation of the reduced density matrix of the superposition by tracing out the thin states . finally we will then discuss what it reveals regarding spontaneous symmetry breaking in more general heisenberg - like spin hamiltonians . due to the homogeneity of space , the laws of nature possess translational invariance . this invariance implies the classical law of conservation of momentum . likewise , space being isotropic enforces rotational symmetry on the laws of physics , implying conservation of angular momentum . in quantum mechanics the power of symmetry is even greater : the translational and rotational invariance of the laws of nature taken at face value , should imply that any physical quantum object that obeys these laws , has translational and rotational symmetry . however , daily experience shows that this conclusion is nonsensical . if the universe around us and everything in it would be translationally and rotationally invariant , it would look the same at all places and in all directions : we would be surrounded by a `` quantum mist '' , while human observers should be dissolved in this quantum fog as well . however , in the real world translational and rotational symmetry are manifestly broken . the fundamental difference between quantum and classical physics lies in the role of symmetry . dealing with an exact quantum mechanical eigenstate , all configurations equivalent by symmetry should have exactly the same status in principle , while in a classical state one of them can be singled out . in the example above , given that space is translationally invariant , a quantum object should be in an eigenstate of total momentum , being spread out with equal probability over all of space . in the classical limit however it takes a definite position . the explanation of this ` spontaneous symmetry breaking ' as a ramification of the singular nature of the thermodynamic limit is one of the central achievements of quantum condensed matter physics @xcite . one imagines a symmetry breaking ` order parameter field ' @xmath18 ( e.g. , a potential singling out a specific position in space ) . upon sending @xmath18 to zero before taking the thermodynamic limit ( @xmath19 ) one finds the exact quantum groundstate respecting the symmetry . however , taking the opposite order of limits one finds that the classical state becomes fact . although the concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking was originally introduced in the context of quantum magnetism in solid state physics @xcite , spontaneous symmetry breaking is a general phenomenon , that is just as relevant in other fields , including elementary particle physics and cosmology @xcite . let us first consider how spontaneous symmetry breaking arises in a crystalline lattice to continue in the next section with antiferromagnets . consider the textbook example of a harmonic crystal , with the hamiltonian @xmath20 where @xmath21 labels all @xmath1 atoms in the lattice , which have mass @xmath22 , momentum @xmath23 and position @xmath24 . the harmonic potential between neighboring atoms is parameterized by @xmath25 ; it turns out that the results on spontaneous symmetry breaking that follow are equally valid for an - harmonic potentials . let us first identify the collective dynamics which describe the spontaneous symmetry breaking of this short - ranged microscopic hamiltonian . in the standard treatment of the quantum crystal one begins by introducing new coordinates , which are the displacements of atoms from their equilibrium position . then , after a fourier transform the eigenstates of this hamiltonian are easily found . we take a slightly longer route by introducing bosonic phonon operators from the very beginning and diagonalizing the quadratic part of the hamiltonian by performing a bogoliubov transformation at the end . in doing so we do not have to introduce any equilibrium position of the atoms . instead we can keep track of the center of mass motion of the crystal as a whole , and this brings to the fore the thin spectrum in a natural manner . moreover we can use the exact same procedure in the next section to find the collective order parameter dynamics for antiferromagnets . the momentum and position operators are expressed in terms of bosonic operators as @xmath26 so that the commutation relation @xmath27 = i \hbar \delta_{j , j'}$ ] is fulfilled . we choose @xmath28 so that the hamiltonian reduces to @xmath29 and after a fourier transformation @xmath30 , \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 is the lattice constant . this hamiltonian is still not diagonal , since the terms @xmath34 and @xmath35 create and annihilate two bosons at the same time . we get rid of these terms by a bogoliubov transformation ( see appendix ) . after this the hamiltonian in terms of transformed boson operators @xmath36 is @xmath37\nonumber \\ & = & 2 \hbar { \sqrt \frac{\kappa}{m } } \sum_k \sin |ka/2| \left [ n_k + \frac{1}{2 } \right ] , \label{eq : hbeta}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath38 . this result seems to coincide with the textbook hamiltonian which we would have obtained if we had followed the conventional route of fourier transforming the hamiltonian for the displacements , and then quantizing it . however , the bogoliubov transformation has the advantage that it brings to the fore a rather subtle point . when @xmath39 the excitation energy @xmath40 and the two parameters in the bogoliubov transformation diverge : @xmath41 and @xmath42 . precisely at @xmath43 the canonical transformation is no longer well defined . we therefore should investigate the bosonic terms in the hamiltonian with @xmath43 separately . this zero momentum part of the hamiltonian describes the obvious fact that the crystal as a whole carries a kinetic energy associated with the combined mass of all of its constituents , and is given by @xmath44\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath45 so that @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the total momentum of the entire system , or equivalently , its center of mass momentum . when @xmath1 is large , this hamiltonian has states that are very low in energy . these states in fact form the thin spectrum of the harmonic crystal . we call this part of the spectrum _ thin _ because it contains so few states of such low energy that its contribution to the free energy in the thermodynamic limit completely disappears ( see appendix ) . in turn , this implies that these thin spectrum states do not contribute to any thermodynamically measurable quantities such as for instance the specific heat of the crystal . their effect on the properties of the crystal is thus increasingly subtle , but its existence can nonetheless have profound consequences . in classical systems this thin spectrum is absent : it is quantum mechanics that generates it . about a decade ago the deep meaning of the thin spectrum for interacting quantum systems became clear and consequently its explicit mathematical structure was determined @xcite . the groundstate of the hamiltonian at @xmath48 , which governs the collective behavior of the crystal as a whole , obviously has total momentum zero . it thus has no uncertainty in total momentum and maximum uncertainty in total position : translational symmetry is unbroken . symmetry breaking can occur if we add to the hamiltonian of equation a symmetry breaking field of the form @xmath49 , where the center of mass coordinate is @xmath50 . this yields a harmonic oscillator equation for the collective position coordinate . its well known groundstate wavefunction is @xmath51 this state describes a wave - packet for the center of mass coordinate in real space , which of course corresponds to an equivalent superposition of total momentum states : the symmetry breaking field @xmath18 couples the different thin spectrum states of the crystal . for a vanishing symmetry breaking field @xmath18 and finite number of atoms we have @xmath52 and the collective coordinate is completely delocalized , as before : @xmath53 . but taking the thermodynamic limit ( @xmath54 ) _ in presence of a finite symmetry breaking field _ gives @xmath55 and the center of mass position becomes completely localized in the center of the potential well ( @xmath56 ) , even if at the end the symmetry breaking field is sent to zero . as we already pointed out , such a singular limit characterizes spontaneous symmetry breaking ; in this particular case the translational symmetry of the crystal as a whole is spontaneously broken . the occurrence of a thin spectrum which consists of the states associated with the quantum mechanics of the macroscopic body as a whole is a universal notion . whenever a system exhibits a continuous symmetry which is broken in the classically realized , macroscopic state , then consequently there must be a spectrum of states associated with the symmetry - restoring fluctuations of the orderparameter as a whole . the universality of this notion is guaranteed by the goldstone protection which holds for the low energy excitations at @xmath39 in any system with a broken continuous symmetry . the smallness of the energy spacing within the thin spectrum warrants the orderparameter dynamics of macroscopic bodies to take place on a time scale much larger than anything observable . to study the effect of the thin spectrum on the coherence of many particle qubits , let us first investigate the dynamics of such a qubit in the most general terms . consider a many particle system that is large enough to display a spontaneously broken continuous symmetry , but small enough to be used as a qubit . this qubit will then have a thin spectrum which we can label by the quantum number @xmath57 . at the same time the system must have two accessible quantum states that can be used as the qubit states , and which can be labeled by the quantum number @xmath22 . because we have no experimental control over the thin spectrum states , we will have to start out the experiment with a thermal mixture of those states : @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the density matrix , @xmath60 is the energy of the state @xmath61 and where , by definition , the partition function is @xmath62 and @xmath63 . to begin using this qubit in a quantum computation we will typically have to prepare it in some coherent superposition of the states in the two level system . to do this we apply a rotation that takes the state @xmath64 into the state @xmath65 for all values of @xmath57 . the resulting density matrix then is given by @xmath66 if we know the hamiltonian @xmath67 which governs the dynamics of the qubit , then we can follow the time evolution of this density operator by applying the time evolution operator @xmath68 . we then find for the density matrix at @xmath69 @xmath70 \right ) , \label{eq : one}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath71 denotes the hermitian conjugate of its preceding term . experimentally the thin spectrum is as good as unobservable because of its extremely low energy and its vanishing thermodynamic weight ( see appendix ) . we therefore have to trace these states out of the density matrix . this will yield a reduced ( observable ) density matrix , defined by @xmath72 where the trace is over thin spectrum states labeled by @xmath21 and @xmath73 . performing the trace , we find the following reduced density matrix in the basis of the states @xmath74 @xmath75^{\rm * } & 1 \end{array } \right ] , \label{eq : three}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the off - diagonal matrix element is defined as @xmath76 if this off - diagonal matrix element vanishes at some time , then the qubit will have decohered at that time , due to the presence of the thin spectrum . in general @xmath77 will not be zero , and this shift in energy corresponds to a phase shift of the thin spectrum states . these phases will typically interfere destructively , lowering @xmath78 and leading to dephasing and decoherence . the timescale for this decoherence process is set by the inverse of the involved energy scale , and will therefore be proportional to @xmath79 . for this dephasing to occur however , it is necessary that a finite number of thin spectrum states participates in the dynamics of decoherence . how many states do contribute to the process is governed by the boltzmann factor @xmath80 , which exponentially suppresses states of energy higher than @xmath81 with @xmath82 the typical level spacing of the thin spectrum states . putting these arguments together , one finds that the characteristic timescale on which @xmath78 will vanish should be proportional to @xmath83 in the following sections we will calculate @xmath5 explicitly for a number of realizations of the many particle qubit . we will see that in the generic situation @xmath84 so that we find @xmath85 which is our main result . as a first example of the influence of the thin spectrum on coherence , let us try to employ the harmonic crystal discussed in the introduction as a qubit . in order to do so we will have to define a set of two states that are to be used as the calculational states of the qubit . a simple choice for such a set could be to use the presence or absence of an interstitial excitation . this leads to the definition of the state @xmath86 describing the crystal with @xmath1 atoms , and the state @xmath87 which has one extra interstitial atom , and is described by the same model , but with @xmath88 atoms in the lattice . the thin spectrum is exactly as described in , so that the energy can be defined as @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the mass of an atom , @xmath57 labels states with different total momentum ( which make up the thin spectrum ) , and @xmath91 is the chemical potential associated with adding an extra atom to the lattice . we are now in the position to simply substitute this information into the general expression for the off - diagonal matrix element of the reduced density matrix , yielding @xmath92 the constant phase factor @xmath93 does not contribute to the decoherence process , but the terms depending on @xmath57 introduce phase shifts into the dynamics of the system , which lead to the disappearance of @xmath78 over time . upon introduction of @xmath94 and @xmath95 , a straightforward evaluation of the sum over thin spectrum states yields @xmath5 , defined as the half time for @xmath96 @xmath97 by using the crystal as a qubit in this way we have assumed that we can just ignore the symmetry breaking field as soon as the crystal has been localized in space at some time in the past . in general this may not be true , because the thermodynamic limit and the limit of disappearing localization field do not commute . we should therefore also consider the situation in the presence of a small but finite symmetry breaking field @xmath18 . in that case the energies of the system will be given by @xmath98 which will again lead to a phase factor which is constant in @xmath57 , and a sum over phases which can be written as multiples of @xmath99 and @xmath100 . the summation over thin spectrum states will thus again yield the coherence time @xmath101 the interstitial excitation used in the previous section to characterize the qubit state of the harmonic crystal is a very rough excitation to use for that purpose . the extra atom in the crystal will immediately affect the whole lattice structure , and thus couple to many phonon - excitations . on top of that it also automatically increases the mass of the crystal as a whole , and thereby influences the thin spectrum directly . because of this direct alteration of the crystal properties , serious decoherence effects are to be expected . in constructing a qubit using the quantum crystal it is therefore better to look for a more silent excitation . these silent excitations are naturally found in the long wavelength goldstone modes of the crystal , i.e. the low energy phonons . to see what is the effect on the thin spectrum of having phonons present , let s consider the general anharmonic term @xmath102 which supplements the hamiltonian , and introduces phonon - phonon interactions in its dynamics . the fourier transform of @xmath103 is @xmath104^z\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath33 the lattice constant . from this expression it is immediately clear that for all values of @xmath105 the @xmath48 part of @xmath103 will vanish . this is of course just a manifestation of the goldstone protection of the long wavelength phonon modes , but it implies that the presence of phonons can not alter the form of the thin spectrum part of the hamiltonian given by . the addition of a symmetry breaking field will not modify that conclusion , because the energies of the collective model in presence of a localization field only depend on the total mass of the crystal and the size of the symmetry breaking field . the phonons do not influence the mass of the quantum crystal , and thus we find that @xmath106 both for zero and finite symmetry breaking field @xmath18 . because the phonons do not influence the thin spectrum at all , there will also be no induced decoherence of a superposition of different phonon states by the thin spectrum . in this case thus @xmath107 of course the superposition of phonon states will be influenced by all the other sources of decoherence that are present in the crystal , but it is protected from the decohering effects of the thin spectrum by the fact that phonons do not influence the properties of the crystal as a whole . the fact that the goldstone modes of the crystal supply an excitation that is protected from all decohering effects of the thin spectrum is due to the fact that we only considered translation symmetry breaking of the crystal _ as a whole_. within it , there is still translation invariance of the atoms . this pathology that is due to the periodic boundary conditations that we implicitely assumed . a coupling between the thin spectrum and the goldstone modes can appear as soon as this internal symmetry is broken as well which is the generic situation . in fact we will show in the next section that even in the most silent non - abelian model that one can think of , i.e. the antiferromagnetic lieb - mattis model , this pathology will disappear . let us now turn to the discussion of the antiferromagnetic lieb - mattis model . the reason for considering the rather particular , long ranged lieb - mattis model is that for a broad class of heisenberg models with short - ranged interactions it constitutes the effective hamiltonian for the thin states . similar collective models underly the breaking of other continuous symmetries , such as for instance gauge symmetry in a superconductor . in that case the collective hamiltonian turns out to be very similar to the lieb - mattis hamiltonian as far as the structure of the thin spectrum and the composition of the wavefunction of the symmetry broken state are concerned . to explicitly show how the lieb - mattis model is arises from a heisenberg model , let us consider an antiferromagnet on a bipartite lattice with isotropic nearest neighbor interactions between quantum spins of size @xmath108 . its hamiltonian is @xmath109 where @xmath110 labels all the spins on the @xmath111 sublattice , and the @xmath112 are the vectors connecting site @xmath110 to its neighbors on sublattice b. the generalization to other types of interactions and even other types of lattices is straightforward @xcite . the magnon spectrum of this hamiltonian can be found within linear spin wave theory . one approximates the spin operators with holstein - primakoff bosons as @xmath113 to quadratic order in the boson operators the hamiltonian becomes , after a fourier transformation @xmath114 where @xmath105 is the coordination number of the lattice , @xmath1 the number of lattice sites and @xmath115 . the last two terms in this expression can be diagonalized by a bogoliubov transformation ( see appendix ) . again the important point is that the bogoliubov transformation is singular at @xmath116 and @xmath117 , as in both cases @xmath118 . we therefore treat these two @xmath119-points separately . turning back to the notation in terms of spins , using that the fourier transform of our hamiltonian is @xmath120 and @xmath121 we find that the singular parts of the spectrum reduce exactly to the lieb - mattis hamiltonian @xmath122 where @xmath123 and @xmath124 are the total spins of each sublattice , and @xmath125 is the _ total _ spin of the system . from here on we will focus entirely on this collective hamiltonian , as it is the only part of the heisenberg - like hamiltonians that is relevant for the spontaneous symmetry breaking of the antiferromagnet as a whole . notice that the _ internal _ ordering of the individual spins within the antiferromagnet can be destroyed by fluctuations of finite wavelength that we do not consider in this collective , long ranged model . we assign to the hamiltonian @xmath126 the superscript @xmath127 because this hamiltonian , as we will show below , describes the symmetric ( symmetry unbroken ) state of the antiferromagnet . in @xmath126 each spin on the @xmath111 sublattice interacts with all spins on the @xmath18 sublattice and vice versa , thus creating infinite range interactions . the energies of the hamiltonian are trivially identified as @xmath128 $ ] and the corresponding eigenfunctions are labeled by their quantum numbers @xmath129 . here the @xmath105-component of the total spin @xmath125 is denoted by @xmath90 . clearly the ground state of @xmath126 is a singlet of total spin : the state with lowest energy has @xmath130 . in fact there is an exact proof that the groundstate of any finite spin system of this sort is a total spin zero ( @xmath130 ) singlet @xcite . notice that all states which differ only in @xmath90 are degenerate . for simplicity ( and without loss of generality ) we henceforth take the quantum number @xmath90 to be zero @xcite . the groundstate singlet @xmath131 , with both @xmath132 and @xmath133 maximal and @xmath134 is separated by energies of order @xmath135 from states with higher @xmath136 . the set of these extremely low energy states that only differ in their total spin quantum number forms the thin spectrum @xcite . since is contained in as its @xmath137 and @xmath138 components , and since the thin spectrum of the lieb - mattis model is formed by the @xmath139 component , exactly the same thin spectrum must govern the collective dynamics of other antiferromagnets with short - range interactions @xcite . there are also excitations in that can be created by lowering @xmath132 or @xmath133 . this costs an energy of order @xmath140 , and it can easily be shown that these excitations correspond to the elementary excitations , the magnons , of the lieb - mattis system @xcite . because of the extremely long ranged interactions the magnons are gapped and dispersionless . having defined the lieb - mattis model in its symmetric form , we now review how to explicitly break its non - abelian su(2 ) spin rotation symmetry . we will show that in the thermodynamic limit the symmetry breaking occurs spontaneously @xcite . since the groundstate of @xmath126 is a singlet of total spin , this state is orthogonal to the nel state , which is the ground state of a classical antiferromagnet . we should stress here that there is a marked difference between ferro- and antiferromagnets . even if spontaneous symmetry breaking is very often discussed with the example of a ferromagnet at hand , the spontaneous symmetry breaking in a ferromagnet is not the generic situation for an interacting quantum system . the reason is that the total magnetization ( pointing along , e.g. , the z - axis ) , which is the order parameter of a ferromagnet , commutes with the hamiltonian : it is nothing but the projection of the total spin along that axis , @xmath141 . so the situation arises that the orderparameter is a constant of motion , which is a pathology of the ferromagnet . this same pathology leads to the absence of an interesting thin spectrum , because in the ferromagnet states with different @xmath141 are strictly degenerate . quantum systems in general , however , have non - trivial thin spectra . refocusing on antiferromagnets , we need to proof that the nel state is a stable groundstate in the thermodynamic limit . in order to do so , an explicit symmetry breaking field @xmath18 is introduced @xcite : @xmath142 clearly the symmetry breaking field induces a finite sublattice magnetization . the field couples the different total spin states of the thin spectrum by the matrix elements these matrix elements are found by performing a rather tedious sum over clebsch gordon coefficients in the following expression ( see also the appendix ) : @xmath145 \nonumber \\ & & \ \ \ \ \ \ \delta_{s_a,{s'}_a } \delta_{s_b,{s'}_b } \delta_{m,{m'}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the spectrum of eigenstates @xmath146 in the presence of a symmetry breaking field can now be found by expanding these states in the basis of total spin states : @xmath147 ( for clarity of notation we suppress the dependency of @xmath148 and other variables on the quantum numbers @xmath132 , @xmath133 and @xmath90 ) . in this basis , schrdinger s equation becomes @xcite @xmath149 |s \rangle = e^{n}_{0 } \sum_{s } u^n_s ~|s\rangle , \label{eq : se}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath150 is the groundstate energy of @xmath126 and @xmath151 is the energy of eigenstate @xmath146 of the _ symmetry broken _ hamiltonian its thin spectrum . here we restricted ourselves to the zero - magnon subspace , where @xmath152 ( hence the subscript @xmath153 in @xmath151 ) . the generalization to systems with a finite number of magnons will be straightforward . in the continuum limit where @xmath1 is large and @xmath154 , the matrix elements due to the symmetry breaking field simplify considerably . it is easy to show that in this case @xmath155 we will see shortly that only the first @xmath156 total spin states contribute to the groundstate wavefunction , so that an expansion in @xmath157 is justified . notice that when the sublattice spin @xmath132 is reduced by one , i.e. when there is a spin - wave present , the matrix element @xmath158 is reduced : @xmath159 , for large @xmath1 . this reflects the fact that a magnon reduces the nel order parameter ( the staggered magnetization ) by unity . this effect is small , but turns out to be essential when we shall consider the quantum coherence of magnons : dephasing will occur because magnons give rise to a subtle change in the level splitting of the thin spectrum . this change in level splitting turns out to be inversely proportional to @xmath1 , the total number of spins in the antiferromagnet . implies that of the harmonic oscillator solutions ( left ) only the odd ones are allowed ( right ) , as these have a node at the origin.,title="fig : " ] implies that of the harmonic oscillator solutions ( left ) only the odd ones are allowed ( right ) , as these have a node at the origin.,title="fig : " ] in the continuum limit the schrdinger s equation reduces to @xmath160 where again we have used @xmath154 . in this equation we introduced @xmath161 and @xmath162 . obviously this is the differential equation of a harmonic oscillator . the eigenstates @xmath148 thus are well known and the corresponding eigenvalues are @xmath163 , so that @xmath164 where the quantum of energy for the states labeled by @xmath57 is @xmath165 . for the harmonic oscillator @xmath57 is a non - negative integer . however , in the present situation we have to meet the boundary condition that @xmath166 or , equivalently , that @xmath167 if @xmath168 . so @xmath148 has to vanish at the origin . this boundary condition is trivially met by eigenfunctions that are odd and have a node at @xmath130 , see fig . [ fig : harmonic ] . thus solutions to the schrdinger s equation are harmonic oscillator eigenfunctions of order @xmath57 , where @xmath57 is an odd positive integer . in fig . [ fig : wave ] the groundstate wavefunction in the continuum limit is compared with the exact wavefunction for large @xmath1 . it makes clear that the continuum approximation is very good one . spins ) and the nel wavefunction in the continuum limit ( a harmonic oscillator eigenstate ) . the overlap of the nel state with the different total spin states is shown as a function of the total spin quantum number . the parameters are @xmath169 and the symmetry breaking field is @xmath170 . the wavefunctions are rescaled such that the maximum of the harminic oscillator wavefunction is unity . ] let us consider the energy spectrum in eq . in more detail . clearly if @xmath18 is zero we recover the groundstate energy @xmath150 of the symmetric case that we discussed before . however , if there is a finite staggered field @xmath18 , there is a gain in groundstate energy proportional to @xmath171 , which reveals that the energy spectrum in eq . is the one of a nel state . the same conclusion is reached by directly calculating the orderparameter ( see appendix ) . the result is shown in fig . [ fig : orderparameter ] . apparently , for the symmetry broken nel state to be stable , the symmetry breaking field can be exceedingly small , as long as @xmath1 is large enough . in other words : in the thermodynamic limit the spin rotation symmetry of @xmath126 can be _ spontaneously _ broken by an infinitesimal field @xmath18 . putting it in a more formal manner : spontaneous symmetry breaking gives rise to the singular limit @xmath172 this in fact defines spontaneous symmetry breaking , just as it did in the case of the quantum crystal . that for the lieb - mattis hamiltonian this limit is singular is directly clear from fig . [ fig : orderparameter ] . in the symmetry broken nel state the excitations labeled by @xmath57 act as a new thin spectrum with excitation energies that are multiples of @xmath173 . the magnon excitation energy is still of order @xmath140 . we now repeat the analysis above for a nel state with @xmath22 magnons ( by setting @xmath174 and using @xmath175 instead of @xmath158 ) . in this case the energy spectrum becomes @xmath176 see fig . [ fig : thin ] . note that as we stated before , there is a subtle effect of the magnons on the thin states : @xmath22 magnons cause a change in energy of the thin spectrum of the order of @xmath177 . this effect will turn out to be essential for the decoherence mechanism that we will discuss in the following section . physically the change in energy of the thin states due to the presence of a magnon can easily be understood . if there are @xmath22 magnons present in the antiferromagnet , then the order parameter of the total system is reduced by @xmath22 . since the thin spectrum describes the global excitations of the order parameter , its energy is proportional to the order parameter itself . the ratio of the nel order parameter of the excited state with @xmath22 magnons and the one of the groundstate with a fully developed order parameter is @xmath178 . therefore , when there are @xmath22 magnons present , the relative change of the orderparameter is @xmath177 and the change in energy of the thin states is therefore of the order @xmath179 which explains the last term in expression ( [ eq : enm ] ) . using the many - body lieb - mattis model with @xmath1 spins and @xmath180 , we now study the coherence of the antiferromagnet when it is used as a qubit . again there are many ways in which one can define a two - level system to be used as the qubit states . the best possible choice in this case is provided by the gapped and dispersionless magnons : we use as a qubit ( or cat - state ) the superposition of a perfectly ordered antiferromagnet and the state of the antiferromagnet with one magnon on each sublattice . due to the long - range nature of the interaction in the lieb - mattis model the gapped magnons themselves are not damped and as such do not decay or decohere . also , in analogy to the quantum crystal we expect the magnons or goldstone modes of the antiferromagnet to influence the thin spectrum as little as possible . a magnon has an energy @xmath140 , which we assume is the energy scale that is available to the ( thought-)experimentalist to prepare , manipulate and read out the qubit ) , which considerably simplifies the calculations without loss of generality . ] . starts interacting with a @xmath1-spin lieb - mattis magnet , thus forming at @xmath69 a many - body qubit made out of @xmath181 spin . quantum coherence is preserved at all times , since in this semi - classical approximation the thin spectrum is neglected . ] with the exact expressions for all eigenstates and energies of both the symmetric and the symmetry broken hamiltonian at hand , we are in the position to set up the initial state for our many - particle qubit . instead of simply assuming that we are in a previously prepared superposition of states with zero and two magnons , we will explicitly construct this initial state . this can be done by coupling at time @xmath182 a two spin singlet to the symmetry broken @xmath1-spin lieb - mattis system , see fig . [ fig : qubit ] . from this the desired superposition results . so for times @xmath183 , the lieb - mattis antiferromagnet is completely decoupled from the two spin singlet and the total wavefunction is thus the direct product of the wavefunctions of the @xmath1-spin magnet and the two - spin singlet state : latexmath:[\ ] ] which reduces to the classically expected order parameter in the thermodynamic limit . note that in this expression it is immediately clear that the limit of vanishing symmetry breaking field does not commute with the limit of infinitely many spins : they form a singular limit . j. van wezel , j. van den brink and j. zaanen , phys . letters * 94 * 230401 ( 2005 ) . i. chiorescu , y. nakamura , c.j.p.m . harmans , and j.e . mooij , science * 299 * , 1869 ( 2003 ) . van der wal , a.c.j . ter haar , f.k . wilhelm , r.n . schouten , c.p.m . harmans , t.p . orlando , s. lloyd and j.e . mooij , science 290 , 773 ( 2000 ) . y. nakamura , yu . a. pashkin , and j. s. tsai , nature ( london ) * 398 * , 786 ( 1999 ) ; y. nakamura y. a. pashkin , t. yamamoto , and j. s. tsai phys . lett . * 88 * , 047901 ( 2002 ) . d. vion , a. aassime , a. cottet , p. joyez , h. pothier , c. urbina , d. esteve , and m. h. devoret , science 296 , 886 ( 2002 ) . friedman , m.p . sarachik , j. tejada and r. ziolo , phys . 76 , 3830 ( 1996 ) . awschalom , j.f . smyth , g. grinstein , d.p . divincenzo and d. loss , phys . 68 , 3092 ( 1992 ) . e. lieb and d. mattis , j. math . phys . * 3 * 749 ( 1962 ) . anderson , phys . rev . * 86 * 694 ( 1952 ) , p.w . anderson , science 177 , 393 ( 1972 ) . see , for instance , s. coleman,_apects of symmetry _ , chapter 5 , cambridge university press ( 1985 ) . kaplan , w. von der linden and p. horsch , phys . b * 42 * 4663 ( 1990 ) . c. kaiser and i. peschel , a 22 , 4257 ( 1989 ) . b. bernu , p. lecheminant , c. lhuillier and l. pierre , phys . b * 50 * 10048 ( 1994 ) . l. capriotti , int . j. mod b * 15 * 1799 ( 2001 ) . b. bernu , c. lhuillier and l. pierre , phys . lett . * 69 * 2590 ( 1992 ) . h. neuberger and t. ziman , phys . b * 39 * 2608 ( 1989 ) . d. s. fisher , phys . b * 39 * 11783 ( 1989 ) . m. gross , e. snchez - velasco and e. d. siggia , phys . b * 40 * 11328 ( 1989 ) . see , for instance a. auerbach , interacting electrons and quantum magnetism , springer - verlag , new york ( 1994 ) , and references therein . mattis , _ the theory of magnetism i : thermodynamics and statistical mechanics _ , springer - verlag , berlin , 1988 .

we have recently shown that there is a limit to quantum coherence in many - particle spin qubits due to spontaneous symmetry breaking . these results were derived for the lieb - mattis spin model . here we will show that the underlying mechanism of decoherence in systems with spontaneous symmetry breaking is in fact more general . we present here a generic route to finding the decoherence time associated with spontaneous symmetry breaking in many particle qubits , and subsequently we apply this approach to two model systems , indicating how the continuous symmetries in these models are spontaneously broken and discussing the relation of this symmetry breaking to the thin spectrum . we then present in detail the calculations that lead to the limit to quantum coherence , which is due to energy shifts in the thin spectrum .

cond-mat0411218

density functional theory@xcite ( dft ) combined with the generalized gradient approximation ( gga ) for the exchange and correlation functional has become a popular method for studying materials and molecules at the atomic scale . recently , there has been an increasing interest in using uniform real - space grids and finite - difference methods for doing dft calculations@xcite . real - space grids give an unbiased description of the wave functions and the quality of the description can easily be controlled by changing the grid - point density . finite - difference operators are used because the wave function values are given on grid points in real - space , and not in terms of a basis set . by doing all operations in real - space , parallelization can be done by simple domain decomposition@xcite . furthermore , real - space methods can make use of multigrid acceleration schemes@xcite for solving the kohn - sham equations@xcite and the poisson equation . a further advantage of real space methods is the possibility for imposing localization constraints on the wave functions , which is the basis for linearly scaling electronic structure methods@xcite ( order-@xmath0 methods ) . today , one of the most used methods for performing dft calculations is the pseudo potential method using periodic super - cells and plane - wave expansions for the pseudo wave - functions . this method shares with the grid - based methods the properties of unbiased representation of the wave functions and simple control of the quality of a calculation ( by changing the number of plane waves ) . however , there are three major difficulties with a plane - wave representation for the wave functions . 1 ) working with spatially localized wave functions , which is important for order-@xmath0 methods , is difficult with the extended nature of plane waves . 2 ) not all operations involving the wave functions , densities and potentials can be done directly in the plane - wave representation , and fourier transformations to and from real - space must be carried out . transformations between real and reciprocal spaces are highly non - local operations , and therefore difficult to parallelize . 3 ) due to the periodicity of plane waves , the natural boundary conditions for a plane wave calculation is periodic boundary conditions . although all three problems have been addressed@xcite , the suggested solutions are not as simple as for grid - based approaches where all three problems have simple solutions . an advantage of a plane - wave representation for the wave functions is its compactness . the memory footprint of a wave function is typically 10 times larger in a real - space grid representation compared to a plane - wave representation of similar accuracy . for this reason it is important to use soft pseudo wave functions that can be accurately represented on coarse grids . to our knowledge , until now , all applications of grid - based electronic structure calculations have used norm - conserving pseudopotentials . one way to get smoother pseudo wave functions is to relax the norm - conservation of the wave functions and use ultra - soft pseudopotentials@xcite or the projector augmented wave ( paw ) method@xcite . we have decided to use the paw method . the paw method works with soft valence wave functions and , similar to the ultra - soft pseudopotential method , the wave functions need not be normalized . contrary to the ultra - soft pseudopotential method , the paw method is an all - electron method within the frozen core approximation , giving access to the true wave functions and the full electron density . the paw method has been implemented for plane waves by several groups@xcite . we see the combination of real - space grid - based methods and the paw method as an important step towards enabling larger calculations at a level of accuracy which is essentially all - electron in nature . there is a clear trend in electronic structure theory towards larger and more complex systems as for example nanostructures , large ( bio-)molecular complexes and extended defects in real materials . systems which all quickly challenge present day high accuracy dft codes , that are typically limited to at most a few hundred atoms . the great potential of the method presented here lies in the parallelization of the real - space algorithms . this makes it possible to make use of massively parallel computers as has been demonstrated by several other groups@xcite . in this paper , we focus on how to do accurate dft calculations efficiently by using a real - space paw method . we demonstrate the accuracy of our grid - based paw calculations by showing that we are able to reproduce results for atomization energies from all - electron dft calculations . this very stringent test shows that the methodology that we have developed is useful for real applications . the solution of poisson s equation is straightforward using multigrid methods@xcite ( no fourier transformations required ) . solving the kohn - sham equations using multigrid methods is a much more difficult task : keeping the different eigenstates separated and orthogonal to each other can be a problem , and representing the hamiltonian on the coarse grids can also be problematic . we have decided to use the techniques typically used in `` state of the art '' pseudopotential plane - wave calculations@xcite as they have been developed and improved over the the last few decades . for iteratively solving the kohn - sham equations , we use pulay mixing techniques for obtaining the self - consistent density@xcite , subspace diagonalizations , and the residual minimization method@xcite using preconditioning of the electronic gradients for iteratively improving the wave functions . the preconditioning operation is a single multigrid v - cycle using only the kinetic energy operator as an approximate hamiltonian@xcite . in the following section , we will briefly summarize the paw method . then , in section [ grids ] , we will go through the details of our grid - based formulation of the paw formalism . in section [ groundstate ] , we describe how we solve the kohn - sham equations , and the evaluation of atomic forces is discussed in section [ forces ] . section [ generalizations ] describes generalizations of the method to periodic systems with use of brillouin zone sampling . in section [ applications ] we apply the methodology that we have developed to a number of example systems and discuss approximations necessary for realistic calculations . finally , in section [ performance ] we discuss the computational performance of our implementation . the notation we use is close to the one used by p. e. blchl in his papers on the paw method@xcite . we have used hartree atomic units ( @xmath1 ) and we write the equations for the case of a spin - paired and finite system of electrons . the paw method is based on a transformation between smooth pseudo wave functions , @xmath2 , and the true all - electron kohn - sham wave functions , @xmath3 ( @xmath4 is the band index ) . the core states of the atoms , @xmath5 , are frozen . here @xmath6 is an atom index and @xmath7 is a combination of principal , angular momentum , and magnetic quantum numbers respectively ( @xmath4 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 ) . given a smooth pseudo wave function , the corresponding all - electron wave function , which is orthogonal to the set of @xmath5 orbitals , can be obtained through a linear transformation @xmath10 the transformation operator , @xmath11 , is given in terms of atom centered all - electron wave functions , @xmath12 , the corresponding smooth partial waves , @xmath13 , and projector functions , @xmath14 , as @xmath15 the atom centered all - electron wave functions are taken from a calculation of a single atom with spherical symmetry : @xmath16 , where the @xmath17 s are real - valued spherical harmonics ( @xmath18 is a combined index for @xmath8 and @xmath9 ) . a radial cutoff distance , @xmath19 , defining the atomic augmentation sphere is chosen . this radius is similar to a cutoff radius for a pseudopotential . the larger the augmentation sphere , the smoother the pseudo wave functions , but overlap with neighboring augmentation spheres must be avoided . for all all - electron valence states smooth partial waves @xmath20 are constructed . the partial waves must match the corresponding all - electron waves for @xmath21 . in this way , the correction in parenthesis in eq . ( [ transform ] ) is zero outside the augmentation spheres and we will have @xmath22 in this region . notice , that there are no norm - conservation requirements to meet when choosing the shape of @xmath23 inside the augmentation sphere . smooth projector functions must also be defined one for each partial wave : @xmath24 . they must be localized inside the augmentation spheres and satisfy @xmath25 , which for the radial part gives @xmath26 with this construction we have @xmath27 . in principle , an infinite number of projectors and partial waves are required for the paw method to be exact . for practical calculations , a high accuracy data set will need only one or two projector functions for each angular momentum channel of importance . this is similar to an ultra - soft pseudopotential , where a comparable number of projectors is needed . one partial wave is usually taken as the bound valence state , and additional waves can be taken from `` excited states '' solutions to the radial kohn - sham equation at different non - eigenvalue energies . the construction of partial waves and projector functions is described in appendix [ construction ] . > from the atomic frozen core electron density , @xmath28 , a smooth core electron density , @xmath29 , is constructed . it must be identical to @xmath28 for @xmath21 . there is no norm - conservation requirement to meet when choosing the shape of @xmath29 inside the augmentation sphere . the pseudo electron density has contributions from the wave functions and from the atom centered smooth core electron densities : @xmath30 where the @xmath31 s are occupation numbers and @xmath32 is the position of atom @xmath6 . an atomic density matrix ( see eq . ( 22 ) in ref . ) is defined as @xmath33 where @xmath34 the paw formalism defines atom centered all - electron and pseudo electron densities as @xmath35 and @xmath36 respectively . by construction , @xmath37 is identical to the all - electron density , @xmath38 , for @xmath39 and @xmath40 for @xmath41 ( see ref . for details ) . therefore , the true all - electron density can be obtained from the pseudo electron density : @xmath42.\ ] ] again , the correction is zero outside the augmentation spheres . a neutral charge density , @xmath43 , is obtained by adding compensation charges , @xmath44 , inside the augmentation spheres to the pseudo electron density . these charges compensate for the lack of norm - conservation and for the nuclear charge : @xmath45 using localized functions @xmath46 normalized as @xmath47 the compensation charges are constructed with electrostatic multipole moments @xmath48 : @xmath49 the values to be used for the electrostatic multipole moments , @xmath48 , are found by requiring the pseudo charge density , @xmath50 , to have the same electrostatic multipole moments as the all - electron charge density , @xmath51 , where @xmath52 is the nuclear charge density ( @xmath53 is the atomic number ) . this requirement can be expressed as @xmath54 y_l(\hat{\mathbf{r } } ) = 0.\ ] ] inserting eqs . ( [ n ] ) , ( [ nt ] ) and ( [ zt ] ) we get : @xmath55 where the constants @xmath56 and @xmath57 are given by : @xmath58\ ] ] and @xmath59.\ ] ] the paw total energy is a function of the pseudo wave functions , @xmath60 , and the occupation numbers , @xmath31 . the energy can be divided into a `` soft '' contribution , @xmath61 , and corrections for each atom ( see ref . and ): @xmath62 the `` soft '' energy contribution is : @xmath63\nonumber \\ & & + \int d\mathbf{r } \tilde{n}(\mathbf{r } ) \sum_a \bar{v}^a(|\mathbf{r } - \mathbf{r}^a|),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath64 is the pseudo hartree potential , satisfying poisson s equation @xmath65 and @xmath66 is an exchange - correlation functional . finally , @xmath67 is an arbitrary localized potential vanishing for @xmath21 . the soft energy contribution , @xmath61 , is to be evaluated on three dimensional grids in real space . the atomic corrections to the energy ( @xmath68 ) are given by : @xmath69 [ n^a(\mathbf{r } ' ) + z^a(\mathbf{r } ' ) ] } { |\mathbf{r } - \mathbf{r}'|}\nonumber \\ & + e_{\text{xc}}[n^a(\mathbf{r } ) ] \label{ea}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath70 [ \tilde{n}^a(\mathbf{r } ' ) + \tilde{z}^a(\mathbf{r } ' ) ] } { |\mathbf{r } - \mathbf{r}'|}\nonumber \\ & + e_{\text{xc}}[\tilde{n}^a(\mathbf{r } ) ] + \int d \mathbf{r } \tilde{n}^a(\mathbf{r } ) \bar{v}^a(r ) . \label{eat}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the energy contributions for @xmath71 and @xmath72 , are evaluated on radial grids inside the augmentation spheres . by using eqs . ( [ n ] ) , ( [ nt ] ) , ( [ zt ] ) and ( [ q ] ) we can reduce the atomic correction , @xmath68 , to a function of @xmath73 : @xmath74 the constants @xmath75 , @xmath76 and @xmath77 are evaluated in the appendix [ constants ] . the last term is an exchange - correlation correction : @xmath78 - e_{\text{xc}}[\tilde{n}^a(\mathbf{r } ) ] , \label{xca}\ ] ] which is a function of @xmath73 through eqs . ( [ n ] ) and ( [ nt ] ) . for local and semi - local exchange - correlation functionals , @xmath79 is written as an integration inside the augmentation sphere . there are several possibilities for the evaluation of this term . we use radial integration along lines from the center to a number of points distributed evenly on the surface of the augmentation sphere@xcite . we find that this approach is the simplest for gga functionals@xcite . alternatively , one can expand the atomic densities in spherical harmonics , as described in ref . or use grid free approaches@xcite . in this section we give the details of our real - space grid - based implementation of the paw method . from now on , wave functions , electron densities and potentials are represented on three - dimensional uniform grids in real - space . in a grid representation , integrals over space are turned into sums over grid points . in the paw method we often need to calculate the integral of a localized function , centered on an atom , multiplied by a function extended over all of space . as an example , let us take a projector function , @xmath80 , centered on atom @xmath6 at position @xmath32 , multiplied by an extended wave function , @xmath60 . in the following , we use the index @xmath81 to index the grid points used for the wave functions . transforming the integral to a sum over grid points , @xmath81 , with @xmath82 being the volume per grid point , we get : @xmath83 where @xmath84 and @xmath85 is the position of grid point @xmath81 ( only the grid points in the localized region around atom @xmath6 needs to be summed over ) . for @xmath86 we could use @xmath87 . however , this is not accurate enough , unless we use a very fine grid , which would compromise efficiency . instead we use the elegant double grid technique of ono and hirose@xcite . here , the extended function is interpolated to a finer grid with grid points @xmath88 : @xmath89 . the interpolation operator @xmath90 takes the wave function from a coarse grid to a fine grid . typically , a cubic interpolation is used and the fine grid has five times more points in each direction as the coarse grid@xcite . the localized projector function is evaluated on a fine grid as @xmath91 . with @xmath92 being the volume per fine grid point we get a more accurate sum : @xmath93 \tilde{\psi}_{ng}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] comparing the rightmost expression with eq . ( [ sum ] ) , we identify the term in square brackets as the more accurate expression for @xmath86 : @xmath94 this is equivalent to a restriction operation taking the localized function from the fine temporary grid to the coarse grid ( restriction is the opposite of interpolation ) . notice that in eq . ( [ sum ] ) , the sum is over coarse grid points , and no actual interpolation of the extended function needs to be done . the evaluation of the localized function on the temporary grid is a relatively inexpensive operation , with an operation count which for each atom is independent of the system size . we use the double grid technique to transfer localized functions , such as @xmath14 , @xmath29 and @xmath67 , to values on real - space grids ( @xmath86 , @xmath95 and @xmath96 ) . the formulas for densities , potentials , and energies , given in section [ paw ] , must be translated to a discretized form for use with a discrete representation of wave functions , densities and potentials . the pseudo electron density , eq . ( [ nofr ] ) , is calculated on a coarse grid as @xmath97 the smooth atomic core electron densities can be chosen very soft , so that they can be added to the coarse grid . the pseudo electron density on the coarse grid is interpolated to a finer grid ( grid points indexed by @xmath98 ) : @xmath99 we use a cubic interpolation for @xmath100 , and the fine grid has twice as many grid points as the coarse grid in each direction . from the pseudo electron density on the fine grid , one can obtain the neutral charge density as [ see eq . ( [ rhot ] ) ] : @xmath101 using our grid representation for wave functions , densities and potentials , we get for @xmath61 : @xmath102 where @xmath82 and @xmath103 are the volumes per grid point for the coarse wave function grids and the fine density and potential grids respectively , and @xmath104 is a central finite difference representation of the laplacian . the discretization that we use for the laplacian , uses a total of twelve neighbor points , giving an error of the order of @xmath105 , where @xmath106 is the grid spacing . the pseudo hartree potential @xmath107 is found by solving poisson s equation , @xmath65 , using a discretization for the laplacian : @xmath108 this equation is solved using the multigrid technique pioneered by brandt@xcite . solving the poisson equation iteratively on the finest grid will quickly reduce the short wavelength errors , but errors with larger wavelengths compared to the grid spacing are reduced only slowly . the multigrid technique introduces a series of coarser grids where the long wavelength errors can be effectively reduced . we use a mehrstellen discretization@xcite , where @xmath109 is expressed in terms of two short - ranged finite difference operators @xmath110 and @xmath111 : @xmath112 for the coarse grids used in the multigrid v - cycle , simple nearest neighbor central finite - difference laplacians are used . adding the compensation charges , @xmath113 , to the pseudo electron density [ eqs . ( [ rhot ] ) and ( [ rho ] ) ] will require a very fine density grid in order to get an accurate description of the charge . the problem is that the compensation charges must be localized inside the augmentation spheres : @xmath114 for @xmath115 . blchl has described a method for plane - wave basis sets@xcite , that allows the use of softer compensation charges extending outside the augmentation spheres . we use the same method for our grid - based approach . a cutoff radius @xmath116 larger than @xmath19 is chosen . soft compensation charges with the same electrostatic multipole moments as the localized compensation charges are constructed : @xmath117 where @xmath118 is a soft function localized within @xmath119 . the soft function , @xmath118 , is normalized in the same way as @xmath120 see eq . ( [ norm ] ) . equation ( [ rho ] ) must now be replaced by : @xmath121 and a correction must be added to @xmath61 . the correction is ( see ref . ): @xmath122 where @xmath123 , and @xmath124 the first term in eq . ( [ correction ] ) is evaluated on the grid as @xmath125 . the transformation of the localized potential , @xmath126 , and the localized compensation charge , @xmath127 , ( both vanishing for @xmath128 ) to values at grid points , @xmath129 and @xmath130 , is done using the double grid technique@xcite . the last term in eq . ( [ correction ] ) is a pair potential with range @xmath131 : @xmath132 where @xmath133 the pair potential terms , @xmath134 , are functions of the difference vectors @xmath135 . the orthogonality constraint of the all - electron wave functions , @xmath136 , can be expressed in terms of the pseudo wave functions@xcite as @xmath137 , where the paw overlap operator @xmath138 is non - local : @xmath139 with @xmath140\nonumber \\ & = & \sqrt{4 \pi } \delta_{00i_1i_2}^a.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the discretised overlap operator looks like : @xmath141 and the orthogonality constraint of the pseudo wave functions can be expressed as @xmath142 in order to find the electronic ground state it is necessary to calculate the derivatives of the total energy with respect to the wave function values . this `` electronic gradient '' can be expressed in terms of a hamiltonian @xmath143 : @xmath144 the hamiltonian is given as a sum of the kinetic energy operator and the local and non - local parts of the effective potential : @xmath145 explicit formulas for the local effective potential , @xmath146 , and the `` atomic '' hamiltonian , @xmath147 , are given in the appendix [ ham ] . the set of orthonormalized ground - state wave functions that diagonalize the hamiltonian matrix @xmath148 , must satisfy the kohn - sham equations : @xmath149 in order to locate the self - consistent ground state , we use the residual minimization method of wood and zunger@xcite ( see also ref . ) . the residuals are calculated as @xmath150 where @xmath151 is the current estimate of the eigenvalue of the @xmath4th band . using a preconditioning operator @xmath152 ( to be discussed later ) , we can improve the wave function by taking a step along the direction of the preconditioned residual : @xmath153 ( @xmath154 is the step length ) . the optimal step length is found by minimizing the norm of the residual for the new guess : @xmath155 finding the optimal value for @xmath154 amounts to finding the minimum of a second order polynomial in @xmath154 . having found the optimal step length for the first step , we do the actual update of the wave function by taking an additional step using the same step length in the direction of the preconditioned residual @xmath156 : @xmath157 for updating one wave function , one must apply the hamiltonian twice , and two preconditioning operations are required . if we were to take steps along the residual ( and not along the preconditioned residual ) , we would need very many iterations in order to converge . the problem is that the residual vector is not necessarily parallel to the error vector ( which we do nt know ) . the purpose of preconditioning is to produce a direction that more accurately represents the error vector@xcite . we would get the optimal preconditioned residual @xmath158 by solving @xmath159 . instead of solving this equation exactly , we solve approximately the simpler equation @xmath160 . this is done using one multigrid v - cycle , where a nearest neighbor discretization is used for the laplacian on the coarse grids@xcite . when all wave functions have been updated , the wave functions are othonormalized , and the density is updated . from the new density , a new hamiltonian is generated ( @xmath146 and @xmath161 ) . finally , a subspace diagonalization is performed , and the next iteration towards self - consistency can begin . for each iteration a new input density is estimated using pulay mixing@xcite . typically three old densities are used . the atomic density matrices , @xmath73 , are mixed as well . we start the iterations from a good guess at the wave function : a linear combination of atomic orbitals . the atomic force acting on an atom is defined as @xmath162 in the last line , we have used eqs . ( [ grad ] ) and ( [ ks ] ) . the variation of the wave function corresponding to a variation in the position can be found from eq . ( [ o ] ) : @xmath163 inserting into eq . ( [ f ] ) , we get : @xmath164 \nonumber \\ & - \sum_{a ' } \sum_{ll ' } q_l^a \frac{dv_{ll'}^{aa'}}{d\mathbf{r}^a } q_{l'}^{a'}. \label{ff}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as an example , we show in fig . [ force ] , the force along the bond of a co molecule calculated using the analytical expression above . fitting a third order polynomial to the energies and taking the negative of the derivative with respect to the bond length , is seen to give exactly the same force . we have implemented the algorithms introduced above , and in addition we have made two extensions : 1 ) treatment of spin - polarized systems and 2 ) treatment of periodic systems using brillouin zone sampling . the first extension is straightforward . when @xmath165-points are introduced in order to treat periodic systems , we can work directly with the wave functions and use bloch boundary conditions@xcite : @xmath166 where @xmath167 is any bravais lattice vector . this is different from the plane wave approach , where the periodic basis set forces one to work with the periodic part of the wave function and the hamiltonian becomes @xmath165-point dependent . in our case , the boundary conditions become @xmath165-point dependent . it is only necessary to work with the @xmath165-points in the irreducible part of the brillouin zone . each @xmath165-point will have a specific weight , and densities , atomic density matrices , and forces should be appropriately symmetrized . for evaluating the gga exchange - correlation energy and potential , we use a finite difference operator for calculating the gradient of the density . the exchange - correlation potential is calculated as the exact derivative of the discretised exchange - correlation energy with respect to @xmath168 ( similar in spirit to the method of white and bird@xcite used for plane - wave basis sets ) . the first application of the algorithms described here is the calculation of atomization energies for the twenty small molecules listed in table [ mol20 ] using the pbe@xcite exchange - correlation functional . the augmentation sphere radii used and the number of projectors used are shown in table [ rc ] . the choice of the augmentation sphere radii is a compromise between smooth pseudo wave functions and a low number of projector functions : a larger radius will allow us to have smoother pseudo wave functions , but more projector functions will be needed for high accuracy . furthermore , the radius is limited by the requirement that the overlap between neighboring augmentation spheres should be small . the radii we have chosen , will give slight overlaps in some of the molecular calculations . .pbe and experimental atomization energies ( experimental geometries are used@xcite , and zero point vibration energy has been removed ) . the ground states of c , o , f , p and cl are found to be non - spherical@xcite . all - electron and experimental numbers are taken from refs . and . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ al ] we have compared the performance of the real - space code with a highly optimized ultra - soft plane - wave code@xcite . the ground state of 64 si atoms in the diamond structure was found using both codes . for the plane wave calculation , plane waves with kinetic energies up to 100 ev were used and the size of the real - space grid for fast fourier transforms was @xmath169 points . the same grid size was used for the real - space code ( @xmath170 ) . after finding the electronic ground state , one atom was displaced by 0.1 , and the time for converging to the new ground state was measured . the measured times were 21 and 26 minutes for the plane wave code and real - space code respectively on a pentium-4 2.6 ghz linux machine . we have estimated the degree of convergence of the two codes by calculating the cohesive energy of silicon . the cohesive energy calculated with the plane wave code and a plane wave cutoff of 100 ev , was converged to within 40 mev of the fully converged value . with the real - space code and @xmath170 , the cohesive energy was converged to within 3 mev of the @xmath171 value . this result and similar results for other calculations we have performed seem to indicate that the real - space code obtains a somewhat better convergence at the same grid spacing as the plane - wave code . furthermore , the real - space code can , most likely , take advantage of a number of improvements , such as algorithmic improvements and optimizations of floating point operations and memory access . the plane wave code has already benefited from optimizations of this sort . regarding the memory requirements , the plane - wave code is clearly more economic . the memory required to store one wave function for the 64 atom silicon system is @xmath172 floating point numbers for the real - space code and 2897 floating point numbers@xcite for the plane - wave code . using the techniques described in this article , an important step in every electronic structure calculation , namely the application of the hamiltonian to all wave functions , can be done in @xmath173 operations . this is a more optimal scaling , than the @xmath174 scaling that can be achieved with plane - wave basis sets and fast fourier transforms . operations such as orthogonalization and subspace diagonalization of the wave functions scale as @xmath175 . luckily , the prefactors for these @xmath175 operations are very low , so that very large system sizes are required before the @xmath175 terms become the bottleneck@xcite . in the limit where @xmath175 terms start to dominate , plane wave methods will in principle have an advantage , because the number of plane wave coefficients will typically be less than the number of grid points used in real - space grid - based calculations . however , we believe , that for those very large systems , efficient parallelization on massively parallel computers and the use of @xmath176 methods is crucial . currently , we have a single processor implementation of our paw real - space algorithms@xcite . this limits us to study rather small systems . obviously a parallelization using real - space domain decomposition is needed . for the small systems that we have studied so far , charge sloshing is less of a problem , but it may become a problem when we move on to larger systems . it will therefore be necessary to improve on our mixing of the density . a preconditioning , such as that proposed by kerker@xcite , that will damp the long wavelength changes to the density should be considered . another improvement would be to use a special metric , that weights long wavelength errors higher than short wavelength errors , for estimating the norm of the difference between input and output densities in the pulay method@xcite . these improvements to the density mixing are easily implemented in reciprocal space , but may be challenging to do in real - space . financial support from the carlsberg foundation is gratefully acknowledged . we furthermore acknowledge support from the materials research program of the danish research agency grant # 5020 - 00 - 0012 , and from the danish center for scientific computing . in the following , we provide explicit formulas needed for calculating the constants and functions that describe an atomic species . a dft calculation for the atom is performed using radial grids for the wave functions , densities and potentials . the radial kohn - sham equation gives us a set of radial all - electron wave functions , normalized as @xmath177 ^ 2 = 1 $ ] . the core states are only used for constructing a frozen core electron density : @xmath178 ^ 2.\ ] ] the smooth partial wave functions are chosen as @xmath179 for @xmath180 , and the coefficients , @xmath181 , are chosen so that @xmath182 joins @xmath183 smoothly at @xmath184 . the projector functions are calculated as @xmath185 the projector functions must be orthonormalized as described by blchl@xcite . the potential @xmath186 is chosen so that the local effective potential , @xmath187 , has the following shape for @xmath188 in the atomic reference state : @xmath189 the constants @xmath190 and @xmath191 are found by requiring that @xmath192 and @xmath193 . for the compensation charges we use gaussians : @xmath194 and @xmath195 with this choice for the compensation charges , the integral , @xmath134 , in eq . ( [ pair ] ) , can be evaluated analytically@xcite . we choose the @xmath196 s so that @xmath197 and @xmath198 . the integrals for @xmath200 , @xmath201 , @xmath202 , @xmath203 , @xmath204 and @xmath205 are ( all integrals are limited to inside the augmentation spheres ) : @xmath208 \nonumber \\ & - \int d\mathbf{r } \tilde{n}_c^a(r ) \bar{v}^a(r),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath209 \nonumber \\ & + \int d\mathbf{r } [ v_{i_1i_2}^a(\mathbf{r})n_c(r ) + v_c^a(r ) \tilde{\phi}_{i_1}^a(\mathbf{r } ) \tilde{\phi}_{i_2}^a(\mathbf{r } ) ] \nonumber \\ & - \int d\mathbf{r } \frac{\phi_{i_1}^a(\mathbf{r } ) \phi_{i_2}^a(\mathbf{r})}{r } \mathcal{z}^a \nonumber \\ & - \int d\mathbf{r } \tilde{\phi}_{i_1}^a(\mathbf{r } ) \tilde{\phi}_{i_2}^a(\mathbf{r } ) \bar{v}^a(r),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath210,\ ] ] @xmath211 @xmath212 and @xmath213 it is advantageous to decompose @xmath214 into angular momentum contributions as @xmath218 and solve @xmath219 = -4\pi g_{l_1l_2}^l y_l(\hat{\mathbf{r } } ) \nonumber \\ & \times [ \phi_{n_1\ell_1}^a(r ) \phi_{n_2\ell_2}^a(r ) - \tilde{\phi}_{n_1\ell_1}^a(r ) \tilde{\phi}_{n_2\ell_2}^a(r)],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath220 is a gaunt coefficient . the discretized hamiltonian , eq . ( [ h ] ) , depends on @xmath146 and @xmath147 . the local effective potential on the coarse grid , @xmath221 , is a restriction of the local effective potential on the fine grid : @xmath222 and the atomic hamiltonian , @xmath147 , is @xmath223 where @xmath224

a grid - based real - space implementation of the projector augmented wave ( paw ) method of p. e. blchl [ phys . rev . b * 50 * , 17953 ( 1994 ) ] for density functional theory ( dft ) calculations is presented . the use of uniform 3d real - space grids for representing wave functions , densities and potentials allows for flexible boundary conditions , efficient multigrid algorithms for solving poisson and kohn - sham equations , and efficient parallelization using simple real - space domain - decomposition . we use the paw method to perform all - electron calculations in the frozen core approximation , with smooth valence wave functions that can be represented on relatively coarse grids . we demonstrate the accuracy of the method by calculating the atomization energies of twenty small molecules , and the bulk modulus and lattice constants of bulk aluminum . we show that the approach in terms of computational efficiency is comparable to standard plane - wave methods , but the memory requirements are higher .

0909.0213

the nucleation of microscopic crystallites in polymer liquids is profoundly influenced by flow @xcite . this flow - induced crystallization ( fic ) , is a fascinating example of an externally driven , non - equilibrium phase transition , controlled by kinetics . furthermore , fic is ubiquitous in industrial processing of semi - crystalline polymers , the largest group of commercially useful polymers . a fundamental understanding of fic promises extensive control of polymer solid state properties , as virtually every property of practical interest is determined by the crystal morphology . flow can drastically enhance nucleation and trigger the formation of highly aligned , elongated crystals , known as shish kebabs @xcite . recent experiments on entangled polymers , have studied , in detail , shish kebab formation @xcite and the role of blend concentration @xcite , molecular architecture @xcite and molecular relaxation time @xcite . often the most pronounced flow - induced effects occur near the melting point , where quiescent crystallization is immeasurably slow @xcite . the widely postulated mechanism for fic states that flow forces the polymer chains into elongated configurations , which lowers the entropic penalty for crystallization @xcite . however , this hypothesis has yet to be developed into a quantitative molecular model . fic is extremely sensitive to the flow - induced configurations of the non - crystalline chains , so an accurate molecular flow model is an essential prerequisite . unfortunately , most polymer flow models predict only the macroscopic stress tensor and not the full molecular configuration . alternatively , detailed simulations of polymer crystallization have provided much useful information on the growth process @xcite , yet simulating primary nucleation has proven difficult , especially at low undercooling , because of the extremely long nucleation times . at a much higher level of coarse - graining , models based on differential equations either assume an empirical dependence of the nucleation rate on the flow conditions @xcite , the stress tensor @xcite , or the chain stretch @xcite ; or assert that free energy changes under flow can be directly subtracted from the nucleation barrier @xcite . in either case the postulated fic mechanism remains untested . an intermediate level of coarse - graining is required to surmount these difficulties . this letter presents coarse - grained kinetic monte carlo ( mc ) @xcite simulations of anisotropic nucleation in flowing polymers . we compute chain configurations using a recent molecular flow model @xcite that reliably predicts both neutron scattering @xcite and bulk stresses . our simulations predict both enhanced nucleation and elongated shish nuclei . kinetic mc has previously been used to model quiescent crystal growth in dilute polymers @xcite . however , it is particularly suited to nucleation and our algorithm is tractable even at low undercooling , providing an efficient and highly flexible framework to simulate general anisotropic nucleation under external fields . we compute the transient chain configuration of the uncrystallized chains under flow using the glamm model @xcite , with finite chain extensibility included using cohen s approximation @xcite . the chains are divided into @xmath0 sub - chains , each corresponding to an entanglement segment of @xmath1 kuhn steps of length @xmath2 . we take @xmath3 throughout this letter . one deterministic run of the model provides the end - to - end vector @xmath4 , where the ensemble average is for sub - chains of type @xmath5 . the data for an entire transient flow are used later in the nucleation simulations . all flow timescales are in units of the subchain rouse time @xmath6 and @xmath7 is normalized by @xmath8 . deformation of the amorphous chains has two effects on the nucleation kinetics : stretching reduces the entropic penalty for crystallization ; and monomer alignment modifies the probability of compatible alignment with the nucleus . the change in elastic free energy @xmath9 for chains with ensemble average constraints @xmath10 , but locally at equilibrium , can be calculated by statistical mechanics @xcite . although an analytic calculation is not possible for finitely extensible chains , steep free energy gradients in highly stretched chains suppress fluctuations . thus our numerical calculations for uniaxial deformations show that @xmath11 can be accurately approximated by an expression that interpolates between gaussian elasticity @xcite for small @xmath12 and cohen s @xcite approximation with @xmath13 at high stretching , @xmath14 similarly , numerical calculation of the monomer orientation distribution @xmath15 for chains with a constraint @xmath16 are well approximated by using @xmath13 in the expression for @xmath15 derived from a direct constraint on @xmath7 @xcite . @xmath17}{4\pi\sinh(\mathcal{l}^{-1}[\sqrt{{\mathrm{tr } \,}{{\mathbf{f}}}}/n_e ] ) } \cosh\left(\mathcal{l}^{-1}\left[\frac{\sqrt{{\mathrm{tr } \,}{{\mathbf{f}}}}}{n_e}\right]\cos\theta\right ) , \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath18 is the inverse langevin function and @xmath19 is the angle between the monomer and the principle axis of @xmath16 . each subchain has an individual @xmath20 so is treated as a separate species with concentration @xmath21 . our coarse - grained simulations use the minimal nucleus description required for anisotropic nucleation . the nucleus comprises @xmath22 crystallized `` monomers '' or kuhn steps , arranged in stems , with each stem formed from a single chain ( see fig [ fig : nucfig ] ) . the total number of stems @xmath23 and the number of monomers in each stem is simulated . the arrangement of the monomers within the crystal is not resolved . the nucleus is assumed to be spheroidal with the polar radius @xmath24 parallel to the stems . assigning a crystalline volume of @xmath25 to each monomer and normalizing all lengths by @xmath26 gives the equatorial radius @xmath27 , the volume @xmath28 and thus the polar radius @xmath29 . we also simulate the unit vector @xmath30 parallel to the polar radius . as in classical nucleation theory the nucleus free energy comprises the free energy of crystallization , proportional to the nucleus volume , and a free energy penalty proportional to the surface area @xmath31 . thus the free energy in units of @xmath32 is @xmath33 , where @xmath34 and @xmath35 are the coefficients of the volume and surface area free energies , respectively . we simulate two types of mc moves : addition of a new stem containing one monomer and lengthening of an existing stem by adding a new monomer , each with a corresponding reverse move . as in @xcite we assume that to attach , a monomer must be oriented within a solid tolerance angle @xmath36 of the nucleus orientation . for small @xmath36 , the fraction of monomers within this angle is @xmath37 , where @xmath19 is the angle between the nucleus polar radius and the sub - chain principle strain axis . the stem attachment rate for species @xmath5 is proportional to its melt concentration @xmath38 . in contrast , for stem lengthening only the next monomer along the chain forming the stem can crystallize . the concentration of this monomer at the nucleus surface where the lengthening event occurs is taken to be unity . thus the attachment ( @xmath39 ) and detachment ( @xmath40 ) move rates for stem addition ( @xmath41 ) and stem lengthening ( @xmath42 ) are : @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the time for a monomer attachment attempt , @xmath45 is the fraction of correctly aligned monomers ( normalized to unity in the quiescent limit ) , and the constant @xmath46 has been added to @xmath34 . the free energy change of attaching a new stem of species @xmath5 is @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the flow - induced free energy change in sub - chain @xmath5 . similar calculations give the free energy changes for the other move types . a stem can only be detached if it contains a single monomer . the kinetic mc algorithm requires a sum over all possible move rates . the area available for stem addition moves is @xmath49 , which is taken to be proportional to @xmath50 , and to give spherical nuclei in the quiescent limit . to obey detailed balance the rate of stem removal must be multiplied by @xmath51 , the probability of a given stem being at the nucleus surface . each stem can lengthen or shorten from either the top of bottom . thus the total sum over all possible move rates is : @xmath52 at each kinetic mc timestep one move is performed at random , with the selection probability weighted by the move rate . time is then incremented by a stochastically determined interval @xmath53 , where @xmath54 is chosen uniformly on @xmath55 $ ] @xcite . after each mc step the nucleus orientation @xmath30 is incremented over @xmath56 by brownian dynamics . flow rotates the spheroid nucleus through the jeffery algorithm @xcite . the angular diffusion time @xmath57 scales with both the nucleus volume @xmath22 and aspect ratio @xmath58 following the expressions in @xcite , giving @xmath59 , where @xmath60 depends only on the aspect ratio and we have introduced a dimensionless constant @xmath61 , connecting @xmath57 with the monomer attachment time @xmath44 . as the jeffery algorithm is for newtonian fluids we have neglected non - newtonian effects here . after each time step all @xmath20 values are updated from the glamm model results , and @xmath48 and @xmath62 are recalculated . the parameter @xmath63 sets the ratio of flow and monomer attachment timescales . we use @xmath64 throughout this letter , unless indicated otherwise , although similar results are obtained for any value of @xmath65 . each simulation evolves a single nucleus from a single monomer . the algorithm is especially effective at low undercooling , as for small nuclei the rate sum is small , leading to large time steps . the quiescent free energy landscape can be calculated analytically from @xmath34 and @xmath66 to give a dimensionless nucleation barrier @xmath67 and a critical nucleus of @xmath68 monomers . the simulated nucleation time @xmath69 is the first time the polar and equatorial radii simultaneously exceed the critical radius @xmath70{3n^*/4\pi}$ ] . choosing a larger threshold size for nucleation has little effect on @xmath71 . the results are accurately approximated by @xmath72 . we obtained good statistics for barriers up to @xmath73 in @xmath74hrs on one @xmath75ghz processor , giving a nucleation time of @xmath76 . the nucleation times are poisson distributed , so the nucleation rate can be defined as @xmath77 . under flow , the nucleation kinetics depend on the evolving chain deformation . we define the instantaneous nucleation rate @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the cumulative fraction of runs nucleated at time @xmath80 . for shear rates @xmath81 that are slow compared to the critical nucleus rotation time ( @xmath82 ) alignment effects can be ignored , equivalent to taking @xmath83 . the glamm model predictions for start - up of constant shear at @xmath84 of a @xmath85 melt and the resulting instantaneous nucleation rate are in fig [ fig : nucdata](a ) . the results are independent of the ratio of flow and crystallization timescales for @xmath86 . in fact , fixing the non - crystalline chain configuration to that corresponding to flow time @xmath80 for the entire simulation and plotting the resulting quasi - static nucleation rate against @xmath80 , reproduces the transient results ( fig [ fig : nucdata]a ) . thus nucleation is fully controlled by the instantaneous configuration of the surrounding chains , if @xmath87 . the stretch ratio @xmath88 is the dominant factor determining the nucleation rate , despite variations in flow rate , molecular weight and flow geometry ( fig [ fig : nucdata](b ) ) . this universal result is somewhat surprising as the distribution of stretch along the chain varies considerably with flow conditions , which may be expected to influence nucleation , especially if molecular weight and flow geometry is varied . this result will be useful in deriving simple differential models of fic @xcite as the nucleation rate can be described the expression @xmath89 , where @xmath90 is a fitting constant . also in fig [ fig : nucdata](b ) is the curve @xmath91 , which empirically fits measured nucleation rates from flowing melts @xcite . the agreement with our simulation data for @xmath92 theoretically justifies this empirical expression . in the inset to fig [ fig : nucdata](b ) the sensitivity of nucleation to chain stretching increases with decreased undercooling ( decreasing @xmath34 ) , as seen experimentally @xcite . fig [ fig : nucdata](c ) directly compares our simulations with steady - state nucleation rate measurements on a polydisperse isotactic polypropylene sample ( ipp ) during shear @xcite . the parameter determination , projection of the simulation to large energy barriers and the approximation of the molecular weight distribution as a bimodal blend are detailed in appendix [ sec : comp - with - nucl ] . the close agreement shows our model can quantitatively account for fic measurements . fig [ fig : nucdata](a ) also shows the transient nucleation rate when @xmath93 . this higher @xmath61 value gives slower angular diffusion , meaning that flow aligns sub - critical nuclei , accelerating nucleation . here , the quasi - static nucleation remains poissonian and matches the transient rates , although @xmath94 now depends on both @xmath95 and @xmath96 . further increases of @xmath61 give almost identical results . high molecular weight blend , ( @xmath97 , @xmath98 , sheared for @xmath99 ) ; inset shows experimental orientation data on a bimodal blend sheared for @xmath100 sec @xcite.,width=264 ] in experiments shish nuclei are especially prevalent in melts of short chains blended with a small amount of very long chains @xcite . we simulated a melt of @xmath101 chains blended with @xmath75wt@xmath102 of @xmath103 chains , using a generalization of the glamm model to bimodal blends @xcite . high shear produces very elongated nuclei ( fig [ fig : shishdata ] ) from a purely kinetic mechanism . the shish widen by adding new stems using any monomer from the melt , whereas shish lengthen by adding monomers along an existing stem . therefore the concentration of monomers from stretched segments at the growth surface is greater for lengthening than for widening , provided the nucleus contains a disproportionate number of stretched segments . fast flow conditions are required for this disparity to overcome the significant surface area cost of elongated nuclei . fig [ fig : shishdata ] ( inset ) shows experimental data for an orientational order parameter , the p2 orientation function , against shear rate for a @xmath104 high molecular weight blend @xcite , highlighting similarities with our predictions . also in fig [ fig : shishdata ] reduced undercooling , from reducing @xmath34 , increases the anisotropy , as seen experimentally @xcite . when crystallization is less favorable , the disparity in the kinetics of stretched and unstretched chain segments increases . our efficient kinetic monte carlo algorithm for flow - induced nucleation in polymer melts is tractable even at low undercooling . the flow - induced nucleation rate is a universal function of the chain stretch ratio , independent of flow rate , molecular weight and flow geometry , but with decreasing undercooling causing increased flow sensitivity . this universal curve is very similar to an empirical relationship that accurately describes flow induced nucleation rate measurements @xcite , justifying this empirical result . our successful quantitative comparison with nucleation measurements @xcite establishes that changes in chain free energy under flow can describe flow enhanced nucleation in semi - crystalline polymers . in our bimodal blend simulations , a few percent of high molecular weight chains optimizes shish formation and the degree of anisotropy increases with shear rate and decreased undercooling , all of which are seen experimentally @xcite . the simulation can readily be generalized to fully polydisperse melts , an essential step to model industrial polymer processing . the efficiency and flexibility of our algorithm makes it suitable to simulate general anisotropic nucleation under external fields . we thank the epsrc for funding ( gr / t11807/01 ) and l balzano , r steenbakkers , g peters , o mykhaylyk , t ryan and t mcleish for useful discussions . here we quantitatively compare our simulation results with directly observed steady - state nucleation rates from a polymer melt under shear @xcite . these measurements , by coccorullo _ et . al _ , were made on a commercial grade isotactic polypropylene ( ipp ) , known as ipp t30 g . these data show an exponential dependence of the nucleation rate with shear rate , which our model correctly predicts . in order to quantitatively model this system , the required parameters fall into two classes : molecular relaxation times , which can be accurately calculated from literature values ; and crystallization parameters , for which order of magnitude estimates are provided by the literature , but whose specific values we determine from the nucleation data . the high polydispersity of ipp t30 g is a further complication . as the full molecular weight distribution ( mwd ) for this resin was not reported , we choose a realistic mwd for highly polydisperse materials and demonstrate that this distribution is consistent with both the reported molecular weight averages and linear rheological measurements . for non - linear flow modeling , we approximate this polydisperse melt as a bimodal blend , since no polydisperse equivalent of the glamm mode is currently available . we note that no fundamental modification of our simulation algorithm would be required to take advantage of the results of a polydisperse tube model . in this data comparison we are able to correctly describe these steady state nucleation rate measurements against shear rate , using crystallization parameters that are consistent with estimates provided by literature measurements . the relaxation times of ipp t30 g can be determined by the tube model and confirmed against linear oscillatory shear measurements . taking the tube model parameters for ipp from the literature @xcite and shifting @xmath6 to the experimental temperature of @xmath105c using the time - temperature superposition parameters for ipp t30 g @xcite , gives @xmath106ns and @xmath107kg / mol . here @xmath6 is the rouse time of an entanglement segment and @xmath108 is the molecular weight between entanglements . the mass of a kuhn step of ipp is @xmath109g / mol @xcite , meaning the number of kuhn steps per entanglement segment is @xmath110 . from these parameters the chain rouse time can be calculated using @xmath111 @xcite . the form of the molecular weight distribution ( mwd ) for ipp t30 g is essential to our modeling as small amounts of high molecular weight ( hmw ) material can control fic ( see , for example , ref @xcite ) . unfortunately , the full mwd of ipp t30 g was not reported , with only the weight and number average molecular weights being given @xcite . furthermore , standard distribution functions , such as the log - normal and generalized exponential distributions , typically under - estimate the hmw tail of highly polydisperse melts @xcite . fortunately , linear rheological measurements are highly sensitive to this hmw tail at low frequencies and these data provide a clear upper - bound on the amount of hmw material . thus we select a realistic form for the full mwd and show that this is consistent with both the reported complex viscosity and molecular weight measurements ( @xmath112kg / mol and @xmath113kg / mol ) . we describe the mwd using a bimodal log - normal distribution , since the augmented tail of this distribution accounts more accurately for the hmw tail of highly polydisperse melts than standard monomodal distributions . this takes the form @xmath114 where @xmath115 is volume fraction of the hmw peak , @xmath116 and @xmath117 are the weight and number average molecular weights for the low and high molecular weight chains , respectively , and @xmath118 is the monomodal log - normal distribution . taking @xmath119 , @xmath120kg / mol , @xmath121kg / mol , @xmath122kg / mol and @xmath123kg / mol gives the correct overall weight and number average molecular weights and correctly predicts the complex viscosity measurements . these values were chosen as they correspond to the longest hmw tail that correctly predicts the complex viscosity measurements . fig [ fig : linrheol](a ) shows the molecular weight distribution and fig [ fig : linrheol](b ) compares the predicted complex viscosity resulting from this distribution with measurements on ipp t30 g . here the linear oscillatory shear response was computed using a polydisperse tube model for linear response , which combines the tube escape formula of likhtman and mcleish @xcite with the rubinstein and colby algorithm for constraint release @xcite and is implemented within our in - house software for molecular rheology , reptate . using a monomodal log - normal distribution , with @xmath124 , produces slightly inferior agreement with the complex viscosity measurements and can not account for the nucleation measurements . ) . the shaded area is the region of the molecular weight distribution defined as the high molecular weight tail in our modelling . ( b ) linear rheological measurements on ipp t30 g @xcite along with the predictions of polydisperse tube model using the molecular weight distribution discussed above and with @xmath125pa).,width=604 ] as discussed above , because there is no suitable polydisperse tube model for non - linear flow , we approximate ipp t30 g as a bimodal blend when modelling its non - linear response . fig [ fig : linrheol](a ) shows that there is no clear molecular weight at which to define the division between the two blend species . we choose the high molecular weight fraction to be all material with a molecular weight above @xmath126kg / mol , giving a hmw volume fraction of @xmath127 . taking a lower value of @xmath128 produces a rouse time that is too short to account for the flow nucleation measurements , but we note that larger values of @xmath128 may be equally valid choices . we note also that this fraction contains discernible contributions from both of the monomodal terms in eqn ( [ eq:4 ] ) . we compute the expectation value of the rouse time of the high molecular weight tail via , @xmath129 which gives @xmath130sec . all material below @xmath128 is defined as matrix material , and a similar calculation gives the average rouse time of this matrix as @xmath131ms . thus , the matrix relaxes too quickly to be stretched by the flow rates in the study of coccorullo _ et al._. hence , we model the non - linear flow dynamics of this polydisperse material by approximating it as a bimodal blend with the two fractions having the rouse times discussed above . to model ipp t30 g we require its quiescent critical nucleus size and barrier height , at the experimental temperature . an estimate for the number of kuhn steps in a critical nucleus can be found from literature data . the critical nucleus diameter has been shown to be of the order of the lamella thickness by transmission electron microscopy @xcite for ipp and confirmed for a different polymer by atomic force microscopy @xcite . for ipp the lamella thickness is @xmath132 nm at @xmath105c . using the ipp crystal density of @xmath133g/@xmath134 @xcite and the kuhn step mass for ipp @xcite and assuming a spherical critical nucleus gives the number of kuhn steps in a critical nucleus as @xmath135 . the barrier height can be estimated from the nucleation data of coccorullo _ et . @xcite ( see fig [ fig : nucplot ] ) . projecting these data to zero shear rate gives a quiescent homogeneous nucleation rate of @xmath136m@xmath137/sec . this can be converted to a rate per kuhn step using the melt density of ipp ( @xmath138g/@xmath134 ) and the ipp kuhn step mass . thus the density of kuhn steps is @xmath139m@xmath137 so the quiescent nucleation rate is @xmath140/sec per kuhn step . taking the crystallization timescale of a kuhn step @xmath44 to be of the order of the kuhn step relaxation time @xmath141ns , means that @xmath142 . clearly nucleation in this system is extremely rare and such a separation of timescales can not feasibly be simulated even by our highly efficient kmc algorithm . instead we systematically project our results to larger energy barriers to allow a comparison with these data . fitted with eqn ( [ eq:3 ] ) [ shapes are simulation data and lines are fits ] ; ( b ) variation of the sensitivity of the nucleation time to shear rate with quiescent barrier height ; ( c ) variation of @xmath44 with quiescent barrier height.,width=604 ] to perform this projection we simulated the average nucleation time over a range of quiescent nucleation barrier heights , varying from @xmath143 to @xmath144 , with the critical nucleus size held fixed at @xmath145 kuhn steps . nucleus alignment was neglected for all of these simulations ( @xmath83 , throughout ) . the steady - state configuration for both blend components for various shear rates was calculated using a recent generalisation of the glamm model to bimodal blends @xcite . the dimensionless steady - state nucleation time @xmath146 against shear rate @xmath81 was simulated using the glamm model predictions , in steady state , for a range of shear rates and molecular weights . the results are independent of molecular weight when the shear rate is expressed as a rouse weissenberg number @xmath147 , but do depend on the height of the quiescent nucleation barrier , @xmath67 , as shown in figure [ fig : pro](a ) . the simulated nucleation times vary exponentially with shear rate and can be described by the expression @xmath148 where @xmath149 and @xmath150 are fitting parameters characterizing the decay of the nucleation time with shear rate , both of which depend on the barrier height @xmath67 . the lines in fig [ fig : pro](a ) are the result of fitting eqn ( [ eq:3 ] ) to the simulation data . both of the fitting parameters have a simple dependence on @xmath67 , as shown in figs [ fig : pro](b ) and ( c ) . data for to the two largest quiescent barriers was used only to confirm the projection and was not involved in the fitting . this procedure allows the simulation results to be projected to nucleation barriers that are too high to be simulated . we can use our projected results to model the data of coccorullo _ et . al _ @xcite . the value of the projected zero shear nucleation rate from these data , combined with the projection formula in fig [ fig : pro](c ) and the requirement that @xmath151 , gives a quiescent nucleation barrier of @xmath152 . the final value of @xmath153 is chosen to reproduce the slope of the experimental data in figure [ fig : nucplot ] . thus , using the rouse time computed above and taking a value of @xmath154 gives @xmath155 from the projection formula in figure [ fig : pro](b ) . this quiescent barrier specifies @xmath156 by the projection formula in figure [ fig : pro](c ) . thus taking @xmath157ns produces agreement with the experimental data in fig [ fig : nucplot ] extrapolated to zero shear rate . we can also confirm that this value for @xmath44 is @xmath158 . with these parameters and using @xmath159 , which is valid because all of the simulated nucleation processes are poissonian , eqn ( [ eq:3 ] ) can be written as @xmath160 eqn ( [ eq:2 ] ) produces the projected simulation data in fig [ fig : nucplot ] . in summary , our model correctly predicts the exponential dependence of nucleation rate on shear rate as observed by coccorullo _ _ @xcite . furthermore , with a characterization of the full molecular weight distribution and extrapolation of our simulation results to high nucleation barriers , we can make a direct quantitative comparison with these data . we use crystallization parameters that are estimated from the literature but whose final values are determined in response to the nucleation data . this results in very good agreement with directly measured nucleation rates under flow using parameters that are consistent with literature estimates . several consequences arise from this data comparison . it demonstrates that changes in chain free energy upon stretching under flow are sufficient to quantitatively account for the degree of enhanced nucleation measured in flowing semi - crystalline polymers . it also indicates the strong need for comprehensive material characterization to accompany fic measurements . in particular , an accurate characterization of the sample s high molecular weight tail , along with linear rheological modeling , will clearly define the full spectrum of molecular relaxation times . the issues of polydispersity could be solved either through fic experiments on model polymers or through the emergence of a reliable non - linear flow model for polydisperse polymers . in principle , our model can predict the effect of varying molecular weight distribution , temperature and flow history , including transient flows , and a more comprehensive test of the model s predictions could be produced by systematic comparison to such a data set . the close agreement between theory and experimental data and our comparison provides a foundation on which further quantitative comparisons can be built .

we perform kinetic monte carlo simulations of flow - induced nucleation in polymer melts with an algorithm that is tractable even at low undercooling . the configuration of the non - crystallized chains under flow is computed with a recent non - linear tube model . our simulations predict both enhanced nucleation and the growth of shish - like elongated nuclei for sufficiently fast flows . the simulations predict several experimental phenomena and theoretically justify a previously empirical result for the flow - enhanced nucleation rate . the simulations are highly pertinent to both the fundamental understanding and process modeling of flow - induced crystallization in polymer melts .

astro-ph9806192

the detection of delayed x - ray , optical and radio emission , `` afterglow '' , following a grb is reasonably described by emission from a spherical relativistic shell , decelerating upon collision with an ambient medium ( waxman 1997a , mszros & rees 1997 , katz & piran 1997 , sari , piran & narayan 1998 ) . a relativistic blast wave is formed and expands through the surrounding medium , heating the matter in it s wake . the observed afterglow is believed to be due to synchrotron emission of relativistic electrons from the heated matter . the surrounding medium will be referred to as interstellar medium ( ism ) , though this may not necessarily be the case . at any given time , a detector receives photons which were emitted at different times in the observer frame , at different distances behind the shock front and at different angles from the line of sight ( los ) to the center of the grb . the properties of the matter are different at each of these points , and so are the emissivity and the frequency of the emitted radiation . early calculations have considered emission from a single representative point ( mszros & rees 1997 , waxman 1997a , sari , piran & narayan 1998 ) . later works included more detailed calculations . synchrotron emission was considered from the shock front ( sari 1998 , panaitescu & mszros 1998 ) , and monochromatic emission was considered from a uniform shell ( waxman 1997b ) . we consider an adiabatic hydrodynamical evolution , and use the adiabatic self similar solution found by blandford and mckee ( 1976 ) for a highly relativistic blast wave expanding into a uniform cold medium , which we will refer to as the bm solution . we neglect scattering , self absorption and electron cooling . self absorption becomes important at frequencies much smaller than the peak frequency , and for slow cooling , electron cooling becomes important at frequencies much higher than the peak frequency , so this should yield a good approximation for the observed flux around the peak . an analysis of the spectrum over a wider range of frequencies was made by sari , piran and narayan ( 1998 ) . in section 2 we derive the basic formula for the observed flux from a system moving relativistically . in section 3 we consider synchrotron emission from a power law electron distribution , and calculate the observed light curve and spectra . we show that both the light curve and the spectra are flat near the peak . this causes difficulty in explaining the shape of the optical peak of grb970508 ( sokolov et . we obtain expressions for the peak frequency at a given observed time , and for the peak flux . in section 4 we consider three alternative magnetic field models . we show that the light curve and the spectra remain flat near the peak in all the cases we considered . in section 5 we calculate the observed light curve and spectra from a locally monochromatic emission . we consider a uniform shell approximation , which was calculated by waxman ( 1997c ) , and compare the light curve and spectra to those obtained for the bm solution . we show that a uniform shell approximation yields results which are considerably different from those obtained for a more realistic hydrodynamics , and very different from those obtained for a realistic emission together with a realistic hydrodynamics . in section 6 we calculate the surface brightness , thus obtaining the observed image of a grb afterglow . as indicated in previous works ( waxman 1997b ) , sari 1998 , panaitescu & mszros 1998 ) , we obtain from detailed calculations , that the image appears brighter near the edge and dimmer near the center , creating a ring near the outer edge . at a given observed time , the contrast between the edge and the center of the image is larger and the width of the ring is smaller at high frequencies , while at low frequencies the contrast is smaller and the width of the ring is larger . we consider a system that is moving relativistically while emitting radiation . we obtain a formula for the flux that is measured by a distant detector ( i.e. @xmath1 where d is the distance to the detector , and l is the size of the area emitting radiation ) . we use a spherical coordinate system and place the origin within the emitting region ( i.e. at the source ) , while the z - axis points towards the detector ( see figure [ fig1 ] ) . the detector is at rest in this frame , and so is the ambient ism . we refer to this frame as the observer frame . consider a small volume element @xmath2 ( where @xmath3 ) and let @xmath4 be the energy per unit time per unit volume per unit frequency per unit solid angle , emitted by the matter within this volume in it s local frame ( note that generally @xmath5 depends on the direction @xmath6 as well as on the frequency , place and time ) . we denote quantities measured in the local rest frame of the matter with a prime , while quantities without a prime are measured in the observer frame . note that @xmath7 is lorentz invariant ( rybici & lightman 1979 ) and @xmath8 , where @xmath0 and @xmath9 are the lorentz factor and the velocity of the matter emitting the radiation , respectively , and @xmath10 is the cosine of the angle between the direction of the velocity of the matter and the direction to the detector , in the observer frame ) . the contribution to @xmath11 from this volume element is given by : @xmath12 ( see figure [ fig1 ] ) . the contribution to the flux at the detector is @xmath13 where @xmath6 is the solid angle seen from the detector , and @xmath14 includes all the contributions from different volume elements along the trajectory arriving at the detector from the direction @xmath6 simultaneously and at the time for which @xmath15 is calculated . consider a photon emitted at time @xmath16 and place @xmath17 in the observer frame . it will reach the detector at a time @xmath18 given by ; @xmath19 where @xmath20 was chosen as the time of arrival at the detector of a photon emitted at the origin at @xmath21 . using @xmath22 , we obtain : @xmath23 where @xmath24 , and later @xmath25 . @xmath26 is taken in the direction @xmath27 at which a photon should be emitted in order to reach the detector , and @xmath28 should be taken at the time @xmath16 implied by equation [ time ] . the contribution of a volume element @xmath29 to the flux observed by a distant observer is @xmath30 , where @xmath31 . since the observer is far away , the direction of emission in the observer frame is almost parallel to the z - axis.,width=491 ] for a spherical expanding system , which emits isotropically in it s local rest frame , one obtains @xmath32 and @xmath33 , so that : @xmath34 note that because of relativistic effects , a jet with an opening angle @xmath35 around the los can be considered locally as spherical ( piran 1994 ) . in order to learn whether the radial integration is important , we calculate the observed flux from emission only along the los . we do this by considering a situation in which at each point the photons are emitted only radially : @xmath36 . note that the correct limit is obtained when the delta function in the direction of the emission is taken in the local frame . since @xmath37 ( rybici & lightman 1979 ) we obtain that : @xmath38 substituting this @xmath26 in equation [ flux j ] we obtain : @xmath39 equation [ prefaf ] is quite general , and includes integration over all space . in the case of grb afterglow , radiation is emitted only from the region behind the shock front . the spacial integration should therefore be taken over a finite volume , confined by the surface of the shock front . we would therefore like to obtain an explicit expression for the radius of the shock @xmath40 as a function of @xmath41 for a given arrival time @xmath18 . in the case of a shell moving with a constant velocity @xmath9 , one obtains from equation [ time ] : @xmath42 if one considers a constant arrival time @xmath18 , this equation describes an ellipsoid , which confines the volume constituting the locus of points from which photons reach the detector simultaneously ( rees 1966 ) . in grbs , most of the matter is concentrated in a thin shell which decelerates upon collision with the ambient medium . when the deceleration of the shell is accounted for , the ellipsoid is distorted . the details of this distortion depend on the evolution of the shock radius @xmath43 ( sari 1998 , panaitescu & mszros 1998 ) . in this paper we consider an adiabatic ultra - relativistic hydrodynamic solution , which implies @xmath44 , where @xmath45 is the lorentz factor of the shock . for this case , equation [ time ] yields : @xmath46 the shape of the volume constituting the locus of points from which photons reach the detector simultaneously resembles an elongated egg ( see figure [ fig2 ] ) , and will be simply referred to as the `` egg '' . the side facing the observer ( the right side in the figures ) will be referred to as the front of the `` egg '' , and the side closer to the origin ( the left side in the figures ) will be referred to as the back of the `` egg '' . we see here the egg - shaped region from which photons reach an observer at a given time @xmath18 . in all the figures of the `` egg '' the observer is located far to the right , and the symmetry axis is the los to the center of the grb . in order to reach the observer simultaneously , photons emitted at different locations should be emitted at different times in the observer frame , according to equation [ time ] . photons that are emitted simultaneously in the observer frame along the dashed - dotted line @xmath47 , reach the observer simultaneously . therefore @xmath47 represents an equal @xmath48 contour line . the location of the shock front at this time of emission is indicated by the solid line @xmath49 , and it s radius @xmath40 appears in the definitions of @xmath50 and @xmath51 . a photon emitted at point a , at a distance of @xmath52 behind the shock front and at a time @xmath53 ( both in the observer frame ) caches up with the shock front at point b , at a later time @xmath54 in the observer frame.,width=491 ] from hydrodynamic considerations , we expect the typical size of the region emitting radiation behind the shock , to scale as : @xmath55 in the observer frame . despite this fact , it is still important to consider the emission from the whole volume of the `` egg '' , whose limits are given by equation [ egg ] . to illustrate this we give a simple example . consider a photon emitted on the los at a distance @xmath56 behind the shock ( point a in figure [ fig2 ] ) at a time @xmath53 in the observer frame , where @xmath57 is the lorentz factor of the matter just behind the shock . this photon will catch up with the shock front at a later time @xmath54 in the observer frame ( at point b in figure [ fig2 ] ) , and will arrive at the detector together with a photon emitted at that point at @xmath54 . from equation [ egg ] we find that on the los : @xmath58 , and so we obtain that @xmath59 . this shows that the emission comes from a substantial part of the volume of the `` egg '' , and not just from a thin layer near it s surface . this is illustrated by the shaded region in figures [ fig5 ] and [ fig6 ] , which corresponds to a shell of width @xmath60 in the observer frame . at a given observed time @xmath18 , the emission should be considered from the volume of the `` egg '' whose surface is described by equation [ egg ] . taking this into account , it is simpler to calculate the flux at a given observed time @xmath18 , using new variables @xmath61 that depend on @xmath18 ( see figures [ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] ) : @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the radius of the shock front , @xmath64 is the lorentz factor of the matter just behind the shock and @xmath65 is the radius of the point on the shock front , on the los from which a photon reaches the detector at a time @xmath18 ( see figure [ fig2 ] ) . since we expect the typical size of the emitting region behind the shock , to scale as : @xmath66 , the choice of @xmath51 is natural to this problem . the exact form of @xmath51 was chosen to suit the bm solution , discussed below . using equation [ time ] we can express @xmath67 in terms of @xmath61 : @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the lorentz factor of the matter just behind the shock , on the los . equal-@xmath48 contour lines ( @xmath70 ) - vertical lines , and equal-@xmath51 contour lines ( @xmath71 ) - curved lines . the horizontal line is the los to the observer , which is located far to the right.,width=340 ] we would like to express equation [ prefaf ] in terms of @xmath61 . this will enable us to calculate the flux for the bm solution . this solution describes an adiabatic highly relativistic blast wave expanding into an ambient uniform and cold medium ( blandford & mckee 1976 ) . in terms of @xmath48 and @xmath51 the bm solution is given by : @xmath72 where @xmath73 and @xmath74 are the number density and the energy density in the local frame , respectively , @xmath0 is the lorentz factor of the bulk motion of the matter behind the shock , @xmath75 is the mass of a proton , @xmath76 is the number density of the unshocked ambient ism in it s local rest frame and @xmath77 . for the bm solution , one obtains ( sari 1997 ) : @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the total energy of the shell in units of @xmath80 , @xmath76 is the number density of the ism in units of @xmath81 and @xmath82 is the observed time in days . for any spherically symmetric self similar solution we can define @xmath83 by : @xmath84 , where @xmath83 describes how @xmath0 varies with the radial profile . for the bm solution @xmath85 , and for a uniform shell @xmath86 . using the definitions above , we obtain from equation [ prefaf ] after the change of variables : @xmath87 ^ 2 g(\chi ) } } \ .\ ] ] this formula for the flux takes into consideration the contribution from the whole volume behind the shock front , and will be referred to as the general formula . we would like to single out the angular integration and the radial integration , in order to find out the different effects each integration has on the observed flux . in order to single out the effect of the angular integration we consider a thin shell of thickness @xmath88 in the observer frame and take the limit @xmath89 . because of kinematical spreading we expect @xmath88 to scale as : @xmath90 . according to the definition of @xmath51 , such a shell corresponds to a constant interval in @xmath51 , i.e. the shell lies within the interval @xmath91 $ ] for some @xmath92 . the limit @xmath89 corresponds to taking a delta function in @xmath51 : @xmath93 . in order to single out the effect of the radial integration , we changed variables in equation [ prelos ] from @xmath94 to @xmath51 . for the bm solution we obtain : @xmath95 according to the fireball model , a highly relativistic shell moves outward and is decelerated upon collision with the ambient ism . this creates a relativistic blast wave that expands through the ism and heats up the matter that passes through it . the relativistic electrons of the heated material emit synchrotron radiation in the presence of a magnetic field . we now consider the synchrotron emission at a certain point , in which the values of @xmath96 and @xmath74 are given by the hydrodynamic solution . in order to estimate the local emissivity , we assume that the energy of the electrons and of the magnetic field at each point are a fixed fraction of the total internal energy at that point : @xmath97 , @xmath98 . we assume that the shock produces a power law electron distribution : @xmath99 for @xmath100 ( for the energy of the electrons to remain finite we must have @xmath101 ) . in the figures for which a definite numerical value of @xmath102 is needed , we use @xmath103 . the constants @xmath104 and @xmath105 in the electron distribution can be calculated from the number density and energy density : @xmath106 assuming an isotropic velocity distribution , the total emitted power of a single average electron ( i.e. with @xmath107 ) is given by : @xmath108 ( rybici & lightman 1979 ) , where @xmath109 is the thomson cross section and @xmath110 , where @xmath111 is the magnetic field ( in the local frame ) . although we refer to the magnetic field in the local frame , throughout the paper , we make an exception and write it without a prime . the synchrotron emission function ( power per unit frequency ) of a single electron is characterized by @xmath112 for frequencies much smaller than the electrons synchrotron frequency , and it drops exponentially at large frequencies . the typical synchrotron frequency , averaged over an isotropic distribution of electron velocities , is given by : @xmath113 where @xmath114 and @xmath115 are the mass and the electric charge of the electron , respectively . we approximate the emission of a single electron as @xmath112 up to the electrons typical synchrotron frequency , where we place a cutoff in the emitted power . we normalized the emission function so that the total power emitted by a single electron equals that of an exact synchrotron emission . the local emissivity from a power law distribution of electrons , emitting synchrotron radiation . the solid curve represents exact synchrotron emission with an isotropic electron velocity distribution , while the dashed curve represents the approximation we used for the local emissivity . the differences in the local emissivity tend to smear out when integration is performed over the whole volume behind the shock front.,width=340 ] under these assumptions , we obtain after integration over the power law electron distribution , that the spectral power per unit volume ( in the local frame ) at any given point is : @xmath116 where @xmath117 is the synchrotron frequency of an electron with the minimal lorenz factor at that point . since the emitted power at each point peaks at @xmath118 , this frequency can be looked upon as the typical emitted frequency around which the emitted power is concentrated . although this emission function was obtained by approximating the spectral emission of each electron as having the shape of the low frequency tail ( @xmath119 ) , the spectral power for the whole electron distribution resembles that obtained for an exact synchrotron emission and an isotropic electron velocity distribution . the solid curve in figure [ fig17 ] represents the local emissivity from an exact synchrotron emission of an isotropic distribution of electrons ( rybici & lightman 1979 , wijers & galama 1998 ) , while the dashed curve represents equation [ emission function ] with : @xmath120 where a factor of @xmath121 was added to improve the fit to the exact synchrotron emission . in our calculations we use the local emission represented by the dashed line in figure [ fig17 ] . this local emission differs from that of an exact synchrotron emission near the peak , by up to @xmath122 , and is only slightly different above or below the peak . note that differences in the local emissivity tend to get smeared out , when the contribution to the observed flux is integrated over the whole volume behind the shock front . we expect that considering exact synchrotron emission should somewhat lower the peak flux and the peak frequency , and make the light curve and spectra more rounded and flat near the peak . we evaluate that the peak flux would be lower by about @xmath123 . since there are only slight differences in high and low frequencies , there should hardly be any effect on the value of the point where the extrapolations of the power laws at high and low frequencies meet ( see table 1 ) . in this section we use the bm hydrodynamical solution . the combination of the realistic emission function described above , and a realistic hydrodynamical solution should yield a reasonable approximation for the observed flux . the results are presented as a function of the dimensionless similarity variable @xmath124 , where @xmath125 is defined as the observed synchrotron frequency of an electron with @xmath126 just behind the shock on the los : @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the cosmological red shift of the grb . our results can therefore be looked upon , with the proper scaling of the logarithmic x - axis , either as the spectra at a given observed time or as the light curve at a fixed observed frequency . similarly , we express the observed flux in terms of a `` standard '' flux @xmath129 defined by : @xmath130 where @xmath131 and @xmath132 are the total power and synchrotron frequency of an average electron at @xmath133 , respectively , @xmath134 is an estimate of the peak spectral power of an average electron , and @xmath135 is the total number of electrons behind the shock at the time @xmath16 in the observer frame for which @xmath136 . allowing for cosmological corrections , @xmath129 is given by : @xmath137 where @xmath138 is the luminosity distance of the grb . the observed flux from synchrotron emission of a power law electron distribution for the bm solution . the different curves stand for emission only along the los , emission from an infinitely thin shell , and emission from the whole volume behind the shock . the emission from the whole volume is very similar to that obtained for an infinitely thin shell , due to a coincidence that rises from our choice for the magnetic field model ( see section [ difb]).,width=377 ] the results for the observed flux are presented in figure [ fig8 ] . the flux arriving from the los ( the dashed curve ) peaks at @xmath139 , and is only slightly rounded near the peak . the flux arriving from an infinitely thin shell ( the dotted curve ) peaks at @xmath140 and is quite rounded and flat near the peak . the flux arriving from the whole volume behind the shock front ( the solid curve ) peaks at @xmath141 and is flat and rounded near the peak , quite resembling the flux from an infinitely thin shell . our best prediction for the flux measured by a distant detector is obtained when we assume a realistic hydrodynamical solution ( the bm solution ) , a realistic radiation emission and use the general formula ( see the solid curve in figure [ fig8 ] ) . we would now like to examine it more closely . the curve looks quite flat near the peak , and we attempt to demonstrate this feature in a quantitative manner . if one compares the peak flux obtained by extrapolation of the power laws , obtained at low and high frequencies , to the `` actual '' peak flux , one obtains that it is larger by a factor of @xmath142 : @xmath143 . in order to further estimate the flatness of the curve near the peak , we define @xmath144 and @xmath145 by @xmath146 , where @xmath147 . we obtain that @xmath148 and @xmath149 , so that @xmath150 . in a similar manner , we define @xmath151 and @xmath152 for a given observed frequency , by @xmath153 , where @xmath154 . one obtains : @xmath155 ( note that @xmath151 and @xmath152 are frequency independent ) . the frequency at which the observed flux peaks at a given observed time @xmath18 is given by : @xmath156 the main dependence on @xmath102 lies in the factor @xmath157 , but there is also a weak dependence of @xmath158 on @xmath102 . the value given here for @xmath158 is for @xmath103 , and it decreases with increasing @xmath102 ( it is higher by @xmath159 for @xmath160 , and lower by @xmath161 for @xmath162 ) . the maximal flux is given by : @xmath163 here there is a much weaker dependence on @xmath102 . the value stated here is for @xmath103 , and it is smaller by @xmath164 for @xmath160 and larger by @xmath165 for @xmath162 . these results can be best understood by looking at the `` egg '' that constitutes the locus of points from which photons reach the detector simultaneously , and mapping upon it the typical emitted frequency in the observer frame . figure [ fig5 ] depicts the lines of equal @xmath166 . from the electron distribution we obtain that @xmath167 and therefore : @xmath168 . for this reason , the frequency contour lines that are depicted in figure [ fig5 ] also represent equal @xmath169 lines . equal observed synchrotron frequency contour lines , at a given observed time , for the bm solution . each line represents a different value of @xmath170 . the bold contour line is @xmath171 . the lines are separated by a constant logarithmic interval in @xmath170 : @xmath172 ( the inner contour lines , which cross the los , represent @xmath173 ) . the shaded region represents a finite shell of thickness @xmath174 in the observer frame . , width=377 ] there are two opposing factors that determine the shape of the observed synchrotron frequency contour lines , that are depicted in figure [ fig5 ] . the shift from the local frame to the observer frame , @xmath175 , causes the frequency to decrease as one moves away from the los . however at earlier emission times , and at locations closer to the shock front , the typical synchrotron frequencies in the local frame are higher , and so is the lorentz factor of the matter . this tends to increase the observed frequencies of photons that were emitted earlier ( i.e. from the back of the `` egg '' ) and closer to the shock ( i.e. closer to the surface of the `` egg '' ) . the result of these two opposing effects , for the bm solution , is that as one goes backwards along the los , to earlier emission times , the observed synchrotron frequency for a constant observed time is almost independent of @xmath51 : @xmath176 . this explains the result for the flux arriving from the los ( the dashed curve in figure [ fig8 ] ) , namely that the peak flux is obtained at a frequency just slightly lower than @xmath125 : @xmath177 , and the light curve is only slightly rounded near the peak . the fact that @xmath178 along the los accounts for the fact that the peak flux is obtained at @xmath179 . the fact that the decrease in @xmath169 as one goes back along the los is very moderate , means that in order for the emitted radiation to be concentrated around a frequency substantially lower than @xmath125 , one has to go very deep in the radial profile along the los to @xmath180 . this implies that one gets far from the shock front ( to @xmath181 ) , and therefore the contribution obtained to the total flux is small . for this reason @xmath158 is very close to 1 . the observed flux from an infinitely thin shell peaks at @xmath182 , and the light curve ( or spectra ) is quite rounded and flat near the peak ( see the dotted line in figure [ fig8 ] ) . this result can be understood by following the surface of the `` egg '' ( see figure [ fig5 ] ) . @xmath169 increases as one goes to the back of the `` egg '' ( i.e. to earlier emission times ) along it s surface , and it does so much faster than it decreases when one goes back along the los . therefore one gets a substantial contribution to the flux at @xmath183 , before one gets too far back in the shell , where the total contribution to the flux drops considerably . this explains why the peak flux for an infinitely thin shell is obtained at a frequency significantly higher than @xmath125 , whereas for the los it is obtained at a frequency only slightly lower than @xmath125 . the contribution to the observed flux as a function of @xmath184 , for an infinitely thin shell . the different curves stand for @xmath185 and @xmath186 . for @xmath173 the contribution peaks at the los ( @xmath187 ) , and for @xmath183 the contribution peaks at a lower value of @xmath48 as @xmath170 increases.,width=491 ] the contribution to the flux from an infinitely thin shell , as a function of the radius of the shell , for different values of @xmath170 is shown in figure [ fig9 ] . the different curves can be looked upon as representing either different observed frequencies at the same observed time , or the same observed frequency at different observed times . one can see that for @xmath173 the contribution to the flux peaks at @xmath187 ( the los ) , while for @xmath183 it peaks at smaller values of @xmath48 . one can obtain the average radius contributing to a given @xmath170 in the following way : @xmath188 @xmath189 is shown in figure [ fig10 ] . for @xmath173 one obtains that @xmath190 is constant : @xmath191 , while for @xmath183 there is a decrease in @xmath190 until for @xmath192 it reaches the limiting value : @xmath193 . the same infinitely thin shell approximation was considered by panaitescu & mszros ( 1998 ) and by sari ( 1998 ) . the values quoted by panaitescu & mszros for @xmath190 in the two limits of high and low frequencies are probably erroneous , and they are not consistent with the value they quote for the bolometric @xmath190 ( this inconsistency occurs only for the case we consider in this paper , of an adiabatic evolution of the shell , and neglecting electron cooling ) . the values obtained by sari are slightly different than ours , since he considered emission from a shell consisting of a given element of matter . the average normalized radius @xmath190 contributing to the observed flux at a given @xmath170 , for an infinitely thin shell . @xmath194 for @xmath173 , and it decreases as @xmath170 increases above @xmath171 , until it reaches the limiting value of @xmath195 for large @xmath170 , at around @xmath196.,width=302 ] although the hydrodynamic profile is given by the bm solution , the structure and profile of the magnetic field are less clear . so far we have assumed that everywhere the magnetic field energy is a fixed fraction of the internal energy : @xmath197 since not much is known about the origin or spacial dependence of the magnetic field , we consider now two alternative models for the magnetic field . this can serve , in a way , as a test for the generality of our results , and it will expose any hidden fine tuning caused due to our previous magnetic field model , if one existed . we assume that each matter element acquires a magnetic field according to equation [ equipartition ] when it passes the shock . the two alternative models are obtained by assuming that the magnetic field is either radial or tangential , and evolves according to the `` frozen field '' approximation . consider a small matter element , which passes the shock at a time @xmath53 in the observer frame . just after it passes the shock it possesses a magnetic field @xmath198 ( in the local frame ) given by equation [ equipartition ] . we consider a cubic volume @xmath199 ( in the local frame ) with one face perpendicular to the radial direction . according to the bm solution , at a later time @xmath16 this matter element will be at @xmath200 , and it will occupy a box of a size @xmath201 in the radial direction , and a size @xmath202 in the two tangential directions ( @xmath203 and @xmath204 ) . one also obtains that @xmath205 , where @xmath206 is the magnetic field at the front of the radial profile , just behind the shock , at the time @xmath16 . we consider two possibilities for the direction of the magnetic field at @xmath53 : a radial and a tangential magnetic field , @xmath207 and @xmath208 . our previous `` equipartition '' model will be denoted simply by @xmath111 . in both new cases the `` frozen field '' approximation implies that the magnetic field will remain in the same direction , while it s magnitude changes in the following way : @xmath209 the observed flux for three different magnetic field models . @xmath210 on the shock front , while behind the shock front @xmath211.,width=415 ] * table 1 + * features of the light curve and spectra for + different models for the magnetic field . * * .@xmath158 , @xmath212 , @xmath129 , @xmath213 , @xmath145 , @xmath144 , @xmath152 and @xmath151 are all defined in the text . the last two columns refer to the point where the extrapolations of the power laws at high and low @xmath170 meet . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] + the observed surface brightness as a function of @xmath214 , for different values of @xmath170 . the surface brightness peaks near the outer edge of the image , drops sharply towards the edge ( @xmath215 ) and decreases more gradually towards the center . the normalization preserves the correct ratio between the absolute surface brightness , for the different values of @xmath170 , which decreases both for low and for high values of @xmath170.,width=491 ] we calculated the surface brightness for several values of @xmath170 , and as before , the different images can be viewed as either the observed images at a given observed time at different observed frequencies , or as the observed images at a given frequency at different observed times . the observed images are quite similar for the different magnetic field models we considered , and therefore we present detailed results only for @xmath111 ( figures [ fig12 ] and [ fig13 ] ) , and summarize the features of the images obtained for @xmath207 , @xmath111 and @xmath208 in table 2 . the observed image is bright near the edge and dimmer at the center . at high values of @xmath170 ( high frequencies or late observed times ) the surface brightness at the center is only a few percent of the maximal surface brightness , which is obtained near the edge ( @xmath216 ) , and a bright ring is clearly seen with a sharp edge on the outer side and a more gradual decrease in the surface brightness towards the center . at @xmath173 ( low frequencies or early observed times ) the surface brightness at the center is around @xmath217 of the maximal surface brightness , and though the image is brighter near the edge , the center should be visible as well ( see the left image in figure [ fig12 ] ) . the transition in the distribution of the relative surface brightness along the observed image , between the limiting cases of small and large @xmath170 , occurs over one order of magnitude in @xmath170 : @xmath218 . the relative surface brightness hardly changes beyond this region ( though the absolute surface brightness drops both for low and for high values of @xmath170 , due to the drop in the observed flux ) . the fact that at a given observed time , the relative surface brightness at the center of the image is smaller for high frequencies than it is for low frequencies , may be intuitively understood : for high frequencies the emittance decays in time , and is therefore lower at large radii , which correspond to small values of @xmath219 , which are located at the center of the image . we have derived a formula for the observed flux from a relativistically moving system . using this formula , we considered the emission from the whole volume behind a spherical relativistic blast wave , expanding into a cold uniform medium . we have considered an adiabatic evolution and used the self similar hydrodynamical solution of blandford & mckee ( 1976 ) to describe the matter behind the shock . we have considered synchrotron emission from a power law distribution of electrons , using a realistic local emissivity , which depends on the local hydrodynamic parameters . we have obtained expressions for the frequency at which the observed flux peaks at a given observed time , and for the value of the peak flux ( equations [ ni peak ] and [ fmax ] ) . the value we obtained for the peak frequency at a given observed time is a factor of @xmath220 smaller than the value obtained by sari , piran & narayan ( 1998 ) , a factor of @xmath221 ( for @xmath103 ) smaller than the value obtained by wijers & galama ( 1998 ) , and a factor of @xmath222 ( for @xmath103 ) smaller than the value obtained by waxman ( 1997b ) . the large difference from the result obtained by waxman is partly due to the fact that he took the peak frequency to be at the synchrotron frequency of an average electron @xmath223 , while the peak frequency is actually obtained much closer to @xmath224 , i.e. the synchrotron frequency of an electron with the minimal lorentz factor . the value we obtained for the peak flux is a factor of @xmath225 ( for @xmath103 ) smaller than the value obtained by wijers & galama ( 1998 ) , a factor of @xmath226 larger than the value obtained by waxman ( 1997b ) , and a factor of @xmath227 smaller than the value obtained by sari , piran & narayan ( 1998 ) . we have shown that both the light curve and the spectra are flat near the peak . the flux at a given observed time drops to half it s maximal value at around one order of magnitude from the peak frequency , on either side . the flux at a given observed frequency drops to half it s maximal value at about a factor of @xmath228 before and after the time of the peak flux . this result was obtained for all the magnetic field models we considered , and it therefore seems to be of quite a general nature . our calculations were made using an approximation for the local emissivity that is obtained from an exact synchrotron emission . we expect that without this approximation the values of the peak flux and the peak frequency should be somewhat lower , and the light curve and the spectra should be even more rounded and flat near the peak . we estimated that these effects should be small . in contrast to the flatness of the peak , discussed above , grb970508 displayed a sharp rise in the optical flux , immediately followed by a power law decay ( sokolov et . sari , piran & narayan ( 1998 ) considered both radiative and adiabatic evolution of the blast wave , and found that the steepest rise in the flux occurs before the peak , for an adiabatic evolution and slow cooling of the electrons , which is the case discussed in this paper . this steepest rise is @xmath229 , and as we have shown in this paper , the rise in the flux decreases as the peak is approached , and the peak itself is quite flat . we obtained @xmath230 , which indicates a flat peak , while grb970508 displayed @xmath231 . this rules out the interpretation of the optical peak of grb970508 as the peak of the light curve , predicted by the existing fireball models . it therefore appears that another explanation is needed . we have considered a locally monochromatic emission , at the typical synchrotron frequency , obtained from the relevant hydrodynamic parameters . we have shown that when this emission is applied to the bm solution , the observed flux peaks at the observed emission frequency of the matter just behind the shock , on the los ( @xmath232 ) . there is a sharp drop in the flux below this frequency , and a gradual decrease above it . when this emission is applied to a uniform shell ( waxman 1997b ) the results change drastically . in particular the location of the peak flux depends critically on the width of the shell @xmath233 ( see equation [ peak flux ] ) , which is chosen quite arbitrarily . the image of a grb afterglow looks like a ring , even when emission is considered from the whole volume behind the shock front . similar results were obtained for more simplified models ( waxman 1997b , sari 1998 , panaitescu & mszros 1998 ) . the image is bright near the edge and dimmer at the center . the contrast in the surface brightness between the center and the edge of the image is larger for high frequencies ( optical and x - ray ) and the ring is narrower , while for low frequencies ( as long as self absorption is not significant ) the contrast is smaller and the ring is wider . radio wave - bands can be considered as `` low frequencies '' for the first few months . the best available resolution is obtained in radio frequencies , and the afterglow of a future nearby grb ( @xmath234 ) might be resolved . this theory predicts that in early times , when @xmath235 the image should appear as a relatively wide ring with a relatively small contrast , while for later times where @xmath236 ( as long as the relativistic regime is not exceeded ) the image should appear as a narrow ring and posses a large contrast . the observed image has been calculated , considering emission only from the surface of the shock front ( sari 1998 ) . this yielded a surface brightness diverging at @xmath237 . this divergence is an artifact of the assumption that the radiation is emitted from a two dimensional surface . other features of the image , such as the difference between high and low frequencies , are quite similar in the more simplified analysis . 99 blandford , r. d. & mckee , c. f. 1976 , phys . of fluids,*19 katz , j. & piran , t. 1997 , apj , * 490 * , 772 . mszros , p. & rees , m. 1997 , apj , * 476 * , 232 . panaitescu , a. & mszros , p. 1998 , apj , * 493 * , l31 . piran , t. 1994 , in aip conference proceedings 307 , gamma - ray bursts , second workshop , huntsville , alabama , 1993 , eds . g. j. fishman , j. j. brainerd , & k. hurley ( new york : aip ) , p. 495 . rybici , g.b . & lightman , a.p . 1979 , _ radiative processes in astrophysics _ , wiley - interscience , chap . vi rees , m. 1966 , nature , * 211 * , 468 . sari , r. 1997 , apj , * 489 * , l37 . sari , r. 1998 , apj , * 494 * , l49 sari , r. , piran , t. & narayan , r. 1998 , apj , * 497 * , l17 . sokolov et . 1997 , astro - ph/9706141 . waxman , e. 1997a , apj , * 485 * , l5 . waxman , e. 1997b , apj , * 489 * , l33 . waxman , e. 1997c , apj , * 491 * , l19 . wijers , r.a.m.j . & galama , t.j . 1998 , astro - ph/9805341 .

the detection of an afterglow , following a @xmath0-ray burst ( grb ) , can be described reasonably well by synchrotron emission from a relativistic spherical expanding blast wave , driven by an expanding fireball . we perform detailed calculations considering the emission from the whole region behind the shock front . we use the blandford mckee self similar adiabatic solution to describe the fluid behind the shock . using this detailed model , we derive expressions for the peak flux , and the peak frequency at a given observed time . these expressions provide important numerical corrections to previous , more simplified models . we calculate the observed light curve and spectra for several magnetic field models . we show that both the light curve and the spectra are flat near the peak . this rules out the interpretation of the optical peak of grb970508 as the peak of the light curve , predicted by the existing fireball models . we calculate the observed image of a grb afterglow . the observed image is bright near the edge and dimmer at the center , thus creating a ring . the contrast between the edge and the center is larger at high frequencies and the width of the ring is smaller .

hep-ph0005228

in this article we study heat diffusion via neutrinos in dense , color superconducting quark matter . recent theoretical works @xcite suggest that quarks form cooper pairs in medium , a natural consequence of attractive interactions destabilizing the fermi surface . this would likely affect the early evolution of neutron stars born through a type ii supernova explosion , where the central role of neutrino diffusion through a strongly - interacting medium has long been postulated on theoretical grounds @xcite . type ii ( core collapse ) supernovae are triggered by the implosion of the inner core of a massive star ( m@xmath1 @xmath2 m@xmath3 ) , when the core mass is on the order of the chandrashekar mass ( m@xmath4 @xmath5 m@xmath3 ) . during the implosion nearly all ( @xmath6% ) of the enormous gravitational binding energy ( @xmath7 ergs ) gained is stored as internal energy of the newly born , proto - neutron star ( pns ) . the subsequent evolution of the proto - neutron star is driven by neutrino diffusion . temporal and spectral characteristics of the neutrino emission depend on the rate at which neutrinos diffuse through the imploded pns which , at this early stage , is composed of hot ( @xmath8 mev ) and dense ( @xmath9 where @xmath10 @xmath11 ) strongly - interacting matter . neutrino emission during this phase is a directly observable feature of a galactic supernova explosion . the few neutrinos detected from sn 1987a indicate that neutrinos of mean energy @xmath12 mev are emitted on a diffusion time scale of about @xmath13 seconds . it is reasonable to expect that neutrino mean free path in the inner , denser regions of the star will strongly influence the temporal characteristics of a supernova neutrino signal . supernova neutrinos can therefore reveal properties of matter at high baryon density , at temperatures substantially lower than those expected in relativistic heavy ion collisions . although the idea of quark pairing in dense matter is not a new one @xcite , it has recently seen renewed interest in the context of the phase diagram of qcd @xcite . model calculations , mostly based on four - quark effective interactions , predict the restoration of spontaneously broken chiral symmetry through the onset of color superconductivity at low temperatures @xcite . for much higher densities color superconductivity is manifest through perturbative gluon exchange @xcite , which can be calculated systematically suggests that the phenomenon is robust . for densities and temperatures relevant to neutron stars , quark matter is therefore expected to be superconducting . models generally predict an energy gap of @xmath14 mev for a typical quark chemical potential of @xmath15 mev . as in bcs theory , the gap will weaken for @xmath16 and at some @xmath17 there is a ( second - order ) transition to a `` standard '' quark - gluon plasma . thus , when cooling from temperatures greater than critical , the formation of a such a gap in the fermionic excitation spectrum in quark matter at high density will influence various neutron star observables if neutron stars contain quark matter in their cores at early time . two examples recently investigated are the effects on magnetic fields @xcite and on the thermal evolution of neutron stars at late time @xcite , when interior temperatures evolve from @xmath18 mev to @xmath19 kev . in this work we shall consider the cooling of quark matter at earlier times , when temperatures pass through the critical @xmath20 . assuming a simplified scenario , we investigate the thermal evolution of the inner core of a proto - neutron star as it cools via neutrino diffusion during its first few seconds . our main finding is that the neutrino mean free path in the superconducting phase has a strong dependence on temperature . an energy gap tends to increase the neutrino mean free paths exponentially when @xmath21 . however in the intermediate regime , when @xmath22 , the temperature dependence is not exponential . from this we predict a uniquely uneven cooling process for simplified pns matter , marked by a slowdown of the cooling rate when the system undergoes a second - order phase transition . this is a consequence of the specific heat being peaked at @xmath0 , a standard characteristic of a phase transition , rather than a large change in the neutrino mean free path . since the energy gap vanishes at this point , the mean free path is _ not _ significantly modified in the neighborhood of @xmath0 . in section ii the neutrino mean free path , always denoted @xmath23 in this work , is computed in a background of superconducting quarks . taking a general , bcs - type model for the energy gap , we relate @xmath23 to in - medium quark polarizations via the differential and total neutrino - quark cross sections . explicit formulae are derived for the imaginary parts of the vector and axial - vector polarizations of a relativistic fermi system with an energy gap . after assuming bcs - type mean field behavior of the gap and the specific heat , in section iii we compute a characteristic time for heat diffusion via neutrino emission from a simple model of superconducting quark matter . we then consider some astrophysical consequences and outline the model s applicability to proto - neutron stars . section iv contains our conclusions . the primary process by which heat escapes a proto - neutron star is neutrino diffusion , and so a significant consequence of color superconductivity in this context will be modified neutrino propagation . while noting that the neutrino production rate will also differ from that of normal matter , in the diffusive regime one can see that the dominant critical behavior will be a change in the _ inelastic _ quark - neutrino cross section , since here neutrino production rates decouple from the transport equation and depend only on the neutrino mean free path . in this section we calculate the differential and total cross sections and then compute the neutrino mean free path in two - flavor quark matter . the magnitude of the superconducting gap , @xmath24 , is taken as arbitrary within a range of values found in recent literature . closely following bcs theory , we assume the gap to be a constant , and calculate the response functions and neutrino cross sections in the weak coupling approximation . the neutral current coupling between neutrinos and quarks , a four - fermion effective interaction for energies @xmath25 , is written as @xmath26 where @xmath27 gev@xmath28 is the fermi weak coupling constant and @xmath29 and @xmath30 are the flavor - specific vector and axial vector coupling constants , respectively . the differential neutrino scattering cross section per unit volume in an infinite and homogeneous system of fermions as calculated in linear response theory is @xcite @xmath31}{\left[1-\exp{\left(-q_0/t\right)}\right ] } ~{\rm im}~(l^{\alpha\beta}\pi_{\alpha\beta } ) \ , , \label{dcross}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath32 ( @xmath33 ) is the incoming ( outgoing ) neutrino energy . the factor @xmath34^{-1}$ ] maintains detailed balance and the final state blocking of the outgoing neutrino is enforced by the pauli blocking factor , @xmath35 $ ] . the neutrino tensor @xmath36 is given by @xmath37 \,,\ ] ] where the incoming four - momentum is @xmath38 and the momentum transferred to the medium is @xmath39 . the minus ( plus ) sign on the final term applies to neutrino ( anti - neutrino ) scattering . the medium is characterized by the quark polarization tensor @xmath40 . in the case of free quarks , each flavor contributes a term of the form @xmath41 \ , , \label{pi_free}\ ] ] where @xmath42 is the free quark propagator at finite chemical potential and temperature . the outer trace is over color and simplifies to a @xmath43 degeneracy . the inner trace is over spin , and the @xmath44 are the neutrino - quark vertex functions which determine the spin channel . specifically , the vector polarization is computed by choosing @xmath45 . the axial and mixed vector - axial polarizations are similarly obtained from @xmath46 and @xmath47 , respectively . the free quark propagators in eq . ( [ pi_free ] ) are naturally modified in a superconducting medium . as first pointed out by bardeen , cooper , and schrieffer several decades ago , the quasi - particle dispersion relation is modified due to the presence of a gap in the excitation spectrum . in calculating these effects , we will consider the simplified case of qcd with two quark flavors which obey su(2)@xmath48 su(2)@xmath49 flavor symmetry , given that the light @xmath50 and @xmath51 quarks dominate low - energy phenomena . furthermore we will assume that , through some unspecified effective interactions , quarks pair in a manner analogous to the bcs mechanism @xcite . the relevant consequences of this are the restoration of chiral symmetry ( hence all quarks are approximately massless ) and the existence of an energy gap at zero temperature , @xmath52 , with approximate temperature dependence , @xmath53 the critical temperature @xmath54 is likewise taken from bcs theory ; this relation has been shown to hold for perturbative qcd @xcite and is thus a reasonable assumption for non - perturbative physics . breaking the su@xmath55(3 ) color group leads to complications not found in electrodynamics . in qcd the superconducting gap is equivalent to a diquark condensate , which can at most involve two of the three fundamental quark colors . the condensate must therefore be colored . since the scalar diquark ( in the @xmath56 color representation ) appears to always be the most attractive channel , we consider the anomalous ( or gorkov ) propagator @xcite @xmath57 here , @xmath58 are color indices , @xmath59 are flavor indices , @xmath60 is the usual anti - symmetric tensor and we have conventionally chosen 3 to be the condensate color . this propagator is also antisymmetric in flavor and spin , with @xmath61 being the charge conjugation operator . the color bias of the condensate forces a splitting of the normal quark propagator into colors transverse and parallel to the diquark . quarks of color 3 , parallel to the condensate in color space , will be unaffected and propagate freely , with @xmath62 this is written in terms of the particle and anti - particle projection operators @xmath63 and @xmath64 respectively , where @xmath65 . the excitation energies are simply @xmath66 for quarks and @xmath67 for anti - quarks . on the other hand , transverse quark colors 1 and 2 participate in the diquark and thus their quasi - particle propagators are given as @xmath68 the quasi - particle energy is @xmath69 , and for the anti - particle @xmath70 . the appearance of an anomalous propagator in the superconducting phase indicates that the polarization tensor gets contributions from both the normal quasi - particle propagators ( [ s_bcs ] ) and anomalous propagator ( [ a_bcs ] ) . thus , to order @xmath71 , eq . ( [ pi_free ] ) is replaced with the two contributions corresponding to the diagrams shown in fig . [ pol_fig ] , and written @xmath72 + 2 { \rm tr}~[s(p)\gamma_{\alpha } s(p+q)\gamma_{\beta } ] + 2 { \rm tr}~[f(p)\gamma_{\alpha } \bar{f}(p+q)\gamma_{\beta } ] \right\ } \ , . \label{pi_bcs}\ ] ] the remaining trace is over spin , as the color trace has been performed . [ pol_fig](a ) corresponds to the first two terms , which have been decomposed into one term with ungapped propagators ( [ s_0 ] ) and the other with gapped quasi - particle propagators ( [ s_bcs ] ) . fig . [ pol_fig](b ) represents the third , anomalous term . for neutrino scattering we must consider vector , axial , and mixed vector - axial channels , all summed over flavors . the full polarization , to be used in evaluating eq . ( [ dcross ] ) , may be written @xmath73\ , . \label{polsum}\ ] ] the coupling constants for up quarks are @xmath74 and @xmath75 , and for down quarks , @xmath76 and @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the weinberg angle . if we specify a frame in which the transfer momentum is @xmath79 we can separate longitudinal components as @xmath80 and the transverse , @xmath81 identical definitions apply to the axial polarizations @xmath82 and @xmath83 . the non - zero mixed correlation function is written @xmath84 detailed calculations of these polarization functions are given in the appendix . as the gap increases , the superconducting quasi - particles naturally become the dominant excitations of the background , a property clearly visible in the neutrino response functions . the left panel of fig . [ pizz ] shows the longitudinal response in the vector channel . the free quark case , shown as a solid line labeled @xmath85 , is the standard result describing pauli - blocking and kinematics of massless single particle excitations @xcite . here , energy - momentum conservation restricts the response to the spacelike region ( @xmath86 ) . superconductivity modifies this result , as the quasi - quark excitations become suppressed due to the pairing correlations at the fermi surface . at the same time , the response is enhanced when @xmath87 , signifying the excitation of cooper pairs . in particular , the results with greater @xmath24 clearly show the threshold for these excitations at energy transfer @xmath88 . results for @xmath89 and @xmath90 mev show the gradual reallocation of response strength from small @xmath91 to the region @xmath92 . since scattering probes only the spacelike region , the @xmath93 contribution to the cross section is generically _ suppressed _ in the superconducting phase . contributions at @xmath94 will contribute to the neutrino production rate , rather than scattering cross section , when the temperature is near @xmath24 . analytic results may be obtained for small transfer energies . when @xmath91 is much smaller than all other energy scales , the vector longitudinal response ( see eq . ( [ veclong ] ) of the appendix ) reduces to @xmath95 from this the weakening of the low energy , vector - longitudinal response can be calculated for a given gap @xmath24 . the axial - longitudinal response , which physically corresponds to the excitation of spin waves , is shown in the right panel of fig . [ pizz ] . as with the vector channel a threshold of @xmath96 is apparent but , unlike the previous case , the response as @xmath97 is _ enhanced_. this is manifest in the the limit @xmath98 , where one finds @xcite @xmath99 where in this limit @xmath100 . this logarithmic enhancement will lead to an integrable peak in the differential cross section at @xmath101 , as will be described below . the transverse response functions , @xmath102 and @xmath103 as defined in eq . ( [ trans_def ] ) , exhibit behavior similar to the longitudinal channels . the primary distinction is that superconductive coherence at low @xmath91 enhances the vector channel and suppresses the axial . in the former case the interference effects are constructive and in the latter case they are destructive @xcite , which is a reversal of the longitudinal results . this difference has been theoretically understood and experimentally observed in electric superconductors , where the absorption of acoustic waves ( vector - longitudinal ) is suppressed while the infra - red absorption ( vector - transverse ) is enhanced for small energy transfer @xcite . in addition to the vector and axial polarizations , the mixed vector - axial polarization ( [ va_def ] ) also contributes to the cross section . while this contribution is always much smaller by at least one order of magnitude we note that it is enhanced in the superconducting phase , leading to an amplified difference between neutrino and anti - neutrino cross sections in pns matter . once the polarization tensors have been computed it is straightforward to obtain the differential cross section , eq . ( [ dcross ] ) . results for neutrinos of energy @xmath104 mev , ambient matter conditions of @xmath105 mev and @xmath106 mev , and gaps of varied size are plotted as a function of transfer energy in fig . [ dsigma ] . a striking feature of these results is the singular behavior of the differential cross section near @xmath101 in superconducting matter . this is the ( integrable ) logarithmic divergence of @xmath107 and @xmath102 ( see ( eq . [ pitqo ] ) ) . the threshold behavior seen in differential cross section , for the case @xmath108 and @xmath109 mev , at @xmath110 and @xmath111 correspond to excitations of the cooper pairs . the total cross section ( per unit volume ) is obtained by integrating over all neutrino energy transfers and angles . from this the mean free path is determined , since @xmath112 as suggested by the differential cross section in fig . [ dsigma ] , the total cross section is reduced in the presence of a gap @xmath24 . the logarithmic peak at @xmath113 has a minimal effect after integration , when @xmath114 and when the neutrino energy @xmath115 since neutrino probe a significant part of the response outside of this @xmath113 region . results for the neutrino mean free path , @xmath23 , are shown in fig . [ lambda ] as a function of incoming neutrino energy @xmath116 ( ambient matter conditions of @xmath105 mev and @xmath106 mev have again been used ) . the same energy dependence has been computed previously in the case of free relativistic and degenerate fermionic matter @xcite ; it decreases as @xmath117 for @xmath118 , and @xmath119 at @xmath120 . the results indicate that this energy dependence is not modified by the presence of a gap when @xmath114 . thus the primary effect of the superconducting phase is a much larger mean free path . this is consistent with the suppression found in the vector - longitudinal response function , which dominates the sum polarization sum ( [ polsum ] ) , at @xmath86 . the immediate application of the last section s results is neutrino emission from a proto - neutron star containing quark matter . while we will fall far short of a complete description of the role of color superconductivity in such a complicated environment , in this section we will outline the key ingredients for estimating the possible physical observables . the first subsection describes a simple and general model for the cooling of quark matter through temperatures relevant to proto - neutron stars , and the second addresses the applicability of this scenario to more realistic situations . having determined the neutrino mean free path in a color superconductor , we now consider the cooling of a macroscopic sphere of quark matter as it becomes superconducting . as stated previously , this toy model is motivated by the possibility that the core of neutron star might contain such matter . following our preceding calculations , we will consider the relatively simple case of two massless flavors with identical chemical potentials . furthermore , we will disregard the quarks parallel in color to the condensate ; _ i.e. _ we consider a background comprised exclusively of quasi - quarks . the cooling of a spherical system of quark matter from @xmath121 mev is driven by neutrino diffusion , for the neutrino mean free path is much smaller than the dimensions of system of astrophysical size , and yet several orders of magnitude larger than the mean free path of the quarks . the diffusion equation for energy transport by neutrinos in a spherical geometry is @xmath122 where @xmath29 is the specific heat per unit volume of quark matter , @xmath123 is the temperature , and @xmath124 is the radius . the neutrino energy luminosity for each neutrino type , @xmath125 , depends on the neutrino mean free path and the spatial gradients in temperature and is approximated by @xmath126 where @xmath127 denotes the speed of light in vacuum . in our analysis we assume that neutrino interactions are dominated by the neutral current scattering common to all neutrino types . consequently , we take the same neutrino and anti - neutrino mean free path for every neutrino flavor , giving rise to the factor of six in eq . ( [ eflux ] ) . the equilibrium fermi distribution , @xmath128 , and the ( scattering ) mean free path , @xmath129 , are integrated over all neutrino energies , @xmath116 . the solution to the diffusion equation will depend on the size of the system and its initial temperature gradients . however , we are merely interested in a qualitative description of cooling through a second - order phase transition to superconducting matter . the temporal behavior is characterized by a time scale @xmath130 , which is proportional to the inverse cooling rate and can hence be deduced from eq . ( [ ediff ] ) . the characteristic time @xmath131 is a strong function of the function of the ambient matter temperature since it depends on the matter specific heat and the neutrino mean free path . this applies to a system characterized by the radial length @xmath132 and the energy - weighted average of the mean free path , @xmath133 . following our general treatment of the superconducting gap , we assume that the temperature dependence of the specific heat is described by bcs theory . we will then use the results obtained in the previous section to calculate @xmath134 . furthermore , since neutrinos are in thermal equilibrium for the temperatures of interest , we may assume @xmath135 the quantity on the left is dependent on the gap @xmath24 , a dependence computed in the previous section and plotted in the right panel of fig . [ lambda ] . the results indicate that for small @xmath136 the neutrino mean free path is not strongly modified , but as @xmath136 increases so too does @xmath23 , non - linearly at first and then exponentially for @xmath137 . we note that the diffusion approximation is only valid when @xmath138 and will thus fail for very low temperatures , when @xmath139 . the ratio @xmath140 , a measure of the extent to which the cooling rate is changed by a gap , is shown by the solid line in fig . [ temp ] . the ratio @xmath141 , plotted with the short - dashed curve , measures the decrease in neutrino interaction rates in the superconducting background . the temperature dependences we have taken from bcs theory , that of the specific heat ( dashed curve ) and the magnitude of the gap itself ( dot - dashed curve ) , are shown for reference in fig . [ temp ] . the results shown in fig . [ temp ] are readily interpreted . the cooling rate around @xmath0 is influenced mainly by the peak in the specific heat associated with the second order phase transition , since the neutrino mean free path is not strongly affected when @xmath142 . subsequently , as the matter cools , both @xmath29 and @xmath143 decrease in a non - linear fashion for @xmath144 . upon further cooling , when @xmath145 , both @xmath29 and @xmath143 decrease exponentially . both of these effects accelerate the cooling process . we conclude that if it were possible to measure the neutrino luminosity from the hypothetical object described here , a unique temporal profile would be observed . this suggests that if a second order , superconducting transition were to occur inside a proto - neutron star it could be identified by the temporal characteristics of the late time supernova neutrino signal . specifically , there would be a brief interval during which the cooling would slow around @xmath146 , signified by a period of reduced neutrino detection . the temporal pattern of neutrino emission deduced here would be observable evidence of the onset of color superconductivity in dense matter . however , ours is a simple model , and we must temper our speculations with considerations of more realistic systems . neutrinos emitted from the core of a proto - neutron star , be it hadronic or quark matter in any phase , must pass through a large amount of matter in the outer shell . the neutron - rich material is characterized in the outer shell is opaque to neutrinos and will thus even out any sharp temporal features associated with the interior emission . this is the first and foremost of caveats since this will directly impact the possibility of observing a characteristic in the neutrino signal associated with the phase transition . as discussed in section ii , the scalar diquark condensate in a two - flavor color superconductor is necessarily colored . therefore quarks of one color , taken conventionally as color 3 , will be color - orthogonal to the scalar condensate and can remain ungapped . we have not included these color-3 quarks in our analysis of neutrino scattering since their fate is uncertain @xcite ; they could form color - symmetric cooper pairs , or perhaps a chiral condensate . if we take the simplest scenario and assume that they remain free , their presence in the medium will further dilute any direct effects of the gapped quasi - quarks . specifically , the physical quantities in plotted in fig . [ temp ] will not vanish when @xmath147 , instead being reduced to one third of their @xmath85 values . likewise , the maxima at @xmath0 will be reduced relative to a color - neutral background . the second - order phase transition is taken directly from bcs theory , which we assume rather than derive . while this is the mean - field result for two massless flavors with equivalent chemical potentials , neutron star matter is constrained in two ways . first of all , weak - interaction equilibrium requires @xmath148 , where the subscripts refer to down quarks , up quarks , and electrons . but since a finite electron number is required to achieve electric charge neutrality in the star , @xmath149 can not vanish and we necessarily have @xmath150 . this difference in chemical potentials is likely to drive a first order rather than a bcs - second order transition @xcite . the other notable omission in our study is the strange quark . as before , weak interaction equilibrium requires that @xmath151 , and thus for @xmath152 strange quarks will be present . furthermore , the finite strange quark mass implies a mismatch in the fermi momenta which would also drive a first order transition @xcite . a generic consequence of a first order transition is a mixed phase containing both normal and superconducting quark matter , and transport in the heterogeneous mixed phase is qualitatively different from that considered here , for neutrino scattering will depend on the size and nature of the structures ( droplets ) present . in previous work it was shown that neutrino mean free path in the heterogeneous phase can be greatly reduced due to coherent scattering of droplets in the mixed phase@xcite . combining the results of section ii with neutrino transport in a mixed phase of superconducting and normal quark matter is beyond the scope of this work . therefore , while our calculation of the neutrino mean free path will be an essential ingredient in a more realistic and hence more complicated model of neutron star evolution , our toy model only applies to a highly idealized quark core of a neutron star where @xmath153 . motivated by the physical relevance of neutrino diffusion in the cooling of strongly - interacting matter , we have analyzed the effects on neutrino - quark scattering arising from a second - order phase transition from normal to color superconducting quark matter . the principal microscopic ingredient is the neutrino mean free path , and this was calculated in linear - response theory with a bcs - type superconducting background . we then applied this result to a schematic model of quark matter at temperatures and densities relevant to the evolution of proto - neutron stars . the modified mean free path for neutrinos in a superconducting background was computed in the simplified approximation of iso - symmetric , two - flavor quark matter . we have enumerated the main shortcomings of these simplifications and realize that a more realistic treatment of pns evolution would include many other effects of similar importance . despite these caveats , our toy model calculation indicates that a superconducting transition in the quark core of a pns can impact its early cooling and thereby potentially alter the temporal characteristics of the neutrino emission . we view this work as a first step towards an understanding of how the presence of color superconducting matter in the core of a neutron star may affect the early and observable neutrino signal . quark pairing invariably occurs in theoretical treatments of finite - density qcd , and thus our microscopic calculations of the neutrino cross sections are pertinent to transport processes in dense quark matter . given the real prospect of detecting neutrinos emitted from a future supernova event , such transport processes might someday serve as an probe of the properties of extremely dense matter . we thank the organizers of the int program on qcd at finite baryon density , during which this work was begun , and g.w.c . thanks the institute for nuclear theory for their hospitality . we also thank david kaplan , m. prakash , krishna rajagopal , and martin savage for critical readings of the manuscript and for useful comments . this work was supported by the us department of energy grants de - fg02 - 88er40388 ( g.w.c . ) and de - fg03 - 00-er41132 ( s.r . ) . at densities relevant to this work , only the quark particle - hole excitations are accessible . thus we discard all anti - particle and anti - hole contributions from the propagators in eqs . ( [ a_bcs ] ) and ( [ s_bcs ] ) . the imaginary part of the vector longitudinal polarization is , for each flavor , @xmath154 \bigg [ \delta(q_0+\xi_p-\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p+e_p)(\xi_k+e_k)-\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad -\delta(q_0-\xi_p+\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p - e_p)(\xi_k - e_k)-\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \bigg ] \nonumber\\ & & \qquad + \left [ 1 - n(\xi_p ) - n(\xi_k ) \right ] \bigg [ \delta(q_0-\xi_p-\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p - e_p)(\xi_k+e_k)+\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad -\delta(q_0+\xi_p+\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p+e_p)(\xi_k - e_k)+\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \bigg ] \bigg\ } \ , . \label{veclong}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the axial longitudinal differs only in the sign of the anomalous @xmath155 term , a consequence of coherence effects being different in different channels , and is given by @xmath156 \bigg [ \delta(q_0+\xi_p-\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p+e_p)(\xi_k+e_k)+\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad -\delta(q_0-\xi_p+\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p - e_p)(\xi_k - e_k)+\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \bigg ] \nonumber\\ & & \qquad + \left [ 1 - n(\xi_p ) - n(\xi_k ) \right ] \bigg [ \delta(q_0-\xi_p-\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p - e_p)(\xi_k+e_k)-\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad -\delta(q_0+\xi_p+\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p+e_p)(\xi_k - e_k)-\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \bigg ] \bigg\ } \ , . \label{axlong}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from these expressions , one may obtain @xmath157 , @xmath158 , and @xmath159 as specified in eq . ( [ long_def ] ) . the transverse response functions have similar forms . the vector is @xmath160 \bigg [ \delta(q_0+\xi_p-\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p+e_p)(\xi_k+e_k)+\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad -\delta(q_0-\xi_p+\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p - e_p)(\xi_k - e_k)+\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \bigg ] \nonumber\\ & & \qquad + \left [ 1 - n(\xi_p ) - n(\xi_k ) \right ] \bigg [ \delta(q_0-\xi_p-\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p - e_p)(\xi_k+e_k)-\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad -\delta(q_0+\xi_p+\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p+e_p)(\xi_k - e_k)-\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \bigg ] \bigg\ } \ , , \label{vectrans}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the axial , @xmath161 \bigg [ \delta(q_0+\xi_p-\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p+e_p)(\xi_k+e_k)+\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad -\delta(q_0-\xi_p+\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p - e_p)(\xi_k - e_k)+\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \bigg ] \nonumber\\ & & \qquad + \left [ 1 - n(\xi_p ) - n(\xi_k ) \right ] \bigg [ \delta(q_0-\xi_p-\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p - e_p)(\xi_k+e_k)-\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad -\delta(q_0+\xi_p+\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p+e_p)(\xi_k - e_k)-\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \bigg ] \bigg\ } \ , . \label{axtrans}\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , there is a small but finite response in the mixed vector - axial channel . since the neutrino tensor element @xmath162 is imaginary , we take the real part of the polarization . antisymmetric in spin , it is @xmath163 \bigg [ \delta(q_0+\xi_p-\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p+e_p)(\xi_k+e_k)+\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad -\delta(q_0-\xi_p+\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p - e_p)(\xi_k - e_k)+\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \bigg ] \nonumber\\ & & \qquad + \left [ 1 - n(\xi_p ) - n(\xi_k ) \right ] \bigg [ \delta(q_0-\xi_p-\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p - e_p)(\xi_k+e_k)-\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad -\delta(q_0+\xi_p+\xi_k)\frac{(\xi_p+e_p)(\xi_k - e_k)-\delta^2}{4\xi_p\xi_k } \bigg ] \bigg\ } \,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] m. alford , k. rajagopal , and f. wilczek , phys . * b422 * , 247 ( 1998 ) . r. rapp , t. schfer , e. v. shuryak , and m. velkovsky , phys . lett . * 81 * , 53 ( 1998 ) . j. berges and k. rajagopal , nucl . * b538 * , 215 ( 1999 ) . g. w. carter and d. diakonov , phys . * d60 * , 016004 ( 1999 ) . m. alford , k. rajagopal , and f. wilczek , nucl . b537 * , 443 ( 1999 ) . m. alford , j. berges , and k. rajagopal , nucl . * b558 * , 219 ( 1999 ) . t. schfer and f. wilczek , phys . rev . * d60 * , 074014 ( 1999 ) . r. d. pisarski and d. h. rischke , phys . * d60 * , 094013 ( 1999 ) . r. d. pisarski and d. h. rischke , phys . rev . * d61 * , 074017 ( 2000 ) . d. h. rischke , nucl - th/0001040 . m. alford , j. berges , and k. rajagopal , nucl . phys . * b571 * , 269 ( 2000 ) . d. page , m. prakash , j. m. lattimer , and a. steiner , hep - ph/0005094 . d. blaschke , t. klhn , and d. n. voskresensky , astro - ph/9908334 . e. m. lifshitz and l. p. pitaevskii , _ physical kinetics _ , ( pergamon press , oxford , 1981 ) . j. bardeen and j. r. schrieffer , in _ progress in low temperature physics _ , ( north - holland , amsterdam , 1961 ) , vol iii . d. c. mattis and j. bardeen , phys . rev . * 111 * , 412 ( 1958 ) . l. h. palmer and m. tinkham , phys . 165 * , 588 ( 1968 ) . f. sannino , hep - ph/0002277 .

we calculate the neutrino mean free path in color superconducting quark matter , and employ it to study the cooling of matter via neutrino diffusion in the superconducting phase as compared to a free quark phase . the cooling process slows when quark matter undergoes a second order phase transition to a superconducting phase at the critical temperature @xmath0 . cooling subsequently accelerates as the temperature decreases below @xmath0 . this will directly impact the early evolution of a newly born neutron star , should its core contain quark matter . consequently , there may be observable changes in the early neutrino emission which would provide evidence for superconductivity in hot and dense matter .

astro-ph0009377

intermediate scale disk galaxies with starbursts are relatively common in the nearby universe . about 5% of galaxies with @xmath017 @xmath1 m@xmath2 @xmath321 have evidence for starbursts . many of these occur in smaller galaxies , produce blue colors and strong emission lines , and are in gas rich systems , as indicated by their relatively large fractional hi content . the more luminous nearby blue starbursts structurally and spectroscopically resemble the faint blue compact narrow emission line galaxies ( cnelgs ) , which become common at redshifts of [email protected] ( e.g. , guzman et al . they are less well - matched to high redshift blue galaxies , which have a combination of high uv luminosities and huge star formation rates that are not common in nearby extreme starbursts . this difference probably reflects secular evolution in the lives of galaxies ; for example , systems at high redshift may be subject to frequent , strong mergers that trigger hyperactive star formation ( e.g. conselice et al . 2001 in prep ) . nearby starbursts frequently show evidence for being dynamically cool , that is they contain strong spiral arms or bars , features that are found in rotationally supported galactic disks . thus the processes that produced these starburst did not severely disrupt the disk , or the disk reformed during the starburst event . local analogs to the cnelgs include profound starbursts arising from minor perturbations ( see figure 1 ) . moderate interactions ( glancing collisions between equals , minor mergers ) are apparently the sources of many starbursts . evidence for this includes subtle optical structural features such as wisps , faint tails , or moderately disturbed kinematics in starbursts , as well as the more ubiquitous signatures of disturbed hi . furthermore , in some starbursts where an interaction is the likely trigger , the outer regions of the optical disk appear to be relatively symmetric and relaxed . three possible explanations for this behavior are : @xmath5 blue starbursts are commonly associated with disk galaxies : near face - on systems can transmit uv light through areas where the disk has been cleaned out by supershells , supernova , etc . ( e.g. conselice et al . 2000 ) . @xmath5 low inclination disks can mimic the kinematics of low mass galaxies due to their narrow line widths ( homeier & gallagher 1999 ) . some intermediate redshift cnelgs could be low inclination disks of moderate mass rather then extreme dwarf starbursts . @xmath5 undisturbed intermediate mass galaxies , such as extreme late - type and superthin spirals ( e.g. , matthews et al . 1998 ) can be inefficient star - formers and thereby store interstellar gas , the fuel for starbursts , over cosmic time scales . @xmath5 uv - bright regions of starbursts frequently occur in features associated with disks , such as rings or arms ( e.g. conselice et al . 2000 ) which may represent star forming environments not yet accessible to severely disturbed high luminosity starbursts in the distant universe . conselice , c.j . 2000 , aj , 119 , 79 + guzman , r. et al . 1998 , apj , 495 , l13 + homeier , n. & gallagher , j.s . 1999 , apj , 522 , 199 + matthews , l. , van driel , w. , & gallagher , j. 1998 . aj , 116 , 1169 + mihos , c. & hernquist , l. 1996 , apj , 464 , 641 +

moderately luminous starbursts in the nearby universe often occur in disk galaxies that are at most subject to mild external perturbations . an investigation of this type of galaxy leads to a better understanding of starburst triggering mechanisms and the resulting star formation processes , and provides useful comparisons to more extreme starbursts seen at high redshifts . # 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in

hep-ph0409072

the understanding of the qcd phase diagram has become one of the most interesting issues in the physics of strong interactions . such phase diagram is relevant to phenomena in the early universe , in the interior of neutron stars and in relativistic heavy ion collisions . already in the seventies it was suggested that there should be two distinct phases : a low temperature and density phase in which quarks and gluons are confined within hadrons and chiral symmetry is broken , and a high temperature and density phase ( the so - called quark - gluon plasma ) in which these particles are deconfined and chiral symmetry is restored . although the possible existence of other phases ( e.g. the color superconducting phase ) was also suggested quite long ago@xcite , this two - phase structure became the standard picture of the qcd phase diagram for more than two decades . in recent years , however , it has been established that at low temperatures and medium densities several other phases might appear ( see e.g. ref.@xcite for recent reviews ) . in particular , for the case of two light flavors it has been shown that there should be a non - negligible region in the qcd phase diagram where strongly interacting matter is a color superconductor ( 2sc phase)@xcite . unfortunately , due to difficulties in dealing with finite chemical potential , ab initio calculations ( as e.g. lattice qcd ) are not yet able to provide a detailed knowledge of the qcd phase diagram@xcite . thus , most theoretical approaches are based on the use of effective models of qcd . among them , the nambu - jona - lasinio model@xcite is one of the most popular . in this model the quark fields interact via local four point vertices which are subject to chiral symmetry . if such interaction is strong enough , chiral symmetry is spontaneously broken at zero temperature and density , and pseudoscalar goldstone bosons appear . it has been shown by many authors that when the temperature and/or density increase , the chiral symmetry is restored@xcite . when effective quark - quark interactions are added to the effective lagrangian other phases also appear@xcite . as an improvement on the local njl model , some covariant nonlocal extensions have been studied in the last few years@xcite . nonlocality arises naturally in the context of several successful approaches to low - energy quark dynamics as , for example , the instanton liquid model@xcite and the schwinger - dyson resummation techniques@xcite . it has been also argued that nonlocal covariant extensions of the njl model have several advantages over the local scheme . several studies@xcite have shown that these nonlocal models provide a satisfactory description of the hadron properties at zero temperature and density . recently@xcite , the characteristics of the chiral phase transition have been investigated within this kind of models . the aim of the present work is to extend such studies to the case in which a superconducting phase can appear . this article is organized as follows . in sec . ii we introduce the model and formalism . our results for some specific nonlocal regulators are presented in sec . iii . in sec . iv we analyze the dependence of our results on the strength of the diquark correlations . finally , in sec . v we give our conclusions . let us begin by stating the euclidean action for the nonlocal chiral quark model in the case of two light flavors and @xmath5 isospin symmetry . for the purpose of the present study it is enough to only consider interactions in the scalar quark - antiquark and quark - quark channels . thus , one has @xmath6 ^ 2 - \frac{h}{2}\ \left [ \bar q(x ) \ i \gamma_5 \tau_2 \lambda_2 \ q_c(x ) \right ] \left [ \bar q_c(x ) \ i \gamma_5 \tau_2 \lambda_2 \ q(x ) \right ] \right\ } \ , \label{action}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath7 is the current quark mass and @xmath8 and @xmath9 are pauli and gell - mann matrices corresponding to the flavor and color groups , respectively . the delocalized quark fields @xmath10 are defined in terms of the quark fields @xmath11 as @xmath12 where the function @xmath13 is a nonlocal regulator . it can be translated into momentum space , @xmath14 lorentz invariance implies that @xmath15 can only be a function of @xmath16 . hence we will use for the fourier transform of the regulator the form @xmath17 from now on . in addition , in eq.([action ] ) we have used @xmath18 the partition function for the model is defined as @xmath19 where the euclidean action at finite temperature @xmath20 and chemical potential @xmath21 is obtained from eq . ( [ action ] ) by going to momentum space and performing the replacement @xmath22 where @xmath23 are the matsubara frequencies corresponding to fermionic modes , @xmath24 . as in ref.@xcite we are assuming here that the quark interactions only depend on the temperature and chemical potential through the argument of the regulators . to proceed it is convenient to perform a standard bosonization of the theory . thus , we introduce the sigma meson field @xmath25 and the scalar diquark field @xmath26 and integrate out the quark fields . in what follows we will work within the mean field approximation ( mfa ) , in which these bosonic fields are expanded around their vacuum expectation values @xmath27 and @xmath28 and the corresponding fluctuations neglected . within this approximation and employing the nambu - gorkov formalism , the mean field thermodynamical potential per unit volume reads @xmath29 \label{z}\ ] ] where @xmath30 stands for the trace over the dirac , flavor , color and nambu - gorkov bispinor indexes . the inverse propagator @xmath31 is @xmath32 where @xmath33 and @xmath34 . after some straightforward algebra @xmath35 can be more explicitly expressed as @xmath36 \right\ } \label{omega}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , @xmath37 for finite values of the current quark mass , @xmath35 turns out to be divergent . the regularization procedure used here amounts to define @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the regularized expression for the thermodynamical potential of a free fermion gas , @xmath40 . \label{freeomegareg}\ ] ] the mean field values @xmath41 and @xmath28 are obtained from the coupled pair of gap equations @xmath42 the explicit form of these equations is @xmath43 , \label{gapeq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , in addition to the definitions given in eq.([def1 ] ) , we have used @xmath44 it should be noticed that , in general , there might be regions for which there are more than one solution for each value of @xmath20 and @xmath21 . in such regions we identify the stable solution by requiring it to be an overall minimum of the potential . given the thermodynamic potential the expressions for all other relevant quantities can be easily derived . for each flavor the quark - antiquark condensate @xmath45 and the quark density @xmath46 are given by @xmath47 in the case of the quark - quark condensate an extra source term @xmath48 has to be added to the effective action . it is easy to see that this leads to a thermodynamic potential @xmath49 which has the form given in eq.([omega ] ) but where @xmath50 has been replaced by @xmath51 . then , we get @xmath52 finally , a magnitud which is important to determine the characteristic of the chiral phase transition is the chiral susceptibility @xmath53 . it can be calculated as @xmath54 in this section we concentrate on the numerical results obtained for two different regulators often used in the literature : the gaussian regulator and the lorentzian regulator . in each case we have considered @xmath55 , @xmath7 and @xmath56 as input parameters fixed so as to reproduce the phenomenological values of the chiral condensate , pion mass and pion decay constant at vanishing temperature and densities@xcite . moreover , we have set @xmath57 as implied by , for example , oge interactions @xcite . the dependence of our results on this ratio will be discussed in the following section . in this case the regulator is given by @xmath58 where @xmath56 plays the role of a cut - off parameter . we have considered two different sets of parameters . set i corresponds to @xmath59 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 while set ii to @xmath62 , @xmath63 and @xmath64 . although for both sets the zero temperature and density properties mentioned above are well reproduced , in the case of set i the quark propagator has no purely real poles while for set ii it does . thus , following ref.@xcite , set i might be interpreted as a confining one , since quarks can not materialize on - shell in minkowski space . the mean field values @xmath41 and @xmath28 as a function of @xmath21 and @xmath20 are obtained by numerically solving eqs.([gapeq ] ) . the corresponding results as a function of @xmath21 for various values of @xmath20 are displayed in fig.[unos ] , where left panels correspond to set i while right ones to set ii . it can be seen that , for small values of @xmath20 and @xmath21 ( full lines in fig.[unos ] ) , the system is in the chiral phase for which @xmath65 and @xmath66 . if we increase @xmath21 keeping @xmath20 fixed , at some critical value of @xmath21 there is sudden drop of @xmath67 and a simultaneous sudden increase in @xmath68 so that we get into the 2sc phase characterized by @xmath69 and @xmath70 . in particular , the values of the diquark gap at the critical chemical potential and @xmath71 can be found in table 1 . if we repeat the process with a higher value of @xmath20 something similar happens until we reach the triple point " ( 3p ) . for temperatures slightly higher than @xmath72 ( dashed lines in fig.[unos ] ) the sudden drop in @xmath67 and the increase @xmath68 start to happen at two different values of @xmath21 . between these values of @xmath21 we have @xmath69 and @xmath66 . moreover there is no discontinuity in the behavior of @xmath68 as a function of @xmath21 . for temperatures above the end point " ( ep ) the discontinuity in @xmath67 also disappears ( dotted lines in fig.[unos ] ) . finally for temperatures above the critical temperature for @xmath73 , @xmath74 , we get @xmath75 for all values of @xmath21 . in the region corresponding to the crossover the transition point is defined by the point at which the chiral susceptibility @xmath53 has a maximum . the positions of the different critical points are summarized in table 1 . also shown in fig.[unos ] are the corresponding quiral @xmath76 and diquark @xmath77 condensates . their behavior is quite similar to those of the mean field values @xmath41 and @xmath28 , respectively . it is worthwhile to mention that the fact that the chiral condensate approaches some positive value for large values of @xmath21 is due to the substraction scheme used to regularize the thermodynamical potential , eq.([omegareg ] ) . in fact , it is not difficult to see that for finite values of @xmath7 the regularized free thermodynamical potential @xmath39 , eq.([freeomegareg ] ) , has such behavior . the corresponding phase diagrams are displayed in fig.[dos ] . again left panels correspond to set i and right ones to set ii . on the other hand , the upper panels correspond to the phase diagrams in the @xmath0 plane and the lower ones to the diagrams in the @xmath78 plane , where the nuclear matter density @xmath79 . in all the cases we have indicated with full lines the first order transition lines , with dashed lines the second order transition lines and with dotted lines the lines corresponding to the crossover between the chiral phase and the weakly interacting quark phase . as it is clear from the @xmath0 phase diagrams , at the triple point the three phases can coexist . it is interesting to remark that for values of the chemical potential below @xmath80 the transition line ( both the first order and crossover sections ) coincides exactly with that obtained in the absence of diquark correlations ( @xmath81 ) . on the other hand , for @xmath82 the first order transition line is different from that obtained in ref.@xcite . this is more clearly seen in the corresponding @xmath78 diagrams . there we have indicated with dash - dotted line the first order transition line corresponding to @xmath81 . as we observed the existence of diquark correlations increases the size of the mixed phase . note that for @xmath83 such mixed phase is composed by the chiral and 2sc phases while for @xmath84 it is a mixture of the chiral and the free quark gas phases . as for the comparison between the results of set i and ii , we see that they are qualitatively very similar , with only small quantitative differences in the position of the critical points . the lorentzian regulator we have considered has the form @xmath85 the input parameters are @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 . once again , we have solved the gap equations for different values of the temperature and chemical potential . the qualitative behavior of the mean field values and condensates is very similar to that found using the gaussian regulator ( fig.[unos ] ) and , thus , will not be explicitly shown . nevertheless it is interesting to note that , as shown in table 1 , in this case the @xmath71 diquark gap at the critical chemical potential @xmath89 is somewhat smaller . the corresponding phase diagrams in the @xmath0 and @xmath78 planes are displayed in fig.[tres ] . as in the previous cases , we observe the existence of an end point " , at which the first order chiral phase transition line becomes a crossover line , and a triple point at which the three phases co - exist . the position of these points , which are quite similar to those of the gaussian regulator set ii , are given in table 1 . in the previous section we have assumed @xmath90 as favored by various effective models of quark - quark interactions . however , this value is subject to rather large uncertainties . in fact , so far there is no strong phenomenological constrain on the ratio @xmath91 . thus , it is worthwhile to explore the consequences of varying @xmath91 in the range @xmath92 . larger values of this ratio are quite unlikely to be realized in qcd and might lead to color symmetry breaking in the vacuum . since the results obtained above for different regulators are qualitatively very similar in what follows we will only consider the gaussian regulator with the set of parameters set ii . for values of @xmath91 in the range @xmath93 the resulting phase diagrams look qualitatively similar to the one displayed in fig.[dos ] , although the details ( in particular the position of the critical points , see below ) do depend on @xmath91 . for @xmath94 there is a qualitative change since the triple point ceases to exist . in this case , even at very low temperatures , as we increase @xmath21 at some point we find a first order phase transition between the chiral phase and the free quark gas phase . for values slightly above this critical @xmath21 we have @xmath95 . if we continue to increase @xmath21 we find a second order phase transition between the free quark gas phase and the 2sc phase . the corresponding @xmath0 phase diagram is shown in the upper panel of fig.[cinco ] . note that in this phase diagram the transition line between the chiral and the free quark gas phases ( both its crossover and first order sections ) coincides exactly to the one obtained for @xmath81 . for @xmath96 the situation is again qualitatively different , since in such range the triple point and the end point merge together . in fact , as @xmath91 comes closer from below to @xmath97 the first order transition line that connects the 3p and the ep becomes shorter and shorter and at this particular value it disappears . moreover , for @xmath96 there is small region at low temperatures at which both @xmath41 and @xmath28 take non - vanishing values . this region is separated from the chiral phase by a second order transition line and from the 2sc for a first order transition line . this situation is illustrated in the lower panel of fig.[cinco ] where the @xmath0 phase diagram for @xmath98 is shown . the possible existence of this type of phase was already noticed in refs.@xcite . the behavior of the critical points as function of @xmath91 is displayed in fig.[seis ] . in the upper panel we show the position of critical chemical potential @xmath99 at @xmath71 . the full line indicates the first order @xmath99 while the dashed line the second order one . in the range @xmath93 we have only a first order @xmath99 . for values below such @xmath99 the system is in the chiral phase while for values above is in the 2sc . for values @xmath94 we have that the second order @xmath99 , i.e. the point at which the second order transition line that separates the 2sc and free quark gas phases meets the @xmath21-axis in the @xmath0 phase diagram , grows rather fast as @xmath91 decreases , signaling the almost disappearance of the 2sc phase for very small values of the diquark coupling constant . for @xmath96 a second order @xmath99 appears again , but now _ below _ the first order @xmath99 . thus , between these two critical chemical potentials we have @xmath100 _ and _ @xmath101 . in the lower panel we display the position of the triple and end points as functions of @xmath91 . note that the temperature scale is given to the right while the chemical potential scale is given to the left . for values of @xmath94 only the the ep exists . its positions remains independent of the diquark coupling constant up to @xmath97 where it meets the 3p , that appears at @xmath102 and which position in temperature ( chemical potential ) increases ( decreases ) as @xmath91 increases . for values of @xmath96 both critical points transform into a single one which position in temperature ( chemical potential ) increases ( decreases ) as @xmath91 increases . in this work we have studied the finite temperature and chemical potential behavior of @xmath103 chiral quark models with nonlocal covariant separable interactions in both the scalar quark - antiquark and quark - quark channels . in our numerical calculations we have considered two types of regulators : the gaussian regulator and the lorentzian regulator . in all these cases we have set the model parameters so as to reproduce the empirical values of the pion mass and decay constant and to get a chiral quark condensate in reasonable agreement to that determined from lattice gauge theory or qcd sum rules . as for the ratio between quark - quark and quark - antiquark interactions @xmath91 which is not well constrained by phenomenology , we have in principle adopted the standard value @xmath90 which follows from some models of the qcd interactions . we find that in all cases the phase diagram is quite similar . in particular , we obtain that for two light flavors there are always two critical points : a triple point " at which the second order transition line separating the 2sc and normal phases meets the first order transition line which separate the chiral and 2sc phases at low temperatures ; an end point " which appears at higher temperatures and at which the first order transition line becomes a crossover line . of course , there is also a critical temperature @xmath104 above which the chiral condensate always vanishes . as displayed in table 1 the values of @xmath104 are in the range @xmath105 mev , that is somewhat below the values obtained in modern lattice simulations which suggest @xmath106 mev@xcite . with this in mind we note that our predictions for the positions of the triple and end points are very similar for all the cases considered . perhaps , the only noticeable difference between the different cases is the prediction for the @xmath71 diquark gap at the critical chemical potential , where we find values that range from 114 to 182 mev . these values are larger than those obtained within models with instantaneous interactions @xcite . it should be noticed ( see fig.[unos ] ) that in the present case the diquark gap also registers a stronger increase with @xmath21 after the phase transition . this leads to rather large values of the gap for chemical potentials of the order of 400 mev , above which strange degrees of freedom have to be taken into account . consequently , for such values of @xmath21 , we also get larger values ( 100 - 120 mev ) for the critical temperature needed to go to the free quark gas phase , as it can be easily seen comparing our phase diagrams with those obtained in e.g. the njl model@xcite . in the final part of this work we have explored the consequences of varying @xmath91 in the range @xmath92 . given the similarity of the results obtained for the two regulators mentioned above we have considered here only the gaussian regulator with the set of parameters set ii . we found that for @xmath94 there is no triple point . on the other hand , for @xmath96 the triple and end point merge and a phase where both the chiral and diquark condensates are non - negligible appears . it is interesting to remark that the value @xmath97 is quite close to the standard one @xmath107 used in most model calculations . thus , it would be important to sort out possible phenomenological consequences of having quark matter with a phase diagram in which the 3p and ep coincide . in this work we have neglected the strangeness degrees of freedom . to go beyond the values of chemical potential considered here and , thus , study for example the color flavor locked phase in the context of models with non local interactions their effect have to be included . work in this direction is in progress . we thank d. blaschke and d. gmez dumm for useful discussions . this work has been partially supported by conicet and anpcyt under grants pip 02368 and pict 00 - 03 - 08580 , respectively . b. c. barrois , nucl . b129 * , 390 ( 1977 ) ; s.c . frautschi , in `` hadronic matter at extreme energy density '' , edited by n. cabibbo and l. sertorio ( plenum press , 1980 ) ; d. bailin and a. love , phys . rep . * 107 * , 325 ( 1984 ) . k. rajagopal and f. wilczek , in _ at the frontier of particle physics / handbook of qcd _ , m. shifman , ed . ( world scientific , singapore , 2001 ) ; m. alford , annu . nucl . part . 51 , 131 ( 2001 ) ; d. h. rischke , prog . phys . * 52 * , 197 ( 2004 ) . ccccccc & & & & & & + regulator & & & & + & @xmath72 & @xmath80 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 & & + gaussian - set i & 64 & 193 & 69 & 180 & 115 & 182 + gaussian - set ii & 54 & 215 & 58 & 207 & 120 & 132 + lorentzian & 48 & 217 & 59 & 195 & 116 & 114 +

we study the competence between chiral symmetry restoration and two flavor color superconductivity ( 2sc ) using a relativistic quark model with covariant nonlocal interactions . we consider two different nonlocal regulators : a gaussian regulator and a lorentzian regulator . we find that although the phase diagrams are qualitative similar to those obtained using models with local interactions , in our case the superconducting gaps at medium values of the chemical potential are larger . consequently , we obtain that in that region the critical temperatures for the disappearance of the 2sc phase might be of the order of 100 - 120 mev . we also find that for ratios of the quark - quark and quark - antiquark couplings somewhat above the standard value 3/4 , the end point and triple point in the @xmath0 phase diagram meet and a phase where both the chiral and diquark condensates are non - negligible appears . * two flavor color superconductivity in nonlocal chiral quark models * + r. s. duhau@xmath1 , a. g. grunfeld@xmath1 and n.n . scoccola@xmath2 + @xmath1 _ physics department , comisin nacional de energa atmica , + av.libertador 8250 , ( 1429 ) buenos aires , argentina . _ + @xmath3 _ conicet , rivadavia 1917 , ( 1033 ) , argentina . _ + @xmath4 _ universidad favaloro , sols 453 , ( 1078 ) buenos aires , argentina _ pacs numbers : 12,39.ki.12.38.mh .

1406.6846

there is growing evidence from nuclear magnetic resonance @xcite , resonant x - ray scattering and diffraction @xcite and scanning tunneling microscopy @xcite that charge ordered states play an important role in underdoped cuprates . in particular , a charge - modulated state with 4 incommensurate wave vectors along the crystalline axes was detected in ybco and in bi - based single and double layer compounds . resonant elastic x - ray scattering showed that the charge order emerges just below the opening of the pseudogap @xcite in underdoped bi2201 @xcite . the formation of the pseudogap , fermi pockets , the appearance of quantum oscillations @xcite and of charge order may thus be intimately related in these systems . it is the aim of this paper to characterize charge ordered states in interacting systems independently of the strength of the interaction . furthermore , the implications of point group and time reversal symmetries as well as the hermiticity of the hamiltonian for the order parameter ( op ) will be taken into account in greater detail than in previous treatments . the microscopic form of the charge op in cuprates is not clear at present . to illustrate this let us consider the following model hamiltonian for electrons on a square lattice which generally is believed to be relevant for cuprates @xcite , @xmath5 @xmath6 denotes the hopping amplitude of electrons between the lattice site @xmath7 and @xmath8 . @xmath9 and @xmath10 are fermionic creation and annihilation operators , @xmath11 spin indices and repeated spin indices are always summed over . the second and third terms in eq . ( [ h ] ) describe antiferromagnetic and coulomb interactions between electrons on neighboring sites @xmath7 and @xmath8 with coupling constants @xmath1 and @xmath12 , respectively . if double occupancies of sites are excluded eq . ( [ h ] ) represents the well - known @xmath0-@xmath1 model for @xmath13 . the interaction terms in eq . ( [ h ] ) give rise to two kinds of charge ops . a hartree - like contraction of the third term yields an op proportional to @xmath14 describing the charge on the site @xmath7 . it may vary from site to site and represents a conventional charge density wave ( cdw ) state . the exchange contractions of the second and third term in eq . ( [ h ] ) yield an op proportional to @xmath15 , where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are nearest neighbor sites . this state may be called a nonlocal cdw or a bond - order wave ( bow ) state @xcite where the cdw acquires an internal degree of freedom because the electron and hole occupy different sites . it has been shown that in the large n limit of the @xmath0-@xmath1 model ( which corresponds to enforcing the constraint of no double occupancies of sites only globally ) the phase diagram consists in the underdoped regime of incommensurate bow states ( at zero doping of the staggered flux phase @xcite as a special case ) @xcite . at the same time the conventional cdw op is zero showing that both kinds of charge order are independent from each other . more recently the bow state has been studied theoretically in more detail @xcite . also models with more than one band @xcite or more complex ops @xcite have been considered . recently a microscopic form for the op in underdoped ybco and bi2201 was proposed @xcite based on experimental data from resonant x - ray scattering . throughout the paper we will assume that the temperature is below the transition temperature to the bow state . the ops are then in general nonzero and their symmetry properties can be studied . we will classify possible ops for bow states by exploiting point - group and time reversal symmetries as well as the hermiticity of @xmath16 . in the appendix it is shown that possible ops for the ground state are basis functions for representations of @xmath17 . if the ground state is non - degenerate in the sense that it does not contain two linearly independent ops the representation is irreducible . if the ground state is degenerate and satifies a two dimensional representation this representation may be irreducible or reducible . in the latter case it is composed of two ops with different symmetries and the degeneracy is not a consequence of symmetry but of coupling constants . in the following we will confine our discussion to ops which form irreducible representations of @xmath17 and exlude accidential degeneracies , additional instabilities or induced higher harmonics @xcite . explicit expressions for the ops will be given for bow states with four wave vectors of the form @xmath18 and the form @xmath19 and @xmath20 . from eq . ( [ h ] ) follows that the bow op has the form of a coupling constant times the matrix element @xmath21 , where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are nearest neighbors . to simplify the nomenclature we will call the modulated part of @xmath21 op in the following . after a fourier transform we obtain , @xmath22 @xmath23 is the vector from the origin to the lattice site @xmath7 . the sum over @xmath24 in eq . ( [ fourier ] ) includes in the plane - wave limit only the wave vectors corresponding to a charge instability of the normal state . they form a star of wave vectors @xmath25 . writing @xmath26 , keeping @xmath27 fixed and performing a fourier transformation with respect to @xmath23 we get @xmath28 the functions @xmath29 are defined by eq . ( [ f ] ) and represent our set of order parameters . if umklapp terms are included the sum over @xmath30 may not only include primary instability vectors of the normal state but higher harmonics with wave vectors @xmath31 where @xmath32 is an integer . they form new stars and cause deviations from the plane - wave limit of the op . because these higher harmonics are important only near the transition to the commensurate phase we will neglect them in the following and restrict ourselves to the plane - wave limit . the symmetry group of the square lattice is @xmath17 . using the notation of ref . @xcite let us denote one of the 8 symmetry transformations by @xmath33 . its action on the order parameter in eq . ( [ f ] ) can be written as @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the 2x2 matrix representing @xmath33 in the two - dimensional direct space . after a fourier transformation with respect to @xmath23 we find that @xmath29 transforms under @xmath33 into @xmath36 , where @xmath37 and @xmath38 belong to the star of wave vectors and to nearest neighbor bonds , respectively . this means that the set of functions @xmath39 forms basis functions for a ( reducible ) representation of @xmath17 . decomposing this reducible representation into irreducible parts the basis function of one of the irreducible representations describes the op of the state corresponding to the global minimum of the free energy . one important feature is that in general both @xmath30 and @xmath27 are transformed under @xmath33 at the same time and not independently from each other . this is a crucial point in our approach . further general properties of the functions @xmath40 are related to time reversal and the hermiticity of the hamiltonian . the operator @xmath41 for time reversal is defined in real space by @xmath42 where the star means conjugate complex . taking fourier transforms on both sides we get , @xmath43 or @xmath44 or , @xmath45 in eqs . ( [ philf2 ] ) and ( [ philf3 ] ) @xmath46 stands for @xmath47 and @xmath27 is fixed in the sums over @xmath23 . @xmath48 is defined by the last equation . some authors interprete the right - hand side of eq . ( [ philf2 ] ) as a fourier transform of @xmath49 which may be written as @xmath50 . the connection to our definition eq . ( [ philf4 ] ) is @xmath51 . in order to avoid confusion we will always use our definition in eq . ( [ philf4 ] ) . using the hermiticity of the hamiltonian the second half of eq . ( [ f ] ) yields @xmath52 @xmath53 denotes the rotation by @xmath54 . ( [ philf4 ] ) implies @xmath55 , which corresponds to the case of integral spin . @xcite applying the frobenius - schur test @xcite to the point group @xmath17 shows that including @xmath41 in the set of symmetry transformations can not produce additional degeneracies of irreducible representations . thus it is convenient to construct first basis functions for irreducible representations of the point group and then to check their behavior under time reversal . in the following we will first consider the case with 4 wave vectors along the diagonals , i.e. , @xmath56 , where @xmath57 lies between 0 and @xmath54 . the four bond directions are denoted by @xmath58 . it is easy to see that the following 8 functions @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 , and @xmath63 yield a reducible representation of @xmath17 . let us denote the linear combinations of the @xmath64 which form basis functions for the corresponding irreducible representations @xmath65 by @xmath66 for the one - dimensional representations @xmath67 one can easily determine the coefficients @xmath68 from the character table of @xmath17 . one finds that each of these representations occurs exactly one time , the corresponding @xmath68 are given in the first 4 lines of table 1 . using again the character table one finds that the remaining 4 functions form 2 two - dimensional representations @xmath69 and @xmath70 . the corresponding @xmath68 are given in the lines 5 - 8 in table 1 . .coefficients @xmath68 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] going back to eq . ( [ herm ] ) we note that for the functions @xmath71 the phase factor @xmath72 is always equal to @xmath57 . multiplying eq . ( [ herm ] ) by @xmath68 and summing over @xmath73 we obtain @xmath74 from the character table of @xmath75 follows that @xmath76 is equal to @xmath77 for @xmath67 and equal to @xmath78 for @xmath79 . the solution of eq . ( [ ff ] ) is @xmath80 where the upper sign refers to @xmath81 and the lower sign to @xmath79 , respectively . the real part of @xmath77 , @xmath82 , may assume any real number . for @xmath83 or @xmath54 the four functions @xmath84 form a basis for a reducible representation of @xmath17 which decomposes into @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 representations with the basis functions @xmath85 , @xmath86 and @xmath87 , @xmath88 , respectively . ( [ ff ] ) still holds the first two basis functions are real ( imaginary ) and the third and fourth ones imaginary ( real ) for @xmath83 ( @xmath89 ) . included as a special case is the staggered flux phase with wave vector @xmath90 . it has @xmath3 symmetry and a purely imaginary op in agreement with previous conclusions . @xcite let us denote the second set of 8 functions by @xmath91 . each @xmath92 is obtained from @xmath64 by exchanging @xmath93 with @xmath94 and @xmath95 with @xmath96 . the linear space spanned by the functions @xmath97 yields a reducible representation of @xmath17 . decomposing it into its irreducible parts gives one time the representations @xmath98 and two times the representation @xmath4 , exactly as for the first 8 functions @xmath64 . the analogue of eq . ( [ c ] ) reads @xmath99 where the coefficients @xmath68 are the same as in table 1 . the phase factor @xmath72 is for all 8 functions equal to @xmath100 so that eq . ( [ ff ] ) reads @xmath101 with the solution @xmath102 @xmath103 is unrelated to @xmath82 and may assume any real value . this expresses the fact that @xmath104 and @xmath105 describe possible ops for all values of @xmath82 and @xmath106 complex functions for @xmath77 and @xmath107 do not necessarily imply that the corresponding states break @xmath41 symmetry . this is true in particular in our case because a possible imaginary part to @xmath104 can come from the matrix element but also from combinations of the exponential functions in eq . ( [ f ] ) . a general criterion for an unbroken @xmath41 symmetry follows from eq . ( [ fhilf1 ] ) , namely , @xmath108 applying fourier transformations on both sides of eq . ( [ fhilf5 ] ) similar as in eqs . ( [ philf2 ] ) and ( [ philf3 ] ) yields @xmath109 comparing with eq . ( [ philf4 ] ) yields the following criterion which must be fulfilled if @xmath41 symmetry is unbroken , @xmath110 for the special case @xmath111 the above criterion is fulfilled for the real op of @xmath2 and @xmath3 symmetry , found above , but not for the imaginary op of the @xmath4 symmetry . thus @xmath41 symmetry is unbroken for the @xmath2 and @xmath3 and broken for the @xmath4 symmetry . for @xmath112 one finds that the purely imaginary ops of the @xmath113 symmetries break and the real op of the @xmath4 symmetry preserves @xmath41 symmetry . considering a general @xmath30 along the diagonals , a ground state with symmetry @xmath65 is in general given by a linear combination of all basis functions belonging to the same representation . it has thus in our case the form @xmath114 with coefficients @xmath11 and @xmath115 which have to be real to be compatible with eq . ( [ f1 ] ) and ( [ f11 ] ) . applying @xmath41 to this state we obtain , @xmath116 inserting the functions @xmath64 into eq . ( [ philf4 ] ) , multiplying by @xmath68 , summing over @xmath73 and using eq . ( [ ff ] ) yields @xmath117 replacing @xmath64 by @xmath92 and using eq . ( [ ffff ] ) instead of eq . ( [ ff ] ) gives @xmath118 eqs . ( [ dia3 ] ) and ( [ dia4 ] ) always hold . if , in addition , @xmath41 symmetry is preserved we obtain from eq . ( [ dia1 ] ) , @xmath119 and @xmath120 inserting eqs . ( [ dia3 ] ) - ( [ dia6 ] ) into eq . ( [ tall ] ) yields @xmath121 noting that eqs . ( [ f1 ] ) and ( [ f11 ] ) can also be written as @xmath122 and @xmath123 eq . ( [ tttt ] ) is equivalent to @xmath124 or , using eqs . ( [ c ] ) and ( [ cc ] ) , @xmath125 the functions @xmath64 and @xmath126 are different from each other and the functions of each of the two sets transform within each set under the elements of the point group and under time reversal . thus symmetry does not enforce any relation between @xmath82 and @xmath106 and eq . ( [ f3 ] ) will not necessarily be fulfilled for a general hamiltonian . however , this does not exclude ops exhibiting @xmath41 symmetry . the left and right - hand sides of eqs . ( [ f3 ] ) may assume independently any real value . the case where both values are equal is not excluded and represents an op with @xmath41 symmetry . such a fine - tuned state may , however , be vulnerable to perturbations , for instance , to a change in the coupling constants , the temperature etc . since no general argument seems to exist which protects eq . ( [ f3 ] ) against such perturbations it is reasonable to conclude that in the general case the basis functions in eq . ( [ c ] ) and eq . ( [ cc ] ) break @xmath41 symmetry for @xmath127 and @xmath128 . whether for a specific hamiltonian the ground state breaks or preserves @xmath41 symmetry can only be determined by an explicit calculation of the ops and the free energy . in the next section we will encounter a totally different case where the breaking and preserving of @xmath41 symmetry is enforced by symmetry independently of the values of microscopic coupling constants or specific hamiltonians . next we consider the case of four wave vectors along the crystalline axes , i.e. , @xmath129 , @xmath130 , @xmath131 , and @xmath132 where @xmath57 lies between 0 and @xmath54 . using the previous notation the functions @xmath133 yield irreducible representations of @xmath113 and @xmath4 symmetries with the basis functions @xmath85 , @xmath134 , @xmath87 , and @xmath135 , respectively . these basis functions can be written in the form of eq . ( [ c ] ) where the sum runs from @xmath136 to @xmath137 and the corresponding @xmath65 in table 1 is chosen . the exponential factor in eq . ( [ herm ] ) is in each case @xmath138 . ( [ ff ] ) holds for these three representations and their basis functions are complex for @xmath139 . all the above results also apply to the set @xmath140 , if the exponential factor is replaced by @xmath141 . thus each of the manifolds @xmath104 and @xmath142 lead to one @xmath113 and one @xmath4 representation and their basis functions are complex for @xmath143 . the arguments concerning @xmath41 breaking in eqs . ( [ tall ] ) - ( [ sum ] ) can be transferred to the present star of wave vectors with the result that all states which are not fine - tuned in the sense discussed above break @xmath41 symmetry . the remaining 8 functions are conveniently split into the combinations @xmath144 and @xmath145 , where @xmath146 , @xmath147 etc . mean @xmath93 , @xmath95 etc . and @xmath73 runs from 1 to 4 . the functions @xmath148 lead to @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 , the functions @xmath149 lead to @xmath150 , @xmath151 and @xmath4 representations . the corresponding basis functions are the same as for the above @xmath64 manifold , once @xmath64 is replaced by @xmath152 or @xmath153 , respectively . for all 8 functions the wave and the bond vectors are perpendicular to each other implying that @xmath57 is identical to zero and that no complex exponential appears in eq . ( [ herm ] ) . as a result we get @xmath154 so that @xmath155 is real for @xmath156 and imaginary for @xmath157 . using these properties we have from eq . ( [ philf4 ] ) @xmath158 for @xmath159 . ( [ fplus ] ) is a direct consequence of the definition of the operator @xmath41 and holds in any case . if in addition @xmath41 symmetry applies eq . ( [ dia1 ] ) also holds . forming appropriate basis functions eq . ( [ dia1 ] ) is identical with eq . ( [ fplus ] ) after taking into account that @xmath160 and @xmath161 are real and @xmath162 imaginary . this means that the condition for @xmath41 symmetry is automatically fulfilled in this case for all three representations . remarkable is that no condition of the kind of eq . ( [ tttt ] ) or eq . ( [ f3 ] ) appears which can not be fulfilled in the general case . the @xmath41 symmetry arises here without fine - tuning and is enforced by symmetry . finally , let us consider the basis functions @xmath163 of the irreducible representations @xmath164 . ( [ herm ] ) yields @xmath165 implying that @xmath166 and @xmath167 are real and @xmath168 are imaginary . forming basis functions in eqs . ( [ philf4 ] ) and ( [ herm ] ) gives @xmath169 if in addition @xmath41 symmetry holds eq . ( [ dia1 ] ) is fulfilled and yields after forming linear combinations of @xmath150 , @xmath151 , and @xmath4 symmetry , @xmath170 clearly , eqs . ( [ fminus1 ] ) and ( [ fminus2 ] ) contradict each other . thus @xmath41 symmetry is always broken in all three cases in a robust way , i.e. , independent of specific hamiltonians and values for microscopic coupling parameters . for completeness let us consider the case of an usual cdw without internal bond degrees of freedom . ( [ herm ] ) reads for @xmath171 @xmath172 . ( [ dia2 ] ) is always fulfilled . forming suitable linear combinations to get basis functions for irreducbile representations we see that @xmath41 symmetry is always unbroken in an usual cdw . the above analysis showed that many of the symmetry allowed ops break @xmath41 symmetry . the finite imaginary part of these ops generate circulating currents and space - dependent magnetic fields @xcite which so far could not be observed @xcite . concentrating therefore on @xmath41 conserving ops there are none without fine - tuning in the case of a star with wave vectors along the diagonals . for the experimentally observed star with wave vectors along the crystalline axes there are three ops which preserve @xmath41 symmetry in a robust way . they have the symmetries @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 and originate from the @xmath173 manifold . in particular , the @xmath161 state with @xmath3 symmetry seems to be a good candidate for the op in underdoped cuprates @xcite . its bond charge pattern @xmath21 is proportional to @xmath174 for @xmath175 and @xmath176 for @xmath177 and is illustrated in fig . 1 . the color on each bond indicates the value for the corresponding bond charge . the pattern represents a simple bidirectional bow state where the charges on the hozontal and vertical bonds vary only in one direction . different ground states for underdoped cuprates have also been proposed , for instance , uniaxial bow states with @xcite or without @xcite @xmath41 breaking . interesting is that the relevant ops of the hot spot model of ref . @xcite are closely related to our manifolds @xmath173 and @xmath178 concerning point group and time reversal symmetries . ( color online ) bond charge pattern of the @xmath161 state using @xmath179 . , width=264 ] the op deduced from experimental data in ref . @xcite uses a form for the op which is based on the approximation @xmath180 this approximation is obtained from eq . ( [ f ] ) by shifting the sum over @xmath181 by @xmath182 and using for the matrix element the @xmath30 independent function @xmath183 . from eq . ( [ herm ] ) follows that @xmath183 has to be real . inserting eq . ( [ f ] ) into eq . ( [ fourier ] ) and using eq . ( [ keim ] ) yields @xmath184 the sum over @xmath181 is only nonzero if @xmath183 is a linear combination of @xmath185 , @xmath186 , @xmath187 and @xmath188 . inserting these functions into eq . ( [ pattern ] ) and using the transformation rule of eq . ( [ trans ] ) shows that these patterns have @xmath2 , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 symmetries . for instance , for the @xmath3 symmetry we have @xmath189 where @xmath190 is a real constant . the bond charge patterns of eq . ( [ pattern ] ) are invariant if @xmath30 is transformed as @xmath191 and @xmath27 is kept fixed . this transformation describes a permutation of the wave vectors of the bow and does not correspond to an element of the point group @xmath17 . invariance under this transformation represents an additional symmetry which we will call @xmath192 symmetry in the following . applying @xmath41 to eq . ( [ pattern ] ) yields @xmath193 where the upper and lower sign holds for the @xmath113 and @xmath4 representations , respectively . the corresponding basis functions are therefore real or imaginary . ( [ pattern ] ) is identical with eq . ( s9 ) in ref . this equation was used to analyse inelastic x - ray data in underdoped cuprates and it was concluded that , disregarding uni - directional modulations , the ground state has @xmath3 symmetry . @xcite . the corresponding bond charges are proportional to @xmath194 for @xmath195 and to @xmath196 for @xmath197 , and yield a quite different pattern from that shown in fig . 1 . as shown above the approximation eq . ( [ keim ] ) yields for each of the symmetries @xmath2 , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 just one op . the charge patterns with @xmath150 and @xmath151 symmetries , discussed in section iv , no longer exist in this approximation . ( [ keim ] ) also implies severe restrictions in the space of ops . for instance , if @xmath30 and @xmath27 are perpendicular to each other the functions @xmath29 become identical for @xmath198 . moreover , using the approximation eq . ( [ keim ] ) , eqs . ( [ tttt ] ) and ( [ f3 ] ) hold which means @xmath41 symmetry for the @xmath2 and @xmath3 states and at the same time fine - tuning of ops . it seems therefore preferable not to specialize @xmath29 as in eq . ( [ keim ] ) but to stick to the general form of the ops and to use our previous general symmetry classification . we will restrict the discussion in the following to @xmath3 states , but similar arguments also apply to the symmetries @xmath2 and @xmath4 . in section iv we found that there are 3 different representations with @xmath3 symmetry . the ground state op @xmath199 will therefore be in general a linear combination of their basis functions , i.e. , @xmath200 where @xmath201 and @xmath202 are real numbers . the charge patterns form a two - fold manifold which is quite different from the case where eq . ( [ keim ] ) holds and only one op exists . this difference is due to the constraints in the space of ops introduced by the approximation eq . ( [ keim ] ) . next we simplify @xmath199 by requesting that it exhibits @xmath192 symmetry . @xmath199 then specializes unambiguously to @xmath203 given by @xmath204 regrouping the terms to form irreducible basis functions we get @xmath205 although @xmath206 and eq . ( [ patternb1 ] ) possess both @xmath192 and @xmath3 symmetry and are unambiguously determined by these symmetries they are different . this can be seen from their behavior under time reversal . ( [ patternb1 ] ) is @xmath41 symmetric according to eq . ( [ tkeim ] ) . applying @xmath41 to eq . ( [ f10 ] ) and using eqs . ( [ tall ] ) - ( [ dia5 ] ) gives @xmath207 thus @xmath203 breaks in general @xmath41 symmetry because eq . ( [ tttt ] ) or the equivalent eq . ( [ sum ] ) are in general not fulfilled so that the first two terms on the right - hand side of eq . ( [ that ] ) are not equal to @xmath208 . according to our previous discussion equations like @xmath209 are satisfied only for fine - tuned ops which neglect the contribution from circulating currents associated with @xmath41 breaking of @xmath210 , and @xmath203 . in contrast to that @xmath161 is @xmath41 symmetric without any restrictions . besides of the most general op of eq . ( [ f0 ] ) there are three distinguished and simple possibilities for the ground state op with @xmath3 symmetry : + ( a ) one is @xmath161 obeying @xmath41 but not @xmath192 symmetry ; + ( b ) another is given by eqs . ( [ fdach ] ) and ( [ f10 ] ) exhibiting @xmath192 but breaking in general @xmath41 symmetry ; + ( c ) state ( b ) with @xmath41 symmetry due to fine - tuning ; this state is equivalent to eq . ( [ patternb1 ] ) . + note that @xmath192 symmetry is in our case not an exact symmetry because the point group transformations change both the momenta of the bow and the bonds at the same time . thus ( b ) and ( c ) represent approximate states . in contrast to that state ( a ) is not @xmath192 symmetric but necessarily invariant under time reversal because this is a result of symmetry . moreover , it is the only state which has this property . since experiments seem to rule out circulating currents in underdoped cuprates @xcite the ground state should be state ( a ) if fine - tuned states ( i.e. , states with restrictions not enforced by symmetry ) can be ruled out . in conclusion , we have identified symmetry allowed bond ops for any model with nearest neighbor interactions such as the @xmath0-@xmath1 model and studied their properties , in particular , with respect to time reversal . the obtained results are relevant for recently observed charge - ordered states in underdoped cuprates and their symmetries . the proposed ops are more general than the variational anstze used in the past both in theoretical and experimental studies . being based on rigorous group theoretical considerations our results are useful to design improved variational forms for the op in microscopic calculations or to interprete experimental data . + * acknowledgements * the author is grateful to h. yamase , p. horsch , w. metzner , a. greco and b. keimer for useful discussions and to t. holder for help in producing the figure . interesting discussions and exchanges of e - mails with s. sachdev , a. allais and j. bauer are also acknowledged . it is well known that ground state wave functions form , disregarding accidential degeneracies , basis functions for irreducible representation of the symmetry transformations commuting with the hamiltonian . @xcite in this appendix we will study the question whether a similar statement is true for the ground state of a system described by a free energy functional and ops . let us denote by @xmath211 one of the ops describing the ground state , i.e. , which correspond to the minimum of the free energy . @xmath211 can be represented as a linear combination of the @xmath29 and thus transforms in a well - defined way under point group transformations . considering @xmath17 and applying its n=8 transformations @xmath212 to @xmath211 we denote by @xmath213 the transformations which lead to linearly independent functions @xmath214 . the functions @xmath215 can be written as linear combinations of the functions @xmath216 . denoting the n point group operators by @xmath217 , we can write @xmath218 where @xmath219 is a matrix with d rows and n columns . applying @xmath220 to @xmath216 gives @xmath221 @xmath222 denotes the column of @xmath223 which corresponds to the point group transformation @xmath224 . for a fixed @xmath225 @xmath222 runs over d columns of @xmath223 which can be used to form a square matrix @xmath226 with @xmath227 rows and @xmath227 columns . ( [ p1 ] ) can now be written as @xmath228 considering a product of two transformations @xmath225 and @xmath229 we have @xmath230 on the other hand is @xmath231 so that @xmath232 eqs . ( [ an1 ] ) and ( [ an2 ] ) establish that the matrices @xmath226 together with the basis functions @xmath216 form a representation of @xmath17 . assuming that no accidential degeneracy of the ground state is present the set of functions @xmath233 form a basis for the degenerate ops of the ground state . if @xmath234 there is only one linearly independent op describing the ground state . moreover , this op must form a basis function for a one - dimensional irreducible representation of @xmath17 . thus if the ground state is non - degenerate its op must be one of the basis functions belonging to irreducible one - dimensional representations discussed in sections iii and iv . in the case @xmath235 there are two linearly independent ops describing the degenerate ground state . they form a two - dimensional representation of @xmath17 . the two basis functions have the same free energy because they transform into each other by symmetry operations of the point group . determining the trace of the associated representation matrices @xmath236 there are two cases possible . the representation is irreducible and the two basis functions transform according to the @xmath4 representation . or , the representation is reducible and a superposition of two different one - dimensional representations . in this case the free energy of the two - dimensional reducible representation may be lower or higher than that of the irreducible representations . this means that the case is not excluded that a two - fold degenerate ground state transforms according to a reducible and not an irreducible representation . in order to illustrate the above statements we consider a simple free energy model without bond degrees of freedom and two real ops , @xmath237 @xmath238 @xmath239 and @xmath240 are wave vectors of equal length along the @xmath241 and @xmath242 axis , respectively . forming the combinations @xmath243 yields basis functions @xmath244 and @xmath245 for a @xmath2 and a @xmath3 representation , respectively . we consider the following free energy functional , @xmath246 in the parameter range @xmath247 and @xmath248 . the underlying symmetry group is @xmath17 . the coefficient @xmath249 is proportional to @xmath250 and becomes negative below the transition temperature @xmath251 to the bow state . note that the prefactor @xmath249 is the same for both order parameters though the latter have different symmetries . in the usual terminology this corresponds to an accidential degeneracy . in our case this degeneracy is caused by the fact that the diverging susceptibilities in the normal state at @xmath252 and @xmath253 are related by point group operations . there is only one @xmath251 for both symmetries @xmath2 and @xmath3 . below @xmath251 the ops @xmath244 and @xmath245 will become finite and in general be also different due to the anharmonic terms in @xmath104 . solving the extremal equations for @xmath104 yields the following solutions : @xmath254 @xmath255 @xmath256 the free energy eq . ( [ fa ] ) is invariant under @xmath257 and @xmath258 which leads to additional degeneracies described by @xmath259 in eqs . ( [ solu1 ] ) - ( [ solu3 ] ) . it is convenient to take this degeneracy tacitly into account and to consider only half of the above solutions . calculating also the corresponding free energies we find that ( a ) represents a basis function @xmath245 of length @xmath260 for a @xmath3 representation with energy @xmath261 . similarly , ( b ) represents a basis function of length @xmath262 for a @xmath2 representation with energy @xmath263 . finally , ( c ) consists of two degenerate basis functions with the components @xmath264 and @xmath265 , respectively , where @xmath244 and @xmath245 are given by the expressions of eq . ( [ solu3 ] ) , omitting @xmath259 in these expressions . the two basis functions yield a reducible two - dimensional representation containing both @xmath2 and @xmath3 symmetries . the corresponding free energy is @xmath266 . because of the assumption @xmath271 the free energy of ( a ) is always lower than that of ( b ) so that the ground state is given either by ( a ) or by ( c ) . 2 shows the ratio of the free energies of ( c ) and ( a ) as a function of @xmath269 for @xmath270 . for @xmath272 the curve in fig . 2 is always below 1 . thus the solution ( a ) has in this region the lowest free energy and describes the stable state . it is non - degenerate and its basis function belongs to an irreducible representation of @xmath3 symmetry . for @xmath273 the curve in fig . 2 is larger or equal to one . as a result solution ( c ) has the lowest free energy in this interval and describes a degenerate ground state . it is given by a two - dimensional reducible representation which consists both of @xmath2 and @xmath3 components . our calculation shows that this two - dimensional reducible representation may have a lower free energy than the @xmath2 and @xmath3 components . our calculation also demonstrates that the same basis functions may describe a degenerate or a non - degenerate ground state depending on the values of the coupling constants . this means that the degeneracy of a ground state described by a reducible two - dimensional representation is not enforced by symmetry as in the case of irreducible representations but depends in general on the values of the coupling constants . it thus can be considered to be accidential . e. blackburn , j. chang , m. hcker , a.t . holmes , n.b . christensen , r. liang , d.a . bonn , w.n . hardy , u. rtt , o. gutowski , m. v. zimmermann , e.m . forgan , and s.m . hayden , phys . lett . * 110 * , 137004 ( 2013 ) . s. blanco - canosa , a. frano , t. loew , y. lu , j. porras , g. ghiringhelli , m. minola , c. mazzoli , l. braicovich , e. schierle , e. weschke , m. le tacon , and b. keimer , phys . lett . * 110 * , 187001 , ( 2013 ) .

we study bond - order parameters for generalized @xmath0-@xmath1 models on a square lattice . using the plane - wave limit the considered order parameters form basis functions for irreducible representations of the symmetry transformations of the point group and of time reversal . we show that for instability wave vectors along the diagonals all possible basis functions are either fine - tuned ( i.e. , obey restrictions beyond the requirements of symmetry ) or break time reversal symmetry and thus describe flux states . for instability wave vectors along the crystalline axes , corresponding to the observed case in underdoped cuprates , there are only three representations with @xmath2 , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 symmetry which do not break time reversal symmetry in the general case . we suggest that one of them has recently been observed in resonant elastic x - ray scattering .

1702.07614

the efficiency of a crystal as a scintillator is parametrized by the light yield ( ly ) , defined as the number of photons emitted per unit of absorbed energy . a remarkable aspect outlined by different studies @xcite is that the @xmath1/@xmath2 ly of a crystal is not constant with the energy deposited inside the lattice . this characteristic , referred to as _ non - proportionality _ , prevents the correct reconstruction of the absorbed energy , affecting the energy calibration . moreover , the ly dependency on energy strongly affects the intrinsic component of the scintillator energy resolution @xcite . events having the same nominal energy can in fact result in multiple depositions differently affected by the _ non - proportionality _ , causing a final broadening of the energy peaks . in recent years great importance has been given to the study of _ non - proportionality _ , because of its correlation with the attainable energy resolution of scintillation crystals @xcite . in order to fully understand this feature , different crystals have been characterized , exciting the scintillation both with @xmath1 rays and charged particles , such as @xmath3s , @xmath2s and ions . in order to characterize the crystal independently from the detector , the ly _ non - proportionality _ has been measured as a relative variation with respect to the ly at the 662 kev @xmath1 line , referred to as _ relative light yield _ ( @xmath4 ) . as the excitation energy lowers , the @xmath4 increases for iodine crystals ( nai and csi for example ) and lowers for oxide crystals ( lso and bgo for example ) @xcite . moreover the @xmath4 is bigger in crystals characterized by worst energy resolution @xcite : as a consequence , the _ non - proportionality _ appears to be the fundamental limit to the attainable scintillators energy resolution . a definite theoretical explanation for the _ non - proportionality _ is not available and in recent years three phenomena have been addressed to as possible causes @xcite : the energy dependence of the relaxation channels , the landau fluctuations of the stopping power and the secondary electrons ( @xmath5-ray ) scattering . these models ascribe the observed _ non - proportionality _ to an actual change in ly , depending on the influence of intrinsic characteristics of crystals on the electrons / holes diffusion inside the lattice . these models generally predicts the behaviour of crystals , but can not give explanation to some particular features , such as the change of @xmath4 obtained with a change in the shaping time chosen for the scintillation pulse @xcite . in particular , the choice of larger shaping times both enhances the intrinsic energy resolution and reduces the @xmath4 . as a consequence , in this paper an in depth study of the _ non - proportionality _ dependence on shaping time is presented , in order to understand how deep this relation is . the compton coincidence technique ( cct ) has been used to measure the @xmath4 of three crystals with different time and light output characteristics ( see table [ cprop ] ) : cdwo@xmath0 , bgo , and nai(tl ) . the point in the application of this technique is that it allows the analysis of the crystal response to electrons @xcite . since the scintillation mechanism is based on the electron diffusion and recombination @xcite , the cct allows an in depth analysis of this phenomenon . .crystal properties table . data were taken from @xcite . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] as previously said , the ly _ non - proportionality _ has been measured as a relative variation with respect to the light yield at the 662 kev @xmath1 line , referred to as _ relative light yield _ ( @xmath4 ) . the obtained variable is given by the following expression : @xmath6 according to the current knowledge @xcite , both the cdwo@xmath7 and bgo crystals should present a negative _ non - proportionality _ , and their @xmath4 should decrease when the deposited energy lowers . on the other hand , the nai(tl ) crystal should be positively non - proportional , thus its @xmath4 should increase when the deposited energy lowers ( see figure [ nonproplit ] ) . crystal digitized by the adc at 60 mhz . ] as reported in @xcite the choice of the shaping time ( st ) used to shape the light signals can change the slope of the _ non - proportionality _ curve . to evaluate the actual effect of st , it has been chosen to apply a digital pulse processing algorithm ( dpp ) to the acquired preamplified scintillator pulses . this strategy allows to check the effects of different shaping times , without acquiring multiple measurements for every configuration . the developed algorithm implements the trapezoidal filtering of the acquired pulses and is based on the procedure adopted in @xcite . the transfer function of the filter , expressed in the z - transform domain , is : @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the number of samples used for rise and decay times , @xmath10 is the number of samples used for the flat top and @xmath11 is the factor responsible for the zero - pole cancellation . since the flat top was affected by noise fluctuations , it has been chosen to use a trapezoidal filter with no flat top , referred to as triangular filter ( see figure [ trapezoidalexample ] ) . in addition to the dpp technique , the digitalized preamplified pulses were also integrated numerically . this operation allows to estimate the amplitude of the light pulse without selecting a defined bandwidth , thus including the majority of the scintillation components . the results obtained for the _ non - proportionality _ behaviour with different sts , for cdwo@xmath7 , bgo and nai(tl ) crystals are reported respectively in figure [ rlycdwo ] , [ rlybgo ] and [ rlynai ] . from these data it can be inferred that the _ non - proportionality _ of scintillation crystals is determined by the st used to process the light signal . choosing a longer shaping time , in fact , causes all the studied crystals to be negatively non - proportional , while choosing a shorter shaping time causes the same crystals to be positively non - proportional . the transition between negative and positive deviation is different for each studied crystal , and it is related to the time characteristics of its scintillation . for example , on one hand the cdwo@xmath7 , which has a main scintillation time constant of @xmath12 @xmath13s , shows negative _ non - proportionality _ for st@xmath1410 @xmath15 . on the other hand the bgo , which has a main time constant of @xmath16 ns , shows negative deviations for st@xmath1450 ns . the obtained results show a clear correlation between the _ non - proportionality _ behaviour with energy and the st chosen to filter the light pulses . the observed behaviour can be explained by a dependence with energy of the involved scintillation component : faster components are predominant at lower energies , while higher energy events are characterized by longer scintillation times . this can be ascribed to an eventual enrolment mechanism of the activation sites in the crystal lattice : on one hand , the deposition of small energies activates just few sites characterized by a short decay time ; on the other hand , an event with higher energy causes the activation of different recombination sites , with both short and long characteristic times . as a consequence it could be inferred a sort of hierarchy between the recombination sites , ruled by the energy of the activation event and by its ionizing potential . the effect of the st is evident , since it causes the _ non - proportionality _ to space in a range between 0.5 and 2.5 . as expected , integrating the preamplifier signal causes the crystal to loose its _ non - proportionality_. ] , all the st@xmath1450 ns give the same effects , and a longer st ( 10 @xmath15 ) return a negative r@xmath17 . at high energies the r@xmath17 is lower than 1 , because the small size of the used bgo crystal ( 2x2x2@xmath18 ) did not allow the complete absorption of the electrons energy . ] and 5@xmath15 cause the observed behaviour to change from the literature studies ( figure [ nonproplit ] ) . ] a detailed study of the _ non - proportionality _ behaviour with energy of three different scintillation crystals ( cdwo@xmath0 , bgo and nai ) has been performed . the relation between _ non - proportionality _ and st has been characterized by the means of a dpp algorithm , which allowed to test different integration times on the same measurement . the obtained results suggest that the _ non - proportionality _ in light yield of scintillation crystals is not an intrinsic characteristics of the crystal itself : as a matter of fact , it depends on which part of the scintillation spectrum is considered in the pulse processing , since different scintillation components are selected by different sts . in the framework of high resolving scintillation detectors , this evidence can be used to tune the analysis strategy for the light pulses , optimizing the spectrometric performances of these crystals . on the other hand , this peculiar characteristics has to be further investigated , in order to enlighten the hidden characteristics of the scintillation mechanism of crystals . m. moszyski and a. syntfeld - kauch and l. swiderski and m. grodzicka and j. iwanowska and p. sibczyski and t. szczniak , _ energy resolution of scintillation detectors _ , _ nucl . instrumention and methods in physics research a _ * 805 * ( 2016 ) 25 - 35 . p. dorenbos and j. t. m. de haas and c. w. e. van eijk , _ non - proportionality in the scintillation response and the energy resolution obtainable with scintillation crystals _ , _ ieee transactions on nuclear science _ * 42 * ( 1995 ) 2190 - 2202 . john d. valentine , brian d. rooney , _ design of a compton spectrometer experiment for studying scintillator non - linearity and intrinsic energy resolution _ , _ nuclear instruments and methods in physics research a _ * 353 * ( 1994 ) 37 - 40 . john d. valentine and brian d. rooney , _ benchmarking the compton coincidence technique for measuring electron response non - proportionality in inorganic scintillators _ , _ ieee transactions on nuclear science _ * 43 * ( 1996 ) 1271 - 1276 . brian d. rooney and john d. valentine , _ scintillator light yield nonproportionality : calculating photon response using measured electron response _ , _ ieee transactions on nuclear science _ * 44 * ( 1997 ) 509 - 516 . n. tsuchida , m. ikeda , t. kamae , m. kokubun , _ temperature dependence of gamma - ray excited scintillation time profile and light yield of gso , yso , yap and bgo _ , _ nuclear instruments and methods in physics research section a _ * 385 * ( 1997 ) 290 - 298 . c. cuesta , m.a . olivn , j. amar , s. cebrin , e. garca , c. ginestra , m. martnez , y. ortigoza , a. ortiz de solrzano , c. pobes , j. puimedn , m.l . sarsa , j.a . villar , p. villar , _ slow scintillation time constants in nai(tl ) for different interacting particles _ , _ optical materials _ * 36 * ( 2013 ) 316 - 320 . m. moszyski , w. czarnacki , w. klamra , m. szawlowski , p. schotanus , m. kapusta , _ intrinsic energy resolution of pure nai studied with large area avalanche photodiodes at liquid nitrogen temperatures _ , _ nucl . instruments and methods in physics research section _ * 505 * ( 2003 ) 63 .

in recent years the scintillation mechanism of inorganic crystals has been extensively investigated in different studies @xcite . the main issues are the _ non - proportionality _ mechanism of the light response versus energy and its connection with the shaping time used for the scintillation signals . in this study the compton coincidence technique has been used to measure the relative _ non - proportionality _ of three crystals : cdwo@xmath0 , bgo , and nai(tl ) . to test the _ non - proportionality _ dependence on shaping time , the preamplified scintillator pulses have been digitized and shaped with a digital trapezoidal filter . since no analogic shaping occurs the majority of the scintillation components are digitized , thus avoiding major information losses . the obtained results suggest the existence of a correlation between the time constant of the scintillation emission and light yield .

nlin0606020

we present a numerical study of exact breather dynamics in two - dimensional nonlinear schrdinger lattices . this issue fits well with the enduring scientific interests of serge aubry in the many faceted subject of localization and transport in nonlinear macroscopic discrete systems , where serge s outstanding contributions are widely recognized . many ideas and lines of study followed in the investigation reported here have found a source of inspiration in early works of aubry and collaborators , among which the doctoral works of th . cretegny and j.l . marn deserve special mention . the existence and properties of localized solutions in extended discrete systems have atracted interest in a broad range of physical fields @xcite . discrete breathers , sometimes referred to as intrinsic localized modes , are spatially localized and time periodic solutions . these solutions arise in the context of nonlinear discrete systems and are of fundamental interest for varied physical applications such as pulse propagation in nonlinear optics , energy storing and transport in biomolecules , plasma physics , etc ... the existence of discrete breathers in these systems has been proved rigorously @xcite for a number of equations with physical relevance and , contrary to continuous nonlinear equations , their existence can be regarded as a generic feature of these systems . one of the most important class of equations are the so - called _ discrete nonlinear schrdinger lattices _ the existence of discrete breathers has been proven for a wide range of systems belonging to this class of nonlinear difference - differential equations . in particular , the most important example of wide aplicability is the standard nonlinear schrdinger equation . for instance , this equation was employed in @xcite for describing the propagation of localized beams in an array of nonlinear ( kerr type ) waveguides , having experimental validation subsequently reported in @xcite . the study of two - dimensional nonlinear schrdinger lattices has atracted much atention @xcite in recent years due to the new phenomena emerging when the dimensionality of the lattice is increased . some examples of these new features are the existence of vortex - breathers @xcite which supports energy flux , the appearance of an energy threshold for the creation of discrete breathers @xcite and the ubiquity of an instability ( the quasi - collapse ) of some discrete breather solutions leading to a highly localized pulson state @xcite . these theoretical efforts have their counterpart in recent advances in the field of nonlinear optics . the studies of two - dimensional arrays of coupled nonlinear waveguides allow the experimental observation of those effects studied theoretically . specially relevant is the recent experimental breakthrough ( theoretically designed in @xcite ) by fleisher _ et al _ @xcite , where a two - dimensional array of nonlinear waveguides is induced in a photosensitive material . this technique provides a clear experimental verification of the two - dimensional discrete breather existence in this system . in particular , besides the observation of standard discrete breathers , these works reported the first observations of staggered discrete breathers . our study here will focus on the computation of numerically exact dicrete breathers in two - dimensional anisotropic nonlinear schrdinger lattices , _ i.e. _ where the couplings in the two spatial directions are different . the use of shooting methods allow us to find these solutions and analyze their structural and stability properties . both pinned and mobile discrete breathers are studied . in the latter case we will study only the ones whose motion is along one axis of the lattice . the analysis of the numerically exact solutions shed light on some features of the properties and stability of localized solutions reported in previous works . the plan of the paper is as follows : in section [ sec : numerical ] we provide the technical background and details needed for self - contained purposes . first we summarize in [ subsec:1d ] the main conclusions on the dynamics of 1d schrdinger discrete breathers reported in @xcite . a detailed account of the numerical methods ( svd - regularized newton continuation of operator fixed points ) that we have used can be found in that reference . also in [ subsec:1d ] , we discuss briefly the most relevant formal differences with respect to alternative approaches to ( one - dimensional ) exact mobility of discrete breathers , _ e.g. _ those in refs @xcite and @xcite . in subsection [ sec : numerics ] we introduce the two - dimensional anisotropic salerno lattice and provide explanations on the implementation of the numerical procedures used to study the dynamics of 2d discrete breathers . the analysis of the results of our numerics on pinned discrete breathers for anisotropic nonlinear schrdinger lattices is reported in section [ sec : pinned ] . we present the numerical computations of the fixed point norm , as a function of three parameters : breather frequency , transversal coupling , and nonlinearity ( see below ) . they show , as anticipated , the so - called _ quasi - collapse _ transition , associated with the ( well - known ) existence of thresholds for the breather norm in two - dimensional lattices . we present numerically computed sectors of the bifurcation surface . we conclude this section with a brief look at the nonlinear dynamics on the unstable manifold , whose typical trajectories have been called _ pulson _ states . early numerical work on the 2d quasi - collapse phenomena in isotropic lattices was reported in @xcite and @xcite . a two - year - old account of the `` state of knowledge '' on 2d schrdinger lattices can be found in section six of @xcite . in section [ secc : mobile ] we show results on a type of mobile breather , namely those moving along the direction of stronger lattice coupling constant . the structure of each of these mobile exact discrete breathers is that of a localized moving _ core _ superimpossed on a specific extended state of resonant small amplitude radiation , the _ background_. we present here the results of an extensive floquet stability analysis of this type of solutions in two sectors of the three - dimensional parameter space , which clearly show the existence of two different transitions . the tangent space eigenvectors associated to each of the transitions are presented , and the relation of the unstable manifold trajectories to pulson states is analyzed afterwards . we conclude with section [ secc : conclusions ] , where we briefly review the results obtained and illustrate their possible implications for mobility of 2d discrete breathers . the use of numerical tools for the continuation of discrete breather solutions has been widely employed since their existence proof was reported ( see _ e.g _ @xcite ) . in particular , the design of numerical techniques for finding exact mobile breathers based on those employed for the pinned ones has been explored in the recent years @xcite and paves the way to resolving the still open question about discrete breather mobility . here , after reviewing the most important features of 1d mobile breathers in nonlinear schrdinger lattices , we briefly explain how the continuation method is implemented in our system . as was introduced in section [ sec : introduction ] , exact mobility of dicrete breathers in 1d schrdinger nonlinear lattices were numerically studied by the authors in previous works @xcite . in particular , a numerical continuation from the integrable _ ablowitz - ladik lattice _ , a - l , ( where exact mobile breathers can be calculated analytically @xcite ) , @xmath1 to the standard _ discrete nonlinear schrdinger equation _ , dnls , @xmath2 was performed within the so - called _ salerno model _ @xcite , @xmath3 where @xmath4 , @xmath5 and @xmath6 are the parameters accounting for the strength of the nonlinear terms . the above equation includes the former two relevant equations ( [ eq : al ] ) and ( [ eq : dnls ] ) , for ( @xmath7 , @xmath8 ) and ( @xmath9 , @xmath10 ) respectively , providing the desired interpolation needed to develop the continuation scheme . the integrability of equation ( [ eq : al ] ) provides for @xmath11 a two - parametric family of discrete breathers @xmath12\;{\mbox{exp}}[{\mbox{i}}(\alpha(n - x(t))-\omega(t))]\;,\ ] ] where the two parameters @xmath13 $ ] and @xmath14 describe the velocity and internal frequency of the solution @xmath15 the salerno lattice ( [ eq : salerno ] ) , possess two dynamical invariants , namely the hamiltonian , @xmath16 where @xmath17 denotes the complex conjugate of @xmath18 , and the norm @xmath19 in order to find exact mobile discrete breathers in the salerno model we define a ( @xmath20)-resonant solution @xmath21 referred to some time scale @xmath22 such that @xmath23 within the above definition , a mobile breather that translates @xmath24 sites after @xmath25 periods of the internal oscillation will satisfy equation ( [ eq : p - q_resonant ] ) when @xmath26 . in this sense , the continuation focuses on the families of ( @xmath20)-resonant discrete breathers , that is breather solutions with the two characteristic time scales ( corresponding to the breather velocity , @xmath27 , and the internal frequency , @xmath28 ) being commensurate . in all the computations we have used finite lattices with periodic boundary conditions ( pbc ) so that @xmath29 and @xmath30 ( with @xmath31 being the lattice size ) . in the previous works @xcite the authors start from those a - l solutions which are ( @xmath20)-resonant , we discretize ( fine grid ) the path @xmath32 ( with @xmath5 and @xmath6 being positive ) along the salerno model , and go through it computing the corresponding ( @xmath20)-resonant solutions for the pairs @xmath33 . we can choose the path without loss of generality because of the scaling property of equation ( [ eq : salerno ] ) . then , each solution is numerically computed as a fixed point of the map @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the lattice translation operator @xmath36 , and @xmath37 is the @xmath38-evolution map ( @xmath39 ) following the dynamics dictated by equation ( [ eq : salerno ] ) for the corresponding value of @xmath6 ( @xmath40 ) ; _ i.e. _ , @xmath41=\{\phi_{n}(t_{0}+t_b)\}$ ] . the continuation was then performed for a fine grid of frequencies belonging to the family of ( @xmath42)-resonant discrete breathers . the most important conclusion about discrete breathers in these nonlinear schrdinger lattices is that mobility in the non - integrable regime ( @xmath43 ) demands the presence of an extended _ background _ to which the fixed point solution is spatially asymptotic ( @xmath44 ) , _ i.e. _ the solution is exactly written as @xmath45 this expression defines the purely localized component @xmath46 of the solution . the background is a finite linear combination of nonlinear plane waves , @xmath47 $ ] . these plane waves are exact solutions of the salerno model ( [ eq : salerno ] ) being the nonlinear dispersion relation @xmath48\cos k_{j } - 2\nu |a_{j}|^{2}$ ] . the results concerning the characterization of the background are discussed in detail in @xcite , here we briefly summarize the most important features : * the set of `` @xmath49 '' plane waves which take part in the background of a @xmath50resonant discrete breather with internal frequency @xmath51 is derived by the simple selection rule for the wave - numbers @xmath52 @xmath53 _ i.e. _ only the plane waves which are ( @xmath20)-resonant with the internal period of the breather can be components of @xmath54 . the number of solutions of ( [ resonant ] ) fixes `` @xmath49 '' . * the amplitudes @xmath55 of the nonlinear plane waves differ by orders of magnitude . * there exist a strong positive correlation between the amplitude of the background and the strength of the peierls - nabarro barrier arising from the periodic lattice . this correlation is particularly clear when symmetry breaking transitions occur for the also studied case of @xmath56 and @xmath57 ( see reference @xcite ) , and reflects the link between non - integrability and the existence of the background dressing of the mobile core . * finally , the interpretation of the correlation described in _ ( iii ) _ is reinforced from a study of the energy evolution of the mobile core : _ there is an energy balance brought by the background when the core moves along the lattice_. in particular , it can be observed how the core energy oscillates periodically so that it takes the maximum energy value when the core visits the inter - site configuration . this extra energy periodically obtained by the core is provided by the background , with the energy maximum clearly related to the background amplitude . before concluding this subsection , it is worth commenting on some of the differences between the newton continuation of fixed points that we use in this paper , and other important recent approaches to breather numerics . the work by ablowitz _ et al _ @xcite uses discrete fourier analysis to obtain a nonlinear nonlocal integral equation , from where the `` ... soliton is thus viewed as a fixed point of a nonlinear functional '' ( sic ) in the fourier transformed space of functions . following these authors , their results seem to differ from those of early pioneering work @xcite ( nowadays textbook material @xcite ) `` in which a _ continuous _ travelling solitary waves were reported using fourier series expansions with finite period @xmath58 while assuming convergence as @xmath59 '' ( sic ) . et al _ term _ continuous _ a solution that can be defined off the lattice points , which they see as `` necessary when discussing travelling waves in lattices '' ( sic ) , and disagree with some conclusions reported in the earlier works . the ( `` orthodoxy matters '' ) discussion above helps us to clarify how differently our numerical approaches `` sees '' the discrete schrdinger breather problem : the very concept of a variable defined off the lattice points is intrinsically alien to our discrete approach , which neither needs of it nor excludes its eventual consideration . in contrast to those views ( but not at all in logical opposition ) , we consistently view the thermodynamical limit ( @xmath60 ) in lattice space , much in the sense used _ e.g. _ by serge aubry in his celebrated work on the frenkel - kontorova ground state problem @xcite : the infinite size limit is built up from a subsequence of pbc ( finite ) lattices for which the limit is well defined . this will make the fourier - transformed @xmath61-space continuum . closer to our approach in some respects , though technically different in many others , is the formal approach purposed recently by james and collaborators @xcite . this approach , which uses recent central manifold theorems , was brought to our attention very recently and unfortunately , we have to defer to a future publication a comparison of our 1d computations with theirs , this is beyond the scope of this paper , namely , the anisotropic 2d schrodinger lattices , which we introduce in the next subsection . motivated by the method described above , we can extend the continuation scheme for calculating exact discrete breathers in higher dimensional systems . in particular we focus on the two - dimensional nonlinear schrdinger lattice @xmath62 this lattice can be viewed as the _ two - dimensional salerno model_. the two coupling parameters @xmath63 and @xmath64 provide a technical advantage for numerics ( see below ) , but they are also introduced for theoretical and experimental interest . the possibility of controlling the ratio between the two linear couplings of the two transversal directions has been studied in various works as a way of analysing how the intrinsic 2d phenomena ( such as the quasi - collapse ) emerge . in fact , for @xmath65 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 equation ( [ eq:2d - dnls ] ) describes a set of weakly coupled nonlinear wavequide arrays and can be considered as a case of `` _ intermediate dimensionality _ '' . this extreme has been studied experimentally in @xcite and using perturbative methods in @xcite . on the other hand , this equation incorporates , as two particular limits , the physically relevant standard two - dimensional dnls equation ( @xmath9 , @xmath10 ) and the two - dimensional a - l lattice ( @xmath7 , @xmath8 ) . the continuation between these two limits provides a useful tool for studying the interplay between the on - site and inter - site nonlinearity in the 2d anisotropic lattice . moreover , the anisotropy ( or freedom in the values of the coupling parameters @xmath66 and @xmath67 ) allows to include an integrable model among the members of the family of nonlinear lattices described by ( [ eq:2d - dnls ] ) . that is , for @xmath8 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 one obtains a set of integrable a - l chains . in this way , every 2d model included in ( [ eq:2d - dnls ] ) is connected with an integrable model where analytic discrete breathers are available . in what follows we set @xmath70 and @xmath71 with @xmath72 and @xmath57 . the dynamics ( [ eq:2d - dnls ] ) can be derived from the salerno poisson structure @xmath73 with the hamiltonian @xmath74 as in the 1d salerno model there is also a second conserved quantity , the norm , due to the phase invariance of the equations of motion ( [ eq:2d - dnls ] ) @xmath75 in the same manner as in the 1d case we will focus on a special set of 2d discrete breathers . for this , we have to generalize the definition ( [ eq : p - q_resonant ] ) of a resonant solution in the two - dimensional case . in this context discrete breathers solutions are characterized by three time scales . namely , one associated with the internal oscillation @xmath28 and the other two derived from the translation of the localization center , _ i.e. _ its velocity @xmath76 . the subset of @xmath77-tuples ( @xmath28,@xmath78 ) that fulfil the ( @xmath79)-resonance condition @xmath80 ( where @xmath81 , @xmath82 and @xmath25 are integers ) denote the breather solution that can be obtained with our continuation method . these solutions are those that after @xmath25 periods of the internal frequency , @xmath83 , translates @xmath81 and @xmath82 lattice sites in the @xmath84 and @xmath85 direction of the square lattice , respectively , _ i.e. _ @xmath86 where again pbc are applied @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 ( with @xmath91 and @xmath92 being the lattice size in the @xmath84 and @xmath85 direction respectively ) . consequently , a ( @xmath79)-resonant state will be a solution of the following set of equations @xmath93 & = & { l}_{y}^{p_{y}}{l}_{x}^{p_{x } } { t}_{(\omega_{b } , \nu , c_{1 } , c_{2})}^q[\{\hat{\phi}_{n , m}(t_{0})\}]= \nonumber \\ & = & \{\hat{\phi}_{n , m}(t)\}\ ; , \label{eq:2d - map}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the operators @xmath94 are the lattice translation in the @xmath95-direction , @xmath96&=&\{\phi_{n+1,m}(t_{0})\}\ ; , \\ l_{y}[\{\phi_{n , m}(t_{0})\}]&=&\{\phi_{n , m+1}(t_{0})\}\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] besides , @xmath97 is the time evolution operator given by equation ( [ eq:2d - dnls ] ) over one period @xmath98 , @xmath99= \{\phi_{n , m}(t_{0}+t_{b})\}\;.\ ] ] in order to illustrate the 2d time scales resonance we consider the plane wave solutions of equation ( [ eq:2d - dnls ] ) : @xmath100 $ ] . these solutions possess the following nonlinear dispersion relation @xmath101 hence , we can obtain the subset of plane waves which are ( @xmath79)-resonant with some time scale @xmath22 ( _ i.e. _ after a time @xmath102 they have translated @xmath81 and @xmath82 sites in the @xmath84 and @xmath85 direction , respectively ) . each member of these subsets will be labelled by the pair @xmath103(@xmath104 , @xmath105 ) and from the condition ( [ eq:2d - map ] ) it follows that the corresponding set of values of @xmath106 for each family will satisfy the relation @xmath107 where @xmath108 is an integer and @xmath109(@xmath81 , @xmath82 ) . in figure [ fig : resonances ] the corresponding values of @xmath106 are represented for two resonances of the type @xmath110 and @xmath111 . cc the method used for solving equation ( [ eq:2d - map ] ) for each resonant @xmath77-tuple ( @xmath28,@xmath78 ) is the same as in the 1d case , which is extensively described in @xcite . the implicit function theorem assures that a fixed point solution of a map ( [ eq:2d - map ] ) given by @xmath112(@xmath81 , @xmath82 , @xmath25 , @xmath28 , @xmath6 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 ) can be obtained provided that _ ( i ) _ the jacobian of the operator @xmath113-{i}$ ] is invertible and _ ( ii ) _ we know a fixed point of a map corresponding to an infinitesimally close set of parameters , @xmath114 ( @xmath81 , @xmath82 , @xmath25 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 , @xmath118 ) . the first demand can be satisfied using a _ singular value decomposition _ ( svd ) @xcite of the jacobian in order to obtain the pseudo - inverse operator . on the other hand , when the second condition is fulfilled convergence of the newton - raphson iterative scheme is guaranteed . for this , we start with a sufficiently good trial solution , @xmath119 and solve the equation @xmath120^{-1}\cdot f_{\vec{\xi}}[\{\phi^{0}_{n , m}(t_{0})\}]\ ; , \label{eq : iteration}\ ] ] in order to obtain @xmath121 . we iterate this calculations to the desired convergence , and then the solution @xmath122 , is obtained . in our numerics this is the case when @xmath123<n\cdot10^{-16}\;,\ ] ] ( where @xmath31 is the total number of sites in the square lattice ) is fulfilled . once the solution is found we use it as the following trial solution , @xmath119 , for solving the map ( [ eq:2d - map ] ) corresponding to the next set of parameters @xmath124 . as an additional benefit , this method provides the linear stability of the computed solution . for this , we only have to compute the eigenvalues of the jacobian of the operator around the solution @xmath125 $ ] . in fact , this jacobian is the extended floquet matrix of the solution . then , a solution is linearly stable if all the eigenvalues of the corresponding floquet matrix are inside the unit circle . moreover , the symplectic character of the dynamics ( [ eq:2d - dnls ] ) implies that all the eigenvalues appear in quadruplets ( @xmath126 , @xmath127 , @xmath128 , @xmath129 ) and thus for a linearly stable solutions all the eigenvalues of its extended floquet matrix lie on the unit circle . there are two possible paths for developing the continuation method depending on the choice of the starting point of the continuation . one possibility is to start from the full anti - continuum limit , @xmath130 , where a pinned breather solution of frequency @xmath28 is written as @xmath131 starting from the above solution , we can perform the continuation increasing the parameters @xmath63 and @xmath64 as usual , and so obtain the whole family of ( @xmath132)-resonant discrete breathers . an alternative path starts from the one - dimensional limit , @xmath133 . the choice of this second limit ( which implies taking as the very initial trial solution of the continuation the whole set of 1d solutions described in section [ subsec:1d ] ) is justified when seeking mobile solutions . as stated above , this limit offers the possibility of studying strongly anisotropic lattices as a controlled interpolating situation between one and two dimensions . on the other hand , employing this strategy we can only obtain those solutions which are ( @xmath134)-resonant , _ i.e. _ the two - dimensional continuation of those one - dimensional ( @xmath135)-resonant discrete breathers . hence , the solution from which we start is @xmath136 where @xmath137 is the corresponding ( @xmath135)-resonant one - dimensional solution . in what follows we will employ both continuation paths when we study the case of pinned breathers ( section [ sec : pinned ] ) , and we will show that the results obtained are the same when approaching the same limit ( the standard two - dimensional dnls ) . as we have discussed , we can choose two different starting points for the continuation of @xmath138-resonant fixed points ( pinned breathers ) of equation ( [ eq:2d - map ] ) : _ ( i ) _ the full anti - continuum ( ac ) limit ( @xmath139 ) , or _ ( ii ) _ the ( one - dimensional , 1d ) limit of uncoupled chains ( @xmath140 ) , where they can be obtained from continuation along increasing values of the parameter @xmath6 from the 1d a - l lattice ( [ eq : al ] ) . as a test for our codes , we have checked that both paths arrive to the same solution . in fact , unique continuations can proceed along any path on the plane of parameters ( @xmath141 ) that we have explored . early works @xcite on the isotropic two - dimensional standard dnls equation analyzed the so - called _ quasi - collapse _ instability of pinned discrete breathers , _ i.e. _ the condensation of all the energy into a few modes in discrete nonlinear systems , which corresponds to the onset of a singularity ( wave collapse ) @xcite in multidimensional continuum models . subsequent numerical works @xcite extended these studies to the isotropic 2d salerno lattice and addressed the question of how the instability is affected by the presence of impurity lattice sites . as expected , our results further corroborate the existence of quasi - collapse instabilities in the anisotropic case : the phase diagram in parameter space ( @xmath51 , @xmath67 , @xmath6 ) consists of two regions ( stable and unstable ) separated by the surface of transition . as we perform the continuation of breather solutions across the parameter space we scan the floquet stability of the computed solution . in figure [ fig : ctresholds ] we present the two stability transition curves in the plane ( @xmath28 , @xmath64 , @xmath142 ) , _ i.e. _ the function @xmath143 , corresponding to the two different continuation starts . the continuation from the ac limit is made through the path @xmath144 and the one from the 1d limit is made at @xmath145 . the convergence of the two paths at @xmath146 is clearly seen . cc the criterion for stability of the pinned discrete breather solution derived in @xcite , @xmath147 is of a very general character and our numerics illustrate it clearly . on the other hand , the floquet stability analysis detects the dimensionality ( and a basis in tangent space ) of the unstable linear manifold associated with the quasi - collapse instability that these exact discrete breathers experience for some parameter values . we have computed numerically , for a fine grid of @xmath51 values and a coarser grid of @xmath67 and @xmath6 , the function @xmath148 , from which we show some sectors in figures [ fig : norma - c2 ] and [ fig : norma - nu ] . in figure [ fig : norma - c2 ] we show the numerically computed norm ( [ eq:2dnorm ] ) as a function of the breather frequency @xmath149 , for three different values of the transversal coupling @xmath67 , and a fixed value of @xmath150 ( anisotropic dnls limit ) . we observe the existence of a minimum value , @xmath151 , which is thus seen as an _ excitation threshold _ for the creation of these solutions . the position of the minimum @xmath152 , which _ naturally _ increases with @xmath67 , separates the stable and unstable branches of pinned breathers . breathers corresponding to values of @xmath51 where @xmath149 has a negative slope are unstable : this is shown in the insets , where the floquet spectra of two representative examples of pinned discrete schrdinger breathers are plotted in the complex plane . note that the high accuracy of the numerical solution allows an unprecedented detailed floquet analysis of the instability , paving the way to rigorous analytical characterizations of the quasi - collapse unstable manifold . this is a one - dimensional manifold , as our numerical results unambiguously confirm . then , in the regime of small time scales , the unstable manifold is fully characterized by a single floquet eigenvector . cc figure [ fig : norma - nu ] shows the ( surface ) function @xmath153 for the volume sector of constant @xmath67(@xmath154 ) . most noticeably , the critical ( threshold ) line of bifurcation points ( @xmath155 ) , as seen in the inset , does not define a monotone function @xmath156 . in fact , in the whole interval of @xmath157 values , the range of values of @xmath158 is quite short , indicating the insensitibity of the gross features of the quasi - collapse transition to the value of @xmath6 . however , considering finer details , one sees that the threshold curve @xmath156 smoothly reaches its slightly larger values around midway between the dnls and the a - l limits . in other words , intermediate values of the interpolating ( salerno ) parameter @xmath6 somewhat favour the enhancement of the quasi - collapse unstable region . these conclusions are in contrast with the stated conclusion ( for isotropic lattices ) in @xcite that the ablowitz - ladik term increases the stability regime . cc when instability is allowed to develop beyond the fixed point tangent space into the nonlinear realm of perturbations , the trajectory obtained by direct integration of the equations of motion invariably ends after a transient ( of time scale given by the real floquet exponent larger than @xmath159 ) in a localized solution with complex dynamics , the _ pulson states_. these states were characterized in @xcite in the following terms `` ... where the peak intensity @xmath160 oscillates between the central site and its four nearest neighbours ... it is not known whether these pulson states represent true quasiperiodic solutions to the dnls equation '' . what makes these trajectories on the unstable nonlinear quasi - collapse manifold of much practical relevance and interest is their ubiquity : they appear as persistent localized states in the hamiltonian dynamical evolution from a wide variety of initial conditions . their description requires at least two frequencies , namely the internal ( genuine breather - like frequency ) and the frequency of the oscillations of the _ breather width _ around a mean width value , which turns out to be less than the width of the unstable exact discrete breather . second and outer shells of neighbours ( in both lattice axes ) also participate in the width oscillations . cc though a more detailed characterization of the pulson states will be presented elsewhere , it is illustrative to consider ( figure [ fig : qc - fft ] ) the power spectrum of the field at the central site of a typical trajectory on the unstable nonlinear manifold of a quasi - collapsing pinned discrete breather . this shows peaks at the combinations @xmath161 ( @xmath162 ) , where @xmath163 is the frequency of the width oscillations characterizing the pulson state , while @xmath164 is a frequency higher than the ( initial condition ) fixed point frequency @xmath51 . the new frequency @xmath165 turns out to be very close to the breather frequency of the same ( initial ) norm on the stable branch . in other words , the instability drives a shift of breathing frequency towards the stable branch , while the excess energy is transferred to the oscillatory motion of the observable width . this behavior seems to be the essence of the physical characterization of the nonlinear quasi - collapse manifold dynamics . the numerical observation of a two - frequency power spectrum for a typical pulson state points towards an eventual positive answer to the question ( on true quasiperiodicity ) arised in @xcite , though , for more details we have to refer to the phd dissertation @xcite . this point serves to illustrate how the high accuracy of the fixed point numerical solution provides detailed clues on many still unsolved ( from a mathematical and physical point of view ) questions on two - dimensional schrdinger localization , which are of prospective experimental interest in nonlinear ( photonic , josephson , ... ) physics technologies . early and current attempts to explore straightaway discrete breather mobility in isotropic 2d schrdinger lattices seem to agree @xcite that `` kicking '' procedures meet huge difficulties in delivering good mobile solutions , contrary to the numerical experiences in 1d lattices . we note here that the formal basis for those methods @xcite takes advantage of the floquet spectra analysis of exact pinned breathers , where the so - called _ depinning _ ( symmetry - breaking ) mode is identified . this allows , _ provided peierls - nabarro barriers are small enough _ , to obtain nice numerical 1d mobile discrete breathers , by computing trajectories from perturbations of the exact pinned breather along the tangent space direction specified by the depinning eigenvector . the presence of symmetry - breaking instabilities leading to exchange of stability between one - site and two - site centered pinned breathers @xcite and the associated lowering of the peierls - nabarro barriers to breather displacements , hugely facilitating the success of these procedures when applied to ( both hamiltonian and dissipative ) one - dimensional lattices . @xcite in contrast , our `` anisotropic lattice '' continuation approach takes advantage of the availability of exact 1d mobile solutions by monitoring the parameter @xmath67 of transversal coupling , and then does not rely on how easily one promotes clean mobility from pinned localization . in this way we obtain accurate numerical ( @xmath166 ) fixed points , that is schrdinger discrete breathers moving along the strong coupling direction . in a forthcoming paper we will address the ( much more difficult ) question for arbitrary direction of motion . in figure [ fig : mob - structure ] we visualize the instantaneous real and imaginary components of the 2d discrete field profile of a typical ( 1,0,1 ) schrdinger breather . its structure can be seen as the natural extension to two - dimensional lattices of the structure of mobile schrdinger breathers analyzed in @xcite . the numerical solution is spatially asymptotic to a _ finely tuned _ small - amplitude extended ( delocalized ) radiation state @xmath167 when @xmath168 . the fixed point solution can be thus decomposed as @xmath169 which defines @xmath170 , the spatially _ localized _ component of the solution . it turns out that the spatially _ delocalized _ component is a highly localized state in the ( continuum , in the thermodynamic limit ) @xmath61-space of wavevectors . more precisely , @xmath171 is a finite linear combination of ( 1,0,1 ) -resonant nonlinear ( _ i.e. _ amplitude - dependent frequency @xmath172 ) 2d planewaves . it can be said that , as might be expected , 1d schrdinger breather mobility smoothly persists when ( strong @xmath66-coupling ) 1d chains are coupled transversally . importantly , the numerical continuation for increasing values of the transversal coupling @xmath67 proceeds far from the weak coupling regime into where the genuine two - dimensional effects start to be manifest , as we will see below . cc most noticeable , the svd - regularized newton procedure invariably selects the values @xmath173 for all values of @xmath67 and @xmath6 , and thus the values of @xmath174 for the 2d resonant planewave are independent of @xmath67 ( so it remains equal to the @xmath61 values of the 1d ( @xmath175 ) fixed point for the uncoupled chain ) . the appearance of an extended background modulation in the transversal direction of @xmath176 appears naturally as the _ best _ choice to take advantage of approximately 1d breather propagation along strong coupling direction , for it keeps the value of @xmath174 favoured by the strong coupling @xmath66 value : any other value of @xmath177 would entail a different @xmath174 value . note however that this provides only a _ plausibility argument _ for the interpretation of the numerical observation ( @xmath176 ) . the high accuracy of the computed solutions allows a detailed analysis of many issues concerning 2d schrdinger breather exact mobility along the strong coupling direction . we leave aside in this paper many of them , and focus here on how the existence of quasi - collapse instabilities of pinned schrdinger breathers , for increasing @xmath67-coupling values , influences the stability properties of moving ( @xmath178 ) breathers . in other words , we search here for genuine 2d effects on these `` strong - coupling -direction '' ( quasi-1d ) moving breathers . we have performed an exhaustive exploration of two sectors of the parameter space ( @xmath179 ) , corresponding to the breather frequency values @xmath180 , and @xmath181 , by computing the continued ( @xmath178 ) fixed point . these values of @xmath51 were chosen low enough to allow the analysis of pinned breather quasi - collapse effects on mobility , which occurs at relatively low values of @xmath182 for these values of @xmath172 . cc + the floquet analysis of the computed solutions provides the stability diagrams represented in figures [ fig : mob - stability ] . both show no qualitative differences : there are two regions in the ( @xmath183 ) plane where the ( @xmath178 ) mobile breather is linearly unstable . the figures are not `` schematic '' : every point of the plane in a fine grid of values of @xmath67 and @xmath6 has been analyzed , _ i.e. _ the floquet spectrum of the computed ( @xmath178 ) fixed point is scrutinized , as shown in figures [ fig : mob - stability].b and [ fig : mob - stability].d , where the modulus of the floquet eigenvalues is shown as a function of either @xmath6 ( figure [ fig : mob - stability].b ) or @xmath67 ( figure [ fig : mob - stability].d ) . the first unstable region appears at low values of @xmath67 and intermediate to high values of the salerno parameter @xmath6 , _ i.e. _ it does not occur close to the a - l limit . this unstable region is also bounded above in the direction of @xmath67 : the variation of the modulus of the unstable floquet eigenvalue versus the transversal coupling parameter @xmath67 shows that the mobile breather becomes stable again at larger values of @xmath67 , before the second instability at even higher coupling takes place . an important observation is that the pinned discrete breather of the same frequency is _ linearly stable _ at the points in this unstable region for ( 1,0,1 ) mobile breathers . thus this instability can not be ascribed to pinned quasi - collapse effects . the second transition occurs for values of @xmath67 close to , but slightly higher than , the values @xmath184 of the quasi - collapse of the pinned breather of the same frequency . we had already seen in the previous section that the quasi - collapse transition @xmath182 is only very weakly dependent on the value of @xmath6 , and note that the same is true for this mobile breather bifurcation . these results suggest that this second transition is related to quasi - collapsing phenomena . significantly , the stability of the ( @xmath178 ) mobile breather persists for a small interval of coupling values above the pinned breather quasi - collapse . this should be regarded as natural , for the mobile breather is a different solution . note in figure [ fig : mob - stability].b that the modulus of the unstable floquet eigenvalue , in the interior of the unstable region , reaches much higher values than those typical for the first type of instability , and decreases for larger values of @xmath67 , before the breather solution ceases to exist and only plane wave solutions are obtained by our numerical method . note that this behaviour of the unstable floquet eigenvalue also fits well to the main features of the pinned quasi - collapse instability strength , as described by the slope @xmath185 . from now on we will refer to this instability of mobile breathers as the quasi - collapse instability . in the next subsection we characterize both generic types of instability , by looking at the details of the unstable manifold associated with each type . as we will see , pulson states turn out to play a role in the description of typical trajectories on the unstable nonlinear manifolds . first , we analyze the quasi - collapse instability of ( @xmath178 ) mobile breathers . the unstable linear subspace in the tangent space of the fixed point is one - dimensional . the typical instantaneous profile of the ( modulus ) unstable floquet eigenvector driving the instability is shown in figure [ fig : unstabledyn].d . it is an exponentially localized 2d profile which decays asymptotically to zero as @xmath186 , _ i.e. _ it does not excite radiation . these characteristics are shared by the quasi - collapse unstable eigenvector of the pinned breathers , which further reinforce the previous considerations leading us to consider this instability as the mobile counterpart of the pinned quasi - collapse transition . in figure [ fig : unstabledyn].c we have visualized the time evolution of the field modulus contour plot for a typical trajectory on the unstable manifold . this is obtained by direct numerical integration of the equations of motion , from an initial condition in which a small perturbation along the quasi - collapse eigenvector has been added to the unstable fixed point solution . one sees that the breather translational motion slows down , and the energy is transferred to width oscillations . these oscillations turn out to be more irregular , see figure [ fig : qc - evolution ] , than those observed in section [ sec : pinned ] when we inspected typical trajectories on the unstable nonlinear manifold of pinned breathers . 1 cc + the difference in the character of the width oscillations in both ( pinned and mobile ) cases may be ascribed to the presence of an extended background component in the mobile breather solution , which naturally enters into the energy transfer taking place during temporal evolution . the slowing down of the translational motion continues and eventually the breather pins into a convulsive pulson state surrounded by the remaining radiation . now we pay attention to the `` low @xmath67 '' instability of ( @xmath178 ) mobile breathers . the modulus profile of the unstable floquet eigenvector that drives this instability is m - shaped ( bimodal ) , as shown in figure [ fig : unstabledyn].b , and is asymptotic to an extended planewave - like profile as @xmath168 , _ i.e. _ it is not a purely localized perturbation . it is indeed rather different from the quasi - collapse unstable eigenvector analyzed above , which is consistent with the fact that the pinned breather of the same frequency is linearly stable in this region of parameter space . as argued above , this instability is not related to quasi - collapse phenomena , and it does not appear in the region of small values of the salerno parameter @xmath6 , close to the a - l limit . cc a typical trajectory on the unstable manifold associated with this instability is shown in figure [ fig : unstabledyn].a , where we have plotted the time evolution of the field modulus contour plot . we can see there that the mobile breather pins quickly while a small pulse moving backwards is ejected , which spreads and finally mixes with the remaining delocalized background . however some energy is transferred to width oscillations of the pinned breather so that also in this case we observe the formation of pulson states surrounded by the remaining radiation . as the main difference of this behaviour , with respect to the evolution observed on the quasi - collapse unstable manifold , is the ejection of the small moving pulse , we refer to this instability as _ fission_. by increasing the strength of the initial perturbation along the direction of the unstable eigenvector , one observes that the size of the ejected pulse increases . this observation is consistent with the results reported in @xcite , where the evolution of initial moving gaussian pulses in isotropic 2d schrdinger lattices was studied . these numerical experiences lead the authors to conclude that `` the characteristic feature of the discrete quasi - collapse of a moving pulse is the splitting of the initially moving broad pulse into a track of the standing narrow structures ... '' ( sic ) . however , we see from our study of the stability of exact moving discrete breathers that the fission and the quasi - collapse instabilities have different origins and they appear in different regions of parameter space . on the other hand , the ubiquitous phenomenon of width oscillations of pinned localized structures ( pulson states ) can not be ascribed to quasi - collapse . they also appear as the preferred way to allocate excess of ( localization ) energy in regions of parameter space far from the quasi - collapse unstable region . we have studied here the dynamics of exact numerical discrete breathers , both pinned and mobile , in two - dimensional anisotropic nonlinear schrdinger lattices . these solutions are computed using a svd - regularized newton method by continuation from a set of uncoupled 1d chains into increasing non - zero values of the coupling in the transversal direction . we have performed an extensive exploration in the parameter space ( @xmath28 , @xmath64 , @xmath6 ) of breather frequency , transversal coupling and salerno parameter , by computing the floquet spectra of the numerical solutions . we have also computed the breather norm @xmath187 and further corroborate the general validity of the criterion found in @xcite , namely that the partial derivative @xmath188 is positive for stable pinned breathers . furthermore , we have analyzed the dynamics on the quasi - collapse unstable manifold , where the unstable breather experiences a shift in frequency towards the ( higher ) value of the stable breather with the same norm . the excess of energy is coherently transferred to oscillations of the breather width , so that the resulting pulson state is characterized by two frequencies . we have studied discrete breathers moving along the strong coupling direction . these solutions are composed of an exponentially localized core on top of an extended background which is itself the finite sum of a finite set of nonlinear 2d plane waves . the time scales asociated with these plane waves are resonant with the core internal frequency as happens in the 1d case . in particular , the background chooses a finite set of plane waves from a continuous family of resonant solutions . the floquet analysis of these mobile discrete breathers reveals the existence of two distinct types of instability . one is the counterpart , for mobile breathers , of the quasi - collapse experienced by pinned breathers . the other instability occurs in a region of parameter space where pinned breathers are linearly stable . the analysis of the dynamics on the unstable manifold show that the excess of energy is partly transferred to a small moving pulse , ejected from the center of localization , which justifies the designation of a fission instability . however , part of the energy excess is also transferred to width oscillations . the appearance of pulson states far from the quasi - collapse regime indicates that the tendency to allocate energy in the form of width oscillations is a general 2d feature , not exclusively associated to quasi - collapse instabilities . in a future work we will focus on mobility of 2d discrete breathers in an arbitrary lattice direction . the results obtained here shed light about how this mobility can be obtained . in fact , our experiences show that mobility of pinned breathers can be induced based on the existence of the extended background in the numerically exact mobile solution . on the other hand , the results obtained here and the aforementioned future work may help to design and better understand recent numerical experiments reported in @xcite , concerning the interaction between high amplitude pinned breathers and mobile ones . these experiments provides a possible way for routing and blocking mobile discrete breathers via the interaction with the high amplitude pinned ones , resulting in a plausible implementation of logical functions . the authors acknowledge f. falo , yu . kivshar , r.s . mackay and m. peyrard for sharing thoughts , and pointing out some important references to us . jg - g and lmf are grateful to m. johansson and b. malomed for discussions on some issues regarding the `` travelling wave '' ( orthodox ) perspective on discrete breathers . financial support came from mcyt ( project no . bfm2002 00113 ) , dga and bifi . jg - g akcnowledges financial support from the mecyd through a fpu grant . work at los alamos performed under the auspices of the us doe . j. c. eilbeck and m. johansson , in proceedings of _ localization and energy transfer in nonlinear systems _ , edited by l. vzquez , r. s. mackay , and m. p. zorzano ( world scientific , singapore , 2003),p.44 . t. peschel and f. lederer , proceedings of the confererence on nonlinear coherent structures in physics and biology , d.b . duncan and j.c . eilbeck eds . , published on www : http://www.ma.hw.ac.uk/solitons/procs/

we study the structure and stability of discrete breathers ( both pinned and mobile ) in two - dimensional nonlinear anisotropic schrdinger lattices . starting from a set of identical one - dimensional systems we develop the continuation of the localized pulses from the weakly coupled regime ( strongly anisotropic ) to the homogeneous one ( isotropic ) . mobile discrete breathers are seen to be a superposition of a localized mobile core and an extended background of two - dimensional nonlinear plane waves . this structure is in agreement with previous results on one - dimensional breather mobility . the study of the stability of both pinned and mobile solutions is performed using standard floquet analysis . regimes of quasi - collapse are found for both types of solutions , while another kind of instability ( responsible for the discrete breather fission ) is found for mobile solutions . the development of such instabilities is studied examining typical trajectories on the unstable nonlinear manifold . [ physica d * 216 * , 31 ( 2006 ) ] , and 05.45.@xmath0a , 63.20.pw

astro-ph0610026

the accelerated expansion of the universe has now been confirmed by several independent observations including those of high redshift type ia supernovae , and the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) combined with the large scale structure of the universe @xcite . another way of presenting this kinematic property of the universe is to postulate the existence of a new entity dark energy ( de ) . this latter statement is dynamical in nature and therefore requires some assumptions to be made about the form of gravitational field equations governing the evolution of the ( observed part of the ) universe . although observationally well established , no single theoretical model provides an entirely compelling framework within which cosmic acceleration or de can be understood . indeed , the very many models of de existing in the literature illustrate that its nature is still very much an enigma . at present , all existing observational data are in agreement with the simplest possibility of de being a cosmological constant @xmath2 with @xmath3gev@xmath4 ( inside @xmath5 error bars in the worst case ) . is used throughout the paper . ] this case is internally self - consistent and non - contradictory . the extreme smallness of the cosmological constant expressed in either planck , or even atomic units means only that its origin is _ not _ related to strong , electromagnetic and weak interactions ( in particular , to the problem of the energy density of their vacuum fluctuations ) . where @xmath6 is some characteristic neutrino rest - mass ( the lightest one ? ) suggests that vacuum energy of the interaction responsible for non - zero neutrino rest - masses may be relevant for a non - zero @xmath2 . ] although in this case de reduces to only a single fundamental constant we still have no derivation from any underlying quantum field theory for its small value . within this context it is but natural that other possibilities admitting a ( slightly ) variable dark energy have also been actively studied by the scientific community in recent years . moreover , it is interesting that properties of the currently observed ` late de ' are _ qualitatively _ similar to those of an ` early de ' which is believed to have given rise to accelerated expansion ( inflation ) in the early universe . however in the case of the latter , there are sufficient grounds to support the view that ` early de ' was unstable and , thus , more complicated than a cosmological constant . so , it is natural to conjecture by analogy that the same might also be true of ` late de ' . de models proposed to account for the present cosmic acceleration include : + ( i ) quiessence with @xmath7 , the @xmath2 ( @xmath8 ) is a special member of this class . + ( ii ) quintessence models which are inspired by the simplest class of inflationary models of the early universe and employ a scalar field rolling down a potential @xmath9 to achieve late - time acceleration . quintessence potentials with @xmath10 have the attractive property that approaches a common evolutionary ` tracker path ' from a wide range of initial conditions . + ( iii ) the chaplygin gas model ( cg ) has the equation of state @xmath11 and evolves as @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the redshift , @xmath14 . it therefore behaves like dark matter at early times ( @xmath15 ) and like the at late times . cg appears to be the simplest model attempting to unify de and non - baryonic cold dark matter . + ( iv ) ` phantom ' de ( @xmath16 ) . + ( v ) oscillating de . + ( vi ) models with interactions between de and dark matter . + ( vii ) scalar - tensor de models . + ( viii ) modified gravity de models in which the gravitational lagrangian is changed from @xmath17 to @xmath18 where @xmath17 is the scalar curvature and @xmath19 is an arbitrary function . + ( ix ) dark energy driven by quantum effects . + ( x ) higher dimensional ` braneworld ' models in which acceleration is caused by the leakage of gravity into extra dimensions . + ( xi ) holographic dark energy , etc . + see the reviews @xcite for an exhaustive list of models and references . however , none of these models leads to the reduction of the number of fundamental constants ( parameters in the microscopic lagrangian ) as compared to standard @xmath2cdm . in other words , at the current state - of - the - art , de requires at least one new parameter whose value is set from observations . models with variable de can be broadly divided into two main classes : , in these models de is the energy density of some new , very weakly interacting physical field . ( otherwise dubbed modified gravity models ) . in these models the gravity equations do not coincide with those of einsteinian general relativity . however , it is usually possible to re - write the new equations in the conventional _ einsteinian _ form by transferring all additional terms from the l.h.s . into the r.h.s . of the einstein equations and referring to them as an effective energy - momentum tensor of de ( see sec . 2 below ) . ( precisely this happened to the cosmological constant which originally appeared in the l.h.s . of einstein s field equations but is now felt by many to constitute an effective matter term such as vacuum energy , etc . ) another category , which is even more important from the observational point of view , arises in response to the question whether or not the description of de requires a new field degree of freedom (= a new kind of matter ) . if the answer is in the affirmative then de may be considered as being ` induced ' by other kinds of matter . all physical de models and many geometrical ones belong to this category but there do exist geometrical de models which do not ( for instance the @xmath18 model with the palatini variation of its action ) . faced with the increasing proliferation of de models each with its own physical motivations and assumptions , a concerned cosmologist can proceed in either of two ways : \(i ) test _ every single _ model against observations . \(ii ) try and ascertain properties of dark energy in a _ model independent manner_. in this article , we proceed along route ( ii ) and attempt to review both the successes as well as difficulties faced by methods attempting to reconstruct the properties of dark energy directly from observations in a model independent manner . before attempting to determine its properties , we first need to provide a definition of _ dark energy_. a traditional approach is to use the einstein form of the gravitational field equations [ einst ] r _ - 12g_r = 8 g ( _ a t_^(a ) + t_^de ) as providing a _ definition _ of the effective energy - momentum tensor @xmath20 of de . here , the summation over @xmath21 in the r.h.s . includes all types of matter known from laboratory experiments ( protons , neutrons , photons , neutrinos , etc . ) as well as non - relativistic non - baryonic cold dark matter ( whose energy - momentum tensor is dust - like in the first approximation @xmath22 ) . @xmath23 is the present value of newton s gravitational constant . this definition has a number of advantages : + ( i ) it is simple , well - defined and self - consistent ; + ( ii ) it treats physical and geometrical de on an equal footing ; + ( iii ) in the absence of direct physical interaction between de with known forms of matter or with cold dark matter , the de energy - momentum tensor is conserved : @xmath24 . + one should stress here that using ( [ einst ] ) we automatically ascribe terms describing ( possible ) gravitational interactions between de and non - relativistic matter , as well as the matter energy - momentum tensor multiplied by a change in the effective gravitational constant , to the de energy - momentum tensor . the latter possibility arises , for instance , in scalar - tensor de models . when applied to a homogeneous and isotropic friedmann - robertson - walker ( frw ) cosmological model , eqs . ( [ einst ] ) reduce to two algebraically independent equations : h^2 & = & ( _ a _ a + _ de ) - , [ eq : acc ] + & = & -(_a ( _ a + 3p_a ) + _ de + 3p_de ) [ eq : acc1 ] where @xmath25 is the frw scale factor and the hubble parameter @xmath26 . at late times when radiation may be neglected , one gets [ eq : energy ] _ de = ( 1 - _ m ) where we have omitted the contribution from the curvature term in ( [ eq : acc ] ) for simplicity . @xmath27 is the total density of non - relativistic matter in terms of its critical value . similarly , the expression for the deceleration parameter q - a / ah^2 = x - 1 , x = 1 + z [ eq : decel1 ] ( prime implies differentiation with respect to @xmath28 ) takes the form : p_de = ( q - ) . [ eq : pressure ] dividing ( [ eq : pressure ] ) by ( [ eq : energy ] ) we get the following expression for the _ effective _ equation of state ( eos ) of dark energy ( @xmath29 ) : [ eq : state ] w(x ) = 2 q(x ) - 1 3 ( 1 - _ m(x ) ) . for physical de , the eos makes physical sense . however , this is not so for geometrical de for which the acceleration of the universe is caused by the fact that the field equations describing gravity are not einsteinian . as a specific example of geometrical de consider the widely studied dgp braneworld @xcite for which [ eq : dgp ] h = + , where @xmath30 is a new length scale and @xmath31 and @xmath32 refer respectively to the four and five dimensional planck mass . the acceleration of the universe in this model arises not because of the presence of de but due to the fact that gravity becomes five dimensional on length scales @xmath33 . the contrast between ( [ eq : acc ] ) and ( [ eq : dgp ] ) makes it abundantly clear that for models such as dgp the eos in ( [ eq : state ] ) is an _ effective _ quantity ( @xmath34 ) , which may still be useful for descriptive purposes but which no longer represents any fundamental physical property of an accelerating universe . indeed , instances are known when @xmath35 even when matter itself satisfies the weak energy condition @xmath36 @xcite . it may be instructive to note that , for geometrical de , @xmath1 may show pathological behaviour in certain cases , such as the presence of poles at finite values of redshift , @xmath37 , even though the underlying cosmological model is completely well behaved ( see for instance @xcite ) . for such models , the deceleration parameter @xmath38 and other geometrical parameters prove to be more robust for determining de properties than the eos . we shall return to these important issues in section [ sec : statefinder ] . observational tests of de rely on an accurate measurement of at least one of the following quantities : 1 . the luminosity distance [ eq : lumdis ] = _ 0^z . the angular size distance [ eq : angdis ] d_a(z ) = _ 0^z . the coordinate distance [ eq : coordis ] r(z ) = _ 0^z . here , we have assumed that the universe is spatially flat for simplicity . note that the distance duality relation @xmath39 which follows from ( [ eq : lumdis ] ) and ( [ eq : angdis ] ) is valid only for metric theories of gravity @xcite . its violation ( if observed ) could , therefore , be used to probe alternative theories of gravity . existing data , however , appear to support it ( within observational errors ) @xcite . in all of the above expressions the value of the hubble parameter can be ` reconstructed ' through a relation similar to the one given below for the luminosity distance @xcite : [ eq : h ] h(z)=^-1 . differentiating a second time allows one to reconstruct the equation of state of de ( [ eq : state ] ) . equations ( [ eq : state ] ) and ( [ eq : h ] ) immediately inform us that @xmath1 will be a noisier quantity than @xmath0 since two successive differentiations are needed for the reconstruction @xmath40 while a single differentiation suffices for @xmath41 . this has led several people to suggest @xmath0 ( or @xmath42 ) as being better suited for providing a model independent description of properties of de . another important difference between @xmath0 defined in ( [ eq : h ] ) and @xmath1 in ( [ eq : state ] ) is that the former is independent of the value of the matter density parameter @xmath27 while the latter is not . as a result , uncertainties in the current value of @xmath27 affect the reconstruction of the eos far more profoundly than they do @xmath0 . we shall return to this issue in section [ sec : obstacle ] . knowing @xmath0 ( either through ( [ eq : h ] ) or using corresponding relations for other observational tests ) , allows us to extend cosmological reconstruction to other important physical properties of the universe including : * its age [ eq : age ] t(z ) = _ z^ . * the deceleration parameter ( [ eq : decel1 ] ) and the equation of state ( [ eq : state ] ) ; * the electron - scattering optical depth to a redshift @xmath43 ( z_reion ) = c_0^z_reion , [ eq : reion ] where @xmath44 is the electron density and @xmath45 is the thomson cross - section describing scattering between electrons and cmb photons . * the product @xmath46 , which plays a key role in the alcock paczynski anisotropy test @xcite . * the product @xmath47 , which is used in the volume - redshift test @xcite . * the parameter @xmath48 associated with the determination of the baryon acoustic peak @xcite a = _ 0^z_1 ^2/3 = 0.469 0.017 , where @xmath49 and @xmath50 is the redshift at which the acoustic scale has been measured in the redshift sample . * the ` shift ' parameter @xmath17 associated with the cmb @xcite + r = _ 0^z_lss = 1.7 0.03 . for quintessence , it is additionally possible to reconstruct its potential , since the einstein equations @xmath51 can be rewritten as ( see , for instance , @xcite ) : @xmath52 integrating ( [ eqn : phidot ] ) , one determines @xmath53 to within an additive constant . the inversion @xmath54 followed by substitution into ( [ eqn : vzed ] ) allows us to reconstruct @xmath9 , since @xmath0 and its first derivative can be determined from observations using ( [ eq : h ] ) . the presence of @xmath55 in ( [ eqn : vzed ] ) and ( [ eqn : phidot ] ) implies that the value of the matter density must be known rather precisely for an accurate reconstruction of @xmath9 . in several important cases ( [ eqn : vzed ] ) and ( [ eqn : phidot ] ) have led to a closed form expression for @xmath9 , for instance : * de with a constant equation of state @xmath56 is described by @xcite + v()=3h_0 ^ 2(1-w)(1-_m0)^1/|w| 16g_m0^ ^-2(|w| ( -_0+_1 ) ) , [ quequi ] where = , _ 0=(t_0 ) , _ 1= . consequently , a universe consisting of such a scalar field will have expansion properties which closely mimic a different kind of de , e.g. , a tangled network of cosmic strings ( @xmath57 ) or domain walls ( @xmath58 ) . * the chaplygin gas model which unifies dark matter and de and has @xmath59 can be described by the scalar field potential @xcite ( in the absence of additional cold dark matter and neglecting baryons and photons ) : + v ( ) = ( ( 2 ) + ) . note that the behaviour of the chaplygin gas may also be modelled completely differently using a scalar field with the born - infeld kinetic term @xcite ( a specific type of k - essence ) . this illustrates once more that , even for physical de , the equation of state @xmath1 does not uniquely define an underlying field - theoretical model is quite different from the quintessence lagrangian @xmath60 . ] ( see also @xcite ) . from the fact that the left - hand side of eq . ( [ eqn : phidot ] ) is always non - negative , follows an important restriction on the expansion law for the universe which must be satisfied before attempts to reconstruct the potential are made , namely 3h_0 ^ 2(1+z)^2 . [ ineq ] equation ( [ ineq ] ) is simply a restatement of the weak energy condition @xmath61 . integrating ( [ ineq ] ) , we get the relation h^2(z)h_0 ^ 2(1+(1+z)^3 ) [ int - ineq ] which is easier to verify observationally . in the case of physical de , with its implied minimal coupling to gravity , the expansion history @xmath0 can also be reconstructed from the growth rate of inhomogeneous density perturbations in the non - relativistic matter component on scales significantly less than the hubble radius @xmath62 , ( provided perturbations in the de component can be neglected and the effective gravitational constant does not change with time ) @xcite . indeed , the linearized perturbation equation and other quantities referring to the evolution of a frw background that , in turn , can be used to determine @xmath0 @xcite . ] + 2h - 4g_m= 0 [ eq : recon3 ] can easily be inverted , with the result : h(z)= h(0 ) - 3_0^z dz^. [ eq : recon7 ] furthermore , an interesting relationship follows between the current value of the matter density @xmath55 and @xmath63 : = ^2(0)(3_0^dz)^-1 , [ eq : recon6 ] which could provide a consistency check on direct observational determinations of @xmath55 . at sufficiently low redshifts @xmath64 , the advent of deep redshift surveys probing large scale structure may help in reconstructing @xmath0 using ( [ eq : recon7 ] ) . although it is unlikely that the value of @xmath63 for @xmath65 will be reliably known in the near future , the fact that the universe is expected to become matter dominated at fairly low redshifts , @xmath66 at @xmath67 , allows us to use the spatially flat matter dominated solution @xmath68 to extrapolate to higher redshifts and thereby evaluate ( [ eq : recon6 ] ) . as a result , for physical de we now have two independent methods to reconstruct the same quantity @xmath69 : ( i ) through quantities like @xmath70 referring to an unperturbed frw background , and ( ii ) through @xmath63 describing the growth of perturbations on small scales . it therefore follows that one should be able to reconstruct the density perturbation @xmath63 from observations of the luminosity distance . consider the quantity @xmath71 which can also be written as the difference of conformal times : @xmath72 . for our purpose it will be useful to invert the quantity @xmath73 ( determined from observations ) to @xmath74 . next , we again assume that de does not cluster and rewrite ( [ eq : recon3 ] ) in the following integral form : ( e(z ) ) = ( 0 ) + (0)_0^e ( 1+z(e))de + _ 0^e ( 1+z(e_1))de_1_0^e_1 ( e_2)de_2 . [ eq : recondelta ] here @xmath75 since @xmath76 for @xmath77 . clearly ( [ eq : recondelta ] ) can be solved iteratively if the value of @xmath78 is known . the value of @xmath79 does not really matter since we are only interested in the ratio @xmath80 . the requirement @xmath81 leads to the integral condition : (0)= - ( 3/2)_m_0^e_lss(e)de , and , as in the case of ( [ eq : recon6 ] ) , one needs to postulate some reasonable interpolating behaviour for @xmath82 at large redshifts for which no supernova data exist at present . since @xmath83 , the value of this quantity should be possible to determine from the cmb . both ( [ eq : recon7 ] ) and ( [ eq : recondelta ] ) can be used as consistency checks for physical de which , by assumption , is minimally coupled to gravity . for geometrical de on the other hand , the linearized perturbation equation is usually modified from its conventional form ( [ eq : recon3 ] ) , see for instance @xcite for scalar - tensor gravity or @xcite for the dgp model . is expected to be different from the reconstructed expression ( [ eq : recondelta ] ) provides an interesting possibility to distinguish between physical and geometrical models of de . ] as a result , de reconstruction becomes more complicated . in particular , a generic scalar - tensor model of de depends on two arbitrary functions @xmath9 and @xmath84 the scalar field potential and its coupling to gravity respectively . in this case one needs information from _ both _ @xmath70 and @xmath63 in order to reconstruct the de model unambiguously @xcite . to summarize , we have shown in this section that the reconstruction of the expansion rate @xmath0 and other de properties from observational data is well defined and unambiguous from the mathematical point of view . in practice , however , the situation is much more difficult since all observational functions such as @xmath70 and @xmath63 are noisy and known only at discrete values of the redshift @xmath85 ( associated with the redshifts of @xmath86 supernovae in the case of @xmath70 ) . thus , it is impossible to directly differentiate them with respect to redshift as formulae ( [ eq : h ] ) and ( [ eq : recon7 ] ) require . add to this the fact that the dispersion in the luminosity distance is not expected to get significantly better than @xcite @xmath87 , and one is confronted with a noisy quantity @xmath88 sampled at a set of discrete intervals @xmath89 . therefore , to convert from @xmath88 to the function @xmath0 defined at _ all _ redshift values within the interval ( say ) @xmath90 using ( [ eq : h ] ) clearly requires a crucial additional step : some sort of _ smoothing _ procedure . this is usually accomplished using either parametric or non - parametric reconstruction which we turn to next . this approach is based on the assumption that the quantities @xmath91 vary ` sufficiently slowly ' with redshift and can therefore be approximated by a fitting formula ( ansatz ) which relies on a small number of free parameters @xmath92 . the ansatz for @xmath93 is compared against observations , and the values of the free parameters @xmath94 are determined using a minimization procedure ( usually maximum likelyhood ) . quite clearly a successful fitting function should , in principle , be able to faithfully reproduce the properties of an entire class of de models . different parameterizations have been suggested for : @xmath95 @xcite , @xmath0 @xcite , @xmath1 @xcite and @xmath96 @xcite . we attempt to summarize some of these approaches below . 1 . * fitting functions to the luminosity distance @xmath95 * + an approximation to a function can easily be generated by expanding it in a taylor series about some redshift @xmath97 . applied to the luminosity distance ( with @xmath98 ) , this method gives the following fitting function @xcite = _ i=1^n a_iz^i . [ eq : poly ] unfortunately , it appears that in order to accurately determine quantities of interest such as @xmath0 and @xmath1 one must take a large number of terms in ( [ eq : poly ] ) which greatly increases the errors of reconstruction @xcite and reduces the reliability of this ansatz . + a more versatile pad - type ansatz was suggested in @xcite = 2 , x = 1+z , [ eqn : star ] which is able to _ exactly _ reproduce the results both for cdm ( @xmath99 ) and the steady state model ( @xmath100 ) . + another accurate fit with a greater number of free parameters is @xcite & & = ( 1)-(y ) , + & & ( y)=2 ^ -1/8 , y = 1/ . [ eq : fit_chiba ] 2 . * fitting functions to the de density * + the dark energy density can be written as a truncated taylor series polynomial in @xmath101 , @xmath102 . this leads to the following ansatz for the hubble parameter @xcite [ eq : poly_fit ] h(x ) = h_0x^3 + a_1 + a_2x + a_3 x^2^ , [ eq : taylor ] which , when substituted in the expression for the luminosity distance ( [ eq : lumdis ] ) , yields = _ 1 ^ 1+z . [ eq : taylor1 ] this fitting function gives exact results for the cosmological constant @xmath8 ( @xmath103 ) as well as for quiessence with @xmath104 ( @xmath105 ) and @xmath106 ( @xmath107 ) . the presence of the term @xmath108 in ( [ eq : poly_fit ] ) ensures that the ansatz correctly reproduces the matter dominated epoch at early times ( @xmath67 ) . for quintessence models as well as the chaplygin gas , the luminosity distance @xmath70 in ( [ eq : taylor1 ] ) can be determined to an accuracy of better than @xmath109 if @xmath110 @xcite . * fitting functions to the equation of state * + in this approach one assumes that the de equation of state @xmath1 is an unknown variable whose behaviour is ` guessed ' by means of a suitable fitting function @xmath111 . since h^2(z ) & = & h_0 ^ 2 ( 1+z)^3 + ^2 , + + & = & ( 1- ) , [ eq : hubble_recon ] the values of @xmath94 can be determined by comparing the luminosity distance ( [ eq : lumdis ] ) or @xmath112 , against observations . + several possible fits for @xmath1 have been suggested in the literature . perhaps the simplest is the taylor expansion @xcite w(z ) = _ i=0^n w_iz^i , [ eq : wpol ] which , for @xmath113 , gives results significantly better than the taylor expansion for the luminosity distance ( [ eq : poly ] ) . the simple two parameter representation @xmath114 is however of limited utility since it is only valid for @xmath115 . a considerably more versatile four parameter ansatz has been suggested in @xcite . + a popular two parameter fit was suggested by chevallier and polarski @xcite and by linder @xcite w(a ) = w_0+w_1(1-a ) = w_0 + w_1 , [ eq : cpl ] the associated luminosity distance can be obtained by substitution into ( [ eq : hubble_recon ] ) and ( [ eq : lumdis ] ) . a more general form for this fit is w(a ) = w_p + ( a_p - a)w_a , where @xmath116 is the value of the scale factor at the ` sweet spot ' where the equation of state @xmath117 is most tightly constrained . the value of @xmath116 usually depends upon the data set being used @xcite . @xmath118 \epsfxsize=2.7 in \epsffile{h_exp_w_g.epsi } & \epsfxsize=3.3 in \epsffile{huterer3.ps } \\ \end{array}$ ] as mentioned earlier , for an ansatz to be regarded as being successful it should embrace within its fold the behaviour of a reasonably wide class of de models . most of the ansatz s discussed above successfully accommodate de whose equation of state evolves moderately with redshift . it is quite clear that these simple fits can not be used to rule out ( using observations ) models with rapidly evolving @xmath1 . one reason for this is that applying an ansatz such as ( [ eq : taylor ] ) or ( [ eq : cpl ] ) to sne data is equivalent to smoothing the evolution of the universe over a redshift interval @xmath119 where @xmath86 is the number of free parameters in the ansatz ( the concrete form of an ansatz defines the form of a smoothing redshift function ) . clearly , an implicit smoothing such as this will cause rapid transitions in dark energy to disappear not because of disagreement with data but simply because of the manner in which the data have been ` massaged ' @xcite . ( an example of the disastrous results of applying the prior @xmath120 constant to models with an evolving eos is discussed in section [ sec : obstacle ] . ) models with a fast phase transition in dark energy ( @xmath121 over a narrow range of redshift @xmath122 ) have been discussed in @xcite . to accommodate such models the following ansatz was suggested @xcite w(z)=w_i+ , [ eq : bass ] where @xmath123 is the initial equation of state at high redshifts , @xmath124 is a transition redshift at which the equation of state falls to @xmath125 and @xmath126 describes the rate of change of @xmath1 . substitution into ( [ eq : hubble_recon ] ) and ( [ eq : lumdis ] ) gives the luminosity distance . finally , models with oscillating de have also been discussed in the literature @xcite . to accommodate an oscillating eos the following ansatz has been suggested @xcite w ( ) = w_0 + w_1where @xmath127 are free parameters whose values must be obtained by fitting to observations . it is encouraging to note that , in spite of some ambiguity in the form of the different fits , when applied to the same supernova data set most of them give consistent results in the range @xmath128 ( where there is sufficient data ) @xcite . one should also note that although increasing the number of parameters usually increases the accuracy of reconstruction of the ` best fit ' , this is often accompanied by severe degeneracies which limit the utility of introducing a large number of free parameters . in addition , extra free parameters are quite severely penalized by information criteria such the akaike information criterion @xcite and the bayesian information criterion @xcite , see also @xcite . however , there exists a subtlety when applying these information criteria to fitting functions of @xmath129 etc . as opposed to concrete theoretical models of de . in the case of the former , one should keep in mind the possibility that a fit with a larger number of parameters might in fact be describing the behaviour of a fundamental de model ( not yet known ) containing a smaller number of truly free parameters . the reverse is also true , a primitive fit ( hence not penalizable ) may , if the information criteria are applied , detract our attention from a more complicated but also more fundamental explanation of a phenomenon . let us illustrate this with an example . the theory of gravitational instability informs us that the linear density contrast @xmath130 and the peculiar velocity field @xmath131 are related as @xcite = - [ eq : velocity ] where the function @xmath132 can be approximated as @xmath133 . an exact calculation however reveals @xmath134 to be a more complicated function involving elliptical integrals , etc . therefore a naive application of information criteria to ( [ eq : velocity ] ) would needlessly penalize the latter , which is correct but complicated , in favour of the simpler @xmath133 . another popular approach the so - called principal component analysis is based on expanding @xmath1 in terms of a basis of orthogonal functions . the form of these functions depends upon the kind of data used and its constraining capabilities @xcite . we end this section by noting that the reconstruction approach has also been extended to scalar - tensor gravity @xcite , string inspired cosmology with the gauss - bonnet term coupled to a scalar field @xcite and dark energy with non - canonical kinetic energy terms @xcite . other applications of cosmological reconstruction may be found in @xcite . non - parametric smoothing usually involves directly smoothing either @xmath95 , or some other quantity appropriately binned in redshift space with some characteristic smoothing scale . different ways of implementing this approach have been discussed in @xcite . all reconstruction methods must deal with the fact that the data sample is usually sparse and the coverage of redshift space uneven . consider for instance the comoving coordinate distance to a single supernova within a larger sample r_i = r(z_i ) + n_i . here , @xmath135 is the noise term @xmath136 , and @xmath137 is related to the distance modulus @xmath138 of the supernova by @xcite @xmath139 . direct differentiation of @xmath140 to give @xmath141 will obviously result in a very noisy quantity . one way to tackle this is to fit @xmath142 piece - wise using a set of basis functions . following this approach , daly and djorgovsky @xcite reconstructed the deceleration parameter from the dimensionless coordinate distance @xmath143 by : ( i ) fitting @xmath144 locally within a small redshift bin by means of a second order polynomial requiring that at least 10 data points lie within each bin ; ( ii ) determining the first and second derivatives of @xmath144 from the fit coefficients ( for each bin ) and reconstructing the deceleration parameter from @xmath144 by means of the relation -q(z ) = 1 + ( 1+z ) . applying their method to a set of radio galaxies in addition to type ia sne , daly and djorgovsky @xcite found that although the cosmological constant provided a very good fit to the data , modest evolution in the dark energy density was also perfectly acceptable . the transition from deceleration to acceleration occured at @xmath145 , with a best fit value of @xmath146 . these results are in broad agreement with those obtained using parametric approaches @xcite . a different approach to non - parametric reconstruction is discussed by shafieloo @xcite who generalize a smoothing ansatz widely used in the analysis of large scale structure . according to this method , a smoothed quantity @xmath147 is constructed from a fluctuating ` raw ' quantity @xmath148 using a low pass filter @xmath19 having a smoothing scale @xmath126 d^s(*x * , ) = d(*x * ) f(|*x*-*x*| ; ) d*x * . in large scale structure studies , @xmath149 is the density field @xcite whereas for cosmological reconstruction @xmath149 could be either of @xmath150 . commonly used filters include : ( i ) the ` top - hat ' filter , which has a sharp cutoff @xmath151 where @xmath152 is the heaviside step function ( @xmath153 for @xmath154 , @xmath155 for @xmath156 ) and ( ii ) the gaussian filter f_g . when applied to snap - quality data using a gaussian filter , this method reconstructs the hubble parameter to an accuracy of @xmath157 within the redshift interval @xmath158 . the look - back time t(z)=t(z=0)-t(z)=h_0 ^ -1_0^z is reconstructed to an even better accuracy of @xmath159 at @xmath160 . despite the considerable success of these approaches , neither they , nor the parametric methods discussed earlier provide independent measurements of either @xmath0 or @xmath38 within a given redshift range . one approach towards an uncorrelated determination of cosmological quantities is to bin the data in redshift bins of size @xmath126 with a weight ( or window ) function assigned to each bin @xcite . each window function vanishes outside its redshift bin and the two supernovae falling on either side of a bin boundary are discarded . this method ensures that , since two adjacent window functions have no common supernovae , the measurement of quantities within these bins will have uncorrelated error bars . this method is quite successful and complements other reconstruction approaches in many respects . one weakness , which practitioners of this approach have to guard against is that , since some information at the bin boundary is lost , discontinuities in the fit values at bin edges may be present @xcite . these , in turn , could lead to unphysically large derivatives of derived quantities such as @xmath0 and @xmath1 . results obtained by applying a variant of this method to recent cmb+sne+lss data are shown in figure [ fig : wangm ] and appear to agree with the results of the parametric approach in figure [ fig : eos ] . other promising methods for obtaining uncorrelated estimates of cosmological evolution are discussed in @xcite . in all of the above approaches , it is important to choose the value of the smoothing scale @xmath126 ( or bin size ) optimally , so that ( i ) a sufficient number of data points is accommodated within each bin to reduce the effects of shot noise , ( ii ) the bin size is not too large to cause excessive smoothing . the following useful formula giving the relative error bars on @xmath0 comes to our aid @xcite [ eq : tegmark ] , where n is the total number of supernovae ( assuming an approximately uniform distribution ) and @xmath161 is the noise of the data . clearly , a reduction in the value of @xmath126 by 3 should be compensated for by having 27 many times more supernovae if one wants to keep @xmath162 unchanged . the situation is far worse for @xmath1 which has a @xmath163 scaling , since the data are being differentiated twice to get @xmath1 . with respect to cosmological reconstruction , considerable caution must be exercised when setting priors on the values of cosmological parameters . this is true both for the density parameter @xmath27 whose value is currently known to about @xmath164 accuracy and the de equation of state . maor @xcite gave a particularly insightful example of the dangers of incorrect reconstruction by assuming a fiducial de model with @xmath165 and an evolving eos @xmath166 . in their reconstruction , the results of which are shown in figure [ fig : maor ] , it was assumed that @xmath167 was a constant and , additionally , that @xmath168 . these two ( incorrect ) priors led to a gross underestimation of @xmath167 and an overestimation of @xmath27 as shown in figure [ fig : maor ] . the above example shows that the eos of dark energy can be badly reconstructed if we assume a misleading prior for @xmath169 . since @xmath1 depends upon the value of @xmath27 through ( [ eq : state ] ) , it follows that an incorrect assumption about the value of the matter density has the potential to affect cosmological reconstruction quite significantly . this is demonstrated in figure [ fig : arman ] in which the de eos is reconstructed for a fiducial @xmath2cdm model with @xmath170 and @xmath165 . cosmological reconstruction is based on the ansatz ( [ eq : poly_fit ] ) in which the _ incorrect _ value @xmath171 is assumed . this results in the reconstructed eos evolving with redshift when , in fact , no such evolution is present in the fiducial model ! as we have seen , the eos has certain blemishes it is obtained from @xmath95 after differentiating _ twice _ and it is sensitive to the _ precise _ value of @xmath55 . both these features hamper its reconstruction which has led several authors to propose the hubble parameter or the de density as being more appropriate for cosmological reconstruction @xcite . carrying these ideas further , the possibility of extracting information about the equation of state from the reconstructed hubble parameter by constructing a _ weighted average _ of the equation of state was explored in @xcite . this quantity , dubbed the @xmath169-probe , gleans information about the equation of state from the _ first derivative _ of the luminosity distance . therefore , it is less noisy and better determined than @xmath1 . the weighted average of the equation of state is defined as @xcite [ eq : weight1 ] 1+|w= ( 1+w(z ) ) . an important feature of the @xmath169-probe ( @xmath172 ) is that it can be expressed in terms of the difference in dark energy density over a given redshift range [ eq : weight2 ] 1+|w(z_1,z_2 ) & = & + & & ( ) . + here @xmath130 denotes the total change of a variable between integration limits and @xmath173 ( @xmath174 ) . thus @xmath172 is easy to determine if the hubble parameter has been accurately reconstructed . an important property of @xmath172 is that it is less sensitive to uncertainties in the value of @xmath55 than @xmath1 . this is demonstrated in figure [ fig : margin ] where the results for @xmath172 are shown after marginalizing over the matter density . remarkably , the value of @xmath172 for the fiducial @xmath2cdm model remains close to @xmath175 , while @xmath172 for the evolving de model shows a clear signature of evolution . thus , small uncertainties in the value of the matter density do not appear to adversely affect the accuracy of the reconstructed @xmath169-probe . furthermore , several excellent methods for determining @xmath176 and @xmath0 have been suggested in the literature @xcite , any of which could be used to determine @xmath172 using ( [ eq : weight2 ] ) . cosmological observations made during the past two decades have brought about both qualitative and quantitative changes in our perception of the universe . observational support has come for many theories ( such as inflation ) which earlier were regarded as being at the level of hypothesis . on the other hand , fundamentally new properties of our universe , such its current state of acceleration , have also been unravelled . the remarkable qualitative similarity between current acceleration ( fueled by de ) and inflationary acceleration ( supported by what may be called primordial dark energy ) may help us understand in which direction cosmology may be headed . the discovery by cobe of an approximately scale - invariant spectrum of primordial fluctuations ( @xmath177 ) was regarded by many as providing tacit support for the inflationary scenario . however , virtually all models of inflation predict small departures from the scale invariance @xmath178 , where @xmath179 is a model dependent quantity . strict scale invariance ( @xmath180 ) arises for a specific 2-parameter family of inflaton potentials only @xcite , which reduces to @xmath181 in the slow - roll approximation . in this context , the recent 3-year data release of the wmap experiment suggests @xmath182 , which is in excellent agreement with predictions made by the simplest inflationary models such as chaotic inflation with @xmath183 . the present situation concerning de resembles , in some respects , the status of inflation just after the release of the cobe data in 1992 . the cosmological constant is in excellent agreement with data and departures ( if any ) from @xmath184 are believed to be quite small . nevertheless , since at present no fundamental theory predicting the ( small ) value of the @xmath2-term exists , it is of utmost importance that departures from @xmath184 be probed to accuracies of at least @xmath109 by future generations of experiments . since virtually all de models ( other than @xmath2 ) have either @xmath185 or @xmath186 , the need for probing both the equation of state as well as its first derivative become crucial if any deep insight is to be gained into the nature of de . it is useful to recall that several de models which agree well with the current data arise because of modifications to the gravitational sector of the theory @xcite . for these _ geometrical de _ models , the eos no longer plays the role of a fundamental physical quantity and it would be very useful if we could supplement it with a diagnostic which could unambiguously probe the properties of all classes of de models . the @xmath169-probe discussed earlier , provides one such method , since it is based on the expansion history @xmath187 . since the expansion factor @xmath25 is an essential feature of all metric theories of gravity , it is worthwhile trying to explore the properties of de by considering the generic form [ eq : taylor0 ] a(t ) = a(t_0 ) + a_0 ( t - t_0 ) + ( t - t_0)^2 + ( t - t_0)^3 + ... . cosmic acceleration appears to be a fairly recent phenomenon @xcite , so we can confine our attention to small values of @xmath188 in ( [ eq : taylor0 ] ) . the second and third terms in the rhs of ( [ eq : taylor0 ] ) have played a crucial role in the development of cosmology . indeed , for a long time the large errors in @xmath189 and @xmath190 impaired a precise picture of cosmic expansion and only recently has the sign of @xmath191 been determined to sufficient accuracy for us to make the statement that the universe is accelerating . links the ricci scalar @xmath17 to @xmath191 . therefore , an accelerating ( @xmath192 ) spatially flat universe corresponds to @xmath193 . ] keeping in mind the significant progress expected in observational cosmology over the next decade , we feel the time to be ripe to supplement @xmath194 and @xmath191 with @xmath195 , which is the next logical step in the hierarchy of cosmological parameters . it is remarkable that @xmath196 for the spatially flat @xmath2cdm model which is the ` standard ' cosmological model at present , as well as for the cdm model . supplementing @xmath197 ( the first statefinder ) with the second statefinder @xmath198 permits us to break this degeneracy and to characterize different de models in a very informative manner . was also dubbed the cosmic jerk in @xcite . ] the statefinder pair @xmath199 is a ` geometrical ' diagnostic since it depends upon @xmath25 and hence upon the space - time geometry . an important property of the statefinder is that spatially flat lcdm corresponds to the fixed point _ lcdm = 1,0 . [ eq : fixedpt ] so the basic question of whether de is the @xmath2-term or ` something else ' can be rephrased into whether the equality ( [ eq : fixedpt ] ) is satisfied for de . indeed , the departure of a de model from @xmath200 provides a good way of establishing the ` distance ' of this model from lcdm @xcite . the fact that different classes of de models show distinctly different behaviour when plotted in the @xmath199-plane adds to the practical utility of this diagnostic . see figure [ fig : statefinder ] and @xcite for some applications of the statefinder . finally , the pair @xmath199 can also be expressed in terms of @xmath201 quite simply [ eq : statefinder1 ] r & = & 1 + ( 1+w ) - , + s & = & 1+w- . it is instructive to note that the second statefinder can be rewritten as @xcite s=(+ p)p [ eq : statefinder2 ] where @xmath202 is the _ total _ pressure including that of de . from ( [ eq : statefinder2 ] ) we find that @xmath203 is very sensitive to the epoch when the total pressure in the universe vanishes . for @xmath2cdm , this takes place at the redshift @xmath204 , when the positive radiation pressure cancels the negative pressure in @xmath2 . consequently , @xmath205 as @xmath206 . in general , the redshift @xmath207 at which the total pressure in the universe becomes zero is quite sensitive to the nature of de . -18pt lll level & geometrical parameter & physical parameter + + 1 & @xmath208 & @xmath209 , + & & @xmath210 + + + 2 & @xmath211 & @xmath212 + & @xmath213 & @xmath214 + + + 3 & @xmath215 & @xmath216 , @xmath217 + + & @xmath218 & + + [ table : dark ] finally , returning to our analogy between an inflaton and dark energy , an interesting correspondence exists between the @xmath219 pair describing de and the _ slow roll parameters _ @xmath220 , @xmath221 , describing inflation q + 1 & = & + r - 1 & = & ( 2 - 3 ) . we end this section by noting that our current description of cosmology relies on parameters which are either _ geometrical _ or _ physical _ in nature . in the table above , we have divided cosmological parameters according to their _ level _ which is related to the number of differentiations of the expansion factor needed to construct that parameter . note that all relative energy densities in the table @xmath222 are defined using the present value @xmath223 of the newton gravitational constant in agreement with the definition ( [ einst ] ) . each higher level requires an additional differentiation of observational data @xmath224 and , therefore , demands a higher level of accuracy for the latter . for current data , we broadly have about 10% accuracy for quantities belonging to the first level , 50% for the second level , while determination of third level parameters lies in the future . by smoothing , we lower the level of a parameter by unity . relations between geometrical and physical parameters are the following : w(z ) = 2 q(z ) - 1 3 ( 1 - _ m(z ) ) ; + _ v(z ) = - _ m0(1+z)^3 ; + _ t(z ) = - _ mo(1+z)^3 ; + _ ( z ) = ( r - 3q - 4 + _ m0 ( 1+z)^3 ) . [ relation ] the nature of dark energy is clearly one of the outstanding physical and cosmological puzzles of this century . although many distinct theoretical models have been advanced to explain the cosmic acceleration , an alternative approach to study and understand de is to determine de properties from observational data in a model independent fashion , thus , _ reconstructing _ de from observations . in this review , we have attempted to briefly summarize some important approaches of cosmological reconstruction . these approaches are briefly classifiable into parametric and non - parametric methods . both methods appear to give consistent results when applied to current data . future directions for model independent reconstruction of dark energy have also been briefly discussed . in the first approximation , within current observational errors , the reconstructed de behaves like a cosmological constant . but future , much more precise data , may well show some deviations from this behaviour . however small , these could have a profound influence on the whole of physics . _ acknowledgments _ : we are grateful to dragan huterer , irith maor , yun wang and jun - qing xia for agreeing to provide figures for this review . vs acknowledges a useful conversation with ranjeev misra . as was partially supported by the russian foundation for basic research , grant 05 - 02 - 17450 , and by the research program astronomy " of the russian academy of sciences . he also thanks the centre emile borel , institut henri poincare , paris for hospitality in the period when this paper was finished . a. g. riess , 1998 , , 1009 [ astro - ph/9805201 ] ; s. j. perlmutter , 1999 , , 565 [ astro - ph/9812133 ] ; r. a. knop , 2003 , , 102(k ) [ astro - ph/0309368 ] . a. g. riess , 2004 , , 665(r ) [ astro - ph/0402512 ] . p. astier , 2005 , astron . astroph . * 447 * , 31 [ astro - ph/0510447 ] . s m. carroll , 2001 , living rev.rel . * 4 * , 1 [ astro - ph/0004075 ] ; p. j e. peebles and b. ratra , 2003 , rev.mod.phys . * 75 * , 559 [ astro - ph/0207347 ] ; t. padmanabhan , 2003 , phys . rep . * 380 * , 235 [ hep - th/0212290 ] ; v. sahni , 2004 , lect . notes phys . * 653 * , 141 [ astro - ph/0403324 ] ; 2005 , astro - ph/0502032 ; s. nojiri and s. d. odintsov , 2006 , hep - th/0601213 ; r. p. woodard , 2006 , astro - ph/0601672 ; e. j. copeland , m. sami and s. tsujikawa , 2006 , hep - th/0603057 ; s. bludman , 2006 , astro - ph/0605198 . a. lue , r. scoccimarro and g. d. starkman , 2004 , , 124015 [ astro - ph/0401515 ] ; k. koyama and r. maartens , 2006 , jcap * 0601 * , 016 [ astro - ph/0511634 ] ; g. deffayet , g. gabadadze and a. inglesias , 2006 , jcap * 0608 * , 012 [ hep - th/0607099 ] . v. sahni and l. m. wang , 2000 , 103517 [ astro - ph/9910097 ] ; s. dodelson , m. kaplinghat and e. stewart , 2000 , , 5276 [ astro - ph/0002360 ] ; c. rubano , p. scudellaro , e. piedipalumbo and s. capozziello , 2003 , , 123501 [ astro - ph/0311535 ] ; g. barenboim , o. mena , c. quigg , 2005 , , 063533 [ astro - ph/0412010 ] ; s. nojiri and s. d. odintsov , 2006 , , 139 [ hep - th/0603062 ] . j. m. f. maia and j. a. s. lima , 2002 , , 083513 [ astro - ph/0112091 ] ; m. szydlowski and w. czaja , 2004 , , 083507 [ astro - ph/0309191 ] ; 2004 , , 083518 [ gr - qc/0305033 ] ; n. j. nunes and j. e. lidsey , 2004 , , 123511 [ astro - ph/0310882 ] ; u. alam , v. sahni , t. d. saini and a. a. starobinsky , 2004 , astro - ph/0406672 ; v. b. johri and p. k. rath , 2005 , astro - ph/0510017 ; m. sahln , a. r. liddle and d. parkinson , 2005 , , 083511 ; s. tsujikawa , 2005 , , 083512 ; d. polarski and a. ranquet , 2005 , , 1 ; y. wang and k. freese , 2006 , , 449 ; f. simpson and s. bridle , 2006 , , 083001 ; a. a. sen , 2006 , jcap * 0603 * , 010 [ astro - ph/0512406 ] ; x. zhang , 2006 , astro - ph/0604484 ; astro - ph/0609699 . v. gorini , a. kamenshchik and u. moschella , 2003 , , 063509 [ astro - ph/0209395 ] ; w. zimdahl and d. pavon , 2004 , gen . . grav . * 36 * , 1483 [ gr - qc/0311067 ] ; a. k. d. evans , i. k. wehus , o. gron and o. elgaroy , 2005 , astron . astrophys . * 430 * , 399 [ astro - ph/0406407 ] ; u. debnath , a. banerjee and s. chakraborty , 2004 , class . quant . grav . * 21 * , 5609 [ gr - qc/0411015 ] ; x. zhang , 2005 , , 1 [ astro - ph/0503075 ] ; x. zhang , 2005 , int.j.mod.phys . * d14 * , 1597 , [ astro - ph/0504586 ] ; x. zhang , feng - quan wu , j. zhang , 2006 , jcap * 0601 * , 003 [ astro - ph/0411221 ] ; p. wu and h. yu , 2005 , int d * 14 * , 1873 [ gr - qc/05090365 ] ; e. e. o. ishida , 2006 , astro - ph/0609614 ; d. rapetti , s. w. allen , m. a. amin , r. d. blandford , astro - ph/0605683 .

this review summarizes recent attempts to reconstruct the expansion history of the universe and to probe the nature of dark energy . reconstruction methods can be broadly classified into parametric and non - parametric approaches . it is encouraging that , even with the limited observational data currently available , different approaches give consistent results for the reconstruction of the hubble parameter @xmath0 and the effective equation of state @xmath1 of dark energy . model independent reconstruction using current data allows for modest evolution of dark energy density with redshift . however , a cosmological constant (= dark energy with a constant energy density ) remains an excellent fit to the data . some pitfalls to be guarded against during cosmological reconstruction are summarized and future directions for the model independent reconstruction of dark energy are explored .

1012.0189

predictions of standard model ( sm ) have so far been in agreement with results of numerous experiments . therefore , sm has been in use to explain many puzzles related to fundamental particles and their interactions . however , there have been a number of fundamental problems ( quark - lepton symmetry , family replication , hierarchy problems , charge quantization etc . ) sm could not deal with . furthermore , masses and mixings of leptons and quarks are fixed by hand . these problems forced physicists to go beyond sm . extra dimensions , supersymmetry ( susy ) , compositeness and so on have been created for solving these problems and to explain the physics underlying them . among these alternative models compositeness has explained the subjects of family replication and quark - lepton symmetry in the best manner according to the theory of compositeness quarks , leptons , gauge bosons need to be composite particles made up of more basic constituents . these basic constituents , in otherwords substructural particles , are named preons . it is assumed that preons are what compose quarks , leptons and gauge bosons . it s also supposed that preons interactions lead to development of many new types of particles such as leptoquarks , leptogluons , diquarks , dileptons and excited fermions . we will be interested in color octet leptons that in the framework of composite models with colored preons @xcite have the same status as the excited leptons . for instance , in the framework of fermion - scalar models , leptons would be a bound state of one fermionic preon and one scalar anti - preon @xmath6 ( both @xmath7 and @xmath8 are color triplets ) , then each sm lepton is thought to accompany with its own color octet partner @xcite . there are many papers about manifestations of excited leptons at high energy colliders whereas color octet leptons are discussed only in a few papers @xcite . resonant production of @xmath0 at future ep colliders have been analyzed in recent paper @xcite , where also current limits on leptogluon masses are briefly discussed . it was shown that the @xmath0 discovery at the lhec simultaneously will determine the compositeness scale . in this paper we will consider indirect manifestation of color octet electrons at the next generation linear colliders : international linear collider ( ilc ) and compact linear collider ( clic ) . in section 2 , we present the interaction lagrangian of the leptogluons as well as signal cross - section for the process @xmath9 via t - channel @xmath0 exchange . the signal and background analysis performed at ilc and clic is given in section 3 . in the last section we give an interpretation of obtained results and concluding remarks . the interaction lagrangian of leptogluons with the corresponding lepton and gluon is given by @xcite : @xmath10 where @xmath11 is field strength tensor for gluon , index @xmath12 denotes the color , @xmath13 is gauge coupling , @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the chirality factors , @xmath16 and @xmath17 denote left and right spinor components of lepton , @xmath18 is the anti - symmetric tensor and @xmath19 is the compositeness scale , which is taken to be equal to @xmath20 . the leptonic chiral invariance implies @xmath21@xmath22 . for numerical calculations we implement this lagrangian into the calchep program @xcite . the cross sections for the process @xmath9 via t - channel @xmath0 exchange at @xmath3 tev are presented in figure 1 . isr and beamstrahlung effects at ilc and clic are calculated with calchep program using parameters given in table i @xcite . .main parameters of ilc and clic . here n is the number of particles in bunch . @xmath23 and @xmath24 are rms beam sizes at interaction point ( ip ) , @xmath25 is the rms bunch length . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] up to now , we assumed the compositeness scale equal to the mass of color octet electron ( @xmath26 ) . in general case this scale can be decoupled from the mass of new particles . for this reason below we consider limits for the compositeness scale as a function of the color octet electron mass . in this analysis we use @xmath27 @xmath28 and @xmath29 @xmath30 for ilc , clic1 and clic2 , respectively . these values correspond to one year operation with nominal luminosities . in figure 9 , 10 and 11 we plot reachable values of the compositeness scale as a function of @xmath20 for ilc , clic1 and clic2 , respectively . tev and @xmath31 @xmath30 . ] tev and @xmath32 @xmath30 . ] tev and @xmath33 @xmath30 . ] we show that , if @xmath26 ilc will give opportunity for indirect observation of octet electron upto @xmath34 @xmath35 gev during one ( three ) operation with nominal luminosity . corresponding values for clic1 are about @xmath36 gev lower . therefore , both ilc and clic1 will give opportunity to pass essentially the tevatron capacity for color octet electron ( @xmath0 ) search . clic2 will be sensitive to @xmath37 times higher mass values , namely , @xmath0 masses upto @xmath38 ( @xmath39 ) gev could be observed during one ( three ) year operation with nominal luminosity . these values essentially exceed capacity of the lhc to observe color octet electron ( @xmath0 ) via pair production . if the compositeness scale and color octet electron mass are decoupled , observable values of @xmath19 at ilc and clic1 exceeds @xmath20 for @xmath40 gev ( at @xmath41 gev the ratio @xmath42 ) . at the clic2 @xmath19 exceeds mass for @xmath43 gev ( at @xmath44 gev observable @xmath19 is @xmath45 gev ) . this work is supported by tubitak in the framework of the bidep 2218 post - doctoral program .

in this study we investigated indirect manifestations of color octet electron at the next generation linear colliders : international linear collider ( ilc ) and compact linear collider ( clic ) . namely , production of two gluons via color octet electron exchange is considered . signal and background analysis have been performed taking into account initial state radiation and beamstrahlung . we show that color octet electron ( @xmath0 ) manifestation will be seen upto @xmath1 tev and @xmath2 tev at ilc and clic with @xmath3 tev , respectively . clic with @xmath4 tev will be sensitive upto @xmath5 tev .

1605.04604

stochastic partial differential equations ( spdes ) , or partial differential equations ( pdes ) with uncertainties , play an important role in many areas of engineering and applied sciences such as turbulence , flows in random media , solid mechanics , filtering , and finance . numerical simulations of spdes are typically based on the monte carlo ( mc ) or the polynomial chaos ( pc ) methods @xcite . in both cases , the long - time simulation of spdes proves to be quite expensive @xcite . in this paper , we extend the pc - based method developed for stochastic differential equations in @xcite to the setting of spdes . the pc method originates from the works @xcite and enables us to expand ( square integrable ) functionals of brownian motion in a basis of hermite polynomials . applications of such a framework to random flows and turbulence theory are examined in @xcite . more recently , works in @xcite combined the pc method with the karhunen loeve ( kl ) expansion @xcite to study structural mechanics problems . the generalized polynomial chaos ( gpc ) developed in @xcite next extends the hermite pc to a set of non - gaussian random parameters . the main advantage of the pc method is that it allows us to propagate stochasticity by providing expansions of quantities of interest in terms of appropriate uncertainties while in effect replacing the stochastic equations by systems of deterministic equations . once these deterministic equations are solved , the statistical properties of the solution can be readily inferred from the coefficients of the expansion , which facilitates uncertainty quantification . in some cases , the pc method can propagate uncertainties with a substantially lower cost than mc methods ; especially for low dimensional uncertainties @xcite ; see also @xcite . however , in cases of high dimensional random parameters , the efficiency of the pc method is reduced because of the large number of terms that appear in the expansion . the presence of a temporal random forcing is a serious challenge to the pc method as the number of stochastic variables increases linearly with time , which hinders the capability of the pc method for long - time computations @xcite . moreover , the optimality of the initial basis typically degrades as time evolves due to the presence of nonlinearities in the equation . these drawbacks were addressed in @xcite . in our previous work @xcite , we proposed the _ dynamical generalized polynomial chaos _ ( dgpc ) method to solve low dimensional stochastic differential equations ( sdes ) driven by white noise . the novelty of the dgpc algorithm is that it utilizes a restart procedure and constructs polynomial chaos expansions ( pces ) dynamically in time by using orthogonal polynomials of the projections of the solution at the current steps and the future random forcing @xcite . this allows the algorithm to keep reasonably sparse random bases , and to mitigate the aforementioned curse of dimensionality and loss of optimality . numerical experiments in that reference illustrate that such a restart procedure has the ability to accurately estimate long - time solutions of sdes ; see the relevant computational and theoretical details in @xcite . although the algorithm performs well for low dimensional sdes , extension to larger systems is challenging and requires serious modifications . in this manuscript , we extend dgpc to the framework of spdes driven by white noise . while solutions to spdes are , in general , high dimensional random fields , they may lend themselves in some cases to low dimensional representations @xcite . armed with this fact , we propose at each restart to use the kl expansion to compress the solution into a representation involving a finite number of random modes , i.e. , a projection onto a lower dimensional manifold . in cases where the modeling equations contain non - forcing random inputs other than brownian forcing , such as a random viscosity , the kl expansion is applied to the solution and the random parameters together so that the algorithm automatically selects the intrinsic variables , which have the largest influence on the solution . since kl expansions are known to be optimal in the mean square sense , at each restart point in time , only a few dominating , most energetic , random modes are chosen and incorporated into pce to represent the future solution . however , the combination of the random kl modes and the random forcing variables brings about high dimensionality . the computational challenges then become : ( i ) computing orthogonal polynomials of arbitrary multivariate distributions ; ( ii ) keeping the number of terms in the expansion as small as possible . the construction of orthogonal polynomials of evolving multivariate distributions is possible by estimating their statistical moments @xcite , which is , in general , a computationally intensive procedure . in this work , we estimate the moments of the solution using its pce through a sampling approach to greatly reduce their computational cost ; see @xcite for a similar sampling methodology . we also show that the method is robust with respect to re - sampling . the second challenge ( ii ) is a major problem for all pc - based methods . the kl decomposition is computationally expensive as it requires solving a large eigenvalue problem . for problems of moderate size , we find that the eigenvalue problem is solved efficiently by using a krylov subspace method . for larger problems , in order to mitigate both memory requirements and computational cost of the kl expansion , we find low - rank approximations to the covariance matrices based on their pc representations and without assembling them . the algorithm leverages randomized projection methods as introduced in @xcite , and uses appropriate random matrices to obtain fast and accurate solutions of large eigenvalue problems . after selecting the dominating modes in the kl expansion , we make use of the sparse truncation technique proposed in @xcite to further reduce the number of terms in a pce . for long - time computations , we also develop an adaptive restart scheme , which adapts the time lag between restarts based on the acuity of the nonlinear effects . the use of compression techniques to exploit intrinsic lower dimensional structures of solutions of spdes is not new and is in fact necessary in many contexts ; see @xcite . the novelty of our approach is that a lower dimensional representation of the solution is learned online and integrated into a pce to integrate future random forcing and represent future solutions . this procedure is computationally viable and the combination of the aforementioned ideas allows us to attain a reasonable accuracy in the long - time evolutions of spdes for a reasonable computational cost . as we are interested in the long - time evolution of spdes , we restrict ourselves here to dynamics with a dissipation mechanism . equilibrium statistics and asymptotic properties of the solutions are relevant in many applications and have been extensively studied in the literature @xcite . based on these motivations , we provide numerical experiments for a 1d randomly forced burgers equation and a 2d stochastic navier stokes ( sns ) system . all equations are driven by white noise and satisfy periodic ( spatial ) boundary conditions . to demonstrate the efficiency of our algorithm , we present both short- and long - time computations . in some cases , we model the viscosity as a random process . statistical moments obtained by the algorithm are compared to the standard mc methods for short times to assess the accuracy of the algorithm . results show promising speed - ups over standard mc methods . we exhibit convergence behavior in terms of the degree of the expansion , the number of random modes retained in the kl expansion , and the ( adaptive ) restart time . in some cases , we provide a purely pce - based numerical verification of the convergence of the process to its invariant measure . the outline of the paper is as follows . section [ sec : kl_pc ] introduces the basic setting for the pc and kl expansions . in the following section , the main algorithm and its implementation details are discussed . numerical experiments are conducted in section [ sec : numerical ] using several settings for the stochastic burgers equation and navier stokes system . some concluding remarks are offered in section [ sec : summary ] . throughout the manuscript , we consider the following time - dependent stochastic partial differential equation ( spde ) driven by the white noise @xmath0 : @xmath1 , \\ & u(x,0,\omega)= u_0(x,\omega ) , \quad x \in g , \ , \omega \in \omega , \end{aligned } \right.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , for concreteness , @xmath2 is the @xmath3-dimensional torus so that @xmath4 and its derivatives are periodic functions in the variable @xmath5 . the dgpc algorithm may easily be extended to more general boundary conditions and geometries . above , @xmath6 is a possibly non - linear differential operator in the spatial variables . the solution takes values in @xmath7 . in the numerical simulations , the parameters @xmath3 and @xmath8 are set to either @xmath9 or @xmath10 . given a probability space @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is a sample space equipped with the sigma - algebra @xmath13 and the probability measure @xmath14 , we denote by @xmath15 the hilbert space of square integrable random fields on @xmath2 . for a random field @xmath16 , we define the expectation @xmath17 = \int_{\omega } u(x,\omega ) { \mathbb{p}}(d\omega),\ ] ] and the covariance @xmath18 , \quad x , y \in g,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath19 denotes the transpose . the kl expansion of a time - independent random field @xmath16 with a continuous covariance is as follows : @xmath20 where the eigenvalues @xmath21 are nonnegative , and the eigenfunctions @xmath22 and the mean zero random variables @xmath23 are given by @xmath24 \ , , \phi_l \rangle_{l^2(g)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath25 denotes the spatial inner product on @xmath2 . the spatial and random modes satisfy bi - orthogonality , i.e. @xmath26 = \delta_{lk}$ ] and @xmath27 , where @xmath28 denotes the kronecker delta function ; see @xcite . the major feature of the kl decomposition is that the truncation after a finite number , denoted by @xmath29 hereafter , of terms is optimal in the @xmath30 sense . how @xmath29 should be chosen obviously depends on the spectrum of the covariance operator . when the process shows a high degree of correlation , then typically @xmath29 may be chosen relatively small due to the rapid decay of the eigenvalues @xcite . this makes the kl expansion a useful dimensionality reduction technique in many applications and will play a crucial role in our algorithm to compress the dimensionality of stochastic solutions of . we assume that the random solution @xmath31 of is a second - order stochastic process for all @xmath32 $ ] , and for simplicity , that the initial condition is deterministic . the pc method for is constructed as follows . given a complete countable orthonormal system @xmath33 $ ] , @xmath34 , we project the brownian motion @xmath35 onto @xmath36 $ ] by defining @xmath37 . then , @xmath38 consists of a countable number of independent and identically distributed standard gaussian random variables , and the convergence @xmath39 ^ 2 \rightarrow 0 , \quad k \rightarrow \infty,\end{aligned}\ ] ] holds for all @xmath40 . basic examples of orthonormal systems are trigonometric functions and wavelets ; see @xcite . the spde solution is a nonlinear functional of brownian motion on the interval @xmath41 $ ] . therefore , the projection onto @xmath42 enables us to consider the solution depending on a countable number of random variables , i.e. , @xmath43 . then , the polynomial chaos expansion ( pce ) of the solution @xmath44 at @xmath32 $ ] is given by @xmath45 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the expansion is a sum of orthogonal projections onto orthogonal subspaces spanned by the wick polynomials @xmath46 , where @xmath47 is the @xmath48th degree normalized one - dimensional hermite polynomial and @xmath49 belongs to set of multi - indices with finite number of nonzero components @xmath50 the completeness of the orthonormal polynomials @xmath51 in @xmath30 , i.e. convergence of the expansion , is established in @xcite and the result is known as the cameron - martin theorem . in the following , we will use the term hermite pce to emphasize that the expansion utilizes gaussian random variables . all statistical information of the random field is contained in the deterministic coefficients @xmath52 of the expansion . specifically , the first two moments are given by @xmath53 = u_{\boldsymbol{0}}(x , t ) , \qquad { \mathbb{e}}[u^2 ] = \sum_{{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}\in \mathcal{j } } u_{\alpha}^2(x , t).\end{aligned}\ ] ] higher order moments can be obtained using the triple products @xmath54 $ ] or the hermite product formula for @xmath42 ; see @xcite . in practice , we truncate the expansion using polynomials of maximum degree @xmath55 and @xmath56 number of random variables @xmath57 , which results in the following approximation @xmath58 this simple truncation gives rise to @xmath59 terms in the approximation . two major problems of the pce in this context are as follows . to maintain a prescribed accuracy as time evolves , the degree of freedom @xmath56 should grow in accordance with the error behavior of , which brings about high dimensional randomness that needs to be incorporated in the expansion . therefore , the computational cost increases rapidly with dimension , which decreases the efficiency of the pc method . the second related problem of pc is that initial predetermined bases may lose their optimality and even fail to converge for long - time evolutions @xcite . to alleviate the aforementioned bottlenecks of the pc method , namely high dimensionality and long - term integration , several approaches have been proposed @xcite . in the following , we briefly summarize the approach called _ dynamical generalized polynomial chaos _ ( dgpc ) , which was developed in @xcite to solve ( reasonably low dimensional ) stochastic differential equations ( sdes ) driven by brownian motion over long times . the solution @xmath60 of a @xmath3-dimensional sde system can be seen as a nonlinear functional of the initial condition @xmath61 and the countable number of variables @xmath42 . the approach in @xcite hinges upon two important observations : ( i ) for sufficiently small time lags @xmath62 , the solution @xmath63 , can be efficiently captured by low - order polynomials in @xmath64 ; and ( ii ) the solution @xmath63 depends on brownian motion only on the interval @xmath65 $ ] by the markov property . these two remarks allowed us to employ evolving pces based on polynomials of the random forcing and projections of the solution onto underlying chaos spaces . in this way , the algorithm can forget " about the past and pc representations remain reasonably sparse in the evolving basis while the accuracy is retained for long times . to be more specific , and given a set of increasing restart times @xmath66 on @xmath67 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 , the algorithm projects the random variable @xmath70 onto a finite chaos space at each @xmath66 . this projection will be denoted by @xmath71 in the following . a major challenge in the implementation is to construct orthogonal polynomials of the varying distribution of the random variable @xmath71 . the pce gives rise to natural formulas to compute statistical moments of the random variable . the algorithm constructs orthogonal polynomials of @xmath71 based on the knowledge of its moments via a gram schmidt procedure . to obtain evolution equations for the expansion coefficients , the algorithm then computes necessary triple products for @xmath71 and performs galerkin projection onto subspaces spanned by orthogonal polynomials in @xmath71 and @xmath42 . convergence of the algorithm is related to the unique solvability of the moment problem of the measures associated to variables @xmath71 ; see @xcite . related theoretical aspects and the estimates of computational costs can be found in detail in @xcite . in @xcite , the algorithm is applied to low dimensional nonlinear sde systems and provides accurate long - time simulations with a small cost compared to standard hermite pce . in particular , we computed invariant measures of sdes in some cases , which standard hermite pce typically fails to achieve . in the subsequent sections , we propose an extension of the dgpc algorithm to spdes , which requires several key modifications . in this section , we present the algorithmic details of the dgpc method applied to the general spde . the main ideas are summarized as follows . let a decomposition @xmath72 be given . following our discussion in section [ sec : dgpc ] and using the markov property , the solution @xmath73 , @xmath74 , can be represented in a pc expansion in terms of @xmath75 and @xmath76 , where @xmath77 denotes the gaussian random variables required for brownian forcing on the interval @xmath78 $ ] . let @xmath79 denote the projection of the solution @xmath80 onto the polynomial chaos space . we will also use the shorthand notation @xmath71 to denote this projection . to construct a pce in terms of polynomials of @xmath71 , we separate the spatial dependence and randomness via the kl expansion : @xmath81 let @xmath82 denote the random modes . since the solution @xmath31 , @xmath83 $ ] , is a functional of the random forcing @xmath76 and modes @xmath84 , the next step pce @xmath85 is given by @xmath86,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the notation @xmath87 , where @xmath88 denotes an orthonormal basis in its arguments . the expansion dynamically needs a pc basis depending on the random forcing and evolving random kl modes of the solution . the coefficients @xmath89 satisfy a pde system obtained by galerkin projection of the spde onto the space spanned by @xmath90 . statistical properties can be retrieved after solving the induced pde system . here are the computational bottlenecks of this approach : ( i ) the simple truncation yields a large number of terms in the expansion , which leads to long computational times to solve the deterministic evolution equations ; ( ii ) estimating the terms appearing in the kl expansion is a major computational bottleneck , especially in higher spatial dimensions ; and ( iii ) computation of the orthogonal polynomials @xmath91 may also require intensive amount of computation . in the following , we address these issues in turn . the number of terms in the simple truncation in the hermite pce increases rapidly with respect to @xmath55 and @xmath56 . given sufficient regularity of the solution , the expansion coefficients decay both in the number of gaussian variables @xmath56 and the degree of polynomials @xmath55 . this observation led the authors @xcite to introduce a sparse truncation of the multi - index set and retain a truncated random basis , which keeps lower ( higher ) order polynomials in @xmath92 with larger ( smaller ) subscripts . this truncation can be quantified using an estimate for the decay rate of the coefficients ; see @xcite . following @xcite , we introduce a sparse index @xmath93 and define the corresponding sparse multi - index set @xmath94 basically , the index @xmath95 keeps track of how much degree we want in each variable @xmath92 . using , one can define the corresponding version of the pc expansion which might have drastically reduced number of terms . this is possible by a suitable choice of the index @xmath95 so that ineffective cross terms in high degree polynomials are eliminated . at each restart @xmath66 , we employ the kl expansion for the projected random field @xmath71 , and the expansion is truncated after a finite number of @xmath29 terms . the decomposition yields the eigenvalues @xmath96 and the eigenfunctions @xmath97 for @xmath98 . therefore , in addition to the gaussian variables @xmath76 , we have the random modes @xmath84 in the pce so that the total number of random variables becomes @xmath99 . to accommodate @xmath84 , we extend the multi - index set to @xmath100 . this can also be done by the tensorization @xmath101 of the multi - index sets since @xmath76 and @xmath84 are independent . however , since tensorization yields higher number of terms in the pce for most values of @xmath56 and @xmath29 , it is not considered in the following . assuming that the orthonormal basis @xmath102 is constructed in the previous step , the solution @xmath80 is approximated using the truncated pce @xmath103 where the time dependence of the coefficients @xmath104 is omitted for brevity . to avoid confusion , we note that both the projection and its truncation will be denoted by @xmath71 . armed with this approximation , using the orthogonality of random bases , the covariance of @xmath71 is easily estimated by @xmath105 where @xmath106 . in practice , we consider a discretization of the spatial domain @xmath2 with an even mesh parameter @xmath107 and grid points @xmath108 , @xmath109 . denote by @xmath110 the resulting covariance matrix . in general , we can use a spectral method , e.g. , fourier series in the case of periodic functions , to approximate the coefficients @xmath111 as @xmath112 where @xmath113 are orthogonal global basis functions on @xmath2 and @xmath114 ; see @xcite . thus , @xmath104 is approximated by a vector @xmath115 on the grid . therefore , the dimension of the covariance matrix @xmath110 becomes of order @xmath116 . after computing the covariance matrix , the corresponding eigenvalue problem can be solved for the first @xmath29 largest eigenvalues . the random modes @xmath84 are given as @xmath117 ) \ , , \phi_{j , l } \rangle_{l^2(g ) } = \frac{1}{\sqrt{\lambda_{j , l } } } \sum_{{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}>0 } \langle u_{j,{\boldsymbol{\alpha } } } , \phi_{j , l } \rangle_{l^2 } \ , t_{{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}}({\boldsymbol{\xi}}_{j-1 } , { \boldsymbol{\eta}}_{j-1 } ) , \quad l=1,\ldots , d . \end{aligned}\ ] ] this representation yields the random modes @xmath84 as a function of @xmath118 and the previous modes @xmath119 . here , we assume that the integrals @xmath120 can be computed by an accurate quadrature method . when the solution @xmath4 is more than one - dimensional , several implementations of the kl expansion can be considered . for instance , we may apply the kl expansion to each component of the solution @xmath4 separately and incorporate the resulting individual random modes into one pce . although this approach certainly makes the kl step faster , we found that it yielded inaccurate results in dgpc and needed a large number of variables in the pce to represent the solution accurately since cross covariance structures between the components of the solution are lost . therefore , in the following , we implement the kl expansion directly to the multi - dimensional solution and produce one set of random modes @xmath121 which represents all of its components . depending on the resolution of the discretization of the domain @xmath2 and the dimension @xmath3 , assembling the covariance matrix and solving the corresponding eigenvalue problem may prove dauntingly expensive . several methods have been devised to reduce computational costs , such as fast fourier techniques ( e.g. , in the case of stationary covariance kernels ) or sparse matrix approximations together with krylov subspace solvers @xcite . here , the assembly of the covariance matrix is performed at each restart via the summation formula . in our one dimensional simulations , with @xmath122 , this assembly can be carried out reasonably fast . since the solution of the eigenvalue problem is required only for the number @xmath123 of eigenvalues and eigenfunctions , krylov subspace methods @xcite perform well . we also utilize the implicitly restarted arnoldi method to efficiently find the few largest eigenvalues and corresponding eigenfunctions ; @xcite . in the higher dimensional simulations , when @xmath124 , computing and storing such large covariance matrices become challenging . covariance matrices are , in general , not sparse and require @xmath125 units of storage in the memory . moreover , assembling a large matrix at every restart is computationally very expensive for long - time simulations . the problem of computing and storing a large covariance matrix resulting from the kl expansion is not new and was addressed before in @xcite . it was noted that although the covariance matrices were dense , they were usually of low - rank ; @xcite . based on this observation , we next introduce an approximation approach , which leverages low - rank structures and avoids assembling large matrices . a low - rank approximation @xmath126 tries to capture most of the action of the matrix @xmath110 by a product of two low - rank matrices @xmath127 and @xmath128 . several efficient algorithms , e.g. , the fast multipole method and @xmath129-matrices , depend on low - rank approximations @xcite . we approximate eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the correlation matrix @xmath110 by using low - rank approximations as follows . given a low rank approximation @xmath130 of the symmetric covariance matrix @xmath110 , where the matrix @xmath131 is of size @xmath132 with @xmath133 orthonormal columns , the eigenvalue problem of @xmath110 can be approximated efficiently by applying @xmath134 or @xmath135 algorithm to the much smaller matrix @xmath136 . in the dgpc setting , this amounts to computing @xmath137 the explicit assembly of the covariance matrix @xmath110 is avoided by computing only the matrix - vector product @xmath138 . an approximate eigenvalue decomposition @xmath139 is deduced from the eigenvalue decomposition of the smaller matrix @xmath140 by setting @xmath141 . the crucial step of the computation is the construction of a low - rank matrix @xmath131 with @xmath142 orthonormal columns that accurately describes @xmath110 . we tried an approach based on the discrete unitary fourier transform to map the coefficients @xmath143 to the frequency space and retain only the lowest frequencies . although this approach allowed us to obtain reasonable compressions of the covariance matrix and enabled faster computations , the following approach consistently yielded much better results . following @xcite , we construct the matrix @xmath131 using random projections . algorithm 4.1 in @xcite draws an @xmath144 gaussian random matrix @xmath145 and forms the matrix @xmath146 . the matrix @xmath131 with @xmath147 orthonormal columns is then obtained by the @xmath134 factorization @xmath148 . note again that we do not assemble the matrix @xmath110 . rather , the matrix - matrix product @xmath149 is computed as in equation @xmath150 . since we require the largest @xmath29 eigenvalues , the target low - rank becomes @xmath29 . as indicated in @xcite , we use an oversampling parameter @xmath8 by setting @xmath151 . typical values of @xmath8 are @xmath152 or @xmath153 . since eigenvalues decay rapidly in our applications , we found @xmath154 to be accurate . with overwhelming probability , the spectral error @xmath155 is bounded within a small polynomial perturbation of the theoretical minimum , the @xmath156 singular value of @xmath110 ; for relevant theoretical details , see ( * ? ? ? * section 10 ) . in practice , we found this randomized approach to be highly accurate in our computational simulations . moreover , since assembly of large covariance matrices are avoided , running times and memory requirements for the kl expansion in @xmath157 are reduced drastically compared to the previously described methods ; see section [ sec : sns ] . in this subsection , we consider the case in which the differential operator @xmath6 in contains additional random input parameters , i.e. , @xmath158 . the random inputs will be denoted by the process @xmath159 of a dimension @xmath160 . a typical case is that of a random viscosity , e.g. , depending on a set of uniformly distributed random variables . we assume that the process @xmath161 is independent of time and that the corresponding orthogonal polynomials are available ; for instance in the askey family @xcite . we first observe that the solution @xmath31 is now a functional of brownian motion @xmath162 and the random process @xmath161 . therefore , assuming @xmath30 integrability , it can be written as a pce in terms of the associated orthogonal polynomials of @xmath162 and @xmath161 . at the restart @xmath66 , there are two options to carry out the kl expansion : ( i ) apply the kl expansion to only the solution @xmath71 and keep the basis variables for @xmath161 in addition to @xmath84 in the next pce ; and ( ii ) compress the combined random variable @xmath163 using the kl expansion and denote by @xmath84 the combined random modes which represent both @xmath71 and @xmath161 . the first approach will yield pces which provide functional representations of the solution in terms of @xmath162 and @xmath161 for each time @xmath66 . in the second approach , the functional dependence of the solution in terms of @xmath161 is lost in the first kl expansion step . however , the moments of the solution can still be computed through the combined random kl modes . in many uq settings , rather than a functional dependence , it is statistical information of the underlying solution , e.g. , moments of the invariant measure in the long - time , that we are after . moreover , the second approach can be seen as a dimensionality reduction technique , which compresses @xmath71 and the process @xmath161 together , thereby further reducing the number of terms in pce . when additional random parameters appear in the equation , we found it reasonable to implement the second approach to reduce cost while the first approach may be used as a reference computation to assess accuracy . it is useful to note that by combining the random fields @xmath71 and @xmath161 , the algorithm automatically chooses the important part of the random process @xmath161 that influences the solution while keeping the moments of the solution accurate ; see section [ sec : numerical ] . after obtaining the random modes @xmath84 , @xmath164 , we need to construct the following orthonormal basis : @xmath165 notice that since @xmath76 is gaussian and identically distributed for each @xmath166 , the corresponding orthonormal polynomials of @xmath76 are known to be the hermite polynomials for each @xmath166 . however , the probability distribution of @xmath84 is arbitrary and changes at each restart . therefore , the computation of orthonormal polynomials is computationally intensive and can be performed using the gram schmidt method as follows . we note that the set can be computed based on the knowledge of moments of the variables @xmath76 and @xmath84 . following @xcite , we assemble the gram matrix @xmath167 with the entries @xmath168 , \quad { \boldsymbol{\alpha}}_k,{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_l \in \mathcal{j}^r_{k+d , n}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] the matrix @xmath167 is a @xmath169-dimensional , square and symmetric matrix . for theoretical reasons , we assume that the moments up to @xmath170 exist and the measure of @xmath171 is non - degenerate . then , the cholesky factorization is employed to @xmath167 and the polynomials @xmath172 is found by inverting the resulting upper triangular matrix as @xmath173 where @xmath174 are real coefficients . the kl expansion yields uncorrelated random variables @xmath84 . if the underlying process is gaussian , it is known that these variables are also independent . however , in general , marginals of @xmath84 are dependent variables . multi - index operations can still be used to construct the polynomial set with respect to the joint distribution , although the estimation of multivariate moments of @xmath84 becomes necessary because of such a dependency . in this case , it is known that orthogonal polynomials are not unique and depend on the ordering imposed on the multi - index set ; see @xcite . in all computations , we use the graded lexicographic ordering for multi - indices . the completeness of the orthogonal polynomials @xmath175 is closely related to the moment problem of the random variables @xmath76 and @xmath84 . in particular , if the moment problem is uniquely solvable , i.e. , the measure is determinate , then the orthogonal polynomials are dense in @xmath30 @xcite . some basic conditions that guarantee determinacy of the measure of a continuous random variable on a finite dimensional space are compact support and exponential integrability . gaussian measures are determinate and the hermite pce converges by the cameron - martin theorem . however , in general , whether the distribution of @xmath84 is determinate or not is unknown . this problem is addressed in our previous work in the case of finite dimensional sde systems ; see @xcite . theoretical results are applied in the setting where the solutions are approximated by compactly supported distributions under appropriate assumptions . in the following , we assume that the measures associated to @xmath84 are determinate so that convergence is guaranteed , which is consistent with our numerical simulations ; see section [ sec : numerical ] . based on the above discussion , the orthonormal basis requires the computation of the moments . the exact moments of the gaussian variables @xmath76 are computed by analytical formulas and then stored during the offline stage . however , the distribution of @xmath84 is varying with @xmath166 . therefore , the computation of moments should be carried out based on information provided by the pce . several methods are available to compute moments of probability distributions in the pc context such as , e.g. , quadrature methods , monte carlo sampling , or a pure pce approach . this procedure is notoriously expensive and ill - posed @xcite . the pure pce approach computes the moments of @xmath84 by repeatedly multiplying its pce and taking expectation ; see @xcite . this approach is discussed in detail in our earlier manuscript @xcite and works reasonably well for a low dimensional sde systems . however , it becomes prohibitively expensive if the dimension of the random variables in the pc basis is even moderate ; see the computational complexity section in @xcite . therefore , in this work , we consider an alternative approach using monte carlo sampling , which drastically reduces the computational cost for computing moments compared to the pure pce approach . we assume that independent samples of the initial condition ( therefore , the samples of @xmath176 ) are provided so that the algorithm can be initialized . to construct the set , based on , we need to compute the first @xmath170 moments of the joint random variable @xmath171 . moreover , since the triple products will be required for the evolution of the pce coefficients , the first @xmath177 moments need to be computed as well ; see section [ sec : galerkin_proj ] . using the same ordering of the multi - index set @xmath178 , we require the computation of the following moments : @xmath179 = { \mathbb{e}}[{\boldsymbol{\xi}}_j^{(\alpha_1,\ldots,\alpha_k ) } ] \,{\mathbb{e}}[{\boldsymbol{\eta}}_j^{(\alpha_{k+1},\ldots,\alpha_{k+d } ) } ] , \quad { \boldsymbol{\alpha}}\in \mathcal{j}^r_{k+d,3n},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used the independence of @xmath76 and @xmath84 . let @xmath180 denote independent samples of the random modes for @xmath181 , where @xmath182 . then , provided the samples @xmath183 are given , the moments of @xmath184 can be approximated by @xmath185 \approx \frac{1}{s } \sum_{i=1}^s ( { \boldsymbol{\eta}}_j(\omega_i))^{(\alpha_{k+1},\ldots,\alpha_{k+d } ) } = \frac{1}{s } \sum_{i=1}^s \prod_{l=1}^d ( \eta_{j , l}(\omega_i ) ) ^{\alpha_{k+l}},\ ] ] where we used the usual multi - index notation for powers . therefore , multivariate moments are computed by a combination of the analytical formulas for @xmath76 and a sampling approximation for @xmath84 . note that in applications , we use small values of @xmath55 with a sufficiently large number of samples @xmath186 to guarantee accuracy . although we discussed computing moments based on samples , we have not explained how the samples of @xmath84 are acquired except for @xmath176 . the distribution of @xmath84 , @xmath187 , is evolving in time . however , owing to the pce of the each component @xmath188 , we can write @xmath189 this representation gives a natural way to sample from the distribution of @xmath84 by the recursion @xmath190 assuming that we obtained samples of @xmath191 at the previous restart @xmath192 . independent samples @xmath193 are obtained through sampling a multivariate gaussian distribution . therefore , on the subinterval @xmath194 $ ] , pce acts like a transport map which maps previously obtained samples of @xmath119 and new samples of @xmath118 to the samples of the new random modes @xmath84 . note that @xmath84 is a function of the variables @xmath118 and @xmath119 . therefore , the number of samples of @xmath84 should be ideally @xmath195 provided the same of number of samples @xmath186 is used for each @xmath118 and @xmath119 . however , in practice , this is not feasible in our method as the number of samples grows in time . instead , the equation keeps only the diagonal terms in the sample space . in the numerical simulations , we use large values of @xmath186 so that the loss of accuracy incurred from discarding some samples would be minimal . moreover , it is important to notice that entails samples from the joint distribution of @xmath84 so that monte carlo method is used to approximate the expectations while preserving the dependence structure of marginals . [ rmk : samples ] the method blends monte carlo sampling into a pc approach to exploit the virtues of the both methods , namely , rapid computation of expectations and spectral accuracy provided by the mc and pc methods , respectively . although the method is utilizing samples for the computation of moments , samples are not used in the evolution stage . the algorithm essentially propagates moments of the measures between successive times , where moments are computed using a sampling technique . to test the robustness of the method with respect to sampling , imagine that the algorithm starts with an infinite supply of independent samples of @xmath196 . we discard the first sample after using it to construct the corresponding orthogonal polynomials at the end of the first time interval and propagate the remaining samples with the pce map to construct ( an infinite supply of ) samples of @xmath197 . the algorithm iteratively estimates the distribution , hence the moments , of each @xmath84 while samples are discarded at each restart . we tested this idea by starting with a set of @xmath48 independent samples of @xmath176 and propagated them by pce for a maximum of @xmath48 restarts . we found that the accuracy of the calculations was not affected by such a re - sampling tool . this comparison showed the robustness of the algorithm under changes of samples . since in practice , such re - sampling increases the computational costs compared to , it is not considered in the numerical experiments presented in the next sections . we also emphasize that the sampling approach readily returns samples of the approximated solution at the endpoint @xmath198 through its kl expansion without a further sampling procedure . these samples can also be useful in uncertainty quantification to estimate further statistical properties of the solution such as probabilities on prescribed sets or probability density functions . once an orthonormal basis is obtained , the algorithm performs a galerkin projection onto the space spanned by the basis , and this requires the computation of triple products . using the representation , the required triple products can be written as @xmath199 = \sum _ { { \boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{k ' } \leq { \boldsymbol{\alpha}}_k}\sum _ { { \boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{l ' } \leq { \boldsymbol{\alpha}}_l } \sum _ { { \boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{m ' } \leq { \boldsymbol{\alpha}}_m } a_{k'k } \ , a_{l'l } \ , a_{m'm } \ , { \mathbb{e}}[({\boldsymbol{\xi}}_j,{\boldsymbol{\eta}}_j)^{{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{k ' } + { \boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{l'}+ { \boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{m ' } } ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where all multi - indices belong to the set @xmath100 . thus this formula can be computed by the knowledge of moments of order up to @xmath177 . depending on the choice of the sparse index @xmath95 , the multi - index @xmath200 might not be an element of @xmath178 . therefore , once we fix the multi - index set @xmath100 in the offline stage , we also compute and store the indices that are elements of @xmath178 . finally , we perform galerkin projection of the spde and obtain the following pde system for the coefficients @xmath89 of , @xmath83 $ ] : @xmath201 + \sigma(x ) \ , { \mathbb{e}}[t_{{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}}({\boldsymbol{\xi}}_j , { \boldsymbol{\eta}}_j ) \dot{w}(t)].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first expectation in the above line is computed with the aid of the triple products and the second using the representation . note that the initial conditions @xmath202 can be obtained by noticing that the representation of @xmath71 is nothing but a sum involving linear polynomials in @xmath188 . it can therefore be rewritten in the basis @xmath203 with the help of galerkin projections . hence , the only coefficients that survive in at @xmath204 are the mean and the ones which correspond to the first degree polynomials in @xmath84 . then , the pde system can be solved in time using a time - integration method combined with the aforementioned spectral method . if the initial condition @xmath61 of is deterministic , we employ the hermite pce on the first interval @xmath205 $ ] , which does not necessitate the computation of the kl decomposition . so far , the method uses a predetermined restart time @xmath206 . for long - term simulations , an adaptive restart scheme that sets the restarts online depending on the properties of the solution can reduce the computational cost . we propose to adapt the restart time based on the following two criteria : ( i ) preserve the accuracy of the representation of the random forcing ; and ( ii ) mitigate the effect the nonlinearities in the accuracy of the polynomial expansions . for a prescribed number of dimensions to describe the random forcing , the algorithm can not take too large steps to preserve accuracy . also , nonlinearities force the solution to be less accurately described by low - degree polynomials in the initial condition as time increases . in both cases , we wish @xmath206 to be as large as possible for a given accuracy in mind . to this end , let @xmath207 denote the adaptive time - step starting from time @xmath66 . to ensure an accurate representation of the forcing term , we set a maximum value @xmath208 for @xmath209 for all @xmath166 , i.e. @xmath210 . in practice , @xmath208 is based on the error analysis of random forcing by a finite dimensional approximation ; see for instance @xcite . to address nonlinearities , we consider the following ratio for the pc coefficients @xmath111 : @xmath211.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the condition measures the norm ratio of the nonlinear terms in the variance to the norm of the variance . in applications , the ratio is computed at each time integration point . similar other conditions were used in different settings in @xcite . consider a threshold value @xmath212 . we propose the following conditions for adaptive time - steps using @xmath213 $ ] : a. @xmath214 , [ item : less3eps ] b. @xmath215 , [ item : bigger3eps ] where @xmath216 is a polynomial approximation to @xmath217 , which can be found by fitting a @xmath8-degree polynomial to @xmath217 on the interval @xmath218 $ ] . this approximation is only required for time values @xmath219 satisfying @xmath220 . the time - steps @xmath209 , @xmath221 are set adaptively . for short time - steps , we do not expect dynamics to change drastically between successive intervals . therefore , condition [ item : less3eps ] verifies whether the ratio is smaller than @xmath222 on the current interval , and then sets the adaptive time - step for the next interval . when @xmath223 , then the algorithm selects a bigger time - step by finding the root of @xmath224 . note that the current evolution on the interval @xmath225 $ ] is not prematurely stopped at the end point . although pces converge at any point inside the interval , errors , however , are known to wildly oscillate inside the interval and become spectrally accurate only at the end point ; see @xcite . ( this is because @xmath226 in is spectrally accurate at @xmath227 and much less so on @xmath67 . ) condition [ item : bigger3eps ] essentially verifies whether the ratio becomes too large ( i.e. @xmath228 ) , and when this happens , forces the evolution to restart from the current initial point @xmath192 . this control ensures that the algorithm does not take too large steps . our procedure is summarized in algorithm [ alg : dgpc ] , where , for simplicity , we only present the version which uses a predetermined number of restarts . + decompose the time domain @xmath41 = [ 0,t_1 ] \cup \ldots \cup [ t_{n-1},t]$ ] + initialize the degrees of freedom @xmath229 + choose the sparse index @xmath230 + compute the indices used in the triple - product formula + compute moments of @xmath231 apply the kl expansion to @xmath71 and obtain @xmath232 compute the moments @xmath233 $ ] construct orthogonal polynomials @xmath175 compute the associated triple products perform galerkin projection onto @xmath234 set up initial conditions for @xmath235 evolve the pce coefficients of @xmath235 we now present numerical simulations for the burgers equation in one spatial dimension and a navier stokes system in two spatial dimensions both driven by white noise . we consider these equations for two reasons . first , the statistical behavior of solutions of these equations is of importance in statistical mechanics and turbulence theory ; see , e.g. , @xcite . second , they serve as challenging test beds for the pce methodology . we illustrate convergence results in terms of the degrees of freedoms @xmath29 , @xmath55 and the time - step @xmath206 , and consider both short - time and long - time evolutions . the convergence of the method in terms of @xmath56 is treated in detail in @xcite . as a general comment , we do not recommend using large values of @xmath55 since the computation of orthogonal polynomials is quite ill - posed . in the following , we use polynomials of degree up to @xmath236 . the algorithm mitigates the ill - posedness by choosing frequent restarts and small degree ; i.e. small @xmath206 and @xmath55 . the settings we consider here closely follow those addressed in the manuscripts @xcite . we consider the following one dimensional viscous stochastic burgers equation for @xmath31 : @xmath237 \times [ 0,t ] , \end{cases}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath226 is a brownian motion in time , @xmath238 is the viscosity ( which will be either deterministic or random ) , the initial condition @xmath61 is deterministic , and the solution itself is periodic in the spatial domain @xmath239 $ ] . following @xcite , we choose cosine functions as an orthonormal basis @xmath240 , for @xmath241 $ ] . employing the equation for each subinterval @xmath242 $ ] and using galerkin projection , we derive the governing equations for the pc coefficients @xmath89 of @xmath235 : @xmath243,\ ] ] where @xmath244 . since the initial condition is deterministic , we employ hermite pce in the subinterval @xmath245 $ ] . the pc coefficients @xmath246 of the nonlinearity @xmath247 are computed by multiplying the corresponding pces with the help of pre - computed triple products . since the coefficients @xmath89 are periodic in the physical space , we utilize a truncated fourier series : @xmath248,\ ] ] with the even number of frequencies @xmath249 to be chosen . further , using the equidistant partition for the spatial domain @xmath239 $ ] and fast fourier transform ( fft ) , we can compute the fourier coefficients @xmath250 with a reasonable computational cost . this procedure gives rise to an ode system which is then integrated in time using a second order predictor - corrector method combined with an exponential integrator for the stiff term @xcite . in the implementation of the burgers equation , the algorithm assembles the covariance matrix at each restart as discussed in section [ sec : klexpansion ] . a large memory is not required for such a one dimensional spatial problem . we found that using the random projection technique described in section [ sec : klexpansion ] did not result in significantly shorter total computational times because the computation of the eigenvalue problem is already efficient in this case by means of krylov subspace methods . [ ex : burgers1 ] for this numerical simulation , we choose the spatial part of the random forcing as @xmath251 , the initial condition as @xmath252 and set the viscosity @xmath253 . under these sets of parameters , it has been proved that there exists a unique invariant measure , which is the long - time limit of the dynamics ( * ? ? ? * theorem 2 ) . thus , the main aim of the following simulations is to demonstrate the efficiency of the algorithm in the long - time setting . for the parameters of dgpc , we take @xmath254 , @xmath255 , and vary the number of the kl modes @xmath29 . final time is @xmath256 and the interval divided into @xmath257 pieces by taking @xmath258 . the spatial mesh size @xmath249 is set to be @xmath259 and the number of samples @xmath186 to compute moments is taken as @xmath260 . finally , sparse indices @xmath95 are chosen as follows : a. if @xmath261 , then @xmath262 , and if @xmath263 , we set @xmath264 resulting in @xmath265 terms in the expansion . b. if @xmath266 , then @xmath267 , and if @xmath263 , we set @xmath268 resulting in @xmath269 terms in the expansion . c. if @xmath270 , then @xmath271 , and if @xmath263 , we set @xmath272 resulting in @xmath273 terms in the expansion . note that the first @xmath56 indices in @xmath95 correspond to degrees of polynomials in @xmath42 and the remaining to @xmath121 . choosing @xmath267 means using only first degree polynomials is @xmath274 and @xmath275 . also , setting @xmath268 for @xmath276 eliminates the cross terms involving first degree polynomials of @xmath275 in the second order terms . note that using a sparse index not only reduces the number of terms in pce but also alleviates the computation of moments . to compare our algorithm , we use a second order weak runge - kutta scheme since the exact solution is not available . to make a fair comparison , both algorithms ( monte carlo & dgpc ) use the same time - step @xmath277 and the same mesh size @xmath278 . the number of samples used in mc algorithms are @xmath279 and @xmath260 and the corresponding algorithms will be denoted by mc1 , mc2 and mc3 , respectively . the exact solution is taken as the result of mc3 and the relative @xmath30 error @xmath280 - { \mathbb{e}}[u_{mc } ] ||_{2}/|| { \mathbb{e}}[u_{mc}]||_2 $ ] of the mean is computed . errors for higher order centered moments are computed similarly . from figure [ fig : ex1_1 ] , we observe that all errors grow with time in the initial stages and in particular , the degree of freedom @xmath261 is the least accurate , which is expected as the dynamics change rapidly during initial stages . increasing the number of kl modes entails more accurate expansion up to some order . it can be observed that all the error levels stabilize for moderate times while @xmath270 is the most accurate . this phenomenon is explained by the convergence to a stationary measure such that statistics do not change considerably after some time . we now increase the final time to @xmath281 . dgpc algorithms use the following parameters : @xmath282 , @xmath255 , @xmath283 , @xmath284 and @xmath258 . the corresponding total number of terms for each subinterval becomes @xmath285 , @xmath286 and @xmath287 . the mesh size is taken as @xmath288 , which offers better spatial resolution . table [ table : burgdet ] summarizes the relative @xmath30 errors of the dgpc algorithms with different degrees of freedom and the mc methods . all errors are computed by taking mc3 as the exact solution . the time ratio column is computed as the total time required by the each algorithm divided by the elapsed time of mc3 with @xmath289 and @xmath290 . the parameters for mc1 and mc2 algorithms remain the same as above ; the algorithms are executed a few times and the resulting errors are averaged . we also include the elapsed times for the offline computation in dgpc algorithms . in practice , the required data for the offline step can be computed once and stored for further executions of the algorithm to speed - up the running time . .relative errors for the centered moments by dgpc and mc methods at t=6 . each time ratio is computed by comparing to mc3 . [ cols=">,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] table [ table : rel_err_vor_rand_vis ] exhibits the relative errors of dgpc for the vorticity using the random matrix approach for the kl expansion . comparing table [ table : rel_err_vor_rand_vis ] and [ table : rel_err_fourier_truncation ] , we see that relative elapsed times of dgpc with respect to mc3 are further improved . additional randomness for mc means an extra dimension to sample from , whereas for dgpc , it means an extra variable that needs to be compressed into the modes @xmath121 . since the dynamics crucially depend on the behavior of the viscosity , using few realizations for viscosity sampling in mc is not recommended . iin this setting , we found that our mc simulations demanded a high cpu time compared to dgpc . note , however , that viscosity sampling could clearly be performed in parallel in a mc framework something that is not as easily feasible in the pce setting . the preceding simulations were concerned with short time evolutions of sns and comparisons of the proposed algorithm with a monte carlo method . numerical results for reasonably short time computations indicated that our algorithm achieved a similar accuracy compared to mc typically for a smaller computational cost . we are now interested in long time simulations and convergence to steady states . since there is no random forcing acting upon the temperature equation in , the ( uncoupled ) temperature diffuses to zero quickly . therefore , we only solve the vorticity equation in the system . the following numerical experiment considers the vorticity equation with a deterministic viscosity @xmath291 and a spatial forcing as described in example [ ex : sns_short1 ] . the parameters of the simulation are @xmath292 , @xmath293 , @xmath294 and @xmath295 . pc expansions with thirty number of terms are employed on each subinterval . the four - step adams predictor - corrector method is used for the time integration . figure [ fig : ex7_1 ] shows three different initial conditions for the vorticity . the first layer is supported around @xmath296 while the others are aligned horizontally . widths of all layers are widened and different sinusoidal perturbations are considered . in figure [ fig : ex7_2 ] , we show the @xmath30-norm of the successive differences of the first two moments in time . each column represents one of the initial conditions presented in the corresponding column in figure [ fig : ex7_1 ] . after a ( very ) long time , the norms of the successive differences drop below @xmath297 , which ( numerically ) indicates that statistical moments no longer change significantly in time . in all cases , we found that the dynamics converged to the same state , which is shown in figure [ fig : ex7_3 ] . notice that the invariant measure is a non - gaussian random field and the moments have oscillations in the @xmath5 variable . we also see that high variance regions correspond to where the mean fields display peaks . based on these findings for this scenario , we assert that the dynamics converge to an invariant measure which is numerically captured in the long - time by the dgpc algorithm . + in long time computations , the mc method usually requires the propagation of many realizations in time , which renders the method hardly affordable in some cases . however , if the dynamical system possesses a unique ergodic invariant measure , the mc method may be carried out to sample such a measure by considering a single , very long time mc realization , which repeatedly visits the whole state space . while carrying out such a sampling is also computationally expensive , it is likely to compare favorably to our dgpc algorithm in this case . in general , ergodicity or uniqueness of an invariant measure may not be known or not hold for complicated physical dynamics ( e.g. , invariant measures parametrized by a random parameter as in example [ ex : randomvis ] ) . in such cases , our algorithm offers a viable alternative to the mc method to capture the long - term dynamics by providing statistical information resulting from the expansion coefficients . we have presented a pc - based algorithm , called dynamical generalized polynomial chaos , to tackle long - time integration and high dimensional randomness in the context of pdes with markovian forcing . to deal with these challenges , dgpc uses a restart procedure , which constructs pces dynamically based on the polynomials of the projections of the solution , the random forcing and the random parameters found in the equation . the karhunen loeve expansion is employed at each restart to find a representation of the solutions which correspond to low - dimensional dynamics of the underlying physical processes . the relevant modes are then incorporated in a pce for the future evolution . using sparse multi - index sets and frequent restarts , the algorithm provides an efficient way to capture the solutions in a fairly sparse random bases in terms of orthogonal polynomials of dynamically evolving measures . the main computational bottlenecks of the algorithm are the simulation of the deterministic evolution equation , the kl expansion , and the computation of moments . the cost of the deterministic evolution is dictated by the complicated nature of the spdes . the kl expansion is an expensive dimensionality reduction technique . since the algorithm constructs pces online , kl expansions ( or other dimensionality reductions methods ) are unavoidable at each restart . we found that for large covariance matrices , the kl cost was drastically reduced when the covariance matrix was estimated by a low - rank approximation obtained by random projections . the estimation of the orthogonal polynomials and corresponding triple products of evolving arbitrary measures is also a costly step as in most pc - based methods . using a 1d randomly forced burgers equation and a 2d stochastic navier stokes system , we provided several numerical simulations for both short- and long - time solutions . we compared the accuracy and computational time of the algorithm to the standard monte carlo method and found that the proposed algorithm achieved similar error levels for a ( generally significant ) lower computational cost in most cases . the substantial speed - up of dgpc is especially promising when the equation contains additional , time - independent , random contributions , which is one of the main reasons to use pc based methods in general . to demonstrate the efficiency of the algorithm for long time simulations , we computed invariant measures for both equations , which is not a trivial task for two dimensional navier stokes systems . other methods such as the recent multilevel monte carlo techniques offer improvements over the standard mc methods @xcite . the restarting step of our algorithm remains expensive computationally , especially for problems in two ( or three ) spatial dimensions . however , the restart method provides a viable means to keep the number of random variables to reasonable levels . its ability to compute statistical properties of long - time evolutions for fairly complicated equations is quite promising . the authors would like to thank the reviewers for their critical reading of the manuscript , and for multiple remarks and suggestions that improved the presentation of our method . this work was partially funded by nsf grant dms-1408867 and onr grant n00014 - 15 - 1 - 2679 . h. c. ozen , g. bal , http://dx.doi.org/10.1137/15m1019167[dynamical polynomial chaos expansions and long time evolution of differential equations with random forcing ] , siam / asa j. uncertain . quantif . 4 ( 1 ) ( 2016 ) 609635 . r. ghanem , j. red - horse , propagation of probabilistic uncertainty in complex physical systems using a stochastic finite element approach , phys . d 133 ( 1 - 4 ) ( 1999 ) 137144 , predictability : quantifying uncertainty in models of complex phenomena ( los alamos , nm , 1998 ) . g. bal , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-11259-6_9-1[propagation of stochasticity in heterogeneous media and applications to uncertainty quantification ] , in : r. ghanem , d. higdon , h. owhadi ( eds . ) , handbook of uncertainty quantification , springer international publishing , cham , 2016 , pp . 124 . g. potte , d. lucor , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jcp.2011.12.038[non intrusive iterative stochastic spectral representation with application to compressible gas dynamics ] , j. comput . phys . 231 ( 9 ) ( 2012 ) 35873609 . g. berkooz , p. holmes , j. l. lumley , the proper orthogonal decomposition in the analysis of turbulent flows , in : annual review of fluid mechanics , vol . 25 , annual reviews , palo alto , ca , 1993 , pp . 539575 . m. jardak , c .- h . su , g. e. karniadakis , http://dx.doi.org/10.1023/a:1015125304044[spectral polynomial chaos solutions of the stochastic advection equation ] , in : proceedings of the fifth international conference on spectral and high order methods ( icosahom-01 ) ( uppsala ) , vol . 17 , 2002 , pp . 319338 . m. arnst , r. ghanem , e. phipps , j. red - horse , measure transformation and efficient quadrature in reduced - dimensional stochastic modeling of coupled problems , internat . methods engrg . 92 ( 12 ) ( 2012 ) 10441080 . n. halko , p. g. martinsson , j. a. tropp , http://dx.doi.org/10.1137/090771806[finding structure with randomness : probabilistic algorithms for constructing approximate matrix decompositions ] , siam rev . 53 ( 2 ) ( 2011 ) 217288 . j. xu , j. li , sparse wiener chaos approximations of zakai equation for nonlinear filtering , in proceedings of the 21st annual ieee international conference on chinese control and decision conference ( ccdc09 ) ( 2009 , ) pp . 910913 . j. s. hesthaven , s. gottlieb , d. gottlieb , spectral methods for time - dependent problems , vol . 21 of cambridge monographs on applied and computational mathematics , cambridge university press , cambridge , 2007 . r. b. lehoucq , d. c. sorensen , c. yang , arpack users guide : solution of large - scale eigenvalue problems with implicitly restarted arnoldi methods , vol . 6 of software , environments , and tools , society for industrial and applied mathematics ( siam ) , philadelphia , pa , 1998 . b. j. debusschere , h. n. najm , p. p. pbay , o. m. knio , r. g. ghanem , o. p. le matre , numerical challenges in the use of polynomial chaos representations for stochastic processes , siam j. sci . comput . 26 ( 2 ) ( 2004 ) 698719 . h. n. najm , uncertainty quantification and polynomial chaos techniques in computational fluid dynamics , in : annual review of fluid mechanics . 41 , vol . 41 of annu . fluid mech . , annual reviews , palo alto , ca , 2009 , pp .

we propose a dynamical generalized polynomial chaos ( dgpc ) method to solve time - dependent stochastic partial differential equations ( spdes ) with white noise forcing . the long - time simulation of spde solutions by polynomial chaos ( pc ) methods is notoriously difficult as the dimension of the stochastic variables increases linearly with time . exploiting the markovian property of white noise , dgpc @xcite implements a restart procedure that allows us to expand solutions at future times in terms of orthogonal polynomials of the measure describing the solution at a given time and the future white noise . the dimension of the representation is kept minimal by application of a karhunen loeve ( kl ) expansion . using frequent restarts and low degree polynomials on sparse multi - index sets , the method allows us to perform long time simulations , including the calculation of invariant measures for systems which possess one . we apply the method to the numerical simulation of stochastic burgers and navier stokes equations with white noise forcing . our method also allows us to incorporate time - independent random coefficients such as a random viscosity . we propose several numerical simulations and show that the algorithm compares favorably with standard monte carlo methods . keywords : stochastic partial differential equations , uncertainty quantification , polynomial chaos , karhunen - loeve expansion

1403.2744

the ultracold quantum gases have been the test bed to investigate the many - body physics @xcite . thanks to the versatile advances in the experiments , the interaction strength @xcite , the optical lattice depth , and the dimensionality can be manipulated to study strongly correlated quantum gases . to name a few , the typical atomic systems involve luttinger liquid of one - dimensional ( 1d ) bose gases @xcite , a three - dimensional ( 3d ) bose - mott insulator @xcite , and the superfluid state of two - component fermi gases @xcite . conventional experimental measurements of the atomic many - body systems include the time - of - flight experiment , the noise correlations measurement @xcite , the bragg scattering spectroscopy @xcite , and the in - situ imaging @xcite . recently , we investigate the spectrum of electromagnetically induced transparency ( eit ) @xcite in the strongly correlated atomic systems @xcite as an alternative and non - destructive method @xcite to probe the quantum many - body physics . the eit spectrum is shown to be solely determined by the single - particle green s function of the ground - state atoms . non - trivial many - body effect for the spectrum is predicted @xcite when the atoms are virtually coupled to the low - lying rydberg states @xcite . the single - particle green s function is crucial for many - body systems , from which the observable of any single - particle operator , the ground state energy , and the excitation spectrum can be extracted @xcite . similar to the well - known angle - resolved photoemission spectroscopy ( arpes ) @xcite , where the single - particle green s function is probed to investigate the electronic structure of the surface in the solids , the eit spectroscopy accesses the information of it as well . what differs is the single - particle green s function in arpes is directly measured whereas the eit spectrum involves an integral of the green s function and the functional laser parameters @xcite . a recent proposal of probing spin correlation functions by ramsey interferometry @xcite provides the other direct way to measure the dynamical green s function of the many - body systems . in ultracold atomic systems , matter wave interference patterns are powerful to reveal the many - body physics . for example in two - dimensional ( 2d ) bose - einstein condensate ( bec ) @xcite , the contrast of interference fringes relates to the spatial single - particle green s function @xcite . therefore , the algebraic decay of spatial correlation in the contrast indicates the quasi - long - range order in the system , which can be fully described by green s function . in addition , the second - order correlation function in the interference pattern of two 1d bose gases is also manifested to provide the evidence of luttinger liquid signatures @xcite . on the contrary to the destructive interference method , quantum non - demolition ( qnd ) detection of quantum matter @xcite provides a least destructive measurement . it can be used to effectively map the quantum correlations of the ultracold atoms into light signals , which is similar to our proposed eit scheme in this paper . the common feature of matter wave interference and eit spectrum in probing the quantum many - body physics is that the measurements respectively involve the average and integral of the green s function , making both methods the indirect probes . nevertheless the eit spectroscopy has the advantage of non - destructive probe with well - controlled laser parameters , which may provide more efficient and precise measurements on the ultracold atoms . in this paper , we demonstrate that the dynamical single - particle green s function of the many - body system can be determined by eit spectroscopy . in section ii , we briefly describe the eit susceptibility in terms of the green s function @xcite . then we propose an experimental setup to realize the reconstruction of the single - particle green s function , and also discuss the finite size effect . in section iii , we investigate finite temperature green s function , and demonstrate the reconstruction steps by measuring the frequency moments from the information of eit spectrum . we take 3d mott - insulator and 1d luttinger liquid as two examples . in the last section , we discuss possible application to other many - body systems and summarize . our results suggest a universal determination on the essential single - particle green s function of the ultracold quantum gases in parallel to the arpes in the solids . we consider the conventional eit setup ( @xmath0 type scheme ) as shown in fig . [ fig1 ] . the probe ( @xmath1 ) and control ( @xmath2 ) fields couple the ground state @xmath3 to the other hyperfine ground state @xmath4 and an excited state @xmath5 . the detunings are @xmath6 and @xmath7 for the probe and control fields respectively . they are defined as the differences from the laser central ( @xmath8 ) to the atomic transition frequencies . in the linear response of the probe field , the electric susceptibility is derived as @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the fourier transform of slow - varying @xmath11 , and @xmath12 is the polarization operator calculated by the perturbation of a weak probe field @xcite . in the momentum - frequency space , the electric susceptibility is obtained as ( @xmath13 ) @xcite @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the quantization volume , @xmath16 is the dipole moment of the probe field transition , and @xmath17 is the fourier transform of the green s function @xmath18 at zero temperature @xcite . the functional @xmath19 that includes the laser parameters is @xmath20 where the mixing angle is @xmath21 and the eigenenergies from the unperturbed hamiltonian in the eit setup ( @xmath22 ) is @xmath23 the recoil - energy shifted detuning is @xmath24 , the kinetic energy is @xmath25 , and the recoil momentum is @xmath26 . the chemical potential is @xmath27 , and @xmath28 are the central momenta of the probe and control fields respectively . a phenomenonological spontaneous decay rate ( @xmath29 ) of the excited state can be added by replacing @xmath30 with @xmath31 . note that we assume negligible dephasing rate between the two hyperfine ground states . the above eq . ( [ chi ] ) provides the crucial recipe of the many - body effects on the eit spectrum for generally any strongly correlated ultracold quantum gases @xcite . the nontrivial power - law dependence of the eit spectrum near the resonance is shown for a luttinger liquid , and the significant frequency shift and asymmetric absorption spectrum can be identified for a bose - mott insulator phase @xcite . this non - destructive eit measurement is proposed to detect the fermi paring in a bardeen - cooper - schrieffer ( bcs ) superfluid state of two - component fermi gases @xcite . the gap energy can be also measured from the transparency position @xcite . as long as the single - particle green s function is known , the eit spectrum can be derived . on the other hand , the eit spectroscopy can be an efficient method to extract the single - particle green s function . ] via an eit experiment with a probe pulse . the experiment is conducted with a probe pulse in the ultracold quantum gas with an atomic @xmath0-type configuration : the counter - propagating control ( @xmath32 ) and the probe [ @xmath33 fields in @xmath34 direction couple two hyperfine ground states @xmath3 and @xmath4 with the excited state @xmath5 ( detunings are @xmath7 and @xmath6 respectively ) . @xmath29 is the spontaneous decay rate of @xmath5 . b.s . represents the beam splitter . open circles denote the fiber coupling that guide the reference and transmitted pulses into the temporal interferometry . from the interferometry box , we characterize the output probe pulse @xmath35 . @xmath36 is then extracted by reconstructing green s function from the frequency moment calculation in eit spectroscopy.,width=302,height=181 ] the functional @xmath19 incorporates all the information of the laser parameters in the eit setup , which is well defined . we find that eq . ( [ chi ] ) has a simple form of the convolution between the single - particle green s function and @xmath37 in momentum - frequency space . since the dispersion of the probe field has @xmath38 in the propagating direction , the momentum ( position ) of @xmath39 ( @xmath40 ) is not able to be resolved independently from frequency ( time ) in the eit spectroscopy . we let @xmath39 @xmath41 @xmath42 in eq . ( [ chi ] ) which is valid if the spread of frequency @xmath43 @xmath44 @xmath8 so @xmath45 @xmath46 @xmath47 . we first fourier transform eq . ( [ chi ] ) in frequency space , @xmath48 where @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the inverse fourier transforms ( @xmath51 ) of @xmath52 and @xmath53 respectively with @xmath54 @xmath55 @xmath56 . we may proceed to fourier transform the momentum degree of freedom ( @xmath54 ) above , and derive directly the transverse space and real - time green s function @xmath57 in terms of @xmath58 and @xmath59 where @xmath60 @xmath55 @xmath61 . the validity of the fourier transform in momentum space requires large enough @xmath54 to cover the complete eit spectrum @xmath49 . to estimate the largest possible transverse range of the probe field momentum , it is limited by @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the average transverse atomic distance . in this limit however the probe field suffers from small optical density if the interacting cross section is less than @xmath64 . therefore the probe field can not probe large enough momentum for general quantum degenerate gases ( with the order of @xmath65 nm for a typical density @xmath66 @xmath67 ) , and we can not further fourier transform eq . ( 5 ) . for simplification and to proceed the investigation of green s function retrieval , we choose @xmath68 and eq . ( [ green1 ] ) becomes @xmath69 where due to the limited spatial bandwidth of the eit , we may not resolve directly the transverse dynamical green s function from the eit susceptibility @xmath70 . however we will show in the examples of the next section that we may still extract the dynamical green s function @xmath71 from the information of @xmath70 . the eit spectrum holds much useful information to reconstruct @xmath71 to provide the features that characterize the many - body systems . in addition we note that choosing a different @xmath54 in eq . ( [ green1 ] ) does not improve our reconstruction steps in the examples of section iii , and in general it makes no significant difference than eq . ( [ green ] ) . in fig . [ fig1 ] , we demonstrate an experimental setup to extract the single - particle green s function using eit spectroscopy . we use a spatio - temporal pulse to probe the ultracold quantum gas . the probe pulse goes through a 50:50 beam splitter ( b.s . ) to interact with the atoms , and the reflected one acts as a reference pulse . the transmitted probe pulse is then guided by the fiber to interfere with the reference one . we denote the process as the interferometry box that characterizes the temporal information of the transmitted pulse . this technique of measuring the spatial and temporal electric field @xcite is not new for the ultrafast optical society . the single trace of interferometry is done through the input fiber at the specific position @xmath72 that the electric field @xmath73 can be resolved @xcite . to further resolve the complete spatiotemporal information of the electric field pulse @xmath74 , the positions of the fiber is scanned with a high resolution of sub-@xmath27 m @xcite . the temporal information of the electric field can be characterized by interfering two input pulses , the reference [ @xmath75 and unknown [ @xmath76 ones respectively , into the interferometry box as shown in fig . [ fig1 ] . inside the box , these two pulses are collimated , and they cross at the camera with an angle @xmath77 which is defined by the separation of two fibers with a distance of @xmath78 and the focal length of the collimating lens @xmath79 . we choose @xmath34 as the propagation axis and the pulses cross in the axis @xmath80 . the oscillation part of the interfered spectrum becomes @xcite @xmath81 where a diffraction grating is used to map the wavelengths ( or frequency @xmath43 ) of pulses to the horizontal positions orthogonal to @xmath80 and @xmath34 . the wavevectors of the collimated pulses are @xmath82 , and the phases of the electric fields are @xmath83 and @xmath84 . since the unknown phase information can be inferred from the interference fringes in @xmath80 axis , the amplitude and the phase of unknown electric field are respectively characterized by dividing out @xmath85 and shifting @xmath83 . with the electric field interferometry , we extract the information of the transmitted pulse @xmath86 . the linear susceptibility @xmath87 can be derived from @xmath88 @xmath41 @xmath89 in the paraxial approximation where @xmath90 is the propagation length . we then retrieve the single - particle green s function according to eq . ( [ green ] ) , and the reconstruction steps are detailed in the next section . for the purpose of extracting the dynamical green s function in the strongly correlated quantum gases , the temporal range of the probe pulse requires less than the natural lifetime of the probe field transition . we choose the low - lying rydberg transition in eit measurements to have significant many - body effects from the quantum gases @xcite . the temporal range is then required to be the inverse of the eit spectrum spread [ @xmath91 . it is in the order of @xmath92 where @xmath29 is several khz for rubidium atoms with a low - lying rydberg transition @xmath93 ( @xmath94 @xmath46 @xmath95 ) @xcite . the @xmath27s pulse is sufficient to probe the entire dynamical eit spectrum in frequency space . note that here we consider a homogeneous system such that the paraxial approximation is valid . in general the maxwell - bloch equation for the probe rabi frequency ( @xmath1 ) in our eit setup reads @xcite @xmath96\omega_1({\mathbf{r}},t)=\frac{i{\mathbf{k}}_1}{2\epsilon_0}p({\mathbf{r}},t),\label{mb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the polarization operator @xmath97 can be derived from the linear perturbation of @xmath1 as in eq . ( [ chi ] ) . therefore eq . ( [ mb ] ) becomes a self - consistent propagating equation for the probe field . the diffraction of the probe field is described by the laplacian term ( @xmath98 ) which is crucial for an inhomogeneous system . furthermore , the diffraction of the probe field has to be considered if the transverse distribution of the electric field is on the order of the central wavelength ( @xmath99 ) . however in this case the small area of the light - matter interactions may invalidate eq . ( [ mb ] ) because of the requirement for large ensemble average over the cross section along the propagation @xcite . for the typical 3d mott - insulator @xcite we will study in the next section , the extent of the system is approximately 65 lattice sites ( @xmath100 m ) . based on this length scale , the diffraction of the probe field is negligible for @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the full - width of half - maximum ( fwhm ) of a transform - limit gaussian pulse . the longitudinal density distribution will indicate a spatial dependence for the electric susceptibility in eq . ( [ chi ] ) . if we average out the spatial dependence , we expect the qualitatively same eit spectrum as in a uniform gas , except for an extra inhomogeneous broadening in the spectrum due to the momentum / density distribution @xcite . we note that in the light propagation dynamics , the edge effect appears in the eit setup in bec @xcite . the spin wave inside the bec will occupy near the cloud edge with a low density , which affects the fidelity of the storage process of the probe pulse @xcite . as in our case for the eit spectroscopy , though the finite size effect influences the overall efficiency , it does not significantly modify the structure of the dynamical response of the transmitted probe field . in this section we take an example of a deep mott - insulator ( mi ) state to demonstrate the finite temperature green s function calculation . then we investigate the reconstruction of dynamical green s function based on eq . ( [ green ] ) for mi and luttinger liquid . in practice , the finite temperature effect should be taken into account in the ultracold quantum gases . we follow the formalism of linear response theory at finite temperature @xcite , and find that the eit spectrum depends on the single - particle temperature green s function , @xmath103 where @xmath104 @xmath55 @xmath105@xmath106@xmath107 is the density operator for the grand canonical ensemble , and @xmath108 is the ground state operator for the hamiltonian @xmath109 . @xmath110 is the unperturbed hamiltonian for the eit setup without the probe light , and @xmath111 where @xmath112 is the boltzmann constant , and @xmath113 is the temperature of the gas . the electric susceptibility of eit at finite temperature is then similar to eq . ( [ chi ] ) with the replacement of the single - particle green s function by a finite temperature one in eq . ( [ temp ] ) . to derive the single - particle temperature green s function , we may utilize the spectral function @xmath114 @xcite that @xmath115,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath116 is the fermi or boson number distributions at finite temperature @xmath113 , and @xmath117 is the retarded green s function . as an example we consider the mi of strongly interacting bosons in a 3d optical lattice . in a single band hubbard model ( hm ) @xcite , the ground state field operator is @xmath118 @xmath41 @xmath119 where @xmath120 is the wannier function , and @xmath121 is the field operator at site @xmath122 . when deep inside the mi state , we use the three - state model @xcite to obtain the green s function at finite temperature in the limit of large on - site interaction @xmath123 , @xmath124,\label{mott_temp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where for convenience we calculate the real time single - particle temperature green s function in momentum space . @xmath125 is a step function , @xmath126 is the integer filling fraction , and @xmath127 is the fourier transform of @xmath120 . note that the particle and hole excitation energies @xmath128 @xmath46 @xmath129 when deep inside the mott state . the first and second parts in the bracket of eq . ( [ mott_temp ] ) represent the contributions from the particle and hole excitations respectively . at zero temperature , only the hole excitation remains as the quantum many - body effect on the eit spectrum @xcite . in the next subsection , we demonstrate the reconstruction of dynamical green s function in the example of 3d mi via eit spectroscopy . first we calculate the electric susceptibility in eq . ( [ chi ] ) from eq . ( [ mott_temp ] ) , and we have @xmath130\left(1 + 3f_b\left(\frac{u}{2}\right)\right ) , \label{motteq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we consider a unit filling phase , @xmath131 . the finite temperature effect on the mi is the fluctuation of the total number of particles , so @xmath132 is not much different from @xmath133 in the deep mott limit . in practical eit experiments , because of the restriction on finite lattice spacing @xmath134 nm , we may not probe the dynamical response at momentum higher than @xmath135 . this essentially limits the spatial bandwidth the probe field could provide . therefore with this limit and considering of the transverse length in the experiment @xcite , we let @xmath136 , and from eq . ( [ motteq ] ) we derive @xmath137 ( for simplicity at zero temperature ) , @xmath138 where we normalize the above by the constants of @xmath16 and atomic density , and @xmath139,\label{mt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath125 is a step function . note that @xmath140@xmath41@xmath141 . in fig . [ fig2 ] , we show the dynamical eit spectrum in frequency and time domains . an inhomogeneous broadening is clear in fig . [ fig2](a ) when a deeper mi is investigated @xcite . in fig . [ fig2](b ) , we plot the eit spectroscopy in time domain , and find the essential information of momentum width ( @xmath142 ) in the wannier function and gap order parameter ( @xmath123 ) can be found from the first and second derivatives of @xmath137 , @xmath143,\label{eq2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we assume a gaussian function of width ( @xmath142 ) for the single band wannier function , and the constant @xmath144 is @xmath145 rb atoms ( lattice constant @xmath134 nm ) in the counterpropagating excitation scheme . we use a resonant control field ( @xmath146 ) with rabi frequency @xmath147 , and set @xmath148 . the excited state is chosen as low - lying rydberg transition of @xmath149 with the spontaneous decay rate , @xmath150 . the corresponding parameters ( @xmath123 , @xmath151 ) in unit of the recoil energy @xmath152 are ( 0.5 , 0.007 ) and ( 1.05 , @xmath153 ) for @xmath154 ( solid - blue and dash - red ) and @xmath155 ( @xmath156 and @xmath157 ) respectively @xcite . ( a ) absorption ( re[@xmath158 , solid - blue , @xmath156 ) and dispersion ( im[@xmath159 , dash - red , @xmath157 ) profiles are demonstrated . we plot @xmath160 versus @xmath161 to demonstrate a normal dispersion inside the transparency window for comparisons with conventional eit . ( b)eit spectrum @xmath137 in time domain with its real ( solid - blue , @xmath157 ) and imaginary ( dash - red , @xmath156 ) parts.,width=302,height=151 ] from eqs . ( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eq2 ] ) , we can solve for the unknown values of @xmath142 and @xmath123 , and we can reconstruct the dynamical green s function of mi as @xmath162 where we show in fig . [ fig3 ] . the real - time dynamics of green s function indicates a modulation of the period which is the inverse of the on - site interaction energy . therefore the eit spectroscopy along with green s function reconstruction can be the alternative approach to lattice potential gradient @xcite or modulation spectroscopy @xcite to determine the gap energy in mi . the presumption of single band wannier function and gap order parameter are crucial for reconstructing the green s function of a 3d mi . since we assume only two parameters for green s function , it is not surprising that the information of the slopes at @xmath140 in eqs . ( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eq2 ] ) infers the essential parameters , and they can be expressed as @xmath163 where @xmath164@xmath55@xmath140 which is normalized . from the above we show how to extract the parameters of green s function , which is equivalent to find the average of the frequency and its variance ( second order moment ) for a normalized eit spectrum . the green s function information embeds in the eit spectroscopy in which we may need higher order moments to extract more complicated forms of green s functions . ] for a unit - filling 3d mott insulator ( mi ) . the on - site interaction @xmath123 in units of the recoil energy @xmath152 ( @xmath46 @xmath95 @xmath165hz ) of the trapping lasers are @xmath166 and @xmath167 respectively for ( a ) @xmath168 @xmath41 @xmath169 and ( b ) @xmath155 . the oscillation period of the green s function determines the inverse of half the gap order parameter in a mi . the spatial distribution of green s function is plotted as @xmath170 where we use a gaussian distribution as an approximate single band wannier function @xmath120 , and @xmath171 are 69 and 54 nm respectively.,width=302,height=170 ] for the second example , we demonstrate the single - particle green s function of the luttinger liquid ( ll ) which is a universal 1d effective model @xcite . the single - particle green s function can be exactly calculated by the bosonization method @xcite , which is @xmath172^{1/(4\kappa)}}.\label{ll}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the luttinger parameter is @xmath173 , @xmath174 is the phonon velocity , @xmath175 is the system - dependent momentum cutoff , and @xmath176 is the atomic density . @xmath141@xmath177@xmath173@xmath177@xmath178 is for a short - range repulsive interaction , while @xmath173 can be smaller than one if the interaction is long ranged . the electric susceptibility can be also derived by substituting eq . ( [ ll ] ) into eq . ( [ chi ] ) @xcite . we may proceed to find @xmath179 from eq . ( [ green ] ) as @xmath180^{1/(4\kappa)}}\bar{m}({\mathbf{k}},t),\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is normalized , and reconstruct the dynamical green s function from its first order derivative at @xmath181 , @xmath182 where we extract the luttinger parameter @xmath173 from the measurement of the first order moment @xmath183 in eit spectroscopy . note that we have assumed the only unknown parameter in green s function of 1d quantum gas is @xmath173 , and in general we may extract for example the phonon velocity or system - dependent cut - off length scale by measuring higher order moments in eit spectroscopy . in fig . [ fig4 ] we show the dynamical eit spectrum in frequency and time domains . the inhomogeneous broadening and shifted transparency position are due to the strong interactions . rb atoms . the driving conditions are the same as in fig . [ fig2 ] but with rabi frequency @xmath184 . ( a ) absorption ( re[@xmath185 , @xmath156 , solid - blue ) and dispersion ( im[@xmath186 , @xmath157 , dash - red ) profiles are demonstrated respectively for @xmath173@xmath41@xmath187 . ( b ) eit spectrum @xmath179 in time domain with its real ( solid - blue , @xmath157 ) and imaginary ( dash - red , @xmath156 ) parts . for a typical experimental regime @xcite , we may take the phonon velocity @xmath174@xmath41@xmath188 mm / s and the cutoff @xmath189@xmath41@xmath190 @xmath27m.,width=302,height=151 ] in fig . [ fig5 ] , we show the real - time single - particle green s function of ll . for a weakly interacting quantum gas ( @xmath191 ) , the relatively flat correlation function indicates the long - range order in the superfluid . the strongly interacting quantum gas ( @xmath192 ) on the other hand shows a noninteger power - law decay in the green s function . this quasi - long - range order originates from the collective excitations in a ll model with a linear dispersion @xmath193 in the low - temperature and long - wavelength limit . in our proposed experiment , the eit spectroscopy provides a nondestructive way to extract the ll parameter @xmath173 which is essential to characterize the 1d bosonic quantum gas . our proposed eit spectroscopy may be also applied to the repulsive 1d two - component fermions . it can provide a genuine observation of the two - fold linear excitations in the spin and the charge sectors from the extraction of the single - particle green s function @xcite similar to our case of a bosonic ll . for attractive 1d spin-@xmath194 fermions , the spin gap order parameter is also observable in the eit spectroscopy in analogy to the bcs superfluid of two - component fermi gases @xcite . therefore , the eit spectroscopy can be applied to investigate on a plethora of low - dimensional quantum many - body systems with arbitrary interactions . ] for a luttinger liquid . the luttinger parameters are @xmath173 @xmath41 @xmath195 ( @xmath196 ) , @xmath141 ( @xmath156 ) , @xmath197 ( @xmath157 ) for the real ( solid ) and imaginary ( dash ) parts of @xmath198 . long - range order is present for a weakly interacting gas ( @xmath173 @xmath41 @xmath197 ) while a strongly interacting gas with @xmath173 @xmath41 @xmath195 or @xmath141 shows a power - law decay by time . the dash - dot line is @xmath199 to compare with a power - law decay.,width=311,height=188 ] as a comparison with the method of ramsey interferometry to extract the spin correlation functions @xcite , eit spectroscopy provides a non - destructive probe of the many - body system while the interferometry involves the destructive projection measurement in the ramsey pulse sequence . valuable information can be extracted from the spin correlation function to determine the quantum phase transition from the characteristic scaling behavior @xcite . similarly , eit measurement extracts the important scaling factor of the power - law decay function for example in 1d ll . a common difficulty in practice is the limited bandwidth in experiments which in our case restricts the direct probe of the transverse spatial dynamics of green s function in the ultracold atomic gases . however , we may still deduce the green s function from the post - calculation of the frequency moments in the eit spectroscopy . in summary , we show that the single - particle green s function can be extracted by an efficient and nondestructive eit spectroscopy . we propose to utilize an electric field interferometry to characterize the temporal profiles of the probe fields . from the information of the transmitted probe pulse or equivalently the eit dynamical response , we may deduce the essential single - particle green s function of the ultracold quantum gases . in the examples we take 3d mott insulator and 1d ll to demonstrate that the gap order and ll parameters respectively can be extracted from the information of eit spectrum . this provides an all optical approach to reveal the essential single - particle green s function in the ultracold quantum gases , and opens up a new avenue to study many - body physics in the strongly correlated system . we appreciate fruitful discussions with t. pohl and ite a. yu . we also thank m. knap and e. demler for pointing out the relevant ramsey interferometry method to probe the correlation functions @xcite . this work is supported by nsc and ncts grants in taiwan . 99 i. bloch , j. dalibard , and w. zwerger , `` many - body physics with ultracold gases , '' rev . phys . * 80 * , 885 ( 2008 ) . c chin , r. grimm , p. julienne , and e. tiesinga , `` feshbach resonances in ultracold gases , '' rev . mod . phys . * 82 * , 1225 ( 2010 ) . f. d. m. haldane , `` effective harmonic - fluid approach to low - energy properties of one - dimensional quantum fluids , '' phys . lett . * 47 * , 1840 ( 1981 ) . f. d. m. haldane , `` luttinger liquid theory of one - dimensional quantum fluids . i. properties of the luttinger model and their extension to the general 1d interacting spinless fermi gas , '' j. phys . c : solid state phys . * 14 * , 2585 ( 1981 ) . m. olshanii , `` atomic scattering in the presence of an external confinement and a gas of impenetrable bosons , '' phys . lett . * 81 * , 938 ( 1998 ) . t. kinoshita , t. wenger , and d. s. weiss , `` observation of a one - dimensional tonks - girardeau gas , '' science * 305 * 1125 ( 2004 ) . b. paredes , a. widera , v. murg , o. mandel , s. flling , i. cirac , g. v. shlyapnikov , t. w. hnsch , and i. bloch , `` tonks - girardeau gas of ultracold atoms in an optical lattice , '' nature * 429 * , 277 ( 2004 ) . t. stferle , h. moritz , c. schori , m. khl , and t. esslinger , `` transition from a strongly interacting 1d superfluid to a mott insulator , '' phys . rev . lett . * 92 * , 130403 ( 2004 ) . m. a. cazalilla , `` bosonizing one - dimensional cold atomic gases , '' j. phys . b : at . mol . . phys . * 37 * , s1 ( 2004 ) . m. p. a. fisher , p. b. weichman , g. grinstein , and d. s. fisher , `` boson localization and the superfluid - insulator transition , '' phys . b * 40 * , 546 ( 1989 ) . m. greiner , o. mandel , t. esslinger , t. w. hnsch , and i. bloch , `` quantum phase transition from a superfluid to a mott insulator in a gas of ultracold atoms , '' nature * 415 * , 39 ( 2002 ) . a. l. fetter and j. d. walecka , _ quantum theory of many - particle systems _ ( dover publications , 2003 ) . e. altman , e. demler , and m. d. lukin , `` probing many - body states of ultracold atoms via noise correlations , '' phys . a * 70 * , 013603 ( 2004 ) . m. kozuma , l. deng , e. w. hagley , j. wen , r. lutwak , k. helmerson , s. l. rolston , and w. d. phillips , `` coherent splitting of bose - einstein condensed atoms with optically induced bragg diffraction , '' phys . . lett . * 82 * , 871 ( 1999 ) . j. stenger , s. inouye , a. p. chikkatur , d. m. stamper - kurn , d. e. pritchard , and w. ketterle , `` bragg spectroscopy of a bose - einstein condensate , '' phys . lett . * 82 * , 4569 ( 1999 ) . s. b. papp , j. m. pino , r. j. wild , s. ronen , c. e. wieman , d. s. jin , and e. a. cornell , `` bragg spectroscopy of a strongly interacting @xmath200rb bose - einstein condensate , '' phys . * 101 * , 135301 ( 2008 ) . g. veeravalli , e. kuhnle , p. dyke , and c. j. vale , `` bragg spectroscopy of a strongly interacting fermi gas , '' phys . * 101 * , 250403 ( 2008 ) . j. m. pino , r. j. wild , p. makotyn , d. s. jin , and e. a. cornell , `` photon counting for bragg spectroscopy of quantum gases , '' phys . a * 83 * , 033615 ( 2011 ) . n. gemelke , x. zhang , c - l . hung , and c. chin , `` in situ observation of incompressible mott - insulating domains in ultracold atomic gases , '' nature * 460 * , 995 ( 2009 ) . l . ho and q. zhou , `` obtaining the phase diagram and thermodynamic quantities of bulk systems from the densities of trapped gases , '' nature physics * 6 * , 131 ( 2010 ) . m. d. lukin , `` colloquium : trapping and manipulating photon states in atomic ensembles , '' , 457 ( 2003 ) . m. fleischhauer , a. imamoglu , and j. p. marangos , `` electromagnetically induced transparency : optics in coherent media , '' , 633 ( 2005 ) . h. h. jen and daw - wei wang , `` theory of electromagnetically induced transparency in strongly correlated quantum gases , '' phys . a * 87 * , 061802(r ) ( 2013 ) . l. jiang , h. pu , w. zhang , and h. y. ling , `` detection of fermi pairing via electromagnetically induced transparency , '' phys . a * 80 * , 033606 ( 2009 ) . h. h. jen , bo xiong , ite a. yu , and daw - wei wang , `` electromagnetically induced transparency and slow light in quantum degenerate atomic gases , '' j. opt . * 30 * , 2855 ( 2013 ) . t. f. gallagher , ( cambridge university press , 1994 ) . d. tong , s. m. farooqi , j. stanojevic , s. krishnan , y. p. zhang , r. ct , e. e. eyler , and p. l. gould , `` local blockade of rydberg excitation in an ultracold gas , '' phys . * 93 * , 063001 ( 2004 ) . a. damascelli , z. hussain , and z .- x . shen , `` angle - resolved photoemission studies of the cuprate superconductors , '' rev . mod . phys . * 75 * , 473 ( 2003 ) . m. knap , a. kantian , t. giamarchi , i. bloch , m. d. lukin , and e. demler , `` probing real - space and time - resolved correlation functions with many - body ramsey interferometry , '' phys . . lett . * 111 * , 147205 ( 2013 ) . z. hadzibabic , p. krger , m. cheneau , b. battelier , and j. dalibard , `` berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless crossover in a trapped atomic gas , '' nature * 441 * , 1118 ( 2006 ) . a. polkovnikov , e. altman , and e. demler , `` interference between independent fluctuating condensates , '' proc . usa * 103 * , 6125 ( 2006 ) . s. hofferberth , i. lesanovsky , t. schumm1 , a. imambekov , v. gritsev , e. demler , and j. schmiedmayer , `` probing quantum and thermal noise in an interacting many - body system , '' nature physics * 4 * , 489 ( 2008 ) . k. eckert , o. romero - isart , m. rodriguez , m. lewenstein , e. s. polzik , and a. sanpera , `` quantum non - demolition detection of strongly correlated systems , '' nature physics * 4 * , 50 ( 2007 ) . p. bowlan , p. gabolde , and r. trebino , `` directly measuring the spatio - temporal electric field of focusing ultrashort pulses , '' opt . exp . vol . * 15 * , 10219 ( 2007 ) . w. amir , t. a. planchon , c. g. durfee , j. a. squier , p. gabolde , r. trebino , and m. mller , `` simultaneous visualization of spatial and chromatic aberrations by two - dimensional fourier transform spectral interferometry , '' opt . . vol . * 31 * , 2927 ( 2006 ) . p. bowlan , p. gabolde , a. schreenath , k. mcgresham , and r. trebino , `` crossed - beam spectral interferometry : a simple , high - spectral - resolution method for completely characterizing complex ultrashort pulses in real time , '' opt . express * 14 * , 11892 ( 2006 ) . m. o. scully and m. s. zubairy , _ quantum optics _ ( cambridge university press , 1997 ) . p. d. drummond and s. j. carter , `` quantum - field theory of squeezing in solitons , '' j. opt . b , vol . * 4 * , 1565 ( 1987 ) . z. dutton and l. vestergaard hau , `` storing and processing optical information with ultraslow light in bose - einstein condensates , '' phys . a * 70 * , 053831 ( 2004 ) . g. d. mahan , _ many - particle physics _ ( kluwer academic / plenum publishers , new york , 2000 ) . e. altman and a. auerbach , `` oscillating superfluidity of bosons in optical lattices , '' phys . lett . * 89 * , 250404 ( 2002 ) . d .- w . wang , `` momentum distribution of noncondensate particles near the superfluid - to - mott - insulator transition of bosonic atoms in a uniform optical lattice , '' phys . a * 80 * , 063620 ( 2009 ) . d. jaksch , c. bruder , j. i. cirac , c. w. gardiner , and p. zoller , `` cold bosonic atoms in optical lattices , '' phys . lett . * 81 * , 3108 ( 1998 ) . thierry giamarchi , _ quantum physics in one dimension _ ( oxford university press , 2003 ) .

the essential quantum many - body physics of an ultracold quantum gas relies on the single - particle green s functions . we demonstrate that it can be extracted by the spectrum of electromagnetically induced transparency ( eit ) . the single - particle green s function can be reconstructed by the measurements of frequency moments in eit spectroscopy . this optical measurement provides an efficient and nondestructive method to reveal the many - body properties , and we propose an experimental setup to realize it . finite temperature and finite size effects are discussed , and we demonstrate the reconstruction steps of green s function for the examples of three - dimensional mott - insulator phase and one - dimensional luttinger liquid .

astro-ph9802085

as very few gamma - ray burst ( grb ) sources have astronomical counterparts at other wavebands , empirical studies of grbs have been largely restricted to the analysis of their gamma ray properties : bulk properties such as fluence and spectral hardness , and evolution of these properties within a burst event ( fishman & meegan 1995 ) . while bursts exhibit a vast range of complex temporal behaviors , their bulk properties appear simpler and amenable to straightforward statistical analyses . studies fall into two categories : examination of whether grb bulk properties comprise a homogeneous population or are divided into distinct classes ; and search for relationships between bulk properties . both types of study may lead to astrophysical insight , just as the distinction between main sequence stars and red giants and the measurement of a luminosity - mass relation along the main sequence assisted the development of stellar astrophysics early in the century . the most widely accepted taxonomy of grbs is the division between short - hard and long - soft bursts proposed by dezalay et al . ( 1992 ) and kouveliotou et al . ( 1993 , henceforth k93 ) . k93 noticed a bimodality in the burst duration variable @xmath1 ( time within which 90% of the flux arrived ) , suggesting the presence of two distinct types of bursts separated at @xmath2 sec . the short bursts have systematically harder gamma - ray spectra than longer bursts . the two groups seemed indistinguishable in most other bulk properties , although the larger group of long - soft bursts may have a subclass with a different fluence distribution ( i.e. , different @xmath3 ; katz & canel 1996 ) and the groups may have different galactic latitude distributions ( belli 1997 ) . other researchers point to small groups of bursts with distinctive properties such as the soft - gamma repeaters ( norris et al . 1991 ) , two possible classes with differing short - timescale variability ( lamb , graziani & smith 1993 ) , fast - rise exponential - decay bursts ( bhat et al . 1994 ) , and two types of bursts with different ratios of total fluence and @xmath4300 kev fluence ( pendleton et al . 1997 ) . a variety of relationships between burst properties have also been reported . norris et al . ( 1995 ) find an anti - correlation between @xmath1 ( calculated after wavelet thresholding ) and peak intensity , consistent with a cosmological time dilation . however , a positive correlation between @xmath1 and total fluence is also seen which does not agree with the simplest cosmological interpretation ( lee & petrosian 1997 ) . additional reported relationships include : @xmath1 correlated with peak heights ( lestrade 1994 ) , peak energy correlated with peak flux ( mallozzi et al . 1995 ) , and peak duration anticorrelated with gamma - ray energy ( fenimore et al . 1995 ) . most of these studies suffer from a failure to treat all of the bulk property variables in an unbiased and quantitative way . astronomers typically examine univariate or bivariate distributions , sometimes constructing composite variables ( such as hardness ratios ) with pre - determined relationships to include one or two additional variables . but it is quite possible that the complex astrophysics producing grbs will not manifest themselves in simple bivariate plots , just as the division between short - hard and long - soft bursts is not evident in spectral variables alone ( pendleton et al . grb catalogs , like most multiwavelength astronomical catalogs , are multivariate databases and should be treated with multivariate statistical methods that can objectively and effectively uncover structure involving many variables ( feigelson & babu 1997 ) . two previous studies take a fully multivariate approach to understanding grb bulk properties . baumgart ( 1994 ) constructs a neural network taxonomy of 99 grbs from the pvo satellite using 26 variables representing both bulk burst properties and detailed temporal characteristics ( e.g. number of peaks , fractal dimension , wavelet transform crossings ) and finds two or three distinct grb classes . bagoly et al . ( 1997 ) perform principal components and factor analyses of nine bulk property variables using 625 grbs from the batse 3b catalog . they find that the relationships in the database are determined principally by only three variables : an appropriately weighted fluence , a weighted burst duration , and ( to a lesser extent ) flux in the highest energy bin . we note , however , that it can be dangerous to look for correlations prior to classifying ( or establishing the homogeneity of ) the population . while the anticorrelation between hardness ratio and burst duration seen in full samples ( k93 ) may be the manifestation of a single astrophysical process , it may alternatively reflect differences between distinct processes . the latter possibility is suggested by a reported hardness - duration positive correlation within the long - soft class of bursts ( dezalay et al . 1996 ; horack & hakkila 1997 ) . most multivariate analyses thus begin with a study of homogeneity and classification , and then investigate the variance - covariance structure ( i.e. correlations ) within each class . this paper describes a multivariate analysis of grbs from the third batse catalog ( meegan et al . 1996 ) . after defining the sample ( 2 ) , we start with a simple statistical description of the variables and their bivariate relationships for the entire dataset ( 3 ) . we then seek distinct types of clusters in two ways . first , a standard nonparametric agglomerative hierarchical clustering analysis is performed ( 4 ) which reveals three distinct classes . the statistical significance of the third cluster is validated , under gaussian assumptions , with manova tests . second , a parametric maximum likelihood model - based clustering procedure is adopted which reveals the same three groups and indicates strong evidence for the presence for three rather than two groups ( 5 ) . the variance - covariance structure of each group is then examined ( 6 ) . results are synthesized in the discussion ( 7 ) . throughout the paper , we discuss our mathematical techniques to help the reader understand the complexities of multivariate analysis . from the vast literature in this subject , we recommend the following monographs for interested readers : johnson & wichern ( 1992 ) and jobson ( 1992 ) for overviews of applied multivariate analysis ; hartigan ( 1975 ) , jain & dubes ( 1988 ) and kaufman & rousseeuw ( 1990 ) for multivariate clustering algorithms ; murtagh & heck ( 1987 ) and , more briefly , babu & feigelson ( 1996 ) and feigelson & babu ( 1997 ) , for multivariate methodology in astronomy . our sample is drawn from the third catalog of the _ burst and transient source experiment _ ( batse ) on board the compton gamma ray observatory . this 3b catalog has 1122 grbs detected by batse between 1991 april 19 and 1994 september 19 . the catalog is presented and fully described by meegan et al . our database was extracted from the on - line database www.batse.msfc.nasa.gov/data/grb/catalog in may 1996 , which provides many properties of each burst . there are roughly eleven variables of potential astrophysical interest : two measures of location in galactic coordinates , @xmath5 and @xmath6 ; two measures of burst durations , the times within which 50% ( @xmath7 ) and 90% ( @xmath1 ) of the flux arrives ; three peak fluxes @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 measured in 64 ms , 256 ms and 1024 ms bins respectively ; and four time - integrated fluences @xmath11-@xmath12 in the 20 - 50 kev , 50 - 100 kev , 100 - 300 kev and @xmath13 kev spectral channels respectively . researchers commonly consider three composite variables : the total fluence , @xmath14 , and two measures of spectral hardness derived from the ratios of channel fluences , @xmath15 and @xmath16 . due to the limitations of available multivariate statistical techniques , we ignore other variables of potential relevance including the heteroscedastic measurement errors of each quantity ( i.e. , errors that differ from point to point ) and truncation values associated with batse triggering operations . of the 1122 listed bursts , 807 have data on all the variables described above . ten bursts listed with zero fluences were eliminated . our sample thus has 797 batse grbs . for some analyses , we also used a subset of 644 bursts with ` debiased ' durations , @xmath17 . here the durations are modified to account for the effect that brighter bursts will have signal above the noise for longer periods than fainter bursts with the same time profiles ( j. norris , private communication ) . statistical analyses in 3 , 4 and 6 were conducted within the statistical analysis system _ sas / stat _ , a very large and widely distributed commercial statistical software package ( sas institute inc . _ sas / stat _ procedures _ cluster _ , _ glm _ , _ princomp _ and _ varclus _ were used . the analysis in 5 was performed with the _ mclust _ software ( banfield & raftery 1993 ; fraley 1998 ) , which is interfaced to the splus statistical package ( splus version 3.4 ; mathsoft , inc . 1996 ) and its extensions . further information is provided at http://stat.washington.edu/fraley/software.html and http://lib.stat.cmu.edu/general/mclust . for multivariate data visualization , we used the xgobi ( swayne , cook & buja 1991 ) program , available from the _ statlib _ software archive at http://lib.stat.cmu.edu/general/xgobi . hypertext links to a variety of public domain software for multivariate analysis , classification and visualization are available at the penn state _ statcodes _ web site , http://www.astro.psu.edu/statcodes . we are faced with a multivariate database of 797 objects and 15 variables ( 11 variables from the catalog , 3 composite variables , and @xmath18 ) . two initial problems are frequently faced in analyses of multivariate databases . first , variables with incompatible units and ranges must be compared . units can be removed by normalization ( e.g. replacing @xmath11 by @xmath19 ) , by standardization ( e.g. replacing @xmath11 by @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the sample standard deviation ) , or by taking logarithms . second , the dimensionality of the problem should be reduced , as many of the variables are closely interrelated either by construction or by astronomical circumstance . although there are no mathematical rules regulating reduction of dimensionality , it can usefully be guided by a correlation matrix showing bivariate relationships and a principal components analysis showing multivariate relationships that are mainly responsible for structured variance in the data . scientific reasoning can also be used to eliminate consideration of variables . we conducted a preliminary examination of data representations , correlation matrices and bivariate plots , and principal components analyses to facilitate choice of variables . when no mathematical preference arose , we selected variables most commonly used by previous researchers to facilitate comparison of results . our choices were as follows . we use log variables , rather than normalized or standardized variables . we kept information on burst fluence and spectra through @xmath22 and hardness ratios rather than through the original fluences @xmath11-@xmath12 . we initially eliminated @xmath8 and @xmath10 from consideration , and later eliminated @xmath9 when we found that its main contribution to the clustering process was noise . we chose to remove the location variables @xmath23 , already established by other researchers to be random for the entire sample , but use them later to test for isotropy of subsamples . the debiased @xmath24 is used only in special tests . our analysis was thus performed in six or fewer dimensions using log @xmath7 , log @xmath1 , log @xmath22 , log @xmath9 , log @xmath25 and log @xmath26 . tables 1 and 2 give basic statistics for these six variables : means , standard deviations , and bivariate values of pearson s linear correlation coefficient @xmath27 . for @xmath28 and assuming bivariate normal populations , any @xmath29 implies that a correlation between the two variables exists at a two - tailed significance level @xmath30 ( beyer 1968 , pp . 389 and 283 ) . but from an astrophysical perspective , we might consider any relationship with @xmath31 to be of little interest . figure 1 shows the bivariate scatter plots . the correlation structure of the entire sample ( table 2 ) shows that the two measures of duration and the two measures of spectral hardness have correlation near unity , indicating that they are nearly redundant . @xmath22 and @xmath9 are quite dissimilar : @xmath22 shows a strong correlation with burst duration ( e.g. lee & petrosian 1997 ) and no relation to hardness , while @xmath9 shows no relation to duration but is mildly correlated with hardness ( mallozzi et al . burst duration is anticorrelated with hardness ( k93 ; fenimore et al . the cosmological anticorrelation between duration and peak flux reported by norris et al . ( 1995 ) is statistically significant , but accounts for only a few percent of the variance between these variables . the correlation matrix based on the debiased @xmath18 values yields very similar results . however , the scatter plots ( figure 1 ) show a more complex story . first , many plots show inhomogeneous distributions inconsistent with the unimodal multinormal ( i.e. multivariate gaussian ) population assumed by pearson s @xmath27 . the distributions often seem bimodal with asymmetrical non - gaussian shapes . one outlier burst is also seen in several projections . we therefore consider the hypothesis that the sample consists of two or more distinct classes , and proceed to find the ` clusters ' using well - established methods . agglomerative hierarchical clustering is a procedure based on the successive merging of proximate pairs of clusters of objects . it produces a clustering tree or dendrogram starting with n clusters of 1 member ( or a coarse partition based on prior knowledge ) and ending with one cluster of n members . unfortunately , there are many possible ways to proceed ; mathematics provides little guidance among the choices and no probabilistic evaluation of the results without the imposition of additional assumptions . the scientist must make four decisions to fully define the clustering procedure : 1 . creating _ unit - free variables _ is essential for meaningful treatment of objects in multivariate space ( 3 ) . a favorite choice by statisticians is standardization , where each variable is normalized by the standard deviation of the sample . astronomers more commonly make logarithmic transformations or construct ratios of variables sharing the same units . we follow the tradition of grb researchers by measuring spectral hardness with ratios of fluences having the same units , and making logarithmic transformations of all variables . the _ metric _ defines the meaning of proximity between two objects or clusters . common choices are the simple euclidean distance between unit - free variables and the squares of euclidean distances . we chose the former option for most of the analyses in this section . 3 . several _ merging procedures _ can be used . one might begin by merging the clusters with the nearest neighbors . this is called single linkage clustering and is most familiar in astronomy where it is frequently called the friends - of - friends algorithm . it tends to produce long stringy clusters , and is equivalent to a well - known divisive clustering procedure known as pruning the minimal spanning tree . complete linkage proceeds by maximizing the distance between clusters , and leads to evenly bifurcating dendrograms . for most of our analysis , we choose average linkage where the distance between two clusters is the average of the distances between pairs of observations , where each member of the pair comes from a different cluster . this is a compromise between single and complete linkage and tends to give compact clusters . specifically , the distance between clusters k and l is given by ( e.g. sas institute inc . 1989 , pp . 529ff ; johnson & wichern 1992 , pp . @xmath32 where the bar indicates an unweighted mean , @xmath33-th cluster . another popular choice is ward s minimum variance criterion where the distance between the two clusters is the anova ( analysis of variance ) sum of squares between two clusters added up over all variables ( ward 1963 ) , @xmath34 if the sample is generated by a mixture of multinormal ( i.e. multidimensional gaussian ) distributions where each distribution has covariance matrix of the form @xmath35 , this method joins clusters to maximize the likelihood at each level of the hierarchy , and so is a special case of the model - based clustering methodology to be discussed in 5 . 4 . as the procedure gives a hierarchy from @xmath36 clusters with 1 object down to one cluster with @xmath36 objects , the user must choose _ how many clusters to report _ as scientifically important clusters . this choice can be assisted by examination of two statistics . the squared correlation coefficient , @xmath37 , states the fraction of the total variance accounted for by a partition into @xmath38 clusters , @xmath39 the squared semi - partial correlation coefficient , @xmath40 measures the difference in the variance between the resulting cluster and the immediate parent clusters normalized by the total sample variance , @xmath41 @xmath37 thus tells how much of the scatter is explained by a given level of clustering , and @xmath40 tells how much improvement is achieved between levels . we emphasize again that there is no mathematically ` best ' choice , although extensive experience with problems in many fields has led to a preference for certain combinations ( e.g. standardized variables and ward s minimum variance criterion ) . we conducted extensive experiments with different choices . the last several levels of the clustering tree for the 797 grbs using the six unit - free variables shown in table 1 , average linkage and a euclidean metric are shown in figure 2 ( left panel ) with details in table 3a . the action taken at each level is indicated in column 2 of table 3 , which may refer to a level higher in the tree which ( for brevity ) is not shown here . two types of mergers are seen : the incorporation of ` twigs ' of one or a few grbs into a large preexisting ` trunk ' ( levels 1 , 3 , 4 , 5 and 7 ) ; and the union of two substantial branches into a single larger trunk ( levels 2 , 6 and 8) . the first type has little effect on the variance of the sample with @xmath42% . the single grb brought into the main trunk at level 1 is the distant outlier seen in several panels of figure 1 . the level 2 merger of clusters with 190 and 606 members is clearly the most important structure , accounting for roughly 53% of the variance of the entire sample . this is the bifurcation of the sample into two classes easily seen in figure 1 and noted by k93 and others . the principal finding that is not immediately obvious from figure 1 is the structure indicated at level 6 . the main trunk of 599 bursts ( plus a few twigs to be merged later ) is divided into groups of 93 and 506 bursts . this division accounts for 10% of the total variance of the sample , indicated in both the @xmath37 and @xmath40 values . we found that the twigs in the tree structure disappear if the peak flux @xmath9 variable is omitted and the analysis is made in 5-dimensional space ( figure 2 , right panel , and table 3b ) . here the largest cluster of 593 members is formed by the union of clusters with 107 and 486 bursts , again accounting for 10% of the sample variance . it is possible that @xmath9 is a nuisance variable irrelevant to the basic astrophysics of grbs , producing noisy ` twigs ' seen in table 3a and figure 2 ( left panel ) . we tested many variants of hierarchical clustering . we replaced average linkage hypothesis with complete linkage , single linkage and ward s minimum variance criterion . the ward s criterion computation , for example , gave three clusters with 468 , 145 and 184 bursts . we clustered using nonparametric density estimation based on the 100 nearest neighbors , and clustered using the principal components rather than the observed variables . various methods were tried with both the observed @xmath1 values and debiased @xmath18 values , with little effect on the results . all methods showed two strong clusters and the outlier but , in some cases , the third cluster appeared only weakly . to proceed further , we choose a single clustering structure for detailed study : the 5-dimensional average linkage analysis ( table 3b ) with three clusters class i with 486 bursts , class ii with 203 bursts , class iii with 107 bursts . class iv consisting of the single outlier is ignored because of independent evidence that its properties are due to data of poor quality ( 7 ) . the membership of these clusters is given in table 4 , and four projections of the clusters onto two - dimensional scatter plots are shown in figure 3 . these are frames from the ` grand tour ' movie of the 5-dimensional dataset provided by the xgobi software where each cluster is ` brushed ' with a different symbol . note that , in general , there is no reason why classification structure should be most evident in projections parallel to the variable axes shown in figure 1 . it is more important that the clusters show cohesion in many projections of the dataset . the grand tour of the 797 grbs shows that classes i , ii and the outlier are very distinct in most projections . class iii often lies between classes i and ii ( e.g. top panels of figure 3 ) , but in other projections is offset from the line between classes i and ii ( e.g. bottom panels of figure 3 ) . it also appears elongated along some projections , while the larger classes i and ii appear roughly hyperspherical . this analyses described here provide considerable evidence for three major clusters and an outlier . but as some nonparametric clustering procedures did not find a strong third cluster , there is some some worry that class iii is simply a group of bursts with properties intermediate between the classes i and ii . while nonparametric hierarchical clustering methods can not address this question , it can be investigated with parametric methods . mathematically well - founded methods for evaluating the statistical significance of a proposed multivariate classification scheme are available under the assumption that the population is a multinormal mixture ; that is , the objects of each class are drawn from multivariate gaussians . all relationships between the variables must thus be linear ( as in table 2 ) , although the relationships may differ between clusters . there is no requirement of sphericity , so that clusters may have shapes akin to pancakes or cigars with arbitrary orientations in multidimensional space . the separate existence of each of the postulated subpopulations can be tested using multivariate analysis of variance ( manova ) . the results of our manova calculations are summarized in table 5 . the columns give the values of the three manova statistics , followed by details for the wilks @xmath0 : the corresponding value of the @xmath58 statistic , the numerator and denominator degrees of freedom for that @xmath58 value ; and the resulting @xmath60 value . details for pillai s and hotelling - lawley s traces are omitted , but give similar results in all cases . the first row tests the null hypothesis that the classes i , ii and iii have the same mean , the second row tests the equality of classes i and ii , and so forth . the @xmath58 values are very high in all cases , indicating that the clusters are different with extremely high statistical significance ( @xmath61 ) . as the tails of the distribution are poorly determined unless the sample size is extremely large . ] this is a clear _ quantitative _ demonstration that at least two clusters exist among grbs ( for a univariate test , see ashman , bird & zepf 1994 ) , which was _ qualitatively _ reported by delazay et al . ( 1992 ) and k93 . the other rows in table 5 test the hypotheses that each proposed class has the same mean as each other class . one problem with these manova tests is that they are conditional on the classification that has been found using the clustering algorithm . because the clustering algorithm is constructed to find groups that are different from one another , tests such as these tend to be biased towards finding structure , perhaps where none exists . although the manova results seem to indicate very strong evidence of structure , they can not be taken as definitive for this reason . tests arising from model - based clustering can overcome this problem , as discussed in the following section . in the previous section , we conducted a hierarchical clustering analysis without making assumptions regarding the shapes of the clusters , but needed the parametric assumption of normality to estimate the statistical significance of the resulting classification . it is reasonable to conduct the entire analysis , both clustering and validation , within a model - based framework . we report here an analysis of this type again assuming that the grb population consists of a mixture of multivariate gaussian classes . early development of this model for clustering is discussed in mclachlan & basford ( 1988 ) ; we use more recent developments here . first , an initial classification for each possible number of clusters is found via agglomerative hierarchical clustering ( murtagh & raftery 1984 , banfield & raftery 1993 , fraley 1998 ) . next , the em ( expectation - maximization ) algorithm is used to refine partitions obtained from hierarchical clustering ( celeux & govaert 1995 , dasgupta & raftery 1998 ) . finally , the bayesian information criterion is used to select the ` best ' partition among those associated with different numbers of clusters ( dasgupta & raftery 1998 ) . in the model considered here , the @xmath43-dimensional observations @xmath62 are drawn from @xmath38 multinormal groups , each of which is characterized by a vector of parameters @xmath63 for @xmath64 . our goals are : to determine the number of grb types , @xmath38 ; to determine the cluster assignment of each burst ; and to estimate the mean @xmath65 and covariance matrix @xmath66 for each cluster . following fraley ( 1998 ) , the density of an observation @xmath67 from the @xmath68th subpopulation is expressed as follows : @xmath69 where @xmath70 means multivariate normal . we estimate the parameters using the principle of maximum likelihood . in the hierarchical clustering phase , we use the classification likelihood @xmath71 where @xmath72 represents the observations and @xmath73 is the cluster assignment : @xmath74 when @xmath75 comes from the @xmath68-th group . equivalently , @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the set of indices corresponding to observations belonging to the @xmath68-th group . the method used here for maximizing the likelihood ( fraley 1998 ) and implemented in the _ mclust _ code involves parameterization of the @xmath78 matrices in terms of their eigenvectors and eigenvalues ( analogous to a principal components analysis ) , and iterative relocation of the clusters using the em algorithm . the em ( estimation - maximization ) algorithm ( dempster , laird & rubin 1977 ) , one of the most successful methods in modern statistics , is a procedure for iteratively maximizing likelihoods in a wide variety of circumstances . for example , the lucy - richardson algorithm in astronomical image restoration is the em algorithm . in the present application , we apply em to the mixture likelihood @xmath79 where @xmath80 are mixing probabilities associated with each group . for a given number @xmath38 of components in the mixture , we use em to estimate the conditional probability that observation @xmath62 belongs to the @xmath68-th group for each @xmath45 and selected @xmath68 via maximum likelihood . although the computational procedure has some limitations ( e.g. convergence of the em iterations is not guaranteed ; clusters can not be extremely small ) , it is generally efficient and effective for gaussian clustering problems when started from reasonable partitions such as those produced by hierarchical agglomeration . we use the bayes factor to assess the evidence for a given number of clusters against a different number of clusters . the bayes factor , defined in the context of bayesian statistics , is the posterior odds for one model against the other when the prior odds are equal to one ( i.e. , when one does not favor one model over the other _ a priori _ ) . kass & raftery ( 1995 ) review the use of bayes factors in adjudicating between competing scientific hypotheses on the basis of data . the bayes factor for a model @xmath81 against a competing model @xmath82 ( say , for three @xmath83 two classes of grbs ) is defined as @xmath84 where @xmath85 ) for @xmath86 is obtained by integrating the likelihood times the prior density over the parameters of the model . it can be viewed as a likelihood ratio , but it differs from the usual frequentist ratio that underlies the likelihood ratio test in that the latter is obtained by maximizing ( rather than integrating ) the likelihood over the model parameters . twice the logarithm of the bayes factor can be approximated by the bayesian information criterion or bic ( schwarz 1978 ) , @xmath87 where @xmath88 is the likelihood and @xmath89 is the number of parameters for one mixture model , and similarly for @xmath90 and @xmath91 . the bic measures the balance between the improvement in the likelihood and the number of model parameters needed to achieve that likelihood . while the absolute value of the bic is not informative , differences between the bic values for two competing models provide estimates of the evidence in the data for one model against another . conventionally , bic differences @xmath92 represent weak evidence , differences between 2 and 6 represent positive evidence , @xmath93 strong evidence , and @xmath94 very strong evidence ( jeffreys 1961 , appendix b ; kass & raftery 1995 ) . the use of the bic in choosing clusters in a mixture or clustering model is discussed by roeder & wasserman ( 1997 ) and dasgupta & raftery ( 1998 ) . bayes factors and bic have the advantage that they can be used to assess the evidence _ for _ a null hypothesis , unlike standard significance tests which can only reject a null hypothesis . they can also easily be used to compare non - nested models , again unlike standard significance tests which require competing models to be nested . to reduce the dimensionality of the problem and the complexity of the calculation , we eliminated the highly redundant @xmath7 and @xmath26 variables ( see figure 1 ) and considered only the 3 variables @xmath1 , @xmath22 and @xmath25 for the sample of 797 batse grbs . the _ mclust _ model - based clustering procedure described above was run for trials of @xmath95 groups . the resulting values of bic(@xmath38 ) are plotted in figure 4 . the maximum bic is achieved for three classes . most importantly , the bic value for @xmath96 is @xmath97 units above that for @xmath98 . this corresponds to strong evidence indeed for the presence of three groups rather than two . this result strongly confirms the analysis in 4 indicating the existence of three clusters , and this time is free of the problem that the manova tests are conditional on the estimated partition . the result here takes account of the fact that the partition is not known in advance . we have also calculated the bic for @xmath99 with various constraints on the covariance matrix * @xmath100 * such as hypersphericity and uniformly shaped ellipsoids . spherical clusters give poor fits . uniform ellipsoids give good fits with 4 and 8 clusters . but in all cases , the maximum likelihood assuming 2 clusters is much lower than the likelihood of @xmath101 clusters . the cluster assignment vector @xmath102 for the @xmath96 model with unconstrained * @xmath100 * is given in table 4 . over 85% of the assignments are the same as those obtained from the nonparametric hierarchical clustering procedure in 4 , so that we note only differences between the two clustering results with @xmath103 and @xmath104 markings . all but one of the 96 assignment differences move bursts from classes i and ii into class iii . the close agreement between the cluster assignments in the two methods reinforces confidences in the conclusions from both of them . we can now examine the properties of grbs within each cluster with reasonable confidence that the populations are distinct from each other but internally homogeneous . these properties become inputs to astrophysical theories seeking to explain grb bulk properties . table 6a lists the means and standard deviations of the principal variables for each cluster based on both the nonparametric and model - based clustering procedures . the two methods give very similar results . the three types are well - separated in the burst duration variables : cluster i bursts have the longest durations around @xmath105-@xmath106 seconds , cluster ii bursts have the shortest durations below 1 second , and cluster iii bursts have intermediate durations around 2 seconds . this is shown clearly in figure 5 , which projects each class onto the univariate @xmath1 axis . cluster iii bursts are also intermediate in their fluences , although their fluence distribution overlaps that of the fainter class ii bursts . the hardness ratios of all three clusters overlap considerably , but class iii bursts have the softest spectra and class i bursts have intermediate spectra . we can thus classify the types in the three principal dimensions duration / fluence / spectrum ( table 6c ) : class i is long / bright / intermediate , class ii is short / faint / hard , and class iii is intermediate / intermediate / soft . a major constraint for the astrophysical interpretation of grbs has been the remarkable isotropy of their spatial distribution in the celestial sphere . it is possible that , while the bulk of grbs are isotropic and have an inferred extragalactic origin , some class of grbs have significant anisotropy which would reflect a galactic origin ( see lamb 1995 ) . we apply four statistical tests for isotropy discussed by briggs ( 1993 ) and applied by briggs et al . ( 1996 ) to various subsamples of the 3rd batse catalog of grbs . the statistics are : @xmath107cos@xmath108 , where @xmath109 is the angle between a burst and the galactic center ; @xmath107sin@xmath110 , where @xmath6 is the galactic latitude ; rayleigh - watson @xmath111 ; and bingham @xmath112 . @xmath107cos@xmath108 tests the dipole moment around the galactic center , @xmath107sin@xmath110 tests the quadrapole moment with respect to the galactic plane , @xmath111 tests the dipole moment around any point in the celestial sphere , and @xmath112 tests the quadrapole moment around any plane or two poles . the expected values for the four statistics assuming random isotropic distribution on the sphere are 0 , 0 , 3 and 5 respectively . the asymptotic distributions of these statistics are known . table 6b shows the results of this analysis for clusters i - iii , kindly calculated for us by michael briggs . no deviations from isotropy are found . the @xmath107cos@xmath108 and @xmath107sin@xmath113 values lie within one standard deviation of the expected value for a random distribution . the @xmath111 and @xmath112 values must be larger than the expected value to indicate anisotropy . the only such case , class ii with @xmath1147.32 , has a deviation with very low significance ( @xmath115 ) . we thus do not confirm belli s ( 1997 ) report of significant differences in spatial distributions of burst classes i and iii , although we did not specifically test the galactic latitude distribution . in principle , the relative populations of the three classes may be an important constraint on astrophysical theory . we find that class i contains more than half of the bursts with the remainder divided between class ii and class iii ( table 6c ) . but we do not believe our analysis gives a precise census for two reasons . first , the exact assignments of individual bursts to clusters depend on the detailed assumptions of the clustering algorithms . for example , class ii is larger than class iii in the 5-dimensional nonparametric procedure but is smaller in the 3-dimensional model - based procedure . second , the numbers of weaker bursts in classes ii and iii are strongly dependent on the details of the batse instrument s burst triggering process which produces a complicated truncation bias for fainter bursts . we look for structure within each of the clusters by computing correlation coefficients similar to those in 3 for the entire sample . results are given in table 7 . here we see a systematic difference between the two clustering methodologies : nonparametric average linkage clustering tends to give stronger correlations between the variables than the model - based clustering . for example , in the nonparametric analysis we find significant positive correlations between total fluence and hardness in classes i and ii , and a correlation between duration and fluence in class ii . however , we attach more credence to the model - based results for this purpose than the average linkage results because the former method is specifically designed to provide optimal estimates of the within - group covariances given the clustering model . the model - based results do not give strong evidence for any non - zero correlations between variables , suggesting that the partition into three clusters explains all of the correlation between variables in the full dataset . we thus find , using clustering and validation methods with different mathematical underpinnings , that three classes of grbs are present in our large subset of the third batse catalog . most of the structure can be found using three fundamental burst properties , duration / fluence / spectrum . the class properties and relation to previous research can be briefly summarized as follows : class i : : these long / bright / intermediate bursts correspond to the well - known populous long - soft class of k93 and others . within this group , we do not confirm a hardness - duration correlation reported by dezalay et al . ( 1996 ) and horack & hakkila ( 1997 ) . class ii : : this short / faint / hard group corresponds to the short - hard burst type of k93 and others . fluence - duration and fluence - hardness correlations may tentatively be present within the class . note that while the mean location of this type is consistent in the two clustering schemes , its size and population ( e.g. 1/2 or 1/4 that of class i ) differs between clustering algorithms . class iii : : the discovery of this group with intermediate / intermediate / soft properties is the principal result of this study . the group is easily distinguished in the projections of figure 3 , but can also be discerned in some panels of figure 1 . for example , it lies between classes i and ii in the @xmath116 , @xmath117 and @xmath118 scatter plots . in the univariate @xmath1 distribution shown in figure 5 , class iii accounts for most , but not all , of the bursts in the small peak around @xmath119 sec between the major short and long duration peaks . it is possible that our class iii is related to the class of no - high - energy ( nhe ) burst and peaks discussed by pendleton et al . these bursts have unusually weak @xmath12 emission , soft @xmath120 kev spectra , and low @xmath22 . however , the nhe class does not appear to exhibit a clear duration segregation from other bursts as we find for class iii . class iii does not appear to be the third cluster found by baumgart ( 1994 , see his table 3 ) , but the high dimensionality of his analysis prevents a simple comparison with our low dimensionality study . outlier : : batse trigger event 2757 , burst 3b 940114 , is the outlier in the nonparametric analysis of 4 and is clearly visible in many projections in figures 1 and 3 . it has an exceedingly soft hardness ratio and short burst duration . but examination of the original batse database shows that the @xmath121 fluxes are very weak with large measurement uncertainties . the published 3b catalog gives only an upper limit to its total fluence and no estimate of its hardness ratio ( meegan et al . the unusual properties of this burst are thus illusory and are due to its very weak fluence . the multivariate analysis described here is not comprehensive and may not have uncovered all of the structure in the third batse catalog of bulk grb properties . our reduction of dimensionality may have been too severe , omitting , for example , the potentially important @xmath12 as a distinct variable ( pendleton et al . 1997 ; bagoly et al . 1997 ) . many methodological options were not exercised . for example , it would be valuable to repeatedly apply the @xmath68-means partitioning algorithm to the database under the assumption that three clusters are present ( see murtagh 1992 for an astronomical application of this method ) , check for skewness or kurtosis in the clusters , and undertake an oblique decision tree analysis to give analytical formulation to hyperplanes separating the clusters ( see white 1997 ) . codes for these and many other multivariate techniques are publicly available through the web metasite _ statcodes _ at www.astro.psu.edu/statcodes . however , the efforts described here are far more capable of finding and quantifying clustering in the database than most previous analyses ( 1 ) . previous studies have been based on qualitative rather than quantitative procedures for identifying structures , and provide no statistical validation of their claims . it is thus not surprising that we uncovered structure missed by previous researchers . in particular , our confidence in the presence of a third cluster , class iii , is strong . two completely independent mathematical procedures ( 4 and 5 ) found very similar structure , each validated with high statistical confidence . it is possible that the clustering reported here is indeed present in the database , but does not have an astrophysical origin . the complex triggering mechanism of the batse instrument mechanism and biases in bulk property values at low signal - to - noise ratio are two problems that probably affect the multivariate structure . we have investigated one manifestation of the latter effect using @xmath18 and found no effect on our results . instrumental biases generally affect the number of bursts found in some regions of the multivariate hyperspace ( thereby biasing log @xmath36 - log @xmath122 distributions ) and may alter the location of clusters , but are unlikely to cause the appearance of clustering that is not present in the underlying population . nonetheless , since the batse instrument identifies bursts on three separate timescales , it is possible that the third cluster here is related to a selection effect associated with the batse triggering mechanisms . we conclude that the third batse catalog shows three statistically significant types of bursts ( duration / fluence / spectrum ) : class i grbs are long / bright / intermediate , class ii grbs are short / faint / hard , and class iii grbs are intermediate / intermediate / soft . unless the separation of class iii from the other types is due to some subtle batse instrumental effect , these types are likely to be real and their existence should be considered an important input into astrophysical theories for grbs . for example , the three types may reflect different types of external environments and internal shocks in relativistic fireball models ( mszros & rees 1993 ; panaitescu & mszros 1998 ) . note that statistical anlaysis is unable to determine whether burst types represent fundamentally different astrophysical processes or distinct conditions within a single astrophysical model . our results can be confirmed and extended in two fashions . first , the analysis described here can be validated with several hundred more bursts collected by batse since the september 1994 cutoff in the database used here . second , following baumgart ( 1994 ) , the dimensionality of the problem can be enlarged to include detailed characteristics of the burst temporal behaviors . burst smoothness @xmath83 peakiness , characteristic wavelet scales , spectral evolution , and other parameters can be included . with this enlarged database , one can perform both an unsupervised exploratory cluster analysis similar to that described here , and manova - type analyses that assume the existence of the three groups to determine whether the clusters have distinctive temporal properties . this work was supported by nasa grant nagw-2120 and nsf grant dms-9626189 funding astrostatistical research at penn state , and onr grants n-00014 - 96 - 1 - 0192 and n-00014 - 96 - 1 - 0330 funding statistical research at washington . sm would like to thank the departments of astronomy & astrophysics and statistics at penn state for hospitality while this work was underway . we are very grateful to jay norris ( nasa - gsfc ) for providing debiased duration values and michael briggs ( nasa - msfc ) for performing isotropy calculations . we also thank drs . briggs , norris and peter mszros ( penn state ) for sharing many valuable insights into grb astronomy . pendleton , g. n. , paciesas , w. s. , briggs , m. s. , preece , r. d. , mallozzi , r. s. , meegan , c. a. , horack , j. m. , fishman , g. j. , band , d. l. , matteson , j. l. , skelton , r. t. , hakkila , j. , ford , l. a. , kouveliotou , c. & koshut , t. m. 1997 , apj , 489 , 175 lrc & & + & mean & s.d@xmath123 + log @xmath7 ( sec ) & 0.55 & 0.92 + log @xmath1 ( sec ) & 0.96 & 0.92 + log @xmath22 ( erg @xmath124 ) & -5.61 & 0.76 + log @xmath9 ( photons s@xmath125 @xmath126 & 0.16 & 0.45 + log @xmath25 & 0.25 & 0.33 + log @xmath26 & 0.48 & 0.30 + lrrrrrr & & & & & & + & log @xmath7 & log @xmath1 & log @xmath22 & log @xmath9 & log @xmath25 & log @xmath26 + log @xmath7 & 1.00 & & & & & + log @xmath1 & 0.97 & 1.00 & & & & + log @xmath22 & 0.63 & 0.66 & 1.00 & & & + log @xmath9 & -0.01 & 0.04 & 0.59 & 1.00 & & + log @xmath25 & -0.36 & -0.36 & 0.02 & 0.24 & 1.00 & + log @xmath26 & -0.35 & -0.35 & -0.00 & 0.19 & 0.96 & 1.00 + rcrrr & & & & + level & merger & members & @xmath40 & @xmath37 + + 8 & 10 + 15 & 506 & 0.08 & 0.65 + 7 & 14 + 137 & 93 & 0.00 & 0.65 + 6 & 8 + 7 & 599 & 0.10 & 0.55 + 5 & 9 + 266 & 188 & 0.00 & 0.55 + 4 & 5 + 26 & 190 & 0.00 & 0.55 + 3 & 6 + 12 & 606 & 0.01 & 0.54 + 2 & 3 + 4 & 796 & 0.53 & 0.01 + 1 & 2 + 616 & 797 & 0.00 & 0.00 + & & & & + + 6 & 15 + 21 & 107 & 0.01 & 0.70 + 5 & 10 + 8 & 486 & 0.01 & 0.69 + 4 & 7 + 20 & 203 & 0.01 & 0.68 + 3 & 6 + 5 & 593 & 0.10 & 0.58 + 2 & 3 + 4 & 796 & 0.58 & 0.00 + 1 & 2 + 616 & 797 & 0.01 & 0.00 + lcrrr & & & & + variable & method@xmath127 & + & & & & + + log @xmath7 & np & 1.13 @xmath128 0.44 & -0.80 @xmath128 0.41 & 0.33 @xmath128 0.27 + log @xmath1 & np & 1.55 @xmath128 0.40 & -0.42 @xmath128 0.44 & 0.71 @xmath128 0.32 + & mb & 1.22 @xmath128 0.39 & -0.91 @xmath128 0.35 & 0.29 @xmath128 0.41 + log @xmath22 & np & -5.21 @xmath128 0.59 & -6.37 @xmath128 0.57 & -6.11 @xmath128 0.37 + & mb & -5.13 @xmath128 0.58 & -6.46 @xmath128 0.54 & -5.93 @xmath128 0.47 + log @xmath25 & np & 0.19 @xmath128 0.27 & 0.51 @xmath128 0.27 & 0.08 @xmath128 0.40 + & mb & 0.21 @xmath128 0.26 & 0.52 @xmath128 0.28 & 0.16 @xmath128 0.40 + log @xmath26 & np & 0.43 @xmath128 0.23 & 0.70 @xmath128 0.26 & 0.35 @xmath128 0.39 + & & & & + + @xmath107cos @xmath109@xmath4 & np & 0.015 & -0.041 & 0.010 + @xmath107sin@xmath129 & np & -0.012 & -0.025 & 0.028 + rayleigh - watson & np & 0.39 & 1.28 & 1.80 + bingham & np & 2.02 & 7.32 & 1.95 + & & & & + + number & np & 486 & 203 & 107 + & mb & 426 & 170 & 201 + duration & & long & short & intermediate + fluence & & bright & faint & intermediate + spectrum & & intermediate & hard & soft + + lrrrrr & & & & & + & log @xmath7 & log @xmath1 & log @xmath22 & log @xmath25 & log @xmath26 + + + log @xmath7 & 1.00 & & & & + log @xmath1 & 0.88 & 1.00 & & & + log @xmath22 & 0.10 & 0.22 & 1.00 & & + log @xmath25 & -0.11 & -0.08 & 0.39 & 1.00 & + log @xmath26 & -0.11 & -0.08 & 0.38 & 0.97 & 1.00 + & & & & & + + + log @xmath7 & 1.00 & & & & + log @xmath1 & n / a & n / a & & & + log @xmath22 & n / a & 0.01 & 1.00 & & + log @xmath25 & n / a & -0.01 & 0.06 & 1.00 & + log @xmath26 & n / a & n / a & n / a & n / a & n / a + & & & & & + + + log @xmath7 & 1.00 & & & & + log @xmath1 & n / a & n / a & & & + log @xmath22 & n / a & -0.03 & 1.00 & & + log @xmath25 & n / a & -0.05 & 0.02 & 1.00 & + log @xmath26 & n / a & n / a & n / a & n / a & n / a + & & & & & + + + log @xmath7 & 1.00 & & & & + log @xmath1 & 0.86 & 1.00 & & & + log @xmath22 & 0.02 & 0.06 & 1.00 & & + log @xmath25 & -0.24 & -0.34 & -0.16 & 1.00 & + log @xmath26 & -0.22 & -0.32 & -0.22 & 0.95 & 1.00 + & & & & & + + + log @xmath7 & 1.00 & & & & + log @xmath1 & n / a & n / a & & & + log @xmath22 & n / a & 0.03 & 1.00 & & + log @xmath25 & n / a & -0.01 & 0.07 & 1.00 & + log @xmath26 & n / a & n / a & n / a & n / a & n / a +

a multivariate analysis of gamma - ray burst ( grb ) bulk properties is presented to discriminate between distinct classes of grbs . several variables representing burst duration , fluence and spectral hardness are considered . two multivariate clustering procedures are used on a sample of 797 bursts from the third batse catalog : a nonparametric average linkage hierarchical agglomerative clustering procedure validated with wilks @xmath0 and other manova tests ; and a parametric maximum likelihood model - based clustering procedure assuming multinormal populations calculated with the em algorithm and validated with the bayesian information criterion . the two methods yield very similar results . the batse grb population consists of three classes with the following duration / fluence / spectrum bulk properties : class i with long / bright / intermediate bursts , class ii with short / hard / faint bursts , and class iii with intermediate / intermediate / soft bursts . one outlier with poor data is also present . classes i and ii correspond to those reported by kouveliotou et al . ( 1993 ) , but class iii is clearly defined here for the first time .

cond-mat0411600

spin - charge separation and interaction dependent power laws of correlation functions have been known as non - fermi - liquid behavior of tomonaga - luttinger ( tl ) liquid , which is expected to describe the low energy physics of one dimensional ( 1d ) interacting electron systems @xcite . in the past ten years , experimental evidences for the realization of tl states have been reported in many systems such as carbon nanotube devices @xcite , quantum wires in semiconductor heterostructures @xcite and fractional quantum hall systems @xcite , as predicted by theories . the power law temperature dependencies of the tunneling density of states @xcite , and the bulk spectral density near the fermi level @xcite have been the key signatures of tl states in these experiments . on the other hand , there are only a few experiments on the direct observation of spin - charge separation @xcite . in order to obtain such low energy spectral profiles , we need to resolve local density of states at long distances from a scatterer or a boundary edge , by scanning tunneling microscope ( stm ) @xcite , which seems rather difficult to obtain high resolution data . instead , experiments on resonant tunneling @xcite seems to be a more suitable procedure to detect the spin - charge separation , since they probes the energy level spacings in the quantum island . the resonant tunneling in tl liquid has been studied for more than a decade since kane and fisher s work @xcite . the charge transport is a main focus on those works . meanwhile , the spin transport in presence of external magnetic field , which is closely linked to detecting spin - charge separation , has not been studied enough . there are some theoretical works concerned with this issue @xcite . they consider the quantum wire forms the quantum dot between ferromagnetic contacts . there the spin and the charge transport can be controlled by the relative angle between the magnetization orientations of the ferromagnets @xcite . in their results , the qualitative change due to the spin - charge separation can be seen . however , the quantitative determination of the spin - charge separation in the excitation spectrum remains difficult . in this paper , we consider the resonant tunneling through double impurities in a spinful tl liquid under magnetic fields . a schematic picture of the system is shown in fig.[fig : system ] ; a strong field @xmath3 is applied to the entire one - dimensional system . the charge and the spin in the region between double impurities are changed by a gate voltage @xmath0 and a weak field @xmath1 , respectively . applying a strong magnetic field breaks the spin rotational symmetry and violate spin - charge separation in the spectral peaks @xcite , due to the fermi velocity differences between two spins . as a result , the spin and the charge sector mix with each other @xcite . it is shown that the spin - charge mixing effects can clearly be seen in the resonant oscillation patterns of zero bias conductance in @xmath4 plane . the spin dependent scaling behavior of a single impurity potential , due to zeeman effect , has been discussed by previous works @xcite . we also discuss a spin - charge mixing effects on the impurity scaling in the resonant tunneling . zero bias conductance is calculated by standard bosonization technique @xcite as a function of a gate voltage , gate magnetic field , temperature @xmath5 and the strong magnetic field . the impurity potential @xmath6 is assumed to be either very weak ( @xmath7 ) or very strong ( @xmath8 ) . when @xmath9 , changing the gate voltage does affect the spin density together with the charge density due to the spin - charge mixing , leading to noticeable deformation in the lattice pattern of the conductance peaks @xcite . moreover contour shapes at low temperatures are divided into three types , depending on the bulk parameters such as @xmath3 , interaction parameters @xmath10 , where the impurity potentials are scaled towards perfect reflection " , `` perfect transmission '' and magnetic field induced `` spin - filtering '' , respectively . these three behaviors are explained by a renormalization group ( rg ) analysis of a single impurity potential in spin - charge mixed systems . we consider a system illustrated in fig.[fig : system ] . schematic figure of spin polarized tomonaga - luttinger liquid with two impurities under magnetic field . , width=295,height=108 ] an infinite tl liquid , under a strong magnetic field @xmath11 perpendicular to the wire , has two impurities ( or barriers ) of the strength @xmath12 at @xmath13 . hereafter we take the spin quantization axis in the direction of @xmath11 , and denote the strength of @xmath11 by @xmath14 . @xmath15 and @xmath16 are set to unity in this paper . zeeman effect due to @xmath3 is incorporated into hamiltonian as the difference in fermi velocity between two spin species . for simplicity , we take into account the zeeman effect only on spins with neglecting the orbital effects . this is allowed when the magnetic length @xmath17 is longer than a width of the tl wire , as discussed in @xcite . in the effective mass approximation @xmath18 , the velocity difference is given by , @xmath19 for not too strong fields , @xmath20 is approximately linear in @xmath3 . for simplicity , we set @xmath21 , where the sign @xmath22 represents up ( down ) spin . we shall call the region @xmath23 an island . in the island , chemical potential of spin @xmath24 electrons can be controlled by gate voltage @xmath25 and gate magnetic field @xmath26 ; @xmath27 . we consider the situation where zeeman energies due to strong magnetic field @xmath3 and due to gate magnetic field @xmath1 are , respectively , on the order of fermi energy and energy level spacing in the island ; _ i.e. _ @xmath28 . then the fermi velocity change due to @xmath1 can be neglected . hamiltonian of the system consists of four parts , @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the hamiltonian for free electrons , two - body interaction , electrons on the island and barrier potential , respectively . they are given in terms of fermion field operator , [ eq : whole ] @xmath32 , \\ & & h_{\rm int}=\frac{1}{2 } \sum_{\sigma,\sigma ' } \int dxdy \ n_{\sigma}(x ) { \mathcal u}_{\sigma,\sigma'}(x - y ) n_{\sigma'}(y ) , \qquad \\ & & h_{{\rm island}}= -ev_{\rm g } \sum_{\sigma } \int_{-d}^{d } dx \ n_{\sigma } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad \quad + \int_{-d}^{d } dx \ \frac{1}{2 } g \mu_{b } \overrightarrow{b_{\rm g } } \cdot ( \psi_{\alpha}^{\dagger } \vec{\sigma}_{\alpha,\beta}\psi_{\beta } ) , \label{h - island } \\ & & h_{{\rm b}}= v \sum_{\sigma } \ \left [ n_{\sigma}(-d ) + n_{\sigma}(d ) \right ] , \label{h - barriers}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath33 and @xmath34 are annihilation operator and density operator for electrons with spin @xmath35 . we neglect the charging energy of the island ( @xmath36 in @xcite ) , which can be incorporated into @xmath37 . @xmath38 are written in terms of bosonic phase fields @xcite , [ eq : whole ] @xmath39 \nonumber \\ & & \qquad \qquad + \pi \delta \int dx \left [ ( \frac{1}{\pi}\partial_{x } \phi_{\rho})(\frac{1}{\pi}\partial_{x } \phi_{s})+ \pi_{\rho}\pi_{s } \right ] , \qquad \label{hamiltonian before diagonalized}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath40 is the inverse of the fermi wave number : @xmath41 and @xmath42 are conjugate pairs of bosonic field with commutation relations @xmath43=i \delta_{i , j } \delta(x - x')$ ] , where @xmath44 @xmath45 represent for charge ( spin ) variables . to diagonalize @xmath38 , we use the linear transformation @xcite ( see also appendix b for the expression in ladder operators of tl bosons ) @xmath46 commutation relations are preserved under this transformation @xmath47=i \delta_{i , j } \delta(x - x')$ ] . parameters @xmath48 and @xmath49 are , respectively , a rotation angle and a scale factor in `` spin - charge space '' given by , @xmath50 the rotation angle @xmath48 is proportional to @xmath20 , and thus to @xmath3 , for small @xmath20 . after the transformation , @xmath51 becomes , @xmath52 . \label{tl hamiltonian}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expression of @xmath53 and @xmath54 are given in appendix a. as discussed in @xcite , in a polarized tl liquid , the scaling dimensions of a single impurity potential split between two spins . renormalization group equations for small backscattering amplitude @xmath55 and small tunneling amplitude @xmath56 are given @xmath57 with @xmath58 and an initial ( running ) energy cutoff @xmath59 ( @xmath60 ) . the scaling dimensions @xmath61 and @xmath62 are given @xmath63 where @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 , and @xmath67 . thus the ratio of reflection amplitudes and tunneling amplitudes scale like , respectively , @xmath68 and @xmath69 . the difference of the exponents @xmath70 and @xmath71 are given @xmath72 this expression tells us that the split of the scaling dimensions between two spins become large when the spin - charge mixing angle is large . due to the split of exponents , we expect the spin current with large polarization @xmath73 at low temperature in the strong barrier limit . this scaling effect with the exponents @xmath61 and @xmath62 also appears in the conductance for double barrier structure . we consider first the weak barrier limit @xmath74 , where the electron transfer is due to the coherent tunneling of the spin - charge mixed density wave . the zero bias conductance is calculated perturbatively with respect to the small barrier potential @xmath75 . the hamiltonian for the island and for the barriers in eq.([h - island ] ) and eq.([h - barriers ] ) are written in terms of the bosonic phase at @xmath13 , @xmath76 @xmath77 is the linear combination of phases at @xmath13 . according to our assumption that the magnetic field @xmath3 is strong enough that @xmath78 , only @xmath79-component of @xmath80 remains after the integration of ( [ h - island ] ) with neglecting the fast oscillating terms . hereafter , we denote @xmath81 by @xmath1 . to make calculations easier , it is helpful to construct an effective action @xcite obtained by integrating out the tl field except for the positions of the barriers @xmath13 , since charge ( spin ) current through barriers depends only on the local variables , @xmath82 . the integrated effective action is calculated as , @xmath83 , \\ & & \tilde{\epsilon}_{i}^{\pm}(\omega_{n } ) = \frac{1}{\pi \tilde{k}_{i}}\frac{| \omega_{n}|}{1 \pm \exp \{-(2d/\tilde{v}_{i})|\omega_{n}| \}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] here we have defined new variables @xmath84 . @xmath85 and @xmath86 relates each other by the same linear transformation between @xmath87 and @xmath88 . we will calculate zero bias conductance for charge ( spin ) current following kubo formula , @xmath89 where analytic continuation is to be taken before taking the limit . the effective action @xmath90 is used for taking thermal average such that @xmath91 hamiltonian for the island @xmath92 is given after canonical transformation ( [ linear transform ] ) as @xmath93 with the coefficients , @xmath94 thus , the terms other than barrier potentials , quadratic in @xmath95 , can be treated exactly in @xmath90 . after straightforward calculation , we obtain an explicit form of the conductance to the second order in @xmath75 ; @xmath96 for @xmath97 . the unperturbed conductance @xmath98 and @xmath99 are @xcite , @xmath100 this expression implies that spin polarized current can flow in a clean , infinite tl liquid due to spin - charge mixing effect , since @xmath101 when @xmath102 for all interaction parameters . however , such a violation of the conductance quantization is shown to be an artifact for infinite system as previous works pointed out for unpolarized system @xcite . we show in appendix c that the prefactors of conductance should vanish @xmath103 @xmath104 also for spin polarized system , by taking into account the effects of fermi liquid reservoirs . thus the spin polarized current can not be generated in a clean system , even when a magnetic field are applied . the second order correction @xmath105 is [ eq : whole ] @xmath106 , \\ & & \qquad r_{\sigma } = \cos{\omega_{\sigma } } \exp\left[-\sum_{\omega'_{n}}f_{\sigma}(\omega_{n } ' ) ( 1+\cos{\omega'_{n}\tau } ) \right ] + \exp\left[-\sum_{\omega'_{n}}f_{\sigma}(\omega_{n } ' ) ( 1-\cos{\omega'_{n}\tau } ) \right ] \\ & & \qquad \omega_{\sigma}=-4k_{{\rm f},\sigma}d+ \bigl [ \frac{-\cos{\alpha}b_{\rho,\sigma}}{\pi \tilde{\epsilon}_{\rho}^{-}(0 ) } + \frac{y^{-1}\sin{\alpha } b_{s,\sigma}}{\pi \tilde{\epsilon}_{s}^{-}(0 ) } \bigr ] 2ev_{g } + \bigl [ \frac{y \sin{\alpha}b_{\rho,\sigma}}{\pi \tilde{\epsilon}_{\rho}^{-}(0 ) } + \frac{\cos{\alpha}b_{s,\sigma}}{\pi \tilde{\epsilon}_{s}^{-}(0 ) } \bigr ] g \mu_{b}b_{g } , \\ & & \qquad f_{\sigma}(\omega_{n } ' ) = \frac{1}{2\beta } \left ( \frac{b_{\rho,\sigma}^2 } { \tilde{\epsilon}_{\rho}^{-}(\omega'_{n } ) } + \frac{b_{s,\sigma}^2 } { \tilde{\epsilon}_{s}^{-}(\omega'_{n } ) } \right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath107 and the constants given by , @xmath108 the second order correction @xmath105 gives us some information about the resonant oscillation in @xmath109 plane ; the exponential terms determine the temperature dependent amplitude , and @xmath110 determines the period . as seen in the above expression , the conductance oscillation comes from a sum of two independent contributions ; resonant tunneling of spin up electrons and spin down electrons . this is because the average of a product of cosine terms for up spin and down spin always vanishes ; @xmath111 . at low temperature @xmath112 , it is given @xmath113 where @xmath59 is the high energy cut - off . at high temperature @xmath114 , the term proportional to @xmath115 is exponentially suppressed as increasing temperature , while the other terms remain unchanged in ( [ eq : weak barrier conductance ] ) . thus , the conductance oscillation dessappers and the double impurity structure can be viewed as a single impurity whose scaling law is given in eq.([eq : single impurity scaling ( weak ) ] ) for @xmath116 . second order conductance correction @xmath117 are plotted as a function of gate voltage and magnetic field normalized by @xmath118 for hubbard model . @xmath119 , @xmath120 ; ( a ) @xmath121 , ( b ) @xmath122 , ( c ) @xmath123 , ( d ) @xmath124 . the temperature is fixed at @xmath125 in all figures . solid ( broken ) arrow indicates the direction of peak line of the conductance deviation due to up ( down ) spin resonant tunneling . , width=296,height=309 ] figure [ fig : conductance ] shows the contour plot of the conductance correction as a function of gate voltage and gate magnetic field . conductance peaks form lattice in ( @xmath126 ) plane and spin - charge mixing effect causes the deformation of the lattice . for unpolarized fermi liquid @xmath102 and @xmath127 in fig.[fig : conductance](a ) , conductance peaks form rectangular lattice with periods @xmath128 . changing the interaction parameter from @xmath129 to @xmath130 ( from fig.[fig : conductance](a ) to fig.[fig : conductance](b ) ) , the lattice shape does not change but with a shift in the period @xmath131 due to the change in charge- and spin- susceptibility of the island @xmath132 and @xmath133 . as increasing @xmath20 from @xmath134 to @xmath135 in fermi liquid case ( from fi.[fig : conductance](a ) to fig.[fig : conductance](c ) ) , stretches in primary unit vectors of the lattice ( arrows in figures ) , by a factor @xmath136 for spin @xmath35 electrons , are seen . it reflects the change in the level spacing due to zeeman effect given by @xmath137 . then , adding the interaction from @xmath129 to @xmath130 ( from fig.[fig : conductance](c ) to fig.[fig : conductance](d ) ) , rotations of the primary unit vectors rotates reflecting rotations of spin - charge space . this is exactly due to spin - charge mixing effect . for @xmath138 , the rotation can not be seen in fig.[fig : conductance](c ) since the principal axis in spin - charge space stay in the direction @xmath139 independent of @xmath20 . the rotation angle @xmath140 is proportional to `` spin - charge mixing angle @xmath48 '' for small @xmath20 , @xmath141 when there are only density - density interactions between electrons @xmath142 _ i.e. _ tl parameters satisfy @xmath143 , @xmath144 when the temperature decreases , the amplitude of oscillation for two spins follow power laws with different exponents . in case of spin isotropic interaction ( @xmath145 @xmath103 @xmath146 ) , depending on the interaction @xmath147 is repulsive or attractive , impurity potentials are scaled toward perfect reflection or perfect transmission . extending the parameter space to spin anisotropic interaction ( @xmath148 @xmath103 @xmath149 ) , `` spin filter phase '' where @xmath150 , emerges between the two phases `` perfect transmission '' and `` perfect reflection '' . in this phase , the impurity potential scales toward perfect transmission for up spin ( majority spin ) , and perfect reflection for down ( minority ) spin . the conductance correction at different temperatures are plotted with tl parameters in spin filter phase in fig.[fig : conductance - low temperature ] . the peaks of the conductance correction changes from lattice structure to one plane wave , as lowering temperature from fig.[fig : conductance - low temperature](a ) to fig.[fig : conductance - low temperature](b ) . this is due to the strong suppression of backscattering current of the majority spins , and the enhansment for the minority spin at low temperature . these results suggest the possibility of generating and modulating spin current with large polarization by gate voltage and gate magnetic field . @xmath117 are plotted as a function of gate voltage and magnetic field normalized by @xmath118 for spin anisotropic interaction parameters . @xmath151 , @xmath152 , @xmath153 ; ( a ) @xmath154 , ( b ) @xmath155.,width=289,height=149 ] in this section , we consider the weak link limit ( @xmath157 ) , where the tunneling amplitudes @xmath56 satisfies @xmath158 and the electron transport is described by a sequential tunneling picture @xcite . we will calculate zero - bias conductance perturbatively to the lowest order within a master equation framework . the higher order contributions , such as cotunneling ( cot ) @xcite and correlated sequential tunneling ( cst ) @xcite , are neglected . contributions from cot and cst become important , respectively , away from the resonance peaks and for rather transparent barriers @xcite . thus , they do not seem to make major changes in the discussions here focusing on the peak positions and the height in the weak link limit . we consider a quantum island with length @xmath159 weakly linked to the semiinfinite tl wires at the both ends . the hamiltonian for the semiinfinite wires @xmath160 are the same as eq.([tl hamiltonian ] ) . we represent electron field operators of the island , the right ( r ) and the left ( l ) wire by @xmath161 , @xmath162 and @xmath163 , respectively . they obey the open boundary condition @xmath164 . the chemical potentials of the right and the left wire are set @xmath165 and @xmath166 , and we take the limit @xmath167 at the last stage of the calculations for the zero bias conductance . in the sequential tunneling regime , the number of excess electrons on the island @xmath168 becomes a good quantum number , which enters in the zero mode hamiltonian @xmath169 , @xmath170 the hamiltonian for non - zero mode @xmath171 is the same as in eq.([tl hamiltonian ] ) ; @xmath172 , where @xmath173 . under the boundary condition , the mode expansion of the electron field operator @xmath174 becomes @xcite , @xmath175 where @xmath176 is zero - mode phase satisfying @xmath177 = i$ ] . non - zero mode phase @xmath178 is given @xmath179 the mode expansion of @xmath180 are similarly obtained . using the boundary operators , the tunnel hamiltonian @xmath181 is given @xmath182 the transition rate @xmath183 from a initial state @xmath184 to a final state @xmath185 ( @xmath186 ) , via tunneling processes at the right ( left ) end of the island , can be calculated perturbatively . to the lowest order , it becomes @xmath187 where the time evolution of operators are given in interaction representation @xmath188 with @xmath189 $ ] . we obtain the expression for @xmath190 @xmath191 as , @xmath192 \gamma^{j}(\varepsilon_{\sigma}^{j},\beta ) , \label{eq : transition rate } \\ & & \gamma^{j}(\varepsilon_{\sigma}^{j},\beta ) \sim \frac{1}{\pi}\left ( \frac{t_{\sigma}^{j}}{v_{{\rm f},\sigma } } \right)^{2 } \left ( \frac{\pi}{\beta \lambda } \right)^{\frac{\lambda_{\sigma}}{2}-2 } \prod_{i=\rho , s } \left(\frac{3\tilde{v}_{i}/d}{\lambda}\right)^{\frac{d_{i,\sigma}^{2}}{2\tilde{k}_{i } } } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad \quad \times 2^{\lambda_{\sigma}-1 } b\left [ \frac{\lambda_{\sigma}+i\beta \varepsilon_{\sigma}^{j}/\pi}{2 } , \frac{\lambda_{\sigma}-i\beta \varepsilon_{\sigma}^{j}/\pi}{2 } \right ] , \label{eq : tunneling rate}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath193 is the energy difference between the two states . the line shape of the conductance near the peak is roughly given by the beta function in ( [ eq : tunneling rate ] ) , and the peak height scales like @xmath194 as lowering temperature . the probability @xmath195 to find the system in @xmath196 , and the current of spin @xmath35 electrons @xmath197 are obtained by solving a set of master equations , @xmath198 where @xmath199 . the zero bias conductance @xmath200 is evaluated from ( [ eq : transition rate])-([eq : current by sequential tunneling ] ) and plotted as a function of gate voltage and gate magnetic field in fig.[fig : weak link conductance ] . zero bias conductance @xmath201 is plotted as a function of gate voltage and magnetic field normalized by @xmath118 , with @xmath202 and @xmath203 . different values of interaction and magnetic field are taken for each figures ; ( a ) @xmath127 , @xmath204 , ( b ) @xmath127 , @xmath205 , ( c ) @xmath130 , @xmath145 , @xmath204 , and ( d ) @xmath130 , @xmath145 , @xmath205.,width=292,height=265 ] the conductance peak form lattice in @xmath2 plane , and one can see the spin - charge mixing effect on the shape as well as in the case of weak barriers . arrows in figures are the primary unit vectors , and a translation by a solid ( dotted ) arrow corresponds to a change in the average particle number of down ( up ) spin electrons in the island by one . when spin and charge excitations are degenerate ( @xmath138 ) , the primary unit vectors of the lattice pattern are in the direction of @xmath139 independently of the magnetic field @xmath20 as shown in fig.[fig : weak link conductance](a ) and fig.[fig : weak link conductance](b ) . on the other hand , when spin - charge separation does hold ( @xmath206 ) , the vectors rotate as increasing @xmath20 as seen in fig.[fig : weak link conductance](c ) and fig.[fig : weak link conductance](d ) . from eq.([eq : zero mode 1]-[eq : zero mode 2 ] ) , one can ensure that the angle of the solid ( dotted ) arrow @xmath207 ( @xmath208 ) is given @xmath209 thus the expansion of the rotation angle @xmath140 to the linear order in @xmath20 , yields the same result as eq.([eq : rotation angle ] ) obtained for the weak barrier case . this could indicate that applying a magnetic field causes a rotation of the lattice of conductance peaks by the same angle for entire range of barrier strength to the linear order . of course , being similar to the weak barrier case , the splits of scaling dimensions for tunneling amplitudes between two spins results in strong suppression of the peak height along the resonant line @xmath210 compared to @xmath211 in fig.[fig : weak link conductance](d ) . another interesting result in the strong barrier limit is that for @xmath212 there are no resonance points of four number states ( say @xmath213 , @xmath214 , @xmath215 and @xmath216 ) like o and @xmath217 . instead , such a resonance point splits into two ; one like a and @xmath218 where the three states @xmath213 , @xmath214 and @xmath215 degenerate , and the other like d and @xmath219 where @xmath216 , @xmath214 and @xmath215 do . the length between the separated resonance points @xmath220 and @xmath221 , corresponds to @xmath222 . it can thus be a measure for the strength of spin - charge separation . we have discussed the spin - charge mixing effect on the resonant tunneling in spin - polarized tomonaga - luttinger liquid under magnetic fields . the zero bias conductance is calculated as a function of gate voltage @xmath223 and gate magnetic field @xmath224 . conductance peaks form a lattice structure in @xmath225 plane . we find two effects of the spin - charge mixing in the plot of zero bias conductance ; ( i ) the primary unit vectors of the lattice pattern rotate as increasing magnetic field due to `` spin - charge mixing '' . ( ii ) the amplitude of conductance oscillation differs significantly at low temperature between two spins , which originates from the split of the scaling dimension of impurity potential . for systems with appropriate interaction parameters , the impurity potential can become a spin - filter that selects electrons of one spin orientation to pass through . we should note that such spin - filtering phase appears only for the systems with spin - anisotropic interaction ( @xmath148 ) , whose candidates in real systems havent been found yet . however , recent studies predicts that spin - orbit interactions in a quantum wire , whose strength is tunable by the gate voltage , can also cause spin - charge mixing @xcite as the zeeman effect does . moreover gritsev @xmath226 @xcite show that an interaction parameter @xmath227 can be renormalized and shift from @xmath145 in the presence of rashba coupling . these facts may suggest a possibility to lead such spin - filtering phase to an experimentally accessible region . finally we would like to address the possibility for the experimental test of our theory . if one uses armchair carbon nanotube as a tl wire , there arise two difficulties to observe the spin - charge mixing . armchair nanotubew are described as four components tl liquid ( spinful tl liquid with two bands @xmath228 ) , having a symmetry in the band structure @xmath229 at the fermi level @xmath230 . due to this unique band structure , the symmetry between up and down spins will not be broken even when applied magnetic field . hense the spin - charge mixing does not occur for @xmath230 . this is one difficulty . however , for doped carbon nanotubes ( @xmath231 ) with the band structure symmetry broken @xmath232 , the spin - charge mixing occur when applied a strong magnetic field . another difficulty is on realization of such a strong magnetic fields that the spin - cahrge mixing effect can be measured . in our case , a significant change in the fermi velocity about @xmath233 is needed . such situation may be difficult to prepare in carbon nanotubes with a band width @xmath234 @xcite since @xmath235-factor for electrons in carbon nanotubes is @xmath236 @xcite , which means a magnetic field 1 t amounts to @xmath237 . to make velocity difference @xmath238 , it requires @xmath239 tesla in case of carbon nanotubes . and the preparation of the local magnetic field @xmath1 with a submicron meter scale is also an open issue , though there are some works reporting magnetic fields with a micron meter scale @xcite . however , if one uses a quantum wire with a small fermi energy and a large @xmath235-factor _ e.g. _ an insb quantum wire with @xmath240 , two problems lying on carbon nanotubes are cleared , and our predictions can possibly be verified in experiments . ultracold fermionic atoms in optical lattices @xcite , which shows remarkable progress in experiments , with controllable parameters such as interaction parameters , lattice shapes , and the potential height , will also give us another conceivable stage to test our theory . it is the more important issue of spintronics to suggest new ways of creating spin filters _ i.e. _ the way to modify the split of scaling dimensions between two spin channels in more realistic models . however the concepts of `` spin - charge mixing effect '' will play one key role in this matter . we thank n. yokoshi and t. kimura for useful comments and discussions . this work is supported by the 21st century coe program ( holistic research and education center for physics of selforganization systems ) at waseda university from the ministry of education , sports , culture , science and technology of japan . is supported by the japan society for promotion of science . luttinger parameters in eq.([tl hamiltonian ] ) are given , @xmath241 where @xmath48 and @xmath49 are given in eq.([rotation angle ] ) . here we represent the linear transformation in eq.([linear transform ] ) in terms of ladder operators of tl bosons @xmath242 , @xmath243 , @xmath244 and @xmath245 , which diagonalize tl hamiltonian as @xmath246 . the phase variables @xmath41 and @xmath42 are expanded in terms of the ladder operators as @xmath247 the representation for @xmath248 and @xmath249 are obtained similarly by putting @xmath250 into the above equations . focusing on a @xmath251-component here , we omit the index @xmath251 for simplicity . from the above expressions , the transformation in eq.([linear transform ] ) is expressed as @xmath252 with @xmath253 , @xmath254 , and a 4@xmath2554 matrix @xmath256 ; @xmath257 for sure , it can be easily checked that the transformation matrix @xmath256 satisfies a normalization condition for a bogoliubov transformation @xmath258 with @xmath259 . here we calculate the zero bias conductance of a clean tl wire under magnetic field , connected to fermi liquid reservoirs . as previous works @xcite have shown , the scaling factor of conductance should disappear by the effect of reservoirs . we check whether their statements can also be applied to a polarized tl liquid , and whether our result in eq.([eq : conductance in clean limit 2 ] ) , which implies that applying bias voltage generates spin current by spin - charge mixing effect , is an artifact of the assumption to be an infinite system . we consider a polarized tl wire is connected to reservoirs of noninteracting fermi liquid at @xmath13 . from hamiltonian ( [ hamiltonian before diagonalized ] ) , the imaginary time action becomes , @xmath260 @xmath20 , @xmath261 and @xmath262 are @xmath263-dependent parameters and abruptly change at the boundaries , @xmath264 conductance can be calculated from the green s function of bosonic field , @xmath265 which satisfies the equation , @xmath266 here @xmath267 is fourier component of @xmath268 obtained by @xmath269 . dc charge current ( @xmath270 ) and spin current ( @xmath271 ) induced by a time independent electronic field @xmath272 in tl wire @xmath273 , are determined from kubo formula for @xmath274 @xmath275_{i,\rho } \right ) e(y ) . \quad\end{aligned}\ ] ] we must solve ( [ eq : equation for greens function ] ) under the boundary conditions at @xmath276 ; ( i ) the green s function should be continuous and ( ii ) the integration should satisfy @xmath277 one can find the solution to become @xmath278 thus the conductance is given by @xmath279 and @xmath101 instead of eq.([eq : conductance in clean limit 1]-[eq : conductance in clean limit 2 ] ) . the result shows the conductance quantization to @xmath280 par spin channel also holds for spin - charge mixed systems under the magnetic field , as far as concerned the dc limit @xmath281 . moreover we can ensure this conclusion is unchanged when a magnetic field is also applied to reservoirs besides the one - dimensional region . a. gogolin , a. nersesyan , and a. tsvelik , _ `` bosonization and strongly correlated systems '' _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , england , 1998 ) . m. bockrath _ et . al . _ , nature ( london ) * 397 * , 598 ( 1999 ) ; z. yao _ et . _ , _ ibd . _ * 402 * , 273 ( 1999 ) . a. bachtold _ et . lett . * 87 * , 166801 ( 2001 ) . h. w. postma , t. teepen , z. yao , m. grifoni , and c. dekker , science * 293 * , 76 ( 2001 ) . s. tarucha , t. honda and t. saku , solid state commun . * 94 * , 413 ( 1995 ) . a. yacoby _ et . al . _ , solid state commun . * 101 * , 77 ( 1997 ) . f. p. milliken , c. p. umbach , and r. a. webb , solid state commun . * 97 * , 309 ( 1996 ) . a. m. chang , l. n. pfeiffer , and k. w. west , phys . * 77 * , 2538 ( 1996 ) . r. egger and a. o. gogolin , phys . lett . * 79 * , 5082 ( 1997 ) ; c. l. kane , l. balents , and m. p. a. fisher , _ ibd . _ * 79 * , 5086 ( 1997 ) x .- g . wen , phys . b * 41 * , 12838 ( 1990 ) . h. ishii , h. kataura , h. shiozawa , h. yoshioka , h. otsubo , y. takayama , t. miyahara , s. suzuki , y. achiba , m. nakatake , t. narumira , m. higashiguchi , k. shimada , h. namatame and m. taniguchi , nature * 426 * , 540 ( 2003 ) . o. m. auslaender , h. steinberg , a. yacoby , y. tserkovnyak , b. i. halperin , k. w. baldwin , l. n. pfeiffer , and k. w. west , science * 308 * , 88 ( 2005 ) . j. lee , s. eggert , h. kim , s. j. kahng , h. shinohara , and y. kuk , phys . lett . * 93 * , 166403 ( 2004 ) . w. liang , m. bockrath , d. bozovic , j. h. hafner , m. tinkham , h. park , nature ( london ) * 411 * , 665 ( 2001 ) ; w. liang , m. bockrath , and h. park , phys . rev . * 88 * , 126801 ( 2002 ) m. r. buitelaar , a. bachtold , t. nussbaumer , m. iqbal , and c. schonenberger , phys . * 88 * , 156801 ( 2002 ) . c. l. kane and m. p. a. fisher , phys . b * 46 * , 15233 ( 1992 ) . a. furusaki and n. nagaosa , phys . b * 47 * , 3827 ( 1993 ) . a. furusaki , phys . b * 57 * , 7141 ( 1998 ) . qimiao si , phys . 81 * , 3191 ( 1998 ) . l. balents and r. egger , phys . lett . * 85 * , 3464 ( 2000 ) ; l. balents and r. egger , phys . rev . b 64 , 035310 ( 2001 ) . c. s. peca , l. balents , and k. j. wiese , phys . b * 68 * , 205423 ( 2003 ) . s. rabello and q. si , europhys . lett . * 60 * , 882 ( 2002 ) . k. penc and j. solyom , phys . b * 47 * , 6273 - 6292 ( 1993 ) . t. kimura , k. kuroki , and h. aoki , phys . b * 53 * , 9572 ( 1996 ) . d. schmeltzer , phys . b * 65 * , 193303 ( 2002 ) ; h. y. chang and d. schmeltzer , phys . lett . a * 345 * , 45 ( 2005 ) . t. hikihara , a. furusaki and k. a. matveev , phys . b * 72 * , 035301 ( 2005 ) . s. lal , s. rao , and d. sen , phys . b * 65 * , 195304 ( 2002 ) . k. kamide , t. tsukada , and s. kurihara , physica b * 359 * -*361 * , 645 ( 2005 ) . h. ajiki and t. ando , j. phys . . jpn . * 62 * , 1255 ( 1993 ) ; j. phys . . jpn . * 65 * , 505 ( 1996 ) . d. l. maslov and m. stone , phys . b * 52 * , r5539 ( 1995 ) . a. kawabata , j. phys . jpn . * 65 * , 30 ( 1995 ) . v. v. ponomarenko , phys . rev . b * 52 * , r8666 ( 1995 ) . m. thorwart , m. grifoni , g. cuniberti , h. w. ch . postma , and c. dekker phys . lett . * 89 * , 196402 ( 2002 ) ; m. thorwart , r. egger , and m. grifoni phys . rev . b * 72 * , 035330 ( 2005 ) . m. fabrizio and a. o. gogolin , phys . b * 51 * , 17827 ( 1995 ) . a. e. mattsson , s. eggert , and h. johannesson , phys . b * 56 * , 15615 ( 1997 ) . f. anfuso and s. eggert , phys . b * 68 * , 241301(r ) ( 2003 ) . a. v. moroz , k. v. samokhin , and c. h. w. barnes , phys . lett . * 84 * , 4164 ( 2000 ) ; a. v. moroz and c. h. w. barnes , phys . b * 60 * , 14272 ( 1999 ) . v. gritsev , g. i. japaridze , m. pletyukhov , and d. baeriswyl , phys . * 94 * , 137207 ( 2005 ) . m. ouyang , j. l. huang , and c. m. lieber , phys . lett . * 88 * 66804 ( 2002 ) . s. j. tans , m. h. devoret , h. dai , a. thess , r. e. smalley , l. j. geerligs , and c. dekker , nature * 386 * , 474 ( 1997 ) ; d. h. cobden , m. bockrath , p. l. mceuen , a. g. rinzler and r. e. smalley , phys . lett . * 81 * , 681 ( 1998 ) . q. ramadan , c. yu , v. samper , and d. p. poenar , appl . . lett . * 88 * , 032501 ( 2006 ) . m. khl , h. moritz , t. stferle , k. gnter , and t. esslinger , phys . lett . * 94 * , 080403 ( 2005 ) ; k. gnter , t. stferle , h. moritz , m. khl , and t. esslinger , phys . rev . lett . * 95 * , 230401 ( 2005 ) .

we investigate spin - charge mixing effect on resonant tunneling in spin - polarized tomonaga - luttinger liquid with double impurities . the mixing arises from fermi velocity difference between two spin species due to zeeman effect . zero bias conductance is calculated as a function of gate voltage @xmath0 , gate magnetic field @xmath1 , temperature and magnetic field applied to the system . mixing effect is shown to cause rotation of the lattice pattern of the conductance peaks in @xmath2 plane , which can be observed in experiments . at low temperatures , the contour shapes are classified into three types , reflecting the fact that effective barrier potential is renormalized towards `` perfect reflection '' , `` perfect transmission '' and magnetic field induced `` spin - filtering '' , respectively .

astro-ph0208023

early hydrogen reionization is a particularly interesting process in the high redshift universe and is inevitably linked to the appearance of the first star forming objects , at least those that served as sources of the ionizing radiation . if it occurred early enough , reionization imprints distinct features in maps of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) on arcminute angular scales @xcite . several aspects of hydrogen reionization remain uncertain despite the rapidly accumulating data on the high redshift universe . for example , it is unclear what objects produce most of the ionizing radiation , although high redshift galaxies are very strong candidates @xcite . it is also unclear how the ionized regions develop in space @xcite . the ionizing sources are likely to lie in high density regions , but those regions do not necessarily ionize first ; the ionizing photons may tunnel into less dense regions and ionize those first . further , the duration of reionization is unknown and only a lower limit on the redshift marking the end of that epoch exists @xcite . in previous papers ( benson et al . 2001 , liu et al . 2001 ) we examined how the cmb is affected by the reionization process and how future cmb maps can be used to extract information on that process . however , hydrogen reionization is currently best probed by spectra of high redshift qsos . unlike maps of the cmb which are sensitive to line of sight integrals over the density and velocity of ionized gas , qso spectra contain direct information on the local distribution of neutral hydrogen . recently , becker et al . ( 2001 ) analyzed spectra of a sample of qsos with redshifts between @xmath0 and @xmath1 . in the spectrum of their highest redshift qso ( @xmath1 ) , the transmitted flux in the ly@xmath2 and ly@xmath3 forest in the redshift stretch @xmath4 is consistent with zero , with a lower limit of 20 on the ly@xmath2 optical depth . this long stretch in redshift corresponds to a comoving distance of @xmath5 in a universe with a cosmological constant of @xmath6 and matter density of @xmath7 . becker et al . suggest that this long neutral region is a detection of the end of the hydrogen reionization era . to increase the signal - to - noise ratio , becker et al . binned their spectra in @xmath8 pixels . this prevented them from detecting small scale dark windows that are likely to appear in the spectra as left overs from the reionization epoch . a high resolution spectrum for one of the quasars observed by becker et al . was obtained by djorgovski et al . the spectrum of this quasar ( @xmath9 ) was thorough analyzed by djorgovski et al . ( 2001 ) and was found to contain several small dark windows signifying the detection of the trailing edge of the reionization epoch . motivated by the results of becker et al . ( 2001 ) and djorgovski et al . ( 2001 ) , we examine here how the key ingredients in the reionization process can be probed by qso spectra and future high redshift galaxy surveys . the methodology of the present paper has been previously developed in benson et al . ( 2001 , hereafter bnsl ) . as in bnsl , we obtain the distribution of ionized gas in an n - body simulation . using a semi - analytic model for galaxy formation @xcite we identify mock galaxies in the simulation and estimate the ionizing flux emitted by stars at high redshift . we then use several schemes to follow the development of ionized regions in the simulation . using the output of this procedure we obtain predictions for two statistics . the first is the expected number of neutral segments longer than a given length , and the second is the cross - correlation function between the galaxies and neutral regions . both of these measures rely on observations of qso spectra , and the latter also on a sample of high redshift candidates for the sources of ionizing radiation . bnsl employed a semi - analytical model for galaxy formation in a high resolution n - body simulation of dark matter to estimate the amount of ionizing radiation produced by stars in high redshift galaxies . here we follow a similar procedure using the latest version of the galform galaxy formation model @xcite , and the same @xmath10cdm simulation as bnsl ( c.f . jenkins et al . 1998 ) . this simulation has @xmath11 , a cosmological constant @xmath12 , a hubble constant of @xmath13 in units of @xmath14 , and is normalized to produce the observed abundance of rich clusters at @xmath15 according to eke , cole & frenk ( 1996 ) . the simulation has a box of length 141.3 @xmath16 and contains @xmath17 dark matter particles . most of the ionizing photons emitted by stars are likely to be absorbed by gas and dust inside galaxies and only a small fraction , @xmath18 , escapes and becomes available for hydrogen ionization in the intergalactic medium ( igm ) @xcite . assuming a value from galaxy to galaxy . here we adopt the simplest model , in which @xmath19 is constant for all galaxies . ] for @xmath18 , bnsl used the following models to follow the propagation of ionized regions in the simulation ( see bsnl for details ) . _ model a ( growing front model ) _ ionize a spherical volume around each source ( halo ) with a radius equal to the ionization front radius for that halo assuming a large - scale uniform distribution of neutral hydrogen . since the neutral hydrogen in the simulation is not uniformly distributed , and also because some spheres will overlap , the ionized volume will not contain the correct total mass of hydrogen . we therefore scale the radius of each sphere by a constant factor and keep repeating the procedure until the correct total mass has been ionized . _ model b ( high density model ) _ we simply rank the cells in the simulation volume by their density . we then completely ionize the gas in the densest cell . if this has not ionized enough hydrogen we ionize the second densest cell . this process is repeated until the correct total mass of hydrogen has been ionized . _ model c ( low density model ) _ as model b , but we begin by ionizing the least dense cell , and work our way up to cells of greater and greater density @xcite . _ model d ( random spheres model ) _ as model a but the spheres are placed in the simulation entirely at random rather than on the dark matter halos . _ model e ( boundary model ) _ ionize a spherical region around each halo with a radius equal to the ionization front radius for that halo . this may ionize too much or not enough neutral hydrogen depending on the density of gas around each source . we therefore begin adding or removing cells at random from the boundaries of the already ionized regions until the required mass is ionized . guided by the observations of becker et al . ( 2001 ) we will compute the number of neutral segments and the cross correlations at three output redshifts , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 . table 1 lists the volume filling factors ( ratio of volume of ionized regions to total volume of the simulation box ) in each of our five models for @xmath23 ( column 2 in table 1 ) and @xmath24 ( column 3 ) . we will see later that the results of becker et al . imply that the amount of ionizing radiation increases significantly between @xmath25 and @xmath26 . therefore we also show results for a variable escape fraction,@xmath27 ( column 4 ) which equals @xmath28 before @xmath29 and increases linearly with time to @xmath30 at @xmath31 . as expected , model c ( low density model ) has the highest filling factor for a given @xmath18 . the simulation box is fully ionized at @xmath31 in all models . .the volume filling factor of ionized regions in the simulation at @xmath32 , 6.22 , and 5.80 , for two constant values of @xmath18 ( columns 3 and 4 ) , and a variable fraction @xmath27 ( column 4 ) that increases linearly with time from 0.01 at @xmath29 to 0.1 at @xmath33 . [ cols="<,^,^,^ " , ] [ table1 ] we are now in a position to compute the proposed statistics . we begin with @xmath34 , the mean number of neutral ( unionized ) segments of length greater than @xmath35 in a given redshift range in a line of sight ( see barkana 2002 , for a similar statistic ) . we have the spatial distribution of ionized and neutral regions in the simulation as a function of redshift , for each of our five reionization scenarios ( see table 1 ) . to compute @xmath34 we choose several random `` lines of sight '' in the output of the simulation at a given redshift . in each line of sight we identify the neutral segments and tabulate their lengths , @xmath35 , in comoving @xmath36 . a line of sight is obtained by starting from a grid point at the boundary of the simulation and going around the boundary of a rectangular slice of perimeter @xmath37 ( comoving ) until we return to the starting point . ( the shape of the path used to extract a line of sight makes no difference to our results . using a rectangular path helps reduce the chance of pattern repetition . ) this yields a total of @xmath38 lines of sight each spanning a redshift range corresponding to @xmath39 ( comoving ) . we then compute the mean @xmath34 from these lines of sight . for convenience we normalize @xmath34 to a redshift span of @xmath40 by multiplying the direct result obtained from the simulation by @xmath41 . the @xmath34 ( normalized to @xmath42 ) is shown in figure ( [ figure1 ] ) for @xmath32 ( top ) , 6.22 ( middle ) , and 5.8 ( bottom ) . the panels to the left show @xmath34 computed for @xmath23 , at these three redshifts . to the right we show curves computed with @xmath24 at @xmath32 ( top ) and @xmath21 ( middle ) , and a variable @xmath27 at @xmath31 ( bottom ) . we have also computed @xmath34 from lines of sight each of length @xmath43 passing through in the simulation box at random positions and found very similar results to those shown in the figure . in observed spectra ionized regions with large optical depths can be confused with completely unionized regions , and vice versa . by measuring ly@xmath3 absorption lower limits of about 20 on the ly@xmath2 optical depth can be obtained . in cdm - like models ionized regions with optical depth larger than this lower limit are small . a careful analysis and modeling of spectra can therefore help reduce this confusion . nevertheless to estimate the degree of the confusion , we have computed @xmath34 assuming that regions with optical depth larger than 20 are identified as unionizeds@xmath44 . the ly@xmath2 line - width and effects of peculiar velocities were also taken into account . ] . we found that in this more detailed calculation @xmath34 is shifted to smaller @xmath35 by less than a factor of 2 at large @xmath35 . at small @xmath35 , @xmath34 is reduced by a factor of less than 2 , although this could likely be reduced with a more careful analysis as suggested above . the cells of our computational grid are approximately @xmath45mpc ( comoving ) in extent . according to benson et al . ( 2002 ) the characteristic smoothing length in the igm at this redshift is approximately @xmath46mpc ( comoving ) . thus , our current simulation does not fully resolve the structure of gas in the igm . to assess the consequences of this limitation we repeated our calculations using a lower resolution computational grid ( @xmath47 cells instead of @xmath17 ) . we find that , at large @xmath35 , the lengths of neutral regions are approximately 30% smaller when the higher resolution grid is used . doubling the grid resolution to @xmath48 cells ( and therefore almost fully resolving the smoothing length ) should make little difference to our results . we also checked that noise due to the finite number of particles is unimportant for the results presented here . in addition to the distribution of neutral hydrogen , the cross - correlation , @xmath49 , requires the spatial distribution of ( potential ) sources of the ionizing photons . in real observations the distribution of neutral hydrogen is obtained from qso spectra and the positions of sources from a high redshift galaxy or qso survey . our goal here is simply to demonstrate that @xmath49 can distinguish between various models for the propagation of the ionized regions . we will therefore simply compute @xmath49 from the three dimensional distribution of neutral hydrogen in the simulation , i.e. we will not address the question of how well @xmath49 can be estimated from realistic mock observations where the neutral regions are identified in lines of sight . the simulation box is divided into a @xmath17 cubic grid . at each grid point @xmath50 we define a quantity @xmath51 to be zero if that point has been ionized and unity otherwise . we also use the cloud - in - cell ( cic ) method to derive the number density @xmath52 of galaxies from the galaxy positions in the simulation . we select galaxies on the basis of their ionizing luminosity and include only those with luminosities sufficiently high to ensure the population is fully resolved in the n - body simulation . because ionizing luminosity correlates only weakly with halo mass since it depends so strongly on the star formation rate this means we select only the most luminous sources@xmath53 , @xmath53 , and @xmath54photons / s at @xmath31 , @xmath55 and @xmath56 respectively . these sources are rare and contribute only a small fraction to the total ionizing luminosity density of the universe ( about 15% and 18% at z=6.222 and 5.80 , respectively ) . denoting the average values of @xmath57 and @xmath51 by @xmath58 and @xmath59 respectively , we define the cross - correlation , @xmath49 , as @xmath60[h(\vx+\vr)/ \bar h -1]>\ ] ] where the symbol @xmath61 implies averaging over all grid points @xmath50 . in practice the calculation of @xmath49 is done using the technique of fast fourier transforms . the results are shown in figure 2 . this figure demonstrates that @xmath49 is sensitive to the ionization model . it is positive for model c ( low density ) , almost vanishes for model d ( random spheres ) , and is negative for models a , b , and e , which ionize dense regions first . however , @xmath49 has a similar shape for all the high density models ( a , b and e ) and we expect that it will be difficult to distinguish between them in observational data . nevertheless they all are significantly different from either model c or d. so @xmath49 should successfully discriminate among low density , random ionization , and high density models . the statistic @xmath34 giving the number of neutral segments of length greater than @xmath35 for a given total length of a qso spectrum is sensitive to the filling factor and the way in which ionization proceeds . the cross correlation between candidate ionizing sources and neutral regions is less sensitive to the filling factor but is a more direct and robust probe of the propagation of the ionization fronts . in addition to qso spectra , the cross - correlation requires a sample of candidates ( galaxies and qso ) for the ionizing radiation . catalogs of galaxies and qso at high redshift are rapidly accumulating , making it possible to compute the qso - flux and galaxy - flux correlations . comparison between galaxy - flux and qso - flux correlation functions will tell us whether galaxies or qso contributed most of the ionizing radiation . current observations do not allow a robust determination of @xmath34 , the number of spectra needed to determine @xmath34 to within a given accuracy can be estimated by noting that the relative error on this function is @xmath62 , where @xmath63 is the number of observed qso spectra covering the same redshift range . nevertheless we still can make general conclusions based on the becker et . 2001 ) result , assuming that the long gunn - peterson trough they observe is indeed a signature of reionization . let us take the length of a spectrum in the ly@xmath2 forest at @xmath64 to be @xmath65 corresponding to the comoving distance between ly@xmath2 and ly@xmath3 emission lines . an inspection of figure [ figure1 ] shows that : @xmath66 a completely neutral stretch of a comoving length of @xmath5 at @xmath25 is inconsistent with a large filling factor . 2 ) the observations indicate that the chances of finding long neutral regions at @xmath67 are tiny while they are significant at higher redshift . this behavior seems inconsistent with our theoretical @xmath34 computed with constant @xmath18 . if @xmath23 then there are similar probabilities for finding long segments at @xmath29 and @xmath33 . if @xmath24 then the box is fully ionized at @xmath22 , while at @xmath29 long segments are very rare . therefore the data favor models in which there is a significant increase in the amount of ionizing radiation in the igm , either due to an increasing escape fraction over this redshift range , or a much stronger evolution in the galaxy / qso population than is predicted by our model . and , @xmath68 a model in which ionization proceeds from low to high density regions seems to be inconsistent with a @xmath69 neutral region even for escape fractions as low as @xmath23 . this research is supported by the ec rtn network `` the physics of the intergalactic medium '' . is supported by the israeli academy of science , the german israeli foundation for scientific research and development , and the technion v. p. r. fund and henri gutwirth promotion of research . is supported by the alexander von humboldt foundation and a japanese grant - in - aid for science research fund of the ministry of education , no . cgl is supported by pparc . a.n . and a.j.b wish to thank the national astronomical observatory of japan in mitaka for its hospitality and support . barkana , r. , 2001 , new astronomy , 7 , 85 benson , a.j . , nusser , a. , sugiyama , n. , and lacey c.g . , 2001 , , 320 , 153 , * bnsl * becker r.h . , fan x. , white r.l . al . _ , 2001 , , 122 , 2833 bruscoli , m. , ferrara , andrea . , fabbri , roberto . , and ciardi , b. 2000 , , 318 , 1068 ciardi , b. , ferrara , a. , governato , f. , jenkins , a. 2000 , , 314 , 611 cole s. , lacey c. g. , baugh c. m. , frenk c. s. , 2000 , to appear in mnras couchman h.m.p . , and rees m.j.r . 1986 , , 221 , 53 djorgovski , s . g. , castro , s. , stern , d. , and mahabal , a.a . 2001 , , 560 , 5 eke , v. r. , cole , s. , and frenk , c. s. , 1996 , , 282 , 263 gunn , j.e . , and peterson , b.a . 1965 , , 142 , 1633 haiman , z. , and loeb , a. 1996 , , 483 , 21 jenkins , a. , frenk , c. s. , pearce , f. r. , thomas , p. a. , colberg , j. m. , white , s. d. m. , couchman , h. m. p. , peacock , j. p. , efstathiou , g. , and nelson , a. h. 1998 , , 499 , 20 kauffmann , g. , white , s.d.m . , and guiderdoni , b. 1993 , , 264,201 leitherer , c. , ferguson , h. , heckman , t.m . , and lowenthal , j. d. 1995 , , 454 , 19 liu , g.c . , sugiyama , n. , benson , a.j . , lacey , c.g . , and nusser , a. , 2001 , , 561 , 504 madau , p. 1995 , apj , 441 , 18 miralda - escud , j. , haehnelt , m. , and rees , m.j . 2000 , , 530 , 1 sommerville , r.s . , and primack , j.r . 1999 , , 310 , 1087 theuns t. , leonard a. , efstathiou g. , pearce f. r. , thomas p. a. , 1998 , mnras , 301 , 478 vishniac , e.t . 1987 , , 322 , 597

we present predictions for two statistical measures of the hydrogen reionization process at high redshift . the first statistic is the number of neutral segments identified in spectra of high redshift qsos as a function of their length . the second is the cross - correlation of neutral regions with possible sources of ionizing radiation . these independent probes are sensitive to the topology of the ionized regions . if reionization proceeded from high to low density regions then the cross - correlation will be negative , while if voids were ionized first then we expect a positive correlation and a relatively small number of long neutral segments . we test the sensitivity of these statistics for reionization by stars in high redshift galaxies . the flux of ionizing radiation emitted from stars is estimated by identifying galaxies in an n - body simulation using a semi - analytic galaxy formation model . the spatial distribution of ionized gas is traced in various models for the propagation of the ionization fronts . a model with ionization proceeding from high to low density regions is consistent with the observations of becker et al . ( 2001 ) , while models in which ionization begins in the lowest density regions appear to be inconsistent with the present data .

astro-ph0511544

the sample is composed of 70 archival _ hubble space telescope _ ( _ hst _ ) images of low - redshift qsos . they have redshifts between @xmath2 and total ( host plus nucleus ) absolute magnitudes brighter than @xmath3 . furthermore , they must have been observed with the _ hst _ s wide - field planetary camera 2 ( wfpc2 ) , using broad - band filters , and have images publicly available in the _ hst _ archives as of 1999 . this brings our sample to 70 qsos . rather than restrict our study to a specific class of qsos , we impose no physical criteria on the qsos beyond those of magnitude and redshift . thus we are able to study a broad range of properties and draw general conclusions . the images are reduced and the physical parameters fitted as described by hamilton et al . for our principal components analysis ( pca ) , we use a restricted sample of those qsos for which we have all of the following parameters : @xmath4 , @xmath5 , @xmath6 , and @xmath7 , where @xmath7 is the effective surface magnitude of the galactic bulge . we further require that each qso have a modeled , spheroidal bulge ( the entire galaxy , in the case of elliptical hosts ) . these qualifications restrict the sample to 42 qsos . we can perform two pcas , an optical one using @xmath4 , @xmath8 , and @xmath7 as the parameters , and an x - ray one that substitutes @xmath9 for the nuclear luminosity . from the optical pca performed on this sample of 42 objects , we find that 96.1% of the variance can be explained with just the first two principal axes , and therefore the qsos mostly lie in a plane within this parameter space . this we consider to be a fundamental plane ( fp ) for qsos . for the corresponding x - ray results , the first two principal axes explain 95.2% of the variance in the sample , and we find here an x - ray qso fundamental plane . the individual subsamples of qsos ( radio - loud or radio - quiet , with spiral or elliptical hosts , and all combinations of these ) are also examined in this way , and they show fundamental planes , as well . we obtain the optical and x - ray formulae for the full sample s fundamental plane : @xmath10 @xmath11 views of the optical and x - ray fundamental planes , with the qso data points superimposed , are displayed in figure [ fig : fp - phys ] . note that the host properties describe the horizontal and the nuclear luminosity the vertical in these plots . figure [ fig : fp - rms ] illustrates the precision of the qso fundamental plane in both forms , with the plane plotted against the measured host sizes . its highest precision is found when solving for @xmath8 . the fundamental plane for qsos shows a relationship between the nuclear and host features that goes beyond the simple ( and weak ) correlation of nuclear and host luminosities . this behavior may be connected to other , known relations between the objects . for example , there is already a well - studied fundamental plane for normal , elliptical galaxies ( djorgovski & davis 1987 ; dressler et al . 1987 ) that incorporates galaxy size , @xmath6 , central velocity dispersion , @xmath12 , and effective surface magnitude , @xmath7 . let us take a @xmath13-band measurement of the normal galaxy fundamental plane ( scodeggio et al . 1998 ) , @xmath14 . the ratio of the coefficients of @xmath8 to @xmath7 differs by about 37% between the qso optical fundamental plane and the normal galaxy fp , and the qso x - ray fp shows a 34% difference . still , there is a formal similarity between the qso and normal fundamental planes , which might point to a link between the host galaxy s central velocity dispersion and the nuclear luminosity of the qso . this could derive from the fueling mechanism of qsos , if the movement of gas to the center of the galaxy and the black hole is related to the velocity dispersion . it is therefore tempting to try to derive the qso fundamental plane directly from the elliptical galaxy fundamental plane , but we find two problems with this approach , both arising from the relation of black hole mass to nuclear luminosity . using the velocity dispersion to black hole mass relation of merritt & ferrarese ( 2001 ) , @xmath15 we can put the elliptical galaxy fundamental plane in terms of black hole mass . using the observed ( but weak ) correlation between black hole mass and nuclear luminosity in our sample , @xmath16 and @xmath17 , we obtain @xmath18 @xmath19 these are our attempts to derive the qso optical fundamental plane from the normal galaxy fp . the optical form differs from the actual qso fp , equation ( [ equ : oall - physical ] ) , completely outside the propagated errors , but the x - ray form is within the errors of equation ( [ equ : xall - physical ] ) . but any derivation of the qso fundamental plane has an additional problem . as mentioned before , the qso fundamental plane for the full sample is composed of individual fps of the several subsamples . some subsample fps actually slope in the opposite direction from the overall qso fp . for example , in the optical form , the fp of radio - quiets in elliptical hosts slopes in the opposite direction . and in the x - ray form , the radio - quiet subsamples slope oppositely from the overall sample . yet these differences can not be accounted for by different correlations of nuclear luminosity with black hole mass . the poor correlation of black hole mass with nuclear luminosity lies in contrast with the relatively thin qso fundamental plane . furthermore , woo & urry ( 2002 ) suggest that the apparent correlations between black hole mass and nuclear luminosity are merely artifacts of sample selection . regardless of how we take this interpretation , the relationship between black hole mass and nuclear luminosity remains the missing link in any derivation of the qso fundamental plane . the insight into the origins of this new fundamental plane relationship might come from the comparison of the qso subsample fps . the thickness of the overall qso fundamental plane appears partly to be the result of the superposition of the subsamples planes . because the qso fp mathematically describes a link between the host and the nucleus , it seems reasonable to suppose that the slope of the plane depends on the physical nature of this link . the fueling mechanism at a qso s core would seem to be the most directly related to this , depending on how we define `` fueling mechanism . '' we could encompass within this term the details of the structure and dynamics of the accretion disk , as well as question of whether the qso is efficiently or inefficiently fueled . it is intriguing that as we change from one class to another , the fundamental plane essentially pivots about an axis , so the differences are mostly reduced to a single dimension , the slope ( or gradient ) relative to the @xmath7@xmath8 plane . the gradient directions , projected onto the @xmath7@xmath8 plane , are almost all either aligned ( or anti - aligned , for those with opposite slope ) . the optical subsample gradient directions are never more than 3.8 degrees away from that of the full sample , and in the x - ray form , they never exceed a 6.4 degree deviation . radio - loudness has the strongest effect on the slopes . in the x - ray form , the subsample fps are almost evenly divided between those aligned with the full sample and those anti - aligned . in the optical form , only radio - quiets in elliptical hosts tilt opposite to the full sample . this effect is interesting because we are seeing a stark difference between the radio - loud and radio - quiet nuclei in the hosts of the same morphology . it would be interesting to find if the different qso fp orientations described above come about from different fueling mechanisms that might be found in the various subsamples . we see , for instance , that radio - quiet and radio - loud qsos are characterized by very different slopes in their x - ray fps , but the understanding of what makes these qso types differ is still too limited to speculate further here . in our ongoing research , we are expanding the fundamental plane study to other types of agn . we can then compare their fp orientations with those of the different qso subsamples , which may teach us more about the physics underlying the qso fundamental plane . we should ask if lower luminosity classes of agn ( such as seyferts or llagn ) also have fundamental planes of this sort . if they do , how do they compare with that of qsos ? we can imagine four possibilities : 1 . they share the same fundamental plane as qsos . this would indicate that agn power scales with the host properties , even across agn types , and would support some form of unification . the plane is parallel to that of qsos , but shifted to lower nuclear luminosities . this would show that these host properties do nt determine the agn class , and a given galaxy could host different types . the plane is tilted with respect to that of qsos . then the fundamental plane slope would be characteristic of the agn type , possibly supporting the idea that the slope is tied to the accretion mechanism . 4 . there is no fundamental plane whatsoever . in that case , this type of fundamental plane would be a unique property of qsos . high - luminosity objects would be more closely connected with their host properties .

we present results from an archival study of 70 medium - redshift qsos observed with the wide field planetary camera 2 on board the _ hubble space telescope_. the qsos have magnitudes @xmath0 ( total nuclear plus host light ) and redshifts @xmath1 . a close relationship between qso host and nucleus is found by examining multiple parameters at once . a principal components analysis shows that 3 nuclear and host properties are related in a kind of fundamental plane : nuclear luminosity and the size and effective surface magnitude of the bulge . using optical nuclear luminosity , this relationship explains 95.9% of the variance in the overall sample , while 94.9% of the variance is accounted for if we use x - ray nuclear luminosity . the form of this qso fundamental plane shows similarities to the well - studied fundamental plane of elliptical galaxies , and we examine the possible relationship between them as well as the difficulties involved in establishing this connection . the key to the relationship might lie in the fueling mechanism of the central black hole . quasars , galaxies : active 98.54.-h

1608.07766

experimental advances in generating strongly interacting photons opened the opportunity to explore various many - body quantum phenomena in a new context @xcite . photonic systems are unique in the sense that it is naturally an open quantum system where the adding and destroying of photons can be accomplished by drive and dissipation in a controlled way . thus it is an ideal system to study many outstanding questions on open systems dynamics , dissipative phase transitions @xcite and the effects of interactions in a dissipative environment . the simplest model to study strongly interacting bosons on a lattice is the celebrated bose - hubbard model where atoms have on - site interactions and can hop across lattices @xcite . there have been several recent proposals @xcite on achieving this model with photons and open systems , such as with photons in coupled cavity arrays , superconducting circuit qed and polaritons . with added drive and dissipation , the bose - hubbard model does not exhibit superfluid or mott insulator phases but gives rise to mixed state nonequilibrium steady states and phases @xcite , the nature and generation of which are not fully understood . a starting point for understanding the complex dynamics of driven dissipative photonic cavity arrays can be a two - site model . such a two - site driven dissipative nonlinear model may be realized with systems such as two coupled photon cavities @xcite , circuit qed systems @xcite and two coupled micropillars @xcite . this system is also referred to as a photonic molecule @xcite , dimer or a double well . for the closed system , the physics of double well has been studied in great detail @xcite , giving rise to phenomena such as the josephson effect , matter wave interference and self - trapped and symmetry breaking states , among others . for open systems , studies of two coupled cavities have appeared in several contexts in both theory @xcite and experiment @xcite . for an end - driven cavity , studies focused on the topics of unconventional photon blockade @xcite and multi - stability @xcite , among others . for symmetrically driven cavities , studies appeared on quantum correlations @xcite , classical to quantum phase transitions for a jaynes - cummings dimer @xcite , and symmetry breaking for incoherent drives @xcite , among others . in this article , we explore the physics of two coupled nonlinear cavities in a dissipative setting where both sites are driven coherently and symmetrically . we perform semiclassical and quantum analysis of the system investigating the complex interplay of many competing terms such as hopping , interaction , drive , dissipation and detuning . in a semiclassical treatment , we show that the nonequilibrium steady states have asymmetric number density in the two cavities in addition to the expected symmetry preserving states . these states are the driven - dissipative analog of the closed system double well symmetry breaking or self - trapped states @xcite with a fundamental difference that these are not minimum energy states but long - time steady states resulting from the competition in drive and dissipation . these can be understood from the bistability of a single driven cavity ; when two cavities are coupled with small but nonzero tunneling , the low density and high density bistable branches of a single cavity are hybridized to form two symmetry breaking steady states with unequal photon occupations in the two cavities . beyond a critical coupling and drive , the symmetry breaking states do not form . we analyze the occurrence and stability of the semiclassical solutions , finding that there can be up to nine solutions , a maximum of four of which are stable containing pairs of symmetry breaking and symmetry preserving states in a multistable region . we delineate a phase diagram for the symmetry broken states in the parameter space of drive and tunneling . and inter - cavity mode overlap contributes to tunneling with strength @xmath0 . the system is coupled to a markovian bath and photons can decay or leak out with rate @xmath1 . coherent pumping ( @xmath2 ) replenishes the photons . we treat the case when drive and dissipation are the same for both cavities . two coupled cavities are the simplest setting for an array of coupled cavities where the interplay of dissipation , drive and interaction plays a crucial role that are being investigated in a wider context.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] we then study the system by solving the full quantum mechanical master equation and using the method of quantum trajectories @xcite . in a full quantum treatment , when quantum fluctuations are taken into account , the symmetry breaking states are no longer seen , similar to the case of single - cavity bistable states @xcite . however , in quantum trajectory simulations of the dynamics , we show that quantum jump statistics of number differences reveal the presence of underlying semiclassical bistability indicating the presence of symmetry breaking states . finally , we present a set of analytical expressions for the steady state correlation functions using the complex p - representation @xcite expressing the master equation in the form of fokker - planck equation . the solutions work for small tunnel couplings ; we discuss the regime of validity of the solutions in the parameter space . the article is organized as follows . in section i , we introduce the model . in section ii , we present semiclassical analysis and analyze the driven - dissipative symmetry breaking states . in section iii , we present quantum trajectory analysis and full quantum treatment of the master equation . in section iv , we derive analytical solutions for the steady state correlation functions , and summarize our results in section v. we consider two cavities with kerr nonlinearity @xcite that are coupled by tunneling @xcite . the cavities are coherently driven in a dissipative setting , with both drive and dissipation acting equally on both sites . [ fig : schematic ] shows a schematic of the set up . the system can be described by the following hamiltonian @xmath3 where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are the annihilation operators for the two cavities labelled @xmath6 and @xmath7 . here @xmath0 is the inter - cavity tunneling strength , @xmath8 is the anharmonicity or the nonlinear kerr - type interaction strength , @xmath2 is the driving field for cavity 1 and 2 , and @xmath9 is the detuning , after the rotating wave approximation for the drive term . @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the cavity resonance frequency and driving frequency , respectively . . the four steady states are reached with four different initial values of @xmath12.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] for our open system , there can be photon losses induced by spontaneous decay or cavity leakage . in the approximation that the system is weakly coupled to a markovian bath , the dynamics of the density matrix can be modeled by a quantum master equation in the lindblad form @xmath13+\gamma [ 2 ( { \hat a}_1 { \hat \rho } { \hat a}_1^{\dagger}+{\hat a}_2 { \hat \rho } { \hat a}_2^{\dagger } ) \nonumber \\ & & -({\hat a}_1^{\dagger } { \hat a}_1+{\hat a}_2^{\dagger}{\hat a}_2 ) { \hat \rho } - { \hat \rho}({\hat a}_1^{\dagger } { \hat a}_1+{\hat a}_2^{\dagger } { \hat a}_2)],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath1 is the dissipation rate in each cavity . we set @xmath14 throughout . ignoring quantum fluctuations , the mean field amplitudes for the field operators are @xmath15 . we assume @xmath16 and @xmath17 , where @xmath18 are occupation numbers and @xmath19 are phases for the two cavities , and @xmath20 . in the semiclassical approximation the correlation functions factorize , and the equations of motion become @xmath21 here @xmath22 and @xmath23 . we find the steady states of these equations by solving the four coupled differential equations eq . [ eq : eqofmotion ] , examining the long - time dynamics for different sets of initial conditions . for most values of parameters we get a single steady state . however , for the value of parameters @xmath24 , @xmath25 , we get four different steady states as depicted in fig . [ fig : dynamics ] showing their long time dynamics . we take @xmath25 for all our calculations in this article , essentially giving other parameters in units of dissipation . two of the steady states have equal number of photon occupations in the two cavities as in figs . [ fig : dynamics](a ) and ( b ) , one with low occupations and the other with higher occupations . in addition to these , we get steady states where the photon occupations are different in the two cavities as shown in figs . [ fig : dynamics](c ) and ( d ) . this pair of states are asymmetric , mirror images of each other , and localized more in one of the cavities . these states are the driven - dissipative analog of the symmetry breaking states of nonlinear josephson coupled junctions as observed in bec and with photons @xcite in a closed system . we call them _ driven - dissipative symmetry breaking states_. unlike the single cavity semiclassical solutions , the phases here are important as the relative phase between the two cavities can not be gauged away . for the symmetry preserving states we find @xmath26 , and for the symmetry breaking states @xmath27 . another method we employ to find the steady state solutions is to set @xmath28 and find roots of the four coupled equations : @xmath29 here we have four equations with four unknowns @xmath30 and @xmath31 that are real . we assume @xmath32 and solve for the variables @xmath33 which is then transformed back into numbers and phases of the two cavities as @xmath34 . the solution set contains both real and complex solutions . there is only one real solution for most of the parameter values ; this is the regime where there is no bistability . for certain parameter values , there can be more than one real solutions , up to a maximum of nine and a maximum of four of which are stable . the stable solutions that we obtain with this method match with what we obtain from the previous method as steady states of long - term dynamics starting with different initial conditions . ) plane for @xmath35 and different values of @xmath36 , and @xmath37 respectively . the area labelled 1 has one symmetry preserving steady state , 2 has two symmetry preserving states in a bistable region while 4 has two symmetry breaking and two symmetry preserving states . ( b ) shows @xmath38 and @xmath39 as a function of @xmath0 for a fixed @xmath40 . ( c ) shows @xmath38 and @xmath39 as a function of @xmath2 for a fixed @xmath41 . these depict how the symmetry breaking states appear and disappear as a function of tunnelling and drive . we see that there is a critical @xmath0 value beyond which the symmetry breaking states do not appear.,scaledwidth=42.0% ] we find stability by introducing small fluctuations to the steady state , obtaining linearized equations for the fluctuations and examining their eigenvalues . introducing small fluctuations about the steady state @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 here the stability matrix @xmath45 is following : @xmath46 where @xmath47 . when the real part of the eigenvalues of @xmath45 are positive the solution is stable . furthermore , we look at the determinant and trace , as done in ref . @xcite , for which the hurwitz criterion for stability requires that the trace and determinant of this matrix is nonzero and positive for stable eigenvalues . we can further analyze the steady state equations eq . [ eq : eqsteadystate ] to get two state equations @xmath48 eqs . [ eq : eqdrive ] capture the parameter dependence for both the symmetry preserving and symmetry breaking semiclassical steady states . for symmetry preserving states , when @xmath49 , @xmath26 and @xmath50 , this simplifies to one equation @xmath51 further taking the limit @xmath52 reproduces the single - cavity result of drummond and walls @xcite @xmath53 eq . [ eq : singlecavity ] is the bistability state equation for a single cavity . the extension of this to a coupled cavity gives us the state equations eqs . [ eq : eqdrive ] and [ eq : coupledbistability ] , expressing the dependence of @xmath0 in going from a single - cavity bistability to the coupled cavity bistability ( eq . [ eq : coupledbistability ] ) and multistability ( eq . [ eq : eqdrive ] ) . the symmetry breaking states are borne out of the bistable behavior of a single cavity . we can understand this by introducing an infinitesimal coupling to the two cavities as illustrated in fig [ fig : sbstates ] . as soon as we turn on @xmath0 , two bistable branches split into four steady states whose number occupations suggest that they are made up of the @xmath54 and @xmath55 density bistable states of individual cavities in this fashion - @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 . the @xmath58 and @xmath59 states are the symmetry breaking states . for a single cavity , there are three solutions to the semiclassical equations ; two are stable and one is unstable . coupling the two cavities gives rise to a maximum of nine solutions in some regime ; out of which a maximum of four are stable . there are regions of one , two or four stable solutions . the regime of four stable solutions is the multistable region where two are symmetry preserving states and two are symmetry breaking states . [ fig : sbstates](c ) shows both stable and unstable branch of the solutions marked in blue and red respectively . a pair of symmetry breaking states never appear in isolation but always come with a pair of symmetric states . in fig . [ fig : phasediag ] we analyze the steady state number and phase differences between the two cavities and delineate a phase diagram in the @xmath60 phase . [ fig : phasediag](b ) shows the number difference @xmath38 as a function of @xmath0 for a fixed @xmath2 , and we see that the self - trapped states appear as soon as we turn on @xmath0 and disappears for a critical @xmath0 . here the positive and negative values of @xmath38 represent the pair of symmetry breaking states while the symmetric states are on zero of the @xmath61-axis . similarly , fig . [ fig : phasediag](c ) shows the dependence on @xmath2 for a fixed @xmath0 . with many of such slices for fixed @xmath2 and @xmath0 , we can now draw a phase diagram for the presence of symmetry broken states in the tunneling - drive ( @xmath60 ) plane for @xmath35 and different interactions ( a ) @xmath36 and ( d ) @xmath62 . the shades differentiate three regions with one , two and four stable steady states . the region labelled @xmath6 has one stable symmetry preserving steady state . the region labelled @xmath7 is a bistable regime with two symmetry preserving states which continues to grow as @xmath0 and @xmath2 increases . the boundaries of the bistability region can be obtained from the analytic expression eq . [ eq : coupledbistability ] which basically gives the turning points for the coupled cavity bistability in a similar way as can be derived for a single cavity @xcite . the boundaries of bistability region are shown in figs . [ fig : phasediag](a ) , ( d ) , having a near linear relationship in @xmath2 and @xmath0 . the region labelled 4 and shaded dark blue is the region of multistability with two symmetry breaking states in addition to two symmetry preserving states . the blue region shrinks and straightens upward as we increase the nonlinearity @xmath8 as shown in fig . [ fig : phasediag](d ) . the characteristics of this region are intimately connected to the whole parameter space of detuning , nonlinearity and that of bistability . we note that the symmetry breaking region always stays inside the bistability region , and therefore can not go beyond the bistable phase boundaries to the right , where the slope a higher slope as @xmath8 increases . as a function of @xmath0 , the phase diagram shows a reentrant behavior as we can see in fig . [ fig : phasediag](a ) near @xmath63 . in our model we do not break any symmetry of the system externally . yet we get steady states which break the symmetry of the system and a stability diagram where there are multiple states for a single value of drive . for coherent pumping as we treat here , these driven dissipative symmetry breaking has not yet been observed . we note that the recent observation of spontaneous mirror symmetry breaking in coupled photonic - crystal nanolasers @xcite used incoherent pumping for which the mechanism and results are different in that the symmetry breaking states are not related to bistability as in our case . in terms of the bifurcation properties , unlike the supercritical pitchfork bifurfactions in experiment @xcite , we get here subcritical bifurcation @xcite as associated with bistable behavior . pumping just one end cavity excites the system modes in a different way and gives rise to multistability @xcite , which has been recently observed in photonic microcavities @xcite . creating an external phase asymmetry such as in drive ( driving two sites with @xmath2 and @xmath64 ) or tunnelling ( using @xmath0 instead of @xmath65 in the bose - hubbard hamiltonian ) , also gives rise to symmetry broken states , whose criticality and entanglement has been investigated recently @xcite . analysis from the perspectives of semiclassical discrete nonlinear schrdinger equation ( dnls ) for lattices and soliton physics have been reported in ref . to understand more features of the driven dissipative bose - hubbard dimer , here we analyze the problem quantum mechanically taking into account the quantum fluctuations and using two methods first , we examine the dynamics by numerically solving the lindblad master equation , and second , we do a quantum trajectory or monte carlo wavefunction analysis @xcite . in fig . [ fig : trajectory](b ) we show the semiclassical multistability diagram which exhibits up to four steady states for a single value of the drive . we integrate the lindblad master equation eq . 2 to find the quantum steady states which we find to be unique for each value of the drive . occupation ( @xmath66 ) and normalized second - order correlator ( @xmath67 ) are shown in the fig . [ fig : trajectory](b ) as a function of drive , where @xmath68 . in the multistability region , @xmath67 exhibits a peak which is due to the presence of enhanced quantum fluctuations that cause the underlying semiclassical multistability . this is similar to the case of single cavity bistability @xcite . however , the @xmath67 signatures only indicate that this is a region of bistability or multistability without giving us any clue about the presence of sysmmetry breaking states . to reveal this feature , we perform quantum trajectory analysis below . quantum trajectory method provides exact results for physical observables under the ensemble averaging of trajectories of wavefunctions . we specifically would like to find out how the quantum jumps occur in the multi - stable region and whether they reveal any signature of the underlying semiclassical symmetry braking solutions . first we pick a specific driving field @xmath40 to run the quantum trajectory simulations . simulation results are analyzed in fig . [ fig : trajectory ] . panel ( a ) shows a histogram of the quantum jumps as they happened as a function of the occupation numbers of one cavity plotted vertically along the semiclassical multistability diagram . the two peaks of the histogram coincide with the lower and upper branches of the multistability diagram as expected for bistability . now if we investigate the dynamics of @xmath69 and @xmath70 separately , a typical such evolution for a single trajectory is given in fig . [ fig : trajectory](c ) . this shows clearly that the photons spend most of the time fluctuating near the two bistable branches . panel ( d ) shows a magnified region where the two cavities have unequal populations during the evolution . a histogram of jumps in the variable of photon population difference ( @xmath71 ) for @xmath40 is shown in panel ( f ) . the distribution in ( f ) not only shows a single peak at @xmath72 , but also broad side peaks at @xmath73 . for comparison , [ fig : trajectory](e ) and ( g ) show the statistics for quantum jumps outside the multistable region at @xmath74 and @xmath75 respectively , showing single lorentzian peaks at @xmath72 . the highest peaks centered at @xmath72 correspond to the jumps related to symmetry preserving states , whereas , we interpret the broad side peaks of the distribution originating from the symmetry breaking states . in our model , the symmetry breaking states always coexist with the symmetric states . so the side peaks are always overshadowed by a prominent central peak . as for a quantum signature of driven - dissipative symmetry breaking states , we show here that a typical quantum trajectory reveals this feature . recent experiments @xcite have used homodyne detection of photocurrents to detect the quantum trajectory underlying a bistability , and hence , the observation of quantum features of dimer symmetry breaking states should be within experimental reach . analytic solutions for steady states of driven - dissipative systems are very rare . for a single cavity with kerr nonlinearity , analytic solutions for the steady - state was presented by drummond and walls in ref . since then , there have been a number of instances where analytic solutions have been obtained for various scenarios in a single - cavity @xcite . drummond and walls @xcite used the complex p - representation to obtain a fokker - planck equation and present closed - form analytic expressions for the correlation functions . we apply a similar technique here for the two - coupled nonlinear cavities and present analytic solutions for the correlation functions expressed as a series . the solutions are applicable for small @xmath0 and deviate slowly from the exact numerical results as @xmath0 is increased . considering the fact that no analytic solutions are known for coupled cavities , we present our investigations here which may find applications in the study of weak coupling limit and in finding an improved solution . a short derivation is provided below . in comparison to the single cavity case @xcite , the additional term in the dimer hamiltonian is the hopping term , @xmath76 . after a rotating wave approximation , the contribution of this term to the master equation dynamics becomes : @xmath77 $ ] . now the full master equation with kerr nonlinearity is @xmath78-i\frac{u}{2}[{\hat a}_{1}^{\dagger 2}{\hat a}_{1}^{2}+{\hat a}_{2}^{\dagger 2 } { \hat a}_{2}^{2},{\hat \rho}]+[f { \hat a}_{1}^{\dagger}+f^ { * } { \hat a}_{1},{\hat \rho}]+[f { \hat a}_{2}^{\dagger}+f^ { * } { \hat a}_{2},{\hat \rho}]\nonumber\\ & & + ij[{\hat a}_{1}^{\dagger}{\hat a}_{2}+{\hat a}_{2}^{\dagger}{\hat a}_{1},{\hat \rho}]+\gamma[2{\hat a}_{1}{\hat \rho } { \hat a}_{1}^{\dagger}-{\hat \rho } { \hat a}_{1}^{\dagger}{\hat a}_{1}-{\hat a}_{1}^{\dagger}{\hat a}_{1}{\hat \rho}]+\gamma [ 2{\hat a}_{2}{\hat \rho } { \hat a}_{2}^{\dagger}-{\hat \rho } { \hat a}_{2}^{\dagger}{\hat a}_{2}-{\hat a}_{2}^{\dagger}{\hat a}_{2}{\hat \rho}].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the contribution to the @xmath79 function dynamics from the hopping term is @xmath80 where @xmath81 . now the fokker - planck equation for the @xmath79 function is given as @xmath82 where the drift matrix and the diffusion vector respectively are @xmath83 in order to have a specific form of analytic solutions for the steady states of the fokker - planck equation , the potential conditions must be satisfied @xcite . now let us check whether the potential conditions , @xmath84 , are satisfied for this multidimensional fokker - planck equation . here @xmath85 denoting @xmath86 as @xmath87 respectively , we find @xmath88 , and @xmath89 . these four potential conditions are satisfied . however , two potential conditions are not satisfied : @xmath90 and @xmath91 . here @xmath92 if @xmath93 and @xmath94 if @xmath95 . they are also approximately satisfied in the limit @xmath96 is small . we present the analytic solutions under this restricted condition . the steady - state @xmath79 function is @xmath97.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can rewrite the steady state @xmath79 function @xmath98,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath99 , and @xmath100 . we now get the analytic expression for any order of correlations . the zeroth order correlator or the normalization integral is @xmath101 first order on - site correlation function ( occupation ) is @xmath102 and the second order on - site correlation function is @xmath103 , @xmath35 , @xmath41 . for these set of parameters , our analytic expressions give a very good match with the exact numerics for the first and second order correlation functions @xmath66 and @xmath104 shown in ( a ) . for small drives @xmath2 , the normalized second order correlation @xmath67 however deviates . please see the discussions in the texts for explanations . ( b ) shows comparisons for a fixed @xmath63 and varying coupling @xmath0 . we find that for small values of @xmath0 the solutions are comparable but deviates slowly as we go to higher @xmath0.,scaledwidth=42.0% ] a comparison of the results of the analytic solutions and numerical solutions of the master equation is shown in fig . [ fig : compare ] . in fig . [ fig : compare](a ) , for the set of parameters used , it is clear that the numeric and analytic results match very well for occupations @xmath66 and second - order correlation @xmath105 . for small values of drive , however , the normalized second - order correlator @xmath106 shows a deviation . this is due to the fact that for this specific value of parameters , slight deviations in @xmath105 in the numerator and @xmath107 in the denominator enhances the discrepancies when @xmath66 is very small . the mismatch could also be due to the potential condition not satisfied in that region , as discussed earlier . in fig . [ fig : compare](b ) we show comparisons for increasing @xmath0 for a fixed @xmath2 , and find deviations that come from the potential conditions not being satisfied . for increasing coupling the solutions deviate more and more , being comparable for small values of @xmath0 . unlike the single cavity case , the series here do not sum to a closed form hypergeometric function . instead the computation involves a series involving six variables leading to difficulties in the convergence of the series . due to the properties of the gamma function , sometimes the series converges fast . more specifically , @xmath108 increases very fast with @xmath109 when @xmath109 is positive . thus if we have the the detuning positive ( i.e. the real part of @xmath110 and @xmath111 positive ) , the summation can converge for indices ( @xmath112 ) up to around 10 . if we have the detuning negative , we may need to compute up to a bigger index to make the series converge . we have checked the results for convergence for indices up to 30 . for a smaller ratio of @xmath96 as in our example fig . [ fig : compare ] , convergence is faster . it is conceivable that we can use monte carlo sampling technique to perform this multidimensional sum . a more fundamental issue is the regime of validity of the analytic expressions originating from the potential conditions as discussed earlier : @xmath90 and @xmath91 . the potential conditions are approximately satisfied when @xmath96 is small . from our investigation we find that when @xmath96 is small , as shown in fig . [ fig : compare ] , the analytical results are comparable to the numerical . the potential conditions are also satisfied when @xmath93 , which involves both the occupation and phase in the two cavities to be equal . in the regime where quantum fluctuations are important such as in the bistability and the symmetry breaking region , @xmath113 and the potential conditions are more likely to be violated . analytical results are rare for a driven - dissipative system especially when going beyond a single cavity . the results presented here , although with a restricted regime of validity , are therefore important in our view . the analytic solutions presented here can be extended to multiple cavities . we investigated the physics of two coupled nonlinear cavities in a lossy setting where both sites are driven coherently and equally . we performed semiclassical , quantum and analytical analyses of the system . in a semiclassical treatment , we find that the nonequilibrium steady states can have asymmetric number density in the two cavities which appear in addition to the symmetry preserving states . these states are the driven - dissipative analog of the double well self - trapped or symmetry broken states . their appearance can be understood from the bistability of a single driven cavity ; when two cavities are coupled , the low density and high density branches of single cavity bistable states hybridize to form two symmetry breaking states with unequal photon occupations in the two cavities . we examined the properties and stability of the semiclassical solutions , finding that there can be up to nine solutions of which a maximum of four are stable , giving rise to a pair of symmetry preserving and a pair of symmetry breaking states . we presented a phase diagram for these states in the tunneling - drive space . we further studied the system using the method of quantum trajectories and by solving the full quantum mechanical master equation . in a full quantum treatment , when quantum fluctuations are taken into account , the coupled cavity bistable self - trapped states no longer appear , a case similar to that of single - cavity bistability . however , in a quantum trajectory analysis of the dynamics , we found that a histogram of quantum jumps in number differences reveal the presence of semiclassical bistability with strong indication of symmetry breaking states . finally , we presented analytical solutions for the steady state correlation functions using the complex p - representation and forming a fokker - planck equation . we pointed out the regime of validity and limitations of this analytic solution . coupled cavity arrays are an exciting system to explore a host of important phenomena such as nonequilibrium dynamics , open system physics , strongly interacting photons and quantum many - body physics . we took the simplest coupled cavity model of a dimer and analyzed it using several different methods . the physics explored here and our predictions are within experimental reach in coupled cavity dimers , in terms of multistable states and single trajectory measurements . besides fundamental physics , bistability and dimers have applications in optical memories and quantum correlation devices . the insights we gained on semiclassical and quantum nature of photons for two coupled cavities can also be useful for an array . we thank howard carmichael , ryan wilson and christian ciuti for helpful discussions . we knowledge the support from afosr - muri , onr - yip , aro - muri , nsf - pfc at the jqi , and the sloan foundation . mh thanks the kavli institute of theoretical physics ( kitp ) at santa barbara for hospitality . kitp is supported by nsf phy11 - 25915 .

we investigate two coupled nonlinear cavities that are coherently driven in a dissipative environment . we perform semiclassical , numerical and analytical quantum studies of this dimer model when both cavities are symmetrically driven . in the semiclassical analysis , we find steady - state solutions with different photon occupations in two cavities . such states can be considered analogs of the closed system double well symmetry breaking states . we analyze the occurrence and properties of these localized states in the system parameter space and examine how the symmetry breaking states , in form of a bistable pair , are associated to the single cavity bistable behavior . in a full quantum calculation of the master equation dynamics that includes quantum fluctuations , the symmetry breaking states and bistability disappear due to the quantum fluctuations . in quantum trajectory picture , we observe enhanced quantum jumps and switching which indicate the presence of the underlying semiclassical symmetry breaking states . finally , we present a set of analytical solutions for the steady state correlation functions using the complex p - representation and discuss its regime of validity .

cond-mat0006287

the transport of fluids through geological media such as hydrocarbon and water reservoirs involves a combination of flow through the microscopic pore space of the rock itself and flows through macroscopic channels such as fractures . the first case is relatively well understood , at least in principle @xcite , by means of models which treat the pore space as a random network , and then use effective medium or percolation concepts for the transport . fractures are typically modeled as simple straight - sided channels , with a cubic relation between fluid flux and average aperture , and a challenging problem is to understand the dynamics of flow in a macroscopic fracture network @xcite . typically the surface of a single fracture appears fairly smooth , aside from some small - scale superficially random roughness , and poiseuille flow in a straight channel is the obvious model for fluid flow . however , more careful analysis @xcite shows that common geological fractures in fact have correlated , self - affine fractal surfaces . the roughness exponent , whose precise definition is recalled below , is usually found @xcite to be close to 0.8 , surprisingly insensitive to the material and the fracturing process . ( other values may arise from intergranular effects @xcite . ) the aim of this paper is to study the permeability of single self - affine two - dimensional fractures . we shall see that it is possible to obtain general analytic expressions in two limiting cases , where the roughness associated with the fracture surface is either small or large compared to the mean aperture . the theoretical predictions will be supported by numerical simulations , using the lattice boltzmann method , which of course can address the case of intermediate sized roughness as well . in subsequent work , we will consider the fully three dimensional case , and go on to consider more general transport processes in fractures , involving both passive tracers and finite - sized suspended particles . complimentary experimental studies on laboratory samples of fractured rock are in progress elsewhere @xcite . to the extent that the fluctuations in the height are small compared to the aperture width , the effect on permeability is modest , and we will obtain small corrections to the usual cubic law , but the effects on other transport processes are much more significant . for example , passive tracer dispersion is very sensitive to the presence of any slow zones in the velocity field , and even uncorrelated roughness leads to significant long - time tails @xcite . similarly , the deposition and erosion of solid particles from a surface is sensitive to the local shear stress , which in turn can change dramatically as a surface roughens . in the opposite extreme of a very narrow fracture , the flow field changes qualitatively as the fluid winds through a highly irregular channel . aside from the challenge of estimating the permeability of difficult geometry in terms of its statistical characteristics , there are further effects arising from the fact that the two sides of the fracture originate from a single crack . in the fractal case , the spatial correlations between the two sides of a fracture lead to velocity field correlations , which again strongly affect tracer motion @xcite . the latter references made use of a very approximate velocity field , obtained in the lubrication limit , and one of the motivations of this paper is to examine the validity of the lubrication approximation for the velocity field . the organization of this paper is as follows . we first recall some basic facts about self - affine surfaces , and give the algorithm used to generate them numerically , and also explain the lattice boltzmann method used for the numerical simulations . we then consider the case of fractures with a wide average aperture , obtain a perturbative estimate for the permeability , and test it numerically . we then turn to narrow fractures , first in the case where the two sides are simply displaced normally to the mean fracture plane , and secondly when there is a lateral shift as well . finally , we summarize the results , and indicate the next steps we briefly review the mathematical characterization of self - affinity , and its implementation in this paper . we consider a rock surface without overhangs , whose height is given by a by a single - valued function @xmath0 , where the coordinates @xmath1 and @xmath2 lie in the mean plane of the fracture . self - affine surfaces @xcite display scale invariance with different dilation ratios along different spatial directions , remaining unchanged under the rescaling @xmath3 here we consider disordered media , so these scaling laws apply only in an ensemble or spatial average sense . experiment indicates that for many materials isotropy can be assumed in the mean plane , implying that there is only one non - trivial exponent relating the dilation ratio in the mean plane to the scaling in the perpendicular direction , _ i.e. _ , @xmath4 , and @xmath5 , with @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the roughness or hurst exponent @xcite . we assume that the process of fracturing the rock is `` clean '' , in the sense that the rock breaks so as separate along one single valued surface without subsequent deformation and without producing loose interstitial material . we shall emphasize two complimentary limiting situations , in which the two surfaces are either well separated with respect to each other , or very close to each other . if @xmath8 is the lateral size of the fracture in the mean plane , the typical range of the fluctuations ( the difference between the maximum and minimum values of @xmath9 ) scales as @xmath10 . if @xmath11 is the mean width of the fracture , with @xmath12 , then the two cases correspond to @xmath13 and @xmath14 , respectively . the local aperture of the crack is the key parameter determining the fracture permeability , and three different cases will be addressed . for large aperture , the roughness associated with the two sides of the fracture act independently , and it suffices to consider a channel with one rough and one smooth boundary . in the case of a narrow fracture , the correlation between the two sides is a key feature , and we consider two possibilities . we first study fractures where the upper surface has been simply translated a distance @xmath11 normal to the mean plane , so that the local aperture @xmath15 equals the constant @xmath11 . alternatively , the two surfaces may have a relative lateral displacement @xmath16 in the mean fracture plane , accompanied by a displacement @xmath11 in the perpendicular direction , so that the two surfaces do not overlap . in this case the local aperture is given by the random variable . @xmath17 it turns out @xcite that @xmath16 is the lateral correlation length for fluctuations in the aperture , in the sense that @xmath18 and @xmath19 decorrelate for @xmath20 . in this paper we restrict ourselves to the two dimensional case where the surface is invariant in the @xmath2 direction , @xmath21 , and the flow is forced in the @xmath1 direction by a constant pressure drop . in a subsequent paper we will extend these calculations to fully three dimensional fractures , but it is convenient , both conceptually and in the numerical simulations , to regard the system as having a translationally invariant third dimension . our aim is to study various aspects of the fracture permeability which are sensitive to the fracture roughness . the first ingredient is the height function @xmath0 , a statistically self - affine surface with periodic boundary conditions . the periodicity is not a physically essential ingredient here , but has some calculational advantages in alleviating finite - size effects . the surface is generated by a fourier synthesis method , based on power - law filtering of arrays of independent random numbers @xcite . the random numbers are generated using a gaussian distribution , and then modulated by an appropriate power law . if @xmath22 is the fourier transform of the initial gaussian random array , then the fourier transform of the surface elevation is chosen to be @xmath23 ( the 1/2 is appropriate for the self - affine _ curve _ used here , and would be 1 for a real rock _ surface_. ) in most cases the roughness exponent is chosen as the often - observed value @xmath24 . the amplitude of the roughness can be expressed in terms of variance of the height distribution over the full range , @xmath25 which in this case is @xmath26 for @xmath27 . alternatively , the amplitude is given indirectly in terms of the range of the fluctuations as @xmath28 , with @xmath29 . in these equations , and in the rest of the paper , the unit of length is that of the spacing between lattice points in the numerical calculations . since we consider fluid flow in a highly irregular geometry , and eventually hope to consider dispersion and the evolution of the solid surface due to particle transport , the lattice boltzmann ( lb ) method @xcite is particularly convenient . in this algorithm , fictitious particles move between neighboring sites on a lattice , with suitable collision rules , and the boundary of the flow domain is simply a surface of sites where the rule is modified in some way to keep the particles out . we use the face centered hypercubic ( fchc - projected ) version of the lb model , with a cubic lattice in 3 dimensions and 19 velocities ( d3q19 in the terminology of @xcite ) . the collision operator is approximated by a single relaxation time , the bhatnagar - gross - krook model@xcite , and the local equilibrium distribution given by @xcite is used . this pseudo - equilibrium distribution locally preserves mass and momentum values , and is formulated specifically to recover the navier - stokes equation at large length and time scales . for the no - slip solid boundaries , we use the simplest implementation of particle exclusion the bounce - back rule , in which a particle incident on the boundary reverses its direction . periodic boundary conditions are used for the inflow and outflow surfaces . a constant pressure gradient forcing the fluid is added in the @xmath1 direction , while the gap between surfaces extends over @xmath9 , and the geometry is taken to be translation invariant in @xmath2 . in this section we consider the case of a channel with one fractally - rough wall , in the limit where the mean width is large compared to the amplitude of the roughness . we ( re-)derive an elegant general result for the permeability , and then an exact variant which gives the permeability of a perturbed pore space . if the pore space perturbation is weak , the leading order correction is easy to evaluate and , when compared to numerical simulation , is seen to provide a reasonably accurate estimate of the permeability . we begin by deriving an integral representation for the permeability , and then considering a perturbation in the boundary shape . although we suspect that these results are known to many , we are not aware of an earlier publication containing them , although the electrical analog of the integral representation is in the literature @xcite . consider a rectangular volume of a porous medium , periodic in all directions , and the following surface integral @xmath30\ ] ] here , @xmath31 and @xmath32 are the velocity and pressure fields of a fluid which completely fills the pore space , assumed to satisfy the stokes equations , and the surface @xmath33 is the complete boundary of the pore space , consisting of the inner grain surfaces and the porous regions of the outer boundary . the pressure and velocity fields are periodic , except that the pressure jumps by a constant amount @xmath34 between two opposite faces in one direction , that of the mean flow . now the velocity vanishes on the grain boundaries by the no - slip condition , and there is complete cancelation between the opposite faces in the two completely periodic directions , but in the flow direction the remaining two faces of the box combine to give @xmath35 here @xmath36 is the fluid flux through this end face @xmath37 , and the minus sign arises because the outward normal is used in @xmath38 . the last equality follows from darcy s law , where @xmath33 is the area of end @xmath37 , @xmath39 is the permeability , @xmath40 the fluid viscosity , and @xmath8 the length of the box . on the other hand , applying the divergence theorem to eq . [ surface ] , we obtain : @xmath41 where the volume @xmath42 is just the pore space . we have used first the incompressibility of the fluid , second the stokes equation , and third integration by parts . comparing the two expressions for @xmath38 , we have @xmath43 the analogous formula for the electrical conductivity @xmath44 , which follows from ohm s law and the laplace equation @xcite , is @xmath45 here @xmath46 is the conductivity of the pore fluid , @xmath47 is the potential and @xmath48 its difference across the sample . note that both of these formulae may also be derived by comparing the energy dissipation rate computed microscopically in the pore space to the same quantity computed using average fields . we next derive an exact variant of the integral expression for the permeability ( [ permeability ] ) due to wilkinson @xcite , which allows us to implement a perturbation analysis . suppose we begin with a pore volume @xmath49 and known stokes equation solutions @xmath50 and @xmath51 , and then _ contract _ the volume to @xmath42 , where the exact ( but unknown ) solution is @xmath52 and @xmath53 . the result to follow is true even if the volume change and alterations in the fields are _ not _ small , but are probably only useful in that limit , hence the suggestive subscript @xmath54 . substituting into the dissipation integral on the right hand of eq [ permeability ] , and suppressing the summation sign for the moment , we obtain @xmath55 + 2~\int_v dv~\partial_i u_{0,j}~\partial_i u_{\epsilon , j } \nonumber\ ] ] the last integral on the right hand can be rewritten as @xmath56 = \int_s ds_i ~ u_{0,j}~\partial_iu_{\epsilon , j } - \int_v dv ~ u_{0,j}~\partial^2_iu_{\epsilon , j}. \nonumber\ ] ] noting that @xmath57 at the surface @xmath33 due to the no - slip condition , and using @xmath58 , we may rewrite the previous expression as @xmath59 \nonumber\ ] ] using incompressibility , the last term in the integrand can be rewritten @xmath60 and converted to a surface integral , which vanishes if the pressure is held constant on the ends of the porous medium . finally , we obtain @xmath61\ ] ] this result is exact but not useful . however , note that if the relative change in volume is small , @xmath62 , the second term is second order in the small parameter , so that to first order the decrease in permeability involves only the integral of the unperturbed velocity over the deleted region , which is easy to calculate . in this section we will determine the decrease in permeability due to the presence of a self - affine perturbation in the lower surface of a straight channel , and in particular its dependence on the size of the channel . to use the previous result , we begin with a straight channel of width @xmath63 which completely contains the rough - walled one ( see fig . [ fracture ] ) , where we have poiseuille flow @xmath64 and an unperturbed permeability @xmath65 . the lower boundary is shifted by @xmath66 , where we assume that that range @xmath67 of @xmath9 satisfies the only surviving velocity derivative is @xmath69 so that the dissipation integral is simply @xmath70 up to first order in @xmath54 this becomes @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the average of @xmath9 over the channel length @xmath8 , and the cross - sectional area is @xmath73 . the mean perturbation @xmath72 is computable for a specific profile , but here we wish to use a statistical characterization and relate it to the average properties of an ensemble of self - affine surfaces . the mean height of the surface is half the range , and therefore has the scaling @xmath74 . substituting , and replacing the previous equation in eq . [ permeability ] we obtain the first - order perturbative correction to the permeability @xmath75\ ] ] we have added an adjustable parameter @xmath76 , which is expected to lie between @xmath77 , to take account of the distinction between open volume and flowing volume . a value @xmath78 means that the fracture is equivalent to a straight channel of height equal to the mean height of the surface . on the other hand , a value @xmath79 means that the whole region of fluid below the maximum excursion of the surface is not contributing to the permeability and the system is equivalent to the maximum channel that does not intersect the surface . note the lowest order correction to the permeability obtained here results from the reduced volume of a fracture compared to that of a straight channel enclosing it , and happens to coincide with the lubrication approximation . the approach taken here allows us to gain some insight in the drawbacks of this approximation and further improve them . using the previous equation we may write the first order correction to the flow rate , @xmath80\ ] ] to verify this prediction , we consider a pore space consisting of a cubic lattice with periodic boundaries in @xmath1 and @xmath2 , one impermeable wall at @xmath81 , and a self - affine rough boundary lying above @xmath82 . we generate an ensemble of 10 self - affine surfaces with exponent @xmath24 , as discussed above . in fig . [ q - vs - size ] we display the correction to the flow rate as a function of the size of the system @xmath8 . the straight line is a fit to the expected exponent , which does reasonably well except at the smallest and largest values of @xmath1 . the origins of the discrepancies are first that the discretization used in the numerical calculation suppresses any roughness less than one unit , which is a significant fraction of the system for small @xmath8 . moreover , the system should be periodic in @xmath8 , but the numerical algorithm used to generate it assumes a system size that is a power of 2 . as usual , there are computational limitations on the sizes we can simulate , and for lengths between 32 and the accessible maximum of 64 , we just truncate the periodic surface . finally , at the largest system sizes , we are really outside the range of validity of the estimates . in fact , the second term in the flux in eq . [ rate ] is greater than 1/3 for the parameters here when @xmath83 . the fitted value @xmath76 given that @xmath24 is @xmath84 , meaning that a portion of the fluid does not contributes to convective transport . expressed in terms of the surface height variance @xmath85 instead of the span range , the excluded fluid represents @xmath86 of the roughness region . the physical consideration absent in the leading order perturbation calculation is the fact that fluid velocity sharply decays inside depressions and corners were resistive eddies are likely to occur @xcite . this deficiency is associated with the omitted second term in eq . [ perm_final ] , _ i.e. _ , the correction to the unperturbed velocity . in fig . [ fracture ] we magnify two regions close to the lower and upper surfaces , respectively , showing the markedly different way the velocity decays towards the surface . we have also simulated a system with an alternative roughness exponent @xmath87 , corresponding to a surface with more persistent correlations and in a sense a lower fractal dimension ( the dimension of the intersection of the surface with a plane normal to it is @xmath88 @xcite ) . in this case the prefactor in the range scaling law is @xmath89 . in fig . [ q - vs - size ] we show the numerical results ; again , good agreement with the predicted behavior is obtained . the fit gives @xmath90 , suggesting that the low - velocity zones are even more important in this case , presumably because the greater degree of correlation enhances them . we wish to disentangle the permeability decrease due to volume reduction of the fracture from that due to low - velocity zones induced by surface fluctuations . the first step is to consider `` zero - mean '' self - affine surfaces , whose mean height @xmath11 is constant , but which have a tunable roughness . the previous profile , @xmath91 for @xmath92 , is rescaled so as to have unit variance , and then multiplied by an adjustable amplitude @xmath93 , giving adjustable variance @xmath94 . if we assume that the effect of the boundary perturbation is to give low velocity zones which do not contribute to the flow , and that the volume of these zones contributing to the dissipation integral is proportional to @xmath93 , we would write in analogy to eq . [ rate ] @xmath95\ ] ] here @xmath93 is analogous to @xmath96 , and @xmath97 an order-1 fitting coefficient . in fig . [ fig - zero - mean ] we show the results obtained by numerical simulation corresponding to a system with @xmath98 and @xmath99 ( and , to be specific , @xmath100 , @xmath101 , @xmath102 , which gives @xmath103 ) . the filled circles are the numerical results , and we see the expected linear decrease of the permeability with @xmath93 . in fact , a linear fit to the numerical data gives @xmath104 and @xmath105 , which are reasonable numerical values given our assumptions . further evidence for our arguments concerning the effects of low - velocity zones can be adduced by showing that the permeability is unchanged if they are deleted . we begin with the family of adjustable - amplitude self - affine surface just discussed , and filter out the smallest wavelengths from the spectrum so as to generate a smother surface . the smooth surface is then shifted upwards so as to enclose the deleted surface fluctuations , in the rms sense . quantitatively , if we have @xmath106 points on the @xmath1-axis , with @xmath107 , and filter all wavelengths smaller than @xmath108 , then @xmath109 the prefactor on the right arises from the discrete form of parseval s theorem @xcite , and in practice we choose @xmath110 . we then simulate fluid flow in the smoothed fracture , and in fig . [ fig - zero - mean ] the open squares show the results obtained as a function of roughness amplitude @xmath93 . the agreement between the actual and filtered surfaces is clear . the extension of this analysis to the 3-d case is conceptually straightforward , since the decrease in the permeability in this limit just corresponds to the decrease in pore space _ volume_. the latter would be @xmath111 , due to the self - affine topography of the fracture surface , and the relevant expansion parameter is again @xmath112 . the effects of low - velocity regions is presumably the same as well . we now turn to the complimentary situation of narrow fractures , where the pore space is winding and convoluted . consider the situation in which a rock is fractured and the two surfaces are simply displaced by a distance @xmath12 , perpendicular to the mean fracture plane , with no lateral shift . the vertical aperture is constant everywhere , but the effective local aperture for fluid flow , _ i.e. _ , the local width of the channel normal to the mean flow direction , strongly depends on the local angle between the surface and the mean plane . in fig . [ displacement ] we show a fracture of length @xmath99 , generated by a self - affine surface of exponent @xmath24 , separated a distance @xmath113 , along with the ( lattice boltzmann ) computed velocity field . the theoretical analysis will be based on a kind of local lubrication approximation , where the channel is divided into a sequence of quasi - linear segments at varying orientation angles . first , we estimate the length @xmath114 in the direction of the mean flow over which the channel formed by the two fracture surfaces can be considered approximately straight , which is a typical size over which the fluctuations in the vertical direction are small compared to the effective aperture of the channel . using the self - affine scaling law for the correlation function , @xmath115 ^ 2 \rangle = \phi(\ell ) \left ( { \xi_\parallel\over\ell } \right)^{2\zeta}\ ] ] where @xmath116 is a microscopic length , say a grain size , and @xmath117 is then on the order of a grain size squared , we estimate @xmath118 a segment of length @xmath119 is roughly straight when this quantity is a small fraction of @xmath11 , which yields @xmath120 returning to the entire fracture , each @xmath114-channel is oriented at some angle @xmath121 with respect to the mean plane , and has effective aperture @xmath122 , and length @xmath123 . assuming poiseuille flow in each @xmath114-channel , the corresponding local permeability is @xmath124 . we compute the pressure drop across the fracture by adding the the local pressure drops along the straight @xmath114-channels along the whole path . noting that the flow rate @xmath125 is constant , @xmath126 finally , noting that @xmath127 is the number of channels , we can convert the sum into an average over the distribution of angles , and write for the permeability @xmath128 we can give a simple if heuristic estimate of the permeability as follows . since the exponent @xmath129 , the channels have small vertical fluctuations , and we can approximate the cosine as @xmath130 substituting in eq . [ k - h ] , we obtain @xmath131\ ] ] a more convincing evaluation of the angular average makes use of the actual height distribution . experimental measurements indicate a gaussian distribution for the spatial correlation in heights , @xmath132 @xcite , and in fact our numerical procedure for generating self - affine surfaces also gives a gaussian distribution for @xmath133 . we illustrate this point in fig . [ g - distribution ] , where we plot our generated probability distribution function of @xmath133 , corresponding to different values of @xmath114 , along with their gaussian fits @xmath134 we also plot the ( numerically - obtained ) dependence of the mean spatial correlation , @xmath135 , on @xmath119 for two choices of @xmath7 , confirming the scaling given above in eq . [ variance ] . the angular average is then given by @xmath136 \\ \nonumber & = & 1 + 2 \left(\frac{\sigma_z(\xi_\parallel)}{\xi_\parallel}\right)^2 + 3 \left(\frac{\sigma_z(\xi_\parallel)}{\xi_\parallel}\right)^4\end{aligned}\ ] ] using eqs . [ variance],[k - h ] , this result is consistent with the previous estimate eq . [ perm - narrow ] based on simple scaling arguments . moreover , aside from the purely numerical coefficients , we can argue that scale invariance requires the angular average to have the form given in ( [ cosine ] ) . the self - affine property of the fracture geometry implies that the probability distribution of heights @xmath137 should only depend on the rescaled variable @xmath138 @xcite . more specifically , @xmath139\ ] ] where the prefactor comes from the normalization . if @xmath140 is evaluated for this distribution , we obtain a variant of eq . [ cosine ] where the numerical coefficients 2 and 3 are replaced by the moments of the function @xmath141 , leading to the same scaling form for the permeability . finally then , using the leading term in eq . [ cosine ] for the angular average , and eq . [ delta - h ] for the value of @xmath119 , we have the result for the permeability of a narrow two dimensional self - affine fracture , @xmath142 \end{aligned}\ ] ] the principal approximation used in obtaining this result is that the fracture aperture may be regarded as a sequence of almost - straight segments . to test eq . [ perm - final ] numerically , we first recast it in terms of the fluid flux . for a straight channel of height @xmath11 , width @xmath143 and length @xmath8 , and pressure drop @xmath34 , we have flux @xmath144 . thus @xmath145 where @xmath146 is another adjustable parameter expected to be of order one , and we have taken @xmath116 to be the ( unit ) lattice spacing . in fig . [ fdisplacement ] we present the correction to @xmath147 as a function of the distance between the opposite surfaces @xmath11 , for both roughness exponents @xmath148 and @xmath149 . we find the good agreement for the predicted exponent for the case @xmath148 . the only adjustable parameter is the coefficient , which is found to be @xmath150 in fairly good agreement with the expected value . the fitted exponent is @xmath151 , which agrees with the predicted value @xmath152 . on the other hand , in the case @xmath87 the numerical results deviates from the asymptotic behavior at small distances between the surfaces . that is because the successive powers given by the expansion of eq . [ perm - final ] are very close to each other ( the difference between them is @xmath153 ) . again if only the coefficient is fitted , we find @xmath154 . fitting also the exponent , but using only the numerical simulations with large separation between surfaces , we obtain @xmath155 where @xmath156 . in fig . [ size - disp ] we compare numerical results corresponding to systems of different sizes with the same roughness exponent @xmath148 . it can be seen that the accuracy in the exponent is improved as the size of the system is larger . we obtain a value @xmath157 for the largest system with size @xmath27 . as mentioned , the crossover between small and large surface roughness , ( compared to the mean aperture of the fracture ) , can be addressed numerically . the narrow fracture regime , where @xmath158 , is expected to be valid when @xmath159 . the critical mean aperture value @xmath160 which corresponds to @xmath161 turns out to be , using the fitted value of @xmath146 , @xmath162 . on the other hand , the small surface - deviation scaling behavior can be obtained from eq . ( [ rate ] ) , where @xmath8 is the constant size of the system and @xmath63 is now the variable mean aperture of the fracture @xmath11 , @xmath163 in fig . [ crossover ] we display the correction to @xmath147 in the range @xmath164 for a system size @xmath99 . a small deviation from the narrow fractures regime can be observed , starting at @xmath165 . as the size of the gap becomes larger , the correction to the unperturbed flow rate @xmath147 decreases as a power of @xmath11 . therefore , both larger computational time ( starting the simulation from an initially at rest fluid the time interval to reach the steady asymptotic value grows as the square of the gap size @xcite ) and higher accuracy in the fluid field close to the solid surface are needed . our current computational limitations prevents us to simulate systems where @xmath166 . nevertheless , we believe that the observed deviation correspond to a crossover towards a smaller exponent ( @xmath167 ) as expected from the previous discussion . in the field , when a rock is fractured its two sides may be shifted laterally parallel to the mean plane by geological processes . we now consider how our results for permeability are modified by this effect . the situation is somewhat different in two dimensions than in three . in order that a two dimensional fracture remain open it is necessary that the two sides do not touch , whereas in three dimensions in the presence of a lateral shift it is easy for the two surfaces to touch at one or a few points in the plane , while the aperture is still open to flow . furthermore , in two dimensions when the fracture nearly touches at a point , the permeability will be dominated by the large pressure drop needed to force fluid through this narrow gap . in fact , in this case an estimate of the permeability is simply @xmath168 , where @xmath169 is the minimum value of the aperture . in this section we address the complimentary case where the fracture is distinctly open . as discussed in section 2 , in the presence of a lateral shift @xmath16 , the fracture aperture is now the random function @xmath18 given by eq . [ aperture ] rather than the constant @xmath11 . however , there is a residual correlation between the two sides of the fracture , which allows us to relate the permeability to the self - affine statistics . first , we determine a condition on the shift for the fracture to be open . provided the average properties of the surface are statistically stationary ( independent of @xmath1 ) , we have @xmath170 , and the variance of the aperture distribution is @xmath171 ^ 2 \rangle = \langle [ z(x+d)-z(x)]^2 \rangle = \sigma_z^2(d ) = \phi(\ell ) \left ( { d\over \ell } \right)^{2\zeta}\ ] ] the aperture is surely open when @xmath172 , which gives @xmath173 , but from eq . [ delta - h ] , this is just @xmath174 . in other words , the shift must be small compared to the typical length of a straight segment of unshifted channel , and there is little change in the geometry compared to the unshifted case . we expect , therefore , that the previous result eq . [ flow - disp ] should apply at least up to a different value of the numerical coefficient @xmath146 . in fig . [ fshift ] we show lb simulation results for the correction to the unperturbed flow rate @xmath147 , for different values of the shift @xmath16 . we see that the behavior is consistent with these arguments for all values of the shift , with deviations occurring when the shift is too large for the mean aperture . several other shift values were simulated obtaining the same general behaviors as in those shown in fig . [ fshift ] . as is often the case with this type of scaling argument , reasoning in terms of asymptotic limits leads to conditions that one quantity must be _ much _ larger than another , but in practice the range of validity is much wider . we have studied the permeability of two - dimensional self - affine fractures , using asymptotic analytic arguments for wide and narrow apertures . numerical simulations using the lattice boltzmann method have verified the predictions , and also suggest a smooth crossover between the limits used in the derivations . we have obtained expressions for the permeability in which the usual expression for straight channels is modified by terms related to the hurst exponent characterizing the fracture surface . in the wide - gap case , we obtained a perturbative correction related to the roughness exponent and amplitude . the result is formally identical to the lubrication theory prediction , but the corrections are known , in principle , and furthermore we can understand the discrepancies between the derived numerical coefficient and simulation in terms of the effects of low - velocity zones which do not contribute to transport . in the narrow gap case , we also derive an analytic correction related to the roughness exponent and amplitude ( or microscopic length @xmath116 ) . the analysis is based in a local lubrication approximation , dividing the whole fracture into a chain of approximately linear channels with varying orientation angles respect to the main flow direction . the results is equivalent to a correction due to the tortuosity of the fracture , where the tortuosity itself depends on the gap size . finally , we show that in the case when there is a lateral shift between the surfaces , there is no qualitative change compared to the unshifted case . this is basically due to the two dimensional geometry , where in order to have an open channel the shift must be small compared to the size of the typical length of a quasi - linear segment of unshifted fracture . the two - dimensional nature of the problem imposes restrictions on the range of validity of analytic estimates , but the numerical results are in general agreement over a much wider range . the extension of this work to fully three - dimensional fractures is in progress . the case of a wide gap does not require any further significant conceptual effort . however , the narrow gap case the fracture geometry is significantly more complicated because it is not feasible to use any quasi - one - dimensional approximation for the flow paths . numerical simulations are certainly feasible , at least up to size limits imposed by one s computational hardware , but additional ideas are required for analytic arguments . future work will consider diffusion , and also convection plus diffusion , in these self - affine fractures , in both two and three dimensions . the lb method is quite simple for numerical simulations , and we will explore the way in which the roughness exponent enters into the quantitative behavior , along the lines given here . we thank j. p. hulin , f. plourabou and m. tanksley for discussions . this research was supported by the geosciences research program , office of basic energy sciences , u.s . department of energy , and computational facilities were provided by the national energy resources scientific computer center . h. press , w. t. vetterling , s. a. teukolsky , and b. p. flannery , _ numerical recipes in fortran : the art of scientific computing _ , @xmath175 ed . ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1988 ) , http://lib-www.lanl.gov/numerical/index.html .

the permeability of two - dimensional fractures with self - affine fractal roughness is studied via analytic arguments and numerical simulations . the limit where the roughness amplitude is small compared with average fracture aperture is analyzed by a perturbation method , while in the opposite case of narrow aperture , we use heuristic arguments based on lubrication theory . numerical simulations , using the lattice boltzmann method , are used to examine the complete range of aperture sizes , and confirm the analytic arguments .

0907.4801

in recent years , quarkonium hadroproduction has become the subject of intense theoretical and experimental investigation . the main reason is that production and decays of heavy quarkonia have been an ideal laboratory to investigate quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) . their large masses provide a hard scale which allows us to use perturbative qcd techniques . basically , there exist three distinct formalisms for quarkonium production . the simplest one is the color evaporation model ( cem ) @xcite , where the hadronization of the @xmath4 pairs into quarkonia is assumed to be dominated by long - distance fluctuations of gluon fields which motivates a statistical treatment of color . in the color - singlet model ( csm ) @xcite , quarkonium is viewed as a non - relativistic color - singlet bound state of a @xmath4 pair with definite angular momentum quantum numbers . production rates for a quarkonium state are computed by calculating the production of a heavy quark pair which is constrained to be in a color - singlet state and have the same angular momentum quantum numbers as the physical quarkonium . in the non - relativistic qcd ( nrqcd ) factorization formalism @xcite , non - perturbative aspects of quarkonium production are organized in an expansion in powers of @xmath5 , the relative velocity of the @xmath4 in quarkonia . for production of @xmath6-wave quarkonia , the results of the csm are recovered in the limit of @xmath7 . in addition , in the nrqcd formalism new quarkonium production mechanisms are now possible since it is no longer required that the @xmath4 produced in the short - distance process have the same color and angular momentum quantum numbers as the quarkonium state . recently , several computations of the qcd corrections to the inclusive quarkonium hadroproduction processes have shed some light on the robustness and/or deficiencies of those models . comprehensive reviews of recent developments in the theory of quarkonium production can be found in refs . @xcite . beside the studies of inclusive production , efforts are being made to obtain improved theoretical predictions for complementary observables to the inclusive yield , such the hadroproduction of @xmath2 and @xmath3 in association with a photon . in the framework of csm , the associated production of @xmath8 at a hadron collider was first proposed as a good channel to investigate the gluon distribution in the proton with a relatively clean signal @xcite . in ref . @xcite , such a process at the tevatron energy has been considered in the csm at lo , and the results show that the contribution from the gluon fusion sub - process is dominant over that from the fragmentation process ( the same occurs at the lhc @xcite ) . the color - octet contributions were investigated in ref . @xcite and it was found they are dominant in the large @xmath9 region . recently , in ref . @xcite the effect of the nlo qcd corrections to @xmath10 hadroproduction at the lhc has been investigated . in ref . @xcite the real next - to - next - to - leading ( nnlo ) order qcd contribution to hadroproduction of a @xmath11 via color singlet transitions for the inclusive case has been addressed . in this letter , we examine the production of associated @xmath8 and @xmath12 at large @xmath9 within the nrqcd approach in proton - nucleus and nucleus - nucleus collisions . such processes are relatively clean because the produced large @xmath9 quarkonium is easy to detect through its leptonic decay modes and the quarkonium s large @xmath9 is balanced by the associated high energy photon . at the lhc energy , the leading contributions are dominated by gluon induced hard processes and then the quarkonium production associated with a direct photon will be strongly dependent on the nuclear gluon distribution . our goal is to use the @xmath8 and @xmath12 processes as auxiliary observables to constrain the nuclear gluon distribution . this is motivated by similar investigations on inclusive heavy quark , quarkonium and prompt photon production in central proton - nucleus and nucleus - nucleus collisions ( see e.g. refs . one of the nuclear effects which is expected to modify the behavior of gluon distribution is the nuclear shadowing . this effect has been observed in the nuclear structure functions by different experimental collaborations @xcite in the study of the deep inelastic lepton scattering ( dis ) off nuclei . the modifications on @xmath13 depend on the parton momentum fraction @xmath14 . while for momentum fractions @xmath15 ( shadowing region ) and @xmath16 ( emc region ) , a depletion is observed in the nuclear structure functions , in the intermediate region ( @xmath17 ) it is verified an enhancement known as antishadowing . these experimental results strongly constrain the behavior of the nuclear quark distributions , whereas the the nuclear gluon distribution is still an open question due to the scarce experimental data in the small-@xmath14 region and/or for observables strongly dependent on the nuclear gluon distribution . this letter is organized as follows . in next section , we summarize the main formulas concerning the process @xmath8 in the nrqcd formalism and define the nuclear modification factors for proton - nucleus and nucleus - nucleus collisions , @xmath18 and @xmath19 , respectively . in last section we present the numerical results considering the more recent nuclear parton parameterizations and estimating the transverse momentum dependence of the nuclear modification factors at the lhc energies . as long as @xmath8 is produced at small longitudinal momentum fraction , @xmath20 , the gluon fusion channel dominates over the @xmath21 annihilation process . therefore , at high energies and at leading order ( lo ) , the process @xmath22 contributes at the partonic level with six feynman diagrams , which is similar to that of @xmath23 in inclusive @xmath2 hadroproduction . the signal we focus on is the production of a @xmath2 and an isolated photon produced back - to - back , with their transverse momenta balanced . the lo cross section is obtained by convoluting the partonic cross section with the parton distribution function ( pdf ) , @xmath24 , in the proton , where @xmath25 is the factorization scale . at nlo expansion on @xmath26 , there are one virtual correction and three real corrections processes , as shown in ref . @xcite . in the nrqcd formalism , the contributing subprocesses are @xmath27 and @xmath28 . the fock - components that contribute to @xmath2 production are the color - singlet @xmath29}$ ] state and the color - octet states @xmath30}$ ] , @xmath31}$ ] and @xmath32}$ ] . the color - singlet @xmath33 state contributes at @xmath34 but the color - octet channels all contribute higher orders in @xmath5 ( the relative velocity between the heavy quarks ) . we are interested here in the quarkonium production in a nuclear medium . in order to get the @xmath8 yield in @xmath35 and @xmath36 collisions , a shadowing - correction factor has to be applied to the @xmath2 yield obtained from the simple superposition of the equivalent number of @xmath37 collisions . this shadowing factor can be expressed in terms of the ratios @xmath38 of the nuclear parton distribution functions in a nucleon of a nucleus @xmath39 to the pdf in the free nucleon . most of shadowing models provide the nuclear ratios at a given value of @xmath40 and then evoluted through the dglap evolution equations @xcite to lo accuracy . only very recently , the nuclear pdfs have been available at nlo accuracy . therefore , in what follows we will consider a lo calculation for the nuclear modification factors in order to be consistent with the limitation of shadowing models . in this respect our analysis can not be considered as fully nlo and should be updated once the nlo calculation in nrqcd approach is available for the nucleon case . on the other hand , this is not an important limitation to our results as we will discuss later on . in order to obtain the transverse momentum ( @xmath9 ) distribution for the process @xmath22 , we express the differential cross section as @xmath41 where we have defined @xmath42 , with @xmath43 being the center of mass energy of the @xmath44 system and @xmath45 being the transverse mass of outgoing @xmath2 . the gluon distribution , @xmath46 , in the hadron a / b is evaluated at factorization scale @xmath25 . the common transverse momentum of the outgoing particles is @xmath9 and @xmath47 is the rapidity of outgoing @xmath2 having mass @xmath48 . the variables @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the momentum fractions of the partons , where @xmath51 ( @xmath52 is the invariant mass of @xmath8 system ) and @xmath50 can be written in terms of other variables as @xmath53 in the nrqcd formalism , the cross section for the production of a quarkonium state @xmath54 is written as @xmath55 , where the short - distance coefficients @xmath56 are computable in perturbation theory . the @xmath57 are matrix elements of nrqcd operators of the form @xmath58 the @xmath59 is a bilinear in heavy quark fields which creates a @xmath60 pair in a state with definite color and angular momentum quantum numbers . hereafter , we will use a shorthand notation in which the matrix elements are given as @xmath61 . the angular momentum quantum numbers of the @xmath62 produced in the short - distance process are given in standard spectroscopic notation , and the subscript refers to the color configuration of the @xmath62 : @xmath63 for a color singlet and @xmath64 for a color octet . the parton level differential cross sections relevant for hadroproduction of @xmath0 , including both color - singlet and color - octet contributions are given below @xcite : @xmath65 , \nonumber \\ { d\hat{\sigma}_{\mathrm{oct } } \over d\hat{t } } & = & \sigma_0 \left [ { 10\over 9 } \left ( { \hat{s}^2 s_1 ^ 2 + \hat{t}^2 t_1 ^ 2 + \hat{u}^2 u_1 ^ 2 \over s_1 ^ 2 t_1 ^ 2 u_1 ^ 2 } \right ) \langle o_8^{j/\psi}(^3s_1)\rangle \right . \nonumber \\ & + & { 6 \over \hat{s } s_1 ^ 2 m_c^2 } \left(2 \hat{s } + { 3 \hat{t } \hat{u } \over 4m_c^2 } - { 4 \hat{t } \hat{u } \over s_1 } \right ) \langle o_8^{j/\psi}(^1p_0)\rangle \nonumber \\ & + & \left . { 3\over 2 } { \hat{t } \hat{u } \over \hat{s } s_1 ^ 2 m_c^2 } \langle o_8^{j/\psi}(^1s_0)\rangle \right ] , \label{jpsixsection}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in eqs . ( [ ggpsiga ] ) we have defined @xmath66 ( with charm quark mass @xmath67 gev ) and @xmath68 , @xmath69 , and @xmath70 . in these formulae , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , and @xmath73 are the mandelstam variables , which can be written as @xmath74 in our numerical calculations the one loop expression for the running coupling , @xmath75 , with @xmath76 gev and @xmath77 is considered . the ( renormalization and factorization ) scale for the strong coupling and for the evaluation of pdfs is @xmath78 , where @xmath48 is the @xmath2 mass . for numerical values of the nrqcd matrix elements we have used those from ref . @xcite , which are ( units of @xmath79 ) : @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 . we have checked that using another set of color octet matrix elements , taken from @xcite , our results do not change considerably , since we only calculate the ratio between the production cross sections , and the dependency on the color octet matrix elements cancels out in those ratios . in what follows we estimate the differential cross sections for central ( @xmath83 ) and forward ( @xmath84 ) rapidities for the @xmath37 , @xmath35 and @xmath36 collisions in order to compute the nuclear modification factors . from eq . ( [ diffcs ] ) , it implies that the differential cross section at small values of the @xmath2 transverse momentum in @xmath85 ( and @xmath86 ) collisions at the lhc is determined by the behavior of the nuclear gluon distribution at @xmath87 . it is important to emphasize that smaller values of @xmath14 contribute at @xmath8 production in the forward rapidity region which can be measured , e.g. , with the cms and alice experiments at lhc . the main input in the calculations of @xmath8 cross sections is the nuclear parton distribution function ( npdf ) . over last years several groups has proposed parameterizations for the npdfs @xcite , which are based on different assumptions and techniques to perform a global fit of different sets of data using the dglap evolution equations . these parameterizations predict very distinct magnitudes for the nuclear effects . for larger values of @xmath14 , the eks and the eps npdfs show antishadowing , while this effect is absent for the hkn and ds parameterizations in the @xmath88 domain . while the nuclear shadowing is moderate for ds and hkn parameterizations and somewhat bigger for eks one , the eps prediction has a much stronger suppression compared with the other parameterizations . for smaller @xmath14 around @xmath89 , while ds and hkn parameterizations have about @xmath90 suppression and eks one have about @xmath91 suppression , for the eps parameterization this effect goes to almost @xmath92 suppression in the nuclear gluon compared with the @xmath39 scaled gluon content in the proton . in what follows we calculate the quarkonium production in association with a direct photon in @xmath35 and @xmath36 collisions , considering the nuclear parton distributions discussed above . we then estimate the nuclear modification factor for these predictions . these factors could be measured at the lhc and we analyze the transverse momentum dependence of them . since the full nlo calculation of @xmath93 including the com contributions is not available yet , and for the sake of simplicity , the calculation of the cross sections is here done at lo accuracy . in order of to be consistent , we consider only the lo version of the npdfs employed ( besides , the eks npdf is only evolved to leading order ) . as we are calculating ratios between cross sections , common uncertainties on the normalization of the @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 cross sections , e.g. due to higher order contributions , are expected to cancel out in the nuclear modification factors . in fig . [ fig : rpa ] we present our estimates for the transverse momentum dependence of the ratio @xmath18 for central and forward rapidities , defined by @xmath94 in @xmath35 collisions at the lhc ( @xmath95 tev ) . the results show distinct behaviors of @xmath18 for different npdf s . the difference between central and forward rapidities for @xmath18 comes from the kinematical @xmath50 range probed in the two cases . while for central rapidities the values of @xmath50 are ever larger than @xmath96 , in the forward case the minimum value could be @xmath97 , increasing with @xmath9 . consequently , the effects in the nuclear gluon distribution which contribute for the quarkonium production are different in the two rapidities . in the @xmath9 interval shown in fig . [ fig : rpa ] , antishadowing effect is not observed as @xmath98 . we have that the nuclear factor is substantially suppressed in the eps ( eks ) case , going down an @xmath99 at @xmath100 gev , while in the ds ( hkn ) case it is almost flat and equal to 0.95 ( 0.85 ) in the full @xmath9 range . moreover , differently from the ds and hkn predictions , the eks and eps parameterizations lead to a strong transverse momentum dependence . consequently , the determination of the magnitude and @xmath9 dependence of the this nuclear modification factor at the lhc could be useful to determine the properties of the shadowing in the gluon distribution . the production of @xmath8 can also be studied in the collision of two heavy nuclei . in what follows we present our estimates for the transverse momentum dependence of the nuclear modification factor @xmath19 for central and forward rapidities defined by @xmath101 in @xmath36 collisions at the lhc ( @xmath102 tev ) . in this case the nuclear effects are amplified by the presence of two nuclei in the initial state of the collision . similarly to the @xmath35 case , we can see in fig . [ fig : raa ] that the factor @xmath19 is strongly modified by the shadowing effects . for low @xmath9 the suppression is stronger than in the @xmath35 case . we can see an anti - shadowing effect appearing in central rapidity for eps and eks npdfs in the region of larger @xmath103 gev . our results indicate that @xmath8 production with @xmath104 gev can be used to determine the gluon shadowing effect . the production of @xmath105 can be obtained from the expression ( [ jpsixsection ] ) above , by replacing the charm mass and charge by the bottom ones , @xmath106 , @xmath107 , the @xmath2 mass by the @xmath108 mass , and by using the corresponding color octet matrix elements . we use the values taken from @xcite , namely ( units of @xmath79 ) : @xmath109 , @xmath110 , @xmath111 and @xmath112 . we notice that using the alternative set for the color octet matrix elements @xcite : @xmath113 , @xmath114 and @xmath115 , our results are not significantly changed ( there is only a very tiny reduction in @xmath116 for larger @xmath9 ) . in fig . [ fig : rpa_upsi ] we present our estimates for the transverse momentum dependence of the ratio @xmath18 for central and forward rapidities , in @xmath35 collisions at the lhc ( @xmath95 tev ) producing @xmath117 . in this case the @xmath9 range is extended to @xmath118 gev , since the distributions tend to be shifted to larger values of @xmath9 due to the larger @xmath3 mass , which makes larger values of @xmath14 to be accessed , and suggests the existence of antishadowing . as in the previous cases the results show distinct behaviors of @xmath18 for different npdf s . for central rapidities , the eks and eps show antishadowing for larger @xmath9 , while this effect is absent for forward rapidities and for the other distributions . for lower @xmath9 , the suppression is different for the different npdfs , being stronger in the forward case . this effect could then be used to discriminate among the nuclear pdf s . the results for the production of @xmath105 in @xmath36 collisions are shown in fig . [ fig : raa_upsi ] , where we present our results for the transverse momentum dependence of the ratio @xmath19 for central and forward rapidities at the lhc ( @xmath102 tev ) . here the nuclear effects are more pronounced than in the @xmath35 case . the eps parameterization shows the steepest behavior , presenting shadowing ( suppression ) for low @xmath9 and antishadowing ( enhancement ) for larger @xmath9 and central rapidities . the eks has a similar although less pronounced behavior , and the hkn , which presented an almost flat behavior in the @xmath2 case , it now grows steeper . thus , the hkn versus ds could be discriminated at low @xmath9 and central rapidities , and at high @xmath9 and forward rapidities . in the forward case , antishadowing behavior at high @xmath9 tend to be less important for the eks and eps npdf s as @xmath9 grows . we conclude that shadowing and antishadowing effects could be tested in different @xmath9 and rapidity regions and therefore help in discriminating among the different nuclear pdf s . finally , we discuss qualitatively the results and comment on the limitations of present calculations . let us first concentrate on the @xmath35 case where cold matter effects also play an essential role . at leading order , the differential cross section is simply proportional to the product of gluon densities @xmath119 where @xmath120 are the projectile and target - parton momentum fractions . in this kinematics , the nuclear modification factor reduces to @xmath121 . in our analysis above we did not take into account the nuclear absorption . in the framework of the probabilistic glauber model , this effect refers to the probability for the pre - resonant @xmath4 pair to survive to the propagation through the nuclear medium . therefore , the @xmath2 may be sensitive to inelastic rescattering processes in a large nuclei , which spoil the simple relationship between @xmath18 and @xmath122 . assuming the factorization between the quarkonium production process and the subsequent possible @xmath2 inelastic interaction with nuclear matter , we can write the production cross section as @xmath123 where @xmath124 denotes the probability for no interaction , or survival probability , of the meson with the nucleus target . in a glauber model it depends on the @xmath125 inelastic cross section , @xmath126 , and reads as ( for large nucleus ) : @xmath127,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the thickness function @xmath128 . as @xmath126 is not well constrained from data , this is additional uncertainty entering on the nuclear modification factor . in a rough estimation we have @xmath129 . the corresponding expression for @xmath36 collision can be obtained using similar methods . we quote ref . @xcite as an example where the magnitude of these corrections has been studied for the @xmath2 production in proton - nucleus and nucleus - nucleus collisions . concerning nucleus - nucleus collisions , the situation is more complicated as final state effects can not be disregarded . for instance , the processes of dissociation and recombination of @xmath130 pairs in the dense medium can be computed through the co - movers interaction model @xcite , which also incorporates also the recombination mechanism @xcite . as mentioned for @xmath35 case , nuclear effects in nucleus - nucleus collisions are usually expressed through the so - called nuclear modification factor , @xmath131 , defined as the ratio of the @xmath2 yield in @xmath36 and _ pp _ scaled by the number of binary nucleon - nucleon collisions , @xmath132 . a similar factor can be defined in our case of @xmath133 production , having in mind that the prompt photon is insensitive to nuclear matter effects . we have then for symmetric nuclei , @xmath134 where @xmath135 $ ] and @xmath136 is the nuclear overlapping function . one has that @xmath128 is obtained from woods - saxon nuclear densities , and @xmath137 where the number of binary nucleon - nucleon collisions at impact parameter @xmath138 is given by , @xmath139 . the three factors appearing in eq . ( [ eq : nbin ] ) , @xmath140 , @xmath141 and @xmath142 , denote the effects of shadowing , nuclear absorption , and interaction with the co - moving matter , respectively . as referred above , the nuclear absorption is usually interpreted as suppression of @xmath2 yield because of multiple scattering of a @xmath130 pair within the nuclear medium . at low energies the primordial spectrum of particles created in scattering off a nucleus is mainly altered by interactions with the nuclear matter they traverse on the way out to the detector and energy - momentum conservation ( it has been shown that it becomes a minor effect at @xmath36 collisions at lhc ) . for nucleus - nucleus collisions these effects can be combined into the generalized suppression factor @xmath143 } { \beta(x_1)\beta(x_2)\ , \sigma_{c\bar{c}}^2 \,a^2 \ , t_a(s ) t_a(b - s ) } \nonumber \\ & \times & \left[1 - \exp \left(-\beta(x_2 ) \,\sigma_{c\bar{c}}\ , at_a(b - s)\right ) \right]\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath144 , and @xmath145 determines both absorption and energy - momentum conservation . the parameters @xmath146 , @xmath147 and @xmath148 can be adjusted to describe collider data . secondly , coherence effects will lead to nuclear shadowing for both soft and hard processes and therefore for the production of heavy flavor . shadowing factor @xmath149 can be calculated within the glauber - gribov theory , and here it is already included in the nuclear pdf ratios . the final state effects can be addressed taking , for example , the co - movers interaction model @xcite . assuming a pure longitudinal expansion and boost invariance of the system , the rate equation which includes both dissociation and recombination effects for the density of charmonium at a given production point at impact parameter @xmath150 reads @xmath151 \ ; , \label{eq : rateeq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath152 , @xmath153 and @xmath154 is the density of comovers , @xmath2 and open charm , respectively , and @xmath155 is the interaction cross section for both dissociation of charmonium with co - movers and regeneration of @xmath2 from @xmath130 pairs in the system averaged over the momentum distribution of the participants . it is the constant of proportionality for both the dissociation and recombination terms due to detailed balance @xmath156 the solution of eq . ( [ eq : rateeq ] ) can be approximated by @xmath157 \ , \ln \left [ \frac{n^{co}}{n_{pp}(0 ) } \right ] \right\ } , \nonumber \\ n^{sh } & = & \frac{\left ( d \sigma^{c\bar{c}}_{pp } \big/ dy \right)^2 } { \sigma^{nd}_{pp } d \sigma^{j/\psi}_{pp } \big/ dy } n_{bin}(b , s ) s^{shad}(b , s , y)\ , . \label{eq : c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] details of the model can be found in @xcite and the quantities in eq . ( [ eq : c ] ) are all related to @xmath37 collisions at the corresponding energy and should be taken from experiment ( the extrapolation for lhc is quite uncertain ) . the magnitude of recombination effect is controlled by the total charm cross section in @xmath37 collisions and then dissociation - recombination effects will be of crucial importance in pbpb collisions at lhc . at this stage is difficult to single out the size of each contribution at the lhc for the @xmath158 . for such photon - associated high-@xmath9 quarkonium production , the final production cross section is modified by nuclear absorption , or final - state interaction between the pre - resonance state and the nuclear medium as discussed above . notice that the glauber absorption model is only valid for total production cross section which is dominated by low-@xmath9 quarkonium production . here , we focus on the transverse momentum dependence of the nuclear modification factor due to gluon shadowing and it is timely to discuss the @xmath9 dependence of the final - state interaction . to address this issue , we can do an educated guess by verifying what we learn from rhic . the modification factor @xmath159 has been determined as a function of @xmath9 in the central rapidity region , analyzed both by the phenix @xcite and star @xcite collaborations . the factor increases with @xmath9 and star data indicate a nuclear modification factor larger than one for @xmath160 gev @xcite . if this non - suppression of @xmath2 at large @xmath9 is confirmed it does not seem to behave as the other hadrons , which are significantly suppressed in central collisions and for increasing @xmath9 . this behavior is closer to the one observed in prompt photons production . in the case of quarkonium plus a prompt photon , we then would expect the same non - suppresion pattern , since the hard photon is not affected by nuclear matter effects . as a final comment , we notice that the present calculation can be also extended for the rhic kinematic region , where the @xmath21 annihilation processes could also contribute . for instance , a study has been done in ref . @xcite for the inclusive @xmath2 production in @xmath37 collisions at rhic within the phenix detector acceptance range using the color singlet and the color octet mechanisms based on nrqcd formalism . the calculations reproduce the rhic data with respect to the @xmath9 distribution , the rapidity distribution and the total cross section at @xmath161 gev . in ref . @xcite , the authors have considered the csm approach ( taking into account the @xmath150-channel cut contributions @xcite ) and cold nuclear matter effects to compute the @xmath2 nuclear modification factor for @xmath162 and @xmath163 collisions at rhic energies . the data description is quite satisfactory . therefore , this indicates the robustness of the framework in describing the high energy data . of course , we are aware of the limitations of present calculation . the picture of a @xmath2 exactly recoiling back to back with the photon is simplified , since possible contributions of the color - octet channel would lead to a fragmentation of the gluon into the meson , which would not be exactly recoiling against the photon . the experimental detection could be an additional concern . for example , alice @xcite can tag the muons in the forward region , where however there is no photon reconstruction , while it can detect the photons in the central region , where however the muon detection is not as good . in the case of cms @xcite , the thresholds in @xmath9 both for muons and for the photon appear quite low to ensure an efficient triggering . in summary , in this letter we have investigated the quarkonium production in association with a isolated photon in pa and aa collisions at the lhc , considering the nrqcd factorization formalism and some of the parameterizations for the nuclear parton distributions available in the literature . our results show that the nuclear modification factors @xmath18 and @xmath19 are useful observables to discriminate among the different parton distributions in the nuclear medium . in particular , the predicted shadowing by the eps parameterization is considerably larger than in the previous nuclear pdf s . the nuclear effects are different at central and at forward rapidities , so measuring the nuclear production of @xmath0 and @xmath1 in these two regions could give additional insights about the correct nuclear gluon distribution . these complementary observables to the inclusive production are useful to shed light on quarkonium production where the lack of a good benchmark , both for proton - proton collisions , where the actual mechanism of quarkonium production is not known , and proton - nucleus collisions where the relative magnitude of the different effects ( shadowing , nuclear absorption ) can not be fixed by present experimental data . j.f amundson , o.j.p . @xmath164boli , e. m. gregores and f. halzen , phys . * b372 * ( 1996 ) 127 ; g. a. schuler and r. vogt , phys . lett . * b387 * ( 1996 ) 181 ; c. brenner mariotto , m. b. gay ducati and g. ingelman , eur . phys . j. c * 23 * , 527 ( 2002 ) . a. capella and e. g. ferreiro , eur . j. c * 42 * , 419 ( 2005 ) . a. capella _ et al _ , eur . j. c * 58 * , 437 ( 2008 ) ; k. tywoniuk _ et al . _ , j. phys . g : nucl . part . phys . * 35 * , 104156 ( 2008 ) . m. leitch [ phenix collaboration ] , nucl * a830 * , 27c ( 2009 ) .

the quarkonium hadroproduction in association with a photon at high energies provides a probe of the dynamics of the strong interactions as it is dependent on the nuclear gluon distribution . therefore , it could be used to constrain the behavior of the nuclear gluon distribution in proton - nucleus and nucleus - nucleus collisions . such processes are useful to single out the magnitude of the shadowing / antishadowing effects in the nuclear parton densities . in this work we investigate the influence of nuclear effects in the production of @xmath0 and @xmath1 and estimate the transverse momentum dependence of the nuclear modification factors . the theoretical framework considered in the @xmath2 ( @xmath3 ) production associated with a direct photon at the hadron collider is the non - relativistic qcd ( nrqcd ) factorization formalism .

1403.3523

ever since the discovery of the geometrical phase accompanying adiabatic driving in quantum systems @xcite , the role that geometric quantities play in many physical phenomena has been in the focus of intense research @xcite . by geometric quantities we mean here quantities which are determined solely by the geometry of the path drawn by the changing driving parameters . the berry phase is one such quantity : as a quantum system is adiabatically transported along a closed cycle in the space of the driving parameters , its wave function accumulates a phase @xmath1 which depends only on the geometry of the cycle . in particular , @xmath1 is the line integral of a vector field ( the berry connection ) over the closed path in the parameter space . geometric quantities are indeed common in other branches of physics besides quantum mechanics , and all can be expressed as the line integral of some vector field . the most prominent example is the work output @xmath2 per cycle of a thermodynamic engine @xcite . this is perhaps the simplest example of a geometric pump , namely , a system that adiabatically converts an ac driving into a dc current ( not to be confused with rectification ) . like the thermodynamic engine , any geometric pump is fully characterized by a vector field @xmath3 , which we shall call the pumping field . adiabatic pumps are currently in the limelight of topical experimental and theoretical research . stochastic pumps @xcite , whose mechanisms underlie , e.g. , the functioning of brownian motors @xcite , or heat pumps @xcite are important examples . quantum charge pumps @xcite , based on the adiabatic manipulation of coherent devices , are another exciting avenue of research of this kind , also in view of their application to metrology @xcite . since the pioneering paper by thouless @xcite many aspects of adiabatic pumping have been elucidated . an incomplete list includes the scattering theory of ( charge , spin , heat ) pumping @xcite , its extension to include electron - electron interaction @xcite , the theory of cooper - pair pumping in superconducting nanocircuits @xcite , and topological pumping @xcite . along with this intense theoretical activity , a number of important experiments have been successfully performed @xcite . in all these cases , dissipation plays an unavoidable , possibly constructive role , whose features are yet to be fully understood . this motivated a renewed interest in studying the combined effects of noise and driving @xcite in the context of adiabatic quantum transport @xcite . all those prior attempts attacked the problem by solving the reduced dynamics of the slowly driven open quantum system within some approximation scheme appropriate to each specific physical case . this gives the reduced density matrix @xmath4 , which is used to calculate the instantaneous current @xmath5 , and by time integration the total pumped charge , out of which one has to single out the geometric contribution . here we pursue instead _ a geometric approach _ to calculate the pumping field @xmath3 giving the geometrically pumped charge directly . our approach is based on the salient observation that , independent of the specific physical scenario , @xmath3 is in fact the vector of linear response coefficients in the adiabatic expansion of the current [ see eq . ( [ eq : taylor ] ) below ] . to the best of our knowledge , this result was never exploited before in the context of dissipative quantum pumping . it brings about two main advantages : ( i ) when applied to an open quantum system , it leads to an exact expression of @xmath0 in terms of equilibrium quantum correlation functions , which are calculated at frozen driving parameters . that is , our scheme makes evident that solving the _ reduced _ dynamics of an undriven system suffices . ( ii ) since @xmath3 characterizes the geometric pumping fully , once one knows it , calculating the charge pumped along any cycle is as simple as doing a line integral . besides , the curl @xmath6 provides immediate visual information about the geometric features associated to dissipative pumping . these unveil the possibility of many previously undetected dissipation - assisted operation protocols . see our cooper - pair sluice example below . our expression of the pumping field [ see eq . ( [ eq : f ] ) ] can be used in a wide range of cases of experimental interest , ranging from electron pumps based on quantum dots to cooper - pair pumps in superconducting devices . we illustrate the method in the latter case . to this end we pursue here the derivation of a specific equation of motion ( eom ) for the calculation of equilibrium quantum correlation functions at fixed driving parameters under the sole assumption of weak coupling to a bosonic bath . we emphasize that the eom neither rests on a markov nor a rotating wave approximation . consider a generic geometric pump , namely , a physical device that can be externally manipulated by several control parameters @xmath7 and supports the flow of a current @xmath8 . we are interested in the `` charge '' @xmath9 that is transported by the device as the parameters draw a closed path @xmath10 in the parameter space . the symbol @xmath11 denotes the time duration of the cycle . in general , the transported charge has a geometric contribution . the key to singling out the geometric component of the transported charge is to perform an `` adiabatic expansion '' of the current at any generic time @xmath12 , namely , a taylor expansion of the current @xmath8 in terms of the rate of change @xmath13 of the parameters : @xmath14 where the coefficients @xmath15 are functions of the value @xmath16 taken by the parameters at time @xmath12 . accordingly , the transported charge is given by @xmath17 the zeroth - order term is what is customarily referred to as the dynamical charge . it is due to the fact that charge could possibly flow even at fixed parameters @xcite . note that the dynamical charge depends very strongly on the duration of the cycle : the same cycle operated at half the speed would result in twice the dynamic charge . the first - order term , in contrast , is geometric , because @xmath18 depends only on the geometry of the path . on the contrary , the higher - order terms are not geometric , because the change of variable @xmath19 would not suffice to remove the explicit @xmath13 dependence of their integrands . thus the full geometric contribution to the transported charge @xmath20 is exactly and solely given by @xmath21 with @xmath0 the vector of adiabatic linear response coefficients , and @xmath6 its curl . ( the double integral is a surface integral over any surface having @xmath10 as its contour , i.e. , the stokes theorem . ) , @xmath22 are separated by a superconducting island ( green ) whose polarization charge @xmath23 is externally controlled by the gate voltage @xmath24 . the resistor ( blue ) represents environmental gate noise of thermal energy @xmath25 . the threading magnetic flux @xmath26 fixes the overall phase difference @xmath27 across the sluice . right panel : typical driving path used in experiments @xcite . ] as an application of timely interest , we consider the cooper - pair sluice @xcite sketched in fig . [ fig : sluice ] . the sluice consists of two superconducting quantum interference devices ( squids ) separated by a superconducting island . the system is phase biased , with the phase difference @xmath27 . the two squids with respective josephson couplings @xmath28 and @xmath29 can be independently manipulated by controlling the magnetic flux threading each of them , @xmath30 and @xmath31 . the island is further capacitively coupled to a gate electrode controlling its polarization charge in units of cooper pairs @xmath32 , where @xmath33 is the gate capacitance , @xmath34 is the electron s charge , and @xmath24 is the applied gate voltage . the three driving parameters in this case are @xmath35 , @xmath36 , and @xmath37 , with @xmath38 the charging energy of the island . we assume the sluice is operated in the regime where the charging energy @xmath38 is much larger than @xmath28 and @xmath29 . in this regime the sluice can be conveniently modeled as a tunable two - level system . in the basis of charge states @xmath39 , the hamiltonian reads @xmath40 , with @xmath41/2 $ ] , @xmath42/2 $ ] , and @xmath43 ( @xmath44 are the pauli matrices ) . the charge flowing through the sluice is associated to the current operator @xcite @xmath45 the sluice is subject to thermal noise at temperature @xmath46 coming from the voltage gate . depending on the time scale @xmath47 , there are two distinct adiabatic regimes : the coherent regime and the dissipative regime @xcite . the first is relevant when the driving time @xmath47 is very short compared to the thermal relaxation and decoherence times but long compared to the transition times @xmath48 . accordingly , one performs an adiabatic expansion around the eigenstate @xmath49 ( as in @xcite ) , and the pumping field emerges as @xmath50 for the cooper pair sluice working close to the ground state , we obtain , for its curl , the following analytical result : @xmath51 notice that @xmath52 , where @xmath53 is the ground - state berry curvature @xcite . in the case when the driving time @xmath47 is very short compared to the thermal - relaxation time , instead , the reference state around which the expansion is performed is the instantaneous thermal state @xmath54 , with @xmath55 the partition function and @xmath56 the total hamiltonian , sum of system , environment , and coupling hamiltonians , respectively . the adiabatic linear response theory developed in ref . @xcite gives then @xmath57 where @xmath58 , @xmath59 , and the subscripts of @xmath60 and @xmath61 denote that these operators are considered in the heisenberg representation generated by the full hamiltonian ( [ totalh ] ) ( with fixed @xmath16 ) at the times @xmath62 and @xmath63 , respectively . note that , as anticipated , the correlation functions of eq . ( [ eq : f ] ) are evaluated at fixed @xmath16 . clearly , their evaluation does not involve the solution of a driven open - system dynamics . the expression ( [ eq : f ] ) is exact and approximations enter only at the point of evaluating it . below we present our original method for its calculation . we emphasize that eq . ( [ eq : f ] ) can not be obtained within the common reduced density matrix approach @xcite , because the sole , single - time , reduced density matrix operator does not suffice for the exact evaluation of two - time quantum correlations @xcite . we model the thermal environment of the sluice as a set of harmonic oscillators @xcite : @xmath64 here @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , are the oscillators positions , momenta , masses , and frequency , respectively , @xmath69 is a system operator , and @xmath70 is an environment operator . the evaluation of the field @xmath71 in ( 7 ) involves evaluating the equilibrium quantum correlation function at various , but fixed , parameter values @xmath16 . the dependence of @xmath3 on @xmath16 comes from the parametric dependence of the total hamiltonian @xmath72 on @xmath16 . to this end we begin by writing the imaginary - time integrals in eq . ( [ eq : f ] ) as real - time integrals @xcite , @xmath73\rangle_{\bm b}^\text{eq } = \frac{i}{\hbar}\int_0^\infty d{s}\,\,{s}\,\mathrm{tr}_s i ( \bm y_{-{s}}-\bm y_{-{s}}^{\dagger } ) $ ] , where @xmath74\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath75 denotes trace over the system ( environment ) hilbert space . the operator @xmath61 belongs to the system - hilbert space , while @xmath76 is the evolution operator with a _ fixed _ , frozen @xmath16 . for simplicity of notation , we will keep in the following , the parametric dependence on the fixed @xmath16 implicit . our aim is to obtain an equation of motion ( eom ) @xcite for @xmath77 . we first focus on the auxiliary operator in the full - hilbert space @xmath78 . next , using the kubo identity @xmath79 $ ] we expand the evolution operator @xmath80 up to second order in @xmath81 to obtain @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the free evolution of @xmath81 , and @xmath84 is the truncated - evolution operator in the interaction picture . using the above definition of the evolution operator and differentiating @xmath85 with respect to @xmath86 we obtain an integro - differential equation , @xmath87-\frac{i}{\hbar}[h_{se},\bm y^{{{\scriptscriptstyle}\text{tot}}}(-{s})]\nonumber \\ & -\frac{1}{\hbar^{2}}\int_{0}^{{s}}{d}{s}_{{\scriptscriptstyle}{1 } } [ h_{se},[h_{se}({s}_{{\scriptscriptstyle}{1}}-{s}),\bm y^{{{\scriptscriptstyle}\text{tot}}}(-{s})]],\end{aligned}\ ] ] involving the operator @xmath88 . the latter contains information about the system - environment coupling due to the presence of @xmath89 . hence , we proceed to expand that up to first order . using the expansion of the equilibrium density matrix @xcite @xmath90,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath91 and @xmath92 , we obtain @xmath93 where @xmath94 with @xmath95 . using the above expansion in eq . ( [ eq : ywoi ] ) and keeping terms only up to second order in @xmath81 , we find @xmath96-\frac{i}{\hbar}[h_{se},\tilde{\bm y}^{{{\scriptscriptstyle}\text{tot}}}(-{s } ) ] \nonumber \\ & + \frac{i}{\hbar}\int_{0}^{\beta}{d}\beta_{{{\scriptscriptstyle}1 } } [ h_{se},\tilde{\bm y}^{{{\scriptscriptstyle}\text{tot}}}(-{s})h_{se}(-{s}-i\hbar\beta_{{{\scriptscriptstyle}1 } } ) ] \nonumber \\ & -\frac{1}{\hbar^{2}}\int_{0}^{{s}}{d}{s}_{{\scriptscriptstyle}{1 } } [ h_{se},[h_{se}({s}_{{\scriptscriptstyle}{1}}-{s}),\tilde{\bm y}^{{{\scriptscriptstyle}\text{tot}}}(-{s})]].\end{aligned}\ ] ] tracing over the environment degrees of freedom and using @xmath97 , we obtain the equation of motion for the reduced operator @xmath77 as @xmath98+\frac{1}{\hbar^{2}}\left(\mathcal{r}+\mathcal{j}\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath99{\mathrm{c}}({s}_{{\scriptscriptstyle}{1}}-{s } ) \nonumber \\ & - [ a , a({s}_{{\scriptscriptstyle}{1}}-{s})\bm y_{-{s}}]{\mathrm{c}}({s}-{s}_{{\scriptscriptstyle}{1}}),\\ \mathcal{j}&=i\hbar\int_{0}^{\beta}{d}\beta_{{\scriptscriptstyle}{1 } } [ a,\bm y_{-{s}}a(-{s}-i\hbar\beta_{{\scriptscriptstyle}{1}})]{\mathrm{c}}(-{s}-i\hbar\beta_{{\scriptscriptstyle}{1}}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath100 and we have taken @xmath101 , which is valid for an environment composed of harmonic oscillators . above , we have replaced @xmath102 in the second - order terms since we are interested in the weak - coupling regime . casting eq . ( [ eq : yop ] ) in the energy eigenbasis of the system hamiltonian @xmath103 , we obtain our central result for the equation of motion as @xmath104 where @xmath105 , with @xmath106 s being the systems eigenenergies , and @xmath107 \nonumber \\ & -\delta_{l , m } \sum_{j } a_{nj}a_{jk}w_{jk}(0,{s})-\delta_{n , k } \sum_{j } a_{lj } a_{jm}w_{jl}^{*}(0,{s}),\\ \mathcal{j}_{nm}^{kl } & = a_{nk}a_{lm}\left[w_{ml}^{*}({s},\infty)-{\mathop{\mathrm{e}}\nolimits}^{\beta\hbar\omega_{lm}}w_{lm}({s},\infty)\right ] \nonumber \\ & -\delta_{n , k}\sum_{j}a_{lj}a_{jm}\left[w_{jl}^{*}({s},\infty)-{\mathop{\mathrm{e}}\nolimits}^{\beta\hbar\omega_{lj}}w_{lj}({s},\infty)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] we recall that the eigenenergies @xmath108 , as well as the coefficients @xmath109 , @xmath110 , @xmath111 , all depend parametrically on @xmath16 . the contribution @xmath112 in eq . ( [ eq : yop ] ) accounts for the salient thermal equilibrium correlations between system and environment . in this initial value term @xmath113 we have converted the imaginary - time integral for the environment correlators to real time using the standard kubo scheme ( see in ref . note that the operator @xmath77 above does not obey the basic properties of reduced density operator , i.e. , it is not trace preserving [ @xmath114 , and it need not be positive . hence , it is worth stressing here that the above eom is _ not _ a master equation for the reduced density operator . in order to derive the eom above , we solely made use of the weak system - environment coupling approximation . the non - markovian nature of this eom , however , is evident from the @xmath86 dependence in the @xmath115 values , i.e. , no markov approximation has been used . figure [ fig : fig2 ] presents various density plots of the @xmath132 component of the curl field on various planes of constant @xmath133 . the first column refers to the coherent regime , eq . ( [ eq : g0 ] ) , whereas the last two columns refer to the dissipative regime at two different temperatures , as obtained from solving eq . ( [ eq : master3 ] ) . for the dissipative regime , gate noise is modeled through @xmath134 with coupling coefficients @xmath135 @xcite . for the environment , we chose an ohmic spectral density @xmath136 with a lorentz - drude cutoff @xmath137 : @xmath138^{-1}$ ] . here @xmath139 determines the dissipation strength . printed in black ( red ) are the values , @xmath20 , of the geometrically pumped charge on a path encircling the whole graph ( black paths ) and half graph ( red paths ) , respectively . striking differences emerge between the two regimes . the most apparent is the emergence of an asymmetry of @xmath140 under @xmath141 , in the dissipative regime as opposed to the coherent regime . this is due to the fact that the two charge states @xmath142 and @xmath143 are differently coupled to the bath . at finite dissipation the asymmetry is weak for small values of @xmath144 , while at large @xmath144 values , it even turns ( at least approximately ) into an odd symmetry . interestingly , this can be used to enhance the pumped charge . take , for example , paths that enclose half of the graph , cf . the red paths in fig . [ fig : fig2 ] . at finite dissipation , they pump more than the paths enclosing the whole graph , where upper and lower parts contribute with opposite signs to the pumped charge . one can pump as much as @xmath145 per cycle on the red path at @xmath146 , @xmath147 . the same path would pump as little as @xmath148 in the zero dissipation case . this evidences the beneficial role of dissipation in quantum pumping . dissipation can even give rise to a change of direction of the current . to conceive this current reversal we shall recall that the force response @xmath149 is composed of two terms : the friction @xmath150 and a geometric magnetism @xmath151 @xcite : @xmath152 , respectively given by the symmetric and antisymmetric component of the conductance matrix , @xmath153 , according to the formulas @xmath154 , @xmath155 [ where @xmath156 is the levi - civita symbol and @xmath157 . we recall that @xmath150 is exactly null in the coherent regime . noticing that the current operator , eq . ( [ eq : i ] ) , is a linear combination of @xmath158 and @xmath159 allows us to express the pumping field @xmath3 as a linear combination of the @xmath160 values or , accordingly , of their symmetric and antisymmetric parts , @xmath161 and @xmath162 . this in turn allows us to quantify the fractions of pumped charge due to geometric magnetism and friction , respectively . we have found that both contributions are greatly affected by the presence of the thermal bath but appear to have competing roles , i.e. , they possess opposite signs . on the red paths in fig . [ fig : fig2 ] , friction wins over geometric magnetism at finite @xmath139 , thus resulting in a different current direction as compared to the coherent case where only geometric magnetism is present @xcite . each pixel in the graphs presented in fig . [ fig : fig2 ] is the result of a single simulation at the corresponding value @xmath16 of the parameters . in fig . [ fig:3 ] ( left panel ) we report additional results for one particular slice of @xmath163 , and @xmath164 for a weaker system - environment coupling strength , @xmath165 , as compared to the coupling strength @xmath166 in fig . [ fig : fig2 ] . the right panel of fig . [ fig:3 ] depicts the pumped charge @xmath167 for @xmath168 and @xmath166 for the red and black paths , as shown in fig . [ fig : fig2 ] . as expected , the pumped charge decreases with the increase in temperature . we have presented a geometric method for calculation of the geometrically pumped charge @xmath20 in dissipative quantum systems . the method is based on the calculation of the pumping field @xmath3 and uses the salient observation that the latter coincides with the vector of linear response coefficients of the adiabatic expansion of the current [ eq . ( [ eq : taylor ] ) ] . for a dissipative open quantum system , this is given by equilibrium quantum correlation functions calculated at fixed driving parameters [ eq . ( [ eq : f ] ) ] . hence , in contrast to the customary procedure , they can be conveniently evaluated by solving an undriven problem . our method for the calculation of @xmath3 consists in deriving an equation of motion for a properly chosen observable under only the assumption of weak coupling ( no markov approximation , no rotating wave approximation , no factorized initial condition ) . the timely application to the cooper - pair sluice reveals an interplay of geometric magnetism and a dissipation - induced enhancement of pumped charge , the emergence of current reversals , and asymmetries . all these novel phenomena can _ a priori _ be identified visually upon the mere inspection of the pumping field in control parameter space . most importantly , the results presented in our fig . [ fig : fig2 ] can be experimentally checked with current devices and setups . the authors thank jukka pekola for useful remarks . this research was supported by a marie curie intra european fellowship within the 7th european community framework programme through the projects nequflux , 623085 ( m.c . ) , and thermiq , grant no . 618074 ( r.f . ) , by the cost action mp1209 through a short term scientific mission ( m.c . ) ; by miur - prin , `` collective quantum phenomena : from strongly correlated systems to quantum simulators '' ( r.f . ) , and by the volkswagen foundation , project no . i/83902 ( p.h . , m.c . ) . this work is dedicated to the memory of late prof . donald h. kobe . for example , a fluidic current flows through a peristaltic pump if none of the pistons fully obstructs the channel in presence of a pressure gradient . similarly a superconducting current flows through a cooper pair sluice in presence of a phase bias .

the charge transported when a quantum pump is adiabatically driven by time - dependent external forces in presence of dissipation is given by the line integral of a pumping field @xmath0 . we give a general expression of @xmath0 in terms of quantum correlation functions evaluated at fixed external forces . hence , an advantage of our method is that it transforms the original time - dependent problem into an autonomous one . yet another advantage is that the curl of @xmath0 gives immediate visual information about the geometric structures governing dissipative quantum pumping . this can be used in a wide range of experimental cases , including electron pumps based on quantum dots and cooper - pair pumps based on superconducting devices . applied to a cooper - pair sluice , we find an intriguing dissipation - induced enhancement of charge pumping , reversals of current , and emergence of asymmetries . this geometric method thus enables one to unveil a plethora of beneficial , dissipation - assisted operation protocols .

physics0412075

energy transfer mechanisms in molecules exposed to short intense laser pulses is of great current interest @xcite . processes such as multiple photoionization , multiphoton dissociation and high - order harmonic generation have been studied for a wide - range of molecular species and an excellent up - to - date review of the field has been provided by posthumus @xcite . the hydrogen molecule and molecular ion represent ideal systems for a detailed understanding of ionization and dissociation dynamics of small molecules @xcite . the simplicity of molecule means that it is the system of choice for theoretical studies . in general the mechanisms of dissociation @xcite and ionization @xcite are very well characterised for this molecule . nonetheless , the solution of three - body disintegration , incorporating spatial and temporal variations in the laser pulse as well as the thermal ensemble of molecular states , remains a severe challenge for simulation . consequently , progress has been fairly limited in dissociative ionization spectrum calculations . although there exists a wealth of data on the photofragment energy spectrum for the neutral molecule , h@xmath4 , and its deuterated forms @xcite . the data for the much simpler isolated molecular ion is extremely scarce . the feasibility of experimental studies is hampered by the difficulty in preparing the molecular ion . in fact experiments on h@xmath5 in intense laser fields has only become possible in the last 4 years @xcite due to refinements in ion sources and charged molecular beam spectroscopy . typically a small portion of the molecules , at a temperature of a few hundred kelvin and hence predominantly in the vibrational state @xmath6 , can be converted into the bound molecular ion by electron - impact ionization , @xmath7 the molecular ions can be extracted , cooled and collimated into a beam that can be injected to the focus of the laser . the photodissociation and/or photoionization processes , @xmath8 produce ions and electrons that can be collected and analysed . owing to the small nuclear mass , the expansion ( vibration ) is very rapid - on the scale of 10 fs or less . consequently the molecule relaxes extremely rapidly on the timescale of the pulse rise time . the design of infrared pulses that would , among other things , allow the resolution of timescale of a fraction of a femtosecond . the main aim of this paper is a direct comparison of theory and experiment for the proton energy spectrum produced by a short intense infrared pulse interacting with h@xmath5 @xcite . fragment - ion coincidence measurements that isolate the dissociation and dissociative ionization processes and make the comparison of theory and experiment feasible and realistic . the molecular dissociation dynamics are modelled using a two - state approximation and takes account of the laser pulse profile . although this approach neglects the ionization channels , the results for dissociation energies are in excellent agreement with the observations . the characteristic vibrational and rotational time of the h@xmath5 molecule are @xmath9 fs and @xmath10 fs , respectively . for a pulse duration 60 fs or less , the laser interaction is sudden on the rotational timescale . thus one can assume a random statistical orientation of the molecular axis , and that the nuclei recoil along the axial direction . we assume that the bound ion is created by vertical transitions from the @xmath11 state of the neutral @xmath12 . the parameters of this potential surface are , bond length @xmath13a.u . with vibrational constants , @xmath14ev and @xmath15 . the @xmath11 wavepacket is promoted onto the corresponding molecular - ion surface @xmath16 with parameters @xmath17a.u . , @xmath18ev , @xmath19ev and @xmath20 @xcite . the @xmath11 state is projected onto the @xmath21 manifold of states according to the franck - condon principle @xcite . the manifold of @xmath21-states is then subjected to intense ti : sapphire light . in the dissociation process , momentum is conserved , for a symmetric pulse , and the recoiling atom and ion have equal and opposite velocity in the centre - of - mass frame . the ions and atoms are collected in coincidence such that dissociation and dissociative ionization can be discriminated . however , depending on the method of measurement , the atomic fragments can arise from the entire focal volume of the laser . so a valid theoretical comparison must firstly establish the single molecule energy spectra , and then sum these spectra with the appropriate focal volume weighting for the experiment . the intensity @xmath22 of a focused cylindrically - symmetric laser beam is spatially gaussian in the radial @xmath23-direction and lorentzian along the axis @xmath24 @xcite @xmath25}\right\}.\ ] ] where the minimum waist of the beam @xmath26 and rayleigh range @xmath27 are given by @xmath28 respectively . in our method , we first discuss the single - molecule response in detail , and then describe the orientation - averaged and focal - volume integrated results . the electronic coordinate , with respect to the origin at the internuclear midpoint , is denoted by @xmath29 and the internuclear coordinate is written as @xmath30 . the two lowest electronic states , namely the ground state @xmath31 , and @xmath32 are sufficient for the study of pure dissociation dynamics . the corresponding adiabatic energies are @xmath33 and @xmath34 . then the two - state approximation is @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath37 are the time - dependent nuclear wavefunctions . in restricting the electronic spectrum to the two lowest levels , the calculations will inevitably be gauge dependence . for low frequency fields ( much less than the energy level gap ) it is essential to use the length gauge for the laser - molecule interaction . let us take the light as linearly polarized along the direction @xmath38 , and denote the dipole moment between @xmath39 as @xmath40 . writing the electric field as @xmath41 , the coupling potential is denoted by @xmath42 , where @xmath43 . within the axial - recoil approximation , @xmath44 , is the angle of ejection of the ion(atom ) with respect to the polarization vector . averaging over the molecular orientation is equivalent to averaging the projection of the electric field along the molecular axis . since the dissociation rate increases rapidly with intensity over the range , @xmath45 w @xmath3 , it follows that the atoms and ions are ejected predominantly along the polarization direction . it is highly anisotropic . however at the higher intensities , @xmath46 w @xmath3 , the dissociation process begins to saturate and , as we will show , the angular distribution is broader . taking @xmath47 to denote the reduced mass of the protons , and using atomic units , the two - state coupled equations are : @xmath48 to a very good approximation @xcite the potential functions can be written in the form , @xmath49 , \\ e_u(r ) & = & 0.1025 \left[e^{-1.44(r-2 ) } + 2.22e^{-0.72(r-2 ) } \right ] \label{morse}\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , the dipole moment @xcite can be fitted by the function @xcite @xmath50 with , @xmath51 . for a frequency @xmath52 and peak field strength @xmath53 this is related to the cycle - average intensity , @xmath54 . the time - dependence of the field can be written explicitly as @xmath55 in this paper we use the gaussian profile that most closely models the pulses in the experiment of interest , @xmath56\ ] ] where @xmath57 is the maximum , and @xmath58 defines the duration of the laser pulse . discretization methods previously developed for photodissociation @xcite and photoionization of molecules @xcite can be readily applied . the discrete - variable representation ( dvr ) has proven to be a very efficient and accurate method in solving both time - independent and time - dependent schrdinger equations . the cartesian lagrange functions @xcite are given by @xmath59\exp\left[i\frac{2\pi k}{n}x\right ] \label{c/08/02/04}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the mesh points @xmath60 ( @xmath61 ) . the radial coordinate @xmath30 is discretised on this mesh cartesian mesh between the limits @xmath62 , with @xmath63 , such that : @xmath64 + { \textstyle { 1 \over 2 } } ( r_{max}+r_{min})\ ] ] then the wavefunctions are expanded as : @xmath65 } \hspace*{0.2cm}(\sigma = g , u ) \label{psiexpan}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath66 . then the matrix equation corresponding to equations ( [ c1 ] and [ c2 ] ) is a dense set of @xmath67 linear equations ( @xmath68 ) : @xmath69 the matrix elements of the kinetic operator are given by @xcite @xmath70 } { \sin^2\left[\pi(i - j)/n\right ] } & i\neq j. \end{array } \right.\ ] ] where the scale factor is , @xmath71 . the diagonal potentials are : @xmath72 with the off - diagonal coupling : @xmath73 we integrate the differential equations using the 18th order arnoldi propagator as described by peng et al @xcite . as is well known @xcite , for @xmath74 , the moment @xmath75 , and the coupling is divergent in the molecular basis . this is simply a manifestation of the molecular basis and the use of the length gauge . it is necessary and convenient to transform to the asymptotic decoupled atomic eigenstates for the energy spectrum . these asymptotic states then evolve adiabatically at large distances and long times . however these states in turn are unbounded in configuration space . as shown by keller @xcite , it is possible to project the diffuse adiabatic asymptotic states onto a compact momentum space . more importantly , this methods produces the energy spectrum of the atoms that can be compared with experiment . following @xcite we divide the entire range of @xmath30 into two regions ; an internal region(_in _ ) , where the molecular forces are significant , and an asymptotic region ( _ as _ ) where they are not . the short - range polarization potential means that the interaction region can be comparatively small ( of the order 20 a.u . ) . then the wavefunction can be partitioned as follows : @xmath76 where : @xmath77 with @xmath78\right)^{-1}\ ] ] where @xmath79 is dividing point and @xmath80 is a parameter which determines the smoothness of the partition . in the asymptotic region hamiltonian is diagonalised by transforming to the atom+ion states @xmath81 : @xmath82 these states evolve into superpositions ( sums over momentum ) of the asymptotic states : @xmath83 ^ 2\right ] \label{scatt}\ ] ] where the ion quiver momentum is @xmath84 a symmetric or zero - area pulse is such that : @xmath85 . the key step in obtaining an energy spectrum is the projection of the numerical wavefunction onto the the continuum of asymptotic states ( [ scatt ] ) . it is efficient to do this by discretizing the @xmath86-space and performing a finite fourier transform @xcite . one difficulty with such an approach is that the momentum shift @xmath87 is a continuous function and inevitably leads to a mismatch of the @xmath86-grid . in the present calculations , we use the quadrature rule for the dvr to calculate the fourier transform directly . we define the shifted fourier transform : @xmath88 } \nonumber \\ & \times&\left\ { \exp\left [ -i r_{max } \left ( ( k\mp\delta_0(t , t^{\prime } ) ) - \frac{2\pi x_m}{nh}\right)\right ] \right . \nonumber \\ & - & \left . \exp\left [ -i r_{min } \left ( ( k\mp\delta_0(t , t^{\prime } ) ) -\frac{2\pi x_m}{nh}\right)\right ] \right\}. \label{myprop } \end{aligned}\ ] ] although this quadrature is less efficient than the fast - fourier transform , it allows for much greater flexibility in choosing the @xmath86 and @xmath30 grids . at each time step , the projection onto the momentum space is made and the coherent momentum space wavefunction is calculated . this process is repeated and continued for some time after the end of the pulse . this allows the dissociating wavepacket still within the interaction region time to reach the asymptotic zone , and for the low energy components to be captured . typically we extend the integration time to @xmath89 for this purpose . the @xmath86-space probability density is then given by @xcite : @xmath90 this choice of normalization gives : @xmath91 is the total probability for dissociation . the dissociation energy is shared equally by the fragments so that the proton energy is given by @xmath92 . the energy spectral density can then be calculated from the equation : @xmath93 for h@xmath96 with @xmath95 nm and pulse duration @xmath97fs . the vertical lines indicate the anticipated energy of the two - photon , three - photon and four - photon absorption from @xmath98.,width=510 ] firstly we consider photodissociation directly from @xmath98 of h@xmath5 . there are several very accurate proton spectra calculation for @xmath98 dissociation by @xmath99 nm pulses for @xmath100 w @xmath3 @xcite . we checked our calculations with these results and found excellent agreement in all cases . now consider long - wavelength dissociation , we recall that the dissociation energy of the @xmath98 state is @xmath18 ev . for @xmath0 nm , corresponding to the ti : sapphire laser , the photon energy is 1.57 ev . therefore dissociation is necessarily a second or higher order process . in figure [ figure1 ] we present results for the proton energy spectrum @xmath101 for a @xmath97fs pulse for a range of intensities . in these calculations , the number of points in @xmath30-space @xmath102 and the number of points in momentum space @xmath103 , with @xmath104 a.u . and @xmath105 a.u .. for the splitting procedure we use , @xmath106 and @xmath107 . for the time - dependent propagation we use @xmath108 . for a pulse of this length , the bandwidth ( fwhm ) is narrow @xmath109 ev , and this is reflected in the sharply - defined proton energy ( figures 1a,1b and 1c ) in the perturbation regime . in figure [ figure1 ] , the relative strength of the two- , three- and four - photon dissociation channels change dramatically with the variation of the pulse intensity . there is a propensity for the high - order process . as the interaction increases there is a leftward shift of the three - photon peaks in frame ( e ) to ( g ) . this is due to the downwards stark shift of the ground state . the leading - order term of this shift is approximately linear with intensity . the broadening of the peaks is evidence of the mixing of vibrational levels and shortening of the lifetime of the decaying state @xmath98 . in the last figure ( h ) at the highest intensity the spectrum is dominated by a large broad peak around 0.7 ev where the field - free vibrational structure is destroyed . at intensities above @xmath110 w @xmath3 , the process is saturated by tunelling dissociation and the spectrum is dominated by low energy ( less than 0.5 ev ) protons @xcite . this data underlines the difficulty in using time - independent perturbation theory to determine the ion spectrum and yield under these conditions . the second calculation ( figure [ figure2 ] ) concentrates on the effect of pulse length for a fixed intensity @xmath111 w @xmath3 . for pulses shorter than 15 fs the vibrational phase is accepted to play a role . however it is also important to note that the bandwidth has a significant effect . for example , a 5 fs pulse has a bandwidth of the order 0.35 ev . this would explain the skewness of the peak in figure 2(a ) , and the presence of the 4-photon peak . however , in figures 2(b ) and 2(c ) , the results resemble the narrow - band data in figure 1 . the oscillations in the peaks reflect wavepacket oscillations within the well and we discuss this in more detail later when investigating dissociation from excited vibrational states . for h@xmath96 with @xmath95 nm and i=@xmath112 w @xmath3 . the figure shows the effect of increasing pulse length ( a).@xmath113 fs ; ( b ) . @xmath114 fs ; ( c ) . @xmath115 fs . the three vertical lines indicate the weak - field two - photon , three - photon and four - photon absorption energies.,width=510 ] in the ion - beam experiments , h@xmath5 is prepared from the collisional ionization process ( equation [ coll ] ) . the h@xmath116 state is projected onto a coherent superposition of the h@xmath5 vibrational states , @xmath117 , where @xmath118 . the amplitudes @xmath119 are given by the franck - condon factors . so that @xcite in the absence of the laser the wavepackt evolves coherently @xmath120 where the relative phases @xmath121 are well defined constants , and @xmath122 are the vibrational energies . the overall phase @xmath123 depends on the time of formation of the ion . according to the franck - condon factors , the largest coefficients correspond to @xmath124 . however a small fraction of the population will be above the dissociation limit leading to shake - off dissociation . @xcite estimate of this population was around 2.8% . in the present calculations , using the energy curves of equation ( [ morse ] ) , we obtain a value around 0.8% . in experiment the shake - off process is eliminated and plays no role . however , the coherence of the @xmath21 states has an important role . since @xmath125 is determined by the start of the pulse the molecules arrive in the focal volume with random vibrational phase . the random nature of the time delay is equivalent to averaging over random vibration phase . we can readily illustrate the physical consequences of this time delay in the proton spectrum . suppose we choose the initial wavepacket as : @xmath126 then 0.8% of this wave function will naturally dissociative ( shake - off ) without laser interaction . in the calculations shown in [ figure3 ] , we present the proton energy distribution in the perturbation regime for a long pulse . the laser intensities are @xmath127 w @xmath3 and @xmath128 w @xmath3 respectively , with @xmath129 nm and pulse duration @xmath130 fs . the intensity - independent background that peaks at zero energy is the shake - off process . the rapid oscillations in this background are artifacts arising from the numerical method . the lowest energy states emerge most slowly and require long propagation times . the major source of noise is the splitting procedure that creates an interference pattern in the long - wavelength wavepacket components . however , above 0.3 ev the interference artifacts disappear and we are confident in the numerical accuracy of the energy spectrum in this range . the 1-photon dissociation threshold means that only levels @xmath131 appear . however the peak heights are modulated according to the values of both @xmath119 and the franck - condon dissociation factors . this vibrational structure has been resolved and measured experimentally @xcite . as predicted by the perturbation theory , the probability for the individual peak is proportional to the laser intensity . very recently , serov and coworkers @xcite have obtained results of excellent agreement with these experimental measurements after careful consideration of averaging over initial ro - vibrational states and over the focus volume effect of the laser pulse . at low laser intensities . the pulse length is @xmath130 fs and @xmath95 nm . full line : i=@xmath132 w @xmath3 ; dashed line : i=@xmath128 w @xmath3 . the low - energy background ( dotted line ) is the shake - off spectrum . the vibrational lines are single - photon peaks . the high intensity lines are 10 times stronger than the low intensity results as expected from perturbation theory.,width=377 ] in figure ( [ figure4 ] ) the results for high intensity show dramatic differences with perturbation theory . in order to compare with experiment , it is desirable to eliminate the spurious shake - off background . this can be achieved by projecting out the continuum or by waiting for the shake - off to occur and absorb the dissociation . in fact , the shake - off background is an imperceptible perturbation to the results at high intensity , as shown in figure [ figure4 ] . in practice , for intensities above @xmath133 w @xmath3 , we have not found it necessary to remove the shake - off wavepacket a priori . at higher intensities the two - photon dissociation process becomes important , and in figure [ figure4 ] ( b ) we include vertical dotted lines to indicate the expected positions of these peaks . again , at the highest intensities , the spectrum peaks move towards the lower energies although the spectrum also broadens . the peak heights in figure [ figure4 ] ( c ) and ( d ) are similar , but the yield is much higher for the higher intensity . the corresponding dissociation probabilities @xmath134 for each intensity are ? ? ? ? . as mentioned before , increasing the angle between molecule and polarization is equivalent to decreasing the intensity . then figure [ figure4 ] represents the angular - differential dissociation rates . thus for a spatially uniform pulse of cycle - average intensity @xmath111 w @xmath3 , figures [ figure4 ] ( b),(c ) and ( d ) are respectively the yields at @xmath13572 , 84 and 88 degrees . for pulses much longer than the vibrational time , the initial phase of the molecular wavepacket is not a significant factor . averaging over the initial phase has little effect . in the next section we will consider pulses of duration comparable to the vibrational dephasing time . @xmath6 . . the pulse parameter are @xmath130 fs and @xmath95 nm . the dashed vertical lines indicate the one - photon vibrational release with one photon absorption from different vibrational states and the dotted vertical line show those with two photon absorption.,width=472 ] w @xmath3 and @xmath95 nm . the corresponding laser pulse length is indicated in the figure for each curve.,width=377 ] in the well - known pump and dump technique , for heavy atoms within a molecule , the vibrational motion can be easily resolved by 100 fs pulses . however for the hydrogen atom the vibration is so fast ( @xmath136fs ) that this requires pulses of 40 fs or shorter . we have already shown ( figure [ figure2 ] ) that for h@xmath5 , the vibrational phase has a role for 20fs or less . in this section we consider the effect on the coherent wavepacket of @xmath21 states created from the @xmath11 state , and speculate on whether this can be resolved by experiments measuring the proton emission spectrum . we begin with a study of pulse length effects for the coherent state . in figure ( [ figure5 ] ) the features of the low - intensity pulse are considered for @xmath95 nm and @xmath137 w @xmath3 , choosing the molecular vibration phases by starting the clock ( pulse ) at @xmath125 . as noticed previously for @xmath98 , for very short pulses the bandwidth broadening and reduced duration leads to a flat spectrum with low dissociation yield . increasing the pulse duration allows the vibrational structure to be clearly resolved at @xmath138fs and the familiar franck - condon distribution highlighted in figure ( [ figure3 ] ) is apparent . also evident in figure([figure5 ] ) is the interference of the shake - off background with the low - energy spectrum . at higher intensity it has been shown that the vibrational signature in the dissociation spectrum can be destroyed to a large extent , even for long pulses . increasing intensity to @xmath139 w @xmath3 , confirms that this occurs for the coherent state ( figure [ figure6 ] ) . firstly , the proton energies shift to less than 1ev . we note that for the 40 fs pulse , the data is very similar to the 55 fs pulse shown in figure [ figure4 ] ( c ) . at the other end of the time scale , for 5fs pulses , the protons emerge with much higher energies that is , apart from the broadening of the peak due to bandwidth effects , the wavepacket favours the high frequency part of the pulse . however it is clear that in this case the pulse delay , or molecular phase , has an important role @xcite and @xcite . in figure ( [ figure7 ] ) we consider the 5 fs pulse and we present results for the wavepacket distribution in space along with the proton energy spectrum . the pulse is delayed by up to 20 fs with respect to the molecular vibration . firstly examining the energy spectrum , there is clearly a strong variation with pulse delay . the 0.7ev peak that appears in figure [ figure5 ] corresponding to the 5 fs peak with time delay 0 fs is clearly present in figure [ figure7 ] . the corresponding state in @xmath30-space is the gaussian wavepacket centred at @xmath140 . the short delay time allows the molecule to dissociate from small @xmath30 values and accelerate along the @xmath141 curve . with a delay of 1 fs the wavepacket moves outwards and disperses , this delay severely decreases the dissociation yield and attenuates the dissociation energy . after 7fs delay the molecular wavepacket is at the outer turning point . a pulse applied at this time yields a low yield peaked around 0.4 ev . as the delay time increases the vibrational components separate and dephase . at 20 fs for example , the wavepacket is irregular and diffuse as the high @xmath21 components become evident . the dissociation from this wavepacket produces a strong low - energy signal at 0.3 ev . comparing with figure [ figure4 ] for example , this energy can only be a bandwidth shifted state . that is , the @xmath142 state dissociating through a low energy photon . in a real experiment the random phases of vibration mean that these details are often lost . the molecular phase ( clock ) can be synchronized by using the same laser for photoionization and dissociation @xcite . however , the assumption that primary photoionization of h@xmath4 is a vertical transition has recently been shown to be invalid @xcite . this is not too surprising since it is generally not a good assumption for infrared light at high intensity . however it is a reasonable model for uv light or electron impact ionization . clearly the sensitivity of the proton spectrum is potentially a very useful tool for experimental diagnostics . the difficulty still exists in that a real laser pulse has temporal and spatial variations that can impede the observation of these details . for a long pulse @xmath143 fs , our calculations show that the kinetic energy distribution is not sensitive to the time - delay at the same intensity of @xmath133 w @xmath3 . at higher intensity of @xmath144 w @xmath3 , the spectrum shows only small structure effects due to pulse delay . in order to test our model with experiment we conclude our paper with a study in which we take into account the experimental parameters and integrate over the focal volume of the pulse and average over molecular orientation . w @xmath3 and @xmath95 nm . the pulse duration is indicated in the figure.,width=377 ] w @xmath3 and @xmath95 nm . ( a ) the @xmath30-space probability density at the start of the pulse ; ( b ) the corresponding proton energy distribution after the pulse . the different time delays are indicated in frame ( a).,width=510 ] i w @xmath3 with @xmath95 nm and @xmath145 fs . @xmath146 @xmath147 . full curve : present calculation ; dashed line : experimental measurement from the pure dissociation channel @xcite.,width=377 ] the experiment @xcite allows the dissociative and dissociative ionization processes can be discriminated by coincidence time - of - flight measurements . the spectrum can be dominated by the large low intensity focal volume . for a theoretical model the relevant spectrum is the probability distribution given by @xmath148 where @xmath149 is the peak intensity in the focus center and @xmath150 is the kinetic energy of the proton . the focus averaging over all these data with the peak intensity @xmath151 w @xmath3 produce figure [ figure8 ] which is in excellent agreement with the experiment for the pure dissociation peak @xcite . unfortunately , many of the structures present in the proton energy spectrum are lost after the averaging process . the small resonant structures in the theoretical modelling correspond to the dissociation from different vibrational levels . at this intensity , saturation occurs at the centre of the focus , thus a large fraction of the dissociation fragments arise from the outer intensity shells . this is confirmed by our calculation in which the proton spectrum has a similar shape for a peak intensity @xmath152 w @xmath3 and @xmath153 w @xmath3 . nonetheless the shape and ion yield of the experiment are extremely well characterised in this experiment , and it is highly encouraging that theory and experiment are in such good agreement . more recent measurement techniques , develop in the last two years , allow sections of the focal volume to be studied , providing and much more detailed examination of the proton spectrum . these new measurements will hopefully reveal some of the features of the proton energy spectrum described in our paper . in summary , we have thoroughly investigated the dissociation dynamics of h@xmath5 in strong laser fields . the vibrational - state resolved kinetic energy distributions have been calculated at various intensities ranging from @xmath154 w @xmath3 to @xmath153 w @xmath3 for @xmath155 nm . the results show the sensitivity of the kinetic energy distribution on the laser intensity , molecular orientation , the pulse length and the pulse delay . at very high intensity , our focus - averaging results reproduce the experimental measurements very accurately @xcite . most importantly , we demonstrate that molecular dissociation dynamics at rather low intensity with a short pulse duration would be more suitable to act as a sub - femtosecond molecular clock . this research is supported by the award of a phd research studentship from the international research centre for experimental physics , queen s university belfast . this work has also been supported by a grant of computer resources at the computer services for academic research , university of manchester , provided by epsrc to the uk multiphoton , electron collisions and bec hpc consortium .

the dissociation spectrum of the hydrogen molecular ion by short intense pulses of infrared light is calculated . the time - dependent schrdinger equation is discretized and integrated in position and momentum space . for few - cycle pulses one can resolve vibrational structure that commonly arises in the experimental preparation of the molecular ion from the neutral molecule . we calculate the corresponding energy spectrum and analyze the dependence on the pulse time - delay , pulse length , and intensity of the laser for @xmath0 nm . we conclude that the proton spectrum is a both a sensitive probe of the vibrational dynamics and the laser pulse . finally we compare our results with recent measurements of the proton spectrum for 55 fs pulses using a ti : sapphire laser ( @xmath1 nm ) . integrating over the laser focal volume , for the intensity @xmath2w @xmath3 , we find our results are in excellent agreement with these experiments . _ to be submitted to j. phys . b _

astro-ph9906187

recent exciting results from the searches for high - redshift type ia supernov ( sne ia ) have been interpreted as suggesting that there is indeed a cosmological constant and that the expansion of the universe is accelerating ( perlmutter 1999 and riess 1998 ) . the results on the cosmology are robust in that they are independent of the value of the hubble parameter , @xmath4 , ( as they use redshift , @xmath5 ) and also of the local calibration of the sne ia luminosities ( as the distance modulus is used ) . they do rest upon an underlying assumption that the local and global values of @xmath4 are the same ( so that the distance - redshift relationship does not change ) . here we examine how different the local value of @xmath4 must be from the global value in order to significantly change the cosmology derived from the fitting of high - redshift sne ia data to the hubble diagram . a similar approach was taken by kim ( 1997 ) to fit data from the first 7 high - redshift sne ia between @xmath6 ; in this paper we extend that work with a much larger number of supernov in the range @xmath7 . ( it should also be noted that the data used by kim favoured an @xmath8 cosmology at the time . ) the idea that the local universe is atypical has been suggested by numerous authors ( see dekel 1994 for a review ) . hudson ( 1999 ) report evidence for a large scale bulk flow on scales possibly greater than 14000 km s@xmath9 . plionis & kolokotronis ( 1998 ) show that there may be contributions to the x - ray cluster dipole from beyond 16000 km s@xmath9 . lauer & postman ( 1994 ) and scaramella ( 1992 ) suggest the possibility of even larger density inhomogeneities out to a distance of 15000 - 30000 km s@xmath9 . phillips & turner ( 1998 ) see that near - ir galaxy counts out to @xmath10 are deficient which may be due to a local underdensity on such scales , implying that the local value of the hubble parameter @xmath4 is up to 30 per cent higher than the global value . tammann ( 1998 ) also sees a decrease in the value of @xmath4 out to 18000 km s@xmath9 of 7 per cent . whilst these claims are not without their detractors it is clear that a body of work exists to suggest that the local value of @xmath4 may not be the same as the global value and could be higher . see turner , cen & ostriker ( 1992 ) for a detailed discussion of this topic . we assume that the value of @xmath4 on scales greater than @xmath11 is equal to the global value , and then fit open and flat cosmologies to the high - redshift sne ia data , shifting the zero - point of the data to find the best fit to the various cosmologies . the difference in zero - points between the local and high - redshift supernov is then used to calculate the difference between the local and global values of the hubble parameter . using the corrected data for 10 high - redshift sne ia presented in tables 5 and 6 of riess ( 1998 ) and for 40 supernova cosmology project ( scp ) high - redshift sne ia from table 1 of perlmutter ( 1999 ) we reconstruct the hubble diagrams . the shift in the local - to - global hubble parameter required to fit various flat and open cosmologies are then calculated using a @xmath12 fit , also finding the 95 per cent confidence limits . figure 1 shows the required local - to - global ratio of the hubble parameter to fit the scp sne ia data . the best fit when @xmath13 in fig . 1(a ) is the well - known @xmath14 cosmology found by perlmutter ( 1999 ) . more interestingly a variety of low @xmath2 open cosmologies are not rejected at the 95 per cent level even if @xmath13 . in order for an @xmath15 open cosmology to be the best fit to the data then @xmath16 is required . the recovery of critical mass density cosmologies is more difficult . they are rejected at greater than the 99 per cent level if @xmath17 and need a large ratio @xmath18 . the data of riess ( 1998 ) was also examined and the fits are very similar to those presented in fig . 1 although they are less significant due to the much lower number of data points . generally the riess data are slightly less consistent with a low @xmath2 open cosmology and @xmath8 critical cosmologies are ruled out at a higher confidence level , requiring a 1.2 to 1.3 @xmath19 ratio . to fit best a low @xmath2 open cosmology then the @xmath19 ratio must be 1.1 - 1.2 . if the local value of the hubble parameter is higher than the global value on scales of a few 100 @xmath20 mpc then the fitting of cosmological parameters to the high - redshift sne ia data of perlmutter ( 1999 ) and riess ( 1998 ) may be inappropriate . previously popular cosmologies such as open or critical matter density universes with no cosmological constant may be acceptable if we live in a local underdensity . whilst large underdensities of scales up to 300 - 600 @xmath20 mpc are not expected from standard power spectra , there is some observational evidence that we may live in such an underdensity ( see section 2 ) , a possibility which is not ruled out by these results . it seems that is too early yet to abandon the traditional models .

the effects of differences between the local and global values of the hubble parameter on the cosmologies consistent with studies of high - redshift type ia supernov are discussed . it is found that with a local hubble parameter around 10 per cent higher than the global value then open cosmological models ( such as @xmath0 ) are prefered and if the local value is around 20 per cent higher then standard cosmological models ( @xmath1 ) can be recovered . even in the case where the hubble parameter ratio is 1 , low @xmath2 open cosmologies with @xmath3 are not rejected at the 95 per cent confidence level .

astro-ph9512037

observational data of cosmological relevance refer to the characteristics of the cmb radiation and the clustering and structural properties of bound virialized ( more exactly , relaxed and steady ) objects such as lyman-@xmath0 clouds , galaxies , and galaxy clusters . to take full benefit of the information contained in the latter kind of data a good knowledge of how , when , and where these objects formed and evolved is required . indeed , this would allow us not only to correctly interpret the observed properties of those cosmological objects but also to properly use them to constrain the correct cosmogony ( i.e. , the possible gaussianity of the initial density field , its power spectrum , and the values of @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 ) . unfortunately , the modeling of the formation and growth of cosmic objects is not an easy task . even in the simple and yet most likely scenario , hereafter assumed , of structure formation via gravitational instability from a primordial gaussian random field of density fluctuations with power spectrum leading to hierarchical clustering no exact model can be build . the reason for this is the lack of an exact solution for the growth of density fluctuations in the non - linear regime . there are only two ways to circumvent this difficulty : the use of numerical simulations and the construction of ( semi ) analytical models relying on approximated collapse dynamics . the former is obviously more exact but it is not free of problems , either . numerical simulations are very time - consuming , which translates into a limited dynamical range and a very reduced region of the parameter space covered . moreover , numerical simulations give access to the yields of the complex processes taking place , but the full understanding of what is going on is not easy . in contrast , models are less accurate , sometimes possibly poorly justified , but are more practical and allow a deeper insight into the physics . in fact , both approaches are complementary : simulations ultimately justifies the goodness of analytical models while the latter bring the possibility to confortably explore a wide range of parameters and allow to better understand the results of the former . there are in the literature numerous reviews dealing with cosmological simulations . here i will focus on the improvements achieved , for the last twenty years , in the construction of a detailed model for the hierarchical clustering of objects . the different models developed so far are of two main kinds . on the one hand , there are models developed to derive the theoretical mass function of objects ( or haloes ) . these are brievely reviewed in 2 , the most relevant ones being discussed in more detail in 3 . on the other hand , there are models which go further and provide us with typical times and rates of the clustering process . these latter models are addressed in 4 . for simplicity , i assume an einstein - de sitter ( @xmath4 , @xmath5 ) universe and comoving units . as mentioned , all clustering models are based on some approximation to the collapse dynamics of density fluctuations . most of them , in particular the seminal model by press & schechter ( 1974 ; ps ) , rely on the spherical collapse model . this is a poor approximation , in general , to the real collapse . yet , the ps mass function gives very good fits to @xmath6-body simulations ( nolthenius & white 1987 ; efstathiou et al . 1988 ; efstathiou & rees 1988 ; carlberg & couchman 1989 ; white et al . 1993 ; bahcall & cen 1993 ; lacey & cole 1994 ) . the reason is likely that massive objects , those intended to be described , arise from high amplitude peaks ( density maxima ) of the initial density field and the collapse of matter around such peaks is particularly well described by the spherical model ( bernardeau 1994 ) . @xmath6-body simulations seem to show that there is no good correspondence between peaks and objects ( van de weygaert & babul 1994 ; katz , quinn , & gelb 1993 ) . but this is likely due to a variety of effects , namely the nesting of peaks on different scales , the use of an unappropriated window , or the inclusion of density constrasts and masses which do not correspond to the collapse times and filtering scales analyzed ( see below ) . actually , the ps mass function and new more or less sophisticated versions of it ( cole & kaiser 1989 ; bond et al . 1991 , bcek ; blanchard , valls - gabaud , & mamon 1994 ; jedamzik 1995 ; yano , nagashima , & gouda 1995 ) do not explicitly deal with peaks as seeds of bound objects . but a parallel set of models has also been developed within the peak theory framework ( colafrancesco , lucchin & matarrese 1989 ; bond 1989 ; peacock & heavens 1990 ; apple & jones 1990 ; manrique & salvador - sol 1995 ) reaching similar results . in the context of models relying on the spherical approximation , we must also mention the model constructed by cavaliere & menci ( 1994 ) using the theory of cayley trees with disorder . this is a more general formalism which recovers , as two extreme limits , the diffusion equation describing , as shown by bcek , the clustering of objects la ps , and the smoluchowski kinetic equation describing the aggregation of objects moving inside a relaxed system . indeed , this formalism is intended to derive the mass function of objects accounting for the fact that may survive and evolve inside larger scale objects ( for example , galaxies in clusters ) . this mass function is different from that intended to be derived in all previous models ; these only consider relaxed haloes which are not embedded within any larger scale relaxed system . here we will focus on the latter most usual viewpoint . there are also a few models based on other dynamical approximations . monaco ( 1995 ) has followed the ps approach but using the ellipsoidal collapse approximation . bond & myers ( 1993a , 1993b ) have considered this latter approximation in the framework of the peak theory . finally , doroshkevich & kotok ( 1990 ) and vergassola et al . ( 1994 ) have used the adhesion model . in principle , these are better approximations to the true collapse than the simple spherical model . however , in the case of the adhesion approximation , the mathematical calculations are very complicated and one can only infer approximate analytical solutions for the cases of pure 1-d , 2-d , or 3-d collapsed structures ( see doroshkevich & kotok 1990 ) . for the real composite case , one can only obtain the asymptotical behavior ( vergassola et al . 1994 ) . concerning the mass function obtained by monaco ( 1995 ) , it is not clear why it does not recover the ps solution at the large mass end where the spherical approximation should be essentially correct . in fact , bond & myers ( 1993a , 1993b ) find , in contrast , that the spherical collapse is a good approximation for very massive objects , indeed . the only drawback of the very accurate approach followed by these latter authors ( the so - called `` peak - patch '' formalism ) is that it involves complicated calculations including monte - carlo simulations which makes it less handy than usual ( semi ) analytical models . according to the spherical collapse model ( gunn & gott 1972 ) , the collapse time @xmath7 for a shell of radius @xmath8 around the center of a spherically symmetric , outwards decreasing ( to avoid shell crossing until @xmath9 ) linear density fluctuation partaking of the general hubble expansion at @xmath10 only depends on the mean density contrast @xmath11 ( the density fluctuation normalized to the mean density of the universe ) inside it through the relation @xmath12 , with @xmath13 the cosmic expansion factor and @xmath14 a constant equal to @xmath15 . the collapse of that shell represents , of course , the appearance , at @xmath7 , of a relaxed object of mass equal to ( to 0th order in @xmath11 ) @xmath16 , with @xmath17 the mean density of the universe . inspired of this simple model , ps assumed that any point in the initial ( linear and gaussian distributed ) density field smoothed with a top - hat filter of scale @xmath8 with density contrast _ above _ the overdensity @xmath18 collects matter so to reach , at @xmath7 related to @xmath18 through the expression above , a mass _ larger than _ @xmath19 . consequently , by differentiating over @xmath20 the volume fraction occupied by such points , @xmath21,\label{e2}\ ] ] with @xmath22 the rms density contrast on scale @xmath8 , one should obtain the volume fraction contributing at @xmath7 with objects of mass @xmath20 to @xmath23 , and by dividing it by @xmath24 the number density of such objects @xmath25 it is worthwhile mentioning that , in the case of power - law power spectra , there should be no privileged time or scale ( in an einstein - de sitter universe as assumed here ) . the ps mass function recovers this expected behavior . the number of objects in a volume @xmath26 , with @xmath27 corresponding to a scale defined through any arbitrary fixed value of @xmath28 , with mass @xmath29 in an infinitesimal range , as well as the volume ( or mass ) fraction subtended by objects of scaled mass @xmath29 in an infinitesimal range are time invariant , indeed . but the growth of density fluctuations can deviate from the spherical collapse in leaving the linear regime . hence , one should check whether small changes in those aspects the most strongly connected with the spherical approximation are suitable . in particular , other filters than the top - hat one , and other values of constant @xmath14 or of the proportionality factor @xmath30 between the mass and @xmath17 times the natural volume of the filter should be investigated . ( we must remark that there is degeneracy between the latter two constants , so there is just one degree of freedom for any given filter . ) yet , lacey & cole ( 1994 ) have recently shown that a very satisfactory fit to @xmath6-body data can be obtained for masses in the relevant range with a top - hat filter and @xmath14 close to the standard value ( for @xmath31 ) . a more serious problem , apart from the unnatural seeds of bound objects assumed , concerns the unjustified factor two in the right - hand member of equation ( [ e1 ] ) . this must be introduced for the final mass function to be correctly normalized , that is , for the integral of @xmath20 times the mass function to be equal to the mean density of the universe . ( every particle in the universe is at any time @xmath7 within some virialized object with appropriate mass . ) on the other hand , the overcounting of objects actually swallowed by previously collapsed ones and the neglected contribution to the mass of objects of low density regions enclosed within high density ones ( which might explain the fudge factor 2 ) are not accounted for . to analyze the effects of such cloud - in - cloud configurations cole & kaiser ( 1989 ) have devised a practical numerical method , called the `` block model '' . after decomposing ( through a series of cuts in two pieces ) a large cuboidal volume in very small cuboidal blocks with different overdensities ( assigned at each level , through monte carlo , according to the gaussian distribution corresponding at that scale ) one can follow their detailed merger trees free of the cloud - in - cloud problem under the same clustering assumptions as in the ps approach ( except for the rather unnatural geometry of the cuboidal filter ) . a more satisfactory solution to these latter problems , in the sense that not attached to any particular realization ( using a spherical filter ) and leading to a fully analytical solution , was provided by bcek by means of the powerful `` excursion set '' formalism . when the filter size is increased , the density contrast at a fixed point can diminish or increase depending on whether the original cloud is embedded in a higher density contrast one or not . so the random walk followed by this point in the @xmath11 vs. @xmath8 diagram will inform us on the nesting of clouds centered on that point . in particular , the mass of the only object which must be counted at @xmath7 attached to a fixed point is given by the largest scale @xmath8 for which the @xmath18 line is upcrossed . the mathematical description of such random walks is hard to achieve in general . however , for the sharp k - space filter , the volumes subtended by different scales @xmath8 are uncorrelated . consequently , the random walk followed by @xmath32 is then purely brownian with variance @xmath33 and the equation describing the number density @xmath34 of trajectories found at @xmath35 which start at @xmath36 is the simple diffusion equation @xmath37 therefore , the volume fraction in objects with mass in the range @xmath20 to @xmath23 , equal to the probability that a trajectory starting at @xmath38 ( corresponding to the limit for @xmath39 of the smoothed density contrast attached to any fixed point ) upcrosses for the first time @xmath18 in the corresponding range of @xmath40 , is simply given by the reduction , in that range , in the number density of trajectories surviving below @xmath18 @xmath41\,ds,\label{frac}\ ] ] with @xmath42\biggr\}\ ] ] the solution of the diffusion equation ( [ e1 ] ) with absorbing barrier at @xmath18 . interestingly enough , the solution one gets ( after changing to variable @xmath20 ) is just the ps mass function with the correct normalization factor 2 . but , why the sharp k - space filter ? moreover , the previous formalism only corrects for nested configurations which are well centered on each fixed point ; off - center nested configurations are not accounted for . to better correct for the cloud - in - cloud one must abandon the excursion set formalism . ( this considers the evolution in the @xmath11 vs. @xmath8 diagram of each fixed point separately , that is , it can not see any correlation of the density field among different points . ) jedamzik ( 1995 ) proposed to directly apply the ps prescription , equation ( [ e1 ] ) to the volume fraction ( [ e2 ] ) uncorrected for any nesting , denoted here by subindex @xmath43 , minus the volume fraction in clouds nested within any larger scale cloud with @xmath18 @xmath44 in writing equation ( [ e3 ] ) we have taken into account the remarks by yano , nagashima , & gouda ( 1995 ) on its correct expression . @xmath45 is the probability that a cloud of size @xmath8 with @xmath46 is located on a background with @xmath47 on scale @xmath48 , while @xmath49 approximately gives the probability that such a background is found inside a non - nested cloud with @xmath18 on scale in the range @xmath48 to @xmath50 . the probability @xmath51 can be easily calculated in the case of sharp k - space filter , since the probability of finding two values of @xmath11 on different scales at a given point is then simply the product of finding each of them separately . @xmath52 is the unknown scale function , i.e. , the mass function previous to the change to variable @xmath20 , that we want to determine . therefore , by applying the ps prescription to equation ( e3 ) one is led to a volterra type integral equation of the second kind for @xmath53 which can be readily solved through the standard iterative method from the initial approximated solution given by the ps mass function . ( this is equivalent to the practical algorithm proposed by jedamzik to solve its equation . ) but peaks are better motivated seeds of objects than the fuzzy regions considered in all previous models . also inspired of the spherical collapse model , the `` peak model '' ansatz states that objects at a time @xmath7 emerge from peaks with density contrast equal to a fixed linear overdensity @xmath18 in the smoothed , on any scale @xmath8 , density field at the arbitrary initial time @xmath10 . the critical overdensity is assumed to be a monotonous decreasing function of @xmath7 , while the mass @xmath20 of objects can also be assumed ( the consistency of this guess is to be confirmed a posteriori ) a monotonous increasing function of @xmath8 . the ps prescription ( equation [ e2 ] ) is therefore achieved , in this framework , by simply taking ( colafrancesco , lucchin , & matarrese 1989 ; peacock & heavens 1990 ) @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the number density of peaks with @xmath56 in the density field smoothed on scale @xmath8 , calculated by bardeen et al . ( 1986 ; bbks ) , and @xmath57 is the average mass of their respective collapsing clouds , i.e. , of the objects giving them rise . note that since peaks in @xmath55 do not have , in general , @xmath47 , the average mass of their collapsing clouds , @xmath57 , will differ from @xmath58 . the above mentioned problems with the normalization of the ps mass function and the cloud - in - cloud are reflected in the different expressions for @xmath57 found in the literature . but there is a more serious problem . in applying equation ( [ e1 ] ) to the volume fraction ( [ e4 ] ) it has been implicitly assumed that : 1 ) the total mass in collapsing clouds associated with peaks ( with @xmath59 ) is conserved with varying scale , and 2 ) the density contrast of peaks is a decreasing function of scale . this guarantees , indeed , that the variation along @xmath60 of the mass associated with peaks above @xmath18 is just that associated with peaks crossing @xmath18 in that infinitesimal range of scales . both points seem to follow from the peak model ansatz , but they actually do not . as shown below , point 2 crucially depends on the shape of the filter used , while mergers invalidate point 1 in any event . as pointed out by bond ( 1988 ) , the only reliable strategy to derive the mass function in the peak model framework is therefore to directly count the density of peaks with density contrast upcrossing @xmath18 in an infinitesimal range of scale , @xmath61 , then correct for the cloud - in - cloud , and finally transform to the mass function of objects at @xmath7 , @xmath62 , through the appropriate @xmath58 and @xmath63 relations . taking into account that for a gaussian filter we have @xmath64 bond ( 1989 ) and appel & jones ( 1990 ) derived the wanted scale function of peaks by computing , la bbks , the density of peaks at @xmath8 with the extra constraint that they cross @xmath18 between @xmath8 and @xmath65 , @xmath66 this leads to @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the density appearing in equation ( [ e4 ] ) , with @xmath69 , and @xmath70 is an average of @xmath71 , with @xmath72 the second order spectral moment , given in manrique & salvador - sol ( 1995a ; msa ) . to correct this scale function for the cloud - in - cloud bond ( 1989 ) used the approximate exclusion factor @xmath73\ ] ] obtained from the excursion set formalism . note that this coincides with the poisson probability that , in a volume typically harboring one peak on scale @xmath8 , there is no such peak located in the volume fraction independently subtended by collapsing clouds associated with larger scale peaks . but what @xmath58 and @xmath63 relations must we take to transform this corrected scale function to the wanted mass function , and why should we use the gaussian filter ? and what is worse , the previous derivation implicitly assumes that the spatial location of peaks does not change in varying the filtering scale which is obviously not true in general . to account for this variation msa have developed a new formalism , the `` confluent system of peak trajectories '' , able to follow the filtering evolution of peaks despite their spatial shift . to guarantee that one peak on scale @xmath74 , with @xmath75 arbitrarily small , traces the same accreting object as another peak on scale @xmath8 at the times corresponding to their respective density contrasts , the separation between both points must be , at most , of the order of @xmath75 . in this manner , the collapsing cloud associated with the peak on scale @xmath74 will essentially include the whole cloud associated with the peak on scale @xmath8 . furthermore , this proximity condition is not only necessary , but also sufficient : as readily seen from the taylor series expansion of the density gradient around a density maximum , there can not be more than one peak on scale @xmath74 in the close neighborhood of any peak on scale @xmath8 . this identification allows one to draw a @xmath11 vs. @xmath8 diagram similar to the excursion set one but for the fact that each trajectory @xmath32 is now attached to one individual accreting object , i.e. , to _ the changing peaks tracing it _ in the filtering process , instead of to one fixed point . it is shown that the total derivative @xmath76 of a peak trajectory in this diagram coincides with the partial derivative @xmath77 of the current peak . moreover , for the mass of accreting objects to increase with time , @xmath11 must decrease with increasing @xmath8 along any peak trajectory , which is only satisfied _ for a gaussian filter_. the density of peak trajectories upcrossing the @xmath18 line in an infinitesimal range of scales is equal to the density of peaks on scale @xmath8 with @xmath56 _ evolving _ into peaks with @xmath78 on scale @xmath74 . given the mandatory gaussian filter and the form of the total derivative of @xmath11 over @xmath8 along a peak trajectory one is just led to equations ( e8)(e10 ) . the important point is that this derivation is now fully justified . moreover , to correct for the cloud - in - cloud msa followed the more accurate approach pointed out by jedamzik ( 1994 ) . the result is the volterra integral equation of the second kind @xmath79 in equation ( [ e11 ] ) @xmath80 is the conditional density of peaks with @xmath18 on scales @xmath8 to @xmath65 given that they have density @xmath18 on scale @xmath48 , which can be written in terms of the analog density per infinitesimal density contrast calculated by bbks in a similar way as equation ( [ e10 ] ) , and @xmath81 gives the approximate probability to find such a point inside the collapsing cloud associated with a non - nested peak with @xmath18 on some scale in the range @xmath48 to @xmath50 . now , if the density field is endowed with a power - law power spectrum the scale function must be self - similar . likewise , the mass fraction in objects with scaled mass @xmath29 in an infinitesimal range , as well as the number of peaks inside the volume @xmath26 on scales @xmath82 in an infinitesimal range must be invariant . but this is only satisfied provided @xmath83 ^ 3 $ ] , with @xmath84 the natural volume associated with the gaussian window and @xmath85 an arbitrary constant . on the other hand , the mass function at @xmath7 is independent of the arbitrary initial time @xmath10 provided only @xmath86 with @xmath14 an arbitrary constant . ( in contrast with the ps case , there is no degeneracy now between constants @xmath85 and @xmath14 . ) with these relations the scale function ( [ e11 ] ) leads to the wanted mass function which turns out to be correctly normalized for whatever values of @xmath85 and @xmath14 governing the exact collapse dynamics . a good fit can be obtained to the ps mass function at any time @xmath7 for appropriate values of these parameters . for non - power - law spectra , the previous @xmath58 and @xmath63 relations are shown to also approximately hold . in this case , however , there is one unique value of @xmath85 yielding the correct normalization for whatever value of @xmath14 . nonetheless , a good fit can also be obtained to the corresponding ps mass function at any time for an appropriate value this parameter . richstone , loeb , & turner ( 1992 ) proposed the time derivative of the ps mass function as an estimate of the formation rate of objects of mass @xmath20 at a given epoch . however , this is a very crude estimate since that quantity is actually equal to the rate at which objects reach mass @xmath20 _ minus the rate at which they leave this state _ , both terms having comparable values . following the ps original approach bower ( 1991 ) derived the conditional mass function of objects of mass at some epoch subject to being part of another object with a given larger mass at a later time . this was subsequently achieved by bcek from the excursion set formalism . to do it one must simply compute the volume fraction in objects with @xmath40 in an infinitesimal range ( [ frac ] ) given by the solution of the diffusion equation ( [ diff ] ) with barrier @xmath18 now with initial condition ( @xmath87 ) corresponding to the more massive object at the later epoch , instead of ( 0,0 ) , @xmath88\biggr\}\,ds,\ ] ] and proceed in the usual manner . the resulting conditional mass function @xmath89 was used by lacey & cole ( 1993 ; lc ; see also kauffmann & white 1993 ) to infer the instantaneous merger rate of objects of mass @xmath20 at @xmath7 into objects of mass @xmath90 to @xmath91 @xmath92 this clustering model has been shown by lacey & cole ( 1994 ) to be in very good agreement with @xmath6-body simulations . however , the ps approach is not fully satisfactory ( see 3 ) . on the other hand , accretion does not play any role in this model ; one can only follow the instantaneous mass increase of objects , event which is generically called merger . as a consequence , there is no specific event marking the beginning or the end of any entity , hence , properly justifying the words formation or destruction of objects . this is the reason why the age and survival time of any object must be defined in terms of the relative variation ( say , by a factor 2 ) in mass along the series of objects with embedded mass connecting with it . the model based on the confluent system formalism is better justified ( peaks are the seeds of objects and simple consistency arguments unambiguously fix the filter and the @xmath58 and @xmath63 relations to be used ) and makes the effective distinction between merger and accretion . when an object evolves by accretion ( tracing a continuous curve @xmath32 in the @xmath11 vs. @xmath8 diagram ) the volume @xmath24 of the collapsing cloud associated with the corresponding evolving peak increases . this makes smaller scale peaks to become nested within it . their @xmath32 curves experience then a discontinuity in @xmath8 at a fixed @xmath11 which can be naturally interpreted as a merger . the net density of peaks with @xmath11 on scales @xmath8 to @xmath65 becoming nested in non - nested peaks with @xmath93 on scales @xmath48 to @xmath50 , @xmath94 , can then be accurately calculated ( manrique & salvador - sol 1995b ; msb ) . the instantaneous ( true ) merger or destruction rate at @xmath7 for objects of mass @xmath20 per specific infinitesimal range of mass @xmath90 ( @xmath95 ) of the resulting objects is , therefore , @xmath96 note that this merger rate is different from that obtained by lc because , in the latter , captures of infinitesimal objects are included while , in the former , they are not . in addition , objects forming in the interval of time @xmath97 from the merger of similarly massive objects are traced by peaks appearing ( there is no previous peak to be identified with ) in the corresponding range of density contrasts @xmath98 without being nested . the net density of non - nested peaks appearing between @xmath11 and @xmath93 , @xmath99 , can also be calculated ( msb ) . this leads to the instantaneous formation rate at @xmath7 of objects of mass @xmath20 @xmath100 finally , the instantaneous mass accretion rate of objects of mass @xmath20 follows from the instantaneous scale increase rate of the corresponding peaks as they evolve along continuous trajectories in the @xmath11 vs. @xmath8 diagram . form equation ( [ e8 ] ) we have @xmath101^{-1}$ ] . averaging over the scaled laplacian of each peak @xmath102 leads to ( msb ) @xmath103 on the other hand , the density @xmath104 of objects surviving ( i.e. , having not merged , just accreted ) until the time @xmath7 from a typical population of objects with masses in the range @xmath105 to @xmath106 at @xmath107 is given by the solution , for the initial condition @xmath108 , of the differential equation @xmath109\,n_{sur}(t)\label{e22}\ ] ] with @xmath110 $ ] the integral over @xmath90 of the specific merger rate ( [ e20 ] ) . hereafter , @xmath111 is the typical mass at @xmath7 of such accreting objects , approximately given by the solution of @xmath112,\label{e25}\ ] ] with @xmath113 . hence , by defining the typical survival time , @xmath114 , of objects with masses @xmath105 to @xmath106 at @xmath115 as the interval of time since @xmath115 after which their density is reduced ( owing to mergers ) by a factor @xmath116 , we are led to the equality @xmath117 , where the destruction time @xmath118 is given by the implicit equation @xmath119 . likewise , the density @xmath120 of objects at @xmath115 that already existed ( i.e. , they have just accreted matter since ) at a time @xmath121 is given by the solution of @xmath122\,n[m(t),t]-r^d[m(t),t]\,n_{pre}(t),\label{e23}\ ] ] with @xmath123 . thus , by defining the typical age @xmath124 of objects with masses between @xmath105 and @xmath106 at @xmath115 as the interval of time until @xmath115 before which their density ( owing to their progressive formation and possible disappearance ) was a factor @xmath116 smaller , we are led to the equality @xmath125 , where the formation time @xmath126 is given by the solution of the implicit equation @xmath127 . one can also define similar times as those adopted by lc as an estimate of the age and survival time of obejcts . these are called half - mass - accretion time and double - mass - accretion and are defined as the interval of time spent since the mass of an object was typically half its current value and the interval of time required by an object to typically double its mass , respectively . ( the only difference from the analog times defined by lc is that , since the new times refer to the typical mass evolution of _ given objects _ , they only involve accretion . ) these time estimates can be readily obtained from equation ( [ e25 ] ) . in figure [ fig-1 ] we plot for comparison the three sets of characteristic times for objects of different masses at two different epochs . appel , l. , & jones , b.j.t . 1990 , , 245 , 522 ( aj ) bahcall , n.a . , & cen , r. 1993 , , 407 , l49 bardeen , j.m . , bond , j.r . , kaiser , n. , & szalay , a.s . 1986 , , 304 , 15 ( bbks ) bernardeau , f 1994 , , 427 , 51 blanchard , a. , valls - gabaud , d. , & mamon , g. 1993 , aa , 264 , 365 bond , j.r . 1988 , in large - scale motions in the universe , eds . rubin , v.c . , & coyne , g.v . ( new jersey : princeton series ) , p. 419 bond , j.r . 1989 , in frontiers in physics . from colliders to cosmology , eds . astbury , a. , campbell , b.a . , israel , w. , & khanna , f.c . ( singapore : world scientific ) , p. 182 bond , j.r . , cole , s. , efstathiou , g. , kaiser , n. 1991 , , 379 , 440 ( bcek ) bond , j.r . , & myers , s.t . 1993a , cita , preprint 93/27 bond , j.r . , & myers , s.t . 1993b , cita , preprint 93/28 bower , r.j . 1991 , , 248 , 332 carlberg , r.g . , & couchman , h.m.p . 1989 , , 340 , 47 cavaliere , a , & menci , n. 1994 , , 435 , 528 colafrancesco , s. , lucchin , f. , & matarrese , s. 1989 , , 345 , 3 cole , s. , & kaiser , n. 1989 , , 237 , 1127 doroshkevich , a.g . , & kotok , t.v . 1990 , , 246 , 10 efstathiou , g. , frenk , c.s . , white , s.d.m . , & davis , m. 1988 , , 235 , 715 efstathiou , g. , & rees , m.j . 1988 , , 230 , 5p gunn , j.e . , & gott , j.r . 1972 , , 176 , 1 jedamzik , k. 1995 , , 448 , 1 kaiser , n. 1984 , , 284 , l9 kauffmann , g. , & white , s.d.m . 1993 , , 261 , 921 katz , n. , quinn , t. , & gelb , j.m . 1993 , 265 , 689 lacey , c. , & cole , s. 1993 , , 262 , 627 ( lc ) lacey , c. , & cole , s. 1994 , , 271 , 676 manrique , a. , & salvador - sol , e. 1995a , , 453 , 6 - 16 ( msa ) manrique , a. , & salvador - sol , e. 1995b , , submitted ( msb ) monaco , p. 1995 , , 447 , 23 nolthenius , r. , & white , s.d.m . 1987 , , 225 , 505 peacock , j.a . , & heavens , a.f . 1990 , , 243 , 133 press , w.h . , & schechter , p. 1974 , , 187 , 425 richstone , d. , loeb , a. , & turner e. 1992 , , 393 , 477 vergassola , m. , dubrulle , b. , frisch , u. , & noullez , 1994 , aa , 289 , 325 van de weygaert , r. , & babul , a. 1994 , , 425 , l59 white , s.d.m . , efstathiou , g. , & frenk , c.s . 1993 , , 265 , 727 yano , t. , nagashima , m. , & gouda , n. 1995 , preprint ( astro - ph/9504073 )

i review the main steps made so far towards a detailed ( semi ) analytical model for the hierarchical clustering of bound virialized objects ( i.e. , haloes ) in the gravitational instability scenario . i focus on those models relying on the spherical collapse approximation which have led to the most complete description . the work is divided in two parts : a first one dealing with the mass function of objects and a second one dealing with the growth times and rates .

cond-mat0210251

quantum - state engineering via optical or electrical manipulation over the coherent dynamics of suitable quantum - mechanical systems has become a fascinating prospect of modern physics . a very intriguing result in the study of a single particle in a double - trap system exposed to a time - dependent external field is the dynamic localization phenomenon@xcite , i.e. , for appropriate field parameters , a localized wave packet remains dynamically localized during the subsequent time evolution . this driving induced trapping has been theoretically and experimentally studied in many physical and chemical systems@xcite . when two or more interacting particles are present , apart from the highly nontrivial question of whether the strong many - body interaction can be overcome for the particles to create and preserve localization , the possibility of entanglement of the many - body wave functions arises . entanglement is an essential ingredient in any scheme of quantum information processing . recently , quantum dot realizations of the entanglement have received increasing attention . various schemes based on electron spins and electron - hole pairs have been proposed to implement quantum computer hardware architectures@xcite . although there have been some numerical studies on interacting electron systems driven by an ac field@xcite , there is still little theoretical understanding of the observed effects beyond the phenomenology level at the present time . in this paper , we address the dynamic localization and quantum entanglement of two interacting electrons in a double quantum dot system driven by an ac field ( see fig . 1 ) . we show that with certain choice of parameters , in contrast to direct intuition , the coulomb repulsion may enhance the localization due to the level crossing associated with different symmetries of a dynamic parity operation ( discussed in more detail later ) . we also show that the maximally entangled bell state can be prepared and maintained with a pulse of an ac field . our study provides useful information for the future exploitation of coherent control of two - electron states in quantum dots . in sec . ii we present the hamiltonian for two interacting electrons in a double - dot system . a simplified spin-1 representation of the hamiltonian is given in sec . iii . in sec . iv we discuss the phenomenon of coulomb - enhanced localization . the field excitation procedure to generate the maximally entangled bell state is showed in sec . v. a summary is given in sec . the hamiltonian which we use to describe the dynamics of two interacting electrons in a coupled quantum dot driven by electric field is @xmath0 @xmath1 @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the coulomb interaction and @xmath4 the single - particle hamiltonian . the time - dependent electric field @xmath5 is applied along the inter - dot axis . the dielectric constant @xmath6 and the effective mass @xmath7 are material parameters . the potential @xmath8 in @xmath4 describes the in - plane confinement , whereas @xmath9 models the longitudinal double - well structure . the transverse coupling of the dots is modeled by a harmonic potential @xmath10 it has been shown in experiments with electrically gated quantum dots in a two - dimensional electron system that the electronic spectrum is well described by a simple harmonic oscillator@xcite . in describing the confinement @xmath9 along the inter - dot axis , we use a ( locally harmonic ) double well potential of the form @xmath11 which , in the limit of large inter - dot distance , separates into two harmonic wells ( one for each dot ) of frequency @xmath12 . although in principle a square - well potential would be a more accurate description of the real potential than the harmonic double well , there is no qualitative difference between the results presented below obtained with harmonic potential and the corresponding results using square - well potential . we assume the transverse confinement is strong enough . thus , the @xmath13 degrees of freedom are frozen in the dynamics and the two - electron wave function can be written as @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the transverse ground state . considering the fact that the external electric field is applied along the longitudinal direction , the approximation of frozen in - plane motion is reasonable and has been employed in previous work@xcite . after integrating over the @xmath13 degrees of freedom , the time dependent schrdinger equation becomes @xmath16|\phi ( z_{1},z_{2},t)\rangle , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath17 is the effective one - dimensional coulomb interaction @xmath18 we use the effective mass @xmath7 and dielectric constant @xmath6 of gaas . the other parameters are chosen as @xmath19mev and @xmath20 nm . the time evolution of the two electrons is obtained by numerically solving the schrdinger equation ( 4 ) using an extension of the crank - nicholson method@xcite to two spatial dimensions . the initial state used in this investigation is the field - free ground state , which is obtained by propagating a trial two - particle wave packet in the imaginary time domain and shown in fig . as illustrated by the spatial symmetry under the particle exchange , the ground state is a singlet , as expected . ( 4 ) contains no mixing between the singlet and triplet sub - spaces , the dynamics of the system will always be confined to the singlet sub - space . to understand the underlying physics behind the numerical results we employ the hund - mulliken ( hm ) approximation by introducing the orthonormalized one - particle wave functions @xmath21 , where @xmath22 are the single - particle ground states for the right and left dots , @xmath23 denotes the overlap integral , and @xmath24 . using @xmath25 , we construct three singlet basis functions with respect to which we diagonalize the two - electron hamiltonian : two states with double occupation in each dot , @xmath26 , @xmath27 , and one state with single occupation in each dot , @xmath28 $ ] . calculating the matrix elements of the hamiltonian in this orthonormal basis , we obtain @xmath29 where we have dropped a constant energy term that makes no contribution to the dynamics . ( 6 ) @xmath30 is the difference between the intradot and interdot coulomb interaction , @xmath31 denotes the single - particle tunneling induced by dot - dot coupling and the coulomb interaction , @xmath32 describes the electron - field coupling , and @xmath33 and @xmath34 are the @xmath35- and @xmath36- components of the spin-1 operator . the localized two - particle state @xmath37 is equivalent to the eigenstate @xmath38 of @xmath34 and @xmath39 to the state @xmath40 , while the delocalized state @xmath41 is identical to the state @xmath42 . according to the expression for @xmath43 and @xmath44 , using the material parameters given below eq . ( 5 ) we obtain @xmath45mev and @xmath46mev . in the absence of an external driving , the eigenenergies of @xmath47 are @xmath48 @xmath49 , and @xmath50 , and the corresponding eigenstates are @xmath51 @xmath52 @xmath53 the symmetric ground state @xmath54 is dominated by the delocalized state @xmath41 due to the strong coulomb repulsion , whereas the other two eigenstates are nearly degenerate and dominated by the two localized states @xmath37 and @xmath39 . the superposition of the two localized states @xmath37 and @xmath39 implies that the spatial wave functions of the two electrons have been entangled and correlated , in the usual sense that they can not be factorized into single - particle states . the nonlinear term in @xmath47 can be exploited to generate entangled states . the ground state of eq . ( 7 ) is plotted in fig . clearly the hm approximation describes the ground state very well when compared with the exact numerical solution [ fig . to investigate dynamic localization , one must start with a localized wave packet . this can be realized from the unperturbed ground state by two separate methods : one is to suddenly switch on a dc field with the strength satisfying the resonance condition @xmath55 . at time @xmath56 , the delocalized ground state @xmath54 evolves into a localized state @xmath39 with two electrons occupying the same right dot . the alternative method is to adiabatically switch on a constant electric field . then as shown in fig . 2(c ) , the ground state configuration develops a series of coulomb stairs as a function of the field amplitude , corresponding to a series of avoided crossing in the energy spectrum [ see fig . 2(d ) ] . after preparing a localized state , say @xmath39 , by adiabatic evolution in the presence of a dc field , the dc field is suddenly swiched off and an ac field of the form @xmath57 is swiched on . we show now that the localization can be dynamically maintained by the ac field even when the field strength is small compared to the coulomb repulsion between the two electrons . time periodicity of the hamiltonian enables us to describe the dynamics within the floquet formalism . in addition , since the hamiltonian is invariant under the combined dynamic parity operation @xmath58 ; @xmath59 , each floquet state is either odd or even . quasienergies of different parity may cross , otherwise an avoided crossing may occur . figures 3(a)-(b ) show the quasienergy spectra of @xmath60 as a function of @xmath61 with the presence and absence of the coulomb interaction , respectively . two prominent features can be identified from the comparison of these two cases : ( i ) the strong coulomb interaction removes the level crossings among three two - particle states and thus induces avoided crossings ; ( ii ) in the weak field regime , there occurs a crossing between the quasienergies @xmath62 and @xmath63 , which develop from the unperturbed eigenenergies @xmath64 and @xmath65 . to illustrate the effect of this crossing on the system s dynamics , we begin with the initial state @xmath39 and follow the time evolution of the probability @xmath66 for finding the two electrons in the right dot . the result is shown in fig . it is clear that @xmath67 always remains near 1 as if the two electrons were frozen in the same right dot . this dynamic localization seems counterintuitive at first as the coulomb repulsion is very strong compared to the ac field , preventing the two electrons occupying the _ same _ dot . the localization shown in fig . 3(c ) has no correspondence in a non - interacting case , since no level crossings occur in the weak field regime if the coulomb interaction is absent . therefore , the present localization effect results from an interplay of the coulomb interaction and an ac field . furthermore , we find that even if the coulomb interaction is strong enough , the dynamic localization can still occur at the crossing of the quasienergies @xmath62 and @xmath63 . slightly away from the crossing point , the life time for finding two electrons in the right dot is very long . this makes the experimental realization of the dynamic localization more realistic . the ratio @xmath68 at the first crossing is about @xmath69 , a root of the zero - order bessel function , suggesting that the two - electron localization can be approximated by a two - state model composed of @xmath70 and @xmath71 . surprisingly , we find that in the strong field regime , the presence of coulomb repulsion may help to enhance the dynamic localization when compared with the non - interacting case . from eq . ( 7 ) we see that due to the strong coulomb interaction , @xmath72 . thus the initial localized state can be approximated by a superposition of the degenerate floquet states developed from the nearly - degenerate states @xmath70 and @xmath73 , which leads to a complete suppression of tunneling at the crossing of the quasienergies @xmath62 and @xmath63 even in the weak field limit . in the absence of the coulomb interaction , the initial localized state @xmath39 is a superposition of all three eigenstates , suggesting dynamic localization at the crossing among three quasienergies . however , the fundamental difference lies in the fact that when the strong interaction is present , the tunneling coupling is @xmath74 , whereas in the absence of the coulomb interaction the tunneling coupling is @xmath75 . thus the coupling between the two localized states greatly decreases in the presence of strong coulomb interaction , which leads to the enhancement of localization effects . we emphasize that the localization only occurs at the crossing of the quasienergies developed from the high - energy eigenstates @xmath76 and @xmath71 , in which case the delocalized ground state @xmath54 is a dark state during time evolution . for comparison , figure 3(d ) shows @xmath77 with the field parameters corresponding to the crossing of the quasienergies @xmath78 and @xmath79 . it reveals that dynamic localization disppears and the two electrons start to oscillate between two dots . this fact highlights the essential difference between a single - particle system and an interacting two - particle system . the level crossing of @xmath78 and @xmath79 induces strong participation of the floquet state evolved from the unperturbed ground state . as its largest component is the delocalized two - particle state @xmath41 , dynamic localization will be completely destructed , as shown in fig . in this section we investigate the field excitation procedure to obtain a maximally entangled bell state of the form @xmath80 with an arbitrary phase angle @xmath81 . figure 4(a ) plots the floquet quasienergies of @xmath60 as a function of the driving frequency @xmath82 . it shows that when @xmath83 , an avoided crossing is formed between the quasienergies @xmath78 and @xmath84 . choosing the field parameters at this avoided crossing and starting with the unperturbed ground state , we present in fig . 4(b ) the probabilities @xmath85 for finding the two electrons in different dots , @xmath86 in the left dot , and @xmath67 in the right dot . it shows that the two electrons oscillate between the delocalized state @xmath41 and two localized states @xmath37 and @xmath39 . the occupations of two localized states are always the same and the oscillations are always in - phase . figure 4(c ) shows the probability @xmath87 for finding the maximally entangled bell state with @xmath88 . one can see that @xmath89 varies with time , reaching a maximum value of 1 when @xmath90 ( the two electrons are maximally entangled with @xmath91 ) . a direct numerical solution of eq . ( 4 ) gives the same prediction . once the two electrons are in the maximally entangled bell state , they can remain maximally entangled by suddenly turning off the ac field . we show this effect in figure 5 . figure 5(a ) plots the time evolution of the occupations of three two - particle states , and figure 5(b ) the probability @xmath92 with @xmath88 ( solid line ) . it is clear from fig . 5(a ) that a pulse of an ac field induces the two electrons to stay in the same dot , while each of them occupies either of the dots with the same probability . as shown in fig . 5(b ) ( solid line ) , the two electrons remain maximally entangled after the electric field is turned off . therefore , the maximally entangled bell state can be created and maintained by applying a pulse of a resonant ac field . we derive an approximate analytical solution to highlight the physical aspect of the bell - state generation procedure . taking into account symmetric properties of the three unperturbed eigenstates of the system , the dynamics shown in fig . 5 is determined by the one - photon transition between the ground state @xmath54 and the first excited state @xmath76 , whereas the transition from @xmath54 to latexmath:[$% in this case , we can approximate the hamiltonian @xmath60 in a hilbert space spanned by the states @xmath54 and @xmath70 @xmath94 where @xmath95 . in the case of one - photon resonance @xmath96 and after applying the rotating - wave approximation we obtain the expression for the probability of finding the maximally entangled bell state @xmath97 in the interaction representation and weak coupling limit @xmath98 . we can see from eq . ( 9 ) that the quantum state of the system at time @xmath99 corresponds to a @xmath88 maximally entangled bell state @xmath100 . the result of eq . ( 9 ) is shown in fig . 5(c ) ( dotted line ) . clearly , in comparison with the exact numerical solution ( solid line ) , our two - state approximation describes the system evolution very well . therefore we arrive at the conclusion that a selective pulse of an ac field with duration @xmath101 can be used to create and maintain a maximally entangled bell state in the system of two electrons in two coupled quantum dots . we notice from eq . ( 9 ) that bell - state generation time is significantly shortened by increasing the amplitude of the ac field . this is important because shorter bell - state generation time is fundamental to the experimental observation of such maximally entangled state , which is impeded by inevitable decoherence occurred in the realistic double quantum dot system . the decoherence is the most problematic issue pertaining to most quantum computing processing . in the present entangled state proposal , the decohering time depends partly on the fluctuation of the single particle energy caused by the modification of the confining potential due to phononic excitations . there is also a quantum electrodynamic contribution because of coupling to the vacuum modes . in addition , impurity scattering and phonon emission also have contributions to the decoherence . however , in principle , their effects can be minimized by more precise fabrication technology and by cooling the system . in summary , we have shown how the dynamic localization and entanglement of two interacting electrons in a coupled quantum dot system can be generated and maintained using an ac field . the bell - state generation time has been calculated by an analytical approach . exact numerical calculation confirms these two kinds of coulomb - involved phenomena . we hope the present study will shed some light on the future development of the coherent control of electrons in quantum dot systems . fig . 2 . ( a ) two - electron ground state versus the longitudinal coordinates of the two electrons along diagonal direction @xmath102 , obtained via numerically integrating eq . ( 4 ) with no ac field ; ( b ) two - electron ground state obtained analytically via the hund - mulliken approximation ; ( c ) electron - number distribution of the right dot in the ground state as a function of dc electric field ; ( d ) low - energy spectrum versus dc field . fig . 3 . ( a ) quasienergy spectrum for two interacting electrons for @xmath103mev ; ( b ) quasienergy spectrum with no coulomb interaction ; ( c ) probability @xmath67 that two electrons occupy the same right dot for an ac field of @xmath104kv / cm , which produces an exact crossing between two quasienergies that developed from nearly - degenerate two - particle eigenenergies ; ( d ) @xmath67 for @xmath105kv / cm and @xmath106mev , corresponding to a crossing between two quasienergies , one of which originates from unperturbed ground - state . fig . 4 . ( a ) floquet spectrum versus the driving frequency of an ac field with a strength @xmath107kv / cm ; ( b ) probabilities that the two electrons are in different combinations of two quantum dots , for a driving frequency @xmath108mev , corresponding to the avoided crossing shown in ( a ) ; ( c ) probability @xmath87 as a function of time . fig . probabilities that the two electrons are in different combinations of two quantum dots , with the ac field switched off after @xmath109ps ; ( b ) probability @xmath87 as a function of time . the numerical and analytic results are shown with the solid and dotted lines , respectively .

we investigate the dynamics of two interacting electrons in coupled quantum dots driven by an ac field . we find that the two electrons can be trapped in one of the dots by the ac field , in spite of the strong coulomb repulsion . in particular , we find that the interaction may enhance the localization effect . we also demonstrate the field excitation procedure to generate the maximally entangled bell states . the generation time is determined by both analytic and numerical solutions of the time dependent schrdinger equation.pacs numbers : 03.65.ud , 78.67.hc , 73.23.-bkeywords : coupled quantum dots , dynamical localization , entanglement [ theorem]acknowledgement [ theorem]algorithm [ theorem]axiom [ theorem]claim [ theorem]conclusion [ theorem]condition [ theorem]conjecture [ theorem]corollary [ theorem]criterion [ theorem]definition [ theorem]example [ theorem]exercise [ theorem]lemma [ theorem]notation [ theorem]problem [ theorem]proposition [ theorem]remark [ theorem]solution [ theorem]summary

1006.3328

in quantum mechanics , the density operator @xmath0 of a quantum system is called a stationary state if @xmath1=0 $ ] , where @xmath2 is a given time - independent hamiltonian of the system . since @xmath0 satisfies the liouville - von neumann equation @xmath3 $ ] , it is clear that stationary states are invariant with respect to the transformation @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the time evolution operator . in other words , stationary states do not change during the time evolution . for low - dimensional closed systems , the stationary states can be obtained relatively easily @xcite . it is a common situation , that a small quantum system is immersed in other , mostly large , system called the environment @xcite . such an open system does not evolve unitarily in time . an analysis of open quantum systems @xcite is much more complicated as they are a stage of a variety of physical phenomena @xcite . the famous decoherence process @xcite may serve as an example . in open quantum systems character of potentially existing stationary states is not obvious . there are various physical problems related to the properties of open quantum systems , which has already been addressed and intensively discussed ( see _ e.g. _ , @xcite ) . nevertheless , the procedure of deriving stationary states is not one of them . the existence and properties of stationary states have significant importance in quantum information processing and quantum theory itself . one can pose natural questions : 1 . do the stationary states exist for a given open system ? 2 . what features of a given model are responsible for existence of such states ? 3 . how such states can be constructed ? the answers to the above questions are still incomplete . for example , it is known that the stationary states exist for completely positive ( cp ) @xcite evolution of the open system , this fact follows directly from schauder fixed point theorem @xcite . however , this is only an existential result and so far there are no available methods to determine explicit form of stationary states . furthermore , the very existence of the stationary states in general case is an open problem _ e.g. _ , in the presence of initial system - environment correlations @xcite . the purpose of this paper is to propose the method of calculating the stationary states in the case of two - dimensional open quantum system . the theory of block operator matrices @xcite is adapted to achieve this goal . in particular , we use the _ riccati operator equation _ @xcite to solve the eigenproblem for the total hamiltonian . it is shown how to derive the stationary states by using the solution of the equation . we begin with a brief review of the block operator matrices approach to the problem of decoherence in the case of a single qubit @xcite . let @xmath6 be the hamiltonian of the total system . we will assume that it has the following form @xmath7 where @xmath8 and @xmath9 represent the hamiltonian of the qubit and the environment , respectively , while @xmath10 specifies the interaction between the systems . the hamiltonian @xmath6 acts on the hilbert space @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the hilbert space ( possibly infinite - dimensional ) related to the environment . @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the identity operators on @xmath15 and @xmath12 , respectively . since the isomorphism @xmath16 holds true , the hamiltonian ( [ total ] ) admits the block operator matrix representation @xcite : @xmath17 all the entries of ( [ bom ] ) are operators acting on @xmath12 . moreover , the diagonal entries , _ i.e. _ , @xmath18 are self - adjoint . in this paper , we will focus on the case in which @xmath19 is bounded , thus @xmath20 is bounded as well ; however , no assumption on boundedness of @xmath18 is made . under these circumstances we have @xmath21 , where domains @xmath22 are assumed to be dense in @xmath12 . the generally accepted procedure to obtain the reduced time evolution of the open system , the so - called reduced dynamics , reads @xmath23 \equiv t_t(\rho_0).\ ] ] above , @xmath24 specifies the state of the open system at @xmath25 . the map @xmath26 assigns to each initial state @xmath24 a single state @xmath27 of the total system . the assignment map must be chosen properly so that @xmath28 can be well - defined @xcite . for instance , if no correlations between the systems are initially present , then @xmath29 , for some initial state of the environment @xmath30 . it is worth mentioning that , if the initial state can not be factorized , the definition of @xmath26 is not accessible @xcite . the unitary operator @xmath31 describes the time evolution of the total system . the map @xmath32 denotes the so - called partial trace : @xmath33 @xmath34 refers to the usual trace operation on @xmath12 , @xmath35 denotes the banach space of trace classes operator with the trace norm : @xmath36 , whereas @xmath37 is the banach space of @xmath38 complex matrices . note , the partial trace is a linear operation transforming the block operator matrices ( square brackets ) to the ordinary matrices ( round brackets ) . fixed point theorems like banach or schauder indicate the existence of stationary states for a given evolution @xmath28 . however , there is no general analytical procedure to obtain explicit form of such states . in this section we propose a method of deriving stationary states for two - level open quantum systems . the generalization to the higher - dimensions seems to be possible . however , we will not deal with this issue in this paper . we begin with some definitions . the density matrix @xmath0 is said to be a stationary state if it is invariant with respect to reduced evolution , @xmath39 . let @xmath40 be an operator acting on the hilbert space @xmath41 . the subset @xmath42 of @xmath43 defined as @xmath44 is said to be the graph of @xmath40 . the graph of a linear and closed operator is a subset of the hilbert space , which is a hilbert space itself equipped with the inner product @xmath45 @xmath46 is an inner product on @xmath12 . it is a known fact ( see lemma @xmath47 in @xcite ) that the graph @xmath42 is @xmath48invariant , that is @xmath49 if and only if @xmath40 is a bounded solution ( with @xmath50 ) of the _ riccati _ equation : @xmath51 along with the equation above we introduce the dual riccati equation , namely @xmath52 it is proved in @xcite that @xmath53 is a solution ( with @xmath54 ) of ( [ ricc2 ] ) if and only if the orthogonal complement of @xmath42 , _ i.e. _ , the subspace @xmath55 is @xmath6-invariant . it is straightforward to see that a bounded operator @xmath40 solves ( [ ricc ] ) if and only if @xmath56 is a solution of ( [ ricc2 ] ) . therefore , @xmath42 as well as @xmath57 are @xmath48invariant if and only if @xmath40 is a bounded solution of ( [ ricc ] ) . in other words , @xmath42 is reducing subspace of @xmath6 if and only if @xmath40 is a bounded solution of ( [ ricc ] ) . from considerations above follow also that @xmath42 and @xmath57 are @xmath58invariant . [ def ] elements from the graph and its orthogonal complement are denoted by @xmath59 and @xmath60 , respectively . the riccati states are defined as @xmath61 and @xmath62 , where @xmath63 and @xmath64 . the vectors @xmath59 and @xmath60 are _ not _ normalized with respect to the norm induced by the inner product ( [ inner ] ) . moreover , the states @xmath65 and @xmath66 are not factorisable ( _ i.e. _ , correlations occur ) , unless @xmath67 and @xmath68 , respectively . however , they are @xmath69invariant , which is obvious because the vectors @xmath59 and @xmath60 are @xmath58invariant . as a consequence , the riccati states @xmath70 and @xmath71 are @xmath72invariant , where the map @xmath28 has been defined in ( [ reduced ] ) . therefore , the set of all the riccati states is invariant under the time evolution . nevertheless , the riccati states are not the stationary states , in general . however , we show that the latter can be found among the riccati states . to be specific , we will prove the following [ th1 ] let @xmath40 be a bounded solution of the riccati equation . then 1 . the riccati state @xmath70 is a stationary state if the vector @xmath73 is a eigenvector of the operator @xmath74 , 2 . the riccati state @xmath75 is a stationary state if the vector @xmath76 is a eigenvector of the operator @xmath77 . let @xmath78 for @xmath79 and @xmath80 . from ( [ ricc ] ) we obtain that @xmath81 , hence in view of ( [ bom ] ) the last equality leads to @xmath82 . thus , the vector state @xmath59 is the eigenvector of the total hamiltonian with the corresponding eigenvalue @xmath83 . since @xmath6 is self - adjoint we have @xmath84 and in consequence @xmath85 , which ultimately leads to @xmath86 . in a comparable manner we have @xmath87 for @xmath88 and @xmath89 so that @xmath90 . just as before @xmath91 , therefore @xmath92 . at this point , some remarks , regarding theorem given above , should be made . the question whether all stationary states are riccati states or if it is possible that stationary states exist that are not riccati states is still open . [ re1 ] since the space @xmath93 is closed , we have the following decomposition @xmath94 . thus the total hamiltonian is similar to certain block diagonal operator matrix , @xmath95 , where @xmath96 this , implies that @xmath97 . therefore , the eigenvalues of @xmath98 are exactly the eigenvalues of the hamiltonian @xmath6 . let @xmath40 be a bounded solution of ( [ ricc ] ) . @xmath19 is assumed to be bounded as well . from the definition of @xmath98 we have @xmath99 , and thus @xmath100 . since @xmath40 solves the riccati equation ( [ ricc ] ) , it is clear that @xmath101 . to prove @xmath102 we will show that @xmath103 is invertible and @xmath104 is bounded . indeed , @xmath105 , where @xmath106 since @xmath107 , the spectrum of @xmath108 is a subset of the imaginary axis . in particular , @xmath109 thus @xmath110 and , hence , @xmath103 has a bounded inverse . [ rem4 ] the stationary states @xmath70 , @xmath75 indicated in theorem [ th1 ] are given by @xmath111 where @xmath80 and @xmath112 are the eigenvectors of @xmath113 and @xmath114 , respectively . @xmath115 , @xmath116 are the normalization constants and @xmath117 . since @xmath118 , the equations ( [ explicit ] ) can be obtained directly from the definition ( [ def ] ) and the formula ( [ partial ] ) . in this subsection we will demonstrate an application of the presented method to a non - trivial example , namely , the paradigmatic spin - boson model @xcite . assume that the hamiltonian of the qubit ( spin - half ) and its environment ( boson ) are in the following forms @xmath119 respectively . for the sake of simplicity , we consider only the case of a single boson . the interaction between the systems reads @xmath120 in the above description , @xmath121 , @xmath122 are the standard pauli matrices and @xmath123 . the creation @xmath124 and annihilation @xmath125 operators obey the canonical commutation relation ( ccr ) @xmath126={{\mathbb}{i}_{\text{e}}}$ ] @xcite . parameters @xmath127 and @xmath128 represent the energy of the boson and the coupling constant between the qubit and the environment , respectively . if @xmath129 ( no energy exchange between the systems ) , the model can be solved , _ i.e. _ , the reduced dynamics can be obtained exactly @xcite . the solution describes the physical phenomena known as the pure decoherence or dephasing @xcite . on the other hand , when @xmath130 the exact solution in not known . the objective is to estimate the stationary states for the latter case . to proceed , we must clarify some technical aspects ( _ e.g. _ , domains of @xmath18 ) . clearly , the operators @xmath125 and @xmath124 can not both be bounded since the trace of their commutator does not vanish @xcite . therefore , the ccr holds only on some dense subspace @xmath131 of @xmath12 . let @xmath132 be the dense domain of both @xmath125 and @xmath124 , on which they are mutually adjoint , that is , @xmath133 , @xmath134 . at this point , it is not obvious that the sets @xmath132 , @xmath131 , having desire properties , exist . the detailed construction can be found in @xcite and the right choice is given by @xmath135 on @xmath132 the creation and annihilation operators can be defined explicitly as ( see also @xcite ) @xmath136 @xmath137 is an orthonormal basis in @xmath138 . from ( [ aa ] ) follows that @xmath139 and @xmath140 , which in most books on quantum mechanics is a definition of the creation and annihilation operators . however , the operators defined in such a way are not closed ; nevertheless , they are closable and their closures are given by ( [ aa ] ) . since @xmath125 is closed , @xmath141 is a positive self - adjoint operator and @xmath142 is a core of @xmath125 ( see _ e.g. _ , theorem 4.2.1 in @xcite ) . henceforward , we assume that the basis @xmath137 is composed with the eigenvectors of @xmath141 . in this case we have @xmath143 by choosing a suitable coupling constant @xmath144 , it is possible to make @xmath145 self - adjoint on @xmath146 . to see this , let us first note that @xmath147 , thus @xmath19 is hermitian ( symmetric ) . since @xmath141 is self - adjoint and @xmath19 hermitian , it is sufficient to show that @xmath19 is relatively bounded with respect to @xmath141 ( @xmath141 bounded ) and with @xmath141-bound less than one . the fundamental result of perturbation theory , known as the kato - rellich theorem @xcite assure hermiticity of @xmath18 in this case . recall that @xmath148 is @xmath149 bounded if i ) @xmath150 and ii ) @xmath151 , for all @xmath152 and some nonnegative constants @xmath125 , @xmath153 . the infimum of all @xmath125 for which a corresponding @xmath153 exists such that the last inequality holds is called @xmath154bound of @xmath148 . note , sometimes it is convenient to replace the condition ii ) by the equivalent one : @xmath155 . it is not difficult to see that if two operators @xmath156 , @xmath157 are bounded with respect to the same operator @xmath149 and their relative bound are less than @xmath158 and @xmath159 , respectively ; then @xmath160 is also @xmath149 bounded and its relative bounded is less than @xmath161 ( see lemma 6.1 in @xcite ) . in other words , the set of all @xmath149 bounded operator form a linear space . therefore , to see that @xmath19 is @xmath141 bounded it is sufficient to prove that both @xmath125 and @xmath124 are @xmath141 bounded . to finish this note @xmath162 in comparable manner one can also verify that @xmath163 . since @xmath164bound of both @xmath125 and @xmath124 is less than one , the @xmath164bound of @xmath19 is also less than one for @xmath165 . the block operator matrix representation of the spin - boson hamiltonian reads @xmath166 the quantity @xmath167 is understood as @xmath168 . for the sake of simplicity we have set @xmath169 , the example remains non - trivial because @xmath170\not=0 $ ] . the corresponding riccati equation takes the form @xmath171 in order to solve this equation we define an operator @xmath172 as @xmath173 directly from ( [ parity ] ) we have @xmath174 and @xmath175 , thus @xmath172 is both self - adjoint and unitary . formally , @xmath172 can be written as @xmath176 , however , unlike @xmath177 , @xmath172 is everywhere defined . the hellinger - toeplitz theorem guaranties that @xmath172 is bounded , which can also be seen directly . indeed , form unitarity we obtain @xmath178 , for @xmath179 , hence @xmath180 . @xmath172 is , in fact , the bosonic parity operator @xcite . we will show that @xmath181 solves ( [ eq : sbriccati ] ) . since @xmath175 it is sufficient to show that @xmath182 in order to prove ( [ syl ] ) let us first note that @xmath183 , for @xmath184 , which means @xmath185 . this follows from @xmath186 . furthermore , @xmath187 and @xmath188 . the first equality is obvious , while the second one follows from @xmath189 and @xmath190 . and as a result we obtain ( [ syl ] ) . the stationary states in this example can be written as @xmath191 and @xmath192 are the eigenvectors of @xmath193 . unfortunately , the solution of this eigenproblem is not known for @xmath130 . however , one can determine certain bounds on @xmath194 using properties of @xmath172 and @xmath195 . first , @xmath196 are real numbers because @xmath172 is self - adjoint . from the non - negativity of @xmath195 we obtain that @xmath197 $ ] . equation ( [ eq : sbstate ] ) provides estimation of the stationary states of the spin - half immersed within the bosonic bath . this result has been obtained without any approximations . of course , @xmath194 can be computed approximately with the use of known methods . it is important to stress that to obtain the exact reduced dynamics for the model in question one needs to resolve an eigenvalue problem for @xmath98 . in the second example we consider the hamiltonian in the following form @xmath198 here we assume that linear , bounded operators @xmath199 , @xmath200 commute . in this example we impose restriction to the spectra of @xmath199 and @xmath200 , _ i.e. _ @xmath201 , @xmath202 are discrete and non - degenerated . the hamiltonian ( [ spin ] ) describes a qubit in contact with an environment and in the presence of the magnetic field @xmath203 , where @xmath204 . examples of such systems occur in the literature , _ e.g. _ @xcite . the block operator matrix representation of ( [ spin ] ) is given by ( [ eq : sbbom ] ) with @xmath205 and @xmath206 . the corresponding riccati equation reads ( [ eq : sbriccati ] ) . using the fact that @xmath199 and @xmath200 commute , so they have a common set of eigenvectors , we write @xmath207 where @xmath208 , @xmath209 and @xmath210 , for @xmath211 . the riccati equation has a positive and self - adjoint solution @xmath212 , where the function @xmath213 is given by @xmath214 unlike to the spin - boson model , in this case the eigenproblem for @xmath98 can be readily solved . indeed , we have @xmath215{\ensuremath{|\phi_n\rangle}}.\ ] ] according to the remark [ rem4 ] we obtain @xmath216 where @xmath217 . in this case there are no initial correlations between the systems since @xmath218 . we wish to emphasize that there may exist other solutions of the riccati equation . for an explicit example see ref . @xcite . in the case @xmath219 , the hamiltonian ( [ bom ] ) is already in a block diagonal form . one can notice that the riccati equation simplifies to the sylvester equation : @xmath220 there exist at least one solution , namely @xmath221 . the corresponding stationary states are given by the projections @xmath222 and @xmath223 . in the last example we consider an interesting example in which all the entries of @xmath6 are unbounded , but still the solution of the riccati equation exists as a bounded operator . to see this , let us choose @xmath224 with domain @xmath225 and let us assume that @xmath19 is self - adjoint with domain @xmath226 . then , the riccati equation @xmath227 has at least two bounded solutions , that is @xmath228 . the stationary states read @xmath229 an example in which all the entries of a block operator matrix are bounded and the solution of the riccati equation is unbounded has been provided in @xcite . in this paper we have proposed the method of calculating the stationary states for two - level open quantum system . the theory of block operator matrices has been adapted to achieve this purpose . in particular , we have related the solution of the algebraic riccati equation to stationary states . in the presented method , the stationary states are generated from the stationary states of the total system by tracing out the environment . our investigation includes the case when the initial system - environment correlations occur . in fact , this case is embedded in the method since the eigenstates of the total hamiltonian are entanglement . at the end , we want to stress that the method can not be used when the total hamiltonian is not known . such a situation arises _ e.g. _ , when the details of the interaction between the systems are not accessible . we hope that despite aforementioned weaknesses the results of the paper may serve as a starting point for further investigations . the authors are deeply grateful to the referee for very careful reading of the original manuscript and valuable suggestions . b. gardas would like to thank jerzy dajka for his suggestions and comments . this work was financed from the polish science budget resources in the years 2010 - 2013 as a research projects : grant number n n519 442339 and project number ip 2010 0334 70 . 10 j dajka m mierzejewski and j uczka 2008 non - markovian entanglement evolution of two uncoupled qubits link:10.1103/physreva.77.042316[*77 * 042316 ] j dajka j uczka and p hnggi 2011 geometric phase as a determinant of a qubit - environment coupling doi : 10.1007/s11128 - 010 - 0178-x[*10 * 85 - 96 ] j dajka m mierzejewski and j uczka 2009 fidelity of asymmetric dephasing channels link:10.1103/physreva.79.012104[*79 * 012104 ] a royer 1996 reduced dynamics with initial correlations , and time - dependent environment and hamiltonians link:10.1103/physrevlett.77.3272[*77 * 32723275 ] v kostrykin k makarov and a motovilov 2003 existence and uniqueness of solutions to the operator riccati equation . a geometric approach 181 198 p telmachovi and v bu ek 2003 erratum : dynamics of open quantum systems initially entangled with environment : beyond the kraus representation [ phys . rev . a 64 , 062106 ( 2001 ) ] link:10.1103/physreva.67.029902[*67 * 029902 ] dephasing of qubits by the schrdinger cat doi : 10.1016/j.physe.2009.06.080[*42 * 374 377 ] m reed b simon 1980 academic press new york f h szafraniec 1998 analytic models of the quantum harmonic oscillator 269276 f h szafraniec 2001 duality in the quantum harmonic oscillator link:10.1088/0305 - 4470/34/48/313[*34 * 10487 ] f h szafraniec 2007 how to recognize the creation operator link:10.1016/s0034 - 4877(07)80075 - 9 [ * 59 * 401 - 408 ] j stochel f h szafraniec 2002 a peculiarity of the creation operator link:10.1017/s0017089502010091[*44 * 137147 ] j blank p exner m havliek 2008 springer science@xmath230business media b.v g teschl 2009 ams providence c m bender p n meisinger and q wang 2003 all hermitian hamiltonians have parity link:10.1088/0305 - 4470/36/4/312[36 1029 ] h krovi 2007 non - markovian dynamics of a qubit coupled to an ising spin bath link:10.1103/physreva.76.052117[*76 * 052117 ] n arshed a h toor and d a lidar 2010 channel capacities of an exactly solvable spin - star system link:10.1103/physreva.81.062353[*81 * 062353 ]

a problem of finding stationary states of open quantum systems is addressed . we focus our attention on a generic type of open system : a qubit coupled to its environment . we apply the theory of block operator matrices and find stationary states of two level open quantum systems under certain conditions applied both on the qubit and the surrounding .

1606.08470

in metallic ferromagnets , spin - polarized currents can induce a spin - transfer - torque ( stt ) on the magnetization via direct transfer of spin - angular momentum from the itinerant charge carriers to the local magnetic moments . @xcite this phenomenon has opened the door for current - driven manipulation of magnetization in spintronic devices . however , a limiting factor is the high current densities required to switch the magnetization and the associated large dissipation and joule heating . a new and alternative current - induced spin - torque mechanism has been observed in systems with broken spatial inversion symmetry and strong spin - orbit coupling ( soc ) . @xcite due to the soc of these systems , an electric current is always accompanied by a net spin - polarization of the charge carriers , @xcite which via the exchange interaction produces a torque on the magnetization . such relativistic current - induced torques are commonly referred to as spin - orbit torques ( sots ) . in contrast to the stts , the sots require neither spin - polarizers nor textured ferromagnets to induce magnetization dynamics . furthermore , the sots show remarkably high torque efficiencies , @xcite leading to magnetization reversal at current densities that are approximately an order - of - magnitude smaller than that typically observed for stt - induced switching in metallic systems . -axis . a typical fermi surface of this system is illustrated in ( c ) . optimal cooper pairing occurs for momentum states with a finite center of mass momentum , i.e. , @xmath1 and @xmath2 . ] in the past few years , there has been a rapidly growing interest in superconductor - ferromagnet heterostructures with strong soc . @xcite these systems are particularly intriguing because they are considered to be promising platforms for realizing topological superconductivity . this was recently experimentally demonstrated for a chain of magnetic atoms placed on a conventional superconductor , where signatures of majorana fermions at the edges of the chain were observed . @xcite topological superconductivity has also been predicted in two - dimensional lattices of ferromagnetically ordered adatoms . @xcite so far , there is little knowledge of how supercurrents in these systems influence the ordered spins . however , studies on ferromagnetic josephson junctions have shown that supercurrents can produce a torque on the ferromagnetic interlayer via the creation of spin - triplet cooper pairs . @xcite the spin - triplet correlations in the interlayer are generated either via magnetic textures , ferromagnet - normal metal - ferromagnet trilayers , or soc . superconductors with broken spatial inversion symmetry and strong soc will be in a mixed superconducting state of singlet and triplet pairings . @xcite the cooper pairs can thus develop a net spin polarization when the time reversal symmetry is broken . because the superconductor / adatom systems have both broken spatial inversion symmetry and strong soc , an interesting question is whether supercurrents in these systems result in current - driven magnetization dynamics . in this work , we consider a lattice of ferromagnetically ordered spins in contact with a conventional superconductor with broken spatial inversion symmetry and strong soc ( fig . [ fig1]a ) . we find that supercurrents produce a reactive sot on the spins and formulate a phenomenological description of the supercurrent - induced magnetization dynamics . in contrast to normal metallic ferromagnets , the back - action of the spin dynamics on the superconducting system is important , and the resulting equations for the condensate and the spin system should be solved simultaneously to provide a correct description of the dynamics . furthermore , we study the spin - torque mechanism by using a tight - binding bogoliubov - de gennes ( bdg ) formalism to self - consistently calculate the response of the system to a supercurrent . we show that the sot originates from current - induced spin - triplet correlations , which is determined by the orientation of the supercurrent with respect to the crystallographic axes . moreover , we find that there exists an intrinsic limitation for the maximum achievable sot and estimate the corresponding effective sot field to be on the order of @xmath0 mt in proximitized hole - doped semiconductors , which is comparable to the critical sot field for magnetization reversal in ( ga , mn)as . we therefore believe that the supercurrent - induced sots can lead to the development of new efficient techniques for manipulating magnetization , which minimize the disadvantages associated with dissipation and joule heating . in what follows , we develop a phenomenology that captures the low - frequency long - wavelength physics of the supercurrent - induced magnetization dynamics . the superconducting condensate is treated in the framework of the ginzburg - landau theory , which is valid at length scales larger than the superconducting coherence length @xmath3 . we assume a homogeneous ferromagnetic equilibrium state and consider spatial modulations of the ferromagnetic order parameter at length scales much larger than the exchange length @xmath4 set by the spin stiffness @xmath5 and relevant anisotropy constants @xmath6 . typically , @xmath7 nm and @xmath8 nm.@xcite the characteristic frequency @xmath9 of ferromagnets is on the order of @xmath10 ghz , @xcite which is far below the typical energy gap of superconductors : @xmath11 mev.@xcite the magnetization precession will therefore not lead to quasi - particle excitations in the superconductor and we can assume that the condensate responds adiabatically to the magnetization dynamics . we start by formulating the free energy functional , @xmath12 $ ] , of the system : @xmath13 . \label{eq : ftot}\ ] ] here , @xmath14 represents the order parameter of the spin system and is a unit vector parallel to the magnetization @xmath15 , @xmath16 is the order parameter field of the superconductor , and @xmath17 is the magnetic vector potential that yields the magnetic field @xmath18 . @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the free energy densities of the isolated spin system and superconducting condensate , respectively , @xcite @xmath21 where @xmath22 describes the magnetic anisotropy energy , @xmath23 is the momentum operator of the condensate , @xmath24 is the charge of the cooper pairs , and @xmath25 is the speed of light . @xmath26 and @xmath27 are second - rank polar tensors , which are invariant under the symmetry point group of the system . @xcite the term @xmath28 describes the coupling between the superconductor and the magnetization . we consider weak modulations of a homogenous ferromagnetic equilibrium state and can thus neglect magnetoelectric coupling effects associated with magnetic textures . in this case , @xmath28 is governed by the lifshitz invariant @xcite @xmath29 where @xmath30 represents the momentum density of the superconducting condensate . the tensor @xmath31 is linear in the soc and is an invariant axial tensor of the point group . @xcite consequently , the tensor vanishes for systems with spatial inversion symmetry . @xmath28 can be derived microscopically by considering an s - wave superconductor with soc of the form @xmath32 ( where @xmath33 ) and calculate the energy change due to a zeeman field . @xcite so far , most works have concentrated on the effects of the lifshitz invariant in non - centrosymmetric superconductors exposed to an external magnetic field . however , two recent studies showed that @xmath28 leads to persistent currents in a conventional superconductor with soc when magnetic impurities are placed at the surface . @xcite @xmath28 couples the momentum of the condensate to the direction of the magnetization and favors a spatial modulation of @xmath34 in equilibrium . the physical origin of @xmath28 is an soc - induced shift of the fermi surface , leading to a finite center of mass momentum of the cooper pairs . to illustrate this phenomenon , consider a system with rashba soc and a zeeman splitting @xmath35 along the @xmath36-axis induced by the magnetization ( fig . [ fig1]b ) : @xmath37 . here , @xmath38 is a vector consisting of the pauli matrices , @xmath39 is the effective quasi - particle mass , and @xmath40 parameterizes the soc . for this system , the lifshitz invariant becomes @xmath41 . the fermi surface of the hamiltonian is two circles , whose centers are shifted in opposite directions along the x - axis ( fig . [ fig1]c ) . due to the shift of the fermi surface , the optimal cooper pairing occurs for momentum states with a finite center of mass momentum , i.e. , @xmath1 and @xmath2 . therefore , the order - parameter field gains a spatial modulation @xmath42 in equilibrium ; a state that is referred to as the helical phase . @xcite phenomenologically , the helical phase is captured by the lifshitz invariant @xmath43 , which favors the vector @xmath44 to be perpendicular to the in - plane component of the magnetization . in what follows , we demonstrate that the lifshitz invariant also leads to a reciprocal phenomenon of the helical phase . if @xmath34 is forced to have a spatial modulation @xmath45 such that a supercurrent is induced , then the condensate can via @xmath28 lower its energy by developing a net spin density @xmath46 ( and magnetic moment @xmath47 ) perpendicular to the vector @xmath48 : @xmath49 . importantly , we find that the induced spin density @xmath46 produces a novel sot on the magnetization . the magnetization dynamics is described by the landau - lifshitz - gilbert ( llg ) equation @xcite @xmath50 + \alpha_g \mathbf{m } \times \dot { \mathbf{m } } . \label{eq : llg}\ ] ] here , @xmath51 is the effective field found from the magnetic free energy functional @xmath52 , @xmath53 is the gyromagnetic ratio , and the term proportional to the gilbert damping parameter @xmath54 determines the magnetization dissipation . because of the lifshitz invariant , the variation of eq . with respect to the magnetization also yields a reactive sot - field @xmath55 which is governed by the soc and the momentum density of the superconducting condensate . the magnetization evolves slowly on the characteristic timescale of the electron dynamics . we can therefore assume that the superconducting condensate at time @xmath56 is close to the equilibrium state with the static magnetization @xmath57 . the equilibrium state , which is determined by the ginzburg - landau ( gl ) equations , is obtained by variational minimization of the free energy . the variation with respect to @xmath58 yields the equation @xmath59 whereas a variation of @xmath60 provides the equation @xmath61 here , @xmath62 is the supercurrent density . the conventional gl equations are obtained for a fully isotropic system , in which @xmath63 and @xmath64 . eqs . , and give a phenomenological description of the coupled dynamics of the spin system and the superconducting condensate . via the lifshitz invariant , the state of the superconducting condensate depends on the direction of the magnetization . the effects of @xmath28 become crucially important when the length scale @xmath65 associated with the helical wavevector @xmath66 is smaller than the characteristic length scales of the ferromagnetic system . in this case , the condensate is strongly affected by the magnetization dynamics and its state can not be considered as quasi - static for the dynamics . thus , eqs . , and should be solved simultaneously to provide a correct description of both the magnetization dynamics and the superconducting condensate . this differs markedly from the situation in normal metallic ferromagnets , in which the back - action of the spin dynamics on the itinerant electron system usually can be disregarded in the solution of the llg equation . for a two - band model with rashba soc , the helical wavevector is on the order of @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the fermi velocity.@xcite here , the factor @xmath69 measures of the difference between the density of states @xmath70 of the two bands at the fermi energy . in the limit @xmath71 , it is determined by @xmath72 . to get some insight into the typical scale of @xmath66 , let us estimate @xmath66 for the proximitized hole - doped semiconductor system studied in sec . [ sec : micro ] . for this system , we find the helical wavevector @xmath73 m@xmath74 ( material parameters are given in sec . [ sec : model ] ) . this is about an order of magnitude larger than the wavevector observed for the pair potential in a proximitized hgte quantum well system subjected to an in - plane magnetic field of @xmath75 t. @xcite thus , it is likely that the spatial modulation of the order parameter field @xmath34 becomes important for the magnetization dynamics at length scales larger than @xmath76 @xmath77 m . to gain a better understanding of the underlying physical mechanisms of the sot , we will now use the bdg formalism to self - consistently calculate the response of the system to a supercurrent . we model the two - dimensional superconductor by the tight - binding hamiltonian @xmath78 here , @xmath79 , where @xmath80 is a fermionic creation operator that creates a particle with spin @xmath81 at lattice site @xmath82 and the symbol @xmath83 implies a summation over nearest lattice sites . @xmath84 is the spin - independent hopping energy , @xmath85 is the zeeman splitting induced by the adatom spins ( @xmath85 and @xmath86 are collinear ) , and @xmath87 is a unit vector that points from site @xmath88 to site @xmath89 . the second - rank tensor @xmath90 parameterizes the soc . we consider a system described by the @xmath91 point group , in which the soc can be decomposed in two terms having rashba and dresselhaus symmetry , respectively . for rashba soc , the soc tensor takes the form @xmath92 , whereas the specific form the dresselhaus soc depends on how the coordinate system is fixed with respect to the crystallographic axes . if the @xmath93-axis is along one of the two reflection planes of @xmath91 , then the dresselhaus soc tensor is @xmath94 . with respect to this reference frame , a rotation of the axes by @xmath95 degrees about the @xmath96-axis leads to a sign change of @xmath97 , while a rotation of @xmath98 degrees changes the tensor to @xmath99 . note that @xmath90 and @xmath31 satisfy the same transformation rules and thus have the same tensorial forms , i.e. , @xmath100 . . the color represents the phase @xmath101 of the pair potential @xmath102 , while the black arrows illustrate the local spin density @xmath103 . ( b ) system ( a ) with an enforced superconducting phase difference of @xmath95 between two of the sample edges . ( c ) symmetry plot of the induced spin density for a rashba system . the figure shows the stereographic projection of the @xmath91 point group and the blue arrows illustrate the orientation of the induced spin density for a supercurrent along different crystallographic directions . ( d)-(f ) show corresponding plots for the case with dresselhaus soc and a zeeman splitting field along @xmath36 . in ( a)-(b ) and ( d)-(e ) , the size of the system is @xmath104 grid points . ] @xmath105 describes the superconducting s - wave pairing and is determined by @xmath106 .\label{eq : delta1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath107 is the on - site attractive interaction between the quasi - particles , @xmath108 denotes the thermal average , @xmath109 is the fermi - dirac distribution , and we have inserted the bogoliubov transformation @xmath110 $ ] , where @xmath111 ( @xmath112 ) are the bogoliubov quasi - particle creation ( destruction ) operators , which represent a complete set of energy eigenstates : @xmath113 . @xmath114 is the groundstate energy ; the summation runs over positive energy eigenstates with an energy smaller than the cut - off energy @xmath115 set by the debye frequency @xmath116 . the hamiltonian is transformed to bdg hamiltonian by using the bogoliubov transformation @xcite , which is then iteratively solved together with the self - consistency condition @xcite until the euclidean norm of the pair potential ( @xmath117 ) reaches a relative error on the order @xmath118 . in the following , the hamiltonian is scaled with the hopping energy @xmath84 and the chemical potential , the pairing strength , the rashba ( dresselhaus ) soc , the zeeman splitting , the thermal energy @xmath119 , and the debye frequency are set to : @xmath120 , @xmath121 , @xmath122 , @xmath123 , @xmath124 , and @xmath125 , respectively . in eq . , we use open boundary conditions . the hopping and rashba energies in the tight - binding hamiltonian are related to a central difference discretization of the corresponding continuum model via the relationships @xmath126 and @xmath127 , where @xmath128 is the spacing between the grid points and @xmath129 is the soc parameter in the continuum model . the parameter values given above model a lightly hole - doped semiconductor in proximity to a conventional s - wave superconductor , in which the effective mass is @xmath130 ( @xmath131 is the electron mass ) , the soc is @xmath132 ev , the fermi energy is @xmath133 mev when measured from the bottom of the lowest subband , and the fermi wavelength is @xmath134 nm , which is much larger than the discretization constant @xmath135 nm . @xcite a , b . the lines represent piecewise polynomial fits of the data points . ] first , we study the equilibrium spin density @xmath103 of the superconducting condensate . we consider the two cases with rashba and dresselhaus soc separately . [ fig2]a shows the self - consistent solution for a rashba system with an exchange field along @xmath93 . the black arrows represent the spin density , while the color illustrates the phase @xmath101 of the pair potential @xmath102 . the phase variation perpendicular to the exchange field ( i.e. , along @xmath36 ) is a signature of the helical phase . we see that the condensate has a net spin polarization anti - parallel to the exchange field . this is also the case for a system with dresselhaus soc of the form @xmath99 and an exchange field along @xmath36 ( fig . [ fig2]d ) . note that in this case , the pair potential has a phase variation parallel to the exchange field , which is in agreement with eq . when @xmath136 . next , we investigate the effects of a supercurrent . a supercurrent is induced along the @xmath93-axis by enforcing the pair potential to have a constant phase in a small region close to each of the two boundaries along @xmath93 . we set the widths of these two regions to three lattice points . thus , the pair potential is solved self - consistently for the entire sample except for the two regions at the boundaries where the phase @xmath101 is kept fixed ( however , the magnitude @xmath137 is allowed to optimize itself ) . these two regions will therefore act as sinks / sources for the supercurrent . [ fig2]b , e shows the solution for the rashba and dresselhaus systems with a phase difference of @xmath95 between the two boundaries . in both cases , the spin density is tilted away from the equilibrium value . in other words : the supercurrent induces a spin - density @xmath46 . a similar inverse spin - galvanic effect has been theoretically predicted for superconductors with rashba soc in the absence of magnetization . @xcite @xmath46 is solely an effect of the soc , and its orientation is determined by the direction of the supercurrent relative to the crystallographic axes . [ fig2]c , f shows the stereographic projection of the @xmath91 point group , and the blue arrows illustrate the orientation of @xmath46 for different directions of the supercurrent ( @xmath138 along the different directions ) . generally , the supercurrent results in a spin density @xmath139 . via the exchange coupling , @xmath46 produces a torque on the magnetization and is the physical origin of the sot field in eq . : @xmath140 . the polarization of the condensate originates from spin - triplet correlations . let @xmath141 ( @xmath142 ) denote the amplitude for triplet pair correlations with spin up ( down ) along an arbitrary quantization axis , which is determined by the unitary rotation operator @xmath143 . here , @xmath144 are the fermionic operators in the rotated frame . the quantity @xmath145 $ ] represents a measure of the spin polarization of the cooper pairs along the quantization axis . in fig . [ fig3 ] , we consider the rashba system in fig . [ fig2]a - b and plot @xmath146 and the supercurrent @xmath147 along @xmath93 as a function of the phase difference @xmath148 between the left and right boundaries . the spin quantization axis is along @xmath36 . it is clear from fig . [ fig3 ] that @xmath146 is proportional to the supercurrent . we obtain a similar relationship between the current and @xmath146 for the dresselhaus system in fig . [ fig2]d - e when the polarization is measured along @xmath93 . thus , we conclude that the underlying physical mechanism of the sot field is current - induced spin - triplet correlations . of the superconductor s free energy @xmath149 for different directions of @xmath150 $ ] . ( b ) the magnetoelectric anisotropy constant @xmath151 for different values of @xmath35 . ( c ) the average energy gap for different values of @xmath35 . in all figures , the size of the system is @xmath152 grid points and the phase difference between the two boundaries is @xmath153 . the squares represent the calculated values , while the line in ( a ) is a piecewise polynomial fit . in ( a ) the free energy was calculated for @xmath154 . ] the strength of the sot field can be investigated by self - consistently calculating the free energy of the condensate for different directions of @xmath150 $ ] . here , @xmath155 is the angle with the @xmath93-axis , which is parallel to the direction of the supercurrent . the anisotropic part of the free energy is then a direct measure of the lifshitz invariant . we consider a system with rashba soc . the free energy of an inhomogeneous superconductor is @xcite @xmath156 + \frac{1}{v } \int { \rm d}\mathbf{r } |\delta ( \mathbf{r } ) |^2 , \label{eq : fs}\ ] ] where the sum is over the positive energy eigenstates and @xmath157 . [ fig4]a shows the anisotropic part @xmath158 of the free energy . the angular dependence of @xmath159 follows the functional form @xmath160 , which is consistent with the lifshitz invariant when a current is applied along the @xmath93-axis ( with extrema at @xmath161 and @xmath162 ) . the different extremum values at @xmath163 and @xmath164 is caused by a change in the momentum density due to the helical modulation ( along the @xmath93-axis ) of the order parameter field . the effect of the zeeman splitting @xmath35 on the sot is twofold . firstly , it determines the coupling strength between the spin system and the condensate and thus enhances the magnetoelectric coupling @xmath159 . secondly , it suppresses superconductivity and thus reduces the supercurrent / momentum density . the competition between these two counteracting effects implies that there exists an intrinsic limitation for the maximum achievable sot . [ fig4]b shows the magnetoelectric anisotropy constant @xmath151 . a maximum sot is achieved for @xmath165 with @xmath166 mev and corresponds the point where the zeeman splitting is comparable to the pair potential , i.e. , @xmath167 . for larger values of @xmath35 , the suppression of the superconductivity becomes stronger ( fig . [ fig4]c ) , which leads to a lowering of @xmath168 . the effective sot field induced by the supercurrent is @xmath169 , where @xmath170 is the volume of the ferromagnetic system . assuming @xmath171 e.m.u . @xmath172 , @xcite @xmath173 , and @xmath174 mev , yields an sot field on the order of @xmath175 mt . in the ferromagnetic semiconductor ( ga , mn)as , current - driven magnetization switching has been observed for effective sot fields on the order of @xmath176 mt . @xcite therefore , it is reasonable to believe that the supercurrent - induced sot is strong enough to manipulate the magnetization of the ferromagnetically ordered spins . in summary , we have studied the magnetization dynamics of a two - dimensional lattice of spins in contact with a conventional superconductor and have formulated a phenomenological description of the coupled dynamics of the superconducting condensate and the magnetization . interestingly , we found that supercurrents induce a reactive sot field that originates from current - induced spin - triplet correlations and whose spatial orientation is determined by the symmetry of the soc . furthermore , we showed that there exists an intrinsic limitation for the maximum achievable sot , which is determined by the coupling strength between the condensate and the spin system . based on material parameters for a proximitized hole - doped semiconductor , we estimated the induced sot field to be on the order of @xmath0 mt . the hamiltonian can be diagonalized by using the bogoliubov transformation @xcite @xmath177 here , @xmath178 and @xmath112 are the bogoliubov quasi - particle creation and destruction operators , which satisfy fermionic anti - commutation relations and represent a complete set of energy eigenstates : @xmath179 @xmath114 is the ground state energy , and the summation runs over positive energy eigenstates with an energy lower than the cut - off energy set by the debye frequency . the thermal averages of the bogoliubov quasi - particle excitations are given by @xmath180 , where @xmath181 is the fermi - dirac distribution . it is also useful to introduce the distribution function of the corresponding hole states : @xmath182 . the charge density @xmath185 at site @xmath89 is given by the thermal average of the number operator @xmath186 , where @xmath187 is the charge of the quasi - particles . an expression for the current density @xmath188 is found from the heisenberg equation @xmath189 $ ] , which yields @xmath190 + \nonumber \\ & & \frac{2q}{\hbar } \sum_{n\tau\tau^ { ' } } \left [ u_{n \tau}^{\ast } ( \mathbf{i } ) a_{k , \tau\tau^ { ' } } u_{n \tau^ { ' } } ( \mathbf{i } ) f ( \epsilon_n ) + v_{n \tau } ( \mathbf{i } ) a_{k , \tau\tau^ { ' } } v_{n \tau^{'}}^{\ast } ( \mathbf{i } ) f_h ( \epsilon_n ) \right ] + \frac{2q}{\hbar } \sum_{\tau\tau^ { ' } } { \rm i m } \left [ \delta_{\mathbf{i } } i\sigma_{y , \tau\tau^ { ' } } \langle c_{\mathbf{i}\tau } ^{\dagger } c_{\mathbf{i}\tau^{'}}^{\dagger } \rangle \right ] . \label{eq : current}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath191 /2 $ ] and @xmath192 , where @xmath193 is the lattice vector along @xmath194 . note that the last term vanishes when the pair potential satisfies the self - consistency condition . otherwise , the term acts as a sink / source . eq . is used to calculate the current - phase relation , which is shown in fig . 3 of this article . these correlation functions can be expressed in an arbitrary reference frame by transforming the fermionic operators : @xmath144 . @xmath196 is the unitary rotation operator , which maps the @xmath96-axis to the quantization axis in the new reference frame . a. chernyshov , m. overby , x. liu , j. k. furdyna , y. lyanda - geller and l. p. rokhinson , nat . phys . * 5 * , 656 ( 2009 ) . i. m. miron , g. gaudin , s. auffret , b. rodmacq , a. schuhl , s. pizzini , j. vogel and p. gambardella nat . mat . * 9 * , 230 ( 2010 ) . d. fang , h. kurebayashi , j. wunderlich , k. vyborny , l. p. zarbo , r. p. campion , a. casiraghi , b. l. gallagher , t. jungwirth and a. j. ferguson , nat . nanotech . * 6 * , 413 ( 2011 ) . x. fan , j. wu , y. chen , m. j. jerry , h. zhang , and j. q. xiao , nat . commun . * 4 * , 1799 ( 2013 ) . h. kurebayashi _ . nanotech . * 9 * , 211 ( 2014 ) . c. ciccarelli , k. m. d. hals , a. irvine , v. novak , y. tserkovnyak , h. kurebayashi , a. brataas , and a. ferguson , nat . nanotech . * 10 * , 50 ( 2015 ) . for reviews see , a. brataas and k. m. d. hals , nat . * 9 * , 86 ( 2014 ) ; p. gambardella and i. m. miron , phil . a * 369 * , 3175 ( 2011 ) . b. a. bernevig and o. vafek , phys . b * 72 * , 033203 ( 2005 ) . a. manchon and s. zhang , phys . b * 78 * , 212405 ( 2008 ) . i. garate and a. h. macdonald , phys . b * 80 * , 134403 ( 2009 ) . k. m. d. hals , a. brataas , and y. tserkovnyak , europhys . lett . * 90 * , 47002 ( 2010 ) . d. a. pesin and a. h. macdonald , phys . rev . b * 86 * , 014416 ( 2012 ) . e. van der bijl and r. a. duine , phys . b * 86 * , 094406 ( 2012 ) . x. wang and a. manchon , phys . rev . * 108 * , 117201 ( 2012 ) . f. freimuth , s. blgel , y. mokrousov , phys . b * 90 * , 174423 ( 2014 ) . k. m. d. hals and a. brataas , phys . b * 88 * , 085423 ( 2013 ) . s. nadj - perge , i. k. drozdov , b. a. bernevig , and a. yazdani , phys . b * 88 * , 020407(r ) ( 2013 ) . j. klinovaja , p. stano , a. yazdani , and d. loss , phys . lett . * 111 * , 186805 ( 2013 ) . m. m. vazifeh and m. franz , phys . * 111 * , 206802 ( 2013 ) . b. braunecker and p. simon , phys . 111 * , 147202 ( 2013 ) . s. nadj - perge _ et al . _ , science * 346 * , 602 ( 2014 ) . m. sato , y. takahashi , and s. fujimoto , phys . b * 82 * , 134521 ( 2010 ) . j. d. sau , r. m. lutchyn , s. tewari , and s. das sarma , phys . * 104 * , 040502 ( 2010 ) . l. mao and c. zhang , phys . b * 82 * , 174506 ( 2010 ) . k. bjrnson and a. m. black - schaffer , phys . b * 88 * , 024501 ( 2013 ) . j. li , t. neupert , z. j. wang , a. h. macdonald , a. yazdani , b. a. bernevig , arxiv:1501.00999 . x. waintal and p. w. brouwer , phys . b * 65 * , 054407 ( 2002 ) . e. zhao and j. a. sauls , phys . b * 78 * , 174511 ( 2008 ) . f. konschelle and a. buzdin , phys . lett . * 102 * , 017001 ( 2009 ) . j. linder , a. brataas , z. shomali , and m. zareyan , phys . lett . * 109 * , 237206 ( 2012 ) . i. kulagina and j. linder , phys . b * 90 * , 054504 ( 2014 ) . k. halterman , o. t. valls , and c. t. wu , phys . b * 92 * , 174516 ( 2015 ) . for a review see j. linder and j. w. a. robinson , nat . phys . * 11 * , 307 ( 2015 ) and references therein . for a symmetry transformation @xmath197 , the tensorial form of an invariant polar tensor @xmath198 of rank @xmath199 is determined by the equations @xmath200 , whereas an invariant axial tensor is determined by @xmath201 . here , @xmath202 represents the determinant of the matrix @xmath203 , which is an element of the system s point group . s. s. pershoguba , k. bjrnson , a. m. black - schaffer , and a. v. balatsky , phys . lett . * 115 * , 116602 ( 2015 ) ; k. bjrnson , s. s. pershoguba , a. v. balatsky , and a. m. black - schaffer , phys . b * 92 * , 214501 ( 2015 ) .

we theoretically investigate the supercurrent - induced magnetization dynamics of a two - dimensional lattice of ferromagnetically ordered spins placed on a conventional superconductor with broken spatial inversion symmetry and strong spin - orbit coupling . we develop a phenomenological description of the coupled dynamics of the superconducting condensate and the spin system , and demonstrate that supercurrents produce a reactive spin - orbit torque on the magnetization . by performing a microscopic self - consistent calculation , we show that the spin - orbit torque originates from a spin - polarization of the cooper pairs due to current - induced spin - triplet correlations . interestingly , we find that there exists an intrinsic limitation for the maximum achievable spin - orbit torque , which is determined by the coupling strength between the condensate and the spin system . in proximitized hole - doped semiconductors , the maximum achievable spin - orbit torque field is estimated to be on the order of @xmath0 mt , which is comparable to the critical field for current - induced magnetization switching in ferromagnetic semiconductors .

0801.1517

the successful launch of the _ swift _ satellite in nov 2004 opened a new window to reveal what has been happening in the early afterglow phase of gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) . as summarized in zhang et al . ( 2006 ) and nousek et al . ( 2006 ) , in a canonical _ swift _ grb x - ray afterglow lightcurve some interesting features are emerging ( detected in a good fraction of but not all bursts ) , including a very early sharp decline ( phase - i ) , a shallow decline or even plateau , ( phase - ii ) , preceding the conventional or so - called normal " decay phase ( phase - iii & -iv ) , and the energetic x - ray flares ( phase - v ) . various modifications of the standard grb afterglow model have been put forward to explain the observations ( see mszros 2006 ; piran & fan 2007 ; zhang 2007 for recent reviews ) . although the underlying physical processes are not very clear , it is widely suggested that the x - ray phases i , ii and v may be relevant to prolonged activities of the central engine while the simultaneous optical afterglow is dominated by grb forward shock emission ( fan & wei 2005 ; zhang et al . 2006 ; ghisellini et al . 2007 ; panaitescu 2007 ) . if so , the early time uv / optical and x - ray polarization behaviors should be independent and may be very different from each other . in some models , the outflows powering energetic flares and x - ray plateaus followed by a sharp drop are poynting - flux dominated ( e.g. , gao & fan 2006 ; giannios 2006 ; troja et al . 2007 ) , thus high - linear polarization of these synchrotron radiation photons is expected ( fan , zhang & proga 2005 ) . except the configuration of the magnetic field , the geometry of the emitting area can influence the polarization property of the synchrotron radiation as well . the broken - down of the symmetry of the visible emitting region may be hiding in the peculiar x - ray data and can give rise to interesting polarization signatures . motivated by this idea , in section 2 we calculate the polarization property of phase - i and show that strong evolution is likely . in section 3 , we argue that similar phenomena are also expected in the decline phase of the x - ray flares and possibly in the late time part of phase - ii , especially those associated with a chromatic break in optical band . we also discuss the detection prospect there . in section 4 , we summarize our work with some discussions . for phase - i , two leading interpretations are : ( i ) these x - ray photons are actually the high latitude emission of a main internal shock pulse ( fenimore et al . 1996 ; kumar & panaitescu 2000 ; zhang et al . 2006 ) while the central engine has died ; and ( ii ) these x - ray photons are powered by the weaker and weaker activity of the central engine , i.e. , the sharp x - ray decline traces the activity of the dying central engine ( fan & wei 2005 ; piran & fan 2007 ) . the interpretation ( i ) has been widely accepted because some x - ray declines can be adjusted as @xmath1 predicted by the high latitude emission model ( liang et al . 2006 ; yamazaki et al . 2006 ; zhang , liang & zhang 2007a ) , where @xmath2 is the x - ray spectral index , and @xmath3 is a free parameter parameterizing the beginning of a certain internal shock pulse.ray emission are powered by some magnetic energy dissipation processes at a distance @xmath4 cm to the central engine , so the emission duration is governed by the angular timescale @xmath5 sec , where @xmath6 is the bulk lorentz factor of the outflow . ] such a test , however , is not conclusive . as shown in sakamoto et al . ( 2007 ) , for the very sharp x - ray decline , the data itself can not well constrain the function form @xmath7 . in many events , @xmath8 can be taken as a constant ( for example , @xmath9 ) and thus is not relevant to @xmath2 . additionally , it is not easy to see why the grb central engine turns off abruptly while the numerical simulation actually shows the contrast ( macfadyen et al . 2001 ; zhang , woosley & heger 2007b ) . interpretation ( i ) also fails to interpret some slowly decaying phase - i as in grb 060614 @xcite . as for interpretation ( ii ) , there has been no strict observational test so far though it seems possible for any energetic burst phenomenon . we take into account both models in our calculation and examine the possibility to distinguish between these two models with future x - ray polarimetry . if interpretation ( i ) is correct , i.e. , the sharp x - ray decline is due to the high latitude emission of a main internal shock pulse , there would be very interesting polarization signals . as is known , grb outflow is likely to be jetted . in this work we only consider the uniform jet model . following ghisellini & lazzati ( 1999 ) , we assume that the half - opening angle of the ejecta is @xmath10 , and that the line of sight ( l.o.s . ) makes an angle @xmath11 with respect to the jet s central axis ( c.a . , see fig.1a for illustration ) . the probability of observing the ejecta along its c.a . is vanishingly small since it corresponds a very small solid angle . for typical bright grbs , the l.o.s . is likely to be within the cone , i.e. , @xmath12 . at early time , the high latitude emission is from zones around the l.o.s . satisfying @xmath13 , so the net polarization of the detected photons vanishes because of the symmetry ; but at later time , the high latitude emission is from @xmath14 , the symmetry is broken and the observed net polarization is not zero any longer . ( 0,200 ) ( 0,0 ) in this model , the photons arrived at @xmath15 were emitted from @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the radius of the main internal shock pulse and @xmath18 is the speed of light . below we adopt the simplified calculation of ghisellini & lazzati ( 1999 ) . the notations used in fig.[fig : cartoon]b are related to @xmath19 , @xmath10 and @xmath20 as @xmath21 and @xmath22 . when @xmath23 , the ring is not a complete circle . the missing parts are in @xmath24 and @xmath25 as shown in fig.[fig : cartoon ] . approximately , we have ( ghisellini & lazzati 1999 ) @xmath26 , & \hbox{for $ \rho > r_1 $ ; } \\ 0 , & \hbox{for $ \rho < r_1 $ , } \\ \end{array}% \right.\ ] ] where @xmath27 . in principle , the grb outflow could be either baryon - rich or poynting - flux dominated . for the former the magnetic field is generated in the shock front and is likely to be random . for the latter the magnetic field is coherent in a large scale . the resulting polarization light curves are expected to be different in these two cases , as shown below . * random magnetic field . * the net polarization of the emission from @xmath28 can be approximated by ( see the appendix for the derivation ) @xmath29\ } % \nonumber\\ % & = & \pi_0{\sin\{2\arcsin[{2\sin\theta_{\rm j } \sin(\theta_{\rm % j}-\theta_{\rm v } ) -\sin^2(\theta_{\rm j}-\theta_{\rm v } ) -\sin^2 % \theta \over 2\sin \theta [ \sin\theta_{\rm j}-\sin(\theta_{\rm % j}-\theta_{\rm v})]}]\ } \over \pi+2\arcsin [ { 2\sin\theta_{\rm j } % \sin(\theta_{\rm j}-\theta_{\rm v } ) -\sin^2(\theta_{\rm % j}-\theta_{\rm v } ) -\sin^2 \theta \over 2\sin \theta % [ \sin\theta_{\rm j}-\sin(\theta_{\rm j}-\theta_{\rm v } ) ] } ] } , \label{eq : main}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath30 is the maximum polarization at one point , @xmath31 is the viewing angle with respect to the fluid velocity in the outflow comoving frame ( see figure [ point ] for illustration ) , which is governed by @xmath32 , and the parameter @xmath33 denotes the level of anisotropy of the magnetic field distribution , where @xmath34 and @xmath35 are magnetic field perpendicular and parallel to the normal of the shock plane . @xmath36 is the velocity of the grb ejecta in units of @xmath18 . we note that in eq.([eq : main ] ) @xmath37 if @xmath38 . for @xmath39 , we have @xmath40\ll 1 $ ] . the resulting net polarization can thus be neglected . but for @xmath41 , the second term in the right side of eq.([eq : main ] ) is @xmath42 . significant net polarization is possible . as @xmath43 , the observers just detected @xmath44 part of the circle , the x - ray flux will decline more steeply than @xmath45 and is governed by @xmath46 we plot in fig.[fig : lc ] the sharp x - ray decline and the corresponding polarization light curves . when the emission is from a circle ring , the net polarization is zero because of the symmetry . as @xmath47 is getting larger and just part of the ring is visible , the observed polarization degree is not zero any longer until @xmath48 ( i.e. , @xmath49 ) . at the point of @xmath50 , the net polarization becomes zero again according to equation ( 3 ) , because the polarization direction abruptly changes by @xmath51 . after this point , the polarization increases again . but the flux may be too weak to have a significant polarization measurement . ( 0,240 ) ( 0,0 ) * homogenous magnetic field . * in this case , the instantaneous stokes parameters ( note that @xmath52 as the polarization is linear ) and the polarization degree are given by ( granot & knigl 2003 ) : @xmath53^{\epsilon/2 } \left\ { \begin{array}{c } \cos(2\theta _ { p } ) \\ \sin(2\theta _ { p } ) \\ \end{array}\right\ } d\phi } { \int _ { \psi_1}^{2\pi-\psi_1}[({1-y \over 1+y})^2 \cos^2\phi+\sin^2 \phi]^{\epsilon/2}d\phi},\ ] ] and @xmath54 where @xmath55 , @xmath56 and @xmath57 ( granot & knigl 2003 ) . again the polarization light curve has been plotted in fig.[fig : lc ] , which is similar to that of the random magnetic field case except an initial high polarization degree . this strongly suggests that the late time non - zero polarization is mainly contributed by the geometry effect , as in the case of a random magnetic field . if the symmetry has not been broken down , the late time net polarization for an ordered magnetized outflow disappears , as already found in nakar , piran & waxman ( 2003 ) . generally , in the dying central engine model there are two possibilities . ( 1 ) if the outflow powering the fast decaying x - ray tail emission always has a lorentz factor @xmath58 , no strong polarization evolution is expected unless the physical composition of the outflow has changed a lot ( e.g. , from byron dominated to poynting - flux dominated ) . we thus may be able to distinguish between the high latitude emission model and the dying central engine model with the future x - ray polarimetry . ( 2 ) the bulk lorentz factor of the outflow drops so quickly as to satisfy @xmath59 in a short period . when @xmath60 , the symmetry of the visible emitting area is broken and interesting polarization signature begins to exist . since there is little information about the evolution of @xmath6 with @xmath15 , we here simply assume @xmath61 for @xmath62 sec and @xmath10 and @xmath20 are constant . again , we calculate the polarization evolution in the cases of _ random magnetic field _ and _ homogenous magnetic field_. but now the calculation should be due to the emission area within @xmath63 , rather than from a ring at @xmath47 in the high latitude emission model . therefore , we calculate the quantities of @xmath64 along the radius @xmath65 and integrate them over @xmath65 . such calculations have been carried out by ghisellini & lazzati ( 1999 ) and granot & knigl ( 2003 ) , respectively . our numerical results are presented in figure [ fig : lc2 ] . one can see that polarization evolution is evident and shares some similarity with that in fig.[fig : lc ] , particularly in the case of _ random magnetic filed _ , though the polarization degree of high latitude emission model is larger than that of the dying central engine model . this is reasonable since in the former case the emission is from the ring while in the latter case the emission is from @xmath66 . in the case of _ homogenous magnetic filed _ , the evolution is small because of the significant polarization background ( the degree is @xmath67 ) caused by the ordered magnetic field from the central source . ( 0,200 ) ( 0,0 ) our calculations in section 2 are actually applicable to more phases in the grb x - ray afterglow light curve . one is the decline phase of x - ray flares ( in phase - v ) , which is also attributed to the high latitude emission model or the dying ( re-)activity of the central engine . the other is the late phase of the x - ray flattening ( in phase - ii ) . recently ghisellini et al . ( 2007 ) interpreted phase - ii , particularly those show chromatic breaks in x - ray and optical bands , as the prolonged emission of the central engine . the x - ray flattening ceases to exist when the bulk lorentz factor of the outflow is so small that one sees the edge of the outflow . if these interpretations are correct , strong polarization evolution should be present at the end of phase - ii and in the decline of phase - v . measuring polarization is of growing interest in high energy astronomy . new technologies are being invented , and several polarimeter projects are under construction . in the x - ray band , the ongoing projects include xpe ( elsner et al . 1997 ) , plexas ( marshell et al . 1998 ) , polar ( produit et al . 2005 ) , xpol ( costa et al . 2006 ) , poet ( polarimeters for energetic transients , see mcconnel et al . 2007 ) , and so on . for example , the planned poet includes two instruments : grape ( gamma - ray polarimeter experiment ) and lep ( low energy polarimeter , working in soft x - ray band ) . so it may be suitable to detect the polarization signatures predicted in the early x - ray afterglow of grbs . an important issue is whether any of these detectors could perform a prompt slew to the grbs localized by the @xmath68ray monitor . an ideal instrument would be an xrt - like detector with polarization capability on board a _ swift_-like grb mission . many surprises in grb afterglows , mainly in the x - ray band , have been brought since the successful launch of _ swift _ in 2004 . though not clearly understood yet , the ( re-)activity of grb central engine is likely to play an important role on producing afterglows , as speculated by katz , piran & sari ( 1998 ) . the different temporal behaviors in the uv / optical and x - ray afterglow favor that the peculiar x - ray emission traces the prolonged activity of the central engine while the optical afterglow is dominated by the forward shock emission @xcite . if true , the polarization behaviors of the early x - ray and optical afterglow may be independent and different . at such an early time , the linear polarization of the optical forward shock emission is expected to be very small @xcite unless the interstellar medium is magnetized @xcite , because the lorentz factor of the outflow is so large that the visible emitting region is well within the cone of the ejecta and is thus symmetric . but in the x - ray band , interesting polarization signatures may be present . for example , fan et al . ( 2005 ) argued that some x - ray flares might have a high linear polarization because these new outflows are likely to be poynting - flux dominated . such an argument is also applicable to the x - ray plateau followed by a sharp drop as detected in grb 070110 . in this work , we focus on the polarization properties of the very early sharp decline of x - ray afterglows ( phase - i ) . in the high latitude emission model , the later the emission , the larger the angular @xmath47 ( see figure [ fig : cartoon ] for details ) . so at late time , the symmetry of the emitting ring is broken when part of the emitting ring is out of the cone of the ejecta . strong polarization evolution thus emerges ( see section 2.1 ) . for comparison , results from the dying central engine model are a bit more complicated . if the outflow powering the fast decaying x - ray tail emission always has a lorentz factor @xmath58 , no strong polarization evolution is expected unless the physical composition of the outflow changed significantly . however , if the lorentz factor drops rapidly to satisfy @xmath60 , then polarization evolution is evident . in this scenario , if the magnetic field involved is shock - generated and is thus random , then strong polarization evolution is expected ; while if the magnetic field involved is brought from the central engine and is thus large - scale ordered , then weak polarization evolution is expected due to the significant polarization background ( the degree is @xmath67 ) . one of our goals to calculate the polarization of phase - i is to see whether it s possible , via x - ray polarimetry , to distinguish between the high latitude emission model and the dying central engine model . this goal is not easy to fulfill in view of the above comparison . however , our calculation does support that strong polarization evolution is likely to accompany phase - i , the decline phase of x - ray flares ( phase - v ) and possibly the late part of phase - ii . fruitful novel features are expected to appear in grb x - ray afterglow polarimetry , though detection of them is beyond the capability of current monitors . we have witnessed the breakthrough made by _ swift _ xrt and we are likely to experience it once more in the coming x - ray polarimetry era . one byproduct of the future x - ray polarimetry is to probe the cosmological birefringence effect that arises in some quantum gravity models ( fan , wei & xu 2007 and the references therein ) . finally we d like to point out that the optical flares in a few bursts ( e.g. , ber et al . 2006 ) may also have a central engine origin ( wei , yan & fan 2006 ) . interesting polarization signatures are also expected . we thank the referee for her / his constructive comments . we d like to thank j. gorosabel , j. hjorth , j. fynbo and j. sollerman for valuable comments , and b. zhang and x. f. wu for communication . this work is supported by the national science foundation ( grant 10673034 , 10621303 ) of china , the national basic research program of china ( 973 program 2007cb815404 ) , and a special grant of chinese academy of sciences ( y.z.f and d.m.w ) and by a ( postdoctoral ) grant from the danish national science foundation ( y.z.f ) . dx is at the dark cosmology centre funded by the danish national research foundation . bor , m. , atteia , j. l. , damerdji , y. , gendre , b. , klotz , a. , & stratta , g. 2006 , apj , 638 , l71 butler n. r. , kocevski d. , 2007 , apj , 663 , 407 costa e. , et al . , 2006 , 39th eslab symposium , sp-588 , 141 , edited by f. favata and a. gimenez . elsner r. f. et al . , 1997 , 190th aas meeting , # 09.11 ; bulletin of the american astronomical society , vol . 29 , 790 fan y. z. , wei d. m. , 2005 , mnras , 364 , l42 fan y. z. , wei d. m. , xu d. , 2007 , mnras , 376 , 1857 fan y. z. , zhang b. , proga d. , 2005 , apj , 635 , l129 , 1996 , apj , 473 , 998 gao w. h. , fan y. z. , 2006 , chin . j. astron . astrophys , 6 , 513 ghisellini g. , ghirlanda g. , nava l. , firmani c. , 2007 , apj , 658 , l75 ghisellini g. , lazzati d. , 1999 , mnras , 309 , l7 giannios d. , 2006 , a&a , 455 , l5 granot j. , konigel a. , 2003 , 594 , l83 gruzinov a. , 1999 , apj , 525 , l29 katz j. i. , piran t. , sari r. , 1998 , phys . lett . , 80 , 1580 , 2000 , apj , 541 , l51 liang e. w. , 2006 , apj , 646 , 351 macfadyen a. i. , woosley s. e. , heger a. , 2001 , apj , 550 , 410 mcconnel m. et al . 2007 , poster at the santa fe meeting marshall , h. l. et al . 1998 , 192nd aas meeting , # 35.04 ; bulletin of the american astronomical society , vol . 30 , 860 mszros p. , 2006 phys , 69 , 2259 nakar e. , piran t. , waxman e. , 2003 , jcap , 0310 , 005 nousek j. a. , et al . , 2006 , apj , 642 , 389 panaitescu a. , 2007 , mnras , in press ( arxiv:0708.1509 ) piran t. , fan y. z. , 2007 , phil . a. , 365 , 1151 produit , n. , et al . 2005 , nucl . instrum . methods . a , 550 , 616 sakamoto t. et al . , 2007 , apj , 669 , 1115 sari r. , 1999 , apj , 524 , l43 troja e. , 2007 , apj , 665 , 599 wei d. m. , yan t. , fan y. z. , 2006 , apj , 636 , l69 xu d. , et al . , 2008 , apj , to be submitted yamazaki r. , toma k. , ioka k. , nakamura t. , 2006 , mnras , 369 , 311 zhang b. , 2007 , chjaa , 7 , 1 zhang b. , fan y. z. , dyks j. , kobayashi s. , mszros p. , burrows d. n. , nousek j. a. , gehrels n. 2006 , apj , 642 , 354 zhang b. b. , liang e. w. , zhang b. , 2007 , apj , 666 , 1002 zhang w. q. , woosley s. e. , heger a. , 2007 , apj , in press ( astro - ph/0701083 ) obviously , first we need to establish a suitable coordinate system to optimize the derivation . as stated in sari ( 1999 ) , at any point in the shock front there is a preferred direction , the radial direction , in which the fluid moves . we call this the parallel direction and choose the @xmath69-direction of the fluid local frame coordinate system to be in that direction . the two perpendicular directions @xmath70 are assumed equivalent , i.e. , the system is isotropic in the plane perpendicular to the direction of motion . we chose the @xmath71-direction to be in the plane that contains the @xmath69-direction and the direction towards the observer @xmath72 , as shown in figure [ point ] . suppose now that the magnetic field has spherical coordinates @xmath73 in that frame . a quite general description of the distribution of the magnetic field in such anisotropic system would be to allow different values of the magnetic field as function of the inclination from the preferred direction @xmath74 as well as a probability function for the magnetic field to be in each given inclination @xmath75 . the relevant component of the magnetic field is that perpendicular to the observer i.e. @xmath76 , where @xmath77 is the angle between the direction of the magnetic field and the observer . this will produce polarization @xmath78 in the direction perpendicular both to the observer and to the magnetic field i.e. in the direction @xmath79 . however , this polarization should be averaged due to contributions from magnetic fields oriented differently . on the other hand , because light is a kind of transverse wave , its polarization should be perpendicular to its propagation . therefore , we project the polarization to @xmath80 ( i.e. , the component @xmath81 ) and @xmath82 ( i.e. , the component @xmath83 ) , respectively . assuming that the emission is proportional to a certain power of the magnetic field , @xmath84 , the total polarization from a point - like region is then , @xmath82 and @xmath85 are all on the same plane which is perpendicular to @xmath86 . ] @xmath87^{\epsilon } f(\theta ) \sin \theta d\phi d\theta } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath88^{\epsilon } f(\theta ) \sin \theta d\phi d\theta},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath89^{\epsilon } f(\theta ) \sin \theta d\phi d\theta}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now substitute equation ( a5 ) into equation ( a2 ) , we get @xmath100^{\epsilon } f(\theta ) \sin \theta d\phi d\theta}\nonumber\\ & \propto & \int \sin^2 \theta \sin \phi ( \cos \alpha \sin \theta \cos\phi-\sin \alpha \cos \theta ) |\hat{\pi}|^{\epsilon-2 } f(\theta ) d\theta d\phi \nonumber\\ & \propto & \int^\pi_0 \sin^2\theta f(\theta)d\theta \int^{2\pi}_0 { \cal f}(\phi,\alpha,\theta ) d\phi.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath101^{(2-\epsilon)/2}}$ ] , and we have taken @xmath102 . in regions of @xmath105 and @xmath106 , @xmath107 changes the sign but @xmath108 does not . so in the above integral the contribution from the angle @xmath109 has been cancelled out by that from @xmath110 . similar results hold for the contribution of regions of @xmath111 and @xmath112 . it is then straightforward to get @xmath113{\cal f}(\phi,\alpha,\theta ) d\phi=0.\ ] ] _ we thus have proved that because of the isotropy of the magnetic field in the @xmath70 direction , the polarization of radiation emitted from a point - like region ( after averaging on magnetic field orientation ) must be in the direction perpendicular to the @xmath69-axis and to the observer , i.e. , in the @xmath80 direction . _ + in the case of @xmath114 , both @xmath81 and @xmath115 can be analytically integrated . with the relations @xmath116 , we have @xmath117d\phi\nonumber\\ & = & \pi \sin^2\alpha \int^\pi_0 b^2 f(\theta)\sin\theta [ 2\cos^2 \theta-\sin^2 \theta ] d\theta,\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath118 and @xmath119 , we have @xmath120 similarly , @xmath121 in the high latitude model for the x - ray sharp decline , the emission is from an angle @xmath31 ( or , equivalently @xmath65 ) . as shown in ghisellini & lazzati ( 1999 ) , it is convenient to write the polarization vector as a complex number @xmath123 and integrate it between @xmath124 and @xmath125 . here @xmath126 is the position angle of the linear polarization in the observer frame . the polarization of a generic ring is thus @xmath127 where @xmath33 .

in the synchrotron radiation model , the polarization property depends on both the configuration of the magnetic field and the geometry of the visible emitting region . some peculiar behaviors in the x - ray afterglows of _ swift _ gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) , such as energetic flares and the plateau followed by a sharp drop , might by highly linearly - polarized because the outflows powering these behaviors may be poynting - flux dominated . furthermore , the broken - down of the symmetry of the visible emitting region may be hiding in current x - ray data and will give rise to interesting polarization signatures . in this work we focus on the polarization accompanying the very early sharp decline of grb x - ray afterglows . we show that strong polarization evolution is possible in both the high latitude emission model and the dying central engine model which are used to interpret this sharp x - ray decline . it is thus not easy to efficiently probe the physical origin of the very early x - ray sharp decline with future polarimetry . strong polarization evolution is also possible in the decline phase of x - ray flares and in the shallow decline phase of x - ray light curves characterized by chromatic x - ray vs. optical breaks . an _ xrt_-like detector but with polarization capability on board a _ swift_-like satellite would be suitable to test our predictions . gamma rays : bursts @xmath0 polarization @xmath0 grbs : jets and outflows @xmath0 radiation mechanisms : nonthermal

astro-ph0105542

observations over the past decade have established that most and probably all pre - main sequence ( pms ) stars are surrounded by disks during early stages of their evolution , and that a substantial portion of their final mass is accreted from these disks . however , the prediction that this accretion will cause the stars to rotate at close to their breakup speed ( _ e.g. _ durisen et al . 1989 ) is not borne out by observations . most pms stars have rotational velocities ( @xmath1 ) of no more than a few tens of km s@xmath2 . by contrast , the typical breakup velocity at @xmath31 myr is @xmath3300 km s@xmath2 . explanations of the observed slow rotation have invoked a magnetic field that is rooted in the central star and intercepts the disk ( knigl 1991 ) . the net consequence of this interaction is a braking torque transmitted to the star by field lines penetrating the disk beyond the co - rotation radius ( where the angular velocity @xmath4 of the disk matches that of the star ) . this braking torque exactly balances the spin - up torque exerted by the material inside the co - rotation radius . this model predicts that stars will be locked to their disks and will rotate slowly until the time that the disk is dissipated . other models ( _ e.g. _ shu et al . 2000 ) make use of a wind , launched from the stellar magnetosphere - disk boundary to carry away stellar angular momentum ( @xmath5 ) , thus reducing rotation rates to well below breakup . by contrast , stars without disks should conserve @xmath5 and spin up as they contract and evolve down their hayashi tracks . considerable observational effort has been devoted to finding empirical correlations between rotation rates and the presence or absence of observable disks ; although such correlations appeared in early studies ( _ e.g. _ edwards et al . 1993 , choi & herbst 1996 ) , recent results are ambiguous at best ( _ e.g. _ rebull 2001 ; stassun et al . 1999 ) . over the past few years , rotation periods @xmath6 or projected rotational velocities @xmath7 have been measured for large samples of pms stars @xmath30.1 - 2.5 m@xmath8and of age @xmath93 myr . these data sets are now large enough to provide direct evidence of how @xmath5 changes as stars of different masses evolve down their convective tracks . in this paper , we examine the early @xmath5 history of stars surrounded by disks and those that lack disks . we show that pms stars , _ even those without observable disks _ , do not conserve angular momentum as they evolve toward the zams but instead evolve at nearly constant angular velocity . this result is inconsistent with expectations that convective stars lacking disks should spin up as they contract , but paradoxically consistent with disk - locking models . the data sets that we draw on for this paper are 256 measurements of @xmath10 in the orion nebula cluster ( onc ) by rhode et al . ( 2001 ; rhm ) ; 197 photometric periods ( @xmath6 ) for the flanking fields ( ff ) that surround the onc ( rebull 2001 , rebull et al . 2000 ) ; and 83 stars with @xmath6 in ngc 2264 ( makidon et al . 2001 , rebull et al . 2001 ) . the age distribution for orion peaks near @xmath31 myr , while ngc 2264 peaks near @xmath31 myr but contains significant numbers of stars out to @xmath33 - 4 myr . together , these clusters allow us to examine changes in stellar angular momenta over a total range in stellar radius of @xmath30.4 dex . in order to estimate accurate stellar radii and to determine the presence or absence of a disk , we required that spectral types along with @xmath11 and @xmath12 photometry be available for all the stars included in the present study . while other disk indicators ( _ e.g. _ uv excess , h@xmath13 emission ) are available for subsets of the orion and ngc 2264 databases , only @xmath11 is widely available . all stars with an @xmath11 color redder by 0.3 mag than expected based on spectral type were considered to be surrounded by disks ( cf.rebull 2001 and references therein ) . we note that 26/197 ( 13% ) stars in the orion ff sample and 20/83 ( 24% ) in the ngc 2264 sample have @xmath11 excesses , whereas 60% of the stars in the onc sample have such an excess . stellar temperatures ( @xmath14 ) were assigned according to spectral types and luminosities ( @xmath15 ) were derived from @xmath16 magnitudes with reddening estimated from colors and spectral types following hillenbrand ( 1997 ) . we adopted distance moduli of 8.36 for orion ( genzel et al . 1981 ) and 9.40 for ngc 2264 ( sung et al . 1997 ) . radii ( @xmath17 ) were calculated using the assigned values of @xmath15 and @xmath14 . photometric uncertainty , the amplitude of the periodic modulation , uncertainties in the reddening correction , and errors in classification all contribute to errors in @xmath15 and @xmath14 and hence to uncertainty in @xmath17 . the distribution of empirically - determined errors in @xmath18 is strongly peaked near @xmath190.1 . the errors in @xmath6 are less than 1% . the @xmath0 data for the onc have sufficient resolution to measure only velocities greater than @xmath311 km s@xmath2 , corresponding to @xmath20d for a typical pms star in our sample . the @xmath6 measurements are sensitive to a much broader range of periods , viz @xmath21d ( @xmath22 km s@xmath2 ) , encompassing much slower rotation velocities than do the published @xmath0 measurements . approximately half of the stars with @xmath0 measurements by rhm were chosen because they had known @xmath6 . the other half were selected as a control sample of objects without known @xmath6 from the same portion of the hr diagram . rhm show there is no statistically significant difference between the @xmath0 distributions of the periodic and control samples , leading to the important conclusion that samples of stars found to show photometric periods can be taken as a fair representation of the range of rotational characteristics of pms stars . if stars conserve angular momentum ( @xmath5 ) as they evolve down their convective tracks , then we would expect that @xmath23 would remain constant , but only if @xmath5 is conserved in the outermost observable layer of the star . we expect fully convective stars to rotate as solid bodies . examination of theoretical models of pms stars ( _ e.g. _ swenson et al . 1994 ) indicates that the predicted changes in surface rotation rate as the star evolves down the convective track are indistinguishable for the two extreme cases of solid body rotation and local conservation of @xmath5 ( _ i.e._@xmath5 conservation in spherical shells ) . along the convective track contraction is nearly homologous , and changes in @xmath24 directly track changes in @xmath25 . if @xmath5 is conserved , then @xmath26 is constant and @xmath27 should be @xmath28 . on the other hand , if angular velocity @xmath29 is constant , as predicted for disk - locking , then @xmath6 is constant . in figure 1 , we plot @xmath6 and @xmath30 vs. @xmath17 , where @xmath31 is computed as in rebull ( 2001 ) , where @xmath24=moment of inertia , and all other terms have been defined . ] . it is immediately apparent that there is no variation of @xmath6 with @xmath17 , but that @xmath31 changes with @xmath17 , consistent with conservation of @xmath4 . the errors in log @xmath17 would have to be about 0.5 dex ( 5 times larger than we estimate them to be ) in order to mask the decline in @xmath6 expected for the case of conservation of @xmath5 . we see no substantial difference between these two clusters , except for the fact that the stars in ngc 2264 include older objects with smaller radii . we find no significant difference in the period - radius relationship of stars with and without @xmath11 excesses , though there may be some marginal tendency for diskless stars to have the shortest periods . we have divided our sample into two bins : @xmath323 d and @xmath333 d. the disk fractions are for orion [email protected] and [email protected] respectively , and for ngc 2264 , both fractions are [email protected] . to enable more direct comparison with the rhm results for the inner onc , we have converted the orion ff and ngc 2264 periods to @xmath1 . the @xmath6 data provide an estimate of @xmath1 rather than @xmath0 and are systematically higher for this reason . for our purposes , it only matters that the data within each group are internally consistent . we have subdivided the @xmath10 and @xmath1 measurements following rhm according to @xmath14 and @xmath15 , corresponding to a subdivsion by mass ( @xmath34 ) for stars on convective tracks , and with age for stars of a given @xmath34 . for each bin we show in table 1 the average @xmath1 or @xmath0 . to first order , each column of the table can be viewed as following the evolution of stars of a given mass down a convective track . as can be seen from table 1 , the average value of @xmath1 or @xmath0 _ decreases _ with @xmath15 at fixed @xmath34 , rather than increasing as one would expect for conservation of stellar @xmath5 . in constructing these averages for the onc sample , we have assigned 11 km s@xmath2 as the @xmath10 for all of those stars for which only upper limits are available . a detailed examination of the data in rhm shows that the percentage of stars rotating at or below this upper limit increases with decreasing @xmath15 , and so the decline in @xmath0 with decreasing @xmath15 is probably even stronger . table 2 tabulates the quantities @xmath35 , which is proportional to @xmath4 , and @xmath26 , which is proportional to @xmath5 . @xmath35 is constant within each mass group , within about a factor of @xmath32 , regardless of how far the stars have evolved down their convective tracks . in other words , it appears as if some agent is keeping stars close to constant @xmath4 over nominal ages from 0.1 - 3 myr . we note that this result stands whether stars appear to have @xmath11 excesses or not . prior to this survey , we expected that pms stars lacking observable disks should spin up as they contract along convective tracks . the observations show that they do not , despite the fact that these stars span a range of 0.4 dex in log @xmath17 , which should correspond to a decrease in log @xmath6 of 0.8 dex . we briefly explore several possible explanations . the absence of evolution in the distribution of periods among pms stars as they contract is consistent with what would be expected for disk - locking . absent observable evidence of disks from infrared excess emission arising from micron - size dust grains , we would need to posit linkage between stellar magnetospheres and disks in which small solid particles have been agglomerated into larger bodies , leaving behind only gas . detection of such disks via h@xmath36 or co emission awaits more sensitive measurements than possible at present . a search for dust - free gaseous disks with sirtf appears to be the most promising near - term approach . suppose that ( 1 ) stars in orion and ngc 2264 were born in a single burst of star formation @xmath31 myr ago ; ( 2 ) the range in @xmath15 ( equivalently @xmath17 ) for the pms stars in these clusters does not reflect evolution down convective tracks , but rather differences in mass accretion rate ( @xmath37 ) that force stars to evolve along different ` birthlines ' and therefore to arrive at different initial luminosities along the convective tracks ( palla & stahler 1992 ) ; and ( 3 ) pms stars are locked to a particular @xmath6 so long as they are surrounded by accretion disks . in this picture , the observed distribution of stars along a convective track for a given mass then reflects a range of @xmath37 : protostars with higher @xmath37 have larger initial radii and lie higher in the color - magnitude diagram following the end of the accretion phase ( see also hartmann et al . 1997 ) . the similarity of @xmath6 at different @xmath17 then follows from the assumption that stars are locked to their disks for much ( nearly all ) of their @xmath31 myr accretion phase . the difficulty with this picture lies with the additional requirement that stellar @xmath15 can not have decreased much since the stars were deposited on their convective tracks . if stars that formed through high @xmath37 and were initially deposited high on their convective tracks had subsequently evolved downwards , we would expect to see a ` tail ' of stars that have spun up to shorter @xmath6 mixed in with the ensemble of objects that started their evolution at smaller @xmath17 . we do not . the only way to resolve this contradiction and still maintain conservation of stellar @xmath5 would be to identify a mechanism for halting or slowing evolution toward smaller radii for a time comparable to @xmath31 myr . the problem is even more severe when considering those stars in ngc 2264 with apparent ages @xmath33 myr , thus requiring @xmath15 evolution for stars with high @xmath37 to be delayed for an even longer time . stellar winds loaded onto open magnetic field lines can exert a spindown torque on stars . however , this mechanism has been shown to be ineffective for pms stars because , during this phase of evolution , the timescale for spindown exceeds the evolutionary timescale by a few orders of magnitude ( _ e.g. _ macgregor and charbonneau 1994 ) fully convective stars are assumed to rotate as solid bodies , and the wind must slow down the entire star . furthermore , this conclusion is nearly independent of the rate of mass loss . calculations ( _ e.g. _ kawaler 1988 ) show that the rate of change of @xmath5 depends on the product of the mass loss rate and the square of the alfven radius , but the alfven radius varies inversely as some power of the mass loss rate , with the specific power depending on the configuration of the magnetic field . for a field geometry intermediate " between a dipolar and a radial field , @xmath38 does not depend on mass loss rate at all ( bouvier et al . the only circumstance under which magnetic winds could play an important role in slowing the rotation of pms stars would be if there were some way in which to decouple the outer layers of the star from the interior , _ i.e. _ if @xmath5 were conserved locally , and the wind had to slow down only a thin outer layer of the star . such decoupling is not expected for fully convective stars . moreover , any putative wind - driven @xmath5 loss mechanism would have to cease on timescales of no more than a few myr in order to account for the significant population of rapidly rotating main sequence stars in young clusters such as alpha persei ( _ e.g. _ stauffer et al . 1989 ) ; such stars require spinup from the pms to the zams . recent theoretical models indicate that tidal locking between a close - in jupiter - mass planet and the parent star can transfer spin @xmath5 from the star to the orbital @xmath5 of the planet , thus slowing the rotation of the star while driving the planet into a larger orbit . unfortunately , this effect is not large enough to account for the observations reported here . the difficulty lies in the apparent incompatibility of two requirements : ( 1 ) the putative planet must be located close enough to the star to produce significant tidal distortion ; and ( 2 ) the planet must be located far enough from the star to dominate the @xmath5 of the system ( and thus be able to create significant changes in stellar @xmath5 with only modest orbital evolution ) . a simple calculation ( cf . trilling et al . 1998 ) in which we assume a jupiter - mass planet orbiting a pms star at a distance of 0.1 au suggests that @xmath5 regulation by tidal locking to such a planet fails by 2 orders of magnitude . previous attempts to test the disk - locking hypothesis have attempted to establish a correlation between rotation rates and the presence or absence of a disk . we see only weak evidence for this correlation , which has also been questioned by many previous authors ( _ e.g. _ rebull 2001 , stassun et al.1999 ) . it is possible that intrinsic variations in rotation rates at the time that stars are deposited on their birthlines is sufficient to mask such a simple correlation . what we do see is that the trends in @xmath39 and in the @xmath6 of pms stars in orion and in ngc 2264 are consistent with evolution down convective tracks at constant angular velocity ( @xmath4 ) , within a factor of @xmath32 . the data are not at all consistent with conservation of stellar angular momentum ( @xmath5 ) . it appears highly unlikely that the errors in the observations could be large enough to mask conservation of stellar @xmath5 . the errors in @xmath0 and @xmath6 are small , and the conclusion that stars do not spin up as they age depends only on the assumption that the stars are properly ordered according to @xmath14 and @xmath15 ; highly accurate calibrations of @xmath14 and @xmath15 are not required . conservation of @xmath4 is consistent with the hypothesis that @xmath5 is controlled by disk - locking . however , @xmath4 appears to be conserved , or nearly so , for both those stars with disks and those for which disks are , at least so far , undetectable by observation . we have found no plausible explanation for this paradox . we find no evidence for spin - up of stars over the age range spanned by the current observations , which is @xmath33 myr . such spin - up must ultimately occur in order to account for the rapid rotators seen on the main sequence in young clusters such as alpha persei ( stauffer et al . however , recent observations of @xmath0 for a small sample of stars in the 10 myr old tw hya association ( torres et al . 2000 ; sterzik et al . 1999 ) suggest mean @xmath0 values similar to those found among the oldest stars in our ngc 2264 sample , despite the fact that the nominal radii among the tw hya stars are smaller by 50% . these observations suggest the urgent need for a campaign focused on mapping the angular momentum evolution of low mass stars in the age range 3@xmath4030 myr so as to understand when rotational spinup in response to contraction takes place . we wish to thank jonathan lunine and lee hartmann for several helpful discussions regarding possible explanations for the apparent paradox explored here . ses acknowledges support from the nasa origins of solar systems program which enabled analysis of the ngc 2264 data . we thank mark adams for multiple comments and support during the early phases of the investigation of periodic stars and the mcdonald observatory for the award of guest investigator time on the 0.9 m telescope . dummy bouvier , j. , forestini , m. , & allain , s. 1997 , , 326 , 1023 choi , p. , & herbst , w. 1996 , aj , 111 , 283 durisen , r. h. , yang , s. , cassen , p. , & stahler , s. 1989 , , 345 , 959 edwards , s. , strom , s. e. , hartigan , p. , strom , k. m. , hillenbrand , l. a. , herbst , w. , attridge , j. , meriill , k.m . , probst , r. , & gatley , i. , 1993 , , 106 , 372 genzel , r. , reid , j. j. , moran , j. m. , & downes , d. 1981 , , 244 , 884 hartmann , l. , cassen , p. , & kenyon , s. j. 1997 , , 475 , 770 hillenbrand , l. a. 1997 , , 113 , 1733 knigl , a. 1991 , , 370 , 39 kawaler , s. d. 1988 , , 333 , 236 macgregor , k. b. , & charbonneau , p. 1994 , in asp conf.ser . 64 , cool stars , stellar systems , and the sun , eighth cambridge workshop , ed . caillaut ( san francisco : asp ) , 174 makidon , r. , rebull , l. , strom , s. , adams , m. , & patten , b. 2001 , in preparation palla , f. , & stahler , s. w. 1992 , , 392 , 667 rebull , l. m. 2001 , , 121 , 1676 rebull , l. m. , hillenbrand , l. , strom s. e. , duncan , d. k. , patten , b. m. , pavlovsky , c. m. , makidon , r. , & adams , m. t. 2000 , , 119 , 3026 rebull , l. m. , makidon , r. b. , strom , s. e. , hillenbrand , l. a. , birmingham , a. , yagi , h. , jones , b. f. , adams , m. t. , & patten , b. m. 2001 , in preparation rhode , k. l. , herbst , w. , & mathieu , r. d. 2001 , , in press ( rhm ) shu , f. , najita , j. , shang , h. , & li , z .- y . 2000 , in protostars and planets iv , ed . v. mannings , a. p. boss & s. s.russell ( tucson : university of arizona press ) , 789 stassun , k. g. , mathieu , r. d. , mazeh , t. , & vrba , f. j. 1999 , aj , 117 , 2941 stauffer , j. r. , hartmann , l. w. , & jones , b. f. 1989 , , 346 , 160 sterzik , m. , alcal , j. , covino , e. , petr , m. 1999 , a&a , 346 , l41 sung , h. , bessell , m. s. , & lee , s - w . 1997 , , 114 , 2644 swenson , f. j. , faulkner , j. , rogers , f. j. , & iglesias , c. a. 1994 , , 425 , 286 torres , c. , da silva , l. , quast , g. , de la reza , r. , jilinski , e. 2000 , aj , 120 , 1410 trilling , d. e. , benz , w. , guillot , t. , lunine , j. i. , hubbard , w. b. , & burrows , a. 1998 , , 500 , 428 cccccccccccc onc & 1 ( 1.48 - 1.11 ) & 33@xmath1913 & 3 & 41@xmath1910 & 5 + & 2 ( 1.11 - 0.74 ) & 30@xmath194 & 6 & 26@xmath196 & 4 & 14 & 1 + & 3 ( 0.74 - 0.37 ) & 26@xmath195 & 7 & 15@xmath194 & 4 & 34@xmath1912 & 7 & 35@xmath199 & 5 + & 4 ( 0.37 - 0.00 ) & 19@xmath197 & 2 & 17@xmath193 & 13 & 17@xmath193 & 18 & 23@xmath194 & 17 & 34@xmath1915 & 3 + & 5 ( 0.00 - @xmath400.37 ) & 12 & 1 & & & 20@xmath198 & 6 & 19@xmath193 & 41 & 19@xmath192 & 22 + & 6 ( @xmath400.37 - @xmath400.74 ) & & & & & 18@xmath197 & 3 & 16@xmath194 & 18 & 2-@xmath193 & 44 + orion ff & 1 & + & 2 & 380 & 1 & & & 266 & 1 + & 3 & 34@xmath197 & 3 & 65@xmath1922 & 3 & 52@xmath1917 & 7 & 20@xmath1912 & 2 & 67 & 1 + & 4 & 62@xmath1942 & 4 & 41@xmath1910 & 12 & 24@xmath194 & 17 & 58@xmath1913 & 7 & + & 5 & & & 12 & 1 & 24@xmath196 & 18 & 37@xmath198 & 20 & 48@xmath1914 & 17 + & 6 & & & & & 13@xmath197 & 2 & 32@xmath197 & 22 & 34@xmath196 & 35 + ngc 2264 & 1 & + & 2 & & & & & 85 & 1 + & 3 & 35 & 1 & 59@xmath1933 & 2 & 55 & 1 + & 4 & 21@xmath198 & 6 & 28@xmath1912 & 5&36@xmath1920 & 3&30@xmath197 & 2 & + & 5 & 28 & 1 & 23@xmath1911 & 5&23@xmath198 & 11&40@xmath1913 & 11 & 36 & 1 + & 6 & 4 & 1 & 15 & 1&48 & 1&23@xmath196 & 18 & 101@xmath1939 & 4 + cccccccccccc onc & 1 ( 1.48 - 1.11 ) & 6 & 191 & 6 & 296 & + & 2 ( 1.11 - 0.74 ) & 8 & 112 & 6 & 123 & 2 & 82 + & 3 ( 0.74 - 0.37 ) & 11 & 64 & 5 & 46 & 9 & 131 & 7 & 168 + & 4 ( 0.37 - 0.00 ) & 12 & 31 & 8 & 34 & 7 & 43 & 7 & 72 & 9 & 133 + & 5 ( 0.00 - @xmath400.37 ) & 11 & 13 & & & 12 & 33 & 9 & 39 & 7 & 48 + & 6 ( @xmath400.37 - @xmath400.74 ) & & & & & 17 & 19 & 12 & 21 & 12 & 33 + onc ff & 1 & + & 2 & 116 & 1246 & & & 50 & 1428 + & 3 & 16 & 75 & 22 & 197 & 16 & 177 & 5 & 81 & 12 & 375 + & 4 & 32 & 120 & 19 & 90 & 10 & 63 & 21 & 165 + & 5 & & & 12 & 14 & 14 & 44 & 19 & 77 & 21 & 116 + & 6 & & & & & 11 & 16 & 21 & 49 & 21 & 57 + ngc 2264 & 1 & + & 2 & & & & & 17 & 428 + & 3 & 13 & 95 & 19 & 191 & 15 & 199 + & 4 & 13 & 38 & 12 & 65 & 15 & 90 & 11 & 87 & + & 5 & 23 & 35 & 16 & 35 & 15 & 38 & 20 & 83 & 17 & 78 + & 6 & 5 & 4 & 22 & 12 & 35 & 69 & 15 & 38 & 60 & 173 +

we examine the early angular momentum history of stars in young clusters via 197 photometric periods in the orion flanking fields , 83 photometric periods in ngc 2264 , and 256 measurements of @xmath0 in the onc . we show that pms stars , even those without observable disks , apparently do not conserve stellar angular momentum as they evolve down their convective tracks , but instead evolve at nearly constant angular velocity . this result is inconsistent with expectations that convective stars lacking disks should spin up as they contract , but paradoxically consistent with disk - locking models . we briefly explore possible resolutions , including disk locking , birthline effects , stellar winds , and planetary companions . we have found no plausible explanations for this paradox .

physics0603043

unstable particles are a perfect testing ground for theories that try to unify the principle of relativity with quantum mechanics for ( at least ) two reasons . first , an unstable particle provides a very simple example of a non - trivial interacting quantum system . due to the specific initial condition characteristic to this problem ( there is just one particle in the initial state ) , a rigorous description of the decay is possible in a small hilbert space that contains only states of the particle and its decay products , so the solution can be obtained in a closed form . second , unstable particles played an important role in confirming predictions of einstein s special relativity . it was demonstrated experimentally that the decay of moving particles slows down in a good agreement with einstein s time dilation formula @xcite . for a long time it was believed that relativistic quantum mechanics and quantum field theory must reproduce exactly the einstein s time dilation formula for unstable particles @xcite . however , a detailed quantum relativistic calculation in @xcite has shown that there are small corrections to this formula in the case of particles with definite momentum . this result was later confirmed in other studies @xcite . although surprising , these findings did not challenge directly the applicability of special relativity to unstable systems . this is because relativistic transformations connect results of measurements of two inertial observers moving with constant velocities with respect to each other . then a fair comparison with the time dilation formula requires consideration of unstable states having definite values of velocity for both observers . such states do not have a definite momentum for , at least , one observer . their decay laws were considered in recent article @xcite which alleges that the decay accelerates when particle s velocity increases , instead of being slowed down as experiment shows . in the present article we resolve this controversy by performing a detailed calculation of the decay laws of particles with narrow distributions of velocities observed from moving reference frames . we found that the result of @xcite is based on an incorrect identification of the subspace of states of the unstable particle in the full hilbert space of the system . in sections [ ss : general ] - [ ss : instant ] we present a rigorous quantum relativistic framework required for the description of decays . the exact formula for the time dependence of the non - decay probability in a moving inertial frame of reference is derived in section [ sc : moving - frame ] . particular cases of this formula relevant to unstable particles with sharply defined momenta or velocities are considered in sections [ sc : mov ] and [ sc : general ] , respectively . section [ sc : numerical ] is devoted to numerical calculations of the differences between the accurate quantum mechanical result and the standard time dilation formula ( [ eq:1b ] ) . although these differences are much smaller than the resolution of modern experiments , their presence is in sharp contradiction with special relativity which does not tolerate even small deviations from the einstein s time dilation . the decay of unstable particles is described mathematically by the _ non - decay probability _ which has the following definition . suppose that we have a piece of radioactive material with n unstable nuclei prepared simultaneously at time @xmath0 and denote @xmath1 the number of nuclei that remain undecayed at time @xmath2 . then the non - decay probability indicates the rapidity of the observer that measures the non - decay probability , as described below . ] @xmath3 ( also called the _ non - decay law _ in this paper ) is defined as the fraction of nuclei that survived the decay in the limit of large @xmath4 @xmath5 so , at each time point the piece of radioactive material can be characterized by its _ composition _ @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the share of undecayed nuclei in the sample and @xmath8 is the share of nuclei that were transformed to the _ decay products_. in this paper , in the spirit of quantum mechanics , we will treat @xmath4 unstable particles as an ensemble of identically prepared systems and consider @xmath3 as a property of a single particle ( nucleus ) , i.e. , the probability of finding this particle in the undecayed state . in this paper we are concerned with comparison of decay observations made by two observers @xmath9 and @xmath10 that move with respect to each other . without loss of generality we will assume that observer @xmath10 moves with respect to @xmath9 with velocity @xmath11 along the @xmath12-axis and that at time @xmath0 measured by both observer s clocks the origins of their coordinate systems coincide and all three pairs of coordinate axes are parallel ( @xmath13 , etc . ) . for discussion purposes we will say that @xmath9 is at rest while @xmath10 is moving . to simplify formulas we will use the _ rapidity _ parameter @xmath14 instead of velocity @xmath15 . for example , in this notation the famous relativistic factor takes the form @xmath16 . if from the point of view of @xmath9 the decay is described by the function @xmath3 , then the non - decay law of the same particle seen by the moving observer @xmath10 will be denoted by @xmath17 . denotes time measured by the clock belonging to the observer @xmath10 . ] calculation of this function and , in particular , the relationship between @xmath17 and @xmath3 is the major goal of this work . the purpose of any relativistic theory is to describe the relationships between measurements made by different _ inertial observers _ or from different _ inertial reference frames _ , i.e. , reference frames moving in space with constant velocities along straight lines and without rotation . the special _ principle of relativity _ tells us that these reference frames are exactly equivalent * * postulate i. * experiments identically arranged and performed in two different inertial reference frames @xmath9 and @xmath18 always yield the same results . for any two observers @xmath9 and @xmath18 there is an _ inertial transformation _ that connects @xmath18 to @xmath9 , i.e. , the set of rules that allows one to change from the reference frame @xmath9 to the reference frame @xmath18 . each inertial transformation is a combination of space and time translations , rotations and boosts . a composition of two inertial transformations is again a valid inertial transformation . this composition obeys the associativity law . the inverse of an inertial transformation is also an inertial transformation . therefore , they form a 10-parameter lie group . the structure of this group is specified in the second postulate * * postulate ii . * inertial transformations ( space and time translations , rotations , and boosts ) form the _ poincar group_. obviously , two different observers obtain different results by measuring observables of the same physical system . most problems in physics can be understood as translations of descriptions of the physical system between different reference frames . for example , if we have a full description of the system from the point of view of observer @xmath9 , then the time evolution is obtained by answering the question `` what is the description of the same system from the point of view of observer @xmath19 that is shifted in time with respect to @xmath9 ? '' it is important to realize that inertial transformations between observers can be divided into two groups : _ kinematical _ and _ dynamical_. kinematical transformations are those whose action on observables does not depend on the interaction . for example , if two stationary observers look at the unstable particle from different points in space , they would assign the same non - decay probability to the particle . the same is true for stationary observers having different orientations in space . from this follows , these forms are not appropriate for the description of non - decay laws of unstable particles . ] * * postulate iii . * space translations and rotations are kinematical . on the other hand , time translations produce non - trivial changes in the system . the composition of the unstable system looks different for observers @xmath9 and @xmath19 shifted in time with respect to each other . the exact action of time translations on observables of the physical system should be obtained as a result of solution of dynamical equations which depend on the interaction acting in the system . hence the following postulate is true for all types of isolated interacting systems . * * postulate iv . * time translations are dynamical , i.e. , interaction - dependent . the above postulates i - iv have overwhelming experimental support . they are assumed to be valid throughout this paper . however they are not sufficient for a full description of the unstable particle in a moving reference frame . such a description requires also knowledge of the nature of boosts . here we have a choice between two paths forward . one path is to postulate certain properties of boosts . this path was taken by einstein . it leads to special relativity and to the time dilation formula ( [ eq:1b ] ) as explained in the next section . in this paper we will argue in favor of choosing another path : keep postulates i - iv , add to them well - established postulates of quantum mechanics , and see what are the implications for the transformations of observables ( in particular , the non - decay probability ) with respect to boosts . this approach is employed starting from section [ ss : general ] throughout the paper . in addition to postulates i - iv , einstein s special relativity makes two more assumptions regarding the nature of boosts * * assumption v. * boosts are kinematical . by postulating the kinematical character of boosts , special relativity insists that the internal composition of a compound system does not depend on the velocity of the observer . for example , if @xmath9 and @xmath10 are two observers moving with respect to each other , then , according to special relativity , both observer will measure the same composition of the unstable system at time @xmath0 . these statements are often considered as self - evident in discussions of special relativity . for example , r. polishchuk writes in @xcite _ `` any event that is `` seen '' in one inertial system is `` seen '' in all others . for example if observer in one system `` sees '' an explosion on a rocket then so do all other observers . '' _ in addition to the universality and interaction - independence of boost transformations , special relativity also postulates the exact transformation laws of physical observables with respect to boosts . they are referred to as _ lorentz transformations_. the most fundamental are lorentz transformations for space - time coordinates of events . loses its localization from the point of view of the moving observer @xmath10 @xcite . so , assumption vi can be applied only in the classical limit . ] * * assumption vi . * if from the point of view of observer @xmath9 an event is localized in a space point @xmath20 at time @xmath21 , then from the point of view of observer @xmath10 the same event has space - time coordinates @xmath22 given by lorentz formulas + @xmath23 let us now demonstrate that in special relativity the postulates i - iv and assumptions v - vi are sufficient to unambiguously describe particle decay in different reference frames without invoking any information about the interaction governing the decay . suppose that from the point of observer @xmath9 the unstable system is prepared in the state with composition @xmath24 at rest in the origin @xmath25 at time @xmath0 . then observer @xmath9 may associate the space - time point @xmath26 with the event of preparation . in accordance with the dynamical character of time translations , the non - decay probability @xmath3 decreases with time . from experiment and quantum mechanical calculations ( see , e.g. , section [ sc : numerical ] ) it is known that the non - decay law has an ( almost ) exponential shape ) here . ] @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the _ lifetime _ of the unstable particle . at time @xmath29 the non - decay probability is exactly @xmath30 , so that the composition is @xmath31 . this `` one lifetime '' event has coordinates @xmath32 according to the observer @xmath9 . let us now take the point of view of the moving observer @xmath10 . due to the assumption v , both @xmath9 and @xmath10 agree that at the `` preparation '' and `` lifetime '' events the non - decay probabilities are 1 and @xmath30 , respectively . however , observer @xmath10 may not agree with @xmath9 about the space - time coordinates of these events . substituting ( [ eq : event1 ] ) and ( [ eq : event2 ] ) in ( [ eq : lorentz - time ] ) - ( [ eq : lorentz - x ] ) we see that from the point of view of @xmath10 , the `` preparation '' event has coordinates @xmath33 , and the `` lifetime '' event has coordinates @xmath34 . therefore , the time elapsed between these two events is @xmath35 times longer than in the reference frame @xmath9 . this also means that the decay law of the particle is exactly @xmath35 slower from the point of view of the moving observer @xmath10 . this is reflected in the famous `` time dilation '' formula @xmath36 this formula was confirmed in numerous experiments @xcite , most accurately for muons accelerated to relativistic speeds in a cyclotron @xcite . these experimental findings were certainly a triumph of einstein s theory . however , as we see from the above discussion , in special relativity eq . ( [ eq:1b ] ) can be derived only under two assumptions v and vi , which lack proper justification . therefore , a question remains whether eq . ( [ eq:1b ] ) is a fundamental exact result or simply an approximation that can be disproved by more accurate measurements ? our goal in the rest of this paper is to demonstrate that this classical result of special relativity is not exact . in section [ sc : numerical ] we will calculate corrections to the formula ( [ eq:1b ] ) . let us now turn to the description of an isolated unstable system from the point of view of relativistic quantum theory . in our approach we will keep postulates i - iv . however , we are not going to use assumptions v and vi . we will consider a model theory with particles @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 , so that particle @xmath37 is massive spinless and unstable , while its decay products @xmath38 and @xmath39 are stable and their masses satisfy the inequality @xmath40 which makes the decay @xmath41 energetically possible . in order to simplify calculations and avoid being distracted by issues that are not relevant to the problem at hand we neglect the spin of the particle @xmath37 and assume that there is only one decay mode of this particle , i.e. , into two decay products @xmath38 and @xmath39 . for our discussion , the nature of the particle @xmath37 is not that important . for example , this could be a muon or a radioactive nucleus or an atom in an excited state . when measuring the non - decay law , experimentalists simply count the number of particles and determine their types . for example , observations of a muon may result in only two outcomes . one can find either a non - decayed muon or its decay products ( an electron , a neutrino , and an antineutrino ) . thus the number of particles is a legitimate observable , and for our model system @xmath42 we can introduce hermitian operators for the number of particles @xmath43 , @xmath44 , and @xmath45 . since these observables can be measured simultaneously , we can assume that these three operators commute with each other . two combinations of their common eigenvalues are allowed in our system : @xmath46 hence the hilbert space of the unstable system should be represented as a direct sum of two orthogonal subspaces , and @xmath47 are allowed to take any values from zero to infinity . however , for most unstable particles the interaction between the decay products in the final state can be ignored , and considering the subspace ( [ eq : tensor - product ] ) of the full fock space is a reasonable approximation . ] @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the subspace of states of the unstable particle @xmath37 which corresponds to the set of eigenvalues ( [ eq : eigenval1 ] ) , and @xmath50 is the orthogonal subspace of the decay products which corresponds to the set of eigenvalues ( [ eq : eigenval2 ] ) . we can now introduce a hermitian operator @xmath51 ( also known as `` yes - no experiment '' ) that corresponds to the observable `` particle @xmath37 exists '' . the operator @xmath51 can be fully defined by its eigensubspaces and eigenvalues . when a measurement performed on the unstable system finds it in a state corresponding to the particle @xmath37 ( i.e. , the state vector is within @xmath52 ) , the value of @xmath51 is 1 . when the decay products @xmath53 are observed ( the state vector lies in @xmath54 ) , the value of @xmath51 is 0 . apparently , @xmath51 is a projection operator on the subspace @xmath52 . for each normalized state vector @xmath55 the probability of finding the unstable particle @xmath37 is given by the expectation value of the observable @xmath51 @xcite @xmath56 in relativistic quantum mechanics , the dynamics of the system is described by a unitary representation @xmath57 of the poincar group in the hilbert space @xmath58 @xcite . it is convenient to express representatives @xmath57 as exponential functions of _ generators _ @xmath59 , and @xmath60 . then a general unitary operator from the set @xmath61 can be always written as a product @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the rotation vector , @xmath64 is the velocity of the boost , @xmath65 is the vector of space translation , and @xmath21 is the amount of time translation . generators are hermitian operators and correspond to certain _ total _ observables of the system . space translations are generated by the vector of the total linear momentum @xmath66 . the generator of rotations @xmath67 is the operator of the total angular momentum . the generator of time translations @xmath68 is the hamiltonian ( total energy ) . the generator of boosts @xmath69 is called the _ boost operator_. these generators must satisfy the commutation relations of the poincar group lie algebra . in this paper we will need , in particular , the following commutators @xmath70 = -i\frac{\hbar}{c^2 } h \delta_{ij } \label{eq:5.55}\ ] ] @xmath71 = -i\hbar p_i \nonumber\ ] ] where @xmath72 . they imply the following useful relationships @xmath73 \label{eq:6.2 } \\ e^ { \frac{i}{\hbar } \mathbf{k } c \vec{\theta } } h e^ { -\frac{i}{\hbar } \mathbf{k } c \vec{\theta } } & = & h \cosh \theta + c ( \mathbf{p } \cdot \frac{\vec{\theta}}{\theta } ) \sinh \theta \label{eq:6.3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the representation ( [ gen - elem ] ) allows us to relate results of measurements in different reference frames . let us first take the point of view of the observer @xmath9 and consider a vector @xmath74 the first argument is the rapidity parameter of the reference frame from which the state @xmath75 is observed and the second argument is the time of observation . this is consistent with the convention adopted for @xmath17 in section [ intro ] . ] that describes a state in which the unstable particle @xmath37 is found with 100% certainty . @xmath76 then the time evolution of the state vector @xmath77 in the reference frame @xmath9 is given by @xmath78 and the non - decay law is given by @xmath79 from this equation it is clear that the hamiltonian @xmath68 describing the unstable system should not commute with the projection @xmath51 @xmath80 \neq 0 \label{eq:44b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] otherwise , the subspace @xmath52 of states of the particle @xmath37 would be invariant with respect to time translations and the particle @xmath37 would be stable ( @xmath81 for all @xmath21 ) . the moving observer @xmath10 describes the initial state ( at @xmath0 ) by the vector @xmath82 the time dependence of this state is @xmath83 then the non - decay law from the point of view of @xmath10 is @xmath84 where the last equation follows from the property @xmath85 of the operator @xmath51 . before calculating the non - decay law in the moving reference frame ( [ eq:3b ] ) , let us first consider a simpler case when the interaction responsible for the decay is `` turned off '' . then the representation of the poincar group @xmath86 acting in @xmath58 is _ non - interacting_. this representation is constructed in accordance with the structure of the hilbert space ( [ eq : tensor - product ] ) as @xmath87 where @xmath88 are unitary irreducible representations of the poincar group corresponding to particles @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 , respectively . the generators of the representation ( [ eq : non - int ] ) are denoted by @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 , and @xmath92 . the operator of non - interacting _ mass _ @xmath93 commutes with @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 , and @xmath92 . according to ( [ eq : masses ] ) , the operator @xmath94 has a continuous spectrum in the interval @xmath95 and a discrete point @xmath96 embedded in this interval . from definition ( [ eq : non - int ] ) it is clear that the subspaces @xmath49 and @xmath97 are invariant with respect to @xmath86 . moreover , the particle number operator @xmath43 and the projection operator @xmath51 commute with the non - interacting generators @xmath98 = [ t,\mathbf{j}_0 ] = [ t,\mathbf{k}_0 ] = [ t , h_0]=0 \label{eq : t - comm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this implies that the particle @xmath37 is stable with respect to time translations and boosts , as expected @xmath99 the primary reason for considering the representation @xmath86 is that it allows us to build a convenient basis in the subspace @xmath52 . let us denote @xmath100 a vector in @xmath52 that corresponds to the particle @xmath37 with zero momentum . @xmath101 then we find that the vector @xmath102 describes the particle @xmath37 with definite momentum @xmath103 . indeed , using ( [ eq:6.2 ] ) we obtain @xmath104 ) | \mathbf{0 } \rangle \\ & = & \frac{\vec{\theta}}{\theta } m_ac \sinh \theta e^{-\frac{ic}{\hbar}\mathbf{k}_0 \vec{\theta } } | \mathbf{0 } \rangle \\ & = & \frac{\vec{\theta}}{\theta } m_ac \sinh \theta | \mathbf{p } \rangle \end{aligned}\ ] ] since particle @xmath37 is spinless by our assumption , the eigenvectors @xmath105 of the total momentum operator @xmath89 form a full basis in the subspace @xmath52 , so that @xmath106 then any state @xmath107 of the particle @xmath37 can be represented by a linear combination of these basis vectors @xmath108 where @xmath109 is the wave function in the momentum representation . in order to ensure the normalization @xmath110 , the function @xmath111 must satisfy @xmath112 apparently , vectors @xmath113 themselves are not normalized . if we want to study the non - decay law of a state with definite momentum @xmath114 , we should use a state vector ( which we denote by @xmath115 to distinguish it from @xmath116 ) that has a normalized momentum - space wave function sharply localized near @xmath114 . in order to satisfy eq . ( [ eq : normalization ] ) such a wave function may be formally represented as a square root of the dirac s delta function @xmath117 the action of boosts on the basis vectors @xmath113 and @xmath118 is known from wigner s theory of irreducible unitary representations of the poincar group ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) @xmath119 where @xmath120 using eq . ( [ eq:129a ] ) and the property @xmath121 we can find boost transformations for an arbitrary state vector of the form ( [ eq : expansion ] ) @xmath122 these transformations can be viewed as transformations of the corresponding momentum - space wave function , e.g. , @xmath123 so that the boost operator can be represented as a differential operator in the momentum space @xmath124 for further calculations we will need to define the _ newton - wigner position _ operator @xcite in @xmath58 @xmath125 which has the property @xmath126 & = & i\hbar \delta_{ij } \label{eq : heis}\end{aligned}\ ] ] that can be verified by direct substitution . according to eq . ( [ eq:7.21 ] ) @xmath127 therefore operator @xmath128 acts as a translation operator in the momentum space . in particular , we can write @xmath129 where @xmath130 . on the other hand , applying the boost transformation ( [ eq : boost - tr ] ) to the momentum eigenfunction we obtain is the jacobian of the transformation @xmath131 . ] @xmath132 this suggests that momentum eigenvector ( [ eq : mom - eigen2 ] ) has another useful representation @xmath133 let us now `` turn on '' the interaction responsible for the decay and discuss the interacting representation @xmath57 of the poincar group in @xmath58 with generators @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath69 , and @xmath68 . according to our postulates iii and iv , the generators of space translations and rotations are interaction - free , @xmath134 while the generator of time translations ( the hamiltonian @xmath68 ) contains an interaction - dependent term @xmath135 . @xmath136 from the commutator ( [ eq:5.55 ] ) it then follows @xcite that the generators of boosts must be interaction - dependent as well @xmath137 where @xmath138 . this means that we are working in the so - called dirac s _ instant form of dynamics_. we will further assume that the interacting representation @xmath57 belongs to the bakamjian - thomas form of dynamics @xcite , which is characterized by the property that the interacting operator of mass @xmath139 commutes with the newton - wigner position operator . ] @xmath140 = 0 \label{eq : nw - comm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] our next goal is to define the basis of common eigenvectors of commuting operators @xmath89 and @xmath141 in @xmath58 . , there are other independent operators in the mutually commuting set containing @xmath89 and @xmath141 . these are , for example , the operators of the square of the total angular momentum @xmath142 and the projection of the total angular momentum on the @xmath12-axis @xmath143 . therefore a unique characterization of any basis vector requires specification of all corresponding quantum numbers as @xmath144 . however these quantum numbers are not relevant for our discussion and we omit them . ] these eigenvectors must satisfy conditions @xmath145 they are also eigenvectors of the interacting hamiltonian @xmath146 @xmath147 where @xmath148 . that depends on the eigenvalue @xmath149 of the interacting mass operator and @xmath150 in eq . ( [ eq : omega ] ) that depends on the fixed value of mass @xmath96 of the particle @xmath37 . ] in the zero - momentum eigensubspace of the momentum operator @xmath89 we can introduce a basis @xmath151 of eigenvectors of the interacting mass @xmath141 @xmath152 then the basis @xmath153 in the entire hilbert space @xmath58 can be built by formula ( cf . ( [ eq : mom - eigen2 ] ) ) @xmath154 . these eigenvectors are normalized to delta functions @xmath155 the actions of inertial transformations on these states are well - known @xcite . in particular , for boosts along the @xmath12-axis ( cf . ( [ eq:129a ] ) ) and time translations we obtain @xmath156 where @xmath157 next we notice that due to eqs . ( [ eq : heis ] ) and ( [ eq : nw - comm ] ) vectors @xmath158 also satisfy eigenvector equations ( [ eq : mom - eigen ] ) - ( [ eq : mass - eigen ] ) , so they must be proportional to the basis vectors @xmath159 @xmath160 where @xmath161 is an unimodular factor . unlike in ( [ eq : alpha ] ) , we can not conclude that @xmath162 , because , generally , the action of @xmath163 on eigenvectors @xmath164 involves multiplication by a unimodular scalar in addition to the shift of momentum . however , if the interaction is not pathological we can assume that the factor @xmath161 is smooth , i.e. , without rapid oscillations . this property will be used in derivation of eq . ( [ eq : appr_dec ] ) . obviously , vector @xmath165 can be expressed as a linear combination of zero - momentum basis vectors @xmath166 , so we can write and @xmath39 , i.e. , discrete eigenvalues of @xmath141 below @xmath167 . then the spectrum of @xmath141 ( similar to the spectrum of @xmath94 ) is continuous in the interval @xmath95 , and integration in ( [ eq : integral ] ) should be performed from @xmath168 to infinity . ] @xmath169 where function @xmath170 describes the _ mass distribution _ of the unstable particle . for most realistic unstable systems the mass distribution @xmath171 has the breit - wigner form ( see fig . 1 ) ) could be different from the mass @xmath96 that particle @xmath37 has in the absence of decay interaction . however , we will disregard this possibility here . ] @xmath172 where parameter @xmath173 is a normalization factor required to ensure that the mass distribution ( [ eq:63 ] ) - ( [ eq:64 ] ) is normalized to unity . we now use eqs . ( [ eq : alpha ] ) and ( [ eq : integral ] ) to expand the vector @xmath113 in the basis @xmath174 @xmath175 then , from ( [ eq:28a ] ) we obtain a useful formula @xmath176 suppose that vector @xmath75 in ( [ eq : expansion ] ) describes a state of the unstable particle @xmath37 from the point of view of the observer @xmath9 . the time dependence of this state seen from the moving reference frame @xmath10 is obtained by applying eqs ( [ eq:44a ] ) , ( [ eq:29a ] ) , ( [ eq:29b ] ) , and ( [ eq : p - expansion ] ) @xmath177 the inner product of this vector with @xmath178 is found by using ( [ eq:35a ] ) @xmath179 introducing new integration variables @xmath180 and taking into account ( [ eq : invar ] ) , this equation can be rewritten as @xmath181 the non - decay probability in the reference frame @xmath10 is then found by substituting ( [ eq : projector ] ) in eq . ( [ eq:3b ] ) @xmath182 which is an exact formula valid for all values of @xmath183 and @xmath21 . in the reference frame at rest ( @xmath184 ) , formula ( [ eq:50 ] ) simplifies @xmath185 let us consider a particular case of this expression when the unstable particle has a well - defined momentum , i.e. , described by the state vector @xmath186 . if the particle @xmath37 is in the state @xmath187 with zero momentum then @xmath188 and from the above equation we obtain @xmath189 which is the standard formula for the non - decay law of a particle at rest . , this formula can be compared , for example , with eq . ( 3.8 ) in @xcite . ] in particular , if we substitute ( [ eq:63 ] ) - ( [ eq:64 ] ) for the mass distribution @xmath171 we obtain approximate exponential decay ( [ eq : expo ] ) where the lifetime is given by @xmath190 if the particle @xmath37 has a definite non - zero momentum @xmath191 , then @xmath192 and @xmath193 in a number of works @xcite it was noticed that if one interprets the state @xmath118 ( where @xmath194 ) as a state of unstable particle moving with definite speed @xmath195 , then the decay law of the moving particle ( [ eq:35 ] ) can not be connected with the non - decay law of the particle at rest ( [ eq:34 ] ) by einstein s formula ( [ eq:1b ] ) , i.e. , @xmath196 this observation prompted authors of @xcite to question the applicability of einstein s special relativity to particle decays . however , at a closer inspection it appears that this result does not contradict einstein s time dilation formula ( [ eq:1b ] ) directly . formula ( [ eq:1b ] ) refers to observations made on the same particle from two frames of reference moving with respect to each other . if from the point of view of observer @xmath9 the particle is described by the state vector @xmath197 which has zero momentum and zero velocity , then from the point of view of @xmath10 this particle is described by the state @xmath198 which is an eigenstate of the velocity operator[multiblock footnote omitted ] @xmath199 but is not an eigenstate of the momentum operator @xmath89 . therefore , strictly speaking , its non - decay law is not described by @xmath200 . in order to compare with einstein s formula ( [ eq:1b ] ) , we need to calculate the decay law in the moving frame of reference @xmath201 . this is done in section [ sc : general ] . let us now discuss the non - decay probability @xmath202 at @xmath0 in the moving frame of reference . instead of eq . ( [ eq:50 ] ) , it is more convenient to use the general definition ( [ eq:3d ] ) which expresses @xmath203 as the square of the norm of the projection of @xmath204 on the subspace @xmath52 . we are going to prove that for a normalized @xmath77 this probability can not be equal to 1 for all non - zero @xmath183 . suppose that this statement is wrong , so that ( in agreement with assumption v ) for any @xmath205 and any @xmath206 , the vector @xmath207 belongs to @xmath52 . then the subspace @xmath52 is invariant under action of boosts @xmath208 and operator @xmath209 commutes with the projection @xmath51 . then from the poincar commutator ( [ eq:5.55 ] ) and @xmath210= 0 $ ] it follows by jacobi identity that @xmath211 & = & \frac{ic^2}{\hbar}[t,[k_z,(p_0)_z ] ] \\ & = & \frac{ic^2}{\hbar } [ k_z,[t , ( p_0)_z ] ] - \frac{ic^2}{\hbar}[(p_0)_z,[t , k_z ] ] \\ & = & 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] which contradicts eq . ( [ eq:44b ] ) . this contradiction implies that the state @xmath207 does not correspond to the particle @xmath37 with 100% probability ; this state must contain contributions from the decay products even at @xmath0 @xmath212 this is the `` decay caused by boost '' . thus we found that assumption v from section [ ss : relativity ] is not correct . sometimes this assumption is formulated as @xcite _ `` flavor is the quantum number that distinguishes the different types of quarks and leptons . it is a lorentz invariant quantity . for example , an electron is seen as an electron by any observer , never as a muon . '' _ although the above statement about the electron is correct ( because the electron is a stable particle ) , this is not true about the muon which , according to ( [ eq : not - in ] ) can be seen as a single particle by the observer at rest and as a group of three decay products ( an electron , a neutrino , and an antineutrino ) by the moving observer . unfortunately exact evaluation of eq . ( [ eq:50 ] ) for @xmath213 is not possible , so we need to make approximations . let us discuss properties of the initial state @xmath77 in more detail . first , in all realistic cases this state is not an eigenstate of the total momentum operator , so the wave function is not localized at one point in the momentum space ( as assumed in ( [ eq : sqrt ] ) ) but has a spread ( or uncertainty ) of momentum @xmath214 and , correspondingly an uncertainty of position @xmath215 . on the other hand , the state @xmath216 is not an eigenstate of the mass operator @xmath141 , and @xmath77 is characterized by the uncertainty of mass @xmath217 ( see fig . 1 ) that is related to the lifetime of the particle @xmath218 by formula ( [ eq : lifetime ] ) . it is important to note that in all cases of practical interest the mentioned quantities are related by inequalities @xmath219 in particular , the latter inequality means that the uncertainty of position is mush less than the distance passed by light during the lifetime of the particle . for example , in the case of muon @xmath220s and , according to ( [ eq : gg2 ] ) , the spread of the wave function in the position space must be much less than 600 m , which is a reasonable assumption . therefore , we can safely assume that the factor @xmath171 in ( [ eq:50 ] ) has a sharp peak near the value @xmath221 . then we can move the value of the smooth function @xmath222 at @xmath223 outside the integral by @xmath149 . ) that the spread of the momentum - space wave function is much less than @xmath224 we could have moved the value of the smooth function @xmath225 outside the integral by @xmath149 . this would mean that the non - decay law in the moving frame of reference is controlled by the spread of the particle wavefunction in the momentum space rather than by its mass uncertainty which disagrees with experimental observations . ] @xmath226 now we are going to use formula ( [ eq : appr_dec ] ) to calculate the decay law for an approximate eigenstate of momentum in @xmath52 whose wave function @xmath227 is localized near zero momentum @xmath228 , though inequality ( [ eq : gg ] ) still remains valid . we denote this state vector by symbol @xmath229 $ ] . the state @xmath230 $ ] is an approximate eigenstate of the velocity operator ( [ eq : velocity ] ) for all values of @xmath183 . therefore @xmath231}(\theta , t)$ ] in eq . ( [ eq : omega-0-t ] ) can be understood as the non - decay law of a particle with definite speed @xmath232 . note that the second factor in the integrand in ( [ eq : appr_dec ] ) is a slowly varying function of @xmath191 . therefore , we can set @xmath233 in eq . ( [ eq : appr_dec ] ) and obtain @xmath234}(\theta , t ) & \approx & \vert \int \limits_{m_b + m_c}^{\infty } dm \vert \mu(m)\vert^2 e^{-\frac{it}{\hbar}\sqrt{m^2 c^4 + m_a^2 c^4\sinh^2 \theta } } \vert^2 \label{eq : omega-0-t}\end{aligned}\ ] ] if we approximately ) . ] identify @xmath235 with the momentum @xmath236 of the particle @xmath37 from the point of view of the moving observer @xmath10 then @xmath234}(\theta , t ) & \approx & e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar}\omega_{\mathbf{p } } t}|^2 \label{eq:62}\end{aligned}\ ] ] so , in this approximation the non - decay law ( [ eq:62 ] ) in the frame of reference @xmath10 moving with the speed @xmath237 takes the same form as the non - decay law ( [ eq:35 ] ) of a particle moving with momentum @xmath238 with respect to the stationary observer @xmath9 . in this section we are going to perform numerical calculations of the differences between the classical einstein s formula ( [ eq:1b ] ) @xmath234}^{class}(\theta , t ) = \omega_{|\mathbf{0}]}(0 , \frac{t}{\cosh \theta } ) \label{eq : time - dilation}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the actual non - decay law ( [ eq : omega-0-t ] ) of a moving particle having either definite momentum or sharply defined speed . in these calculations we assumed that the mass distribution @xmath171 of the unstable system ( see eqs . ( [ eq:63 ] ) - ( [ eq:64 ] ) and fig . 1 ) is centered at the value of mass @xmath239 mev/@xmath240 , the total mass of the decay products was @xmath241 mev/@xmath240 , and the width of the mass distribution was @xmath217= 20 mev/@xmath240 . these values do not correspond to any real particle , but they are typical for strongly decaying baryons . it is convenient to measure time in units of the classical lifetime @xmath242 . denoting @xmath243 , we find that einsteinian non - decay laws ( [ eq : time - dilation ] ) for any value of @xmath183 are given by the same universal function @xmath244 . this function was calculated for values of @xmath245 in the interval from 0 to 6 with the step of 0.1 the calculations were performed by direct numerical integration of eq . ( [ eq:34 ] ) using the _ mathematica _ program shown below .... gamma = 20 mass = 1000 theta = 0.0 do[print[(1/0.9375349 ) abs[nintegrate [ gamma/(2 pi ) / ( gamma^2/4 + ( x - mass)^2 ) exp [ i t sqrt [ x^2 + mass^2 ( sinh [ theta])^2 ] cosh [ theta ] / gamma ] , { x , 900 , 1010 , 1100 , 300000 } , minrecursion - > 3 , maxrecursion - > 16 , precisiongoal - > 8 , workingprecision - > 18]]^2 ] , { t , 0.0 , 6.0 , 0.1 } ] .... as expected , function @xmath244 is very close to the exponent @xmath246 . for small values of the argument @xmath245 are too large to be shown on the scale of fig . next we used eq . ( [ eq : omega-0-t ] ) and the above _ mathematica _ program to calculate the non - decay laws @xmath247}(\theta , \chi ) $ ] in moving reference frames for three values of the parameter @xmath183 ( = ` theta ` ) , namely 0.2 , 1.4 , and 10.0 , that correspond to velocities of 0.197c , 0.885c , and 0.999999995c , respectively . these calculations qualitatively confirmed the time dilation formula ( [ eq : time - dilation ] ) to the accuracy of better than 0.3% . however , they also revealed important differences @xmath248}(\theta , \chi ) - \omega ^{class}(\chi ) $ ] which are plotted as thin lines in fig . 2 . the lifetime of the particle @xmath37 considered in our example ( @xmath249 s ) is too short to be observed experimentally . so , calculated corrections to the einstein s time dilation law have only illustrative value . however , from these data we can estimate the magnitude of corrections for particles whose time - dependent non - decay laws can be measured in a laboratory , e.g. , for muons ( @xmath250s , @xmath251 , @xmath252 ) . taking into account that the magnitude of corrections is roughly proportional to the ratio @xmath253 @xcite , we can expect that for muons the maximum correction should be about @xmath254 which is much smaller than the accuracy of modern experiments ( about @xmath255 @xcite ) . so , experimental observation of the predicted corrections requires significant improvements of existing experimental techniques . note that formulas ( [ eq : omega-0-t ] ) and ( [ eq:62 ] ) for the particle seen from the moving frame are approximate in the sense that they ignore the `` decay caused by boost '' expressed by eq . ( [ eq : not - in2 ] ) . nevertheless , our major approximation ( [ eq : gg ] ) is well justified and it can not explain the discrepancy of our results ( einsteinian time dilation of the decay plus small interaction - dependent corrections ) with the conclusion of ref . @xcite about the acceleration of the decay of moving particles . in our view this conclusion does not refer to the experimentally measured non - decay law that is defined as the probability of finding one unstable particle . instead of eq . ( [ eq:3b ] ) , the non - decay probability was defined in @xcite by formula @xmath256 whose physical meaning remains unclear . in this article we assumed that the interaction responsible for the particle decay has the bakamjian - thomas instant form of dynamics . this assumption was used to simplify calculations , but there is no good reason to believe that real interactions have this form . then , naturally , one may ask a question : `` is there another form of dynamics in which einstein s time dilation formula ( [ eq:1b ] ) is exactly true ? '' the answer is _ no_. in any instant form of dynamics ( including non - bakamjian - thomas instant forms of dynamics ) the boost operators contain interaction terms , so the results ( [ eq : not - in ] ) - ( [ eq : not - in2 ] ) are still valid , and eq . ( [ eq:1b ] ) holds only approximately . in the point form dynamics and rotations @xmath90 are kinematical , while generators of space translations @xmath66 and time translations @xmath68 contain interaction terms . ] the subspace @xmath52 of the unstable particle is invariant with respect to boosts , so there can be no boost - induced decays ( [ eq : not - in ] ) . however , due to the interaction - dependence of the total momentum operator @xmath66 , one should expect decays induced by space translations @xmath257 this prediction is not confirmed by experiments which show that the composition of an unstable particle is not affected by space translations of the observer . times instead of experimentally observed slowdown @xcite . ] therefore , the point form of dynamics is not acceptable for the description of decays . similarly , never observed translation- and/or rotation - induced decays are characteristic for all non - instant forms of dynamics , e.g. , the front form . therefore only the instant form of dynamics is appropriate for the description of particle decays . note , however , that the decay slowdown and the absence of translation - induced decays are firmly established only for unstable systems whose lifetimes are long enough to be measured experimentally , i.e. , those governed by electromagnetic and weak interactions . for strongly interacting resonances these properties are beyond experimental resolution , and the non - instant forms of dynamics can not be ruled out . in this paper we analyzed the relationships between the non - decay laws in the moving reference frame and in the reference frame at rest . we used a rigorous quantum relativistic approach that is applicable to any unstable system independent on the nature of interaction governing the decay . a complete description of dynamics in different reference frames was obtained by using relativistic postulates i - vi and rules of quantum mechanics only . we found that assumptions v and vi of special relativity are not needed . moreover , their consequences ( the universal and exact time dilation of the decay of moving particles ) are in contradiction with rigorous calculations . although the time dilation ( [ eq:1b ] ) of special relativity was qualitatively confirmed by our results , we also found small corrections to this formula that depend on the strength of interaction . in a broader sense our results indicate that clocks viewed from the moving reference frame do not go exactly @xmath258 slower . the exact amount of time dilation depends on the physical makeup of the clock and on interactions responsible for the operation of the clock . b. rossi and d. b. hall , _ variation of the rate of decay of mesotron with momentum _ , phys . rev . * 59 * ( 1941 ) , 223 ; d. s. ayres , a. m. cormack , a. j. greenberg , r. w. kenney , d. o. cladwell , v. b. elings , w. p. hesse , and r. j. morrison , _ measurements of the lifetime of positive and negative pions _ , d. * 3 * ( 1971 ) , 1051 ; c. e. roos , j. marraffino , s. reucroft , j. waters , m. s. webster , e. g. h. williams , a. manz , r. settles , and g. wolf , @xmath259 _ lifetimes and longitudinal acceleration _ , nature * 286 * , ( 1980 ) , 244 . j. bailey , k. borer , f. combley , h. drumm , f. kreinen , f. lange , e. picasso , w. von ruden , f. j. m. farley , j. h. field , w. flegel , and p. m. hattersley , _ measurements of relativistic time dilatation for positive and negative muons in a circular orbit _ , nature * 268 * ( 1977 ) , 301 ; f. j. m. farley , _ the cern ( g-2 ) measurements _ , z. phys . c * 56 * ( 1992 ) , s88 . b. bakamjian and l. h. thomas , _ relativistic particle dynamics . ii _ , phys . rev . * 92 * ( 1953 ) , 1300 ; f. coester and w. n. polyzou , _ relativistic quantum mechanics of particles with direct interactions _ , phys . rev . d * 26 * ( 1982 ) , 1348 .

a rigorous quantum relativistic approach has been used to calculate the relationship between the decay laws of an unstable particle seen from two inertial frames moving with respect to each other . in agreement with experiment , it is found that the usual einstein s time dilation formula is rather accurate in this case . however , small corrections to this formula were also obtained . although the observation of these corrections is beyond the resolution of modern experiments , their presence indicates that special relativistic time dilation is not rigorously applicable to particle decays .

1202.0858

in atomic , molecular , and chemical physics , linear quadrupole traps ( lqts ) are ubiquitous . they are routinely used in the study of topics ranging from quantum information@xcite to plasma dynamics@xcite to precision measurement@xcite . moreover , in the rapidly emerging field of hybrid atom - ion devices , lqts are now being employed to study the interactions of cold atomic and molecular ions with neutral atoms and molecules@xcite . these studies have already resulted in important quantum chemistry measurements@xcite and promise to enable new technologies and science such as the implementation of novel quantum gates@xcite , probes of quantum gases@xcite , observation of novel charge - transport dynamics@xcite , and the sympathetic cooling of atomic and molecular systems which can not be laser cooled@xcite . while the lqt is a thoroughly proven device , direct identification of non - fluorescing ions in a lqt is not straightforward and is often problematic . current methods to identify ions in a lqt include nondestructive resonant - excitation mass spectrometry using laser - induced fluorescence@xcite , destructive resonant - excitation mass spectrometry using channel electron multiplier ( cem ) detection@xcite , lqt mass - filtering techniques@xcite , and molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations@xcite . the first three methods are complicated by lqt properties which give rise to nonlinear resonances , multiple secular frequencies , and trap - depth limitations . these complications may lead to either the incorrect labeling or the lack of observation of certain ions . the last method is limited by the inability to even indirectly identify the non - laser - cooled ion . these limitations and complications can be avoided if ions are instead directly observed in a simple , straightforward manner using time - of - flight ( tof ) mass spectrometry . unfortunately , while commercial devices which couple ion traps with tof units do exist , they do not offer a practical solution for most experimental architectures employed in atomic , molecular , and chemical physics . first , commercial tof devices are predominantly geared towards life science research where the study of large molecules requires extremely high mass resolutions ( @xmath1)@xcite . to meet these stringent demands , commercial tof devices are large , highly integrated designs that are constructed to be the principle feature of the experimental apparatus . second , in most commercial units the tof unit is coupled to a 3d paul trap rather than a lqt@xcite . while this type of device works well for many applications , 3d paul traps , unlike lqts , are not amenable to studies that require large trap capacities and high optical access to the trapped ions demands typical of atomic , molecular , and chemical physics experiments . and finally , though some commercial devices incorporate a lqt , the trapped ions are typically axially ejected from the lqt and subsequently accelerated orthogonally into the tof drift tube to recover good mass resolution@xcite . although this is an effective coupling technique , the commercial implementation of orthogonal acceleration is technically complicated , space - demanding , and expensive . here we describe a simple lqt - tof device , which offers near - isotopic mass resolution for atomic and molecular ions with masses of a few 100 amu . the straightforward , compact design ensures that the device does not impede non - tof related functions by limiting optical or spatial access , making it ideal for most atomic , molecular , and chemical physics applications . this is accomplished by coupling the lqt to the tof apparatus through a novel radial extraction method resulting in good mass resolution and without the complications associated with axial ejection and orthogonal acceleration . additionally , due to the use of ion optics to enhance ion detection efficiency , long interrogation times do not need to be sacrificed for higher measurement rates , as in most commercial devices , in order to build statistics on reasonable time scales . finally , the proposed device can be built for a small fraction of the cost of current commercial tof devices . in the remainder of this article , we demonstrate the implementation and characterization of the lqt - tof device . we first discuss the design and construction of the device addressing the tof unit , the lqt used to trap and interrogate a sample of ions , and the associated electronics . secondly , we describe the calibration of the device using mass - filtering techniques . we conclude with proof - of - principle experiments which demonstrate the effectiveness of the device as a simple , practical method of mass spectrometry for use in atomic , molecular , and chemical physics . the tof device , shown in fig . [ fig : app ] , is built onto a @xmath2-@xmath3 conflat flange and is supported by three @xmath4-@xmath5 threaded rods . the @xmath6 mm drift tube , confined by a surrounding @xmath2-@xmath3 conflat nipple , includes ion optics which are used to guide ions into the detector region to increase the detection efficiency of the device . the detector region is composed of a cem held at @xmath7 v and a stainless steel grid used to ensure that the drift tube remains field - free , apart from the field created by the ion optics . the total length of the device is @xmath8 mm and is designed to couple with a lqt ( @xmath9 mm and @xmath10 where @xmath11 and @xmath12 are the field and electrode radii , respectively ) via pulsed radial extraction . the entire apparatus is maintained at background pressures below @xmath13 mbar by a triode sputter - ion pump . to simplify the coupling process , the tof device couples directly to a lqt through radial extraction . this method is superior to that of the normal axial extraction for three critical reasons . first , field lines from the axially - confining end caps do not penetrate far into the trapping region . if the ions are pulsed from the trap axially ( _ i.e. _ by grounding an end cap ) , relatively long durations are required to completely empty the trap due to this weak coupling . this leads to a relatively large temporal spread of ions , which results in poor mass resolution . this problem can be partially solved by using segmented trap electrodes@xcite to apply a more strongly - coupled , axially - ejecting field to the trapped ions ; however , this solution requires more sophisticated machining and electronics . second , the axial distribution of trapped ions in a lqt is generally larger than the radial distribution . this leads to a larger distribution of initial energies and overall flight distances , and thereby poorer mass resolution when ions are axially pulsed . third , it is often the case in atomic , molecular , and chemical physics that the lqt axis is used for the introduction of cooling or spectroscopy beams , which generally precludes axial extraction into a tof device . despite the obvious drawbacks of axial ion extraction , there have been relatively few implementations of radial ion extraction into a tof device . in the patent of franzen et al.@xcite , the use of plate electrodes external to the lqt is proposed to apply pulsed potentials that radially eject the ions into the drift tube . these plates , however , obstruct optical access to the trap and also require space in the vacuum chamber . additionally , field lines from the external plates do not penetrate far into the lqt , resulting in weak coupling between the plates and the trapped ions . as a result it is difficult to establish an optimal ion extraction scheme using this method and no experimental data is found in the literature . unlike the design proposed by franzen , radial extraction in our device is achieved by applying the extraction pulses directly to the trap electrodes , in a manner similar to that proposed by makarov in ref . , eliminating the need for external plate electrodes . for the operation of our device , various ions are introduced to the trap by ablating solid precursors with a pulsed nd : yag laser as in ref . . for optimal loading , the radiofrequency ( rf ) trapping voltage is applied 50 @xmath14s after the ablation pulse . this rf is applied to all four electrodes with the appropriate phases to create a quadrupole trapping potential with typical values of @xmath15 khz and @xmath16 v leading to mathieu @xmath17 parameters of roughly @xmath18 for @xmath19 amu / e , where @xmath20 is the trapping frequency , @xmath21 is the rf amplitude , @xmath22 , and @xmath23 is the mass - to - charge ratio of the trapped ion . to be clear , the prefactor of @xmath24 in the expression for @xmath17 is a result of applying voltage to all four electrodes rather than to only a diagonal pair . after the trapping period , the rf is switched off and the ions are briefly allowed to expand for @xmath25 @xmath14s . this delay redistributes the ions such that higher energy ions will either receive a lower extraction energy or have to travel farther before reaching the detector , leading to improved mass resolution@xcite . to realize maximum mass resolution a two - stage acceleration scheme is implemented following the delay . extraction potentials of roughly @xmath26 v ( blue ) and @xmath27 v ( green ) , as shown in fig . [ fig : trap ] , are applied to vertically paired electrodes . this results in the radial extraction of ions from the trapping region , through the right pair of electrodes , and into the tof drift tube which is referenced to ground . the electronics used to provide the pulsing voltages include two sets of positive - high - voltage power supplies and pulsers . a circuit , shown schematically in fig . [ fig : trap ] , is used to combine the pulsing and trapping potentials . amplified rf voltage is applied to the primary windings of two hand - wound center - tapped transformers . the center - taps of the secondary coils are connected to the high - voltage pulsing units and the two pairs of secondary wires are connected to vertically paired trap electrodes . when the trapping rf is on , the pulser outputs are grounded , resulting in the normal quadrupole trapping potential . however , when the trapping rf is off and the pulser outputs are high , identical high - voltage is applied to the vertically paired electrodes , resulting in the radial ejection of the ions into the tof drift tube . a rf switch with a @xmath28 @xmath14s fall - off time is used to switch off the rf prior to pulsing . this large fall - off time relative to the pulse delay ( @xmath25 @xmath14s ) guarantees the remainder of an rf component in the pulsed high voltage . the phase of this rf can be tuned to optimize ion detection , mass resolution , and signal stability which may be otherwise limited due to fringing fields , charging effects , or engineering imperfections in the experiment . to optimally implement the two - stage acceleration of the ions from the trap , lqt - tof dimensions are determined based on the work of wiley et al in ref . . critical distances , shown in fig . [ fig : trap ] , include the length of the drift tube , @xmath29 , the mean length of the first acceleration stage , @xmath30 , and the length of the second acceleration stage , @xmath31 . the extraction voltages ( @xmath26 and @xmath27 v ) establish the equipotential contours shown in fig . [ fig : trap ] . the corresponding potential energy plot shows the approximately uniform two - stage extraction field along the extraction axis . the first stage ( dark grey ) has a mean length of @xmath32 mm and field of @xmath33 v / cm . the second stage ( medium grey ) has a length of @xmath34 mm and field of @xmath35 v / cm . due to the grounded skimmer and grid , a field less than @xmath36 v / cm extends past @xmath37 mm into the drift tube ( light grey ) . in this two - stage scheme , the distribution of total energies received by the ions is much smaller than in the single - stage scheme , which results in higher mass resolutions as originally asserted in ref . . in order to establish a large detection efficiency ion trajectories in both the radial and axial planes must be corrected to prevent ions from colliding with the walls . this is complicated by the difference in divergences of ion trajectories in the radial and axial planes , which occurs as a result of the extraction geometries . to correct this astigmatic ion beam we employ two einzel lenses ( @xmath36 mm diameter , @xmath38 mm center - lens length , @xmath39 mm lens gap ) with different focal lengths . the first einzel lens , added immediately after the skimmer , approximately collimates the ions in the axial plane and sufficiently decreases the divergence in the radial plane to avoid ion loss . a second einzel lens , added closer to the detection region , slightly focuses ions in the axial plane while approximately collimating the ions in the radial plane . setting the first and second einzel lenses to @xmath40 and @xmath41 v , respectively , leads to optimal detection by the cem , as shown in fig . [ fig : trajectories ] . while , the use of ion optics increases detection efficiency by enabling the detection of ions that would otherwise collide with the walls , those ions with bent trajectories travel farther , thus compromising mass resolution . to mitigate this effect , a skimmer with a @xmath42 mm diameter aperture is used to block ions with extremely off - axis trajectories from entering the drift tube . the device was calibrated and tested by trapping ions in the lqt and subsequently recording their tof spectra . representative tof spectra produced by ablating bacl@xmath43 , srcl@xmath43 , and yb targets are shown in fig . [ fig : spectra ] . these targets were chosen due to the cold atomic and molecular ion community s interest in their ablation products , namely ba@xmath44@xcite , bacl@xmath44@xcite , sr@xmath44@xcite , srcl@xmath44@xcite , and yb@xmath44@xcite . to calibrate the tof signal , the mass - to - charge ratio , @xmath23 , of each peak in the recorded tof spectra was determined using standard mass - filtering techniques@xcite . for each @xmath23 peak , the lqt @xmath21 was increased at fixed @xmath20 until the mathieu stability parameter exceeded @xmath45 , leading to the loss of ions from the lqt and the disappearance of the associated @xmath23 peak from the tof spectrum . this process was repeated for several values of @xmath20 and for all @xmath23 peaks in each tof spectrum , leading to a list of @xmath46 pairs for each @xmath23 peak . the @xmath23 ratio for each peak was then found by fitting the @xmath45 stability parabola to the @xmath47 pairs with @xmath23 as the only free parameter , as shown in the left panel of fig . [ fig : calibration ] . the calculated @xmath23 ratios for each peak are listed in table [ tab : m ] . .comparison of actual and measured @xmath23 ratios . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the flight time of each peak was then mapped to its calculated @xmath23 ratio which provides the flight time to @xmath23 calibration curve shown in the right panel of fig . [ fig : calibration ] . to further characterize the device , a 3d monte carlo simulation of the lqt - tof was performed using simion v8.1 . in all simulations , we attempted to , at least partially , account for the coulomb repulsion between the ions by simultaneously tracking groups of 1000 ions ( a limit set by computational resources ) and including their point - to - point and image - charge interactions . the results of these simulations are shown alongside data in fig . [ fig : spectra ] as dashed curves . due to delays in the electronics and engineering imperfections , a @xmath48 @xmath14s flight - time offset must be added to the simulations for maximum agreement . the simulated mass resolution , defined as @xmath49 , where @xmath50 and @xmath51 are the mean and fwhm of the ions flight - time distribution , was @xmath52 whereas typical experimental mass resolution was found to be @xmath53 . this discrepancy might be explained by experimental imperfections such as misalignment and/or by the fact that the number of simulated ions may underestimate space - charge effects . finally , to determine the detection efficiency , the number of number of ba@xmath44 ions in the lqt prior to extraction was measured by observing laser - induced fluorescence . the ba@xmath44 laser system includes a @xmath54 nm cooling laser which drives the @xmath55p@xmath56s@xmath57 transition ( @xmath58 mhz ) and a @xmath59 nm repump laser which drives the @xmath55p@xmath56d@xmath60 transition ( @xmath61 mhz ) . these beams were both aligned along the axis of the lqt . upon loading ba@xmath44 into the lqt , fluoresence from the @xmath55p@xmath62s@xmath57 transition was measured by a photomultiplier tube while the cooling laser s frequency was scanned roughly @xmath63 mhz about the transition . this signal was used to determine the number of trapped ba@xmath44 ions which was then compared to the number of ba@xmath44 ions detected by the tof device . the detection efficiency , which is sensitive to both ion - cloud and skimmer size , was found to be roughly @xmath64 which is in reasonable agreement with the monte carlo simulation prediction of @xmath65 . to demonstrate the usefulness of this device for atomic , molecular , and chemical physics , we carried out two proof - of - principle experiments which are characteristic of atom - ion experiments performed with lqts and hybrid atom - ion devices . a major challenge to the present study of ultracold molecular ions is the current lack of spectroscopic information as discussed in ref . . to advance this promising field , a new effort in molecular ion spectroscopy is needed . however , because fluorescence spectroscopy typically requires numbers of ions much larger than can be held in even a lqt , an alternate technique such as action spectroscopy , where spectroscopic photons are used to drive photofragmentation processes , must be employed . the lqt - tof device could significantly aid this experimental effort as it affords high optical access and the ability to identify any action - spectroscopy ion products that are able to be co - trapped with the parent molecular ion . to prove the usefulness of this device for molecular - ion action spectroscopy , we performed a simple experiment to observe the photodissociation of bacl@xmath44 , a candidate for ultracold molecular ion studies@xcite . this type of data is a necessary first step to understanding the structure for these relatively unstudied molecular ions . for this experiment , bacl@xmath44 and ba@xmath44 were first loaded into the lqt by ablating a bacl@xmath43 target . the ba@xmath44 ions were removed from the trap using mass - filtering techniques@xcite . next , the bacl@xmath44 ions were exposed to laser pulses produced by a pulsed dye laser ( pdl ) , which drive an electronic transition from the x@xmath66 state to the repulsive wall of the a@xmath67 state resulting in the dissociation of bacl@xmath44 into ba@xmath44 ( trapped ) and cl ( untrapped ) fragments@xcite . to prove the sensitivity of the device , we used @xmath68 pdl pulses at @xmath69 @xmath14j / mm@xmath70 per @xmath68 ns pulse and a photon energy of @xmath71 @xmath72 which was red - detuned from the peak - resonance at @xmath73 @xmath72@xcite , and as a result , led to a small action - spectroscopy ba@xmath44 ion - product signal . as seen in fig . [ fig : pd ] , the minimal discernible action - spectroscopy ion - product signal was measured to be approximately @xmath39 part in @xmath74 . by detecting small increases in product ion from background levels , this method of fragment detection is much more sensitive than the previously - used method of trap depletion@xcite , in which small losses of parent ion are detected . this affords the ability to search for sensitive processes like predissociation , which are rovibronically state - selective and thus necessary for the ultracold - molecular - ion community , but typically have ion - product branching ratios of only one part in a few hundred . in the emerging field of hybrid atom - ion devices , quantum chemistry occurring between cold trapped ions and ultracold external neutral species is beginning to be explored@xcite . however , because these studies employ lqts , it is often difficult to conclusively identify the products of these chemical reactions using current techniques , as aforementioned . these difficulties are especially poignant as there is some disagreement between theory and experiment in characterizing the branching ratio of radiative association to direct charge - transfer processes@xcite . to demonstrate the effectiveness of this device for these types of experiments , we performed a simple measurement to characterize the reaction rates between trapped ba@xmath44 and background gases which were present while the vacuum chamber was being pumped down to base pressure . in this experiment , ba@xmath44 and bacl@xmath44 were first loaded into the trap via ablation of the bacl@xmath43 target . these trapped ions were allowed to interact with an assortment of background gases for varying times . the predominant gases were h@xmath43o ( @xmath75 mbar ) , hcl ( @xmath76 mbar ) , and n@xmath43 ( @xmath76 mbar ) as measured by a residual gas analyzer . the presence of the hcl background gas can be explained by the presence of an alcl@xmath77 solid ablation target , which is known to react with h@xmath43o to form hcl@xcite . following the interaction period between trapped ions and the background gas , the remaining ions were extracted from the trap and the tof spectra recorded . integration of the spectra for various trap times , @xmath78 s , led to the data shown in fig . [ fig : reactions ] . from this data it appears that trapped ba@xmath44 reacts with the background gas to create both bacl@xmath44 and baoh@xmath44@xcite . the total ion count remains approximately @xmath79 for all trap times , suggesting that this is a closed system and thus the most likely reactions are @xmath80 by fitting exponentials to the data we determine the above reactions to have rates of @xmath81 hz and @xmath82 hz . these rates are in good agreement with the @xmath83 hz loss rate of ba@xmath44 . estimates of the rate constants are @xmath84 @xmath85 s@xmath86 and @xmath87 @xmath85 s@xmath86 , subject , of course , to the accuracy of the residual gas analyzer . from this data , it is clear that the lqt - tof can be used to measure reaction rates to an accuracy of a few hundred mhz and , combined with the results from the previous section , can constrain the branching ratio of radiative association to direct charge - transfer processes to @xmath39 part in @xmath74 , representing an order of magnitude gain in sensitivity@xcite . the lqt - tof device can be further optimized beyond its current implementation with the addition of several new features . first , the current cem can be substituted for a multichannel plate ( mcp ) , which would increase the detection area and thus the detection efficiency of the device . the operator control of the device would also be enhanced by the added ability to spatially resolve the ion beam incident upon the mcp . additionally , the use of a mcp would reduce the risk of signal saturation . second , cylindrical einzel lenses can be used in place of the current spherical einzel lenses to afford more flexibility and operator control in collimating the ion beam . third , different skimmer geometries can be explored in order to deliver the optimal balance of detection efficiency and off - axis ion discrimination . rather than a skimmer with a circular aperture , as was used here , a skimmer with a narrow slit parallel to the lqt axis could be used to increase the number of ions which pass into the drift tube without sacrificing mass resolution . we have demonstrated the implementation of a novel , simplified tof mass spectrometer with medium mass resolution ( @xmath53 ) , which is designed to couple directly to a lqt using radial extraction . to establish the usefulness of this device to atomic , molecular , and chemical physics we have performed two proof - of - principle experiments , which are germane to these fields of study . first we used the lqt - tof device to record an action spectroscopy signal with sufficient sensitivity to carry out _ e.g. _ predissociation spectroscopy of molecular ions . in fact , we are currently using this device to search for a predicted predissociation channel in bacl@xmath44@xcite . next , we demonstrated the ability of the device to characterize chemical reactions of trapped ionic species . here we showed significant improvements over current techniques in detection sensitivity , which should afford the ability to resolve discrepancies between experiment and theory regarding the branching ratio of radiative association to direct charge - transfer processes . finally , we have offered several simple improvements that could be implemented to improve the resolution and efficiency of the device . the authors thank paul jordan from jordan tof products , inc . and alexander makarov from thermo fisher scientific for their informative conversations on tof mass spectrometry , craig taatjes for useful discussions involving ion - chemical reactions , and shylo stiteler for his help with the machining of the lqt - tof device . this work was supported by nsf and aro grants , phy-0855683 and w911nf-10 - 1 - 0505 . 41ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.090502 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.99.120502 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nature04279 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.81.2878 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1192720 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1154622 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.173002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nature08865 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.133202 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.243201 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.243202 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.102.223201 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.76.033409 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.76.063602 [ * * , ( ) ] http://prl.aps.org/abstract/prl/v85/i25/p5316_1 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.79.032716 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1080/09500340500275850 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1143/jjap.35.l1134 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.73.042712 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1039/c1cp21205b [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 4075/42/3/035101 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/mas.20004 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.97.243005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.68.053406 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.78.042709 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1021/ac991131p [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/rcm.1290020802 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/rcm.1290030511 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase 10.1002/(sici)1097 - 0231(19981030)12:20<1463::aid - rcm357>3.0.co;2-h [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/s1044 - 0305(02)00622 - 0 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.83.030501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1715212 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 4075/38/20/004 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1105497 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.103.103001 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1146/annurev.pc.32.100181.002155 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.133201 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/14356007.a01_527.pub2 [ _ _ ] , vol . ( , ) pp . link:\doibase 10.1063/1.444009 [ * * , ( ) ]

we demonstrate the implementation of a simple time - of - flight ( tof ) mass spectrometer with medium - mass resolution ( @xmath0 ) geared towards the demands of atomic , molecular , and chemical physics experiments . by utilizing a novel radial ion extraction scheme from a linear quadrupole trap , a device with large trap capacity and high optical access is realized without sacrificing mass resolution . here we describe the construction and implementation of the device as well as present representative tof spectra . we conclude by demonstrating the flexibility of the device with proof - of - principle experiments that include the observation of molecular - ion photodissociation and the measurement of trapped - ion chemical reaction rates .

astro-ph0001157

in this paper we continue the exploration of the stellar content of obscured galactic giant h ii regions begun by ( * ? ? ? * hereafter paper i ) . @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 images are used to make a broad assessment of the stellar content of obscured star forming regions in the milky way . infrared spectroscopy follows , providing details of the brightest cluster members which can be used to make distance , mass , and luminosity estimates . the spectra are placed in proper context by comparison to new infrared spectral classification systems for massive stars @xcite . the known hot star content of the galaxy is rapidly expanding on the strength of the sophisticated infrared detector gains of the last 10 years . @xcite have recently published a very detailed account of the most massive stars in the ( relatively ) nearby giant h ii region m17 . the present project ( paper i , this work , and future work ) seeks to provide a large sample of massive star clusters with which to study the young and massive stellar content in the galaxy . this sample builds on the detailed visual studies of the galactic ob associations @xcite and provides a bridge to studies of young stellar objects in star forming regions . finally , the investigation of a large sample of clusters in galactic giant h ii regions will be important in understanding the massive star clusters in the galactic center @xcite which may have formed under different conditions than are typical in the disk of our galaxy @xcite . w42 is located in the fourth galactic quadrant at _ @xmath4 25.4 , 0.2 . @xcite determined w42 to be at the `` near '' kinematic distance ( 3.7 kpc for @xmath5 8 kpc ) and hence somewhat less luminous than earlier estimates @xcite . in this series of papers we shall follow a suggestion of dr . robert kennicutt ( private communication ) that `` giant '' means that more than @xmath6 lyman continuum ( @xmath4 lyc ) photons are inferred to be emitted per second from the h ii region . this is about ten times the luminosity of the orion nebula and roughly the number emitted from the hottest _ single _ o3-type star . as these stars are not found in isolation , there is an implication that a `` giant '' h ii region contains some minimum of _ multiple _ o - type stars . in light of our new distance estimate ( see 4 ) , w42 probably falls below this limit being perhaps a few times more luminous than the trapezium in orion . our target list was originally based on eleven of the most luminous giant h ii regions from the study of @xcite who tabulated their lyc output derived from radio continuum measurements and kinematic distance estimates . w42 is not seen in visual images , and we estimate a foreground extinction of @xmath7 @xmath4 10 mag ( see below ) . @xmath0 ( @xmath8 , @xmath9 ) , @xmath1 ( @xmath10 , @xmath9 ) , and @xmath2 ( @xmath11 , @xmath12 ) images of w42 were obtained on the nights of 29 august 1998 and 01 , 02 may 1999 with the f/14 tip tilt system on the cerro tololo interamerican observatory ( ctio ) 4 m blanco telescope using the two facility imagers cirim ( 1998 data ) and osiris , the ohio state infrared imager / spectrometer ( 1999 data ) . spectroscopic data were obtained on the night of 02 may 1999 using the f/14 tip tilt system at the blanco telescope with osiris . cirim and osiris are described in the instrument manuals found on the ctio web pages ( www.ctio.noao.edu ) . for osiris , see also @xcite . the tip - tilt system is described by @xcite . the tip tilt system uses three piezo electric actuators to move the secondary mirror at high frequency in a computer controlled feed back loop which corrects the natural image centroid motion . osiris employs 0.16@xmath13 pixels and cirim 0.21@xmath13 pixels . all basic data reduction was accomplished using iraf . each image / spectrum was flat fielded using dome flats and then sky subtracted using a median combined image of five to six frames . for w42 itself , independent sky frames were obtained five to ten arcminutes south of the cluster . standard stars used the median combination of the data for sky . the osiris 1999 may images were obtained under photometric conditions and in @xmath14 0.5@xmath13 to 0.6@xmath13 fwhm seeing ( with the tip tilt correction ) . total exposure times were 270 s , 135 s , and 135 s at @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 , respectively . the individual @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 frames were shifted and combined ( figure [ w42i ] ) , and these combined frames have point sources with fwhm of @xmath14 0.6@xmath13 , 0.7@xmath13 , and 0.6@xmath13 at @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 , respectively . dophot @xcite photometry was performed on the combined images . the flux calibration was accomplished using standards 9170 and 9172 from @xcite which are on the las campanas observatory standard system ( lco ) . the lco standards are essentially on the cit / ctio system @xcite , though color transformations exist between the two systems for redder stars . the standards were taken just before the w42 data and within 0.16 airmass of the airmass for w42 ; no corrections were applied for these small differences in airmass . aperture corrections using 11 pixel radius apertures were used to put the instrumental magnitudes on a flux scale . stars brighter than about 10th magnitude are expected to be a few percent non - linear on the osiris images . we have included the 1998 cirim data for such stars since the count levels for the cirim images were in the fully linear regime ( no linearity correction needed ) . the zero point to the cirim photometry was determined by comparing the instrumental magnitudes of stars in common to the osiris and cirim images . the cirim @xmath15band photometry includes a color correction term in order to make a transformation on to the cit / ctio system ( paper i ) . the osiris data was placed on the cit / ctio system by making small corrections ( @xmath16 10 @xmath17 ) to the @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 magnitudes based on linear fits to the magnitude differences as a function of color for stars in common to the cirim and osiris images . uncertainties for the final @xmath18 magnitudes include the formal dophot error added in quadrature to the error in the mean of the photometric standards ( including the transformation to osiris magnitudes for the cirim data ) , and the error in aperture corrections used in transforming from the dophot photometry to osiris magnitudes . the latter errors dominate and were derived from the scatter in the measurements of four to seven relatively uncrowded stars on the mosaic frames . the sum ( in quadrature ) of the aperture correction and standard star uncertainties is @xmath19 0.018 , @xmath19 0.023 , @xmath19 0.019 mag in @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 , respectively . the dophot errors ranged from approximately @xmath19 0.01 mag to an arbitrary cut off of 0.2 mag ( stars with larger errors were excluded from further analysis ) . the flat field illumination was not uniform . a smooth gradient with full range of about 10@xmath17 was present . corrections for this gradient were made based on observations of a standard star taken over a 49 position grid covering the array . the spectra of three of the brightest four stars in the center of w42 were obtained with a 0.48@xmath13 wide slit ( oriented ew ) in 0.7@xmath13 fwhm seeing and divided by the spectrum of hr 6813 ( a1v ) to remove telluric absorption features . br@xmath20 absorption in hr 6813 was removed by eye by drawing a line across it between two continuum points . one dimensional spectra were obtained by extracting and summing the flux in a @xmath19 2 pixel aperture ( 0.64@xmath13 wide ) . the extractions include background subtraction from apertures centered 1.0@xmath13 on either side of the object . the wavelength calibration was accomplished by measuring the positions of bright oh@xmath21 lines from the @xmath3band sky spectrum @xcite . lines are identified by their relative differences between one and another . the measured dispersion is 0.0003683 pix@xmath22 . the spectral resolution at 2.2 is @xmath23 3000 . a spectacular stellar cluster is revealed at the heart of w42 in our near infrared images ( figure [ w42i ] and figure [ w42c ] ) . apparently , the cluster has just emerged from the edge of the molecular cloud from which it formed . this is confirmed below through @xmath3band spectroscopy which shows that the central massive star has largely cleared away its birth cocoon , but two of the next brightest stars have not . @xcite observed w42 in the mid and far infrared . their analysis revealed two distinct sites of star formation toward w42 . one , g25.4se is located at 3.7 kpc from the sun ( accounting for a sun to galactic center distance of 8 kpc ) , while the other , g25.4nw is probably located at about 9.6 kpc . lester et al . found a 10 unresolved source located at ra ( 2000 ) @xmath24 , dec ( 2000 ) @xmath25@xmath26 which is coincident with g25.4se . this mid ir source is associated with the stellar cluster we have observed . comparison of the position of the bright foreground star in the se corner of our @xmath3band image to the same star on the image from the digitized sky survey ( dss ) results in a position for the ( @xmath3band ) bright central star in the cluster ( w42 # 1 ; see 3.2 ) of ra ( 2000 ) @xmath27 , dec ( 2000 ) @xmath25@xmath28 . the @xmath29 color@xmath30magnitude diagram ( cmd ) for the region toward w42 is shown in figure [ cmd ] . a cluster sequence is evident at 0.6 @xmath29 1.5 along with stars with much redder colors and a probable foreground sequence . the @xmath31 vs. @xmath29 color color diagram is presented in figure [ cc ] . as expected from the morphology and range of colors in figure [ w42c ] , the strong effects of differential reddening can be seen in the color color diagram . typical reddening lines are shown for m giants @xcite and early o stars @xcite . the latter color was transformed as described in 3.1.3 . the cluster stars defined below in 3.1.1 and shown as _ open circles _ in figure [ cc ] may have a slight unexplained systematic offset relative to the reddening line for normal o stars . this possible offset will not affect the conclusions in this paper regarding the cluster stars . the relationship for the intrinsic colors of classical t tauri stars ( pre main sequence stars ) @xcite is also shown for reference . the adopted reddening law is from @xcite . by separating the stars in figure [ cmd ] based on radial position , we can better define the central cluster relative to the surrounding field . in figure [ surf ] , we plot the radial surface density of stars centered on the position of the bright central star , w42 # 1 ( 3.2 ) . we also plot the radial surface density for stars with @xmath2 @xmath32 14 mag , for which the number counts are more nearly complete ( see below ) . the surface density becomes approximately uniform at a radius of @xmath33 , continuing up to 50@xmath13 . it then begins to fall rapidly at the edge of the array ( _ dashed vertical line _ ) as expected due to the rectangular shape of the field . taking these radii as representative , we divide the cmd into regions with 0@xmath34 30@xmath13 , 30@xmath34 50@xmath13 , and @xmath35 50@xmath13 , as shown in figure [ cmdrad ] . these represent the central cluster , a background annulus , and the region of the array where edge effects are important to the radial number counts . the range of color and brightness in figure [ cmdrad ] overlaps for stars in the cluster and background regions . a distinct blue sequence can be seen in the 0@xmath34 30@xmath13 cluster cmd which appears to merge smoothly with other stars in the 30@xmath34 50@xmath13 cmd . clearly the cluster can not be completely extracted from the surrounding field based on radial position alone . in order to further enhance the cluster sequence , we defined a background cmd using the 30@xmath34 50@xmath13 region and accounting for the area difference between this annulus and the central region . the background cmd was binned in 0.5 mag color magnitude bins . we then randomly selected and subtracted stars from the cluster in equal numbers from bins matching the background cmd . the resulting cmd is shown in figure [ cmdsub ] . the corresponding colors for these stars are plotted as _ open circles _ in figure [ cc ] . most of the brightest stars in the central cluster fall along an essentially vertical track as expected for hot stars . the average color of the brightest seven of these stars is @xmath29 @xmath4 0.637 which corresponds to an extinction at 2.2 of @xmath36 1.07 mag ( @xmath7 @xmath37 10 mag ) using the interstellar reddening curve of @xcite and an intrinsic @xmath29 @xmath4 @xmath38 @xcite . many other stars appear more reddened , typically up to @xmath29 @xmath14 2 with some as high as 3.8 . a star with @xmath29 @xmath4 2 and intrinsic @xmath29 @xmath4 0 would have @xmath36 3.2 mag ( @xmath7 @xmath37 32 mag ) . it will be useful in discussing the w42 cluster below to have an estimate for the zero age main sequence ( zams ) transformed into the @xmath2 vs. @xmath29 plane . we have constructed such an estimate using the model results of @xcite . the models give bolometric luminosities ( ) and effective temperatures ( ) for stars of a given mass as they begin their evolution on the zams . using relationships for spectral type vs. @xcite , visual bolometric correction ( bc@xmath39 ) vs. effective temperature @xcite , @xmath40 vs. spectral type @xcite , and @xmath29 vs. spectral type @xcite , we transform the and to the @xmath2 vs. @xmath29 cmd . a small correction has been made in an attempt to place the @xmath29 colors from @xcite onto the cit / ctio system . the @xcite colors are basically referred to the system of @xcite with newly defined colors involving @xmath1 ( johnson used no @xmath1 filter ) . in addition , @xcite found that interpolating an @xmath1 magnitude from the observed @xmath0 and @xmath2 values gives a very good estimate of the observed @xmath1 magnitude . @xcite found no discernible color correction between the saao system and that of @xcite . we have therefore used the transformation of @xcite between the saao system and cit / ctio to transform the @xmath29 colors given by @xcite . these corrections are at most one percent and hence negligible compared to the measurement uncertainties and scatter due to differential reddening . the zams cmd is shown in figure [ cmdsub ] for a particular distance ( 2.2 kpc ) which is discussed in 4 . the values plotted in figure [ cmdsub ] are listed in table [ tabzams ] . these values may be compared to those given by @xcite . there is generally good agreement as a function of . this is expected since the same models and colors were used in both cases . there are systematic differences at the @xmath14 @xmath19 0.3 mag level for @xmath41 as a function of spectral type since the spectral type vs. relation adopted here @xcite is different than that used by @xcite who used the relation given by @xcite . these differences do not affect the conclusions of 4.3 since the resulting @xmath41 for the spectral type in question ( o5o6 ) is within 0.1 mag in both cases . the @xmath3band luminosity function ( klf ) is shown in figure [ klf ] . neglecting the last five bins where the counts appear to be incomplete and the first 3 bins where the counts may be better described as uniform , the @xmath3band counts are well fit by a power law with index 0.4 ( log@xmath42n @xmath4 0.4 @xmath43 @xmath2 + constant ) . we estimated the completeness of the klf by performing artificial star experiments . initially , we attempted to add stars to the original @xmath3band image , but even adding 10@xmath17 of the observed klf resulted in recovered luminosity functions much less complete than the observed one . this is due to the high spatial density of the cluster . to avoid this problem , we constructed complete artificial frames and analyzed them in the same way as the original frame . anticipating the result , we used the spatial density distribution of the stars on the @xmath3band image with @xmath44 14 mag ( figure [ surf ] ) to generate the positions of stars on the artificial frames . the input luminosity function was constructed from two components , a uniform distribution from 8.5 @xmath45 10.5 , and a power law for 10.5 @xmath46 19.5 . the total number of stars was set by the flux on the @xmath3band image , less a uniform background component determined from the sky frame . this should be conservative regarding the number of stars since the strong nebular flux is included . this latter aspect may be balanced somewhat by the fact that the artificial frames did not include variable extinction and nebular emission . the total @xmath3band flux in figure [ w42i]@xmath47 is 6.0 mag , not including the bright saturated star in the se corner of the frame . the total flux of the average actual input luminosity function ( figure [ fake ] ) was 5.9 mag which can be compared to the total flux in observed stars ( figure [ klf ] ) , @xmath48 6.18 mag . we constructed 10 artificial frames by randomly sampling the spatial distribution and luminosity functions . dophot was run on each frame and the recovered stars matched to the input lists . the average recovered luminosity function , input luminosity function , and completeness fraction are shown in figure [ fake ] . the general shape and distribution of the recovered stars in figure [ fake ] suggest the experiments are a fair test of completeness of the original frame . from the same input and recovered star lists , we also show the luminosity functions and completeness fraction for the stars located at 0@xmath3430@xmath13 . see figure [ fake30 ] . tests were also made to check whether somewhat steeper power laws were also consistent with the observed klf . this might be the case if the crowding were sufficient to `` hide '' many fainter stars . artificial star experiments analogous to those above ( including the same uniform component ) but with a power law component of 0.5 are not consistent with the data . a single power law component of this steepness produces more star light than is necessary to account for the observed total flux and produces too many stars in the recovered luminosity function at fainter magnitudes if it is required to produce approximately the correct numbers at brighter magnitudes . the spectra of the targets w42 # 1 , # 2 , and # 3 are shown in figure [ spec ] . the final signal to noise in the three spectra is typically 80105 , 7595 , and 5578 for w42 # 1 , w42 # 2 , and w42 # 3 , respectively and is higher on the red end than the blue end for all three . the brightest star in the central cluster , w42 # 1 ( @xmath49 8.8 mag ) , shows characteristic o star features @xcite . these include ( 2.069 and 2.078 ) emission , ( 2.1155 ) emission , br@xmath20 ( 2.1661 ) absorption , and ( 2.1891 ) absorption . comparison to the standards presented by @xcite results in @xmath3band spectral type of ko5-o6 . these stars typically have mk spectral types of o5 to o6 . the present classification system laid out by @xcite does not have strong luminosity class indicators . still , the ( 2.06 ) and br@xmath20 features can be used to approximately distinguish between dwarf+giants on the one hand , and supergiants on the other : the supergiants tend to have emission or weak absorption in these lines . the spectrum of w42 # 1 shown in figure [ spec ] has been background subtracted with nearby apertures to account for the nebular emission seen in projection toward the star . the apparent absorption feature at the position of br@xmath20 and absence of a feature at ( 2.06 ) ( which might indicate a poor subtraction of the nebular contribution ) , suggests that w42 # 1 is a dwarf or giant star . in contrast to w42 # 1 , the spectra of w42 # 2 and # 3 show only emission features at ( 2.06 ) and br@xmath20 . these spectra have also been background subtracted with nearby ( 1.0@xmath13 ) background apertures . we believe the strong emission remaining after this subtraction is related to the local environment in these stars ( see 4.1 ) . the dense stellar cluster evident in figure [ w42i ] surrounded by intense nebulosity leaves no doubt that this is a young object still emerging from its birth environment at the edge of its parent molecular cloud . the cluster appears to have emerged by clearing the foreground material to the west ; darker regions with fewer stars remain toward the east . there is a suggestion of photoevaporated regions on the edge of the cloud to the east similar to those seen in m16 @xcite and ngc 3603 @xcite . this is particularly evident in figure [ w42i]@xmath50 . this picture is consistent with the co line maps of @xcite , who found the peak brightness temperature of the associated molecular cloud to be offset to the east of the w42 ( g25.4se ) h ii region ( see their figure 8) . higher spatial resolution images and in nebular lines are in order to further study the interaction and impact of the ionizing cluster on the molecular cloud interface . the process of clearing the local environment is still on going , clumps of dark material are seen in projection against the photoionized h ii region ( e.g. sw of the cluster center ) . in 3.1.2 , the extinction to the brightest stars on the cluster sequence was found to be @xmath51 @xmath4 1.07 mag . this value can be taken as representative of the foreground extinction to the cluster , and indicates a @xmath52 magnitude of approximately 18 for w42 # 1 . this is consistent with the non detection of the cluster on the dss plates . a few stars remain after subtracting the `` background '' component from the cmd ( 3.1.1 ) , but these are more likely in the foreground since the extinction toward them is as low as @xmath51 @xmath14 0.3 mag . there are a host of very red objects indicated in figures [ w42i ] , [ cmdrad ] , and [ cmdsub ] . such colors are suggestive of young stellar objects ( yso ) in the context of an embedded stellar cluster emerging from its parent cloud . the observed colors of known populations of pre main sequence stars ( pms ) and more heavily embedded protostars appear to lie on / occupy rather well defined sequences / regions in observational color space ; and their colors , which are redder than usual stellar photospheres have been successfully modeled as arising from excess emission produced by circumstellar disks @xcite and envelopes @xcite . like normal stars , pms objects may be seen through foreground extinction , further reddening their colors . deeply embedded protostars may have colors with or without excess emission , but typically suffer large extinction due to the dense envelope surrounding them @xcite . obviously , protostars too may suffer additional foreground extinction . the @xmath31 vs. @xmath29 color color diagram is most useful in assessing whether any particular star may have excess emission . the diagram distinguishes between normal stellar colors which are seen through a column of dust , hence making them redder , and a contribution which is due to emission ( reprocessed stellar light from circumstellar envelope and/or accretion luminosity from a circumstellar disk ) . @xcite and @xcite have shown that disks can provide a source of excess emission to the normal stellar colors . in figure [ cc ] , we have plotted the classical t tauri sequence ( ctts ) from @xcite along with reddening lines for the interstellar reddening law of @xcite . the former locus may be understood as arising from disk luminosity and projection effects ( e.g , lada & adams 1992 and references therein ) . the near infrared colors of weak lined t tauri stars ( wtts ) are similar to normal stars @xcite . these stars exhibit spectra which suggest they have disks , but the disk contribution to the near infrared colors is negligible . the herbig aebe stars which are higher mass analogs to the ctts show similar colors to the ctts but extend to generally larger @xmath29 excess and with a larger contribution to the colors from circumstellar extinction @xcite . the colors of these objects have been fit by circumstellar envelope models in which the excess emission arises from reprocessed stellar light via dust heating and re - radiation @xcite , or alternatively , from circumstellar disks with central holes @xcite . we also show the reddening lines for a main sequence o star and m giant ( see s3.1 ) which can be taken as approximate guides for the expected colors for normal stars along sight lines to the inner galaxy . the _ black squares _ in figure [ cc ] represent all the stars in figure [ w42i ] for which @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 colors were measured . the _ open circles _ represent the stars in the `` background subtracted '' central cluster ( 3.1.1 ) . the w42 cluster stars ( including w42 # 1 ) occupy a rather tight sequence at modest reddening in figure [ cc ] as expected for young massive stars seen through different columns of obscuring material . at larger reddening ( @xmath29 , @xmath31 @xmath4 1,2 ) , there is a larger dispersion of colors . there are also a number of stars which lie significantly beyond the reddening band for normal stars in the region of pms stars and protostars as discussed above . two of these objects are w42 # 2 and # 3 . spectra for these objects are shown in figure [ spec ] . neither spectrum shows stellar absorption features , though both exhibit emission at br@xmath20 or ( 2.06 ) after background subtraction ( 2 ) . accounting for the foreground extinction to w42 # 1 , both w42 # 2 and # 3 lie in a region of the color color plot occupied by luminous protostars and herbig aebe stars @xcite . @xcite suggest that herbig aebe stars might be recently `` uncovered '' protostars given the large overlap in the color color plot for the two objects . we believe that the position of w42 # 2 and # 3 in the color color plot combined with their emission line spectra , strongly suggests they are also luminous ysos . the absence of absorption features is consistent with veiling due to the excess emission seen in figure [ cc ] . in the case of w42 # 2 , the residual br@xmath20 emission may be due to a circumstellar disk ; spherical or envelope distributions to the circumstellar material are also possible . higher spectral resolution data on the br@xmath20 line in this object will be required to rule out models of one nature or the other . in w42 # 3 , the presence of emission but no br@xmath20 could be due to imperfect subtraction . w42 # 3 has closer neighbors making the subtraction of the background more difficult . if the emission seen in projection toward w42 # 3 is due to a compact h ii region , then the emission may be coming from a region closer to the star than the br@xmath20 , the latter naturally subtracting off better on these angular scales . we plan to obtain @xmath53band spectra of w42 # 2 and # 3 where the excess emission should be less allowing for an improved picture of the nature of the embedded objects which give rise to the emission spectra seen at @xmath2 . there are several other stars with similar or slightly lower brightness indicated in figure [ cmdsub ] , but with apparently normal colors for hot stars . this suggests a mixture of massive objects with and without circumstellar ( possibly disk ) signatures as seen in m17 @xcite . like m17 , the ysos indicate a very young age for the cluster . the situation in w42 may be compared to other stellar clusters in giant h ii regions . for m17 , @xcite report that the vast majority of cluster stars they studied have infrared excesses . this result should be confirmed with higher spatial resolution images ; the photometry presented by @xcite was performed by summing the flux in 4.8@xmath13 diameter apertures on their 0.8@xmath13 images . @xcite note that their data set was analyzed with profile fitting by @xcite who obtain similar results , and @xcite clearly show that at least some of the massive stars in m17 have disk like spectroscopic features . @xcite find far fewer stars with excess emission in the orion trapezium cluster and attribute this to a mixture of older and younger stars . however , @xcite reach a different conclusion regarding the ages of the orion cluster stars , and we will discuss this further in the next section . in w43 ( paper i ) , only a handful of objects appear in the excess emission region of the color color plot and none of the three spectroscopically classified hot stars do . the brightest object in w43 exhibits wolf rayet features in its @xmath3band spectrum suggesting an older age relative to w42 . this is similar to ngc 3603 , r136 , and the arches ( see the discussion in paper i and references therein ) , and the implication is that while such stars may still be core hydrogen burning , they are not on the zams . these comparisons need to account for the fact that the extinction is generally greater in w42 and ( much so ) in w43 , so that many objects are not detected at @xmath0 or @xmath1 and hence do not appear in the color color plot . clearly , high spatial resolution , homogeneous data sets , each analyzed in detail for for completeness at @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 would be useful in assessing the intrinsic fractions of stars with excess emission in embedded clusters in giant h ii regions . without spectra , it is not possible to identify the nature of the remaining objects in the color excess region of figure [ cc ] , though in the context of this young cluster , it is likely that some are pms stars or protostars . it is also clear from figure [ cc ] that some ysos can occupy the same region of color space as normal stars . some of the cluster stars in figure [ cc ] near ( @xmath29 , @xmath31 @xmath4 1,2 ) where the dispersion in color is larger might be a combination of wtts with essentially normal stellar colors and ctts / herbig aebe stars with smaller excess emission , the actual nature depending also on the luminosity of any particular object . alternately , these could be normal main sequence stars . finally , some could be normal k or m giants in the background , though it is unlikely that many are , given the large number of stars in close association with the central region of the cluster and the fact that we have subtracted a background component from the cmd . inspection of figures [ cmd ] and [ cc ] indicates that w42 # 3 has varied in brightness and color between the 1998 and 1999 observations presented here , becoming fainter at @xmath2 and redder . color and brightness variations in ysos can be explained by a combination of changes in the accretion luminosity produced by the circumstellar disk and changes in the extinction toward the source . @xcite monitored a sample of ysos for color changes , finding the slopes of the colors ( measured over day to year timescales ) in the @xmath31 vs. @xmath29 color color diagram were intermediate between the ctts locus ( excess color arising from disk luminosity ) and pure variations along the interstellar reddening lines such as might occur when clumps of obscuring material pass in front of the line of sight to the yso . @xcite found some yso variations were consistent with one or the other effect dominating . the color variation for w42 # 3 appears most consistent with a change in the local extinction . the klf has been used as the basis for mass function determinations in young embedded or obscured massive star clusters . @xcite found that the m17 cluster klf had a slope consistent with the @xcite initial mass function ( imf ) value if the m17 stars were normal main sequence type , but noting that this was difficult to reconcile with their finding that essentially all the m17 cluster stars had infrared excesses . only in the case where such excesses arise in passive disks could their mass function determination still follow from the klf . @xcite present a klf for the trapezium cluster in orion ( m42 ) . they found the slope of the klf to be inconsistent with that for the @xcite initial mass function ( imf ) , hypothesizing that there are substantial numbers of older stars in m42 as well as very young ones . however , @xcite found that the klf in m42 was consistent with a population of only very young stars if pms evolutionary tracks were used instead of assuming the cluster stars were on the main sequence . @xcite show that deuterium burning on the pms can cause peaks in the klf which are a function of age thus producing luminosity functions different from expected if main sequence mass luminosity relations are assumed . more recently , the detailed optical imaging / spectroscopic investigation of @xcite exquisitely details the young main sequence and pms stellar population in the orion trapezium cluster , clearly demonstrating the overall youth of the cluster . @xcite presented a mass function determination for the arches cluster located near the galactic center ( gc ) . they find that the arches cluster may have upwards of 100 o stars and an age of @xmath14 2 myr . using their observed klf and a mean value for @xmath51 , these authors determined the mass function by relating the @xmath2 magnitudes to stellar mass using the @xcite stellar evolutionary models . @xcite find a mass function in the arches which is significantly flatter than @xcite . they attribute this result to the different pre conditions for star formation in the central few hundred parsecs of the galaxy which they argue should favor higher mass stars . this is in contrast to the situation elsewhere in the galaxy and in the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) @xcite . @xcite find from a combination of spectroscopy and imaging that the imf is similar for ob associations and dense massive star clusters ( most notably r136 in the lmc ) and in agreement with a @xcite imf . the preceding discussion indicates that care must be taken in transforming the klf into a mass function , including the effects of pms evolution . in this sense , the determination of a mass function for w42 is premature given the implied young age and lack of transformations between pms models and near infrared colors ( which should include the effects of associated disk emission ) . however , a comparison to the different klfs is warranted . in 3.1 we derived the klf for the inner 30@xmath13 central cluster in w42 and showed that it should be complete to 80 @xmath17 for @xmath54 15 mag . the measured slope of the cumulative counts in the central 30@xmath13 klf ( @xmath54 15 , correcting for incompleteness ) is 0.38 @xmath19 0.016 . if we consider only stars in the background subtracted cmd ( figure [ cmdsub ] , the measured slope ( @xmath54 15 ) is 0.36 @xmath19 0.011 . the slope in our background annulus ( 30@xmath13 to 50@xmath13 , @xmath54 15 , correcting for incompleteness ) is 0.51 @xmath19 0.017 . these values may be compared to the results of @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . for convenience , we compare the power law slope to the _ cumulative _ klf which @xcite also calculated for their data . in m17 , @xcite report a slope of 0.26 , which they claim is consistent with the @xcite imf . we have calculated approximate slopes for @xcite and @xcite from figures of the published luminosity functions ; these are 0.39 @xmath19 0.016 and 0.28 @xmath19 0.013 , respectively . @xcite conducted completeness detailed tests and corrected the published counts . @xcite conducted more rudimentary checks on completeness and report the klf for the magnitude range they believe to be complete . @xcite and @xcite conducted no completeness tests using artificial stars , to the best of our knowledge , though @xcite claim the klf is complete . all the klfs discussed here are defined for the central clusters in the respective star forming regions , and none have been corrected for reddening . thus our comparison is only for the slopes of the klfs and does not account for possible differences resulting from differential reddening . the klf in w42 appears to be more similar to that in orion ( i.e. relatively steep ) than in m17 or the arches . given the likely presence of ysos as discussed above , we may be seeing the effects of pms evolution on the number counts as is the case for the trapezium . both the arches and m17 clusters clearly have more massive stars than are present in the central cluster of w42 or the trapezium @xcite . the apparent klfs in these latter two clusters appear at least superficially similar , though @xcite and @xcite reach rather different conclusions when converting to mass functions . @xcite derive an imf which is much flatter ( @xmath14 factor of 2 ) than @xcite , while @xcite find a mass function which is possibly consistent with @xcite . in 3.2 we classified the spectrum of the bright central star , w42 # 1 , as an early to mid o type ( @xmath37 o5o6 ) . several lines of evidence presented above suggest that the w42 cluster is quite young . if we take w42 # 1 to be on the zams then its apparent brightness would give a distance to the cluster of 2.2 kpc , considerably closer than the radio distance ( 3.7 kpc , see 3 ) . in 3.2 , we argued that the spectrum of w42 # 1 was most similar to those for the dwarf or giant luminosity classes . using the average @xmath55 from @xcite for dwarf stars and colors from 3 , gives 2600@xmath56 kpc . if the giant star @xmath55 from @xcite is used , then the distance estimate becomes 3400@xmath57 pc . the uncertainty in the distance estimate is completely dominated by the luminosity class assumed and the scatter in the intrinsic @xmath55 of o stars ( @xmath19 0.67 mag ) . the uncertainties in the reddening and apparent magnitude are negligible in comparison : a few percent for @xmath58 and 10 @xmath17 for @xmath51 , where the largest part of the uncertainty is in the choice of reddening law ( see mathis 1990 ) . these distance estimates are in agreement with @xcite who argued that w42 ( g25.4se ) was at the near distance given by the radio recombination line velocity and galactic rotation model . depending on the true luminosity of w42 # 1 , the cluster may even be somewhat closer . @xcite estimated the lyc luminosity of w42 to be 8.2@xmath59 assuming the far kinematic distance ( 13.4 kpc ) . adopting the zams distance ( 2.2 kpc ) as indicated by the young nature of the cluster ( stars w42 # 2 and # 3 ) considerably reduces the expected ionizing flux to 2@xmath60 . in figure [ cmdsub ] , we have plotted a zero age main sequence ( zams ) derived from the models of @xcite ( z @xmath4 0.02 ) ; see 3.1.3 . we have placed the zams in figure [ cmdsub ] at 2200 pc , assuming that the w42 # 1 is on the zams . in this case , the ( incomplete ) cluster sequence reaches early k type stars . for the trapezium @xcite claim that the klf shows an intrinsic peak well above the sensitivity of their @xmath3band images . this peak is due to the pms evolution of the lower mass stars and is sensitive to age on the pms . for the close distance to w42 implied if w42 # 1 is on the zams , the similarity found above for the klf of w42 compared to the trapezium then suggests a similar effect on the klf may be at work . i.e. , the fainter magnitudes may correspond to lower mass pms stars . in the present case , we are not claiming to see a real turn over in the klf ( as zinnecker et al . do in orion ) since this occurs where the @xmath3band counts are demonstrably incomplete due to crowding . for a distance of 2.2 kpc , the cluster has a radius of 0.32 pc at 30@xmath13 . the surface density in the inner 10@xmath13 ( figure [ surf ] ) is then within a factor of two for that in the trapezium ( * ? ? ? * @xmath14 6500 pc@xmath61 ) not accounting for the substaintial incompleteness in the present case . w42 is thus quite dense , and this is another indication of its young age @xcite . the zams clearly demonstrates the lack of any sensitivity to temperature in the hot stars at near infrared wavelengths . this means that traditional methods of cluster fitting ( in the observational color magnitude plane ) for age or distance can not be used and only through suitable numbers of infrared spectra ( resulting in and ) will the cluster properties truly emerge . the lack of temperature sensitivity in the near infrared colors does , however , lead to accurate estimates of the foreground extinction . we have presented high spatial resolution @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 images of the massive star cluster at the heart of the giant h ii region w42 . our @xmath3band spectra of three of the brightest four stars in the central 30@xmath13 of the cluster indicate a very young population . the brightest star w42 # 1 is classified as ko5o6 based on the system of @xcite . such stars are typically associated with mk o5o6.5 dwarfs . # 2 and w42 # 3 show no stellar absorption features . this fact , combined with their position in the excess emission band of the @xmath31 vs. @xmath29 color color plot , leads us to classify them as ysos . the klf was computed and compared to other massive star clusters . the klf in w42 appears more similar to that of the trapezium than to the more massive clusters in m17 and the arches . the steepness of the klf in the trapezium has been attributed to the pms stars present there , and it is possible that a similar effect is present in w42 given our spectroscopic and imaging evidence for ysos . our spectrum of w42 # 1 confirms the results of @xcite that w42 ( g25.4se ) can not be at the far kinematic distance . earlier estimates of the lyc output from this giant h ii region must therefore be revised downward ( by @xmath14 an order of magnitude ) . if w42 # 1 is on the zams , as we argue based on the presence of young stellar objects , then the cluster is even closer than the near kinematic distance ( 3.7 kpc ) . we estimate 2.2 kpc . in this case , w42 should not be considered a giant h ii region as defined in 1 . our spectrum of w42 # 1 is not sensitive to luminosity class , though it suggests a dwarf or giant classification . psc appreciates continuing support from the national science foundation . we wish to acknowledge the continuing excellent support received from the ctio mountain staff , particularly from night assistants hernn tirado , patricio ugarte , and alberto zuiga . lrrrrrrr o3 & 51230 & 89.7 & @xmath3010.28 & @xmath305.73 & @xmath304.80 & @xmath300.93 & @xmath300.05 + o4 & 48670 & 65.1 & @xmath309.74 & @xmath305.34 & @xmath304.41 & @xmath300.93 & @xmath300.05 + o4.5 & 47400 & 56.4 & @xmath309.50 & @xmath305.17 & @xmath304.24 & @xmath300.93 & @xmath300.05 + o5 & 46120 & 49.3 & @xmath309.24 & @xmath305.00 & @xmath304.07 & @xmath300.93 & @xmath300.05 + o5.5 & 44840 & 43.6 & @xmath308.97 & @xmath304.82 & @xmath303.89 & @xmath300.93 & @xmath300.05 + o6 & 43560 & 38.9 & @xmath308.70 & @xmath304.62 & @xmath303.69 & @xmath300.93 & @xmath300.05 + o6.5 & 42280 & 34.9 & @xmath308.41 & @xmath304.43 & @xmath303.50 & @xmath300.93 & @xmath300.05 + o7 & 41010 & 31.5 & @xmath308.12 & @xmath304.23 & @xmath303.30 & @xmath300.93 & @xmath300.05 + o7.5 & 39730 & 28.6 & @xmath307.84 & @xmath304.04 & @xmath303.11 & @xmath300.93 & @xmath300.05 + o8 & 38450 & 26.0 & @xmath307.55 & @xmath303.85 & @xmath302.92 & @xmath300.93 & @xmath300.05 + o8.5 & 37170 & 23.7 & @xmath307.28 & @xmath303.68 & @xmath302.75 & @xmath300.93 & @xmath300.05 + o9 & 35900 & 21.6 & @xmath307.01 & @xmath303.51 & @xmath302.62 & @xmath300.89 & @xmath300.05 + o9.5 & 34620 & 19.7 & @xmath306.75 & @xmath303.36 & @xmath302.49 & @xmath300.87 & @xmath300.05 + b0 & 33340 & 17.9 & @xmath306.49 & @xmath303.21 & @xmath302.36 & @xmath300.85 & @xmath300.05 + b0.5 & 32060 & 16.3 & @xmath306.23 & @xmath303.07 & @xmath302.28 & @xmath300.79 & @xmath300.04 + b1 & 21500 & 7.2 & @xmath303.52 & @xmath301.70 & @xmath300.94 & @xmath300.76 & @xmath300.04 + b2 & 18000 & 5.4 & @xmath302.31 & @xmath300.92 & @xmath300.25 & @xmath300.67 & @xmath300.04 + b3 & 15500 & 4.3 & @xmath301.39 & @xmath300.36 & 0.21 & @xmath300.57 & @xmath300.03 + b5 & 13800 & 3.6 & @xmath300.74 & 0.09 & 0.52 & @xmath300.43 & @xmath300.02 + b7 & 12200 & 3.0 & @xmath300.07 & 0.59 & 0.89 & @xmath300.30 & @xmath300.02 + b9 & 10600 & 2.5 & 0.70 & 1.15 & 1.29 & @xmath300.14 & @xmath300.01 + a0 & 9850 & 2.2 & 1.13 & 1.44 & 1.44 & 0.00 & 0.00 + a2 & 9120 & 2.0 & 1.59 & 1.76 & 1.63 & 0.13 & 0.01 + a5 & 8260 & 1.8 & 2.23 & 2.15 & 1.80 & 0.35 & 0.02 + a7 & 7880 & 1.7 & 2.55 & 2.42 & 1.97 & 0.45 & 0.02 + f0 & 7030 & 1.4 & 3.36 & 3.23 & 2.44 & 0.79 & 0.04 + f2 & 6700 & 1.3 & 3.72 & 3.61 & 2.68 & 0.93 & 0.05 + f5 & 6400 & 1.2 & 4.07 & 3.98 & 2.97 & 1.01 & 0.06 + f8 & 6000 & 1.1 & 4.58 & 4.52 & 3.40 & 1.12 & 0.06 + g0 & 5900 & 1.1 & 4.71 & 4.67 & 3.45 & 1.22 & 0.07 + g2 & 5770 & 1.1 & 4.89 & 4.86 & 3.46 & 1.40 & 0.08 + g5 & 5660 & 1.0 & 5.05 & 5.04 & 3.49 & 1.55 & 0.08 + g8 & 5440 & 1.0 & 5.37 & 5.41 & 3.81 & 1.60 & 0.09 + k0 & 5240 & 0.9 & 5.69 & 5.76 & 4.01 & 1.75 & 0.10 + k2 & 4960 & 0.8 & 6.15 & 6.30 & 4.05 & 2.25 & 0.13 +

we present near infrared @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 images and @xmath3band spectroscopy in the giant h ii region w42 . a massive star cluster is revealed ; the color color plot and @xmath3band spectroscopic morphology of two of the brighter objects suggest the presence of young stellar objects . the spectrum of the bright central star is similar to unobscured stars with mk spectral types of o5o6.5 . if this star is on the zero age main sequence , then the derived spectrophotometric distance is considerably smaller than previous estimates . the lyman continuum luminosity of the cluster is a few times that of the trapezium . the slope of the @xmath3band luminosity function is similar to that for the trapezium cluster and significantly steeper than that for the massive star cluster in m17 or the arches cluster near the galactic center .

hep-ph0312008

i was asked to comment on the impact of neutrino oscillation measurements on theory . it is completely clear that recent neutrino oscillation data had big impact on theory , and it will continue to do so . i will remind you about the ongoing impact . then i will list measurements that will have critical impact on theory in the future . let me organize my discussion as `` past , '' `` present , '' and `` future . '' it is useful to recall why theorists had always been interested in the small neutrino masses and their consequences on neutrino oscillation . it is because we are always interested in probing physics at as high energies as possible . one way to probe it is of course to go to the high - energy collider experiments and study physics at the energy scale directly . another way is to look for rare and/or tiny effects coming from the high - energy physics . the neutrino mass belongs to the second category . to study rare and/or tiny effects from physics at high energies , we can always parameterize them in terms of the power series expansion , @xmath0 the zeroth order term @xmath1 is renormalizable and describes the standard model . on the other hand , the higher order terms are suppressed by the energy scale of new physics @xmath2 . possible operators can be classified systematically , which i believe was done first by weinberg ( but i could nt find the appropriate reference ) . with two powers of suppression , there are many terms one can study : @xmath3 the examples here contribute to proton decay , @xmath4 , anomalous triple gauge boson vertex , @xmath5@xmath6 mixing , and the @xmath7-parameter , respectively . it is interesting that there is only one operator suppressed by a single power : @xmath8 after substituting the expectation value of the higgs , the lagrangian becomes @xmath9 nothing but the neutrino mass . therefore the neutrino mass plays a very unique role . it is the lowest - order effect of physics at short distances . this is a very tiny effect . any kinematical effects of the neutrino mass are suppressed by @xmath10 , and for @xmath11 ev which we now know is already too large and @xmath12 gev for typical accelerator - based neutrino experiments , it is as small as @xmath13 . at the first sight , there is no hope to probe such a small number . however , any physicist knows that interferometry is a sensitive method to probe extremely tiny effects . for interferometry to work , we need a coherent source . fortunately there are many coherent sources of neutrinos in nature , the sun , cosmic rays , reactors ( not quite nature ) , etc . we also need interference for an interferometer to work . because we ca nt build half - mirrors for neutrinos , this could have been a show stopper . fortunately , there are large mixing angles that make the interference possible . we also need long baselines to enhance the tiny effects . again fortunately there are many long baselines available , such as the size of the sun , the size of the earth , etc . nature was very kind to provide all necessary conditions for interferometry to us ! neutrino interferometry , a.k.a . neutrino oscillation , is therefore a unique tool to study physics at very high energy scales . gev , compared to the suggested scale of new physics from the neutrino oscillation data.[fig : mssm],scaledwidth=70.0% ] indeed , the recently established neutrino oscillation results @xcite @xmath14 interpreted naively in a `` hierarchical '' mass scheme @xmath15 suggests @xmath16 it is tantalizingly close to the energy scale of apparent gauge coupling unification in the minimal supersymmetric standard model , @xmath17 gev . ( see , fig . [ fig : mssm ] . ) this way , the neutrino oscillation appears to provide us a unique window to physics at very high energies as their `` leading order '' effects . indeed , theoretical estimates based on the seesaw mechanism in the grand unified theories @xcite are practically confirmed ! the last year was an amazing year in neutrino physics . before march , the situation of the solar neutrino data looked like the first plot in fig . [ fig : allsolar1 ] , and there had been overlaps between superk , homestake , and gallium experiments in the lma and low regions , some down in quasi - vaccum . after sno neutral current result in april , the parameter space focused only on the lma region shown in red in the second plot in fig . [ fig : allsolar1 ] . in december , kamland has excluded most of the parameter space as shown in the first plot in fig . [ fig : allsolar2 ] , while its preferred region ( inside the blue contours in the second plot in fig . [ fig : allsolar2 ] ) has consistent overlaps with the that preferred by the solar neutrino data . it was a tremendous convergence from the parameter space over many decades down to factors of a few . it is useful to recall what a typical theorist used to say back around 1990 . * the solution to the solar neutrino problem must be the small mixing angle msw solution because it is so beautiful . * the natural scale for @xmath18 oscillation is @xmath19 because it is the cosmologically interesting range . * the angle @xmath20 must be of the same order of magnitude as @xmath21 because of the grand unification . * the atmospheric neutrino anomaly must go away because it would require a large mixing angle to explain . needless to say , theorists have a very good track record in neutrino physics . indeed , the recent results from neutrino oscillation physics had surprised almost everybody . the prejudice has been that the mixing angles must be small because quark mixing angles are small , and the masses must be hierarchical because both quarks and charged lepton masses are hierarchical . given that the lma is now chosen , all mixing angles are large except for @xmath22 that must be small - ish ( but the current limit is not very strong , @xmath23 ) . the natural question then is if this newly discovered surprising pattern of neutrino masses and mixings require a new symmetry or any special structure to explain . in fact , the big question has always been _ what distinguishes flavor ? _ three generations share exactly the same quantum numbers . yet , they have such different masses . the hierarchy with small mixings means that there is a need for some kind of ordered structure . the `` common sense '' in quantum mechanics is that states with the same quantum numbers should have similar energy levels ( _ i.e. _ masses ) and mix significantly under small perturbations . the observed patterns go against this `` common sense . '' the hierarchical masses and small mixings among quarks and charged leptons had been a puzzle . therefore , there has been a strong suspicion that there is a new set of quantum numbers , _ flavor quantum numbers _ , that distinguish three generations of quarks and leptons . as noether told us , a new quantum number requires a new symmetry , _ flavor symmetry_. this new symmetry must allow the top quark yukawa coupling because it is of the natural size , @xmath24 . on the other hand , all the other yukawa couplings are practically zero ( as opposed to @xmath25 ) , and the flavor symmetry must forbid them . after the symmetry is broken by a small parameter , all the other yukawa couplings become allowed , but suppressed @xcite . the hope is to identify the underlying symmetry based on the data , similarly to what was done by heisenberg ( isospin ) or gell - mann okubo ( flavor @xmath26 ) . indeed , the neutrino data had been already effective in narrowing down the possibilities of flavor symmetries . in table [ tab : afm ] , many proposed flavor symmetries are shown together with their predictions on the mass - squared ratio @xmath27 , @xmath22 , @xmath28 , and @xmath20 , taken from @xcite ( october 2002 ) . in the model sa refers to a degree of accidental cancellation in the 23 sector , that is used to enhance @xmath28 . ] since then , models h@xmath29 , h@xmath30 , and ih ( low ) had been excluded by kamland . .prediction of different flavor symmetries on the neutrino mass - squared ratio and various mixing angles , taken from @xcite.[tab : afm ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] among them , i liked the model a the best , because it is _ mine _ it is called _ anarchy _ , based on the idea that neutrinos are actually normal , while quarks and charged leptons are nt . as i mentioned already , the hierarchical masses and small mixing angles are against the `` common sense , '' while the neutrinos do not seem to have a large hierarchy and mix a lot . maybe the _ lack of flavor symmetry _ can explain the data . indeed , if there is no fundamental distinction among three neutrinos , or in other words if their flavor quantum numbers are all equal , the group theory of three - by - three unitary matrices uniquely determine the probability distribution of mixing angles @xcite . then all three angles , @xmath28 , @xmath20 , and @xmath31 are three random draws from the distribution @xmath32 for @xmath33 . because it is peaked towards the maximal angle @xmath34 , it is very plausible that two draws come out large , while one of them comes down the tail ( but not expected _ way _ down the tail ) . indeed , the kolgomorv smirnov test suggests that the probability that three random draws come out worse than the actual data is 64% , and hence the observed pattern is completely natural if there is _ no _ fundamental distinction among three generations @xcite . on the other hand , @xmath31 is expected to be not too far below the current limit . the one - dimensional ks probability is @xmath35 , and hence we expect @xmath36 at `` 95% cl . '' the size of the cp - violation @xmath37 is distributed as @xmath38 , and hence is expected to be large . based on anarchy , _ i.e. _ , no fundamental distinction among three neutrinos . taken from @xcite.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] having discussed the impact of neutrino data on theory so far , it is clear what will be the critical measurements in the future . * @xmath39 ? if it comes out that precisely maximal , it surely will require a new symmetry . * @xmath40 ? if so , electron - neutrino must have a different flavor quantum number from muon and tau neutrinos . * normal or inverted hierarchy ? most flavor symmetries predict the normal hierarchy , but theorists had been wrong ! * cp violation ? even though the cp violation in neutrino oscillation may not prove the relevant cp violation for leptogenesis , it will at least make it very plausible . after going through the critical measurements , we hope to determine the underlying flavor symmetries behind neutrinos ( and flavor in general ) . then comes an even bigger question : can we understand the dynamics behind the flavor symmetry ? in the case of the strong interaction , isospin and flavor @xmath26 are the flavor symmetries , while the qcd is the dynamics . can we get to the same level ? this question will depend crucially on what we will find at the tev - scale . if it is supersymmetry , the answer may be anomalous u(1 ) gauge symmetry with the green schwarz mechanism from the string theory @xcite . if it is extra dimensions , the answer may be physical dislocation of different particles within a thick brane @xcite . if it is technicolor , the answer may be new broken gauge symmetries at 100 tev scale @xcite . of course one should nt forget lsnd @xcite because no theory fit the data very well . it is true that most theorists do not take the lsnd evidence seriously at this moment , only data will decide . currently all explanations have difficulties : sterile neutrino(s ) @xcite , cpt violation @xcite , lepton - number violating muon decay @xcite . but if any of them will turn out to be true , it will have a huge impact on theory . neutrino oscillation physics has had big impact on theory already . yet , there is a lot more to learn . the ( precise ) measurements of @xmath20 , @xmath31 , the type of hierarchy , and the cp violation , will have critical impact . through these measurements , we hope to determine the symmetries behind the neutrino masses and mixings or flavor in general . in conjunction with data from the energy frontier , we may even have access to understand dynamics behind the flavor . depending on how things will turn out , there may well be even more surprises . this work was supported by the institute for advanced study , funds for natural sciences , as well as in part by the doe under contracts de - fg02 - 90er40542 and de - ac03 - 76sf00098 and in part by nsf grant phy-0098840 . t. yanagida , in _ proceedings of the workshop on unified theory and baryon number of the universe _ , eds . o. sawada and a. sugamoto ( kek , 1979 ) p.95 ; m. gell - mann , p. ramond and r. slansky , in _ supergravity _ , eds . p. van niewwenhuizen and d. freedman ( north holland , amsterdam , 1979 ) . c. d. froggatt and h. b. nielsen , nucl . b * 147 * , 277 ( 1979 ) . g. altarelli , f. feruglio and i. masina , jhep * 0301 * , 035 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0210342 ] . l. j. hall , h. murayama and n. weiner , phys . lett . * 84 * , 2572 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9911341 ] . n. haba and h. murayama , phys . d * 63 * , 053010 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0009174 ] . a. de gouva and h. murayama , phys . b * 573 * , 94 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0301050 ] . l. e. ibaez and g. g. ross , phys . b * 332 * , 100 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9403338 ] . p. bintruy and p. ramond , phys . b * 350 * , 49 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9412385 ] . n. arkani - hamed and m. schmaltz , phys . rev . d * 61 * , 033005 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9903417 ] . e. eichten and k. d. lane , phys . b * 90 * , 125 ( 1980 ) . b. louis , in this proceedings . m. maltoni , t. schwetz , m. a. tortola and j. w. f. valle , nucl . b * 643 * , 321 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0207157 ] . m. c. gonzalez - garcia , m. maltoni and t. schwetz , phys . d * 68 * , 053007 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0306226 ] . b. armbruster _ et al . _ , phys . lett . * 90 * , 181804 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0302017 ] .

neutrino oscillation data had been a big surprise to theorists , and indeed they have ongoing impact on theory . i review what the impact has been , and what measurements will have critical impact on theory in the future . address = school of natural sciences , institute for advanced study , princeton , nj 08540 , [email protected] , homepage = http://hitoshi.berkeley.edu , altaddress = department of physics , university of california , berkeley , ca 94720 , thanks = this work was supported by the institute for advanced study , funds for natural sciences , as well as in part by the doe under contracts de - fg02 - 90er40542 and de - ac03 - 76sf00098 and in part by nsf grant phy-0098840 .

cond-mat0603755

there has recently been much interest in a fascinating topic in the research community , namely _ spin hall effect _ ( she ) . she is such a phenomenon that a transverse spin current is generated when a longitudinal charge current circulates through a sample , and if the sample has a thin strip geometry , the transverse spin current will cause non - equilibrium spin accumulation at both edges of the samplehirsch1999,murakamiscience2003,sinovaprl2004 . such a phenomenon would be much useful in the context of semiconductor spin - based electronics ( _ spintronics _ ) because it might provide an effective way for generating spin currents and/or non - equilibrium spin density in a nonmagnetic semiconductors without use of ferromagnetic metals or ferromagnetic semiconductors , a principal challenge in semiconductor spintronicsdassarma2004,semibook2002 . from the theoretical points of view , such a phenomenon can arise from either _ intrinsic _ spin - orbit ( so ) coupling ( i.e. , spin - orbit splitting of the band structure ) murakamiscience2003,sinovaprl2004 or _ extrinsic _ so coupling ( i.e. , spin - orbit dependent impurity scatterings ) @xcite in a semiconducting material , and correspondingly , the phenomena due to intrinsic so coupling was termed _ intrinsic spin hall effect _ and the phenomena due to spin - orbit dependent impurity scatterings termed _ extrinsic spin hall effect_. from the standpoint of spintronic applications , intrinsic she are more attractive since it is an intrinsic property of a semiconducting material and does not rely on spin - orbit dependent impurity scatterings@xcite . recently two experiments were reported on the observation of she . one is on @xmath0-doped bulk gaas by kato et al.@xcite and the other is on two - dimensional @xmath1-doped gaas by wunderlich et al.@xcite . the phenomenon observed in two - dimensional @xmath1-doped gaas by wunderlich et al . was believed to be an intrinsic spin hall effect since the edge spin accumulation measured in a thin strip of such a system is insensitive to impurity scatterings in the weak impurity scattering regimewunderlichprl2005 , an important feature of intrinsic spin hall effectmurakamiscience2003,sinovaprl2004 . in contrast , the phenomenon observed in @xmath0-doped bulk gaas by kato et al . was believed to have an extrinsic origin ( i.e. , due to spin - orbit dependent impurity scatterings ) since the edge spin accumulation measured in a thin strip of such a system is several order of magnitude smaller compared with the theoretical predictions of refs.[2 - 3 ] . although substantial progresses have been achieved on the detection of spin hall effect , it should be noted that from the theoretical points of view there are still intensive debates on whether intrinsic spin hall effect does can survive in a spin - orbit coupled system . for example , several recent theoretical works have argued that , except for the ballistic transport limit , intrinsic spin hall effect can not survive in a diffusive two - dimensional electron gas with rashba spin - orbit coupling even in the weak impurity scattering limitinoueprb2004,mishchenkoprl2004,rashbaprb2003 , raim05 , dim05 , szhang05 , kha06 . as to the physical understanding of the recent experimental results@xcite , some significant controversies also exist which needs further clarifications . for details please refer to refs.[16 - 25 ] . in this paper , we investigate theoretically another kind of electric - field driven edge spin - accumulation which might occur in a thin strip of a two - dimensional electronic ( electron or hole ) system . from the theoretical points of view , this phenomenon is essentially a _ _ kinetic magnetoelectric effect__@xcite due to boundary - confinement induced spin - orbit coupling ( which will be called _ edge so coupling _ below ) . but very interestingly , it would manifest in a very similar manner as was conceived in an spin hall effect . for example , the electric - field driven edge spin accumulation in a thin 2deg strip due to this phenomenon will be polarized perpendicular to the 2deg plane but along opposite directions at both edges of the strip ; and in the weak impurity scattering regime ( below a certain disorder strength ) the edge spin accumulation will not decrease as the disorder strength increases , thus it can survive even in the diffusive transport regime . these features are very similar to the recently discovered spin hall effect , but the mechanisms involved in this phenomenon are very different from that of the usual spin hall effect from the theoretical points of view . the results obtained in the present paper might provide some new implications to the proper physical understanding of the recent experimental results@xcite . the paper is organized as following : in section ii an edge so coupling model describing the boundary - confinement induced so coupling in a thin 2deg strip will be introduced and some details of the theoretical formalism used in the paper will be briefly explained , and in section iii some numerical results will be presented and discussed . the system considered in the present paper consists of a thin 2deg strip connected to two ideal leads , as was shown in fig.1(a ) . according to the theory of the relativistic quantum mechanics , if the movement of an electron is confined by a spatially non - uniform potential , the spin and orbital degree of freedom of the electron will be coupled together@xcite . the longitudinal direction of the strip will be defined as the @xmath2 direction and the normal of the 2deg plane defined as the @xmath3 direction . for the sake of simplification , we assume that the confining potential is spatially uniform along the longitudinal direction of the strip , i.e. , the spatial variation of the confining potential occurs only in the transverse direction of the strip ( defined as the @xmath4 direction ) . under this assumption , the so coupling due to the transverse spatial variation of the confining potential will take the following form@xcite , @xmath5where @xmath6 are the usual pauli matrices , @xmath7 is the wave vector of electrons , @xmath8 denotes the usual gradient operator and @xmath9 is the transverse confining potential , which depends only on the @xmath4 coordinates . from the effective hamiltonian ( 1 ) one can see that , for an electron moving along the @xmath10 ( or @xmath11 ) direction , the so coupling will tend to force the electron spin to align along the @xmath12 ( or @xmath13 ) direction , depending on the sign of @xmath14 . in the absence of external electric field , the numbers of electrons moving along the @xmath10 and @xmath11 directions are equal and no net spin density can be resulted . however , if an external electric field is applied in the longitudinal direction of the strip , the numbers of electrons moving to @xmath11 direction will be larger than the number of electrons moving to the @xmath10 direction , and hence a net spin density polarized along the @xmath12 or @xmath15 @xmath13 @xmath16 direction might be resulted from the so coupling . such an effect was dubbed the _ kinetic magnetoelectric effect _ in the literatureedelstein . for a 2deg strip , if the strip width is much larger than the lattice constant , one can further assume that the confining potential @xmath9 varies substantially only in a narrow boundary region as was shown in fig.1(b ) . ( we assume that the two boundaries of the srip are located at @xmath17 ) . then the so coupling exists only near both edges of the strip , and due to the symmetry of the confining potential , the so coupling coefficient ( proportional to @xmath18 ) has opposite signs at both edges of the strip , as was shown in fig.1(c ) . thus , the edge so coupling model described by the effective hamiltonian ( 1 ) implies that the electric - field driven spin accumulation will be polarized along opposite directions ( normal to the 2deg plane ) at both edges of the strip , similar to a spin hall effect . this will be confirmed by detailed numerical calculations below . in order to make a comparison with the widely studied intrinsic spin hall effect in a rashba two - dimensional electron gas , we can also include a rashba so coupling in our edge so coupling model . then the total hamiltonian of the 2deg strip will be @xmath19where the second term is the rashba so coupling ( which arises from the inversion asymmetry of the trapping well along the normal of the 2deg plane ) and @xmath20 the rashba so coupling constant . ( @xmath21 is a unit vector along the normal of the 2deg plane ) . a direct use of the hamiltonian ( 2 ) is not convenient if one wants to take into account the effects of impurity scatterings properly , which are very important in the diffusive transport regime . so in our calculations we will transform the hamiltonian ( 2 ) into a discrete form . the discrete version of the effective hamiltonian for the total system ( including both the leads and the 2deg strip ) will read : @xmath22\nonumber\\ & & -\sum_{r_{i}}t_{r_{i}}^{b}[i\psi _ { r_{i}}^{\dag } \sigma ^{z}\psi _ { r_{i}+x}+h.c.]\label{eq : one}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath23 is the hopping matrix element between two nearest - neighbour sites and @xmath24 the lattice constant in the 2deg strip . @xmath25 is the annihilation operators of electrons at the lattice site @xmath26 in the strip . @xmath27 is the annihilation operator of electrons with spin @xmath28 at the lattice site @xmath29 in the lead @xmath1 ( @xmath30 ) . @xmath31 stands for a nearest - neighbor pair of lattice sites across the interfaces between the 2deg strip and the leads . @xmath32 is the on - site energy in the 2deg strip . in a clean system without disorder , one usually sets @xmath32 to be zero . @xmath33 is the rashba so coupling coefficient in the 2deg strip , which is assumed to be site - independent . the last term in eq . ( [ eq : one ] ) stands for the boundary - confinement induced so coupling and @xmath34 is the coupling coefficient , which is site - dependent . the site - dependence of @xmath35 will be determined by the actual form of the transverse confining potential in the 2deg strip . in our calculations we assume a parabolic confining potential near both edges of the strip , as was shown in fig.1(b ) . in such cases , the site - dependence of the edge so coupling coefficient can be expressed as @xmath36where @xmath37 is the width of the strip ( in units of lattice constant ) , @xmath38 is the width of the narrow boundary regions in which the edge so coupling exists , and @xmath39 is the minimum value of the site - dependent edge so coupling coefficient . the sign @xmath40 is different for the two edges , as shown in fig.1(c ) . our calculations will be based on the landauer - buttiker formula . to this end , we first consider the transmission and reflection of an electron incident from a lead . the real space wave function of an incident electron with spin @xmath28 will be denoted as @xmath41 , where @xmath42 denotes the @xmath43th transverse mode with spin index @xmath28 in the lead @xmath1 and @xmath44 the longitudinal wave vector . we adopt the local coordinate scheme for all leads . in the local coordinate scheme , the longitudinal coordinate @xmath45 in the lead @xmath46 will take the integer numbers @xmath47 ... ,@xmath48 away from the 2deg interface and the transverse coordinate @xmath49 take the value of @xmath50 . the longitudinal wave vector @xmath44 satisfys the relation @xmath51 , where @xmath52 is the eigen - energy of the @xmath43th transverse mode in the lead @xmath1 and @xmath53 the energy of the incident electron . including both the incident and reflected waves , the total wave function in the lead @xmath46 has the the following general form : @xmath54where @xmath55 stands for the scattering amplitude from the ( @xmath56 ) mode in the lead @xmath1 to the ( @xmath57 ) mode in the lead @xmath46 . to obtain the scattering amplitudes @xmath58 from the schrdinger equation ( which has now a lattice form and hence there is _ a separate equation _ for each lattice site and spin index ) , we must solve the wave function @xmath59 in the 2deg strip simultaneously . as dealing with usual scattering problems in quantum mechanics , we use boundary conditions to determine the scattering amplitudes @xmath55 . in the lattice formalism , the wave functions in the entire 2deg strip and in the _ first row _ of the leads ( i.e. , @xmath60 ) will be involved in the boundary conditions , which will be determined from the schrdinger equation . because eq.(eq : swavefunction ) is a linear combination of all out - going modes with the same energy @xmath53 , the schrdinger equation is satisfied automatically in the lead @xmath46 , except for the lattice sites in the _ first row _ ( i.e. , @xmath61 ) of the lead which are connected directly to the 2deg strip . the wave function in the _ first row of _ a lead _ _ _ _ ( which are determined by the scattering amplitudes @xmath62 ) must be solved simultaneously with the wave function in the 2deg strip . to simplify the notations , the wave function in the 2deg strip will be defined as a column vector @xmath63 whose dimension is @xmath64 ( @xmath65 is the total number of lattice sites in the 2deg strip ) . the scattering amplitudes @xmath55 will be arranged as a column vector @xmath66 whose dimension is @xmath67 ( @xmath68 is the total number of lattice sites in the first row of the leads ) . from the schrdinger equation for the 2deg strip and for the first row of a lead , one can show that the boundary conditions at the interface between a lead and the 2deg strip can be expressed as the following forms : @xmath69where @xmath70 and @xmath71 are two square matrices with a dimension of @xmath72 and @xmath73 , respectively ; @xmath74 and @xmath75 are two rectangular matrices describing the hopping interaction between the leads and the 2deg strip , whose matrix elements will depend on the actual form of the geometry of the system . the vectors @xmath76****and * * * * @xmath77 describe the contributions from the incident waves . the details of these matrices and vectors will be given elsewherejiang2 . after obtaining all scattering amplitudes @xmath62 from the boundary conditions , we can calculate the charge current in each lead through the landauer - buttiker formula , @xmath78 , where @xmath79 is the voltage applied in the lead @xmath46 and @xmath80 is the chemical potential in the lead @xmath46 , @xmath81 are the transmission probabilities defined by @xmath82 and @xmath83 is the velocity for the @xmath43th mode in the lead @xmath1 . the spin current in each lead can be calculated similarly , @xmath84 $ ] . with the wave function @xmath85 in the 2deg strip at hand , the non - equilibrium spin density in the 2deg strip can also be calculated readily by taking proper ensemble average , and the results can be expressed as @xmath86where @xmath87 denotes the spin density at the lattice site @xmath26 in the 2deg strip . in our calculations we will take the typical values of the electron effective mass @xmath88 and the lattice constant @xmath89nittaprl1997 . the chemical potentials in the leads will be set by fixing the longitudinal charge current density to the experimental value ( @xmath90 ) as reported in ref.[8 ] . the fermi energy of the 2deg strip will be set to @xmath91 throughout the calculations . ( in units of @xmath92 ) in the 2deg strip obtained based on ( a ) the edge edge so coupling model and ( b ) the rashba so coupling model , resepctively . in fig.1(a ) the rashba so coupling coefficient @xmath93 is set to zero and the edge so coupling coefficient @xmath39 is set to be @xmath94 . the width of the boundary regions in which the edge so coupling exists is set to be @xmath95 . in fig.1(b ) the rashba so coupling coefficient @xmath93 is set to be @xmath96 and the edge so coupling coefficient @xmath39 is set to be zero . in both cases , the 2deg strip contains @xmath97 lattice sites . , width=264,height=340 ] in fig.2(a ) we show the typical pattern of the spatial distribution of the electric - field induced nonequilibrium spin density @xmath98 in the 2deg strip obtained based on the edge so coupling model . ( other components of the spin density is zero in the case of the edge so coupling model , which were not shown in the figure ) . we have used @xmath99 lattice sites in total ( including both the leads and the 2deg strip ) in the calculations and the 2deg strip contains @xmath100 lattice sites . from fig.2(a ) one can see that , the spatial distribution of the electric - field induced nonequilibrium spin density in the 2deg strip obtained based on the edge so coupling model manifests in a very similar form as was conceived in a spin hall effect@xcite , i.e. , the spins are polarized perpendicular to the 2deg plane but along opposite directions on both edge of the strip and the spin density has two opposite extrema near both edges . by fixing the longitudinal charge current density to the experimental value ( @xmath101 ) as reported in ref.[8 ] and setting the edge so coupling coefficient to @xmath102 , we found that the spin polarization in the 2deg strip obtained based on the edge so coupling model ( @xmath103 ) has roughly the same order of magnitude as the corresponding experimental values reported in ref.[8 ] . to make a comparison with the widely studied rashba so coupling modelnikolicprl2005 , in fig.2(b ) we have also plotted the spatial distribution of the electric - field induced nonequilibrium spin density @xmath98 in the 2deg strip obtained based on the usual rashba so coupling model . from fig.2(a ) and 2(b ) one can see that the typical patterns of the spatial distribution of the electric - field induced nonequilibrium spin density @xmath104 are very similar in both cases . but it should be pointed out that , in the case of our edge so coupling model , only the @xmath3 component of the spin density is non zero . in contrast , for the case of the usual rashba model , all three components of the spin density are nonzero . ( in fig.2(b ) we have plotted only the spatial distribution of the @xmath3 component of the spin density for comparison ) . another slight difference that can be seen from fig.2(a ) and 2(b ) is that , the transverse spatial distribution of the spin density has a very regularly striped pattern in the case of the edge so coupling model , but for the case of the usual rashba model , the spin - density pattern is not much regularly striped . this slight difference arises from the fact that , in the case of our edge so coupling model , the so coupling exists only in a narrow boundary region near both edge of the 2deg strip ( see the illustration shown in fig.1(b - c ) ) and was assumed to be uniform along the longitudinal direction of the strip . these assumptions lead to a regularly striped spin - density pattern as shown in fig.2(a ) . for the case of the usual rashba model , the so coupling exists in entire the strip ( i.e. , the so coupling coefficient is nonzero everywhere in the strip ) , thus the spin - density pattern in the strip is not much regularly striped . in the case of the edge so coupling model . the lattice sizes of the 2deg strip are chosen as : ( a ) @xmath105 , ( b ) @xmath106 , ( c ) @xmath107 , and ( d ) @xmath108 . the edge socouling coefficent is set to be @xmath109 . fig.3(e ) shows the dependences of the transverse spatial distribution of @xmath110 on the edge so coupling strength , where the lattice size is fixed to be @xmath111 in all these calculations , the width of the boundary region in which the edge so coupling exists is set to be @xmath112 . , width=302,height=377 ] next , we study the dependence of the edge spin accumulation on the strip width and the so coupling strength in the case of the edge so coupling model . because the spatial distribution of the spin density has a regularly striped pattern along the longitudinal direction , we can use an averaged value of @xmath113 , defined by @xmath114 , as a measure of the spin accumulation . in fig.3(a - d ) we plot the profiles of the transverse spatial distribution of the spin accumulation obtained in several different cases with different lattice sizes . from these figures one can see that , @xmath115 oscillates inside the strip and has opposite signs on both edges of the strip , and the magnitude of the spin density will reach a maximum value ( denoted as @xmath116 below ) near both edges of the strip . as the strip width increases , the transverse spatial distribution of the spin accumulation become sharper and sharper near both edges of the strip and the oscillations of the amplitude of the spin density inside the strip tend to be smeared , i.e. , the spin accumulation will be localized near both edges of the strip if the strip width is much larger than the lattice constant . from these figures one can also note that , the order of the magnitude of the spin density near both edges of the strip remains unchanged as the strip width increases , suggesting that the electric - field induced edge spin accumulation due to boundary - confinement induced edge so coupling can survive even in the diffusive transport regime , similar to the phenomenon reported in ref.[8 ] . ( for a 2d semiconductor strip with rashba spin - orbit coupling , it was generally believed that the intrinsic spin hall effect can not survive in the diffusive transport regimeinoueprb2004,mishchenkoprl2004,rashbaprb2003 , raim05 , dim05 , szhang05 , kha06 ) . the dependence of the transverse spatial distribution of the spin density on the edge so coupling strength was shown in fig.3(e ) , from which one can see that the profiles of the transverse spatial distribution of the spin density do not change substantially as the edge so coupling strength varies . finally , we discuss the effects of random impurity scatterings on the electric - field induced nonequilibrium spin density in the case of the edge so coupling model . to include properly the effects of random impurity scatterings , we assume that the on - site energy @xmath117 in the 2deg strip are randomly but uniformly distributed in an energy region @xmath118 $ ] , where @xmath119 is the amplitude of the on - site energy fluctuations , which characterizes the disorder strengthlshengprl2005,nikolicprb2005 . we will calculate the spin density for a number of random impurity configurations and then do impurity average . in fig.4(a - b ) we show the relation between the edge spin accumulation and the disorder strength in both cases of ( a ) the edge so coupling model and ( b ) the usual rashba model , respectively . we have done impurity average over 10000 random impurity configurations for each case . from fig.4(a ) one can see that , for the case of the edge so coupling model , the edge spin accumulation does not decrease ( or may even increase ) as the disorder strength increases in the weak impurity scattering regime ( i.e. , below a certain disorder strength ) and for a fixed longitudinal change current density ( @xmath101 ) , similar to the intrinsic spin hall effect observed by wunderlich et al.@xcite . in contrast , for the case of the rashba model , the edge spin accumulation decreases monotonously as the disorder strength increases even in the weak impurity scattering limit , which can be seen clearly from fig.4(b ) . on the disorder strength @xmath119 in both cases of ( a ) the edge so coupling model and ( b ) the rashba so model . in the weak impurity scattering regime ( below a certain disorder strength ) , the edge spin accumulation _ do not _ decrease as the disorder strength increases in the case of the edge so coupling model . ] the different behaviors in these two models can be understood qualitatively as following . for the edge so coupling model , the so coupling exists only in a narrow boundary region near both edges of the strip ( see the illustration shown in fig.1(b - c ) ) . the electric - field induced nonequilibrium spin density in this model is due to the kinetic magnetoelectric effect but not due to the flow of a transverse spin hall current , thus only those scattering events occurred near both edges of the strip will affect substantially the spin density . in contrast , for the case of the rashba model , the electric - field induced nonequilibrium spin density is due to the flow of a transverse spin hall current@xcite , which will be damped significantly by all random impurity scattering events occurred in entire the strip and hence the edge spin accumulation will be decreased substantially with increasing disorder strength even in the weak impurity scattering limit . of course , because localization effects will become important in the presence of strong impurity scatterings , the electric - field induced nonequilibrium spin density in the case of the edge so coupling model will also be decreased substantially in the presence of strong impurity scatterings , which can be seen clearly from fig.4(a ) . in summary , we have presented a microscopic model calculation for the kinetic magnetoelectric effect in a thin strip of a two - dimensional electronic system due to boundary - confinement induced edge so coupling . we have shown that this effect can manifest in a very similar form as was conceived in a spin hall effect@xcite , and some important features of this effect are similar to the intrinsic spin hall effect observed recently in thin strips of two - dimensional _ p_-doped semiconductors@xcite . the results obtained in the present paper may provide some new implications to the proper physical understanding of the recent experimental results . y. j. jiang was supported by natural science fundation of zhejiang province ( grant no.y605167 ) . l. b. hu was supported by the national science foundation of china ( grant no.10474022 ) and the natural science foundation of guangdong province ( no.05200534 ) .

in a thin strip of a two - dimensional semiconductor electronic system , spin - orbit coupling may be induced near both edges of the strip due to the substantial spatial variation of the confining potential in the boundary regions . in this paper we show that , in the presence of boundary - confinement induced spin - orbit coupling , a longitudinal charge current circulating through a 2d semiconductor strip may cause _ strong _ non - equilibrium spin accumulation near both edges of the strip . the spins will be polarized along the normal of the 2deg plane but in opposite directions at both edges of the strip . this phenomenon is essentially a kinetic magnetoelectric effect from the theoretical points of view , but it manifests in a very similar form as was conceived in a spin hall effect .

astro-ph0609695

strong gravitational lensing is a powerful probe of the large scale properties of the universe @xcite . the well - known physics makes it straightforward to use lensing in cosmological estimates of the dark energy @xcite and the hubble constant @xcite . the gravitational lensing effect depends solely on the mass density of the field , it is also an ideal tool for studies of dark matter in galaxies and clusters of galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? the cosmic lens all sky survey ( class ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , which was conducted in the radio band , is the largest current statistical sample of lensed compact sources . however , the class has only 13 lensed radio sources in its well - defined statistical sample . larger lens samples are critical to using lensed quasars for cosmological and astrophysical tests . optical surveys for lensed quasars are both complementary to radio surveys like the class and likely to produce larger lens samples since only one - tenth of quasars are radio - loud @xcite . our sloan digital sky survey quasar lens search ( sqls ; * ? ? ? * ) is based on the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; * ? ? ? * ) , and its catalog of roughly 100,000 spectroscopically - confirmed quasars ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . so far , the sqls has succeeded in discovering 14 new lensed quasars @xcite , as well as recovering many previously known lensed quasars @xcite . indeed , the number of sdss - discovered lensed quasars is already a significant fraction of all known quasar lenses ( @xmath3 ) . the large number of lenses contained in the sqls and its well - defined selection function means that the lens catalog provided by the sqls will be very useful for statistical studies of strong lensing @xcite . in this paper , we report the discovery of a gravitationally lensed quasar , sdss j133222.62 + 034739.9 ( hereafter sdss j1332 + 0347 ) . the quasar was confirmed to be doubly imaged by a low - redshift early - type galaxy , from observations using the subaru 8.2-meter telescope and the university of hawaii 2.2-meter ( uh88 ) telescope . this paper is organized as follows . the sdss data for sdss j1332 + 0347 , including its selection , is described in [ sec : sdss ] . the follow - up images and spectra are shown in [ sec : image ] and [ sec : spec ] , respectively . in [ sec : model ] we model the lens . finally we summarize our results in [ sec : conc ] . throughout the paper we assume a cosmological model with the matter density @xmath4 , cosmological constant @xmath5 , and hubble constant @xmath6 . magnitudes are measured in ab system . the sdss is a survey to conduct both optical imaging and spectroscopy . it covers about 10,000 square degrees of the sky approximately centered on the north galactic cap with the dedicated wide - field 2.5-m telescope @xcite at the apache point observatory in new mexico , usa . the five broad - band photometric data are taken in imaging surveys @xcite and are reduced automatically by the photometric pipeline @xcite . from the magnitudes , colors , and morphologies of each object , quasar and galaxy candidates are selected as spectroscopic targets @xcite , and then assigned for spectroscopic observations by the tiling algorithm @xcite . the spectra cover the wavelength range from 3800 to 9200 with a resolution of @xmath7 . the astrometric accuracy is better than @xmath8 rms @xcite and the photometric zeropoint errors are less than @xmath9 magnitude over the entire survey area @xcite . most of the data have already become publicly available @xcite . sdss j1332 + 0347 was selected as a lensed quasar candidate from the sdss quasar sample , using the same selection algorithm as that described in @xcite . in this algorithm , the morphological parameters of each quasar are used to select lensed quasar candidates . sdss j1332 + 0347 was also selected by an improved algorithm @xcite whose selection function has been extensively tested , and it is in the well - defined source quasar sample of the sqls for lensed quasar statistics . figure [ fig : sdss_i ] shows the sdss @xmath10-band image of the field under the seeing of @xmath11 . the sdss point spread function ( psf ) magnitudes and the quasar redshift are summarized in table [ tab : sdss ] . the sdss images indicate that the object is more extended than a single star , making it a good lens candidate and a target for higher angular resolution observations . we obtained a 90 sec @xmath10-band image of sdss j1332 + 0347 with the suprime - cam @xcite on the subaru 8.2-meter telescope at mauna kea in seeing @xmath12 on 2003 may 28 . the @xmath10-band image was reduced in a standard way for the suprime - cam data using the neko software @xcite and the sdfred package @xcite . the absolute flux was calibrated using nearby stars in the sdss catalogs . the small differences between the sdss and suprime - cam @xmath10-band response functions are not important here . we also acquired a 720 sec @xmath13-band image of this object with the quick near - infrared camera ( quirc ) on the uh88 telescope in @xmath14 seeing on 2005 february 20 . the @xmath13-band image was reduced in a standard way using iraf , and calibrated using the standard star fs 23 @xcite . the @xmath10 and @xmath13 images are shown in figure [ fig : images ] . taking a closer look at the images , especially the @xmath10-band suprime - cam image , we see two compact sources bracketing an extended elliptical source . indeed , models of the images using a public software , galfit @xcite , consisting of two point sources and an extended object with a de vaucouleurs profile between them fit the data well . we used stars in the images as templates for the psf in this procedure . we also show the observed galaxy after subtracting models for the two point sources , the observed stellar components after subtracting models for the galaxy , and the residuals after subtracting models for the point sources and the galaxy , in the second , third , and bottom panels of figure [ fig : images ] , respectively . we name the two stellar components a and b , where a is the brighter component that lies closer to the galaxy ( separated by @xmath15026 ) , component g. the separation of the two stellar components derived from the @xmath10-band image is @xmath16 , and our relative astrometry is summarized in table [ tab:1332 ] . the stellar components have similar colors of @xmath17 and @xmath18 mag for a and b , respectively , while the galaxy g has a redder color of @xmath19 mag . the photometry of the components is also summarized in table [ tab:1332 ] . these astrometric and photometric properties are typical of known lensed quasar systems ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , and imply that both components a and b are lensed images of a quasar and component g is the lens galaxy . we carried out a spectroscopic observation of sdss j1332 + 0347 using the faint object camera and spectrograph ( focas ; * ? ? ? * ) installed on the subaru 8.2-meter telescope on 2003 june 20 with an exposure time of 900 sec in @xmath14 seeing . the observation was conducted in 2@xmath202 on - chip binning mode , using a @xmath21-width slit aligned along components a and b , with the grism 300b and the filter l600 . this configuration provides a spectrum covering 3,900 to 6,000 with a spectral resolution of r@xmath22 , a spectral dispersion of 2.7 pixel@xmath23 and a spatial pixel scale of @xmath24 . we used iraf to analyze the spectra , extracting two traces corresponding to a blend of image a with the galaxy g and image b , respectively . the two spectra are shown in figure [ fig : spec1 ] . we clearly see broad emission lines redshifted to @xmath25 . on the red wings of the emission lines , we also see an absorption doublet at 4686 and 4728 , which we interpret as h and k absorption lines redshifted to @xmath26 . these strong absorption lines significantly distort the emission lines . it would be helpful to have a cleaner emission line in order to determine the quasar redshifts more accurately , but , the emission lines are the only strong emission lines in the focas spectra . we estimated the quasar redshifts using three approaches ; 1 ) using the whole line profiles ( @xmath27 ) , 2 ) using only the line peaks ( @xmath28 ) , and 3 ) using the whole line profiles after masking and then interpolating through the absorption lines ( @xmath29 ) . the results , summarized in table [ tab : caiii ] , confirm that the two quasars have the same redshifts . we adopt procedure 3 ) for our standard result of @xmath30 as it is likely to be the most reliable . we also verified that the spectrum a+g has little contamination from quasar b by extracting a spectrum at the same distance from component b as component a+g but in the opposite direction . the spectrum , shown in figure [ fig : spec1 ] , has no significant emission , and we conclude that the emission line in the spectrum a+g is due to component a. furthermore , in the spectra of both components a+g and b , we can see @xmath312796,2803 doublet absorption lines and a @xmath322600 absorption line by an intervening object at @xmath33 . the spectral flux ratio between components a+g and b , displayed in the bottom panel of figure [ fig : spec1 ] , indicates that combination of a+g is redder than component b. if we scale the spectrum b by the @xmath13-band flux ratio of @xmath34 between components a and b , and subtract it from the spectrum a+g , then we obtain the residual spectrum shown in figure [ fig : spec2 ] . while the spectrum is noisy , especially around the emission line and towards the blue wavelength region , the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) is consistent with a template spectrum of an elliptical galaxy @xcite at the redshift of the absorption feature , @xmath26 . given the strength of the absorption , we conclude that the seds of components a and b are identical and that component g is an elliptical galaxy at @xmath26 . we used the _ lensmodel _ package @xcite to fit a mass model to the observations of sdss j1332 + 0347 , assuming that the object is indeed a lensed quasar system . we assume the standard singular isothermal ellipsoid ( sie ) model characterized by eight parameters : the einstein radius @xmath35 , ellipticity @xmath36 , position angle @xmath37 , position of the lensing galaxy , the position and flux of the source quasar . since the number of observable constraints is also eight ( the positions of a , b , and g , and the fluxes of a and b ) , the number of degrees of freedom is zero . as expected , we were able to find a model that perfectly reproduces the observables , @xmath38 . the results of the model are presented in table [ table : model ] . we note that the best - fit values for the ellipticity and the position angle , @xmath39 and @xmath40 , are in good agreement with those observed for the galaxy g ( derived using galfit in @xmath10-band image ; see figure [ fig : images ] ) , of @xmath41 and @xmath42 , respectively . einstein radii @xmath35 are related to the velocity dispersions of lensing galaxies , so we can use the faber and jackson relation @xcite to estimate the luminosity of the lens galaxy . from the best - fit value @xmath43 , we estimate that the apparent magnitude of the lens is @xmath44 , assuming the correlation of velocity dispersions and magnitudes of early - type galaxies derived by @xcite . this is again in good agreement with the observed magnitude of the galaxy g , @xmath45 ( table [ tab : massmodel ] ) , implying that galaxy g is responsible for the most of the lens potential . we have presented the extensive follow - up observations of sdss j1332 + 0347 using the subaru telescope and uh88 telescope . we found a bright galaxy ( component g ) between two stellar components ( components a and b ) with similar color in both the subaru / suprime - cam @xmath10-band and uh88/quirc @xmath13-band images . although the emission lines of the two stellar components are distorted by the h and k absorption lines from the bright galaxy at @xmath2 , we can still confirm that the two quasars are at the same redshift , @xmath1 . subtraction of a scaled spectrum of component b from the component a+g leaves a residual that is consistent with the spectrum of an elliptical galaxy redshifted to @xmath26 . the observed luminosity , ellipticity and position angle of the bright galaxy are in good agreement with those expected from a standard lens model . all these results lead us to the conclusion that sdss j1332 + 0347 is indeed a lensed quasar system , where a source quasar at @xmath1 is lensed by a bright lens galaxy at @xmath2 resulting in an image separation of @xmath46 . one peculiar characteristic of the lens is that the brighter component a is closer to the lens galaxy than the fainter component b. we have no difficulty reproducing the flux ratio , and note that such _ inverted _ flux ratios were also observed and easily modeled in the two - image lens he11041805 @xcite . this discovery adds another object to the complete sample of the sdss lensed quasars that can be used to estimate the cosmological model . the brightness of the lens galaxy also makes it a good candidate for dynamical observations ; higher - resolution imaging would allow us to determine more accurately the brightness of the components in this lens system , and spectroscopic observations with better signal - to - noise ratios would also allow us to study the interstellar medium in the lens galaxy in detail . n. i. is supported by jsps through jsps research fellowship for young scientists . this paper is based in part on data collected at subaru telescope , which is operated by the national astronomical observatory of japan . use of the uh 2.2-m telescope for the observations is supported by naoj . i. k. acknowledges the support from ministry of education , culture , sports , science , and technology , grant - in - aid for encouragement of young scientists ( no . 17740139 ) . this work was supported in part by the department of energy contract de - ac02 - 76sf00515 . funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s . department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england . the sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions . the participating institutions are the american museum of natural history , astrophysical institute potsdam , university of basel , cambridge university , case western reserve university , university of chicago , drexel university , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , johns hopkins university , the joint institute for nuclear astrophysics , the kavli institute for particle astrophysics and cosmology , the korean scientist group , the chinese academy of sciences ( lamost ) , los alamos national laboratory , the max - planck - institute for astronomy ( mpia ) , the max - planck - institute for astrophysics ( mpa ) , new mexico state university , ohio state university , university of pittsburgh , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington . lupton , r. , gunn , j. e. , ivezi , z. , knapp , g. r. , kent , s. , & yasuda , n. 2001 , in asp conf . 238 , astronomical data analysis software and systems x , ed . f. r. harnden , jr . , f. a. primini , and h. e. payne ( san francisco : astr . soc . pac . ) , p. 269 ( astro - ph/0101420 ) 700 ) of components a+g ( thin black solid line ) and b ( thick black solid line ) obtained with the subaru / focas in the upper panel . the spectrum of component a+g is shifted by constant to make it visible . a spectrum extracted at the same distance from component b as component a+g , but in the opposite direction , is also shown by the gray solid line . emission lines ( vertical solid line ) in components a and b at @xmath30 , and h and k absorption lines ( vertical dashed line ) of galaxy g at @xmath26 are detected . and absorption lines from an intervening system at @xmath33 are also detected ( vertical dot - dashed line ) . the absorption line doublet ratio of @xmath73 is typical of such systems ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . the spectral flux ratio between components a+g and b is shown in the bottom panel . [ fig : spec1 ] ]

we report the discovery of the two - image gravitationally lensed quasar sdss j133222.62 + 034739.9 ( sdss j1332 + 0347 ) with an image separation of @xmath0 . this system consists of a source quasar at @xmath1 and a lens galaxy at @xmath2 . the agreement of the luminosity , ellipticity and position angle of the lens galaxy with those expected from lens model confirms the lensing hypothesis .

1306.1664

to study the plasma boundary sheath with algebraic models has a long tradition @xcite . in contrast to more complex models which require time - consuming computer simulations , algebraic sheath models execute effectively in zero time . this makes them suitable for many practical purposes , for example for the model based real - time control of plasma processes . of course , the validity of simplified descriptions is always an issue . algebraic sheath models should thus be carefully derived from first principles and thoroughly tested against more complex ( and more physical ) approaches such as _ particle in cell _ ( pic ) simulations . in the present manuscript we propose a novel algebraic model for the electrical behavior of the rf modulated plasma boundary sheath . our investigation is motivated by a critical assessment of the pioneering ( and still `` classical '' ) algebraic sheath models which were proposed by lieberman twenty - five years ago @xcite . in many aspects , our approach is similar : we focus on the rf regime , where the applied radio frequency lies between the plasma frequencies of ions and electrons , @xmath0 , consider only one species of singly charged positive ions without any `` chemistry '' , and assume a one - dimensional cartesian geometry.we endeavor , however , to correct the three fundamental weaknesses of the lieberman models , namely that they are limited to the case of a single driving frequency , to the regime of large applied voltages ( compared to the thermal voltage @xmath1 , with @xmath2 the electron temperature ) , and to the two limiting cases of either highly collisional or completely collision - free motion . in other words , our goal is an algebraic model which captures the plasma sheath behavior in a wide range of frequencies , waveforms , amplitudes , and collisionality . our manuscript is organized as follows : in the next section , we describe our starting point , the `` standard model '' of the rf modulated sheath . after reviewing the lieberman approach , we return to the standard model and employ the _ advanced algebraic approximation _ @xcite to transform it practically without any loss of accuracy into a mathematically simpler form . the outcome of this first step is a valid sheath model of its own , but not yet of a closed form . we thus take a second step , employing a sequence of additional , more drastic approximations . ( a two - step approach is chosen because the intermediate model is better suited to assess the effects of the `` drastic appproximations '' than the original one . ) the result of the second step is our novel algebraic model , which then will be thoroughly tested against pic simulations . some conclusions and final remarks are given in the last section . for the description of the sheath , we employ what may be called the `` standard model '' . it assumes the rf regime , i.e. , that the exciting radio frequency @xmath3 lies between the plasma frequencies of ions and electrons , @xmath0 , and also imposes the length scale ordering @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the debye length , @xmath6 the sheath thickness , @xmath7 the system length , and @xmath8 the ionization length scale . the geometry is one - dimensional ; we consider the spatial interval @xmath9 $ ] , where @xmath10 denotes the location of the electrode and @xmath11 a point far enough into the bulk so that quasineutrality prevails for all phase points.fig . [ fig1schematicplot ] shows the coordinates and other conventions . symbols have their standard meaning . we also define the phase interval @xmath12 $ ] , and the corresponding phase average as @xmath13 the electron part of the model consists of the equation of continuity with ionization and recombination neglected and of the relation of boltzmann equilibrium , @xmath14 & t_{\rm e } \frac{\partial n_{\rm e}}{\partial x } + e n_{\rm e } e = 0 . \label{boltzmannequilibrium}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ions are assumed to experience no modulation . their equation of continuity can be integrated to express the constancy of the ion flux flowing in negative @xmath15-direction , @xmath16 the equation of motion describes the acceleration of ions under the action of the phase - averaged electrical field @xmath17 and the friction due to collisions with the neutral background.in sheath models , the latter term is typically modeled by the assumption of a constant ion mean free path @xmath18 which is valid for strong electrical fields . ( a more general ansatz for the friction gives qualitatively similar results but with less transparent formulas ) . @xmath19 the field is described by poisson s equation , @xmath20 the model is mathematically completed by a set of boundary conditions and constraints . sheath - like solutions as shown in fig . [ fig1schematicplot ] are sought which obey asymptotic quasineutrality and transport equilibrium ( drift regime ) for @xmath21 and electron depletion for @xmath22 . ( together , these assumptions remove all degrees of freedom of the ode system except one . ) the rf modulation of the sheath is introduced by prescribing the total current density @xmath23 , which is divergence free and a spatial constant in 1d . we express it as the sum of a temporally constant part @xmath24 and a periodic , average free , not necessarily harmonic part @xmath25 , @xmath26 this relation can be cast in a more explicit form . we define the sheath charge per area @xmath27 as the integral of the charge density between the electrode @xmath28 and the bulk point @xmath11 , @xmath29 integrating poisson s equation from @xmath28 to @xmath11 yields a relation between @xmath27 and the electrical field at the electrode ; provided that the field at @xmath11 can be neglected : @xmath30 the electron current @xmath31 at the electrode can be found by the hertz - langmuir formula which expresses the flux as the product of the projected thermal speed and the local density @xcite.taking into account an effective sticking factor @xmath32 which may be , contrary to common belief , not equal to unity @xcite , we set : @xmath33 integrating the boltzmann relation from @xmath28 to @xmath11 , we can express the electron density at @xmath28 in terms of presumably constant density at @xmath11 and the sheath voltage @xmath34 : @xmath35 here , the sheath voltage is defined as the field integral from @xmath28 to @xmath11 , with the negative sign reflecting the fact that the field is oriented into the negative @xmath15-direction : @xmath36 together , these assumptions gives the current balance as follows , which is the justification for the popular diode model @xcite of the plasma boundary sheath ( fig . 2 ) : the total current @xmath23is the sum of a capacitive part ( represented by a nonlinear capacitor ) , an exponential electron part ( represented by a diode ) and a constant part ( represented by a current source ) : @xmath37 taking the phase average of the current balance relation yields a representation of the dc current characteristics of the sheath : @xmath38 when the electrode is current - free or `` floating '' , the dc current density @xmath39 is equal to zero . to determine the corresponding sheath condition , one must solve @xmath40 in the fluctuating part of the current balance , we can neglect the ( in comparison with the rf current ) typically small electron current @xmath41 and write @xmath42 it is advantageous to split @xmath43 into an average @xmath44 and a fluctuating , average - free part @xmath45 . the average sheath charge defines the mean sheath thickness @xmath46 via @xmath47 for the fluctuating sheath charge , we get the explicite representation @xmath48 we take the view that the fluctuating charge @xmath45 is the control parameter of the modulation and define @xmath49 and @xmath50 as its minimum and maximum values within the phase cycle @xmath12 $ ] . for vanishing modulation , both are zero , otherwise @xmath49 is negative and @xmath50 is positive . their absolute values are different unless @xmath45 is symmetric . as additional characterization we introduce the effective modulation amplitude @xmath51 it is advantageous to write the model dimensionless . however , some care must be taken , as an unfortunate choice of units may obscure the scaling relations . we take as basis the voltage scale @xmath52 of the sheath ; for weak modulation it is several @xmath1 , for strong modulation it is equal to the applied voltage . the other units are calculated using collisionless relations . altogether , we make the following substitutions , with the prime ( which is dropped soon)denoting dimensionless quantities : @xmath53 we also introduce dimensionless numbers ( and their typical values ) . the ratio of the length scale to the ion mean free path , with @xmath54 absorbed , is the collisionality @xmath55 , @xmath56 the ratio of the electron voltage to the voltage scale is the thermal parameter @xmath57 , @xmath58 and the combination of the electron sticking factor @xmath32 and the square root of the mass ratio , with @xmath59 absorbed , is the effective sticking parameter @xmath60 , @xmath61 another parameter , the ratio of the rf current to the dc current , does not appear explicitly , but it should be noted that it is typically large ( except for non - modulated sheaths ) : @xmath62 the dimensionless equations then consist of several subgroups : the stationary ion model involves the phase - averaged field @xmath17 , @xmath63 the electron model consists of boltzmann s equilibrium and poisson s equation , @xmath64 it is parametrical modulated by the condition that the fluctuating sheath charge follows a given time function @xmath45 which is related to the fluctuating rf current @xmath65 , @xmath66 the position of the electrode @xmath28 relative to the solution is determined by chosing a particular point of the dc ( phase - averaged ) current voltage curve @xmath67 where the sheath voltage is calculated as @xmath68 for the particularly important case of a floating electrode or wall , the current relation reduces to the condition for a current - free sheath , @xmath69 once the electrode position is known , also the average sheath charge can be calculated : @xmath70 the problem posed by the listed equations is quite intricate . the two subsystems alone are nonlinear differential equations , but they are coupled by the operation of phase averaging.altogether , the sheath problem thus amounts to a system of nonlinear integro - differential equations for which no analytical solutions are known . of course , numerical solutions of the system can be easily constructed , but this misses the point of an analytical treatment . clearly , a `` short - cut '' is needed which allows to construct explicit expressions for the phase - averaged quantities @xmath71 or @xmath72 . ( see fig . [ shortcut ] ) . in his pioneering work , lieberman proposed such a shortcut @xcite . his approach consisted of three approximations and specializations : first , he imposed godyak s step model @xcite . this approximation rests on the fact that the thermal electron voltage @xmath1 is small compared to the applied sheath voltage @xmath34 ; i.e. , in our notation , that the thermal parameter @xmath57 is small . it replaces the boltzmann relation for the electrons by the assumption that the density of the electrons is zero below the electron edge @xmath73 and equal to the ion density above : @xmath74 the value of @xmath73 is related to the sheath charge @xmath27 ; @xmath75 substituted into poisson s equation , the step model allows to calculate the electrical field , where the integration constant is chosen so that the field vanishes at the step : @xmath76 lieberman s second simplification was that he did not study the full range of collisionality but only the limiting cases of completely collisional and completely collisionless dynamics.in our notation , they are given by the ion equations of motion or instead of .both assumption enable the explicit evaluation of the ion model by establishing an algebraic relation between the ion speed and either the averaged potential @xmath77 ( in the collisionless case)or the averaged electrical field @xmath71 ( in the collisional case ) : @xmath78 and , finally , focussed on the case of a single harmonic excitation , @xmath79 lieberman s models were quite successful , and , to this date , they represent the standard for any algebraic sheath model . they have , however , shortcomings which directly arise from the assumptions mentioned above : * the restriction on single - frequency excitation is limiting . for technological reasons , double and triple frequency plasmas have become frequently employed in the last years . moreover , it is now known that even harmonically excited discharges may exhibit very unharmonics rf currents @xcite . * equally limiting is the concentration on the cases of purely collisional and purely collisionless ion motion . many technical plasmas are operated in the transition regime , where the mean free path and the sheath thickness are comparable @xcite . * the adoption of the godyak step model implies that all `` thermal effects '' are neglected . this is especially serious when the excitation amplitude is small ; in particular the phenomena of a finite sheath thickness and a non - vanishing `` floating potential '' at zero modulation amplitude can not be captured @xcite . these deficiencies are of very different nature . the assumption of a sinusoidal excitation is merely a matter of convenience . the generalization to more complex current wave forms is easily possible ( if cumbersome ) ; several models which cover this point were published @xcite . the restriction to the limit cases of collisionality is more severe ; the derivations of lieberman require explicite relations which express the ion density either in terms of the potential ( collisionless case ) or in terms of the field strength ( collisional case ) . a direct generalization of the derivations to the transitional regime is not possible . however , the most critical assumption is that of the step model . three recent publications have analyzed the situation in detail @xcite . it was found that expression performs well in the electron depletion region but badly in the transition zone and the quasineutral zone where it misses the ambipolar field . this deficit causes a divergence of the ion density density at the sheath edge but is of minor importance for the value of the sheath voltage . the error caused by , however , is more critical : it can not capture the residual electron population in the depletion region which is needed to evaluate the conditions or @xmath80 . lieberman was thus forced to identify the electrode position @xmath28 with the minumum value of the electron step @xmath81 . the analysis of @xcite found that the sheath voltage error caused by this uncertainty of the sheath shickness can be substantial . publications @xcite did not only analyze the problems caused by the godyak step model but proposed also a cure . based on a better approximate for all practical purposes : exact solution of the boltzmann - poisson problem and , the so - called _ advanced algebraic approximation _ ( aaa ) was constructed . it is expressed in a new system of _ charge coordinates _ , where the integration limit @xmath46 was defined in : @xmath82 the approximation consists of expressions for the electrical field and the electron density , all expressed in terms of the difference of @xmath83 to the sheath charge @xmath84 , and the local values of the ion density and its derivative . ( the dependence on the dimensionless numbers @xmath57 , @xmath55 , and @xmath60 is suppressed in the notation . ) the special functions @xmath85 and @xmath86 which appear in and are defined in terms of certain differential equations ; they are smooth and in fact analytical . we call them `` switch functions '' ; they switch the behavior of the field and density expressions from electron depletion to quasineutrality ( see figs . [ xiplot ] and [ sigmaplot ] ) . finite values of @xmath57 lead to a thermal `` softening '' of the transition ; the limit @xmath87 recovers the step model : @xmath88 the aaa allows also an easy calculation of the phase - averages of the field and the density . it is useful to define a further set of functions @xmath89 and @xmath90 , also termed `` switch functions '' , which depend functionally on @xmath45 but only locally on @xmath83 and @xmath91 : @xmath92 & \gamma_1\left(q , n_{\rm i},\{\tilde{q}\}\right ) = { 1\over 2\pi}\int_0^{2\pi } \xi_1\!\left(\frac{q-\tilde{q } } { \sqrt { \vartheta n_{\rm i}}}\right)\ , dt , \\[1.0ex ] & n_0\left(q , n_{\rm i},\{\tilde{q}\}\right ) = { 1\over 2\pi}\int_0^{2\pi } \sigma_0\!\left(\frac{q-\tilde{q } } { \sqrt { \vartheta n_{\rm i}}}\right)\ , dt , \\[1.0ex ] & n_1\left(q , n_{\rm i},\{\tilde{q}\}\right ) = { 1\over 2\pi}\int_0^{2\pi } \sigma_1\!\left(\frac{q-\tilde{q } } { \sqrt { \vartheta n_{\rm i}}}\right)\ , dt \ , \frac{1}{\sqrt{\vartheta n_{\rm i}}}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in terms of these special functions , the phase averages of the electrical field and the electron density are local functions of @xmath83 and @xmath93 and linear forms in the derivative : @xmath94 & { \bar n}_{\rm e}\left(q , n_{\rm i},n_{\rm i}^\prime,\{\tilde{q}\}\right ) = n_0\left(q , n_{\rm i},\{\tilde{q}\}\right ) n_{\rm i } + \vartheta n_{\rm i } { \partial n_{\rm i}\over\partial q } \,n_1\left(q , n_{\rm i},\{\tilde{q}\}\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the ion model can also be written in charge coordinates . using the equation of continuity to express the velocity in terms of the density , the equation of motion reads @xmath95 inserting the field expression and sorting the derivatives finally results in the sheath equation , a quasi - linear differential equation of first order for ion density @xmath93 : @xmath96 the properties of the sheath equation were discussed in @xcite . its most important feature is its inner singularity at a point @xmath97 where the lhs and the rhs simultaneously vanish . this singularity which was identified as a `` collisionally modified bohm point '' acts as an inner boundary condition and fixes the remaining degree of freedom of the sheath equation.the resulting ion density @xmath98 is a function of @xmath83 and a functional of the curve @xmath99 . subsequently , the electrode position can be found from the dc current - voltage curve ; @xmath100 under floating conditions one has to solve : @xmath101 the average sheath charge is the negative of that value , @xmath102 finally , the electrical potential across the sheath is calculated as @xmath103 as the last step , one can construct transformation back into physical coordinates , @xmath104 for all practical purposes , the formulas given in the last chapter amount to an exact solution of the `` standard sheath model '' . numerical studies confirmed that the deviation from the exact solution is in the percentage range ( densities ) or below ( sheath voltage ) @xcite . however , the model is not yet algebraic , one must still solve the differential equation . in this section , we will employ further approximations to achieve an algebraic form . we start by recalling that the presence of the ambipolar field in enables the solution to cross the critical point and enter the bulk regime . neglecting this contribution confines the model solely to the sheath , but the resulting error in the sheath voltage is only of order @xmath57.we may safely neglect also other thermal effects in the representation of the sheath field . the resulting model is exactly the step approximation : @xmath105 the phase average of @xmath106 yields the step function version of the switch function @xmath107 , @xmath108 the sheath differential equation now assumes a much simpler form . it is advantageous to express it in terms of the ion velocity , and to set as the now necessary boundary condition the ion velocity at @xmath50 equal to the collisionally modified bohm velocity @xcite : @xmath109 the step function approximation can also be used for the sheath voltage , leading to @xmath110 unfortunately , a similar approximation for the current conditions or is not feasible . simply neglecting thermal effects taking @xmath87 would render the conditions meaningless ; any approximate evaluation would be instable due to the exponential nature of the relations . we thus keep for the moment the conditions or , and will look later for other possibilities to determine the location of the electrode position @xmath111 . in the form displayed above , the ion velocity @xmath112 or density @xmath93 are still given in terms of the solution of a nonlinear differential equation . we first focus on the two limiting cases . the collision - free limit equation is as follows , with the boundary condition now derived from the conventional bohm condition @xmath113 we define the function @xmath114 as the negative integral of @xmath115 , @xmath116 and get thus the algebraic solution @xmath117 the collisional limit is also algebraic and can be solved directly , @xmath118 the general case of the ion model does not have a similarly simple algebraic solution but its physical content is transparent : the electrical force is balanced by inertia and friction , and thus dominated by whatever is larger . numerical experiments have shown that it is reasonable to employ the approximation of a quadratic harmonic mean , @xmath119 together , the described equations constitute an algebraic (= `` closed form '' ) model to calculate the time - resolved sheath voltage @xmath34 . however , it is not yet very convenient to use , owing to the presence of the functions @xmath120 and @xmath121 which depend not only on the variable @xmath83 but also functionally on the modulation @xmath99 . we therefore implement a sequence of additional approximations which replace this dependence with a dependence on the modulation amplitude defined in which reads in dimensionless units @xmath122 first , consider the function @xmath123 . it functionally depends on the charge @xmath45 , but all curves yield the same qualitative behavior . it is @xmath124 for @xmath125 , zero for @xmath126 , and monotonically decreasing with positive curvature in between . we replace this family of functions by a qualitatively similar but mathematically simpler model which exhibits the same asymptotic behavior as the originals for @xmath127 and matches the branches smoothly with an interpolating parabola of positive curvature : @xmath128 \displaystyle -\frac{\left(\sqrt{3}\delta q - q\right)^2}{4 \sqrt{3 } \delta q } & |q| \leq \sqrt{3}\delta q,\\[1.0ex ] 0 & q > \sqrt{3}\delta q. \end{array } \right . \label{gammamodel } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the choice of matching points minimizes the deviation to the original family of functions , in the sense that the integral over the difference vanishes , @xmath129 numerical experiments have convinced us that form is a reasonable approximation of @xmath130 for all `` generic '' charge modulation functions @xmath131 . ( to elaborate the point : the formula is exact when @xmath131 is a saw tooth ; it is generally very satisfactory when the fundamental in @xmath131 is dominant . it is less appropriate for square wave or pulsed modulation ; in this case the development should be carried out with the original formulas and . ) once adopted , approximation can be used to define @xmath132 \displaystyle\frac{\left(\sqrt{3 } \delta q - q\right)^3}{12 \sqrt{3}\delta q } & |q| \leq \sqrt{3}\delta q,\\[1.0ex ] 0 & q > \sqrt{3}\delta q. \end{array } \right . \label{pimodel}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the ion velocity @xmath133 and the ion density @xmath134 are then @xmath135 and the charge - voltage relation of the sheath is : @xmath136 formula is nearly the desired result , an algebraic description of the sheath behavior . unfortunately , however , the integral can not be carried out analytically . we therefore resort to an approximate evaluation in the spirit of kepler s barrel rule : namely , we interpolate the function @xmath137 by a quadratic parabola , with nodes specified at @xmath138 , @xmath139 , and @xmath99 . inserting this parabola , evaluating the integral , and substituting @xmath140 and @xmath141 finally leads to the desired algebraic formula for the sheath voltage @xmath142 it may be helpful to view our results in dimensional units . we define the quantity @xmath143 as the absolute value of the ion velocity @xmath144 and obtain the following , where @xmath83 and @xmath145 have units @xmath146 and @xmath147 and @xmath148 are litterally unchanged from above : @xmath149 the inverse of this quantity , times the ion flux , is the ion density @xmath150 these functions allow to explicitly express the dc current characteristics of the sheath . employing formula in leading order in @xmath57 , we get @xmath151 for a practical evaluation of this expression it may be useful to know that the switch function @xmath152 can be approximated as @xmath153 once the charge coordinate position @xmath138 of the electrode is known , for instance by imposing the floating condition @xmath154 , one can set the average sheath charge @xmath155 and finally calculate the desired charge - voltage relation from @xmath156 we now compare our algebraic charge - voltage relation with the predictions of a more fundamental modeling approach , namely a fully self - consistent particle - in - cell simulation . pic is truly kinetic , i.e. , makes no priori assumptions on the particle distribution functions , and is therefore particularly suited for an investigation of the boundary sheath where both ions and electrons are far from equilibrium . we employ _ yapic _ , an explicite 1d3v version of the pic algorithm which is described in @xcite . the discharge gas is argon , at @xmath157;the pressure values are @xmath158 ( nearly collisionless regime ) , @xmath159 ( transition regime ) , and @xmath160 ( collisional regime ) . for all pressures values , both a single frequency and a double frequency excitation are studied see table 1 for details of the simulation parameters . in all simulation runs , the net dc current is assumed to be zero , i.e. , the boundary sheaths are driven under floating conditions . the pic simulation gives access to all relevant quantities . [ pic1fresults ] ( one frequency ) and [ pic2fresults ] ( two frequencies ) show the ion density @xmath161 and the phase - averaged electron density @xmath162.the charge - voltage relations [ qvresults1f ] and [ qvresults2f ] can be obtained from the monitoring the electrical field at the electrode and the integral of the field from the electrode to the sheath edge . further quantities taken from the pic simulations are the mean ion flux @xmath163 at the electrode , the phase - averaged sheath charge @xmath44 , and the electron temperature @xmath2 . based on these quantities , the charge - voltage characteristics of our algebraic model are calculated and plotted into the same figures [ qvresults1f ] and [ qvresults2f ] . we apply two different procedures . in the first one ( dashed ) , we use all quantities of the pic simulation ; in the second ( dotted ) , we do not utilize the pic sheath charge @xmath44 but evaluate the floating condition . the agreement is excellent . when all information from pic is used , the characteristics of the collision - less and the collisional case are nearly exactly reproduced . the agreement is less spectacular in the transition regime ; our interpolation is only a rough representation of the complicated ion dynamics in this regime . when the pic information in @xmath44 is not used , the agreement is only slightly worse ; except for the one frequency/ @xmath164 case where the calculation of the average sheath charge ( or electrode position ) shows a considerable offset . the same conclusion is also suggested by the phase - resolved voltages of figs . [ voltage0p1pa ] , [ voltage1pa ] , and [ voltage10pa ] . a closer inspection of the pic data reveals that the deviation at 1f/@xmath164 is caused by a highly non - maxwellian electron energy distribution due to stochastic heating . in this manuscript , we have presented a novel algebraic model for the electrical behavior of rf modulated plasma boundary sheaths . our investigation was motivated by a critical assessment of the pioneering lieberman models @xcite and shared many of their assumptions : the focus on the rf regime , where the applied frequency lies between the plasma frequencies of the ions and the electrons , @xmath0 , the concentration on only one species of singly charged positive ions with `` chemistry '' ( ionization ) neglected , and the assumption of a one - dimensional cartesian geometry . we have corrected , however , the three fundamental weaknesses of the lieberman models , namely their limitations to a single driving frequency , to the regime of large applied voltages ( compared to the thermal voltage @xmath1 ) , and to the two cases of either highly collisional or completely collision - free motion . our new algebraic sheath model captures the plasma sheath dynamics for a wide range of frequencies , waveforms , amplitudes , and collisionality . a comparison with self - consistent particle - in - cell simulations has demonstrated the excellent accuracy of our final expression . we believe that our model will find many useful approcations in the future . the authors gratefully acknowledge support by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft via sfb - tr87 and the ruhr - university research school . -axis points from the electrode @xmath10 into the bulk . ( note that several other conventions are used in the literature . ) shown are the stationary ion density @xmath161 ( solid ) and the momentaneous electron density @xmath165 at a certain rf phase @xmath166 ( thin ) . the average electron density @xmath167 is dashed . also shown are the momentaneous location @xmath73 of the equivalent electron edge , and the minimal and maximal values of that quantity , @xmath81 and @xmath168 . note that the value of @xmath81 is generally different from the position of the electrode , and that @xmath168 is only an approximate indicator of the sheath edge.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] l*7cr case & 1f/0.1pa & 1f/1pa & 1f/10pa & 1f/0.1pa & 1f/1pa & 2f/10pa & units + pressure & 0.1 & 1 & 10 & 0.1 & 1 & 10 & pa + mean free path & 0.078 & 0.0078 & 0.00078 & 0.078 & 0.0078 & 0.00078 & m + electrode gap & 0.1 & 0.05 & 0.05 & 0.01 & 0.05 & 0.05 & m + amplitude 13.56 mhz & 400 & 200 & 200 & 200 & 100 & 100 & v + amplitude 27.12 mhz & & & & 200 & 200 & 200 & v + ion flux & 1.85 & 1.48 & 1.58 & 2.55 & 1.47 & 1.35 & @xmath173 + electron temperature & 13 & 4.3 & 2.5 & 13 & 4.3 & 2.5 & ev + @xmath44 from pic & 2.19 & 1.83 & 2.72 & 2.30 & 1.65 & 2.28 & @xmath174 + @xmath175 from floating condition & 1.94 & 1.79 & 2.78 & 2.28 & 1.60 & 2.35 & @xmath174 + for the 1f and 2f cases at a pressure @xmath176 . the pic results are solid , the results from the algebraic model with @xmath44 taken from pic are dashed , those obtained with the floating condition are dotted.,scaledwidth=100.0% ] for the 1f and 2f cases at a pressure @xmath177 . the pic results are solid , the results from the algebraic model with @xmath44 taken from pic are dashed , those obtained with the floating condition are dotted.,scaledwidth=100.0% ] for the 1f and 2f cases at a pressure @xmath178 . the pic results are solid , the results from the algebraic model with @xmath44 taken from pic are dashed , those obtained with the floating condition are dotted.,scaledwidth=100.0% ]

the boundary sheath of a low temperature plasma comprises typically only a small fraction of its volume but is responsible for many aspects of the macroscopic behavior . a thorough understanding of the sheath dynamics is therefore of theoretical and practical importance . this work focusses on the so - called `` algebraic '' approach which strives to describe the electrical behavior of rf modulated boundary sheaths in closed analytical form , i.e. , without the need to solve differential equations . a mathematically simple , analytical expression for the charge - voltage relation of a sheath is presented which holds for all excitation wave forms and amplitudes and covers all regimes from the collision - less motion at low gas pressure to the collision dominated motion at gas high pressure . a comparison with the results of self - consistent particle - in - cell simulations is also presented .

1510.03589

searching 3d data cubes is not a straightforward task . it is non - trivial to design a source - finding algorithm which is flux - limited , and complex , spurious structures can be difficult to automatically distinguish from astronomical sources . while visual inspection of the data can , through the extremely powerful capabilities of human pattern recognition , often overcome the problem of distinguishing real from spurious sources , it suffers from being subjective . it is also , traditionally , an extremely slow and laborious process , to the point where the scientific returns are diminished : weeks ( or even months ) spent searching a data cube could be more usefully employed in analysing trends in the data . i here focus on neutral hydrogen ( hi ) data cubes . developments in multibeam single - dish surveys ( e.g. hipass , @xcite ; alfalfa , @xcite ) have made very large 3d data sets a reality . smaller , more sensitive surveys such as ages ( the arecibo galaxy environment survey - @xcite ) possess similar problems of source extraction . although the total number of sources is lower , the source density is higher , as shown in table [ tab : surveys ] . this is necessarily a crude comparison ( since not every survey provides access to the raw data , accurately estimating what fraction of the data the sources occupy is impossible ) , but suffices to demonstrate the very substantial increase in the discovery potential of hi surveys over the last decade or so . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] although once the data is loaded the display frame rate is high , initially converting that data into the blender - readable png images and loading them into blender is much slower than loading in a cube in , say , _ kvis_. on the hp elite , the larger cube took a mere 1 second to load in _ kvis_. _ kvis _ , which was designed from the ground up as a fits viewer , is far superior in this regard to frelled , which is essentially a hack to load fits data into a program never designed with astronomers in mind . i discuss the consequences of this in section [ sec : sourcefinding ] . as described above , since frelled s loading times are so much greater than for _ kvis _ , it is not necessary to load in all three projections of the data cube - the user can select only one or two , if they wish to save time and/or memory . i account for this in the benchmarks table . the `` loading time '' column shows the time to first load in the data ( i.e. convert the cube into png images and then display one projection ) plus the extra time needed when switching to a different projection . note that this delay _ only occurs once _ as the images must be loaded into gpu memory when the user switches the view to a different projection for the first time - after that there is no delay in rotating the view from one projection to any other . once the user has converted the data with a satisfactory transfer function and altered the display parameters appropriately , they can then save the .blend file , which preserves these display settings . the `` reloading time '' refers to the time needed to re - open this file , which does not require converting the fits data into png images . both the time to render an image ( using blender s internal raytracing engine ) and the realtime display frame rate depend ( by a factor of a few ) on the data being displayed and the orientation of the view . moving the viewpoint closer to the data causes a drop in frame rate and an increase in render time . for the benchmark table i chose a viewpoint in all cases where the whole of the data was just about visible - zooming in reduces the frame rate to as low as 5 f.p.s . , but moving slightly further out increases this to 20 f.p.s . even in the the slowest case . since the larger cube is asymmetrical , the benchmark table reflects this in the non - linear difference in times for the different projections . i only give the render times for the longest projection in each case . i chose to render a 500@xmath3500 pixel image without oversampling using 7 threads , with a field of view equivalent to half the extent of the data . it is an unfortunate necessity to render the images rather than simply record screenshots , since this is very much slower . at 3 minutes per frame , a 10 second animation ( at standard 25 f.p.s . ) would take 12.5 hours to render . while blender does have the ability to record screenshots , this feature does not function correctly in 2.49 and not usable for our purposes ( see section [ sec : future ] ) . note that all of the above benchmarks are for the standard 3d display mode . in 2d mode , in which only one slice of the data is displayed ( and loaded into gpu memory ) at a time , loading and rendering speeds improve dramatically . for the larger cube on the hp elite , using all three projections ( but only one colour map since transparency is not necessary in the 2d view ) , loading speed actually increases to 7 min 33 seconds ( but see below ) . however , reloading speed is slashed to a mere 1 second , competitive with _ kvis_. rendering speed is reduced to 0.25 seconds per frame ( the display frame rate remains above 25 f.p.s for the largest cube shown at any angle and zoom level ) . since frelled preserves the original fits file and generates png images , this has the disadvantage of generating a ( potentially ) large amount of extra data . for the 1.5 gb vla fits file we use for benchmarking ( see section [ sec : bench ] ) , an additional 1.7 gb of png data was generated . however , this is a worst - case scenario in which two maps were used for all three projections on a very large cube . for the 16 mb simulation data cube , generating one map for a single projection resulted in an extra 1 mb of data , while generating two maps for all three projections created 6 mb of extra data . users should therefore be aware that frelled can , typically , approximately double the file space required . conversion of the fits file is parallelised using python s `` multiprocessing '' module . this is a trivial operation since each slice of the data can be treated independently . optimising blender to load the png images as rapidly as possible is more complicated ( see figure [ fig : code ] for pseudocode ) . creating an object in blender , for instance , is much slower than transforming an existing object . older versions of frelled simply created the correct number of planes to hold the images depending on the shape of the data cube . more recent versions ( 4.0 onwards ) contain a pre - existing set of image planes , 1,000 for each projection in both 2d and 3d modes ( with appropriate materials assigned in each case ) . if a data set has more than 1,000 channels ( or spatial pixels along any projection ) , it is necessary to remove the existing image planes for that projection and re - create the correct number . this step causes a significant slowdown . for example , truncating the large vla gps cube to have 1,000 pixels in r.a . ( instead of 1,023 ) reduces the loading speed to 4 min 6 seconds ( compared to 6 min 47 seconds for the full cube ) . a similar issue affects 2d mode . in 2d mode , the image planes are animated to move between the visible layer and a non - visible layer depending on the current frame . for example , when displaying channel maps , blender s frame counter corresponds to the channel number . as in 3d mode , a set of 1,000 image planes per projection are provided in the default file , the difference being that these have also been set up with the necessary animation data . in 2d mode new planes must be both created and animated ( a significantly slower extra step ) if the image has more than 1,000 pixels along a dimension . using the truncated cube as above , loading in the data in 2d mode takes only 1 min 58 seconds , compared to 7 min 33 seconds for the full cube . i estimate that parallelising the code and providing pre - loaded image planes has increased the loading speed of frelled by a factor of approximately 7 in 3d mode and up to 9 in 2d mode , using frelled v3.8 and 4.1 to display the vla gps cube described in section [ sec : bench ] on the quad - core hp elite . p15 describe in detail four viewers designed explicitly for viewing data in 3d . however , none of these viewers was designed specifically for astronomy - all , for instance , lack the ability to use world coordinate systems , which is a severe handicap ( as will become apparent in section [ sec : astrofrelled ] ) . here i briefly compare the 3d display capabilities of frelled with those of other programs designed for astronomy . _ xray _ is part of the karma package . though now about twenty years old ( @xcite ) its loading times are far superior to frelled ( @xmath4 10 seconds for the vla gps cube ) . its rendering speeds are considerably lower than frelled ( @xmath0 1 f.p.s . ) and the user can not freely change the angle of the viewpoint - after setting the pitch , yaw and roll via sliders , they must explicitly tell the program to recompute the view . _ xray _ is only a viewer and provides no tools to analyse the data . while it does have a 3d cursor , on our hp elite this feature invariably caused the program to crash . _ xray _ allows the user to interactively define the transfer function and choose different display integrations ( e.g. the minimum or maximum voxel along the line of sight ) . the user is limited to setting the data range via the range selector buttons ( e.g. 95% , 99% , 99.9% ) - they can not set precise numerical values . conversely , the angle of the viewpoint can _ only _ be set via precise sliders , and not by freely rotating the view ( as in frelled ) using the mouse . this makes it much more difficult to `` home in '' on a particular feature of interest . however , it has a very easy to use interface for creating animations for presentations ( which frelled deliberately emulates ) . it does not have any facility to stretch data , so if a data cube has a relatively short velocity axis , _ xray _ is of little use ( recall figure [ fig : stretch ] ) . in short , _ xray _ is useful for quick inspection of data , but can not be used for detailed analysis . _ ds9 _ is a widely - used , general purpose fits viewer . it was first released in 1999 and has had 3d display capabilities since 2010 . it is , indisputably , an extremely powerful and versatile tool , able to interface with external packages such as iraf and , for example , perform surface brightness profile fitting , aperture photometry , and the result of operations such as smoothing and filtering can be saved directly to the fits file . it can also be used to access other programs such as topcat and _ aladin _ , and , for instance , automatically retrieve and overlay source catalogues . like _ xray _ , the transfer function can be controlled interactively , and in 3d the user can choose which line - of - sight integration method to use . the advantage of _ ds9 _ s 3d view is that performance does not depend on system configuration . unlike _ xray _ , although the user is limited to using sliders to control the viewpoint orientation , the view is updated while they adjust the sliders , rather than waiting until the user forces a redraw . however this update is not instantaneous as in frelled ( while updating , only part of the data in the field of view is shown ) , but depends heavily on the exact display . while the frame rate may drop ( at worst ) to a few frames per second in frelled with a small field of view , in ds9 this can decrease to many seconds or tens of seconds per frame ( or even minutes per frame for a large cube ) ; during the rendering process the user sees a ` patchwork ' - the data which has been processed is shown with the remaining areas white until the calculations are complete . as with _ there is no way to alter the z - axis scale , so kinematic information is hard to discern in cubes with a short velocity axis . all this makes it very difficult to use _ ds9 _ to really explore a data set in 3d , except for very small cubes . the analysis features in 3d are also very limited . while there is a 3d crosshair , it is not obvious how to use the display to place this in a controlled way , and there is no true 3d cursor ( see section [ sec : astrofrelled ] ) . it is possible to define 2d regions in the 3d view , but there are no true 3d region capabilities . as with _ ds9 _ provides a quick , simple way to view data in 3d , but not much more than that . gaia , the graphical astronomy and image analysis tool , offers a similar ( if not greater ) level of versatility to _ ds9 _ , including photometry , source finding , and interaction with virtual observatory tools . however , like _ ds9 _ , its 3d capabilities are limited . gaia provides two types of 3d rendering : volume rendering and isosurfaces . isosurfaces can be useful , for instance , in understanding the structures of sources of very complex 3d geometry by reducing them to simpler information , i.e. the levels of constant flux value . frelled does not yet implement isosurfaces ( but see section [ sec : renzo ] ) as the main motivation for developing the visualisation routine was source extraction . isosurfaces are not ideal for this purpose , since they intrinsically rely on clipping much of the data so risk the user missing faint sources . gaia s volume renderer has some advantages over that of _ ds9_. when panning , zooming , or rotating the view , one does not entirely lose the display but it is replaced with a low - resolution `` preview '' image ( rendered at a very high frame rate ) , which is then recalculated at full resolution once the operation is complete . the user does this not through sliders ( which are not present ) but through the mouse , making it possible - in principle - to really explore the data set . unfortunately in practise the navigation interface is very imprecise and centering the view on specific features is extremely difficult . navigation is also possible via the keyboard ( though this is no more precise ) in a similar way to frelled ( see below ) , though no gui buttons are present to complement this . strong artifacts can be visible when altering the view ( and even when the display generation is complete ) . like _ ds9 _ , and the rendering frame rate depends on the size of the image on the screen . for large data sets at full hd resolution , this can be measured in frames per minute rather than frames per second . the view is also lost if the user switches workspaces and it must be recalculated when they switch back . gaia does allow the user to very easily generate 3d axes around the data cube ( which assist in orientation and navigation ) , unlike _ ds9_. while gaia does have the capability to load mask polyhedra from an external file , it has no capability of generating or manipulating these interactively . from the above discussion it is apparent that existing astronomical viewers have only rudimentary 3d display capabilities . two features in particular are lacking : 1 ) the ability to maintain the full detail of the data in the field view at any screen resolution and zoom level , especially while altering the viewpoint , while also maintaining a high frame rate ( as discussed above , other viewers suffer from displaying a patchwork view of the data while updating the view and/or other artifacts ) ; 2 ) the ability to intuitively and precisely navigate through 3d data . by using blender , frelled completely avoids these problems . in blender the frame rate in the realtime display ( see section [ sec : bench ] ) is not strongly affected by screen resolution or zoom level , nor is it necessary to reduce the level of detail when altering the viewpoint angle . the extremely slow ` realtime ' display of _ ds9 _ ( at least for large data sets ) means that the user is not really viewing an interactive 3d display at all , but simply changing from one fixed viewpoint to another . the experience when freely changing the view without loss of frame rate or detail is wholly different . while art is normally described as an intuitive process , artists require tools which are both intuitive and precise . the navigation interface in blender is far in advance of those of any of the tools discussed above . blender has a true 3d cursor which is easy to place ( see section [ sec : sourcefinding ] ) either using the mouse or by exact numerical values , and the user can then instantly re - orient the view on this position . this can also be used as the pivot point around which the view rotates . frelled provides altitude / azimuth sliders to control the viewpoint , if necessary . translating the view can be done with very high precision in blender - unlike in gaia the movement of the view correlates perfectly with the mouse movement . navigation is also possible via the keypad , and frelled provides gui buttons to support these options . for really exploring a 3d data set , a straightforward navigation interface which makes it easy to examine particular features is not an optional extra : it is an essential , fundamental part of the process . frelled was originally designed specifically for source - finding in hi data cubes . it has since been adapted to work as a viewer for simulation data , though most of its analysis tools are geared towards hi . while the goal is to provide a general - purpose astronomical viewer , at the present time some features are still hard - coded to assume the data is hi ( in particular drawing the velocity axis ) . as discussed in [ sec : displaycode ] , source extraction demands using minimal ( or no ) clipping of the data . i have already described in detail how this is accomplished in frelled . in t14 , we demonstrated that using frelled gave the same level of reliability of source extraction as using an established viewer such as _ kvis_. describing a search of a 330@xmath3270@xmath34096 voxel cube containing 334 sources : `` one of us ( hh ) searched the cube using kvis , while another ( rt ) searched with our new viewer . hh found 20 sources that rt did not , and rt found 18 sources that hh did not . such differences are inevitable given the subjective nature of the procedure ; however , rt was able to complete the process in a day , whereas hh required approximately six weeks . '' we also note that hh did not mask the sources , as this is very difficult to do in _ kvis _ ( see below ) . the key to this dramatic increase in visual source finding speed is the ability of the user to interactively mask regions of the data - especially in combination with the realtime 3d view of the data . the user can place blender s 3d cursor using the mouse . it is straightforward to define the exact position of the cursor since its position is restricted to the current plane of the screen . for example if the user is viewing the xy projection ( sky coordinates ) , they can only alter the right ascension and declination of the cursor , not its redshift . similarly in the xz projection they can only alter its right ascension and redshift , not its declination . switching back and forth between the projections ( which is instant ) enables the cursor to be placed very precisely ( numerical values can also be specified ) . once the user has placed the cursor at the center of the source , they can then add a blender object using the frelled script . by default this object will be a black cuboid , which they can scale along any and all axes using the keyboard and mouse ( again it is also possible to enter precise numerical values ) . with practise this is an extremely fast procedure that takes no more than a few seconds per source ( note that i am primarily using frelled to catalogue single - dish data where most sources are unresolved ) . it is easier to do this in 3d since the user can see how much of the source they have masked along all three axes at once - there is not much need to change the projection once the source center has been determined . this method reduces the limiting factor on the speed of visual source extraction , which has been _ recording _ sources rather than actually _ finding _ them ( see below for details ) . it is possible to mask data in a similar way using a combination of the miriad task _ immask _ and _ kvis_. however , this is scarcely a viable alternative . firstly , it is not interactive . the user must determine the precise numerical values for the minimum and maximum coordinates of the box and record them by hand . they must then use _ immask _ to apply the mask , re - load the cube in _ kvis _ and navigate back to the source in question . if a mistake is made , the mask file must be deleted and a new one created - essentially all the masks must be re - applied . moreover , this mask functions only as a mask , and nothing else . by allowing the user to interactively create an object which is used as a mask , frelled essentially eliminates all of these difficulties . as well as being much faster to create ( see below ) , the masks can be moved interactively , which is not possible using _ kvis_. they can also be toggled so that they are displayed either as true masks ( solid black in place of the data ) or transparent wireframes . an example of mask objects is shown in figure [ fig : masks ] . furthermore , since frelled can use world coordinates , it is straightforward to generate a source catalogue and/or compare detections with other data on the fly ( see below ) . the user rarely even needs to know the coordinates of the source they have found . while frelled s file loading times are mostly abysmal compared to conventional viewers such as _ ds9 _ or _ kvis _ , for source finding this is irrelevant . for the sake of a few extra minutes of loading time , weeks of source extraction time can be avoided . however , it is important to note that this is only true provided the source density is sufficiently high . it is interesting to ask : at what point does frelled s high loading time offset its fast masking capabilities ? this will depend on the size of the cube and system configuration . as a ballpark estimate , i masked ten random sources in a standard ages subset cube ( 330@xmath3270@xmath3925 voxels ) . the cube took approximately 1 min 30 seconds to load on our hp elite and it required an average of 30 seconds to mask each source . in comparison , in _ kvis _ is took less than 1 second to open the cube , but about 1 min 50 seconds to mask each source , on average . therefore it would still have been faster to use frelled for this cube if there were only two sources present . even with the ( truncated ) 577@xmath1 voxels cube described in sections [ sec : bench ] and [ sec : opt ] ( which is about the largest cube frelled is capable of displaying anyway , on a contemporary desktop machine ) , using _ kvis _ would only have been faster then frelled if no more than two sources were present . note that in the case of a real source - finding process , _ kvis _ can be significantly slower than in this simple test . the user must record source coordinates , which must also be done by reading values from the screen . masking sources can be much slower than in the ideal case if source density is high , as it can be difficult to determine where one source ends and other begins . applying the masks should be done whenever a single source is found , rather than after finding ten sources as in the test , otherwise there is a risk of cataloguing sources twice . if the user chooses to avoid masking the sources , they must continually check their catalogues to see if they have found a source or not . all of these factors mean that the factor of four difference in masking speeds in our idealised test translates into a very much larger difference in practise . p15 describe the necessity of having linked 3d and 2d views . as we are limited by blender s display to only displaying the sum of values along the line of sight ( and not minimum or maximum as most other viewers ) , the faintest sources are difficult to see in 3d mode . noise is rarely the ideal gaussian with a peak at exactly zero , and structures in the noise can overwhelm faint sources even with different line - of - sight display options . some data , however little , must usually be clipped to give a useful 3d display . in a 2d display , on the other hand , no data need be clipped at all , and structures in the noise do not necessarily obstruct the view of fainter sources . for these reasons , a 2d display mode remains a valuable tool for source finding . objects created in the 3d view are automatically linked to the 2d display . any changes made to an object in one view are propagated to the other . masking sources is slightly more difficult in the 2d view since the user has to change the visible channel ( or slice ) and then adjust the size of the mask region ( as opposed to the 3d view where it is not necessary to change the viewpoint ) . therefore a sensible approach is for the user to first mask all the sources visible in the 3d view ( i.e. the bright ones ) and then search the cube in 2d to find the fainter sources . it is often the case that hi detections do not appear especially interesting in the hi data cube itself . for instance , one can not tell from the hi data alone whether a galaxy has a particularly high hi mass - to - light ratio or is unusually compact compared to the stellar emission . such information can only be obtained after a much more detailed analysis . once determined the user may wish to re - asses the hi data in light of this new information and perhaps process it in different ways . one very simple but indispensable feature of blender objects is that they are given names , unlike regions in _ ds9 _ or masks in _ kvis_. this means that it is very simple to find the objects again later - one does not even need to know their coordinates , just the name ( or even just a number depending on the naming scheme used ) . the viewpoint in frelled can be automatically centred on the object using its name or coordinates . blender does not allow objects to have names longer than 21 characters . frelled assumes objects have the naming format string_xxx , where xxx is a numerical suffix . the string part of the name is limited by frelled to be 13 characters long . therefore the user can theoretically generate up to 10 million objects . through the python interpreter , it is possible in principle to perform any type of numerical analysis on the specified sources . i briefly describe those features which are currently implemented in frelled below . while all of the following require a region to be defined , it is ( if needed ) straightforward to define a region as large as the entire data cube . most operations can also be applied to multiple regions simultaneously . note also that the display of the fits data can be disabled at any time , to ensure a clearer view of the other maps ( see below ) frelled can generate . the realtime display in frelled provided a qualitative view of the data . more quantitative displays are possible using contour plots . the user has only to specify the minimum , maximum , and interval values . at present the interval size contours are enabled through the _ matplotlib _ python module and either displayed as png images , or converted into blender s internal mesh format . this is done through a combination of internal frelled code and a `` solidify '' code provided with blender , which converts the one - dimensional lines generated in _ matplotlib _ into 3d structures . to help produce conventional 2d plots ( e.g. for publications ) , the colours of the contours can be set according to the velocity ( or whatever the third axis of the cube happens to be ) of the sources . these can be defined by the axis range of the entire cube or by the subset of selected sources . for examples , see t14 appendix b. if a region spans more than one channel , the contours plotted will be of the integrated flux ( moment 0 ) for that region . the colour assigned will depend on the systemic velocity of the source , i.e. the central channel of each region . renzograms are contour plots of the flux in each channel of a source , with each channel assigned a different colour . the colours are set in the same way as for contour plots : they can either depend on the global velocity axis , or the particular velocity range of the selected regions . in 3d , renzograms are essentially slices of an isosurface . the ability to generate true isosurfaces will be included in a future version of frelled . moment maps can show a variety of different quantities , though currently only moment 0 ( integrated flux ) maps are supported in frelled . they can be useful in increasing sensitivity to extend flux , as discussed in t14 . moment maps in frelled are limited to greyscale images . the support for world coordinates means it is straightforward for frelled to query the nasa extragalactic database and the sloan digital sky survey ( @xcite ) . this is obviously useful to discover if a source has a counterpart at other wavelengths , which can be important in - for example - deciding if a source requires follow - up observations . queries are performed using a near - position search in ned and by opening the sdss navigate tool at the coordinates specified ( both by simply opening the ned or sdss url in a web browser with the appropriate parameters ) . no attempt is made by frelled to match the objects found through the query with the source identified in the data - this is a non - trivial operation for which it is better to allow the user full control ( for instance , the user may demand only optical redshift data and not hi redshifts , or sources found in ned may not have any redshift information in which case the user must decide if a closer or brighter source is more likely to be the actual counterpart ; the user might also decide that _ none _ of the counterparts are plausibly associated with their source ) . rgb images from the sdss can be directly displayed in frelled . their field of view is set to be the same as the region queried . thus is it is very easy to overlay , for example , hi contours on an optical image with a single mouse click . the sdss does not permit downloading images larger than 2048@xmath32048 pixels . images are normally extracted at the maximum resolution of 0.3961@xmath5 . if the region is so large that the image would exceed the maximum limit , frelled adjusts the resolution to keep the field of view the same . it is straightforward to compute the sum of values in a specified region . since blender s internal python enables us to check if a point is inside a mesh of arbitrary complexity , this allows analysis of regions of any shape . frelled reports both the raw sum of values and the beam - corrected total integrated flux , as described in t14 . an array of the locations of points inside the mesh is also written to a text file , allowing the user to write their own scripts to process data from regions of complex shapes . basic statistics ( minimum , maximum , mean , median and standard deviation ) of the raw values in the selected region are also calculated . miriad is a widely - used tool in radio astronomy for data reduction and also spectral line analysis ( @xcite ) . in particular the _ mbspect _ package is an accepted standard way in which to determine the precise coordinates of a source and also measure its line width and total flux . this requires the user to numerically specify their initial estimate of the coordinates , the velocity ( or frequency ) range of the source , any velocity range that should be masked to avoid measuring ( for instance ) rfi , and the name of a log file to save the extracted spectrum . frelled allows the user to access _ mbspect _ via the user - created regions . these feed the ( world ) coordinates and velocity range of the source into _ mbspect_. any other regions which are at similar coordinates but at a different velocity are also used to mask data , preventing the baseline fit in _ mbspect _ from being unduly affected by other sources . frelled can access _ mbspect _ in two different ways : 1 ) interactively - if a single source is selected , _ is run without saving any information to a log file , and the fitted spectrum is displayed in an x - window ; 2 ) non interactively - if multiple sources are selected , all the necessary parameters are saved to input files , named according to the regions , with log files specified . in both cases , since frelled does not offer direct access to all _ mbspect _ parameters , the idea is provide a useful first look at the data and reduce the workload when fine - tuning the parameters later . regions in frelled can also be used to mask data with miriad . the advantage of doing so is that miriad s _ immask _ sets values in the specified region to nan , rather than merely hiding them as in frelled . this can be useful , for example , when analysing the noise characteristics of a cube . while only a few miriad tasks are current accessible via frelled , there is no reason why any other tasks which benefit from having a specified region ( essentially any which analyse individual sources rather than entire data sets ) can not be similarly utilised . frelled accesses miriad simply by writing the necessary parameters to a text file and running the appropriate task , avoiding the need to re - invent the wheel and recode all of the well - tested miriad features . thus , extending frelled to use other miriad tasks is a straightforward procedure . numerical simulations present a few special concerns . they usually contain far more information than observational data : the user will probably opt to display true 3d spatial information rather than two dimensions of space and one of velocity . a frelled tool can display velocity information as 3d mesh arrow vectors . alternatively the user could use a separate fits file to display velocity information as colour ( see section [ sec : displaycode ] ) . there is also support for loading n - body particle data ( as with vectors these are loaded as blender meshes ) . one other key difference between numerical simulations and observational data is that simulations usually have multiple timesteps . both the particle and fits data can be animated in frelled - in the latter case the user simply supplies a file containing a list of the fits files they wish to animate . it is also possible to render batches of simulations ( currently they should all have similar data ranges , since it is not possible to specify a different transfer function for each simulation ) . for presenting data , simple rotation movies are also supported ( this can be used in conjunction with time series data ) . the user specifies the position and orientation of the camera and the number of frames for it to complete one rotation . p15 describe in detail the requirements for an hi fits viewer . i have described many of those features which frelled already offers throughout this article . here i describe the limitations of frelled , including features that potentially could be implemented and those which are impossible . of the requirements listed in p15 , three are likely impossible in frelled and/or blender , short of involving a blender developer . firstly , we can not interactively change the transfer functions . in most fits viewers , the user can interactively change the contrast of the displayed image by using the mouse and/or numerically setting the minimum and maximum data values . this is not possible in frelled without re - converting the fits file into png images an reloading them . as i showed in section [ sec : bench ] , this is prohibitively slow except for small data sets , and can not be considered to be an interactive feature . while the contrast of the png images can be directly controlled within blender , this does not affect the realtime display and the rendering the result is also prohibitively slow . fortunately , frelled is not entirely without the ability to control the image display . controlling the transfer function is useful since the data often has a high dynamic range . studying extended , complex bright features requires a different data range to that suitable for even detecting unresolved faint sources . to this end , there are some options in frelled / blender to interactively enhance the visibility of different features : * the maximum opacity of the data - see figure [ fig : display ] . making the data more opaque makes fainter sources easier to see , but reduces the visibility of structures within bright features . * clipping of faint features . blender allows all features below a specified transparency threshold to be rendered completely invisible . this is useful for hiding faint features ( e.g. noise ) that may obscure the view of other , brighter sources . * adjusting how the colour maps are applied to the data . for instance a texture map can affect only the transparency or the transparency and the colour ( which results in a higher contrast display ) , and these mapping modes can be toggled interactively . therefore , while frelled does not allow the transfer function to be controlled interactively , i believe it has enough alternative options that this is only a minor deficiency . more problematically , it is not possible to change the line - of - sight integration method . as mentioned in section [ sec:2d ] blender is limited to displaying only the sum of values . although i have not found this to be a severe handicap in practise , it would certainly be advantageous to be able to display , say , the peak flux instead ( as is possible in _ xray _ and _ ds9 _ ) . frelled is restricted by the whims of the blender developers in this case ( or more accurately by the needs of blender s main user base ) . the third feature which is essentially impossible is to interactively smooth the data . as noted in p15 , this can help reveal fainter features by increasing sensitivity - but of course this also decreases resolution , hence the need to be able to interactively switch between smoothed and unsmoothed cubes . _ ds9 _ is able to interactively smooth the data on the fly , a process which is somewhat slow but not prohibitively so ( about 38 seconds for our large vla gps cube on the hp elite ) . in contrast it takes about two minutes to smooth the png images for the 128@xmath1 voxel cube - much longer than the 40 seconds it takes to load the data into frelled . possible workarounds for this would be the implementation of isosurfaces , which would allow smoothing of much smaller subsets , or using pre - computed smoothed cubes ( see section [ sec : multi ] ) - the latter would be slow to initially load in , but switching between different cubes would be instantaneous . p15 also discuss the size of the data sets that various ska precursor surveys will return . as shown in section [ sec : bench ] , frelled is certainly not capable of handling the enormous @xmath04000@xmath1 voxel data sets such surveys will produce . it is in fact possible to already visualise such enormous data sets , but this requires access to a large cluster of gpus ( @xcite ) , something the average user does not have . frelled is , however , fully capable of handling subset cubes returned by automatic algorithms ( see p15 ) on a standard desktop workstation . for most contemporary data sets , frelled is perfectly adequate . most of the other features mentioned in p15 are already partially implemented in frelled and it should be straightforward to develop them fully . it already supports moment 0 maps , extending this to other moments ( e.g. velocity , velocity dispersion , peak flux ) would be straightforward . isosurfaces are not yet supported but renzograms are - and as noted in section [ sec : renzo ] , these are essentially slices of isosurfaces . it is quite literally a matter of `` joining the dots '' to turn these into isosurfaces , for which a blender script already exists ( see http://sourceforge.net/projects/pointcloudskin/[this url ] ) . i have described the capabilities of frelled , a fits viewer designed specifically to display astronomical fits data cubes in 3d . i have discussed in detail the problems of visual source extraction , noting that frelled is an effective way to alleviate one of its principle difficulties : the low speed in comparison with automatic programs . i have demonstrated that using interactive objects to mask and catalogue data , with the appropriate interface ( particularly using a 3d display ) is a highly effective way to increase the visual source extraction process . this makes it possible to catalogue hundreds of sources per day , which is sufficiently fast that there is little point in _ not _ undertaking such a search . i have also discussed how visual source extraction out - performs most algorithms in terms of reliability , if not completeness . it is worth emphasising that both techniques have an important role . in large data sets , the subjective nature of visual source extraction makes it desirable to do multiple searches - both by multiple people and algorithms ( who / which may all have different biases ) . while visual extraction will always been subjective , at the current time so - called automatic algorithms fare little better in this regard . at low s / n levels ( which is often where the most interesting sources are found ) , their reliability levels are so low that their catalogues require human inspection anyway . moreover , while it is obviously desirable to have a catalogue which is complete to some ( say ) flux limit , there is also value in finding every source possible without imposing any rigorous selection criteria . imposing criteria for cataloguing sources too strictly runs the risk of avoiding important serendipitous discoveries . finally , i note that many of the features provided by frelled are , technically , also possible with other software . regions of data can be masked using a combination of miriad and _ kvis _ , but far more slowly and laboriously . one can input all of the necessary parameters to analyse a spectral line in _ mbspect _ by carefully inspecting the data and typing them in by hand . what frelled attempts to do is provide not so much new features but simply a better _ interface _ to control them . in this way , it becomes possible to do visual source finding and analysis much more rapidly and on a larger scale than was previously possible . similarly , the far superior navigation interface of blender makes it possible to explore data sets in a completely different way to other 3d viewers . while frelled itself may not be used in analysing the large data cubes returned by ska precurosr surveys , i believe that similar features , implemented in other software , would bring tremendous benefits . the authors wish to thank kevin douglas for graciously providing the multi - wavelength data shown in figure [ fig : multirender ] . this work is based on observations collected at arecibo observatory . the arecibo observatory is operated by sri international under a cooperative agreement with the national science foundation ( ast-1100968 ) , and in alliance with ana g. mndez - universidad metropolitana , and the universities space research association . this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration . this work has made use of the sdss . funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s . department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england . the sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions . the participating institutions are the american museum of natural history , astrophysical institute potsdam , university of basel , university of cambridge , case western reserve university , university of chicago , drexel university , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , johns hopkins university , the joint institute for nuclear astrophysics , the kavli institute for particle astrophysics and cosmology , the korean scientist group , the chinese academy of sciences ( lamost ) , los alamos national laboratory , the max - planck - institute for astronomy ( mpia ) , the max - planck - institute for astrophysics ( mpa ) , new mexico state university , ohio state university , university of pittsburgh , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington .

i present a new fits viewer designed to explore 3d spectral line data ( in particular hi ) and assist with visual source extraction and analysis . using the artistic software blender , frelled can visualise even large ( @xmath0600@xmath1 voxels ) data sets at high frame rates ( @xmath210 f.p.s . ) in 3d . blender s interface enables easy navigation within the 3d environment , and the frelled scripts support world coordinate systems . a variety of tools are included to aid source extraction and analysis , including interactively masking data ( using 3d polyhedra of arbitrary complexity ) , querying ned , calculating the flux in specified volumes , generating contour plots and overlaying optical data . it includes tools to overlay n - body particle data , and multi - volume rendering is supported . the interface is designed to make cataloguing sources as easy as possible and i show that this can be as much as a factor of 50 times faster than using other viewers . radio lines : galaxies , galaxies : kinematics and dynamics , surveys , scientific visualization , visual analytics

0706.2578

one of the goals of the large hadron collider ( lhc ) @xcite is the discovery of supersymmetry ( susy ) . the squark and gluino decays produce missing transverse energy @xmath9 from lightest stable superparticle ( lsp ) plus multiple jets and isolated leptons @xcite . one of the most interesting and widely discussed signatures for susy discovery at the lhc is the signature with two opposite charge and the same flavour leptons @xcite : @xmath10 . the main reason of such interest is that neutralino decays into leptons and lsp @xmath11 contribute to this signature and the distribution of the @xmath12 invariant mass @xmath13 has the edge structure @xcite that allows to determine some combination of the susy masses . the signature @xmath14 can be realized when @xmath15 decays into @xmath16 pair which is only relevant at large @xmath3 @xcite . also as it is shown in ref.@xcite at the level of cmsjet @xcite simulation the use of @xmath17 signature for large @xmath3 allows to obtain nontrivial information on parameters of the decay @xmath18 . on the other hand , the @xmath14 ( with an arbitrary number of jets ) can be used for the detection of lepton flavour violation in slepton decays @xcite , @xcite at the lhc . in the minimal supersymmetric model ( mssm ) @xcite supersymmetry is broken at some high scale @xmath19 by generic soft terms , so in general all soft susy breaking terms are arbitrary which complicates the analysis and spoils the predictive power of the theory . in the minimal supergravity model ( msugra ) @xcite the universality of the different soft parameters at the grand unified theory ( gut ) scale @xmath20 gev is postulated . namely , all the spin zero particle masses ( squarks , sleptons , higgses ) are postulated to be equal to the universal value @xmath21 at the gut scale . all gaugino particle masses are postulated to be equal to the universal value @xmath22 at gut scale . also the coefficients in front of quadratic and cubic susy soft breaking terms are postulated to be equal . the renormalization group equations are used to relate gut and electroweak scales . the equations for the determination of a nontrivial minimum of the electroweak potential are used to decrease the number of the unknown parameters by two . so the msugra model depends on five unknown parameters . at present , the more or less standard choice of free parameters in the msugra model includes @xmath23 and @xmath24 @xcite . all sparticle masses depend on these parameters . in ref.@xcite the possibility to detect susy and lepton flavour violation using the @xmath25 signature at the lhc for the compact muon solenoid ( cms ) detector at the level of full detector simulation was studied . note also ref.@xcite where the susy msugra cms detector discovery potential was investigated for the @xmath26 signature at the level of full detector simulation . in this paper we study the @xmath0 and @xmath1 signatures @xmath2 for different values of @xmath27 in the msugra model . with @xmath28 rising , we observe a characteristic change in the shape of dilepton mass spectra in @xmath4 versus @xmath5 final states reflecting the decrease of @xmath6 branching ratio . we also study the non msugra modifications of the cms test point lm1 with arbitrary relations among gaugino and higgsino masses . for such modifications of the msugra test point the number of lepton events depends rather strongly on the relations among gaugino and higgsino masses and in some modifications of test point lm1 the signatures with leptons and @xmath7 do not lead to the susy discovery and the single susy discovery signature remains the signature with @xmath8 . the organization of the paper is the following . section [ tede ] describes some useful technical details of performed simulations . in section [ basi ] the backgrounds and cuts used to suppress the backgrounds are discussed . section [ resca ] contains the results of numerical calculations concerning the possibility to detect susy and constrain the susy parameters using the @xmath29 and @xmath26 signatures . section [ ressim ] contains the results of the simulations for different values of @xmath28 . in section [ ressim2 ] we discuss the results of the simulation of the mssm with nonuniversal gaugino and higgsino masses . section [ conc ] contains concluding remarks . the coupling constants and cross sections in the leading order ( lo ) approximation for susy processes and backgrounds were calculated with isasugra 7.69 @xcite , pythia 6.227 @xcite and comphep 4.2pl @xcite . for the calculation of the next - to - leading order ( nlo ) corrections to the susy cross sections the prospino @xcite code was used . for considered signal events and backgrounds the nlo corrections are known and the values of nlo cross sections ( or @xmath30-factors ) were used for normalization of the numerical results . we used the full simulation results of ref.@xcite for the estimation of the number of background events . the cms fast simulation code @xmath31 @xcite was used for the estimation of signal events . the reconstructed electrons and muons were passed through packages defining lepton isolation criteria . for each electron and muon the following parameters were defined : * @xmath32 is a number of additional tracks with @xmath33 2 gev/@xmath34 inside a cone with @xmath35 0.3 around the lepton . * @xmath36 is a ratio of energy deposited in the calorimeters ( electromagnetic ( ecal ) + hadronic ( hcal ) ) inside a cone with @xmath37 around given track to the energy deposited inside a cone with @xmath38 . * @xmath39 is defined as a ratio of energy deposited in the hcal inside a cone with @xmath40 to the energy deposited in the ecal inside the same cone . * @xmath41 is a ratio of energy deposited in the ecal inside a cone with @xmath40 to the momentum of the reconstructed track . the susy production @xmath42 with subsequent decays @xmath43 @xmath44 @xmath45 @xmath46 lead to the event topologies @xmath14 and @xmath1 . note that in the mssm with lepton flavour conservation neutralino decays into leptons @xmath47 ( @xmath48 ) do not contribute into the @xmath0 signature . the main backgrounds which contribute to the @xmath5 events are : @xmath49 , ww , wz , zz , wt , z@xmath50 , @xmath51 and z+jet . it is found that @xmath49 is the largest background and it gives more than 50% contribution to the total background . in this paper we used the results of ref.@xcite for the estimation of the number of background events . in the analysis the events with the following isolation criteria for electrons were used : @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 , @xmath55 . the same criteria for muons were the following : @xmath52 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 . these numbers were adjusted by studying electron and muon tracks in the process @xmath59 . the selection cuts are the following : * cut on leptons : @xmath60 , @xmath61 , lepton isolation within @xmath62 cone * cut on missing transverse energy : @xmath63 . here @xmath64 and @xmath65 are corresponding thresholds in this section we remind the main results of ref.@xcite on susy detection using the @xmath25 signature . the possibility to detect susy using the cms test points lm1 - lm9 @xcite chosen for the detailed study of susy detection at the cms was investigated in ref.@xcite . this study was based on the counting the expected number of events for both the standard model ( sm ) and the msugra model . the parameters of the cms test points lm1 - lm9 are given in table [ points ] . . the parameters of the cms test points . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ leptons ] as it follows from table [ leptons ] for points ( 7 - 12 ) the perspective to discover susy using the signature with single lepton or dileptons plus @xmath9 looks hopeless . moreover for the points ( 7 - 12 ) the use of more powerful from the susy discovery point of view signature @xmath66 also looks very problematic . the invariant mass distributions of @xmath12 ( solid line ) and @xmath5 ( dotted line ) lepton pairs at the extensions of the point lm1 are shown in figs.[pm2_minvbsm4]-[pm2mu_minvbsm4 ] . the distributions of @xmath67 leptons , @xmath68 lepton , @xmath69 leptons and @xmath70 leptons on @xmath9 for the modifications of the point lm1 are shown in figs.[ppx4425 ] - [ pl02x102 ] for an integral luminosity @xmath71 . as one can see from fig.[ppx4425 ] for the points ( 7 - 10 ) there is sharp change in lepton spectra distributions on @xmath9 compared to the test point lm1 , namely , the number of lepton events for the points ( 7 - 10 ) are much smaller than for the test point lm1 . the same situation takes place for the @xmath9 spectrum of events without leptons , see fig.[pl02x4425 ] . in this paper we studied the @xmath0 and @xmath1 signatures @xmath2 for different parameters @xmath3 of the mssm model . with @xmath3 rising , we observed a characteristic change in the shape of dilepton mass spectra in @xmath4 versus @xmath5 final states reflecting the decrease of @xmath6 branching ratio . we also studied some non msugra modifications of the point lm1 . we have found the drastic change in dilepton spectra with the increase of gaugino masses . for the points ( 7 - 12 ) the perspective to discover susy using the signatures with leptons and @xmath9 looks hopeless . even more powerful signature with @xmath72 looks rather pessimistic . as a recent review , see for example : + n.v.krasnikov and v.a.matveev , ; + hep - ph/0309200 . h.baer , c .- h.chen , f.paige and x.tata , . as a review , see for example : + s.abdullin _ et al . _ , cms note 1998/006 . d.denegri , w.majerotto and l.rurua , . n.v.krasnikov , ; + n.v.krasnikov , . f.deppisch _ et al . _ , hep - ph/0401243 . reviews and original references can be found in : + h.e.haber and g.l.kane , ; + r.barbieri , ; + d.v.nanopoulos , ; + h.p.nilles , ; + n.v.krasnikov and v.a.matveev , ; + n.polonsky , . yu.andreev , s.bityukov , n.krasnikov and a.toropin , cms note 2006/103 ; hep - ph/0608176 . m.chiorboli , m.galanti and a.tricomi , cms note 2006/133 . h.baer , f.e.paige , s.d.protopopescu and x.tata , hep - ph/0001086 . et al . _ , ; + http://www.thep.lu.se/@xmath73torbjorn/pythia.html v.i.savrin _ et al . _ , . w.beenakker _ _ , hep - ph/9611232 ; + http://people.web.psi.ch/spira/prospino/ http://cmsdoc.cern.ch/cmsoo/cmsoo.html http://cmsdoc.cern.ch/cms/prs/susybsm/msugra_testpts/ msugra_testpts.html m.battaglia _ et al . s.i.bityukov and n.v.krasnikov , ; + s.i.bityukov and n.v.krasnikov , . v.bartsch and g.quast , cms note 2005/004 ; + r.cousins , j.mumford and s.valuev , cms note 2005/002 .

we study the @xmath0 and @xmath1 signatures @xmath2 for different values of @xmath3 in the msugra model . with @xmath3 rising , we observe a characteristic change in the shape of dilepton mass spectra in @xmath4 versus @xmath5 final states reflecting the decrease of @xmath6 branching ratio . we also study the non msugra modifications of the cms test point lm1 with arbitrary relations among gaugino and higgsino masses . for such modifications of the msugra test point lm1 the number of lepton events depends rather strongly on the relations among gaugino and higgsino masses and in some modifications of the test point lm1 the signatures with leptons and @xmath7 do not lead to the susy discovery and the single susy discovery signature remains the signature with @xmath8 . # 1#2#3#4#1 * # 2 * ( # 4 ) # 3

1307.5680

the neutron lifetime @xmath1 is an important parameter in tests of the standard model of particle physics . it also affects the rate of helium production in the early universe and the energy production in the sun . the current particle data group ( pdg ) average is @xmath1 = 880.1@xmath2 1.1 s @xcite . however , the value of one experiment @xcite , which reported the lowest measurement uncertainty of @xmath3 0.8 s , is @xmath3 3.5 s lower than the bulk of other data in the pdg collection @xcite , that are grouped consistently around 882.0 s ( @xmath2 1.0 s ) @xcite . therefore the actual uncertainty of @xmath1 to be used in cosmological calculations may be of the order of 2 seconds or more . as a possible way of advancing this field , storage of polarized ultracold neutrons ( ucns ) in a magnetic trap has been pioneered by paul _ _ @xcite and is currently being pursued vigorously by several groups worldwide @xcite . one advantage of magnetic ucn storage versus storage in material bottles , the method used in a number of previous neutron lifetime measurements @xcite , is the potential absence of losses due to effects other than @xmath4-decay . there are no wall losses , the slow loss due to quasi - stable orbits is serious but believed to be manageable by avoiding regular orbits @xcite , and the potential loss due to depolarization , defined as spin flip relative to the local field direction , is commonly assumed to be negligible . for systems using permanent magnets the question of gradual demagnetization over time appears to have found little attention so far . until recently ucn depolarization estimates @xcite were based on majorana s quasi - classical result of 1932 @xcite for a free polarized particle with magnetic moment moving with constant velocity vector through a non - uniform static magnetic field of specific form . only its spin state was assumed to be affected by the magnetic field . this model predicted a depolarization probability @xmath5 for one passage through the field . this value decreases exponentially with the adiabaticity parameter @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the frequency of rotation of the field as seen from the reference frame of the moving particle , in the critical region where the field rotates fastest while the magnitude @xmath8 of the magnetic field may be small . @xmath9 is the larmor frequency . for magnetic field parameters as currently used or proposed for ucn storage , @xmath10 would be of order @xmath11 , thus immeasurably small . recently , walstrom _ et al . _ @xcite pointed out that the values of @xmath10 for confined , rather than freely moving , neutrons are much larger . for a ucn moving along a vertical path in the storage system proposed by them , @xmath10 was estimated to be in the range @xmath12 to @xmath13 . this is much larger than the majorana value but still negligible in any actual or projected neutron lifetime experiment . using a simplified model of magnetic field distribution we extend the theory of @xcite to include arbitrary ucn motion with both vertical and horizontal velocity components , confined to the vertical space between upper and lower turning points that depend only on the ucn energy for vertical motion . in our model ( introduced in sec . [ sec : ii ] ) the magnetic field magnitude @xmath8 is uniform within any horizontal plane , so there is no horizontal component of magnetic force . therefore the neutron moves with constant velocity in the horizontal @xmath14- and @xmath15- directions . we show that @xmath10 could reach a level approaching the tolerance limit for a high precision neutron lifetime measurement unless precautions are taken . as is well known the most critical issue is the choice of a stabilization field perpendicular to the magnetic mirror field , of sufficient strength so that the depolarization rate will be negligible in a neutron lifetime experiment . our model field is close to the `` bathtub configuration '' of ref . @xcite but the lateral confinement of ucns , achieved there by double curvature of the magnetic mirror , is simulated differently . the magnetic mirror is horizontal and extends to infinity in both lateral dimensions . however , one could imagine the presence of ideal vertical mirrors reflecting the ucns back and forth in the horizontal directions without any change in the analysis . more specifically , we use an infinite ideal planar halbach array @xcite , which is free of the field ripples present in actual realizations @xcite . in the design of ref . @xcite , the ripples are important only within about 1 mm of the surface of the magnets . this region is not reached by the ucns whose maximum energy ( for vertical motion ) is @xmath345 nev ( for the parameters in @xcite ) , since they reverse their flight direction before entering this zone . using this model of field distribution we have also studied the problem of depolarization of ucns in reflection from a non - magnetic mirror immersed in a non - uniform magnetic field . this question is important as a mechanism that may limit the efficiency of ucn polarizers based on transmission through a magnetic field . for a sufficiently strong field , neutrons in only one spin state can pass the field to proceed to the experiment . otherwise they are reflected . however , following the polarizer the ucns are usually reflected on trap or guide walls exposed to the stray field of the polarizer and thus may lose their 100% polarization if the reflection process involves depolarization . moreover , a possible depolarization on non - magnetic trap walls in a magnetic field is highly relevant in measurements of the neutron decay asymmetry parameter @xmath0 using ultracold neutrons @xcite . this problem has first been investigated by pokotilovski @xcite who used an adaptation of the majorana model to the reflection geometry . in the present work we study certain aspects of this problem by imagining a horizontal lossless non - magnetic ucn mirror inserted at a variable height into the magneto - gravitational storage space . the net depolarization per bounce on this mirror will be compared to the depolarization for one bounce in the magnetic field in the absence of the mirror to obtain an estimate for the depolarization effect of the mirror . the topic of ucn depolarization in magnetic storage or in mirror reflection in a magnetic field raises interesting questions of quantum interpretation . fig . 3 of ref . @xcite and our fig . [ fig : two ] ( to be discussed in sec . [ sec : iii.b.2 ] ) show the probability for the neutron to be in the spin - flipped state ( relative to the field direction ) as a function of position of the neutron as it moves through the magnetic storage space . the curve is strongly peaked at the critical level where the field rotates fastest in the reference frame of the moving neutron . this behavior is the same as displayed by the majorana result @xcite ( where it is more difficult to deduce since the author used a quantization axis fixed in space rather than rotating together with the field ) . in a semi - classical interpretation , as the ucn starts moving from one turning point , say the upper one , down toward the lower one , the spin vector rotates away from the quantization axis ( which was chosen parallel to the local magnetic field vector in ref . it reaches a certain maximum angle around the critical zone ; then this rotation is reversed and ends at a much smaller value at the next turning point for ucn motion . this indicates that an analyzer of neutron polarization placed at different heights would show a variation of depolarization by many orders of magnitude ( @xmath16 8 decades for the example shown in fig . 3 of ref . @xcite ) over the vertical range of the storage space . the depolarization rate expected for an actual ucn magnetic storage experiment , without any polarization analyzer intersecting the beam , is determined by the current of ucns in the `` wrong '' spin state , i.e. of high - field seekers leaving the system at the lower and upper turning points while the `` correct '' ( high - field repelled ) state is reflected and returns to the storage space . this association of net depolarization with loss currents is consistent with the following interpretation : at the turning points a measurement is performed ( in the sense of quantum mechanics ) , conceptually by neutron detectors placed just below the bottom and just above the top of the storage region for a given ucn energy for vertical motion . these detectors would intersect the ucns in the `` wrong '' spin state as they exit the storage system . in the copenhagen interpretation , such a measurement ( actual or hypothetical ) resets the ucn wave function to a pure state of high - field repelled neutrons . the spin state then evolves as described by the spin - dependent schrdinger equation ( or its semi - classical analog ) until the next `` measurement '' takes place at the following turning point and the process of wave collapse and wave evolution is repeated . alternative interpretations are conceivable but we will use the picture outlined above . following ref . @xcite we use the wentzel - kramers - brillouin ( wkb ) approximation to solve the spin - dependent schrdinger equation . this appears justified since the spatial variation of field variables ( gravitational potential and magnetic field * b * ) is much slower than the variation of ucn wave function . the scales are of order cm for gravity and * b * , and of order @xmath17 m or less for the neutron wavelength . we are aware of the fact that an exact treatment of ucn depolarization in magnetic storage may involve quantum electrodynamics since the moving neutron , in its reference frame , is affected by a time - dependent electromagnetic field , i.e. by low - energy photons . we will also neglect temporal fluctuations of the field due to mechanical vibrations or , if electromagnets are used for field generation , ac components of the current supply . we are not aware of any work on time - dependent effects of this kind in magnetic ucn storage . as it rotates in the ( @xmath18)-plane . its magnitude @xmath19 decreases exponentially with height @xmath20 and is represented by the arrow length using a log scale . the angle @xmath21 of the halbach field is also shown . the superimposed stabilization field @xmath22 in the @xmath14-direction increases slowly with @xmath20 as in ref . @xcite and is symbolized by the crosses of variable size.,width=291 ] we consider a halbach array @xcite of permanent magnets of thickness @xmath23 covering the infinite @xmath24-plane , where the @xmath15-axis points to the right , the @xmath20-axis points up ( against gravity ) and the @xmath14-axis toward the front ( fig . [ fig : one ] ) . we choose @xmath25 at the upper magnet surface and will closely follow the description in ref . @xcite , apart from this choice of system of coordinates . this choice will allow us to use the pauli matrices in their standard form . in the limit of infinitely fine division of magnet blocks in the @xmath15-direction , let the magnetization vector have a constant magnitude @xmath26 but , viewed along the positive @xmath14 direction , rotate clockwise in the @xmath27-plane with periodicity @xmath28 in @xmath15-direction : @xmath29 using a complex quantity @xmath30 , eq . ( [ ( 1 ) ] ) can also be written @xmath31 . @xmath32 and @xmath33 are unit vectors . we choose the same parameters as for the design in ref . @xcite , thus @xmath34 = 5.2 cm and @xmath35 @xmath36 . the special feature of the halbach system is that it generates a magnetic field only on one side of the magnets , namely in the half space @xmath37 for clockwise sense of rotation . this halbach field is @xmath38 or , in complex notation , @xmath39 . @xmath40 is determined by the remanent field @xmath41 and the block depth @xmath23 = 2.54 cm . the magnitude of @xmath42 , @xmath43 , only depends on the vertical coordinate @xmath20 . the field distribution is shown schematically in fig . [ fig : one ] . in the actual scheme @xcite , the uniform rotation is replaced by dividing the rotation period @xmath34 into four blocks , each of length @xmath44 and with the same magnetization @xmath45 , but with an angle of 90@xmath46 between the directions of @xmath47 in adjacent blocks ( schematically represented as @xmath48 . alternative designs are in the form of vertical or horizontal cylinders where the magnets are assembled along the cylindrical surface : in a dipolar way in @xcite , with adjacent blocks magnetized in the peripheral direction with equal magnetic poles facing each other ( schematically : @xmath49 ) . in project @xcite a cylindrical octupole halbach magnet is used where 32 blocks are distributed uniformly over the perimeter and the direction of magnetization advances by 56.25@xmath50 from one block to the next . in these systems the magnitude @xmath8 of magnetic field increases sharply near the magnetic wall . a superconducting quadrupole system of magnetic ucn storage for a neutron lifetime experiment is used in ref . @xcite while in ref . @xcite the ucn are stored in superfluid helium using a ioffe system with horizontal electromagnetic quadrupole . for a quadrupole the field magnitude increases linearly with radial distance from the axis . at least one magnetic end cap is required for all cylindrical systems ; on the upper side of vertical systems gravitational confinement can be used . the field distribution for systems using permanent magnets with magnetization direction advancing in steps from block to block may be expressed as a fourier series , as in eq . ( 7 ) of ref . @xcite . the first term of the expansion is dominant and has the form ( [ ( 2 ) ] ) with constant @xmath51 somewhat smaller than @xmath52 . for the planar quadrupole halbach system the reduction factor is @xmath53 @xcite and the field in the lower half space @xmath54 no longer vanishes . the higher fourier components generate a ripple field in the @xmath27-plane , which is significant within @xmath55 mm from the magnet surface ( and even induces a logarithmic divergence in the field gradient within @xmath56 m ) . but this space is not accessible to the ucns if we choose a spectrum soft enough to ensure that all neutrons approaching the magnet from above are reflected back up before reaching the ripple zone . we use the value of 0.64 t for the magnetic field at a safe distance 2 mm , which corresponds to @xmath57 t at the surface . thus , for the halbach array generated field we assume the form ( [ ( 2 ) ] ) with @xmath57 t and strict confinement of the vector @xmath42 in the @xmath27-plane . we ignore the small field ripple in the @xmath14-direction considered in @xcite since it also decays strongly with distance from the magnet surface . these small perturbations are not expected to affect the depolarization results obtained below in a significant way . our value of @xmath58 is @xmath59% lower than the design value of @xcite to take into account partial demagnetization , over time , of the ndfeb permanent magnets exposed to large fields . a common feature of the various magnetic ucn storage schemes is the requirement of a bias field @xmath60 perpendicular to the main field . it ensures that the field magnitude @xmath61 exceeds a certain minimum value everywhere in the storage volume , especially at critical positions where the field rotates fast in the neutron s moving reference frame . the main purpose of the present work is to provide an estimate of this minimum field for typical field parameters , as those in ref . @xcite where the field @xmath60 also serves the purpose of guiding the decay electrons out of the storage space to a detector as a way to monitor the neutron decay rate in real time . @xmath60 is generated by a toroidal electromagnet , and it is oriented along the longitudinal direction of the `` bathtub surface '' which corresponds to the @xmath14-direction in our model with a planar , rather than curved halbach magnet . we use the same @xmath20-dependence as in ref . @xcite , @xmath62 with @xmath63 m. the magnitude of @xmath64 is uniform on a horizontal plane , and since the halbach field magnitude @xmath19 is uniform for given height @xmath20 no horizontal force acts on the stored ucn . in ref . @xcite a value of 0.05 to 0.1 t was proposed for @xmath65 . we will consider field strengths down to the mt range since this range seems to be closer to the bias field used in ref . @xcite . in this latter work the value used was not given but it was estimated , on the basis of the majorana formula , that a minimum field @xmath66 of @xmath30.001 t was required for their neutron lifetime measurement . our analysis of the evolution of spin - flip probability for ucns moving in our model magnetic field distribution differs from that of ref . @xcite as follows . it is not restricted to purely vertical motion but assumes that the ucns can also have arbitrary horizontal velocity components @xmath67 and @xmath68 . @xmath67 and @xmath68 are constant since neither gravity nor the net magnetic field @xmath69 of our model exert a horizontal force on the neutron . as noted earlier , both @xmath19 and @xmath66 are uniform at given height @xmath20 , and @xmath42 is perpendicular to @xmath60 , thus @xmath70 depends on @xmath20 only . as a result , the magnetic force , which is determined by the gradient of @xmath71 , has no horizontal components and the equation of motion is separable in three dimensions . we use three different methods of analysis , both for purely magnetic confinement of ucns with arbitrary 3d velocity components , and for a system involving a non - magnetic mirror placed into our model magnetic field distribution : ( a ) in sec . [ sec : iii ] a quantum approach using the wkb approximation , ( b ) in sec . [ sec : iv ] a quasi - classical approximation and ( c ) in sec . [ sec : v ] direct numerical integration of the equations of motion . in the quantum approach the stationary spin - dependent schrdinger equation is solved using the wkb approximation , extending the method of ref . @xcite to 3d motion . the semi - classical majorana method @xcite which was adapted to magnetically confined ucns in ref . @xcite will also be extended to 3d . using both methods we will also analyze ucn reflection on a non - magnetic mirror in a magnetic field . in sec . [ sec : v ] we will show that some analytic results can be obtained as well by direct numerical integration of the wave equation for the spin - flipped component of the wave function . this is only feasible because the magnetically trapped ucns have relatively long wavelengths , in the @xmath17 m range , so the number of wave oscillations for the entire integration path is not too large . the wave function for a ucn moving in the magneto - gravitational field of the trap is a linear superposition of the two eigenstates of the magnetic moment interaction hamiltonian @xmath72 where @xmath73 is the neutron magnetic moment in terms of the nuclear magneton @xmath74 j / t , @xmath75 is the pauli spin operator , and @xmath76 is the local magnetic field . the two eigenstates @xmath77 and @xmath78 of @xmath79 satisfy the eigenvalue equations @xmath80 and correspond , respectively , to neutron spin parallel to @xmath81 with spin energy @xmath82 , and to antiparallel spin with energy @xmath83 . these spin eigenfunctions are obtained by spin rotation from the @xmath14-axis to the direction of @xmath76 through angles @xmath84 and @xmath85 . the polar field angle is @xmath86 , where @xmath87 is due to the bias field @xmath88 and @xmath89 is the magnitude of the halbach field @xmath42 . the azimuthal angle in the @xmath27-plane is @xmath90 . ( [ ( 2 ) ] ) shows that for the halbach field configuration @xmath91 thus @xmath85 depends only on @xmath15 ( not on @xmath20 or @xmath14 ) , while @xmath84 depends only on @xmath20 . these properties will simplify the analysis considerably . exact correspondence between the system of coordinates @xmath92 used here and the system @xmath93 used in ref . @xcite ( with @xmath94 pointing up ) is established if we add the constant @xmath95 to the right - hand side of eq . ( [ ( 5 ) ] ) . performing the spin rotation through angles @xmath84 and @xmath85 we obtain for the spin basis vectors @xcite with quantization axis along @xmath81 @xmath96 where @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 . we write the dependence of the wave function on position and spin in the form @xmath100 where we have used the superscript ( 3 ) to indicate that @xmath101 are functions of the three space coordinates while the corresponding functions @xmath102 and @xmath103 , introduced below , depend on @xmath20 only . @xmath104 satisfies the eigenvalue equation @xmath105 \chi\ ] ] for a neutron of mass @xmath106 with constant total energy @xmath107 moving in a uniform gravitational field of magnitude @xmath108 and a non - uniform magnetic field @xmath109 . using subscripts to denote partial differentiation , the laplace operator acting on the wave function gives @xmath110 where for the second and third term the indicated permutations are performed . the basis vectors for quantization along the fixed @xmath14-axis can be expressed in terms of the basis vectors @xmath77 and @xmath78 : @xmath111 using eq . ( [ ( 10 ) ] ) and noting that , from ( [ ( 5 ) ] ) , @xmath112 , @xmath113 , @xmath114 and also @xmath115 , we obtain @xmath116 as in ref . @xcite we will use the wkb approximation @xcite and keep only those terms in eq . ( [ ( 9 ) ] ) that contain the derivatives of the field variables ( @xmath84 and @xmath85 ) in lowest order since those change on the scale of centimeters while the waves in real space , @xmath117 and @xmath118 , vary on the micrometer scale , i.e. @xmath119 times faster . this implies that all second derivatives of @xmath77 and @xmath78 are dropped , along with other small terms . ( using the numerical integration described in sec . [ sec : v ] we have performed test runs where the small terms were retained . the results were the same within the precision of numerical integration . ) assuming that the ucn started out from a pure ( + ) spin state and keeping only the dominant terms in eq . ( [ ( 9 ) ] ) we obtain @xmath120 \chi^- , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used @xmath121 , @xmath122 , and the fact that in practice @xmath123 . the functions in real space multiplying @xmath77 and @xmath78 can be simplified by noting that the @xmath15 and @xmath14 dependence of @xmath117 has the plane wave form @xmath124 and @xmath118 is proportional to @xmath125 . the wave numbers @xmath126 and @xmath127 are constant and @xmath128 represents a bloch - wave modulation due to the periodicity of the halbach field . in practice , @xmath126 and @xmath127 are of order @xmath17m@xmath129 , thus much larger than @xmath130 and @xmath131 , both of which are of order @xmath36 . thus we can factor eq . ( [ ( 12 ) ] ) in the form @xmath132\chi^+ \\ & + \mathrm{e}^{-ikx}[\beta '' - ( k_x^2+k_z^2)\beta - ( \theta'\alpha'+kk_x\alpha\sin\theta)]\chi^-\},\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] simplifying the notation . in eq . ( [ ( 13 ) ] ) and henceforth , @xmath102 and @xmath103 stand for the @xmath20-dependent parts of the wave function only , and differentiation with respect to @xmath20 is denoted by primes . we also drop the subscript @xmath20 from the @xmath20-component of the wave vector . thus , @xmath133 and @xmath134 . the terminology @xmath135 conforms to that used in ref . @xcite where motion in horizontal directions was not taken into account in the depolarization calculations . inserting eq . ( [ ( 13 ) ] ) into the eigenvalue equation ( [ ( 8) ] ) gives @xcite two coupled equations , one for spinor @xmath77 ( i.e. , for low - field seeking ucns with spin parallel to @xmath136 , which can be stored ) and the other for @xmath78 ( i.e. , for the fraction of ucns whose spin has flipped relative to @xmath136 and which therefore can escape from the trap ; the probability of flipping twice is negligible ) : @xmath137+mgy\alpha+|\mu_{\textrm{n}}|b\alpha\ ] ] and @xmath138 \nonumber \\ & + mgy\beta-|\mu_n|b\beta.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the framework of the wkb approximation , the solution of ( [ ( 14 ) ] ) is @xcite @xmath139 where @xmath140 @xmath141 is the magnitude of the @xmath20-component of local wave vector for the storable ( + ) spin state ( parallel to @xmath81 ) and @xmath142 is that for the ( @xmath143 ) spin state . in eq . ( [ ( 17 ) ] ) , @xmath144 is the greatest height a neutron of energy @xmath107 and given @xmath126 and @xmath127 would achieve in the gravitational field if the magnetic field were switched off . in eq . ( [ ( 16 ) ] ) , @xmath145 is the phase angle , for the + spin state , accumulated between the start of vertical motion and the position @xmath20 . the initial height @xmath146 for motion upward is assumed to be that of the lower turning point , thus @xmath147 , and for motion downward the initial level is taken at the upper turning point , @xmath148 . the additional + or @xmath143 sign in the argument of the exponential function in ( [ ( 16 ) ] ) , in front of @xmath149 , refers to this direction of the motion ; plus for upward and minus for downward , as in @xcite . the wkb wave function ( [ ( 16 ) ] ) is normalized to a constant particle flux @xmath150 in the @xmath20-direction . for the spin - flipped ucns , the flux in the @xmath20-direction is the measure of the probability of depolarization , as shown below . at the classical turning points , where @xmath151 , the wkb form ( [ ( 16 ) ] ) diverges and has to be replaced by the airy function , as shown in @xcite , but the wkb form is still valid almost all the way to the turning point , except for the last @xmath17 m or so , since it correctly represents the asymptotic behavior of the airy function in this region this is an important feature of the approximation used in ref . @xcite and in the present work . it is made more explicit as follows : the asymptotic form of the airy function in the region of real waves ( rather than the exponentially decaying wave on the other side ) is @xcite @xmath152 . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the wave number @xmath153 is determined by the local acceleration @xmath154 at the turning point @xmath146 , and @xmath155 . for upward motion the wkb wave approximation ( [ ( 16 ) ] ) for @xmath102 , which is valid between the turning points , is matched to the first term inside the braces of ( [ ( 19 ) ] ) , and for downward motion to the second term by adjusting the constant multiplying the airy function . it follows from eq . ( [ ( 15 ) ] ) that the wave function @xmath156 for the spin flipped component is determined by the inhomogeneous second - order differential equation @xmath157 having separated off the @xmath15 and @xmath14 dependence allows us to choose the same wkb form for @xmath103 as in ref . @xcite : @xmath158 where the function @xmath159 modulating the wkb wave represents the amplitude of spin flip . apart from the modulation @xmath159 , @xmath103 is constructed in the same way as @xmath102 . the phase accumulated since the start at a turning point , @xmath160 always has a larger magnitude than the phase @xmath161 for @xmath102 since @xmath162 is greater than @xmath163 ( except in zero magnetic field ) . summarizing , the governing equation for @xmath103 is the second - order differential equation @xmath164 \alpha(y),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the right - hand side represents an inhomogeneous term and @xmath102 is given by eq . ( [ ( 16 ) ] ) while @xmath103 has the form @xmath165 in the second expression on the right - hand side of ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) we have carried out the differentiation of @xmath102 , using the wkb rule of considering the slow - varying terms as constant , with the result @xmath166 where the + sign applies to upward motion and the @xmath143 sign to downward motion . this replacement is valid except within a few @xmath17 m of the turning points . ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) is the same as eq . ( 28 ) of ref . @xcite except for the additional , @xmath126 dependent term on the right - hand side . it is present because we include motion with finite lateral momentum @xmath167 , whereas the analysis in ref . @xcite was restricted to the special case @xmath168 . we will show that this new term makes the major contribution to ucn depolarization in magnetic storage . we also note that eq . ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) does not depend on @xmath127 , thus motion exactly along the @xmath14-direction does not induce depolarization . this is understandable since neutrons moving along the @xmath14-axis during the short periods of horizontal motion at the turning points move in a uniform @xmath81-field . on the other hand , in motion along the @xmath15-direction they are exposed to the strong field ripple due to the rotating halbach field . these features are expected to hold , on a qualitative basis , also for the `` bathtub system '' of ref . @xcite , where the direction perpendicular ( parallel ) to the curved halbach array corresponds to our @xmath14-axis ( @xmath15-axis ) . next we will solve eq . ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) to obtain the depolarization rate for ucn storage in our model field distribution . we will first consider a neutron of given energy and fixed values of @xmath126 and @xmath127 , moving downward from the upper turning point @xmath169 . using the wkb rule , the second derivative @xmath170 is obtained from ( [ ( 24 ) ] ) as @xmath171 inserting @xmath172 and @xmath102 from ( [ ( 16 ) ] ) into eq . ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) gives @xmath173 \exp\big(-i\phi(y)\big),\ ] ] where @xmath174 and @xmath175 . defining a function @xmath176 through @xmath177 we obtain from ( [ ( 26 ) ] ) @xmath178 \exp\big(-i\psi(y)\big),\ ] ] where @xmath179 . the phases @xmath180 and @xmath181 are fast - varying quantities , while the field variables @xmath182 and @xmath183 vary slowly with @xmath20 and will therefore be considered constant in all differentiations . in integrations , as needed to obtain @xmath176 from eq . ( [ ( 27 ) ] ) , this `` wkb rule '' directly corresponds to performing the integral of products of slow- and fast varying terms by parts and neglecting the second term which contains the derivative of the slow - varying factor . it has been shown numerically in ref . @xcite that for the parameters of magnetic ucn storage at hand this procedure gives approximations with precision in the range @xmath184 . thus we obtain from ( [ ( 27 ) ] ) @xmath185\exp(-i\psi')dy ' \nonumber \\ & = \int_{\psi_s}^\psi \frac{iu(y')+v(y')}{k_-+ k_+ } \exp(-i\psi ' ) d\psi ' \\ & = \frac{i[iu(y ) + v(y)]}{k_-(y ) + k_+(y ) } \exp\big(-i\psi(y)\big ) . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the third step in ( [ ( 28 ) ] ) is an integration by parts , where only the leading term is kept . the lower limit of the @xmath20-integration in ( [ ( 28 ) ] ) is the upper turning point . carrying out the integration in the last step of eq . ( [ ( 28 ) ] ) we should expect a contribution from this lower limit of integration ( @xmath186 or @xmath187 ) . however , such a term does not appear in ( [ ( 28 ) ] ) for the following reasons : first we note that in the quantum treatment involving the airy function the turning `` point '' is blurred within a range of order @xmath17 m . second , as mentioned in sec . [ sec : i ] , we assume , as the authors of ref . @xcite did , that at a turning `` point '' ( here the region around @xmath169 ) the neutron starts out in a pure low - field seeking spin state ( + ) , i.e. from @xmath188 , @xmath189 . this implies that @xmath102 and the functions @xmath190 and @xmath176 , derived from @xmath191 and @xmath192 through eq . ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) , tend to 0 as @xmath193 ( in practice , for @xmath20 just a few @xmath17 m above the classical turning point ) . it was also mentioned earlier , that the wkb function used here for @xmath102 is just the asymptotic representation of the airy function @xmath194 which does satisfy the initial condition without any constant added since @xmath194 and @xmath195 vanish for @xmath193 . as a result , there is no lower - limit contribution to @xmath196 in ( [ ( 28 ) ] ) , and the same is true also for the functions @xmath159 and @xmath103 derived below by further integration ( in equations ( [ ( 29 ) ] ) and ( [ ( 32 ) ] ) ) . we can also argue that , due to the factor @xmath197 in @xmath198 ( defined following ( [ ( 26 ) ] ) ) , a wave containing a term derived from a finite integration constant in ( [ ( 28 ) ] ) would diverge at the endpoint @xmath199 of integration , where @xmath200 , and therefore must be zero , in the same way as in total reflection a wave increasing exponentially inside the medium must have amplitude zero . the singularity is avoided only by setting the integration constant in ( [ ( 28 ) ] ) equal to zero . remembering the definition @xmath201 , we integrate eq . ( [ ( 28 ) ] ) once more to obtain @xmath202 in ( [ ( 29 ) ] ) , we have defined @xmath203 it follows from the definition of @xmath163 and @xmath162 in eq . ( [ ( 17 ) ] ) that @xmath204 depends only on the magnitude @xmath205 of the local magnetic field . from the symmetry of the problem it follows that motion in the opposite direction , from the lower turning point at @xmath199 upward to @xmath169 gives the same function @xmath159 as in the last form of eq . ( [ ( 29 ) ] ) , except that the phase term @xmath206 is replaced by @xmath207 and @xmath208 is replaced by its complex conjugate @xmath209 . @xmath210 is a phase factor of unit amplitude , which arises due to the shift of reference point for @xmath211 from @xmath169 to @xmath199 when we change from downward to upward motion . none of these differences affect the squared magnitude @xmath212 which measures the probability to find the neutron in the spin - flipped state at height @xmath20 . an explicit expression for @xmath210 will be given following eq . ( [ ( 44 ) ] ) . we can compare our eq . ( [ ( 29 ) ] ) for the depolarization amplitude @xmath213 with the corresponding result in equations ( 31 - 35 ) of ref . @xcite , where only the case @xmath168 was analyzed . this corresponds to setting @xmath214 in our analysis . apart from this difference , our eq . ( [ ( 29 ) ] ) can be obtained from eq . ( 35 ) of @xcite by multiplying the latter by the factor @xmath215 . the magnitude of this factor is close to unity if @xmath141 is only slightly less than @xmath142 . for fairly high - energy ucns this is the case for most of the path between the turning points , but not near these points . this minor difference appears to be due to the neglect , in ref . @xcite , of @xmath216 in the derivation of their eq . ( 31 ) . the main difference between the results of @xcite and our numbers , obtained below , is due to the restriction of the previous work to @xmath168 . our analysis of the depolarization current and depolarization rate for magnetically stored ucns yields a loss @xmath310 decades larger for a typical velocity @xmath67 up to @xmath217 m / s than the range of values , @xmath218 to @xmath13 given in ref . @xcite for @xmath219 . we can now insert @xmath159 from ( [ ( 29 ) ] ) into ( [ ( 24 ) ] ) to determine the wave function @xmath103 for spin - flipped ucns . for the downward motion , this gives @xmath220 the phase @xmath149 ( with the index @xmath221 ) indicates that this wave for the ( @xmath143 ) spin state propagates , not with wave number @xmath162 , but with the same wave number @xmath163 as the ( + ) spin state , as it should . using @xmath222 we can verify that the function ( [ ( 32 ) ] ) solves equation ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) , starting from a pure ( + ) spin state , as described following eq . ( [ ( 28 ) ] ) . on a more formal basis , eq . ( [ ( 32 ) ] ) represents a particular solution to ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) and we could add to ( [ ( 32 ) ] ) any solution @xmath223 of the homogeneous equation @xmath224 corresponding to ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) . in the wkb framework , these solutions are @xmath225 with arbitrary constants @xmath226 . these functions represent a constant current in the upward ( downward ) direction for the + ( @xmath143 ) sign . thus the same current enters and leaves the storage space , resulting in a zero contribution to the net flux out which corresponds to the depolarization loss as described below . as an example , such a homogeneous term may represent a neutron that has undergone a spin flip on the way up , proceeds past @xmath169 until it reaches its reversal point in the gravitational field and , on its way down , traverses the storage space without contributing to further depolarization . reverting to solution ( [ ( 32 ) ] ) without added terms , we associate the net depolarization over the path from upper turning point @xmath169 to @xmath199 with the current of spin - flipped ucns at the endpoint @xmath199 , which is consistent with the interpretation in ref . this current represents the net flux out of the storage space since no flux enters at @xmath169 . ) multiplied by @xmath227 , as a function of neutron position for drop heights @xmath144 = 450 mm and 100 mm , stabilization field parameter @xmath228 = 0.005 t , and neutron velocity component @xmath67 = 3 m / s or zero . the sharp peak occurs in the region where the gradient of field angle @xmath84 is largest.,width=291 ] at an arbitrary position @xmath20 along the way the current @xmath229 is given by @xcite @xmath230.\ ] ] for function ( [ ( 32 ) ] ) we have @xmath231 and thus the current as a function of position @xmath20 between @xmath199 and @xmath169 becomes @xmath232 the function @xmath233 corresponds to the depolarization probability of ref . it is plotted in fig . [ fig : two ] for ucns with energy for vertical motion determined by the `` drop heights '' @xmath234 cm and 45 cm ( @xmath144 was defined following eq . ( [ ( 17 ) ] ) ) , a bias magnetic field @xmath228 = 0.005 t and @xmath67 = 3 m / s . as in fig . 3 of @xcite we see a sharp peak at the @xmath20-position where @xmath235 is large , and a decrease as the particle drops further down . the third curve in fig . [ fig : two ] is for @xmath144 = 45 cm , @xmath228 = 0.005 t and @xmath67 = 0 . the peak value and the decrease on the upper side are quite similar . below the peak position the curve for @xmath67 = 0 decreases faster than for @xmath67 = 3 m / s . the current leaving the storage space at @xmath236 is @xmath237 @xmath238 where the index @xmath239 refers to the values at @xmath236 and the last form of eq . ( [ ( 35 ) ] ) uses the fact that @xmath163 vanishes at the turning points . in the analysis of ref . @xcite for @xmath168 only this vanishing term ( @xmath240 ) appeared , and a higher order of approximation as well as numerical integration were used to estimate the depolarization probability . the result was a very small value which is negligible compared to the second term given in the last form of ( [ ( 35 ) ] ) , even for values of @xmath67 as small as 0.1 m / s . the dependence of ( [ ( 35 ) ] ) on the primary field variables is established by noting that @xmath241 , @xmath242 and @xmath243 , where @xmath244 is the frequency of the halbach field as seen by the moving ucn . for upward motion from @xmath199 to @xmath169 we get the same result for the current as in ( [ ( 35 ) ] ) except that all indices @xmath239 are replaced by @xmath245 , i.e. , the quantities relevant for the spin - flipped current leaving the system at the upper turning point are determined by the field angle @xmath246 and by @xmath247 at @xmath169 . the combined depolarization loss for one reflection on the magnetic field , i.e. for one complete round trip down and up , is determined by @xmath248 to approximate the actual situation in magnetic ucn storage , where the ucns have positive and negative velocities in any direction and , for a low - energy maxwell spectrum , with uniform probability per unit of @xmath249 and @xmath127 ( since the phase space density is constant ) , we take the mean value of @xmath250 in ( [ ( 36 ) ] ) for the spectral interval @xmath251 with the result @xmath252 as a final step in this analysis of depolarization in the wkb approximation we establish the explicit connection between the loss current ( [ ( 37 ) ] ) and the rate of depolarization , @xmath253 , that is observable as a contribution to the decay rate ( but should be negligible compared to the neutron @xmath4-decay rate in a neutron lifetime measurement ) . for given neutron energy for vertical motion , i.e. fixed turning levels at @xmath199 and @xmath169 , the depolarization rate ( in s@xmath129 ) is determined by the loss current ( [ ( 37 ) ] ) divided by the number of ucns in the field - repelled spin state present in the trap , @xmath254 we have used the square magnitude of the wkb form ( [ ( 16 ) ] ) for @xmath102 as the density . the factor 2 takes into account that both downward and upward moving ucns are in the trap at the same time . since @xmath255 and @xmath256 , the expression in ( [ ( 38 ) ] ) equals @xmath257 where @xmath258 is the time required for one round trip down and up . thus , the depolarization rate is @xmath259 where we have inserted ( [ ( 37 ) ] ) for the current in the last step . this shows that the loss current ( [ ( 37 ) ] ) of spin - flipped ucns is the loss per round trip , i.e. for one bounce in the magnetic field . this interpretation is consistent with the interpretation in ref . @xcite . to compare to actual experiments storing polarized ( + ) ucns in a broad velocity range in three dimensions , we have to average ( [ ( 39 ) ] ) also over @xmath68 and @xmath260 . averaging over @xmath68 is trivial since ( [ ( 39 ) ] ) does not depend on @xmath68 . averaging over @xmath260 can be achieved as follows . as a measure of @xmath260 for a stored ucn we could take its value at any height within the confinement range , but the most convenient choice of reference plane is the neutral plane at @xmath261 where the gravitational force is compensated by the magnetic force pushing upward , i.e. where @xmath262 . this is the plane where the ucns with the lowest energy for vertical motion reside . in our field model , a ucn with vertical velocity @xmath263 in the neutral plane floats or moves along the plane at constant speed . in actual confinement fields as in @xcite they would follow closed or open paths on the curved neutral surface . for small values of @xmath264 the vertical motion is a classical harmonic oscillation with natural frequency @xmath265 where @xmath266 is the net downward acceleration . this implies that for small oscillations about the neutral plane the time for a round trip becomes @xmath267 . for larger vertical velocities the oscillator potential is strongly anharmonic but the drop height @xmath144 , used originally as a measure of energy for vertical motion , is unambiguously determined by @xmath268 . therefore , if we plot the depolarization rate ( [ ( 39 ) ] ) versus @xmath268 , rather than @xmath144 , the mean height of this curve in the range from @xmath269 to its maximum value for the stored ucn spectrum directly gives the average value of depolarization rate for a maxwell spectrum . ( the trap loading process used in an actual experiment may induce deviations from the maxwell spectrum . ) ) , and neutron @xmath4-decay rate ( for a lifetime of 882s ) , plotted as a function of vertical velocity component @xmath270 in the neutral plane ( where the gravitational and magnetic forces are balanced ) . @xmath270 is normalized with the constant @xmath271 which is determined by the field magnitude in the neutral plane . the curve for @xmath228 = 0.005 t is plotted to scale @xmath272 and the curve for @xmath228 = 0.05 t is plotted with magnification factor @xmath273 @xmath274 . their difference by about two orders of magnitude shows the strong suppression of depolarization by a stabilization field of sufficient strength . for a maxwell spectrum , the mean height of the curves over the range of the abscissa , from 0 to 2.5 for @xmath275 t and from 0 to 4.7 for @xmath276 t , directly determines the average over the full spectrum ( here for @xmath277 m / s @xmath278 @xmath279 m / s and drop heights @xmath144 up to 450 mm).,width=291 ] such a plot is presented in fig . [ fig : three ] where we have normalized @xmath268 to @xmath280 , the @xmath20-velocity for the spin - flipped state on the neutral plane for @xmath281 . @xmath282 is solely determined by the field magnitude @xmath283 on the neutral plane . the parameters used are : @xmath284 cm , @xmath285 t and @xmath286 t and @xmath287 m / s . for these parameters the mean depolarization rate , normalized to the @xmath4-decay rate @xmath288 , is @xmath289 for @xmath276 t and about two orders of magnitude less for @xmath275 t. it might come as a surprise that the largest contribution to the depolarization rate originates from ucns with fairly low energy of vertical motion . they move through the field almost horizontally , with small vertical oscillations about the neutral plane . the result is plausible since these ucns spend the largest fraction of time in the region where the field rotates rapidly in the reference frame of the laterally moving neutron . in section [ sec : iv.b ] we will analyze the same problem of depolarization in magnetic storage of ucns using the semiclassical method and compare the two approaches . next we apply the quantum approximation to analyze the depolarization in reflection of polarized neutrons on a non - magnetic mirror immersed in a non - uniform magnetic field . between the upper and lower turning surfaces at @xmath169 and @xmath199 for a given ucn energy for vertical motion . the reflected spin - flipped wave consists of the two components in eq . ( [ ( 42 ) ] ) : ( a ) the particular solution @xmath290 which is the same as for a wave moving upward from the lower turning point at ii in the absence of the mirror ; ( b ) the homogeneous wave @xmath291 induced at the mirror surface by the wave incident from above , starting from the upper turning level at point i. the position iii of the virtual image of i below the mirror determines a phase angle.,width=291 ] in sec . [ sec : i ] we mentioned two examples where the possible depolarization of ucns in total reflection from a non - magnetic wall , like copper , is of major importance : ( a ) ucn experiments on spin anisotropy parameters in neutron decay , such as the neutron - electron spin correlation coefficient @xmath0 @xcite ; and ( b ) ucn polarizers based on transmission through a high magnetic field . depolarization in mirror reflection has been investigated theoretically in ref . we will study aspects of this problem by imagining an ideal , non - magnetic mirror inserted horizontally into our magnetic model field at various heights @xmath292 , as shown in fig . [ fig : four ] , and comparing the depolarization per bounce on this mirror with that in the field without the mirror . the reflecting mirror surface at @xmath292 lies between the upper and lower turning points @xmath169 and @xmath199 for ucns . we use index @xmath106 to denote the quantities at the reflecting mirror surface and have assumed that the ucns have given lateral velocities @xmath67 and @xmath68 and a fixed energy for vertical motion . an ideal ucn mirror has reflection amplitude @xmath293 and reflectivity @xmath294 . the phase angle @xmath295 depends on the limit @xmath296 of total reflection and , for the system at hand , on the vertical component of incident wave vector , @xmath297 , which is the same for both wave components , @xmath191 and @xmath4 . we will see that the depolarization at the mirror is independent of @xmath298 , i.e. , it should be virtually the same for any low loss ( almost ideal ) mirror material . on physical grounds , no abrupt change of depolarization probability @xmath299 is expected since the dwell time of @xmath300 s inside the wall is much shorter than the larmor precession period ( 1 @xmath17s for @xmath301 mt ) which sets the time scale for any change . as in the previous sections , we assume that the particle started out from an upper turning level @xmath169 in a pure ( + ) spin state . on incidence at @xmath302 its wave function has acquired a depolarized component given by eq . ( [ ( 32 ) ] ) : @xmath303 where @xmath304 has been defined in ( [ ( 30 ) ] ) . the evolution of @xmath103 following reflection is determined by the inhomogeneous differential equation ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) : @xmath305 \alpha(y),\ ] ] where we replaced the @xmath2 sign in ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) by + since the reflected wave is propagating upward . the solution to ( [ ( 41 ) ] ) can be written as a superposition @xmath306 of a particular solution , @xmath307 , and the general solution @xmath308 of the homogeneous equation @xmath309 the amplitude multiplying @xmath310 is adjusted to satisfy initial conditions . a particular solution @xmath290 for downward motion has been given as eq . ( [ ( 32 ) ] ) . for the mirror - reflected beam we need the corresponding solution for upward motion . it follows from the discussion in sec . [ sec : iii.b.1 ] that this particular solution is @xmath311 the phase factor @xmath312 , with @xmath313 , arises as follows : for the mirror reflection problem we choose a time axis with @xmath314 at the upper turning point @xmath169 and increasing as the motion proceeds . however , the corresponding time @xmath315 , chosen in sec . [ sec : iii.b.1 ] for the upward motion , starts from @xmath316 at @xmath199 ( not from @xmath169 ) . the times required to reach a given particle position are related through @xmath317 , where , as before , @xmath258 is the time for a round trip down and up . the phase factor @xmath210 arises due to this difference in the time coordinates . the homogeneous equation ( [ ( 45 ) ] ) has two solutions but only one , @xmath318 , corresponds to upward wave propagation , as required for the reflected wave . the plane wave form is valid only near the mirror surface where @xmath142 is considered constant on the scale of the neutron wavelength . thus , in the framework of the wkb approximation , we use the homogeneous solution @xmath319 where the constant @xmath320 is to be adjusted to match the outgoing wave ( [ ( 42 ) ] ) to the wave @xmath321 excited by the incoming beam . expression ( [ ( 46 ) ] ) is the incoming wave ( [ ( 32 ) ] ) multiplied by the phase factor @xmath322 where @xmath323 is the reflection amplitude . the factor @xmath324 is due to a shift of time scales similar to that defined following eq . ( [ ( 44 ) ] ) but now referring to mirror reflection with start from the upper turning point @xmath169 versus start from its virtual image at @xmath325 below the mirror surface , as shown in fig . [ fig : four ] . now we match the outgoing wave @xmath326 ( from ( [ ( 44 ) ] ) and ( [ ( 45 ) ] ) ) to the wave @xmath327 at the mirror surface @xmath292 ( from ( [ ( 46 ) ] ) ) to determine the constant @xmath320 , with the result @xmath328 @xmath329 \exp(-i\phi_{-m}).\ ] ] thus the mirror reflected wave becomes @xmath330 \exp(-i\phi_{-m } ) \exp\big(i\phi_-(y)\big)\big\}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term in the braces represents an outgoing wave with wave number @xmath331 and the second one with wave number @xmath162 . to calculate the outgoing current we also need the derivative @xmath332\exp(-i\phi_{-m } ) \exp\big(i\phi_-(y)\big)\big\}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the current propagating in the upward direction is obtained from @xcite @xmath333,\ ] ] and the result is a sum of slowly varying terms representing the measurable depolarization . there are also fast oscillating terms with phase @xmath334 $ ] which would be averaged to zero by a detector of spin - flipped ucns except within a narrow range of order @xmath335 , i.e. , of a few wavelengths above the mirror . with the same proviso , mixed terms @xmath336 ( or @xmath337 can also be dropped since the phase factors @xmath210 and @xmath338 depend sensitively on the exact position of the mirror and the exact distance between upper and lower turning points . in practice these quantities are blurred by geometrical imperfections as well as the finite spread in ucn energy . thus @xmath210 and @xmath338 can be considered statistically independent of one another . as a result we obtain for the measurable average current @xmath339 to measure the depolarization per one complete bounce on the mirror from upper turning point down and back up to the upper turning point , we insert @xmath340 for the detector position and obtain @xmath341 this corresponds to expression ( [ ( 36 ) ] ) for one bounce in the magnetic field . in ( [ ( 52 ) ] ) we have used @xmath342 and we note that in typical cases the first term in ( [ ( 52 ) ] ) is negligible . we have assumed that the ucns are incident on the mirror from above , i.e. are confined to the space @xmath343 . if , instead , they impinge from below at @xmath344 ( now the lower mirror surface ) and are confined to the space @xmath345 , the expressions ( [ ( 51 ) ] ) and ( [ ( 52 ) ] ) ( now for @xmath346 , not @xmath347 ) remain the same except that in ( [ ( 52 ) ] ) the index @xmath245 is replaced by @xmath239 . we will discuss these results in greater detail in sections [ sec : iv.c ] and [ sec : vi ] . the semi - classical schrdinger equation describes the particle in time @xmath348 , rather than in space coordinates . the particle is assumed to follow a known classical path , so the field variable @xmath109 is considered a known function of @xmath348 . we again choose the quantization axis along the position - dependent direction of @xmath109 , for which the mutually orthogonal basis vectors @xmath77 and @xmath78 are given in ( [ ( 6 ) ] ) and the wave function for the ( + ) and ( @xmath143 ) state is @xmath349 but these quantities are now considered to be functions of @xmath348 , rather than of space variables . as before , the spin flip probability @xmath350 is considered small compared to the probability @xmath351 1 to find the neutron in the storable ( + ) spin state . in this approximation the schrdinger equation reads @xcite @xmath352 where the hamiltonian @xmath79 for spin interaction was given in ( [ ( 3 ) ] ) . we denote time derivatives by a dot and , using the notation and relations of sec . [ sec : iii.a ] and , from @xmath21 , @xmath353 , obtain @xmath354 and @xmath355 inserting into ( 54 ) and keeping only the dominant contributions we get for the terms with @xmath77 @xmath356 and for those with @xmath78 @xmath357 where @xmath358 is the larmor frequency . in practice , @xmath359 . equations ( [ ( 57)]-[(58 ) ] ) correspond to equations ( 14 ) and ( 15 ) of @xcite , but ( [ ( 58 ) ] ) contains the new phase factor @xmath360 ( as the quantum equivalent , eq . ( [ ( 12 ) ] ) , does ) and the term dependent on @xmath67 . equation ( [ ( 57 ) ] ) is solved by @xmath361 where @xmath362 is twice the phase angle accumulated since the start time @xmath363 . as for the quantum case , we assume that the motion starts at the upper or lower turning point with velocity @xmath364 , where @xmath365 const . and the constant @xmath14-component @xmath68 does not induce depolarization for our field model . @xmath366 implies @xmath367 at the start . as in @xcite , eq . ( [ ( 58 ) ] ) is solved using the ansatz @xmath368 , where @xmath369 , the new measure of depolarization amplitude @xcite , satisfies the relation @xmath370 since @xmath371 the factor @xmath372 is time dependent and therefore @xmath373 contributes to the energy . however , as noted before , @xmath374 is much smaller than @xmath375 and can be neglected in the same way small terms are neglected in the wkb approximation . ( [ ( 60 ) ] ) is readily integrated by parts : @xmath376 as for the quantum analog ( [ ( 28 ) ] ) of ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) , the right - hand side of eq . ( [ ( 61 ) ] ) does not include a term for the lower integration limit @xmath363 . as we will see , this leads to results matching those of the quantum approach . we again can argue , as in the discussion of eq . ( [ ( 28 ) ] ) , that in view of the airy - function character of the actual wave solution around the turning region , the initial time @xmath363 is a blurred quantity and the contribution from the lower limit of integration averages to zero . but a rigorous justification may be impossible within this semi - classical mix of ingredients as incongruent as classical and quantum mechanics are . we identify @xmath377 with the probability @xmath378 of finding the neutron in the spin - flipped state @xcite @xmath379 in the last step of eq . ( [ ( 62 ) ] ) we have used @xmath380 , and @xmath381 , since in our field model @xmath84 depends only on @xmath20 . the result ( [ ( 62 ) ] ) agrees with eq . ( [ ( 34 ) ] ) for the function @xmath382 which had also been identified as the depolarization probability . therefore we have full agreement also for the mean depolarization per bounce ( [ ( 37 ) ] ) and for the depolarization rate given in eq . ( [ ( 39 ) ] ) . in the next section we will see that the semi - classical and quantum approaches do not always produce exactly the same results , although a strong correlation between the two will be found also in this case . the semi - classical analysis of the mirror problem follows the same path as for the quantum case analyzed in sec . [ sec : iii.c ] . the crucial step again is matching the superposition of particular plus homogeneous solution for the ascending reflected beam , @xmath383 to the wave @xmath327 induced by the incident beam at the mirror surface at @xmath384 . in eq . ( [ ( 63 ) ] ) , @xmath385 is the general solution of the homogeneous equation @xmath386 , which corresponds to the inhomogeneous equation ( [ ( 58 ) ] ) with the direction of time reversed as described following eq . ( [ ( 44 ) ] ) . using the same sequence of terms as in ( [ ( 63 ) ] ) and the notation of sec . [ sec : iii.c ] , the matching condition @xmath387 reads @xmath388 where we have divided out the common factor @xmath389 . @xmath390 is the larmor frequency at the mirror position and @xmath391 , @xmath392 are statistically independent unitary phase factors similar to their quantum analogs @xmath210 , @xmath338 in ( [ ( 44 ) ] ) and ( [ ( 46 ) ] ) . solving for the constant @xmath320 of the homogeneous term and inserting into ( [ ( 63 ) ] ) gives @xmath393.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , taking the square magnitude of ( [ ( 65 ) ] ) and performing the same statistical averaging as for ( [ ( 50 ) ] ) , which includes setting @xmath394 and @xmath395 , we find for the probability of depolarization @xmath396\nonumber \\ & + \frac{1}{2\omega_{lm}^2 } \left[\dot\theta_m^2 + ( kv_x\sin\theta_m)^2\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] to facilitate comparison with the quantum result ( [ ( 51 ) ] ) we convert from time to space dependent variables @xmath397 , as for eq . ( [ ( 62 ) ] ) , and obtain @xmath398}{(k_{-m}^2 - k_{+m}^2)^2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is the same expression as ( [ ( 51 ) ] ) except that the factor @xmath399 for the second term on the right - hand side is missing . except for very low energy ucns hovering in the magnetic field , and for mirror position at a turning point , this factor is close to 1 . for a complete bounce on the mirror , starting from , and ending at , the upper turning point level @xmath169 we obtain @xmath400}{(k_{-m}^2-k_{+m}^2)^2 } .\ ] ] . we use eq . ( [ ( 52 ) ] ) for the quantum treatment ( qm ) and eq . ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) for the semi - classical approach . the plotted values are normalized by dividing ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) by ( [ ( 36 ) ] ) , the depolarization due to the field alone , and by the ratio of duration of one bounce with and without the mirror . the data show a strong enhancement of depolarization due to the mirror . the enhancement factor depends on incident ucn energy ( which increases with larger fall height @xmath144 ) and on the gradient @xmath401 of field angle @xmath84 at the mirror position . @xmath401 is largest in the region where the curves have their peak value which is of order @xmath402 for @xmath67 = 3 m / s . for the examples shown , the turning point levels are : @xmath403 mm , @xmath404 mm for @xmath405 mm and @xmath406 mm , @xmath407 mm for @xmath408 mm.,width=291 ] fig . [ fig : five ] shows the depolarization per bounce on the mirror in our model field as a function of mirror position @xmath292 . for the quantum treatment ( qm ) this probability is given by eq . ( [ ( 52 ) ] ) and for the semi - classical approach ( cl ) by eq . ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) . to separate the role of the non - magnetic mirror in the field from the depolarization due to the field alone we have divided ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) by ( [ ( 36 ) ] ) , the depolarization due to the field alone , and by the ratio of duration of one bounce with and without the mirror . fig . [ fig : five ] shows a strong enhancement due to the mirror . the enhancement factor depends on incident ucn energy ( which increases with larger fall height @xmath144 ) and on the gradient @xmath401 of field angle at the mirror position . @xmath401 is largest in the region where the curves have their peak . the enhancement reaches four orders of magnitude for @xmath409 m and @xmath410 m / s , and six decades for @xmath411 m / s . in the latter comparison , the role of lateral velocity component @xmath67 appears so large because the depolarization in the field alone vanishes for @xmath219 in our approximation ( [ ( 36 ) ] ) ( and is negligibly small in higher - order approximations @xcite ) , while the mirror depolarization remains finite for @xmath219 . the quantum and semi - classical results , compared for identical parameters by the dashed and dash - dotted curves in fig . [ fig : five ] , are quite similar . for the given parameters they differ by a few percent at most if we exclude the range within @xmath3 5 mm from a turning point . as for the quantum approach , the results ( [ ( 67 ) ] ) and ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) remain the same ( except for the index @xmath245 in ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) changing to @xmath239 ) if incidence on the mirror from above is replaced by incidence from below , with start from the lower turning point @xmath412 rather than from @xmath413 . in the next section we will show that for low ucn energies these analytical results can also be obtained by numerical integration of the basic differential equation . numerical integration does not rely on the wkb approximation . however , the lengthy integration over many oscillations of the wave function is plagued with the rounding errors and the error due to the finite step size . reasonable agreement of the two methods would be an indication that the results are reliable . the equation of motion of the wave function @xmath103 for spin flip is given by the second - order inhomogeneous differential equation ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) , @xmath414 \alpha(y ) , \nonumber\ ] ] with ( [ ( 16 ) ] ) @xmath415 and the + ( @xmath143 ) sign refers to motion upward ( downward ) . using the fourth - order runge kutta process , eq . ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) may be integrated numerically , starting from an initial point @xmath416 slightly above ( below ) the turning point @xmath146 . key is the suitable choice of initial values @xmath417 and @xmath418 . we choose the wkb solution which is given by ( [ ( 32 ) ] ) for downward motion . its extension to include also the upward path reads @xmath419 with derivative @xmath420 where @xmath421 and @xmath422 . @xmath208 has been defined in ( [ ( 30 ) ] ) . as discussed following ( [ ( 19 ) ] ) , near a turning point @xmath146 eq . ( [ ( 69 ) ] ) is based on the asymptotic form of the airy function wave solution @xmath423 , where the coefficient @xmath424 is adjusted to match ( [ ( 16 ) ] ) asymptotically . the constants @xmath425 and @xmath426 were defined following eq . ( [ ( 19 ) ] ) . since @xmath427 varies slowly , the constant value @xmath425 is a good approximation over hundreds of oscillations of the airy function , starting from @xmath428 . = 8 cm , @xmath228 = 0.05 t and @xmath67 = 3 m / s . direct numerical integration , represented by the solid curve , coincides with the analytic result shown by the dashed curve , with a maximum deviation of 1% over the entire range from upper to lower turning point ( @xmath429 mm , @xmath430 mm).,width=291 ] using initial values ( [ ( 69 ) ] ) and ( [ ( 70 ) ] ) , eq . ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) may be integrated numerically up to a point slightly before the next turning point , @xmath431 , is reached . the method fails at @xmath431 itself due to the divergence of @xmath432 . we calculate the current @xmath433 $ ] at every point along the integration path and fig . [ fig : six ] shows the result of downward integration for parameters @xmath434 cm , @xmath435 t , @xmath410 m / s and starting point at @xmath436 . we have tested that the solution is stable in a wide range of initial position from @xmath4372 to 20 . [ fig : six ] shows that the numerical result coincides with the analytical solution ( [ ( 69 ) ] ) , with maximum deviations of @xmath438 over the entire range including the far endpoint @xmath199 . this consistency at the lower turning point is vital since the current leaving there from the storage space is identified with the depolarization probability for the move from top to bottom . to be specific , this depolarization probability @xmath439 is obtained by extrapolating the numerical solution over the short distance of order @xmath440 to the next endpoint @xmath431 with the result @xmath441 for the case shown in fig . [ fig : six ] . the extrapolation at @xmath442 mm is straightforward since the current shows a smooth behavior in the entire integration range . the same level of agreement within @xmath443 is obtained for the upward motion which is represented by the same curve of fig . [ fig : six ] , but the extrapolation for the loss current is now made at the upper end @xmath444 mm ( and this contribution is much smaller in the case shown , but it is comparable for smaller drop heights ) . we found agreement within 1% between the various methods also for other parameters @xmath445 within the range of interest . there is one exception . for the strictly vertical mode of motion analyzed in ref . @xcite , where @xmath219 , the analytical solution vanishes and the numerical solution for the intercept is at least four orders of magnitude smaller than for @xmath410 m / s . in this case the numerical precision is insufficient to determine a reliable value of depolarization probability . however , this is inconsequential since extremely small values of @xmath67 make a negligible contribution to the mean depolarization rate in a broad ucn spectrum . we add one remark . if the explicit analytical solutions ( [ ( 69)]-[(70 ) ] ) for @xmath4 and @xmath446 were not known , we could use , for the numerical integration , initial values derived solely from the properties of the airy function solution near the turning points . in these regions the second derivative @xmath170 in eq . ( [ ( 23 ) ] ) is negligible compared with @xmath447 since @xmath448 . therefore , @xmath449 \alpha(y)/k_-^2(y)$ ] is a good approximation . it differs from ( [ ( 69 ) ] ) only by the multiplier @xmath450 $ ] which is close to 1 at either turning point since @xmath163 vanishes there . it turns out that these modified initial values give the same results for @xmath103 at both endpoints , and therefore the same depolarization probability , as the more exact method . however , the function @xmath103 will be somewhat different in the range between the endpoints , where @xmath170 can not be neglected . we may summarize the results on depolarization in magnetic storage as follows : the fact that the three methods used agree ( quantum and semi - classical analysis as well as direct numerical integration ) appears to be a good indication that the approximations made were justified . for ucn reflection from a non - magnetic mirror in a magnetic field the analytical results given in ( [ ( 52 ) ] ) and ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) are similar but not identical . we used numerical integration for the reflected beam , starting from initial conditions ( [ ( 46 ) ] ) at the mirror surface and note that in this case the extrapolation to the next turning point is less straightforward since the curve for current shows , superimposed on a smooth variation , fast oscillations due to beating between two wave components : one propagating with wave number @xmath163 and the other with @xmath162 . this is expected for the superposition of these two waves in eq . ( [ ( 48 ) ] ) . the numerical results are generally consistent with the analytical expressions but not precise enough to decide whether the semi - classical approximation ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) or the quantum approximation ( [ ( 52 ) ] ) is more reliable . depolarization in high precision neutron lifetime experiments using magnetic confinement must either be negligible or else very small and quantitatively understood . using two analytical methods based on ref . @xcite and direct numerical integration we have analyzed the depolarization per bounce and the depolarization rate ( per s ) for ucns stored in a model magnetic field configuration . our magnetic field model is similar to the system envisaged for the `` bathtub '' project @xcite which uses a halbach array of permanent magnets . our model is simplified to a configuration with translational symmetry in both horizontal directions ( @xmath14 and @xmath15 ) and an ideal halbach field whose magnitude depends only on the vertical distance @xmath20 from the horizontal magnet surface . the parameters for the halbach field are the same as those proposed in ref . our analysis shows that depolarization is mainly caused by the rotating halbach field the ucns see as they move through the field with finite lateral velocity component @xmath67 , not by the small field ripple due to imperfections of the halbach system . therefore we do not expect the simplification of the model to affect the depolarization in a significant way . however , the role of the additional horizontal stabilization field @xmath22 perpendicular to the halbach field @xmath451 is critical . it has to be strong enough to suppress depolarization to an acceptable level . the main purpose of this work was to determine tolerance limits for its magnitude @xmath66 . our analysis extends that of ref . @xcite by including arbitrary ucn orbits in 3d space whereas the analysis in @xcite was restricted to purely vertical motion . as a main result of the extension we find that the lateral @xmath15-component of motion in the plane of the halbach field makes the dominant contribution to depolarization while the depolarization due to the vertical motion is insignificant . as a result , some previous estimates of depolarization probability may have been overoptimistic . for the parameters of @xcite ( 0.05 - 0.1 t for @xmath228 ) we estimate on the basis of fig . [ fig : three ] that even a measurement of the neutron lifetime with precision @xmath452 should be possible ( disregarding other potential limitations ) but the safety margin may be smaller than previously expected . systems with smaller stabilization field , as possibly that of ref . @xcite , where @xmath66 has not been specified , may require a separate analysis since they use a cylindrical rather than planar field distribution . however , the main result of the present work is independent of geometrical details : the depolarization loss is determined , not by the largest rotation frequency of @xmath136 as seen by the ucns as they traverse the field , but by the conditions at the turning points where the spin - flipped neutrons can leave the storage system . this is an important point which may appear to contradict the common view , but is also implied by the work of ref . our interpretation of the present results is as follows : the measurable depolarization is not directly caused by critical spots within the storage volume , where the @xmath136-field has a small magnitude @xmath8 and rotates fast in the moving reference frame . all that matters for depolarization are the field conditions at the turning points where the storable ucns are reflected back into the storage space while the spin - flipped fraction leaves the trap . the loss current in eq . ( [ ( 37 ) ] ) is determined by the value of @xmath453 at such a surface . this factor is large for fast field variation ( @xmath454 ) seen by the neutron moving in a horizontal direction ( parallel to the turning surface ) , as well as for small @xmath8 since @xmath455 from ( [ ( 31 ) ] ) is directly proportional to @xmath8 at a turning point where @xmath151 . it also increases quadratically with sin@xmath456 , i.e. with the magnitude @xmath457 of the halbach field at a turning surface . if a broad spectrum of ucns is stored the critical points will be of importance in the sense that some , usually ucns with very low energy of vertical motion , may have a turning surface near such areas and therefore make a large contribution . in fact , the low - energy ucns make the largest contribution to depolarization seen in the peaks in fig . [ fig : three ] , and they are the reason why a larger stabilization field @xmath66 suppresses the net depolarization very effectively . fig . [ fig : three ] shows @xmath458 , the depolarization rate divided by the @xmath4-decay rate , as a function of normalized vertical velocity @xmath268 in the neutral plane , where gravity and the magnetic force are balanced . both curves , for @xmath228 = 0.05 t and for @xmath228 = 0.005 t , are peaked at small values of @xmath459 . thus the ucns most in danger of suffering depolarization are confined to a narrow space of @xmath310 cm about the neutral plane , moving laterally as they float in the field ( for @xmath460 or oscillate up and down about the neutral plane with small amplitude . the magnetic field configurations and neutron orbits in actual or projected 3d magneto - gravitational ucn confinement systems @xcite are more complex than in our field model . however , for some of these concepts the 1d approximation of our model appears to be justified . for the bathtub " system @xcite , the neutral plane of our model , about which low - energy ucns oscillate , corresponds to a strongly anisotropic oscillator potential in the vicinity of the minimum of potential @xmath461 for the low - field seeking spin state . for @xmath276 t the minimum is located about 1.8 cm up from the lowest point of the double - curved surface of permanent magnets of ref . @xcite . for this anisotropic oscillator , the frequency for oscillations in the vertical @xmath20-direction , @xmath462 s@xmath129 , is 22 times larger than for the @xmath14-direction , @xmath463 s@xmath129 where the radius of curvature is @xmath464 m. for the @xmath15-direction , with its asymmetry , there are two curvatures ( 0.5 and 1.0 m ) and , therefore , two ratios replacing 22 : 13 on one side ( @xmath465 ) and 18 for @xmath466 . since all these factors are large , the neutrons move almost freely , on a relative scale , in the peripheral @xmath15- and @xmath14-directions and , therefore , our 1d model should be a good approximation . as a result , we expect the peripheral velocity in the plane of the halbach field , which corresponds to @xmath467 in the model , to be the main source of depolarization . in the cylindrical field geometries of references @xcite , the field magnitude @xmath8 varies more slowly in space . thus , the oscillator is less anisotropic , the degrees of freedom of motion in different coordinate directions are less decoupled and a more complex analysis may be required . to the extent that qualitative features of our model may still apply we expect that the main source of depolarization would be a large peripheral ucn velocity perpendicular to the cylinder axis . in this case , the peripheral velocity corresponds to the component @xmath467 of the model . besides depolarization of magnetically confined ucns we also studied depolarization in ucn reflection on a non - magnetic mirror immersed in a magnetic field . the field was our model field into which we conceptually inserted an ideal neutron mirror horizontally at a variable height . the problem of possible depolarization in mirror reflection is of paramount importance in ucn experiments on the asymmetry parameter @xmath0 in neutron decay @xcite and it is also encountered in high - field ucn polarizers . depolarization is expected since the adiabaticity condition may be violated due to the abrupt change of flight direction at the reflection point , thus @xmath468 changes abruptly . this problem has first been studied in ref . @xcite by adapting the majorana semi - classical approach @xcite to the mirror geometry . in our analysis the three methods used ( quantum approximation , semi - classical and numerical approach ) gave identical results for depolarization in magnetic ucn storage . for the mirror reflection problem the quantum result ( [ ( 52 ) ] ) and the semi - classical result ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) are very similar but not identical , as shown in fig . [ fig : five ] . the numerical method is not accurate enough in this case to distinguish between the two . the semiclassical result ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) lacks the factor @xmath399 which would cause a divergence if the mirror is placed at a turning point height ( since @xmath469 in this region ) . between the turning points the difference is minor and the common result is as follows : depolarization in mirror reflection , averaged over field directions as in our model field , is determined mainly by the second term of eq . ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) . it increases with the frequency of field variation ( @xmath470 ) seen by the neutron moving along the in - plane @xmath15-direction . it also increases quadratically with the sine of the field angle @xmath84 , which is a measure of halbach field strength @xmath471 , and with its gradient , @xmath472 , at the mirror location . depolarization strongly decreases with increasing field strength @xmath8 at the mirror ( @xmath473 ) . [ fig : five ] shows that , for @xmath67 = 3 m / s , the magnitude of depolarization per one bounce on the mirror is up to @xmath119 times larger than the depolarization per bounce in the magnetic field without the mirror . the depolarization on the mirror has its peak value at the vertical location where the depolarization probability plotted in fig . [ fig : two ] also has its peak . in fact , comparing expression ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) for depolarization at the mirror with the result ( [ ( 34 ) ] ) for the field alone ( and neglecting the small first term on the right - hand side of ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) ) we realize that the mirror acts like a polarization analyzer inserted into the particle beam moving through the * b*-field . this interpretation also holds for a non - horizontal or curved mirror since the second term on the right - hand side of ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) is independent of the orientation of the reflecting surface element . in this case , the second term should be averaged over the mirror extension . in cases where many successive wall reflections take place in a weak , non - uniform magnetic field , the depolarization may become significant . comparing our result ( [ ( 66 ) ] ) with equations ( 10 - 11 ) of ref . @xcite we note that both results have the square of the larmor frequency @xmath9 at the mirror position in the denominator . however , a quantitative comparison is difficult since the magnetic field variations assumed in the two approaches are different . in either analysis , no depolarization is expected for a uniform magnetic field . our field model may be too specific to allow a quantitative comparison with the data @xcite on depolarization in ucn reflection from various mirror materials ( like beryllium or samples with diamond - like carbon coating ) . expression ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) does not depend on specific properties of the mirror , as long as it is a good , nearly loss - free ucn reflector . therefore , ( [ ( 68 ) ] ) could explain , without having to invoke any anomalies @xcite , the remarkable similarity and temperature independence of depolarization probabilities measured for different wall materials . such independence would be expected if the samples were exposed to the same non - uniform magnetic field . our results , which were obtained as straightforward solutions to the spin - dependent schrdinger equation , may also provide an alternative to the discussion of new short - range , spin - dependent forces as a possible pathway to explaining the depolarization data for stored ucns . for a recent comprehensive review of fundamental physics with neutrons see @xcite .

we analyze the depolarization of ultracold neutrons confined in a magnetic field configuration similar to those used in existing or proposed magneto - gravitational storage experiments aiming at a precise measurement of the neutron lifetime . we use an extension of the semi - classical majorana approach as well as an approximate quantum mechanical analysis , both pioneered by walstrom _ et al_. [ nucl . instr . meth . phys . res . a 599 , 82 ( 2009 ) ] . in contrast with this previous work we do not restrict the analysis to purely vertical modes of neutron motion . the lateral motion is shown to cause the predominant depolarization loss in a magnetic storage trap . the system studied also allowed us to estimate the depolarization loss suffered by ultracold neutrons totally reflected on a non - magnetic mirror immersed in a magnetic field . this problem is of preeminent importance in polarized neutron decay studies such as the measurement of the asymmetry parameter @xmath0 using ultracold neutrons , and it may limit the efficiency of ultracold neutron polarizers based on passage through a high magnetic field .

1609.02933

single - ended optical fiber link characterization techniques have been a point of major focus since the late seventies when barnosky and others demonstrated that , by measuring the rayleigh backscattered signal from a pulse sent into the optical fiber , one could extract its physical properties such as attenuation coefficient and eventual power losses along its length @xcite . presently , different techniques for optical fiber characterization are available and standardized such as the optical time domain reflectometry ( otdr ) and frequency domain reflectometry ( ofdr ) @xcite . in any case , embedding any of these fiber - monitoring techniques in passive optical networks ( pon ) systems remains a challenge in terms of technology and cost - effectiveness not to mention the in - service monitoring paradigm @xcite . otdr makes use of high - power short optical pulses while measuring the rayleigh backscattered power as a function of time , its spatial resolution being defined by the duration of the optical pulse . ofdr may present two different flavors : coherent - ofdr ( c - ofdr ) , where the wavelength of a low - power continuous - wave coherent light source is swept and the heterodyne beat between the backscattered light signal and a reference reflection is measured ; and incoherent - ofdr ( i - ofdr ) , where a radio - frequency optical sub - carrier frequency is swept and , once again , a heterodyne beat between the detected backscattered signal and the modulating signal is measured . in both c- and i - ofdr , the spatial profile of the fiber is obtained from the fourier transform of the detected ofdr signal and the frequency range covered by the optical sweep limits its resolution . a very complete review of frequency domain optical network analysis , where the distinctions between c- and i - ofdr , their pro s , and con s are highlighted , may be found in @xcite . in terms of the apparatus necessary to guarantee reasonable high dynamic range and spatial resolution , otdr and ofdr differ greatly : on one hand , otdr must employ high bandwidth detection in order to increase spatial resolution since it is directly proportional to the probe pulse width , which , in general , has a trade off associated to a reduction of dynamic range since the energy is reduced along with pulse duration @xcite . frequency domain techniques usually make use of a frequency sweep at the source level and a fourier transform which provides the conversion from frequency to distance based on the sweeping rate . c - ofdr does not require high frequency response detectors since the detection is performed in the base band , but highly coherent sources are needed in order to achieve long range in optical fibers @xcite . on the other hand , the resolution of the frequency domain techniques , such as in i - ofdr , are given by the frequency sweep range , which imposes high bandwidth detection bringing up again the trade - off between resolution and dynamic range . high resolution is bandwidth demanding whereas high sensitivity imposes low resolution @xcite . incoherent ofdr measurements have been extensively studied in @xcite and rayleigh scattering has been successfully observed . the mathematical model developed in the time - domain concludes that the amplitude of the rayleigh scattering signal within an optical sub - carrier is inversely proportional to the sub - carrier s frequency ( hereby referred to as the _ high - frequency issue _ ) , which complicates signal acquisition when there is a requirement for high spatial resolution . recently , however , urban _ et al . _ @xcite showed that fiber monitoring can be accomplished in a sub - carrier multiplexed pon ( scm - pon ) context by measuring the rayleigh backscattered signal from a high - frequency ( up to 220mhz was reported ) inside a 20mhz band , which translates into a 10 meter achievable spatial resolution . the method resembles the step - frequency method presented in the late eighties by nakayama _ @xcite however , instead of disregarding the rayleigh backscattering and focusing on reflective events as in the latter , the effect of the backscattered signal was exploited at its full potential in @xcite . an alternative to the _ high - frequency issue _ of i - ofdr rayleigh backscattering measurements would be to perform the fiber monitoring in the low - frequency range , up to a few hundred kilohertz , where the @xmath0 hindering effect is not too harsh . the downside of this approach would be the diminished spatial resolution associated to one s measurement when the fourier transform of the acquired signal is taken . in order to overcome this preclusion and , at the same time , improve the signal - to - noise ratio at the receiver s end , we tackle the fiber characterization procedure in a different manner : instead of taking the fourier transform we attempt to fit the resulting backscattered signal with its associated mathematical model , which , in order to simplify its description , we model as a spatial - dependent phasor and arrive at an equivalent expression to the one found in @xcite , but in the frequency domain . by employing a fitting procedure developed in matlab@xmath1 , we show that not only a fiber fault s position but also its magnitude can be identified with high precision . the remainder of the article is laid out as follows . in section [ expset ] , we present the experimental apparatus , its characteristics , and limitations . section [ matmodel ] attempts to develop an intuitive mathematical model associating the acquired signal to an analytic frequency - dependent function . the relation between a fault s magnitude and the signal s amplitude as well as the limitation associated to eventual reflection events along the fiber are also discussed . the experimental results are presented and discussed in section [ results ] , section [ impact ] presents the technique s limitations and the impact on in - service data transmission , and section [ conclusion ] concludes the article and details our future points of investigation . the experimental apparatus is rather simple and a block diagram identifying its main structures is presented in fig . [ fig : setup ] . in order to achieve even higher signal - to - noise ratio , we perform the detection in a low - frequency lock - in amplifier which is also responsible for generating the modulating optical sub - carrier tone . according to @xcite , forcing the measuring time to be higher than the round trip time of the sub - carrier signal inside the fiber is equivalent to measuring the steady state response of the system for a given frequency . this way , determining the relative values of magnitude and phase of the backscattered signal for each frequency value in the range is the same as tracing the system s transfer function . by setting the time constant of the lock - in amplifier to @xmath2 milliseconds is sufficient to account for the steady state measurement of any practical optical fiber link available ( shorter than @xmath3 kilometers ) and translates into reasonable measuring periods ( less than 5 minutes ) given that the frequency is swept from 100 hz to 100 khz in 100 hz steps . furthermore , the sweep time is long enough so that each measurement is acquired after one time constant of the lock - in amplifier , which was verified to be short enough to avoid dragging effects on the measured curve . the noise level at each step frequency measurement is @xmath4 for the sr530 analog lock - amplifier model employed in the measurements . hz to @xmath5 khz ) modulates the laser diode . the backscattered signal corresponding to the base tone is amplified by the low - frequency photodetector s pre - amplifier and sent to the lock - in amplifier . ] the lock - in amplifier generates the sweeping tone which falls inside the 100 hz to 100 khz band and is responsible for determining the relative amplitude and phase parameters of the backscattered signal which composes the system s transfer function . note , however , that if we take into account the transfer functions of each element apart from the fiber itself and then proceed to calibrate the resulting signal , we get rid of the contribution from the laser diode , the photodetector , the electronic amplifier , and the lock in , and are left with the fiber s transfer function . the system s calibration is achieved by inducing a reflective event at port @xmath6 of the optical circulator and measuring the system s response . the laser diode operates linearly within a @xmath7 range centered at @xmath8 bias current . the low - frequency tone with angular frequency @xmath9 ( @xmath10 ) at full modulation depth has a peak voltage amplitude of @xmath11 since the laser diode s input impedance is @xmath12 . the optical signal launched into the fiber under test ( assumed to have a length @xmath13 ) will carry its modulation properties as will the backscattered signal . upon detection , the modulated backscattered signal will produce an electrical signal with current amplitude proportional to the field amplitude squared and the detector s detectivity @xcite . if we disregard the dc term after the detection , which is a good assumption since we are performing a steady state matched detection at lock - in amplifier , the electric signal entering the lock - in amplifier as a function of time can be written as @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the detected signal s current amplitude and @xmath16 is the photodetector s detectivity . for simplicity purposes , we first neglect possible reflective events throughout our mathematical modeling so the total signal intensity arriving at the lock - in amplifier is given solely by the incoherent sum of light scattered from all positions of the fiber . such reflective events , associated to defective connectors and fresnel reflections due to an abrupt change in the refractive index , will be input to the model after these first considerations are laid out . if we assume the distribution of scattering centers is uniform along the fiber , we can write the signal entering the lock - in amplifier as a spatial - dependent phasor in integral form : @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the launched probe signal power at the fiber s input and @xmath19 is the rayleigh scattering coefficient , assumed to be constant along the whole fiber length . @xmath20 is the complex wave vector of the modulating signal which includes the fiber s attenuation coefficient @xmath21 in its imaginary part . @xmath22 is the group index of refraction of the fiber . we now suppose a faulty _ non - reflective _ event at position @xmath23 induces an optical loss @xmath24 , where @xmath25 . to take into account this fault , we re - write eq . [ eq : fullfiber_intform ] as : @xmath26 where the first integral corresponds to power being scattered back from the portion of the fiber before the loss event whereas the second integral corresponds to power scattered back from the last portion of the fiber , after the fault event at @xmath23 . the loss factor @xmath24 appears multiplying the second integral twice ( hence , squared ) due to the fact that light passes two times through the fault in its round trip and we assume that the transmission coefficient is symmetric ( it is the same whether light is propagating from the generator to the load or in the opposite direction ) . to simplify the expression , we condensed the constants into @xmath27 . note that the second term in eq . [ eq : fiberbreak_intform ] can be dismembered into two integrals with different limits @xmath28 which , when substituted back into eq . [ eq : fiberbreak_intform ] , yields @xmath29 the signal arriving at the lock - in amplifier can , thus , be interpreted as the combination of two parcels : the modulated backscattered signal from a fiber with length @xmath23 , which contributes with a factor @xmath30 to the overall optical power ; and the modulated backscattered signal from a fiber with length @xmath13 , which contributes with a factor @xmath31 to the overall optical power . splitting the expression of @xmath32 into two parcels and dealing with the integrals separately , we find that the results are complex sinusoidal functions with the oscillatory parameter ( the product @xmath33 which governs the oscillation of the sinusoidal function ) being the distance of the fiber : @xmath34 where we have condensed the factors @xmath35 and @xmath36 into @xmath37 and @xmath38 , respectively , and @xmath39 . we would like to highlight that this modelling approach is rather intuitive as it has a somewhat direct correspondence to otdr - like traces , i.e. , the signal contributions from different portions of the fiber are independently weighted and piled up forming the resulting trace . the difference here is that , instead of step functions as in the standard otdr , the signal contributions are sinusoidal functions that oscillate more or less within the frequency range of the sweep depending on the fiber length to which they are associated . in @xcite , a similar expression has been derived following a distinct mathematical framework . there , however , the phase factor of the monitoring signal has been disregarded and the authors focused on the magnitude of the phasor in order to obtain an otdr - like trace by employing a fourier transform . as we show in the next section , the phase factor is rather sensitive to changes in the fiber and , if used in conjunction with the magnitude information , may raise the precision of fault location . in order to take both the phase and magnitude informations into account , a fitting procedure in the complex frequency domain is necessary and , although the result is not presented as an otdr - like trace but , rather , as an event list , it is possible to extend the spatial resolution beyond the limit imposed by the fourier transform . although the fourier transform operator is unambiguous , there are some pitfalls that may arise from computational methods : the non - localizability of the fourier transform operator causes it to interpret all frequency components with the same weight ; for that reason , there are several methods in the literature that focus on enhancing the localizability of the fourier transform operator through signal processing in order to enhance the spatial resolution of frequency measurements ( @xcite and references therein ) . such methods , however , tend to be very expensive in computational complexity even though the result is equivalent to the fitting procedure demonstrated in this document . the fitting procedure on the frequency domain is much more attractive in our application since the phase information is highly dependent on the position of the break which translates into a computationally cheap and accurate method for determining the position of a fault thus enhancing the achievable spatial resolution with respect to a straightforward fourier transform . the result conveyed by eq . [ eq : int2sinc ] is that @xmath32 is the sum of two sinusoidal terms which take different arguments corresponding to the length of fiber traversed by the backscattered optical signal . from the expressions of eq . [ eq : int2sinc ] , we may attempt to write a generic term @xmath40 for the backscattered signal from a fiber of arbitrary length @xmath41 . this generic term is a function of both the frequency and the fiber length and has the form presented below , where we took the liberty of expanding and simplifying all terms : @xmath42 note that , for an arbitrary number of non - reflective faults along the fiber link , the procedure presented in eq . [ eq : dismember ] can be used indefinitely . moreover , the backscattered signal from an optical fiber link which contains a number @xmath43 of fault events along its length will be represented as the sum of @xmath43 generic terms presented in eq . [ eq : genericterm ] , each dependent on the fault position @xmath44 and with different amplitude factor @xmath45 , so we may write : @xmath46 the expression of @xmath45 gets progressively intricate as the number of fault event rises as can be perceived from the right - hand side of eq . [ eq : integral_form2 ] : with @xmath43 terms , for instance , the value of @xmath47 depends on the values of all @xmath48 from @xmath49 downto @xmath50 which also holds true for @xmath51 and so forth . extending the expression of @xmath45 for any number of fault events yields the following : @xmath52 once the non - reflective events have been considered and modeled , we turn our attention to the parcel associated to reflective events . observing reflections along an optical fiber link has been a matter of extensive research and , as previously commented , nakayama _ et al . _ were able to detect such reflections with a similar experimental apparatus @xcite . in a way , therefore , reflection events are manageable and the method hereby proposed offers a means of not only identifying these specific events , but also the non - reflective ones . as we know , reflective events are always accompanied by a loss of intensity due to energy conservation conditions ( namely , the @xmath53 condition at any partially reflective interface ) but the converse does not hold , i.e. , an intensity loss may or may not be accompanied by a reflection . generally , loss events that are not associated to a reflection peak in standard otdr measurements are due to absorption or irradiation effects , such as macro- and micro - bend losses @xcite . reflection events are more easily observed since the _ high - frequency issue _ does not arise in modeling its amplitude and a sinusoidal function which reflected back will arrive at the lock - in amplifier as a sinusoidal function with lesser magnitude and constant phase . hence , taking reflective events into account is as straightforward as including a constant magnitude and constant phase factor to the model . we , then , rewrite eq . [ eq : s_final ] as @xmath54 with @xmath55 , meaning that the set of reflective events is a subset of all the events but not necessarily equal to the latter . in the same fashion as nakayama _ considered the rayleigh backscattering some sort of noisy contribution that could spoil the reflection measurements performed @xcite , we consider the reflection events as noisy contributions that can spoil our fiber characterization method . suppose , for instance , that a optical fiber link presents a non - reflective event at position @xmath23 and a reflective fiber - end at position @xmath13 . if the reflective fiber - end contribution rises above the backscattering power level , the non - reflective event wo nt be observed even though it is there . we first wish to validate the mathematical modelling of the signal arriving at the lock - in amplifier . for that , we simulated the results from eq . [ eq : s_final ] using @xmath56 , @xmath57 km , and a frequency range of @xmath5hz to @xmath5khz . we then compared the amplitude and phase data with the results acquired from measuring a @xmath58-km standard optical fiber within the same frequency range using our proposed method . the amplitude of the modulating signal throughout all experiments were kept at one eighth of the full modulation depth . the result is depicted in fig . [ fig : ampphasesimulationcomp ] . -km standard optical fiber . a ) amplitude data series ; b ) phase data series . ] even though the results show good agreement between simulated and experimentally acquired data , there is still a slight discrepancy , specially in the phase data series . note , however , that the generic term presented in eq . [ eq : genericterm ] depends on @xmath59 and @xmath41 but also on @xmath21 and @xmath22 , the fiber s attenuation coefficient and the group index of refraction of the fiber , respectively . since , from an optical link monitoring perspective , there is usually no _ a priori _ access to such information , we utilized standard values within the international telecommunication union ( itu - t ) specification range , i.e. , @xmath60db / km and @xmath61 @xcite . nevertheless , these values may suffer variations from one fiber to the other and the discrepancy perceived between simulated and experimental data may be attributed to that . observe that , from a systematic point of view , if one was capable of identifying which frequency - dependent sinusoidal functions are present in a data series originated by the monitoring procedure described which is equivalent to finding all the generic terms of eq . [ eq : genericterm ] that compose the signal , the eventual positions of faults could be determined . before that , and in order to further investigate the correspondence between the mathematical model and the experimentally acquired data , as well as determining the availability of this fiber characterization method , we conducted laboratory tests referenced by a standard otdr device with previously unknown fibers ( unknown length and attenuation coefficient ) . first , the amplitude and phase profiles were extracted from the fiber in its original configuration using the lock - in amplifier . afterwards , a fiber bend loss was induced in an arbitrary position also with unknown magnitude . the goal is to identify how a fiber bend alters the transfer function s profile , so the amplitude and phase profiles of the modified fiber were extracted using the lock - in amplifier . from the results of fig . [ fig : ampphasecomp]-a and fig . [ fig : ampphasecomp]-b , it is clear that tempering with the fiber has a direct effect on the signal measured with the lock - in amplifier , so the possibility of quantifying the effect by employing our knowledge of the mathematical model is a straightforward assumption . to assess the capability of identifying a fault event along an optical fiber link , the otdr trace of the unknown fiber was acquired in its original and fault - induced conditions . at the same time , a model fit of the amplitude and phase profiles was ran based on an _ extensive search _ heuristic developed in matlab@xmath62 : the algorithm sorts an arbitrary fiber length and calculates the generic component ( eq . [ eq : genericterm ] ) of our mathematical model ; it then calculates the minimum square error between the original profile ( the fiber without the induced fault ) summed with this generic component and the profile after the induced fault ; the position ( @xmath44 ) , amplitude factor ( @xmath45 ) , and attenuation coefficient parameters are adjusted to find the candidate that best fits the new result . note that the nature of the mathematical model enables one to test an arbitrary number of generic components in order to best estimate the fiber fault position . in a sense , the spatial resolution is limited by the amount of generic components one is inclined to test since the higher this number , the longer the algorithm will take to come up with a result . in the examples that follow , the generic components were created each separated by 1 meter , i.e. , for a 4-km fiber , four thousand components will be tested and the one that best fits the acquired signal will be selected . the non - linear search algorithm employed in matlab@xmath1 , however , must deal with four parameters at a time ( position , magnitude , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 ) so the average processing time revolves around @xmath5 milliseconds . increasing this separation over 1 meter will be computationally costly and ever slower , for which reasons we set 1 meter as our default separation between generic components achieving a @xmath63 minutes computing time . the developed algorithm along with a testbench data series is available at @xcite . we tested two different optical links : link @xmath64 has its amplitude versus phase profile presented in fig . [ fig : ampphasecomp ] and corresponds to a @xmath65-km long composition of two fibers with the induced fault at @xmath66 kilometers . link @xmath6 corresponds to a @xmath67-km composition of two fibers with the induced fault at @xmath68 kilometers . the results are shown in table [ table : comp1 ] , for which we found a less than @xmath69 meters difference between the standard otdr and the low - frequency sweep measurements in both cases . this results are a clear indication that the fourier transform limitation of i - ofdr has indeed been overcome since a 100khz frequency sweep would allow for a maximum spatial resolution of 2 kilometers . .standard otdr vs low - frequency sweep [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ table : comp2 ] the fiber end contribution varies inversely , as expected . according to these results , the dynamic range is limited to a maximum of @xmath70 db , i.e. , the maximum attenuation throughout the link which still permits one to identify the fiber end . in the access systems of rof , the optical link distribution does not , usually , exceed 15 km . therefore , even though the technique achieves low dynamic range , it is an interesting candidate for short range mobile fronthaul applications with low optical splitting ratios @xcite . the possibility of in - service network monitoring has been assessed by measuring the resulting error vector magnitude ( evm@xmath71 ) for different data signal amplitude under two conditions : with ; and without the monitoring tone . once again , the monitoring tone amplitude was kept at one eighth of the laser s full modulation depth in order to simulate an eight - channel scm network . the result indicates that the monitoring signal deteriorates the quality of the communication , even if by a very small factor . under these conditions , however , the required evm@xmath71 for lte communication is respected with a large margin @xcite . it can be observed that , above a certain value of the data signal s amplitude , the quality of communication is deteriorated . this behavior is associated to the laser s non - linear response region , achieved when the modulation signal violates the laser s full modulation depth at around 1.5 [ vpp ] , or 30 [ ma ] . the recent interest in the deployment of scm - pon and cost restrictions imposed by modern commercial needs bring up low cost embedded monitoring techniques as an essential tool for operational success of access networks . although a method capable of replacing one optical sub - carrier channel by a monitoring probe has been presented in @xcite , dynamic range is limited by the 1/f factor impairing backscattering measurements inside an optical sub - carrier . the results presented here shows that an embedded in - service short - reach link monitoring can be performed and the impact over data transmission is expected to be not higher than the cross contribution from any two sub - carrier channels due to the probe signal s very nature . using the baseband for monitoring purposes , the method benefits of the high - sensitivity low - frequency detection and further overcomes the _ high - frequency issue _ , fully preserving the rf sub - carrier band for data transmission . fulfilling the steady state condition over the round trip path along the fiber during the measurement is imperative for the performance of the technique and a feature that distinguishes it from the technique presented in @xcite . nevertheless , minute - long measurement times are achieved in fibers a few kilometers long . the mathematical model presented here is similar to the one previously developed in @xcite but with a different approach , namely the development in the frequency domain when one represents the incoming signal as an integral of phasors originated from the modulated light coming from distinct portions of the fiber . the intuitiveness of the model is useful since the signal is not transformed back to the spatial domain as in standard c- or i - ofdr and the results are given in the form of an event table as opposed to an otdr - like trace . the algorithm developed to treat the signal , even though simple and still limited enables highly reliable fault location , as backed by our experimental results contrasted to standard otdr measurements . this is possible due to the fact that several signal component candidates may be tested and the one that best approximates the acquired complex signal in the frequency domain is selected . using the phase combined with the magnitude information of the backscattered signal , we could overcome the fourier transform spatial resolution limitation of low - frequency measurements . we believe that , as the method developed by @xcite , the method presented here may also figure as a good candidate for embedded in - service short - reach scm - pon monitoring , not demanding a sub - carrier channel for that purpose . assuming that the data channels are delegated to highest frequencies ( in the order of hundreds of megahertz ) , the base band would be unoccupied and could be reserved for the low - frequency probing tone herewith described . we also believe that the standard deviation reported in figure [ fig : estimatevsreal ] is the limitation of localizability of the phase measurement even when the fitting procedure in the frequency domain is employed . even though we surpass the standard fourier transform limitation , there is still a fourier transform limitation to the technique , i.e. , we can not retrieve perfect information of the fiber unless an infinite frequency span is performed . unfortunately , the lock - in amplifier employed in the measurements is incapable of reaching higher than @xmath5 khz frequencies and , therefore , we are limited to this spatial resolution of @xmath72 meters . higher frequency spans should improve the resolution , so conducting the experiments with a device specified for higher frequencies is a goal for future developments . location of multiple faults is , unfortunately , still impracticable with the present signal processing technique . we believe , however , that it could be achieved and leave it as our major future point of investigation . the innovation centre , ericsson telecomunicaes s.a . , brazil and brazilian agencies cnpq and faperj supported this work . g. c. amaral , l. e. y. herrera , d. vitoreti , g. p. temporo , p. j. urban , and j. p. von der weid , `` wdm - pon monitoring with tunable photon counting otdr , '' _ photonics technology letters _ , vol . 26 , no . 13 , pp . 49214926 , 2014 . g. c. amaral , j. d. garcia , l. e. herrera , g. p. temporao , p. j. urban , and j. p. von der weid , `` automatic fault detection in wdm - pon with tunable photon counting otdr , '' _ lightwave technology , journal of _ , vol . 33 , no . 24 , pp . 50255031 , 2015 . j. p. von der weid , r. passy , g. mussi , and n. gisin , `` on the characterization of optical fiber network components with optical frequency domain reflectometry , '' _ lightwave technology , journal of _ , vol . 15 , no . 5 , pp . 11311141 , 1997 . p. j. urban , g. c. amaral , and j. p. von der weid , `` fiber monitoring using a sub - carrier band in a sub - carrier multiplexed radio - over - fiber transmission system for applications in analog mobile fronthaul , '' _ lightwave technology , journal of _ , vol . 34 , no . 13 , pp . 31183125 , 2016 . j. a. tropp , j. n. laska , m. f. duarte , j. k. romberg , and r. g. baraniuk , `` beyond nyquist : efficient sampling of sparse bandlimited signals , '' _ ieee transactions on information theory _ , vol . 56 , no . 1 , pp . 520544 , 2010 . l. herrera , g. amaral , and j. von der weid , `` investigation of bend loss in single mode fibers with ultra - high - resolution photon - counting optical time domain reflectometer , '' _ applied optics _ , vol . 55 , no . 5 , pp . 11771182 , 2016 . , `` a low - frequency tone sweep method for fault location in optical fiber links matlab source files and testbench data series , '' https://github.com/tungstenio/tonesweepfibarlocation , accessed : 2016 - 05 - 07 .

we demonstrate an optical fiber fault location method based on the frequency response of the modulated fiber optical backscattered signal in a steady state low - frequency step regime . careful calibration and measurement allows for the reconstruction of the fiber transfer function , which , associated to its mathematical model , is capable of extracting the fiber characteristics . the technique is capable of identifying non - reflective fault events in an optical fiber link and is perfectly compatible with previous methods that focus on the reflective events . the fact that the recuperation of the complex signal is performed in the frequency domain and not via a fourier transform enables the measurements to overcome the spatial resolution limitation of fourier transform incoherent - ofdr measurements even with frequency sweep ranges down to 100 - 100000 hz . this result is backed up by a less than 10 meters difference in fault location when compared to standard otdr measurements .

cond-mat9906158

many adsorption systems exhibit either complete wetting below the triple point or triple point wetting transitions . these behaviors are recognized to arise from strongly attracting substrate potentials and/or small mismatch of substrate / adsorbate lattice constants @xcite . less attractive potentials exhibit incomplete or nonwetting behavior at the triple point . there is considerable interest in the nature of such weakly attractive situations near and above this temperature @xcite . general arguments and model calculations of cahn @xcite and of ebner and saam @xcite in 1977 implied that systems which are nonwetting at the triple point ought to exhibit transitions to wetting at some temperature below the critical point . experimental confirmation of this proposal was not found until appropriate systems were identified . in 1991 , it was argued that alkali metals provide the weakest adsorption potentials of any surfaces for he atoms and therefore wetting transitions were expected for such substrates at tow temperature @xcite . this hypothesis was subsequently confirmed and the corresponding transition has since been studied in many laboratories @xcite . more recently , similar phenomena have been predicted and/or seen for h@xmath0 , ne , and hg on various surfaces @xcite . key theoretical questions arising from these studies involve the reliability of both the assumed adsorption potentials and the statistical mechanical description of the transition , as well as the effects of surface heterogeneity @xcite present in any real experiment . in the course of these investigations , cheng _ @xcite ( ccst henceforth ) posited a simple model which interprets the transitions in terms of a balance between the surface tension cost of producing a thicker film and the energy gain associated with the film s interaction with the surface , v(z ) @xcite . there results an implicit equation for the wetting temperature ( t@xmath3 ) : @xmath4 @xmath5 where @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the number densities of the adsorbate liquid and vapor at coexistence , @xmath8 is the surface tension of the liquid , and @xmath9 is the equilibrium distance of the potential . if one assumes a simple 3 - 9 form of the adsorption potential @xmath10 then the transition condition becomes @xmath11 ccst used this model to predict wetting transitions for a large number of specific systems . more recently , the same general approach was used by chizmeshya _ et al . _ ( ccz ) @xcite , who based their predictions on new _ ab initio _ adsorption potentials . the latter potentials differ from earlier potentials in several respects ; especially important are differences in values of the coefficient c of the van der waals asymptotic potential , resulting in significantly larger well depths d. there is indication that these revised potentials are more consistent with experimental data than are their predecessors . particularly striking is the improved agreement for @xmath12he contact angle @xcite and wetting temperature on cs , the most studied wetting transition to date @xcite . these predictions have also been tested by recent experiments of hess _ _ @xcite and simulations of ne on alkali metals and mg @xcite . in this paper , we extend the simulation studies to a larger family of systems for which the hypothesis is relevant . we focus here on the following question : assuming that v(z ) is known , does the ccst model correctly predict whether a specific adsorption system exhibits wetting at and above the triple temperature ? the outline of this paper is the following . section [ label.3.sec:method ] summarizes our simulation methodology and presents detailed results for several systems which yield fairly distinct adsorption behaviors . these include complete wetting for all t ( kr / mg and xe / mg ) , an anomalous wetting transition near the triple point ( kr / pmg ) , a prewetting transition line ( ar / mg ) somewhat above the triple temperature , and prewetting transitions characterized by the formation of very thick films ( for ar , kr and xe on li ) . here pmg is our own nomenclature for `` pseudo - magnesium '' , an ersatz surface which attracts kr atoms about 7% more strongly than mg itself @xcite . we also evaluate other hypothetical substrates in order to ascertain the triple point wetting threshold . in section [ label.3.sec:interpretation ] , we compare these findings with those obtained previously in simulations and/or experiments for inert gases on various surfaces @xcite . the simulation technique has been described in detail previously @xcite , so only a brief description is given here . for this study , isotherms for various model systems were calculated using the grand canonical monte carlo ( gcmc ) technique @xcite . for each isotherm , 6.8 million steps ( each step being an attempted creation , deletion , or displacement of a molecule ) were performed to reach equilibration and 4.5 million steps were performed in the data gathering phase . for some points near the transition regions , where the fluctuations are larger , the number of equilibration steps was increased to 20 million and 12 million steps were performed for data gathering . as in our previous work , the model for the atom - atom interaction is a lennard - jones 12 - 6 potential and the atom surface interaction is modeled using the potential described by chizmeshya _ these potentials can be characterized by four parameters for each system studied . a well - depth @xmath13 and distance @xmath14 are needed to specify the adsorbate lj potential and a well - depth @xmath15 and the van der waals constant @xmath16 specify the atom - surface potential . the values of these parameters used in this study are listed in table [ label.3.table:param ] . the parameters correspond to ne , kr , ar , and xe adsorbed on alkali and alkali earth metal surfaces . the surface labeled pmg ( pseudo magnesium ) was obtained when we attempted to simulate xe on li , but used the @xmath13 and @xmath14 values for kr instead of xe . this potential is similar to that of kr on a mg surface ; however , the kr / pmg distance of closest approach is 20% smaller and the well depth is about 7% weaker than estimated for kr on mg . while this potential does not correspond to a `` real '' system , we shall see that this small decrease in interaction strength significantly affects the wetting properties of the substrate / adsorbate system . in most cases the simulation cell had a height of h = 70 , with the metal surface forming the boundary at one end and a hard wall surface at the other . in xe / li and ar / li simulations we increased the height to 140 and 210 . the surface unit cell was taken to be @xmath17 giving a nominal monolayer coverage of roughly 100 atoms . periodic boundary conditions in these dimensions render the surface effectively infinite ; we used a fairly large cutoff ( 5@xmath14 ) to minimize long range corrections . for each system , we simulated adsorption isotherms over relevant temperature ranges from the triple point to the critical temperature . the results are shown in figures [ label.3.fig:xeli1]-[label.3.fig:krmg ] . of the systems studied the least attractive surface of the surface interactions are for the ar / li , kr / li and xe / li cases . in all of these , we see evidence of prewetting transitions and , based on our results , we report wetting temperature . for ar / li we estimate t@xmath18 k , for kr / li , t@xmath19 k and t@xmath20 k for xe / li . all @xmath21 are reported in table [ label.3.table:param ] . despite the fact that these systems are examples of prewetting transitions , there are some qualitative differences from the case ( say ne / mg ) where the wetting transition appears close to the triple temperature . figure [ label.3.fig:xeli1 ] shows a series of isotherms for xe / li from @xmath22 1.0 to 1.25 . the isotherm at 221 k ( the lowest @xmath23 ) shows nonwetting behavior , manifested as slight adsorption below saturated vapor pressure . the higher temperature isotherms however , show prewetting transitions below saturated vapor pressure , from which we estimate @xmath21 . the nature of the prewetting jump can be further characterized by the results in figures [ label.3.fig:xeli2 ] , [ label.3.fig:xeli3 ] , and [ label.3.fig:xeli4 ] , all at t=254 k. figure [ label.3.fig:xeli2 ] shows the dependence of the isotherm on the height @xmath24 [ @xmath25 ] of the simulation box . the rapid rise occurs at the same pressure , independent of box height . this is a clear indication that the transition is prewetting rather than capillary condensation . the detailed behavior is most easily understood by looking at the density profiles dependences on @xmath24 . figure [ label.3.fig:xeli3 ] shows these profiles at @xmath26 atm . note that the data for two largest boxes coincide but differ from those of the smallest box . evidently , this regime requires quite large values of @xmath24 in order to obtain reliable data ; this is not surprising because the compressibility of the system is particularly high at this transition as the slope of the isotherms suggest . the same phenomenon is even more dramatic for the case of a 1% higher pressure . as seen in figure [ label.3.fig:xeli4 ] , one must go to even larger @xmath24 ( @xmath27 ) in order to derive accurate adsorption data even though the liquid regime occupies only the region @xmath28 . while this sensitivity to @xmath24 and the details of the transition are quite interesting they are not the focus of this paper . suffice it to say that the density jumps discontinuously near @xmath29 atm , as seen in the different densities in figures [ label.3.fig:xeli3 ] and [ label.3.fig:xeli4 ] . we note one further point about these data which is that the film s density close to the surface is qualitatively similar to that on a relatively more attractive surface . there appears a quite large accumulation of adsorbate atoms in the region associated with the first layer . there is even a significant density maximum occurring where a dense second layer might occur . the latter is , however , preempted by the prewetting jump in the regime of temperature seen here . above the prewetting critical point , in contrast , one does expect such smooth film growth . as the relative strength ( @xmath30 ) of the surface interaction increases , ( ar on mg , kr on pmg ) the isotherms give evidence of wetting transitions . the results for ar on mg , ( shown in figure [ label.3.fig:armg ] ) indicate prewetting transitions at about 10% above the triple point ( t@xmath31 = 81 k ) . from these data , we estimate the wetting temperature to be 90 k for ar / mg with a prewetting critical temperature of 95 k. in figure [ label.3.fig:krpmg ] , the results for kr on pmg are shown . this system shows clear prewetting transitions below 128 k for all temperatures above the triple temperature ( estimated to be 116 k @xcite ) . although this is a fictitious system , it represents one of the first simulations of triple point wetting . the only other simulation of wetting in this region is the case of ne / mg which we reported in @xcite . finally , as the surface interaction strength further increases , one begins to see continuous growth for all t between the triple temperature and the critical point . this is evident in figure [ label.3.fig:krmg ] which shows isotherms for kr on mg . the isotherms were simulated at temperatures near the estimated triple temperature and demonstrate complete wetting on the mg surface by the adsorbate even at the lowest temperatures . the results for xe on mg ( not shown ) are qualitatively the same . to interpret our results we follow ccst , who evaluated their simple model in terms of the law of corresponding states . then we note that equation [ label.3.eq:criterion ] may be written in a universal form in terms of the reduced well depth @xmath32 and interaction range @xmath33 , defined as follows : @xmath34 the values of these parameters are reported in table [ label.3.table:param ] . the ccst model may then be written in terms of a dimensionless wetting parameter @xmath35\ ] ] the triple point experimental data summarized in ccst yield a value of 3.6 for the right side of this equation . hence the criterion is @xmath1 = 3.6 for a wetting transition precisely at the triple point . the latter value , however , presupposes a 3 - 9 adsorption potential , which we have not used in the present simulations . if , instead , we compute the integral of the actual potential used in the calculations , we find a value which is 8 to 10% higher than the result obtained with the 3 - 9 potential . taking this correction into account , the threshold for wetting at the triple point becomes somewhat lower for the realistic potential : @xmath36 this is shown in figure [ label.3.fig:threshold ] as a dashed curve . turning to the actual simulation results , we find that this prediction characterizes our data relatively well , insofar as the vicinity of the value 3.3 is a crossover regime of wetting behavior . for all gases exposed to the alkali metal surfaces the quantity @xmath1 is less than 2.3 , and the systems are nonwetting at the triple point . the case of ar / mg ( @xmath1 = 3.2 ) is one for which a wetting transition occurs about 10% above the triple temperature ; similar behavior was found in our previous study of ne / mg ( @xmath37= 3.4 ) . the case of kr / pmg involves a similar value ( @xmath1 = 3.2 ) , but we find anomalous triple point wetting transition behavior for that system . finally , the cases of kr / mg ( @xmath1 = 3.4 ) and xe / mg ( @xmath1 = 3.8 ) both correspond to complete wetting . for comparison with a more typical adsorption system , the case of ar / au ( @xmath1 = 6.7 ) is one which exhibits wetting at and above the triple temperature @xcite . we may add to this list of relevant systems the recently studied case of ar / co@xmath0 . _ @xcite found that it exhibits triple point wetting ; this finding agreed with their density functional calculation using their theoretical potential . this potential would be roughly consistent with the ccst model in that the latter would predict a wetting transition at a temperature only 3% above the triple point temperature , 83.8 k @xcite . while the criterion @xmath1 = 3.3 successfully discriminates between the nonwetting and wetting data sets mentioned above , it is worthwhile to ascertain the validity of this criterion more accurately . hence we have performed extensive simulations at the triple temperature , varying the well depth near the values @xmath33 = 0.7 , 0.9 , and 1.4 in order to determine the wetting transition line . the results are shown in figure [ label.3.fig:threshold ] . one identifies this line as the point where the letter c is just above the letter w. note that these transition values ( dash - dot curve ) lie somewhat above the @xmath1 = 3.3 dashed line . this comparison indicates that the ccst model underestimates the well depth criterion for wetting . this finding is qualitatively consistent with results reported recently by ancilotto and toigo @xcite . using a density functional method , these workers found wetting transitions very close to the coexistence curve for several systems ( e.g. ne / li and na ) for which our simulations find nonwetting behavior . the different findings of the simulations may be due to the uncertainty in identifying wetting behavior close to saturation , especially at t approaching t@xmath38 . in these and other cases , the transitions occurred at ( typically @xmath39 10% ) higher temperature than is predicted by the ccst model . these findings are also consistent with one s realization that the ccst model predicts wetting transitions for all adsorption circumstances , however weakly attractive , while a more reliable theory yields drying transitions for _ ultraweakly _ adsorbing potentials @xcite . to summarize , we have found the ccst equation [ label.3.eq:integral ] to be a semiquantitative guide to the occurrence of wetting transitions . it would be valuable to have additional , genuine experimental data to test this conclusion . we wish especially to encourage experimentalists to explore totally new systems , especially ar , kr , and xe adsorption on alkali metals . there are several reasons for doing so . one is that such experiments will provide tests of the weak adsorption potentials for these systems , for which no experimental data exist . a second is that triple point wetting can involve interesting behavior at and just below the triple temperature , as has been found in many experiments @xcite . we have not explored either these systems , or analogous ones , below the triple temperature . in order to reliably describe the crystalline phase , as is necessary there , such simulations would require a more careful handling of the unit cell dimensions and shape than has been employed here . in view of the many relevant systems , such a study seems well justified for the future . this research was supported by the national science foundation . it has benefited from discussion with f. ancilotto , v. bakaev , m. h. w. chan , j. z. larese , g. mistura , and f. toigo . we are especially grateful to _ fondazione aldo ing . gini _ for the generous support of ing . s. curtarolo . c|ccccccc gas / surface & & rb & na & li & pmg & mg & co@xmath0 + ne & @xmath32 & 0.7 & 1.1 & 1.5 & & 2.8 & + @xmath40 k & @xmath33 & 1.6 & 1.4 & 1.4 & & 1.2 & + @xmath41 &behavior&d & n & n & & tp(22k ) & + & @xmath42 & 1.1 & 1.5 & 2.1 & & 3.4 & + ar & @xmath32 & 1.1 & 1.6 & 2.1 & & 3.5 & 3.8 + @xmath43 k & @xmath33 & 1.1 & 1.1 & 1.0 & & 0.9 & 1.0 + @xmath44 &behavior&n & n & w(130k ) & & w(90k ) & c + & @xmath42 & 1.2 & 1.7 & 2.1 & & 3.2 & 3.8 + kr & @xmath32 & & & 2.3 & 3.6 & 3.8 & + @xmath45 k & @xmath33 & & & 0.9 & 0.9 & 0.9 & + @xmath46 &behavior & & & w(175k)&tp(116k)&c & + & @xmath42 & & & 2.1 & 3.2 & 3.4 & + xe & @xmath32 & & & 2.8 & & 5.45 & + @xmath47 k & @xmath33 & & & 0.8 & & 0.7 & + @xmath48 &behavior & & & w(225k ) & & c & + & @xmath42 & & & 2.2 & & 3.8 & + j. rutledge and p. taborek , phys . . lett . * 69 * , 937 ( 1992 ) ; j. e. rutledge and p. taborek , j. low temp . phys . * 95 * , 405 ( 1994 ) ; d. ross , j. a. phillips , and p. taborek , j. low temp . phys . * 106 * , 81 ( 1997 ) ; d. reinelt , h. gau , s. herminghaus and p. leiderer , czech . j. phys . * 46 * , suppl . s1 , 431 ( 1996 ) . k. s. ketola , s. wang , and r. b. hallock , phys . lett . * 68 * , 201 ( 1992 ) ; r. b. hallock , j. low temp . phys . * 101 * , 31 ( 1995 ) ; a. f. g. wyatt , j. klier , and p. stefanyi , phys . 74 * , 1151 ( 1995 ) . d. ross , j. e. rutledge , and p. taborek , fluid phase equilibria * 150 - 151 * , 599 ( 1998 ) ; d. ross , j. e. rutledge , and p. taborek , science * 278 * , 664 ( 1997 ) ; j. a. phillips , p. taborek , and j. e. rutledge , j. low temp . phys . * 113 * , 829 ( 1998 ) ; j. a. phillips , d. ross , p. taborek , and j. e. rutledge , phys . b * 58 * , 3361 ( 1998 ) ; d. ross , p. taborek , and j. e. rutledge , phys . rev . b * 58 * , r4274 ( 1998 ) . the alert reader might notice that the adsorption potential parameters for kr / pmg coincide with those for xe / li ; this reveals the accidental origin of this serendipitous choice of fictitious substrate . prior to the recent work of mistura _ et al . _ , much theoretical attention had been devoted to the ar / co@xmath0 problem , but the assumed potential was less attractive than that implied by the recent study . @xcite . a. d. migone , j. g. dash , m. schick , and o. e. vilches , phys . b * 34 * , 6322 ( 1986 ) ; a. d. migone , a. hoffmann , j. g. dash , and o. e. vilches , phys . rev . b * 37 * , 5440 ( 1988 ) ; m. s. pettersen , m. j. lysek and d. l. goodstein , surf . sci . * 175 * , 141 ( 1986 ) ; l. bruschi and g. mistura , phys . b * 58 * , 1181 ( 1998 ) ; j. z. larese and m. y. m lee , phys . rev . * 79 * , 689 ( 1997 ) .

grand canonical simulations are used to calculate adsorption isotherms of various classical gases on alkali metal and mg surfaces . _ ab initio _ adsorption potentials and lennard - jones gas - gas interactions are used . depending on the system , the resulting behavior can be nonwetting for all temperatures studied , complete wetting , or ( in the intermediate case ) exhibit a wetting transition . an unusual variety of wetting transitions at the triple point is found in the case of a specific adsorption potential of intermediate strength . the general threshold for wetting near the triple point is found to be close to that predicted with a heuristic model of cheng _ et al . _ this same conclusion was drawn in a recent experimental and simulation study of ar on co@xmath0 by mistura _ et al . _ these results imply that a dimensionless wetting parameter @xmath1 is useful for predicting whether wetting behavior is present at and above the triple temperature . the nonwetting / wetting crossover value found here is @xmath2 3.3 . _ pacs numbers : 64.70.fx , 68.35.rh , 68.45.gd , 82.20.wt_

1202.1396

supernovae ( sne ) are dramatic and violent end - points of stellar evolution , and lie at the heart of some of the most important problems of modern astronomy since their huge luminosities were first estimated and a clear distinction between classical novae and sne was made @xcite . * sne and stellar evolution * + sne provide natural laboratories for studying the physics of hydrodynamic , nuclear processes in extreme conditions and are involved in the formation of neutron stars , black holes , and gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) . furthermore , sne are sources of gravitational waves and of neutrino emission , and candidate sites for high - energy cosmic ray acceleration . thus , it is of broad astrophysical importance to understand the physical conditions for these spectacular explosions . + we recognize two physically defined classes : core collapse - induced explosion of short - lived massive stars ( cc sne ) and thermonuclear explosions of long - lived low mass stars ( sne ia ) . in recent years deeper and more frequent searches for transient events in the local and distant universe as well the identification of sn progenitor stars on pre - discovery images from hubble and spitzer space telescopes have provided us with important information on the evolution of massive stars and binary systems @xcite . _ however , a growing number of peculiar events suggests that the standard scenario of stellar evolution and explosion physics may not be complete and demands further physical understanding and theoretical explanation . _ * sne and dark energy * + type ia sne are standard candles due to their significant intrinsic brightness and homogeneity . they have provided the first evidence for an accelerated expansion of the universe and remain one of the more promising probes of the nature and amount of dark energy , @xcite . cc sne display a huge range in their physical characteristics , including kinetic energy , radiated energy and the amount of radioactive elements created during the explosion . however , plateau cc sne ( sne iip ) that undergo a long phase of constant luminosity in their photometric evolution are potential standardizable candles , although they are not as luminous and uniform as sne ia @xcite . _ understanding the mechanism that is responsible for the accelerating expansion of the universe is one of the crucial next steps for cosmology and requires both new searches for type ia and type iip sne to populate the hubble diagram and the knowledge of their progenitors and explosion mechanisms . _ * sne and galaxy evolution * + sne play also a major role in driving the chemical , kinetic , and dynamical evolution of galaxies . they are the main producers of heavy elements and are fundamental for understanding global abundances and abundance patterns in galaxy clusters and in the intergalactic medium @xcite . sne ia are important contributors of iron and release it to the interstellar medium over longer timescales , compared to the @xmath0 elements produced by cc sne . therefore the @xmath0 to iron abundance ratio can be used to evaluate the formation timescales of stellar systems . moreover the sn metal - rich ejecta are believed to be a potentially important site of cosmic dust formation . the energy release from sne can initiate episodes of star formation ( sf ) , impact the evolution of gas flow and contribute to the feedback processes in galaxies @xcite . _ a complete and coherent picture of the formation and evolution of the galaxies is a fundamental objective of modern astronomy and sne are an important ingredient to model the chemical enrichment of the galaxies and the effect of energy / momentum feedback on galaxy formation . _ * sne and sfr * + the cosmic evolution of sn rates is an alternative and complementary probe of the sf history ( sfh ) in the galaxies . due to the short lifetime of progenitor stars the cc sn rate is directly proportional to the current sfr while type ia sn rate reflects the convolution of the sfh with the distribution of the delay times between progenitor star formation and explosion @xcite . poor statistics is a major limiting factor for using the cc sn rate as a tracer of the sfr . at low redshift the difficulty is in sampling large enough volumes of the local universe to ensure significant statistics ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) , while at high redshift the difficulty lies in detecting and typing complete samples of intrinsically faint sne @xcite . moreover it is expected that a fraction of cc sne are missed by optical searches , since they are embedded in dusty spiral arms or galaxy nuclei . this fraction may change with redshift , if the amount of dust in galaxies evolves with time . _ progress in using cc sn rates as sfr tracers requires accurate measurements of rates at various cosmic epochs and in different environments . furthermore it requires a comparison with other sfr diagnostics in a wide range of redshift to investigate the causes of the observed discrepancy . _ + despite the importance of sne in several astronomical topic many fundamental questions remain with regard these exciting phenomena . stellar evolution theory predicts that all stars more massive than @xmath1 complete eso - energetic nuclear burnings and develop an iron core that can not be supported by any further nuclear fusion reaction , or by electron degenerate pressure . the collapse of the iron core results in the formation of a compact object , a neutron star or a black hole , accompanied by the high - velocity ejection of a large fraction of the progenitor mass . despite this basic understanding , the picture of massive star death emerging from recent discovery is far to be clear . * which massive star in which evolutionary stage produce which cc sn type ? * + different types of cc sne have been identified on the basis of their spectroscopic and photometric properties : type ii sne show presence of h in the spectra , ( type iip sne exhibit a long plateau in their light curve while type iil show a linear decline rate ) , type ib sne lack h but show he , type ic sne lack both h and he , type iin sne exhibit a narrow @xmath2 emission line and present other strong evidences of interaction of the ejecta with circumstellar material ( csm ) already at early phases of their evolution . this sequence has been explained on the basis of the progenitor mass loss history with the most massive stars loosing the largest fraction of their initial mass @xcite : type iip progenitor stars are red super giants ( rsgs ) that explode with most of their h envelope present , type iil progenitors had extensive mass loss but preserved a small h envelope , type ib / c progenitors are wolf - rayet stars that had lost their h and he envelopes , type iin progenitor have suffered a major mass loss episode just before the explosion . several cc sne with characteristics intermediate between these canonical types have been recently discovered suggesting a smooth transition and requiring the introduction of hybrid classes ( for example type iib sne and ibn sne ) . the progenitor stars of sne iip are the best constrained from direct detection since these sne are the most frequent in the nearby universe . their mass function seems to suggest a lack of high mass progenitors ( @xmath3 ) and raises the intriguing possibility that more massive stars collapse directly to a black - hole and produce either faint or failed sne @xcite . the progenitors of sne ib / c have so far eluded discovery and several observational evidences have suggested an alternative scenario where a significant fraction of their progenitors are stars of much lower initial mass in close binary systems stripped of their envelopes by the interaction with the companion @xcite . recent observations have suggested the possibility that stars explode as cc sne shortly after the luminous blue variable ( lbv ) phase characterized by sporadic variability and occasionally giant outbursts with a huge mass loss in a single short event @xcite . in particular some sne ( 2006jc , 2006gy , @xcite ) showed evidence that their progenitors had properties consistent with lbv and in one case a pre - explosion outburst was seen . * which physical parameters drive the cc sn diversity ? * + the variety of the observational properties shown by cc sne and the relative numbers of different types reflects the large range of stellar types seen in the upper region of the hertzsprung russel diagram above @xmath4 and the different physical conditions ( radius , density profile and surrounding csm ) before the explosion @xcite . the simple scheme where only the mass loss drives the evolution of massive stars can not explain the surprising diversity in explosion energies and it is essential to investigate the effect of other key factors ( metallicity , rotation rate , magnetic fields , binary membership ) @xcite . a major puzzle is due to the discovery of a number of sne at the extrema of the luminosity function and requires further physical understanding . a subset of sub - luminous type ii sne shows both a very faint radioactive tail in the light curve and a low expansion velocity suggesting low energy explosions and a possible black hole remnant , giving rise to significant fallback @xcite . different types of extremely luminous cc sne have been recently discovered in dwarf , faint host galaxies @xcite with an enormous luminosity at maximum that can not be powered by radioactive @xmath5ni . several scenarios have been proposed to explain these events : an explosion driven by black hole accretion @xcite , the spin down of a rapidly rotating young magnetar @xcite , interaction of the sn ejecta with a dense csm @xcite or pulsational pair instability in which collisions between high velocity shells are the source of multiple , bright optical transients @xcite . * what are the alternative explosion mechanisms producing a cc sn ? * + to explain the full range of explosion parameters of cc sne some theoretical studies suggested two alternative explosion mechanisms with respect to the collapse of the iron core : electron capture and pair instability . electron capture sne ( ec sne ) occur when a star in the mass range of @xmath6 forms an electron degenerate o - ne - mg core and the core may collapse before ne ignition @xcite . the lower and maximum initial mass for ec sne is determined by the competing effects of core growth and mass loss during the late evolutionary stages of super - agb stars and are quite uncertain ( @xmath7 , @xcite ) . the pair instability sne ( pi sne ) occur when the high temperatures in a massive core ( he core @xmath8 and initial mass @xmath9 ) induces electron - positron pair production reducing the radiation pressure and hence leading to a rapid contraction followed by a thermonuclear explosion . a similar mechanism is pulsational pair instability in which a massive core undergoes interior instability again due to electron - positron pair production ejecting many solar masses in a series of giant pulses @xcite . at the moment there are few observational probes of pi sne . * which type of massive stars produce black holes ? * + the origin of stellar mass black holes is not yet understood : some stars ( @xmath10 ) are expected to produce weak explosions with a black hole formed by fallback , some others ( @xmath11 ) collapse into a black hole directly without any optical signature ( failed sne ) . the failed sne have been invoked by theorists because of the difficulties of producing an explosion in analytical models but there are remarkably few observational probes of them , e.g. the lack of high mass progenitors may suggest there is a population of black - hole forming sne which so far have eluded discovery . the detection of sudden neutrino bursts with given duration and energy ( to discriminate other events , such as ordinary sne , neutron stars formations and so on ) , may be pontentially the signature of failed sne @xcite . also gamma - ray astronomy @xcite and gravitational - wave astronomy may be sensitive probes of failed sne @xcite . * what is the nature of sn impostors ? * + the luminosity gap separating novae and sub - luminous sne is recently being populated by a number of low energy events that have been classified as sne ( sn impostors ) and show a significant diversity ranging from giant eruptions of lbvs to very faint transients of unknown physical origin @xcite . the overlapping of bolometric luminosity and kinetic energies between sn impostors and faint cc sne requires to investigate in more detail the observational differences between explosive and eruptive transients . at the moment the only certain test to distinguish stellar eruptions from genuine cc sn explosions is to observe the outcome of the transient event : the surviving progenitor star in the case of eruptive event or a compact sn remnant in the case of cc sn explosion @xcite . we also need to understand the diversity of these transients that may reflect different eruption or explosion mechanisms ( luminous red novae , stellar mergers in low mass systems , erupting oh / ir stars , weak ec sne from super - agb stars ) @xcite . * what distinguishes a grb progenitor from that of hypernovae ? * + the energetically most extreme sne ib / ic ( hypernovae ) have been associated to long grbs @xcite . grb - sne are strongly aspherical explosions characterized by a very luminous maximum light , a huge expansion velocity and a very high kinetic energy ( about 10 larger than observed in standard cc sne ) @xcite . their progenitors are massive stars ( @xmath12 ) in low metallicity star forming environments @xcite with high rotation rate @xcite that lost all h envelope . to date only six clear cases of hypernovae have been discovered plus another three cases which show possible sn signatures in the spectra of the grb afterglows . the existence of sne ic / ib without observed grbs , as well as that of grbs without sn signatures , raises the question of what distinguishes a long grb progenitor from that of a hypernova and an ordinary sn ic / ib @xcite . there is general consensus that sne ia are thermonuclear explosions of a carbon and oxygen white dwarf ( co wd ) near the chandrasekhar mass ( @xmath13 ) in a binary system . the use of sne ia as standard candles is based on the assumption that all sne ia have similar progenitors and are highly homogeneous but the nature of the companion star and the details of the explosion mechanism are still debated . * what is the progenitor star and explosion mechanism of sne ia ? * + the most widely favoured progenitor scenarios for sne ia are the single degenerate scenario ( sd ) in which a wd , accreting from a non degenerate companion ( a main sequence star , a subgiant , a red giant or a helium star ) , grows in mass until it reaches the chandrasekhar mass and explodes in a thermonuclear runaway , or double degenerate scenario ( dd ) , in which a close double wd system merges after orbital shrinking due to the emission of gravitational waves @xcite.the time elapsed from the birth of the binary system to the sn explosion ( delay - time ) spans from tens of million years to ten billion years @xcite . a thermonuclear explosion may occur before the wd reaches the chandrasekhar mass ( sub - chandrasekhar models ) ( * ? ? ? * and reference therein ) or when the wd exceed the chandrasekhar mass ( super - chandrasekhar models ) in both sd and dd scenario @xcite . the observed features of standard sne ia are better explained by the chandrasekhar mass although no conclusive evidence for a specific scenario has so far been found . the recent discovery of variable circumstellar absorption lines in the snia 2006x @xcite and the first direct detection of the precursor of a sn ia ( an x - ray source at the position of sn 2007on , @xcite ) seem to support the sd scenario . however @xcite did not detect any x - ray source in images taken six weeks after sn 2007on optical maximum and found an offset between the sn and the measured x - ray source position of @xmath14 " . only future observations can shed light on the proposed connection between the x - ray source and the progenitor of sn 2007on , and thus on the most plausible scenario for this sn ia progenitor . the analysis of the recent sn 2011fe in m101 seems to rule out the presence of a red giant and helium - star donors in pre - explosion images @xcite , of a circumstellar wind from a giant donor @xcite and of shocks from ejecta hitting a companion , by analysing very early optical and uv data @xcite . the explosion mechanism of standard sne ia is also largely unknown ( see @xcite for a review ) . key issues include the initiation of the thermonuclear runaway , its initial ignition point and subsequent evolution . in the chandrasekhar mass scenario , a wd is thought to ignite near the center . at first the flame propagates subsonically as a deflagration and in a second phase a detonation triggers that propagates supersonically . the mechanism that leads to the formation of the detonation is still an open question : detonation transition by turbulence ( e.g. @xcite ) gravitationally confined detonation ( e.g. @xcite ) and pulsating reverse detonation @xcite . * why does their brightness correlate with light curve shape , color , stellar population age , metallicity ? * + thanks to the uniformity of their peak luminosities sne ia can be used as cosmological standard candles . a phenomenological correlation between their absolute magnitude and the shape of their light curves ( with brighter objects having a slower rate of decline ) has been provided to calibrate their distances @xcite . only recently models were able to reproduce this calibration in terms of the underlying physics @xcite . however , this one - parameter description does not completely account for the variety of sne ia . the relation between color and light curve shape ( brighter sne ia are both bluer and have wider light curves than their fainter counterparts ) has been exploited to provide a more accurate luminosity calibration . however , the intrinsic color variations of sne ia have not yet been fully understood . several suggestions have been made for additional parameters : metallicity @xcite , high - velocity spectral features , spectral flux ratios @xcite , and the mass and/or the morphological type of the host galaxy @xcite . an interesting possibility for the origin of the diverse properties of sne ia was recently suggested by @xcite theoretically and by @xcite observationally , namely an asymmetry in the sn explosion combined with the observer viewing angle . * what is the origin of sn ia diversity ? * + the standard sne ia used as cosmological distance indicators make up about 70% of the observed sne ia @xcite . with the advent of the new wide - area transient surveys , spectroscopic and photometric peculiarities have been noted in sne ia with increasing frequency and new subclasses of sne ia @xcite have been introduced : sub - luminous ( e.g. sn 1991bg ) , normal , bright ( e.g. sn 1991 t ) and super - luminous events ( e.g. sn 2007if ) . whether they form distinct physical groups from normal sne ia , with different progenitors and explosion models , or whether they lie at the extreme end of a continuous distribution is unclear . recent observations of sub - luminous and super - luminous sne ia suggest that their wd progenitors might have sub - chandrasekhar and super - chandrasekhar mass , respectively @xcite . various scenarios , for example a standard explosion with strong deviations from spherical symmetry of a chandrasekhar mass wd @xcite , or alternative energy sources other than radioactivity have been proposed to explain the super - luminous sne . it is also established that sub - luminous sne ia preferably occur in non - star - forming host galaxies with large stellar masses , such as ellipticals @xcite while super - luminous sne ia occur in relatively metal poor host galaxies @xcite understanding super - luminous and sub - luminous sne ia has important implications for cosmology and may challenge the paradigm of sn ia progenitors . modern sn searches are revealing ever more extreme examples of faint sne ia with lower kinetic energies , the nature of which is controversial with possible models ranging from the direct collapse of a massive star to a black hole to the pure deflagration of a wd ( e.g. , @xcite ) * are there two different progenitor channels ? * + a distinct population of sn ia progenitors ( called prompt ) with short delay time ( few hundred million years ) has been proposed to explain the high sn ia rate in blue star - forming galaxies and in radio - loud galaxies @xcite . tardy sne ia arise in old population of at least several gyr in red , passively evolving ellipticals @xcite . the prompt sne ia seem to have broader light curves , to be on average brighter and to show fewer intermediate - mass elements than their tardy counterparts . the ratio of prompt to tardy events is expected to change with redshift , tracking increasing sfr , with a resulting evolution in average light curve width , sn ia brightness , and spectral feature strength . the current measurements of type ia sn rates can not constrain the progenitor models for the uncertainties in the sf history and in sn rate measurements . progress in investigating the nature of type ia sn progenitors requires to link sn rates and parent stellar populations with measurements in star forming and in passively evolving galaxies over a wide range of redshifts from @xmath15 to @xmath16 @xcite . the first systematic supernova search was undertaken in 1934 by zwicky using a modest 3 - 1/4 inch lens camera . in 1936 he continued the search using photographic plates obtained with the 18 inch schmidt telescope at palomar observatory @xcite . this program was followed by the palomar supernova search @xcite , performed with the 18 and 48 inch schmidt telescopes , which lasted from 1959 till 1974 and discovered a total of @xmath17190 sne @xcite . + several sn searches followed . we list here a few examples : the asiago sn search , that covered the period 1959 - 1990 , and was performed with the 40/50 cm schmidt until 1967 and with the 67/92 cm schmidt afterward . this search produced @xmath1750 sne , most of them discovered by l. rosino on photographic plates @xcite . + the crimean sn search operated in the period 1961 - 1991 , using the 40 cm astrograph of the sternberg institute in crimea , and announced @xmath1740 sne @xcite . + reverend evans visual search produced 24 sne in the period 1980 - 1988 using 25 - 41 cm telescopes @xcite . evans sne were usually bright and nearby objects caught soon after explosion and hence interesting targets for detailed follow - up campaigns . + the observatoire de la cte dazur search was performed analyzing photographic plates acquired for other programmes using the 90/152 cm schmidt in the period 1987 - 1994 and produced @xmath1768 sne @xcite . + the caln tololo search operated in the period 1989 - 1995 using the 60/90 cm schmidt . the survey discovered @xmath1754 sne ( on photographic plates ) between 1990 and 1993 @xcite . this was the first survey at redshifts suitable for starting cosmological studies ( @xmath18 ) . in the last two decades of the @xmath19 century the advent of ccds revolutionized astronomy and visual or photographic observations were substituted by digital images . mechanical blinking machines and visual inspections were replaced by computer analysis.the improved ccd and computer technology , the increasing size of telescopes , the advent of larger detectors or ccd mosaics , the development of automated / robotic telescopes and more sophisticated image analysis software boosted the productivity of sn surveys of the 90s . [ fig : sndiscoveryrate1 ] graphically shows the evolution of the sn discovery rate with time and the steep increase that started at the end of last century.the same figure shows that a bit less than one half of the total are type ia sne . [ fig : sndiscoveryrate2 ] shows that the number of sne discovered from 1980 to 2010 increased by a factor @xmath20 with respect to all sn discovered before 1980 . we report here a not - exhaustive list of modern supernova surveys to illustrate this boom : * the high - z sn search @xcite ; * the supernova cosmology project ( scp ; @xcite ) ; * the lick observatory and the tenagra observatory supernova searches ( loss / lotoss ) @xcite ; * the perth automated sn search @xcite ; * the mount stromlo abell cluster supernova search ( msacss ; @xcite ) ; * the wise observatory optical transients search ( woots ; @xcite ) ; * the cfa supernova search @xcite ; * the seoul national university sn search ( snuss ; @xcite ) ; * the european sn cosmology consortium ( escc ; @xcite ) ; * the quest survey @xcite ; * the nearby galaxies sn search ( ngss ; @xcite ) ; * the eros nearby sn search ( erosnss ; @xcite ) ; * the beijing astronomical observatory sn survey ( baoss ; @xcite ) ; * the all - sky southern supernova search @xcite ; * the uk nova / supernova patrol @xcite ; * the super livermore optical transient imaging system ( super - lotis ; @xcite ) ; * goods hst sn search @xcite ; * the carnegie supernova project ( csp ; @xcite ) ; * the nearby supernova factory @xcite ; * the cfht supernova legacy survey ( snls ; @xcite ) ; * skymapper @xcite ; * the essence supernova survey @xcite ; * the southern intermediate redshift eso supernova search ( stress ; @xcite ) ; * sdss @xcite ; * the chilean automatic supernova search ( chase ; @xcite ) ; * the palomar transient factory ( ptf ; @xcite ) ; * the des supernova survey ( a dedicated supernova survey within the dark energy survey , des @xcite ; * the catalina real - time transient survey ( crts , @xcite ) ; the main characteristic distinguishing the surveys listed above is the targeted redshift range : surveys such as the high - z sn search , scp , essence , cfht snls , goods , des , are focused on high @xmath21 sne while other survey look for closer events . another distinct difference is the observational strategy : galaxy - targeted ( usual local ) sn surveys , monitoring a selected sample of galaxies or galaxy clusters , such as the loss search , and wide field non targeted and unbiased searches such as sdss . also some searches are not focused on sn only ( as the sdss , ptf or the crts ) , nevertheless they represent a relevant contribution to the sn discovery rate ( see fig . [ fig : sndiscoveryrate2 ] upper - right panel ) . [ fig : sndistribution ] shows the sn distribution in the sky . as expected from historical reasons , the northern sky is more populated than the southern , even if the sn distribution is quite homogeneous in galactic coordinates , with about one half of the sn discovered above and below the galactic plane ( the galaxy prevents the detection of sne behind the disk , that is in fact well visible as an empty strip in fig . [ fig : sndiscoveryrate2 ] ) . + in the course of the years the sn searches explored deeper and deeper redshifts . each redshift range presents different observational difficulties : low redshift surveys ( @xmath22 ) need wide but shallow field observations while pencil beam but deep imaging is enough for high redshift ( @xmath23 ) surveys . intermediate redshift searches ( @xmath24 ) require wide field and deep observations , that have been problematic for a long time . for this reason for some time hubble diagrams had a gap at the intermediate @xmath21 . nevertheless filling such interval was important for several reasons : to reduce the statistical uncertainties and to help detecting systematic errors such as a possible evolution of the supernovae characteristics . + the total number of sn announced in the last years is of the order of a few hundred ( see fig . [ fig : sndiscoveryrate1 ] ) but several surveys are being planned or have just started that are expected to significantly increase the discovery rate of sne producing ( each of them ) thousands of detection per years . some of the most promising next generation surveys are the following : * the panoramic survey telescope & rapid response system ( pan - starrs ) , an array of @xmath25 m telescopes monitoring @xmath26 square degrees in the northern hemisphere ( hawaii ) . this project is expected to detect @xmath27 transients in total ( sn , grb etc ) and in particular @xmath28 sne of all types per year ( 5000 sne ia per year at @xmath29)avishay / zwicky1/ppts/- + price.pdf ] . the prototype single - mirror telescope ps1 is already operational on mount haleakala , maui , hawaii @xcite . * the large synoptic survey telescope ( lsst ) , a 8.4 m telescope monitoring @xmath30 square degrees in the southern hemisphere ( cerro pachn , chile ) . first light is foreseen in 2018 , scientific observations will start in 2019 and the survey will be fully operational by 2020 . lsst is expected to detect @xmath31 sne per night ( up to @xmath32 ) , 30000 sne ia per year at @xmath33 and 250000 sne ia per year at an average redshift of @xmath34 , but with the most distant sn up to @xmath35 or even @xmath36 with extended exposure time . multiband ( six colors ) photometry will be provided and a fiber spectrograph can be attached to lsst , but dedicated spectroscopic follow up is required . these complementary surveys ( one in the northern and the other in southern sky ) will provide homogeneous unbiased sn samples order of magnitudes larger than the current ones . multicolour light curves will be secured for each observed object . the bottle - neck of such large surveys will be the rejection of false positive detections , the confirmation of the sn candidates and their follow - up . so far the astronomical community managed to provide substantial spectroscopic follow - up for relatively bright discoveries , but did not provide significant help for slightly fainter ( and much more numerous ) events @xcite . + we note the importance of untargeted and unbiased sn surveys . in the past supernovae searches were usually focused on large galaxies with high star formation rate to maximize the probability of sn detections . in this case the results were affected by selection effects . the modern unbiased surveys will allow us to detect sne in faint dwarf galaxies , hostless _ orphans _ sne and even new sn classes . many supernovae with peculiar new properties , such as ultra bright sne , have been already found ( e.g. @xcite ) . we expect that the untargeted surveys to produce an even larger richness in the sn variety that , in turn , will push for new explosion mechanism models . in this context , a significant contribution will be offered by the esa space mission gaia . gaia satellite is constituted by two 1.45 m @xmath37 0.5 m telescopes pointing in two directions separated by a 106.5 deg basic angle and merged into a single focal plane . the satellite will operate from l2 , @xmath38 km from the earth . launch date is set in june 2013 , the nominal mission ends after 5 years . gaia will continuously scan the whole sky spinning at 60/sec . due to the basic angle , each sky field is observed again after 106.5 minutes and it is possibly re - observed after a full satellite rotation , 4h 13 m later . this time sampling pattern is repeated sequentially several times as the result of the slow spinning and precession of the satellite . the same field may be observed again after @xmath3930 days on average and @xmath3980 times on average over the 5 years , but the scanning law is largely uneven and transits may vary between 40 and 250 times . regions lying at ecliptic latitude @xmath40 will be scanned on average more often than other locations . as shown in fig . [ fig : transitssky ] more than one half of the sky will be observed 60 - 90 times . recent estimates of the observable sne ( type ia + cc ) based on a limiting magnitude @xmath41 predicts @xmath42 sne over the 5-year mission and the most distant observed type ia sne will be at @xmath43 ( @xmath44 ) . about 1/3 of the sne is expected to be observed before maximum . with the aim to obtain a preliminary characterization of sne detected by gaia , we exploit our simulation tool which was developed to estimate the expected number of both sne types , along with their redshift and apparent magnitude distributions , for any given sn search . there are two types of inputs for this simulation : the transient properties ( photometric evolution and rate of occurrence ) and the survey strategy ( survey area , limiting magnitude and monitoring cadence ) . we considered `` classical '' sn classes : ia , iip , iil , iin and ib / c . for each of these sn types we need to know : a ) the template light and color curves along with absolute magnitude at maximum and dispersion ( li et al . 2011 ) ; b ) the k - correction as a function of redshift from the template to the survey observing band ( cf . @xcite ) ; c ) the current best estimate of the sn rate evolution with redshift ( @xcite and references therein ) . sne occur in galaxies with a rate that depends on the galaxy type and , for a given type , is , at least in first approximation , proportional to the galaxy luminosity . therefore , in principle , an accurate simulation would require as input the catalog of galaxies monitored by the search along with their type and luminosity . however , if the volume of the search , which is defined by the survey area times its depth , is large enough we can rely on the universe homogeneity on large scale and adopt volumetric rates . for the current simulation we assume that this is the case for the gaia survey that , although not very deep , is all sky . we derived the transit distributions for the different sky pixels from the gaia sky coverage map adopting a pixel resolution of 0.84 square degrees . as a further simplification we assumed that the transits occurring within 6 hours from the first observation ( i.e. after a full satellite rotation ) see the same sky while more distant transits are evenly distributed within the 5 years of the mission . for our aim to estimate the total number of sne detected by gaia and given the timescale of sn evolution this is quite a good approximation . we expect that gaia will detect about 6300 sne , most of them ia ( 85% ) and the remaining cc sne . of the sne ia detected about 30% will be discovered before maximum light . sne ia will be discovered up to redshift @xmath45 with a peak around @xmath46 . instead almost all cc sne will be at redshifts @xmath47 ( fig . [ fig : snzdistribution ] ) . based on tests with different assumptions , the uncertainty of the simulation is @xmath3910 - 15% . our results agree very well with the recent estimates by s. hodgkin ( private communication ) . + even if the expected number of sne detected by gaia decreased in the most recent estimates ( see @xcite , this work ) , it still represents a significant contribution to the current discovery rate ( fig.[fig : sndiscoveryrate1 ] ) . the gaia science alerts stream , with almost real time transient events , will be the first gaia data released to the astronomical community . it should be noted that transients will not be proprietary , as is often the case nowadays in many wide - field surveys undertaken by `` private '' projects . all transients data will be distributed immediately after the detection in accordance with the esa agreement . this will allow the scientific community to investigate interesting targets immediately . gaia is expected to disseminate several sn alerts per day along the five years mission , however many of these sn candidates will be either already discovered by other sn survey or very late due to the satellite time sampling . only the regions with frequently repeated visits will produce sn candidates which are very young , hence potentially most interesting . in all large surveys the rejection of false positive , the confirmation of the sn candidates and their prompt follow - up represent a challenging issue . the gaia time sampling will provide a photometric confirmation and a partial follow up , since for each observed object will be available a color and a low resolution spectrum provided by the two low dispersion slitless prism spectrographs , the blue photometer ( bp ) and the red photometer ( rp ) , that cover the 3300 - 6800 and 6400 - 10500 ranges respectively , with a spectral resolution varying from 20 to 100 approximately . in principle , these data can be very valuable to obtain a prompt transient classification as sn and possibly the sn type . each object brighter than magnitude 17 will be also observed through the radial velocity spectrometer ( rvs ) , providing an high resolution ( @xmath48 ) spectrum in a narrow region ( 8470 - 8740 ) around the calcium triplet . unfortunately most of the expected sne will be fainter than magnitude 17 . + due to the irregular time sampling and to the instrumental setup that is not optimal for sn follow - up , ground based observations are highly desirable . a prompt follow up is also desirable for studying early phases properly . the astronomical community , including the italian one , is trying to set up a network to secure a prompt reaction to the announcement of the transients detected by the satellite ( @xcite ) and an intensive follow - up of the most interesting transients . the most distant sne ia accessible to gaia are at @xmath49 , hence @xmath50 m class telescope , or even smaller for brighter objects , located in both the hemispheres , will be suitable . follow - ups may be limited to the most intensively regions monitored by gaia to achieve the maximum efficiency . + some of us are involved in the public eso spectroscopic survey for transient objects ( pessto ) at ntt and in the gaia - eso survey ( ges ) at vlt . the goal of pessto is to exploit the large allocations of telescope time available through an eso public survey to assemble data on all forms of sne covering the full range of parameter space that the current surveys now deliver ( luminosity , host metallicity , explosion mechanisms ) . the survey is expected to deliver time series spectra of 150 transients and optical and nir light curves for tha majority of these transients . in order to select the targets , @xmath51 sne are expected to be classified , and all information on these will be publicly available , providing an alert list available to the global community . pessto will start on april 2012 and 90 nights per year over 4 years ( with a possible 1 year extension ) have already been granted . the public spectroscopic survey ges started on dec . 31 , 2011 and a total of 240 nights over 4 years ( with a possible 1 year extension ) have already been awarded to the project . the main goal of the ges is to study the formation and evolution of the milky way and its stellar populations . the observation of @xmath52 stars , systematically covering all major components of the milky - way will provide valuable complementary data to gaia and vice versa . the unified study of sn progenitor stars and sn explosion characteristics as well as the analysis of the sn rate evolution with redshift are promising to solve important issues about these intriguing events and to exploit sne as cosmological standard candles and as a probe of the sfr . searches for transients to increase the sample of both standard and peculiar sne are required . while transients are not the founding scientific rationale of gaia , it has become clear that the mission will be a competitive , all sky transient survey without any input object bias and will collect a huge data - set of local sne , with a significant fraction of under - luminous and over - luminous events . a community of interested scientists is being formed and is in contact to discuss the science opportunities with this mission . + the big and homogeneous samples provided by gaia , coupled with a homogeneous data treatment , will allow robust statistical studies . relatively rare / peculiar sne or new transients will be studied in a statistically significant way , subclassifying them into much finer grids if necessary . these large statistical studies will significantly improve our understanding of the sn explosions and they will substantially reduce systematic errors in distance estimates , providing tighter constraints on cosmological parameters . + the extremely accurate positions provided by gaia will allow a detailed study of the sn spatial distribution in different galaxy types and environments . the precise spatial location together with additional data from ground - based observations may provide evidence for possible progenitors and correlations between sne properties , location / environment and host type . distances and redshifts will also be useful to probe the local velocity field .

despite decades of dedicated efforts there are still basic questions to answer with regard to supernova progenitor systems and explosion mechanisms . in particular , in the last years a number of exceptionally bright objects and extremely faint events have demonstrated an unexpected large supernova variety . the large number of supernovae candidates at different redshifts provided by the next generation surveys , from ground and space , will allow to reach a better insight of the supernova events in all their flavours . in particular it will be the possible to assess the systematics of type ia supernovae as distance indicator at any redshift . the gaia astrometric mission is expected to discover a huge number of transient events , including supernovae , which will be immediately disseminated to the astronomical community by a transients alert system for a suitable follow up .

1503.03312

statistics of neuronal activity is often described as a renewal point process , or even a poisson process , see @xcite and references therein . on the other hand , in some sets of experimental data correlations are observed between consecutive interspike intervals ( isi ) , @xcite , which does not conform with the renewal hypothesis . what could be the reason of such correlations ? in principle , any sort of memory in the neuronal firing mechanism could bring about memory into the sequence of isis , thus disrupting a possibility for it to be renewal . memory in the firing mechanism can appear due to partial reset of the membrane potential after firing , @xcite , or due to threshold fatigue @xcite , or for other reasons , see @xcite for a review . biologically , non - renewal statistics of neuronal activity can improve discrimination of weak signals @xcite and therefore is essential feature of functioning of a nervous system . in this context , it was checked in @xcite if it is possible to represent activity of electrosensory neuron as a markov chain of some finite order . conclusion made in @xcite is that the corresponding order , if any , can not be lower than 7 . normally , any neuron is embedded into a network . inter - neuronal communication in the network is delayed due to finite speed of nervous impulses . in a reverberating network , this brings about one more reason for non - renewal firing statistics the delayed feedback . we study here the simplest possible case of a network a single neuron with delayed feedback . in the previous paper @xcite , it was proven for a concrete neuronal model the binding neuron with threshold 2 stimulated with poisson stream of input impulses , that statistics of its isis is essentially non - markov . in this paper , we refine and extend methods of @xcite making those applicable to any neuron , which satisfies a number of very simple and natural conditions ( see cond0-cond4 in n. [ neuron ] ) . under those conditions , we prove rigorously that isi statistics of a neuron with delayed feedback can not be represented as a markov chain of any finite order . we do not specify any concrete neuronal model , only expect that a neuron satisfies the following conditions : * cond0 : neuron is deterministic : identical stimuli elicit identical spike trains from the same neuron . * cond1 : neuron is stimulated with input poisson stream of excitatory impulses . the input stream has intensity @xmath0 . * cond2 : neuron may fire a spike only at a moment when it receives an input impulse . * cond3 : just after firing , neuron appears in its standard state , which is always the same . * cond4 : the output interspike interval ( isi ) distribution is characterized with a probability density function ( pdf ) @xmath1 , which is positive : @xmath2 , and bounded : @xmath3 . the cond0 , above , is imposed in accordance with experimental observations , see e.g. @xcite . as regards the cond1 , poisson stream is a standard stimulation when neuronal random activity is studied . the cond2 , above , is satisfied for most threshold - type neuronal models , starting from standard leaky integrate and fire ( lif ) neuron @xcite and its modifications , see @xcite . in order the cond2 to be valid , it is enough that the following three conditions are satisfied : ( i ) neuronal excitation gets abrupt increase at the moment of receiving input impulse - function form . ] , ( ii ) after that moment , the degree of excitation does not increase ( it decreases for most neuronal models ) until the next input impulse . ( iii ) the neuron fires when its degree of excitation exceeds a threshold level . the threshold can be either static , as in the basic lif model , or dynamic @xcite . these conditions seem to be standard for many threshold neuronal models used , see @xcite and citations therein . cond3 means that any kind of memory about previous input / output activity , which can be present in a neuron , is cleared after each triggering . due to cond3 , output stream of neuron without feedback will be a renewal stochastic process . cond4 seems to be natural for any neuronal model stimulated with poisson stream . at least , all the five conditions are satisfied for the binding neuron model and for the basic lif model , see @xcite , where @xmath1 is calculated exactly for each model , respectively . we expect that each output impulse fired by neuron is fed back to the neuron s input through a feedback line . the feedback line has the following properties : * prop1 : the time delay in the line is @xmath4 . * prop2 : the line is able to convey no more than one impulse . * prop3 : the impulse conveyed to the neuronal input is identical to that from the input poisson stream . it is known that a neuron can form synapses ( autapses ) on its own body , or dendritic tree , e.g. @xcite . this substantiates consideration of a single neuron with feedback not only as the simplest reverberating `` network '' possible , bat also as an independent biologically relevant case . the delay @xmath5 comprises the time required by the output spike to pass the distance from axonal hillock , where it is generated , to the autapse and the synaptic delay . the prop2 is somehow related to the refractoriness even if we do not introduce here the refractoriness to its full extent . the prop3 means that we consider here an excitatory neuron . the important for us consequence of prop2 is that at any moment of time the feedback line is either empty , or conveys a single impulse . if it does convey an impulse , then its state can be described with a stochastic variable @xmath6 , which we call further `` time to live '' . the variable @xmath6 denotes the exact time required by the impulse to reach the output end of the line , which is the neuron s input , and to leave the line . it is clear that @xmath7 . in what follows , we use the time to live @xmath6 only at moments when an isi starts ( just after triggering ) . now it is worth to notice that each triggering starts a new isi . and at the beginning of any isi the line is never empty , but holds an impulse . this happens for the following reasons : * if neuron is triggered by an impulse from the poisson input stream , and the line was empty just before that moment , then the emitted impulse enters the line . at that moment the line is characterized with @xmath8 . * if neuron is triggered by an impulse from the poisson input stream , and the line already conveys an impulse at that moment with time to live @xmath6 , then that same impulse with that same time to live is retained at the beginning of the isi that starts after that triggering , and the line is characterized with that same @xmath6 . * if neuron is triggered by an impulse from the line , then the line is empty at the firing moment and the emitted impulse enters the line . after that moment the line is characterized with @xmath8 . we expect that defined in nn . [ neuron ] , [ line ] system of neuron with delayed feedback line fed with poisson stream is in its stationary regime . this can be achieved if the system functions long enough that its initial state is forgotten . in the stationary regime , let @xmath9 denotes the joint probability density function of neuron with delayed feedback . the probability to get , in the output , starting from the beginning , @xmath10 consecutive isis @xmath11 such that @xmath12 , @xmath13 with infinitesimal @xmath14 is given by @xmath15 . let @xmath16 denotes the conditional probability to get the duration of @xmath17-th isi in @xmath18 provided that previous @xmath19 isis had duration @xmath20 , respectively . now we reformulate in terms of probability density functions the definition from ( * ? ? ? * ch.2 6 ) : the sequence of random variables @xmath21 , taking values in @xmath22 , is called the markov chain of the order @xmath23 , if @xmath24 and this equation does not hold for any @xmath25 . in particular , taking @xmath26 , we have the necessary condition @xmath27 required for the stochastic process @xmath21 to be @xmath10-order markov chain . in the case of isis one reads @xmath28 . we intend to prove that the relation ( [ def ] ) does not hold for any @xmath10 . for this purpose we calculate exact expression for @xmath29 as @xmath30 from which it will be clearly seen that the @xmath31-dependence in @xmath29 can not be eliminated whatever large the @xmath10 is . as it is seen from ( [ defcond ] ) , we need initially to calculate exact expressions for @xmath32 with arbitrary @xmath10 . in @xcite , for the binding neuron model with threshold 2 this is done by introducing an auxiliary stochastic process with events @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the time to live at the beginning of isi @xmath35 . it was proven that the sequence of events @xmath33 , @xmath36 , is markov chain , which helps to calculate the joint probability density @xmath37 and then @xmath32 as marginal probability by integrating it over @xmath380;\delta]$ ] with respect to each @xmath34 . to simplify this approach , it is worth to notice that in the sequence of consecutive random events @xmath39 only the values of variables @xmath40 are fairly random . indeed , with @xmath41 given , one can figure out exact value for the @xmath42 : if @xmath43 then @xmath44 , and @xmath45 otherwise . now , with @xmath46 known , the same way it is possible to find the exact value of @xmath47 and so on . this allows one to reconstruct unambiguously all the values @xmath48 from the given sequence of values of @xmath40 . having this in mind , we introduce the conditional joint probability density @xmath49 , which we use to calculate required joint pdfs as follows @xmath50 where @xmath6 ( dented previously as @xmath51 ) is the time to live at the beginning of isi @xmath31 , @xmath52 is the stationary pdf which describes distribution of times to live at the beginning of any isi in the stationary regime . in what follows we analyze the structure of functions @xmath52 and @xmath49 . it appears that @xmath52 has a singular component @xmath53 with @xmath54 , and @xmath49 has a @xmath55-function - type singularities at definite hyper - planes in the @xmath17-dimensional space of its variables @xmath56 . after integration in ( [ pdfs ] ) , some of those @xmath55-functions will survive , and one of those survived has its argument depending on @xmath31 . the latter statement depends on exact value of isis in the sequence @xmath57 . here , we limit our consideration to the domain in the @xmath17-dimensional space of variables @xmath56 , which is defined as follows @xmath58 notice that @xmath59 is not involved in ( [ domain ] ) . the @xmath31-dependent @xmath55-function will as well survive in the @xmath29 for any @xmath10 , which will complete the proof that the condition ( [ def ] ) can not be satisfied for any @xmath10 . a question remains of whether the domain ( [ domain ] ) has a strictly positive probability . this indeed takes place due to positiveness of pdfs @xmath60 for any positive values of @xmath56 . the latter follows from the exact expressions for @xmath60 given in n. [ form ] , eq . ( [ pn ] ) . expect that the inequality ( [ domain ] ) holds . in order to perform integration in ( [ pdfs ] ) , we split the integration domain into the following @xmath62 disjoint sub - domains : @xmath63\sum\limits_{i=0}^{k-1}t_i\,;~\sum\limits_{i=0}^{k}t_i\right],~ k=0,\dots , n,~~ d_{n+1}=\left]\sum\limits_{i=0}^{n}t_i\,;~\delta\right]\,.\ ] ] it is clear that @xmath640;\delta].\ ] ] mutual disposition in time of @xmath6 and @xmath65 if @xmath66.,scaledwidth=66.0% ] the conditional pdf @xmath61 has different structure at different domains . if @xmath66 , then a relation between @xmath6 and @xmath35 is as shown in fig . [ relk ] . as it could be suggested by fig . [ relk ] , the first @xmath67 isis are produced with the delay line not involved . the @xmath68-th isi is generated with the line involved . the corresponding time to live is @xmath69 , the next time to live is @xmath70 . therefore , the structure of @xmath61 at @xmath71 is as follows @xmath72 mutual disposition in time of @xmath6 and @xmath65 if @xmath73.,scaledwidth=66.0% ] where @xmath74 . and if @xmath73 , then relation between @xmath6 and @xmath35 is as shown in fig . this suggests the following structure for @xmath61 @xmath75 here @xmath76 denotes the conditional pdf to get isi of duration @xmath77 if at its beginning , time to live of impulse in the feedback line is @xmath6 . by utilizing the same reasoning with ( [ domain ] ) taken into account , one can represent the first factor in ( [ struk ] ) as follows @xmath78 representation of @xmath61 by means of @xmath1 and @xmath76 , similar to that displayed in ( [ struk ] ) , ( [ strun+1 ] ) , ( [ strukf ] ) , can be as well constructed if ( [ domain ] ) does not hold . for our purpose it is enough to have ( [ struk ] ) , ( [ strun+1 ] ) and ( [ strukf ] ) . expect that at the beginning of an isi , there is an impulse in the feedback line with time to live @xmath6 . then the probability that this isi will have its duration @xmath80 does not depend on the feedback line presence . therefore , @xmath81 the probability to get exactly @xmath82 is not zero , because in this case the impulse , which triggers the neuron and finishes the isi under consideration comes from the delay line . in order this to happen , it is necessary and sufficient that the following two events take place : ( i ) the neuron does not fire at the interval @xmath380;s[$ ] ; ( ii ) at the moment @xmath6 , the neuron , due to previous stimulation from the poisson stream , achieves such a state that adding one more input impulse will trigger it . the probability of ( i ) and ( ii ) is @xmath83 , which can be easily concluded from the definition of @xmath1 . thus , @xmath84s-\epsilon;s+\epsilon[\,\ , \rightarrow\ , p(t\mid s ) = \frac{p^0(t)}{\lambda}\delta(s - t)\ ] ] with infinitesimal @xmath85 . if the neuron still not triggered at moment @xmath6 , then it is triggered by an input impulse from the poisson stream at @xmath86 . the probability to get such an impulse in @xmath87 is @xmath88 . therefore , one can expect that for @xmath86 , @xmath89 . based on the above reasoning we represent @xmath76 in the following form @xmath90 where @xmath91 is a bounded function is calculated exactly for the binding neuron model . ] . in the stationary regime , the pdf @xmath52 must satisfy the following equation @xmath92 where the transition function @xmath93 gives the probability density to find at the beginning of an isi an impulse in the line with time to live @xmath6 provided at the beginning of the previous isi , there was an impulse with time to live @xmath94 . to determine exact expression for @xmath93 we take into account that after single firing , time to live can either decrease , or become equal @xmath5 . therefore , @xmath95 if @xmath96 , then the firing , which causes transition from @xmath94 to @xmath6 , happens without the line involved . therefore , @xmath97 finally , it is possible that starting from @xmath94 one obtains @xmath8 after the next firing . in order this to happen , it is necessary and sufficient that no firing happens during @xmath94 units of time . and this happens with probability @xmath98 having this in mind , one could conclude that in the plane @xmath99 , at the straight line @xmath8 , @xmath94 any , the @xmath93 has singularity of the following form : @xmath100 now , with ( [ trans1])-([trans3 ] ) taken into account , eq . ( [ trans ] ) can be rewritten as follows @xmath101 it is clear from this equation that @xmath52 has the following form is calculated exactly for the binding neuron model . ] @xmath102 where @xmath54 and @xmath103 is bounded and vanishes out of interval @xmath380;\delta]$ ] . let @xmath105 . at @xmath106 , representations ( [ struk ] ) and ( [ strukf ] ) are valid . also at @xmath106 , @xmath52 reduces to @xmath103 . therefore , @xmath107 taking into account ( [ pstruc ] ) it can be concluded that expression ( [ intd ] ) , after performing integration , does not have any term with @xmath55-function depending on @xmath31 . consider now the remaining part of integral in ( [ pdfs ] ) . with ( [ strun+1 ] ) taken into account one has : @xmath108after substituting here expressions ( [ pstruc ] ) , ( [ ff ] ) one obtains four terms : @xmath109 after performing integration , only the fourth term here includes a @xmath55-function . and argument of this @xmath55-function does depend on @xmath31 . after taking ( [ intd ] ) and ( [ intdn+1 ] ) together we conclude that the required joint probability density has the following form @xmath110 where function @xmath111 does not have singularities depending on @xmath31 . if ( [ domain ] ) is satisfied , then we have similarly to ( [ struk ] ) , ( [ strun+1 ] ) @xmath112 @xmath113 again due to ( [ domain ] ) , and in analogy with ( [ strukf ] ) we have instead of the last two equations the following one : @xmath114 it is clear that expression similar to ( [ strun+1 ] ) turns here into the following @xmath115 now , due to ( [ strn ] ) , ( [ strn+1 ] ) we have @xmath116 now , with representations ( [ pn+1 ] ) for @xmath60 and ( [ pn ] ) for @xmath104 we can pose a question about the form of @xmath118 . the latter can be found as defined in ( [ defcond ] ) . first of all notice that due to ( [ pn ] ) and cond4 , @xmath104 is strictly positive for positive isis . this allows us to use it as denominator in the definition ( [ defcond ] ) . second , it can be further concluded from ( [ pn ] ) and cond4 , that @xmath104 is bounded , and therefore does not include any singularity of @xmath55-function type . the latter means that any singularity contained in the @xmath60 appears as well in the @xmath118 . it follows from the above that the conditional pdf @xmath118 can be represented in the following form : @xmath119 where @xmath120 does not contain any @xmath55-function depending on @xmath31 , and @xmath121 is strictly positive bounded function : @xmath122 the representation ( [ firepr ] ) thus proves unequivocally that for any @xmath10 , conditional pdf @xmath118 does depend on @xmath31 ( the second term in ( [ firepr ] ) ) and this dependence can not be eliminated . we have proven here that any neuronal model , which satisfies cond0-cond4 , above , and is equipped with a delayed feedback , will display essentially non - markov activity expressed in terms of output isis , when stimulated with poisson stream . this has a consequence for admissible approaches while modeling activity of neuronal networks with stochastic behavior . indeed , in a reverberating network , a delayed feedback mediated by other neurons is always present . our result suggests that in this case , activity of individual neurons in the network should be essentially non - markov . another situation in networks with instantaneous interneuronal communication . in the case of no delay communications , the neuronal activity can well be markov , or even poisson , see example in @xcite . we used here a single neuron with delayed feedback as the simplest case of reverberating `` network '' . at the same time , neurons which send to themselves their output impulses are known in real nervous systems , @xcite . therefore , our conclusions about essentially non - markov behavior should be valid for those neurons even without taking into account their involvement in a wider network activity . the set of conditions cond0-cond4 while being rather natural and wide enough , leaves out of our consideration many neuronal models known in neuroscience . e.g. , cond2 excludes models with spike latency . cond3 excludes models with internal memory extending beyond a single isi duration . thus , we do not consider here partial afterspike resetting @xcite , threshold fatigue @xcite , another types of adaptation , like multi - timescale adaptive threshold @xcite . any kind of adaptation in individual neuron is by itself able to bring about a kind of memory in the neuronal output stream . therefore , considering neurons without adaptation we demonstrate here , that delayed feedback without additional memory - like mechanisms known for neurons makes neuronal output essentially non - markov . another limitation is cond1 we use a poisson process as a stimulus . it seems that the proof given here can be extended to a wide class of renewal processes taken as stimuli . this will be checked in further work . a. k. vidybida . output stream of binding neuron with delayed feedback . in j. jzefczyk , w. thomas , and m. turowska , editors , _ 14th international congress of cybernetics and systems of wosc , wroclaw , poland , september 9 - 12 , 2008 _ , pages 292302 . oficyna wydawnicza politechniki wroclawskiej , 2008 .

for a class of excitatory spiking neuron models with delayed feedback fed with a poisson stochastic process , it is proven that the stream of output interspike intervals can not be presented as a markov process of any order . * keywords . * spiking neuron ; poisson stochastic process ; probability density function ; delayed feedback ; non - markov stochastic process

quant-ph0205106

the quantum mechanical motion of electrons in two - dimensional space , subject to crossed magnetic and electric fields and in the presence of a single impurity described by a zero - range potential , provides a basis for the explanation of the integer quantum hall effect @xcite . until now in all considerations the electric field has been treated as a small perturbation . the purpose of the present work is to reconsider these investigations and to discuss some novel phenomena which appear for nonperturbative electric fields . in our approach an attractive impurity is modelled as a zero - range potential center , as has been already exploited in @xcite . it turns out that in order to define such a point interaction one needs to renormalize the strength of the @xmath0-function and that such a renormalized potential is capable of supporting one localized state per landau level . this finding also corresponds to the result obtained by gyger and martin @xcite . investigating the case of a weak electric field they have proven that all localized states change into resonances with lifetimes varying with the electric field in a gaussian way . with reference to these papers we shall focus our attention on the opposite regime , i.e. , when the electric fields is strong . our aim is to answer the following questions : 1 . how many resonance states exist per one landau level for a non - vanishing electric field ? 2 . what is a maximum electric field above which resonance states of a given lifetime can not exist ? we shall see that apart from the well - known localized states lying between landau levels @xcite _ new resonance states _ are created by a strong electric field , the lifetime of which can be comparable to or larger than typical times encountered in solid state physics . throughout this paper we use units in which @xmath1 . the two - dimensional system we are concerned with is governed by the hamiltonian which , for convenience , we decompose into two parts , @xmath2 related to the physical situation for which the green s function is known and a @xmath0-like potential with the strength given by the so - called bare coupling constant @xmath3 , @xmath4 such a model has been extensively studied in the literature @xcite proving its usefulness in many branches of physics . it is , however , important to realize that the model is not free from difficulties . to be more precise , it exhibits divergencies which have to be tempered by renormalizing the bare coupling constant @xmath3 . therefore , let us address this problem and show how to remove all divergent terms by considering the retarded green s function for the hamiltonian @xmath5 . our starting point is the lippmann - schwinger equation which , in this particular case , adopts the form @xmath6 where the regularized green s function for the hamiltonian @xmath2 , denoted by @xmath7 , is assumed to be known . now performing the foregoing integral over @xmath8 and making some algebraic manipulations we arrive at the retarded green s function for our model @xmath9 it appears that @xmath10 is the only term which needs to be regularized in order to avoid divergencies . let us explain how to cope with them analyzing the simplest case of a free electron with an effective mass @xmath11 interacting only with the @xmath0-like potential . in our approach we choose a particular regularization scheme which we call the proper time regularization . we expect that although the bare coupling constant @xmath3 depends on the regularization scheme chosen , the observable quantities , like poles of the full green s function in the complex energy plane , can not depend on this scheme . indeed , we shall demonstrate that our method leads to the same equation for energies of localized states in the magnetic field as in @xcite . for a free particle the retarded green s function in the so - called fock - schwinger proper time represantation @xcite has the form @xmath12 where the singularity for @xmath13 is avoided by modifying the integration contour over the proper time @xmath14 in such a way that it lies just below the real axis ( this means that @xmath15 is a small positive parameter ) . naturally , the retarded green s function for non - vanishing @xmath16 or @xmath17 is recovered by putting @xmath18 . such a prescription we call the proper time regularization . now , it is straightforward to show that the denominator in eq . ( [ e2.3 ] ) reads @xmath19 it is also clear that the integral above diverges logarithmically for small values of @xmath14 when @xmath18 . this divergence , however , can be absorbed into the bare coupling constant @xmath3 giving the finite expression for the full green s function even for @xmath15 equal to 0 . indeed , performing the proper time integration by parts we arrive at @xmath20 where @xmath21 is an arbitrary positive parameter of the same dimensionality as @xmath14 , whereas @xmath22 is the renormalized coupling constant defined by the relation @xmath23 let us remark that in order to temper a singular part in the formula above the bare coupling constant @xmath3 has to be negative . this means , in fact , that in two dimensions there can not exist a repulsive point interaction . having this in mind we shall restrict ourselves only to the case with an attractive point interaction for which , after performing the remaining integral , we have @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the euler s constant . this equation shows that independently of numerical values of @xmath22 and @xmath21 there exists @xmath26 such that the denominator of the full green s function vanishes , i.e. , the two - dimensional zero - range potential always supports a bound state . denoting the energy of this state by @xmath27 we end up with the following expression for the denominator @xmath28 , @xmath29 let us add in closing that there still remains a free parameter of the theory , i.e. , the energy of a bound state @xmath27 . nevertheless , it has now the clear physical meaning in the sense that its value can be measured , contrary to the artificial and physically unclear parameters @xmath21 and @xmath22 . in this section we consider the two - dimensional system composed of an electron and @xmath0-like impurity placed in the external magnetic and electric fields for which the hamiltonian @xmath2 can be written as @xmath30-e{\cal e}x \ , , \label{e3.1}\ ] ] where the electric @xmath31 and magnetic @xmath32 fields are directed towards @xmath33 and @xmath34 axes , respectively , whereas the vector potential is taken in the circular gauge , @xmath35 . as we have already pointed out , the problem of finding energies of impurity - induced resonance states consists in searching for zeros of the denominator in eq . ( [ e2.3 ] ) . therefore , what we have to know is the regularized green s function for the hamiltonian @xmath2 . applying the proper time regularization scheme discussed above we arrive at the regularized retarded green s function @xmath36 , @xmath37 \ , , \label{e3.2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the denominator @xmath28 , @xmath38 \ , , \label{e3.3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath39 is the cyclotron frequency . comparing this formula with eq . ( [ e2.5 ] ) one can notice that in both these expressions the integrals over @xmath14 diverge for small arguments exactly in the same way . hence , we gather that now it is also possible to temper the divergent term by renormalizing the coupling constant @xmath3 . at this point let us introduce new dimensionless units . as a typical length scale for the problem we take @xmath40 , whereas the dimensionless scaled electric field and energy are @xmath41 and @xmath42 , respectively . additionally , choosing a new variable @xmath43 we find that @xmath44 \ , . \label{e3.4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] at first glance it might seem that the integral above is divergent for @xmath45 , where @xmath46 . it is not , however , the case . indeed , analyzing the integrand in the close vicinity of these points one can prove the convergence of the foregoing integral . having this in mind we shall discuss below the special case when the electric field is switched off . for @xmath47.,width=283 ] for @xmath47.,width=283 ] for @xmath48.,width=283 ] the problem without an electric field has been already examined by cavalcanti and de carvalho in @xcite . however , we have found it interesting to derive their equation for energies of the impurity - induced localized states using the proper time regularization scheme . our point of departure is the function defined by eq . ( [ e3.4 ] ) with @xmath49 , @xmath50 \ , . \label{e3.5}\ ] ] in order to treat these two integrals separately we regularize them first . this allows us to integrate them by parts and put finally the regularization parameter @xmath15 equal to 0 , keeping in mind , however , that the integration contour over @xmath51 lies just below the real axis , @xmath52 \ , . \label{e3.6}\end{aligned}\ ] ] next , let us expand @xmath53 into series of @xmath54 . this is allowed because the inequality @xmath55 holds for @xmath51 possessing a negative imaginary part , which is guaranteed by our choice of a regularization scheme . hence , inserting into eq . ( [ e3.6 ] ) the series expansion @xmath56 and carrying out all integrations term by term , we arrive at @xmath57 \ , . \label{e3.8}\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , relating the sum above to a digamma function @xmath58 , we find that the eigenenergies of our system are zeros of the following function @xmath59 \ , , \label{e3.9}\ ] ] which is adequate to the result derived in @xcite with the help of another regularization scheme . zeros of @xmath60 determine the dependence of @xmath61 on @xmath62 for those localized states which are extracted from the landau levels by the zero - range interaction . it is shown in fig . [ fig1 ] that only one state is extracted per landau level , which is understandable , since in the degenerate landau level there is only one state the wavefunction of which does not vanish at the origin , i.e. , the cylindrically symmetric state @xcite . the situation changes if the electric field is present . it mixes this state with those landau states which explicitly depend on the polar angle . for small electric fields such a mixing is also small and the effect of a point interaction can be neglected . however , for strong electric fields this effect becomes considerable as we are going to show this below . and @xmath63 in fig . [ fig3].,width=283 ] for @xmath64.,width=283 ] in order to determine resonance energies for a non - vanishing electric field we have to find complex zeros of @xmath60 defined by eq . ( [ e3.4 ] ) and lying below the real axis . this means that we have to solve one complex equation , @xmath65 , with four unknown real parameters : @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath62 and the scaled electric field @xmath68 . to this end we shall fix one of these parameters , treat another one as a free parameter , and find the remaining two parameters by solving this equation , i.e. , by determining poles of the full green s function . at the beginning let us fix the imaginary part of the resonance energy and find all possible zeros of @xmath60 . the results are shown in figs . [ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] . in fig . [ fig2 ] we present the real part , @xmath66 , of all resonance states of a given @xmath47 for the bound state energy @xmath62 between @xmath69 and 0 , as it has been already presented in fig . [ fig1 ] for the vanishing electric field ( in both these figures we show only those states for which @xmath70 , i.e. , lying above the first landau level ) . we observe that , apart from the already existing impurity - induced bound states for @xmath71 , a non - vanishing electric field generates new resonance states which are located in the vicinity of landau levels of energy @xmath72 for @xmath73 greater than 0 . moreover , as it follows from our numerical investigations , the number of these new resonance states is equal to @xmath73 . this means that for a non - vanishing electric field and for a given quantum system , specified by the binding energy @xmath62 , the number of impurity - induced resonances per landau level is equal to @xmath74 , where the quantum number @xmath73 labels the landau energy . it appears that for the vanishing electric field real parts of energies of these new resonances approach the landau energy , as it is shown in fig . [ fig3 ] , in which we present the real part , @xmath66 , of all resonance states of a given @xmath47 as the function of @xmath68 . we observe that for a given imaginary part of resonances there is a maximum electric field above which no such resonance states exist . this is not a surprising fact . what is unexpected , however , is that the maximum electric field very little depends on the imaginary part of resonance energies chosen , as it is shown in fig . [ fig4 ] for @xmath48 ; although the lifetime of these _ new states _ has increased hundred times the maximum electric field has decreased only by a small fraction . this finding could suggest that even for nonperturbative electric fields there could exist long - living resonance states , as it will be discussed in details in @xcite . the lines in figs . [ fig3 ] and [ fig4 ] corresponding to the electric - field - induced resonances are , in fact , a narrow loops . in fig . [ fig5 ] we present in an enlarged scale two such resonances labelled by @xmath75 and @xmath63 in fig . it is clearly seen that for these particular resonances paths of the real part of resonance energies with a changing electric field represent closed loops which start from a landau level . for a fixed electric field there are two states which correspond to two different binding energies @xmath62 and , as could be expected , the lower parts of these loops correspond to the stronger attraction , i.e. , to the larger values of @xmath76 . .physical values of the magnetic field @xmath77 , electric field @xmath78 and lifetime @xmath79 for some chosen values of the bound state energy @xmath27 for a particular resonance . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in order to estimate the lifetime of one of these new resonance states let us take @xmath80 and @xmath81 for which there exists the resonance of energy @xmath82 . this resonance corresponds in fig . [ fig3 ] to the rightmost point lying near the first excited landau level . in table [ tab1 ] we show some numerical values of the magnetic field @xmath77 ( in teslas ) , electric field @xmath78 ( in kilovolts per meter ) and lifetime @xmath79 ( in nanoseconds ) for this resonance state and for some typical values of the binding energy @xmath27 of an electron with effective mass @xmath83 ( in the electron s mass unit ) trapped by an attractive impurity in the gaas quantum well @xcite . our evaluations show that in spite of applying strong electric fields , which , in general , are expected to destabilize a system , one can observe generation of long - living states with lifetimes comparable to or even larger than typical timescales encountered in semiconductor heterostructures . let us close this paper discussing the resonances extracted by an attractive impurity and electric field from the third excited landau level of @xmath84 . we fix now the binding energy by assuming that @xmath64 and draw the dependence of the complex resonance energy @xmath61 on the electric field intensity @xmath68 . as we have shown this above , the number of such states is equal to @xmath74 and @xmath73 of them approach the @xmath73-th landau level for the vanishing electric field . the same conclusion can be reached looking at the upper panel of fig . [ fig6 ] , while in the lower panel we present lifetimes of these states . we see that the state a , related to the old states discussed before in @xcite , is very stable for weak electric fields , but with an increasing @xmath68 its lifetime suddenly decreases . on the contrary , the lifetimes of new electric - field - induced resonances , discussed in this paper , are shorter for weak fields , but with the increasing @xmath68 we observe a peculiar behavior for one of them , i.e. , for the resonance d ; instead of a continuous decrease we observe that for some particular values of @xmath68 the lifetime increases , approaches its maximum value , and then starts decreasing . we call this phenomenon the electric - field - induced stabilization and we relate it to quantum vortices , positions of which are controlled by an electric field . a detailed analysis of this problem will be presented in our subsequent paper @xcite . 99 r. e. prange , phys . b 23 ( 1981 ) 4802 . r. e. prange , r. joynt , phys . b 25 ( 1982 ) 2943 . r. joynt , r. e. prange , phys . b 29 ( 1984 ) 3303 . f. perez , f. a. b. coutinho , am . j. phys . 59 ( 1991 ) 52 . r. m. cavalcanti , c. a. a. de carvalho , j. phys . a 31 ( 1998 ) 2391 . s. gyger , p. a. martin , j. math . 40 ( 1999 ) 3275 . e. h. hauge , j. m. j. van leeuwen , physica a 268 ( 1999 ) 525 . s. albeverio , f. gesztesy , r. hegh - krohn , h. holden , solvable models in quantum mechanics , springer , heidelberg , 1988 . i. j. berson , j. phys . b 8 ( 1975 ) 3078 . f. h. m. faisal , p. filipowicz , k. rzaewski , phys . a ( 1990 ) 6176 . p. filipowicz , f. h. m. faisal , k. rzaewski , phys . a ( 1991 ) 2210 . n. l. manakov , m. v. frolov , a. f. starace , i. i. fabrikant , j. phys . b 33 ( 2000 ) r141 . k. wdkiewicz , phys . a 43 ( 1991 ) 68 . c. itzykson , j. b. zuber , quantum field theory , mcgraw - hill , new york , 1980 . i. biaynicki - birula , m. cieplak , j. kamiski , theory of quanta , oxford university press , new york , 1992 . k. krajewska , j. z. kamiski , in preparation . t. pang , s. g. louie , phys . 65 ( 1990 ) 1635 .

a two - dimensional electron system interacting with an impurity and placed in crossed magnetic and electric fields is under investigation . since it is assumed that an impurity center interacts as an attractive @xmath0-like potential a renormalization procedure for the retarded green s function has to be carried out . for the vanishing electric field we obtain a close analytical expression for the green s function and we find one bound state localized between landau levels . it is also shown by numerical investigations that switching on the electric field new long - living resonance states localized in the vicinity of landau levels can be generated .

astro-ph0611123

hii galaxies are low - metallicity objects undergoing violent star formation @xcite.their optical spectra show strong emission lines ( recombination lines of hydrogen and helium , as well as forbidden lines of elements like oxygen , neon , nitrogen , sulfur , among others ) that are very similar to the spectra of extragalactic hii regions ( e.g. @xcite ) . among them we can find the least chemically - evolved galaxies in the local universe.due to their proximity they offer ideal laboratories for studying massive star formation with an accuracy and spatial resolution that can not be achieved in similar studies in the distant universe . the integral field unit ( ifu ) spectrographs allow simultaneous spectra to be taken of extended objects . from this , we can learn how the interstellar medium ( ism ) is structured , and derive physical conditions and chemical properties corresponding to individual star - forming knots and external ionized gas component ( located at more or less one kpc from the main body of the galaxy ) . the study of the distribution of these properties is an important issue for our understanding of the interplay between the massive stellar population and the ism , unveiling the mechanisms that govern star formation . studying the chemical abundance distribution of the ionized gas can be used as a tool to explore the possible chemical evolution paths . our sample is composed by three hii galaxies : izw18 , iizw70 and iizw71 . izw18 , since pioneering work of @xcite , has remained a unique object for the study of the chemical evolution galaxies , given its very low oxygen abundance , approximately 1/50 solar , and the absence of a significant underlying old population . however , whether this is a signature of youth remains a subject of debate ( e.g. @xcite ) . the optical structure of this galaxy is very rich , including the two ( southeast and northwest ) central bright knots within the main body @xcite . iizw70 and iizw71 are two prototypical hii galaxies that are interacting . iizw70 presents a conspicuous central star - forming region , and extending to the north - west and south - west there appear fan - like extensions , resembling jet structures @xcite . iizw71 shows a chain of individual star - forming knots that crosses the whole optical body of the galaxy and accounts for all the h@xmath2 emission . two - dimensional spectra have been analyzed in order to derive the properties of the different components of the galaxy iizw70 , that was observed with pmas at caha . the pmas spectrograph is equipped with 256 fibers coupled to a @xmath3 lens array . each fiber has a spatial sampling of 0 @xmath45@xmath50 @xmath45 on the sky resulting in a field of view of @xmath6 . mosaic patterns were used to cover the central regions and different regions of interest ( e.g. , tidal tails ) . the data were reduced using the software r3d @xcite . we fitted the line profiles to derive the integrated flux of each emission line , using the software fit3d @xcite , already used in previous similar studies @xcite,@xcite . in figure [ maps ] we show maps of iizw70 in the flux for the lines h@xmath2@xmath06563 and [ oiii]@xmath05007 . the original pixels have been resampled in order to smooth the emission features . emission line images are created by selecting appropriate narrow band filters from the data cube . these narrow band images are created in a wavelength range of @xmath710 around the emission wavelength and show emission line fluxes not corrected by reddening . the continuum emission is subtracted using narrow - band images in wavelengths adjacent to the emission lines . figure [ fig1 ] shows the diagnostic diagrams , [ oiii]@xmath05007/h@xmath8 vs. [ sii]@xmath96717,31/h@xmath2 and [ oiii]@xmath95007/h@xmath8 vs. [ nii]@xmath96584/h@xmath2 @xcite , only for the fibers that present diagnostic line - intensity ratios with relative errors @xmath10 30@xmath11 . line fluxes were corrected for interstellar extinction using the value of c(h@xmath12 ) for each fiber , applying the extinction law given by @xcite . the solid lines show the classical separation between ionization due to star formation ( left ) and active galactic nuclei ( agn ) ( right ) . the boundary curve between agns and star forming regions is taken from @xcite . @xmath05007/h@xmath12 and [ sii]@xmath0@xmath06717,31/h@xmath2 and right panel displays [ oiii]@xmath05007/h@xmath12 line ratio as a function of [ nii]@xmath06584/h@xmath2 ; only line ratios with relative errors @xmath10 30@xmath11 are shown ; the solid lines are the dividing lines between hii - regions galaxies ( left ) and agns ( right ) @xcite.,width=302 ] the diagnostic diagrams give us information about the nature of the ionizing source . we can see that most of line - intensity ratios measured for each fiber , at both diagrams , are located on the left side of the solid curves . this suggests that for the galaxy iizw70 the ionising radiation is mainly related to the most massive youngest stars . we would like to stress that spectrophotometric studies of hii galaxies are of paramount importance in order to derive their evolutionary status . besides , high - resolution spectroscopy of hii galaxies will help trace the kinematics of the galaxy and provide valuable information on the mechanisms triggering the star formation . a detailed analysis of these data is going to be presented in a forthcoming paper .

we present preliminary results from our ongoing work on integral field spectroscopy ( ifs ) of the three prototypical hii galaxies iizw70 , iizw71 and izw18 @xcite . the observations were taken with the instruments integral / wyffos at the wht ( orm , la palma ) and pmas ( calar alto , almeria ) , covering a spectral range from 3600 to 6800 thus including from [ oii]@xmath03727 @xmath1 up to the [ sii]@xmath0@xmath06717,31 @xmath1 lines . two - dimensional spectroscopy allows us to collect simultaneously the spectra of many different regions of an extended object , combining photometry and spectroscopy in the same data set . the great advantage of using ifs for the investigation of galaxies is that it allows us to obtain data on the galaxy positions , velocity fields and star - formation properties all in one data cube . our main aim is to perform a bidimensional study of the ionization structure , physical - chemical conditions and the velocity field of the ionized gas in these galaxies @xcite . maps of the relevant emission lines and a preliminary analysis of the ionization structure are presented for iizw70 .

hep-th0512084

in this contribution we discuss a model for noncommutative quantum mechanics ( ncqm ) where noncommutativity in the phase space is considered in the context of the gravitational quantum well ( gqw ) @xcite . furthermore , we consider the dependence of the energy spectrum of the gqw on the mass of the particles in order to study the quantum to classical transition @xcite recently , there has been quite some interest on the noncommutative geometry in the context of quantum mechanics . this has its roots on the role that noncommutative geometry plays in unification models and in string theory . indeed , since the discovery that the low - energy effective theory of a d - brane in the background of a ns - ns b field lives in a noncommutative space @xcite , many efforts have been devoted to the study of noncommutative field theories ( see @xcite and refs . therein ) , to the understanding of the coupling to gravity ( see @xcite and refs . therein ) and , to the non - relativistic limit , through versions of ncqm @xcite . although in string theory only the coordinates space exhibits a noncommutative structure , models in which the noncommutative geometry is extended to the phase space have been recently much discussed @xcite . the main argument for this approach is that noncommutativity between momenta arises naturally as a consequence of noncommutativity between coordinates , as momenta are defined as the partial derivatives of the action with respect to the noncommutative coordinates @xcite . in a 4-dimensional space , this type of phase space structure is defined through the following algebra : [ noncommutation_1 ] x^,x^]=&i^ , p^,p^]=i^ , x^,p^]=i^ , where the parameters @xmath2 and @xmath3 are antisymmetric . this algebra is consistent with standard quantum mechanics thanks the last commutation relation in the set of eqs . ( [ noncommutation_1 ] ) . in a recent paper @xcite , a 2-dimensional version of this algebra , defined by the noncommutative parameters @xmath4 and @xmath5 and by planck s constant @xmath6 has been considered [ noncommutation_2 ] x , y]&=&i , p_x , p_y]=i , x_i , p_j]=i_iji=1,2 . the implementation of this algebra can be performed by considering the noncommutative variables @xmath7 from the commutative variables @xmath8 through linear transformations . two sets of linear transformations can be used to obtain the complete algebra , eqs . ( [ noncommutation_2 ] ) . the first kind of transformation affects only the variables @xmath9 and @xmath10 , while the second affects variables @xmath11 and @xmath12 , thus leading to different results . to eliminate this ambiguity it is convenient to consider a set of linear transformations that modify simultaneously all variables : [ linear_1 ] x=(x-2p_y ) , y=(y+2p_x ) , p_x=(p_x+2y ) , p_y=(p_y-2x ) , where @xmath13 is a scaling factor . in this way , the commutation relations between coordinates and the ones between momenta in eq . ( [ noncommutation_2 ] ) are recovered , however the commutation relation between coordinates and momenta is altered to [ noncommutation_3 ] [ x_i , p_j]=i_eff_iji=1,2 , where we have defined the _ effective planck constant _ @xmath14 and set @xmath15 . in a 4-dimensional space , the generalization of the linear transformations eq . ( [ linear_1 ] ) may be written as : [ linear_2 ] x^=(x^-^ _ 2p^ ) , p^=(p^+^ _ 2x^ ) . if one chooses @xmath15 , these transformations lead to the following 4-dimensional algebra : [ noncommutation_4 ] x^,x^]&=&i^ , p^,p^]=i^ , x^,p^]=i(^+^^ _ 4 ^ 2 ) . hence , one can define a _ 4-dimensional effective planck constant _ as : [ planck_constant_1 ] _ eff=(1+tr[]4 ^ 2 ) . furthermore , it is clear that the commutation relation between coordinates and momenta is not diagonal , the off - diagonal elements are proportional to products of @xmath2 and @xmath3 . we have considered in ref . @xcite the linear transformations eqs . ( [ linear_1 ] ) to determine the noncommutative hamiltonian for a particle moving in the @xmath16 plane subject to a uniform gravitational field @xmath17 . as the effects of phase space noncommutativity are presumably small , we have compared the leading order corrections to the commutative hamiltonian with the experimental results obtained by nesvizhevsky _ _ et al.__@xcite for neutrons in the gqw formed by a horizontal mirror and the earth s gravitational field . this has allowed us to set an upper bound of about mev / c for the fundamental momentum scale introduced by noncommutativity , @xmath18 . supposing that the fundamental noncommutative length scale , @xmath19 , is smaller than the neutron size , that is , of order @xmath20 , we have found that @xmath21 . therefore , the difference between the effective planck s constant and the usual planck constant has no practical effects . on the other hand , it has been recently claimed in ref . @xcite that for a particular choice of the value of the scaling factor @xmath13 the commutation relation between coordinates and momenta is exactly defined by the usual planck constant . however , it can be shown that ncqm models with or without corrections to the value of planck s constant are , in fact , physically equivalent , differing only in the way one defines the noncommutative parameters @xcite . in what follows we shall present our analysis of the gqw in the context of the ncqm . we consider now a particle of mass m moving on the @xmath16 plane in a uniform gravitational field @xmath17 . when a horizontal mirror is placed at @xmath22 , a gqw is set up . in the direction transverse to the gravitational field , @xmath11 , the particle is free , exhibiting a continuous energy spectrum . in the direction of the gravitational field , @xmath9 , the particle exhibits a discrete energy spectrum . its wave function in the @xmath23-th quantum level is given by the airy function @xmath24 , where @xmath25 and @xmath26 @xcite , with energy eigenvalues given by : [ gqw_2 ] e_n=-(mg^2 ^ 22)^1/3_n , where @xmath27 corresponds to the @xmath23-th zero of the airy function and @xmath28 to the maximum height that is classically compatible with a particle with energy @xmath29 . the probability of finding the particle is non - vanishing for all values of @xmath30 . however , when @xmath9 exceeds the value of @xmath31 for each quantum state @xmath23 , this probability decays exponentially , but the particle has a finite probability of penetrating a classically forbidden region through quantum tunneling . these ideas have been used to study the spectrum of neutrons in the quantum well of the earth s gravitational field and a horizontal mirror @xcite . an ultra cold neutron beam was employed , with a mean velocity @xmath32 , traveling through a narrow slit formed by the mirror and a scatterer / absorber placed above it . therefore , the neutron flux through the apparatus is measured as a function of @xmath9 . for @xmath33 , neutrons in the @xmath23-th quantum state have a small probability of crossing the gravitational barrier and tunnel into the scatterer / absorber . this probability is given by @xmath34 and vanishes as the slit height increases . hence , for @xmath33 , neutrons pass through the slit with little loss . for @xmath35 , however , neutrons have a @xmath36 probability of being absorbed by the scatterer and so the slit is not transparent to neutrons . thus flux of neutrons through the slit is given by : [ gqw_4 ] f(x)=f_0_n_n ( -l_nv\ { ll e^(-43_n^3/2 ) , _ n>0 + 1,_n<0 } ) , where @xmath37 is a normalization factor , depending on the incident flux , @xmath38 is the relative population of the @xmath23-th quantum level , @xmath39 is the length of the slit and @xmath40 @xcite . from eq . ( [ gqw_4 ] ) , one can conclude that , for @xmath41 , the flux of particles in the @xmath23-th state approaches its maximum value @xmath37 , while for @xmath42 , this flux tends to vanish . therefore , the classical turning points @xmath31 separate two regions where the neutron flux exhibits distinct behaviour for each state @xmath23 . by adjusting the experimentally measured flux to the predicted flux given by eq . ( [ gqw_4 ] ) , the values of the two lowest classical turning points were obtained @xcite , and these are in good agreement with the quantum mechanical predictions , namely @xmath43 and @xmath44 . we mention that the equivalence principle in the context of the gqw has been analyzed in ref . @xcite . we consider now the discussed gqw , with hamiltonian given by : [ hamiltonian_1 ] h=p_x^22m+p_y^22m+mgx . the corresponding noncommutative hamiltonian can be straightforwardly obtained using the inverse transformations of eq . ( [ linear_1 ] ) , for @xmath15 , [ linear_inverse ] x=c(x+2p_y ) , y=c(y-2p_x ) , p_x=c(p_x-2y ) , p_y=c(p_y+2x ) , to replace the commutative variables by the noncommutative ones : [ hamiltonian_2 ] h&=&c^22m(p_x-2y)^2+c^22m(p_y+2x)^2 + + mgc(x+2p_y)= + & = & c^22mp_x^2+c^22mp_y^2+mgc2p_y+c^22m(xp_y - yp_x)+c^28m^2 ^ 2(x^2+y^2)+mgcx , where @xmath45 and @xmath46 . it should be noticed that [ aux_1 ] c^22mp_y^2+mgc2p_y=12m(cp_y+m^2g2)^2-m^3g^2 ^ 28 ^ 2 , so that the last term is an additive constant that can be subtracted from the hamiltonian . through the redefinition [ momenta ] as : [ hamiltonian_3 ] h=|p_x^22m+|p_y^22m+c2m(x|p_y - y|p_x ) + c^28m^2 ^ 2(x^2+y^2)+mgcx - mgc4 ^ 2x . notice that the last two terms correspond to the commutative gravitational potential , @xmath47 . thus the noncommutative hamiltonian is given by [ hamiltonian_4 ] h=|p_x^22m+|p_y^22m+mgx + c2m(x|p_y - y|p_x)+c^28m^2 ^ 2(x^2+y^2 ) . the similarity between the first three terms in the commutative and noncommutative hamiltonians is clear , the only difference lying in the redefined momenta @xmath48 and @xmath49 . the constant term in the definition of @xmath49 , eq . ( [ momenta ] ) , has , however , no physical meaning as it corresponds to a translation of all the eigenvalues of @xmath50 by the same amount . it does not imply any change in the commutation relations of this operator either . thus , the only physical difference between @xmath10 and @xmath49 concerns the factor @xmath51 and likewise for @xmath12 and @xmath48 , meaning that the kinetic terms in the noncommutative hamiltonian differ from the commutative ones only by a factor @xmath52 . we study now the physics of the hamiltonian eq . ( [ hamiltonian_4 ] ) . to first order in the noncommutative parameters @xmath4 and @xmath5 , it is given by : [ hamiltonian_5 ] h = p_x^22m+p_y^22m+mgx+2m(xp_y - yp_x)=h+2m(xp_y - yp_x ) . notice that as @xmath53 , to first order in the noncommutative parameters , @xmath48 and @xmath49 are equal to @xmath12 and @xmath10 , respectively . we can then conclude that at this order of approximation the noncommutative hamiltonian differs from the commutative one by a term proportional to @xmath5 . hence , the configuration space noncommutativity does not influence the gqw energy spectrum to leading order . it is expected that @xmath5 is a small correction at the quantum mechanical level , and so one can treat the new term as a perturbation to the commutative hamiltonian . the shift caused by this term on the energy levels of the system is given by the expectation value of the perturbed wave function of the system . we note that as the airy function is real , @xmath54 , and hence [ aux_3 ] p_x _ n&=&_0^+dx_n^*(-i_n ) = -i([_n^*_n]_0^+-_0^+dx_n)= + & = & i_0^+dx_n_nx= -_0^+dx_n^*(-i_n)=-p_x_n=0 , where , due do the presence of the horizontal mirror , we have used that @xmath55 and the normalization of the wave function . therefore , the term proportional to @xmath12 in eq . ( [ hamiltonian_5 ] ) does not yield any shift on the energy levels , whatever the expectation value of @xmath11 . thus , the perturbed potential due to noncommutativity is at leading order given by [ perturbative_1 ] v_1=2mxp_y . this is clearly analogous to a potential describing the effect of a magnetic field @xmath56 , where @xmath57 is the direction perpendicular to the plane , on a particle of charge @xmath58 , where @xmath59 . this is of course simply a formal analogy with no physical meaning , as particles in the gqw must be neutral , as is the case of the neutrons used in the experiment by nesvizhevsky and collaborators . the leading order energy correction to the @xmath23-th quantum state is given by the expectation value of potential eq . ( [ perturbative_1 ] ) [ perturbative_2 ] e_n^(1)=k2m_0^+dx_n^*(x)x_n(x)= k2 m , where the integral @xmath60 is defined as : [ aux_4 ] i_n__n^+dz(z)z(z ) , and @xmath61 for the experiment described in ref . the values of the normalization factor @xmath62 and of the integral @xmath60 were determined numerically for the first two energy levels : [ numerical_1 ] a_1= 588.109 , a_2= 513.489 , i_1=-0.383213 , i_2=-0.878893 . with these values , the leading order corrections to the energy levels are given by : [ energy_corrections ] e_1^(1)=2.8310 ^ 29 ( j ) , e_2^(1)=4.9410 ^ 29 ( j ) . finally , requiring these corrections to be smaller or of the order of the maximum absolute energy shifts allowed by the experiment , the following upper bounds for @xmath5 are obtained : [ eta_bounds_1 ] || & 2.3210 ^ -61 kg^2m^2s^-2 ( n=1 ) , || & 1.7610 ^ -61 kg^2m^2s^-2 ( n=2 ) . these values correspond to the following upper bounds on the fundamental momentum scale : [ eta_bounds_2 ] || & & 4.8210 ^ -310.90 ( n=1 ) , + we compute now the energy correction of second order on the noncommutative parameters . the second order perturbed potential is the following : [ perturbative_3 ] v_2=2 ^ 2p_x^22m+2 ^ 2p_y^22m+^28m^2(x^2+y^2 ) . the terms proportional to @xmath63 and @xmath64 do not affect the particle s energy spectrum in the direction of the gravitational field and , hence , do not give rise to any shift on the discrete energy levels . thus , the second order perturbed potential reduces to : [ perturbative_4 ] v_2=2 ^ 2p_x^22m+^28m^2x^2 . there are now two second order terms that can modify the energy spectrum of the particle . the first one is proportional to the kinetic energy in the direction of the gravitational field ; the second one is formally identical to an harmonic oscillator with frequency @xmath65 . the energy correction due to the first term on the @xmath23-th quantum state is given by [ perturbative_5 ] e_n^(2a)=-4m_0^+ dx _ n^*(x)^2_nx^2(x ) = -4ma_n^2(2m^2g^2)^13j_n , where the integral @xmath66 is defined as [ aux_5 ] j_n__n^+dz(z)d^2dz^2(z ) . we have computed the value of this integral for the first two quantum states , obtaining : [ numerical_2 ] j_1=-0.383213,j_2=-0.878893 . in order to set an upper bound on the value of this correction , we need not only the upper bounds obtained for @xmath5 but also an upper bound for the value of @xmath4 . clearly , the latter can not be estimated by the gravitational quantum well experiment . one can resort to the bound on the value of the coordinates commutator , obtained in a different context @xcite , @xmath67 ( which correspond to @xmath68 for @xmath69 ) or , consider a more conservative point of view and argue that the fundamental length scale introduced by noncommutativity should be at least smaller than the minimum scale compatible with the quantum mechanical approach to the gqw problem . this scale is given by the average neutron size of about @xmath20 , below which the neutron s internal structure becomes relevant . with this hypothesis , one can get an upper bound on @xmath4 of @xmath70 and , consequently , the following upper bounds on the contribution of eq . ( [ perturbative_5 ] ) to the energy correction : [ perturbative_6 ] e_1^(2a)&7.8310 ^ -55 ( j ) , e_2^(2a)&1.0410 ^ -54 ( j ) . as for the contribution of the second term : [ perturbative_7 ] e_n^(2b)&=&^28m^2_0^+dx_n^*(x)x^2_n(x)= + & = & ^28m^2 , where the integral @xmath71 is defined by : [ aux_6 ] l_n__n^+dz(z)z^2(z ) , whose values were numerically determined for the first two energy levels : [ numerical_3 ] l_1=0.537596,l_2=2.15572 . hence , [ perturbative_8 ] e_1^(2b)3.6410 ^ -38 ( j ) , e_2^(2b)&&6.3910 ^ -38 ( j ) . we can then see that the contribution of the first set of second order terms is negligible in comparison with the contribution of the second term , which is itself @xmath72 orders of magnitude smaller than the respective first order correction for @xmath73 ( @xmath74 ) . it follows that the perturbation approach is reliable using the upper bounds obtained for @xmath5 for both quantum states . clearly , if had we used the bound on @xmath4 derived in ref . @xcite , the energy corrections would have been about ten orders of magnitude smaller . therefore the nesvizhevsky _ _ experiment constrains the fundamental momentum scale to be below the mev / c scale . of course , one could expect the fundamental scale to be smaller than this . an increase in the precision of the experiment may lead to more stringent bounds on the value of @xmath18 if the results are still consistent with the theoretical predictions . one should take into account , however , that the experimental energy resolution is bounded by the uncertainty principle due to the finite lifetime of the neutron @xcite . the maximum energy resolution corresponds to a minimum energy uncertainty : [ uncertainty_2 ] e^min ~1.210 ^ -37 j 7.410 ^ -19 ev . if the theoretical predictions are confirmed to this precision by the experiment , then one should be able to place the following upper bounds on the value of @xmath5 : [ eta_bounds_3 ] lead to the following upper bounds on the value of the fundamental momentum scale : [ eta_bounds_4 ] || & & 7.2210 ^ -341.35(n=1 ) , + be obtained within the framework of the gqw and they imply for the effective planck s constant , the @xmath75 correction : [ xi_1 ] we turn now to the discussion of the conditions for the transition between the quantum and the classical descriptions in the context of the gqw . this is a central and recurrent issue in quantum mechanics . more recently , this somewhat conceptual and philosophical discussion has become a quite concrete experimental problem given the impressive new experiments of interference of macromolecules @xcite . in these experiments the conditions under which the quantum coherence of complex systems is lost have been carefully examined . it is believed that determining the drawing line between quantum and classical behaviour may bring new insights on the nature of macroscopic objects which exhibit quantum properties @xcite . in this work , we study the transition between the quantum and classical regimes in the gqw . in such a system , particles exhibit a discrete energy spectrum and present a non - vanishing probability of tunneling into classically forbidden regions . we analyze how an increase in the particles mass may destroy these quantum properties , so that the system will , at least from an experimental point of view , behave as its classical analogue . hence , we suggest a generalization of the nesvizhevsky _ _ experiment @xcite with neutrons to more massive particles , such as atoms and fullerene - type molecules . the proposed criteria is based on the assumption that the dependence of separation between quantum states is a reliable criteria for establishing the quantum to classical divide , at least within the experimental resolution . we shall consider atoms and fullerene - type molecules . the gqw is a convenient system for testing if a system exhibits a quantum or a classical behaviour , given that its energy spectrum depends on the mass of the particles involved . in what follows we shall analyze the consequences of increasing the particle s mass and consider its experimental implications . we point out that , for all particles , the energy spectrum approaches a classical continuous spectrum for high energies . this can be shown explicitly for our problem studying the asymptotic form of the zeros of the airy function @xcite . indeed , one can show that , both @xmath76 and @xmath77 tend to zero as @xmath78 . also , @xmath79 is strictly decreasing with @xmath23 , and hence the largest separation between consecutive heights @xmath31 occurs for the first two quantum states . let us now consider the effects of increasing the particle s mass . from eq . ( [ gqw_2 ] ) , one can conclude that all energy eigenvalues are proportional to @xmath80 , the same occurring for the separation between consecutive energy eigenvalues . this is somewhat unexpected , as one assumes that this separation decreases with increasing mass . however , one should note that the experimentally relevant quantities are the heights @xmath31 . one can conclude that these heights and the separation @xmath81 , are proportional to @xmath82 . hence , for more massive particles , it is more difficult to distinguish consecutive levels . if two of these can not be separated experimentally , the quantum states can not be distinguished and the spectrum appears classical . thus , as the largest separation between values of @xmath31 occurs for the two lowest quantum states , if the particles mass is large enough so that the experimental error is larger than @xmath83 , there will be no means of distinguishing two consecutive classical turning points . in this case , the flux of particles through the slit will show a classical behaviour , increasing as @xmath84 , where @xmath9 is the slit height @xcite . the conclusion is that classical or quantum behaviour depend on the experimental resolution and on the mass of the particles . this can be quantified in the following way : for a minimum uncertainty , @xmath85 , to measure the slit height , one can distinguish at least two consecutive quantum states if the particle s mass does not exceed @xcite : [ limit_1 ] m_max=(_1)^3/2 . for instance , with the error of @xmath86 for @xmath73 @xcite , one could distinguish the first two quantum states for particles with a mass @xmath87 , where @xmath88 is the mean mass of a nucleon . equivalently , in order to distinguish two quantum states of a particle with mass @xmath89 , one must require as maximum experimental error : [ limit_2 ] _ max=(^22m_n^2g)^1/3_1a^-2/310.3 a^-2/3 . moreover , the uncertainty principle places limits on the experimental resolution for particles with a finite lifetime . measuring @xmath31 , an uncertainty @xmath90 is equivalent to an uncertainty @xmath91 . therefore , in order to have sufficient spatial resolution to separate the first two quantum states of a particle with mass @xmath89 , its mean lifetime must be greater than : [ limit_3 ] _ min=(2m_ng^2)^1/3a^-1/3_16.310 ^ -4a^-1/3 . for the nesvizhevsky _ set up , the minimum lifetime is @xmath92 ms , which is 6 orders of magnitude smaller than the neutron s mean lifetime of 885.7 s @xcite . the uncertainty principle allows a precision up to @xmath93 , meaning that the experiment can be further improved . another implication of the increase on the particle s mass is the decrease in the probability of tunneling through the gravitational barrier . as already referred to , in the state @xmath23 this probability is given by @xmath94 . this rapid decrease is expected since in the classical limit particles with energy @xmath29 can not be found at a height greater than @xmath31 . naturally , the frequency @xmath95 , which can be viewed as the frequency of the collisions between the particles and the gravitational barrier @xcite , increases as @xmath80 , an effect that is not compensated by the decrease of the tunneling probability . thus , more massive particles exhibit a sharper transition between zero and maximum flux , turning the transition to the classical limit @xmath96 discontinuous . this makes it more difficult to observe distinct quantum states . till now the focus of our discussion has been on point - like particles . for neutrons , the average radius of about @xmath97 is @xmath98 smaller than the value of @xmath99 and so it can be neglected . however , as the particle s mass increases , the affect of their size must be taken into account . let us then examine the size effects on the gqw energy spectrum . before that we point out that although the gqw problem has only been solved for point - like particles , some of the consequences of the particles finite size may still be inferred to from a qualitative analysis . indeed , let us assume that the effects of gravity on all particles which make part of a massive system are much smaller than the effects of the forces which bind them . therefore , one can focus on the movement of the massive particle s center of mass ( cm ) , which behaves as a point - like particle . the most salient difference between these descriptions is that the wave function of a composed particle exhibits an additional dispersion around the position of its cm . this dispersion is quantified by the particle s mean radius , @xmath100 . therefore , in the gqw experiment , when the slit height becomes of order @xmath101 , the absorber gets sufficiently close to the wave function of a particle in the @xmath23-th state and the latter can be absorbed at @xmath102 . thus the transition between the regions of maximum and minimum flux occurs in the neighborhood of @xmath101 and not at @xmath31 , as for a point - like particle . if @xmath103 , this effect must be taken into account . another finite size consequence is that massive particles will tend to leave the lowest quantum states less occupied . the horizontal mirror implies the wave function of each of the elementary particles that constitute the composed one vanishes at the origin . this implies that the composed particle must be above the horizontal mirror . hence , the particle s cm must be at a height larger than its average radius @xmath100 . if @xmath104 , particles in the @xmath23-th level are only allowed to be in the classically forbidden region , where they have a very low probability of being found . it then follows that the great majority of particles will tend to be found in quantum states @xmath105 and higher . the more massive the particle the more likely it will lie at higher quantum states . this solves an apparent paradox of our previous discussion , namely that the growth in the particle mass implies an increase in the separation between its energy levels . however , as its size also increases , the particle is more likely be found in the higher quantum levels , where @xmath106 . one must also bear in mind that , as the whole particle must lay above the horizontal mirror , there is a minimum value of the slit height , corresponding to the average diameter of the particle . for @xmath107 of order @xmath101 , one is no longer able to observe the transition between zero and maximum flux . this occurs when @xmath108 , so that one can not measure the @xmath23-th quantum state as the particle can not be found at this level . hence , one is unable to test experimentally whether particles of radius @xmath108 are not really in the @xmath23-th quantum state . we consider now the properties of the particles that may be used to test the quantum to classical transition in the gqw . clearly , these particles must possess the following features : ( i ) they must be electrically neutral so that neither electromagnetic effects overlap the gravitational ones nor that the decoherence of the particle beam is induced . a high level of symmetry in the spatial distribution of electrons prevents polarization effects . having vanishing total spin avoids the coupling to external magnetic fields ; ( ii ) they must have long lifetimes , so to satisfy eq . ( [ limit_3 ] ) . thus , radioactive particles are not suitable ; ( iii ) the horizontal velocity of the beam must be small so to maximize the time particles remain as gqw states . given these requirements , atoms are , after neutrons , the natural choice in the mass hierarchy . from conditions ( i ) and ( ii ) , they can not be in ionized states and must be stable isotopes with valence electrons in @xmath109-type orbitals . considering that the main contribution to an atom s mass is due its nucleons , @xmath89 , thus from eqs . ( [ limit_2 ] ) and ( [ limit_3 ] ) one computes @xmath110 and @xmath111 . the former has been plotted in figure 1 for @xmath112 ( lanthanides and actinides are excluded ) . from these results one concludes that the maximum allowed error lies in the range @xmath113 . the minimum lifetime can be shown to lie in the range @xmath114 ms . the atomic radius can be estimated using the average value of the radial coordinate for a hydrogen type atom @xcite , substituting the atomic number , @xmath115 , by an effective one , @xmath116 , which accounts for shielding effects of inner electrons according to the slater rules @xcite : [ r_atoms ] r = a_02z_eff[3n^2-l(l+1 ) ] , where @xmath117 m is the bohr radius and @xmath118 denote the atom s valence orbital quantum numbers . in figure 2 the values of the ratio @xmath119 for atoms with @xmath112 are shown , and one sees that they lie in the interval @xmath120 . for atoms and fullerene molecules.,title="fig : " ] [ fig : fraccao ] the next scale in the mass hierarchy are molecules . there is a broad variety of molecules , but few satisfy our criteria . among these , fullerenes or _ buckyballs _ , large groups of @xmath121 , stand out as suitable candidates . these molecules are highly symmetric ( @xmath122 has spherical symmetry ) and are globally neutral , although with a slight polarization @xcite . they are considerably larger than atoms and the higher number of correlated particles enhances the probability of decoherence of the beam through interactions with the external environment . furthermore , they have a large number of internal degrees of freedom , rotational and vibrational , and can radiate , yielding in interactions with the external environment . despite these properties , fullerenes are more appropriate than most massive molecules for the gqw study . for pure @xmath121 fullerenes , @xmath123 , where @xmath124 is the number of carbon atoms . the values of @xmath110 and @xmath111 for fullerenes up to 3840 carbon atoms ( after the numerical simulations of ref . @xcite ) were computed using eqs . ( [ limit_2 ] ) and ( [ limit_3 ] ) . the values of @xmath110 are exhibited in figure 1 . one obtains that in order to distinguish the first two gqw states of these molecules the maximum error must lie in the interval @xmath125 , corresponding to a minimum lifetime of 0.02 to 0.10 ms . supposing a fullerene to be modeled by a sphere of radius @xmath100 , than the area of the sphere must be proportional to the number of carbon atoms @xcite , @xmath126 , where the constant @xmath127 is determined using values of ref . the ratio @xmath119 for fullerenes is shown in figure 2 and is in the range @xmath128 . therefore , one can see that the finite size effects can not be neglected for the largest fullerenes . one can estimate the value of @xmath124 for which @xmath100 becomes of the order of @xmath99 , yielding that molecules with more than about @xmath129 carbon atoms will have a quite small probability of being found in the lowest quantum state of the gqw . this means that , the considered fullerenes ( @xmath130 ) , can be found at the first quantum level . in this contribution we have studied the two - dimensional gqw . on a first instance we have considered its noncommutative version in phase space and used the latest results from the experiment by nesvizhevsky _ _ to constrain the fundamental momentum scale introduced by noncommutativity to be smaller than @xmath131 . further improvements in the experimental precision could allow for achieving the minimum upper bounds of about @xmath132 . we conclude that to leading order , noncommutativity in configuration space does not affect the energy spectrum of the system . supposing that the latter introduces a fundamental length scale smaller than the neutron s size , we find that the model implies in a modification of the planck constant which is experimentally consistent by many orders of magnitude . furthermore , we have considered the consequences of the increase in the particles mass and size on the energy spectrum of the usual gqw . we find that it leads to a decrease in the separation of consecutive classical turning points . this implies that the more massive the particles , the greater the precision required to distinguish the lowest two quantum states . the precision already achieved allows studying particles up to @xmath133 . for heavier atoms , it is required to increase the precision of position measurements at least by a factor of 10 . for fullerenes up to @xmath122 , this increase in precision may be sufficient , but for larger molecules such as @xmath134 an improvement by at least a factor of 1000 is required of course , performing this kind of experiment with sizable particles implies in considerable experimental challenges , which involve strong isolation from external agents such as electromagnetic fields , precautions to avoid collisions so not to decohere the particle s beam and ultra cold beams of particles to maximize the captured time in the gqw . nevertheless , despite these difficulties , this kind of experiment might be of relevance for testing the limits of applicability of the quantum mechanics . in the proposed set up , the transition to a classical regime is made independently of the phenomenon of decoherence , depending only on the mass of the particles in the gqw and on the experimental resolution . observing quantum states of massive particles in a gqw may turn out to be a relevant complement to quantum interference experiments with complex molecules . 0.1 cm * acknowledgments * it is a pleasure the thank our colleagues cristiane arago , paolo castorina and dario zapall for the discussions and for the collaboration which gave rise to part of the work reported here .

we discuss the implications of a model of noncommutative quantum mechanics where noncommutativity is extended to the phase space . we analyze how this model affects the problem of the two - dimensional gravitational quantum well and use the latest experimental results for the energy states of neutrons in the earth s gravitational field to establish an upper bound on the fundamental momentum scale introduced by noncommutativity . we show that the configuration space noncommutativity has , in leading order , no effect on the problem and that in the context of the model , a correction to the presently accepted value of planck s constant to @xmath0 part in @xmath1 arises . we also study the transition between quantum and classical behaviour of particles in a gravitational quantum well and analyze how an increase in the particles mass turns the energy spectrum into a continuous one . we consider these effects and argue that they could be tested by through experiments with atoms and fullerene - type molecules . ps . # 1#2#1 # 1 # 1 # 1| # 1|#1 # 1#2|#2 # 1 # 1#2__#1| # 1#2|#1__#2 # 1#2#3#4__#1

quant-ph0012011

the space - time geometry that is commonly used today arose from classical physics . an interesting question is what geometry is appropriate for quantum physics . it was suggested that the universal symmetry group elements which act on all hilbert spaces may be appropriate for constructing a physical geometry for quantum theory @xcite . i also proposed the systematic study of all the fundamental interactions _ operationally _ from their effects on quantum interference @xcite . the purpose of this paper is to attempt to bring together these two approaches . the modular variables introduced by aharonov , pendleton and petersen @xcite will play a useful role in this . in section 2 , i shall review noether s theorem and its converse in a generalized form in which the conserved quantities are elements of a group and not the generators of this group as usually stated . this will suggest a quantum geometry by relations defined by the universal group elements , which constitute the symmetry group of physics , that act on all hilbert spaces , as discussed in section 3 . the classical limit of this geometry will be obtained in section 4 as the usual space - time geometry from the quantum state metric in hilbert spaces and the universality of the action of the translational group in every hilbert space . in section 5 , the non locality of fundamental interactions in quantum physics implied by this approach , as shown physically by the aharonov - bohm effect @xcite and its generalizations @xcite , will be studied . the study of the gravitational aharonov - bohm effect around a cosmic string in particular suggests that the use of universal group elements as quantum distances may be appropriate . the usual statement of noether s theorem is that for every continuous symmetry of the equations of motion ( determined by the lagrangian or hamiltonian ) there exists a conserved quantity . although this is easy to prove , the meaning of this theorem is more readily evident in the hamiltonian than in the lagrangian formulation . a symmetry of the equations of motion or time evolution is a transformation @xmath0 such that in any experiment if @xmath0 is applied to the initial state of the physical objects ( fields , particles , etc . ) participating in the experiment then the final state of the transformed experiment must be the same as @xmath0 applied to the final state of the original experiment . for example , spatial translational symmetry implies that if the apparatus is translated to a new spatial location then the same experiment should give the same result . suppose @xmath1 is the time - evolution operator , and @xmath2 , @xmath3 are the initial and final states , i.e. @xmath4 . then the above definition of @xmath0 being a symmetry of the time evolution is @xmath5 for every initial state @xmath2 . this is equivalent to the commutator @xmath6=0 . \label{symmetry}\ ] ] but ( [ symmetry ] ) states also that @xmath0 is conserved during the time - evolution . therefore , the statements that @xmath0 is a symmetry and that @xmath0 is conserved are the _ same _ statement ( [ symmetry ] ) , and there is nothing to prove ! now suppose that there is a continuous symmetry generated by @xmath7 . then ( [ symmetry ] ) is satisfied with @xmath8 for all @xmath9 , and therefore @xmath10=0 . \label{commutator}\ ] ] hence , @xmath7 is conserved , which is noether s theorem . furthermore , if the hamiltonian @xmath11 is independent of time @xmath12 , as it is for an isolated system , then @xmath13 . if ( [ commutator ] ) is valid for all @xmath12 , then @xmath14=0 . \label{hcommutator}\ ] ] the above results may be extended to classical physics by turning the above commutators into poisson brackets in classical phase space . these classical results may be regarded as the classical limit of the quantum results by recognizing that the symplectic structure that gives the poisson brackets are the classical limit @xcite of a symplectic structure in quantum theory @xcite that gives the commutators . but the conservation of @xmath0 that follows from ( [ symmetry ] ) is more general than the usual form of noether s theorem . there are at least two situations in which ( [ symmetry ] ) is valid but there are no corresponding ( [ commutator ] ) or ( [ hcommutator ] ) . first , as is well known , in both classical and quantum physics , @xmath0 may be a discrete symmetry instead of a continuous symmetry . for example , @xmath0 may be parity , which is a symmetry and therefore conserved for all interactions except the weak interaction , as far as we know . another example is that ( [ symmetry ] ) is satisfied for @xmath15 for a discrete set of values @xmath16 only . second , in quantum physics the mean value of @xmath8 has more information than the mean value of all the moments of @xmath7 , namely @xmath17 where @xmath18 is any positive integer @xcite . this is unlike in classical physics where the mean value of a transformation generated by @xmath7 may be obtained using the mean values of all the @xmath17 . both these situations will be considered in section 5 . since in ( [ symmetry ] ) @xmath1 and @xmath0 occur symmetrically , it follows that the converse of the generalized noether s theorem is also true : _ a transformation @xmath0 that is conserved must be a symmetry of the equations of motion . _ the usual view is that @xmath1 is more fundamental than @xmath0 because @xmath1 is determined by the dynamical laws which are regarded as primary , whereas the symmetries such as @xmath0 are obtained secondarily as the symmetries of these laws . but the concise form ( [ symmetry ] ) of the connection between the dynamical laws and symmetries , in which @xmath1 and @xmath0 are on an equivalent footing , suggest that we may equally turn the usual view around and regard the transformations @xmath19 as primary and @xmath1 as derived from them to satisfy ( [ symmetry ] ) so that @xmath19 are the symmetries @xcite . the possibility of regarding symmetries as fundamental relations between quantum states by associating them with a quantum geometry will be explored in the next section . the concept of space originates from our common experience of translating objects and from the possible states they can occupy . if we translate a cup , for example , in various possible ways , classically we may say that the different configurations or states of the cup are `` immersed '' in `` space '' . this space is _ universal _ in the sense that it is regarded as independent of the objects which are `` contained '' in it . but quantum mechanically it is not clear what is meant by the cup being `` immersed '' in space . the cup consists of electrons , protons and neutrons ( or the quarks and gluons which make up the protons and neutrons ) , and the states of these particles belong to the corresponding hilbert spaces which are different from the physical space or the phase space of classical physics . the translation of a cup therefore needs to be represented by the corresponding translation operators that act on these hilbert spaces . the fact that all the particles constituting the cup move together in some approximate sense suggests the introduction of universal translation group elements that are represented by operators that act on each hilbert space . it is this _ universality _ of the translation group that gives us the concept of `` space '' that is independent of the particular system that partakes in it . also , it is well known that we can not operationally determine the metric in space- time , or even the points of space - time , using quantum probes @xcite because of the uncertainty principle . if one tries to obtain the space - time geometry using a clock and radar light signals , which is possible in classical physics @xcite , the uncertainty in the measurement of time in quantum physics is @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the uncertainty in the energy of the clock . if we try to decrease this uncertainty by increasing @xmath22 , then @xmath22 causes a corresponding uncertainty in the geometry of space- time . the total uncertainty in the measurement of space - time distances is then @xmath23 . the minimum value of this uncertainty as @xmath21 is varied is @xmath24 planck - length @xmath25 . hence , space- time geometry is only approximately valid in quantum theory , with an uncertainty of the order of planck length . however , a geometry for quantum theory may be defined by relations determined by a universal group @xmath26 , which generalizes the above translation group . this is universal in the sense that the same @xmath26 has a representation in each hilbert space . but @xmath26 may have subgroups which may have trivial representations in some hilbert spaces and not in others . an object may be displaced by any @xmath27 , which means that @xmath0 acts on each of the hilbert spaces of the particles or fields constituting that object through the corresponding representation of @xmath26 . each @xmath28 in each of these hilbert spaces is mapped to a corresponding @xmath29 by this action of @xmath0 , and the group element @xmath0 that determines the _ relation _ between @xmath28 and @xmath29 is independent of the hilbert space and is therefore universal . in the example of a cup considered above , @xmath0 is an element of the translation group , @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the states of each particle constituting the cup before and after the translation , and the relation between each such pair is universal in the sense that the entire cup has undergone this translation , or any other object that could take the place of the cup . this quantum geometry can not be subject to the above criticisms of the space - time geometry because the action of @xmath26 on each hilbert space is not subject to any uncertainty . it is reasonable to require that this geometry is preserved in time in the absence of interactions . then each @xmath27 is conserved and the converse of noether s theorem stated in the last paragraph of the previous section implies that @xmath0 is also a symmetry of the time evolution . since the evolution equations are now determined by the standard model , @xmath26 may be the symmetry group of the present day standard model , namely @xmath30 , where @xmath31 is the poincare group . but if the standard model is superseded by new physics that has a different symmetry group then @xmath26 should be this new group and the above statements would all be unaffected . as an illustration of the geometrical relations proposed here , consider the experimentally known quantization of electric charge : all known charges are integral multiple of the fundamental charge @xmath32 . an aspect of this is that the magnitudes of the charges of the electron and the proton are experimentally known to be equal to an amazing precision . to obtain charge quantization , take @xmath0 above to be an arbitrary element of the electromagnetic @xmath33 group , which is a subgroup of @xmath26 . this universal @xmath33 group is a circle parametrized by @xmath34 , say , that varies from @xmath35 to @xmath36 so that @xmath35 and @xmath36 represent the same point on this group , chosen to be the identity . since @xmath33 is abelian , it has only one - dimensional representations . hence the action of @xmath37 on an arbitrary state gives @xmath38 where @xmath7 corresponds to the particular representation of @xmath33 in the hilbert space in which @xmath28 belongs to . but since @xmath39 , which is due to the compactness of the @xmath33 group , @xmath40 for all representations @xcite . hence , @xmath41 or @xmath42 where @xmath18 is an integer . to interpret @xmath7 , consider the physical implementation of the transformation @xmath0 . this may be done by sending each of the particles through the same electromagnetic field with 4-vector potential @xmath43 in a particular gauge so that the effect of the electromagnetic field alone on the particle is given by @xmath44 which is a @xmath33 transformation . indeed , the statement that the electromagnetic field is a @xmath33 gauge field may be taken to mean that it is physically possible to implement a @xmath33 gauge transformation using the electromagnetic field in this way . then @xmath9 has the interpretation of the electric charge . comparing ( [ em ] ) with ( [ u1 ] ) , we may take @xmath34 to be @xmath45 in which case @xmath46 . hence , from ( [ quantization ] ) , @xmath47 where @xmath48 is a universal constant that is determined experimentally to be @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is the charge of the electron . the exact equality of the magnitudes of the charges of the electron and the proton may now be understood as due to them belonging to representations corresponding to @xmath51 and @xmath52 , respectively . the above argument also provides a reason for the introduction of planck s constant which is purely geometrical . the exponent in ( [ em ] ) must be dimensionless because the expansion of the exponential has all powers of the exponent . now , @xmath53 is meaningful in classical physics . but to turn it into a dimensionless quantity , it is necessary to introduce a new scale , which is provided by @xmath54 . from the present point of view , this is needed in order to physically implement the @xmath33 group elements that define relations between states which are part of the quantum geometry . also , from ( [ quant ] ) , @xmath9 is proportional to @xmath50 , and @xmath43 is also proportional to @xmath50 because the charges that generate @xmath43 via maxwell s equations are proportional to @xmath50 . hence , the exponent in ( [ em ] ) is proportional to the fine - structure constant @xmath55 . this argument may be extended to gauge fields in general , and dimensionless coupling constants are obtained for all of them . from now onwards , units in which @xmath56 will be used , and the metric convention is @xmath57 . the relation defined by ( [ em ] ) is not gauge invariant . hence , it can not be used to define an invariant geometrical ` distance ' . consider again the translation of a cup which may be performed by acting on all the quantum states of the particles constituting the cup by a universal group element @xmath58 , where @xmath59 is a generator of translation . the action of this group element on a wave function is also not gauge invariant . but we may combine the two transformations to define the gauge - covariant transformation @xmath60 , where @xmath61 stands for @xmath62 or equivalently @xmath63 , and @xcite @xmath64 where at present the integral is taken along the straight line joining @xmath65 and @xmath66 for simplicity . then , clearly , @xmath67 it is easy to show , using ( [ p ] ) and ( [ reversed ] ) , that the set of operators @xmath68 is a group under multiplication . from ( [ p ] ) , under a gauge transformation , @xmath69 , where @xmath70 , and @xmath71 , @xmath72 transforms to @xmath73 on using @xmath74 it follows that @xmath75 hence , @xmath76 acts gauge covariantly on the hilbert space . @xmath76 may also shown to be gauge covariant from the fact that @xmath77 is gauge invariant because the integrand is gauge invariant @xcite . it also follows from ( [ < f > ] ) that the operator ( [ p ] ) is observable . for example , in the josephson effect , where the current depends on the gauge invariant phase difference across the junction , if @xmath78 is chosen to be the vector across the junction then @xmath72 is observable from the current @xcite . a gauge may be chosen , even if the field strength is non vanishing , so that the component of @xmath79 in the direction of @xmath78 is zero . then in this gauge @xmath80 , which is conserved for an isolated system . since @xmath72 is gauge covariant , it follows that ( [ p ] ) is conserved for an isolated system in every gauge . @xmath72 is a gauge covariant generalization of the modular momentum @xcite , and may be called the modular kinetic momentum . when two systems interact , there would be an exchange of modular kinetic momentum . indeed , this may be regarded as the definition of two systems interacting @xcite . as will be seen in section [ interactions ] , this exchange may happen even when there are no forces between the two systems , which makes the latter interaction more general than the usual interaction via forces . if @xmath81 is the momentum space wave function of @xmath28 , then clearly @xmath82 hence , the change in @xmath83 results in a change in the distribution of the probability density @xmath84 of momentum @xmath85 @xcite . since in the above gauge the gauge invariant @xmath86 is the same as ( [ ft ] ) , it follows that , in an arbitrary gauge , an interaction results in a change in the distribution of the gauge invariant kinetic momentum @xmath87 . similarly , the modular energy @xcite may be generalized gauge - covariantly as follows . define the transformation on the hilbert space @xmath88 by @xmath89 , where @xmath90 and @xmath91 denotes time - ordering . to prove that @xmath88 is gauge - covariant under the above gauge transformation , note first that for a solution @xmath92 of schrdinger s equation , @xmath93 therefore , under the gauge transformation @xmath94 @xmath95 using ( [ se ] ) . hence , @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the gauge transformed hamiltonian . the last equation is equivalent to @xmath98 under this gauge transformation , @xmath99 transforms to @xmath100 on using ( [ h ] ) . hence , @xmath88 acts gauge - covariantly on the hilbert space . more generally , for an arbitrary gauge field the above arguments hold with @xmath101 replaced by @xmath102 where @xmath103 generate the gauge group , and @xmath104 is the corresponding local gauge transformation . the gauge field exponential ( parallel transport ) operator will be generalized to be along an arbitrary piece - wise differentiable curve @xmath105 in @xmath106 . path ordering is necessary because @xmath107 do not commute in general . the energy - momentum operator @xmath108 is defined by @xmath109 . now define the transformation @xmath110 on the hilbert space by @xmath111 , where @xmath112 with p denoting path ordering , and @xmath113 is a curve in space - time that is congruent to @xmath105 while @xmath114 is the curve @xmath113 traversed in the reverse order . in ( [ g ] ) , @xmath113 begins at @xmath61 and ends at @xmath115 , where @xmath116 is a fixed vector ( independent of @xmath62 ) , and @xmath114 therefore begins at @xmath115 and ends in @xmath61 . then @xmath117 under a local gauge transformation , ( [ g ] ) transforms to @xmath118 where @xmath119 . now write @xmath120 as a product of infinitesimal exponentials of the form @xmath121 , and use ( [ p ] ) and ( [ h ] ) in their infinitesimal forms . then ( [ g ] ) implies @xmath122 hence , the operator @xmath110 acts gauge covariantly on the hilbert space . it follows from this proof that @xmath110 would be gauge - covariant also when @xmath114 in ( [ g ] ) is replaced by any piece - wise differentiable curve that would connect @xmath115 to @xmath61 . also , on using ( [ conjugate ] ) , @xmath123 where @xmath124 . the expectation value ( [ expectation ] ) is gauge invariant because the integrand is gauge invariant . it may be observable , in principle , by the josephson effect for a non abelian gauge theory proposed in @xcite . more experimental consequences of @xmath110 will be discussed in section v. the energy - momentum operator @xmath108 may be generalized to relativistic quantum field theory by defining its components as the conserved quantities obtained via noether s theorem from the invariance of the lagrangian under space - time translations : @xmath125 where @xmath126 is the conserved , normal - ordered energy - momentum tensor . then the canonical commutation relations imply that @xmath108 generates space - time translations . it therefore follows from arguments analogous to the above that @xmath110 , given by ( [ g ] ) with the quantum field theoretic @xmath108 , is gauge covariant . since @xmath108 transforms as a covariant vector under lorentz transformations , it also follows that @xmath110 is lorentz invariant . moreover , @xmath110 may be generalized to curves @xmath113 in @xmath127 ( @xmath18 is any positive integer ) , which would correspond to an @xmath128dimensional space - time . it may be reasonable to take @xmath110 as a quantum distance that replaces the classical space - time distance along the curve @xmath113 . but to do so it would be necessary to obtain the classical distance in an appropriate limit from @xmath110 , which will be studied in the next section . to take the classical limit of this geometry , note that classical space - time is constructed with measuring instruments consisting of particles that have approximate position and momentum . it is therefore reasonable to represent them by gaussian wave packets which have minimum uncertainty . for a particle with mean position at the origin and mean momentum zero , the normalized wave function of such a state up to an arbitrary phase factor is @xmath129 where @xmath130 is the uncertainty in position . this may be a state of a molecule in the cup , mentioned in section 3 , in a harmonic oscillator potential in which case it would not spread . as the cup is displaced , the above wave function becomes @xmath131 up to a phase factor . in ( [ p ] ) the second factor may be made the identity by choosing a gauge in which @xmath132 . therefore , @xmath133 may be regarded as a special case of ( [ p ] ) or ( [ g ] ) , and hence as defining a quantum distance between the states @xmath134 and @xmath135 . we may therefore expect a metric to be defined on the translation group to which this operator belongs to and use that to define a metric in space . but this group , being abelian , has no natural metric on it . there are two ways , however , that a metric may be defined on it . one is to use the casimir operator of the poincare group , @xmath136 , to define a metric on it , which locally may be associated with the space - time metric @xcite . the other method , which will be used here , is to utilize the overlap of the two wave functions to obtain a measure of the displacement between them , which would then give an equivalent metric in the translation group . this is possible if the space of wavefunctions on which this group acts has an inner product , which would give a measure of the overlap and therefore how far a state has been translated . such a measure is given by the fubini - study metric in the quantum state space , or the set of rays , of every hilbert space . this is the unique metric , up to multiplication by an overall constant , that is invariant under unitary ( and anti - unitary ) transformations . this may therefore be written in the form @xcite @xmath137 where @xmath138 is the infinitesimal distance between two neighboring states ( rays ) represented by normalized state vectors @xmath28 and @xmath139 . clearly , @xmath138 is zero when the states are the same , and it increases when the overlap between the states decreases . it is also invariant under unitary transformations , and must therefore be the fubini- study metric . the factor @xmath140 in ( [ fs ] ) is just a convention which ensures that this metric in the state space of the hilbert space spanned by @xmath28 and @xmath139 is the metric on a sphere of unit radius . now substitute @xmath141 and @xmath142 as @xmath28 and @xmath139 in ( [ fs ] ) . then , @xmath143 neglecting higher order terms in @xmath144 because it is infinitesimal . hence @xmath145 , which is the same for all hilbert spaces , may be used as a metric on the @xmath146 dimensional translational group that is parametrized by the components of the vector @xmath147 . locally , this metric may be regarded as a metric in the physical space of classical physics . this result may be generalized to an arbitrary state @xmath28 as follows . require that @xmath148 to be close to the identity , where @xmath149 therefore expand @xmath150 where @xmath151 is the momentum component in the direction of @xmath152 . substituting this in ( [ fs ] ) , @xmath153 where @xmath154 is the uncertainty in @xmath155 : @xmath156 . for the gaussian wave packet , @xmath157 and therefore ( [ metric2 ] ) gives ( [ metric ] ) in this case . time is measured by a clock . since the clock must have moving parts , the uncertainty @xmath21 of its hamiltonian @xmath158 must be non zero . neglecting any external interaction of the clock , @xmath158 is a constant . the infinitesimal time evolution of the the clock is given by @xmath159 the fubini - study distance @xmath138 along the evolution curve in the quantum state space corresponding to @xmath160 is obtained analogous to the derivation of ( [ metric2 ] ) to be @xcite @xmath161 a quantum clock directly measures the fubini - study distance @xmath26 and the time @xmath12 is then inferred from @xmath26 using ( [ clock ] ) . the appearance of the same @xmath12 in ( [ clock ] ) in all hilbert spaces is due to the universality of the action of the time translation @xmath162 in every hilbert space . this is analogous to the universality of the spatial displacements which was used earlier to obtain the spatial metric . the spatial translation ( [ spatial ] ) and the active time translation corresponding to ( [ evolution ] ) may be written covariantly as @xmath163 where @xmath164 . this transformation is the infinitesimal version of ( [ g ] ) in a special gauge that makes the second factor in ( [ g ] ) the identity @xcite . in an arbitrary gauge , the same space and time metrics are obtained by replacing the operator in ( [ covariant ] ) with the infinitesimal version of ( [ g ] ) in the above treatment . in relativistic quantum theory , owing to the transformation property of @xmath165 mentioned at the end of section iii , these metrics give a space - time metric that is invariant under lorentz transformations . in the presence of gravity , this lorentzian metric may be obtained locally by doing the above space- time translations in a freely falling einstein elevator , which then globally gives a curved pseudo - riemannian metric . if the quantum geometry is determined by relations between states that are group elements , and if these group elements , which are our observables , are made dynamical the way einstein made space - time distances dynamical in order to obtain gravity , then this would give both gravity and gauge fields @xcite . also , quantum mechanics has an inherent non locality , which may also be understood as due to these group elements being the basic observables . the combination of these two statements imply that gauge fields and gravity should affect quantum states in a non local manner as in the aharonov - bohm effect @xcite , as will be discussed later . first consider the non locality of quantum theory , which may be illustrated by the following example : electrons with initial momentum in the @xmath166 direction go through an infinite diffraction grating in the @xmath167plane of a cartesian coordinate system , with the length of the slits along the @xmath168-direction . then the grating destroys continuous translational symmetry for the electrons in the @xmath169 direction . however , if the distance between successive slits in the @xmath170 direction is @xmath171 then @xmath172 satisfies ( [ symmetry ] ) , where @xmath155 is the momentum operator for electrons in the @xmath169direction which generates translations in the @xmath169direction . ( for simplicity , here and henceforth , the @xmath173 over operators is omitted . ) hence , it follows from the generalized noether s theorem in section 2 that @xmath174 is conserved although @xmath155 is _ not _ conserved . indeed , it is well known that the interference fringes on a screen that is parallel to and far away from the @xmath175- plane is given by @xmath176 , where @xmath177 is the wave length and @xmath18 is an integer . therefore , the possible values of the momentum for an electron in the @xmath169 direction after the interaction are @xmath178 , i.e. @xmath179 . hence , @xmath180 is conserved during the passage of electrons through the grating . the above operator @xmath0 is equivalent to the modular momentum @xmath181 introduced by aharonov et al on the basis of the above example @xcite . but here i shall treat @xmath0 as an element of a universal group that is used to define a quantum geometry as in section 3 . @xmath0 may be obtained from experiments by measuring the hermitian observables @xmath182 , s_i \equiv { 1\over 2i}[\exp(-i { p \ell\over \hbar})- \exp(i { p \ell\over \hbar})].\ ] ] therefore , the unitary operator @xmath0 may also be regarded as an observable . it is important to note that this is a _ non - local _ observable , unlike @xmath155 . this non locality in quantum mechanics may be illustrated also in the simple interference experiment of two coherent wave packets . suppose that the two wave packets are moving in the @xmath166direction and have no overlap at time @xmath12 . for simplicity , assume that they are the same except that their centers are separated by a displacement @xmath171 in the @xmath169direction . let @xmath183 be the phase difference between the wave packets . the wave is then a superposition of these two wave packets : @xmath184 now no local experiments performed on the two wave packets at the two slits could determine the phase factor @xmath185 . for example , the expectation values of the local variables @xmath186 , where @xmath18 is any positive integer , give no information about @xmath187 @xcite . this is easily verified by writing @xmath188 in the coordinate representation . but @xmath189 this means that the momentum distribution at time @xmath12 does depend on the phase factor @xmath190 , i.e. if @xmath155 is measured then the probability distribution for obtaining the individual eigenvalues of @xmath155 is changed by this phase factor ( but the average @xmath191 is unchanged ) . and this may be experimentally verified by letting the wave packets interfere and observing the shift in interference fringes . hence , @xmath192 contains more information than the expectation values @xmath193 of any of the moments of momentum @xmath186 . this is basically due to the linear structure of the hilbert space , which physically corresponds to the principle of superposition , and the fact that @xmath28 is not an analytic function . this fundamental non locality of quantum mechanics translates into a non locality of the effect of all the fundamental interactions on the wave function . this has been shown for the aharonov - bohm effect due to a magnetic field by aharonov et al @xcite . it may be illustrated in the above described interference of two wave packets as follows . suppose the above two wave packets @xmath194 and @xmath195 are those of an electron and they pass on the two sides of a solenoid containing a magnetic flux @xmath196 . the gauge may be chosen so that the vector potential is non zero only along a thin strip bounded by two planes indicated by the dotted lines in figure 1 . then when the line @xmath197 passes the solenoid , the wave packet @xmath194 acquires a phase difference @xmath198 with respect to the wave packet @xmath195 . therefore , the expectation value of the modular momentum @xmath0 , given by ( [ alpha ] ) , which was @xmath199 before the line @xmath197 passed the solenoid is now @xmath200 . it was pointed out by aharonov @xcite that in the last statement @xmath0 may be replaced by the gauge invariant modular kinetic momentum @xmath72 given by ( [ p ] ) . this is because before and after the wave packets pass the solenoid the vector potential @xmath79 is zero along the line @xmath197 and therefore @xmath72 is the same as @xmath0 . since @xmath201 is gauge covariant , @xmath202 is gauge invariant . hence , the above mentioned change in @xmath202 by the factor @xmath203 , as the line @xmath197 crosses the solenoid , is the same in every gauge . vector aharonov - bohm effect in which a wave packet of an electron is split coherently into two wave packets at the beam splitter @xmath204 which are then made to interfere at @xmath205 . when the imaginary line joining the centers of the wave packets @xmath194 and @xmath195 sweeps across the magnetic flux in the solenoid ( shaded region ) the modular momentum or the modular kinetic momentum associated with this line changes , as pointed out by aharonov @xcite . however , we may replace @xmath76 in the above arguments by the more general gauge covariant operator @xmath110 given by ( [ g ] ) with @xmath113 here being an arbitrary ( piece - wise differentiable ) space - like curve that joins @xmath194 and @xmath195 . then @xmath206 where the integral is from @xmath207 to @xmath208 along @xmath113 . hence , @xmath209 which is gauge invariant . then @xmath210 changes by the factor @xmath211 as a portion of @xmath113 crosses the solenoid . it follows that there is nothing special about the straight line @xmath197 crossing the solenoid in the experiment described in figure 1 . the arbitrariness of the choice of @xmath113 joining @xmath194 and @xmath195 in the above argument reflects the topological nature of the aharonov - bohm effect . what is ultimately observed in this effect is the phase factor @xmath212 where the integral is around the solenoid or more generally around the region in which the field strength is non vanishing . since this is an integral of the @xmath213form @xmath43 along a curve , it contains no information about the metric of space - time@xcite . to determine the straight line , or a geodesic in general , the metric is needed , and the above phase factor therefore can not show any preference to a geodesic such as the line @xmath197 . the integrand of ( [ gamma ] ) ( with @xmath50 replaced by 2@xmath50 ) was previously used in ref . @xcite to study the josephson effect due to the enclosed magnetic flux in a superconducting ring that has a josephson junction , which is also an aharonov - bohm effect . consider now the scalar aharonov - bohm effect . a wave packet traveling in the @xmath166 direction is partially transmitted and reflected by a beam splitter @xmath204 ( figure 2a ) . the resulting two wave packets which travel in opposite directions are reflected by two mirrors @xmath214 and @xmath215 situated along the @xmath166axis and they interfere subsequently . meanwhile a pair of oppositely charged capacitor plates @xmath216 is separated and closed so that there is a non zero electric field in the region enclosed by the world- lines of the centers of the wave packets in the @xmath217plane . the same experiment is viewed in the rest frame of the reflected wave packet in figure 2b . figure 2 . a scalar aharonov - bohm effect shown schematically in the @xmath218plane . ( a ) the modular energy and modular kinetic energy associated with the imaginary lines @xmath219 and @xmath220 are different , partly because of the scalar @xmath197 phase shift due to the region of non zero electric field in the capacitor that is open and shut ( shaded region ) . ( b ) the same experiment viewed in the rest frame of the wave packet that is reflected at the beam splitter @xmath204 . when the imaginary line @xmath197 joining the wave packets sweeps across the region of non zero electric field in the capacitor the modular energy and modular kinetic energy associated with this line changes due to the ab phase shift . we may choose a gauge in which the vector potential is non zero only along a strip between the dotted lines parallel to the time - axis in figure 2a or 2b . then the wave packet @xmath194 at time @xmath221 develops a phase shift @xmath222 with respect to @xmath195 at time @xmath12 as the imaginary line @xmath197 crosses the space - time region containing the electric field , where @xmath223 and @xmath216 is the region in which the electric field @xmath224 is non zero . this is a non local effect which may be understood using @xmath225 , where @xmath91 denotes time ordering and @xmath226 is the time interval between the events @xmath227 and@xmath228 . we shall assume that the time dependence of @xmath11 comes only from the vector potential contained in @xmath11 . suppose the wave function of the electron is @xmath229 where @xmath230 and @xmath231 are the wave functions of the above two localized wave packets . then @xmath232 changes by the factor @xmath233 due to the electric field @xmath234 in the region @xmath216 as the imaginary line @xmath197 sweeps across the small region @xmath216 where @xmath234 is non zero ( fig . 2b ) . in the last statement and in ( [ scab ] ) we may replace @xmath1 by the gauge covariant modular kinetic energy operator @xmath88 given by ( [ h ] ) , with @xmath50 replacing @xmath9 . this is because @xmath235 is zero along @xmath236 and @xmath237 , which are outside the strip that contains the non zero @xmath43 . however , is gauge invariant and therefore its change mentioned above may be obtained in any gauge . but since there are no forces acting on the electron , there is no change of its kinetic energy @xmath238 or any of its moments . hence , @xmath239 contains non local aspects which can not be obtained by measurements of the kinetic energy operator or any of its moments . thus the scalar aharonov - bohm effect may be viewed as a quantum effect which is _ non local in time_. the above results are easily generalized to the aharonov - bohm effects due to non abelian gauge fields@xcite by replacing the electromagnetic fluxes by fluxes of yang - mills field strength , and using the expectation values ( [ expectation ] ) of the gauge covariant operator @xmath110 given by ( [ g ] ) . in all cases , the gauge invariant @xmath240 changes as @xmath113 passes a cross - section of the gauge field flux . if the gauge field flux has a singular cross - section , then @xmath113 passes the flux at an event , which of course is independent of the inertial frame in which the effect is being described . when this happens , in this idealized case , @xmath240 changes to @xmath241 , where @xmath216 is a closed curve going around the yang - mills flux . the group element ( [ g ] ) belongs to the group @xmath242 , where for a closed system @xmath243 is the translation group and @xmath244 is the gauge group . but it has an asymmetry in that the part of ( [ g ] ) that belongs to @xmath244 is dynamical , whereas the part that belongs to @xmath243 is fixed . since i proposed that the fundamental interactions should correspond to the universal group element ( [ g ] ) being dynamical , consistency requires that the part of ( [ g ] ) that belongs to @xmath243 should be dynamical as well , i.e. @xmath116 should be made dynamical . but the classical space - time geometry was constructed in section 4 using the latter group elements . it follows therefore that making @xmath116 dynamical would make the space - time metric dynamical and not fixed as it is in minkowski space - time . therefore , the interaction that corresponds to making the @xmath243 group elements dynamical gives , in the classical limit , the well known geometrical description of gravity in classical general relativity . a generalization of it is obtained by replacing @xmath243 with @xmath245 , where @xmath18 is any positive integer . thus the present approach requires the existence of gravity . i now give a simple illustration of the above unified way of treating gravity and gauge fields by considering the gravitational analog of the above vector aharonov - bohm effect . the geometry surrounding a cosmic string in the two dimensional section normal to the axis of the string at a given time is that of a cone whose center is at the axis , which is seen by solving the classical gravitational field equations @xcite . the space - time geometry of a non- rotating cosmic string is obtained by simply adding to this plane the extra dimension in the direction of the axis and the time dimension ; then the curvature outside the string is zero everywhere ( figure 3 ) . it is known that this geometry is similar to the electromagnetic field around a solenoid because the curvature is zero outside the string and yet there is a non trivial holonomy around it . consider now two wave packets separated by a distance @xmath171 and whose centers move along initially parallel lines such that the geodesic line @xmath197 joining their centers meets the conical singularity @xmath26 at its midpoint . but there is another geodesic that connects the same pair of points @xmath194 and @xmath195 of length @xmath246 , shown by the line @xmath247 in figure 3 , where @xmath248 is identified with @xmath194 . ( actually , there are two geodesics connecting @xmath194 and @xmath195 when the angle @xmath249 on the left side exceeds @xmath250 but is less than @xmath251 . the corresponding angles @xmath249 on the right side are @xmath251 and @xmath250 , respectively . the figure 3 . a gravitational analog of the experiment in fig . the conical geometry around a cosmic string that is normal to the plane through @xmath26 is represented by cutting off the wedge @xmath252 from flat space and identifying the planes along which it is cut . the wave packets moving at @xmath194 ( same as @xmath248 ) and @xmath195 are focused by this geometry to interfere at @xmath205 . just before @xmath197 crosses @xmath26 , there are two geodesics connecting @xmath194 and @xmath195 of lengths @xmath171 and @xmath253 in the curvature free region . but just after the crossing there is a unique geodesic @xmath247 of length @xmath253 joining @xmath194 and @xmath195 . singularity may be replaced by a small smooth cap that merges with the rest of the cone smoothly . then there would be a third geodesic joining @xmath194 and @xmath195 though this cap . ) just after @xmath197 crosses the conical singularity , there is only one geodesic joining @xmath194 and @xmath195 , whose length is @xmath253 . this is somewhat analogous to the change in modular kinetic momentum when @xmath197 crosses the solenoid in fig . 1 , because @xmath254 now translates locally along parallel geodesic line segments of length @xmath171 , and this length has gotten shorter after the crossing . in figure 4 , this result is generalized to the case of @xmath26 not being the midpoint of the geodesic @xmath255 , and it is also seen to be ` gauge ' independent in the sense of being invariant under the rotation of the ` wedge ' mentioned above . there is then a phase shift @xmath256 due to the difference in path lengths traveled by the wave packets given by @xmath257 for small @xmath258 , where and @xmath259 and @xmath260 are the path lengths @xmath261 and @xmath262 , @xmath263 is the mass per unit length of the cosmic string , and @xmath264 is the initial momentum of the particle . if the particle carries spin , then there is also a phase shift due to the coupling of spin to the curvature . a generalization of the gedanken experiment shown schematically in fig . 3 to unequal lengths @xmath265 and @xmath266 . the wedge @xmath267 has an arbitrary orientation . but since @xmath268 and @xmath269 are identified , and @xmath270 in order for @xmath271 to be a geodesic , the distances along the geodesics @xmath255 and @xmath271 are respectively @xmath272 and @xmath273 , as shown in fig . ( b ) , independently of the orientation of the wedge . this and other phase shifts for interference of two wave packets around a cosmic string are studied elsewhere and are understood as being due to the poincare holonomy around the string @xcite . in the present approach , these phase shifts may be understood by associating with each curve an element of the poincare group element @xcite whose expectation value changes as the curve crosses the cosmic string . the change in geodesic distances between the wave packets due to the cosmic string , in section 5 , is not surprising because gravity changes distances , according to general relativity , and the cosmic string is a purely general relativistic object without a newtonian analog . what may be more interesting is the similar change of the ` quantum distances ' due to the electromagnetic field in the usual aharonov - bohm effect and its generalization to non abelian gauge fields . both these effects may be treated in a somewhat analogous manner if the modular kinetic energy - momentum ( [ g ] ) , regarded here as universal group elements , may be interpreted as ` distances ' in a quantum geometry as proposed earlier . the fact that space - time distances may be obtained from them approximately , as shown in section 4 , reinforces this view . the treatment of ( [ g ] ) as an observable , which implies the above mentioned non local effects in quantum theory , perhaps removes the mystery of why although the interactions are local as they occur in the hamiltonian or lagrangian , nevertheless there are non- local effects such as the aharonov - bohm and its generalizations to non abelian gauge fields and gravitation @xcite . a criticism that may be made against regarding the universal group elements ( [ g ] ) as quantum distances is that their action on wave functions seems to require that @xmath105 be interpreted as a set of space - time curves , whereas it was argued in section 3 that space - time geometry is not appropriate for quantum theory . however , as discussed in that section , this limitation becomes critical only at the planck scales . but at the planck scale these group elements need not be associated with curves in space - time . they may be defined simply as operators acting on quantum states defining the quantum geometry and representing the fundamental interactions . thus it is possible to have a quantum geometry even at scales in which the space - time geometry breaks down and this would also give a quantum description of all the interactions . the action of @xmath274 on an analytic wave function @xmath28 may be understood as the usual taylor expansion of @xmath28 . if @xmath28 is not analytic , then @xmath275 acts on the momentum space wave function @xmath81 according to @xmath276 in either case , we obtain @xmath277 . this explains why in the non relativistic limit for the charged particle , the aharonov - bohm phase shift that it experiences due to the phase factor @xmath212 remains the same . this is because the latter phase factor is unaffected by the change in the space - time metric that takes place in the non relativistic limit . this reconciles the views of y. aharonov and c. n. yang , who regarded the aharonov - bohm effect as being non local and local , respectively , in proceedings of the international symposium on the foundations of quantum mechanics , tokyo , august 1983 , edited by s. kamefuchi et al . ( physical society of japan , tokyo , 1984 ) 65 - 73 .

a generalized noether s theorem and the operational determination of a physical geometry in quantum physics are used to motivate a quantum geometry consisting of relations between quantum states that are defined by a universal group . making these relations dynamical implies the non local effect of the fundamental interactions on the wave function , as in the aharonov - bohm effect and its generalizations to non abelian gauge fields and gravity . the usual space - time geometry is obtained as the classical limit of this quantum geometry using the quantum state space metric . _ paper presented at the xxiii international colloquium on group theoretical methods in physics , dubna , russia , 30 july - 05 august , 2000 , quant - ph/0012011_.

physics0703165

photonic crystals ( pcs ) have recently become the object of increased interest as possible hosts for optical functional devices , e.g. , beam splitters , demultiplexers , etc . @xcite these elements , as well as the basic building blocks of photonic integrated circuits waveguide bends , junctions etc.have often been investigated by methods designed for finite systems , such as the finite - difference time - domain ( fdtd ) method @xcite and the multiple - scattering ( ms ) method @xcite . consequently , the devices in question were considered to be embedded in a finite fragment of a pc . this , however , involved spurious reflections at the artificial pc boundaries , significantly complicating the analysis of the device behavior . to remedy this situation , several methods suitable for analyzing systems with semi - infinite waveguides have been developed . in the effective discrete equations method @xcite and the wannier function method @xcite , the electric and magnetic fields are represented in a basis of states localized at elementary defects ; various grating - based techniques , like those presented in @xcite , have been developed as well . both approaches , however , impose some restrictions on the problems to which they can be applied : the former is ill - suited to open systems ( i.e. , those with vacuum regions extending to infinity ) , while the latter only applies to systems with unidirectional waveguides . recently , the multiple multipole method has been extended by moreno _ et al . _ @xcite to systems with semi - infinite waveguides ; here , the fields on a transverse section of each waveguide , sufficiently distant from discontinuities ( junction , bend etc . ) , are matched to a linear combination of the waveguide eigenstates . as demonstrated in @xcite , this technique is very general and applicable also to the problems which can not be dealt by the other above - mentioned methods . the aim of this paper is to show how to take into account the presence of semi - infinite waveguides in calculations performed on the basis of the ms technique . owing to its particular simplicity and efficiency in dealing with the case of pcs composed of cylindrical rods , this technique has gained significant popularity @xcite . although the approach proposed by moreno _ et al . _ @xcite could be straightforwardly carried over to the combination of the ms method and the method of fictitious sources , formulated in @xcite , this would require significant changes in the computational procedure , as well as availability of externally calculated data describing the fields corresponding to the waveguide eigenstates . in contrast , the approach outlined below consists solely in postprocessing of the results obtained by the ` pure ' ms method . while admittedly less general than the other technique , it is nevertheless applicable to a number of situations frequently encountered in practice . two of them are discussed in sections [ sec : onewaveguide ] and [ sec : twowaveguides ] , in which the proposed procedure is applied to devices linked with one waveguide and two waveguides , respectively . possible extensions of the method are discussed in section [ sec : extensions ] . the first system to be considered is a single waveguide terminated at the surface of a semi - infinite pc [ fig . [ fig : system1](a ) ] . a frequently discussed problem ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) is the design of the precise shape of the waveguide outlet that would allow maximization of the power transmitted into free space . in this case , the main objective is to calculate the reflection coefficient of the outlet ; the intensity of the field produced at some point of the free - space region ( possibly at infinity ) when an eigenmode of unitary power propagates towards the end of the waveguide is sometimes searched for , too . in the following we will show how both quantities can be found on the basis of calculations done for the finite system shown in fig . [ fig : system1](b ) , presenting a waveguide that is @xmath0 unit cells long . unit cells of the waveguide . smigaj-1.eps[fig:system1 ] ] the waveguide is assumed to be a single - mode one , and its unit cell to have a mirror - symmetry plane parallel to the @xmath1 plane , so that the propagating bloch states of the waveguide are characterized by wave numbers @xmath2 and @xmath3 . an arbitrary source @xmath4 placed near the waveguide inlet excites the right - propagating mode , which then undergoes multiple reflections . let @xmath5 and @xmath6 ( @xmath7 ) denote the @xmath8 component of the electric ( tm polarization ) or magnetic ( te polarization ) field corresponding to the mode of wave number @xmath2 and @xmath3 , respectively , at point @xmath9 represented by coordinates @xmath10 in fig . [ fig : system1](b ) . the choice of @xmath11 is arbitrary ; the zero value can be assumed unless the waveguide eigenmode is antisymmetric with respect to the @xmath12 plane . from the bloch theorem , we have [ eq : abloch ] @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the waveguide transfer matrix ; @xmath15 is the waveguide period and @xmath16 . the outgoing modes get partly reflected at the waveguide ends ; this can be expressed by the following ` boundary conditions ' : [ eq : abndconds ] @xmath17 where @xmath18 and @xmath19 are the reflection coefficients at the waveguide outlet and inlet , respectively , and @xmath20 stands for the effective field corresponding to the right - propagating mode excited by the source @xmath4 , extrapolated to point @xmath21 . by combining eqs. and eliminating the variables @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 , we get the linear system @xmath26 whose solution reads @xmath27 in cells lying sufficiently far from the waveguide ends for the contribution of the evanescent states to be negligible , the total field @xmath28 can be expressed only in terms of the propagating modes : @xmath29 we are interested in the reflection coefficient @xmath18 , as well as in the intensity @xmath30 of the field which would be generated at some point @xmath31 in the free space if the waveguide were semi - infinite and the incident right - propagating mode carried unitary power . the reflection coefficient can be found simply by least - squares fitting of the numerically calculated values of @xmath32 to those calculated by the formula resulting from eq . : @xmath33 in addition to @xmath18 , this gives also the value of @xmath34 , which can be used for calculating the wave number @xmath2 . let us note by the way that solving eq . for @xmath35 and @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is some fixed integer , yields [ eq : astartingpt ] @xmath38 these values , calculated for @xmath39 , i.e. , near the waveguide center , can be used as starting points in the nonlinear least - squares fitting procedure . the sign of @xmath2 should correspond to the physics of the problem at hand . it should be stressed that only cells distant enough from the waveguide ends ( i.e. , those labeled @xmath40 , where the ` margin ' @xmath41 is a sufficiently large integer ) should be taken into account in the above fitting procedure , since eq . has been derived with the assumption that evanescent states are of negligible amplitude in the cells labeled @xmath9 and @xmath42 . let us proceed to the determination of @xmath30 . the intensity @xmath43 of the field generated at point @xmath31 in the finite system can be written as @xmath44 where the transmission coefficient @xmath45 represents the fraction of the total energy emitted into free space when a waveguide mode reaches the outlet , and the ` transfer coefficient ' @xmath46 , dependent on the position of @xmath31 and the geometry of the waveguide outlet , but not on the waveguide length , is a measure of the amount of this energy getting to point @xmath31 . in the ideal case of the semi - infinite waveguide , @xmath19 would be zero ; thus , @xmath47 with @xmath48 chosen so that the incident mode would carry power @xmath49 . from eqs. we get @xmath50 since the incident power in each case is proportional to @xmath51 . as shown in the appendix , the total power flowing through an arbitrary transverse section of the waveguide is equal to @xmath52 this power can be easily calculated by the ms method . by using eq . for eliminating from eq . the factor @xmath53 , which contains the unknown coefficient @xmath19 , we finally get @xmath54 to sum up , the data obtained in a single ms calculation performed for a finite system with an @xmath0-cell - long waveguide suffice for determination of the reflection coefficient of the waveguide outlet , as well as the ` corrected ' field intensity in free space . when only the former quantity is required , the field excited at @xmath55 sites lying along the waveguide axis is all that needs to be calculated in the simulation ; otherwise , the power flow through an arbitrary transverse section of the finite waveguide must be computed too . as an example of application of these results , let us first consider the system shown in fig . [ fig : system1](a ) : a w1-type waveguide embedded in a hexagonal lattice of dielectric cylinders with permittivity @xmath56 and radius @xmath57 , where @xmath15 is the lattice constant . the surface termination creates a slight tapering of the waveguide exit . figure [ fig : system1reflcoeff ] presents the frequency dependence of . circles : the calculation results of lin and li @xcite ; line : results of our calculations . smigaj-2.eps[fig:system1reflcoeff ] ] the reflection coefficient @xmath58 in this configuration ; the results obtained by the proposed technique are compared to the data reported in @xcite [ fig . 7(c ) ] , acquired by the plane - wave - based transfer - matrix method . our calculations were done for waveguide length @xmath59 with margin @xmath60 . the convergence is very fast : in fact , the data obtained in the @xmath61 , @xmath62 case ( essentially the shortest waveguide for which fitting makes sense ) differ by at most 6% from those plotted in the graph , and for frequency values below @xmath63 the difference does not exceed 1% . there is a good agreement between our results and those of lin and li @xcite , except for a small peak at frequency value @xmath64 , present in the @xmath65 plot obtained by these authors , but not reproduced by the curve resulting from our calculations . since the waveguide is a single - mode one and the mode dispersion curve is smooth around this frequency value , the physical origin of this sharp peak is not clear to us and we believe it might be a numerical artifact . as a second example , let us consider the leaky - wave photonic antenna @xcite shown in fig . [ fig : antenna](a ) . here , the and @xmath66 , respectively , @xmath15 being the lattice constant ; all cylinders have permittivity @xmath56 . every second surface cylinder is shifted by @xmath67 towards the bulk . the corrugated surface is @xmath68 unit cells long . ( b ) the far - field intensity of the radiation emitted perpendicularly to the surface , calculated for waveguide length @xmath69 , and @xmath70 , as well as for the semi - infinite waveguide on the basis of data obtained for @xmath71 , @xmath72 . normalization : see text . smigaj-3.eps[fig:antenna ] ] surface surrounding the waveguide outlet is corrugated with period @xmath73 and supports leaky surface modes , which are excited by the radiation coming from the waveguide . at a certain frequency value waves scattered at individual perturbed surface cylinders interfere constructively along the surface normal to produce a collimated beam . figure [ fig : antenna](b ) presents the frequency dependence of the far - field intensity of the radiation emitted perpendicularly to the surface ; the outcomes of ` nave ' calculations done for finite - length waveguides are juxtaposed with those obtained by the proposed scheme for the semi - infinite waveguide . all curves are normalized to their absolute maxima . evidently , in the finite - waveguide case , the shape of the main peak depends on the precise length of the waveguide ; this dependence is especially pronounced to the right of the maximum , where the intensity values obtained for waveguides 11 and 12 cells long differ by as much as a factor of two . on the other hand , the sidelobes in the frequency range @xmath74 are not significantly affected by changes in the waveguide length ; this leads to the conclusion that they result from interference occurring at the crystal surface rather than in the waveguide . in this section , we will focus on the more complex system with two linked semi - infinite waveguides ; the link can be realized , for instance , by a junction , a bend or a resonant cavity where scattering can occur . our goal is to calculate the reflection and transmission coefficients of this discontinuity . the waveguides are again assumed to be single - mode ones and to possess a transverse symmetry plane ; to these assumptions let us add that of their identical geometry . figure [ fig : system2 ] depicts the finite system used in numerical calculations , where the left and right waveguide comprise @xmath0 and @xmath75 unit cells , respectively , and the field is excited by the source @xmath4 . ] let @xmath5 and @xmath6 denote the field ( electric or magnetic , depending on the polarization ) , at point @xmath76 inside the left waveguide in fig . [ fig : system2 ] , corresponding to the incoming and outgoing guided modes , respectively . their right - waveguide counterparts at point @xmath77 will be labeled @xmath78 and @xmath79 . the junction linking the waveguides can be described by its scattering matrix @xmath80 defined by @xmath81 @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 , @xmath85 denote the respective reflection and transmission coefficients of the junction . the ` boundary conditions ' are in this case [ eq : bbndconds ] @xmath86 where @xmath18 is the reflection coefficient at the waveguide outer ends ( the waveguides having the same geometry , their terminations can be assumed to be identical too ) , and @xmath20 is defined as in section [ sec : onewaveguide ] . the bloch theorem gives @xmath87 with the waveguide transfer matrix @xmath88 defined , as before , by eq . . by eliminating the variables @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 from eqs . and , and the variables @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath91 , and @xmath92 from eqs . and , we obtain the linear system @xmath93 the solution of which yields the expressions for the total fields in the left and the right waveguides : [ eq : bfsolution ] @xmath94 \phi^{2n - n } } { ( 1 - r \bar\rho \phi^{2 m } ) - r [ \rho + r(\tau\bar\tau - \rho\bar\rho ) \phi^{2 m } ] \phi^{2n } } u{_{\text{inc } } } , \\ \bar f_m & \equiv \bar u_m + \bar d_m = \frac{\tau(r\phi^m + \phi^{-m})\phi^{n+m } } { ( 1 - r \bar\rho \phi^{2 m } ) - r [ \rho + r(\tau\bar\tau - \rho\bar\rho ) \phi^{2 m } ] \phi^{2n } } u{_{\text{inc}}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] the above procedure can be repeated for the situation when source @xmath4 is replaced with source @xmath95 located near the entry of the _ right _ waveguide ; in this case , the fields @xmath96 and @xmath97 in the left and the right waveguides are given by [ eq : bgsolution ] @xmath98 \phi^{2 m } } \bar u{_{\text{inc}}}. \\ \bar g_m & = \frac{(1 - r \rho \phi^{2n } ) \phi^m + [ \bar\rho + r(\tau\bar\tau - \rho\bar\rho ) \phi^{2n } ] \phi^{2m - m } } { ( 1 - r \rho \phi^{2n } ) - r [ \bar\rho + r(\tau\bar\tau - \rho\bar\rho ) \phi^{2n } ] \phi^{2 m } } \bar u{_{\text{inc } } } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath99 being defined analogously to @xmath20 . it is important to note that the ms method allows very efficient calculation of the fields excited in a single structure by several independent sources ( e.g. , @xmath4 and @xmath95 ) , since the scattering matrix of the whole system , whose diagonalization is by far the most time - consuming step of the computational algorithm , is independent of the incident field @xcite . in the following we show how the values of @xmath28 , @xmath100 , @xmath96 , and @xmath97 , calculated by the ms method , can be used for determination of the junction parameters @xmath82 , @xmath83 , @xmath84 , and @xmath85 . as before , in all these computations only cells sufficiently distant from the waveguide ends should be taken into account . 1 . we have @xmath101 therefore , as in the one - waveguide case , the parameters @xmath34 and @xmath18 can be obtained by least - squares fitting of the above formula s right - hand side to simulation results . good starting points for the fitting procedure are in this case + [ eq : bstartingpt ] @xmath102 + with @xmath103 . 2 . to shorten the notation , we introduce the following symbols : @xmath104 consequently , the formulas for @xmath28 , @xmath100 , @xmath96 , and @xmath105 become : + [ eq : bfshort ] @xmath106 + thus , _ linear _ least - squares fitting of the numerically calculated values of @xmath28 to the function @xmath107 allows to find the coefficients + [ eq : bstep2params ] @xmath108 3 . with definitions of @xmath109 and @xmath110 included , the formulas for @xmath111 , @xmath112 , @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath115 , and @xmath116 form a system of six equations with six unknowns : @xmath117 , @xmath118 , @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath20 , and @xmath99 . its solution reads + [ eq : bstep3solution ] @xmath121 4 . the reflection and transmission coefficients @xmath82 , @xmath83 , @xmath84 , and @xmath85 can now be calculated from eqs . , since the values of all the other parameters are already known . to test the accuracy of our method , we are going to apply it to the waveguide bend depicted in fig . [ fig : system2 ] . a number of numerical studies of this system , using different methods , are available in the literature @xcite , providing a reference for new techniques . the superimposed plot in fig . [ fig : bend ] shows the frequency dependence of the reflection calculated by different methods ( see text ) . the data plotted with circles , crosses , and squares have been taken from @xcite , @xcite and @xcite , respectively . smigaj-5.eps[fig:bend ] ] coefficient @xmath122 ( since the bend is symmetric , @xmath123 ) calculated according to the above - presented scheme against the spectra obtained by the effective discrete equations method @xcite , the wannier function method @xcite , and the multiple multipole method @xcite . clearly , the overall shape of all four curves is very similar , although the exact values of @xmath122 differ , especially near the boundaries of the bulk crystal gap . the spectrum resulting from our calculations is almost identical to that calculated by moreno _ et al_. @xcite this may be partly due to the similarity of the ms and multiple multipole methods ( in both of them the field is expanded in a basis of bessel and hankel functions ) ; however , it must also be noted that these methods are intrinsically ` exact ' in the sense that the maxwell equations are solved rigorously , which makes the calculations accuracy only depend on the maximum order of the basis functions kept , and the results are known to be rapidly convergent with the truncation order @xcite . in contrast , the derivation of the effective discrete equations @xcite involves a number of approximations ( for instance , only the monopole eigenmodes of the elementary defects are taken into account ) . this may be the reason why the reflection coefficient calculated by mingaleev _ _ takes values @xmath124 larger than those obtained in our approach . the two device classes discussed above , i.e. , those linked with one or two semi - infinite waveguides , represent a large fraction of commonly investigated photonic building blocks . though the two - waveguide case has been analyzed with the assumption of identical geometry of both waveguides , this condition can be eliminated , with the transmission coefficients renormalized to refer to eigenmodes carrying unitary power , in a way similar to that presented for a single waveguide at the end of section [ subsec : onewaveguidetheory ] . our formalism can be extended to systems with more than two waveguides as well . however , many such systems , including most _ t _ and _ y _ junctions discussed in the literature , are symmetric with respect to the axis of one or more constituent waveguides . therefore , they can also be analyzed with the simpler two - waveguide formalism presented in this paper . to see this , note that the scattering matrix @xmath80 of a three - waveguide junction is defined by [ cf.eq . ] @xmath125 where @xmath126 and @xmath127 refer to the incoming and outgoing mode , respectively , in the @xmath128th waveguide ( @xmath129 ) . for simplicity reasons , all the waveguides are assumed to be of the same length @xmath0 . if waveguides 2 and 3 are identical and the axis of waveguide 1 is a symmetry plane of the system , we have @xmath130 , @xmath131 , @xmath132 , and @xmath133 . to these equalities we can add @xmath134 and @xmath135 , provided that the sources are placed symmetrically with respect to that axis . as a result , eq . simplifies to @xmath136 therefore , the junction can be treated as a two - waveguide system with effective reflection and transmission coefficients given by the above formula . the values of these parameters can be calculated by the method presented in section [ sec : twowaveguides ] . evidently , the coefficients @xmath137 and @xmath138 occur only in the form of their sum , and therefore can not be obtained independently . however , normally , the quantities of interest are the coefficients @xmath139 and @xmath140 , which are related to transmission and reflection of the radiation incoming from the first ( ` input ' ) waveguide . equation clearly shows that these parameters can be obtained straightforwardly from the two - waveguide formalism . we have presented a method , based on multiple - scattering numerical simulations performed for finite systems , allowing to find the reflection and transmission coefficients of photonic crystal functional elements linked with ideal semi - infinite waveguides . as our approach does not involve modification of the existing code implementing the multiple - scattering method , no serious programming and testing effort are necessary for its application . the proposed formalism allows for dealing with a wide variety of photonic crystal building blocks likely to be encountered in practice , as demonstrated by its successful application to a tapered waveguide outlet , a photonic crystal leaky - wave antenna , and a waveguide bend . this appendix presents the derivation of formula for the power flowing through an arbitrary transverse section of the waveguide shown in fig . [ fig : system1](b ) . only tm polarization will be considered ; the procedure to be followed in the case of te polarization is completely analogous . the power @xmath141 flowing to the right through a plane @xmath142 ( perpendicular to the waveguide axis ) per unit length in the @xmath8 direction is given by the integral of the @xmath143 component of the time - averaged poynting vector @xmath144 : @xmath145 . \end{split}\ ] ] from eq . we have @xmath146 where @xmath147 denotes the electric field corresponding to the right - propagating waveguide eigenmode of amplitude satisfying the condition @xmath148 . similarly , for the magnetic field we obtain @xmath149 note the change of sign in the numerator , which results from the magnetic field being a pseudovector . by including these formulas into eq . , after some straightforward algebra , we arrive at @xmath150 \operatorname{im}j \bigr\ } , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath151 from the conservation of energy , @xmath141 must be constant for all @xmath9 , since the waveguide is not leaky . we conclude that the second term in braces in eq . , being @xmath9-dependent , must be identically zero ; this leads to the following condition for the fields corresponding to the waveguide eigenmode : @xmath152 in consequence , eq . simplifies to @xmath153 where @xmath154 denotes the power carried by the incident mode . l. c. botten , t. p. white , a. a. asatryan , t. n. langtry , c. m. de sterke , and r. c. mcphedran , `` bloch mode scattering matrix methods for modeling extended photonic crystal structures . i. theory , '' phys . e * 70 * , 056606 ( 2004 ) . white , l. c. botten , c. m. de sterke , r. c. mcphedran , a. a. asatryan , and t. n. langtry , `` bloch mode scattering matrix methods for modeling extended photonic crystal structures . applications , '' phys . e * 70 * , 056607 ( 2004 ) . p. kramper , m. agio , c. m. soukoulis , a. birner , f. mller , r. b. wehrspohn , u. gsele , and v. sandoghdar , `` highly directional emission from photonic crystal waveguides of subwavelength width , '' phys . lett . * 92 * , 113903 ( 2004 ) .

we propose a technique of compensating the spurious reflections implied by the multiple - scattering ( ms ) method , commonly used for analyzing finite photonic crystal ( pc ) systems , to obtain exact values of characteristic parameters , such as reflection and transmission coefficients , of pc functional elements . rather than a modification of the ms computational algorithm , our approach involves postprocessing of results obtained by the ms method . we derive analytical formulas for the fields excited in a finite system , taking explicitly into account the spurious reflections occurring at the artificial system boundaries . the intrinsic parameters of the investigated functional element are found by fitting the results of ms simulations to those obtained from the formulas derived . devices linked with one and two semi - infinite waveguides are analyzed explicitly ; possible extensions of the formalism to more complex circuits are discussed as well . the accuracy of the proposed method is tested in a number of systems ; the results of our calculations prove to be in good agreement with those obtained independently by other authors .

astro-ph0007294

the x - ray pulsar gx 1 + 4 is unusual in several respects . it is the only confirmed neutron star in a symbiotic binary @xcite which appears to be accreting from the giant companions stellar wind . the neutron star spin period evolution exhibits long periods of almost constant spin - up or -down , punctuated by ` torque reversals ' lasting tens of days ( e.g. * ? ? ? indirect estimates indicate a surface magnetic field strength of 23@xmath5 g @xcite . these values are significantly greater than the @xmath6 g inferred for other accreting x - ray pulsars , generally from measurements of cyclotron scattering resonance features ( csrfs ; e.g. * ? ? ? * ) in the x - ray spectra . as the presence of such a strong field in gx 1 + 4 awaits confirmation by such methods , the possibility that the field strength may in fact be one or more orders of magnitude lower remains . historically x - ray pulsar spectra have generally been fitted with variations on a power law , which is well known to be a signature of unsaturated comptonization ( e.g * ? ? ? model fitting to the available archival _ data show that the spectra of gx 1 + 4 are broadly consistent with an analytic approximation to a comptonization continuum component combined with a gaussian to represent iron line emission , both attenuated by neutral absorbtion with variable column density @xcite . the archival _ rxte _ data , which span two orders of magnitude in flux for the source , has also revealed that the x - ray lightcurves and mean pulse profiles of all but one of the observations exhibit sharp dips spanning @xmath70.2 in phase . during 1996 july the countrate dropped to @xmath8 @xmath9 over @xmath10 h ; sharp dips were observed in the mean pulse profiles even then @xcite . similar dips are observed in only two other x - ray pulsars , rx j0812.4 - 3114 @xcite and a 0535 + 262 @xcite . a recent analytic and modelling study suggests that the sharp dips are signatures of eclipses of the emitting region by the accretion column ( galloway et al . 2000 , in preparation ) . pulse - phase spectroscopy using a continuum spectral model simulating thermal comptonization of both gx 1 + 4 and rx j0812.4@xmath113114 shows a significant increase in the fitted optical depth @xmath4 coincident with the dip phase . if the inclination angle @xmath12 of these systems are roughly equal to their magnetic colatitude @xmath13 , such an increase may result when one of the accretion columns approaches alignment with the line of sight once each rotation period . at the phase of closest alignment , photons emitted from the polar cap must propagate a greater distance through the column to escape and ultimately reach the observer . numerical modeling using a simplified column geometry confirms that the resulting increase in optical depth will have just the effect observed in gx 1 + 4 and rx j0812.4@xmath113114 @xcite . _ rxte _ consists of three instruments , the proportional counter array ( pca ) sensitive to photons in the energy range 260 kev , the high - energy x - ray timing experiment ( hexte ) covering 16250 kev , and the all - sky monitor ( asm ) which spans 210 kev @xcite . analysis of _ rxte _ data presented in this letter was carried out using lheasoft 5.0 , released 23 february 2000 by the _ rxte _ guest observer facility ( gof ) . the data were first screened to ensure that the pointing offset was @xmath14 and the source was @xmath15 from the sun . this introduces additional gaps to the data . instrumental background from cosmic ray interactions and as a result of satellite passages close to the saa are estimated using the pcabackest software which is included in the lheasoft package . the ` bright ' source background models from the 23 february 2000 release were used , which are appropriate when the net source countrate is @xmath16 @xmath9 . spectral fitting was undertaken using the xspec spectral fitting package version 11 @xcite . for more details of the spectral analysis see @xcite . [ p20170 ] between 1997 may 1620 gx 1 + 4 was observed daily for @xmath17 min . the phase - averaged background subtracted countrate varied from day to day , from @xmath18 @xmath9 ( with all 5 proportional counter units operating ) on 17 may to @xmath19 @xmath9 on 18 and 20 may ( figure [ p20170-y ] ) . for four of the five observations the sharp dips which form the primary minimum in the pulse profile were clearly observed in the background subtracted pca countrate . the pulse fraction is defined as @xmath20 and where @xmath21 is the mean pulse profile calculated over @xmath22 bins . on may 16 and 1820 @xmath23 , as is typical for the source . on 17 may however , the sharp dips in the pulse profile were weaker or absent , resulting in a pulse fraction @xmath0 ( figure [ p20170-y ] , second panel from top ) . the minima are instead broad and irregular , lacking the consistency over successive cyles observed on other days . spectral model fitting of the standard-2 mode spectra averaged over each daily observation was undertaken with the comptonization continuum model ( comptt in xspec ; * ? ? ? * ) following @xcite . note that it was not possible to obtain a background spectrum for the may 20 observation due to problems with the filter file ; the background spectrum from the previous days observation was used instead . several of the spectral fit parameters show significant variability ( table [ tab - p20170 ] ) . the column density @xmath24 varied between @xmath25 and @xmath26 . the source spectrum temperature @xmath27 was somewhat higher than is typical on 16 may but decreased to a more typical 1.21.3 kev by 18 may . for two of the spectra the scattering plasma temperature @xmath28 similarly could not be constrained by the fitting algorithm , and instead was fixed at 10 kev . for the other three days @xmath28 varied between @xmath297 and @xmath8 kev . the most dramatic variation was in the fitted optical depth @xmath4 , which was 3.64 on may 16 and 1820 but @xmath30 on may 17 . the equivalent width of the fe gaussian component was also unusually high for this spectrum , at more than 1.8 kev . these variations occurred as the luminosity varied between 1.5@xmath31 , assuming a source distance of 10 kpc . the actual distance of the source is thought to be in the range 315 kpc @xcite . the @xmath32 values indicate good fits for each spectrum except on may 17 . the spectrum obtained on this day does not resemble any of the other @xmath33 spectra extracted over the course of the _ rxte _ observations between 1996 and 1997 . the model fit was problematic in several respects . initial fits with all parameters free to vary resulted in a fit value for the @xmath34 parameter ( associated with the xe absorption edge at 4.83 kev ) an order of magnitude greater than the maximum for all the other spectra . thus the value for this parameter was instead fixed ( ` frozen ' ) at the fit value for the spectrum extracted over the whole of the 1997 may observation . the fitted @xmath27 value , when free to vary , also became much larger than was consistent than for the other spectra and so was fixed at 1.3 kev . this value is typical for the source at other times @xcite . while the resulting fit statistic @xmath35 indicates an unacceptable fit , no improvement was found using alternative continuum models , including power law , power law with exponential cutoff and broken powerlaw . a comparable fit was obtained with a blackbody component resulting in @xmath36 with fitted @xmath37 kev in rough agreement with @xmath38 for the comptt fit of @xmath39 kev . the data from each of the observations on may 1620 were divided into 10 phase bins based on the pulse period @xmath40 s estimated from regular batse monitoring of the source . the ephemeris for each day was chosen arbitrarily so that the first phase bin was centered on the primary minimum , defined as phase 0.0 . each of the resulting phase - selected spectra were fitted with the usual spectral model with at most @xmath28 , @xmath4 and the comptt and gaussian component normalisations free to vary . the other parameters were fixed at the fit values for the phase - averaged spectrum on the same day . this approach is essentially identical to that of @xcite . for the may 16 and 19 observations @xmath28 was also fixed at the same value as for the phase - averaged spectrum ( see table [ tab - p20170 ] ) . variation of @xmath28 and @xmath4 with phase is small except close to the primary minimum . the fitted @xmath4 around phase 0.0 on may 16 and 1820 was significantly greater than the value for the phase - averaged spectrum , by 2060 per cent . for the may 17 observation , at the much shallower primary minimum @xmath4 is instead marginally lower than the phase - averaged fit values , while @xmath28 is somewhat higher ( figure [ pps - y2 ] ) . for sources with @xmath41 , assuming that @xmath12 , @xmath13 and the footpoints of the accretion column on the neutron star do not change , dips due to column eclipses must always be observed while accretion continues through the columns . the apparent disappearance of the dip during the 1997 may 17 observations clearly challenges this picture . the flux at this time is more than an order of magnitude larger than the lowest level measured by _ complete cessation of accretion seems unlikely . another possibility is that the geometry of the system is changing such that the accretion column drops out of alignment briefly . the inclination angle @xmath12 may vary due to geodetic precession of the pulsar , as is suggested for some radio pulsars ( e.g. * ? ? ? alternatively , the magnetic colatitude @xmath13 may change due to evolution of the neutron star magnetic field . variations due to the former effect , however , are only expected on timescales of years . and while the latter possibility can not be discounted due to the lack of knowledge regarding such evolution , it seems much more likely that each of these mechanisms would cause a much longer - lasting , if not permanent , cessation of eclipses rather than what is observed in gx 1 + 4 . variations in the position of the column itself are much more plausible . as the accretion rate @xmath42 ( and hence the luminosity @xmath43 ) decreases , the balance of magnetic and gas pressures at the inner edge of the accretion disc means that the disk will be truncated further out from the neutron star @xcite . field lines threading the boundary region where disk material decelerates and becomes bound to the accretion column will thus meet the neutron star at progressively higher latitudes on the star . in principle at least this mechanism may cause the column to move in and out of alignment , in which case eclipses ( and dips ) would be expected only over a finite range of @xmath43 . instead what appears to be the case for gx 1 + 4 is that dips are normally observed at the full range of luminosities at which the source was observed by _ rxte _ , and are perhaps absent at a particular flux level only within that range . observations at flux levels comparable to that of 1997 may 17 however do generally exhibit sharp dips . if the accretion column has indeed been disrupted rather than moved , accretion must be occurring over a much larger region of the neutron stars magnetosphere to give the observed x - ray flux . that material can enter the magnetosphere of the star without being channeled along the field lines suggests either that the magnetic field strength is in actual fact low for an x - ray pulsar , or that some global magnetohydrodynamic instability is operating which can completely disrupt the flow . the unique phase - averaged _ rxte _ spectrum observed coincident with the unusually low pulse fraction underlines the significance of this event . that the optical depth has increased fivefold compared to values obtained before and after suggests that the source has been ` smothered ' by hot accreting material , which presumably also contributes to the unusually strong fe line emission . such a large @xmath4 suggests that the photon spectrum will approach thermalization with the scattering material ; the close agreement of the fitted blackbody temperature and the scattering plasma temperature provides corroboration for the comptt component fits during this interval . the pulse - phase spectral variation was also different to that normally observed in the source . typically @xmath4 is significantly greater than the mean value around the primary minimum ; this is the case for previously published results ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) as well as the observations on may 16 and 1820 . on may 17 @xmath4 was instead somewhat _ less _ than the phase - averaged value around the primary minimum . these results are strongly suggestive of a substantially different distribution of matter around the source . the increase in the equivalent width also observed on may 17 was not accompanied by the usual increase in the neutral column density @xmath24 @xcite , further indicating varying conditions close to the star rather than in the outer circumstellar matter . at least one similar event has been observed previously from this source . on 1993 december 11 a pulse fraction @xmath44 per cent ( 20100 kev ) was measured using balloon - borne instruments , along with an unusually hard spectrum with power law energy index @xmath45 @xcite . for comparison , a power law fit was made to _ spectra from 17 may in the energy band 2040 kev only . the resulting photon index @xmath46 is consistent with the fit value for the full pca energy range , and represents a significantly harder spectrum than on 1993 december 11 . flux measurements by the burst and transient source experiment ( batse ) aboard the _ compton gamma - ray observatory _ satellite indicate that following that observation the source entered a hard x - ray low state with @xmath47 ( 2060 kev ) which persisted ( with brief interruptions ) for the next @xmath48 d. in contrast , the may 17 observation was made during a flare lasting @xmath49 d where the flux peaked at @xmath50 . the other spectra from 1997 may give fitted @xmath4 values at intermediate levels between the two distinct spectral states suggested by analysis of the archival _ rxte _ observations @xcite . it is possible that the disruption of the accretion column is also related to transitions between distinct spectral and luminosity states inferred from analysis of the full set of _ rxte _ archival data @xcite . this research has made use of data obtained through the high energy astrophysics science archive research center online service , provided by the nasa / goddard space flight center , and also the batse pulsar group home page at http://www.batse.msfc.masa.gov . lccccc @xmath24 & @xmath51 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 + @xmath27 ( kev ) & @xmath56 & 1.3 ( fixed ) & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 + @xmath28 ( kev ) & 10 ( fixed ) & @xmath39 & @xmath60 & 10 ( fixed ) & @xmath61 + @xmath4 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 & @xmath64 & @xmath65 & @xmath66 + @xmath67 & @xmath68 & @xmath69 & @xmath70 & @xmath71 & @xmath72 + @xmath73 ( kev ) & @xmath74 & @xmath75 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 + @xmath79 & @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 + @xmath85 & @xmath86 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 + ew ( ev ) & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath93 & @xmath94 & @xmath95 + @xmath43 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 + @xmath101 & 1.20 & 2.60 & 0.899 & 1.03 & 1.68 +

daily observations of the binary x - ray pulsar gx 1 + 4 were made with the _ rossi x - ray timing explorer _ ( _ rxte _ ) satellite between 1997 may 1620 as part of a four - month monitoring program . on may 17 the sharp dips normally observed in the lightcurve were all but absent , resulting in a pulse fraction @xmath0 instead of the more typical value of @xmath1 measured before and after . also observed was a dramatic hardening of the 240 kev phase - averaged spectrum . the power - law photon index was @xmath2 , whereas values of 1.62.0 are more typical . in terms of a comptonization continuum component , the optical depth for scattering was @xmath3 , with 46 the usual range for _ rxte _ spectra @xcite . pulse - phase spectrosopy indicates that @xmath4 is decreased relative to the phase - averaged value around the primary minimum , where an increase is normally observed . the reduced depth of the dip is interpreted as disruption of the accretion column , and the accompanying spectral variation suggests a substantially different accretion regime than is usual for this source .

hep-ph0311165

the origin of mass is a central mystery of the standard model ( sm ) . in particular , why are the masses of w , z , and the top quark exceptionally large compared with those of other particles in the sm ? the idea of the top quark condensate @xcite explains naturally the large top mass of the order of the electroweak symmetry breaking ( ewsb ) scale . in the explicit formulation of this idea @xcite , often called the `` top mode standard model '' ( tmsm ) , the scalar bound state of @xmath9 plays the role of the higgs boson in the sm . ( for reviews , see , e.g. , refs . @xcite . ) there are several problems in the original version of the tmsm : we need to introduce ad hoc four - fermion interactions of the top quark in order to trigger the ewsb . the top mass @xmath10 , given as a decreasing function of the composite scale @xmath11 , is predicted about 10%30% larger than the experimental value , even if we take @xmath11 to the planck or the gut scale @xcite . such a huge @xmath11 also causes a serious fine - tuning problem . as a possible solution to these problems , following the line of an earlier attempt @xcite of the tmsm in the tev - scale extra dimension scenario @xcite , arkani - hamed , cheng , dobrescu and hall ( acdh ) @xcite proposed an interesting version of such where the sm gauge bosons and the third generation of quarks and leptons live in the @xmath12-dimensional bulk , while the first and second generations are confined in the 3-brane ( 4-dimensional minkowski space - time ) . gauge interactions in higher dimensions than four become strong in a certain high - energy region . bulk gauge interactions are expected to trigger the top condensation without adding ad hoc four - fermion interactions , in contrast to the original version of the tmsm . however , the dynamics of bulk gauge theories was not concretely analyzed in ref . in particular , as it turned out @xcite ( see also refs . @xcite ) , the bulk qcd coupling , which is the most relevant interaction for the top condensation , has an ultraviolet fixed point ( uv - fp ) or upper bound within the same @xmath13-scheme of the truncated kaluza - klein ( kk ) effective theory @xcite as that ref . @xcite was based on . thus , it is quite nontrivial whether the top condensation is actually realized or not . in refs . @xcite , we have studied the dynamical chiral symmetry breaking ( d@xmath14sb ) in bulk gauge theories , based on the ladder schwinger - dyson ( sd ) equation.sb in other scenario for extra dimensions was investigated in ref . switching off the electroweak interaction in the bulk , we then found that the bulk qcd coupling can not become sufficiently large to trigger the top condensation for @xmath2 , while the top condensation can be realized for @xmath1 . for the purpose of model building , we further need to study the effect of the bulk electroweak interactions : since the bulk @xmath15 interaction grows very quickly due to the power - like running behavior and reaches immediately its landau pole @xmath16 , it may affect the most favored channel for condensate , i.e. , the most attractive channel ( mac ) @xcite . we also need to study whether or not the prediction of the top mass agrees with the experiments . in this paper , we demonstrate a possibility that the top condensate is actually the mac even including all of the bulk sm gauge interactions . this is quite nontrivial , because inclusion of the strong bulk @xmath15 interaction may favor the tau condensation rather than the top condensation . in order for only the top quark to acquire the dynamical mass of the order of the ewsb scale , the binding strength should exceed the critical binding strength @xmath17 only for the top quark ( `` topped mac '' or `` tmac '' ) . namely , our scenario works only when @xmath18 where @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 denote the binding strengths of the top , bottom , and tau condensates at the scale @xmath11 , respectively . we refer to the scale @xmath11 satisfying eq . ( [ top - cond ] ) as the tmac scale @xmath22 . for the mac analysis , we study binding strengths @xmath23 by using the one - loop renormalization group equations ( rges ) of dimensionless bulk gauge couplings . it is in contrast to the analysis of acdh @xcite where all of bulk gauge couplings are assumed equal ( and strong enough for triggering the ewsb ) . in order to check reliability of our mac analysis , we also study the regularization - scheme dependence of the binding strengths . we calculate gauge couplings in two prescriptions , the @xmath13-scheme of the truncated kk effective theory and the proper - time ( pt ) scheme @xcite . there are some varieties in the estimation of @xmath17 : the naive dimensional analysis ( nda ) @xcite implies @xmath24 , while the ladder sd equation yields much smaller value @xmath25 @xcite . as the estimate of @xmath17 increases in eq . ( [ top - cond ] ) , the region of the tmac scale gets squeezed . even if we adopt the lowest possible value of @xmath17 given by the ladder sd equation @xcite , we find that _ the tmac scale does not exist for the simplest scenario with @xmath2_. on the other hand , _ the tmac scale does exist in @xmath1 _ for the value of the ladder sd equation , @xmath26@xmath27 , where the compactification scale @xmath28 is taken to be 1100 tev . for @xmath3 , the mac analysis significantly depends on the regularization scheme . once we obtain the tmac scale @xmath22 , we can easily predict the top mass @xmath10 and the higgs mass @xmath29 by using the renormalization group equations ( rges ) for the top yukawa and higgs quartic couplings , and the compositeness conditions @xcite at the scale @xmath30 . this is in contrast to the earlier approach @xcite ( see also ref . @xcite ) where the composite scale @xmath11 is treated as an adjustable free parameter and fixed so as to reproduce the experimental value of @xmath10 . without such an adjustable parameter , we predict the top quark mass @xmath31 for @xmath1 and @xmath32 1100 tev . this agrees with the experimental value , @xmath33 gev @xcite . we find that the value of @xmath10 near the compactification scale @xmath28 is governed by the quasi infrared fixed point ( ir - fp ) for the top yukawa coupling @xmath34 @xcite , which is approximately obtained as @xmath35 with the 4-dimensional qcd coupling @xmath36 , the number of color @xmath37 , the quadratic casimir of the fundamental representation @xmath38 , and @xmath39 . the suppression factor @xmath40 in @xmath34 arises from one - loop effects of the bulk top quark which is equivalent to a tower of kk modes ( massive vector - like fermions ) . the mechanism suppressing the top mass prediction is thus similar to that of the top seesaw @xcite . we also predict the higgs boson mass as @xmath41 thanks to the ir - fp property , the prediction for @xmath10 and @xmath29 is stable . the higgs boson with such a characteristic mass can be distinguished clearly from that of supersymmetric or other typical dynamical ewsb models simply through its mass determination in experiments . it will also be discovered immediately after the physics run of lhc . the paper is organized as follows . in sec . ii , we study running effects of bulk gauge couplings in the @xmath13- , and pt - schemes . in sec . iii , we identify the tmac scale . in sec . iv , we predict @xmath10 and @xmath29 for @xmath1 . sec . v is devoted to summary and discussions . in appendix a , we present details of our procedure for the orbifold compactification . we also count the total number of kk modes below the renormalization point . appendix b is for details of bulk gauge couplings in the pt - scheme . let us consider a simple version of the tmsm with extra dimensions where the sm gauge group and the third generation of quarks and leptons are put in @xmath42-dimensional bulk , while the first and second generations live on the 3-brane ( 4-dimensional minkowski space - time ) . the @xmath42-dimensions consist of the usual 4-dimensional minkowski space - time and extra @xmath43 spatial dimensions compactified at a tev - scale @xmath28 . the number of dimensions @xmath42 is taken to be even , @xmath44 , so as to introduce chiral fermions in the bulk . in order to obtain a 4-dimensional chiral theory and to forbid massless gauge scalars , we compactify extra dimensions on the orbifold @xmath45 ( see appendix a ) . we emphasize that there is no elementary field for higgs in our model . the chiral condensation of bulk fermions may generate dynamically a composite higgs field , instead . hence we investigate rges of bulk gauge couplings including loop effects of the composite higgs . we expand bulk fields into kk modes and construct a 4-dimensional effective theory . in this subsection , we study running of gauge couplings in the `` truncated kk '' effective theory @xcite based on the @xmath13-scheme . below the compactification scale @xmath28 , rges of 4-dimensional gauge couplings @xmath46 are given by those of the sm , @xmath47 with @xmath48 and @xmath49 for one ( composite ) higgs doublet . we need to take into account contributions of kk modes in @xmath50 . since the kk modes heavier than the renormalization scale @xmath51 are decoupled in the @xmath13-rges , we only need summing up the loops of the kk modes lighter than @xmath51 . within the truncated kk effective theory , we obtain rges for gauge couplings @xmath46 : @xmath52 where rge coefficients @xmath53 are given by @xmath54 for @xmath55 , @xmath56 for @xmath57 , and @xmath58 for @xmath15 . here @xmath59 is defined as @xmath60 in eqs . ( [ b3kk])([bykk ] ) , @xmath61 denote the total number of kk modes for gauge bosons , gauge scalars , dirac ( 4-component ) fermions , and composite higgs bosons below @xmath51 , respectively . the number of generations in the bulk is @xmath62 , which is unity in our model . in the following analysis , we assume one composite higgs doublet , @xmath63 . @xmath64 for @xmath65 are not necessarily equal , since the orbifold boundary conditions are depending on @xmath66 . for details , see appendix a. we show numerical values for @xmath67 , ( the solid lines ) , @xmath68 , ( the dashed lines ) , and @xmath69 , ( the dotted lines ) in figs . [ fig - g-6d](b ) , [ fig - g-8d](b ) and [ fig - g-10d](b ) . matching the 4-dimensional action to the bulk action , we find the relation between the 4-dimensional gauge coupling @xmath70 and the _ dimensionful _ bulk gauge coupling @xmath71 , @xmath72 . we define the _ dimensionless _ bulk gauge coupling @xmath73 as @xmath74 and thereby obtain @xmath75 combining eq . ( [ hat - g ] ) with eq . ( [ rge_ed ] ) , we find rges for @xmath76 , @xmath77 . \label{rge_ed2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in figs . [ fig - g-6d](a ) , [ fig - g-8d](a ) and [ fig - g-10d](a ) , we show typical behavior of the dimensionless bulk gauge couplings . we have used the couplings @xmath78 at @xmath79 as inputs of rges : @xcite @xmath80 @xmath81 and @xmath82 , i.e. , @xmath83 we note here that the @xmath15 has the landau pole @xmath16 . the bulk gauge coupling @xmath84 rapidly grows due to the power - like behavior of the running . as a result , the landau pole @xmath16 is close to the compactification scale @xmath28 . a cutoff smaller than the landau pole @xmath16 needs to be introduced in our model . a handy approximation for @xmath85 is widely used , @xmath86 2^{\delta/2 - 1 } n_{\rm kk}(\mu ) & \text{for $ i = f,$ } \end{cases } \label{nkki_app}\ ] ] with @xmath87 we show @xmath88 in figs . [ fig - g-6d](b ) , [ fig - g-8d](b ) and [ fig - g-10d](b ) with the dash - dotted line . the deviation of eq . ( [ nkki_app ] ) from the numerical calculations of @xmath64 is negligibly small for @xmath2 , whereas it is sizable for @xmath89 in @xmath90 . we do not use the approximation of eq . ( [ nkki_app ] ) for the mac analysis ) in the previous report @xcite . while the mac analysis is somewhat affected by the approximation , the predictions of @xmath10 and @xmath29 are not . ] . here we comment on the uv - fp discussed in ref . @xcite , which relies on the approximation of eq . ( [ nkk_app ] ) . ( see also refs . @xcite . ) using eqs . ( [ nkki_app ] ) and ( [ nkk_app ] ) , ref . @xcite gave a rge formula @xmath91 with @xmath92 being the loop factor in @xmath42 dimensions , @xmath93 the rge coefficients @xmath94 are @xmath95 the rge ( [ rge_ed3 ] ) leads to the uv - fp @xmath96 @xcite , @xmath97 for @xmath98 . in the case of @xmath99 and @xmath100 , @xmath101 become negative and hence the bulk qcd has such a uv - fp . on the other hand , in @xmath102 the bulk qcd coupling has a landau pole at @xmath103 . there are several manners to define bulk gauge couplings . in this subsection , we study bulk gauge couplings based on the proper - time ( pt ) regularization scheme with a matching condition slightly different from that in ref . @xcite . in the pt - scheme , one - loop contributions of all kk modes are smoothly ( exponentially ) suppressed , whereas the contributions of kk modes heavier than the renormalization scale @xmath51 are sharply cut off in the truncated kk effective theory . we here note that the landau pole @xmath16 is not so far from the compactification scale @xmath28 , particularly for @xmath89 . under such a situation , numerical differences between @xmath13- , and pt - couplings may be significant . we briefly present our definition of the pt - coupling and give the matching condition to the @xmath13-coupling through the effective charge . see appendix b for details . our 4-dimensional pt - coupling @xmath104 is a bare quantity defined at the cutoff @xmath11 , in sharp contrast to the @xmath13-coupling @xmath105 , which is a renormalized quantity . the effective charge @xmath106 with euclidean momentum @xmath107 is obtained in the pt - scheme as @xmath108 with @xmath109 , @xmath110 and a constant @xmath111 to be discussed later . the coefficient @xmath112 of the logarithmic divergent term from zero modes is given by @xmath113 where @xmath114 is the quadratic casimir of the adjoint representation , @xmath115 the trace of the product of two generator matrices , @xmath116 , and @xmath117 the number of flavor of 4-component fermions . the constant term @xmath118 in eq . ( [ eff_pt_q ] ) arises from zero modes and is given by @xmath119 with @xmath120 the kk mode summation of the vacuum polarization function @xmath121 is calculated in the pt - scheme , @xmath122e^{-tx(1-x)q_e^2}k_g(t ) \nonumber \\ & & \hspace*{-4mm}- \frac{\delta}{2 } \ , \frac{c_a}{(4\pi)^2 } \int_0 ^ 1dx\int_{r\lambda^{-2}}^\infty\frac{dt}{t}\ , ( 2x-1)^2 e^{-tx(1-x)q_e^2 } k_{gs}(t ) \nonumber \\ & & \hspace*{-4mm}- 8t_r \ , \frac{n_f}{(4\pi)^2 } \int_0 ^ 1dx\int_{r\lambda^{-2}}^\infty\frac{dt}{t}\ , x(1-x ) e^{-tx(1-x)q_e^2 } k_f ( t ) \nonumber \\ & & \hspace*{-4mm}- t_r \ , \frac{n_h}{(4\pi)^2 } \int_0 ^ 1dx\int_{r\lambda^{-2}}^\infty\frac{dt}{t}\ , ( 2x-1)^2 e^{-tx(1-x)q_e^2 } k_h ( t ) , \nonumber \\ \label{pi_pt_q}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath123 s are defined as @xmath124_1 } \left[\,\frac{1}{2}(\vartheta_3 - 1)\,\right ] + { \cal n}_i^{\delta,[n]_2 } \left[\,\frac{1}{2}(\vartheta_3 - 1)\,\right]^2 + \cdots\ ] ] for @xmath65 , with @xmath125 being the jacobi @xmath125 function , @xmath126 . the definition of the factor @xmath127_k}$ ] is given in appendix a. ( for values of @xmath127_k}$ ] in @xmath128 , see table [ tab1][tab3 ] . ) on the other hand , the effective charge @xmath106 is also calculated in the @xmath13-scheme @xcite , @xmath129 where @xmath130 and @xmath131 \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{\delta}{2 } \ , c_a \ , i_s^r(q_e^2;m_{\vec n}^2 ) \nonumber \\ & & + 8 t_r \ , n_f \ , i_f^r(q_e^2;m_{\vec n}^2 ) \nonumber \\ & & + t_r \ n_h \ , i_s^r(q_e^2;m_{\vec n}^2 ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath132 the constant term from zero modes is given by @xmath133 now , we impose the matching condition to relate the pt- and @xmath13-couplings : @xmath134 i.e. , @xmath135 following ref . @xcite , we further impose a condition , @xmath136 in @xmath137 . the parameter @xmath111 of the pt - cutoff is then determined as @xmath138 the matching condition in ref . @xcite roughly corresponds to @xmath139 with @xmath140 . there is an ambiguity associated with the matching scale @xmath141 . on the other hand , eq . ( [ match_cond ] ) includes effects of the finite parts @xmath142 and hence is less ambiguous about the matching scale . the matching condition ( [ match_cond ] ) determines values of pt - couplings at @xmath143 tev , @xmath144 while the corresponding values in the @xmath13-scheme at @xmath145 tev are @xmath146 where inputs are eqs . ( [ qcd - mz ] ) and ( [ su2-mz ] ) . at the compactification scale @xmath28 , the scheme dependence between the pt- , @xmath13-couplings are not significant for @xmath128 . in order to discuss the scheme dependence at the scale beyond @xmath28 , we define the dimensionless bulk gauge coupling in the pt - scheme @xmath147 , @xmath148 in the same way as eq . ( [ hat - g ] ) , where @xmath149 is the 4-dimensional coupling . in the next section , we will discuss the scheme dependence of the couplings , @xmath147 and @xmath150 : the scheme dependence near the landau pole @xmath16 is small for @xmath151 , while it is significant for @xmath3 . in this section , we analyze the energy scale @xmath22 ( tmac scale ) where the top condensate is the mac and only in the @xmath9-channel the binding strength exceeds the critical value , i.e. , @xmath152 where @xmath23 are given in terms of the sm gauge couplings in the bulk such as those shown in figs . [ fig - g-6d](a ) , [ fig - g-8d](a ) , [ fig - g-10d](a ) and the critical binding strength @xmath17 is determined by the ladder sd equation @xcite . this is contrasted to the mac analysis in ref . @xcite where it was assumed that @xmath153 and that the value is large enough to trigger the d@xmath14sb . however , as we have shown in figs . [ fig - g-6d](a ) , [ fig - g-8d](a ) and [ fig - g-10d](a ) , values of the couplings at the scale where @xmath154 are not necessarily large , @xmath155 , for @xmath128 . it is thus highly non - trivial whether or not the tmac scale @xmath22 exists . as usual , we discuss the mac based on the one - gauge - boson - exchange approximation @xcite . the binding strength @xmath156 of a @xmath157 channel is given by @xmath158 where @xmath159 , @xmath160 are the generators of @xmath161 , and @xmath162 is the hypercharge . noting the identity @xmath163 with @xmath164 being the quadratic casimir for the representation @xmath111 of the gauge group , we calculate the binding strengths : @xmath165 for the top , bottom and tau condensates , respectively , where @xmath166 is the quadratic casimir of the fundamental representation of @xmath55 . in the following analysis , we study these three channels . we next turn to the estimation of the critical binding strength @xmath17 . often applied is the naive dimensional analysis ( nda ) @xcite , @xmath24 . on the other hand , the value of @xmath17 is fairly smaller than that of the nda in the approach of the improved ladder sd equation @xcite , @xmath167 there are actually some issues in the estimation of @xmath17 through the ladder sd equation : * non - ladder corrections may push the value of @xmath17 down as much as 120% , as in the analysis of the 4-dimensional walking technocolor @xcite . * another momentum identification of the ( dimensionful ) running coupling constant requires the nonlocal gauge fixing @xcite , which pushes up the value of @xmath17 as @xcite , @xmath168 * the values in eqs . ( [ kd_sd1])([kd_sd2 ] ) were obtained under the assumption that the dimensionless bulk gauge coupling @xmath73 is constant . as shown in figs . [ fig - g-6d](a ) , [ fig - g-8d](a ) and [ fig - g-10d](a ) , all of bulk gauge couplings @xmath169 are monotonously increasing functions . this means that the attractive force is overestimated under the simplification of @xmath170 const . , i.e. , the momentum dependence of @xmath73 makes values of @xmath17 larger than eqs . ( [ kd_sd1])([kd_sd2 ] ) . * effects of the compactification were also neglected in the estimate of eqs . ( [ kd_sd1])([kd_sd2 ] ) . if such effects are included , the value of @xmath17 becomes also larger . taking these issues into account , we may regard the value of @xmath17 in eq . ( [ kd_sd1 ] ) to be a reference value as the best compromise . + now , we are ready to investigate the tmac scale . we show behavior of the binding strengths @xmath23 both in the @xmath13- and pt - couplings in figs . [ fig - tmac-6d][fig - tmac-10d ] to study the scheme dependence . we first discuss the tmac scale based on the @xmath13-coupling . we compare attractive forces of top , bottom , and tau condensates with @xmath17 in figs . [ fig - tmac-6d](a ) , [ fig - tmac-8d](a ) and [ fig - tmac-10d](a ) for @xmath171 tev . as the value of @xmath17 becomes larger , the tmac scale gets squeezed . for @xmath2 , we find that _ the tmac scale is squeezed out _ , if we use _ the reference value _ @xmath172 eq . ( [ kd_sd1 ] ) . the conclusion is unchanged against varying the compactification scale as far as @xmath173 tev . actually , the tau condensation instead of the top condensation becomes the mac . in order for the tmac scale to survive , the value of @xmath172 should be lower than the reference value by about 20% for @xmath32 1100 tev , which is highly unlikely . thus the scenario does not work for @xmath2 . for @xmath1 , on the other hand , the tmac scale @xmath22 satisfying eq . ( [ top - cond - sec3 ] ) does exist , @xmath174 for the reference value of @xmath17 . if we vary the compactification scale as @xmath175100 tev , we find the tmac scale , @xmath176 for @xmath3 , the tmac scale does not exist for @xmath177 tev . if we admit @xmath178 tev , we barely find the tmac scale @xmath179@xmath180 for @xmath181@xmath182 tev . we have studied the tmac scale so far by using the @xmath13-coupling . in order to clarify the scheme dependence , we also investigate the pt - coupling in the mac analysis . we show binding strengths @xmath23 in the pt - scheme in figs . [ fig - tmac-6d](b ) , [ fig - tmac-8d](b ) and [ fig - tmac-10d](b ) for @xmath171 tev . we find that the scheme dependence is negligibly small for @xmath2 . although behavior of the binding strengths @xmath23 for @xmath1 somewhat depends on the regularization scheme , there does exist an overlapped region of the tmac scale between the @xmath13- and pt - schemes . for @xmath3 , however , the scheme dependence is rather large : there is no overlap of the tmac scale for @xmath175@xmath183 tev . in conclusion we have shown that the region of the tmac scale is squeezed out for @xmath2 , while the tmac scale does exist for @xmath1 without much ambiguity . for @xmath3 , we can not obtain a reliable result because of the significant scheme dependence . in this section , we calculate the top mass @xmath10 and the higgs mass @xmath29 by using rges of the top yukawa and higgs quartic couplings with the compositeness conditions @xcite in a way used by acdh @xcite . let us first recapitulate the compositeness conditions in ref . @xcite : assume that the top condensation takes place in the bulk . then , at the compositeness scale @xmath11 , a scalar bound state @xmath184 ( composite higgs ) , @xmath185 is formed in the bulk , where @xmath186 $ ] and @xmath187 are bulk fermions . at this stage , the composite higgs @xmath184 does not propagate in the bulk . its kinetic term is expected to develop at the scale below @xmath11 . it is assumed that the effective theory below @xmath11 is described by the bulk sm . in the truncated kk effective theory of the bulk sm , the compositeness conditions then read @xmath188 where @xmath34 and @xmath189 denote the top yukawa and higgs quartic couplings , respectively . we shall use the above procedure to calculate @xmath10 and @xmath29 . in contrast to the acdh analysis , however , we have shown existence of the tmac scale for @xmath1 without much ambiguity and hence the extra dimension scenario of the tmsm is actually possible . furthermore , while the compositeness scale @xmath11 in ref . @xcite was treated as a free parameter to be adjusted for reproducing the experimental value of @xmath10 , we identify the compositeness scale @xmath11 with the tmac scale @xmath22 , @xmath190 which is no longer an adjustable parameter but constrained as eq . ( [ tmac ] ) . thus we can test our model by comparing the predicted @xmath10 with the experimental value . within the truncated kk effective theory , rges for @xmath34 and @xmath189 read ) are missing in the rges of ref . @xmath191 & ( 4\pi)^2 \mu \frac{d \lambda}{d \mu } = \beta_\lambda^{\rm sm } + \beta_\lambda^{\rm kk } , \label{rge_lam}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath192 , \\[2 mm ] \beta_y^{\rm kk } & = & \left ( 6 { n_{\rm kk}^f}+\frac{3}{2 } { n_{\rm kk}^h}\right)\,y^3 \nonumber \\ & & \quad -{n_{\rm kk}^g}\left ( 8 g_3 ^ 2 + \frac{9}{4 } g_2 ^ 2 + \frac{17}{12 } g_y^2 \right)\,y \nonumber \\ & & \quad - \delta { n_{\rm kk}^{gs}}\left(\frac{4}{3 } g_3 ^ 2 - \frac{3}{8 } g_2 ^ 2 - \frac{1}{72 } g_y^2 \right)\,y , \label{rge_y - ed } \\ \beta_\lambda^{\rm sm } & = & 12 \left(\lambda y^2-y^4\right ) + 12\lambda^2 \nonumber \\ & & \quad + \frac{3}{4}(3 g_2 ^ 4 + 2g_2 ^ 2 g_y^2 + g_y^4 ) \nonumber \\ & & \quad -3(3g_2 ^ 2+g_y^2)\lambda , \\ \beta_\lambda^{\rm kk } & = & 24 { n_{\rm kk}^f}\left(\lambda y^2-y^4\right ) + 12 { n_{\rm kk}^h}\lambda^2 \nonumber \\ & & \hspace*{-0.5 cm } + { n_{\rm kk}^g}\left[\ , \frac{3}{4}\left(3 g_2 ^ 4 + 2g_2 ^ 2 g_y^2 + g_y^4\right ) - 3(3g_2 ^ 2+g_y^2)\lambda\,\right ] \nonumber \\ & & \hspace*{-0.5 cm } + \frac{\delta}{4 } { n_{\rm kk}^{gs}}(3 g_2 ^ 4 + 2g_2 ^ 2 g_y^2 + g_y^4 ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath193 and @xmath194 stand for contributions of zero modes and kk modes , respectively . we calculate the rges by using the uv - bcs eq . ( [ comp - cond ] ) and determine @xmath10 and @xmath29 through the conditions , @xmath195 with @xmath196 gev . + + + we show results of @xmath10 and @xmath29 in figs . [ mt - mh-6d ] , [ mt - mh ] , [ mt - mh-10d ] for @xmath128 , @xmath171 tev for various values of the compositeness scale @xmath11 . as we have shown in sec . iii , the tmac scale does exist only for @xmath1 without much ambiguity , @xmath26@xmath27 . identifying @xmath11 with @xmath22 , we depict the region of the tmac scale for @xmath1 by the shaded area in fig . [ mt - mh ] . there is no shaded region in figs . [ mt - mh-6d ] and [ mt - mh-10d ] , because a sensible tmac scale is absent for @xmath197 . for @xmath1 we predict @xmath198 and @xmath199 for the range of the compactification scale @xmath32 1100 tev . the uncertainties in eqs . ( [ 8d - mt ] ) and ( [ 8d - mh ] ) also include error of @xmath200 @xcite . remarkably , the prediction eq . ( [ 8d - mt ] ) for @xmath10 is consistent with the reality , the @xmath13-mass @xmath201 gev which is calculated from the observed value of the pole mass , @xmath202 gev @xcite . it should be emphasized that the compositeness scale @xmath11 in ref . @xcite is an arbitrary parameter and was adjusted to reproduce the experimental value of the top mass . on the contrary , our compositeness scale @xmath11 is fixed by the tmac scale @xmath22 by requiring that the top quark condensation actually takes place , while other condensations do not . hence the top mass as well as the higgs mass is the prediction in our approach . compared with the prediction of ref . @xcite , @xmath203 gev for @xmath1 , eq . ( [ 8d - mh ] ) is determined more sharply . this is because our compositeness scale @xmath11 is given by the tmac scale @xmath22 which is more severely constrained than @xmath11 of ref . @xcite , the value determined from the top mass within 3@xmath204 of the experimental value . we now discuss the reason why the value of eq . ( [ 8d - mt ] ) is significantly smaller than that of the original tmsm in four dimensions which predicted @xmath205 gev . let us consider a simplified rge for @xmath34 neglecting the electroweak gauge interactions : @xmath206 with @xmath207 , @xmath208 . using eq . ( [ nkki_app ] ) as an approximation for @xmath209 and equating the r.h.s . of eq . ( [ y_app ] ) to zero , we find the quasi ir fixed point @xmath210 @xcite @xmath211 the value of eq . ( [ qir ] ) decreases as @xmath212 increases at @xmath213 , since the value of @xmath214 is determined within the sm independently of @xmath59 . in the original tmsm with @xmath215 the prediction of @xmath10 is governed by eq . ( [ qir ] ) with @xmath216 @xcite . as a result , the prediction of @xmath10 with @xmath217 is substantially lower than that of the original tmsm with @xmath218 . the mechanism is still operative even including the electroweak gauge interactions : in fig . [ ir - fp ] , we show the quasi ir fixed point and the behavior of @xmath34 based on the full one - loop rge ( [ rge_y ] ) with various boundary conditions at @xmath11 . we also show the pendleton - ross ( pr ) fixed point @xcite determined from @xmath219 : @xmath220 with @xmath101 being @xmath221 and @xmath222 , @xmath223 . for @xmath224 the pr fixed point is identical to the quasi ir fixed point . as far as @xmath225 @xmath226 , the value of the pr fixed point is smaller than that of the quasi ir fixed point , @xmath227 , while @xmath228 for @xmath3 . the top yukawa coupling at @xmath28 for @xmath151 is actually between @xmath229 and @xmath230 for a sufficiently large top yukawa , @xmath231 , at high energy scale @xmath232 . we note here that the actual prediction of @xmath10 with @xmath151 is even smaller than the value expected from @xmath230 . we also comment that the predicted values of @xmath10 and @xmath29 would be stable thanks to these fixed points , even if the estimate of the tmac scale were somewhat changed from ours for some reason . as was already pointed out in ref . @xcite , the lower value prediction of @xmath10 than that of the original tmsm can also be understood as follows : since kk modes of the top quark ( @xmath233 ) as well as its zero mode ( @xmath234 ) contribute to the vev @xmath235 , @xmath236 the condensate @xmath237 is suppressed compared with the original tmsm and so is the top mass . now we discuss implication of our higgs mass prediction eq . ( [ 8d - mh ] ) . the upper limit of @xmath29 from radiative corrections in the sm is @xmath238 gev at 95% cl @xcite . the prediction eq . ( [ 8d - mh ] ) is still below this upper limit . in order to discriminate the present model from the sm in experiments , we need further information of physics at the compactification scale . however , the higgs boson in such a mass range , @xmath7 gev , is characteristically small within the framework of the dynamical ewsb . yet the value is substantially larger than that of typical supersymmetric models , @xmath239 gev . thus the present scenario is clearly distinguished from most of the models beyond the sm simply through the higgs mass observation . the higgs boson of this mass range decays into weak boson pair almost 100% . it will be immediately discovered in @xmath8 once the lhc starts . we have argued a viable top mode standard model ( tmsm ) with tev - scale extra dimensions where bulk @xmath240 sm gauge interactions ( without ad hoc four - fermion interactions ) trigger condensate of only the top quark , but not of other quarks and leptons . in order for such a situation to be realized , the binding strength @xmath156 should exceed the critical binding strength @xmath17 only for the top quark ( tmac ) , @xmath241 the binding strengths @xmath23 were calculated by using rges for bulk sm gauge couplings . comparing @xmath23 with @xmath17 , we searched for the region of the tmac scale @xmath22 satisfying eq . ( [ top - cond - fin ] ) . we then found that the region of the tmac scale is squeezed out for @xmath2 for the reference value of @xmath17 in ref . @xcite , while it does exist for @xmath1 , @xmath242 ( 3.53.6)@xmath28 . we were not able to draw a reliable conclusion for @xmath3 , since the mac analysis for @xmath3 strongly depends on the regularization scheme . for @xmath1 , we predicted the top mass @xmath10 and the higgs mass @xmath29 : @xmath243 and @xmath244 by using rges for the top yukawa and higgs quartic couplings with the compositeness conditions at the tmac scale @xmath22 . our predictions are governed by the quasi ir - fp and hence are stable against varying the composite scale . the predicted values would not be changed so much , even if the region of the tmac scale got wider than our estimate for some reason . why is the value of eq . ( [ mt - fin ] ) significantly smaller than that of the original tmsm in four dimensions which predicted @xmath205 gev ? the value of the top yukawa coupling at the quasi ir - fp is @xmath245 . thanks to the suppression factor @xmath40 in @xmath34 , the mass of the top quark decreases as the number of dimensions increases . the predicted higgs mass eq . ( [ mh - fin ] ) is substantially larger than that of typical supersymmetric models , while it is distinctively small as a dynamical ewsb scenario . we are thus able to distinguish the present model from typical supersymmetric or dynamical ewsb scenarios simply through the higgs mass observation . we also note that the higgs boson in this mass range will be immediately discovered in @xmath8 once the lhc starts . the upper limit of @xmath29 from radiative corrections in the sm is @xmath238 gev at 95% cl @xcite and the predicted value eq . ( [ mh - fin ] ) is below this upper limit , however . it is thus difficult to discriminate the higgs in the present model from that of the sm only from its mass . we definitely need experimental information other than @xmath29 in order to establish the present model . many issues remain to be explored : \1 ) our results on the tmac scale are sensitive to the value of @xmath17 . although we used the reference value of @xmath17 in the approach of the ladder sd equation neglecting the effect of the compactification , it would be more preferable if we can determine @xmath17 more reliably . for such a purpose , we should take into account effects of the compactification scale @xmath28 which turned out not so small compared with the tmac scale @xmath22 in our analysis . we also need running of bulk gauge couplings beyond one - loop perturbation . \2 ) we incorporated only one composite higgs doublet into rges , assuming other possible bound states such as vector / axial - vector bosons are irrelevant . in order to justify the assumption , we need to solve bound state problems in the bulk gauge theories . once such a composite scalar exists , it should be a tightly bound state formed by strong short distance dynamics with large anomalous dimension . such a system is expected to resemble the gauged nambu - jona - lasinio ( gnjl ) model where the compositeness condition is explicitly formulated . actually , as it happened in the 4-dimensional case @xcite , the pure gauge dynamics strong at short distance in our case can also induce strong four - fermion interactions which may become relevant operators due to large anomalous dimensions , @xmath246 @xcite . we will report elsewhere the phase structure of the bulk gnjl model @xcite . \3 ) there are potential constraints on our model from precision electroweak measurements . the summation of kk modes below the cutoff @xmath11 contributes to @xmath247 as @xmath248 @xcite . in our case with @xmath30 , @xmath249 for @xmath1 , we thus need to take @xmath250 , which may be subtle about the fine tuning . more involved estimate will be done elsewhere . \4 ) masses of other quarks and leptons have not been dealt with in this paper . in the original tmsm , these masses are descended from the top condensate through ad hoc flavor - breaking four - fermion interactions @xcite . the origin of such four - fermion interactions will be highly hoped for in the present scenario . \5 ) our scenario crucially relies on the short distance strong dynamics around the composite scale . we thus need a better - controlled theory in the uv - region . it would be interesting to study a deconstructed / latticized version @xcite of our model . the work is supported in part by the jsps grant - in - aid for the scientific research ( b)(2 ) 14340072 ( k.y . and m.t . ) and by krf pbrg 2002 - 070-c00022 ( m.h . ) . the torus compactification of extra dimensions leaves vector - like zero - modes in the 4-dimensional space - time , even if we start with a chiral gauge theory in the bulk . we thus need to compactify the extra dimensions to an orbifold in order to obtain the conventional sm particles as zero modes . an example of such a compactification was explicitly constructed in ref.@xcite based on the @xmath252 orbifold for @xmath253 ( @xmath254 even ) dimensions . in this appendix , we discuss the massive kk spectrum in the orbifold compactification of ref.@xcite . let us start with the 6-dimensional case ( @xmath253 , @xmath256 ) . the 6-dimensional space - time is decomposed into conventional and extra dimensions , @xmath257 with @xmath258 , @xmath259 and @xmath260 . we assume the compactification radius @xmath261 and the fields at @xmath262 and @xmath263 are identified with the field at @xmath264 . we thus impose the periodic boundary conditions , @xmath265 for a gauge field and @xmath266 for a fermion . the @xmath267 identification of the orbifold @xmath268 leads to the orbifold boundary conditions ( bcs ) , @xmath269 here @xmath270 and @xmath271 are chirality matrices in four- and six - dimensions , respectively to that in ref . ] , @xmath272 it is easy to show that the gauge - vector field @xmath273 is decomposed into its kk - modes , @xmath274 } \cos\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1>0 } a_{\mu , 0c}^{[n_1 ] } \cos\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^6}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1 , n_2 > 0 } a_{\mu , cc}^{[n_1 , n_2 ] } \cos\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \cos\left(\dfrac{n_2 y^6}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1 , n_2 > 0 } a_{\mu , ss}^{[n_1 , n_2 ] } \sin\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \sin\left(\dfrac{n_2 y^6}{r}\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath275 , @xmath276 being positive integers , where we omitted the arguments for the kk - modes at @xmath277 , except for the zero mode @xmath278 . we note that the orbifold condition eq.([eq : z2_gauge_vector ] ) leads to @xmath279 } = a_{\mu , s0}^{[n_1 ] } = a_{\mu , cs}^{[n_1,n_2 ] } = a_{\mu , sc}^{[n_1,n_2 ] } = 0\ ] ] in the kk - spectrum . in order to investigate the kk - spectrum , we define sets of the kk - fields , @xmath280 } & \equiv & \ { a_{\mu , c0}^{[n_1]}(x ) , \ , a_{\mu , 0c}^{[n_1]}(x ) \ } , \\ { \cal a}_\mu^{\delta=2 , [ n_1,n_2 ] } & \equiv & \ { a_{\mu , cc}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) , \ , a_{\mu , ss}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq : gauge_vector_set ] the masses of these kk - states are given by @xmath281 for a state contained in @xmath282}$ ] and @xmath283 for @xmath284}$ ] . using the number of elements of these sets , @xmath285 } = { \cal n}_g^{\delta=2,[n_1,n_2 ] } = 2,\ ] ] the number of kk - modes of gauge bosons @xmath273 with @xmath286 is written as @xmath287 } \cdot n_1(\mu ) + { \cal n}_g^{\delta=2,[n_1,n_2 ] } \cdot n_2(\mu)\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath255 dimensions , where @xmath288 and @xmath289 are given by @xmath290 respectively . it is straightforward to perform similar analysis for the gauge scalar @xmath291 . since the zero - mode of @xmath291 is projected out from the kk - spectrum due to the orbifold bc ( [ eq : z2_gauge_scalar ] ) , the kk decomposition of @xmath291 is given by @xmath292 } \sin\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1>0 } a_{m , 0s}^{[n_1 ] } \sin\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^6}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1 , n_2 > 0 } a_{m , cs}^{[n_1 , n_2 ] } \cos\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \sin\left(\dfrac{n_2 y^6}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1 , n_2 > 0 } a_{m , sc}^{[n_1 , n_2 ] } \sin\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \cos\left(\dfrac{n_2 y^6}{r}\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] sets of the kk - fields are defined as @xmath293 } & \equiv & \ { a_{m , s0}^{[n_1]}(x ) , \ , a_{m , 0s}^{[n_1]}(x ) \ } , \\ { \cal a}_m^{\delta=2 , [ n_1,n_2 ] } & \equiv & \ { a_{m , cs}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) , \ , a_{m , sc}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) \}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in a similar manner to eqs.([eq : gauge_vector_set ] ) , where the number of elements are given by @xmath294 } = { \cal n}_{gs}^{\delta=2,[n_1,n_2 ] } = 2.\ ] ] we can now easily count the number of kk - modes of the gauge scalars @xmath291 , @xmath295 } \cdot n_1(\mu ) + { \cal n}_{gs}^{\delta=2,[n_1,n_2 ] } \cdot n_2(\mu).\end{aligned}\ ] ] we next consider the kk spectrum of the bulk chiral fermion @xmath296 , @xmath297 in @xmath255 dimensions , which has obviously 4-components . the orbifold bc ( [ eq : z2_fermion ] ) reads @xmath298 the kk expansion of @xmath299 is thus given by @xmath300}(x ) \cos\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1>0 } \psi_{+,0c}^{[n_1]}(x ) \cos\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^6}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1,n_2>0 } \psi_{+,cc}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) \cos\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \cos\left(\dfrac{n_2 y^6}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1,n_2>0 } \psi_{+,ss}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) \sin\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \sin\left(\dfrac{n_2 y^6}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1>0 } \psi_{+,s0}^{[n_1]}(x ) \sin\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1>0 } \psi_{+,0s}^{[n_1]}(x ) \sin\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^6}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1,n_2>0 } \psi_{+,cs}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) \cos\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \sin\left(\dfrac{n_2 y^6}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{n_1,n_2>0 } \psi_{+,sc}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) \sin\left(\dfrac{n_1 y^5}{r}\right ) \cos\left(\dfrac{n_2 y^6}{r}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & \end{aligned}\ ] ] with 2-component fermions . in particular , we find that the zero - mode is right - handed under the 4-dimensional chiral rotation , thanks to eq.([eq : z2_fermion ] ) , @xmath301 other kk modes include both of right , and left - handed fermions . we thus define sets of kk - fields , @xmath302 } & \equiv & \ { \psi_{+,c0}^{[n_1]}(x ) , \ , \psi_{+,0c}^{[n_1]}(x ) \ } , \\ \psi_{+,r}^{\delta=2 , [ n_1,n_2 ] } & \equiv & \ { \psi_{+,cc}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) , \ , \psi_{+,ss}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) \ } , \\ \psi_{+,l}^{\delta=2 , [ n_1 ] } & \equiv & \ { \psi_{+,s0}^{[n_1]}(x ) , \ , \psi_{+,0s}^{[n_1]}(x ) \ } , \\ \psi_{+,l}^{\delta=2 , [ n_1,n_2 ] } & \equiv & \ { \psi_{+,cs}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) , \ , \psi_{+,sc}^{[n_1,n_2]}(x ) \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the kk fields in @xmath303}$ ] and @xmath304}$ ] ( @xmath305}$ ] and @xmath306}$ ] ) are right - handed ( left - handed ) . these kk - modes acquire their dirac masses among @xmath303}$ ] and @xmath305}$ ] ( @xmath304}$ ] and @xmath306}$ ] ) in four dimensions . the number of these kk dirac fermions is therefore given by @xmath307 } \cdot n_1(\mu ) + { \cal n}_f^{\delta=2,[n_1,n_2 ] } \cdot n_2(\mu ) \label{nkk_f}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath308 } & \equiv & \ # \psi_{+,r}^{2,[n_1 ] } \nonumber\\ & = & \ # \psi_{+,l}^{2,[n_1 ] } = 2 , \\ { \cal n}_f^{\delta=2,[n_1,n_2 ] } & \equiv & \ # \psi_{+,r}^{2,[n_1,n_2 ] } \nonumber\\ & = & \ # \psi_{+,l}^{2,[n_1,n_2 ] } = 2 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] we note @xmath309 for @xmath255 dimensions . it is straightforward to apply the above procedure to the bulk chiral fermion @xmath310 , @xmath311 we easily find that the zero mode of @xmath310 is left - handed . we thus identify the right[left]-handed fermions in the sm to @xmath296 [ @xmath310 ] . the number of the kk dirac fermions for @xmath313 is equal to eq . ( [ nkk_f ] ) . for the ( composite ) higgs field , we take the same @xmath267 identification as eq . ( [ eq : z2_gauge_vector ] ) . this always leads to @xmath314 for the number of kk modes of the higgs field . hereafter , we abbreviate @xmath59 in the arguments of @xmath315 , @xmath316 , when the number of @xmath59 is obvious . let us next turn to the 8-dimensional case ( @xmath253 , @xmath318 ) , @xmath319 we impose the orbifold bcs : @xmath320 and @xmath321 with @xmath322 noting the relations , @xmath323 we can easily see that the zero - mode of the 8-dimensional bulk chiral fermion @xmath299 is chiral under the 4-dimensional chiral symmetry . the bulk gauge field is decomposed into its kk - modes in a similar manner with the @xmath255 case . we obtain @xmath324_1 } = } \nonumber\\ & & \ { a_{\mu , c000}^{[n]_1 } , \ , a_{\mu , 0c00}^{[n]_1 } , \ , a_{\mu , 00c0}^{[n]_1 } , \ , a_{\mu , 000c}^{[n]_1 } \ } , \\ \lefteqn { { \cal a}_\mu^{\delta=4,[n]_2 } = } \nonumber\\ & & \ { a_{\mu , cc00}^{[n]_2 } , \ , a_{\mu , 00cc}^{[n]_2 } , \ , a_{\mu , ss00}^{[n]_2 } , \ , a_{\mu , 00ss}^{[n]_2 } , \ , \nonumber\\ & & \quad a_{\mu , c0c0}^{[n]_2 } , \ , a_{\mu , c00c}^{[n]_2 } , \ , a_{\mu , 0cc0}^{[n]_2 } , \ , a_{\mu , 0c0c}^{[n]_2 } \ } , \\ \lefteqn { { \cal a}_\mu^{\delta=4,[n]_3 } = } \nonumber\\ & & \ { a_{\mu , ccc0}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{\mu , cc0c}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{\mu , c0cc}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{\mu , 0ccc}^{[n]_3 } , \ , \nonumber\\ & & \quad a_{\mu , ssc0}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{\mu , ss0c}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{\mu , c0ss}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{\mu , 0css}^{[n]_3 } \ } , \\ \lefteqn { { \cal a}_\mu^{\delta=4,[n]_4 } = } \nonumber\\ & & \ { a_{\mu , cccc}^{[n]_4 } , \ , a_{\mu , ccss}^{[n]_4 } , \ , a_{\mu , sscc}^{[n]_4 } , \ , a_{\mu , ssss}^{[n]_4 } \},\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the kk - expansion of @xmath273 . here @xmath325_i$ ] stands for @xmath326_1\equiv [ n_1 ] , \quad [ n]_2\equiv [ n_1 , n_2 ] , \quad [ n]_3\equiv [ n_1 , n_2 , n_3 ] , \cdots.\ ] ] we thus find @xmath327_1 } & = & 4 , \quad { \cal n}_g^{\delta=4,[n]_2 } = 8 , \\ { \cal n}_g^{\delta=4,[n]_3 } & = & 8 , \quad { \cal n}_g^{\delta=4,[n]_4 } = 4.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath291 ( @xmath260 ) we obtain @xmath328_1 } = } \nonumber\\ & & \ { a_{m , s000}^{[n]_1 } , \ , a_{m , 0s00}^{[n]_1 } \ } , \\ \lefteqn { { \cal a}_m^{\delta=4,[n]_2 } = } \nonumber\\ & & \ { a_{m , sc00}^{[n]_2 } , \ , a_{m , cs00}^{[n]_2 } , \ , a_{m , s0c0}^{[n]_2 } , \ , a_{m , s00c}^{[n]_2 } , \ , \nonumber\\ & & \quad a_{m , 0sc0}^{[n]_2 } , \ , a_{\mu , 0s0c}^{[n]_2 } \ } , \\ \lefteqn { { \cal a}_m^{\delta=4,[n]_3 } = } \nonumber\\ & & \ { a_{m , scc0}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{m , sc0c}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{m , csc0}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{m , cs0c}^{[n]_3 } , \ , \nonumber\\ & & \quad a_{m , s0cc}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{m , 0scc}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{m , s0ss}^{[n]_3 } , \ , a_{m , 0sss}^{[n]_3 } \ } , \\ \lefteqn { { \cal a}_m^{\delta=4,[n]_4 } = } \nonumber\\ & & \ { a_{m , sccc}^{[n]_4 } , \ , a_{m , cscc}^{[n]_4 } , \ , a_{m , scss}^{[n]_4 } , \ , a_{m , csss}^{[n]_4 } \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is straightforward to obtain similar expression for @xmath329 ( @xmath330 ) . we find @xmath331_1 } & = & 2 , \quad { \cal n}_{gs}^{\delta=4,[n]_2 } = 6 , \\ { \cal n}_{gs}^{\delta=4,[n]_3 } & = & 8 , \quad { \cal n}_{gs}^{\delta=4,[n]_4 } = 4.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the numbers of kk - modes of gauge fields and gauge scalars are given by @xmath332_k } \cdot n_k(\mu ) , \\ { n_{\rm kk}^{gs}}(\mu ; \delta=4 ) & = & \sum_{k=1}^4 { \cal n}_{gs}^{4,[n]_k } \cdot n_k(\mu ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath333 s are defined in eq.([eq : n1n2 ] ) for @xmath334 and @xmath335 for @xmath336 . for a bulk chiral fermion @xmath299 in @xmath253 ( @xmath318 ) dimensions , we find @xmath337_1 } & \equiv & \ # \psi_{+,r}^{4,[n]_1 } \nonumber\\ & = & \ # \psi_{+,l}^{4,[n]_1 } = 4 , \\ { \cal n}_f^{\delta=4,[n]_2 } & \equiv & \ # \psi_{+,r}^{4,[n]_2 } \nonumber\\ & = & \ # \psi_{+,l}^{4,[n]_2 } = 12 , \\ { \cal n}_f^{\delta=4,[n]_3 } & \equiv & \ # \psi_{+,r}^{4,[n]_3 } \nonumber\\ & = & \ # \psi_{+,l}^{4,[n]_3 } = 16 , \\ { \cal n}_f^{\delta=4,[n]_4 } & \equiv & \ # \psi_{+,r}^{4,[n]_4 } \nonumber\\ & = & \ # \psi_{+,l}^{4,[n]_4 } = 8.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the number of 4-component dirac kk - modes is then given by @xmath338_k } \cdot n_k(\mu).\ ] ] here , we note @xmath339 and @xmath340 in our orbifold compactification , because of @xmath341_2 } \ne { \cal n}_{gs}^{\delta=4,[n]_2 } , \quad { \cal n}_g^{\delta=4,[n]_2 } \ne \frac{1}{2}{\cal n}_f^{\delta=4,[n]_2}.\ ] ] the differences between them impact on the running of @xmath342 around @xmath343 . the bulk qcd coupling in eq . ( [ rge_ed2 ] ) grows slowly , comparing with that in the approximation ( [ rge_ed3 ] ) . as a result , the region of the tmac scale is slightly suppressed , if the identical value for @xmath344 at the compactification scale @xmath28 is used in both rges . ( see fig . [ fig - tmac-8d](a ) and fig . 2 in ref . ) we also comment on the relation @xmath345 in our orbifold compactification . it is now trivial task to extend the analysis to @xmath253 ( @xmath347 ) dimensions . the number of the kk - modes for @xmath347 is given by @xmath348_k } \cdot n_k(\mu)\ ] ] for @xmath65 . we summarize the number of elements among sets of kk - fields in tables [ tab1 ] , [ tab2 ] and [ tab3 ] for @xmath349 , respectively . .@xmath127_k}$ ] for @xmath256 ( @xmath2 ) . the column shows @xmath127_k}$ ] for @xmath350 ( gauge bosons ) , @xmath351 ( gauge scalars ) , @xmath352 ( dirac fermions ) , and @xmath353 ( higgs ) . [ tab1 ] [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] we may take yet another choice for evaluating the vacuum polarization function , instead of the truncated kk effective theory @xcite . in this appendix , we consider the proper - time ( pt ) scheme as well as the @xmath13-scheme in the truncated kk effective theory . the effective charge is defined by @xmath354 where @xmath355 is the bare coupling and @xmath356 denotes the vacuum polarization function , @xmath357 the effective charge is closely related to physical quantities such as scattering amplitudes . through the effective coupling , we determine the relation of gauge couplings calculated in the two regularization schemes . we consider bulk gauge theories with bulk fermions and bulk scalars . in four dimensions , it is straightforward to calculate the contributions of fermions and scalars : @xmath358 for @xmath117 pieces of dirac fermions of the fundamental representation , and @xmath359 for @xmath360 pieces of complex scalars of the fundamental representation , respectively , where @xmath116 and @xmath361 is the mass of fermions and scalars . for bulk fields , we perform to sum over their kk modes . on the other hand , it is slightly complicated to compute the loop correction of massive gauge bosons within the 4-dimensional theory . instead higgsing gauge theory in four dimensions , we directly calculate the loop correction in extra dimensions . in order to keep the gauge invariance , we use the background field method with the feynman gauge . taking effects of compactification into account , we replace the loop integral in @xmath42 dimensions to @xmath362 with the @xmath42-dimensional ( dimensionful ) coupling @xmath71 and the 4-dimensional one @xmath70 . we here decomposed the loop momentum @xmath363 to the 4-dimensional one @xmath364 and the discrete one @xmath365 in extra @xmath59 dimensions , @xmath366 where masses of kk modes @xmath367 are given by @xmath368 of course , the external momentum @xmath369 does not have the extra momentum , @xmath370 . we thus obtain contributions of gauge bosons and gauge scalars as @xmath371 , \label{pibare - g}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath372 respectively . we separate the vacuum polarization function to the contributions of zero modes @xmath373 , which corresponds to the sm corrections , and kk modes @xmath374 : @xmath375 with @xmath376 and @xmath377 we briefly review the results in refs . @xcite . in the truncated kk effective theory , we calculate the vacuum polarization function by using the dimensional regularization ( taking the loop integral to @xmath378 instead of @xmath379 ) : @xmath380 , \\ ( 4\pi)^2 \pi_{gs}^{\overline{\rm ms}}(-q^2;m^2 ) & = & - \frac{\delta}{2 } \ , i_s(-q^2;m^2 ) , \\ ( 4\pi)^2 \pi_f^{\overline{\rm ms}}(-q^2;m^2 ) & = & - 8 t_r \ , n_f \ , i_f(-q^2;m^2 ) , \\ ( 4\pi)^2 \pi_h^{\overline{\rm ms}}(-q^2;m^2 ) & = & - t_r \ , n_h \ , i_s(-q^2;m^2 ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we defined @xmath381^{-\epsilon } , \\ i_s(-q^2;m^2 ) & \equiv & \frac{\gamma(\epsilon)}{(4\pi)^{-\epsilon } } \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , ( 2x-1)^2 \left[\,m^2-x(1-x)q^2\,\right]^{-\epsilon},\\ i_f(-q^2;m^2 ) & \equiv & \frac{\gamma(\epsilon)}{(4\pi)^{-\epsilon } } \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , x(1-x ) \left[\,m^2-x(1-x)q^2\,\right]^{-\epsilon } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we renormalize the bare coupling in the @xmath13-scheme : @xmath382 with the rge coefficient of zero mode @xmath383 , @xmath384 and that of kk modes @xmath385 , @xmath386 where @xmath387 denote the total number of kk modes for gauge bosons , gauge scalars , fermions , and scalars ( composite higgs fields ) below @xmath51 , respectively . we then find the effective coupling in the truncated effective theory based on the @xmath13-scheme , @xmath388 with @xmath389 where we defined @xmath390 + \frac{\delta}{2 } \ i_s^r(-q^2;m^2 ) \nonumber \\ & & \quad + 8 t_r \ , n_f \ , i_f^r(-q^2;m^2 ) + t_r \ , n_h \ , i_s^r(-q^2;m^2 ) , \\ i_g^r ( -q^2;m^2 ) & \equiv & \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ln \left(\,1-x(1-x)\frac{q^2}{m^2}\,\right ) , \\ i_s^r ( -q^2;m^2 ) & \equiv & \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , ( 2x-1)^2 \ln \left(\,1-x(1-x)\frac{q^2}{m^2}\,\right ) , \\ i_f^r ( -q^2;m^2 ) & \equiv & \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , x(1-x ) \ln \left(\,1-x(1-x)\frac{q^2}{m^2}\,\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] and obtained the constant term @xmath391 we identify the mass of the heaviest kk state to the cutoff @xmath11 . in the limit of @xmath392 , we easily find @xmath393 with @xmath394 where @xmath395 is replaced by @xmath396 for @xmath256 . since we can not take so large value to the cutoff @xmath11 due to the landau pole for @xmath15 , the effects of the finite parts ( [ ms - q ] ) summing over kk modes are negligible in a certain low energy scale , comparing with the finite term arising from zero modes , @xmath397 . numerically , we find the finite sums for qcd at @xmath398 , @xmath399 for @xmath128 , respectively , where we took @xmath175 tev , @xmath400 gev , @xmath401 for @xmath128 , respectively . of course , the effects of eq . ( [ ms - q ] ) get smaller for larger values of @xmath28 . at the zero momentum , the effects of finite terms via kk modes come to be completely negligible thanks to eq . ( [ ms - q ] ) . we thus identify @xmath402 to the sm value . we also find the @xmath403-function , @xmath404 we calculate the vacuum polarization function in the pt - scheme . using the trick with the pt - parameter @xmath405 , @xmath406 and performing the momentum integral , @xmath407 we can rewrite vacuum polarization functions in eqs . ( [ pibare - f ] ) , ( [ pibare - s ] ) , ( [ pibare - g ] ) , and ( [ pibare - gs ] ) as follows : @xmath408 , \\ ( 4\pi)^2 \pi_{gs}^{\rm pt}(q_e^2;m^2 ) & = & - \frac{\delta}{2 } \ , c_a \ , j_s(-q^2;m^2 ) , \\ ( 4\pi)^2 \pi_f^{\rm pt}(q_e^2;m^2 ) & = & - 8 t_r \ , n_f \ , j_f(q_e^2;m^2 ) , \\ ( 4\pi)^2 \pi_h^{\rm pt}(q_e^2;m^2 ) & = & - t_r \ , n_h \ , j_s(q_e^2;m^2 ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath409 , \\ j_s(q_e^2;m^2)&= \int_0 ^ 1 dx \int_0^\infty \frac{dt}{t } ( 2x-1)^2 \exp[-t(x(1-x)q_e^2+m^2 ) ] , \\ j_f(q_e^2;m^2)&= \int_0 ^ 1 dx \int_0^\infty \frac{dt}{t } x(1-x ) \exp[-t(x(1-x)q_e^2+m^2)],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the suffix @xmath410 denotes the euclidean momentum . since the pt - integral diverges near @xmath411 , we regularize the integral with the cutoff @xmath11 : @xmath412 we first calculate @xmath373 . performing the feynman parameter integration , we obtain @xmath413,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used the confluent hypergeometric function @xmath414 and the relation between the confluent hypergeometric function and the error function , @xmath415 here , we note the kummer s transformation , @xmath416 and the recurrence formula , @xmath417 = -\frac{1}{c}{}_1f_1(1,c+1;-t ) .\ ] ] since the behaviors of @xmath414 around @xmath418 and @xmath419 are given by @xmath420 and @xmath421 respectively , we separate the pt - integration to the singular part and finite ones : @xmath422 \nonumber \\ & & - \int_0^{\frac{r q_e^2}{4\lambda^2 } } \frac{dt}{t } \left[\,{}_1f_1(1,c ;- t)-1\,\right ] + \int_1^\infty \frac{dt}{t}{}_1f_1(1,c ;- t ) , \\ & = & -\ln \frac{r q_e^2}{4\lambda^2 } + \frac{1}{c } \int_0^{\frac{r q_e^2}{4\lambda^2 } } dt\ , { } _ 1f_1(1,1+c ;- t ) \nonumber \\ & & -\frac{1}{c } \int_0 ^ 1 dt\ , { } _ 1f_1(1,1+c ;- t ) + \int_1^\infty \frac{dt}{t}{}_1f_1(1,c ;- t ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] noting the integration of the confluent hypergeometric function , @xmath423 we find @xmath424 with @xmath425 we can read @xmath426 from the above results : @xmath427 with @xmath428 here , we note @xmath429 thanks to @xmath430 . now , we study the contributions of the kk modes . we can perform the summation over all kk states by using the jacobi @xmath125 function , @xmath431 which has the remarkable property , @xmath432 we then obtain the summation of the vacuum polarization via kk modes : @xmath433\exp[-tx(1-x)q_e^2]k_g(t ) \nonumber \\ & & - \frac{\delta}{2 } \cdot \frac{c_a}{(4\pi)^2 } \int_0 ^ 1dx\int_{r\lambda^{-2}}^\infty\frac{dt}{t}\ , ( 2x-1)^2 \exp[-tx(1-x)q_e^2]k_{gs}(t ) \nonumber \\ & & - 8t_r \cdot \frac{n_f}{(4\pi)^2 } \int_0 ^ 1dx\int_{r\lambda^{-2}}^\infty\frac{dt}{t}\ , x(1-x ) \exp[-tx(1-x)q_e^2]k_f ( t ) \nonumber \\ & & - t_r \cdot \frac{n_h}{(4\pi)^2 } \int_0 ^ 1dx\int_{r\lambda^{-2}}^\infty\frac{dt}{t}\ , ( 2x-1)^2 \exp[-tx(1-x)q_e^2]k_h ( t ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we defined @xmath124_1 } \left[\,\frac{1}{2}(\vartheta_3 - 1)\,\right ] + { \cal n}_i^{\delta,[n]_2 } \left[\,\frac{1}{2}(\vartheta_3 - 1)\,\right]^2 + { \cal n}_i^{\delta,[n]_3 } \left[\,\frac{1}{2}(\vartheta_3 - 1)\,\right]^3 + \cdots\ ] ] with @xmath65 and @xmath126 . the values of @xmath127_k}$ ] are given in table [ tab1][tab3 ] . combining with eq . ( [ pt0 ] ) , we obtain the effective coupling as @xmath434 with @xmath435 where we neglected the corrections of the order of @xmath436 . in the limit of @xmath437 , we find @xmath438 where @xmath395 is replaced by @xmath396 for @xmath256 . we regard the bare coupling @xmath355 as a quantity defined at the cutoff @xmath11 : @xmath439 since the effective coupling @xmath106 should not depend on the cutoff @xmath11 at the zero momentum @xmath440 , we can deduce the `` @xmath403-function '' for @xmath149 : @xmath441 with the `` rge coefficient '' @xmath442 , @xmath443 matching the rge for the @xmath13-coupling with @xmath444 in the limit of @xmath445 , we easily find @xcite @xmath446 we identify the effective coupling at the zero momentum calculated in the pt - scheme to the sm one with @xmath447 : @xmath448 although the coefficients of @xmath449 in the @xmath13-scheme and the pt - scheme are accidentally identical in @xmath451 , they have generally the regularization dependence and their difference is the factor @xmath452 in eq . ( [ pt - q2 ] ) . y. nambu , enrico fermi institute report no . 89 - 08 , 1989 ; in _ proceedings of the 1989 workshop on dynamical symmetry breaking _ , edited by t. muta and k. yamawaki ( nagoya university , nagoya , japan , 1990 ) . k. yamawaki , in _ proceedings of the 14th symposium on theoretical physics `` dynamical symmetry breaking and effective field theory '' _ , cheju island , korea , july 21 - 26 , 1995 , ed . j. e. kim ( minumsa pub . co. , korea , 1996 ) p.43 - 86 , [ arxiv : hep - ph/9603293 ] . c. t. hill , and e. h. simmons , phys . * 381 * , 235 ( 2003 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0203079 ] . n. arkani - hamed , h. c. cheng , b. a. dobrescu and l. j. hall , phys . rev . * d62 * , 096006 ( 2000 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0006238 ] . m. hashimoto , m. tanabashi and k. yamawaki , phys . rev . * d64 * , 056003 ( 2001 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0010260 ] . k. agashe , jhep * 0105 * , 017 ( 2001 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0012182 ] . v. gusynin , m. hashimoto , m. tanabashi and k. yamawaki , phys . rev . * d65 * , 116008 ( 2002 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0201106 ] . h. abe , k. fukazawa , and t. inagaki , prog . * 107 * , 1047 ( 2002 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0107125 ] ; h. abe , and t. inagaki , phys . rev . * d66 * , 085001 ( 2002 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0206282 ] . s. raby , s. dimopoulos and l. susskind , nucl . b169 * , 373 ( 1980 ) . m. hashimoto , m. tanabashi , and k. yamawaki , in _ proceedings of the 2002 international workshop on strong coupling gauge theories and effective field theories ( scgt 02 ) _ , nagoya , japan , dec 10 - 13 , 2002 , ed . m. harada , y. kikukawa , and k. yamawaki ( world scientific pub . co. , singapore 2003 ) , p.291297 , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0304109 ] . a. manohar and h. georgi , nucl . b234 * , 189 ( 1984 ) . b. a. dobrescu and c. t. hill , phys . lett . * 81 * , 2634 ( 1998 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/9712319 ] ; r. s. chivukula , b. a. dobrescu , h. georgi and c. t. hill , phys . * d59 * , 075003 ( 1999 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/9809470 ] . see also h - j . he , c. t. hill and t. m. p. tait , phys . rev . * d65 * , 055006 ( 2002 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0108041 ] . h. georgi , e. h. simmons , and a. g. cohen , phys . b236 * , 183 ( 1990 ) ; e. h. simmons , phys . rev . * d42 * , 2933 ( 1990 ) ; t. kugo , and m. g. mitchard , phys . lett . * b282 * , 162 ( 1992 ) . b. pendleton and g. g. ross , phys . b98 * , 291 ( 1981 ) . w. a. bardeen , c. n. leung and s. t. love , phys . lett . * 56 * , 1230 ( 1986 ) ; c. n. leung , s. t. love and w. a. bardeen , nucl . b * 273 * , 649 ( 1986 ) . kondo , s. shuto and k. yamawaki , mod . . lett . * a6 * , 3385 ( 1991 ) . p. nath and m. yamaguchi , phys * d60 * , 116004 ( 1999 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/9902323 ] . n. arkani - hamed , a. g. cohen and h. georgi , phys . lett . * 86 * , 4757 ( 2001 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/0104005 ] ; c. t. hill , s. pokorski and j. wang , phys . rev . * d64 * , 105005 ( 2001 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/0104035 ] .

we perform the most attractive channel ( mac ) analysis in the top mode standard model with tev - scale extra dimensions , where the standard model gauge bosons and the third generation of quarks and leptons are put in @xmath0 dimensions . in such a model , bulk gauge couplings rapidly grow in the ultraviolet region . in order to make the scenario viable , only the attractive force of the top condensate should exceed the critical coupling , while other channels such as the bottom and tau condensates should not . we then find that the top condensate can be the mac for @xmath1 , whereas the tau condensation is favored for @xmath2 . the analysis for @xmath3 strongly depends on the regularization scheme . we predict masses of the top @xmath4 and the higgs @xmath5 , @xmath6 gev and @xmath7 gev for @xmath1 , based on the renormalization group for the top yukawa and higgs quartic couplings with the compositeness conditions at the scale where the bulk top condenses . the higgs boson in such a characteristic mass range will be immediately discovered in @xmath8 once the lhc starts .

astro-ph9906376

the success of symplectic integration algorithms ( ) as tools for the numerical solution of hamiltonian systems illustrates the importance of numerical algorithms that inherit the fundamental physical constraints of the systems to which they are applied ( `` geometric integrators '' ) . time - reversal symmetry plays a central role in physics ( e.g. , davies 1974 ) . to define reversibility formally and without reference to coordinates , let @xmath0 denote the state of the system governed by the differential equations = f(x ) . [ eq : basicde ] let @xmath1 be an involution , i.e. an operator such that @xmath2 . the system ( [ eq : basicde ] ) is @xmath1-reversible if @xmath1 reverses the direction of time , that is , if = -f(tx ) . in standard phase space @xmath3 and @xmath4 . the trajectory of the system governed by the differential equations ( [ eq : basicde ] ) is defined by a map @xmath5 such that a system located at @xmath0 at time 0 is found at @xmath6 at time @xmath7 ; by definition @xmath8 . then , @xmath1-reversibility implies that g_ttg_t = t tg_t = g_t^-1t = g_-tt . reversible systems may or may not be hamiltonian . however , the general features of motion in reversible and hamiltonian systems show many similarities , including the existence of families of kam tori ( e.g. , moser 1973 ; arnold 1984 ; roberts & quispel 1992 ) . these considerations motivate us to examine reversible integration algorithms ( ) . a one - step numerical integration algorithm with timestep @xmath9 is defined by an operator @xmath10 that is intended to be a close approximation to @xmath11 , and the algorithm is an if when it is applied to a reversible system _ note that in contrast to @xmath5 , @xmath12 is not necessarily equal to @xmath13 . let us first briefly review ; for more detail see channell & scovel ( 1990 ) , yoshida ( 1993 ) , marsden et al . ( 1996 ) , and sanz - serna & calvo ( 1994 ) . the standard example of a hamiltonian system is motion in a conservative potential ( this is also reversible ) . the hamiltonian is h(,)=^2+u ( ) [ eq : sepham ] and the equations of motion are = , = -u , or = -u . [ eq : second ] the most popular for such systems is the leapfrog or verlet algorithm ( e.g. , hockney & eastwood 1981 ) . this is a map from the phase - space coordinates @xmath14 at time @xmath15 to coordinates @xmath16 at time @xmath17 , defined by =_n+h_n , _ n+1=_n - hu( ) , _ n+1=+h_n+1 . leapfrog is an explicit second - order method ( i.e. the one - step error is o@xmath18 ) , but higher - order explicit can be constructed by concatenating leapfrog steps of different sizes , including backwards steps . leapfrog can be generalized to any separable hamiltonian of the form @xmath19 where each @xmath20 is integrable . for general hamiltonians , can be constructed by two methods . the first is based on expanding the scalar generating functions for the symplectic transformation @xmath21 in powers of @xmath9 ( kang 1986 ; channell & scovel 1990 ) . the simplest example is the first - order _ n+1=_n+hh(_n,_n+1)_n+1 , _ n+1=_n - hh(_n,_n+1)_n , which is implicit in general but explicit for hamiltonians of the form ( [ eq : sepham ] ) . the second approach is to construct symplectic implicit runge - kutta algorithms . for the differential equation ( [ eq : basicde ] ) , the @xmath22-stage runge - kutta method is defined by ( e.g. , ralston & rabinowitz 1978 ) k_i = f(x_n+h_j=1^sa_ijk_j),x_n+1=x_n+h_i=1^s b_jk_j . [ eq : rkimp ] runge - kutta methods are symplectic if they satisfy a simple algebraic test ( sanz - serna & calvo 1994 ) b_ia_ij+b_ja_ji - b_ib_j=0 , 1i , j s. [ eq : criterion ] on setting @xmath23 in ( [ eq : criterion ] ) , it is evident that all symplectic runge - kutta methods are necessarily implicit . the best known examples are the gauss - legendre runge - kutta methods ( e.g. , sanz - serna & calvo 1994 ) . the simplest can be written x_n+1=x_n+hf , [ eq : midptt ] which is the second - order implicit midpoint method . a symplectic fourth - order two - stage runge - kutta method is given by a_11=a_22= , a_12=- , a_21=+ , b_1=b_2=. [ eq : rk ] more generally , the gauss - legendre runge - kutta method is the unique @xmath22-stage method with order @xmath24 , and this method is always symplectic . these attractive features are offset by the computational cost of solving the implicit equations ( [ eq : rkimp ] ) . a limitation of is that they are difficult to generalize to variable timesteps . when a standard variable timestep prescription is applied to an , its performance is no better than that of non - symplectic integrators . the reason is simply that the mapping @xmath25 is usually not symplectic even when @xmath26 is . this is a serious problem , since most applications benefit from a variable timestep . one way to introduce variable timestep is by extending the phase space ( mikkola 1997 ) . suppose we wish to use a timestep @xmath27 . we define an extended phase space @xmath28 by @xmath29 and @xmath30 , where @xmath7 is time and @xmath31 is energy . we then define a new hamiltonian ( , ) = g ( , ) . the equations of motion for the hamiltonian @xmath32 in the extended phase space with fictitious time @xmath33 are the same as the equations of motion for the hamiltonian @xmath34 in the original phase space , supplemented by the condition @xmath35 . we may now integrate the hamiltonian @xmath32 using an with fixed timestep @xmath36 , which corresponds to @xmath37 . a limitation of this approach is that the hamiltonian @xmath32 is generally not separable , so that leapfrog and its generalizations can not be applied . several well - known one - step second - order algorithms for the differential equation ( [ eq : basicde ] ) are : for example , the implicit midpoint method ( eq . [ eq : midptt ] ) , the trapezoidal method , x_n+1=x_n+h , [ eq : trapp ] and the explicit midpoint method , x_n+2=x_n+hf(x_n+1 ) . [ eq : expmidpt ] some are also when they are applied to reversible hamiltonians . leapfrog and its generalizations are reversible . a reversible version of leapfrog with variable timestep @xmath27 is given by ( huang & leimkuhler 1997 ; calvo et al . 1998 ) @xmath38 quinn et al . ( 1997 ) describe a closely related algorithm based on a discrete set of timesteps that depend only on @xmath39 or @xmath40 and are separated by factors of two . a different approach to constructing is to modify non - reversible integration algorithms . for example , the following two operators are reversible even if @xmath10 is not : _ ^ -1 t , ( 1+t_ht)^-1(1+_h ) ; if we write @xmath41 then both of these operators are equal to @xmath42 to first order in @xmath9 . hut et al . ( 1997 ) describe numerical experiments with the second of these operators , calling it a `` time - symmetrization meta - algorithm '' since it can be applied to any one - step numerical integration algorithm . reversible algorithms remain reversible with a variable timestep so long as the timestep is determined symmetrically by the location of the system at the start and end of the step , e.g. @xmath43 $ ] ( hut et al . 1995 ) . special second - order differential equations of the form = f(x ) [ eq : fff ] are reversible , and so can profitably be integrated using . a useful source of high - order is linear multistep methods ( e.g. , henrici 1962 ; gear 1971 ; lambert 1973 ) , which have the form _ j=0^k ( a_k - jx_n - j - h^2b_k - jf_j)=0 , where @xmath44 , @xmath45 . we may assume without loss of generality that @xmath46 . the method is explicit if @xmath47 and otherwise implicit . linear multisteps include the classic strmer ( explicit ) and cowell ( implicit ) methods , which are characterized by @xmath46 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 for @xmath51 . it is easy to show that the requirement for reversibility is that @xmath52 and @xmath53 where @xmath54 ; thus the strmer and cowell methods are generally not reversible . multistep are discussed by lambert & watson ( 1976 ) , quinlan & tremaine ( 1990 ) , and fukushima ( 1998 , 1999 ) . in general , their performance over long time intervals on reversible dynamical systems is much better than strmer - cowell methods , although for occasional unfortunate choices of timestep their performance is ruined by timestep resonances ( quinlan 1999 ) . systems of first - order differential equations such as ( [ eq : basicde ] ) can be integrated by linear multistep methods of the form _ j=0^k(_k - jx_n - j - h_k - jf_n - j)=0 , [ eq : basic ] where @xmath44 , @xmath55 . we can assume without loss of generality that @xmath56 ; explicit methods have @xmath57 . these include the classic adams - bashforth ( explicit ) and adams - moulton ( implicit ) methods , which have @xmath58 and @xmath59 for @xmath51 ( e.g. , henrici 1962 ; gear 1971 ) . multistep methods for first - order differential equations are more general than multistep methods for special second - order equations , since any second - order equation can be written as a set of first - order equations . moreover , implementing variable timesteps is easy in first - order equations if we wish to use a timestep @xmath60 we introduce a fictitious time @xmath33 by the relation @xmath61 , and equation ( [ eq : basicde ] ) can be rewritten as = g(x)f(x ) , which can be integrated using unit timestep in @xmath33 . the aim of this paper is to investigate linear multistep for first - order differential equations . an important earlier investigation is that of cano & sanz - serna ( 1998 ) , who found that such methods typically possess grave numerical instabilities . we review general linear multistep methods in [ sec : intro ] , multistep in [ sec : reverse ] , together with their instabilities in [ sec : zero ] . we show in [ sec : zmm ] that it is possible to construct some linear multistep that are not subject to the cano & sanz - serna instabilities . a general discussion of stable multistep with up to 6 steps is given in [ sec : onetwo ] [ sec : fivesix ] . finally , [ sec : kep ] describes numerical examples based on integrating kepler orbits and [ sec : disc ] discusses our results . following henrici ( 1962 ) and lambert ( 1973 ) , we associate with ( [ eq : basic ] ) the linear operator l[x(t),h]=_j=0^k\{_k - jx[t+(k - j)h]- h_k - jx[t+(k - j)h]}. [ eq : linearoperator ] we can expand @xmath62 in a taylor series to obtain l[x(t),h]=_q=0^c_qh^qx^(q)(t ) , [ eq : tay ] where c_0=_l=0^k_l , c_q=1q!_l=0^k_ll^q - 1(q-1)!_l=0^k_ll^q-1,q=1,2, the order @xmath63 of the multistep is the unique integer for which @xmath64 , @xmath65 . the constant @xmath66 is known as the error constant and is a measure of the local truncation error . now define the characteristic polynomials ( ) = _ j=0^k_j^j,()= _ j=0^k_j^j . [ eq : poly ] if @xmath67 , then l[x(t),h]=e^t[(e^h)-h(e^h ) ] , which together with equation ( [ eq : tay ] ) implies ( 1+z)-(1+z)(1+z)=c_p+1z^p+1+(z^p+2 ) , [ eq : series ] where @xmath63 is the order and @xmath68 . order @xmath69 requires ( 1)=_j=0^k_j=0 , [ eq : rhoone ] and order @xmath70 requires (1)=(1 ) . [ eq : rel ] a multistep method is zero - stable if and only if the roots of @xmath71 lie inside the unit circle in the complex plane , or are on the unit circle and simple ( proofs of this are given by henrici 1962 , gear 1971 and lambert 1973 ) . zero - stability ensures that the parasitic solutions generated by the additional roots of the difference equation ( which is of order @xmath72 , while the original differential equation ( [ eq : basicde ] ) has order one ) do not grow , at least in the limit of zero timestep . we will discuss other forms of stability shortly in [ sec : zero ] . we assume that the polynomials @xmath71 and @xmath73 have no common roots other than 1 , for the following reason . suppose that @xmath74 is a common root , so that @xmath75 is a common factor . then @xmath76 , @xmath77 where @xmath78 and @xmath79 are polynomials of degree @xmath80 . then equation ( [ eq : series ] ) may be written ( 1+z)-(1+z)(1+z)=c_p+11-_0z^p+1 + ( z^p+2 ) . [ eq : seriesa ] thus @xmath81 define a @xmath82-step method with the same order and the same error constant ( @xmath83 $ ] ) as the original @xmath72-step method , and there is no obvious reason why the simpler method should not be used instead . there are @xmath84 unknown coefficients in equation ( [ eq : basic ] ) ( since @xmath56 ) , and therefore in principle these coefficients can be chosen so that the order is @xmath85 ( or @xmath86 if the method is explicit , with @xmath57 ) . however , the maximum order of a zero - stable multistep method is @xmath87 if @xmath72 is odd and @xmath88 if @xmath72 is even ( henrici 1962 ) . suppose that a trajectory @xmath89 , @xmath90 satisfies the difference equation ( [ eq : basic ] ) . the same segment of the time - reversed trajectory is given by @xmath91 , @xmath92 , where @xmath1 is the time - reversal operator and @xmath93 . we shall assume that @xmath94 and that @xmath95 . then @xmath4 and @xmath96 . in an the time - reversed trajectory should also satisfy the difference equation ( [ eq : basic ] ) , that is _ j=0^k(_k - jtx_n - k+j - h_k - jg_n - k+j)=0 . since @xmath97 , we may operate with @xmath1 to obtain _ j=0^k(_k - jx_n - k+j+h_k - jf_n - k+j)=0 , or , equivalently , _ j=0^k(_jx_n - j+h_jf_n - j)=0 . [ eq : reverse ] if ( [ eq : reverse ] ) is to be satisfied whenever ( [ eq : basic ] ) is satisfied , then we must have _ k - j = c_j,_k - j =- c_j , [ eq : cond ] where @xmath98 is a constant . applying this relation twice gives @xmath99 so @xmath54 . if @xmath100 , we shall say that the multistep method has even parity ; if @xmath101 , the parity is odd . the characteristic polynomials ( [ eq : poly ] ) now satisfy ( ) = c^k(^-1 ) , ( ) = -c^k(^-1 ) [ eq : symm ] . now let @xmath102 be the roots of @xmath71 . equation ( [ eq : symm ] ) implies that if @xmath103 is a root then so is @xmath104 . for zero - stability , the roots can not lie outside the unit circle therefore they must lie on the unit circle , and moreover they must be simple . equation ( [ eq : rhoone ] ) guarantees that @xmath105 is a root for any method with order @xmath69 . this root is simple if @xmath106 , and equation ( [ eq : rel ] ) then requires that @xmath107 for any method with order @xmath108 . however , even - parity methods have @xmath109 . therefore , even - parity methods are not zero - stable and we can restrict our attention to odd - parity methods , @xmath101 . if the reversibility criterion ( [ eq : cond ] ) is satisfied , then l[x(t),h]=cl[x(t+kh),-h ] . using ( [ eq : tay ] ) and the taylor series expansion for @xmath110 , we may derive the constraint c_p = c_n=0^p(-1)^p - nk^nn!c_p - n . we can re - write this equation as c_p[1-c(-1)^p]=_n=1^p(-1)^p - nk^nn!c_p - n . if @xmath111 , then this equation implies that @xmath112 if @xmath113 and thus the order can not be @xmath114 . therefore , odd - parity methods have even order . the stability of multistep methods for oscillatory problems can be parametrized by the interval of periodicity introduced by lambert & watson ( 1976 ) . suppose the right - hand size of equation ( [ eq : basicde ] ) is @xmath115 , with @xmath116 real . then , the multistep method ( [ eq : basic ] ) becomes a linear difference equation , with solution @xmath117 . here , @xmath118 and @xmath119 are complex constants , the latter satisfying ( ) -ih()=0 g ( ) -i(e^i)(e^i)=h . [ eq : period ] the interval of periodicity is the largest value of @xmath120 such that all of the roots of the first of equations ( [ eq : period ] ) lie on the unit circle . outside the interval of periodicity , the solution grows exponentially and hence is unstable . for reversible methods with odd parity , we may write g()=_j=0^k_j_j=0^k_j . if the multistep method is zero - stable , then @xmath71 has @xmath72 distinct roots on the unit circle . thus , @xmath121 has @xmath72 distinct roots on the interval @xmath122 $ ] . for sufficiently small values of @xmath120 , the equation @xmath123 will still have @xmath72 roots . as @xmath120 is increased , eventually a pair of these roots will disappear . this occurs at the smallest local maximum of @xmath121 and marks the end of the interval of periodicity . so , a plot of @xmath121 can be used to determine the interval of periodicity ( fukushima 1998 ) . the growth of errors in multistep methods is discussed by henrici ( 1962 ) , gear ( 1971 ) and especially by cano & sanz - serna ( 1998 ) . for our purposes , a limited heuristic version of these analyses is sufficient . let @xmath124 be a solution of the multistep method ( [ eq : basic ] ) . now perturb the solution to @xmath125 , @xmath126 . linearizing equation ( [ eq : basic ] ) , we have _ j=0^k(_k - j - h_k - jf_n - j)e_n - j=0 , [ eq : basica ] where @xmath127 . now look for solutions of the form @xmath128 where @xmath129 is smooth and @xmath119 is a complex constant . in the limit @xmath130 , @xmath131 , where @xmath132 is the accurate solution of the differential equation ( [ eq : basicde ] ) and therefore is smooth . then ( [ eq : basica ] ) becomes _ j=0^k^jy(t+jh)=0 , [ eq : basicb ] where @xmath133 . now expand in a taylor series in @xmath9 . to order @xmath134 we have @xmath135 , which requires that @xmath119 is one of the roots @xmath102 of the polynomial @xmath136 . to order @xmath9 we have = ( _ j=0^k_j^j _ j=0^kj_j^j)y(t ) fx(x(t))= ( x(t ) ) . thus , as @xmath137 , the linearized difference equation ( [ eq : basica ] ) has solutions of the form e_n=_j=1^k a_j_j^ny_j(t_0+nh ) , where @xmath138 satisfies the differential equation = _ jf(x(t))xy_j(t ) , [ eq : lvar ] and the growth parameters are _ j=(_j)_j(_j),j=1, ,k . [ eq : growth ] this should be contrasted with the variational equation of the orbit itself . if the trajectory @xmath139 is perturbed to @xmath140 , @xmath141 , then = f(x(t))xe(t ) . [ eq : var ] cano & sanz - serna ( 1998 ) point out that the variational equations ( [ eq : lvar ] ) and ( [ eq : var ] ) generally have quite different solutions , and hence the former can be unstable even if the latter is stable . however , this instability can be evaded for special values of the growth parameters @xmath142 : for @xmath143 , equations ( [ eq : growth ] ) and ( [ eq : var ] ) are the same , for @xmath144 , equation ( [ eq : growth ] ) is simply the time - reversed version of equation ( [ eq : var ] ) , and for @xmath145 , the solution of equation ( [ eq : growth ] ) is simply @xmath146const . we use the term `` zero - growth '' methods to denote multistep methods such that @xmath147 . cano ( 1996 ) has shown that for the reversible planar kepler problem , these are the only possible choices for the growth parameters @xmath142 to ensure stability , although for other potentials this may not be the case . multistep methods for integrating the special second - order equation @xmath148 ( lambert & watson 1976 ; quinlan & tremaine 1990 ) are not generally subject to this sort of instability , for the following reason . the expansion of the analog to equation ( [ eq : basicb ] ) in this case yields @xmath135 to order @xmath134 and @xmath149 to order @xmath9 . satisfying these two equations simultaneously requires that @xmath119 is a double root of @xmath71 ; therefore there is no instability if all of the roots of @xmath71 are simple ( cano & sanz - serna 1998 ) . in this section , all the zero - growth multistep algorithms with up to six steps are found . let us begin with some general results for stable , odd - parity , multistep , specified by the characteristic polynomials @xmath71 and @xmath73 . let @xmath102 be the roots of @xmath71 ; for zero - stable reversible methods , these are distinct , lie on the unit circle and are either real ( @xmath150 or @xmath151 ) or appear in complex - conjugate pairs . equation ( [ eq : rhoone ] ) implies that @xmath152 is always a root , which we denote @xmath153 . therefore , @xmath151 is also a root if and only if the total number of roots @xmath72 is even ; when present , we denote this root as @xmath154 . we normalize the multistep method so that @xmath56 and ( ) = _ j=1^k(-_j ) . we now demand that the growth parameter associated with the root @xmath155 is @xmath156 ( note that @xmath157 by eq . [ eq : rel ] ) . from equation ( [ eq : growth ] ) , this requires that ( _ l)=_l_l(_l)=_l_l_j = l(_l-_j ) . [ eq : sigjj ] the unique polynomial of order @xmath72 that passes through the points ( [ eq : sigjj ] ) and satisfies the symmetry condition ( [ eq : symm ] ) is ( ) = _ l=1^k _ l(+_l)_j = l(-_j ) , [ eq : sigdef ] with @xmath158 when @xmath159 . an alternative form is ( ) = ( ) _ l=1^k _ l+_l-_l . [ eq : sigdefa ] note that if @xmath160 then @xmath155 is a root of both @xmath71 and @xmath73 . in this case , there is a zero - growth multistep with the same order and error constant but fewer steps ( see [ sec : intro ] ) . therefore , we restrict our attention to methods with @xmath161 . the method is explicit if @xmath162 , which in turn requires _ j=1^k _ j=0 , [ eq : www ] a condition that can only be satisfied if @xmath72 is even . a @xmath72-step method is completely specified by the @xmath163-order polynomials @xmath71 , @xmath73 . in a stable multistep with @xmath72 even , the roots of @xmath71 are @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath164 where @xmath165 , @xmath166 . for @xmath72 odd , the root at @xmath151 is not present and the index runs to @xmath167 . in a zero - growth method , the polynomial @xmath73 is determined by equation ( [ eq : sigdef ] ) once @xmath71 and the signs @xmath142 are specified . we now discuss all stable , zero - growth , multistep of @xmath168 steps . we label the interesting methods by sz@xmath72p where @xmath72 is the number of steps and `` p '' is an optional suffix that distinguishes different methods with the same @xmath72 . since @xmath105 is always a root , for @xmath169 we must have @xmath170 . since @xmath157 by equation ( [ eq : rel ] ) , the zero - growth requirement is automatically satisfied . equation ( [ eq : sigdef ] ) requires that @xmath171 , which yields the trapezoidal method ( eq . [ eq : trapp ] ) x_n+1=x_n+h(f_n+1+f_n ) ; [ eq : trap ] the first few terms of the taylor series ( [ eq : tay ] ) are c_0=0 , c_1=0 , c_2=0 , c_3=- ; thus the error constant is @xmath172 and the method is second - order . the function @xmath121 ( eq . [ eq : period ] ) is @xmath173 , so the interval of periodicity is infinite . for @xmath174 the roots of @xmath71 can only be @xmath175 ( @xmath105 is always a root ; @xmath154 must be real since @xmath176 is also a root and there are only two roots ; @xmath154 must be on the unit circle and distinct from @xmath153 ; thus @xmath177 ) . thus , the first characteristic polynomial is ( ) = ^2 - 1 . there are two choices for the second characteristic polynomial @xmath73 , depending on @xmath178 : ( ) = 2,()=^2 + 1 . [ eq : sigtwo ] the first of these gives the explicit midpoint method ( eq . [ eq : expmidpt ] ) , x_n+1=x_n-1 + 2hf_n . [ eq : mid ] the first few terms of the taylor series ( [ eq : tay ] ) are c_0=0 , c_1=0 , c_2=0 , c_3= ; thus the error constant is @xmath179 and the method is second - order . the function @xmath121 is @xmath180 so the interval of periodicity is @xmath181 . the second equation for @xmath73 in ( [ eq : sigtwo ] ) yields x_n+1=x_n-1+h(f_n+1+f_n-1 ) , [ eq : traptwo ] which is the same as the trapezoidal method ( [ eq : trap ] ) , with a timestep of @xmath182 . all of these two - step methods are special cases of a one - parameter family of multistep , x_n+1=x_n-1+h[_0f_n+1 + 2(1-_0)f_n+_0f_n-1 ] . [ eq : btwo ] the explicit midpoint method ( eq . [ eq : mid ] ) has @xmath183 and the trapezoidal method with timestep @xmath182 ( eq . [ eq : traptwo ] ) has @xmath184 . when @xmath185 , the method is simply the composition of two trapezoidal steps ( eq . [ eq : trap ] ) . milne s method ( @xmath186 ) is the two - step method of maximum possible order ( @xmath187 ) , but its disadvantage is that its growth parameter @xmath188 and so it is susceptible to numerical instability . the interval of periodicity @xmath189 for @xmath190 and infinity for @xmath191 . to compare these methods we have integrated a kepler orbit with unit semimajor axis and period @xmath192 for 100 time units using various eccentricities and timesteps ( fig . [ fig : multi2 ] ) . even for timesteps as low as @xmath193 , the relative energy error @xmath194 , except near the zero - growth methods at @xmath195 . in particular , the second - order zero - growth methods even the explicit method at @xmath183 exhibit much better behavior than the fourth - order milne s method . for @xmath196 , the distinct roots of @xmath119 can only be @xmath105 and @xmath197 where @xmath198 and @xmath199 . thus , ( ) = ^3-(2u+1)^2+(2u+1)-1 . there are two choices for @xmath73 . the first choice is to take @xmath200 , so that we have ( ) = ^3-(+u)^2-(+u)+ . the first few terms of the taylor series ( [ eq : tay ] ) are c_0=0 , c_1=0 , c_2=0 , c_3=-+u . @xmath201 has no solution for @xmath198 so the method is second - order ; the interval of periodicity is infinite . the second choice is to take @xmath202 so that we have ( ) = -^3+(-u)^2+(-u)- . the first few terms of the taylor series ( [ eq : tay ] ) are c_0=0 , c_1=0 , c_2=0 , c_3=+u . once again , @xmath201 has no solution for @xmath198 so the method is second - order . the interval of periodicity ranges from @xmath203 as @xmath204 to 0 as @xmath205 . for @xmath206 , the distinct roots of @xmath119 can only be @xmath105 , @xmath177 and @xmath207 where @xmath198 and @xmath199 . thus , ( ) = ^4 - 2u^3 + 2u-1 . there are four choices for @xmath73 : @xmath208 , @xmath209 . none of these yield methods of order @xmath210 for @xmath198 . the three- and four - step methods have no obvious advantage over the trapezoidal or explicit midpoint methods , and we will not explore them further . for @xmath211 , the distinct roots of @xmath119 are @xmath105 , @xmath212 and @xmath213 , where @xmath214 and @xmath215 . there are three choices for @xmath73 : @xmath216 , or @xmath217 ( note that @xmath218 is not a distinct choice ) , with @xmath219 and @xmath220 . the choices @xmath221 yield only second - order methods . the choice @xmath222 yields a fourth - order method if u_2=1 + 11u_113-u_1 , u_1(-1,1 ) , u_2(-,1 ) . [ eq : l5pm ] the integration formula is @xmath223 \qquad\qquad\hbox{method sz5}. \label{eq : s5pm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the error constant is c = c_5(1)=17u_1 + 1031440(u_1 - 1 ) . for @xmath224 , the distinct roots of @xmath119 are @xmath105 , @xmath177 , @xmath225 and @xmath226 , where @xmath214 and @xmath215 . there are six choices for @xmath73 : @xmath227 or @xmath150 and @xmath228 , @xmath217 , with @xmath229 and @xmath230 . the choices @xmath231 or @xmath217 yield only second - order methods . the choice @xmath232 yields a fourth - order method if u_2=1 + 2u_14-u_1 , u_1(-1,1 ) , u_2(-,1 ) . [ eq : l6ppm ] the error constant is c = c_5(1)=14+u_145(u_1 - 1 ) . the integration formula is @xmath233 \qquad\qquad \hbox{method sz6i } , \label{eq : s6ppm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the label `` i '' stands for `` implicit '' . the choice @xmath234 yields an explicit fourth - order method if u_2=7u_1 - 1u_1 + 5 , u_1(-,1 ) , u_2(-1,1 ) . [ eq : l6mpm ] the error constant is c = c_5(1)=19 + 11u_1180(1-u_1 ) . the integration formula is @xmath235\qquad\qquad \hbox{method sz6e}. \label{eq : s6mpm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the intervals of periodicity for the three fourth - order methods are shown in figure [ fig : period ] . these are largest for @xmath236 near @xmath151 and decrease rapidly for @xmath237 . thus , only methods with negative @xmath236 are of practical use . at best , the interval of periodicity is significantly smaller than that of comparable multistep for special second - order equations ( lambert & watson 1976 ; quinlan & tremaine 1990 ; fukushima 1998 ) . this is the price of the greater generality of the present methods . this section supplements our theoretical analysis of multistep with numerical experiments using the keplerian hamiltonian @xmath238 . the equations of motion are = v_x , = v_y , = -xr^3 , = -yr^3 , where @xmath239 and the gravitational constant @xmath240 and the attracting mass @xmath241 have been set to unity . our test integrations follow an orbit with eccentricity @xmath242 , unit semi - major axis , and orbital period @xmath192 . the orbit is started at apocenter on the @xmath0-axis , so the initial conditions are x=1+e , y=0 , v_x=0 , v_y=[(1-e)/(1+e)]^1/2 . the interval of periodicity shown in figure [ fig : period ] gives the maximum stable timestep for the harmonic oscillator potential only . it is of greater relevance to astronomers to establish the timesteps that can be safely used to integrate circular or mildly eccentric orbits in the kepler potential . figure [ fig : periodkepler ] shows the largest timestep for which the relative energy error is less than @xmath243 after 100 orbital periods . the results displayed are for circular orbits , but the curves for mildly eccentric orbits ( @xmath244 ) are almost indistinguishable . a comparison between figures [ fig : period ] and [ fig : periodkepler ] reveals that the timestep needed for accurate integration of keplerian near - circular orbits is typically at least a factor of five smaller than would be naively inferred from the interval of periodicity . figure [ fig : multi56 ] shows a further test of the multistep . the standard kepler problem is integrated for 100 time units with timestep @xmath245 and eccentricities 0.2 and 0.5 . a striking feature is that the error is almost independent of the parameter @xmath236 over a limited range , while outside this range the method is unstable . the stable range shrinks as the eccentricity increases . the dependence of energy error on timestep is explored in figure [ fig : hvar56 ] . in this figure , we have specialized to a single value of the parameter @xmath236 : @xmath246 for sz5 and sz6i and @xmath247 for sz6e . all three methods display the expected dependence @xmath248 for @xmath249 . for larger values of @xmath9 , the methods are unstable . we have also plotted the behavior of the classic fourth - order adams - bashforth ( explicit ) and adams - moulton ( implicit ) multistep methods . the classic methods exhibit similar errors for @xmath249 but remain stable at much larger timesteps . the advantage of the reversible multistep methods only becomes clear over longer time intervals . figure [ fig : long56 ] shows that the maximum energy error in the reversible methods is constant at large times , while the energy error in the classical methods grows linearly . variable timesteps are useful for eccentric kepler orbits . to incorporate these , we introduce a fictitious time @xmath33 by the relation @xmath250 , so the equations of motion become = g(x , y)v_x , = g(x , y)v_y , = -g(x , y)xr^3 , = -g(x , y)yr^3 , = g(x , y ) . [ eq : kepvar ] these are integrated using unit timestep in @xmath33 . we typically use @xmath251 since this is the characteristic free - fall time from radius @xmath252 . we parameterize the timestep by the number of force evaluations per unit time ( or per radian , since the orbital period is @xmath192 ) . this is distinct from the number of steps per radian because implicit methods require several iterations per step , and because some explicit methods though not multistep methods require several force evaluations per step . figure [ fig : trap ] shows the fractional energy errors resulting from integrating kepler orbits using the trapezoidal method ( eq . [ eq : trap ] , solid lines ) and explicit adaptive leapfrog ( eq . [ eq : calvo ] , dashed lines ) . each step of the trapezoidal method was iterated to convergence , with the first approximation taken from the first - order euler method typically 3 iterations were required at the smallest timesteps , rising to @xmath253 at the largest . the energy errors are the maximum over 1000 time units or @xmath254 orbits . the results for shorter integrations over 100 time units are almost indistinguishable , showing that there is no secular energy drift with either integration method . adaptive leapfrog generally gives energy errors that are smaller by about an order of magnitude , mostly because it is explicit so there are fewer force evaluations per timestep . we have conducted similar experiments with the explicit midpoint method ( eq . [ eq : mid ] , not shown in figure ) but this is much less successful at following high - eccentricity orbits , presumably because of its smaller interval of periodicity . we next investigate the fourth - order multistep . these have relatively small intervals of periodicity and can not reliably integrate high - eccentricity orbits . however , they are successful at following orbits with moderate eccentricities . figure [ fig : fourth ] shows the fractional energy errors resulting from integrating a kepler orbit with eccentricity @xmath255 using four methods : the explicit six - step method with @xmath256 ( method sz6e , eq . [ eq : s6mpm ] ) ; the implicit six - step method with @xmath257 ( method sz6i , eq . [ eq : s6ppm ] ) ; the implicit five - step method with @xmath257 ( method sz5 , eq . [ eq : s5pm ] ) . in all panels , the heavy solid line is the error resulting from integrating the eccentric orbit with variable timestep , the light solid line is the error from integrating the same orbit with fixed timestep , and the dashed line is the error from integrating a circular orbit with fixed timestep . for large timesteps , the implicit methods do not converge and in this case no energy error is plotted . for all four methods a variable timestep yields errors that are 12 orders of magnitude smaller than a fixed timestep ( at the same number of function evaluations per unit time ) . the explicit multistep method performs much better than the implicit methods , in part because the implicit methods require 38 force evaluations per step to iterate to convergence . however , even if the convergence of the implicit multistep methods could be achieved in 23 iterations they would not perform significantly better than the explicit method on this test . a surprising result is that there is a range of the horizontal axis in which the multistep methods with variable timestep integrate eccentric orbits with smaller energy error than circular orbits . toomre ( 1990 , private communication ) and quinlan ( 1999 ) showed that multistep for the special second - order differential equation ( [ eq : fff ] ) suffer instabilities at unlucky timesteps at which there is a resonance between the oscillation frequencies of the solution and the method . this phenomenon must also occur in the multistep for first - order differential equations that are investigated here . suppose the angular speed of the circular orbit given by the numerical method is @xmath116 . if the number of steps in the multistep is at least 5 ( or 6 for second - order differential equations ) , then there are two or more complex - conjugate pairs of roots of the characteristic polynomial ( [ eq : poly ] ) on the unit circle . these we write as @xmath258 and @xmath259 . quinlan ( 1999 ) shows that the troublesome timesteps @xmath9 satisfy _ i - _ j = 2h . [ eq : gerry ] in practice these resonant instabilities are never a concern for our zero - growth multistep . this is because the timesteps ( [ eq : gerry ] ) lie outside the interval of periodicity for nearly circular keplerian orbits . let us demonstrate this by considering one example in more detail namely , the 6-step implicit method sz6i defined by ( [ eq : l6ppm ] ) and ( [ eq : s6ppm ] ) . this is the most susceptible to resonant instabilities of the zero - growth methods we have examined , both because it has the largest interval of periodicity and because , as @xmath260 , two of the spurious roots coalesce as @xmath261 . we recall that there are five spurious roots on the unit circle , namely @xmath177 , and the two complex - conjugate pairs @xmath225 and @xmath262 , where @xmath215 . using ( [ eq : l6ppm ] ) , the angular separations between the spurious roots on the unit circle can be readily computed as a function of @xmath236 . figure [ fig : final ] shows the locations of the potentially troublesome timesteps @xmath9 , together with the maximum possible timestep ( already presented in figure [ fig : periodkepler ] ) . the resonant instabilities always occur at timesteps that are outside the interval of periodicity for keplerian orbits . similar results hold for the methods sz5 and sz6e . the generic instabilities of multistep for first - order differential equations identified by cano & sanz - serna ( 1998 ) are a grave problem and render many of these methods unusable . the main contribution of this paper is the elaboration of a class of multistep the zero - growth methods that successfully evade the instabilities . this select group includes two familiar second - order multisteps , namely the trapezoidal method ( [ eq : trap ] ) and the explicit midpoint method ( [ eq : mid ] ) , as well as entirely new multistep . in particular , we have identified three one - parameter families of zero - growth , fourth - order namely , the five - step implicit method sz5 defined by equations ( [ eq : l5pm ] ) and ( [ eq : s5pm ] ) , the six - step implicit method sz6i defined by ( [ eq : l6ppm ] ) and ( [ eq : s6ppm ] ) , and the six - step explicit method sz6e defined by ( [ eq : l6mpm ] ) and ( [ eq : s6mpm ] ) . of these , the explicit method sz6e eliminates the need to iterate to convergence at each timestep without a major sacrifice in the interval of periodicity . the stability of the zero - growth methods has been understood at a theoretical level and confirmed at a practical level by integrations of circular and eccentric keplerian orbits . there are several advantages of multistep for first - order differential equations over the multistep for special second - order differential equations examined by lambert & watson ( 1976 ) , quinlan & tremaine ( 1990 ) , and fukushima ( 1998 , 1999 ) . they permit the introduction of variable timesteps without spoiling reversibility or long - term energy conservation . they are also more general , since any ordinary differential equations can always be reduced to a system of first - order equations ; thus , for example , the methods described here can be used to follow orbits in rotating frames of reference or the motions of rotating rigid bodies . a third advantage is that they are less susceptible to timestep resonances . the price paid for these attractive features is that ( i ) the interval of periodicity of the higher order methods such as sz5 , sz6i and sz6e is rather small , forcing the use of smaller timesteps than other methods ; ( ii ) more steps are needed for a method of given order ; there are no fourth - order methods with fewer than five steps and no fifth or sixth - order methods with 8 or fewer steps ( the limit of our explorations ) . nonetheless , the six - step explicit method ( sz6e ) remains a competitive option for problems in which it is critical to have variable timesteps and to avoid irreversible numerical errors : examples include long - term integrations of asteroid or comet orbits , or orbits near the centers of galaxies . 1 . are there zero - growth with more than @xmath224 steps that have higher order or a larger interval of periodicity ? we have explored all @xmath263 but have found no of order greater than 4 . gautschi ( 1961 ) developed a class of methods closely related to the linear multisteps . just as a linear multistep is defined by the requirement that the operator ( [ eq : linearoperator ] ) annihilate all algebraic polynomials of order @xmath264 , so the gautschi multisteps annihilate certain trigonometric polynomials up to a given degree . these methods are particularly appealing when the solution is known to be periodic and a reasonable estimate for the period of the orbit can be guessed in advance requirements that are often satisfied in solar system integrations . can we find reversible gautschi multisteps ? integration methods are generally designed to maximize the order @xmath63 , defined so that the one - step error in following a system with characteristic frequency @xmath116 is proportional to @xmath265 . perhaps it is more sensible to `` economize '' the error , by minimizing the maximum value of the error over a range of frequencies @xmath266 . in this case the error would be nearly proportional to a chebyshev polynomial @xmath267 with argument @xmath268 and degree @xmath269 , instead of @xmath270 . we are indebted to gerry quinlan for communicating his results on resonant instabilities in advance of publication . this research was supported in part by nasa grant nag5 - 7310 . nwe thanks both the canadian institute for theoretical astrophysics and the department of astrophysical sciences , princeton university for their hospitality during working visits . his research is supported by the royal society . hut , p. , funato , y. , kokubo , e. , makino , j. , & mcmillan , s. 1997 , in computational astrophysics : 12th kingston meeting on theoretical astrophysics , eds . d. a. clarke & m. j. west ( san francisco : astronomical society of the pacific ) , 26

this paper studies multistep methods for the integration of reversible dynamical systems , with particular emphasis on the planar kepler problem . it has previously been shown by cano & sanz - serna that reversible linear multisteps for first - order differential equations are generally unstable . here , we report on a subset of these methods the _ zero - growth methods _ that evade these instabilities . we provide an algorithm for identifying these rare methods . we find and study all zero - growth , reversible multisteps with six or fewer steps . this select group includes two well - known second - order multisteps ( the trapezoidal and explicit midpoint methods ) , as well as three new fourth - order multisteps one of which is explicit . variable timesteps can be readily implemented without spoiling the reversibility . tests on keplerian orbits show that these new reversible multisteps work well on orbits with low or moderate eccentricity , although at least 100 steps / radian are required for stability . # 1#2 # 1to 0pt#1

1008.2948

radio frequency ( srf ) cavities will be used in the international linear collider ( ilc ) to explore electron - positron collisions in high energy physics research . in order to achieve a 1 tev beam energy it is necessary to build @xmath2 nb cavities with electrodynamic properties approaching the intrinsic limit dictated by theory . despite the maturity of material fabrication techniques and improvement of chemical and physical surface treatments and annealing processes in the past several years , it is still challenging to fabricate so many state - of - the - art nb cavities without performance - limiting defects . in general , many types of defects are found on nb cavity surfaces . under intense rf loading , some of these defects can act as a hot spot to locally warm up the nb superconductor above its critical temperature ( @xmath3 ) , leading to a quench of the cavity . one approach to this problem is to postpone the quench of the superconductor by enhancing the rf breakdown field of the material at the surface . there is considerable interest in preparing novel coatings on nb cavities . superconductor / insulator multilayer thin film coatings have been proposed to enhance the rf breakdown field of the superconductor @xcite . it is of interest to measure whether or not this enhancement is possible with practical materials . however , the properties of uncontrolled localized defects present in the finished srf cavities appear to limit their ultimate microwave performance . therefore , there is an urgent need to understand the connections between localized defects , surface treatments , and the rf breakdown field in the high frequency regime . optical microscopy techniques have been developed to identify defects in finished nb cavities @xcite . however this optical screening process may result in identification of relatively benign defects which will not result in a quench of the superconductor . ideally , one would like a microscopic technique that identifies defects based on their poor microwave performance at low temperatures in the superconducting state . one of the best candidates for this job is the near field microwave microscope which has been developed to quantitatively image rf and microwave properties of a variety of materials on deep sub - wavelength scales @xcite , @xcite . in order to generate a strong and localized rf magnetic field , and to enhance the spatial resolution of this microscope , a magnetic writer is utilized in our experiment . taking advantage of magnetic write head technology with write - gap widths on the order of 100 nm @xcite , an rf field on the scale of 1 tesla @xcite with sub - micron spatial extent @xcite can be created . in this work , we integrate the magnetic writer probe into our microwave microscope and demonstrate that this probe can develop a nonlinear meissner effect signal from several kinds of superconductors such as mgb@xmath4 and tl@xmath4ba@xmath4cacu@xmath4o@xmath5 ( tbcco ) . this probe has great potential for high resolution nonlinear meissner effect microscopy and in the future will be used in analyzing defects on nb cavity surfaces at high frequencies and low temperatures . in previous work , we developed a low resolution near field microwave microscope to nondestructively measure the local harmonic generation from unpatterned superconducting samples @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite . in this design , a loop probe ( fig . [ fig_probe ] left ) is made by shorting the inner conductor and outer conductor of a commercial semi - ridge coax cable with inner diameter 200 @xmath6@xmath7 and outer diameter 2 @xmath8 . the loop is brought to within 10 @xmath6@xmath7 of the superconducting surface and a high frequency signal is applied to the loop . rf screening currents are induced in the sample . due to its nonlinear response , harmonics of the drive signal are created , and these couple back into the loop probe and are measured at room temperature with a spectrum analyzer . this experiment can determine both the second and third harmonic nonlinear products at the same location at any excited frequency and temperature of interest . here , we have modified this basic experiment to produce stronger and more localized rf magnetic fields . based on the need to investigate nb near the thermodynamic critical field , we require at least 200 @xmath9 magnetic field at the sample surface . in order to enhance the magnetic coupling between probe and superconducting sample , we replace the loop probe with a magnetic write head ( fig . [ fig_probe ] right ) . the system setup is shown in fig . [ fig_setup ] . both the magnetic write head probe and the superconductor are kept in a high vacuum cryogenic environment . microwave fundamental frequency power @xmath10 is generated by a microwave synthesizer . low pass filters are used to filter out higher harmonics generated by the microwave source . because of the perturbation of the super fluid density coming from the externally applied rf magnetic field , higher order harmonic response ( @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 ) will be induced on the sample for temperatures below @xmath3 . those harmonic signals will be radiated from the sample and can be extracted by high pass filtering the signal from the probe . here we shall concentrate on @xmath12 , which arises from time - reversal invariant perturbations of the superconductor and can be used to examine both intrinsic and extrinsic nonlinear characteristics of the material . in fig . [ fig_setup ] , the closed dashed line encloses a reference microwave circuit designed for cancellation of nonlinearity from the magnetic write head probe itself , and will be discussed below . in addition , a bias tee is integrated into the microwave microscope circuit to allow injection of a small dc current into the probe , also discussed further below . the generated third harmonic power @xmath12 is estimated as @xcite , @xcite @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the frequency of the incident wave , @xmath16 is the temperature dependent magnetic penetration depth , @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the nonlinear scaling current and a current - distribution geometry factor , respectively . @xmath19 is the surface current induced in the superconductor at the fundamental frequency and @xmath20 is total volume current induced in the sample . from eq . ( [ p3f : equation ] ) , a strong magnetic field from the magnetic write head probe will enhance the surface current @xmath21 and confine the current distribution , both leading to an enhancement of @xmath18 , and therefore @xmath12 , for a given excitation power . this has the added benefit of improving the spatial resolution of the probe . defective regions of the sample , including those responsible for hot - spot generation , have smaller values of @xmath17 than the surrounding material , hence will develop larger @xmath12 , thus giving away their position to the microscope . previous work has demonstrated the ability of this microscope to identify a grain boundary josephson junction defect in a cuprate thin film @xcite , @xcite , @xcite . the superconducting samples we study include a tbcco thin film of thickness 500 @xmath22 , epitaxially grown by the magnetron sputtering method @xcite . in addition , a high quality epitaxial mgb@xmath4 thin film with thickness 25 @xmath22 is also examined . the mgb@xmath4 film is deposited on a sic substrate by a hybrid physical - chemical vapor deposition technique @xcite . both samples are examined at a single location in the center of the 10 mm*10 mm area . before integrating the magnetic write head into our near field microwave microscope , we measured the complex load impedance that the head presents to the microwave generator . [ fig_impeadance ] shows the impedance measured with a picoprobe touching the contact pads on the slider . remarkably , the write head is very well impedance matched to 50 @xmath23 in resistance and 0 @xmath23 in reactance over a broad frequency range from around 2 ghz to 25 ghz , which is quite ideal for the present application . such good impedance match implies that we can deliver 45 @xmath24 of current to the write head using 100 @xmath25 ( + 20 dbm ) of rf power , and we have found that this does not burn out the magnetic write head coil . of a tbcco film , measured by a magnetic write head probe with an excitation frequency of 3.5 ghz . inset is measured by the bare loop probe with excitation frequency of 3.5 ghz and excited power 18 dbm.,width=326,height=288 ] a measurement of the temperature dependent 3rd order harmonic power is performed at the center of the tbcco film by the magnetic write head probe with different exciting powers . the inset of fig . [ fig_tbcco ] shows @xmath26 measured by the bare loop probe . a peak in @xmath12 near @xmath3 shows up , as expected . this enhancement of @xmath12 is due to the nonlinear meissner effect near @xmath3 . from eq . [ p3f : equation ] one sees that due to @xmath17 approaching zero and @xmath27 diverging at @xmath3 the third harmonic power will increase strongly . the divergence is cut off by the distribution of transition temperatures in the sample , and the influence of quasiparticle electrodynamics . with the loop probe , the enhancement of @xmath12 above background is only 15 db , for 18 dbm fundamental input power . such a small enhancement can be easily achieved by the magnetic head probe with only 9 dbm excited power ( fig . [ fig_tbcco ] ) , which means that the magnetic write head generates a more localized and intense field , inducing stronger surface currents on the sample . despite these higher currents , there is no evidence of localized heating in the sample from the data in fig . [ fig_tbcco ] . in order to test the magnetic write head probe in a liquid helium cooled environment , temperature dependent 3rd order harmonic power is also measured in the center position of an mgb@xmath4 thin film . in fig . [ fig_mgb2 ] , a peak at 39.1 k shows up clearly near the @xmath3 of the film . this proves that the magnetic probe can function in the low temperature region . comparison of this peak with that of tbcco , one finds a much sharper transition , implying a narrow distribution of @xmath28 values in the mgb@xmath4 thin film . from an mgb@xmath4 film , measured with the magnetic write head probe with an excitation frequency of approximately 3.5 ghz and a power of 12 dbm.,width=3,height=288 ] one can see from fig . [ fig_tbcco ] that as the excitation power to the probe is increased , the noise floor is also enhanced . this is due to the nonlinearity of the magnetic write head itself . generally speaking , all of the tested magnetic write heads show some degree of nonlinearity . to clarify the origin of this probe nonlinearity , a dc current is injected into the write head drive coil to control the magnetization direction of the magnetic materials inside the probe . third harmonic power from the probe under 3.5 ghz and 16 dbm illumination is shown in the inset of fig . [ fig_phase_cancelation ] , as a function of dc current from -55 ma to + 55 ma . the @xmath12 from the magnetic write head decreases dramatically at + 45 ma and -45 ma , demonstrating that an applied dc current can suppress background nonlinearity . this decrease in @xmath12 may be due to establishment of a fully magnetized state of the ferromagnetic films in the write head , thus elimianting nonlinearity from minor hysterisis loops . the applied current may also reduce magnetic domain wall motion and magnetic moment precession , thus reducing background nonlinearity @xcite . to experimentally reduce the background nonlinearity , a reference arm is created to cancel the contributions of the probe to the measured nonlinearity . the area circled by the dashed line in fig . [ fig_setup ] includes an identical magnetic write head probe . the phase shifter and variable attenuator are used to create an equal amplitude but 180-degree phase - shifted third harmonic signal from the reference arm . a plot of the total @xmath12 generated by both arms combined , at different phase shifts , is shown in fig . [ fig_phase_cancelation ] . with 127.2@xmath29 of phase shift , the background nonlinearity is completely cancelled ( down to the noise level of the spectrum analyzer ) by the reference probe . this result implies that the microscope can be made sensitive to just the @xmath12 signal from the superconductor , despite the presence of nonlinear magnetic materials in the write probe . with this modification we expect to achieve high spatial resolution in nonlinear near field microwave microscopy , and apply it to defect identification in nb materials . from the sample probe and reference probe , as a function of phase shift in the full setup shown in fig . [ fig_setup ] . the experiment is carried out with an excitation frequency of 2.12 ghz and power of 14 dbm at ambient temperature under vacuum . no samples are present in this measurement.,width=3,height=268 ] at present the cryostat housing this microscope is not able to achieve sample temperatures below the transition temperature of nb . the probe assembly causes localized heating on the nb sample , preventing it from being cooled below @xmath3 . further improvements in the probe cooling system are required . a magnetic write head is successfully integrated into the near field microwave microscope operating at cryogenic temperatures . the magnetic write head should generate rf magnetic field on the scale of the thermodynamic critical field of nb on sub-@xmath6 m length scales . using this probe , a clear reproducible nonlinear response signal from superconducting samples of tbcco and mgb@xmath4 are obtained . although this probe can generate strong nonlinearity itself , a phase cancellation method is demonstrated to nearly zero out this contribution . this microscope will be employed to identify defects that degrade the rf performance of nb used in srf cavities . s. m. anlage , v. v. talanov , a. r. schwartz , _ principles of near - field microwave microscopy in scanning probe microscopy : electrical and electromechanical phenomena at the nanoscale _ , new york : springer - verlag , vol . 215 - 253 , 2007 . d. w. face , r. j. small , m. s. warrington , f. m. pellicone , p. j. martin . large area yba@xmath4cu@xmath30o@xmath31 and tl@xmath4ba@xmath4cacu@xmath4o@xmath33 thin films for microwave and electronic applications . " _ physica c _ , vol . 1488 - 1494 , 2001 . x. zeng , a. v. pogrebnyakov , a. kotcharov , j. e. jones , x. x. xi , e. m. lysczek , j. m. redwing , s. y. xu , j. lettieri , d. g. schlom , w. tian , x. q. pan , z. k. liu , in situ epitaxial mgb@xmath4 thin films for superconducting electronics , " _ nature materials _ , vol . 1 , pp . 35 - 38 , 2002 . s. y. an , p. krivosik , m. a. kraemer , h. m. olson , a. v. nazarov , c. e. patton , high power ferromagnetic resonance and spin wave instability processes in permalloy thin films " , _ j. appl . 96 , pp.1572 - 1580 , 2004 .

niobium - based superconducting radio frequency ( srf ) cavity performance is sensitive to localized defects that give rise to quenches at high accelerating gradients . in order to identify these material defects on bulk nb surfaces at their operating frequency and temperature , it is important to develop a new kind of wide bandwidth microwave microscopy with localized and strong rf magnetic fields . by taking advantage of write head technology widely used in the magnetic recording industry , one can obtain @xmath0200 @xmath1 rf magnetic fields , which is on the order of the thermodynamic critical field of nb , on sub - micron length scales on the surface of the superconductor . we have successfully induced the nonlinear meissner effect via this magnetic write head probe on a variety of superconductors . this design should have a high spatial resolution and is a promising candidate to find localized defects on bulk nb surfaces and thin film coatings of interest for accelerator applications . harmonic generation , microwave microscope , magnetic write head , nonlinear meissner effect , near - field , rf superconductivity .

physics0303089

virus particles ( virions ) come in a variety of sizes and shapes . however , approximately spherical shapes with diameters in the range between @xmath1 and @xmath2 are especially common . many nearly spherical viruses are revealed by x - ray crystallography to have icosahedral symmetry . a typical virus particle contains genetic material , rna or dna , surrounded by a protein coat ( capsid ) . such an object should have reasonably distinct vibrational frequencies , the study of which may be of interest . excitation of these vibrations could have applications in either the diagnosis or treatment of viral diseases . to this author s knowledge , the sole discussion of these vibrational modes in the literature is that of babincov _ et al _ @xcite . these authors discuss the conjecture that ultrasound in the ghz range could be resonantly absorbed by hiv virus particles , leading to their destruction . et al _ @xcite have recently reported the detection of viruses by acoustic oscillations . however , the process of `` rupture event scanning '' , which these authors report , involves the separation of a virus particle from antibodies by ultrasound . this is distinct from the excitation of the vibrational modes of the virus particle itself , and occurs at much lower frequencies . there have also been some experimental studies of ultrasonic absorption by empty viral capsids @xcite . these experiments reveal an enhanced absorption in the mhz range as proteins reassemble into a capsid , but do not find a resonant peak in this frequency range . witz and brown @xcite have emphasized that these and other results show that viral capsids are flexible and change size or shape in response to vibrations or to changes in temperature or ph . the purpose of the present paper is to provide some estimates of the lowest vibrational frequencies of a spherical virus particle . the simplest estimate is to take this frequency to be of the order of a characteristic speed of sound divided by the size of the virus particle . this is the estimate used in ref . @xcite . for the purpose of giving a more accurate estimate , we will examine two models , which treat the particle ( 1 ) as a liquid drop and ( 2 ) as a uniform elastic sphere . similar models have been used by bulatov _ @xcite to estimate the vibrational frequencies of nanoclusters . consider a sphere of radius @xmath3 filled with a nonviscous liquid with surface tension @xmath4 and mass density @xmath5 . the lowest vibrational mode of this sphere will be a quadrupole mode with frequency @xcite @xmath6 which can be written as @xmath7 where @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the mass density and surface tension for water , respectively . the surface tension and mass density , along with the lowest vibrational frequency derived from eq . ( [ eq : nu_drop ] ) for @xmath10 , are given in table 1 for several liquids . .the mass density , surface tension , and the lowest vibrational frequency predicted by eq . ( [ eq : nu_drop ] ) for drops of various liquids with a radius of @xmath10 . the data for benzene and diethylene glycol @xcite are for droplets in air at room temperature . the data for the three proteins @xcite are for aqueous solutions at approximately @xmath11 . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] we can see that for a wide range of materials , the lowest mode of vibration is a purely radial mode with a frequency of the order of a few times @xmath12 for a sphere of radius @xmath10 . in the previous sections , we have examined two models for a spherical virus particle , a liquid drop model and an elastic sphere model . it is of interest that the two models yield estimates for the lowest vibrational frequency which differ by only about one order of magnitude . of the two models , the elastic sphere model is probably the better description of a virus particle . an even better model might be one in which the particle has a liquid core ( dna or rna ) surrounded by an elastic outer shell ( the capsid ) . such a model would probably yield vibrational frequencies intermediate between those predicted by the two models discussed in this paper . in any case , we obtain an estimate for the lowest vibrational frequency of the same order of magnitude as that given in ref . @xcite , in the range of a few ghz for particles with a size of about @xmath13 . of course , the existence of a resonance requires that damping be below the critical value above which overdamped motion occurs . even if this condition is fulfilled , it is difficult to predict the width of the resonance . this remains a question for experimental investigation . the existence of well defined resonances could prove valuable both for basic science and for medicine . thus this is a potentially fruitful area for further research .

the possible normal modes of vibration of a nearly spherical virus particle are discussed . two simple models for the particle are treated , a liquid drop model and an elastic sphere model . some estimates for the lowest vibrational frequency are given for each model . it is concluded that this frequency is likely to be of the order of a few ghz for particles with a radius of the order of @xmath0 .

cond-mat0006193

paradoxes are among the best weaponry available to a scientist . the paradox in science is associated with a flaw in the theoretical understanding on the most basic level . recently an interview with edward witten was broadcasted on dutch tv . the interviewer tried to corner witten , arguing that quantum - gravity is a shaky affair because it is not accessible by experimental means . witten was prepared for this question , arguing that the situation is not that bad because quantum gravity is firmly rooted in a grand paradox . einstein s theory of gravity and quantum mechanics are fundamentally incompatible . this is intimately linked to basic assumptions that are so self evident that they are not even explicitly formulated . the pursuit of string - theory should be considered as an attempt to lay bare these hidden assumptions , and in this sense progress is made . we want to suggest that high @xmath0 superconductivity is in a similar state . the field revolves around a grand paradox , with the added merit that it has experimental physics on its side . the arrival of a paradox is accompanied by raging controversy , and the controversy in high @xmath0 superconductivity is not easy to overlook . the community has bifurcated in two schools of thought . the first school rests on the conceptual backbone of conventional bcs theory and has been quite successful in addressing the physics of the fully developed superconducting state@xcite . their stronghold are the quasiparticles associated with the d - wave order parameter . the other school refers to the growing body of empirical and theoretical evidence suggesting that the electrons have been eaten by dynamical stripes@xcite . the paradox is that stripes and nodal fermions are mutually exclusive . the basic assumption underlying stripes is that the electrons are expelled from the magnetic domains , with the unavoidable consequence that the soft charge degrees of freedom are associated with the motions inside the stripes . since the stripes are oriented along the @xmath1 lattice directions the low energy propagating electronic excitations should be found along the @xmath2 directions in the brillioun zone . along @xmath3 the excitations have to traverse the insulating domains and this should cause a severe damping if not a complete gapping . instead , photo - emission shows relatively sharp dispersive features along @xmath3 which are quite like the nodal fermions of a d - wave superconductor . the messy fermions are found along the stripe directions . it seems a widespread reflex to postulate a ` two - fluid ' picture : stripes and nodal fermions reflect separate universes , both governed by their own laws , which are for whatever reason completely disconnected . one has no other choice within the confines of bcs theory and the present understanding of dynamical stripes . however , this is no more than admitting defeat in the face of the paradox . we want to pose the following question : can it be that stripes and nodal fermions are two manifestations of an underlying unity while they appear as dissimilar because of flawed hidden assumptions in the theory ? the remainder of this text will be a modest attempt to make the mind susceptible to the possibility that a positive answer exists for this question . a tactics will be followed which is not dissimilar to the habits in string theory . an alternative theory is suggested , of a highly speculative kind while its consequences are far from clear because of severe technical difficulties . however , it has the special merit that it does not suffer from the paradox , thereby shedding some light on what can be wrong in the current understanding . the burden is on the stripe side . one has to get out of the narrow interpretations of textbook bcs theory to appreciate the nodal fermions on a sufficiently general level , and this work has already been done by others see the next section . our speculation is that the current way of viewing dynamical stripes is too classical . instead , we assert that the superconducting- and stripe states are related by duality ( section 3 ) . static stripes and superconductivity are competing orders and the duality principle of quantum field theory states that the competing phases can be viewed as ` two sides of the same coin'@xcite : the disordered state ( the superconductor ) can be viewed as a condensate of the topological excitations ( disorder fields ) associated with the ordered state ( the static stripes ) . the topological excitations of the stripe phase ( ` stripe dislocations ' ) have such an unusual structure that it is a - priori unreasonable to assume that the associated disorder field - theory does not support nodal fermions . all what is needed on this side of the coin is to obtain a sufficiently general view on the nature of what has to be demonstrated : the nodal fermions . although controversial@xcite , we will take here the conservative position that bcs is correct as the fixed point theory . one has to be , however , aware of the over - interpretations associated with the weak - coupling treatments in the textbooks . these are twofold : the ultraviolet is not governed by a non - interacting electron gas , even not to some degree of approximation@xcite . secondly , bogoliubov quasiparticles are in fact @xmath4 excitations of the spin system ( spinons ) which acquire fully automatically a finite electron pole - strength in the superconducting state@xcite . _ @xmath5 is not a sommerfeld gas . _ the universality principle states that systems differing greatly at microscopic scales can nevertheless exhibit the same physics at macroscopic scales . bcs is a universal theory and its infrared structure can be deduced from a simple model . the standard textbook approach sets off by guessing a zero - th order hamiltonian ( @xmath6 ) which depicts the large energy scale physics . in systems such as aluminum , the fermi - liquid renormalizations are basically complete at @xmath0 and @xmath5 is simply the sommerfeld gas hamiltonian . all one has to do is to add a small perturbation ( the bcs - attractive interaction ) which leaves the uv physics unaltered ( the fermi surface ) while veering the system to the correct ir fixed point . although the fixed point might still be the same , the way one gets there is entirely different in cuprates@xcite . there is no such thing as a close approach to the fermi - liquids at short scales- and times as is the case in al . instead , the analysis of shen and coworkers of the photo - emission suggests that at truly large energies the electrons move in stripes : the ` holy cross'@xcite . upon descending in energy , the cross starts to deteriorate and the nodal fermions start to appear . it is as if the nodal fermions are a long wavelength phenomenon associated with the quantum disordering of stripes ! it is only at low temperatures , deep in the superconducting state that one finds features which behave like quantum - mechanically propagating particles ( the ` quantum protection principle'@xcite ) . the ramification is that it is not necessary to deduce a large , noninteracting fermi - surface from quantum stripes . it is only necessary to demonstrate that the vacuum structure supports massless electron - like excitations living on dirac cones : the nodal fermions . _ nodal fermions are spinons . _ as a next step , it is even not necessary to reinvent the electron . all that needs to be done is to find excitations carrying spin quantum number @xmath4 living on the dirac cones . the superconducting condensate will take care of connecting these to the electrons . for this purpose we only have to remind the reader of an insight by kivelson and rokshar@xcite , further elaborated by fisher and coworkers@xcite . according to the textbooks , the bogoliubov quasiparticle is an electron because it has a pole - strength proportional to the square of a coherence factor . the finiteness of the pole - strength implies that the quantum numbers carried by the external electron can be attached to the excitations supported by the vacuum structure of the superconductor . although spin- and momentum quantum numbers are sharply defined in the bcs state , there is a subtlety associated with the quantum of electrical charge : charge density is a fluctuating quantity in the superconductor and charge quanta can be added and removed at will from the condensate . hence , the charge of the external electron can always be ` dumped ' in the condensate . to summarize , instead of reinventing aluminum , all what has to be done is to find out if a quantum disordered stripe phase can be constructed , which is superconducting while it carries @xmath4 excitations with a nodal - fermion dispersion . one of the quiet revolutions of mathematical physics is the discovery of the field - theoretic principle of duality . at first it appears as a mathematically rigorous procedure which can be carried through to the end in only a few simple cases ( e.g. , ref . however , it seems to reflect a physical principle of a far greater generality . especially in the condensed matter context it has a stunning consequence : except for the critical state , the universality of duality seems to suggest that there are no truely disordered states at zero temperature . what appears as disorder is actually order of the disorder operators . duality can be formulated as an algorithm , with the following subroutines : ( a ) characterize the order in the system in terms of an order parameter structure . ( b ) enumerate the topological excitations , and link them to singular configurations of the order fields defined in ( a ) . a single topological excitation suffices to destroy the order everywhere . ( c ) at a critical value of the coupling constant these topological excitations will proliferate , signalling the transition to the ` disordered ' state . ( d ) the constituents of the disordered state are the topological excitations of its ` ordered ' partner . as these objects interact this in turn defines a ` disorder ' field theory describing the condensation of the disorder matter . the ` disordered ' state corresponds with an ordered state in terms of the topological excitations of the ` ordered ' state . why should this have anything to do with the cuprates ? static stripes and superconductivity are clearly competing forms of order . when stripe order sets in , superconductivity is suppressed and vice versa . moreover , it appears that this competition is governed by a ( near ) continuous quantum phase transition@xcite . this is not unimportant , since duality is only rigorously defined in continuum field theory and therefore the characteristic length scales should be large as compared to the lattice constant . dynamical stripes seem to fulfill this condition at least in the underdoped regime . finally , the ordered stripe phase and the superconductor appear to be very different states of matter , but this is not an a - priori problem . after all , the central notion of duality is that one is supposed to be the ` maximally disordered ' version of the other , although at elevated energies they are bound to merge in a single critical regime . the remainder of this section is intended to illustrate the problems encountered in the duality construction which are so severe that it can not be excluded that it is actually the correct way of viewing these matters . according to the duality recipe , we have to start out specifying precisely what stripe order means . a stripe phase is a highly organized entity and characterized by a variety of distinct , coexisting orders : + ( i ) _ the stripe phase is a wigner - crystal_. this is obvious : the electrons form a crystal , breaking translational and rotational symmetry . we will adopt here the viewpoint that a fully ordered stripe state exists which can be used as reference state where translational symmetry is broken both parallel- and perpendicular to the stripes . + ( ii ) _ the stripe phase is a mott - insulator . _ we use here ` mott - insulator ' in the general sense that the charge order discussed under ( i ) is commensurate with the underlying crystal structure@xcite , causing a full gap in the charge excitation spectrum . this is actually controversial , and not of central importance in the present context . it is merely helpful , because there is nothing mysterious about an insulating stripe phase . specifically , we will associate a conserved charge of @xmath7 to the stripe mott - insulator , since with this choice the correct superconductivity emerges directly ( see , however , @xcite ) . the insulator would then correspond with a @xmath8 on - stripe density wave@xcite . + ( iii ) _ the stripe phase is a collinear antiferromagnet . _ this is also obvious . even when the charge order stays complete , the antiferromagnet can quantum disorder all by itself@xcite , and this is especially worth a consideration in the bilayer systems . however , we will ignore this possible complication since the focus here is in first instance on the 214 system where the charge ordered systems seem always to be nel ordered as well . + ( iv ) _ the stripe phase is ` topologically ' ordered . _ this is the novelty of the stripe phase : whenever stripes are observed in cuprates and nickelates the charges are localized on the antiphase domain walls in the nel state . it is intuitively clear that this is a form of order , although of an unusual kind . in the fully disordered stripe phase this ` anti - phase boundarieness ' must also be destroyed . hence , the topological excitations of the topological order have to be considered and these are predominantly responsible for the unusual nature of the disorder theory . + given the complexity of stripe order , one anticipates a rather rich disorder - field theory . this is indeed the case . however , this structure can be built up starting from an elementary topological texture of a remarkable simplicity : the stripe dislocation as sketched in fig . this is a stripe which is just ending somewhere in the middle of the sample . in the present context one should appreciate this object as a quantum particle , which can freely propagate through the lattice , occurring at a finite density in the quantum disordered stripe state . the disorder fields are responsible for the fixed point physics in the disordered state , and these reflect the topological charges associated with the constituent topological excitations . what are the conserved charges associated with the stripe dislocations ? everything one needs to know for the charge sector is available , and the problems are associated with the topological- and spin sectors . let us first shortly discuss the charge sector this will be discussed in detail elsewhere . the ordered reference state is assumed to be a mott - insulator , characterized by local conservation of charge . the stripe dislocation destroys this local charge conservation and is thereby an electrically charge particle carrying the charge quantum of the insulator . assuming this charge to be 2e and neglecting of the sign structure associated with the spin sector , the dislocations become hard - core bosons . moreover , if the dislocations can move freely , then the infinitely long dislocation world lines of the dislocated state will wind around each other . the resulting entangled state is none other than a superconductor . this is just the inverse of the well known abelian higg s duality in 2 + 1 d@xcite . this is not all , because the stripe phase is not just a featureless mott - insulator but its charge sector also breaks translational- and rotational symmetry . the dislocation of fig . [ fig ] is the topological defect associated with the restoration of translational symmetry , carrying a burger s vector topological charge . rotational symmetry is restored by a distinct topological excitation , and it is expected that these disclinations are initially suppressed . although dislocations restore translational invariance , they leave the rotational symmetry breaking unaffected and this is the quantum - nematic state as introduced by kivelson _ et . @xcite ( see also balents and nelson@xcite ) . as will be discussed elsewhere @xcite , instead of the single nematic of kivelson _ et . al . _ one finds actually a variety of physically distinct nematic like phases if one starts from a mott - insulating stripe phase . for the present purposes all what matters is , however , that a state exists which is dislocated while the dislocations are subjected to 2 + 1d motions . the stage is now set for the case we wish to make . the question is : what is the meaning of ` topological order ' ( or ` antiphase - boundarieness ' ) and what does it mean to destroy this topological order ? our assertion is that the low energy effective theory associated with this ` order ' is actually not an order parameter theory , but instead a _ geometrical _ theory . the spin system lives in a ` internal ' space which is different from the space experienced by an external observer . in the absence of stripe dislocations this internal space is ` flat ' , but the dislocations are sources of ` curvature ' . for the quantum antiferromagnet all that matters is the bipartiteness of the underlying lattice geometry . ` curved ' means that this bipartiteness is destroyed by the stripe dislocations . the spin system of the stripe - dual lives on a frustrating lattice which itself is fluctuating . this can be discussed in a fairly rigorous setting , but given the space limitations let us just illustrate the main steps on an intuitive - geometrical level . what does anti - phase boundarieness mean ? in fact , it does not make sense to call stripes domain walls in the spin system . domain walls occur when a @xmath9 symmetry is in charge and the ( semiclassical ) spin system is @xmath10 invariant . stripes are in this sense non - topological and some other principle is in charge , and this should be made explicit in order to construct the duality . this is a geometric principle and our claim is based on an exact result in 1 + 1d physics where ` antiphase boundarieness ' is called ` spin - charge separation ' . spin - charge separation has been demystified in a seminal contribution by ogata and shiba @xcite . by inspecting the bethe - ansatz wave - function of the hubbard model in 1 + 1d in the large @xmath11 limit they come up with a particular prescription for constructing the spin dynamics . although it does not seem to be fully appreciated , this involves the notions of a geometric theory : on the most basic level it is similar to the einstein theory of gravity . their prescription is as follows : choose a particular distribution of holes on the lattice , and the amplitude of this configuration in the wave function will be entirely given by the configuration of the charges . every given distribution of holes defines a pure spin problem which is indistinguishable at large u from the heisenberg spin chain _ after a redefinition of the lattice . _ this is the ` squeezing ' operation : take out the holes , together with the sites where they reside , and substitute an antiferromagnetic exchange bond between the spins neighbouring the hole for the taken out hole+site . in a geometrical language , the external observer ( us ) experiences the full chain . however , the internal observer ( spin system ) experiences a different space : the squeezed chain where the holes and their corresponding sites have been removed . although the internal observer is ` blind ' for the charge dynamics , it does matter for the external observer and this gives rise to a particular simple factorizable form for the spin - spin correlation function measured by the latter . since this correlator is universal , the geometric structure which it reflects is also universal , and apparently even realized in the weak coupling ( tomonaga - luttinger ) limit . taking this geometrical principle as physical law , how does it generalize to a higher dimension ? the only feature of the embedding space which matters for the quantum antiferromagnet is the bipartiteness of the lattice . there are two ways of dividing a bipartite lattice in two sublattices and this defines a sublattice parity @xmath12 : @xmath13 or @xmath14 if the covering is @xmath15 or @xmath16 , respectively . divide now both the original- and the squeezed lattice in two sublattices : it is immediately seen that relative to the squeezed lattice the sublattice parity on the original lattice flips every time a hole is passed . the sublattice parity is the ` hidden ' @xmath9 symmetry ! this generalizes in a unique way to the d dimensional bipartite lattice . in order to keep the bipartiteness intact in the absence of the holes , the holes have to lie on d-1 dimensional manifolds . hence , in 2 + 1d the holes are localized on 1 + 1d manifolds : the stripes . these manifolds can be of arbitrary shape in principle : the stripe fluctuations . since the spin system on the higher dimensional squeezed lattice is unfrustrated , it will show long - range nel order . when the hole manifolds order , this spin order will also become manifest.we claim that this prescription is consistent with all available experiments on stripes . we emphasize that we take here a phenomenological stand : the reason that this happens should be given by microscopic theory and this is far from settled . however , if the interest is in the long wavelength behavior one might as well pose the principle and take it for granted as long as it is consistent with the experiments . in 2 + 1d the form of order described in the above can be destroyed in a way which is impossible in 1 + 1d : the stripe dislocation is the topological excitation of the ` topological ' ( sublattice parity ) order in 2 + 1 d. although it can be stated more precisely , it is already clear from fig . [ fig ] : the sublattice parity order of the upper part of the figure can not be matched with the lower part . more precisely , the space experienced by the spin system ( the squeezed lattice ) is no longer bipartite . this loss of bipartiteness , a frustration , is analogous to spatial curvature . in prior works @xcite , geometrically frustrated systems have been investigated on their own right- there frustration was incurred by the noncommuting nature of the generators of translation . in the present context , the frustration inherent in the loss of bipartiteness may be similarly reformulated in a geometrically precise manner @xcite . charge ( stripe ) dislocations destroy spin charge separation and act as gravitational sources for the spin texture . the analogy with gravity becomes more literal in the classical limit . consider @xmath17 and static dislocations . the nel order parameter texture is as indicated with the arrows in fig . 1 . this can be called a ` @xmath18-vortex ' ( see also @xcite ) , since it looks like ` half ' the topological excitation of a @xmath19 system . however , the spin system is @xmath10 invariant and the soliton of the @xmath10 system in 2 + 1d is the skyrmion , corresponding with a texture where the plane in which the order parameter rotates in internal space depends on the direction one takes in the embedding space . the rotation in fig . 1 is in a single plane ( like a vortex ) and therefore it does not carry a conserved topological spin charge . also notice that it is distinguished from a @xmath19 vortex because it carries a zero - mode . ascribe the rotation as indicated in the figure to the equator of the @xmath10 sphere . keeping the order parameter fixed at left- and right infinity , degenerate configurations are obtained by canting the order parameter ` above ' the dislocation in the direction of one of the poles . interestingly , the above is exactly reproduced by embedding a @xmath10 sigma model in a 2 + 1d space with a metric given by einstein theory in the presence of a mass source of strength @xmath20 ( @xmath21 is newton s constant and @xmath22 the mass ) . in this limit , stripe dislocations act like the famous ` conical singularities ' of 2 + 1d gravity @xcite . unfortunately , the stripe dislocations are not lorentz invariant , otherwise the semiclassical theory of quantum stripes would reduce to an exercise in 2 + 1d quantum gravity ! although these textures are non - topological , they are clearly ` disorder operators ' in the spin system and when the stripe dislocations are proliferated while their spin zero - modes are also disordered , they will destroy the nel order completely , giving rise to a dynamical mass - gap . however , there is a next subtlety : even when @xmath7 is chosen for the electrical charge quantum the theory can no longer be bosonic when free stripe dislocations are present . in order to see this , we have to go back to the lattice geometry . take the ogata - shiba prescription and remove the charge - stripes , substituting an anti - ferromagnetic bond for the lattice sites where the stripe reside . the lattice geometry as seen by the spins is as indicated in the inset of fig . [ fig ] . at the dislocation a ` pentagon ' plaquette is found and this is directly recognized as a spin frustration event causing minus signs which can not be transformed away . the ground state wave function of a nearest - neighbor heisenberg spin system on a bipartite lattice is nodeless . this is easily seen as follows . keep the spin operators on the @xmath23 sublattice fixed and regauge the spin - operators on the @xmath24 sublattice according to @xmath25 and @xmath26 which leaves the commutation relations unaffected . in the basis which is diagonal in the ising term , all off - diagonal matrix elements become negative and this means that the ground state wave function only contains positive definite amplitudes . repeating this on the squeezed spin lattice associated with the stripe dislocation , one finds a seam of positive bonds , starting at the dislocation and ending at infinity . the location of this seam is without physical meaning ; it is easily checked that by repeatedly applying the gauge transformations @xcite the sign - string can be moved arbitrarily through the plane , and the locus of the string is therefore a gauge freedom . elsewhere we will argue that the spin - system is also insensitive to the locus of the half - infinite stripe attached to the dislocation and this means that the stripe dislocation the stripe dislocation appears in the spin system as a quantum particle attached to infinity by the sign string . in the presence of irreducible signs mathematical physics comes to a grinding halt , and we are not aware of a precedent for the above sign structure . all one can say in general is that deep in the semi - classical regime signs are not immediately detrimental . studies of the @xmath27 model show that the nel state is robust against a substantial degree of geometrical frustration while the ( spin - peierls ) physics found at optimum frustration can be understood without referral to marshall signs@xcite . however , also in the semi - classical case one encounters a problem with the above , which now takes the shape of a wess - zumino - witten type berry phase@xcite . in the derivation of the semi - classical theory using the spin - coherent state path integral formalism one encounters imaginary terms in the euclidean action which are proportional to the topological ( berry- ) phase which takes care of the quantization of the microscopic spin . in a many - spin system it takes the form @xmath28 ( @xmath29 is imaginary time ) . in the 1 + 1d case and for large @xmath30 , this reduces to @xmath31 , where the integer @xmath32 is the skyrmion number associated with the order parameter texture in space - time . for half - integer spin this leads to alternating signs in the the quantum partition function and these are believed to be responsible for the collapse of the mass gap of the integer spin systems@xcite . it was pointed out that in the large @xmath30 limit these topological terms are inconsequential for the 2 + 1d quantum antiferromagnet on the bipartite lattice@xcite . this lattice can be divided into even and odd 1 + 1d rows , and the topological phase associated with the even ` chains ' exactly compensate those of the odd ` chains ' . consider now the stripe dislocation . computing the topological phase for the ` conical ' texture of fig . [ fig ] , we find that the compensation is no longer complete . the texture can be smoothly deformed because the phase itself is topological , and it is easily demonstrated that it corresponds precisely with the 1 + 1d topological phase associated with the additional row in the lattice of half - infinite length , starting at the dislocation . hence , even in the semi - classical case ` sign ' problems remain although it is not at all clear to us what these imply . what did we accomplish ? in fact very little . following the duality algorithm to the letter , we found that in combination with our understanding of the ` antiphase - boundarieness ' of the stripes a novel problem is generated . we have no clue regarding the nature of the solution of this problem . however , it is interesting to revisit the paradox discussed in the introduction . its signature was that it was not possible to simultaneously take stripes and nodal fermions seriously . in this stripe - duality framework this is no longer true . the paradox has been resolved to yield a question : could it be that the stripe - disorder fields support nodal fermion excitations ? let us first completely neglect the signs and in this case we know what to do . in the superconducting phase the world lines of the dislocations are winding around each other . to every world line a spin texture is attached of the kind as indicated in fig . the signature of the spin system as it appears in the inelastic neutron scattering suggests that the spin system can be considered as semiclassical and since the spin - wave velocity is large it might well be that the spins can follow the charge motions nearly instantaneously . the ` @xmath18-vortices ' are clearly disordering events in the spin system and , interestingly , they exert this disordering influence in the same way in all the directions in space . the ` @xmath18-vortex ' covers the half - infinite plane ` above ' ( fig . [ fig ] ) the dislocation and since the dislocation occurs at all ` vertical ' positions the spin system is disordered identically in all directions . a quantum fluid of ` @xmath18-vortices ' does not know about the directionally of stripes . this is a somewhat too rigorous resolution of the stripes - nodal fermion paradox : a dynamical mass gap should be generated in the spin sector and this gap should be rather uniform in momentum space , because of the isotropic disordering influence of the @xmath18-vortices . fortunately , there are the minus signs . although little can be said in general , they do cause destructive interferences and have a reputation to diminish spin - gaps in favor of massless spinon excitations . the effective spin problem to be solved is that of a quantum - antiferromagnet living on a bipartite lattice pierced by the local frustration events associated with the stripe dislocations which themselves are moving around quantum mechanically . is there any reason to exclude that this behaves like a d - wave superconductor ? we acknowledge stimulating discussions with s. a. kivelson , h. v. kruis , and o. y. osman . financial support was provided by the foundation for fundamental research on matter ( fom ) , which is sponsored by the netherlands organization of pure research ( nwo ) . j. orenstein and a. j. millis , science * 288 * , 468 ( 2000 ) . j. zaanen , nature * 404 * , 714 ( 2000 ) , and ref s therein . h. kleinert , `` gauge fields in condensed matter '' , vol i & ii ( world scientific , singapore , 1989 ) . t. senthil and m. p. a. fisher , physical review b * 60 * , 6893 ( 1999 ) . `` the theory of superconductivity in the high @xmath0 cuprates '' ( princeton univ . press , princeton , 1997 ) . s. a. kivelson and d. rokshar , phys . b * 41 * , 11693 ( 1990 ) . r. b. laughlin and d. pines , proc usa * 97 * , 28 ( 2000 ) . x. j. zhou _ et . science * 286 * , 268 ( 1999 ) ; z. x. shen _ et . j. zaanen , science * 286 * , 251 ( 1999 ) and ref.s therein . m. bosch , w. van saarloos and j. zaanen , cond - mat/0003236 . s. sachdev , science * 288 * , 475 ( 2000 ) . s. kivelson , e. fradkin , and v. j. emery , nature * 393 * , 550 ( 1998 ) l. balents and d. r. nelson , phys . b * 52 * , 12951 ( 1995 ) . h. v. kruis , z. nussinov , and j. zaanen ( in preparation ) o. zachar , cond - mat/9911171 . n. read and s. sachdev , nucl . b * 316 * , 609 ( 1989 ) ; m. s. l. du croo de jongh , j. m. j. van leeuwen and w. van saarloos , phys . b ( in press ) . e. fradkin , `` field theories of condensed matter physics '' ( addison - wesley , redwood city , usa , 1991 ) . f. d. m. haldane , phys . lett . * 50 * , 1153 ( 1988 ) .

one of the central conceptual problems in high @xmath0 superconductivity is to reconcile the abundant evidence for stripe - like physics at ` short ' distances with the equally convincing evidence for bcs - like physics at large distance scales ( the ` nodal fermions ' ) . our central hypothesis is that the duality notion applies : the superconductor should be viewed as a condensate of topological excitations associated with the fully ordered stripe phase . as we will argue , the latter are not only a form of ` straightforward ' spin and charge order but also involve a form of ` hidden ' or ` topological ' long range order which is also responsible for the phenomenon of spin - charge separation in 1 + 1d . the topological excitation associated with the destruction of this hidden order is of the most unusual kind . we suggest that the associated disorder field theory has a geometrical , gravity like structure concurrent with topological phases with no precedent elsewhere .

1602.05032

the problem of enumerating the strings in a language @xmath2 is to list all the elements in @xmath2 in some order . several papers study this problem . for example , enumerating all spanning trees , @xcite , minimal transversals for some geometric hypergraphs , @xcite , maximal cliques , @xcite , ordered trees , @xcite , certain cuts in graphs , @xcite , paths in a graph , @xcite , bipartite perfect matchings , @xcite , maximum and maximal matchings in bipartite graphs , @xcite , and directed spanning trees in a directed graph @xcite . see the list in @xcite for other enumeration problems . one of the challenges in enumeration problems is to find an order of the elements of @xmath2 such that finding the next element in that order can be done in quasilinear time in the length of the representation of the element . the time that the algorithm takes before giving the first element is called the _ preprocessing time_. the time of finding the next element is called the _ delay time_. in @xcite , ackerman and shallit gave a linear preprocessing and delay time for enumerating the words of any regular language ( expressed as a regular expression or nfa ) in lexicographic order . enumeration is also of interest to mathematicians without addressing the time complexity . calkin and wilf,@xcite , gave an enumeration of all the rational numbers such that the denominator of each fraction is the numerator of the next one . another problem that has received considerable attention is the problem of ranking the elements of @xmath2 . in ranking the goal is to find some total order on the elements of @xmath2 where the problem of returning the @xmath0th element in that order can be solved in polynomial time . obviously , polynomial time ranking implies polynomial time enumeration . in the literature , the problem of ranking is already solved for permutations @xcite and trees of special properties @xcite . those also give enumerating algorithms for such objects . let @xmath3 be a finite field with @xmath4 elements . let @xmath5 be the set of irreducible polynomials over @xmath3 of degree @xmath0 and their roots in @xmath6 . several algorithms in the literature use irreducible polynomials of degree @xmath0 over finite fields , especially algorithms in coding theory , cryptography and problems that use the chinese remainder theorem for polynomials @xcite . some other algorithms use only the roots of those polynomials . see for example @xcite . in this paper , we study the following problems 1 . enumeration of any number of irreducible polynomials of degree @xmath0 over a finite fields . 2 . enumeration of any number of irreducible polynomials of degree @xmath0 and their roots over the extended field . 3 . enumeration of any number of roots of irreducible polynomials of degree @xmath0 over the extended field . one root for each polynomial . there are many papers in the literature that mention the result of enumerating all the irreducible polynomials of degree _ less than or equal _ to @xmath0 but do not give the exact algebraic complexity of this problem @xcite . in this paper we give a detailed analysis of deterministic and randomized algorithms that enumerate any number of irreducible polynomials of degree @xmath0 over a finite field and/or their roots in the extension field in quasilinear where @xmath1 is the size of the output . ] time cost per element . our algorithm is based on an improved algorithm for enumerating all the lyndon words of length @xmath0 in linear delay time and the well known reduction of lyndon words to irreducible polynomials . in the next subsection we define the lyndon word and present the result of the improved algorithm . let @xmath7 be any total order on @xmath3 . a _ lyndon word _ ( or string ) over @xmath3 of length @xmath0 is a word @xmath8 where every rotation @xmath9 , @xmath10 of @xmath11 is lexicographically larger than @xmath11 . let @xmath12 be the set of all the lyndon words over @xmath3 of length @xmath0 . in many papers in the literature , it is shown that there is polynomial time ( in @xmath0 ) computable bijective function @xmath13 , where @xmath5 is the set of all polynomials of degree @xmath0 over @xmath3 . so the enumeration problem of the irreducible polynomials can be reduced to the problem of enumerating the elements of @xmath12 . bshouty gave in @xcite a large subset @xmath14 where any number of words in @xmath15 can be enumerated in a linear delay time . in fact , one can show that @xmath15 has a small dfa and , therefore , this result follows from @xcite . it is easy to show that the set @xmath12 can not be accepted by a small size nfa , i.e. , size polynomial in @xmath0 , so one can not generalize the above result to all @xmath12 . duval @xcite and fredricksen et . , @xcite gave enumeration algorithms of all the words in @xmath16 that run in linear delay time . berstel and pocchiola in @xcite and cattell et . al . in @xcite show that , in duval s algorithm , in order to find the next lyndon word in @xmath16 , the amortized number of _ updates _ is constant . the number of updtes is the number of symbols that the algorithm change in a lyndon word in order to get the next word . such an algorithm is called cat algorithm . see the references in @xcite for other cat algorithms . kociumaka et . al . gave an algorithm that finds the rank of a lyndon word in @xmath17 time and does unranking in @xmath18 time . in this paper , we give an enumeration algorithm of @xmath12 with linear delay time . our algorithm is the same as duval s algorithm with the addition of a simple data structure . we show that this data structure enable us to find the next lyndon word of _ length @xmath0 _ in constant updates per symbol and therefore in linear time . we also show that our algorithm is cat algorithm and give an upper bound for the amortized update cost . another problem is testing whether a word of length @xmath0 is lyndon word . in @xcite , duval gave a linear time algorithm for such test . in this paper we give a simple algorithm that uses the suffix trie data structure and runs in linear time . this paper is organized as follows . in section 2 we give the exact arithmetic complexity of the preprocessing and delay time for enumerating any number of irreducible polynomials and/or their roots . in section 3 we give a simple data structure that enable us to change duval s algorithm to an algorithm that enumerates all the lyndon words of length @xmath0 in linear delay time . we then show in section 4 that the algorithm is cat algorithm . in section 5 we give a simple linear time algorithm that tests whether a word is a lyndon word . in this section we give the analysis for the algebraic complexity of the preprocessing time and delay time of enumerating irreducible polynomials of degree @xmath0 over a finite field and/or their roots in the extended field . let @xmath4 be a power of a prime @xmath19 and @xmath20 be the finite field with @xmath4 elements . our goal is to enumerate all the irreducible polynomials of degree @xmath0 over @xmath3 and/or their roots in the extension field @xmath6 . the best deterministic algorithm for constructing an irreducible polynomial over @xmath3 of degree @xmath0 has time complexity @xmath21 for any @xmath22 . the best randomized algorithm has time complexity @xmath23 for any @xmath22 . for a comprehensive survey of this problem see @xcite chapter 3 obviously , the preprocessing time for enumerating irreducible polynomials can not be less than the time for constructing one . therefore , @xmath24 for the deterministic algorithm , and @xmath25 for the randomized algorithm . the main idea of the enumeration algorithm is to enumerate the roots of the irreducible polynomials in the extension field and then construct the polynomials from their roots . let @xmath6 be the extension field of @xmath3 of size @xmath26 . one possible representation of the elements of the field @xmath6 is by polynomials of degree at most @xmath27 in @xmath28/(f(\beta))$ ] where @xmath29 is an irreducible polynomial of degree @xmath0 . a _ normal basis _ of @xmath6 is a basis over @xmath3 of the form @xmath30 for some @xmath31 where @xmath32 is linearly independent . the _ normal basis theorem _ states that for every finite field @xmath6 there is a normal basis @xmath32 . that is , an @xmath33 for which @xmath32 is linearly independent over @xmath3 . it is known that such an @xmath33 can be constructed in deterministic time @xmath34 and randomized time @xmath35 the enumeration algorithm will use the normal basis for representing the elements of @xmath6 . notice that the time complexity to find such an element @xmath33 is less than constructing one irreducible polynomial . if we use the normal basis @xmath32 for the representation of the elements of @xmath6 , then every element @xmath36 has a unique representation @xmath37 where @xmath38 for all @xmath39 . it is known that any irreducible polynomial @xmath40 of degree @xmath0 over @xmath3 has @xmath0 distinct roots in @xmath6 . if one can find one root @xmath36 of @xmath40 then the other roots are @xmath41 and therefore @xmath42 . the coefficients of @xmath43 can be computed in quadratic time @xmath44 . see theorem a and b in @xcite and references within . the element @xmath37 is a root of an irreducible polynomial of degree @xmath0 if and only if @xmath45 are distinct . now since @xmath46 @xmath47 is a root of an irreducible polynomial of degree @xmath0 if and only if the following @xmath0 elements @xmath48 @xmath49 are distinct . when ( [ ddd ] ) happens then we call @xmath50 _ aperiodic word_. we will write @xmath51 as a word @xmath52 and define @xmath53 . therefore we have 1 . for any word @xmath54 the element @xmath55 is a root of an irreducible polynomial of degree @xmath0 if and only if @xmath51 is an aperiodic word . 2 . given an aperiodic word @xmath51 , the irreducible polynomial @xmath56 can be constructed in time ] @xmath57 . obviously , the aperiodic word @xmath58 and @xmath59 @xmath60 @xmath61 corresponds to the same irreducible polynomial . see ( [ pk ] ) . that is , @xmath62 for any @xmath63 . therefore to avoid enumerating the same polynomial more than once , the algorithm enumerates only the minimum element ( in lexicographic order ) among @xmath64 . such an element is called _ lyndon word_. therefore the word @xmath52 is called a lyndon word if @xmath65 for all @xmath66 . to enumerate all the irreducible polynomials the algorithm enumerates all the lyndon words of length @xmath0 and , for each one , it computes the corresponding irreducible polynomial . in the next section , we show how to enumerate all the lyndon words of length @xmath0 in linear delay time @xmath67 . then from @xmath55 ( that corresponds to an irreducible polynomial ) the algorithm constructs the irreducible polynomial @xmath68 and all the other @xmath27 roots in quadratic time @xmath69 . since the size of all the roots is @xmath70 , this complexity is quasilinear in the output size . for the problem of enumerating only the roots ( one root for each irreducible polynomial ) the delay time is @xmath67 . let @xmath12 be the set of all lyndon words over @xmath3 of length @xmath0 . we have shown how to reduce our problem to the problem of enumerating all the lyndon words over @xmath3 of length @xmath0 with linear delay time . algorithm `` enumerate '' in figure [ alg ] shows the reduction . putting all the above algebraic complexities together , we get the following let @xmath22 be any constant . there is a randomized enumeration algorithm for 1 . the irreducible polynomial over @xmath3 and their roots in @xmath6 in preprocessing time @xmath71 and delay time @xmath72 . 2 . the roots in @xmath6 of irreducible polynomials of degree @xmath0 over @xmath3 in preprocessing time @xmath71 and delay time @xmath67 . let @xmath22 be any constant . there is a deterministic enumeration algorithm for 1 . the irreducible polynomial over @xmath3 and their roots in @xmath6 in preprocessing time @xmath73 and delay time @xmath74 @xmath75 . 2 . the roots in @xmath6 of irreducible polynomials of degree @xmath0 over @xmath3 in preprocessing time @xmath76 and delay time @xmath67 . in this section we give duval s algorithm , @xcite , that enumerates all the lyndon words of length at most @xmath0 , @xmath77 , in linear delay time and change it to an algorithm that enumerates the lyndon words of length @xmath0 , @xmath12 in linear time . we will use a simple data structure that enable the algorithm to give the next lyndon word of length @xmath0 in duval s algorithm in a constant update per symbol and therefore in linear time . let @xmath78 be the alphabet with the order @xmath79 . we here identify @xmath3 with @xmath80 . we will sometime write the symbols in brackets . for example for @xmath81 the word @xmath82 ^ 2[q-3]$ ] is @xmath83 . let @xmath84 be a lyndon word for some @xmath85 . to find the next lyndon word , ( of length @xmath86 ) duval s algorithm first define the word @xmath87 of length @xmath0 where @xmath11 is a non - empty prefix of @xmath11 and @xmath88 ( and therefore @xmath89 ) . that is , @xmath90 . then if @xmath91 is of the form @xmath92^t$ ] where @xmath93 and @xmath94 $ ] then the next lyndon word in duval s algorithm is @xmath95 $ ] . we denote the next lyndom word of @xmath11 ( in duval s algorithm ) by @xmath96 . for example , for @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 , @xmath100 and @xmath101 . then @xmath102 . the following lemma is well known . we give the proof for completeness [ increase ] if @xmath11 is a lyndon word and @xmath103 then @xmath104 . let @xmath105^t$ ] where @xmath94 $ ] . then @xmath106 because otherwise we would have @xmath107^tu < ub[q-1]^t = w$ ] and then @xmath11 is not a lyndon word . let @xmath108 where @xmath88 and @xmath109 is a nonempty prefix of @xmath11 . since @xmath110 we have @xmath111 . since @xmath112 , we have that @xmath113 in this subsection we give the data structure and the algorithm that finds the next lyndon word of length @xmath0 in linear time . we note here that , in the literature , the data structure that is used for the lyndon word is an array of symbols . all the analyses of the algorithms in the literature treat an access to an element in an @xmath0 element array and comparing it to another symbol as an operation of time complexity equal to @xmath114 . the complexity of incrementing / decrementing an index @xmath115 of an array of length @xmath0 and comparing two such indices are not included in the complexity . in this paper , the lyndon words are represented with symbols and _ numbers _ in the range @xmath116 $ ] . every access to an element in this data structure and comparison between two elements are ( as in literature ) counted as an operation of time complexity equal @xmath114 . operations that are done on the indices of the array ( as in literature ) are not counted but their time complexity is linear in the number of updates . let @xmath117 . we define the _ compressed representation _ of @xmath91 as @xmath118^{i_1}v^{(1)}[q-1]^{i_2}\cdots v^{(t-1)}[q-1]^{i_t}$ ] where @xmath119 are not zero ( @xmath120 may equal to zero ) and @xmath121 are nonempty words that do not contain the symbol @xmath82 $ ] . if @xmath91 do not contain the symbol @xmath82 $ ] then @xmath118 ^ 0 $ ] where @xmath82 ^ 0 $ ] is the empty word and @xmath122 . the data structure will be an array ( or double link list ) that contains @xmath123 if @xmath124 and @xmath125 otherwise . define @xmath126 . this is the _ compressed length _ of the compressed representation of @xmath91 . notice that for a word @xmath127 that ends with a symbol @xmath128 $ ] we have @xmath129 $ ] and for @xmath130^i$ ] we have @xmath131 . therefore @xmath132 . let @xmath118^{i_1}v^{(1)}[q-1]^{i_2}\cdots v^{(t-1)}[q-1]^{i_t}$ ] be any lyndon word of length @xmath0 . the next lyndon word in duval s algorithm is @xmath133^{i_1}v^{(1)}[q-1]^{i_2}\cdots [ q-1]^{i_{t-1}}\cdot p(v^{(t-1)})\ ] ] to find the next lyndon word @xmath134 after @xmath135 we take @xmath136 of length @xmath0 where @xmath137 is a nonempty prefix of @xmath135 and then @xmath138 . this is because @xmath139 $ ] . since by lemma [ increase ] , @xmath140 we will eventually get a lyndon word of length @xmath0 we now show that using the compressed representation we have [ kkk]the time complexity of computing @xmath141 from @xmath142 is at most @xmath143 . let @xmath144^{i_1}w^{(1)}[q-1]^{i_2}\cdots w^{(t-1)}[q-1]^{i_t}$ ] of length less than @xmath0 . then @xmath145 where @xmath146 is a nonempty prefix of @xmath142 . so it is enough to show that @xmath147 can be computed in at most @xmath148 time . notice that the length of @xmath146 is @xmath149 ( here the mod is equal to @xmath150 if @xmath150 divides @xmath0 ) . since @xmath146 is a prefix of @xmath142 we have that , in the compressed representation , @xmath151^{i_1}w^{(1)}[q-1]^{i_2}\cdots w^{(t'-1)}[q-1]^{i_{t'}}$ ] for some @xmath152 . then @xmath153^{i_1}w^{(1)}[q-1]^{i_2}\cdots p(w^{(t'-1)})$ ] . therefore the complexity of computing @xmath147 is @xmath154 from the above lemma it follows that [ th3 ] let @xmath91 be a lyndon word of length @xmath0 . using the compressed representation , the next lyndon word of length @xmath0 can be computed in linear time . to compress @xmath91 and find @xmath155 we need a linear time . by lemma [ increase ] the lyndon words after @xmath91 are @xmath156 where @xmath157 . by lemma [ kkk ] the time complexity of computing the next lyndon word @xmath158 of length @xmath0 is @xmath159 . then decompressing the result takes linear time . we now give a case where duval s algorithm fails to give the next lyndon word of length @xmath0 in linear time . consider the lyndon word @xmath160 of length @xmath161 . the next lyndon word in duval s algorithm is @xmath162 . then @xmath163 to get to the next lyndon word of length @xmath0 , @xmath164 , the algorithm does @xmath165 updates . in this section , we show that our algorithm in the previous section is cat algorithm . that is , it has a constant amortized update cost . we first give some notation and preliminary results . let @xmath166 be the number of lyndon words of length @xmath0 , @xmath167 for all @xmath168 and @xmath169 . it is known from @xcite that for @xmath170 and any @xmath4 @xmath171 and for any @xmath0 and @xmath4 @xmath172 and @xmath173 denote by @xmath174 the number of lyndon words of length @xmath0 of the form @xmath105^i$ ] where @xmath175 . then @xmath176 . let @xmath177 be the number of lyndon words of length @xmath0 that ends with the symbol @xmath178 $ ] . that is , of the form @xmath179 $ ] . for the analysis we will use the following . let @xmath105^t\in \sigma^n$ ] where @xmath175 and @xmath180 . if @xmath105^t$ ] is a lyndon word of length @xmath0 then @xmath181 $ ] is a lyndon word . in particular , @xmath182 if @xmath183 $ ] is a lyndon word of length @xmath0 then @xmath184 $ ] is a lyndon word . in particular , @xmath185 [ klkl ] if @xmath105^t$ ] is lyndon word of length @xmath0 then the next lyndon word in duvel s algorithm is @xmath186^t))=p(ub[q-1]^t)=u[b+1]$ ] . if @xmath183 $ ] is a lyndon word of length @xmath0 then @xmath187 $ ] is the next lyndon word in duvel s algorithm . the amortized number of updates of listing all the lyndon words of length at most @xmath0 in duval s algorithm is @xcite @xmath188 we now show that using the compressed representation the amortized number of updates for enumerating all the lyndon words of length exactly @xmath0 is at most @xmath189 the number of lyndon words of length @xmath0 of the forms @xmath190 where @xmath191 , @xmath192 $ ] and @xmath193 $ ] is @xmath194 . the next word of length @xmath0 is @xmath181 $ ] . so each such word takes one update to find the next word . for words that end with the symbol @xmath178 $ ] we need to change this symbol to @xmath82 $ ] and plausibly merge it with the previous one in the compressed representation . this takes at most two updates . one for removing this symbol and one for merging it with the cells of the form @xmath82^t$ ] . therefore for such words we need @xmath195 updates . thus , for lyndon words that do not ends with @xmath82 $ ] we need @xmath196 updates . for strings of the form @xmath105^t$ ] where @xmath192 $ ] and @xmath180 we need at most @xmath197 updates and therefore at most @xmath198 for all such words . see the proof of theorem [ th3 ] . therefore , the total updates is at most @xmath199 by lemma [ klkl ] , this is at most @xmath200 now , the amortized update is @xmath201 by ( [ one ] ) , ( [ two ] ) and ( [ three ] ) we get @xmath202 in this subsection , we study the complexity of deciding membership in @xmath12 . that is , given a word @xmath203 . decide whether @xmath204 is in @xmath12 . since @xmath205 if and only if for all @xmath206 , @xmath207 , and each comparison of two words of length @xmath0 takes @xmath67 operations , membership can be decided in time @xmath70 . duval in @xcite gave a linear time algorithm . in this subsection , we give a simple algorithm that decides membership in linear time . to this end , we need to introduce the suffix tree data structure . the suffix tree of a word @xmath208 is a trie that contains all the suffixes of @xmath208 . see for example the suffix tree of the word @xmath209 in figure [ suffixtree ] . a suffix tree of a word @xmath208 of length @xmath0 can be constructed in linear time in @xmath0 @xcite . using the suffix tree , one can check if a word @xmath210 of length @xmath211 is a suffix of @xmath208 in time @xmath212 . denote by @xmath213 the suffix tree of @xmath208 . define any order @xmath7 on the symbols of @xmath208 . define min@xmath214 as follows : start from the root of the trie and follow , at each node , the edges with the minimal symbol . then min@xmath214 is the word that corresponds to this path . one can find this word in @xmath213 in time that is linear in its length . the function @xmath215 defines the following total order @xmath216 on the suffixes : let @xmath217 . take @xmath218 as the minimum element in that order . now remove this word from @xmath219 and take @xmath218 as the next one in that order . repeat the above until the tree is empty . for example , if @xmath220 then the order in the suffix tree in figure [ suffixtree ] is @xmath221 obviously , for two suffixes @xmath208 and @xmath222 , @xmath223 if and only if for @xmath224 we have @xmath225 ( in the lexicographic order ) . we define @xmath226 the suffix tree of the suffixes of @xmath208 of length at least @xmath227 . we can construct @xmath226 in linear time in @xmath228 by taking a walk in the suffix tree @xmath213 and remove all the words of length less than @xmath227 . in the same way as above , we define @xmath229 . the algorithm is in figure [ alg02 ] . we use lemma [ cond01 ] . the algorithm constructs the trie @xmath235 . the construction takes linear time in @xmath255 and therefore linear time in @xmath0 . finding @xmath256 in a trie takes linear time . f. ashari - ghomi , n. khorasani , a. nowzari - dalini . ranking and unranking algorithms for k - ary trees in gray code order . international scholarly and scientific research & innovation . . 833838 . ( 2012 ) k. cattell , f. ruskey , j. sawada , m. serra , c. r. miers . fast algorithms to generate necklaces , unlabeled necklaces , and irreducible polynomials over gf(2 ) . _ j. algorithms . _ 267 - 282 .

in this paper we give a detailed analysis of deterministic and randomized algorithms that enumerate any number of irreducible polynomials of degree @xmath0 over a finite field and their roots in the extension field in quasilinear where @xmath1 is the size of the output . ] time cost per element . our algorithm is based on an improved algorithm for enumerating all the lyndon words of length @xmath0 in linear delay time and the known reduction of lyndon words to irreducible polynomials .

astro-ph0207320

one of the main observational results stemming from five years of @xmath7-ray burst ( grb ) follow - ups at optical wavelengths is that about @xmath8 of well - localized grbs lack a detected optical afterglow , ( `` dark bursts '' ; taylor et al . 2000 ; fynbo et al . 2001 ; reichart & yost 2001 ; lazzati , covino , & ghisellini 2002 ) . in some cases , a non - detection of the optical afterglow could simply be due to a failure to image quickly and/or deeply enough . however , there are two grbs for which there is strong evidence that the optical emission should have been detected , based on an extrapolation of the radio and x - ray emission ( djorgovski et al . 2001a ; piro et al . 2002 ) . one interpretation in these two cases is that the optical light was extinguished by dust , either within the immediate environment of the burst or elsewhere along the line of sight ( e.g. groot et al . 1998 ) . an alternative explanation is a high redshift , leading to absorption of the optical light in the ly@xmath9 forest . however , the redshifts of the underlying host galaxies of these grbs are of order unity ( djorgovski et al . 2001a ; piro et al . 2002 ) . several authors have recently argued that a large fraction of the dark bursts are due to dust extinction within the local environment of the bursts ( e.g. reichart & yost 2001 ; lazzati et al . 2002 ; reichart & price 2002 ) , but other scenarios have also been suggested ( e.g. lazzati et al . 2002 ) . moreover , it has been noted that regardless of the location of extinction within the host galaxy , the fraction of dark bursts is a useful upper limit on the fraction of obscured star formation ( kulkarni et al . 2000 ; djorgovski et al . 2001b ; ramirez - ruiz , trentham , & blain 2002 ; reichart & price 2002 ) . however , from an observational point of view , we must have a clear understanding of the diversity of afterglow properties before extracting astrophysically interesting inferences from dark bursts . for example , afterglows which are faint or fade rapidly ( relative to the detected population ) would certainly bias the determination of the fraction of truly obscured bursts . in this vein , fynbo et al . ( 2001 ) , noting the faint optical afterglow of grb000630 , argued that some dark bursts are due to a failure to image deeply and/or quickly enough , rather than dust extinction . here we present optical and radio observations of , an afterglow that would have been classified dark had it not been for rapid and deep searches . furthermore , is an example of an afterglow , which is dim due to the combination of intrinsic faintness and a relatively fast decline , and not strong extinction . , localized by the hete - ii satellite on 2002 , jan 24.44531 ut , had a duration of @xmath10 s and a fluence ( @xmath11 kev ) of @xmath12 erg @xmath13 ( ricker et al . eight minutes after receiving the coordinates we observed the error box with the dual - band ( @xmath14 , @xmath15 ) macho imager mounted on the robotic 50-in telescope at the mount stromlo observatory ( mso ) . we also observed the error box with the wide - field imager on the 40-in telescope at siding spring observatory ( sso ) . we were unable to identify a transient source within the large error box ( price , schmidt , & axelrod 2002 ) . we subsequently observed the error box refined by the inter - planetary network ( hurley et al . 2002 ) with the palomar 48-in oschin schmidt using the unfiltered neat imager . psf - matched image subtraction ( alard 2000 ) between the macho and neat images revealed a fading source ( price et al . 2002 ) , which was @xmath16 mag at the epoch of our first observations , and not present in the digitized sky survey . two nights later we observed the afterglow using the jacobs camera ( jcam ; bloom et al . 2002b ) mounted at the east arm focus of the palomar 200-in telescope ( bloom et al . the position of the fading source is @xmath9(j2000)= , @xmath17(j2000)= , with an uncertainty of about @xmath18 arcsec in each coordinate ( fig . [ fig : field ] ) . using the very large array ( vla ) we observed the fading source at 8.46 and 22.5 ghz ( see table [ tab : rad ] ) . we detect a faint source , possibly fading , at 8.46 ghz located at @xmath9(j2000)= , @xmath17(j2000)= , with an uncertainty of about @xmath19 arcsec in each coordinate . given the positional coincidence between the fading optical source and radio detection we suggest this source to be the afterglow of . the optical images were bias - subtracted and flat - fielded in the standard manner . to extract the photometry we weighted the aperture with a gaussian equivalent to the seeing disk ( `` weighted - aperture photometry '' ) , using iraf / wphot . the photometric zero - points were set through photometry of calibrated field stars ( henden 2002 ) with magnitudes transformed to the appropriate system ( bessell & germany 1999 ; smith et al . the photometry is summarized in tab . [ tab : opt ] we observed the afterglow with the _ hubble space telescope _ ( hst ) using the space telescope imaging spectrograph ( stis ) on 2002 feb . 11.09 , 18.30 , and 25.71 ut ( bloom et al . 2002a ) , as part of our large hst cycle 10 program ( go-9180 , pi : kulkarni ) . the hst observations consisted of 750850 sec exposures . the hst data were retrieved after `` on - the - fly '' pre - processing . using iraf we drizzled ( fruchter & hook 2002 ) each image onto a grid with pixels smaller than the original by a factor of two and using pixfrac of 0.7 . we found an astrometric tie between the hst and jcam images using iraf / geomap with nine suitable astrometric tie objects in common between the images . the rms of the resultant mapping is 133 mas ( ra ) and 124 mas ( dec ) . using this mapping and iraf / geoxytrans we transfered the afterglow position on the jcam image to the hst images . the rms of the transformation is 604 mas ( ra ) and 596 mas ( dec ) , and is dominated by the uncertainty in the jcam position . the source `` s1 '' ( fig . [ fig : hst ] ) coincides with the afterglow position within the astrometric uncertainty . we performed differential photometry at the position of s1 by registering the images of epochs 1 and 2 using a cross - correlation of a field of size 10 arcsec centered on s1 ( using iraf / crosscor and shiftfind ) . we used iraf / center and the fwhm of a relatively bright point source ( `` psf star '' ; fig . [ fig : field ] ) to fix the position of s1 in each of the final images , and to determine the uncertainty in the position . we photometered the source ( and the psf star ) in epoch 1 using iraf / phot , and determined a count - rate of @xmath20 e@xmath21 s@xmath22 ( corrected by @xmath23 for the loss of flux from an infinite aperture radius ) . using iraf / synphot and assuming a source spectrum of @xmath24 ( see below ) , we find that the source was @xmath25 mag at the time of epoch 1 . the photometry of the three epochs is summarized in tab . [ tab : opt2 ] . please note that this more careful analysis supersedes our preliminary report ( bloom et al . 2002c ) . there are no obvious persistent sources within 1.75 arcsec of the ot down to @xmath26 mag . to date , all of the grbs localized to sub - arcsecond accuracy have viable hosts brighter than this level within @xmath27 arcsec of the ot position ( bloom , kulkarni , & djorgovski 2002 ) . the faintest host to date is that of grb990510 , @xmath28 mag ( z=1.619 ; vreeswijk et al . 2001 ) . thus , the host of may be at a somewhat higher redshift ; however , @xmath29 since the afterglow was detected in the @xmath14 filter . in figure [ fig : opt ] we plot the optical lightcurves of , including a correction for galactic extinction , @xmath30 mag ( schlegel et al . the optical lightcurves are usually modeled as @xmath31 . however , as can be seen in fig . [ fig : opt ] , the @xmath32-band lightcurve can not be described by a single power law . restricting the fit to @xmath33 days we obtain ( @xmath34 for 14 degrees of freedom ) @xmath35 , @xmath36 , and @xmath37 @xmath38jy ; here @xmath39 is defined at the effective frequency of the @xmath15 filter and @xmath40 day . for @xmath41 days we get @xmath42 . to account for the steepening we modify the model for the @xmath32-band lightcurve to : @xmath43^{1/n } , \label{eqn : model2}\ ] ] where , @xmath44 is the asymptotic index for @xmath45 , @xmath46 is the asymptotic index for @xmath47 , @xmath48 provides a smooth joining of the two asymptotic segments , and @xmath49 is the time at which the asymptotic segments intersect . we retain the simple model for the @xmath15 and @xmath14 lightcurves since they are restricted to @xmath50 days ( i.e. well before the observed steepening ) . we investigate two alternatives for the observed steepening in the framework of the afterglow synchrotron model ( e.g. sari , piran , & narayan 1998 ) . in this framework , @xmath44 , @xmath46 , and @xmath51 are related to each other through the index ( @xmath52 ) of the electron energy distribution , @xmath53 ( for @xmath54 ) . the relations for the models discussed below , as well as the resulting closure relations , @xmath55 , are summarized in tab . [ tab : models ] . the observed steepening , @xmath56 , can be due to the passage of the synchrotron cooling frequency , @xmath57 , through the @xmath32-band . this has been inferred , for example , in the afterglow of grb971214 , at @xmath58 days ( wijers & galama 1999 ) . if the steepening is due to @xmath57 , this rules out models in which the ejecta expand into a circumburst medium with @xmath59 ( hereafter , wind ) , because in this model @xmath57 increases with time ( @xmath60 ; chevalier & li 1999 ) , and one expects @xmath61 . there are two remaining models to consider in this case : ( i ) spherical expansion into a circumburst medium with constant density ( hereafter , @xmath62 ; sari , piran , & narayan 1998 ) , and ( ii ) a jet with @xmath63 ( i.e. a jet break prior to the first observation at @xmath64 days ; hereafter , @xmath65 ) . the subscript b indicates that @xmath57 is blueward of the optical bands initially . in both models we use eqn . [ eqn : model2 ] for the @xmath32-band lightcurve , with @xmath49 defined as the time at which @xmath66 , and @xmath67 . we find that in the @xmath62 model @xmath68 days , while in the @xmath65 model @xmath69 days . moreover , in both models the closure relations can only be satisfied by including a contribution from dust extinction within the host galaxy , @xmath70 . we estimate the required extinction using the parametric extinction curves of cardelli , clayton , & mathis ( 1989 ) and fitzpatrick & massa ( 1988 ) , along with the interpolation calculated by reichart ( 2001 ) . since the redshift of is not known we assume @xmath71 , which spans the range of typical redshifts for the long - duration grbs . the inferred values of @xmath72 are summarized in tab . [ tab : models ] , and range from 0.2 to 0.9 mag . an alternative explanation for the steepening is a jet expanding into : ( i ) an ism medium with @xmath57 blueward of the optical bands ( j-@xmath73 ) , ( ii ) a wind medium with @xmath57 blueward of the optical bands ( j-@xmath74 ) , and ( iii ) an ism or wind medium with @xmath57 redward of the optical bands ( j-@xmath75 ) . we note that the j-@xmath62 model is different than the @xmath62 model ( [ sec : cooling ] ) since previously it was defined such that the jet break is later than the last observation . in these models , @xmath76 is the time at which @xmath77 . from the closure values we note that the j-@xmath75 requires no extinction within the host galaxy , while the j-@xmath62 and j-@xmath74 models require values of about @xmath78 to @xmath79 mag . we find @xmath80 days , corresponding to @xmath81 . using the measured fluence ( [ sec : opt ] ) we estimate the beaming - corrected @xmath7-ray energy , @xmath82 erg , assuming a circumburst density of 1 @xmath83 and @xmath84 ( @xmath85 is a weak function of @xmath86 ) . this value is in good agreement with the distribution of @xmath85 for long - duration grbs ( frail et al . regardless of the specific model for the afterglow emission , the main conclusion of [ sec : model ] is that the optical afterglow of suffered little or no dust extinction . still , this afterglow would have been missed by typical searches undertaken even as early as 12 hours after the grb event . as shown in fig . [ fig : rlims ] , about @xmath87 of the searches conducted to date would have failed to detect an optical afterglow like that of . this is simply because the afterglow of was faint and exhibited relatively rapid decay . from fig . [ fig : alpha_f0 ] we note that is one of the faintest afterglows detected to date ( normalized to @xmath40 day ) , and while it is not an excessively rapid fader , it is in the top @xmath88 in this category . thus , the afterglow of , along with that of grb000630 ( fynbo et al . 2001 ; fig . [ fig : alpha_f0 ] ) , indicates that there is a wide diversity in the brightness and decay rates of optical afterglows . in fact , the brightness distribution spans a factor of about 400 , while the decay index varies by more than a factor of three . coupled with the low dust extinction in the afterglow of , this indicates that some dark bursts may simply be dim , and not dust obscured . given this wide diversity in the brightness of optical afterglows , it is important to establish directly that an afterglow is dust obscured . this has only been done in a few cases ( [ sec : intro ] ) . therefore , while _ statistical _ analyses ( e.g. reichart & yost 2001 ) point to extinction as the underlying reason for some fraction of dark bursts , and may even account for an afterglow like that of , it is clear that observationally the issue of dark bursts is not settled , and the observational biases have not been traced fully . since progress in our understanding of dark bursts will benefit from observations , we need consistent , rapid follow - up of a large number of bursts to constrain the underlying distribution , as well as complementary techniques which can directly measure material along the line of sight . this includes x - ray observations which allow us to measure the column density to the burst ( galama & wijers 2001 ) , and thus infer the type of environment , and potential extinction level . along the same line , radio observations allow us to infer the synchrotron self - absorption frequency , which is sensitive to the ambient density ( e.g. sari & esin 2001 ) ; the detection of radio emission , as in the case of , implies a density @xmath89 @xmath83 . finally , prompt optical observations , as we have carried out in this case , may uncover a larger fraction of the dim optical afterglows , and provide a better constraint on the fraction of truly obscured bursts . j. s. b. is a fannie and john hertz foundation fellow . f. a. h. acknowledges support from a presidential early career award . s. r. k. and s. g. d. thank the nsf for support . r. s. is grateful for support from a nasa atp grant . r. s. and t. j. g. acknowledge support from the sherman fairchild foundation . j. c. w. acknowledges support from nasa grant nag59302 . k. h. is grateful for ulysses support under jpl contract 958056 and for ipn support under nasa grants fdnag 5 - 11451 and nag 5 - 17100 . support for proposal hst - go-09180.01-a was provided by nasa through a grant from the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc . , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 . lccl 0.1 in jan 24.51204 & mso50 & @xmath15 & @xmath90 + jan 24.51204 & mso50 & @xmath14 & @xmath91 + jan 24.51516 & sso40 & @xmath32 & @xmath92 + jan 24.51655 & mso50 & @xmath15 & @xmath93 + jan 24.51655 & mso50 & @xmath14 & @xmath94 + jan 24.51938 & sso40 & @xmath32 & @xmath95 + jan 24.52106 & mso50 & @xmath15 & @xmath96 + jan 24.52106 & mso50 & @xmath14 & @xmath97 + jan 24.52373 & sso40 & @xmath32 & @xmath98 + jan 24.55791 & mso50 & @xmath15 & @xmath99 + jan 24.55791 & mso50 & @xmath14 & @xmath100 + jan 24.56243 & mso50 & @xmath15 & @xmath101 + jan 24.56243 & mso50 & @xmath14 & @xmath102 + jan 24.56696 & mso50 & @xmath15 & @xmath103 + jan 24.56696 & mso50 & @xmath14 & @xmath104 + jan 26.34100 & p200 & @xmath105 & @xmath106 lccccc 0.1 in feb 11.09 & @xmath107ccd / clear & 10.0 & @xmath108 & 4.82 & @xmath109 + feb 18.30 & @xmath107ccd / clear & 7.4 & @xmath110 & 2.34 & @xmath111 + feb 25.71 & @xmath107ccd / clear & 7.5 & @xmath112 & 1.98 & @xmath113 + feb 18.30 + 25.71 & @xmath107ccd / clear & 14.9 & @xmath114 & 2.91 & @xmath115 lccccccc 0.1 in @xmath62 & @xmath121 & @xmath122 & @xmath123 & ( @xmath124 ) & @xmath125 & @xmath126 & ( @xmath127 ) + @xmath65 & @xmath128 & @xmath128 & @xmath123 & ( @xmath129 ) & @xmath130 & @xmath131 & ( @xmath132 ) + j-@xmath62 & @xmath121 & @xmath128 & @xmath123 & ( @xmath124 ) & @xmath125 & @xmath133 & ( @xmath134 ) + j-@xmath74 & @xmath135 & @xmath128 & @xmath123 & ( @xmath136 ) & @xmath137 & @xmath138 & ( @xmath139 ) + j-@xmath75 & @xmath140 & @xmath128 & @xmath141 & ( @xmath142 ) & @xmath143 & @xmath144 &

we present ground - based optical observations of starting 1.6 hours after the burst , as well as subsequent very large array ( vla ) and _ hubble space telescope _ ( hst ) observations . the optical afterglow of is one of the faintest afterglows detected to date , and it exhibits a relatively rapid decay , @xmath0 , followed by further steepening . in addition , a weak radio source was found coincident with the optical afterglow . the hst observations reveal that a positionally coincident host galaxy must be the faintest host to date , @xmath1 mag . the afterglow observations can be explained by several models requiring little or no extinction within the host galaxy , @xmath2 mag . these observations have significant implications for the statistics of the so - called dark bursts ( bursts for which no optical afterglow is detected ) , which are usually attributed to dust extinction within the host galaxy . the faintness and relatively rapid decay of the afterglow of , combined with the low inferred extinction indicate that some dark bursts are intrinsically dim and not dust obscured . thus , the diversity in the underlying properties of optical afterglows must be observationally determined before substantive inferences can be drawn from the statistics of dark bursts . # 1#2#3#1@xmath3#2@xmath4#3@xmath5 # 1#2#3@xmath6

0912.4469

there is current interest ( see , for instance , refs . ) in studying inverse transitions , melting or freezing , motivated by the quite unconventional situation present in such transitions in which the ordered phase is more entropic than the disordered one @xcite . this apparent counter - intuitive transition has become even more interesting since there are now various physical systems displaying this kind of transition , as for example , magnetic films @xcite and , particularly , high-@xmath0 superconductors @xcite . therefore , the knowledge about which conditions are necessary for the existence of inverse transitions is a challenging issue @xcite . among the proposed classical magnetic models which can show inverse transitions , the blume capel ( bc ) @xcite and the gathak - sherrington ( gs ) @xcite models can be useful to clarify what would be such conditions . for instance , the phase diagram of the bc model @xcite displays inverse melting with a phase transition from the ferromagnetic ( @xmath1 ) phase to the paramagnetic ( @xmath2 ) one when the temperature is decreased . however , in order to obtain inverse melting in the bc model , it is strictly necessary to impose in the problem the entropic advantage of the interacting state through parameter @xmath3 , where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are the degeneracy of @xmath6 and @xmath7 spins states , respectively @xcite . in contrast with the bc model , the gs model @xcite - which is similar to the the bc model except that it has the spins couplings given as random gaussian variables - shows naturally inverse freezing . in other words , there is a reentrant first order boundary phase separating the spin glass ( @xmath8 ) and @xmath2 phases . however , there is no need of any entropic advantage of interacting states @xcite . the previous discussion suggests that the randomness is responsible for producing naturally inverse freezing in the gs model as compared with the inverse melting case in the bc model . in fact , to be more precise , it seems that the presence of non - trivial form of randomness , which means frustration , @xcite would be the essential ingredient which allows inverse freezing in the gs model with no need of entropic advantage . that sets some questions : what is the actual role of non - trivial randomness to produce naturally inverse freezing ? is this natural inverse freezing robust when the level of frustration is diminished ? can models with trivial randomness present naturally inverse transitions ? the purpose of the present work is to investigate what is the actual role of frustration as a basic condition to produce naturally inverse freezing . that could be achieved by comparing two distinct situations , the trivial randomness and the highly frustrated regime and also studying how natural inverse freezing would be affected when the level of frustration is varied . therefore , the problem is not only to find a random magnetic model which presents naturally inverse freezing , but also to get one which allows the level of frustration to vary . quite recently , the fermionic ising spin - glass ( fisg ) model @xcite has been proposed as a model able to display naturally inverse freezing in a phase diagram temperature _ versus _ the chemical potential @xmath9 . this model has the spin operators @xmath10 given as bilinear combinations of creation and destruction fermionic operators which have four eigenstates , two of them non - magnetic @xcite . the spin - spin coupling @xmath11 , likewise the gs model , is a random variable which follows a gaussian distribution . indeed , the existence of inverse freezing in this model could be expected since there is a close relationship between the gs and the fisg models @xcite . for instance , the partition function of these two models can be related by a mapping between the anisotropy constant @xmath12 of the gs model and @xmath9 @xcite . the fisg model is also useful to examine how quantum effects , included by the presence of a transverse field @xmath13 @xcite can affect inverse freezing . in ref . , it has been shown that , when @xmath13 is increased , the reentrance in the @xmath14 first order boundary phase in the phase diagram temperature @xmath15 _ versus _ the chemical potential @xmath9 gradually disappears . this scenario also suggests that @xmath13 in the fisg model plays the opposite role of the rather artificial parameter @xmath16 in the bc model discussed in ref . . nevertheless , the fisg model , in its original form with gaussian random couplings , is a strongly frustrated model . therefore , it is not possible to investigate in this model how the change of the level of frustration could affect the inverse freezing . an alternative route to accomplish the previously mentioned investigation would be to use the fisg model in a version in which one could adjust the level of frustration . in that sense , the classical hopfield spin glass @xcite can be quite useful . in this model , the interactions @xmath11 between classical ising spins are given below : @xmath17 where @xmath18 ( @xmath19 or @xmath20 , @xmath21 is the number of sites ) are independent random distributed variables . this type of interaction has been intensively used to study complex systems @xcite . there are clearly two extreme cases for the classical hopfield ising spin glass model . when @xmath22 , it becomes the mattis model @xcite , which is a well known example of trivial randomness @xcite . the second one is when @xmath23 . in that limit , the thermodynamics corresponds to the strongly frustrated regime given by a random gaussian distributed @xmath11 @xcite . in particular , the replica symmetric mean field solution of the classical hopfield spin glass model @xcite can provide a useful method for the purposes of the present work . it is described in terms of two order parameters , the usual spin glass @xmath24 and @xmath25 which indicates the presence of mattis states that have a thermodynamics similar to the usual ferromagnetism @xcite . most important , there is a parameter called here degree of frustration , @xmath26 which allows controlling the level of frustration in the theory . it is important to remark that there is a particular value @xmath27 which for @xmath28 the effects of frustration are dominant @xcite . as a consequence , it is possible to interpolate the thermodynamics from the trivial randomness ( @xmath29 ) to the strongly frustrated regime ( @xmath28 ) . therefore , to answer the questions arisen previously , we use the hopfield fermionic ising spin glass ( hfisg ) model . in this case , the spin operators @xmath30 are defined as the fisg model , but the random spin coupling @xmath11 is given as eq . ( [ hebb ] ) . the partition function is obtained in the functional integral formalism using grassmann fields where the disorder is treated with the replica method @xcite . the problem can be reduced to a one - site problem by using a similar procedure to solve the classical hopfield spin glass @xcite within the static approximation ( sa ) @xcite and one - step replica symmetry breaking ( 1s - rsb ) @xcite . it should be remarked that in the hfisg model , as the fisg one @xcite , the replica diagonal component of the sg order parameter @xmath31 appears as an additional order parameter to be solved with the others . particularly , this order parameter represents the spin self - interaction that has an imaginary time dependence for quantum sg models @xcite . however , the spin operators @xmath32 commute with the hamiltonian operators for the present hfisg model . consequently , the @xmath31 has no dynamic , which means that the sa is exact in the present work@xcite . one important point in the present work is how to locate first order boundaries phases found for different degrees of frustration . the criterion adopted here follows closely that one suggested in ref . for the classical @xmath33 model . hence , we selected , from the set of spin glass solutions in the transition , that one which meets continuously with the spin glass solution for small value of the chemical potential @xmath9 . in fact , that corresponds to the largest spin glass order parameter which gives the lowest grand canonical potential ( see also the discussion in ref . ) . then , by equating the grand canonical potential of the spin glass and paramagnetic solutions , the first order boundary phase is located . the use of the 1s - rsb scheme also deserves some remarks since our main interest is to obtain boundaries of phase transitions . it has been found in previous works @xcite that the use of the replica breaking symmetry ( rsb ) schemes in gs or fisg models essentially preserves the reentrance in the @xmath14 first order boundary phase associated to the inverse freezing . there are only small differences which appear mainly at very low temperatures . even so , for the hfisg model , we decided to use 1s - rsb scheme to check for intermedianted values of @xmath34 whether or not these differences will remain unimportant . moreover , we also analyzed the stability of the rs solutions for a sake of completeness of the work . this paper is structured as follow : in section 2 , we derived the thermodynamics and the set of coupled equations for the saddle point order parameters . in section 3 , phase diagrams temperature _ versus _ the chemical potential are presented for several values of @xmath34 . the entropy behavior as function of temperature and the grand canonical potential as function of chemical potential are also discussed . finally , section 4 is reserved to conclusions . the hamiltonian considered here is a hopfield fisg ( hfisg ) model @xmath35 where @xmath36 is given in eq . ( [ hebb ] ) and the random @xmath37 follows the distribution @xmath38 in this model , @xmath39 $ ] is the spin operator , with @xmath40 as the number operator , @xmath41 are fermions creation ( destruction ) operators and @xmath42 or @xmath43 indicate the spin projections . the partition function in the grand canonical ensemble is given in the lagrangian path integral formalism where the spin operators are represented as bilinear combinations of anticommuting grassmann fields ( @xmath44 ) @xcite @xmath45 where @xmath46 \phi_{j\sigma}(\tau ) \\ & - h(\phi^{*}(\tau),\phi(\tau ) ) \ } \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath9 is the chemical potential and @xmath47 . @xmath48 is fourier transformed in time which results in @xmath49 with @xmath50\phi_{j\sigma}(\omega ) \label{eqao}\ ] ] @xmath51 and @xmath52 where @xmath9 is chemical potential , @xmath53 , @xmath54 are the matsubara s frequencies and @xmath55 if @xmath56 . in this work , the problem is analyzed within sa which considers only the term when @xmath57 in eq . ( [ eqs ] ) @xcite . the grand canonical potential is obtained by using the replica method : @xmath58 where @xmath59 and @xmath60 means the configurational averaged over @xmath61 . thus : @xmath62 \label{zn1}\ ] ] where after using @xmath11 given in eq . ( [ hebb ] ) , the action @xmath63 can be written as @xmath64 with @xmath65 denoting the replica index and @xmath66 . the average over @xmath67 given in eq . ( [ zn1 ] ) is discussed in detail in the appendix a. in the present work , the one - step replica symmetry breaking ( 1s - rsb ) ansatz is adopted , in which the replica matrix @xmath68 and the matrix @xmath69 are parametrized as : @xmath70 and order parameters @xmath71 are invariant with respect to permutations of replicas : @xmath72 , where @xmath73 . therefore , the parametrization ( [ 1srsb ] ) is used in eqs . ( [ med1])-([e25 ] ) . as a consequence , the 1s - rsb grand canonical potential is found as @xmath74}{1-\beta j(\bar{q}-q_1 ) } \\ & -\frac{1}{2 } \frac{\beta j a q_0}{1-\beta j[\bar{q}-q_1 + x(q_1-q_0 ) ] } + \frac{\beta j m^2}{2 } + \frac{a}{2 } \\ & \times\ln [ 1-\beta j(\bar{q}-q_1 ) ] -\lim_{n\rightarrow 0}\frac{1 } { n}\ln\langle\langle \theta(\{r\},m,\xi ) \rangle\rangle_{\xi } , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath75 \\&\times\exp \left [ ( r_1-r_0)\sum_{l=1}^{n / x}\left(\sum_{\alpha=(l-1)x+1}^{lx}s^\alpha\right)^2 \right ] \\&\times\exp\left [ r_0(\sum_{\alpha=1}^n s^{\alpha})^2 + \beta j \sum_{\alpha=1}^{n } ( \xi m s^{\alpha } ) \right ] \end{split}\ ] ] with @xmath26 . the quadratic forms into the function @xmath76 can be linearized by hubbard - stratonovich transformations where new auxiliary fields are introduced in the problem . therefore , one has : @xmath77^{n / x } , \end{split } \label{e28}\ ] ] with @xmath78 ( @xmath79 ) and @xmath80 the local spin glass component of the random field @xmath81 is defined by @xmath82 . \end{split } \label{e30}\ ] ] the functional integral over the grassmann variables , as well as the sum over the matsubaras frequencies in eq . ( [ e28 ] ) , can be performed following closely the procedure given in references @xcite . finally , the grand canonical potential within 1s - rsb approximation can be written as @xmath83 } + \frac{a}{2}\ln [ 1-\beta j(\bar{q } % -q_1 ) ] \\&-q_1)]+\frac{a}{2x}\ln \frac{1-\beta j[\bar{q}-q_1 + x(q_1-q_0)]}{1-\beta j(\bar{q}-q_1 ) } \\ & -\beta\mu-\frac{1}{x}\int dz\langle\langle\ln \int dv\left(2k(z , v|\xi)\right)^x\rangle\rangle_{\xi } \label{eq1 } \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath84}\cosh\bar{h}(z , v,\xi ) \label{kzv}\ ] ] and @xmath85 . \label{eq20}\ ] ] the set of equations for the order parameters @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 and the block size parameter @xmath90 can be found from eq . ( [ eq1 ] ) using the saddle point conditions . in particular , the elements of matrix r are given by @xmath91\}^2 } \label{r01}\ ] ] @xmath92\{1-\beta j[\bar{q}-q_1+x(q_1-q_0)]\}}\ ] ] @xmath93}. \label{rbarra}\ ] ] the average over @xmath61 in the grand canonical potential can be done using the parity properties of the functions dependent on @xmath94 and @xmath95 . the entropy can also be obtained directly from the grand canonical potential . the numerical solutions for the coupled set for the saddle point order parameters @xmath88 , @xmath87 , @xmath89 and @xmath86 are displayed in phase diagrams @xmath103 _ versus _ @xmath104 given below for several values of the parameter @xmath34 , where @xmath15 is the temperature and @xmath105 is defined in eq . ( [ hebb ] ) . for the numerical results , @xmath106 is used . the rs scheme for the order parameters is also calculated when @xmath107 . the stability of such solution is investigated by calculating the almeida - thouless eigenvalue @xmath108 given in eqs . ( [ linhaat1])-([linhaat2 ] ) . such analysis shows that the @xmath2 solutions and mattis states ( @xmath109 ) present @xmath110 while the @xmath8 ones have @xmath111 . this result could indicate that it is necessary to use rsb schemes to locate more adequately the @xmath14 first order boundary phase . however , the results shown in figs . ( [ fig1])-([fig2 ] ) have found that , in such first order boundary phase , the reentrance and , therefore , the inverse freezing are not essentially affected by the use of rs or 1s - rsb schemes similar to the fisg model @xcite . in fig . ( [ fig1 ] ) , it is presented phase diagrams which illustrate two quite distinct situations concerning the degree of frustration . the first one ( @xmath29 ) , which is shown in fig . ( [ fig1]-a ) , corresponds to trivial randomness @xcite , which means that there are no effects of frustration . in this phase diagram , for low @xmath103 and small @xmath104 , one gets @xmath109 as solution . for higher @xmath103 and/or larger @xmath104 , it is found the @xmath2 solution . for small @xmath104 , the boundary phase transition between @xmath109 and @xmath2 phase ( called here @xmath112 ) is second order . however , when @xmath104 increases , it appears a tricritical point located at @xmath113 and @xmath114 ( see appendix b ) . most important , there is no reentrance in the subsequent first order part of the boundary phase transition @xmath115 . in fig . ( [ fig1]-b ) , the degree of frustration is increased ( @xmath116 ) and , for that case , effects of frustration become dominant . thus , the @xmath109 solution is replaced by a @xmath8 one in which , @xmath117 , @xmath118 , @xmath119 and @xmath120 , while the @xmath2 phase has @xmath117 , @xmath118 , @xmath121 and @xmath122 . the freezing temperature has also a second order part @xmath123 . as for the trivial randomness case , a tricritical point appears , with value @xmath124 and @xmath125 ( see appendix b ) . nevertheless , the first order part of the freezing temperature @xmath126 now shows a reentrance which indicates the existence of inverse freezing , as it can be seen in the insert in fig . ( [ fig1]-b ) , which displays the entropy as function of @xmath103 . there , it is shown that entropy of the @xmath8 phase is larger than the @xmath2 one for that particular degree of frustration . it should be remarked that this phase diagram is quite similar to that one found for the fisg model @xcite . the location of the boundaries phases in fig . ( [ fig1 ] ) has been checked in the limits @xmath127 and @xmath128 as it can be seen in appendices b and c. there is a more complex scenario as compared with that one described in fig . ( [ fig1]-b ) when @xmath129 . in fig . ( [ fig2]-a ) ( @xmath130 ) , the solution for the order parameters shows a phase diagram which illustrates this new scenario . for a small @xmath104 , when @xmath103 is decreased , there is a second order phase transition between the @xmath2 and @xmath8 phases . however , for even lower temperatures , there is another phase transition , which is now a first order one , between the @xmath8 phase and @xmath109 region , which is given now by @xmath131 , @xmath118 , @xmath119 and @xmath120 . for this particular value of @xmath34 , @xmath8 and @xmath109 solutions occupy approximately equal sizes in the phase diagram . the freezing temperature has a similar behavior to that one found in fig . ( [ fig1]-b ) . it has a second order part @xmath123 for small @xmath9 , then it appears a tricritical point at @xmath132 and @xmath133 ( see appendix b ) . below this point , @xmath126 presents a reentrance which allows , for an adequate constant @xmath9 , crossing from the @xmath8 phase to the @xmath2 one when the temperature is decreasing . nonetheless , this first order boundary phase has a complex nature . it appears a triple point at ( @xmath134,@xmath135 ) where @xmath109 , @xmath2 and @xmath8 phases coexist . below this point , the first order boundary phase @xmath115 diplays no reentrance , as in the case @xmath29 . for smaller values of @xmath34 , as shown in figs . ( [ fig2]-b)-([fig2]-d ) , the region where @xmath109 solutions are found becomes increasingly larger than the @xmath8 one which is consistent with earlier results found in the classical hopfield spin glass model which displays , in a phase diagram @xmath15 _ versus _ @xmath34 , a dominance of the mattis states when @xmath136 0@xcite . even so , in this new situation , the location @xmath123 is not affected so much . however , the tricritical point is displaced for smaller and lower values of @xmath104 and @xmath103 , respectively . in comparison , the triple point is displaced for smaller values of @xmath104 and higher values of @xmath103 . as a consequence , @xmath126 and @xmath115 appear in a decreasing and increasing range of temperature , respectively . nevertheless , most important , the reentrance in @xmath137 is gradually suppressed when @xmath129 . however , the insert in fig ( [ fig2]-d ) shows that even when the level of frustration is very weak , and @xmath123 appears in a very short range of temperature , a reentrance in such first order boundary phase is still preserved . _ versus _ @xmath104 for @xmath138 and two values of @xmath116 . the full , dotted and dashed - dotted lines represent the @xmath139 of sg , pm and fe solutions , respectively . , width=327 ] @xmath103 for several values of @xmath34 and @xmath104 . the labels @xmath115 and @xmath126 indicate the first order transition between the @xmath140 and @xmath14 phases , respectively . the full vertical line indicates the second order transition between @xmath14 phases . , width=325 ] the procedure to locate the first order boundary lines in the previous phase diagrams is illustrated in fig . ( 3 ) , where the grand canonical potential _ versus _ @xmath104 is plotted for @xmath138 . in fig . ( 3 ) , the set of multiple @xmath8 solutions is represented by branches of full lines , where the chosen @xmath8 solution is that one which meets continuously with the only one @xmath8 solution available for small values of @xmath104 . from that @xmath8 solution , the first order boundary phase is obtained by equating the grand canonical potential of sg , pm and fe solutions . the corresponding behavior of the entropy as a function of @xmath103 for the values of @xmath34 used in fig . ( [ fig2 ] ) is shown in fig . ( [ fig4 ] ) . this figure illustrates the gradual suppression of inverse freezing when @xmath129 . for instance , in fig . ( [ fig4]-a ) , the value of @xmath141 is chosen to cross the reentrant first order boundary phase in @xmath126 in fig . ( [ fig2]-a ) . the figure shows that the entropy of @xmath8 phase is larger than the entropy of the @xmath2 one in the first order transition which , as in the inset of fig . ( [ fig1]-b ) , indicates the existence of inverse freezing . the same procedure has been adopted in figs . ( [ fig2]-b)-([fig2]-d ) , values of @xmath9 are adjusted to be close to @xmath135 . the result found in fig . ( [ fig2]-b ) is similar to that one found in fig.([fig2]-a ) . however , fig . ( [ fig2]-c ) displays the entropy behavior when @xmath126 and @xmath115 are now crossed . the first crossing is in the reentrant line transition @xmath126 giving an inverse freezing as in figs . ( [ fig2]-a)-([fig2]-b ) . the second one in @xmath115 gives a usual phase transition in which the @xmath2 phase is more entropic than the @xmath109 one , as already found in fig . ( [ fig1]-a ) . in fig . ( [ fig2]-d ) the reentrance in @xmath126 is almost suppressed . thus , for the chosen value of @xmath9 , there is only one crossing in @xmath115 which gives the entropy behavior of a usual phase transition as that one found in fig . ( [ fig1]-a ) . in the present work , it has been studied the hfisg model in which the random spin - spin coupling @xmath11 , instead of the usual gaussian distribution , is given by eq . ( [ hebb ] ) . for this particular choice of @xmath11 , the problem can be treated in a mean field framework which allows adjusting the level of frustration . therefore , it is possible to study not only the existence of a natural inverse freezing in the limits of trivial randomness and strong frustration but also how changing the level of frustration could affect such transition . in this approach , within 1s - rsb scheme , besides the replica non - diagonal @xmath8 orders parameters @xmath87 , @xmath88 and the block size parameter @xmath90 , there is also the replica diagonal order parameter @xmath89 . the set of order parameters is completed with @xmath86 which corresponds to the presence of mattis states ( @xmath109 ) @xcite . the coupled equations for @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath90 , @xmath89 and @xmath86 are solved for several values of degree of frustration @xmath34 in a phase diagram @xmath15 _ versus _ chemical potential @xmath9 . in particular , the rs solution is also obtained when @xmath107 . the comparison among the several scenarios displayed in figs . ( [ fig1])-([fig2 ] ) elucidates the role of frustration as the essential ingredient responsible for producing naturally inverse freezing in the hfisg model . in other words , an inverse freezing without any need of an artificial entropic advantage . for instance , the comparison between results given in figs . ( [ fig1]-a ) and ( [ fig1]-b ) shows that only in the case @xmath116 ( the strong frustrated regime ) a reentrant first order boundary phase appears . the trivial randomness is not able to generate naturally a reentrance and , therefore , an inverse transition . furthermore , in fig . ( [ fig2 ] ) , when the level of frustration is diminished , the range in temperature of the @xmath14 first order boundary phase is decreased but , most importantly , the reentrance in this first order boundary phase is gradually suppressed , what implies in the gradual suppression of inverse freezing until the complete disappearing in the trivial randomness case ( @xmath29 ) . nevertheless , whatever the level of frustration , there is always a reentrance in @xmath14 first order boundary phase which gives an inverse freezing . in contrast , the range of the @xmath140 first order boundary phase is simply increased , nothing else happens . these previous features lead to the conclusion that frustration in any level is the necessary condition to create naturally the entropic advantage of the @xmath8 phase as compared with the @xmath2 one which generates an inverse freezing . albeit , these results are restrict to a particular model , we suggest that the role of frustration as an essential ingredient to rise naturally inverse freezing could be more general . one last remark must be done . the present approach could be used directly in gs model with the coupling @xmath11 as given in eq . ( [ hebb ] ) replacing the original gaussian distributed one @xcite . however , the great advantage of the hfisg model is that it would also allow studying the present problem in the presence of a transverse magnetic field @xmath13 @xcite . in ref . , it has been shown that @xmath13 tends to destroy the inverse freezing . therefore , the presence of an additional @xmath13 would lead to another question : what would happen with the inverse freezing in the hfisg model when the level of frustration and the strength of quantum effects are simultaneously changed ? in that case , it would possible to investigate the robustness of the inverse freezing by adjusting simultaneously the degree of frustration and @xmath13 . this question is currently under investigation . sgm acknowledges the hospitality of the departamento de ciencias de la tierra y la materia condensada - universidad de cantabria where this work was concluded and the support of fundacion carlina / spain . this work was partially supported by the brazilian agencies capes ( coordenao de aperfeioamento de pessoal de nivel superior ) and cnpq ( conselho nacional de pesquisas cientficas ) . in this appendix , the averaging procedure of the partition function of the hfisg model is introduced following closely ref . . the first term in the action @xmath63 ( see eq . ( [ asg ] ) ) can be linearized by a hubbard - stratonovich transformation by introducing @xmath142 auxiliary fields @xmath143 which are splitted in two subsets with @xmath144 and @xmath145 terms . therefore , @xmath146 \\ & \times \int_{-\infty}^{\infty } d m_{\nu}^{\alpha } \exp\left\lbrace \tau \sum_{\nu=1}^{l}\sum_{\alpha}\left [ -\frac{1}{2}(m_{\nu}^{\alpha})^2 + \eta_{i,\alpha}^{\nu } \right ] \right\rbrace \\ & \times \int_{-\infty}^{\infty } d m_{\varrho}^{\alpha } \exp\left\lbrace \tau \sum_{\varrho = l+1}^{p}\sum_{\alpha}\left [ -\frac{1}{2}(m_{\varrho}^{\alpha})^2 + \eta_{i,\alpha}^{\varrho } \right ] \right\rbrace , \label{mu } \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath147 , @xmath148 and @xmath149 . it is assumed that the relevant contributions come from @xmath150 which are order unity , while @xmath143 is of order @xmath151 . therefore , the average over the @xmath152 independent random variables @xmath153 can be done using @xmath154 given in eq . ( [ gaussian ] ) which results in : @xmath155 \rangle\rangle_{\xi}= \nonumber \\ \exp\left [ \sum_{i}\sum_{\varrho = s}^{p } \ln\left ( \cosh ( \beta j \sum_{\alpha}s_{i}^{\alpha}m_{\varrho}^{\alpha})\right ) \right ] . \label{mu1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the argument of the exponential in the right hand side of eq . ( [ mu1 ] ) can be expanded up to second order in @xmath143 . the result is a quadratic term of the spins variables @xmath156 in the last exponential of eq . ( [ mu ] ) . this term can be linearized by introducing the spin glass order parameter @xmath157 using the integral representation of the delta function as @xmath158\\ & = \delta(q_{\alpha\beta}-\frac{1}{n}\sum_{i}s_{i}^{\alpha}s_{i}^{\beta } ) . \label{mu2 } \end{split}\ ] ] therefore , the exponential involving @xmath143 in eq . ( [ mu ] ) can be written as : @xmath159\right\}\\&= \int_{-\infty}^{\infty } \prod_{\alpha\beta } \frac{dq_{\alpha\beta } d\tilde{r}_{\alpha\beta}}{2\pi } \exp \left [ \frac{\beta}{2 } \sum_{\varrho = l+1}^{p } m_{\varrho}^{\alpha}\lambda_{\alpha\beta } m_{\varrho}^{\beta } d_{\alpha\beta } \right ] , \label{e20 } \end{split}\ ] ] with @xmath160 where the matrix element @xmath161 introducing eqs . ( [ e20])-([e21 ] ) into eq . ( [ mu ] ) , the @xmath143 fields can be integrated to give : @xmath162 \\&\times \langle\langle \int^{+\infty}_{-\infty } dm_{\nu}^{\alpha } \exp\left\{\tau \sum_{\nu=1}^{l}\sum_{\alpha } \left [ -\frac{1}{2}(m_{\nu}^{\alpha})^{2}+ \eta_{i,\alpha}^{\nu } \right]\right\ } \rangle\rangle_{\xi } \\ & \times \int^{\infty}_{-\infty}\prod_{\alpha\beta } \frac{dq_{\alpha\beta}{\tilde{r}}_{\alpha\beta}}{2\pi } \exp\ { d_{\alpha\beta}- \frac{1}{2}(p - l)tr\ln\underline{\underline{\lambda } } ) \}. \label{e22 } \end{split}\ ] ] assuming @xmath163 in eq . ( [ e22 ] ) , the averaged partition function is given as @xmath164 \\ & \times \exp \left [ -\frac{p-1}{2 } tr\ln\underline{\underline{\lambda } } \right ] \langle\langle \theta(\tilde{r}_{\alpha\beta},\tilde{r}_{\alpha\alpha},m^{\alpha}_{1})\rangle\rangle_{\xi } \end{split } \label{med1}\ ] ] where the matrix @xmath165 is defined in eq . ( [ e21 ] ) and @xmath166 \label{e25 } \end{split}\ ] ] with @xmath167 and @xmath168 . the trace of the matrix @xmath165 given in eq . ( [ e21 ] ) is obtained in terms of its eigenvalues . the grand canonical potential is found introducing eq . ( [ med1 ] ) in eq . ( [ replica ] ) which is evaluated at the saddle point . thus , @xmath169 and @xmath170 this appendix presents a procedure to obtain the tricritical point @xmath171 for both cases : @xmath29 and @xmath172 . for @xmath29 , the landau expansion of the grand canonical potential , eq . ( [ eq1 ] ) , in powers of @xmath86 gives @xmath173 with @xmath174/2,\ ] ] @xmath175 sech [ ( \beta \mu)/2]^4/96.\ ] ] the tricritical point is obtained when @xmath176 . the position of @xmath177 in the fig . ( [ fig1]-a ) for @xmath127 can be also checked from the equation @xmath178 . for @xmath179 , the @xmath180 phase transition is investigated . in this case , it is assumed that there is no essential difference between rs and 1s - rsb schemes concerning the location of the tricritical point.@xcite therefore , we start with the thermodynamic potential within the rs solution ( @xmath181 , @xmath182 and @xmath183 ) written explicitly as a function of the order parameters @xmath16 and @xmath184 , and with @xmath117 : @xmath185 - \int dz \\ \times \ln [ \cosh \beta\mu + \mbox{e}^{[\frac{\beta^2 j^2 a}{2}(\bar{r}-r)-\frac{\beta j a}{2 } ] } \cosh\beta j \sqrt{ar}z ] \label{aa1 } \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath16 and @xmath184 are given by eqs . ( [ r01 ] ) and ( [ rbarra ] ) within the rs solution , respectively . equation ( [ aa1 ] ) is expressed as an expansion in powers of @xmath16 , which is related to the @xmath8 order parameter . therefore , @xmath186 where @xmath187 is obtained by a saddle point solution of @xmath139 . in this case , @xmath187 can also be written in the form of a series @xmath188 with @xmath189 as a result , @xmath190^{-1 } , \\ \bar{r}_2=-\frac{2+\beta^6 j^6 a^2 \bar{r}_0 ^ 3 x_0 ^ 2(1-x_0)}{\bar{r}_0[2-\beta^4 j^4 a\bar{r}_0 ^ 2 x_0(1-x_0)]},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath191 now , eq . ( [ rbr ] ) is introduced into the coefficients of expression ( [ omegae ] ) , which are expanded in powers of @xmath16 again . the resulting expression is then expressed in powers of the @xmath8 order parameter @xmath24 by expanding @xmath16 : @xmath192 with @xmath193 @xmath194 -6\beta j ( 1-\beta j \bar{q}_0)f_3 \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath195 $ ] . the @xmath180 second order phase transition occurs when @xmath196 and @xmath197 with the tricritical point located when @xmath196 and @xmath198 . in particular , one can use the condition @xmath196 with eqs . ( b7 ) and ( b9 ) to obtain the critical temperature @xmath199 by solving @xmath200}\ ] ] where @xmath201 . for @xmath127 , it is recovered the result @xmath202 for @xmath116 here a procedure is presented to obtain the first order boundary phases of @xmath140 phases @xmath203 and @xmath14 phases @xmath204 at @xmath128 within the rs and 1s - rsb solutions . for @xmath29 , the grand canonical potential of fm solution at @xmath128 is @xmath205 . by comparing @xmath206 with the grand potential potential of pm phase , @xmath207 , the first order boundary is located at @xmath208 . for the cases shown in fig . ( [ fig2 ] ) , it is recovered the grand canonical potential for @xmath29 . for @xmath28 , the effects of frustration are dominants . in this case for rs solution , @xmath209 for @xmath210 . therefore , close to the transition , which means @xmath211}$ ] , the @xmath212 at @xmath213 is @xmath214 \label{omegax}\ ] ] where @xmath215 ( @xmath216 is the error function ) , @xmath217 and @xmath218 . from the condition @xmath219 , @xmath220 and @xmath16 can be solved which allows finding @xmath221 . particularly , @xmath222=0.689 for @xmath116 . where @xmath227 \\ & + e^{\gamma \vartheta_{-}}\left [ 1 + \mbox{erf } \left ( \frac { \eta_{- } } { \sqrt{2 a ( r_{1}-r_{0 } ) } } \right ) \right ] \\ & + \mbox{erf}\left ( \frac { \bar{u}+ \sqrt{a r_{0}}z } { \sqrt{2 a ( r_{1}-r_{0 } ) } } \right ) + \mbox{erf}\left ( \frac { \bar{u } - \sqrt{a r_{0}}z } { \sqrt{2 a ( r_{1}-r_{0 } ) } } \right ) \end{split } \label{1rscompl}\ ] ] with @xmath228 , @xmath229 and @xmath230 . the previous results for rs solution are recovered from eqs . ( [ 1srsbsch])-([1rscompl ] ) when @xmath231 . again , equations for @xmath232 , @xmath233 , @xmath234 , @xmath235 , @xmath236 and @xmath237 can be obtained from @xmath212 and solved . in this case , @xmath222=0.682 for @xmath116 . 00 n. schupper and n. m. shnerb , phys . e * 72 * , 046107 ( 2005 ) ; n. schupper and n. m. shnerb , phys . lett . * 93 * , 037202 ( 2004 ) . a. crisanti and l. leuzzi , phys . lett . * 95 * , 087201 ( 2005 ) . m. sellitto , phys . b * 73 * , 180202(r ) ( 2006 ) . s. prestipino , phys . e * 75 * , 011107 ( 2007 ) . l. leuzzi , philos . mag . * 87 * , 543 ( 2007 ) . r. angelini , g. ruocco , s. de panfilis , phys . e * 78 * , 020502(r ) ( 2008 ) . s. g. magalhaes , c. v. morais , f. m. zimmer , phys . b * 77 * , 134422 ( 2008 ) . a. l. greer , nature * 404 * , 134 ( 2000 ) . o. portmann , a. vaterlaus , and d. pescia , nature ( london ) * 422 * , 701 ( 2003 ) . n. avraham et al . , nature ( london ) * 411 * , 451 ( 2001 ) . m. r. feeney , p. g. debenedetti , f. h stillinger , j. chem . * 119 * , 4582 ( 2003 ) . m. blume , phys . 141 * , 517 ( 1966 ) ; h. w. capel , physica ( amsterdan ) * 32 * , 966 ( 1966 ) . s. k. ghatak and d. sherrington , j. phys . c * 10 * , 3149 ( 1977 ) . e. fradkin , b. a. huberman , and s. h. shenker , phys . b * 18 * , 4789 ( 1978 ) . r. oppermann and a. muller - groeling , nucl . phys . b * 401 * , 507 ( 1993 ) . a. theumann , a. a. schmidt and s. g. magalhes , physica a * 311 * , 498 ( 2002 ) . w. wiethege , d. sherrington , j. phys . c : solid state phys . * 19 * , 6893 ( 1986 ) . i. p. castillo , d. sherrington , phys . b * 72 * , 104427 ( 2005 ) . h. feldmann and r. oppermann , j. phys . a * 33 * , 1325 ( 2000 ) . f. m. zimmer , s. g. magalhaes , phys . b * 74 * , 012202 ( 2006 ) . d. j. amit , _ modelling brain function . the world of attractor neural networks _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , england , 1989 ) . d. j. amit , h. gutfreund , h. sompolinsky , phys rev . a * 32 * , 1007 ( 1985 ) . d. j. mattis , phys . lett . * 56a * , 421(1977 ) . j. p. provost and g. vallee , phys . * 50 * , 598 ( 1983 ) . d. sherrington and s. kirkpatrick , phys . rev lett * 35 * , 1792 ( 1975 ) ; s. kirkpatrick and d. sherrington , phys . b * 17 * , 4384 ( 1978 ) . a. j. bray and m. a. moore , j. phys . c * 13 * , l655 ( 1980 ) . g. parisi , j. phys . * 13 * , 1101 ( 1980 ) . alba theumann and m. vieira gusmo , phys . let . * 105a * , 311 ( 1984 ) . j. miller and d. a. huse , phys . rev . 70 , 3147 ( 1993 ) . f. a da costa , c. s. o. yokoi and s. r. a. salinas , j. phys . a * 27 * , 3365 ( 1994 ) . p. mottishaw , europhys . lett . * 1 * , 409 ( 1986 ) . j. w. negele , h. orland , _ quantum many - particle systems _ ( addison - wesley publishing company , eua , 1988 ) . f. m. zimmer , s. g. magalhes , physica a * 359 * , 380 ( 2006 ) . d. j. amit , h. gutfreund and h. sompolinsky , ann . phys . * 173 * , 30 ( 1987 ) .

in this work it is studied the hopfield fermionic spin glass model which allows interpolating from trivial randomness to a highly frustrated regime . therefore , it is possible to investigate whether or not frustration is an essential ingredient which would allow this magnetic disordered model to present naturally inverse freezing by comparing the two limits , trivial randomness and highly frustrated regime and how different levels of frustration could affect such unconventional phase transition . the problem is expressed in the path integral formalism where the spin operators are represented by bilinear combinations of grassmann variables . the grand canonical potential is obtained within the static approximation and one - step replica symmetry breaking scheme . as a result , phase diagrams temperature _ versus _ the chemical potential are obtained for several levels of frustration . particularly , when the level of frustration is diminished , the reentrance related to the inverse freezing is gradually suppressed .

1212.1028

the parent compounds of the high-@xmath1-temperature superconductors are antiferromagnetic ( afm ) mott insulator . superconductivity ( sc ) emerges when charge carries ( holes or electrons ) are doped into the @xmath2 planes . as well known that the clear electron - hole asymmetry is found in the phase diagram . for hole doped case , the afm and superconducting phases are separated by spin glass phase . in contrast , the afm phase extends over a much wider range of doping and even coexists with sc in the electron doped cuprates@xcite . due to proximity of antiferrmagnetism and sc , it is generally believed that there exists intrinsic link between these two phases . the studies of the spin dynamics in n - type and p - type cuprates will shed light on the mechanism of superconductivity . one of the most available techniques to study the spin dynamics is the inelastic neutron scattering ( ins ) , which directly measures the magnetic excitations ( mes ) . compared with the well studied p - type cuprate@xcite , the investigations on the mes in n - type cuprates@xcite are much less due to the technical reason . a robust feature of mes in n - type cuprates , i.e. , the commensurate spin response , had been revealed by these ins measurements . the commensurability , characterized by the strongest intensity peaked at @xmath3 , covers for a wide low - energy region near the optimal doped nccoyamada - prl03 and plcco@xcite . further detecting shows that such commensurability in n - type cuprates exists for a wide doping range from the underdoping to heavy overdoping@xcite . more importantly , the commensurate mes persist well above superconducting critical temperature @xmath1 , indicating its non - superconducting origin . it gradually develops into the spin - wave - like dispersion centered around the @xmath4 point at higher energy , analogous to its undoped parent compoundwilson - nature06 . in contrast , the well known hourglass type magnetic dispersion had been discovered in the p - type cuprates , where the commensurate peak can only be found at the resonance energy . therefore , the two types of cuprates exhibit distinct spin response , indicating the intrinsic particle - hole asymmetry . theoretically , several works had been carried out to interpret the mes features of n - type cuprates . adopting the single band description with experimentally fitted parameters , krger _ _ claimed that the fermiology random phase approximation ( rpa ) approach with a momentum independent ( or weakly dependent ) coulomb repulsion can not account the low - energy commensurability . their numerical results indicated that the mes in n - type case should be more incommensurate than that in p - type casekruger - prb07 . such conclusion may reveal the fact that the single band description is invalid in the n - type cuprates@xcite . _ showed that this may be improved by a strongly momentum dependent coulomb repulsion with form of @xmath5@xcite . however , such improvement is more likely originated from its sharply peaked form at @xmath6 , which can not be understood physically . using a slave - boson mean - field approach , li _ et al . _ showed that the commensurability can be established in the sc stateljx - prb03 . these above mentioned theoretical works are all based on the belief that the d - wave sc is response for the low energy commensurability . it is hard to image that the small superconducting gap can produce the wide energy range commensurability . the most important is that the commensurate phenomenon is also found in the normal state of n - type cuprates , where the d - wave sc disappears . the mes had also been discussed within the frame work of coexisting of sc and afm@xcite . commensurate me had been subsequently obtained@xcite . however , this result clearly contradicts with the stoner critition@xcite . furthermore , recent ins data reveal a magnetic quantum critical point where the sc first appears , implying that the coexistence may not existmotoyama - nature07 . additionally , as we mentioned above , the commensurability also exists in the state without long - range afm order . in this paper , we focus on the commensurate mes in the n - type cuprates near the optimal doping . its energy region is closely related the to strength of effective @xmath6-scattering . the commensurate peak disappears at magnetic resonance energy @xmath7 and develops into the spin - wave like dispersion . these features are qualitatively consistent with ins measurements . this commensurability is a normal state property , and has nothing to do with the superconductivity . we explicitly demonstrate that the commensurability is originated from the band splitting and fermi surface topology . therefore , the afm correlation plays key roles in the n - type cuprates . the differences of mes between the p - type and n - type cuprates are further discussed for comparison . a spin - density wave ( sdw ) description is adopted to investigate the n - type cuprates near the optimal doping . such description is first suggested by armitage _ based on the arpes measurements on @xmath8@xcite . the underlying fermi surface disappears around the hot - spot near the optimal doping , where the long - range antiferromagnetism is absent , strongly suggesting the existence of a @xmath9-scattering . further proposed an effective energy band with @xmath10 ( @xmath11 , and @xmath12 for upper , and lower band , respectively)parker - prb07 , where @xmath13 is the strength of the effective @xmath14-scattering , representing the influence of the sdw . @xmath15 and @xmath16 is the inter- and intra - lattice hopping term . this description well reproduces the @xmath17 band folding and fermi surface reconstruction@xcite , and its applications on the temperature evolution of optical conductivityzimmer and the hall coefficient@xcite give qualitative agreement with experiments . now , the model hamiltonian is expressed as @xmath18 where , the two sublattices @xmath19 and @xmath20 with respective fermionic operator @xmath21 and @xmath22 are introduced due to sdwexplain . @xmath23 , and @xmath24 with @xmath25 , @xmath26 , and @xmath27 are the fitting parameters for nearest - neighbor ( nn ) , second - nn , and third - nn hoping . the summation is restricted in the afm brillouin zone . the quasiparticle dispersion @xmath28 can be obtained by the rotation transformation , with corresponding weight factor @xmath29 . here , @xmath30 , and @xmath31 . here , we would like to emphasize that the long - range afm order disappears near the optimal doping . as pointed by motoyama _ _ that the neel temperature detected above @xmath32 in @xmath8 originates from the region of samples that were not fully oxygen - annealedmotoyama - nature07 . this means that the genuine long - range antiferromagnetism does not coexist with superconductivity . however , the @xmath33-dimensional afm correlation remains . unlike only several lattice - distant length in p - type cuprates@xcite , the afm correlation is about tens lattice - distance in the optimal electron - doped cuprates@xcite . in this sense , the afm correlations in the n - type cuprates is similar to the long - range afm order at least in the small scaling . therefore , using a slowly fluctuating sdw order to describe the long - range afm correlation is a considerable treatment . though present sdw description is analogous to the form in the afm phaseyqs - prb05 , the physics behind is essentially different . the spin susceptibility under random phase approximation is @xmath34 with @xmath35 is a reduced coulomb interaction due to the screening effectzhou - pla10 . the bare spin susceptibilities are @xmath36 with @xmath37 is @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the fermi distribution function . in numerically , the doping level is fixed at @xmath40 , near the afm quantum critical point@xcite . @xmath41 , @xmath42 , and @xmath43 are adopted@xcite . the best fitted effective @xmath44 scattering strength is @xmath45 , and it will be adjusted for necessary . the temperature is fixed at @xmath46 . we adopt a broaden factor @xmath47 to calculate the spin susceptibility . the reduced coulomb interaction is about @xmath48 , which is about @xmath49 . our calculations are carried out on a mesh with @xmath50 k - point in the full brillouin zone . for different energy @xmath51 . only the near @xmath52 region are shown for clarification with @xmath53 . @xmath54 , the effective @xmath55-scattering strength @xmath56 , and the broaden factor @xmath57.,width=336 ] the typical energy - evolution of the mes @xmath58 is shown in fig . [ f.1 ] . in the low - energy regime below @xmath59 ( fig . [ f.1](a ) , ( b ) ) , the mes are incommensurate with strong intensity at diagonal directions . simultaneously , the intensity near @xmath52 enhances gradually . in the intermediate - energy regime , the strongest intensity locates at the @xmath52 point , leading to the the so - called commensurability ( fig . [ f.1](c ) , ( d ) ) . it maintains up to an critical energy about @xmath60 ( fig.[f.1](e ) ) , where the strongest intensity @xmath61 in the normal state can be found , and is referred as the magnetic resonance @xmath62 . the total energy range for the commensurability is approximately @xmath63 for @xmath64 . this magnetic resonance is directly related to the fact that the real part in denominator of the rpa formula ( eq . [ e2 ] ) reduces to zero . subsequently , it evolves into a ring - like incommensurability in the high - energy region with its radius expanding upon the further increased energy ( fig . [ f.1](f ) ) . for high enough energy , the mes are incommensurate with strong intensity at the vertical directions ( not shown ) . along the high symmetry direction . upper panels are for vertical direction with @xmath65 , and lower panels are for the diagonal direction with @xmath66 . from left to right is @xmath67 , @xmath68 , and @xmath69 , respectively . the effective @xmath52-scattering potential is @xmath70 and the damping rate @xmath71 . all data had been renormalized by setting the strongest intensity at given @xmath72 as unit , denoted by the white lines.,width=345 ] such features can be more clear in dispersion of the mes at high symmetry scanning lines as shown in fig . a wide energy regime with commensurability exists for all selected @xmath35 , manifesting its universal nature . the low - energy incommensurability increases slightly upon @xmath73 . hence the commensurability can not not be viewed as the overlap of two incommensurate peaks . it is an intrinsic feature of n - type cuprates . the low - energy incommensurability may be suppressed and even absent with enhanced @xmath35 . for example , when @xmath74 ( fig . [ f.2](c ) ) , the mes are still commensurate at low enough energy . correspondingly , the magnetic resonance energy @xmath62 decreases down to @xmath75 for @xmath76 . the experimental discovered commensurability in @xmath8yamada - prl03 and @xmath77@xcite near the optimal doping is more like similar to this case . the value of @xmath78 is near the afm stability , consisting with the fact that the optimal doping is near the afm quantum critical point@xcite . the possible energy range of commensurability is mainly determined by the effective @xmath52-scattering potential @xmath13 . for @xmath79 and @xmath80 , it is about @xmath81 . this energy range decreases down to @xmath82 when the @xmath83 . however , the realistic energy range of commensurability may be substantially reduced for strong @xmath35 due to the proximity of the afm stability . it is only @xmath75 for stronger @xmath84 . for strong enough @xmath85 at given @xmath79 , the commensurability is entirely suppressed and only the ring - like magnetic feature remains . this situation is indeed an afm state . therefore , the ring - like feature at high - energy regime in the electron - doped cuprates shares the same origin as that in their parents compounds . in fact , those theories based on the long - range afm order@xcite can not account the commensurability found in @xmath8@xcite and @xmath77@xcite due to stone instability at @xmath86@xcite , unless some special control parameter is adopted . the energy range of commensurability also depends on the broaden factor @xmath87 as comparing the data in fig . [ f.1 ] and fig . [ f.2 ] ( ( e ) and ( f ) ) . however , this phenomenon is still present even a small @xmath88 is adopted , which is less than the instrument resolution . hence , the commensurability is an intrinsic and universal property of the electron - doped cuprates in the normal state . the main difference in present work from the previous theoretical investigation by krger _ _ et al.__@xcite is the influence of the afm correlation is taken into account . the sdw description take the place of the single band description , producing a splitting two - band . therefore , the commensurability is a directly result of the band - splitting . this can be also seem from the fact that commensurate energy region diminishes with the reduced @xmath13 as we shown before . as we known that the afm correlation weakens with doping@xcite . in the heavy overdoping range , the afm correlation disappears , i.e. , @xmath89 , leading to the absence of band - splitting . our results is then same as the work of krger _ _ , the mes become incommensurate , consisting with ins measurements@xcite . in the p - type cuprate , the mes exhibit the well known hourglass dispersion , the commensurate peak emerges at the single energy point @xmath90 . the underdoped p - type cuprates can also be described by the two - band description due to the opening of pseudogap@xcite , where the two bands near the antinodes are separated . why do the two types of cuprates show significant particle - hole asymmetry ? as well known that the fermi surface is an arc or hole pocket near the node point in the underdoped p - type cuprates@xcite , while it is an electron - pocket near antinodal point in the n - type cuprates even near the optimal doping as shown in fig . in fact , the two bands coincides at node point in p - type cuprates , which leads to the single - point commensurability at resonance energy . furthermore , this can also interpret the commensurability exists in slightly overdoped n - type cuprates even the large - three - pieced fermi surface@xcite forms because of the band splitting at nodes . therefore , both the band splitting and fermi surface topology play the important roles in the universal commensurability in the n - type cuprates . as we stressed before , they both originate from the afm correlation . together with the previous theoretical works on the band structure@xcite and transport properties@xcite , we conclude that the afm correlation plays essential roles in the cuprates . the commensurate mes remain in the presence of superconductivity . we introduce a phenomenological bcs - like pairing term @xmath91 with standard @xmath21-wave symmetry @xmath92 . the resultant mes change little , consistent with the ins observations . therefore , the commensurability in n - type cuprate is a normal state property , and has nothing to do with sc . the commensurability had been also obtained in a single band description with d - wave superconductivity@xcite . though the d - wave pairing produces two bands . however , the superconducting gap in the optimal doped n - type cuprates is only @xmath93@xcite , too small to account for the wide energy range commensurability . it seems that the commensurability comes from the strong peaked factor @xmath94@xcite or @xmath95@xcite rather than the @xmath21-wave superconductivity in these theoretical investigations . more importantly , the commensurability is a normal state property , which can also be discovered well above the superconducting transition temperature @xmath1 . in conclusion , the magnetic excitations near the optimal doped n - type cuprates are studied within a spin - density wave description . the main features of magnetic excitations in the normal state are well established . our analyses clearly demonstrate that the band splitting and the fermi surface topology are the key for commensurability in n - type cuprates . this strongly suggests that the antiferromagnetic correlation plays important roles in cuprates . we emphasize that the commensurability is a normal state property , and has nothing to do with superconductivity . the qualitative agreement between the theoretical calculations and experimental data also suggests the validity of the spin - density wave description near the optimal doping where the long range antiferromagnetic order is absent . we also discuss the distinct behavior of magnetic excitations in the n- and p - type cuprates . this work was supported by nsfc projects no . 10804047 , 11274276 , and a project funded by the priority academic program development of jiangsu higher education institutions . cd gong acknowledges 973 projects no . hq lin acknowledges rgc grant of hksar , project no . hkust3/crf/09 . j. brinckmann and p. a. lee , phys . lett . * 82 * , 2915 ( 1999 ) ; i. eremin , d. k. morr , a.v . chubukov , k. h. bennemann , and m. r. norman , phys . lett . * 94 * , 147001 ( 2005 ) ; g. seibold and j. lorenzana , phys . b * 73 * , 144515 ( 2006 ) ; e. demler and s .- c . zhang , phys . lett . * 75 * , 4126 ( 1995 ) . a. zimmers , j. m. tomczak , r. p. s. m. lobo , n. bontemps , c. p. hill , m. c. barr , y. dagan , r. l. greene , a. j. millis , and c. c. homes , europhys . lett . * 70 * , 225 ( 2005 ) ; a. zimmers et al . b * 76 * , 064515 ( 2007 ) . m. r. norman , h. ding , m. randeria , j. c. campuzano , t. yokoya , t. takeuchik , t. takahashi , t. mochiku , k. kadowaki , p. guptasarma , and d. g. hinks , nature * 392 * , 157 ( 1998 ) ; k. m. shen , f. ronning , d. h. lu , f. baumberger , n. j. c. ingle , w. s. lee , w. meevasana , y. kohsaka , m. azuma , m. takano , h. takagi , and z .- x . shen , science * 307 * , 901 ( 2005 ) .

the antiferromagnetic correlation plays an important role in high - t@xmath0 superconductors . considering this effect , the magnetic excitations in n - type cuprates near the optimal doping are studied within the spin density wave description . the magnetic excitations are commensurate in the low energy regime and further develop into spin wave - like dispersion at higher energy , well consistent with the inelastic neutron scattering measurements . we clearly demonstrate that the commensurability originates from the band splitting and fermi surface topology . the commensurability is a normal state property , and has nothing to do with d - wave superconductivity . the distinct behaviors of magnetic excitation between the n - type and p - type cuprates are further discussed . our results strongly suggest the essential role of antiferromagnetic correlations in the cuprates .

0912.3913

the shape of the gamma - ray burst s lightcurves of the batse gamma - ray burst catalog @xcite carry an immense amount of information . here we focus on the possible sgr - like contamination in the batse data . we used data from the batse discsc @xmath3 dataset keeping in mind that the distant sgr signals could be very similar to the short grbs : a bright short peak and a - probably weak , noisy - extended periodic emission in the low energy bands . during the processing we ve focused on the harmonic content of the grb lightcurve . therefore during the analysis * the three background - subtracted lowest energy bands ( below @xmath4 kev ) were joined to reduce the noise ( the high energy ( @xmath5 kev ) channel behaves differently @xcite ) . we used a quadratic background fit for each channel . * fft was used to calculate the power spectrum with a window size of 1024 samples ( @xmath6 ) . this sampling determines both the lowest frequency ( @xmath7 , @xmath8 ) and the highest ( @xmath9 , @xmath10 ) . * the first @xmath11 data was excluded from the signal after the trigger ( @xmath12 ) : this ensures that even the strongest short grb lightcurve will decay and it does not interfere with any possible signal in the tail . * we generated as many data windows as possible . the starting point of the 1024-sample - sized sliding window was increased with 256 samples ( @xmath13 ) until the window s endpoint reaches the end of the data . * to reduce the power spectrums sensitivity to edge effects a blackman window was used : this data windowing prevents leakage from the nearby frequency components @xcite , and makes the power spectrum more regular . the window also reduces any spurious effects originating from the non - perfect background subtraction . * each data block was whitened before the fft . no data winzorization was applied . most of the data probably contains a poissonian noise only , therefore to determine the significance of any probable signal a monte - carlo simulation was needed . for each 1024 sample block random signals were generated 500 times by randomly shuffling the data : the maximum value in the power spectrum of each mc signal was compared with the real signal s maximum value . we select only bursts where the real signal s maximum power is bigger than _ any _ maximum in the mc signals . the candidate trigger also required to produce such harmonic power signal at least for two different window starting point ( overlapping windows were not excluded ) . these requirements select 22 grbs with unusually high harmonic power above @xmath14 . 1 . shows the power spectra of these bursts with the corresponding window start times . 2 . we show some triggers folded phase - frequency diagram and ( selected ) folded pulse shape . one can observe that some of the signals appears to be periodic : however we should keep in mind that for these triggers have only one kind of observation with fixed time resolution ( @xmath3 ) , so it is very hard to assign real significance levels to these curves . triggers # 0373 and # 6591 show a broad signal , while # 0434 and # 3359 show more narrow peaks . it is remarkable that all suspicious frequencies are beyond any known batse periodic detector effect . the sky distribution of the selected 22 triggers is plotted with on fig . 3 . , with all the batse grbs positions . the figure seems to be asymmetric : to check the randomness we calculated the dipole components from the selected subset and from @xmath15 cases of a random 22-element sample drawn from the complete batse database : this method fully eliminates the non - uniform sky - exposure function of the batse . we ve got only 3 random cases where the dipole s magnitude was bigger than the 22 triggers dipole . it gives a @xmath2 significance ( approx . @xmath16 ) for the extraordinary dipole moment . the direction of the dipole is @xmath17 . there are increasing evidence that all the grbs do not represent a physically homogeneous group @xcite . in the last years the papers @xcite provided several different tests probing the sky distribution of grb groups in batse catalog . the celestial distribution of the short batse bursts shows anisotropic behavior @xcite . the direction of the dipole is not correlated with the supergalactic plane ( not like @xcite ) and interestingly the dipole s direction is only @xmath18 away from the the cmb dipole s temperature minimum . our results suggests that some anomalous subgroups could be responsible for the weak anisotropic signals : for a more detailed answer a deeper study of this effect is necessary . we plan to provide it in a forthcoming paper . thanks are due to g. tusndy for valuable discussions . this research is supported by hungarian otka grant k077795 , by the bolyai scholarship ( i. h. ) , by the gauk grant no . 46307 , and by the research program msm0021620860 of the ministry of education of the czech republic ( a.m. ) . 99 meegan c.a . et al . , 2000 , batse gamma - ray bursts catalog , http://gammaray.msfc.nasa.gov/batse/grb/catalog bagoly , z. , mszros , a. , horvth , i. , balzs , l.g . & mszros , p. 1998 , apj , 498 , 342 press w.h . , flannery b.p . , teukolsky s.a . , vetterling w.t . , 1992 , numerical recipes , cambridge university press , cambridge horvth i. , 1998 , apj , 508 , 757 mukherjee , s. , et al . 1998 , apj , 508 , 314 hakkila j. , haglin d.j . , pendleton g.n . , mallozzi r.s . , meegan c.a . , roiger r.j . , 2000 , apj , 538 , 165 horvth i. , 2002 , a&a , 392 , 791 balzs l.g . , bagoly z. , horvth i. , mszros a. , mszros p. , 2003 , a&a , 401 , 129 hakkila , j. , et al . , 2003 , apj , 582 , 320 horvth i. , balzs l.g . , bagoly z. , ryde f. , mszros a. , 2006 , a&a , 447 , 23 balzs l.g . , mszros a. , horvth i. , 1998 , a&a , 339 , 1 mszros a. , bagoly z. , vavrek r. , 2000a , a&a , 354 , 1 mszros a. , bagoly z. , horvth i. , balzs l.g . , vavrek r. , 2000b , apj , 539 , 98 litvin , v.f . , matveev , s.a . , mamedov , s.v . , & orlov , v.v . 2001 , pisma v astronomicheskiy zhurnal , 27 , 495 r. vavrek , et al . , 2008 , mnras , 391 , 1741 - 1748 norris , , j.p . 2002 , apj , 579 , 386

the power spectra of 457 short batse bursts were analyzed , focusing on the @xmath0 lightcurves tails in the low energy bands . using mc simulations , 22 grbs were identified with unusually high harmonic power above @xmath1 . the sky distribution of these bursts shows an extraordinarily strong dipole moment with a @xmath2 significance .

astro-ph0409265

a fundamental problem in understanding the evolution of galaxy clusters and their constituent galaxies is the importance of dynamical processes such as tidal stripping . theoretical models of cluster evolution have considered collisions , mergers , dynamical friction and tidal stripping in order to explain the galaxy morphology - density relation and the presence of luminous halos around supergiant d galaxies . it is generally accepted that tidal stripping will remove the more loosely bound stars in the outer envelopes of galaxies @xcite . @xcite has argued that the extensive envelopes of cd galaxies consist of this tidal debris moving in the potential well of the cluster . however , the efficiency of tidal stripping is not well understood , because of uncertainties in the velocities , the mean tidal field , the distribution of dark matter , and the orbits of stars in the outer envelopes of the stripped galaxies . typical theoretical estimates indicate that 10 - 20% of the total cluster light should be in the intergalactic medium @xcite and that the amount of icl should increase with time @xcite . @xcite and @xcite have therefore stressed the importance of obtaining reliable measurements of the intracluster light ( icl ) as a direct indicator of the tidal damage suffered by galaxies . attempts to measure the icl date back to the early 1970s , originally being done with photographic plates . more recently ccd surveys have been employed by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite with results ranging from non - detections up to @xmath1% of the total cluster light ( surface brightnesses of @xmath2 mag arcsec@xmath3 ) . even with ccds , detecting the icl directly is notoriously difficult and fraught with uncertainties such as the contributions from overlapping galaxy halos . an independent means of measuring the icl , not subject to the same problems as measuring the extremely low surface brightness diffuse emission is needed . methods using planetary nebulae ( pne ) have been developed and applied to virgo @xcite and fornax @xcite . intergalactic red - giant - branch stars have also been detected in virgo by comparing the luminosity function of point sources in intracluster space with control fields far from any cluster or galaxy @xcite . intracluster sne have also been identified and have extended measurements of the icl out to @xmath4 @xcite . novae typically range in brightness from m@xmath5 to @xmath6 , while the bright end of the pn luminosity function reaches m@xmath7 @xcite and red - giant - branch stars typically reach m@xmath8 . supernovae are much brighter , but also much rarer than novae . novae can therefore be detected more easily in a given cluster , or be observed to greater distances than pne or red - giant stars . the transient nature of novae and their h@xmath9 brightness help eliminate the contamination suffered by pne or red - giant - branch stars due to background emission line objects or unresolved compact galaxies . another appealing property of novae is that the rate of novae per unit mass is high enough such that with a deep enough survey , one can expect to accrue a statistically interesting number of novae in each epoch , thus increasing the accuracy of the icl measurement with each new epoch . these properties give novae the potential to be useful as an independent and accurate measure of the icl in nearby clusters . in spite of this , to our knowledge , no intra - cluster novae have been reported in the literature to date . as an independent check on highly uncertain direct measures of intracluster light , we can use novae to verify the amount of stellar tidal debris in the cluster . this then places constraints on the importance of tidal stripping in the formation and evolution of galaxy clusters . our m81 nova results from the most complete nova survey ever undertaken indicate that novae are preferentially associated with the older , bulge populations in galaxies @xcite . we can use this knowledge to attempt to discern the predominant source of the icl either in bulge - dominated or disk - dominated galaxies . another lesson we have learned from our nova studies is that accurate rates and distributions can only be derived from comprehensive , densely time - sampled surveys @xcite . the data set we use in this paper is diverse and very sparsely sampled . we therefore restrict our investigation to a relative comparison of galaxy versus inter - galaxy novae . our aim is to prove the _ feasibility _ of using novae to perform an accurate assessment of the amount and origin of the icl . we have acquired six epochs of survey data of the central 30 square of the fornax cluster . fornax is nearby and has a fairly high surface density of galaxies in the core , increasing the likelihood of tidal stripping . at the distance of fornax , @xmath10 = 31.35 @xcite , novae will have an average m@xmath11(peak ) @xmath12 ( the brightest novae will have peak brightnesses of m@xmath11 = 21.35 ) , and are easily detectable . novae have been observed by @xcite in virgo cluster galaxies , which are at the same distance as fornax . novae are very bright in h@xmath9 ( b @xmath13 h@xmath14 when the nova erupts , and b @xmath13 h@xmath15 shortly thereafter ) . furthermore , novae remain bright in h@xmath9 for an extended period of time ( months ) , providing a useful means of discovering them . to a limiting magnitude of m@xmath16 = -7.5 ( m@xmath16 = 23.85 at fornax ) the mean h@xmath9 visibility lifetime is 3 months @xcite . assuming a nova rate of 24 yr@xmath17 per 10@xmath18 ( b ) @xcite , a luminosity in galaxies of m@xmath19 in the core of fornax @xcite , a visibility lifetime in h@xmath9 of 3 months , and a conservative completeness factor of 0.5 due to the high surface brightness of galaxy cores , we estimate that at any given epoch there should be @xmath1 novae in eruption ( with visible h@xmath9 emission ) in galaxies in the central 1 deg@xmath20 of the fornax cluster . since we are surveying the central @xmath21 deg@xmath20 we multiply this estimate by @xmath22 and predict we will see 12 novae in any given epoch . the observations that went into this study are a diverse set acquired over the span of more than a decade . the central 30 of fornax , centered on ra 03:38:13.72 , dec -35:32:52.2 ( j2000 ) , was surveyed . this area includes the central dominant ( cd ) galaxy ngc 1399 and three other elliptical galaxies : ngc 1404 , ngc 1387 , and ngc 1389 . this region was imaged twice in 1993 , once in 1995 , for five nights in 1999 , and once each in 2003 and 2004 . the data were acquired during programs for other projects and during engineering time or director s discretionary time . these observations are summarized in table [ tabforobs ] . because of the long - term nature of the data acquisition , there was no uniform observing strategy employed . we started with the tek2048 camera , and when the mosaic ii camera became available ( before the 1999 run ) , we switched to that camera for the remaining epochs . we used standard johnson b- and r - band filters and narrow - band h@xmath9 filters primarily , but for two epochs ( b and c , see below ) we were constrained to using a t1 filter from the washington system ( @xmath23 , fwhm @xmath24 , canterna 1976 ) , which is roughly equivalent to a johnson r filter ( @xmath25 , fwhm @xmath26 ) . the h@xmath9 filter used for the 1993 a epoch was the 6600/75 ctio filter with @xmath27 and @xmath28 which accounts for the velocity of fornax ( 1517 @xmath29 91 km s@xmath17 , grillmair et al . the h@xmath9 filter used for the 1999 and 2003 epochs was the mosaic ii c6009 filter with @xmath30 and @xmath31 . there is no h@xmath9 filter in the mosaic ii set that correctly accounts for the velocity of fornax , so we chose the filter whose central wavelength comes the closest to 6600 . we will discuss the impact of using this filter below . total exposure times were restricted by the gaps available in the schedule for other programs . individual exposure times were chosen to provide at least three frames per epoch so cosmic rays could be removed in the combining process . for the h@xmath9 frames the only exceptions to this are the 1999 g epoch ( 1 exposure ) and the 1999 h epoch ( 2 exposures ) . since cosmic rays could not be adequately removed from these exposures , they were only used for nova confirmation and measurement and not detection ( see below ) . all of the data were acquired using the ctio 4 m telescope with the exception of the b and c epoch data ( taken exclusively through the t1 filter ) which were acquired with the ctio 1.5 m telescope . the data acquired in 1993 and 1995 were taken with the tek2048 chip . the focal ratios of the 4 m and the 1.5 m are such that they produce an identical pixel scale for these images of 043 per pixel . the resulting field of view is 147 and thus required four pointings to cover the central 30 of the cluster . the seeing tabulated in table [ tabforobs ] for these epochs represents the range of seeing across the four pointings . sky flats were acquired in each filter to remove the instrumental response . the data acquired in 1999 , 2003 , and 2004 were taken with the mosaic ii camera on the 4 m telescope . this camera is a mosaic of eight 2048x4096 pixel ccds with a pixel scale of 027 per pixel . the resulting field of view is 368 and thus required only one pointing . sky flats were used to remove the instrumental response for the 1999 epochs , and dome flats were used for the 2003 and 2004 epochs . all data were reduced using the standard tools in iraf @xcite or the * mscred * external iraf package developed by the noao mosaic instrument team . individual exposures for a given epoch were combined to produce a coadded image for the epoch and to remove all but a few cosmic rays . classical novae erupt with amplitudes of up to 20 magnitudes , reaching absolute magnitudes as high as m@xmath32 and fading back to their pre - outburst brightness in a matter of weeks or months @xcite . novae in the fornax cluster are therefore invisible before outburst and fade back to invisibility after outburst on time scales of less than a year . thus , our primary criterion for detecting novae is that they be transient on this timescale . for the data used in this study this means that they must only appear in only one year s images . if a variable object appears in images from more than one year , it is most likely some other kind of variable source : a foreground periodic , or semi - periodic variable , or a background , unresolved active galaxy nucleus ( agn ) . classical novae also exhibit strong h@xmath9 emission in outburst , providing the next criterion : the candidate should be h@xmath9-bright . data from 1993 and 1999 were taken both through h@xmath9 and red continuum filters allowing us to produce h@xmath9 - red continuum subtracted images . these images were used to test candidates from 1993 and 1999 against this criterion . the primary method for implementing these criteria consisted of performing a spatial registration of the different epochs , and then blinking them against each other . we required that any candidate nova be visible on each of the individual exposures for the epoch in which it was detected . this eliminated cosmic ray hits from our candidate list . this method worked well for candidates outside of the galaxies . for candidates in the galaxies , we employed the spatial median filter technique described in @xcite with a box size of 17 pixels . the median subtracted image was then blinked in the same way as the unsubtracted images . for the epochs taken through an h@xmath9 - continuum filter pair , we scaled and subtracted the continuum image from the h@xmath9 image to accentuate the objects with h@xmath9 emission . the a ( 1993 ) and the e , g , and h ( 1999 ) epochs had this filter combination which allowed us to blink the h@xmath9-bright objects in these epochs . figure [ fnx_nov_pos ] shows the locations of the detected nova candidates on an image from the digitized sky survey covering the central 38 of the fornax cluster , corresponding to our survey area . the nova candidates are labeled by number and the galaxy identifications are also indicated . the positions of the novae are listed in table [ tab_fnx_nov_pos ] . since each candidate was discovered using slightly different techniques , each will be discussed in detail below . _ nova 1_. this candidate was discovered in the t1 image from the 1993 epoch b. it was easily compared with the t1 image from the 1995 epoch c which has a deeper frame limit afforded by the longer exposure time ( see table [ tabforobs ] ) . we did a careful spatial registration of the images from other epochs and found that , indeed , this object is a transient variable meeting the first criterion described above . it appears near a faint unresolved object , but is at least 10 times brighter than that object . figure [ fnx_n1 ] shows the three epochs of t1 images of the region ( a , b , and c ) and a subtraction of epoch c from epoch b , which removes the other stars in the field and shows nova 1 as distinct from the faint point source . _ nova 2_. the 1993 a epoch h@xmath9 - t1 image revealed an h@xmath9-bright source near the galaxy ngc 1389 . our deep h@xmath9 image from from the 1999 e epoch allowed us to easily confirm that this source was transient and an excellent nova candidate , as illustrated in figure [ fnx_n2 ] . in addition , we confirmed that the object was not visible in images from any other year . _ nova 3_. in this case we found an h@xmath9-bright source in the h@xmath9 - r image from the 1999 e epoch near the galaxy ngc 1399 as shown in figure [ fnx_n3 ] . we confirmed its transient nature by the fact that it was undetectable in all h@xmath9 and r or t1 filter epochs from other years . because we had 5 closely spaced epochs in 1999 , we were able to generate a light curve in h@xmath9 and b for this candidate ( see below ) and measure its decline rate . _ nova 4_. this candidate is nearly identical to nova 3 in the way it was discovered , although its magnitude is fainter . it is shown in figure [ fnx_n4 ] . the light curve is displayed in the next section and shows an offset between the h@xmath9 and b - band brightness of 2 magnitudes , similar to that shown by the novae in m31 @xcite . due to its faintness , we were unable to derive a decline rate in the b - band for this candidate . it was also not seen in the images from any other year . _ nova 5_. this candidate was discovered in the 2003 i h@xmath9 epoch , which did not have a corresponding red continuum image to allow subtraction . it was compared with the deeper 1999 e epoch which proves that the source is transient , as shown in figure [ fnx_n5 ] . it also does not appear on any continuum ( b or r or t1-band ) image in any other epoch . _ nova 6_. we discovered this candidate in the b - band image from the 1999 epochs after we obtained the 2004 j b - band epoch ( see figure [ fnx_n6 ] ) . in the 1999 e h@xmath9 epoch it fell on a part of the chip that had a readout problem and therefore was missed using the h@xmath9 - red continuum subtraction technique . it was missed in the comparison between the b - band epochs of a ( 1993 ) and e ( 1999 ) because the depth of the 1993 a epoch b - band image was not sufficient for a good comparison . after detecting this candidate in the b - band image from 1999 , we then went back and found the corresponding h@xmath9-bright source in the h@xmath9 - r - band image . we were unable to calibrate this candidate s h@xmath9 magnitude to better than 0.5 magnitudes because there were no calibration sources on the part of the chip with the readout problem . we were able to generate a b - band light curve ( see below ) and measure its decline rate . the h@xmath9 magnitude is highly uncertain for this candidate because of the readout problem mentioned above . nova instrumental magnitudes were derived using daophot @xcite aperture photometry . to account for variable seeing , we set the aperture radii to 1/2 the fwhm of the stellar profile measured from high signal - to - noise , well - isolated stars . photometric calibration was achieved using a variety of secondary standards . for b - band calibration we used the yale / san juan southern proper motion program @xcite which had 7 unsaturated stars in common with our b - band observations in 1999 . this produced a calibration accurate to 0.1 magnitudes . for the calibration of the t1 , and r - band photometry we used the r - band magnitudes for the globular clusters published by @xcite . for the calibration we used measurement apertures that were at least as large as those used to produce the published magnitudes @xcite . since the t1 and the r filter cover a similar wavelength range , we simply forced the t1 magnitudes to the r system . this calibration is also accurate to 0.1 magnitudes . for the h@xmath9 magnitudes , we had no calibrated h@xmath9 sources in our fields and no observations of flux standards in our h@xmath9 filters . we decided , instead , to use the r - band magnitudes from @xcite to calibrate our h@xmath9 magnitudes . this procedure is less than ideal because it introduces several uncertainties . novae are h@xmath9 emission line objects and globular clusters are continuum objects . this has been overcome in the past by using a filter that is broad enough to include most of the h@xmath9 light and then assuming the h@xmath9 light fills the bandpass , i.e. by just quoting a filter magnitude and not a line flux ( see e.g. ciardullo et al . 1989 ) . this will hold for the 1993 a epoch which used an h@xmath9 filter that is correctly redshifted for fornax and a width that includes most of the h@xmath9 light ( nova expansion velocities up to 1700 km s@xmath17 ) . for the other epochs which used an unshifted h@xmath9 filter , most of the h@xmath9 light will fall toward the red edge of the filter bandpass where the transmission is dropping rapidly . without spectra of each nova , the amount of flux lost is unknown . for objects from these filters , there will be an unknown systematic error in the filter magnitudes . this also makes calculating the limiting magnitudes for these epochs uncertain as well . with this in mind , we simply calculated the offset between the r system and our instrumental h@xmath9 magnitudes using the globular clusters , and applied this offset to force our instrumental h@xmath9 magnitudes to the r system . the number of objects used to perform the calibration varied from 13 to 30 . for the 1993 a epoch the external error in h@xmath9 is better than 0.2 magnitudes , while for the other epochs the external h@xmath9 error is such that the magnitudes quoted are overestimates ( the novae are probably brighter ) . table [ tab_fnx_nov_phot ] lists the calibrated magnitudes for each nova and figure [ fnx_lcs ] shows the b and h@xmath9 light curves for the multiply observed novae ( nova 3 , nova 4 , and nova 6 ) . we used error - weighted linear fits to derive a decline rate for nova 3 of 0.183 m@xmath11 day@xmath17 and for nova 6 of 0.205 m@xmath11 day@xmath17 . the fits are are indicated in figure [ fnx_lcs ] by the thin solid lines . the errors quoted in table [ tab_fnx_nov_phot ] and plotted in figure [ fnx_lcs ] are the internal measurement errors and in most cases are smaller than the external calibration errors . could these six candidates be some other kind of variable and not novae ? without spectra , it is impossible to be certain . all of our candidates are transient according to the criterion discussed in the first paragraph of [ novae_det ] , thus making periodic or semi - regular variables unlikely contaminators . four of the six candidates ( novae 2 , 3 , 4 , and 6 ) are h@xmath9-bright and transient , virtually ruling out other possible variables ( see below ) . other types of variables that are transient include background agn , @xmath33-ray bursts ( grbs ) , supernovae ( sne ) , and microlensing events . we must resort to statistical arguments in an attempt to eliminate each of these classifications for novae 1 and 5 . the long - term quasar variability study of @xcite shows that the rms variability of their sample is 0.45 mag in the blue and 0.33 mag in the red ( see their figure 4 ) . both nova 1 and nova 5 are measured at least a magnitude above the plate limit in the red ( t1 for nova 1 and h@xmath9 for nova 5 ) making it unlikely that these could be background agn that have varied on timescales of a year . we also checked the positions of all our novae against the deep _ chandra _ fornax x - ray survey of @xcite and found no coincidences with any x - ray sources . as an additional check we consulted the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) and found no coincidences with nova 1 or nova 5 out to a search radius of 30 arcseconds . the total grb rate derived from _ batse _ detections is about 600 yr@xmath17 , of which @xmath040% are dark , or not visible in the optical @xcite . this gives an optical grb rate of close to 1 per day over the entire sky . our survey was roughly 30 arcminutes on a side or 0.25 square degrees , so the a priori probability of detecting a grb in our survey field in any given epoch is @xmath34 . an estimate of the sn rate in the local universe is given by @xcite who gives the rate for all types of sne of @xmath35 sn @xmath36 yr@xmath17 . if we compare this to the nova rate from @xcite of 24 novae @xmath37 yr@xmath17 we see that novae are @xmath38 times more common than sne in the local universe ( using h@xmath39 mpc@xmath17 ) . this makes it more likely that our candidates are novae rather than sne in the fornax cluster that declined substantially before we detected them . it is also very unlikely that a sn in the fornax cluster would go undetected since it would reach a brightness of 12th magnitude and would decay with a timescale of months . that being said , we can see sne 100 times more distant than novae ( sn reach m@xmath40 ) . we must , therefore , consider sne in undetected background galaxies and intracluster sne in background clusters . @xcite did find a background cluster in their deep x - ray survey of fornax , but it is located 2.6 arcminutes from nova 1 and has a diameter of 1.4 arcminutes in the soft band and so it is not likely that nova 1 is a sn associated with this cluster . we can not rule out the possibility that the object next to nova 1 is an unresolved galaxy and that nova 1 is a sn in that galaxy . a spectrum of this object would resolve this issue , but it would require a very large telescope since it is very faint ( r @xmath0 24.5 ) . our deepest b - band image has a plate limit of 26 . no objects are found to this limit at the positions of any of the novae ( with the exception of nova 1 ) . if nova 5 was really a sn in an undetected background galaxy or cluster it would have to be fainter than b of 26 and therefore much fainter than the sn itself . although unlikely , we can not rule this possibility out . to assess the contamination from microlensing events , we will turn to a microlensing survey of m87 in virgo by @xcite . using the wfpc2 camera on _ hst _ every day for a month , this study detected 1 strong microlensing candidate . it s peak magnitude was fainter than 24 and would have been barely detected in our deepest survey epochs . they report that this detection rate is consistent with the sensitivity and coverage of their survey and their microlensing models that included self - lensing from stars in m87 , lensing from the m87 halo , the virgo halo , and foreground lensing from the milky way @xcite . our sensitivity to microlensing events would be considerably less than their survey due to our lower resolution and shallower depth ( our faintest measurement in the b - band is 24.8 , their faint limit is 28.5 assuming a 3@xmath41 detection , see baltz et al . the microlensing models from @xcite show that self - lensing and lensing from the milky way halo provide the smallest contributions to the microlensing rate . the largest microlensing rates come from the virgo halo , however , the rate depends strongly on the concentration of lenses toward the center of m87 where there are more sources to be lensed . this means that our much larger survey area does not drastically increase our sensitivity to microlensing events relative to theirs . this is because even though we include many more lenses ( the fornax cluster halo ) , we only include a factor of a few more sources to be lensed ( the stars of ngc 1399 and the other three galaxies ) which would not make up for the much brighter faint limit and the lower resolution of our survey . from the models of @xcite , we assume that the probability for a microlensing event drops with underlying stellar density . from their observed rate and the relative similarity of m87 and ngc 1399 , we would expect to barely detect one event in ngc 1399 in one month . we can eliminate the microlensing classification for our h@xmath9-bright candidates because microlensing events are not h@xmath9-bright . the two remaining nova candidates , nova 1 and nova 5 , are distant from background stellar light and so the probability of detecting a lensing event in those regions should be much less than predicted in the study by @xcite . admitting that the classification for all our candidates is not iron - clad , these arguments indicate the most probable interpretation is that our candidates are novae . we will assume so for our subsequent analysis . we were fortunate that three of the novae erupted during the five epoch run in 1999 . the two measured decline rates ( see figure [ fnx_lcs ] ) of 0.183 m@xmath11 day@xmath17 for nova 3 and 0.205 m@xmath11 day@xmath17 for nova 6 place both in the fast nova category . if we assume a distance modulus to the fornax cluster of @xmath42 @xcite , then our brightest b magnitude for nova 3 is at [email protected] . typically , novae reach peak b magnitudes of m@xmath44 , so nova 3 is clearly a brighter - than - average nova ( see , e.g. , figure 5.3 in warner 1995 ) . the flat shape of the h@xmath9 light curve indicates that we have caught this nova near h@xmath9 maximum and during the earliest phases of the b decline . the brightness of nova 3 is consistent with its fast decline rate since decline rate is known to correlate with nova peak brightness @xcite . given the decline rate of nova 6 , it is possible that this nova was at least as bright as nova 3 at maximum , but that we are observing it in its later decline phase . the large uncertainty in the h@xmath9 magnitude for this nova does not allow us to compare its b and h@xmath9 magnitudes . with the uncertainties in the survey h@xmath9 limit mentioned above it is difficult to quantitatively assess the nova populations in the cluster . as stated in [ fnx_intro ] , we predicted 12 novae to have visible h@xmath9 emission down to the limit of m@xmath45 in any given h@xmath9 epoch , yet we detected only 5 novae in our 3 h@xmath9 epochs , a factor of 7 less than we expected . there are several factors that could reduce the number of novae we detected . intracluster novae with velocities that would shift their h@xmath9 emission even farther to the red would lose a significant amount of their flux in the epochs using the unshifted h@xmath9 filter ( epochs e , g , h , and i ) . accounting for the velocity dispersion of the intracluster population and the individual galaxies , it is possible that we are down by at least a factor of 4 by using the unshifted h@xmath9 filter for two of the three years of the survey . we point out that our earlier results indicate that novae are predominantly associated with the bulge population of m81 @xcite . novae , therefore , have the potential to provide some clues to the source of the intracluster light . a long - term , densely time - sampled study is required to properly assess the nova parent population in fornax . since all regions in the survey were sampled with equal frequency , an analysis of the spatial distribution of the fornax novae is worthwhile , though it can not be conclusive . we deliberately limited ourselves to two simple questions about the spatial distribution of novae in the fornax cluster . first , assuming that novae follow the bulge light in galaxies @xcite , how many novae did we miss in the centers of the galaxies ? second , based on the light profiles of the galaxies , how many novae are associated with the cluster potential and not with any galaxy ? to answer these questions , we required the light profiles of the four galaxies in our survey region : ngc 1399 , ngc 1404 , ngc 1389 , and ngc 1387 . since ngc 1399 has an extended halo , we used the study of @xcite for its light profile . they used a combination of wide - field photographic plates and narrower - field ccd data to generate a profile that extends nearly 2000 arcseconds from the center of ngc 1399 . for the other profiles , we used our b - band mosaic image from the 1999 epochs . we measured their profiles using the ellipse task in the stsdas * isophote * package . isophotes were fit on background subtracted images with the background being determined by the region in the chip most distant from the galaxy . the task was given the initial center position , position angle ( pa ) , and ellipticity and allowed to vary these parameters at each semi - major axis position , which was set to grow geometrically and not linearly . this allowed the outer isophotes to contain enough signal to produce reasonable fits . to answer the incompleteness question , we used artificial stars to determine our detection limit for each galaxy . our goal was to produce a simple correction to the number of novae found in the galaxies . we used the artificial stars to ask the question , how close to the nucleus of the galaxy could the nova that was discovered in that galaxy be found ? by comparing this radial limit to the light profile , we know how much light in the galaxy was effectively unsurveyed for novae of the brightness already discovered , and can thus make a correction based on the fraction of the total light unsurveyed . daophot was used to generate a point spread function ( psf ) and then used to add artificial stars around each galaxy . the galaxy images were then median - filtered , and subtracted , and ( as described above ) blinked to see where the artificial novae become undetectable . in all cases this limit was determined by the residual light left by the subtraction of the median - filtered image . thus , the inner profiles of the galaxies strongly affected this detection limit . figure [ fnx_profs ] shows the cumulative light profiles for the four galaxies , normalized to the total light . we set the total light limit at 26 b magnitudes per square arcsecond for the galaxies we measured . the profile of ngc 1404 was contaminated by a very bright star 180 " from the galaxy , so we set a limit at that distance of 25 b magnitudes per square arcsecond . the first thing we notice is the extent of the halo of ngc 1399 . nearly the entire survey area is enclosed by this halo . we will assume that this halo actually traces the inner potential well of the cluster itself as suggested by @xcite . we also see that nova 2 is clearly associated with ngc 1389 : it is close to the half - light radius , but the association of the other novae is not straightforward . nova 4 appears at a radius that encloses over 80% of the light of ngc 1387 , while nova 5 and nova 6 are even farther outside of ngc 1404 . interpreting the nova placement in ngc 1399 is complicated by the extended halo , although it seems clear that nova 3 belongs with that galaxy . the extent of the halo of ngc 1399 means that nova 1 is located just beyond the half - light radius , but clearly it is more properly placed in the cluster rather than in that galaxy ( see figure [ fnx_nov_pos ] ) . @xcite found that the transition from being bound to ngc 1399 and being bound solely to the cluster occurs at a distances between 15 and 55 from the center of ngc 1399 ( see their figure 2 ) . nova 1 is 82 from the center of ngc 1399 and well past this transition . we also placed nova 6 on the ngc 1399 light profile and it appears at a radius that encloses only 65% of the light . to be conservative , we ll assume that 4 of our novae ( 2 , 3 , 4 , and 5 ) are associated with the galaxies in the cluster and 2 ( 1 and 6 ) are not . but how many novae did we miss in the centers of the galaxies ? to generate a correction for missed novae , we look at the fraction of light unsurveyed , as determined by our detection limits and plotted as the vertical dot - dashed lines in figure [ fnx_profs ] . for ngc 1399 this fraction of unsurveyed light is 0.15 , for ngc 1404 it is 0.4 , for ngc 1387 it is 0.3 and for ngc 1389 it is 0.45 , giving a total unsurveyed light fraction of @xmath46 . since we found , on average , 1 nova associated with a galaxy , this would essentially add another @xmath47 novae to our number associated with galaxies , giving a final score of 5.3 novae in and 2 novae outside of galaxies in the cluster . the x - ray study of the fornax cluster by @xcite offers some interesting evidence concerning the association of the novae with the galaxies nearby . figure [ fnx_xray ] shows the x - ray flux levels near ngc 1399 and ngc 1404 generated from a soft band image ( 0.3 - 1.5 kev ) with an exposure time of @xmath045 ksec @xcite . ten evenly spaced contour levels ranging from a flux of 7.7@xmath4810@xmath49 erg cm@xmath3 s@xmath17 arcmin@xmath3 to a flux of 4.9@xmath4810@xmath51 erg cm@xmath3 s@xmath17 arcmin@xmath3 are overplotted on our b - band image from epoch j ( 2004 ) . three of our novae ( nova 3 , nova 5 and nova 6 ) fall in this region and are indicated by small boxes and labeled with their identifications . as pointed out in @xcite , ngc 1404 has a bow - shock on the side facing ngc 1399 due to its motion toward ngc 1399 . the comet - like tail they describe is apparent in the lowest contour of figure [ fnx_xray ] . this figure solidifies the association of nova 6 with intracluster space and not with ngc 1404 because it is well outside the lowest x - ray contours for ngc 1404 and well outside the bow - shock of the x - ray gas in ngc 1404 . using our optical light profiles alone ( see figure [ fnx_profs ] ) , we would associate nova 5 with ngc 1404 . we see from figure [ fnx_xray ] that nova 5 is outside of the bow - shock of ngc 1404 . without a detailed investigation of the dynamics of ngc 1404 , we can not conclusively say that the stars outside the bow - shock are not bound to ngc 1404 , but the placement of nova 5 is suggestive of its membership in the intracluster population . this evidence suggests that we might revise our score to 4.3 novae in galaxies and 3 novae in intracluster space . assuming that novae trace the intracluster light in a galaxy cluster , we calculate that the icl contributes @xmath52% of the total light in the fornax cluster . this is very close to the estimate of 40% by @xcite , who used intergalactic planetary nebulae ( pne ) . this is likely an overestimate of the icl due to contamination by background ly@xmath9-emitting galaxies masquerading as pn @xcite . if we move one nova from the out to the in category ( e.g. , nova 5 ) , we get an icl fraction of @xmath53% of the total light , similar to the icl fraction of 22% estimated for virgo by @xcite from intergalactic pne . if we also assume that one of our intracluster novae is really a background sn ( e.g. , nova 1 ) , then we get an icl fraction of @xmath54% . all these numbers are within the range of other measures of icl . _ our key result is that we have demonstrated for the first time that intergalactic tramp novae very likely exist in the fornax cluster , and that they can be useful tracers of the icl_. clearly , a longer - term , densely time - sampled survey in h@xmath9 and continuum light of this region would allow us to provide a much more accurate measure of the icl in fornax . using an h@xmath9 filter that accounts for both the redshift of fornax and the velocity dispersion of the cluster and member galaxies as well as the range of nova line widths would improve the number of novae detected in each epoch by a factor of up to 7 over the survey reported here . this kind of survey would not only bolster the statistics by adding more novae , but would also provide light curves which can be used to better verify novae and estimate their peak brightnesses . it would also allow us to estimate the nova rates in each galaxy and in the icl . this would be the first step toward assessing the source population of the icl and estimating the effect of the galaxy cluster environment on close binary stars . \1 . intra - cluster novae do exist in the fornax cluster and their distribution is consistent with @xmath016 - 41% of the total light in the cluster being contributed by the icl . the high end of this range is close to the estimate of the icl in fornax using intracluster pne by @xcite . the low end is close to the estimate of the icl in virgo using intracluster pne by @xcite . tramp novae are very interesting and useful as tracers of the icl . their brightness at peak ( m@xmath11 up to @xmath1310 ) allows them to be visible out to the coma cluster with current telescopes . new objects can be accumulated with each observation epoch , increasing the accuracy of the measure of the icl with time . as our understanding of nova parent populations improves , they may become useful for constraining the origin of the tidal debris in clusters . we wish to thank martin bureau , jeremy mould , tim abbott , knut olsen , and chris smith for their support in acquiring fornax cluster survey epochs in 2003 and 2004 . we would also like to thank the anonymous referee for very useful comments on the manuscript . this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration . arnaboldi , m. , et al . 2003 , , 125 , 514 baltz , e. a. , lauer , t. r. , zurek , d. r. , gondolo , p. , shara , m. m. , silk , j. , & zepf , s. e. 2004 , astro - ph/0310845 bernstein , g. m. , nichol , r. c. , tyson , j. a. , ulmer , m. p. , & wittman , d. 1995 , , 110 , 1507 boughn , s. p. , kuhn , j. r. , & uson , j. m. 1990 , iau symp . 139 : the galactic and extragalactic background radiation , 139 , 357 cappellaro , e. 2001 , memorie della societa astronomica italiana , 72 , 863 canterna , r. 1976 , , 81 , 228 ciardullo , r. , jacoby , g. h. , ford , h. c. , & neill , j. d. 1989 , , 339 , 53 ciardullo , r. , shafter , a. w. , ford , h. c. , neill , j. d. , shara , m. m. , & tomaney , a. b. 1990a , , 356 , 472 ciardullo , r. , tamblyn , p. , jacoby , g. h. , ford , h. c. , & williams , r. e. 1990b , , 99 , 1079 ciardullo , r. , feldmeier , j. j. , krelove , k. , jacoby , g. h. , & gronwall , c. 2002 , , 566 , 784 dressler , a. 1984 , , 22 , 185 durrell , p. r. , ciardullo , r. , feldmeier , j. j. , jacoby , g. h. , & sigurdsson , s. 2002 , , 570 , 119 feldmeier , j. j. , ciardullo , r. , & jacoby , g. h. 1998 , , 503 , 109 feldmeier , j. j. , ciardullo , r. , jacoby , g. h. , & durrell , p. r. 2003 , , 145 , 65 ferguson , h. c. 1989 , , 98 , 367 ferguson , h. c. , tanvir , n. r. , & von hippel , t. 1998 , , 391 , 461 gal - yam , a. , maoz , d. , guhathakurta , p. , & filippenko , a. v. 2003 , , 125 , 1087 grillmair , c. j. , freeman , k. c. , bicknell , g. v. , carter , d. , couch , w. j. , sommer - larsen , j. , & taylor , k. 1994 , , 422 , l9 helfand , d. j. , stone , r. p. s. , willman , b. , white , r. l. , becker , r. h. , price , t. , gregg , m. d. , & mcmahon , r. g. 2001 , , 121 , 1872 kissler - patig , m. , grillmair , c. j. , meylan , g. , brodie , j. p. , minniti , d. , & goudfrooij , p. 1999 , , 117 , 1206 maddox , s. j. , efstathiou , g. , sutherland , w. j. , & loveday , j. 1990 , , 243 , 692 merritt , d. 1984 , , 276 , 26 miller , g. e. 1983 , , 268 , 495 murante , g. , et al . 2004 , , 607 , l83 neill , j. d. & shara , m. m. 2004 , 127 , 816 partridge , r. b. 1990 , iau symp . 139 : the galactic and extragalactic background radiation , 139 , 283 platais , i. , et al . 1998 , , 116 , 2556 pritchet , c. j. & van den bergh , s. 1987 , , 318 , 507 richstone , d. o. 1976 , , 204 , 642 saglia , r. p. , kronawitter , a. , gerhard , o. , & bender , r. 2000 , , 119 , 153 shara , m. m. 1981 , apj , 243 , 926 scharf , c. a. , zurek , d. & bureau , m. 2004 , apj , submitted stetson , p. b. 1987 , , 99 , 191 theuns , t. & warren , s. j. 1997 , , 284 , l11 tody , d. 1986 , proc . spie , 627 , 733 vilchez - gomez , r. , pello , r. , & sanahuja , b. 1994 , , 283 , 37 warner , b. 1995 , cataclysmic variable stars , cambridge astrophysics series ( cambridge , new york : cambridge university press ) willman , b. , governato , f. , wadsley , j. & quinn , t. 2004 , , 355 , 159 zhang , b. & meszaros , p. 2004 , astro - ph/0311321 clllllc a & nov-1993 & 4m - ctio & tek2048 & b & 900 & 1.5 - 2.2 + & `` & '' & `` & t1 & 900 & 1.4 - 1.7 + & '' & `` & '' & h@xmath9 & 4500 & 1.4 - 1.9 + b & dec-1993 & 1.5m - ctio & tek2048 & t1 & 5400 & 1.1 - 1.3 + c & oct-1995 & 1.5m - ctio & tek2048 & t1 & 9000 & 1.1 - 1.5 + d & 05-dec-1999 & 4m - ctio & mosaic 8k & b & 4200 & 1.0 + e & 07-dec-1999 & `` & '' & r & 1260 & 0.9 + & `` & '' & `` & h@xmath9 & 7200 & 0.8 + f & 08-dec-1999 & '' & `` & b & 4200 & 1.1 + g & 11-dec-1999 & '' & `` & r & 1260 & 1.2 + & '' & `` & '' & h@xmath9 & 1800 & 1.2 + & `` & '' & `` & b & 1800 & 1.4 + h & 12-dec-1999 & '' & `` & r & 1260 & 1.6 + & '' & `` & '' & h@xmath9 & 3600 & 1.4 + & `` & '' & " & b & 3000 & 1.2 + i & 27-feb-2003 & 4m - ctio & mosaic 8k & h@xmath9 & 6000 & 1.2 + j & 14-jan-2004 & 4m - ctio & mosaic 8k & b & 8100 & 1.8 1 & 03:39:06.2 & -35:23:48 & b & ngc 1399 & 489 + 2 & 03:37:12.1 & -35:44:11 & a & ngc 1389 & 37 + 3 & 03:38:29.0 & -35:29:02 & d - h & ngc 1399 & 121 + 4 & 03:36:55.8 & -35:28:39 & d - h & ngc 1387 & 108 + 5 & 03:39:04.5 & -35:34:45 & i & ngc 1404 & 164 + 6 & 03:39:18.4 & -35:35:55 & d - h & ngc 1404 & 329 rrclrc 1 & 49331.53 & b & t1 & 21.9 & 0.1 + + 2 & 49299.84 & a & h@xmath9 & 21.1 & 0.4 + + 3 & 51519.07 & e & h@xmath9 & 22.1 & 0.1 + & 51523.10 & g & h@xmath9 & 22.0 & 0.1 + & 51525.05 & h & h@xmath9 & 22.1 & 0.1 + + & 51517.05 & d & b & 22.2 & 0.1 + & 51521.04 & f & b & 23.0 & 0.1 + & 51523.13 & g & b & 23.2 & 0.2 + & 51525.10 & h & b & @xmath5523.0 & + + 4 & 51519.07 & e & h@xmath9 & 22.8 & 0.1 + & 51523.10 & g & h@xmath9 & 23.1 & 0.2 + & 51525.05 & h & h@xmath9 & 22.8 & 0.1 + + & 51517.05 & d & b & @xmath5524.9 & + & 51521.04 & f & b & 24.8 & 0.3 + & 51523.13 & g & b & @xmath5523.8 & + & 51525.10 & h & b & @xmath5523.0 & + + 5 & 52697.07 & i & h@xmath9 & 22.8 & 0.1 + + 6 & 51519.07 & e & h@xmath9 & 24.2 & 0.5 + & 51523.10 & g & h@xmath9 & @xmath5523.5 & + & 51525.05 & h & h@xmath9 & @xmath5522.8 & + + & 51517.05 & d & b & 23.4 & 0.1 + & 51521.04 & f & b & 24.2 & 0.1 + & 51523.13 & g & b & @xmath55 24.3 & + & 51525.10 & h & b & @xmath55 22.7 &

we report the results of a survey for novae in and between the galaxies of the fornax cluster . our survey provides strong evidence that intracluster novae exist and that they provide a useful , independent measure of the intracluster light in fornax . we discovered six strong nova candidates in six distinct epochs spanning eleven years from 1993 to 2004 . the data were taken with the 4 m and the 1.5 m telescopes at ctio . the spatial distribution of the nova candidates is consistent with @xmath016 - 41% of the total light in the cluster being in the intracluster light , based on the ratio of the number of novae we discovered in intracluster space over the total number of novae discovered plus a simple completeness correction factor . this estimate is consistent with independent measures of intracluster light in fornax and virgo using intracluster planetary nebulae . the accuracy of the intracluster light measurement improves with each survey epoch as more novae are discovered .

astro-ph0305474

as we heard in the talks by uros seljak and lam hui in this meeting , the physics of the forest , as measured in high-@xmath0 quasi - stellar object ( qso ) spectra , is reasonably simple . at these redshifts the gas making up the intergalactic medium is in photoionization equilibrium , which results in a tight density temperature relation for the absorbing material with the neutral hydrogen density proportional to a power of the baryon density . since pressure forces are sub - dominant , the neutral hydrogen density closely traces the total matter density on the scales relevant to the forest ( @xmath1mpc ) . the structure in qso absorption thus traces , in a calculable way , slight fluctuations in the matter density of the universe back along the line of sight to the qso , with most of the forest arising from over - densities of a few times the mean density . in this contribution i want to focus on two areas where the forest can be used to constrain cosmology and astrophysics . the first , dealing with measuring the matter power spectrum at high redshift , is quite speculative , but might be very exciting . the second has a higher chance of success and may tell us something about the nature of the ionizing sources , the end of the dark ages and the formation of the first objects in the universe . the presence of a series of almost regularly spaced peaks in the cosmic microwave background temperature angular power spectrum has now been compellingly demonstrated . the same physics which gives rise to these peaks , acoustic oscillations in the baryon - photon plasma prior to recombination @xcite , also predicts a ( much smaller ) series of peaks in the matter power spectrum . a measurement of these peaks would provide a fundamental test of the paradigm , and an independent measure of the @xmath0-dependent hubble constant and distance - redshift relation @xcite . because non - linear growth ` washes out ' the peaks @xcite they are best searched for at high redshift . the baryon oscillations themselves lie at @xmath3mpc ( see fig . [ fig : d2 ] ) , with an amplitude of 5% or less for currently popular cosmological models @xcite . the higher modes are roughly out of phase with the photon peaks ( also in @xmath4-space ) and appear half as often as the peaks in the cmb spectrum ( see e.g. fig . 1 of @xcite ) . the peaks are suppressed by silk damping beyond @xmath5mpc . naively the best way to measure the small baryonic oscillations in the matter power spectrum would be an ultra - large galaxy redshift survey at high-@xmath0 . such a survey would require next - generation instruments and a large dedicated team . thus even with adequate funding and heroic efforts it is several years away . it is therefore interesting to explore whether one could measure the baryonic oscillations another way . within a few years the sdss will return a catalogue of @xmath6 qsos over @xmath7 square degrees of sky . these quasars will be distributed in both redshift and angular separation , but simple counting suggests that one should find many hundreds to several thousands with separations of tens of mpc above @xmath8 . it is therefore interesting to ask whether this sample could be used to probe the baryon oscillations . using simply the auto - power spectrum of the forest will not work , because the line - of - sight spectrum at @xmath4 is an integral of the 3d spectrum over wavenumbers greater than @xmath4 . this integration suppresses the small oscillations which are our primary signal . however one can consider the cross - spectra , where one line - of - sight is cross - correlated with a neighboring line - of - sight . as we shall show below this statistic is sensitive to the oscillations . in addition uncorrelated errors from e.g. continuum fitting , should be averaged down in this procedure relative to their value in the auto - spectrum . since we are working on large scales , where the noise is essentially absent , one could in principle measure the flux cross - spectrum to the cosmic variance limit @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the number of pairs , @xmath11 is the fundamental mode along the line - of - sight and @xmath12 is the width of the bin in @xmath4-space in which we are measuring the power . we can alternatively write @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the length of the ` useful ' part of the spectrum . unless we attempt to fit to the higher lines , the useful length of the spectrum is the section between and ly@xmath15 which covers hundreds of mpc in the rest frame of the absorbers . thus with a few hundred pairs it is possible to measure the cross - spectrum with error bars on the order of per cent . one major advantage here is that , like the cmb itself , the redshift and scale dependence of the peaks is accurately calculable given a cosmological model . this allows us to perform a likelihood estimation of the relevant cosmological factors , including pairs of different distances and redshifts , rather than attempt to perform an inversion on the irregularly sampled data . though the latter can be done , it is considerably more difficult than the ` forward ' approach . by applying the idea of the peak - background split from large - scale structure is it possible to show that , for sufficiently large scales and assuming @xmath16 , the flux cross - spectrum , @xmath17 , along two lines of sight separated by distance @xmath18 is proportional to the dark matter cross - power spectrum @xmath19 ( see also @xcite ) . on these very large scales we can neglect the effects of thermal broadening or peculiar velocities . the dm cross - spectrum is simply related to the 3d power spectrum by @xmath20 or @xcite @xmath21 where the inverse relation holds @xmath22 . note that for smooth spectra , @xmath23 gets contributions from @xmath24 . as @xmath25 , @xmath26 and we find the auto - spectrum is the projection of the 3d spectrum as anticipated . converting from @xmath27mpc to s / km using @xmath28 we find that the relevant spectral range is roughly @xmath29s / km to @xmath30s / km . this is quite large scale , roughly comparable to the fundamental mode if we measure only from 100 nm to 120 nm . on the positive side fig . [ fig : pi ] shows that the signal is present in the cross spectra at separations of 10mpc or so . the relative amplitude of the oscillations ( which is the figure of merit for cosmic variance dominated measurements ) can be quite large , 10% or more , compared to the accuracy with which @xmath19 can be measured . because we can accurately predict the positions and amplitudes of the peaks we know both the @xmath18 and @xmath0 dependence of the signal . on the negative side there is only a small fractional change in @xmath19 when @xmath19 is big ( i.e. @xmath18 small ) and the larger fractional change in @xmath19 when @xmath19 is small . this suggests we would be working primarily at very low signal levels , where systematics become increasingly important . also , if we work with the spectra only between and ly@xmath15 we do not have very much ` spare ' resolution in @xmath4 to see the oscillations . we would ideally probe @xmath31s / km which requires very long spectra . in summary , the signal of baryon oscillations is lurking in the cross - spectra of qso pairs , which allow us to probe large volumes of space at high redshift with a modest investment in telescope time . a naive estimate of the cosmic variance limitations of a qso survey like the sdss suggests that the signal could be seen in a likelihood analysis with high confidence . however the overall signal levels are very low and there are numerous sources of systematic error which may make the signal forever unmeasurable . currently the sources that make up the uv background are unknown . however the mean optical depth @xmath32 in the forest offers a way to constrain the source emissivity and fluctuations in the uvbg can be used to constrain the nature of the sources . i have been involved in a long - running collaboration with avery meiksin to investigate these issues @xcite , and present some of our basic results here . first we consider the constraints on the source emissivity @xmath33 . given a cosmological model , the mean flux or optical depth @xmath32 fixes the ionization rate @xmath34 . if we approximate @xmath35 $ ] as @xmath36 $ ] where @xmath37 is the _ attenuation length _ then @xmath38 . here @xmath39 is an effective attenuation length which interpolates between the attenuation limited ( @xmath40 ) and cosmological expansion+age limited ( @xmath41 ) regimes and @xmath42 is the hubble distance . as a function of @xmath33 the transition between the attenuation limited and cosmologically limited regimes is very abrupt , and at fixed @xmath33 , @xmath37 falls rapidly with increasing redshift . this in turn means that @xmath32 rises rapidly , almost exponentially , with redshift . [ fig : fig3 ] shows the emissivity of the sources , as a function of @xmath0 , required to fit the observed @xmath32 . this is compared to extrapolations of the qso luminosity function . from this we can see that qsos may contribute a substantial fraction of the uv background even as high as @xmath43 . if qsos do contribute non - negligibly to the uv background then we would expect large spatial fluctuations in @xmath34 . conversely , if galaxies or star clusters dominate the uv background we expect to see only the imprint of large - scale structure . unfortunately the effects of uv background correlations are most conspicuous at @xmath44 , where the precise level of absorption by the forest is most difficult to measure because of extremely low flux values . fig . [ fig : onesource ] shows how a simulated spectrum is changed if the uv background is ( unrealistically ) dominated by a single source as compared to the usually assumed smooth behavior . to assess a more realistic situation it is necessary to resort to monte carlo simulations in which sources are placed within the simulation volume , the uv background computed and then spectra created from the density and velocity fields within the box . our investigations suggest that the 1-point distribution is relatively unaffected by fluctuations in the uvbg , however the 2-point statistics ( the flux correlation function and power spectrum ) show noticeable differences at high redshift @xcite . in addition fluctuations in the uvbg will increase the estimated optical depth over the value that would be estimated assuming a homogeneous background @xcite . this increases the demand placed on the ionization rate required to reproduce @xmath32 and needs to be included when comparing with estimates of source emissivity . the forest is emerging as a powerful probe of structure formation at high redshift . because the physics is relatively well understood we can compare increasingly realistic calculations with ever better data to constrain our cosmological models . here we have investigated two ways in which the forest constrains cosmology . the first , speculative , proposal was to search for baryonic oscillations in the matter power spectrum through their imprint in the forest cross - spectra . the second proposal was to constrain the emissivity of the sources of the uv background using the measured mean optical depth of qso spectra . in the first case we found that while in principle the signal - to - noise and statistics of the signal were favorable , in practice the very low signal levels made this measurement prone to numerous systematic effects . in the second case we showed that reasonable extrapolations of the qso luminosity function to high-@xmath0 would allow qsos to contribute a non - negligible fraction of the uv background even as early as @xmath45 . if this turns out to be the case , the uv background should have relatively large spatial fluctuations which can affect the 2-point statistics of the forest at high @xmath0 . _ acknowledgements : _ i thank simon white for allowing me to present our work on baryon oscillations in the forest , and avery meiksin for several years of productive collaborations , including many enlightening conversations on the physics of the igm . i would also like to thank the organizers for such an interesting and successful conference .

the forest has emerged as one of the few systems capable of probing small - scale structure at high-@xmath0 with high precision . in this talk i highlight two areas in which the forest is shedding light on fundamental questions in cosmology , one speculative and one which should be possible in the near future .

cond-mat0112216

resonant tunneling ( rt ) through double - barrier structures ( dbs ) make these systems very promising candidates for a new generation of ultra - high speed electronic devices . for instance , a gaas - ga@xmath1al@xmath0as dbs operating at thz frequencies has been reported in the literature.@xcite the basic reason for rt to arise in dbs is a quantum phenomenon whose fundamental characteristics are by now well understood : there exists a dramatic increase of the electron transmission whenever the energy of the incident electron is close to one of the unoccupied quasi - bound - states inside the well.@xcite in practice , a bias voltage is applied to shift the energy of this quasi - bound - state of nonzero width so that its center matches the fermi level . consequently , the @xmath2 characteristics present negative differential resistance when the quasi - bound - state lies well below the fermi level . in actual samples , however , the situation is much more complex than this simple picture . scattering by phonons , electrons or defects reduces the required quantum coherence and , in fact , deviations from the above simple description are observed . these scattering mechanisms explain the occurrence of side - band resonant peaks due to the interaction with phonons@xcite and photons,@xcite hysteresis in the @xmath2 characteristics due to many body effects,@xcite and the decrease of electron mobility due to rough surfaces even in good - quality heterostructures.@xcite while one - dimensional models successfully describe scattering by electrons and phonons , they obviously can not account for all interface roughness effects . so far , there are analytical results concerning the propagation of wave packets in a randomly layered medium when the potential is a random function of only one coordinate,@xcite but for a small number of layers , as in dbs , in - plane disorder becomes important and one expects such approaches to fail . realistic models of in - plane disorder , including power - like or exponential spatial correlations observed by transmission electron microscopy , usually lead to intractable analytical models ; hence the importance of numerically solvable models to bridge this gap . an important contribution was already provided by henrickson _ et al . _ , who applied the tight - binding green function method to interface roughness in dbs.@xcite in this paper transmission was studied for a dbs with a rather simple model of disorder ( periodic roughness with random relative phases at the interfaces ) . a level splitting was found for narrow well dbs and a dependence on the roughness lateral size was observed . in this work we present a simple two - dimensional model that allowed us to carry out an extensive study of electron scattering by interface roughness and how it manifests trough vertical transport properties of the dbs . in particular , we aim to elucidate the relationship between macroscopic properties of the dbs ( e.g. conductance ) with microscopic parameters of the model ( e.g. correlation length of the surface disorder ) . the paper is organized as follows : the body of the paper is sec . [ sec2 ] , where we present our model based , on the effective - mass approximation , describing a disordered sample ( e.g. an imperfect dbs ) connected to two perfectly ohmic leads . the ben daniel - duke equation is discretized , boundary conditions are discussed and scattering solutions are found by means of the transfer - matrix method for _ any _ arbitrary heterostructure made of wide gap semiconductors . afterwards , expressions for two - terminal conductance and current for unintentionally disordered dbs are provided . the model is worked out in a two - dimensional space for computational limitations , although it will be clear that generalization to three dimensions is rather straightforward . section [ sec3 ] describes the various models of disorder we have used to mimic structural data obtained by transmission electron microscopy and x - ray scattering . in sec . [ sec4 ] we present the numerical results and , in particular , the relationship between macroscopic properties of the dbs with microscopic parameters of the model . finally , in sec . [ sec5 ] we discuss our results and the main conclusions of the work . we consider the single - electron two - dimensional schrdinger equation within the framework of the one - band effective - mass approximation . close to the @xmath3 valley , this approach leads to the ben daniel - duke equation for the envelope function @xmath4\psi(y , z)=e\psi(y , z).\ ] ] where @xmath5 denotes the coordinate along the growth direction ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) . notice that we have taken a constant effective mass @xmath6 at the @xmath3 valley although this is not a serious limitation as the model can be easily generalized to include a position - dependent effective mass . we then consider a mesh with lattice spacings @xmath7 and @xmath8 in the @xmath9 and @xmath5 directions , respectively . defining @xmath10 and @xmath11 , we arrive at the following discretized version of eq . ( [ hamiltonian ] ) @xmath12 the potential term @xmath13 in eq . ( [ discrete ] ) is given by the conduction - band edge energy at the point @xmath14 which , in turn , depends on the al mole fraction in the vicinity of that position . consequently , both kinds of disorder ( lateral and compositional ) are taken into account through this diagonal term ( diagonal disorder ) . in order to solve the tight binding - like equation ( [ discrete ] ) we use the transfer matrix method based on the solutions calculated for each slide of the system along the @xmath5 direction . to this end , we define @xmath15 and @xmath16 here @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the number of mesh divisions in the @xmath9 and @xmath5 directions , respectively . note that periodic boundary conditions have been taken into account on each slide . with these definitions , eq . ( [ discrete ] ) can be cast in a more compact form @xmath19 where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the @xmath22 identity and null matrices respectively . this expression allows us to relate by iteration the envelope function amplitudes at non - consecutive slides . in particular , we can obtain the expression of the envelope function amplitudes in the left contact as a function of the amplitudes in the right one @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the transfer matrix for the heterostructure . we are interested in the scattering of electrons incident from the left contact . the envelope functions within the contacts will be determined by the boundary conditions . these boundary conditions are open in the @xmath5 direction , and periodic on each slide , that is in the @xmath9 direction . the former imply plane wave solutions in the @xmath5 axis , and the latter yield an energy discretization on @xmath9 . as a consequence , this discretization results in a number of transverse channels equal to the number of points in the transverse mesh direction . considering by the moment @xmath25 at the contacts and setting @xmath26 , a particular solution of eq . ( [ discrete ] ) is given by @xmath27 here @xmath28 is a normalization constant that is needed for the different _ propagating _ modes to carry the same current all of them . this normalization constant is given by @xmath29 note that we consider a dependence on the index @xmath30 of the momentum in the @xmath5 direction . this is a consequence of the implicit assumption that all the scattering processes in region ii are elastic , so energy is conserved . thus , for a given energy @xmath31 + 1 \right\}.\ ] ] finally we can write a general solution of the scattering problem for an electron of energy @xmath32 impinging on the scattering region on the @xmath30 transverse mode . on the left contact the solution will be of the form @xmath33 on the right contact we have @xmath34 the matrices @xmath35 and @xmath36 appearing in these two solutions are the _ reflection _ and _ transmission _ matrices and they are responsible for the channel _ mixing _ due to scattering events . thus , @xmath37 represents the probability amplitude for an electron impinging in channel @xmath38 to be reflected into the chanel @xmath39 . similarly @xmath40 represents the probability amplitude for an electron impinging in chanel @xmath38 to be transmited through the scattering region ii into the channel @xmath39 . note that the solution within region ii is unknown . actually , we are not interested in this solution since all the physics of the scattering problem is contained in the _ mixing _ matrices @xmath36 and @xmath35 . in the following , our main goal will be to relate the elements of @xmath36 and @xmath35 to those of @xmath41 in eq . ( [ transfer ] ) . we start by re - writting formally eq . ( [ discrete ] ) as @xmath42 . now we perform the following transformation upon the envelope functions @xmath43 it is easy to see that the hamiltonian is invariant under such a transformation , that is , @xmath44 . this is clear since @xmath36 and @xmath45 formally commute as they act upon different vector spaces . the fact that @xmath46 is invariant implies that @xmath41 is not affected by transformation ( [ transformation ] ) so it remains unchanged . in addition , equations ( [ solutioni ] ) and ( [ solutioniii ] ) are transformed into @xmath47 and @xmath48 respectively , where we have defined @xmath49 and @xmath50 . for each channel @xmath30 we can write the transform of eq . ( [ transfer ] ) as @xmath51 now , introducing the definitions @xmath52 we arrive at the following transform of eq . ( [ chanel_l ] ) in terms of the elements of the _ mixing _ matrices @xmath53 and , finally , we have @xmath54 that give us the matrix elements @xmath55 and @xmath56 with @xmath57 for each channel @xmath30 in terms of the product of two known matrices and the transformed solutions ( [ new_solutioniii ] ) at the right contact for the @xmath30 channel . it is worth noticing that all the scattering information is contained in the transfer matrix @xmath41 . thus , this quantity turns out to be the fundamental object in the resolution of the scattering problem . once @xmath58 and @xmath59 have been calculated , obtaining @xmath36 and @xmath35 is an easy task . however , the matrices calculated this way are the _ response _ matrices that contains some non - physical information . this non - physical information comes from the fact that we have been considering _ all _ the mathematical solutions of the scattering problem , including those diverging at infinity . these solutions are those for which momentum in eq . ( [ kl ] ) is an imaginary number . in order to avoid the unphysical solutions we will cancel out all the elements on @xmath36 for which the incoming and/or the outgoing transverse quantum number @xmath30 satisfy the following condition @xmath60 once the physical _ mixing _ matrices are known , particularly the transmission matrix @xmath36 , we can use them to calculate different physical quantities like the conductance or the electric current . from the landauer - bttiker formalism,@xcite the zero temperature two - leads multichannel conductance can be calculated using de fisher - lee formula@xcite @xmath61 in order to calculate the electric current due to an applied field @xmath62 we have to modify slightly our equations and further approximations are needed . first of all , we consider perfect leads , so no voltage drop occurs within the contacts . besides , we will not consider the contribution to the current of electrons impinging from the right contact . this is a good approximation provided @xmath63 , where @xmath64 is the voltage drop along the region i and @xmath65 is the electron fermi level on the contacts . finally , we will assume zero temperature so no carrier statistics will be taken into account . when an electric field applied along the growth direction is considered , the potential @xmath66 in eq . ( [ hamiltonian ] ) has to be replaced by @xmath67 , where @xmath68 is constant in the contacts ( @xmath69 in region i and @xmath70 in region iii ) and behaves linearly in region ii , namely @xmath71 . here @xmath62 is the applied electric field and @xmath72 is the voltage drop across the scattering region whose length is @xmath73 . the electron momentum on the right contact now reads @xmath74 + 1 \right\ } , \quad ( m , n ) \in \mathrm{iii}\ ] ] and solution in region iii changes to @xmath75 bearing in mind all the approximations considered so far , a new transfer matrix @xmath41 can be calculated for a each value of @xmath62 . inserting solution ( [ new_solution ] ) in eq . ( [ defin_ii ] ) we can obtain the _ mixing _ matrices for a given applied field and then calculate using them the electric current induced by that field . from the expression for the probability current we can write the discretized version of the electronic current density contribution of chanel @xmath30 along the applied field direction across the right lead ( calculated on a slide @xmath76 within the region iii ) as @xmath77.\ ] ] in order to calculate the total density current across the sample , we just need to sum up over all the allowed transverse states below the fermi level at the left contact , that is @xmath78 dk.\ ] ] notice that the electron momentum in the @xmath5 direction , @xmath79 , varies continously as the energy for an incident electron can take values from @xmath80 to @xmath65 . here , @xmath81 is the component of the electron momentum along the @xmath5 direction for an incident electron with transverse quantum number @xmath30 and an incident energy @xmath65 . using the transmission matrix elements we finally arrive at @xmath82 \left[\exp\left(iq_s a_z\right)- \exp\left(-iq_j a_z\right ) \right ] dk.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the results we have obtained so far provide an exact , although nonclosed , analytical description of _ any _ two - dimensional heterostructure based on wide - gap semiconductors , whenever the ben daniel - duke holds valid . let us stress that the generalization to three - dimensional heterostructures is fairly straightforward . with these results at hand , we can compute the transport magnitudes we mentioned above . all expressions are very simple and suitable for an efficient numerical treatment for any specific case . we will now evaluate them for unintentionally disordered dbs to describe the relevant features of the model . unintentional disorder appearing during growth in _ actual _ heterostructures depends critically on the growth conditions . there exist several techniques , like scanning tunneling microscopy @xcite and x - ray scattering , @xcite which have been applied in recent years to quantitatively determine structural properties of multilayers and superlattices . precise information about the nature and extend of defects at interfaces is now available . following mder _ et al . _ , disorder in a heterostructure can be classified into two categories , namely lateral and vertical.@xcite lateral disorder occurs whenever one semiconductor protrudes into the other , forming chemically intermixed interfaces , steps and islands . as a consequence , the interface is not flat and translational symmetry in the plane perpendicular to the growth direction is broken . on the other side , vertical disorder is observed whenever layer thicknesses fluctuate around their nominal values . compositional disorder due to different local al concentration in each ga@xmath1al@xmath83as layer can be viewed as mixing of vertical and lateral disorder . in order to treat lateral disorder we have considered the formation of islands on the interface between two consecutive layers having identical lateral sizes all of them and being consecutive one to each other . in our model islands have heights that are randomly distributed ( see fig . [ fig2 ] ) . it is possible to express the rough profile of the interface between two consecutive layers defining the following height function @xmath84 -1\}.\ ] ] here @xmath85 represents the deviation from the flat surface at position @xmath9 , @xmath86 is the heavyside theta function , @xmath87 is the island width , @xmath88 is a random variable associated to the @xmath89th island that controls the fluctuation around the mean value , and @xmath90 is the largest deviation in absolute value assuming that the @xmath88 s are uniformly distributed between @xmath91 and @xmath92 . hereafter @xmath90 will be referred to as degree of _ lateral disorder_. in the following , two models will be introduced . first of all , uncorrelated disorder will be considered , for which the random variables @xmath88 take values from @xmath91 to @xmath92 uniformly , satisfying the following correlator @xmath93 . however , experimental data and theoretical models of molecular - beam - epitaxy growth processes@xcite indicate that the heigths of the surface at distant points are strongly correlated . to mimic this situation , we will consider a second model of lateral disorder where the @xmath88 s are normally distributed with zero mean satisfying the exponential correlator @xmath94 , where @xmath95 is the correlation length of the disorder . compositional disorder in gaas - al@xmath0ga@xmath1as heterostructures is due to the lack of spatial uniformity of the al mole fraction during the heterostructure growth process . we will simulate compositional disorder by defining a spatial two - dimensional mesh over the al@xmath0ga@xmath1as barriers , as shown in fig . we will associate a value @xmath96 for the al mole fraction to each region of the mesh . this value will fluctuate randomly around the nominal value of the aluminum fraction on the barrier @xmath97 . thus we can write @xmath98 where @xmath99 is the maximum fluctuation of the al mole fraction , and @xmath100 is a random variable related to the @xmath101 point of the mesh , taking values uniformly between @xmath91 and @xmath92 . note that the overall averaged mole fraction is equal to @xmath102 . we have performed several numerical calculations in order to study the effect of both lateral and compositional disorder over the transport properties of dbs made of gaas - al@xmath0ga@xmath1as heterostructures . we start by considering the effect of the interface roughness , characterized by the degree of lateral disorder @xmath90 given in ( [ deviation ] ) , on the conductance . figure [ fig4 ] shows the conductance calculated for different values of @xmath90 . here @xmath103 nm , @xmath104 nm , @xmath105 nm , @xmath106 , and @xmath107 . the barrier widths are @xmath108 nm for both the emitter and the collector , their heights are also the same , @xmath109ev , and the well width is @xmath110 nm . the curves correspond to an ensemble average of the conductance curves over @xmath111 different realizations of the lateral disorder . three different values of @xmath90 were studied , namely @xmath112 ( perfect dbs ) , @xmath113 nm ( largest fluctuation of the order of one monolayer ) and @xmath114 nm ( largest fluctuation of the order of two monolayers ) . as a main result , it can be seen in fig . [ fig4 ] that increasing the degree of lateral disorder , @xmath90 , results in a decrease of the conductance at the resonant energy . notice that the resonant conductance peak slightly widens due to the fluctuations of its energy for each realization of the disorder . besides , an additional effect can be seen , that is , as the degree of lateral disorder @xmath90 increases the conductance peak shifts to smaller energies . this effect will be important in order to explain the @xmath2 characteristics later . regarding the effect of the size of the islands , @xmath87 , we have observed that it can be neglected unless this size is of the order of the electron wavelength , that is , for @xmath115 the conductance does not depend on @xmath87 . as expected , when @xmath116 the electron starts to _ see _ the disorder and then the conductance increases as @xmath87 decreases , as shown in fig . [ fig5 ] . for energies about @xmath117ev this transition takes place at sizes @xmath118 nm @xcite . current as a function of the applied bias is depicted in fig . [ fig6 ] . for this calculation we have chosen @xmath103 nm , @xmath119 nm , @xmath120 nm , @xmath121 and @xmath122 . the barrier widths are @xmath108 nm for both the emitter and the collector and their heights are also the same , @xmath123ev . the well width is @xmath124 nm . curves show in fig . [ fig6 ] correspond to an average over @xmath125 different realizations of the lateral disorder . the fermi level was fixed at @xmath126mev , the maximum applied bias was @xmath127ev , and @xmath128 nm . surprisingly , current in disordered dbs is larger than that measured in ordered dbs . this counterintuitive result can be explained recalling that conductance peak shifted to lower energies , as mentioned above . the lowering of the conductance peak can be understood assuming that surface roughness makes the effective width of the quantum well larger than its nominal value . this would imply a lower transmission resonance so the current peak shifts toward lower bias . but an effective wider well implies a higher current too , so in some statistical sense the current for the disordered dbs will be higher . up to now we have been considering only lateral uncorrelated roughness at the heterojunctions . we have also calculated the conductance for a dbs in which interface roughness is an exponentially correlated random variable , as described previously . figure [ fig7 ] shows the conductance at a given energy about the conductance resonance for the ordered case ( where fluctuations are lower ) , @xmath129 ev , when the correlation length varies several orders of magnitude . physical parameters of the dbs are the same as in fig . the size of the islands is @xmath126 nm and the degree of lateral disorder is @xmath113 nm . an average over 50 realizations of the disorder has been performed . it can be observed that the conductance increases as the correlation length increases . two asymptotic regimes are clearly observed for small and large correlation lengths , respectively . the former limit , @xmath130 , can be understood as the situation previously studied where lateral disorder is uncorrelated . from a closed inspection of fig . [ fig7 ] we come to the remarkable result that this uncorrelated limit correctly describes transport properties whenever the correlation length do not exceed @xmath131 nm . then we are led to an important conclusion , namely those models of electron transport in disordered dbs based on the assumption that disorder is uncorrelated would yield right values of the conductance even if the correlation length is not vanishing but fairly large . there is no need to mention that uncorrelated disordered models are much more convenient for analytical work than correlated ones . the size of the plateau for which correlations in the disorder do not play an essential role is governed by the size of the islands , @xmath87 , as might be expected . this is due to the fact that only correlations of the lateral disorder whose correlation length is greater than the size of the islands affect electron motion . for these sizes , the conductance increases as the correlation length becomes larger . this trend is observed up to sizes of the order of @xmath132 nm , namely the system size in the @xmath9 direction , and then the second regime appears . in this regime the limiting value of the conductance can be calculated as an average over different ordered dbs , each one having barrier widths distributed normally . having discussed the effects of interface roughness , let us now present our results regarding compositional disorder . to clarify the effects of local fluctuations of the al mole fraction , we assume that the interfaces are perfectly flat and that the width of the different semiconductor layers are exactly their nominal values , i.e. , we neglect fluctuations of their widths . we show typical results in fig . [ fig8 ] , where physical parameters are the same as in fig . the espatial extend of the region where the al mole fraction can be assumed locally constant was taken to be @xmath133 nm and @xmath134 nm ( see fig . [ fig3 ] ) . it can be observed that , for fluctuations as large as @xmath135 , that is , height fluctuations of about @xmath117 ev , when averaging over @xmath111 realizations the conductance is almost unchanged ( only 3% variation ) . this behavior is a consequence of the small electron probability amplitudes within the barriers , where compositional disorder is considered to appear . in other words , even moderately high spatial inhomogeneities in the barriers scarcely affect the electron envelope function . thus we can conclude that the effects of compositional disorder can be disregarded as they are much smaller than those of lateral disorder . in this paper we have presented a method to study electron transport in unintentionally disordered dbs when translational symmetry along the normal plane to the growth direction is broken by structural imperfections . two different kinds of disorder leading to electron scattering has been presented , namely lateral disorder and compositional disorder . lateral disorder appears as a consequence of the roughness present at the interfaces between gaas and al@xmath0ga@xmath1as . compositional disorder is due to the inhomogeneity of the al mole fraction occurring during the growth process of al@xmath0ga@xmath1as epilayers . we have shown that the main effect of the lateral disorder is to decrease the dbs conductance . when correlations are introduced , conductance starts improving , the larger the correlation length , the higher the conductance . however , current shows a surprising behavior , as it is higher in the disordered case than in the ordered one . we attributed it to an energy shift of the transmission resonance of the dbs . another important conclusion regards the validity of uncorrelated disordered models ; they provide right values of the conductance whenever the actual correlation length does not exceed the system size , thus allowing a simpler theoretical description . finally we have shown that the effect of compositional disorder can be disregarded as it is much smaller than the effect of lateral disorder . the authors want to thank v. a. malyshev for the critical reading of the manuscript . work in madrid was supported by dgi - mcyt ( project mat2000 - 0734 ) and cam ( project 07n/0075/2001 ) . p. orellana would like to thank milenio icm p99 - 135-f and ctedra presidencial de ciencias for financial support .

we present a novel model to calculate vertical transport properties such as conductance and current in unintentionally disordered double barrier gaas - al@xmath0ga@xmath1as heterostructures . the source of disorder comes from interface roughness at the heterojunctions ( lateral disorder ) as well as spatial inhomogeneities of the al mole fraction in the barriers ( compositional disorder ) . both lateral and compositional disorder break translational symmetry along the lateral direction and therefore electrons can be scattered off the growth direction . the model correctly describe channel mixing due to these elastic scattering events . in particular , for realistic degree of disorder , we have found that the effects of compositional disorder on transport properties are negligible as compared to the effects due to lateral disorder .

astro-ph9812166

the first face - on map of our galaxy was constructed by oort , kerr & westerhout ( 1958 ) from 21 cm observations , interpreting the observed gas velocities in terms of circular motions in a thin disk . this map revealed many arm like features in the gas distribution . more recent surveys of atomic hydrogen , molecular gas , hii regions , giant molecular clouds ( gmc ) , and other spiral arm tracers have helped to constrain the location of galactic spiral arms . the majority of observations appear to be consistent with a four armed spiral pattern as suggested by georgelin & georgelin ( 1976 ) ; see the review in valle ( 1995 ) . the gas in the inner galaxy is not on circular orbits , however . this is most evident from the so called ` forbidden ' velocities which would then imply gas in counterrotation . the most prominent example is the 3-kpc - arm , which appears in the @xmath0-diagram at negative radial velocities on both sides of the galactic center . in the direction of the galactic center this arm is seen in absorption , which indicates that it passes between the sun and the galactic center . in recent years , near - ir observations with the cobe satellite have motivated a series of new studies aiming to understand the dynamics of the inner galaxy . the nir maps obtained with dirbe clearly show signatures of non - axisymmetric structure in the galactic bulge . dwek _ et al_. ( 1995 ) used parametric bar models to determine the basic properties of this triaxial bulge . full advantage of the observed asymmetries was taken by binney , gerhard & spergel ( 1997 ; bgs ) , who applied a newly developed richardson lucy deprojection algorithm . by assuming that the bulge has three mutually orthogonal planes of symmetry , they recovered approximately the 3d distribution of nir light in the galactic center . for their favored bar inclination of @xmath1 , the bulge has axis ratios 10:6:4 and semi major axis @xmath2 . it is surrounded by an elliptical disk that extends to @xmath3 . outside the bar , the deprojected near ir luminosity distribution shows a maximum @xmath4 down the minor axis . here we report gas dynamical simulations in this model and compare to the observed spiral arm structure of the galaxy . to follow the gas flow we have used a two - dimensional ( 2d ) ` smoothed particle hydrodynamics ' ( sph ) method , which has a large dynamical range in resolution and can include self - gravity . we assume an isothermal equation of state . see englmaier & gerhard ( 1998 ; eg ) for more details . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,<",options="header " , ] r8.0 cm here we describe the gas flow in the deprojected mass model of bgs for @xmath1 , and assume that the potential rotates with a constant pattern speed @xmath5 , such that the corotation radius falls between the molecular ring and the 3-kpc - arm at @xmath6 . the morphology of the gas flow ( fig . 2 ) is insensitive to the choice of these parameters within reasonable bounds ; see eg . in these models a four armed spiral pattern forms , driven by the rotating triaxial bulge and elliptical disk , and the strong mass concentrations on the bar minor axis with negative quadrupole moment . the latter are presumably signatures of the spiral arm heads of the arms embedded in the molecular ring at @xmath7 radius . the model arm tangents can be identified with the five observed arm tangents ( see table ) . the model arms also give a reasonable representation of the locations of hii regions and gmc s in the @xmath0-diagram ( see fig . 1 ) . finally , the model gives a good approximation for the terminal velocity curve ( tvc ) , and hence the galactic rotation curve , for @xmath8 without including a dark halo component . the observed tvc is used to fix the unknown velocity scale of the model , assuming a distance to the galactic center @xmath9 and an lsr velocity @xmath10 . one spiral arm in the model qualitatively corresponds to the 3-kpc - arm . the tangent of the model arm is at the correct longitude , however , the non - circular motion at @xmath11 is somewhat smaller than for the observed 3-kpc - arm . it has always been a puzzle why we do not see a symmetric counter arm for the 3-kpc - arm at the far side of the galaxy . the counter arm in our model runs almost parallel in the @xmath0-diagram to another arm which ends at about @xmath12 . in fact , the observed arm there is known to split into two parts ; see the two concentrations of warm co clouds at @xmath13 and @xmath12 , indicating the presence of two shocks ( solomon _ et al_. 1985 ; arrows in fig . 1 ) . our model does not include a live stellar disk . thus the gravitational force of the stellar spiral arms is not included . however , we can use the gaseous arms as tracers to estimate the influence of stellar spiral arms : we take a fraction of the mass from the stellar background disk model and add it to the mass in gas particles . this extra mass does not , however , enter the hydrodynamical equations . then we smooth the potential of the extra mass over @xmath14 , to mimic the fact that the stellar arms are much broader than gaseous arms . the resulting gas flow is similar to the previous one , in particular , the spiral arm tangents are hardly changed . the most significant difference is that now the 3-kpc - arm displays just the right amount of non - circular motion . in nature , gaseous spiral arms are driven by stellar spiral arms . in our model , however , both are driven by the bar and the non - axisymmetric features in the disk . ) and gmc ( @xmath15 ) and observed tangents ( lines ) . the bar major axis is horizontal , and the sun is at @xmath16 , @xmath17 . , title="fig:",width=328]-5 mm the idea of a four armed spiral pattern goes back to georgelin & georgelin ( 1976 ) , who used hii regions as tracers for spiral arms . in fig . 2 we compare the face - on view of our model to the tracer positions inferred from their and other more recent studies including surveys of gmc s ( see eg for references ) . note that this plot does not take into account the non - circular motions of the tracers . correcting for this effect will focus the points towards the spiral arms , due to velocity crowding ; thus the correspondence will improve . beuermann , k. _ et al_. , 1985 , , 153 , 17 binney , j.j . , gerhard , o.e . & spergel , d. , 1997 , , 288 , 365 bloemen , j.b.g.m . _ et al_. , 1990 , , 233 , 437 burton , w.b . , shane , w.w . , 1970 , iau symp . w. becker , g. contopoulos , reidel , dordrecht , p. 397 chen , w. _ et al_. , 1996 , , 120 , 315 clemens , d.p . , 1985 , , 295 , 422 cohen , r.j . _ et al_. , 1980 , , 239 , l53 dame , t.m . _ et al_. , 1986 , , 305 , 892 downes , d. _ et al_. , 1980 , , 40 , 379 dwek , e. _ et al_. , 1995 , , 445 , 716 englmaier , p. & gerhard , o.e . 1998 , , _ in press _ georgelin , y.m . , georgelin , y.p . , 1976 , , 49 , 57 grabelsky , d.a . _ et al_. , 1987 , , 315 , 122 hayakawa , s. _ et al_. , 1981 , , 100 , 116 henderson , a.p . , 1977 , , 58 , 189 lockman , f.j . , 1979 , , 232 , 761 oort , j.h . , kerr , f.t . & westerhout , g. , 1958 , , 118 , 379 solomon , p.m. _ et al_. , 1985 , , 292 , 19 valle , j.p . , 1995 , , 454 , 119 weaver , h. , 1970 , iau symp . 38 , eds . w. becker , g. contopoulos , reidel , dordrecht , 126

we report simulations of the gas flow in the gravitational potential of the cobe nir bulge and disk . these models lead to four armed spiral structure between corotation of the bar and the sun , in agreement with the observed spiral arm tangents . the 3-kpc - arm is identified with one of the arms emanating from the ends of the bar .

astro-ph0202194

over 70 extra - solar planets have now been detected since the discovery of a companion to the solar - type star 51 peg in 1995 ( mayor & queloz 1995 ) . all of these planets have been discovered via the radial velocity technique , in which the planet s presence is inferred by the central star s motion around the system s barycentre . instrumental and intrinsic noise limit the sensitivity of these studies to saturn - mass companions in short - period orbits , with more massive companions detectable in more distant orbits . the duration of current programmes limits this to @xmath23.5au ( fischer et al . 2002 ) , although some systems do display interesting trends indicative of more distant companions . therefore , we have little information on systems with massive companions at large radii , such as our own solar system . the only constraint on jovian - like systems comes from micro - lensing statistics , which suggest less than @xmath3 of m stars have jupiter - like planets orbiting at @xmath4au ( albrow et al.2001 ) . the planets discovered by the radial velocity technique are not open to further _ direct _ study , due to their close proximity to the much brighter parent star . the only exception to this is the transiting companion to hd209458 ( @xmath5 days ) . transit photometry shows this planet is a gas - giant , and charbonneau et al . ( 2002 ) have recently detected sodium in its atmosphere . still , the planet itself can not be directly imaged . several groups have conducted imaging surveys of nearby main sequence stars to search for low mass companions , including the use of adaptive optics , coronographs and space - based observations with hst ( e.g. turner et al.2001 , neuhuser et al . 2001 , oppenheimer et al . 2001 , kuchner & brown 2000 , schroeder et al . however , the extreme contrast ( @xmath620 magnitudes ) and small separations ( 5au@xmath7 at 5pc ) between main sequence stars and jovian planets makes sensitive surveys very difficult . to date , no planetary mass companions to nearby stars have been imaged , although several brown dwarf companions have been detected via direct imaging ( e.g. nakajima et al . 1995 ) . the end state of main sequence stars with m@xmath88 , white dwarfs , are typically 10@xmath910@xmath10 times less luminous than their progenitors . thus , there is potentially a strong gain in the brightness contrast between a planet and a white dwarf when compared to a main sequence star , assuming that planets can survive the late stages of stellar evolution . the gain in contrast is strongest in the mid - infrared , where the planet s thermal emission peaks well into the white dwarf s rayleigh - jeans tail . indeed , ignace ( 2001 ) has suggested that excess infra - red emission could be detectable from a hot jupiter orbiting a 10,000k white dwarf at a distance of @xmath11 white dwarf radii and with an orbital period of @xmath12 days . chu et al . ( 2001 ) have also suggested that , near a hot uv - bright white dwarf , the atmosphere of a jovian planet would be photoionized and emit variable hydrogen recombination lines , which may be detected by high - dispersion spectroscopic observations . however , both these methods rely on the planet being in a close ( 0.012au ) proximity to the white dwarf , where it would be difficult to resolve . in this letter , we discuss the potential for imaging planetary companions in wide ( @xmath135au ) orbits around nearby white dwarfs . in section 2 we investigate the probability of a planetary system surviving the late stages of stellar evolution . we discuss the detectability of any surviving planets in section 3 , suggest suitable target white dwarfs in section 4 , and discuss the expected frequency of wide planetary companions to white dwarfs in section 5 . any planetary companion to a white dwarf must have survived the red giant branch ( rgb ) and asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) phases of stellar evolution . during these stages , the white dwarf progenitor swells up to a few hundred solar radii in size and undergoes significant mass loss . what happens to a planet during this time depends on the initial orbital separation , the stellar mass loss rate , the total mass lost , tidal forces , and interaction with the ejected material . any planet in an initial orbit within the final extent of the red giant s envelope will be engulfed and migrate inwards . livio & soker ( 1984 ) showed that these planets will either completely evaporate or accrete mass and become a close companion to the eventual white dwarf . planets in wider orbits that avoid direct contact with the expanding red giant envelope ( such as the jovian planets of our own solar system ) will have a greater chance of survival , migrating outward as mass is lost from the central star . however , stars more massive than the sun lose more than half of their original mass in evolving to the white dwarf stage ( weidemann 1987 , wood 1992 ) . if over half the mass of the central star is lost _ instantaneously _ then any accompanying planets will likely escape , since their orbital velocity will suddenly exceed the escape velocity of the system . thus , we might naively expect no white dwarfs to retain planetary systems . of course , in reality , main sequence stars of [email protected] do not evolve into white dwarfs instantaneously . mass loss on the rgb and agb , and final ejection of the planetary nebula is a relatively slow process . the sun , for example , will lose around @xmath15 on the rgb in @xmath210@xmath16 years , and up to another @xmath15 on the agb on a timescale of up to @xmath210@xmath17 years . the final thermal pulse , in which the cool red giant develops a super - wind and finally ejects the remainder of its envelope , exposing the core , is poorly understood but probably occurs on a timescale of a few @xmath1810@xmath10 years ( soker 1994 ) . the dynamical timescale for a planet to react to the change in the mass of the central star , and thus the gravitational force between the star and planet , is given by ; @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the semi - major axis of the orbit and @xmath21 is the orbital velocity , and ; @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the mass of the central star and @xmath24 is the mass of the planet . assuming @xmath25 ; @xmath26 this is much less than the mass loss timescales mentioned above . even if a @xmath27 star lost its entire envelope ( @xmath28 ) during a short pn phase of @xmath29 years ( which it does nt , only the last few tenths of a solar mass ) , the orbit would not become unbound . thus , to a first approximation , the orbits of planets which do not interact directly with the red giant will simply expand adiabatically by a maximum factor m@xmath30/m@xmath31 ( jeans 1924 , zuckerman & becklin 1987 ) . for example , for a main sequence star @xmath22 and a white dwarf @xmath20.6 , the orbit would expand by a maximum factor @xmath23 . a planet in a jupiter - like orbit would be relocated to @xmath215au , and a planet in a neptune - like orbit to @xmath290au . for planets in orbits @xmath810au , tidal forces between the planet and red giant are important in slowing orbital migration by transfering angular momentum from the orbit to stellar rotation . for example , soker ( 1994 ) shows that , neglecting tidal forces , as the sun evolves to a white dwarf jupiter s orbital radius will expand from its present value of @xmath32 to @xmath33 . however , tidal forces on the rgb will counteract this expansion , reducing this final orbital radius by @xmath34% , and by a further @xmath35% on the upper agb . for planets within 5au , livio & soker ( 1983 ) showed that tidal interactions will actually cause them to migrate _ inwards_. soker ( 1996 ) suggests that tidal interactions between evolving red giants and low mass companions could be responsible for producing the large fraction of elliptical pn observed , indicating low mass companions may be common amoung pn progenitors . the orbits of distant planets will also be subjected to drag resulting from their interaction with the material ejected by the central star . duncan & lissauer ( 1998 ) define the total amount of material impacting a planet during post - main sequence evolution as ; @xmath36 \\ & & \times \left(\frac{v_{sw}^2 + v_{orb}^2}{v_{sw}^2}\right)^{1/2 } \left(1 + \frac{v_{esc}^2}{v_{sw}^2 + v_{orb}^2}\right)\\ \label{eq : accrate}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath37 , @xmath21 and @xmath38 are the velocities of the stellar wind , the planet and the escape velocity of the planet respectively , and @xmath39 is the radius of the planet s magnetosphere . evaluation of this equation , however , shows that gas giants will collide with significantly less than 1% of their own mass over the entire red giant phase . the orbits will decay inwards only slightly as a result . duncan & lissauer ( 1998 ) have made detailed simulations of the effects of post - main sequence mass loss on the stability of the solar system and for planetary systems around more massive stars . they show that the orbits of the giant planets will probably be stable for tens of billions of years subsequent to the sun s death . however , planetary systems dynamically similar to our own around somewhat more massive stars may eventually be de - stabilised . duncan & lissauer s calculations show that giant planets around , for instance , an initially @xmath40 star , will be liberated by large - scale chaos in less than a hubble time . finally , soker ( 1999 ) points out that the newborn planetary nebula central star is hot ( t@xmath41k ) and a strong source of ionizing soft x - ray and uv radiation . the interaction of this radiation with a planet may lead to ablation of the planetary atmosphere , but this will only be effective for planets having an escape velocity @xmath42 , where @xmath43kms@xmath44 is the sound speed of the ionised planetary material . for a jupiter - mass planet @xmath45kms@xmath44 and thus there will be negligible ablation . it seems likely , then , that giant planets in initially distant ( a@xmath135au ) orbits around main sequence stars @xmath46 will survive the late stages of stellar evolution , and remain in orbit around the remnant white dwarfs at increased orbital radii for at least several billion years . our ability to detect an extra - solar planet around a nearby white dwarf will depend on its intrinsic luminosity , which in turn depends on its age , its distance from us , and its separation from the parent star . burrows et al . ( 1997 ) have made nongray calculations of the expected spectra , colours and evolution of solar - metallicity massive planets . we have used these models to predict the infra - red magnitudes of planets around nearby white dwarfs . the burrows et al . models describe the evolution of a planet in isolation , and do not include the effects of thermal insolation by , or reflected light from , a parent star . in reality , gas - giant planets will have been kept warm throughout their lives by the white dwarf progenitors . they will also have accreted matter during the rgb / agb / pn phases . both effects would act to increase their temperatures and luminosities , although in the white dwarf phase reflected light makes a negligible contribution to the planet s brightness . our predicted luminosities are , therefore , lower limits . the white dwarf cooling age and progenitor main sequence lifetime are the dominant timescales determining the brightness of any planetary companions , as they are significantly longer than the rgb or pre - main sequence phases . white dwarf cooling ages are dependent on a number of parameters including : effective temperature , mass ( usually derived from the surface gravity ) , composition of the core and the thickness of the surface h- ( or he- ) dominated atmosphere . temperature , surface gravity and atmospheric composition are usually determined through fitting model atmospheres to optical and uv spectra ( e.g. bergeron , saffer & liebert 1992 , marsh et al . 1997 , finley , koester & basri 1997 ) . the mass is then inferred from the surface gravity measurement using evolutionary models ( e.g. wood 1992 , 1995 ) . these same models also give the cooling age . the cooling ages and masses of many nearby white dwarfs have been calculated in this manner by bergeron , leggett & ruiz ( 2001 , blr ) . for nearby white dwarfs not included in the blr sample ( generally , those hotter than @xmath47k ) , we have estimated cooling ages from published temperature and mass measurements . the relationship between the mass of a white dwarf and its main sequence progenitor , the initial - final mass relation , has been investigated by a variety of authors . we have adopted model a from wood ( 1992 ) : @xmath48 \msun % { \textrm{m}}_{\textrm{\tiny ms } } = 10.4\ln\left(\frac{\textrm{m}_{\textrm{\tiny wd}}}{0.49}\right ) \msun \label{eq : massrelation}\ ] ] wood ( 1992 ) also gives a simple formula for estimating main sequence lifetimes : @xmath49 the white dwarf cooling age and the main sequence lifetime can then be combined to give the _ system _ age of local white dwarfs . we use this age , combined with the distance to the white dwarf , to estimate the magnitude of planets . there are 118 white dwarfs currently catalogued within 20pc of the sun ( holberg et al . all of these systems are close enough to allow us to resolve planetary companions in @xmath25100au orbits from the ground . for example , at 10pc an orbit of 10au is equivalent to a maximum separation of @xmath50 on the sky . planets in wider orbits will be even easier to resolve . adaptive optics , coronographs and techniques such as nulling interferometry will increase the chances of resolving closer companions . however , only those white dwarfs young enough for jovian companions to still be detectable will make suitable targets for extra - solar planet searches . we are most likely to be able to detect an extra - solar planet around a relatively warm and young ( @xmath51a few@xmath52yrs ) , massive ( @xmath130.6 ) white dwarf descended from a relatively massive progenitor ( @xmath132 ) , since its main sequence lifetime is short ( @xmath511.8gyr ) . for @xmath510.6 , the main sequence lifetime is very sensitive to errors in the estimate ( see figure [ fig : mass - mstime ] ) . therefore , we would be unwise to rule out white dwarfs with mass estimates below 0.6 , as they may be descended from more massive stars than we expect . table [ tab : wdtable ] lists the top 10 candidates among nearby white dwarfs for a search for planetary companions , considering the main sequence lifetime , the white dwarf cooling age t@xmath53 and the distance . also included in the table are the estimated j band magnitude of 3 , 5 , & 10 planets in each system . in figure [ fig : magsroundwds ] we plot the magnitude of a 5 planet around these white dwarfs in several near - ir bands ( j , h , k , l@xmath54 & m ) . also plotted are the nominal sensitivity limits for current near - infrared imaging instruments ( from on - line exposure time estimates ) ; gemini - north @xmath55 niri ( solid lines ) and vlt @xmath55 isaac ( dashed lines ) . we can see that although the planets are brighter in the m band ( 5@xmath56 m ) , the instruments are only sensitive enough in the j and h bands ( 1.1 & 1.6@xmath56 m ) . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] assuming that massive planets born in initially wide ( @xmath0au ) orbits remain bound to white dwarfs , then the expected frequency of massive planets around nearby white dwarfs is simply a function of the frequency of solar - like and more massive main sequence stars with jovian - like planetary systems . unfortunately , we currently have little observational information on these systems , although it is possible to extrapolate from existing data to make some estimate of what we might expect . lineweaver & grether ( 2002 , lg ) have analysed the statistics of planets detected via radial velocity techniques , and estimated the number of jovian - like systems we might expect to find . they have produced a fit to the completeness - correct period distribution of planets so far detected , in the mass range @xmath5713 ; @xmath58 where @xmath59 and @xmath60 . the initial orbital periods of interest range from @xmath210yr , to avoid direct interaction with the expanding red giant envelope , to @xmath2200yr , where we might expect jovian planet formation to end . integrating equation [ eq : dndlogp ] over this range , we estimate there to be @xmath255@xmath6116 jovian planets per @xmath21000 white dwarf systems . however , for a significant sample of nearby white dwarfs we can only detect planets @xmath62 with current technology . lg fit the observed planetary mass function as ; @xmath63 where @xmath644 . to produce 55@xmath6116 planets over the mass range @xmath65 we need to set @xmath66 . therefore , from equation [ eq : dlogm ] , we expect @xmath215@xmath616 planets @xmath62 per 1000 white dwarfs . hence , we may expect @xmath212% of white dwarfs to possess one or more planets @xmath62 . note that we treat @xmath67 as equivalent to @xmath68 , so this predicted number density is a lower limit . this analysis is , however , based on statistics for planets in orbits @xmath83.5au . it is quite possible that laws derived for planets in this area of orbital parameter space around @xmath21 stars do not apply to jovian planets at large radii ( @xmath135au ) around more massive stars ( @xmath69 ) . we have suggested that jovian planets will survive the late stages of stellar evolution , and that some nearby white dwarfs possess planetary systems in wide orbits . utilising evolutionary models for jovian planets , we have shown that infra - red imaging of suitable nearby white dwarfs should allow us to resolve and detect companions m@xmath703with 8 m class telescopes . the best candidates for an observational search are relatively hot ( young ) , massive ( @xmath71 ) white dwarfs , as they have the shortest overall system age . however , given that we have neglected potential heating mechanisms such as thermal insolation and accretion from the red giant s wind , jovian planets around nearby white dwarfs are likely to be brighter than we have suggested in figure [ fig : magsroundwds ] , and may be detectable around @xmath72 white dwarfs descended from progenitors as low in mass as @xmath73 . our `` top ten '' list of targets among nearby white dwarfs ( table 1 ) includes degenerates descended from main sequence progenitors from 2.6 @xmath74 7.4 , corresponding to spectral types early a and b. the existence of a dust disk around vega ( a0v ) strongly suggests that planetary systems may exist around such early - type stars , although they are not the subject of current radial velocity searches . detection of massive planetary companions to nearby white dwarfs would prove that such objects can survive the final stages of stellar evolution , place constraints on the frequency of main sequence stars with planetary systems dynamically similar to our own , and allow direct spectroscopic investigation of their composition and structure . an unsuccessful search would suggest one of , or a combination of , a number of scenarios , including : ( a ) that planets @xmath1 are fainter than expected from the evolutionary models we have used ; ( b ) that , at least for a sub - sample of targets , any accompanying planets have too small a projected separation from the white dwarf to be resolved ; ( c ) that massive jupiters in wide orbits around 18 main sequence stars are not common ; ( d ) that these planets do not remain bound to white dwarfs . this last scenario would raise the possibilty that the galaxy contains a population of isolated jovian - mass planets ejected by white dwarfs during the final stages of their evolution . mrb , fjc and sth acknowledge the support of pparc , uk . we would like to thank eduardo martin for an illuminating discussion , and james murray and andrew king for comments concerning orbital evolution .

we suggest that jovian planets will survive the late stages of stellar evolution , and that white dwarfs will retain planetary systems in wide orbits ( @xmath0au ) . utilising evolutionary models for jovian planets , we show that infra - red imaging with 8 m class telescopes of suitable nearby white dwarfs should allow us to resolve and detect companions @xmath1 . detection of massive planetary companions to nearby white dwarfs would prove that such objects can survive the final stages of stellar evolution , place constraints on the frequency of main sequence stars with planetary systems dynamically similar to our own and allow direct spectroscopic investigation of their composition and structure . stars : white dwarfs planets : extra - solar

1301.5773

dy centauri is known as a hot r coronae borealis ( rcb ) star . rcb stars are a rare class of peculiar variable stars with two principal defining characteristics : ( i ) they exhibit a propensity to fade at unpredictable times by up to about eight magnitudes as a result of obscuration by clouds of soot , and ( ii ) they have a supergiant - like atmosphere that is very h - deficient , he - rich and c - rich . the subject of this paper , the remarkable star dy cen , one of the hottest rcbs , is even a peculiar rcb member on several accounts . it is one of the most hydrogen - rich rcbs . its circumstellar environment may be home to the fullerene c@xmath1 or more likely proto - fullerenes ( garca - hernndez et al . 2011a ; 2012 ) . in terms of its chemical composition , dy cen may have a composition that sets it apart from most rcb and extreme helium ( ehe ) stars see jeffery & heber s ( 1993 ) abundance analysis : dy cen is not only uncharacteristically h - rich but is very fe - poor with a very high s / fe ratio , thus has been classified as a minority rcb star ( lambert & rao 1994 ) ; i.e. , a rcb with extraordinarily high si / fe and s / fe ratios . however , jeffery et al . ( 2011 ) suggest that the fe abundance was greatly underestimated in 1993 . finally , dy cen is a single - lined spectroscopic binary ( rao et al . 2012 ) , the only known binary among rcbs . the origins of the hydrogen - deficient rcb and ehe stars are not presently fully understood . two proposals are commonly advocated . in one , a final helium shell flash or a very late thermal pulse occurs on a cooling white dwarf star ( iben et al . 1983 ; renzini 1990 ; herwig 2000 ) which swells the envelope of the star to supergiant dimensions for a few thousand years and the remaining hydrogen is convected in and consumed while helium and carbon are convected out to the surface . living examples are believed to be sakurai s object ( v4334 sgr ) and fg sge ( asplund et al . 1997 ; jeffery & schnberner 2006 ) . the other proposal involves the merger of two white dwarfs : a carbon - oxygen white dwarf accretes a helium white dwarf as a close binary orbit shrinks under the influence of energy loss by gravitational radiation ( webbink 1984 ; iben & tutukov 1986 ) . the merger leads to a swollen envelope around the c - o white dwarf which lasts a few thousand years . evidence from the chemical compositions of rcb and ehe stars suggests that most are products of a merger ( garca - hernndez et al . 2009 , 2010 ; pandey & lambert 2011 ; jeffery et al . 2011 ) . dy cen with an orbital period of about 39 days is experiencing mass loss and presumably mass transfer to a low mass companion . years . ] moreover , it is likely to have experienced mass loss and transfer previously in arriving at its h - poor condition . rao et al . ( 2012 ) suggest dy cen may evolve to a he - rich sdb star . many such sdb stars are binaries . in this sense , dy cen is a representative of a third way to form a rcb star . the fact that its supergiant phase is short - lived relative to life as a sdb accounts for the rarity of such hot rcbs relative to the sdb population . the presence of forbidden emission lines in dy cen s optical spectrum , was noticed in 1989 ( rao et al . 1993 ) . these lines were attributed to a nebula around dy cen . in this paper , we analyse the nebular lines and their evolution over two decades . nebular lines were especially prominent in a 2010 high - resolution spectrum with broad wavelength coverage . inspection of earlier spectra show that physical conditions in the region emitting the nebular lines have changed since 1989 . in particular , the electron density inferred from the ratio of the [ sii ] 6717 and 6731 lines increased about eight - fold from 1989 to 2010 . the general properties of dy cen s spectrum have been described by pollacco & hill ( 1991 ) , jeffery & heber ( 1993 ) , rao , giridhar & lambert ( 1993 ) , giridhar , rao & lambert ( 1996 ) and de marco et al . optical spectra are presently a combination of photospheric absorption lines ( e.g. oii , nii , siiii lines ) , emission lines due to a stellar wind ( mainly cii , hei often superposed on underlying absorption lines ) , and nebular emission lines of [ sii ] , [ nii ] , [ oi ] , [ feii ] , etc . in addition , circumstellar and interstellar lines from caii , nai , ki and other species as well as the enigmatic diffuse interstellar bands ( dibs ) are present in absorption ( garca - hernndez et al . 2012 ) . this paper considers new spectra from 2010 acquired as a result of an eso director s discretionary proposal . the spectra were obtained on four nights in february - march 2010 with the cross - dispersed echelle spectrograph uves at the vlt at eso s paranal observatory . the uves spectrograph was used with the 1.2 `` slit ( slit length of 8 '' and p.a.=0 degrees ) and the standard setting dic2 ( 390 + 760 ) . the seeing was always better than 1.5 " and we obtained 11 individual exposures of 1800 s each ( total exposure time of 5.5 hours ) . since the nebular lines are not expected to change in a short time , the individual exposures were combined to increase the signal - to - noise ( s / n ) ratio . the s / n in the continuum at 4000 is @xmath2200 and at wavelengths longer than 6000 it is higher than 250 . the slit width is just about the size of the nebular diameter , as estimated later . the spectral resolving power is about 37000 , as estimated from o@xmath3 telluric lines at 6970 . wavelength coverage is from 3300 to 4500 , 5700 to 7525 and 7660 to 9460 . along with dy cen , hd 115842 a nearby b supergiant was observed with the same setup . hd 115842 was observed soon after the dy cen exposures on all nights to correct for telluric lines in the dy cen spectrum . the s / n of the hd 115842 spectrum is 300 even for a single night s observation . in addition to these spectra from 2010 , we draw on a spectrum obtained in 2003 from the 3.9 m aat with the university college london echelle spectrograph ( ucles ) . the ucles spectrograph was used with the 1.4 `` slit ( slit length of 6 '' ) and three individual exposures of 1200 s each were obtained . wavelength coverage is from 4780 to 8800 . the final s / n in the summed spectrum is 38 to 40 in the continuum at 6300 to 6750 spectral region . resolving power is about 40000 as estimated from telluric [ oi ] lines . also , considered here is the 1989 spectrum used by rao et al . this was acquired at ctio with the blanco 4-meter telescope and a cassegrain echelle spectrograph . the slit width was 2 " , which gives a resolving power of about 18000 with the wavelength coverage from 5480 to 6830 in 1989 . a 1992 spectrum with blanco telescope covered the interval 5480 to 7080 at a resolving power of 35000 ( see giridhar , rao & lambert 1996 ) . dy cen was identified as a rcb variable by hoffleit ( 1930 ) from well - determined minima in 1897 , 1901 , 1924 , and 1929 . no rcb type minima have been recorded since 1958 ( bateson 1978 , a. a. henden 2010 , private communication ) . thus , dy cen is not an active rcb star and all the spectra discussed here were taken when the star was at maximum light . quantitative interpretation of nebular emission lines requires knowledge of the line fluxes and , hence , of the continuum fluxes across a spectrum . to obtain such fluxes , we use ubvri photometry of the star reported for the period 1989 - 2010 . dy cen has been slowly fading for the last 40 to 50 years ( bateson 1978 ; rao et al . this fading is independent of rcb - like events . we have collected ubvri photometry reported in the literature . figure 1 shows the variation of b , v , and r from 1970 to 2010 . = 8truecm the earliest published ubv magnitudes are from mid-1970 by marino & walker ( 1971 ) : v , b - v and u - b are 12.23 , 0.39 and -0.62 , respectively . u band measurements are few and were obtained only in 1970 ( see above ) and during the 1982 - 83 period at saao by kilkenny et al . the 1972 measurements are from v.e . sherwood ( quoted by rao , giridhar & lambert 1993 ) . pollacco & hill ( 1991 ) obtained bv mesurements during 1987 may and june . the 2007 bvri measurements are from the aavso . it is clear from the figure that there is a gradual increase in magnitude over 40 years . the total variation is about 0.90 magnitude in v and 0.83 magnitude in b in 37 years : the ( b - v ) colour variations are minimal . even ( u - b ) seems to be same in 1970 and 1982 - 83 . because of these very slow changes , we adopted the colours observed in 1987 for our spectroscopic observations in 1989 and the mid-2007 photometry for our 2010 spectroscopic observations to estimate continuum fluxes . the continuum fluxes are estimated from the ubvri colours after applying a correction for interstellar reddening for an e(b - v ) of 0.47 ( garca - hernndez et al . standard relations : @xmath4@xmath5 3.1 e(b - v ) and e(b - v)/e(u - b ) = 0.72 , @xmath6/ @[email protected] and @xmath7/@[email protected] have been used ( cardelli et al 1989 ) . flux calibrations given by drilling & landolt ( 2000 ) are adopted . reddening - corrected line fluxes are given in the table 1 for the 1989 , 1992 , 2003 , and 2010 observations . the s / n of the 2010 spectrum is over 200 to 250 . the uncertainities in equivalent widths ( eqws ) are 3% in weaker lines ( and less in strong lines like h@xmath8 ) . the photometric colours are more or less unchanged so resulting errors in flux are also expected to be around 3% or better . thus , the relative flux ratios are expected to be better than a percent . the 2003 spectrum s / n is about 40 and the uncertainty in fluxes are around 5% level . the 1989 and 1992 entries are from rao et al . ( 1993 ) and giridhar et al . ( 1996 ) , respectively . for some lines , corrections for blending with absorption or other emission lines are applied . in particular , the [ sii ] 6730.8 line is blended with the cii 6731.1 absorption line on the redside , particularly on the 1989 july spectrum . a gaussian fit to the blueside of the forbidden line was used in estimating the absorption line correction . since the fwhm ( after a minor correction instrumental broadening ) agrees with the fwhm from 2010 spectrum , we suggest that proper allowance is made for the blending . in the 2010 spectra several cii lines are in emission . the emission is seen only in the core of absorption lines of the multiplet of which 6731.1 is a member ( figure 2 ) . the contribution of this line to the strong emission [ sii ] 6730.8 is fortunately minor . thus , we trust the line ratio of [ sii ] 6716 to 6731 is not unduly affected . gradual fading of dy cen seems unlikely to be due to an increased presence of dust along the line of sight to the star ; a colour variation would likely result from the dust . for a magnitude extinction the e(b - v ) change of 0.32 is expected , if the reddening law of the diffuse ism is adopted . even otherwise rcbs in recovery phases typically show a@xmath9/e(b - v ) @xmath10 4 - so one would expect a change in e(b - v ) of 0.25 . such colour changes are large and noticeable . any colour change @xmath110.1 in e(b - v ) is noticeable . we speculate that the fading may be due to the star evolving to higher temperature at constant bolometric luminosity , as expected for such stars . jeffery & heber ( 1993 ) from a spectrum obtained on 1987 april 17 derived an effective temperature of 19500 k. our 2010 spectra suggest a spectroscopic ionization / excitation temperature of 25000 k. across the temperature range 19000 k to 25000 k , ( b - v ) is insensitive to temperature : the change is only 0.07 . if the bolometric magnitude is constant , the v change over this temperature range is about 0.9 magnitude with v increasing as the effective temperature increases . this is close to the observed change in v ( and b ) . the rate of evolution may be surprisingly rapid . jeffery et al . ( 2001a ) have monitored 12 ehe stars over a period of 10 years looking for the changes in their t@xmath12 and radii . the surface of four stars was found to show heating ( contraction ) at rates between 20 and 120 degrees per year in agreement with theoretical predictions based on models by saio ( 1988 ) . dy cen , which may be considered an ehe star , shows a heating rate of 239 k degrees per year somewhat more rapid than ehe stars . lcllcrllllllll & & & & & & & & & & & & & + & & 2010 & & & & & 2003 ( 1992)@xmath13 & & & 1989 & & & + + ion & @xmath14 & eq.w & flux@xmath15 & ( fwhm)@xmath16 & rad.vel&&eq.w & flux@xmath15 & & eq.w & flux@xmath15 & ( fwhm)@xmath17 & rad.vel + & & ( m ) & x 10@xmath18 & km s@xmath19&km s@xmath19&&(m ) & x 10@xmath18 & & ( m ) & x 10@xmath18 & km s@xmath19 & km s@xmath19 + & & & & & & & & & & & + [ oii ] & 3726.0 & 433 & 10.2 & 34 & 20.9 & & & & & & & & + [ oii ] & 3728.8 & 224 & 5.3 & 34 & 18.8 & & & & & & & + [ nii ] & 5754.6 & 38 & 0.28 & 41 & 19.8 & & & & & & & & + [ oi ] & 6300.3 & 131 & 0.76 & 28.5&20.2 & & 74 & 0.46 & & 87 & 0.68 & 26 & 23.3 + [ oi ] & 6363.8 & 52 & 0.29 & 26.6&21.1 & & 33(67)&0.20(0.47 ) & & & & & + [ nii ] & 6548.0 & 1425 & 7.25 & 41 & 21.3 & & 478(46)&2.59(0.29 ) & & 47 & 0.32 & & 25.8 + @xmath20 & 6562.8 & 9620 & 48.6 & 44.6 & & & 3798(2000)&20.4(12.4 ) & & 1473 & 9.95 & & + [ sii ] & 6716.5 & 350 & 1.61 & 34 & 22.6 & & 157(67)&0.77(0.38 ) & & 92 & 0.56 & 34&22.2 + [ sii ] & 6730.8 & 588 & 2.69 & 34 & 22.0 & & 169&0.82 & & 83 & 0.50 & 34 & 22.4 + [ oii ] & 7319.1 & 93 & 0.31 & 43.7 & & & & & & & & & + [ oii ] & 7320.1 & 273 & 0.92 & 46.6 & & & & & & & & & + [ oii ] & 7329.7 & 154 & 0.52 & 45 & & & & & & & & & + [ oii ] & 7330.8 & 157 & 0.53 & 45 & & & & & & & & & + [ feii ] & 4287.4 & 25 & 0.36 & 10.4&21.1 & & & & & & & & + [ feii ] & 4359.3 & 17 & 0.26 & 8.8&21.5 & & & & & & & & + [ feii ] & 4413.8 & 13 & 0.20 & 8.6 & & & & & & & & & + [ feii ] & 4243.9 & 7 & 0.10 & & & & & & & & & & + @xmath13 1992 data from giridhar et al . ( 1996 ) are given between bracketts + @xmath15 in ergs @xmath21 s@xmath19 [ cols="<,^,<,<,^ , > , < , < , < , < " , ] on the assumption that n / o @xmath22 n@xmath23/o@xmath23 , this nebular ratio is about a factor of three larger than the photospheric value which is n / o = 0.14 from jeffery & heber s ( 1993 ) lte analysis and 0.07 from our unpublished non - lte analysis ( in preparation ) . interestingly , the photospheric s / o ratio is 0.018 ( jeffery & heber 1993 ) , a value in good agreement with the nebula s ionic ratio . thus , comparison of the nebula and photospheric n / o / s ratios suggests that the former is n - rich relative to the latter . this could be accounted for if the nebula represents the envelope of dy cen ejected after its first dredge - up when the envelope is n - rich following the dredge - up of cn - cycled material . to a rough approximation , much of the envelope at that point is n - rich owing to the conversion of large amounts of the c to n , say n / o @xmath22 0.5 . the he shell and deeper layers of the star surviving the episode of envelope ejection may well be far less n - rich because the n has been processed by @xmath24-captures to @xmath25ne . the 2010 spectrum shows balmer and paschen lines in emission . the paschen lines , particularly the lower members of the series , occur as photospheric absorption lines on which nebular emission is superposed . we estimate emission line fluxes from higher members of the series where absorption is minimal . fluxes are given in table 2 . comparison between observed and predicted flux ratios is accomplished using hi recombination line ratios computed by storey & hummer ( 1995 ) for case b - see osterbrock & ferland ( 2006 - table 4.4 ) . we interpolate to conditions @xmath26 k and @xmath27 @xmath0 for the flux ratio of a paschen line to h@xmath24 ; the predictions are mildly sensitive to the adopted @xmath28 and insensitive to @xmath29 . observed and predicted ratios for five clean paschen lines with respect to h@xmath24 are given in table 2 . good agreement is seen suggesting that the lines including h@xmath24 are optically thin . = 8truecm the oi 8446 line is present strongly in emission ( figure 6 ) but presents a different profile than either h@xmath24 or other nebular lines . figure 6 shows a comparison with hi paschen 17 line . since the fwhm of the oi line is about the same as other nebular lines , it is plausible to attribute the apparent doubling to superposed absorption rather than to a blend of two emission lines . oi 8446 is produced by resonance fluorescence of hi @xmath30 with @xmath311025.76 of oi . the excitation of oi by @xmath311025.76 is followed by emission at 11287 and then by emission at 8446 . the oi exists in either the h@xmath32 zone thanks to charge exchange between oxygen and hydrogen or the neutral zone immediately surrounding the hii region . the superposed absorption component in oi 8446 line implies that even hi @xmath30 might be experiencing the superposed absorption . it is a curious fact that a circumstellar absorption component at the same radial velocity exists in caii @xmath313933 and is associated with stellar velocity ( not the systemic velocity ! ) . although h@xmath24 profile shows much wider radial velocity range it does not show any superposed absorption or asymmetry . it is centered on the nebular velocity and has a range -42.5 to 88.5 km s@xmath19 in radial velocity . the superposed absorption suggests the presence of neutral gas surrounding the nebula . an estimate of the amount of this gas is made from the absorption component of caii 3933 line ( figure 6 ) . the equivalent width of this component is about 55 m . the expansion velocity from the fwhm is estimated to be about 8.5 km s@xmath19 . assuming it is optically thin , the column density of ca@xmath32 is 6.4 x 10@xmath33 @xmath21 . the gf values from morton ( 2003 ) . assuming that ca@xmath32/hi @xmath34 ca / h and further assuming solar abundance ratio , the hi column density estimated is 2.7 x 10@xmath35 @xmath21 . for the nebular radius estimated ( in the next section ) the mass of neutral gas is estimated as 1.2 x 10@xmath36 @xmath37 . this estimate is dependent on how the line of sight to the star intercepts the nebula . de marco et al . ( 2002 ) suggest that the distance to dy cen is much more than 4.8 kpc , as was suggested earlier by giridhar , rao & lambert ( 1996 ) . assuming that dy cen has the same m@xmath9 ( -3.0 mag ) as its spectroscopic twin the hot rcb star hv 2671 in the large magellanic cloud ( de marco et al . 2002 ) , the estimated distance of dy cen is about 7 kpc . in addition , the very nearby b - type star hd 115842 ( with e(b - v)=0.5 of ism identical to dy cen ) may provide a constraint that the distance should be greater than 5 kpc . hd 115842 seems to be a hypergiant very similar to hd 169454 ( m@xmath9=-9.2 mag ; federman & lambert 1992 ) as indicated by the presence of fe iii emission lines in its spectrum . for m@xmath9=-9.2 mag , hd 115842 would be at a comparable distance of 5.4 kpc . thus , assuming a distance of 7 kpc for the star ( de marco et al . 2002 ) and the h@xmath24 flux given in table 1 for 2010 , the h@xmath24 effective recombination coefficient of 8.6 x 10@xmath18 @xmath0 s@xmath19 for the nebula s density and temperature leads to an angular radius of the nebula of about 0.64 arcsec . thus , the slit width of 1.2 arcsec used for the 2010 observations should have covered the nebular emission . the geometrical radius corresponding to the angular radius is 6.5 x 10@xmath38 cm . the semi - major axis of the binary system is estimated to be 9.3/@xmath39 i@xmath40 ( rao et al . 2012 ) where i is the angle of inclination of the binary orbit to the line of sight . for @xmath39 i @xmath22 0.6 , the semi - major axis is 1.1 x 10@xmath41 cm . thus , the nebular radius is @xmath20.02 pc or 60000 times larger than the binary orbit . the earlier estimated nebular expansion velocity ( 17 to 20 km s@xmath19 ) , suggests an age of about 1100 years for the nebula . the ionized mass ( mainly h which is providing electrons ) within the nebula is about 3 x 10@xmath42 @xmath37 . ) x ( n@xmath43(=n@xmath44)/m@xmath43 ) where r is the estimated radius of the nebula ( = 6.5 x 10@xmath38 cm ) , n@xmath43 is number of protons (= no . electrons/@xmath45 ) and m@xmath43 is the proton mass . ] note that the main electron donor is hydrogen because : i ) no nebular emission lines of he i are observed ( i.e. , no dominant nebular he i recombinations ) ; and ii ) the photoionizations of h i dominate over he i by a factor of @xmath235 . thus most of the electrons are contributed by h i. the nebula centred on dy cen , a hot rcb star , is surely intimately related to the star because its radial velocity is coincident within about one km s@xmath19 with the systemic velocity of binary system to which dy cen belongs . the nebula s expansion velocity as estimated from the width of nebular forbidden lines suggests that the nebula may have been created about 1000 years ago . spectra from 1989 to 2010 indicate that the star and the nebula are evolving . in apparent concert with an increase in the effective temperature of the star , the electron density in the nebula has increased several - fold over the two decades sampled by available high - resolution spectra . it is quite possible that the recent formation of the nebula , the changes in nebular conditions over the preceding 20 years , and the increase in the stellar effective temperature since 1987 and the steady fading of the star at optical wavelengths are all manifestations of dy cen s past and present evolution . the nebula may be the product of an episode of common envelope evolution that resulted in a primary ( dy cen ) which became a h - deficient supergiant . such supergiants are expected to evolve rapidly to a very hot luminous star at the tip of the white dwarf cooling track . interestingly , dy cen shows a heating rate ( contraction ) more rapid than ehe stars . in either of the two present evolutionary scenarios ( white dwarf mergers or a last helium flash ) for the origin of ehe stars and rcbs , the star has to become a cooler supergiant ( for a second time ) and starts contraction at constant luminosity . whether the rate of contraction is uniform in time or not is not clear . in case of dy cen this path of evolution might not be the one the star passed through . the binarity of the star might introduce a different course ( see rao et al . 2012 for some discussion ) . further observations of the star are most crucial and important in understanding the evolution of hydrogen deficient stars . one is hopeful that dy cen s future behaviour will be followed intensively spectroscopically and photometrically . in particular , it will be important to separate behaviour linked to the 39 day orbital period from the supposedly slower evolutionary trends as dy cen crossed the top of the h - r diagram . we acknowledge the anonymous referee for useful comments that help to improve the paper . we also acknowledge with thanks the variable star observations from the aavso international database contributed by world wide observers used in this research . this research has made use of the simbad database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france . our sincere thanks are due to simon jeffery and vincent woolf for supplying the aat archival spectrum of dy cen . n. k. r. would like to thank david and melody lambert for their hospitality at ut , austin where part of this work is done . d.a.g.h.and a.m. acknowledge support for this work provided by the spanish ministry of economy and competitiveness under grant aya-2011 - 27754 . asplund , m. , gustafsson , b. , lambert , d. l. , kameswara rao , n. 1997 , a&a 321,17 bateson , f. m. 1978 , publs . star , sect . , r. astron . new zealand , 6 , 39 cardelli , j.a . , clayton , g.c . , mathis , j.s . 1989 , apj , 345 , 245 de marco , o. , et al , 2002 , a.j.,123 , 3387 drilling , j. , landolt , a.u . , 2000 , in ` allen s astrophysical quantities ' ed . cox flower , p.j . , 1996 , apj . , 469 , 355 federman , s. r. , & lambert , d. l. 1992 , aj , 104 , 691 garca - hernndez , d. a. , hinkle , k.h . , lambert , d.l . , eriksson , k. 2009 , apj , 696 , 1733 garca - hernndez , d. a. , lambert , d. l. , kameswara rao , n. , hinkle , k. h. , eriksson , k. , 2010 , apj , 714 , 144 garca - hernndez , d. a. , rao , n. k. , lambert , d. l. , 2011a , apj , 729 , 126 garca - hernndez , d. a. , rao , n. k. , lambert , d. l. , 2011b , apj , 739 , 37 garca - hernndez , d. a. , rao , n. k. , lambert , d. l. , 2012 , apj , 759 , l21 garca - rojas , j. , pea , m. , morisset , c. , mesa - delgado , a. , & ruiz , m. t. 2012 , a&a , 538 , a54 giridhar , s. , rao , n. k. , lambert , d.l . , 1996 , jap&a , 17 , 23 herwig , f. , 2000 , a&a , 360 , 952 hoffleit , d. 1930 , harvard college observatory bulletin , 874 , 13 iben , i. , & tutukov , a. v. 1986 , apj . , 311 , 753 iben , i. , kaler , j. b. , truran , j. w. , et al . 1983 , apj , 264 , 605 jeffery , c.s . , heber , u. , 1993 , a&a , 270 , 167 jeffery , c.s . , starling , r. l. c. , hill , p.w . , & pollacco , d. 2001a , mnras , 321 , 111 jeffery , c.s . , woolf , v.m . , & pollacco , d.l . 2001b a&a 376 , 497 jeffery , c. s. , schnberner , d. 2006 , a&a , 459 , 885 jeffery , c.s . , karakas , a.i . , saio , h. , 2011 , mnras , 414 , 3599 kilkenny , d. , et al , 1987 , saao . , 9 , 87 lambert , d. l. , rao , n. k. , 1994 , jap&a , 15 , 47 leuenhagen , u. , heber , u. , jeffery , c.s . , 1994 , a&as , 103 , 445 luridiana , v. , morisset , c. , & shaw , r.a . 2012 , iau symposium , 283 , 422 marino , b.f . , walker , w.s.g . , 1971 , cir . new zealand . var . star sec . , 184 , 1 morton , d.c . , 2003 , apj , suppl . , 149 , pandey.g , lambert , d.l , 2011 , apj , 727,122 perinotto , m. , bencini , c.g . , pasquali , a. , manchando , a. , rodriguez espinosa , j.m . , stanga , r. , 1999 , a&a , 347 , 967 pollacco , d.l . , hill , p.w . , 1991 , mnras , 248 , 572 osterbrock , d.e . , ferland , g.j . , 2006 , ` astrophysics of gaseous nebulae and active galactic nuclei ' , university science books , sausalito , california rao , n. k. , giridhar , s. , lambert , d.l . , 1993 , a&a , 280 , 201 rao n. k. , lambert , d. l. , garca - hernndez . d. a. , jeffery , c. s. , woolf , v. m. mcarthur , b . , 2012 , apj , 760 , l3 renzini , a. , 1990 , in ` confrontation between stellar pulsation and evolution ' , eds . cacciari , c . , clementini , g. , astronomical society of the pacific conf . 11 , 549 , san francisco , ca . saio , h. , 1988 , mnras , 260 , 465 storey , p.j . , hummer , d.g . , 1995 , mnras , 272 , 41 viotti , r. , 1976 , apj , 204 , 293 webbink , r. f. , 1984 , apj , 277 , 355

among the distinguishing characteristics of the remarkable hot r coronae borealis star dy cen , which was recently found to be a spectroscopic binary , is the presence of nebular forbidden lines in its optical spectrum . a compilation of photometry from 1970 to the present suggests that the star has evolved to higher effective temperatures . comparison of spectra from 2010 with earlier spectra show that between 2003 and 2010 , the 6717 and 6730 emission lines of [ sii ] underwent a dramatic change in their fluxes suggesting an increase in the nebula s electron density of 290 @xmath0 to 3140 @xmath0 from 1989 to 2010 while the stellar temperature increased from 19500 k to 25000 k. the nebular radius is about 0.02 pc , 60000 times bigger than the semimajor axis of dy cen binary system . rapid changes of stellar temperature and its response by the nebula demonstrate stellar evolution in action . [ firstpage ] star : individual : dy cen : variables : rcb type : nebula , stellar evolution

1301.4421

the main goal of this paper is to develop a general theory of flag bicolorings and the related concepts of coverings and pseudo - orientations . the idea of consistent colorings of the flags of a map with two colors has appeared previously in literature in different contexts . for instance , when the automorphism group of a map which is a polytope has two orbits on the flags , we may color the flags with two colors in such a way that flags in different orbits have different colors . these are called 2-orbit maps in @xcite , but this investigation requires the extra property that the maps be abstract . specific @xmath0-colorings of flags are equivalent to the concept of @xmath1-_compatible _ maps introduced in @xcite , where @xmath1 is a class of @xmath0-orbit maps . this concept , generalized to hypermaps is called @xmath1-_conservative _ in @xcite . in all these instances , the colorings are used as a tool to work with automorphisms of maps . although some of the motivations behind the bicoloring of flags come from maps admitting symmetries , the ideas can be applied to general maps . in this work we shall not make assumptions on the automorphism groups of the maps in consideration . maps admitting a bicoloring of flags in which adjacent flags have different colors are precisely maps on orientable surfaces ( see proposition [ oble012 ] ) . although the other types of bicolorings of flags that we consider in this paper do not have a known topological equivalence , some results on orientability do translate directly to analogous results on bicolorability . in this sense we may think of bicolorings of flags as a generalization of orientability of maps . the paper is organized as follows . sections [ sec : maps ] , [ sec : ori ] , [ sec : col ] introduce the concepts of maps , pseudo - orientations and bicolorings , respectively . a relationship between pseudo - orientability and bicolorings is provided in section [ sec : colori ] . section [ sec : op ] explores the impact on bicolorability of operations on maps . in section [ sec : doubles ] , we discuss a natural double cover of every map which is not bicolorable . the set of bicolorings of any map can be given a natural group structure . in section [ sec : everygroup ] we determine , for each possible group , which surfaces admit maps with the given group of bicolorings . finally , in section [ sec : mpx ] , we generalize some of the results about maps to higher dimensional structures . a map @xmath2 is , first and foremost , an embedding of a graph ( or pseudograph ) on a ( compact , connected ) surface so that the components of the complement of the embedding ( called _ faces _ ) are topologically open disks . we can , for example , regard the cube as an embedding of the graph @xmath3 on the sphere . the graph @xmath3 is an example of a graph which is _ bipartite _ , i.e. , its vertices can be colored with two colors so that every edge joins vertices of opposite colors . when speaking about maps , we will use the term _ vertex - bipartite _ to describe a map @xmath2 whose underlying graph is bipartite . similarly , we will call @xmath2 _ face - bipartite _ provided its faces can be colored with two colors so that each edge separates faces of opposite colors . we will call @xmath2 _ edge - bipartite _ provided that the edges can be colored with two colors so that edges which are consecutive around a face ( and hence around a vertex ) have different colors . to look more closely at the structure of a map , we find the following subdivision useful : choose a point in the interior of each face to call its _ center _ and a point in the relative interior of each edge to be its _ midpoint_. draw dotted lines to connect each face - center with each incidence with the surrounding vertices and edge - midpoints . the original edges and these dotted lines divide the surface into triangles called _ flags_. figure [ fig : cubeflags ] shows the subdivision of the cube into flags . if a face meets a vertex ( or an edge ) more than once , we emphasize that the face center is connected to each incidence each appearance of the vertex or midpoint . for instance , consider the map @xmath4 shown in the left of figure [ fig : m4 ] . this map has only one face , an octagon , four edges and only one vertex . nonetheless , the dissection into flags draws 16 dotted lines , dividing the octagon , and the map , into 16 flags , as shown on the right . , title="fig:",height=113 ] , title="fig:",height=113 ] each flag corresponds to a mutual incidence of face , edge , and vertex , though different flags may correspond to the same triple . let @xmath5 be the set of flags . then let @xmath6 be the permutations on @xmath5 which match each flag @xmath7 with its three immediate neighbors , as in figure [ fig : flags ] . in that figure , we see that @xmath7 and @xmath8 are adjacent along a face - center - to - edge - midpoint line . thus @xmath7 and @xmath9 differ only in their incidences to a vertex , a 0-dimensional face of @xmath2 . similarly , @xmath7 and @xmath10 differ only in their incidences to an edge , a 1-dimensional face , while @xmath7 and @xmath11 differ only in their incidences to a 2-dimensional face . notice from figure [ fig : flags ] that the flag @xmath12-adjacent to @xmath8 is also @xmath13-adjacent to @xmath14 . in other words , as permutations on @xmath15 and @xmath12 commute . we can take a slightly more abstract point of view by defining a map to be a pair @xmath16)$ ] where @xmath5 is a set of things called _ flags _ , the @xmath17 s and @xmath18 are fixed point free permutations of order 2 on @xmath5 , the _ connection group _ @xmath19 is transitive on @xmath5 , and @xmath13 and @xmath12 commute . this @xmath20 is often called the _ monodromy group _ of the map . we can then think of vertices in @xmath2 as orbits of @xmath21 in @xmath20 . similarly , edges correspond to orbits of @xmath22 and faces to orbits of @xmath23 . we will use the word _ kite _ or _ corner _ for the area within a face where two consecutive edges meet . more formally , a kite is the union of two flags which are @xmath24-adjacent . if @xmath2 and @xmath25 are maps on surfaces @xmath26 and @xmath27 , a _ projection _ from @xmath25 to @xmath2 is a function @xmath28 mapping @xmath27 to @xmath26 which is locally a homeomorphism at all points of @xmath25 except perhaps at vertices and/or face - centers , and which sends faces to faces , edges to edges , and vertices to vertices . in combinatorial terms , if @xmath29)$ ] and @xmath30)$ ] , a projection of @xmath25 to @xmath2 is a function @xmath28 mapping @xmath31 to @xmath5 such that @xmath32 for all @xmath33 . we call such an @xmath25 a _ cover _ of @xmath2 . notice that if @xmath25 is a cover of @xmath2 , and the pre - image of some one flag in @xmath2 has size @xmath0 , then the projection @xmath28 is @xmath0-to-1 onto every flag of @xmath2 . we say then that @xmath25 is a _ @xmath0-fold _ cover of @xmath2 . we call a map _ orientable _ provided that the surface on which it is embedded is itself orientable . we check that a map is orientable by giving it a _ face orientation _ ; this is an assignment of a circular arrow to each face of @xmath2 such that at every edge , the arrows on the faces joined by the edge point along the edge in _ opposite _ directions , as in figure [ fig : faceori ] . we can define a _ vertex orientation _ similarly , and it is clear that @xmath2 has a vertex - orientation if and only if it has a face - orientation , and this happens if and only if @xmath2 is orientable . the word _ pseudo - orientation _ has been used in two different ways . we will use the term _ vertex pseudo - orientation _ ( vpso for short ) for what is called in @xcite simply a pseudo - orientation . here , we mean an assignment of one circular arrow to each vertex so that at each edge the two arrows cross in the _ same _ direction , as in figure [ fig : pso ] . if we visualize a gear wheel at each vertex so that cogs on the wheels of adjacent vertices mesh , the map is vpso if we can turn one wheel , causing all wheels to turn at the same time . in @xcite , the idea is used to make an important distinction about @xmath0-fold rotary covers of a rotary map @xmath2 for which the branching is totally ramified at vertices . if @xmath2 is non - orientable , @xmath0 can be larger than 2 only if @xmath2 is vertex pseudo - orientable . similarly , a _ face pseudo - orientation _ ( or fpso ) is an assignment of one circular arrow to each face , as in figure [ fig : pso ] , so that at each edge , the arrows in adjacent faces flow along the edge in the _ same _ direction . we can simplify this by orienting each edge so that the cycle of edges around each face is consistently oriented . in @xcite this is called a pseudo - orientation , and the result in that paper is that the _ dart graph _ of @xmath2 is connected if and only if @xmath2 is not face pseudo - orientable . finally , we may define an _ edge pseudo - orientation _ ( or epso ) to be an orientation of the edges such that in every face the direction of the arrows in adjacent edges flows in the _ same _ direction ( either into or out of the face ) as in figure [ fig : pso ] . in this paper , the word ` coloring ' will be used to describe what might be more fully notated as a ` consistent flag 2-coloring ' . if @xmath34 is any subset of @xmath35 , then an @xmath34-coloring of a map @xmath2 is a function @xmath36 such that for every flag @xmath7 , if @xmath37 , then @xmath38 , while if @xmath39 , then @xmath40 . to say that in another way , @xmath41 figure [ fig : cubecols ] shows a @xmath42-coloring , a @xmath43-coloring , and an @xmath44-coloring of the cube . the reader should check that the colorings extend unambiguously to the unseen faces of the cube as well . let us first notice that if @xmath45 is an @xmath34-coloring of @xmath2 , then so is @xmath46 , and these are , in fact , the only @xmath34-colorings of the map . give the name _ sub - edge _ to the segments forming sides of the flags . these are of three types : type 0 : : : midpoint - of - edge to face - center , type 1 : : : face - center to vertex , type 2 : : : vertex to midpoint - of - edge . each flag @xmath7 is adjacent to flag @xmath47 along their mutual sub - edges of type @xmath48 . if @xmath2 is @xmath34-colorable , therefore , the sub - edges bounding each color are the sub - edges of types in @xmath34 . note that when considering maps in class @xmath49 as defined in @xcite , the subset @xmath34 is used to indicate that @xmath48-adjacent flags belong to the _ same _ orbit this means that maps in class @xmath49 admit an @xmath50-coloring . in the context of colorings it turns out to be more practical to define @xmath34-coloring requiring @xmath48-adjacent flags to be a different color rather than requiring @xmath48-adjacent flags to be the same color if and only if @xmath51 . let @xmath52 stand for the symmetric difference operation : @xmath53 . let @xmath54 be the power set of @xmath44 . it is well - known that @xmath54 is a group under @xmath52 and it is an elementary abelian group of order eight whose identity element is @xmath55 . [ delta ] if a map @xmath2 admits an @xmath34-coloring and a @xmath56-coloring , then it admits an @xmath57-coloring . proof : it is easy to verify that the sum of an @xmath34-coloring and a @xmath56-coloring is an @xmath57-coloring ' '' '' from this proposition we see that , for each map @xmath2 , the sets @xmath34 for which @xmath2 has an @xmath34-coloring form a set @xmath58 which is a subgroup of @xmath54 . whenever @xmath34 is a subset of size 1 , @xmath34-colorable maps have a nice characterization . [ vbip ] a map @xmath2 is vertex - bipartite if and only if @xmath2 has a @xmath42-coloring . proof : given such a coloring , all the flags incident with one vertex will be the same color , while those at an adjacent vertex will be the other color . this is a bipartite coloring of the vertices . conversely , given a bipartition of the vertices , color all flags incident with black vertices with color 1 and all those incident with white vertices with color 0 . this is then a @xmath42-coloring of @xmath2 . ' '' '' similar proofs lead us to these : [ fbip ] a map @xmath2 is face - bipartite if and only if @xmath2 has a @xmath59-coloring . ( _ i.e. _ a @xmath59-coloring corresponds to a bipartite coloring of the faces of @xmath2 . ) [ ebip ] a map @xmath2 is edge - bipartite if and only if @xmath2 has a @xmath60-coloring . ( _ i.e. _ a @xmath60-coloring corresponds to a bipartite coloring of the edges of @xmath2 . ) consider a _ @xmath61 of flags in a map @xmath2 . we abbreviate that @xmath62 , where @xmath63 is the string @xmath64 . write @xmath65 for @xmath66 . we call a cycle @xmath62 _ @xmath34-consistent _ if the number of occurrences in @xmath63 of indices which are in @xmath34 is even . if @xmath62 is @xmath34-consistent , this says that , at least along the cycle , we can color flags from two colors so that flags which are @xmath48-connected for @xmath67 are the same color and those for which @xmath51 are not . a cycle which is not @xmath34-consistent is _ @xmath34-inconsistent_. it follows , then that @xmath2 is @xmath34-colorable if and only if every cycle in @xmath2 is @xmath34-consistent . consider this quite general fact : for any function @xmath68 from a set @xmath69 to @xmath70 , extend @xmath68 to the power set of @xmath69 by @xmath71 for each subset @xmath72 of @xmath69 . then for any subsets @xmath73 of @xmath69 , it is clear that @xmath74 . [ lemma13 ] for any subsets @xmath75 of @xmath44 , if @xmath76 , then every cycle in @xmath77 is consistent either for exactly one of @xmath78 or for all three . proof : fix a cycle @xmath62 of @xmath2 , and define @xmath68 on @xmath44 with @xmath79 being the parity of the number of occurrences in @xmath63 of @xmath17 ; furthermore , consider @xmath68 extended to @xmath54 . the cycle is @xmath34-consistent , then , provided that @xmath80 . now consider @xmath81 . these are elements of @xmath70 , and so we can rephrase that in this form : @xmath82 . the number of zeros in @xmath83 must be 1 or 3 ; the conclusion follows directly . ' '' '' we will have use for this lemma in section [ sec : doubles ] . a natural operator in topology is the _ connected sum _ of two surfaces , which is defined to be the surface formed by cutting a small disk from each of the two surfaces and attaching them along the newly created border . we extend this definition to maps by causing the attachment sets to be the boundaries of two suitably chosen faces . formally , let @xmath29)$ ] and @xmath30)$ ] be maps and suppose @xmath84 and @xmath85 are flags of these maps for which their respective faces @xmath86 and @xmath87 have the same number @xmath0 of sides . furthermore , suppose that no flag of @xmath86 is @xmath12-connected to any of the flags of @xmath86 , and similarly for @xmath87 . then we define the _ connected sum _ @xmath88 with respect to @xmath89 to be the map whose flag set is @xmath90 , with connections @xmath91 , where @xmath92 and @xmath93 are the restrictions of @xmath94to this set , and @xmath95 is the same except that , for each @xmath96 is @xmath95-connected to @xmath97 and @xmath98 is @xmath95-connected to @xmath99 . because of the restriction on the faces , these flags are both in the new flag set , and it is easy to check that @xmath100 . the following figure illustrates this construction : [ th : oplus ] suppose @xmath2 and @xmath25 are @xmath34-colorable maps for some @xmath101 and suppose @xmath88 exists for some flags @xmath84 and @xmath85 . then @xmath88 is @xmath34-colorable . proof : choose an @xmath34-coloring for @xmath2 and one for @xmath25 in such a way that @xmath84 and @xmath85 have opposite colors if @xmath102 and the same color if @xmath103 . then the induced coloring provides the desired coloring on @xmath104 . ' '' '' as we ll see in the following theorem , it is almost always the case that the group @xmath105 is equal to @xmath106 . this can fail , roughly , when for some @xmath107 , @xmath108 is @xmath34-colorable but @xmath2 is not , or similarly for @xmath25 . [ t : plus ] suppose @xmath2 and @xmath25 are maps and suppose @xmath88 exists for some flags @xmath84 and @xmath85 . furthermore , suppose that for each @xmath109 there exists an @xmath34-inconsistent cycle that does nt include any of the flags of face @xmath86 , and similarly for @xmath25 . then @xmath110 . proof : for @xmath107 , if @xmath111 , then @xmath112 by proposition [ th : oplus ] . if @xmath113 , then without loss of generality , assume that @xmath2 is not @xmath34-colorable . then @xmath2 has cycles which are @xmath34-inconsistent , and by the hypothesis , at least one of them includes none of the flags in @xmath86 . this cycle , then , occurs in @xmath88 , and is still @xmath34-inconsistent . thus @xmath114 . ' '' '' we now offer and prove a series of propositions connecting the ideas of orientations and colorings . first , we show a collection of easy facts to embody our belief that colorings generalize orientations . we then generalize these facts in theorem [ thm : super ] . [ oble012 ] a map is orientable if and only if it has an @xmath44-coloring . proof : if @xmath2 has an @xmath44-coloring , orient each face so that , along each edge , the orientation points from the flag with color 0 to the flag with color 1 . this is consistent within the face and faces that meet along an edge have orientations which meet correctly . conversely , given the orientation , assign colors so that along each edge within a face , the orientation points from the flag with color 0 to the flag with color 1 . this causes colors to alternate within each face . because the orientation opposes the orientation in each adjacent face , the colors alternate at each edge , giving an @xmath44-coloring . ' '' '' similar arguments give us the following two propositions : [ th : fpso01 ] a map @xmath2 has a face pseudo - orientation if and only if @xmath2 admits a @xmath115-coloring . [ vpso12 ] a map @xmath2 has a vertex pseudo - orientation if and only if @xmath2 admits a @xmath43-coloring . our aim in this subsection is to generalize the definition of pseudo - orientability and the previous results . for any subset @xmath34 of @xmath44 ( except @xmath55 ) , we form the map @xmath116 whose faces are the regions formed by conjoining flags which are connected by each @xmath17 for which @xmath67 . for example , if @xmath2 is the cube , then @xmath117 and @xmath118 are shown below . and @xmath118 ] notice that the boundaries of the faces in @xmath120 are the sub - edges of types that are _ in _ @xmath34 . thus @xmath2 is @xmath34-colorable if and only if @xmath120 is face - bipartite . however , the map @xmath120 can be constructed even if @xmath2 is not @xmath34-colorable . we call @xmath2 _ @xmath34-pseudo - orientable _ provided that @xmath121 is face pseudo - orientable . if this happens , we can orient the edges of @xmath69 so that around each face of @xmath69 , the arrows all point the same way . we say a map is @xmath55-pseudo - orientable when it is orientable . it is clear that @xmath122 and so @xmath59-pso is equivalent to fpso . observation [ th : fpso01 ] shows that this happens exactly when @xmath2 is @xmath115-colorable . similarly , @xmath2 is @xmath42-pso when it is vpso , and this happens exactly when @xmath2 is @xmath43-colorable . surprisingly , this generalizes completely : [ thm : super ] let @xmath2 be a map . then @xmath2 is @xmath34-pseudo - orientable if and only if @xmath2 is @xmath123-colorable . proof : first , recall that the sub - edges of @xmath2 are of three different types : type 0 : : : midpoint - of - edge to face - center , type 1 : : : face - center to vertex , type 2 : : : vertex to midpoint - of - edge . furthermore , let us think of the sub - edges as directed . call the directions above the ` standard ' orientations for the sub - edges , and the reverse of these are the non - standard orientations . in order to form @xmath121 , we delete or ignore sub - edges of each type @xmath124 , so we only consider sub - edges of type in @xmath34 . suppose @xmath2 is already @xmath123-colored . then in @xmath120 , both flags around each sub - edge have the same color . then we may assign this as the color of the sub - edge . now give every sub - edge with color 0 the standard orientation , and each sub - edge with color 1 the non - standard direction . if @xmath34 has 2 elements , then consecutive sub - edges around a face of @xmath69 of different types are the same color , while those of the same type are opposite colors . this causes the directions to be consistent about a face . on the other hand , if @xmath34 has only one element , then the sub - edges around a face of @xmath69 alternate in color and are all of the same type ; again , this forces the orientation to be consistent . the following examples show how this works : 1 . if @xmath125 , then by definition the map is @xmath34-pseudo - orientable if and only if it is orientable , and this happens if and only if it is @xmath44-colorable . 2 . if @xmath126 , then @xmath127 , which is face pseudo - orientable if and only if it is @xmath115-colorable . in this case , we orient black type 2 sub - edges from vertex to midpoint - of - edge but white type 2 sub - edges from midpoint - of - edge to vertex . if @xmath128 , we orient black type 1 sub - edges from vertex to face - center and black type 2 sub - edges from midpoint - of - edge to vertex . we orient the opposite colors in the opposite direction : + 4 . if @xmath129 , the @xmath55-coloration colors all sub - edges the same and so the faces of @xmath69 , the flags of @xmath2 , are all oriented consistently . every map is @xmath55-colorable and every map is @xmath44-pso . + for the converse we may use the orientation to color in the way prescribed to match the previous list . ' '' '' we summarize here the results of previous sections relating to the question of which maps have @xmath34-colorings for a given @xmath34 . [ cols=">,<,^",options="header " , ] proof : the medial of any map always admits a @xmath59-coloring ( face - bipartition ) , since we have two types of faces : those that surround vertices of @xmath2 , and those that surround face - centers of @xmath2 . for the first row , if the map is edge - bipartite , then we may color each vertex of the medial with the color corresponding to the color of the edge it was the midpoint of and vice - versa . for the second , note that an edge of the medial corresponds to a kite of the original . finally , the medial maps lies on the same surface as the original . ' '' '' given a map @xmath29)$ ] and a subset @xmath34 of @xmath35 , we define the _ @xmath34-double _ of @xmath2 , denoted @xmath130 , to be the map @xmath131)$ ] , where @xmath132 here , we write `` @xmath133 '' for @xmath134 . notice that the function sending @xmath133 to @xmath7 is a projection of @xmath25 onto @xmath2 , and so @xmath130 is a covering of @xmath2 . also notice that the function which sends @xmath133 to @xmath135 , is an @xmath34-coloring of @xmath130 . now , if @xmath2 has an @xmath34-coloring , then @xmath130 consists of two disjoint copies of @xmath2 ; in this case we discard one copy and say that @xmath130 is isomorphic to @xmath2 . if @xmath2 does not have an @xmath34-coloring then @xmath130 truly is a double cover ( i.e. , a 2-fold topological covering which may or may not be branched at vertices and/or face - centers ) of @xmath2 . in this case , for every cycle @xmath62 in @xmath2 , if it is @xmath34-consistent , then @xmath136 , and @xmath137 , and so the cycle is covered by two cycles of the same length . and if @xmath62 is @xmath34-inconsistent , then @xmath138 , and @xmath139 . then the cycle @xmath62 is covered by a single cycle of twice the length of @xmath62 . in that case the covering cycle is @xmath140 , which is consistent for any subset of @xmath44 . we have remarked above that the map @xmath130 always has an @xmath34-coloring . moreover , we claim , it is universal minimal in the sense of the following proposition : [ th : mindub ] if @xmath25 is any map that is a covering of @xmath2 and which is @xmath34-colorable , then @xmath25 must itself cover @xmath130 . proof : let @xmath45 be an @xmath34-coloring of @xmath25 and let @xmath28 be a projection of @xmath25 onto @xmath2 . define @xmath141 mapping @xmath25 onto @xmath130 to send the flag @xmath7 of @xmath25 to the flag @xmath142 of @xmath130 . because @xmath45 is an i - coloring of @xmath25 , this @xmath141 is a projection , as required . ' '' '' an example of a double covering is @xmath143 when @xmath2 is a non - orientable map . because @xmath2 does not have an @xmath44-coloring , @xmath25 is truly a double cover of it , and since @xmath25 then _ does _ have an @xmath44-coloring , it must be orientable and so @xmath25 is the orientable twofold cover ( some say the _ canonical _ cover ) of @xmath2 . another example of the double construction in the literature comes from sherk s 1962 paper @xcite . at that time few non - toroidal chiral maps were known . sherk constructed an infinite family of such maps on an infinite number of different surfaces , using a simple and clever technique . starting with a chiral map @xmath2 on the torus , with triangles as faces and six of them incident to each vertex , he made a new map @xmath25 in the following way . for each vertex @xmath144 of @xmath2 , he created vertices @xmath145 ; for each edge @xmath146 , he made edges @xmath147 and @xmath148 ; and each triangular face @xmath149 $ ] became a hexagonal face @xmath150 $ ] . this map has hexagonal faces , still meeting 6 at a vertex . thus if @xmath2 had @xmath151 vertices , @xmath152 faces and @xmath153 edges , then @xmath25 has @xmath152 vertices , @xmath152 faces and @xmath154 edges . it follows that @xmath25 must lie on the orientable surface of characteristic @xmath155 , i.e. , of genus @xmath156 . from our point of view , we can construct @xmath25 as @xmath157 . as a final example , the reader might like to verify that if @xmath158 is the tetrahedron then @xmath159 is the orientable map with hexagonal faces , six of them around each vertex , shown in figure [ fig:1yt ] . , height=170 ] we present here some of the facts about @xmath34-doubles : [ th : jup ] if @xmath2 has a @xmath34-coloring then so does any @xmath160 . proof : in fact , by definition _ any _ covering of @xmath2 inherits an @xmath34-coloring from that of @xmath2 . ' '' '' [ t : idj ] if @xmath2 has a @xmath56-coloring then any @xmath130 is isomorphic to @xmath161 . proof : for any map @xmath2 , @xmath130 is the smallest covering of @xmath2 which admits an @xmath34-coloring . if @xmath2 has a @xmath56-coloring , then @xmath130 has a @xmath56-coloring as well . thus , by proposition [ delta ] , @xmath130 admits an @xmath162-coloring , and whether @xmath2 has an @xmath34-coloring or not , this covering of @xmath2 must be minimal of those admitting an @xmath162-coloring . thus @xmath163 . ' '' '' the following two results summarize the examples given above . if @xmath2 is non - orientable , then @xmath164 is isomorphic to the orientable double covering of @xmath2 . we say that a map @xmath25 is the _ sherk double cover _ of a non - vertex - bipartite map @xmath2 whenever @xmath25 can be obtained from @xmath2 by the above procedure used by sherk to obtain the chiral maps with hexagonal faces . if @xmath2 is not vertex - bipartite , then @xmath157 is isomorphic to its sherk double cover . note that @xmath42 , @xmath60 , @xmath59 generate @xmath54 under @xmath52 , and so if @xmath2 is any map , then @xmath165 has @xmath166 , and so @xmath25 is an un - double - able map in our context . [ th : dubgp ] for any map @xmath2 and any subset @xmath34 of @xmath44 , @xmath167 proof : this is obvious if @xmath168 . if not , it is clear that @xmath169 is contained in @xmath170 , and so we need only to show that the opposite containment holds . this is equivalent to showing that if @xmath171 and @xmath172 , then @xmath173 ( see proposition [ t : idj ] ) . let @xmath174 and note that , if @xmath175 , then @xmath25 is a @xmath56-colorable double cover of @xmath2 ; by proposition [ th : mindub ] , @xmath25 must be isomorphic to @xmath176 . because @xmath172 , there is some cycle @xmath62 which is @xmath56-inconsistent . if any such cycle is @xmath34-consistent , then in @xmath25 , the cycle @xmath177 has the same length as @xmath62 , and so is also @xmath56-inconsistent , contradicting @xmath175 . thus every cycle which is @xmath56-inconsistent is also @xmath34-inconsistent . a similar argument in @xmath178 shows that every cycle in @xmath2 which is @xmath34-inconsistent is also @xmath56-inconsistent . therefore every cycle is either consistent for both , or inconsistent for both . by lemma [ lemma13 ] , every cycle in @xmath2 is @xmath76-consistent , and then @xmath179 , as required . ' '' '' we want to generalize the result from @xcite which says , loosely speaking , that a reflexible map is a 2-fold orientable cover of a non - orientable reflexible map if and only if its rotation group contains an involutory element which conjugates each of the generators to its inverse . to re - phrase that in our context , a reflexible map @xmath25 which has an @xmath44-coloring is an @xmath44-double of some reflexible map @xmath2 which does not have such a coloring if and only if the subgroup of @xmath180 which preserves colors in the coloring contains an involutory element which conjugates each of the generators ( of the color - preserving group ) to its inverse . if @xmath25 is @xmath34-colorable , let @xmath45 be either of the @xmath34-colorings of @xmath25 and define @xmath181 to be the subgroup of @xmath182 consisting of all @xmath183 such that @xmath184 for all @xmath185 . because @xmath25 is @xmath34-colorable , this group has index 2 , and so is normal , in @xmath182 . note that theorem [ t : isdouble ] generalizes the result from @xcite not only to all @xmath34-colorings , but also to maps with no assumption on their automorphism group . [ t : isdouble ] a map @xmath186)$ ] is @xmath130 for some non-@xmath34-colorable map @xmath187)$ ] if and only if @xmath25 is @xmath34-colorable and there exists @xmath51 and @xmath188 of order 2 such that for every element @xmath189 , @xmath190 . * proof * : first , assume @xmath174 with @xmath2 a non-@xmath34-colorable map . we will prove the existence of @xmath183 . the group @xmath191 has index 2 in @xmath182 , and there is an isomorphism @xmath192 which is the letter - to - letter projection , @xmath193 whenever the word @xmath194 is in @xmath191 and so has an even number of indices in @xmath34 . because @xmath77 is not @xmath34-colorable , @xmath34 is not empty . so consider any @xmath51 and let @xmath195 . note that @xmath183 is an involution since @xmath7 is an isomorphism . this @xmath183 is not @xmath17 , since @xmath196 ; it is , instead , expressible as some longer product of @xmath197 s . then for any @xmath198 we have @xmath199 , while @xmath200 , since @xmath201 is in @xmath202 , and @xmath7 acts there as letter - to - letter projection . since @xmath7 is an isomorphism and hence one - to - one , we conclude that @xmath203 . now assume we have @xmath188 of order 2 and @xmath204 such that for every element @xmath205 , @xmath190 . in particular , with @xmath206 , we have @xmath207 . from this we see that @xmath208 . we then construct @xmath2 by identifying flags in the following consistent way : let @xmath209 , so that @xmath210 is an involution . we shall identify flag @xmath185 with @xmath211 . because @xmath210 is an involution , this identification is unambiguous , and each flag is identified with exactly one other . since @xmath183 preserves coloring and @xmath17 changes it , we are identifying a white flag with a black flag . these equivalence classes are the flags of @xmath2 . then we have to define the connectors @xmath212 and @xmath213 of @xmath2 . notice that for every @xmath214 we have @xmath215 , so @xmath210 commutes with all of @xmath191 . but @xmath191 has index 2 , and @xmath216 so @xmath210 commutes with all of @xmath182 . then we define @xmath217)s_j = [ f r_j , f u r_j = f r_j u]$ ] . the @xmath218 s are well defined and we can easily see @xmath219 and @xmath213 commute , since @xmath13 commutes with @xmath12 . to see that @xmath25 is the @xmath34-double cover of @xmath2 , identify each black flag @xmath7 of @xmath25 with the flag @xmath220_1 $ ] of @xmath130 , and each white flag @xmath7 with the flag @xmath220_0 $ ] . ' '' '' in order to use this theorem we would , in theory , need to prove the existence of @xmath183 and observe that under conjugation , @xmath183 acts in the same way as some @xmath17 on _ every _ element of @xmath221 . but in practice , we only need to find @xmath183 that acts in such a way for the _ generators _ of @xmath221 . the element @xmath17 must not be in @xmath202 and so we will refer to it as an _ external generator_. table i below summarizes information about each subset @xmath34 of @xmath44 . the second column ( adapted from @xcite ) gives generators for @xmath221 as a subgroup of @xmath182 . the third column gives the @xmath222 which are not in @xmath202 , and the last column shows the actions on the generators of @xmath202 under conjugation by this external generator . the purpose of this section is to prove that every subgroup @xmath223 of @xmath54 occurs on every surface on which it _ can _ appear . to clarify that statement , we call a group which includes @xmath44 an _ orientable _ subgroup of @xmath54 , and subgroups which do not contain @xmath44 are _ non - orientable_. so we want @xmath223 to appear on @xmath224 when they are both orientable or both non - orientable . this is almost true , as explained by the following theorem : [ thm : everygroup ] for every subgroup @xmath223 of @xmath54 and every surface @xmath224 , there is a map @xmath2 on @xmath224 such that @xmath225 if and only if @xmath224 and @xmath223 are both orientable or both non - orientable , with the following exceptions : 1 . the group @xmath226 does not appear on the sphere . 2 . the group @xmath227 does not appear on the projective plane . 3 . the group @xmath228 does not appear on the projective plane . [ allgp ] the proof of this claim is contained in and scattered through the remaining parts of this section . we will consider the 16 possible groups subgroups of @xmath54 individually and in dual pairs . such a proof would appear to require 16 constructions , but we can use lemma [ di ] and proposition [ th : jup ] for some simplification . moreover , the insertion techniques that we will introduce and the connected sum construction of subsection [ sec : connectedsum ] allow even more simplification . we consider the non - orientable cases first ; then a simple argument , using the results of section [ sec : doubles ] , takes care of the orientable ones . consider any triangulation of a non - orientable surface @xmath224 . refine the triangulation slightly by placing one new vertex inside some triangular face and connect it to the three vertices on its boundary so as to have one vertex of degree 3 . call this map @xmath2 . because of the triangular faces and the the degree-3 vertex , the cheat sheet of section [ sec : colori ] shows us that none of the sets of size 1 or 2 are in the group , and because @xmath224 is non - orientable , it can not contain @xmath44 either . thus @xmath58 must be the trivial group . in this subsection , we introduce the technique of _ insertion_. we shall prove that any map @xmath2 can be easily modified to produce a map which is face or vertex bipartite and also face or vertex pseudo - orientable . let us assume , for example , that we wish to modify @xmath2 to construct a vertex - bipartite map . color the vertices of @xmath2 at random . for the edges for which both vertices are the same color , add a vertex ( of degree 2 ) to split the edge in two . the same idea can be applied if we wish vertex pseudo - orientability . we may assign orientations to the vertices at random and then split the edges whose endpoints do nt match into two edges . call this process _ vertex - insertion_. this can also be used to turn a map which _ is _ vertex - bipartite or vpso into one that is _ not_. note that vertex - insertion does not modify the status of either face - bipartiteness of fpso of @xmath2 . dually , we may replace an edge by a face bounded by two edges to get either face - bipartition or fpso . the following picture illustrates this for face pseudo - orientation : we begin with an arbitrary map on a surface @xmath224 , and an arbitrary orientation of each face . if there is an edge , as in figure [ fig : otopso]a , where the assigned arrows flow in opposite directions along the edge , replace the edge with a face bounded by a pair of edges as shown in [ fig : otopso]b . orient the resulting lune with an arrow as shown . this gives a map on the same surface with one fewer edge for which the given arrows fail to give a face pseudo - orientation . continuing this process eventually gives us a map on @xmath224 admitting a face pseudo - orientation . let s call this process _ face - insertion_. here , we used it to produce a fpso map on any surface . we can use it equally well to turn any map into a face - bipartite map on the same surface . as with vertex insertion , this same process can also be used to convert a map which _ is _ face bipartite or fpso to one which is _ not_. for many groups we can use these two operations to produce maps with that group on any non - orientable surface . we will show one of these in detail and summarize the rest . consider the non - orientable group @xmath229 . for any non - orientable surface @xmath224 , we choose any map on @xmath224 , and , using face - insertion as above , construct a map which is fpso . now we must be certain that the group of the map is no bigger than @xmath223 . the other cosets of @xmath223 in @xmath54 are @xmath230 . by inserting one vertex on one edge , if necessary , we can cause the map to have a face with odd degree , eliminating @xmath42 and @xmath43 and hence all @xmath231 from the group . the non - orientability of the surface eliminates @xmath35 and hence all of @xmath232 . thus the final form @xmath2 of the map has @xmath233 , as required . notice that the group @xmath234 is then @xmath235 . we produce maps having most of the other non - orientable groups in a similar way . starting with an arbitrary map on a non - orientable surface we perform insertions in the following ways : * use face - insertion to force fpso and vertex - insertion to force vpso . the result is a map whose group is @xmath236 . * use face - insertion to force fpso and then vertex - insertion to force it to be vertex - bipartite . the resulting map has group @xmath237 . its dual has group @xmath238 . * use face - insertion to force the map to be face - bipartite and vertex - insertion to force it to be vertex - bipartite . the resulting map has group @xmath239 . * use face - insertion to force face - bipartiteness and vertex - insertion in order to force some face to have an odd number of sides . the group must be just @xmath240 . its dual then has group @xmath241 . these constructions take care of all non - orientable groups except for two : @xmath242 and @xmath243 . in order to cope with the two non - orientable exceptional groups , we apply the technique of connected sums of maps , developed in subsection [ sec : connectedsum ] , as well as by giving constructions of parameterized families of suitable maps in order to have explicit constructions . for each group @xmath244 with @xmath245 and @xmath246 , there exists a map @xmath2 on every non - orientable surface such that all the following hold : * @xmath225 . * there is a face @xmath68 with exactly 2 sides and exactly 2 vertices . * @xmath247 . that is , the flags of @xmath2 that are not in @xmath68 are _ not _ @xmath34-colorable for every @xmath248 . proof : let @xmath224 be an arbitrary non - orientable surface . to construct a map on @xmath224 with the desired properties , first consider any map for which no face shares a vertex with itself . because the surface is non - orientable , we may choose an arbitrarily fine subdivision for which there is a mbius band of faces which does not use all the faces or edges . then apply the operations described in subsection [ insert ] to make the map @xmath249-colorable for each @xmath249 in @xmath223 . this is possible since any group @xmath223 with 4 elements with @xmath245 must contain two of the following : vertex - bipartite , face - bipartite , fpso or vpso , with the other non trivial element being the symmetric difference of the other two . now consider an edge that is not in any of the faces of the chosen mbius band and convert it into three edges , as with face - insertion but with three edges instead of two . this operation does _ not _ change the status of vertex - bipartition , face - bipartition , vpso or fpso as required . now pick either of the two newly created faces and call it @xmath68 . since we still have a mbius strip , @xmath250 , but every @xmath251 is in @xmath252 . therefore , @xmath247 . ' '' '' for @xmath253 and @xmath254 we have that for every surface ( except the projective plane ) there exists a map @xmath2 on that surface with @xmath255 . proof : let @xmath224 be a surface with non - orientable genus @xmath256 . consider maps as in the previous lemma @xmath257 and @xmath258 such that @xmath257 lies on a surface with non - orientable genus @xmath259 and @xmath258 lies on the projective plane and such that : * if @xmath254 , then @xmath260 * if @xmath261 , then @xmath262 then @xmath263 ( along the 2-sided faces as in the previous lemma ) lives on the non - orientable surface with genus @xmath0 and @xmath264 ( see theorem [ t : plus ] ) . ' '' '' we give explicit constructions for these last two groups : let @xmath265 , and consider the map @xmath266 where @xmath267 . this map has @xmath268 faces , each one a square . they are arranged in an @xmath269 rectangle . the top @xmath270 edges are identified with the bottom @xmath270 directly and orientably . each vertical edge is identified with the one diametrically across from it ; the first @xmath0 orientably , the rest non - orientably . figure [ fig : g573 ] shows @xmath271 . , height=226 ] because vertical and horizontal edges alternate around every face and every vertex , this map is always edge - bipartite , i.e.,@xmath60-colorable , and lies on the non - orientable surface of genus @xmath272 . ( @xmath273 , then , is on the klein bottle ) if @xmath274 is odd and @xmath275 , then the map is neither face - bipartite nor vertex - bipartite , and so its group is @xmath227 . for @xmath276 consider the maps shown in figure [ fig : one ] : in general we have a rectangle one unit wide , having any height . the maps shown in figure [ fig : one ] have characteristic 0 and 1 respectively . in the left picture , by making the strip long enough , we may switch enough pairs of adjacent labels on the right side ( for example , switch labels 3 and 4 on the right ) to make any even genus non - orientable surface . similarly , for the picture on the right we may switch enough pairs of adjacent labels in a sufficiently long strip to construct any odd genus non - orientable surface . to see that the group is indeed @xmath277 , we see that neither map is face - bipartite , since some faces are glued to themselves , or face pseudo - orientable , since both contain faces that are glued to themselves in an orientable way . similarly , neither are vertex - bipartite or vertex pseudo - orientable . this concludes the proof for the non - orientable case . if the subgroup @xmath223 contains @xmath44 , then it is generated by @xmath44 and some subgroup @xmath278 not containing @xmath44 . each orientable surface @xmath224 is the orientable twofold cover of some non - orientable surface @xmath279 . by the preceding subsections , @xmath279 has a map @xmath280 whose group is @xmath278 ( unless s is the sphere , @xmath279 is the projective plane and @xmath223 is @xmath281 ) . then @xmath282 is a map on @xmath224 whose group is @xmath223 . by proposition [ th : dubgp ] , @xmath58 is exactly @xmath223 . thus , with the one exception , for each subgroup @xmath223 containing @xmath44 , every orientable surface admits a map whose group is @xmath223 . ' '' '' all that is left to prove now is that the three exceptions mentioned in the theorem are in fact exceptions namely that there is no map on the specified surfaces with the specified group . we shall prove this first for the group @xmath226 on the sphere . [ l : nosphere ] there is no map on the sphere with group @xmath226 . proof : suppose @xmath2 is one such map . since @xmath283 , the underlying graph of @xmath2 is not bipartite , which means it has an odd cycle @xmath284 . by jordan s closed curve theorem , this divides the sphere into two connected components . choose either and erase every edge and vertex exterior to it in order to form the deleted part into a single face whose boundary is @xmath284 . this gives a new map @xmath280 , also on the sphere . since @xmath285 , every face of @xmath2 must have an even number of sides . therefore @xmath280 has exactly one face with an odd number of sides . then the underlying graph of @xmath286 has exactly one vertex of odd degree , a well - known impossibility . ' '' '' no map @xmath2 on the projective plane has @xmath287 or @xmath288 . proof : if such a map were to exist , its orientable double cover would violate lemma [ l : nosphere ] . ' '' '' the proof of theorem [ allgp ] is now complete . no map on a non - orientable surface has an @xmath44-coloring . in all other cases , for any subset @xmath34 of @xmath44 , and any surface @xmath224 , there is a map @xmath2 on @xmath224 which is @xmath34-colorable . to generalize the results of this paper to higher - dimensional objects , we use the idea of a _ maniplex _ , first introduced in @xcite . we summarize the definitions here : an _ @xmath274-maniplex _ is a pair @xmath289)$ ] , where @xmath5 is a set of things called _ flags _ , and each @xmath17 is a fixed - point - free involution on @xmath5 such that @xmath290 is transitive on @xmath5 , and for every @xmath48 , @xmath291 such that @xmath292 , the permutations @xmath17 and @xmath197 commute and are disjoint . maniplexes clearly generalize maps and slightly generalize ( the flag - graphs of ) abstract polytopes . in particular , every map is a 2-maniplex and every 2-maniplex is a map . the language of maniplexes is the language of polytopes : an @xmath48-face is an orbit under the group @xmath293 , generated by all of the @xmath197 s except @xmath17 . a 0-face is a vertex , a 1-face is an edge , an @xmath274-face is a _ facet_. the definitions of _ coloring , projection , cover _ generalize easily . there is no notion of surface or manifold which applies to maniplexes ; nevertheless , we describe a maniplex which has an @xmath294-coloring as being orientable . in view of theorem [ thm : super ] , one may define a maniplex to be @xmath34-pseudo - orientable if and only if it is @xmath295-colorable . we may give a definition of fpso that is more in the spirit of our intuition : first , we need each facet to be orientable and second , orientations can be assigned to the facets so that they agree on every subfacet . it is easy to see that this is equivalent to an @xmath296-coloring of @xmath2 . the idea of an @xmath34-coloring , for any @xmath107 , comes forward easily , as does the fact that the set of @xmath34 s for which a given maniplex @xmath2 is @xmath34-colorable forms a subgroup @xmath58 of the power set @xmath54 of @xmath44 under @xmath52 . we can define @xmath48-face bipartiteness : an @xmath48-face is a connected component under all of the @xmath197 s except @xmath17 . make these the vertices of a graph , and join two of them by an edge is some flag of one is @xmath17 adjacent to some flag of the other . if this graph is bipartite , we say that @xmath2 is @xmath48-face bipartite . then , it is easy to show then that @xmath2 is @xmath48-face bipartite if an only if it is @xmath297-colorable . we can define connected sum of two @xmath274-maniplexes , removing isomorphic facets , one from each maniplex and adjusting the @xmath298 connections to form the sum . the theorem that the sum has any coloring common to both still holds . the operators generalize with a little care . we form @xmath299 from @xmath2 by replacing @xmath12 with the product @xmath300 . we form @xmath301 from @xmath2 by reversing the order of the generators . and then @xmath302 . similar facts hold about how colorings of @xmath2 are inherited by its direct derivates . the medial operation is more difficult to generalize . the construction of @xmath34-doubles is straightforward to generalize , and all of the facts about the doubles do as well . the fact that maps have rank 3 plays no role in any of these proofs . again , because there is no notion equivalent to that of ` surface ' , there is no natural way to generalize the results of section [ sec : everygroup ] . the constructions in section [ sec : everygroup ] lead to quite general maps , although some of them may be somewhat degenerate in the viewpoint of other previous work . it may be the case that more exceptions in theorem [ allgp ] are needed if we ask the extra requirement that the maps are polyhedral maps ( that is , the intersection of the closure of two distinct faces is either empty , a single vertex , or a single edge . see @xcite ) . however , this is beyond the scope of this paper . in previous sections we considered colorings of the flags of maps insisting that we use only two colors . in doing so , we ensure that if a given flag is @xmath48-adjacent to another flag with the same color then all flags are the same color as their @xmath48-adjacent flags . consistent colorings with @xmath0 colors can be defined following the idea of @xcite and @xcite , that is , each flag is assigned a color in @xmath303 with the restriction that for every @xmath304 and @xmath305 , the color of the @xmath48-adjacent flag to a flag @xmath7 colored @xmath291 depends on @xmath291 but not on @xmath7 . when @xmath0-coloring a map consistently for @xmath306 then it may not be true that a flag is @xmath48-adjacent to another flag with the same color if and only if each flag is @xmath48-adjacent to another flag with the same color . for example , we can color the flags of the pentagons of a pentagonal prism with color @xmath307 , the flags of the edges shared by two squares with color @xmath308 , and the remaining flags with color @xmath309 , as in figure [ fig:3orb ] . the reader can easily verify that this is a consistent 3-coloring , however , flags colored @xmath307 are @xmath307-adjacent to flags colored @xmath307 , and flags colored @xmath308 are @xmath307-adjacent to flags colored @xmath309 . it is unlikely that the concept of pseudo - orientability admits a generalization that preserves the connections between 2-colorings and pseudo - orientations of maps . however , @xmath0-colorings may still keep an interesting relation with @xmath0-fold covers of maps and maniplexes as well . * acknowledgements : * the authors , particularly the last , would like to thank the organizers of the workshop on abstract polytopes ( this set of organizers overlaps the set of authors ) for bringing us together . without that meeting , this research might not have happened . the first author was partially supported by agencija za raziskovalno dejavnost republike slovenije under the research project mu - prom/11 - 010 . the second and fourth authors were partially supported by papiit mexico under grant in112512 . the third author was supported supported by dgapa postdoctoral scholarship and additionally by papiit grant ib100312 .

this paper discusses consistent flag bicolorings of maps and maniplexes , in their own right and as generalizations of orientations and pseudo - orientations . furthermore , a related doubling concept is introduced , and relationships between these ideas are explored . = 5 * flag bicolorings , pseudo - orientations , and double covers of maps . * hiroki koike + ` [email protected] ` + institute andrej marui + university of primorska + koper , slovenia + daniel pellicer + ` [email protected] ` + centro de ciencias matemticas + universidad nacional autnoma de mxico + morelia , mexico + miguel raggi + ` [email protected] ` + centro de ciencias matemticas + universidad nacional autnoma de mxico + morelia , mexico + steve wilson + ` [email protected] ` + department of mathematics and statistics + northern arizona university + flagstaff , usa +

hep-ph0403011

the following work is based on the research reported in ref . @xcite . it pursues the objective of empathizing the analogy between accessible condensed matter systems and the currently accepted framework for the evolution of the universe , notably the symmetry - breaking phase transitions @xcite it has undergone after the big - bang . a key aspect to this comparison is the creation of topological defects , frustrations of the unbroken phase within the broken one , arising from the continuity of the order parameter values . these are generally categorized according to the homotopy group of the quocient of the unbroken symmetry groups to the broken one and which enables for comparison of different physical phenomena . these objects can appear as magnetic monopoles or point - like defects , cosmic strings , vortices or flux tubes , magnetic domain walls or textures . besides its mere aesthetical value , this analogy can provide a powerful probe into the early stages of the evolution of the universe , since direct , hands - on experimental tests are unattainable : the existence of more accessible systems that exhibit a formally similar behavior could provide crucial clues to many cosmologically relevant issues . these `` cosmology in the laboratory '' experiments can be found in various systems , ranging from vortices in superfluid phase transitions of @xmath0 and @xmath1 ( see e.g. ref . @xcite ) , which exhibit common features with cosmic strings @xcite , to liquid crystals undergoing an isotropic - nematic phase transition @xcite . polymer chains were shown to also possess analogous thermodynamic and transitional behavior @xcite . however , most of these systems lack the existence of a quantity analogous to the magnetic field , which could be a key player in the early evolution of the universe and formation of structure . for that reason , superconductors are a case of special interest . these comprise phase transitions involving a local gauge symmetry - breaking process , during which the photon acquires a `` mass '' and , therefore , a penetration length , giving rise to the meissner effect : the expulsion of the magnetic field from a superconducting material , with formation of shielding `` supercurrents '' on its surface . this symmetry breaking originates topological defects which are known as flux tubes or vortices , lines of non - null magnetic field trapped inside the superconductor . experiments targeted at observing defect densities in high-@xmath2 materials @xcite were not in accordance with the density predictions of the kibble - zurek ( k - z ) mechanism @xcite . this , however , is to be expected , since the k - z prediction should be accurate only for global gauge symmetry breaking , when the geodesic rule for phase angle summation is valid . a new defect generation mechanism , based on a local gauge treatment by hindmarsh and rajantie ( h - r ) @xcite , leads to an ( additive ) prediction . this , although well below the first carmi - polturak experimental sensitivity , is in reasonable agreement with the second . as a starting point for this research , we note that the above experiments were both conducted in type - ii materials , which exhibit a higher critical temperature and are therefore easier to manipulate , leading the current trend in experimental superconductivity . these materials display a second order phase transition , with no release of latent heat . on the other hand , type - i materials are metastable , showing different responses to a magnetic field when in normal - superconductor or superconductor - normal phase transitions . in this work , we try to account for this more elaborate behavior and to estimate to which extent it affects the defect density predictions for type - i superconductors . type - i and type - ii superconductors are commonly distinguished according to their ginzburg - landau ( g - l ) parameter @xmath3 , the ratio between the magnetic field penetration length @xmath4 and the coherence length @xmath5 of the order parameter . in the presence of a gauge field @xmath6 , these characteristic length scales are obtained from the free energy density f ( ) = 1 2m_e |i - e c |^2 + v ( ) + 1 2 ( ) , [ free ] where @xmath7 is the sample s magnetic moment , @xmath8 is the electron mass and @xmath9 is the order parameter . the g - l potential is usually written as @xcite v ( ) = ^2 + 2 ^4 , [ pot ] where @xmath10 is assumed to be linear with temperature , @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 are constants , and @xmath2 is the critical temperature . one obtains = , [ lambda ] and = / . [ xi ] the coherence length at zero temperature is @xmath15 , with @xmath16 . the transition is second order if @xmath17 , and @xmath18 is typically less than @xmath19 ; for @xmath20 , the transition is first order and @xmath18 typically greater than @xmath21 . it is commonly accepted that , if there is no applied magnetic field , one always has a second - order phase transition , for all values of @xmath22 . first order transitions arise from the external field term in eq . ( [ free ] ) if the sample has a characteristic dimension @xmath23 . this degeneracy of the phase transition at @xmath24 is , however , only verifiable to the current experimental sensitivity , and it can be argued that there is some yet undetected intrinsic metastability , regardless of the applied magnetic field . bearing in mind the analogy between condensed matter and cosmology , we now briefly look at phase transitions in high energy physics . in thermal field theory ( tft ) a first order phase transition arises due to 1-loop radiative corrections to a potential similar to that of eq . ( [ pot ] ) ; a barrier between minima of the potential is created , as these corrections give rise to a cubic scalar field term v ( ) = ^2 - ||^3 + 2 ^4 , [ 3pot ] where @xmath25 @xcite . as before , @xmath14 is assumed to be constant and @xmath11 to depend linearly with temperature . in the normal - to - superconductor phase transition , a term similar to @xmath26 also arises if one takes into account gauge field fluctuations @xcite , producing = 8 _ 0 e c t_c . [ fluct_gamma ] this result enables a first order phase transition for all values of @xmath22 . thermal fluctuations @xcite and non local bcs effects @xcite describe crossover behavior between first and second order transitions . in the following , we adopt a potential of the form of eq . ( [ 3pot ] ) and constrain @xmath27 based on experimental data . the results are then compared with both tft 1-loop radiative corrections and the the results of ref . @xcite ( valid only at temperature close to @xmath28 , that is , @xmath29 ) . the introduction of @xmath30 in the potential ( [ pot ] ) can produce changes in both the k - z and h - r defect generating mechanisms . also , a possible nucleation suppression due to the potential barrier can significantly reduce the number of observed defects . the obtained constraints on @xmath31 are used to access the impact on these claims . a superconductor undergoing a first - order phase transition crosses different supercritical fields , displaying a metastable behavior , as shown in the phase diagram of figure [ curves ] . the superheating curve is given by the condition @xmath32 , for @xmath33 , equivalent to @xmath34 . the supercooling curve is given by the condition @xmath35 for @xmath36 , corresponding to @xmath37 . the ( unobservable ) critical curve is given by @xmath38 and @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is the non - vanishing minimum of the potential . this corresponds to @xmath41 . assuming @xmath42 and @xmath43 , we obtain for the superheating curve (t-1 ) = 9 16 ^2 t^2 , [ sh_cond ] and t_sh = 2 1 + ~1 + 9 16 ^2 . [ t_sh ] due to the presence of the cubic term in the potential of eq . ( [ 3pot ] ) , the superheating curve shows a zero - field shift in temperature from @xmath2 by @xmath44 . this shift , if detected , would indicate an intrinsic metastability , in the sense that it does not depend on the existence of an applied field . since such temperature shift has not yet been signaled , the current experimental temperature sensitivity being @xmath45 @xcite , a bound on the slope of @xmath46 is < t_exp . [ tbound ] the supercooling transition still occurs at @xmath47 , the critical temperature ; this is natural , since it is determined solely by @xmath48 ( neglecting a smaller order correction to @xmath10 , @xcite ) . .critical properties of @xmath49 and @xmath50 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] table [ table2 ] provides a comparison of the bounds on @xmath51 with the cubic term arising from 1-loop corrections in tft and the prediction of ref . this is achieved by computing the slope of @xmath52 from @xmath53 , obtaining @xmath54 . notice that @xmath52 as a function of the reduced temperature is material dependent , although @xmath30 is not . the quantities @xmath13 and @xmath14 are also included . we notice that unit conversion is not direct , but achieved through a multiplicative factor @xmath8 : since the dimension of the scalar field in g - l theory is @xmath55=l^{-3}$ ] , its square representing a density , while in field theory @xmath56=l^{-1}$ ] , the dimensionality of @xmath46 depends of the theory at hand . for comparison sake , we have chosen @xmath57 = l^{-1}$ ] . hence , the definition of @xmath46 is changed with respect to the free energy potential of eq . ( [ 3pot ] ) , through a convenient @xmath8 factor ; the electron mass determines the conversion as it is absent from the kinetic term of the lagrangean density of field theory , @xmath58 , but present in the corresponding condensed matter free energy term , @xmath59 ; equivalently , one can loook at the coherence length : @xmath60 _ vs. _ @xmath61 . according to ref . @xcite , in the absence of an applied magnetic field , momentum fluctuations of the gauge field have an expectation value derived from the equipartition theorem . integrating over momentum space ( with a cutoff @xmath62 of the order of @xmath63 ) , one gets a^2_= 4 _ 0 t_c - 8 _ 0 e c t_c || . [ meangauge ] hence , from this result arises , asides from an unimportant correction to the scalar field mass ( or coherence length ) , a more relevant ( negative ) cubic term , @xmath64 . at zero field , this produces a shift in the superheating temperature of _ t = 7.25 10 ^ -12 t_c^3 h_c(0)^2 _ 0 ^ 6 , [ deltat ] with @xmath65 expressed in _ gauss _ and @xmath18 in @xmath66 . for sn , it requires a temperature sensitivity of @xmath67 , well below current possibilities . al , however , requires just a sensitivity of @xmath68 , attainable if one employs state of the art relative temperature measurement techniques . one can see that , for both materials , the slopes of @xmath46 predicted by tft and ref . @xcite have similar magnitudes @xmath69 . this is a confirmation of the underlying analogous mechanisms : one can view the thermal averaging of the gauge field in condensed matter as equivalent to finite temperature vacuum polarization , given by renormalization of 1-loop feynmann diagrams . we now discuss possible implications of the presence of this cubic term in the mean - field potential : the k - z mechanism predicts a topological defects ( vortices ) density of @xmath70 , where @xmath71 is the characteristic time scale , given by the gorkov equation , @xmath72 is the quench time , and @xmath73 is a critical exponent . one topological defect per @xmath74 area is assumed . since the characteristic scales @xmath18 and @xmath4 are obtained by linearizing the g - l equations close to @xmath2 , thus neglecting the @xmath46-cubic and @xmath14-quartic terms contribution , we expect no significant changes to @xmath18 and , hence , to this prediction . the defect density predicted by the h - r mechanism for a thin slab of width @xmath75 is given by @xmath76 , where @xmath77 is the domain size after the transition and is related to the highest wave number @xmath78 to fall out of equilibrium . this is obtained from the adiabaticity relation = ^2(k ) . [ dispersion ] for an underdamped dispersion relation , one has @xmath79 and the photon mass is given by @xmath80 . this leads to a defect prediction @xmath81 . recall that the penetration length @xmath4 expresses a non - null photon `` mass '' arising from the spontaneous symmetry breaking that occurs during the normal - to - superconductor phase transition . the presence of a cubic term in the potential will change the photon mass , as the true vacuum of the broken phase shifts to = -3 + 4 . [ field ] however , since @xmath82 , the effect is , as in the k - z case , too small to affect the h - r prediction in a significant way . there is also a non - vanishing probability of the order parameter to quantum tunnel from the false vacuum towards the true one . the rate of transition per unit volume and time is given , in the thin wall approximation , @xcite = t^4(s_3 2 t)^3/2e^-s_3/t . [ decayingrate ] s_3(t ) = 281 1 ^7 ^9(t ) ^2(t ) [ thinwall ] is the euclidean action , and @xmath83 the depth " of the true vacuum . for the thin wall approximation to be valid , one assumes that the barrier s height is much greater than this `` depth '' @xmath84 , which implies that @xmath46 is comparable to @xmath10 and @xmath14 , that is , @xmath85 . since , as shown above , the current temperature sensitivity of @xmath86 only allows for @xmath87 , the approximation breaks : the field should always tunnel through the potential barrier , that is , with a probability close to unity . therefore , topological defect production is unsuppressed , and one does not need to be concerned that these may not have sufficient time to nucleate within the measurement s resolution time . in this work we have examined a description of a type - i superconductive phase transition including a cubic term in the g - l mean - field potential , inspired both by analogy with tft 1-loop corrections and gauge field thermal averaging @xcite . superheating field and temperature constraints impose bounds on this cubic term so that its effects are small compared to that of other parameters in the g - l potential . in particular , there is negligible impact on the defect density predictions of k - z @xcite or h - r @xcite , with no suppression or slowing down of defect production due to nucleation suppression arising from the induced potential barrier between false and true vacua . in the absence of any sizeable perturbations , the h - r prediction for topological defect density in type - i superconductors should be reduced by a factor of @xmath88 . however , it has been suggested that defects nucleated in type - i materials survive significantly longer than in type - ii @xcite : for type - i superconductors , their lifetime is expected to be of order @xmath89 seconds . this increases the possibility of measuring the created defects before they disappear , possibly compensating for an inferior net number . finally , we point out that the superheating temperature shift induced by a cubic term , derived either from ref . @xcite or from tft 1-loop corrections , increases with decreasing @xmath22 ( @xmath90 ; @xmath91 ) . thus , possible searches for a cubic term should be conducted with extreme ( @xmath92 ) type - i materials like @xmath10-tungsten , which displays @xmath93 , @xmath94 . also , much more precise bounds could be attained by using a dc squid to measure the shift in the supercritical field , since this device currently possesses a sensitivity of @xmath95 , or @xmath96 over a 10 @xmath97 m grain diameter . this talk was presented at the coslab workshop `` cosmological phase transitions and topological defects '' , which took place in 22 - 24 may 2003 , at porto , portugal . the author thanks the organisers for their hospitality , and also tom girard and orfeu bertolami for remarks and helpful discussion . the work was supported by grants praxis/10033/98 and cern/40128/00 of the portuguese fundao para a cincia e tecnologia . jp is sponsored by the fundao para a cincia e tecnologia under the grant bd 6207/2001 . `` superconductive applications : squids and machines '' , b.b . schwartz , s. foner , eds . ( plenum , new york , 1977 ) ; `` low temperature techniques '' , a.c . rose - innes ( english universities press , london , 1964 ) . experimentally , @xmath98 $ ] . @xmath84 depends on whether the superconductor is strong or weakly coupled : b. muhlschlegel , ( 1959 ) 313 ; moreover , the leading @xmath99 is only the first term in a general expansion of @xmath100 in @xmath22 : a.j . dolgert , s.j . dibartolo , a.t . dorsey , ( 1996 ) 5650 .

in this work we address the impact of a cubic term addition to the ginzburg - landau mean - field potential , and study the consequences on the description of first order phase transitions in superconductors . constraints are obtained from experiment and used to assess consequences on topological defect creation . no fundamental changes in either the kibble - zurek or hindmarsh - rajantie predictions are found . 0.5 cm 0.2 cm 0.2 cm 0.5 cm

1003.3378

quantum dots ( qds ) have played a prominent role in the investigation of the kondo problem physics in recent years , @xcite as they allow a systematic and well - controlled variation of structure parameters , with the consequent exploration of electronic correlations in this paramount many - body state . this exploration is of course possible by being able to experimentally tune the relevant parameters in the system over rather wide ranges . moreover , in a feature that is unique to these systems , qds also facilitate the incorporation and study of quantum coherence effects in the kondo state , and its interplay with structure resonances and field - induced phase shifts . in fact , the kondo effect has been studied in multi - quantum dot systems , including double,@xcite and triple dots , @xcite in different geometrical arrangements , motivated in part by the richness of the kondo physics in the presence of localized levels , as well as by their potential application as spin filters . one of the main signatures of the kondo state is the enhancement of the quasi - particle density of states at the fermi level ; this kondo resonance is accessible in electronic transport experiments , as it opens an additional transport channel , which is readily seen in the differential conductance of these structures ( typically in the zero - bias limit ) . in the case of multiple qd geometries , the kondo and other single - particle like resonances provide different transport channels which can even interfere with one another . as a result , these structures offer the interesting possibility of controlling the transport properties by exploiting quantum interference in the electronic propagation , allowing the study of scattering phenomena such as the well - known fano @xcite and aharonov - bohm effects,@xcite competing with the kondo effect . for example , the interference of kondo and fano resonances in suitably designed structures has been shown recently in beautiful experiments , giving rise to complex conductance features.@xcite these results demonstrate that consideration of multiple coherent scattering of traveling electronic waves , both through single - particle as well as many - body resonances , is crucial for the understanding of the resulting conductance features . in this regard , being able to tune the structure parameters of a multiple qd system , as well as its kondo state , provides a unique arena to study correlations and coherence effects in a controllable manner . it is clear that the features of the kondo resonance near the fermi level significantly affect the conductance of the system , sometimes in quite subtle ways . for example , the shape of the density of states in the leads near the fl has been shown to produce strong modifications of the kondo resonance and characteristic energy ( the kondo temperature ) . these modifications can arise from intrinsic global properties,@xcite or from the local environment in the vicinity of the active qd.@xcite we are here especially interested in resonances and modifications due to the electronic version of the dicke effect . @xcite the latter is the electronic analogue of the well - known dicke effect in quantum optics , which takes place in the spontaneous emission of closely - linked atoms lying in the same environment ( within one characteristic wavelength of each other).@xcite in the electronic case , the decay rates ( level broadenings ) are produced by the couplings between localized levels and a conduction channel , and their close proximity and effective coupling gives rise to effectively fast ( _ super - tunneling _ ) and slow ( _ sub - tunneling _ ) modes.@xcite interestingly , this coherent single - particle physics results in strong changes of the kondo screening , as we will discuss below , once coulomb interactions are fully taken into account . although other multidot geometries would exhibit similar physics , a specific configuration to study this effect consists of three qds where two large ( essentially non - interacting ) dots are attached laterally to a central dot that is embedded between current leads , as schematically shown in fig . this cross - bar structure is reminiscent of quantum wave guides with a resonator cavity . @xcite in our case , the side qds act as scattering centers to the main transport channel , and compete with the kondo effect of the central dot.@xcite similar configurations have been studied before , and recent work by trocha and barnas using a slave boson mean field approach has identified interesting regimes.@xcite they studied the interplay between kondo and dicke resonances and considered the limit of infinite coulomb repulsion ( @xmath1 ) , which suppresses virtual processes involving the doubly occupied state in the interacting dot . additionally , the mean - field approximation adopted in the auxiliary boson fields neglects correlations due to charge fluctuations involving the empty state of the dot . all of these processes may be expected to be important in providing a full description of the kondo resonance , especially in competition with the dicke effect here , as we indeed show in this work . our numerical renormalization group ( nrg ) approach , @xcite provides a reliable description that incorporates all charge and spin fluctuations in the problem , it allows the study of finite @xmath0 values corresponding to real qd experiments and gives us a systematic way to study the subtle interference effects inherent in this geometry . in this work , we explore the kondo state that appears when the levels of the non - interacting dots are brought together both symmetrically and asymmetrically about the fermi level . in both situations , the kondo resonance narrows drastically and is `` squeezed '' between the two single - particle levels , suggesting a drop in the kondo temperature of the system , as described recently in the symmetric case.@xcite we show that indeed the kondo temperature drops , as the onset of the dicke effect involving the interacting dot totally suppresses the kondo state and results in _ vanishing _ kondo temperature . this behavior , due to the enhancement of spin - spin correlations in the qds orbitals , results in the formation of a _ local _ singlet , which decouples from the current leads . as the system moves away from a fully degenerate dicke configuration , the kondo temperature is non - zero but has a non - monotonic dependence on structure parameters , behavior which is only brought out by our numerical renormalization group approach . this optimization of the kondo effect in a structure may have interesting applications in a real experimental system . we will further show that the competition of kondo and dicke effects modifies excited states near the kondo regime as well , resulting in unexpected changes in the thermodynamic and transport properties of the system . interestingly , the local ( non - kondo ) singlet state mentioned above emerges due to a strong coupling between the interacting qd and the super - tunneling state . a crossover between these two configurations can be tuned by varying the coupling between the qds . we also describe the effects of asymmetries in the system , including different interdot couplings , as well as energy levels and finite coulomb interactions in all the dots of the structure . we show that these structural asymmetries introduce interesting particle - hole asymmetries in the problem , resulting in strong changes in the kondo temperatures and the linear conductance of the system . the system consists of an interacting qd ( labeled qd1 ) coupled to two current leads ( @xmath2 and @xmath3 ) and to two effectively non - interacting qds ( qd2 and qd3 ) ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) ; one could also think of qd2 and qd3 as being close to a coulomb blockade peak , so that they conduct and their behavior is single - resonance like , as charging effects are typically small when conducting . the three - dot structure is described by a multi - impurity anderson hamiltonian , @xmath4 , with @xmath5 , \\ h_{leads}&=&\sum _ { { k\sigma } , \ell = r , l } \varepsilon_{\ell k}c^\dagger_{\ell k\sigma } c_{\ell k\sigma } \\ h_t&=&v\sum_{\ell k\sigma \atop \sigma}\left[c^\dagger_{1\sigma}c_{\ell k\sigma}+h.c.\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath6 ( @xmath7 ) is the operator that creates ( annihilates ) an electron with energy @xmath8 ( @xmath9 ) and spin @xmath10 in the respective qd and @xmath11 is the corresponding fermion operator for the leads @xmath12 , with energy @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the momentum quantum number of the free conduction electrons . the second term in eq . ( [ h_dots ] ) accounts for the coulomb repulsion in the doubly occupied state of the dots . the hopping amplitudes @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 couple the interacting qd1 to the leads and to qd2 and qd3 , respectively . for simplicity , unless stated otherwise ( see sec . [ phasym ] ) , we will take @xmath18 , and @xmath19 , while @xmath20 . the characteristic properties of the kondo physics of the system will be probed through thermodynamic quantities , namely the local magnetic moment and its contribution to the entropy , which can be readily obtained from the nrg procedure . to calculate dynamical quantities , such as the spectral functions and the conductance of the system , one needs to calculate the local retarded green s function ( gf ) at the interacting dot , which is defined in the standard form , @xmath21 where @xmath22 , and @xmath23_+\rangle\end{aligned}\ ] ] is the double - time green s function , with @xmath24 the usual step function , and @xmath25_+$ ] the anticommutator . once @xmath26 is known , the spectral function @xmath27 [ or density of states ( dos ) ] of the interacting dot can be obtained from the relation @xmath28.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the non - interacting limit ( @xmath29 ) the gf @xmath30 can be easily obtained by the equation - of - motion method , leading to an exact closed expression , @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the self - energy in the non - interacting case , which takes into account the effects of the qd1 contacts with the leads , and with qd2 and qd3 . the self - energy can be written as @xmath33 in these expressions , the frequency @xmath34 must be understood in its analytical continuation sense , @xmath35 , where @xmath36 is an infinitesimal . notice that the poles at @xmath37 and @xmath38 appearing in the self - energy describe localized states in the effective conduction band due to the presence of qd2 and qd3 . in the limit of @xmath39 , the self - energy reduces to the single impurity case , @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the hybridization function for a flat density of states , and @xmath42 is the half - bandwidth of the conduction electrons . notice that the effect of the leads and the two side - coupled qds is fully taken into account in eq . ( [ green0 ] ) by the self - energy @xmath43 , which provides a structured " effective conduction band . the electrons localized in qd1 are then coupled via the effective density of states in the leads represented by @xmath44 in eq . ( [ eqs ] ) . the spectral function , @xmath45 in this _ non - interacting case _ is depicted in fig . [ fig12 ] for @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 and different values of @xmath49 . we observe that by increasing @xmath49 the width of the central peak increases , while the satellite peaks are just slightly shifted away from the fermi level . the shift of the satellite peak position can be estimated by analyzing the poles of @xmath50 . assuming the satellite peaks to be lorentzian - shaped , we find that their positions are given by @xmath51 . in the inset we show the peak positions as function of @xmath49 . the continuous ( black ) curve corresponds to the analytical expression @xmath52 , while symbols correspond to the values obtained from the curves in the main panel . the need for the factor 1.01 results from the assumption that the peak has a lorentzian shape in the analytical estimate . on the other hand , close to zero energy ( @xmath53 ) and for small detuning ( @xmath54 ) , the dos can be written as a superposition of a symmetric fano lineshape arising from the super - tunneling dicke state of width @xmath55 , and a lorentzian line arising from the subtunneling state of width @xmath56 , respectively.@xcite this complex behavior of the dos is due to the hybridization of the lateral dots through the continuum of the central dot and leads . this phenomenon is in close analogy to the dicke effect in quantum optics.@xcite here , the super - tunneling and subtunneling modes give rise a broad ( @xmath57 ) antiresonance and a sharp ( @xmath58 ) resonance , respectively . as we will discuss later , this effect also modifies dramatically the many - body kondo state . we will now consider the interesting case of interactions in the central dot only , so that @xmath59 is finite , while @xmath60 . in this case , the system can also be mapped into a single qd coupled to an effective conduction band . in this case the dressed gf of the interacting dot can be formally written as : @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the proper self - energy which takes into account the influence of the lateral qds , the current leads , as well as the coulomb repulsion @xmath0 . unlike the non - interacting case , a closed expression for @xmath62 is not possible , due to the many - body term in the hamiltonian . however , @xmath26 can be reliably obtained using the nrg procedure.@xcite for convenience , we write the gf in the lehmann representation,@xcite @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the partition function in the canonical ensemble , @xmath65 is an eigenstate of the hamiltonian @xmath66 , with corresponding eigenenergy @xmath67 , and @xmath68 . the imaginary part of @xmath26 is calculated at zero temperature ( @xmath69 ) directly from the nrg spectrum , @xcite while the real part can be obtained from a kramers - krnig transformation.@xcite as we will see in the next section , it is also useful to analyze the details of the states involving the three qds , considering the system as a whole . this approach also proves essential when dealing with coulomb interactions in all three qds , as the approach of an effective density of states described in the previous section , is no longer applicable in the more general case . to that end , we solve the problem considering all the dots composing the impurity region , " so that the three - dot cluster is coupled to a flat conduction band . this requires a simple generalization of the nrg procedure : start with a cluster impurity described by a set of 64 basis states , on which one writes and diagonalizes the initial hamiltonian , @xmath70 , while the current lead is characterized by a flat density of states . for these nrg cluster impurity " runs , we typically keep 1600 states and use a discretization parameter @xmath71 , which provides sufficient accuracy for the spectral function in the scales of interest . hereafter , we set @xmath72 ( typically the largest energy scale of the problem ) as our energy unit . we further consider the coulomb repulsion @xmath73 , and @xmath74 , which corresponds to a particle - hole symmetric system with interactions in qd1 . in order to study the dicke effect in this system we first focus on the particle - hole symmetric point _ of the entire system . _ to this end , we tune the on - site energies @xmath37 and @xmath38 of the non - interacting qds ( @xmath75 ) symmetrically displaced from the fermi level , for which we set @xmath76 . with this choice of parameters , the last term of eq . ( [ sigma ] ) shows two poles located at @xmath77 , which produce strong enhancement of the effective coupling @xmath78 . this results in a dramatic distortion of the local interacting dos projected in qd1 , @xmath79 , with important implications on the properties of the system . we first fix @xmath49 ( @xmath80 ) and vary the interdot coupling @xmath81 . figure [ fig2 ] shows @xmath82 ( @xmath83 in eq . [ rho1eq ] ) , for several values of @xmath81 . the solid ( black ) curve shows the case @xmath84 , which corresponds to the typical case of a qd coupled to a conduction band with a flat density of states . notice the kondo resonance at the fermi level in addition to the two hubbard peaks at @xmath85 ( see inset ; which give rise to coulomb blockade peaks in the conductance at appropriate gate voltages ) . the width of the kondo peak is proportional to the kondo temperature , which in this case is @xcite @xmath86 . as @xmath81 increases , the low - energy structure of @xmath87 is strongly modified . two satellite peaks emerge symmetrically about the central peak at @xmath88 . these peaks become more pronounced for larger @xmath81 and the distance between them increases somewhat more than @xmath89 , as one would expect from the non - interacting regime . the widths of the satellite peaks increase as @xmath81 increases , similarly to the non - interacting case , where their width is given by @xmath90 . notice also fano antiresonances in @xmath91 between the central and satellite peaks , located at @xmath92 . these antiresonances result from destructive interference between the kondo state of qd1 and the localized levels in the lateral qds.@xcite we will discuss this point in greater detail below . it is interesting to notice that the central kondo resonance peak width shows a non - monotonic dependence on @xmath81 , first increasing with @xmath81 , but decreasing after a particular value . this behavior , first identified in ref . from the slave boson approximation , suggests that the kondo temperature has a similar behavior , although this suspicion was not explicitly verified . using nrg , we find indeed that to be the case . in fig . [ tk](a ) we show @xmath93 as function of @xmath81 for @xmath94 , and obtain a clearly convex curve with a maximum value ( @xmath95 ) at @xmath96 , in agreement with the behavior seen in the kondo resonance in fig . we should emphasize that @xmath93 for @xmath97 is _ larger _ than for the isolated qd1 , @xmath98 ( see value above ) . the zero - energy resonance also depends strongly on @xmath49 . figure [ fig5 ] shows @xmath87 for @xmath99 and several values of @xmath49 . notice that all curves show well - defined peaks and their positions remain nearly constant at either @xmath100 or @xmath101 . however , the dips between the kondo and the satellite peaks are less pronounced for larger @xmath49 , and their position shifts with @xmath49 , as can also be seen in the inset . the displacement of the dips toward the fermi level as @xmath49 decreases produces a squeezing " of the kondo peak at the fermi energy . the most evident situation shown in fig . [ fig5 ] is the case of @xmath102 , when the kondo resonance takes the form of a narrow and sharp peak . the behavior of @xmath93 with @xmath49 is shown in fig . [ tk](b ) , and it is clearly non - monotonic as well . notice that for @xmath10305 we find a maximum value of @xmath104 at @xmath105 . more importantly , the `` squeezing '' of the kondo resonance as @xmath106 is accompanied by a strong suppression of @xmath93 , which vanishes completely as @xmath107 . the above behavior is a clear signal of the influence of the subtunneling mode on the kondo state . indeed , one can understand these results in terms of the dicke state physics . for small values of @xmath49 , the subtunneling dicke state dominates and the kondo temperature decreases . for sufficiently large values of @xmath49 the supertunneling dicke state dominates and the kondo temperature reaches its maximum value . for larger @xmath49 values , however , the system goes out of the dicke regime and the kondo temperature drops . @xcite we should also comment that the total suppression of the kondo screening for @xmath108 is essentially a quantum phase transition , which results in the qd cluster isolating itself from the current leads . perhaps one way to view this suppression of kondo screening is to think of a kondo resonance in the central dot that interferes destructively with the single - particle like resonances of the side - connected dots ( themselves hybridized with the leads via the central dot ) . the fact that all these resonances appear at the same energy , @xmath88 , results in the eventual suppression of the kondo state for the entire cluster . of course , this is only a qualitative argument , ultimately validated by the nrg results . the underlying physical mechanism for this destructive interference and resulting ground state is fascinating , as we proceed to describe . to provide a different perspective on the suppression of the kondo screening ( and vanishing kondo temperature ) , we study the thermodynamical properties of the system , namely the contribution of the impurity to the magnetic moment , @xmath109 , and the entropy , @xmath110 , from which one extracts information about the nature of the states the system visits when the parameters are varied . as usual , @xmath111 and @xmath112 , where @xmath113 and @xmath114 ( with @xmath115 ) are thermodynamical quantities of the system calculated _ with _ and _ without _ impurity , respectively . the magnetic moment and the entropy can be written in terms of the magnetic susceptibility and the partition function as @xmath116 , and @xmath117 ( we set @xmath118 ) . in order to study the effects of all three dots , we employ here the cluster impurity " approach described in sec . [ cia ] . figures [ fig3](a ) and [ fig4](a ) show , respectively , @xmath109 and @xmath110 as function of the nrg iteration energy ( temperature @xmath119 ) for several values of @xmath81 and @xmath49 . before engaging in the discussion of the more complicated situations , lets us examine the result for @xmath120 ( small open circles , purple ) , corresponding to a single impurity case , as qd2 and qd3 have their level at the fermi energy ( @xmath121 ) but are decoupled from the rest of the system ( @xmath84)we include this curve as a reference for the more general cases . for @xmath122 , all the curves show convergence to @xmath123 and @xmath124 , resulting from the free orbital ( fo ) fixed point of the system . as @xmath125 , dq1 undergoes a crossover into a kondo singlet state and its magnetic moment is screened by the conduction band , while qd2 and qd3 remain in their free orbital states ( since @xmath126 and @xmath121 ) , resulting in a net unscreened magnetic moment of @xmath127 and entropy @xmath128 for the three - dot cluster . for @xmath129 , different regimes can be found . in the low temperature limit ( @xmath130 ) the system always flows into a kondo state , where qd1 is in a kondo singlet configuration with the reservoirs , while qd2 and qd3 are combined into a symmetric / antisymmetric pair of states , one of which is doubly occupied ( and the other empty ) at @xmath69 , as schematically shown in fig . [ transf](a ) . this situation is characterized by a magnetic moment completely screened by the conduction band ( @xmath131 ) and with entropy @xmath132 , as shown by all curves in fig . [ fig3 ] and [ fig4 ] . other interesting situations occur when @xmath133 . @xcite for @xmath134 , the physics can still be understood in terms of the local orbitals , in which case ( since @xmath135 ) qd2 and qd3 are still locked in one doubly - occupied and one empty state . in contrast , qd1 is in the magnetic moment regime , contributing alone to the magnetic moment @xmath136 and to the entropy @xmath137 . when @xmath138 , however , the system goes into a more intricate configuration of local molecular orbitals . this is better understood in terms of symmetric ( super - tunneling ) and anti - symmetric ( sub - tunneling ) combination of the qd2 and qd3 local orbitals , defined as @xmath139 where @xmath140 and @xmath141 annihilate an electron in the bonding and anti - bonding orbital , respectively , with energy @xmath142 ( for @xmath76 as before ) . with this transformation , the hamiltonian of the dots reads @xmath143\nonumber\\ & & -\delta \sum_{\sigma}\left[c^\dagger_{+\sigma}c_{-\sigma } + h.c.\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the transformed system is schematically represented in fig . [ transf](b ) . note that the orbital `` @xmath144 '' and `` @xmath145 '' are coupled to each other by a matrix element @xmath146 and only the orbital @xmath144 " couples to the qd1 via matrix element @xmath147 . on this transformed basis we can provide a more intuitive analysis of the thermodynamic quantities as follows . for @xmath133 and @xmath148 the configuration of the system is represented in fig . [ transf](c ) , where the qd1 orbital couples to the `` @xmath144 '' orbital to form a local singlet " ( essentially decoupled from the leads ) , while the `` @xmath145 '' orbital remains almost free ( since @xmath149 ) . the contribution to the magnetic moment and entropy is then provided solely by the `` @xmath145 '' orbital , resulting in @xmath136 and @xmath150 , as clearly seen in the curves with ( blue ) square symbols in fig . [ fig3](a ) and [ fig4](a ) . we should notice that the two curves for @xmath84 ( for @xmath121 and @xmath94)in each of the ( a ) panels of both figures are identical for temperatures @xmath151 , since for high @xmath119 the qd2 and qd3 levels at @xmath152 are thermally accessible ( which is no longer the case when @xmath153 ) . in fig . [ fig3](b ) and [ fig4](b ) we fix @xmath154 and plot the magnetic moment and entropy for different values of @xmath49 . for @xmath155 , the situation described above is favored , but when @xmath156 , the plateaus in the susceptibility and entropy shift towards the curves with empty ( black ) circles of panel ( a ) in the respective figures . the system is then returning to the situation when the local orbitals are described independently , as shown in fig . [ transf](d ) . notice the kondo singlet is not yet formed at these high temperatures ( @xmath157 ) . these results reveal the establishment of a local antiferromagneticaly correlated state , involving orbitals @xmath158 and `` @xmath144 '' , emerging at temperatures above @xmath93 . in order to provide more evidence of the local singlet between qd1 and the `` @xmath144 '' orbital , fig . [ correlation ] depicts the spin - spin correlation value @xmath159 ( top panel ) ; the correlation with the `` @xmath145 '' orbital , @xmath160 is shown in the bottom panel , as function of temperature for various values of @xmath81 . notice that @xmath161 is always negative ( antiferromagnetic ) and has increasingly negative values for larger @xmath81 . in contrast , the correlation between the spin in qd1 and in the `` @xmath145 '' orbital is an order of magnitude weaker , and totally vanishes for large @xmath81 . it is interesting to notice that although the local correlation with the `` @xmath144 '' orbital is large , it does not fully exhaust the anticipated singlet correlation of @xmath162 , even for the larger @xmath81 values , where it seems to saturate at @xmath163 . in a typical experimental situation , asymmetry in the structure parameters is more likely to occur . it is therefore of interest to analyze the stability and behavior of the results discussed above with respect to changes that more generally make the problem particle - hole asymmetric . we introduce asymmetry parameters @xmath164 and @xmath165 that allow for @xmath166 , and @xmath167 , respectively as : @xmath168 and @xmath169 where the positive ( negative ) sign in the expressions above corresponds to the index @xmath170 . the fully symmetric situation previously described corresponds obviously to the case @xmath171 . we first allow for asymmetry in the couplings to the side dots ; fig . [ fig9 ] shows the results for weakly asymmetric couplings @xmath16 and @xmath17 for different values of @xmath49 . the top ( bottom ) panel shows the case of @xmath172 ( @xmath173 ) . the asymmetry in the couplings results in a shift of the central peak away from the fermi level , as well as its strong suppression ( compare with fig . [ fig5 ] ) . this effect is less pronounced for larger values of @xmath49 . notice , for instance , that for @xmath102 the central peak is almost completely suppressed . also , comparing the curves in the top and bottom panels , we observe that for a given @xmath49 the shift and suppression of the peak is larger as @xmath164 increases . in fig . [ fig10 ] we fix @xmath94 and @xmath174 ( symmetric couplings to central dot ) , and show the spectral function as function of energy for two values of @xmath165 and different values of @xmath81 . in the top ( bottom ) panel we have @xmath175 ( @xmath176 ) . we notice that for small @xmath81 ( for instance @xmath177 ) , there is a strong distortion in the spectral function near the fermi level for both values of @xmath165 . however this distortion is much weaker when @xmath81 increases , so that for @xmath178 and @xmath179 , the asymmetry in the spectral function is nearly absent . one would expect , from seeing these results for the spectral functions , that the particle - hole asymmetry in the system would introduce non - monotonic changes in the kondo temperature . in fig . [ tksa ] we illustrate this point . panel ( b ) shows the associated kondo temperature for the system parameters of fig . [ fig9]a , where the coupling to the side dots is asymmetric ( with a value of @xmath172 ) . as suggested by the increasing width of the zero - energy peak in fig . [ fig9]a , @xmath93 increases with @xmath49 , reestablishing the kondo state that was absent in the full dicke regime ( for @xmath108 ) , while larger values eventually reduce @xmath93 , although _ not to zero_. similarly , the asymmetry in side dot level location illustrated in fig . [ fig10]a , results in a rapid increase of @xmath93 with @xmath180 , shown in panel ( a ) , so that the system has an order of magnitude larger kondo temperature for @xmath181 , before dropping for larger @xmath180 values . an additional important source of particle - hole asymmetry is the bare level position of qd1 . in order to explore how it affects our results , we allow the level @xmath182 to be different from @xmath183 . for convenience , we keep @xmath184 and change @xmath0 , which allows not only to explore the effect of the particle - hole asymmetry but also the effect of larger values of @xmath0 . figure [ fig11 ] shows the spectral function vs. energy for @xmath94 and various values of @xmath0 . the curve for @xmath73 , corresponding to the symmetric case studied in sec . [ symmetric ] , exhibits two peaks symmetrically placed about the fermi level , as well as hubbard bands located near @xmath182 and @xmath185 , as can be seen in the inset of the figure . as @xmath0 increases , one clearly observes that the curves no longer display particle - hole symmetry . we observe a decreasing height of the central peak , as well as a minor shift in position , while its width remains almost unchanged with increasing @xmath0 . more interesting , we notice that the satellite peak below the fermi level is suppressed and shifted toward @xmath88 , while the corresponding peak on the positive side is nearly unchanged . this is a clear consequence of breaking particle - hole symmetry in the problem . we have also investigated the role of non - vanishing coulomb interactions in the side dots qd2 and qd3 . to that effect , the problem is addressed using nrg for the three quantum dot complex treated as a cluster impurity , as described in sec . [ cia ] , and with the inclusion of a non - zero coulomb interaction @xmath186 . figure [ uprime ] presents the spectral function for different values of @xmath187 , for qd2 and qd3 levels placed asymmetrically about the fermi level ( @xmath94 ) . for @xmath75 the system is particle - hole symmetric ( as @xmath74 ) , as also shown in fig . [ fig2 ] . for increasing @xmath187 , however , the asymmetry in the spectral function is evident , strongly shifting and suppressing the kondo resonance near the fermi level . this indicates the important role that coulomb interactions in the nearby dots have in the overall correlations present in the system , and suggests that the observation of the dicke effect is indeed a delicate undertaking . we now turn our attention to the effect on the conductance of the system of the various features discussed above . it is clear that the details of the density of states at the fermi level are directly connected to the zero - temperature transport properties in linear response . in the zero - bias limit , the conductance of the system can be obtained by the landauer formula , @xmath188\left ( \partial f(\omega)/\partial \omega\right)d \omega$ ] , where @xmath189 is the fermi distribution function and , in the present case , @xmath190 . at @xmath69 the conductance reduces to @xmath191 . from the density of states in fig . [ fig2 ] and [ fig5 ] we observe that for all values of @xmath81 and @xmath192 , the dos always exhibits a kondo peak at the fermi level ( which becomes very narrow and sharp as @xmath106 ) . since the conductance of the system is proportional to the density of states of dq1 , this results in unitary conductance ( @xmath193 ) for all values of @xmath81 and @xmath192 , discontinuously dropping to zero at @xmath121 . the above behavior is explained by the complete localization of the subtunneling state for @xmath121 . in this case the state has no projection on the central quantum dot and therefore it does not contribute to the conduction . similarly , one would expect vanishing conductance for small bias as long as @xmath121 . @xcite an interesting result of the particle - hole asymmetry , as we have seen in the previous section , is to shift the kondo resonance away from the fermi level , as well as to change its amplitude . this has direct impact on the linear conductance of the structure . figure [ figlast ] illustrates this behavior for different asymmetries ( notice in fact that although @xmath164 and @xmath165 are constant in this figure , increasing @xmath180 or @xmath49 value increases the asymmetry of the structure ) . in both cases , the conductance is indeed found to change drastically with the appropriate parameter . it is interesting that asymmetry in the qd2 and qd3 level position ( for @xmath175 ) and increasing dot coupling @xmath180 results in a strong suppression of the linear conductance , even as the kondo temperature of the system ( fig . [ tksa]a ) is _ increasing_. on the other hand , the enhancement of @xmath93 that we see for the coupling asymmetry ( @xmath172 ) in fig . [ tksa]b , does produce a rapid increase in conductance for larger @xmath49 values . in summary , we have investigated the interplay of dicke and kondo effects in a central strongly interacting quantum dot coupled to a conduction band and two localized levels provided by additional nearly non - interacting dots . we study in detail the kondo regime of the system , by applying a numerical renormalization group analysis to a finite-@xmath0 multi - impurity anderson hamiltonian model . we find that the system displays a squeezed " kondo resonance as we tune the single particle levels of the side - coupled dots toward the fermi level . in the strict dicke limit of degenerate single - particle levels , the kondo singlet disappears , as its kondo temperature vanishes . this behavior is found to be closely related to the formation of a local singlet state involving the ( coupled ) orbitals of the interacting dot and the super - tunneling state ( the symmetric combination of the single particle levels of the two side coupled dots ) . this local singlet results in the suppression of the kondo screening , which is detrimental to the conductance of the system . we have further explored the consequences of system asymmetries , introduced by different couplings , level locations and coulomb interactions . these are found to strongly affect the spectral density and the conductance through the structure . we believe that our study not only clarifies the relevant picture of an interacting system coupled to side quantum dots and conduction band , but it also provides important guidelines for experimental realization of these ideas . we thank helpful discussions with n. sandler and g. b. martins and financial support from cnpq , capes , fapemig , nsf - pire , and mwn / ciam ( cnpq , conicyt , nsf - dmr ) . p.a.o acknowledges financial support from conicyt / programa bicentenario de ciencia y tecnologia ( cenava , grant act27 ) and fondecyt , under grant 1080660 . l. g. g. v. d. dias da silva , n. sandler , k. ingersent , and s. e. ulloa , phys . lett . * 97 * , 096603 ( 2006 ) ; l. g. g. v. d. dias da silva , n. sandler , p. simon k. ingersent , and s. e. ulloa , phys . rev . lett . * 102 * , 166806 ( 2009 ) .

the interplay between the coupling of an interacting quantum dot to a conduction band and its connection to localized levels has been studied in a triple quantum dot arrangement . the electronic dicke effect , resulting from quasi - resonant states of two side - coupled non - interacting quantum dots , is found to produce important effects on the kondo resonance of the interacting dot . we study in detail the kondo regime of the system by applying a numerical renormalization group analysis to a finite-@xmath0 multi - impurity anderson hamiltonian model . we find an extreme narrowing of the kondo resonance , as the single - particle levels of the side dots are tuned towards the fermi level and squeeze " the kondo resonance , accompanied by a strong drop in the kondo temperature , due to the presence of a supertunneling state . further , we show that the kondo temperature _ vanishes _ in the limit of the dicke effect of the structure . by analyzing the magnetic moment and entropy of the three - dot cluster versus temperature , we identify a different _ local _ singlet that competes with the kondo state , resulting in the eventual suppression of the kondo temperature and strongly affecting the spin correlations of the structure . we further show that system asymmetries in couplings , level structure or due to coulomb interactions , result in interesting changes in the spectral function near the fermi level . these strongly affect the kondo temperature and the linear conductance of the system .

1601.05680

the aim of this paper is to present a novel weak galerkin finite element method for solving the stationary stokes equations . let @xmath0 be a polygonal or polyhedral domain in @xmath1 . as a model for the flow of an incompressible viscous fluid confined in @xmath0 , we consider the following equations @xmath2 for unknown velocity function @xmath3 and pressure function @xmath4 ( we require that @xmath4 has zero average in order to guarantee the uniqueness of the pressure ) . bold symbols are used to denote vector- or tensor - valued functions or spaces of such functions . here @xmath5 is a body source term , @xmath6 is the kinematic viscosity and @xmath7 is a boundary condition that satisfies the compatibility condition @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the unit outward normal vector on the domain boundary @xmath10 . this problem mainly arises from approximations of low - reynolds - number flows . the finite element methods for stokes and navier@xmath11stokes problems enforce the + divergence - free property in finite element spaces , which satisfy the inf - sup ( lbb ) condition , in order for them to be numerically stable @xcite . the stokes problem has been studied with various different new numerical methods : @xcite . throughout this paper , we would follow the standard definitions for lebesgue and sobolev spaces : @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14^d$ ] , @xmath15^d=\{\bv\in [ h^1(\omega)]^d : \bv=\b0\ { \rm on}\ \partial \omega\}\ ] ] and @xmath16 are the natural spaces for the weak form of the stokes problem @xcite . denote @xmath17 for inner products in the corresponding spaces . next we assume that @xmath18 and @xmath19 . then one of the variational formulations for the stokes problem ( [ ose1])-([ose3 ] ) is to find @xmath20^d$ ] and @xmath21 such that @xmath22 for all @xmath23^d$ ] and @xmath24 . here @xmath25 denotes the velocity gradient tensor @xmath26 . it is well known that under our assumptions on the domain and the data , problem ( [ vf1])-([vf2 ] ) has a unique solution @xmath27^d\times l_0 ^ 2(\omega)$ ] . it is easy to know that the weak form ( [ vf1])-([vf2 ] ) is also equivalent to the following variational problem : find @xmath28^d\times l_0 ^ 2(\omega)$ ] such that @xmath29 for all @xmath23^d$ ] and @xmath24 . the unique solvability of ( [ vf3])-([vf4 ] ) follows directly from that of the ( [ vf1])-([vf2 ] ) . the wg method refers to a general finite element technique for partial differential equations where differential operators are approximated as distributions for generalized functions . this method was first proposed in @xcite for second order elliptic problem , then extended to other partial differential equations @xcite . weak functions and weak derivatives can be approximated by polynomials with various degrees . the wg method uses weak functions and their weak derivatives which are defined as distributions . the most prominent features of it are : * the usual derivatives are replaced by distributions or discrete approximations of distributions . * the approximating functions are discontinuous . the flexibility of discontinuous functions gives wg methods many advantages , such as high order of accuracy , high parallelizability , localizability , and easy handling of complicated geometries . the above features motivate the use of wg methods for the stokes equations . it can easily handle meshes with hanging nodes , elements of general shapes with certain shape regularity and ideally suited for hp - adaptivity . in @xcite , wang considered wg methods for ( [ vf1])-([vf2 ] ) . similarly , in @xcite , they presented wg methods for the brinkman equations , which is a model with a high - contrast parameter dependent combination of the darcy and stokes models . the numerical method of @xcite is based on the traditional gradient - divergence variational form for the brinkman equations . in @xcite , we presented a new wg scheme based on the gradient - gradient variational form . it is shown that this scheme is suit for the mixed formulation of darcy which would present a better approximation for this case . in fact , for complex porous media with interface conditions , people often use brinkman - stokes interface model to describe this problem , which is an ongoing work for us now . in order to present a more efficient wg scheme , we prefer to utilize this gradient - gradient weak form to approximate the model . in order to unify the weak form of this interface problem , we need the numerical analysis results of this form for stokes problem . however , to the best of our knowledge , the numerical analysis of methods based on the variational form ( [ vf3])-([vf4 ] ) has never been done before . therefore in this paper , we propose a wg method based on the weak form ( [ vf3])-([vf4 ] ) of the primary problem . in addition , if we choose high order polynomials to approximate the model and use schur complement to reduce the interior dof of the velocity and pressure by the boundary dof , the total dof of this new method is less than the scheme of @xcite . the rest of this paper is organized as follows . in section 2 we shall introduce some preliminaries and notations for sobolev spaces . section 3 is devoted to the definitions of weak functions and weak derivatives . the wg finite element schemes for variational form of the stokes equation ( [ vf3])-([vf4 ] ) are presented in section 4 . this section also contains some local @xmath30 projection operators and then derives some approximation properties which are useful in a convergence analysis . in section 5 , we derive an error equation for the wg finite element approximation . optimal - order error estimates for the wg finite element approximations are derived in section 6 in an @xmath31-equivalent norm for the velocity , and @xmath30 norm for both the velocity and the pressure . in section 7 , we present some numerical results which confirm the theory developed in earlier sections . finally , we present some technical estimates in the appendix for quantities related to the local @xmath30 projections into various finite element spaces . let @xmath32 be an open bounded domain with lipschitz continuous boundary in @xmath33 . we shall use standard definitions of the sobolev spaces @xmath34 and inner products @xmath35 , their norms @xmath36 , and seminorms @xmath37 , for any @xmath38 . for instance , for any integer @xmath38 , the seminorm @xmath37 is defined as @xmath39 with notations @xmath40 the sobolev norm @xmath41 is defined as @xmath42 the space @xmath43 is same as @xmath44 , whose norm and inner product are denoted by @xmath45 and @xmath46 , respectively . if @xmath47 , we would drop the subscript @xmath48 in the notations of the @xmath30 norm and the @xmath30 inner product . in this section we will define weak functions for both the vector - valued function and the scalar - valued function , also we will introduce the weak gradients and the corresponding discrete forms . let @xmath49 be a polygonal or polyhedral domain with boundary @xmath50 . a weak vector - valued function on the domain @xmath49 is defined as @xmath51 such that @xmath52^d$ ] and @xmath53^d$ ] . let @xmath54^d,\bv _ b \in [ l^2(\partial t)]^d \},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath55 is not necessarily the trace of @xmath56 . ( @xcite ) for any @xmath57 , the weak gradient of @xmath58 , denoted by @xmath59 , is defined as a linear functional in the dual space of @xmath60^{d\times d}$ ] whose action on each @xmath61^{d\times d } $ ] is given by @xmath62^{d\times d},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath9 is the outer unit normal vector to @xmath50 , @xmath63 is the @xmath30 inner product of @xmath56 and @xmath64 , and @xmath65 is the inner product of @xmath66 and @xmath55 in @xmath67^d$ ] . consider the inclusion map @xmath68^d\rightarrow v(t)$ ] defined below @xmath69^d.\ ] ] by this map the sobolev space @xmath60^d$ ] can be embedded into the space @xmath70 . with the help of map @xmath71 , the sobolev space @xmath60^d$ ] can be considered as a subspace of @xmath70 by identifying each @xmath72^d$ ] with @xmath73 . let @xmath74 be the set of polynomials on t with degree no more than @xmath75 . ( @xcite ) the discrete weak gradient operator @xmath76 is defined as follows : for each @xmath77 , @xmath78^{d\times d}$ ] is the unique element such that @xmath79^{d\times d}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we define a weak scalar - valued function on the domain @xmath49 as @xmath80 such that @xmath81 and @xmath82 . let @xmath83 where @xmath84 is not necessarily the trace of @xmath85 . ( @xcite ) for any @xmath86 , the weak gradient of @xmath87 , denote by @xmath88 , is defined as a linear functional in the dual space of @xmath60 ^ 2 $ ] whose action on each @xmath89 ^ 2 $ ] is given by @xmath90 ^ 2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath9 is the outer unit normal vector to @xmath50 , @xmath91 is the @xmath30 inner product of @xmath85 and @xmath92 , and @xmath93 is the inner product of @xmath94 and @xmath84 in @xmath95 . consider the inclusion map @xmath96 defined as follows @xmath97 by which the sobolev space @xmath98 is embedded into the space @xmath99 . with the help of map @xmath100 , the sobolev space @xmath101 can be considered as a subspace of @xmath99 by identifying each @xmath102 with @xmath103 . ( @xcite ) the discrete weak gradient operator @xmath104 is defined as follows : for each @xmath105 , @xmath106^d$ ] is the unique element such that @xmath107^d.\end{aligned}\ ] ] let @xmath108 be a partition of the domain @xmath0 into polygons in 2d or polyhedral in 3d . assume that @xmath108 is shape regular in the sense as defined in @xcite . denote by @xmath109 the set of all edges or flat faces in @xmath108 , and let @xmath110 be the set of all interior edges or flat faces . denote by @xmath111 the diameter of @xmath112 and @xmath113 the meshsize for the partition @xmath108 . for any interger @xmath114 , we define weak galerkin finite element spaces as follows : for velocity variable , let @xmath115^d\times [ p_k(e)]^d , e\subset \partial t,\bv_b=\b0 ~\rm{on}~ \partial \omega\}.\ ] ] it should be noticed that @xmath55 is single valued on each edge @xmath116 . for pressure variable , we define @xmath117 also @xmath84 is single valued on each edge @xmath116 . the discrete weak gradients @xmath118 and @xmath119 on the spaces @xmath120 and @xmath121 can be computed by the equations ( [ dwvg ] ) and ( [ dwqg ] ) on each element @xmath49 respectively , that is , @xmath122 for the sake of simplicity , we shall drop the subscripts @xmath123 and @xmath124 of @xmath118 and @xmath119 in the rest of the paper . we use the @xmath30 inner product to denote the sum of inner products on each of the elements as follows : @xmath125 for each element @xmath129 , denote by @xmath130 the @xmath30 projection operator from @xmath131^d$ ] onto @xmath132^d$ ] . for each edge or face @xmath133 , denote by @xmath134 the @xmath30 projection from @xmath135^d$ ] onto @xmath136^d$].we shall combine @xmath130 with @xmath134 as a projection onto @xmath120 , such that on each element @xmath137 @xmath138 on each element @xmath129 , denote by @xmath139 the @xmath30 projection onto @xmath140^{d\times d}$ ] . denote by @xmath141 the @xmath30 projection operator from @xmath142 onto @xmath143 . for each edge or face @xmath133 , denote by @xmath144 the @xmath30 projection from @xmath145 onto @xmath146 . we shall combine @xmath141 with @xmath144 as a projection onto space @xmath121 , such that on each element @xmath137 @xmath147 then we shall present a useful property which indicates the discrete weak gradient operators are good approximation to the gradient operators in the classical sense . now we introduce four bilinear forms as follows : @xmath149 using these bilinear forms we define the following two norms . for any @xmath150 and @xmath151 , @xmath152 and @xmath153 where @xmath154 is a seminorm . it is easy to verify that @xmath155 and @xmath156 are norms in @xmath120 and @xmath121 , respectively , a numerical approximation for ( [ ose1])-([ose3 ] ) can be obtained by seeking @xmath157 and @xmath158 such that @xmath159 for all @xmath160 and @xmath151 . next we shall show that the weak galerkin finite element algorithm ( [ wf1])-([wf2 ] ) has only one solution . since the system is linear , it suffices to show that if @xmath161 , the only solution is @xmath162 . the wg finite element scheme ( [ wf1])-([wf2 ] ) has a unique solution . let @xmath161 , we shall show that the solution of ( [ wf1])-([wf2 ] ) is trivial . to this end , taking @xmath163 and @xmath164 and subtracting ( [ wf2 ] ) from ( [ wf1 ] ) we arrive at @xmath165 by the definition of @xmath166 and @xmath167 , we know @xmath168 on each @xmath137 , @xmath169 , and @xmath170 on each @xmath50 . thus @xmath171 and @xmath85 are continuous . by ( [ ifw1 ] ) and the fact that @xmath172 on @xmath50 we have , for any @xmath173^{d\times d}$ ] , @xmath174 which implies @xmath175 on each @xmath137 and thus @xmath171 is a constant . since @xmath176 on each @xmath50 and @xmath177 on @xmath178 , we arrive at @xmath179 in @xmath0 . it follows from ( [ wf1 ] ) , @xmath179 , and @xmath180 that for any @xmath126 , @xmath181 hence we have @xmath182 on each @xmath137 . thus @xmath183 is a constant in @xmath0 . from @xmath184 , we would obtain @xmath185 in @xmath0 . since @xmath186 on each @xmath50 , @xmath187 . this completes the proof of the lemma . in this section , we shall derive the error equations for the wg finite element solution we get from ( [ wf1])-([wf2 ] ) . this error equation is essential for the following analysis . now we define two bilinear forms @xmath188 for all @xmath189^d , \bv\in v_h$ ] and @xmath151 . let @xmath190 be the exact solution of ( [ ose1])-([ose3 ] ) , and @xmath191 be the solution of ( [ wf1])-([wf2 ] ) . define @xmath192 we shall derive the error equations that @xmath193 and @xmath194 satisfy . let @xmath195 and @xmath196 be the solution of the numerical scheme ( [ wf1])-([wf2 ] ) , and @xmath190 be the exact solution of ( [ ose1])-([ose3 ] ) . then , for any @xmath126 and @xmath151 we have @xmath197 first , from ( [ ifw1 ] ) and the property ( [ qcfv ] ) we obtain @xmath198 summing over all elements @xmath137 , we have @xmath199 from the commutative property ( [ qcfp ] ) we arrive at @xmath200 it follows from ( [ ifw2 ] ) that @xmath201 summing over all @xmath137 yields @xmath202 next , using @xmath56 in @xmath160 to test ( [ ose1 ] ) , we have @xmath203 integrating by parts , we obtain @xmath204 where we have used the fact that @xmath205 . using @xmath85 in @xmath206 to test ( [ ose2 ] ) , we arrive at @xmath207 using the fact that @xmath208 one has @xmath209 finally combining the equations ( [ eefa1 ] ) and ( [ eefb1 ] ) with ( [ eefa2 ] ) yields @xmath210 substituting it into ( [ wf1 ] ) , then we would have @xmath211 combining the equations ( [ eefb2 ] ) with ( [ eefc1 ] ) we arrive at @xmath212 substituting ( [ eefl1 ] ) into ( [ wf2 ] ) yields the following error equation @xmath213 for all @xmath151 , which completes the proof of ( [ ee2 ] ) . in this section we shall present the error estimates between the exact solution of ( [ ose1])-([ose3 ] ) and the numerical solution of wg finite element method ( [ wf1])-([wf2 ] ) . the two norms @xmath155 and @xmath156 are essentially @xmath31 norm and @xmath30 norm on @xmath120 and @xmath121 respectively . in this section we always assume @xmath108 is shape regular ( @xcite ) . let @xmath214 be the exact solution of ( [ ose1])-([ose3 ] ) , @xmath215 be the numerical solution of ( [ wf1])-([wf2 ] ) , then the following error estimates hold true @xmath216 and consequently , one has @xmath217 letting @xmath218 in ( [ ee1 ] ) and @xmath219 in ( [ ee2 ] ) , we would obtain @xmath220 then from ( [ iqfs])-([iqfc ] ) we arrive at @xmath221 from which we would have @xmath222 for any given @xmath223 , it follows from @xcite that there is a @xmath224^d$ ] such that @xmath225 where c is a positive constant which is dependent only on @xmath0 . let @xmath226 , we claim that the following inequality holds true @xmath227 where c is a constant . from ( [ qcfv ] ) , we have @xmath228 it follows from the definition of @xmath134 , ( [ czi1 ] ) , and ( [ ti ] ) that @xmath229 which yields @xmath230 from ( [ eefb2 ] ) , ( [ btiqfb ] ) , ( [ 1qfl3 ] ) , and the fact that @xmath231 on @xmath178 , we would obtain @xmath232 using ( [ ee1 ] ) , ( [ ereq1 ] ) , ( [ iqfs ] ) and ( [ iqfl1 ] ) , we obtain @xmath233 let @xmath58 be such that ( [ ifb ] ) is true , it follows from ( [ ifb1 ] ) that @xmath234 then ( [ ereq1 ] ) implies that @xmath235 from what we have demonstrated , one has @xmath217 we shall use the dual technique to derive the @xmath30 error . assume this problem has the @xmath236^d\times h^1(\omega)$]-regularity , then the solution @xmath237^d\times h^1(\omega)$ ] of the following equations @xmath238 satisfies the following property @xmath239 let @xmath240^d\times(l^2_0\cap h^k(\omega))$ ] be the exact solution of ( [ ose1])-([ose3 ] ) , @xmath191 be the numerical solution of ( [ wf1])-([wf2 ] ) , @xmath241 in @xmath242 then the following error estimate holds true @xmath243 since @xmath244 is the solution of ( [ eefl3])-([eefl5 ] ) , letting @xmath245 and @xmath246 in ( [ eefl2 ] ) gives @xmath247 letting @xmath248 in ( [ ee2 ] ) , we obtain @xmath249 from ( [ eefb2 ] ) and ( [ eefl4 ] ) , we arrive at @xmath250 where we have used the fact that @xmath251 taking @xmath252 in ( [ ee1 ] ) , combined with ( [ eefl8])-([eefl10 ] ) one has @xmath253 it follows from ( [ iqfs])-([iqfl1 ] ) that @xmath254 using ( [ 1qfl3])-([iqfc ] ) , we would obtain @xmath255 from the definition of @xmath134 , ( [ czi1 ] ) , ( [ czi2 ] ) , and ( [ ti ] ) , we arrive at @xmath256 it follows from the definition of @xmath134 , ( [ ti ] ) , and ( [ czi1 ] ) that @xmath257 the definition of @xmath134 together with ( [ czi1 ] ) , ( [ czi3 ] ) , and ( [ ti ] ) yields @xmath258 from the definition of @xmath134 , ( [ czi3 ] ) , and ( [ ti ] ) , we obtain @xmath259 from ( [ bt1])-([bt8 ] ) , one has @xmath260 it follows from ( [ eefl6 ] ) that @xmath261 together with ( [ ereq1 ] ) , we would have @xmath262 which completes the proof of the theorem . the goal of this section is to report some numerical results for the weak galerkin finite element method proposed and analyzed in previous sections . let @xmath190 be the exact solution of ( [ ose1])-([ose3 ] ) and @xmath263 be the numerical solution of ( [ wf1])-([wf2 ] ) . denote @xmath264 and @xmath265 the error for the weak galerkin solution is measured in four norms defined as follows : @xmath266 \displaystyle\|\be_h\|^2&=&\sum_{t\in\mathcal{t}_h } \int_t|\be_h|^2 dt , \\[1 mm ] \displaystyle|\!|\!| \varepsilon_h |\!|\!|^2_0&= & \sum_{t\in\mathcal{t}_h } \left(\int_t|\varepsilon_0|^2 dt + h_t\int_{\partial t}|\varepsilon_0- \varepsilon_b|^2 ds\right ) , \\[1 mm ] \displaystyle\|\varepsilon_h\|^2&=&\sum_{t\in\mathcal{t}_h } \int_t|\varepsilon_h|^2 dt.\end{aligned}\ ] ] * example 7.1 * consider the problem ( [ ose1])-([ose3 ] ) in the square domain @xmath267 . the wg finite element space @xmath268 is employed in the numerical discretization . it has the analytic solution @xmath269 the right hand side function @xmath5 in ( [ ose1 ] ) is computed to match the exact solution . the mesh size is denoted by @xmath270 . table 7.1 shows that the errors and convergence rates of example 7.1 in @xmath271 norm and @xmath272norm for the wg - fem solution @xmath3 are of order @xmath273 and @xmath274 when @xmath275 , respectively . table 7.2 shows that the errors and orders of example 7.1 in @xmath276norm and @xmath272norm for pressure when @xmath275 . the numerical results are also consistent with theory for these two cases . table 7.3 and 7.4 show the errors and orders of example 7.1 for the case @xmath277 , and the convergence rates coincide with the theoretical expectation . table 7.1 . numerical errors and orders for @xmath3 of example 7.1 with @xmath275 . + [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in this section , we will give some important inequalities . ( @xcite ) assume that @xmath108 , the finite element partition of @xmath0 , is shape regular . let @xmath278^d$ ] and @xmath279 with @xmath280 . then for any @xmath281 we have @xmath282 where @xmath283 is a constant which is independent of the meshsize h and the functions . ( @xcite ) let t be an element of the finite element partition @xmath108 , @xmath284 is an edge or face which is part of @xmath50 . for any function @xmath285 , the following trace inequality holds true @xmath286 it follows from the definition of @xmath134 , ( [ czi1 ] ) , and ( [ ti ] ) that @xmath290 from ( [ czi2 ] ) and ( [ ti ] ) , we would have @xmath291 using ( [ czi1 ] ) and ( [ ti ] ) , we would arrive at @xmath292 from the definition of @xmath134 and ( [ czi3 ] ) , we obtain @xmath293 now we have proved all the estimates in this lemma .

a weak galerkin ( wg ) finite element method for solving the stationary stokes equations in two- or three- dimensional spaces by using discontinuous piecewise polynomials is developed and analyzed . the variational form we considered is based on two gradient operators which is different from the usual gradient - divergence operators . the wg method is highly flexible by allowing the use of discontinuous functions on arbitrary polygons or polyhedra with certain shape regularity . optimal - order error estimates are established for the corresponding wg finite element solutions in various norms . numerical results are presented to illustrate the theoretical analysis of the new wg finite element scheme for stokes problems . weak galerkin finite element methods , weak gradient , stokes equations , polytopal meshes . primary , 65n30 , 65n15 , 65n12 , 74n20 ; secondary , 35b45 , 35j50 , 35j35

physics0505128

complex social networks arise in a wide range of contexts , for example as corporate partnership networks @xcite , scientist collaboration networks @xcite , company director networks @xcite , film actors networks @xcite , sexual contact networks @xcite , etc . indeed , a lot of attention has been given by both physical and social scientists in recent years to model these networks so as to gain better understandings of their general structures as well as their various functions like information flow @xcite , locating individuals @xcite , disease spread @xcite , etc . for a review of recent efforts , see for example @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . while there is an apparent increase in the number of network models in the literature , not all of these models have taken full advantage of the sociological and psychological insights on how social networks may be formed . the principle of _ homophily _ , or in essence `` birds of a feather flock together , '' has been firmly established by many empirical studies @xcite . while we clearly tend to befriend those who are like us , there are many situations where having a lot of friends like us is simply because we are _ stuck _ with people who are like us in the first place . for example if you are a millionaire and all your friends are millionaires , it might simply be because you were born into an elite family and live in an elite area so you only know millionaires in your life , even though you do not actively choose to befriend millionaires over non - millionaires . therefore , it is useful to divide homophily into two main types : _ baseline _ homophily and _ inbreeding _ homophily @xcite . baseline homophily is attributed to the fact that we have a _ limited potential tie pool _ due to factors like demography and foci of activities @xcite . inbreeding homophily is conceptualised as any other kind of homophily measured over that potential tie pool this may include homophily regarding gender , religion , social class , education , and other intra - personal or behavioural characteristics . while many network models have taken inbreeding homophily into account @xcite , they have generally assumed that there are no baseline homophily effects , i.e. the potential tie pool for all actors equals the _ entire _ population . however , this is obviously not very realistic and baseline homophily effects can potentially have profound consequences on the structure of social networks . a basic source of baseline homophily is the _ geographical space_. as a matter of simple opportunity and/or the need to minimise efforts to form and maintain a social tie @xcite , we can expect that we tend to form ties with those who are geographically close to us . thus , intuitively , this creates a very strong constraint on our potential tie pool . in fact , there is ample empirical evidence that demonstrates this claim . the earliest studies of which we are aware of date back to festinger _ _ @xcite and caplow and forman @xcite both on student housing communities . the results showed that in these rather homogeneous communities , spatial arrangement of student rooms / units was an important factor in predicting whether two dwellers have at least weak ties . many other network studies also reached similar results , for example see @xcite . more recently , wellman @xcite and mok _ _ et al.__@xcite re - analysed wellman s earlier dataset on torontorian personal communities @xcite and noted that most personal friendships were indeed `` local , '' contrary to the beliefs that recent technological advances have freed us from spatial constraints . for instance , in @xcite it was found that on average @xmath0 of `` frequent contact '' ties live within a mere 1 mile radius of a typical person , while the rest of his / her ties could be directed to anywhere in the rest of the world . before embarking on specifying the model , we shall review some of the general features of social networks . not many current models simultaneously displays all of these . we suggest that , by including baseline spatial homophily into our network model , one can reproduce all the following features , at least in broad terms : 1 . * low tie density . * the number of possible ties in a network is theoretically quadratic to the number of actors , but most networks realise only a tiny fraction of these ties . the cognitive ability of human places an upper bound on the number of ties one may maintain @xcite . on the other hand , other factors corresponding to baseline homophily can also play a role @xcite ; 2 . * short average geodesic distances . * geodesic distance between two actors is defined to be the length of the shortest connection between them . in large social networks , it is believed that the typical geodesic distance between any two actors remains small . this property was demonstrated empirically by stanley milgram in his classical experiment in the 1960s @xcite , contributing to the popular saying that no one on this earth is separated from you by more than six `` handshakes '' ; 3 . * high level of clustering . * clustering is defined to be the average probability that two friends of an actor are themselves friends . equivalently , it is a measure of how having a mutual friend will heighten the conditional probability that the two friends of an actor will be friends themselves . in their well - known article @xcite , watts and strogatz demonstrated the importance of _ short - cuts _ in social networks that simultaneously display high clustering and short average geodesic distances . such an idea of short - cuts dates back to granovetter s arguments on the strength of weak ties @xcite ; 4 . * positively skewed actor degree distribution . * the degree of an actor is the number of social ties he / she has . in many social networks , a majority of actors have relatively small degrees , while a small number of actors may have very large degrees . this feature is displayed in a wide range of social networks . while it is still debated whether generic social networks have power - law , exponential , or other degree distributions , or indeed whether there is any _ generic _ distribution at all @xcite , there is no doubt that degree distributions are in general positively skewed ; 5 . * existence of communities . * in many cases , clustering does not occur evenly over the entire network . we can often observed subgroups of actors who are highly connected within themselves but loosely connected to other subgroups which are themselves highly inter - connected . we call these highly - connected subgroups _ communities _ a long tradition in social network analysis has developed a range of algorithms to identify these cohesive subsets of nodes @xcite . an example of a social network that displays all of the above properties is a well - known alliance network of 16 tribes in the eastern central highlands of new guinea @xcite . the network is depicted in fig . [ fig : gamapos ] where nodes correspond to tribes and ties correspond to alliances between the relevant tribes . first of all , the density of the network is fairly low ( @xmath1 ) given the small size of the network . the degree distribution is positively skewed ( skewness statistic = @xmath2 ) . the network is a `` small world '' in which it has low median geodesic distance ( @xmath3 ) and high level of clustering coefficient ( clustering coefficient = @xmath4 ) . most importantly , two distinct communities can be easily observed in fig.[fig : gamapos ] : one is disjoint from the rest and is fully connected ( i.e. nodes 1 , 2 , 15 , and 16 ) and the other is highly connected within itself ( i.e. nodes 3 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 11 , and 12 ) . we here represent social networks by non - directed graphs . a non - directed graph is defined to be a pair @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the _ node set _ denoting the individual actors in the network , and @xmath7 , with each edge @xmath8 being an unordered pair of nodes @xmath9 ( @xmath10 and @xmath11 ) , is the _ edge set _ denoting the social ties among the actors . a compact way to represent a graph is through its _ adjacency matrix _ @xmath12 $ ] , @xmath13 such that @xmath14 iff @xmath15 , otherwise @xmath16 . in general , the size of the set @xmath17 ( or equivalently the dimensions of @xmath18 ) is fixed but whether an edge @xmath19 ( or equivalently @xmath14 in @xmath18 ) is determined by a random process . such a random process is defined so as to reflect the underlying social dynamics . the simplest model for social networks is the erds - rnyi or _ bernoulli _ random graph model , initiated independently by paul erds and alfred rnyi @xcite and anatol rapaport @xcite , where the random process is a _ bernoulli _ trial , i.e. @xmath20 where the constant @xmath21 $ ] is called the _ edge probability_. in other words @xmath22 are identically and independently distributed ( i.i.d . ) bernoulli random variables . due to its simplicity , it is amenable to rigorous treatments . it is fairly straightforward to show that the average geodesic distance between any two nodes is @xmath23 , a feature that , as discussed above , resembles the property in some real networks . however the level of clustering in this model can be shown to vanish as @xmath24 and it is one of the major short - comings of this simple model in modelling social networks . further , erds and rnyi showed that there is a critical edge probability @xmath25 at which there always exists a connected component containing a significant proportion of nodes in the network ( almost surely ) @xcite . such component is known as the giant component . for an extensive review of these results refer to bollobs @xcite and janson _ et al . _ @xcite . the main advantage of the erds - rnyi model is its simplicity . although it does not predict some of the generic features outlined above , it serves as a good foundation to build more realistic models . in this paper , we study a generalisation of erds - rnyi random graph model for social networks which incorporates a simple _ baseline spatial homophily _ effect in the formation of individual network ties . we note that this class of models is for a _ single snapshot _ of a network , thus _ temporal network dynamics _ are not taken into account . in section 2 , we shall specify the model and examine some of its basic properties . in section 3 , we shall outline our simulation methods and discuss the main results . in section 4 , we shall demonstrate the application of our model in a particular social network . in section 5 , we shall discuss the implications of the results and describe ongoing research on this and more generalised models . first of all , we embedded the nodes of graphs in the euclidean space @xmath26 with a _ distance _ function @xmath27 defined to map any unordered pair of nodes to a real number , i.e. @xmath28 . further , @xmath27 satisfies the standard triangle inequalities and the positivity condition . every node @xmath29 is assigned a coordinate @xmath30 according to some spatial distribution and we define @xmath31 to be the location vector that specifics the spatial locations of _ all _ nodes in a network . further we shall use the shorthand @xmath32 to denote the distance between nodes @xmath29 and @xmath33 . next , we assume that the spatial locations of the nodes are randomly scattered in space ( and therefore all locations are mutually independent as well ) . in other words , we assumed that the points are distributed in space according to a homogeneous poisson point process ( see for example @xcite ) . recall that a poisson point process with rate @xmath34 in the @xmath27-dimensional euclidean space @xmath35 is a process such that : * for all disjoint subsets @xmath36 , the random variable denoting the number of point in the each subset , @xmath37 , are independently distributed ; * @xmath38 has poisson distribution ; and * @xmath39 = \rho |a|$ ] for all @xmath40 . to model the baseline homophily effect , we let the edge probability between two nodes to be dependent on the spatial distance between them . that is , given a @xmath41 , @xmath42 , where @xmath43 $ ] . motivated by the discussion in the last section , we shall consider the case where @xmath44 is a simple step function , i.e. @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the average density of the network , @xmath47 is the _ neighbourhood radius _ , @xmath48 is the _ proximity bias _ which specifies the sensitivity to geographical space by the actors on establishing social links . thus @xmath48 probabilistically controls the locations of potential tie pool . of course we have assumed that such a spatial sensitivity is the same for all actors in the network . further , @xmath49 is some correction term . the correction term @xmath50 is introduced to maintain the expected average density to be a constant @xmath46 , given @xmath41 , for all feasible values of @xmath47 and @xmath48 , i.e. @xmath51 = p,\ ] ] and there is no other substantive purpose . without maintaining constant density , it will be difficult to isolate the effects of @xmath48 and @xmath47 on the graph s structural properties because of the confounding effects from the varying expected number of edges in the model . to calculate @xmath50 , we first determine the number of all possible edges shorter than the neighbourhood radius @xmath47 in the network embedded in @xmath41 , call this number @xmath52 ; when @xmath53 is sufficiently large ( ignoring boundary effects ) , @xmath54 . the number of possible edges longer than the neighbourhood radius is therefore @xmath55 . by definition the expected density within neighbourhoods is @xmath56 , so the expected number of all realised edges within all neighbourhoods is @xmath57 . it follows that , in order to maintain density to equal @xmath46 , the expected number of realised edges outside the neighbourhood ought to be @xmath58 . as a result , @xmath59 = p - \frac{s_{\le h}}{\binom{n}{2 } - s_{\le h}}p_b . \label{eq : delta}\]]$ ] , we can then repeat the above and arrive at a simpler form for the correction term , @xmath60}{(n-1)-e[s_{\le h}]}p_b.\ ] ] ] since the probability @xmath61 is bounded by 0 and 1 , @xmath62 and @xmath63 . these conditions defines upper and lower bounds for @xmath48 given a @xmath46 and @xmath47 . we note that at the a particular set of values where @xmath64 / \binom{n}{2}$ ] and @xmath65 , i.e. when there is probability 1 that all pair of nodes less than distance @xmath47 apart will be joint and probability 0 otherwise , this model becomes the so - called _ random geometric graph model _ @xcite @xcite . in @xcite , some rigorous results regarding the giant cluster on the model has been obtained , however , the main variable of their model is the poisson rate @xmath66 in space while keeping @xmath67 general . however here our focus on the function @xmath67 . ] . a typical instance of spatial random graph can be found in fig . [ fig : srg - example ] . it is convenient to express our model in the exponential form which fits into the exponential random graph network modelling framework . more details of the framework can be found in wasserman and pattison @xcite . the modelling framework has recently received renewed attention in the physics community , see @xcite and @xcite . let @xmath68 be an instance of random graph with spatial locations of nodes specified by @xmath41 . then the general form of the probability function for obtaining @xmath68 is given by @xmath69 } , \label{eq : expform}\ ] ] where @xmath70 is the hamiltonian of graph @xmath68 given the locations of nodes specified by @xmath41 and @xmath71}\ ] ] is the partition function of the model . the hamiltonian can take any ( sensible ) form to reflect the dependency of edges . the simplest choice is @xmath72 , where @xmath73 is the number of edges in the graph @xmath68 independent of @xmath41 and @xmath74 is its associated parameter . by tuning @xmath74 , we can change the expected density of a typical graph in the model . this gives us the classical erds - rnyi random graph model @xcite as introduced in section 1 . to define @xmath75 for our simple spatial model , we first define @xmath76 and @xmath77 be the number of edges shorter and longer than @xmath47 respectively , then the hamiltonian for our model can be written as @xmath78 where @xmath79 and @xmath80 are parameters whose values can be calculated directly from eq . [ eq : modeldef ] , i.e. @xmath81 where @xmath82 $ ] . equivalently , we can also write the hamiltonian in another form : @xmath83 , where @xmath84 @xmath85 , @xmath86 and @xmath87 . in the following however , we shall only use the former form of the hamiltonian . the simplicity of the hamiltonian allows us to write down the partition function in closed form , @xmath88 } & = & \sum_x \exp\left(\theta_\le l_\le(x ) + \theta _ > l_>(x)\right ) \\ & = & \sum_x \exp\left(\theta_\le \sum_{i < j , d_{ij } \le h } x_{ij } + \theta _ \sum_{i < j , d_{ij } > h } x_{ij } \right ) \\ & = & \left(1 + e^{\theta_\le}\right)^{s_\le(\chi ) } \left(1 + e^{\theta _ > } \right)^{\binom{n}{2 } - s_\le(\chi)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using this explicit form , one can double - check the constant density in our model for all @xmath48 and @xmath47 given @xmath41 : @xmath89\exp\left[-\mathcal{h}(x | \chi)\right ] \\ & = & \binom{n}{2}^{-1}\frac{1}{z(\chi)}\left(\frac{\partial z(\chi)}{\partial \theta_\le } + \frac{\partial z(\chi)}{\partial\theta_>}\right ) \\ & = & \binom{n}{2}^{-1 } \left[s_\le(\chi)(p+p_b ) + s_>(\chi)(p-\delta)\right ] = p,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is what we expected . in theory , we can calculate any statistical average statistical quantities @xmath90 , for example the average clustering coefficient etc , from @xmath91 by adding an auxiliary term in the hamiltonian @xmath92 . then , @xmath93 } \\ & = & \frac{1}{z(\chi)}\left.\frac{\partial z(\chi)}{\partial y}\right|_{y = 0 } \label{eq : intheory}\end{aligned}\ ] ] however , as is the case in many other statistical mechanics models , equations like eq . [ eq : intheory ] are very difficult to evaluate exactly as a general approach in not yet available . in this study , we resort to using numerical simulations to explore the properties our model . the poisson rate @xmath66 and the neighbourhood radius are relative to each other , so we shall always fix @xmath94 and vary @xmath47 only . on the other hand , the choice of the value of @xmath47 is not crucial as long as @xmath47 is sufficiently large . when @xmath47 is too small , the vast majority of ties connected to a node are inevitably from the outside of the neighbourhood , therefore , the model behaves as the simple erds - rnyi random graph model . here we fix @xmath95 . the main program of simulations below is to vary the proximity bias @xmath48 and investigate the effects on the overall structures of the graphs . we used a markov chain monte carlo method outlined in snijders @xcite for all our simulations . each individual data point below is a result of a simulation run ( @xmath96 markov iterations ) of random graphs with 100 nodes on a fixed @xmath41 . the burn - in phase for each run is about @xmath97 iterations and statistics from this phase were removed before further analysis . the estimates of the statistics are then calculated as the simple averages in the post - burn - in phase . and we collect the estimates for six realisations of @xmath41 . in fig . [ fig : h15longshort ] , we plot the average number of edges shorter than ( @xmath98 ) and longer than ( @xmath99 ) the neighbourhood radius ; we called them _ short _ and _ long _ edges respectively . when @xmath100 , the opportunity tie pool of each node equals the entire population ( except itself ) . in this case , since there are many more potential long edges than short edges in the graph , the graphs are on average dominated by long edges . as @xmath48 increase , the potential tie pool of each node concentrate more and more on the population geographically close , so short edges dominate . the two scatter plots in fig . [ fig : h15longshort ] clearly display linear opposing trends . the linearity is simply a result of our model definition , refer to eq . [ eq : modeldef ] . also as @xmath48 increases , there is growing variance of statistics for fixed @xmath48 . it is because as the difference between short edge probability and long edge probability grows , the graphs are more and more dependent on the configuration of the _ specific instance _ of the point process . however , as @xmath48 approaches @xmath101 , the variability decreases again . it is because the large @xmath48 values place significant constraints on the feasible instances of the point process and thus only a small number of instances @xmath41 are feasible for large @xmath48 ( see eq . [ eq : delta ] ) . let us now investigate the effect of @xmath48 on the global structure of the graphs . first let us define the _ geodesic distance _ , or graph distance , between two nodes . note that this distance is independent of the spatial distance between the nodes involved . given a graph @xmath102 , let the geodesic distance between @xmath29 and @xmath33 , @xmath103 , be length of the shortest _ self - avoiding path _ connecting @xmath29 and @xmath33 . if @xmath29 and @xmath33 are disconnected , we assign @xmath104 . now , given a @xmath41 , define @xmath105^{-1},\ ] ] to be the ( harmonic ) mean of @xmath103 over all possible pairs on nodes in @xmath106 . @xmath107 is a simple measure of _ connectivity _ of @xmath108 . refer to the upper part of fig . [ fig : h15plc ] for a plot of @xmath109 against @xmath48 . from the plot , @xmath110 remains small for a large range of @xmath48 . then there appears to be a critical @xmath48 , as in the watts - strogatz model @xcite , that @xmath111 dramatically increases . this indicates a switch from the _ simple random graph _ regime , where `` short - cuts '' between neighbourhood are abundant , to the _ random geometric graph _ regime , where most edges are within each actor s neighbourhood . further , we study the level of clustering in the model . let @xmath112 be the number of independent @xmath113-cycles , or triangles , in graph @xmath106 , i.e. @xmath114 . also let @xmath115 be the number of @xmath3-stars in graph @xmath106 , i.e. @xmath116 . then we define the global clustering coefficient to be @xmath117 @xmath118 measures the overall level of clustering in a network or in other words how much on average an actor s friend s friends are also the actor s friends . by definition , @xmath119 for all @xmath106 . refer to fig . [ fig : h15plc ] for a plot of the average @xmath120 over all @xmath106 in the ensemble as we changes @xmath48 . this model also display similar behaviours as in the watts - strogatz model , and there is a steady increase in its value as @xmath48 increases . the source of this clustering is entirely _ spatial _ , i.e. triangles are likely to be formed simply because of the fact that the involved nodes are closed to each other spatially . overall , there is a range of @xmath48 where the model display _ simultaneously _ relatively low average path length _ and _ significant level of clustering a signature of a `` small - world '' model . although the clustering coefficient defined above measures the _ overall _ level of clustering in a graph , there is the question of whether clustering is distributed evenly over the entire graph on average , in other words , do the triangles in the graph tend to clump together or not ? the `` clumpiness '' of triangles can be measured by the number of _ higher - order triangles_. a @xmath3-triangle is defined to be the combination of two triangles sharing a common edge ( which is called the base edge ) . in general , a @xmath121-triangle is defined to be the combination of @xmath121 triangles all sharing a common base edge and let @xmath122 its number in @xmath106 . let @xmath123 be the number of two - paths connecting @xmath29 and @xmath33 , then a useful and convenient way to combine all @xmath124 into a single measure is as follows : @xmath125,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath126 is an arbitrary constant . for a detailed discussion of the motivation for this definition , see @xcite . a plot of @xmath127 for @xmath128 against @xmath48 can be found in figure [ fig : h15ktri - m - tri ] . there we can see a steady increase in @xmath129 as @xmath48 increases . this suggests that graphs have higher tendencies on average to form clumps of triangles we call these clumps _ communities _ for large @xmath48 . inspection of instances of graphs when @xmath48 is large suggests that the delineation of communities are determined by large gaps in the spatial distribution of the nodes . this happens in spite of that fact that the nodes are distributed uniformly randomly in space . this phenomena can be compared with the observation that communities are likely to be separated by large streets , railroad tracks , etc @xcite . now that we have shown that a typical graph in the model is likely to have strong community structures when @xmath48 is reasonably large . one possible implication of having such kind of structures is that the whole graph can be composed of _ disjoint _ communities . to detect whether it is the case , we consider the average size of the largest connected component over the ensemble . we define the _ component size _ containing node @xmath29 , @xmath130 , to be the number of nodes with finite path length from @xmath29 ( including itself ) , i.e. @xmath131 , where @xmath132 is the normal delta function . let @xmath133 to be the number of nodes of @xmath106 in _ largest _ component over all @xmath29 . we have plotted the @xmath134 against @xmath48 in fig . [ fig : h15gc ] . when @xmath48 is small , a vast majority of nodes is contained in the largest component . as @xmath48 increases , there is a higher chance that the largest component no longer contains most nodes , leaving a significant proportion of nodes in smaller isolated components . the instance of network in fig.[fig : srg - example ] is an example of such a situation . [ fig : degdistn ] shows the average degree distribution of graphs for various values of @xmath48 . they are all positively skewed and as @xmath48 increases the corresponding degree distribution has an increasingly fatter tail . as @xmath48 becomes very large , the distribution becomes a bimodal distribution . this is due to the boundary effect where nodes near the spatial boundary of the graph are disadvantaged by having less possible neighbours within their neighbourhood radius . this is confirmed by the studying the correlation between the spatial distance of nodes from the centre of a typical graph and the degree of the nodes . a scatterplot for a typical instance can be found in fig . [ fig : degcor ] and in this case it is found that there is a significant correlation between the two ( @xmath135 ) . we can use our current model to gain insights into the underlying dynamics of a social network . our example here is a communication network of 33 individuals observed over two days in a single - floor office as part of a large organisation in australia @xcite . we define a communication tie to exist between two individuals if and only if each of the two parties has sought information from each other more than three times over the two - day period . this definition is to avoid brief idiosyncratic encounters that create much noise on top of the regular communication pattern . the network is depicted in fig.[fig : comnet - pajek ] . the location of the nodes in the figure are the actual locations of the individual s cubicle or room up to a linear scaling . in particular , the dimension of the office space is scaled so that all relevant locations fits into a @xmath136 unit square . the network displays the generic features introduced in section 1.2 . first of all , the density is low ( @xmath137 ) . the degree distribution is ( slightly ) positively skewed ( skewness statistics = 0.303 ) . the clustering coefficient is high ( 0.389 ) while the median geodesic distance is very small ( 2 ) . also , in a spatially rearranged layout of the network in fig . [ fig : comnet - pajek - re ] , one can easily identify the two distinct communities . indeed , one can reasonably conjecture that spatial process is important in this communication network . to verify this , we use our current model and estimate the model parameters , i.e. @xmath46 , @xmath47 , and @xmath48 ( see eq . [ eq : modeldef ] ) . the empirical edge probability @xmath138 is plotted in fig . [ fig : comnet - pd ] . it displays the expected big drop at the small values of @xmath27 . based on this , we can fit @xmath138 with a simple step function with some neighbourhood size @xmath47 such that the sum of squared errors is minimal . in this case , @xmath47 is found to be @xmath139 . as the overall density @xmath46 is @xmath140 , the proximity bias @xmath48 is estimated to be @xmath141 , and the correction term @xmath50 is estimated to be @xmath142 using eq.[eq : delta ] . ] . the large bias @xmath48 indicates that there is a strong spatial component in the underlying social process . in this study , we have performed monte carlo simulations on a class of spatial random graph models . it has been found that the properties of these models differs significantly from the simple erds - rnyi random graph model . in particular , for a range of @xmath48 values , the model displays simultaneously many general features of social networks as discussed in section 1 while the erds - rnyi random graph model fails in many aspects . we note that the properties of the model are similar to those of the well - known watts - strogatz `` small world '' model @xcite but that the current model has the advantage of specifying an explicit probability distribution over the collection of all graphs with a given number of nodes . it is also important to note that the clustering properties of the current model arise entirely from the poisson process describing node locations and hence from a form of spatial baseline homophily . it is clearly an empirical question whether such models for social networks provide an adequate descriptive account or whether it is necessary to also incorporate inbreeding homophily effects ( as in exponential random graph selection models @xcite ) or endogenous network processes characteristic of the watts - strogatz model @xcite and more general exponential random graph model specifications @xcite . this is a question that has received little attention in the network literature despite its fundamental importance to our understanding of network evolution . in order to identify models that provide a good match to empirical data , it will be useful to construct a nested family of exponential random graph models that can be used to evaluate the empirical evidence for spatial and other forms of baseline homophily , inbreeding homophily and endogenous clustering effects . indeed , reference to empirical data immediately raises the possibility of at least two alternative conceptualisations of a spatial model : the first , a geographical space , in which geographical coordinates are associated with each node ; and the second , a more abstract `` social '' space , in which spatial proximities reflect baseline homophily across a broad range of individual attributes . in each case , spatial locations may be observed or unobserved . for the current model and the case of observed locations , it would be necessary to estimate the model parameters @xmath46 and @xmath47 from the combination of location and network data ; in the case of unobserved locations , it would be desirable to use a version of hoff , handcock and raftery s @xcite more general exponential random graph model specifications to estimate model parameters from network data alone . more generally , it would be desirable to construct within the exponential random graph model family , models that also include inbreeding homophily and endogenous clustering effects and associated estimation methods . the model described in this paper takes a useful first step towards the construction of such a family of models . the results presented here suggest that the fit of models to empirical data will need careful quantitative evaluation ( e.g. as in @xcite ) because of the likely capacity of many models within the family to exhibit in broad terms the commonly observed features of empirical social networks laid out in section 1.2 . this study is financially supported by a australian research council discovery grant and the csiro university of melbourne collaboration supportive scheme . we thank sean bergin and paul rogers for sharing with us the communication network data . we express our gratitudes to paul walker , stanley wasserman and tom snijders for their helpful discussions , and the anonymous referee for pointing out the relevant literature and various other suggestions . we would also like to thank peng wang for programming the simulation program and the high performance computer facility at the university of melbourne for allowing us to use the ibm alfred cluster for simulations . newman m.e.j . and girvan m. , _ mixing patterns and community structure in networks _ , in statistical mechanics of complex networks , r. pastor - satorras , j. rubi , and a. diaz - guilera ( eds . ) , springer , berlin ( 2003 ) . pattison p.e . , and robins g. l. , _ neighbourhood - based models for social networks _ , sociological methodology * 32 * , 301 - 337 ( 2002 ) . penrose m.d . , _ on a continuum percolation model _ , adv . appl . prob . * 23 * , 536 - 556 ( 1991 ) . robins g.l . , and pattison p. , _ interdependencies and social processes : generalized dependence structures _ , in carrington , scott , and wasserman ( eds ) models and methods in social network analysis . cambridge university press ( in press ) . robins , g.l . , and alexander , m. , _ small worlds among interlocking directors : network structure and distance in bipartite graphs _ , journal of computational and mathematical organization theory * 10 * , 69 - 94 ( 2004 ) . robins g. and johnston m. , _ joint social selection and social influence models for networks : the interplay of ties and attributes _ , presentation at sunbelt international social network conference , portoroz , slovenia ( 2004 ) . the alliance network in eastern central highlands of new guinea . note that the numbers next to the nodes are for illustrative purpose only and the spatial arrangements of the nodes do not reflect the actual tribe locations . , title="fig:",width=415 ] + a plot of average geodesic distance @xmath146 ( upper graph ) and average clustering coefficient @xmath147 ( lower graph ) against @xmath48 . , title="fig:",width=415 ] a plot of average geodesic distance @xmath146 ( upper graph ) and average clustering coefficient @xmath147 ( lower graph ) against @xmath48 . , title="fig:",width=415 ] scatterplot for the degree of nodes versus distance from the centre of the graph in one typical instance of the model ( @xmath149 , @xmath150 , @xmath151 ) . the line is the least square fit line . , width=415 ]

we study spatial embeddings of random graphs in which nodes are randomly distributed in geographical space . we let the edge probability between any two nodes to be dependent on the spatial distance between them and demonstrate that this model captures many generic properties of social networks , including the `` small - world '' properties , skewed degree distribution , and most distinctively the existence of community structures . * msc classifications : * 91d30 , 90b10 , 82b99 . * keywords : * social networks , small world , spatial model , community structure , homophily .

0810.3281

the standard model of particle physics describes neutrinos as massless , neutral fermions , which can be detected only via weak interactions . the observations of neutrino flavour oscillation @xcite indicate the existence of massive neutrinos . since experiments investigating these neutrino oscillations are only sensitive to differences of the square of mass eigenvalues @xmath3 and not to the absolute values , the scale and hierarchy of neutrino masses are not determined yet . an identification of the mass scheme realized in nature would not only solve the puzzle of absolute neutrino masses but could also point to the mechanisms of mass generation in extensions of the standard model . in standard cosmological models , our universe is filled with primordial neutrinos arising from freeze - out in the early universe . these neutrinos are natural candidates for non - baryonic hot dark matter . depending on the actual neutrino mass , the neutrino content of the universe can exceed the baryonic mass density . the above arguments demonstrate the importance of the absolute neutrino mass scale for both particle physics and cosmology . a model - independent approach to determine the neutrino mass is the kinematical analysis of electrons from radioactive near the endpoint energy . a non - vanishing neutrino mass reduces the electron endpoint energy and distorts the shape of the electron spectrum in the vicinity of @xmath4 . the scheme of a measurement investigating the endpoint region of the electron energy spectrum from tritium ( @xmath5 ) with an electrostatic filter is illustrated in figure [ fig - mac - e - filter ] . electrons emitted by in the source are guided magnetically through the electrostatic retarding potential of the spectrometer , to be counted by a segmented silicon detector . this _ magnetic adiabatic collimation _ followed by the _ electrostatic _ ( mac - e ) filter represents an integrating high pass filter for . this technique has been used in the mainz and troitsk experiments with different tritium sources , providing the most stringent , model - independent limits on the neutrino mass so far , with ( @xcite,@xcite,@xcite,@xcite ) @xmath6 with well understood systematic effects , both experiments have now reached their sensitivity limits . the energy resolution of a mac - e - filter depends on the ratio of the strongest magnetic field @xmath7 in the beam - line and the weakest field @xmath8 in the centre of the spectrometer . flux conservation requires that @xmath9 remains constant , where @xmath10 is the cross section of the magnetic flux tube , guiding the electrons from the source to the detector . improving the energy resolution of such an experiment needs a much lower @xmath8 and therefore a spectrometer with a much larger cross section , which will be able to contain the magnetic flux . an improved sensitivity requires not just size , but also a stronger source with higher statistics and a better understanding of systematic uncertainties . the * ka*rlsruhe * tri*tium * n*eutrino ( katrin ) experiment will use the techniques developed in mainz and troitsk with a strong gaseous molecular tritium source and an electro - static filter of unprecedented energy resolution ( @xmath11 @xcite . the expected sensitivity for the neutrino mass will be @xmath12 after three years of measurement . as the experimental observable is , an improvement in sensitivity on @xmath13 of one order of magnitude corresponds to an improvement of a factor @xmath14 in accuracy on leading to numerous technical challenges for this experiment . figure [ fig - katrin - scheme ] outlines the experimental set - up of katrin @xcite , which adds up to a total length of about @xmath15 . katrin overview : a ) tritium source ( wgts ) , b ) differential pumping ( dps ) and cryo - pumping section ( cps ) , c ) pre - spectrometer and main spectrometer , d ) detector.,width=604 ] the katrin experiment is currently under construction at forschungszentrum karlsruhe ( fzk ) , germany . with the tritium laboratory karlsruhe ( tlk ) , a unique lab is available on site , which will house the complete tritium inventory , including the source and transport section . first components such as the pre - spectrometer ( 2003 ) , main spectrometer ( 2006 ) , some magnets and a prototype detector array are on site , being thoroughly tested . the experiment is now in the construction and commissioning phase . first measurements are expected to start in 2012 , with a total measuring time of 5 years . the source and transport section includes the _ windowless gaseous tritium source _ ( wgts ) , followed by _ differential pumping sections _ ( dps ) and a _ cryogenic pumping section _ ( cps ) . the beam tubes inside the super - conducting solenoids have a diameter between @xmath16 and @xmath17 , interspersed with pump ports for turbo - molecular pumps ( tmp ) . these pumps are integrated in the closed loop tritium circulation system . the pressure inside the vacuum beam - line will range from @xmath18 at the source to less than @xmath19 in the spectrometer section . the wgts will be the standard @xmath20-electron source for long - term tritium measurements . ultra - cold molecular tritium gas ( @xmath21 ) will be injected through a set of capillaries at the centre of the @xmath22 long wgts tube with an injection pressure of @xmath23 and a flow rate of about @xmath24 ( @xmath25 ) . the density profile of the gas inside the beam - tube has to be kept stable on the @xmath26 level . the stability depends on a constant beam - tube temperature and inlet pressure in the wgts . maintaining these conditions is a very challenging task , and the technical feasibility will be demonstrated with the partly assembled wgts in 2009 . after injection the t@xmath27 molecules will be transported by diffusion over a length of @xmath28 to both ends of the source tube , where most of the tritium will be pumped out by tmps of the first stage of the differential pumping section . this process leads to an almost linear decrease of the tritium number density @xcite,@xcite . electrons from @xmath20-decays will be guided adiabatically by a magnetic field of b@xmath29 . the background generated by tritium decay within the spectrometers must be less than @xmath30 counts / s , which limits the amount of tritium permissible in the main spectrometer to a partial pressure of about @xmath31 . with a pumping speed of @xmath32 this leads to a maximum allowed tritium flow rate into the spectrometer section in the order of @xmath33 . this very large suppression factor will be achieved in two stages , based on a combination of differential ( dps ) and cryogenic ( cps ) pumping sections , with each stage providing a suppression factor in the order of @xmath34 . the first part of the tritium flow suppression is based on differential pumping @xcite,@xcite,@xcite . along the beam - line turbo - molecular pumps with high pumping speed reduce the tritium flow both at the rear and front ends of the source . as the dps elements adjacent to the wgts ( dps1-f , dps1-r ) influence the stability of the gas flow in the source , they have to be operated under almost identical conditions as the wgts . therefore these first dps sections are included in the source cryostat . the tmps have to be operated close to the beam - line , in order to minimize conductance losses . due to the strong magnets extensive tests have been made to investigate the behaviour of tmps in magnetic fields . the differential pumping system will reduce the tritium flow into the subsequent passive cryo - trapping system ( cps ) to @xmath35 ( at 273 k ) . the cps will reduce the tritium flow by another 7 orders of magnitude , allowing only a remaining flow below @xmath33 into the pre - spectrometer . during a normal measuring period of 60 days a total amount of about @xmath36 of tritium molecules can be accumulated in the cps , corresponding to an activity of @xmath37 . the beam - tube of the cps will be kept at a temperature of @xmath38 . at this temperature tritium molecules are passively adsorbed on the wall . to enhance the trapping probability , the cold surfaces of the cps beam - tubes will be covered by a thin layer of argon frost . the main advantage of a condensed gas layer , compared to a solid adsorbent like charcoal , lies in the easy removal of both the adsorbent and the adsorbed tritium , thus minimizing the residual tritium contamination of the beam - tube . after each measuring period the cps will be re - heated and the tritium gas will be returned to the closed tritium cycle . although data on hydrogen and deuterium adsorption on condensed gases are available @xcite , no data on tritium adsorption were found . the effect of electron stimulated desorption from tritium @xmath20-decay on the migration of tritium molecules along the cryo - sorption pump of the cps beam - tube and the influence on the suppression factor have been investigated in monte carlo simulations @xcite,@xcite . in order to experimentally explore the adsorption properties of condensed argon for tritium , the test experiment trap has been set up by the katrin collaboration and first results have been published for deuterium and tritium @xcite,@xcite,@xcite , confirming the cps design values . all three major components of the source and transport section are expected to be delivered between 2009 ( dps ) and 2011 ( wgts and cps ) . after commissioning tests of each components they will be connected to the spectrometer section . the source is expected to provide first tritium electrons to be analysed in the spectrometer early 2012 . the central part of the experiment will be the tandem spectrometer section . it consists of two electrostatic spectrometers of mac - e - filter type : the _ pre - spectrometer _ , allowing only electrons with the highest energies to pass into the _ main spectrometer _ , where their kinetic energy will be analysed with a resolution of @xmath39 . the high energy resolution of the main spectrometer requires large dimensions ( see fig . [ fig - mainspec ] ) . it has a diameter of @xmath1 , an overall length of @xmath40 , a surface area of @xmath41 and a volume of @xmath42 . the * pre - spectrometer * with a diameter of @xmath43 , a length of @xmath44 , a surface of @xmath45 and a volume of @xmath46 served as a prototype for the design of the main spectrometer . it demonstrated the scalability of the vacuum layout and the reliability of the large @xmath43 flange design at all temperatures . ) arrived at fzk after a @xmath47 long journey . right : a custom made adjustable cleanroom scaffolding has been set up inside the spectrometer to install the wire electrodes on the inner wall.,width=604 ] during standard operation very good uhv conditions of @xmath48 have to be maintained in both spectrometer vessels at room temperature in order to keep a low background rate . the vacuum systems are based on a combination of cascaded turbo - molecular pumps ( tmp ) and neg - pumps made of double - coated @xmath49 wide zr - v - fe getter strips . both vessels are made of electro - polished stainless steel ( 316ln ) . hydrogen outgassing from the walls is expected to be the main source of gas , which limits the final pressure in each vessel . the surface of each vacuum vessel can be baked at temperatures up to @xmath50 for reduction of outgassing and activation of the neg - pumps . the temperature of the walls is controlled by heat - transfer oil pumped through a system of stainless steel pipes , welded to the surface of each vessel . the pre - spectrometer vacuum measurements showed in 2004 , that a hydrogen outgassing rate of @xmath51 can be reached with 316ln stainless steel , using standard manufacturing procedures @xcite . the cleaning process after manufacturing included pickling , electro - polishing and rinsing with de - ionized water . based on this measured outgassing rate the main spectrometer requires a total pumping speed of @xmath52 , which will be provided by @xmath53 of neg strips @xcite,@xcite . for the main spectrometer similar production methods and cleaning procedures were used . during manufacturing a large workshop hall was reserved for katrin . before manufacturing started the floor was coated and the whole hall was cleaned . the distance between the manufacturer and fzk is about @xmath54 . due to the large size of the main spectrometer , it had to be shipped on a river barge down the river danube to the black sea , around europe and up the river rhine on a @xmath47 detour ( see fig.[fig - mainspec ] , left ) . after delivery and installation of the heating and vacuum systems in first commissioning tests in 2007 confirmed an outgassing rate of @xmath51 , as expected from pre - spectrometer measurements . the electrostatic field will be generated by connecting the outer wall of each spectrometer to high voltage ( @xmath55 ) . the field will be fine - tuned by an inner electrode system , made of very thin stainless steel wires . both pre - spectrometer and main spectrometer have large , metal - sealed vacuum flanges ( diameter : @xmath56 ) , which allow to enter the vessel for installation of the inner electrode system . the beam - tubes end in cone - shaped ground electrodes , which are attached to the vacuum vessels via conical ceramic insulators . the shape of the inner electrodes have been calculated in extensive monte carlo simulations and tested with the pre - spectrometer . a lot of effort went into the investigation of penning traps in the @xmath57 fields , which can lead to a strong increase of background rates . currently the pre - spectrometer is used to optimize the electrode design . the electrode system of the main spectrometer consists of 248 individual wire electrode frames with a total of 23120 stainless steel wires , with each wire electrically insulated against the frame . these electrodes are presently produced at the university mnster . at the same time preparations have been started to install these electrodes inside the main spectrometer under cleanroom conditions ( see fig.[fig - mainspec ] , right ) . the electrodes will be installed in 2009 . another challenge is the high voltage system of the spectrometer . the variable retarding voltage has to be known with ppm accuracy . since no known commercially available precision high voltage divider meets this requirement , a unique voltage divider with an appropriate stability has been developed at the university mnster together with ptb braunschweig . together with this high voltage system the electro - magnetic properties of the spectrometer will be investigated in an intensive test programme , which also includes the segmented silicon detector , currently being built at the university of washington in seattle . the katrin experiment has ambitious goals , both in particle physics and in the technical realization of the experimental set - up . currently all major components are either under construction or have already been delivered to fzk . first vacuum measurements with the large main spectrometer vessel indicate an outgassing behaviour , which agrees well with results from earlier measurements with the much smaller pre - spectrometer . after installing the final vacuum system , we expect to reach the required pressure of @xmath58 in the spectrometer section . other components of the experiment face different challenges , like the dps , where tmps have to be operated close to super - conducting solenoids or the wgts with its stringent requirements on stability of temperature and pressure . the next step will be the installation of the inner electrode system of the main spectrometer in 2009 an a test of its energy resolution . after delivery and test of all components we expect first tritium measurements in 2012 . this work has been supported in part by the german bmbf ( 05ck5vka/5 , 05ck5pma/0 , 05ck1rea/1 ) and by the dfg project sfb transregio 27 . , * b * ( proc . suppl . ) * 143 * ( 2005 ) j. bonn , nucl . b ( proc . suppl . ) * 91 * , 273 ( 2001 ) v. lobashev , nucl . phys . b ( proc . suppl . ) * 91 * , 280 ( 2001 ) c. kraus , eur . phys . j. * c33 * , s01 ( 2004 ) v. lobashev , nucl . phys . * a 719 * ( 2003 ) 153c a. osipowicz , ( katrin collab . ) , hep - ex/0109033 , fzka report 6691 , t. thmmler , ( katrin collab . ) , fzka report 6752 katrin collaboration , _ katrin design report 2004 _ , fzka report 7090 f. sharipov , katrin internal reports http://fisica.ufpr.br/sharipov/katrin/ x. luo , vacuum 80 ( 2006 ) 864 - 869 o.b . malyshev , _ tritium gas flow dynamics through the source and transport system of the katrin experiment _ , submitted to j. vac . technol . * a * o.b . malyshev , vacuum 81 ( 2007 ) 752 - 758 v.b . yuferov , r.m . kobez , sov . phys * 14 * ( 1970 ) 1261 o.b . malyshev , j. vac . a , * 26*(1 ) 68 ( 2008 ) x. lou and ch . day , j. vac . a , * 26*(5 ) 1319 ( 2008 ) f. eichelhardt , proceedings of the 25th international symposium on rarefied gas dynamics , saint - petersburg , russia , july 21 - 28 , 2006 , p.1241 , publishing house of the siberian branch of the russian academy of sciences , novosibirsk ( 2007 ) o. kazachenko , nucl . methods * a 587 * ( 2008 ) 136 f. eichelhardt , fusion science and technology * 54 * ( 2008 ) 615 j. wolf et al . , _ aip conference proceeding 837 : hydrogen in matter _ ( 2006 ) 200 - 209 chr . day , a , * 25*(4 ) 824 ( 2007 ) x. luo , vacuum , 81(2007 ) 777 - 781

the * ka*rlsruhe * tri*tium * n*eutrino experiment ( katrin ) aims to measure the mass of electron neutrinos from beta - decay of tritium with an unprecedented sensitivity of @xmath0 improving present limits by one order of magnitude . the decay electrons will originate from a @xmath1 long windowless , gaseous tritium source . super - conducting magnets guide the electrons through differential and cryogenic pumping sections to the electro - static tandem spectrometer ( mac - e - filter ) , where the kinetic energy will be measured . the experiment is presently being built at the _ forschungszentrum karlsruhe _ by an international collaboration of more than 120 scientists . the largest component , the @xmath2 main spectrometer , was delivered end of 2006 and first commissioning tests have been performed . this presentation describes the goals and technological challenges of the experiment and reports on the progress in commissioning first major components . the start of first measurements is expected in 2012 .

nucl-th9510051

the qcd sum rule ( qcd - sr ) approach to qcd continues to be a highly active field . the influence of the field is reflected in over 1500 references to the seminal paper of shifman , vainshtein and zakharov ( svz ) @xcite , with over 380 of these references following the beginning of 1992 @xcite . while the approach has been applied to a variety of hadronic observables in both vacuum and finite density nuclear matter , a comprehensive review of the systematic errors associated with the approach has not been considered . one of the key assumptions of the approach is the use of the so called `` continuum model '' to remove excited state contaminations from the hadron correlator under investigation . recently , the continuum model for the nucleon was tested by using correlation functions calculated via lattice regularized qcd @xcite . the results suggest that the continuum model adequately removes the excited state contaminations and allows the isolation of the ground state . the success of the continuum model warrants a more careful investigation of other aspects of the qcd - sr approach so that uncertainties in the predictions may be reliably and quantitatively determined . the focus of this paper is to establish a rigorous procedure for extracting quantities of phenomenological interest from qcd sum rules . the main conclusion of this investigation is that qcd sum rules work and they are predictive when the analysis is done rigorously . the ground state masses of the @xmath0-meson and the nucleon are used to introduce the concepts . however , the procedures introduced here are more generally applicable to quantities of current experimental interest . the goal is to shed light on the stability of qcd sum rule analyses and thus the accuracy to which observables may be reliably determined . implementation of the procedure introduced here does not lead to slight adjustments in the extracted parameters , but rather leads to qualitatively different conclusions . it will become apparent that most existing qcd - sr investigations of nucleon properties are in fact unreliable . previous calculations are based on sum rules in which neither the operator product expansion ( ope ) nor the phenomenological description are under acceptable control . the qcd - sr method is presently the best fundamentally based approach for investigating the properties of hadrons in nuclear matter , as the lattice approach is challenged by a number of formidable obstacles @xcite . issues surrounding the finite width of the rho - meson make reliable lattice calculations of @xmath2 mixing very difficult . these are two of the many topics of current interest to nuclear physicists where the best fundamentally based approach is that of qcd - srs . moreover , the approach has minimal model dependence . hence it is imperative to probe the predictive ability of the approach and the ideas presented here are currently being applied to these topics mentioned above @xcite . the most significant source of uncertainty in the qcd sum rule approach is an imprecise knowledge of the vacuum condensates appearing in the operator product expansion ( ope ) . this is particularly problematic for the higher dimension operators , where one usually invokes the vacuum saturation hypothesis ( factorization ) to replace higher - dimension - operator vacuum - expectation values by products of lower - dimension operators . a list of key sources of uncertainty in the qcd - sr approach should include : * the unfactorized condensate values , * factorization of higher dimensional operators , * small but neglected @xmath3 corrections , * the truncation of the operator product expansion ( ope ) , * the selection of the regime for matching the qcd and phenomenological sides of the sum rules , * uncertainties associated with the summation of perturbation theory in large orders , and * the possibility of significant direct instanton contributions . with the exception of direct instanton contributions , the effects of these uncertainties will be estimated via a monte - carlo error analysis . gaussian distributions for the condensate values are generated via monte carlo . these distributions are selected to reflect the spread of values assumed in previously published qcd - sr analyses , and the uncertainties such as operator factorization listed above . these distributions provide a distribution for the ope and thus uncertainty estimates for the ope which will be used in a @xmath4 fit . in turn , the ope distribution provides distributions for the phenomenological fit parameters , thus establishing the predictive ability of the qcd - sr approach . in the field of qcd inspired models , the focus is often on whether or not the model is able to encompass the known experimental data , as opposed to assessing the predictive potential of the method . a review of the qcd - sr literature leaves no doubt as to whether or not the qcd - sr method is able to encompass the established data . the poorly determined condensate values and arbitrary aspect of the matching borel regime provides tremendous freedom in devising ways to achieve the desired result in fact , it is difficult to find qcd - sr - based predictions of hadronic observables which fail to agree with experiment . this is somewhat surprising , since the physics responsible for some observables may be poorly represented in a truncated ope commonly limited to distances of less than 0.3 fm . most qcd - sr calculations of nucleon properties in the literature fall short in the analysis stage where the phenomenological parameters are determined by matching the qcd and phenomenological sides of the sum rules . typical analysis short - comings include : * selecting a single value for the borel parameter which gives `` nice '' results . a borel _ regime _ should be selected in order to evaluate the stability and reliability of the results . * a selection of the borel regime without careful regard to ope convergence nor maintaining ground state dominance of the phenomenological side of the sum rules . * the fixing of search parameters ( such as the continuum threshold ) to preferred values . it will become apparent that this introduces a strong bias to the remaining fit parameters which may not reflect the properties of qcd . * claiming an accuracy for qcd - sr predictions without supporting calculations . occasionally a `` stability analysis '' @xcite is considered , in which fit parameters are monitored as a single condensate value is varied . however , such analyses explore a relatively small corner of the condensate parameter space . in general , former procedures adopted for matching the two sides of the sum rules lack the level of rigor which will be presented here . this general lack of rigor can be traced back to the original paper of svz @xcite . in their conclusions , they comment `` we prefer not to deepen into the debris of computer calculations , sophisticated fit programs , arranging error bars here and there@xmath5 '' while this may be appropriate for a seminal paper on the qcd - sr approach , continuation of this philosophy has lead to strong negative criticism of the qcd - sr field . it is not uncommon to hear remarks such as `` qcd sum rules are useful only if you know the answer . '' or `` you can get anything you want from qcd sum rules . '' and `` 10% here , 10% there pretty soon you re talking about real numbers ! '' these remarks are unfortunate , as a rigorous and proficuous analysis is possible . in this paper , a method for the quantitative determination of phenomenological quantities with uncertainties will be presented . since this paper is directed to both qcd - sum - rule practitioners and skeptics alike , we begin by briefly outlining the qcd - sr approach in section [ qcdsr ] . a more pedagogical review of the approach may be found in the recent review article of ref . this section also introduces the `` ioffe formula '' @xcite , argued by many to qualitatively encapsulate a description of the nucleon mass in terms of the chiral symmetry breaking order parameter @xmath1 . uncertainties associated with the evaluation of the ope will be addressed via a new monte - carlo based procedure . estimates for these uncertainties are presented in section [ uncert ] . section [ analysis ] details the monte - carlo uncertainty analysis and discusses the optimization algorithm and cautious convergence criteria used in the following . section [ rho ] presents an analysis of @xmath0-meson sum rules . here the criteria for the selection of the regime for matching the qcd and phenomenological sides of the sum rules is reviewed . reasonable alternatives are considered via monte carlo . these considerations lead to the selection of the optimal interpolating field for nucleon sum rules . new insights into unconventional nucleon interpolators obtained from the lattice qcd investigation of ref . @xcite play a significant role here . section [ nucleon11 ] reviews the selection of the optimal nucleon interpolating field for correlators obtained from spin-1/2 interpolating fields . the effects of choosing non - optimal interpolators is demonstrated . section [ nucleon13 ] explores additional sum rules obtained from the overlap of the generalized spin-1/2 and a spin-3/2 interpolator . in section [ correl ] we explore the correlations between condensate values , fit parameters and sum rule consistency . these correlations serve to identify the roles of the leading terms of the ope in hadronic physics . the validity of the `` ioffe formula '' is evaluated here , and these results may be of interest to those modeling the qcd vacuum . the contingency table analysis reveals that the intimate relationship between the quark condensate and the nucleon mass suggested in the `` ioffe formula '' is invalid . the necessity of direct instanton contributions to the qcd sum rules is determined in section [ instantons ] . we demonstrate that there is no evidence indicating that direct instanton contributions are required to maintain sum rule consistency . the implications of the results of this analysis on coordinate space correlators are discussed in section [ coordimpl ] . finally , section [ conclusions ] summarizes the findings of this in - depth investigation . the underlying principle of field theoretic approaches to hadron phenomenology is the ansatz of duality . that is , it is possible to simultaneously describe a hadron as quarks propagating in the qcd vacuum , and as a phenomenological field with the appropriate quantum numbers . hadron masses are extracted from an analysis of the two - point function @xmath6 the interpolating field @xmath7 is typically constructed from quark field operators combined to give the quantum numbers of the hadron under investigation . the @xmath0-meson interpolator related to the decay constant is @xmath8 to maintain maximal overlap with the ground state relative to excited states , only interpolators without derivatives are considered . for the nucleon we begin by considering the most general spin-1/2 nucleon interpolator @xmath9 where @xmath10 and @xmath11 @xmath12 is the interpolator typically used in lattice qcd analyses . @xmath13 vanishes in the nonrelativistic limit . however in a theory with light relativistic current quarks , there is no reason to exclude such an interpolating field _ a priori _ @xcite . with the use of the fierz relations , the combination of the above two interpolating fields for @xmath14 may be written @xmath15 [ chisr ] giving the proton interpolating field advocated by ioffe @xcite and often found in qcd - sr calculations . at the phenomenological level one proceeds by inserting a complete set of eigenstates with the quantum numbers of the interpolator . the ability of the interpolator to annihilate a positive parity baryon to the qcd vacuum is described by the parameter @xmath16 in @xmath17 for state @xmath18 of momentum @xmath19 and spin @xmath20 . @xmath21 is a dirac spinor . negative parity states require a @xmath22 on the right - hand side of ( [ lambdadef ] ) . for the nucleon , the two point function has the form @xmath23 where @xmath24 corresponds to positive / negative parity baryons . while there is some suppression of excited state contributions to the two - point function , there is little hope of isolating ground state properties from such a function . hence one uses the celebrated borel transform @xmath25 = \lim_{{\scriptstyle -p^2 \to \infty \atop \scriptstyle n \to \infty } \atop \scriptstyle -p^2/n = m^2 } { 1\over n ! } ( -p^2)^{n+1 } \left ( { d \over d p^2 } \right ) ^n f ( p^2 ) \ , , \ ] ] at each dirac-@xmath26 structure to obtain exponential suppression of excited states . the parameter @xmath27 is commonly referred to as the borel mass . the borel transform is easily applied to a dispersion relation for @xmath28 at each dirac-@xmath26 structure @xmath29 and the polynomial subtraction terms are eliminated by the borel transform . at the structure @xmath30 one has @xmath31 where we have introduced the spectral density @xmath32 , @xmath33[gp ] at the structure @xmath34 @xmath35 where @xmath36 here , @xmath37 and @xmath38 account for excited state contributions , and @xmath24 in ( [ rho1 ] ) corresponds to positive / negative parity states . for the vector meson one has @xmath39 @xmath40 [ rhov ] at the structure @xmath41 . at the quark level , one exploits the operator product expansion ( ope ) to describe the short distance behavior of the two - point function @xmath42 [ ope ] where @xmath43 is the normalization point at which the coefficient functions and the operators are defined . here we have explicitly included all operators up to dimension eight , to leading order in the quark mass @xmath44 , having the quantum numbers of the vacuum . the first digit of the subscript of the wilson coefficients @xmath45 gives the energy dimension of the operator . @xmath46 may take any of the 16 independent dirac-@xmath26 matrices . upon fourier transforming to momentum space , ( [ ope ] ) becomes an expansion in @xmath47 , valid for large momentum transfers . thus one may use perturbation theory to calculate the wilson coefficients . the contribution of the gluon operator term 4.1 in the expansion for the proton is suppressed due a factor of @xmath48 which appears in the denominator of the wilson coefficient arising from integration over the quark - loop momentum which introduces the factor @xmath49 . terms involving more than two gluon field strength tensors @xmath50 and products of @xmath44 and @xmath51 are estimated to be small and are typically neglected . the standard treatment of the ope proceeds via inserting the explicit forms of the interpolating fields into the two - point function of ( [ twopt ] ) and contracting out pairs of time - ordered quark - field operators which are the fully interacting quark propagators of qcd . wick s theorem for the time - ordered product of two fermion fields provides @xmath52 taylor expansion of the normal ordered piece leads to @xmath53 the well known trick is to select the coordinate gauge @xmath54 such that @xmath55 and the partial derivatives of ( [ taylor ] ) may be replaced by covariant derivatives @xmath56 generally , one works with ( [ aexp ] ) to leading order . the following relations allow an easy determination of the covariant derivatives @xmath57 @xmath58 = i g_c g^{\mu \nu } \ , , \ ] ] @xmath59 in summary , the quark correlators employed in calculating the ope under the usual assumption of vacuum saturation of the intermediate states of composite operators include @xmath60 \bigl ( g_c g_{\alpha \beta}^n \bigr ) \sigma^{\alpha \beta } { \lambda^n_{ab } \over 2 } \ , . \label{quarkcorr } \\ & & \nonumber \\ \lefteqn{\langle \omega \bigm | t \left \ { q^a ( x ) \ , g_c g_{\alpha \beta}^n \ , \overline q^b ( 0 ) \right \ } \bigm | \omega \rangle = } \hspace{36pt } \nonumber \\ & & - { 1 \over 2 ^ 6 \ , 3 } \langle \overline q g_c \sigma \cdot g q \rangle \sigma_{\alpha \beta } { \lambda^n_{ab } \over 2 } \nonumber \\ & & + { i \over 2 ^ 8 \ , 3 } m_q \langle \overline q g_c \sigma \cdot g q \rangle \bigl ( \gamma \cdot x \ , \sigma_{\alpha \beta } + \sigma_{\alpha \beta } \ , \gamma \cdot x \bigr ) { \lambda^n_{ab } \over 2 } \nonumber \\ & & + { x^2 \over 2^{10 } \ , 3 ^ 2 } \langle g_c^2 g^2 \rangle \langle \overline q q \rangle \sigma_{\alpha \beta } { \lambda^n_{ab } \over 2 } \ , . \label{quarkgluoncorr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally the momentum space correlator is borel transformed . here one encounters the factorial suppression of higher - dimension operators as indicated in @xmath61 = ( -1)^k \ , { 1 \over ( k-1 ) ! } \ , { 1 \over ( m^2)^{k-1 } } \ , .\ ] ] it is worth noting that the factorial suppression does not really set in until one reaches the term @xmath62 . for the @xmath0 meson this term corresponds to an operator of dimension eight , and for the nucleon the dimensions are twelve and thirteen for the two nucleon sum rules obtained from spin-1/2 interpolating fields . since the ope for the @xmath0-meson is traditionally truncated at dimension eight @xcite , the correlator should be more reliable than for the nucleon sum rules which are truncated at dimension nine . it is well known that the standard treatment of the ope encounters difficulties at large orders in the perturbative expansion of the wilson coefficients . perturbative expansions are divergent at large orders and are asymptotic at best @xcite . in the standard treatment , these divergences limit the accuracy to which the perturbative coefficients may be determined . renormalons @xcite , a particular set of perturbative graphs , provide a simple illustration of the factorial growth in the contributions of perturbative graphs at large orders @xcite . the factorial growth in large - order contributions associated with soft infrared ( ir ) virtual momenta is problematic , as the series is not borel summable . as such , the wilson coefficients , by themselves , are ill defined in the standard treatment . the uncertainty resulting from the restriction to finite orders of the asymptotic expansion is commonly referred to as the ir renormalon ambiguity . of course the use of perturbative propagators to describe soft virtual momenta is incorrect . instead , one must utilize fully dressed nonperturbative propagators . hence , it is not surprising one encounters difficulties in the ir regime , as one is simply encountering the landau pole of the perturbative coupling constant . a solution to the ir renormalon ambiguity problem was provided by the itep group @xcite through the introduction of the normalization / separation scale @xmath43 of ( [ opemu ] ) . the ope becomes a separation of scales , with virtual momenta lying above @xmath43 represented in the wilson coefficients , and momenta below @xmath43 in the vacuum expectation values ( vevs ) of higher - dimension operators beginning at dimension four . the introduction of the scale @xmath43 eliminates the ir renormalon ambiguity of the perturbative expansion . however , in principle , both the wilson coefficients and the vevs of operators contain perturbative as well as nonperturbative physics . in principle , the ope defined in ( [ opemu ] ) is free of ir renormalon ambiguities . however , in practice it is difficult to implement the formal procedure of truncating virtual momenta below @xmath43 when calculating higher order @xmath3 corrections to the wilson coefficients . while these contributions are small for leading order corrections , their inclusion is a source of error which can be accommodated in the monte - carlo uncertainty analysis . in the ultraviolet ( uv ) virtual momenta regime , the renormalon series is sign alternating and borel summable . summation of the uv series can give rise to a power correction proportional to @xmath63 which closely resembles the squared quark mass contribution to the ope @xcite . for the vector correlator , the uv renormalon gives rise to an effective mass of roughly @xmath64 , which is much larger than the usual current quark mass the order of 5 mev @xcite . hence there is some concern that important power corrections associated with uv renormalons has been overlooked in the standard qcd - sr treatment . moreover , it is the power corrections that provide the link to nonperturbative phenomena . to the extent that the power correction is scheme dependent and not reliably known , we will refer to these quark - mass like power corrections as uv renormalon uncertainties . additional evidence for @xmath65-type power corrections independent of renormalons has been obtained through a consideration of constraints imposed by asymptotic freedom and analyticity on the large - order behavior of perturbation theory @xcite . in this case the perturbative series is not borel summable . given the absence of a local gauge - invariant field - operator product of dimension two , some might argue that the coefficient of the singularity in the borel plane governing the large - order behavior of perturbative series must have a zero . however , perturbative estimates of the coefficient do not provide evidence of such a zero @xcite and the issue is unsettled . hence the issue of possible dimension - two power corrections is of current interest . the techniques presented in this manuscript might be used to provide some phenomenological insight into the debate . however , such considerations would take us too far afield and will be deferred to a subsequent analysis @xcite . on the other hand , it is interesting to look for discrepancies which might be rooted in such power corrections , and this is done in the following analysis . to summarize the points of this section , we present the traditional qcd sum rules for the nucleon @xcite obtained from the consideration of the interpolating field @xmath66 of ( [ chisr ] ) to operator dimension 8 . @xmath67 [ tradit ] the dots allow for excited state contributions . ) has had an elusive history . early calculations @xcite appear to have calculated a subset of the diagrams contributing to the dimension 7 operator @xcite . however a more persistent error lies in a factor of 3 correction in the term @xmath68 \left < \overline q q \right > \left < g_c^2 g^2 \right > \sigma_{\alpha \beta } \lambda_{ab}^n/2 $ ] of ( [ quarkgluoncorr ] ) from that used in previous analyses . ] the ioffe formula for the nucleon mass is obtained from ( [ tradit ] ) by keeping the leading terms of the opes and assuming dominance of the ground state on the right - hand side of the equations , @xmath69 [ bigassumption ] the ioffe formula follows from the ratio of these two equations , @xmath70 if one prefers to eliminate the borel mass by selecting @xmath71 , @xmath72 here the quark condensate is estimated from the partially conserved axial current ( pcac ) relation and pion decay to give @xmath73 which corresponds to @xmath74 gev , @xmath75 gev and the average light quark mass is 7 mev . the qualitative features of chiral symmetry breaking coupled with the quantitative success of these relations has lead to enormous faith being placed into the validity of the ioffe formula . most practitioners expect this relation to be valid , at least in a qualitative manner of proportionality . the operator product expansion provides knowledge of the two - point function ( [ twopt ] ) in the near perturbative regime . as such the correlator represents contributions from both the ground state hadron and excited states . to maintain some predictive ability in the qcd - sr approach , a `` continuum model '' for excited state contributions to the correlator is introduced guided by the principle of duality , the leading terms of the ope surviving in the limit @xmath76 are used to model the form of the spectral density accounting for excited state contributions . consider , as an example , the identity operator for the nucleon interpolator @xmath77 of ( [ chisr ] ) . explicitly including the excited state term of ( [ gp ] ) in equation ( [ ioffe1a ] ) leads to @xmath78 for large borel mass . the laplace transform readily provides @xmath79 the continuum model contribution is obtained by introducing a threshold , @xmath80 , at which strength in the excited states becomes significant . such a model is motivated well by the experimental cross section for @xmath81 hadrons . in addition , this approach accommodates the finite widths and the multi - particle continuum of qcd . hence the excited state contributions associated with the identity operator are @xmath82 continuum model contributions associated with @xmath83 and @xmath84 terms are calculated in a similar manner . usually the continuum contributions are placed on the ope side of the sum rules . hence , terms surviving in the limit @xmath76 have the following factors associated with them : @xmath85 \ , , \\ m^4 \ , : & & \left [ 1 - e^{-w^2/m^2 } \ , \left ( { w^2 \over m^2 } + 1 \right ) \right ] \ , , \\ m^2 \ , : & & \left [ 1 - e^{-w^2/m^2 } \right ] \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ continuum ] the contributions of this model relative to the ground state , whose properties one is really trying to determine , are not small . they are typically 10 to 50% @xcite . the validity of this somewhat crude model is relied upon to cleanly remove the excited state contaminations . in the lattice qcd investigation of the continuum model formulated in euclidean space @xcite , the short time regime of point - to - point lattice correlation functions is described well by the qcd - sum - rule - inspired continuum model . there , the laplace transform of the spectral density appears to be sufficient to render any structure in the spectral density insignificant in the short euclidean time regime of point - to - point correlators . similar conclusions are expected to hold for the borel transformed sum rules under investigation here . it should be noted that the spectral density of the physical world is different than that encountered on the lattice . for example , in the nucleon channel one expects strength in the correlator above the ground state to start at the @xmath86 threshold @xcite , whereas in the lattice calculations such contributions are altered by the heavier quark mass and the quenched approximation . while the lattice results are encouraging , one may find that in some cases the continuum model is not sufficiently detailed when the continuum model contributions are large . an example of this will be presented in the discussion surrounding the @xmath0-meson sum rules , where discrepancies may be due to an over simplified continuum model . the origin of the uncertainty estimate for the ope lies in the uncertainties assigned to the qcd parameters appearing in the truncated ope . in this section we assess the uncertainties on these qcd parameters . in assigning these uncertainties one would like to select values conservatively enough such that the qcd - sr approach can test the validity of our present understanding of qcd . qcd - sr predictions that fail to agree with experiment at the @xmath87 level should indicate a possibly interesting discrepancy . at the same time one would also like to select uncertainties in accord with the generally accepted values in the literature . in addition , the error assessments need to reflect uncertainties associated with the factorization of higher dimensional operators and small but never - the - less neglected @xmath3 corrections . these considerations have been balanced in the following . while some may argue that some values are known better than that indicated here , others will no doubt argue that the errors are underestimated . in any event , one will learn for the first time how the uncertainties in the qcd parameters are mapped into uncertainties in the phenomenological fit parameters . in the lattice qcd investigation of ref . @xcite it was noted that interplay between the pole position and continuum threshold lead to rather large uncertainties in the fit parameters . it will be interesting to see how reasonable estimates of the qcd uncertainties are revealed in the fit parameters . for the quark condensate , @xmath88 we note that there are two values commonly found in qcd - sr analyses . pcac and pion decay considerations coupled with quark masses of @xmath89 mev lead to a value of @xmath90 gev@xmath91 . qcd - sr considerations of @xmath92 and octet baryon magnetic moments @xcite prefer a smaller magnitude at @xmath93 gev@xmath91 . expecting the value to lie some where in this regime , we take the average of these values with an uncertainty of half the difference at an 80% confidence level . introducing the standard qcd - sr notation we define @xmath94 this value and uncertainty is also in accord with @xmath95 obtained from more recent quark mass estimates @xcite . early estimates of the gluon condensate @xmath96 from charmonium sum rules @xcite place the value at @xmath97 gev@xmath98 , which is generally referred to as the `` standard value '' @xmath99 however , a number of more recent investigations place the gluon condensate at much larger values @xcite . for example , a finite - energy sum rule ( fesr ) analysis of the @xmath0-meson channel places the gluon condensate at 2 to 5 times the standard value @xcite . in this analysis the spectral density is taken from a fit of the isospin - one channel of @xmath100 scattering data . first results from the aleph and cleo ii experiments @xcite also suggest a larger value at @xmath101 gev@xmath98 . a recent laplace based sum rule analyses @xcite suggests a value of @xmath102 gev@xmath98 , more in accord with the standard value . however , we are somewhat skeptical of the refinements of this result as the analysis is based on an approach which is criticized in the following . the most reliable sum rules of sec . [ nucleon13 ] also prefer a larger gluon condensate in order to maintain consistency between the sum rules . there it is found that the nucleon mass may be reproduced with a value of @xmath103 gev@xmath98 which agrees with experimental estimate . since the gluon condensate plays a critical role in the nucleon sum rules as part of a factorized dimension seven operator we adopt an uncertainty of 50% and take @xmath104 the mixed condensate is parameterized as @xmath105 . early analyses of baryons @xcite as well as more recent analyses of heavy - light quark systems @xcite place @xmath106 gev@xmath107 , while an analysis of @xmath108 qcd - sr sum rules demand @xmath109 to be smaller @xcite at @xmath110 gev@xmath107 . hence we take the average and half the difference as the uncertainty . @xmath111 since the parameter @xmath109 is selected via monte carlo , the value of the mixed condensate is obtained by multiplying @xmath109 by the central value of the quark condensate , as opposed to a randomly selected value of the quark condensate . this is in contrast to factorized operators where both condensates appearing in the operator are selected via monte carlo . relatively little is known about the magnitude of the dimension - six , four - quark operators . early arguments placed the values of these condensates within 10% of the factorized values @xcite . however other analyses claimed significant violation of factorization @xcite for these operators in both nucleon and vector meson sum rules . parameterizing the four quark - operators as @xmath112 , estimates of factorization violation place @xmath113 or more . for the nucleon we consider @xmath114 if one adopts the standard value for the gluon condensate , then @xmath115 is sufficient to reproduce the @xmath0-meson mass . however , selection of the more recent and reliable estimates of @xmath116 demands @xmath117 to reproduce the @xmath0-meson mass . this value is in accord with the observations of refs . @xcite , however the uncertainty on this parameter is large . hence we adopt as opposed to 2 , even a small suppression of the chirally even four - quark condensate at finite density can give rise to substantial suppression of the @xmath0-meson mass and width . further investigation of these issues is warranted . ] @xmath118 figure [ distrib ] displays histograms drawn from 1000 qcd parameter sets for four of the qcd parameters discussed to this point . = variation of the qcd scale parameter @xmath119 has little effect on the results . however , we restrict the values to the conventional range adopted in qcd - srs @xmath120 variation of @xmath119 above 200 mev is only sensible if the separation scale @xmath43 of the ope , taken to be 500 mev , is increased to maintain plausible convergence of the power corrections of the ope . a change in @xmath43 redefines the condensate values . a systematic determination of the new condensate values is beyond the scope of this investigation and we choose to simply restrict the value as above . it is perhaps interesting to note that if @xmath119 is very large , say near the upper limit of the current world average @xcite , the ope separation scale would necessarily become large . consequently , the borel mass would be restricted to larger values , and access to ground state properties may not be possible . the correlator may be dominated by strength from excited states , similar to the present situation for the pseudoscalar pion correlator . fortunately , the lower bound on the current world average for @xmath121 bodes well for present qcd sum rule analyses . however , if the current world average for @xmath119 persists , a comprehensive reformulation of the approach should be pursued . the @xmath0-meson sum rule requires knowledge of @xmath122 at the scale of 1 gev@xmath107 . since this scale is rather low for two - loop perturbation theory , we adopt a 10% uncertainty @xmath123 finally , the @xmath0-meson sum rule requires knowledge of the average light quark mass @xmath44 . since it appears multiplied by the quark condensate , we will use the relation of ( [ gor ] ) and equate @xmath124 monte - carlo techniques might also be used to probe ope truncation errors by randomly selecting the size of the next term to follow the truncated series . the problem lies in determining a sensible and realistic estimate without actually calculating the term . instead , we will emphasize the importance of ope convergence and select the borel analysis regime such that truncated terms are very unlikely to be important . gaussian distributions are generated using established algorithms for the conversion of uniform distributions on the interval ( 0,1 ) @xcite . a particularly fast algorithm used in this investigation is as follows . if @xmath125 and @xmath126 are uniform on ( 0,1 ) , then construct @xmath127 and @xmath128 . calculate @xmath129 . if @xmath130 start over . otherwise , calculate @xmath131 @xmath132 and @xmath133 are independent and normally distributed with mean 0 and variance 1 . a set of gaussianly - distributed randomly - selected condensate values is generated , from which an ope in borel space , @xmath134 , is constructed . by repeating this procedure , an uncertainty for the ope may be determined . selecting @xmath135 evenly distributed points in the borel parameter space @xmath136 , the standard deviation in the ope at the @xmath137th borel mass is given by @xmath138 ^ 2 \ , , \label{sigmaope}\ ] ] where @xmath18 denotes the @xmath18th set of @xmath139 qcd parameter sets and @xmath140 in practice , @xmath141 was used in estimating the ope uncertainty . however , @xmath142 was sufficient to get a stable uncertainty estimate . the uncertainties in the ope are not uniform throughout the borel regime . they are larger at the lower nonperturbative end of the borel region where uncertainties in the higher - dimensional vacuum condensates dominate . hence , it is crucial that the appropriate weight is used in the calculation of @xmath4 . having determined the ope uncertainty , a @xmath4 measure is easily constructed . for the ope obtained from the @xmath143th set of qcd parameters , the @xmath4 per degree of freedom is @xmath144 ^ 2 \over \sigma_{{\rm ope}}^2(m_j ) } \ , , \label{chisq}\ ] ] where @xmath145 is the number of phenomenological search parameters , and @xmath146 denotes the phenomenological spectral representation of the qcd - sr . in practice , @xmath147 points were used along the borel axis . @xmath4 is minimized by adjusting the phenomenological parameters including the pole residue @xmath148 , the hadron mass @xmath149 , and the continuum threshold @xmath150 . distributions for the phenomenological parameters are obtained by minimizing @xmath4 for many qcd parameter sets . provided the resulting distributions are gaussian , an estimate of the uncertainty in the phenomenological results such as the hadron mass is obtained from @xmath151 in the event that the resultant distribution is not gaussian , we will report the median and asymmetric standard deviations from the median . we note that ( [ sigmam ] ) is the standard deviation of the distribution and not the standard error obtained by further dividing by @xmath152 , the number of qcd parameter sets in the sample . the standard deviation is roughly independent of the number of qcd parameter sets used in the analysis , and directly reflects the input parameter uncertainties . in the following , we generally select @xmath153 . while 100 qcd parameter configurations are sufficient for obtaining reliable uncertainty estimates , we also wish to explore correlations among the qcd parameters and the phenomenological fit parameters . the extra sets aid in resolving more subtle correlations . some care must be taken in the interpretation of the @xmath154 . while we are free to choose any number of points @xmath135 along the borel axis for fitting the two sides of the sum rule , it is important to recognize that the actual number of degrees of freedom is determined by the number of terms in the ope . for the @xmath154 to have true statistical meaning , a correlated @xmath4 calculation is required . @xmath155 \times \nonumber \\ & & \quad c_{j\,j'}^{-1 } \left [ \pi^{\rm ope}_k(m_{j ' } ) - \pi^{\rm sr}(m_{j ' } ; \lambda_k , m_k , w_k ) \right ] \ , , \label{corrchisq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath156 is the inverse covariance matrix . the covariance matrix may be estimated by @xmath157 \left [ \pi^{\rm ope}_i(m_{j ' } ) - \overline{\pi^{\rm ope}}(m_{j ' } ) \right ] \label{covar}\ ] ] unfortunately , for most of the fits considered here the covariance matrix is ill - conditioned . inverting the covariance matrix via singular value decomposition leads to well known pathological problems @xcite such as best fit lines which do not pass through the data points etc . while one could experiment with different approaches to stepping around this problem , we prefer to use the robust method of determining best fit parameters by minimizing the uncorrelated @xmath4 of ( [ chisq ] ) . even if some correlation among the data is suspected , it is still acceptable to use the uncorrelated @xmath4 fit provided the errors on the parameters are estimated using a monte - carlo based procedure like that discussed here rather than from the dependence of @xmath4 on the parameters @xcite . when simultaneously fitting multiple sum rules which may have some fit parameters in common , ( [ chisq ] ) is simply modified to @xmath158 ^ 2 \over \sigma_{{\rm ope}}^2{}_i(m_{ij } ) } \ , , \label{chisqmulti}\ ] ] where @xmath18 runs over the considered sum rules . ( in this example , @xmath149 is a common parameter to all @xmath159 sum rules . ) the subscript @xmath18 in @xmath160 indicates that each sum rule has a unique set of @xmath135 borel masses @xmath161 spanning the region of interest in borel space . the subscript @xmath143 in ( [ chisq ] ) , denoting a particular set of qcd parameters , has been suppressed . in the following discussion it will become apparent that it is advantageous to weight the contributions in the sum over the various sum rules by the size of their valid borel regimes . if @xmath162 is the size of the valid borel regime for the @xmath18th sum rule , then ( [ chisqmulti ] ) is modified to @xmath163 ^ 2 \over \sigma_{{\rm ope}}^2{}_i(m_{ij } ) } \ , . \label{chisqweight}\ ] ] the optimization method utilized in this investigation is an updated version of a direction - set routine by powell originally published in ref . this algorithm finds the minimum value of a function by iterative variation of the function parameters which need not be independent . modifications of the original routine improve the selection of conjugate directions in the search and avoid the possible generation of linearly dependent search directions @xcite . powell s method is among the best methods for finding minima in a multidimensional parameter space when derivatives are not readily available @xcite . part of the reason for the robust nature of powell s routine is the cautious criterion for ultimate convergence . once a minimum is found , the optimal vector , @xmath164 , in the parameter space is displaced by ten times the requested accuracy . the search proceeds from this new point until a minimum is found at vector @xmath165 . the minimum on the line joining @xmath164 and @xmath165 is found at @xmath166 . convergence is reached if the components of the vectors @xmath167 and @xmath168 are all less than 10% of the required accuracy . otherwise the direction @xmath167 is utilized in a new search . the displacement of the first minimum by ten times the requested accuracy plays a crucial role in removing the sensitivity of the ultimate minimum from the initial parameter estimates . while there is sufficient flexibility in the algorithm parameters to search in the locality of the initial parameter estimates , the opposite criteria has been utilized in this investigation . one of the main goals of this investigation is to eliminate the possibility of fine tuning the initial parameter estimates which otherwise can bias the results . instead , we are interested in the predictions of the qcd sum rules . the fundamental qcd - sr for the @xmath0 meson follows from the consideration of ( [ twopt ] ) , ( [ chirho ] ) , ( [ rhov ] ) and ( [ continuum ] ) . we consider the correlator , @xmath169 , where the continuum model is subtracted from the phenomenological side and placed on the ope side . @xmath170 + c_1 + { c_2\over m^2 } + { c_3\over 2!\ , m^4 } + \cdots \nonumber \\ & & + { c_m \over ( m-1 ) ! \ , ( m^2)^{m-1 } } + \cdots \ , . \label{rhosr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the wilson coefficients are given by @xcite @xmath171 the phenomenology of the qcd - sr is described by the vector - meson pole of interest plus the continuum model accounting for the contributions of all excited states . by working in a region where the pole dominates the phenomenology , one can minimize sensitivity to the model and have assurance that it is the spectral parameters of the ground state of interest that are being determined by matching the sum rules . in practice , these considerations effectively set an upper limit in the borel parameter space , beyond which the model for excited states dominates the phenomenological side . at the same time , the truncated ope must be sufficiently convergent as to accurately describe the true ope . since the ope is an expansion in the inverse squared borel mass , this consideration sets a lower limit in borel parameter space , beyond which higher order terms not present in the truncated ope are significant and important . monitoring ope convergence is absolutely crucial to recovering nonperturbative phenomena in the sum - rule approach , as it is the lower end of the borel region where the nonperturbative information of the ope is most significant . as we shall see , this information must also be accurate . in short , one should not expect to extract information on the ground state spectral properties unless the ground state dominates the contributions on the phenomenological side and the ope is sufficiently convergent . in this investigation , we will analyze each individual sum rule with regard to the above criteria . a sum rule with an upper limit in borel space lower than the lower limit is considered invalid . as a measure of the relative reliability of various sum rules we consider the size of the regime in borel space where both sides of the sum rules are valid . this quantity is used as a weight in the calculation of the @xmath154 as indicated in ( [ chisqweight ] ) . in addition , the size of continuum contributions throughout the borel region can also serve as a measure of reliability , with small continuum model contributions being more reliable . the fiducial borel region is chosen @xcite such that the highest - dimensional operator(s ) ( hdo ) contribute no more than @xmath172 to the qcd side while the continuum contribution is less than @xmath173 of the total phenomenological side ( i.e. , the sum of the pole and the continuum contribution ) . the former sets a criterion for the convergence of the ope while the latter controls the continuum contribution . while the selection of @xmath174 is obvious for pole dominance , the selection of @xmath175 is a reasonably conservative criterion that has not failed in practice . and @xmath174 criteria are automatically explored in the monte - carlo error analysis , as the condensate values and the continuum threshold change in each sample . ] see ref . @xcite for further specific examples . figure [ sr1hdo ] displays the valid borel window for the @xmath0-meson sum rule of ( [ rhosr ] ) . the hdo contributions limited to @xmath175 of the ope and the continuum model contributions limited to 50% of the phenomenology are illustrated . the continuum contributions are the order of @xmath176 of the phenomenological contributions at the lower end of the borel regime . here , the pole of interest truly dominates the qcd - sr . figure [ sr1fit ] displays the corresponding fit obtained by minimizing @xmath4 in a three parameter search including @xmath177 , @xmath178 and @xmath179 . figure [ binrhomass ] displays the distribution of @xmath0-meson masses obtained from the 1000 sum rule fits . the distribution corresponds to @xmath180 the uncertainty is somewhat larger than the commonly assumed 10% . figure [ binrhof ] displays the distribution of the square of @xmath177 which corresponds to @xmath181 which agrees with the experimental value of @xmath182 gev . the continuum threshold is @xmath183 gev which compares favorably with @xmath184 gev ( the @xmath185 mass less the half width ) , given the approximate nature of the continuum model . = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = in addition to the fundamental sum rule of ( [ rhosr ] ) one also finds the use of sum rules obtained by differentiating ( [ rhosr ] ) with respect to @xmath186 . for the @xmath187th derivative @xmath188 \ , \label{derivsr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] while these sum rules are obviously unnecessary for the extraction of @xmath0-meson properties , the hope is that these additional sum rules will provide new useful information that might be used to further constrain the phenomenological properties . it is possible to isolate the @xmath0-meson mass as a function of the borel mass , by taking a ratio of the first derivative sum rule with the fundamental sum rule . this approach has some aesthetic appeal , and has widely become the method of choice for analyzing qcd - srs . the continuum threshold is selected to make the ratio of the two sum rules as flat as possible as a function of borel mass . finally , the @xmath0-meson mass is selected from the point at which the ratio is most flat or stable . unfortunately , this method has some very unpleasant shortcomings . the ratio method does not check the validity of each individual sum rule . it is possible to have individual sum rules that are not valid while their ratio is flat as function of borel mass . in addition , the ratio method can not account for the fact that sum rules do not work equally well . the borel region where a sum rule is valid can vary from one sum rule to another . moreover , large uncertainties in one sum rule can spoil the predictions of another sum rule . finally , the continuum contributions to the sum rules are not monitored in the ratio method . if the continuum contribution is dominant in a sum rule , one should not expect to get reliable information about the lowest resonance . the fact that sum rules do not work equally well deserves further discussion . in ref . @xcite a detailed comparison of fundamental and derivative sum rules is carried out for the @xmath0 meson . these arguments are not broadly known and are generally applicable to any derivative borel - improved qcd - sr . hence the important observations are highlighted here . if one could carry out the ope to arbitrary accuracy and use a spectral density independent of models for excited state contributions , the predictions based on ( [ rhosr ] ) and those based on the derivative sum rules of ( [ derivsr ] ) should be the same . in practical calculations , however , one has to truncate the ope and use a simple phenomenological ansatz for the spectral density . thus it is unrealistic to expect the sum rules to work equally well . compare the @xmath187th derivative sum rule of ( [ derivsr ] ) with the direct sum rule of ( [ rhosr ] ) . 1 . the perturbative contribution in the derivative sum rule has an extra factor @xmath189 relative to the corresponding term in ( [ rhosr ] ) , implying that the perturbative contribution is more important in the derivative sum rules than in the fundamental sum rule , and becomes increasingly important as @xmath187 increases . since the perturbative term mainly contributes to the continuum of the spectral density , maintaining dominance of the lowest resonance pole in the sum rule will become increasingly difficult as @xmath187 increases . 2 . in ( [ rhosr ] ) , the term proportional to @xmath190 is suppressed by a factor of @xmath191 , while it is only suppressed by @xmath192 in the derivative sum rule ( @xmath193 ) . this implies that the convergence of the ope is much slower in the derivative sum rule than in the fundamental sum rule . consequently , the poorly known high - order power corrections are more important in the derivative sum rule than in eq . ( [ rhosr ] ) , and become more and more important as @xmath187 increases . if one would like to restrict the size of the last term of the ope to maintain some promise of ope convergence , the size of the borel region in which the sum rules are believed to be valid is restricted . 3 . the power corrections proportional to @xmath194 do _ not _ contribute to the @xmath195 derivative sum rule but do contribute to ( [ rhosr ] ) . if one truncates the ope , part or all of the nonperturbative information will be lost in the derivative sum rules . it is also worth noting that the leading power corrections are the most desirable terms to have . they do not give rise to a term in the continuum model and they are not the last term in the ope , whose relative contribution should be restricted to maintain ope convergence . in practice , the predictions based on the fundamental sum rule of ( [ rhosr ] ) are more reliable than those from the derivative sum rules , which become less and less reliable as @xmath187 increases . this can also be demonstrated by analyzing the sum rules numerically . figure [ sr12hdo ] displays the valid borel windows for a simultaneous fit of the @xmath0-meson sum rules of ( [ rhosr ] ) and the first derivative @xmath196 of ( [ derivsr ] ) . the reliability of the fundamental sum rule over the derivative sum rule is obvious . the valid borel regime for the derivative sum rule is nearly nonexistent . all three points of the discussion surrounding derivative sum rules are displayed in this figure . item 1 indicates the continuum model contributions will be much larger in the derivative sum rule for a given borel mass . indeed the continuum model contribution never drops below 45% in the valid regime . the relative contribution of the last term in the truncated ope is larger in the derivative sum rule for a given borel mass , in agreement with the expectations of items 2 and 3 . figure [ sr12fit ] displays the corresponding fit obtained by minimizing the weighted @xmath154 of ( [ chisqweight ] ) in a three parameter search including @xmath177 , @xmath178 and @xmath179 . this time the logarithms of the left- and right - hand sides of equations ( [ rhosr ] ) and ( [ derivsr ] ) are plotted as a function of the inverse squared borel mass . this method has the advantage of revealing the possible breakdown of the ope signified by deviations of the dashed curves from linearity . uncertainties are displayed only at the ends of the borel region for clarity . = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = while the central values of the best fit parameters @xmath197 gev , @xmath198 gev@xmath107 , and @xmath199 gev , remain essentially unchanged , the reduction of the uncertainties comes from rather unreliable information as discussed above . these arguments are further supported by the failure of the two sides of ( [ derivsr ] ) for @xmath200 to agree as illustrated in figure [ sr12fit ] . to further probe the reasons for this failure , the analysis of these sum rules is repeated with a spectral representation that accounts for the finite width of the @xmath0 meson . to account for the finite width of the @xmath0-meson , the @xmath201 function in ( [ rhov ] ) is replaced by a normalized breit - wigner form @xmath202 and the integral over the @xmath0-meson ground state @xmath203 is handled numerically @xcite . using the experimental width of 151.5 mev , a three parameter fit of the fundamental and derivative sum rules with the breit - wigner form leads to essentially the same results reported in figure [ sr12fit ] . the mass , coupling , and continuum threshold all agree within uncertainties , and have similar uncertainties . hence , these spectral properties may be reliably estimated without precise information on the @xmath0 width . however , @xmath2 mixing provides an interesting example where finite mesonic widths can play a central role in arriving at the correct physics @xcite . the origin of the discrepancy for the derivative sum rule is more likely to lie in short - comings of continuum model . for this sum rule the continuum model contributions never drop below 45% , which may be too large for the simple model typically used in qcd - sr calculations . alternatively , poorly known higher order terms , not present in the truncated ope may become important in the derivative sum rule . in the derivative sum rule , the next term in the series is suppressed by merely @xmath204 . the importance of carefully monitoring the validity of qcd - srs is nicely displayed in the recent debate over the behavior of vector - meson masses in nuclear matter . there an analysis involving invalid sum rules leads to the conclusion that vector - meson masses increase in finite density @xcite , in contradiction to a previous analysis @xcite also based on the ratio method . the debate is resolved in ref . @xcite where valid sum rules indicate that vector - meson masses decrease for increasing nuclear matter density . having firmly established the analysis procedure in the well understood @xmath0-meson channel , we are ready to apply the same approach to the nucleon sum rules . we will find that many results contradict the conventional wisdom . here we focus on the borel improved qcd sum rules for the generalized interpolator of ( [ chio ] ) . the sum rules proportional to the correlator @xmath205 where continuum model contributions are subtracted from the phenomenological side and placed on the ope side are @xmath206 \nonumber \\ & & \quad + { 5 + 2 \beta + 5 \beta^2 \over 256 } \ , b \ , m^2 \ , l^{-4/9 } \left [ 1 - e^{-w_1 ^ 2/m^2 } \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \quad + { 7 - 2 \beta - 5 \beta^2 \over 24 } \ , a^2 \ , l^{4/9 } -{13 - 2 \beta - 11 \beta^2 \over 96 } \ , { m_0 ^ 2 \ , a^2 \over m^2 } \ , l^{-2/27 } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad = \widetilde \lambda_{\cal o}^2 \ , e^{-m_n^2/m^2 } \ , , \label{nucl11atp } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath207 \nonumber \\ & & \quad -{3 ( 1 - \beta^2 ) \over 16 } \ , m_0 ^ 2 \ , a \ , m^2 \ , l^{-14/27 } \left [ 1 - e^{-w_2 ^ 2/m^2 } \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \quad + { 19 + 10 \beta - 29 \beta^2 \over 2 ^ 7 \ , 3 ^ 2 } \ , a \ , b \nonumber \\ & & \qquad = \widetilde \lambda_{\cal o}^2 \ , m_n \ , e^{-m_n^2/m^2 } \ , , \label{nucl11at1}\]][nucl11 ] where the dirac-@xmath26 structures are indicated on the left , and @xmath208 . the factors of @xmath209 $ ] account for the anomalous scaling of the operators and interpolators in the leading logarithmic approximation @xcite . let us begin with the traditional or standard nucleon sum rule analysis where @xmath3 corrections are ignored . the more common interpolator of ( [ chisr ] ) is utilized by setting @xmath14 in ( [ nucl11 ] ) . in addition , the traditional condensate parameter set with @xmath210 is selected in order to evaluate the validity of previously published results . for a preliminary analysis of the validities of the sum rules , the nucleon mass is fixed to 1 gev . figure [ sr34k2hdo ] illustrates the valid borel regimes for these two sum rules found by implementing the procedure discussed for the @xmath0-meson . = 11.7truecm = a comparison of figure [ sr34k2hdo ] with the analogous figure [ sr12hdo ] for the @xmath0-meson suggests the nucleon sum rules will not be as reliable . in the nucleon sum rules , the continuum model contributes 20% or more to the phenomenological side of the sum rules . in particular , the continuum model contribution in the sum rule of ( [ nucl11atp ] ) exceeds that for the derivative @xmath0-meson sum rule which has already been shown to be incompatible with the fundamental sum rule . it should not be surprising to find a similar disaster for the nucleon case . as in the @xmath0-meson case , there is an analogous ratio method for obtaining the nucleon mass that has also become popular . here the nucleon mass is isolated as a function of the borel mass by taking the ratio of equations ( [ nucl11at1])/([nucl11atp ] ) . the mass is usually extracted from a regime in which the ratio is flat . again ope convergence and ground - state dominance criteria are not checked in this approach , and too often the mass is extracted from a regime in which the continuum model dominates . figure [ sr34k2fit ] illustrates the three parameter fit of the residue @xmath148 , and the two continuum model thresholds of @xmath211 and @xmath212 . the small borel regime and the relatively huge ope uncertainties of the sum rule of ( [ nucl11atp ] ) indicate that this sum rule plays a negligible role in determining the spectral properties of the nucleon . this is a perfect example of a case where large uncertainties in the sum rule of ( [ nucl11atp ] ) would spoil the predictive ability of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) if the ratio method was used . the origin of the large uncertainties lies in the poorly known value of the four - quark condensate . the resultant fit parameters for this sum rule are also unphysical as the continuum threshold lies at zero below the nucleon pole . in other words , the present form of the sum rule at @xmath213 is unable to provide any information on the ground state that is consistent with the more reliable sum rule of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) at the structure 1 . = 11.7truecm = unfortunately , the community has incorrectly identified ( [ nucl11atp ] ) as the more reliable sum rule . this belief is based on the simple fact that the leading term of the ope ( the identity operator ) has a well known vacuum expectation value . however , the @xmath3 corrections for the identity operator @xcite are uncomfortably large . the first order corrections are independent of @xmath214 and are @xmath215 where @xmath216 . this correction is @xmath217% and suggests perturbative corrections are completely out of control for this sum rule . since the magnitude of the identity operator contribution is closely tied to the size of continuum model contributions , it is not surprising to find the valid borel regime for this sum rule disappears when @xmath3 corrections are added . another factor in the traditional preference of ( [ nucl11atp ] ) over ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) is that the second term of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) vanishes for ioffe s choice of nucleon interpolator @xmath218 . this is really nothing more than a good reason to exclude the interpolator @xmath77 of ( [ chisr ] ) as an optimal interpolator . when one considers the monstrous leading - order @xmath3 corrections , the possibility of a significant dimension - two power correction arising from a summation of the perturbative series @xcite , and the large uncertainties associated with the value of the four - quark condensate , one can not help but reach the conclusion that the qcd side of the sum rule of ( [ nucl11atp ] ) is really unknown . since the sum rule of ( [ nucl11atp ] ) has traditionally been the nucleon sum rule of choice , it is interesting to consider the predictions of this sum rule alone . applying the same techniques as used for the @xmath0-meson to ( [ nucl11atp ] ) , a three parameter fit of @xmath148 , @xmath211 and @xmath219 yields @xmath220 while setting @xmath221 slightly increases the nucleon mass to 0.47 gev , adding leading order @xmath3 corrections has a negligible effect on the fit parameters . consideration of the more recent condensate parameter set discussed in sec . [ uncert ] leads to similar results @xmath222 this may be the first qcd sum rule to predict spectral properties that significantly contradict experiment . as such , this may be the most interesting of all qcd sum rules , and we shall return to this sum rule after examining the selection of the most optimal interpolator for nucleon sum rule analyses . the predictions of ( [ nucl11atp ] ) summarized in ( [ failure ] ) are extremely different from that found in the literature . hence it is important to understand how these new results come about . a critical examination of the nucleon ground state results reported in ref . @xcite by the present author sheds considerable light on the importance of the rigorous qcd - sr analysis presented here . @xcite was the first analysis to give careful regard to the issues of ope convergence and ground - state dominance of the phenomenological side . moreover , all phenomenological parameters were included as fit parameters to be determined by the sum rules . however , there are three important differences between the analysis presented here and that of ref . @xcite . 1 . the standard logarithmic measure @xcite of sum rule agreement was used to fit the sum rules . this approach fails to apply an appropriate weight to sum rule discrepancies , unlike the @xmath4 measure of ( [ chisq ] ) . 2 . the algorithm used to fit the sum rules did not employ the cautious convergence criteria discussed in section [ algorithm ] . implementation of the new criteria aids in avoiding insignificant local minima . 3 . only the standard condensate parameter set was considered in determining the nucleon mass . here 1000 sets are considered . the optimal parameter set found in ref . @xcite corresponds to a local minimum which is sensitive to the measure of sum rule agreement , the initial parameter estimates and the condensate parameter set . other authors have managed to keep the nucleon mass closer to the experimental result by extracting the result from a regime in borel space that provides the correct answer or fixing the continuum threshold to values suggested by the particle data tables . as we shall see in section [ correl ] , fixing the continuum threshold to phenomenologically motivated values largely determines the mass . hence you _ can _ get anything you want provided you are clever enough to fix the threshold to the _ right _ value . and since the excited states are modeled there is tremendous freedom in the threshold parameter space . of course , such input may not be in agreement with the content of the ope . in any event , such results must not be regarded as predictions of qcd sum rules . having established the nucleon sum rule of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) at the structure 1 to be the potentially more reliable sum rule , it is important to determine the optimal mixing of spin-1/2 interpolators for this sum rule . it has long been established that there are two independent interpolating fields with no derivatives having the quantum numbers of spin 1/2 and isospin 1/2 . both are expected to excite the ground state nucleon from the vacuum . as such , there is a history of argument over the optimal nucleon interpolating field to be used in analyses @xcite and this issue is recognized to be of paramount importance @xcite . while some advocate an interpolating field for which the leading terms of the ope are stationary with respect to the interpolating field mixing parameter @xcite , others argue that a balance between ope convergence and qcd continuum contributions must be maintained @xcite . ideally , one would like to simply calculate with alternate interpolating fields and confirm that the nucleon properties remain unchanged . however , previous implementations of the qcd - sr approach have hindered any firm conclusions . the rigorous analysis introduced here will shed considerable light on these issues . fortunately , the lattice approach to qcd is not plagued with the same limitations and the debate over the optimal interpolating field was resolved in ref . there is was found that , to a good approximation , @xmath223 of ( [ chin2 ] ) excites pure qcd continuum . since @xmath223 has negligible overlap with the ground state nucleon , it is tempting to simply conclude that the optimal interpolating field is @xmath224 . while this is certainly the case for lattice qcd investigations , it is not the case for qcd - sr analyses . by including @xmath223 components in an interpolating field , one can reduce the continuum contributions excited by @xmath224 and allow a broader borel analysis window in which better contact with the ground state of interest is obtained . one of the most difficult things to monitor in the qcd - sr approach is whether the ope is sufficiently convergent for a particular value of borel mass . the lattice results of ref . @xcite indicate the @xmath225 correlator has the fastest converging ope , as its overlap with the nucleon ground state is negligible . similarly , the combination @xmath226 produces an ope with the slowest convergence , as this correlation function is dominated by the ground state nucleon for small borel masses . hence , errors made in truncating the ope are dominated by errors in the @xmath226 component of the general correlator . the relative error in the ope truncation can be reduced by adding @xmath223 components to the correlator . however , the @xmath223 components in the ope are simply subtracted off again by the continuum model terms . hence the relevant error is the absolute error . for @xmath227 , this error is dominated by @xmath226 components of the correlator . as a result , ope truncation errors are approximately independent of @xmath214 . this crucial point has been neglected in previous arguments regarding the optimal nucleon interpolating field . since the errors made in truncating the ope are dominated by errors in the @xmath226 component of the general correlator the criteria of a 10% limit on the hdo contribution to the ope should be applied to sum rules when @xmath228 . once this lower limit is established , it may be used for all @xmath227 . we will refer to this approach for determining the valid borel regime as the `` refined '' method in the following . the optimal nucleon interpolator must involve @xmath224 , as this interpolator is required to maintain overlap with the ground state . the task is to determine the optimal mixing of @xmath223 . since @xmath223 has negligible overlap with the nucleon , the ground state contribution to a sum rule is also independent of @xmath214 . hence , the size of the continuum model contribution is the predominant factor in determining the optimal interpolator . figure [ optcon ] illustrates the contributions of the continuum model terms in ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) for @xmath229 gev and @xmath230 gev . the following discussion is not dependent on the precise values of these parameters . the first point to be made is that contributions from the continuum model are largest for @xmath231 . this selection of mixing is the worst possible choice for extracting information on the ground state nucleon . = 11.7truecm = figure [ optcon ] also indicates it is possible to have vanishing continuum model contributions at @xmath232 or @xmath233 . however , we are relying on the continuum model to account for strength in the correlator that does not have its origin in the ground state . without a continuum model , one would need to include additional poles on the right - hand - side of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) to account for positive and negative parity excitation strength . for @xmath234 or @xmath235 the correlator is negative indicating the sum rule is saturated by a negative parity state . thus the optimal interpolator is @xmath236 or @xmath237 . to discriminate between these two regimes , we turn to the higher - dimension - operator contributions which do not contribute to the continuum model . it is these terms that provide crucial information on whether the strength in the correlator lies in the ground state or the excited states . if these terms are absent , the optimal fit of the correlator is obtained when @xmath238 and @xmath239 . in this case the continuum model and the ope become equivalent via the laplace transform of ( [ laplacetrans ] ) and the fit is perfect . hence the higher - dimension - operator contributions should be large in magnitude . a change in sign from the leading terms of the ope will also assist in distinguishing ground state strength from excited state strength as the change in the curvature of the correlator will be more prominent . the last term of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) is independent of the continuum model , and its value is plotted as a function of beta in figure [ optcon ] . the contributions are larger for @xmath236 than for @xmath240 . in addition , the sign of the contribution is opposite that of the continuum model contributions . hence the preferred regime is @xmath236 . these arguments are supported by the numerical analysis described below . in summary , the lattice results indicate ope convergence , and ground state pole contributions are approximately independent of @xmath214 . considerations of the size of continuum model contributions and the sign and magnitude of operators independent of the continuum model leads to the preferred value of @xmath241 a more precise determination of @xmath214 will depend on the details of limits for continuum model and hdo contributions , condensate values , and other parameters of the sum rules . at @xmath242 , where the leading term of the ope is stationary with respect to @xmath214 @xcite , the continuum contributions are maximal . the positive value and small magnitude of the hdo contribution indicates the stability of the leading terms of the ope will not be realized as stability in the ground state mass , coupling , nor in the continuum threshold . another point of view argues that the optimal interpolating field is one that eliminates direct instanton contributions from the correlator @xcite . however , such arguments are based on the assumption that direct instantons necessarily contribute to the nucleon correlator in a significant manner . section [ instantons ] will demonstrate that direct instantons are not necessary to maintain sum rule self consistency for a wide range of interpolating fields . the @xmath214 dependence of the direct instanton contributions to ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) is proportional to @xmath243 . minimization of instanton contributions would place @xmath244 , very near @xmath245 where the hdo term of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) vanishes and where continuum contributions are near their peak . isolation of ground state contributions is nearly impossible in this regime . therefore minimization of direct instanton contributions does not lead to an optimal interpolating field . while it is important to establish the optimal mixing of interpolating fields for qcd - sr analyses , one should not overlook the fact that there is a range of values for @xmath214 where the sum rules are expected to work . moreover , the ground state contribution to all these sum rules is equivalent to the 1% level @xcite . in other words , the right - hand side of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) for a single pole plus continuum model is independent of @xmath214 . after the first sum rule is written down , additional sum rules may be introduced with merely one new fit parameter ( the continuum threshold ) per sum rule . since direct instanton contributions to the sum rules are not independent of @xmath214 @xcite , one has an excellent opportunity to see if direct instanton contributions really are necessary to maintain sum - rule consistency . this issue is addressed in section [ instantons ] below . having discovered that @xmath223 has negligible overlap with the nucleon ground state , it might be interesting to return to the `` ioffe formula '' this time generalized for arbitrary @xmath214 @xmath246 \ , { 4 \ , \left ( 2 \pi \right ) ^2 \ , \langle \overline q q \rangle \over m^2 } \ , .\ ] ] for @xmath228 , @xmath247 gev when @xmath248 gev , or @xmath249 gev when @xmath71 gev . the explicit dependence on the choice of interpolating field and the borel mass limits the significance of the `` ioffe formula '' to a qualitative role at best . here we focus on the more reliable sum rule of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) at the optimal interpolator mixing of @xmath250 . fortunately , the @xmath3 corrections for the leading order operator of the ope are much smaller than for the identity operator at the order of 10% . the @xmath214-dependent coefficient of the quark condensate in ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) becomes @xcite @xmath251 these corrections are small relative to uncertainties in the other terms of the correlator and can be absorbed by a small shift in the condensate itself . since our qcd parameter set is extracted from analyses with neglected @xmath3 corrections , we shall do the same here . armed with knowledge of the optimal interpolator , and a refined understanding of ope convergence tests , we now present the qcd - sr predictions for the nucleon spectral properties from spin-1/2 interpolators . figure [ sr4hdo ] displays the valid borel regime for this sum rule . the hdo contributions are less than 10% of the ope contributions for this fit when @xmath228 , as indicated by the solid curve . as described above , contributions from correlator components known to be more convergent increase the hdo operator contributions making resolution of the pole from the continuum more probable . = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = figure [ sr4fit ] displays the fit for this sum rule . the near perfect linearity of the ope@xmath252continuum side of @xmath205 supports the arguments presented above . despite 40% contributions of the hdo term to this sum rule , the ope@xmath252continuum side displays the anticipated behavior of reasonable ope convergence . the optimal fit parameters obtained from consideration of 1000 qcd parameter sets are @xmath253 the uncertainty of the nucleon mass is more than double the traditional expectation at 260 mev . figures [ sr4binm ] , [ sr4binw ] , and [ sr4binlambda ] display histograms for the nucleon mass , threshold and residue respectively . these histograms will aid in the discussion of the following section . = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = table [ comparesr ] compares the prediction for @xmath254 with other estimates of @xmath255 . this residue corresponds to ioffe s interpolator of ( [ chisr ] ) and is expected to be independent of @xmath227 to the order of 1% @xcite . 0.0(0 ) .comparison of predictions for @xmath256 for various approaches to qcd . [ cols="<,<,^ " , ] what this indicates is that the intimate relationship between the quark condensate and the nucleon mass suggested in the `` ioffe formula '' is invalid . considering the assumptions made in deriving the `` ioffe formula '' one might expect the quark condensate value to be tied more tightly to the continuum model than the ground state pole , and this is borne out in table [ nucleoncorr ] . there the quark condensate plays the dominant role in determining the continuum model threshold . of course , all the condensate values themselves are correlated by the theory of qcd , and this correlation has not been included in this analysis . it may very well be that the nucleon mass is positively correlated with the quark condensate when the higher dimension condensates are also correlated with the quark condensate . the important point to recognize is that the correlation does not come about through some direct connection such as the `` ioffe formula '' . moreover , we are extracting nucleon properties in a borel regime in which these leading order condensates just happen to be the dominant ones . one could also extract the mass from much deeper in the non - perturbative regime , perhaps by a lattice qcd calculation . there , it is much higher dimension operators which account for the same nucleon mass @xcite . therefore , it is really impossible to identify a particular condensate for giving rise to ground state hadron properties . the only true statement that may be made about the relationship between condensates and spectral properties is what we have known all along : the condensates reflecting chiral symmetry breaking play a significant role in determining hadron properties . correlations among the phenomenological fit parameters themselves are qualitatively different from the correlations with the qcd parameters . figures [ rhowlambda ] , [ rhomw ] and [ rhomlambda ] display the close correspondence between all three of the fit parameters , @xmath179 , @xmath177 , and @xmath178 obtained from 1000 fits of ( [ rhosr ] ) . this close association between the @xmath0-meson spectral parameters suggests an underlying constraint on the fit parameters . indeed , local duality necessarily leads to correlations among the spectral parameters . to examine the correlations of local duality in an analytical but qualitative fashion , consider the finite energy sum rules ( fesr ) @xcite obtained from @xmath257 here , @xmath258 is given by ( [ rhovb ] ) and @xmath259 is the qcd evaluation of ( [ twopt ] ) at the structure @xmath260 . the weighting function @xmath261 for fesr is taken to be @xmath262 . these functions weight excited state contributions in favor of ground state contributions and , as such , fesr are inappropriate for a quantitative determination of ground state properties . however , the first moment and , to a lesser extent , the second moment of the fesrs can provide some general insight into the relationships among the spectral parameters . taking @xmath263 and @xmath264 yields the following two relationships @xmath265 [ fesrrho ] in a qualitative sense , the contributions from the ope on the right - hand side of ( [ fesrs ] ) are negligible . in this case ( [ fesrrho ] ) implies @xmath266 [ fesrrel ] these relationships , capturing the features of local duality in a qualitative sense , are independent of the precise values of the qcd parameters . the relationships remain prominent in the more quantitative borel sum rule analysis as indicated in figures [ rhowlambda ] , [ rhomw ] and [ rhomlambda ] . of course , the borel analysis is done independent of these qualitative constraints . the first relation , the most reliable fesr relation , is satisfied remarkably well . = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = an even more striking correlation is illustrated in figure [ sr4corrmw ] for the nucleon sum rule of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) with the optimal @xmath250 . the association between the continuum threshold and the nucleon mass is nearly one - to - one despite the underlying scatter of qcd parameter values . the explanation for this phenomena is that there is a single term in ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) which is capable of resolving the pole from the continuum . the two leading terms of the ope are used in deriving the continuum model . hence if the third term is vanishingly small , the best fit is most certainly pure continuum @xmath239 as the sum rule is satisfied as a perfect laplace transform . the few points lying above the curve in figure [ sr4corrmw ] where the mass equals the threshold are cases where the third term in the sum rule has failed to resolve the pole from the continuum . figure [ sr4corrmlambda ] displays the corresponding association for the mass and the residue of the pole . in the @xmath0-meson case there are in fact two terms independent of the continuum model in ( [ rhosr ] ) . both terms act together to resolve the pole and continuum and hence give rise to some scatter in the mass threshold association . scatter in the residue of the pole reflects the fact that all terms affect the strength of the pole . the strong associations among nucleon spectral parameters reflect the underlying constraints of local duality . relationships analogous to the fesr for the @xmath0 meson may be derived for the nucleon spectral parameters @xcite . however , the larger continuum model contributions to the nucleon correlator make the use of fesr less desirable . the approximate nature of the continuum model may be too crude for a weighting function that fails to suppress excited state strength in the spectral density . the resultant fesr relations are relatively crude and do not capture the essence of local duality as well as in the @xmath0-meson case . a very different picture develops for the correlations among the nucleon fit parameters obtained from the analysis of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) for the unfavorable value of @xmath267 . figure [ sr4at0.8corrmw ] displays the correlation between the mass and the continuum threshold , @xmath212 . the corresponding correlation between the mass and the residue is illustrated in figure [ sr4at0.8corrmlambda ] . = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = the nature of the three regimes discussed earlier in section [ secnucl11at1.8 ] is resolved here . the near - pure continuum fits are revealed in the lower - left corner of the mass - threshold scatter plot of figure [ sr4at0.8corrmw ] . the collision of the continuum threshold and the nucleon mass gives rise to the intermediate regime where the gap between ground and excited states has not been resolved . the smaller residue compensating for strength from the continuum model in these fits is illustrated in figure [ sr4at0.8corrmlambda ] . the third pole - plus - continuum regime displays the same near one - to - one correspondence between the mass and the threshold as seen in figure [ sr4corrmw ] for the optimal @xmath250 . the correlations among the spectral parameters are interesting because they reveal the manner in which the sum rules work . correlations among the fit parameters from the simultaneous analysis of ( [ nucl13atgg ] ) and ( [ nucl13atgqq ] ) at @xmath228 are illustrated in figures [ sr467corrmw2 ] and [ sr467corrmlambda2 ] . these distributions are similar to those for the celebrated @xmath0-meson sum rule , and reflect the presence of two terms separating pole from continuum . = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = arguments favoring the need for direct instanton contributions to the qcd side of qcd - srs @xcite are based on the assumption that the average instanton size @xcite , @xmath268 fm @xmath269 fm , the separation scale of the ope . even though @xmath270 , proponents of direct instanton contributions still argue that the effects of instantons are not sufficiently accounted for in qcd condensates alone . the analysis of direct instantons in nucleon sum rules are based on many additional assumptions . here we focus on the most recent investigation of ref . @xcite . there , @xmath3 corrections to the identity operator are neglected . as discussed in section [ nucleon11 ] these leading order corrections are 50% and suggest that @xmath3 corrections are completely out of control . moreover the possibility of a significant dimension - two power correction arising from a summation of the perturbative series , uncertainties surrounding the factorization of the four - quark operator , coupled with an absence of a valid borel regime for the sum rule of ( [ nucl11atp ] ) make any conclusions dubious . in addition , the ope is truncated at dimension six . as we saw in section [ nucleon11 ] the dimension six , seven , and eight operators are crucial to separating the ground state pole from the continuum . without the dimension seven term , the best fit of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) is pure continuum . the fit is perfect when @xmath239 and @xmath271 . hence , the nucleon sum rule at the structure 1 in ref . @xcite ( equation 12 ) is unstable by design . any further discussion of stabilizing the sum rule by adding instanton contributions is uninteresting . finally , issues surrounding the problems of double counting were handled crudely by simply eliminating ope contributions beyond dimension five . hence one should not be prejudiced by existing analyses suggesting nucleon sum rules require direct instanton contributions . the issue is really not settled . for the spin-1/2 interpolator of ( [ chin1 ] ) , direct instanton contributions to the sum rule of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) are governed by the factor @xcite @xmath272 the direct instanton contributions were argued to be of vital importance in ref . @xcite in the vicinity of @xmath273 . in the lattice qcd investigation of @xcite it was discovered that the overlap of the interpolator @xmath223 with the nucleon ground state is one hundred times smaller than that for @xmath224 . while the nucleon mass is certainly independent of the interpolating field mixing parameter @xmath214 , one also has the residue of the pole , @xmath148 , independent of @xmath214 at the 1% level . this anticipated independence of both ground state properties provides new opportunities for evaluating the necessity of direct instanton effects . as a first test of sum rule consistency , we utilize the sum rule of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) to extract the mass as a function of the interpolating field mixing parameter @xmath214 . as @xmath274 the terms contributing to the continuum model become very small and additional poles must be added to the phenomenological side of the sum rule to account for strength in the correlator lying above the ground state mass . as a result we restrict @xmath275 . valid borel regimes were found over the range @xmath276 . the coefficient @xmath277 changes by 50% over this range . if direct instanton contributions are indeed important at @xmath278 , the absence of direct instanton contributions in this investigation might be revealed by a significant @xmath214 dependence in the nucleon mass . figure [ sr4massevol ] displays the ratio of the nucleon mass extracted at @xmath214 to the value obtained at the optimal @xmath279 . uncertainties are obtained from two uncorrelated samples of 200 qcd parameter sets . as such the central value at @xmath250 need not be 1 . the large uncertainties associated with this sum rule prevent a sensitive test of the necessity of direct instantons . it is clear that all ratios accommodate the ratio of 1 . = 11.7truecm = a more demanding test may be performed using the sum rules arising from the consideration of the overlap of spin-1/2 and spin-3/2 interpolators . the smaller uncertainties allow a more interesting examination of these issues . in addition , the continuum model terms are independent of @xmath214 and provide a wider range of @xmath214 in which a valid borel regime exists . figure [ massevol ] addresses the dependence of the nucleon mass obtained from the sum rules of ( [ nucl13atgg ] ) and ( [ nucl13atgqq ] ) on the interpolating field mixing parameter @xmath214 . here , ratios of the mass obtained at finite @xmath214 to @xmath228 are displayed . sum rule consistency demands that all ratios agree with one , and this is satisfied in figure [ massevol ] without direct instanton contributions . the uncertainty estimates are obtained from two uncorrelated samples of 200 qcd parameter sets . we note that a valid regime does not exist for @xmath280 . hence the use of the ioffe interpolator ( @xmath14 ) is a particularly unfavorable choice for these sum rules . the large error bar at @xmath281 reflects the small valid borel regime used in the fit . = 11.7truecm = the corresponding dependence of @xmath148 on @xmath214 is plagued by huge uncertainties . small changes in the nucleon mass which appears squared in the exponential of the phenomenological side of the sum rules leads to large fluctuations in @xmath148 . hence it is difficult to gain any information on the possible size of direct instanton contributions . however , they are certainly unnecessary as all ratios encompass 1 . in order to proceed , we consider fixing the nucleon mass to the value determined at @xmath228 in an attempt to reduce the uncertainty in @xmath148 . figure [ lambdaevolmfixed ] displays these ratios . the corresponding plot for the continuum threshold is given in figure [ contevol ] . = 11.7truecm = = 11.7truecm = for @xmath282 the continuum threshold tends to rise and the distribution of the residue remains largely independent of @xmath214 without direct instanton contributions . for @xmath283 the continuum threshold drops to account for strength that would otherwise be absorbed by the rising nucleon mass as illustrated in figure [ massevol ] . with the threshold near the pole position , strength which might otherwise rest in the pole has been suppressed as discussed in section [ phenomcorr ] . hence the drop in the residue is an artifact of our fixing the nucleon mass in an attempt to reduce the error bar . in summary , the independence of the mass and residue from @xmath227 is satisfied within uncertainties in the absence of direct instanton contributions . as the sum rules are improved in the future and qcd input parameters are better determined , it will be important to repeat this analysis to again evaluate the necessity of direct instanton contributions or other refinements of the qcd - sr approach . at present , direct instanton contributions are not required . this is good news indeed as the amount of modeling required for instanton estimates is relatively unpalatable when compared to that for the standard qcd - srs themselves . in fact a preferable approach would be to simply raise the ope separation scale further into the perturbative regime to ensure that direct instanton effects are more fully accounted . however , this does not yet appear to be necessary . ground state properties have been found to be independent of the interpolating field mixing parameter @xmath214 . on the other hand , the leading terms of the ope for ( [ nucl11 ] ) are very dependent on @xmath214 . this situation has interesting ramifications for previous analyses of coordinate space point - to - point correlation functions @xcite where there has been some confusion surrounding the physics represented in point - to - point correlation functions . in ref . @xcite some conclusions are drawn from an incorrect interpretation of the physics represented in two - point correlators . these authors suggest that the behavior of a ratio of the interacting to free correlator can reveal information on clustering in the scalar diquark channel . it should be emphasized that the phenomenological description of the two - point function involves the baryon mass , the continuum threshold describing the effective onset of excited states and the residue of the pole which indicates the ability of the particular interpolator to excite the baryon from the qcd vacuum . information on quark configurations in the nucleon wave function is absent in point - to - point correlation functions . the coordinate - space correlator may be obtained from ( [ rhop ] ) or ( [ rho1 ] ) via @xmath284 the important point here is that for large @xmath285 , @xmath286 is dominated by the contribution from the ground state pole . as such @xmath286 is independent of @xmath227 at the 1% level , or alternatively @xmath286 is independent of @xmath287 at the 10% level @xcite . the coordinate space analyses focused on a ratio of @xmath288 where @xmath289 is the free coordinate - space correlator . for the correlator at the structure @xmath290 studied in @xcite at @xmath14 , the generalized free correlator is given by @xmath291 since the denominator is @xmath214 dependent and the numerator is independent of @xmath214 for large @xmath285 , the ratio is dependent on @xmath214 . the rate at which the curve turns up as the ground state dominates and the free correlator continues to drop off for increasing @xmath285 is dependent on the interpolator mixing parameter @xmath214 . the rate at which the ratio increases above 1 describes the relative weightings of ground versus excited states generated by the interpolating field . it has nothing to do with the possibility of scalar diquark degrees of freedom being predominant in the nucleon wave function . moreover , a comparison with a @xmath292 correlation function for example has no meaning . a rigorous procedure for extracting quantities of phenomenological interest from qcd sum rules has been established . we have performed a comprehensive analysis of ground state @xmath0-meson and nucleon qcd sum rules . the inclusion of uncertainty estimates for the phenomenological parameters has allowed us to evaluate the predictive ability and self consistency of the qcd - srs . when the analysis is done rigorously , qcd sum rules are predictive . some have argued that fitting sum rules appears to be more of an art than a science . indeed , many of the findings here contradict the conventional wisdom of both practitioners and skeptics alike @xcite and suggests that past arguments have been based more on rhetoric than sound scientific arguments . * the nucleon sum rule of ( [ nucl11atp ] ) , traditionally taken to be the most reliable sum rule , fails to have a borel regime where both the truncated ope is reasonably convergent and the ground state dominates the phenomenology . * the nucleon sum rule of ( [ nucl11at1 ] ) , also obtained from spin-1/2 interpolating fields , resolves the nucleon mass to @xmath293 mev . this uncertainty is more than double the value commonly assumed by most practitioners . * the nucleon sum rules of ( [ nucl13atgg ] ) and ( [ nucl13atgqq ] ) obtained from the consideration of a spin-3/2 isospin-1/2 interpolator projected by the generalized spin-1/2 isospin-1/2 interpolator are much more reliable than the traditional sum rules . they have greater overlap with the ground state pole relative to the continuum model , have broader valid borel regimes and provide phenomenological estimates of nucleon spectral properties which are more stable than those obtained from the conventional sum rules . * the nucleon mass obtained from a simultaneous analysis of ( [ nucl13atgg ] ) and ( [ nucl13atgqq ] ) at the optimal @xmath228 is resolved to @xmath294 mev using qcd parameter estimates from the literature . * the dependence of the spectral parameters on the interpolating field mixing parameter is in accord with expectations without resort to direct instanton contributions . this is compelling evidence that instanton physics is adequately accounted for in the nonperturbative vacuum expectation values . the latter point is truly exciting for the qcd sum rule approach . the amount of modeling required for instanton estimates is relatively unpalatable when compared to that for the standard qcd - srs themselves . * the leading order @xmath3 corrections are the order of 50% . as such , perturbative corrections to this sum rule are very likely out of control . * summation of the perturbative series may give rise to an important dimension - two contribution @xcite . the size of such a correction is presently unknown . * contributions from the four - quark condensate are not well known and appear to be large . unlike the @xmath0-meson sum rule , the four - quark condensate is not suppressed by a factor of @xmath3 . * a regime in which the ope is reasonably convergent while the phenomenological description is dominated by the ground state pole is non - existent . if one proceeds with this sum rule , the results are very sensitive to the model for the continuum , or inaccuracies in the ope lead to incorrect results as seen here . the `` ioffe formula '' directly relating the nucleon mass to the local chiral condensate has been found to be misleading at best . while there is a strong connection between chiral symmetry breaking and hadron properties , such detailed or direct relationships are impossible to make and it is inappropriate to be more specific on the origin of the nucleon mass . the fundamental and derivative sum rules for the @xmath0 meson have also been examined . once again , the popular sum rule analysis has been found to be undesirable . the use of derivative sum rules for the determination of @xmath0-meson spectral properties is unfavorable . increased continuum model contributions , poorer ope convergence , and loss of vital information in the derivative sum rule results in discrepancies between the fundamental and derivative sum rules . the associations among the phenomenological fit parameters are particularly interesting as they reveal how the sum rules resolve the spectral properties . we have found that the separation of the ground state from the excited state continuum model is completely determined by the high dimension operators of the ope which are not used in formulating the continuum model . the practice of fixing the continuum threshold to a preferred value has been exposed as strongly determining the outcome of the sum rule analysis . qcd sum rule determinations of phenomenological spectral properties are necessarily dependent on the treatment of high dimension operators where a factorization assumption is usually invoked . moreover , careful attention to ope convergence is crucial to extracting meaningful results . these issues are somewhat unsettling , as we are working with expansions which are asymptotic . the emphasis here has been on exploring the qcd parameter space via monte carlo . further refinements of the parameter space might be made by adjusting the valid borel regime for each qcd parameter set such that the 10%50% criteria are satisfied . this was not done here in order to explore other criteria and reduce the sensitivity to a reasonable yet somewhat arbitrary criteria . in addition , the hlder inequalities might be applied as a further check of the validity and consistency of the sum rules @xcite . we are now in an excellent position to attack phenomena which is of current interest to the nuclear physics community . the techniques are currently being applied to an in - medium study of vector meson properties @xcite . there the debates over the behavior of the vector - meson masses and the sum rules to be used in extracting vector meson properties in nuclear matter are resolved . using standard in - medium condensate estimates , the analysis leaves no doubt that vector - meson masses decrease with increasing density . these techniques are also being applied to in - medium properties of the nucleon @xcite , by generalizing the vacuum sum rules analyzed here to finite nuclear matter density . the monte - carlo techniques are resolving the predictive ability of the in - medium sum rules . another investigation utilizing these monte - carlo techniques studies the qcd - sr determination of the @xmath295 meson mixing parameter @xmath16 @xcite . there , correlations between the ratio of @xmath296 and @xmath297 quark masses are particularly interesting . the relatively large uncertainty in the residue of the pole does not bode well for qcd sum rule analysis beyond two - point functions . for example , the residue of the pole appears as a pre - factor to any nucleon matrix element such as @xmath92 or magnetic form factors @xcite . it will not be surprising to find uncertainties in these observables as large as the 35% relative error in the squared residue itself . as the uncertainties in the additional vacuum matrix elements relevant to the three - point functions are folded in the uncertainties are likely to exceed 50% and may in fact approach 100% . analyses of these issues are currently underway @xcite . when compared to uncertainty estimates previously published in the literature , our uncertainty estimates are somewhat larger . this is not due to any shortcoming of the approach presented here . instead , previous authors have failed to provide a reliable method for determining realistic uncertainties . often , uncertainty estimates have been conjectured without any supporting quantitative analysis . this in - depth examination of qcd sum rule self consistency paints a favorable picture for further quantitative refinements of the approach . of course such progress will be very difficult , as there are many aspects of the approach which must be refined for any particular improvement to be relevant . the techniques introduced here , such as maintaining independence of ground state properties from the interpolating field mixing parameter , might be used to further narrow the uncertainties of the approach . it is extremely important to refine the qcd - sr approach such that uncertainties in the qcd input parameters may be reduced while maintaining @xmath298 . research in this direction is required before meaningful qcd - sr - based predictions for nucleon matrix elements and moments of structure functions are possible . i am indebted to kai hencken for his careful checking of the wilson coefficients and his discovery of new corrections in the dimension seven operators . his contribution is key to resolving the discrepancy between the sum rules presented here and modern estimates of the vacuum condensates . thanks also to xuemin jin for numerous beneficial discussions . dick furnstahl and xuemin jin have provided a critical examination of this analysis and i thank them for their insightful comments . thanks also to javed iqbal for his contributions to the evaluation of the finite width integrals for the @xmath0-meson correlator . many years ago , jimmy law provided the optimization routine used in this investigation , and i thank him for providing this useful program . this research was supported by the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada and the u.s . department of energy under grant de - fg06 - 88er40427 . d. b. leinweber , in _ lattice 93 , proceedings of the international symposium _ , edited by t. draper , s. gottlieb , a. soni , and d. toussaint , * 34 * , ( 1994 ) 407 , dallas , tx , 1993 , nucl . b ( proc . suppl . ) . f. x. lee , d. b. leinweber , and x. jin , new qcd sum rules for nucleon axial vector coupling constants , in _ panic 96 , proceedings of the xiv international conference on particles and nucleii _ , river edge , nj , ( 1996 ) , tjnaf , world scientific publishing co. , u. washington pp doe / er/40427 - 10-n96 .

a new monte - carlo based uncertainty analysis is introduced to quantitatively determine the predictive ability of qcd sum rules . a comprehensive analysis of ground state @xmath0-meson and nucleon spectral properties is performed . many of the findings contradict the conventional wisdom of both practitioners and skeptics alike . associations between the phenomenological fit parameters are particularly interesting as they reveal how the sum rules resolve the spectral properties . the use of derivative sum rules for the determination of @xmath0-meson spectral properties is shown to be a very unfavorable approach . most prior nucleon sum rule analyses are based on a sum rule which is found to be invalid ; the results are suspect , and should be reevaluated . the `` ioffe formula '' , argued by many to qualitatively encapsulate a description of the nucleon mass in terms of the chiral symmetry breaking order parameter @xmath1 is misleading at best . qcd sum rules are found to be self - consistent without contributions from direct instantons . this implies that instanton effects are adequately accounted for in the nonperturbative vacuum condensates . this in - depth examination of qcd sum rule self consistency paints a favorable picture for further quantitative refinements of the qcd sum rule approach .