Datasets:

giuliadc

/

arxiv-filtered-978rows

like 0

physics0408066

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ since all men have imperfections + hanging bones inside their closets + that they trust no one will notice + absent tips on where to find them , + it will shock no one to learn that + even mighty hiawatha + famous chief of myth and legend + did some things he was not proud of + while a brother in a frat house + with a surly reputation + at an unknown little college + that his father helped to finance + so that he would get admitted + by the shores of gitche - gumee . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ far from loving fields and flowers + and the odor of the forest + as one reads in all the textbooks + hiawatha hated woodlands + and the animals one finds there , + whom he felt were always pooping , + and the plants the critters fed on + down in dank and swampy bottoms , + nearly perfect grounds for breeding + mighty hordes of great mosquitoes + who were always lean and hungry + and equipped with maps and radar + could detect where you were hiding + to inflict their bites and torments , + with their sneaky friends the black flies , + and their angry friends the green flies , + and the rocks ensnared by tree roots + that existed just to trip you + and would look improved as concrete + in foundation for a condo . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the kindly , thoughtful image + of a noble man of nature + was a total fabrication + of a team of gifted spin docs + hired later for this purpose . + he was really just a tech nerd + who cared only for equations + and explaining all behavior + from the basic laws of physics + armed with only mathematics . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha hated woodlands . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus , instead of lakes and forests , + hiawatha worshipped newton , + whose account of kepler s orbits + built on rules that galileo + had inferred from observation + plus the innocent assumption + of a law of gravitation + was a cosmic inspiration ; + and the brilliant sadie carnot , + whose insightful laws of heat flow + were deduced from working engines + absent microscopic theories ; + and the tragic ludwig boltzmann + who ascribed these laws to counting + but fell victim to depression + when he found no one believed him + and so killed himself by jumping + from an adriatic tower . + hiawatha saw that maxwell s + guessing missing laws of motion + needed for predicting light waves , + was the most transcendent genius , + as was albert einstein s insight + that the speed of light being constant + must mean time was not consistent + and that mass could be converted + into heat and vice versa . + just as clear was that the planck law + must imply debroglie s wavelength + was in force in any matter + so that sharp atomic spectra + and distinct atomic sizes + and the laws of bond formation + came from quantum interference . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus it was that hiawatha + came to be infatuated + with the laws of quantum matter , + which means liquid noble gases , + neutrons in a burnt - out star core , + or just rocks so cryogenic + they can not get any colder , + even with improved equipment , + like the state of too much sliding + on the ice of gitche - gumee + after dark in dead of winter + in an inexpensive loincloth . + pain and danger notwithstanding + quantum matter s simple structure + makes the eager physics tyro + quite unable to resist it . + hiawatha learned how atoms + self - assemble into crystals , + how electrons move right through them , + waving past the rigid ions + thereby making them metallic + in the absence of a bandgap + which arises from diffraction + and prevents the charge from moving + thereby causing insulation , + but by means of wires and doping + with atomic imperfections + when the bandgap is a small one + can be used to make transistors . + in addition to the basics + he learned how electric forces + like those seen in clinging woolens + cause some things to be magnetic + up until the lowly phonon , + quantum particle of sound wave , + storing heat the way that light does + mediates a strong attraction + that can pair up two electrons + causing them to move together + overcoming all resistance + and producing other magic + such as quantum oscillations . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ they were little more than con men . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ at this quite untimely moment + of his fragile student history + when his mind was most suggestive + our poor hapless hiawatha + had the terrible misfortune + to fall in with wicked people + who were little more than con men + and advanced in their profession + making theories of such matter + that were not at all deductive + but instead used mathematics + as a way to sow confusion + so that no one would discover + that their stuff was pure opinion + spiced with politics and chutzpah + so it looked somewhat like science + even though it really was nt . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ how they did this was ingenious + for it s not a simple matter + to produce concrete equations + that are absolutely hokum + and escape without detection + when they represent relations + of some quantities one measures + written down as abstract symbols + that could easily be tested . + what they did was deftly prey on + prejudicial ways of thinking + that their colleagues thought were reasoned + but were simply misconceptions , + generated during training + they had all received as students , + that the properties one wanted + were completely universal + so details did not matter . + but the data did not say this + and , moreover , had they done so + there would have been no good reason + to think any more about it . + so , while everyone was watching , + they swapped in some new equations + that they said would solve the problem + on account of being much simpler + but in fact described a system + very different from the first one + and , moreover , was unstable , + balanced at competing phases , + so that nobody could solve it + thus betraying the deception . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ adding to the dazzling brilliance + of this coldly thought - out swindle + they declared it _ fundamental _ + so that all the strange creations + made by people trying to solve it + and quite clearly not succeeding + proved it was a fount of deepness + one should struggle to unravel + even if it took a lifetime . + as a nifty added bonus + any hint you dropped in public + that it might have no solution + simply meant you were nt a genius , + told the world that you were stupid , + that you were a hopeless failure + who should not command a pencil . + no one wanted to admit this + so they d cover up their failure + and pretend that they had solved it + even though they clearly had nt . + this succeeded , for the most part , + but in one respect it did nt , + for their desperate need to publish + and thereby maintain their funding + caused a massive flood of papers , + each quite different from the others , + to descend upon the journals + and to overwhelm and clog them . + this would have been very funny + had it not been so pathetic . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ it just meant you were nt a genius . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha bought the story + took the bait , hook , line , and sinker + and , like many other students + who d been victimized before him , + got convinced that his strong math skills , + far exceeding those of others , + would reveal nature s mysteries + when he solved the hubbard model + and its child the t - j model + and the lattice kondo model + and the quantum spin glass model , + all of which possessed the feature + that no human being could solve them . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ nature has a sense of humor , + as one learns by working with it , + but it is an opportunist , + so that life s most bitter lessons + often wind up learned the hard way + when it moves to take advantage + of a single bad decision + and compound it with some mischief + custom made for the occasion . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ just when he d resolved to strike out + on his suicidal mission + there occurred a bold announcement + in a well - known german journal + that a tiny lab near zrich + had discovered a material + with the structure of perovskite + made of oxygen and copper + and some other stuff like strontium + that when cooled to thirty kelvin + lost all traces of resistance . + this event was simply shocking + for existing quantum theory + said it had to get much colder + for this special thing to happen , + as did all the careful surveys + of the properties of metals , + which were very comprehensive + and agreed well with the theory . + since the chemists were ambitious + to somehow transcend this limit , + which they thought too academic , + and someday kill all resistance + using no refrigeration , + there ensued a feeding frenzy + worthy of a horror movie , + like what happens when a trawler + dumps its hold of tuna entrails + off a reef in north australia . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ one example of this madness + was the _ physics woodstock _ conference + that took place in mid - manhattan + shortly after the announcement + where attendees got together , + comandeered a giant ballroom , + and gave talks not on the program + in a special all - night session + dedicated to the cuprates + which was packed to overflowing . + there was talk of maglev transport , + new kinds of computer circuit , + mighty , compact little motors + and efficient power cables , + all of which would soon be coming + thanks to this momentous breakthrough . + but it turns out we do nt have them + for they were nt a big improvement + over things we had already + and were hopelessly expensive . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ then there were the frantic searches + to find compounds that were better , + which one knew could be accomplished + if one spent enough time looking , + since this stuff had lots of phases + subtly different from each other , + and there had to be a best one . + there was very rapid progress + culminating in a patent + for a more complex material + in the same broad class of structure + which performed at ninety kelvin , + so much higher than the theory + would allow to ever happen + even with extreme assumptions + that one knew it was in trouble . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ almost overnight one found that + every spectrum known to science + had been taken on a cuprate . + their alleged profound importance + was , of course , a major factor , + but what mattered most was tactics . + without need to tell one s funders , + since it could be done so quickly , + one could telephone a chemist , + cut a deal to get some samples , + put them in one s apparatus + presto ! out would come a paper + that would instantly get published + even if it was a stinker . + this produced a pile of data , + growing without bound , like cancer , + that completely overwhelmed you + by being mostly unimportant , + like the growing list of options + coming from your cable service . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ presto ! out would come a stinker . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ often spectra were nt consistent , + but , instead of getting angry + as one would have in the old days , + one would handle it maturely + and just chalk it up to errors + that occur when one is hasty + or has had bad luck with samples . + but this tolerance , it turns out , + was a bargain with the devil + for it later was discovered + that enormous variation + was endemic to the cuprates , + and that things not reproducing + due to complex phase inclusions , + foreign atoms in the sample , + careless oxygen annealing , + surface preparation methods , + and a thousand other factors + was essential to their nature . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ sadly , by the time this surfaced + shameful habits of denying + that the differences existed + had become enshrined in writing , + and so wedded to the culture , + that they could not be corrected . + it was now accepted practice + in a public presentation + of experimental findings + not to mention other data + even if your own group took them . + grounds for this were rarely stated , + other than the innuendo + that one s sorry competition + were a hopeless bunch of bozos + who did not know how to measure + and therefore could not be trusted . + it was likewise viewed as kosher + to make up a little theory + or adopt somebody else s + that gave all your findings meaning + although not those of your colleagues , + which were , sadly , so imperfect + they were simply inconsistent . + but one never heard recanting , + since it would have meant admission + that one s judgement had been faulty . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the cuprates weird caprices + long escaping understanding + transformed into pseudotheories + that , like gods on mount olympus , + were political creations + that could not be killed with reason + and , empowered as immortals , + took control of their creators , + warred among themselves for power , + schemed to have a lot of children , + and , in general , made a circus + of the scientific method . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha , being a student , + and , quite frankly , rather callow + did not have the slightest inkling + that such nonsense ever happened . + he believed the claims of science + to be rather more objective + than competing kinds of knowledge + on account of its precision + and the fact that you could test it . + rather than the yawning snake pit + seething with disinformation + that was really there before him , + certain death for young beginners , + he saw just a chance for glory + something of immense importance , + judging from the acrimony + coursing through the talks and papers , + and a vast supply of data + on which one could build a theory + and thereby become a hero , + much the way the dumber brother + of the famous brave odysseus + that no one has ever heard of , + sure he could outfox the sirens , + ordered that the men unbind him + and , of course , succumbing quickly + dove right in and bashed his brains out . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha s misconceptions were not shared by everybody . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha s misconceptions + of the nature of the problem + he was setting out to conquer + were not shared by everybody . + just as buzzards , with keen noses , + circling high above their breakfast + wait until it can not hurt them , + to swoop down and get to business , + and ichneuman wasps impregnate + larval caterpillar victims + with some eggs that grow to eat them , + thus not let them reach adulthood + when they might be hard to handle , + hiawatha s crafty mentors + sensed that science had stopped working + in the sub - field of the cuprates , + as it had before in others + where their scams had been successful . + smelling death was close upon it , + they resolved the time was ready . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ what ensued was simply awesome , + destined to go down in legend . + they proposed a cuprate theory + so magnificent in concept , + so much bolder than the others + that it blasted them to pieces + like some big atomic warhead , + so outshined them in its glory + like a nova in the heavens + that it blinded any person + who would dare to gaze upon it . + cuprates did these things , it stated , + just because a quirk of nature + made them like the _ hubbard model _ , + which , as had been long established , + did some things quite fundamental , + not yet known to modern science , + which explained the crazy data , + so to understand the cuprates + one would have to solve this model . + how colossal ! how stupendous ! + it was absolutely foolproof ! + no one could disprove this theory + with existing mathematics + or experimental data + for exactly the same reasons + nor could they admit they could nt , + so they d spend their whole lives trying , + blame themselves for being so stupid , + and pay homage in each paper + with the requisite citation ! + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ they left clues in great abundance + that they d made a vast deception + far surpassing p. t. barnum s + most creative whims and musings + trusting that no one would catch them + on account of being so guileless , + which they knew was part of science , + rather like the clever killer , + sure he can outsmart columbo , + leaving marks upon the crime scene + then in later verbal sparring + hints at them in brazen taunting . + one was that its short description , + resonating bonds of valence , + was the name that linus pauling + used for common bonds of benzene , + something so profoundly different + from the physics of the cuprates + that its use on this occasion + seemed to show a lousy word sense . + but , in fact , it was inspired , + for the permanent confusion + left by its uncertain meaning + like the data it reflected , + was defense against attackers , + made it very hard to target , + left its enemies bewildered . + and the thoughtful usurpation + of a well - established brand name + had the lovely added feature + of dispatching pesky pauling , + who had always been a nuisance , + down to davy jones s locker + in the minds of younger people . + _ getting rid of pesky pauling . _ there was also the assertion + running rampant through the theory + that the essence of the cuprates + was coulombic insulation , + which , on close inspection , turned out + no one could define precisely , + with a few concrete equations , + but was nonetheless a concept + people thought they comprehended , + like the fancy secret contents + of competing brands of toothpaste + that , of course , are total fictions + made up during lunch by ad guys . + but the best clue by some margin + was the _ deus ex machina _ + known as gutzwiller projection , + which began life as a method + for controlling the equations + but was morphed on this occasion + to a monsterous distortion + of the basic mathematics + on the grounds it was insightful . + but , in fact , it came from nowhere , + and was just a simple dictat + that an off - the - shelf conductor + could not be a quantum magnet + while one forced it to become one + thus creating awful conflict + when , in fact , there simply was none . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha , being clever , + quickly saw that he could do this , + saw that such manipulations + were , in fact , extremely easy , + that a high school kid could do them , + once he got the key idea + that one should evade the problem + of deducing the behavior + from the actual equations + by declaring that some answer + was correct because one said so + and proceeding to defend it + with a lot of complex symbols + simply cooked up to confuse things . + thus emboldened to abandon + his perverse outdated fear of + uncontrolled approximations + hiawatha bit the bullet + and jumped into cuprate theory + with the fury of a madman , + doing reckless calculations + based on nothing but some gas fumes + that produced some fine predictions , + as one was inclined to call them , + matching some existing data + but , of course , not matching others , + since they were not all consistent . + he would then just pick and choose them + as one would an orange or lemon + in the local supermarket + and declare the rest defective . + then he wrote up his conclusions + in a little physics paper + loaded up with fearsome symbols + proving that he had credentials + to make all these speculations , + sent it in for publication + and then found an awful problem + he had not anticipated . + for the paper to be published + it must get past refereeing + which , in theory , was for stopping + false results from being reported + but , in practice , was to censor + anyone whose work you hated , + somewhat of a sticky wicket + for someone who s main objective + was to publish speculation . + hiawatha soon discovered + though the process of rejection + that his papers could not make it + if they championed new ideas + or in any way conflicted + with the viewpoints of the experts + which , of course , were simply made up . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the mighty hiawatha + found his plans to be a scholar + had an unexpected down side + that would later prove quite fatal + in that he was forced to pander + in his writing for the public + to a set of flakey concepts + that he d found extremely useful + but had not had time to question , + in exchange for recognition + needed for career advancement . + for a while it did not matter + but the problem slowly festered + and one day poor hiawatha , + waking to a huge disaster , + found himself up to his eyeballs + in a soup of black corruption . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ he would simply pick and choose them . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha s revelation + took a while to find its footing + for , as happens in such cases , + many awful misconceptions + were embedded in his thinking + where they had been put on purpose + and could only be uncovered , + if at all , through painful hours + scrutinizing tiny details , + contemplating reams of data , + finding out who s stuff was careful , + tracking down suspicious rumors , + reading through a mass of papers , + slowly tossing out the bad ones , + racking up the airline mileage + going to humongous meetings , + thereby building up a fact base + cleansed of all manipulations . + over time , as things got clearer , + hiawatha grew unhappy + trying to reconcile his viewpoint + with the facts that he had winnowed , + always finding that he could nt . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied transport + both electrical and thermal + that , one argued , showed the absence + of the landau fermi surface + symptomatic of a metal + thereby proving one was dealing + with a strange new state of matter . + but he found in every instance + that a sample made its coldest , + so one knew what one was doing , + either showed disorder problems + generated by the chemists + or agreed with classic theory . + thus , like all those dot - com profits + that they claimed would make you wealthy , + but , in fact , were nonexistent , + arguments for novel physics + built upon the facts of transport + did not hold up on inspection . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied optics + by and large his favorite spectrum + for he knew that light reflection + measured dielectric functions + in a way that used no theory , + and it showed how loose electrons + moved about and caused the bonding . + but , alas , the data varied + from one sample to another + even after years of efforts + to ensure that they were stable ! + this left lack of clear consensus + even over things that mattered . + understanding why this happened + was not really rocket science , + for the kramers - krnig process + amplified the defect signals + that were there in great abundance , + even though they all denied it , + and depended on the process + by which one prepared the sample , + something different for each grower + and a closely - guarded secret . + also , things would change with doping , + something very hard to measure + and which often was nt constant + as one moved across the sample + due to troubles in the furnace + which they claimed they d licked but had nt . + thus the stories of new physics + built upon results of optics , + like the troubled u. s. census + or the the streets of downtown boston + after weeks of too much snowing , + were polluted by disorder , + and , moreover , were deceptive + in that aspects of the spectra + that were reasonably stable + like the strange non - drude lineshapes + happened at such tiny wavelengths + one could plausibly ascribe them + to a nearby phase transition + rather than the state in question . + thus the stories were fantastic , + and , like those that richard nixon + told while he was in the white house , + or that pop star michael jackson + claimed occurred in los olivos + for the pleasure of the children , + in the end would not hold water . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the stories were fantastic . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied neutrons + which he found he liked immensely + since they flowed from a reactor + with big purple signs upon it + warning you of radiation + that would kill you if allowed to , + since the neutrons went right through you + but would sometimes choose to stop there + and decay like little time bombs , + thus inducing stomach cancer . + but they went through cuprates also , + and that made them very useful , + since a few of them would scatter , + and detecting those that did so + gave you lots of information + from down deep inside the sample , + such as how the atoms ordered , + how they moved when something hit them + and if they were little magnets . + but the bad news was the signal + was quite small and hard to measure , + so one needed a detector + bigger than a dempsey dumpster + and a truly mammoth sample , + leading to big compromises + in the sample growing process + they preferred deemphasizing + but one knew was wreaking havoc + on the meaning of the data . + they would also never tell you + what the measurement itself was , + since the neutron kinematics + made it sensitive to factors + like the speed spread of the neutrons + and the tip of the detector + and the path on which one moved things + to survey deflection angles + that were messy and annoying , + so they d first massage the data + using big computer programs + to remove these nasty factors + and report the program output , + representing you should trust it + just because they were the experts . + but , of course , there were those upgrades + and the quiet little tweaking + that one always did at run time + that one never heard reported . + once he caught these key omissions + hiawatha got suspicious , + and quite quickly found the practice + of reporting neutron spectra + in some secret custom units + given names like `` counts '' to fool you , + like those helpful content labels + found on packs of sandwich slices + listing salt and beef by - products , + thus preventing one from telling + there was very poor agreement . + all this made a clearer picture + but it also meant the data + like the air - brushed prints in _ playboy _ + were , in fact , manipulated , + and that many strange behaviors + like the famous funny phonon + dogma said was nonexistent + got removed as standard practice + on the grounds they should not be there . + thus his plan to use those spectra + to pin down the magnetism + present sometimes in the cuprates + on account of all the errors + ended up a dismal failure . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ever helpful content labels . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied currents + made when cold electrons tunnel + right across an insulator + where they should have been forbidden , + something very close to magic + rather like the twinkly transport + people undergo on star trek , + and it s also quite revealing + of important quantum pairing + that goes on inside the cuprate . + in the old days one would simply + oxidize a thin - film sample , + coat the oxide with another , + solder on two tiny contacts , + dunk the whole thing into vapors + made so cold that they were liquid , + then just measure plain resistance + of the two protruding wires , + which would vary with the voltage + thus producing useful data . + hiawtha read these papers + with a mounting sense of horror , + for the wild disagreement + even in the basic features + from one sample to another + was so large it left one breathless . + and , of course , the accusations + that the other guys were morons + who just could not make good junctions + rose to unmatched heights of grandeur + even though the real villain , + obvious from spectral sharpness , + was the sample variation . + hiawatha s indignation + escalated when he found that + over time this fact got buried + since each group soon found a method + of preparing stable samples + different from that used by others + and producing different spectra + that they marketed as products , + thus evading any need to + answer penetrating questions . + an important fact , however , + that emerged from all these studies , + was that steady lossless currents + could indeed be made to flow from + films of lead into the cuprates + if one made a pitted surface , + proving that the state of matter + operating in the cuprates + was not new and was not different . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied spectra + made when light shined on a sample + causes it to lose electrons + which fly out in all directions + and one can detect by counting , + thus obtaining information + of their status in the sample + just before the light removed them . + hiawatha saw at once that + peaks for plain undressed electrons + that were not supposed to be there + in this great new state of matter + always were and had a sharpness + at the resolution limit + of the latest new detector + for the special ones at threshold , + where one knew what one was doing . + in addition they were beaming + in a lovely fourfold pattern + with the symmetry of d - wave , + something that had been suggested + they might do if they were simple , + just like those in other metals . + thus the arguments for strangeness + based on counting these electrons + lost their force as things got better , + and in time were proved a failure . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied muons , + which he thought were even neater + than the more prosaic neutrons , + since they came from atom smashers + that could also quickly kill you + if you chose to be so careless , + but they d stop inside much better + and once there , decay to gammas + that were easily detected + since they d even go through concrete , + and , moreover , they d be beaming + in the muon s spin direction + just before it went to heaven . + thus , implanted in a cuprate + they d arrest at some location + known to no one but their maker + and precess like little searchlights , + if there was some magnetism , + thus allowing you to see it + way deep down inside the sample . + thus with knowledge of their trapping + and a batch of big detectors + one could then back out the distance + of magnetic penetration . + hiawatha found this distance + shortened with increasing doping + just as theory said should happen , + if one forced the hubbard model + not to be a quantum magnet + by just saying that it was nt , + which might well have been important + had it not been for the problem + that this depth would not continue + to decline with increased doping + but instead would turn and lengthen . + this effect was quite perplexing , + since no theory of the cuprates + even twisted hubbard models , + could account for such behavior , + for it violated sum rules , + hence one just did not discuss it . + but the meaning was transparent + if one faced the facts with courage , + for the samples were degrading + in extremes of overdoping + in some ways that were nt predicted + and , moreover , were nt detected + by techniques except for this one . + this , in turn , implied these problems + might occur at other dopings + and likewise escape detection + or , what s worse , be used to argue + that new physics was occurring + when , in fact , it was just garbage . + thus the trail blazed by muons + led out in the woods to nowhere . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ dental pamphlets make you tired . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied spin flips + that the nuclei of atoms + undergo in great big magnets + near a radio transmitter + causing them to be antennas , + which absorb with complex lineshapes + one can read if one s a genius + but not , sadly , if one is nt , + since they , by and large , consist of + just a simple blobby bell curve + with a width and displaced center , + to which one must give some meaning + not a simple undertaking . + thus the all - important knight shift + and spin - lattice relaxation , + noms de plume for width and center , + vastly different for the copper + and the oxygen of cuprates , + were the source of endless theories , + often very thought - provoking , + stunning in sophistication , + but , like all those glossy pamphlets + found in waiting rooms of dentists + urging you to practice flossing , + soon began to make you tired , + since the data mainly showed you + that the stuff was not a metal + in the sense of gold or iron + which , in fact , one knew already + and was not a revelation . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha studied structure + of the surfaces of cuprates + freshly cleaved inside a vacuum + so that air would not get on them + and then probed with tiny needles + one could move with great precision , + by adjusting some piezos + on which everything was standing . + what he found was quite disturbing , + for while atoms at the surface + all had unperturbed positions , + showing that the cleave succeeded , + there were also complex patterns + on the scale of twenty atoms + that appeared to be diffraction . + this behavior might have come from + atoms underneath the surface + that were missing or defective + or some novel magnetism + of a kind unknown to science , + but the thing that so upset him + was that quantum interference + of the kind that he was seeing + could not happen if the lifetimes + were as short as he had thought them , + and which had been used to argue + for a brand new state of matter . + thus he soberly concluded + that this matter was nt different + and the whole confounded story + was a misinterpretation + of a plain materials problem . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the mighty hiawatha + through the patient application + of the practices of science + tested over generations + slowly sloughed off misconceptions + and , in face of mounting failure , + sadly came to the conclusion + he d been taken to the cleaners . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ given all the clever swindles + lurking there to take our money , + that , of course , are part of living , + like a virus for pneumonia + or a hungry venus fly trap , + we must all be very thankful + that the celebrated law of murphy + strikes at random without warning + causing even brilliant concepts , + that appear completely foolproof + like distributing tobacco + or the business plan of enron , + to sometimes become derailed + due to something unexpected + one was sure could never happen , + like a lawsuit from consumers , + that requires intervention + of the most creative nature + to prevent strategic meltdown . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ sure enough , that s just what happened . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ as it turns out , the idea + that the conflict in the models + one was using for the cuprates + due to nearby phase transitions + would both hamper their solution + and engender rampant fibbing , + thus enshrining mass confusion + one would then call proof of meaning + with no need to fear exposure + had the unexpected weakness + that someone might _ solve _ the model + using tons and tons of money + and some capable computers + to a crude degree sufficient + to unmask the real problem + thus revealing the deception . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ sure enough , that s just what happened . + when the cuprates were discovered + and the whole endeavor started + one had not the slightest worry + that these guys would ever solve it , + since the accuracy needed + was not clear in the beginning , + so they uniformly low - balled + with the too - familiar outcome + that results were inconsistent . + so they quarrelled over method + and who had convergence problems + and whose code was most clairvoyant + even though a child could see that + they were different apparati , + so the test that they were working + was agreement with each other . + but , unlike the other issues + that had come and gone before it , + cuprates lingered on as timely + long enough to cause a shake - out , + for the money kept increasing + even as machines got cheaper + and their power kept on growing + due , of course , to needs of gaming , + rather than the ones of lanczos + or the quantum monte carlo + that one used for basic physics . + so the robots kept on plugging + as their owners upped the ante + very slowly , as did wagner + when composing _ ring _ and _ tristan _ + and their stuff began converging ! + there , of course , was no agreement + over matters of the phases + such as whether it conducted + when one cooled it down to zero , + since a crystal of electrons + was one state in competition . + but at length scales one could access + there was clearly dissipation + of a most peculiar nature + in the dielectric function + and the quantum magnetism , + just exactly as predicted + by an ancient bunch of papers + over quantum phase transitions , + which these guys had never studied + since it was too esoteric + and had not been seen in nature + and was hated by their funders . + but the thing that really clinched it + was the endless disagreement , + that got worse as things proceeded + and was very clearly cronic , + over type and shape of edges + that would best produce convergence , + since one found that subtle changes + in the way one built the model + would turn on and off the striping + and therefore the insulation , + so that whether it was present + in the limit of large sample + simply could not be determined + with the codes that they had written . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ soon their stuff began converging . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ this , of course , was a disaster + for the plan to keep things murky + and required drastic action + to somehow repair the damage + all this progress had created , + and prevent these guys from seeing + what was right beneath their noses . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ and one was not disappointed . + once again a flash of brilliance + like a great big city - buster + brighter than the sun at midday , + blazed across the dome of heaven + toward its final destination + in the guinness book of records . + they declared the problem _ over _ ! + the computer guys had solved it ! + for their codes had proved the cuprates + were indeed the hubbard model , + and that s why the stuff conducted . + thus there was no urgent reason + to pursue the matter further ! + one could zero out their budgets + with no loss to human knowledge + and , in fact , perhaps improve it + since this money was incentive + to continue calculations + that were clearly unimportant + and report them in the journals + thus just adding to the clutter . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha , now much wiser + through his labors as a scholar + and , quite frankly , some maturing + watched these things unfold before him , + as he had on past occasions , + but this time with eyes wide open + and was filled with understanding . + it was not a happy moment , + for it meant that his own judgement + as to what was good and worthy + had been faulty from the outset , + something for which he must answer . + but instead of indignation + and a passion to get even + that he might have felt when younger + hiawatha , deep in thinking , + found himself consumed with sadness . + he was not the only victim , + for the guys who manned those robots , + and were heroes of the cuprates + for through focussed dedication + they had stumbled on the answer + that the models were unstable + and did _ not _ describe the cuprates , + since a modest perturbation + would profoundly change their nature + were about to have their triumph + snatched from them by clever scoundrels + who , pretending to befriend them , + would then redefine their output + to mean something that it did nt , + thus protecting their investment , + but , of course , destroying others . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha s knowing sadness , + like the darkening at twilight + or a gathering storm in winter , + slowly gained in strength and deepened + as he spent time in reflection , + working through the implications + of the things that he had witnessed + for the cause of noble science + that thus far had so beguiled him . + it would simply not be manly + to pretend he was nt guilty + of ignoring frequent warnings + that the needed path to nature + was obscured or nonexistent . + it was clear that he d been foolish + to have bought this awful fiction + and that blame must fall quite squarely + on himself and not on others . + but this candid _ mea culpa _ , + made in silence where it mattered , + while it comforted his conscience , + did not quite assuage the wounding , + for it begged the nagging question + of how they could have succeeded + in hoodwinking all the people + for so long without some doubting . + it was simply not an option + to presume these guys were stupid , + since the instruments they dealt with , + often built by hand from nothing , + needed great sophistication + to deploy and mine for data . + there was clearly something larger + and extremely fundamental + working in the group dynamic + that involved access to funding + and the policy of journals + and the need to service markets + and the mythos of the subject + one must use to make a living + that these crooks had first deciphered , + then reduced with understanding , + then usurped to do their bidding . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hiawatha , turning inward , + thought for weeks about this problem + during which he was obnoxious + due to his preoccupation . + but at last he got an answer + that made sense and was quite simple , + thus withstanding occam s razor , + so he thought that he believed it . + when he d set out on his mission + he had understood the challenge + of the mastery of nature + but not basic economics + and the fact that art and science + both require sacrifices + of a clear financial nature + that one sometimes just ca nt handle + nor , in fairness , should one do so + since a good guy pays the mortgage + and supports the kids in college + and the other things a body + has to do to keep the lights on . + but , in fact , the compromises + that one makes as part of living + such as saying what one has to + for maintaining healthy cash flow + often toss big monkey wrenches + in the fine machine of science + and can stop it altogether + in conflicted situations . + then the body , badly weakened , + barely able to keep breathing , + gets exploited by diseases , + such as villains lacking scruples + who descend on it like termites + to a house that s been neglected , + wreaking terrible destruction + on the lives of those affected . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the conclusion of this story + is well known from all the textbooks . + hiawatha never wavered + in his deep respect for physics , + but he came by this adventure + to the deeper understanding + that to get things done that mattered + often was a social question , + not just logical abstraction , + and , as well , a part of nature , + just the thing he thought he d hated + and had thrilled at desecrating + as a tender freshman student + in the little private college + by the shores of gitchee - gumee . + it was true that all the creatures + living in those swamps and woodlands + generated lots of pooping , + but then so did real people , + and the people poop was stronger , + so that one could not ignore it . + but one really would not want to , + for the lesson of the cuprates + was that lack of understanding + of these basic group dynamics , + was a recipe for failure + since they were the central issue + for most things that were essential . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ thus the mighty hiawatha + turned his mind to other problems + such as how to use resources + that were his by luck and birthright + through the power of his father + which he d been inclined to squander , + but now realized he should nt . + thus he studied like a madman + to acquire the skills of statecraft , + such as how to plan a project , + how to give effective orders , + how to make sure they were followed , + how to get things done with meetings , + and to leave the money grubbing + up to folks his father hired + such as all those gifted spin docs + who created key revisions + necessary for his image + to be something people honored . + thus the pain of too much sliding + on the ice in dead of winter + in an inexpensive loincloth + and his other misadventures + got removed , as did the cuprates , + from his long official story . + but the memory persisted + and it helped to make him wiser + for , of course , as he got older + he had many bad encounters + not so different from the cuprates . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ but whenever he was troubled + with a problem that would vex him + he would cheer himself by thinking + of the special room in hades + into which these happy people + on account of their transgressions + would be ushered when they bagged it + and be stuck in there forever , + forced to listen to each other + giving lectures on the cuprates . + it would always leave him smiling . + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

there is increasing circumstantial evidence that the cuprate superconductors , and correlated - electron materials generally , defy simple materials categorization because of their proximity to one or more continuous zero - temperature phase transitions . this implies that the fifteen - year confusion about the cuprates is not fundamental at all but simply overinterpreted quantum criticality an effect that seems mysterious by virtue of its hypersensitivity to perturbations , _ i.e. _ to sample imperfections in experiment and small modifications of approximation schemes in theoretical modeling , but is really just an unremarkable phase transition of some kind masquerading as something important , a sheep in wolf s clothing . this conclusion is extremely difficult for most physicists even to think about because it requires admitting that an identifiable physical phenomenon might cause the scientific method to fail in some cases . for this reason i have decided to explain the problem in a way that is nonthreatening , easy to read , and fun as a satire modeled after a similar piece of lewis carroll s i once read . my story is humorous fiction . any similarity of the characters to living persons is accidental . my apologies to henry w. longfellow . [ published as annals of improbable research * 10 * , no . 6 ( may / june 2004 ) , p. 8 . ]

astro-ph0411404

unlike the optical spectra of hot cspn , which are characterized by lines of hydrogen , helium and some light metals , the ultraviolet spectra are dominated by fe and ni lines ( schnberner & drilling 1985 ) . their observed strengths show large variations between different objects suggesting a possible spread in abundances . iron group lines are ideal temperature indicators ( fig.1 ) , which is important to set up a reliable temperature scale for the hottest cspn . effective temperatures of the hottest central stars are known with low accuracy only . as a temperature indicater one usually takes the relative strength of neutral and ionized helium lines in optical spectra , however , at very high temperatures neutral helium lines disappear . the sample of stars in our study includes seven very hot hydrogen - rich cspn . these are the same objects that are investigated by traulsen et al . ( these proceedings ) to derive temperature and gravity by utilizing uv lines from light metals , namely c , n , and o. this sample covers the hottest phase of post - agb evolution ( @xmath0@xmath170000k ) and includes four objects , which have been observed with fuse _ and _ hst / stis . the fuse spectra cover the range 9101180 with a resolution of about 0.1 . fig.2 displays a section of the available spectra . they are ordered by increasing effective temperature ( starting from ngc1360 with 97000k , up to ngc6853 with 126000k ) which becomes obvious in the shift of the iron ionisation balance . only lines of fevi and fevii are labeled in this figure , and the numbers next to the identification bars are the respective log__gf _ _ values . we also detect lines of c , n , o and of other elements of the iron group . as yet unidentified spectral lines are possibly absorptions of covi ( 1139.4 ) , nivi ( 1096.6 , 1121.9 , 1125.4 , 1141.9 , 1145.0 , 1148.9 ) and mnvi ( 1088.7 , 1128.5 ) . in addition to the fuse observations , fig.2 displays a model spectrum which is plotted over the spectrum of ngc1360 . the model has solar abundances , and includes , besides h and he , lines from fevi and fevii . temperature and gravity of the model ( @xmath0 @xmath2 95000 k and log__g _ _ @xmath2 5.50 ) are close to those derived from the cno analysis mentioned above . note the h@xmath3 contamination of the fuse spectra other than ngc1360 . the very broad troughs in lss1362 are h@xmath3 lines , and one can see the matching ( relatively weak ) absorption in ngc7293 . a large fraction of the absorption features in ngc6853 are from warm h@xmath3 , which will have to be deblended to obtain the photospheric spectrum . the spectra are analyzed using nlte metal line blanketed model atmospheres in order to determine @xmath0 , surface gravity , and chemical composition . for model calculations we use the tbingen nlte model atmosphere package tmap ( werner & dreizler 1999 ) and the atomic data files of the iron group ions were prepared with the iron opacity interface `` ironic '' ( rauch & deetjen 2003 ) . the large number of iron lines calls for a statistical treatment of opacities . we include data from kurucz s ( 1991 ) line list . the final synthetic spectra contain only lines whose wavelength position is accurately known from laboratory measurements ( so - called pos tables of kurucz ) . so far , all models have solar abundances and include h and he , plus lines from fevi , and fevii . the possibility of using the fevi / fevii ionisation equilibrium as a temperature indicator can be seen by the disappearance of fevi lines and the increasing strength of fevii lines in the spectra of models with increasing effective temperature ( fig.1 ) . the decrease of the fevii line strengths in the hottest model is explained by a shift of the ionization balance from fevii to feviii . ( all models have log__g _ _ = 7 . ) our first calculations seem to confirm that the temperature of ngc1360 is indeed lower than previously thought . the study of cno lines arrived at a similar result . the iron abundance in ngc1360 is apparently close to solar . kurucz , r. l. 1991 , in stellar atmospheres : beyond classical models , ed . l.crivellari , i.hubeny , d.g.hummer , nato asi ser . c 341 , kluwer , dordrecht , p.441 rauch , t. , & deetjen , j. l. 2003 , in stellar atmosphere modeling , eds . i. hubeny , d. mihalas , & k. werner , asp conference proceedings , 288 , 103 schnberner , d. , & drilling , j. s. 1985 , apj , 290 , l49 werner , k. , & dreizler , s. 1999 , in computational astrophysics , eds . h.riffert & k.werner , journal of computational and applied mathematics , 109 , 65

we report on an on - going analysis of high - resolution uv spectra of hot hydrogen - rich central stars of planetary nebulae ( cspn ) , obtained with the hubble space telescope and fuse . since uv spectra of many cspn are dominated by fe and ni lines , we intend to use them as temperature indicators to check the cspn temperature scale we have derived earlier from cno ionization balances . furthermore , the observed line strengths of heavy metals show large variations between different objects suggesting a possible spread in abundances . we will determine abundances of iron group elements by quantitative spectral analyses with non - lte model atmospheres .

astro-ph0212293

the modified newtonian dynamics ( mond ) is an empirically - based modification of newtonian gravity or inertia in the limit of low accelerations ( @xmath1 ) suggested by milgrom ( 1983 ) as an alternative to cosmic dark matter . in addition to explaining galaxy scaling relations ( tully - fisher , faber - jackson , fundamental plane ) , this simple algorithm allows one to accurately predict the shapes of spiral galaxy rotation curves from the observed distribution of gaseous and stellar matter . mond also accounts for the kinematics of small groups of galaxies ( milgrom 1998 ) and of superclusters , as exemplified by the perseus - pisces filament ( milgrom 1997 ) without the need for unseen mass . these well - documented phenomenological successes ( sanders & mcgaugh 2002 and references therein ) challenge the cold dark matter ( cdm ) paradigm and provide some support for the suggestion that the current theory of gravity and inertia ( general relativity ) may need revision in the limit of low accelerations or field gradients . however , problems do arise when one attempts to apply mond to the large clusters of galaxies . the and white ( 1988 ) first noted that , to successfully account for the discrepancy between the observed mass and the traditional virial mass in the coma cluster , the mond acceleration parameter , supposedly a universal constant , should be about a factor of four larger than the value implied by galaxy rotation curves . with mond , the dynamical mass of a pressure supported system at temperature t is @xmath2 ; therefore , the the and white result could also be interpreted as an indication that the mond dynamical mass is still larger than the detectable mass in stars and gas . in astronomical tests involving an individual extragalactic object , such as the coma cluster , a contradiction is not necessarily a falsification . one can always argue that the peculiar aspects of an object , such as deviations from spherical symmetry or incomplete dynamical relaxation , exempt that particular case . however , gerbal et al . ( 1992 ) , looking at a sample of eight x - ray emitting clusters , noted that the problem is more general : although mond reduced the newtonian discrepancy by a factor of 10 , there is still a need for dark matter , particularly in the central regions . later , considering a large sample of x - ray emitting clusters , i found that the mass predicted by mond remains , typically , a factor of two or three times larger than the total mass observed in the hot gas and in the stellar content of the galaxies ( sanders 1998 ) . more recently , aguirre , schaye & quataert ( 2001 ) pointed out that mond is inconsistent with the observed temperature gradient in inner regions of three clusters for which such data is available . again , the problem can be remedied by additional non - luminous mass , primarily in the inner regions , of order two or three times the observed gas mass . this discrepancy is also evident from strong gravitational lensing in the central regions of clusters the formation of multiple images of background galaxies . here , mond does not apply because accelerations are newtonian , and the implied surface density greatly exceeds that of visible matter and hot gas ( sanders 1998 ) . so , although mond clearly reduces the classical newtonian mass discrepancy in clusters of galaxies , there still remains a missing mass problem , particularly in the cores . here i consider the issue of the remaining missing mass in clusters and whether or not this a fundamental problem for mond . first i calculate the structure and x - ray surface brightness distribution of mond isothermal gas spheres . except for the very central regions , the structure of these objects is self - similar ; the finite mass is primarily determined by the temperature and is very weakly dependent upon the central density . thus there exists a mass - temperature relation ( @xmath3 ) which is absolute ; this implies a gas mass typically 5 to 10 times larger than that observed in x - ray emitting clusters of the same temperature . moreover , for central electron densities in the range of 0.001 to 0.01 , there is a well - defined x - ray luminosity - temperature relation which is less steep ( @xmath4 ) and lies well above the observed luminosity - temperature relation for clusters ( @xmath5 ) . looking at individual objects , the radial dependence of x - ray surface brightness does not reproduce that typically observed in x - ray emitting clusters observations which are well - fit by the traditional @xmath0-model " ( sarazin 1988 ) . the conclusion is that self - gravitating mond isothermal gas spheres are not good representations of clusters of galaxies . gas spheres with a density distribution described by a @xmath0-model are not isothermal in the context of mond . a central or boundary temperature must be specified to determine the run of temperature in such objects , but those models with the lowest temperature gradients have large core radii and are again over - massive and over - luminous with respect to observed clusters of the same temperature . these problems may be solved by postulating the existence of a second rigid component in the mass distribution : a constant density core having a radius about twice that of the @xmath0 model core and a central surface density comparable to @xmath6 . here , by rigid i mean a component with a fixed density distribution which does not respond to the gravitational field of the hot gas or galaxies . the presence this additional component in the coma cluster is implied by the mond hydrostatic gas equation for cumulative mass . if this component is generally present in clusters , it contributes to the gravitational force in the inner regions and reduces the core radius at a given temperature . in this way the observed luminosity - temperature and mass - temperature relations for clusters may be reproduced . about 40 individual clusters have been considered in terms of such a two - component model ; i.e. , the observed surface - brightness distributions and mean temperatures are fit by specifying the density of the non - luminous component which is assumed to extend to two gas core radii . the total mass of this additional component varies between a few times @xmath7 and @xmath8 m@xmath9 and the implied mass - to - light ratio is typically 50 in solar units . therefore , the required rigid component is not a standard stellar population ; as noted previously , mond requires dark , or heretofore undetected , matter in the central regions of rich clusters . although the total discrepancy between dark and detectable mass is reduced by , on average , a factor of four over that implied by newtonian dynamics , it is clear that there remains a dark matter problem for mond . i discuss the issue of whether or not this is a contradiction . i speculate on the possible nature of this non - luminous component and argue that neutrinos of finite mass are a possible candidate . the structure of isotropic isothermal spheres may be determined by solving the equation of hydrostatic equilibrium : @xmath10 with the pressure @xmath11 given by @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the one - dimensional velocity dispersion ( constant for an isothermal sphere ) , @xmath14 is the density . the gravitational acceleration , @xmath15 , in the context of mond , is given by @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the usual newtonian gravitational acceleration , @xmath18 @xmath19 is the critical acceleration below which gravity deviates from newtonian ( found to be about @xmath20 cm / s@xmath21 from fits to galaxy rotation curves ) , and @xmath22 is a function which interpolates between the newtonian regime ( @xmath23 when @xmath24 ) and the mond regime ( @xmath25 when @xmath26 ) . a function having this asymptotic form , @xmath27 works well for galaxy rotation curves and is also used here . milgrom ( 1984 ) demonstrated that mond isothermal spheres have a finite mass and a density which falls of as @xmath28 where @xmath29 at large radii . in the outer regions , where @xmath30 = constant , it follows immediately from eqs . 1 and 2 that @xmath31 which means that the mass is uniquely determined by the specified velocity dispersion or temperature . for an isothermal gas sphere this relation becomes @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the mean atomic weight ( @xmath34 for an fully ionized gas with solar abundances ) and @xmath35 is the proton mass . this would be , in effect , the extension of the faber - jackson relation to clusters of galaxies ( sanders 1994 ) . however , the observational definition of such a relation is ambiguous because the total gas mass defined by the @xmath0-model is typically divergent . if one considers the mass inside a fixed radius ( sanders 1994 ) , or within a radius where the density falls to some fixed value ( mohr , mathiesen & evrard 1999 ) , a relationship of this form ( eq . 4 ) is observed for clusters . however , the mass at a given temperature is typically a factor of 5 to 10 below that implied by eq . is shown in fig . 1 where the mond mass - temperature relation for isothermal gas spheres ( dashed line ) is compared to the observed gas mass - temperature relation for 42 clusters listed in table 1 . here the observed gas mass is given by the @xmath0-model ( eq . 7 below ) extrapolated to a radius where the gas density has fallen to about @xmath36 g/@xmath37 , or 250 times the mean cosmological density of baryonic matter . the characteristic scale of mond isothermal gas spheres is @xmath38 ( sanders & mcgaugh 2002 ) . given that the x - ray luminosity due to free - free emission is @xmath39 ; then , eqs . 4 and 5 above would imply an x - ray luminosity - temperature relation of the form @xmath4 . the observed luminosity - temperature relation ( e.g. , ikebe et al . 2002 ) is significantly steeper , @xmath5 , than that of mond isothermal spheres . to pursue this in more detail , i calculated the x - ray luminosity for mond isothermal spheres with electron densities and temperatures similar to those of the x - ray emitting clusters of galaxies . i assume a central electron density of 0.006 @xmath40 as being typical of clusters , and , for a given temperature , numerically integrate eqs . 1 and 2 from the center outward . the optically thin free - free radiation for the entire sphere is then calculated from the run of electron density . the resulting luminosity - temperature relation is shown by the dashed curve in fig . 2 . compared to the observations by ikebe et al . ( 2002 ) scaled to h=0.7 . in both cases , this is the radiation emitted in the band 0.2 to 2.4 kev where the x - ray flux is typically measured by satellites such as asca and rosat . not only is the theoretical dependence shallower than observed , the predicted luminosities are an order of magnitude larger than actual clusters at the same temperature . on the basis of these scaling relationships , it would seem that mond isothermal spheres are not good representations of clusters of galaxies . this conclusion is reinforced when we consider the surface brightness distribution of a mond isothermal gas sphere . although the mass of an isotropic , isothermal sphere is effectively determined by the temperature , the detailed structure depends upon the central density ; for a single temperature there is a family of solutions bounded by a limiting solution with a 1/r density cusp at the center ( milgrom 1984 ) . the limiting mond solution resembles the hernquist model ( hernquist 1990 ) with the 1/r cusp steepening to a 1/r@xmath41 beyond a radius @xmath42 . lower density spheres are characterized by a constant density core with a 1/r@xmath41 gradient at large r ; the central gas densities observed in clusters of galaxies would place these objects in this category of the sub - limiting solutions . the x - ray surface brightness distribution resulting from such a mond isothermal sphere is shown in fig . 3 compared to that observed for the coma cluster ( briel , henry & bhringer 1992 ) . these observations are well fit by the traditional @xmath0-model ( cavaliere & fusco - femiano 1976 , sarazin 1988 ) , @xmath43}^{-3\beta + 1/2}\eqno(6)\ ] ] shown by the dashed curve in fig . we see that the mond isothermal gas sphere provides a poor representation of the actual surface brightness distribution . moreover , the temperature of this best fitting mond isothermal sphere is about 2.5 kev whereas the actual temperature of the coma cluster is in excess of 8 kev . the radial dependence of electron number density which produces the x - ray intensity distribution described by eq . 6 is @xmath44}^{-1.5\beta}\eqno(7)\ ] ] ( cavaliere & fusco - femiano 1976 ) . rather than assuming a constant temperature and solving eq . 1 for the density distribution , one may alternatively take eq . 7 as the density distribution and solve for the radial dependence of the temperature . it is necessary to specify @xmath0 ( typically 0.6 to 0.7 for clusters ) , a central electron density , @xmath45 ( again taken to be 0.006 @xmath40 ) , a core radius , @xmath46 ( ranging from 50 to 300 kpc for clusters ) , and a central gas temperature , @xmath47 . . 1 and 2 may be solved for the run of temperature to an outer boundary , usually taken to be where the gas density falls to some fixed multiple of the mean cosmological density . for a given central temperature , the run of temperature is completely determined by the core radius . there is one specific value of @xmath46 which minimizes the temperature gradients . for smaller core radii , the temperature rapidly increases toward the boundary ( the models are very far from isothermal ) ; for larger core radii , the temperature decreases to zero before the boundary is reached . because clusters of galaxies are observed to be near isothermal , these mond @xmath0-models with the smallest temperature variations are taken to be appropriate for clusters . the emission - weighted temperature of this most nearly - isothermal model as a function of _ projected _ radius is shown by the dashed curve in fig . 4 for @xmath48 @xmath40 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 kev . the required core radius is 436 kpc . it is evident from fig . 4 that the model still deviates significantly from pure isothermal , with a roughly a factor of two variation around the central temperature . moreover , compared to actual clusters , the implied core radius for this temperature is too large by a factor of two . for these near isothermal @xmath0 models , i determined the mean emission weighted temperature , the total gas mass within the cut - off radius and the x - ray luminosity within the 0.1 to 2.4 kev band . the resulting gas mass - temperature relation is almost identical to that of mond isothermal spheres ( the dashed curve in fig . 1 ) and thus again much larger than the observationally inferred gas mass of x - ray emitting clusters the luminosity - temperature relation for these mond @xmath0 models is shown in fig . 2 by the dotted curve . unsurprisingly , this nearly coincides with the calculated relation for mond isothermal spheres and is clearly an equally poor description of reality . the basic problem is that , for both mond isothermal spheres and mond @xmath0 models , the core radii are too large . it is evident that some ingredient is missing from these models ; that an additional mass component must be added to decrease the gas core radius at a given temperature . for a cluster with an observed density and temperature distribution , eqs . 1 and 2 directly yield m(r ) , the interior dynamical mass as a function of radius . in the newtonian regime this is given simply by @xmath51_r.\eqno(8)\ ] ] with mond , taking @xmath22 to be given by eq . 2c , the dynamical mass is @xmath52 where a is the observed " acceleration @xmath53_r.\eqno(10)\ ] ] obviously , from eq . 9 in the limit of large accelerations ( @xmath54 ) the mond dynamical mass is equivalent to the newtonian dynamical mass . we may apply these relations to the coma cluster which has a density distribution well - fit by a @xmath0-model with @xmath0 = 0.71 , @xmath46 = 276 kpc , @xmath45 = .0036 ( reiprich 2001 ) , an observed radial temperature profile ( arnaud et al . 2001 ) and average emission weighted temperature of 8.6 kev . the results are shown in fig . 5 which is the cumulative newtonian dynamical mass ( dotted line ) , the mond dynamical mass ( solid line ) , and the gas mass ( dashed line ) . here it is evident that while the newtonian dynamical mass continues to increase at radius of 1 mpc , the mond mass has essentially converged . however , the total mond mass is still a factor of four times larger than the mass in gas alone . this discrepancy can not be accounted for by the stellar content of the galaxies which , assuming a mass - to - light ratio of seven , amounts only to about @xmath55 m@xmath9 within 1 mpc ( the & white 1988 ) . this is , in fact , the discrepancy pointed out by the and white a discrepancy which can be resolved by increasing @xmath19 by a factor of 3 or 4 over the value required for galaxy rotation curves , or by admitting the presence of non - luminous mass which mond does not remove . the density of this non - luminous component is roughly constant and contained within two gas core radii . in other words the missing mass is essentially present in the inner regions of the cluster as implied in the work of aguirre , shaye , and quataert ( 2001 ) . this suggests that , with mond , clusters might be described by a two component model : a gas component with a density distribution given by the @xmath0-model and a dark central component of constant density and a radius of about two times the core radius of the the gas distribution . in coma , the central surface density of the dark component is about @xmath56/pc@xmath57 , which is comparable to the mond surface density of @xmath58 pc@xmath57 . this is the characteristic central surface density of mond self - gravitating isothermal systems ( milgrom 1984 ) . therefore , to determine scaling relations , i assume that the non - luminous component is a rigid sphere having a central surface surface density equal to that in the coma cluster and radius twice that of the gas core radius , as in coma . then the constant density of the second component is @xmath59 and the total dark mass is @xmath60 evidently , with this assumption , larger clusters have a more massive dark component , but because the gas mass scales as @xmath61 , the dark to gas mass decreases with increasing core radius or temperature . the procedure followed is identical to that of the pure mond @xmath0 models described above : i assume a gas distribution described by eq . with @xmath49 , @xmath48 . then for a given central gas temperature , i determine the core radius of the model for which the temperature gradient is minimized . the new aspect is the second component which makes its presence felt by contributing to the total cumulative mass ( m(r ) in eq . 2 ) and hence the total gravitational force this has the effect of decreasing the core radius at a given temperature compared to the single component mond @xmath0 models . the emission - weighted temperature of as a function of projected radius is shown by the solid line in fig . 4 again for a model with a central temperature of 6.5 kev . this is the most - nearly isothermal model , and we see that the temperature gradients are much smaller than in the the single component @xmath0-model . the total variation about the central temperature is less than 40% . in other words , _ isothermal @xmath0 models require , in the context of mond , this second central component with roughly constant density_. the gas - mass - temperature relation of such models is shown by the solid line in fig . 1 which is evidently consistent with the observations . the luminosity - temperature relation for these two component cluster models is shown by the solid line in fig . 2 . these models provide a reasonable description of the observed relation . this is due to the fact that , in the low temperature systems , a relatively larger fraction of the mass is not in gaseous form . it is also not in the form of luminous material in galaxies as the implied mass - to - light ratios would be too large . agreement of mond with the cluster scaling relations is achieved at the expense of adding unseen matter . individual clusters may be described by such two component models . given the parameters of a @xmath0 model fit to the x - ray emission from an specific cluster ( i.e. , @xmath0 , @xmath45 , and @xmath46 ) , and a characteristic temperature for the entire cluster , i determine , via eqs . 1 and 2 , the central temperature , @xmath47 , and the density ( or surface density , related by eq . 11 ) of the dark component which yields the observed emission weighted temperature and the observed core radius , @xmath46 of the @xmath0 model . in all cases the dark component is assumed to extend to 2@xmath46 . uniqueness is ensured by requiring that the temperature gradients be minimized i.e. , these are again the most nearly isothermal models . the fitting parameter is the density of the central dark component which yields the total dark mass via eq . 12 above . table 1 lists the clusters which have been modeled in this way along with the the parameters of the @xmath0-model fit and the mean temperature , all from the compilation of reiprich ( 2001 ) with cluster properties scaled to h=0.7 . the the required central surface density of the dark component , @xmath62 , is given along with the total gas mass ( out to the cutoff radius ) and the total mass of the dark component . the enclosed newtonian dynamical mass is also given . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] this sample was chosen to include a number of objects with significant inferred cooling flows ( such as abel 1689 and 2029 ) . these clusters are characterized by relatively small core radii ( @xmath63 kpc ) and large central electron densities ( @xmath64 @xmath40 ) . the sample also includes clusters at the other extreme large core radii ( @xmath65 kpc ) and low central electron densities ( @xmath66 @xmath40 ) with no inferred cooling flow ( such as abel 119 and 2256 ) . in general , mond reduces the classical newtonian discrepancy for clusters of galaxies . for this sample , with mond the ratio of the total dark mass to the gas mass is 1.60 @xmath67 1.7 . the newtonian dark mass - to - gas mass ratio is 7.14 @xmath67 2.7 . while this is a significant reduction , it is also clear that mond does not fully resolve the mass discrepancy in clusters . moreover , it should be noted that the ratio of masses of the dark - to - hot gas components in the central two core radii ( where the additional component is required ) can be as large as 10 , as was also pointed out by aguirre , schaye & quataert ( 2001 ) . this rigid component can not be stars of a normal population because the mass - to - light ratio within two core radii would still be , on average , in excess of about 50 . the principle question is whether or not this dark component is a fundamental problem or can be accommodated in the context of mond . it could be that a high m / l population of low mass stars or sub - stellar objects is deposited in the central regions of clusters as a result of cooling flows . 6 is a plot of the total mass in the dark component vs. the cooling rate as estimated by white , jones & forman ( 1997 ) . the solid points are those clusters with a large discrepancy : @xmath68 . the crosses are clusters with a smaller discrepancy : @xmath69 . we see that there is no obvious correlation between the total mass of the dark component and the cooling rate especially for those clusters with the largest discrepancy . on the other hand , in fig . 7 we see a plot of the surface density of the dark component vs. the mass deposition rate . here there does appear to be a correlation . this is because those clusters with the highest central dark matter densities are not the clusters with the largest mass discrepancies . it is unclear if this apparent correlation between surface density and mass deposition rate is significant . the mass deposition is not actually observed but calculated from the central gas density . those clusters with large inferred cooling flows are clusters with high central gas densities and small core radii . but it precisely these clusters which require a large surface density of dark matter to produce the small core radius . while it may be the case that cooling flows contribute to the dark component of those clusters with the largest central density of dark matter , it is also evident from fig . 6 that this can not be the explanation for the discrepancy in clusters with the largest dark mass problem . these tend to be the clusters with low central gas densities and low inferred dark matter densities but large core radii . in the next section , i consider another possibility : particle dark matter in the form of massive neutrinos . the most well - motivated form of particle dark matter consists of neutrinos with finite mass . aspects of the observed fluxes of atmospheric and solar neutrinos provide strong evidence for neutrino oscillations and hence non - zero neutrino masses ( gonzales - garcia & nir 2002 ) . the fact that the number density of neutrinos produced in the early universe is comparable to that of photons then implies that there is a universal dark matter sea of neutrinos . the contribution to cosmological mass density would be @xmath70 ev where the sum is over neutrino types . the neutrino oscillation experiments do not provide information on the actual masses of neutrino species but on the square of the mass differences . these are small , such that , the largest mass difference , suggested by the atmospheric oscillations , is @xmath71 ev . if @xmath72 then the three active neutrino types would have no significant cosmological mass density ( @xmath73 ) and could not contribute to the mass budget of any bound astronomical object . but another possibility is that @xmath74 and that the masses of all three active types are nearly equal . in this case an upper limit to the masses is provided by an experimental limit on the mass of the electron neutrino , i.e. 2.2 ev at 90% c.l . ( groom et al . 2000 ) if it were the case that the electron neutrino mass were near 2 ev , then neutrinos would constitute a significant fraction of the cosmic density ( @xmath75 for h=0.7 ) . however , neutrinos of this mass could not contribute to the mass budget of galaxies . this follows from a classic argument by tremaine & gunn ( 1979 ) based upon conservation of the phase space density of the neutrino fluid . relativistic neutrinos are created with a maximum phase space density of @xmath76 per type including anti - neutrinos ( this is a factor of two less than the absolute limit implied by quantum mechanical degeneracy ) . in subsequent evolution of the neutrino fluid involving gravitational instability and collapse , the final phase space density can not exceed this value . this provides a relation between the final density of neutrino dark matter and the velocity dispersion of the system ; with three types @xmath77 equivalently , for virialized systems , this may be written as a relation between the effective core radius of a dark halo and its velocity dispersion ; this is , roughly , @xmath78 clearly for objects with the required velocity dispersion of galaxy halos ( @xmath79 ) , neutrinos in the mass range of one to two ev could not possible cluster on sub - mpc scales . however , it obviously would be possible for such neutrinos to contribute to the mass budget of large clusters . fig . 8 shows the the fitted matter density of the dark cores of the clusters of galaxies listed in table 1 vs. the gas temperature of the clusters . the solid points are the clusters with significant mass discrepancies ( @xmath68 ) and the open points the clusters with lower discrepancies ( @xmath69 ) . the solid and dashed lines show the relation between maximum neutrino density and the temperature implied by eq . 13 , for neutrinos of 2 ev and 1 ev respectively . for neutrinos of 2 ev , this relation appears to form an upper envelope for the clusters with the largest discrepancies . however , due to the extreme sensitivity of this density limit on neutrino mass ( eq . 13 ) , neutrinos with mass as low as 1 ev could not comprise the dark component . i have calculated the structure of a self - gravitating system supported by the degenerate pressure of neutrinos ( a neutrino star ) . in the non - relativistic case there is a pressure - density relation of the form @xmath80 where @xmath81 , and density is in g/@xmath37 . inserting this relation in eq . 1 , i determine the run of density in a system with a given central velocity dispersion . such objects ( n=1.5 polytropes ) have nearly constant density out to a finite radius where the density drops to zero . as for white dwarfs , there is a mass - radius relation . this is shown by the solid curve ( @xmath82 ev ) and the dashed curve ( @xmath83 ev ) in fig . 9 where i have assumed that the central velocity dispersion of the neutrinos is equal to the gas velocity dispersion . the solid points show the mass and radius of the dark matter cores for those clusters with significant discrepancies ( @xmath68 ) and the open points those with small discrepancies . the dotted line separates the mond and newtonian regime where we see that the mass - radius relation has different forms : @xmath84 in the mond regime and @xmath85 in the newtonian regime . it is of interest that for @xmath86 ev the range of radii and masses correspond in magnitude to the dark cores required in clusters . moreover , we see that those clusters with large discrepancies lie generally above the mass - radius relation as would be expected for neutrino clusters with density less than or equal to that given by eq . 13 . further , not even neutrinos of 2 ev apparently could contribute to the mass budget of those objects with low discrepancies . that neutrinos in the range of one to two ev make up the missing mass in clusters is a provocative possibility , and one which is within reach of experimental verification . the accelerator limits on the electron mass can soon be pushed to within a few tenths of an electron volt ; if there is no positive detection , then active neutrinos can not supply the dark mass of clusters . what one may call , generically , `` the dark matter problem '' first became evident with radial velocity studies of rich clusters of galaxies ( zwicky 1933 ) . the discrepancy between the visible and newtonian dynamical mass , quantified then in terms of mass - to - light ratio , was more than a factor of 100 . with the advent of x - ray observatories and the detection of hot gas in clusters , this discrepancy between dynamical and detectable mass was reduced to a factor of 10 . modified newtonian dynamics reduces the discrepancy further , to a factor of 2 to 3 , but it is clear that a discrepancy remains which can not be explained by detected gaseous or luminous mass . it is also apparent that while the missing mass is primarily in the inner regions of clusters , it does extend beyond the core radius as defined by the gas density distribution . how serious is this remaining mass discrepancy for mond ? formally speaking , it does not constitute a falsification . if the dynamical mass predicted by mond were generally less than the detected mass in stars and gas , then it would be a definite falsification , but this is not the case . more mass can always be found ( as in the case of the hot gas ) , but it is difficult to make observed mass disappear . one might reasonably argue that the implied presence of undetected mass runs against the spirit of mond , which , in the view of most people , was suggested primarily as a replacement for dark matter . but more generally , mond should not be viewed simply as an alternative to dark matter ; the systematic appearance of the mass discrepancy in astronomical systems with low internal accelerations is an indication that newtonian dynamics or gravity may break down in this limit . mond primarily addresses this issue : is physics in the low - acceleration regime newtonian ? the success of mond in explaining the scaling properties and observed rotation curves of galaxies suggests that it may not be . mond does not rest upon the principle that there is no undetected or dark matter . indeed , comparing the density of luminous matter to the baryonic content of the universe implied by considerations of primordial nucleosynthesis , one can only conclude that there is , as yet , undetected baryonic matter , probably in the form of diffuse gas in the intergalactic medium . moreover , it is virtually certain that particle dark matter exists in the form of neutrinos ; only its contribution to the total mass density of the universe is unclear . mond would be incompatible with the wide - spread existence of dark matter which clusters on the scale of galaxies cold dark matter . but mond is not inconsistent with hot dark matter such as 2 ev neutrinos , which can only aggregate on the scale of clusters of galaxies indeed , i have presented evidence that this may be the case . neutrinos , as particle dark matter candidates , are unquestionably well - motivated , both from a theoretical point - of - view ( they definitely exist ) and from an experimental point - of - view ( they have mass ) . no conjectured cdm particle shares these advantages . while i do not wish to state that the dark matter in clusters is definitely in the form of 2 ev neutrinos ( there is more than enough remaining baryonic matter to make up the missing mass ) , there are indications that point this way . the largest discrepancies are found in the clusters with the largest core radii as would be the case with neutrinos . the indicated densities of dark matter are comparable to the maximum possible density of 2 ev neutrinos . the radius - mass relationship for self - gravitating degenerate neutrino objects forms an envelope for those clusters with large discrepancies . the fact remains that there exists an algorithm , mond , which allows galaxy rotation curves to be predicted in detail from the observed distribution of matter , and it is for these systems that the kinematic observations are most precise . this fact challenges the current cdm paradigm , and demands explanation if dark matter lies behind the discrepancy . the factor two remaining discrepancy in clusters is less challenging for mond , particularly given that mond makes no claims about the full material content of the universe . aguirre a. , schaye j. , quataert e. , 2001 , apj , 561 , 520 arnaud m. et al . , 2001 , a&a , 365 , l67 briel u.g . , henry j.p . , bhringer h. , 1992 , a&a , 259 , l31 cavaliere a.l . , fusco - femiano r. , 1976 , a&a , 49 , 137 gerbal d. , durret f. , lachize - rey m. , lima - neto g. , 1992 , a&a , 262 , 395 gonzalez - garcia m.c . , nir y. , 2002 , hep - th/0202058 groom d.e . et al . , 2000 , eur.phys.j . , c15 , 1 hernquist l. , 1990 , apj , 356 , 359 ikebe i. , reiprich t.h . , bhringer h. , tanaka y. , kitayama t. , 2002 , a&a , 383 , 773 milgrom m. , 1983a , apj , 270 , 365 milgrom m. , 1983b , apj , 270 , 371 milgrom m. , 1983c , apj , 270 , 384 milgrom m. , 1984 , apj , 287 , 571 milgrom m. , 1997 , apj , 478 , 7 milgrom m. , 1998 , apj , 496 , l89 mohr j.j . , mathiesen b. , evrard a.e . , 1999 , apj , 517 , 627 reiprich t.h . , 2001 , dissertation , _ cosmological implications and physical properties of an x - ray flux - limited sample of galaxy clusters _ , ludwig - maximilians - universitt mnchen sanders r.h . , 1994 , a&a , 284 , l31 sanders r.h . , 1999 , apj , 512 , l23 sanders r.h . , mcgaugh s.s . , 2002 , ann.rev.a&a , 40 , 263 sarazin c.l . , 1988 , _ x - ray emissions from clusters of galaxies _ , cambridge university press , cambridge the l.s . , white s.d.m . , 1988 , aj , 95 , 1642 tremaine s. , gunn j.e . , 1979 , phys.rev.lett . , 42 , 408 white d.a . , jones c. , forman w. , 1997 , mnras , 292 , 419 zwicky f. , 1933 , helv.phys.acta , 6 , 110

x - ray emitting clusters of galaxies are considered in the context of modified newtonian dynamics ( mond ) . i show that self - gravitating isothermal gas spheres are not good representations of rich clusters with respect to the radial gas density distribution as indicated by the x - ray surface brightness . pure gas spheres with a density distribution described by a @xmath0 model , as observed , also fail because , with mond , these objects are far from isothermal and have a gas mass and luminosity much larger than observed for clusters of the same mean temperature . these problems may be resolved by adding an additional dark mass component in the central regions ; a constant density sphere contained within two core radii and having a total mass of one to two times that in the gas . with this additional component , the observed luminosity - temperature relation for clusters of galaxies is reproduced . when the observed x - ray surface brightness distribution in actual clusters is modeled by such a two - component structure , the typical mass discrepancy is three to four times smaller than with newtonian dynamics . thus while mond significantly reduces the mass of the dark component in clusters it does not remove it completely . i speculate on the nature of the dark component and argue that this is not a fundamental problem for mond . galaxy clusters : x - ray emission : kinematics and dynamics dark matter , gravitation

astro-ph0401487

since the discovery of 51 peg b ( mayor & queloz 1995 ) , over a hundred gaseous planets have been discovered in orbit around g , k , and m stars . these discoveries have opened a new domain of research in astronomy , at the crossroad between stellar and planetary physics . many ground - based and space - based missions are planned for the coming years to search for more of these objects , and the next decade will probably see the first direct detection of an extrasolar planet . these projects require a robust theoretical background to accurately understand the properties of these objects and to provide reliable guidance for observations . the vast majority of these planets have a projected mass , @xmath4 , of about one jupiter mass ( @xmath5 ) but are found to orbit much closer to their parent star than jupiter , with a pile - up around @xmath6 au . as such , these planets experience strong irradiation from their parent star . observations of objects that transit their parent star provide information crucial to understanding these so - called hot - jupiters . the transit light curve or photometry , supplemented by radial velocity measurements of the star , yields the absolute mass and average radius of the planet . together with an estimate of the age of the parent star from stellar evolution models , the radius and mass provide stringent constraints on the evolution of the internal and atmospheric properties of strongly irradiated planets . the correct description of these properties has been questioned recently by the detection of the transit planet @xmath0 ( brown et al . no consistent model can adequately reproduce the observationally determined mass and radius of the planet ( @xmath7 ) ( cody & sasselov 2002 ) without stretching these determinations beyond their error bars ( guillot & showman 2002 , baraffe et al . 2003 , burrows et al . this led to the suggestion that an important part of fundamental physics might be missing in the description of irradiated planets and has motivated several authors to propose possible shortcomings of the theory . in the present letter , the theory developed in baraffe et al . ( 2003 ) for non - irradiated and irradiated planets is applied to various cases of hot - jupiters , with special focus on the case of the second observed transit , @xmath1 . the theory adequately reproduces the observed radius of the planet , for the proper age of the system and the more recent mass determination ( torres et al . 2003 ) . the comparison of the present predictions for the evolution of hot - jupiters with forthcoming transit detections will allow the unambiguous verification or rejection of the present theory for a planet in close orbit around its parent star , the strong incident stellar radiation substantially modifies not only the emergent spectrum but also the evolution of the irradiated planet , as shown initially by guillot et al . these effects are examined below . under strong irradiation conditions , the solution of the transfer equation , which determines the atmospheric thermal structure of the planet , must include the incoming incident stellar flux in the source function . such calculations were first conducted for hot - jupiters by seager & sasselov ( 1998 ) , using a limited set of opacities , and have subsequently been improved by barman , allard & hauschildt ( 2001 ) and sudarsky , burrows & hubeny ( 2003 ) . figure [ f1.eps ] compares the thermal structures of irradiated and non - irradiated planets with surface gravity @xmath8 ( cgs units ) and intrinsic temperatures @xmath9 k and @xmath10 k , respectively , orbiting a g2 main sequence star at 0.023 au or 0.046 au . the atmosphere models were produced using the same cloud - free opacity setup described by allard et al . ( 2001 ) and barman , allard & hauschildt ( 2001 ) . as examined below , this @xmath11 sequence corresponds to an age sequence of @xmath123@xmath13 yr to @xmath129@xmath14 yr for @xmath1 . the irradiated thermal profile is shown to be strongly modified with respect to the non - irradiated one . as stressed in baraffe et al . ( 2003 ) , the differences between irradiated and non - irradiated temperature profiles clearly demonstrate the necessity to do _ consistent _ calculations that combine the irradiated atmosphere profile and interior profile . matching arbitrarily the inner profile to an atmospheric profile defined by the equilibrium temperature of the planet yields severely flawed results . note that the present calculations assume that all the incident flux is concentrated on the day - side of the planet . such an assumption maximizes the effect of irradiation and might overestimate the flux deposit . the present nearly isothermal irradiated profiles , however , are consistent with the 2@xmath15 m observed spectrum of @xmath0 ( richardson , deming & seager 2003 ) . future calculations will include the latitude dependence of the incoming radiation but it is certainly interesting to verify whether the present calculations , with minimal assumptions , adequately reproduce the radius of new observed transiting planets . consistent evolution calculations of irradiated planets have been conducted only recently by baraffe et al . ( 2003 ) and burrows et al . the calculations presented here proceed as described in chabrier & baraffe ( 1997 ) for the non - irradiated case . a grid of irradiated atmospheric structures is computed for various @xmath16 conditions , for a given orbital distance @xmath17 , and interpolation between these structures yield the unique boundary condition with the internal structure , at large enough optical depth ( @xmath18 ) . as shown initially by guillot et al . ( 1996 ) , irradiation pushes the radiative - convective boundary deeper into the interior and , under strong irradiation conditions , may force the boundary between the atmospheric and internal structure to lie in a radiative layer . to insure consistency between the atmosphere and internal thermal structures , we have computed the rosseland mean of the atmospheric opacities and used this value to calculate the radiative gradient for the interior structure . the evolution of the planet obeys the usual first and second principles of thermodynamics . the energy balance , however , must include the incoming stellar radiative flux @xmath19 , where @xmath20 and @xmath21 denote the parent star flux and radius , respectively . the total emergent flux of the planet @xmath22 now reads : @xmath23 where @xmath11 denotes the intrinsic effective temperature of the planet , @xmath24 its bond albedo , and the first term on the r.h.s . of eqn.([evolir ] ) describes the reflected part of the spectrum . note that the albedo @xmath24 is not a free parameter in our calculations but is calculated consistently with the radiative transfer equation . for both transit cases , the models predict @xmath25 . the total luminosity thus reads : @xmath26 where @xmath27 denotes the specific entropy of the planet . whereas the total flux @xmath28 or luminosity @xmath29 is the quantity accessible to observation , only the last term on the right hand side of eqn.([evolirrad ] ) concerns the evolution of the planet intrinsic luminosity @xmath30 . the first term , which defines the bond albedo , illustrates the fraction of the stellar luminosity reflected by the planet atmosphere . the second term defines its equilibrium temperature , i.e. the temperature the planet would reach in the absence of any internal source of energy ( @xmath31 ) . figure [ f2.eps ] compares the emergent flux calculated for @xmath1 and @xmath0 at their present ages . in both cases , the infrared part of the spectrum ( @xmath32 m ) is dominated by the re - radiation of the absorbed incident stellar flux . indeed , under the conditions of interest , this contribution largely dominates the intrinsic contribution of the planet ( @xmath33 k @xmath34100 k for @xmath1 , and @xmath35 k @xmath34100 k for @xmath0 ) . for @xmath0 , the short wavelength part of the spectrum ( @xmath36 m ) is mostly due to reflection of stellar light by h@xmath37 rayleigh scattering . however , in @xmath1 the high equilibrium temperature , @xmath38 k , leads to a lower concentration of h@xmath37 . consequently , reflection is less significant and the majority of the spectrum of @xmath1 is thermal radiation . figure [ f3.eps ] displays the evolution of the radius for different strongly irradiated planet conditions , with masses 0.69 @xmath39 and 1.5 @xmath39 , orbiting a g2 star ( @xmath40 k ) at different orbital distances , namely @xmath410.046 au and @xmath410.023 au . at a given orbital distance , the less massive the planet the larger the effect of irradiation . this was expected from figure [ f1.eps ] , showing the larger modification of the inner atmosphere profile with larger stellar / planet flux ratio . in all cases , however , irradiation substantially slows down the contraction of the planet , in particular at the early stages of evolution , when degeneracy effects in the interior are smaller . the case @xmath42 and @xmath410.023 au ( thick solid line ) corresponds to @xmath1 , for its recently revised mass , @xmath43 , and radius @xmath44 ( torres et al . 2003 ) . the age of the system was derived from the evolution of the parent star for its observed extinction - corrected magnitude and effective temperature ( sasselov 2003 ) . we derive @xmath45 , @xmath46 gyr to reproduce the observations , in excellent agreement with sasselov ( 2003 ) . the striking result is the very good agreement , within the error bar , between the present calculations and the observations . a prediction of the theory is that irradiation from a g2 star yields less than about @xmath47 increase of the planet radius after @xmath48 gyr , compared with the non - irradiated case , with all radii merging within the @xmath49 - 1.15 @xmath50 range at this stage . a key test for the theory , however , would be the observation of young @xmath51 yr ) transits , where radii of irradiated planets are predicted to vary rapidly with time and to depend substantially on the orbital distance . the case of @xmath0 thus becomes a puzzle . as discussed at length in baraffe et al . ( 2003 ) , no consistent evolution calculation can reproduce the observed radius . note that our calculations take into account the extension of the atmosphere , which we find to be of the order of @xmath52 ( at optical wavelengths ) for the age of this object . given the remaining uncertainties in the opacities of these planets , including for example non - equilibrium processes or day - night temperature gradients , we can not exclude larger extensions . it is very unlikely , however , that different opacities modify the internal adiabat strongly enough to increase the planet radius by 30% and thus solve the aforementioned discrepancy between theory and observation for @xmath0 . such a modification requires a drastic change of the energy deposited at the top of the internal adiabat , which essentially determines the radius ( baraffe et al . 2003 , guillot & showman 2002 ) . molecular absorption , however , will prevent incident photons from penetrating that deep ( @xmath53 k near the top of the internal adiabat , see figure [ f1.eps ] ) . as discussed in 4.3 of baraffe et al . ( 2003 ) , dynamical processes such as tidal dissipation or synchronization are unlikely to provide the extra source of energy , for these timescales are at most of the order of @xmath54 yr . an interesting alternative scenario involves the inner redistribution of large scale atmospheric kinetic energy ( winds ) generated by the incident irradiation ( guillot & showman 2002 , showman & guillot 2002 ) . besides arbitrarily modifying the atmosphere - interior boundary condition , however , these calculations face a similar issue as mentioned above , namely about 1% of this kinetic energy must _ constantly _ be dissipated at the internal adiabat level , i.e. @xmath55 bar for @xmath0 ( see figure 5 of baraffe et al . 2003 ) and @xmath56 bar for @xmath1 ( see figure [ f1.eps ] ) . this corresponds to 18 and 23 pressure scale heights for these two planets , respectively . whether such a fraction of the surface flux of kinetic energy can be transported downward over so many scale heights and converted into thermal energy remains to be uniquely determined . in order to test this scenario in the case of @xmath1 , we have made evolution calculations where a fraction of the incident stellar flux is deposited deep enough in the planet to modify its internal adiabat ( see baraffe et al . figure [ f4.eps ] displays the evolution for the two transiting planets when a fraction @xmath57 of the incident flux over the day - side surface is deposited in the interior , with @xmath58 0.1% to 1 or 2% . these values correspond to about 40 to 400 times the planet s intrinsic energy flux for @xmath1 and up to about 2000 times for @xmath0 . as shown in the figure , _ if _ indeed @xmath1 is unambiguously confirmed as a transiting planet , values of @xmath59 larger than @xmath60 seem to be excluded , for they yield an interior entropy and radius that are too large . for @xmath0 , on the contrary , @xmath61 is about the minimum fraction needed to be consistent with the observational error bar . as shown earlier , however , the internal adiabat for the @xmath0 irradiation conditions lies at fewer pressure scale heights from the surface than for @xmath1 so that we expect intuitively a larger fraction of energy to be transported downward . although these conclusions must be considered with caution , they suggest that the dissipative process invoked by showman & guillot may indeed take place in hot - jupiters . a tiny ( @xmath62 ) fraction of the surface kinetic flux transported downward and converted into thermal energy at the planet s radiative - convective boundary is enough to modify significantly its internal adiabat and thus its contraction rate . the result would be a total @xmath63 - 30% increase of the radius , instead of the aforementioned @xmath64 increase due to bare insulation . another appealing alternative solution to the @xmath0 dilemma is the suggestion by bodenheimer , laughlin & lin ( 2003 ) of a second orbiting planet , forcing the finite eccentricity ( @xmath65 ) of @xmath0 . the constant tidal heating due to the orbit circularization could provide the required mysterious extra source of energy . this key issue will be nailed down in the near future with further observations of transits , as planned with the various ground - based ( stare , vulcan ) and spaced - based ( corot , mons , most ) missions . in this letter , we have extended the theory we derived recently for the evolution of @xmath0 to various conditions of so - called hot - jupiters , i.e. gaseous planets in close enough orbit around their parent star for the incoming stellar irradiation to affect substantially their structure and evolution . as argued previously , a consistent treatment between the atmospheric profile and the interior profile is mandatory to yield reliable results , both in the irradiated and non - irradiated case . the theory , in its most simple foundation ( 1d irradiation , with incoming flux deposited uniformly over the day side and no dynamical redistribution of the incident flux due to day - night temperature differences ) is found to adequately reproduce the radius of @xmath1 . these conclusions , of course , rely on @xmath1 being a genuine exoplanet . recent high resolution spectroscopic observations seem to support this conclusion ( konacki et al . if @xmath1 is confirmed to be , unambiguously , a planet , then the present results add intriguing support to the suggestion that the large radius of @xmath0 might be due to ongoing tidal interaction with an undetected companion . however , we show that a very small fraction of the stellar incident flux , transformed into large scale kinetic energy partly dissipated at the internal adiabatic level , is sufficient to modify substantially a planet s internal entropy rate and thus evolution . this fraction is unlikely to be larger than a few 0.1% , but certainly depends on the irradiation conditions . a fraction @xmath2 to 0.5 % would superbly reproduce the observations of the two presently detected transits , @xmath1 and @xmath0 . the present theory allows us to derive the fundamental properties of hot - jupiters ( mass , temperature , radius ) and their observable spectroscopic or photometric signatures as a function of age and orbital distance . additional transit detections will also allow better constraints on possible irradiation induced dissipative processes , as explored in this letter . comparisons between the present evolution theory and transit or direct detections of exoplanets will greatly improve our understanding of these objects and provide strong motivation for exploring this exciting new field of astronomy . part of this work was conducted at the anglo - australian observatory , under the auspice of the franco - australian pics program . this research was supported in part by the ltsa grant nag 5 - 3435 to wichita state university .

extending the theory we derived recently for @xmath0 to different cases of strongly irradiated gaseous exoplanets , we have calculated the consistent evolution of the new transiting planet , @xmath1 , for its recently revised mass determination . the theory is shown to successfully reproduce the observed radius , for the proper age of the system . we also examine the dissipation of kinetic energy at the planet s internal adiabat due to atmospheric winds , and place constraints on the efficiency of this process . we show that a fraction @xmath2 @xmath3 of the incident flux transformed into thermal energy deposited at the adiabatic level can accommodate the observed radii of both @xmath1 and @xmath0 . the present theory yields quantitative predictions on the evolution of the emergent spectrum and fundamental properties of hot - jupiters . the predictions for radius , luminosity , temperature as a function of the planet s mass and orbital distance can be used as benchmarks for future detections of transit planets .

1605.00733

molecular polymorphism , the observation of different crystal structures made up of the same molecules , has been a central problem standing in the way of affordable and reliable crystal structure prediction ( csp ) which would greatly accelerate the development of new materials for applications in solid state chemistry , material science and pharmaceutical science @xcite . the key challenges for ab initio csp of molecular crystals can be summarized as * i ) * the computational cost of thermodynamical exploration of a rich polymorphic phase space , * ii ) * the accuracy needed to resolve similarly - low energies among polymorphs @xcite , and * iii ) * the fact that kinetic factors may control the crystallization procedure rather than thermodynamic ones @xcite . the past decade witnessed these challenges being tackled by the scientific community and the progress can be followed through the blind tests organized yearly by the cambridge crystallographic data centre @xcite . the exponential growth in the hardware performance and new , efficient algorithms tailored for molecular crystals have allowed a wider region of the phase space to be explored . the increased computational performance also enabled a transition from empirical interatomic potentials to more accurate but time consuming quantum mechanical techniques , mainly density functional theory ( dft ) . this transition did not guarantee however an increase in predictive power in all cases @xcite : the standard dft functionals do not describe properly van der waals ( vdw ) interactions , which forces csp studies to employ approximate semi - empirical corrections . these approximations to vdw interactions strongly affect the energy ordering of explored structures , which is a core information in predicting polymorphism . hence , to render csp predictions reliable , a fully ab initio method , able to obtain an accurate lattice energy including the vdw interactions , has been highly desirable . recently a breakthrough in the description of vdw interactions in dft has been made : many new non - local functionals that accurately describe the dispersion interactions have been proposed and demonstrated unprecedented success in a wide range of systems from molecules , molecular crystals to layered materials , with a computational cost comparable to that of standard functionals @xcite . it has been recently shown that even in difficult cases such as glycine crystals , where polymorphs show energy differences as little as 1 kcal / mol , new non - local functionals can yield the correct stability ordering as well as accurate pressure evolution @xcite . encouraged by these results we combine this critical progress in dft with recent developments in evolutionary csp @xcite , specifically adapted for molecular structure search @xcite , and perform a fully ab initio csp search on glycine crystals , without semi empirical corrections in the energy description , using neither information on cell geometry nor the symmetry of the experimentally observed polymorphs . we thus assess whether state - of - the - art ab - initio csp can pass the challenging blind test of exploring the phase space of polymorphic glycine . glycine , nh@xmath2ch@xmath2cooh , the smallest aminoacid , is an excellent test case for csp studies as its already rich polymorphism under ambient conditions is amplified and becomes less understood at higher pressure ( see fig.[fig1 ] ) . , with indicated @xmath3 molecules in unit cell , the form readily obtained by evaporation of aqueous solutions is @xmath1-glycine , which for long was believed to be the most stable phase instead of the later discovered ground - state phase @xmath4 . pressure evolution of ambient pressure phases show that while @xmath4 and @xmath5 phases quickly lose single crystal nature or undergo a phase transition within a few gpa , @xmath1 phase stays stable up to 23 gpa , the highest pressure reached in experiments . a reversible , hysteresis - free single - crystal to single - crystal transition occurs from @xmath5 to @xmath6 phase at 0.76 gpa . single crystals of the @xmath4 phase instead undergo an extended polymorphic transformation in the wide range of 2.7 - 7.6 gpa , to a high - pressure polymorph , the @xmath7 phase , accompanied with the fragmentation of single crystals into powder . upon decompression , the @xmath7 phase is stable down to 0.62 gpa , where a new , irreversible phase transition occurs to the @xmath0 phase , a new polymorph which is reported to be stable at ambient conditions for at least three days.,scaledwidth=47.0% ] a clear example to this is the @xmath0 phase , which is reported to be stable at ambient conditions for at least three days @xcite . interestingly , despite its stability , and at least three csp studies devoted to glycine so far @xcite , a decade after its observation , the @xmath0 phase has not been structurally resolved yet . the complex polymorphism of glycine highlights the importance of performing an extensive search in phase space , while practical concerns limit any csp study to explore primarily the lowest energy structures . in this study we use evolutionary algorithms ( ea ) as implemented in the uspex package to address this interplay efficiently @xcite . we perform three test suits with z=2 , 3 or 4 glycine molecules in the crystal unit cell . at the first generation , we start with a population of 30 random structures . this population evolves through generations where only the thermodynamically most stable members are allowed to procreate. the procreation operations are cross - overs of parent structures , and mutations that involve variation of the molecular position and orientation . the diversity of the population is guaranteed by addition of new random structures at each generation . the highest computational cost in this workflow is due to the ab initio geometry optimization of each structure considered . to keep this cost well within the capacity of modern high - performance computing technologies and within the budget of academic as well as industrial research , we limit the evolution to 20 generations at most ( see methods for details ) . we use ea as implemented in the uspex package to search for the low - energy structures of glycine with z=2 , 3 or 4 molecules in the unit cell . at the first generation , 30 structures are created randomly . after energy ordering , the @xmath8 of the population that is energetically least favorable is discarded . among the remaining , a fingerprint analysis is performed and potential parents whose fingerprint is within a threshold distance of 0.01 from any lower energy structure are discarded as well . the so - determined unique structures are eligible as parents and are allowed to procreate . the 30 new structures of the next generation are created from parents through the following operations : heredity ( cross - over of two structures ) ( @xmath9 ) , softmutation ( translation and rotation based on estimate of soft vibrational modes ) ( @xmath8 ) , rotation of the molecule ( @xmath8 ) , and random structure generation ( @xmath8 ) . in addition , the three best parents are directly cloned to the next generation . in all simulations , the maximum number of generations was 20 . for every structure generated by uspex , the geometry and cell relaxation is performed using vdw - df functional @xcite which was implemented in the quantum espresso package @xcite . a kinetic energy cutoff of @xmath10 ryd and a charge density cutoff of @xmath11 ryd are used . the brillouin zone sampling resolution was gradually increased in three steps during relaxation : resolution of @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 respectively . energies and geometries of the last step with the densest k - point are used throughout the study . paw pseudopotentials are taken from the pslibrary project@xcite . by using this setup all structures are fully relaxed within a convergence of less than 0.1 mry for absolute total energy , @xmath15 mry / a.u . for the forces on atoms and less than @xmath16 gpa for the stress tensor . the cluster analysis is performed by using single linkage clustering , where two structures with fingerprint distance less than distance threshold @xmath17 are considered to belong to the same cluster . since uspex definition of fingerprint does not include any information on the enthalpy of the structure , a constraint is added such that two structures with enthalpy difference more than 0.5 kj / mol are not allowed to form a cluster . this constraint is found necessary only when the clustering analysis is performed for all the encountered structures , while limiting the analysis to low enthalpy region , such constraint was not necessary as each cluster was successfully identified with distance only . the results of csp can be visualized through the distribution of energy as a function of volume for the structures encountered during the search . despite the exploration of a wide region in phase space ( see left panel of fig.[fig2 ] ) , phase . as shown in the _ inset _ of the z=4 panel , crowding around each polymorph , when compared with its equation of state , is compatible with numerical noise due to incomplete relaxation . the distance - based clustering techniques adopted here are however well suited to separate and identify the different low lying polymorphs even in presence of noise . , scaledwidth=47.0% ] about 40% of all the structures lies within 4 kj / mol of the experimentally known ground state structure , @xmath4 . focusing on this region of the energy landscape as shown in the right panels of fig.[fig2 ] , we see structures forming islands with varying size and shapes . this feature illustrates the added complication in the case of molecular csp with respect to standard inorganic solids where a well - defined , isolated minimum would be observed for each phase . the shape and finite size of the islands can be understood considering that glycine is very soft , therefore structures that are far off from the equilibrium lattice parameters are thermodynamically penalized only slightly as demonstrated in the inset of fig.[fig2 ] . this effect , combined with the numerical noise in geometry optimization , as well as an increased number of degrees of freedom in molecular crystals , is enough to give rise to crowding around each polymorphic minimum . nevertheless islands are well separated and a clear assignment of polymorphs can be made for most of them . this is in stark contradiction with a very recent csp study for glycine with empirical corrections for intermolecular interactions , which reported that the obtained energy - volume points were not separated well enough to clearly identify each polymorph , thus underlining the challenge of polymorphism for csp @xcite . in this study instead the separation between several islands are well represented down to very small energy differences ( inset of fig.[fig2 ] ) . we believe this stems from the leap in accuracy and precision reached by the use of fully ab initio energetics together with last generation evolutionary algorithm tools . ssibility of machine learning the polymorphs reliable energetics from ab initio calculations is necessary but not sufficient to guarantee a reliable structure classification in csp . more than one polymorph can be present within a given extended island ; or what appears to be two adjacent islands due to insufficient sampling and/or relaxation , may actually correspond to the same packing order . indeed the most human - time consuming part of a csp procedure is known to be the stage where the output structures are comparatively examined in order to successfully separate the essential data from the crowd of repetitions @xcite . although not utilized to their full extent within csp , concepts from data mining , mainly clustering techniques , can be of great help in this stage of the analysis , as we demonstrate in the following . * for all structures ( green line ) and low - energy structures within approximately 4 kj / mol of the ground state ( blue line ) for the case of @xmath18 . insets show the enthalpy ( kj / mol ) as a function of volume ( @xmath19 ) per molecule for different values of @xmath20 . different colors and point types in each inset correspond to different clusters . the value of @xmath21 can distinguish different clusters successfully . for @xmath22 and @xmath23 , see supplementary material fig.s1,scaledwidth=47.0% ] in fig.[fig3 ] we display a step by step clustering analysis where a bottom - up distance - based hierarchical clustering approach with single linkage is used to identify the unique polymorphs among all the structures obtained with csp . in distance - based approaches , a similarity metric is defined so that a distance can be measured between data points , and clusters are constructed based on proximity . in this study we use as the metric the fingerprint - based cosine distance @xcite defined in the ea code uspex @xcite : @xmath24 where individual structure fingerprints are defined as @xmath25 where the double sum runs over all @xmath26th molecules of type @xmath27 within the unit cell and all @xmath28th molecules of type @xmath29 within a distance @xmath30 ; @xmath31 is a gaussian - smeared delta function ; @xmath32 is the distance measured from the centers of molecules @xmath26 and @xmath28 ; @xmath33 is the unit cell volume ; the function @xmath34 is discretized over bins of width @xmath35 ; @xmath36 and @xmath37 are the number of molecules of type @xmath27 and @xmath29 , respectively . the distance threshold used to define whether two data points belong to the same cluster is then monotonically increased . as a result the cluster population evolves from the situation where every data point forms a distinct cluster to the situation in which all data points belong to the same global cluster , revealing the bottom - up and hierarchical nature of the approach . translated to the csp problem , this data mining approach transforms the challenge of identification of unique polymorphs from the visual comparison of all structures into an easier decision on the value of the distance - threshold . the optimal distance threshold is such that each data cluster matches a unique physical polymorph . in the case of glycine a distance threshold around 0.05 - 0.1 is found to be appropriate to identify the low energy polymorphs successfully ( see supplementary material table.s1 and related .cif files ) . the so - determined optimal threshold can serve in advanced supervised learning techniques and be fed back in the csp procedure to increase considerably the efficiency by reducing the generation of replicas of already explored structures . the cluster analysis outlined above identifies all experimentally observed phases of glycine compatible with 2 , 3 or 4 molecules per cell , as well as suggesting others , hereon named according to their enthalpy - per - molecule ordering . phases 1 to 11 lie within approximately 2 kj / mol of the experimentally most stable phase , @xmath4 . among them one of the lowest energy polymorphs ( phase 2 ) can be identified with @xmath0glycine based on the excellent agreement with xrd results ( fig.[fig4](a ) ) as well as its pressure evolution ( fig.[fig4](b ) ) . phase . * * a*. comparison of simulated x - ray diffraction patterns for @xmath7- , @xmath4- and @xmath0 - glycine at 2 gpa with experimental data taken from @xcite at 0.2 gpa . the xrd of proposed @xmath0-glycine can explain most of the unassigned peaks that were marked in the experimental spectrum . the theoretical spectra are calculated at higher pressure to offset the overestimation of ground state volumes in ab initio calculations . * b*. enthalpy per molecule as a function of pressure for @xmath7-glycine and @xmath0-glycine with respect to the @xmath4 phase up to 5 gpa . the black arrows indicate the phase transitions observed in the experiment @xcite : under pressure , the @xmath4 phase undergoes a phase transition to @xmath7-glycine . the decompression of @xmath7-glycine instead results in the @xmath0 phase . , scaledwidth=47.0% ] the structural identification of the @xmath0 phase , previously experimentally observed but not resolved up to now , marks an important achievement for csp and is a key result of our study . the search for @xmath1glycine proved very demanding despite it being the experimentally most readily formed polymorph at ambient conditions . in this study the @xmath1 phase could not be found even after 20 generations with the standard settings in uspex . this difficulty revealed one of the remaining challenges of csp : the effective exploration of the topology of an erratic and vast configuration space . indeed , the fully ab - initio scheme advocated for in this work pays for the higher accuracy with a heavy computational cost that makes this effectiveness even more crucial . to improve on this aspect we weighted the random selection of the space group of the candidate structures according to the frequency distribution appearing in known organic crystal structure database [ @xmath38 ( 36.59 % ) , @xmath39 ( 16.92 % ) , @xmath40 ( 11.00 % ) , @xmath41 ( 6.95 % ) , @xmath42 ( 6.35 % ) , @xmath43 ( 4.24 % ) , and uniform otherwise ] @xcite this procedure successfully produced the @xmath1 phase at the @xmath44 generation , demonstrating that incorporation of even mild and system unspecific experimental knowledge in the search strategy may have a significant impact to overcome the effectiveness challenge in the most demanding cases . indeed if more system specific information is available it can be used to further constrain and guide the phase - space search : limiting the search to the experimentally known , @xmath45 , space group of @xmath1glycine , or fixing the cell shape to its experimental value , resulted in its identification at the @xmath46 and @xmath47 generations , respectively . combining the two constraints resulted in an even quicker discovery at the third generation . once the low energy structures are found and examined , the configuration space search can be further instructed to look for certain patterns . in the case of @xmath1glycine , it is noteworthy that the crystal building block can be seen as a glycine dimer , with head to tail orientation . this feature is not seen in other ambient pressure polymorphs of glycine , and can be speculated to be one of the reasons for the @xmath1 phase not being readily connected with other phases in the energy landscape . this correlates with the difficulty of generating the structure during the ea procedure , as well as with its exceptional stability under pressure . instead , if the dimer unit is taken as building block in a csp search , the @xmath1 phase is found at the third iteration and new phases such as phase 8 , phase 14 , phase 24 and phase 38 are also discovered . hence the difficulty of exploring the @xmath1 phase as well as the finding of new phases only after a dimer unit is employed , underlines the remaining challenges of csp and calls for even more efficient methods for exploring new structures and innovative data analysis applications to guide the search on the go for a full optimization of resources . ( see supplementary material fig.s2 - 10 for details of all search attempts ) . we presented a fully blind , fully ab initio crystal structure prediction test on glycine , a system that has been examined several times in the past yet never fully grasped . a remarkable precision and a broad sampling is obtained in an affordable computational time thanks to last generation van der waals density functionals and evolutionary algorithms at the leading edge . the comparison of our results with existing experimental studies enabled us to resolve the so - far unidentified @xmath0 phase a decade after its first experimental observation . further analysis of the results of the blind test allowed us to propose several new thermodynamically plausible structures with varying volume , compressibility and polarization . to address the experimentally well established but csp - wise challenging @xmath1 phase , we introduced an intuitive sampling strategy based on crystal structure relative frequency found in nature . this strategy successfully found this challenging phase and allowed us further insight in the energy landscape . overall , the results of our blind test shows us that a reliable crystal structure prediction procedure is possible with incorporation of several complementary recipes to reach success , emphasizing that one - size - fits - all solutions are yet to be discovered . fortunately , the leap in precision and sampling capability we have demonstrated with these new generation tools opens new paths for crystal structure prediction with data processing procedures such as clustering algorithms . hence we strongly believe ab initio csp as presented here has come a long way and that a new standard for structure prediction for molecular crystals is set , and an interdisciplinary horizon for computational science within this field is now open . work supported by the italian miur through the prin 2010 initiative ( prin 20105zztse ) . computational resources have been provided by sissa and cineca , italy , and on curie@tgcc - cea through prace project 2011050736 .

accurate molecular crystal structure prediction is a fundamental goal in academic and industrial condensed matter research and polymorphism is arguably the biggest obstacle on the way . we tackle this challenge in the difficult case of the repeatedly studied , abundantly used aminoacid glycine that hosts still little - known phase transitions and we illustrate the current state of the field through this example . we demonstrate that the combination of recent progress in structure search algorithms with the latest advances in the description of van der waals interactions in density functional theory , supported by data - mining analysis , enables a leap in predictive power : we resolve , without prior empirical input , all known phases of glycine , as well as the structure of the previously unresolved @xmath0 phase after a decade of its experimental observation [ boldyreva et al . _ z. kristallogr . _ * 2005 , * _ 220 , _ 50 - 57 ] . the search for the well - established @xmath1 phase instead reveals the remaining challenges in exploring a polymorphic landscape .

1106.3031

general relativity concerns a geometrical formulation of gravity and has as a tenet a pseudo - riemannian geometry for the manifolds taken in consideration . however , this is an arbitrary choice and is intended to preserve scalar products between vectors and , consequently , their lengths when parallel transported along an arbitrary path on the manifold . nevertheless , considering that in this theory the characterization of space - time is made by rulers and clocks based on light rays emission and reception , ehlers , pirani and schild@xcite ( eps ) , followed by woodhouse,@xcite have shown that the pseudo - riemannian geometry represents a restriction among the possibilities those measuring tools allow . that is , starting from axioms concerning light rays and trajectories of freely falling particles you get , necessarily , a weyl geometry as the most general one . this , in turn , differs from the pseudo - riemannian one by allowing vectors to change their modulus when paralel transported along any curve . weyl s motivation was to geometrize electromagnetism , with the intend to unify it with gravitation , and the length variation of vectors was associated with the electromagnetic potential.@xcite being so , it suffered some criticisms that made it be abandoned . however , the axiomatic characterization of space - time by eps and woodhouse bring weyl geometry to light once again . this time there is no association of length variation with any known physical field . the vector field that performs such a variation , which we will call @xmath0 , is purely geometrical , and thus the objections raised before are transcended . in sec . [ sec - propriedades ] are presented the main properties of weyl geometry . from them , preserving the postulate that test particles travel through time - like geodesics , it is verified that those should be different from the pseudo - riemannian case of general relativity ( gr ) . the @xmath0 field appears giving extra contributions to the trajectories of material particles and thus influencing on an observable of the theory . this is one of the motivations to study einstein gravity in weyl geometry : as a way to determine how or to what extent one can use the new geometric field to make the theory more consistent . in the following section it is made a brief study of congruences of curves in weyl . it is defined the concept of physical distance between neighboring curves and it is shown that their evolution is given by a linear transformation . next , the matrix of this transformation is decomposed in their irreducible parts , which are the corresponding expressions for the expansion , shear and rotation from gr . in sec . [ sec - form varia e acopl ] we restrict the weyl geometry to its integrable version , where @xmath1 . in this case , variations of length depend only on the starting and ending points of the trajectory . variational formulations are presented for both obtaining gravitation in this geometry and for particles to follow geodesics . it is established how other physical fields are coupled with the new geometric one and it is observed that the coupling used endows our theory with a gauge symmetry inducing a conformal invariance . as discussed in ref . , since dirac@xcite raised the question about the gravitational constant be , in fact , a constant , this problem has been a challenge for theoretical physics . however , it is argued that this can be solved by taking into account the principle that all fundamental equations of physics must be invariant under local transformations of scale , as proposed by weyl@xcite and hoyle and narlikar.@xcite it is therefore of great theoretical interest to examine a conformal invariant version of gravitation . other versions of a non - conformal model for the gravitational interaction in weyl integrable space - times ( wist ) were already developed@xcite and applications were made in cosmology@xcite and in spherically symmetric configurations for modeling stars.@xcite besides that , the wist geometry has been used to describe the quantum behavior of a particle in an external potential in the non - relativistic@xcite and the relativistic@xcite regime . nevertheless , none of them has formulated the theory in this gauge invariant way . carrying on with the reformulation of the theory , it remained to redefine the observables of gr within this formalism . in sec . [ sec - red - shift ] this is done for the red - shift and in sec . [ sec - verif inv conf ] it is shown that it preserves the gauge symmetry of the theory , as expected . moreover , in sec . [ sec - inv conf em mod cosmo ] it is shown that for cosmological models the conformal invariance opens the possibility that observations may no longer indicate a curvature nor an evolution to the metric . all observations and conclusions from the red - shift in gr being fully described in terms of the @xmath2 field . we conclude that this reformulation of einstein s gravitation in the more general and axiomatic context of weyl geometries turns out to acquire a gauge symmetry that , although it represents a theoretical advance , introduces an indeterminacy of their objects which needs to be solved , for consistency . weyl s geometry differs from that of riemann by allowing vectors to also change their modules when parallel transported along a closed path . this can be summarized by the following expression for the covariant derivative of the metric:@xcite @xmath3 this implies a connection given by @xmath4 where symbols with hat refer to their equivalent in the riemannian case . from it , we can also conclude that for any vector @xmath5 we have : @xmath6 then , the most general geodesic equation is given by : @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the tangent vector of the geodesic and @xmath9 is the parameter which describes it . we consider a congruence of curves @xmath10 , @xmath11 , which in a local coordinate system @xmath12 , have coordinates @xmath13 and we take the parameter @xmath14 so that @xmath15 two neighboring points , @xmath16 and @xmath17 , define a new vector which we will call _ connection vector_. their components are @xmath18 and it is associated with the distance , on the manifold , between the points @xmath19 and @xmath20 . the physical distance , locally determined by an observer at rest in relation to what has the curve @xmath21 as world line , is given by @xmath22 , which we will call _ relative position vector _ , where @xmath23 makes the projection of any vector in the space perpendicular to @xmath8 . introducing the notation @xmath24 to any vector @xmath5 , the relative velocity between two neighboring particles in the congruence is given by @xmath25 and is related to @xmath26 by the following equation : @xmath27 by the property @xmath28 , we can simplify the result to @xmath29 where we have defined @xmath30 . this shows that the velocity of separation between neighboring particles is related to the relative position vector by a linear transformation . it can be easily verified that @xmath31 , then we have their irreducible parts : @xmath32 } \end{array}\right\}\;\rightarrow\ ; v_{\alpha\beta } = \omega_{\alpha\beta } + \sigma_{\alpha\beta } + \frac{1}{3}\theta h_{\alpha\beta } \ , . \label{decomp irredutivel para v}\ ] ] where @xmath33 and @xmath34}$ ] are their symmetric and antisymmetric parts respectively . although we are not with the riemannian connection anymore , the parameter we have defined is such that @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 are still related to the expansion , shear and rotation of the congruence respectively.@xcite in order to make this geometric description compatible with a variational principle for the dynamics of a particle in a gravitational field,@xcite we will restrict ourselves to a particular case of weyl geometry which is called weyl integrable space - time ( wist ) in what follows . this is done simply by restricting the field @xmath38 to a gradient . that is , from now on we will consider only @xmath39 this kind of geometry is easily obtained by performing a palatini approach to the action @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the ricci scalar and we follow the sign conventions of ref . . variation of the connection gives precisely ( [ conexao de weyl ] ) with ( [ omega em wist ] ) , what is necessary and suficient to give ( [ deriv da metrica em weyl ] ) ensuring we are in wist . variation of the metric and @xmath2 gives respectively : @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the einstein tensor . we see that variation of @xmath2 gives a redundant equation , since ( [ variacao de omega - vacuo ] ) is the same as the trace of ( [ variacao da metrica - vacuo ] ) . such equality implies in a freedom to one of the functions to be determined . soon it will be shown what this freedom can imply in turn . for test particles to obey the geodesic equation ( [ eq geodesica em weyl ] ) , we first note that in wist we have @xmath44 so , the equation becomes @xmath45 moreover , according to refs . and , in order to characterize a good clock for the observer who follows this geodesic , we should choose such a parameter in which the right hand side of the above equation is zero . this is achieved by precisely that same parameter @xmath14 defined before , in ( [ parametro afim ] ) . this equation is obtained by the following action for a test particle with mass @xmath46 : @xmath47 if we now notice that @xmath48 that is , the connection is just like the riemannian one ( christoffel symbol ) written with @xmath49 , we see that things work much like they were in riemann , but with @xmath49 instead of @xmath50 whenever it appears . that is exactly what happened in the action ( [ acao para part teste em wist ] ) and hence in the geodesic equation ( [ eq geodesica em wist ] ) . specially if we take the parameter @xmath51 defined in sec . [ sec - congruencia de curvas ] , which is again another case of replacing @xmath50 by @xmath49 in the definition of the affine parameter in the riemannian case . moreover , the situation is the same in ( [ acao para weyl - vacuo ] ) : since we have @xmath52 , the einstein - hilbert action becomes @xmath53 now we have made these considerations , it is quite clear that the most natural choice for coupling other fields with @xmath2 is by keeping this same recipe . that is , we take any other lagrangian of the form @xmath54 , in gr , and write it as @xmath55 . then , we will have for our wist action : @xmath56\sqrt{-\tilde{g}}d^4x \ , . \label{acao inv conf wist}\ ] ] variation of the connection gives us wist . variation with respect to the metric gives @xmath57 e^{\omega}\sqrt{-\tilde{g } } = 0 \quad \rightarrow \nonumber \\ \rightarrow \quad & g_{\mu\nu}(\tilde{g}^{\mu\nu } ) = -t_{\mu\nu}(\tilde{g}^{\mu\nu } , ... ) \;\ ; \therefore \;\ ; r(\tilde{g}^{\mu\nu } ) = t(\tilde{g}^{\mu\nu } , ... ) \ , , \label{eq einstein inv conforme}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined @xmath58}{\delta \tilde{g}^{\alpha\beta } } \ , . \label{tensor momento energia wist}\ ] ] varying @xmath2 we have @xmath59 e^{\omega}g^{\mu\nu}\sqrt{-\tilde{g } } = 0 \quad \rightarrow \nonumber \\ \rightarrow \quad & r(\tilde{g}^{\mu\nu } ) = t(\tilde{g}^{\mu\nu } , ... ) \ , , \label{dinamica p omega wist}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is a redundant equation , since it is equal to ( [ eq einstein inv conforme ] ) . so we still have a freedom to one of the functions to be determined . but now it is very clear where this freedom comes from . since the function @xmath2 always appears together with the metric in the form @xmath49 , it is just a matter to see that it remains unchanged under the transformation @xmath60 so we have an arbitrariness in the fields that keeps the theory just developed invariant . such invariance should be present in all observables defined on this theory , and so , our next task is to check it for the red - shift . we will now define it in this new context and show that it is invariant under the above transformation . following the lines of ref . we have for the geometrical optics approximation that light rays follow trajectories whose tangent vector , @xmath61 , is given by : @xmath62 where @xmath63 is a phase . moreover , according to ( [ contracao de x com deriv de x ii ] ) , we also have @xmath64 . since @xmath65 , we then have @xmath66 . this , in turn , implies @xmath67 that is , light rays follow null geodesics just like the manifold was riemannian instead of a weyl one . for the red - shift we have the following relation between the frequency of the electromagnetic waves in the moment of emission , @xmath68 , and observation , @xmath69 : @xmath70 the red - shift , @xmath71 , of a source as measured by an observer is defined in terms of wavelenghts by @xmath72 which determines the red - shift from the vectors @xmath73 , @xmath74 and the tangent vector @xmath61 of the null geodesic . this relation is valid regardless of the separation between the emitter and the observer and accounts for both doppler and gravitational red - shift . next , we make the following decomposition of @xmath61 : we consider an observer with four - velocity @xmath8 and let @xmath75 be a projection of @xmath61 into the observer s rest frame , given by @xmath76 taking @xmath77 as the parameter along the null geodesic , we have @xmath78 and we can calculate the variation of @xmath79 on an interval @xmath80 along it as being . ] @xmath81 from ( [ decomp irredutivel para v ] ) and ( [ decomp de k em u e n ] ) we can rewrite it as @xmath82 now , from ( [ def do redshift ] ) we have @xmath83 which gives the variation of the wavelength along a small increment @xmath80 on the parameter that describes the light ray . next , we show that both this expression and ( [ def do redshift ] ) are gauge invariants , as expected . let us examine the invariance of the objects that characterize the red - shift under the conformal transformation ( [ transformacao metrica e omega ] ) . we see that the following quantities from their definitions are transformed as follows : @xmath84 thus , we have @xmath85 and we confirm the invariance of ( [ def do redshift ] ) . for equation ( [ variacao infinitesimal de lambda 3 ] ) we have @xmath86 and their different terms are transformed as : @xmath87 given ( [ transformacao de uk ] ) , it remains only to determine the transformation of @xmath80 , which is obtained from @xmath88 so we have @xmath89 and we see that the gauge freedom of our theory still holds for the red - shift , preserving the arbitrariness to one of their geometrical objects . we have the friedmann model for the three possible curvatures in a weyl geometry where , initially , @xmath90 : @xmath91 \label{metrica de friedmann em f(rho)}\ ] ] where @xmath92 is equal to @xmath93 , @xmath94 or @xmath95 for the spherical , flat and hyperbolic cases , respectively . the red - shift can be calculated from ( [ relac entre freq no redshift ] ) or ( [ variacao infinitesimal de lambda 3 ] ) , where the velocities of the observer and emitter are both equal to @xmath96 now for @xmath61 , we have in the three models : @xmath97 this expression can also be obtained from ( [ variacao infinitesimal de lambda 3 ] ) , since we have in it : @xmath98 and the equation gets : @xmath99 however , being the metric ( [ metrica de friedmann em f(rho ) ] ) conformally flat , we can perform coordinate transformations in order to rewrite it as @xmath100 ( see appendix ) . then , we make the transformation ( [ transformacao metrica e omega ] ) and we are now with a weyl geometry where @xmath101 , @xmath102 and we have the same expression for the red - shift . that is , we now have the possibility that observations of red - shift can be attributed to the field @xmath2 of a weyl geometry in minkowski space . no longer indicating a curvature nor evolution to the metric likewise , we could have done something in between , _ i.e. _ , a gauge transformation to get @xmath103 and @xmath104 . motivated by the axiomatic approach of eps and woodhouse to characterize space - time we performed a reformulation of gr in the context of wist for the sake of consistency . after introducing the variational formulation of their basic concepts , like the dynamics for their geometrical objects and test particles , it was established how other physical fields couples with the geometry . the particular coupling choosen endows our reformulation with an unprecedented gauge symmetry that is of great theoretical interest by itself . on the other hand , this same gauge freedom leaves the role of their geometric fields undetermined . that is , one can choose any expression for one of them . it was then presented a reformulation of the red - shift in which the symmetry is still present . it was observed that in the cosmological case the gauge freedom may be used to deprive the metric of any curvature or evolution . we can make , as a particular case , such a transformation in which the metric becomes the minkowski one and the whole red - shift observations turns out to be described solely in terms of the new geometrical field , @xmath2 . we see that , so far , this reformulation still lacks a complete description of their geometric objects . the attempt of having them fully described is our current subject of investigation . we acknowledge conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico for financial support . we want to perform coordinate transformations in order to rewrite the metric ( [ metrica de friedmann em f(rho ) ] ) as * flat case : + @xmath106 = e^{-\lambda(t)}\left[dt^2 - dr^2 - r^2 d\omega^2\right ] \ , . \label{metrica de friedmann caso plano}\ ] ] + this is accomplished by making + @xmath107 * hiperbolic case + @xmath108 = e^{-\lambda(\tau(t , r))}\left[dt^2 - dr^2 - r^2 d\omega^2\right ] \ , . \label{metrica de friedmann caso hiperbolico - hiperbolico transf}\ ] ] + this is achieved by the transformations : + @xmath109 + with the condition that + @xmath110 \quad \leftrightarrow \quad \frac{d}{d\tau } \left[e^{\frac{\lambda(\tau)}{2}}a(\tau)\right ] = \mp e^{\frac{\lambda(\tau)}{2 } } \ , . \label{caso hiperbolico - equacao para lambda}\ ] ] * spherical case + @xmath111 = e^{-\lambda(\tau(t , r))}\left[dt^2 - dr^2 - r^2 d\omega^2\right ] \ , . \label{metrica de friedmann caso hiperbolico - hiperbolico transf}\ ] ] + this is done by simply making the changes : + @xmath112 + in the transformation used for the hyperbolic case , where @xmath113 . given those transformations , it is straightforward to apply the gauge transformation ( [ transformacao metrica e omega ] ) and check that everything actualy tranforms like it was shown in sec . [ sec - verif inv conf ] . the final result ( [ z em friedmann 2 ] ) then follows necessarily . f. hoyle and j. v. narlikar , _ action - at - a - distance in physics and cosmology _ , ( freeman , san francisco , 1974 ) , and in _ cosmology , fusion and other matters _ , ed . f. reines , ( colorado associated universities press , boulder , 1972 ) . g. f. r. ellis , relativistic cosmology , in _ proceedings of the international school of physics `` enrico fermi '' , course 47 : general relativity and cosmology _ , ed . r. k. sachs ( academic press , new york and london , 1971 ) , p. 104 . reprinted in _ _ , * 41 * , 581 ( 2009 ) .

motivated by an axiomatic approach to characterize space - time it is investigated a reformulation of einstein s gravity where the pseudo - riemannian geometry is substituted by a weyl one . it is presented the main properties of the weyl geometry and it is shown that it gives extra contributions to the trajectories of test particles , serving as one more motivation to study general relativity in weyl geometry . it is introduced its variational formalism and it is established the coupling with other physical fields in such a way that the theory acquires a gauge symmetry for the geometrical fields . it is shown that this symmetry is still present for the red - shift and , considering cosmological models , it opens the possibility that observations can be fully described by the new geometrical scalar field . it is concluded then that this reformulation , although representing a theoretical advance , still needs a complete description of their objects .

1302.3790

in the field of microarrays it has traditionally been difficult to compare new methods to methods in published papers as the many methods available for pre - processing , summarizing and filtering make it almost impossible to work with the exact same data , even when the raw data is made available . that is why we consider reproducible research fundamental as it will facilitate easy 1 ) revision of papers , 2 ) access to data and results , 3 ) communication to other researchers and 4 ) comparison between different methods . reproducible research is gaining relevance among the scientific community as shown by the number of papers published on the subject during the last years @xcite . _ showed that the results of only 2 out of 18 published microarray gene - expression analyses were completely reproducible @xcite . this is why some authors demand that documentation and annotation , database accessions and url links and even scripts with instructions are made publicly available @xcite . journals like biostatistics have even appointed an associate editor for reproducible research , but still treat it as a desirable goal " rather than a requirement @xcite . setting up a framework for reproducible research necessarily implies working with free and open - source software as for example r / bioconductor @xcite . additionally , using sweave @xcite ( a tool for embedding ` r ` code in latexdocuments @xcite ) , enables automatic reports that can be updated with output from the analysis . the main tool in this paper will be the bioconductor package ` aroma.affymetrix ` @xcite that can analyse all affymetrix chip types with a ( .cdf ) chip definition file . the number of arrays ( samples ) that can be simultaneously analysed by ` aroma.affymetrix ` is virtually unlimited as the system requirements are just 1 gb ram , for any operating system @xcite . this package is freely available and can easily be installed into ` r ` . the aroma.affymetrix website www.aroma-project.org is conceived as reference for all the possible microarrays that can be analysed with ` aroma.affymetrix ` , and does not focus specifically on the analysis of the genechip human exon 1.0 st array ( or exon array in short ) . portable scripts for a fast and basic analysis can be obtained on request to ` aroma.affymetrix ` s authors . the analysis of exon array data in ` r`/bioconductor is not yet standard . there are several packages available , and it can be a tremendous effort for a newcomer to maneuver between them , and to overcome the numerous challenges associated with these packages . this paper aims to make this task easier and to provide a quick reference guide to ` aroma.affymetrix ` s documentation . we also explain how to extract data for different statistical analyses and propose a method for gene annotation and for gene profile visualization . for this last step , we use the packages ` biomart ` and ` genomegraphs ` to annotate and visualize the transcripts in a genomic context . the analysis workflow presented in this paper is carried out solely in ` r`/bioconductor , and the paper is available as a sweave ( .snw ) document that will allow the reader to reproduce our exact results . the .snw document can also be converted into an ` r ` script and executed . the workflow starts by reading in the data , followed by background correction and quantile normalization . we then explain how to obtain transcript cluster - , probeset - , and probe - level estimates . afterwards , different methods for the statistical analysis of differential splicing or differential gene expression are reviewed . finally , we make a suggestion on how to annotate transcript clusters to genes in the lists obtained from the statistical analyses , and how to plot the data including genomic information . to exemplify the use of the workflow , an example dataset @xcite is analysed along the way . splicing is the post - transcriptional process that generates mature eukaryotic mrnas from pre - mrnas by removing the non - coding intronic regions and joining together the exonic coding regions . for many genes , two or more splicing events take place during maturation of mrna molecules resulting in a corresponding number of alternatively spliced mrnas . these mature mrnas translate into protein isoforms differing in their amino acid sequence and ultimately in their biochemical and biological properties @xcite . alternative splicing is one of the main tools for generating rna diversity , contributing to the diverse repertoire of transcripts and proteins @xcite . it is known that 92 - 94% of multi - exon human genes are alternatively spliced and that 85% of those have a minor isoform frequency of at least 15% @xcite . in our case we will focus on the detection of differential splicing between groups , as for instance tissue types , or healthy vs. diseased samples . the exon array was presented in october 2005 as a tool for the analysis and profiling of whole - transcriptome expression @xcite . to interrogate each potential exon with at least one probeset , the exon array contains about 5.6 million probes grouped into more than 1.4 million probesets ( most probesets consisting of 4 probes ) , which are further grouped into 1.1 million exon clusters , or collections of overlapping exons . finally , exon clusters are grouped into over 300.000 transcript clusters to describe their relationship , as for example shared splice sites or overlapping exonic sequences . each gene is covered , on average , by 40 probes interrogating regions located along the entire gene @xcite . this probe positioning aims at providing better estimates of gene expression levels than previous arrays , and allows for the study of differential splicing @xcite and differential gene expression based on summarized exon expression . the exon array has three levels of annotation for the interrogated transcript clusters : _ core , extended _ and _ full _ @xcite . core transcript clusters are supported by the most reliable evidence such as refseq transcripts and full - length mrnas @xcite and a core transcript cluster is roughly a gene @xcite ; the extended level contains the core transcript clusters plus cdna - based annotations @xcite and the full level contains the two previous levels plus _ ab - initio _ , or algorithmic , gene predictions @xcite . it is worth noting that ` aroma.affymetrix ` enables the analysis at the three levels of annotation mentioned above , and also that it provides intensity estimates for probes , probesets and transcript clusters , allowing for a variety of options for the analysis . our workflow for the analysis of exon array data starts setting up the required folder structure for ` aroma.affymetrix ` . the data is then preprocessed and summarised at transcript cluster and/or probeset level . next , transcript clusters are analysed with several statistical models to detect differential expression or splicing and the transcripts of interest are annotated and visualised at the end , see figure [ fig : flowchart ] . in the code , places where user input is needed are marked by * * * " , and places where the user can choose whether to modify parameters are marked by * * " . to exemplify the use of the tutorial we have used affymetrix s colon cancer data set @xcite , consisting of a collection of paired samples of colon tumour tissue and adjacent normal tissue from 10 patients and available at http://www.affymetrix.com/support/technical/sample_data/exon_array_data.affx . according to affymetrix s website , the rna samples are from a commercial source . this dataset has been used in a number of papers to evaluate the performance of different analysis methods @xcite and a number of genes have been validated to present differential splicing or not @xcite . the analysis was done in ` r ` version 2.15.1 ( 32 bit ) . start by installing and loading ` aroma.affymetrix ` in ` r ` and loading the other libraries required : .... > source("http://aroma - project.org / hblite.r " ) > hbinstall("aroma.affymetrix " ) > require(aroma.affymetrix ) > require(biomart ) > require(genomegraphs ) .... this section corresponds to steps 1 . and 2 . in figure [ fig : flowchart ] . the first step is to create the folder structure : under a main folder of our choice - ` myworkingdirectory ` " - we will create the ` rawdata ` " and ` annotationdata ` " folders , which will be common to all ` aroma.affymetrix ` projects . inside ` annotationdata ` " , the subfolder ` chiptypes ` " will contain one subfolder per chip type , with the exact name of the .cdf file provided by affymetrix , ` huex-1_0-st - v2 ` " in our case . inside this folder we will save any library and annotation files that might be needed . besides , the ` mydataset ` " folder will be created under ` rawdata ` " to store .cel files . these files are the output of a microarray experiment and contain the result of the intensity calculations per probe or pixel . note that the microarray experiment produces one .cel file per array and that one array analyses one sample . affymetrix sometimes refer to their microarrays as chips " . note also that we need one ` mydataset ` " folder per experiment and that ` mydataset ` " will be added as a tag at the end of the ` aroma.affymetrix ` output . .... > # * * * user - defined working directory > wd < - " myworkingdirectory " > # * * * user - defined data set name > ds < - " mydataset " .... in the second step we save our library ( chip definition file ( .cdf ) in our case ) and .cel files in the corresponding folders . affymetrix s unsupported .cdf files can be downloaded from http://www.affymetrix.com/auth/support/downloads/library_files/huex-1_0-st-v2.cdf.zip , note that registration is needed . for the exon array , elizabeth purdom has created a number of binary .cdf files based on affymetrix s text .cdf file @xcite that are faster to query and more memory efficient . such binary .cdf files for core , extended and full sets of probesets can be downloaded from http://aroma-project.org/node/122 . in the example below we use the custom aroma file for core transcript clusters , which might be updated in the future . our original .cel files will be copied from the user - specified ` mycelfiledirectory ` " into the exon ` rawdata ` " subfolder ( the code is part of the .snw version of this paper ) . the desired output folder specified in ` output.folder ` " should exist in advance . .... > # * * download user - defined library file > library.file < - + paste(annotation.data.exon , + " huex-1_0-st - v2,corer3,a20071112,ep.cdf " , + sep = " / " ) > download.address < - + " http://bcgc.lbl.gov/cdffiles/ " > file < - paste("huex-1_0-st - v2,a20071112,ep " , + " huex-1_0-st - v2,corer3,a20071112,ep.cdf " , + sep = " / " ) > custom.cdf < - + paste(download.address , file , sep = " ") > download.file(url = custom.cdf , + destfile = library.file , + mode = " wb " , quiet = false ) > # * * * user - defined directory containing .cel files > cel.directory < - " mycelfiledirectory " > # * * * user - defined output folder > output.folder < - " output.folder " .... besides , the sample information should be saved in a tab separated file with column names ` celfile ` , ` replicate ` , and ` treatment ` containing .cel file name ( without .cel ) , replicate identifier and treatment name , respectively . this file should be called `` sampleinformation.txt '' and it will be copied from the user - specified directory into the ` \rawdata\mydataset \huex-1_0-st - v2 ` folder ( which will also contain the .cel files ) after it has been created . the sample information file for the colon cancer example is attached as an additional file . .... < - + read.table(file = paste(raw.data.exon , + " sampleinformation.txt " , sep = " / " ) , + sep = " \t " , header = true ) .... finally , netaffx transcript clusters and probesets annotation files should be saved in `` ` annotationdata / chiptypes/ ` '' `` ` huex-1_0-st - v2 ` '' . we have used release 32 , which was most up to date at the time of writing and we downloaded files `` huex-1_0-st - v2.na32.hg19.transcript.csv.zip '' and `` huex-1_0-st - v2.na32.hg19.probeset.csv.zip '' from http://www.affymetrix.com/estore/browse/products.jsp?productid=131452&categoryid=35676&productname=genechip-human-exon-st-array#1_3 , _ technical documentation _ tab , under _ netaffx annotation files_. the extracted .csv files should be converted into .rdata files for querying them faster in the future . note that the number of lines to skip might differ for future annotation files . .... transcript.clusters.netaffx.32 < - + read.csv(file = paste(annotation.data.exon , + " huex-1_0-st - v2.na32.hg19.transcript.csv " , + sep = " / " ) , skip=24 ) > probesets.netaffx.32 < - + read.csv(file = paste(annotation.data.exon , + " huex-1_0-st - v2.na32.hg19.probeset.csv " , + sep = " / " ) , skip=23 ) .... after defining chip type and dataset , background correction and quantile normalization are carried out as shown in figure [ fig : flowchart ] , step 3 . in these pre - processing steps , it is possible to use either affymetrix s original .cdf file , the .cdf files provided by the aroma project ( the file for core transcript clusters in our example ) , or a .cdf file created by the user . the summarization step , however , must be done using one of the custom .cdf files available at the ` aroma.affymetrix ` project website . background correction as defined by irizarry @xcite and quantile normalization are performed by the ` rmabackgroundcorrection ( ) ` and ` quantilenormalization ( ) ` functions , respectively . the raw , background corrected and quantile normalized probe intensities can be visualized using the ` plotdensity ( ) ` function applied to the corresponding object . summarization is done with the ` exonrmaplm ` function @xcite . the parameter ` mergegroups ` determines whether to summarize at transcript level ( ` true ` ) or probeset level ( ` false ` ) . all the functions described automatically create subfolders such as plmdata " or probedata " inside ` myworkingdirectory ` " . a more detailed version of this code with interesting comments about the choice of .cdf and possibilities for quality control is available at http://www.aroma-project.org/vignettes/firma-humanexonarrayanalysis . .... > chiptype < - " huex-1_0-st - v2 " > # * * user - defined .cdf file : change tags parameter > cdf < - affymetrixcdffile$bychiptype(chiptype , + tags = " corer3,a20071112,ep " ) > cs < - affymetrixcelset$byname(ds , cdf = cdf ) > > # background correction > bc < - rmabackgroundcorrection(cs ) > csbc < - process(bc , verbose = verbose ) > > # quantile normalization > qn < - quantilenormalization(csbc , + typestoupdate = " pm " ) > csn < - process(qn , verbose = verbose ) > > # summarization > # transcript cluster level > plmtr < - exonrmaplm(csn , mergegroups = true , + tag = " coreprobesetsgeneexpression " ) > # probeset / exon level > plmex < - exonrmaplm(csn , mergegroups = false , + tag = " coreprobesetsexonexpression " ) .... the ` aroma.affymetrix ` documentation focuses on analyses at the probeset and transcript cluster levels . the respective intensities are obtained by applying the function ` getchipeffectset ( ) ` to the transcript or probeset ` plm ` objects ( ` plmtr ` and ` plmex ` , respectively ) and then extracting the corresponding dataframes . however , it is also possible to extract the background corrected and quantile normalized intensities of all probes using the function ` getunitintensities ` . while ` plmtr ` is suitable for the firma analysis ( [ subsec : statistics ] ) , ` plmex ` is well suited for probeset - level analysis . for the linear model analysis described in section [ subsec : statistics ] we have created one list of dataframes containing probe intensities per transcript cluster , and another list of dataframes containing probeset intensities per cluster ( code included in .snw ) . .... > # extract a matrix of gene intensities > cestr < - getchipeffectset(plmtr ) > trfit < - extractdataframe(cestr , addnames = true ) > # extract a matrix of probeset intensities > cesex < - getchipeffectset(plmex ) > exfit < - extractdataframe(cesex , addnames = true ) > # extract a list of probe intensities per gene > unitintensities < - readunits(csn , verbose = verbose ) .... the high number of transcript clusters analysed in combination with the usually small number of chips tends to cause a high number of false positives @xcite . in order to reduce the number of false positives , affymetrix recommends to perform detection above background ( dabg ) @xcite on the dataset prior to the analysis @xcite . the dabg procedure is not implemented in ` aroma.affymetrix ` , so we decided to follow the procedure described in @xcite and use 3 as a threshold for the probeset intensity , so that probesets with a @xmath0 intensity below 3 will be marked as absent . except for this change , we followed the guidelines proposed in @xcite to remove absent transcript clusters and probesets , where neither probesets that are absent in more than half of the samples of a group nor transcript clusters with more than half of the probesets absent are analysed . besides this filtering based on expression levels , another filtering that removes probesets presenting cross - hybridization is also advisable @xcite . cross - hybridising probesets are identified in file `` huex-1_0-st - v2.na32.hg19.probeset.csv '' and removed . affymetrix recommends to filter them out after the analysis , but we have decided not to include them in the analysis in order to narrow down the number of probesets / transcript clusters to investigate . the filtering procedure is part of the .snw file . in our example , where we analysed only core probesets , 136233 probesets out of 284258 were deemed present by our filter , and the number of transcript clusters to analyse ( present in both samples ) was reduced from 18708 to 8401 . in this section we give an overview of model - based statistical methods available for the analysis of differential splicing and suggest a method for the analysis of differential gene expression . the analyses carried out in this paper are model - based approaches , and the analysis of differential splicing is done genewise . the models we use are extensions of the linear model by li and wong @xcite @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the intensity measure of probe @xmath3 for treatment @xmath4 , @xmath5 is a probe affinity term , @xmath6 is the gene - level estimate for treatment @xmath4 , and @xmath7 is the error term . * anosva * ( analysis of splicing variation ) was presented by cline _ _ @xcite and is a two - way anova model with probeset and treatment as factors : @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the intensity measure of probe @xmath3 in probeset @xmath10 and treatment @xmath4 , the overall mean @xmath11 is the baseline level of all probes in all experiments , and @xmath12 and @xmath6 are the probeset and treatment effects . the interaction term @xmath13 tells whether the effect of the probeset depends on the treatment and is therefore key to the detection of differential splicing . the model in can be extended to include random effects associated to replications from the same individual , @xmath14 : @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the random effect of each individual @xmath14 and @xmath17 is the random chip effect . the error terms @xmath18 are i.i.d . @xmath19-distributed . under the null - hypothesis of no differential splicing , the @xmath13 s will all be zero , therefore we consider the test statistic @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the estimate for @xmath13 , and @xmath22 is the standard error of @xmath21 . large values will be critical for the null hypothesis . under the model assumptions , @xmath4 will follow a @xmath23 distribution ( * ? ? ? 5 ) , with @xmath24 the total number of observations per transcript cluster , @xmath25 the number of treatments , @xmath26 the number of probesets in the transcript cluster and @xmath27 the number of individuals . for each gene , the smallest @xmath3-value from the above @xmath4-tests is regarded as a measure of confidence that the gene is differentially spliced across the experimental conditions @xcite . the interaction estimates and variances and thus the test statistics are contrast - dependent , so choosing a different contrast will alter the gene lists . in our analysis , we have used the ` sum ` contrast available in ` r ` , where parameter estimates are centred around zero . a package in ` r ` for fitting linear and generalized linear mixed - effects models is ` lme4 ` @xcite . linear mixed - effects models can also be analysed using ` lm ` , which is faster but requires a balanced design . in our example dataset we use ` lm ` to fit the model in equation ( [ eq : meanosva ] ) to the probe level estimates obtained using ` unitintensities ( ) ` from ` aroma.affymetrix ` to 8075 multiexonic transcript clusters . here , we only show the code corresponding to equation , the rest of the code is part of the .snw file . .... > # * * user - defined parameters for linear model > lm < - + lm(intensity ~ probeset + treatment + + c(probeset : treatment , contr.sum ) + + replicate / treatment ) > n.probesets < - length(unique(dataframe$probeset ) ) > main.effects < - + 1 + ( n.probesets - 1 ) + + ( length(unique(dataframe$treatment ) ) - 1 ) > ds.parameters < - ( n.probesets - 1 ) * + ( length(unique(dataframe$treatment ) ) - 1 ) > p.t < - + min(summary(lm)$coefficients[(main.effects+1 ) : + ( main.effects + ds.parameters),"pr(>|t| ) " ] ) .... although the vast majority of probesets contain 4 probes , transcript clusters containing probesets with less than 4 probes will give rise to an unbalanced design . nevertheless , the @xmath4-distribution is almost a normal distribution for long transcript clusters so the unbalanced design does not have any practical implications . for shorter transcript clusters , however , an unbalanced design might be a problem . the top 10 most differentially spliced genes , sorted by the minimum @xmath3-value of their @xmath4-tests , appear in table [ tab : anosvaprobe ] . zak _ was validated as differentially spliced in @xcite . see figure [ fig : anosvaprobe ] for the profile plot of _ klk10 _ , where the thick lines representing the mean intensity in each group have been plotted for easing the interpretation . note that there is one measurement per probe in each probeset , typically 4 probes per probeset . how to obtain such plots is described in section [ subsec : annotationandvisualization ] below . the genes in figures [ fig : anosvaprobe ] , [ fig : anosvaprobeset ] , [ fig : firma ] and [ fig : deprobe ] were chosen because they span over a shorter genomic region and show a more clear picture of the relationship between probesets and exons than the other genes in the lists of top 10 genes . a slight variation of anosva is the probeset - model as implemented in partek @xcite ( note that the probe subscript @xmath3 has been removed ) : @xmath28 for the probeset - level anosva we used the probeset level estimates obtained by ` affyplm ( ... , mergegroups = false ) ` . after filtering for non - present or cross - hybridising probesets , and absent transcript clusters , we were left with 9494 transcript clusters to study . these clusters are sorted according to the minimum @xmath3-value of the individual @xmath4-test scores for differential splicing , and the top 10 genes obtained appear in table [ tab : anosvaprobeset ] . the genes _ mmp11 , zak _ and _ comp _ are in the top 10 genes for both the anosva probe and the anosva probeset models . gene _ tgfbi _ appears in figure [ fig : anosvaprobeset ] . * firma * ( finding isoforms using robust multichip analysis ) was first introduced by purdom _ @xcite for the exon array . in presence of differential splicing the model in will not fit and this will show up in the residuals . the linear model used is the following : @xmath29 with @xmath5 the probe affinity , @xmath30 the gene - level effect for chip @xmath31 and the error terms @xmath18 are i.i.d . @xmath19-distributed . note that in contrast to the model in we do not compute an overall gene - level estimate , but a gene - level estimate per chip . as in model , there is no treatment / probeset interaction term , so differential splicing is analysed probesetwise , using the residuals per probeset @xmath10 : @xmath32 where @xmath33 and @xmath34 are the estimates of @xmath5 and @xmath30 . the median of the standardized residuals per probeset per chip is chosen as score statistic : @xmath35 the standardization with the median absolute deviation ( mad ) of the residuals per gene makes the scores comparable across transcript clusters . the firma scores are extracted from the ` plmtr ` object obtained in section [ subsec : pre - processing ] . all probesets and transcript clusters were analysed by firma , since it is part of the default ` aroma.affymetrix ` workflow . .... > firma < - firmamodel(plmtr ) > fit(firma , verbose = verbose ) > fs < - getfirmascores(firma ) > firma.scores < - extractdataframe(fs ) .... after obtaining the firma scores per probeset per sample , we proceeded as described in @xcite : 1 ) for each probeset we took the difference of firma scores for each of the 10 pairs of normal / cancer samples and 2 ) calculated the mean of the 10 differences per probeset . then 3 ) we ranked the probesets according to their absolute mean difference : as the scores are comparable across transcript clusters , larger average differences between the normal and cancer samples will point at exons more differentially spliced between the two conditions . the resulting list was filtered to keep only probesets and transcript clusters that has passed the filter described in [ subsec : extractingintensities ] above , the code is part of the .snw file . in order to get a gene list instead of a probeset list as in @xcite we mapped probesets to transcript clusters and then selected the top 10 genes on the list , see table [ tab : firma ] . the profile plot of gene _ lgals4 _ appears in figure [ fig : firma ] . the very high average difference for this gene is due to a firma score of 830030.8 at probeset _ 3861578 _ corresponding to the tumour sample of replicate 7 . out of 14 genes investigated for differential splicing in ( * table 1 ) , 10 passed our filtering procedure and were analysed for differential splicing : _ actn1 , vcl , cald1 , slc3a2 , col6a3 , cttn , fn1 , mast2 , zak _ and _ fxyd6_. the gene _ zak _ appears in the top 10 genes from anosva probe and anosva probeset , but a plot is not produced automatically by the code because _ zak _ is not recognised by biomart . instead , we looked the gene up in pubmed obtaining the ensembl i d : ensg00000091436 , and used this to plot the gene , see figure [ fig : zak ] . the gene _ col6a3 _ appears among the top 100 genes for the anosva probe and the anosva probeset methods . gene _ actn1 _ is among the top 100 genes for anosva probeset and it is also the first of gardina s genes to appear in the filtered firma list , at position 154 . + in this section we analyse differential gene expression using probe level data . we study two types of transcript clusters : 1 ) the ones not included in the anosva probe analysis above ( with only one probeset or not present in both normal and cancer groups ) and 2 ) the ones not showing differential splicing ( anosva probe @xmath3-value above 0.1 ) . the analysis of group 2 ) is based on the hierarchical principle : only look for significant main effects ( differential expression in this case ) among those transcript clusters with no significant interaction terms ( differential splicing ) @xcite . in total , we analysed 16231 transcript clusters . we fit the following linear model to those transcript clusters : @xmath36 where @xmath6 is the gene level treatment effect , @xmath12 is a parameter that captures probesets expressed above or below the overall transcript cluster level and @xmath16 and @xmath17 are random effects for patient and chip , respectively . .... > aov < - + aov(intensity ~ probeset + treatment + + error(replicate + replicate : treatment ) ) > p.f < - + summary(aov)$"error : within"[[1]]["treatment " , + " pr(>f ) " ] .... the null hypothesis is that the gene expression is the same in all groups . the top 10 genes , with adjusted @xmath3-values appear in table [ tab : de ] . the method used for adjusting the @xmath3-values was benjamini - hochberg s correction @xcite using the function ` p.adjust ( ... , method = bh ) ` . only 80 out of 159 genes appearing in gardina s list of genes up- and down - regulated in tumour ( * ? ? ? * additional file 1 ) passed our filters and were analysed for differential gene expression . among those analysed , the genes _ cldn1 , sst , musk , kiaa1199 _ and _ slc30a10 _ were in the top 100 . best4 _ is shown in figure [ fig : deprobe ] . this gene is down - regulated in tumour ( blue ) compared to normal ( red ) samples . the thicker lines represent the mean expression levels in the two groups . .top 10 differentially expressed genes from with corrected @xmath3-values . best4 _ , highlighted in gray , appears in figure [ fig : deprobe ] . [ tab : de ] [ cols="<,>",options="header " , ] we chose to annotate transcript clusters to genes using the netaffx transcript cluster annotation release 32 specified in section [ subsec : folderandfiles ] using the ` annotategenes ( ) ` function . some transcript clusters present unspecific annotation and have several possible associated gene names . we have decided to remove such clusters from our output as we can not map them uniquely to a gene and afterwards interpret the result according to the gene structure . after gene annotation , the user can select genes for visual inspection . visual inspection of candidates for differential splicing is recommended by affymetrix as a way to identify possible false positives @xcite . plots of gene profiles with integrated genomic information are obtained using the ` biomart ` @xcite and ` genomegraphs ` @xcite packages in bioconductor . we use ` biomart ` to connect to the latest version of the homo sapiens dataset in ensembl @xcite ( ensembl genes 68 , grch37.p8 at the time of writing ) and retrieve genes by their hgnc symbol @xcite . gene and exon structures are imported from ensembl . ` gene ` and ` exon ` objects are created by ` makegene ( ) ` and ` maketranscript ( ) ` from ` genomegraphs ` . we store expression data and probeset start and stop positions in an ` exonarray ` object by ` makeexonarray ( ) ` . the final plot is created passing a list with the objects created to the ` gdplot(list(exon , gene , transcript , ... ) ) ` function . our plots show on top the gene hgnc symbol followed by ( + ) for genes on the forward strand and by ( - ) for those on the reverse strand . below , the plot of probeset intensities appears with vertical lines delimiting probesets . note that for models based on probe - level data ( anosva probe , firma and differential expression ) , the intensities of all probes in the probeset ( 1 to 4 ) are shown . samples from the same treatment group appear in the same colour , red for normal samples and in blue for tumour samples in this case . immediately after the profile plot , the gene model retrieved from ensembl is shown in orange , followed by the possible transcript model(s ) in blue . the gene model consists of the exons that appear in all possible transcript models . exons ( boxes ) in the gene model are linked by blue lines to the probesets above , indicating which probeset(s ) interrogate which exon . see figures [ fig : anosvaprobe ] to [ fig : deprobe ] . the aim of this paper was to give a tutorial on how to perform a complete and reproducible analysis of exon array data in ` r`/bioconductor . we have worked with three packages : ` aroma.affymetrix ` , ` biomart ` and ` genomegraphs ` to go from .cel files to intensity data , statistical analysis , annotation and visualization . the packages were chosen for their flexibility and easy of integration . we believe that our workflow covers a number of analysis variants for the exon array , including differential splicing analysis at probe and probeset - level and differential expression analysis at probe level , and gives the user the opportunity to focus on all or only some of the aspects of the data analysis . we make our entire code available so that other researchers can use it as it is or adapt it to their needs . different bioconductor packages could have been used in some of the analysis steps . for example , ` xmapcore ` @xcite provides annotation data and cross - mappings between genetic features as transcript clusters or exons and affymetrix probesets . this package , however , requires the separate installation of a mysql database , which makes this a more complex alternative than the one we have chosen . the ` xps ` package @xcite could have been used for data pre - processing and summarization , but it requires the installation of the ` root ` framework @xcite , and a certain level of understanding of root files and root trees is recommended . our workflow does not require any prior knowledge beyond ` r`/bioconductor . other free software includes brb - array tools @xcite , based on ` r ` , c , fortran and java , with an excel front end , and dchip @xcite , which is written in visual c`++ ` and developed for windows - though some users have been able to run it on mac and unix computers . a previous paper on exon arrays @xcite suggests a pragmatic approach and does the analysis piecewise starting with affymetrix power tools ( apt ) and then exporting the data to ` r ` . we recognise this is a fix for the lack of straightforward packages for dealing with the exon array in bioconductor . however , it implies working with several pieces of software so we do not find it fit for reproducible research . licensed software , like partek @xcite or genespring gx @xcite , has been used in other studies @xcite . in contrast to licensed software , ` r`/bioconductor is free and available for anyone , it allows the user to control most analysis options and it enables customizable and reproducible analyses that are more easily reviewed . still , the ` aroma.affymetrix ` package does not provide the speed of affymetrix power tools or the licensed software , and it requires more user input . nevertheless , with this code and minimal user input , any dataset can be analysed regarding differential expression at probe level and differential splicing using the anosva model . differential gene expression could have been analysed using the gene level estimates obtained from the ` plmtr ` object in other ` r ` packages such as ` limma ` @xcite . another extension of the workflow could include a general analysis strategy of the firma scores , which in this study was tailor - made for a two - treatment scenario . besides , the profile plots we obtained with ` genomegraphs ` , though highly informative , are difficult to interpret for genes spanning over a long genomic region , as for example _ tgfbi _ in figure [ fig : anosvaprobeset ] and _ zak _ in figure [ fig : zak ] . in the future , it would be interesting to study the flexibility of the output imported from ensembl and , for example , remove the intronic regions from the gene and transcript models . the authors would like to thank henrik bengtsson for helpful answers and comments regarding ` aroma.affymetrix ` . the authors would also like to thank hang phan and anders ellern bilgrau for helpful discussions and ideas about code implementation and data plotting . mrd designed and implemented the workflow , analysed data and drafted the manuscript . rw assisted in paper drafting and statistical modelling and interpretation . jsb , sf and mkk tested the workflow . jsb , mkk , hej and kds assisted with data interpretation and participated in paper drafting . mb conceived and tested the workflow , assisted in manuscript drafting and coordinated the work . all authors read and approved the final manuscript . bengtsson h , simpson k , bullard j , et al . : a generic framework in r for analyzing small to very large affymetrix data sets in bounded memory . technical report 745 , department of statistics , university of california , berkeley , 2008 .

alternative splicing is the post - transcriptional process by which a single gene can produce multiple transcripts and thereby protein isoforms . the presence of different transcripts of a gene across samples can be analysed by whole - transcriptome microarrays . reproducing results from published microarray data represents a challenge due to the vast amounts of data and the large variety of pre - processing and filtering steps employed before the actual analysis is carried out . to ensure a firm basis for methodological development where results with new methods are compared with previous results it is crucial to ensure that all analyses are completely reproducible for other researchers . we here give a detailed workflow on how to perform reproducible analysis of the genechip human exon 1.0 st array at probe and probeset level solely in ` r`/bioconductor , choosing packages based on their simplicity of use . to exemplify the use of the proposed workflow we analyse differential splicing and differential gene expression in a publicly available dataset using various statistical methods . we believe this study will provide other researchers with an easy way of accessing gene expression data at different annotation levels and with the sufficient details needed for developing their own tools for reproducible analysis of the genechip human exon 1.0 st array . + * contact : * [email protected]

1403.2389

the so - called @xmath0-cdm cosmology @xcite , in which the universe is dominated by dark energy and cold dark matter ( cdm ) , accurately describes the large scale properties and evolution of the cosmos . on the scale of the halos of large galaxies , this model predicts copious cdm sub - structures , the most massive of which are identified with the dwarf satellite galaxies that are observed to inhabit such regions @xcite . numerical simulations that adopt this framework @xcite generally reveal that the sub - halos that could host visible dwarf galaxies are distributed roughly spherically about the large galaxy . observationally however , the distribution of dwarf galaxies within the local group appears to be more complicated . @xcite and @xcite first noted that several prominent dwarf galaxies are correlated with streams of emission , and suggested that the outer halo globular clusters of the milky way may represent ` ghostly ' indicators of ancient accretions @xcite . more recent analyses @xcite that include the faint dwarf galaxies detected during the past decade in the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) support the earlier results , although concerns remain about the spatial selection biasses given the sdss sky coverage . interestingly , the satellites appear to be rotationally stabilized , orbiting within the plane defined by their spatial alignment @xcite . it has been claimed that the proposed planes of satellites are not predicted within @xmath0-cdm , and can not simply represent a memory of past coherent accretion , although other studies dispute this conclusion @xcite . in a previous contribution we showed that our nearest large companion , the andromeda galaxy , possesses an immense , kinematically coherent , thin plane of dwarf galaxies , representing @xmath2 of the total dwarf population of andromeda ( @xcite ; see also @xcite ) , confirming previous studies @xcite that had hinted at potential spatial correlations of dwarfs in m31 . a scenario that has been proposed to explain these alignments is that the present - day satellites are the remnants of tidal dwarf galaxies formed in ancient major mergers @xcite . this explanation is problematic , however , as it requires that the dwarfs are not dark matter dominated . it is in this context that ( * ? ? ? * hereafter bb14 ) recently analyzed the millennium - ii simulation @xcite , to investigate the incidence of satellite alignments in that large @xmath3 volume of a @xmath0-cdm universe . they concluded that due to the spatial correlation between satellites in @xmath0-cdm , structures similar to that observed are relatively common , arising in approximately 2% of the halos they investigated . the aim of the present paper is to examine the validity of the bb14 analysis , and to extend our earlier analysis to make better use of the accurate kinematic information available for the real satellites . in section [ sec : sample_selection ] , we discuss how the samples were selected from the simulation . section [ sec : results ] presents the analysis and results , and conclusions are drawn in section [ sec : conclusions ] . we select sub - halos from the millennium - ii simulation , using the @xcite catalog which was scaled to the wmap year 7 analysis . the semi - analytic recipes that were applied to the dark matter simulation provide a wealth of predicted physical properties for galaxies that reside within the dark matter halos . since we are interested in selecting systems similar to m31 , we follow bb14 and pick all halos in the redshift @xmath4 snapshot that have virial masses between @xmath5 and @xmath6 , mass - weighted age @xmath7 , and whose neighbors within @xmath8 have a baryonic component less massive than @xmath9 . ( we define the baryonic mass to be the sum of the stellar and cold gas components ) . a total of 1141 such hosts are found . in addition to those bb14 selection criteria , we apply the following three criteria to select hosts that are reasonably similar to m31 . we require that the hosts have baryonic masses in the range @xmath10@xmath11 ( this leaves 1024 galaxies ) , and we require that the group that the host galaxy resides in should have mass @xmath12 , a 95% upper limit to the mass of the local group @xcite ( leaving 885 galaxies ) . to ensure that the m31 analog , as in reality , is the dominant galaxy within the survey region , we finally reject hosts that have a companion within @xmath8 that possesses @xmath13 of their baryonic mass . these cuts yield a sample of 679 host galaxies within the millennium - ii simulation . figure [ fig : observations]a shows the observed distribution of the 15 satellites of m31 that are confined to a narrow plane . it can be immediately appreciated that the plane lies almost perfectly edge - on from our viewing point . the side view is displayed in figure [ fig : observations]b , using the most likely value of the line of sight distances measured by @xcite . the arrows mark the measured line of sight velocity @xcite , with the red arrows showing those satellites that have the same sense of rotation . to reproduce the observational configuration , we place ourselves in the simulation at a random position @xmath14 distant from the host galaxy ( equivalent to the milky way - m31 distance , @xcite ) , with a random camera angle . we initially select all the sub - halos within the millennium - ii simulation that lie within @xmath8 of the chosen host and that have stellar mass @xmath15 ( as proposed by bb14 ) , to which we then apply the pandas spatial selection function . within the pandas area shown in figure [ fig : observations]a , 27 satellites are known ( beyond @xmath16 ) , of which 15 are narrowly aligned in the thin plane discussed by @xcite . to approximate this observed sample , we select in the simulation the brightest 27 satellites that are visible within the pandas field of view . if there are less than 27 satellites within this field of view , we discard the viewing position and draw a new one . using exactly the same procedure as was applied to the real data in @xcite , we calculate the pole of the plane that has the lowest perpendicular rms dispersion ( i.e. the thinnest plane ) for any sub - sample of 15 satellites . in a coordinate system where @xmath17 points east , @xmath18 points north and @xmath19 points along the line of sight vector to m31 ( i.e. as shown in figures [ fig : observations]b and [ fig : observations]d ) , the pole of the observed structure points towards @xmath20 . if the pole of the lowest rms plane , as seen from the randomly - chosen viewpoint , lies within @xmath21 of the pole of the real plane , we store this host and its sample of satellites ; otherwise a new viewing position is randomly drawn . if no sample is found after @xmath22 random draws of the viewing position , we discard the host . this procedure is repeated 12 times , so as to obtain ( in the best cases ) 12 different views of each of the 679 host galaxies . cases where a new viewing position of the same host coincided within @xmath23 to one previously calculated were discarded , as we considered such configurations to be `` repeats '' of the previous solutions ) of satellites , meaning that different sub - samples are selected from different viewing positions . while our procedure gives rise to identical satellite sub - samples in 1.2% of the random draws , the @xmath24 separation requirement still means that these provide different line of sight velocity projections ( used in figure [ fig : angular_momentum ] ) . in 76% of the draws more than @xmath25 of the satellites are different . hence the multiple views help build up better statistics . ] . in figures [ fig : observations]c and [ fig : observations]d we overplot all the sub - samples of 15 satellites found around the host galaxies in the way described above . the samples have been rotated so that the viewpoint lies at @xmath26 . by construction , the random samples have the same orientation as the data . our main motivation to force the alignments to be edge - on was to be able to compare the radial velocity information on the satellites directly to the simulations , but this also automatically corrects for the inclination - dependent detection bias in pandas @xcite , and it also avoids the issue that rotation of a structure aligned perpendicular to the line of sight would not have been detected . nevertheless , tests show that forcing this orientation does not substantially alter the results below . the semi - analytic modeling of @xcite differentiates normal galaxies from `` orphans '' ; the latter being systems whose parent subhalo is no longer resolved . it is possible that many of these orphans are tidally disrupted , and that they are hence not directly comparable to the observed dwarf galaxies . despite these concerns , we will first assume that the orphan satellites represent structures that can be reliably compared to real dwarf galaxies ( this is an assumption that bb14 considered ) . however , we noticed that in the millennium - ii simulation , many of the orphans are spatially clustered around massive sub - halos . we decided to reject all the orphan satellites that were next to a massive , non - orphan , satellite , closer than twice the radius of the stellar disk of the non - orphan satellite . this is justified on the grounds that in reality it is unlikely that such objects would have been identified ( they would be very hard to distinguish from their companion ) . additionally , we reject orphan satellites that are both closer than @xmath27 ( which corresponds approximately to the line of sight distance uncertainty for the best measured dwarf galaxies ) and that have space velocities @xmath28 from a non - orphan satellite , since observationally we would consider such objects to be tidal debris . this is the sample that was displayed previously in figures [ fig : observations]c and [ fig : observations]d . one notices immediately from a visual comparison of panels ( b ) and ( d ) that the sample of simulated satellites that includes orphans is significantly more centrally - concentrated than the real satellites , so clearly the extent of the plane is an important property to attempt to reproduce , in addition to its thinness . bb14 decided to parametrize the radial extent via the rms dispersion within the plane ( `` rms parallel '' ) , which we calculate as the sum of the squares of the distances in the plane _ from the host galaxy_. in figure [ fig : parameters]a we show this parameter plotted against the plane thickness ( `` rms perpendicular '' ) . let us define `` condition 1 '' to be the requirement that the simulated systems should be thinner than the observed structure ( @xmath29 ) , `` condition 2 '' that they should be spatially more extended than the observations ( @xmath30 ) , and `` condition 3 '' that 13 or more out of the subsamples of 15 satellites share the same sense of rotation . we find that 2% of the systems @xmath31 conform to conditions 1 and 2 ( crosses in panel ( a ) ) , but only 3 out of 7757 simulated systems ( 0.04% ) conform to conditions 1,2 and 3 ( crosses in panel ( c ) ) . if instead we discard all the orphan satellites , we obtain the parameter distributions displayed in panels ( b ) and ( d ) of figure [ fig : parameters ] . in this case not a single system within the millennium - ii simulation out of a sample of 4974 is more extreme than the m31 satellite structure ( upper limit of @xmath32% ) . note that we have been very conservative in the selection , and have not counted any system in which we could not find 27 satellites of which 15 are in an edge - on configuration ( which is why the number of systems in the right panels of figure [ fig : parameters ] is lower than in the left panels ) . an interesting and useful additional view of the parameter space of the properties of the satellite structure is given in figure [ fig : angular_momentum ] . since we deliberately enforced the simulated alignments to be seen with the same orientation as the observations , we can directly compare the line of sight velocities of the satellites with the real measurements . in reality we do not have access to the proper motions of the satellites , neither do we have reliable total mass estimates , so we can not measure their total angular momentum . however , it is possible to calculate the minimum specific angular momentum , @xmath33 , simply by using the line of sight velocities and taking the unknown transverse motions to be zero . exactly the same statistic can be calculated for the simulated satellite galaxies , so the comparison should be very robust . in many of the simulated systems , there are a few satellites with extreme values of @xmath33 . to avoid being dominated by such outliers , we chose to adopt ( the absolute value of ) the median of @xmath33 as our statistic . this parameter is displayed along with the rms thickness in figure [ fig : angular_momentum ] , for which we define a further `` condition 4 '' : that the simulated systems should have median @xmath34 , the value of the @xmath33 in the real data , which implies that bulk motion is not likely to be important for the present discussion . ] . the bottom panels show the result of applying conditions 1 to 4 to the simulated systems . if we discount orphan satellites , there are no structures in the millennium - ii simulations that compare to what is seen in m31 , but if we allow orphans , 2 out of 7757 systems ( 0.03% ) are more extreme in their thinness , radial extent and kinematic properties than the real structure around andromeda . it is interesting to inspect these two cases closely . both systems contain very massive satellites , with virial masses of @xmath35 and @xmath36 , representing mass fractions of 1@xmath375 and 1@xmath373 , and with baryonic masses of @xmath38 and @xmath39 ( baryonic mass fractions of 1@xmath377 and 1@xmath374 ) , respectively . furthermore , each of these halos has an accompanying compact entourage of orphan companions ( unlike the spread - out real system ) , as can be seen in figure [ fig : observations]d , where we plot the positions and velocities of one of these systems . finally , in both cases , the massive companion is approaching the host for the first time . this suggests the possibility that the observed structure in m31 is due to the accretion of such a system , and indeed the baryonic masses listed above seem to be in reasonable agreement with that of m33 , which has a stellar mass of @xmath40@xmath41 and a total gas mass of @xmath42 @xcite . it should nevertheless be kept in mind that these accretions of a massive satellite galaxy with a tight sub - system of their own are _ extremely rare _ events in the millennium - ii simulations . note also that in reality m33 does not partake in the observed planar alignment . what is the origin of the discrepancy between the conclusions of our work and bb14 ? the limitation with their study is that when they examine the kinematics of the alignments , they only use one of the structural parameters ( @xmath43 ) , not both ( @xmath43 and @xmath44 ) . once this error is corrected , our results and theirs are surprisingly consistent ( i.e. , our more conservative selection of hosts and the proper pandas spatial selection function applied to the satellites do not substantially affect the result ) : both studies measure a @xmath45% occurrence rate% joint probability only if conditions 2 and 3 are independent . ] . we have carefully reanalyzed the large - scale `` millennium - ii '' @xmath0-cdm simulation , searching for alignments of satellites similar to that observed around the andromeda galaxy . we consider m31-like host galaxies in a range of a full decade in stellar mass around the m31 value and require that they reside in parent dark matter halos that are no more massive than plausible values for the local group . by applying the pandas spatial selection function we derive views of planes of 15 satellites that are comparable to the observed configuration . we analyzed the perpendicular thinness , radial extent , coherent kinematics and angular momentum properties of the simulated samples together , and found cases similar to the observed planar structure to be extremely rare , occurring in only 0.030.04% of the samples . this shows that the observed alignment discovered by @xcite is surprising in @xmath0-cdm , if one assumes that the millennium - ii simulation has sufficient resolution to reliably detect counterparts of the observed satellites . nevertheless , the extreme rarity of analogs to the m31 system in the millennium - ii simulation does not necessarily preclude the possibility that planar structures may exist around different types of hosts in @xmath0-cdm simulations . by relaxing our search criteria that are specific to m31 , such as the adopted virial and baryonic mass constraints , and the requirement that there be no nearby large neighbor , the number of candidate systems increases from 679 to over 2000 for virial masses in the range @xmath46@xmath47 . while a thorough analysis of such simulated satellite systems is beyond the scope of the present paper , we believe that it will be of great importance to ascertain the incidence of satellite alignments in nature for galaxies beyond the local group .

in a recent contribution , @xcite investigated the incidence of planar alignments of satellite galaxies in the millennium - ii simulation , and concluded that vast thin planes of dwarf galaxies , similar to that observed in the andromeda galaxy ( m31 ) , occur frequently by chance in @xmath0-cold dark matter cosmology . however , their analysis did not capture the essential fact that the observed alignment is simultaneously radially extended , yet thin , and kinematically unusual . with the caveat that the millennium - ii simulation may not have sufficient mass resolution to identify confidently simulacra of low - luminosity dwarf galaxies , we re - examine that simulation for planar structures , using the same method as employed by ibata et al . ( 2013 ) on the real m31 satellites . we find that 0.04% of host galaxies display satellite alignments that are at least as extreme as the observations , when we consider their extent , thickness and number of members rotating in the same sense . we further investigate the angular momentum properties of the co - planar satellites , and find that the median of the specific angular momentum derived from the line of sight velocities in the real m31 structure ( @xmath1 ) is very high compared to systems drawn from the simulations . this analysis confirms that it is highly unlikely that the observed structure around the andromeda galaxy is due to a chance occurrence . interestingly , the few extreme systems that are similar to m31 arise from the accretion of a massive sub - halo with its own spatially - concentrated entourage of orphan satellites .

0707.3479

the field of _ computational learning theory _ deals with the abilities and limitations of algorithms that learn functions from data . many models of how learning algorithms access data have been considered in the literature . among these , two of the most prominent are via _ membership queries _ and via _ random examples_. membership queries are `` black - box '' queries ; in a membership query , a learning algorithm submits an input @xmath9 to an oracle and receives the value of @xmath10 . in models of learning from random examples , each time the learning algorithm queries the oracle it receives a labeled example @xmath11 where @xmath9 is independently drawn from some fixed probability distribution over the space of all possible examples . ( we give precise definitions of these , and all the learning models we consider , in section [ sec : jprelim ] . ) in recent years a number of researchers have considered quantum variants of well - studied models in computational learning theory , see e.g. @xcite . as we describe in section [ sec : jprelim ] , models of learning from quantum membership queries and from fixed quantum superpositions of labeled examples ( we refer to these as _ quantum examples _ ) have been considered ; such oracles have been studied in the context of _ quantum property testing _ as well @xcite . one common theme in the existing literature on quantum computational learning and testing is that these works study algorithms whose only access to the function is via some form of quantum oracle such as the quantum membership oracle or quantum example oracles mentioned above . for instance , @xcite modifies the classical harmonic sieve algorithm of @xcite so that it uses only uniform quantum examples to learn @xmath12 formulas . @xcite considers the problem of quantum property testing using quantum membership queries to give an exponential separation between classical and quantum testers for certain concept classes . @xcite studies the information - theoretic requirements of exact learning using quantum membership queries and probably approximately correct ( pac ) learning using quantum examples . many other articles such as @xcite could further extend this list . as the problem of building large scale quantum computers remains a major challenge , it is natural to question the technical feasibility of large scale implementation of the quantum oracles considered in the literature . it is desirable to minimize the number of quantum ( as opposed to classical ) oracle queries or examples required by quantum algorithms . thus motivated , in this paper we are interested in designing testing and learning algorithms with access to both quantum and classical sources of information ( with the goal of minimizing the quantum resources required ) . all of our positive results are based on a quantum subroutine due to @xcite , which we will refer to as an @xmath2 ( fourier sample ) oracle call . as explained in section [ sec : jprelim ] , a call to the @xmath2 oracle yields a subset of @xmath13 ( this set should be viewed as a subset of the input variables @xmath14 of @xmath3 ) drawn according to the fourier spectrum of the boolean function @xmath3 . as demonstrated by @xcite , such an oracle can be implemented using @xmath15 uniform quantum examples from a uniform distribution quantum example oracle . in fact , all of our algorithms will be purely classical apart from their use of the @xmath2 oracle . thus , all of our algorithms can be implemented within the ( uniform distribution ) quantum pac model first proposed by @xcite . this model is a natural quantum extension of the classical pac model introduced by valiant @xcite , as described in section [ sec : jprelim ] . we emphasize that no membership queries , classical or quantum , are used in our algorithms , only uniform quantum superpositions of labeled examples , and we recall that such uniform quantum examples can not efficiently simulate even classical membership queries in general ( see @xcite ) . our approach of focusing only on the @xmath2 oracle allows us to abstract away from the intricacies of quantum computation , and renders our results useful in any setting in which an @xmath2 oracle can be provided to the user . in fact , learning and testing with @xmath2 oracle queries may be regarded as a new distinct model ( which may possibly be weaker than the uniform distribution quantum example model ) . we are primarily interested in the information theoretic requirements ( i.e. the number of oracle calls needed ) of the learning and testing problems that we discuss . we give upper and lower bounds for a range of learning and testing problems related to _ @xmath0-juntas _ ; these are boolean functions @xmath16 that depend only on ( an unknown subset of ) at most @xmath0 of the @xmath1 input variables @xmath14 . juntas have been the subject of intensive research in learning theory and property testing in recent years , see e.g. @xcite . our first result , in section [ sec : testjuntas ] , is a @xmath0-junta testing algorithm which uses @xmath17 @xmath2 oracle calls . our algorithm uses fewer queries than the best known classical junta testing algorithm due to fischer _ @xcite , which uses @xmath18 membership queries . however , since the best lower bound known for classical membership query based junta testing ( due to chockler and gutfreund @xcite ) is @xmath19 , our result does not rule out the possibility that there might exist a classical membership query algorithm with the same query complexity . to complement our @xmath2 based testing algorithm , we establish a new lower bound : any @xmath0-junta testing algorithm that uses only a @xmath2 oracle requires @xmath6 calls to the @xmath2 oracle this shows that our testing algorithm is not too far from optimal . finally , we consider algorithms that can both make @xmath2 queries and also access classical random examples . in section [ sec : learnjuntas ] we give an algorithm for learning @xmath0-juntas over @xmath20 that uses @xmath7 @xmath2 queries and @xmath21 random examples . since any classical learning algorithm requires @xmath22 examples ( even if it is allowed to use membership queries ) , this result illustrates that it is possible to reduce the classical query complexity substantially ( in particular , to eliminate the dependence on @xmath1 ) if the learning algorithm is also permitted to have some very limited quantum information . moreover most of the consumption of our algorithm is from classical random examples which are considered quite `` cheap '' relative to quantum examples . from another perspective , our result shows that for learning @xmath0-juntas , almost all the quantum examples used by the algorithm of bshouty and jackson @xcite can in fact be converted into ordinary classical random examples . we show that our algorithm is close to best possible by giving a nearly matching lower bound . in section [ sec : jprelim ] we describe the models and problems we will consider and present some useful preliminaries from fourier analysis and probability . section [ sec : testjuntas ] gives our results on testing juntas and section [ sec : learnjuntas ] gives our results on learning juntas . in keeping with standard terminology in learning theory , a _ concept _ @xmath3 over @xmath23 is a boolean function @xmath24 , where @xmath25 stands for true and @xmath26 stands for false . concept class _ @xmath27 is a set of concepts where @xmath28 consists of those concepts in @xmath29 whose domain is @xmath30 for ease of notation throughout the paper we will omit the subscript in @xmath28 and simply write @xmath31 to denote a collection of concepts over @xmath20 . the concept class we will chiefly be interested in is the class of _ @xmath0-juntas_. a boolean function @xmath32 is a @xmath0-junta if @xmath3 depends only on @xmath0 out of its @xmath1 input variables . we are interested in the following computational problems : pac learning under the uniform distribution : : : given any _ target concept _ @xmath33 , an _ @xmath34-learning algorithm for concept class @xmath31 _ under the uniform distribution outputs a _ hypothesis _ function @xmath35 which , with probability at least @xmath36 , agrees with @xmath37 on at least a @xmath38 fraction of the inputs in @xmath30 this is a widely studied framework in the learning theory literature both in classical ( see for instance @xcite ) and in quantum ( see @xcite ) versions . property testing : : : let @xmath3 be any boolean function @xmath39 . a _ property testing algorithm for concept class @xmath31 _ is an algorithm which , given access to @xmath3 , behaves as follows : + * if @xmath33 then the algorithm outputs accept with probability at least @xmath36 ; * if @xmath3 is _ @xmath34-far _ from any concept in @xmath31 ( i.e. for every concept @xmath40 , @xmath3 and @xmath41 differ on at least an @xmath34 fraction of all inputs ) , then the algorithm outputs reject with probability at least @xmath36 . + the notion of property testing was first developed by @xcite and @xcite . quantum property testing was first studied by buhrman _ et al . _ @xcite , who first gave an example of an exponential separation between the query complexity of classical and quantum testers for a particular concept class . note that a learning or testing algorithm for @xmath31 `` knows '' the class @xmath31 but does not know the identity of the concept @xmath3 . while our primary concern is the number of oracle calls that our algorithms use , we are also interested in _ time efficient _ algorithms for testing and learning ; for the concept class of @xmath0-juntas , these are algorithms running in poly@xmath42 time steps . in order for learning and testing algorithms to gather information about the unknown concept @xmath3 , they need an information source called an _ oracle_. the number of times an oracle is queried by an algorithm is referred to as the _ query complexity_. sometimes our algorithms will be allowed access to more than one type of oracle in our discussion . in this paper we will consider the following types of oracles that provide classical information : membership oracle @xmath43 : : : for @xmath3 a boolean function , a _ membership oracle _ @xmath44 is an oracle which , when queried with input @xmath9 , outputs the label @xmath10 assigned by @xmath3 to @xmath45 uniform random example oracle @xmath46 : : : a query @xmath47 of the random example oracle returns an ordered pair @xmath48 where @xmath9 is drawn uniformly random from the set @xmath49 of all possible inputs . clearly a single call to an @xmath43 oracle can simulate the random example oracle @xmath46 . indeed @xmath46 oracle queries are considered `` cheap '' compared to membership queries . for example , in many settings it is possible to obtain random labeled examples but impossible to obtained the label of a particular desired example ( consider prediction problems dealing with phenomena such as weather or financial markets ) . we note that the set of concept classes that are known to be efficiently pac learnable from uniform random examples only is rather limited , see e.g. @xcite . in contrast , there are known efficient algorithms that use membership queries to learning important function classes such as @xmath12 ( disjunctive normal form ) formulas @xcite . we will consider the following quantum oracles , which are the natural quantum generalizations of membership queries and uniform random examples respectively . quantum membership oracle @xmath50 : : : the quantum membership oracle @xmath51 is the quantum oracle whose query acts on the computational basis states as follows : @xmath52 uniform quantum examples @xmath53 : : : the uniform quantum example oracle @xmath54 is the quantum oracle whose query acts on the computational basis state @xmath55 as follows : @xmath56 the action of a @xmath54 query is undefined on other basis states , and an algorithm may only invoke the @xmath54 query on the basis state @xmath57 . it is clear that a @xmath50 oracle can simulate a @xmath53 oracle or an @xmath43 oracle , and a @xmath53 oracle can simulate an @xmath46 oracle . the model of pac learning with a uniform quantum example oracle was introduced by bshouty and jackson in @xcite . several researchers have also studied learning from a more powerful @xmath51 oracle , see e.g. @xcite . turning to property testing , we are not aware of prior work on quantum testing using only the @xmath54 oracle ; instead researchers have considered quantum testing algorithms that use the more powerful @xmath51 oracle , see e.g. @xcite . we will make use of the fourier expansion of real valued functions over @xmath23 . we write @xmath58 $ ] to denote the set of variables @xmath59 . consider the set of real valued functions over @xmath23 endowed with the inner product @xmath60 = { \frac 1 { 2^n } } \sum_x f(x ) g(x)\ ] ] and induced norm @xmath61 . for each @xmath62 $ ] , let @xmath63 be the parity function @xmath64 it is a well known fact that the @xmath65 functions @xmath66\}$ ] form an orthonormal basis for the vector space of real valued functions over @xmath23 with the above inner product . consequently , every @xmath67 can be expressed uniquely as : @xmath68 } { \hat{f}(s)}\chi_s(x)\ ] ] which we refer to as the _ fourier expansion _ or _ fourier transform _ of @xmath3 . alternatively , the values @xmath69 \ } $ ] are called the _ fourier coefficients _ or the _ fourier spectrum _ of @xmath3 . _ parseval s identity _ , which is an easy consequence of orthonormality of the basis functions , relates the values of the coefficients to the values of the function : [ bparseval ] for any @xmath67 , we have @xmath70 } |{\hat{f}(s)}|^2= { { \bf e}}[f^2]$ ] . thus for a boolean valued function @xmath70 } |{\hat{f}(s)}|^2=1 $ ] . we will use the following simple and well - known fact : [ kmfact ] for any @xmath32 and any @xmath71 , we have @xmath72\leq{{\bf e}}_{x}[{(f(x)-g(x))}^{2}]=\sum_{s\subseteq[n]}|{\hat{f}(s)}-\hat{g}(s)|^{2}\ ] ] recall that the _ influence _ of a variable @xmath73 on a boolean function @xmath3 is the probability ( taken over a uniform random input @xmath9 for @xmath3 ) that @xmath3 changes its value when the @xmath74-th bit of @xmath9 is flipped , i.e. @xmath75.\ ] ] it is well known ( see e.g. @xcite ) that @xmath76 [ dpi]let @xmath77 be two random variables over the same domain . for any ( possibly randomized ) algorithm @xmath78 , one has that @xmath79 let @xmath80 be random variables corresponding to sequences of draws taken from two different distributions over the same domain . by the above inequality , if @xmath81 is known to be small , then the probability of success must be small for any algorithm designed to distinguish if the draws are made according to @xmath82 or @xmath83 . we will also use standard chernoff bounds on tails of sums of independent random variables : let @xmath84 be i.i.d . random variables with mean @xmath85 taking values in the range @xmath86 $ ] . then for all @xmath87 we have @xmath88\leq 2 \exp(\frac{-2\lambda^2 m}{(b - a)^2})$ ] . let @xmath89 be a boolean function . the _ fourier sampling oracle _ @xmath90 is the classical oracle which , at each invocation , returns each subset of variables @xmath91 with probability @xmath92 , where @xmath93 denotes the fourier coefficient corresponding to @xmath94 as defined in section [ sec : bfour ] . this oracle will play an important role in our algorithms . note that by parseval s identity we have @xmath95 } @xmath96 indeed has total weight 1 . in @xcite bshouty and jackson describe a simple constant - size quantum network ` qsamp ` , which has its roots in an idea from @xcite . ` qsamp ` allows sampling from the fourier spectrum of a boolean function using @xmath15 @xmath53 oracle queries : [ bjfact ] for any boolean function @xmath3 , it is possible to simulate a draw from the @xmath90 oracle with probability @xmath97 using @xmath98 queries to @xmath54 . all the algorithms we describe are actually classical algorithms that make @xmath2 queries . fischer _ et al . _ @xcite studied the problem of testing juntas given black - box access ( i.e. , classical membership query access ) to the unknown function @xmath3 using harmonic analysis and probabilistic methods . they gave several different algorithms with query complexity independent of @xmath1 , the most efficient of which yields the following : [ s1thm1]there is an algorithm that tests whether an unknown @xmath89 is a @xmath0-junta using @xmath18 membership queries . fischer _ et al . _ also gave a lower bound on the number of queries required for testing juntas , which was subsequently improved by chockler _ _ to the following : [ s1thm2 ] any algorithm that tests whether @xmath3 is a @xmath0-junta or is @xmath99-far from every @xmath0-junta must use @xmath19 membership queries . we emphasize that that both of these results concern algorithms with classical membership query access . in this section we describe a new testing algorithm that uses the @xmath2 oracle and prove the following theorem about its performance : [ s1qthm1]there is an algorithm that tests the property of being a @xmath0-junta using @xmath5 calls to the @xmath2 oracle . as described in section [ sec : jprelim ] , the algorithm can thus be implemented using @xmath100 uniform quantum examples from @xmath54 . consider the following algorithm @xmath101 which has @xmath2 oracle access to an unknown function @xmath32 . algorithm @xmath101 first makes @xmath102 calls to the @xmath2 oracle ; let @xmath103 denote the union of all the sets of variables received as responses to these oracle calls . algorithm @xmath101 then outputs `` accept '' if @xmath104 and outputs `` reject '' if @xmath105 . it is clear that if @xmath3 is a @xmath0-junta then @xmath101 outputs `` accept '' with probability 1 . to prove correctness of the test it suffices to show that if @xmath3 is @xmath4-far from any @xmath0-junta then @xmath106 outputs `` reject''@xmath107 \geq { \frac 2 3}.$ ] the argument is similar to the standard analysis of the coupon collector s problem let us view the set @xmath103 as growing incrementally step by step as successive calls to the @xmath2 oracle are performed . let @xmath108 be a random variable which denotes the number of @xmath2 queries that take place starting immediately after the @xmath109-st new variable is added to @xmath103 , up through the draw when the @xmath74-th new variable is added to @xmath103 . if the @xmath109-st and @xmath74-th new variables are obtained in the same draw then @xmath110 . ( for example , if the first three queries to the @xmath2 oracle are @xmath111 @xmath112 , @xmath113 , then we would have @xmath114 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 , @xmath118 . ) since @xmath3 is @xmath4-far from any @xmath0-junta , we know that for any set @xmath119 of @xmath120 variables , it must be the case that @xmath121 ( since otherwise if we set @xmath122 and use fact [ kmfact ] , we would have @xmath123\leq{{\bf e}}_{x}[{(f(x)-g(x))}^{2 } ] = \sum_{s \not\subseteq \mathcal{t } } \hat{f}(s)^2 < \epsilon\ ] ] which contradicts the fact that @xmath3 is @xmath4-far from any @xmath0-junta ) . it follows that for each @xmath124 , if at the current stage of the construction of @xmath103 we have @xmath125 , then the probability that the next @xmath2 query yields a new variable outside of @xmath103 is at least @xmath4 . consequently we have @xmath126 \leq { \frac 1 { \epsilon}}$ ] for each @xmath127 , and hence @xmath128 \leq { \frac { ( k+1 ) } { \epsilon}}.\ ] ] by markov s inequality , the probability that @xmath129 is at least @xmath130 , and therefore with probability at least @xmath130 it will be the case after @xmath102 draws that @xmath105 and the algorithm will consequently output `` reject . '' note that the @xmath100 uniform quantum examples required for algorithm @xmath101 improves on the @xmath131 query complexity of the best known classical algorithm . however our result does not conclusively show that @xmath53 queries are more powerful than classical membership queries for this problem since it is conceivable that there could exist an as yet undiscovered @xmath100 classical membership query algorithm . as a first attempt to obtain a lower bound on the number of @xmath2 oracle calls required to test @xmath0-juntas , it is natural to consider the approach of chockler _ et al . _ from @xcite . to prove theorem [ s1thm2 ] , chockler _ et al . _ show that any classical algorithm which can successfully distinguish between the following two probability distributions over black - box functions must use @xmath19 queries : * * scenario i : * the distribution @xmath132 is uniform over the set of all boolean functions over @xmath1 variables which do not depend on variables @xmath133 * * scenario ii : * the distribution @xmath134 is defined as follows : to draw a function @xmath3 from this distribution , first an index @xmath74 is chosen uniformly from @xmath135 , and then @xmath3 is chosen uniformly from among those functions that do not depend on variables @xmath136 or on variable @xmath74 . the following observation shows that this approach will not yield a strong lower bound for algorithms that have access to a @xmath2 oracle : with @xmath137 queries to a @xmath2 oracle , it is possible to determine w.h.p . whether a function @xmath3 is drawn from scenario i or scenario ii . it is easy to see that a function drawn from scenario i is simply a random function on the first @xmath138 variables . the fourier spectrum of random boolean functions is studied in @xcite , where it is shown that sums of squares of fourier coefficients of random boolean functions are tightly concentrated around their expected value . in particular , proposition 6 of @xcite directly implies that for any fixed variable @xmath139 we have : @xmath140 < \exp(-2^{k+1}/2592).\ ] ] thus with overwhelmingly high probability , if @xmath3 is drawn from scenario i then each @xmath2 query will `` expose '' variable @xmath74 with probability at least @xmath99 . it follows that after @xmath137 queries all @xmath138 variables will have been exposed ; so by making @xmath137 @xmath2 queries and simply checking whether or not @xmath138 variables have been exposed , one can determine w.h.p . whether @xmath3 is drawn from scenario i or scenario ii . thus we must adopt a more sophisticated approach to prove a strong lower bound on @xmath2 oracle algorithms . our main result in this section is the following theorem : [ s1qthm2 ] any algorithm that has @xmath2 oracle access to an unknown @xmath3 must use @xmath6 oracle calls to test whether @xmath3 is a @xmath0-junta . let @xmath0 be such that @xmath141 for some positive integer @xmath142 we let @xmath143 denote @xmath144 the _ addressing function _ on @xmath145 variables has @xmath146 `` addressing variables , '' which we shall denote @xmath147 and @xmath148 `` addressee variables '' which we denote @xmath149 the output of the function is the value of variable @xmath150 where the `` address '' @xmath151 is the element of @xmath152 whose binary representation is given by @xmath153 . figure 1 depicts a decision tree that computes the addressing function in the case @xmath154 . formally , the addressing function @xmath155 is defined as follows : @xmath156 [ fig : tree ] [ @xmath157[@xmath158 [ @xmath159 [ @xmath160 [ @xmath161 ] [ @xmath159 [ @xmath162 [ @xmath163 ] ] [ @xmath158 [ @xmath159 [ @xmath164 [ @xmath165 ] [ @xmath159 [ @xmath166 ] [ @xmath167 ] ] ] intuitively , the addressing function will be useful for us because as we will see the fourier spectrum is `` spread out '' over the @xmath143 addressee variables ; this will make it difficult to distinguish the addressing function ( which is not a @xmath0-junta since @xmath168 and as we shall see is in fact far from every @xmath0-junta ) from a variant which is a @xmath0-junta . let @xmath169 be the @xmath1 variables that our boolean functions are defined over . we now define two distributions @xmath170 , @xmath171 over functions on these variables . the distribution @xmath170 is defined as follows : to make a draw from @xmath170 , 1 . first uniformly choose a subset @xmath172 of @xmath143 variables from @xmath173 ; 2 . next , replace the variables @xmath174 in the function @xmath175 with the variables in @xmath172 ( choosing the variables from @xmath172 in a uniformly random order ) . return the resulting function . note that step ( 2 ) in the description of making a draw from @xmath170 above corresponds to placing the variables in @xmath172 uniformly at the leaves of the decision tree for @xmath176 ( see figure 1 ) . equivalently , if we write @xmath177 to denote the following function _ over @xmath1 variables _ @xmath178 a draw from @xmath170 is a function chosen uniformly at random from the set @xmath179 where @xmath180 ranges over all permutations of @xmath181 it is clear that every function in @xmath182 ( the support of @xmath170 ) depends on @xmath145 variables and thus is not a @xmath0-junta . in fact , every function in @xmath182 is far from being a @xmath0-junta : every @xmath3 that has nonzero probability under @xmath170 is @xmath183-far from any @xmath0-junta . fix any such @xmath3 and let @xmath41 be any @xmath0-junta . it is clear that at least @xmath184 of the `` addressee '' variables of @xmath3 are not relevant variables for @xmath41 . for a @xmath185 fraction of all inputs to @xmath3 , the value of @xmath3 is determined by one of these addressee variables ; on such inputs the error rate of @xmath41 relative to @xmath3 will be precisely @xmath186 fix any function @xmath177 in @xmath182 . we now give an expression for the fourier representation of @xmath177 . the expression is obtained by viewing @xmath177 as a sum of @xmath143 subfunctions , one for each leaf of the decision tree , where each subfunction takes the appropriate nonzero value on inputs which reach the corresponding leaf and takes value 0 on all other inputs : @xmath187 @xmath188 note that whenever @xmath189 , the sum on the rhs of equation has precisely one non - zero term which is @xmath190 . this is because the rest of the terms are annihilated since in each of these terms there is some index @xmath191 such that @xmath192 which makes @xmath193 . consequently this sum gives rise to exactly the addressing function in equation which is defined as @xmath194 and consequently the equality in equation follows . equation follows easily from rearranging . now we turn to @xmath195 the distribution @xmath171 is defined as follows : to make a draw from @xmath171 , 1 . first uniformly choose a subset @xmath172 of @xmath196 variables from @xmath173 ; 2 . next , replace the variables @xmath197 in the function @xmath175 with the variables in @xmath172 ( choosing the variables from @xmath172 in a uniformly random order ) . 3 . finally , for each @xmath198 do the following : if variable @xmath199 was used to replace variable @xmath200 in the previous step , let @xmath201 be a fresh uniform random @xmath202 value and replace variable @xmath203 with @xmath204 . return the resulting function . observe that for any integer @xmath205 with binary expansion @xmath206 , we have that the binary expansion of @xmath207 is @xmath208 . thus steps ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) in the description of making a draw from @xmath171 may be restated as follows in terms of the decision tree representation for @xmath176 : * place the variables @xmath209 randomly among the leaves of the decision tree with index less than @xmath196 . * for each variable @xmath209 placed at the leaf with index @xmath210 above , throw a @xmath202 valued coin @xmath201 and place @xmath211 at the antipodal leaf location with index : @xmath212 . equivalently , if we write @xmath213 to denote the following function _ over @xmath1 variables _ @xmath214 a draw from @xmath171 is a function chosen uniformly at random from the set @xmath215 where @xmath180 ranges over all permutations of @xmath216 and @xmath217 ranges over all of @xmath218 . it is clear that every function in @xmath219 depends on at most @xmath220 variables , and thus is indeed a @xmath0-junta . by considering the contribution to the fourier spectrum from each pair of leaves @xmath221 of the decision tree , we obtain the following expression for the fourier expansion of each function in the support of @xmath171 : @xmath222 @xmath223}\quad = \frac{1}{2^{r-1}}\sum_{\mathbf{i}=0}^{r/2 - 1}\begin{cases}\displaystyle \sum_{x\subseteq\{x_1,\ldots , x_r\ } , |x|\ \text{even } } ( -1)^{(\sum_{x_{j}\in x } i_{j } ) } y_{\tau(\mathbf{i } ) } \chi_{x } & \text{if $ s_{\mathbf{i}}=1$;}\\ \displaystyle \sum_{x\subseteq\{x_1,\ldots , x_r\ } , |x|\ \text{odd } } ( -1)^{(\sum _ { x_{j}\in x } i_{j } ) } y_{\tau(\mathbf{i } ) } \chi_{x } & \text{if $ s_{\mathbf{i}}=-1$.}\\ \end{cases}\ ] ] just as in the equation , whenever @xmath224 , the sum on the rhs of equation has precisely one non - zero term which is @xmath190 if @xmath225 and @xmath226 if @xmath227 . therefore this sum gives rise to exactly the addressing function in equation which is defined as @xmath213 and consequently the equality in equation follows . it follows that for each @xmath228 in the support of @xmath171 and for any fixed @xmath199 , all elements of the set @xmath229 will have the same parity . moreover , when draws from @xmath171 are considered , for every distinct @xmath199 this odd / even parity is independent and uniformly random . now we are ready to prove theorem [ s1qthm2 ] . recall that a @xmath2 oracle query returns @xmath96 with probability @xmath230 for every subset @xmath96 of input variables to the function . considering the equations and , for any @xmath3 in @xmath219 or @xmath182 its @xmath2 oracle will return a pair of the form @xmath231 . let us define a set @xmath232 of `` typical '' outcomes from @xmath2 oracle queries . fix any @xmath233 , and let @xmath232 denote the set of all sequences @xmath234 of length @xmath235 which have the property that _ no @xmath236 occurs more than once among @xmath237_. note that for any fixed @xmath238 , every non - zero fourier coefficient @xmath239 satisfies @xmath240 due to equation . therefore after @xmath194 is drawn , for any fixed @xmath199 the probability of receiving a response of the form @xmath241 as the outcome of a @xmath2 query is either @xmath242 , : : if @xmath194 is not a function of @xmath199 , i.e. @xmath243 ; or @xmath244 , : : if @xmath245 . this is because each of the @xmath246 responses @xmath241 occurs with probability @xmath247 . similarly , for any fixed @xmath248 , every non - zero fourier coefficient @xmath249 satisfies @xmath250 due to equation . therefore after @xmath228 is drawn , for any fixed @xmath199 the probability of receiving a response of the form @xmath241 as the outcome of a @xmath2 query is either @xmath242 , : : if @xmath228 is not a function of @xmath199 , i.e. @xmath251 ; or @xmath252 , : : if @xmath253 . this is because each of the @xmath254 responses @xmath241 occurs with probability @xmath255 . now let us consider the probability of obtaining a sequence from @xmath232 under each scenario . * if the function is drawn from @xmath170 : the probability is at least @xmath256}.\ ] ] * if the function is from @xmath171 : the probability is at least @xmath257}\ ] ] now the crucial observation is that whether the function is drawn from @xmath170 or from @xmath171 , each sequence in @xmath232 is equiprobable by symmetry in the construction . to see this , simply consider the probability of receiving a fixed @xmath258 for some new @xmath259 in the next @xmath2 query of an unknown function drawn from either one of these distributions . using the above calculations for @xmath260 , one can directly calculate that these probabilities are equal in either scenario . alternatively , for a function drawn from @xmath171 one can observe that since each successive @xmath259 is `` new '' , a fresh random bit determines whether the support is an @xmath258 with @xmath261 odd or even ; once this is determined , the choice of @xmath262 is uniform from all subsets with the correct parity . thus the overall draw of @xmath241 is uniform over all @xmath262 s . considering that the subset of relevant variables @xmath263 is uniformly chosen from @xmath264 , this gives the equality of the probabilities for each @xmath241 with a new @xmath259 when the function is drawn from @xmath171 . the argument for the case of @xmath170 is clear . consequently the statistical difference between the distributions corresponding to the sequence of outcomes of the @xmath235 @xmath2 oracle calls under the two distributions is at most @xmath265 . now fact [ dpi ] implies that no algorithm making only @xmath235 oracle calls can distinguish between these two scenarios with high probability . this gives us the result , and concludes the proof of theorem [ s1qthm2 ] . intuitively , under either distribution on functions , each element of a sequence of @xmath235 @xmath2 oracle calls will `` look like '' a uniform random draw @xmath262 from subsets of @xmath266 and @xmath191 from @xmath267 where @xmath191 and @xmath262 are independent . note that this argument breaks down at @xmath268 . this is because if the algorithm queried the @xmath2 oracle @xmath269 times it will start to see some @xmath270 s more than once with constant probability ( again by the birthday paradox ) . but when the functions are drawn from @xmath171 the corresponding @xmath108 s will always have a fixed parity for a given @xmath270 whereas for functions drawn from @xmath170 the parity will be random each time . this will provide the algorithm with sufficient evidence to distinguish with constant probability between these two scenarios . the problem of learning an unknown @xmath0-junta has been well studied in the computational learning theory literature , see e.g. @xcite . the following classical lower bound will be a yardstick against which we will measure our results . [ s2lem1 ] any classical membership query algorithm for learning @xmath0-juntas to accuracy @xmath271 must use @xmath22 membership queries . consider the restricted problem of learning an unknown function @xmath10 which is simply a single boolean variable from @xmath272 . since any two variables disagree on half of all inputs , any @xmath271-learning algorithm can be easily modified into an algorithm that exactly learns an unknown variable with no more queries . it is well known that any set of @xmath1 concepts requires @xmath273 queries for any exact learning algorithm that uses membership queries only , see e.g. @xcite . this gives the @xmath273 lower bound . for the @xmath274 lower bound , we may suppose that the algorithm `` knows '' that the junta has relevant variables @xmath275 . even in this case , if fewer than @xmath276 membership queries are made the learner will have no information about at least @xmath277 of the function s output values . a straightforward application of the chernoff bound shows that it is very unlikely for such a learner s hypothesis to be @xmath271-accurate , if the target junta is a uniform random function over the relevant variables . this establishes the result . learning juntas from uniform random examples @xmath47 is a seemingly difficult computational problem . simple algorithms based on exhaustive search can learn from @xmath278 examples but require @xmath279 runtime . the fastest known algorithm in this setting , due to mossel _ et al . _ , uses @xmath280 examples and runs in @xmath280 examples time , where @xmath281 is the matrix multiplication exponent @xcite . bshouty and jackson @xcite gave an algorithm using uniform quantum examples from the @xmath53 oracle to learn general @xmath12 formulas . their algorithm uses @xmath282 calls to @xmath53 to learn an @xmath217-term @xmath12 over @xmath1 variables to accuracy @xmath4 . since any @xmath0-junta is expressible as a @xmath12 with at most @xmath283 terms , their result immediately yields the following statement . [ s2thm2 ] there exists an @xmath34-learning quantum algorithm for @xmath0-juntas using @xmath284 quantum examples under the uniform distribution quantum pac model . note that @xcite did not try to optimize the quantum query complexity of their algorithms in the special case of learning juntas . in contrast , our goal is to obtain a more efficient algorithm for juntas . the lower bound of ( * ? ? ? * observation 6.3 ) for learning with quantum membership queries for an arbitrary concept class can be rephrased for the purpose of learning @xmath0-juntas as follows . [ s2fac1 ] any algorithm for learning @xmath0-juntas to accuracy @xmath285 with quantum membership queries must use @xmath274 queries . since we are proving a lower bound we may assume that the algorithm is told in advance that the junta depends on variables @xmath286 consequently we may assume that the algorithm makes all its queries with nonzero amplitude only on inputs of the form @xmath287 . now ( * ? ? ? * observation 6.3 ) states that any quantum algorithm which makes queries only over a shattered set ( as is the set of inputs @xmath288 for the class of @xmath0-juntas ) must make at least vc - dim(@xmath31)/100 @xmath50 queries to learn with error rate at most @xmath289 ; here vc - dim(@xmath31 ) is the vapnik - chervonenkis dimension of concept class @xmath31 . since the vc dimension of the class of all boolean functions over variables @xmath275 is @xmath290 , the result follows . this shows that a @xmath50 oracle can not provide sufficient information to learn a @xmath0-junta using @xmath291 queries to high accuracy . it is worth noting that there are other similar learning problems known where an @xmath235-query @xmath50 algorithm can exactly identify a target concept whose description length is @xmath292 bits . for instance , a single @xmath2 oracle call ( which can be implemented by a single @xmath50 query ) can potentially give up to @xmath0 bits of information ; if the concept class @xmath31 is the class of all @xmath290 parity functions over the first @xmath0 variables , then any concept in the class can be exactly learned by a single @xmath2 oracle call . note that all the results we have discussed in this subsection concern algorithms with access to only one type of oracle ; this is in contrast with the algorithm we present in the next section . the motivating question for this section is : `` is it possible to reduce the classical query / sample complexity drastically for the problem of junta learning if the learning algorithm is also permitted to have very limited quantum information ? '' we will give an affirmative answer to this question by describing a new algorithm that uses both @xmath2 queries ( i.e. quantum examples ) and classical uniform random examples . [ s1qlem1 ] let @xmath32 be a function whose value depends on the set of variables @xmath293 . then there is an algorithm querying the @xmath2 oracle @xmath294 times which w.h.p . outputs a list of variables such that * the list contains all the variables @xmath73 for which @xmath295 ; and * all the variables @xmath296 in the list have non - zero influence : @xmath297 . the algorithm simply queries the @xmath2 oracle @xmath298 many times and outputs the union of all the sets of variables received as responses to these queries . if @xmath295 then the probability that @xmath73 never occurs in any response obtained from the @xmath235 @xmath2 oracle calls is at most @xmath299 the union bound now yields that with probability at least @xmath130 , every @xmath73 with @xmath295 is output by the algorithm . [ s2thm3 ] there is an efficient algorithm @xmath34-learning @xmath0-juntas with @xmath7 queries of the @xmath2 oracle and @xmath300 random examples . we claim algorithm 1 satisfies these requirements . * input : * @xmath301 . * stage 1 : * construct a set containing all variables of @xmath3 with an influence at least @xmath302 using the algorithm in lemma [ s1qlem1 ] . let @xmath78 be the final result . * stage 2 : * @xmath304 draw from @xmath47 . let @xmath305 denote the projection of @xmath9 onto the variables in @xmath78 . @xmath306 . . output the hypothesis : @xmath307 assume we are given a boolean function @xmath3 whose value depends on the set of variables @xmath293 with @xmath308 . by lemma [ s1qlem1 ] , @xmath7 queries of the @xmath2 oracle will reveal all variables with influence at least @xmath302 with high probability during stage 1 . assuming the algorithm of lemma [ s1qlem1 ] was successful , we group the variables as follows : [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] note that @xmath309 by lemma [ s1qlem1 ] and by the assumption that @xmath3 is a @xmath0-junta . we reorder the variables of @xmath3 so that the new order is @xmath310 for notational simplicity , i.e. @xmath3 is now considered to be over @xmath311 . we will denote an assignment to these variables by @xmath312 . in stage 2 the algorithm draws random examples until at least @xmath313 fraction of all assignments to the variables in @xmath78 are observed . let us call this set of assignments by @xmath103 , and for every @xmath314 , let us denote the first example @xmath315 drawn in stage 2 for which @xmath316 by @xmath317 . at the end of the algorithm , the following hypothesis is produced as the output : @xmath318 in other words , the value of the hypothesis only depends on the setting of the variables in @xmath78 . observe the probability that any given setting of a fixed set of variables in @xmath78 has not been seen can be made less than @xmath319 using @xmath320 uniform random examples . therefore the linearity of expectation implies that after @xmath320 random examples , the expected fraction of unseen assignments is @xmath321 . thus by markov s inequality the fraction of unseen assignments will be @xmath322 w.h.p . hence stage 2 will terminate w.h.p . after @xmath320 random examples . consequently , the whole algorithm terminates with high probability with the desired query consumption . all we need to verify is that the hypothesis constructed is @xmath34-accurate . * the hypothesis @xmath323 is @xmath34-accurate with high probability : * we introduce some notation : let @xmath324 ; and given two strings @xmath325 , let @xmath326 denote the bitwise multiplication between @xmath327 ; and let @xmath328 denote the total number of @xmath25 s in @xmath329 . also let @xmath330 denote the indicator function that takes value @xmath26 if @xmath331 holds and value @xmath332 if @xmath331 is false . we start with the following fact : [ fac : stupidfact ] for any @xmath333 , we have @xmath334 } < { \epsilon}/10 $ ] . given any string @xmath335 , clearly there exists a sequence of @xmath336 strings : @xmath337 therefore , @xmath338 } \\ & \leq\frac{1}{2^{n } } \displaystyle\sum_{\mathbf{a}\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{a}| } } \sum_{\mathbf{b}\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{b}| } } \sum_{\mathbf{c}\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{c}|}}\sum_{i=1}^{|s|}\mathbf{1}_{[f(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b}\odot u^{i+1},\mathbf{c})\neq f(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b}\odot u^{i},\mathbf{c } ) ] } \\ & = \sum_{i=1}^{|s|}\underbrace{\left(\frac{1}{2^{n } } \displaystyle\sum_{\mathbf{a}\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{a}| } } \sum_{\mathbf{b}\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{b}| } } \sum_{\mathbf{c}\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{c}|}}\mathbf{1}_{[f(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b}\odot u^{i}\odot u^{i+1},\mathbf{c})\neq f(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b},\mathbf{c})]}\right)}_{=\text{the influence of the unique variable $ b_{j(i)}$ that takes value $ -1 $ in $ u^{i+1}\odot u^{i}$}}\\ & < { \epsilon}/10.\quad [ \text{since every $ b_j\in\mathcal{b}$ has influence $ < \frac{{\epsilon}}{10k}$ and $ |\mathcal{b}|\leq k$ } ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] for each @xmath339 , consider a fixed setting of strings @xmath340 , @xmath341 . let us call the list of all these assignments @xmath342 , i.e. @xmath343 for any such `` list of assignments '' @xmath342 , we define the function @xmath344 as follows : @xmath345 . the error incurred by approximating @xmath3 by @xmath346 is : @xmath347 = { \mathbf{pr}}_{(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b},\mathbf{c})}[f(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b}^{\mathbf{a}},\mathbf{c}^{\mathbf{a}})\neq f(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b},\mathbf{c})]\ ] ] @xmath348\quad [ \text{since $ f$ does not depend on the variables in $ \mathcal{c}$}]\ ] ] @xmath349 } = \frac{1}{2^{n } } \displaystyle\sum_{\mathbf{a}\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{a}| } } \sum_{s\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{b}| } } \sum_{\mathbf{c}\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{c}|}}\mathbf{1}_{[f(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b}^{\mathbf{a}},\mathbf{c})\neq f(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b}^{\mathbf{a}}\odot s,\mathbf{c})]}\label{eqn : fgamma}\ ] ] therefore if we consider the expected value of the incurred error @xmath350 $ ] over all `` lists of assignments '' @xmath342 , equation implies that : @xmath351&=\frac{1}{2^{|\mathcal{b}|}}\sum_{s\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{b}|}}\underbrace{\left(\frac{1}{2^{n } } \displaystyle\sum_{\mathbf{a}\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{a}| } } \sum_{\mathbf{b}^{\mathbf{a}}\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{b}| } } \sum_{\mathbf{c}\in\mathbb{b}^{|\mathcal{c}|}}\mathbf{1}_{[f(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b}^{\mathbf{a}}\odot s,\mathbf{c})\neq f(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b}^{\mathbf{a}},\mathbf{c})]}\right ) } _ { < { \epsilon}/10,\ \text{due to fact~\ref{fac : stupidfact}}}\\ & < { \epsilon}/10 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] consequently , the expected error of approximating @xmath3 by a uniformly chosen @xmath346 is less than @xmath352 . this also implies that for a uniformly chosen subset @xmath103 of assignments to variables in @xmath78 with size @xmath353 , the expected error over @xmath103 satisfies : @xmath354 < { \epsilon}/10 $ ] . therefore by markov s inequality , we obtain the following observation : [ obs : jlproof]for a uniformly chosen subset @xmath103 and @xmath346 as described above , @xmath346 will agree with @xmath3 on @xmath355 fraction of the coordinates @xmath356 with probability at least @xmath357 . now if we go back and recall what the algorithm does in stage 2 , we will observe that the generation of the hypothesis in stage 2 is equivalent to drawing a uniform @xmath346 and @xmath103 as described and resetting the values of @xmath346 at those coordinates @xmath358 to true . this is because the algorithm only draws classical random examples during stage 2 . therefore due to observation [ obs : jlproof ] , the hypothesis will disagree with @xmath3 on at most @xmath359 fraction of the inputs with overall probability at least @xmath36 . this gives the desired result . note that this algorithm * uses only a moderate number of quantum examples ; * has overall query complexity with no dependence on @xmath1 , in contrast with known lower bounds ( lemma [ s2lem1 ] ) for learning from classical membership queries ; * uses the @xmath46 oracle as its only source of classical information ( @xmath43 queries are not used ) ; and * is computationally efficient . one can compare this result to that of theorem [ s2thm2 ] which requires @xmath284 quantum examples to learn @xmath0-juntas . in contrast , our algorithm uses not only substantially fewer quantum examples but also fewer uniform random examples , which are considered quite cheap . intuitively , this means that for the junta learning problem , almost all the quantum queries used by the algorithm of bshouty and jackson @xcite can in fact be converted into ordinary classical random examples . the algorithm of theorem [ s2thm3 ] is optimal in the following sense : [ obsjlrn ] any @xmath360-learning quantum membership query algorithm for @xmath0-juntas that uses only @xmath361 classical @xmath43 queries must additionally use @xmath362 @xmath50 queries . this statement easily follows from fact [ s2fac1 ] since a classical membership query can be simulated by a @xmath50 query . contrasting our junta learning algorithm with observation [ obsjlrn ] , we see that if the allowed number of classical examples or queries is decreased even slightly from the @xmath363 used by our algorithm to @xmath361 , then an additional @xmath362 quantum queries are required , even if @xmath50 queries are allowed . we have given some results on learning and testing @xmath0-juntas using both quantum examples and classical random examples . it would be interesting to develop other testing and learning algorithms that combine these two sorts of oracles , with the goal of minimizing the number of quantum oracle calls required . another interesting goal for future work is to further explore the power of the @xmath2 oracle . can the gap between our @xmath100-query upper bound and our @xmath6-query lower bound for the @xmath2 oracle be closed ? a. blum , _ learning a function of @xmath146 relevant variables ( open problem ) _ , proceedings of the 16th annual conference on learning theory and 7th kernel workshop , pp . 731733 ( 2003 ) . h. buhrman , l. fortnow , i. newman , h. rhrig , _ quantum property testing _ , proceedings of 14th soda , pp . 480488 ( 2003 ) . n. bshouty , r. cleve , r. gavald , s. kannan and c. tamon . _ oracles and queries that are sufficient for exact learning _ , j. comput , vol * 52 * , no . 3 , pp . 421 - 433 ( 1996 ) . r. lipton , e. markakis , a. mehta , n. vishnoi , _ on the fourier spectrum of symmetric boolean functions with applications to learning symmetric juntas _ , proceedings of the 20th annual ieee conference on computational complexity , pp . 112119 ( 2005 ) . e. mossel , r. odonnell and r. a. servedio , _ learning functions of @xmath0 variables _ , journal of computer and system sciences , vol . * 69 * , no . 3 , pp . 421434 ( 2004 ) . m. nielsen and i. chuang , _ quantum computation and quantum information _ , cambridge university press ( 2000 ) . r. odonnell , r. a. servedio , _ extremal properties of polynomial threshold functions _ , journal of computer & system sciences , to appear . available at http://www.cs.columbia.edu/`~`rocco/papers/ccc03.html . preliminary version appeared in eighteenth annual ieee conference on computational complexity , pp . 312 ( 2003 ) . r. rubinfeld and m. sudan , _ robust characterizations of polynomials with applications to program testing _ , siam journal on computing , * 25*(2 ) : pp . 252271 ( 1996 ) .

in this article we develop quantum algorithms for learning and testing _ juntas _ , i.e. boolean functions which depend only on an unknown set of @xmath0 out of @xmath1 input variables . our aim is to develop efficient algorithms : whose sample complexity has no dependence on @xmath1 , the dimension of the domain the boolean functions are defined over ; with no access to any classical or quantum membership ( `` black - box '' ) queries . instead , our algorithms use only classical examples generated uniformly at random and fixed quantum superpositions of such classical examples ; which require only a few quantum examples but possibly many classical random examples ( which are considered quite `` cheap '' relative to quantum examples ) . our quantum algorithms are based on a subroutine @xmath2 which enables sampling according to the fourier spectrum of @xmath3 ; the @xmath2 subroutine was used in earlier work of bshouty and jackson on quantum learning . our results are as follows : we give an algorithm for testing @xmath0-juntas to accuracy @xmath4 that uses @xmath5 quantum examples . this improves on the number of examples used by the best known classical algorithm . we establish the following lower bound : any @xmath2-based @xmath0-junta testing algorithm requires @xmath6 queries . we give an algorithm for learning @xmath0-juntas to accuracy @xmath4 that uses @xmath7 quantum examples and @xmath8 random examples . we show that this learning algorithms is close to optimal by giving a related lower bound .

1512.03679

smc 3 is one of the symbiotic systems in the magellanic clouds . the system contains a wd and an m giant with an orbital period of 4.5 years ( eg . it is a supersoft x - ray source powered by a steady hydrogen burning on the surface of the white dwarf ( orio _ et al . _ 2007 ) . because the system contains a massive white dwarf ( [email protected] m@xmath1 ; orio _ et al . _ @xcite ) with a high accretion rate ( @xmath2 m@xmath1/yr ; kahabka @xcite ) it is considered as one of the most promising supernova ia progenitors among the known symbiotic population . to estimate the mass of the red giant we used the fact that it pulsates with a period of 110 days ( kahabka @xcite ) . smc 3 lies on the sequence b in the k - log(p ) plane ( wood 2000 ) which suggests the first overtone pulsation . assuming the pulsation constant of q=0.04 we derived the mass of 2.3@xmath3 m@xmath1 . to carry out our analysis we used the startrack population synthesis code ( belczyski _ et al . _ the code includes the wind accretion through bondi - hoyle mechanism , roche - lobe overflow , @xmath4 roche - lobe overflow and @xmath5 roche - lobe overflow . as initial conditions we adopted the current parameters of the system and then we modeled its future evolution . we assumed @xmath6=1.44 m@xmath1 and , since we studied the system in the sn ia context , a co wd . for all of our models the system went trough a common envelope ( ce ) after @xmath7 yrs and for none of the models system wd managed to accumulate enough matter to become a type ia supernova . the orbital separation after the ce was relatively big ( a@xmath8r@xmath1 ) , which makes a merger in the hubble time unlikely . the obtained parameters of the system are presented in fig . we predict that the system will not become a type ia supernova in contrary to what was suggested in the literature ( orio _ et al . _ the caveat is that our predicted mass transfer rate is somewhat lower then the one expected for the steady hydrogen burning on the surface of the white dwarf ( nomoto _ et al . _ a lower @xmath9 then expected could be due to the fact that our model underestimates the rg mass loss trough wind by treating it as in the single star scenario , whereas there is a strong observational evidence that this wind is significantly enhanced due to tidal interactions in syst ( mikoajewska _ et al . _ large roche lobe filling factor suggests ellipsoidal variability in the system . 99 belczyski k. 2008 , apjs , 174 , 223 kahabka p. , 2004 , a&a , 416 , 57 kato m. 2013 , apj , 763 , 5 nomoto k. 2007 , apj , 663 , 1269 mikoajewska j. 2002 , adspr , 30 , 2045 orio m. 2007 , apj , 661 , 1105 wood p.r . , 2000 , pasa , 17 , 18

smc 3 is one of the most interesting symbiotic stars . this binary contains a bright k - type giant transferring mass to a massive white dwarf comanion , which makes it is a very promising sn ia candidate . we discuss the evolutionary status of the system using results of population synthesis code .

1506.00356

this article proposes an approach to inferring the causal impact of a market intervention , such as a new product launch or the onset of an advertising campaign . our method generalises the widely used difference - in - differences approach to the time - series setting by explicitly modelling the counterfactual of a time series observed both before and after the intervention . it improves on existing methods in two respects : it provides a fully bayesian time - series estimate for the effect ; and it uses model averaging to construct the most appropriate synthetic control for modelling the counterfactual . the ` causalimpact ` r package provides an implementation of our approach ( http://google.github.io/causalimpact/ ) . inferring the impact of market interventions is an important and timely problem . partly because of recent interest in big data , many firms have begun to understand that a competitive advantage can be had by systematically using impact measures to inform strategic decision making . an example is the use of `` a@xmath0b experiments '' to identify the most effective market treatments for the purpose of allocating resources [ @xcite ] . here , we focus on measuring the impact of a discrete marketing event , such as the release of a new product , the introduction of a new feature , or the beginning or end of an advertising campaign , with the aim of measuring the event s impact on a response metric of interest ( e.g. , sales ) . the causal impact of a treatment is the difference between the observed value of the response and the ( unobserved ) value that would have been obtained under the alternative treatment , that is , the effect of treatment on the treated [ @xcite , @xcite ( @xcite ) ] . in the present setting the response variable is a time series , so the causal effect of interest is the difference between the observed series and the series that would have been observed had the intervention not taken place . a powerful approach to constructing the counterfactual is based on the idea of combining a set of candidate predictor variables into a single `` synthetic control '' [ @xcite ] . broadly speaking , there are three sources of information available for constructing an adequate synthetic control . the first is the time - series behaviour of the response itself , prior to the intervention . the second is the behaviour of other time series that were predictive of the target series prior to the intervention . such control series can be based , for example , on the same product in a different region that did not receive the intervention or on a metric that reflects activity in the industry as a whole . in practice , there are often many such series available , and the challenge is to pick the relevant subset to use as contemporaneous controls . this selection is done on the _ pre - treatment _ portion of potential controls ; but their value for predicting the counterfactual lies in their _ post - treatment _ behaviour . as long as the control series received no intervention themselves , it is often reasonable to assume the relationship between the treatment and the control series that existed prior to the intervention to continue afterwards . thus , a plausible estimate of the counterfactual time series can be computed up to the point in time where the relationship between treatment and controls can no longer be assumed to be stationary , for example , because one of the controls received treatment itself . in a bayesian framework , a third source of information for inferring the counterfactual is the available prior knowledge about the model parameters , as elicited , for example , by previous studies . ) with an intervention beginning in january 2014 . two other markets ( @xmath1 , @xmath2 ) were not subject to the intervention and allow us to construct a synthetic control [ cf . @xcite ] . inverting the state - space model described in the main text yields a prediction of what would have happened in @xmath3 had the intervention not taken place ( posterior predictive expectation of the counterfactual with pointwise 95% posterior probability intervals ) . the difference between observed data and counterfactual predictions is the inferred causal impact of the intervention . here , predictions accurately reflect the true ( gamma - shaped ) impact . a key characteristic of the inferred impact series is the progressive widening of the posterior intervals ( shaded area ) . this effect emerges naturally from the model structure and agrees with the intuition that predictions should become increasingly uncertain as we look further and further into the ( retrospective ) future . another way of visualizing posterior inferences is by means of a cumulative impact plot . it shows , for each day , the summed effect up to that day . here , the 95% credible interval of the cumulative impact crosses the zero - line about five months after the intervention , at which point we would no longer declare a significant overall effect . ] [ fig : intro : illustration ] we combine the three preceding sources of information using a state - space time - series model , where one component of state is a linear regression on the contemporaneous predictors . the framework of our model allows us to choose from among a large set of potential controls by placing a spike - and - slab prior on the set of regression coefficients and by allowing the model to average over the set of controls [ @xcite ] . we then compute the posterior distribution of the counterfactual time series given the value of the target series in the pre - intervention period , along with the values of the controls in the post - intervention period . subtracting the predicted from the observed response during the post - intervention period gives a semiparametric bayesian posterior distribution for the causal effect ( figure [ fig : intro : illustration ] ) . as with other domains , causal inference in marketing requires subtlety . marketing data are often observational and rarely follow the ideal of a randomised design . they typically exhibit a low signal - to - noise ratio . they are subject to multiple seasonal variations , and they are often confounded by the effects of unobserved variables and their interactions [ for recent examples , see @xcite , @xcite ( @xcite ) ] . rigorous causal inferences can be obtained through randomised experiments , which are often implemented in the form of geo experiments . many market interventions , however , fail to satisfy the requirements of such approaches . for instance , advertising campaigns are frequently launched across multiple channels , online and offline , which precludes measurement of individual exposure . campaigns are often targeted at an entire country , and one country only , which prohibits the use of geographic controls within that country . likewise , a campaign might be launched in several countries but at different points in time . thus , while a large control group may be available , the treatment group often consists of no more than one region or a few regions with considerable heterogeneity among them . a standard approach to causal inference in such settings is based on a linear model of the observed outcomes in the treatment and control group before and after the intervention . one can then estimate the difference between ( i ) the pre - post difference in the treatment group and ( ii ) the pre - post difference in the control group . the assumption underlying such _ difference - in - differences _ ( dd ) designs is that the level of the control group provides an adequate proxy for the level that would have been observed in the treatment group in the absence of treatment [ see @xcite ] . dd designs have been limited in three ways . first , dd is traditionally based on a static regression model that assumes i.i.d . data despite the fact that the design has a temporal component . when fit to serially correlated data , static models yield overoptimistic inferences with too narrow uncertainty intervals [ see also @xcite , @xcite ( @xcite ) , @xcite ] . second , most dd analyses only consider two time points : before and after the intervention . in practice , the manner in which an effect evolves over time , especially its onset and decay structure , is often a key question . third , when dd analyses _ are _ based on time series , previous studies have imposed restrictions on the way in which a synthetic control is constructed from a set of predictor variables , which is something we wish to avoid . for example , one strategy [ @xcite ] has been to choose a convex combination @xmath4 of @xmath5 predictor time series in such a way that a vector of pre - treatment variables ( not time series ) @xmath1 characterising the treated unit before the intervention is matched most closely by the combination of pre - treatment variables @xmath6 of the control units w.r.t . a vector of importance weights @xmath7 . these weights are themselves determined in such a way that the combination of pre - treatment outcome time series of the control units most closely matches the pre - treatment outcome time series of the treated unit . such a scheme relies on the availability of interpretable characteristics ( e.g. , growth predictors ) , and it precludes nonconvex combinations of controls when constructing the weight vector @xmath8 . we prefer to select a combination of control series without reference to external characteristics and purely in terms of how well they explain the pre - treatment outcome time series of the treated unit ( while automatically balancing goodness of fit and model complexity through the use of regularizing priors ) . another idea [ @xcite ] has been to use classical variable - selection methods ( such as the lasso ) to find a sparse set of predictors . this approach , however , ignores posterior uncertainty about both which predictors to use and their coefficients . the limitations of dd schemes can be addressed by using state - space models , coupled with highly flexible regression components , to explain the temporal evolution of an observed outcome . state - space models distinguish between a state equation that describes the transition of a set of latent variables from one time point to the next and an observation equation that specifies how a given system state translates into measurements . this distinction makes them extremely flexible and powerful [ see @xcite for a discussion in the context of marketing research ] . the approach described in this paper inherits three main characteristics from the state - space paradigm . first , it allows us to flexibly accommodate different kinds of assumptions about the latent state and emission processes underlying the observed data , including local trends and seasonality . second , we use a fully bayesian approach to inferring the temporal evolution of counterfactual activity and incremental impact . one advantage of this is the flexibility with which posterior inferences can be summarised . third , we use a regression component that precludes a rigid commitment to a particular set of controls by integrating out our posterior uncertainty about the influence of each predictor as well as our uncertainty about which predictors to include in the first place , which avoids overfitting . the remainder of this paper is organised as follows . section [ sec : theory ] describes the proposed model , its design variations , the choice of diffuse empirical priors on hyperparameters , and a stochastic algorithm for posterior inference based on markov chain monte carlo ( mcmc ) . section [ sec : apps : synthetic ] demonstrates important features of the model using simulated data , followed by an application in section [ sec : apps : empirical ] to an advertising campaign run by one of google s advertisers . section [ sec : disc ] puts our approach into context and discusses its scope of application . structural time - series models are state - space models for time - series data . they can be defined in terms of a pair of equations @xmath9 where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are independent of all other unknowns . equation ( [ eq : observation ] ) is the _ observation equation _ ; it links the observed data @xmath12 to a latent @xmath13-dimensional state vector @xmath14 . equation ( [ eq : transition ] ) is the _ state equation _ ; it governs the evolution of the state vector @xmath14 through time . in the present paper , @xmath12 is a scalar observation , @xmath15 is a @xmath13-dimensional output vector , @xmath16 is a @xmath17 transition matrix , @xmath18 is a @xmath19 control matrix , @xmath20 is a scalar observation error with noise variance @xmath21 , and @xmath22 is a @xmath23-dimensional system error with a @xmath24 state - diffusion matrix @xmath25 , where @xmath26 . writing the error structure of equation ( [ eq : transition ] ) as @xmath27 allows us to incorporate state components of less than full rank ; a model for seasonality will be the most important example . structural time - series models are useful in practice because they are flexible and modular . they are flexible in the sense that a very large class of models , including all arima models , can be written in the state - space form given by ( [ eq : observation ] ) and ( [ eq : transition ] ) . they are modular in the sense that the latent state as well as the associated model matrices @xmath28 , and @xmath25 can be assembled from a library of component sub - models to capture important features of the data . there are several widely used state - component models for capturing the trend , seasonality or effects of holidays . a common approach is to assume the errors of different state - component models to be independent ( i.e. , @xmath25 is block - diagonal ) . the vector @xmath14 can then be formed by concatenating the individual state components , while @xmath16 and @xmath18 become block - diagonal matrices . the most important state component for the applications considered in this paper is a regression component that allows us to obtain counterfactual predictions by constructing a synthetic control based on a combination of markets that were not treated . observed responses from such markets are important because they allow us to explain variance components in the treated market that are not readily captured by more generic seasonal sub - models . this approach assumes that covariates are unaffected by the effects of treatment . for example , an advertising campaign run in the united states might spill over to canada or the united kingdom . when assuming the absence of spill - over effects , the use of such indirectly affected markets as controls would lead to pessimistic inferences , that is , the effect of the campaign would be underestimated [ cf . @xcite ] . the first component of our model is a local linear trend , defined by the pair of equations @xmath29 \label{eq : local - linear - trend } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber \delta_{t+1 } & = & \delta_{t } + \eta_{\delta , t},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath30 and @xmath31 . the @xmath32 component is the value of the trend at time @xmath33 . the @xmath34 component is the expected increase in @xmath35 between times @xmath33 and @xmath36 , so it can be thought of as the _ slope _ at time @xmath33 . the local linear trend model is a popular choice for modelling trends because it quickly adapts to local variation , which is desirable when making short - term predictions . this degree of flexibility may not be desired when making longer - term predictions , as such predictions often come with implausibly wide uncertainty intervals . there is a generalisation of the local linear trend model where the slope exhibits stationarity instead of obeying a random walk . this model can be written as @xmath37 \label{eq : generalized - local - linear - trend } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber \delta_{t+1 } & = & d + \rho(\delta_{t } - d ) + \eta_{\delta , t},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the two components of @xmath38 are independent . in this model , the slope of the time trend exhibits @xmath39 variation around a long - term slope of @xmath40 . the parameter @xmath41 represents the learning rate at which the local trend is updated . thus , the model balances short - term information with information from the distant past . there are several commonly used state - component models to capture seasonality . the most frequently used model in the time domain is @xmath42 where @xmath43 represents the number of seasons and @xmath44 denotes their joint contribution to the observed response @xmath12 . the state in this model consists of the @xmath45 most recent seasonal effects , but the error term is a scalar , so the evolution equation for this state model is less than full rank . the mean of @xmath46 is such that the total seasonal effect is zero when summed over @xmath43 seasons . for example , if we set @xmath47 to capture four seasons per year , the mean of the _ winter _ coefficient will be @xmath48 . the part of the transition matrix @xmath16 representing the seasonal model is an @xmath49 matrix with @xmath50 s along the top row , 1 s along the subdiagonal and 0 s elsewhere . the preceding seasonal model can be generalised to allow for multiple seasonal components with different periods . when modelling daily data , for example , we might wish to allow for an @xmath51 day - of - week effect , as well as an @xmath52 weekly annual cycle . the latter can be handled by setting @xmath53 , with zero variance on the error term , when @xmath33 is not the start of a new week , and setting @xmath16 to the usual seasonal transition matrix , with nonzero error variance , when @xmath33 is the start of a new week . control time series that received no treatment are critical to our method for obtaining accurate counterfactual predictions since they account for variance components that are shared by the series , including , in particular , the effects of other unobserved causes otherwise unaccounted for by the model . a natural way of including control series in the model is through a linear regression . its coefficients can be static or time - varying . a _ static _ regression can be written in state - space form by setting @xmath54 and @xmath55 . one advantage of working in a fully bayesian treatment is that we do not need to commit to a fixed set of covariates . the spike - and - slab prior described in section [ sec : posterior - sampling ] allows us to integrate out our posterior uncertainty about which covariates to include and how strongly they should influence our predictions , which avoids overfitting . all covariates are assumed to be contemporaneous ; the present model does not infer on a potential lag between treated and untreated time series . a known lag , however , can be easily incorporated by shifting the corresponding regressor in time . an alternative to the above is a regression component with _ dynamic _ regression coefficients to account for time - varying relationships [ e.g. , @xcite ] . given covariates @xmath56 , this introduces the dynamic regression component @xmath57 \label{eq : dynamic - regression } \\[-8pt ] \nonumber \beta_{j , t+1 } & = & \beta_{j , t } + \eta_{\beta , j , t},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath58 . here , @xmath59 is the coefficient for the @xmath60th control series and @xmath61 is the standard deviation of its associated random walk . we can write the dynamic regression component in state - space form by setting @xmath62 and @xmath63 and by setting the corresponding part of the transition matrix to @xmath64 , with @xmath65 . structural time - series models allow us to examine the time series at hand and flexibly choose appropriate components for trend , seasonality , and either static or dynamic regression for the controls . the presence or absence of seasonality , for example , will usually be obvious by inspection . a more subtle question is whether to choose static or dynamic regression coefficients . when the relationship between controls and treated unit has been stable in the past , static coefficients are an attractive option . this is because a spike - and - slab prior can be implemented efficiently within a forward - filtering , backward - sampling framework . this makes it possible to quickly identify a sparse set of covariates even from tens or hundreds of potential variables [ @xcite ] . local variability in the treated time series is captured by the dynamic local level or dynamic linear trend component . covariate stability is typically high when the available covariates are close in nature to the treated metric . the empirical analyses presented in this paper , for example , will be based on a static regression component ( section [ sec : apps : empirical ] ) . this choice provides a reasonable compromise between capturing local behaviour and accounting for regression effects . an alternative would be to use dynamic regression coefficients , as we do , for instance , in our analyses of simulated data ( section [ sec : apps : synthetic ] ) . dynamic coefficients are useful when the linear relationship between treated metrics and controls is believed to change over time . there are a number of ways of reducing the computational burden of dealing with a potentially large number of dynamic coefficients . one option is to resort to dynamic latent factors , where one uses @xmath66 with @xmath67 and uses @xmath68 instead of @xmath69 as part of @xmath15 in ( [ eq : observation ] ) , coupled with an ar - type model for @xmath68 itself . another option is latent thresholding regression , where one uses a dynamic version of the spike - and - slab prior as in @xcite . the state - component models are assembled independently , with each component providing an additive contribution to @xmath12 . figure [ fig : theory : model ] illustrates this process assuming a local linear trend paired with a static regression component . is modelled as the result of a latent state plus gaussian observation noise with error standard deviation @xmath70 . the state @xmath71 includes a local level @xmath32 , a local linear trend @xmath34 , and a set of contemporaneous covariates @xmath69 , scaled by regression coefficients @xmath72 . state components are assumed to evolve according to independent gaussian random walks with fixed standard deviations @xmath73 and @xmath74 ( conditional - dependence arrows shown for the first time point only ) . the model includes empirical priors on these parameters and the initial states . in an alternative formulation , the regression coefficients @xmath75 are themselves subject to random - walk diffusion ( see main text ) . of principal interest is the posterior predictive density over the unobserved counterfactual responses @xmath76 . subtracting these from the actual observed data @xmath77 yields a probability density over the temporal evolution of causal impact . ] let @xmath78 generically denote the set of all model parameters and let @xmath79 denote the full state sequence . we adopt a bayesian approach to inference by specifying a prior distribution @xmath80 on the model parameters as well as a distribution @xmath81 on the initial state values . we may then sample from @xmath82 using mcmc . most of the models in section [ sec : components - state ] depend solely on a small set of variance parameters that govern the diffusion of the individual state components . a typical prior distribution for such a variance is @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the gamma distribution with expectation @xmath85 . the prior parameters can be interpreted as a prior sum of squares @xmath86 , so that @xmath87 is a prior estimate of @xmath88 , and @xmath89 is the weight , in units of prior sample size , assigned to the prior estimate . we often have a weak default prior belief that the incremental errors in the state process are small , which we can formalise by choosing small values of @xmath89 ( e.g. , 1 ) and small values of @xmath87 . the notion of `` small '' means different things in different models ; for the seasonal and local linear trend models our default priors are @xmath90 , where @xmath91 is the sample variance of the target series . scaling by the sample variance is a minor violation of the bayesian paradigm , but it is an effective means of choosing a reasonable scale for the prior . it is similar to the popular technique of scaling the data prior to analysis , but we prefer to do the scaling in the prior so we can model the data on its original scale . when faced with many potential controls , we prefer letting the model choose an appropriate set . this can be achieved by placing a spike - and - slab prior over coefficients [ @xcite ( @xcite ) , @xcite ] . a spike - and - slab prior combines point mass at zero ( the `` spike '' ) , for an unknown subset of zero coefficients , with a weakly informative distribution on the complementary set of nonzero coefficients ( the `` slab '' ) . contrary to what its name might suggest , the `` slab '' is usually not completely flat , but rather a gaussian with a large variance . let @xmath92 , where @xmath93 if @xmath94 and @xmath95 otherwise . let @xmath96 denote the nonzero elements of the vector @xmath97 and let @xmath98 denote the rows and columns of @xmath99 corresponding to nonzero entries in @xmath100 . we can then factorise the spike - and - slab prior as @xmath101 the spike portion of ( [ eq : spike - slab - general ] ) can be an arbitrary distribution over @xmath102 in principle ; the most common choice in practice is a product of independent bernoulli distributions , @xmath103 where @xmath104 is the prior probability of regressor @xmath60 being included in the model . values for @xmath104 can be elicited by asking about the _ expected model size _ @xmath105 , and then setting all @xmath106 . an alternative is to use a more specific set of values @xmath104 . in particular , one might choose to set certain @xmath104 to either 1 or 0 to force the corresponding variables into or out of the model . generally , framing the prior in terms of expected model size has the advantage that the model can adapt to growing numbers of predictor variables without having to switch to a hierarchical prior [ @xcite ] . for the `` slab '' portion of the prior we use a conjugate normal - inverse gamma distribution , @xmath107 the vector @xmath108 in equation ( [ eq : slab - normal ] ) encodes our prior expectation about the value of each element of @xmath75 . in practice , we usually set @xmath109 . the prior parameters in equation ( [ eq : slab - variance ] ) can be elicited by asking about the expected @xmath110 $ ] as well as the number of observations worth of weight @xmath111 the prior estimate should be given . then @xmath112 . the final prior parameter in ( [ eq : slab - normal ] ) is @xmath99 , which , up to a scaling factor , is the prior precision over @xmath75 in the full model , with all variables included . the total information in the covariates is @xmath113 , and so @xmath114 is the average information in a single observation . zellner s @xmath115-prior [ @xcite ] sets @xmath116 , so that @xmath115 can be interpreted as @xmath115 observations worth of information . zellner s prior becomes improper when @xmath113 is not positive definite ; we therefore ensure propriety by averaging @xmath113 with its diagonal , @xmath117 with default values of @xmath118 and @xmath119 . overall , this prior specification provides a broadly useful default while providing considerable flexibility in those cases where more specific prior information is available . posterior inference in our model can be broken down into three pieces . first , we simulate draws of the model parameters @xmath120 and the state vector @xmath121 given the observed data @xmath122 in the training period . second , we use the posterior simulations to simulate from the posterior predictive distribution @xmath123 given the observed pre - intervention activity @xmath124 . third , we use the posterior predictive samples to compute the posterior distribution of the pointwise impact @xmath125 for each @xmath126 . we use the same samples to obtain the posterior distribution of cumulative impact . we use a gibbs sampler to simulate a sequence @xmath127 from a markov chain whose stationary distribution is @xmath128 . the sampler alternates between a _ data - augmentation _ step that simulates from @xmath129 and a _ parameter - simulation _ step that simulates from @xmath130 . the data - augmentation step uses the posterior simulation algorithm from @xcite , providing an improvement over the earlier forward - filtering , backward - sampling algorithms by @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . in brief , because @xmath131 is jointly multivariate normal , the variance of @xmath132 does not depend on @xmath124 . we can therefore simulate @xmath133 and subtract @xmath134 to obtain zero - mean noise with the correct variance . adding @xmath135 restores the correct mean , which completes the draw . the required expectations can be computed using the kalman filter and a _ fast mean smoother _ described in detail by @xcite . the result is a direct simulation from @xmath136 in an algorithm that is linear in the total ( pre- and post - intervention ) number of time points ( @xmath137 ) and quadratic in the dimension of the state space ( @xmath13 ) . given the draw of the state , the parameter draw is straightforward for all state components other than the static regression coefficients @xmath138 . all state components that exclusively depend on variance parameters can translate their draws back to error terms @xmath22 and accumulate sums of squares of @xmath38 , and , because of conjugacy with equation ( [ eq : typical - variance ] ) , the posterior distribution will remain gamma distributed . the draw of the static regression coefficients @xmath138 proceeds as follows . for each @xmath139 in the pre - intervention period , let @xmath140 denote @xmath12 with the contributions from the other state components subtracted away , and let @xmath141 . the challenge is to simulate from @xmath142 . because of conjugacy , we can integrate out @xmath138 and @xmath143 and be left with @xmath144 where @xmath145 is an unknown normalizing constant . the sufficient statistics in equation ( [ eq : inclusion - indicator - posterior ] ) are @xmath146 to sample from ( [ eq : inclusion - indicator - posterior ] ) , we use a gibbs sampler that draws each @xmath147 given all other @xmath148 . each full - conditional is easy to evaluate because @xmath147 can only assume two possible values . it should be noted that the dimension of all matrices in ( [ eq : inclusion - indicator - posterior ] ) is @xmath149 , which is small if the model is truly sparse . there are many matrices to manipulate , but because each is small , the overall algorithm is fast . once the draw of @xmath150 is complete , we sample directly from @xmath151 using standard conjugate formulae . for an alternative that may be even more computationally efficient , see @xcite . while the posterior over model parameters and states @xmath152 can be of interest in its own right , causal impact analyses are primarily concerned with the posterior incremental effect , @xmath153 as shown by its indices , the density in equation ( [ eqn : theory : postpred ] ) is defined precisely for that portion of the time series which is unobserved : the counterfactual market response @xmath154 that would have been observed in the treated market , after the intervention , in the absence of treatment . it is also worth emphasising that the density is conditional on the observed data ( as well as the priors ) and only on these , that is , on activity in the treatment market before the beginning of the intervention as well as activity in all control markets both before and during the intervention . the density is _ not _ conditioned on parameter estimates or the inclusion or exclusion of covariates with static regression coefficients , all of which have been integrated out . thus , through bayesian model averaging , we commit neither to any particular set of covariates , which helps avoid an arbitrary selection , nor to point estimates of their coefficients , which prevents overfitting . the posterior predictive density in ( [ eqn : theory : postpred ] ) is defined as a coherent ( joint ) distribution over all counterfactual data points , rather than as a collection of pointwise univariate distributions . this ensures that we correctly propagate the serial structure determined on pre - intervention data to the trajectory of counterfactuals . this is crucial , in particular , when forming summary statistics , such as the cumulative effect of the intervention on the treatment market . posterior inference was implemented in c@xmath155 with an r interface . given a typically - sized data set with @xmath156 time points , @xmath157 covariates , and @xmath158 iterations ( see section [ sec : apps : empirical ] for an example ) , this implementation takes less than 30 seconds to complete on a standard computer , enabling near - interactive analyses . samples from the posterior predictive distribution over counterfactual activity can be readily used to obtain samples from the posterior causal effect , that is , the quantity we are typically interested in . for each draw @xmath159 and for each time point @xmath160 , we set @xmath161 yielding samples from the approximate posterior predictive density of the effect attributed to the intervention . in addition to its pointwise impact , we often wish to understand the cumulative effect of an intervention over time . one of the main advantages of a sampling approach to posterior inference is the flexibility and ease with which such derived inferences can be obtained . reusing the impact samples obtained in ( [ eqn : theory : causal_samples ] ) , we compute for each draw @xmath159 @xmath162 the preceding _ cumulative sum _ of causal increments is a useful quantity when @xmath163 represents a _ flow _ quantity , measured over an interval of time ( e.g. , a day ) , such as the number of searches , sign - ups , sales , additional installs or new users . it becomes uninterpretable when @xmath163 represents a _ quantity , usefully defined only for a point in time , such as the total number of clients , users or subscribers . in this case we might instead choose , for each @xmath159 , to draw a sample of the posterior _ running average _ effect following the intervention , @xmath164 unlike the cumulative effect in ( [ eqn : cumlift ] ) , the running average is always interpretable , regardless of whether it refers to a flow or a stock . however , it is more context - dependent on the length of the post - intervention period under consideration . in particular , under the assumption of a true impact that grows quickly at first and then declines to zero , the cumulative impact approaches its true total value ( in expectation ) as we increase the counterfactual forecasting period , whereas the average impact will eventually approach zero ( while , in contrast , the probability intervals diverge in both cases , leading to more and more uncertain inferences as the forecasting period increases ) . to study the characteristics of our approach , we analysed simulated ( i.e. , computer - generated ) data across a series of independent simulations . generated time series started on 1 january 2013 and ended on 30 june 2014 , with a perturbation beginning on 1 january 2014 . the data were simulated using a dynamic regression component with two covariates whose coefficients evolved according to independent random walks , @xmath165 , initialised at @xmath166 . the covariates themselves were simple sinusoids with wavelengths of 90 days and 360 days , respectively . the latent state underlying the observed data was generated using a local level that evolved according to a random walk , @xmath167 , initialised at @xmath168 . independent observation noise was sampled using @xmath169 . in summary , observations @xmath12 were generated using @xmath170 to simulate the effect of advertising , the post - intervention portion of the preceding series was multiplied by @xmath171 , where @xmath172 ( not to be confused with @xmath173 ) represented the true effect size specifying the ( uniform ) relative lift during the campaign period . an example is shown in figure [ fig : apps : synthetic : inference](a ) . prior . interval coverage . using an effect size of 10% , the plot shows the proportion of simulations in which the pointwise central 95% credible interval contained the true impact , as a function of campaign duration . intervals should contain ground truth in 95% of simulations , however much uncertainty its predictions may be associated with . error bars represent 95% credible intervals . ] to study the properties of our model , we began by considering under what circumstances we successfully detected a causal effect , that is , the statistical power or sensitivity of our approach . a related property is the probability of _ not _ detecting an absent impact , that is , specificity . we repeatedly generated data , as described above , under different true effect sizes . we then computed the posterior predictive distribution over the counterfactuals and recorded whether or not we would have concluded a causal effect . for each of the effect sizes 0% , 0.1% , 1% , 10% and 100% , a total of @xmath174 simulations were run . this number was chosen simply on the grounds that it provided reasonably tight intervals around the reported summary statistics without requiring excessive amounts of computation . in each simulation , we concluded that a causal effect was present if and only if the central 95% posterior probability interval of the cumulative effect excluded zero . the model used throughout this section comprised two structural blocks . the first one was a local level component . we placed an inverse - gamma prior on its diffusion variance with a prior estimate of @xmath175 and a prior sample size @xmath176 . the second structural block was a dynamic regression component . we placed a gamma prior with prior expectation @xmath177 on the diffusion variance of both regression coefficients . by construction , the outcome variable did not exhibit any local trends or seasonality other than the variation conveyed through the covariates . this obviated the need to include an explicit local linear trend or seasonality component in the model . in a first analysis , we considered the empirical proportion of simulations in which a causal effect had been detected . when taking into account only those simulations where the true effect size was greater than zero , these empirical proportions provide estimates of the sensitivity of the model w.r.t . the process by which the data were generated . conversely , those simulations where the campaign had no effect yield an estimate of the model s specificity . in this way , we obtained the power curve shown in figure [ fig : apps : synthetic : inference](b ) . the curve shows that , in data such as these , a market perturbation leading to a lift no larger than 1% is missed in about 90% of cases . by contrast , a perturbation that lifts market activity by 25% is correctly detected as such in most cases . in a second analysis , we assessed the coverage properties of the posterior probability intervals obtained through our model . it is desirable to use a diffuse prior on the local level component such that central 95% intervals contain ground truth in about 95% of the simulations . this coverage frequency should hold regardless of the length of the campaign period . in other words , a longer campaign should lead to posterior intervals that are appropriately widened to retain the same coverage probability as the narrower intervals obtained for shorter campaigns . this was approximately the case throughout the simulated campaign [ figure [ fig : apps : synthetic : inference](c ) ] . to study the accuracy of the point estimates supported by our approach , we repeated the preceding simulations with a fixed effect size of 10% while varying the length of the campaign . when given a quadratic loss function , the loss - minimizing point estimate is the posterior expectation of the predictive density over counterfactuals . thus , for each generated data set @xmath178 , we computed the expected causal effect for each time point , @xmath179 to quantify the discrepancy between estimated and true impact , we calculated the absolute percentage estimation error , @xmath180 this yielded an empirical distribution of absolute percentage estimation errors [ figure [ fig : apps : synthetic : acc](a ) , blue ] , showing that impact estimates become less and less accurate as the forecasting period increases . this is because , under the local linear trend model in ( [ eq : local - linear - trend ] ) , the true counterfactual activity becomes more and more likely to deviate from its expected trajectory . 2 s.e.m . ) at which predictions become less accurate as the length of the counterfactual forecasting period increases ( blue ) . the well - behaved decrease in estimation accuracy breaks down when the data are subject to a sudden structural change ( red ) , as simulated for 1 april 2014 . illustration of a structural break . the plot shows one example of the time series underlying the red curve in . on 1 april 2014 , the standard deviation of the generating random walk of the local level was tripled , causing the rapid decline in estimation accuracy seen in the red curve in . ] it is worth emphasising that all preceding results are based on the assumption that the model structure remains intact throughout the modelling period . in other words , even though the model is built around the idea of multiple ( nonstationary ) components ( i.e. , a time - varying local trend and , potentially , time - varying regression coefficients ) , this structure itself remains unchanged . if the model structure does change , estimation accuracy may suffer . we studied the impact of a changing model structure in a second simulation in which we repeated the procedure above in such a way that 90 days after the beginning of the campaign the standard deviation of the random walk governing the evolution of the regression coefficient was tripled ( now 0.03 instead of 0.01 ) . as a result , the observed data began to diverge much more quickly than before . accordingly , estimations became considerably less reliable [ figure [ fig : apps : synthetic : acc](a ) , red ] . an example of the underlying data is shown in figure [ fig : apps : synthetic : acc](b ) . the preceding simulations highlight the importance of a model that is sufficiently flexible to account for phenomena typically encountered in seasonal empirical data . this rules out entirely static models in particular ( such as multiple linear regression ) . to illustrate the practical utility of our approach , we analysed an advertising campaign run by one of google s advertisers in the united states . in particular , we inferred the campaign s causal effect on the number of times a user was directed to the advertiser s website from the google search results page . we provide a brief overview of the underlying data below [ see @xcite for additional details ] . the campaign analysed here was based on product - related ads to be displayed alongside google s search results for specific keywords . ads went live for a period of 6 consecutive weeks and were geo - targeted to a randomised set of 95 out of 190 designated market areas ( dmas ) . the most salient observable characteristic of dmas is offline sales . to produce balance in this characteristic , dmas were first rank - ordered by sales volume . pairs of regions were then randomly assigned to treatment / control . dmas provide units that can be easily supplied with distinct offerings , although this fine - grained split was not a requirement for the model . in fact , we carried out the analysis as if only one treatment region had been available ( formed by summing all treated dmas ) . this allowed us to evaluate whether our approach would yield the same results as more conventional treatment - control comparisons would have done . the outcome variable analysed here was search - related visits to the advertiser s website , consisting of organic clicks ( i.e. , clicks on a search result ) and paid clicks ( i.e. , clicks on an ad next to the search results , for which the advertiser was charged ) . since paid clicks were zero before the campaign , one might wonder why we could not simply count the number of paid clicks after the campaign had started . the reason is that paid clicks tend to cannibalise some organic clicks . since we were interested in the net effect , we worked with the total number of clicks . the first building block of the model used for the analyses in this section was a local level component . for the inverse - gamma prior on its diffusion variance we used a prior estimate of @xmath181 and a prior sample size @xmath176 . the second structural block was a static regression component . we used a spike - and - slab prior with an expected model size of @xmath182 , an expected explained variance of @xmath183 and 50 prior @xmath184 . we deliberately kept the model as simple as this . since the covariates came from a randomised experiment , we expected them to already account for any additional local linear trends and seasonal variation in the response variable . if one suspects that a more complex model might be more appropriate , one could optimise model design through bayesian model selection . here , we focus instead on comparing different sets of covariates , which is critical in counterfactual analyses regardless of the particular model structure used . model estimation was carried out using 10,000 mcmc samples . we began by applying the above model to infer the causal effect of the campaign on the time series of clicks in the treated regions . given that a set of unaffected regions was available in this analysis , the best possible set of controls was given by the untreated dmas themselves ( see below for a comparison with a purely observational alternative ) . as shown in figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : original](a ) , the model provided an excellent fit on the pre - campaign trajectory of clicks ( including a spike in `` week @xmath185 '' and a dip at the end of `` week @xmath50 '' ) . following the onset of the campaign , observations quickly began to diverge from counterfactual predictions : the actual number of clicks was consistently higher than what would have been expected in the absence of the campaign . the curves did not reconvene until one week after the end of the campaign . subtracting observed from predicted data , as we did in figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : original](b ) , resulted in a posterior estimate of the incremental lift caused by the campaign . it peaked after about three weeks into the campaign , and faded away after about one week after the end of the campaign . thus , as shown in figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : original](c ) , the campaign led to a sustained cumulative increase in total clicks ( as opposed to a mere shift of future clicks into the present or a pure cannibalization of organic clicks by paid clicks ) . specifically , the overall effect amounted to 88,400 additional clicks in the targeted regions ( posterior expectation ; rounded to three significant digits ) , that is , an increase of @xmath186 , with a central 95% credible interval of @xmath187 $ ] . to validate this estimate , we returned to the original experimental data , on which a conventional treatment - control comparison had been carried out using a two - stage linear model [ @xcite ] . this analysis had led to an estimated lift of 84,700 clicks , with a 95% confidence interval for the relative expected lift of @xmath188 $ ] . thus , with a deviation of less than 5% , the counterfactual approach had led to almost precisely the same estimate as the randomised evaluation , except for its wider intervals . the latter is expected , given that our intervals represent prediction intervals , not confidence intervals . moreover , in addition to an interval for the sum over all time points , our approach yields a full time series of pointwise intervals , which allows analysts to examine the characteristics of the temporal evolution of attributable impact . the posterior predictive intervals in figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : original](b ) widen more slowly than in the illustrative example in figure [ fig : intro : illustration ] . this is because the large number of controls available in this data set offers a much higher pre - campaign predictive strength than in the simulated data in figure [ fig : intro : illustration ] . this is not unexpected , given that controls came from a randomised experiment , and we will see that this also holds for a subsequent analysis ( see below ) that is based on yet another data source for predictors . a consequence of this is that there is little variation left to be captured by the random - walk component of the model . a reassuring finding is that the estimated counterfactual time series in figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : original](a ) eventually almost exactly rejoins the observed series , only a few days after the end of the intervention . an important characteristic of counterfactual - forecasting approaches is that they do not require a setting in which a set of controls , selected at random , was exempt from the campaign . we therefore repeated the preceding analysis in the following way : we discarded the data from all control regions and , instead , used searches for keywords related to the advertiser s industry , grouped into a handful of verticals , as covariates . in the absence of a dedicated set of control regions , such industry - related time series can be very powerful controls , as they capture not only seasonal variations but also market - specific trends and events ( though not necessarily advertiser - specific trends ) . a major strength of the controls chosen here is that time series on web searches are publicly available through google trends ( http://www.google.com/trends/ ) . this makes the approach applicable to virtually any kind of intervention . at the same time , the industry as a whole is unlikely to be moved by a single actor s activities . this precludes a positive bias in estimating the effect of the campaign that would arise if a covariate was negatively affected by the campaign . as shown in figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : observational ] , we found a cumulative lift of 85,900 clicks ( posterior expectation ) , or @xmath189 , with a @xmath190 $ ] interval . in other words , the analysis replicated almost perfectly the original analysis that had access to a randomised set of controls . one feature in the response variable which this second analysis failed to account for was a spike in clicks in the second week before the campaign onset ; this spike appeared both in treated and untreated regions and appears to be specific to this advertiser . in addition , the series of point - wise impact [ figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : observational](b ) ] is slightly more volatile than in the original analysis ( figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : original ] ) . on the other hand , the overall point estimate of 85,900 , in this case , was even closer to the randomised - design baseline ( 84,700 ; deviation ca . 1% ) than in our first analysis ( 88,400 ; deviation ca . 4% ) . in summary , the counterfactual approach effectively obviated the need for the original randomised experiment . using purely observational variables led to the same substantive conclusions . ) that had been based on a randomised design . ] to go one step further still , we analysed clicks in those regions that had been exempt from the advertising campaign . if the effect of the campaign was truly specific to treated regions , there should be no effect in the controls . to test this , we inferred the causal effect of the campaign on _ unaffected _ regions , which should _ not _ lead to a significant finding . in analogy with our second analysis , we discarded clicks in the treated regions and used searches for keywords related to the advertiser s industry as controls . . time series of clicks to the advertiser s website . pointwise ( daily ) incremental impact of the campaign on clicks . cumulative impact of the campaign on clicks . ] as summarised in figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : null ] , no significant effect was found in unaffected regions , as expected . specifically , we obtained an overall nonsignificant lift of @xmath191 in clicks with a central 95% credible interval of @xmath192 $ ] . in summary , the empirical data considered in this section showed : ( i ) a clear effect of advertising on treated regions when using randomised control regions to form the regression component , replicating previous treatment - control comparisons ( figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : original ] ) ; ( ii ) notably , an equivalent finding when discarding control regions and instead using observational searches for keywords related to the advertiser s industry as covariates ( figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : observational ] ) ; ( iii ) reassuringly , the absence of an effect of advertising on regions that were not targeted ( figure [ fig : apps : empirical : forecast : null ] ) . the increasing interest in evaluating the incremental impact of market interventions has been reflected by a growing literature on applied causal inference . with the present paper we are hoping to contribute to this literature by proposing a bayesian state - space model for obtaining a counterfactual prediction of market activity . we discuss the main features of this model below . in contrast to most previous schemes , the approach described here is fully bayesian , with regularizing or empirical priors for all hyperparameters . posterior inference gives rise to complete - data ( smoothing ) predictions that are only conditioned on past data in the treatment market and both past and present data in the control markets . thus , our model embraces a dynamic evolution of states and , optionally , coefficients ( departing from classical linear regression models with a fixed number of static regressors ) , and enables us to flexibly summarise posterior inferences . because closed - form posteriors for our model do not exist , we suggest a stochastic approximation to inference using mcmc . one convenient consequence of this is that we can reuse the samples from the posterior to obtain credible intervals for all summary statistics of interest . such statistics include , for example , the average absolute and relative effect caused by the intervention as well as its cumulative effect . posterior inference was implemented in c@xmath193 and r and , for all empirical data sets presented in section [ sec : apps : empirical ] , took less than 30 seconds on a standard linux machine . if the computational burden of sampling - based inference ever became prohibitive , one option would be to replace it by a variational bayesian approximation [ see , e.g. , @xcite ] . another way of using the proposed model is for power analyses . in particular , given past time series of market activity , we can define a point in the past to represent a hypothetical intervention and apply the model in the usual fashion . as a result , we obtain a measure of uncertainty about the response in the treated market after the beginning of the hypothetical intervention . this provides an estimate of what incremental effect would have been required to be outside of the 95% central interval of what would have happened in the absence of treatment . the model presented here subsumes several simpler models which , in consequence , lack important characteristics , but which may serve as alternatives should the full model appear too complex for the data at hand . one example is classical multiple linear regression . in principle , classical regression models go beyond difference - in - differences schemes in that they account for the full counterfactual trajectory . however , they are not suited for predicting stochastic processes beyond a few steps . this is because ordinary least - squares estimators disregard serial autocorrelation ; the static model structure does not allow for temporal variation in the coefficients ; and predictions ignore our posterior uncertainty about the parameters . put differently : classical multiple linear regression is a special case of the state - space model described here in which ( i ) the gaussian random walk of the local level has zero variance ; ( ii ) there is no local linear trend ; ( iii ) regression coefficients are static rather than time - varying ; ( iv ) ordinary least squares estimators are used which disregard posterior uncertainty about the parameters and may easily overfit the data . another special case of the counterfactual approach discussed in this paper is given by synthetic control estimators that are restricted to the class of convex combinations of predictor variables and do not include time - series effects such as trends and seasonality [ @xcite ] . relaxing this restriction means we can utilise predictors regardless of their scale , even if they are negatively correlated with the outcome series of the treated unit . other special cases include autoregressive ( ar ) and moving - average ( ma ) models . these models define autocorrelation among observations rather than latent states , thus precluding the ability to distinguish between state noise and observation noise [ @xcite ] . in the scenarios we consider , advertising is a planned perturbation of the market . this generally makes it easier to obtain plausible causal inferences than in genuinely _ observational _ studies in which the experimenter had no control about treatment [ see discussions in @xcite , robinson , mcnulty and krasno ( @xcite ) , @xcite ] . the principal problem in observational studies is endogeneity : the possibility that the observed outcome might not be the result of the treatment but of other omitted , endogenous variables . in principle , propensity scores can be used to correct for the selection bias that arises when the treatment effect is correlated with the likelihood of being treated [ @xcite ] . however , the propensity - score approach requires that exposure can be measured at the individual level , and it , too , does not guarantee valid inferences , for example , in the presence of a specific type of selection bias recently termed `` activity bias '' [ @xcite ] . counterfactual modelling approaches avoid these issues when it can be assumed that the treatment market was chosen at random . overall , we expect inferences on the causal impact of designed market interventions to play an increasingly prominent role in providing quantitative accounts of return on investment [ @xcite ] . this is because marketing resources , specifically , can only be allocated to whichever campaign elements jointly provide the greatest return on ad spend ( roas ) if we understand the causal effects of spend on sales , product adoption or user engagement . at the same time , our approach could be used for many other applications involving causal inference . examples include problems found in economics , epidemiology , biology or the political and social sciences . with the release of the causalimpact r package we hope to provide a simple framework serving all of these areas . structural time - series models are being used in an increasing number of applications at google , and we anticipate that they will prove equally useful in many analysis efforts elsewhere . the authors wish to thank jon vaver for sharing the empirical data analysed in this paper .

an important problem in econometrics and marketing is to infer the causal impact that a designed market intervention has exerted on an outcome metric over time . this paper proposes to infer causal impact on the basis of a diffusion - regression state - space model that predicts the counterfactual market response in a synthetic control that would have occurred had no intervention taken place . in contrast to classical difference - in - differences schemes , state - space models make it possible to ( i ) infer the temporal evolution of attributable impact , ( ii ) incorporate empirical priors on the parameters in a fully bayesian treatment , and ( iii ) flexibly accommodate multiple sources of variation , including local trends , seasonality and the time - varying influence of contemporaneous covariates . using a markov chain monte carlo algorithm for posterior inference , we illustrate the statistical properties of our approach on simulated data . we then demonstrate its practical utility by estimating the causal effect of an online advertising campaign on search - related site visits . we discuss the strengths and limitations of state - space models in enabling causal attribution in those settings where a randomised experiment is unavailable . the causalimpact r package provides an implementation of our approach . , , ,

0801.4454

the nonequilibrium properties of strongly correlated electron systems are a challenging subject in need of a better understanding . while experimental studies in this area face difficulties in the solid state context , ultracold quantum gases provide a controlled way to address this difficult issue . for this reason , recent experiments employing out - of - equilibrium cold atom gases in optical lattices , which allows the realization of model hamiltonians for strongly correlated particles ( for a review , see , e.g. , ref . @xcite ) , have attracted considerable attention @xcite . among the fundamental questions recently addressed in these experiments is the issue of thermalization in isolated quantum systems @xcite . in the transient regime , quantum quenches have been shown to induce a collapse and revival of coherence properties @xcite , and transport measurements in different lattice systems have unveiled the intriguing consequences of strong correlations @xcite . the important effects of interactions have been observed in the expansion of bosons in one - dimensional ( 1d ) lattices as well @xcite . in the expansion from a mott insulator ( mi ) state , quasi - condensates at finite momenta emerge @xcite , while in the hard - core regime , the expansion from a superfluid state leads to the dynamical fermionization of the bosonic momentum distribution function ( mdf ) @xcite . the latter is a generic feature of the expansion of harmonically trapped hard - core bosons in the absence of a lattice @xcite . in addition , it has been shown in ref . @xcite that , independently of the initial interaction strength , a freely expanding lieb - liniger gas always enters a strongly correlated ( hard - core like ) regime . the expansion dynamics of strongly correlated fermions , which due to the spin - degree of freedom is expected to be richer , has not yet been addressed , and it is the objective of this work . concretely , we study the expansion of two - component interacting fermions in a 1d lattice . the ground state physics of these systems is characterized by a tomonaga - luttinger ( tl ) state with power - law decaying correlations at any incommensurate filling . at half - filling , a charge gap opens and the system exhibits quasi long - range antiferromagnetic correlations @xcite . here , we wish to elucidate how the initial state of the system , being either mi or tl , affects the expansion process . identifying distinctive features for the mi is of much interest to experimentalists in the search for the fermionic mi state . however , our main objective is to shed light on the relation , if any , between these out - of - equilibrium systems and their equilibrium counterparts . as the main result of this work , we provide evidence that correlations measured in nonequilibrium are quantitatively described by appropriately chosen equilibrium reference systems . the outline of the paper is the following . first , we describe the model and the numerical procedure in sec . [ sec : model ] . section [ sec : mdf ] contains our results on the time - evolution of density profiles and the momentum distribution function for both tl and mi initial states . in sec . [ sec : gs ] , we investigate what the possible relation to equilibrium system is , and we present a comparative analysis of spin and charge correlation functions . we also comment on the validity of our findings in other models , such as the hubbard chain with a nearest - neighbor repulsion , which renders the model nonintegrable . we conclude with a summary of our results contained in sec . [ sec : sum ] . the nonequilibrium dynamics is analyzed using the adaptive time - dependent density - matrix renormalization group method ( tdmrg ) @xcite . we consider the 1d hubbard model with nearest - neighbor hopping @xmath1 and an on - site coulomb repulsion @xmath2 : @xmath3 @xmath4(@xmath5 ) is a fermion creation(annihilation ) operator acting on site @xmath6 , with ( pseudo-)spin index @xmath7 , @xmath8 is the corresponding density operator , and we define @xmath9 . @xmath10 denotes the number of sites , @xmath11 is the lattice constant , and open boundary conditions are imposed . we prepare an initial state with a filling @xmath12 that is non - vanishing in only a portion of the system by applying a confining box - potential @xmath13 . hence , we have @xmath14 , with @xmath15 for @xmath16 and @xmath17 otherwise . at time @xmath18 , we turn off @xmath19 . @xmath20 is given in units of @xmath21 , we set @xmath22 to unity . in our tdmrg runs we use a third - order trotter - suzuki time - evolution scheme with a time step of @xmath23 . the discarded weight during the time - evolution is kept below @xmath24 . to simulate the longest time scales possible on a given system size before the particles are reflected at the boundaries , we select an asymmetric set - up and , hence , particles can only expand into one direction . we have checked that the same overall picture is observed in symmetric set - ups ( see also ref . @xcite ) . = @xmath25 ; main panel : mdf ; inset : density ) ; ( b ) tl ( @xmath12=@xmath26 ) ; both at @xmath27 and plotted at times @xmath28 . note that at @xmath29 and before the right boundary is reached , the mdf exhibits only small changes . dotted line in ( b ) : mdf of a reference system ( see text in sec . [ sec : gs ] a for details ) with @xmath30 . inset in ( b ) : decay of one - particle correlations during the expansion of the mi . the @xmath20=@xmath31 curve is for a @xmath10=@xmath32 system at half - filling . dotted vertical lines in ( a ) and ( b ) denote @xmath33.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] we first discuss the properties of the mdf @xmath34 , computed from @xmath35 , where @xmath36 is the one - particle density matrix . in fig . [ fig : nk_fermi](a ) , we show the evolution of @xmath34 ( main panel ) and the density @xmath37 ( inset ) for an initial mi state . the main panel reveals a peculiar behavior of @xmath34 : as the mott insulator melts , a peak develops at a finite momentum @xmath38 . we further find that , for @xmath2 larger than the band - width @xmath39 , @xmath38 closely approaches @xmath40 . this behavior resembles that of hard- and soft - core bosons @xcite . qualitatively , we understand this in terms of an energy argument : in the mi state with @xmath41 , the total kinetic energy is close to zero . hence , particles emitted into an empty lattice have a small average kinetic energy corresponding to a momentum @xmath40 . as the fermi statistics prohibits quasi - condensation into a single momentum state , @xmath34 becomes a broad function around @xmath42 . while the initial mi state is characterized by an exponential decay of one - particle correlations , _ i.e. _ , @xmath43@xmath44@xmath45 , @xmath46=const , we find that during the expansion , the system develops power - law correlations . in the inset of fig . [ fig : nk_fermi](b ) , we compare the @xmath43 of a mi in equilibrium with the correlations that emerge during its expansion , measured within the moving cloud . the inset reveals the weak decay of correlations during the expansion , consistent with a power law . one may associate the dynamical emergence of this power law with a _ metallization _ of the moving cloud , which , after the melting of the mi , starts behaving as an inhomogeneous metal . as of now , our numerical analysis is restricted to a small number of particles and time scales of @xmath47 only , which prevents us from extracting , _ e.g. _ , exponents of the power laws . note , though , that in the case of free fermions expanding from an insulating state with @xmath48 , _ i.e. _ , a state with no off - diagonal correlations , the emergence of power laws has been established for a large number of particles and hence over substantially larger distances than in the present work @xcite . in the main panel of fig . [ fig : nk_fermi](b ) , we show the evolution of the mdf starting from a tl state with @xmath49 . in this case , the initial state has a well - defined fermi momentum and a power - law decay of correlations @xcite . such decay is preserved during the expansion . moreover , @xmath34 also exhibits a peak , but at a momentum @xmath50 ( @xmath38 increases as @xmath51 ) . another property of this peak , distinguishing it from the peak formed after the melting of the mi , is that it exhibits a much sharper edge at the large momentum side , reminiscent of a fermi edge . from the previous analysis , we conclude that if @xmath34 could be experimentally studied during the expansion in the strongly correlated regime , then the emergence of peaks at @xmath52 in the fermionic mdf would serve to identify the presence of a mott insulator in the initial state . the experimental challenge is to independently control the trapping potential and the lattice @xcite . this has been achieved in the experimental study of disordered ultracold bose gases in both 1d optical lattices @xcite and homogeneous 1d systems @xcite . at this point we would like to emphasize that the physics of our expanding system is different from the one found in theoretical studies of strongly correlated systems in 1d lattices undergoing a relaxation following a quantum quench @xcite . in the latter , correlations have been found to decay faster than with a power law ( sometimes clearly exponentially ) @xcite , while in our moving clouds we find power - law decaying correlations [ inset of fig . [ fig : nk_fermi](b ) ] . in addition , after the relaxation to a steady state , one can ask the question of what statistical ensemble may best describe physical observables , but here we are solely concerned with the transient regime , _ i.e. _ , a regime in which statistical ensembles do not provide us with insights into the behavior of physical observables . our results thus far have singled out a noticeable property of these systems during their expansion : independently of the initial ground state , power laws are observed in the nonequilibrium dynamics . in 1d systems in equilibrium , power - law correlations are only seen in the ground state , as finite temperatures introduce a cut - off at large distances , followed by an exponential decay @xcite . hence , one may wonder whether a system out of equilibrium can in some way resemble the ground state of a system in equilibrium . a natural choice for such a reference state is the ground state of a system that has exactly the same density distribution as the time evolving state , _ i.e. _ , @xmath53 for all sites @xmath6 . hence , a reference system has to be determined at each given time . we construct such reference states by self - consistently computing a set of onsite energies @xmath54 in @xmath55 with @xmath56 from eq . ( [ eq : ham ] ) such that at a desired time , the density profile @xmath57 is reproduced , while keeping @xmath1 and @xmath2 fixed . once the density has converged within an error of @xmath58 we compare quantities of interest in both systems . we now turn to the comparative analysis of correlation functions . we compute the spin - spin ( @xmath59 ) and density - density ( @xmath60 ) structure factors , which are the fourier transforms of the spin - spin ( @xmath61 ) and density - density ( @xmath62 ) correlations , respectively . the spin operator is defined as @xmath63 . in equilibrium and for a homogeneous system , @xmath59 peaks at @xmath64 while @xmath60 exhibits a kink at @xmath65 @xcite , where @xmath66 is the fermi momentum . consistently , for the two cases @xmath48 and @xmath67 shown in figs . [ fig : n1](a ) and [ fig : n1](c ) , respectively , @xmath68 [ dotted lines ] peaks at @xmath69 and @xmath70 , while @xmath60 in the case of @xmath67 has a weak kink at @xmath71 [ dotted line in fig . [ fig : n1](d ) ] . during the expansion , the peak in @xmath59 shifts to smaller momenta and the maximum is less sharp , as shown in figs . [ fig : n1](a ) and [ fig : n1](c ) [ solid lines ] . qualitatively , we understand this behavior in terms of the decrease of the average density during the expansion into the initially empty lattice , giving rise to a shift of the @xmath64 peak in @xmath59 and a broadening due to the inhomogeneity . further , we propose an operational definition of a fermi - momentum @xmath72 in the expanding clouds by taking the position of the peak in @xmath59 , yielding @xmath73 . this supports the use of the term `` metallization '' for the process that fermions escaping from a mi undergo . the density correlation @xmath60 does not show any particular features during the time - evolution , as the kink is washed out due to the inhomogeneity . @xmath60 increases monotonously with time , reflecting an increase of the overall charge fluctuations , due to the closing of the charge gap as the mi melts . our most remarkable finding , and thus the key result of this work , is the excellent agreement seen in fig . [ fig : n1 ] for @xmath59 and @xmath60 between the expanding cloud a genuine nonequilibrium situation and the inhomogeneous reference systems , which are in their ground state ( circles in fig . [ fig : n1 ] ) . we are therefore led to conclude that , during the expansion , spin and charge correlations out of equilibrium are , to a very good approximation , the same functionals of the density as the ones in equilibrium systems in the ground state . intuitively , we expect that our way of preparing the reference systems must yield properties similar to those of the moving clouds on short time scales . however , the agreement between the clouds and the equilibrium systems exists both at short and long times , and is thus preserved during the expansion into the empty lattice . a noticeable difference exists between @xmath34 of the moving clouds and @xmath34 of the corresponding reference systems . as discussed before , @xmath34 of the expanding cloud has a finite - momentum maximum , which is also present in the symmetric expansion , while @xmath34 of the reference system in its ground state is symmetric around @xmath74 [ see dotted line in fig . [ fig : nk_fermi](b ) ] . hence , observables related to @xmath34 can not be accounted for with this procedure . our previous findings on the spin and density structure factors may seem puzzling : at any given time , the sum of the kinetic , @xmath75 , and interaction energy @xmath76 of the time - evolving state is much higher than the energy of the reference system , which , having the same density profile , is in its ground state . this difference grows with time . in the case of @xmath67 and @xmath27 , we have @xmath77 , which of course is a constant in time . at @xmath78 , this splits into @xmath79 and @xmath80 . in contrast , for the reference system , we find @xmath81 , and @xmath82 , adding up to @xmath83 . thus , the main difference is due to the kinetic energies . and ( b ) the potential energy @xmath84 for the expansion from an initial tl state with @xmath27 , @xmath67 ( dashed lines ) and the corresponding reference systems ( squares ) . the plot further shows the kinetic energy of the cloud as estimated from eq . ( [ eq : est ] ) [ thick dotted line and stars ] as well as our approximate results for the kinetic energy @xmath85 associated with the center - of - mass motion of the cloud ( solid line ) . see text in sec . [ sec : erg ] for definitions and details . , scaledwidth=48.0% ] we argue that both systems can be related by a galilean transformation and , thus , understand why their structure factors are similar . this means that the difference between the kinetic energies @xmath75 and @xmath86 is mainly due to the average momentum of the moving cloud [ @xmath87 , _ i.e. _ , that @xmath88 , the latter being the kinetic energy of the particles in a reference frame moving with the cloud . to prove this , we first notice that , using the mdf , the kinetic energy can be estimated as @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the dispersion relation in the noninteracting case . this assumption leads to @xmath91 and @xmath92 , as estimates for the kinetic energy of the expanding and reference systems at @xmath78 ( @xmath67 , @xmath27 ) , respectively . both values are very close to the exact results presented before . we then compute @xmath93 at @xmath78 , which corroborates our interpretation : the energy difference is mostly due to the finite momentum of the cloud , and not due to contributions of the internal kinetic or interaction energy . this picture is further supported by fig . [ fig : erg ] that contains the time - evolution for @xmath75 , @xmath76 , @xmath86 , and @xmath85 for the parameters discussed in this section . ) ] , for : ( a ) @xmath12=@xmath94 and a harmonic trap ( 8 fermions , @xmath95=@xmath96 , @xmath2=@xmath97 ) and ( b ) @xmath12=@xmath25 ( @xmath98=@xmath99 ) . we estimate our calculation of @xmath100 to have an accuracy of @xmath101 in the worst case . inset in ( b ) : density in the leftmost site vs. time for @xmath102.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] it is next important to identify conditions for a breakdown of the reference - system description . to this end , we study the relative difference between the time - dependent and the reference systems density structure factors , @xmath103 the corresponding errors in @xmath59 are smaller than those in @xmath60 , and we thus concentrate on the latter . let us start with the initial tl . we consider two cases : first , @xmath49 in a box trap [ see fig . [ fig : n1](d ) ] . second , as such a set - up is more realistic to account for experiments , we follow the evolution of fermions escaping from a harmonic trap @xmath104 . from the results displayed in fig . [ fig : long](a ) , our key observation is that @xmath105 remains very small in both cases . hence , for an initial tl state and for both @xmath60 and @xmath59 , the description given by the equilibrium systems is very good up to the largest times simulated . we next turn to the case of an initial mi region , and present results in fig . [ fig : long](b ) for @xmath106 . the @xmath107 case is treated with exact diagonalization , after mapping the charge sector of our two - component fermion system to spinless fermions @xcite . a behavior similar to the tl case is found at times @xmath108 , with @xmath109 . however , for times after the melting of the mi region [ @xmath110 , see the inset in fig . [ fig : long](b ) ] , a substantial increase of @xmath100 becomes evident , as shown in fig . [ fig : long](b ) . thus , for the mi expansion , reference systems work well only up to the point at which the mott insulator totally melts . this deviation of the time - dependent data from the reference systems is associated to the appearance of particular coherence properties in the portion left behind by the moving cloud after the melting of the mi , a feature that is not captured by the reference systems . to substantiate this interpretation , we present results for the decay of @xmath111 in the @xmath107 limit in fig . [ fig : inf ] . in that limit , we are able to exactly treat arbitrary time scales for both large number of particles and a large system size . the data displayed in fig . [ fig : inf ] are for 500 spinless fermions expanding from a mi region into a lattice of 2000 sites . , 500 particles , @xmath48 . ( a ) decay of @xmath112 at time @xmath113 for @xmath114 ( solid line with squares ) . the dashed lines are fits to the envelope of @xmath112 using @xmath115 . note that two regions appear that are described by the same exponent @xmath116 , but a different prefactor @xmath117 . ( b ) the same as in ( a ) , but for @xmath118 ( solid line ) . note that we plot correlations for @xmath119 only . ( c ) density - density correlations measured in the reference system for @xmath113 , with @xmath114 ( solid line with squares ) and @xmath118 ( solid lines ) . the latter curve has been offset for clarity . the dashed - dotted lines are the fits from panels ( a ) and ( b ) . ( d ) density profile at time @xmath113 . vertical , dashed lines in ( a ) and ( d ) mark @xmath120 , separating the regions with different prefactors in the power - law decay of @xmath112 at the time @xmath113 considered in this plot.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] in fig . [ fig : inf ] , we measure the density - density correlations at a time @xmath113 , at which the initial fock state has already completely melted . figure [ fig : inf](d ) shows the density profile at this time and from that plot , we see that at time @xmath121 @xmath122 separates the front of fast particles from slower ones , as indicated by the vertical dashed line in the figure . panels ( a ) and ( b ) show @xmath112 for @xmath119 , and @xmath114 and @xmath118 , respectively , _ i.e. _ , measured from behind and from inside the moving front [ fig . [ fig : inf](d ) ] . while in the latter case , clearly a unique power - law decay of @xmath112 is observed , the former case is more involved . there , the envelope of the correlator also decays according to @xmath123 , yet for @xmath124 and @xmath125 , a different prefactor @xmath117 is found . these are the two regions in fig . [ fig : inf](a ) indicated by the arrows . the exponent @xmath126 is universal and expected to be @xmath127 since the luttinger parameter @xmath128 of spinless fermions is @xmath129 , but the prefactor _ in the ground - state _ is essentially a function of the average density , or the fermi momentum , respectively @xcite . the density - density correlations therefore exhibit a distinctly different behavior comparing the moving front of fast particles ( @xmath125 ) and those left behind ( @xmath124 ) . it is exactly this step - like feature , _ i.e. _ , the sudden change in the prefactor of the power law followed by @xmath112 , that is not captured by the reference systems . this is revealed in fig . [ fig : inf](c ) , which shows the @xmath130 as measured in the reference system constructed for time @xmath113 , for both @xmath114 and @xmath118 . the plot includes the fits to @xmath112 from panels ( a ) and ( b ) [ dot - dashed lines ] . while for @xmath118 , @xmath112 is well described by the reference systems , @xmath130 with @xmath114 does not show the step like feature observed in the moving cloud , as the reference systems fail to account for the separation of particles moving at different velocities . for this reasoning to apply , it is important to realize that such a separation of velocities as reflected in the two prefactors to the power - law decay is not observed in the expansion from a tl state . there , a power - law with a single pair of exponent and prefactor governs the decay of one - particle and density - density correlations @xcite . beyond the case of the hubbard model eq . ( [ eq : ham ] ) , the question arises whether non - stationary states of other model hamiltonians may as well be described by ground - state reference systems . conceptually , one may wonder whether integrability plays a role or not . , @xmath131 . the results are for the expansion from an initial state with @xmath67 and 6 particles . time - dependent data are represented with solid lines and solid symbols , the corresponding ground state reference system ones are displayed with open circles . , scaledwidth=48.0% ] while a full account of these interesting issues is beyond the scope of the present work , we wish to at least comment on one additional model , the extended hubbard model . in addition to the terms given in eq . ( [ eq : ham ] ) , this model incorporates a nearest - neighbor repulsion @xmath132 : @xmath133 the nearest - neighbor interaction both renders the system nonintegrable and induces additional phases at half - filling . for @xmath134 , the system is a mott insulator , while a large @xmath135 drives the system into a charge - density wave phase @xcite . here we focus on the numerically less demanding case of the expansion from an initial state with an incommensurate filling of @xmath67 . we postpone the discussion of the mdf to a future publication , but rather compute the spin and charge structure factors for both the expanding system and the reference systems constructed according to the prescription of sec . [ sec : ref ] . the results for @xmath27 and @xmath131 are collected in fig . [ fig : nonint ] , and we note that in this case , we consider the expansion from a box trap only . our observation is that the reference systems still provide a very good approximation to the time - dependent correlations . moreover , the agreement remains to be much better for the spin structure factor than for the charge structure factor . future work will have to clarify whether the reference system description breaks down as @xmath135 is increased . in conclusion , we find that the reference system description does not seem to be crucially dependent on integrability , and we expect a similar picture to emerge in other models . our main results have shown that starting from a mott - insulator , the temporal evolution of spin and density correlation functions are very accurately described by the ground - state of reference systems defined at each instant of time so that they have the same density distribution as the time evolving system . such a description deteriorates after the mott insulating region has totally melted . on the other hand , for systems starting with densities @xmath136 , the description with reference systems remains valid up to the largest times reached in our simulations . these results explicitely show that the correlation functions studied here are functionals of the density , a fact that is in accordance with density functional theory ( dft ) for time - dependent systems @xcite . dft considers , both for the ground state and time - dependent situations , this kind of hamiltonian @xcite : @xmath137 _ i.e. _ , one separates the hamiltonian into kinetic energy , the interaction energy due to coulomb interactions , and an external potential . we should here remark that in our case , the time - dependent external potential is discontinuous at time @xmath18 , as we use @xmath138 at time @xmath18 and @xmath139 for @xmath140 . therefore , it does not strictly comply with the assumptions needed to prove the runge - gross theorem @xcite , _ i.e. _ , the external potential needs to be analytical around @xmath18 . however , and most importantly , the reference systems explicitely provide the required functionals , namely the correlation functions in the respective ground - states . this is , to our opinion , a rather surprising and nontrivial fact that the correlations of a genuinely non - stationary state can be quantitatively described by equilibrium systems . moreover , since they are in their ground - state , this suggests that a minimum principle is at work here . as shown in sec . [ sec : nonint ] , these conclusions are not restricted to the pure hubbard - model , _ i.e. _ , they are not a consequence of integrability . therefore , we expect that they hold in general . in this work , we have identified several remarkable and unexpected properties of fermions expanding into an empty lattice . these include the emergence of coherence as well as well as an accumulation of particles at momentum @xmath40 in the expansion of particles coming from a mi region . in particular , we have shown that correlation functions of expanding , interacting fermions can be accurately described by equilibrium reference systems in their ground state . these results are expected to qualitatively carry over to other models as well , and certainly also apply to the case of hard - core bosons . we thank a. kolezhuk , a. leggett , and d. scalapino for fruitful discussions . f.h .- m . and e.d . were supported in part by the nsf grant no . dmr-0706020 and the division of materials science and engineering , u.s . doe , under contract with ut - battelle , llc . m.r . was supported by the nsf grant no . dmr-0706128 and the department of energy grant no . doe - bes de - fg02 - 06er46319 . a.m. acknowledges partial support by the dfg through sfb / trr21 . h. moritz , t. stferle , m. khl , and t. esslinger , phys . lett . * 91 * , 250402 ( 2003 ) ; h. ott , e. de mirandes , f. ferlaino , g. roati , g. modugno , and m. inguscio , _ ibid . _ * 92 * , 160601 ( 2004 ) ; c. d. fertig , k. m. ohara , j. h. huckans , s. l. rolston , w. d. phillips , and j. v. porto , _ ibid . _ * 94 * , 120403 ( 2005 ) ; j. mun , p. medley , g.k . campbell , l. g. marcassa , d.e . pritchard , and w. ketterle , _ ibid . _ * 99 * , 150604 ( 2007 ) ; n. strohmaier , y. takasu , k. gnter , r. jrdens , m. khl , h. moritz , and t. esslinger , _ ibid . _ * 99 * , 220601 ( 2007 ) . r. m. dreizler and e.k . gross , _ density functional theory _ ( springer , berlin , 1990 ) . e.k.u gross and k. burke , lect * 706 * , 1 ( 2006 ) . e. runge and e.k.u . gross , phys . lett . * 52 * , 997 ( 1984 ) .

we study the sudden expansion of strongly correlated fermions in a one - dimensional lattice , utilizing the time - dependent density - matrix renormalization group method . our focus is on the behavior of experimental observables such as the density , the momentum distribution function , and the density and spin structure factors . as our main result , we show that correlations in the transient regime can be accurately described by _ equilibrium _ reference systems . in addition , we find that the expansion from a mott insulator produces distinctive peaks in the momentum distribution function at @xmath0 , accompanied by the onset of power - law correlations .

cond-mat0012410

nonuniform growth is inherently present in a broad class of phenomena including the development of biological populations , communication networks or economic systems like incomes of persons or companies @xcite . in many cases it is obvious to assume that in a system consisting of groups or clusters of units the attachment of a new entity to one of the groups depends on the already achieved strength or size of that particular group . simon @xcite analysed a simple model of this kind where the growth probability was proportional to the cluster size and he gave exact results for the time dependent size distribution . referring to the examples of words in a book or personal incomes simon derived a power law distribution of cluster sizes . recently , in the search for an explanation of the widely observed scale invariance of large networks like the www @xcite , the internet or power networks @xcite , scientific citation @xcite the idea of preferential growth has been applied to evolving graphs @xcite . it turned out that such graphs behave remarkably : they have `` small world '' properties @xcite and the distribution of the strength of vertices ( number of edges from or to a vertex ) is scale free , provided that the probability of linking a vertex with a new one is proportional to its strength @xcite this class of models represent a new mechanism for `` self - organized criticality''@xcite . the idea of preferential growth seems to be essential in economic systems too where clustering of companies , e.g. , according to their market seem to follow such a pattern @xcite . these models have been treated by different tools including simulations , continuum or mean field theories @xcite and exact calculations @xcite by which information has been accumulated about the asymptotic behavior and the time dependence of the global distribution functions . however , much less attention has been paid to the full time - dependent solution of the problem . the aim of the present work is to give such a solution of a particular model . the paper is organized as follows . in section ii we define the model and the quantities of interest as well as we present the basic master equation . in section iii the main steps of the full time dependent analytic solution is given and the consequences for the steady state and the integrated distributions are drawn . section contains the analysis about the asymptotics and scaling . in section v we present a discussion of our results . the paper terminates with two appendices containing some details of the calculations . we model a growing system which consists of groups of different sizes . at the beginning ( @xmath5 ) we have one group with one element in it . at each time step we add a new element to the system . with probability @xmath6 it will belong to one of the existing groups . the probability that it joins the @xmath2-th group is proportional to the size of the group ( @xmath7 ) , see fig [ fig_explain ] . ( the number of elements is equal to the time , @xmath8 , because the system size is rising by one in each time step . ) with probability @xmath9 the new element will belong to a new group . the process can be described by the following master equation : [ master ] _ i(k , t ) & = & p(k-1 ) t-1 _ i(k-1,t-1 ) + p(1-k t-1 ) _ i(k , t-1 ) + + & & + ( 1-p ) _ i(k , t-1 ) + ( 1-p ) _ i-1(t-1 ) _ k,1(1-_i,1 ) , where @xmath1 is the probability that at time @xmath3 there are @xmath4 elements in the group @xmath2 , and @xmath10 is the probability that at time @xmath3 there are @xmath2 groups in the system : [ boxprob ] _ i(t ) = t-1 i-1 p^t-1-(i-1 ) ( 1-p)^i-1 . in the following we introduce some important quantities and their definitions . given the size distribution of the individual groups , @xmath1 , the size distribution of the total system can be calculated as their average : [ def_p_k , t ] ( k , t ) = 1 t _ i=1^t _ i(k , t ) . in the long time limit this quantity approximates to a stationary value : @xmath11 . the mean of the @xmath2-th group size : [ def_mean ] ( t ) = _ k=1^t - i+1 k _ i(k , t ) . the reason that the upper limit of the above sum is not infinity is that @xmath12 if @xmath13 . in the first step we calculate the group size distribution in the asymptotic case , @xmath14 . the exact analytic formula for @xmath14 was already calculated in @xcite , we present it here to see the dependence of the exponent on the parameter @xmath6 . if we sum up eq . ( [ master ] ) for @xmath15 , we get : [ recurs_p ] t ( k , t ) = ( t-1-pk ) ( k , t-1 ) + p(k-1 ) ( k-1,t-1 ) + ( 1-p)_k,1 , since : _ i-1(t-1 ) ( 1-_i,1 ) & = & 1 , + _ i(k , t-1 ) = _ i=1^t-1 _ i(k , t-1 ) & = & ( t-1 ) ( k , t-1 ) . the stationary behavior of @xmath16 , mentioned in the previous section , can be checked from eq . ( [ recurs_p ] ) . replacing the stationary quantity @xmath14 into eq . ( [ recurs_p ] ) one gets : ( k ) = -pk(k ) + p(k-1)(k-1 ) + ( 1-p ) _ k,1 , which can be solved for @xmath14 : [ p_k , inf ] ( k ) = ( k)(2 + 1 p ) ( k+1 + 1p ) 1-p 1+p_k k^-1 - 1/p . [ fig_p_k , inf ] in the model the first group has an accentuated role since it always has at least one element because of the initial conditions . therefore the master equation ( [ master ] ) for the first group ( @xmath17 ) has the following simpler form : [ i1_master ] _ 1(k , t ) = _ 1(k , t-1 ) - p t-1 k _ 1(k , t-1 ) + ( k-1 ) _ 1(k-1,t-1 ) . for @xmath18 in the above equation on the r.h.s the last term vanishes so the probability @xmath19 can be calculated easily : _ 1(1,t ) = ( t - p ) ( t ) ( 1-p ) . for @xmath20 one can prove ( see appendix [ sec_sum ] ) that the following equality holds : [ k>1_i1_biz ] _ k=1^l ( -1)^k-1 l-1 k-1 _ 1(k , t ) = ( t - lp ) ( t ) ( 1-lp ) . the analytic form of @xmath21 can be received from eq . ( [ k>1_i1_biz ] ) by multiplying both sides with @xmath22 and summing up for @xmath23 , [ pm_1,k ] _ 1(k , l=1^k ( -1)^l-1 k-1 l-1 . in the case of @xmath24 we have to look at the hole master equation ( [ master ] ) . in this case the equality ( [ k>1_i1_biz ] ) does nt hold because of the last factor in ( [ master ] ) . our assumption is that the probability @xmath1 will have a modified form : [ pm_i , k , t ] _ i(k , t ) = ^_1(k , t ) . the validity of the above form can be checked by replacing it back in eq . ( [ master ] ) , see appendix [ sec_i>1 ] . replacing the analytic formula ( [ pm_i , k , t ] ) into ( [ def_mean ] ) one gets : ( t ) = _ k=1^t - i+1 k _ l=1^k ( -1)^l-1 k-1 l-1 ( t - lp ) ( t)(1-lp ) , the two sums can be transposed @xmath25 , and @xmath26 so the mean value will have the following form : [ mean - k , t ] ( t ) = _ l=1^t - i+1 ( -1)^l-1 l t - i+2 l+1 ( t - lp ) ( t)(1-lp ) _ b = i^t ( b)(1-lp ) ( b - lp ) b-2 i-2 p^b - i ( 1-p)^i-1 . in sec . [ sec_p_k , inf ] we calculated the stationary group size distribution directly from the master equation . now we are interested in its dynamic . in order to compute that , we start from the definition ( [ def_p_k , t ] ) of @xmath16 , and replace the solution we got for @xmath1 in the previous sections ( [ pm_i , k , t ] ) . [ p_k , t _ _ ] ( k , t ) & = & 1 t _ l=1^k ( -1)^l-1 k-1 l-1 ( t - lp ) ( t)(1-lp ) transposing the two sums : @xmath27 , and taking into account that : @xmath28 one finally arrives at the time dependent distribution : [ p_k , t ] ( k , t ) = _ ( k , ) + p+lp 1+lp ] in the long time limit we will get back our result ( [ p_k , inf ] ) since the second term in @xmath29 $ ] decays for large @xmath3 values with @xmath30 , and the sum transforms into : ( k , ) = 1-p 1+p ( k)(2 + 1/p ) ( k+1 + 1/p ) . we study the @xmath31 limes of @xmath1 and @xmath32 . in the analytic formula for @xmath1 , see . ( [ pm_i , k , t ] ) , there are two components , @xmath33 and @xmath34 , that depend on the time . [ beta_pm_i , k , t ] _ i(k , t ) = ( 1-p)^i-1 _ l=1^k ( -1)^l-1 k-1 l-1 _ a(l , p , t ) _ b(i , l , p , t ) the limes of the first term , @xmath33 , can be easily calculated _ t a(l , p , t ) = 1 ( 1-lp ) t^-lp the second term in the long time limit @xmath35 will converge to a hypergeometric sum : _ t b(i , l , p , t ) = ( i , l , p ) = ( i ) ( 1-lp ) ( i - lp ) _ 2f_1(i , i-1;i - lp;p ) . for large time values the only time dependent term in ( [ beta_pm_i , k , t ] ) will be @xmath36 which in case of large @xmath3 is a fast decaying function of @xmath37 . so in the case of @xmath38 we can assume that only the first term of the sum gives non - negligible component for @xmath1 . [ pm_i , k , inf ] _ t _ i(k , t ) = t^-p ( 1-p)^i-1 ( i ) ( i - p ) _ 2f_1 ( i , i-1;i - p;p ) + o(t^-2p ) for large @xmath2 values the above formula simplifies further , because in that case @xmath39 , and @xmath40 : [ pm_inf , k , inf ] _ i(k , t ) = ( i t ) ^p to study the asymptotic behavior of @xmath41 we start from the fact , that for small @xmath4 values , @xmath42 , the individual group size distribution , @xmath1 , can be described by the first term of the sum , see eq . ( [ pm_i , k , inf ] ) , and for larger values @xmath43 it has a fast decay , fig . [ fig_pm - k , inf ] . a cut - off parameter , @xmath44 , can be defined and we can assume that ( [ def_mean ] ) transforms into [ mean_inf ] ( t ) _ k=1^k^ * k _ i(k , t ) = _ i(1,t ) k^ * ( k^ * + 1 ) 2 . the definition of @xmath44 can be done in many ways . we defined @xmath44 as the inflection point of @xmath1 , hence : [ def_k_star ] k^ * = t^p ( i,3,p ) ( i,4,p ) ( 1 - 4p ) ( 1 - 3p ) + 2 + o(t^-p)= t^p ( i-4p ) ( i-3p ) + 2 + o(t^-p ) . replacing @xmath44 into ( [ mean_inf ] ) ( t ) t^p ( 1-p)^i-1 ( i ) ( i - p ) _ 2f_1 ( i , i-1;i - p;p ) ^2 . for large @xmath2 values the above formula gets a simpler form , because in this case @xmath40 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , @xmath39 . [ mki_inf ] ( t ) _ i ( t i ) ^p in this paper we presented a simple preferential growth model consisting of a system of clusters with different sizes . we gave exact solutions for the main characteristic quantities as the distribution , @xmath1 , and the mean value , @xmath32 , of the individual group size as well as for the distribution of the average group size , @xmath16 . the question rises why are such time dependent quantities of interest since most of the asymptotic scaling behavior can be obtained with much less labor . in fact the growth models and network usually provide only a background for some dynamic process an aspect which has not yet paid enough attention to . if there is a strong separation of time scales , i.e. , the growth is much smaller than the process itself then it is satisfactory to concentrate on the asymptotics only . this is probably the case with the internet or the www . however , in some cases such a separation of scales could be approximate only or even missing and then the importance of the full time dependence becomes apparent . we expect that in certain economic processes this will be the case . an important aspect in the asymptotic scaling is universality . similarly to other preferential growth models , our system exhibits nonuniversal parameter dependent scaling : the exponents depend on the parameter @xmath0 ( the probability of creating a new group ) . it is worth mentioning that the examples quoted in the introduction also show a wide variety of scaling exponents . further interesting study would be to analyse a model where this parameter @xmath0 depends on the time of the growth . the presented system is not a network , the different groups are not linked to each other . however , for a specific value of the parameter , @xmath47 , it can be interpreted as a kind of mean field network model . the clusters then denote the different nodes , and the particles are the links . the value @xmath47 means that in average in every second time step one new group and two elements are created ( in the odd time steps the new element joins to an old group and in even time steps it will create a new group . ) the new group is the new node while the two new elements are the two ends of the new link , one is pointing to the old node , the other is to the new one . this case corresponds to the barabasi s network model with parameter @xmath48 which means that the new node connects to _ one _ old sites . for this particular parameter choice our results agree with them got for the barabasi s network model : @xmath49 , see eq . ( [ p_k , inf ] ) , and @xmath50 , see eq . ( [ mki_inf ] ) . 0.5truecm 99 r. albert , h. jeong , a. l. barabsi , nature * 401 * , 130 ( 1999 ) a. l. barabsi , r. albert science * 286 * , 509 ( 1999 ) b. a. huberman , l. a. adamic , nature * 401 * , 131 ( 1999 ) h. a. simon , biometrica * 42 * , 425 ( 1955 ) , s. n. dorogovtsev , j. f. f. mendes , a. n. samukhin , phys . rev . * 85 * , 4633 ( 2000 ) m. faloutsos , p. faloutsos , c. faloutsos , comput . comm . rev . * 29 * 251 ( 1999 ) s. redner , eur . j. b. * 4 * , 131 ( 1998 ) a. l. barabsi , nature - progress report , _ in press _ m. kochen ( ed . ) , _ the small world _ ( ablex , norwood , nj , 1989 ) , s. milgram , psychology today * 1 * , 61 ( 1967 ) , d. j. watts , s. h. strogatz , nature * 393 * , 440 ( 1998 ) p. l. krapivsky , s. redner , f. leyvraz , phys . * 85 * , 4629 ( 2000 ) p. bak : how nature works ( copernicus , new york , 1996 ) h.j.christensen : self - organized criticality ( cambridge university press , 1998 ) since the absence of characteristic sizes occurs in preferential growth at a natural choice of the parameters it can be considered as an example of soc . of course , the mechanism is totally different from that of the `` sand pile models '' . a similarity with the usual soc models is that change in some of the model parameters leads out of criticality , e.g. , the preferential growth with a nonlinear probability introduces a characteristic size @xcite . n. kiyotaki , r. wright , american economic review * 83 * , 63 ( 1993 ) a. l. barab ' asi , r. albert , and h. jeong , physica a * 272 * , 173 ( 1999 ) s. n. dorogovtsev , j. f. f. mendes , a. n. samukhin , cond - mat/0011115 , s. n. dorogovtsev , j. f. f. mendes , cond - mat/0012009 a. erdlyi , higher transcendental functions , mcgrow - hill book co. , inc . ( 1953 ) if one multiplies ( [ i1_master ] ) by @xmath51 and sums it up for @xmath52 one gets : [ k>1_i1_rekurz ] & & _ k=1^l ( -1)^k-1 l-1 k-1 _ 1(k , t ) = _ k=1^l ( -1)^k-1 l-1 k-1 _ 1(k , t-1 ) - + & & - p t-1 , where in the first term ( @xmath53 ) we detach the last term of the sum : x = _ k=1^l-1 ( -1)^k-1 k l-1 k-1 _ 1(k , t-1 ) + ( -1)^l-1 l _ 1(l , t-1 ) . taking into account that @xmath54 the second term ( @xmath55 ) can be rewritten as : y = _ k=2^l ( -1)^k-1 l-1 k-1 ( k-1 ) _ 1(k-1,t-1 ) = - _ k=1^l-1 ( -1)^k-1 ( l - k ) l-1 k-1 _ 1(k , t-1 ) . [ x_min_y ] x - y = l _ k=1^l ( -1)^k-1 l-1 k-1 _ 1(k , t-1 ) . replacing the difference , @xmath56 , back to eq . ( [ k>1_i1_rekurz ] ) one gets the time evolution of the sum : _ k=1^l ( -1)^k-1 l-1 k-1 _ 1(k , t ) = t-1-lp t-1 _ k=1^l ( -1)^k-1 l-1 k-1 _ 1(k , t-1 ) , which leads us back to our assumption ( [ k>1_i1_biz ] ) . the l.h.s of the equation after detaching the last term ( @xmath57 ) of the sum : [ 1term ] _ i(k , t ) = _ l=1^k ( -1)^l-1 k-1 l-1 p^t - i + _ l=1^k ( -1)^l-1 k-1 l-1 ( t - lp ) ( t)(1-lp ) _ b = i^t-1 ( b)(1-lp ) ( b - lp ) b-2 i-2 p^b - i . the first term of the r.h.s : [ 2term ] t-1-kp t-1 _ i(k , t-1 ) & = & ( -1)^k-1 ( t - kp ) ( t ) _ b = i^t-1 ( b ) ( b - kp ) b-2 i-2 p^b - i + + & + & t-1-kp t-1 _ l=1^k-1 ( -1)^l-1 k-1 l-1 ( t-1-lp ) ( t-1 ) _ b = i^t-1 ( b ) ( b - lp ) b-2 i-2 p^b - i , taking into account that @xmath58 , the second term will be : [ 3term ] ( k-1)p t-1 _ i(k-1,t-1 ) = p t-1 _ l=1^k-1 ( -1)^l-1 ( k - l ) k-1 l-1 ( t-1-lp ) ( t-1 ) _ b = i^t-1 ( b ) ( b - lp ) b-2 i-2 p^b - i . the sum of ( [ 2term ] ) and ( [ 3term ] ) will be : [ 23term ] & & t-1-kp t-1 _ i(k , t-1 ) + ( k-1)p t-1 _ i(k-1,t-1 ) = + & & = ( -1)^k-1 ( t - kp ) ( t ) _ b = i^t-1 ( b ) ( b - kp ) b-2 i-2 p^b - i + _ l=1^k-1 ( -1)^l-1 k-1 l-1 ( t - lp ) ( t)_b = i^t-1 ( b ) ( b - lp ) p^b - i = + & & = _ l=1^k ( -1)^l-1 k-1 l-1 ( t - lp ) ( t)_b = i^t-1 ( b ) ( b - lp ) p^b - i , which will be equal to the second term of ( [ 1term ] ) . simplifying with this term the remaining equation : p^t - i _ l=1^k ( -1)^l-1 k-1 l-1 = t-2 i-2 p^t - i _ k,1 . which is true , because the sum equals with @xmath59 .

we consider a preferential growth model where particles are added one by one to the system consisting of clusters of particles . a new particle can either form a new cluster ( with probability @xmath0 ) or join an already existing cluster with a probability proportional to the size thereof . we calculate exactly the probability @xmath1 that the size of the @xmath2-th cluster at time @xmath3 is @xmath4 . we analyze the asymptotics , the scaling properties of the size distribution and of the mean size as well as the relation of our system to recent network models . pacs numbers : 05.10.-a , 05.40.-a , 02.50.cw = 0truecm

cond-mat0305468

aging is a key aspect of the dynamics in a host of complex glassy systems @xcite . its main characteristics are a slow , sub - linear drift of macroscopic averages with the age @xmath0 of the system , i.e. the time elapsed after an initial thermal quench , and a concomitant age dependence of the correlation and response functions . the latter shows that a quasi - stationary fluctuation regime for short observation times @xmath1 is followed by off - equilibrium dynamics for @xmath2 . this behavior can be attributed to an increasing degree of thermal stability of the dynamically relevant attractors or landscape valleys as the age @xmath0 grows @xcite . within each valley , the pseudo - equilibrium fluctuations are determined by the free energy . however , the inter - valley non - equilibrium dynamics could be practically irreversible , and hence qualitatively different . adopting the simplified view that the selection is truly irreversible allows us to formulate a theoretical description of large non - equilibrium rearrangements , or ` quakes ' , which borrows from studies of non - thermal models @xcite and which supplies a basis to the striking similarity of complex dynamics seen in very different systems with multiple metastable states . the key feature is dynamical invariance to shifts in the _ logarithm _ of time . this implies that the time spent in thermally metastable attractors is power - law distributed with an exponent @xmath3 . furthermore , the distribution has a @xmath4 aging behavior , often called full or pure aging . the exponent @xmath3 depends on the system size but not on the temperature . the further assumption that the memory of the initial configuration decays as @xmath5 with the number @xmath6 of quakes leads to a power - law decay and a @xmath4 form of the correlation function for @xmath7 . the corresponding non - equilibrium exponent @xmath8 is jointly determined by @xmath3 and @xmath9 . these theoretical results are checked through extensive numerical simulations of short ranged spin glass systems . while direct experimental evidence is not yet available , possibly related large - scale irreversible rearrangements similar to quakes have recently been identified in aging colloidal gels @xcite . beyond its original macro - evolutionary context , the concept of ` punctuated equilibrium ' @xcite is applicable to any stochastic dynamics where long periods of stagnation are dotted by fast irreversible changes . this occurs e.g. in micro - evolution @xcite and in certain driven dissipative models @xcite . within a population evolving in a fitness landscape @xcite , fitness _ records _ achieved by an individual through random mutations are amplified to the macroscopic level by darwinistic selection and trigger punctuations . since the same statistics describes both punctuations and records , the analytical description available for the latter @xcite can be applied to the former . below , we discuss how thermal noise may similarly induce large and irreversible quakes in glassy systems . to summarize the basic ideas of record statistics @xcite , consider times @xmath10 and @xmath11 , and independently draw for each integer time a random number from any fixed distribution not supported on a finite set . the attempts whose outcome exceeds all previous outcomes are marked as records . for large times , the probability that @xmath6 such events occur in @xmath12 $ ] is then @xmath13^k \left [ \frac{t_w + t}{t_w } \right]^{-\alpha } , \label{logpoisson}\ ] ] where @xmath14 for a single sequence of attempts . the total number of records produced by @xmath15 independent sequences is a sum of log - poisson variables , and hence itself log - poisson distributed , with @xmath16 . equation ( [ logpoisson ] ) can be recognized as a poisson distribution with @xmath17 replacing the linear difference @xmath18 between the time arguments , or , for short , a log - poisson distribution , but the generalization to the propagator @xmath19 is straightforward and completely analogous to the standard case . ] . equation ( [ logpoisson ] ) implies that the rate of events decays as @xmath20 , while the logarithmic rate of events approaches the constant value @xmath3 for @xmath21 . glossing over the discreteness of the time arguments , we can now pick thermal noise as the ( arbitrary ) source of randomness producing the records . since landscape induced correlations are negligible if records are intercalated by long intervals spent dwelling near a local energy minimum , the number of energy records observed in a fixed time interval is expected to be proportional to a log - poisson variable @xcite . the same applies if energies are measured relative to the current lowest energy minimum , producing the energy difference henceforth referred to as a ` barrier ' . with this definition , not all barrier crossings carry physical significance . however , if quakes are log - poisson distributed , they are naturally associated with the crossing of barriers of record magnitude . two special landscape features sketched in fig.[land_sketch ] would allow barrier records to induce quakes : i ) the stability of the attractors successively selected , as gauged by e.g. an exit barrier , must only increase marginally @xcite , i.e. in principle by an infinitesimal amount . this requires that shallow attractors be predominant , and implies that the actual magnitude of the records generating the quakes is immaterial . ii ) a large and negative energy change associated to a quake , ensures its irreversibility . such changes are observed in both atomistic glass models @xcite and spin glasses @xcite , the only adjustable quantities in this landscape cartoon are the parameter @xmath3 and the form of the quake induced decorrelation . the noise independence of the statistics restricts @xmath3 to be a temperature independent quantity . an interesting increase with system size can arise in spatially extended systems , where sufficiently distant regions can evolve independently . in the sequel , we first deal with some theoretical consequences of the marginal stability of the attractors and irreversibility of the quakes . to make contact with experiments , we then summarize an empirical way to identify quakes in glassy systems @xcite and apply it to spin glasses . the distribution of the residence or trapping time @xmath22 in valleys of an energy landscape has been considered theoretically @xcite , but has not previously been measured . let @xmath23 mark the occurrence of the @xmath6th event in a log - poisson process with logarithmic rate @xmath3 . in perfect analogy to the usual poisson process , the ` log - waiting time ' @xmath24 has the exponential distribution @xmath25 which is mathematically equivalent to the event distribution given in eq . ( [ logpoisson ] ) . we now consider the distribution of the residence time @xmath26 for traps entered at @xmath27 . as @xmath28 , we find @xmath29 which corresponds to full aging behavior . equation . ( [ an_scaling ] ) with @xmath30 is plotted ( circles ) in the main panel of fig . [ residence_t ] , together with spin glass data ( lines ) . these are scaled in a slightly different manner , to account for a small but systematic deviation from full aging . the power - law form of eq . ( [ an_scaling ] ) was suggested by bouchaud @xcite , with the added and crucial assumption of an infinite average residence time . in our case , the average residence time @xmath31 is equal to @xmath32 which is finite and @xmath33 for the observed @xmath34 . as a consistency check , we note that the largest relaxation time @xmath35 in a valley must be smaller than @xmath36 , for local equilibration to apply . when the latter is of order @xmath0 , @xmath37 follows . in the lack of special symmetries @xcite , @xmath38 , where @xmath39 characterizes the short time decay of correlation functions , either as a cut - off parameter or directly as the time constant of an exponential decay . hence @xmath40 as expected . additional information on the effect of the quakes enters the calculation of thermally averaged correlations functions . let @xmath41 be the configurational overlap between the lowest energy configurations in valley @xmath42 and @xmath43 . with probability @xmath44 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 are the ` current ' attractors at times @xmath0 and @xmath45 , whence the _ non_-equilibrium part of the configurational autocorrelation function is given by @xmath46 of special interest is @xmath47 , the average overlap between the first and the ( @xmath48th valley . this is the sole contribution to eq . ( [ two - point ] ) for @xmath49 , in which case @xmath50 additionally describes the magnetization decay of the fully polarized configuration of a spin glass @xcite . the exponential form @xmath51 anticipates the results in fig . [ correlation ] . an exponential decay means that each event induces the same relative change , and leads to @xmath52 where the non - equilibrium exponent @xmath53 is given by @xmath54 equation ( [ expos ] ) thus links a dynamical exponent to the landscape geometry . the second approximate equality given in eq . ( [ expos ] ) is only justified for @xmath55 . the further assumption that @xmath41 is altogether independent of @xmath42 amounts to translational invariance with respect to @xmath42 , and hence with respect to additive shifts in the logarithm of @xmath0 . these are equivalent to a multiplicative rescaling of @xmath0 . not surprisingly , eq . ( [ two - point ] ) yields the scale invariant and full aging form @xmath56 how should valleys and quakes be concretely defined given a time sequence of data ? one approach is the protocol developed @xcite for numerical data describing isothermal relaxation after a deep quench . the basic observation is that at sufficiently low @xmath57 pseudo - equilibrium fluctuations repeatedly visit the same local energy minimum . hence , the attainment of an energy value lower than all previous values implies a non - equilibrium event , i.e. an ongoing quake . several closely spaced minima records will often occur as a quake slides downhill among which the one preceding a barrier record is likely to be the most physically significant , as it ideally coincides with a new local minimum . by the same token , in a series of barrier records corresponding to an uphill climb , the last record preceding a low energy record is most significant , as it marks the access to a new local minimum , and hence the start of a quake . the times at which the above types of event occur provide an empirical definition of both valleys and quakes . this procedure yields a null result if i ) only a single energy minimum is present ; or ii ) the initial condition is the ground state irrespective of the number of local minima present ; or iii ) all the minima and/or barriers are equal . also , iv ) if the trajectories can bypass the energy barriers and edge their way into states of lower energy through ` entropic barriers ' , the number of valleys discovered remains less or equal to one at all times . the actual outcome is very different , as illustrated in fig . [ no_valleys ] , where the estimated average and variance of the number @xmath58 of valleys visited is plotted versus the logarithm of time . an equality between variance and average is a key feature of poisson distributions . if we neglect the initial curvature , the estimated quantities are very nearly proportional to @xmath59 , indicating that @xmath58 itself is proportional to a log - poisson variable through a constant of order one . we emphasize that log - poisson statistics is an idealized low @xmath57 description , and that systematic corrections in the form of a decaying logarithmic rate of events must be expected , since each valley has a growing probability to contain the true ground state . since @xmath3 is not truly constant , the single value required by the log - poisson theory can not be estimated accurately . as @xmath57 grows , local thermal equilibration within each attractor is not granted , and low energy records lose connection to landscape minima . a check of the energy and configurational changes associated with the quakes , of the sort performed in @xcite is required to independently establish their physical relevance . we additionally checked that the low energy record configurations are close ( albeit usually not identical ) to actual valley minima . we performed extensive simulations of short - ranged ising spin glasses on cubic lattices ( @xmath60 spins ) with periodic boundary conditions and symmetric gaussian couplings with unit variance , see also @xcite . the waiting time method @xcite with single spin flip dynamics , which is dynamically equivalent to the metropolis algorithm but much faster at low @xmath57 , was used . the ` intrinsic ' and size independent time variable of this method corresponds to the number of monte carlo ( lattice ) sweeps in the metropolis as well as to the physical time of a real experiment . in all our runs , we skip the data within the first @xmath61 time units in order to let the system settle down from its random @xmath62 initial configuration . the set of data shown in fig . [ no_valleys ] was obtained for a system of linear size @xmath63 at temperature @xmath64 . numerous similar plots ( not shown ) were obtained for temperatures in the range @xmath65 , for @xmath66 and @xmath67 . in most cases @xmath68 independent runs were performed for each value of @xmath57 and @xmath69 , removing any visible statistical flutter . when @xmath3 is calculated as the logarithmic slope of the number of valleys seen on average in the time window @xmath70 $ ] , its size dependence for @xmath71 and @xmath72 is found to be @xmath73 , @xmath74 , @xmath75 and @xmath76 , respectively . while the growth clearly tapers off , we can not with confidence conclude on the true asymptotic behavior for large @xmath69 . we note , however , that @xmath77 should remain finite in the thermodynamic limit . hence , the growth of @xmath3 must either remain bounded , or be compensated by a corresponding decrease of @xmath78 . to see that the latter is likely the case , we note that @xmath79 , where @xmath80 is the hamming distance between the local minima at the bottom of consecutive ( @xmath81 ) valleys . in 3 d , @xmath82 was found in @xcite , whence , using @xmath83 one obtains the slow decay @xmath84 . in order to obtain a proper log - poisson variable , the number of valleys must be divided by @xmath85 , the ratio between variance and average , and the empirical value of @xmath3 must be similarly rescaled to the effective value @xmath86 for a @xmath87 system , and @xmath88 for a @xmath89 system . next , we analyze the distribution of the residence time @xmath22 within valleys entered at time @xmath90 $ ] for @xmath91 . the observed frequencies of the scaled quantities @xmath92 with @xmath93 are obtained from the same runs as in fig . [ no_valleys ] . they are plotted as lines in the main panel of fig . [ residence_t ] , and the excellent quality of the resulting collapse gives the false impression of a single continuous line . the same distributions are also plotted in the insert , this time with @xmath94 , which is the theoretical prediction of the log - poisson statistics . we see that while @xmath95 fails to produce a complete data collapse , it nevertheless accounts for the main features of the distribution . the corresponding theoretical prediction of eq . ( [ an_scaling ] ) with @xmath96 is given by the circles in the main panel . we finally consider the correlation decay . the overlap @xmath97for short @xmath98between the lowest lying configurations of the first and the @xmath99th valley was calculated separately for temperatures @xmath100 starting in each case from a random initial condition . in this case , data are for each @xmath57 averages over @xmath101 trajectories belonging to @xmath102 different realizations of the couplings . since no data were taken for the first @xmath61 time steps , the smallest age value considered is @xmath103 , rather than the theoretical value @xmath104 . a two parameter non - linear fit to the exponential form in eq . ( [ twoparameterfit ] ) was performed , producing the lines shown in the main panel of fig . [ correlation ] , while the actual data are given by the symbols . the main error in fitting @xmath98 is systematic and originates from the poor sampling of late events , which is dealt with by introducing a cut - off at @xmath105 . the fitted values of @xmath9 and @xmath106 vary a few percent as the position of the cut - off is varied slightly around this value . the insert of fig . [ correlation ] compares the temperature dependence of the predicted non - equilibrium exponent @xmath107 ( squares ) with the corresponding result by kisker et al . the comparison is primarily qualitative , since we are unable to determine @xmath3 with great precision . we used @xmath108 in this plot . the ( implied ) temperature dependence of @xmath78 shows that , for the same number of quakes , configurations decorrelate faster at higher temperatures , as one would expect . we note in passing that @xmath106 systematically decreases with @xmath57 , and that @xmath106 would equal the edwards - anderson order parameter if the simple exponential decay of @xmath98 were to continue indefinitely . while the exponential decorrelation form given by eq . ( [ simple_decorr])and the self - similar picture of the landscape it implies is required for full aging , it is is not likely to be exactly fulfilled on all time scales . yet it agrees with the full aging behavior observed in spin glasses @xcite , which highlights the dynamical nature of their behavior . interestingly , strong superaging behavior is found in gels @xcite . hence , either the latter systems are closer to thermal equilibrium than spin glasses , or considerable deviations from the marginal stability increase of the visited attractors occur . this project has been supported by statens naturvidenskabelige forskningsrd through a block grant and by the danish center for super computing with computer time on the horseshoe linux cluster . we are grateful to s. boettcher and to j.c . schn for useful comments and discussions .

we argue that poisson statistics in logarithmic time provides an idealized description of non - equilibrium configurational rearrangements in aging glassy systems . the description puts stringent requirements on the geometry of the metastable attractors visited at age @xmath0 . analytical implications for the residence time distributions as function of @xmath0 and the correlation functions are derived . these are verified by extensive numerical studies of short range ising spin glasses .

astro-ph9812215

recently , a paradigm has appeared to emerge according to which black - hole binaries in the hard state show weak both compton reflection ( i.e.backscattering of x - rays from a surrounding cold medium ) and associated fluorescent fe k@xmath0 lines ( as found by gierliski et al . 1997 ; ycki , done & smith 1997 , 1998 ; zdziarski et al . 1998 ; ebisawa et al . 1996 ) whereas seyfert-1 agns would universally show stronger reflection ( nandra & pounds 1994 ) and strong and broad fe k@xmath0 lines ( nandra et al . 1997 ) . if this were correct , it would certainly be of importance for our understanding of the physics of x - ray sources in accreting compact objects . we critically examine this paradigm based on available data . we concentrate on the continuum spectral properties , deferring an analysis of a more complex issue of the fe k@xmath0 fluorescent emission to a future work . here , we study the strength of compton reflection as a function of the intrinsic spectral slope . a correlation between these quantitites has originally been found in observations of gx 3394 ( ueda , ebisawa & done 1994 ) . in this work , we consider seyferts , radio galaxies , and x - ray binaries containing either black holes or weakly - magnetized neutron stars . our seyfert sample consists of ( makino et al . 1987 ) spectra ( extracted from the leicester database ) of radio - quiet ( hereafter rq ) seyfert 1s and narrow emission - line galaxies . the latter are seyferts intermediate between type 1 and 2 showing moderate x - ray absorption ( e.g. smith & done 1996 ) . this sample is basically the same as that of the classical study of spectra of seyferts of nandra & pounds ( 1994 ) . however , here we exclude 3 radio - loud agns , as there are hints that their nature is different from that of rq ones ( woniak et al . 1998 ) . on the other hand , we include some late observations of seyfert 1s not listed in nandra & pounds ( 1994 ) , which gives us 61 observations of 24 rq seyferts . we further include 2 observations of 4u 0241 + 61 , a low - redshift agn ( @xmath1 ) , which we find to be of rq type after correcting its @xmath2 magnitude for galactic extinction . finally , we include an observation of ngc 4151 contemporaneously by both and the osse detector on board of _ cgro _ , which latter data allow a determination of the strength of reflection in this strongly - absorbed bright seyfert ( zdziarski , johnson & magdziarz 1996 ) . we compare the data for seyferts with those for 4 x - ray binaries in the hard ( also called low ) state . two of them , cyg x-1 and gx 3394 , are black - hole candidates , and two , gs 1826238 and 4u 1608522 , are x - ray bursters ( thus containing weakly - magnetized neutron stars ) . for cyg x-1 , we use 5 , 3 and 4 observations from 1987 , 1990 and 1991 , respectively ( ebisawa et al . 1996 and references therein ; gierliski et al . 1997 ) . for gx 3394 , we use 5 observations out of 6 ones of ueda et al . ( 1994 ) ( excluding one in an off state ) . a spectrum of gs 1826238 ( strickman et al.1996 ) and 2 spectra of 4u 1608522 from 1990 and 1991 ( yoshida et al . 1993 ) have been extracted from the database . we use spectra from both the top ( @xmath320 kev ) and mid ( @xmath420 kev ) layers of the lac ( turner et al . 1989 ) , to which data we add a systematic error of 0.5 per cent per channel . inclusion of the mid - layer data significantly increases the effective area above 10 kev , allowing to measure the hard x - ray spectra much more accurately than with the top layer alone ( see woniak et al . 1998 ; magdziarz et al . we further select only the data with no systematic differences between the top and mid - layer spectra above 10 kev , which reduces the number of usable seyfert observations by 10 . we fit the data ( using xspec , arnaud 1996 ) with a continuum model consisting of an e - folded power law ( unless stated otherwise ) and a component due to its compton reflection ( magdziarz & zdziarski 1995 ) at a normalization , @xmath5 . in the case of an isotropic primary source and no obscuration of either the source or the reflector , @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the solid angle subtended by the reflector . we initially assume the reflector is neutral with the abundances of anders & ebihara ( 1982 ) , but allow for its ionization and/or a free fe abundance when it is statistically required . we fix the e - folding energy at 400 kev ( zdziarski et al . 1995 ) and the reflector viewing angle of seyferts at @xmath8 ( nandra et al . ( for @xmath9 , the fits below would typically give @xmath5 higher by @xmath10 per cent . ) we model the fe k@xmath0 line as a gaussian with the line flux as a free parameter , independent of reflection . this allows for resonant absorption and/or additional line components due to either matter in the line of sight ( makishima 1986 ) , scattering of a part of the primary continuum by an ionized medium ( krolik & kallman 1987 ) and/or emission of a thomson - thin torus surrounding an agn nculeus ( e.g. woniak et al . 1998 ) . then we carefully treat the low - energy part of the spectra . for each object , we initially model absorption of the above continuum by a neutral medium at the redshift of the source ( in addition to a fixed local absorber with the galactic column density ) . we then test for the effect of either replacing the neutral absorber by an ionized one , ignoring some low - energy channels , or using a broken power - law incident continuum . this is to assure that the hard x - ray power - law photon index , @xmath11 , is properly measured and not affected by either the presence of a soft excess or by complex absorption . in the case of ngc 4151 , we assume @xmath12 and fit the /osse data with a dual absorber model ( zdziarski et al . 1996 ) and a thermal - comptonization continuum model ( misra et al . , in preparation ) . the above procedure gives us @xmath5 and @xmath11 with their error contours . for seyferts , some detections are rather weak and yield very large error contours . since our main goal is to study the dependence @xmath13 , we have eliminated from the sample observations for which the 1-@xmath14 ( @xmath15 ) error contour has @xmath16 . inclusion of such data would only weakly affect our fitted dependences ( see section 3 ) but would confuse our graphical representation of the results . this criterion eliminates , in particular , all the observations of mcg 6 - 30 - 15 and mkn 335 . to improve statistics in those cases , we have coadded multiple observations of each of those objects . in the case of mkn 335 , the resulting @xmath17 was still @xmath18 , and thus we kept it out of the sample . for mcg 6 - 30 - 15 , we coadded 4 ( out of 5 ) observations that were performed in the standard mode with all the lac detectors operating , which then resulted in data with an acceptable @xmath19 . [ fig : cor ] = 17.6 cm the procedures outlined above give us 47 data sets for 23 rq agns : 4u 0241 + 61 , akn 120 , fairall 9 , ic 4329a , mcg 2 - 58 - 22 , mcg 5 - 23 - 16 , mcg 6 - 30 - 15 , mkn 509 , mkn 841 , ngc 2110 , ngc 2992 , ngc 3227 , ngc 3783 , ngc 4051 , ngc 4151 , ngc 4593 , ngc 526a , ngc 5506 , ngc 5548 , ngc 7172 , ngc 7213 , ngc 7314 and ngc 7469 . 1a shows their best - fit points in open symbols , and the corresponding 1-@xmath14 confidence contours are shown in thin solid line . for clarity , the inset shows the best - fit points ( except that of mcg 6 - 30 - 15 ) without the contours . the open circles denote rq seyferts from the sample of nandra & pounds ( 1994 ) , and the open square and triangles , ngc 4151 and 4u 0241 + 61 , respectively . we see an extremely strong correlation . at the hard end , objects with @xmath20 have almost no reflection . the reflection strength then increases with increasing @xmath11 . reflection appears to saturate at @xmath21 as our softest seyfert , mcg 6 - 30 - 15 , has @xmath21 at the best - fit @xmath22 , somewhat below an extrapolation of the trend for objects with harder spectra . we also see that ngc 4151 and 4u 0241 + 61 show rather average values of @xmath11 and @xmath5 . we checked in section 3 below that the correlation is not an artefact of our fitting procedure . indeed , although there are intrinsic @xmath5-@xmath11 correlations due to finite measurement errors for each observation , we clearly see in fig . 1a that their extents are much less ( especially for data with good statistics ) than the extent of the global correlation . objects with hard power laws and significant reflection would have reflection easily measured by due to their high count rate at @xmath23 kev . also , soft power laws without reflection would also have been measured as such by , albeit with relatively large errors . the absence of such objects in the sample strongly supports the physical reality of the correlation . we note that a similar @xmath13 correlation has been observed for ngc 5548 ( magdziarz et al . we show the contours for this object alone in fig . 1b , including one contour omitted in fig . 1a [ due to our criterion of @xmath24 , which also obeys the correlation . we also find an @xmath13 correlation for mkn 509 . we then consider hard - state x - ray binaries , for which fit results are shown by heavy contours and filled symbols in fig . the 12 filled squares correspond to cyg x-1 ( at assumed @xmath8 ) . we see that cyg x-1 has typically _ more _ reflection than average for seyferts with the same @xmath11 ( although its contours are still within the area covered by seyferts ) . although the presence of an @xmath13 correlation can not be proven from these data alone , done & ycki ( 1999 ) found such a correlation in observations by and . the filled circles in figs . 1a , c correspond to the data for gx 3394 . we fit the data as in zdziarski et al . ( 1998 ) , assuming @xmath9 . we see that the contours show a highly significant correlation themselves , as found before by ueda et al . ( 1994 ) , and that their correlation is consistent with that for average seyferts . filled triangles in fig . 1a correspond to the x - ray bursters ( at assumed @xmath25 ) . the large triangle and 2 small ones correspond to gs 1862238 and 4u 1608522 , respectively , fitted with the same model as that used for seyferts . we see that strong reflection is present at high statistical significance in both objects , and that its strength is consistent with that typical for seyferts . finally , we consider 6 observations of 5 nearby radio galaxies , 3c 111 , 3c 382 , 3c 390.3 , 3c 445 , cen a , fitted as in woniak et al . those authors find that they show significantly less reflection than the average for rq seyfert 1s . those data are shown by crosses in the inset of fig . we see that these data points still obey the overall correlation , albeit with reflection indeed much weaker than that average for rq seyferts . the correlation between @xmath5 and @xmath11 was first tested using 2 rank - order correlation tests of spearman and kendall ( press et al . we use our sample of rq seyferts but excluding mcg 6 - 30 - 15 , for which @xmath5 appears saturated . we find @xmath26 , @xmath27 with the significance levels of @xmath28 and @xmath29 being @xmath30 of @xmath31 and @xmath32 , respectively . thus , the correlation between @xmath5 and @xmath11 is indeed very strong . note , however , that those statistical methods do not take into account individual measurement errors . we have then fitted a few phenomenological functions to these data in order to express quantitatively the dependence . the best model found is a power law , @xmath33 , giving @xmath34 , @xmath35 at @xmath36 . errors along both axes were taken into account in the fitting as described in brandt ( 1997 ) . as pointed out above , the error contours for individual measurements exhibit themselves significant intrinsic correlations , which should be taken into account . direct estimates of the intrinsic correlation coefficients , @xmath37 ( as given by xspec ) , are not reliable due to an asymmetry of the covariance matrix for @xmath38 . however , this asymmetry is reflected in deviation of a contour from the shape of an ellipse with the axes parallel to the coordinate axes , and we can thus estimate @xmath37 by graphically measuring its shape . the obtained values vary from @xmath39 for contours with @xmath40 to @xmath41 for those with the strongest reflection . we then use the individual values of @xmath37 in fitting the power - law model using a method of brandt ( 1997 ) . this yields @xmath42 , @xmath43 , which is within the 1-@xmath14 confidence ranges of the @xmath44 , @xmath45 above . on the other hand , @xmath46 is substantially larger than that of the fit above . this can be interpreted as due to the area of the distorted ellipses being much smaller than that of rectangles obtained from taking the errors on @xmath11 and @xmath5 as uncorrelated . note that the latter large value of @xmath47 reflects an actual spread of values of @xmath5 for a given @xmath11 due to a range of physical conditions in the objects rather than due to measurement errors . still , @xmath5 is very strongly correlated with @xmath11 even taking into account this physical width of the correlation as well as the measurement - related correlation between the parameters . this can be quantified by fitting a constant , @xmath48 , to the data , which corresponds to the null hypothesis of the absence of a physical correlation . the fit is performed with the same method as above , i.e. , taking into account the intrinsic @xmath13 correlation . we obtain @xmath49 at @xmath50 . from comparison to @xmath47 for the corresponding power - law dependence , the probability that there is no correlation between @xmath5 and @xmath11 beyond the measurement - related one is @xmath51 , as obtained from the f - test . we note first that since at least some individual objects ( ngc 5548 , mkn 509 , gx 3394 , cyg x-1 ) exhibit an @xmath13 correlation similar to the global one , the correlation can not be due to an orientation effect ( e.g.hard objects with weak reflection being oriented edge - on ) . rather , its cause must be some feedback within the source in which the presence of a cold medium ( responsible for reflection ) affects the hardness of the x - ray spectra . a natural explanation for the feedback is that the cold medium emits soft photons that irradiate the x - ray source and serve as seeds for compton upscattering . then , the larger the effective solid angle subtended by the reflector , the stronger the flux of soft photons , and , consequently , the stronger cooling of the plasma . in the case of a thermal plasma , the larger the cooling by seed photons incident on the plasma , the softer the resulting x - ray power - law spectra . indeed , x - ray and soft -ray spectra of both seyferts and black - hole binaries in the hard state appear to be due to comptonization by thermal electrons rather than non - thermal ones ( gierliski et al . 1997 ; johnson et al . 1997 ; grove et al . 1998 ; zdziarski et al . 1996 , 1997 , 1998 ) . we consider here 2 models . in the first one , a central uniform , optically - thin , sphere with unit radius and unit luminosity is surrounded by a flat , optically - thick disc ( e.g. poutanen , krolik & ryde 1997 ) . the disc extends down to a radius @xmath52 ( fig . 2 ) . in the limit of @xmath53 , this geometry corresponds to a localized active region above the surface of an optically - thick accretion disc ( haardt , maraschi & ghisellini 1994 ; stern et al . 1995 ) . on the other hand , @xmath54 corresponds to an inner hot accretion disc ( shapiro , lightman & eardley 1976 ) , possibly advection - dominated ( e.g.abramowicz et al . 1995 ; narayan & yi 1995 ; zdziarski 1998 ) surrounded by an optically - thick outer disc . we assume that the sphere is a hot plasma radiating via thermal comptonization and the seed photons for upscattering are the reprocessed ones emitted by the cold disc . in order to compute the fraction of the emission of the sphere intercepted by the disc , we need the flux , @xmath55 , incident on the disc at a distance @xmath56 from the center . the specific intensity of radiation emitted by the sphere in a direction towards the disc is @xmath57 , where the emission coefficient is @xmath58 for a uniform sphere with unit luminosity and unit radius , and @xmath59 is the length through the sphere in this direction . then @xmath60 , where @xmath0 is the angle between the direction of an incoming ray and the disc normal , and we denoted the integral of @xmath59 as @xmath61 . by integration , we obtain , @xmath62 , & $ r<1$;\cr \left[\left(2r - r^{-1}\right)e\left(r^{-2}\right)+ 2\left(r^{-1}-r\right)k\left(r^{-2 } \right)\right ] , & $ r\geq 1$,\cr } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath63 and @xmath64 are complete elliptic integrals . the function @xmath61 has the following properties : @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , and @xmath70 ^ 2=\upi^2/3 $ ] . the luminosity of the disc is obtained by integrating the flux over the surface , @xmath71 . in particular , @xmath72 ( as expected from the isotropy of the sphere emission ) and @xmath73 ( as found by chen & halpern 1989 ) . the ratio of the luminosity of the disc to the part of the sphere luminosity radiated outward can be identified with the average strength of compton reflection , @xmath74 . the reflection albedo is relatively low , @xmath750.2 ( e.g. , magdziarz & zdziarski 1995 ) , and most of the incident flux is reradiated isotropically as soft blackbody radiation with the specific intensity @xmath76 , where @xmath77 . if the disc radiates solely the reprocessed flux , @xmath78 . the power in seed photons scattered in the sphere ( assuming a unit optical depth ) is then , @xmath79 where @xmath80 , and @xmath81 is the amplification factor of the process of thermal comptonization . we then use an estimate of beloborodov ( 1999a ) for @xmath82 , @xmath83 , where @xmath84 , 1/10 for x - ray binaries and agns , respectively . from @xmath85 $ ] and @xmath86 above , we obtain the model prediction for @xmath13 , plotted for @xmath87 and @xmath88 in a dashed curve in the inset of fig . we see that this model can reproduce the data in a middle range of @xmath11 and @xmath5 ( especially for black - hole binaries ) , but it can not reproduce @xmath89 . in fact , scattering of reflected photons in the hot plasma ( neglected in the above model ) will significantly reduce reflection for small @xmath90 , i.e. , for large @xmath11 , which reduces the maximum possible @xmath5 to a value @xmath91 ( e.g. poutanen et al . ( also , intrinsic dissipation in the disc will reduce @xmath5 for given @xmath11 . ) disc flaring ( shakura & sunyaev 1973 ; enhanced by irradiation , vrtilek et al . 1990 ) and the presence of thomson - thick molecular torii in some seyferts can increase @xmath5 . however , such torii should also be present in some seyferts with @xmath92 , contrary to our data showing @xmath93 . concluding , this model may apply to some sources but it is unlikely to account for the full range of @xmath5 observed in seyferts . another model to explain the observed range of @xmath11 and @xmath5 has been proposed by beloborodov ( 1999a , b ) . in this model , the parameter controlling the spectral shape is the bulk - motion velocity of the x - ray emitting plasma located above an accretion disc . a mildly relativistic outflow reduces the downward flux , which in turn reduces both reflection and reprocessing in the disc . the reduction of the reprocessed flux incident on the hot plasma leads to a spectral hardening ( analogously to the previous model ) . such outflows were also proposed by woniak et al . ( 1998 ) to explain the weakness of reflection in radio galaxies . on the other hand , a mildly relativistic motion directed towards the disc will enhance reflection and cooling , leading to soft spectra . beloborodov [ 1999a , eqs . ( 3 ) and ( 7 ) ] derives approximate formulae for @xmath5 and @xmath94 as functions of the bulk motion velocity . we show here the same model as in beloborodov ( 1999b ) , for @xmath87 , @xmath9 and his geometry - dependent factor , @xmath95 , by solid curve in the inset of fig . this model reproduces well the observed average @xmath13 . variations in the energy of the seed photons , the plasma temperature and optical depth ( affecting @xmath96 ) , plasma geometry and orientation from source to source can reproduce the width of the correlation . thus , this model appears fully capable to explain the observed correlation . our main finding is of a very strong correlation between the intrinsic spectral slope and the relative strength of compton reflection in seyferts . the statistical significance of the correlation is @xmath97 after removing the effect of an intrinsic correlation between those two quantities in each individual measurement . we have also found that the correlation is satisfied by hard - state spectra of 4 x - ray binaries containing either black holes or weakly - magnetized neutron stars . since that sample is limited , more data are needed to test the generality of the correlation in x - ray binaries . our general interpretation of the correlation is as follows . the x - ray and soft -ray spectra of these classes of sources are well modeled by thermal comptonization in hot plasmas , which emit power - law x - ray spectra with the slope related to the rate of cooling by incident soft photons . then , the spectral slope will be correlated with the strength of reflection provided the main source of the cooling photons is emission of the same medium that is responsible for the observed reflection . a specific model with a mildly relativistic bulk motion of the hot plasma above an accretion disk ( beloborodov 1999a ) can quantitatively explain the correlation . an observational prediction of our interpretation of the correlation in terms of plasma cooling is that objects with soft x - ray spectra should on average have lower electron temperatures than those with hard x - ray spectra . this effect might , however , be compensated for by a reduction of the temperature due to pair production , which is more efficient in hotter plasmas . the presence of the correlation strongly argues against thermal synchrotron radiation being a significant source of seed photons for comptonization in those sources . this agrees with modeling of that process showing it to be insignificant in luminous sources ( zdziarski et al . 1998 ; wardziski & zdziarski , in preparation ) . an interesting issue is whether black - hole binaries in the soft state obey the correlation . their spectra in hard x - rays are typically power laws with @xmath983 ( grove et al . no systematic studies of the presence of reflection in this state exist yet . in the case of cyg x-1 , gierliski et al . ( 1999 ) find @xmath99 , which is less than that predicted by the correlation found here . this can be explained by hard x - ray spectra in the soft state being due to emission by non - thermal plasmas ( poutanen & coppi 1998 ; gierliski et al . 1999 ) , in which case an @xmath13 correlation is _ not _ expected theoretically . this is because compton scattering by non - thermal electrons leads to a photon spectrum with the slope related to the slope of the electron distribution rather than to the cooling rate . we thank j. poutanen for valuable comments and suggestions , k. ebisawa for providing us with his data on cyg x-1 , and a. beloborodov , m. gierliski and g. wardziski for discussions . this research has been supported in part by the kbn grants 2p03c00511p0(1,4 ) and 2p03d00614 and nasa grants and contracts , and it has made use of data obtained from the leicester database and archive service at the dept . of physics and astronomy , leicester univ .

we find a very strong correlation between the intrinsic spectral slope in x - rays and the amount of compton reflection from a cold medium in seyfert agns and in hard state of x - ray binaries with either black holes or weakly - magnetized neutron stars . objects with soft intrinsic spectra show much stronger reflection than ones with hard spectra . we find that at a given spectral slope , black - hole binaries have similar or more reflection than seyferts whereas neutron - star binaries in our sample have reflection consistent with that in seyferts . the existence of the correlation implies a dominant role of the reflecting medium as a source of seed soft photons for thermal comptonization in the primary x - ray source . -0.2 cm = = = = = = = = # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupeurmn @mathgroup@bold@groupeurbn @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupmsamn @mathgroup@bold@groupmsamn = `` 019 = ' ' 016 = `` 040 = ' ' 336 = " 33e = = = = = = = = # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 = = = = = = = = [ firstpage ] accretion , accretion discs binaries : general galaxies : seyfert radiation mechanisms : thermal x - rays : galaxies x - rays : stars .

1003.3890

the possible exploration of chemical composition of planets and extraterrestrial materials @xcite by analysis of gamma spectra emitted from the surface , renewed the interest for gamma ray production cross sections in stable nuclei @xcite . the energy level structure of the stable @xmath2 has been studied extensively in the past via _ inelastic neutron scattering _ ( ins ) @xcite , and pertinent cross sections for the gamma ray production exist @xcite . however , secondary neutrons produced by primary cosmic rays have much higher energies compared to reactor ones and cross sections for gamma ray production by the use of neutrons with energies up to 150 mev were studied recently @xcite . despite @xmath3 nuclear reaction being well - explored , few publications @xcite report on relative intensities of gamma lines induced by ins on @xmath2 nuclei . pre - world war ii iron is widely used as a passive shield and 846.8 kev gamma line , induced by inelastic scattering of neutrons produced by cosmic muons , is a well - known feature in background spectra @xcite . even though detailed knowledge of all possible sources of radiation could be of crucial importance in numerous low - background experiments , the gamma radiation due to excitation of @xmath2 nuclei by inelastic scattering of muon - produced neutrons received little attention . reliable experimental studies @xcite of cross sections for @xmath3 reaction have indicated that detected intensities of gamma lines depend on incident neutron energy , and it is to be expected that the same holds for _ relative _ intensities . indeed , for incident neutron energies between 6.3 mev and 14.2 mev , relative intensity of 1238.3 kev gamma line changes by almost 80% @xcite . there are several muon - stimulated mechanisms of neutron production with significant contributions to the background @xcite : muon capture , muon - induced spallation reactions , muon - induced hadrons cascades , and photonuclear reactions ( high energy photons from a muon - induced electromagnetic cascade ) . at the earth s surface and shallow depths , the dominant neutron production mode is negative muon capture . this process occurs by stopping muons and plays a significant role @xcite because the mean energy of surface muons is about 4 gev . on the other hand , the energies of neutrons emitted after muon capture do not exceed several mev @xcite . high energy muons , also present at earth s surface in much lower arrival numbers , penetrate to the larger depths . it has been demonstrated through several background measurements in underground laboratories @xcite that the hard muon component may create neutrons with energies up to several hundred mev . the goal of this paper is to identify characteristic @xmath2 gamma lines in background spectra registered by a iron - shielded hpge detector . the relative intensities of measured gamma transitions are assessed against published results on the same gamma transitions detected in neutron beam scattering experiments . we use @xmath4 source to get the qualitative information about the average energy of muon - created neutrons in the iron shield and to infer relative intensities of gamma lines associated with scattering of muon - induced neutrons and fission neutrons . the hpge detector used in experiments is located in the low - background laboratory of the department of physics in novi sad ( 80 m amsl ) . the detector is placed inside a cube chamber made of pre - world war ii iron with a useful cube - shaped inner volume of @xmath5 . iron walls are 25 cm thick and the total mass of the shield is about 20 tons . no other passive shields were used throughout the measurements . the distance between the top of the iron shield and 30 cm thick concrete roof construction is about 3 m. iron chamber is placed on concrete base over 2 m away from walls made of bricks and wood . relative efficiency of hpge detector is 25% with the active detection volume of ge crystal being located in the center of the inner volume of the iron cube chamber . the integral background count rate for energies ranging from 20 kev to 2 mev was about 1 count per second . to get experimental evidence about relative intensities of gamma lines following de - excitation of @xmath2 nuclei after inelastic scattering of fission neutrons , @xmath4 source ( having stable neutron emission rate of @xmath6 into @xmath7 sr ) was placed at several different positions inside the iron chamber . to attenuate gamma radiation originating from @xmath4 fission products accumulated in source , solid angle of detector as seen from the californium source was screened by a layer of iron . measurements were done with uncovered @xmath4 source , as well as with the source packed in 2 cm of paraffin . in order to explore the gamma radiation produced by the interaction of neutrons with surrounding iron , long time spectra was obtained by the summing a number of background spectra , thus amounting to a total observation time of @xmath8 . the strongest gamma transition in fig . [ fig:1 ] is due to 846.8 kev background line with the measured intensity of @xmath9 . intensities of the remaining three gamma lines in fig . [ fig:1 ] have been normalized to that of 846.8 kev line and are summarized in table [ tab:1 ] . variations in detection efficiency , due to different penetration abilities of gamma photons in iron and detector itself , were accounted for at each observed energy with the help of geant4 simulations @xcite . in the first approximation , it was considered that gamma photons are emitted uniformly from a complete volume of the iron shield . however , simulations also take into account attenuation of the emitted radiation originating from the part of the iron shield that is shaded by the dewar vessel . it is interesting to note that @xmath10 gamma transition in fig . [ fig:1 ] occurs at energy that coincides with the background line of @xmath11 ( @xmath12 series member ) at 1238.1 kev . hence , intensity of @xmath2 1238.3 kev gamma line was inferred by proper decoupling and subtraction of @xmath11 contribution . namely , nine @xmath11 gamma lines in the energy interval between 609.3 kev and 1764.6 kev were used for proper efficiency calibration of our detector and for deconvolution of the 1238.1 kev @xmath11 portion from the nearby @xmath2 1238.3 kev line profile . we further note that isolated @xmath2 1810.8 kev gamma line appeared relatively weak in background spectra , whereas another line of interest at 1037.9 kev remained absent . it is the flat part of the background spectra at the place of the missing 1037.9 kev gamma line that was used in resolving the upper limit for its intensity reported in table [ tab:1 ] . .[tab:1 ] relative intensities ( in % ) of gamma transitions depopulating excited states in @xmath2 . gamma lines were detected both in the background and by the use of californium source ( see text for details ) . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] similar procedure was repeated in the case of spectra recorded with @xmath4 source located inside of the iron chamber . namely , two types of additional measurements were performed : one with uncovered californium source and the other with the source enclosed in 2 cm thick paraffin container . paraffin moderator was used primarily to reduce the mean energy of fission neutrons emitted by @xmath4 . the outcome of these measurements showed that relative intensities of @xmath2 gamma lines originating after inelastic neutron scattering do not depend on @xmath4 source position in the chamber . characteristic times of both measurements were about @xmath13 . in this relatively short period of time , intensities of background @xmath11 lines were much lower than the intensity of lines emitted from @xmath2 excited nuclei and there was no need to subtract a possible contribution due to 1238.1 kev background line . relative intensities of all three gamma lines of interest obtained in these measurements are also presented in table [ tab:1 ] . part of the energy level scheme of @xmath2 with gamma - ray lines investigated in this work . ] due to slow - down of neutrons in the paraffin , intensities of the observed gamma lines became significantly lower , however , relative intensities remained similar to those obtained with uncovered @xmath4 source . figure [ fig:2 ] juxtaposes the relative intensities of 1037.9 kev , 1238.3 kev , and 1810.8 kev gamma lines measured in our iron shield with those from neutron beam experiments . the solid squares denote results of relative intensities of gamma lines obtained in the standard neutron beam experiments . data for 6.3 mev and 7.3 mev neutrons were published by lachkar _ et al _ @xcite and 14.2 mev data are due to xiamin _ et al _ @xcite . our result acquired by the use of uncovered californium source is also given in fig . [ fig:2 ] at the adopted mean energy of 2.3 mev for @xmath4 fission neutrons . the solid horizontal lines in fig . [ fig:2 ] represent the values of the relative intensities of gamma lines measured in the background spectra whereas the dashed lines denote a 1-@xmath14 uncertainty corridor . relative intensities of gamma lines detected both in the background spectra and the spectra measured by the use of @xmath4 source . results of pertinent gamma transitions obtained in neutron beam measurements at 6.3 mev , 7.3 mev , and 14.2 mev @xcite are shown in solid squares ( see text for details ) . ] another possible source of gamma radiation emitted from the excited @xmath2 nucleus is the @xmath15 reaction where muon capture occurs without the emission of neutrons . heisinger _ et al _ @xcite estimated that about 15.7% of the overall number of muon captures in iron take place through this channel . the product of the muon capture , @xmath16 , decays to the @xmath2 and we report the relative intensities of three gamma lines of interest in the last column of table [ tab:1 ] . very weak 1238.3 kev gamma radiation emitted in the decay of @xmath16 suggests that almost all 1238.3 kev photons come from ins at @xmath17 nuclei . relatively strong gamma line of 1810.8 kev is emitted in decay of @xmath16 and it is possible that both processes , inelastic neutron scattering and decay of @xmath16 , contribute jointly to the total count rate under 1810.8 kev gamma peak in the background spectra . the evidence about possible @xmath16 involvement in measured gamma lines in the background spectra can be obtained by analysis of its high energy part . one of the strongest gamma lines in decay scheme of @xmath16 has 14.3% intensity and comes from the 2113.2 kev transition depopulating the 2959.9 kev level . the neutrons created by cosmic muons have insufficient energy to excite the 3122.9 kev level in @xmath17 , and 1037.9 kev gamma line remains unobserved in the background spectra . one can draw similar conclusion for radiative depopulation of nearby 2959.9 kev level ( not shown in fig . [ fig:2 ] ) . recent measurements by castaneda _ et al _ @xcite showed that cross sections for neutron induced 1037.9 kev and 2113.2 kev gamma ray production from iron have similar values in broad energy range . the cross sections for both transitions appear much lower compared to the cross section for production of 846.8 kev gamma transition . for example , the cross section for 846.8 kev gamma transition at the neutron energy of 6.5 mev is almost fifty times larger than the cross section for the 1037.3 kev and the 2113.2 kev transitions . in this case , the 2113.2 kev gamma line in the background spectra should originate from the decay of @xmath16 alone . unfortunately , the upper limit of the background spectra used in this study was 2 mev . thus , we had new background data accumulated in the extended range of energies with an upper limit slightly over the @xmath18 2614.5 kev gamma line , used here to calibrate the high - energy part of spectrum . however , this new spectra accrued for @xmath19 also contained no gamma lines at 2113.2 kev . flat part of continuum , at the place where the 2113.2 kev gamma line should have appeared , can serve as an estimate of possible influence that @xmath16 decay may exert on the overall intensity of the 846.8 kev @xmath17 gamma line . our measurements show that inelastic scattering of neutrons produced by cosmic muons in @xmath17 can create only three gamma lines : relatively strong 846.8 kev and pair of weak ones , 1238.3 kev and 1810.8 kev . muon - induced neutrons , as well as fission neutrons , do not produce 1037.9 kev gamma line as this transition de - excites poorly populated 3122.9 kev level . both types of neutrons , fission as well as cosmic , possess continuous energy distribution . absence of 1037.9 kev gamma line , both in the background spectra and the spectra collected by the use of californium source , clearly suggest that number of neutrons in the high - energy tail above the 3122.9 kev of both energy distributions is insufficient to produce a measurable number of 1037.9 kev photons . contrary to our findings , the previously published results shown in fig . [ fig:2 ] and obtained by the use of beams of neutrons at 6.3 mev , 7.3 mev , and 14.2 mev detected up to 10% relative intensity for 1037.9 kev gamma line . data presented in fig . [ fig:2 ] for 1238.3 kev gamma line show an apparent increase of relative intensities with different neutron energies between 6.3 mev and 14.2 mev , a trend that can be explained in terms of results reported by savin _ et al _ namely , the cross section for emission of 846.8 kev normalization line increases at energies below 3.5 mev and remains independent of neutron energy at the higher incident energies . on the other hand , cross section for emission of 1238.3 kev photons uniformly increases with the energy of incident neutrons . the energy threshold for emission of 846.8 kev gamma photons is significantly lower than energy threshold for 1238.3 kev line . hence , relative intensity of 1238.3 kev gamma line measured in the background spectra ( incapable of exciting 3122.9 kev level ) should be lower than relative intensity measured with neutrons having energies of 6.3 mev and higher . results presented in fig . [ fig:2 ] support this argument . relative intensities of 1810.8 kev gamma line show just opposite tendency from 1238.3 kev case , as can be seen in fig . [ fig:2 ] . it can be explained once again in terms of experimental results of savin _ et al _ @xcite : the cross section for production of 1810.8 kev photons has maximum at about 4 mev and at higher neutron energies uniformly decreases . unfortunately , in the background spectra of the present study 1810.8 kev gamma line appears very weak and relative intensities were determined with large statistical uncertainties . obtained values for relative intensity of 1238.3 kev gamma line , measured both in the background spectra and the spectra induced by a californium source , are mutually compatible ; in both spectra the 1037.9 kev gamma line is missing and relative intensities of 1810.8 kev gamma lines appear consistent within error margins . comparing the results of mannhart @xcite and schrder _ et @xcite , one finds that both fission neutrons and muon - induced neutrons obey similar energy distributions . further on , compatibility of our measured neutron energy spectra obtained with and without @xmath4 source suggest that the dominant mechanism for neutron production at the earth s surface is due to muon - capture . to get better experimental evidence about possible influence of @xmath16 decay on intensities of gamma lines emitted after neutron scattering in natural iron , intensity of 2113.2 kev gamma line should be acquired in long - time background spectra . the authors acknowledge financial support from the ministry of science and technological development of the republic of serbia , under the project no . 141002 ( nuclear spectroscopy and rare processes ) .

we report on the study of the intensities of several gamma lines emitted after the inelastic scattering of neutrons in @xmath0fe . neutrons were produced by cosmic muons passing the 20 t massive iron cube placed at the earth s surface and used as a passive shield for the hpge detector . relative intensities of detected gamma lines are compared with the results collected in the same iron shield by the use of @xmath1cf neutrons . assessment against the published data from neutron scattering experiments at energies up to 14 mev is also provided .

1605.07208

plasmonic nanostructures and optical metamaterials have emerged as promising candidates for controlling light - matter interactions at subwavelength from terahertz to near infrared . owing to their interesting physics and exotic properties , engineering spectral properties of light such as absorption , transmission , reflection and emission has been widely realized by manipulating amplitude , phase and polarization of independent electric and magnetic waves responses @xcite . such structures provide improved performance in established technologies such as photodectors @xcite , thermophotovoltaic solar energy conversion @xcite , thermal emitters @xcite , and biochemical sensing @xcite . in all aforementioned modern technologies , perfect black body as the main part which soaks up electromagnetic waves with arbitrary wavelength , polarization and incident angle is much more desirable @xcite . as a result , investigating novel approaches to significantly boost the absorption efficiency of black bodies trapping wideband , angle independent and polarization insensitive light has been a major concern for many researchers @xcite . amongst advanced light trapping methods , bodies based on resonant cavities have demonstrated dramatic promise , including fabry - perot cavities which can be designed by multilayer thin - film coatings to yield resonant enhancement @xcite . however , there is a trade - off between their operational bandwidth and absorption efficiency . in addition , their angle dependent optical response necessitate tracking systems in specific applications such as solar cells to maximize achieving energy @xcite . using metallic subwavelength structures supporting surface plasmons ( sps ) , i.e. , light induced collective surface electron density fluctuations at the interface between metal and dielectric , have been approved as a promising method for high efficiency energy harvesting systems @xcite . by proper structuring metalic nanoparticles @xcite , grating arrays @xcite and subwavelength slits @xcite , light can be concentrated into a thin semiconductor in the form of both localized and propagative surface plasmon polaritons . although progress in fabrication technologies at nanoscale in the past few years has facilitated the development of optical nanoantennas with various characterization such as size , shape and thickness , sharp resonance response with high quality factor nature of sps impose narrow operating bandwidths which strongly depends on the incident polarization @xcite . accordingly , to achieve a broadband optical response , several pseudo - random , periodic , and aperiodic plasmonic nanostructures have recently been proposed @xcite . in this paper , in order to achieve wideband , polarization insensitive , and angle - independent absorber over solar spectrum , we investigate absorption mechanism of an inspired fractal pattern , namely sierpinski carpet . in scattering theory , reflected , refracted or diffracted phenomena is strongly dependent on the size of scaterrer relative to the wavelength of spectrum . due to the self - similarity of fractals , different scales within the same structure are replicated resulting in multiple - band spectral response which is useful in broadband applications such as multiband antennas @xcite . moreover , fractal structures might have a larger perimeter - to - footprint ratio than its basis shape leading to reduced spaced resonant elements and compact devices @xcite . our proposed configuration consists of an array of silver nanobricks on top of a thin silicon dioxide platform . the proposed experimentally feasible metallo - dielectric super absorber is capable of absorbing light in the visible spectrum ( @xmath3-@xmath4 nm ) with a simulated average absorption more than @xmath5% . performing three - dimensional ( 3d ) simulations based on finite integration technique ( fit ) , we theoretically investigate the effect of propagative and localized plasmon modes and localized magnetic and electric dipole resonances on enhancing the efficiency of proposed light trapping structure . these results suggest alternative schemes for design and improvement of subwavelength high performance optical absorbers , sensors and thermal emitters . a schematic image of our proposed broadband absorber is shown in fig . as it is observed , each unit cell consists of a three - layer metal - dielectric - metal ( mdm ) thin - film where a silicon dioxide substrate with thickness @xmath6 is settled on a thick silver backreflector with thickness @xmath7 needed to reflect the incident light back and extends the absorption thickness . the top plasmonic layer is formed in a way that a fractal - like pattern of silver nanobricks is appeared . this pseudo - similar geometrical shape , namely sierpinski carpet , is constructed with a square of side width @xmath8 and height @xmath9 ( fig . [ fig2](a ) ) ; then divided into a grid of @xmath10 smaller cuboids with width of @xmath11 and height of @xmath12 , and only the central sub - square is remained(fig . [ fig2](b ) ) . the same procedure is then recursively applied to the eight side squares . we continue this process up to the second iteration as shown in fig . [ fig2](c ) in which all dimensions are compatible with the current nanotechnology fabrication limitations . the dielectric function of silver and refractive index of silicon dioxide are taken from experimental results @xcite , respectively , and inserted into the cst microwave studio commercial software package . periodic boundary conditions are applied in @xmath13 and @xmath14 directions , and the ports at the front and back surfaces of the unit cell are set for the optical ray incidence , reflection and transmission . furthermore , to consider strong interactions between metal and silicon dioxide , an extremely refined mesh is constructed for the whole structure . we first perform numerical computations to investigate the relationship between the absorption spectrum , lattice constant and dielectric spacer thickness . due to the nature of fractal - like structures , the optimal width of all metal nanocuboids will be achieved automatically by obtaining the optimum lattice constant . other design parameters are chosen in a manner to be subwavelength and practicable . it is notable that sensitivity of the absorption response to these parameters can also be readily explored . now , consider a plane wave impinges toward the structure shown in fig . [ fig1](b ) at normal incidence . [ fig3 ] presents the optical extinction spectrum of the structure for verious values of @xmath8 and @xmath6 while other geometric parameters are chosen as @xmath15 , @xmath16 nm , @xmath17 nm and @xmath18 . optical extinction is defined by @xmath19 in which @xmath20 and @xmath21 are frequency - dependent total transmittance and reflectance from the mdm absorber , respectively . it is notable that using an optically thick silver backreflector hinders light transmission and approximately reduces the optical extinction to @xmath22 . obviously , the lower the amount of the @xmath21 and @xmath20 , the higher the performance of the absorber . it should be noted that reflectance @xmath21 can be readily obtained from the @xmath23-parameters @xmath24 . moreover , since the operating wavelength window is at least @xmath25 times larger than the lattice constant of the unit cell , no higher order diffraction is considered due to the subwavelength characterization of each unit cell . an optimal thickness of the dielectric layer exists which maximizes the extinction . with the aforementioned geometry parameters , when @xmath26 nm , the reflectance has its minimum values in most wavelengths resulting in higher average absorption . for the present geometry , absorption is mainly attributed to metal losses and plasmon coupling between the silver nanocuboids and the backreflector . by increasing the thickness of the dielectric layer , coupling strength will be enhanced first until reaching its maximum value , then decreases thereafter @xcite . when the nanocuboids array resides far away from the silver backreflector , the optical extinction of such system is dominantly determined by the dielectric layer properties @xcite . to investigate the electromagnetic wave trapping in the dielectric layer and plasmonic fractal , we first break down the fractal - like structure into two base - periodicity patterns as shown in fig . [ fig4 ] . by exploring the underlying mechanism of these two simple individual patterns , physical analysis of the main complex unit cell can readily be revealed . the corresponding calculated extinction spectra over the wavelength window ( @xmath0 nm ) are depicted in fig . [ fig4 ] . to disclose the physical origin of the absorption , the electromagnetic field distributions for these resonant modes should be first presented . as fig . [ fig4 ] shows , two distinct peaks observed for the first base - periodicity pattern : one is around the wavelength @xmath27 nm and the other is about @xmath28 nm . these peaks are attributed to the electric / magnetic dipolar resonances and the presence of surface plasmon modes ; although , contribution of parasitic absorption of silver nanocuboids and backreflector plays an important role in enhancement of optical extinction . for the absorption peak at @xmath29 , the electric displacement vectors are represented by the arrows in both of nanocuboids and the backreflector ( fig . [ fig6](a ) ) . this opposite electric displacement generates circulating currents between the top and bottom plasmonic layers . such circulating current , namely magnetic resonance leads to an artificial magnetic moment that interacts significantly with the magnetic field of the incident light @xcite . as a result , an intense enhancement of the localized electromagnetic fields is emerged between the two plasmonic layers as shown in fig . [ fig6](b ) by surface colormap . furthermore , the electric field distribution amplitude and polarization plotted in fig . [ fig6](c ) and fig . [ fig6](d ) imply that the accumulated charges at the both sides of nanocuboids which couple to their image charges in the silver backreflector generate strong electric dipole resonances . as a result , such strong resonances trap and confine incident electromagnetic energy efficiently to the intermediate dielectric spacer and provide enough time to be dissipated as heat due to the ohmic losses within the plasmonic section . the feature of enhanced absorption is further illustrated with the time - averaged resistive loss density for the absorption peaks . [ fig6](e ) depicts that a large portion of incident power is absorbed by the plasmonic nanocuboids and the silver backreflector . the absorption peak at @xmath30 is related to the excitation of sp modes at the interface between the silicon dioxide dielectric spacer and the ground mirror due to the coupling effect of periodic top silver nanocuboids . the main advantage of sp modes is their tunability by adjusting the the shape and size of subwavelength plasmonic structures . it is worth mentioning that at larger periods , the metal nanocuboids array will excite lower - energy modes by providing smaller momenta @xcite . [ fig6](f ) and fig . [ fig6](g ) depict that the magnetic and electric fields are mainly confined at the silicon dioxide / silver interface which confirms the typical feature of interface - bounded sp modes . furthermore , as shown in figs . [ fig6](h ) , high electric field intensity around the metal edges implies the existence of localized surface plasmon mode . such an anti - phase electric field distribution is induced by the accumulation of opposite charges at the tips of silver nanopatterns . due to the strong coupling of resonant electric modes excited at sharp corners of nanocuboids , electric field is significantly boosted between the gap of adjacent metallic nanoparticles . [ fig6](i ) illustrates that power dissipation due to resistive loss almost occurs in the nanocubids . for the case of @xmath10 small nanocuboids array shown in fig . [ fig4 ] , two peaks are emerged at @xmath31 nm and @xmath32 nm . as fig . [ fig8](a ) and fig . [ fig8](b ) depict , cavity mode which comes from the interaction between the incident light and the reflected light from silver back reflector is appeared at @xmath33 . such a cavity mode confirms the fabry - perot resonance at the longitudinal cavities which is independent of the plasmonic effect and is determined by the dielectric spacer thickness @xcite . the physical mechanism of absorption at @xmath34 is similar to @xmath29 ; the electric field is mainly confined in the corner areas of the silver nanocuboids and the inside area of the intermediate dielectric . [ fig8](f ) demonstrates the significant amount of charge in the corner areas of the top metallic section which verifies the excitation of the electric dipolar resonances . furthermore , as fig . [ fig8](a ) depicts the anti - parallel current creating a loop between the silver nanosquares array and the bottom silver film . this loops gives rise to artificial magnetic dipole moments that interact strongly with the incident magnetic field . by revealing the fundamental mechanism of extinction in our proposed fractal - like absorber ( fig . [ fig1 ] ) , now , we focus on robustness of the absorption spectrum against oblique incident angles . since the whole structure is symmetric in @xmath13 and @xmath14 directions , we expect approximately similar responses for both transverse - magnetic ( tm ) and transverse - electric ( te ) polarized electromagnetic waves under oblique incident . to this end , a further study of polarization and angle dependent performance of the absorption is performed . [ fig10](a ) and fig . [ fig10](b ) present the absorption behaviors of the broadband absorption under a tuning oblique incidence with tm and te polarization states , respectively . it is observed that the proposed absorber accomplishes absorptance higher than @xmath35% in a wide angle range over almost the entire solar spectrum . such polarization - independent and incident angle insensitive broadband light absorption is achieved due to the symmetry structural feature of fractal - like pattern and excitation of localized resonances in the system . in summary , we numerically demonstrated a broadband , polarization - insensitive and wide - angle plasmonic absorber with top silver fractal - like pattern in the form of sierpinski nanocarpets . simulation results demonstrated average extinction of @xmath5% in the spectral range of @xmath0 nm due to the self - similarity property in the plasmonic fractal . moreover , the extinction spectra show substantial overlap between both te and tm - polarized electromagnetic waves in a wide range of incident angles . physical interpretation of the underlying mechanism of absorption was carried out through simulation of magnetic field , electric field , and displacement current for the two - base periodicity patterns of main structure . it was well revealed that broadband absorption profile is attributed to the excited cavity modes , sp modes , and electric / magnetic dipoles . the proposed configuration is a promising candidate for enhancing light trapping in sensing and camouflage applications . atwater , h. a. ; polman , a. _ nature materials _ * 2010 * , _ 9 _ , 205213 schuller , j. a. ; barnard , e. s. ; cai , w. ; jun , y. c. ; white , j. s. ; brongersma , m. l. _ nature materials _ * 2010 * , _ 9 _ , 193204 abdollahramezani , s. ; arik , k. ; khavasi , a. ; kavehvash , z. _ optics letters _ * 2015 * , _ 40 _ , 52395242 abdollahramezani , s. ; arik , k. ; farajollahi , s. ; khavasi , a. ; kavehvash , z. _ optics letters _ * 2015 * , _ 40 _ , 53835386 youssefi , a. ; zangeneh - nejad , f. ; abdollahramezani , s. ; khavasi , a. _ arxiv preprint arxiv:1604.07368 _ * 2016 * , lopez - sanchez , o. ; lembke , d. ; kayci , m. ; radenovic , a. ; kis , a. _ nature nanotechnology _ * 2013 * , _ 8 _ , 497501 avitzour , y. ; urzhumov , y. a. ; shvets , g. _ physical review b _ * 2009 * , _ 79 _ , 045131 greffet , j .- j . ; carminati , r. ; joulain , k. ; mulet , j .- p . ; mainguy , s. ; chen , y. _ nature _ * 2002 * , _ 416 _ , 6164 liu , n. ; mesch , m. ; weiss , t. ; hentschel , m. ; giessen , h. _ nano letters _ * 2010 * , _ 10 _ , 23422348 kravets , v. ; schedin , f. ; grigorenko , a. _ physical review b _ * 2008 * , _ 78 _ , 205405 narimanov , e. e. ; kildishev , a. v. _ applied physics letters _ * 2009 * , _ 95 _ , 041106 aydin , k. ; ferry , v. e. ; briggs , r. m. ; atwater , h. a. _ nature communications _ * 2011 * , _ 2 _ , 517 watts , c. m. ; liu , x. ; padilla , w. j. _ advanced materials _ * 2012 * , _ 24 _ cao , l. ; fan , p. ; vasudev , a. p. ; white , j. s. ; yu , z. ; cai , w. ; schuller , j. a. ; fan , s. ; brongersma , m. l. _ nano letters _ * 2010 * , _ 10 _ , 439445 landy , n. ; sajuyigbe , s. ; mock , j. ; smith , d. ; padilla , w. _ physical review letters _ * 2008 * , _ 100 _ , 207402 teperik , t. v. ; de abajo , f. g. ; borisov , a. ; abdelsalam , m. ; bartlett , p. ; sugawara , y. ; baumberg , j. _ nature photonics _ * 2008 * , _ 2 _ , 299301 bouchon , p. ; koechlin , c. ; pardo , f. ; hadar , r. ; pelouard , j .- l . _ optics letters _ * 2012 * , _ 37 _ , 10381040 white , j. s. ; veronis , g. ; yu , z. ; barnard , e. s. ; chandran , a. ; fan , s. ; brongersma , m. l. _ optics letters _ * 2009 * , _ 34 _ , 686688 cui , y. ; he , y. ; jin , y. ; ding , f. ; yang , l. ; ye , y. ; zhong , s. ; lin , y. ; he , s. _ laser & photonics reviews _ * 2014 * , _ 8 _ , 495520 yan , m. ; dai , j. ; qiu , m. _ journal of optics _ * 2014 * , _ 16 _ , 025002 pala , r. a. ; white , j. ; barnard , e. ; liu , j. ; brongersma , m. l. _ advanced materials _ * 2009 * , _ 21 _ , 35043509 ding , f. ; cui , y. ; ge , x. ; jin , y. ; he , s. _ applied physics letters _ * 2012 * , _ 100 _ , 103506 zhang , b. ; zhao , y. ; hao , q. ; kiraly , b. ; khoo , i .- c . ; chen , s. ; huang , t. j. _ optics express _ * 2011 * , _ 19 _ , 1522115228 werner , d. h. ; ganguly , s. _ antennas and propagation magazine , ieee _ * 2003 * , _ 45 _ , 3857 sederberg , s. ; elezzabi , a. _ optics express _ * 2011 * , _ 19 _ , 1045610461 johnson , p. b. ; christy , r .- w . _ physical review b _ * 1972 * , _ 6 _ , 4370 palik , e. d. _ handbook of optical constants of solids _ ; academic press , 1998 ; vol . 3 hao , j. ; wang , j. ; liu , x. ; padilla , w. j. ; zhou , l. ; qiu , m. _ applied physics letters _ * 2010 * , _ 96 _ , 251104 lvque , g. ; martin , o. j. _ optics letters _ * 2006 * , _ 31 _ , 27502752 liu , h. ; liu , k. ; wang , l. ; jiang , s. ; zeng , w. _ photonics technology letters , ieee _ * 2015 * , _ 27 _ , 786789 zhu , l .- h . ; shao , m .- r . ; peng , r .- w . ; fan , r .- h . ; huang , x .- r . ; wang , m. _ optics express _ * 2013 * , _ 21 _ , a313a323 ) and dielectric spacer thickness ( @xmath6 ) at normal incidence . thickness of the silver backreflector and the central nanobrick are chosen as @xmath17 nm and @xmath36 nm , respectively . , title="fig:",width=627 ] +

in this paper , a plasmonic absorber consisting of a metal - dielectric - metal stack with a top layer of sierpinski nanocarpet is theoretically investigated . such compact absorber depicts broadband angle - independent behavior over a wide optical wavelength range ( @xmath0 nm ) and a broad range of angles of light incidence ( @xmath1 ) . including several feature sizes , such fractal - like structure shows widely strong extinction ( @xmath2% ) response for either transverse electric or magnetic polarization states under normal incidence . underlying mechanisms of absorbance due to excited surface plasmon modes as well as electric / magnetic dipole resonances are well revealed by investigating electric field , magnetic field and current distributions . the proposed absorber opens a path to realize high - performance ultrathin light trapping devices .

1207.6443

neutrinos have masses , the tiny masses far below the range of the masses of the quarks and charged leptons . maybe due to the non - zero masses , neutrinos oscillate among themselves , giving rise to a lepton - flavor violation ( lfv ) . neutrino masses and neutrino oscillations may be regarded as one of the most important experimental facts over the last thirty years @xcite . certain lfv processes such as @xmath0 @xcite and @xmath1 are closely related to the most cited picture of neutrino oscillations so far @xcite - they also occur , however tiny , if neutrinos oscillate . in this note , i wish to point out that the cross - generation or off - diagonal neutrino - higgs interaction may serve as the detailed mechanism of neutrino oscillations , with some vacuum expectation value ( vev ) of the new higgs field(s ) . presumably just like other building blocks of matter such as quarks and charged leptons , we could treat these neutrinos as point - like dirac particles . then , neutrino oscillations are fundamental and deep , certainly deeper than oscillations in other composite systems - such as oscillations in the @xmath2 system . thus , it would be natural to describe the reaction as @xmath3 with some vev for the family higgs field @xmath4 , where @xmath5 and @xmath6 are family - triplet dirac fields . here the curl - dot product is to be explained later . the existence of this unique story for neutrino oscillations is amazing . for over half a century , we have the outstanding question why there are three generations in the minimal standard model @xcite . and , for the last decade , another outstanding puzzle emerges that the dark - matter world is about five times the visual ordinary - matter world ( the latter described by the minimal standard model ) . besides the role in the minimal standard model , neutrinos may be able to tell us something in the dark - matter world which our neutrinos are capable of talking to ( or interacting with ) . indeed , there is room left for something very interesting . remember that the right - handed neutrinos never enter in the construction of the minimal standard model @xcite . the message that the right - handed neutrinos seem to be `` unwanted '' could be telling us something . now , the fact that neutrinos have tiny masses suggests that `` more naturally '' they would be four - component dirac particles , and unlikely to be the two - component majorana particles . the room left for the right - handed neutrinos is that they are `` unwanted '' in the minimal standard model and that they could form some multiplet(s ) under a new ( dark - matter ) gauge group besides the minimal standard model . we have some candidate from the symmetries - the family symmetry that there are three generations in the building blocks of ( ordinary ) matter , and so far only three . the puzzle so well - known that we no longer question ourselves why or why not ! we have seen this fact , but we do nt know why - let s speculate that it could be the story associated with the dark - matter world . it arises naturally the so - called family gauge theory @xcite . note that the right - handed neutrinos do not appear in the minimal standard model . so , we could make a massive @xmath7 gauge theory completely independent of the minimal standard model , including the particle content . we could treat @xmath8 as a triplet under this @xmath7 - so to give rise to a family gauge theory . this completes the derivation of the family gauge theory @xcite . the @xmath7 is by definition the massive gauge theory - all the involved particles , except the neutrinos , are massive dark - matter particles . so , the question becomes : can we construct the overall consistent theory based on the group @xmath9 , i.e. , to add an extra @xmath7 to the minimal standard model ? the answer is an amazing `` yes '' . the first step is to decide what our `` basic units '' ( out of the building blocks of matter ) are and how many they are . for instance , the right - handed neutrino triplet @xmath8 ( @xmath10 - @xmath7 triplet and @xmath11 singlet ) would be a `` basic unit '' . in hwang and yan @xcite , we assign three @xmath7 fermion triplets - @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 ( charged ) . all quarks are singlets under @xmath7 . as the major second step , we have to check whether the complicated higgs mechanisms would work out . this is the `` amazing '' part of the story . in the extended standard model @xcite , we have three scalar / higgs fields : the standard - model higgs @xmath15 , the family higgs triplet @xmath16 , and the mixed family - triplet and @xmath11-doublet scalar / higgs @xmath17 . in the u - gauge , the standard - model higgs picks out the neutral component ( one degree of freedom ) , which in turn projects out the neutral components in @xmath17 such that the neutral part has the spontaneous symmetry breaking ( i.e. the `` projected - out higgs mechanism '' ) but the charged part remains to be massive . the neutral part of @xmath17 and the family higgs @xmath16 make the eight gauge bosons very massive , leaving four real family higgs . using this language @xcite , we can write the mass term of the neutrinos : @xmath18 which is an off - diagonal matrix ( in @xmath7 ) . although it is trivial , the operation does not belong to the mathematics of the matrix . that is , @xmath19 would transform into @xmath20 or into @xmath21 , @xmath20 would into @xmath21 or @xmath19 , and so on . this is interesting in view of neutrino oscillations , since it could be regarded as the underlying interaction ( mechanism ) for neutrino oscillations ( which we are talking about @xcite ) . an oscillation occurs in a way similar to the decay by way of creating a new species plus the vacuum expectation value ( or , changing the vacuum ) . in quantum mechanics , this may be so far the only way how an oscillation can occur . to illustrate the point further , we calculate the golden lepton - flavor - violating decay @xmath0 as the celebrated example . we show in figures 1(a ) , 1(b ) , and 1(c ) three leading basic feynman diagrams . here the conversion of @xmath20 into @xmath19 is marked by a cross sign and it is a term from our off - diagonal interaction given above with the higgs vacuum expectation values @xmath22 and @xmath23 . here the higgs masses are assumed to be very large , i.e. , greater than a few @xmath24 , as in @xmath7 . the only small number ( coupling ) is @xmath25 , explaining the tiny masses of neutrinos . .,width=384 ] using feynman rules from wu and hwang @xcite , we write , for fig . 1(a ) , @xmath26 with @xmath27 . on the other hand , feynman rules yield , for fig . 1(b ) , @xmath28 and a similar result for fig . the four - dimensional integrations can be carried out , via the dimensional integration formulae ( e.g. ch . 10 , wu / hwang @xcite ) , especially if we drop the small masses compared to the w - boson mass @xmath29 in the denominator . in this way , we obtain @xmath30 it is interesting to note that the wave - function renormalization , as shown by figs . 1(b ) and 1(c ) , yields @xmath31 noting that @xmath32 and @xmath33 would make the contribution from figs . 1(b ) and 1(c ) to be the same as , but opposite in sign , that from fig . this is a manifestation of `` gauge invariance '' . in a normal treatment , one ignores the wave - function renormalization diagrams 1(b ) and 1(c ) in the treatment of the decays @xmath0 , @xmath34 , and @xmath35 . thus , one may ignore some important cancelation , if any . comparing this to the dominant mode @xmath36 @xcite , we could obtain the branching ratio . the decay rate for @xmath37 , as would be obtained here , would be of the order @xmath38 , which is extremely small . the off - diagonal mass matrix would be modified by the self - energy diagram since the neutrinos form a triplet under @xmath7 . it is presumed that these self - energy diagrams , after the ultraviolet divergences get subtracted , lead to masses of the right order . the four family higgs have to belong to two triplets - the neutral part of @xmath17 and the purely family higgs @xmath16 . if it is two - two divided such as that addressed in @xcite , then the situation would be as follows : if the off - diagonal mass matrix is diagonalized alone , the three roots would be two negative and one positive , adding up to zero . this seems like one ordering in the masses of neutrinos - one up and two downs . of course , it could be three - one divided as well . besides the golden decay @xmath37 ( much too small ) and neutrino oscillations ( already observed ) , violation of the @xmath39 universality is also anticipated and might be observed . as the baryon - antibaryon asymmetry is sometime attributed to the lepton - antilepton asymmetry , the current scenario for neutrino oscillations @xcite seems inadequate for this purpose . if we take the hints from neutrinos rather seriously , there are so much to discover , even though the minimal standard model for the ordinary - matter world would , by and large , remain to be intact . of course , the standard - model higgs has now been discovered . the direct search for the family higgs and the massive family bosons in the @xmath24 range would be too costly . so , the searches for some lepton - flavor - violating decays and for violation of the @xmath39 universality would be alternative for the moment . to sum up , if we treat neutrinos as `` point - like '' dirac particles , the curl - dot product as in eq . ( 1 ) would be the way to go . it is the way to connect neutrino oscillations with the lepton - flavor - violating decays or reactions . the curl - dot products are _ not _ the matrix operations ( in the mathematics sense ) ; it represents a new way to introduce renormalizable interactions and so expands the horizon of quantum field theory . we believe that , in the dark - matter world , the dark - matter particles are also species in the extended standard model . most of reactions happening among dark - matter particles , even involving neutrinos , can not be detected in the ordinary - matter world . it is clear that the minimum extended standard model would be the extended standard model to be based on the group @xmath40 , since this model is rather unique ( and economical ) . the issue is whether our standard model would close up our world - that is , all particles in our world are accounted for . in a slightly different context @xcite , i propose to work with two working rules : `` dirac similarity principle '' , based on eighty years of experience , and `` minimum higgs hypothesis '' , from the last forty years of experience . using these two working rules , the extended model mentioned above becomes rather unique - so , it is so much easier to check it against the experiments . the close - up question of our world may have to be answered , provided that the two working rules , or similar , are assumed . we would be curious about how the dark - matter world looks like , though it is difficult to verify experimentally . the first question would be : the dark - matter world , 25 % of the current universe ( in comparison , only 5 % in the ordinary matter ) , would clusterize to form the dark - matter galaxies , maybe even before the ordinary - matter galaxies . the dark - matter galaxies would then play the hosts of ( visible ) ordinary - matter galaxies , like our own galaxy , the milky way . note that a dark - matter galaxy is by our definition a galaxy that does not possess any ordinary strong and electromagnetic interactions ( with our visible ordinary - matter world ) . this fundamental question deserves some thoughts , for the structural formation of our universe . of course , we should remind ourselves that , in our ordinary - matter world , those quarks can aggregate in no time , to hadrons , including nuclei , and the electrons serve to neutralize the charges also in no time . then atoms , molecules , complex molecules , and so on . these serve as the seeds for the clusters , and then stars , and then galaxies , maybe in a time span of @xmath41 ( i.e. , the age of our young universe ) . the aggregation caused by strong and electromagnetic forces is fast enough to help giving rise to galaxies in a time span of @xmath41 . on the other hand , the seeded clusterings might proceed with abundance of extra - heavy dark - matter particles such as familons and family higgs , all greater than a few @xmath24 and with relatively long lifetimes ( owing to very limited decay channels ) . so , further simulations on galactic formation and evolution may yield clues on our problem . finally , coming back to the fronts of particle physics , neutrinos might couple to the dark - matter particles . any further investigation along this direction would be of utmost importance . it may shed light on the nature of the dark - matter world and , eventually , we would be able to close up our world . this research is supported in part by national science council project ( nsc 99 - 2112-m-002 - 009-my3 ) . we wish to thank the authors of the following books @xcite for thorough reviews of the minimal standard model . ta - you wu and w - y . pauchy hwang , `` relatistic quantum mechanics and quantum fields '' ( world scientific 1991 ) ; francis halzen and alan d. martin , `` quarks and leptons '' ( john wiley and sons , inc . 1984 ) ; e.d . commins and p.h . bucksbaum , `` weak interactions of leptons and quarks '' ( cambridge university press 1983 ) . this was `` my '' early list of the textbooks on the `` standard model '' . pauchy hwang , nucl . a844 * , 40c ( 2010 ) ; w - y . pauchy hwang , international j. mod . phys . * a24 * , 3366 ( 2009 ) ; the idea first appeared in hep - ph , arxiv : 0808.2091 ; talk presented at 2008 cospa symposium ( pohang , korea , october 2008 ) , intern . series * 1 * , 5 ( 2011 ) ; plenary talk at the 3rd international meeting on frontiers of physics , 12 - 16 january 2009 , kuala lumpur , malaysia , published in american institute of physics 978 - 0 - 7354 - 0687 - 2/09 , pp . 25 - 30 ( 2009 ) . p. hwang , arxiv:11070156v1 ( hep - ph , 1 jul 2011 ) , plenary talk given at the 10th international conference on low energy antiproton physics ( vancouver , canada , april 27 - may 1 , 2011 ) , unpublished .

to describe neutrino oscillations in the sense of quantum mechanics and quantum field theory , we propose to use an off - diagonal neutrino - higgs ( mass ) interaction , as discussed originally in a family gauge theory and in the extended standard model . for neutrino oscillations which take place presumably between point - like dirac particles , the proposed description would be unique in the quantum mechanics sense . this may help us to resolve a few outstanding puzzles - the question of why there are only three generations , the question of why the masses of neutrinos are so tiny , the question of why neutrinos oscillate , and the question of why the dark - matter world is so huge ( 25% ) as compared to the visible ordinary - matter world ( 5% ) . pacs indices : 12.60.-i ( models beyond the standard model ) ; 98.80.bp ( origin and formation of the universe ) ; 12.10.-g ( unified field theories and models ) . * neutrino oscillations as a lepton - flavor - violating interaction * .5 cm w - y . pauchy hwang 27 jul 2012 . ] + _ asia pacific organization for cosmology and particle astrophysics , + institute of astrophysics , center for theoretical sciences , + and department of physics , national taiwan university , taipei 106 , taiwan _ .2 cm ( 24 july 2012 ; revised : august 15 , 2013 )

astro-ph0101420

the sdss ( york et al . 2000 ) consists of four major components : a dedicated 2.5 m telescope at apache point , new mexico , along with a separate 50 cm telescope used to monitor the extinction and to provide calibration patches for the main telescope ; a large format imaging camera ( gunn et al . 1998 ) containing 30 @xmath0 ( 13@xmath113 arcmin ) photometric ccds with @xmath2 filters and 24 @xmath3 astrometric and focus ccds ; two 320-fibre - fed double spectrographs , each with two @xmath0 ccds ; and lots and lots of software , with contributions from most of the sdss institutions ( listed in the acknowledgments ) . the primary goals of the project are to survey the northern galactic cap ( @xmath4 square degrees ) in five bands to ( psf ) limits of 22.3(u ) , 23.3(g ) , 23.1(r ) , 22.3(i ) , and 20.8(z ) , and to carry out a spectroscopic survey of @xmath5 galaxies , @xmath6 qsos , and a few @xmath7 stars . the sdss is now in operational mode , and as of this writing ( late january 2001 ) has imaged some 1600 @xmath8 and obtained about 120,000 spectra as part of its commissioning and initial operations phases . these data have allowed dramatic new astronomical discoveries to be made , discoveries that we shall not further discuss here ( e.g. blanton et al . 2001 , fan et al . 2000 , 2001 , fischer et al . 2000 , ivezi et al . 2000 , leggett et al . the sdss took an early decision to use public domain software wherever possible ; in practice this has largely been applied to our infrastructure rather than scientific codes . our software engineering tools are entirely public domain ( with the exception of compilers ) . we adopted as a source code manager and have been pleased with its performance . we currently have about 1.7gby in our cvs repository ( including at least one version of iraf ) . we have found that , after an initial period of distrust , scientists have found cvs to be extremely useful ; in at least some cases , people sitting next to each other at the observatory in new mexico have communicated via a cvs repository in illinois . while cvs allows us to control individual pieces of software , it does not provide a means of controlling complete systems . we have used a fermi national accelerator laboratory ( fnal ) utility called which allows us to associate a set of _ dependent products _ with a piece of our software . for example , version ` v5_2_10 ` of the image processing pipeline depends upon ` v7_15 ` of our infrastructure routines . this enables us to guarantee that at any time in the future we can reconstruct an entire system , using exactly the same bits and pieces . the particular versions ( e.g. ` v5_2_10 ` ) correspond to tags in the cvs repository . we have adopted a procedure that stable versions of our pipelines correspond to _ branch tags _ in cvs ; this has allowed us to proceed with development while giving us the ability to fix bugs found in the stable , delivered , code . we have used as our problem report and bug database . since july 1998 we have acquired 1799 entries in the database ; the last thousand have been filed since february 2000 . we use a heavily enhanced version of tcl 7.4 ( actually , of tclx ) as our command language . much of the work developing this system ( known as _ dervish _ , n _ shiva _ , sergey et al . 1996 ) was carried out at fnal . in addition to what now appear to be basically cosmetic changes ( which we regret ) , the major enhancements that we made were : * memory tracing / defragmentation / debugging + a common problem with programs that make heavy use of dynamically allocated memory is that the memory acquired from the operating system becomes _ fragmented _ , or that the program forgets to free resources . both of these problems can be resolved by adding a layer above ` malloc ` , and we have done so . figure [ figmemtrace ] shows that the total memory used in the steady state by the frames pipeline ( see below ) is well controlled . * support for c datatypes at tcl level . + we wrote a processor that scans the c include files ( ` .h files ' ) and generated a description of the schema of all the types declared therein . this was originally used to implement a primitive persistent store , but proved more useful in making the c data elements available at the tcl prompt ; this greatly increased the power and flexibility of our command language , allowing us to build the command - and - control parts of our pipelines in tcl rather than having to use compiled c. for example , where a ` handle ' is an address and a datatype . * easy(ish ) bindings from c to tcl . + we implemented a set of library calls that made it possible to bind c commands to tcl in a way that , if not simple , at least required no thought and could be handled by pasting appropriate boiler - plate code . saoimage we gratefully adopted ` saoimage ` , and added a facility to overlay bitmasks . slatec pgplot if we were starting this problem today , we would probably not use tcl ( maybe python in its pyraf incarnation ? ) , and we would certainly make greater efforts to use _ vanilla _ , up - to - date , versions of our chosen system . the sdss has quite a large number of pipelines which must be run in order to fully process the data ; we shall not discuss the spectroscopic reductions or the operational and scientific databases . * ` astroline ` + on the mve167 processors ( running vxworks ) used to archive the raw data on the mountain , we also run a pipeline that processes the pixels before they re written to disk / tape . we generate star cutouts ( ` postage stamps ' ) and column quartiles ; this is all that we save from the 22 astrometric ccds . * ` mt ` pipeline . + process the photometric telescope camera data . this consists of a set of staring - mode observations of fields of standard stars , used to define the extinction and photometric zero - points for the 2.5 m scans . * ` serial stamp collecting ` ( ssc ) pipeline . + reorganise the data stream , cut a more complete set of postage stamps . * ` astrometric ` pipeline . + process the centroids of stars from ` astroline`/`ssc ` and generate the astrometric transformations from pixels to @xmath9 and between bands . * ` postage stamp ` pipeline ( psp ) . + estimate the flat field vectors , bias drift , and sky levels , and characterise the psf for each field . * ` frames ` pipeline . + process the full imaging data , producing corrected frames , object catalogues , and atlas images . * calibration . + take the outputs from ` mt ` pipeline and ` frames ` , and convert counts to fluxes . one major gain from splitting responsibilities in this way is that once we get to the ` frames ` pipeline , fields ( 10arcmin@xmath114arcmin patches on the sky ) may be processed independently and in any order . the sdss imaging piplelines employ a number of novel and even interesting algorithms , which are slowly being written up for publication ; for example the image deblender ( lupton 2001 ) . here we shall only discuss a couple of features connected to handling the point spread function ( psf ) and the related problem of star / galaxy separation . even in the absence of atmospheric inhomogeneities the sdss telescope delivers images whose fwhms vary by up to 15% from one side of a ccd to the other ; the worst effects are seen in the chips furthest from the optical axis . if the seeing were constant in time one might hope to understand these effects ab initio , but when coupled with time - variable seeing the delivered image quality is a complex two - dimensional function and we chose to model it heuristically using a karhunen - love ( kl ) transform . the description of the psf ( as derived in the next subsection ) is critical for accurate psf photometry , i.e. for all faint object photometry if the psf varies so does the aperture correction . we also need to accurately know the psf in order to be able to separate stars from galaxies ; after all , the _ only _ valid discriminant that is nt based on colours or priors is that galaxies do nt look like stars . a good knowledge of the local psf is also needed for all studies that measure the shapes of non - stellar objects ( e.g. weak lensing studies , fischer et al . 2000 ) . the first step is to identify a set of reasonably bright , reasonably isolated stars from our image . we then use these stars to form a kl basis , retaining the first @xmath10 terms of the expansion : @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the @xmath13 psf star , the @xmath14 are the kl basis functions , and @xmath15 are pixel coordinates relative to the origin of the basis functions . in determining the @xmath14 , the @xmath12 are normalised to have equal peak value . once we know the @xmath14 we can write @xmath16 where @xmath17 are the coordinates of the centre of the @xmath13 star , @xmath18 determines the highest power of @xmath19 or @xmath20 to include in the expansion , and the @xmath21 are determined by minimising @xmath22 note that all stars are given equal weight as we are interested in determining the spatial variation of the psf , and do not want to tailor our fit to the chance positions of bright stars . for each ccd , in each band , there are typically 15 - 25 stars in a frame that we can use to determine the psf ; we usually take @xmath23 and @xmath24 ( i.e. the psf spatial variation is quadratic ) . we need to estimate @xmath10 kl basis images , and a total of @xmath25 @xmath26 coefficients , and at first sight the problem might seem underconstrained . fortunately we have many _ pixels _ in each of the @xmath12 , and thus only the number of spatial terms ( @xmath27 , i.e. 6 for @xmath24 ) need be compared with the number of stars available . in fact , rather than use only the stars from a single frame to determine that frame s psf , we include stars from both proceeding and succeeding frames in the fit . this procedure has several advantages : the spatial variation is better constrained at the leading and trailing edges of the frame ; the psf variation is smoother from frame to frame ; and the psf is determined from more stars . we have found that optimal results are obtained by using a range of @xmath28 frames to determine the kl basis functions @xmath14 and @xmath29 frame to follow the spatial variation of the psf . if we try to use a larger window we find that variation of the @xmath30 coefficients is not well described by the polynomials that we have assumed . we have not tried using a different set of expansion functions ( e.g. a fourier series ) . we fit three models to every object , in every band : a psf , a pure devaucouleurs profile , and an exponential disk ; the galaxy models are convolved with the local psf ( as estimated using the kl expansion of the previous section ) . this is potentially an expensive operation as it involves a 3-dimensional ( @xmath31 ) non - linear minimisation ; each iteration requires the calculation of a 2-d analytical model of a galaxy followed by convolution with the psf and the calculation of @xmath32 by summing over many pixels of the image . we make heavy use of pre - calculated tables of models , and pre - extract the radial profile into a series of annuli , each containing 12 30@xmath33 sectors ; in consequence , fitting a single galaxy model in a single band takes of order 1.5ms on an 800mhz alpha . the primary use of these models is in star / galaxy separation and morphological classification of galaxies . we initially hoped to use the relative likelihoods of the psf and galaxy fits to separate stars from galaxies , but found that the stellar likelihoods were tiny for bright stars , where the photon noise in the profiles is small , due to the influence of slight errors in modelling the psf . instead we found the ratio of the _ flux _ in the best - fit galaxy model to that in the psf to be an excellent discriminant . figure [ figgr ] shows a colour - magnitude diagram from a small area of sdss imaging data . the top left panel shows only objects classified as stars ; note that most objects with colours of @xmath34 are preferentially classified as galaxies . the star / galaxy separation is independent of the object s colours , so this rejection _ must _ be a measure of how well the star / galaxy classification is working . studies of the performance of the sdss s / g separation in the groth strip data ( where accurate classification is available from hst imaging ) indicate that separation is reliable to at least a @xmath35 of 21.5 in data that has a @xmath36 limit of @xmath37 . the @xmath38 colour of galaxies is a good discriminant of hubble type ( strateva et al . figure [ figgalclass ] shows @xmath38 plotted against what is essentially the likelihood ratio for devaucouleurs and exponential models shows that the galaxy likelihoods provide clear _ morphological _ classification to @xmath39 , in data with a psf @xmath36 limit of about 22.5 . as far as he knows , this section represents the views only of the primary author and not of his coauthors . those of you who know him will have heard these opinions before . the sdss has been very challenging technically , scientifically , and managerially . in all categories the software stands out : the hardest technical aspect of building the sdss was probably the software , although building the mosaic camera was nt easy ; some of the software was a major _ scientific _ challenge ; and the software was undoubtedly the hardest part of the project to manage . let me expand upon some of these issues . we have found it extremely hard to hire good people to work on astronomical software . there is no career path within the universities for software specialists , despite the fact that there s no logical distinction between building hard- and soft - ware instruments . smart and sensible graduate students , desirous of a career in astronomy , simply do nt choose to specialise in the software required to reduce modern observational datasets . hiring computer professionals is not the solution to this problem . besides being ( if competent ) too expensive for the average astronomical project , they simply do nt possess the skills needed to solve the _ scientific _ challenges posed by astronomical data . we need _ scientists _ to resolve scientific problems , albeit with support from people whose job it is to know about optimizers , lalr(1 ) grammars , and good software engineering practices . we also need our software - scientists to be in rich scientific environments , where they can talk with ( e.g. ) the quasar - scientists about the data analysis that they are carrying out . if we , as a community , knew how to reuse software from one project on another some of these problems might be alleviated , but i do nt believe that they would go away . the availability of good numerical libraries hasnt made the development of new cosmological codes stop ; the impetus for change comes from the desire to do things better , not just from the not - invented - here syndrome . i believe that part of the problem is that we , as a community have not yet faced the reality that software is _ difficult _ , and that the dynamic range between the really good and the average programmer is as great as that between lyman spitzer and the average graduate student . this makes management difficult ; imagine trying to get a collaboration of 100 self - opinionated astronomers to agree about the best way to solve a problem , and tell me why this is any easier than running a large modern collaboration involving large amounts of software . i reluctantly believe that we must learn to run large software projects ( and all large projects nowadays are large software projects ) as benevolent dictatorships of course with the implicit hope that i shall be the dictator ( but not the manager ) . the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) is a joint project of the university of chicago , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , the johns hopkins university , the max - planck - institute for astronomy , new mexico state university , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington . apache point observatory , site of the sdss telescopes , is operated by the astrophysical research consortium ( arc ) . funding for the project has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the sdss member institutions , the national aeronautics and space administration , the national science foundation , the u.s . department of energy , monbusho , and the max planck society .

we summarise the properties of the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) project , discuss our software infrastructure , and outline the architecture of the sdss image processing pipelines . we then discuss two of the algorithms used in the sdss image processing ; the karhunen - love transform based modelling of the spatial variation of the psf , and the use of galaxy models in star / galaxy separation . we conclude with the first author s personal opinions on the challenges that the astronomical community faces with major software projects .

0911.2335

ultracold atoms provide a unique toolbox to study many - particle physics under very clean and well - defined conditions . the precise control over their interactions and their trapping potentials allows to study the dynamics of phase transitions as well as the preparation of strongly correlated quantum states @xcite . while so far the majority of experiments is carried out with ground state atoms , exploiting the unique properties of highly excited states is gradually moving into the focus of experimental and theoretical efforts . atoms in highly excited states can interact strongly , i.e. , the interaction strength can be of the order of several tens of mhz at a distance of several micrometers . the corresponding quantum dynamics takes place on a microsecond timescale and thus is orders of magnitude faster than the atoms external dynamics . such scenario is usually referred to as frozen gas @xcite . a number of experimental groups have studied the excitation dynamics of such system using rydberg states of alkali metal atoms @xcite which were excited from an ultracold gas . here a dramatic reduction of the fraction of excited atoms was observed once the atomic density was too high or the interaction between excited states was too strong @xcite . this is a manifestation of the so - called rydberg blockade @xcite effect that is responsible for the collective character @xcite of rydberg excitations in dense gases . very recently the power of rydberg states to establish a controlled interaction of single atoms trapped in distant traps has been demonstrated in a series of impressive experiments @xcite . strongly supported by these results , highly excited atoms nowadays are believed to have a manifold of applications ranging far beyond traditional atomic physics . indeed , exploiting the properties of atoms in rydberg states permits the study of spin systems at criticality @xcite , the quantum simulation of complex spin models @xcite , the investigation of the thermalization of strongly interacting many - particle systems @xcite and also the implementation of quantum information protocols @xcite . in a recent work ( ref . @xcite ) we showed that the unique properties of rydberg atoms allow the creation of entangled many - particle states on a one - dimensional ring lattice on a short time scale . finding simple ways for creating entangled many - particle states is of importance , since such states have a number of applications , e.g , they serve as resource for the creation of single - photon light sources @xcite , for improving precision quantum measurements @xcite and for measurement based quantum information processing . in this paper we will go into depth and largely expand on our previous study . we show that excited many - particle states of a laser - driven gas of rydberg atoms on a ring lattice can be obtained analytically in the limit of strong laser driving . we give a detailed derivation of the system s hamiltonian in sec . [ sec : system ] . the construction of the many - body excitations , their eigenenergies and their correlation properties are analyzed in sec . [ sec : states ] . in sec . [ sec : how_address ] we discuss thoroughly how these states can be excited in an experiment . we conclude with a summary and outlook in sec . [ sec : conclusion ] . we study a gas of bosonic ground - state atoms confined to a deep large spacing optical or magnetic @xcite ring lattice with periodicity @xmath0 ( see fig . [ fig : lattice ] ) . the wannier functions @xmath1 are localized at the @xmath2-th site with a width @xmath3 . we assume the external dynamics of the atoms to be frozen , i.e. , no hopping and hence no particle exchange between the lattice sites is present . this is well justified as the internal ( electronic ) dynamics - in which we are interested here - takes place on a much shorter timescale , of the order of hundred nanoseconds . we consider two electronic levels which are denoted by @xmath4 and @xmath5 . here @xmath5 is a rydberg @xmath6s - state which - due to its quantum defect - is well isolated from any other electronic level . it is coupled to the ground state @xmath4 via a laser with rabi frequency @xmath7 and detuning @xmath8 . within the rotating wave approximation , the hamiltonian describing the coupling of the atoms to the laser field reads ( with @xmath9 ) @xmath10 where @xmath11 and @xmath12 ( @xmath13 and @xmath14 ) represent the creation ( annihilation ) of a ground and a rydberg state , respectively , and @xmath15 stands for the number of atoms in state @xmath5 at the @xmath2-th site . being much larger than the extension @xmath16 of the wannier functions ( deep lattice ) . the internal atomic degrees of freedom at each site are described by the ( collective ) states @xmath17 and @xmath18 , coupled by @xmath19.,width=264 ] we will consider throughout this paper the case where each lattice site is occupied by the same number of atoms , @xmath20 . this is achieved , for example , if the system is initialized in a mott - insulator state . the interaction between the rydberg atoms is given by the van - der - waals potential @xmath21 , that is quickly decaying with the distance @xmath22 between atoms . nevertheless , as @xmath23 scales with the eleventh power of the principal quantum number @xmath6 , the interaction can strongly affect the excitation dynamics of atoms that are separated by several micrometers . this strong interaction gives rise to the so - called blockade effect @xcite . we consider a scenario in which the simultaneous excitation of two or more atoms to the rydberg state on a single lattice site is blockaded . thus , on each lattice site @xmath2 , only the two states @xmath24_1\otimes\dots\left[\left|g\right>_k\right]_{n_0}\\ \left|r\right>_k&=&\frac{1}{\sqrt{n_0}}{\cal s } \left\{\left[\left|r\right>_k\right]_1\otimes\left[\left|g\right>_k\right]_2\otimes\dots\left[\left|g\right>_k\right]_{n_0}\right\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] are accessible , where @xmath25 is the symmetrization operator . the effective rabi frequency for the laser coupling between these so - called ( super)atom states ( see fig . [ fig : lattice ] ) is given by @xmath26 . taking all this into account , in eq . ( [ eqn : laser_ham ] ) we can replace @xmath27 $ ] , where @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the pauli spin matrices . since @xmath3 ( see fig . [ fig : lattice ] ) we can rewrite the van - der - waals potential between two ( super)atoms in the state @xmath30 located @xmath31 sites apart as @xmath32 , where @xmath33 is the separation between those sites . as already pointed out , @xmath34 is quickly decaying with the distance . in particular , the next - nearest neighbor interaction is a factor of @xmath35 smaller than the nearest neighbor one ( @xmath36 ) . we will thus only focus on the nearest neighbor interaction which is well - justified for large enough lattices . the interaction hamiltonian for the entire atomic ensemble , with @xmath37 , then reads @xmath38 with the rydberg number operator @xmath39/2 $ ] and the boundary condition @xmath40 . in summary , the complete hamiltonian that drives the dynamics of our system can be written as @xmath41.\ ] ] the system can be described as a periodic arrangement of spin-@xmath42 particles , where the two spin states , corresponding to the two internal states of the ( super)atoms , @xmath17 and @xmath18 , interact via an ising - type potential . in this picture , the rabi frequency @xmath19 and the combination of @xmath43 can be effectively interpreted as perpendicular magnetic fields . hence , the relevant parameters in our system will be : a ) the ones related to the laser , i.e. , the single - atom rabi frequency @xmath7 and detuning @xmath8 , which can be time - dependent and b ) the interaction between rydberg atoms represented by @xmath44 . throughout this paper , we consider the regime where the detuning is much smaller than both the collective rabi frequency ( laser driving ) and the interaction strength , i.e. , @xmath45 . as a consequence , the behavior of the system will be determined by the ratio of the latter two parameters . here we focus on the limit @xmath46 , i.e. , the laser coupling is much stronger than the interaction between atoms . in this regime the first term of the hamiltonian ( [ eqn : working_hamiltonian ] ) is the dominant one and it is convenient to make it diagonal by means of a rotation of the basis . this is achieved by the unitary transformation @xmath47 which brings @xmath48 and @xmath49 . when applied to our hamiltonian ( [ eqn : working_hamiltonian ] ) , it yields @xmath50 with @xmath51\label{eqn : h_xy}\\ h_1&=&\frac{\delta}{2}\sum_{k=1}^l\left(1-\sigma_{x}^{(k)}\right)\label{eqn : h_1}\\ h_2&=&\frac{\beta}{4}\sum_{k=1}^l \left[\left(\sigma_{+}^{(k)}\sigma_{+}^{(k+1)}+\sigma_{-}^{(k)}\sigma_{-}^{(k+1)}\right)-2\sigma_x^{(k)}\right]\label{eqn : h_2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath52 is the famous @xmath53-model of a spin chain with a transverse magnetic field . let us now analyze the importance of the individual contributions of @xmath54 . as we can see in fig . [ fig : spectrum ] , the spectrum of @xmath54 decays into manifolds of states which are separated by gaps whose width is approximately @xmath55 . this is caused by the dominant first term of @xmath52 , i.e. , @xmath56 . the eigenstates of @xmath57 are - in terms of the ( super)atom states - given by @xmath58\ ] ] with @xmath59 . thus , each of the manifolds that determine the coarse structure of the spectrum is spanned by a set of product states that have the same number of ( super)atoms in the state @xmath60 . in fig . [ fig : spectrum ] , these manifolds are denoted by @xmath61 , which is the eigenvalue of the states with respect to the operator @xmath62 . the second term of @xmath52 conserves the total number of @xmath60 ( super)atoms . in other words , it couples only states that belong to the same @xmath61-manifold and that are nearly degenerate . as a consequence , the strength of these intra - manifold couplings due to @xmath63 is proportional to @xmath44 . conversely , @xmath64 and @xmath65 couple states that belong to manifolds with different number of ( super)atoms in the state @xmath60 . in particular , @xmath64 and the last term of @xmath65 flip one of the ( super)atoms from @xmath60 to @xmath66 or viceversa . thus , the coupled states belong to different manifolds with @xmath67 , energetically separated by @xmath55 . the two first terms of @xmath65 drive a similar process , flipping always two contiguous ( super)atoms in the same state simultaneously , i.e. , @xmath68 or @xmath69 . as a result , these terms connect states with eigenvalue @xmath61 to those with @xmath70 , which are separated roughly by @xmath71 . these features are reflected in fig . [ fig : spectrum ] . and @xmath72 . the spectrum splits into manifolds which can be labeled by the quantum number @xmath61 of the operator @xmath73 . for sufficiently large @xmath19 , the coupling between manifolds that is established only by @xmath64 and @xmath65 can be neglected . the ( constrained ) dynamics inside the @xmath61-subspaces is then determined by @xmath52.,width=188 ] the transition rates between @xmath61-manifolds corresponding to @xmath64 and @xmath65 can be estimated by second order perturbation theory to be of the order @xmath74 and @xmath75 , respectively . hence , for sufficiently strong driving @xmath46 , their contribution can be neglected and the system s dynamics is constrained to the @xmath61-manifolds . as a consequence , the hamiltonian that drives the intra - manifold dynamics , @xmath52 , _ effectively drives the dynamics of the entire system in this parameter regime_. this hamiltonian is analytically solvable , and we thus have access to the actual spectrum and eigenstates of the system . the diagonalization of this hamiltonian relies on the so - called jordan - wigner transformation and a fourier transform that we explain thoroughly in the following paragraph @xcite . the pauli matrices in the hamiltonian ( [ eqn : h_xy ] ) obey anti - commutation and commutation relations when they belong to the same and different sites , respectively . thus , the algebra is neither bosonic nor fermionic . this difficulty can be overcome by the jordan - wigner transformation , @xmath76 which introduces the operators @xmath77 and @xmath78 that obey the canonical fermionic algebra @xmath79 after this transformation , the hamiltonian ( [ eqn : h_xy ] ) takes on the form @xmath80\\ & -&\frac{\beta}{4}\left(c_l^\dagger c_1+c_1^\dagger c_l\right)\left(e^{i\pi n_+}+1\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , the hamiltonian has been transformed into one which describes a chain of spinless fermions with nearest neighbor hopping . the last term of hamiltonian ( [ eqn : h_jw ] ) appears due to the periodic boundary conditions . it depends on the operator @xmath81 which counts the total number of fermions , which is also equivalent to the number of ( super)atoms in the state @xmath60 . thus , depending on the parity of the number of fermions of the state , @xmath52 reads @xmath82 for even ( e ) or odd ( o ) parity , respectively . these two cases can be accounted for simultaneously in a convenient way by introducing a matrix representation for the fermionic operators . they are projected onto the subspaces with even and odd eigenvalue of @xmath83 by means of the projectors @xmath84/2 $ ] , with @xmath85 . since the hamiltonian @xmath52 conserves the number of fermions , i.e. , @xmath86=0 $ ] , it is diagonal in this representation and can be decomposed as @xmath87 we now introduce new matrix - valued creation and annihilation operators of the form @xmath88 which obey the fermionic algebra provided @xmath78 and @xmath89 are fermionic operators . the hamiltonian can now be conveniently written as @xmath90 with @xmath91 the diagonalization of the hamiltonian ( [ eqn : h_matrix_gamma ] ) is achieved by performing the following fourier transform @xmath92 with the fourier coefficients @xmath93 the operators @xmath94 and @xmath95 are matrix - valued @xmath96 with @xmath97 and @xmath98 being fermionic creation and annihilation operators , respectively . defining the eigenvalue matrix @xmath99 as @xmath100 } & 0\\ 0 & \cos{\left[\frac{2\pi}{l}n\right ] } \end{array}\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] the diagonalized hamiltonian ( [ eqn : h_matrix_gamma ] ) reads @xmath101 as we will see in the next section , the introduction of the matrix - valued fermionic operators has the advantage that excited states can be constructed by applying products of @xmath94 to the ground state . as a consequence , this matrix notation allows us to automatically distinguish between the odd and even fermion cases , which otherwise has to be done manually . the symmetry properties of our system impose certain selection rules for the excitation of the many - particle states . in order to understand this , let us start our analysis of the excited states by studying the symmetries of the hamiltonian . because of the special arrangement of the sites , the hamiltonian ( [ eqn : working_hamiltonian ] ) and also ( [ eqn : h_matrix_lambda ] ) are invariant under cyclic shifts and reversal of the lattice sites . this can be formally seen by representing these two symmetries through the operators @xmath102 and @xmath103 , respectively . their action on the spin ladder operators are @xmath104 and @xmath105 , from where follows that @xmath106=\left[h_\mathrm{spin},{\cal r}\right]=0 $ ] , i.e. , both of them correspond to conserved quantities . thus , if the system is initialized in an eigenstate with respect to @xmath107 and @xmath108 , the time evolution will not take place in the entire hilbert space , but merely in the subspace spanned by the states with the same quantum number with respect to @xmath102 and @xmath103 . this observation is highly relevant for our system . in practise , the natural initial situation will be that in which all atoms are in the ground state , i.e. , @xmath109 . this state has the above - mentioned properties , i.e. , it is invariant under cyclic shifts and the reversal of the sites : @xmath110 and @xmath111 . we will refer to such a state that has eigenvalue @xmath112 with respect to @xmath107 and @xmath108 as being fully - symmetric . hence , only the states from this fully - symmetric subspace can be actually accessed in the course of the system s time evolution under hamiltonian ( [ eqn : working_hamiltonian ] ) . in the following we will thus focus on constructing excited states that belong to this subset . the ground state of hamiltonian ( [ eqn : h_matrix_lambda ] ) is given by @xmath113 and it is fully - symmetric . excited states that contain @xmath114 fermions are in general formed by successive application of the creation operator , i.e. , @xmath115 . however , not all combinations will give rise to states that belong to the fully - symmetric subset . let us start considering the possible cases of a single - fermion excitation . for a fully - symmetric state we require @xmath116 , i.e. , @xmath117 with @xmath118 being a placeholder for @xmath102 and @xmath103 . after some algebra one finds that @xmath119 since @xmath120 and @xmath121 , only the single excitation with @xmath122 is symmetric under cyclic shifts and reversal . hence , the only one - fermion state that can be reached by the time - evolution reads @xmath123 to have a better physical understanding of this state , it is convenient to write it in terms of the atomic operators , @xmath124 thus , @xmath125 is a spin wave or , in other words , a superatom that extends over the entire lattice . these states are of interest since they can be used as a resource for single photon generation . for the two - fermion states , we follow the same procedure and demand @xmath126 one finds that @xmath127c_1^\dagger\left(e^{i\pi n_+}-1\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] from this , one sees that the condition @xmath128 has to be accomplished . as a result , the fully - symmetric states are @xmath129 with @xmath130 . these are entangled states formed by superpositions of two - atom excitations in the ring with opposite momentum . this is more clearly seen by writing everything in terms of the pauli matrices @xmath131 these states are potentially interesting for the production of photon pairs . how they can be actually accessed will be discussed in sec . [ sec : how_address ] . finally , let us illustrate how the three - fermion excitations are formed . we have @xmath132 and thus fully symmetric three - fermion states are of the form @xmath133 with @xmath134 . writing these eigenexcitations back in terms of the spin operators yields @xmath135}\sigma_+^{(k)}\sigma_+^{(k')}\sigma_+^{(k'')}\left|g\right>,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath136 is the levi - civita symbol . in a similar way , states with higher number of fermions are obtained . now that we have analyzed the eigenstates of the system we will focus on the corresponding eigenenergies . in the course of this investigation we will also perform a comparison of the analytic results to the ones obtained from a numerical diagonalization of the hamiltonian ( [ eqn : working_hamiltonian ] ) . this will allow us to assess the accuracy of our analytical approach . let us begin with the ground state energy . from eq . ( [ eqn : h_matrix_lambda ] ) we can read off the value @xmath137 where we have included the general energy - offset @xmath138 ( see eq . ( [ eqn : uhu ] ) ) . for @xmath139 , @xmath140 , @xmath141 and @xmath142 , the result is @xmath143 . this is to be compared with the numerical value of @xmath144 which is obtained by diagonalizing the hamiltonian ( [ eqn : working_hamiltonian ] ) . we find both results to be in good agreement . for the first excited state we obtain @xmath145 using the same set of parameters , the energy of the single - fermion state is @xmath146 , which is very close to the numerically exact value @xmath147 . the energies of higher eigenexcitations are given by @xmath148},\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath130 , for the two - fermion case and @xmath149,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath134 , for the three - fermion one . for @xmath142 , we obtain five and eight different eigenenergies for the two- and three - fermion states , respectively ( see insets in fig . [ fig : spectrum_real ] ) . in the tables [ tab:2n ] and [ tab:3lmn ] we perform a comparison between the analytical and the numerical results . a difference of less than a @xmath150 is observed in all cases . ( [ eqn : uhu ] ) for a lattice of @xmath142 sites versus the laser driving @xmath19 in units of @xmath44 . in the right insets , the energies of the two- and three - fermion states are shown for @xmath140 . five two - fermion and eight three - fermion eigenenergies arise as it is analytically predicted for this lattice size.,width=340 ] .energies of the five two - fermion states @xmath151 for @xmath142 , @xmath139 , @xmath140 and @xmath141 and comparison with the numerically exact values . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] the discrepancies between analytical and numerical values are mainly caused by second order energy shifts due to @xmath64 and @xmath65 ( eqs . ( [ eqn : h_1 ] ) and ( [ eqn : h_2 ] ) ) . these contributions vanish only in the limits @xmath152 and @xmath153 . here , we will calculate them for a finite ratio . there is a constant term in @xmath64 which is proportional to @xmath8 that gives rise to a global energy shift @xmath154 . being aware of this shift facilitates the comparison between the numerically exact and the approximate analytical eigenvalues for @xmath155 . let us focus first on the ground state . @xmath64 and @xmath65 only couple states whose number of fermions differ by one or two ( fig . [ fig : spectrum ] ) . as a consequence , only the states @xmath125 and @xmath151 contribute to the second order correction of the energy of the ground state . it yields @xmath156}}{4\omega+\beta\cos{\left[\frac{2\pi}{l}(p-1/2)\right]}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] analogously , we calculate the energy shift of the first excited state , @xmath125 , due to @xmath64 and @xmath65 . in this case , we have to compute the effect of the states @xmath157 , @xmath151 and @xmath158 . the resulting energy correction is given by @xmath159}}{2\omega+\frac{\beta}{2}\left(2 \cos{\left[\frac{2\pi}{l}(p-1/2)\right]}-1\right)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the parameters @xmath139 , @xmath140 , @xmath141 and @xmath142 , these shifts yield @xmath160 and @xmath161 . the corrected energies of the ground and the single - fermion state are now @xmath162 and @xmath163 , much closer to the numerically exact ones of @xmath144 and @xmath147 , respectively . we will later see that these energy corrections can be useful for the selective excitation of many - particle states in the lattice . in this subsection we are going to study the density - density correlation function of the many - particle states . this quantity measures the conditional probability of finding two simultaneously excited atoms at a distance @xmath22 from each other normalized to the probability of uncorrelated excitation . it is defined - for a fully - symmetric state @xmath164 - as @xmath165 where we have used @xmath166 for all sites . the correlation function will give @xmath167 when two sites separated by a distance @xmath22 are completely uncorrelated , and @xmath168 for correlation ( anticorrelation ) between the sites . in particular , for the case @xmath169 , @xmath170 can be analytically calculated . in terms of the expectation values of the spin operators , the correlation function reads @xmath171 . for @xmath172 we have @xmath173 and for @xmath174 the calculation yields @xmath175}\right.\\ & & \left.+2\sin{\left[\frac{2\pi}{l}(p-1/2)x\right]}\cot{\left[\frac{2\pi}{l}(p-1/2)\right]}\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] by inspecting this expression for the allowed values @xmath176 , some general statements can be made : \a ) independently of the total number of sites @xmath177 , there are always two extremal cases ( see fig . [ fig : correlations]a ) which correspond to @xmath178 and @xmath179 : for @xmath178 , the correlation function shows a positive maximum at @xmath180 , i.e. , nearest neighbor , and then decreases monotonically and smoothly with the distance , staying always positive ; for @xmath179 , the nearest neighbor is pronouncedly anticorrelated , the next - nearest neighbor is correlated and this pattern of correlation - anticorrelation persists with increasing distance . \b ) for @xmath179 , the oscillations of @xmath170 are more pronounced for @xmath177 than for odd @xmath177 , see fig . [ fig : correlations]a . the ratio of the amplitudes of the correlations for @xmath180 and @xmath181 is , @xmath182 in the even and odd cases , respectively . also , for an even number of sites , the correlation functions of the two extreme cases accomplish @xmath183 , i.e. , the envelope of the oscillating function @xmath184 is given by the smoothly decreasing @xmath185 . \c ) for a fixed value of @xmath186 , the amplitude of the correlations decreases with increasing number of sites as @xmath187 , as can be seen in fig . [ fig : correlations]b . numerically , we have observed agreement to the analytical results shown in fig . [ fig : correlations ] . as expected , this agreement improves with a decreasing ratio @xmath188 . states . * a * : for @xmath178 and @xmath179 , the correlations show completely different behavior , i.e. , smoothly decreasing and strongly oscillating , respectively . these oscillations are much more pronounced for the even value of @xmath189 than for the odd , @xmath190 . * b * : the magnitude of the correlations decreases as the number of sites @xmath177 is enhanced , as can be seen for @xmath191.,width=340 ] the correlations could be directly monitored experimentally provided that a site - resolved detection of atoms in the @xmath60-state is possible . the next section will deal with the open question of how these correlated states can be experimentally accessed . our aim is to selectively excite correlated many - body states by a temporal variation of the laser parameters . initially the atoms shall be in the product state @xmath192 and the laser shall be turned off , i.e. , @xmath193 and @xmath194 . starting from these initial conditions , the goal is to vary @xmath195 and @xmath196 such that at the end of the sequence , i.e. , at @xmath197 , the detuning is zero and the laser driving is much larger than the interaction ( @xmath198 and @xmath199 ) . this final situation corresponds to the right - hand side of the spectrum presented in fig . [ fig : spectrum_real ] . once a desired many - particle state has been populated , and due to the limited lifetime of the highly excited levels which is in the order of several @xmath200 ( e.g. , 66 @xmath200 for rb in the 60s state ) , we want to map it to an stable configuration . to do so , we first turn off the laser ( @xmath201 ) and then switch on a second one whose action can be described by the hamiltonian @xmath202 in this expression , @xmath203 and @xmath204 stand for the creation and annihilation operators of an single - atom stable storage state @xmath205 on site @xmath2 , respectively . in the limit where the interaction is much smaller than the rabi frequency of this transition , i.e. , @xmath206 , we can neglect the second term of this hamiltonian . thus , performing a global @xmath207-pulse to the considered many - particle state means to perform the mapping @xmath208 , such that a stable configuration is achieved . hence , the difficulty lies in finding a trajectory or sequence @xmath209 for which at @xmath197 only a single many - particle state is occupied . we propose two different methods in the following . in certain cases , one can guess a trajectory @xmath210 like the ones shown in fig . [ fig : address ] that eventually connects @xmath211 with a desired eigenstate of @xmath52 @xcite , but this is not always possible . the general appearance of the laser sequence strongly depends on the sign of the initial detuning @xmath212 . in fig . [ fig : address ] the two possible scenarios ( taking @xmath213 ) are depicted . for @xmath214 , the initial state is not the ground state of the system when the laser is turned off ( @xmath201 ) . as a consequence , this initial state suffers several avoided crossings with other levels when @xmath19 is increased . thus , it is not easy to find a path through the spectrum that connects it to a single desired eigenstate of @xmath52 , as the one shown in fig . [ fig : address]a . a more general framework for finding a proper trajectory is provided by optimal control theory @xcite . here , the desired fidelity with which the final state is achieved can be set and certain constraints on the trajectory can be imposed . this method is successfully applied to quantum information processing @xcite , molecular state preparation @xcite and optimization of number squeezing of an atomic gas confined to a double well potential @xcite . the case of @xmath215 will be treated in the next subsection . ) through the spectrum of @xmath54 with @xmath216 ( units of @xmath44 ) . * a * : when @xmath214 , the ground state at @xmath201 does not coincide with the initial state , @xmath211 , and the energy of the initial state goes through a number of avoided crossings . a possible path through them to reach the state @xmath217 is shown . * b * : if @xmath215 , the initial state @xmath211 is adiabatically connected to the ground state @xmath157.,width=340 ] we present in this work a different route to populate single many - particle states . this is accomplished in two steps : first , one has to prepare the ground state @xmath157 of hamiltonian ( [ eqn : h_xy ] ) in the limit @xmath46 ; once the ground state is populated , the single - fermion and two - fermion many - particle states can be accessed by means of an oscillating detuning , that gives rise to a time - dependent @xmath64 . _ step 1 : _ let us start by explaining how to vary the laser parameters to prepare the ground state @xmath157 . in particular , when setting @xmath215 , the ground state of the system at @xmath201 coincides with the initial state @xmath211 . with increasing @xmath19 , it is adiabatically connected to the ground state @xmath157 of @xmath63 ( see fig . [ fig : address]b ) . the problem that we can encounter here is that non - adiabatic transitions to other energy levels occur when increasing @xmath19 , so that we do not populate only @xmath157 but also other states . to avoid this , we choose a large enough value of @xmath212 when the laser is still turned off ( @xmath201 ) . this increases the energy gap between @xmath211 and other energy levels , and , as a consequence , suppresses non - adiabatic transitions . this initial detuning can be decreased as @xmath19 increases so that in the desired regime , i.e. , @xmath218 , it is set to zero . as an example , we propose the following shapes of @xmath219 and @xmath196 @xmath220\label{eqn : detuning}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the obtained fidelity @xmath221 for different values of the initial detuning @xmath212 and time intervals @xmath222 is given in fig . [ fig:0togs ] , where @xmath223 stands for the wavefunction of the final state . it is actually possible to populate the desired state with high fidelity , e.g. , over @xmath224 is achieved for all considered lattice sizes with @xmath225 and @xmath226 . we find that : i ) the fidelity depends only weakly on the lattice size although the dimension of the hilbert space grows exponentially with @xmath177 , and ii ) as expected , for a fixed value of the initial detuning , the fidelity increases with the increasing length of the time interval . note that the timescale of this whole process is limited by the lifetime of the rydberg state . when populating the ground state of @xmath52 from the initial state via variation of the parameters of the laser @xmath219 and @xmath196 in the form given by ( @xmath227 ) and ( [ eqn : detuning ] ) , respectively . several initial values of the detuning and time intervals , as well as different lattice sizes , are considered . for a fixed value of @xmath212 ( units of @xmath44 ) , better fidelities are obtained for larger time intervals ( units of @xmath228 ) . for a fixed time interval , there is an optimal value of @xmath212 for each size of the lattice , around @xmath229.,width=340 ] if there is only one atom per site , and based on the fact that @xmath230 is a product state , an alternative procedure to this adiabatic passage can be envisaged . starting from the vacuum @xmath211 ( also a product state with every atom in @xmath4 ) , we perform a global @xmath231-pulse to the single - atom transition @xmath232 . as a result , we obtain a product state where every atom is in a superposition @xmath233/\sqrt{2}$ ] . in a second step , the @xmath207-pulse with the mapping laser described by the hamiltonian ( [ eqn : h_map ] ) and with @xmath206 , transfers every atom to the state @xmath234/\sqrt{2}$ ] , i.e. , we have prepared the ground state @xmath157 . it is worth remarking that this method eliminates the lifetime limitation in this first stage . _ step 2 : _ let us show now how to address the single - fermion and two - fermion states from this ground state @xmath157 . as we explained in section [ sec : constrained ] , the hamiltonian @xmath64 , associated with the detuning , drives transitions between neighboring manifolds , i.e. @xmath235 , ( see fig . [ fig : spectrum ] ) . we exploit this fact and introduce an oscillating detuning of the form @xmath236 . if we tune @xmath237 to coincide with the gap between two given states , this detuning acts effectively as a laser that couples them resonantly with a rabi frequency that is proportional to @xmath238 . using this oscillating detuning , we want to transfer the population from the ground to the first excited state ( fig . [ fig : excitation]a ) . to do so , @xmath237 is tuned to be on resonance with the corresponding energy gap , i.e. , @xmath239 , and by a @xmath207-pulse we populate @xmath125 . one has to take into account that in the limit of @xmath46 the energy gap between any two neighboring manifolds is equal , i.e. , also higher lying excitations are populated . to avoid this effect and address only the @xmath125 state , we can choose a not too large value of @xmath19 . in this regime , the second order level shifts caused by @xmath64 and @xmath65 , that are roughly given by @xmath74 and @xmath75 , respectively ( see section [ sec : energy ] ) , become increasingly important . in particular , as it is sketched in fig . [ fig : excitation]a , the gap between @xmath240 and any of the @xmath151 levels becomes more and more different from @xmath241 and , as a consequence , the unwanted transitions fall out of resonance . analogously , the same procedure could be used to address the two - fermion many - particle states ( see fig . [ fig : excitation]b ) . the first @xmath207-pulse resonant with the @xmath242 transition , is followed by another @xmath207-pulse with @xmath237 tuned to coincide with the energy gap of the specific @xmath243 transition , @xmath244 . the separation between neighboring @xmath151 states is of the order of @xmath44 and the rabi frequency of the transition is proportional to @xmath238 . as a consequence , to populate only a single level of the two - fermion manifold , the parameters have to accomplish that @xmath245 and , at the same time , @xmath238 has to be large enough in order to perform the transfer at a time interval that is much shorter than the lifetime of the rydberg state . . * a : * in a first step , the population is transferred by a @xmath207-pulse to the single - fermion state by tuning the frequency of the detuning on resonance with the gap @xmath246 . * b : * a second @xmath207-pulse with @xmath237 tuned to match @xmath247 addresses the corresponding @xmath151 state , bearing in mind that @xmath245 in this step.,width=321 ] in this work we have studied the collective excitation of a laser - driven rydberg gas confined to a ring lattice . we have focused on the regime in which the interaction between the highly excited states is much weaker than the laser field . we found that the corresponding system can be described as a chain of spinless fermions whose dynamics is driven by the @xmath53-model . this hamiltonian can be analytically solved and , by exploiting the symmetries of the system , we were able to completely characterize the many - particle states arising . in particular , we have shown that the first excited state of the hamiltonian corresponds to a spin wave or to an excitation which is completely delocalized all over the lattice . the two - fermion states could be expressed as a superposition of excitation pairs and an investigation of their density - density correlation function has been performed . we have demonstrated that the qualitative behavior of these correlations differs substantially from one state to another of the same two - fermion manifold , going from a smoothly decaying function to a pronounced correlation - anticorrelation pattern . the analytical eigenenergies of the @xmath53-hamiltonian were compared to the numerical exact ones of the complete hamiltonian , and excellent agreement between both results has been found . finally , we have investigated several paths for the selective excitation of the many - particle states . one of them relies on the variation of the laser parameters with time , finding trajectories from the initial to a given final many - body state . the other possibility we have presented makes use of an oscillating detuning which allows to access excitations starting from the ground state of the hamiltonian . in each step , a @xmath207-pulse is performed with the frequency of the oscillation matching the energy gap between the involved states . throughout this work we have considered an homogeneous occupation of the sites of the ring lattice . the situation of having a randomly fluctuating number of atoms per site would effectively lead to a disorder potential for the fermions , as outlined in ref . this would imply as well a change in the symmetry properties of the system , so that more states become accessible by a time - evolution ( e.g. , @xmath177 possible single - fermion states instead of only the fully - symmetric one ) . in addition , we have assumed that the atoms are strongly localized , @xmath248 ( fig . [ fig : lattice ] ) . taking into consideration the finite width of the wave packet would lead to another kind of disorder , this time associated to the interaction parameter @xmath44 . as we have pointed out , the main problem one has to face in this system is the limited lifetime of the rydberg states , which is in the order of several microseconds . one could think of preparing a parallel system to the one described in this work but using polar molecules @xcite , to overcome this lifetime limitation . an interesting extension is also the investigation of the system in two - dimensional geometries , e.g. , triangular or square lattices , as well as several rings disposed in concentric or cylindric configurations . in all these cases , the symmetries of the particular arrangement of the sites might give rise to new interesting many - particle states .

we study the collective excitation of a gas of highly excited atoms confined to a large spacing ring lattice , where the ground and the excited states are coupled resonantly via a laser field . our attention is focused on the regime where the interaction between the highly excited atoms is very weak in comparison to the rabi frequency of the laser . we demonstrate that in this case the many - body excitations of the system can be expressed in terms of free spinless fermions . the complex many - particle states arising in this regime are characterized and their properties , e.g. their correlation functions , are studied . in addition we investigate how one can actually experimentally access some of these many - particle states by a temporal variation of the laser parameters .

1011.3732

experiments on single photons coupled strongly to single ( artificial ) atoms @xcite allow for in - depth studies of photon - atom interactions on a single particle level . this has first been demonstrated with individual atoms coupled to microwave @xcite and later optical cavity fields @xcite . in solids , strong coupling has been achieved with quantum dots @xcite and superconducting circuits @xcite . despite the diversity of physical realizations the coherent exchange of energy between photons and atoms can be described in all these systems by a generic model named after jaynes and cummings @xcite . in circuit quantum electrodynamics experiments , superconducting quantum circuits are coupled to single microwave photons in a planar transmission line cavity @xcite . in this configuration , coupling strengths exceed decay rates by two orders of magnitude , and strong resonant coupling between a microwave cavity and a single @xcite or multiple @xcite superconducting qubits has been observed . in the case of finite detuning between a single qubit and a resonator mode , energy exchange between the individual systems is strongly suppressed due to energy conservation . in this dispersive regime , a residual interaction mediated via virtual photons induces a finite lamb @xcite and ac - stark shift @xcite of the energy levels . for two qubits coupled to a common cavity field , the same mechanism leads to an interaction mediated by virtual photons @xcite as experimentally demonstrated @xcite . this coupling is similar to the j - coupling of interacting nuclear spins as observed in nuclear magnetic resonance experiments ( e.g.@xcite ) . it is also a dominant interaction of double quantum dots , where the exchange splitting between spin singlet and spin triplet state can be used to control a logical qubit state encoded in a two - electron spin - state @xcite . in contrast to these local interactions , and also opposed to the direct coupling of superconducting quantum circuits @xcite , the coupling mediated via virtual resonator photons allows for a long - range interaction between two or more distant superconducting qubits . in the context of quantum information processing , it can be used to realize two - qubit gates @xcite with superconducting qubits @xcite . in this paper we measure the exchange coupling as a function of detuning of two qubits from a single or multiple resonator modes and characterize the symmetry properties of the coupled system . in section [ sec : jcoupling ] the inter - qubit coupling mechanism and its spectroscopic measurement is outlined . in section [ sec : singlemode ] the coupling near a single resonator mode is analyzed . in section [ sec : multimode ] higher harmonic modes of the transmission line resonator are included in the analysis . section [ sec : darkstate ] and [ sec : twophoton ] describe the formation of a dark state at the avoided level crossing and the observation of a two - photon transition from the ground to the doubly excited state that is allowed only at qubit resonance . in our experiments two superconducting qubits are dispersively coupled to a microwave cavity , see fig . [ fig : setup ] . the quantum circuits are realized as weakly anharmonic transmon qubits @xcite and the cavity is formed by a @xmath0 coplanar - waveguide resonator supporting several harmonic modes @xcite . to input and output transmission lines . two transmons are capacitively coupled to the resonator at its ends ( @xmath1 ) . additional ac - signal lines are capacitively coupled to the qubits ( not used in the experiments ) . ( b ) optical micrograph of a transmon qubit . ( c ) schematics of the measurement setup . the state of the qubit is determined by measuring the transmission of the rf signal through the transmission line cavity modeled as an lcr oscillator . when a spectroscopy signal ( spec ) is resonant with a qubit transition , the resonance frequency of the cavity is shifted and the change in transmission amplitude is recorded at the analog - digital converter ( adc ) after down - conversion with a local oscillator ( lo ) @xcite . the qubit frequencies can be tuned independently with superconducting coils ( sc coil 1/2).,width=325 ] in the dispersive regime , the detuning @xmath2 is larger than the coupling strength @xmath3 of both qubits ( @xmath4 ) to each resonator mode @xmath5 . the relevant hamiltonian @xmath6 is obtained by adiabatically eliminating the direct qubit - resonator interaction of the qubits for each harmonic mode @xmath7 in the jaynes - cummings hamiltonian @xcite . the first term denotes the qubit hamiltonian with lamb - shifted transition frequencies @xmath8 from the ground to the first excited state . higher transmon levels do not play a role in our experiments and are therefore neglected . the second term in eq . ( [ eq : hj ] ) describes the resonator modes with frequencies @xmath9 , integer multiples of the fundamental frequency @xmath10 , shifted by the cavity pulls @xmath11 @xcite . finally , the third term describes the effective qubit - qubit coupling , also called j - coupling or transverse exchange coupling , @xmath12 a flip - flop interaction mediated by virtual photon exchange . the transverse exchange coupling in eq . ( [ eq : j ] ) leads to an avoided level crossing of the excited qubit states @xcite . at qubit - resonance , where @xmath13 , the size of the splitting is @xmath14 . the new eigenstates are the symmetric triplet states @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 , as well as the anti - symmetric singlet state @xmath18 , see fig . [ fig:2qsplitting](a ) . in the maximally entangled states @xmath19 a single excitation is shared between the two qubits . more generally , for @xmath20 the eigenstates of the hamiltonian in eq . ( [ eq : hj ] ) can be parametrized as @xmath21 with the mixing angle @xmath22 determined by @xmath23 and @xmath24 . the separable qubit states @xmath25 and @xmath26 are asymptotically realized , @xmath27 and @xmath28 , for large qubit - qubit detunings ( @xmath29 ) , as indicated in fig . [ fig:2qsplitting](b ) . we have performed two sets of experiments using samples with different parameters listed in table [ tab : parameters ] . in these experiments , the energy spectrum of the coupled qubits is probed by monitoring the transmission through the resonator while applying a second spectroscopy tone @xcite at frequency @xmath30 . for the spectroscopy measurement shown in fig . [ fig:2qsplitting](b ) , the first qubit is kept at a fixed frequency @xmath31 and the second qubit frequency @xmath32 is swept across the avoided crossing by changing its flux bias using external coils . the value of @xmath33 can be extracted from a fit of the upper and lower branch of the avoided crossing to the function @xmath34 where @xmath35 is in this parameter regime an approximately linear function of the flux @xmath36 threading the second qubit loop . the fit parameters are the transition frequency @xmath37 of the first qubit and the coupling strength @xmath33 . both are determined with a precision of typically better than @xmath38 . in this particular example we find @xmath39 and @xmath40 . + two additional features are observed in fig . [ fig:2qsplitting](b ) . first , a third spectroscopic line centered between the upper and the lower branch appears at higher drive powers . this is a signature of a two - photon transition from the ground state ( @xmath15 ) to the doubly excited state ( @xmath16 ) of the coupled qubit system that is only allowed directly at the anti - crossing . this is discussed in section [ sec : twophoton ] . second , the upper branch shows a transition to a dark resonance at the avoided crossing , which can be explained by the symmetry of the states with respect to the spectroscopic drive , see section [ sec : darkstate ] . according to eq . ( [ eq : j ] ) the coupling @xmath41 scales inversely with the detuning @xmath42 , considering only a single resonator mode . we have recorded the avoided crossing between the two qubits at different detunings @xmath43 from the fundamental mode of the resonator using a spectroscopic measurement performed on sample a. the corresponding parameters are listed in table [ tab : parameters ] . the measured values of @xmath33 shown in fig . [ fig:2qsplitting](c ) are determined for each detuning from a fit as described in section [ sec : jcoupling ] . .parameters of samples a and b as determined from independent measurements . @xmath44 denotes the fundamental frequency , @xmath45 the cavity decay rate , @xmath46 the charging energy , @xmath47 the maximum josephson energy and @xmath48 the coupling strength to the fundamental cavity mode of qubits @xmath49 and @xmath50 . [ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ] ) . ( b ) spectroscopic measurements of the anti - crossing in the regions labeled a , b , c and d in ( a).,width=325 ] the spectroscopic line between upper and lower branch of the avoided level - crossing in fig . [ fig:2qsplitting](b ) is a two - photon transition from the ground state @xmath15 to the doubly excited state @xmath16 . similarly , this transition has also been observed in a phase qubit coupled coherently to a two level fluctuator in the tunnel barrier of the josephson junction comprising the qubit @xcite and in molecular spectroscopy of two nearby molecules @xcite . it becomes visible only at the center of the avoided level crossing , again a manifestation of the symmetry properties of the system . the rate of the corresponding two - photon transition @xcite @xmath51 is given by a sum over the intermediate states @xmath52 . off the avoided crossing the qubits are effectively decoupled . in this case the intermediate states are @xmath53 . the transition is then prohibited due to destructive interference between the two possible paths , @xmath54 or @xmath55 , connecting the ground to the doubly excited state . due to the opposite sign of the detunings @xmath56 , the two terms in the sum cancel and the transition rate @xmath57 . with the qubits at resonance , the intermediate states are @xmath58 and one term in the sum vanishes due to the forbidden transition to the dark state . with only one possible path connecting the @xmath59 to the @xmath60 state , no interference takes place and the transition becomes allowed . the enhanced transition rate can be employed for directly creating the maximally entangled state @xmath61 . we have analyzed the coupling between two distant qubits mediated by the harmonic modes of a resonator . we have observed an overall increase of the exchange coupling with frequency as expected from a model including higher - harmonic modes of the coplanar waveguide resonator . good qualitative agreement over a wide frequency range between the dispersive model and experimental data is obtained when taking spurious resonances of the coplanar waveguide in addition to the coplanar waveguide modes into account . hence , measurements of the transverse inter - qubit coupling can be employed to detect and investigate spurious global coupling channels between distant qubits , complementary to measurements of single qubit spectra used to detect spurious local resonances @xcite . how many higher harmonic modes to include in the theory , i. e. where to set a high - frequency cut - off , can , however , not be decided on the basis of current measurements . in addition , we have observed dark states and enhanced two - photon absorption at the avoided level crossing in spectroscopic measurements . these characteristic features are based on the relation between the symmetry of the drive and the singlet and triplet states formed by the coupled qubits , which also explains the dark state at either the lower or higher energy branch . these symmetries also affect decay processes of singlet and triplet states and , together with the non - trivial environment formed by the microwave resonator , dissipative dynamics of separable and entangled states can be studied . the exchange coupling can also be useful for building two - qubit gates when fast flux - pulses are applied to tune the qubits into resonance . in the context of quantum information processing , the resulting swap gate forms a universal two - qubit gate with short operation times . moreover , the transverse exchange coupling mechanism described in this article mediates interaction not only between two , but an arbitrary number of distant qubits , an interesting playground for studies of collective phenomena with superconducting circuits , where the interaction is not restricted to nearest - neighbours . the authors acknowledge useful discussions with a. blais . also , the group of m. siegel is acknowledged for the preparation of niobium films . this work was supported by swiss national science foundation ( snf ) , austrian science foundation ( fwf ) and eth zurich . the coupling @xmath62 to the resonator is proportional to the rms voltage fluctuations of the vacuum field @xmath63 at the position of the @xmath64-th qubit and to the off - diagonal matrix element @xcite of the charge operator @xmath65 , @xmath66 the prefactor @xmath67 is determined by the geometry of the circuit used in our experiments . in the large @xmath68 limit , realized in the devices , the matrix element is proportional to the square - root of the qubit transition frequency , @xmath69 . the vacuum field @xmath63 is proportional to the square root of the mode frequency , @xmath70 @xcite . for a single qubit on resonance with the @xmath5-th resonator mode , @xmath71 , the scaling of the qubit - resonator coupling is approximately linear in the mode number , @xmath72 . to verify the linearity of the coupling strength we have measured the vacuum rabi splitting of a single qubit up to the third harmonic resonator mode ( fig . [ fig : coupling+permutation](a ) ) using qubit 2 of sample b ( for the parameters , see table [ tab : parameters ] ) . the simple estimate shows good agreement with the measured coupling strengths @xmath73 ( dashed line in fig . [ fig : coupling+permutation](a ) ) . the parameter @xmath74 , obtained from a linear fit to the analytic model in the large @xmath68 limit @xcite , agrees with the designed value within 10% . a numerical simulation of the transmon including four energy levels can explain also the slight deviations from the linear dependence at high frequencies ( solid red line , fig . [ fig : coupling+permutation](a ) ) . in the case of two resonant qubits with identical coupling strength to the @xmath5-th harmonic mode , the exchange coupling strength is , according to eq . ( [ eq : j ] ) , linear in the qubit transition frequency @xmath75 and the mode frequency @xmath76 , @xmath77 when the detuning of the qubits to the resonator mode is varied , the frequency @xmath76 of the @xmath5-th resonator mode is constant and @xmath33 scales proportional to the transition frequency @xmath75 . of qubit 2 to the @xmath5-th harmonic mode in sample b. ( b ) expectation value of the permutation operator @xmath78 for the eigenstates of the jaynes - cummings hamiltonian as a function of qubit - qubit detuning @xmath79.,width=325 ] the spectroscopic drive @xmath80 @xcite anti - commutes with the permutation operator @xmath81 @xmath82_+ \equiv h_d p + p h_d = 0.\ ] ] this relation can be fulfilled only if the drive transforms a symmetric ( @xmath83 ) to an anti - symmetric ( @xmath84 ) state , or vice versa , such that @xmath85_+ \psi_{s } & = h_d p \psi_{s } + p h_d \psi_{s}\\\nonumber & = h_d \psi_{s } + p \psi_{a}\\\nonumber & = \psi_{a } - \psi_{a } = 0 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the symmetry of the coupled qubit states ( see figure [ fig:2qsplitting](a ) ) can be characterized by the corresponding expectation value of the permutation operator @xmath86 . @xmath87 is one for the @xmath15 and the @xmath16-state , i. e. the @xmath15 and @xmath16 states are symmetric for all detunings . for the symmetric and anti - symmetric states @xmath88 and @xmath89 formed at zero qubit - qubit detuning , @xmath87 is @xmath49 or @xmath90 indicating that these states are eigenstates of @xmath91 with well - defined symmetry . for non - zero detuning between the qubits , @xmath92 , the eigenstates of the hamiltonian ( [ eq : hj ] ) do not have well - defined symmetry and @xmath87 approaches asymptotically zero for large detunings ( fig . [ fig : coupling+permutation](b ) ) . hence , no strict selection rules are imposed off the level crossing and the transition between ground state and single excited states is allowed .

microwave cavities with high quality factors enable coherent coupling of distant quantum systems . virtual photons lead to a transverse exchange interaction between qubits , when they are non - resonant with the cavity but resonant with each other . we experimentally probe the inverse scaling of the inter - qubit coupling with the detuning from a cavity mode and its proportionality to the qubit - cavity interaction strength . we demonstrate that the enhanced coupling at higher frequencies is mediated by multiple higher - harmonic cavity modes . moreover , in the case of resonant qubits , the symmetry properties of the system lead to an allowed two - photon transition to the doubly excited qubit state and the formation of a dark state .

astro-ph0209230

the distant globular cluster palomar 13 has been found to have a very high m / l ratio of @xmath0 and its profile can be well fitted either by a king profile with a power - law tail or a nfw model [ 1 ] with scale radius @xmath1pc and central density @xmath2 . a possible explanation is that this distant cluster @xmath3 is one of the numerous dark clumps predicted by cdm scenarios , which was not destroyed by the galactic tidal field . it may be a disrupted cluster as well , out of dynamical equilibrium . here we assume that the nfw profile is the signature of a halo made of cold particles . physics beyond the standard model could be supersymmetry . the lowest massive supersymmetric particle , i.e. the neutralino , is a natural candidate for cdm . if r - parity is conserved the neutralino is stable , is its own antiparticle and has a very small cross - section for annihilation . we assume that the halo of palomar 13 is made of neutralinos and calculate the flux in high energy @xmath4-rays due to their annihilation . theoretical physics beyond the standard model is reviewed by j. ellis in this book . the susy benchmark models have been proposed to provide a common way of comparing the discovery potential of future accelerators [ 2 ] . these scenarios correspond to 13 configurations of the 5 msugra parameters with the trilinear coupling parameter @xmath5 set to 0 . the models fulfill the conditions imposed by lep measurements , @xmath6 result and relic density constraint @xmath7 . we calculate the @xmath4 fluxes for the benchmark models bcgil in the `` bulk '' region with our current mc simulation programs : darksusy [ 3 ] and suspect [ 4 ] . the simultaneous use of the suspect and darksusy package allows to perform the rge evolution from the gut scale to the ewsb scale . the fluxes ( in @xmath8 ) obtained by varying the threshold energy and integrated within @xmath9 are shown in the following figure . the main points are that we need to work at low energy threshold and very low flux @xmath10 . these fluxes are not out of reach but ground - based ongoing instruments will have to be improved by one order of magnitude for that purpose . an array of 5 hesses ( each including four 15-m class telescopes like in hess ) , operating in adjacent areas at 5000 m altitude , would reach a flux limit of @xmath11 at 25 gev in 400 h. * with that flux limit most of the neutralino parameter space in the galactic center could be explored . this is roughly the instrument needed to demonstrate or disprove supersymmetry in astrophysics . * p. cot , s.g . djorgovski , g. meylan , s. castro , j.k . mccarthy , 2002 astro - ph/0203410 j. ellis , j.l . feng , a. ferstl , , k.t . matchev , & k. olive , 2001 , astro - ph/0110225 http://www.physto.se/~ edsjo / darksusy/ http://www.lpm.univ - montp2.fr:7082/~ kneur / suspect.html

the distant globular cluster palomar 13 has been found to have a very high mass - to - light ratio and its profile can be well fitted either by a king model with a tail , or with a nfw model [ 1 ] . this cluster may be the first case of the many clumps predicted by cdm simulations that would not be disrupted by the galactic halo potential . we make the hypothesis that pal 13 is made of neutralinos and run the darksuspect code to estimate the high - energy photon flux due to the annihilation of neutralinos through various channels in some benchmark scenarios . these low fluxes may be used as targets to be reached in proposals for future ground - based high altitude cerenkov telescopes .

astro-ph0507445

the first of the four veritas telescopes has been in routine operation since january 2005 at the basecamp of the fred lawrence whipple observatory at mt . hopkins , arizona . the site is 1275 m above sea level . several tev gamma ray sources have been detected @xcite and the construction of the other telescopes is underway . a detailed description of the first veritas telescope , called _ telescope 1 _ in the following , can be found in @xcite , a full description of the veritas project in @xcite . for the following comparison of data with monte carlo simulations , gamma - ray candidates are extracted from observations of the crab nebula ( 3.9 h on source ) and mrk 421 ( 4.2h on source ) in march and april 2005 . the data is taken in on - off mode at elevations above 60@xmath4 and in good weather conditions . images are parameterized using standard second moment analysis @xcite . image pixels are selected by a two level cut on the charge per pixel . picture and boundary thresholds are pedestal plus four respective two times the pedestal variance . the cuts on image parameters to select gamma - rays are @xmath5 , length / size @xmath6 , length @xmath7 , @xmath8 width @xmath9 , and @xmath10 distance @xmath11 . alpha is the orientation angle of the image ellipse relative to the direction of the source position . length and width describe the shape of the image , and distance the location of the image centroid with respect to the source position . only events with at least five image pixels are taken into account . these cuts results in a combined significance of about 21.7@xmath12 and roughly 900 gamma - ray candidates for the observations of the crab nebula and mrk 421 . the crab data set is statistically limited due to the fact that the observation started very late in the season . a complete chain of monte carlo simulations has been developed . it consists of air shower simulations with corsika @xcite and a detailed simulation of the telescope response @xcite . corsika version 6.20 is used with the hadronic interaction models qgsjet for primary energies above 500 gev and fluka below . simulated hydrogen , helium , and oxygen nuclei induced air showers are produced in an energy range from 10 gev ( 150 gev for oxygen ) to 50 tev at different elevations . spectral indices are taken from fits to balloon measurements @xcite . the shower cores are distributed randomly on a circular area with a radius of 1000 m around the telescope . the isotropic distribution of the cosmic ray incident angles is simulated by randomizing the shower directions in a cone of radius 3.5@xmath4 around the pointing direction of the telescope . primary gamma - rays are simulated with a crab - like spectrum in an energy range from 10 gev to 10 tev on a circular area at the ground with radius 450 m . scatter areas are chosen according to the lateral cherenkov light distributions of hadronic and gamma - ray showers . measurements of the atmospheric properties at the current site of telescope 1 and the final one at kitt peak are currently in progress . the calculations described here use the u.s . standard atmosphere , which does not always reflect the properties of the atmosphere in southern arizona . atmospheric extinction values are estimated by modtran 4 @xcite assuming 50 km visibility at 550 nm at ground level . the photo - electron rate per pmt is measured to be 100 - 200 mhz . this corresponds to a night sky background rate of @xmath13 photons @xmath14 m@xmath2 s@xmath3 sr@xmath3 , which is used in the simulations . the telescope simulations consist of two parts , the propagation of cherenkov photons through the optical system and the response of the camera and electronics . the geometrical properties of the optical system is fully implemented in the simulation . misalignment of the mirrors and their surface roughness is taken into account . the camera configuration is that of april 2005 , i.e. a 499 pixel camera with 1 1/8 phototubes without light cones . the field of view of the camera is 3.5@xmath4 . the response of the pmts to single photons has been measured ; the single photo - electron pulse has a rise time of 3.3 ns and a width of 6.5 ns @xcite . in the simulations a signal in a pmt is created by adding up single photo - electron pulses with appropriate amplitude and time jitters applied . electronic noise and all efficiencies , including mirror reflectivities , geometrical , quantum , and collection efficiencies , and losses due to signal transmission have been modeled . the pulses are digitized into 2ns samples with a trace length of 24 samples reflecting the properties of the fadc system . the trigger simulation utilizes a simplified model of the constant fraction discriminator , which is the first stage of the veritas multi - level trigger , and a full realization of the pattern trigger , requiring three adjacent pixels above threshold in a time window of 5 ns . the currently used trigger threshold of 70 mv corresponds to about 6.7 photoelectrons . the output of the telescope simulations , i.e. fadc traces for all pmts , are written to disk in the veritas raw data format . the analysis steps , which include pedestal calculation , image cleaning , image parametrisation , and source reconstruction , are exactly the same for simulated and real data . comparison of image parameter distributions from observation data ( closed symbols ) and monte carlo calculations ( open symbols).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=41.0% ] comparison of image parameter distributions from observation data ( closed symbols ) and monte carlo calculations ( open symbols).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=41.0% ] comparison of image parameter distributions from observation data ( closed symbols ) and monte carlo calculations ( open symbols).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=41.0% ] comparison of image parameter distributions from observation data ( closed symbols ) and monte carlo calculations ( open symbols).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=41.0% ] the raw trigger rate of telescope 1 with trigger conditions as described above is between 140 and 150 hz , mainly depending on elevation . dead time losses due to readout are @xmath1510% , the corrected trigger rate is consequentially @xmath15150 - 160 hz . the simulation of the cosmic ray background results in trigger rates of 101 hz from air showers induced by protons , 26 hz from helium nuclei , and @xmath155 hz from nuclei of the cno group for an elevation of 70@xmath4 . the monte carlo calculations reproduce the observed trigger rate with an accuracy of @xmath1515% , which is acceptable , taking into account an estimated uncertainty in the cosmic ray fluxes of @xmath1525% and various systematic uncertainties in the modeling of the telescope . second moment image parameters are the standard tool in analyzing data from iacts . the suppression of the hadronic and muonic background as well as the estimation of the primary energy depends strongly on the correct predictions of the image parameters from monte carlo calculations . fig.[fig1 ] shows a comparison of image parameter distributions from real data and simulations . the alpha , distance , length , and width distributions show very good agreement and proof the validity of the simulations . the described cuts on image parameters are chosen to extract a sample of gamma ray candidates with very little contamination from background events . about 10% of all gamma ray showers are accepted with these cuts , rejecting @xmath1599.9% of all cosmic ray showers . these hard cuts are necessary for data from a single telescope to reject the large background due to local muons . ( telescope arrays are insensitive to such single muons and can be run and analyzed with looser cuts . ) left : effective area of telescope 1 after @xmath0-selection cuts ( filled circles ) and extended supercuts ( filled triangles ) . right : energy spectrum of the crab nebula compared with earlier results from whipple @xcite and hegra @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=41.0% ] left : effective area of telescope 1 after @xmath0-selection cuts ( filled circles ) and extended supercuts ( filled triangles ) . right : energy spectrum of the crab nebula compared with earlier results from whipple @xcite and hegra @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=41.0% ] the effective area of telescope 1 after cuts is shown in fig.[fig2 ] ( left ) . most of the high - energy events fail the hard @xmath0-selection cuts due to the cut on distance . this is different for the application of extended supercuts @xcite , which do not result in a similar good rejection of background events , but take the dependence of the image parameters on image size into account . the maximum effective area after extended supercuts is @xmath16 m@xmath17 . the measured gamma ray rate from the observation of the crab nebula is @xmath18 @xmath0s / min . using the crab spectra reported in @xcite results in a simulated gamma ray rate from the crab nebula of 2.2 @xmath0s / min . the energy threshold of a cherenkov telescope is conventionally defined as the position of the peak of the energy spectrum of the source convoluted with the effective area curve of the detector . according to this definition , the threshold is 150 gev at trigger level , 160 gev after applying extended super cuts , and 370 gev after applying the hard cuts described earlier . the right - hand side of fig.[fig2 ] shows the reconstructed energy spectrum of the crab nebula after applying extended supercuts to the data set . a power law fit to the data points results in a spectral index of @xmath19 and a flux constant of @xmath20 m@xmath2s@xmath3tev@xmath3 ( statistical errors only ) . this agrees well with earlier measurements by other telescopes . the agreement of the monte carlo simulations with observational data shows that we have a good understanding of the first veritas telescope and that the design performance is being met . the final configuration of veritas with four telescopes will have a significant higher sensitivity and an energy threshold of 110 gev @xcite . this research is supported by grants from the u.s . department of energy , the national science foundation , the smithsonian institution , by nserc in canada , by science foundation ireland and by pparc in the uk . gernot maier acknowledges the support as a feodor lynen fellow of the alexander von humboldt foundation . j. holder et al . , _ status and performance of the first veritas telescope _ , 29th icrc , pune ( 2005 ) t. weekes et al . , astroparticle physics , 17 , 221 ( 2002 ) a. m. hillas , proc . 19th int . cosmic ray conf . , 3 , 445 ( 1985 ) d. heck et al . , report fzka 6019 , forschungszentrum karlsruhe ( 1998 ) c.duke & s.lebohec , http://www.physics.utah.edu/gammaray/grisu/ j. hrandel , astroparticle physics , 19 , 193 ( 2003 ) kneizys et al . , _ the modtran 2/3 report and lowtran 7 model _ , technical report , ontar corporation ( 1996 ) g. mohanty et al . , astroparticle physics , 9 , 15 ( 1998 ) a.m. hillas et al.,the astrophysical journal , 503 , 744 ( 1998 ) f. aharonian et al . , the astrophysical journal , 614 , 897 ( 2004 ) s. fegan , proc . 28th int . cosmic ray conf . , 2847 ( 2003 )

the very high energy radiation telescope array ( veritas ) is a system of four imaging cherenkov telescopes currently under construction at kitt peak , arizona , usa . the first telescope has been in operation at the mt . hopkins basecamp since january 2005 . we present here detailed monte carlo simulations of the telescope response to extensive air showers . the energy threshold for this stand - alone telescope is calculated to be 150 gev at trigger level , the @xmath0-ray trigger rate is 22 @xmath0s / min . image parameter distributions , and the quality of gamma - hadron discrimination are calculated and show good agreement with distributions from observations of background cosmic rays and high - energy gamma - rays from the crab nebula and markarian 421 . the energy spectrum of the crab is reconstructed as @xmath1 m@xmath2s@xmath3tev@xmath3 .

1112.4826

one possible classification of evolutionary games @xcite is to those that are governed by pairwise interactions and to those that are governed by group interactions . the prisoner s dilemma and the snowdrift game @xcite , as well as the stag - hunt game @xcite , are classical examples of evolutionary games that are governed by pairwise interactions . the public goods game , on the other hand , is a typical example of an evolutionary game that is governed by group interactions . similarly as by the transition from two - body to many - body interactions in many branches of physics , in evolutionary games too the transition from pairwise to group interactions leads to a substantial increase in complexity . for example , reciprocity @xcite , _ i.e. _ the act of returning favor for a favor , is straightforward in games governed by pairwise interactions . as there are only two players involved at each instance of the game , it is relatively easy to decide what to do based on what the opponent has done in the past @xcite . in games governed by group interactions , however , it is much more difficult to keep track of actions of all the other players , and hence it is difficult to reciprocate . the same argument is valid for punishment @xcite , where unlike returning positive actions , the goal is to identify those that inflict harm or act antisocial and sanction them accordingly . regardless of the distinction between pairwise and group interactions , the central theme of evolutionary game theory is the successful evolution of cooperation . according to darwin , natural selection favors the fittest and the most successful individuals , which implies an innate selfishness that greatly challenges the concept of cooperation @xcite . to cooperate namely means to sacrifice some fraction of personal benefits for the sake of social welfare . the opposite strategy is defection , implying that players who defect will always try to maximize their fitness regardless of the consequences this might have for the society . since the focus here is on games governed by group interactions , we may use the definition of the public goods game to illustrate the key difference between cooperation and defection as follows . in a group consisting of @xmath0 players , those that cooperate will contribute @xmath1 to the public good , while those that defect will contribute nothing . note that on a larger scale , the contribution of cooperators can be considered as a contribution to society , which will typically contain a large number of such groups . all the contributions will then be multiplied by a factor @xmath2 , which is typically larger than @xmath1 to take into account synergetic effects of collaborative efforts , and subsequently the resulting amount will be shared amongst all the group members irrespective of their initial contribution . from this definition it follows that defectors acquire an evolutionary advantage over cooperators by withholding the initial contribution to the public good , and from the viewpoint of each individual defection is thus clearly the rational strategy to choose . from the viewpoint of the group and the society as a whole , however , cooperation is the optimal strategy as then the multiplication factor @xmath2 will have the biggest impact and accordingly the welfare of the society will be maximized . the fact that defection maximizes individual payoffs while cooperation maximizes social prosperity , and thus that what is best for an individual is opposite to what is the best for society , is traditionally refereed to as a social dilemma . failure to maintain cooperation in such a case leads to the so - called `` tragedy of the commons '' @xcite , where nobody contributes to the public good ( everybody defects ) and the society is therefore destined to go bankrupt . rather surprisingly , and in fact contradictive to the darwinian concept of acting so as to maximize personal fitness , economic experiments on public goods games indicate that humans cooperate much more in such situations than expected @xcite , and in so doing these experiments call for the identification of mechanisms that can explain the successful evolution of cooperation . introducing additional strategies besides cooperation and defection has proven to be very effective . for example , if players are given the chance to abstain from the public goods game by not contributing but also by not taking part in the distribution of accumulated payoffs , cooperation may be promoted by means of the spontaneous emergence of cyclic dominance between the three competing strategies @xcite . the introduction of peer - punishers , _ i.e. _ those that are willing to bare additional costs in order to sanction defectors , has also proven to be effective for the promotion of cooperation @xcite , as was the introduction of pool - punishers that contribute to the establishment of sanctioning institutions @xcite . rewarding cooperative players instead of punishing defectors has also been considered as an additional strategy that may promote cooperation @xcite , and the emerging `` stick versus carrot '' dilemma ( whether to sanction defectors or reward cooperators ) has recently received ample attention @xcite . interestingly , random explorations of these additional strategies , termed conveniently as exploration dynamics " @xcite , may also substantially elevate the level of cooperation in a society . driven by the application of methods from statistical physics ( see @xcite for a comprehensive review ) , as well as by the fascinating complexity arising from the evolutionary competition between the strategies , physicists have also made important contributions to the understanding of the successful evolution of cooperation . foremost , research published in recent years has made it clear that heterogeneities amongst players play a crucial role by the evolution of cooperation . scale - free networks , for example , have been recognized as very potent promoters of cooperative behavior @xcite . in fact , evolutionary games on complex and coevolving networks @xcite in general tend to promote cooperation past the boundaries imposed by regular lattices @xcite . similarly , heterogeneities in strategy adoption probabilities can also enhance cooperation @xcite , especially if the strategy adoption is favored from the more influential players @xcite . heterogeneities can also be introduced directly to payoffs in terms of noise @xcite or quenched diversity @xcite , whereby cooperators are promoted as well provided the uncertainties are adequately adjusted and distributed . while the majority of previous works aimed at disentangling the impact of heterogeneity on the evolution of cooperation focused on games governed by pairwise interactions , recent results indicate @xcite that cooperation within the public goods game is also susceptible to the same mechanism of promotion . however , if payoffs are evaluated from public goods games in multiple groups , the indirect linkage of players due to their membership in the same groups may result in qualitatively different behavior @xcite as reported previously for games governed by pairwise interactions @xcite . this motivates us to examine to what extent strongly heterogeneous states do in fact promote the evolution of cooperation in games governed by group interactions . for this purpose , we study the evolution of cooperation in the public goods game on three types of regular graphs , namely on the square lattice , the triangular lattice , and the random regular graph ( rrg ) . these are characteristic for interaction graphs with ( square and triangular lattice ) and without ( rrg ) spatial structure , as well as for interaction graphs with zero ( square lattice and rrg ) and a high ( triangular lattice ) clustering coefficient , thus covering a broad plethora of properties that are known to vitally affect the evolution of cooperation @xcite . heterogeneity is then introduced by means of either a uniform or an exponential distribution of payoffs amongst the players , thereby violating the traditional assumption of equally distributed public goods amongst all group members . according to the statistical properties of the two considered distributions , exponentially distributed public goods give rise to strongly heterogeneous states , while uniformly distributed public goods correspond to moderate heterogeneities affecting the evolution of cooperation . unexpectedly , we find that moderate heterogeneities promote cooperation better than strongly heterogeneous states , which is not in agreement with results obtained previously for evolutionary games governed by pairwise interactions @xcite . the remainder of this paper is organized as follows . in the next section we describe the employed evolutionary public goods game and the interaction graphs , while in section 3 we present the results . lastly , we summarize our findings and compare them with those reported earlier for evolutionary games governed by pairwise interactions . assuming structured interactions defined by either the square lattice , the triangular lattice , or the random regular graph , as schematically depicted in figure [ graphs ] , @xmath3 players are arranged into overlapping groups of size @xmath0 such that every player is surrounded by its @xmath4 neighbors . accordingly , each individual belongs to @xmath5 different groups . initially each player on site @xmath6 is designated either as a cooperator ( @xmath7 ) or defector ( @xmath8 ) with equal probability . cooperators contribute a fixed amount ( here considered being equal to @xmath1 without loss of generality ) to the public good while defectors contribute nothing . the sum of all contributions in each group is multiplied by the factor @xmath2 and the resulting public goods are distributed amongst all the group members . if @xmath7 the payoff of player @xmath6 from every group @xmath9 is @xmath10 and if @xmath8 the payoff is @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the number of cooperators in group @xmath9 while @xmath13 is the scaling factor by means of which the heterogeneity in the distribution of public goods is introduced . the scaling factors are drawn randomly from either the uniform distribution @xmath14 or the exponential distribution @xmath15 . here @xmath16 are uniformly distributed random numbers from the unit interval , and @xmath17 in all cases , so that the average @xmath18 over all the players is zero . moreover , @xmath19 scales the magnitude of heterogeneity and will , together with @xmath2 , be considered as the key parameter affecting the evolution of cooperation . naturally , @xmath20 returns the traditional version of the game , while large @xmath19 lead to segregation of players , which may be additionally amplified by considering exponential rather than uniformly distributed @xmath13 . it should be noted that heterogeneity is here not quantified explicitly ( _ e.g. _ by means of standard deviation of @xmath13 ) , but rather it refers to the diversity of players in the sense of to what extend they can differ from one another . since the exponential distribution segregates the players much more than the uniform distribution , the former is referred to as being substantially more heterogeneous ( see also @xcite for explicit shapes of the two distributions and alternative ways of interpretation ) . related to this setup , it is important to note that quenched heterogeneities introduced via @xmath13 may evoke the existence of the griffiths phase @xcite , which has recently attracted considerable attention @xcite , also in studies concerning the evolution of cooperation @xcite . the essence of the problem of quenched heterogeneities for the extinction processes has been well described in @xcite , where it was shown that such systems are frequently characterized by patches of different sizes , providing better conditions for one of the strategies ( or species ) to survive . due to the localization , the subordinate strategy can die out very slowly on the separated ( or weakly interacting ) patches , with an average lifetime increasing with the patch size . noest @xcite demonstrated that for suitable conditions ( determined by the distribution of patch sizes ) the extinction of the subordinate strategy follows a power law , whereby the exponent depends on the parameters . the latter fact can cause serious technical difficulties in the classification of the final stationary state , especially related to the @xmath21 transition in game theoretical models , as demonstrated for example in figure 3 of @xcite , where it can be inferred that even very long simulation times might not be enough to reach the final stationary state , although the trend ( power law behavior ) clearly indicates the disappearance of the subordinate strategy in the limit when the time goes to infinity . we note that often the introduction of an additional time - dependence in the background can make the analysis more convenient . for example , if the quenched heterogeneities are varied on an extremely slow time scale ( much slower than is characteristic for the main evolutionary process ) , the final conclusions remain the same , yet the occasional variations can accelerate the extinction significantly . this approach seems viable for alleviating difficulties that are frequently associated with models entailing quenched heterogeneities . monte carlo simulations are carried out comprising the following elementary steps . first , a randomly selected player @xmath6 plays the public goods game with its @xmath0 partners as a member of all the @xmath22 groups . the payoff it thereby acquires is thus @xmath23 . next , player @xmath6 chooses one of its nearest neighbors at random , and the chosen co - player @xmath24 also acquires its payoff @xmath25 in the same way as player @xmath6 . finally , player @xmath6 enforces its strategy @xmath26 onto player @xmath24 with the probability @xmath27\}$ ] , where @xmath28 quantifies the uncertainty by strategy adoptions and @xmath0 normalizes the effect for different interaction graphs ( see @xcite for details concerning the selection of the @xmath29 value and the applied normalization ) . these three elementary steps [ 1 random selection of player @xmath6 and the determination of @xmath30 , 2 random selection of neighbor @xmath24 and the determination of @xmath25 , 3 attempted strategy transfer with probability @xmath31 are repeated consecutively , whereby each full monte carlo step ( mcs ) gives a chance for every player to enforce its strategy onto one of the neighbors once on average and is comprised of @xmath3 three elementary steps described above . the average fractions of cooperators ( @xmath32 ) and defectors ( @xmath33 ) in the population were determined in the stationary state after sufficiently long relaxation times . depending on the actual conditions ( proximity to extinction points and the typical size of emerging spatial patterns ) the linear system size was varied from @xmath34 to @xmath35 and the relaxation time was varied from @xmath36 to @xmath37 mcs to ensure proper accuracy . we start by presenting results obtained on the square lattice with @xmath38 ( depicted schematically in figure [ graphs ] left ) in figure [ sqr ] . the left panel features the full @xmath39 phase diagram for uniformly distributed public goods . focusing on the @xmath40 transition line ( depicted red ) , marking the survivability threshold of cooperators , we find that increasing values of @xmath19 continuously decrease the minimally required multiplication factor @xmath2 . from @xmath41 at @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( note that such weekly expressed heterogeneity actually returns the traditional version of the game where the public goods are distritbuted equally @xcite ) , the minimally required multiplication factor decreases to @xmath44 at @xmath45 , and further to @xmath46 at @xmath47 . importantly , note that such contradictory critical values of @xmath2 that are smaller than @xmath1 are possible only when individual @xmath13 can exceed @xmath0 , _ i.e. _ when some individuals can effectively collect shares of the public good also from players that are not within the same group . for the uniformly distributed public goods it is straightforward to determine that this happens when @xmath48 , which is also approximately where the critical multiplication factor @xmath2 dips below @xmath1 . for such high @xmath19 , however , the public goods game is essentially overridden and the stationary state is always @xmath49 , irrespective of @xmath2 ( within the mixed @xmath50 phase ) . the pure @xmath51 phase , _ i.e. _ @xmath52 , on the other hand , emerges only for intermediate values of @xmath19 , as depicted by the green line marking the @xmath21 transition . by comparing the results depicted in the left panel of figure [ sqr ] with those depicted in the right panel , we can observe that exponentially distributed public goods ( right ) on the square lattice fail to promote cooperation to the same extent as uniformly distributed public goods ( left ) . while the position of the @xmath40 transition line remains largely unaffected , the mixed @xmath50 phase is characterized by substantially lower values of @xmath53 ( brighter shades of blue prevail ) . moreover , the pure @xmath51 region is substantially smaller , and the override of the public goods game , where @xmath49 irrespective of @xmath2 ( within the mixed @xmath50 phase ) sets in already for @xmath54 ( see left panel of figure [ sqr ] ) . these observations indicate that strongly heterogeneous states ( constituted by exponentially distributed public goods ) may be less effective in warranting high levels of cooperation at low multiplication factors than moderately heterogeneous states ( constituted by uniformly distributed public goods ) . irrespective of the type of heterogeneity , however , the survivability of cooperators can be greatly enhanced , _ i.e. _ the minimally required @xmath2 for @xmath32 to be larger than zero greatly reduced . figure [ tri ] features the results of the same analysis as depicted in figure [ sqr ] , only that instead of the square lattice the triangular lattice was used as the interaction graph . the use of the triangular lattice is motivated by its high clustering coefficient ( note that the square lattice has the clustering coefficient equal to zero ) , which is a property that has been found crucial for the evolution of cooperation , especially by games governed by pairwise interactions @xcite . in particular , while interaction graphs with zero or negligible clustering coefficients are characterized by an optimal level of uncertainty at which cooperators can survive , as was reported in @xcite , interaction graphs with overlapping triangles ( which are inherent to the triangular lattice , as can be observed from figure [ graphs ] ) preclude such an observation , _ i.e. _ the @xmath40 phase boundary is monotonically descending towards lower @xmath2 in the @xmath55 limit . remarkably , recent results for games governed by group interactions indicate that there the interaction graph may play a less crucial role , since in fact joint memberships in the same groups effectively link players that are otherwise not directly connected @xcite . by comparing the results presented in figures [ sqr ] and [ tri ] for the same type of heterogeneity in @xmath13 , this is indeed fully confirmed as all the main features are identical . altogether , these results solidify the impression that strongly heterogeneous states in the public goods game can be less effective in warranting high levels of cooperation than moderately heterogeneous states . as the last type of interaction graph we consider the random regular graph ( rrg ) , which unlike the square lattice and the triangular lattice , lacks spatial structure . note that locally the random regular graph is similar to the bethe tree ( see figure [ graphs ] right ) . since the seminal paper by nowak and may @xcite clearly established spatial structure as an important agonist for the successful evolution of cooperation , it is certainly appropriate to test our results also against this variation moreover , due to the lack of spatial structure , there is an expected difference in the directed percolation universality class @xcite if compared to the square lattice . results presented in figure [ rrg ] depict full @xmath39 phase diagrams for uniformly ( left ) and exponentially ( right ) distributed public goods . compared to results obtained for the square lattice ( see figure [ sqr ] ) , on the rrg too the position of the @xmath40 transition line remains largely unaffected by the type of distribution of @xmath13 . moreover , the mixed @xmath50 phase for exponentially distributed public goods ( right panel of figure [ rrg ] ) is characterized by substantially lower values of @xmath53 ( brighter shades of blue prevail ) and the pure @xmath51 region is altogether missing . it is thus from results obtained for the rrg that in fact the failure of strongly heterogeneous states to reach the same levels of cooperation promotion as moderately heterogeneous states is most obvious . at the same time , as already noted above for the square as well as the triangular lattice , the position of the @xmath40 transition line does not shift due to the difference in the distribution of @xmath13 , which highlights that in games governed by group interactions the details of the interaction graph play a less prominent role than this is the case for games governed by pairwise interactions . with ample support from these final observations , we conclude that the strongly heterogeneous distribution is a less potent promoter of cooperative behavior in the public goods game . we have studied the evolution of cooperation on three different types of regular graphs in the public goods game with uniformly and exponentially distributed payoffs , with the aim of determining to what extent do strongly heterogeneous states promote cooperative behavior . the presented results have important implications for the evolution of cooperation in games governed by group interactions . while past research has undoubtedly shown that strongly heterogeneous states facilitate the evolution of cooperation in games governed by pairwise interactions ( for reviews see @xcite ) , results presented in this paper question this in relation to moderate heterogeneities for games governed by group interactions . in fact , here we find that uniformly distributed public goods are more successful in maintaining high levels of cooperation than exponentially distributed public goods , which is different to what was reported previously for games governed by pairwise interactions @xcite . this conclusion prevails irrespective of the type of the interaction graph , and is in agrement with previous observations @xcite in that qualitative differences between the outcomes of games governed by pairwise interactions and games governed by group interaction should be expected due to the indirect linkage of players that are members of the same groups . a direct consequence of this indirect linkage is also the fact that differences in the clustering coefficient play a minor role by the promotion of cooperation , which is different from what was reported previously for games governed by pairwise interactions @xcite , where a high clustering coefficient was found to be tightly linked to flourishing cooperative states . accordingly , in our case one could expect the triangular lattice to promote cooperation much better than the square lattice or the random regular graph , yet the difference is quite marginal . moreover , it is also important to note that the random regular graph is fundamentally different from the square and the triangular lattice in that it has no local structure . the indirect linkage of players due to group interactions , however , renders these differences in structural properties of the interaction networks virtually irrelevant . altogether , results presented in this paper point clearly towards the fact that the transition from pairwise to group interactions has important implications for the successful evolution of cooperation . we hope that this work will inspire future studies aimed at clarifying the role of heterogeneity for other types of games and further promote quantitative research in social systems with methods from physics @xcite . we thank eberhard bodenschatz for valuable comments towards the presentation of our work , as well as attila szolnoki and gyrgy szab for illuminating discussions and helpful advice . this research was supported by the slovenian research agency ( grants z1 - 2032 and j1 - 4055 ) . 10 url # 1#1urlprefix[2][]#2 sigmund k 1993 _ games of life : exploration in ecology , evolution and behavior _ ( oxford , uk : oxford university press )

previous research has highlighted the importance of strong heterogeneity for the successful evolution of cooperation in games governed by pairwise interactions . here we determine to what extent this is true for games governed by group interactions . we therefore study the evolution of cooperation in the public goods game on the square lattice , the triangular lattice and the random regular graph , whereby the payoffs are distributed either uniformly or exponentially amongst the players by assigning to them individual scaling factors that determine the share of the public good they will receive . we find that uniformly distributed public goods are more successful in maintaining high levels of cooperation than exponentially distributed public goods . this is not in agreement with previous results on games governed by pairwise interactions , indicating that group interactions may be less susceptible to the promotion of cooperation by means of strong heterogeneity as originally assumed , and that the role of strongly heterogeneous states should be reexamined for other types of games .

hep-ex0209038

space - borne cosmic ray experiments require the capability to measure the energies of particles with lorentz factors @xmath1 with detectors that are relatively large yet lightweight . nasa s proposed advanced cosmic ray composition experiment for space science ( access ) mission @xcite , for example , requires a transition radiation detector ( trd ) capable of measuring the energies of cosmic rays up to 100 tev / nucleon for particles with charge @xmath3 . such experiments require that the range of existing trds must be extended upward by an order of magnitude or more , requiring designs modified for use at these higher energies . transition radiation ( tr ) is produced when a charged particle crosses the interface between two materials with different dielectric constants , resulting in the rapid rearrangement of the particle s electric field as it passes from one material to the next @xcite . for highly relativistic particles ( @xmath4 ) the radiation is emitted at x - ray frequencies . the spectrum produced depends on the plasma frequencies and thicknesses of the two materials as well as the energy of the particle . typically , the materials used are a low atomic number solid such as plastic with plasma frequency @xmath5 , and a gas or vacuum with plasma frequency @xmath6 . radiation is emitted up to a frequency @xmath7 , beyond which the spectrum is suppressed . in the usual case , where @xmath8 , the total intensity produced from a single interface is proportional to @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the atomic number of the incident particle . the intensity from a single interface is weak . therefore , in practical applications , a radiator is constructed with a large number @xmath11 ( typically @xmath12 ) of thin foils of thickness @xmath13 separated by a distance @xmath14 ( or fiber or foam radiators with equivalent average @xmath15 and @xmath16 ) with radiation produced at each of the @xmath17 interfaces . interference effects from the superposition of the amplitudes produced at each interface give rise to pronounced minima and maxima in the spectrum , with the last ( highest frequency ) maximum near @xmath18 where @xmath19 is 1 for a metal and 0 for a nonconductor . as the particle energy increases , the total radiated intensity increases up to a lorentz factor @xmath20 above which saturation sets in due to the interference . we have included here the possibility of a nonzero conductivity which introduces an imaginary part to the wave vector and leads to an effective plasma frequency @xmath21 @xcite . the saturation energy and characteristic frequency can be tuned by varying the radiator foil material , thickness , and separation . an x - ray detector appropriate for absorbing the tr x - rays must be placed after the radiator . the radiation is emitted at an angle @xmath22 with respect to the incident particle direction , so for high lorentz factors the x - rays are spatially inseparable from the ionization energy deposited in the detector by the particle itself . therefore , in conventional applications , the detector must be made thin in order to minimize the ionization signal , yet with sufficient stopping power to absorb the x - rays . for @xmath23 less than about 40 kev , gaseous detectors ( e.g. xenon - filled wire chambers ) are typically employed . in order to improve statistics and provide redundancy , a complete trd consists of multiple layers of radiators and x - ray detectors . such trds have been used successfully both at accelerators and in space . in most cases , the trd is employed as a threshold device to identify particle types : for example , a meson or hadron may be accompanied by a small tr signal , while an electron of the same energy but larger @xmath24 is characterized by a large signal . in the case of the space shuttle crn experiment @xcite , a fiber trd was used to measure the energies of cosmic ray nuclei with @xmath25 . ref . @xcite gives an extensive review of tr applications and radiator configurations . a brief listing of cosmic ray experiments incorporating trds is given in @xcite . in order to increase the maximum particle energy @xmath26 , one must increase the plasma frequency ( or equivalently , density ) , thickness , and/or spacing of the foils ( eq . [ eq : saturation ] ) . in a space instrument , the overall thickness will be constrained , putting a limit on @xmath27 ( assuming @xmath28 ) . increasing @xmath5 by using metal foils instead of plastic , for example , and/or @xmath13 results in a hardening of the x - ray spectrum produced ( eq . [ eq : omega_max ] ) . metal foils have been used in early accelerator tests @xcite , and in particular lithium foils have been used in order to minimize the absorption at low x - ray frequencies @xcite . in the case of very high energies , though , with @xmath29 and a typical spacing @xmath30 cm , @xmath31 can be in excess of several hundred kev . gas detectors are then no longer efficient in detecting these hard x - rays . although @xcite describes the use of gas detectors near @xmath29 by optimizing the radiator design , scintillators such as nai or csi provide an efficient alternative at these lorentz factors and corresponding high x - ray energies . the higher density of the scintillators leads to an increase in the ionization energy deposited by the particle as it traverses the detector . however , as the tr spectrum hardens , compton scattering in the radiators becomes important , becoming the dominant photon interaction above @xmath32 kev . a significant portion of the x - rays produced are scattered out of the path of the incident particle . thus , a detector that is segmented or positioned outside of the beam can efficiently detect the tr signal spatially separated from the ionization . we describe here the test of a scintillator - based compton scatter trd for high lorentz factor particles , including the use of metal foils , based on the results of accelerator measurements with high energy electrons at the cern sps . comparisons of the measured results with detailed simulations will also be presented . a scintillator - based compton scatter trd was designed to investigate the predicted increase in saturation energy obtained by using thick , dense radiator materials including mylar ( @xmath33 g/@xmath34 ) , teflon ( @xmath35 g/@xmath34 ) , and aluminum ( @xmath36 g/@xmath34 ) . metal foils are of particular interest because of the characteristic enhancement in the signal expected due to the nonzero conductivity @xcite . , width=326 ] [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] for the plastics , radiators of @xmath37 foils were constructed by attaching 19.1 cm @xmath38 18.4 cm plastic foils to 3.4 mm thick wood frames and stacking them together . for the aluminum , each radiator consisted of seven 2.7 cm thick honeycomb panels bundled together and aligned with the cells perpendicular to the particle beam . the honeycomb was a composite material chosen both for its dimensions and its adaptability as a combined detector - plus - structure for a space instrument ( fig . [ fig : honeycomb ] ) . particles passing through the structure passed through either 1 ) a section of foils perpendicular to the beam in which two 3 mil sheets glued together form a foil with an effective @xmath39 mil , @xmath40 mm , and @xmath41 foils along the particle trajectory or 2 ) a section of foils at a @xmath42 angle with respect to the particle beam , resulting in an effective foil thickness @xmath43 mil , @xmath14 ranging from 0 to 5.2 mm , and @xmath44 . the yield from a composite material ( e.g. , a foam ) with average values @xmath45 , @xmath46 , and @xmath47 has been shown to be essentially the same as from a regular foil radiator with the same @xmath13 , @xmath14 , and @xmath11 @xcite . we therefore calculate the al honeycomb effective parameters as averages of configuration 1 weighted by 46% ( to account for the fraction of the area perpendicular to the beam covered by configuration 1 ) and configuration 2 weighted by 54% . the resulting average honeycomb radiator parameters are given in table [ tab : rad_par ] , along with the parameters of the plastic radiator configurations tested . the total length of each radiator was 19 cm . each radiator was viewed by three x - ray detectors , each consisting of a 19 cm @xmath38 19 cm @xmath38 5 mm thick nai(tl ) crystal hermetically sealed between a 6.4 mm thick glass optical window on one flat face and a 0.75 mm thick aluminum entrance window on the other face . an ultraviolet transmitting lucite lightguide was coupled to the glass window using optical grease , reducing the aperture to a 13 cm diameter circle . an electron tubes 9390 kb 130 mm photomultiplier tube with a standard bialkali photocathode was mated to the lightguide with optical grease . the lightguide was wrapped in aluminum foil and the whole assembly wrapped with black tape to make it light tight . six identical modules were constructed , with each module containing a radiator and the three nai(tl ) detector assemblies , one on each side of the radiator and one above the radiator outside of and parallel to the beam ( fig . [ fig : schematic ] ) . the modules were positioned one behind the other along the beam and aligned such that the particle beam travelled down the center of the modules . only x - rays scattered at large angles away from the beam were then detected . , width=432 ] for the first accelerator run , the 18 pmt signals were fed into camac - based , 11-bit caen c205a charge adcs and read out with the cern cms h2a daq computer . for the second accelerator run , the signals from the pmts were fed into custom - built 8-channel front end modules which contained a charge integrator , peak detect and hold circuit , and gain - adjustable amplifier . analog - to - digital conversion was performed with a 64-channel , 12-bit national instruments pci-6071e daq board running in a pc and controlled under labview 6i . the instrument was exposed to high energy electrons at the cern sps h2a test beam site in august / september 1999 and again in august / september 2001 . beam energies ranged from 7 to 150 gev , covering the range of lorentz factors @xmath48 . a set of scintillators in the beam upstream of the trd provided event triggering . the trigger rate was kept to about 1 khz to avoid deadtime in the daq system . beam definition scintillators in front of and behind the trd ( s1 and s2 in fig . [ fig : schematic ] ) flagged events for which the electrons showered within the radiator stacks . a pb shower counter ( s3 ) was placed downstream of s2 to flag pions present as a contaminant in the higher energy beams . energy calibration runs were performed both immediately before and after the beam runs using radioactive @xmath49ba ( 81 , 303 and 356 kev ) and @xmath50cs ( 662 kev ) x - ray sources . in order to account for bremsstrahlung and other background produced by the electrons in passing through the radiators and upstream material , a background run was performed for each radiator configuration in which the radiators were replaced by solid blocks with the same material and thickness ( in g/@xmath51 ) as the radiators . ) represent the calculated spectrum for module 1 . the upper histogram ( solid line ) and diamonds ( @xmath52 ) show the measured and calculated spectra , respectively , in module 5.[fig : spectra],width=326 ] for each material , a background run and a foil run were made for each electron energy used . figure [ fig : spectra ] shows spectra obtained for aluminum foil and background runs at 150 gev . several conclusions can be drawn immediately : first , compton scattered transition radiation is being detected away from the path of the incident electron , at levels well above that of the background ; second , the detected tr x - ray spectrum peaks near 100 kev , with some x - rays detected at energies @xmath53 kev ; and third , the measured intensity increases as the particle moves downstream through the set of radiator / detector modules . calculated spectra are produced by a monte carlo routine based on the description in @xcite , in which the differential intensity per unit solid angle per unit frequency is expressed in terms of the coherent sum of the complex amplitudes from the individual interfaces @xcite . the effect of the metal foils is included by incorporating an effective absorption cross section ( i.e. , the imaginary part of the wave vector ) that depends on the foil conductivity . individual x - rays in the range @xmath54 kev are produced at random locations along the trajectory and followed through the geometry of the radiator stacks and detector modules taking into account the effects of photoelectric absorption , compton scattering , fluorescence , and escape in both the detectors and radiators , and photoelectron statistics and electronic resolution in the scintillators , photomultipliers , and electronic readout . examples of the pure tr spectra , showing the characteristic interference pattern and a maximum in the predicted spectrum near 200 kev , are shown in @xcite . the calculated tr plus background spectra are shown here : the triangles in fig . [ fig : spectra ] show the result of convolving the measured background in module 1 with the expected tr signal ; the diamonds show the result in module 5 . the predicted signals agree well with the measured tr - plus - background spectra . figure [ fig : saturation ] shows the total number of photons detected per nai detector summed over the x - ray energy range @xmath55 kev as a function of electron energy . the points show the measured data ; the curves show the results calculated as described above . the observed saturation lorentz factors for the thick teflon and aluminum honeycomb are @xmath56 , as expected from the calculated values in table [ tab : rad_par ] . the calculations reproduce the differences in detected yield between different radiator materials , the effects due to different thicknesses of the same material , and the dependence on electron energy to an accuracy of @xmath57 . kev per detector per event in the first module as a function of electron energy for various radiator configurations . the error bars represent statistical errors . [ fig : saturation],width=326 ] as shown in fig . [ fig : spectra ] , the number of x - rays measured in each detector depends on the position of the module . most of the tr x - rays produced in the beginning of the first module will pass through that module without interacting ( @xmath58 probability in an al honeycomb radiator at 100 kev ) . but as they encounter the radiator material in successive modules , they can compton scatter and be absorbed in a downstream detector . for the al honeycomb , there is an 80% probability that a 100 kev x - ray created at the front of the first module will compton scatter in the radiators before leaving the last module . this feedthrough effect enhances the number of photons detected in modules downstream and can be used to advantage in designing a practical detector @xcite . for 150 gev electrons and al radiators over the x - ray energy range @xmath55 kev , the ratios of x - rays detected in the downstream modules compared to module 1 are @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 , and @xmath63 for modules 26 , respectively . the corresponding predicted ratios are @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 , and @xmath68 . a new compton scatter transition radiation detector capable of measuring the x - rays produced by particles with lorentz factors near @xmath69 has been built and successfully tested . compton scattered tr x - rays were detected outside of the particle beam using relatively thick nai scintillator detectors , effectively isolating the tr signal from the ionization signal . for thick teflon and al honeycomb radiators , the detected x - ray spectrum peaks near 100 kev with some x - rays of energy @xmath53 kev detected , and saturation lorentz factors near @xmath70 were achieved . the detected yields for most radiator configurations agree with detailed simulations , including the enhancement expected from metal foils . the measurements tend to saturate at slightly higher particle energies than predicted , and the measured number of photons at saturation are @xmath71 higher than predicted for the thin mylar and teflon radiators . these discrepancies are presumably due to nonuniformities known to be present in the radiator material . likewise , the measured peak of the tr plus background spectrum from the aluminum honeycomb radiator occurs approximately 30 kev higher than expected . this discrepancy presumably reflects the approximations inherent in treating an irregular honeycomb structure as a periodic stack of foils . in the case of hard x - ray energies , photon feedthrough enhances the signal in the downstream detectors , again as predicted by the simulations ( within @xmath72 ) . this work was supported by nasa grant nag5 - 5177 and nasa / louisiana board of regents grant nasa / leqsf - imp-02 . the authors wish to thank a. aranas , s. apewokin , t. brown and o. shertukde for their many hours of work during the construction and testing of the radiators and detectors ; the staff at cern for their superb cooperation and assistance , particularly d. lazic and g. bencze ; and j. anderson , j. marsh and c. welch for assisting with the data analysis .

x - ray transition radiation can be used to measure the lorentz factor of relativistic particles . standard transition radiation detectors ( trds ) typically incorporate thin plastic foil , foam , or fiber radiators and gas - filled x - ray detectors , and are sensitive up to @xmath0 . to reach lorentz factors up to @xmath1 , thicker , denser radiators can be used , which consequently produce x - rays of harder energies ( @xmath2 kev ) . at these energies , scintillator detectors are more efficient in detecting the hard x - rays , and compton scattering of the x - rays out of the path of the particle becomes important . the compton scattering can be utilized to separate the transition radiation from the ionization background spatially . the use of conducting metal foils is predicted to yield enhanced signals compared to standard nonconducting plastic foils of the same dimensions . we have designed and built an inorganic scintillator - based compton scatter trd optimized for high lorentz factors and exposed it to high energy electrons at the cern sps . we present the results of the accelerator tests and comparisons to simulations , demonstrating 1 ) the effectiveness of the compton scatter trd approach ; 2 ) the performance of conducting aluminum foils ; and 3 ) the ability of a trd to measure energies approximately an order of magnitude higher than previously used in very high energy cosmic ray studies . transition radiation , scintillator detectors , compton scattering , cosmic rays 95.55.vj , 29.40.mc , 07.87.+v

astro-ph0001423

during 19971998 the number of x ray pulsars found in the small magellanic cloud ( smc ) rapidly increased from three ( smcx1 , rxj0053.87226 , and 2e0050.17247 ; lucke et al 1976 ; hughes 1994 ; israel et al . 1997 ) up 14 ( for a review see yokogawa et al . 1998 ) thanks to sensitive observations of the large area detectors on board the _ r_xte and asca satellites . the majority were found to be associated with massive be spectral type stars showing intense h@xmath7 emission lines . only smcx1 , which is associated with a super giant b0 spectral type star in a 3.9d orbital period binary system , is a persistent ( although moderately variable ) x ray pulsar . for all the remaining x ray pulsars pronounced variability ( a factor @xmath850 ) or , more often , transient behaviour has been definitively proven . the source 2e0101.57225 was detected at a nearly constant flux level in all the _ einstein _ , _ rosat _ and _ asca _ pointings which surveyed the relevant region of the smc ( see hughes & smith 1994 ) , but pulsations were not found due to poor statistics . based on the accurate position obtained with the _ rosat _ hri , these authors found that 2e0101.57225 is very likely associated with a be spectral type star ( r.a.=01@xmath903@xmath101386 , dec.=7209141 ; equinox j2000 ) . 2e0101.57225 is located near the optical limb of the supernova remnant snr010172.4 . hughes & smith ( 1994 ) present several arguments that make the be / x ray binary snr association unlikely . in this _ letter _ we report the discovery of 345s pulsations from the source saxj0103.27209 during a _ beppo_sax observation of the smc . the comparison with the data of past x ray missions allows us to conclude that saxj0103.27209 and 2e0101.57225 are the same object , a persistent source with moderate variability ( within a factor of 510 ) . we also report the results of the timing analysis of a recent public _ chandra _ observation and discuss optical observations carried out at eso . the smc field including the position of the 2e0101.57225 was observed by the narrow field instruments ( nfis ) on board the _ beppo_sax satellite ( boella et al . 1997a ) on 1998 july 2627 ( effective exposure time of 40320s ) . we used data from the medium energy ( mecs ; boella et al . 1997b ) and low energy ( lecs ; parmar et al . 1997 ) instruments . a bright x ray source ( @xmath03.7@xmath210@xmath11cts@xmath4 , 110kev ) was detected on axis in the mecs , at r.a.=01@xmath903@xmath1013@xmath12 , dec.=720916 ( j2000 ; 90% confidence uncertainty radius of 30 ) . the mecs event list and spectrum were extracted from a circular region of 4 radius ( corresponding to an encircled energy of @xmath090% ) around the x ray position . a 4 extraction radius ( @xmath085% encircled energy ) was also used for the lecs in order to minimize the contamination from the soft x ray emission of the bright nearby source 2e0102.37217 . the local background was measured in a region of the mecs and lecs images far from any detected field sources . the arrival times of the @xmath01500 photons were corrected to the barycenter of the solar system and background subtracted light curves were accumulated in 0.5s bins . a single power spectrum was calculated over the entire time span covered by the observation in order to maximize the sensitivity to coherent pulsations . significant power spectrum peaks were searched for using the algorithm described in israel & stella ( 1996 ) . a highly significant peak ( @xmath09.4@xmath13 based on the fundamental only ; see upper left panel of fig.1 ) was found at a frequency of 0.002889hz , corresponding to a period of 345.2s . an accurate determination of the period was obtained by fitting the phases of the modulation over 4 different intervals of @xmath016000s each . the scatter of the phase residuals was consistent with a strictly periodic modulation at the best period of [email protected] ( 90% confidence ) . a comparison of the 14kev ( panel s in fig.1 ) and 410kev ( panel h ) folded light curves provides marginal evidence for an energy dependent pulse profile : nearly sinusoidal at low energies , while double horned above 4kev . however the pulsed fraction ( semi amplitude of modulation divided by the mean source count rate ) of @xmath045% is constant over the two energy intervals considered . a spectral analysis was performed in the 0.76.5 and 1.610kev energy ranges for the lecs and mecs , respectively . the spectra were rebinned to have at least 20 counts in each energy channel , such that @xmath15 fitting techniques could be used . no single component model was found to fit the data well ( a power law gave a @xmath16=41/15 ; where @xmath17 is the degree of freedom ) . among double component models , an absorbed power law plus a black body gave the best fit ( @xmath16=15/15 ) for a photon index of 1.0@xmath18 , n@[email protected]@xmath21@xmath210@xmath22cm@xmath11 , and a black body temperature of [email protected] ( uncertainties refer to 1@xmath13 ) . the observed flux in the 210 kev energy band was 2.7@xmath210@xmath24ergs@xmath4 cm@xmath11 ( the soft component accounts for @xmath015% of the total ) corresponding to an unabsorbed 210kev x ray luminosity of 1.2@xmath210@xmath3ergs@xmath4 assuming a distance of 62kpc ( laney & stobie 1994 ) . after the discovery of 345s pulsations in 2e0101.57225 ( israel et al . 1998 ) , yokogawa & koyama ( 1998 ) found a signal at a period of 348.9s during a 1996 may _ asca _ observation ( absorbed luminosity of 5@xmath210@xmath5ergs@xmath4 ; 210kev ) implying a period derivative ( with respect to _ beppo_sax ) of 1.7syr@xmath4 . the source was also detected by _ asca _ on 1993 may 12 and 1997 november 14 at an absorbed luminosity level of 6 and 5@xmath210@xmath5ergs@xmath4 , respectively . a re analysis of the latter _ asca _ datasets allowed us to infer an upper limit ( 3@xmath13 confidence ) in the 6080% range on the pulsed fraction for a period of @xmath0345s . to better constrain the absorption we used archival data from the _ rosat _ satellite ( pspc ; 0.12kev band ) which observed the field of 2e0101.57225 between 1991 october 8 and 1992 april 28 ( sequence 600195 ; effective exposure time 26630s ) . assuming that the source showed the same flux and spectrum during the two observations , we fitted the _ rosat _ and _ beppo_sax data together . we found that the two component model derived above again gave the best fit ; a @xmath16=23/25 was obtained for a photon index of [email protected] with n@xmath19 of 3.9@xmath25@xmath210@xmath22cm@xmath11 and a black body temperature of 0.12@xmath26kev corresponding to an equivalent black body radius r@xmath27 in the 260 km range ( see fig.2 ; 1@xmath13 uncertainties ) . the corresponding power spectrum shows no significant ( 3@xmath13 confidence ) peak in the 339359s period interval with a @xmath060% upper limit on the pulsed fraction . the field including 2e0101.57225 was observed by the nasa advanced x ray astrophysics facility satellite _ chandra _ on 1999 august 23 with the imaging spectrometer ( acis ; garmire et al . 1992 , bautz et al . 1998 and references therein ) in the high resolution imaging mode for an effective exposure time of 19551s . the source was detected at an off axis angle of about 9 in the s4 ( front illuminated ) ccd of the acis s detector with a count rate of @xmath09@xmath210@xmath11 ct s@xmath4 ( in the 0.510kev energy range ; see fig.3 left panel ) . the source shows two emission peaks separated by @xmath05 . however the size of the emission region is comparable with the 90% encircled energy region of a source at 9 off axis angle . we extracted a 3.24s binned light curve of the source from a region within 8 from the center of the emission : r.a.=01@xmath903@xmath101406 , dec.=72091525 ( equinox j2000 ) . the statistical uncertainty radius is only @xmath00.5 but at this stage the uncertainty in the absolute positioning at such an off axis angle might be as large as 90 . however the detection of the pulsations clearly associates the _ chandra _ source with that of _ beppo_sax . we also note that the _ chandra _ coordinates are consistent with the _ rosat _ hri uncertainty circle and differ by less than 2 from those of the proposed optical counterpart ( see below ) making the association very likely . according to the _ chandra _ source naming convention we designated it as cxoj010314.1720915 . a single power spectrum was calculated over the entire observation . the search was performed over a period interval around that detected by _ beppo_sax and assuming a maximum @xmath28p@xmath28 of @xmath03 s yr@xmath4 which translates into a search over only two fourier frequencies ( see fig.1 lower panels ) . a peak was detected at a significance level of 7.5@xmath13 . a refined period was determined by means of the phase fitting technique ; this gave a value of [email protected] ( see table1 ) . we note that the _ chandra _ data were not corrected to the barycenter of the solar system . however , for a relatively long period pulsar in the direction of the smc , the effect of the spacecraft and of the earth motion , would cause a maximum correction of a factor of 10 smaller than the statistical uncertainty of the period given above . the pulse profile is sinusoidal ( over the whole _ chandra _ energy band ) and the pulsed fraction is @xmath045% ( see fig.1 ) . this result implies that the pulsar is continuing to spin up at a constant rate of 1.7syr@xmath4 since 1996 ( see fig.1 ; right panel ) . in order to further address the issue of the double peaked _ chandra _ image ( see fig.3 ) , we extracted two separate light curves for each of the two peaks . we found that the signal at 343.5s was present with a similar pulsed fraction in both light curves ; this result is consistent with the hypothesis of a point like source . an independent confirmation was also obtained through a raytracing simulation , encompassing a monochromatic source ( 1.49kev ) and models for the mirror assembly and acis detector . the results indicate that expected psf at an off axis angle of 9 is artificially elongated in the direction connecting the two peaks detected in the chandra image around the position of 2e0101.57225 ; the two peaks are probably artefacts resulting from the small number of x rays in the image . we conclude that the source is consistent with being point like . optical images ( h@xmath7 and h@xmath7 red continuum ; 200s each ) of the _ beppo_sax error circle of saxj0103.27209 were obtained on 1998 july 24 at the danish 1.5 m telescope with the danish faint object spectrometer camera ( dfosc ) at la silla ( chile ) in order to search for emission line stars . the data were reduced using standard eso midas procedures for bias subtraction , flat field correction , aperture photometry and one dimensional stellar and sky spectra extraction . within the _ beppo_sax position circle we found only one h@xmath7 active object : this is the o9b1iii ve m@xmath6=14.8 star originally suggested as the optical counterpart of 2e0101.57225 ( hughes & smith 1994 ) . a 10a resolution 38008500a spectrum ( 20 slit ) of this star was obtained with the same instrument on 1998 october 20 . strong h@xmath7 and h@xmath29 emission lines were detected , with equivalent width 20@xmath142a , and [email protected] , respectively . these results are in good agreement with those obtained by hughes & smith ( 1994 ) during observations carried out on december 1992 . ccccccc + + mission & instrument & period & date & exposure & 210kev l@xmath30 & reference + & & ( s ) & & ( s ) & ( 10@xmath5ergs@xmath31 & + _ asca _ & gis & [email protected] & 1996 may 2123 & 32912 & 5 & 1 + _ beppo_sax & mecs & [email protected] & 1998 jul 2627 & 40320 & 11 & 2 ; this work + _ chandra _ & acis & [email protected] & 1999 aug 23 & 19551 & & this work + note : luminosities refer to absorbed fluxes . 90% uncertainties are reported . + 1 yokogawa & koyama ( 1998 ) ; 2 israel et al . although 2e0101.57225 shares several characteristics with other x ray pulsators in the magellanic clouds ( mcs ) and in the galactic plane ( i.e. , the spin period and pulsed fraction , the spectral shape at high energy and the presence of a soft thermal component , the association with a high mass companion , etc . ) , it has also some peculiar differences which make it unusual . the absence of long term variability greater than a factor of @xmath0510 over an interval of @xmath020 years is strongly suggestive of a _ persistent _ x ray pulsar , the second in the smc since the discovery of pulsations from smcx1 . moreover , the association of the companion with a be spectral type star makes 2e0101.57225 the first example of a persistent ( main sequence ) be / x ray binary system in the smc . 2e0101.57225 is also a relatively low luminosity ( 10@xmath510@xmath3ergs@xmath4 ) x ray pulsar . finally , the inferred period derivative of 1.7syr@xmath4 corresponds to a secular spin up time scale of @xmath0200yr which is the shortest of any known x ray pulsar in a high mass x ray binary . by using the p and p measurements and an x ray luminosity in the 0.52@xmath210@xmath3 erg s@xmath4 range , we infer a magnetic field of 412@xmath210@xmath32gauss and , correspondingly , a maximum magnetospheric radius of @xmath33 @xmath04@xmath210@xmath34 cm ( see lamb et al . 1973 ) . since the derived corotation radius @xmath35 is @xmath08@xmath210@xmath34 cm , the @xmath33 is considerably smaller than @xmath35 , and accretion on the surface of the neutron star proceeds unaffected by the magnetosphere s centrifugal drag , as long as the luminosity of the source is larger than @xmath02@xmath210@xmath5ergs@xmath4 . such a luminosity is not unusual for a bright x ray pulsar in a nearly circular orbit around a giant ob companion star where the intense stellar wind continuously supplies matter to the compact object . assuming a main sequence star , an orbital period of @xmath0300d is expected for 2e0101.57225 based on the pulse period orbital period correlation of be star / x ray pulsar binaries ( corbet 1984 ) . a timing analysis of i band photometric measurements from the optical gravitational lensing experiment ( ogle ) revealed no evidence of any coherent signal in the 150d period interval ( see coe & orosz 1999 ) suggesting that 2e0101.57225 is a long period system . the characteristics of 2e0101.57225 have their closest analogy to those of the persistent low luminosity ( 10@xmath510@xmath3ergs@xmath4 ; 210kev band ) x ray pulsar rxj0146.9 + 6121 , a 1455s ( spin up timescale of @xmath0250 yr ) spinning neutron star in a binary system with a b1ve companion star ( see reig et al . 1997 ; haberl et al . 1998 ; mereghetti et al . 2000 ) . two other recently discovered long period be / x ray pulsars in the smc , namely axj0051733 ( p@xmath36=323s ; imanishi et al . 1999 ) and axj00587203 ( p@xmath36=280s ; tsujimoto 1999 ) , although highly variable ( a factor of 10100 ) , have a maximum luminosity level close to that of 2e0101.57225 . in conclusion , we discovered a new x ray pulsar with a period of @xmath0345s in the smc which is persistent , has a relatively low luminosity , is rapidly spinning up and is associated with a o9b1iii ve star . the relatively high value inferred for the magnetic field and period derivative point to a young object . all these findings make 2e0101.57225 an unusual x ray pulsar which deserves more detailed investigations with instrumentation ranging from the x ray to the ir band . this work was partially supported through asi and cnaa grants . we thank the _ chandra _ data archive ( cda ) of the _ chandra _ x ray observatory science center ( cxc ) at cfa for a prompt release of the data . we thank r. ragazzoni for obtaining the optical spectrum of the counterpart of 2e0101.57225 . we thank h. tananbaum , r.j . edgar and l. burderi for their helpful comments . this work has been supported in part by nasa contract nas8 - 39073 . bautz , m. w. , et al . 1998 , spie , 3444 , 210 boella , g. , et al . 1997a , a&as , 122 , 299 boella , g. , et al . 1997b , a&as , 122 , 327 coe , m.j . & orosz , j.a . 1999 , , in press ( astro ph/9908303 ) corbet , r.h.d . 1984 , , 141 , 91 garmire , g. p. et al . 1992 , aiaa , space programs and technologies conference , huntsville , p.8 haberl , f. , angelini , l. & motch , c. 1998 , , 335 , 587 hughes , j.p . 1994 , , 427 , l25 hughes , j.p . & smith , r.c . 1994 , , 107 , 1363 imanishi , k. , et al . 1999 , , in press ( astro ph/9910463 ) israel , g.l . & stella , l. 1996 , , 468 , 369 israel , g.l . , et al . 1997 , , 484 , l141 israel , g.l . , 1998 , iau circ . 6999 lamb , f.k . , pethick , c.j . & pines , d. 1973 , 184 , 271 laney , c.d . & stobie , r.s . 1994 , , 266 , 441 lucke , r. , et al . 1976 , , 206 , l25 mereghetti , s. , tiengo , a. & israel , g.l . 2000 , , in press parmar , a.n . , 1997 , , 122 , 309 reig , p. , fabregat , j. & coe , m.j . 1997 , , 322 , 193 tsujimoto , m. , et al . 1999 , , in press ( astro ph/9910505 ) yokogawa , j. & koyama , k. 1998 , iau circ . 7009 yokogawa , j. , et al . 1998 , mpe report 270 , eds . becker , w. & itoh , m. , p.151

we report the results of a 1998 july _ beppo_sax observation of a field in the small magellanic cloud ( smc ) which led to the discovery of @xmath0345s pulsations in the x ray flux of saxj0103.27209 . the _ beppo_sax x ray spectrum is well fit by an absorbed power law with photon index @xmath01.0 plus a black body component with @xmath1=0.11kev . the unabsorbed luminosity in the 210 kev energy range is @xmath01.2@xmath210@xmath3ergs@xmath4 . in a very recent _ chandra _ observation the 345s pulsations are also detected . the available period measurements provide a constant period derivative of 1.7syr@xmath4 over the last three years making saxj0103.27209 one of the most rapidly spinning up x ray pulsars known . the _ beppo_sax position ( 30 uncertainty radius ) is consistent with that of the _ einstein _ source 2e0101.57225 and the _ rosat _ source rxj0103.27209 . this source was detected at a luminosity level of few 10@xmath510@xmath3ergs@xmath4 in all datasets of past x ray missions since 1979 . the _ rosat _ hri and _ chandra _ positions are consistent with that of a m@xmath6=14.8 be spectral type star already proposed as the likely optical counterpart of 2e0101.57225 . we briefly report and discuss photometric and spectroscopic data carried out at the eso telescopes two days before the _ beppo_sax observation . we conclude that saxj0103.27209 and 2e0101.57225 are the same source , a relatively young and persistent x ray pulsar in the smc .

0911.5185

periodic arrangements are quite ubiquitous in various physical systems . from naturally occurring crystal structures in solid state systems , to artificially made periodic arrangements such as photonic crystals and optical lattices , both theoretical and experimental research in these systems has provided us with an understanding of fundamental physical phenomena , as well as with the possibility of achieving technological applications . there has been a growing interest in recent years in understanding the fundamental properties of photonic crystals @xcite and of optical lattices @xcite , particularly concerning their possible applications in quantum optics and condensed matter systems . photonic crystals are periodic arrays of dielectric media in which light propagates linearly in various ways , depending on the geometry of the system . on the other hand , optical lattices are periodic arrays of electromagnetic field arising from the interference pattern of concurrent laser fields . in this case , ultracold atoms propagate nonlinearly in ways which depend also on the specific geometry of the system . both systems share important properties , namely the band structure of their energy spectrum as well as the possibility of producing confined and extended modes of light in photonic crystals @xcite and of matter in optical lattices@xcite . however , there are important physical differences which render each system unique . interaction between atoms in optical lattices has led to research into the nature of nonlinear matter waves in these systems , revealing a vast spectrum of nonlinear behaviour(see e.g. @xcite ) . by contrast , light waves in photonic crystals obey maxwell s equations and , hence , always satisfy the superposition principle . it is of conceptual importance to understand how light and matter waves in these two systems are comparable , and to investigate the possibility of using the light fields in photonic crystals to control the matter waves in optical lattices . such a study can be carried out in two regimes : in the high - particle - density and coherent regime ( in the case of photonic crystals , we mean photons , and in the case of optical lattices , we mean atoms ) , a description using a classical field in both systems is appropriate ; on the other hand , in the low particle density regime , quantum phenomena arise , and the description of both systems will require a microscopic study ( for photonic crystals see , @xcite , and for optical lattices , see @xcite ) . in the present paper , we address the first regime of high particle density . we focus on two interesting connected possibilities : first , one particular type of wave manipulation , namely the generation of confined modes produced by defects in both periodic structures ; and second , the propagation of nonlinear matter waves in the presence extended light fields produced in photonic crystals . we will see that , although defects are just one example of wave manipulation that would be interesting to implement experimentally to create elaborate optical lattices , there are technical difficulties that have to be met before a successful realization . the present paper is organized as follows : first , we review some important properies of defects in photonic crystals and in optical lattices . second , we explain how an optical lattice can be induced by extended modes in photonic crystals . finally , we exemplify this new way of obtaining optical lattices by using a photonic crystal with a two - dimensional square geometry . we conclude by suggesting the potential of using defect modes of photonic crystals to manipulate nonlinear matter waves embedded in them , and comment on the difficulties that must be resolved before realizing it experimentally . photonic crystals ( pc ) are periodic arrays of different dielectric materials whose dispersion relation presents bandgaps depending on specific structural parameters . this is their most important feature , because it allows us to control the flow of light through the material with low energy loss . the dielectric contrast of a photonic crystal is what produces a gap in the energy spectrum , for a given value of the propagation vector @xmath0 of the light field that propagates in the structure . periodicity allows us to use the bloch theorem to obtain with ease the band diagram and electric and magnetic field modes . @xcite by introducing defects , it is possible to confine a single mode of the electromagnetic field in a very narrow space of the lattice . furthermore , we can introduce an active medium , such as a quantum dot or a two level atom , inside the defect , thus making it possible to analize radiation - matter interactions @xcite . in order to obtain an analytical solution for the master equation , use is made of maxwell s equations in free space in cartesian coordinates for a square array of dielectric rods embedded in air ; only the linear term in the electric displacement is taken into account . the solution consists on diagonalizing the resulting matrix which is obtained when we expand the dielectric function and the electric field in a basis of plane waves and introducing them in the corresponding maxwell equation . the dielectric function has the form @xmath1 where the @xmath2 are the expansion coefficients of the dielectric function . these contain the information about the geometrical distribution of the dielectric rods and have the form @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the diameter of the rods , @xmath5 is the dielectric constant and @xmath6 is the length of the supercell ( @xmath7 is its area ) ; @xmath8 is the number of layers around the defect . we have obtained equation ( [ a1 ] ) analytically . the unitary cell for @xmath9 is shown in fig.([diel1 ] ) . the electric field has the form @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the periodic function that takes into account the periodicity of the field in the @xmath12 plane and the @xmath13 are the reciprocal vectors of the square array . the periodic function has the form @xmath14 introducing eq.([die21 ] ) and eq.([ezp ] ) in maxwell s equations we obtain the resulting eigenvalue equation @xmath15=k^{2}\sum_{p , q}{\alpha_{nm}\beta_{n - p , m - q}},\label{auto2}\ ] ] where the @xmath16 are the expansion coefficients of the electric field . we can note that this is a generalized eigenvalue problem whose eigenfunctions correspond to the expansion coefficients of the electric field with eigenvalues that correspond to the allowed energies for a fixed pair @xmath17 and @xmath18 . with this solution , we construct the band diagram of the pc with a defect and we analyze the effect of introducing it in the crystal . ultracold atoms in optical lattices are described in three different regimes depending on the particle density in the system @xcite . we focus on the limit of high - particle - density , in which the system remains in a macroscopic superfluid state . in this limit , we can make use of a classical field to describe the macroscopic coherent state of the atoms in the optical lattice , which is reminiscent of the classical field that describes light in photonic crystals . however , as has been noted , there is a marked difference between both systems : in the case of ultracold atoms , the waves behave nonlinearly , due to the interparticle interaction , whereas light always propagates linearly . this nonlinear description of the atomic case can be modeled using the well - known gross - pitaevskii ( gp ) equation : @xmath19\psi(\mathbf{r})=\mu \psi(\mathbf{r}),\ ] ] where @xmath20 denotes the nonlinear coupling . this equation can be derived using a hartree - type ansatz to minimize the energy of the system , asuming @xmath21wave scattering between the atoms . the wavefunction @xmath22 describes a macroscopic coherent state . in the case of optical lattices , the periodic potential is given by @xmath23 where @xmath24 is proportional to the intensity of the laser light . such a periodic potential can be generated by setting up standing waves with two lasers at perpendicular angles . the two - dimensional nature of this optical lattice can be achieved by setting up a tightly confining field in the third perpendicular direction , thus eliminating to a large extent the corresponding degree of freedom . the gp equation was numerically integrated with a procedure consisting of two stages . first , we perform a pseudospectral interpolation of the gp equation without the nonlinearity , i.e. of the schr@xmath25dinger single - particle equation . since the usual bloch argument concerning periodic lattices in solid state physics applies also in optical lattices , we make use of the bloch form of the wave function . once we obtain the solution in @xmath26-space we reconstruct the spatial wave function as a superposition of plane waves , which amounts to making the plane - wave expansion that what was done in the photonic crystal case . afterwards , we propagate this single - particle wavefunction in imaginary time , using the gp equation . the evolution in imaginary time generates a superposition of eigenstates of the gp equation with exponentially decaying coefficients . by using this procedure , the term in the superposition with the lowest energy , i.e. the ground - state , will be the least suppressed in the evolution and , thus , will be predominant after some time has passed . in this way we will have obtained the gp ground state . it is important to notice that , because the gp equation is determined by the spatial density of the system , we need to normalize the wave function continuously in the time evolution . otherwise , the system will not evolve with the correct effective gp hamiltonian . using this same procedure , we can introduce a gaussian defect in the optical lattice . such defects have been studied in one - dimensional optical lattices , and have been shown to exhibit transport properties with dynanic solitonic behaviour due mainly to the nonlinearity inherent in the system @xcite . however , here we focus mainly on the ground state of the system . it should be noted that there is an important difference between defects in optical lattices and in photonic crystals concerning confined states . in experimental setups in optical lattices , it is the ground state which can be achieved by lowering the temperature of the system . as a result , in the band diagram of the optical lattice , we always choose the point of lowest energy . this contrasts to what is done in photonic crystals , where the interest focuses on confined modes that have an energy in the bandgap of the spectrum . in this case , it is not the lowest energy state which is chosen in order to confine light waves , but rather a higher energy state . as we have discussed previously , optical lattices are stationary periodic light fields . such lattices are usually generated through the use of interfering laser fields . however , it is not necessary to use laser fields . what matters is that we have a light field that couples to the atoms we are using through an effective external dipole potential . such a dipole potential is proportional to the intensity as @xmath27 where @xmath28 denotes the field intensity . in particular , photonic crystals are suitable structures in which various types of distributions can be generated . as we reviewed in the previous section , by a suitable combination of geometry , it is possible to mold the field distribution by making use of , for example , defects . if we could take advantage of the vast set of intensity distributions in photonic crystals , we could achieve much more exotic behaviour than what has been achieved up until now in conventional optical lattices . before discussing an example of an optical lattice induced by a photonic crystal , let us first show some results of both systems independently , in which we can witness the use of defects as important means of generating more elaborate light fields in photonic crystals , and of studying nonlinear behaviour in optical lattices . for the pc case , we have taken a finite basis of plane waves to expand eq.([auto2 ] ) and to obtain a set of linear equations . after diagonalizing the resulting coefficient matrix , we have obtained the eigenfunctions corresponding to the electric field modes whose spatial distribution is shown in fig . ( [ elecfield ] ) . point defects in pc confine light modes with a definite energy in a very narrow space . this fact can be used to construct cavities with a very high quality factor and obtain a strong coupling regime wich is important , for example , in the study of polaritonic systems . furthermore , in these systems it is important to have a single mode of the field for simulating certain theoretical models in quantum optics such as the jaynes - cummings model . we have obtained the tm modes of the electric field because the square geometry only presents bandgap for such modes . these are precisely the modes which can be confined when we introduce the defect in the pc , modifying their band diagram and allowing modes into the gap . the band diagram is shown in fig.([band1 ] ) . it can be noticed that the field is highly , although not totally , concentrated in the defect region . the reason the field is largely concentrated inside the defect is due to the fact that point defects introduce defective modes in the bandgap . however , there is a region outside the defect where the intensity is not zero . this is due to the evanescent nature of the light in point defects that do not have quality factor high enough as to confine the field completely . on the other hand , for the optical lattice case , we can see the resulting ground state in fig.([ground ] ) . this can be compared to the ground state without defect , shown in fig . ( [ density ] ) . the localization effect of the wave function comes out of the minimization of the average energy of the system . since the gaussian defect serves as a deeper quantum well than other parts of the optical lattice , it becomes more energetically favourable to occupy it , even though this effect competes with the increased positive interaction between the atoms when they are brought close together . the manipulations we show here of both light and matter waves are interesting on their own right . the molding of both types of waves through the use of appropriate geometries seems to offer a large number of possibilities . in particular , it would be interesting if we could use the molding of light in photonic crystals in order to further accomplish molding of matter waves . we now discuss a simplified example of this possibility using a system with perfect square periodicity for proof of principle . however , we do not introduce defects , or any special geometry , in this example because there is a technical difficulty in photonic crystals that must first be resolved before taking advantage of the actual molding of light to manipulate atoms . we will discuss this difficulty shortly . in the following example , we have considered a square photonic crystal which has very thin dielectric posts ( of the order of @xmath29 , with @xmath30 being the lattice constant ) , so that the cold atoms we use can be affected by the the periodic optical potential without being significantly affected by the material obstacles . we chose an extended mode to illustrate a simple example in which the potential is perfectly periodic . we show this in fig.([elecfield ] ) : the electric field of the extended mode is mainly concentrated at the dielectric posts , further inhibiting the atoms to come into close proximity of the dielectric posts . the gross - pitaevskii ground state was computed using this potential , and the resulting distribution is shown in fig . ( [ ground2 ] ) . this distribution is markedly different from that of the usual optical lattice . the new effective potential is such that each potential minimum is not completely separated by a tunneling barrier from the neighboring minima but , instead , the potential tends to be flat . this facilitates the motion of the atoms between minima of the optical potential . because of this , we see that the height of the wave function does not change significantly in the region between the posts , which contrasts with the ground state found in fig.([density ] ) . the solution shown in fig.([ground2 ] ) exhibits the basic effect of having an extended mode of the pc as an optical lattice . in an actual experimental setup it would be necessary to have an external parabolic potential to provide a confinement for the atoms ; otherwise they would just escape from the photonic crystal . we must address the deterrents which might make it difficult to use these types of optical lattices . the most important one is that if we use , for example , periodic defects in a photonic crystal to induce an optical lattice , we must take into account that the kinds of modes we can produce have some field minima inside the dielectric regions , which would promote collisions of atoms with the posts . although this is not an actual disadvantage , it does require a careful theoretical study in order to quantify such effects . furthermore , even if we can manage to have the light intensity concentrate at the posts , there will inevitably be some residual scattering of the atoms from the posts . this would make it difficult to model the system theoretically , as opposed to relatively simple hamiltonians that arise in the standard optical lattices . finally , there is the experimental difficulty of mounting atoms to the photonic crystal and of performing , for example , time - of - flight measurements to probe the state of the system . however , we feel these experimental difficulties , although important , could be eventually resolved through suitable modifications of the usual experimental setups for optical lattices . in the present work we have explored the possibility of using photonic crystals to induce an optical lattice . by using geometrical constructs such as defects , it is possible to manipulate and mold the intensity distribution of light waves in photonic crystals and the nonlinear dynamics of matter waves in optical lattices . we have argued that a suitable combination of both will provide a new source of many - body quantum behaviour . furthermore , using an extended mode in photonic crystals in order to generate the periodic potential for an optical lattice could be more favourable in reducing costs and in exploring new geometries which can not be obtained easily with the conventional lasers used today . thus , there is a practical , besides fundamental , justification for considering such new types of optical lattices . the authors acknowledge financial support from the codi - universidad de antioquia . we aknowledge j. p. vasco , b. rodriguez and p. soares guimaraes for enlightening discussions . 10 yamamoto y , machida s and bjrk g 1991 _ phys . rev . a _ * 44 * 657 - 668 abdel - aty m 2005 _ applied physics b : lasers and optics _ * 81 * 193 akahane y , asano t , song b and noda s 2003 _ nature _ * 425 * 944 vignolini s , riboli f , intonti f , belotti m , gurioli m and chen y 2008 _ phys . e _ * 78 * 045603 badolato a , winger m , hennessy k j , hu e l and imamoglu a 2008 _ comptes rendus physique _ * 9 * 850 - 856 tuchman a k and kasevich m a 2009 _ phys . lett . _ * 103 * 130403 catani j , barontini g , lamporesi g , rabatti f , thalhammer g , minardi f , stringari s and inguscio m 2009 _ phys . lett . _ * 103 * 140401 pepino r a , cooper j , anderson d z and holland m j 2009 _ phys . lett . _ * 103 * 140405 mishmash r v and carr l d 2009 _ phys . * 103 * 140403 joannopoulos j d , meade r d , johnson s g and winn j n 2008 _ photonic crystals : molding the flow of light , second edition _ ( new jersey : princeton university press ) morsch o and oberthaler m 2006 _ rev . * 78 * 179 stanescu t d , galitski v , vaishnav j y , clark c w and das sarma s 2009 _ phys . a _ * 79 * 053639 peterson m r , zhang c , tewari s and das sarma s 2008 _ phys . lett . _ * 15 * 150406 wang b , chen h , das sarma s 2009 _ phys . rev . a _ * 79 * 051604 wu c and das sarma s 2008 _ phys . * 235107 greentree a d , tahan c , cole j h and hollenberg l c l 2006 _ nature _ * 2 * 856 - 861 jaksch d , bruder c , cirac j i , gardiner c w and zoller p 1998 _ phys . rev . * 81 * 3108 - 3111 yablonovitch e 1987 _ phys . lett . _ * 58 * 2059 - 2026 brazhnyi v a , konotop v v and prez - garca v m 2006 _ phys lett . _ * 96 * 060403

we propose a way of generating optical lattices embedded in photonic crystals . by setting up extended modes in photonic crystals , ultracold atoms can be mounted in different types of field intensity distributions . this novel way of constructing optical lattices can be used to produce more elaborate periodic potentials by manufacturing appropriate geometries of photonic crystals . we exemplify this with a square lattice and comment on the possibility of using geometries with defects .

1410.3099

most of the compact objects currently investigated and modeled in astrophysics are observable `` because of the presence of some matter or radiation around them ( we will often term them as central objects '' below ) . at the lowest order of approximation , the associated gravitational field can be described by the spherically symmetric schwarzschild solution , when shape deformation and rotation effects of the source can be neglected , and matter can be considered as a collection of test particles moving along geodesics . however , this is only an idealized situation which is likely not to represent any real astrophysical system . the dynamics of a body orbiting a compact object is indeed strongly influenced by the combined effect of the overall gravitational field , the surrounding matter and in turn the radiation distribution associated with high energy processes arising thereby . a typical example is represented by a luminous compact object surrounded by orbiting matter , such as accretion discs around a neutron star or a black hole . the most luminous and persistent sources of electromagnetic radiation in the universe are the active galactic nuclei ( agn ) , which are believed to be powered by mass accretion onto black holes . their emitting range is from @xmath0 erg s@xmath1 ( e.g. , the nuclei of some nearby galaxies ) to more than @xmath2 erg s@xmath1 ( distant quasars ) , which is far beyond the eddington luminosity ( about @xmath3 erg s@xmath1 ) . therefore , the x - ray variability in agns and the disc emission lines might contain imprints of the radiation drag effects . in a series of papers we have studied the dynamics of test particles in a given gravitational background while subject to a thomson - type interaction with a superimposed test radiation field , namely the so called poynting - robertson ( pr ) effect @xcite . we modeled the radiation flux as made of photons emitted all along a common direction from a point - like source , leading to an effective drag force to be added to the gravitational force . more realistic descriptions would take into account the finite size of the radiating source and allow for photons to be emitted in any direction . however , the computation of the radiation force in this case usually requires complicated numerical ray - tracing calculations for null geodesics in the background spacetime . the general relativistic stress - energy tensor associated with such a more general scenario was constructed for the first time in the pioneering work of @xcite , who considered the special case of test bodies radially moving in the spacetime of a spherically symmetric non - rotating radiation source with finite radius to model jets and solar winds . they studied the radial equilibrium solutions in which the test particle remains at rest under the combined inward gravitational attraction and the outward photon pressure ( the eddington sphere ) . the stability of this equilibrium configuration has been recently investigated by @xcite , who have also discussed its implications for hoyle - lyttleton accretion onto a luminous star ( see also @xcite ) . @xcite , @xcite and @xcite have then analyzed the effects of a luminosity variation on the eddington sphere , especially in view of the possible occurrence of coronal ejection from the system . within this framework , leaving the spherical symmetry makes the problem very difficult to be addressed . the generalization of the abramowicz et al . approach to the case of an arbitrary particle motion in the equatorial plane of a rotating source is due to @xcite , but in the limit of slow rotation only . their model was then used by @xcite to study the existence of equilibrium solutions . following the original robertson approach , we have considered so far different spacetime solutions of astrophysical interest endowed with reflection symmetry with respect to the equatorial plane , like black hole solutions ( schwarzschild and kerr ) @xcite or radiating spacetimes ( vaidya ) @xcite . we have also discussed the effect of coupling with additional properties of test particles ( like intrinsic spin ) @xcite . the main result of our previous analysis is that particles moving on the symmetry plane ( which do not escape ) are definitely attracted to a certain critical radius where they orbit the central source maintaining equilibrium . in general , the critical radius is not unique for sufficiently large values of the impact parameter of the photons as well as of the strength of the radiation field . here we explore the case of a central source having a quadrupolar structure as described by the erez - rosen solution . this is an exact solutions to the vacuum einstein s field equations which generalizes the schwarzschild spacetime to the case of a gravitational source endowed with an arbitrary mass quadrupole moment , and hence it is specified by two parameters , the mass @xmath4 and the quadrupole parameter @xmath5 . this situation has a strong astrophysical motivation and represents a natural generalization of previous results , even if rotational effects are neglected . in fact , also the kerr solution possesses a non - vanishing quadrupole moment , but the latter is induced by the spacetime rotation . here , the quadrupole parameter @xmath5 describes a genuine mass quadrupole moment directly related to the shape deformation of the source . for instance , the supermassive objects hosted in galaxy centers are generally expected to be also endowed with a non - negligible mass quadrupole moment , which may affect the dynamics of stars moving in the region very close to the central object @xcite . besides rotation , torques from the source s quadrupole moment cause in general precession of the stellar orbital planes , which can be measured by high - precision astrometry . this is the case of the compact cluster of stars orbiting the center of the milky way galaxy at milliparsec distances , monitored since many years @xcite . taking into account quadrupolar deformations is also important when considering the spacetime region around neutron stars , which can assume a pronounced oblate configuration . neutron stars can be part of low mass x - ray binaries ( lmxbs ) , where they are spun up by matter that accretes from a companion , which is typically either a low mass star or a white dwarf . for a dynamically negligible magnetic field , the accretion disc of lmxbs can extend down to the star s surface , where curvature effects dominate . therefore , the observed flux emitted in the inner part of the disc may contain the signatures of a more complicated structure of the source , which can be inferred from available x - ray data . however , significant quadrupolar deformations are mainly due to rotation , as in the case of kerr black holes or rapidly rotating neutron stars . hence , an accurate description of the above systems would need also the inclusion of rotation , which is but beyond the scope of the present analysis , mostly motivated to better understand the role of the quadrupole . the main outcome of this work is the analysis of the effects induced on the equilibrium solutions by the quadrupolar deformation of the source . this is a typical feature of particles undergoing pr effect already discussed in previous works , as already mentioned . we will show that the presence of the quadrupolar structure of the source of the gravitational field may affect the conditions for equilibrium in a significant way , introducing an additional degree of freedom with respect to spherically symmetric sources represented by the quadrupole parameter . this feature can in principle give rise to observable effects . we use geometrical units ( @xmath6 ) and follow notations and conventions of @xcite . the metric signature is @xmath7 . latin indices run from 1 to 3 , greek indices from 0 to 3 . the gravitational field of a nonrotating mass with a quadrupole moment can be described by the erez - rosen solution @xcite . it belongs to the static weyl class of solutions with the line element written in prolate spheroidal coordinates ( @xmath8 ) , with @xmath9 and @xmath10 , as follows @xcite [ metric_weyl ] s^2=-ft^2+\{e^2(x^2-y^2)(+)+(x^2 - 1)(1-y^2)^2 } , where @xmath11 is a constant and the quantities @xmath12 and @xmath13 are functions of @xmath14 and @xmath15 only . the metric functions are given by @xmath16 \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath17 and @xmath18 are legendre polynomials of the first and second kind , respectively ( see appendix a ) , and @xmath5 is the dimensionless quadrupole parameter . positive values of @xmath5 correspond to prolate configurations , i.e. , the mass is mostly concentrated along the axes @xmath19 , whereas negative values to oblate ones . when @xmath20 , the metric ( [ metric_weyl ] ) reduces to the schwarzschild solution provided that @xmath11 be identified with the mass of the source , namely @xmath21 . transition of this metric form to the more familiar one associated with standard schwarzschild - like coordinates is accomplished by the following coordinate transformation @xmath22 and @xmath23 . furthermore , the above solution reduces to the well known hartle - thorne spacetime @xcite with vanishing rotation parameter when linearized with respect to the quadrupole parameter . a suitable family of fiducial observers is that of the so called static observers , with unit timelike four velocity @xmath24 aligned with the timelike killing vector @xmath25 . they are accelerated with acceleration @xmath26 . an orthonormal frame adapted to the static observers is thus given by e_t = n , e_x=1_x , e_y=1_y , e_=1_. the four acceleration as well as the curvature vectors @xmath27 , where @xmath28 , associated with the diagonal metric coefficients @xcite only have nonzero components in the @xmath14-@xmath15 2-plane of the tangent space , i.e. , @xmath29 we limit our analysis to the symmetry plane @xmath30 . therefore , both the acceleration and the curvature vectors are directed along the @xmath31axis , which hereafter will be referred to as the radial direction . let a pure electromagnetic radiation field be superposed as a test field on the gravitational background described by the metric ( [ metric_weyl])([metdef ] ) , with the energy - momentum tensor [ ten_imp ] t^=^2 k^k^ , k^k_=0 , where @xmath32 is assumed to be tangent to an affinely parametrized ( ingoing / outgoing ) null geodesic in the symmetry plane , i.e. , @xmath33 with @xmath34 . we then have [ kdef ] k = e(n)[n+(k , n ) ] , ( k , n)= e_x+ e _ , where e(n)= - k n = is the relative energy of the photons and [ cosbeta ] = . the constant @xmath35 denotes the photon impact parameter defined in terms of the conserved energy @xmath36 and angular momentum @xmath37 associated with the timelike and azimuthal killing vectors , respectively . the case @xmath38 corresponds to outgoing photons ( increasing radial distance from the central source ) and @xmath39 to incoming photons ( decreasing @xmath14 ) . since @xmath32 is completely determined , the coordinate dependence of the quantity @xmath40 then follows from the conservation equations @xmath41 , and will only depend on @xmath14 in the symmetry plane . from eq . ( [ ten_imp ] ) using the geodesic condition for @xmath32 , these can be written as [ flux_cons ] 0=_(^2 k^ ) = _ ( ^2 k^ ) , implying that @xmath42 . therefore , we find @xmath43 , leading to ^2=_0 ^ 2 = _ 0 ^ 2 . in the limit @xmath44 corresponding to photons in radial motion the flux simplifies as ^2=_0 ^ 2 . the photon motion in the symmetry plane has been investigated by @xcite through the analysis of the associated effective potential . a number of interesting features has been discussed there , including the occurrence of multiple photon spheres corresponding to spatially circular null orbits due to the presence of a nonvanishing mass quadrupole moment . [ fig : flux ] shows the behavior of the relative velocity lines of the radiation field ( with respect to the observers @xmath45 ) as well as that of the radiation flux as a function of the radial distance in the case of a erez - rosen spacetime with a selected value of the quadrupole parameter in comparison with the spherically symmetric schwarzschild solution . in the latter case the flux is peaked at @xmath46 ( i.e. , @xmath47 ) and approaches a finite value at the horizon , for the chosen ( high ) value of the photon impact parameter . in the case of a non - spherical source , instead , the behavior of the flux strongly depends on @xmath5 . [ fig : flux ] shows a typical situation corresponding to a prolate configuration ( @xmath48 ) . as it is evident , there exists a forbidden region to photons extending from @xmath49 up to a certain value of @xmath14 , where the flux diverges , hence manifesting a completely different behavior in comparison with the schwarzschild case . for oblate configurations the situation is instead similar to the spherically symmetric case . + consider now a test particle moving in the symmetry plane @xmath30 accelerated by the radiation field , i.e. with 4-velocity [ polarnu ] u=(u , n ) [ n+ ( u , n ) ] , ( u , n)^xe_x+^e _ , where @xmath50 is the lorentz factor ( not to be confused with the metric function ) and the abbreviated notation @xmath51 has been used . a straightforward calculation gives the coordinate components of @xmath52 [ ucoord_comp ] u^t= , u^x= , u^= , where @xmath53 is the proper time parameter along the particle s world line , and @xmath54 . the scattering of radiation as well as the ( constant ) momentum - transfer cross section @xmath55 of the particle are assumed to be independent of the direction and frequency of the radiation so that the associated force is given by @xcite [ frad ] f_(rad)(u)^= -p(u)^ _ t^ _ u^ , where @xmath56 projects orthogonally to @xmath52 . explicitly _ ( rad)(u)^=-^2 [ p(u)^_k^ ] ( k_u^ ) = [ e(u)]^2 ( k , u)^ , where e(u)=-uk = e(n)[1-^x-^ ] , is the photon energy as measured by @xmath52 and ( k , u ) = -u , is the photon relative velocity in the test particle local rest space with the property @xmath57 . the decomposition of the radiation force with respect to @xmath45 is thus given by _ ( rad)(u)=f_(rad)(u)^tn + f_(rad)(u)^xe_x + f_(rad)(u)^e _ , with components @xmath58 and @xmath59 ^ 2\ , \hat { \mathcal v}^{\hat x}\ , , \nonumber\\ { \mathcal f}_{\rm ( rad)}(u)^{\hat \phi } & = & \tilde \sigma \ , [ \phi e(u)]^2\ , \hat { \mathcal v}^{\hat \phi } \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath60 test particle motion is then described by the equation [ eqprtest ] m a(u)^m = f_(rad)(u)^. the frame components of the particle 4-acceleration @xmath61 in the symmetry plane are given by @xmath62\ , , \nonumber \\ a(u)^{\hat y } & = & 0\ , , \nonumber \\ \gamma^{-2}a(u)^{\hat \phi } & = & -\nu^{\hat x}\nu^{\hat \phi}\ , k(\phi , n)^{\hat x } + \gamma\left[\nu^{\hat x}\nu^{\hat \phi}\frac{\rmd \nu^{\hat x}}{\rmd \tau } + ( 1-\nu^{\hat x}{}^2)\frac{\rmd \nu^{\hat \phi}}{\rmd \tau}\right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] from eq . ( [ eqprtest ] ) , the evolution equations for the frame components of the linear velocity then read as @xmath63 -\gamma\nu^{\hat \phi}\left[\nu^{\hat \phi}k(\phi , n)^{\hat x}+\nu^{\hat x}\frac{{\mathcal f}_{\rm ( rad)}(u)^{\hat \phi}}{m\gamma^2}\right]\ , , \nonumber \\ \frac{\rmd \nu^{\hat \phi}}{\rmd \tau } & = & ( 1-\nu^{\hat \phi}{}^2)\frac{{\mathcal f}_{\rm ( rad)}(u)^{\hat \phi}}{m\gamma } + \gamma\nu^{\hat x}\nu^{\hat \phi}\left[a(n)^{\hat x}+k(\phi , n)^{\hat x } -\frac{{\mathcal f}_{\rm ( rad)}(u)^{\hat x}}{m\gamma^2}\right]\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which should be considered together with eq . ( [ ucoord_comp ] ) . the explicit expressions for the radial components of the acceleration as well as curvature vectors are listed in appendix a. examples of numerical integration of the orbits are shown in fig . [ fig : orbite ] for a fixed value of the radiation field strength and different values of the quadrupole parameter . the case of a spherically symmetric source ( @xmath20 ) is also shown for comparison . initial conditions are chosen so that the particle trajectory is initially tangent to a circular orbit with a value of the azimuthal velocity which is either less than ( first row ) or equal to ( second row ) the geodesic one . as a general feature , unless the particle has a sufficiently high initial speed that it can escape to infinity , it is forced to end up in a circular orbit which is an equilibrium solution , representing the balance between gravitational attraction , centrifugal force and radiation drag , as discussed in the next section . [ fig : orbite ] shows that particles feel a gravitational field with different strength if the source is oblate ( @xmath64 ) or prolate ( @xmath65 ) . in the former case the incoming particle feels a stronger gravitational field as it approaches the gravity source . for prolate configurations , instead , the gravitational mass is mainly concentrated along the @xmath66axis , so that a particle moving sufficiently close to the source will feel a decreasing gravitational field . as a result , the balance between inward gravitational force and outward radiation force will occur at larger radii . the set of equations ( [ motioneqs ] ) and ( [ ucoord_comp ] ) admits an equilibrium solution which corresponds to a circular orbit with constant speed at a given distance @xmath67 from the central source . in fact , setting @xmath68 and @xmath69 const . in the above equations we get the conditions @xmath70 where it is understood that all functions of @xmath14 are evaluated at @xmath67 and we have used the notation @xmath71 , as in @xcite . the second eq . ( [ equileqs ] ) yields the critical circular velocity [ nu0limit ] ^_0 = _ 0 = _ 0= , which turns out to be equal to the photon azimuthal velocity ( see eq . ( [ cosbeta ] ) ) . substituting then into the first equation gives an implicit relation determining the critical radius @xmath72 itself as a function of @xmath73 , which can be also written as [ equil ] a(n)^x(1-)= , where the circular geodesic ( @xmath74 ) azimuthal velocities @xmath75 , with _ g=1 , have been introduced , satisfying the relation @xmath76 . partial derivatives of the metric functions with respect to @xmath14 and @xmath15 are indicated by a subscript . solving eq . ( [ equil ] ) for @xmath77 finally gives [ equil2 ] = sgn(_0)_0 ^ 3(1-)(x^2 - 1 ) . [ fig : equil ] shows the behavior of the critical azimuthal velocity ( first row ) as well as critical photon impact parameter ( second row ) as a function of the radial distance for selected values of the friction parameter @xmath77 ( in units of @xmath11 ) and different values of the quadrupole parameter . the critical speed is less / greater than the geodesic speed in the case of outgoing / ingoing photons ( @xmath78 ) . the features of equilibrium are different depending on whether prolate or oblate sources are considered . in the former case , for increasing values of @xmath77 the curves lie in the region above the geodesic velocity for ingoing photons , with the asymptotic limit @xmath79 for @xmath80 . for outgoing photons , instead , the curves are below the geodesic one , continuing to move out far from the source for increasing values of @xmath77 without limit . in the case of oblate sources , instead , the situation is very similar to the schwarzschild one @xcite . consider first the case of outgoing photons . the curves of constant @xmath77 start at the value @xmath74 at the hypersurface @xmath49 ( vertical axis ) and on the geodesic velocity curves , and increase in value towards the saddle point on the separatrix curve at a certain value of @xmath77 . for @xmath77 further increasing past that value , the curves fill the inner sector above that point ( near the hypersurface @xmath49 ) . at the same time , in the region below the meeting point they move farther out to larger radii , moving out to infinity in the limit @xmath81 , corresponding to the fact that for @xmath82 , test particles are pushed out to infinity in this region . in the case of ingoing photons , instead , all the curves of constant @xmath77 are confined in the region above the geodesic velocity . the equilibrium condition ( [ equil2 ] ) can also be written in terms of the photon impact parameter in place of the critical speed , by using eq . ( [ nu0limit ] ) . the resulting equation determines the critical radius in terms of the photon impact parameter . for fixed values of @xmath73 and @xmath77 , one or more values of @xmath72 may satisfy it , which may correspond to stable orbits or not . the stability analysis of critical orbits is done in the next section . for each curve in the plots shown in the second row of fig . [ fig : equil ] corresponding to fixed values of @xmath77 , the number of its intersections with the horizontal line at each value of @xmath73 indicates the number of critical radii which exist for that case . those horizontal curves which pass through the interior of the closed shaded regions correspond to the case in which three critical radii exist , with the unstable orbit of the three lying in the interior , while those passing outside these loops correspond to the single stable critical radius case . finally , fig . [ fig : x_vs_q ] shows the behavior of the critical radius as a function of the quadrupole parameter for selected values of the friction parameter @xmath77 and different values of the the photon impact parameter @xmath73 ( in units of @xmath11 ) . for small values of @xmath73 there exists in general a single equilibrium radius for every value of the quadrupole parameter , which is closer to the source as the configuration is more oblate . for larger values of the photon impact parameter multiple solutions appear for @xmath83 . increasing the strength of the radiation field then causes the latter behavior to occur for even smaller values of @xmath73 . + in the limit of vanishing photon impact parameter @xmath84 eq . ( [ nu0limit ] ) implies @xmath85 , which corresponds to suspension orbits,"i.e . , particle trajectories end up at a certain point in the symmetry plane . the equilibrium condition ( [ equil ] ) reduces to a(n)^x= = , and implicitly gives the suspension radius as a function of @xmath77 for fixed values of the quadrupole parameter . let us study the stability properties of the critical circular orbits under small first order linear perturbations of the equilibrium solution , whose parametric equation is given by x = x_0 , = _ 0 ( ) , ^x=0 , ^=^_0 , or symbolically @xmath86 ( @xmath87 ) . note that this analysis will not check for stability against perturbations away from the equatorial plane . consider the linear perturbations of this solution @xmath88 , namely x = x_0+x_1 ( ) , = _ 0()+_1 ( ) , ^x=^x_1 ( ) , ^=^_0+^_1 ( ) , which leads to the following linear system of constant coefficient homogeneous linear differential equations = c^_x_1^ , which can easily be solved in terms of the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the coefficient matrix . the real parts of all eigenvalues must be nonnegative for stability . the explicit expressions for the nonzero coefficients are @xmath89 \right\ } \,,\nonumber\\ c^3{}_{3 } & = & -2c^4{}_{4}\,,\qquad c^3{}_{4}=-2\gamma_0 ^ 3\nu^{\hat \phi}_0(a(n)^{\hat x}+k(\phi , n)^{\hat x } ) \ , , \nonumber\\ c^4{}_{1}&=&\frac{\sqrt{g_{xx}}}{2\gamma_0 ^ 3}c^3{}_{4}c^4{}_{4}\,,\qquad c^4{}_{3}=\frac{\nu^{\hat \phi}_0}{\gamma_0}(k(\phi , n)^{\hat x}-c^4{}_{4})\,,\qquad c^4{}_{4 } = \frac{a\sigma^2}{\gamma_0f\sqrt{g_{yy}}\sqrt{g_{\phi\phi}}}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath77 given by eq . ( [ equil2 ] ) . the quantities @xmath90 in the above equations are the frame components with respect to @xmath45 of the electric part of the riemann tensor defined by @xmath91 . the associated eigenvalue equation is [ eqlambda ] = 0 , where @xmath92 \,,\nonumber\\ c_1 + 2c_2 ^ 2 & = & \frac{\gamma_0 ^ 2}{\gamma_{\rm g}^2}\omega_{\rm ( ep)}^2 + \gamma_0 ^ 2(\nu^{\hat \phi}_0{}^2-\nu_{\rm g}^2)\left [ -e(n)_{\hat y\hat y}+\frac{a(n)^{\hat x}{}^2}{\nu_{\rm g}^4}(3 - 2\nu_{\rm g}^2 ) \right]\nonumber\\ & & -c_2\left[k(y , n)^{\hat x}-\gamma_0 ^ 2a(n)^{\hat x}\left(2 - 3\nu^{\hat \phi}_0{}^2+\frac1{\nu_{\rm g}^2}\right)\right ] \ , , \nonumber\\ c_2&=&c^4{}_{4 } \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and [ eq : omegaep ] _ ( ep)^2=3+_g^2(e(n)_xx-_g^2e(n)_yy ) , is the corresponding proper time normalized version of the time coordinate epicyclic frequency governing the radial perturbations of circular geodesics . in the schwarzschild case it reduces to _ ( ep)^2= = . the explicit expressions for the eigenvalues can be obtained straightforwardly . in the case of geodesic motion ( i.e. , @xmath74 and @xmath93 ) the eigenvalue equation ( [ eqlambda ] ) reduces to ^2(^2+_(ep)^2)=0 , since @xmath94 and @xmath95 . the behavior of the eigenvalues as functions of the radial distance from the central source shows that for a given value of the quadrupole parameter there exist in general two disconnected regions where circular orbits are stable ( see fig . [ fig : equil ] ) : one very close to the singularity , and another for larger radii , which is relevant for observational effects . therefore , we refer to the left boundary of that region as the radius corresponding to the innermost stable orbit ( isco ) . the behavior of the isco radius as a function of the quadrupole parameter is shown in fig . [ fig : isco ] for both fixed values of @xmath73 ( left panel ) and fixed values of @xmath77 ( right panel ) . we find that the orbits are always stable for prolate configurations with @xmath96 . in any attempt to construct a realistic model of test particle motion around compact objects to be constrained by observations one should take into account both the structure of these objects and the effects of the presence of electromagnetic or radiation fields surrounding them . black holes are commonly expected to be hosted at the center of galaxies as well as in x - ray binary systems ( see , e.g. , @xcite and references therein ) . according to the einstein s theory of gravity , an uncharged black hole is completely specified by its total mass and angular momentum , which determine all the higher order mass and current moments of the gravitational field . in particular , the mass quadrupole moment of a spinning black hole is proportional to the angular momentum squared . however , general relativity allows for exact solutions which represent compact objects with additional structure , i.e. , with the multipole moments of the associated gravitational field expressed in terms of an arbitrary set of parameters @xcite . for instance , the erez - rosen solution , which we adopt in the present paper , generalizes the schwarzschild spacetime to the case of a gravitational source endowed with an arbitrary mass quadrupole moment , and hence it is specified by two parameters , the mass @xmath4 and the quadrupole parameter @xmath5 . as expected , the presence of the quadrupole affects the motion of test particles and photons in a significant way @xcite . there is a growing interest in the current literature in constraining the geometry around compact objects with observations in both the electromagnetic and gravitational wave spectra . in fact , both space and ground - based advanced gravitational wave detectors ( like lisa @xcite and advanced ligo / virgo @xcite ) are expected to detect , e.g. , the gravitational waves emitted during the inspiral of binary systems . any deviation from either the schwarzschild or kerr black hole geometry will then lead to a phase difference in the gravitational waveforms as well as to the ringdown radiation in the form of the so - called quasinormal modes of the end state of the merger @xcite . it is also a general feature that compact objects are surrounded by an accretion disc , which forms due to the diffuse material orbiting them coming from either the companion in the case of stellar - mass objects in x - ray binary systems , or from the interstellar medium in the case of supermassive objects in galactic nuclei . for these systems the effect of a nonvanishing quadrupolar structure can also be inferred from available x - ray data , by studying for instance relativistic broadening of iron lines @xcite , disc s thermal spectrum @xcite , quasi - periodic oscillations @xcite , x - ray polarization @xcite and mean radiative efficiency of agn @xcite . in many of the existing models , accretion flows are represented by thin discs lying in the equatorial plane of the compact object , and the particles in the disc typically move on circular orbits . since the spacetime curvature experienced by the disc is largest at the inner edge , where most of the observed flux is emitted , its location is of special importance . it is usually taken to coincide with the innermost stable circular orbit ( isco ) , which depends on the mass and angular momentum in the case of a kerr black hole , but may depends on other spacetime parameters , if more general solutions are considered . in the present paper , we have studied the motion of test particles undergoing poynting - robertson effect ( i.e. , scattered by a superposed test radiation field ) in the field of a static non - spherical source described by the erez - rosen solution . the radiation field is modeled by photons which move on the equatorial plane and have an arbitrary , but constant angular momentum . the particle - photon interaction produces non - geodesic orbits around the central body whose features depend both on the radiation field strength and the photon impact parameter , but also on the value of the mass quadrupole parameter of the source . in fact , particles as well as photons are expected to feel a gravitational field with different strength in the region close to the source with respect to the spherically symmetric case ( @xmath20 ) depending on whether the central object is oblate ( @xmath64 ) or prolate ( @xmath65 ) . in the former case the incoming particle feels a stronger gravitational field as it approaches the gravity source . for prolate configurations , instead , the gravitational mass is mainly concentrated along the @xmath66axis , i.e. , orthogonally to the symmetry plane where the motion takes place , so that a particle moving sufficiently close to the gravity source will feel a decreasing gravitational field , since most of the gravitational action is being neutralized there . the main outcome of our analysis is that there exists a whole family of equilibrium solutions ( circular orbits ) representing the balance between gravitational attraction , centrifugal force and radiation drag . in fact , if the strength of the radiation field is fixed , the quadrupole parameter of the source can be used to parametrize this family , so leading to a scenario which is more rich with respect to that of a spherically symmetric source . the associated stability analysis has allowed to determine the isco radius as a function of the parameters characterizing the radiation field as well as of the quadrupole parameter of the source . we have found that for a given value of the quadrupole parameter there exist in general two disconnected regions where circular orbits are stable : one very close to the central object , and another for larger radii , which is relevant for observational effects . this analysis can be straightforwardly extended to more general situations , e.g. , by accounting for quadrupolar sources also endowed with nonvanishing rotation . the legendre polynomials entering the definition of the metric functions ( [ metdef ] ) are listed below : @xmath97\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] according to the geroch - hansen @xcite definition of relativistic multipole moments @xmath98 , the mass monopole moment associated with this solution is @xmath99 and the quadrupole moment is given by @xmath100 . higher multipole moments of the order @xmath101 , @xmath102 , are determined by @xmath5 and @xmath4 in such a way that they all vanish when @xmath20 . the presence of the quadrupole parameter @xmath5 changes significantly the structure of the spacetime as compared with the schwarzschild solution . in particular the hypersurface @xmath49 , which is null in the schwarzschild case , becomes directionally singular . furthermore , its character depends both on the value of @xmath5 . for instance , in the symmetry plane @xmath30 this hypersurface is null for @xmath103 and timelike otherwise ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . the explicit expressions for the radial components of the acceleration as well as curvature vectors in the symmetry plane @xmath30 are listed below : @xmath104\ , , \nonumber \\ k(y , n)^{\hat x } & = & k(\phi , n)^{\hat x}-e^{-\gamma}\frac{\sqrt{f}}{\sigma x^2\sqrt{x^2 - 1}}[(x^2 - 1)x\gamma_x-1]\ , , \nonumber \\ k(\phi , n)^{\hat x } & = & a(n)^{\hat x}-e^{-\gamma}\frac{\sqrt{f}}{\sigma\sqrt{x^2 - 1}}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath105 and @xmath106 satisfies the following second order differential equation q_2+q_2-q_2=0 . finally , the relevant frame components of the electric part of the riemann tensor are given by @xmath107\ , , \nonumber \\ e(n)_{\hat y\hat y } & = & -e(n)_{\hat x\hat x}+\frac14\frac{e^{-2\gamma}}{\sigma^2x^2}\frac{f_x}{f}\left[(x^2 - 1)f_x-2xf\right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] db and ag acknowledge icranet for partial support . all the authors thank prof . l. stella for useful discussions at the beginning of the present project . ap acknowledges support from the european union seventh framework programme ( fp7/2007 - 2013 ) under grant agreement no . 267251 astronomy fellowships in italy ( astrofit).

the motion of a test particle in the gravitational field of a non - spherical source endowed with both mass and mass quadrupole moment is investigated when a test radiation field is also present . the background is described by the erez - rosen solution , which is a static spacetime belonging to the weyl class of solutions to the vacuum einstein s field equations , and reduces to the familiar schwarzschild solution when the quadrupole parameter vanishes . the radiation flux has a fixed but arbitrary ( non - zero ) angular momentum . the interaction with the radiation field is assumed to be thomson - like , i.e. , the particles absorb and re - emit radiation , thus suffering for a friction - like drag force . such an additional force is responsible for the poynting - robertson effect , which is well established in the framework of newtonian gravity and has been recently extended to the general theory of relativity . the balance between gravitational attraction , centrifugal force and radiation drag leads to the occurrence of equilibrium circular orbits which are attractors for the surrounding matter for every fixed value of the interaction strength . the presence of the quadrupolar structure of the source introduces a further degree of freedom : there exists a whole family of equilibrium orbits parametrized by the quadrupole parameter , generalizing previous works . this scenario is expected to play a role in the context of accretion matter around compact objects . [ firstpage ] non - spherical sources mass quadrupole moment radiation drag

1007.2789

the dimension 2 gluon condensate @xmath0 in pure yang - mills theory has been proposed in @xcite , and it has been investigated in different ways since then @xcite . in @xcite an analytical framework for studying this condensate has been developed , based on work carried out in the gross - neveu model @xcite . different problems had to be overcome . first of all there is the gauge invariance of this condensate . in order to make the operator @xmath1 gauge invariant , one can take the minimum of its integral over the gauge orbit . since @xmath2 , with @xmath3 , is positive , this minimum will always exist . in a general gauge , however , the minimum is a highly nonlocal and thus hard to handle expression of the gauge field . a minimum is however reached in the landau gauge ( @xmath4 ) , though , so that working in this gauge reduces the operator to a local expression . secondly adding a source @xmath5 , coupled to @xmath1 , makes the theory nonrenormalizable at the quantum level . to solve this , a term quadratic in the source must be added , which in turn spoils the energy interpretation of the effective action . one way around this is to perform the legendre inversion , but this is rather cumbersome , especially so with a general , spacetime dependent source . one can also use a hubbard - stratonovich transform , which introduces an auxiliary field ( whose interpretation is just the condensate ) and eliminates the term quadratic in the source . details can be found in @xcite . the result was that the yang - mills vacuum favors a finite value for the expectation value of @xmath1 . the precise renormalization details of the procedure proposed in @xcite were given in @xcite . recently , chernodub and ilgenfritz @xcite have considered the asymmetry in the dimension two condensate . they performed lattice simulations , computing the expectation value of the electric - magnetic asymmetry in landau gauge , which they defined as @xmath6 at zero temperature , this quantity must of course be zero due to lorentz invariance . necessarily it can not diverge as divergences at finite @xmath7 are the same as for @xmath8 , hence this asymmetry is in principle finite and can be computed without renormalization , for all temperatures . a first remark concerns the visibility of the ( de)confinement phase transition in the value of the asymmetry@xcite . at temperatures lower than the critical one , the asymmetry goes from zero at zero temperature to a positive value , which reaches a maximum at the critical temperature . at higher temperatures , the asymmetry decreases and becomes negative when @xmath9 . the two transition points the phase transition temperature and the symmetric point where the asymmetry goes through zero divide the temperature range in three regions . these seem to coincide with those associated with the condensed , liquid , and gaseous states of the magnetic monopoles , whose dynamics are closely related to confinement and deconfinement ( see , for example , @xcite ) . at yet higher temperatures , one would expect the perturbative behavior to kick in , which goes like @xmath10 at lowest order . however , lattice artifacts prohibit lattice computations at sufficiently high temperatures to see this @xcite . at low temperatures , from thermodynamical arguments one would expect an exponential fall - off with the lowest glueball mass in the exponent , @xmath11 . instead , the authors of @xcite found an exponential with a mass @xmath12 significantly smaller than @xmath13 . so far , there is no explanation for this behavior . in @xcite , the authors and collaborators have extended the framework from @xcite to include the asymmetry @xmath14 . in that article , the potential was computed for @xmath8 , and no non - trivial value for the asymmetry was found as is necessary for lorentz invariance . in this paper we extend the computations in order to include finite temperature effects , with the aim of shedding more light on the results of @xcite . in section [ prel ] we give a short review of what was found in @xcite , which is then continued by a computation of the finite temperature effective action in section [ tr ] . in section [ min ] we find and discuss the minima of the potential , the values of the different condensates and their temperature dependence . section [ conc ] concludes the paper . in @xcite the effective action in the presence of a dimension two condensate and of an asymmetry was computed . since the starting point for the calculations when @xmath15 are identical , we shortly review the steps taken in @xcite . the starting point to compute the effective potential is the following lagrangian density : @xmath16 where the following couplings have been introduced : @xmath17 to one - loop order . the vacuum expecation values of the @xmath18 and @xmath19 fields are @xmath20 in order to simplify notations , we set @xmath21 which denote an effective mass and an effective mass matrix . with these notations , the condensates as defined with the conventions of @xcite are @xmath22 where the latin index denotes the space components . with these givens it is possible to compute the effective action for a space - time independent @xmath23 and @xmath24 using the background field formalism . we separate the two fields into a classical part and quantum fluctuations , after which the fluctuations can be integrated out . expanding the resulting path integral over @xmath25 to one - loop order gives @xmath26 + \frac{n^2 - 1}2 \operatorname{tr}\ln \left ( -\partial^2\delta_{\mu\nu } + \left(1-\frac1\xi\right)\partial_\mu\partial_\nu + \delta_{\mu\nu } g\sigma ' + m_{\mu\nu}\right ) \;,\ ] ] where the limit @xmath27 is implied , as we work in the landau gauge . as we are interested in the asymmetry , we parametrize the mass matrix as @xmath28 i.e. we preserve rotational invariance in the spatial part . with this form , the @xmath29 in the effective potential can be split into different parts , and in the limit @xmath27 we get @xmath30 + \frac{n^2 - 1}2\operatorname{tr}\ln ( -\partial^2 ) + \frac{n^2 - 1}2(d-2 ) \operatorname{tr}\ln\left(-\partial^2+m^2-\frac { a}{d-1}\right ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{n^2 - 1}2\operatorname{tr}\ln\left(-\partial^2+m^2 + a\left(1-\frac{d}{d-1}\frac{\partial_0 ^ 2}{\partial^2}\right)\right ) \;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] at finite @xmath7 and in euclidean space - time , the spectrum of @xmath31 is discrete the eigenvalues are @xmath32 where @xmath33 are the matsubara frequencies and @xmath34 is the momentum in the spacelike directions . it happens to be convenient to take the second and the last terms of together ( mark that @xmath35 in dimensional regularization does not vanish for finite @xmath7 , but it gives a constant contribution to the energy ) , so that we have to compute the following traces : [ beginnetje ] @xmath36 the sums can be computed using standard techniques . in order to have convergent sums , one first writes ( for concreteness , consider the first sum ) : @xmath37 then the sum can be computed , for example using a formula derived from the product representation for the sine function : @xmath38 where we have taken the logarithm of both sides of the first identity , and subsequently taken the derivative with respect to @xmath39 . applying this to our sum and performing the indefinite integral in @xmath40 , we find @xmath41 where @xmath42 is a constant of integration . by considering the @xmath43 limit , one can show that it must be equal to @xmath44 . this gives the result that @xmath45 this can be split into the @xmath8 contribution and a finite temperature correction : @xmath46 where we have set @xmath47 in the temperature correction . the second expression can be computed in an analogous way , except that the numerator in the sum is a fourth - order polynomial , and it is thus necessary to split the fraction in partial fractions . we find the temperature correction to the trace to be equal to @xmath48 where we have used the short - hand notations @xmath49 and @xmath50 . from @xcite we already know the zero - temperature effective potential . if we add the temperature correction found above , we can start the work of searching for minima . as the expressions involved are pretty much unhandleable , we use two strategies : expanding in series gives some analytical insight in the low- and high-@xmath7 behavior , and numerical minimization gives a global view of the temperature dependence . for the numerical part , we have used @xmath51 , the value of @xmath52 in the non - perturbative minimum at zero temperature@xcite , and @xmath53 . it is possible to have @xmath54 shift as @xmath52 gets modified at finite temperature ; this , however , does not significantly change the results . plotting and visually inspecting the potential reveals only one minimum , which coincides with the already known non - perturbative minimum at @xmath8 . one would expect the zero - temperature perturbative solution to become a saddle - point of the potential at finite @xmath7 , but it turns out that this saddle - point can only be found from @xmath55 onwards . for lower temperatures it seems that the saddle - point is located in a region of the parameter space where the effective potential has an imaginary part . for slightly higher temperatures , the saddle - point and the non - perturbative minimum merge and from a temperature of @xmath56 onwards no solutions to the gap equation can be found anymore . we will say more about this in paragraph [ hoget ] . the values of the condensates in the non - perturbative minimum are plotted in figure [ eerstefiguur ] . in this figure we have used the sign and prefactor conventions of @xcite instead of those from @xcite , which means that the value of @xmath0 , being the opposite of @xmath18 , is negative . we see that the absolute value of @xmath0 is slightly lowered by raising the temperature . the asymmetry is positive and rising , just as was found on the lattice in @xcite . our value for the asymmetry seems to be slightly lower , but as we have only done a one - loop calculation , one can not expect the results to have very high accuracy . condensate ( full line ) and the asymmetry @xmath14 ( dashed line ) as functions of the temperature , in units @xmath57 . [ eerstefiguur],width=264 ] in figure [ elem ] the values of the electric part and the magnetic part are plotted separately . at @xmath8 both are , naturally , equal . when increasing the temperature , the electric component goes up , while the magnetic component remains approximately constant . this is also what has been found on the lattice@xcite . similar conclusions for correlations in the gluon condensate were also found in @xcite . condensate as function of the temperature . ( the magnetic component has been divided by three to be able to compare with the electric component . ) [ elem],width=264 ] analytically , the limit @xmath58 can be considered . in order to find the dominant behavior , we proceed as follows : first , the exponentials in the integrals are small for small @xmath7 , meaning that @xmath59 . then , we expand the square roots for small @xmath60 . the expansion of the square root will only be valid up to a certain value of @xmath60 , but this is still a legitimate step as the greater values of @xmath60 hardly contribute due to exponential suppression . in the expansion we only keep the terms up to the first non - trivial order of @xmath60 , after which the integrals can be easily evaluated . we find that the three integrals in the potential have lowest - order behavior @xmath61 respectively . it is clear that , for low @xmath7 , the second integral will dominate . if we take this to be the first low - temperature correction , we find for the asymmetry @xmath62 and ( to this order in the temperature ) there is no correction to @xmath63 . if we apply a fit to the low - temperature part of our numerical data , the two results are in nice agreement . mark that , as there is no @xmath64 correction to @xmath63 but there is a positive one to @xmath14 , the magnetic component of the condensate will decrease its value , or increase its absolute value , as can be seen in figure [ elem ] . this is in opposition to the behavior of the electric component , which only decreases in absolute value . the increase in @xmath65 is small , however , and it is not sure how higher - loop correction will influence this result . in @xcite it was found that the value of the asymmetry was best described by an exponential form @xmath66 with @xmath67 . they , however , only had data for @xmath68 . for such higher temperatures , the lowest order in the expansion is , of course , not sufficient , and the exponential corrections can not be ignored anymore . in order to investigate the behavior of the asymmetry , the numerical results have to be used again . it turns out to be very difficult to find a fit good enough in broader intervals . given the complexity of the analytical expressions and given the fact that we have only done the calculations up to one - loop order , it is not possible to say more about it , however . mark that , given the fact that our model has a mass gap , one would expect an exponential behavior with the effective gluon mass in the exponential . our not finding this is due to the landau gauge prescription : the last inverse propagator in does not correspond to a simple yukawa form when the asymmetry becomes nonzero . one should mark that the landau gauge is singled out as the gauge where @xmath0 reaches its minimum along the gauge orbit , giving this condensate a physical meaning . this is not the case with the asymmetry , and as such it is not all that surprising to find a non - exponential behavior for it . in order to get more insight in the disappearance of all solutions to the gap equation at higher @xmath7 , we will expand the effective potential in this limit . herefore it is necessary we return to and do the integrations first , receiving , for example , for the first expression @xmath69 this can be expanded in high @xmath7 , but one sees that the @xmath70 term has to be split off . we find : @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the riemann zeta function . the term with @xmath73 will give a pole in the @xmath74 limit . the second contribution from can be expanded analogously . all together , we find the following high-@xmath7 expansion : @xmath75 where we have dropped the @xmath64 term , as it does not depend on the fields in any way and is , thus , irrelevant . now one has to keep in mind that , at high temperatures , one expects the fields to scale with the temperature , and that all terms in the expansion above are effectively of the same order in @xmath7 . however , one expects to have that @xmath76 , making the above series one in @xmath77 , with the first two terms being of the same order . solving the gap equation perturbatively yields at lowest order @xmath78 and for the condensates : @xmath79 this is exactly the result one expects from a perturbative computation . going to higher order in this expansion , some subtleties are encountered . first note that the effective gluon masses squared are negative , and the next term in the expansion contains square roots of the masses . this gives an imaginary part to the potential . another point of note is the fact that our expansion has effectively become a series in the coupling @xmath77 instead of one in the temperature . this means that , when going to higher order in @xmath80 , one has to take into account the effect of higher - loop diagrams . these two problems are actually related . it has been known for a long time that , at higher temperatures , the perturbation series must be reorganized . in ordinary pure yang mills theory , this amounts to giving the timelike gluon a debye mass @xmath81 , which effectively resums the hard ( high momentum ) contributions of the diagrams in figure [ debye1 ] . in our formalism , however , there are four additional vertices . this gives rise to four extra diagrams that need to be resummed . they are shown in figure [ debye2 ] . computing these diagrams , it turns out that they exactly cancel the lowest - order contribution from the condensate . , width=151 ] part of the lco lagrangian , and again the same two diagrams from the @xmath19 part of the lco lagrangian . the index `` @xmath82 , @xmath83 '' has been added to remind of the fact that this depicts the two four - gluon vertices coming from the lco formalism . the dotted line is the @xmath18 or @xmath84 propagator . [ debye2],width=151 ] when doing this resummation , one has to watch out for double counting , which can happen when considering diagrams without external lines@xcite . however , it turns out that this double counting is put right by the mismatch in symmetry factors in the diagrammatic expansion of the vacuum energy . as such , we can proceed without worrying about this . adding the resummed diagrams to the result found in , we find up to the effective order @xmath85 : @xmath86 where , again , terms not containing the fields @xmath87 and @xmath88 have been dropped . again solving this perturbatively , we find : @xmath89 and analogously for @xmath63 and @xmath14 . this is exactly what one would expect from perturbation theory . we computed the effective action of su(@xmath90 ) landau gauge yang - mills theory in the presence of a dimension two condensate and an asymmetry in this condensate . figure [ eerstefiguur ] is the main result of this article . we find good qualitative agreement with the numerical results of @xcite , with some discrepancies due to different definitions we define the condensates with the perturbative contributions subtracted , whence they vanish in the high temperature , perturbative , regime . the quantitative agreement is less excellent , but as our computations are just one - loop and the coupling is not all that small , one may not hope for miracles . a two - loop treatment , however , is intractable , even at zero temperature@xcite . the low-@xmath7 behavior seems to be best described by @xmath91 , as a naive computation in an abelian higgs model would lead us to expect@xcite . the mismatch with the exponential fit found in @xcite is probably due to their having data only for @xmath68 . at high temperatures it turns out that resummation _ la _ hard - thermal - loop is necessary , and not doing this will give no solutions when imposing that the effective action be real . after resumming the necessary diagrams , the perturbative values for the condensates are recovered . no non - perturbative solutions are found . the only part of the temperature range where we can not boast good results is around the phase transition . at that point the temperature is already too high to trust a simple one - loop computation , and the high - temperature expansion can not be expected to still yield good results at a temperature so low . when this article was in preparation , we learned that lattice computations for the full dimension two condensate and for the electric and magnetic components separately at finite temperature have been completed@xcite . qualitative agreement is again good . for @xmath92 , it is indeed found that the electric component shows much more temperature dependence than the magnetic component , which is nearly constant in that range . we wish to thank m. chernodub for encouraging this research and for many discussions . d.v . also gratefully acknowledges helpful discussions with d. dudal .

in this paper , we continue the work begun in a previous article . we compute , in the formalism of local composite operators , the value of the asymmetry in the dimension two condensate for finite temperatures . we find a positive value for the asymmetry , which disappears when the temperature is increased . we also compute the value of the full dimension two condensate for higher temperatures , and we find that it decreases in abolute value , finally disappearing for sufficiently high temperature . we also comment on the temperature dependence of the electric and magnetic components of the condensate seperately . we compare our results with the corresponding lattice date found by chernodub and ilgenfritz .

physics0509174

the large hadron collider ( lhc ) at cern will open a new frontier in particle physics due to its higher collision energy and luminosity as compared to the existing accelerators . the general - purpose atlas and cms experiments at the lhc will employ precision tracking , calorimetry and muon measurements over a large solid angle to identify and measure electrons , muons , photons , jets and missing energy accurately . therefore , they have great physics potential in discovering many possible new particles . among them are the standard model ( sm ) higgs boson , supersymmetric ( susy ) and other new particles beyond the sm . all of them can have masses in a very large range up to the tev scale . the significance calculation in searching for and observation of a physics signal with known location and shape is no longer valid when either the location or the shape of the signal is unknown . this will be the case for many of the possible new physics signals at the lhc . in section 2 , we give a short review of the significance calculation and current analysis strategy in high energy physics ( hep ) and at the lhc . using a signal with known shape but unknown location as an example , we discuss in detail in section 3 the problems of the current significance calculation . we then describe general procedures for significance calculation and comparing different search schemes in section 4 . in section 5 , we describe a new analysis method and compare it with the current `` sliding - window '' approaches following these procedures . detailed comparison results are also given in this section . summary and discussion are given in section 6 . in this note we limit ourselves to the significance calculation and analysis method used in searching for an individual decay mode of new physics signals . in the field of hep , a common strategy to detect a physics signal is to search for an excess of events in a certain region of a kinematic observable . the observation probability is given by poisson statistics : @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the number of the expected events to be observed in the region , and @xmath2 is the number of the observed events in this region . when @xmath1 is large ( over 25 , for instance ) , the significance of an observation can be approximated well by @xmath3 of gaussian statistics , where @xmath4 . in hep , the significance of an observation is defined by the probability that such an observation is due to statistical fluctuation of background events . when we claim an observation has a significance of @xmath5 @xcite , the common criterion for a hep discovery , the probability that the claimed discovery is due to statistical fluctuation of background events , known as the type i error rate in statistics , needs to be less than @xmath6 . the background fluctuation probabilities which define the 1@xmath7 to 5@xmath7 significances in hep are shown in table [ tab : sig - def ] . .the definition of significance in hep and the corresponding background statistical fluctuation probabilities . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ result30 ] the work and results for 5 , 10 , 15 , 20 , 25 , 30 and 35 signal events embedded with gaussian means at 42.00 , 46.00 , 48.00 , 49.00 , 49.50 , 49.75 , 49.90 and 50.00 are shown in ref . the results for 10 , 20 , and 30 signal events embedded are shown in tables [ result10 ] , [ result20 ] and [ result30 ] . we can see that the number of signal embedded experiments successfully found with a certain significance is much lower than what expected from @xmath3 calculations . this is a price we have to pay for not knowing the exact location of the signal . furthermore , for the `` sliding - window '' method , the sensitivity strongly depends on the exact location of the embedded signal . if the step size is greater than 1 , the embedded signals are totally missed for the worst - case scenarios . for step size of 1 or less , there are still significant differences in the sensitivities between the best - case and worse - case scenarios , depends on the step size of the `` sliding - window '' used to scan the kinematic range . in comparison , the new analysis method is independent of the exact location of the gaussian mean of the embedded signal events . this is because the new method scans the entire parameter space for the best fit to the entire experiment . the maximum @xmath3 from `` sliding - window '' approaches with step sizes of 16 , 4 , 1 , and 0.1 for the best - case scenario mc experiments each with 20 signal events embedded are shown in figure [ fig : sw-20-best ] . similarly , the maximum @xmath3 from `` sliding - window '' approaches with step sizes of 16 , 4 , 1 , and 0.1 for the worst - case scenario mc experiments each with 20 signal events embedded are shown in figure [ fig : sw-20-worst ] . the maximum likelihood output of the best fits for mc experiments with 5 , 10 , 20 and 30 signal embedded are shown in figure [ fig : ml - signal ] . compared to `` sliding - window '' approaches with a step size small enough not to miss the worst - case scenarios , the sensitivity of the new analysis method is significantly higher . this means that the new analysis approach is a significantly better and more sensitive scheme to search for new physics signals at the lhc than the current `` sliding - window '' method . = 0.90 = 0.90 the analysis method described above performs a scan of the entire parameter space using unbinned maximum likelihood fits at every small interval of the parameter space . it is very cpu - intensive . the 13.45 million background - only and 630,000 signal embedded mc experiments were generated and analyzed over several months with about 10 dual - cpu servers . we have examined the significance calculation and analysis methods in searching for an individual decay mode of a new physics signal at the lhc . unlike the search for a physics signal with known location and shape , the significance calculation for new physics signals with unknown location or shape strongly depends on the details of the search scheme and the situation it applies to . using a signal with known shape but unknown location as an example , we have demonstrated that the significance calculation using the current `` sliding - window '' method at the lhc is over - estimated . this is because we search for an excess of events over multiple narrow windows , but the significance is still calculated according to an individual narrow window . the significance and sensitivity of the `` sliding - window '' method strongly depends on the specifics of the method and the situation it applies to , e.g. the step size of the `` sliding - window '' used to scan the available kinematic range , the total available kinematic range to search for the new physics signal , and the exact location of the new physics signal , etc . we describe general procedures for significance calculation and comparing different search schemes . we have applied the procedures and compared the current `` sliding - window '' approaches with a new analysis method . the proposed new analysis method uses maximum likelihood fits with floating parameters and scans the parameter space for the best fit to the entire sample . we find the results of the new analysis method is independent of the location of the new physics signal and significantly more sensitive in searching for new physics signal than the current `` sliding - window '' approaches . while the lhc experiments have great potential in discovering many possible new physics signals , we need to be extremely careful in evaluating the significance of an observation from the real lhc data . because possible new physics can show up in many kinematic observables , over a very large kinematic range , the fluctuation probability of background events will be much higher . for individual decay modes of new physics signals , the expected significances in observing the new physics signal will be much smaller than current expectations @xcite . combining independent decay modes of the same new physics signal will be essential to establish the discovery of the new physics signal . significant observations of the same new particle in independent decay modes at consistent locations will be the most effective way to establish the discovery of this new particle . careful evaluation of the observation significance in each individual decay mode following the general procedures described in this paper is the starting point , before we can evaluate the significance of the observations of independent decay modes . the authors would like to thank the members of the smu hep group for their encouragements and useful discussions . this work is supported by the u.s . department of energy under grant number de - fg02 - 04er41299 .

the lhc experiments have great potential in discovering many possible new particles up to the tev scale . the significance calculation of an observation of a physics signal with known location and shape is no longer valid when either the location or the shape of the signal is unknown . we find the current lhc significance calculation of new physics is over - estimated and strongly depends on the specifics of the method and the situation it applies to . we describe general procedures for significance calculation and comparing different search schemes . a new method uses maximum likelihood fits with floating parameters and scans the parameter space for the best fit to the entire sample . we find that the new method is significantly more sensitive than current method and is insensitive to the exact location of the new physics signal we search . 0.0 mm 0.0 mm 5 mm 170 mm 220 mm 0.0 mm

cond-mat0202400

long - range forces , namely gravitation and electromagnetic interactions , are difficult to treat exactly in many - particle systems . in condensed matter , biological and solid state physics , there is considerable interest in the simulation of charged and polar molecules embedded in a slab in which the particles are replicated periodically in two directions . the applications range widely to include soap bubbles , cell membranes and electrochemistry . surprisingly ewald and other rapidly convergent methods for computing long - range interactions in infinitely periodic systems are computationally more demanding when the system is periodic in only one or two of the three spatial dimensions because of the breaking of spatial symmetry . several `` two - dimensional ewald '' ( * ew2d * ) methods have already been proposed@xcite . the most successful is that introduced by parry@xcite and others@xcite . this method can be used to obtain accurate results but is limited to small systems ( i.e. @xmath1 to @xmath2 charges ) . this springs from the fact that the pair separations , @xmath3 , are no longer separable in the fourier summation because of the necessary decoupling of the aperiodic @xmath4 component from the periodic @xmath5 and @xmath6 components . therefore it appears that the complexity ( scaling of time with number of charges ) of this method can be no better than quadratic . also the one dimensional ewald method@xcite suffers from the same problem . a promising alternative to ewald summation is possible using a convergence - factor technique@xcite . the basic coulomb pair interaction is multiplied by one with the factor @xmath7 . it is crucial to prove that the limit can be taken outside of the summation and now the modified potential is more readily susceptible to analysis . in a recent study,@xcite arnold and holm derive a two - dimensional version of this method with complexity @xmath8 along with accurate error formulas . this method is particularly attractive when extremely high accuracy is desired . we will use this method , abbreviated as * mmm2d * and the * ew2d * algorithm mentioned above as reference methods . one idea , used several times to study water interfaces , introduces a spatial constraint within the simulation cell . if the box has dimensions @xmath9 , the particles may have @xmath4-coordinates on @xmath10 , while the space within @xmath11 ( the gap size ) remains empty @xcite . the primary cell is , as usual , replicated in all three directions periodically . the effect of this is to create a `` primary layer '' and an empty layer followed by an infinite array of intercalated image and empty layers . figure [ periodicity ] summarizes the essential geometrical considerations in this problem . while this idea seems trivially to be correct , it has one flaw . the flaw can be realized by attempting to reproduce the results of an * ew2d * calculation using a three dimensional ewald summation ( * ew3d * ) as just described . one will find that the results always differ by a dipole - moment dependent constant . this fact , although at first thought to be merely a slow convergence issue , was noticed by spohr @xcite . the * ew3d * formula contains a shape dependent dipole - term whose origin was mathematically proven in the 1980 s @xcite , that reflects the naturally chosen spherical order of summation in the conditionally convergent coulomb sum . for the case of layers , however , it is necessary to use a _ slab - wise summation order_. this was realized by yeh and berkowitz@xcite , who applied a theory due to e. r. smith @xcite for infinite crystals of various shapes in order to obtain the correct dipole term for a slab - wise summation order . another complication arises , if the periodic supersystem is surrounded by some medium with a different dielectric constant . this medium has a polarizing effect on the particles in the simulation cell no matter how large the supersystem is . for the remainder of this paper we consider only the simple case of zero contrast for which the dielectric constant is the same inside and outside the supersytem . this is often referred to as the vacuum boundary condition . one of the advantages of using this method from a practical point of view is that any standard ewald program may be used with only minor modification . it is easy to show numerically that the use of this new dipole term and sufficient spacing ( @xmath12 ) , yields the same result as two - dimensional `` brute force '' , * mmm2d * and * ew2d * summation methods . as explained in a previous paper , referred to here as `` paper i''@xcite , errors introduced due to the image layer effects decay exponentially with the size of the gap . this method is sometimes referred to as a corrected three - dimensional ewald sum ( * ew3dc*)@xcite . like the original ewald method it has a complexity of @xmath13 and the equations can be discretized onto a mesh yielding an @xmath14 complexity . in paper i @xcite , we derived an analytic electrostatic layer correction term , called * elc*-term , that subtracts the interactions of the unwanted slab replicas . this term can be evaluated linearly in @xmath15 , and has full error control . the use of the * elc * term and the change of summation order , shortly called the * elc * method , enables us to adapt any 3d summation method , such as the non - ewald convergence - factor@xcite and multipole expansion@xcite methods , to slab geometries . the latter of these , though in possession of a slightly better scaling , has such a considerable amount of overhead that it is useful only for much larger systems than normally used@xcite . the abbreviations and complexities of some of the two - dimensional methods available at present are summarized in table [ tab1 ] , where the ending lc always denotes the use of the * elc * method . in this terminology the * ew3d * algorithm plus the * elc * method is called * ew3dlc * and so on . .methods for slab geometry . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab2 ] the results of this analysis are displayed in table [ tab2 ] . under these conditions , the * ew3dlc * method is only slightly ( 30% ) faster . the reason is that much of the work in these calculations is performed in the real - space and therefore the extra amount of reciprocal - space required by * ew3dc * due to the enlarged gap is not a major issue . in fact it is almost compensated by the time used by layer correction term . for larger @xmath15 , * ew3dlc * should become faster than * ew3dc * since the reciprocal - space time becomes much longer than the layer correction time . the same is true about higher accuracy conditions as is observable from the analytical error estimates ( eqs . [ real_error]-[fourier_error ] ) . moreover , in a mesh implementation , the same comparison should yield a more substantial advantage to the layer correction since more of the computational effort is expended in reciprocal space . we have presented and tested a method with broad applicability and low computational cost for computing the electrostatic forces or energy of a cell of charges with two - dimensional periodicity . this method has a complexity that is virtually linear when applied to a mesh , so that only minor further improvements in computation time can be attempted through a reduction of computational overhead . the algorithm differs from * ew3dc * only by the effort to program the * elc*-term , but once this is done the errors are easier to control and there is a greater degree of freedom in choosing the box edges . this makes it easy to apply to cubic versions of the * p3 m * algorithm ( which was one of our initial motivations ) . for larger systems and better accuracy as may be required in monte carlo and some molecular dynamics simulations the method should be considerably faster than * ew3dc*. it is interesting to estimate the largest system tractable with modern computing . the * p3 m * algorithm can be optimized to be at least twice as fast as the version presented here , so an @xmath16 calculation could be carried out in approximately . 2 seconds . a 100-node parallel computer with a 90% scale factor could handle a system of 0.45 million particles in 1 second which is sufficient for a many molecular dynamics and monte carlo simulations . finally we can draw attention to several issues suitable for further research . most importantly we have not treated the case of dissimilar dielectric materials at the slab surfaces . because of the symmetry of the consequent charge reflections there could be a way to handle the problem efficiently within the current framework . another topic is the clarification of the dipole term for slab - wise summation for different dielectric constants at the interface between the periodic supersystem and the surroundings . the authors thank zuowei wang and florian mller - plathe for helpful discussions . financial support from the dfg `` schwerpunkt polyelektrolyte '' is gratefully acknowledged . for quick reference the force and pressure formulas for the layer correction are given here . the layer correction force on particle @xmath17 is @xmath18 , \nonumber \\ & & \sum_{j}q_{i}q_{j}\bigl[\;2\sum_{k_{x},k_{y}>0}\frac{k_{y}\cosh ( k_{\parallel } z_{ij})}{k_{\parallel } ( e^{k_{\parallel } l_{z}}-1)}\cos ( k_{x}x_{ij})\sin ( k_{y}y_{ij})+ \nonumber \\ & & \sum_{k_{y}>0}\frac{\cosh ( k_{y}z_{ij})}{(e^{k_{y}l_{z}}-1)}\sin ( k_{y}y_{ij})\bigr ] , \nonumber \\ & & -\sum_{j}q_{i}q_{j}\bigl[\;2\sum_{k_{x},k_{y}>0}\frac{\sinh ( k_{\parallel } z_{ij})}{(e^{k_{\parallel } l_{z}}-1)}\cos ( k_{x}x_{ij})\cos ( k_{y}y_{ij})+ \nonumber \\ & & \sum_{k_{x}>0}\frac{\sinh ( k_{x}z_{ij})}{(e^{k_{x}l_{z}}-1)}\cos ( k_{x}x_{ij})+\sum_{k_{y}>0}\frac{\sinh ( k_{y}z_{ij})}{(e^{k_{y}l_{z}}-1)}\cos ( k_{y}y_{ij})\bigr]\biggr).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the diagonal components of the pressure tensor can be obtained from the partition function . for example the normal component is @xmath19 . this yields @xmath20 where @xmath21 for one of the parallel components we find @xmath22 \cos ( k_{x}x_{ij})\cos ( k_{y}y_{ij})+ \nonumber \\ \sum_{k_{x}>0 } & & \nu ( k_{x})\cos ( k_{x}x_{ij})+ \nonumber \\ \sum_{k_{y}>0 } & & \frac{1}{k_{y}l_{z}}\frac{\cosh ( k_{y}z_{ij})}{(e^{k_{y}l_{z}}-1)}\cos ( k_{y}y_{ij})\biggr).\end{aligned}\ ] ] obviously this is cumbersome since after decomposing the trigonometric and hyperbolic terms to obtain a formula that can be evaluated linearly in @xmath15 the expanded version will contain over 80 terms . if rapid pressure calculations are not demanded one can omit this term and increase @xmath23 . one third of the trace of this tensor will as usual yield the scalar pressure , @xmath24 . another consideration in obtaining the pressures is the treatment of the dipole term . fortunately , a shear or distortion on the system does not result in a distortion in the shape of the supersystem . this is in contrast to the treatment of standard ewald summation because the spherical summation order requires a complex analysis of the consequences of a distorted sphere.@xcite the summation order of the layer correction is implicitely cylindrical . it probably does not matter whether the summation procedes along the radius of the cylinder first and then along its axis ( as written ) or vice versa . but they may not proceed simultaneously .

in a previous paper a method was developed to subtract the interactions due to periodically replicated charges ( or other long - range entities ) in one spatial dimension . the method constitutes a generalized `` electrostatic layer correction '' ( * elc * ) which adapts any standard 3d summation method to slab - like conditions . here the implementation of the layer correction is considered in detail for the standard ewald ( * ew3dlc * ) and the * p3 m * mesh ewald ( * p3mlc * ) methods . in particular this method offers a strong control on the accuracy and an improved computational complexity of @xmath0 for mesh - based implementations . we derive anisotropic ewald error formulas and give some fundamental guidelines for optimization . a demonstration of the accuracy , error formulas and computation times for typical systems is also presented .

astro-ph0611204

it is commonly accepted that the present globular cluster ( gc ) population in the milky way represents the survivor of an initially more numerous one , depauperated by many disruptive processes @xcite . + the observational results obtained in the last decade have clearly confirmed the role played by the milky way environment on the gc evolution . up to now , about @xmath2 galactic gcs show evidences of star depletion due to the tides caused by the field of the galaxy . + the first evidence of the existence of tails surrounding gcs were achieved by @xcite . using colour - magnitude selected star counts in a dozen of galactic gcs , these authors showed that in the outer parts the stellar surface density profiles exceeded significantly the prediction of king models , extending also outside the tidal radius . they identified this surrounding material as made up of stars in the act of being tidally stripped from the cluster field and pointed out the importance of defining the large - scale distribution of extra - tidal stars on the sky to obtain constraints and traces for the gc orbits . more recently , other works confirmed and enlarged grillmair et al.s findings @xcite giving evidence of the existence of many gcs surrounded by haloes or tails . for m92 , @xcite found , also , that the extratidal material is not randomly distributed , being the density profile in the tails shallower for bright stars than for fainter ones . + this was the state of the art until the spectacular findings of two tidal tails emanating from the outer part of the palomar 5 globular cluster and covering an arc of 10 degrees on the sky , corresponding to a ( projected ) length of 4 kpc at the distance of the cluster @xcite , obtained in the framework of the sloan digital sky survey ( see also _ http://www.sdss.org_ ) . the stellar mass in the tails of this sparse , low - mass , halo cluster ( with an estimated concentration parameter @xmath3 ) adds up to 1.2 times the mass of stars in the cluster , estimated in the range between @xmath4 and @xmath5 . more recently , @xcite , still using sdss data , have detected a continuation of pal 5 s trailing tidal stream out to almost 19 degrees from the cluster . combining this with the already known southern tail of pal 5 yields a stream some @xmath6 kpc long on the sky . + substantial tidal streams have recently been found associated with another low - mass and low - concentration gc in the sdss area : ngc 5466 . for this cluster @xcite reported giant tails extended for about 1 kpc in length and @xcite , still using sdss data , suggested that a @xmath7 kpc tidal stream of stars , extending from bootes to ursa major , could also be associated with this system . + together with the so - called sagittarius stream @xcite , which emerges from a dwarf galaxy that is currently being accreted by the milky way , palomar 5 and ngc 5466 represent outstanding examples of ongoing tidal erosion of stellar systems in the milky way , being , up to now , also the only two globulars known for which such extended stream - like structures have been detected in the galactic halo . + one of the first numerical investigations of the role played by a galactic tidal field on spherical stellar systems was that of @xcite , who studied the effect of realistic , time - varying tidal fields on the stellar orbits in a star cluster . they numerically integrated the equations of motion of three - bodies in models of spherically symmetric clusters which , in turn , move in eccentric orbits in the field of a model galaxy . one of the main conclusions of this work , which extended previous investigations made by @xcite , was that star clusters rotating in a retrograde sense are more stable in a tidal field than clusters with either direct rotation or no rotation due to the contribution of the coriolis acceleration , acting in the same direction as the gravitational attraction for retrograde motion . + more recent works on weak tidal encounters based on a fokker - planck approach @xcite and self - consistent n - body techniques @xcite confirmed that the interaction with external tidal field , combined with two - body relaxation in the core of the cluster and following replenishment of stars near the tidal radius , causes a flow of stars away from the cluster . the stripped stars remain in the vicinity of the cluster for several orbital periods , migrating either ahead of the cluster or falling behind , giving rise to a slow growth of the tidal tails . + a semi - analytic study of the development of tidal streams in galactic satellites was done by @xcite , who gave estimates for the rate of growth of tidal tails . the effects of a realistic galactic tidal field ( including both bulge , halo and disk ) on gcs were investigated few years later by @xcite . the main findings of the work were the following : stars escaped from the system go to populate two giant tidal tails along the cluster orbit ; these tails present substructures , or clumps , attributed to strong shocks suffered by the cluster , and are preferentially formed by low mass stars . + @xcite performed n - body simulations of gcs orbiting in a two - component galaxy model ( with bulge and halo and no disk ) , using the direct - summation nbody6 code @xcite and focusing their attention , in particular , to the correlation between tidal tail elongation ( described by mean of a position angle , defined as the angle between the direction of the tail and the galactic center direction ) and the cluster orbit . they found that , on circular orbits , tidal tails mantain an almost constant position angle ( @xmath8 ) , while gcs on non circular orbits show a variation of the position angle , according to orbital path and phase . the position angle increases when the cluster heads for perigalacticon . on the other hand , it tends to decreases when the cluster heads for apogalacticon . finally , some authors investigated also the dynamical evolution of some globular clusters in the tidal field of the galaxy . in this context @xcite modelled the disruption of the globular cluster pal 5 by galactic tides . pal 5 is remarkable not only for its extended and massive tidal tails , but also for its very low mass and velocity dispersion . in order to understand these extreme properties , they performed many simulations aiming at reproducing the pal 5 evolution along its orbit across the milky way . they explained the very large size of pal 5 as the result of an expansion following the heating induced by the last strong disk shock about 150 myr ago . the clumpy substructures detected in the tidal tails of pal 5 are not reproduced in their simulations , so that they argued that these overdensities have been probably caused by interaction with galactic substructures , such as giant molecular clouds , spiral arms , and dark matter clumps , which were not condsidered in their modeling . these simulations also predict the destruction of pal 5 at its next disk crossing in about 110 myr , suggesting that many more similar systems have once populated the inner parts of the milky way but have been transformed into debris streams by the galactic tidal field . + in this context , it may be interesting mentioning the recent numerical work devoted to the study of smaller size systems ( open clusters ) in the mw tidal field @xcite , which confirms already known results in the case of the external part of gc tidal tails ) about the alignement of stars of the tidal stream around a common orbit in the external field @xcite . in the above sketched theoretical and observational background , this work which is inserted in a wider study on the dynamics of globular clusters in external tidal fields @xcite is devoted to clarifying the connection among tidal tails and cluster orbit . we will describe and discuss the mechanisms that determines the tails morphology and how they depend on cluster trajectory and orbital phase . + for this purpose , we performed detailed @xmath9body simulations ( with @xmath10 ) of gcs moving in a realistic three - components ( bulge , disk and halo ) milky way potential . + the paper is organized as follows : in sect.[cluster ] the galaxy ( sect.[galaxy ] ) and cluster ( sect.[cluster1 ] ) models adopted are presented , so as the numerical approach used ; in sect.[results ] we deal with the main results of our work , showing the formation and development of tidal tails around the cluster ( sect . [ tails ] ) , giving a qualitative approach for describing the tail morphology ( sect.[qualit ] ) , presenting the numerical procedure adopted to fit tails direction ( sect.[fit ] ) and , finally , discussing the tail - orbit alignement and its dependence on the orbital phase . in sect.[concl ] , all the results are summarized and discussed . the model adopted for the galactic mass distribution is that of @xcite . it consists of a three component system : a spherical central bulge and a flattened disk , both of @xcite form , plus a massive spherical halo . the gravitational potential is time indipendent , axysimmetric and given in an analytical form which is continuous together with its spatial derivatives . + choosing a reference frame where the ( _ x , y _ ) plane coincides with the mw equatorial plane , the three components of the potential have , in cylindrical coordinates , the form : @xmath11^{100}_r,\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where square brackets indicate the difference of the function evaluated at the 100 kpc and the generic @xmath12 extremes . the parameters in the formulas above are listed in table [ tbl1 ] . the total initial mass of the cluster was chosen @xmath13 m@xmath14 , i.e. a value compatible with masses of galactic globular clusters lying inside 4.5 kpc from the mw center ( see @xcite and @xcite ) . the stellar mass spectrum of our cluster initial model was chosen as a kroupa imf sampled in the range @xmath15 and `` evolved '' ( in the sense of accounting for mass loss on the base of stellar evolution , according to @xcite ) up to @xmath16 gyr ( which corresponds to our assumed cluster age ) . in this interval of time all masses greater than @xmath17 m@xmath18 go into the @xmath19 range . as in @xcite , we sampled this mass function into 12 mass classes , equally spaced in a linear scale , whose space and velocity distribution were evaluated by the adoption of a multimass king distribution @xcite . + obviously , the choice of @xmath10 as total number of cluster stars , together with the given value of @xmath20 and of the above described mass function implied a rescaling of the star masses . finally , to investigate the role played by the degree of cluster concentration , we considered clusters with two different values for the king concentration parameter @xmath21 ( listed in table [ tbl2 ] ) . + the clusters move on the @xmath22 coordinate plane ( the ( @xmath23 ) plane corresponds to the galactic disk ) , along orbits of different eccentricity , defined as @xmath24 being @xmath25 and @xmath26 , respectively , the gc pericentric and apocentric orbital distances . see table [ tbl3 ] for gc orbital parameters and fig.[orbits ] for a plot of the different simulated orbits . all the simulations were performed by means of the treeatd code , developed by two of us @xcite which , as the original code by @xcite , relies upon a tree - algorithm for the gravitational force evaluation on the large scale and on a direct summation on the small scale . the code was parallelized to run on high performance computers ( via mpi routines ) employing an original parallelization approach ( see again ( * ? ? ? * see ) ) . the time - integration of the ` particles ' trajectories is performed by a leap - frog algorithm that uses individual and variable time - steps according to the block - time scheme @xcite . see @xcite for further details . the only constant of motion that can be significantly used to check the quality of the orbital time integration is the total energy of the cluster , i.e. including the contribution of the external field to the gc potential energy . we saw that the upper bound of the relative error in the energy conservation , @xmath27 , is @xmath28 over the whole simulation time . this is no more than one order of magnitude worse than the error we got in a comparison simulation for the same gc in abscence of external field . in figs . [ orbitai],[orbitaii ] and [ orbitaiii ] the formation and subsequent evolution of tidal tails around the gc is shown , for all the simulations performed in the case of the least concentrated of the two gc models ( the one with @xmath29 in table [ tbl2 ] ) . in the case of the more concentrated initial model cluster , the development of the tidal tails shows the same time dependence being just slightly less populated . + after about @xmath30 yr , tidal tails have clearly formed . they continuously accrete by the stars leaving the cluster , so that after @xmath31 yr , in the case of the quasi - circular orbit ( orbit iii ) , they are elongated for more than 1.5 kpc each . in general , the extention of the two cluster tails depends on the velocity of the cluster and its variation along the orbit . for the quasi - circular orbit ( orbit iii ) this velocity is almost constant and the two tails have nearly the same length . for more eccentric orbits ( orbit i and ii ) , the tail extending between the gc and the pericenter is more elongated than the opposite tail , because the stars in the latter have smaller velocities than those belonging to the former one . in any case , the tail that precedes the cluster always extends slightly below the orbit , whereas the trailing one lies slightly above the orbit in agreement with what was observed for pal 5 . this feature can be explained considering the role played by the coriolis acceleration , as we will see later . as regards the tails orientation , these figures ( figs [ orbitai],[orbitaii],[orbitaiii ] ) clearly show the alignment of the outer part of the tails ( at distances from the gc center @xmath0@xmath1 tidal radii ) with the orbit . on the contrary , the alignment of the inner part is strongly correlated to both the orbit eccentricity and the gc location . notice , indeed , that the inner tails are roughly aligned with the orbital path only when the cluster is near the perigalacticon of the more eccentric orbits ( i and ii , respectively shown in fig.[orbitai ] and fig.[orbitaii ] ) . this confirms previous results in @xcite , where analogous features were found for gcs movings in a triaxial potential . it is also worth noting the peculiar morphology in the streams when the cluster is approaching the apocenter in the eccentric orbits ( orbits i and ii ) : tidal tails divide into `` multiple arms '' , two nearly elongated along the gc path , while the other two point to the galactic center ( and anticenter ) direction . at this regard , the tails observed around ngc288 @xcite have a similar complex morphology , showing three different `` arms '' . interestingly , this cluster has been estimated to be near its apogalacticon @xcite in agreement with our results . also the galactic satellite willman 1 shows multi - directional stellar tails @xcite , which according to our results , could represent evidence that this system is approaching the apocenter on an eccentric orbit . as anticipated in @xcite , the simplified scheme of the formation and shape of tidal tails around gcs can be understood by the motion of a star escaping from a cluster moving in a spherical potential . let us consider a rotating reference frame with the origin in the cluster center - of - mass , the @xmath32 plane coinciding with the orbital plane and @xmath33 pointing to the galactic center . the equation of motion of the @xmath34 star belonging to the cluster that moves around the galaxy center with variable angular velocity @xmath35 is ( see also appendix [ app ] and fig.[coriolis ] ) : @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the position vector in the rotating frame , while @xmath38 and the position vector of the gc center - of - mass@xmath39 , refer to the inertial frame . for a star escaping through one of the unstable lagrangian points along the @xmath33 axis , the first , second and fourth terms on the right - hand side of eq . [ equat ] are directed along the @xmath33 direction , while the third term ( the coriolis acceleration ) and the fifth term are along @xmath40 . the latter is parallel to the coriolis term when @xmath41 increases ( i.e. moving from the apogalacticon to perigalacticon ) and antiparallel when @xmath41 decreases ( moving from the perigalacticon to the apogalacticon ) . consequently , these latter two terms ere responsible of the initial deviation of the tails from the radial direction and of the formation of the s - shape profile ( see * ? ? ? * ) ) . as a reliable quantitative definition of the tail orientation , we used the direction of the eigenvector corresponding to the greatest eigenvalue - axis , while the other two lye in the ( @xmath23 ) plane . among these latter two , the eigenvector associated to the greatest eigenvalue gives the direction of maximum elongation of the stellar stream . ] of the inertia tensor of a suitable portion of the cluster . more precisely , we considered the stars contained in an annulus centered at the cluster center - of - density ( cd ) , as defined by @xcite , and extending from @xmath42 pc up to a distance of @xmath43@xmath1 tidal radii ( @xmath44 pc ) . this region includes , indeed , the tail portion we call `` inner '' part of the tails ; this part is that usually detected in the observations . note that in the study of @xcite the direction of the tails was determined by eye , without any mathematically defined procedure . + for each configuration of the system : * we evaluated the gc center - of - density ; * we selected all the stars distributed between @xmath2 pc and @xmath45 pc from the cluster cd ( excluding stars lying inside @xmath46 pc , because this region corresponds to the spherical part of the system ) ; * we evaluated the inertia tensor and the corresponding eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the selected stars ; * we determined the eigenvector @xmath47 corresponding to the maximum eigenvalue . this eigenvector is parallel to the direction of the two tails having opposite orientation . in the following , we always refer to the tail internal to the cluster orbit . the evolution of the tidal tail orientation is shown in figs . [ tail - radi ] , [ tail - radii ] , [ tail - radiii ] . + these figures show the gc orbit and some kinematic quantities plotted as functions of time . from top to bottom we plot : the gc orbit ( first panel ) , the distance @xmath48 of the cluster from the galaxy center ( second panel ) , the magnitude of the angular velocity vector @xmath35 ( third panel ) , the time derivative of @xmath41 ( fourth panel ) . finally , the fifth panel shows the evolution with time of two quantities : the angle @xmath49 between the tail direction and that of the galactic center and the angle @xmath50 interval ) . + in figure [ tail - radi ] , which refers to the orbit i , @xmath51 is represented by two , barely distinguishable , solid curves , corresponding respectively to the gc with @xmath52 and @xmath53 . the first result is that the time evolution of @xmath51 is independent of the gc concentration ( in the interval of @xmath21 studied ) ; this means that the morphology and orientation of the tails depend on gc orbit , rather than on gc internal parameters . + moreover , the tail is elongated toward the galactic center for most of the time : more in particular , if in fig.[tail - radi ] we exclude the regions around the pericenter , the average value of @xmath51 is @xmath54 , i.e. the inner tail has only a slight deviation respect to the galactic center . when approaching the pericenter , instead , the coriolis and the @xmath55 terms ( in eq.[equat ] ) are parallel and grow up . this induces a rapid alignement of the tails with the gc orbit . beyond the pericenter , the coriolis acceleration decreases and @xmath55 becomes antiparallel to the former . the net effect yields a realignment of the tails with the direction of the galactic center . figure [ tail - radii ] , which refers to orbit ii , confirms the results found for the previous orbit . finally , figure [ tail - radiii ] shows the case of the quasi - circular orbit ( orbit iii ) . along this orbit , both the distance of the gc from the galactic center and the orbital angular velocity are nearly constant . this leads to a roughly constant @xmath56 . this suggests that the change in time of the orbital angular velocity is what determine the tails orientation . the dashed curve shown in the bottom panel of figures [ tail - radi],[tail - radii ] and [ tail - radiii ] represents the angle @xmath57 , previously defined . in the case of eccentric orbits , the first striking feature is that when approaching the pericenter the angle @xmath57 decreases , reaches a minimum at the pericenter and then increases moving away from the pericenter . the maximum value of @xmath57 is reached between the pericenter and the apocenter , depending on the shape of the gc orbit . however , in correspondence of the apocenter , @xmath57 is @xmath58 in agreement with the value @xmath59 . at the apocenter the tail is aligned along the radial direction and roughly perpendicular to the gc velocity . it is worth noting that , in all the cases considered here , the tidal tails deviate considerably by the gc velocity direction ; only for very eccentric orbits and close to the pericenter , the angle @xmath57 reaches a minimum value of @xmath60 . this indicates that the extrapolation of the cluster orbit from the elongation of this part of the tidal streams leads , in general , to predict gc paths with large errors . this work is devoted to the study of the morphology and orientation of tidal tails surrounding globular clusters , in order to understand to what extent they trace the gc orbit and if some correlations exist between their orientation and the gc orbital phase . + the main findings of our work can be resumed as follows : 1 . tidal tails are good tracers of gc orbit only on the large scale , being the _ inner part of the streams never aligned with the gc path _ , unless the system moves on very eccentric orbit and close to the orbital pericenter . a _ strong correlation _ exists between the orientation of the inner tails and gc orbital position : they tend to be more elongated along the gc orbit when the cluster approaches the pericenter , while , in turn , they tend to align toward the galactic center when the gc approaches the apocenter . we have shown that a key role in determining the tails morphology is played by the orbital angular velocity of the system and its variation with time . in the case of the least eccentric orbit , a nearly constant angular velocity determines an almost constant orientation of tails with respect to the cluster orbit and the galactic center direction . the amplitude of @xmath55 contributes , too , to the alignement of tails with the gc path , in particular just beyond the pericenter . the existing correlation between tails elongation and gc position along its orbit can be easily understood when referring to a non - inertial frame centered on the gc center , due to the role played by non inertial accelerations , as the coriolis acceleration and that related to @xmath61 . we want to outline that our findings are in good agreement with some observational results . in particular we refer to the galactic globular clusters sample studied by @xcite , considering the 7 clusters for which the reliability level of the observed tidal streams is highest and orbital parameters are available @xcite . six clusters of this subsample ( see * ? ? ? * table 5 ) have tidal tails clearly elongated along the galactic center direction , and eccentricities greater than 0.62 . this in agreement with our results that gcs , on eccentric orbits , have tidal tails elongated towards the galactic center for most of their path . the only exception is represented by ngc5139 ( @xmath62 cen ) , which has tidal tails deviating from the galactocentric direction and extending towards the galactic plane ; this situation does not contradict our results considering that ngc5139 is presently only 1.3 kpc above the galactic disk and is most probably undergoing a strong disk - shocking . + the simulations also reproduce the formation of multiple tails around globular clusters , as observed for ngc288 @xcite and for the galactic satellite willman 1 @xcite . our simulations show that these features are expected for gcs on eccentric orbits near their apogalacticon , while they are absent in the case of gcs moving on less eccentric orbits . actually , their formation can be explained by the behaviour of the coriolis acceleration along the orbit : when its value is large , stars escaping from the cluster are pushed toward the orbital path . this is particularly evident around the pericenter ; at the apocenter , where the coriolis acceleration is weaker , stars tend to escape from the cluster more radially . at every pericenter passage , this effect produce a new tidal tail roughly aligned to the cluster path . the authors acknowledge the centro de astrobiologi ( madrid , spain ) for the use of its computational facilities . we also thank prof . d. heggie for useful comments and for pointing us an error in one of the figure catpions . using a no - inertial reference frame @xmath63 with the origin in the cluster center - of - mass , with the @xmath64 plane coinciding with the cluster orbital plane and @xmath65 always pointing to the galactic center ( so that this reference frame rotates with the gc angular velocity @xmath35 respect to the inertial reference system @xmath66 ) , the position of the @xmath67 star in the galactocentric @xmath66 reference frame can be expressed simply as : @xmath68 being @xmath69 the position of the cluster center - of - mass in the inertial system . rewriting the previous equation in terms of the @xmath64 components ( we omit the @xmath70 one for simplicity ) we have : @xmath71 being @xmath72,@xmath73 and @xmath74,@xmath75 the unity vectors in the two frames , respectively . derivating eq.[pos ] with respect to time @xmath76 , one obtains : @xmath77 being @xmath78 derivating eq.[vel ] with respect to time @xmath76 and using eqs . [ xdot]-[ydot ] , one obtains : @xmath79 and so , finally , eq.[equat ] . allen , c. , santillan , a. 1991 , revmexaa , 22 , 255 aarseth , s.j . 1985 , in ` multiple time scales ' , acad . press , 378 aarseth , s. j. 1999 , pasp , 111 , 1333 barnes , j. & hut , p. 1986 , , 324 , 446 baumgardt , h. , makino , j. 2003 , , 340 , 227 belokurov , v. , evans , n. w. , irwin , m. j. , hewett , p. c. , wilkinson , m. i. 2006 , apjl,637,29 capuzzo dolcetta , r. , di matteo , p. & miocchi , p. 2005 , aj , 129 , 1906 casertano , s. , hut , p. 1985 , , 298 , 80 chumak , ya . o. , rastorguev , a. s. 2006 , astronomy letters , 32 , 446 combes , f. , leon , s , meylan , g. 1999 , , 352 , 149 da costa , g. s. , freeman , k. c. 1976 , , 206 , 128 dehnen , w. , odenkirchen , m. , grebel , e. k. , rix , h. w. 2004 , , 127 , 2753 di matteo , p. , capuzzo dolcetta , r. , miocchi , p. , 2005 mech . , 91 , 59 dinescu , d.i . , girard , t.m . & van altena , w.f . 1999 , , 117 , 1792 dominguez , i. , chieffi , a. , limongi , m. & straniero , o. 1997 , , 524 - 1 , 226 fall , s. m. , zhang , q. 2001 , , 561 , 751 grillmair , c. j. , freeman , k. c. , irwin , m. , quinn , p. j. 1995 , , 109 , 2553 grillmair , c. j. 1998 , in d. zaritsky ed . , asp conf . vol.136 , galactic halos : a uc santa cruz workshop , astron . , san francisco , p.45 grillmair , c. j. , dionatos , o. 2006 , , 641 , l37 grillmair , c. j. , johnson , r. 2006 , , 639 , l17 harris , w.e . 1996 , aj , 112 , 1487 hernquist , l. & katz , n. 1989 , , 70 , 419 johnston , k. v. 1998 , , 495 , 297 keenan , d. w. , innanen , k. a. 1975 , , 80 , 290 king , i. r. 1962 , aj , 67 , 471 king , i. r. 1966 , , 71 , 276 kroupa , p. , 2001 , mnras , 322 , 231 lee , h. m. , goodman , j. 1995 , , 443 , 109 lehmann , i. , scholz , r.d . 1997 , , 320 , 776 lee , k. h. , lee , h. m. , fahlman , g. g. , lee , m. g. 2003 , , 126 , 815 leon , s. , meylan , g. , combes , f. 2000 , , 359 , 907 majewski , s. r. , skrutskie , m. f. , weinberg , m. d. , ostheimer , j. c. 2003 , apj , 599 , 1082 martnez - delgado , d. , aparicio , a. , gmez - flechoso , m. a. , carrera , r. 2001 , apj , 549 , l199 martnez - delgado , d. , gmez - flechoso , m. a. , aparicio , a. , carrera , r. 2004 , apj , 601 , 242 mateo , m. , olszewski , e. w. , morrison , h. l. 1998 , apj , 508 , l55 miocchi , p. & capuzzo - dolcetta , r. 2002 , , 382 , 758 miocchi , p. , capuzzo - dolcetta , r. , di matteo , p. , & vicari , a. 2006 , apj , 644 , 940 miocchi , p. , capuzzo - dolcetta , r. , di matteo , p. , contribution to `` globular clusters : guides to galaxies '' , march 6th-10th , 2006 , astro - ph/0605008 murali , c. , weinberg , m. d. 1997a , , 291 , 717 murali , c. , weinberg , m. d. 1997b , , 288 , 749 miyamoto , m. & nagai , r. 1975 , pub.astr.soc.japan , 27 , 533 odenkirchen , m. , grebel , e. k. , rockosi , c. m. , dehnen , w. , ibata , r. , rix , h. w. , stolte , a. , wolf , c. , anderson , j. e. jr . , bahcall , n. a. , brinkmann , j. , csabai , i. , hennessy , g. , hindsley , r. b. , ivezic , z. , lupton , r. h. , munn , j. a. , pier , j. r. , stoughton , c. , york , d. g. 2001 , , 548 , l165 odenkirchen , m. , grebel , e. k. , dehnen , w. , rix , h. w. , cudworth , k. m. 2002 , , 124 , 1497 odenkirchen , m. , grebel , e , k. , dehnen , w , rix , h. w. , yanny , b. , newberg , h. j. , rockosi , c. m. , martnez - delgado , d. , brinkmann , j. , pier , j. r. 2003 , , 126 , 2385 oh , k. s. , lin , d. n. c. 1992 , apj , 386 , 51 pryor , t. , meylan , g. 1993 , in structure and dynamics of globular clusters , ed . s. g. djorgovski , & g. meylan ( san fransisco ) , asp conf . ser . , 50 , 357 siegel , m. h. , majewski , s. r. , cudworth , k. m. , takamiya , m. 2001 , , 121 , 935 straniero , o. , chieffi , a. & limongi , m. 1997 , , 490 , 425 . testa , v. , zaggia , s. r. , andreon , s. , longo , g. , scaramella , r. , djorgovski , s. g. , de carvalho , r. 2000 , , 356 , 127 yanny , b. , newberg , h.j . , kent , s. , laurent - muehleisen , s. a. , pier , j. r. , richards , g. t. , stoughton , c. , anderson , j. e. , jr . , annis , j. , brinkmann , j. , chen , b. , csabai , i. , doi , m. , fukugita , m. , hennessy , g. s. ; ivezi , @xmath80 . , knapp , g. r. , lupton , r. , munn , j. a. , nash , t. , rockosi , c. m. , schneider , d. p. , smith , j. a. , york , d. g.2000 , apj , 540 , 825 yim , k. , lee , h. m. 2002 , jkas , 35 , 75 willman , b. , masjedi , m. , hogg , d. w. , dalcanton , j. j. , martinez - delgado , d. , blanton , m. , west , a. a. , dotter , a. , chaboyer , b. 2006 , astro - ph/0603486 _ .5 : solid curve : angle @xmath51 formed by the inner part of the tails and the galactic center direction , vs time ; dashed curve : angle @xmath57 formed by the inner part of the tails and the cluster velocity , vs time . both angles are in degrees . [ tail - radi ] ] cccccccc orbit i d & @xmath98[pc ] & @xmath99[pc ] & @xmath100[pc ] & @xmath101[km / s ] & @xmath102[km / s ] & @xmath103[km / s ] & @xmath104 + & & & & & & & + i & 0 . & 0 . & 4000 . & 0 . & 53.3 & 0 . & 0.8 + ii & 0 . & 0 . & 2500 . & 0 . & 116.7 & 0 . & 0.7 + iii & 0 . & 0 . & 1500 . & 200.0 & 0 . & 0.1

we present the results of detailed n - body simulations of clusters moving in a realistic milky way ( mw ) potential . the strong interaction with the bulge and the disk of the galaxy leads to the formation of tidal tails , emanating from opposite sides of the cluster . some characteristic features in the morphology and orientation of these streams are recognized and intepreted . the tails have a complex morphology , in particular when the cluster approaches its apogalacticon , showing multiple `` arms '' in remarkable similarity to the structures observed around ngc 288 and willman 1 . + actually , the tails are generally good tracers of the cluster path quite far from the cluster center ( @xmath0@xmath1 tidal radii ) , while on the smaller scale they are mainly pointing in the direction of the galaxy center . in particular , the orientation of the inner part of the tails is highly correlated to the cluster orbital phase and to the local orbital angular acceleration . this implies that , in general , the orbital path can not be estimated directly from the orientation of the tails , unless a sufficient large field around the cluster is available .

astro-ph0007369

several recent papers have shown that a surprisingly tight correlation exists between the masses of supermassive black holes and the velocity dispersions of the bulges which host them . ferrarese & merritt ( 2000 ) re - analyzed published samples of black hole mass estimates , showing that if the analysis is restricted to 12 galaxies with reliable black hole mass measurements , the correlation is extremely good , with @xmath4 . gebhardt et al . ( 2000a ) report a similar relation with a somewhat shallower slope , @xmath5 , and a scatter of only 0.3 dex , based on a sample of 26 galaxies , including 13 new black hole mass estimates derived using hubble space telescope spectra . in a second paper , gebhardt et al . ( 2000b ) demonstrate that black holes with reverberation mapping mass estimates also fall on the same relation . the tightness of this new correlation greatly increases confidence in the accuracy of the observed black hole mass estimates . it also strengthens theoretical arguments that spheroid formation and the growth of black holes are closely linked ( richstone et al . 1998 ; cattaneo , haehnelt & rees 1999 ; kauffmann & haehnelt 2000 ( kh2000 ) ; monaco , salucci & danese 2000 ; cavaliere & vittorini 2000 ) . cattaneo et al . ( 1999 ) and kh2000 demonstrated that the @xmath6 relation and the scatter reported by kormendy & richstone ( 1995 ) and magorrian et al . ( 1998 ) is well reproduced in phenomenological models of galaxy formation in hierarchical cosmogonies . in this letter , we analyze the relation between black hole mass and bulge velocity dispersion in the kh2000 model . we assume a @xmath7cdm cosmology with @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 throughout . in cold dark matter ( cdm)-like cosmologies , galaxies form in a hierarchy of merging halos ( e.g. white & rees 1978 ; white & frenk 1991 ) . the formation and evolution of galaxies in such a picture has been studied in considerable detail using monte - carlo realizations of the hierarchical growth of structure , which include simple prescriptions to describe gas cooling , star formation and supernova feedback ( see kauffmann et al 1999 ; somerville & primack 1999 ; cole et al 2000 for a selection of recent results ) . below we summarize the main features of the model described by kh2000 , who constructed a unified model for the formation and evolution of galaxies , supermassive black holes and qsos . in their model , the quiescent accretion of cooling gas from a halo results in the formation of a disk . the fraction of cold gas in the disk that forms stars over one dynamical time is assumed to scale with redshift as @xmath12 . this assumption was required in order to fit the observed decline in the total content of cold gas in galaxies towards low redshift inferred from observations of damped lyman - alpha systems ( storrie - lombardi et al . if two galaxies of comparable mass merge , a spheroid forms and the remaining gas is transformed into stars in a `` starburst '' . the same major mergers are responsible for the formation and fuelling of black holes in galactic nuclei . during the merger the central black holes of the progenitors coalesce and a fraction of the available cold gas is accreted by the black hole . the accreted fraction is assumed to scale with the circular velocity @xmath13 of the surrounding dark matter halo as @xmath14 ( this scaling was adopted in order to fit the slope of the @xmath15 relation of magorrian et al ( 1998 ) . ) the only change in this letter compared to kh2000 is a reduction by a factor of three in the fraction of gas assumed to accrete onto the black hole . this is needed because the mass estimates of black holes from the new data are significantly smaller than those of magorrian et al ( 1998 ) . in the kh2000 model , black holes grew in mass only during major mergers . as pointed out previously , it is certainly possible that supermassive black holes have more complicated accretion histories ( see haehnelt , natarajan & rees 1998 and haehnelt & kauffmann 2000 for a detailed discussion ) . other accretion modes could easily be incorporated into the model . we note , however , that the recent reduction in the estimated total mass density in black holes makes arguments for accretion modes other than those traced by optical- and infrared - bright qsos less compelling . fig . 1a shows scatterplots of black hole mass versus bulge velocity dispersion in our models . we do not have a dynamical model for computing @xmath1 for the bulges in our simulations . for simplicity , we have assumed a constant ratio @xmath16 , where @xmath13 is the circular velocity of the halo in which the bulge found itself after its last major merger . it is easy to show that any well - mixed population of stars orbiting within an isothermal potential must satisfy @xmath17 . following kauffmann & charlot ( 1998 ) , we choose the ratio of @xmath18 to reproduce the zero point of the observed faber - jackson relation ( see fig . 2 ) . to fit the observations , we require @xmath19 . the thick solid line in fig . 1a ( @xmath20 ) shows the relation derived by gebhardt et al . ( 2000a ) , which is reproduced very well . in the models , the total mass of gas that cools in a halo scales roughly as @xmath21 . feedback effects steepen the relation to approximately @xmath22 , but feedback would have to be more extreme in order to obtain a correlation as steep as @xmath23 ( ferrarese & merritt 2000 ) . the scatter in the relation is 0.2 dex , somewhat smaller than the 0.3 dex reported by gebhardt et al . which include measurement errors . 1b shows the black hole mass bulge luminosity correlation compared with the observed relation in the gebhardt et al . sample . for the simulated galaxies , the scatter is about a factor two larger and again agrees well with the observational data . the large scatter in the relation in fig . 1b is a consequence of the large dispersion in the relation between the luminosities and velocity dispersions of bulges . this is illustrated in in fig 2a where we plot the @xmath24 ( faber - jackson ) relation for the elliptical galaxies in our model . elliptical galaxies are defined as those objects with a ratio of bulge to total luminosity greater than 0.4 in the b - band . in the next section , we study the origin of the scatter in these relations and explain why the scatter in the @xmath2 relations is significantly smaller than that of the @xmath25 or @xmath26 relations . previous work has demonstrated that hierarchical galaxy formation models succesfully reproduce the faber - jackson ( @xmath28 ) and the magorrian ( @xmath15 ) relations ( kauffmann & charlot 1998 , kh2000 ) . the slopes of these correlations are determined by how much gas is able to cool and forms stars or is funneled to the centre in a dark matter halo of given mass or circular velocity . this is set by the assumed balance between gas cooling , star formation , supernova feedback and accretion in the halos . the correlations are tight for bulges that form at fixed epoch , but the scatter increases substantially if the galaxy population as a whole is considered . this is demonstrated by fig . 2b , where we plot the residuals in our `` faber - jackson '' relation as a function of the age of the bulge . age is defined as the time elapsed since the bulge had its last major merger . as can be seen , the residuals in the faber - jackson relation correlate strongly with age : young bulges of fixed velocity dispersion are brighter than old bulges . our results are in good agreement with those of forbes & ponman ( 1999 ) , who study residuals in the faber - jackson relation for a sample of 88 nearby ellipticals with ages determined from absorption line spectroscopy . kh2000 showed that a similar effect is expected for the @xmath15 relation . young bulges of fixed luminosity contain less massive black holes than older bulges . this prediction was recently confirmed by merrifield , forbes & terlevich ( 2000 ) . why does the @xmath2 relation exhibit such small scatter ? in fig . 3a , we show how the gas and the stellar masses of bulge progenitors vary as a function of the formation redshift of the bulge . results are shown for bulges with @xmath29 km s@xmath30 and @xmath31 km s@xmath30 . the cold gas masses of the progenitors of bulges of given velocity dispersion _ are essentially independent of redshift _ , whereas their stellar masses decrease at high redshift . as discussed by kh2000 , this decrease in the ratio of gas mass to stellar mass in galaxies is crucial for explaining the observed rapid decline of the qso activity at late times , as well as the decrease in the total content of cold gas in galaxies inferred from damped ly@xmath32 systems ( storrie - lombardi et al . 1996 ) . in our model the amount of gas available for accretion onto a black hole during a major merger depends only on the velocity dispersion of the bulge and not on redshift . this together with our assumption that a fixed fraction of this gas is accreted by the black hole accounts for the small scatter in the @xmath2 relation for bulges forming in gas - rich mergers . what about gas - poor mergers , where gas accretion contributes little to the growth of the black hole ? such gas - poor mergers are important for massive bulges forming at late times ( kh2000 ) . figure 3b shows `` evolutionary tracks '' in the @xmath33 plane for 20 black holes in our model with masses @xmath34 . these black holes typically form in 3 - 5 merging events spaced quite widely in redshift . at late times , the host galaxies of these black holes have rather small cold gas fractions . nevertheless , it is clear from our plot that black holes always move along the correlation as they merge , even for massive systems at late times . the latter can be understood as follows . let us consider the case where black holes grow only by merging and therefore have masses that scale in proportion to those of their host halo . for halos of constant characteristic density , the velocity dispersion @xmath1 scales @xmath35 . with decreasing redshift the characteristic density decreases and the velocity dispersion grows more slowly with increasing mass : @xmath36 . in cdm - like cosmogonies the characteristic mass of typical dark matter haloes scales as @xmath37 , where @xmath38 is the effective slope of the dm fluctuation spectrum . at galaxy scales @xmath39 . this gives a scaling @xmath40 . we have demonstrated that the model of kh2000 where supermassive black holes are formed and fuelled during major mergers produces a tight correlation between black hole mass and bulge velocity dispersion very similar to that observed by gebhardt et al . ( 2000a ) . the model also reproduces the observed relation between black hole mass and bulge luminosity , as well as the relation between bulge luminosity and bulge velocity dispersion . in the model , the slopes of these relations are determined by how much gas cools , forms stars or is funneled to the centre in dark matter halos of different mass / velocity dispersion . adopting simple , but physically plausible prescriptions to describe these processes , we are able to fit all three relations simultaneously . note that the only change we have made compared to kh2000 is an overall reduction of the accreted gas fraction . the large scatter in the @xmath15 and the @xmath41 relations is primarily a consequence of the wide range in redshift over which bulges and supermassive black holes form . the stellar mass of a bulge of fixed velocity dispersion depends strongly on when the bulge formed . bulges that form early are less massive than bulges that form late . note that the same is true of disk galaxies in our model . these predicted correlations with age appear to be supported by the available data . nevertheless , the scatter in the @xmath27 relation is small . there are two reasons for this . * the amount of gas accreted by a black hole during the formation of a bulge of fixed velocity dispersion does not depend on redshift . in our model , disk galaxies of given circular velocity contain about the same amount of gas at all redshifts . this is a further prediction of the model to be tested by future observations . * the frequent merging of galaxies in hierarchical cosmogonies moves galaxies along the correlation in the @xmath2 plane , even when galaxies are gas - poor and their black holes grow mainly by the merging of pre - existing black holes . the model of kh2000 is a supply - limited model for the accretion history of supermassive black holes . we note that the model does not allow for any dependency in the amount of gas accreted by the black hole on the orbital parameters of the merger . we have also assumed a fixed scaling between the velocity dispersion of a bulge and the circular velocity of the halo in which it resides . these are all potential sources of additional scatter . detailed numerical simulations will be needed to decide whether a physical mechanism that depends on the bulge potential and that limits the growth of supermassive black holes is required to keep the correlation tight . from our present analysis , we conclude that the tightness of the observed correlation is in apparent agreement with a scenario in which merging events produce supermassive black holes and bulges over a wide range in redshift . cattaneo , a. , haehnelt , m.g . & rees , m.j . , 1999 , 308 , 77 cavaliere , a. , vittorini , v. , 2000 , apj , in press , astro - ph/0006194 cole , s. , lacey , c.g . , baugh , c.m . , frenk , c.s . , 2000 , mnras , in press , astro - ph/0007281 ferrarese l. , merrit d. , 2000 , supmitted to apjl , astro - ph/0006053 gebhardt k. , bender r. bower g. , dressler a. , faber s.m . , filippenko a.v . , green r. , grillmair c. , ho l.c . , kormendy j. , lauer t.r . , magorrian j. , pinkney j. , richstone d. , & tremaine s. , astro - ph/0006289 gebhardt k. , kormendy j. , ho l.c . , bender r. bower g. , dressler a. , faber s.m . , filippenko a.v . , green r. , grillmair c. , lauer t.r . , magorrian j. , pinkney j. , richstone d. , & tremaine s. , submitted to apjl , astro - ph//0007123 forbes , d.a . , ponman t.j . , 1999 , mnras , 309 , 623 haehnelt m.g . , kauffmann g. , 2000 , in : ` black holes in binaries and galactic nuclei' eso workshop in honour of prof . r. giacconi , garching 1999 , eds . woudt p. et al . , in press , astro - ph/9911514 haehnelt m.g . , natarajan p. , rees m.j . , 1998 , mnras , 300 , 817 kauffmann , g. & charlot , s. , 1998 , mnras , 297 , 23 kauffmann , g. , colberg , j.m . , diaferio , a. , white , s.d.m . , 1999 , mnras , 303,188 kauffmann , g. & haehnelt , m.g . , 2000 , mnras , 311 , 576 ( kh2000 ) kormendy j. , richstone d. , 1995 , ara&a , 33 , 581 magorrian j. , tremaine , s. , richstone , d. , bender , r. , bower , g. , dressler , a.,faber , s.m . , gebhardt , k. et al . , 1998 , aj , 115 , 2285 merrifield , m.r . , forbes , d.a . , terlevich , a.i . , 2000 , mnras , 313 , 29 monaco p. , salucci p. , danese l. , 2000 , mnras 311 , 279 prugniel , p. , simien f. , 1996 , a&a , 309 , 749 richstone d. , ajhar , e.a . , bender , r. , bower , g. , dressler , a. , faber , s.m . , filippenko , a.v . , gebhardt , k. et al . , 1998 , suppl . , 395 , 14 somerville , r.s . & primack , j.r . , 1999 , mnras , 310 , 1087 storrie - lombardi , l.j . , macmahon , r.g . & irwin , m.j . , 1996 , mnras , 283 , l79 white , s.d.m . & rees , m.j . , 1978 , mnras , 183 , 341 white , s.d.m . & frenk , c.s . , 1991 , apj , 379 , 52

recent work has demonstrated that there is a tight correlation between the mass of a black hole and the velocity dispersion of the bulge of its host galaxy . we show that the model of kauffmann & haehnelt , in which bulges and supermassive black holes both form during major mergers , produces a correlation between @xmath0 and @xmath1 with slope and scatter comparable to the observed relation . in the model , the @xmath2 relation is significantly tighter than the correlation between black hole mass and bulge luminosity or the correlation between bulge luminosity and velocity dispersion . there are two reasons for this : i ) the gas masses of bulge progenitors depend on the velocity dispersion but not on the formation epoch of the bulge , whereas the stellar masses of the progenitors depend on both ; ii ) mergers between galaxies move black holes along the observed @xmath3 relation , even at late times when the galaxies are gas - poor and black holes grow mainly by merging of pre - existing black holes . we conclude that the small scatter in the observed @xmath2 relation is consistent with a picture in which bulges and black holes form over a wide range in redshift . black hole physics galaxies : formation galaxies : nuclei quasars : general .

1511.01902

gauge theories in three spacetime dimensions typically possess solitonic disorder operators that strongly affect the physics at long distances . a classic example is polyakov s proof that monopoles in a pure @xmath2 gauge theory lead to confinement even at weak coupling @xcite . that emit magnetic flux . we will give a more careful definition in section 2 , where we will also explain what we mean by monopole states in three dimensions . for a general review of basic properties of monopoles and their relation to other solitons in various dimensions , see e.g. @xcite . ] effects of gauge theory disorder operators on the phase structure of many other three - dimensional models have been analyzed in e.g. @xcite . the primary question concerning these operators is whether they cause confinement ; if not , as is often the case , the next order of business is to understand the ir fixed point . identifying disorder operators in such a nontrivial cft is often a daunting task . using various classical limits , their quantum numbers have been calculated in the ir of qed with many fermion flavors @xcite , in the critical @xmath3 model at large @xmath4 @xcite , in the ir of qcd with many fermion flavors and with various gauge groups @xcite , and in the infinite - level limit of conformal chern - simons - matter theories @xcite . disorder operators also feature prominently in supersymmetric theories , where their dimensions and intricate duality mappings can often be understood using holomorphy and localization @xcite . understanding disorder operators in the ir of non - abelian theories without supersymmetry is generally difficult . even in the planar limit , no results at finite t hooft coupling were available unless the number of matter flavors was much larger than the number of colors . however , recent progress in studying the t hooft limit of chern - simons ( cs ) theories coupled to matter @xcite makes it possible to elegantly compute the scaling dimensions of an interesting class of disorder operators in conformal cs - fermion theories with only one fermion flavor . we perform this computation in this brief note . our main result is that the lowest - dimension disorder operators with @xmath5 units of magnetic flux have dimension where @xmath6 is the yang - mills - regulated cs level . this result is valid at all t hooft couplings . our presentation starts with a technical definition of disorder operators in section 2 . in section 3 we obtain the advertised result by computing the thermal partition function of all cs - fermion states with a given magnetic flux on a two - sphere , and along the way we clarify certain aspects of the path integral computation given in @xcite . in section 4 we conclude by discussing implications of our findings for the bosonization duality between cs - fermion and cs - boson theories . we are interested in local operators @xmath7 that create magnetic flux in a theory with gauge group @xmath8 . a state created by a such a disorder operator at @xmath9 has flux that can be gauge - fixed into the form where @xmath10 is any two - sphere enclosing @xmath11 , @xmath12 is the gauge field strength in the theory , @xmath13 are the anti - hermitian cartans of @xmath8 , and @xmath14 are the gauge - invariant gno charges that index different monopole states in four spacetime dimensions @xcite . the quantization of gno charges is most easily demonstrated in the path integral language , where configurations with a disorder operator at the origin can be depicted ( in a suitable gauge ) as fluctuations around wu - yang gauge field configurations @xcite ( note that the field strength associated to the above connection gives @xmath15 when integrated over an @xmath16 centered at the origin . ) this is an allowed configuration if the gauge fields on the south and north hemispheres differ by a gauge transformation . fixing @xmath17 for convenience , the difference between north and south at @xmath18 is @xmath19 , and so the appropriate gauge transformation is enacted by the group element @xmath20 . this object must be well - defined as we circle the equator of the @xmath16 by letting @xmath21 . this condition , @xmath22 , is only satisfied for a discrete set of @xmath14 s . there are reasons to believe that not all gno charges correspond to different disorder operators . first , even if the wu - yang backgrounds are classical saddles , they need not all be stable in the quantum theory @xcite . second , the operators defined via eq . need not be eigenstates of the dilatation operator in the ir cft , and so they might not all be independent . third , the gno monopoles are not all topologically protected . topological charges exist only if the gauge group has a nontrivial fundamental group @xmath23 , e.g. for @xmath24 but not for @xmath25 @xcite . however , even though the gno classification may be too refined , we will find disorder operators with small amounts of flux in the planar limit that appear to have well - defined scaling dimensions with no indication of instabilities . this means that the situation is similar to the one found in many - flavor qcd @xcite , where large classes of gno charges were shown to correspond to stable monopoles even though there was no a priori reason for them to do so . so far we did not assume that the theory was conformal , and the operators @xmath7 were instantonic in character . these instantons represent transitions to / from states with magnetic flux that we will call monopoles . analyzing the spectrum of such states in general qfts is hard , but progress was made in the supersymmetric context in @xcite . things are simpler in a conformal theory , where each disorder operator corresponds to a monopole state @xmath26 on @xmath27 , a two - sphere of radius @xmath28 . in the path integral these states correspond to configurations with background fields @xmath29 on @xmath30 . in a yang - mills theory coupled to matter , disorder operators are defined in a gauge - invariant way using eq . . their scaling dimensions are determined , via the state - operator correspondence , as casimir energies of the fluctuations around wu - yang monopoles on @xmath31 , when these are good saddles . is given by a constant times the area form . if there is a reason to break the rotational invariance in the theory , it may happen that the true saddles are large deformations away from eq . for which the magnetic flux is not uniformly distributed across the sphere . in that case , all comments we make apply to fluctuations around these new backgrounds . spherical symmetry will never be broken in our examples , so we will work with fluctuations around uniform flux backgrounds . ] the fluctuations in question must be gauge - invariant themselves . in the case of yang - mills theory this means that no operators with electric charge may be present . this picture changes if a chern - simons term at level @xmath6 is present in the action . the wu - yang configuration in this case has electric charge @xmath32 , and the gauss law requires that matter fields compensate for this charge @xcite . this means that gauge - invariant disorder operators in cs - matter theories do not merely create magnetic flux ; they also create enough matter to dress themselves into an electric singlet . this dressing may introduce large corrections to the casimir energy due to matter self - interactions @xcite . for instance , in a cs - fermion theory at @xmath33 ( or at zero t hooft coupling in the planar limit ) , the matter fields can be heuristically treated as noninteracting fermions in a background magnetic field that fill up a fermi sea until they reach @xmath34 units of charge ; the landau levels are separated by gaps of order @xmath35 , giving a total fermi energy of @xmath36 @xcite . ( see also @xcite . ) we will show that this holds at all t hooft couplings . our approach to calculating disorder operator dimensions is the following . we focus on the conformal cs - fermion theory , radially quantized with a wu - yang background on the spatial two - sphere , and we compute the path integral over all gauge field and matter fluctuations around this background . if the euclidean spacetime is taken to be @xmath37 , the result is a thermal partition function of all monopole states with the given set of gno charges ( with matter dressing automatically taken care of ) . in the low temperature ( @xmath38 ) limit , the result must take the form @xmath39 , with @xmath40 being the desired energy ( or flat - space scaling dimension ) of the lightest disorder operator in this gno class . we will calculate this @xmath40 in the t hooft limit by using several subtle tricks that we carefully explain in the following section . consider the conformal @xmath0 chern - simons theory coupled to dirac fermions in the fundamental representation . the thermal partition function is given by the path integral on @xmath41 , with the two - sphere volume @xmath42 and temperature @xmath43 . the euclidean action is we normalize @xmath44 , and in particular we choose @xmath45 to be a matrix whose only nonzero entry is @xmath46 at the @xmath47th place on the diagonal . ( this choice means that gno charges have values @xmath48 for @xmath49 . ) we are interested in the planar limit , where @xmath4 and @xmath6 are taken to infinity with the t hooft coupling @xmath50 fixed . in dimensional regularization , the theory is unitary only for @xmath51 @xcite . the cs level @xmath6 is quantized by demanding invariance under large gauge transformations ; in order to offset the parity anomaly of the fermions , @xmath52 should take on values in @xmath53 @xcite , but in the t hooft limit this is immaterial and we may think of @xmath6 as being a ( large ) integer . at @xmath54 we recover the singlet fermion model @xcite , and as @xmath55 approaches unity the theory approaches pure cs theory @xcite . a subtlety ( pointed out by o. aharony ) arises here because we regulate the above theory using dimensional reduction , but the preceding discussion of disorder operators in cs theory assumed regularization using a yang - mills term . the cs levels in the two regularizations are related by @xmath56 . in dimensional reduction this shift arises because we must regulate the monopoles by giving them a core of nonzero size . this uv regularization effectively acts as an edge of the system , and the electric charge of the monopoles gets shifted by the @xmath4 edge states of cs theory . the operator content is simple to describe : cs has no dynamical degrees of freedom and the only operators with @xmath57 energies are products of @xmath58 `` single - trace '' singlets built out of two matter fields and covariant derivatives . these single - trace operators are the scalar operator @xmath59 and conserved currents @xmath60 ; they have protected ( @xmath61-independent ) scaling dimensions in the planar limit , and they are conjectured to be holographically dual to higher - spin fields of the vasiliev system in ads@xmath62 @xcite . if the gauge group is @xmath63 , the theory also contains baryons @xmath64 whose energies are @xmath65 @xcite . for any gauge group , there are also disorder operators defined in section 2 , and if the group is not simply connected ( e.g. for @xmath58 ) these operators may have nontrivial topological charge . the phase structure of planar cs - fermion theory at finite temperature is very rich ( see fig . [ fig phases ] ) . at any finite t hooft coupling @xmath66 there are two phase transitions ( which overlap at a critical @xmath61 ) . both transitions happen at temperatures of order @xmath67 . these different phases are observed in the density of eigenvalues of the matrix model obtained by integrating out matter fields from in the high temperature limit @xmath68 . interpreting the transitions in terms of the original variables is still an open question , but ref . @xcite has shown suggestive evidence that baryon - antibaryon pairs introduce relations between singlet states at high energies and thereby cause a qualitative change in the density of states an effective `` deconfinement '' that allows one set of singlets to recombine its constituents into a different set of singlets . this transition is accompanied by going from a singlet free energy @xmath69 to a deconfined free energy @xmath70 . it has also been speculated that the second phase transition is related to the proliferation of monopoles @xcite . ( -2 , 2 ) ( -2 , -2 ) ( 2 , -2 ) ( 2 , 2 ) ; ( 2 , -2 ) .. controls ( 0.5 , -1.95 ) and ( -2 , -1 ) .. ( -1.95 , 2 ) ; ( -2 , -1 ) .. controls ( -1 , -1 ) and ( 2 , 0.5 ) .. ( 1.95 , 2 ) ; ( 0 , -2.05 ) node[anchor = north ] @xmath71 ; ( -2 , -2.05 ) node[anchor = north ] @xmath72 ; ( 2 , -2.05 ) node[anchor = north ] @xmath73 ; ( -2.05 , 0 ) node[anchor = east ] @xmath74 ; ( -2.05 , -1.8 ) node[anchor = east ] @xmath75 ; ( -2.05 , 2 ) node[anchor = east ] @xmath76 ; a fascinating property of this planar cs - fermion theory is that it appears dual to the bosonic theory of cs gauge fields coupled to a wilson - fisher fixed point @xcite . ( similarly , the cs - gross - neveu model is related to the cs theory coupled to the ordinary free scalar ; our calculation holds for monopoles in this other cs - fermion theory , as well . ) this `` bosonization '' duality relates bosonic and fermionic theories with groups @xmath77 and @xmath78 and with couplings that satisfy @xmath79 . this is a strong - weak duality that can be viewed both as a nonsupersymmetric giveon - kutasov duality @xcite and as a level - rank duality of pure cs theory extended to theories with matter @xcite . the bosonization conjecture holds at the level of matching partition functions , correlators , s - matrices , and single - trace operators , but it is not known how nonperturbative operators map across the duality . since our result gives us dimensions of disorder operators at strong coupling , we will be able to tie this to the known facts about nonperturbative operators at weak coupling , and we will conjecture two possible patterns for how these nonperturbative operators may map to each other . let us now review the methodology of solving the cs - fermion theory in the planar limit and without monopole backgrounds . we present a streamlined version of the procedure that has been explained in great detail in ref . @xcite . for convenience , we will set the radius of the two - sphere to be @xmath80 ; this turns the temperature @xmath81 into a tunable dimensionless parameter . at finite temperature , matter fields develop thermal masses proportional to @xmath81 , so at @xmath82 the fermions become very massive , propagating only on scales @xmath83 much smaller than the size of the spatial @xmath16 . as for the gauge fields , the only gauge - invariant degrees of freedom are contained in the polyakov loop , i.e. in the holonomy of the gauge field around the thermal circle . this object is defined as the path - ordered exponential the polyakov loop can be viewed as a map from @xmath16 to @xmath58 . as such , it is not gauge - invariant it can still change under time - independent gauge transformations . its eigenvalues are gauge - invariant , however , and below we will describe the gauge fixing needed to reduce @xmath84 to its abelianized ( diagonal ) form @xmath85 with @xmath86 . the cs action produces a @xmath87-function potential that sharply suppresses spatial variations of the polyakov loop eigenvalues , and the large thermal mass of the fermions ensures that integrating out matter will not change this potential on length scales greater than @xmath88 . thus we may separate the fields in into `` high - energy '' modes ( all matter fields and the large - momentum gauge fields that glue them into singlets ) and `` low - energy '' modes ( the polyakov loop and the small - momentum gauge fields ) . the high - energy degrees of freedom are all fields at momenta above @xmath81 ( in particular , this includes all matter fields ) . since the curvature of @xmath16 is much smaller than @xmath81 , these fields should be thought of as living in a flat space with a constant polyakov loop in the background @xcite . the gauge fields can be dealt with by fixing the light - cone gauge , @xmath89 @xcite . this choice gives a trivial faddeev - popov determinant . integrating out the remaining gauge fields @xmath90 and @xmath91 gives a nonlocal potential for the matter fields , and matter can in turn be integrated out by the usual large-@xmath4 procedure for @xmath58 models @xcite . after all the high - energy modes are integrated out , we are left with an effective potential for the polyakov loop that takes the form of a derivative expansion : the potentials @xmath92 above are all of order @xmath4 and are formed by traces of arbitrarily many powers of @xmath84 and @xmath93 powers of @xmath94 . at large @xmath81 the derivative pieces can be ignored and we can replace the polyakov loop @xmath84 with a constant matrix @xmath95 governed by the eigenvalue potential exact forms of this potential for various theories at all @xmath61 have been given in ref . @xcite . integrating low - energy modes now proceeds by fixing the maximal torus gauge @xcite . this is done in three steps @xcite : 1 . fix the temporal gauge @xmath96 ; 2 . use time - independent gauge transformations to abelianize the polyakov loop and impose @xmath97 at each @xmath98 on the two - sphere ; 3 . use the remaining time - independent transformations to impose the coulomb gauge for the cartan components of spatial gauge fields @xmath99 . fixing this gauge and integrating all modes other than @xmath84 ( with @xmath81 as the uv regulator ) results in a matrix model for the polyakov loop . as we have mentioned , the gauge - fixed integral will impose a @xmath87-function on non - constant abelianized configurations @xmath84 , so once we go to the maximal torus gauge we may just talk about a constant matrix @xmath100 . the faddeev - popov determinants and the integration over the remaining modes ( the off - diagonal spatial components of gauge fields ) combine to give the vandermonde determinant of the @xmath58 matrix model , which is , modulo constant prefactors that we ignore , given by a subtle and crucially important point arises when abelianizing the polyakov loop : matrices @xmath84 with equal eigenvalues represent degenerate points in the set of all polyakov loop configurations . ( we retain position dependence because the gauge must be fully fixed before we can meaningfully say that the integration of gauge fields fixes the @xmath101 s to be constant . ) we can not perform the second gauge - fixing step outright , but instead we must break up the path integral over all @xmath84 s into a sum over domains in which there are no eigenvalue overlaps anywhere on the sphere , and then abelianize in each domain separately . remarkably , these domains are indexed by gno charges . more precisely , it is possible to show that time - independent gauge transformations @xmath102 needed to abelianize a generic nondegenerate @xmath84 at all @xmath103 need to be defined patch - wise on the two - sphere , just like in the wu - yang construction @xcite . these transformations @xmath102 are then classified by the winding profile around the equator , and in turn this means that nondegenerate @xmath84 s are classified by winding numbers of the gauge transformations needed to abelianize them . the winding numbers ( a.k.a . `` flux sectors '' ) are given by @xmath4 numbers @xmath104 , one for each cartan @xmath13 so that @xmath105 . performing a gauge transformation with nontrivial winding diagonalizes the holonomy @xmath84 but simultaneously turns a smooth profile of the spatial gauge fields into a monopole configuration of form . when evaluated on a configuration with a nontrivial winding of @xmath84 and after the @xmath106 s are forced to be constant , the cs term gives the @xmath107-dependent potential @xcite the integral over all polyakov loops in the maximal torus gauge thus reduces to summing over flux sectors of spatial fields and integrating over all spatially constant configurations of eigenvalues @xmath101 . the sum over flux sectors gives in other words , this sum discretizes eigenvalues in units of @xmath108 , meaning that instead of working with an @xmath4-fold integral over all @xmath109 we must work with a sum over @xmath110 for @xmath111 . in the planar limit , these eigenvalues are essentially continuous , although their discretization must be taken into account at large @xmath61 @xcite . it is important to emphasize that polyakov loops associated to nontrivial flux sectors do _ not _ correspond to the monopole backgrounds discussed in the previous section . we are talking about _ different _ gauge - invariant field configurations here : disorder operators correspond to nontrivial profiles of the spatial components of the gauge field , while flux sectors label domains defined by eigenvalues of @xmath84 , the integral of the temporal component of the gauge field . it is only in the maximal torus gauge that some polyakov loop configurations @xmath84 manifest themselves as monopole backgrounds . in the next subsection we will explain how bona fide monopoles are to be included in the computation . finally , once the gauge is fixed and all other degrees of freedom have been integrated out , the partition function is given by the matrix model with discretized eigenvalues this model is solved using the usual large @xmath4 methods , e.g. @xcite , by replacing @xmath101 with an eigenvalue density @xmath112 and carrying out a saddle - point calculation . this was done for all @xmath61 in refs . the four phases on fig . [ fig phases ] are seen when @xmath113 and they correspond to different qualitative behaviors of @xmath112 : crossing the red critical line causes @xmath112 to lose support on the entire circle ( the gww transition ) , and crossing the blue line causes @xmath112 to cap off at @xmath114 , saturating the maximal possible value it can attain given the quantization of eigenvalues due to flux sectors ( the dk transition ) . previous calculations of cs - matter partition functions using the above high-@xmath81 method did not sum over states with magnetic flux . the resulting partition function obeyed the dualities expected of the full partition function with monopoles included , however . this situation is similar to the calculation of the partition function for singlet vector models in @xcite . this partition function knew about the phase transition caused by baryons even though it was constructed just by counting single - trace operators , and in fact the @xmath58 and @xmath63 results were the same even though the @xmath58 theory did not even have baryons ; this indicates that the contribution of baryon states to the partition function was negligible . the same is expected to happen for monopole states . we now wish to take the sum over monopoles into account . we focus on those terms in this sum that correspond to states created by a single disorder operator with given gno charges @xmath115 . the calculation we need differs from the ones in earlier works in three ways : 1 . some of the gauge symmetry needs to be spent on fixing the monopole background to the maximal torus form at each spacetime point , as done in @xcite . for each set of @xmath93 equal gno charges , a @xmath116 factor contributes to the remaining gauge symmetry . thus , for instance , if @xmath117 and all other charges are zero , the symmetry left to be fixed is @xmath118 . if e.g. @xmath119 and all other charges are @xmath120 , the gauge symmetry is @xmath121 . the faddeev - popov determinant from this gauge - fixing depends on the saddle - point configurations , not on the dynamical fields . the space of single - monopole backgrounds is discrete , and we focus on one specific background at a time ; therefore the fp determinant can not influence the physics of fluctuations around the saddle that we wish to study , and we may ignore it just as we ignore other constant prefactors . the reduced gauge symmetry influences the vandermonde determinant @xmath122 and the abelianization of the polyakov loop . for instance , on backgrounds with all different gno charges , the remaining gauge symmetry is @xmath123 , the vandermonde is trivial , the contribution of the polyakov loop to the action is just as if it was abelian to begin with , and there are no flux sectors to sum over . 2 . high - energy modes will be insensitive to the flux background if the flux through a `` thermal cell '' of size @xmath124 is much less than unity . in other words , as long as each gno charge satisfies @xmath125 , the integral over high - energy modes proceeds just as in the case without monopoles . it is currently not known how to perform this integral at high gno charges . 3 . the computation we wish to perform is reliable at high temperatures , but we are ultimately interested in extracting the casimir energy at @xmath126 . we proceed by taking @xmath127 and then working in the double scaling limit @xmath128 , @xmath129 . this is not as outlandish as it may seem : the theory has no phase transitions below a critical @xmath130 , so any computations in the regime @xmath131 will be analytically connected to the @xmath132 region . indeed , @xcite has shown that the @xmath129 limit of the free energy on a monopole - free background always reproduces the @xmath133 result obtained by other means . in a monopole background the situation is only a bit more complicated . in the monopole - free sector , the dominant term of the partition function in the lowest - temperature phase is @xmath134 . in the case of interest for us , however , we are interested in the very small quantity @xmath135 , and so in our double scaling limit we should expect to reproduce the @xmath133 result up to corrections that have the same order in @xmath4 . in other words , we expect to find the partition function of the form @xmath136 with @xmath137 . this is the form of the partition function we will recover , and we will be able to indicate which states contributed to the @xmath138 correction . computing the partition function in the single - monopole background is now straightforward , and we can borrow most of the technical results from earlier work . in particular , the first two points above show that the integral over high - energy modes does not depend on the monopole background as long as the gno charges are much smaller than @xmath81 . thus , when setting up the matrix model with monopoles , in eq . we may use the result for the @xmath129 limit of the eigenvalue potential of cs - fermion theories obtained in eq . ( 6.33 ) of ref . @xcite , the partition function in which this potential figures is a modification of that takes into account the monopole background according to the three precepts above : in writing the above we arrange the gno charges such that @xmath139 with @xmath49 . for a general @xmath140 , there are @xmath141 segments of @xmath142 equal charges ( with @xmath143 ) . the primed sum over flux sectors @xmath144 leaves out all the @xmath145 s that belong to a segment of length one , i.e. all @xmath144 such that @xmath14 is not equal to any other gno charge . the remaining fluxes are summed just like in eq . . the vandermonde is the one appropriate for the @xmath146 group and is given by the product of determinants for subsets @xmath147 of eigenvalues that are conjugate to the same gno charge , eq . shows that monopoles with equal nonzero gno charges are special : the sum over polyakov loop windings @xmath144 will subsume part of the @xmath5-dependent potential @xmath148 in any sector with @xmath149 . the sum over @xmath144 s will still discretize the eigenvalues , and the remaining potential will depend on @xmath140 through the term @xmath150 . it would be fascinating to analyze such monopole states , but the discretization of eigenvalues takes this problem outside the scope of the current work . from now on we restrict ourselves to monopoles whose nonzero gno charges are all different . for simplicity , let us consider @xmath151 and @xmath152 for @xmath153 ; the generalization to multiple nonzero charges will be trivial . the eigenvalue conjugate to @xmath154 now has special status , while the other eigenvalues @xmath155 can be treated just like in the previous subsection . in fact , the density of these @xmath156 eigenvalues is unaffected by the dynamics of @xmath157 at large @xmath4 , and the density @xmath158 is determined by the very same saddle - point calculation used to find @xmath112 in the monopole - free case . the special eigenvalue @xmath157 thus decouples , and the remaining eigenvalues are integrated over to give a multiplicative factor of @xmath159 , defined in eq . . the contribution of these eigenvalues to the partition function with monopoles represents the resummed single - trace fluctuations on top of monopole states , and in the low-@xmath81 limit it does not affect the casimir energy @xmath40 . the remaining integral should be understood as an integral over all excitations of the matter dressing the monopole . in other words , the integral over the remaining eigenvalue represents the sum over all monopoles with the given gno charge . this type of integral over a single eigenvalue and its relation to nonperturbative effects has , in fact , been observed in matrix models describing quantum gravity @xcite . the partition function is thus given by with the above integral can be solved using steepest descent . before we proceed to find saddles of @xmath160 , we note that cs - matter is invariant under the parity transformation @xmath161 , @xmath162 , and the above potential clearly respects this . from now on we take @xmath163 ; any saddle @xmath164 we find at a fixed positive @xmath61 will correspond to a saddle @xmath165 at @xmath166 . for the same reason we also take @xmath167 . the saddle point equation is it is easy to find a complex saddle of the form @xmath168 , where @xmath169 is positive and large at small @xmath170 . to see that this is consistent and to find @xmath169 , we substitute this ansatz and use @xmath171 in the saddle point equation , getting and consequently which is indeed large as @xmath129 . the value of the effective potential at this saddle point is we can now read off the casimir energy @xmath40 from @xmath172 , giving the advertised result it can be checked that the steepest descent through this point in the complex plane is in the direction parallel to the real axis , and the initial contour can be deformed in the needed way without complications . there are no indications of instability around this saddle point . the contribution from the rest of the contour can be analytically shown to behave as @xmath173 for some coefficients @xmath174 and @xmath175 . limit this contribution overwhelms the saddle point value and dominates the integral . this is confirmed by numerical evaluation of the integral . there are no inconsistencies here because we are really taking the double - scaling limit in which @xmath81 is always large , as described in the third point at the beginning of this subsection . i thank guy gur - ari and ethan dyer for numerous discussions and help with understanding the behavior of this integral away from the saddle point . ] this term comes from parts of the contour far away from the saddle point , and we believe it can be understood as the partition function of highly excited monopole states the ones in which the dressing matter is not in its ground state but rather in states so energetic that their free energy eclipses the casimir energy . we now ( very schematically ) show how this contribution from excited monopoles can come about . consider the integral over monopole states with dressing matter excited to an energy @xmath176 above the ground state . their contribution to the partition function is if @xmath81 is infinitesimal ( meaning @xmath132 on a spatial @xmath16 of unit radius ) , the above integral can be approximated just by @xmath177 . however , as stressed in point 3 ) above , we work with @xmath178 and with @xmath128 taken before @xmath129 . thus , states with energies that differ by less than @xmath81 will not be suppressed relative to each other , and the cumulative effect of all these states can be enough to overwhelm the exponential suppression afforded by @xmath129 . consider high - energy excitations with @xmath179 , the density of states appropriate for three - dimensional theories . a saddle point calculation shows that integrating over sufficiently high energy modes in the above integral gives we take this as evidence that highly excited monopoles can , _ in principle _ , sum to a number that cancels out the @xmath177 prefactor and gives the above formula for a small positive @xmath174 . only at @xmath82 would it be possible to get @xmath174 of order one , so this is consistent with the expectation that our total result , @xmath180 , is analytically connected to @xmath181 that we would have gotten at @xmath126 without the double - scaling limit , had we been able to carry out that calculation . a careful study of monopole excitations would give us the correct density of states and allow us to check this conjecture . if the monopole state has several different nonzero gno charges , the same saddle - point equation is solved for each eigenvalue conjugate to these charges . the resulting casimir energy can thus be recorded as the general answer for a monopole with few nonzero gno charges : this result stops being valid when there are so many nonzero gno charges that the collective dynamics of their eigenvalues can no longer be neglected when studying the remaining eigenvalue density @xmath158 . moreover , if we had so many different charges , some of them would have charge comparable to @xmath4 , thus invalidating the assumption that the magnetic flux in each thermal cell is negligible . understanding high - flux monopole states remains an open problem . we now possess a fair amount of information about the spectrum of operators at strong coupling in @xmath58 cs - fermion theories . at low scaling dimensions we only have the tower of higher - spin @xmath58 single - traces and multi - traces with @xmath61-independent dimensions . going to higher dimensions , we encounter the lightest disorder operators of dimension @xmath182 , and from there on we find more and more disorder operators with dimensions given by ; there are also the monopoles with excited matter dressing whose dimensions we can not calculate using the above method . ( disorder operators with several gno charges equal to @xmath183 are not expected to have dimensions lower than the one with just one nonzero gno charge @xmath183 , but they might appear just above it in the spectrum ; these have different topological charge , however , and we do not expect them to have nontrivial overlaps . ) there are no baryon operators in @xmath58 theories , so the disorder operators with @xmath184 are the lowest - dimension nonperturbative operators . what can these operators map to under the large @xmath4 cs - matter bosonization dualities ? the dual to the stronly coupled cs - fermion theory of rank @xmath185 is the weakly coupled cs - wilson - fisher theory of rank @xmath186 . ( recall that dual pairs of theories have ranks related by @xmath187 . ) all single - trace operators match across the duality , so the fermionic disorder operator can not be dual to any combination of bosonic single - traces . moreover , global symmetries must map across the duality , and the single - flux disorder operator is charged with a topological @xmath188 symmetry @xcite . if the dual theory has gauge group @xmath189 , the only candidate in the weakly coupled bosonic theory is the bosonic disorder operator . if the dual theory is @xmath190 , the only reasonable candidate is a baryon operator based on level - rank duality of pure cs theory @xcite , we may expect that @xmath191 maps to @xmath189 while @xmath192 maps to @xmath190 , meaning that disorder operators must map to disorder operators and baryons must map to baryons . however , in this speculative section we remain open to the possibility that @xmath191 maps to @xmath190 . can a bosonic baryon be dual to a fermionic disorder operator ? the powers @xmath193 of derivatives must be inserted so that the levi - civita symbol does not antisymmetrize the baryon to zero . their positioning is similar to populating the fermi sea with fermions in the disorder operator s matter dressing this is a pleasant feature but should not be taken to mean much , as the fermi sea picture is not meaningful at strong coupling . more interestingly , though , this operator is charged under a baryon current @xmath194 , and in an @xmath190 theory this current is the natural ( and only ) candidate dual to the topological current @xmath188 of disorder operators in @xmath191 cs - fermion theories . a mapping between monopoles and baryons has been observed in some supersymmetric theories in three dimensions @xcite . even if some monopoles map to baryons under bosonization , the corresponding dimensions do not match up completely . the lowest bosonic baryon has dimension proportional to @xmath195 at weak coupling @xcite . the lowest fermionic disorder operator has dimension proportional to @xmath196 . their dimensions differ by a factor of @xmath197 . to make dimensions match without ruining the mapping of @xmath2 charges , we must postulate that the fermionic disorder operator is bosonized to a bosonic baryon _ and _ a sea of singlets needed to raise the dimension to the right number . in particular , a way that this can be done is to state that the lowest - dimension fermionic disorder operator maps to @xmath198 baryons and @xmath199 antibaryons in a bosonic theory , with @xmath200 at strong fermionic coupling . the @xmath199 baryon - antibaryon pairs can then be written as a combination of multi - traces . a similar multi - trace - dressing trick can be used to match up the dimensions of monopoles in the case of bosonic @xmath189 duals to the @xmath191 cs - fermion theory . however , this leaves open the question of what a single bosonic baryon is dual to . the mismatch of baryon and monopole dimensions that comes from studying the lowest - dimension disorder operators may serve as evidence that bosonization really does map a @xmath201 fermionic theory to a @xmath202 bosonic one , just as one would expect from pure cs level - rank duality . it is particularly interesting to study these operator maps in light of the fact that the two phase transitions in fig . [ fig phases ] are dual to each other @xcite . based on general expectations of analyticity and the evidence from @xcite , at any @xmath61 the gww transition should be induced by baryon - antibaryon pairs that affect the multi - trace density of states . as all single - trace operators are dual to each other , the relations between them that cause the phase transitions should also be dual . the dk transition , being the dual of the gww transition , should thus be induced by relations between single - traces , and in particular it is natural to assume that it arises due to either monopole - antimonopole or baryon - anitbaryon pairs affecting the density of states of single - traces . monopole - antimonopole pairs can drive a phase transition via different ways to enact the ope of disorder operators @xmath7 and @xmath203 of opposite gno charges ; @xmath204 has zero topological charge so we can expect to find higher - spin currents in this ope . in other words , a two - monopole state with zero topological charge may have nontrivial overlaps with multiple multi - trace states , and this may lead to relations between multi - traces . and @xmath58 . the theories with these groups have the same phase structure , but only @xmath58 has topologically charged monopoles , so once again we are led to think of topologically neutral configurations as the ones that drive the phase transition . in the same way , the baryonic phase transition exists in @xmath58 theories in which baryons are not gauge - invariant operators . ] it is thus very natural to conjecture that we can express a baryon - antibaryon pair @xmath205 in a fermionic theory as a pair of nonperturbative bosonic operators . this is consistent with the picture of individual disorder operators mapping to individual baryons or monopoles , and it is now an interesting question of combinatorics ( relegated to future work ) to show whether the pairwise mapping of operators can be factored into mapping individual operators . doing this combinatorics while respecting constraints set by the duality of phase transitions and the known dimensions of lowest - lying nonperturbative operators seems likely to reveal fascinating patterns in operator maps at finite @xmath4 . if this is possible , we should also be able to conclusively decide whether the bosonization duality maps @xmath191 to @xmath189 , to @xmath190 , or to something else entirely . another question of interest is the bosonization of disorder operators with zero topological charge . based on our calculations , at least some of these are also stable saddles of the path integral ( e.g. the dimension of the operator with @xmath206 is @xmath207 ) . thus they should not map to single- or multi - trace operators . a possible option is that they map to other disorder operators of zero topological charge . finally , a good check for the speculations given in this section would come from studying all the currently unknown quantum numbers of these nonperturbative operators . in particular , understanding bosonic disorder operators would be of great interest . the methods in this paper are not applicable to monopole states in cs - boson path integrals because scalar matter can condense even when the magnetic flux in a thermal cell is small . we view the generalization of the calculation in this paper to bosonic and supersymmetric theories as the most immediate and pressing topic for future work . it is a pleasure to thank guy gur - ari , ethan dyer , and jen lin for collaborating on various stages of this project . thanks are also due to shamik banerjee , shiraz minwalla , steve shenker , and ran yacoby for comments and useful conversations , and in particular to ofer aharony and spenta wadia for pointing out monopole regularization subtleties . the author is supported by a william r. hewlett stanford graduate fellowship . j. preskill , `` magnetic monopoles , '' ann . nucl . part . sci . * 34 * , 461 ( 1984 ) . d. tong , `` tasi lectures on solitons : instantons , monopoles , vortices and kinks , '' hep - th/0509216 . a. m. polyakov , `` quark confinement and topology of gauge groups , '' nucl . b * 120 * , 429 ( 1977 ) . g. baskaran and p. w. anderson , `` gauge theory of high temperature superconductors and strongly correlated fermi systems , '' phys . b * 37 * , 580 ( 1988 ) . n. read and s. sachdev , `` valence - bond and spin - peierls ground states of low - dimensional quantum antiferromagnets , '' phys . lett . * 62 * , 1694 ( 1989 ) . n. read and s. sachdev , `` spin - peierls , valence - bond solid , and neel ground states of low - dimensional quantum antiferromagnets , '' phys . b * 42 * , 4568 ( 1990 ) . t. senthil , l. balents , s. sachdev , a. vishwanath and m. p. a. fisher , `` quantum criticality beyond the landau - ginzburg - wilson paradigm , '' phys . rev . b * 70 * , 144407 ( 2004 ) . m. hermele , `` non - abelian descendant of abelian duality in a two - dimensional frustrated quantum magnet , '' phys . b * 79 * , 184429 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0902.1350 [ cond-mat.str-el ] ] . v. borokhov , a. kapustin and x. k. wu , `` topological disorder operators in three - dimensional conformal field theory , '' jhep * 0211 * , 049 ( 2002 ) [ hep - th/0206054 ] . s. s. pufu , `` anomalous dimensions of monopole operators in three - dimensional quantum electrodynamics , '' phys . rev . d * 89 * , no . 6 , 065016 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1303.6125 [ hep - th ] ] . g. murthy and s. sachdev , `` action of hedgehog instantons in the disordered phase of the ( 2 + 1)-dimensional cp@xmath208 ) model , '' nucl . b * 344 * , 557 ( 1990 ) . m. a. metlitski , m. hermele , t. senthil and m. p. a. fisher , `` monopoles in cp@xmath208 model via the state - operator correspondence , '' phys . b * 78 * , 214418 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0809.2816 [ cond-mat.str-el ] ] . e. dyer , m. mezei , s. s. pufu and s. sachdev , `` scaling dimensions of monopole operators in the @xmath209 theory in 2 @xmath210 1 dimensions , '' jhep * 1506 * , 037 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1504.00368 [ hep - th ] ] . e. dyer , m. mezei and s. s. pufu , `` monopole taxonomy in three - dimensional conformal field theories , '' arxiv:1309.1160 [ hep - th ] . s. kim and k. madhu , `` aspects of monopole operators in n=6 chern - simons theory , '' jhep * 0912 * , 018 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0906.4751 [ hep - th ] ] . h. c. kim and s. kim , `` semi - classical monopole operators in chern - simons - matter theories , '' arxiv:1007.4560 [ hep - th ] . k. a. intriligator and n. seiberg , `` duality , monopoles , dyons , confinement and oblique confinement in supersymmetric so(n(c ) ) gauge theories , '' nucl . phys . b * 444 * , 125 ( 1995 ) [ hep - th/9503179 ] . o. aharony , a. hanany , k. a. intriligator , n. seiberg and m. j. strassler , `` aspects of n=2 supersymmetric gauge theories in three - dimensions , '' nucl . b * 499 * , 67 ( 1997 ) [ hep - th/9703110 ] . o. aharony , `` ir duality in d = 3 n=2 supersymmetric usp(2n(c ) ) and u(n(c ) ) gauge theories , '' phys . b * 404 * , 71 ( 1997 ) [ hep - th/9703215 ] . a. kapustin and m. j. strassler , `` on mirror symmetry in three - dimensional abelian gauge theories , '' jhep * 9904 * , 021 ( 1999 ) [ hep - th/9902033 ] . m. j. strassler , `` confining phase of three - dimensional supersymmetric quantum electrodynamics , '' in * shifman , m.a . ( ed . ) : the many faces of the superworld * 262 - 279 [ hep - th/9912142 ] . v. borokhov , a. kapustin and x. k. wu , `` monopole operators and mirror symmetry in three - dimensions , '' jhep * 0212 * , 044 ( 2002 ) [ hep - th/0207074 ] . a. giveon and d. kutasov , `` seiberg duality in chern - simons theory , '' nucl . b * 812 * , 1 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0808.0360 [ hep - th ] ] . s. kim , `` the complete superconformal index for n=6 chern - simons theory , '' nucl . b * 821 * , 241 ( 2009 ) [ nucl . b * 864 * , 884 ( 2012 ) ] [ arxiv:0903.4172 [ hep - th ] ] . d. bashkirov , `` aharony duality and monopole operators in three dimensions , '' arxiv:1106.4110 [ hep - th ] . f. benini , c. closset and s. cremonesi , `` comments on 3d seiberg - like dualities , '' jhep * 1110 * , 075 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1108.5373 [ hep - th ] ] . h. c. kim , j. kim , s. kim and k. lee , `` vortices and 3 dimensional dualities , '' arxiv:1204.3895 [ hep - th ] . k. intriligator and n. seiberg , `` aspects of 3d n=2 chern - simons - matter theories , '' jhep * 1307 * , 079 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1305.1633 [ hep - th ] ] . o. aharony , s. s. razamat , n. seiberg and b. willett , `` 3d dualities from 4d dualities , '' jhep * 1307 * , 149 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1305.3924 [ hep - th ] ] . o. aharony and d. fleischer , `` ir dualities in general 3d supersymmetric su(n ) qcd theories , '' jhep * 1502 * , 162 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1411.5475 [ hep - th ] ] . o. aharony , p. narayan and t. sharma , `` on monopole operators in supersymmetric chern - simons - matter theories , '' jhep * 1505 * , 117 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1502.00945 [ hep - th ] ] . s. h. shenker and x. yin , `` vector models in the singlet sector at finite temperature , '' arxiv:1109.3519 [ hep - th ] . o. aharony , g. gur - ari and r. yacoby , `` @xmath211 bosonic vector models coupled to chern - simons gauge theories , '' jhep * 1203 * , 037 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1110.4382 [ hep - th ] ] . s. giombi , s. minwalla , s. prakash , s. p. trivedi , s. r. wadia and x. yin , `` chern - simons theory with vector fermion matter , '' eur . phys . j. c * 72 * , 2112 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1110.4386 [ hep - th ] ] . o. aharony , g. gur - ari and r. yacoby , `` correlation functions of large n chern - simons - matter theories and bosonization in three dimensions , '' jhep * 1212 * , 028 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1207.4593 [ hep - th ] ] . s. jain , s. p. trivedi , s. r. wadia and s. yokoyama , `` supersymmetric chern - simons theories with vector matter , '' jhep * 1210 * , 194 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1207.4750 [ hep - th ] ] . . radievi , `` singlet vector models on lens spaces , '' jhep * 1403 * , 048 ( 2014 ) arxiv:1210.0255 [ hep - th ] . s. yokoyama , `` chern - simons - fermion vector model with chemical potential , '' jhep * 1301 * , 052 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1210.4109 [ hep - th ] ] . g. gur - ari and r. yacoby , `` correlators of large n fermionic chern - simons vector models , '' jhep * 1302 * , 150 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1211.1866 [ hep - th ] ] . t. takimi , `` duality and higher temperature phases of large @xmath4 chern - simons matter theories on @xmath212 , '' arxiv:1304.3725 [ hep - th ] . s. jain , s. minwalla and s. yokoyama , `` chern simons duality with a fundamental boson and fermion , '' jhep * 1311 * , 037 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1305.7235 [ hep - th ] ] . d. anninos , r. mahajan , . radievi and e. shaghoulian , `` chern - simons - ghost theories and de sitter space , '' jhep * 1501 * , 074 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1405.1424 [ hep - th ] ] . s. jain , m. mandlik , s. minwalla , t. takimi , s. r. wadia and s. yokoyama , `` unitarity , crossing symmetry and duality of the s - matrix in large n chern - simons theories with fundamental matter , '' jhep * 1504 * , 129 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1404.6373 [ hep - th ] ] . y. dandekar , m. mandlik and s. minwalla , `` poles in the @xmath213-matrix of relativistic chern - simons matter theories from quantum mechanics , '' jhep * 1504 * , 102 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1407.1322 [ hep - th ] ] . k. inbasekar , s. jain , s. mazumdar , s. minwalla , v. umesh and s. yokoyama , `` unitarity , crossing symmetry and duality in the scattering of @xmath214 susy matter chern - simons theories , '' arxiv:1505.06571 [ hep - th ] . g. gur - ari and r. yacoby , `` three dimensional bosonization from supersymmetry , '' arxiv:1507.04378 [ hep - th ] . s. minwalla and s. yokoyama , `` chern simons bosonization along rg flows , '' arxiv:1507.04546 [ hep - th ] . p. goddard , j. nuyts and d. i. olive , `` gauge theories and magnetic charge , '' nucl . b * 125 * , 1 ( 1977 ) . t. t. wu and c. n. yang , `` concept of nonintegrable phase factors and global formulation of gauge fields , '' phys . d * 12 * , 3845 ( 1975 ) . s. pufu , `` properties of monopole operators in 3d gauge theories , '' presentation at ` http://online.kitp.ucsb.edu/online/qft-c14/pufu/ ` ( 2014 ) . s. hellerman , d. orlando , s. reffert and m. watanabe , `` on the cft operator spectrum at large global charge , '' jhep * 1512 * , 071 ( 2015 ) doi:10.1007/jhep12(2015)071 [ arxiv:1505.01537 [ hep - th ] ] . s. r. wadia , `` a study of u(n ) lattice gauge theory in 2-dimensions , '' arxiv:1212.2906 [ hep - th ] . d. j. gross and e. witten , `` possible third order phase transition in the large n lattice gauge theory , '' phys . d * 21 * , 446 ( 1980 ) . s. r. wadia , `` @xmath4 = infinity phase transition in a class of exactly soluble model lattice gauge theories , '' phys . b * 93 * , 403 ( 1980 ) . m. r. douglas and v. a. kazakov , `` large n phase transition in continuum qcd in two - dimensions , '' phys . b * 319 * , 219 ( 1993 ) [ hep - th/9305047 ] . m. moshe and j. zinn - justin , `` quantum field theory in the large n limit : a review , '' phys . rept . * 385 * , 69 ( 2003 ) [ hep - th/0306133 ] . m. blau and g. thompson , `` derivation of the verlinde formula from chern - simons theory and the g / g model , '' nucl . b * 408 * , 345 ( 1993 ) [ hep - th/9305010 ] . h. neuberger , `` nonperturbative contributions in models with a nonanalytic behavior at infinite @xmath4 , '' nucl . b * 179 * , 253 ( 1981 ) . doi:10.1016/0550 - 3213(81)90238 - 8 f. david , `` phases of the large n matrix model and nonperturbative effects in 2-d gravity , '' nucl . phys . b * 348 * , 507 ( 1991 ) . doi:10.1016/0550 - 3213(91)90202 - 9 s. h. shenker , `` the strength of nonperturbative effects in string theory , '' in * brezin , e. ( ed . ) , wadia , s.r . ( ed . ) : the large n expansion in quantum field theory and statistical physics * 809 - 819 o. aharony , `` baryons , monopoles and dualities in chern - simons - matter theories , '' arxiv:1512.00161 [ hep - th ] .

building on the recent progress in solving chern - simons - matter theories in the planar limit , we compute the scaling dimensions of a large class of disorder ( `` monopole '' ) operators in @xmath0 chern - simons - fermion theories at all t hooft couplings . we find that the lowest - dimension operator of this sort has dimension @xmath1 . we comment on the implications of these results to analyzing maps of fermionic disorder operators under 3d bosonization . ` su - itp-15/16 ` * disorder operators in chern - simons - fermion theories * ore radievi _ stanford institute for theoretical physics and department of physics + stanford university + stanford , ca 94305 - 4060 , usa _ + ` [email protected] ` +

1507.08459

on 15 february 2013 at about 03:20 utc 17-meter asteroid entered the earth s atmosphere and exploded while travelling at a speed of 19 km / s . the body became a superbolide meteor , which was seen over the southern ural region . at the moment of maximum brightness , which occurred near the city of chelyabinsk , the meteor was brighter than the sun . the several small fragments of meteorite ( ordinary chondrite ) were quickly found on the west of chelyabinsk , with the largest fragment of total mass of 654 kg raised from the bottom of the chebarkul lake on 16 october 2013 ( popova et al . 2013 , brown et al . 2013 , borovicka et al . 2013 , kohut et al . 2014 ) . about 16 hours after chelyabinsk fireball occurrence the 45-meter asteroid 367943 duende ( 2012 da14 ) approached the earth and missed it by about 27 700 km . this was striking coincidence but subsequent analysis of the data clearly indicated the two objects could not have been related because they had widely different orbits ( wlodarczyk 2012 , moskovitz et al . 2013 ) what is more interesting similar situation occurred over two years earlier . on the night of 2010 oct 9/10 , mt . lemmon survey reported a discovery of a new 20-meter apollo type asteroid designated as 2010 tb54 ( hergenrother 2010 ) . the asteroid has been expected to pass only 6.1 lunar distance ( 0.011 au ) from the earth . over 11 hours earlier sky over central poland was illuminated by @xmath0 magnitude fireball . what is even more interesting these both bodies , contrary to chelyabinsk meteorite parent body and duende asteroid , seem to be related . in this paper we report an analysis of the multi - station observations of the pf131010 fireball made by cameras of the _ polish fireball network_. both the trajectory and orbit are calculated indicating that the fireball was related to 2010 tb54 asteroid . even closer resemblance of orbits is found for 2010 sx11 asteroid . the _ polish fireball network ( pfn ) _ is the project whose main goal is regularly monitoring the sky over poland in order to detect bright fireballs occurring over the whole territory of the country ( olech et al . 2005 , odek et al . 2007 , 2009 , winiewski et al . 2012 ) . it is kept by amateur astronomers associated in _ comets and meteors workshop ( cmw ) _ and coordinated by astronomers from copernicus astronomical center in warsaw , poland . currently , there are over 20 fireball stations belonging to _ pfn _ which operate during each clear night . the pf131010 ciechanw fireball was observed by five _ pfn _ video stations ( table 1 ) : two of the recordings allowed us to determine the trajectory of the phenomenon , one recording includes observations made from a distance of over 400 km , another one features an initial part of the trajectory , and the last one noticed a bright reflection on clouds layer only . the most detailed and valuable recording comes from the pfn37 station in nowe miasto lubawskie , positioned 80 km north - east of toru ( see fig . 1 ) . a camera with a 70-degree field of view registered its path in the southern direction diagonally through the field of view . the bolide appeared between the constellations of orion and the gemini as a point - like structure of about 2 magnitude . the brightness of the meteor increased quickly , and after 1.2 seconds the wake appeared . until about 3 seconds the bolide continued its luminous path as an object of about @xmath5 magnitude . the fireball started to lose its brightness in the middle of the visible trajectory , reaching a local minimum at about 4.6 second of the flight . [ cols="<,<,^,^,^,<,<",options="header " , ] the observed final velocity of 5.8 km / s at the height of 29 km ( which most probably could descend even lower ) indicates a possible meteorite fall near grabowo , south of ostoka . an estimated impact point of the single meteorite weighing about 2 kilograms is about 22 kilometers of the final trajectory point , about 3.5 km to the left of the trajectory axis ( see fig . the exact coordinates of the impact point are @xmath6 n , @xmath7 e. calculations have been performed with assumption that only one fragment survived the ablation . the dynamic mass has been calculated using parameters observed at the end of the visible trajectory . the mass is given for chondrite body with bulk density of 3.7 @xmath8 and calculated using standard formulas ( ceplecha 1987 ) . because of huge trajectory uncertainties concerning the parameters observed in the final part of the trajectory the precision in determining the final place of impact amounts to about 3 km . an atmosphere profile , obtained during atmospheric probing performed on october 13 , 2010 at 00:00 ut ( the legionowo meteorological station located 65 km south of the terminal point ) , was used for the computations . a searching expedition was launched soon after the first rough estimates of results was determined , but their efforts were fruitless . after another manual measurement of the meteor position there was a new result ( presented here ) , slightly different from the previous one . the second expedition took place at the end of march 2015 , though without positive results either . the area ( with active agriculture ) is not easy to search , with at least half of it not easily accessible . based on the observational data we were able to determine the radiant of ciechanw fireball , its geocentric velocity and orbital parameters of the meteoroid which entered the earth s atmosphere . the orbital parameters are listed in the first row of table 3 * * , * * and the diagram showing orbit of the fireball in the inner solar system is displayed in fig . the orbit of ciechanw fireball is located almost in the ecliptic plane and has low eccentricity . the meteoroid hit the earth less than two months before perihelion passage which was expected on december 4 , 2010 at distance of @xmath9 au . comparison of the orbit of ciechanw fireball to orbits of near earth objects ( neo ) allowed us to select several asteroids with drummond criterion @xmath10 ( drummond 1979 ) . two of them are especially interesting . the 2010 tb54 asteroid has @xmath11 criterion value as small as 0.058 . what is more interesting this object passed within the distance of only 0.016 au from the earth on october 13 , 2010 at 14:14 ut , i.e. only 11.4 hours before the occurrence of the ciechanw fireball . this asteroid has been discovered by mount lemnon survey on october 9 , 2010 , its observing arc is 3 day long and based on 30 optical measurements . 2010 tb54 has absolute magnitude @xmath12 magnitude , and its diameter is less than 29 meters . even lower drummond criterion value ( @xmath13 ) was noted for 2010 sx11 asteroid . the close encounter with this body occurred on october 11 , 2010 at 13:10 ut at the distance of 0.025 au . in this case the time difference amounts to 37.7 hours . 2010 sx11 is a larger body , with absolute magnitude @xmath14 magnitude and diameter between 33 and 73 meters . observing arc span is 21 days , 33 optical measurements were used to determine orbital elements . uncertainties of orbital elements for both asteroids are similar but slightly smaller for 2010 sx11 . our results indicate the possibility that in period of october 11 - 13 there is an activity of meteor shower of asteroid origin with radiant located in the border of pisces and aries constellations . a numerical integration of the orbital parameters backwards in time has been performed in order to test the link between the fireball ciechanw and two neos : 2010 sx11 and 2010 tb54 . for the integrations of the asteroids and test particles representing fireball , the radau integrator in the mercury software was used ( chambers 1999 ) . the model of the solar system used in integrations included : 8 planets , four asteroids ( ceres , pallas , vesta , and hygiea ) , and the moon as a separate body . the positions and velocities of the perturbing planets and the moon were taken from the de406 ( standish 1998 ) . the initial orbital elements of asteroids 2010 sx11 and 2010 tb54 were taken from jpl horizons website . together with initial orbital elements of asteroids , the test particles were integrated to the same epoch of the beginning of the integration . next , the backward integration was continued for 5000 yr . during the evolution , the ascending and descending nodes of theoretical particles are dispersed within heliocentric distances from 0.8 to 1.8 au , with a concentration around earth s orbit . the generated stream has been widely dispersed in longitude , mostly by perturbation from the earth . therefore , application of a conventional similarity functions : @xmath15 ( southworth and hawkins 1963 ) , @xmath11 ( drummond 1981 ) , or @xmath16 ( jopek 1993 ) , would be strongly influenced in the longitude term in the d - criterion . due to it , we used ( steel 1991 ) criterion , @xmath17 , where the longitude term is not included . figures 7 and 8 show that the evolution of the @xmath17 criterion reveals a link between the ciechanw fireball and neos , with the values of @xmath17 being less than 0.15 through the whole integration time ( except one test particle when we compare orbits with 2010 tb54 and 2010 sx11 , respectively ) . the theoretical geocentric radiants of the asteroids has been determined using fortran code which is able to calculate radiant coordinates and theoretical stream orbit ( neslusan et al . theoretical radiants of asteroids and ciechanw meteoroid does nt match if calculated from present orbital elements . however similarity of the radiant is visible for back integrated orbital elements . distance between 2010 sx11 radiant and ciechanw radiant was close to 8.5 degrees 5000 years ago . also the theoretical radiant of 2010 tb54 was located in the same sky area , 7.5 degrees from the ciechanw radiant . five thousands years ago all theoretical radiants were closer than 10 degrees each other with geocentric discriminants @xmath18 for 2010 sx11 , @xmath19 for 2010tb54 and @xmath20 for ciechanw . change of radiant distances in time may suggest that age of possible stream is probably larger than 10000 years . in this paper we presented an analysis of the multi - station observations of a bright fireball which occurred over eastern poland . our main conclusions are as follows : * the meteor appeared on 2010 oct 12/13 at 02:52:32 ut over the eastern part of poland was detected by five video stations of _ polish fireball network _ , * the maximum brightness of the fireball reached @xmath21 mag and was observed at height of @xmath22 km over ciechanw city , * the entry velocity was only @xmath1 km / s and after three seconds of flight the meteoroid was significantly decelerated with the rate of @xmath23 resulting with final velocity of only @xmath3 km / s , * low value of final velocity indicates a possible 2 kg meteorite fall near grabowo , south of ostoka , * the low eccentric orbit of the fireball , positioned almost in the ecliptic plane , is similar to orbits of 2010 tb54 and 2010 sx11 asteroids , which passed the earth 11.4 and 37.7 hours before the occurrence of the fireball , respectively , * numerical integration of the orbital elements backwards in time indicates that ciechanw fireball and 2010 tb54 and 2010 sx11 asteroids may have common origin . this work was supported by the ncn grant number 2013/09/b / st9/02168 . 99 borovika , j. , spurn , p. , brown , p. , wiegert , p. , kalenda , p. , clark , d. , shrben , l. , 2013 , nature , 503 , 235 , j. and tth , j. and igaz , a. and spurn , p. and kalenda , p. and haloda , j. and svore , j. and korno , l. and silber , e. and brown , p. and husrik , m. , 2013 , meteoritics and planetary science , 48 , 1757 brown , p.g . , assink , j.d . , astiz , l. et al . , 2013 , nature , 503 , 238 carter , r.t . , jandir , p.s . , kress , t.e . , 2009 , 40th lunar and planetary science conference , id.2059 ceplecha , z. , 1987 , bulletin of the astronomical institutes of czechoslovakia , 38 , 222 chambers , j. e. 1999 , mon . not . r. astron . , 304 , 793 drummond , j.d . , 1979 , southwest reg . astrophys . , 5 , 83 drummond , j. d. , 1981 , icarus , 45 , 545 hergenrother , c.w . , 2010 , minor planet electronic circular , 10 oct . 2010 jopek , t. j. , 1993 , icarus , 106 , 603 kohout , t. , gritsevich , m. , grokhovsky , v.i . et al . , 2014 , icarus , 228 , 78 moskovitz , n.a . , endicott , t. , lister , t. et al . , 2013 , american geophysical union , fall meeting 2013 neslusan , l. , svoren , j. , porubcan , v. , 1998 , a&a , 331 , 411 olech , a. , odek , p. , winiewski , m. , et . al , 2005 , proceedings of the international meteor conference , oostmalle , belgium , 15 - 18 september , edt . : bastiaens , l. , verbert , j. , wislez , j .- m . , verbeeck , c. international meteor organisation , p. 53 popova , o. , jenniskiens , p. , emelyanenko , v. et al . , 2013 , science , 342 , 1069 sonotaco , 2009 , wgn , 37 , 55 southworth , r. b. and hawkins , g. s. , 1963 , smithson . astrophys , 7 , 261 standish , e. m. , 1998 , jpl iom , 312.f - 98 - 048 steel , d. i. , asher , d. j. , clube , s. v. m. , 1991 , mnras , 251 , 632 winiewski , m. , odek , p. , fietkiewicz , k. , et al . , 2012 , european planetary science congress 2012 , held 23 - 28 september , 2012 in madrid , spain . wlodarczyk , i. , 2012 , mnras , 427 , 1175 odek , p. , olech , a. , winiewski , m. , kwinta , m. , 2007 , earth , moon and planets , 100 , 215 odek , p. , winiewski , m. , olech , a. , et al . , 2009 , wgn , 37 , 161 odek , p. , 2012 , proceedings of the international meteor conference , sibiu , romania , 15 - 18 september , 2011 eds . : gyssens , m. ; and roggemans , p. p. 53

on 2010 october 13 , the apollo type 20-meter asteroid 2010 tb54 passed within 6.1 lunar distances from the earth . on the same date , but 11.4 hours earlier , exactly at 02:52:32 ut , the sky over central poland was illuminated by @xmath0 magnitude pf131010 ciechanw fireball . the trajectory and orbit of the fireball was computed using multi - station data of _ polish fireball network ( pfn)_. the results indicate that the orbit of the meteoroid which caused the pf131010 fireball is similar to the orbit of 2010 tb54 asteroid and both bodies may be related . moreover , two days before appearance of ciechanw fireball another small asteroid denoted as 2010 sx11 passed close to the earth - moon system . its orbit is even more similar to the orbit of ciechanw fireball parent body than in case of 2010 tb54 . + the pf131010 ciechanw entered earth s atmosphere with the velocity of @xmath1 km / s and started to shine at height of @xmath2 km . clear deceleration started after first three seconds of flight , and the terminal velocity of the meteor was only @xmath3 km / s at height of @xmath4 km . such a low value of terminal velocity indicates that fragments with total mass of around 2 kg could survive the atmospheric passage and cause fall of the meteorites . the predicted area of possible meteorite impact is computed and it is located near grabowo village south of ostroka city . [ firstpage ] meteorites , meteors , meteoroids , asteroids

1008.5008

almost a century ago , in their pioneering research @xcite , kaluza and klein ( kk ) proposed unification of four dimensional gravity and electromagnetism in a five dimensional gravity framework . this proposal raised a fair amount of curiosity , interest and research activity among theoretical physicists , on the physics of extra dimensions . the idea of extra spatial dimensions appeared in a new incarnation with the advent of superstring theories @xcite . the theoretical existence of branes in string theory eventually motivated the hypothesis that we may be living on an embedded , timelike submanifold ( the brane ) of a higher dimensional ( @xmath0 ) lorentzian spacetime ( warped or unwarped ) , as assumed in the so - called arkani - hamed dvali dimopoulos ( add ) @xcite and randall sundrum ( rs ) @xcite braneworld models . the seminal work of randall and sundrum ( rs ) @xcite on warped braneworlds , published more than a decade ago , refers to the idea of the scale of the extra dimension being spacetime dependent , while addressing the issue of stability , in a two - brane scenario . in a single brane scenario or from a purely higher dimensional bulk perspective , the space - time dependence of the metric function(s ) associated with the extra dimensional coordinate(s ) basically imply that the scale of the extra dimension depends on the on - brane ( four dimensional ) spacetime coordinates . except for a brief discussion on rs type models , we shall , in this article , mostly work with the single brane scenario and a five dimensional bulk . in earlier papers @xcite , geodesics in warped spacetimes have been investigated in detail . however , such a study of geodesics alone can not tell us about the overall local behavior of a family of test particles , as observed in the neighbourhood of a freely falling observer . this motivates us to study the evolution of geodesic congruences . since the appearance of _ raychaudhuri equations , in 1955 @xcite , relativists have discussed and analysed its implications in various contexts . in its original incarnation , the raychaudhuri equations provided the basis for the analysis of spacetime singularities in gravitation and cosmology @xcite . for example , the equation for the expansion and the resulting theorem on geodesic focusing , is a crucial ingredient in the proofs of penrose - hawking singularity theorems @xcite . the kinematics of geodesic congruences is characterised by three kinematical quantities : isotropic expansion , shear and rotation ( henceforth referred as esr ) @xcite , which evolve along the flow according to the raychaudhuri equations . though mostly quoted and used in the context of gravity , these equations by virtue of their geometric nature , have a much wider scope in studying geodesic as well as non - geodesic flows in nature , which may possibly arise in diverse contexts ( see @xcite for some open issues ) . two of the authors here have recently used these equations to investigate the kinematics of geodesic flows in stringy black hole spacetimes @xcite and flows on flat and curved deformable media ( including elastic and viscoelastic media ) in detail @xcite . in this article , we attempt to understand the kinematics of geodesic flows in five dimensional warped bulk spacetimes with and without branes . in section ii we quickly recall the background spacetime geometries and geodesics . section iiia analyses flows in the rs geometry with and without branes . the esr , as obtained from definitions , for a background with a thick brane are discussed in section iiib . numerical solutions of the geodesic and raychaudhuri equations are presented in iiic . finally , section iv contains our conclusions and comments . the bulk spacetimes we work with are given by the line element @xcite ( @xmath1 is the conformal time ) , @xmath2 + b^2(\eta ) d\sigma^2 . \label{eq : cmetric}\ ] ] table [ tab : models ] , shows the chosen functional forms of @xmath3 ( the warp factor ) , the cosmological [ @xmath4 and extra dimensional [ @xmath5 scale factors ( following @xcite ) . .the four possible combinations of @xmath3 , @xmath6 and @xmath7 . [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] we began by considering geodesic flows in the rs background . without branes congruence singularities always occur whereas with two branes , the expansion profile indicates how focusing / defocusing can occur in the spacetime between the branes . later , we analyse geodesic flows in a bulk geometry with a thick brane . using first integrals of geodesic motion , analytic expressions for the kinematic variables are obtained . we show how differences arise as we change the warp factor from growing to decaying or when we do not have any warping but retain the time - evolving cosmological and extra dimensional scales . further , we numerically solve the raychaudhuri and geodesic equations to obtain the expansion , shear , rotation and demonstrate the role of initial conditions on their evolution . with @xmath8 , a growing warp factor leads to a finite @xmath1 ( and @xmath9 ) congruence singularity whereas for a decaying warp factor , geodesics are focused at @xmath1 ( and @xmath9 ) @xmath10 . for a de sitter universe , a decaying warp factor may fail to focus the geodesics ( due to the large negativity of the curvature term in the raychaudhuri equation ) , though this is not the case with a growing warp factor . when the curvature effect is relatively small , a congruence singularity can still arise but for high enough negative initial expansion . the effect of initial rotation , on the esr profiles , especially the expansion scalar , is found to be quantitative . focusing without and with initial rotation yields similar results , though with large initial rotation , geodesics tend to spread for a while ( focusing at larger @xmath11 value ) . all our conclusions are summarised in table [ summary - table ] . for a visual perspective , we have shown snap - shots of the evolution of a square element orthogonal to a geodesic congruence , from a local observer s point of view . the evolution of the expansion , shear and rotation , along the congruences become more explicit through these figures . the effect of @xmath7 seems to be largely quantitative since , in our models , as @xmath11 evolves @xmath7 tends to a static value with a deceleration . it may be asked what relevance , if any , does a congruence singularity have in the context of realistic scenarios ? after all , congruence singularities are not real spacetime singularities where curvatures diverge . here , we are tempted to draw an analogy from null geodesic congruences , for which congruence singularities are nothing but the well - studied caustics where optical intensities get magnified immensely . similarly , in the case of timelike geodesics , we may end up with accretion like effects resulting out of matter accumulation in the neighborhood of a point . for instance , our visualisation analyses do show how the square elements change shape , get rotated because of variations in the metric functions . we may contemplate such accretion effects for flows around brane world black holes @xcite and in such situations , it will become necessary to pursue a line of thought very similar to what we have followed in this article . sg thanks council for scientific & industrial research ( csir ) , india for providing financial support and centre for theoretical studies , iit kharagpur , india for allowing him to use its research facilities . m. s. green , j. h. schwarz and e. witten , _ superstring theory _ ( cambridge university press , uk , 1987 ) ; j. polchinski , _ string theory _ ( cambridge university press , uk , 1997 ) . i. antoniadis , phys . lett . b * 246 * ( 1990 ) 377 . n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos , g. dvali , phys . b * 429 * , 263 - 272 ( 1998 ) ; n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos , g. dvali , phys . d * 59 * , 086004 ( 1999 ) . i. antoniadis , n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos and g. r. dvali , phys . b * 436 * ( 1998 ) 257 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9804398 ] . l. randall and r. sundrum , phys . 83 * , 3370 ( 1999 ) . t. c. scott and r. b. mann , _ general relativity and quantum mechanics : towards a generalization of the lambert w function _ , aaecc ( applicable algebra in engineering , communication and computing ) , vol . 6 , ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : math - ph/0607011v2 ] .

in this article , we explore the kinematics of timelike geodesic congruences in warped five dimensional bulk spacetimes , with and without thick or thin branes . beginning with geodesic flows in the randall sundrum ads ( anti de sitter ) geometry without and with branes we find analytical expressions for the expansion scalar and comment on the effects of including thin branes on its evolution . later , we move on to congruences in more general warped bulk geometries with a cosmological thick brane and a time - dependent extra dimensional scale . using analytical expressions for the velocity field , we interpret the expansion , shear and rotation ( esr ) along the flows , as functions of the extra dimensional coordinate . the evolution of a cross - sectional area orthogonal to the congruence , as seen from a local observer s point of view , is also shown graphically . finally , the raychaudhuri and geodesic equations in backgrounds with a thick brane are solved numerically in order to figure out the role of initial conditions ( prescribed on the esr ) and spacetime curvature on the evolution of the esr .

1111.0169

the signatures of the strong interactions in the quark - gluon matter were found in heavy ion collisions experiments @xcite . there are proposals @xcite suggesting that color - magnetic monopoles contribution can explain this rather unexpected property . these proposals inspired a number of publications devoted to the properties and possible roles of the monopoles in the quark - gluon phase @xcite . lattice gauge theory suggests a direct way to study fluctuations contributing to the euclidean space functional integral , in particular , the color - magnetic monopoles can be studied . in a number of papers the evidence was found that the nonperturbative properties of the nonabelian gauge theories such as confinement , deconfining transition , chiral symmetry breaking , etc . are closely related to the abelian monopoles defined in the maximally abelian gauge @xmath3 @xcite . this was called a monopole dominance @xcite . the drawback of this approach to the monopole studies is that the definition is based on the choice of abelian gauge . there are various arguments supporting the statement that the abelian monopoles found in the mag are important physical fluctuations surviving the cutoff removal : scaling of the monopole density at @xmath4 according to dimension @xmath5 for infrared @xmath6 cluster @xcite ; abelian and monopole dominance for a number of infrared physics observables ( string tension @xcite , chiral condensate @xcite , hadron spectrum @xcite ) ; monopoles in the mag are correlated with gauge invariant objects - instantons and calorons @xcite . it has been recently argued that the mag is a proper abelian gauge to find gauge invariant monopoles since thooft - polyakov monopoles can be identified in this gauge by the abelian flux , but this is not possible in other abelian gauges @xcite . most of these results were obtained for @xmath0 gluodynamics but then confirmed for @xmath7 theory and qcd @xcite . listed above properties of abelian monopoles survive the continuum limit and removal of the gribov copy effects . it is worth noticing that removal of gribov copy effects changes numerical values of monopole characteristics quite substantially @xcite . in this paper we are studying thermal monopoles . it was shown in ref . @xcite that thermal monopoles in minkowski space are associated with euclidean monopole trajectories wrapped around the temperature direction of the euclidean volume . so the density of the monopoles in the minkowski space is given by the average of the absolute value of the monopole wrapping number . in @xcite another approach to study thermal monopole properties in the quark - gluon plasma phase based on the molecular dynamics algorithm was suggested and implemented . the results for parameters of inter - monopole interaction were found in agreement with lattice results @xcite . first numerical investigations of the wrapping monopole trajectories were performed in @xmath0 yang - mills theory at high temperatures in refs . @xcite and @xcite . a more systematic study of the thermal monopoles was performed in ref . it was found in @xcite that the density of monopoles is independent of the lattice spacing , as it should be for a physical quantity . the density density spatial correlation functions were computed in @xcite . it was shown that there is a repulsive ( attractive ) interaction for a monopole monopole ( monopole antimonopole ) pairs , which at large distances might be described by a screened coulomb potential with a screening length of the order of @xmath8 fm . in ref . @xcite it was proposed to associate the respective coupling constant with a magnetic coupling @xmath9 . in the paper @xcite trajectories which wrap more than one time around the time direction were investigated . it was shown that these trajectories contribute significantly to a total monopole density at @xmath10 slightly above @xmath1 . it was also demonstrated that bose condensation of thermal monopoles , indicated by vanishing of the monopole chemical potential , happens at temperature very close to @xmath1 . however , the relaxation algorithm applied in @xcite to fix the mag is a source of the systematic errors due to effects of gribov copies . it is known since long ago that these effects are strong in the mag and results for gauge noninvariant observables can be substantially corrupted by inadequate gauge fixing @xcite . for the density of magnetic currents at zero temperature it might be as high as @xmath11 . for nonzero temperature the effects of gribov copies were not investigated until recently . in a recent paper @xcite this gap was partially closed . it was shown that indeed gauge fixing with sa algorithm and @xmath12 gauge copies per configuration gives rise to the density of the thermal monopoles @xmath13 to @xmath14 lower ( depending on the temperature ) than values found in @xcite . large systematic effects due to effects of gribov copies found in ref . @xcite imply that results obtained in earlier papers @xcite for the density and other monopole properties can not be considered as quantitatively precise and need further independent verification . the quantitatively precise determination of such parameters as monopole density , monopole coupling and others is necessary , in particular , to verify the conjecture @xcite that the magnetic monopoles are weakly interacting ( in comparison with electrically charged fluctuations ) just above transition but become strongly interacting at high temperatures . in this paper we use the same gauge fixing procedure as in refs . @xcite to avoid systematic effects due to gribov copies . the careful study of the finite volume and finite lattice spacing effects was made in @xcite . we fix our spatial lattice size to @xmath15 which was shown in ref . @xcite to be large enough to avoid finite volume effects . we check finite lattice spacing effects comparing results obtained on lattices with @xmath16 and 6 at two temperatures . let us emphasize that our studies are computationally much more demanding in comparison with studies undertaken in refs . @xcite , since we produce @xmath12 gribov copies per configuration to avoid gribov copies effect . for this reason our check of the continuum limit is not as extensive as it was in refs . @xcite . the important contribution of this work to the thermal monopole studies is a check of universality . in studies of magnetic currents at zero temperature it was found @xcite that the density of the infrared magnetic currents is different for different lattice actions with difference as large as @xmath14 . the conclusion was made that the ultraviolet fluctuations contribute to the infrared density and this contribution has to be removed . partial removal was made by the use of the improved action . in present paper we use the improved lattice action - tadpole improved symanzik action and compare our results for the density and other quantities with results obtained with the wilson action @xcite . we find that the universality holds for monopoles which do not form short range ( ultraviolet ) dipoles . we also want to point out that in this work we use more natural procedure of computing monopole correlators in comparison with papers @xcite and @xcite . it was mentioned in ref . @xcite that monopole trajectories had a lot of small loops attached to them which were uv noise . presence of such loops do not allow to determined monopole spatial coordinates unambiguously for all time slices . this problem was bypassed in @xcite by using only one time slice . we remove the small loops attached to thermal monopole trajectories and thus we are able to determine the monopole coordinates in every time slice unambiguously . then we use all time slices to compute the correlators what allows us to decrease the statistical errors substantially . we studied the @xmath0 lattice gauge theory with the tadpole improved symanzik action : parameter @xmath22 is the input tadpole improvement factor taken here equal to the fourth root of the average plaquette p = @xmath23 . we use the same code to generate configurations of the lattice gauge field as was used in ref . our calculations were performed on the asymmetric lattices with lattice volume @xmath24 , where @xmath25 is the number of sites in the time ( space ) direction . the temperature @xmath10 is given by : where @xmath27 is the lattice spacing . to determine the values of @xmath22 we used results of ref . @xcite either directly or to make interpolation to necessary values of @xmath28 . the critical value of the coupling constant for @xmath29 is @xmath30 @xcite . for @xmath29 the ratio @xmath31 was obtained using data for the string tension from ref . @xcite again either directly or via interpolation . for @xmath32 ratio @xmath31 was taken to be equal to the ratio for @xmath29 multiplied by factor @xmath33 . in table [ tab : lattice_size ] we provide the information about the gauge field ensembles and parameters used in our study . we apply the simulated annealing ( sa ) algorithm which proved to be very efficient for this gauge @xcite as well as for other gauges such as center gauges @xcite and landau gauge @xcite . to further decrease the gribov copy effects we generated @xmath12 gribov copies per configuration starting every time gauge fixing procedure from a randomly selected gauge copy of the original monte carlo configuration .

the properties of the thermal abelian color - magnetic monopoles in the maximally abelian gauge are studied in the deconfinement phase of the lattice @xmath0 gluodynamics . to check universality of the monopole properties we employ the tadpole improved symanzik action . the simulated annealing algorithm combined with multiple gauge copies is applied for fixing the maximally abelian gauge to avoid effects of gribov copies . we compute the density , interaction parameters , thermal mass and chemical potential of the thermal abelian monopoles in the temperature range between @xmath1 and @xmath2 . in comparison with earlier findings our results for these quantities are improved either with respect to effects of gribov copies or with respect to lattice artifacts .

1106.4934

magnetars , comprising soft gamma repeaters ( sgrs ) and anomalous x - ray pulsars ( axps ) , have been brought to great attention because they are likely to have super strong surface magnetic fields reaching @xmath8 g @xcite . this exceeds the critical field strength @xmath9 g , where @xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath12 , and @xmath13 are the electron mass , the light velocity , the electron charge and the reduced planck constant , respectively . to understand radiation processes in such an environment , it is necessary to fully take into account non - perturbative effects in quantum electrodynamics . outstanding properties of magnetars include burst activity , observed from all sgrs and some axps . a typical `` short burst '' has a duration of @xmath1100 ms , and a 2100 kev energy release by 10@xmath14 erg ( e.g. , @xcite ) . among a variety of burst activities , the most energetic ones are the giant flares , which were so far detected from sgr0526@xmath1566 ( e.g. , @xcite ) , sgr1900@xmath014 ( e.g. , @xcite ) , and sgr1806@xmath1520 ( e.g. , @xcite ) . x - ray spectra of short bursts provide useful diagnostics of their emission mechanism . wide - band spectra of short bursts from sgr1806@xmath1520 and sgr1900@xmath014 , detected by high energy transient explorer 2 ( hete-2 ; @xcite ) , are generally described by a photoelectrically absorbed two - blackbody ( 2bb ) model @xcite , even though this could be a phenomenological description . spectra of bursts @xcite and intermidiate flares @xcite from sgr 1900@xmath014 also favor the 2bb modeling . in addition , bursts from the new magnetar sgr0501@xmath04516 , detected by suzaku @xcite and swift @xcite , also exhibited 2bb - type spectra ( @xcite , hereafter paperi ; @xcite ) . in terms of this modeling , these short bursts all exhibit an interesting scaling as @xmath16 @xcite , where @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the higher and lower temperatures of the 2bb model , respectively . it has long been known that sgrs and axps show not only burst activities but also persistent emission in energies below @xmath110 kev , of which the spectra are generally reproduced by two phenomenological models ; 2bb ( e.g. , @xcite ) or a photoelectrically absorbed blackbody plus power law model ( bb@xmath0pl ; e.g. , @xcite ) . moreover , recent studies of sgr0501@xmath04516 and other objects propose a `` blackbody plus comptonized blackbody '' model ( @xcite , hereafter paperii ) and a resonant cyclotron scattering model @xcite as alternative possibilities . although the spectral modeling is thus ambiguous , the persistent x - ray emission interestingly shows the same @xmath16 relation as those of the bursts @xcite if we employ the 2bb representation . this suggests a common radiation mechanism between the bursts and persistent emission , further leading to a possibility that the persistent x - ray emission may consist of numerous micro bursts @xcite . recent studies using integral ( e.g. , @xcite ) and suzaku ( @xcite ; paperii ; @xcite ) revealed an extremely hard x - ray component above @xmath110 kev in persistent emission spectra of a significant fraction of sgrs ( including sgr0501@xmath04516 : paperii ) and axps . the hard x - ray component , which is thought to be distinct from the blackbody - like soft component , can be reproduced by a power law ( pl ) model with an extremely hard photon index of @xmath19 . as reported in paperii for sgr0501@xmath04516 and in @xcite for some other sources , the 2100 kev luminosity of the hard x - ray component is often comparable to that of the soft blackbody component . considering these properties , as well as a clear dependence of the hardness ratio between the hard and soft luminosities on the characteristic age as revealed with suzaku @xcite , the hard x - ray component is expected to provide an important clue to the nature of magnetars . theoretically , the hard x - ray production mechanism is extensively discussed @xcite , but it is not yet conclusive . if there is a common radiation mechanism between the bursts and persistent emissions , the hard x - ray component may also be seen in burst spectra . however , short bursts of magnetars so far studied , with fluence @xmath20 erg @xmath3 , generally have @xmath21715 kev ( e.g. , @xcite ) . as a result , their 2bb spectra , extending well up to @xmath22 kev , would mask any hard x - ray component . this raises a possibility that bursts with considerably lower fluence , which have remained not much studied , may have lower values of @xmath17 , e.g. , close to those found in the persistent emission ( e.g. , @xmath210.43.9 kev ; @xcite ; paperii ) , and would allow more sensitive searches for the hard - tail component . considering this , we focus on wide - band spectroscopy of low - fluence bursts . observations with suzaku are suitable for this purpose , because of its high sensitive over a broad energy band , realized by the x - ray imaging spectrometer ( xis ; 0.212 kev ; @xcite ) and the hard x - ray detector ( hxd ; 10600 kev ; @xcite ) . we have hence revisited the suzaku data of sgr0501@xmath04516 , acquired during its 2008 august activity . as a third publication ( after paperi and paperii ) from this observation , the present paper reports on our successful detection of a hard component , in an hxd spectrum which sums over 31 short bursts from this new magnetar . the new soft gamma repeater sgr0501@xmath04516 was discovered on 2008 august 22 by the burst alert telescope on - board swift , when it displayed sgr - like burst activity @xcite . soon after the discovery , a spin period of @xmath23 was reported based on an observation by the rossi x - ray timing explorer @xcite . as described in paperi and paperii , we triggered a suzaku target - of - opportunity ( too ) observation , which started at 00:05 on 2008 august 26 and ended at 08:25 on 2008 august 27 ( ut ) . the xis was operated with a 1/4 window option which yields a 2 s time resolution , while the hxd was operated in the standard mode . the acquired data were already utilized in paperi and paperii ; the former described a strong short burst and persistent soft x - ray emission , while the latter focused on the detection of a hard component in the persistent emission . the present paper , utilizing the same too data , deals with broad - band spectra of 31 smaller short bursts . the distance to sgr0501@xmath04516 , though estimated to be 1.5 kpc based on its directional proximity to the young supernova remnant hb9 @xcite , is actually very uncertain . in this paper , the distance is hence assumed to be 4 kpc , which is similar to the value of @xmath15 kpc employed by @xcite . the reduction of the xis and hxd event data ( v2.2 ) were made using heasoft6.6.1 software . the latest calibration database ( caldb:20090402 ) was applied to unfiltered xis event data using _ xispi _ ( v2008 - 04 - 10 ) . then , using _ xselect _ ( v2.4a ) , we extracted a new set of filtered xis events with the standard criteria and a grade selection `` grade = ( 0,2 - 4,6 ) '' . after that , hot and flickering pixels were removed using _ cleansis _ ( v1.7 ) . telemetry - saturated time intervals , estimated by _ xisgtigen _ ( v2007 - 05 - 14 ) , were removed from the xis data using _ xselect_. we created light curves and spectra from the cleaned xis event data using _ xselect_. response matrix files were generated by _ ( v2007 - 05 - 14 ) , and ancillary response function files by _ xissimarfgen _ ( v2008 - 04 - 05 ) . the obtained net exposure is @xmath160 ks . using _ hxdpi _ and _ hxdgrade _ ( v2008 - 03 - 03 ) , we applied the latest calibration database ( caldb:20090902 ) to the unfiltered hxd event data . cleaned pin and gso events were extracted from these newly calibrated data with the standard criteria using _ xselect_. again , we created light curves and spectra using _ xselect_. dead time corrections were applied to the spectra using _ hxddtcor_. response matrix files of version 2008 - 01 - 29 were used . this yielded a net exposure of @xmath24 ks for the hxd data . as shown in figure1 of paperi , a number of visually obvious bursts are found in a 0.212 kev xis light curve with 2-s resolution , obtained by summing the data from the two fi sensors ( xis0 and xis3 ) and the one bi sensor ( xis1 ) . at least three of them , including the strongest one analyzed in paperi , were also noticed in the 1020 kev hxd - pin light curve with a 500 ms time resolution . following our preliminary attempt in paperi , we conducted a quantitative burst search using the 0.212 kev light curve of the xis . after visually eliminating 8 obvious bursts which have @xmath25 cts(2s)@xmath26 , the light curve was converted to a count - rate ( per 2s ) histogram as shown in figure [ fig : xis_hist ] ; this includes the background , the persistent signal emission , and short bursts . the histogram has an average of @xmath27 and a standard deviation of @xmath28 , both in units of cts(2s)@xmath26 , where the quoted errors refer to 90% confidence levels , and can be approximated by a poissonian distribution . we searched the xis count - rate histogram for those 2-s bins where the count rate exceeds @xmath29 cts(2s)@xmath26 . this selection has yielded 35 time bins with significant excess counts . regarding a set of consecutive such bins as representing a single burst , we thus detected 32 short bursts altogether . among them , the strongest one was already analyzed in paperi . below , we therefore analyze the remaining 31 bursts , which are summarized in table [ tab : burst_summary ] . they are hereafter identified sequentially as # 01 , # 02 , @xmath30 , and # 31 . these 31 short bursts are considered to be free from event pile - up effects in the xis , because their count rates were less than 107 cts(2s)@xmath26xis@xmath26 above which the effect becomes significant . light curves of typical short bursts ( # 03 , # 13 , # 14 , # 22 and # 23 ) are presented in figure [ fig : burst_lc ] . among them , two ( # 03 and # 14 ) are accompanied by significant emissions in the hxd - pin and/or hxd - gso energy bands . since the present paper puts its focus on burst spectra , we must subtract the persistent emission of sgr0501@xmath04516 , as well as the non x - ray background and the cosmic x - ray background . for each burst , we therefore accumulate the xis and hxd data over a time region ( see below ) containing the burst , and subtract the corresponding background spectra which are acquired before and after the burst period . the on - burst and background data of the xis were both extracted from box regions with sizes of ( detx , dety ) = ( @xmath31 , @xmath32 ) for xis1 , and ( @xmath32 , @xmath31 ) for xis0 and xis3 , where detx and dety are detector coordinates . each on - burst spectrum was made using a 2-s or 6-s time interval , depending on the burst duration in the xis . the corresponding background spectra were extracted from two 10-s time intervals , one before and the other after the burst , both separated by 2 s from the on - burst time region . the result does not change if we instead employ 15 s for the background time intervals . therefore , the pulsed persistent emission with a period of @xmath33 s ( paperi ) does not affect the background spectrum . if the background time intervals contained other bursts , they were eliminated from the background spectra . figure [ fig : lc ] shows 6-band synthetic light curves summed over the 31 short bursts , obtained by stacking their individual light curves in reference to the 0.212 kev xis data . thus , the burst emission is clearly seen in the hxd - pin data up to 40 kev , and possibly in the 50100 kev hxd - gso band . average on - burst and background count - rates of the xis are @xmath153 cts(2s)@xmath26 and @xmath114 cts(2s)@xmath26 , respectively . since the xis have a time resolution of 2 s , the burst profiles in the hxd energy bands in figure [ fig : lc ] must be considerably smeared out . figure [ fig : fgbg_comp ] shows on - burst ( _ green _ ) , background ( _ red _ ) , and background subtracted ( _ black _ ) spectra of the xis and the hxd , summed over the 31 bursts . in agreement with figure [ fig : lc ] , the burst emission is significantly detected with hxd - pin up to @xmath140 kev . also , the burst signal may be detected marginally in the 50100 kev gso data . before quantifying the burst spectrum , let us compare it with that of the persistent emission of sgr0501@xmath04516 . to do this in a model - independent manner , we directly divided the summed burst spectrum to the background - subtracted persistent - component spectrum derived in paperii . the ratio in the xis range was estimated using the two fi sensors . the results , presented in figure [ fig : spc_ratio ] , indicate that the burst spectrum is clearly harder than the persistent emission spectrum . in addition , the ratio in the hxd range is approximately flat , implying that in this energy range the burst and persistent emission have approximately the same spectral shape . using xspec 12.5.0 @xcite , we fitted the summed burst spectrum with a photoelectrically absorbed 2bb model , which has been most successful on the short bursts from sgr1806@xmath1520 and sgr1900@xmath014 ( section [ intro ] ) . the photoelectric absorption was fixed to @xmath34 @xmath3 , as estimated from the persistent x - ray emission observed by the xis ( paperi ) . according to a cross - calibration between the xis and the hxd described in @xcite , the hxd normalization is typically 13% higher than that of the xis for crab data acquired at the xis nominal position . therefore the relative normalization of the hxd above the xis was fixed to 1.13 . as shown in figure [ fig : spc ] ( b ) , this 2bb fits leaves significant positive residuals in energies above @xmath120 kev , which makes the fit unacceptable with @xmath35 . although the 2bb fit could be improved to @xmath36 by allowing to vary the hxd vs. xis relative normalizaiton , the obtained normalization ratio , @xmath37 , is far outside the value of @xmath38 obtained from crab observations @xcite , making the fit unrealistic . conversely , the 2bb fit did not improve significantly if the hxd normalization is kept within this uncertainty range . given figure [ fig : spc_ratio ] , as well as the failure of the 2bb model , we fitted the burst spectrum with a 2bb plus power law model ( 2bb@xmath0pl ) . the fit was then improved to @xmath39 . the pl component is considered to be significant , because an f - test indicates a probability of @xmath10.1% for the fit improvement ( by adding pl ) to arise by chance . the best - fit spectral parameters are summarized in table [ tab : spc_summary ] , and the @xmath40 form of the 2bb@xmath0pl fit is given in figure [ fig : spc ] ( d ) . as already expected from figure [ fig : spc_ratio ] , the power - law component indeed exhibits a photon index of @xmath19 , which is comparable to that of the hard x - ray component of the persistent emission ( e.g. , paperii ) . consequently , we conclude that the summed short burst spectrum has a hard - tail component , which has never been detected in the burst spectra of any other magnetar . using the best - fit 2bb@xmath0pl spectral parameters , a bolometric fluence of the 2bb component and a 240 kev fluence of the pl component are calculated as shown in table [ tab : spc_summary ] . those fluences refer to average values of the 31 short bursts , and are lower by two orders of magnitude than a typical 2100 kev fluence of @xmath41 erg@xmath3 for short bursts from sgr1806@xmath1520 and sgr1900@xmath014 ( e.g. , @xcite ) studied so far . thus , the high sensitivity of suzaku allowed us to study , for the first time , the wide - band properties of these low - fluence bursts . assuming the effective duration of the 31 short bursts from sgr0501@xmath04516 to be 0.1 s , which is a typical value for this type of events ( e.g. , @xcite ) , we calculated the flux ( luminosity ) and the blackbody radii , all averaged over the 31 short bursts , and show the results in table [ tab : spc_summary ] . the effective emission radii of the two bb components , @xmath114 km and @xmath11.9 km ( assuming a distance of 4 kpc ) , are comparable to typical values found in short bursts from sgr1806@xmath1520 and sgr1900@xmath014 @xcite , and from sgr0501@xmath04516 @xcite , although the distance uncertainty remains . using the suzaku too observation of sgr0501@xmath04516 conducted in 2008 august , we studied relatively dim 31 short bursts from this new magnetar . their average fluence , @xmath2 erg@xmath3 in 240 kev , is 12 orders of magnitude lower than those of typical short burst studied so far ( e.g. , @xcite ) . following the detection of a hard component from the persistent emission of sgr0501@xmath04516 ( paperii ; @xcite ) , the data have allowed a clear detection of a similar hard - tail component in the spectrum summed over the 31 short bursts . these results for the first time reveal spectral properties of such dim bursts , and provide a new clue to the formation mechanisms of persistent and burst emissions from magnetars . as already reported in paperi , the spectrum of the strongest burst ( actually its precursor ) from sgr0501@xmath04516 was well reproduced by a 2bb model , without indication of an additional hard x - ray component . however , this could be due to the effect mentioned in section [ intro ] , namely , obscuration by the high 2bb temperatures ( @xmath42 kev ) ; the data of this strong precursor are worth searching for a hard tail component . therefore , we re - analyzed the same pile - up and dead - time corrected spectrum of the precursor as studied in paperi , using the 2bb@xmath0pl model . the photon index was fixed to @xmath43 to emulate the results obtained in subsection [ sec : spc_ana ] , and the photoelectric absorption was again fixed to @xmath34 @xmath3 after paperi . the fit resulted in @xmath4/d.o.f . = 40.1/37 = 1.09 , which is no better than the value of 41.2/38 = 1.08 using the 2bb model . therefore , the data do not require any excess hard - tail component with @xmath44 . the best - fit spectral parameters are summarized in table [ tab : spc_summary ] , which are consistent with the results in paperi after renormalizing to the distance of 4 kpc and the duration of 0.2 s. there , the 2100 kev flux of the pl component is given as a 90% upper limit . given the gross spectral similarity between the short bursts and the persistent emission of sgr0501@xmath04516 ( subsection [ sec : spc_ana ] ) , let us perform more quantitative comparison among their soft components , referring to figure [ fig : comp_kt_r ] which summarizes three sets of 2bb parameters of sgr0501@xmath04516 ; the persistent emission , the 31 short bursts , and the precursor of the strongest burst . there , we find three properties that are common to all the three spectra . one is that the cooler and hotter blackbodies have comparable luminosities , and another is that @xmath17 is @xmath45 times higher than @xmath18 . these 2bb properties are considered rather intrinsic to magnetars , because they also apply to more energetic ( typically by an order of magnitude in bolometric fluence ) bursts from sgr1806@xmath1520 and sgr1900@xmath014 observed with hete-2 ( figure 5 of @xcite ) , sgr1900@xmath014 observed with swift @xcite , and sgr0501@xmath04516 observed with swift @xcite , as well as to persistent emission from some other magnetars ( @xcite and references therein ) . the remaining property found in figure [ fig : comp_kt_r ] is that the two temperatures increase with the luminosity . in fact , the temperature of the 31 short bursts are by a factor of 49 lower than those of the typical bursts ( e.g. , @xcite ) . this justifies a posteriori our conjecture made in section [ intro ] , i.e. , a positive temperature - luminosity correlation of the 2bb component . incidentally , the ratio increase in figure [ fig : spc_ratio ] , from a few kev to @xmath46 kev , is at least partially due to the higher 2bb temperatures of the dim bursts than those of the persistent emission . in contrast to the present results , some published results ( e.g. , @xcite ) suggest a weak negative correlation between the 2bb temperatures and the burst fluence . however , these results are usually limited to rather strong bursts with fluence @xmath20 erg @xmath3 . then , the temperature vs. fluence might change at about this fluence . alternatively , weaker bursts in these studies may have actually contained hard - tail components , and hence their spectra appeared rather hard . in addition to these similarities in the soft component , the presence of a distinct pl - shaped hard component , found in the present work , provides a novel resemblance between the 31 short bursts and the persistent emission . moreover , the photon index of the former , @xmath47 , is consistent with the latter , @xmath48 ( paperii ) . however , as already visualized by figure [ fig : spc_ratio ] , the two phenomena can differ in their ratios between the 240 kev hard - component luminosity @xmath49 and the bolometric soft - component luminosity @xmath50 , even excluding the effect caused by different bb temperatures . we observed @xmath51 from the 31 short bursts , which is possibly higher than that of @xmath52 for the persistent emission at 2.6@xmath7 level . here , quoted errors are 68% confidence levels for the ratios , and 90% confidence levels for the photon indices . in order to visualize the wide - band spectral hardness , we compare in figure [ fig : lbb_lpl ] the relations between @xmath53 and @xmath54 . there , @xmath49 was calculated again in the 240 kev range . even though the @xmath55 ratio could vary to some extent , a fact of basic importance is that @xmath49 and @xmath50 increases , by about 2 orders of magnitude in an approximate proportion , from the persistent emission to the dim short bursts . this , together with the spectral similarities discussed above , suggests that common emission mechanisms operate between these short bursts and the persistent emission . this in turn gives a support to our idea that persistent x - ray emission of magnetars may in general consist of numerous micro - bursts @xcite . in contrast , the upper limit on the @xmath55 ratio obtained for the strongest burst is considerably lower than is extrapolated from the other two less luminous data points , suggesting some changes in the emission mechanism from weaker to stronger short bursts . arnaud , k. a. 1996 , in astronomical data analysis software and systems v , eds . g. jacoby and j. barnes , asp conference series , 101 , 17 baring , m. g. , & harding , a. k. 2007 , , 308 , 109 barthelmy , s. d. 2008 , grb coord . , 8113 duncan , r. , & thompson , c. 1992 , , 392 , l9 enoto , t. 2010 , ph.d . thesis , university of tokyo enoto , t. 2009 , , 693 , l122 enoto , t. 2010a , , 715 , 665 enoto , t. 2010b , , 62 , 475 enoto , t. 2010c , , 722 , l162 esposito , p. 2007 , , 476 , 321 feroci , m. , calliandro , g. a. , massaro , e. , mereghetti , s. , & woods , p. m. 2004 , , 612 , 408 gaensler , b. m. , 2008 , grb coord . , 8149 g , e. , woods , p. , & kouveliotou , c. 2008 , grb coord 8118 gehrels , n. , 2004 , , 611 , 1005 heyl , j. s. , & hernquist , l. 2005 , , 362 , 777 hurley , k. , 1999 , , 397 , 41 israel , g. l. , 2008 , , 685 , 1114 kokubun , m. , 2007 , , 59 , 53 koyama , k. , 2007 , , 59 , s23 kuiper , l. , hermsen , w. , & mendez , m. 2004 , , 613 , 1173 kumar , h. s. , ibrahim , a. i. , & safi - harb , s. 2010 , , 716 , 97 leathy , d. a. , & aschenbach , b. 1995 , , 293 , 853 marsden , d. , & white , n. e. 2001 , , 551 , l155 mazets , e. p. , golenetskii , s. v. , & guryan , yu . a. 1979 , soviet astron . lett . , 5 , 343 mereghetti , s. , esposito , p. , & tiengo , a. 2007 , , 308 , 13 mitsuda , k. , 2007 , , 59 , s1 molkov , s. , hurley , k. , sunyaev , r. , shtykovsky , p. , revnivtsev , m. , & kouveliotou , c. 2005 , , 433 , l13 nakagawa , y. e. , 2007 , , 59 , 653 nakagawa , y. e. , 2008 , grb coord . circ . , 8265 nakagawa , y. e. , 2009 , , 61 , s387 olive , j. -f . 2004 , , 616 , 1148 paczyski , b. 1992 , acta astron . , 42 , 145 palmer , d. m. , 2005 , , 434 , 1107 rea , n. , zane , s. , turolla , r. , lyutikov , m. , gtz , d. 2008 , , 686 , 1245 rea , n. , 2009 , , 396 , 2419 ricker , g. , 2003 , in gamma - ray bursts and afterglow astronomy , ed . g. r. ricker & r. vanderspek ( melville : aip ) , 662 , 3 takahashi , t. , 2007 , , 59 , s35 tanaka , y. t. , terasawa , t. , yoshida , m. , horie , t. , hayakawa , m. 2008 , , 113 , a07307 thompson , c. , & beloborodov , a. m. 2005 , , 634 , 565 thompson , c. , & duncan , r. 1995 , , 275 , 255 thompson , c. , & duncan , r. 1996 , , 473 , 322 tiengo , a. , esposito , p. , & mereghetti , s. 2008 , , 680 , 133 llr burst & date ( ut ) & xis counts + # 01 & 2008 - 08 - 26 01:05:44 & 35 + # 02 & 2008 - 08 - 26 01:07:02 & 30 + # 03 & 2008 - 08 - 26 01:23:20 & 309 + # 04 & 2008 - 08 - 26 01:24:08 & 42 + # 05 & 2008 - 08 - 26 01:30:22 & 38 + # 06 & 2008 - 08 - 26 02:43:44 & 34 + # 07 & 2008 - 08 - 26 02:46:02 & 61 + # 08 & 2008 - 08 - 26 02:46:48 & 30 + # 09 & 2008 - 08 - 26 02:50:24 & 32 + # 10 & 2008 - 08 - 26 02:50:38 & 36 + # 11 & 2008 - 08 - 26 03:16:32 & 33 + # 12 & 2008 - 08 - 26 03:16:54 & 37 + # 13 & 2008 - 08 - 26 03:21:00 & 240 + # 14 & 2008 - 08 - 26 03:21:08 & 99 + # 15 & 2008 - 08 - 26 03:21:26 & 30 + # 16 & 2008 - 08 - 26 04:38:10 & 35 + # 17 & 2008 - 08 - 26 08:00:58 & 30 + # 18 & 2008 - 08 - 26 09:25:06 & 31 + # 19 & 2008 - 08 - 26 10:47:32 & 42 + # 20 & 2008 - 08 - 26 12:45:34 & 66 + # 21 & 2008 - 08 - 26 12:45:42 & 50 + # 22 & 2008 - 08 - 26 14:22:50 & 66 + # 23 & 2008 - 08 - 26 14:22:58 & 33 + # 24 & 2008 - 08 - 26 15:27:48 & 30 + # 25 & 2008 - 08 - 26 15:27:56 & 33 + # 26 & 2008 - 08 - 26 15:44:14 & 32 + # 27 & 2008 - 08 - 26 22:26:44 & 30 + # 28 & 2008 - 08 - 27 06:07:02 & 33 + # 29 & 2008 - 08 - 27 07:55:40 & 38 + # 30 & 2008 - 08 - 27 07:55:48 & 31 + # 31 & 2008 - 08 - 27 07:55:56 & 34 + lllllllllll model & @xmath18 & @xmath56 & @xmath17 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & @xmath60 & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & @xmath4/d.o.f . + & ( kev ) & ( km ) & ( kev ) & ( km ) & & & & & & + + 2bb & @xmath63 & ( @xmath64)@xmath65 & @xmath66 & ( @xmath67)@xmath65 & @xmath30 & @xmath68 & @xmath30 & ( @xmath68)@xmath69 & @xmath30 & 74/50 + 2bb@xmath0pl & @xmath70 & ( @xmath71)@xmath65 & @xmath72 & ( @xmath73)@xmath65 & @xmath74 & @xmath75 & @xmath76 & ( @xmath75)@xmath69 & ( @xmath76)@xmath69 & 56/48 + + 2bb@xmath0pl & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 & @xmath80 & 1.0 ( fixed ) & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & 40/36 +

using data with the suzaku xis and hxd , spectral studies of short bursts from the soft gamma repeater sgr0501@xmath04516 were performed . in total , 32 bursts were detected during the @xmath160 ks of observation conducted in the 2008 august activity . excluding the strongest one , the remaining 31 bursts showed an average 240 kev fluence of @xmath2 erg@xmath3 . a 140 kev spectrum summed over them leaves significant positive residuals in the hxd - pin band with @xmath4/d.o.f . = 74/50 , when fitted with a two - blackbody function . by adding a power law model , the fit became acceptable with @xmath4/d.o.f . = 56/48 , yielding a photon index of @xmath5 . this photon index is comparable to @xmath6 @xcite for the persistent emission of the same object obtained with suzaku . the two - blackbody components showed very similar ratios , both in the temperature and the emission radii , to those comprising the persistent emission . however , the power - law to two - blackbody flux ratio was possibly higher than that of the persistent emission at 2.6@xmath7 level . based on these measurements , average wide - band properties of these relatively weak bursts are compared with those of the persistent emission .

gr-qc0101015

there is considerable current interest in studying the collision of two black holes , since these events could be primary sources of gravitational waves for interferometric gravitational wave detectors currently under construction . the mathematics describing such events consists of the nonlinear partial differential equations of general relativity , einstein s theory of gravitation . these equations are very difficult to solve especially in the case of two merging holes , or of the highly distorted final hole that is formed by the merger . limited ( in resolution and evolution time ) full numerical simulations of grazing collisons of black holes are being done now @xcite , but long term stable evolutions are still distant in the future . it is therefore of interest to have at hand approximate results which in certain regimes could be used to test and possibly even complement the full numerical evolutions . among such approximation methods is the close - limit " approximation in which spacetime of a black hole collision is represented as a single distorted black hole and evolutions are done with simple linear perturbative equations . in the past , this method has been applied to the case of a head - on collision of two boosted holes @xcite and the case of slow inspiral @xcite with considerable success . in both these cases , the black holes considered had no spin . in this work , we will consider the collision of spinning holes . since we are attempting a linear , first order perturbative calculation , it is sufficient to study the coalescence of two spinning holes with zero initial linear momentum . this is because , to obtain the results for the inspiral of spinning holes , one can simply do a linear superposition of these results with those from our past work @xcite . however , the first order perturbative treatment imposes several restrictions on the physical scenarios we can treat . in addition to the close - slow limitations , we can only easily analyze cases in which the spins of the two black holes are equal and opposite . this happens because , to lowest order , the ( perturbative ) extrinsic curvature of a black hole with spin @xmath0 and a conformal distance @xmath1 from the origin is of order @xmath2 . superposing another hole with parallel and equal spin and at @xmath3 will yield a situation with zero perturbation in extrinsic curvature , which is not a case of interest . so in the following , we shall present two cases that are exhaustive . _ case i _ , when the two spins are equal and opposite and aligned along the common axis of the two holes . specifically , we place the two holes at @xmath4 and have their spins parallel and anti - parallel to the x - axis . _ case ii _ , when the two spins are equal and opposite and perpendicular to the common axis of the two holes . here , we place the two holes at @xmath4 and have their spins parallel and anti - parallel to the y - axis . these cases have no net angular momentum . so we expect zerilli and teukolsky formalisms to agree exactly ( kerr parameter @xmath5 ) . we , therefore report calculations and results from the teukolsky formalism only . part of this work , in the context of the zerilli formalism can be found in this reference @xcite . to evolve a spacetime in general relativity , one needs to provide initial data , a 3-geometry @xmath6 and an extrinsic curvature @xmath7 , that solve einstein s equations on some starting hypersurface ( i.e. , at some starting time ) . these initial value equations have the form , @xmath8 where @xmath6 is the spatial metric , @xmath7 is the extrinsic curvature and @xmath9 is the scalar curvature of the three metric . if we propose a 3-metric that is conformally flat @xmath10 , with @xmath11 a flat metric , and @xmath12 the conformal factor , and we use a decomposition of the extrinsic curvature @xmath13 , and assume maximal slicing @xmath14 , the constraints become , @xmath15 where @xmath16 is a flat - space covariant derivative . to solve the momentum constraint , we start with a solution that represents a single hole with spin @xmath0 @xcite , @xmath17\ .\ ] ] in this expression for the conformally related extrinsic curvature at some point @xmath18 , the quantity @xmath19 is a unit vector , in the `` base '' flat space with metric @xmath20 , directed from a point representing the location of the hole to the point @xmath18 . the symbol @xmath21 represents the distance , in the flat base space , from the point of the hole to @xmath18 . it is straightforward to show that the solution of the hamiltonian constraint corresponding to eq . ( 5 ) corresponds to a spacetime with adm angular momentum @xmath22 . the next step is to modify this to represent holes centered at @xmath4 in the conformally flat metric . since the momentum constraint is linear , we can simply add two expressions of the above form , @xmath23 we will choose in further expressions to use a polar coordinate system in the flat space determined by @xmath20 centered in the mid - point separating the two holes and label the polar coordinates as @xmath24 . so @xmath25 will be the distance in the flat space from the midpoint between the holes . to solve the hamiltonian constraint [ hami ] , we introduce an approximation , ( the slow approximation ) which we will show is enough for our purposes . in fact , in this approximation the solution for the conformal factor turns out to be the familiar misner @xcite solution if one chooses the topology of the slice to have a single asymptotically flat region , or the brill lindquist @xcite solution if there are three asymptotically flat regions . we assume that the black holes are initially close , and that the initial spins @xmath0 are small . we denote by @xmath26 and @xmath27 the normal vectors corresponding , respectively , to the one hole solutions at @xmath28 and at @xmath29 , and we recall @xmath25 to be the distance to a field point , in the flat conformal space , from the point midway between the holes . for large @xmath25 , the normal vectors @xmath26 and @xmath27 almost cancel . more specifically @xmath30 . a consequence of this is that the total initial @xmath31 is first order in @xmath32 . it scales linearly with the spin @xmath0 as well . thus the source term in the hamiltonian constraint is quadratic in @xmath0 . if we choose to find a solution to the conformal factor to first order in @xmath0 ( which should give us a good approximation in the case of slowly spinning holes ) , we can ignore this quadratic source term . so now , the hamiltonian constraint looks like the one for zero momentum , which is simply the laplace equation . a well known solution to this , is the misner solution @xcite . this solution , is characterized by a parameter @xmath33 which describes the separation of the two throats . we can relate this parameter to the conformal distance @xmath1 in the following way @xcite , @xmath34 we must now map the coordinates of the initial value solution to the coordinates for the schwarzschild ( kerr with @xmath5 ) background . to do this , we interpret the @xmath25 as the isotropic radial coordinate of a schwarzschild spacetime , and we relate it to the usual schwarzschild radial coordinate @xmath21 by @xmath35 . from this we arrive at the following expressions for the components of the metric and extrinsic curvature . following the construction as outlined in the last section , we get the following expressions for the initial spatial metric and extrinsic curvature : @xmath36\ .\ ] ] the metric has a form , identical to the misner solution @xcite . now , we use the methodology and expressions in @xcite , to find the initial data for the teukolsky function , @xmath37 , where @xmath38 . for the azimuthal modes @xmath39 we get these expressions , @xmath40 @xmath41 and for the azimuthal mode @xmath42 we get , @xmath43 @xmath44 to all these expressions , we also need to add metric contributions . they have the same form as the ones in @xcite , therefore we will not list them here . again , following the construction as outlined in the last section , and using the close - slow approximation , we arrive at the following expressions for the initial spatial metric and extrinsic curvature : @xmath45\ .\ ] ] the metric again has a form , identical to the misner solution @xcite . using the methodology and expressions we discussed in @xcite , the initial data for the teukolsky function , is : for the azimuthal modes @xmath39 we get , @xmath46 @xmath47 and for the azimuthal mode , @xmath42 the initial data are identically zero . to all these expressions we need to add the metric contributions , that have a form identical to the ones in our past work @xcite . given the cauchy data from the last section , the time evolution is obtained from the teukolsky equation @xcite , @xmath48 \partial_{tt}- \frac{4 m a r}{\delta}\partial_{t\varphi } + 4\left[r+ia\cos\theta-\frac{m(r^2-a^2)}{\delta}\right]\partial_t \nonumber\\ & & + \,\delta^{2}\partial_r\left(\delta^{-1}\partial_r\right ) + \frac{1}{\sin\theta}\partial_\theta\left(\sin\theta\partial_\theta\right ) + \left[\frac{1}{\sin^2\theta}-\frac{a^2}{\delta}\right ] \partial_{\varphi\varphi}\\ & & -\ , 4 \left[\frac{a ( r - m)}{\delta } + \frac{i \cos\theta}{\sin^2\theta } \right ] \partial_\varphi -\left(4 \cot^2\theta + 2 \right)\biggr\}\psi=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath49 is the mass of the black hole , @xmath50 its angular momentum per unit mass ( which is zero in our case ) , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 . evolving the initial data we just calculated , with this equation will enable us to extract gravity wave waveforms that correspond to the late stage merger of spinning holes . we can also estimate the energy carried away by these gravitational waves . the radiated energy is given by @xcite , @xmath53 note that the angular momentum radiated in the cases we consider is zero . in this section we show waveforms and plots for energy radiated from the collision of two spinning holes . recall that the two holes have equal mass and equal and opposite spin , and we are considering two cases , _ case i _ in which the spins are aligned along the common axis of the two holes , and _ case ii _ in which the two spins are perpendicular to the common axis of the two holes . the waveforms that follow , are for a collision of two black holes that were initially separated by a conformal distance of @xmath54 and had an individual spin of @xmath55 in units of adm mass . in figure [ waveformi ] we show the @xmath56 mode of the teukolsky function for a _ case i _ collision . we see the typical quasi - normal ringing , in both the real and imaginary parts of the function . in figure [ waveformii ] we plot the @xmath56 mode of the teukolsky function for a _ case ii _ collision . note that the initial data is purely real for this case , hence the imaginary part of the waveform is identically zero . quasi - normal ringing is self - evident here as well . this is the type of signal that gravity wave observatories like ligo , will detect if they happen to witness a collision of the kind we are considering . let us turn now to the evaluation of the radiated energies for these two cases . figure [ energy ] shows the radiated energy as a function of the initial spin , for a fixed separation of the holes . the first noteworthy thing is that the two curves , corresponding to _ case i _ and _ case ii _ are very close to each other throughout . this indicates that the geometry of the initial configuration does not matter much as far as energy loss is concerned . but , it should be observed that for any spin @xmath0 , _ case i _ radiates more than _ case ii_. the next important observation ( by looking at the trend of the curves for large spin ) is that , even for high values of the initial spin of the two holes this type of collision radiates less than @xmath57 of its total mass . this means that inclusion of spin does _ not _ dramatically change our original estimate @xcite @xcite of a percent of the mass - energy being carried away by gravity waves in binary black hole inspiral . we performed a first order , perturbative calculation to study the merger of two spinning holes . the exhaustive cases considered had holes with spins either aligned or perpendicular to the common axis of the two holes . for these cases we extracted waveforms and estimated energy radiated . we observed that in the case in which the spins of the two holes are perpendicular to the common axis , the system radiates a little less than the case in which the spins are along the common axis . in either case , the energy radiated appears to be a fraction of a percent of the total mass of the system . since we know that the late stage inspiral of two non - spinning holes typically radiates about a percent of the mass - energy @xcite @xcite this implies that adding spin to the holes does nt really change such estimates by much . with these results ( along with our earlier ones @xcite ) we can predict the properties of the gravity waves radiated from the ringdown phase of the slow inspiral of two spinning , equal mass black holes . the author is grateful for research support and equipment from long island university . part of this work was done at the pennsylvania state university with support from nsf grants phy-9800973 and phy-9423950 . the author thanks j. pullin , p. laguna , r. gleiser , d. cartin , d. arnold and l. smolin for comments and suggestions .

in this paper we consider the collision of spinning holes using first order perturbation theory of black holes ( teukolsky formalism ) . with these results ( along with ones , published in the past ) one can predict the properties of the gravitational waves radiated from the late stage inspiral of two spinning , equal mass black holes . also we note that the energy radiated by the head - on collision of two spinning holes with spins ( that are equal and opposite ) aligned along the common axis is more than the case in which the spins are perpendicular to the axis of the collision .

physics0611243

the dynamics of a non - equilibrium system often results in highly complicated domain structures ( microstructures ) . typically , as time proceeds , the average size of these structures grows as a direct consequence of free - energy reduction : the interface is eliminated resulting in an increase in the size of homogeneous regions . traditional non - equilibrium dynamics usually deals with the equilibrium states that are spatially uniform @xcite , i.e. , the stable phases are characterized by homogeneous values for the appropriate intensive thermodynamic variables . classic , albeit quite simple , examples of models governing the evolution of such systems are the cahn - hilliard ( ch ) equation for conserved systems @xcite and allen - cahn ( ac ) equation for non - conserved systems @xcite . examples are found in polymer mixtures @xcite , alloys @xcite , liquid - crystals @xcite , and in cosmology @xcite . a model that has generated considerable recent interest is the phase field crystal ( pfc ) equation @xcite , which is a conservative form of the familiar , non - conserved , swift - hohenberg ( sh ) equation @xcite . these systems differ from the ch and ac systems in that the stable phase is periodic . for sh models , the order parameter is viewed as capturing the inhomogeneities in a fluid associated with rayleigh - bnard convection . in the case of the pfc model , which is a simple version of more elaborate density functional theories of liquid / crystal interfaces @xcite , the model captures features at the atomic scale , and thus contains highly detailed physical information about the system s structure . such models can describe many of the basic properties of polycrystalline materials that are realized during non - equilibrium processing . the equations of motion governing these non - equilibrium phenomena are non - linear partial differential equations that can not generally be solved analytically for random initial conditions . therefore , computer simulations play an essential role in our understanding and characterization of non - equilibrium phenomena . the standard euler integration is known to be unstable for time step @xmath0 above a threshold fixed by lattice spacing @xmath1 @xcite . in ch and ac systems , to maintain an interfacial profile , the lattice spacing must be smaller than the interfacial width @xmath2 , and in pfc and sh systems , @xmath1 must smaller than the periodicity selected by the system . thus , the euler update is inefficient , and in practice it is computationally costly to use to evolve large systems . various computational algorithms @xcite have been developed by increasing @xmath3 compared to the simplest euler discretization . however , these methods still require a fixed time step , so they eventually become inefficient . recently , unconditionally stable algorithms @xcite were developed to overcome this difficulty for ch and ac equations . these algorithms are a class of stable algorithms free of the fixed time step constraint for equations with a mix of implicit and explicit terms . while these algorithms allow for an increasing time step in ch systems as time proceeds , only a finite effective time step is possible for ac systems . a recent study @xcite , based on this unconditionally stable algorithm , demonstrated analytically that one can use an accelerated algorithm @xmath4 to drive the ch equation , with the accuracy in correlation controlled by @xmath5 . in this manuscript we apply this unconditionally stable algorithm to the pfc and sh equations ( section @xmath6 ) . in section @xmath7 we establish the effectiveness of this approach through numerical studies of the algorithm , demonstrating that the algorithm is both efficient and accurate for solving pfc equation . finally , in section @xmath8 we provide some concluding remarks . in this section , we develop a class of unconditionally stable time stepping algorithms ( @xmath3 taken arbitrarily large without the solution becoming unstable ) to the pfc and sh equations . although the main purpose of this section is to study unconditionally stable algorithms for the pfc equation , we include a parallel discussion of the sh equation , as the methodology applies to both equations with only trivial differences . both the pfc and sh equations start from a free energy functional that describes the configurational cost of periodic phases in contact with isotropic phases , and can be expressed as @xmath9=\int d\vx \left\{\frac{1}{2 } \phi\left[r + ( 1 + \nabla^2)^2\right]\phi + \frac{\phi^4}{4}\right\ } , \label{eq : pfcbasic}\ ] ] where the periodic order parameter @xmath10 has the wave number @xmath11 in equilibrium , and @xmath12 characterizes the quench depth . for the pfc equation , @xmath13 is proportional to the deviation of the temperature from the melting temperature @xmath14 . in the pfc model the order parameter ( the density ) is conserved , and thus the equation of motion is in the form of a continuity equation , @xmath15 , with current @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is the mobility . absorbing @xmath17 into the time scale , we obtain the dimensionless form of the pfc equation @xmath18\phi + \phi^3\right\}. \label{eq : eq_of_motion : pfc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the sh equation , on the other hand , the order parameter is not conserved by the dynamics , and its evolution is postulated to have the the form @xmath19\phi - \phi^3 . \label{eq : eq_of_motion : sh}\end{aligned}\ ] ] eq . ( [ eq : eq_of_motion : sh ] ) has a simple dissipative form , where the rate of change of @xmath20 is proportional to the gradient ( with an an @xmath21 inner product in functional space ) of the free energy . in order to obtain an unconditionally stable algorithm , we now follow methods previously developed for the ch and ac equations @xcite , and work out in some detail how to semi - implicitly parameterize the equation of motion . we begin by `` splitting '' the linear terms in the equation of motion into `` forward '' and `` backward '' pieces , both for eq . ( [ eq : eq_of_motion : pfc ] ) : @xmath22 \nonumber \\ = & & \phi_t+\dt \grad^2 \left[a_1(r+1 ) \phi_t+2a_2 \nabla^2 \phi_t+a_3\nabla^4 \phi_t + \phi_t^3 \right ] , \label{eq : semi_implicit : pfc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and for eq . ( [ eq : eq_of_motion : sh ] ) : @xmath23 \nonumber \\ = & & \phi_t-\dt \left[a_1(r+1 ) \phi_t+2a_2 \nabla^2 \phi_t+a_3\nabla^4 \phi_t + \phi_t^3 \right ] . \label{eq : semi_implicit : sh}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the constants @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 control the degree of splitting . in order to find the constraints on these parameters that yield an unconditionally stable algorithms , a standard von neumann linear stability analysis on eq . ( [ eq : semi_implicit : pfc ] ) and eq . ( [ eq : semi_implicit : sh ] ) may be performed . the procedures are quite similar and the results are identical for these two equations . we will only show the details for the pfc model in next subsection . as was found in the analysis of vollmayr - lee and rutenberg @xcite for the ch equation , the pfc equation will be linearly unstable to perturbations for legitimate physical reasons . specifically , the isotropic phase @xmath27 can be metastable or unstable to the stable periodic ( crystalline ) phase @xcite if the system is an undercooled liquid . this situation ( which is precisely what we are interested in modeling ) is established when @xmath28 . this _ physical instability _ complicates our standard von neumann stability analysis , as we wish to predict when our numerical methods will cause an instability that is unrelated to the physical instability resulting from the thermodynamic . we can investigate the physical instability by a linear stability analysis on the equation of motion eq . ( [ eq : eq_of_motion : pfc ] ) . we let @xmath29 , where @xmath27 is a constant phase and @xmath30 is a small perturbation , and linearize the pfc equation eq . ( [ eq : eq_of_motion : pfc ] ) in @xmath30 to get @xmath31\eta_t . \end{aligned}\ ] ] this can be fourier transformed to find @xmath32 \eta_{\vk , t}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the physical instability for the above equation occurs for @xmath33<0 , \label{eq : physical_instability}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which reduces to @xmath28 with @xmath34 in the stable phase , as we indicated above . now we can proceed to analyze the _ numerical stability _ and determine the constraints for the splitting parameters . we linearize the general step eq . ( [ eq : semi_implicit : pfc ] ) by substituting @xmath29 and get @xmath35 \nonumber \\ = & & \eta_t+\dt \grad^2\left[a_1(r+1 ) \eta_t+2a_2 \nabla^2 \eta_t+a_3\nabla^4 \eta_t + 3\bar{\phi}^2 \eta _ t \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] the fourier transform of the above equation results in @xmath36 \nonumber \\ = & & \eta_{\vk , t}\left[1-\dt k^2 \ { a_1(r+1)-2a_2 k^2+a_3 k^4 + 3\bar{\phi}^2 \ } \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] this can be re - expressed as @xmath37=\eta_{\vk , t}[1+\dt \mathcal{r}_\vk].\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath38 . while we want to avoid numerical instability , the physical instability is to be expected during the dynamics , and will not lead to numerical problems . but , as we indicated above , both of the instabilities will be captured by a general von neumann stability analysis . one manner of dealing with this is to recognize that a proper unconditionally stable algorithm will be stable if and only if @xmath39 and should be unstable if and only if @xmath40 . the von neumann stability criterion is @xmath41 ^ 2 & > & \left[1+\dt\mathcal{r}_\vk\right]^2 \quad\mathrm{for}\ \mathbf{r_k}>0 \nonumber\\ \left[1+\dt \mathcal{l}_\vk\right]^2 & < & \left[1+\dt\mathcal{r}_\vk\right]^2 \quad\mathrm{for}\ \mathbf{r_k}<0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the above inequalities can be rewritten as @xmath42&>&0 \quad\mathrm{for}\ \mathbf{r_k}>0 \nonumber\\ \mathbf{r_k}\left[2+\dt(\mathcal{l}_\vk+\mathcal{r}_\vk)\right]&<&0 \quad\mathrm{for}\ \mathbf{r_k}<0 \nonumber , \label{eq : von_neumann}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which , dividing by @xmath43 can be reduced to a single inequality , @xmath44 , which implies @xmath45 for arbitrarily large @xmath3 , and we obtain @xmath46,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which can be satisfied using the mode independent restrictions ( and @xmath47 ) @xmath48 these are the constraints on the parameters @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 for unconditionally stable algorithms for all modes , for quenches in the range @xmath49 . with these choices there is no threshold for @xmath3 in order to maintain numerical stability . the quantity @xmath3 is termed the _ algorithmic time step_. we note that unconditional stability does not mean that the user of such algorithms may simply take as large a time step as is desired . indeed , to obtain accurate physical results , there are additional restrictions on how large @xmath3 may be . to determine how large a time step we may take , and still maintain an accurate solution , we calculate the fourier space `` effective time step '' , as will be described below . we first note that when @xmath50 , eq . ( [ eq : semi_implicit : pfc ] ) corresponds to the traditional euler update @xmath51\phi_t + \phi_t^3\right\ } , \label{eq : pfc - euler - update}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath52 denotes the field obtained after an euler update on a previous field @xmath53 , while we use the unprimed @xmath54 to denote the field obtained by unconditionally stable algorithm on @xmath53 throughout . we now define the spatial fourier transform of @xmath55 . in fourier space , writing @xmath56 , the euler update becomes @xmath57\phi_{\vk , t } + ( \phi^3)_{\vk , t}\right\ } , \label{eq : pfc - euler - fourier}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath58 . in fourier space , the unconditionally stable algorithms eq . ( [ eq : semi_implicit : pfc ] ) can be written in a form that is analogous to eq . ( [ eq : pfc - euler - fourier ] ) : @xmath59\phi_{\vk , t } + ( \phi^3)_{\vk , t}\right\ } , \label{eq : pfc - fourier}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we define @xmath60-dependent effective time step by @xmath61 } \label{eq : dteff : pfc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for sh equation , the effective time step is @xmath62}. \label{eq : dteff : sh}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath63 is an effective time step for a mode @xmath60 , corresponding to an algorithmic time step @xmath3 . of particular interest in the case of periodic systems is the dominant mode ( the lattice spacing in the pfc model ) , which , for the scaling choices made in eq . ( [ eq : eq_of_motion : pfc ] ) and eq . ( [ eq : eq_of_motion : sh ] ) is simply @xmath64 . using the parameters employed in the simulations shown in the next section of @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , we obtain the dominant effective time step for both equations @xmath69 as @xmath70 , we obtain the maximum dominant effective time step @xmath71 . we see that a large algorithmic time step @xmath3 does not always translate into a significant amount of system evolution , as the effective time step always remains less than 28 for these parameter choices , no matter how large the algorithmic time step becomes . thus , this value provides us with a useful bound on our exploration of just how large an algorithmic time step to take , and still obtain accurate results . for example , if we take algorithmic time steps that yields an effective time step @xmath72 , then we find @xmath73 . we demonstrate in the next section that this algorithm , when applied to the pfc equation , realizes a significant speedup compared to the traditional euler algorithm , while maintaining a controlled level of accuracy . the second to bottom rows show the fields obtained employing the unconditionally stable algorithms , when using algorithmic time steps of @xmath74 , @xmath75 , and @xmath76.,width=510 ] the simulations were performed in two - dimensions . [ fig : system_snapshots ] shows typical snapshots of simulations for the pfc model with parameters @xmath77 , @xmath78 , and @xmath79 with random initial conditions which corresponds to the liquid state . for comparison , all the simulations start with the same initial condition . in the figure white regions indicate @xmath80 , red @xmath81 and blue @xmath82 . the top row was obtained using the euler algorithm @xmath83 at time steps @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 , and @xmath87 . the second and lower rows were obtained using the unconditionally stable algorithm with ( moving down ) @xmath74 , @xmath75 , and @xmath76 . for illustration and comparison purposes , we show the system snapshots at the same energy density as the top row from left , the energy density @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 , and @xmath91 from the first to fourth column , respectively . we immediately see that , for the times and energies selected , there are no visible differences between the euler update simulation and the unconditionally stable algorithm with @xmath74 . however , there are visible differences between the euler update and the simulations with @xmath92 . we now wish to make these qualitative observations more quantitative . versus the algorithmic time step @xmath3.,width=453 ] to study the accuracy , we compare simulations at the same energy density @xmath88 ( the first column in fig . [ fig : system_snapshots ] ) . we compute a measure of the error : @xmath93 , where @xmath94 denotes the fields obtained using euler algorithm and @xmath95 denotes the fields obtained using the unconditionally stable algorithm . [ fig : error ] shows a plot of the error versus a range of algorithmic time steps @xmath3 . [ fig : error ] indicates that , unsurprisingly , the accuracy increases as we decrease the algorithmic time step @xmath3 . when @xmath96 , the error is below @xmath97 . on the other hand , the error behavior in fig . [ fig : error ] for a large algorithmic time step tends to saturate , mirroring the saturation in the effective time step @xmath98 for the dominant mode @xmath64 . [ fig : eff_timestep ] shows a comparison between the dominant effective time step @xmath99 in eq . ( [ eq : dominant - dteff : pfc ] ) and a numerical estimate of the same quantity . the numerical estimate is obtained by calculating @xmath100 , where @xmath101 is the total time needed to reach the final state ( a crystalline state without dislocations ) using euler algorithm and @xmath102 is the number of computer steps needed to reach the same state using unconditionally stable algorithms . we find good agreement for @xmath103 , while for @xmath92 , the separation between the analytic and numerical expressions increases . while the agreement at small times steps in unsurprising , the curve provides a useful metric for the optimum algorithmic time step of @xmath104 , for the chosen parameters . when @xmath74 , the ratio of the number of time steps needed to achieve a particular energy using the unconditionally stable versus euler algorithm is approximately @xmath105 ( the ratio of the dominant mode effective time step to the euler time step ) . this is a substantial speedup , and requires minimal analysis to implement the technique . in this paper , we have presented an unconditionally stable algorithm applicable to finite difference solutions of the the pfc equation . we have demonstrated that a fixed algorithmic time step driving scheme may provide significant speedup , with a controlled level of accuracy , when compared with euler algorithm . for the representative parameters chosen , a speedup of a factor of 180 was obtained . the analytical results and the numerical results are consistent with an effective time step analysis . although this algorithm allows arbitrarily large algorithmic time steps , caution is indicated , as taking too large an algorithmic time step will yield inaccuracies with little improvement in the overall speedup of the calculation . this saturation in the speedup results from the details of how the system s energy evolution ( and its corresponding microstructural evolution ) is governed by the effective time step , which saturates as the algorithmic time step increases . thus , there is little advantage in too large an algorithmic time step . a method for obtaining a reasonable value for the algorithmic time step @xmath3 is suggested , in which a few test cases are run with different values of @xmath3 to see which one offers a good speedup and maintains the desired accuracy . the analytic form of the effective time step provides a useful guide for deciding how large a time step to select when trading off the obtainable speedup versus the loss of accuracy . we expect the methodology developed in this paper could find extensive applications in a wide class of non - equilibrium systems . for example , it can be straightforwardly applied to the swift - hohenberg equation , given its similarity with the phase field crystal model . additionally , the method also will apply to systems where there is a dominant mode realized at late times , such as is found in diblock co - polymers . this method should allow researchers to dramatically improve the computational efficiency associated with modeling the dynamics of materials systems . we thank andrew reid and daniel wheeler for useful discussions . j. s. langer , in _ solids far from equilibrium _ , edited by c. godrche ( cambridge university press , 1992 ) , pp . a. j. bray , theory of phase - ordering kinetics , adv . phys . * 43 * , 357 ( 1994 ) . j. d. gunton , m. san miguel and p. s. sahni , in _ phase transitions and critical phenomena _ , vol . 8 , edited by c. domb and j. l. lebowitz ( new york academic press , 1983 ) pp . 267 . h. furukawa , dynamic scaling assumption for phase separation , adv . * 34 * , 703 ( 1985 ) . j. w. cahn and j. e. hilliard , free energy of a nonuniform system . i. interface free energy , j. chem . * 28 * , 258 ( 1958 ) . s. m. allen and j. w. cahn , a microscopic theory for antiphase boundary motion and its application to antiphase domain coarsening , acta metall . * 27 * , 1085 ( 1979 ) . p. wiltzius and a. cumming , domain growth and wetting in polymer mixtures , phys lett . * 66 * , 3000 ( 1991 ) . r. f. shannon , s. e. nagler , c. r. harkless and r. m. nicklow , time - resolved x - ray - scattering study of ordering kinetics in bulk single - crystal cu@xmath106au , phys . b * 46 * , 40 ( 1992 ) . b. d. gaulin , s. spooner and y. morii , kinetics of phase separation in mn@xmath107cu@xmath108 , phys . lett . * 59 * , 668 ( 1987 ) . n. mason , a. n. pargellis and b. yurke , scaling behavior of two - time correlations in a twisted nematic liquid crystal , phys . lett . * 70 * , 190 ( 1993 ) . i. chuang , n. turok and b. yurke , late - time coarsening dynamics in a nematic liquid crystal , phys lett . * 66 * , 2472 ( 1991 ) . laguna and w. h. zurek , density of kinks after a quench : when symmetry breaks , how big are the pieces ? , phys . lett . * 78 * , 2519 ( 1997 ) . k. r. elder , m. katakowski , m. haataja , and m. grant , modeling elasticity in crystal growth , phys . lett . * 88 * , 245701 ( 2002 ) . k. r. elder and m. grant , modeling elastic and plastic deformations in nonequilibrium processing using phase field crystals , phys . e * 70 * , 051605 ( 2004 ) . j. swift and p. c. hohenberg , hydrodynamic fluctuations at the convective instability , phys . a * 15 * , 319 ( 1977 ) . w. h. shih , z. q. wang , x. c. zeng , and d. stroud , ginzburg - landau theory for the solid - liquid interface of bcc elements , phys . a * 35 * , 2611 ( 1987 ) . wu , a. karma , j. j. hoyt , and m. asta , ginzburg - landau theory of crystalline anisotropy for bcc - liquid interfaces , phys . b * 73 * , 094101 ( 2006 ) . t. m. rogers , k. r. elder and r. c. desai , numerical study of the late stages of spinodal decomposition , phys . b * 37 * , 9638 ( 1988 ) . y. oono and s. puri , study of phase - separation dynamics by use of cell dynamical systems . i. modeling , phys . a * 38 * , 434 ( 1998 ) . l. q. chen and j. shen , applications of semi - implicit fourier - spectral method to phase field equations , comput . * 108 * , 147 ( 1998 ) . j. zhu , l. q. chen , j. shen and v. tikare , coarsening kinetics from a variable - mobility cahn - hilliard equation : application of a semi - implicit fourier spectral method , phys . e * 60 * , 3564 ( 1999 ) . d. j. eyre , in _ computational and mathematical models of microstructural evolution _ , edited by j. w. bullard _ et al . _ ( the material research society , warrendale , pa , 1998 ) , pp . vollmayr - lee and a. d. rutenberg , fast and accurate coarsening simulation with an unconditionally stable time step , phys . e * 68 * , 66703 ( 2003 ) . m. cheng and a. d. rutenberg , maximally fast coarsening algorithms , phys . rev . e * 72 * , 055701(r ) ( 2005 ) . m. cheng and j. a. warren , controlling the accuracy of unconditionally stable algorithms in cahn - hilliard equation , cond - mat/0609354 .

we present and discuss the development of an unconditionally stable algorithm used to solve the evolution equations of the phase field crystal ( pfc ) model . this algorithm allows for an arbitrarily large algorithmic time step . as the basis for our analysis of the accuracy of this algorithm , we determine an effective time step in fourier space . we then compare our calculations with a set of representative numerical results , and demonstrate that this algorithm is an effective approach for the study of the pfc models , yielding a time step effectively 180 times larger than the euler algorithm for a representative set of material parameters . as the pfc model is just a simple example of a wide class of density functional theories , we expect this method will have wide applicability to modeling systems of considerable interest to the materials modeling communities . and unconditionally stable , phase field crystal model 05.10.-a , 02.60.cb , 64.75.+g , 81.15.aa

astro-ph9803235

early - type galaxies in clusters exhibit a linear color - magnitude ( cm ) relation indicating that bright galaxies are systematically redder than their faint cluster companions ( visvanathan & sandage 1977 ) . this remarkable relation shows very small scatter ( @xmath3 magnitude ) in high precision photometry of local clusters such as coma and virgo ( bower , lucey & ellis 1992a , 1992b , hereafter ble92 ) and can be extended to clusters at medium - to - high redshift ( @xmath4 ) ( ellis et al 1997 , stanford , eisenhardt & dickinson 1998 ) . a first attempt at explaining the universality of the cm relation involves using the age of each galaxy as the main determinant of its color . ageing stellar populations redden progressively as stars with decreasing initial mass evolve off the main sequence . therefore , if the colors of cluster galaxies are purely controlled by age , the small scatter about the cm relation implies a nearly synchronous star formation process for all galaxies of a given mass , while the slope of the cm relation implies systematically older ages for more massive galaxies . as shown most recently by kodama & arimoto ( 1997 ) , such a picture is highly unlikely because it does not preserve the slope nor the magnitude range of the cm relation in time . another important factor that affects the colors of stellar populations is metallicity . at fixed age , a more metal - rich stellar population will appear redder and fainter than a more metal - poor one ( e.g. , worthey 1994 ) . hence , increasing metallicity at fixed age has a similar effect on colors as increasing age at fixed metallicity . this is usually referred to as the _ age - metallicity degeneracy _ ( worthey 1994 ) . several studies have shown that cm relation of cluster elliptical galaxies could be primarily driven by metallicity effects ( larson 1974 ; matteuci & tornamb 1987 ; arimoto & yoshii 1987 ; bressan , chiosi & tantalo 1996 ; kodama & arimoto 1997 ) . the physical mechanism usually involved is that of a galactic wind : supernovae - driven winds are expected to be more efficient in ejecting enriched gas , and hence in preventing more metal - rich stars from forming , in low - mass galaxies than in massive galaxies with deeper potential wells . although age is generally assumed to be the same for all galaxies in these studies , this has not been proven to be an essential requirement . in fact , scenarios in which e / s0 galaxies progressively form by the merging of disk galaxies ( schweizer & seitzer 1992 ) in a universe where structure is built via hierarchical clustering also predict that the cm relation is driven primarily by metallicity effects ( kauffmann & charlot 1998 ) . moreover , age effects could be important if , for example , there is sufficiently strong feedback from early galaxy formation to bias the luminous mass distribution of subsequent generations of galaxies by the heating of intergalactic gas . in this paper we present a new , more model - independent approach for evaluating the full range of ages and metallicities allowed by the spectro - photometric properties of early - type galaxies in clusters . the method is based on the construction of age - metallicity diagrams constrained by the colors of early - type galaxies in the nearby coma cluster and in 17 clusters observed with the _ hubble space telescope _ ( _ hst _ ) at redshifts up to @xmath5 ( stanford et al . such an analysis has hitherto been hindered because of the lack of both accurate stellar libraries for different metallicities and reliable morphological information on cluster galaxies at medium - to - high redshifts . our results can subsequently be reframed into specific theories of galaxy formation , since they will be indispensable for any model that seeks to produce galaxies resembling those actually observed . in 2 we present the spectral evolution models used in this paper . the cluster sample is described in 3 . in 4 we construct the age - metallicity diagrams allowed by the observations , and in 5 we compute the corresponding ranges in mass - to - light ratio and in several commonly used spectral indices . we discuss our main conclusions in 6 . we compute the spectral evolution of early - type galaxies using the latest version of the bruzual & charlot ( 1998 ) models of stellar population synthesis . these span the range of metallicities @xmath6 and include all phases of stellar evolution , from the zero - age main sequence to supernova explosions for progenitors more massive than @xmath7 , or to the end of the white dwarf cooling sequence for less massive progenitors . in addition , the models predict the strengths of 21 stellar absorption features computed using the worthey et al . ( 1994 ) analytic fitting functions for index strength as a function of stellar temperature , gravity and metallicity . this constitutes the standard `` lick / ids '' system that is often used as a basis for spectral diagnostics in early - type galaxies . the resulting model spectra computed for stellar populations of various ages and metallicities have been checked against observed spectra of star clusters and galaxies ( bruzual et al . 1997 ; bruzual & charlot 1998 ) . the uncertainties in the models are discussed in charlot , worthey & bressan ( 1996 ) . these can reach up to 0.05 mag in rest - frame @xmath8 , 0.25 mag in rest - frame @xmath9 and a 25% dispersion in the @xmath10-band mass - to - light ratio . with these uncertainties in mind , we will concentrate more on understanding the trends seen in the observations than on inferring absolute age and metallicity values . it is worth noting that the most massive elliptical galaxies exhibit [ mg / fe ] ratios in excess of that found in the most metal - rich stars in the solar neighborhood ( by @xmath11 dex ; see worthey , faber , & gonzalez 1992 ) . while this may limit the accuracy of the predicted mg@xmath12 indices of bright elliptical galaxies , the recent models of bressan et al . ( 1998 ) convincingly show that an enhancement in light elements at fixed total metallicity has virtually no effect on the other spectrophotometric properties of model stellar populations . we approximate model early - type galaxies by instantaneous - burst stellar populations . the reason for this is that we aim at constraining the age and metallicity ranges of stars dominating the light of early - type galaxies , whose photometric properties are well represented by instantaneous - burst populations . in fact , this is true even if the galaxies underwent subsequent small amounts of star formation or if the epoch of major star formation was extended over several billion years ( e.g. , fig . 1 of charlot & silk 1994 ) . the predicted colors of our models at fixed age and metallicity agree well with the results of more refined calculations including the effects of infall and galactic winds for corresponding values of the mean age and metallicity ( kodama & arimoto 1997 , bressan , chiosi & tantalo 1996 ) . for example , adopting metallicities matching the luminosity weighted metallicities @xmath13 in table 2 of kodama & arimoto yields @xmath14 and @xmath9 colors that agree to better than 0.05 mag with the results from these authors at an age of 15 gyr . such a discrepancy is well within the errors of current population synthesis models ( charlot et al . 1996 ) . in the remainder of the present paper , the initial mass function ( imf ) is taken from scalo ( 1986 ) and is truncated at 0.1 and 100@xmath15 . we use the above models to compute the locations in the age metallicity diagram of stellar populations satisfying specified spectro - photometric properties . figure 1 shows four such age metallicity diagrams corresponding to imposed values of the @xmath14 and @xmath9 colors and mg@xmath16 and h@xmath17 spectral indices . these quantities are chosen here because they can be constrained by many observations of early - type galaxies ( 3 and 5 ) . in each panel , the models satisfying the same value of the spectro - photometric property of interest are related by a continuous line , different lines corresponding to different imposed values . with this definition , the slope of a line in the age metallicity diagrams indicates the relative sensitivity of the color or index under consideration to age and metallicity . vertical lines would correspond to a sensitivity purely to age , and horizontal lines to a sensitivity purely to metallicity . figure 1 then shows immediately that the @xmath14 and @xmath9 colors and mg@xmath16 index depend more strongly on metallicity than on age , while the h@xmath17 index depends more strongly on age than on metallicity . we will return to this point in 4 and 5 . the relative dependence of the spectro - photometric properties of instantaneous - burst populations on age and metallicity has been previously investigated by worthey ( 1994 ) . he used the parameter @xmath18 at fixed color or index to represent the ratio of the change @xmath19 in age needed to counterbalance a change @xmath20 in metallicity in order to keep that color or index unchanged . the difference between worthey s and our approach is that he computed a single effective value of @xmath18 for each spectro - photometric property , while the different lines in figure 1 show the behavior of the @xmath18 slope for different values of the color or index under consideration . for comparison , the arrow in each panel of figure 1 indicates the @xmath21 vector obtained by worthey ( 1994 ) . in each case , the general agreement with the mean slope of the lines is good . table 1 gives a more quantitative comparison between worthey s ( 1994 ) and our results . we computed linear fits to all lines in figure 1 and then a linear fit between the derived slopes and their corresponding color or index value . the slopes and zero points of these relations for each spectro - photometric property are listed in columns ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) of table 1 . we then evaluated @xmath18 for four values of the @xmath14 and @xmath9 colors ( and corresponding model predictions for the mg@xmath16 and h@xmath17 indices ) matching the properties of early - type galaxies at four magnitudes @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath24 and @xmath25 along the local cm relation ( ble92 ; see 3 ) . the agreement with worthey s ( 1994 ) predictions is seen to be of the order of @xmath26 % . it is worth noting that our generalized fits deviate significantly from worthey s `` 3/2 rule '' which takes the @xmath27 ratio to be 1.5 for any color . c|cc|cccc|c property & slope & zero point & @xmath28= 17.5 & @xmath28= 19.0 & @xmath28= 20.5 & @xmath28= 22.0 & worthey + [ @xmath14 ] & 0.444 & 0.653 & 1.19 & 1.24 & 1.30 & 1.35 & 1.5 [ @xmath9 ] & 0.886 & @xmath311.004 & 1.59 & 1.69 & 1.79 & 1.89 & 1.9 [ mg@xmath16 ] & 0.118 & 0.976 & 1.33 & 1.36 & 1.40 & 1.45 & 1.7 [ h@xmath17 ] & @xmath310.092 & 0.645 & 0.47 & 0.48 & 0.49 & 0.50 & 0.6 observational constraints on the photometric properties of early - type galaxies are taken from the recent sample of stanford , eisenhardt & dickinson ( 1998 ) . the sample consists of 19 clusters in the redshift range @xmath34 . these were extracted on the basis of available _ hst _ imaging from a larger , heterogeneous sample of 46 clusters drawn from a variety of optical , x - ray and radio - selected samples . the 19 clusters studied by stanford et al . ( 1998 ) were imaged in the near infrared @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 passbands . exposure times in all passbands were chosen to achieve 5-@xmath38 detection of objects with the spectral energy distribution of an unevolved present - day elliptical galaxy down to 2 mag fainter than @xmath39 ( corresponding to an apparent limiting magnitude @xmath40 and 20.0 at @xmath41 and 0.895 , respectively ) . for 17 out of these 19 clusters , photometry is also available in two optical passbands , referred to as _ blue _ and _ red _ , that were tuned as a function of redshift to span the 4000 break in the galaxy rest frame spectra . this subsample of 17 clusters is of considerable interest to us because it sets the most useful constraints on the spectral properties of galaxies . stanford et al . morphologically classified the galaxies in these clusters on the basis of _ hst _ wide field and planetary camera 2 ( wfpc2 ) images . they did not attempt to distinguish between e and s0 galaxies , and for the purpose of the present analysis we also consider these galaxy types together as a single early - type class . table 2 lists the name , redshift , _ blue _ and _ red _ passbands and number of e / s0 galaxies for each of the 17 clusters in the sample . on the average , cluster membership is expected to be secure for over 85% of the e / s0 galaxies in the sample , as estimated either from morphologically - dependent number counts or from statistical field corrections ( see stanford et al . 1998 for a thorough analysis ) . furthermore , all clusters exhibit a tight cm relation with a slope showing no significant change out to @xmath5 . this has been taken as evidence that all galaxies shared a common history of star formation ( stanford et al . 1998 ; kodama et al . 1998 ; but see kauffmann & charlot 1998 ) . we note that there is an open question about the membership of some morphologically - selected early - type galaxies with faint magnitudes and colors far bluer than the cm relation in the clusters ( e.g. , kodama et al . this can be appreciated most readily from deep _ hst _ wfpc2 imaging by ellis et al . ( 1997 ) of three of the clusters in table 2 , f1557.19tc , cl 0016 + 16 and j1888.16cl . although these faint ( @xmath42 ) galaxies may be field contaminants , for completeness we should not abandon the possibility that they are blue cluster early - type galaxies that violate the cm relation . thus , they are also included in our analysis . it is worth pointing out that stanford et al . ( 1998 ) find no significant difference between the photometric properties of early - type galaxies in clusters of different richness or x - ray luminosity at a similar redshift . while this finding does not necessarily imply that all early - type galaxies were assembled early ( kauffmann & charlot 1998 ) , it strongly supports analyses like the one presented in 4 in which constraints on photometric evolution are drawn from comparisons of the properties of galaxies in clusters at different redshifts . also , to avoid any bias near the bright end of the cm relation , we have checked that the brightest cluster galaxies in the sample of table 2 match the @xmath37-band absolute luminosity versus redshift relation published by aragn - salamanca et al . ( 1998 ) . finally , to tighten the models at @xmath43 , we use the cm relation derived by ble92 for e / s0 galaxies in the coma cluster . this takes the forms @xmath44 and @xmath45 , with standard deviations of 0.055 mag and 0.065 mag in @xmath14 and @xmath9 colors , respectively . to define the absolute magnitude scale of the models , the recession velocity of the coma cluster is taken to be @xmath46 km s@xmath47 ( han & mould 1992 ) . we adopt @xmath48 km sec@xmath47mpc@xmath47 and @xmath49 , except when otherwise indicated . the distance modulus to the coma cluster is therefore 35.41 mag . the small scatter of the cm relation at fixed luminosity has been used by ble92 to constrain the age range of early - type galaxies in clusters ( see also ellis et al . they computed the maximum spread in star - formation epoch allowed by the observed scatter in @xmath14 color according to the rate of color change @xmath50 predicted by population synthesis models . the basis of this argument can be understood from figure 2 . the top panel shows the @xmath14 color evolution of a stellar population in the time interval @xmath51 $ ] as a function of age @xmath52 for several metallicities , while the bottom panel shows the inferred @xmath50 evolution as a function of @xmath52 . since @xmath50 decreases with model age @xmath52 , ble92 found that the older the galaxies , the larger the allowed spread in star - formation epoch . on the basis of this analysis , ble92 favored a major star - formation epoch at @xmath53 for early - type galaxies in clusters , spread over a period of roughly 1 gyr . it is crucial to realize that ble92 s argument utilizing @xmath50 is based on the _ a priori _ requirement that at fixed luminosity , all early - type galaxies in the cm relation have the same metallicity . in fact , the analysis was conducted using population synthesis models for uniquely solar metallicity . as the present paper demonstrates , however , at fixed luminosity the photometric constraints on cluster galaxies allow a wide range of ages and metallicities ( 4 ) . hence , the @xmath54 argument already includes restrictive hypotheses on the ages and metallicities of early - type galaxies with respect to the full allowed ranges . it is not surprising , therefore , that ble92 s conclusions on the epoch of major star formation for early - type galaxies in clusters are unnecessarily constraining when compared to the results of our more complete analysis below . lccccc cluster & @xmath55 & _ blue _ @xmath31 _ red _ & n(e / s0 ) & & & ac 118 & 0.308 & @xmath56 & 38 ac 103 & 0.311 & @xmath56 & 32 ms 2137.3 - 234 & 0.313 & @xmath56 & 21 cl 2244 - 02 & 0.330 & @xmath56 & 24 cl 0024 + 16 & 0.391 & @xmath56 & 39 gho 0303 + 1706 & 0.418 & @xmath56 & 38 3c 295 & 0.461 & @xmath57 & 25 f1557.19tc & 0.510 & @xmath57 & 29 gho 1601 + 4253 & 0.539 & @xmath57 & 42 ms 0451.6 - 0306 & 0.539 & @xmath57 & 51 cl 0016 + 16 & 0.545 & @xmath57 & 65 j1888.16cl & 0.560 & @xmath57 & 38 3c 220.1 & 0.620 & @xmath57 & 22 3c 34 & 0.689 & @xmath57 & 19 gho 1322 + 3027 & 0.751 & @xmath58 & 23 ms 1054.5 - 032 & 0.828 & @xmath58 & 71 gho 1603 + 4313 & 0.895 & @xmath59 & 23 we now use the models described in 2 and the observational constraints outlined in 3 to compute the regions allowed in age metallicity space for early - type galaxies in clusters . we proceed as follows . we consider each cluster in table 2 , with redshift @xmath55 , and search for all models which can match the photometric properties of galaxies in that cluster at @xmath55 and those of coma galaxies at @xmath43 . in practice , we start by considering models that span a full range of metallicities and with ages at @xmath60 that range between the age of the universe and the lookback time to redshift @xmath55 . out of these models , we select all those matching @xmath14 and @xmath9 colors of galaxies in coma within the scatter of the observed cm relation ( 3 ) . for a set of @xmath14 and @xmath9 colors this defines a range of possible @xmath10 magnitudes . we then compute the predicted apparent @xmath37 magnitudes and _ blue_@xmath61 , _ red_@xmath61 , @xmath62 and @xmath63 colors of the selected models at the cluster redshift @xmath55 . to decide whether a model is acceptable , we compare the predicted photometric properties at @xmath55 with the observations . for this purpose , the observed cm relation of each cluster in table 2 was divided into four apparent @xmath37 magnitude bins , roughly 1 mag wide , allowing good sampling from the brightest to the faintest galaxies ( see 3 ) . for each bin , the standard deviation around the relation was computed in _ blue_@xmath61 , _ red_@xmath61 , @xmath62 and @xmath63 colors . this procedure allows us to account for the increased scatter of the observed cm relations towards fainter magnitudes . a model is retained if it simultaneously falls within @xmath64 of the cm relation in all four colors . the main reason for adopting a @xmath64 criterion is that we must allow for known uncertainties in the spectral evolution models . uncertainties in the predicted optical / infrared color evolution over lookback times of a few billion years can reach a few tenths of a magnitude in current population synthesis models ( charlot et al . this is several times larger than the typical scatter around the cm relation for the clusters of table 2 ( see fig . 5_a _ of stanford et al . 1998 and table 1 of kodama et al . 1998 ) . figures 3_a _ , 3_b _ and 3_c _ show the results of our analysis for the clusters in the redshift ranges @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 , respectively . metallicity space is parameterized in terms of the formation redshift @xmath68 and the iron abundance computed as [ fe / h]@xmath69 , with @xmath70 and @xmath71 . we separate galaxies into four luminosity bins at @xmath43 by defining apparent magnitude bins in coma centered on @xmath72 , 14.25 , 13.5 and 12.75 . these correspond roughly to absolute @xmath10 luminosities @xmath73 , @xmath74 , @xmath75 and @xmath76 , respectively . the four panels in figures 3_a_3_c _ separately show the results for each of the four luminosity bins . at fixed luminosity , figure 3 indicates that the observations of all 17 clusters roughly constrain similar regions in @xmath77})$ ] space . this is a consequence of the similarity of the cm relation among all clusters in the sample . an important discriminant , however , is that the condition @xmath78 allows more recent formation epochs and higher metallicities for galaxies in low - redshift clusters than for those in high - redshift clusters . as expected , different luminosities imply different allowed values of @xmath68 and [ fe / h ] . since faint galaxies on the cm relation are bluer than bright galaxies , they can be modelled on average by more metal - poor , and to some extent younger , stellar populations . we also note that the metallicity range of model galaxies in figure 3 , @xmath79 } \simlt + 0.2 $ ] , compares well with the range observed in nearby e / s0 galaxies ( e.g. , worthey , faber & gonzalez 1992 ) . the upper panel of figure 4 shows the areas corresponding to all four luminosity bins superimposed on a similar diagram for the cluster cl0016 + 16 . this cluster , at @xmath80 , has one of the best - defined cm relations in the sample ( 65 e / s0 galaxies ; see table 2 ) . figure 4 readily shows that a pure age sequence can not account for the photometric properties of early - type galaxies because a single horizontal line can not cross all four areas simultaneously in @xmath81})$ ] space . alternatively , different combinations of age and metallicities can accommodate the data . the simplest assumption of a pure metallicity sequence ( vertical line ) requires that the bulk of stars in galaxies formed at redshifts @xmath53 , otherwise one can not account for the photometric properties of the brightest galaxies . this confirms earlier conclusions by ellis et al . ( 1997 ) based on similar data for cl0016 + 16 . as figure 4 demonstrates , however , there is no requirement that the bulk of stars in all early - type galaxies in this cluster formed at the same epoch . if the most metal - rich galaxies form most recently , as might be expected from simple chemical enrichment arguments , then figure 4 implies that the dominant stellar populations of all early - type galaxies in cl 0016 + 16 were already in place at redshifts @xmath82 . on the other hand , a wide range of scenarios are also allowed in which faint metal - poor galaxies form as recently as @xmath83 , i.e. , more recently than bright metal - rich galaxies . the lower panel of figure 4 shows that the alternative cosmology @xmath84 km sec@xmath47mpc@xmath47 and @xmath85 would lead on average to slightly larger @xmath68 values for model galaxies because of the lower age of the universe implied at redshift 1 . we emphasize that the constraints on the formation redshift and metal abundance of the stellar populations of early - type galaxies derived from figure 4 apply to cl 0016 + 16 only . as figure 3_a _ shows , constraints on clusters at lower redshifts are consistent with formation redshifts as small as 0.6 for even the brightest , reddest galaxies . hence , the apparent lack of evolution of the slope and scatter of the cm relation in clusters does not imply by itself a common epoch of star formation for all early - type galaxies . instead , what is strictly implied is that new galaxies joining the cm relation at low redshifts must be more metal - rich than their older cluster companions of similar luminosity . the required age metallicity evolution inferred from figure 3 corresponds roughly to a 25% increase in [ fe / h ] from @xmath86 to @xmath87 , i.e. , over a period of 2.5 gyr for the assumed @xmath88 km sec@xmath89mpc@xmath47 and @xmath49 . we note that adopting longer timescales of star formation instead of an instantaneous burst for early - type galaxies in clusters would increase the formation redshift of the first stars in model galaxies with respect to the results of figure 3 . whatever the adopted history of star formation , however , the values of @xmath68 in figure 3 are robust limits on the redshift of the last major event of star formation in early - type galaxies ( see 2 ) . finally , we have explored the possibility that the faint morphologically - selected early - type galaxies with very blue colors in cl 0016 + 16 were actual cluster members ( see 3 ) . the inferred @xmath68 and [ fe / h ] ranges for these objects is indicated by the heavy shaded region in figure 4 . as expected , the blue colors imply that the galaxies must be both young and metal - poor . we may speculate that they are young objects which `` violate '' the main sequence cm relation , but which could eventually evolve towards it as they age and undergo chemical enrichment . however , spectroscopic confirmation as well as a deeper search for faint blue outliers in clusters at higher redshifts are needed before we can draw any definitive conclusions as to their true nature . the above analysis has enabled us to determine the areas allowed in @xmath90})$ ] space for the stellar populations of e / s0 galaxies in clusters . while we emphasize that real galaxies may occupy only part of these allowed areas , it is interesting to compute the implied evolution with redshift of other observable properties of early - type galaxies such as mass - to - light ratios and spectral indices . since we do not know which subareas real galaxies might occupy in figure 3 , in the following we investigate properties averaged over the entire allowed areas . we first investigate the mass - to - light ratios of the model galaxies selected in figure 3 . for each cluster , we compute the logarithmic mean of @xmath91 in each luminosity bin at the cluster redshift by averaging over the @xmath81})$ ] area constrained by the observations . since absolute values of @xmath91 depend sensitively on the assumed low - mass end of the imf , we adopt for all clusters the arbitrary normalization @xmath92 at @xmath93 and focus our investigation on the dependence of the mass - to - light ratio on luminosity . the mean values of @xmath94 computed in this way are shown as triangles in figure 5 . since the mass - to-@xmath10 light ratio of a stellar population increases at increasing age and metallicity , brighter galaxies in figure 5 generally tend to have larger @xmath94 than fainter galaxies . this is not always true , however , as can be understood from the dispersion in the results of figure 3 . also shown in figure 5 are the results from two recent observational studies of the fundamental plane for cluster e / s0 galaxies . jrgensen , franx , & kjrgaard ( 1996 ) have parameterized the mass - to - gunn @xmath95 luminosity ratio , @xmath96 , in terms of a combination of half light radius and central velocity dispersion from observations of a large sample of 226 e / s0 galaxies in 10 nearby clusters . they conclude that the half light radius has a negligible effect on determinations of @xmath96 and show that the data follow the simple relation @xmath97 with a scatter of only 25% . the central velocity dispersion @xmath38 is tightly correlated with luminosity via the faber - jackson relation ( faber & jackson 1976 ) . we use ble92 s calibration of this relation based on observations of early - type galaxies in the coma cluster in order to relate @xmath98 to @xmath99 in figure 5 . we then adopt the mean @xmath100 colors of galaxies along the cm relation to convert jrgensen et al.s ( 1996 ) result into an expression involving the mass - to-@xmath10 luminosity ratio . this yields @xmath101 , corresponding to an increase of less than 3% in logarithmic slope with respect to the relation derived in gunn @xmath95 . the horizontal shading in figure 5 then indicates the range of slopes allowed after accounting for the scatter of jrgensen et al.s ( 1996 ) data around the mean relation . an alternative constraint on the observed range of mass - to-@xmath10 luminosity ratios can be obtained from the relation recently derived by graham & colless ( 1997 ) between half light radius , central velocity dispersion and mean surface brightness of early - type galaxies . their analysis is based on accurate fitting of the @xmath10-light profiles of 26 e / s0 galaxies in the virgo cluster using both homologous ( @xmath102 ) and non - homologous ( @xmath103 , with @xmath104 a free parameter ) radial dependence laws . the results indicate a slight but systematic breaking of the generally assumed homology in the sense that @xmath104 increases with increasing half - light radius . we can use the virial theorem and faber - jackson relation to reexpress the results of graham & colless ( 1997 ) in terms of a relation involving @xmath91 and @xmath98 . the outcome is shown in the upper and lower panels of figure 5 for non - homologous and homologous light profiles , respectively . in each case , the heavy solid line indicates the mean relation and the slanted shading represents the allowed range of slopes when the uncertainties quoted by graham & colless are included . figure 5 shows that the mass - to - light ratios of model galaxies are all within the range constrained by current observations . the models appear to be mostly compatible with the graham & colless ( 1997 ) results for non - homologous light profiles . however , we point out that the model values correspond to purely stellar mass - to - light ratios , whereas there is some observational evidence for the presence of dark halos around early - type galaxies . this is inferred via the studies of hi kinematics ( e.g. franx et al . 1994 ) , x - ray emission ( e.g. forman et al . 1994 ) , radial velocities of planetary nebulae and globular clusters ( e.g. mould et al . 1990 , hui et al . 1995 ) , gravitational lensing ( e.g. maoz & rix 1993 ) and measurements of the shape of the stellar line - of sight velocity distribution ( e.g. carollo et al . 1995 ) . more recently , rix et al . ( 1997 ) have analyzed the velocity profile of the elliptical galaxy ngc 2434 and show that roughly half the mass within an effective radius is dark . hence , one must remain cautious in interpreting trends in the mass - to - light ratios of early - type galaxies on the basis of pure population synthesis models . for completeness , we also compute the strengths of several commonly used spectral indices implied by the above photometric study for early - type galaxies in clusters . most observations in this domain have concentrated on measurements of h - balmer , magnesium and iron - dominated indices of the lick system ( 2 ) such as h@xmath17 , mg@xmath12 , mg@xmath16 and mgfe ( worthey et al . 1992 ; bender , burstein & faber 1993 ; gonzalez 1993 ; davies , sadler & peletier 1993 ; ziegler & bender 1997 ) . one of the main motivations for studies of this type is to identify a pair of indices including one mostly sensitive to age and one mostly sensitive to metallicity in order to break the age metallicity degeneracy from photometric colors . sensitive h@xmath17 index , however , can be significantly contaminated by nuclear emission in e / s0 galaxies , for which the corrections are uncertain ( e.g. , gonzalez 1993 ) . it is therefore deemed preferable to study higher - order balmer indices such as h@xmath105 ( e.g. , worthey & ottaviani 1997 ) . also , the apparent systematic increase of [ mg / fe ] from faint to bright e / s0 galaxies challenges analyses based on models with solar - scaled abundance ratios ( e.g. , worthey et al . 1992 ; tantalo , bressan & chiosi 1997 and references therein ) . worthey ( 1995 ) shows that the metal - sensitive index c4668 of the lick system appears to be significantly less enhanced with respect to iron than mg in bright e / s0 galaxies . thus , c4668 represents a good alternative to mg - dominated indices for reliable model investigations of early - type galaxy spectra ( e.g. , kuntschner & davies 1998 ) . by analogy with our approach in 5.1 , we compute mean spectral indices for each of the four luminosity bins in each cluster of our sample . the results are shown in figure 6 for the mg@xmath12 , h@xmath17 , mg@xmath16 , mgfe , c4668 and h@xmath106 indices of the lick system . as expected , there is a general correlation between index strength and luminosity , which is more pronounced for metal - sensitive ( mg@xmath12 , mg@xmath16 , mgfe and c4668 ) than for age - sensitive ( h@xmath17 , h@xmath106 ) indices . the reason for this is that luminous galaxies in figure 3 are on average found to be significantly more metal - rich and slightly older than faint galaxies . also , figure 1 shows that the sensitivity to age of h - balmer indices such as h@xmath17 is significantly weakened after @xmath107 gyr , when a and b stars have evolved off the main sequence . for comparison , the solid and dashed lines in figure 6 show the locations of passively evolving model galaxies with @xmath108 and the metallicities @xmath109 and @xmath110 , respectively . the mean index strengths of cluster galaxies appear to evolve roughly along these lines , supporting the consistency of the stellar populations with apparently passive evolution . in fact , ziegler & bender ( 1997 ) find that the evolution from @xmath43 to @xmath111 of the correlation existing between the mg@xmath16 index strength and central velocity dispersion of e / s0 galaxies is consistent with passive evolution . it should be noted that the model indices computed in figure 6 are global indices averaged over the emission from all stars in a galaxy . observations of nearby e / s0 galaxies , however , reveal systematic variations of the strengths of spectral indices between the central and outer regions ( e.g. , worthey et al . we have shown that the tight photometric constraints on early - type galaxies in clusters allow relatively wide ranges of ages and metallicities for the dominant stellar populations . in particular , the small scatter of the cm relation out to redshifts @xmath2 does not necessarily imply a common epoch of star formation for all early - type galaxies . it requires , however , that galaxies assembling more recently be on average more metal - rich than older galaxies of similar luminosity . in this context it is interesting to mention that , based on the spectral indices of nearby e / s0 galaxies , worthey , trager & faber ( 1996 ) favor younger ages for more metal - rich galaxies than for metal - poor ones at fixed velocity dispersion . the results of our unbiased analysis therefore define the boundaries in age and metallicity that must be satisfied by theoretical studies aimed at explaining the formation and evolution of early - type galaxies in clusters . the constraints obtained here on the age and metallicity ranges of e / s0 galaxies are consistent with conventional models in which the galaxies all form monolithically in a single giant burst of star formation at high redshift ( e.g. , kodama et al . 1998 , and references therein ) . in fact , this implies that regardless of the true ages and metallicities of early - type galaxies within the allowed range , their photometric properties will always be consistent with _ apparently _ passive evolution of the stellar populations . as figure 6 shows , this consistency even extends to spectral index strengths . our results are also consistent with scenarios in which e / s0 galaxies are formed by the merging of disk galaxies ( schweizer & seitzer 1992 ) in a universe where structure is built through hierarchical clustering ( kauffmann 1996 ; baugh , cole & frenk 1996 ; kauffmann & charlot 1998 ) . for such scenarios , figure 3 constrains the metallicity and epoch of the last major event of star formation in e / s0 galaxies and their progenitors ( see 2 and 4 ) . the ages and metallicities of cluster e / s0 galaxies predicted by hierarchical models are found to be consistent with these constraints ( kauffmann & charlot 1998 ) . to better assess the origin of e / s0 galaxies in clusters one therefore needs to appeal to observational constraints other than their spectro - photometric properties . for example , conventional models of e / s0 galaxy formation are being challenged by the paucity of red galaxies found at high redshifts in deep surveys ( kauffmann , charlot , & white 1997 ; zepf 1997 ) . also , morphological distinction between e and s0 galaxies and the evolution of the morphology - density relation out to moderate redshifts appear to point to different formation epochs for e and s0 galaxies ( dressler et al . 1997 ) . the tightness of the cm relation is proof of a stable process in the assembly of cluster early - type galaxies . however , as we move towards greater redshifts , a drastic change is expected at lookback times that approach the formation of the first e / s0 galaxies . this change can arise as a systematic blueing , an increased scatter or a slope flattening in the cm relation ( e.g. , aragn - salamanca et al . 1993 ; charlot & silk 1994 ; kauffmann & charlot 1998 ) . an interesting question is raised by the presence of morphologically - selected early - type galaxies with very blue colors in clusters at moderate redshifts ( 3 and 4 ) . if these objects are true cluster members , our analysis shows that they could be young metal - poor galaxies that will later join the cm relation . hence , we need to probe deeper down the galaxy luminosity function in distant clusters in order to assess whether these objects can have any fundamental bearing on the origin of early - type galaxies . we thank adam stanford for sending us a machine readable list of the cluster photometry used in this paper . thanks the cnrs and the institut dastrophysique de paris for hospitality and financial support , and also acknowledges a ph.d . scholarship from the `` gobierno de cantabria . '' j.s . acknowledges support from nasa , nsf and the blaise - pascal chair at the institut dastrophysique de paris . aragn - salamanca , a. , ellis , r.s . , couch , w.j . , & carter , d. 1993 , mnras , 262 , 764 aragn - salamanca , a. , baugh , c. m. & kauffmann , g. 1998 , mnras , in press ( astro - ph/9801277 ) arimoto , n. & yoshii , y. 1987 , , 173 , 23 baugh , c.m . , cole , s. & frenk , c.s . , 1996 , mnras , 283 , 1361 bender , r. , burstein , d. & faber , s. m. 1993 , , 411 , 153 bower , r. g. , lucey , j. r. & ellis , r. s. 1992 , , 254 , 589 bower , r. g. , lucey , j. r. & ellis , r. s. 1992 , , 254 , 601 bressan , a. , chiosi , c. & tantalo , r. 1996 , 311 , 425 bressan , a. et al . 1998 , in preparation bruzual , g. , barbuy , b. , ortolani , s. , bica , e. , cuisinier , f. , lejeune , t. , & schiavon , r.p . 1997 , aj , 114 , 1531 bruzual , g. & charlot , s. 1998 , in preparation carollo , c.m . , de zeeuw , p.t . , van der marel , r.p . , danziger , i.j . & qian , e.e . , 1995 , apj , 441 , l25 charlot , s. , & silk , j. 1994 , apj , 432 , 453 charlot , s. , worthey , g. & bressan , a. 1996 , , 457 , 625 davies , r.l . , sadler , e.m . , & peletier , r.f . 1993 , mnras , 262 , 650 dressler , a. , et al . 1997 , apj , 470 , 577 ellis , r. s. , smail , i. , dressler , a. , couch , w. j. , oemler , a. , butcher , h. & sharples , r. m. 1997 , , 483 , 582 faber , s.m . , & jackson , r. 1976 , apj , 204 , 668 forman , w. , jones , c. & tucker , w. , 1994 , apj , 429 , 77 gonzalez , j.j . 1993 , phd thesis , univ . of santa - cruz graham , a. , colless , m. 1997 , , 287 , 221 han , m. , & mould , j.r . 1992 , apj , 396 , 453 hui , x. , ford , h.c . , freeman , k.c . & dopita , m.a . , 1995 , apj , 449 , 592 jrgensen , i. , franx , m. & kjrgaard , p. 1996 , , 280 , 167 kauffmann , g. 1996 , mnras , 281 , 487 kauffmann , g. , charlot , s. , & white , s.d.m . 1997 , mnras , 283 , 117l kauffmann , g. & charlot , s. 1998 , mnras , in press kodama , t. & arimoto , n. 1997 , 320 , 41 kodama , t. , arimoto , n. , barger , a. j. & aragn - salamanca , a. 1998 , astro - ph/9802245 kuntschner , h. , & davies , r.l . 1998 , mnras , in press ( astro - ph/9710176 ) larson , r. b. 1974 , mnras , 166 , 585 lilly , s. j. , tresse , l. , hammer , f. , crampton , d. & le f ` evre , o. 1995 , , 455 , 108 maoz , d. & rix , h .- w . , 1993 , apj , 416 , 215 matteuci , f. & tornamb , f. 1987 , , 185 , 51 mould , j.r . , oke , j.b . , de zeeuw , p.t . & nemec , j.m . , 1990 , aj , 99 , 1823 rix , h .- w . , de zeeuw , p.t . , cretton , n. , van der marel , m. , roeland , p. , & carollo , m. 1997 , apj , 488 , 702 scalo , j.n . 1986 , fundamentals of cosmic physics , 11 , 1 stanford , s. a. , eisenhardt , p. r. & dickinson , m. 1998 , , 492 , 461 schweizer , f. , & seitzer , p. 1992 , aj , 104 , 1039 tantalo , r. , bressan , a. , & chiosi c. 1997 , a&a , submitted ( astro - ph/9710101 ) visvanathan , n. , & sandage , a. 1997 , apj , 216 , 214 worthey , g. 1994 , , 95 , 107 worthey , g. 1995 , in from stars to galaxies , ed . c. leitherer , u. fritze - von alvensleben , & j. huchra ( asp conf . series 98 ) , 167 worthey , g. , faber , s.m . , & gonzalez , j.j . 1992 , apj , 398 , 69 worthey , g. , trager , s.c . , & faber , s.m . 1996 , in fresh views of elliptical galaxies , ed . a. buzzoni , a. renzini , & a. serrano ( asp conf . series 86 ) , 203 worthey , g. , & ottaviani , d.l . 1997 , apjs , 111 , 377 zepf , s.e . 1997 , nature , 390 , 377 ziegler , b.l . , & bender , r. 1997 , mnras , 291 , 527

we present an unbiased method for evaluating the ranges of ages and metallicities which are allowed by the photometric properties of the stellar populations that dominate the light of early - type galaxies in clusters . the method is based on the analysis of morphologically - classified early - type galaxies in @xmath0 clusters at redshifts @xmath1 and in the nearby coma cluster using recent stellar population synthesis models that span a wide range of metallicities . we confirm that metallicity effects must play a role in the origin of the slope of the color - magnitude relation for cluster early - type galaxies . we show , however , that the small scatter of the color - magnitude relation out to redshifts @xmath2 does not formally imply a common epoch of major star formation for all early - type galaxies . instead , it requires that galaxies assembling more recently be on average more metal - rich than older galaxies of similar luminosity . regardless of the true ages and metallicities of early - type galaxies within the allowed range , their photometric properties and the implied strengths of several commonly used spectral indices are found to be consistent with _ apparently _ passive evolution of the stellar populations . also , the implied dependence of the mass - to - light ratio on galaxy luminosity is consistent with the observed trend . the results of our unbiased analysis define the boundaries in age and metallicity that must be satisfied by theoretical studies aimed at explaining the formation and evolution of early - type galaxies in clusters . 0.5truecm 1truecm ( accepted for publication in the _ astrophysical journal _ )

quant-ph0505042

the imaginary time path integral @xcite has provided a useful framework suitable for numerical analyses of quantum statistical - mechanical systems . most of the static properties of quantum systems can be calculated by means of the path integral monte carlo ( pimc ) or path integral molecular dynamics ( pimd ) technique @xcite . however , it is not straightforward to apply the pimc / pimd methods to computing dynamical properties such as the real time quantum correlation function @xmath2 . this is because it is nontrivial to construct real time quantities from a finite number of imaginary time data obtained numerically @xcite . to overcome such difficulty , a number of promising methods of numerical analytic continuation based on the maximum entropy method have been proposed and applied to various many - body systems @xcite . recently , the centroid molecular dynamics ( cmd ) method @xcite , the ring polymer molecular dynamics ( rpmd ) method @xcite , and the effective potential analytic continuation ( epac ) method @xcite have been proposed as new quantum dynamics methods to calculate real time quantum correlation functions at finite temperature . both the cmd and the rpmd are the methods to calculate the canonical ( kubo - transformed ) correlation function @xcite @xmath3 by means of molecular dynamics techniques . on the other hand , the epac is a method to obtain the real time quantum correlation function @xmath2 by means of the effective action formalism @xcite and an analytic continuation procedure @xcite . it has been shown analytically that all these methods are exact in harmonic systems for the real time quantum correlation functions of a linear function of the position operator , @xmath4 @xcite . however , for nonlinear operators such as @xmath5 , it is nontrivial whether these quantum dynamics methods yield the exact result even in harmonic systems @xcite . this is the _ nonlinear operator problem _ in quantum dynamics methods . from a practical point of view , the nonlinear operator problem is a quite important subject to be tackled . in many problems of chemical interest , the real time correlation functions of nonlinear operators are often needed for the calculation of various dynamical properties @xcite . for example , the cmd has been applied to the calculation of the transport coefficients such as thermal conductivity , shear viscosity , and bulk viscosity of quantum liquid parahydrogen @xcite . here it is found that the calculated transport properties are in good agreement with the experimental data . however , there is no rigorous theoretical basis for applying the cmd method to such properties represented by means of the correlation functions involving operators nonlinear in @xmath0 ( or momentum operator @xmath6 ) . therefore we need , in general , a quantum dynamics method which is theoretically valid even for the time correlation functions of nonlinear operators . the present status of the nonlinear operator problem in the three quantum dynamics methods , cmd , rpmd , and epac , is summarized as follows . for the cmd method , _ have argued this problem in their pioneering paper to conclude that a cmd correlation function involving nonlinear operators corresponds to a higher - order kubo - transformed correlation function @xcite . on the other hand , craig and manolopoulos have shown that the rpmd is exact for all the operators involving @xmath0 in the limit @xmath7 @xcite . as for our epac method , the nonlinear operator problem has not been examined yet . in addition to these three methods , a theoretical approach based on the quantum mode - coupling theory has been applied to study the dynamical properties involving nonlinear operators in quantum liquids @xcite . in the present paper , we develop the method of the epac for the calculation of the real time quantum correlation function involving the nonlinear operator @xmath5 . as a simple example , at first we show the epac correlation function @xmath8 for a harmonic oscillator comparing with the results of the cmd and the rpmd . next we calculate @xmath8 numerically in an asymmetric anharmonic system . we also propose a simplified epac method to reduce the computational cost required in the epac calculation . in sec . ii , we summarize the effective action formalism and present how to calculate the epac correlation function involving nonlinear operators . the results for a harmonic oscillator are given in sec . numerical results for an anharmonic oscillator are shown in sec . iv . in this section we also present the simplified epac method . the conclusions are given in sec . hereafter we treat the real time quantum autocorrelation function of the nonlinear operator @xmath9 , @xmath10 . in principle , this can be obtained from the imaginary time green function @xmath11 via an analytic continuation procedure @xcite . here @xmath12 represents a time - ordered product . on the other hand , it is known that the green function @xmath11 is given as a special case of @xmath13-point imaginary time green function @xmath14 , which can be constructed from the standard effective potential @xmath15 appearing in the effective action formalism @xcite . consequently , the real time quantum correlation function @xmath16 should be obtained by means of the effective action formalism and the analytic continuation . a series of these procedures is the epac method for the nonlinear operator @xmath9 , which we newly show in this section . as the simplest example , we present the epac calculation of the autocorrelation function of the quadratic operator @xmath17 , @xmath18 , in secs . iia and iib . we begin with the effective action formalism @xcite . consider a quantum system where a quantum particle of mass @xmath19 moves in a one - dimensional potential @xmath20 at inverse temperature @xmath21 . the quantum canonical partition function of this system is expressed in terms of the imaginary time path integral @xmath22&=&\int^{\infty}_{-\infty}dq \int^{q(\beta\hbar)=q}_{q(0)=q}{\cal d}q ~\!\exp\left [ -s_{e}/\hbar + \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}d\tau j(\tau)q(\tau)/\hbar \right ] , \label{2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath23 is the euclidean action functional @xmath24=\int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}d\tau \left[~\!\frac{1}{2}~\!m ~\!\dot{q}^2 + v(q)~\!\right ] , \label{3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath25 is an external source . the generating functional @xmath26 $ ] is defined as @xmath27 & = & \hbar \log { \cal z}_{\beta}[j ] .\label{4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the functional derivative of @xmath26 $ ] with respect to @xmath25 produces the quantum statistical - mechanical expectation value of the operator @xmath0 in the presence of @xmath28 , @xmath29}{\delta j(\tau ) } & = & \langle \hat{q}(\tau)\rangle_{\beta}^{j } \equiv q(\tau ) .\label{5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the effective action @xmath30 $ ] is defined by the legendre transform of @xmath26 $ ] , @xmath31&=&-w_{\beta}[j ] + \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}d\tau j(\tau)q(\tau ) , \label{6}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which satisfies the quantum - mechanical euler - lagrange equation @xmath32/\delta q(\tau)=j(\tau)$ ] . the exact quantum statistical - mechanical expectation value @xmath33(@xmath34 ) is obtained as a solution of the equation @xmath35}{\delta q(\tau)}=0 .\label{8}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the expectation value @xmath33 is independent of imaginary time @xmath36 in thermal equilibrium . the @xmath37-point connected green function @xmath38 is generated by the @xmath37th - order functional derivative of @xmath26 $ ] with respect to @xmath25 @xcite . for example , the two - point connected green function is given by @xmath39}{\delta j(\tau_{1})\delta j(\tau_{2 } ) } \right|_{j=0 } \nonumber \\ & = & \langle t \hat{q}(\tau_{1})\hat{q}(\tau_{2})\rangle_{\beta } -\langle \hat{q}(\tau_{1})\rangle_{\beta } ~\!\langle \hat{q}(\tau_{2})\rangle_{\beta } .\label{9}\end{aligned}\ ] ] then we obtain the two - point green function @xmath40 the procedure in eqs . ( [ 2])-([10 ] ) has been described in ref . . in a similar way , the three- and four - point green functions can be explicitly expressed as @xmath41 } { \delta j(\tau_{1})\delta j(\tau_{2})\delta j(\tau_{3 } ) } \right|_{j=0 } \nonumber \\ & & + q_{s}(\tau_{1 } ) \langle t \hat{q}(\tau_{2})\hat{q}(\tau_{3})\rangle_{\beta } + ( 1\leftrightarrow 2)+(1\leftrightarrow 3 ) \nonumber \\ & & -~2~q_{s}(\tau_{1})q_{s}(\tau_{2})q_{s}(\tau_{3 } ) , \\ \label{11 } \langle t \hat{q}(\tau_{1})\hat{q}(\tau_{2})\hat{q}(\tau_{3 } ) \hat{q}(\tau_{4})\rangle_{\beta } & = & \hbar^{3}\left.\frac{\delta^{4 } w_{\beta}[j ] } { \delta j(\tau_{1})\delta j(\tau_{2})\delta j(\tau_{3})\delta j(\tau_{4 } ) } \right|_{j=0 } \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! + \hbar^{2}q_{s}(\tau_{1})\left.\frac{\delta^{3 } w_{\beta}[j ] } { \delta j(\tau_{2})\delta j(\tau_{3})\delta j(\tau_{4 } ) } \right|_{j=0 } + ( 1\leftrightarrow 2)+(1\leftrightarrow 3)+(1\leftrightarrow 4 ) \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! + \langle t \hat{q}(\tau_{1})\hat{q}(\tau_{2})\rangle_{\beta } \langle t \hat{q}(\tau_{3})\hat{q}(\tau_{4})\rangle_{\beta } + ( 2\leftrightarrow 3)+(2\leftrightarrow 4 ) \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! -~2~q_{s}(\tau_{1})q_{s}(\tau_{2})q_{s}(\tau_{3})q_{s}(\tau_{4 } ) , \label{12}\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively . here @xmath42 denotes the interchange of @xmath43 with @xmath44 . on the other hand , the @xmath37th - order functional derivative @xmath45 is connected with the @xmath37th - order functional derivative of the effective action @xmath46 @xcite , @xmath47}{\delta j(\tau_{1})\delta j(\tau_{2 } ) } \right|_{j=0 } & = & \left(\left . \gamma_{\beta}[q]}{\delta q(\tau_{1})\delta q(\tau_{2 } ) } \right|_{q = q_{s}}\right)^{-1 } , \label{13 } \\ \left . \frac{\delta^{3 } w_{\beta}[j ] } { \delta j(\tau_{1})\delta j(\tau_{2})\delta j(\tau_{3 } ) } \right|_{j=0 } & = & -\frac{1}{\hbar^{3 } } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!ds_{1 } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!ds_{2 } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!ds_{3 } \nonumber \\ & & \times g_{\beta}^{c}(s_{1}-\tau_{1 } ) g_{\beta}^{c}(s_{2}-\tau_{2 } ) g_{\beta}^{c}(s_{3}-\tau_{3 } ) \nonumber \\ & & \times\left . \frac{\delta^{3 } \gamma_{\beta}[q ] } { \delta q(s_{1})\delta q(s_{2})\delta q(s_{3 } ) } \right|_{q = q_{s } } , \label{14}\\ \left . \frac{\delta^{4 } w_{\beta}[j ] } { \delta j(\tau_{1})\delta j(\tau_{2})\delta j(\tau_{3})\delta j(\tau_{4 } ) } \right|_{j=0 } & = & -\frac{1}{\hbar^{4 } } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!ds_{1 } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!ds_{2 } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!ds_{3 } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!ds_{4 } \nonumber \\ & & \times g_{\beta}^{c}(s_{1}-\tau_{1 } ) g_{\beta}^{c}(s_{2}-\tau_{2 } ) g_{\beta}^{c}(s_{3}-\tau_{3 } ) g_{\beta}^{c}(s_{4}-\tau_{4 } ) \nonumber \\ & & \times\left . \frac{\delta^{4 } \gamma_{\beta}[q ] } { \delta q(s_{1})\delta q(s_{2})\delta q(s_{3})\delta q(s_{4 } ) } \right|_{q = q_{s } } \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! + \frac{1}{\hbar^{5 } } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!ds_{1 } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!ds_{2 } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!ds_{3 } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!ds_{4 } \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!du \int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}\!\!\!\!\!dv \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! \times g_{\beta}^{c}(s_{1}-\tau_{1 } ) g_{\beta}^{c}(s_{2}-\tau_{2 } ) g_{\beta}^{c}(u - v ) g_{\beta}^{c}(s_{3}-\tau_{3 } ) g_{\beta}^{c}(s_{4}-\tau_{4 } ) \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! \times\left . \frac{\delta^{3 } \gamma_{\beta}[q ] } { \delta q(s_{1})\delta q(s_{2})\delta q(u ) } \right|_{q = q_{s } } \!\!\!\!\cdot~\left . \frac{\delta^{3 } \gamma_{\beta}[q ] } { \delta q(v)\delta q(s_{3})\delta q(s_{4 } ) } \right|_{q = q_{s } } \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! + ( 2\leftrightarrow 3)+(2\leftrightarrow 4 ) .\label{15}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using eqs . ( [ 9])-([15 ] ) , we can construct the imaginary time green functions in terms of the effective action @xmath30 $ ] . now we employ the local potential approximation ( lpa ) to the effective action , @xmath31&=&\int^{\beta\hbar}_{0}d\tau\left [ v_{\beta}(q)+\frac{1}{2}~\!m~\!\dot{q}^{2 } \right ] , \label{16}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath15 is the standard effective potential , i.e. , the leading order of the derivative expansion of @xmath30 $ ] @xcite . for the case @xmath33 is @xmath36 independent , eq . ( [ 8 ] ) becomes the stationary condition @xmath48 , which determines the expectation value @xmath33 as the standard effective potential minimum @xmath49 . then the functional derivatives of the effective action @xmath46 become @xmath50}{\delta q(\tau_{1})\delta q(\tau_{2 } ) } \right|_{q = q_{s } } & = & \left(-m\frac{d^{2}}{d\tau^{2}}+ \left . \frac{\partial^{2 } v_{\beta}}{\partial q^{2 } } \right|_{q = q_{\rm min } } \right)\delta(\tau_{1}-\tau_{2 } ) , \label{17}\\ \left . \frac{\delta^{3 } \gamma_{\beta}[q ] } { \delta q(\tau_{1})\delta q(\tau_{2})\delta q(\tau_{3 } ) } \right|_{q = q_{s } } & = & \left . \frac{\partial^{3 } v_{\beta}}{\partial q^{3 } } \right|_{q = q_{\rm min } } \delta(\tau_{1}-\tau_{2})\delta(\tau_{1}-\tau_{3 } ) , \label{18}\\ \left . \frac{\delta^{4 } \gamma_{\beta}[q ] } { \delta q(\tau_{1})\delta q(\tau_{2})\delta q(\tau_{3})\delta q(\tau_{4 } ) } \right|_{q = q_{s } } & = & \left . \frac{\partial^{4 } v_{\beta}}{\partial q^{4 } } \right|_{q = q_{\rm min } } \delta(\tau_{1}-\tau_{2})\delta(\tau_{1}-\tau_{3})\delta(\tau_{1}-\tau_{4 } ) .\label{19}\end{aligned}\ ] ] if we expand @xmath51 around the minimum @xmath52 , @xmath53 then the derivatives of @xmath51 appearing in eqs . ( [ 17])-([19 ] ) are given as the coefficients in the series , @xmath54 . now we proceed to the calculations of the real time quantum correlation function @xmath18 , i.e. , the aim of the present paper . first , by setting @xmath55 and @xmath56 in eq . ( [ 12 ] ) , we obtain the imaginary time green function @xmath57 } { \delta j(\tau)\delta j(\tau)\delta j(0)\delta j(0 ) } \right|_{j=0 } \nonumber \\ & + & 2\hbar^{2}q_{\rm min}\left [ \left.\frac{\delta^{3 } w_{\beta}[j ] } { \delta j(\tau)\delta j(\tau)\delta j(0 ) } \right|_{j=0 } + \left.\frac{\delta^{3 } w_{\beta}[j ] } { \delta j(\tau)\delta j(0)\delta j(0 ) } \right|_{j=0 } \right ] \nonumber \\ & + & 2\left(\langle t \hat{q}(\tau)\hat{q}(0)\rangle_{\beta}\right)^{2 } + \left(\langle t \hat{q}(0)\hat{q}(0)\rangle_{\beta}\right)^{2 } -~2~q_{\rm min}^{4 } .\label{21}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the definition @xmath58 and @xmath59 , from eqs . ( [ 9 ] ) , ( [ 10 ] ) , ( [ 13])-([15 ] ) , and ( [ 17])-([20 ] ) , the components of eq . ( [ 21 ] ) can approximately be written as @xmath60+q_{\rm min}^{2 } , \label{22}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath61 } { \delta j(\tau)\delta j(\tau)\delta j(0 ) } \right|_{j=0 } & + & \left.\frac{\delta^{3 } w_{\beta}[j ] } { \delta j(\tau)\delta j(0)\delta j(0 ) } \right|_{j=0}\nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! = -\frac{a_{3}}{6m^{3}\omega_{\beta}^{4 } } \frac{1 } { \left(e^{\alpha}-e^{-\alpha}\right)^{3 } } \left [ ( e^{\alpha}-e^{3\alpha})e^{-2\omega_{\beta}\tau } + ( e^{-3\alpha}-e^{-\alpha})e^{2\omega_{\beta}\tau } \right.\nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! + \left.2(e^{3\alpha}-e^{-\alpha})e^{-\omega_{\beta}\tau } + 2(e^{\alpha}-e^{-3\alpha})e^{\omega_{\beta}\tau } + 6(e^{\alpha}-e^{-\alpha } ) \right ] , \label{23}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath62 } { \delta j(\tau)\delta j(\tau ) \delta j(0)\delta j(0 ) } \right|_{j=0 } \nonumber \\ & = & -\frac{a_{4}}{32m^{4}\omega_{\beta}^{5 } } \frac{1 } { \left(e^{\alpha}-e^{-\alpha}\right)^{4 } } \left[~ 4\alpha ( 4+e^{-2\omega_{\beta}\tau}+e^{2\omega_{\beta}\tau})\right . \nonumber \\ & & + 2(e^{4\alpha}-1)\omega_{\beta}\tau e^{-2\omega_{\beta}\tau } + 2(e^{-4\alpha}-1)\omega_{\beta}\tau e^{2\omega_{\beta}\tau } \nonumber \\ & & \left . + 8(e^{2\alpha}-e^{-2\alpha } ) + ( e^{4\alpha}-1)e^{-2\omega_{\beta}\tau } + ( 1-e^{-4\alpha})e^{2\omega_{\beta}\tau } ~\right ] \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{a_{3}^{2}}{288m^{5}\omega_{\beta}^{7 } } \frac{1 } { \left(e^{\alpha}-e^{-\alpha}\right)^{5 } } \left[~ 60\alpha ( e^{\alpha}-e^{-\alpha } ) ( 4+e^{-2\omega_{\beta}\tau}+e^{2\omega_{\beta}\tau})\right . \nonumber \\ & & + 30(e^{5\alpha}-e^{3\alpha}-e^{\alpha}+e^{-\alpha } ) \omega_{\beta}\tau e^{-2\omega_{\beta}\tau } + 30(-e^{\alpha}+e^{-\alpha}+e^{-3\alpha}-e^{-5\alpha } ) \omega_{\beta}\tau e^{2\omega_{\beta}\tau } \nonumber \\ & & + 16(e^{5\alpha}-2e^{3\alpha}+e^{\alpha})e^{-3\omega_{\beta}\tau } + 16(e^{-\alpha}-2e^{-3\alpha}+e^{-5\alpha})e^{3\omega_{\beta}\tau } \nonumber \\ & & -17(e^{5\alpha}-e^{3\alpha}-e^{\alpha}+e^{-\alpha})e^{-2\omega_{\beta}\tau } -17(e^{\alpha}-e^{-\alpha}-e^{-3\alpha}+e^{-5\alpha})e^{2\omega_{\beta}\tau } \nonumber \\ & & + 16(e^{5\alpha}+3e^{3\alpha}-8e^{\alpha}+3e^{-\alpha}+e^{-3\alpha } ) e^{-\omega_{\beta}\tau } + 16(e^{3\alpha}+3e^{\alpha}-8e^{-\alpha}+3e^{-3\alpha}+e^{-5\alpha } ) e^{\omega_{\beta}\tau } \nonumber \\ & & \left . + 248(e^{3\alpha}-e^{\alpha}-e^{-\alpha}+e^{-3\alpha } ) ~\right].\label{24}\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting eqs . ( [ 22])-([24 ] ) into eq . ( [ 21 ] ) , we can approximately represent the quadratic imaginary time green function @xmath63 in terms of the quantities @xmath49 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 . similarly , the higher - order real time correlation functions @xmath16 can approximately be obtained as @xmath72 using the information of the standard effective potential @xmath15 . in this section , as a simple example we show the calculation of the epac correlation function @xmath67 for a quantum harmonic oscillator whose classical potential is given by @xmath73 next , the results of the other quantum dynamics methods , the cmd @xcite and the rpmd @xcite , are shown . the standard effective potential for the system ( [ 26 ] ) is obtained as @xcite @xmath74 for the harmonic system , the minimum of @xmath15 is located at the point @xmath75 , while the effective frequency is @xmath76 . furthermore , it is evident that the higher - order derivatives of @xmath15 vanish , @xmath77 . consequently , the epac correlation function ( [ 25 ] ) becomes @xmath78 , \label{28}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is equal to the exact quantum correlation function @xmath18 . that is , the epac method is exact in the harmonic system ( [ 26 ] ) at any temperature . this is because the lpa [ eq . ( [ 16 ] ) ] , which is the only approximation employed in the epac method , is exact for harmonic systems @xcite . therefore , it can be shown that the epac correlation function @xmath72 is exact for any @xmath37 for harmonic systems . in harmonic systems , both the cmd and the rpmd are exact for the linear operator @xcite . that is , both the cmd correlation function and the rpmd correlation function are equal to the exact canonical , or kubo - transformed , correlation function @xmath79 . however , even in harmonic systems , these methods are no longer exact for the correlation functions of nonlinear operators @xcite . in the harmonic system ( [ 26 ] ) , we explicitly present the exact canonical autocorrelation function of the nonlinear operator @xmath17 @xmath80 , \label{29}\end{aligned}\ ] ] while the corresponding cmd correlation function with the _ classical operator _ @xcite is obtained as @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the position centroid variable . the cmd correlation function with the _ effective classical operator _ @xcite is also obtained as @xmath83 , \label{31b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath84 is the effective classical operator : @xmath85 . on the other hand , the rpmd correlation function is given by @xmath86 , \label{31}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath87 , @xmath88 , and @xmath89 is the number of discretization of imaginary time . figure [ fig : harm ] shows the plot of the four correlation functions , eqs . ( [ 29])-([31 ] ) , at two different temperatures with the parameters @xmath90 . here we have also set @xmath89 as @xmath91 , which is so large as to make the rpmd results converged sufficiently . at higher temperature @xmath92 , in fig . [ fig : harm ] ( a ) , all the cmd results and the rpmd result are slightly deviate from the exact one . these deviations become remarkable at lower temperature @xmath93 [ fig . [ fig : harm ] ( b ) ] . as is observed clearly at @xmath93 , the cmd correlation functions [ eqs . ( [ 30 ] ) and ( [ 31b ] ) ] fail to reproduce the exact value at @xmath1 and the exact amplitude , while they oscillate with the correct frequency @xmath94 . on the other hand , the rpmd correlation function ( [ 31 ] ) is exact at @xmath1 , while it damps with time because of the dephasing effect caused by the mode summation @xmath95 . this damping is remarkable at lower temperature . for the cmd method , jang and voth have explicitly shown that the cmd should be used for the computation of the canonical correlation function @xmath96 where the operator @xmath97 must be linear in position and/or momentum operators @xcite . as for the operator @xmath98 , the _ effective classical operator _ @xmath99 should be used for the cmd description of this correlation function @xcite . the cmd method is known to be problematic when the operator @xmath97 is a nonlinear function . afterwards two major approaches have been reported to deal with this nonlinear operator problem in the cmd method @xcite . here we note these approaches : \(1 ) the first approach is a theory based on the higher - order kubo - transformed correlation function ; reichman et al . have pointed out that the cmd correlation function with the effective classical operator @xmath99 , @xmath100 , corresponds to the @xmath37th - order kubo - transformed correlation function @xmath101 @xcite . that is , the cmd correlation function with effective classical operator , @xmath102 , corresponds to the second - order kubo - transformed correlation function @xmath103 for the harmonic oscillator ( [ 26 ] ) , it can readily be shown that eq . ( [ 31b ] ) is equal to eq . ( [ 31a ] ) . the cmd with effective classical operators works very well in this framework . however , there remains a practical problem in converting the higher - order kubo - transformed correlation function @xmath101 to the original quantum correlation function @xmath104 ; this conversion would be a complicated procedure in general.@xcite \(2 ) the second approach is based on novel expressions for physical quantities , which are formulated using correlation functions involving linear operators . have shown that the quantum reaction rate constant can be expressed in terms of the canonical correlation function @xmath105 @xcite . their approach enables us to evaluate the rate constants via cmd calculations without further approximations @xcite . in this section we calculate the epac correlation function @xmath67 for an asymmetric anharmonic system with the classical potential @xcite @xmath106 where natural units @xmath107 are employed . in the following , first we show the calculated epac correlation functions with the exact correlation functions @xmath18 , and then we present a simplified version of the epac method to discuss its validity . to evaluate the standard effective potential @xmath15 , we need to compute the generating functional @xmath26 $ ] [ eq . ( [ 4 ] ) ] and to carry out the legendre transformation ( [ 6 ] ) . there are various computational schemes to evaluate the generating functional @xmath26 $ ] . among them , the pimd / pimc technique is a practical tool to evaluate @xmath26 $ ] directly or indirectly @xcite . here we have , however , employed the renormalization group ( rg ) method , which is suitable for precise calculation of @xmath26 $ ] @xcite . then the standard effective potential @xmath15 has been computed by means of the numerical legendre transformation @xcite . figure [ fig : ep ] shows the evaluated standard effective potentials at various inverse temperatures @xmath108 0.1 , 1 , 10 , and 100 . minimizing the effective potential @xmath15 , we have obtained the quantities @xmath49 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 . table [ tab : table1 ] lists the results of computed quantities for the system ( [ 32 ] ) .

we apply the effective potential analytic continuation ( epac ) method to the calculation of real time quantum correlation functions involving operators nonlinear in the position operator @xmath0 . for a harmonic system the epac method provides the exact correlation function at all temperature ranges , while the other quantum dynamics methods , the centroid molecular dynamics and the ring polymer molecular dynamics , become worse at lower temperature . for an asymmetric anharmonic system , the epac correlation function is in very good agreement with the exact one at @xmath1 . when the time increases from zero , the epac method gives good coincidence with the exact result at lower temperature . finally , we propose a simplified version of the epac method to reduce the computational cost required for the calculation of the standard effective potential .

1604.01332

the structure , properties and reactions of nuclei and nuclear matter depend on the dynamics of the nucleons @xcite . this is the reason why the derivation of the nuclear forces is probably the most important problem of nuclear physics . after the discovery of quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) the fundamental theory of strong interactions a solid theoretical understanding of the nuclear force should be grounded on qcd , either directly or indirectly . lattice qcd represents the direct , computational derivation : the interaction of quarks and gluons is not analytically solvable at the distances that are characteristic for nuclear physics but it is numerically solvable at the expense of huge computational resources . recent progress in this front is exciting @xcite . the indirect derivation requires to explain the nuclear interaction without explicitly solving qcd . yet qcd must enter indirectly in the picture . otherwise we will end up with a phenomenological description instead of a theoretical explanation . physics as a science depends to a great extent on the existence of scale separation in nature . one can describe the properties of atoms without explicit knowledge of the composite nature and internal structure of the nuclei within . the nucleus is indeed much smaller than the atom containing it , i.e. there is an excellent separation of scales . analogously , one can describe the dynamics of nucleons and pions without knowing the details of the strong interaction of the quarks and gluons inside them . however the average distance of nucleons in a nucleus about @xmath0 is not that different from the size of the nucleon or the wavelength of the quarks and gluons inside , maybe @xmath1 . without a clear separation of scales the development of satisfactory theoretical explanations to physical phenomena becomes more difficult . as a consequence the description of nuclei is less clear and more involved than that of atoms . effective field theories ( efts ) are the standard theoretical tool to exploit the separation of scales of a physical system with the intention of building the most general description of it at low energies @xcite . if we call the low energy scale @xmath2 and the high energy scale @xmath3 , an eft provides a power expansion in terms of @xmath4 of all the physical quantities of a system . for that one considers first all the possible interaction terms in the lagrangian that are compatible with the low energy symmetries of the system . then one orders the infinite feynman diagrams obtained in the previous step according to their expected size . the method by which we estimate the size of the diagrams is called power counting . while writing the diagrams is trivial , their power counting is not . the connection of the eft to the fundamental theory at the scale @xmath3 is provided by renormalization , the core idea of eft . in its standard formulation renormalization deals with ultraviolet ( uv ) divergences in the feynman diagrams of the eft . to remove the divergences one includes an uv cut - off and allows the couplings in the lagrangian to depend on the cut - off . if the calculation of the observable quantities of the eft is independent of the cut - off then the eft is renormalizable . power counting is decided according to how we have to arrange calculations to remove the divergences at each order in the expansion . wilsonian renormalization @xcite provides an alternative but equivalent formulation . here the starting point is the independence of observables with respect to the cut - off . in this case it is the calculation of the couplings under the assumption of cut - off independence that leads to the size of these couplings at low energies and to their power counting @xcite . this is referred to as renormalization group : the focus is on the evolution of the couplings as the cut - off changes , not on the divergences . in wilsonian renormalization the cut - off runs from the high to the low energy scale , from @xmath3 to @xmath2 . this is counterintuitive from the standard point of view , where the cut - off runs from @xmath2 to @xmath3 with the purpose of finding out whether there are uv divergences . yet they are equivalent . the cut - off can either run to the ultraviolet or the infrared ( ir ) . as far as the observables are independent of the cut - off we end up with identical power countings . the starting point in wilsonian renormalization can be either an eft or the fundamental theory . the advantage in the first case is that power counting can be determined without a complete order - by - order calculation of observables . in the second case there is the possibility of evolving a fundamental theory from @xmath3 to @xmath2 , which amounts to uncovering the eft by means of a concrete calculation . of course this is only possible in the few cases where the fundamental theory is known or easily solvable ( a nice example can be found in ref . ) . this manuscript is dedicated to wilsonian renormalization in nuclear eft @xcite : even though it is less well - known than the standard idea of removing divergences , it can provide a clearer interpretation of power counting and the role of the cut - off in eft . in nuclear physics the eft usually contains nucleon and pion fields that are constrained by chiral symmetry , a low energy symmetry of qcd that is exact in the limit of massless @xmath5 , @xmath6 and sometimes @xmath7 quarks . the problem is that historically renormalization has been only well understood in the case of systems that are perturbative @xcite . this is the case in hadron physics for processes involving at most one baryon , where chiral perturbation theory ( chpt ) @xcite , the standard eft for low energy hadronic processes , is used . but in nuclear physics the existence of the deuteron and the virtual state ( the @xmath8 singlet ) , not to mention the few thousand known nuclei , indicates that the nuclear force is non - perturbative . besides there is the additional problem that eft entails nuclear forces that are strongly divergent at short distances . thus it is not a surprise that progress in nuclear eft has been full of unexpected turns and controversies . recently we have begun to have a solid grasp of the non - perturbative renormalization of the eft potentials @xcite and how to organize the power counting in this situation @xcite , but even these advances have been the subject of debate @xcite . here we will review power counting from the perspective of the renormalization group . historically events have unfolded in a zig - zag pattern . weinberg made the first proposal for a nuclear eft @xcite , which includes the iteration of the eft potential ( at least at lowest order ) . this serves to capture the non - perturbative character of nuclear interactions but in exchange requires non - perturbative renormalization . as previously said , this has been the source of a few surprises . kaplan , savage and wise ( ksw ) discovered a subtle but nonetheless serious inconsistency with the weinberg proposal @xcite . these authors also developed a new formulation of nuclear eft , the ksw counting @xcite , which is free from that inconsistency . however the convergence of the ksw counting in the triplet partial waves happened to be unsatisfying to say the least @xcite . the community turned back to the weinberg proposal in search for phenomenological success @xcite . but later nogga , timmermans and van kolck @xcite discovered that the weinberg proposal contains a new , more conspicuous inconsistency at the lowest order : it is not renormalizable in some p- and d - waves . new developments about renormalizability followed @xcite that made finally possible a consistent nuclear eft with good convergence properties @xcite . despite these advancements , there is an ongoing debate about whether these problems are relevant and whether it would be simply more sensible to reinterpret renormalizability for non - perturbative problems in a different way @xcite . we will not discuss these new developments , except for a brief comment . here we are mostly concerned about the derivation of eft power counting from a specific set of renormalization tools , which happen to be more than enough to make nuclear eft work at the theoretical level . from this perspective the previous ideas , though interesting , do not appear to be totally necessary . this manuscript is organized as follows : in sect . ii we introduce wilsonian renormalization for the particular case of non - relativistic scattering of two particles . part of it is general and part of it is specific to nuclear physics . we also discuss the relationship of power counting with the anomalous dimension of couplings and the relationship between wilsonian renormalization and the more standard approach of removing ultraviolet divergences . in sect . iii we extend the results beyond the two - nucleon system , in particular to the deuteron electroweak reactions and to the three - body problem . finally we summarize our conclusions . we also include an appendix discussing the derivation of a particular equation in this manuscript . here we illustrate how wilsonian renormalization works for non - relativistic s - wave scattering @xcite . the starting point is a `` fundamental theory '' . for a non - relativistic two - body system the equivalent of a fundamental theory is the non - relativistic potential @xmath9 . to obtain the scattering amplitudes we solve the schrdinger equation at finite momentum @xmath10 @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the reduced wave function , @xmath13 the reduced mass , @xmath10 the center of mass momentum and @xmath14 the underlying potential , which we assume to be known at all distances . as we are considering s - wave scattering there is no centrifugal term . we solve this equation with the regular boundary condition at the origin @xmath15 finally the phase shift can be extracted from the asymptotic wave function @xmath16 wilsonian renormalization works as follows . in a first step we include a cut - off @xmath17 as a separation scale @xmath18 we will consider that the physics at distances shorter than the cut - off @xmath19 is unknown . of course if we cut the potential for @xmath19 the physical observables will change . we want to prevent this from happening . in a second step we include a new piece in the potential that counteracts the loss of information from having a cut - off and keeps the observables unchanged . this extra piece is the contact - range potential , which can take many parametrizations . for simplicity we choose the following form for the contacts @xmath20 that is , an energy - dependent delta shell potential . now we solve the schrdinger equation with the `` renormalized '' potential @xmath21 for distances below @xmath17 we have a free schrdinger equation @xmath22 with the regular solution @xmath23 for distances above @xmath17 we have the original schrdinger equation , i.e. eq . ( [ eq : schro - fundamental ] ) . finally at @xmath24 the delta - shell potential @xmath25 generates a discontinuity in the first derivative of the wave function that takes the form @xmath26 where @xmath27 refers to @xmath28 , with @xmath29 . a derivation can be found in [ app : delta ] . this is the renormalization group equation ( rge ) for the contact - range coupling @xmath30 . the rge we have written above is exact : the starting point is the full potential @xmath9 and we want to check what type of contact interaction we have to include to account for the existence of a cut - off radius @xmath17 . for @xmath31 we have the boundary condition @xmath32 : we know the potential at all distances and there is no need for the contact - range couplings . as we increase the cut - off radius , we will need non - vanishing @xmath33 couplings to account for the missing physics . the reason we are interested in wilsonian renormalization is because we want to know how physics looks like at large distances in general . we want to describe phenomena at low energies regardless of which is the fundamental theory at high energies . with wilsonian renormalization we can build a theory for distances larger than the cut - off ( @xmath34 ) that is equivalent to the fundamental theory for momenta @xmath35 . in this context it is useful to define the soft and hard scales @xmath2 and @xmath3 . the soft scale @xmath2 is the characteristic momentum of the low energy physics we want to describe , while the hard scale @xmath3 is the natural momentum scale of the fundamental theory . if we solve the rge for @xmath36 we will be able to derive the kind of generic low energy theory we are interested in . to solve the rge and obtain the contact range couplings we simply have to make an ansatz for the wave function @xmath12 . the simplest case is provided by a theory in which the underlying potential has a finite range set by the hard scale @xmath3 @xmath37 with this is mind we see that the wave functions for @xmath38 are given by @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the phase shift of the fundamental potential @xmath9 . therefore the solution of the rge for @xmath41 is @xmath42 for finding the running of the individual @xmath33 couplings we expand the rge in powers of @xmath43 . we first take into account that @xmath9 is a finite - range potential and the effective range expansion applies ( for @xmath44 ) @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the scattering length , @xmath47 the effective range and @xmath48 the shape coefficients . now we expand and get the set of equations @xmath49 plus analogous equations for the higher order couplings . in the equations above @xmath50 and @xmath51 are polynomials of the cut - off @xmath17 and the effective range coefficients . they are easy to calculate but they are not included here because their exact form is inconsequential for the analysis that follows . the previous equations are generic solutions for an arbitrary finite range potential @xmath9 . however the counting of the couplings @xmath33 as @xmath52 depends on which is the size of the effective range coefficients and in particular the scattering length . in general the size of the effective range coefficients is known to scale according to the range of the potential ( therefore the name ) : @xmath53 the exception is the scattering length @xmath46 that can take any value , more so if there is non - perturbative physics . thus we distinguish two possibilities : @xmath54 the first one is a scattering length of natural size and the second an unnaturally large scattering length , which is what happens for instance if there is a bound state near the threshold . if the scattering length is of order @xmath55 we are entitled to expand in powers of @xmath56 because @xmath41 . we obtain @xmath57 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] that is , @xmath58 scales as @xmath59 . if we analyze now the subleading couplings @xmath33 , we find for @xmath60 @xmath61 + c_2^r(r_c ; a_0 ) \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] that is , @xmath62 scales as @xmath63 . in the equation above @xmath64 is a `` redundant '' piece of the coupling @xmath60 that does not contain information about a the effective range @xmath47 . the function of @xmath64 is to absorb the cut - off dependence that the @xmath65 coupling generates at finite energy . the @xmath64 piece of @xmath60 is inessential for power counting . for @xmath66 we have @xmath67 + c_4^r(r_c ; a_0 , r_0 ) \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which scales as @xmath68 and where @xmath69 is analogous to @xmath64 , only that it absorbs the residual cut - off dependence of @xmath65 and @xmath60 . for the higher order couplings we have @xmath70 . the other possibility is that the scattering length is large : @xmath71 . now the cut - off and the scattering length can have the same size and we are not allowed to expand in powers of @xmath56 . if we solve the rge for @xmath65 we obtain @xmath72 which means @xmath73 , an enhancement of one power of @xmath74 . for the @xmath62 coupling we get @xmath75 which entails @xmath76 , an enhancement of two powers of @xmath74 . for the @xmath77 coupling we find @xmath78 and in general for the @xmath30 we have @xmath79 which implies a @xmath80 enhancement over the natural case . the first implementation of this type of rg analysis of the couplings in nuclear eft is due to birse , mcgovern and richardson @xcite , who formulated the rges in momentum space . instead of imposing the invariance of the phase shifts with respect to the regulator , their analysis requires the invariance of the full off - shell t - matrix . for contact - range interactions both conditions are equivalent : on - shell renormalization implies off - shell renormalization . probably this is the case too for finite - range potentials ( it has been proved for potentials that have power - law divergences near the origin @xcite ) . the analysis of the rges in momentum space is pretty convoluted though . the analysis of the coordinate space rges of ref . is simpler as it only depends on the schrdinger equation and its solutions . it connects the rges with the cut - off dependence of the observables after an arbitrary number of contact - range operators are included . but at the same time it neglects how the rges relate to the power counting of the couplings . the purpose of this section has been to close this gap and to translate the rg analysis of ref . from momentum to coordinate space , attempting to make its interpretation clearer in the way . the question we wanted to answer is : what kind of low energy theory does one derive from the rges ? the answer involves two ingredients . the first is a non - relativistic potential for the low energy theory , the effective potential : @xmath81 that is , the contact - range potential that compensates the cut - off dependence . the fundamental potential @xmath9 does not enter into the effective potential for the simple reason that it vanishes at large distances ( @xmath38 ) . the second ingredient is the size of the couplings , that we have already calculated from the rges . as a consequence of the scaling properties of the couplings we can write the effective potential as a power series in @xmath4 . let us consider the example of a theory with a natural scattering length , for which we have @xmath82 if we take into account the typical factors of @xmath83 and the reduced mass that are common in non - relativistic scattering , the previous scaling allows to rewrite the @xmath30 couplings as @xmath84 where @xmath85 is a number of @xmath86 . now we plug this expression into the effective potential . we arrive to @xmath87 that is , a power series in @xmath4 . for large scattering length we have instead @xmath88 with @xmath89 and @xmath90 for @xmath91 . in this case the expansion of the potential reads @xmath92 \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] independently of the power counting of the couplings we end up with a series that converges for @xmath93 . this idea of arranging the effective potential as a power series extends to every physical quantity we can think of . it is a fundamental concept in eft , the reason why calculations are systematic . we can predict observable quantities up to a given degree of accuracy , that is , up to a given power of the expansion parameter @xmath94 . the calculations are organized as to only include the operators that contribute within the accuracy goals we have set up in the first place . we can illustrate this concept with the phase shift . in perturbation theory the phase shift is expanded as @xmath95 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] i.e. the born approximation followed by second and higher order perturbation theory . that is , we have written a coordinate space version of the lippmann - schwinger equation . in the expression above @xmath96 is a green function , which we can take to be @xmath97 \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] if the scattering length is natural , the size of the born and second order term are @xmath98 \ , , \\ \frac{2 \mu}{k}\,\langle v g_0 v \rangle & = & { \left(\frac{q}{m } \right)}^2\,f_2(k r_c)\ , { \left [ \sum_{n=0}^{\infty } c_{2n}(r_c)\ , { \left ( \frac{q}{m } \right)}^{2n } \right]}^2 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath99 , @xmath100 is simply a compact notation for the first and second order of the perturbative series and @xmath101 , @xmath102 are functions that encode the cut - off dependence . if we continue we will find that for higher order perturbations we have @xmath103}^r \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath104 refers to the number of insertions of the potential @xmath9 . the eft expansion for the phase shift starts at @xmath4 leading order ( lo ) from now on and second order perturbation theory carries an additional factor of @xmath4 over the born approximation . analogously each additional iteration of the potential involves an extra power of @xmath4 . putting all the pieces together , the @xmath105 calculation only contains @xmath65 at tree level , the next - to - leading order ( @xmath106 ) calculation requires to include two iterations of @xmath65 , the next - to - next - to - leading order ( @xmath107 ) calculation contains @xmath60 at tree level and three iterations of @xmath65 . higher orders calculations are set up in a similar fashion . for the large scattering length case the evaluation of the perturbative series for the tangent of the phase shift leads to @xmath108 \ , , \\ \frac{2 \mu}{k}\,\langle v g_0 v \rangle & = & f_2'(k r_c)\ , { \left [ c_0(r_c ) + \sum_{n=1}^{\infty } c_{2n}(r_c)\ , { \left ( \frac{q}{m } \right)}^{2n } \right]}^2 \ , , \\ \frac{2 \mu}{k}\,\underbrace{\langle v g_0 \dots g_0 v \rangle}_{\mbox{$r$ iterations of $ v$ } } & = & f_r'(k r_c)\ , { \left [ c_0(r_c ) + \sum_{n=1}^{\infty } c_{2n}(r_c)\ , { \left ( \frac{q}{m } \right)}^{2n } \right]}^r \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] now the eft expansion of the phase shift begins at order @xmath109 , which is the @xmath105 for this power counting ( i.e. the @xmath105 is defined differently for each scaling of the couplings ) . it is also apparent that the @xmath105 calculation contains all the iterations of the @xmath65 coupling . that is , @xmath65 is non - perturbative at @xmath105 . however all the other couplings are perturbative : @xmath60 enters at tree level at @xmath106 , @xmath77 at @xmath110 and @xmath30 at @xmath111 . a systematic exposition of the diagrams involved in the calculation of the amplitudes ( for natural and unnatural scattering length ) can be found in ref . . the previous analysis can be extended to the possibility that the potential can be separated into a short and long range piece @xmath112 the range of @xmath113 scales as @xmath3 , while the range of @xmath114 as @xmath2 . to determine the effect of a long range potential on the power counting we follow the previous steps : introduce a cut - off and include a contact - range potential to keep physics unchanged . the couplings @xmath30 of the contact - range potential can be calculated from the rge , i.e. eq . ( [ eq : rge ] ) . for @xmath41 the short - range potential vanishes and the wave functions that enter into the rge are solutions of @xmath115 with the boundary conditions @xmath116 with @xmath40 the phase shift of the full potential @xmath117 . we are interested in the wave functions in the distance range @xmath118 . the condition @xmath38 is necessary if we use a wave function that is a solution of the long range potential @xmath114 . a soft cut - off let s say @xmath119 is perfectly acceptable . but a excessively soft cut - off of the order of @xmath120 is not : for this choice of the cut - off the long range potential @xmath114 vanishes and we end up with the power counting of a pure short range potential . everything that is left is to calculate the wave functions for the long range potential . in general the form of the solution of the wave function will take the form @xmath121 where @xmath122 and @xmath123 are two linearly independent solutions of @xmath114 and @xmath124 a coefficient that selects the particular linear combination . if we expand the solutions in powers of @xmath43 @xmath125 and the coefficient @xmath124 as @xmath126 we end up with the following expressions for the running of the @xmath30 couplings @xmath127 plus analogous expressions for the higher order couplings , where the wave functions and their derivatives are understood to be evaluated at @xmath24 . in the expression above , @xmath128 is a polynomial of @xmath129 and @xmath130 , @xmath131 and its derivatives that encodes the residual cut - off dependence . a few general comments might be of help at this point . first : the coefficient @xmath124 can be thought of as the analogous of the ere in the presence of a long range potential . what this means is that the set of coefficients @xmath132 , @xmath133 , etc . , will scale according to inverse powers of @xmath3 . the exception is @xmath129 , which could take any value if @xmath113 is non - perturbative . second : if the long range potential is perturbative , the wave functions will coincide with the free wave functions at tree level in perturbation theory . the couplings will also accept a perturbative expansion , but at tree level will coincide with the couplings of the short - range case . thus the power counting does not change if the long range potential is perturbative . in nuclear physics the longest range piece of the interaction is the one pion exchange ( ope ) potential . this potential can be written as @xmath134 \ , \vec{\tau}_1 \cdot \vec{\tau}_2 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath135 and @xmath136 are the spin and isospin operators acting on the nucleon 1(2 ) , @xmath137 is the pion mass , @xmath138 the nucleon mass and @xmath139 is a mass scale that characterizes the strength of the ope potential ( its value is of the order of @xmath140 ) . the tensor operator is defined as @xmath141 , while @xmath142 and @xmath143 refer to the spin - spin and tensor components of the potential @xmath144 we will ignore the complications coming from the tensor operator and will concentrate on the fundamentals : ( i ) @xmath145 vanishes in the singlet and ( ii ) @xmath142 and @xmath143 behave as a @xmath146 and a @xmath147 potential respectively . before analyzing the power counting with ope it will be helpful to comment on the role of @xmath139 . notice that we have written the ope potential as @xmath148 where @xmath149 is a polynomial that contains a @xmath150 , @xmath151 and @xmath147 term , where all the terms have three powers of @xmath152 . the analogy with the contact - range potential is clear , more so if we write @xmath25 as @xmath153 where we can appreciate that the @xmath154 factor in @xmath155 plays the same role as the @xmath65 coupling in @xmath156 . that is , if we count @xmath139 as @xmath3 the ope potential will be perturbative @xcite . on the contrary if we count @xmath139 as @xmath2 the ope potential will be non - perturbative @xcite . we are interested in the later case : as we have already pointed out , if ope is perturbative the counting is the same as that of a pure short - range potential . the bottom line is that non - perturbative ope goes along with the assumption that @xmath139 is a light scale . the idea that non - perturbative ope requires the existence of an additional light scale ( besides the obvious choices such as the external momenta , the pion mass or the inverse of the scattering length ) was probably _ explicitly _ realized in ref . for the first time . in ref . one can see how to include this scale in the rg equations and what kind of consequence it has for the power counting . the @xmath146 potential , which corresponds to the ope potential in the @xmath8 singlet , is the easiest to analyze . here we are not going to enter into the specific details of how to do the detailed analysis . we merely comment that the power counting is unchanged with respect to the case where there is no long range potential @xcite . that is , there are two possible arrangements of the power counting : a natural one , in which the couplings scale as @xmath70 and an unnatural one , in which the couplings scale as @xmath157 and @xmath158 . the reason for that is that the @xmath146 potential is not strong enough as to modify the behaviour of the wave functions in the distance window @xmath159 . even if the strength of the potential is such as to generate a low lying bound state , the wave functions are only substantially modified for @xmath160 . however this cut - off range is not of interest for power counting because we are already making the assumption that @xmath161 . for the @xmath162 triplet the potential behaves as an attractive @xmath147 for @xmath163 , which induces important changes in the scaling of the couplings triplet is a coupled channel and the ope is a matrix : the tensor operator contains an attractive and repulsive eigenvalue , and the attractive one happens to have a bigger impact on power counting . ] . the first thing to notice is that there is not anymore a natural and unnatural power counting . the solutions of the wave function are all equally fine - tuned : there is not a more natural or preferred solution ( see ref . for a different conclusion though ) . the reason is that the attractive @xmath147 potential has no unique solution in quantum mechanics : the choice of the solution inherently depends on the existence of short range physics , which is the only responsible for fixing the wave function . every linear combination of independent wave functions is equally acceptable . for @xmath163 the wave function can be written as @xcite @xmath164 \ , , \label{eq : uk_lo}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath165 is a dimensionless number and @xmath166 is a phase the semiclassical phase that characterizes the particular solution we are dealing with . the value of @xmath166 depends on the short - range physics . the changes in the counting are the following : @xmath167 this result requires a careful examination of the scaling properties of @xmath166 , which are not trivial ( the derivation is not contained here but will be included in a future publication ) . as a matter of fact the counting with an attractive tensor force is more similar to nda than to that of a short range potential with large scattering length . for a repulsive singular potential the analysis is analogous with the exception of a few details . the wave function is @xmath168 \nonumber \\ & \times & \left [ 1 + \mathcal{o}(\sqrt{\lambda_{\rm nn } r } , \,k^2 r^2\ , , m r ) \right ] \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath169 a coefficient that depends on the short - range physics . it is expected to be small and as happened with @xmath170 its scaling properties are important in the detailed analysis , yet they are not trivial . the scaling of the coupling now is @xmath171 that is , the only difference with the attractive case is the scaling of the @xmath65 coupling . however the previous scaling properties are difficult to interpret . it is sensible to expect that the importance of short - range physics within eft depends on the long - range dynamics . the attractive @xmath147 potential complies with this expectation : as a consequence of the strong attraction the wave function is enhanced at short distances , which in turn enhances the short - range couplings . for the repulsive @xmath147 potential we expect the contrary to happen , that the size of the @xmath30 couplings diminishes . what happens is precisely the contrary , which is puzzling to say the least . with this we have finished the discussion of power counting for the moment . the types of power counting and the physical situations to which they correspond are summarized in table [ tab : counting ] . of course they are not the only types of power counting that can be built , but they are for sure the most relevant ones for nuclear eft . now i will try to show how to rederive these counting rules with other methods . in particular i will consider the calculation of anomalous dimensions , ultraviolet renormalizability and residual cut - off dependence . summary of the power counting for s - wave two - body scattering . the table indicates when the coupling enters as a power of @xmath2 ( and the relative order in parenthesis ) . in the text we have considered the case of a pionless and a pionful eft . for pionless the scaling of the couplings depends on the size of the scattering length . for pionful the scaling is identical to the pionless case if either one of these conditions is met : ( i ) pion exchanges are perturbative ( ii ) pion exchanges are non - perturbative but there is only the central piece . if the tensor piece is non - perturbative the scaling of the couplings will be modified with respect to the previous cases . we show this in the table by indicating whether the long - range potential is zero ( @xmath172 ) , perturbative ( @xmath173 ) or non - perturbative ( @xmath174 ) and then the type of long - range potential ( @xmath146 or @xmath147 ) . finally in the last row we indicate the size of a perturbation of @xmath65 , which determines whether the power counting is infrared stable or unstable ( see discussion around eq . [ eq : dc0 ] ) [ tab : counting ] there is a very interesting simplification in the above calculations : it is enough to take into account the cutoff dependence of @xmath30 to guess its scaling @xcite . more specifically we refer to the cut - off dependence for @xmath175 ( @xmath176 ) , a condition that will remarkably simplify the discussion below . if we consider a two - body system with natural scattering length the cut - off dependence of the @xmath30 couplings is trivial @xmath177 \ , , \\ c_{2n}(r_c ) & = & \frac{2\pi}{\mu}\,a_0 ^ 2\,v_n \,\times\ , \left[1 + \mathcal{o}(\frac{r_c}{a_0 } ) \right ] \ , , \quad \mbox{for $ n \geq 1$,}\end{aligned}\ ] ] while for a system with a large scattering length we have @xmath178 \ , , \\ c_{2n}(r_c ) & = & \frac{2\pi}{\mu}\,r_c^2\,v_n \ , \times \ , \left [ 1 + \mathcal{o}(\frac{r_c}{a_0 } ) \right ] \quad \mbox{for $ n \geq 1$,}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where to simplify the notation we have taken @xmath179 . that is , the power - law dependence on the cut - off matches the enhancement of the coupling . the rule is simple : if @xmath180 for @xmath181 the size of @xmath30 for @xmath52 is @xmath182 , a @xmath183 enhancement . equivalently , in momentum space , if @xmath184 for @xmath185 the size of @xmath30 for @xmath186 is @xmath182 . why is that so ? actually the idea can be better explained with a momentum space cut - off . if the couplings scale as @xmath187 with respect to the radial cut - off @xmath17 , in momentum space they will scale as or @xmath188 . ] @xmath189 which simply amounts to take into account that @xmath190 . this scaling property implies that the couplings follow a rge of the type @xmath191 = 0 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the dots refer to corrections involving smaller powers of @xmath188 . for the moment we will assume that this rge is valid in the cut - off window @xmath192 . if we ignore the dots the solution is straightforward @xmath193 with @xmath194 and @xmath195 two arbitrary cut - offs . therefore with a boundary condition we can get the running of the couplings for arbitrary @xmath188 this boundary condition is the value of the couplings at @xmath196 . at this scale we expect the couplings to scale with @xmath3 ( we do not expect @xmath2 to play a role at high energies , which means that @xmath3 is the only relevant scale ) , which implies @xmath197 as a consequence @xmath198 which is the expected enhancement for @xmath30 . in short , the scaling of the coupling decides the power counting . this idea is not new and has appeared in different contexts . in the ksw counting @xcite the hard scale can be deduced from the running of the @xmath199 coupling : the scaling of @xmath199 changes when @xmath188 approaches @xmath139 , which happens to be the hard scale in ksw instead of @xmath188 . it is also worth noticing that ksw does not use a cut - off regularization , but a variant of dimensional regularization . ] . recently it has been applied in nuclear eft for the analysis of reactions on the deuteron @xcite . there is the issue of where the rge of the @xmath30 couplings comes from , which is related to the calculation of the power @xmath200 that appears in it . the starting point in wilsonian renormalization is to include a cut - off and then require observable quantities to be independent of the cut - off @xmath201 where @xmath202 is the wave function and @xmath203 an operator corresponding to an observable . notice that here we are demanding the matrix element to be independent of the cut - off . actually this condition is too strong observables are the square modulus of matrix elements but in most situations it will work . if we are in the cut - off window @xmath192 we can substitute the wave function and the operator by the corresponding ones in the eft @xmath204 moreover the operator @xmath205 can be divided into a contact- and finite - range piece @xmath206 now we can rewrite @xmath207 which tell us that the contact - range piece has two functions : to absorb the cut - off dependence of the finite - range piece and to directly contribute to the matrix element . had we used the full wave function @xmath202 and the full operator @xmath203 instead of the eft ones , the contact would have only been there to absorb the cut - off dependence ( the contacts vanish for @xmath208 ) . but within the eft description the contacts must have a non - trivial contribution to the observables regardless of the cut - off . the reason is that the finite - range piece of the eft potential / wave function / operator does not correspond to the fundamental potential / wave function / operator . the bottom line is that for the contact - range operators we can distinguish between a piece that directly contributes to observables and a piece that absorbs cut - off dependence @xmath209 where the superscript @xmath210 and @xmath211 stand for `` direct '' and `` residual '' . this distinction is analogous to the one that we made previously for the running of the @xmath30 in short - range theories . each of these pieces follows a different rge @xmath212 corresponding to their different roles within eft . notice that we are assuming that the distinction between @xmath213 and @xmath214 exists . this is not clear ( if we want the definitions to be unambiguous ) , but we are only using this distinction to simplify the arguments here . we can write a contact - range operator @xmath215 as a coupling times a polynomial involving the light scales in momentum space @xmath216 where @xmath217 is the coupling and @xmath218 is the polynomial , which can be regularized ( hence the subscript @xmath188 ) . if we include this general form in the rge for the `` direct '' piece we arrive to @xmath219 & = & 0 \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] what is left is to determine the cut - off dependence of the matrix element of the polynomial , which in general will take the form @xmath220 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the form of the corrections follow from the assumption that the rge are valid in the region @xmath221 , that is , from the analyticity of the rge which in turn implies that we can write a power series on @xmath222 and @xmath223 . the previous discussion is rather general and concerns any observable that receives a direct , linear contribution from a contact - range operator . in the case of two - body scattering the matrix element we are interested in is the t - matrix @xmath224 which is not receiving a linear contribution from the contact - range physics , at least at first sight . the t - matrix is the solution of the lippmann - schwinger equation @xmath225 which is a convenient way of rewriting the schrdinger equation for a scattering problem . in eft we can expand the t - matrix and the potential as power series @xmath226 or more concisely as @xmath227 that is , a lo contribution plus a subleading correction . the interesting thing here is that the subleading correction to the t - matrix is perturbative and is given by @xmath228 \\ & = & \langle \psi_{\rm lo } | \delta\,v_{\rm eft } | \psi_{\rm lo } \rangle + \mathcal{o}\left [ { \left(\delta\,v_{\rm eft}\right)}^2 \right ] \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where in the second line @xmath229 is the lo wave function ( @xmath230 ) . if we ignore the iteration of @xmath231 , make the separations @xmath232 and follow the steps previously described , we end up with the rge @xmath233 the solution of this rge depends on the evaluation of the matrix element of the contact - range potential . the details depend on the particular representation for the contacts . for a delta - shell representation in coordinate space @xmath234 the evaluation is trivial @xmath235 with @xmath12 the @xmath236 reduced wave function . we can concentrate on the evaluation of a particular coupling @xmath30 , in which case we obtain @xmath237 where @xmath238 is the zero - energy @xmath236 reduced wave function . the rge for the coupling @xmath30 reads @xmath239 = 0 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which means that the running is determined by the power - law dependence of the wave function for @xmath240 . in a purely short - range theory the running of the @xmath30 couplings is easy to compute . the zero - energy wave function is @xmath241 where @xmath242 is a normalization factor that is arbitrary ( it does not affect the running of @xmath30 ) . we remind the reader that we are interested in the region @xmath243 . if the scattering length is natural ( @xmath244 ) , we can take @xmath245 and rewrite the wave function as @xmath246 \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore the rge for the couplings is @xmath247 = 0 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] as a consequence @xmath248 , in agreement with the previous determination . if the scattering length is large ( @xmath71 ) , we set the normalization to @xmath249 to express the wave function as @xmath250 which leads to the rge @xmath251 = 0 \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] that is , the couplings scale as @xmath252 . there is a point of explain here : the counting of @xmath65 can not always be determined with this method . the reason is that we are calculating the scaling of the perturbative piece of the potential . if @xmath65 is perturbative in the first place we will obtain the correct scaling this is the case in a short - range theory with natural scattering length , where we get @xmath253 . on the contrary if @xmath65 is non - perturbative the ideas presented here do not apply . we know that @xmath65 is enhanced by @xmath254 if the scattering length is large . yet the application of this method to @xmath65 is not useless : it gives us information about the scaling of a small , perturbative change of @xmath65 @xmath255 where @xmath256 is enhanced as @xmath80 . that is , the perturbation @xmath256 is of lower order than the original unperturbed coupling @xmath65 . how is that so ? the meaning of this enhancement for @xmath257 is that systems with large scattering lengths are fine - tuned @xcite . a minor change in @xmath65 generates a large change in the scattering length . in particular @xmath258 which entails @xmath259 . from the rg flow perspective the natural solution represents a stable fixed point of the rg equations and the large scattering length solution an unstable fixed point @xcite . that is , the running of the @xmath65 coupling eventually behaves as a constant as @xmath260 . but if the scattering length is large @xmath65 will scale as @xmath261 only as far as @xmath262 . the scaling of @xmath256 for the different cases that we are considering can be consulted in table [ tab : counting ] . the extension to the pionful eft is trivial but requires a case - by - case discussion . if pion exchanges are perturbative ( i.e. subleading ) , the power counting is exactly the same as in the short - range case . the reason is that the @xmath105 wave functions are identical to the short - range case . if pion exchanges are non - perturbative ( i.e. leading ) , the power counting depends on whether the potential is @xmath146 ( central ) or @xmath147 ( tensor ) . for central ope the power counting is again as for a short - range potential because the wave functions behave either as @xmath263 or as @xmath104 for @xmath240 . however for attractive tensor ope the power counting changes . using the wave function written in eq . [ eq : uk_lo ] we find @xmath264 } + \dots \right ] = 0 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the dots account for power - law corrections , which are at least of order @xmath265 ( @xmath266 ) . it is worth noting that the corrections to the wave function were computed in ref . for the @xmath267 triplet . it can be checked that they do not affect the counting . the conclusion is that the @xmath30 are bigger than expected by a factor of @xmath268 . the title of this section makes mention of the _ anomalous dimension_. what is that ? the concept is easy to understand . let us assume that we have a physical quantity ( operator , coupling , observable ) @xmath269 where @xmath270 depends on the light scale @xmath2 , on the cut - off @xmath188 and the hard scale @xmath3 . we can define several types of dimensions for @xmath270 . the most obvious one is the canonical dimension @xmath6 , which can be related to the rescaling @xmath271 that is , the canonical dimension refers to how @xmath270 changes with a change of physical units . another type of dimension we can define is the power counting dimension , which refers to a rescaling of @xmath2 ( and @xmath272 only @xmath273 it is important to notice that while the canonical dimension of a physical quantity is unique , the power counting dimension is not . rather a physical quantity is a superposition of contributions with different power counting dimensions @xmath274 the inclusion of @xmath188 among the things we rescale for the power counting dimension seems counter - intuitive at first , but it is natural once we consider the argument about the rg evolution of cut - off dependent quantities from @xmath196 to @xmath275 . finally the anomalous dimension can be defined as @xmath276 which is exactly the kind of power - law dependence on the cut - off that we have been studying along this section . thus we can restate that the anomalous dimension of a coupling is what determines its power counting . wilsonian renormalization is not the most popular or widely understood method of analyzing power counting in efts . this honor corresponds to ultraviolet ( uv ) renormalizability , in which contact - range couplings are included to absorb divergences in feynman diagrams . quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) provides a good illustration of this idea for a quantum field theory ( qft ) that only contains marginal or relevant operators for @xmath277 , while for a marginal operator the coupling runs either as a constant , as @xmath278 or more generally as something that is not power - law . ] , i.e. what is traditionally known as a _ renormalizable _ qft . at this point it is important to mention that nowadays after the discovery of efts renormalizability is understood in a broader sense . yet for efts the application of this principle is simple : we begin by considering the matrix element of an eft operator between eft wave functions @xmath279 the operator contains a finite- and a contact - range piece . for the moment we will ignore the contact - range piece because we want to use these operators to remove divergences in the finite - range piece . thus we consider @xmath280 now we expand this matrix element in powers of @xmath94 as before . to simplify the analysis we only take into account the @xmath105 wave functions @xmath281-th order contribution , include a cut - off @xmath188 and check whether the matrix element @xmath282 is finite for @xmath208 . if not , we include contact - range contributions until the matrix element @xmath283 , the contact is counted as being of this order . we can illustrate the idea in non - relativistic scattering , where the relevant matrix element is @xmath284 where @xmath285 represents the @xmath105 reduced wave function and @xmath17 ( @xmath286 ) is the radial cut - off . in the formula above a contribution to the finite - range potential is said to be of order @xmath287 when it contains @xmath287 powers of the light scales in the momentum space representation @xmath288 where @xmath2 includes @xmath289 , @xmath290 , the pion mass @xmath137 in pionful nuclear eft and/or other scales depending on the particular eft we are dealing with . the expression @xmath291 refers to an arbitrary ratio of light scales ( for instance , @xmath292 and @xmath293 in nuclear eft ) and @xmath294 is a non - polynomial function that we must compute from the eft lagrangian , but which exact form is not important at this point . if we fourier - transform this expression into coordinate space ( and assume for simplicity that the potential is local ) , we find @xmath295 where @xmath291 refers to @xmath296 in nuclear physics . the point is that we know the uv behaviour of the eft potential . provided we have the @xmath105 wave functions we can analyze the matrix element @xmath297 for divergences and decide which contacts to include . the complete analysis can be found in refs . . here we merely comment on the results . if the @xmath105 wave function comes from the @xmath146 potential , perturbative and wilsonian renormalization lead to identical power countings . this is also true if the @xmath105 wave function comes from a purely contact - range potential . on the contrary if the @xmath105 potential is of the @xmath147 type and attractive there is a small , yet significant difference between perturbative and wilsonian renormalization . removing the divergences only requires the @xmath30 to enter at order @xmath298 , in contrast with @xmath299 from rge . the apparent scaling of the couplings is thus @xmath300 , i.e. an extra suppression of @xmath301 with respect to the wilsonian renormalization value @xmath302 . if the @xmath105 @xmath147 potential is repulsive the matrix elements for scattering are always finite and no contact interaction is required . however we will not discuss this problem here . back to the attractive @xmath147 potential the reason for the mismatch probably has to do with the @xmath43 expansion of the @xmath105 wave function , which induces a contamination of @xmath303 into the @xmath30 coupling . in fact the @xmath43 expansion of the @xmath105 wave function reads @xmath304\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath165 , @xmath129 , @xmath132 , @xmath133 , etc . numerical coefficients and where @xmath170 now is independent of energy wave functions for the rg equations we included an energy - dependent semiclassical phase ( see eq . [ eq : uk_lo ] ) , instead of an energy - independent one like here . the reason is that here we are writing the @xmath105 wave functions , in which only the energy - independent @xmath65 operator contributes , while there we were writing the generic solution of the @xmath147 potential with arbitrary short - range physics . ] . we can see that each two powers of @xmath10 imply half a power of @xmath139 as a consequence the couplings that make the matrix element of the potential finite are not the standard @xmath30 s but implicitly contain @xmath305 half integer powers of @xmath139 . that is , they have a different operator structure : @xmath306 instead of @xmath307 . in the same way that it is useful to make the distinction @xmath308 we can also write @xmath309 to make the different structure of these couplings explicit . in this notation the @xmath310 s happen to be enhanced by @xmath311 , just as the @xmath30 s . however the drawback of this explanation is that unlike the @xmath312 coupling , the proposed @xmath310 couplings do not have a clear interpretation at the lagrangian level . the analysis of the residual cut - off dependence of the matrix elements is another method for determining the power counting @xcite . first we will review the theoretical basis for this idea : for that we consider a matrix element for which all uv divergences have been removed at the arbitrary order @xmath13 . the matrix element still contains a residual cut - off dependence that vanishes for @xmath313 : @xmath314 where @xmath315 refers to the contact - range potential that renormalizes the order @xmath13 calculation , while @xmath316 and @xmath317 are coefficients . the point is that the residual cut - off dependence indicates that the next new higher - order coupling of the contact - range potential enters at order @xmath318 . what is the reason for that ? let us assume that the next divergence indeed enters at order @xmath318 . the softest divergence that we are expected to find in the matrix elements of the potential is logarithmic , thus @xmath319 where the previous matrix element is the one for the finite - range potential at order @xmath318 plus the number of contact - range couplings that is expected at order @xmath13 . notice that the value of these couplings change order - by - order , but their number only changes at the order at which a new @xmath30 coupling is included : we have written @xmath320 with a prime to indicate this fact . as the divergence of the finite - range potential is @xmath321 , it is not difficult to infer that going one order down translates into a residual cut - off dependence of @xmath17 while going one order up gives rise to a @xmath322 divergence . equivalently , if we move @xmath323 orders down the expansion the residual cut - off dependence will be @xmath324 , from which the previous conclusion about power counting follows . after this an example might be the best way to illustrate the method . the easiest one is that of a contact - range theory with a large scattering length . if we solve @xmath325 at @xmath105 for the delta - shell short - range potential that we have been using , we obtain the result @xmath326\ , k^2 + \mathcal{o}(k^4 ) \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the residual cut - off dependence if of order @xmath17 . the conclusion is that the next counterterm is one order below @xmath65 . that is , @xmath60 enter at @xmath327 . if we now proceed to compute @xmath325 at @xmath106 we find calculation includes @xmath60 at first order perturbation theory . otherwise the residual cut - off dependence will be different . ] @xmath328\ , k^4 + \mathcal{o}(k^6 ) \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the residual cut - off dependence is now of order @xmath261 : @xmath77 enters two orders below @xmath60 , that is @xmath110 . strictly speaking residual cut - off dependence is a constructive process and we can use it to determine the location of only the next coupling that enters in the theory , but not more . if we want to find the order of @xmath329 we must first compute the @xmath110 amplitudes that contain @xmath77 and from this extract the residual cut - off dependence . alternatively , we can always rely on the natural expectation that @xmath329 should enter two orders below @xmath77 . finally it is interesting to check the predictions of this idea for the tensor force . on general grounds we expect the cut - off dependence of a @xmath236 calculation of the phase shift with attractive tensor ope to be @xcite @xmath330 which after integration leads to a residual dependence of @xmath331 . this indicates that @xmath60 enters at @xmath332 in agreement with the previous determinations . the central point of this section has been to review how we can derive power counting in wilsonian renormalization . the application of renormalization group analysis ( rga ) to nuclear eft , though sometimes considered a bit arcane , can lead to interesting insights . to illustrate the idea we have taken non - relativistic s - wave scattering as an example and shown in detail how to derive well - known facts about power counting in the two - body sector that we review in table [ tab : counting ] . we have used two equivalent rg formulations . the first is the standard one in which the starting point is a `` fundamental theory '' : we include a cut - off in the theory and then evolve it from the ultraviolet to the infrared . as a result we find a physical theory the eft that is equivalent to the fundamental theory at low energies . the eft incorporates the familiar counting rules that we already know , for instance the enhancement of the couplings when the scattering length is large . the second is a more streamlined formulation in which we do not directly evolve the eft from the fundamental theory and instead use a convenient shortcut to determine the size of the effective couplings . this shortcut is the calculation of the anomalous dimension of the couplings , which turns out to be relatively easy , at least in the two - body case . as we will see , this is also the case for reactions of external probes on two - body states and for the three - body problem in pionless . other important point is the relationship between rga and more standard techniques of determining the power counting . by more standard techniques we refer to ultraviolet renormalization and residual cut - off dependence . in principle we expect all derivations to be equivalent . in practice this equivalence has to be shown by means of concrete calculations . the results indicate the direct equivalence with rge in the absence of singular pion exchanges , i.e. in the absence of the tensor force . if the tensor force is present there is an apparent contradiction though : the @xmath30 couplings seem to be more demoted in ultraviolet renormalization than in rga or in residual cut - off dependence . this disagreement can be explained as a contamination of the @xmath30 couplings with the @xmath139 scale . in other words , what we call @xmath30 in ultraviolet renormalization is not really the @xmath30 coupling , but rather a coupling with the structure @xmath333 instead of the expected @xmath334 . this distinction is in fact analogous to the one that is usually made between @xmath65 and @xmath335 . there are a few open problems that we have not addressed though . the most obvious example is the power counting of the triplet channels where the ope potential is a repulsive @xmath147 . the rg evolution of the couplings indicates that , with the exception of @xmath65 , the scaling of the couplings is identical to that of the attractive @xmath147 potential . this conclusion agrees with a previous rga of the ope potential @xcite , but it is counterintuitive to say the least . if the long - range physics is repulsive we expect that the short - range physics will play a lesser role at low energies because the repulsive long - range physics acts as a potential barrier . that is why some authors prefer to use naive dimensional analysis in this case @xcite . other problem that is related to the previous one is what happens with coupled channels such as the @xmath267 deuteron channel . in this latter case three different countings have been proposed @xcite . even in the attractive triplet channels there are two proposals about the scaling of the @xmath65 coupling : does it enter at @xmath236 ( @xmath336 ) or at @xmath337 ( @xmath338 ) ? the rga of birse @xcite assumes that @xmath65 is @xmath337 in the attractive triplet channels . but here we have taken the view that @xmath65 is @xmath236 : it has to be there because the @xmath236 wave function of a non - perturbative attractive triplet is not well defined without the inclusion of short - range physics . we find it worth noticing that the perturbation @xmath256 of this coupling is @xmath337(@xmath338 ) , which is where @xmath65 is predicted to be by birse s rga @xcite . that is , the cause of the disagreement seems to be that ref . overlooks the presence of short - range physics in the @xmath236 wave functions : the @xmath65 coupling is implicit in the choice of a semiclassical phase , i.e. the choice of @xmath170 in eq . ( [ eq : uk_lo ] ) . one last problem is the scaling of the @xmath30 couplings in the @xmath8 singlet . the standard counting @xcite is that the piece of @xmath30 that carries physical information enters at @xmath339 : @xmath60 at @xmath327 , @xmath77 at @xmath340 , @xmath329 at @xmath341 , etc . long and yang @xcite get to a different conclusion instead : the @xmath30 s enter at @xmath342 : @xmath60 at @xmath327 , @xmath77 at @xmath343 , @xmath329 at @xmath340 , etc . the conclusion is a bit puzzling : according to ref . , dimensional regularization with minimal subtraction leads to a stronger enhancement of the @xmath30 couplings than cut - off regularization other aspect to discuss is the interpretation of the cut - off in eft . the rg equations use a cut - off in the region @xmath192 . this raises the question of whether the cut - off should stay below the breakdown scale , as happens in the rga . the answer is _ not necessarily_. the rg equations are formulated with the limits @xmath344 and @xmath345 in mind to uncover the scaling of the couplings this is a formal requirement to make the analysis easier , not a practical requirement in eft calculations . efts are rg - invariant : the cut - off does not appear in the observable quantities that we compute , only in the intermediate calculations leading to the eft predictions . that is , the cut - off is kept low in rga with the intention of making the scaling of the contact - range couplings as obvious as possible . once the rga is done the only constraints about the size of the cut - off are practical ones . one of these constraints is the existence of residual cut - off independence . in most eft calculations we do not include all the couplings that are required to achieve exact rg independence . we only include the couplings that carry physical information at the order we are considering . there are two reasons for doing this : first , exact rg independence is not well - defined if we are making calculations in an eft at a given order . the systematic eft error is always present and rg independence must be understood within this error . the second reason is that exact rg independence requires the inclusion of what we have called here the redundant couplings , i.e. the @xmath346 piece of the couplings in the rg equations . these redundant operators can be calculated and included explicitly in a few specific cases : the ksw counting @xcite and pionless eft with pds @xcite . but on more general cases this is unpractical and not really necessary . it is easier to keep the residual cut - off dependence under control by a judicious choice of the cut - off . for this condition to be true it is usually enough for @xmath188 to be of the order of the hard scale , though the exact details will depend on the regulator . other important thing is to stress that a power counting is merely an ideal organization of the size of the interactions of a theory . they are derived under the assumption that the scale separation is large and that we can clearly classify all scales either as soft ( @xmath2 ) or hard ( @xmath3 ) . however the real physical world is not necessarily like that . what do we do if we have a two - body system with a scattering length that is neither small nor large ? the point is that what we obtain with rga is just an approximation to a more complex reality . in particular other power countings are possible beyond the ones we have discussed here . for instance in ref . van kolck developed a counting for two - body systems in which the scattering length is tiny . other possibility is when both the scattering length and the effective range are large , a case which can be useful for the description of low lying s - wave resonances or even for the @xmath8 singlet to improve the convergence @xcite . that means that we are entitled to curb the counting rules in view of practical physical information of the system . the limit is theoretical consistency : the eft must be equivalent to the fundamental theory at low energies , which means that renormalizability must be respected . the principles of renormalization work in the same way for operators different than the two - body potential . the advantage of calculating the anomalous dimension is that we can extend the idea seamlessly to any other problem . the point is to have a coupling and a polynomial contact - range operator , to evaluate their matrix element and to demand rg invariance at the end , @xmath347 actually the whole process amounts to nothing more than following a recipe . the only thing we have to do is to choose the wave functions and the operators that are appropriate for the particular physical process we are studying . let us consider the case of a reaction involving a external probe and the deuteron ( or more generally the two - nucleon system ) . in this case the contact - range operators of the theory involve two nucleons and one ( or more ) external fields . the external fields we are interested in are pions , photons and neutrinos . in principle the initial and final wave functions are the product of a two - nucleon wave function and the wave function of zero , one or more external probes @xmath348 where @xmath349 refers to the probes , with the index @xmath350 . the contact - range operator involves a coupling and a polynomial of the momenta of the nucleons and the external probes . in the plane wave basis it reads @xmath351 where @xmath352 ( @xmath353 ) is the center - of - mass momentum of the initial ( final ) two - nucleon system and @xmath354(@xmath355 ) the momenta of all the incoming ( outgoing ) probes involved in the operator . in general the polynomial @xmath356 will involve spin and isospin degrees of freedom , but for the moment we will ignore them . how does one evaluate the matrix elements ? if we consider that the wave functions of the external probes are plane waves , the evaluation of the contact - range operator yields latexmath:[\ ] ] with @xmath478 a small positive number . the evaluation of the following pieces is direct @xmath479 while the two remaining pieces vanish in the @xmath29 limit @xmath480 the reason being that the integrand is bounded in the region around @xmath17 . we can see that while @xmath12 is continuous at @xmath24 , @xmath481 develops a discontinuity . putting the pieces together for @xmath29 we arrive at @xmath482 finally , expanding @xmath483 in powers of @xmath43 we obtain eq . ( [ eq : rge ] ) . nplqcd collaboration ( s. r. beane , e. chang , w. detmold , h. w. lin , t. c. luu , k. orginos , a. parreno , m. j. savage , a. torok and a. walker - loud ) , _ phys . * d85 * ( 2012 ) 054511 , http://arxiv.org/abs/1109.2889[arxiv:1109.2889 [ hep - lat ] ] . nplqcd collaboration ( s. r. beane , e. chang , s. d. cohen , w. detmold , h. w. lin , t. c. luu , k. orginos , a. parreno , m. j. savage and a. walker - loud ) , _ phys . _ * d87 * ( 2013 ) 034506 , http://arxiv.org/abs/1206.5219[arxiv:1206.5219 [ hep - lat ] ] . hal qcd collaboration ( s. aoki , t. doi , t. hatsuda , y. ikeda , t. inoue , n. ishii , k. murano , h. nemura and k. sasaki ) , _ ptep _ * 2012 * ( 2012 ) 01a105 , http://arxiv.org/abs/1206.5088[arxiv:1206.5088 [ hep - lat ] ] . j. polchinski , effective field theory and the fermi surface , in _ theoretical advanced study institute ( tasi 92 ) : from black holes and strings to particles boulder , colorado , june 3 - 28 , 1992 _ , ( 1992 ) . [ arxiv : hep - th/9210046 [ hep - th ] ] . t. s. park , l. e. marcucci , r. schiavilla , m. viviani , a. kievsky , s. rosati , k. kubodera , d. p. min and m. rho , _ phys . * c67 * ( 2003 ) 055206 , http://arxiv.org/abs/nucl-th/0208055 [ arxiv : nucl - th/0208055 [ nucl - th ] ] .

effective field theories are the most general tool for the description of low energy phenomena . they are universal and systematic : they can be formulated for any low energy systems we can think of and offer a clear guide on how to calculate predictions with reliable error estimates , a feature that is called power counting . these properties can be easily understood in wilsonian renormalization , in which effective field theories are the low energy renormalization group evolution of a more fundamental perhaps unknown or unsolvable high energy theory . in nuclear physics they provide the possibility of a theoretically sound derivation of nuclear forces without having to solve quantum chromodynamics explicitly . however there is the problem of how to organize calculations within nuclear effective field theory : the traditional knowledge about power counting is perturbative but nuclear physics is not . yet power counting can be derived in wilsonian renormalization and there is already a fairly good understanding of how to apply these ideas to non - perturbative phenomena and in particular to nuclear physics . here we review a few of these ideas , explain power counting in two - nucleon scattering and reactions with external probes and hint at how to extend the present analysis beyond the two - body problem .

1409.8277

demand for large - scale networks consisting of multiple agents ( i.e. , nodes ) with different objectives is steadily growing due to their increased efficiency and scalability compared to centralized distributed structures @xcite . a wide range of problems in the context of distributed and parallel processing can be considered as a minimization of a sum of objective functions , where each function ( or information on each function ) is available only to a single agent or node @xcite . in such practical applications , it is essential to process the information in a decentralized manner since transferring the objective functions as well as the entire resources ( e.g. , data ) may not be feasible or possible @xcite . for example , in a distributed data mining scenario , privacy considerations may prohibit sharing of the objective functions @xcite . similarly , in a distributed wireless network , energy considerations may limit the communication rate between agents @xcite . in such settings , parallel or distributed processing algorithms , where each node performs its own processing and share information subsequently , are preferable over the centralized methods @xcite . here , we consider minimization of a sum of unknown convex objective functions , where each agent ( or node ) observes only its particular objective function via the stochastic gradient oracles . particularly , we seek to minimize this sum of functions with a limited number of gradient oracle calls at each agent . in this framework , we introduce a distributed online convex optimization algorithm based on the sgd iterates that efficiently minimizes this cost function . specifically , each agent uses a time - dependent weighted combination of the sgd iterates and achieves the presented performance guarantees , which matches with the lower bounds presented in @xcite , only with a relatively small excess term caused by the unknown network model . the proposed method is comprehensive , in that any communication strategy , such as the diffusion @xcite and the consensus @xcite strategies , are incorporated into our algorithm in a straightforward manner as shown in the paper . we compare the performance of our algorithm respect to the state - of - the - art methods @xcite in the literature and present the outstanding performance improvements for various well - known network topologies and benchmark data sets . distributed networks are successfully used in wireless sensor networks @xcite , and recently used for convex optimization via projected subgradient techniques @xcite . in @xcite , the authors illustrate the performance of the least mean squares ( lms ) algorithm over distributed networks using different diffusion strategies . we emphasize that this problem can also be casted as a distributed convex optimization problem , hence our results can be applied to these problems in a straightforward manner . in @xcite , the authors consider the cooperative optimization of the cost function under convex inequality constraints . however , the problem formulation as well as the convergence results in this paper are significantly different than the ones in @xcite . in @xcite , the authors present a deterministic analysis of the sgd iterates and our results builds on them by illustrating a stronger convergence bound in expectation while also providing msd analyses of the sgd iterates . in @xcite , the authors consider the distributed convex optimization problem and present the probability-@xmath4 and mean square convergence results of the sgd iterates . in this paper , on the other hand , we provide the expected convergence rate of our algorithm and the msd of the sgd iterates at any time instant . similar convergence analyses are recently illustrated in the computational learning theory @xcite . in @xcite , the authors provide deterministic bounds on the learning performance ( i.e. , regret ) of the sgd algorithm . in @xcite , these analyses are extended and a regret - optimal learning algorithm is proposed . in the same lines , in @xcite , the authors describe a method to make the sgd algorithm optimal for the strongly convex optimization . however , these approaches rely on the smoothness of the optimization problem . in @xcite , a different method to achieve the optimal convergence rate is proposed and its performance is analyzed . on the other hand , in this paper , the convex optimization is performed over a network of localized learners , unlike @xcite . our results illustrate the convergence rates over any unknown communication graph , and in this sense build upon the analyses of the centralized learners . furthermore , unlike @xcite , our algorithm does not require the optimization problem to be sufficiently smooth . distibuted convex optimization appears in a wide range of practical applications in wireless sensor networks and real - time control systems @xcite . we introduce a comprehensive approach to this setup by proposing an online algorithm , whose expected performance is asymptotically the same as the performance of the optimal centralized processor . our results are generic for any probability distribution on the data , not necessarily gaussian unlike the conventional works in the literature @xcite . furthermore , our performance bounds are optimal in a strong deterministic sense up to constant terms . our experiments over different network topologies , various data sets and cost functions illustrate the superiority and robustness of our approach with respect to the state - of - the - art methods in the literature . our main contributions are as follows . 1 . we introduce a distributed online convex optimization algorithm based on the sgd iterates that achieves an optimal convergence rate of @xmath0 after @xmath1 gradient updates , for each and every node on the network . we emphasize that this convergence rate is optimal since it achieves the lower bounds presented in @xcite up to constant terms . we show that the average sgd iterate achieves a msd of @xmath3 after @xmath1 gradient updates . our analyses can be extended to analyze the performances of the diffusion and consensus strategies in a straightforward manner as illustrated in our paper . we illustrate the highly significant performance gains of the introduced algorithm with respect to the state - of - the - art methods in the literature under various network topologies and benchmark data sets . the organization of the paper is as follows . in section [ sec : prob ] , we introduce the distributed convex optimization framework and provide the notations . we then introduce the main result of the paper , i.e. , a sgd based convex optimization algorithm , in section [ sec : main ] and analyze the convergence rate of the introduced algorithm . in section [ sec : sim ] , we demonstrate the performance of our algorithm with respect to the state - of - the - art methods through simulations and then conclude the paper with several remarks in section [ sec : conc ] . throughout the paper , all vectors are column vectors and represented by boldface lowercase letters . matrices are represented by boldface uppercase letters . for a matrix @xmath5 , @xmath6 is the frobenius norm . for a vector @xmath7 , @xmath8 is the @xmath9-norm . here , @xmath10 ( and @xmath11 ) denotes a vector with all zero ( and one ) elements and the dimensions can be understood from the context . for a matrix @xmath5 , @xmath12 represents its entry at the @xmath13th row and @xmath14th column . for a convex set @xmath15 , @xmath16 denotes the euclidean projection onto @xmath15 , i.e. , @xmath17 . we consider the problem of distributed strongly convex optimization over a network of @xmath2 nodes . at each time @xmath18 , each node @xmath13 observes a pair of regressor vectors and data , i.e. , @xmath19 and @xmath20 , where the pairs @xmath21 are independent and identically distributed ( i.i.d . ) for all @xmath22 , which is a common framework in the conventional studies in the literature @xcite . here , the distributions of the data pairs can differ from one node to another and we do not have any information on the underlying distributions . in such a framework , the aim of each node is to minimize a strongly convex cost function @xmath23 over a convex set @xmath15 . however , @xmath23 s are now known and each node accesses to its @xmath23 only via a stochastic gradient oracle , which given some @xmath24 , produces a random vector @xmath25 , whose expectation @xmath26 is a subgradient of @xmath27 at @xmath28 . using these stochastic gradient oracles , each node estimates a parameter of interest @xmath29 on a common convex set @xmath15 and calculates an estimate of the output as @xmath30 i.e. , by a first order linear method . after observing the true data at time @xmath18 , node @xmath13 suffers a loss of @xmath31 , where @xmath32 is a strongly convex loss function . as an example , our cost function can be defined as follows @xmath33 where @xmath34 is a lipschitz - continuous convex loss function with respect to the first variable , where is extensively studied in the literature @xcite as a strongly convex loss function involving regularity terms . nodes , where each agent communicates with a set of nodes in its neighborhood.,title="fig : " ] + here , the aim of each node is to minimize its expected loss over the convex set @xmath15 . to continue with our example in , the aim of each node is to minimize @xmath35 where we drop the notational dependency of @xmath36 to the time index @xmath18 since the data pairs are assumed to be independent over time . we emphasize that the formulation in covers a wide range of practical loss functions . as an example , when @xmath37 , we consider the regularized squared error loss and when @xmath38 , we consider the hinge loss . since we make no assumptions on the loss function @xmath39 other than strong convexity , one can also use different loss functions with their corresponding gradients and our results still hold . in this framework , at each time @xmath18 , after observing the true data @xmath20 , each node exchanges ( i.e. , diffuses ) information with its neighbors in order to produce the next estimate of the parameter vector @xmath40 . for example , in fig . [ fig : network ] , we have a distributed network consisting of @xmath41 nodes , where each node communicates with its neighbors . although the aim of each node is to minimize its expected loss in , the ultimate goal of the distributed network is to minimize the total expected loss , i.e. , @xmath42 for each node @xmath13 , with at most @xmath18 stochastic gradient oracle calls at each agent , where @xmath2 is the number of nodes in the distributed network . here , we emphasize that the expected total loss in is defined with respect to the data statistics at every node , whereas the parameter vector is trained using the gradient oracle calls at @xmath13th node and the information diffusion over the distributed network . thus , our aim is to minimize a global , strongly convex cost function at each node over a distributed network , where each learner is allowed to use at most @xmath18 calls to the gradient oracle until time @xmath18 . in this section , we present the main result of the paper , where we introduce an algorithm based on the sgd updates that achieves an expected regret upper bound of @xmath0 after @xmath1 iterates . the proposed method uses time dependent weighted averages of the sgd updates at each node together with the adapt - then - combine diffusion strategy @xcite to achieve this performance . however , as later explained in the paper ( i.e. , in section [ sec : ext ] ) , our algorithm can be extended the consensus strategy in a straightforward manner . the complete description of the algorithm can be found in algorithm [ alg ] . @xmath43 % estimation @xmath44 % gradient oracle call @xmath45 % sgd update @xmath46 % projection @xmath47 % diffusion @xmath48 % weighting to achieve the aforementioned result , we first introduce the following lemma , which provides an upper bound on the performance of the average parameter vector . + * lemma 1 * _ assume that ( i ) each @xmath27 is @xmath49-strongly convex over @xmath15 , where @xmath50 is a closed convex set ; ( ii ) the norms of any two subgradients has a finite covariance , i.e. , @xmath51 \leq g^2 $ ] , for any @xmath52 . then defining @xmath53 algorithm [ alg ] yields @xmath54 + 4g^2\mu_t^2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] + _ this lemma provides an upper bound on the regret and the squared deviation of the average parameter vector . it provides an intermediate step to relate the performance of the parameter vector at each agent to the best parameter vector . the assumptions in lemma 1 are widely used to analyze the convergence of online algorithms such as in @xcite . particularly , the first assumption in lemma 1 is satisfied for many loss functions , such as the hinge loss , that are widely used in the literature . even though this assumption may not hold for some loss functions such as the square loss , one can incorporate a small regularization term in order to make it strongly convex @xcite . the second assumption in lemma 2 is practically a boundedness condition that is widely used to analyze the performance of sgd based algorithms @xcite . we emphasize that our algorithm does not need to know this upper bound and it is only used in our theoretical derivations . + * proof * in order to efficiently manage the recursions , we first consider the projection operation and let @xmath55 and @xmath56 . then , we can compactly represent the averaged estimation parameter @xmath57 in a recursive manner as follows @xcite @xmath58 { \nonumber}\\ & = { { \mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t + \frac{1}{n } \sum_{i=1}^n \left ( { { \mbox{\boldmath${x}$}}}_{t , i } - \mu_t { { \mbox{\boldmath${g}$}}}_{t , i } \right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the last line follows since @xmath5 is right stochastic , i.e. , @xmath59 . hence , the squared deviation of these average iterates with respect to @xmath60 can be obtained as follows @xmath61 we first upper bound the second term in the right hand side ( rhs ) of as follows @xmath62 we then note that @xmath63 where the second line follows since @xmath64 thus , we can rewrite as follows @xmath65 where the last line follows since @xmath66 \leq g^2 $ ] for any @xmath67 according to the assumption . we next turn our attention to @xmath68 $ ] term in and upper bound this term as follows @xmath69 where @xmath70 , follows from the @xmath49-strong convexity , i.e. , @xmath71 also follows from the @xmath49-strong convexity , i.e. , @xmath72 and follows from the cauchy - schwarz inequality . summing from @xmath73 to @xmath2 and taking expectation of both sides , we obtain @xmath74 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{.6 cm } \leq { { \mathbbm{e}}}\big [ f({{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^ * ) - f({{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t ) + 2 g \sum_{i=1}^n { \left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t , i}\right|\right| } { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{1.2 cm } - \frac{\lambda n}{2 } { \left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 \big],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the first inequality follows due to the assumption and the last inequality follows from the jensen s inequality due to the convexity of the norm operator . we finally turn our attention to @xmath75 term in and write this term as follows @xmath76 where the inequality follows from the definition of the euclidean projection . taking the expectation of both sides , we can upper bound this term as follows @xmath77 { \nonumber}\\ & \leq g \mu_t \ , { { \mathbbm{e}}}{\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t-{{\mbox{\boldmath${\psi}$}}}_{t+1,i}\right|\right|}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] putting , , and back in , we obtain @xmath78 + 4g^2\mu_t^2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this concludes the proof of lemma 1 . @xmath79 + having obtained an upper bound on the performance of the average parameter vector , we then consider the msd of the parameter vectors at each node from the average parameter vector . this lemma will then be used to relate the performance of each individual node to the performance of the fully connected distributed system . + * lemma 2 * _ in addition to the assumption in lemma 1 , assume that ( i ) the communication graph @xmath5 forms a doubly stochastic matrix such that @xmath5 is irreducible and aperiodic ; ( ii ) the initial weights at each node are identically initialized to avoid any bias , i.e. , @xmath80 , @xmath81 . then algorithm [ alg ] yields @xmath82 and @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the second largest singular value of matrix @xmath5 . + _ we emphasize that the assumptions in lemma 2 are not restrictive and previous analyses in the literature also use similar assumptions @xcite . the first assumption in lemma 2 indicates that the convergence of the communication graph is geometric . this assumption holds when the communication graph is strongly connected , doubly stochastic , and each node gives a nonzero weight to the iterates of its neighbors . this holds for many communication strategies such as the metropolis rule @xcite . the second assumption in lemma 2 is basically an unbiasedness condition , which is reasonable since the objective weight @xmath60 is completely unknown to us . even though the initial weights are not identical , our analyses still hold , however with small additional excess terms . + * proof * we first let @xmath85 $ ] , @xmath86 $ ] , and @xmath87 $ ] . then , we obtain the recursion on @xmath88 as follows @xmath89 letting @xmath90 denote the basis function for the @xmath13th dimension , i.e. , only the @xmath13th entry of @xmath90 is @xmath4 whereas the rest is @xmath91 , we have @xmath92 where the third line follows due to the unbiased initialization assumption , i.e. , @xmath80 , @xmath93 . we first consider the term @xmath94 of and define the matrix @xmath95 . then , we can write @xmath96 where the last line follows since @xmath97 , @xmath98 . here , we let @xmath99 denote the singular values of a matrix @xmath100 and @xmath101 denote the eigenvalues of a symmetric matrix @xmath100 . then , we can upper bound as follows @xmath102 @xmath98 . therefore , using the above recursion @xmath103 times to , we obtain @xmath104 here , we note that @xmath5 is assumed to be a doubly stochastic matrix , thus @xmath105 . therefore , the eigenspectrums of @xmath106 and @xmath107-@xmath108 are equal to the eigenspectrums of @xmath5 and @xmath109 , respectively , except the largest eigenvalues , i.e. , @xmath110 . thus , we have @xmath111 and combining , , and , we obtain @xmath112 from here on , we denote @xmath113 for notational simplicity . putting back in , we obtain @xmath114 taking the expectation of both sides and noting that @xmath115 we can rewrite as follows @xmath116 an upper bound for the term @xmath117 can be obtained as @xmath118 where the last line follows from the triangle inequality . taking expectation of both sides , we obtain the following upper bound @xmath119 this concludes the proof of lemma 2 . @xmath79 + the results in lemma 1 and lemma 2 are combined in the following theorem to obtain a regret bound on the performance of the proposed algorithm . this theorem illustrates the convergence rate of our algorithm ( i.e. , algorithm [ alg ] ) over distributed networks . the upper bound on the regret @xmath0 results since the algorithm suffers from a `` diffusion regret '' to sufficiently exchange ( i.e. , diffuse ) the information among the nodes . this convergence rate matches with the lower bounds presented in @xcite up to constant terms , hence is optimal in a minimax sense . the computational complexity of the introduced algorithm is on the order of the computational complexity of the sgd iterates up to constant terms . furthermore , the communication load of the proposed method is the same as the communication load of the sgd algorithm . on the other hand , by using a time - dependent averaging of the sgd iterates , our algorithm achieves a significantly improved performance as shown in theorem 1 and illustrated through our simulations in section [ sec : sim ] . + * theorem 1 * _ under the assumptions in lemma 1 and lemma 2 , algorithm [ alg ] with learning rate @xmath120 and weighted parameters @xmath121 , when applied to any independent and identically distributed regressor vectors and data , i.e. , @xmath122 for all @xmath22 and @xmath123 , achieves the following convergence guarantee @xmath124 \leq \frac{4ng^2}{\lambda(t+1 ) } \left ( 3 + \frac{8\sigma\sqrt{n}}{1-\sigma } \right),\ ] ] for all @xmath125 , where @xmath84 is the second largest singular value of matrix @xmath5 . + _ this theorem illustrates that although every node uses local gradient oracle calls to train its parameter vector , each node asymptotically achieves the performance of the centralized processor through the information diffusion over the network . this result shows that each node acquires the information contained in the gradient oracles at every other node and suffers asymptotically no regret as the number of gradient oracle calls at each node increse . + * proof * according to lemma 1 and lemma 2 , we have @xmath126 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{.5 cm } \leq \frac{n}{2\mu_t } \ , { { \mathbbm{e}}}\left [ ( 1-\lambda\mu_t){\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 - { \left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t+1}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 \right ] { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{1.5 cm } + 3ng^2\mu_t + 6n\sqrt{n}g^2 \sum_{z=1}^{t-1 } \mu_{t - z } \sigma^{z}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the convexity of the cost functions , we also have @xmath127 \geq { { \mathbbm{e}}}\ , { { \mbox{\boldmath${g}$}}}_{t , i , j}^t({{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t , j}),\ ] ] @xmath93 , where @xmath128 . here , we can rewrite as follows @xmath129 & \leq { { \mathbbm{e}}}\ , { { \mbox{\boldmath${g}$}}}_{t , i , j}^t({{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t , j}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t ) { \nonumber}\\ & \leq { { \mathbbm{e}}}\left [ { \left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${g}$}}}_{t , i , j}\right|\right| } { \left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t , j}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t\right|\right| } \right ] { \nonumber}\\ & \leq g \ , { { \mathbbm{e}}}{\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t , j}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t\right|\right|},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the second line follows from the triangle inequality and the last line follows from the boundedness assumption . summing from @xmath73 to @xmath2 , we obtain @xmath130 \leq n g \ , { { \mathbbm{e}}}{\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t , j}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t\right|\right|}.\ ] ] using lemma 2 in , we get @xmath131 \leq 2 n\sqrt{n } g^2 \sum_{z=1}^{t-1 } \mu_{t - z } \sigma^z.\ ] ] we then add and to obtain @xmath132 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{.5 cm } \leq \frac{n}{2\mu_t } { { \mathbbm{e}}}\left [ ( 1-\lambda\mu_t){\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 - { \left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t+1}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 \right ] { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{1.5 cm } + 3ng^2\mu_t + 8n\sqrt{n}g^2 \sum_{z=1}^{t-1 } \mu_{t - z } \sigma^{z}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] multiplying both sides of by @xmath18 and summing from @xmath133 to @xmath1 yields @xcite @xmath134 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{.1 cm } \leq \frac{n(1-\lambda\mu_1)}{2\mu_1 } { { \mathbbm{e}}}{\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_1-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 - \frac{tn}{2\mu_t } { { \mathbbm{e}}}{\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t+1}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{.5 cm } + \sum_{t=2}^t \frac{n}{2 } \left ( \frac{t(1-\lambda\mu_t)}{\mu_t } - \frac{t-1}{\mu_{t-1 } } \right ) { { \mathbbm{e}}}{\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_t-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{.5 cm } + 3ng^2\sum_{t=1}^t t\mu_t + 8n\sqrt{n}g^2 \sum_{t=1}^t t \sum_{z=1}^{t-1 } \mu_{t - z } \sigma^{z}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we observe that @xmath135 putting back in and inserting @xmath120 , we obtain @xmath136 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{.5 cm } \leq - \frac{\lambda nt(t+1)}{4 } \ , { { \mathbbm{e}}}{\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t+1}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{1.5 cm } + \left ( 3ng^2 + 8n\sqrt{n}g^2 \frac{\sigma}{1-\sigma } \right ) \sum_{t=1}^t \frac{2t}{\lambda(t+1 ) } { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{.5 cm } \leq - \frac{\lambda nt(t+1)}{4 } \ , { { \mathbbm{e}}}{\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t+1}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{1.5 cm } + \frac{2ng^2t}{\lambda } \left ( 3 + 8\sqrt{n}\frac{\sigma}{1-\sigma } \right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the last line follows since @xmath137 . dividing both sides of by @xmath138 , we obtain @xmath139 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{1.5 cm } \leq - \frac{\lambda n}{2 } \ , { { \mathbbm{e}}}{\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t+1}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{2.5 cm } + \frac{4ng^2}{\lambda(t+1 ) } \left ( 3 + 8\sqrt{n}\frac{\sigma}{1-\sigma } \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath27 s are convex for all @xmath140 , @xmath36 is also convex . thus , from jensen s inequality , we can write @xmath141 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{2 cm } \leq { { \mathbbm{e}}}\left [ \frac{2}{t(t+1 ) } \sum_{t=1}^t t \left ( f({{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t , j } ) - f({{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^ * ) \right ) \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] combining and , we obtain @xmath142 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{1.5 cm } \leq - \frac{\lambda n}{2 } \ , { { \mathbbm{e}}}{\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t+1}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{2.5 cm } + \frac{4ng^2}{\lambda(t+1 ) } \left ( 3 + 8\sqrt{n}\frac{\sigma}{1-\sigma } \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] this concludes the proof of theorem 1 . @xmath79 + hence , using the weighted average @xmath143 instead of the original sgd iterates , we can achieve a convergence rate of @xmath0 . the denominator @xmath1 of this regret bound follows since we use a time variable weighting of the sgd iterates . the linear dependency to the network size follows since we add @xmath2 different cost functions , i.e. , one corresponding to each node . finally , the sublinear dependency to the network size results from the diffusion of the parameter vector over the distributed network . in the following theorem , we then consider the performance of the average sgd iterate instead of the time - variable weighted iterate in . in particular , we show that the average sgd iterate achieves a msd of @xmath3 . this msd follows due to the number of gradient oracle calls and diffusion regret over the distributed network . + * theorem 2 * _ under the assumptions in lemma 1 and lemma 2 , algorithm [ alg ] with learning rate @xmath120 and weighted parameters @xmath121 , when applied to any independent and identically distributed regressor vectors and data , i.e. , @xmath122 for all @xmath22 and @xmath123 , yields the following msd guarantee @xmath144 for all @xmath125 , where @xmath145 and @xmath84 is the second largest singular value of matrix @xmath5 . + _ * proof * following similar lines to the proof of theorem 1 , in particular following the steps between - , we get @xmath146 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{1.5 cm } \leq - \frac{\lambda n}{2 } \ , { { \mathbbm{e}}}{\left|\left|{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}_{t+1}-{{\mbox{\boldmath${w}$}}}^*\right|\right|}^2 { \nonumber}\\ & \hspace{2.5 cm } + \frac{12ng^2}{\lambda(t+1 ) } \left ( 1 + 2\sqrt{n}\frac{\sigma}{1-\sigma } \right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] which yields @xmath147 which is the desired result . this concludes the proof of theorem 2 . algorithm [ alg ] can be generalized into the consensus strategy in a straightforward manner , while the performance guarantee in theorem 1 still holds up to constant terms , i.e. , we still have a convergence rate of @xmath0 . for the consensus strategy , the lines 57 of algorithm [ alg ] is replaced by the following update @xmath148 hence , we have the following recursion on the parameter vectors @xmath149 instead of the one in . according to this modification , lemma 2 can be updated as follows @xmath150 this loosens the upper bounds in and by a factor of @xmath151 . therefore , diffusion strategies achieves a better convergence performance compared to the consensus strategy . in this section , we first examine the performance of the proposed algorithms for various distributed network topologies , namely the star , the circle , and a random network topologies ( which are shown in fig . [ fig ] ) . in all cases , we have a network of @xmath152 nodes where at each node @xmath123 at time @xmath18 , we observe the data @xmath153 , where the regression vector @xmath19 and the observation noise @xmath154 are generated from i.i.d . zero mean gaussian processes for all @xmath22 . the variance of the observation noise is @xmath155 for all @xmath123 , whereas the auto - covariance matrix of the regression vector @xmath156 is randomly chosen for each node @xmath123 such that the signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) over the network varies between @xmath157db to @xmath158db ( see fig . [ fig : snr ] ) . the parameter of interest @xmath159 is randomly chosen from a zero mean gaussian process and normalized to have a unit norm , i.e. , @xmath160 . we use the well - known metropolis combination rule @xcite to set the combination weights as follows @xmath161 where @xmath162 is the number of neighboring nodes for node @xmath13 . + for this set of experiments , we consider the squared error loss , i.e. , @xmath163 as our loss function . in the figures , css represents the distributed constant step - size sgd algorithm of @xcite , vss represents the distributed variable step - size sgd algorithm of @xcite , uw represents the distributed version of the uniform weighted sgd algorithm of @xcite , and tvw represents the distributed time variant weighted sgd algorithm proposed in this paper . the step - sizes of the css-1 , css-2 , and css-3 algorithms are set to @xmath164 , @xmath165 , and @xmath166 , respectively , at each node and the learning rates of the vss and uw algorithms are set to @xmath167 as noted in @xcite , whereas the learning rate of the tvw algorithm is set to @xmath168 as noted in theorem 1 , where @xmath169 . these learning rates chosen to guarantee a fair performance comparison between these algorithms according to the corresponding algorithm descriptions stated in this paper and in @xcite . in the left column of fig . [ fig ] , we compare the normalized time accumulated error performances of these algorithms under different network topologies in terms of the global normalized cumulative error ( nce ) measure , i.e. , @xmath170 additionally , in the right column of fig . [ fig ] , we compare the performance of the algorithms in terms of the global msd measure , i.e. , @xmath171 in the figures , we have plotted the nce and mse performances of the proposed algorithms over @xmath172 independent trials to avoid any bias . as can be seen in the fig . [ fig ] , the proposed tvw algorithm significantly outperforms its competitors and achieves a smaller error performance . this superior performance of our algorithm is obtained thanks to the time - dependent weighting of the regression parameters , which is used to obtain a faster convergence rate with respect to the rest of the algorithms . hence , by using a certain time varying weighting of the sgd iterates , we obtain a significantly improved convergence performance compared to the state - of - the - art approaches in the literature . furthermore , the performance of our algorithm is robust against the network topology , whereas the competitor algorithms may not provide satisfactory performances under different network topologies . we next consider the classification tasks over the benchmark data sets : covertypecjlin / libsvmtools / datasets/ ] and quantum . for this set of experiments , we consider the hinge loss , i.e. , @xmath173 as our loss function . the regularization constant is set to @xmath174 , where the stepsizes of the tvw , uw , and vss algorithms are set as in the previous experiment . the step - sizes of the css-1 , css-2 , and css-3 algorithms are set to @xmath175 , @xmath164 , and @xmath165 for the covertype data set , whereas the step - sizes of the css-1 , css-2 , and css-3 algorithms are set to @xmath176 , @xmath175 , and @xmath164 for the quantum data set . these learning rates are chosen to illustrate the tradeoff between the convergence speed and the steady state performance of the constant stepsize sgd methods . the network sizes are set to @xmath177 and @xmath178 for the covertype and quantum data sets , respectively . in fig . [ fig : covtype ] and fig . [ fig : quantum ] , we illustrate the performances of the proposed algorithms for various training data lengths . in particular , we train the parameter vectors at each node using a certain length of training data and test the performance of the final parameter vector over the entire data set . we provide averaged results over @xmath179 and @xmath180 independent trials for covertype and quantum data sets , respectively , and present the mean and variance of the normalized accumulated hinge errors . these figures illustrate that the proposed tvw algorithm significantly outperforms its competitors . although the performances of the uw and vss algorithms are comparably robust over different iterations , the tvw algorithm provides a smaller accumulated loss . on the other hand , the variance of the constant stepsize methods highly deteriorate as the stepsize increases . although decreasing the stepsize yields more robust performance for these constant stepsize algorithms , the tvw algorithm provides a significantly smaller steady - state cumulative error with respect to these methods . trials for a network size of @xmath181.,title="fig : " ] + trials for a network size of @xmath182.,title="fig : " ] + we study distributed strongly convex optimization over distributed networks , where the aim is to minimize a sum of unknown convex objective functions . we introduce an algorithm that uses a limited number of gradient oracle calls to these objective functions and achieves the optimal convergence rate of @xmath0 after @xmath1 gradient updates at each node . this performance is obtained by using a certain time - dependent weighting of the sgd iterates at each node . the computational complexity and the communication load of the proposed approach is the same with the state - of - the - art methods in the literature up to constant terms . we also prove that the average sgd iterate achieves a mean square deviation ( msd ) of @xmath3 after @xmath1 gradient oracle calls . we illustrate the superior convergence rate of our algorithm with respect to the state - of - the - art methods in the literature . a. h. sayed , s .- y . tu , j. chen , x. zhao , and z. j. towfic , `` diffusion strategies for adaptation and learning over networks : an examination of distributed strategies and network behavior , '' _ ieee signal processing magazine _ , vol . 30 , no . 3 , pp . 155171 , may 2013 . f. yan , s. sundaram , s. v. n. vishwanathan , and y. qi , `` distributed autonomous online learning : regrets and intrinsic privacy - preserving properties , '' _ ieee transactions on knowledge and data engineering _ , vol . 25 , no . 11 , pp . 24832493 , nov 2013 . s. sundhar ram , a. nedic , and v. v. veeravalli , `` distributed stochastic subgradient projection algorithms for convex optimization , '' _ journal of optimization theory and applications _ , 147 , no . 3 , pp . 516545 , dec 2010 . c. g. lopes and a. h. sayed , `` diffusion least - mean squares over adaptive networks : formulation and performance analysis , '' _ ieee transactions on signal processing _ 56 , no . 7 , pp . 31223136 , july 2008 . tu and a. h. sayed , `` diffusion strategies outperform consensus strategies for distributed estimation over adaptive networks , '' _ ieee transactions on signal processing _ 60 , no . 12 , pp . 62176234 , dec 2012 . a. agarwal , p. l. bartlett , p. ravikumar , and m. j. wainwright , `` information - theoretic lower bounds on the oracle complexity of stochastic convex optimization , '' _ ieee transactions on information theory _ , 58 , no . 5 , pp . 32353249 , may 2012 . a. rakhlin , o. shamir , and k. sridharan , `` making gradient descent optimal for strongly convex stochastic optimization , '' in _ proceedings of the 29th international conference on machine learning ( icml-12 ) _ , 2012 , pp . 449456 . k. slavakis , g. b. giannakis , and g. mateos , `` modeling and optimization for big data analytics : ( statistical ) learning tools for our era of data deluge , '' _ ieee signal processing magazine _ , vol . 31 , no . 5 , pp . 1831 , sept 2014 . i. d. schizas , g. mateos , and g. b. giannakis , `` distributed lms for consensus - based in - network adaptive processing , '' _ ieee transactions on signal processing _ , vol . 57 , no . 6 , pp . 23652382 , june 2009 . g. mateos , i. schizas , and g. giannakis , `` distributed recursive least - squares for consensus - based in - network adaptive estimation , '' _ signal processing , ieee transactions on _ , vol . 57 , no . 11 , pp . 45834588 , nov 2009 . e. hazan and s. kale , `` beyond the regret minimization barrier : optimal algorithms for stochastic strongly - convex optimization , '' _ journal of machine learning research _ , vol . 15 , pp . 24892512 , jul 2014 . s. lacoste - julien , m. w. schmidt , and f. bach , `` a simpler approach to obtaining an @xmath183 convergence rate for the projected stochastic subgradient method , '' http://arxiv.org/pdf/1212.2002v2.pdf , dec 2012 .

we study diffusion and consensus based optimization of a sum of unknown convex objective functions over distributed networks . the only access to these functions is through stochastic gradient oracles , each of which is only available at a different node , and a limited number of gradient oracle calls is allowed at each node . in this framework , we introduce a convex optimization algorithm based on the stochastic gradient descent ( sgd ) updates . particularly , we use a carefully designed time - dependent weighted averaging of the sgd iterates , which yields a convergence rate of @xmath0 after @xmath1 gradient updates for each node on a network of @xmath2 nodes . we then show that after @xmath1 gradient oracle calls , the average sgd iterate achieves a mean square deviation ( msd ) of @xmath3 . this rate of convergence is optimal as it matches the performance lower bound up to constant terms . similar to the sgd algorithm , the computational complexity of the proposed algorithm also scales linearly with the dimensionality of the data . furthermore , the communication load of the proposed method is the same as the communication load of the sgd algorithm . thus , the proposed algorithm is highly efficient in terms of complexity and communication load . we illustrate the merits of the algorithm with respect to the state - of - art methods over benchmark real life data sets and widely studied network topologies . distributed processing , convex optimization , online learning , diffusion strategies , consensus strategies .

1302.4563

molten salts are liquid mixtures of ionic species at high temperatures . they receive much attention due to their diverse but promising applications that range from metal production @xcite , the pyrochemical treatment of nuclear waste @xcite , primary or secondary coolants in several concepts of generation iv fission @xcite and fusion @xcite nuclear reactors , and electricity storage devices @xcite . in the context of nuclear applications , the nuclear reactions produce rare earth elements in the core . from the neutronic point of view , these have a poisoning effect and must therefore be eliminated . one of the advantages of most of the concepts of reactors based on molten salts , including the promising thorium - fueled molten salt fast reactor ( msfr ) is that their fuel is dissolved in the primary coolant ( which is the molten salt ) @xcite . such liquid state fuel allows for the elimination and reprocessing of several fission products and rare earth elements during the reactor operation , via chemical or electrochemical methods @xcite . one drawback is the complex handling of the molten salt fuel inside the ( recycling ) circuit : important care must be taken for controlling the physico - chemical conditions@xcite , and additional efforts have to be made on the development of adapted structure materials @xcite . the knowledge on molten fluoride salts chemistry has long remained fragmented and limited to a few experimental techniques ( mainly electrochemical ones ) due to experimental hindrances . one has to deal with high temperatures ( from 500 k to 1800 k ) and to control the corrosive properties by setting up original experiments . many efforts have been made towards this direction and several experimental techniques have been adapted to the study of molten salts . the development of new cells has unlocked the study of molten fluorides by exafs spectroscopy @xcite , which , coupled to other spectroscopic methods such as nuclear magnetic resonnance ( nmr ) @xcite or raman @xcite , is able to provide a view of the local structure in these melts . as for the dynamic properties , similar improvements have been made and the self - diffusion coefficients can be measured up to 1500 k by pulsed field gradient nuclear magnetic resonance ( pfg - nmr ) @xcite . such measurements are important since the diffusion coefficients provide an information on the _ individual _ dynamics of the ions , complementing the viscosity or electrical conductivity measurements which inform about the _ collective _ dynamics of the macroscopic system . during the past decade , these experimental efforts have been accompanied by the development of simulation tools adapted to the study of molten fluorides and chlorides , namely density functional theory @xcite , thermodynamic modeling @xcite and molecular dynamics ( md ) @xcite . among those , the latter has proven to be efficient for the study of the structure and dynamics of the system at the microscopic scale , allowing the interpretation of experimental results @xcite and the prediction of quantities that hitherto remained unknown @xcite . the simulations are based a polarizable ion model , which has strong physical grounds @xcite and can efficiently be parameterized from first - principles @xcite , _ i.e. _ , without having empirically recourse to any experimental data . in this work , we combine state - of - the - art experimental and simulation tools to study a series of lif - yf@xmath2 molten salts of varying compositions . we first describe shortly the methodological aspects . then , we compare measured and calculated self - diffusion coefficients and electrical conductivity to show that md simulations are in quantitative agreement with experiments , which allows for further use of the simulations to discuss the interplay between the microscopic structure of the electrolytes and their dynamic properties . mixtures of lif and yf@xmath0 salts ( purity @xmath3 % ) were prepared in a glove box under argon in order to avoid h@xmath4o and o@xmath4 contamination of the samples . we use boron nitride ( bn ) crucibles to confine the salts , and to prevent them from any chemical reaction . the amount of salt in each crucible is _ ca_. 50 mg . the bn crucible is heated by a symmetrical irradiation with two co@xmath4 lasers . the laser power is increased progressively until the target temperature is reached . the high temperature pfg nmr spectra were recorded using a bruker avance wb 400 mhz operating at 9.40 t. an argon stream prevents oxidation of the bn at high temperature . the 10 mm liquid nmr probe is specially designed by bruker and adapted in cemhti to work up to 1500 k. it is equipped with a gradient coil providing 5.5 g@xmath5@xmath6a@xmath7 that is combined with a gradient amplifier of 10 a. we use a nmr pulse sequence combining bipolar gradient pulses and stimulated echo@xcite . it is repeated with 8 gradients of linearly increasing strength . measurements were performed using the following nmr parameters : durations of radiofrequency magnetic field application for @xmath8 pulses @xmath9 @xmath10s ( @xmath11f ) and @xmath12 @xmath10s ( @xmath13li ) , gradient strength @xmath14 was varied from 0 to 50 g / cm , gradient application time @xmath15 between 1 and 5 ms . for @xmath13li measurements , we used a pre - saturation cycle before the diffusion sequence because of the long relaxation time @xmath16 of this nucleus ( 25 s in pure molten lif ) . finally , the self - diffusion coefficients were obtained by nonlinear least - square fitting of the echo attenuation@xcite . the experimental setup used for measuring the electrical conductivity is described in details in reference @xcite ; the conductivity cell configuration was derived from the one proposed by hives and thonstad @xcite . the conductivity was measured for lif - yf@xmath0 mixtures with compositions ranging from @xmath17 = 0.00 to 0.18 , at several temperatures . here we report the results obtained for the 1130 k isotherm . all the details are given in the supplementary material document no.1 @xcite . we use molecular dynamics ( md ) to compute static and dynamic properties of the molten salt at the atomic scale . the md simulations used therein rely on interatomic interaction potentials parameterized from first principles . the parameterization procedure is described elsewhere @xcite . they are of _ ab initio _ accuracy and have been successful in reproducing accurately the electrical conductivity , the heat capacity , the viscosity , etc , of various ionic materials ( mainly molten fluorides and solid oxides@xcite ) . in the case of molten fluorides , the interaction potential is best described as the sum of four different components : charge - charge , dispersion , overlap repulsion , and polarization . the detailed description of the potential is given in the supplementary material document no.1 @xcite . we studied 11 concentrations ranging from @xmath17 = 0.10 to 0.60 by steps of 0.05 . each system was simulated along two isotherms . the first one at 1130 k allows for comparison with experimental data . the other one at 1200 k allows for comparison with previous works on fluorozirconates @xcite . for both temperatures , ( i ) the equilibrium volume was determined from a simulation in the isothermal isobaric ( npt ) ensemble with a target pressure of 1 atm , using the method described by martyna _ et al . _ @xcite ; ( ii ) production runs were then performed in the canonical ( nvt ) ensemble , @xcite with a time step of 1.0 fs . the total simulation time was of 4 ns for the production runs for each system . the relaxation time of the thermostat was set to 20 ps . the simulation cell parameters and the number of atom of each species are summarized for each composition and temperature in the supplementary material document no.1 @xcite . the cut - off distance for the real space part of the ewald sum @xcite and the short range potential was set to half the length ( @xmath18 ) of the cubic simulation cell . the value of the convergence parameter in the ewald sum was set equal to @xmath19 and 8@xmath20 @xmath21-vectors were used for the reciprocal space part calculation of the forces and potential energy . the self - diffusion coefficients of fluoride , lithium and yttrium ions along the 1130 k isotherm are presented in fig . [ fig : diffusion_coef ] as a function of the salt concentration . both experimental and molecular dynamics results are presented for f@xmath22 and li@xmath23 . for y@xmath1 , the self - diffusion coefficient can only be measured from molecular simulations , due to the nmr characteristics of @xmath24y ( low gyromagnetic ratio and long relaxation time up to 45 min ) . the self - diffusion coefficient @xmath25 of species @xmath26 is extracted from molecular dynamics simulations using einstein s relation , _ i.e. _ , from the long - time slope of mean squared displacement : @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the position of atom @xmath29 of type @xmath26 at time @xmath30 . the brackets denote an ensemble average over all trajectories and atoms @xmath29 of type @xmath26 . the self - diffusion of li@xmath23 is about 60 % higher than that of f@xmath22 , whatever the concentration . excellent agreement is found between experiments and simulations . we can therefore be confident in the md simulation results for y@xmath1 . the latter value is about one third of the diffusion coefficient of li@xmath23 over the whole range of compositions . all self - diffusion coefficients decrease at the same rate with the increase in yttrium fluoride concentration . at @xmath31 k as a function of the mole fraction in yf@xmath0 . full ( open ) symbols indicate experimental ( molecular dynamics ) data[fig : diffusion_coef ] . dashed and dotted lines are just guides for the eyes . ] the electrical conductivities measured at a temperature of 1130 k are presented in fig . [ fig : conductivity ] for different salt concentrations in yf@xmath0 and compared to experimental results@xcite . in molecular dynamics simulations , the electrical conductivity is calculated from @xmath32 where @xmath33 with @xmath34 the boltzmann constant , @xmath35 is the elementary charge , @xmath36 the volume of the cubic simulation cell of length @xmath18 , and @xmath37 is the net displacement of all the ions of species @xmath26 and charge @xmath38 in time @xmath30 . there are @xmath39 species here . the error bars associated to our calculations of the electrical conductivity from eq . [ eq : conductivity ] are estimated to 10 % . such high values are due to the collective nature of @xmath40 . it is not averaged over both the time steps and all the atoms of a given species , as self - diffusion coefficients are , and consequently require long simulations runs . the true electrical conductivity of eq . [ eq : conductivity ] is thus often approximated by the nernst - einstein formulae , which relates @xmath40 to the individual diffusion coefficients of the various species in the liquid . surprisingly , we find the electrical conductivity calculated from the nernst - einstein formulae to be overestimated by only 10 to 20 % . larger differences , typically 40 % , are usually observed for such salts@xcite . margulis et al . showed that the nernst - einstein relation always overestimates the conductivity in molten salts and ionic liquids because of conditions in the momentum balance that contraint the motion of ions of same charge to be anticorrelated@xcite . the real electrical conductivity , as calculated from md using eq . [ eq : conductivity ] , is plotted in fig . [ fig : conductivity ] . again , good agreement is found with experiments . the electrical conductivity falls from @xmath41 @xmath42cm@xmath7 in pure lif to @xmath44 @xmath42cm@xmath7,when the molar fraction of yf@xmath2 rises from 0 to 0.5 . this decrease in @xmath40 despite the addition of the highly charged y@xmath1 ions is not surprising in view of the variations observed in other mixtures @xcite . it correlates with the reduced diffusion of all species with @xmath45 observed above ; in the following sections , we will analyze these variations in light of the microscopic structure of the melt . of molten lif - yf@xmath2 mixtures as a function of the mole fraction in yf@xmath0 at 1130 k. ( black circles ) experimental data from this study ; ( white circles ) experimental data from reference @xcite ; ( red squares ) molecular dynamics results.[fig : conductivity ] ] in the previous section , we have shown that our molecular dynamics simulations were able to predict the transport properties of molten lif - yf@xmath0 with a very high accuracy . an advantage of such simulations is that we can extract precisely atomic scale informations on the local structure of such melts . we will mainly focus on the study of the solvation shell of yttrium ions . in fig . [ fig : rdf ] , we present the partial radial distribution functions ( rdf ) @xmath46 for f@xmath47-f@xmath47 , f@xmath47-y@xmath1 , y@xmath1-y@xmath1 and li@xmath23-f@xmath47 pairs at 1130 k. situations corresponding to low and high contents in yf@xmath2 ( @xmath48 and 0.60 ) are presented . firstly , we observe that the y - f ionic bond length , taken at the position of the first maximum in @xmath49 , is of @xmath502.24 for all the compositions . this is significantly larger than the zr - f distance ( @xmath502.02 ) in fluorozirconate melts shown in fig . [ fig : rdfzry ] while both cations have rather similar short - range repulsion potentials @xcite . this is due to the larger charge carried by the zr@xmath51 cations which therefore tend to be more attractive to fluorides with opposite charges . secondly , we observe that the first peak in this y - f rdf is 1.5 times less intense and sharper than its zr - f counterpart . also , the following minimum is less marked in yf@xmath2 . these quantities seem to show that the first solvation shell of y@xmath1 is more weakly bound than the one of zr@xmath51 in molten fluorides . in the case of the li@xmath23-f@xmath22 pair , the rdf has a shape very similar to the case of other molten fluoride mixture @xcite . radial distribution functions in lif - yf@xmath0 at 1130 k for @xmath48 ( black line ) and 0.60 ( red dashed line ) . ] radial distribution functions for y@xmath1f@xmath22 ( solid line in black ) and zr@xmath51f@xmath22 ( dashed line in magenta ) respectively in lif - yf@xmath0 at 1130 k and @xmath48 and lif - zrf@xmath52 at 1200 k and @xmath53 . the rdf for zr@xmath51f@xmath22 is taken from pauvert et al . @xcite . ] the extraction of precise coordination numbers is a difficult experimental task , for example by extended x - ray absorption fine structure ( exafs ) spectroscopy , that leads to errors of the order of 20 % for liquid state systems . here the difficulty is increased by the high temperatures of the systems . from nmr , it is possible to extract an average coordination number by comparing the chemical shift of the probed species to typical values obtained for this quantity in well - defined solid state compounds . this was performed in lif - yf@xmath0 mixtures @xcite , which led to the conclusion that the yttrium ions are most probably 7-fold or 8-fold coordinated . a smaller coordination number ( cn ) of 6 was extracted from raman spectroscopy experiments by dracopoulos in kf - yf@xmath0 mixtures @xcite . such a reduction in the cn when switching from lif to kf - based systems and a stabilization of octahedral coordination shell in the latter is consistent with our recent results in molten fluorozirconates @xcite . because of the intrinsic atomic - scale of our md simulations , we can extract cns with estimated error less than 2 % . the evolution of the cn of yttrium with its molar fraction in lif - yf@xmath2 is presented in fig . [ fig : coordination ] . we find the predominant species to be 7-fold coordinated yttrium ions for @xmath45 below 30 % and 8-fold coordinated ions above . from nmr experiments , one extracts the average cn over time . from fig . [ fig : coordination ] , the average cn for an yttrium ion at the eutectic composition ( @xmath54 ) is @xmath55 in our simulations , which compares well with the one estimated from nmr experiments @xcite . we observe almost linear evolutions for all cns . the proportions of cns 6 and 7 decrease with @xmath45 , and are compensated by increases in cns 8 and 9 . contrarily to the case of lif - zrf@xmath52 mixtures , no anomalous behaviour is observed around a given specific composition @xcite . the average coordination number @xmath56 , plotted in the bottom panel of fig . [ fig : coordination ] , varies indeed remarkably slowly and linearly with @xmath45 , between 7.0 and 7.8 . as for the like - like rdfs which are also shown in fig . [ fig : rdf ] , the f - f one does not show any strong evolution with the composition of the melt . the y - y one is characterized by a first peak , which is located at a distance of @xmath503.9 which is smaller than twice the y - f distance and therefore corresponds to pairs of cations that share a common fluoride anion . the intensity of this first peak slowly increases with the yf@xmath0 concentration . this evolution is linked to the slow increase in average cn discussed just above and shown in the bottom panel of fig . [ fig : coordination ] . it is larger than the one of the corresponding zr - zr rdf in fluorozirconates @xcite . such a structural feature , which denotes some medium - range , network - like ordering , has been shown to impact importantly the transport properties in molten fluorides . stands for the proportion of @xmath29-fold coordinated ytrium ions . no noticeable differences were observed between the two temperatures studied here ( 1130 k and 1200 k ) . reported values have a typical error bar of 1 % . + ( bottom ) average coordination number of ytrium ions as a function of the composition of the melt.[fig : coordination ] ] in molten salts , the coordination number is often seen as the most important structural criterion . it is heavily used for the interpretation of various properties through the perspective of the lux - flood acidity @xcite . in a molten fluoride melt , this definition of acidity induces that ( i ) an acid is a fluoride ion acceptor and ( ii ) a base is a fluoride ion donor @xcite . in this context , based on their coordination numbers , which range between 6 and 9 , y@xmath1 and zr@xmath51 should both be considered as strongly acidic species . nevertheless , very distinct behaviours are observed in these melts concerning the transport properties . on the one hand , in mf - zrf@xmath52 melts ( with @xmath57 being li@xmath23 , na@xmath23 , k@xmath23 or even a mixture of li@xmath23 and na@xmath23 ) , the @xmath58 ratio starts from a value very close to unity in the alkali fluoride melt , then strongly decreases upon addition of zrf@xmath52 . in parallel , the @xmath59 ratio also decreases , taking values close to unity in zrf@xmath52 concentrated melts @xcite ( note that a similar behavior is observed in lif - bef@xmath60 mixtures @xcite ) . here , in lif - yf@xmath0 both ratios hardly vary , showing that the diffusion of fluoride is barely impacted by the presence of yttrium ions , even at high yf@xmath0 concentrations . on the other hand , we have already mentioned that the nernst - einstein approximation overestimates the electrical conductivity of lif - yf@xmath0 molten salts by 10 to 20 % , independently of the composition . such a relatively good agreement is usually observed in molten alkali halides , _ i.e. _ , without complexing species . in lif - naf - zrf@xmath52 mixtures , we have shown that deviation from the nernst - einstein approximation increases with @xmath61 , the content of complexing species . for the highest concentration studied ( @xmath61=0.29 ) the conductivity is overestimated by as much as a factor of 2 if correlations between the ions are neglected , in agreement with the picture of margulis et al . discussed above that relates strong correlations in mobilities of the various ions in molten salts to a decrease in conductivity@xcite . this again shows that association effects between y@xmath1 and f@xmath22 ions are weak in lif - yf@xmath0 melts , despite the high coordination numbers . these points lead to the picture of a loosely bound network structure . the association behaviour of lif - yf@xmath0 is thus qualitatively different from that of lif - zrf@xmath52 , although their coordination number is high . in order to investigate further the associative behaviour in lif - yf@xmath0 , we analyze the rate of change of the instantaneous coordination number , which can be interpreted as the solvation shell lifetime . this is done by performing a cage correlation function analysis . the first minimum of the y - f partial radial distribution function is used as a simple geometrical criterion to determine the limit of the first coordination shell of a given y@xmath1 . the number of counter - ions f@xmath22 that have left the shell between times @xmath30 and @xmath62 is noted @xmath63 . the rate at which a single counter - ion ( f@xmath47 ) leaves the y@xmath1 ions solvation shell ( the cage ) is given by the cage - out correlation function @xcite , which is defined as : @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the heaviside step function . cage - out correlation functions for y@xmath1 and zr@xmath51 ions solvation shell in lif - yf@xmath2 and lif - zrf@xmath66 , respectively , at 1200 k and molar fraction @xmath67 or @xmath68 . ] the cage - out functions for @xmath69y@xmath1 and zr@xmath51 in lif - yf@xmath2 and lif - zrf@xmath66 are presented in fig . [ fig : cagecf ] for the same molar fraction of 0.35 at 1200 k. note that the changes with composition are very small , as shown in the supplementary materials . the exponential decay of the cage - out function is much faster for the y@xmath1-based salt . the corresponding characteristic time is of 0.7 ps , which is much lower than the ones obtained in lif - zrf@xmath66 ( 3.1 ps ) , naf - zrf@xmath66 ( 15.7 ps ) and kf - zrf@xmath66 ( 76.4 ps ) . these values are summarized in table [ tab : time_ea ] . the very short characteristic time measured in the case of lif - yf@xmath0 is at the origin of the particular transport properties obtained in this particular molten salt . it shows that even if y@xmath1 and zr@xmath51 have rather similar ( and high ) coordination numbers , the ionic bond is much weaker for the former . although the use of such cage correlation functions appears to be very useful for understanding the associative properties of molten salts , this quantity can only be obtained from simulations . it would nevertheless be valuable to extract similar information from a quantity which is more readily accessible . to this end , we compare in fig . [ fig : pmf ] the effective potential between zr@xmath51 and f@xmath22 , and between y@xmath1 and f@xmath22 , in the two melts . these were obtained from : @xmath70 indeed , eq . [ eq : pmf ] relates the partial radial distribution functions @xmath71 discussed above to an effective interaction potential . the last term in eq . [ eq : pmf ] accounts for the rotational invariance of @xmath72 . following the transition state theory @xcite , the rate at which the f@xmath22 ions escape from the y@xmath1 solvation shell should depend strongly on the height of the corresponding barrier . we observe a smaller barrier ( by @xmath50 1 @xmath73 ) in the lif - yf@xmath0 melt , in agreement with the smaller characteristic time extracted from the cage - out correlation function . this clearly shows that the shape of the rdf , rather than the cn distribution , should be studied for determining the associating properties in a molten salt . effective potential between zr - f and y - f ionic pairs , at 1200 k and molar fraction @xmath74 or @xmath75 . vertical dotted lines indicate the height of the barrier according to the transition state theory . ] these functions show a deep first minimum followed by a local maximum . the height of this variation can be seen as an activation energy ( @xmath76 ) , that we tabulate for lif - yf@xmath2 , lif - zrf@xmath66 , naf - zrf@xmath66 and kf - zrf@xmath66 in table [ tab : time_ea ] . this activation energy ( @xmath76 ) that is the thermal energy a single counterion ( f@xmath22 ) has to provide to cage out , is minimal in the case of y@xmath1 . this also strenghtens the conclusions about the loosely bound nature of lif - yf@xmath0 . .[tab : time_ea ] lifetime ( @xmath77 ) of the y@xmath1 first solvation shell extracted from the cage - out correlation function and activation energies ( @xmath78 ) extracted from the potential of mean forces . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] we have characterized the transport properties of lif - yf@xmath0 melts by combining pfg - nmr spectroscopy , potentiometric measurements and molecular dynamics simulations . the latter are able to provide diffusion coefficients of li@xmath23 and f@xmath22 ions and electrical conductivities in quantitative agreement with the experiments . it is then possible to extract many other quantities , such as the partial radial distribution functions , the coordination number distributions and the cage - out correlation functions , as a function of the molar fraction of yf@xmath0 . we have shown that despite being appealing , the coordination number is _ not _ the right observable to predict the strength of the association between a metallic species and the anion . it does therefore not bring much insight on the transport properties of molten salts . indeed , although y@xmath1 and zr@xmath51 ions have similar coordination numbers in fluorozirconate melts , their diffusion coefficients do not show similar behavior : in lif - zrf@xmath52 melts , when @xmath61 increases , @xmath79 decays much faster than @xmath80 , eventually reaching @xmath81 . on the contrary , in lif - yf@xmath0 melts , the three diffusion coefficients evolve in a similar way . the analysis of the effective potentials , which can readily be extracted from the radial distribution functions , and of the cage correlation functions , which measure the lifetime of the first solvation shell of the ions , provide a much more complete framework for interpreting the dynamic properties . here we show that the variation of the diffusion coefficients is linked to a short lifetime of the y - f ionic bonds , which in turn arises from a rather shallow well in the effective potential . this points toward the potential use of the transition state theory for rationalizing the ionic association effects in molten salts . the authors acknowledge the support of the french agence nationale de la recherche ( anr ) , under grant anr-09-blan-0188 ( `` milifox '' ) and of the pacen program . the research leading to these results has received funding from the european community s seventh framework program under grant agreement n@xmath82 249696 evol . 65ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/j.ssi.2006.01.051 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.85.064111 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.86.184201 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.84.184205 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.87.075409 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nimb.2004.06.034 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/j.jct.2012.09.005 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/0022 - 2364(89)90189 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1021/jp912195j [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1098/rspa.1957.0146 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1021/jp204182c [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1002/bbpc.19390450405 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/j.electacta.2011.03.099 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( )

the transport properties of molten lif - yf@xmath0 mixtures have been studied by pulsed field gradient nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy , potentiometric experiments , and molecular dynamics simulations . the calculated diffusion coefficients and electric conductivities compare very well with the measurements across a wide composition range . we then extract static ( radial distribution functions , coordination numbers distributions ) and dynamic ( cage correlation functions ) quantities from the simulations . then , we discuss the interplay between the microscopic structure of the molten salts and their dynamic properties . it is often considered that variations in the diffusion coefficient of the anions are mainly driven by the evolution of its coordination with the metallic ion ( y@xmath1 here ) . we compare this system with fluorozirconate melts and demonstrate that the coordination number is a poor indicator of the evolution of the diffusion coefficient . instead , we propose to use the ionic bonds lifetime . we show that the weak y - f ionic bonds in lif - yf@xmath0 do not induce the expected tendency of the fluoride diffusion coefficient to converge toward the one of yttrium cation when the content in yf@xmath0 increases . implications on the validity of the nernst - einstein relation for estimating the electrical conductivity are discussed .

0807.3773

in active galactic nuclei various physical processes such as particle acceleration , emission of high energy photons , and so on , take place . accretion of matter onto the central black holes is thought to be the energy source of these processes . when a fraction of matter is ejected from the accretion disks , relativistic jets of plasmas are formed . the relativistic jets are thought to explain intense and variable emission from blazars . the beaming effect amplifies the radiation from jets depending on the opening angle of the jets , bulk lorentz factor , @xmath4 , and the angle between the line of sight and the jet axis , @xmath5 . some blazars are known to emit very high energy @xmath6-rays in the tev energy band . they are , for example , pks 2155304 , mrk 421 , and mrk 501 ( e.g. , * ? ? ? recent observations of tev @xmath6-rays have found remarkably short time variability of tev blazars . in 2006 july pks 2155304 with redshift @xmath7 showed an outburst of tev @xmath6-rays . the average flux during the outburst was more than 10 times typical values observed from the object @xcite . during this period x - rays were also monitored by _ swift_. in the 0.310 kev energy band the x - ray flux increased by a factor of 5 @xcite . the observations by the high energy stereoscopic system ( h.e.s.s . ) report that the timescale of variation is a few minutes @xcite . the well - resolved burst of the tev @xmath6-ray flux from pks 2155304 varied on timescales only @xmath8 s. recently magic also observed short time variation in mrk 501 @xcite . when the size of the emission region in the comoving frame of the jet is denoted by @xmath9 , the observed timescale of the variability sets a limit on @xmath9 , i.e. , @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is the speed of light and @xmath12^{-1}$ ] is the beaming factor with @xmath13 . @xcite argued that @xmath14 60 - 120 @xmath15 is required to explain @xmath16 min , where @xmath17 is the schwarzschild radius with @xmath18 and @xmath19 being the gravitational constant and the central black hole mass , respectively . such large values of @xmath20 are also suggested by @xcite recently , based on the requirements of radiative cooling time and optical depth for @xmath6-rays due to electron - positron pair production . the emission spectra of blazars are characterized by two peaks in the @xmath21-@xmath22 representation , where @xmath23 is the differential energy flux . the lower energy peak is located in the optical x - ray bands and the higher energy peak is located in very high energy @xmath6-ray bands . the lower energy peak is most probably by synchrotron radiation of nonthermal electrons / positrons . radiation mechanisms of high energy @xmath6-rays are thought to be inverse compton scattering off soft photons in the leptonic models ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) and hadronic interaction of relativistic particles and photons in the hadronic models ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the soft photons of the leptonic models are supplied by synchrotron radiation by relativistic electrons / positrons in the jet ( synchrotron self - compton model ) or by the external sources such as accretion disks @xcite and disk radiation scattered around the jet @xcite . these emission models assume that the emission region is one zone . observations of tev @xmath6-rays of blazars have revealed that large values of @xmath24 are required to fit the emission spectra of very high energy @xmath6-rays by inverse compton scattering ( e.g. , * ? ? ? on the other hand , the observations of the apparent velocity of vlbi knots show that parsec - scale jets are subrelativistic or at most mildly relativistic @xcite . to reconcile the discrepancy between these values of @xmath4 , the deceleration of jets is considered . @xcite assumed that tev @xmath6-rays are produced by inverse compton scattering off synchrotron photons that are emitted by decelerated jet components . @xcite , on the other hand , proposed a spine - layer model . in this model they assumed that a fast moving emission region is surrounded by a slow moving sheath . gamma - rays are then produced by inverse compton scattering off the photons emitted in the spine and the sheath . although various emission models of jets with multiple radiation zones have been proposed as mentioned above , a simple synchrotron self - compton ( ssc ) model is still worth use in obtaining physical parameters of the emission regions in jets . in this paper we show that a simple ssc model can explain the tev @xmath6-rays and x - rays of pks 2155304 . pks 2155304 is an interesting source because of its strong tev @xmath6-ray emission and the short time variability of tev emission . since the redshift of pks 2155304 is 0.116 , the absorption of tev @xmath6-rays by extragalactic background light ( ebl ) is effective ( e.g. , * ? ? ? this is an ideal object to test ebl models as well as emission models . in [ sec : model ] we describe the parameters of our numerical calculations and in [ sec : results ] the values of the parameters are determined by fitting the observed data . finally discussion is given in [ sec : sum ] . the emission region is assumed to be a sphere with radius @xmath9 moving relativistically with bulk lorentz factor @xmath4 . below we assume @xmath25 , i.e. , @xmath26 . we solve kinetic equations of electrons and photons in the emission region @xcite . here we assume that the plasmas and radiation in the emission region are in a steady state . electrons are continuously injected in the emission region at rate @xmath27 . the injection spectrum is given by @xmath28 where @xmath29 , @xmath30 , and @xmath31 are parameters , and @xmath32 is the normalization constant determined by @xmath33 the electrons escape from the emission region by advection on timescale @xmath34 , where @xmath35 is a dimensionless parameter . the cooling processes of the electrons are synchrotron radiation and inverse compton scattering . we assume that the emission region has randomly oriented magnetic field @xmath36 . photons are assumed to escape from the emission region on timescale @xmath37 . we also include the absorption of @xmath6-rays in the emission region by @xmath38 production due to photon - photon collisions . this effect is found to be negligible for @xmath6-rays with observed energy less than 10 tev in our numerical results . parameters in our model are @xmath4 , @xmath9 , @xmath36 , @xmath27 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath35 . the dependence of solutions on @xmath35 is weak and we set @xmath39 . in addition to the above parameters , the cosmological parameters such as hubble constant @xmath40 and the density parameters of matter @xmath41 and cosmological constant @xmath42 are needed to calculate the luminosity distance and the optical depth for @xmath6-ray absorption by ebl . we assume @xmath43 km s@xmath44 mpc@xmath44 , @xmath45 , and @xmath46 . it is known that tev @xmath6-rays emitted by distant sources are absorbed by ebl . this was first pointed out by @xcite and detailed calculations were performed by @xcite and @xcite . later @xcite proposed that the ebl spectrum is estimated by considering the absorption of tev @xmath6-rays from blazars . since then various models of ebl have been proposed ( see * ? ? ? * for review ) . the redshift of pks 2155304 is 0.116 and the optical depth of tev @xmath6-rays is greater than unity for @xmath6-rays with energy greater than 1 tev . in our previous work @xcite , we used models by @xcite to fit the emission spectrum from h1426 + 428 . there we found that model lll of @xcite is applicable in the ssc model . in this paper we use the same ebl model to calculate the deabsorbed tev spectrum . h.e.s.s . observed a @xmath6-ray outburst from pks 2155304 on 2006 july 28 ( mjd 53944 ) @xcite . almost simultaneous observation by _ swift _ was performed in the x - ray band on july 29/30 @xcite . the observed emission spectra are shown in figure [ fig : photonspec1 ] . the tev data in 2006 july are from h.e.s.s . the tev spectrum is corrected with an ebl model , lll , of @xcite for absorption by @xmath38 production through photon - photon collisions . the x - ray spectrum of 2006 july 29 and 30 is shown by a thick dashed line . this spectrum is a log - parabolic model fit given by @xcite . other x - ray , optical , and radio data are not simultaneous with the tev data . the x - ray data except those of _ swift _ are from _ bepposax _ and radio data are from ned . 2mass data are also plotted . the tev emission spectrum observed in 2003 july @xcite is shown for comparison . our models are shown in figure [ fig : photonspec1 ] by solid and dashed lines for 2006 july and 2003 july , respectively . we did not fit the emission spectra below @xmath47 hz , assuming this emission is from different regions , possibly from extended regions far away from the central black hole . the values of the parameters for the flare in 2006 july are the following : @xmath48 , @xmath49 g , @xmath50 cm , @xmath51 , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 ( model a in table [ tbl-1 ] ) . the value of @xmath9 is @xmath54 , if @xmath55 . from these parameters , the timescale of variability is @xmath56 s. we also obtained the parameter values which give @xmath57 s. those are shown in table [ tbl-1 ] ( models b and c ) . when @xmath57 s is assumed , the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) of 2006 july is fitted well if @xmath4 is in the range @xmath58 . when @xmath59 , the fluxes in the tails of the lower and higher peaks of the sed are too high . on the other hand , when @xmath60 , the tail of the lower peak ( the x - ray band ) is too steep . seds for models a , b , and c are shown in figure [ fig : photon - abc ] . in table [ tbl-1 ] the parameters given in other papers such as @xcite and @xcite are also listed . note that @xmath61 h is assumed in @xcite and that @xcite did not perform the spectral fitting . in figure [ fig : photon - tev ] various deabsorbed tev spectra are compared with our models . the deabsorbed spectra are calculated with different ebl models given by @xcite . when ebl models other than lll , lhh , llh , and lhl are applied ( llh and lhl are not shown in the figure ) , the tev spectrum has a peak at @xmath62 hz . such a spectrum is difficult to produce by the one - zone ssc model , if the x - rays are emitted in the same region as tev @xmath6-rays . in particular the klein - nishina effect suppresses the emission in the tev band . in our simulations , small numbers of nonthermal electrons and synchrotron photons are initially injected and time evolution is followed until a steady state is attained . because of this initial condition , the sed takes longer time than the observed timescale to attain a steady state . the time evolution of the sed of model a is shown in figure [ fig : photon - evolv ] . in actual flares , the initial condition may different from that used here and flares are not in a steady state . we used a steady state to obtain typical values of the source parameters . in figure [ fig : electronspec1 ] the electron spectrum for the flare is shown . the electron spectrum has a cutoff at @xmath63 . because the injection spectrum has an exponential cutoff at @xmath64 , efficient compton cooling made the cutoff energy smaller . the synchrotron cooling time of electrons with @xmath65 is about @xmath66 s for @xmath49 g. the energy density of synchrotron photons is @xmath67 ergs @xmath68 in model a. this results in the compton cooling time @xmath3 @xmath69 s for electrons with @xmath65 . electrons with @xmath70 are cooled in the flare timescale in the comoving frame of the jet . the compton cooling time is short enough to be a major cooling process during the tev flare . the numerical results show that the energy densities of nonthermal electrons and magnetic fields in model a are , respectively , @xmath71 ergs @xmath68 and @xmath72 ergs @xmath68 . this yields a large value of @xmath73 . the values of energy contents of different models are shown in table [ tbl-2 ] . the dominance of particle kinetic energy over magnetic energy should be taken into account in consideration of acceleration mechanisms . the powers contained in the jet are , in the form of radiation and electron kinetic energy , given by @xmath74 and @xmath75 , respectively , where @xmath76 is the radiation energy density . the numerical results are given in table [ tbl-2 ] . our model include internal absorption of @xmath6-rays by @xmath38 production . however , our numerical results show that the @xmath6-ray absorption is negligible . because of the large values of @xmath4 , the soft photon density and the maximum @xmath6-ray energy in the comoving frame of the jet are not large enough for @xmath38 pair production . in figure [ fig : photonspec1 ] we show a tev spectrum observed in 2003 july as well . in 2003 , tev emission was observed by h.e.s.s . several times @xcite . in those observations the tev flux was much lower than that in the 2006 july flare . the tev spectrum of 2003 july are fitted with parameters such as @xmath77 , @xmath78 g , @xmath79 cm , @xmath80 , @xmath52 , and @xmath81 . with these parameters , numerical results give @xmath82 . compared with the flare of 2006 july , a blob with a larger size but a smaller value of @xmath4 was involved . the powers of radiation and electrons are , respectively , @xmath83 ergs s@xmath44 and @xmath84 ergs s@xmath44 . compared with the flare state in 2006 , @xmath85 is smaller by a factor 0.24 and @xmath86 is smaller by a factor 0.52 , if model a is adopted . in @xcite , they derived source parameters for the h.e.s.s . observation in 2003 , october and november , with different ebl models from that used here . according to their results , the source was in a low or quiet state . with their leptonic model , they obtained @xmath87 cm , @xmath88 , and @xmath89 g ( model 2 ) . @xcite , on the other hand , used the ssc model to fit another quiescent state , but without the correction for @xmath6-ray absorption by ebl . they obtained @xmath90 cm , @xmath91 , and @xmath92 g. the ratio @xmath93 is 3 , which is smaller by a factor 9 , compared with our results for 2003 july . the source size obtained by us is the largest among these models for quiescent states . in this work we have shown that a large value of the bulk lorentz factor , @xmath94 , is required to explain the emission from pks 2155304 in the tev band as well as the x - ray band . with @xmath50 cm and @xmath95 , the timescale @xmath96 s is obtained , while @xmath57 s is obtained for @xmath97 cm and @xmath98 - 150 . the value of @xmath25 as large as 100 requires the viewing angle as small as 0.01 rad , which makes the case an unlikely coincidence if the opening angle of the jet is the same order as @xmath99 . however , if the opening angle is larger than @xmath99 , we can observe a portion of the jet that aligns with the line of sight , thus avoiding an excessively small observability . considering that mrk 501 also exhibited a similar short timescale tev flare , we think that the opening angle is larger than @xmath100 ( by a factor @xmath101 ) . if this is the case , @xmath9 represents the lateral size along the jet motion , while the transverse size is larger than @xmath9 by the same factor @xmath101 . thus the real size of the emission region is larger than @xmath9 and only a part of the emission regions is observed owing to a strong relativistic beaming effect . then the kinetic power should be by a factor @xmath102 larger than a conventional estimate given by @xmath103 . a further speculative possibility is that the opening angle is as small as @xmath99 but the jet axis wanders within a large angle and the flare is observed when its direction happens to fall in the line of sight . our results show that the jet plasma is highly particle energy dominated over magnetic energy , i.e. , @xmath104 in the flare state in 2006 . the ratio @xmath93 has been discussed in many papers . in @xcite we discussed that tev blazars are generally particle dominated typically by a factor of 10 . for a quiescent state of pks 2155304 we obtained the ratio of 3 . thus the ratio of @xmath105 seems unusually high , although there is no serious theoretical reason to expect a ratio of unity except that it leads to a minimum kinetic power for a given observed spectrum . the obtained high value of the ratio basically results from the fact that the ssc luminosity is much larger than the synchrotron luminosity . in this respect , we note that the x - ray and tev observations are not strictly simultaneous ; if the x - ray flux during the tev flare is higher than the adopted value in this paper , the ratio decreases correspondingly . also , some soft photon sources other than synchrotron radiation will help to decrease the ratio . however , considering a good fit to the observed spectrum obtained here , such possibilities are not easy to realize and the reduction will not be significant . @xcite and @xcite adopted the view that the tev flare is caused by external compton mechanism . in this case , the model may avoid an extremely large value of @xmath93 . however , considering the short timescale of radiative deceleration , the acceleration of the emitting plasma to the large bulk lorentz factor itself becomes very difficult because of the large radiation drag effect . also note that both papers did not make detailed multi - wavelength fitting . as mentioned above , @xcite argued that inverse compton scattering off external soft photons is favored as the dominant radiation process to produce tev @xmath6-rays . the major differences between their model and ours are that they assumed the dominance of the poynting flux over the kinetic energy flux as well as the synchrotron radiation as a major cooling process to estimate particle s cooling timescale , while in our model the energy flux is dominated by nonthermal particle s kinetic energy and the cooling is dominated by ssc . in comparison between the flare state in 2006 july and the quiescent state in 2003 july , the powers in radiation and electrons increased by factors 2 and 4.2 , respectively , during the flare in 2006 , if model a is adopted . the increase in the jet power is significant and the efficient acceleration of electrons is implied . the size of the blob for the 2006 july flare is @xmath1 cm . this is about 3 @xmath106 , if the mass of the central black hole is @xmath107 . a large energy injection into a very compact region occurred in the flare . the obtained parameter values for the flare event and various phases are not well ordered and we found no simple tendencies from quiescent states to flares . the tev flare may be caused by a concentration of energy into a sub - horizon scale region , while during quiescent states we may be seeing larger scale energy dissipation on longer timescales . in applying our model , we assumed a low flux model of ebl , i.e. , lll of @xcite . with this ebl model the one - zone ssc model is found to be viable for this tev blazar , although other models proposed by @xcite and @xcite might explain the tev spectrum with higher fluxes of ebl . this should be studied in future work . radiation below @xmath47 hz is not fitted with our model . we assumed that the emission comes from more extended regions far away from the central black hole ( see also * ? ? ? * ) . if the radiation below @xmath47 hz is emitted by the jet plasma , inverse compton scattering produces radiation in the mev observation in this energy band is particularly important to set constraints on the emission mechanisms of blazars . cccccc @xmath4 & 90 & 100 & 120 & 30 & @xmath109 + @xmath110 & 90 & 100 & 120 & 33.5 & @xmath111 + @xmath36 ( g ) & 0.1 & 0.14 & 0.08 & 0.27 & @xmath112 + @xmath9 ( @xmath113 cm ) & 9.6 & 5.4 & 6.5 & 50 & 4.5 + @xmath29 & 1.9 & 1.9 & 1.9 & 2.5 & @xmath111 + @xmath31 ( @xmath105 ) & 8.0 & 6.7 & 5.5 & 17.5 & @xmath111 + @xmath30 & 10 & 10 & 10 & @xmath111 & @xmath111 + @xmath114 & @xmath111 & @xmath111 & @xmath111 & @xmath115 & @xmath111 + @xmath116 & @xmath111 & @xmath111 & @xmath111 & @xmath111 & @xmath105 + . cccc @xmath4 & 90 & 100 & 120 + @xmath117 ( ergs @xmath68 ) & 3.8 & 8.7 & 5.7 + @xmath118 ( @xmath119 ergs @xmath68 ) & 4.0 & 7.8 & 2.6 + @xmath93 ( @xmath105 ) & 0.95 & 1.1 & 2.2 + @xmath86 ( @xmath120 ergs s@xmath44 ) & 3.3 & 2.9 & 1.7 + @xmath85 ( @xmath121 ergs s@xmath44 ) & 2.7 & 2.4 & 3.3 +

h.e.s.s . observed tev blazar pks 2155304 in a strong flare state in 2006 july . the tev flux varied on timescale as short as a few minutes , which sets strong constraints on the properties of the emission region . by use of the synchrotron self - compton model , we found that models with the bulk lorentz factor @xmath0 , the size of the emission region @xmath1 cm , and magnetic field @xmath2 g explain the observed spectral energy distribution and the flare timescale @xmath3 a few minutes . this model with a large value of @xmath4 accounts for the emission spectrum not only in the tev band but also in the x - ray band . the major cooling process of electrons / positrons in the jet is inverse compton scattering off synchrotron photons . the energy content of the jet is highly dominated by particle kinetic energy over magnetic energy .

astro-ph0612597

x - ray emission from agn is thought to be produced in the very central regions of accretion flow , close to the black hole , since this is where most of the gravitational potential energy is dissipated . observational evidences for this come from results of modeling of spectral features , often showing distortions consistent with those caused by doppler effects and gravitational redshift . in particular , broad profiles of the fe k@xmath0 line are currently the best evidences for the very central x - ray generation and reprocessing . geometrical models of x - ray emitting accretion flows are of two kinds : the accretion disk with a corona scenario , and a hot flow scenario . these were extensively studied in the context of x - ray binaries , where the wealth of data enables putting stronger constraints on the geometry of accretion flow than in the case of agn . in the former scenario the standard keplerian accretion disk extends to the last stable orbit and the hard x - rays are produced by an active corona above the disk . this is motivated mainly by the solar corona where magnetic flares are thought to be powered by differential rotation of the sun s interior . the hot flow scenario is based on an alternative solutions of accretion flow , where the flow is optically thin and hot , most likely two - temperature , with proton temperature reaching the virial value . both the observational data and the theoretical arguments suggest that the two solutions operate in different ranges of mass accretion rate . presence of spectral features from x - ray reprocessing by cold optically thick plasma , with strong relativistic distortions obviously implies that the disk has to extend to the last stable orbit . this is the situation in , e.g. , the seyfert 1 galaxy mcg6 - 30 - 15 , which is currently the best example of effects of strong gravity in x - ray spectra . in this contribution we study some of the consequences of the relativistic effects on the variability of x - ray emission . assume that the hard x - rays are produced by magnetic flares co - rotating with the keplerian disk . assume further that durations of the flares are consistent with the flare avalanche model of @xcite , so that there is a broad distribution of the durations ( superposition of flare profiles of different durations explains the slope of the power spectrum ) . then , the natural association of a flare time scale with the keplerian time scale ( so that longer flares are produced further away ) , results in the radial x - ray emissivity increasing with radius , which is clearly inconsistent with the dissipation rate of gravitational energy @xcite . abandoning this association leads to a possibility of long flares occurring at small distances ( @xmath1 ) . the x - rays source can then participate in the keplerian motion , possibly for a number of @xmath2 , which produces a periodic modulation of emission due to doppler boost . the strength of the resulting quasi - periodic signal in the pds depends on the black hole spin , inclination angle and other details of the radial distribution of flares . for parameters appropriate for the seyfert galaxy mcg6 - 30 - 15 , where @xmath3 and @xmath4 , the strength of the predicted signal is high enough for the signal , if present , to be detected in the _ xmm - newton _ data @xcite . however , the data @xcite do _ not _ reveal such a signal . this would suggest that the x - rays can not be produced by co - rotating flares , but rather by a structure not participating in the keplerian rotation , e.g. , the base of a jet . on the other hand , a number of observations show periodic variability of the energy of a narrow fe k@xmath0 line , suggesting line production in localized regions co - rotating with the disk ( t. j. turner , these proceedings ) . if the two properties no qpo signal in the primary emission and a periodic modulation of the fe line turn out to be universal , this will clearly suggest a non - trivial geometry of the x - ray source . the reprocessed component ( fe k@xmath0 line and the compton reflected continuum ) show rather weaker variability than , and uncorrelated with , the variability of the primary emission ( e.g. , * ? ? ? this is observed on a time scale of @xmath5@xmath6 sec , i.e. , _ longer _ by a factor of @xmath7100 than the keplerian timescale at the inner disk ( assuming @xmath8 ) . such a reduction of variability is rather surprising , since in the simplest model the reprocessed component should respond to primary variations on the light travel timescale . the latter is very short , if indeed the reprocessing takes place close to the center , as evidenced by the broad profiles of the fe k@xmath0 line . the light bending model , formulated by ( * ? * hereafter mf ) , postulates that the de - coupling of variations is due to changing amount of relativistic effects , in particular bending of light trajectories from the source to the accretion disk , as the location of the source changes . in its basic form the model assumes that the intrinsic emission is constant , and the observed variability is solely due to changing location of the primary source . the variability of the reprocessed component is reduced because reprocessing takes place in a more extended area . @xcite demonstrate that in the simple geometry of an off - axis source moving vertically , the model predicts reduction of line variability of a factor of @xmath9 , as the source height changes from 1 to @xmath10 . we have extended the mf model to consider a number of geometrical scenarios : in addition to the basic model ( c the same as in mf ) , where the source is located off - axis , at projected radial distance @xmath11 , and moves vertically , we considered an on - axis source ( model a ) moving vertically and a source located very low above the disk surface , moving _ radially _ ( model s ) . photon transfer in the kerr metric was computed with the code described in detail in @xcite . we first computed time averaged profile of the fe k@xmath0 line in order to find the range of parameters where the profile match that observed in mcg6 - 30 - 15 . then , we computed variability of the line vs. that of the primary emission , as the source location changes . details are presented in niedwiecki & ycki ( in preparation ) . our results are somewhat different than those of mf . for @xmath12 and @xmath13 , in model c ( with @xmath14 ) , we find that the observed line profile requires a very low height of the source , @xmath15 . the profile computed for @xmath16 ( as in mf ) has a rather weak red wing , certainly not compatible with what is observed in mcg6 - 30 - 15 ( see fig . [ zyckifig : kaprof]a ) . similar profiles can be obtained in model s , where the source _ radial _ position changes around 23@xmath17 ( fig [ zyckifig : kaprof]b ) . we then addressed the problem of reduced variability of the k@xmath0 line and we computed the luminosity of the primary source vs. that of the fe k@xmath0 line , as the source position is changed . our results are plotted in fig . [ zyckifig : ff ] for a number of models . in model c we find no reduction of variability of the line in contrast to results of mf , especially for source height @xmath18 . this is most likely caused by differences in the assumed value of the outer disk radius : @xmath19 in our case compared to @xmath20 in mf computations . this latter value is too small for the line to be computed correctly when the height of the source is @xmath21 . we find a significant reduction of line variability in model s , for a source moving radially very low above the disk surface . source position changing between @xmath22@xmath23 produces line flux changes by a factor of @xmath9 compared to a factor of @xmath24 for the continuum . this is primarily a result of light bending to the equatorial plane , beyond @xmath25 , where a relatively constant blue horn is then produced ( niedwiecki & ycki , in preparation ) . note , though , that model s would predict the strong signal in pds ( on keplerian timescale ) which is not observed ( sec [ zyckisec : qpo ] ) . miniutti , g. , fabian , a. c. 2004 , mnras , 349 , 1435 poutanen , j. , & fabian , a. c. 1999 , mnras , 306 , l31 vaughan , s. , fabian , a. c. 2004 , mnras , 348 , 1415 vaughan , s. , fabian , a. c. , nandra , k. 2003 , mnras , 339 , 1237 ycki , p. t. , niedwiecki , a. 2005 , mnras , 359 , 308 ycki , p. t. 2002 , mnras , 333 , 800

special relativistic and strong gravity effects are clearly seen in x - ray energy spectra from agn . most important here are the broad profiles of the fe k@xmath0 line observed in a large fraction of sources . these indicate that x - ray generation and reprocessing takes place very close to the central black hole . here we explore consequences of such effects on x - ray variability . we perform computations of a possible quasi - periodic signal from a keplerian motion of primary x - ray source . we also study in some details the light - bending model of variability of the x - ray reprocessed component , extending previous work on the subject .

gr-qc0312119

the theory about the structure of space and time has been discussed from very long time not only among philosophers but also among physicists . it is very well known the correspondence between newton s disciple s. clark and leibniz about the absolute or relational character of space and time @xcite . the laws of mechanics and electromagnetism were written with the hypothesis of an absolute space and time but relational theories were unable to construct a consistent model of physical world and were abandoned . with the invention of the special theory of relativity the old arguments of relational theories were renewed but only in the phenomenological level . einstein himself recognized the atractive ideas of leibniz as a pioneering work in the theory of relativity @xcite . in this century the controversy among the physicists who defend the absolute or relational theory of space and time has increased in great amount from different reasons @xcite . the experimental and theoretical development of general relativity and cosmological models have forced to review the concepts of space and time . the revision of the foundations of quantum mechanics has moved some physicists to reduce the structure of space and time to some properties of quantum processes @xcite . finally , the study of fundamental axioms of geometry ( in the mathematical as well in the physical sense ) has introduced new light into the discussion about the primitive or derived character of space and time . we do nt want to go again in the arguments given by the two positions . instead we will expand some recent relational theories of space and time to prove that the basic assumption common to all of them is that there exists some fundamental objects out of them the structure of space and time is constructed . we will identify those objects as events , processes , yes - no experiments , monads ( following leibniz s ideas ) and so on . therefore the conceps of space and time are for these authors derived concepts in the logical as well in the ontological level . his model starts with objects and the interrelations between objects . an object is thus `` located '' either directionally or positionally in terms of its relations with other objects . `` one does not really need a space to begin with . the notion of space comes out as a convenience at the end '' . the physical objects consist of some units with definite spin acting among themselves giving rise to a n - unit with a total spin representing a direction . the interaction of two n - units es interpreted as the angle between the two directions . they consider the notion of space - time continuum as an illusion of low energy dynamics . quantum systems are defined without the notion of space . the @xmath0 variables have to be replaced by the labels for quantum degrees of freedom . bose and fermi fields satisfy the canonical commutation relation , where the quantum degree of freedom play the role of site variable . @xmath1 = -i\delta_{\ell m},\left\{\psi_{\alpha } ^+ \left(\ell\right),\psi_\beta \left(m\right)\right\}=\delta_{\alpha \rho}\delta_{\ell m}\ ] ] the hamiltonian incorporates link fields @xmath2 and @xmath3 to boson and fermion fields , satisfying @xmath4=-i\delta _ { \ell \ell ' } \delta_{mm'}\delta _ { \alpha \alpha ' } \delta_{\beta \beta ' } \ ] ] the hamiltonian is constructed out of such fields . @xmath5\ ] ] all the fields are labelled by integer indexes , that is , they are connected among themselves as a finite network , with the structure of 1-simplex , ( where each field is acting with all the other fields ) and the different 1-simplices are interacting with other 1-simplices giving rise to n - simplex of more complicated structure . this is called a generalized slac lattice , which underlies the continuum space - time . @xcite . this author , after classifying the relational theories of space and time , proposes a set - theoretical model of space and time in which the primitive concepts are preparticles as the most basic components of a physical system . using the membership relation of set theory he construct the elementary particles as subsets of the power set of preparticles . inclusion relations among preparticles and interaction among them gives rise to the temporal and spatial structure of the world out of which reference frames and motions are described . @xcite proposes a relational theory of physical space . the world is constituded by things such as elementary particles and fields and physical systems are composed out of these things . the concept of space is a derived one , therefore these things are not located in the space . these things are acting among themselves , the result of these interactions are called processes or events . space is nothing more that the collections of these individual things and their relations . @xcite starts from the set of concrete physical events @xmath6 , or , the set of space - time points that are actually occupied by material objects or processes . there is a relationalist s ontology by which the ( 3 + 1)-dimensional continuum is nothing more than a construction out of the set @xmath6 of physical events . @xcite offers a relational theory of minkowski space - time . suppose that there are a finite number of point particles and the mutual spatial relations among the particles obey the axioms of euclidean geometry . any talk about space is to be analyzed according to the representations of the interparticle relations . of course these theories must recover the field - theoretical models out of the individual events that are finite in number . a real challenge for the relational theories . @xcite has introduced the concept of pregeometry to understand the laws of euclidean and non - euclidean geometry . the objects in the pregeometry are logical in character . space and time are not physical entities but conceptions created by man , to keep track of the order of things . time and space must be derived in the classical limit from the universe of our discrete elements ( or bits ) of information . @xcite have develope wheeler s ideas in some model of curved space time using spin - network , the elementary structure of which are the @xmath7-simbols for 3 particles of spin 1/2 acting among themselves . the structure of a curve 2-dimensional surface is described by the closed interaction of half - integral spin particles whose diagramatic representation is given by a closed finely triangulated 2-surface with @xmath8 triangles and @xmath9 edges . the fineness of the diagram , determined by @xmath10 , can be used to derive a correspondence law between the basic pregeometry and the continuous limit of physical geometry . the ponzano - regge model has been developped by modern authors in the study of quantum gravity . in the last section we have reviewed some modern theories in which the concepts of space and time are derived from the relations among fundamental objects ( building blocks ) . the underlying structure should be compared with the properties of the physical space and time . we want to develope now some pregeometry in which the axioms are given by mutual relations of these building blocks . given some reticular network of fundamental objects we can postulate from purely logical properties ( in the sense of wheeler s pregeometry ) a n - dimensional cubic lattice . the difference between hilbert s axiomatic formulation and our approach is the following : hilbert @xcite presuposes the concepts of points , lines and surfaces , and the axioms are constructed with these objects . in our approach the points , lines and surfaces are derived from the relational character of the lattice , but the logical consecuences of the lattice are equivalent to the set of axioms in hilbert s formulation . a _ principal straight line _ is a indefinite set of points in the lattice , such that each of them is contiguous to other two , and the minimal path between two arbitrary points of this line is always unique . from these two theorems we can define cartesian ( discrete ) coordinates and an euclidean space . this structure of 2-dimensional space can be easily generalized to 3-dimensional cubic lattice . with the help of cartesian coordinates we can define a ( non principal ) straight line passing through two arbitrary points . 1 . there is a unique straight line through any two different points . any straight line contains at least two points . there are three non - colinear points . 2 . given three points a , b , c of a straight line if b is between a and c , a , b , c are three distinct points , and b is between c and a. given two points a and c , there exists one point b over the straight line ac such that c is between a and b. given three points on a straight line there is only one between the other two . 3 . given two points a , b of a straight line , and a point @xmath13 of the same or different line there exists a point @xmath14 in the same line as @xmath13 such that the segment @xmath13@xmath14 is congruent with ab . if two segments are congruent with a third one , they are congruent one to another . 4 . given a straight line and a point exterior to it , there exists one and only one straight line that incides in the point and does not cross the first one . for more complicated lattice we can follow the `` skeleton '' geometry of wheeler used to describe the topological properties of curved space - time , that where developped by regge and recently by many other authors . @xcite `` angular momentum : an approach to combinatorial space - time '' in _ quantum theory and beyond _ ( t. bastin ed . ) cambridge 1971 ; `` newton , quantum theory and reality '' in _ three hundred years of gravitation _ ( s.w . hawking and w. israel ed . ) cambridge 1987 .

we present current theories about the structure of space and time , where the building blocks are some fundamental entities ( yes - no experiment , quantum processes , spin net - work , preparticles ) that do not presuppose the existence of space and time . the relations among these objects are the base for a pregeometry of discrete character , the continuous limit of which gives rise to the physical properties of the space and time .

cs0701180

since the mid-1990s we built visual interactive maps of bibliographic and database information at strasbourg astronomical observatory , and some of these , with references , are available at murtagh [ 2006d ] . the automated annotation of such maps is not easy . at the time of writing zdnet and the bbc ( british broadcasting corporation ) use interactive annotated maps to support information navigation . in zdnet s case , some prominent terms are graphically presented and can be used to carry out a local search ; and in the bbc case , terms relating to downloadable radio programs are displayed in moving sizes and locations . in the work described in this article , we adopt a different approach : we select the terms of interest in a manual or semi - automated way . this not only represents expert user judgement but also allows for inclusion of rare or very frequent terms . in one of our three case studies , we use an automated way to select such terms . for selected terms , we use their inter - relationships to build a hierarchy and use this as a central device for summarizing information and supporting navigation . `` ontologies are often equated with taxonomic hierarchies of classes ... but ontologies need not be limited to such a form '' [ gruber 2001 ] . gruber is cited in gmez - prez et al . [ 2004 ] as characterizing an ontology as `` an explicit specification of a conceptualization '' . in wache et al . [ 2001 ] , ontologies are motivated by semantic heterogeneity of distributed data stores . this is also termed data heterogeneity and is counterposed to structural or schematic heterogeneity . ontologies are motivated by wache et al . [ 2001 ] `` for the explication of implicit and hidden knowledge '' , as `` a possible approach to overcome the problem of semantic heterogeneity '' . so , ontologies may help with integration of diverse , but related , data ; or they may help with clarifying or disambiguating distinctions in the heterogeneous data . ontologies are likely to be of immediate help in supporting querying . for example , the query model may be based on the ontology ( or ontologies ) used . there is extensive activity on standards and software , relating more to the above - mentioned schematic rather than semantic heterogeneity , and a useful survey of this area is denny [ 2004 ] . denny takes an ontology in a broad - ranging view as a knowledge - representation scheme . a short review of some recent approaches in this area follows . ahmad and gillam [ 2005 ] develop a semi - automated approach using text with no markup . multiword expressions are determined , and frequency of occurrence information is used to point to term or phrase importance . a stop list is used to avoid irrelevant words . part of speech analysis is not used . a semantic net is formed to allow development of the ontology elements . abou assali and zanghi [ 2006 ] use syntactic part of speech tagging to determine the nouns . these authors retain sufficiently frequent nouns . they apply the notion of weak subsumption : if for the most part a word is in a text that another is in , and not vice versa , then this leads to a hierarchical relationship . chuang and chien [ 2005 ] assert that multiway trees are appropriate for concept hierarchies , whereas binary trees are built using hierarchical clustering algorithms . hence they modify the latter to provide more appropriate output . ( a formal approach for mapping a binary hierarchical classification tree onto a multiway hierarchy is described in murtagh [ 2006b ] . ) a hierarchical clustering has often been used to represent an ontology . note that this is usually not a concept hierarchy . a concept hierarchy is based on a subsumption relationship between terms , whereas a hierarchical clustering is an embedded set of clusters of the term set . later in this article ( section [ secorientree ] ) , we show a way to derive a concept hierarchy , involving subsumption of terms , from a hierarchic clustering . a hierarchic clustering is typically a binary , rooted , terminal labeled , ranked tree , and a concept hierarchy is typically a multiway , rooted , terminal and non - terminal labeled , ranked tree . by starting with the former ( binary ) tree representation , we have an extensive theoretical and formal arsenal at our disposal , to represent the main lines of what we need to do , and to help to avoid ad hoc , user parameter - based , `` engineering '' approaches . as seen later in this work , we start by laying the foundations of our perspective by basing this on binary trees , and later proceed to the multiway tree . an alternative approach can be found in ganesan et al . [ 2003 ] , where similarities or distances on trees are redefined and re - axiomatized for the case of multiway trees . an alternative representation for an ontology is a lattice , and formal concept analysis ( fca ) is a methodology for the analysis of such lattices . if we have a set of documents or texts , @xmath0 , characterized by an index term set @xmath1 , then as janowitz [ 2005 ] shows , hierarchical clustering and fca are loosely related . hierarchical clustering is based on pairwise distances or dissimilarities , @xmath2 ( @xmath3 is the set of non - negative reals ) . fca is based on partially ordered sets ( posets ) such that there is a dissimilarity @xmath4 ( @xmath5 is the power set of the index terms , @xmath1 ) . other approaches ( rule - based ; machine learning approaches , etc . ; layered , engineering , approaches with maintenance management see maedche [ 2006 ] ) are also available . one difficulty with such `` engineering '' approaches is that there is an ad hoc understanding of the problem area , and often there is dependence on somewhat arbitrary threshold and selection criteria that do not generalize well . our approach formalizes the problem area the information space in terms of its local or global topology . where we do have selection criteria , such user interaction is at the application goal level . visualization is often an important way to elucidate semantic heterogeneity for the user . visual user interfaces for ontological elucidation are discussed in murtagh et al . [ 2003 ] , with examples that include interactive , responsive information maps based on the kohonen self - organizing feature map ; and semantic network graphs . a study is presented in murtagh et al . [ 2003 ] of client - side visualization of concept hierarchies relating to an economics information space . the use of `` semantic road maps '' to support information retrieval goes back to doyle [ 1961 ] . motivation , following murtagh et al . [ 2003 ] , includes the following : ( i ) visualization of the semantic structure and content of the data store allows the user to have some idea before submitting a query as to what type of outcome is possible . hence visualization is used to summarize the contents of the database or data collection ( i.e. , information space ) . ( ii ) the user s information requirements are often fuzzily and ambiguously defined at the outset of the information search . hence visualization is used to help the user in his / her information navigation , by signaling the relationships between concepts . ( iii ) ontology visualization therefore helps the user before the user interacts with the information space , and during this interaction . it is a natural enough progression that the visualization becomes the user interface . this article is organised as follows . to begin with , in section [ sect2 ] , we table the issue of whether or not there is inherent hierarchical structure in a text , or a collection of texts . in section [ sect3 ] we show how we can rigorously determine the extent of inherent hierarchical structure in a text . this quantifying of inherent hierarchical structure is then used in subsections [ sect41 ] , [ sect42 ] , [ sect52 ] and [ sect7 ] . a text provides both global and linear semantics , and how we can process these two different perspectives on a given text is discussed in section [ sect4 ] . a central aspect of our approach is a new distance or metric , which we have recently introduced and exemplified on another data analysis problem . this new distance is described in subsection [ sect5 ] . in section [ sect6 ] we apply what we have described in earlier sections to the selection of salient and characteristic pairs and triplets of terms , and also the selection of pertinent terms . our motivation is not just the traditional view of phrase counting ( even though we incorporate this view ) but rather the characterization of text content using its internal ( local hierarchical ) structure . a natural approach to defining a concept hierarchy lies in use of a hierarchical clustering algorithm . however , the latter forms an embedded sequence of clusters , so that a hierarchy of concepts must somehow be derived from it . in section [ secorientree ] we first of all show that `` converting '' any hierarchical clustering into a hierarchy of concepts is relatively straightforward . however we do have to face the problem of a unique , and beyond that best , solution . we show how we can admirably address this need for a unique solution . our innovative approach is based on the foundations laid in sections [ sect2 ] and [ sect4 ] of this article . we analyze three different data sets in this work : firstly a set of documents , with some degree of heterogeneity , to illustrate our key goal ; secondly a homogeneous text , partitioned into successive textual segments ; and thirdly a small homogeneous text , partitioned at the sentence level , proxied by lines of text . we select terms , indeed nouns , in a partially automated way , since this crucial aspect of ontology design may benefit from being user - driven , and may have scalability advantages . in later sections we address the issue of finding and presenting structure in text . we link such structure with the textual content . consequently a key , initial question is to know whether or not there is structure present , and to what extent . a first problem to be addressed is whether or not the document has any hierarchical structure to begin with . as input , we have possibly a fully tagged document ( based , e.g. , on part - of - speech tagging , schmid [ 1994 ] ) . however in this work , we start with free text , because it is the most generally available and applicable framework . additional information provided by part - of - speech tagging can be of use to us , as we will show later . next we consider the issue of whether or not a document has sufficient inherent hierarchical structure to warrant further investigation . we could approach this problem by fitting a hierarchy , and there are many algorithms for doing so ( such as any hierarchical clustering algorithm ; de soete [ 1986 ] describes a least squares optimal fitting approach ) . however departure from inherent hierarchical structure is not easily pinpointed . after all , we have an output induced structure , and we are told , let s say , that the fit is 80% ( defined as @xmath6 where @xmath7 is input dissimilarity , @xmath8 is tree or ultrametric distance read off the output , and the sums are over all pairs ) , which is not very revealing nor useful . an alternative `` bottom - up '' approach is pursued here , which allows easy assessment of inherent structure , and also pinpointing where this occurs or does not occur . a formal definition of hierarchical structure is provided by ultrametric topology ( in turn , related closely to p - adic number theory ) . the triangular inequality holds for a metric space : @xmath9 for any triplet of points @xmath10 . in addition the properties of symmetry and positive definiteness are respected . the `` strong triangular inequality '' or ultrametric inequality is : @xmath11 for any triplet @xmath10 . an ultrametric space implies respect for a range of stringent properties . for example , the triangle formed by any triplet is necessarily isosceles , with the two large sides equal ; or is equilateral . in an ultrametric space ( i.e. , a space endowed with an ultrametric , or an ultrametric topology ) , one `` lives '' , so to speak , in a tree . all `` moves '' between one location and another are as if one descended the tree to a common tree node , and then reclimbed to the target point . topologically , an ultrametric goes a lot further : all points in a circle or sphere are centers , for example ; or the radius of a sphere is identical to its diameter . the triangle property respected by any triplet of points in an ultrametric space affords a useful way to quantify extent of hierarchical structure . we will describe our `` extent of hierarchical structure '' , on a scale of 0 ( no respect for ultrametricity ) to 1 ( everywhere , respect for the ultrametric or tree distance ) algorithmically . we examine triplets of points ( exhaustively if possible , or otherwise through sampling ) , and determine the three angles formed by the associated triangle . we select the smallest angle formed by the triplet points . then we check if the other two remaining angles are approximately equal . if they are equal then our triangle is isosceles with small base , or equilateral ( when all triangles are equal ) . the approximation to equality is given by 2 degrees ( 0.0349 radians ) . our motivation for the approximate ( `` fuzzy '' ) equality is that it makes our approach robust and independent of measurement precision . this approach works very well in practice [ murtagh 2004 ; 2006a ] . we may note our one assumption for our data when we look at triangles in this way : scalar products define angles so that by assuming our data are in a hilbert space ( a complete normed vector space with a scalar product ) we may proceed with this analysis . this hilbert space assumption is very straightforward in practice . when finite ( as is always the case for us , in practice ) , we are using a euclidean space . often in practice , for arbitrary euclidean data , there is very little ultrametricity as quantified by the proportion of triangles satisfying the ultrametric requirement . but recoding the data can be of great help in dramatically increasing the proportion of such ultrametricity - respecting triangles [ murtagh 2004 ; 2005a ] . if we recode our data such that each pairwise distance or dissimilarity is mapped onto one element of the set @xmath12 , then as seen in subsection [ sect5 ] below the triangular inequality becomes particularly easy to assess for existence of , or non - existence of , a locally ultrametric relationship . in our use of free text , we have already noted how a mapping into a euclidean space gives us the capability to define distance in a simple and versatile way . in correspondence analysis [ murtagh 2005b ] , the texts we are using provide the rows , and the set of terms used comprise the column set . in the output , euclidean factor coordinate space , each text is located as a weighted average of the set of terms ; and each term is located as a weighted average of the set of texts . ( this simultaneous display is sometimes termed a biplot . ) so texts and terms are both mapped into the same , output coordinate space . this can be of use in understanding a text through its closest terms , or vice versa . a commonly used methodology for studying a set of texts , or a set of parts of a text ( which is what we will describe below ) , is to characterize each text with numbers of terms appearing in the text , for a set of terms . the @xmath13 distance is an appropriate weighted euclidean distance for use with such data [ benzcri 1979 ; murtagh 2005b ] . consider texts @xmath14 and @xmath15 crossed by words @xmath16 . let @xmath17 be the number of occurrences of word @xmath16 in text @xmath14 . then , omitting a constant , the @xmath13 distance between texts @xmath14 and @xmath15 is given by @xmath18 . the weighting term is @xmath19 . the weighted euclidean distance is between the _ profile _ of text @xmath14 , viz . @xmath20 for all @xmath16 , and the analogous _ profile _ of text @xmath15 . ( our discussion is to within a constant because we actually work on _ frequencies _ defined from the numbers of occurrences . ) correspondence analysis allows us to project the space of documents ( we could equally well explore the terms in the _ same _ projected space ) into a euclidean space . it maps the all - pairs @xmath13 distance into the corresponding euclidean distance . for a term , we use the ( full rank ) projections on factors resulting from correspondence analysis . as noted , this factor space is endowed with the ( unweighted ) euclidean distance . we will also take into consideration the strongest `` given '' in regard to any classical text : its linearity ( or total ) order . a text is read from start to finish , and consequently is linearly ordered . a text endowed with this linear order is analogous to a time series . if we use the correspondence analysis ( full dimensionality ) factor coordinates for each term , then the textual time series we are dealing with is seen to be a multivariate time series . just as the way we code our input data plays a crucial role in the resulting analysis , so also the recoding of pairwise distances can influence the analysis greatly . in murtagh [ 2005a ] we introduced a new distance , which we will term the `` change versus no change '' , cvnc , metric , and showed its benefits on a wide range of ( financial , biomedical , meteorological , telecoms , chaotic , and random ) time series . motivation for using this new metric is that it greatly increases the ultrametricity of the data . the cvnc metric is defined in the following way . take the euclidean distance squared , @xmath21 for all @xmath22 , where we have terms @xmath23 in the factor space with coordinates @xmath24 . it will be noted below in this section how this assumption of euclidean distance squared has worked well but is not in itself important : in principle any dissimilarity can be used . we enforce sparseness on our given squared distance values , @xmath25 . we do this by approximating each value @xmath26 , in the range @xmath27 , by an integer in @xmath28 . the value of @xmath29 must be specified . in our work we set @xmath30 . the recoding of distance squared is with reference to the mean distance squared : values less than or equal to this will be mapped to 1 ; and values greater than this threshold will be mapped to 2 . thus far , the recoded value , @xmath31 is not necessarily a distance . with the extra requirement that @xmath32 whenever @xmath33 it can be shown that @xmath31 is a metric [ murtagh 2005a ] : * theorem : * _ the recoded pairwise measure , @xmath34 , defined as described above from any dissimilarity , is a distance , satisfying the properties of : symmetry , positive definiteness , and triangular inequality . _ to summarize , in our coding , a small pairwise dissimilarity is mapped onto a value of 1 ; and a large pairwise dissimilarity is mapped onto a value of 2 . identical values are unchanged : they are mapped onto 0 . this coding can be considered as encoding pairwise relationships as `` change '' , i.e. 2 , versus `` no change '' , i.e. 1 , relationships . then , based on these new distances , we use the ultrametric triangle properties to assess conformity to ultrametricity . the proportion of ultrametric triangles allows us to fingerprint our data . for any given triplet ( of terms , with pairwise cvnc distances ) , if the triplet is to be compatible with the ultrametric inequality , each set of three recoded distances is necessarily of one of the following patterns : trivial : : : at least one ( recoded ) distance is 0 , in which case we do not consider it . equilateral : : : recoded distances in the triplet are 1,1,1 or 2,2,2 , defining an equilateral triangle . ultrametric isosceles : : : recoded distances in the triplet are 1,2,2 in any order , defining an isosceles triangle with small base . non - ultrametric : : : recoded distances in the triplet are 1,1,2 in any order . the non - ultrametric case here is seen to be an isosceles triangle with large base . we could `` intervene '' and change one of the values to make it ultrametric . if we change the 2-value to a 1-value , this will produce an equilateral triangle , which is ultrametric . in this case , we are approximating our three values optimally from below , and the resulting ultrametric is termed the subdominant , or maximally inferior , ultrametric . the associated stepwise algorithm for constructing a hierarchy is known as the single link hierarchical clustering algorithm . on the other hand , we could change one of the 1-values to a 2 . this is not unique , since we could change either of the 1-values . the resulting hierarchy is termed the minimally superior ultrametric . the associated stepwise algorithm for constructing a hierarchy is known as the complete link hierarchical clustering algorithm . all of this is very clear from the case considered here . the recoding into the cvnc metric is a particular example of symbolic coding . see murtagh [ 2006c ] . in the next section , we will show the usefulness of this cvnc metric for quantifying inherent hierarchical structure . in this section we first describe the data set used . next , based on the foundation of the previous section , we quantify inherent hierarchical structure in our data . this justifies going further , to harness and exploit this structure . we use 14 texts taken from wikipedia ( mid-2006 ) , and coverted to straight text from html . table [ tabprop ] shows the numbers of words in each . .properties of texts used . [ cols= " < , < , > , > , > " , ] to the extent that our data satisfies , globally and throughout , the ultrametric inequality , we can adopt any of the widely used hierarchical clustering algorithms ( single , complete , average linkage ; minimum variance , median , centroid ) to induce an identical , unique hierarchy . but when we find our data to be , say , 86% ultrametric , as is not untypically the case in practice , then we must consider carefully what our aim is . if we wished to look at each and every isosceles triangle , then in the case of the artificial intelligence text this means , out of a total of 2,027,795 triplets ( i.e. , @xmath35 ) we must consider 1,007,597 . what we will do instead is return to taking our text as a time series . we have 231 unique nouns in the artificial intelligence text . in the text , these nouns are used , in total , on 405 occasions . so our text is a time series of 405 values . for successive nouns in this textual time series , the cvnc metric has an evident meaning : _ we are noting semantic change versus lack of change as we read through the text_. we examine successive triplets in the textual time series . for the artificial intelligence text , we find 45% of the triplets to be equilateral ; 37% of the triplets are isosceles ; and 18% of the triplets are non - ultrametric . the isosceles triplets point to a dominance or subsumption relationship that will be of use for us in a concept hierarchy . say we have a triplet @xmath36 . say , further , that the cvnc distance between @xmath37 and @xmath38 is 1 , so therefore there is no change in progressing from use of term @xmath37 to use of term @xmath38 . however both @xmath37 and @xmath38 are at cvnc distance 2 to term @xmath39 , and this betokens a semantic change . so the relationship is simply represented as @xmath40 . the term @xmath39 dominates or subsumes @xmath37 and @xmath38 . the following results hold . firstly , say that a successive triplet of values , in any order , is found as @xmath36 , and later in the text , again , this triplet is found in any order . then the relationship between the three recoded distances in both cases will be identical . _ for a given triplet , in any order within the triplet , the relationship is unique . _ secondly , consider any other term , @xmath41 , such that some or all of the terms @xmath36 are found to have a relationship with @xmath41 . as an example , we meet with @xmath42 at one point in the text , and later we meet with @xmath43 . then there is no influence by @xmath41 on the relationship ensuing from the @xmath43 triplet , vis - - vis the relationship ensuing from the earlier @xmath42 triplet . _ we have locality of the relationship in any given triplet , from successive terms . the relationship is strictly local to the given triplet . _ among the isosceles triangles in the artificial intelligence text , we find the following relationships . .... ( computer science ) branch ( home computer ) world ( analysis systems ) formalism ( analysis systems ) reasoning ( expert system ) conclusion ( expert system ) amounts ( example networks ) reasoning ( networks learning ) reasoning ( pattern recognition ) capabilities ( control systems ) computation ( consciousness systems ) logic ( medicine computer ) commentators ( computer technology ) commentators ( application feature ) os ( application feature ) languages ( libraries systems ) specialist ( libraries systems ) programmers ( software engineering ) development ( software engineering ) practices ( programs example ) logic ( example type ) logic ( projects publications ) life ( publications bayesian ) life ( bayesian networks ) life ( cybernetics systems ) agents ( systems control ) agents ( wiki web ) website ( wiki web ) category ( algorithm implementations ) projects ( algorithm implementations ) demonstrations ( implementations research ) demonstrations ( research group ) demonstrations .... however there are other isosceles triplets that are less self - evident . for this reason therefore we take all texts . for the 14 texts , we have 6439 nouns , and 1470 unique nouns . with our cvnc metric on all pairs of nouns , the complete link hierarchical clustering method gives 21 clusters in all . while one application of the foregoing is to deriving common pairs and triplets of terms , in practice it would be better to combine all relationships into a `` bigger picture '' . we will address this below in section [ secorientree ] . presenting a result with around 1500 terms does not lend itself to convenient display . we ask therefore what the most useful perhaps the most discriminating terms are . in correspondence analysis both texts and their characterizing terms are projected into the same factor space . see figure [ caout ] . so , from the factor coordinates , we can easily find the closest term(s ) to a given text . we do this for each of the 14 texts , and find the closest terms , respectively , as follows : .... bayesian automaton brain captcha psychologists image maps logic topologies databases agents representation game games .... a hierarchical clustering of these is shown in figure [ den15 ] . the ward minimum variance method is used , as being appropriate for structuring data well ( see murtagh [ 1984b ] ) and also having an agglomerative criterion that is appropriate for the prior euclidean embedding ( viz . , inertia - based in both cases ) . the data clustered are exactly those illustrated in the best planar projection of figure [ caout ] : these are 14 texts in a 4048-dimensional term space . due to centering in the dual spaces , the inherent dimensionality of both text and term spaces are : min@xmath44 = 13 . based on the dual spaces , we carry out the eigen - reduction in the space of smaller original dimensionality ( viz . , the space of the terms , which are in a 14-dimensional space ) , and then subsequently project into the 4048-dimensional space . proceeding further , the 5 closest terms to any given text , based on the full inherent dimensionality of this data ( viz . , smaller of dimensionality of texts , and dimensionality of terms ) , are as follows . .... text and set of 5 closest characterizing terms : artificial intelligence bayesian intelligence consciousness brains chatterbots artificial life automaton automata biology chemical allelomimesis artificial neural networks brain prediction forecasting aircraft epitomes captcha captcha captchas robot intelligence chemistry computational linguistics psychologists logics morphology pragmatics logicians computer vision image images diagnosis dimensionality dimensions evolutionary computation maps intelligence robot biology chemistry fuzzy logic logic mapping animals brakes armies genetic algorithms topologies communications music finance representations machine translation databases chemistry database memory robot multi - agent system agents agent robotics cybernetics robot semantic network representation database map namespaces robot turing test game chatterbot consciousness memory intelligence virtual world games gameplay topography communication representations .... we have noted in the introduction how a hierarchical clustering may be the starting point for creating a concept hierarchy , but the two representations differ . in this section we show how we can move from an embedded set of clusters , to an oriented tree . orientation in the latter case aims at expressing subsumption . consider the dendrogram shown in figure [ den1 ] , which represents an embedded set of clusters relating to the 8 terms . we will consider first such a strictly 2-way hierarchy , where we assume that no two agglomerations take place at precisely the same level . in the later case study , in subsection [ sect7 ] , we will consider the practical case where agglomerations take place at the same level . rather than the 14 texts used in section [ sect6 ] , to clarify the presentation in this section we will take just one text . we took aristotle s _ categories _ , which consisted of 14,483 individual words . we broke the text into 24 files , in order to base the textual analysis on the sequential properties of the argument developed . in these 24 files there were 1269 unique words . we selected 66 nouns of particular interest . a sample ( with frequencies of occurrence ) : man ( 104 ) , contrary ( 72 ) , same ( 71 ) , subject ( 60 ) , substance ( 58 ) , ... no stemming or other preprocessing was applied . for the hierarchical clustering , we further restricted the set of nouns to just 8 . ( these will be seen in the figures to be discussed below . ) the data array was doubled [ murtagh 2005b ] to produce an @xmath45 array , which with removing 0-valued text segments ( since , in one text segment , none of our selected 8 nouns appeared ) gave an @xmath46 array , thereby enforcing equal weighting of ( equal masses for ) the nouns used . the spaces of the 8 nouns , and of the 23 text segments ( together with the complements of the 23 text segments , on account of the data doubling ) are characterized at the start of the correspondence analysis in terms of their frequencies of occurrence , on which the @xmath13 metric is used . the correspondence analysis then `` euclideanizes '' both nouns and text segments . we used a 7-dimensional ( corresponding to the number of non - zero eigenvalues found ) euclidean embedding , furnished by the projections onto the factors . a hierarchical clustering of the 8 nouns , characterized by their 7-dimensional ( euclidean ) factor projections , was carried out : figure [ den1 ] . the ward minimum variance agglomerative criterion was used , with equal weighting of the 8 nouns . figure [ den2 ] shows a canonical representation of the dendrogram in figure [ den1 ] . both trees are isomorphic to one another . figure [ den2 ] is shown such that the sequence of agglomerations is portrayed from left to right ( and of course from bottom to top ) . we say that figure [ den2 ] is a canonical representation of the dendrogram , implying that figure [ den1 ] is not in canonical form . in figure [ den3 ] , the canonical representation has its non - terminal nodes labeled . next , figure [ den4 ] shows a superimposed oriented binary rooted tree , on @xmath47 nodes , which is isomorphic to the dendrogram on @xmath48 terminal nodes . this oriented binary tree is an inorder traversal of the dendrogram . sibson s [ 1973 ] `` packed representation '' of a dendrogram uses just such an oriented binary rooted tree , in order to define a permutation representation of the dendrogram . from our example , the packed representation permutation can be read off as : @xmath49 : for any terminal node indexed by @xmath14 , with the exception of the rightmost which will always be @xmath48 , define @xmath50 as the rank at which the terminal node is first united with some terminal node to its right . discussion of combinatorial properties of dendrograms , as related to such oriented binary rooted trees , and associated down - up and up - down permutations , can be found in murtagh [ 1984a ] . , but now with successively _ later _ agglomerations always represented by _ right _ child node . apart from the labels of the initial pairwise agglomerations , this is otherwise a unique representation of the dendrogram ( hence : `` existence '' and `` object '' can be interchanged ; so can `` disposition '' and `` fact '' ; and finally `` name '' and `` disposition '' ) . in the discussion we refer to this representation , with later agglomerations always parked to the right , as our canonical representation of the dendrogram.,width=529 ] , with non - terminal nodes numbered in sequence . these will form the nodes of the oriented binary tree . we may consider one further node for completeness , 8 or @xmath51 , located at an arbitrary location in the upper right.,width=529 ] finally , in figure [ den5 ] , we `` promote '' terminal node labels to the nodes of the oriented tree . we will use exactly the procedure used above for defining a permutation representation of the oriented tree . first the left terminal label is promoted to its non - terminal node . next , the right terminal label is promoted as far up the tree as is necessary in order to find an unlabeled non - terminal node . this procedure is carried out for all non - terminal labels , working in sequence from left to right ( i.e. , consistent with our canonical representation of the dendrogram ) . the rightmost label is not shown : it is at an arbitrary location in the upper right hand side , with a tree arc oriented towards the top non - terminal node of the dendrogram , now labeled as `` motion '' . in this section , we have specified a consistent procedure for labeling the nodes of an oriented tree , starting from the labels associated with the terminal nodes of a dendrogram . we start therefore with embedded clusters , and end up with terms and directed links between these terms . there is some non - uniqueness : any two labels associated with terminal nodes that are left and right child nodes of one non - terminal node can be interchanged . this clearly leads to a different label promotion outcome . our promotion procedure was motivated by the permutation representation of an oriented binary tree , as described above . here too we do not claim uniqueness of permutation representation . but we do claim optimality in the sense of parsimony , and well - definedness . in the case of a multiway tree with very few distinct levels , the promotion procedure becomes very simple , but continues to be non - unique . in the previous subsection , we discussed an algorithm which takes a hierarchical clustering , and hence a dendrogram , into an inorder tree traversal , and hence a permutation of the set of terms used . the formal procedure discussed in the previous subsection suffers from non - uniqueness : alternative permutations could be defined . this leads us to question the relationship of subsumption ( or direction in the oriented tree ) . in this section we will develop another approach which is even more closely associated with the data that we are analyzing . we have already seen that triangle properties between triplets of points , or data objects , are fundamental to ultrametricity and hence to tree representation . a dendrogram , representing a hierarchical clustering , allows us to read off , for all triplets of points , either ( i ) isosceles triangles , with small base , or ( ii ) equilateral triangles , and ( iii ) no other triangle configuration . the reason for the last condition is simply that non - isosceles , or isosceles with large base , triangles are incompatible with the ultrametric , or tree , metric . we will leave aside for the present the equilateral triangle case . firstly , it implies that all 3 points are _ ex aequo _ in the same cluster . secondly , therefore we will treat them altogether as a concept cluster . thirdly , the equilateral case does not arise in the example we will now explore . and [ den3 ] , with clusters indicated by ellipses . shown here are ellipses covering the clusters at nodes 7 , 6 , 5 , and 3.,width=529 ] in figure [ den6 ] , cluster number 3 indicates the following isosceles triangle with small base : ( ( existence , object ) position ) . our notation is : ( ( x , y ) z ) , such that triplet x , y , z has small base x , y , and the side lengths x , z and y , z are equal . this is necessarily implied by relationships represented in figure [ den6 ] . so , motivated by this triangle view of the cluster number 3 part of the dendrogram we will promote `` position '' to the cluster number 3 node . similarly we will promote `` motion '' to the cluster number 5 node . note the consistency of our perspective on the cluster number 3 and 5 nodes relative to how the associated terms here form an isosceles triangle with small base . we will straight away generalize this definition . in any case of a node in the form of nodes 3 or 5 , where we have a 2-term left subtree , and a 1-term right subtree , where left and right are necessarily labeled in this way given the canonical representation of the dendrogram , then : _ the left subtree is dominated by the right subtree_. we will next look at cluster number 6 ( remaining with figure [ den6 ] ) . as always for such trees , the node corresponding to this cluster has two subtrees , one to the left ( here : 3 ) and one to the right ( here : 5 ) . since our dendrogram is in canonical form , any such node has a subtree with smallest non - terminal node level to the left ; and the subtree which was more recently formed in the sequence of agglomerations to the right . based on either or both of these criteria which serve to define what are the left and right subtrees we define the ordering relationship : _ the left subtree is dominated by the right subtree_. figure not available : see pdf version of paper at www.cs.rhul.ac.uk/home/fionn/papers/auto_onto.pdf figure [ concepts ] summarizes the concept relations that we can derive in a similar way from any dendrogram . figure [ aristontoex ] indicates how the concept relations , shown in figure [ concepts ] , are to be used . firstly the term set is summarized , using our selection of terms . scaling to large data sets is addressed in this way . secondly , in our interactive implementation ( web address : + thames.cs.rhul.ac.uk/@xmath52dimitri/textmap ) , we allow the terms shown to continually move in a limited way , to get around the occlusion problem , and we also allow magnification of the display area for this same reason . thirdly , terms other than those shown are highlighted when a cursor is passed over them . next , double clicking on any term gives a ranked list of text segment names , ordered by frequency of occurrence by this term . clicking on the text segment gives the actual text at the bottom of the display area . are shown in decreasing size ( and in rainbow colors , from red ) , with other terms ( in all , 66 ) displayed with a dash , and all text segments ( in all , 24 ) represented by an asterisk . the principal factor plane of a correspondence analysis ( based on the 24 text segments @xmath53 66 terms frequencies of occurence ) output is used.,width=529 ] we proceed now to a third case study of this work , where we have a multiway hieararchy ( and not a binary hierarchy ) from the start . we require a frequency of occurrence matrix which crosses the terms of interest with parts of a free text document . for the latter we could well take documentary segments like paragraphs . oneill [ 2006 ] is a 660-word discussion of ubiquitous computing from the perspective of human computing interaction . with this short document we used individual lines ( as proxies for the sequence of sentences ) as the component parts of the document . there were 65 lines . this facilitates retrieval of a small segment of such a single document . we chose this text to work with because it is a very small text ( a single text compared to the data used in section [ sect6 ] , and a far smaller text compared to that used in section [ secorientree ] ) . based on a list of nouns and substantives furnished by the part - of - speech tagger ( schmid , 1994 ) , we focused on the following 30 nouns : support = @xmath54 `` agents '' , `` algorithms '' , `` aspects '' , `` attempts '' , `` behaviours '' , `` concepts '' , `` criteria '' , `` disciplines '' , `` engineers '' , `` factors '' , `` goals '' , `` interactions '' , `` kinds '' , `` meanings '' , `` methods '' , `` models '' , `` notions '' , `` others '' , `` parts '' , `` people '' , `` perceptions '' , `` perspectives '' , `` principles '' , `` systems '' , `` techniques '' , `` terms '' , `` theories '' , `` tools '' , `` trusts '' , `` users '' @xmath55 . this set of 30 terms was used to characterize through presence / absence the 65 successive lines of text , leading to correspondence analysis of the @xmath56 presence / absence matrix . this yielded then the definition of the 30 terms in a factor space . in principle the rank of this space ( taking account of the trivial first factor in correspondence analysis , relating to the centering of the cloud of points ) is min ( @xmath57 ) . however , given the existence of zero - valued rows and/or columns , the actual rank was 25 . therefore the full rank projection of the terms into the factor space gave rise to 25-dimensional vectors for each term , and these vectors are endowed with the euclidean metric . define this set of 30 terms as the _ support _ of the document . based on their occurrences in the document , we generated the following _ reduced _ version of the document , defined on this support , which consists of the following ordered set of 52 terms : reduced document = `` goals '' `` techniques '' `` goals '' `` disciplines '' `` meanings '' `` terms '' `` others '' `` systems '' `` attempts '' `` parts '' `` trusts '' `` trusts '' `` people '' `` concepts '' `` agents '' `` notions '' `` systems '' `` people '' `` kinds '' `` behaviours '' `` people '' `` factors '' `` behaviours '' `` perspectives '' `` goals '' `` perspectives '' `` principles '' `` aspects '' `` engineers '' `` tools '' `` goals '' `` perspectives '' `` methods '' `` techniques '' `` criteria '' `` criteria '' `` perspectives '' `` methods '' `` techniques '' `` principles '' `` concepts '' `` models '' `` theories '' `` goals '' `` tools '' `` techniques '' `` systems '' `` interactions '' `` interactions '' `` users '' `` perceptions '' `` algorithms '' this reduced document is just the `` time series '' of the nouns of interest to us , as they are used in traversing the document from start to finish . each noun in the sequence of 52 nouns is represented by its 25-dimensional factor space vector . out of 43 unique triplets , with self - distances removed , we found 31 to respect the ultrametric inequality , i.e. 72% . our measure of ultrametricity of this document , based on the support used , was thus 0.72 . for a concept hierarchy we need an overall fit to the data . using the euclidean space perspective on the data , furnished by correspondence analysis , we can easily define a terms @xmath53 terms distance matrix ; and then hierarchically cluster that . consistent with our analysis we recode all these distances , using the cvnc mapping onto @xmath58 for unique pairs of terms . now approximating a global ultrametric from below , achieved by the single linkage agglomerative hierarchical clustering method ( and this best fit from below , termed the subdominant or maximal inferior ultrametric , is optimal ) , and an approximation from above , achieved by the complete linkage agglomerative hierarchical clustering method ( and this best fit from above , termed a minimal superior ultrametric , is non - unique and hence is one of a number of best fits from above ) , will be identical if the data is fully ultrametric - embeddable . if we had an ultrametricity coefficient equal to 1 we found it to be 0.72 for this data then it would not matter what agglomerative hierarchical clustering algorithm ( among the usual lance - williams methods ) that we select . in fact , we found , with an ultrametricity coefficient equal to 0.72 , that the single and complete linkage methods gave an identical result . this result is shown in figure [ fig1 ] . a convenient label promotion procedure to apply here is first to re - represent the terminal labels from left to right as : @xmath54 `` users '' , `` trusts '' , @xmath59 , `` agents '' , `` algorithms '' @xmath55 ; @xmath54 `` goals '' , `` perspectives '' @xmath55 ; @xmath54 `` tools '' @xmath55 ; @xmath54 `` techniques '' @xmath55 ; and @xmath54 `` methods '' @xmath55 . this is the canonical form , with ordering of left and right subtrees now extended to all subtrees . next , we must in fairness take the nodes at level 2 as being _ ex aequo _ , @xmath54 `` tools '' @xmath55 ; @xmath54 `` techniques '' @xmath55 ; and @xmath54 `` methods '' @xmath55 . similarly at level 1 , we also have two clusters that are _ ex aequo _ : @xmath54 `` users '' , `` trusts '' , @xmath59 , `` agents '' , `` algorithms '' @xmath55 ; and @xmath54 `` goals '' , `` perspectives '' @xmath55 . figure not available : see pdf version of paper at www.cs.rhul.ac.uk/home/fionn/papers/auto_onto.pdf figure [ ubiq ] shows our resulting scheme where level 1 clusters dominate level 2 clusters . this provides our ontology . the granularity of this one document is , as mentioned above , line - based , and there are 65 lines in all . hence retrieval of one or more of these document snippets is supported , and the ontology is based on a 30-noun document support . having first appraised text collections in terms of their local hierarchical structure , we then proceeded in this work to show how this new methodology could be employed for a wide range of tasks that include : * finding salient pairs and triplets of terms , which are not necessarily in sequence ; * permitting us to consider any given text as a whole with all pairwise relationships between terms , or alternatively as a time series with relationships restricted to terms that are successive in sequence ; * passing seamlessly from the exploration of local hierarchical structure to global hierarchical structure ; * especially when global hierarchical structure is manifest , being able to use any of a wide range of agglomerative clustering criteria to furnish the same resultant hierarchy ; * determining a hierarchy of concepts from the embedded , partially ordered subsets provided by a hierarchical clustering ; * obtaining unique results when given a 2-way hierarchical clustering tree , and then readily generalizing this to the practical case of multiway trees ; * exemplifying an efficient and an effective textual data processing pipeline ; and * through the measurement of local hierarchical structure , having available an approach to validating the appropriateness of any data for this data analysis pipeline . by analysis of text through local hierarchical relationships between terms we determine extensive internal textual structure , without being stifled by the more traditional approach of fitting some global structure , such as a hierarchy , to the text . a ( local ) hierarchical structure is a powerful one : it includes peer as well as subsumption types of relationships . we stress that we can find very pronounced hierarchical structures of this sort if we encode the text is novel ways . an example is to start with a euclidean spatial embedding of the terms and documents ( or segments of a document ) , which is quite traditional ; and then look at interrelationships between terms using `` relatively close / similar '' versus `` relatively distant / new '' ( and this alone can be shown to have metric properties ) . another example of an encoding - related strategy is not to take into consideration all interrelationships between terms , but only between successive terms , and thereby view the text as a particular type of time series . user interactivity with the system is to select the terms of interest ( people s personal names , industrial product names , location or venue names , etc . ) . the interrelationships between these terms are then explored through their local hierarchical links . our general application targeted is , as stated in murtagh et al . [ 2003 ] , to have readily available a self - description of data , as a basis for visually - based interactive and responsive querying of , retrieval from , and navigation of data collections . this work was carried out in the context of the european union sixth framework project , `` ws - talk , web services communicating in the language of their community '' , 20042006 . pedro contreras and dimitri zervas contributed to this work . the textmap demonstrator was developed by dimitri zervas . : : abou assali , a. and zanghi , h. 2006 . automated metadata hierarchy derivation . in _ proc . ieee ictta06 _ ( damascus , syria ) . : : ahmad , k. and gillam , l. ( 2005 ) . automatic ontology extraction from unstructured texts . in _ odbase 2005_. : : benzcri , j.p . _ lanalyse des donnes , tome i taxinomie , tome ii correspondances _ , 2nd ed . ( dunod , paris ) . : : chuang shui - lung and chien lee - feng ( 2005 ) . taxonomy generation for text segments : a practical web - based approach , acm transactions on information systems . 23 , 363396 . : : de soete , g. ( 1986 ) . a least squares algorithm for fitting an ultrametric tree to a dissimilarity matrix . _ pattern recognition letters _ , 2 , 133137 . : : denny , m. ( 2004 ) . ontology tools survey , revisited , at + http://www.xml.com/pub/a/2004/07/14/onto.html , july 2004 . : : doyle , l.b . semantic road maps for literature searches . _ journal of the acm_. 8 , 553578 . : : ganesan , p. , garcia - molina , h. and widom , j. ( 2003 ) . exploiting hierarchical domain structure to compute similarity _ acm transactions on information systems_. 21 , 6493 . : : gmez - prez , a. , fernndez - lpez , m. and corcho , o. ( 2004 ) . _ ontological engineering ( with examples from the areas of knowledge management , e - commerce and the semantic web ) _ ( springer , berlin ) . : : gruber , t. ( 2001 ) . what is an ontology ? , http://www-ksl.stanford.edu/kst/what-is-an-ontology.html , sept . : : janowitz , m.f . cluster analysis based on abstract posets , preprint . also presentation , enst de bretagne , 30 oct . 2004 ; dimacs , 9 mar . 2005 ; and sfc , 31 may 2005 . : : maedche , a. ( 2006 ) . _ ontology learning for the semantic web _ ( kluwer , dordrecht ) . : : murtagh , f. ( 1984a ) . counting dendrograms : a survey . _ discrete applied mathematics _ , 7 , 191199 . : : murtagh , f. ( 1984b ) . structures of hierarchic clusterings : implications for information retrieval and for multivariate data analysis . _ information processing and management _ , 20 , 611617 . : : murtagh , f. ( 2004 ) . on ultrametricity , data coding , and computation , _ journal of classification , 21 , 167184 . : : murtagh , f. ( 2005a ) . identifying the ultrametricity of time series , _ european physical journal b _ , 43 , 573579 . : : murtagh , f. ( 2005b ) . _ correspondence analysis and data coding with r and java _ ( chapman & hall / crc ) . : : murtagh , f. ( 2006a ) . ultrametricity in data : identifying and exploiting local and global hierarchical structure , arxiv : math.st/0605555v1 19 may 2006 . : : murtagh , f. ( 2006b ) . the haar wavelet transform of a dendrogram , + arxiv : cs.ir/0608107v1 28 aug 2006 , forthcoming in _ journal of classification_. : : murtagh , f. ( 2006c ) . symbolic dynamics in text : application to automated construction of concept hierarchies , _ festschrift for edwin diday _ , in press . available at : www.cs.rhul.ac.uk/home/fionn/papers : : murtagh . f. ( 2006d ) . visual user interfaces , interactive maps , references , theses , http://astro.u-strasbg.fr/@xmath52fmurtagh/inform : : murtagh , f. , taskaya , t. , contreras , p. , mothe , j. and englmeier , k. ( 2003 ) . interactive visual user interfaces : a survey , _ artificial intelligence review _ , 19 , 263283 . : : oneill , e. ( 2006 ) . understanding ubiquitous computing : a view from hci , in discussion following r. milner , ubiquitous computing : how will we understand it ? , _ computer journal _ , 49 , 390399 . : : schmid , h. ( 1994 ) . probabilistic part - of - speech tagging using decision trees . in _ proc . new methods in language processing _ ( see treetagger site ) . : : treetagger , www.ims.uni-stuttgart.de/projekte/corplex/treetagger/ decisiontreetagger.html : : sibson , r. ( 1973 ) . slink : an optimally efficient algorithm for the single - link cluster method , _ computer journal _ , 16 , 3034 . : : wache , h. , vgele , t. , visser , u. , stuckenschmidt , h. , schuster , g. , neumann , h. and hbner , s. ( 2001 ) . ontology - based integration of information a survey of existing approaches . in _ proceedings of the ijcai-01 workshop : ontologies and information sharing_.

we study the notion of hierarchy in the context of visualizing textual data and navigating text collections . a formal framework for `` hierarchy '' is given by an ultrametric topology . this provides us with a theoretical foundation for concept hierarchy creation . a major objective is _ scalable _ annotation or labeling of concept maps . serendipitously we pursue other objectives such as deriving common word pair ( and triplet ) phrases , i.e. , word 2- and 3-grams . we evaluate our approach using ( i ) a collection of texts , ( ii ) a single text subdivided into successive parts ( for which we provide an interactive demonstrator ) , and ( iii ) a text subdivided at the sentence or line level . while detailing a generic framework , a distinguishing feature of our work is that we focus on _ locality _ of hierarchic structure in order to extract semantic information . * categories and subject descriptors : * h.5 ( information interfaces and presentation ) , i.5.3 ( clustering ) , h.5.2 ( user interfaces ) , i.7.2 ( document preparation ) , h.3 ( information storage and retrieval )

1308.5960

one - dimensional electronic systems are characterized by the increased role of interactions and the formation of gapless collective modes , that breaks down the fermi liquid theory . instead , a state of matter is formed that is described as the luttinger liquid @xcite . it has become experimentally accessible in the quantum hall ( qh ) effect systems , where the edge states act as one - dimensional ( 1d ) chiral conductors . some of the recent exciting experiments worth mentioning would include : electronic mach - zehnder ( mz ) interferometry , in which the observed behavior of the interference oscillations has demonstrated the inapplicability of the single - electron description @xcite ; energy relaxation along the qh edge channels with some unexplained losses in the energy transfer @xcite ; a demonstration of coherence and indistinguishability of independently emitted electrons @xcite ; and coulomb interaction of a localized state , quantum dot ( qd ) , with qh edge states @xcite , which presents a situation that potentially contains very interesting physics in the strong coupling regime . however , the latter experimental work @xcite has considered the system only in thermal equilibrium , where , due to the detailed balance , the whole range of implications of strong coupling has remained obscured . . the quantum dot with the single relevant level at @xmath0 close to the fermi energy is coulomb interacting ( waved lines ) with the surrounding channels @xmath1 , with coupling strengths @xmath2 , and has a weak tunnel coupling with amplitudes @xmath3 with the inner channels ( dotted lines ) . voltage bias @xmath4 is applied to one of the outer channels , which creates nonequilibrium excitations after the left partitioning quantum point contact ( labeled @xmath5 ) with transparency @xmath6 . the visibility of the interference pattern with respect to the aharonov - bohm phase @xmath7 is observed after the right qpc . , scaledwidth=35.0% ] in this work we extend the discussion to the case far from equilibrium , where the tunneling transitions recharging the qd are stimulated by the nonequilibrium processes in the edge channels . the cooperation of the two factors , the nonequilibrium excitations in the channels and the backaction of the quantum fluctuations of the fermi sea due to perturbation by an event of tunneling , is manifested in the strong coupling regime by the orthogonality catastrophe , leading to the fermi edge singularity ( fes ) @xcite in the transition rates , and by their asymmetry with respect to the sign of the dissipative component of current . this is because the strong coupling negates the limitations of the _ central limit theorem _ , therefore giving access to the non - gaussian fluctuations of the charge current that break the charge symmetry , while commonly they are small @xcite and difficult to observe @xcite . an equivalent system at zero temperature has been considered in the previous initiative by rosenow and gefen @xcite . however , we must clearly indicate that in the specific regime defined above , our results are in sharp contradiction . particularly , we believe that thoroughly accounting for the effects of strong coupling might have been an issue in their case , while they assumed that the coupling is finite ( not weak ) and is even maximum possible in the most interesting case . in this respect , our results can also be contrasted with the results of some earlier works , in which the transition rates between a lead and a quantum dot interacting with noisy 1d conductors were studied , e.g. , refs . @xcite . in levinson s work @xcite the interaction between the qd and a qpc ( analogous to the 1d edge channels in our case ) was assumed to be weak . this assumption narrows the effects to the gaussian noise , and allowed a perturbative expansion in the interaction strength to the lowest order . in turn , @xcite , although using strong coupling , has adopted an assumption about the structure of the scattering matrix , that the mixing of the states arriving from different reservoirs is weak . this led to a substantially reduced effect of nonequilibrium noise , which only appeared as a small correction to the power - law exponent in the transition rates . the differences between the assumptions and the findings of these works and ours essentially highlight the exceptionality of the situation where strong coupling is combined with the non - gaussian noise . it should be also noted that a number of exact solutions of the fes problem exist in various systems @xcite , but they all require the use of highly complex methods that may obscure the physics , such as in ref . @xcite in which the distinctive nonequilibrium phenomenon of charge symmetry breaking in the strong coupling limit has been overlooked . in 1d systems , however , the complexity can be largely overcome by employing the recently developed nonequilibrium bosonization technique @xcite . this approach naturally accounts for the interactions and allows us to reduce the problem of finding electron correlation functions to the calculation of the full counting statistics ( fcs ) of a 1d current @xcite , which can then be calculated analytically for asymptotically low transmission or reflection , or numerically in a general case . the experimental setup is constructed by embedding the 1d channel as an arm of an electronic mz interferometer at @xmath8 @xcite , as shown schematically in fig . [ fig : setup ] . then the electron correlation function in the channel can be investigated by measuring the phase shift @xmath9 of the aharonov - bohm ( ab ) oscillations of the current @xmath10 and the visibility @xmath11 . the quantum dot charge fluctuates due to tunneling to some of the additional channels nearby . voltage bias @xmath4 applied before the partitioning quantum point contact ( qpc ) with transparency @xmath6 creates nonequilibrium excitations in the arms of the interferometer . the operating regime of the setup is determined by the interplay of the principal energy scales : the temperature @xmath12 of the environment , the quantum level broadening widths @xmath13 due to the tunnel coupling , and the classical level broadening @xmath14 due to the nonequilibrium noise - induced transitions , where @xmath15 is the fermi density of states and @xmath3 are the tunneling amplitudes . in the essentially quantum case , when @xmath13 is the dominant energy scale , the interferometer is found close to its ground state , where the interference pattern does not sustain any loss of visibility . assuming the low - energy limit , where the relevant energies : @xmath16 , the voltage bias @xmath4 , and the detuning @xmath0 of the quantum dot level from the fermi energy are much smaller than the inverse time of flight through the interferometer , the internal dephasing in the channels can be neglected , and therefore the loss of coherence is solely due to the interaction with the localized state . when the latter is occupied , the interference pattern acquires an additional shift compared to the empty state . this shift corresponds to the phase of scattering @xmath17 on the localized charge . due to the transitions , this pattern is averaged with the occupation probabilities @xmath18 , @xmath19 of the quantum dot , which gives the visibility @xmath20 and the phase shift @xmath9 as @xmath21 \label{visibility def } , } \ ] ] where the constant prefactor @xmath22 is arbitrary , and without loss of generality we will further refer to the normalized value of the visibility @xmath20 in the sense of assuming @xmath23 . the experiment by weisz _ at al . _ @xcite has been realized in thermal equilibrium with @xmath16 being the largest energy scale . in that case the transition rates at the impurity satisfy the detailed balance equation , and therefore the dot occupation probability @xmath24 is boltzmannian . this yields the result for the visibility @xmath25 @xcite . in the limit of strong coulomb interaction and symmetric coupling @xmath26 ( see fig . [ fig : setup ] ) , complete loss of visibility is observed , respectively , accompanied by the @xmath27-valued jump of the phase shift of the ab oscillations when the energy level of the dot crosses the fermi level . throughout the rest of this paper we assume the low - temperature limit @xmath28 , where the charge fluctuations at the impurity are activated by the partitioning noise of the @xmath29 . the low - energy physics of a qh system shown in fig . [ fig : setup ] can be conveniently described by the bosonized hamiltonian ( see , _ e.g. _ , refs . @xcite ) @xmath30 where the coulomb interaction potential @xmath31 of the charge densities @xmath32 at different points of channels @xmath33 and @xmath34 governs the propagation of the excitations along the edge channels ; the bosonic fields @xmath35 satisfy the commutation relations @xmath36 = 2i\pi \delta_{a b}\delta(x - y)$ ] , and indexes @xmath37 enumerating the fields take values @xmath38 on the corresponding channel to the left of , to the right of , up from , or down from the quantum dot . the bare level energy of the quantum dot @xmath39 is determined by the applied gate voltage , which is the key controllable parameter of the system . the quantum dot charge @xmath40 interacts with the charge densities on the channels via the coulomb potentials @xmath41 . the amplitudes of tunneling from channel @xmath42 are denoted by @xmath43 , and @xmath44 are the annihilation operators of an electron at @xmath45 , chosen at the location of the quantum dot . when the quantum level broadening is smaller than the classical broadening @xmath46 , tunneling between the channels and the dot can be taken into account perturbatively . the remaining part of the hamiltonian can be diagonalized by eliminating the coulomb interaction term with the help of a standard unitary transformation @xmath47 , where @xmath48 the functions @xmath49 are chosen with the aim to cancel the interaction part @xmath50 of the hamiltonian by the term produced after the transformation of the first line in eq . ( [ hamiltonian ] ) . this requirement is expressed by the integral equation @xmath51 on the other hand , the coulomb potential along channel @xmath33 , created by the impurity charge and the arbitrary charge density distribution @xmath52 on channel @xmath34 , is @xmath53 from which it follows that the solution @xmath54 of eq . ( [ integral equation ] ) is nothing but the charge density @xmath55 , accumulated on the grounded channels @xmath56 , screening the charge present on the quantum dot , i.e. , when @xmath57 . these densities are , naturally , localized in the interaction region around the quantum dot at @xmath45 . the total charges @xmath58 can be expressed in terms of the zero - frequency fourier components of the potentials @xmath41 . in absence of other metallic objects in proximity of the dot , the electroneutrality principle implies that @xmath59 . this relation repeats the statement of the friedel sum rule @xcite via the direct connection between the additional phase @xmath60 acquired by an electron passing by the dot and the charges @xmath61 . as a result of the transformation , the tunneling part of the hamiltonian is rendered in the form @xmath62 where the fields @xmath63 have been approximated by their value @xmath64 at @xmath45 since in the low - energy limit the fields change on distances longer than the size of the interferometer and thus are almost constant in the region of interaction . the transformation also shifts the parameter @xmath39 , which determines the time evolution of the annihilation operator @xmath65 by the static self - interaction energy of the accumulated charge density @xmath66 . the physical quantities , such as the visibility , will be investigated as functions of this parameter . the rates of the tunneling transitions ( fig . [ fig : rates ] ) between the quantum dot and the side channels are found from the _ golden rule _ expression @xmath67 where @xmath68 and @xmath69 denote the states of the whole system unperturbed by the tunneling , when the quantum dot is empty and occupied , respectively . following the nonequilibrium bosonization approach @xcite , the fields @xmath70 are expressed in terms of the total charges @xmath71 that are transmitted across a certain cross section , such as right after the partitioning qpc for @xmath72 on the biased channel , or the corresponding cross sections of the other channels that are in the ground state . tunneling in the beam splitter qpcs is therefore taken into account nonperturbatively through the boundary conditions at @xmath73 ( see also ref . @xcite ) , and the correlation functions in eq . ( [ golden rule rates ] ) can be expressed in terms of the correlation functions of these charges @xmath74 and thus via the fcs generating function @xcite @xmath75 which is defined for @xmath76 and is continued for negative times as @xmath77 . the total rates are therefore @xmath78 , where @xmath79 and @xmath80 here @xmath81 for @xmath82 are the ground - state correlation functions on the unbiased channels . the dimensional prefactor is non - universal and will be omitted from here on . for the nonequilibrium excitations from the partitioning qpc , the generating function is not trivial but can be found analytically in the long - time markovian limit as a classical probability game result known as the levitov - lee - lesovik formula @xcite : @xmath83 as a long - time asymptotic , it is applicable when the main contribution to the integrals in eqs . ( [ rates through fcs ] ) comes from the long times @xmath84 , which requires small transparency @xmath85 or small reflection @xmath86 , and small transmitted energies @xmath87 . here @xmath88 is the charge degeneracy point , i.e. , the resonance energy , and will be discussed later . one therefore obtains the result @xmath89 , } \ ] ] where the opposite rates @xmath90 and @xmath91 are distinguished by the factors @xmath92 and @xmath93 , respectively . the power - law exponent in the denominator is the conventional fes absorption - rate exponent @xmath94 = 2\eta_b - \sum_a \eta_a^2 , \label{exponent } } \ ] ] expressed in terms of the accumulated charges , related to the scattering phases @xmath95 on the impurity . the singularity is smeared by the real part of @xmath96 \label{gamma } , } \ ] ] while the imaginary part of @xmath97 defines the shift of the level energy @xmath0 depending on the transparency @xmath6 ( see fig . [ fig : energy ] ) and determines the positions of the peaks of @xmath98 , which are also discussed later . in the free - fermion case @xmath99 without the coulomb interaction , the rates are reduced to the corresponding step functions . interaction with the same channel @xmath33 , to which the tunneling occurs , provides the positive term @xmath100 to the exponent @xmath101 , the so - called _ mahan contribution _ @xcite , which favors low - energy transitions , leading to a more singular character of the transition rate profiles as in fig . [ fig : rates ] for the positive exponent @xmath102 . interaction with other channels , @xmath103 . reduces the exponent @xmath101 by @xmath104 , representing the _ anderson contribution _ @xcite , which favors higher - energy transitions ; see fig . [ fig : rates ] for the negative exponent @xmath105 , which is approximately the value in the experiment @xcite . however , since @xmath101 depends on the distribution of the couplings @xmath41 between the channels surrounding the quantum dot via the screening charges @xmath61 , by switching from weak tunneling to weak backscattering of the inner channels , one can shift the balance and achieve positive values @xmath106 , changing qualitatively the energy dependence of the transition rates . without loss of generality we will omit index @xmath34 in @xmath107 and @xmath108 , as in the case where there is tunneling to only one side channel . to complement the limited range of applicability of the markovian approximation , we use the numerical data obtained in ref . it is valid for intermediate transparencies @xmath109 and shorter times @xmath110 . the approach is based on the calculation of the fcs generator of the transmitted charges at the left qpc @xcite , expressed in terms of a free - fermion determinant ( see ref . @xcite ) : @xmath111f(\varepsilon)\},\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath112 is the electron distribution function , @xmath113 is the projector on the time interval @xmath114 $ ] , and @xmath115 is the scattering matrix of the qpc . such a determinant can then be evaluated numerically @xcite . although the data are currently available for one special value of a phase shift of @xmath116 , that happens to be the value relevant for the existing experiment @xcite . since the markovian approximation is valid for asymptotically small transparency or reflection , a direct comparison with the numerical calculations at finite transparency can not be expected . nevertheless , we still see a surprisingly adequate quantitative agreement for the transition rate profiles at transparencies @xmath117 and @xmath118 ( see fig . [ fig : rates ] ) . while the shape of the curves remains very similar , note the shift of the resonance position of the solid lines compared to the dashed lines , which is related to the imaginary part of eq . ( [ gamma ] ) . in the markovian limit all the rates have identical energy profiles @xmath119 and @xmath120 ( see dashed lines in fig . [ fig : rates ] ) , but in the numerics ( solid lines ) the opposite direction rates for the same transparency @xmath121 are clearly distinct , emphasizing the specific correspondence @xmath122 which reflects the particle - hole symmetry , while the simple charge symmetry is broken @xmath123 . ( blue ) and @xmath118 ( red ) for @xmath124 and screening @xmath125 as in the experiment @xcite , corresponding to the phase shift of @xmath27 on the upper arm , hence the complete loss of visibility is achieved . each analytic curve has a mirror symmetry and is also identical to its equivalent for @xmath126 due to the symmetry incidental of the markovian approximation . the numerical results manifest a well - pronounced asymmetry of the dip due to the non - gaussian effects at strong coupling . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] the structure of the transition rates tails has an origin similar to that of the dynamic coulomb blockade effect . in the present case it is sensitive to the sign of the charge of the edge excitations . using the example of the @xmath127 rate at large partitioning transparency @xmath86 ( solid red line in fig . [ fig : rates ] ) , the holelike excitations on the arm of the interferometer attract the electron on the dot , assisting the energetically unfavorable tunneling transition from the side channel onto the dot and enhancing the tail at @xmath128 , even compared to that of the markovian limit result ( dashed line ) . however , away from the resonance @xmath129 , the effects become perturbative in transparency @xmath6 , and the tunneling is then enabled by single - particle excitations with a maximum energy of @xmath4 ; thus the tail is eventually suppressed at @xmath130 . conversely , transitions onto the dot at low transparency @xmath85 are disadvantaged by the electronlike excitations , leading to the rapid decay of the @xmath127 rate at @xmath131 . the @xmath132 rates behave accordingly , in agreement with the symmetry ( [ symmetry ] ) . ( blue ) and @xmath118 ( red ) for the markovian limit ( dashed lines ) and the numerics ( solid lines ) for ( top ) @xmath133 and ( bottom ) @xmath134 . notice how the numeric curves hit the horizontal axis at @xmath135 and @xmath136 . for @xmath124 the markovian limit breaks down considerably sooner , which explains the noticeable discrepancy between the numerics and analytic plots . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] the visibility is expressed ( [ visibility def ] ) in terms of the stationary occupation probability @xmath137 , which is a ratio of the transition rates . for @xmath138 it demonstrates complete loss of coherence in the resonances ( see fig . [ fig : visibility ] ) and is equivalent to the _ detector function _ discussed in ref . the previous effect of the transition rates tails suppression is reincarnated in the rapid reconstruction of the visibility in the numerical results , shown in fig . [ fig : visibility ] . we stress that unlike in ref . @xcite in the single - photon , weak coupling regime , in our case the physical nature of this threshold effect is based on strong coulomb coupling and is related to the finite energy @xmath4 carried by the partitioning excitations in the interferometer . the charge sign dependence of the coupling therefore leads to the pronounced asymmetry of the visibility dip seen in the numerical results due to the odd cumulants of the nonequilibrium noise . in the long - time limit , however , the transition rates are insensitive to the charge sign and the branches of the visibility dip are symmetric ( see dashed lines in fig . [ fig : visibility ] ) . for @xmath125 , the resulting visibility profile ( [ visibility def ] ) becomes @xmath139}{\textrm{im}\left[\left(1+e^{i \pi ( 1-\alpha)}\right ) ( { \varepsilon}_0 + i \gamma)^{-\alpha}\right ] } \label{visibility mark } . } \ ] ] the branches of the visibility dip exhibit a crossover between the two asymptotes : @xmath140 with the effective temperature @xmath141 at @xmath142 , and @xmath143 with @xmath144 $ ] at @xmath145 . both temperatures @xmath146 and @xmath147 become equal to the `` free - fermion '' noise temperature @xmath148 of the weak coupling limit @xmath149 when the transition rates become regular lorentzians @xcite . note that even at fixed upper channel screening @xmath150 and a phase shift of @xmath27 , the exponent @xmath108 can still vary due to the remaining couplings . since the power - law factor @xmath151 enters homogeneously to the transition rates ( [ rates analytic ] ) , it is canceled in the tails of the visibility profile ( [ visibility mark ] ) . moreover , one can demonstrate that for the markovian limit there is a symmetry @xmath152 , even though the transition rate profiles for @xmath126 and for @xmath124 are unmistakably distinct , as can be seen in fig . [ fig : rates ] . this observation hints that the visibility itself is not the most fully characteristic quantity for an experimental consideration . we therefore suggest that apart from the visibility , other measurements can be very interesting , such as the linear - response tunneling current ( [ linear current ] ) through the quantum dot . for this , a small bias @xmath153 is applied to one of the tunneling contacts , and the linear response tunneling current @xmath154 through the quantum dot is measured @xmath155 assuming symmetric tunneling couplings @xmath156 and charge screening @xmath157 , the resulting differential conductance @xmath158 then retains the signature of the fes power law in the lorentzian - like peak @xmath159\right\ } } , } \ ] ] with the power - law tails @xmath160 and the resonance width @xmath161 due to the nonequilibrium noise ( see fig . [ fig : tunneling ] ) . however , due to the suppression of the tails at @xmath162 indicated by the numerical results , the power law spans only the limited segment of @xmath163 , which can prove to be problematic for getting a good fit at moderately small transparencies @xmath6 . of the visibility dip center as a function of the qpc transparency . solid lines are the numerical results for @xmath126 ( blue ) and @xmath124 ( red ) . the dashed line is for the markovian limit , although it is applicable only asymptotically for @xmath164 and @xmath165 . the dotted line presents the gaussian case with suppression of the higher cumulants , reflecting simply the average charge density on the channel as the partitioning qpc transparency changes . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] alternatively , spectroscopy of the quantum dot can be performed by filling or draining the dot with a finite bias in one lead at highly asymmetric tunneling couplings ( see , for example , the recent experiment in @xcite ) and measuring directly the transition rates in one of the contacts . then the exponent can be accessed from the nonvanishing tails , and the characteristic shape of the decaying tails should also be observable . a particularly notable feature , related to the phase transition studied in ref . @xcite , is the dependence of the position @xmath88 of the resonance , where the visibility is maximally reduced , on the transparency @xmath6 of the partitioning qpc @xmath6 . at full transparency , the arm of the interferometer acts as an additional gate with the voltage @xmath4 , which electrostatically raises the energy level of the quantum dot by @xmath166 . the resonance therefore occurs at a lower value of the original parameter @xmath167 . this corresponds to the shift obtained in the markovian approximation as the imaginary part @xmath168 of eq . ( [ gamma ] ) . for @xmath125 the argument of the logarithm is real , and @xmath168 jumps from zero for @xmath169 to @xmath170 for @xmath171 @xcite . if the higher cumulants in the correlation function ( [ fcs ] ) are suppressed for some reason , one can also consider the gaussian approximation that predicts a linear drift of the level energy on the qpc transparency ( dotted line in fig . [ fig : energy ] ) . the numerical results show a behavior that is somewhat intermediate between the markovian and the gaussian limits , suggesting that for @xmath126 the higher cumulants have more influence than they do for @xmath124 . it is therefore particularly interesting that the actual profiles are measured in an experiment . a quantum hall edge channel , embedded in an electronic interferometer , with a controllable coulomb interaction with an artificial impurity , is a very promising system for investigating the interaction and noise effects on the fermi - edge singularity manifestations in a one - dimensional electronic system . in the low - energy limit , in which there is no intrinsic loss of coherence on the edge channels , the visibility of the interference pattern is only suppressed due to the averaging of the phase of scattering on the fluctuating impurity charge ( [ visibility def ] ) . experimental efforts to study such a system have been undertaken recently @xcite , although they concentrated on the thermal equilibrium case , in which the observed visibility is trivial due to the thermal occupation of the impurity . we extend the discussion to the case where the transitions at the impurity are induced by the nonequilibrium partitioning noise created in the interferometer and the backaction of the fermi sea perturbations due to tunneling . both factors are strong and are taken into account nonperturbatively . the nonequilibrium bosonization technique @xcite is the framework of choice , which allows us to express all the electron correlation functions in terms of the full counting statistics ( [ fcs ] ) of the charge transmitted through the beam splitter . the analytical expression for the fcs ( [ levitov formula ] ) is used in the markovian limit for weak tunneling or backscattering in the partitioning qpc , and for intermediate transparencies the fcs is computed numerically . we have provided a comprehensive description of the system in the given regime . even in the long - time , markovian limit , the visibility profile ( fig . [ fig : visibility ] ) is found to nontrivially depend on both the fes exponent ( [ exponent ] ) and the parameters of the nonequilibrium noise , which are determined by the partitioning qpc transparency . beyond the long - time limit , as revealed by the numerical calculations , we discover a prominent manifestation of the non - gaussian component of noise . in fact , at strong coulomb coupling this becomes a dominant effect and leads to a particular kind of particle - hole symmetry , which also causes a pronounced asymmetry between the tunneling rates at small transmission versus small reflection of the qpc . consequently , the non - gaussian effects appear in the asymmetry of the visibility dip branches and the characteristic dependence of the dip position on the qpc transparency ( fig . [ fig : energy ] ) . considering all the predicted features , we can strongly recommend further experimental investigations with this type of setup operating out of equilibrium . nozierres , c. t. de dominicis , phys . rev . * 178 * , 1097 ( 1969 ) ; k. a. matveev , a. i. larkin , phys . b * 46 * , 15337 ( 1992 ) ; a. k. geim et al . , * 72 * , 2061 ( 1994 ) ; d. h. cobden and b. a. muzykantskii , _ ibid . _ * 75 * , 4274 ( 1995 ) . a different approach was formulated earlier in ref . @xcite in the context of the dynamical scattering theory for bosons , in which boundary fields are replaced by time - dependent electrochemical potentials with the purpose of finding the linear - response conductance matrix .

we study the effects of strong coupling of a localized state charge to one - dimensional electronic channels out of equilibrium . while the state of this charge and the coupling strengths determine the scattering phase shifts in the channels , the nonequilibrium partitioning noise induces the tunneling transitions to the localized state . the strong coupling leads to a nonperturbative backaction effect which is manifested in the orthogonality catastrophe and the fermi - edge singularity in the transition rates . we predict an unusually pronounced manifestation of the non - gaussian component of noise that breaks the charge symmetry , resulting in a nontrivial shape , and a shift of the position of the tunneling resonance .

nucl-th0502003

the properties of hadrons and their masses at finite density and temperature are extremely important to study the phase transition from the hadronic phase to the quark gluon plasma . generally speaking , the nonperturbative calculations at finite temperature and/or density support the idea that hadronic masses change as a function of temperature and density . the nucleon mass is found to depend substantially on temperature variations of the quark condensate and interaction process . as the condensate disappears smoothly with chiral - symmetry restoration so does the nucleon mass@xcite . recently , baryons have been studied in the context of bethe - salpeter equation ( bse ) . the baryon is considered as a bound state of the confined constituent diquark and quark interacting via an exchange quark . despite the simplicity of the model , it has been used to study the intermediate energy physics successfully @xcite . furthermore , it has been some attempts to extend bse to study mesons at finite temperature@xcite . however , the dressed quark propagator and the variation of the constituent quark mass with temperature are essential to study the bound states in a hot bath . the schwinger - dyson equation ( dse ) is used to study the quark propagator at finite temperature@xcite . the dse with qcd potential can be solved numerically at finite temperature @xcite . furthermore , the constituent quark mass and its variation with temperature is studied using the lattice - qcd - based schwinger - dyson equation . spontaneously broken chiral symmetry is found to be restored at the critical temperature@xcite . the linear confinement dissociates smoothly with temperature@xcite . from dse , it is expected that the dressed quark mass to decrease with temperature in the same order of the linear confinement dissociation . the condensate is found also to disappear smoothly at the same order . in sec . ii , we shall derive the bse for a quark - diquark bound state at finite temperature . the modification of the interaction with temperature is approximated using a mixed representation of the imaginary time formalism and then we adopt the adiabatic ( instantaneous ) approximation . in this approximation , we set the time component to zero after evaluating the matsubara sums not before . the constituent scalar - diquark and quark substructures are effectively taken into account and their masses are taken momentum and temperature dependent based on the lattice - qcd . in sec . iii , we briefly review the mit bag model for nucleon and then we extend it to finite temperature case by taking on the considerations the dissociation of the nucleon bag pressure with temperature . finally in sec . v , we present our results and conclusions . the baryon is considered as a bound state of confined constituent diquark and quark interacting via quark exchange . the bse for the diquark and quark bound states is given by @xmath4\chi_p(p'),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath5 we have taken @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the quark - diquark vertex coupling @xmath8 and @xmath9 is the exchange quark propagator and @xmath10 . the scalar diquark propagator reads @xmath11 } \nonumber \\ & = & \left(\frac{1}{z_d}\right ) \frac{i}{2\epsilon_1}\left [ \frac{1}{p_0+m_1-\epsilon_1+i\delta } - \frac{1}{p_0+m_1+\epsilon_1-i\delta } \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the fermion quark propagator reads @xmath12\beta,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath13 and @xmath14 refers to the scalar diquark while @xmath15 refers to the quark and @xmath16 and @xmath17 . we have chosen the proper choice @xmath18 . in the center of mass frame we have @xmath19 . the fermion positive and negative energy projections read @xmath20 where @xmath21 . it is possible to take @xmath22 and @xmath23 with a good approximation . in principle , these functions can be considered in the calculations by adopting smearing functions in the propagators@xcite . in the present calculations , we shall assume these functions are absorbed by the quark - diquark vertex coupling @xmath24 . the constituent diquark and quark masses are given by @xmath25 and @xmath26 for the diquark and quark , respectively . in the adiabatic approximation , the temperature response is separated from the momentum dependent and the constituent diquark and quark masses reduce to @xmath27 and @xmath28 . the dynamical chiral - symmetry breaking ( dcsb ) is one of the most nonperturbative qcd feature . based on the lattice qcd at the quenched level and landau gauge and the lattice data in the chiral limit , the quark mass function at zero temperature is reproduced by @xmath29 } , \label{qconstit}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath30 870 mev , @xmath31 , the current mass @xmath32 mev and @xmath33 is the momentum in euclidean space . using the lattice - qcd - based gap equation ( dse ) at finite temperature , it is found that @xmath34 has a chiral symmetry restoration phase transition at the critical temperature @xmath35 . the quark and diquark acquire their constituent masses from the linear confinement . these masses can be computed using dse to calculate the self - energy correction . however the linear confinement constant @xmath36 in the configuration space is found to dissociate thermally spontaneously to @xmath37 . the linear confining is a nonperturbative effect and it is believed to generate the major contribution to the self - energy correction for the current quark mass to acquire its constituent value . it is reasonable to take the self - energy correction and mass variation with respect to the temperature at the same order of the spontaneous linear confinement dissociation @xmath38 where @xmath39 for @xmath40 and @xmath41 for @xmath42@xcite . since the constituent diquark is assumed as a weekly quark - quark bound state , it is reasonable to assume @xmath43 . furthermore , we assume the diquark substructure takes the same quark formula substructure given in eq.([qconstit ] ) . in the adiabatic approximation , euclidean momentum @xmath33 in the quark substructure is reduced to three dimensional momentum where @xmath44 . however , in the imaginary time formalism , we can write @xmath45 where @xmath46 and we can take @xmath47 to the first order approximation . to be consistent with the adiabatic approximation considered in our calculations , we have adopted @xmath44 in our calculations . furthermore , we have shown that the first order approximation effect is small . in an adiabatic approximation , the bound state equation at finite temperature is derived as follows @xmath48 \int \frac{d^3 p'}{(2\pi)^3 } \left[-k(q_0,{\bf q};t)|_{q_0=0}\int \frac{d p'_0}{(2\pi)}\chi_p(p')\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] at zero temperature , the adiabatic approximation is reduced to the instantaneous approximation . however , as we shall show below , a special attention must be paid for the interaction potential in the adiabatic approximation . the kernel interaction is taken as an exchange quark between the diquark and quark , @xmath49 where @xmath10 . the bse propagator is reduced to @xmath50 where @xmath51\left[1+n_b\left(\epsilon_{-1}\right ) -n_f\left(\epsilon_{-2}\right)\right ] \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{1}{2\epsilon_1}\left [ \frac{1}{m+(\epsilon_1-\epsilon_2 ) } \right ] \left[n_b\left(\epsilon_{+1}\right ) + n_f\left(\epsilon_{-2}\right)\right ] \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath52 \left[1+n_b\left(\epsilon_{+1}\right ) -n_f\left(\epsilon_{+2}\right)\right ] \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{1}{2\epsilon_1}\left [ \frac{1}{m-(\epsilon_1-\epsilon_2)}\right ] \left[n_b\left(\epsilon_{-1}\right ) + n_f\left(\epsilon_{+2}\right)\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath53 . the thermal distribution functions for quark and scalar diquark @xmath54 and @xmath55 are the fermi - einstein and bose - einstein distribution functions , respectively , and @xmath56 . at zero temperature , the bse propagator given by eq.([bs_propg1 ] ) is reduced to @xmath57.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is a wonderful to write the thermal distribution function of bse propagator in a proper way to discuss thermal reaction processes . the thermal distribution function for the positive energy solution is written as follows @xmath58= \left[1+n_b(\epsilon_{-1})\right]\left[1-n_f(\epsilon_{-2})\right ] + n_b(\epsilon_{-1})n_f(\epsilon_{-2}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] it corresponds to the difference between the virtual decay and creation rates via the virtual reaction processes @xmath59 and @xmath60 , respectively . it is interested to note that the constituent diquark and quark chemical potentials @xmath61 and @xmath62 , respectively , are always less than their relativistic energies and @xmath63 and @xmath64 to preserve the confinement condition . this guarantees the creation rate is always larger than the decay rate . furthermore , the additional ` landau damping ' term @xmath65 = n_b(\epsilon_{+1})\left[1-n_f(\epsilon_{-2})\right ] + \left[1+n_b(\epsilon_{+1})\right]n_f(\epsilon_{-2}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] corresponds the virtual decay and creation processes via the reaction scattering @xmath66 and @xmath67 , respectively . this corresponds particles disappear or are created through the scattering in the bath , and not via the process which are available at zero temperature . the thermal distribution function for the negative energy solution corresponds to @xmath68 and @xmath69 for the decay and creation processes , respectively . on the other hand , the ` landau damping ' term in the negative energy solution reduces to the creation and decay processes @xmath70 and @xmath71 , respectively . the exchange quark propagator is decomposed as follows @xmath72.\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence the kernel interaction reads @xmath73.\end{aligned}\ ] ] when we substitute @xmath74 , we get @xmath75.\end{aligned}\ ] ] however , this choice is not adequate in the adiabatic approximation . in the adiabatic assumption , we shall consider the instantaneous approximation after evaluating the matsubara frequencies sum in the mixed representation for the imaginary time formalism . the fourier transformation of the kernel interaction to the mixed representation reduces to @xmath76 \beta\lambda_{+}(-{\bf q } ) + e^{\epsilon_q\tau } \left[n_f\left(\epsilon_q\right)\right ] \beta\lambda_{-}(-{\bf q } ) \right ] . \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] the inverse transformation of the mixed representation with an adiabatic approximation reads @xmath77 \beta\left[\lambda_{+}(-{\bf q})+\lambda_{-}(-{\bf q})\right ] , \nonumber\\ & = & -g^2_{dq}\frac{1}{\epsilon_q}\left[1 - 2n_f\left(\epsilon_q\right)\right]\beta,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath78 . it is worth to note here that in the adiabatic approximation we have substituted @xmath74 in the mixed representation after evaluating the matsubara frequencies sum . we have introduced in bse the following interaction potential @xmath79 where @xmath80 $ ] . the bse reduces to @xmath81 the bse wavefunction decomposes as dirac wavefunction for positive parity @xmath82 the bse wavefunction reads @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the spinor and the quantum numbers are suppressed . the decompositions of the bse wave function with respect to the positive and negative energy components read @xmath85\eta({\bf p'})- i\hat{\bf p}\times\hat{\bf p'}\cdot\vec{\sigma}]\zeta({\bf p ' } ) , \\ \sigma\cdot\hat{\bf p}\left[-|{\bf p}|\eta({\bf p'})+ [ \epsilon_2-m_2][\hat{\bf p}\cdot\hat{\bf p'}+ i\hat{\bf p}\times\hat{\bf p'}\cdot\vec{\sigma}]\zeta({\bf p'})\right ] \end{array}\right)\chi,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath86\eta({\bf p ' } ) + |{\bf p}|[\hat{\bf p}\cdot\hat{\bf p'}+ i\hat{\bf p}\times\hat{\bf p'}\cdot\vec{\sigma}]\zeta({\bf p ' } ) \\ p}\left [ |{\bf p}|\eta({\bf p'})+ [ \epsilon_2+m_2][\hat{\bf p}\cdot\hat{\bf p'}+ i\hat{\bf p}\times\hat{\bf p'}\cdot\vec{\sigma}]\zeta({\bf p'})\right ] \end{array}\right)\chi.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we have taken @xmath87 where @xmath88 and @xmath89 , @xmath90@xcite , @xmath91 mev and @xmath92 mev for the diquark and quark , respectively . the nucleon is assumed as mit bag of the confined quarks@xcite . the quark field @xmath93 inside the nucleon bag of radius @xmath94 satisfies the dirac equation @xmath95\psi_{q}(\vec{r},t)=0 , \label{dirac } % ( 2.1)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath96 is the current mass of a quark of flavor @xmath97 . the current quark masses are taken @xmath98 for the up and down flavor quarks . the single - particle quark energy is given by @xmath99 where @xmath100 for a given value of the bag radius @xmath94 , the quark momentum @xmath101 is determined by the confinement boundary condition at the bag surface which , for quarks of flavor @xmath97 in a spherical bag , reduces to @xmath102 , where @xmath103 and @xmath104 are spherical bessel functions of order zero and one , respectively . the bag energy is given by @xmath105 where @xmath106 is the total constituent quarks kinetic energy inside the bag and @xmath107 term is the zero - point energy for quarks and @xmath108 is the bag parameter . the spurious center - of - mass energy is subtracted to obtain nucleon mass , @xmath109 where @xmath110 the bag radius @xmath94 is obtained through the minimization of the baryon mass with respect to its bag radius @xmath111 the bag parameter @xmath108 is taken as @xmath112 corresponding to its value for a free nucleon . the values @xmath113 mev and @xmath114 are chosen to reproduce the free nucleon mass @xmath115 at its experimental value 939 mev and bag radius @xmath116 fm . the current quark mass @xmath117 is taken equal to zero . in order to consider the thermal effects for the nucleon mass @xmath118 , we assume that the bag parameter dissolves with temperature as follows @xmath119 where @xmath120 with a choice @xmath121 , the nucleon mass at finite temperature reduces to @xmath122 this choice is relevant to the thermal dissociation of the linear confinement @xmath123 @xcite and its possible connection to the bag pressure dissociation @xmath124 . this connection leads to the choice @xmath121 . we have studied the nucleon as a bound state of a scalar - diquark and a quark by diagonalizing the bse at finite temperature . the interaction is taken as a quark exchange in the adiabatic approximation . the quark and scalar - diquark substructures and their modifications with momentum and temperature are introduced self - consistently in the bse . the interaction modification with temperature is approximated using a mixed representation of the imaginary time formalism in the propagator and then the adiabatic ( instantaneous ) approximation is adopted by substituting the time component to zero @xmath74 after evaluating the matsubara frequency sums not before . we have included explicitly in our calculations the smooth decreasing of the constituent quark and diquark masses with temperature . the thermal variations of the constituent particle masses are based on the lattice - qcd calculation . in fig.(i ) , we display the dependence of constituent quark and scalar - diquark masses on their substructure momenta at zero temperature . the quark and diquark acquire their constituent masses 350 and 650 mev , respectively , at zero momentum . they decrease with momentum to reach their current masses at large momentum . the diquark acts as a weakly bound state of quark - quark and its mass varies with temperature in the same order of variation of its constituent quarks . in fig . ( ii ) , we display the quark and diquark masses versus temperature at zero momentum . it is shown that the constituent masses decrease with temperature as @xmath125 . the thick lines correspond @xmath126 , while the thin lines correspond @xmath127 . it is shown that the first order matsubara frequency correction has a very small correction to the adiabatic approximation . we have calculated the nucleon mass by diagonalizing bse with several temperatures . the nucleon mass versus temperature is displayed in fig.(iii ) . we have found that @xmath128 is always less than @xmath129 until the temperature reaches just below the critical one . this means that the nucleon bound state persists to exist until the temperature reaches a critical one . therefore , the quarks continue to confine in the hadronic phase and they shall not deconfine spontaneously until the temperature reaches the critical one . furthermore , we have found just below the critical temperature , the nucleon bound state ceases to exist . it deconfines to its constituents spontaneously at the critical temperature . in our calculations , the critical temperature is taken @xmath130 mev . this probably a signature for the first order phase transition . furthermore , the nucleon mass decreases smoothly with temperature in the same manner the constituent quark mass decreases with temperature and at the same order of the linear confinement dissociation in the lattice - qcd calculation . these results are compared with those for mit bag model . we assume that mit bag pressure is temperature dependent and it dissociates as @xmath124 and @xmath121 . this dissociation is at the same order of the linear confinement dissociation in the potential models and lattice - qcd calculations@xcite . we have found with this choice , the nucleon mass decreases smoothly with temperature as @xmath131 . furthermore , the choice @xmath132 does nt match the mass spectrum for bse . furthermore , the solutions of bse and mit bag are in a good agreement with each other but the mit bag model lacks the first order phase transition that found for bse in the critical temperature . however , the mit bags might have the first order phase transition when they are embedded in a nuclear matter because of their interaction with the medium and the the production of particles and antiparticles . finally , in our conclusions , we argue the nucleon mass in a hot bath should be a temperature dependent and it decreases smoothly as @xmath133 where @xmath1 . nucleon mass calculated using bse and the scalar - diquark constituent mass at @xmath134 versus temperature . it is shown that the bound state persists to exist until the temperature reaches just below the critical one and then the bound state ceases to exist at the critical one . ] 99 c. adami , t. hatsuda and i. zahed , phys . d * 43 * , 921 ( 1991 ) . c. adami and i. zahed , phys . d * 45 * , 4312 ( 1992 ) . m. kacir and i. zahed , phys . d * 54 * , 5536 ( 1996 ) g. ropke , d. blaschke and h. schulz , phys . b * 174 * ( 1986 ) 5 . v. keiner , z. phys . a * 354 * , 87 ( 1996 ) v. keiner , phys . c * 54 * , 3232 ( 1996 ) g. hellstern , r. alkofer , m. oettel and h. reinhardt , nucl . a * 627 * , 679 ( 1997 ) m. oettel , r. alkofer and l. von smekal , eur . j. a * 8 * , 553 ( 2000 ) r. alkofer , a. hoell , m. kloker , a. krassnigg and c. d. roberts , [ arxiv : nucl - th/0412046 ] . d. blaschke , y. l. kalinovsky and p. c. tandy , [ arxiv : hep - ph/9811476 ] . d. blaschke , g. burau , y. l. kalinovsky , p. maris and p. c. tandy , int . j. mod . a * 16 * , 2267 ( 2001 ) c. d. roberts and s. m. schmidt , prog . * 45 * , s1 ( 2000 ) t. ikeda , prog . phys . * 107 * , 403 ( 2002 ) h. iida , m. oka and h. suganuma , nucl . * 129 * ( 2004 ) 602 h. iida , m. oka and h. suganuma , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0410222 ] . a. chodos , r. l. jaffe , k. johnson , c. b. thorn and v. f. weisskopf , phys . d * 9 * , 3471 ( 1974 ) . p. a. m. guichon , phys . b * 200 * , 235 ( 1988 ) . i. zakout and h. r. jaqaman , phys . c * 59 * , 962 ( 1999 ) r. d. pisarski and o. alvarez , phys . d * 26 * , 3735 ( 1982 ) .

we study the nucleon at finite temperature using bethe - salpeter equation ( bse ) where it is considered as a bound state of a scalar - diquark and a quark . the interaction between the diquark and the quark is taken as an exchange quark . the constituent quark and diquark substructures are considered momentum and temperature dependent based on the lattice qcd and dynamical chiral symmetry breaking ( dcsb ) . the kernel interaction modification with temperature is approximated using the mixed representation in the imaginary time formalism and then we adopt an adiabatic ( instantaneous ) approximation after evaluating the matsubara frequencies sum . the results of bse are compared with those for mit bag model . we argue the bag pressure is a temperature dependent and it decreases smoothly with temperature to be consistent with the results for bse . furthermore , the nucleon bound state obtained by bse ceases to exist just below the critical temperature and this indicates that the nucleon deconfines to its constituent quarks at the critical temperature . the nucleon mass decreases with temperature as @xmath0 where @xmath1 and @xmath2 and this suggests @xmath3 for mit bag .

0905.3547

the study of the time - evolution of a non - relativistic charged particle in homogeneous magnetic and electric fields has a long history in physics . in a quantum context , the treatment of the problem goes back to darwin @xcite , who considered the evolution of a gaussian wave - packet in a magnetic field , and fock @xcite who obtained the eigenenergies and eigenstates of a charged particle in an isotropic harmonic potential , subjected to a magnetic field normal to the plane of motion . if one takes a particle of charge @xmath0 and mass @xmath1 , moving in the @xmath2 plane in an harmonic potencial of frequency @xmath3 and subjected to a magnetic field @xmath4 , the hamiltonian describing the system is given , in the symmetric gauge where @xmath5 , by @xmath6+\frac{1}{2}\,m\,\omega_0 ^ 2\,(\hat{x}^2 + \hat{y}^2)\ , , \label{eq1}\ ] ] where the operators @xmath7 obey the canonical commutation relations . this simple problem has applications in the context of the quantum hall effect @xcite , where disorder and the coulomb interaction also play a crucial role . another field for which the study of this hamiltonian has proved fruitful is that of quantum dots , where the simple hamiltonian given by ( [ eq1 ] ) seems to give a good account of the @xmath8 curves obtained when a gate voltage is applied to the quantum dot @xcite , with corrections due to the assymetry of the confining potential and to the coulomb interactions also playing a role . for some types of quantum dots , such as inas / gaas quantum dots , the agreement between the theoretical and experimental results seems to hold for magnetic fields up to 15 t @xcite . the study of the evolution of gaussian wave packets also goes back to the first days of quantum mechanics . this study was first undertaken by schrdinger @xcite , kennard @xcite and also by darwin @xcite in the context of the harmonic oscillator , of a free particle and of a particle in constant electric and magnetic fields . this problem continues to attract attention to the present day in many contexts , see the review by dodonov @xcite . schrdinger considered the time - evolution of a minimal uncertainty state , i.e. a coherent state of the harmonic oscillator , in the terminology of glauber @xcite . these states have a wide range of applications in quantum optics ( see e.g. @xcite ) , where they act as the quasi - classical states of the em field , and in quantum field theory , where they are the basis of the phase - space path integral @xcite . such states and their derivatives have become important in quantum information processing in recent years , in the context of the manipulation of cold atoms in traps . it has become possible to reconstruct the wigner function of a coherent state of the center - of - mass of an harmonically bound ion @xcite . kennard has on the other hand considered the evolution of a more general wavepacket of the harmonic oscillator , what is now known as a squeezed state . important early contributions are those of husimi @xcite and infeld and plebaski @xcite . these later authors introduced the so - called squeezing operator and established a relation between the evolution of initial states for which the time - evolution is known ( unsqueezed states ) and states which are derived from such initial states by the application of the squeezing operator ( squeezed states ) . the generalisation of this relation to the fd hamiltonian in an homogeneous time - dependent electric field is the main result of the present paper . stoler @xcite proved that squeezed - coherent states are unitarily equivalent to coherent states , thus being minimal uncertainty states , but that their minimal character is not preserved by time - evolution , although the uncertainty periodically assumes the minimum value compatible with heisenberg s uncertainty relation . he also showed that the squeezing operator as currently written in terms of quadratures operators is exactly of the form given by infeld and plebaski . squeezed states play a proeminent role in quantum optics , see again @xcite . recently , they have also become important in quantum information processing both in a quantum optics context and also through the manipulation of cold atoms @xcite . see in particular reference @xcite for an up - to - date report of the state of quantum information processing using cold atoms and photons . besides the paper of darwin already referred , the time - evolution of states of a non - relativistic particle in homogeneous electric and magnetic fields was also considered by malkin , manko , trifonov and dodonov @xcite , who considered the dynamics of a particle in an homogeneous electromagnetic field in terms of coherent states , obtaining an explicit representation of the green s function , and studied the invariants of the system ; by lewis and riesenfeld @xcite , who also considered the invariants of such a system ; by kim and weiner @xcite , who considered the evolution of gaussian wave - packets in a magnetic field , subjected to an isotropic harmonic potential ( i.e. the fd hamiltonian ) , but also to sadle - point potentials , which are relevant for tunnelling problems . the structure of this paper is as follows : in the next section , we review the notion of squeezing operator and generalise the relation of infeld and plebaski to states evolving under the fock - darwin hamiltonian . in section [ secc ] , with a view to applications in the manipulation of cold atoms , we use the relation obtained to establish a relation between the wigner function of different states and apply it to the special case of squeezed - coherent states . in section [ secd ] , we present our conclusions . in appendix [ appendixa ] , we present a derivation of the finite frequency permitivity and conductivity of the fd hamiltonian that uses the same operator methods that are used in the main text but which lies somewhat outside of the scope of the main text . finally , in appendix [ appendixb ] , we derive the original infeld - plebaski relation through elementary means . we consider the time - evolution of the state @xmath9 , that obeys the time - dependent schrdinger equation @xmath10 , where @xmath11 , with @xmath12 being given by equation ( [ eq1 ] ) and where the interaction hamiltonean @xmath13 of the charge with the external electric field is given , in the schrdinger picture , by @xmath14 . if one now expands the squares and groups the different terms of ( [ eq1 ] ) , one obtains @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the giration frequency and @xmath17 , with @xmath18 being the angular momentum component along the @xmath19 axis . one should note that one can write @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the hamiltonean of the isotropic harmonic oscillator with frequency @xmath22 , and also that @xmath23=0 $ ] . given the state vector @xmath9 , one can define the corresponding state vector @xmath24 , in the interaction representation , such that the two vectors coincide at @xmath25 . this state vector evolves acording to the hamiltonian @xmath26 , which given that @xmath21 and @xmath27 in @xmath12 commute , one can also write as @xmath28 if one now applies the time - dependent rotation , encoded by @xmath27 to @xmath13 , followed by the dynamics of the isotropic harmonic oscillator , encoded in @xmath21 , one obtains for @xmath29 : @xmath30+\,e_{y}'(t)\left[\,\hat{y}\,\cos(\omega_r t)+\hat{p}_y\,\sin(\omega_r t)\,\right]\right\ } , \label{eq3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath31 are the components of the electric field in the rotated frame . the wave equation for @xmath32 can be formally integrated in terms of time - ordered products of the integral of @xmath29 , i.e. @xmath33 . now , since the commutator of the operators @xmath34 at different times is a c - number , one can write the time ordered operator above as @xmath35\right)\ , , \label{eq3_1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the second term on the rhs is a phase factor . collecting the several terms , one obtains for the evolution of @xmath9 @xmath36\ , \,[e_x'(u)e_x'(v)+e_y'(u)e_y'(v)]\right)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\times \exp\left(-\frac{i\omega_lt}{2\hbar}\,\hat{l}_z\right)\ , \exp\left(-\frac{i}{\hbar}\,\hat{h}_0\,t\right)\,\exp\left(-\frac{i}{\hbar } \,\int_{0}^{t}\,du\,\hat{h}_1^{int}(u)\right)\ , { \mbox{$ \mid \overline{\psi}_0\ , \rangle$}}\ , . \label{eq4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one now assumes , following infeld and plebaski @xcite , that the initial state @xmath37 is related to a certain initial state @xmath38 , for which the time - evolution under the isotropic harmonic oscillator hamiltonian @xmath21 is known , by @xmath39 where the first operator is a translation operator in phase space , with @xmath40 being arbitrary real constants , and the second operator is the squeezing operator , with @xmath41 being a real constant that indicates the degree of squeezing . substituting equation ( [ eq5 ] ) in ( [ eq4 ] ) one can combine the operators @xmath42 and @xmath43 , since the commutator of their exponents is a c - number . this operation merely generates a phase factor , coming from the commutator . one can then commute the resulting operator to the left - hand side , through @xmath44 , using the time - evolution of @xmath45 under @xmath21 and under the time - dependent rotation around the @xmath19 axis . combining the resulting phase factors and operators , we obtain @xmath46\right)\ , \exp\left(\frac{i}{\hbar}(\,p^c_x(t)\hat{x}+p^c_y(t)\hat{y } -x_c(t)\hat{p}_x - y_c(t)\hat{p}_y\,)\right)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\times \exp\left(-\frac{i\omega_lt}{2\hbar}\,\hat{l}_z\right)\ , \exp\left(-\frac{i}{\hbar}\,\hat{h}_0\,t\right)\ , \exp\left(\frac{i}{2\hbar}\,r\,(\hat{{\mbox{${\boldsymbol p}$}}}\cdot\hat{{\mbox{${\boldsymbol r}$}}}+ \hat{{\mbox{${\boldsymbol r}$}}}\cdot\hat{{\mbox{${\boldsymbol p}$}}})\right)\,{\mbox{$ \mid \psi_0\ , \rangle$}}\ , . \label{eq6}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the classical solutions of the equations of motion for the fock - darwin problem with initial positions @xmath51 and @xmath52 and initial momenta @xmath53 and @xmath54 . these solutions are given by @xmath55\,\cos(\omega_rt)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}+\frac{1}{m\omega_r}\,\left[\,p_x^0 \cos\left(\frac{\omega_l}{2}t\right)-p_y^0 \sin\left(\frac{\omega_l}{2}t\right)\,\right]\,\sin(\omega_rt)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}-\frac{e}{2m\omega_r}\,\int_0^t\,du\ , \left\{e_x(u)\,\left[\sin(\omega_+(t - u))+\sin(\omega_-(t - u))\right]\right . \nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\left.+e_y(u)\,\left[\cos(\omega_+(t - u))-\cos(\omega_-(t - u))\right]\right\}\ , , \label{eq7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath56\,\cos(\omega_rt)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}+\frac{1}{m\omega_r}\,\left[\,p_x^0 \sin\left(\frac{\omega_l}{2}t\right)+p_y^0 \cos\left(\frac{\omega_l}{2}t\right)\,\right]\,\sin(\omega_rt)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}-\frac{e}{2m\omega_r}\,\int_0^t\,du\,\left\{-e_x(u)\,\left[\cos(\omega_+(t - u))-\cos(\omega_-(t - u))\right]\right . \nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\left.+e_y(u)\,\left[\sin(\omega_+(t - u))+\sin(\omega_-(t - u))\right]\right\}\ , , \label{eq8}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath57\,\cos(\omega_rt)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}-m\omega_r\,\left[\,x_0 \cos\left(\frac{\omega_l}{2}t\right)-y_0 \sin\left(\frac{\omega_l}{2}t\right)\,\right]\,\sin(\omega_rt)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}-\frac{e}{2}\,\int_0^t\,du\,\left\{e_x(u)\,\left[\cos(\omega_+(t - u))+\cos(\omega_-(t - u))\right]\right . \nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\left .- e_y(u)\,\left[\sin(\omega_+(t - u))-\sin(\omega_-(t - u))\right]\right\}\ , , \label{eq9}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath58\,\cos(\omega_rt)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}-m\omega_r\,\left[\,x_0 \sin\left(\frac{\omega_l}{2}t\right)+y_0 \cos\left(\frac{\omega_l}{2}t\right)\,\right]\,\sin(\omega_rt)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}-\frac{e}{2}\,\int_0^t\,du\,\left\{e_x(u)\,\left[\sin(\omega_+(t - u))-\sin(\omega_-(t - u))\right]\right . \nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\left.+e_y(u)\,\left[\cos(\omega_+(t - u))+\cos(\omega_-(t - u))\right]\right\}\ , . \label{eq10}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one can read the classical dielectric permitivity of the system from equations ( [ eq7],[eq8 ] ) and one obtains the same results as in appendix [ appendixa ] , which shows that the quantum and classical results are identical , as one would expect for a linear system . the classical velocities @xmath59 can be easily computed by derivation of ( [ eq7],[eq8 ] ) with respect to time or , using the relations @xmath60 and @xmath61 , from equations ( [ eq7 ] ) to ( [ eq10 ] ) . one can then read the classical conductivity of the system from the resulting expression and this result again coincides with that of appendix [ appendixa ] , i.e. the classical and quantum results are the same . finally , one can also show , after derivation of the velocity expressions with respect to time , that the solution given by ( [ eq7 ] ) and ( [ eq8 ] ) obeys the classical equations of motion in two dimensions @xmath62 , with @xmath63 . the left most operator in equation ( [ eq6 ] ) is again a translation operator in phase phase . if one considers the wave - function in the coordinate representation , @xmath64 , and one applies this translation operator to @xmath65 , followed by the rotation operator @xmath66 , one obtains the following result @xmath67\,\right)\right)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\times\exp\left(\frac{i}{\hbar}[p^c_x(t)\,x+p^c_y(t)\,y]\right)\ , { \mbox{$ \langle\ , { \cal r}^{-1}_t\cdot\,(\,{\mbox{${\boldsymbol r}$}}-{\mbox{${\boldsymbol r}$}}_c(t)\,)\mid$ } } \,\,e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar}\,\hat{h}_0\,t}\ , e^{\frac{i}{2\hbar}\,r\,(\hat{{\mbox{\bf\scriptsize p}}}\cdot\hat{{\mbox{\bf\scriptsize r}}}+ \hat{{\mbox{\bf\scriptsize r}}}\cdot\hat{{\mbox{\bf\scriptsize p}}})}\,{\mbox{$ \mid \psi_0\ , \rangle$}}\ , , \label{eq11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath68 being the classical solutions of the equations of motion ( [ eq7 ] ) and ( [ eq8 ] ) and @xmath69 being the rotation matrix in two dimensions by an angle of @xmath70 . for the wave - function in the momentum representation @xmath71 , one obtains , applying the translation operator to @xmath72 , followed again by the rotation operator , @xmath73\,\right)\right)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\times\exp\left(-\frac{i}{\hbar}[p_x\,x_c(t)+p_y\,y_c(t)]\right)\ , { \mbox{$ \langle\ , { \cal r}^{-1}_t\cdot\,(\,{\mbox{${\boldsymbol p}$}}-{\mbox{${\boldsymbol p}$}}^c(t)\,)\mid$ } } \,\,e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar}\,\hat{h}_0t}\,e^{\frac{i}{2\hbar}\,r\,(\hat{{\mbox{\bf\scriptsize p}}}\cdot\hat{{\mbox{\bf\scriptsize r}}}+ \hat{{\mbox{\bf\scriptsize r}}}\cdot\hat{{\mbox{\bf\scriptsize p}}})}\,{\mbox{$ \mid \psi_0\ , \rangle$}}\ , , \label{eq12}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath74 being the classical solutions of the equations of motion ( [ eq9 ] ) and ( [ eq10 ] ) . one can now apply the relation of infeld and plebaski @xcite , relating the evolution of @xmath75 to that of @xmath76 and the evolution of @xmath77 to that of @xmath78 , to equations ( [ eq11 ] ) and ( [ eq12 ] ) , respectively . this relation is derived by elementary means in appendix [ appendixb ] . one obtains for ( [ eq11 ] ) the result @xmath79\right)\right ) \nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\times \exp\left(\frac{i}{\hbar}(p^c_x(t)\,x+p^c_y(t)\,y)\right)\ , \exp\left(\,\frac{i\,m\,\omega_r\,\sinh(2r)\sin(2\omega_rt)}{2\,\hbar\,\mu_r^{2}(t)}\ , [ \,(x - x_c(t))^2+(y - y_c(t))^2\,]\,\right)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\times \psi\left(\frac{{\cal r}^{-1}_t\cdot\,(\,{\mbox{${\boldsymbol r}$}}-{\mbox{${\boldsymbol r}$}}_c(t)\,)}{\mu_r(t)},\tau_r\right)\ , , \label{eq13}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath80 and @xmath81 . for equation ( [ eq12 ] ) , one obtains @xmath82\right)\right ) \nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\times \exp\left(-\frac{i}{\hbar}[p_x\,x_c(t)+p_y\,y_c(t)]\right ) \exp\left(-\frac{i\,\sinh(2r)\sin(2\omega_rt)}{2\,\hbar \,m\,\omega_r\,\mu_{-r}^{2}(t)}\ , [ \,(p_x - p_x^c(t))^2+(p_y - p_y^c(t))^2\,]\right)\nonumber\\ & & \mbox{}\times\psi\left(\frac{{\cal r}^{-1}_t\cdot\,(\ , { \mbox{${\boldsymbol p}$}}-{\mbox{${\boldsymbol p}$}}^c(t)\,)}{\mu_{-r}(t)},\tau_{-r}\right)\ , , \label{eq14}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath83 and @xmath84 . the expressions ( [ eq13 ] ) and ( [ eq14 ] ) constitute the main result of this paper and generalise those of infeld and plebaski as presented in @xcite to states evolving under the fock - darwin hamiltonian subjected to a time - dependent electric field in the plane of the system . one can also establish a relation between the wigner function of a state subjected to squeezing in the presence of electric and magnetic fields and the wigner function of an unsqueezed state evolving under the isotropic harmonic oscillator dynamics . the wigner function is defined as @xcite @xmath85 the wigner function gives , after integration with respect to the momentum @xmath86 or to the coordinate @xmath87 , the coordinate or momentum distribution function of the system and can be considered a quantum generalisation of the boltzmann distribution function . however , the wigner function is not a _ bonna - fide _ distribution since it can assume negative values . substituting the result of equation ( [ eq13 ] ) in ( [ eq15 ] ) , one obtains , after a substitution of variable on @xmath88 @xmath89}{\mu_r(t ) } , { \cal r}^{-1}_t\cdot{\mbox{${\boldsymbol u}$}}({\mbox{${\boldsymbol r}$}},{\mbox{${\boldsymbol p}$}},t),\tau_r\right)\ , , \label{eq16}\ ] ] where @xmath90 -m\omega_r\sinh(2r)\sin(2\omega_rt ) \frac{{\mbox{${\boldsymbol r}$}}-{\mbox{${\boldsymbol r}$}}_c(t)}{\mu_r(t)}$ ] and where @xmath91 is the wigner function of the unsqueezed initial state @xmath92 evolving under the isotropic harmonic oscillator dynamics in the absence of magnetic or electric fields . if the unsqueezed initial state @xmath38 in equation ( [ eq5 ] ) is the vacuum of the isotropic harmonic oscillator , then the state @xmath37 is a squeezed - coherent state , evolving under the fock - darwin hamiltonian . in the context of cold ion experiments , one can produce squeezed states of the ion center of mass , either by queenching of the trap frequency or parametric amplification @xcite , as well as multichromatic excitation of the ion @xcite . in this case , @xmath93 , and we obtain for the wigner function of the squeezed - coherent state the result @xmath94 which represents an assymetric gaussian , whose shape is preserved by the dynamics of the system , rotating in phase - space , with its center determined by the solutions of the classical equations of motion ( [ eq7]-[eq10 ] ) . note that for @xmath95 , i.e. for a coherent state , the wigner function decouples into a product of functions that depend only on the coordinates or the momenta . also , note that for the result ( [ eq17 ] ) is strictly positive , but this is not the case in general , e.g. if we had taken @xmath38 to be an excited - state of the harmonic oscillator . a group of still pictures of the @xmath96 section of the wigner function ( [ eq17 ] ) is shown in the figures , for a system subjected to a right - handed circularly polarised wave , incident along the @xmath97 axis and aligned with the @xmath98 axis at @xmath25 . the intensity of the field is @xmath99 vm@xmath100 , with frequency equal to @xmath101 hz . the harmonic frequency of the trap is @xmath102 hz and the mass of the particle @xmath103 kg , is that of a @xmath104 ion , with the applied magnetic field being @xmath105 t , which gives a giration frequency @xmath106 hz and @xmath107 hz . finally , the squeezing parameter @xmath108 . the integration of expression ( [ eq17 ] ) with respect to @xmath86 or @xmath87 yields the coordinate or momentum distribution . the wave - packets in coordinate or position space are centered around the classical solutions of the equations of motion , the uncertainty in e.g. @xmath109 , @xmath110 being given by @xmath111 , @xmath112 , i.e. the uncertainties oscillate with period @xmath113 . their product is given by @xmath114 in agreement with heisenberg s uncertainty relation . note that the uncertainty in @xmath109 and @xmath110 oscillate in opposition , i.e. one increases while the other is decreasing . also note that , unlike a coherent state , the squeezed - coherent state is not a minimum uncertainty state for these two canonical variables , except when @xmath115 @xcite . in this paper , we have considered the time - evolution of general squeezed states evolving under the fock - darwin hamiltonian in an homogeneous time - dependent electric field . we have generalised a relation of infeld and plebaski , between the time - evolution of states of the harmonic oscillator subjected to squeezing and states not subjected to squeezing and for which the time - evolution is known , to states evolving under the fd hamiltonian in two dimensions . a corresponding relation was also established for the wigner functions of the states . finally , in an appendix , we computed the response functions of the fd hamiltonian to an external electric field , using the same techniques as in the main text . * acknowledgements : * we acknowledge helpful discussions with a. ferreira . the authors were supported by fct under grant no . ptdc / fis/64404/2006 . we will first indicate how to diagonalise the hamiltonian ( [ eq1 ] ) in the operator representation . the diagonalisation of this hamiltonian and the determination of its eigenfunctions was first obtained by fock @xcite . introducing the annihilation and creation operators @xmath116 through @xmath117 , @xmath118 , @xmath119 , @xmath120 , one can write such hamiltonian in the form @xmath121 with @xmath122 being the only operator that is non - diagonal in the annihilation and creation operators in the above expression . introducing the circular polarisation operators @xmath123 through @xmath124 , @xmath125 , @xmath126 , @xmath127 , one has @xmath128 and one can write @xmath12 as @xmath129 where @xmath130 , @xmath131 . the energy levels are now given in terms of the occupation numbers of the modes @xmath132 by @xmath133 . we will now compute the dielectric permitivity and optical conductivity of the system in the quantum regime by considering the hamiltonian @xmath134 of the system interacting with an homogeneous time - dependent electric field , as given in section [ secb ] . expressing the operators @xmath135 and @xmath136 in terms of @xmath137 , we have the following expression for the interaction hamiltonian @xmath13 , @xmath138\ , , \label{eq3a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath139 and @xmath140 . if @xmath141 is a solution of the time - dependent schrdinger equation , one defines , as above , the state vector @xmath142 , in the interaction representation , such that the two vectors coincide at @xmath25 , when the field is turned on . given that in the interaction representation the annihilation and creation operators contained in @xmath13 evolve in time through multiplication by a phase factor @xmath143 , @xmath29 is given by @xmath144\ , . \label{eq4a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one can now write , as in section [ secb ] , the formal solution @xmath145 . the time - ordered operator above is then written using identity ( [ eq3_1 ] ) , the second term in this product being a phase factor that can be discarded when computing expectation values . we can write for @xmath141 the result @xmath146 with @xmath147 being given by @xmath148 and where we have discarded the phase factor referred above . the operator @xmath149 is the displacement operator for the annihilation and creation operators , i.e. @xmath150 , @xmath151 . therefore , using the above representation of @xmath141 , one can show that the average value of any operator @xmath152 , in the schrdinger representation , is given by @xmath153\ , { \mbox{$ \mid \psi_{0}\ , \rangle$}}\ , . \label{eq6a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular , if @xmath154 , i.e. for a linear function of the annihilation or creation operators , such as @xmath155 , which is the case that will concerns us below , one has that @xmath156 where @xmath157 is the difference between the average value in presence and absence of the applied electric field . using this result , one can easily show that the induced polarisation in the system @xmath158 , @xmath159 , is given by @xmath160 , where the permitivity of the system is given by @xmath161 the first equality between the permitivities follows from rotational invariance around the @xmath19 axis , the second from linear response theory . the induced current @xmath162 , @xmath163 , is related to @xmath164 and @xmath165 , by @xmath166 , @xmath167 and given that @xmath168 , one easily obtains for the conductivity , defined by @xmath169 , the result @xmath170 . hence , @xmath171 obviously and as above , one can also compute it from the definition of @xmath172 , @xmath173 , since all the operators involved are linear in the annihilation and creation operators . note that , since @xmath174 , @xmath175 , a result which agrees with the _ f - sum _ rule for a single quantum particle . it is interesting to consider this system in two limits , namely @xmath176 ( simple harmonic oscilator ) and @xmath177 ( particle in a magnetic field ) . in the first case , @xmath178 and one obtains @xmath179 , @xmath180 ( this result is obvious , given the lack of transverse response if @xmath181 ) . in the second case , @xmath182 , @xmath183 , @xmath184 . one has that @xmath185 , @xmath186 . finally , let us consider the case in which a constant electric field is turned on at @xmath25 . in that case , one obtains at large times @xmath187 that the current @xmath188 , where @xmath189 is the laplace transform of @xmath190 . performing the integrals , one obtains @xmath191 . the limit @xmath192 requires a bit of care in the transverse conductivity case , since @xmath193 . we obtain @xmath194 if @xmath195 . however , we obtain @xmath196 in the @xmath197 case ( @xmath183 ) . this result is physically simple to understand if one realises that , when a harmonic force is present , a constant electric field merely displaces the force center , whether a constant magnetic field is present or not ( a shift in the origin of the coordinates merely contributes a constant term to the vector potential , that can be simply gauged away ) . therefore , one will not observe a response of the velocity to the electric field in that case . however , in the absence of an harmonic force , the electric field pulls on the giration radius center as if it were a free particle and one does observe a transverse response . one should again note that the quantum and classical results obtained for the susceptibilities computed above and those obtained from the classical equations of motion ( [ eq7]-[eq10 ] ) are identical and , moreover , that the response to the electric field is purely linear . this result follows from the fact that the classical equations of motion and their quantum counterparts , the ehrenfest equations , are linear and can therefore be solved with respect to the field and the initial conditions . in this respect , the system behaviour is trivial . however , the equality of results between the classical and quantum cases is limited to operators that are linear combinations of the coordinates and momenta . in the case of non - linear operators , one can still use the methods discussed in this appendix to study their time evolution . furthermore , if one is interested in the evolution of wave - functions , as discussed in the main text , one should keep the phase factors that were discarded in the computation of average values . we give here an elementary demonstration of the relation of infeld and plebaski @xcite . if @xmath198 is the squeezing operator introduced above , it is easy to show @xcite that @xmath199 , @xmath200 , i.e. @xmath201 is a scale transformation operator that preserves the volume of phase space . using these identities , one can show that @xmath202 where @xmath203 is the space dimension ( two in this case ) . we now wish to consider the wave - function of a squeezed state evolving under the isotropic harmonic oscillator @xmath21 , i.e. the matrix element @xmath204 ( the discussion in momentum space is completely analogous ) . inserting a complete set of position eigenstates , one can write this quantity as @xmath205 where @xmath206 . using the identity ( [ eqb1 ] ) , one has that @xmath207 where @xmath208 is the isotropic harmonic oscillator propagator . note , however , that ( [ eqb3_1 ] ) is valid for an arbitrary one - particle hamiltonian . the harmonic oscillator propagator is given by @xcite @xmath209 now , introducing the scaled variables @xmath210 , @xmath211 , with @xmath80 , and @xmath81 , one can show , using equation ( [ eqb3_1 ] ) , that @xmath212 substituting ( [ eqb5 ] ) in ( [ eqb3 ] ) , one obtains @xmath213 which is the infeld - plebaski relation used in the main text . since the expression for the propagator in momentum space is entirely analogous to ( [ eqb4 ] ) , the steps are identical to those above , except that @xmath41 is replaced by @xmath214 . one obtains @xmath215 10 d. leibfried , d. m. meekhof , b. e. king , c. monroe , w. m. itano , and d. j. wineland , `` experimental determination of the motional quantum state of a trapped atom '' phys . * 77 , * 281285 ( 1996 ) . h. r. lewis and w. b. riesenfeld , `` and exact theory of the time - dependent harmonic oscillator and of a charged particle in the time - dependent electromagnetic field '' j. math . * 10 , * 14581473 ( 1969 ) . * figure captions * + * figure 1 . * @xmath96 section of wigner function of squeezed - coherent state , as given by equation ( [ eq17 ] ) at @xmath25 , evolving under the fock - darwin hamiltonian . the length of the @xmath109 , @xmath110 axis is , respectively , @xmath216 m and @xmath217 kg m s@xmath100 and the wigner function was multiplied by @xmath218 . + * figure 2 . * + same as [ f1 ] at time @xmath219 . + * figure 3 . * + same as [ f1 ] at time @xmath220 . + * figure 4 . * + same as [ f1 ] at time @xmath221 .

we develop a complete analytical description of the time evolution of squeezed states of a charged particle under the fock - darwin hamiltonian and a time - dependent electric field . this result generalises a relation obtained by infeld and plebaski for states of the one - dimensional harmonic oscillator . we relate the evolution of a state - vector subjected to squeezing to that of state which is not subjected to squeezing and for which the time - evolution under the simple harmonic oscillator dynamics is known ( e.g. an eigenstate of the hamiltonian ) . a corresponding relation is also established for the wigner functions of the states , in view of their utility in the analysis of cold - ion experiments . in an appendix , we compute the response functions of the fd hamiltonian to an external electric field , using the same techniques as in the main text .

0908.2938

a clear understanding of nuclear structure beyond the valley of @xmath4-stability requires detailed spectroscopic investigations . direct reactions , such as single - nucleon transfer reactions are established probes of the single - particle nuclear shell structure and have provided considerable insight into the properties of stable nuclei in the past . with the on - going increase in radioactive nuclear beam intensities , such as those achieved at the spiral facility , this kind of reaction is now feasible . the inverse kinematics of such reactions leads , however , to significant constraints on the experimental apparatus @xcite . one of the main obstacles to overcome is to reach good energy resolution in the kinematically reconstructed excitation energy given that the energy spread of the secondary beam may be relatively large , the target - like residue can be emitted over a large angular range and that thick targets are often required to compensate for the relatively low intensities of the beams @xcite . already , pioneer detectors such as must @xcite and the active target maya @xcite have been build to tackle some of these obstacles and , the detector tiara described here proposes a new alternative to these other apparatus . the tiara array is designed and built specifically to study direct reactions with radioactive beams and addresses the challenge of the excitation energy resolution by employing the technique of @xmath1-ray tagging . this has the advantage of providing , in principle , a final excitation energy resolution limited only by doppler broadening . the tiara array was commissioned at the ganil laboratory through a study of the d(@xmath2n , p)@xmath3n reaction @xcite with coincident @xmath1-ray detection . the results are reported here together with a full description of the array . the tiara array @xcite has been designed with the ultimate goal of performing nucleon transfer and other direct reaction studies in inverse kinematics using radioactive ion beams @xcite . the array is used to identify the binary reaction channels and to determine the excitation energies of the populated states . this task is achieved by providing position and deposited energy measurements of the light charged target - like residue , which can be emitted over a wide angular range . tiara consists of a set of single - layer silicon detectors manufactured by micron semiconductor @xcite which covers 85@xmath5 of 4@xmath0 ( fig . [ fig : tiaracoverage ] ) . the set includes a large annular double sided silicon strip detector ( sihyball ) , eight resistive charge division silicon detectors forming a `` barrel '' around the target , and two smaller `` cd - type '' silicon strip detectors ( s1 and s2 ) . eight resistive charge division detectors based on 6-inch silicon wafer technology form an octagonal barrel around the beam axis and surrounding the target . each of the detectors presents an active area 94.6 mm long and 22.5 mm wide with a thickness of 400 @xmath6 m . the junction side facing the target is divided into 4 longitudinal resistive strips obtained by p@xmath7 implantation on n - type silicon . each 4k@xmath8-resistive strip has a 5.65 mm pitch while the inter - strip gap is 100 @xmath6 m . the strips provide for measurement and pixellation of the azimuthal angle in 32 bins of approximately 9.5@xmath9 . the pcb board around the silicon has been minimised and bevelled so that the dead area between the detectors as well as between the barrel and annular detectors , is minimised . at one end of the ohmic side of the detector , the pcb board is extended by @xmath1015 mm in order to gather all the output signal tracks : the 8 position signals ( 2 signals per strip ) and the connection of the ohmic side to ground . miniature junkosha coaxial cables of 1 mm diameter and 30 cm length were chosen for their favourable vacuum properties to transmit the signals from the detector to the vessel feed - throughs . once assembled ( fig . [ fig : photohybbar ] right ) , the barrel presents an octagonal cross section of 27.6 mm side length and 33.3 mm inner radius . from the centre , the angular range spans 36@xmath9 to 144@xmath9 . for the commissioning measurements described later , the centre of the barrel was mounted 1 mm forward of the target position leading to an angular coverage of 35.5@xmath9 to 143.5@xmath9 . the measurement of the position along the strip is achieved by resistive charge division and , with alpha particles of 5.5 mev , the position resolution along the longitudinal axis is determined to better than 0.5 mm ( fwhm ) . the resulting polar angle is thus deduced with a precision better than 1@xmath9 . the energy of the particle is obtained simply by summing the signals from the two strip ends . figure [ fig:3alphas ] was obtained using a mixed source of @xmath11pu , @xmath12am and @xmath13 cm with alpha energies of 5156 , 5484 and 5805 kev respectively . it illustrates the correlation between the signals from the ends of the strips ( fig [ fig:3alphas](a ) ) . with a shaping time of 1@xmath6s the barrel suffers slightly from ballistic deficits which result in a non - linear dependence of the energy sum , measured at each end of a strip , as a function of the position . nevertheless , this dependence is easily described with a second - order polynomial function and a corresponding corrective factor can be applied to the energy sum . the resolution for one strip is @xmath1070 kev ( fwhm ) for 5.5 mev alphas ( fig [ fig:3alphas](b ) ) . s shaping time . ( c ) : same as ( b ) for the 4 strips of a barrel detector.,width=453,height=264 ] as noted earlier , in order to enhance the angular coverage of the tiara array , double - sided dc annular silicon - strip detectors are mounted at both ends of the barrel . for these detectors the annular rings on the entrance face ( junction side ) were fabricated by p@xmath7 implantation on n - type silicon . the forward angles are covered by two 500 @xmath6 m thick annular detectors based on 4-inch wafer technology . the smallest of the two ( s2-design ) was positioned 150 mm downstream of the target position covering the polar angular range [ 3.8@xmath9,13.1@xmath9 ] . the active area is delimited by a disk of 11 mm inner radius and 35 mm outer radius . the detector is divided into 48 rings of 0.5 mm pitch at the front ( target side ) and 16 azimuthal sectors at the back . however , for the present measurements , the number of channels to instrument was reduced by linking the rings in threes giving effectively 16 rings of 1.5 mm pitch . the second forward annular detector ( s1 design ) was mounted 92 mm downstream of the target position to cover the polar angular range [ 12.6 @xmath9,27.5@xmath9 ] . its active area is divided into 4 quadrants of 20.5 mm inner and 48 mm outer radii . although each quadrant has 16 front rings ( 1.65 mm pitch ) and 4 azimuthal back sectors , for the experiment reported here the four quadrants were combined to form two semi - circles to reduce the total number of rings from 16@xmath154 to 16@xmath152 . the backward angles from 137.0@xmath9 to 169.4@xmath9 are covered by a 400 @xmath6 m thick double - sided silicon - strip detector ( dsssd ) based on 6-inch wafer technology and positioned 150 mm upstream of the target position . this detector is composed of six individual wedges ( fig . [ fig : photohybbar ] ) originally developed at oak ridge for the sihyball forward array @xcite . each wedge is divided into 16 strips facing the target and 8 azimuthal back sectors . the active area of a wedge is delimited by inner and outer radii of 28.11 mm and 140 mm , respectively , and spans approximately 55@xmath9 of the total azimuthal angle . the pitch of the rings is 5.3 mm and the polar angular range is close to 2 degrees per strip . the energy resolution , illustrated in fig . [ fig:3alphas]b , is typically @xmath1070 kev ( fwhm ) for 5.5 mev alpha particles . one of the critical features of the tiara array is the target changing mechanism ( fig . [ fig : target ] ) . the design of this mechanism has been chosen to maximise the solid angle coverage of the array . positioned upstream , just behind the sihyball , it offers the possibility to use four different targets during a run without breaking vacuum . the mechanism consists of a target storage wheel with 4 positions and a rod parallel and slightly offset to the beam axis . a set of clamps , four on the storage wheel and one at the extremity of the rod ( fig . [ fig : target ] ) are used to hold the target frames . the rod is driven along the beam axis via a ball screw . it first picks up a target from the wheel and continues its motion along the beam axis through the inner hole of the sihyball detector until the target position in the barrel is reached . the target frame is 3@xmath153 @xmath16 in area with a central hole of 20 mm diameter . it can only be positioned perpendicular to the beam axis , introducing some shadowing at 90@xmath9 in the barrel detector ( section 3.3 ) . the whole mechanism is controlled remotely and the position of both the wheel and the rod is monitored by optical readouts . four feed - throughs on the vacuum vessel are used for the target control system . the reaction chamber of tiara is made of aluminium and is some 56 cm long ( excluding the target mechanism ) . figure [ fig : photosetup ] shows the vessel in position in front of the vamos spectrometer and in the middle of the exogam support structure . the vessel presents a longitudinal diabolo shape with a central cylindrical section of 85 mm outer diameter housing the barrel and two 500 mm diameter cylindrical sections at each end housing the annular detectors . two aluminium end plates accommodating fischer dbpe 105-series feed - throughs ( 27 pins each ) and supporting kinematics plates for detector alignment complete the chamber . while one of the end - plates can accommodate up to 17 feed - throughs , the other one , which also includes two pipes for additional pumping , can accommodate up to 15 of them . given that 4 feed - throughs are already used for the target mechanism , a total of 28 feed - throughs can be used for the transmission of the detector signals . the tiara reaction chamber has been designed to allow a gamma - ray array such as exogam to be placed as close as possible to the target . as such , the thickness of the walls of the central section has been limited to 2 mm in order to reduce the @xmath1-ray attenuation to a minimum . for a photon energy of 1 mev , the linear attenuation coefficient in aluminium is 0.166 @xmath17 . this leads to an attenuation of 3.3@xmath5 in a 0.2 cm layer compare to 8@xmath5 in a 0.5 cm layer . there are 8@xmath152@xmath154 channels to be instrumented for the octagonal barrel , ( 16 rings + 8 sectors)@xmath156 channels for the sihyball detector , ( 16 rings + 8 sectors)@xmath152 channels for the s1 detector and ( 16 rings + 16 sectors ) channels for the s2 detector , resulting in a total of 288 channels . a schematic diagram of the tiara electronics is shown in fig . [ fig : tiaelec ] . eighteen 16-channel charge - sensitive preamplifier modules manufactured at the university of the west of scotland , eighteen caen n568b 16-channel spectroscopy amplifiers controlled remotely via a caenet v288 controller module , eighteen caen v814 16-channel low threshold discriminators and nine 32-channel adc modules are employed to record the energy signals from the array . a sy2527 caen universal multi - channel power supply system equipped with a a1737n 12 high voltage ( hv ) channel board provided the -50 volts necessary for the full depletion of all the silicon detectors . typically leakage currents of around 0.2 , 0.3 , 4.0 and 1.1 @xmath6a respectively are drawn by each element of the barrel and each wedge of the sihyball , the s1 and the s2 detectors . the 16 charge - sensitive preamplifiers are mounted in double width nim modules and are designed specifically for use with room temperature silicon - strip detectors and resistive - sheet detectors with capacitances in the range of 0 to 1000pf . each unit houses two 8 channel motherboards with easily dismountable preamplifier chips . both the motherboards and preamplifiers chips are housed in a rugged well shielded metal housing . with a quiescent dc output approaching zero , this unit is well adapted for use with the caen n568b spectroscopy amplifier , which has 50 @xmath8 input impedance . for each of the six wedges of the sihyball detector , one complete module was used for the 16 front rings ( with all 16 hv inputs combined ) while half of another module was used for the eight back sectors . in this way , three preamplifier modules instrumented two wedges of the sihyball . similarly three and two modules instrumented the s1 and s2 detector , respectively . for the four resistive strips of each of the eight barrel detectors , only half a module was required with all the corresponding eight preamplifier hv inputs combined and connected . among the eighteen discriminators , five had to be adapted by the manufacturer to run with positive polarity inputs in order to instrument the eighty back sectors of the sihyball , s1 and s2 dsssd annular detectors . both the caen amplifiers and discriminators are remotely programmable and , for tiara , the control of this hardware is ensured via the multi instance data acquisition system ( midas)@xcite application developed at the stfc daresbury laboratory . also used for the present work , and programmable via midas , are the eight 32-channel ganil xdc3214 adcs @xcite operating in common dead - time mode and an additional 32-channel silena s9418 adc . exogam , vamos and the tiara array have their own stand - alone electronics and data acquisition systems ( daqs ) . for the tiara commissioning measurements discussed below , the 3 daqs were merged together using 3 hardware vxi centrum modules which provided time stamping of the events and the merger software for building the events @xcite . the principal trigger of this commissioning experiment was defined by a hit in any element of tiara . due to room constraint around the tiara vacuum chamber , a @xmath103 m cable length was necessary to connect the tiara detectors to the preamplifiers . as a direct consequence , the thresholds in energy had to be set high . they were @xmath101 mev for the double sided annular detectors and @xmath101.5 mev for the resistive charge division detector . for the commissioning of the array and in order to validate the technique of heavy - ion particle@xmath1 coincidence measurements , the d(@xmath2n , p@xmath1)@xmath3n reaction was investigated at an energy representative of spiral radioactive beams . the 10.6 mev / nucleon @xmath2n beam was delivered by the first cyclotron of the ganil facility . the target was a 1 mg/@xmath18 deuterated polythene ( cd@xmath19)@xmath20 self - supporting foil . the choice of the reaction was dictated by a number of considerations : ( a ) the ground state of @xmath3n is isolated and easily resolved from the excited states ; ( b ) the excited states populated in the reaction can not be easily resolved in inverse kinematics and ( c ) the reaction has been studied before in direct kinematics with light - particle detection at a similar centre - of - mass energy . as shown in fig . [ fig : photosetup ] the tiara reaction chamber allows four clovers of the exogam array @xcite to be mounted in a cube - like configuration . in this configuration the segmented ge clover detectors are all positioned at 90@xmath9 relative to the beam axis and from a distance between the target and the front face of each detector of approximately 5 cm . the photopeak efficiency in this configuration ( figure [ fig : tiaexosim ] ) is 13.5@xmath5 at 1.332 mev when the 4 central contact signals of the 4 crystals in each clover detector are added together ( `` addback '' ) . the tiara and exogam arrays were mounted at the entrance of the vamos spectrometer ( fig . [ fig : photosetup ] ) operating in momentum - dispersive mode @xcite . the forward focused beam - like fragments are then identified in mass and charge from measurements of the time - of - flight , energy loss , residual energy and position in vamos . a plastic finger was placed in front of the vamos focal plane detection system to intercept the intense non - interacting direct beam , which could damage the focal plane detectors . the data presented here were recorded over a total of approximately 4 hours of beam time with an average beam intensity of 2@xmath2110@xmath22 pps . knowing the efficiency of the experimental setup is essential if reaction cross sections and , hence , spectroscopic factors , are to be extracted . in this context a complete and realistic simulation of the setup can be extremely useful . a monte - carlo simulation based on the geant4 code @xcite has been developed to mimic the response of the tiara and exogam arrays . the geometry defined in this simulation includes , in particular , the entire active area of the tiara array and the 2 mm thick aluminium walls of the reaction chamber , the four exogam ge clover detectors , and the target @xcite . figure [ fig : tiaexosim](a ) illustrates a reconstructed image of the response of the setup to a 1mev @xmath1-ray . for the simulation of nucleon - transfer reactions , the event generator takes into account the kinematics of the 2-body reactions and the differential angular cross section is set to be isotropic . the position of the proton source ( or interaction ) in the target is chosen randomly according to the beam spot size and the target thickness . the @xmath1-rays are simulated assuming isotropic emission in the rest frame of the beam - like reaction product and then boosted by the lorentz effect . the intrinsic resolutions of all the detectors are also included . taking into account the inactive regions of the si detectors , the simulated overall efficiency of the tiara array for proton detection with energies of a few mev emitted isotropically was found to be 84@xmath5 . the efficiency of the various components of the array as a function of the polar angle is illustrated in figure [ fig : effang ] . an isotropic @xmath1-source at the target position and with variable energy was also simulated to estimate the exogam photopeak efficiency and the result is shown in figure [ fig : tiaexosim](b ) . the photopeak attenuation induced by the presence of the tiara detectors and the reaction chamber is about 5@xmath5 at 1.332 mev , with the silicon layer accounting for about 1@xmath5 . the output of the simulation is recorded in a root tree which includes as many leaves as channels for the two arrays . the simulated data and the real calibrated data can then be analysed identically using the same analysis code performing the `` add - back '' and doppler corrections . an `` addback '' correction between the clover detectors was not considered here and , as noted above , was only applied to the 4 crystals of each clover . when more than one crystal was hit in a clover , the energies collected by the central contacts were summed together . the crystal with the highest deposited energy was taken to be , for the doppler correction , the first crystal hit . simulations ( figure [ fig : exogsim ] ) show that this assumption is a valid approximation as long as the energy of the @xmath1-rays is higher than 500 kev . indeed , below 500 kev , when two crystals are hit the energies deposited in each crystal tend to be similar ( see bottom - left panel of fig . [ fig : exogsim ] ) and , as a consequence , the identification of the first crystal to be hit becomes uncertain . for events of crystal multiplicity @xmath23 , the average angles chosen for the doppler correction are 78@xmath24 for downstream crystals and 102@xmath24 for upstream crystals . for events of higher crystal multiplicity , the angles become respectively 84@xmath24 and 96@xmath24 as the closer to an adjacent crystal a compton interaction occurs the higher is the probability for @xmath25 . these angles have been determined empirically by matching of the photopeaks in downstream and upstream crystals and are consistent with the angles returned by the simulations . -ray of e@xmath26=1332 kev , with no condition ( left ) and with the condition that crystal a is hit first ( right ) . middle panels : e@xmath26=700 kev . bottom panels : e@xmath26=500 kev . , width=302,height=453 ] the energy of the charged particles deposited in tiara resulting from the reaction of the @xmath2n beam with the ( cd@xmath27)@xmath20 target as a function of laboratory polar angle recorded in the tiara array is displayed in figure [ fig : de_pos ] . the shadowing introduced by the presence of the target frame at 90@xmath9 is noticeable . at backward laboratory angles where the emission of protons is expected , two clear kinematic loci are observed . these loci become even more pronounced when the @xmath3n residue is identified in coincidence in the focal plane of the vamos spectrometer ( fig . [ fig : de_pos]b ) . in the barrel detector , data associated with a low discriminator threshold have been removed , resulting in a noticeable inverted v - shaped cut at low deposited energy in figs [ fig : de_pos]a and b. the additional requirement of the detection of any @xmath1-ray in coincidence , shown in figure [ fig : de_pos]c , leads to the disappearance of the protons in region r1 and , consequently , allows one to definitively associate this locus with the d(@xmath2n , p)@xmath3n@xmath28 reaction . indeed , when the kinematics of this reaction channel are used as input to the simulation , a perfect match between the simulation and the data ( fig . [ fig : de_pos]d ) is obtained . both the kinematics and the expected proton punch - through energies are well reproduced . note that the results of the simulations extend to very forward angles because the differential cross sections d@xmath29/d@xmath8 have , as noted earlier , been assumed to be isotropic . since the reaction cross - section decreases relatively sharply with decreasing proton laboratory angle , the protons punching through the detectors are not so apparent in the data . n identified in vamos . ( c ) same as ( b ) with a coincidence in exogam . ( d ) same as ( b ) with monte - carlo simulations superimposed.,width=340,height=340 ] n detected in coincidence in vamos ; ( b ) as for ( a ) with a @xmath1-ray in coincidence in exogam ; ( c ) as for ( a ) with a 1885 kev ( solid ) and 2295 kev ( dash ) @xmath1-ray in coincidence.,width=302,height=340 ] similarly , the simulation indicates that the protons observed in region r2 can be associated with the population of the 5/2@xmath7 ( 7.16 mev ) , 3/2@xmath7 ( 7.30 mev ) or 7/2@xmath7 ( 7.57 mev ) states of the @xmath3n . the energy resolution of the excitation energy spectrum ( fig . [ fig : ex ] ) reconstructed from the proton energy and position measured in the barrel detector is @xmath101 mev ( fwhm ) and is clearly insufficient to resolve the three states that lie above 7.1 mev within 500 kev of each other . apart from a broad structure centred at 7.5 mev , figure [ fig : ex](a and b ) only reveals a small structure above 5 mev . this can easily be interpreted as the direct population of the known 5/2@xmath7 ( 5.27 mev ) and 1/2@xmath7 ( 5.3 mev ) states . in addition , with a spectroscopic factor only 6 times smaller than the spectroscopic factors of the 7.16 and 7.57 mev states , and 15 times higher than the 5.3 mev state@xcite , the 5/2@xmath7 state at 5.27 mev is most probably the main contribution . -ray energy spectra in coincidence with the protons in region r2 of fig . [ fig : de_pos ] . the data and the simulations ( histograms ) of the @xmath1-cascades from 5/2@xmath7 and 7/2@xmath7 levels to the ground state are shown before ( a ) and after ( b ) doppler correction . the contributions of the cascades from the 5/2@xmath7 and 7/2@xmath7 levels at 7.16 and 7.57 mev excitation energy are shown separately in ( b ) . the distributions are normalized to the data by the integral of the number of events between 1 and 6 mev . ( c ) displays the data collected by a single clover after doppler correction based on the 4 central contact signals ( black histogram ) and on the 16 outer contact signals ( grey histogram ) . ( d ) low energy @xmath3n level scheme including the strongest transitions.,width=359,height=453 ] the spectrum shown in figure [ fig : exogamdata ] illustrates the crucial role played by the @xmath1-ray array . all the spectra of figure [ fig : exogamdata ] are conditioned by a clover multiplicity equal to one . the middle panel shows the energy distribution of the @xmath1-ray measured in coincidence with the protons of region r2 , after `` addback '' and doppler correction . two narrow peaks at 1885 and 2295 kev and a broader structure at 5270 kev which result from the de - excitation of the 5/2@xmath7 and 7/2@xmath7 states of @xmath3n at 7.16 and 7.57 mev , are observed ( figs . [ fig : exogamdata ] ) . as discussed earlier , the de - excitation of the 5/2@xmath7 and 1/2@xmath7 states at 5.27 and 5.30 mev , populated directly in the reaction ( fig . [ fig : ex ] ) , also contributes to the broad structure at 5170 kev , to a small extent . it should be noted that the 3/2@xmath7 level at 7.30 mev , also observed by @xcite , decays directly to the ground state ( fig.[fig : exogamdata]d ) and will , therefore , not be seen in coincidence with @xmath1-rays in exogam ( owing to the very low detection efficiency at such high energies ) . the compton edges of the 1885 and 5270 kev @xmath1-rays are also evident at around 1650 and 5000 kev respectively . a simulation of the two decay cascades , taking into account the lorentz boost and assuming that the two states were equally populated , has been carried out . the result is displayed by the histogram in figure [ fig : exogamdata](a ) which has been normalized to the data such that the integrals between 1 and 6 mev are the same . although the intensities of the photopeaks at 1885 and 2296 kev seem slightly over - estimated , there is a good overall agreement between the simulation and the data . the discrepancy below 1 mev is believed to arise from @xmath1-rays scattering in material surrounding the detectors that have not been included in the simulation . indeed , in both the data and the simulation , only the events for which a single clover detector is hit , have been taken into account . when all multiplicities are required , the number of counts at low energy increases in both the data and the simulated spectrum . figure [ fig : exogamdata](b ) also displays the contribution of each cascade and , in particular , the contribution of the compton background in the region of the photopeaks . according to the simulation these compton events represent 26@xmath5 of the peak intensity at 1885 kev and @xmath103.5@xmath5 at 5270 kev . given that the @xmath1-decay of the two states ( assumed here to be equally populated ) proceeds via the 5.27 mev state , half of the compton contribution from the line at 5270 kev is actually in coincidence with the unobserved 1885 kev @xmath1-ray . therefore the total background contribution to the 1885 peak is 27.8@xmath5 . the compton background from the 5270 kev line to the 2296 kev peak has similarly been estimated to be 2.5@xmath5 . while , with the proton detection only , the final resolution on the excitation energy is restricted to @xmath101 mev , the gamma tagging technique improves dramatically the resolution to @xmath10100 kev , allowing for the two closely spaced @xmath3n excited states to be resolved . during the experiment , the segmentation information of the ge crystals was only available for one of the four clover detectors . a comparison of the @xmath1-ray energy spectra recorded in this clover with and without segmentation information is shown in figure [ fig : exogamdata](c ) . at 2.3 mev , the resolution ( fwhm ) is 80 and 120 kev with and without the segmentation information , respectively . the proton angular distributions displayed in figure [ fig : datadwba ] were extracted by selecting events in region r1 of figure [ fig : de_pos](b ) corresponding to the @xmath3n ground state , and in coincidence with the 1885 and 2296 kev @xmath1-ray lines ( fig . [ fig : exogamdata]b ) corresponding to the @xmath3n levels at 7.16 and 7.57 mev . the dwba calculations displayed in figure [ fig : datadwba ] were performed using the twofnr code @xcite with the optical model parameters calculated according to the johnson - soper prescription @xcite . each of the theoretical distributions have been multiplied by the corresponding spectroscopic factors derived from direct kinematics measurements in order to obtain the absolute differential cross section @xcite : c@xmath19s(g.s.)=1.33 , c@xmath19s(7.16 mev)=0.90 and c@xmath19s(7.57 mev)=0.88 . transferred angular momenta of _ l_=1 for the ground state and _ l_=2 for the two excited states were considered in the dwba calculations in agreement with the results obtained in direct kinematics @xcite . the experimental proton angular distributions for the ground and excited states were normalized to the theoretical distribution . the shape of the experimental distributions for the ground state ( fig . [ fig : datadwba]a ) is in good agreement with the theoretical distributions . similarly , the shapes of the experimental and theoretical distributions for the two excited states figures [ fig : datadwba](b ) , and ( c ) , are also in good agreement . unfortunately , in the present measurements , the absolute cross sections , and hence spectroscopic factors , could not be derived from the data . as noted earlier , part of the focal plane of vamos was protected from the transmitted beam by a `` finger '' . as a result , no direct measurement of the beam dose or of the elastic scattering could be made . using , however , as a global normalisation the spectroscopic factor of 1.33 for the ground state @xcite , the relative spectroscopic factors for the two excited states may be estimated . values some 0.7 that of those previously measured @xcite were so deduced , which is within the statistical uncertainties of the measured differential cross section . future measurements with radioactive beams will employ an active `` finger '' together with beam detectors also capable of counting the beam particles . in the present study , knowing the level scheme of @xmath3n facilitates the identification of the populated states . for a nucleus with unknown level scheme , provided that there is enough statistics , a @xmath1-@xmath1 coincidence analysis can be carried out , in addition of simulations , to restore or establish a consistent level scheme . therefore , when coupled to a high efficiency @xmath1-ray detector array , the tiara array proposes a new alternative to other existing detectors for direct reaction with unstable beams . other detectors like must offer a much higher dynamic range , better particle identification and intrinsic resolution than the tiara array but they have a limited solid - angle coverage which can make ( d , p ) reactions studies difficult . on the other hand , active target detectors like maya competes very much with the tiara array in term of solid - angle coverage and are known to have significant lower energy threshold than silicon detectors . however , the large volume occupied by active target detectors prohibits a coupling with a @xmath1-ray array and , consequently , the @xmath1-tagging technique can hardly be used . a new compact , large solid - angle segmented silicon detector array , tiara , designed for the study of direct reactions in inverse kinematics with radioactive beams , has been described . coupled with a high efficiency @xmath1-ray detector array , such as exogam , tiara employs the technique of light ( target - like ) particle-@xmath1 coincidences to obtain the necessary resolution in excitation energy in the residual target - like recoil . identification of the latter , if required , may be performed using a magnetic spectrometer such as vamos . these techniques have been validated in a commissioning experiment in which the d(@xmath2n , p@xmath1)@xmath3n reaction was measured . in the near future , it is planned to increase the dynamic range of the silicon detector by the installation of a second 700 @xmath6 m thick si layer around the existing barrel detectors together with 15 mm thick csi(tl ) segmented detectors backing the forward angle annular detectors . the collaboration wishes to thank the ganil cyclotron operations crew for delivering the @xmath2n beam . partial support from the european union under contract n@xmath9506065 and from the spanish mec grant fpa2005 - 03993 are also gratefully acknowledged . the development and construction of tiara were financed by an epsrc(uk ) grant .

a compact , quasi-4@xmath0 position sensitive silicon array , tiara , designed to study direct reactions induced by radioactive beams in inverse kinematics is described here . the transfer and inelastic all - angle reaction array ( tiara ) consists of 8 resistive charge division detectors forming an octagonal barrel around the target and a set of double - sided silicon - strip annular detectors positioned at each end of the barrel . the detector was coupled to the @xmath1-ray array exogam and the spectrometer vamos at the ganil laboratory to demonstrate the potential of such an apparatus with radioactive beams . the @xmath2n(d , p)@xmath3n reaction , well known in direct kinematics , has been carried out in inverse kinematics for that purpose . the observation of the @xmath3n ground state and excited states at 7.16 and 7.86 mev is presented here as well as the comparison of the measured proton angular distributions with dwba calculations . transferred _ l_-values are in very good agreement with both theoretical calculations and previous experimental results obtained in direct kinematics . position sensitive silicon detectors , nucleon transfer reactions , radioactive beams , inverse kinematics

1008.5395

in a recent paper miller - jones et al . ( 2010 , here after m2010 ) present a detail study of an outburst of the x - ray binary ( xrb ) aquila x-1 ( aql x-1 ) . aql x-1 is a binary system of a k7v star and a neutron star ( ns ) that experiences repeated outbursts . m2010 discuss the outburst properties in the context of the transition from the hard state to the soft state and back , and plot the evolution of aql x-1 on the hardness - intensity diagram ( hid ) commonly used for outbursts of accreting black hole ( bh ) . during the canonical hard state of a bh xrb outburst , a steady optically thick compact jet is expected . during the hard to soft state transition ( and sometimes back the other way ) a major radio flare , brighter than the compact jet , occurs , and optically thin jet ejecta are often observed or inferred to be launched when the `` jet line '' is crossed ( e.g. , fender et al . 2009 ) . it is still not known whether the compact jet exist during the soft state . m2010 notice two significant differences between the outburst of aql x-1 and outbursts of bhs . these are the flat radio spectrum between 5 and 8 ghz , and the absence of bright , optically thin , relativistically moving knots . a major radio outburst is observed to occur during the hard - soft transition in the outburst of aql x-1 . however , during this transition , its spectrum is flat and no jet ejecta are seen . g2010 argue that during this transition only the compact jet is being observed . the presence of a compact jet in this transition may or may not be consistent with bh xrbs . it is the lack of transient , optically thin jet emission in this transition that is different from other bh xrb outbursts . in light of these differences and some similarity with solar flares , i speculate on an alternative interpretation to the radio and soft x - ray emissions ( but not to the hard x - ray emission preceding these two ) based on magnetic flares . the alternative interpretation of magnetic activity was discussed for an accreting white dwarf by soker & vrtilek ( 2009 ) . soker & vrtilek ( 2009 ) suggested that the radio emission from an outburst of the dwarf nova ss cyg reported by krding et al . ( 2008 ) originated from magnetic activity that formed a corona similar to coronae found in magnetically active stars , rather than from jets . soker & vrtilek ( 2009 ) based their claim on the results of laor & behar ( 2008 ; hereafter lb2008 ) , who found that when the ratio between radio and x - ray fluxes of accretion disks in radio - quiet quasars is as in active stars , @xmath0 , then most of the radio emission might come from coronae . in lb2008 , the radio luminosity is @xmath1 , usually at around 6 cm , while @xmath2 is the integrated x - ray luminosity in the range @xmath3 . jets might still occur . if the magnetic activity in erupting accreting disks is similar to that in active stars , then mass ejection , is expected . the presence of coronae above accretion disks ( e.g. , galeev et al . 1979 ; done & osborne 1997 ; wheatley & mauche 2005 ) , and the connection between coronae and jets ( e.g. , fender et al . 1999 ; markoff et al . 2005 ; rodriguez & prat 2008 ) has already been proposed . however , the results of ishida et al . ( 2009 ; also lb2008 ) put the presence of coronae in accretion disks on a solid ground , and further suggest that magnetic activity similar to that in active stars occur in these coronae . the speculative interpretation in the present letter ( section [ sec : flare ] ) is based on three properties of the november 2009 outburst of aql x-1 ( m2010 ) . i emphasize that i do not propose an alternative explanation to the hard ( @xmath4 ) x - ray peak , and in any case postpone its detail study for a future paper . in x - ray transients the hard x - ray peak can generally be accounted for by a disk instability as studied by dubus et al . ( 2001 ) . in the present case , the hard x - ray peak has a triangular shape ( see definition in chen et al . 1997 ) for @xmath5d . the radio peak appears during the decay phase of the hard x - ray emission . the soft ( rxte asm ; @xmath6 ) x - ray emission appears with the hard x - ray emission , but its large and rapid rise starts only after the radio peak ( see below ) . the two peaks , one in the hard x - ray followed by one in the soft x - ray , can be seen for another flare of aql x-1 in yu et al . ( 2003 ) , but they do not have radio observations . the two x - ray peaks do not resemble at all the secondary peaks discussed for x - ray novae by chen et al . ( 1997 ) , and must be explained by a different process . among xrb systems the double peak structure of the outburst is common , like xte j1859 + 226 ( brocksopp et al . 2002 ) in which the radio peak occurs at the start of the extended soft x - ray peak ; the hard x - ray peak occurs before the peaks of the radio and of the soft x - ray emissions ( brocksopp et al . such a structure is seen in solar flares as well . in the magnetic flare model the hard x - ray peak is related to the event that rapidly amplifies the magnetic field . this field later powers the radio and soft x - ray emissions . the appearance of the hard x - ray and soft x - ray peaks one after the other is quite similar to that seen in bh xrb systems , but it is not at all similar to the delay in rise to maximum between the optical and extreme uv and x - ray emissions in dwarf novae ( mauche et al . 2001 ; wheatley et al . 2003 ) . in aql the two peaks are separated , while in dwarf novae their behavior with time is more or less similar , with a relatively short delay . the disk instability can account for the delay in dwarf novae ( schreiber et al . 2003 ) , but here a different explanation is required . many solar flares , as well as of similar stars such as uv ceti ( gdel et al . 1996 ) , show the neupert effect ( neupert 1968 ) . this effect is a behavior where the integration of the radio flux ( and in many cases the non - thermal hard x - ray emission ) is proportional to the x - ray flux at rise . in some cases , the radio peak comes at the beginning of the x - ray rise . in figure [ fig : flare ] , i compare the behavior of one specific solar flare as compiled by gdel et al . ( 1996 ; more detail in cliver et al . 1986 , dennis & zarro 1993 , and benz & gdel 1994 ) , with the november 2009 outburst of aql x-1 ( m2010 ) in radio and soft x - ray emissions . the solar flare is a gradual hard x - ray burst ( ghb ) of april 26 , 1981 ( cliver et al . 1986 ) . in many cases ghbs are preceded by coronal mass ejection and with a hard x - ray peak . the flux units are in relative units , while each time unit is 1 hour for the solar flare , and 7.1 weeks for aql x-1 . namely , a ratio of 170 in the time scale . radio fluxes are in thin lines and x - ray fluxes are in thick lines . aql x-1 is depicted by a blue dashed line , while the solar flare is shown with a red solid line . note that the aql x-1 radio intensity was multiplied by 600 , as the ratio @xmath7 is @xmath8 times weaker in aql x-1 as in the solar flare that is shown . + 3.5 cm ) fluxes in relative units of aquila x-1 november 2009 outburst ( from m2010 ; blue dashed line ) , and a solar flare from april 26 , 1981 as compiled by gdel et al . ( 1996 ; red solid line ; @xmath9 ) . for aql x-1 there are three radio segments , where the left one is only an upper limit . the ratio of radio to x - ray in aql x-1 is @xmath8 times smaller than that in the solar flare . in the plot , the aql x-1 radio flux was multiplied by 600 . each time unit is one hour for the solar flare and 7.1 days for aql x-1 . , title="fig : " ] i note the following similarities between the bursts in these two vastly different systems : 1 . the general shape of the radio ( 3.6 cm-6 cm ) and the soft ( @xmath6 ) x - ray emissions is similar , with a ratio of @xmath10 in time scale between the two systems . the beginning of the soft x - ray emission appears before the radio . part of this early rise might be a contribution from the hard x - ray component . however , from the different behavior of the two components , some of the early rise is part of the soft x - ray component itself . however , the steep rise in x - ray flux comes only after the radio peak . the rise to maximum in radio flux is slightly faster than the decline . 5 . in the 1981 april 26 solar ghb there is a hard x - ray peak preceding the radio peak ( fig . 1 in cliver et al . 1986 ; fig . 7 in dennis & zarro 1993 ) . this is similar to the hard x - ray peak preceding the radio peak in aql x-1 . however , i do not claim the same explanation for the hard x - ray peaks in the two systems . i only claim that the hard x - ray emission is connected to the process that powers the radio and soft x - ray peaks that follow . there is a weaker second radio peak in the light curve of aql x-1 . the popular accretion disc - radio jet paradigm ( the spectral state transition paradigm ) predicts reflaring in radio as the source hardens . the magnetic flare interpretation proposed here , on the other hand , requires the presence of a second flare . indeed , the small radio peak precedes a major x - ray flare that has its x - ray peak 24 days after the second radio peak ( swift / bat hard x - ray transient monitor home - page ) . it is possible that a larger radio peak was presence closer to the second x - ray peak , but no radio data exit . consecutive flares are seen in stars . the january 7 1995 flare c of uv ceti occurred during the decline of flare b ( gdel et al . 1996 ) . the radio peak of flare c was stronger than that in flare b , but its x - ray emission was much weaker . lb2008 present a correlation between the radio and soft x - ray luminosities @xmath11 , that holds over 20 orders of magnitude , excluding some systems , e.g. , the sun , galactic bh xrbs , and radio loud quasars . in some cases this ratio is as low as @xmath12 , in particular in weak solar flares ( micro - flares ; benz & gdel 1994 ) and in galactic bh xrbs . lb2008 raised the possibility that the lower @xmath7 in bh xrbs is due to the higher temperature of their disk . if this is indeed the case , it strengthens the connection between the flaring systems proposed here . in the november 2009 outburst of aql x-1 this ratio was @xmath13 . at the radio peak the x - ray luminosity was lower , and this ratio was @xmath14 . this is similar to weak solar flares . in the solar flare from april 26 , 1981 this ratio is @xmath15 ( the total energy in the radio is six orders of magnitude below that in the x - ray ) . we note that the ratio in solar flares is mainly obtained with the soft x - ray flux @xmath16 ( e.g. , gdel et al . 1996 ) . taking the @xmath17 range for the solar flare , will reduce the @xmath7 ratio only by a factor of 2 . the fluxes for aql x-1 is taken for the @xmath18 band ( m2010 ) , which is somewhat narrower than the band used by lb2008 ( @xmath3 ) . for the spectra of these sources this does not make a significant difference , as emission peaks around a few kev . in accretion onto compact objects some x - ray emission comes from shocked gas , a process that does not exist in the sun . over all , the ratio @xmath19 in the november 2009 outburst of aql x-1 falls within the range of weak solar flares and bh xrbs too . m2010 attribute the flat radio spectrum to an optically thick compact jet . however , in bh xrb outbursts , the radio emission after a major radio flare is dominated by optically thin jet ejecta , and there is currently no evidence that the compact jet remains on . for the november 2009 outburst m2010 find ( near 8 ghz ) @xmath20 . the weighted vla data yields @xmath21 . both measurements would need to be off by 3 sigma to be consistent with @xmath22 ( as in optically thin jet ejecta ) . according to m2010 , this is not compatible with internal shocks in jets . it thus seems that a magnetic flare can account for this radio spectrum . kundu et al . ( 2009 ) , for example , find for the magnetic looptop in a solar flare @xmath23 near 8 ghz . although xrb systems might show different behaviors ( e.g. , agrawal & misra 2009 ) , in general xrb emission can be well fitted by a combination of a soft component composed of a multi - color disc blackbody and a hard component of a power - law or comptonized single temperature ( e.g. , maitra & bailyn 2004;gou et al 2009 ) . stellar ( including solar ) flares can be fitted by emission from thin plasma ( coronal emission ) , e.g. , battaglia et al . the x - ray spectra of stellar flares , therefore , are not similar to those of xrb systems . but they do not need to be identical in the proposed model . lb2008 note the different x - ray spectra of agn and stellar flares . they argue that the cooling mechanism of the hot gas formed by the magnetic activity is different . while in stellar flares the cooling is by thermal emission from optically thin plasma , in agn the cooling is comptonization of the optical - uv disk continuum by hot thermal gas ( @xmath24 ) . still , lb2008 argue , in both types of systems the hot plasma is formed by magnetic activity . as for xrb systems discussed here , it is possible that the hot gas is cooling by heating the disk . for example , the hot electrons formed in the magnetic reconnection process stream down along magnetic field lines anchored to the disk . this will increase the black body emission from the disk . in addition , some contribution from optically thin plasma ( as in stellar flares ) is expected . these processes are the subject of a future paper . in particular two processes will be studied : the formation of the very hot gas by magnetic activity in the flaring region , and heat conduction from that region to the disk . after all , this chain of event is what is behind the neupert effect : hot electrons heat ( and evaporate ) the chromosphere . this future study will have to examine where the heat conduction in the environment of accretion disks can indeed heat the disk to increase its blackbody radiation . the three properties discussed in section [ sec : flare ] hint that the behavior of the soft x - ray and radio emissions in the november 2009 outburst of the xrb aql x-1 , were similar to gradual hard x - ray bursts ( ghbs ) in the sun and similar stars , e.g. , uv ceti ( gdel et al . the strongest of these properties is the similar light curve in hard x - ray , soft x - ray , and radio emissions . the similarity in the radio and soft x - ray light curves is shown in figure [ fig : flare ] . the hard x - ray peak in aql x-1 can be attributed to the disk instability ( dubus et al . 2001 ) . it is the behavior of the soft x - ray and radio emissions that i try to explain in this letter . the typical size of the soft x - ray loop of solar ghbs is @xmath25 ( see fig . 10 in cliver et al . if we use a very simple scaling from the solar flare , the duration of the aql x-1 , which is @xmath26 times as long as a solar flare , implies a reconnection size that is @xmath26 times as large , or @xmath27 . interestingly , the orbital separation in aql x-1 is @xmath28 ; for an orbital period of 19 h ( chevalier & ilovaisky 1991 ) and a total mass of @xmath29 ( welsh et al . 2000 ) . namely , the magnetic field reconnection event occurs over a size about equal to the binary separation , which is just a little larger than the disk size . i propose that a disk instability triggered the formation of an extended corona around the accretion disk , on a size about equal to the binary separation . this is the event seen in the hard x - ray of aql x-1 by m2010 that preceded both the radio and soft x - ray fluxes . then , a major magnetic flaring ( reconnection and other means of magnetic energy release ) occurred . such a magnetic flare can accelerate gas and lead to the formation of a jet . the total energy emitted in the soft x - ray in the flare is @xmath30 . taking the total volume occupied by the reconnecting magnetic fields to be @xmath31 , the required average magnetic field intensity is @xmath32 g. this is not unreasonable . active stars with a similar size of @xmath33 have magnetic fields of @xmath34 g. the magnetic field of the ap star hd 137509 , for example , reaches values of @xmath35 g ( mathys 1995 ) . the magnetic field comes from a disk dynamo , which should be a major issue to be studied in the future . encouraging are also some similarities of the properties mentioned in this paper to strong and long x - ray flares of young stars characterized by having active or inactive accretion disks around them . favata et al . ( 2005 ) observed the orion nebula cluster with _ chandra _ , and analyzed flares from young stars with such disks around them . some flares last for up to 5 days . the structure favata et al . ( 2005 ) infer is of large and long , @xmath36 , magnetic structures . a large and long magnetic loop can be behind the outburst of aql x-1 in the proposed model . the total energy in the strong flares studied by favata et al . ( 2005 ) is @xmath37 . this is @xmath38 times that in the flare of aql x-1 . the six ( out of 32 ) brightest flares have luminosities in the range of @xmath39 , or @xmath40 times that of the outburst of aql x-1 . this ratio is of the same order of magnitude as the ratio of the gravitational potential wells in the two types of objects some points must be clarified before the speculative interpretation suggested here can gain more credibility . ( 1 ) it should be shown that a reconnection event ( or several events ) can account for the high luminosity in the x - ray ( up to @xmath41 ) . ( 2 ) there is a need to compare not only the observed properties , but also the physical processes . namely , lots of work has been done on solar flares and ghbs . it will have to be shown that similar processes can take place in an extended coronae of xrbs . the proposed magnetic flare explanation is a paradigm shift from the common interpretation of outburst in xrbs . this paradigm shift can be traced back to lb2008 who pointed out the similar radio to x - ray fluxes ratio in a variety of astronomical objects , including stellar flares and accreting super massive bhs in active galactic nuclei . i therefore suggest that the proposed magnetic flaring model holds for bh xrbs as well ( see also , e.g. , rodriguez & prat 2008 ) . basically , where we expect strong dynamo to operate , we should expect strong magnetic flares . accretion disks have very strong shear compared with stars , and they must have some kind of turbulence to supply the viscosity . as such , a strong dynamo exists in accretion disks . the large flares are expected to occur when the magnetic field energy is further amplified . such can be the case when the disk becomes unstable , and erupt . the outflowing gas stretches magnetic field lines and substantially amplifies the field . after this triggering eruption , the field lines reconnect and release the huge amount of magnetic energy . however , in some cases disk outbursts might not result in substantial magnetic field amplification , and no large magnetic flare will occur . if the similarity presented in this paper holds , it adds to previous suggestions on similarity between coronae in active stars and accretion disks ( lb2008 ) , and similarity in the processes of mass ejection by solar flares and the launching of jets from accretion disks powered by magnetic fields reconnection ( de gouveia dal pino & lazarian 2005 ; de gouveia dal pino et al . 2010 ; soker 2007 ) .

i point to an interesting similarity in the radio and the soft x - ray light curves between the november 2009 outburst of the x - ray binary aquila x-1 and some solar flares . the ratio of the soft x - ray and radio luminosities of aquila x-1 in that outburst is also similar to some weak solar flares , and so is the radio spectrum near 8 ghz . based on these , as well as on some other recent studies that point to some similar properties of accretion disk coronae and stellar flares , such as ratio of radio to x - ray luminosities ( laor & behar 2008 ) , i speculate that the soft x - ray outburst of aquila x-1 was related to a huge magnetic flare from its disk corona .

0711.2297

after the well known leading paper by morris and thorne @xcite , considerable attention has been devoted to the study of traversable lorentzian wormholes @xcite . such kind of geometries would connect two regions of the same universe , or of two universes , by a traversable throat . if they actually exist , they would present some features of particular interest as , for example , the possibility of using them for time travel @xcite . however , the flare - out condition @xcite to be satisfied at the throat requires the presence of exotic matter , that is , matter which violates the null energy condition ( nec ) @xcite . however , it was shown in ref . @xcite that the amount of exotic matter necessary for the existence of a wormhole can be made infinitesimally small by suitably choosing the geometry . after this , special attention has been devoted to quantifying the amount of exotic matter @xcite ; in particular , this amount has been pointed as an indicator of the physical viability of a traversable wormhole @xcite . besides , for a wormhole to be considered traversable , the geometry must be such that the magnitude of tidal forces are admissible for an hypothetic traveller ; this has also been analyzed for most physically meaningful configurations studied in the literature . of course , no unstable solution of the equations of gravitation could be of interest as a candidate for a traversable wormhole . thus , besides the characterization of static solutions , their stability under perturbations must always be explored . in particular , this has been thoroughly studied for the case of small perturbations preserving the symmetry of the original configuration . a class of wormholes for which poisson and visser @xcite developed a straightforward approach for analyzing this aspect are thin - shell ones , that is , wormholes which are mathematically constructed by cutting and pasting two manifolds to obtain a geodesically complete new manifold @xcite . in these wormhole configurations the exotic matter lies in a shell placed at the joining surface ; so the theoretical framework for dealing with them is the darmois israel formalism , which leads to the lanczos equations , that is , the einstein s equations projected on the joining surface @xcite . once an equation of state for the exotic matter in the shell is provided , the solution of the lanczos equations gives the dynamical evolution of the wormhole . such a procedure has been subsequently followed to study the stability of more general spherically symmetric configurations ( see , for example , refs . @xcite ) . according to present day theoretical developments , a scenario in which the fundamental building blocks of nature are extended objects instead of point objects should be considered quite seriously . in particular , 1dimensional objects ( strings ) are the most popular candidate for such fundamental objects . the study of the gravitational effects of matter in the form of clouds of both cosmic and fundamental strings has then deserved considerable attention ; see for example refs . we are interested in the viability of wormholes ; so within this framework any reasonable configuration including more parameters and thus allowing for improving its features as : amount of exotic matter , pressure , traversability and stability , deserves to be analyzed . in the present work we start from the metric proposed in the leading paper by letelier @xcite to address the study of thin - shell wormholes associated to a string cloud ( and also a global monopole ; see below ) . we study in detail the amount of exotic matter required for the construction , the traversability and also the stability of the configuration under perturbations preserving the original symmetry . as we shall see , comparing with the schwarzschild case , the string cloud allows for more freedom in the choice of the configurations to be stable , and also allows to reduce the amount of exotic matter without increasing the pressure . because recently certain attention was devoted to exotic matter fulfilling the chaplygin gas equation of state , in appendix a we explicitly impose it on the shell matter to obtain its time evolution beyond a perturbative approach . in appendix b we discuss a possible extension of the analysis to a related geometry . throughout the paper we set units so that @xmath0 . the action of a string evolving in spacetime is given by @xmath1 where @xmath2 is a constant characterizing each string , @xmath3 , @xmath4 are a timelike and a spacelike parameter , and @xmath5 is the determinant of the induced metric on the string world sheet : @xmath6 introducing the bivector @xmath7 with @xmath8 the two - dimensional levi civita symbol , the lagrangian density @xmath9 can be put as @xmath10 with this notation , a cloud of strings is described by the energy - momentum tensor @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the proper density of the cloud . the quantity @xmath13 is gauge invariant , and is called the _ gauge invariant density _ of the cloud @xcite . in the case of a static spherically symmetric cloud , we have @xmath14 with @xmath15 a positive constant . the general solution to einstein s equations for a string cloud with spherical symmetry in ( 3 + 1)-dimensional spacetime , that is with density given by ( [ rho0 ] ) , takes the form @xcite @xmath16 where @xmath17 this metric represents the spacetime associated with a spherical mass @xmath18 centered at the origin of the system of coordinates , surrounded by a spherical cloud of strings . besides , it can also be understood as the metric associated to a global monopole , which increases the interest of starting from it to construct a wormhole ( for the details see refs . @xcite , and for a related work involving a traversable wormhole see ref . the event horizon of this metric is placed at @xmath19 where @xmath20 . if @xmath15 is less than unity we have that the cloud of strings enlarges the schwarzschild radius of the mass by the factor @xmath21 . when @xmath22 the metric represents a homogenous spacetime . the cloud of strings alone @xmath23 does not have horizon ; it only presents a naked singularity at @xmath24 . in fig . 1 we show where the event horizon is located and how this changes with the parameter @xmath15 . when @xmath25 we recover the schwarzschild radius and for @xmath15 close to unity the event horizon radius tends to infinity . is shown . we can see how the position of the event horizon changes when the parameter @xmath15 varies within the range @xmath26,height=377 ] now we build a spherically symmetric thin - shell wormhole starting from the generic geometry ( [ 1 ] ) ( see fig . we take two copies of the string cloud spacetime and remove from each manifold the four - dimensional regions described by @xmath27 the resulting manifolds have boundaries given by the timelike hypersurfaces @xmath28 then we paste or identify these two timelike hypersurfaces to obtain a geodesically complete new manifold @xmath29 with a matter shell at the surface @xmath30 , where the throat of the wormhole is located . this manifold is constituted by two asymptotically _ locally _ flat regions connected by a traversable lorentzian wormhole . and @xmath31 , for @xmath32 when @xmath25 . after the boundaries are identified we get a geodesically complete new manifold with a matter shell at @xmath30.,height=302 ] to study this class of wormhole we use the standard darmois israel formalism @xcite . the wormhole throat is placed at the surface @xmath33 . this is a synchronous timelike hypersurface . we can introduce coordinates @xmath34 in @xmath33 , with @xmath35 the proper time on the throat . in order to be able to perform a quite general analysis ( for example , to study the mechanical stability of the configuration ; see below ) , we allow the radius of the throat be a function of the proper time , @xmath36 . this is strictly right because the existence of a generalized birkhoff theorem for the string cloud @xcite ensures that the metric of the embedding remains the same independently of the motion of the throat , as long as the spherical symmetry is preserved . so , the boundary hypersurface reads : @xmath37 the second fundamental form ( extrinsic curvature ) at the two sides of the throat is given by @xmath38 where @xmath39 are the unit normals ( @xmath40 ) to the surface @xmath33 in @xmath29 . defining the jump in the extrinsic curvature as @xmath41={k}^{+}_{il}-{k}^{-}_{il}$ ] and its trace as @xmath42)$ ] we obtain the so - called lanczos equations : @xmath43+{k}g_{il}=8\pi{s_{il}}\ ] ] where @xmath44 is the surface stress - energy tensor of the shell placed at the throat . the non vanishing components of the extrinsic curvature are : @xmath45 @xmath46 where the dot means derivation with respect to the proper time @xmath35 , and a prime stands for a derivative with respect to @xmath47 . then , from eqs . ( 8) , ( 9 ) and ( 10 ) we get a formal expression for the pressure @xmath48 and the energy density @xmath49 in terms of @xmath50 , first and second derivatives of @xmath50 , and the function @xmath51 which depends on the parameters of the system @xmath52 : @xmath53 @xmath54 where the prime means derivation with respect to @xmath47 . as it was to be expected , the energy density is negative , indicating the existence of exotic matter at the shell . we shall focus on this aspect of the wormhole in the next section . it is easy to see from eqs . ( 11 ) and ( 12 ) that the energy conservation equation is fulfilled : @xmath55 where @xmath56 is the area of the wormhole throat . the first term in eq . ( 13 ) represents the internal energy change of the shell and the second the work by internal forces of the shell . the dynamical evolution of the wormhole throat is governed by the lanczos equations and to close the system we must supply an equation of state @xmath57 that relates @xmath58 and @xmath59 . in section 4 we shall develop this point in a perturbative approach , while in the appendix we shall obtain the dynamical evolution of the throat for a particular equation of state . many authors ( see for instance refs . @xcite ) have proposed to quantify the amount of exotic matter as a way to characterize the viability of a traversable wormhole . here we shall analyze the energy conditions and evaluate the total amount of exotic matter for the wormholes built in section 2 , in the case of static configurations , i.e. , @xmath60 . in this case , the energy density and pressure are @xmath61 @xmath62 the _ weak energy condition _ ( wec ) states that for any timelike vector @xmath63 it must be @xmath64 ; the wec also implies , by continuity , the _ null energy condition _ ( nec ) , which means that for any null vector @xmath65 it mus be @xmath66 @xcite . in an orthonormal basis the wec reads @xmath67 , @xmath68 , while the nec takes the form @xmath69 . in the case of the wormhole constructed in section 2 we have that the radial pressure is zero , @xmath70 , and the energy density verifies @xmath71 , so that both energy conditions are violated . the transverse pressure is @xmath72 and the sign of @xmath73 is not fixed by this conditions , but it depends on the values of the parameters of the system . there have been several proposals for quantifying the amount of exotic matter in wormholes . in order to allow for an immediate comparison with the results of other works , we shall adopt the most usual choice , which is the integral over space including the pressure associated to the violation of the energy conditions : @xmath74 where @xmath75 is the determinant of the metric tensor . the advantages of this quantifier , compared with others including other measures as @xmath76 or @xmath77 , have been carefully discussed in @xcite . besides , this choice is consistent with previous proposals for covariant conservation laws in general relativity ( see @xcite ) . we introduce a new radial coordinate @xmath78 with @xmath79 corresponding to each side of the shell . in our construction the shell does not exert radial pressure , and the energy density is located on the surface so the energy density can then be written as @xmath80 . this yields the following formula for the amount of exotic matter : @xmath81 replacing the explicit form of @xmath82 we obtain the exotic matter amount as a function of the parameters ( @xmath83 ) that characterize the configurations : @xmath84 the amount of exotic matter is thus always smaller than in the schwarzschild case @xmath25 . in fig . 3 we show @xmath85 as a fuction of @xmath86 for different values of @xmath15 . note that for @xmath87 the amount @xmath88 becomes linear in @xmath89 : @xmath90 . , for given values of the parameter @xmath15.,height=377 ] a natural question is which conditions allow to reduce @xmath91 . since @xmath92 and @xmath93 as @xmath94 , we shall investige this limit more carefully . for @xmath95 near the event horizon @xmath96 , the transverse pressure and the surface density energy behave as @xmath97,\ ] ] @xmath98,\ ] ] where @xmath99 . then , when we take the limit @xmath94 the surface energy density goes to zero but the transerve pressure tends to infinity ( see ref . @xcite for a similar behaviour ) . we can also consider the case when the wormhole radius @xmath100 is fixed and fulfils @xmath101 , and the exotic matter amount is taken as a function of the parameter @xmath102 . in this case @xmath91 can be reduced by increasing the value of the parameter @xmath15 ( see fig . 4 ) , while the energy density and the pressure remain under control ( see figs . 5 and 6 ) : in this limit we have @xmath103 where the second term is kept finite even if @xmath104 precisely because the condition @xmath101 implies @xmath105 . in fact , under these conditions the amount of exotic matter can be reduced without increasing the pressure , which constitutes a remarkable feature for a wormhole construction ( in the pure schwarzschild case and in the same limit @xmath101 , the amount @xmath88 can only be reduced by reducing @xmath100 , which leads to an increase of the pressure ) . this is shown in figs . 5 and 6 . a possible way to define the traversability of a lorentzian wormhole is to compare the relative aceleration ( proportional to the tidal force ) between to parts of a traveller , with the magnitude of the earth surface gravity . we start from the expression of the four - velocity of a traveller falling towards the throat straight in the radial direction ( that is with zero angular momentum ) @xmath106 where @xmath107 is its energy at infinity ( basically its rest mass ) . then from the definition of the geodesic deviation we calculate the covariant relative acceleration between two parts of the traveller separated by a distance @xmath108 in the radial direction : @xmath109 where @xmath110 is the proper time of the traveller . from this expression it can easily be shown that a choice of the parameters making the wormhole stable ( see the next section ) and also reducing the amount of exotic matter , can render it traversable . for example , this happens for @xmath111 and @xmath112 , which for a length of order one meter give a tidal acceleration which is about earth surface gravity . , with @xmath113 , for given values of @xmath95.,height=302 ] .,height=302 ] .,height=302 ] a physically interesting wormhole geometry should last enough so that its traversability makes sense . thus the stability of a given wormhole configuration becomes a central aspect of its study . here we shall analyze the stability under small perturbations preserving the spherical symmetry of the configuration ; for this we shall proceed as poisson and visser in ref . @xcite . as we said , the dynamical evolution is determined by eqs . ( 11 ) and ( 12 ) , or by any of them and eq . ( 13 ) , and to complete the system we must add an equation of state that relates @xmath58 with @xmath114 , i.e , @xmath57 . by introducing the explicit form of the metric in eq . ( 11 ) we have @xmath115^{2}=a-1.\ ] ] to obtain @xmath116 we first note that the energy conservation equation can be written as @xmath117 which can be integrated to give @xmath118 from eq . ( 26 ) , if the equation of state @xmath57 is given , one can obtain @xmath116 . following the procedure introduced by poisson and visser , the analysis of the stability of the configuration can be reduced to the analogous problem of the stability of a particle in a one dimensional potential @xmath119 . this is easy to see if we write eq . ( 24 ) as @xmath120 with @xmath121^{2}+1-a.\ ] ] ( we can verify the procedure by setting @xmath25 and see that we recover the results of ref . so , to study the stability we expand up to second order the potential @xmath119 around the static solution @xmath95 ( for which @xmath122 ) . as we expect , for a stable configuration it is @xmath123 and @xmath124 , where the prime means a derivative with respect to @xmath125 . then , eq . ( 27 ) takes the following form : @xmath126.\ ] ] to compute the derivates it is convenient to define the parameter @xmath127 which for ordinary matter would represent the squared speed of sound : @xmath128 . for now , however , we simply considerer @xmath129 as a useful parameter related with the equation of state ( see below ) . then , we obtain the second derivative of the potencial for the metric ( 1 ) : @xmath130,\ ] ] where @xmath131 . the wormhole is stable if and only if @xmath132 while for @xmath133 a radial perturbation grows ( at least until nonlinear regime is reached ) and the wormhole is unstable . because the function @xmath134 is always positive for @xmath135 , we only have to analyze the sign of the bracket in eq . ( 31 ) for determining which are the values of the parameters @xmath136 that make the wormhole stable . then , after some simple manipulations , the stability conditions can be written as follows : @xmath137 , \\ b_{0 } & < 3m/(1-a ) \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \mathrm{if } & \eta_{0 } > -[(1-a)^{2}-3m(1-a)/b_{0 } + 3m^{2}/b^{2}_{0 } ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] to get a good insight of the stability regions , we draw the curve @xmath138 in the plane @xmath139 for different values of the parameter @xmath15 ( see fig . we can identify the regions of stability as follows : in the case of @xmath25 , for @xmath140 the region of stability lies under the curve , but for @xmath141 the stability region is placed above the curve showed in fig . 7 ( we can also see that when @xmath25 we recover the results by poisson and visser ) . then , for values of @xmath142 the shape of the regions of stability remains the same of the case @xmath25 , but their locations are shifted as the event horizon changes with the parameter @xmath15 . we find that when @xmath15 is increased , the regions of stability , though shifted away , become considerably enlarged . is shown.,width=566,height=415 ] we observe from these plots that the stability of the wormhole configuration demands that the parameter @xmath143 of the exotic matter at the shell is , when positive , greater than unity ( see , however , the same analysis for a related model in appendix b ) . it is clearly not easy to interprete @xmath144 as a kind of velocity of propagating waves at the shell . furthermore , from the regions of stability obtained , we conclude that traversable wormholes with radii @xmath145 could be stable , under perturbations that preserve the spherical symmetry , only if the parameter @xmath146 is negative . however , it was pointed out by visser and poisson that the interpretation of @xmath147 as the speed of sound would require an understanding of the microphysics of exotic matter , which is not available by now . we have built traversable thin - shell wormholes applying the cut and paste procedure to the geometry corresponding to a spherical cloud of strings . we have found that the amount of exotic matter which is restricted to the throat can be reduced by a suitable choice of the parameters . moreover , we have shown that for a fixed wormhole radius @xmath101 , there exists a range of values of the parameter @xmath15 such that , while the amount of exotic matter can be reduced , the transverse pressure and the surface energy density can be kept under control . we have also studied the stability of the configuration under perturbations preserving the spherical symmetry , and we have found that the stability regions though shifted away become enlarged when the parameter @xmath15 is increased . within the characterization of static configurations , we have considered the traversability of large wormholes by evaluating the tidal force ; we have found that it turns to be acceptable in the case of values of @xmath15 and @xmath100 such that the wormhole is stable . besides , in the appendix a ( see below ) we briefly study the dynamics of the shell beyond the perturbative approach by considering the particular case of the chaplygin equation of state for the shell matter . also , the features of a related wormhole configuration are discussed in the appendix b. the authors want to thank lvaro corvaln for useful comments on differential equations , and ernesto eiroa for helpful discussions . this work was supported by universidad de buenos aires and conicet . as noted above , it can be proved that there exists a generalized birkhoff theorem for the string cloud , so the geometry exhibited in section 2 is the general solution for the case of spherical symmetry ; in particular , no gravitational waves are emitted . thus the time evolution can be obtained from eqs . ( 11 ) and ( 12 ) plus an equation of state relating the energy density and pressure of the exotic matter . here , we consider the special case of the chaplygin gas @xcite , i.e. a perfect fluid fulfilling @xmath148 where @xmath149 is a positive constant . a remarkable feature of the chaplygin gas model is that it has positive and bounded squared sound velocity : @xmath150 , which is not trivial for an exotic matter fluid . this model has been applied in cosmological models because it describes a smooth transition from a deccelerated expansion of the universe to the present epoch of cosmic acceleration and because it gives a unified macroscopic description of dark matter and dark energy @xcite . it has been recently proposed for supporting a class of thin - shell wormholes in ref . @xcite . ) and initial radius ( @xmath151 ) we show the relation between the ( scaled ) proper time @xmath152 and the wormhole radius in the case of the chaplygin equation of state . for large @xmath153 there is no sensible dependence with the parameter @xmath15 while in the case of small @xmath153 , the evolution exhibits some dependence with @xmath15 ; here we plot @xmath154 for @xmath155 . note the difference between the two plots in the scales of both axes.,width=585,height=264 ] if we take the eqs . ( 11 ) and ( 12 ) and replace them in eq . ( 34 ) , the equation for the wormhole radius @xmath125 can be written as : @xmath156 where we have defined dimensionless variables @xmath157 , @xmath158 and @xmath159 . in order to solve eq . ( 35 ) , we define the variable @xmath160 and multiply this equation by @xmath161 . so then , after integrating , we obtain a first order differential equation for the squared velocity : @xmath162 now , if we return to the variable @xmath153 , eq . ( 36 ) can be put in the following integral form : @xmath163 the solution of this integral has a closed expression in terms of elliptic functions of first and third kind . the general solution is parametrized by @xmath15 , so for simplicity we just exhibit a plot of the solution for large @xmath153 and for small @xmath153 ( see fig . of course , initial conditions are taken such that @xmath164 corresponds to an initial radius greater than the horizon radius of the original manifold . in the case of large @xmath153 , this approximation leads to study the dynamical equation of an anti - oscillator and the solution does not exhibit a dependence with the parameter @xmath15 . in the case of small @xmath153 , the solution has a smooth dependence with @xmath15 , and here we have solved the differential equation by taylor expanding up to fourth order about the initial radius @xmath151 . as can be seen from fig . 8 , a monotonic evolution is obtained . thus , differing from the results obtained with a linear equation of state ( section 4 ) , within this model no stable configurations would exist . this seems to be consistent with the results of @xcite , where it was shown that in the case of the chaplygin equation of state , stable configurations required a non vanishing charge or a cosmological constant , which , compared with the string cloud , represents a more considerable departure from the pure schwarzschild metric . an immediate extension of our analysis of sections 3 and 4 can be performed in the case of a perfect string fluid ( see @xcite and the first paper in ref . @xcite ) . such a model includes a non vanishing angular pressure such that the energy - momentum tensor of the fluid has the form @xmath165 . as a result of this , for @xmath166 the function @xmath51 in the metric ( 1 ) takes the form because it allows to reproduce the results of the schwarzchild de sitter and the reissner nordstrm thin - shell wormholes in the cases @xmath167 and @xmath168 respectively ( see the papers by lobo and crawford and by eiroa and romero , ref . @xcite ) ] @xmath169 where @xmath170 is a positive constant of dimension length , and @xmath171 denotes the sign of the energy density of the string fluid . , @xmath172 in the case of a perfect string fluid . four values of the parameter @xmath173 are considered . the stability regions are compared with those corresponding to the cloud of strings with @xmath111 ( gray line).,width=491,height=377 ] because the calculations are analogous to those above , we omit the details and give the results for @xmath174 ( we want to restric exotic matter to the shell ) and for @xmath170 of order @xmath175 . we compare the stability regions and the amount of exotic matter with the case of the string cloud with @xmath111 . as can be seen from figs . 9 and 10 , while certain values of @xmath173 allow to reduce the amount @xmath176 with respect to the string cloud case , the regions of stability for low values of @xmath173 are shifted towards the horizon and become smaller . however , lower values of the would be squared speed of sound become compatible with stability ; in particular , for large @xmath173 a numerical calculation shows that positive values of @xmath177 slightly smaller than unity are now possible . n. sen , ann . ( leipzig ) * 73 * , 365 ( 1924 ) ; k. lanczos , _ ibid . _ * 74 * , 518 ( 1924 ) ; g. darmois , mmorial des sciences mathmatiques , fascicule xxv ch v ( gauthier - villars , paris , 1927 ) ; w. israel , nuovo cimento * 44b * , 1 ( 1966 ) ; * 48b * , 463(e ) ( 1967 ) . e. f. eiroa and g. e. romero , gen . * 36 * , 651 ( 2004 ) ; f. s. n. lobo and p. crawford , class . quantum grav . * 21 * , 391 ( 2004 ) ; m. thibeault , c. simeone and e. f. eiroa , gen . . gravit . * 38 * , 1593 ( 2006 ) ; f. rahaman , m. kalam and s. chakraborty , gen . . gravit . * 38 * , 1687 ( 2006 ) . h. h. soleng , gen . * 27 * , 367 ( 1995 ) ; p. s. letelier and v. t. zanchin , phys . lett * a198 * , 79 ( 1995 ) ; m. nouri - zonoz , n. dadhich and d. lynden - bell , class . quantum grav . * 16 * , 1021 ( 1999 ) ; i. yilmaz , i. yavuz , h. baysal , i. tarhan and u. camci , int . j. mod d8 * , 659 ( 1999 ) ; h. baysal and i. yilmaz , class . quantum grav . * 19 * , 6435 ( 2002 ) .

we study spherically symmetric thin - shell wormholes in a string cloud background in ( 3 + 1)-dimensional spacetime . the amount of exotic matter required for the construction , the traversability and the stability under radial perturbations , are analyzed as functions of the parameters of the model . besides , in the appendices a non perturbative approach to the dynamics and a possible extension of the analysis to a related model are briefly discussed . .25 in

1512.06925

nearest neighbor search in very large databases is becoming increasingly important in machine learning , computer vision , pattern recognition , and multimedia retrieval along with many applications in document , image , audio , and video retrievals @xcite . however , it becomes difficult to efficiently store and search huge collections when the dataset size gets larger and larger ( e.g. millions or even billions ) . the idea of mapping real - valued vectors to compact codes @xcite provides a very attactive way to solve this problem . there have been many recent methods on developing hashing methods for compressing data to compact binary strings @xcite , or vector quantization based methods @xcite that compress data to compact codes . vector quantization ( vq ) was actively studied for source coding / signal compression under real - time constraints dating back to decades ago @xcite . recently , the problem of how to apply vq techniques to efficient approximate nearest neighbor ( ann ) search has attracted a lot of attension @xcite . while many structured vq models can be found @xcite , in this paper , we restrict our attention to product quantization ( pq ) and residual quantization ( rq ) , which both have been successfully applied to fast nearest neighbor search @xcite . product quantization works by grouping the feature dimensions into groups , and performs quantization to each feature group . in particular , it performs a @xmath0-means clustering to each group to obtain sub - codebooks , and the global quantization codebook is generated by the cartesian products of all the small sub - codebooks . in this way , it can generate a huge number of landmark points in the space , which guarantees low quantization error ; it has achieved state of the art performance on approximate nearest neighbor search @xcite , and can also provide a compact representation to the vectors . inspired by the success of pq , some latest works have extended pq to a more general model by finding an optimized space - decomposition to minimize its overall distortion @xcite . a very recent work @xcite has deployed this optimized pq within residual clusters . while it maximizes the strength of locality , it also uses extra space for multiple transformations as well as pq codebooks . different from pq , rq works by performing quantization to the whole feature space , and then recursively apply vq models to the residuals of the previous quantization level , which is a stacked quantization model . in particular , it performs a @xmath0-means clustering to the original feature vectors , and construct @xmath0 clusters . for points in each cluster , it computes the residuals between points and the cluster centers . in the next level , it aggregates all the residual vectors for all points , and performs another clustering to these residual vectors . this process is recursively applied ( stacked ) for several levels . in this way , rq produces sequential - product codebooks . a comprehensive survey of earlier rq models can be found in barnes et al . recent works have shown the effectiveness of rq to perform both indexing @xcite and data compression @xcite tasks in ann search problems . however , it has been observed that the effectiveness of rq might be limited to a very small number of levels @xcite , and the randomness of residual vectors increases very quickly when we stack more and more rq layers . this results in increasingly noisy residual vectors of each level , and effective quantization at higher rq levels becomes more difficult . in other words , the layer - wise learning in rq models provides suboptimal sub - codebooks in that each sub - codebook is learned without consideration to subsequent layers . thence several global optimization approaches have been proposed by jointly learning sub - codebooks over all layers @xcite . different from seeking out joint optimization solutions , we here look for specific transformations to each of the residual clusters to make the resulting vectors more aligned , in order to directly address the problem of cluster misalginment and noise increase over each level after the first and improve overall quantization accordingly . to this end , we propose a novel approach to optimizing the rq model that is motivated by the noise and shape in the residual space , as shown in figure [ figure : orq - example ] . we find that the residual vectors for each cluster have significantly different directions , which make quantization at the next level much harder . a natural idea is to align these residual vectors for each cluster , which can potentially reduce quantization error in the next level . thus , we propose to learn one rotation matrix for each residual cluster , and use them to align the residual vectors in each cluster , so as to reduce the global quantization error . then we alternate between learning rotation matrices and the residual quantization to minimize its distortion , which is mainly inspired by `` iterative quantization ( itq ) '' @xcite ; very recently itq has been successfully applied to the pq models @xcite . different from itq and the optimized pq ( opq ) , which learn a global rotation , both ours and the locally optimized pq ( lopq ) @xcite learn one projection matrix per residual cluster . in stead of independent learning in lopq , however , all local transformations in our method are learned associatively with a shared codebook . in this way , we successfully reduce the memory overheads about codebook usage in lopq . this offers a great flexibility to use reasonable larger codebooks in potential . we have found that by doing this iterative alignment and quantization , we can achieve significantly smaller quantization error than both vanilla rq and opq methods . in addition , we also propose a hybrid ann search method which is based on the proposed trq and pq . experimental results on several large - scale datasets have clearly demonstrated the effectiveness of our proposed methods , in particular have shown that the extra transformations only introduced very limited computation overheads when integrated with advanced indexing structures , e.g. the inverted mutli - index @xcite . therefore , our method is able to achieve very significant gain over other state of the art methods in terms of trade - off among memory usage , search quality and speed . in this section , we review related background on two types of structured vector quantization , i.e. product quantization and residual quantization . to accurately quantize large number of points in a high dimensional space , we need a large number of landmark points ( or centroids ) . for example , if we use the @xmath0-means clustering method to find such quantizers , when the number of cluster centers @xmath0 becomes huge ( e.g. millions or even more ) , performing @xmath0-means becomes prohibitively expensive . structured vector quantization make special assumptions about the data distribution , and try to explore such structure to generate large number of landmark points to increase the quantization accurateness @xcite . pq and rq are two structured vq families with different assumptions about data distribution . we here present discussions on structural codebook constructions and objective function formulations of the related vq models following a brief introduction of the unstructured vq . vector quantization ( vq a.k.a . @xmath0-means ) without any structure constraints is probably one of the most widely used vector quantization method . given a dataset @xmath1 , vq is a mapping : @xmath2 where @xmath3 is a quantizer and @xmath4 is a _ centroid _ or a _ center _ from the codebook @xmath5 . according to lloyd s optimality conditions , an optimal quantizer satisfies the nearest neighbor condition : @xmath6 here @xmath7 is the distance between two vectors and euclidean distance is used in this paper . for each centroid , a set of data points will be assigned to it , and forms a cluster . according to the second optimal condition , a centroid is computed as : @xmath8 we estimate the codebook centers to minimize the objective function : the mean squared error ( mse ) @xmath9 while the globally optimal solution of the above problem is np - hard , it can be solved by heuristic alternatives . the best known approach is the @xmath0-means algorithm @xcite , in which the above two conditions are optimized alternatively . product quantization assumes that certain groups of features are independent with each other , and explores this assumption to generate a large number of landmark points by grouping the feature space into @xmath10 groups ( each group is a subspace ) . by quantizing each of the subspaces separately using sub - quantizer @xmath11 , it produces an implicit codebook as a cartesian product of @xmath10 small sub - codebooks , @xmath12 . in this case , codebook @xmath5 can provide an exponentially large number of cluster centers while retains a linear size of storage . given a data point @xmath13 , it estimates the globally nearest center by concatenating all its nearest sub - centers from the sub - codebooks as @xmath14 . the mse of this product quantizer can be estimated as : @xmath15 the degradation of pq performance can be severe if there are substantial statistical dependences among the feature groups @xcite ; recent works have shown that such dependences could be reduced , to some extent , by more careful space - decomposition @xcite . their works extended the idea from iterative quantization @xcite to the pq scheme that learn an rotation to transform the data to reduce the dependences between feature groups . for example , the work from @xcite jointly seeks a whole space rotation @xmath16 and pq codebooks @xmath5 by minimizing @xmath17 @xmath18 residual quantization ( rq ) has a different assumption in that it does not assume the features are independent , but assumes the quantization residuals of the first level quantizer can be further quantized . thus , it is a stacked quantization model . for the first level , rq simply uses a @xmath0-means clustering to quantize the data , and assign them to @xmath0 centers . for each data point , by subtracting from the assigned centroid , we can collect their residual vectors as @xmath19 . then @xmath20 will be used as the input to the next level , and we again use @xmath0-means - means is a basic choice . ] to quantize the residual vectors . by repeating this for @xmath21 times , we can have a sequential product codebook @xmath22 . given an input vector @xmath13 , by computing the nearest center at each level , we can get a sequence of indexes @xmath23 . the globally nearest center for @xmath13 here becomes a direct sum of all the sub - centers @xmath24 . simply considering one level , we represent @xmath13 at level @xmath25 as @xmath26 where @xmath27 . then the residual vector from level @xmath25 is @xmath28 the mse for a @xmath21-level rq is @xmath29 the most important advantage of rq is that it does not make the unrealistic assumption that the features are statistically independent . in addition , it holds a non - increasing property , that is , adding a level will always reduce the mse error . as discussed above , residual quantization recursively performs quantization on residual vectors from previous levels . in other words , all the residual vectors from different clusters are collected and fed into the same quantizer in the next level . as shown in figure [ figure : orq - example ] ( b ) , the residual clusters can have different shapes , orientations , or scales , which makes effective quantization of them very hard in general . to address this problem , we propose to learn one rotation per cluster to transform the residual clusters , to make them more aligned to each other , and potentially can make more fruitful residual - level quantizers ( see figure [ figure : orq - example](c ) ) . for simplicity , we focus our analysis on a two - level rq model . we fix the first level to be an @xmath0-means clustering with @xmath30 clusters . and at this point , we are not going to specify the second - level quantizer @xmath31 considering our proposed method is general to any quantizer performed in the residual space . in this way , we have a first - level codebook @xmath32 with @xmath30 cluster centers @xmath33 . we suppose that a vector @xmath13 is assigned to @xmath34 , its residual vector is denoted as @xmath35 a residual cluster @xmath36 then is a collection of all residual vectors assigned to its center , @xmath37 the residual set @xmath38 forms the input for the next level quantizer @xmath31 . finally , the objective function for such a rq model simply follows either equation [ eq : rq_mse ] or equation [ eq : pq_mse ] , depending on whether another @xmath0-means or pq is selected to be the residual quantizer . to alleviate the misalignment of these clusters , we propose to apply cluster - specified transforms right after the first level so that all clusters are aligned for better adaption to the shared residual quantizer . we associate each cluster center @xmath34 with a transform @xmath39 , whose inverse @xmath40 must exist . accordingly , a transformed residual cluster is then represented as @xmath41 we dubbed the generalized rq model as transformed residual quantization ( trq ) . while our generalization only requires transforms to be invertible , the property of non - increasing mse error remain valid if transforms are orthogonal matrices , i.e. , @xmath42 , ( where @xmath43 is the identity matrix ) because applying orthogonal matrices does not change the mse error . yet , in this case , scaling inhomogeneity among residual clusters can not be accounted for by the transforms . finally , denoting a reproduction cluster as @xmath44 , and frobenius norm as @xmath45 , the mse for our trq model is given by @xmath46 0.15 in .complexity comparison with different vq models , where @xmath10 is the number of subspaces in pq model , @xmath21 is the number of levels in rq and trq models , and @xmath25 is the number of levels having transformations involved in our trq model ; @xmath47 and @xmath48 are operation costs on distance computations and vector transformations respectively . [ cols="<,^,^,>",options="header " , ] -0.1 in * parameters * there are mainly four parameters involved , where @xmath49 and @xmath50 are used to represent the numbers of feature groups for the two different level pq models , while @xmath30 and @xmath51 as the numbers of centers . we choose @xmath52 and @xmath53 , with @xmath54 and @xmath55 , to be consistent with @xcite and @xcite . since the multi - index has split the features to two groups ( see @xmath56 ) , the system can simply be seen as a concatenation of two independent residual product quantization models , and each of them has @xmath57 and @xmath58 while @xmath59 and @xmath60 are retained . in our case , they are optimized as two trq models . from now on , we only need to present how one of the trq models works during a search . note that , we are integrating trq with omulti , so the whole raw space has been transformed by , say @xmath61 , the transformation learnt in omulti . a query @xmath62 becomes @xmath63 before it probes to the first - level clusters . we split @xmath64 equally to two segments , @xmath65 . here we show only what happens to @xmath66 ; it then will be probed into the left subspace . if it is assigned to the sub - center @xmath67 , in our setting , the residual for @xmath66 is @xmath68 . finally , the concatenation @xmath69 are used for re - ranking pq - codes on the shortlist that is provided by the indexer omulti . * computation - wise discussion * a potential concern might be centered on the extra computational and storage costs required by the proposed trq model . trq applies transformations in the residual spaces and aims to improve the quantization quality and furthermore the search accuracy in the ann problem . it slightly increases memory usage due to the local transformations . in the setting for table [ table : sift1b - result ] , for instance , it requires about 2.5% extra memory space for all the transformation matrices relative to pq or opq model . this is acceptable with the substantially increased search accuracy considered . even though our presented results have been restricted to comparisons with pq and opq , we here give a short discussion about comparison between our method with lopq @xcite considering the common feature of the locally learned transformations . lopq learn different pq codebooks for each cluster while our trq share just one pq codebook among all clusters . this results in lopq use much more extra memory than trq dose . in the same setting as table [ table : sift1b - result ] lopq produce 16384 pq codebooks that takes 2 gb ( about 10% ) extra memory compared to ours and other methods . taking advantage of the considerable memory usage , lopq have achieved about 2% higher recall than our trq on this sift1b dataset . computationally , the number of transformations or matrix multiplications in both trq and lopq for each query is determined by the number of visited cells from the first level index ; it is usually less than 100 out of 16384 ( in table 2 ) . the results in table [ table : sift1b - result ] show that the extra computational costs can be well justified given the significant improvements on search accuracy . we also use only 10 millions of the training points to speed up the codebooks learning in both of opq and trq . all the results have been produced using a single thread with an intel(r ) xeon(r ) cpu @ 3.40ghz with 25.6 m cache size , and 128 gb ram . all methods have been implemented in matlab and c ( for codebook learning and database encoding ) and c++ ( for searching ) . product quantization and residual quantization are the well - known quantization models that reduce both computation and storage complexities . we have seen that different ways to optimize these models are becoming active and fruitful in the computer vision area . in this paper , we have presented a novel approach to reducing quantization error of residual quantization for fast nearest neighbor search . we have also presented two hybrid searching architectures that are based on product quantization and the proposed transformed residual quantization . our experiments show that the proposed trq has achieved significantly smaller quantization error than previous methods , which clearly demonstrates the benefits of the proposed model . also , in large - scale ann experiments on 1 billion vectors , our method has achieved significantly better accuracy than previous methods . despite that we have restricted our attention to the ann search problem in this paper , the approach can be extensively used for many other problems that require efficient and effective very large - scale clustering . for examples , @xmath0nn graph construction , and feature matching for image retrieval , and for object recognition to name a few . in addition , how to integrate our transformation - based approach with the global codebook learning approaches arises to be a very interesting question for residual quantization optimization . these become our future research directions .

the success of product quantization ( pq ) for fast nearest neighbor search depends on the exponentially reduced complexities of both storage and computation with respect to the codebook size . recent efforts have been focused on employing sophisticated optimization strategies , or seeking more effective models . residual quantization ( rq ) is such an alternative that holds the same property as pq in terms of the aforementioned complexities . in addition to being a direct replacement of pq , hybrids of pq and rq can yield more gains for approximate nearest neighbor search . this motivated us to propose a novel approach to optimizing rq and the related hybrid models . with an observation of the general randomness increase in a residual space , we propose a new strategy that jointly learns a local transformation per residual cluster with an ultimate goal to reduce overall quantization errors . we have shown that our approach can achieve significantly better accuracy on nearest neighbor search than both the original and the optimized pq on several very large scale benchmarks .

1111.6803

the large area telescope ( lat ) , on board the _ fermi _ gamma - ray space telescope @xcite , is a pair - conversion @xmath0-ray telescope , sensitive to photon energies from about 20 mev up to @xmath1 gev . the lat consists of a tracker ( two sections , front and back ) , a calorimeter and an anti - coincidence system to reject the charged - particle background . _ fermi _ lat , working in all - sky survey mode , is an optimal hunter for high - energy flares , transients and new gamma - ray sources , and is an unprecedented monitor of the variable @xmath0-ray sky , thanks to the large peak effective area , wide field of view ( @xmath2 sr ) , improved angular resolution and sensitivity . 0.0 cm 0.3 cm this all - sky monitoring is complemented by the flare advocate ( a.k.a . gamma - ray sky watcher , fa - gsw ) duty , a scientific service belonging to the lat instrument science operations and devoted to quicklook inspection and daily review of the gamma - ray sky observed by _ lat , performed with continuity for all the year through weekly shifts . 0.0 cm the fa - gsw service points out basic facts and information about the @xmath0-ray sky of potential interest for the lat internal science groups , through a day - by - day inspection and review of the all - sky photon count maps collected and of the quicklook science pipeline results . summaries about the sky surveyed and monitored by _ fermi _ lat , transients , flaring and new sources on six - hour and 1-day time intervals are communicated along with any relevant news to the external multiwavelength ( mw ) astrophysical community using the lat - mw mailing - list . furthermore astronomer s telegrams ( atels ) , automatic burst gcns and special gcns for blazar flares are distributed in addiction to weekly summary reports in the `` fermi sky blog '' ( fig . [ fig : fermiskyblog ] ) . thanks to this service joined with the public distribution of lat data at the fssc the _ fermi _ lat collaboration is therefore able to promote and increase the rate of multifrequency collaborations and observations , maximizing the scientific return and rate of international scientific cooperation of the _ fermi _ mission . first seeds for variability and mw follow - up and studies are often triggered by the fa - gsw activity ( see the lat mw coordinating group and @xcite ) . this activity is based on the automated quicklook data analysis of level 2 ( l2 ) at the _ fermi _ lat instrument science operation center ( isoc ) of slac - stanford ( fig . [ fig : schemeblocks.eps ] ) . l2 processing ( instrument monitoring pipeline , background monitoring , and quick look science analysis ) is triggered by the first availability of level 1 ( l1 ) processed data and performed on longer time intervals ( six hour , 1 day and 1 week ) referred therefore as automated science processing ( asp ) . the asp analysis pipeline running on the final astrophysical science data ( photon event files ft1 , and spacecraft data files ft2 fits files ) is composed of several scientific tasks ( fig . [ fig : schemeblocks.eps ] , and @xcite ) : 0.0 cm .the 159 atels posted divided for topics . [ cols="<,^",options="header " , ] [ table : ateltypes ] * automatic analysis of gamma - ray bursts ( impulsive transients ) through refinement of parameters for lat - detected grbs , detection and characterization of grbs not detected onboard , search and analysis of delayed high - energy afterglow emission ; * flux history monitoring based on maximum - likelihood method ( gtlike science tool ) of predefined list of sources ( called data release plan , drp , sources ) with subsequent addictions of publicly announced sources ( like flaring blazars subject of atels ) ; * blind guess - detection on all - sky photon counts maps accumulated in 6-hours , 1-day , 1-week intervals , through a fast method based on two - dimensional mexican hat wavelet transform , thresholding and sliding cell algorithms @xcite ; * transient and flare identification based on variability test ; * interactive lat source catalogs ; * multi - mission / multifrequency tools and archives ( like the error circle explorer and the spectral energy distribution builder ) linked to asp and provided by the asi science data center ( asdc , roma ) . 0.0 cm * gamma - ray flare advocate task . flaring sources approaching a daily flux of @xmath3 photons @xmath4 s@xmath5 deserves attention ( detection , localization , flux , photon index checked , photon counts maps and exposure maps are outlooked ) . internal / public notes , atels , target of opportunity ( too ) are submitted , mw observing campaigns are organized when needed . * gamma - ray sky watcher task . results from the lat automated science processing ( asp ) pipeline in 1-day and 6-hour time intervals are checked , searching for transients , increasing / decrasing brightness trends , and new @xmath0-ray source candidates and spatial associations . fa - gsws discovered new gamma - ray blazars before the release of _ fermi _ catalogs , discovered several bright flares and outbursts from blazars , some transient from low galactic latitude source , observed the emission of the quiet - sun and the flaring - sun emission . in multifrequency science fa - gsws triggered several targets of opportunity ( toos ) with the _ swift _ satellite ( about a dozen per year ) and involved the radio - astronomy community in joint observing programs . mw observing campaigns on several blazar and galactic source targets were also performed . in table [ table : ateltypes ] and fig.[fig : atelstastistics ] basic statistics about the 159 astronomical telegrams ( atels ) published on behalf of the fermi lat collaboration from july 24 , 2008 ( atel#1628 ) to august 24 , 2011 ( atel#3580 ) are illustrated . the average rate of published atels is about one per week / shift . more in detail the substantial menu of discoveries triggered by the fa - gsw service is : many flares from @xmath0-ray blazars ( the extraordinary outbursts of 3c 454.3 fig . [ fig:3c454 ] and @xcite large flares of pks 1510 - 089 , 4c 21.35 , pks 1830 - 211 , ao 0235 + 164 , pks 1502 + 106 , fig . [ fig : pks1502 ] , 3c 279 , 3c 273 , pks 1622 - 253 , 3c 66a , etc . ) ; short / long activity duty cycles of bright @xmath0-ray blazars ; unidentified transients near the galactic plane ( like j0910 - 5041 , j0109 + 6134 , galactic center region ) or associated to galactic sources ( like the crab nebula , the nova v407 cyg fig . [ fig : v407cyg ] and @xcite , the microquasar cyg x-3 , the binary star system 1fgl j1018.6 - 5856 ) , intense mev emission from the quiet and active sun . the all - sky variability monitor of _ fermi _ and the continuous day - by - day service performed by fa - gsws represents the liaison between the fermi lat collaboration and the mw astrophysical / astroparticle community , always invited to observe fermi lat sources and to propose mw collaborations .

the fermi flare advocate ( also known as gamma - ray sky watcher , fa - gsw ) service provides for a daily quicklook analysis and review of the high - energy gamma - ray sky seen by the fermi gamma - ray space telescope . the duty offers alerts for potentially new gamma - ray sources , interesting transients and relevant flares . a public weekly digest containing the main highlights about the gev gamma - ray sky is published in the web - based fermi sky blog . during the first 3 years of all - sky survey , more than 150 astronomical telegrams , several alerts to the tev cherenkov telescopes , and targets of opportunity to swift and other observatories have been distributed . this increased the rate of simultaneous multi - frequency observing campaigns and the level of international cooperation . many gamma - ray flares from blazars ( like the extraordinary outbursts of 3c 454.3 , intense flares of pks 1510 - 089 , 4c 21.35 , pks 1830 - 211 , ao 0235 + 164 , pks 1502 + 106 , 3c 279 , 3c 273 , pks 1622 - 253 ) , short / long flux duty cycles , unidentified transients near the galactic plane ( like j0910 - 5041 , j0109 + 6134 , the galactic center region ) , flares associated to galactic sources ( like the crab nebula , the nova v407 cyg , the microquasar cyg x-3 ) , emission of the quiet and active sun , were observed by fermi and communicated by fa - gsws .

hep-ph0702186

the problem of the study and measurement of t - odd distributions in hadron - hadron scattering has recently acquired a certain relevance and quite a few related experiments have been thought or scheduled for the next ten years@xcite . in particular several studies and models have been proposed for the sivers distribution function@xcite . its possible existence as a leading - twist distribution was demonstrated@xcite recently , and related@xcite to previously studied t - odd mechanisms@xcite . some phenomenological forms for its dependence on @xmath0 and @xmath2 have been extracted@xcite from available data@xcite . while studies of general properties@xcite of t - odd functions relate these functions with a wide spectrum of phenomena , quantitative models mostly follow the general scheme suggested in @xcite . a known quark - diquark spectator model@xcite is extended by including single particle ( meson or gluon ) exchange@xcite . in the case of @xcite the unperturbed starting model was a bag model . the class of processes i want to consider here is the one of single spin asymmetries in collisions between an unpolarized hadron and a transversely polarized proton . in particular , azimuthal asymmetries in drell - yan dilepton production and hadron semi - inclusive production , where in both cases one of the colliding hadrons is normal - polarized . i consider phenomena that may be present in the beam energy range 10 - 300 gev ( so , not necessarily leading twist effects ) . the present work uses phenomenological schemes that are not typical of perturbative qcd , but rather of high - energy nuclear physics . it is inspired by previous works on t - odd structure functions in high - energy nuclear physics@xcite , by a previous work on nuclear - target induced polarization in drell - yan@xcite , and by the results from the theory and phenomenology of spin - orbit interactions in high - energy hadron - hadron exclusive processes ( see e.g. @xcite and references therein ) . the goal is not to reproduce precisely some phenomenology . rather , it is to establish whether scalar and spin - orbit interactions dominated by their absorption part are able to build a nonzero sivers - like asymmetry with a reasonable shape , possibly of higher - twist nature . for this reason , the model for both the initial `` intrinsic '' state of a quark in the proton , and for initial state interactions is built in such a way to be as simple as possible . all the necessary functions have been chosen in gaussian form and the parameter number has been reduced to the minimum necessary to explore the interesting independent physical situations . contrary to the ordinary treatment of the problem , where one works on a two - point correlation operator deriving from a set of squared one - point amplitudes , i develop most of the work at the level of one - point amplitudes , square them and then sum over the relevant states . i imagine , for a hadron with a given spin projection @xmath3 @xmath1 @xmath4 , a two - component quark spinor @xmath5 , with @xmath6 associated with the transverse quark spin . in this scheme , the @xmath7trace normally calculated on the correlation operator simply corresponds to the sum @xmath8 . this quantity is the final goal of the calculation , and the distribution functions associated to an unpolarized quark , including sivers one , are extracted from it . concerning the initial , `` intrinsic '' state of a quark in the hadron , i assume that the relevant quantity defining this state is the quark total angular momentum @xmath9 in the hadron rest frame . in this state a nonzero correlation @xmath10 @xmath11 @xmath12 is present . in other words , the quark @xmath9 coincides with the parent hadron spin . this may be realized both in s - wave and in p - wave , with spin - spin correlation @xmath13 @xmath11 @xmath14 . a nonzero correlation between the hadron and the quark angular momentum is necessary in any model , since a spin - related effect is impossible if a quark transports no information on the parent hadron spin . clearly , we have different effects in the s and p - wave cases . this correlation alone would not produce a single - spin asymmetry of naive time - odd origin because of global invariance rules . initial state interactions between the two hadrons , or between the quarks of one hadron and the quarks of the other one , must be introduced@xcite . i reproduce these interactions in eikonal approximation @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is a 2x2 space - time dependent matrix reproducing a mean field acting on the projectile quark , and @xmath17 is a light - cone coordinate . then the full matrix element , affected by this operator , is calculated in space - time representation . although it may seem more natural to adopt a mean field treatment for problems where a projectile is subject to multiple soft scattering@xcite , there is also a tradition for such recipes in hadronic problems dominated by a single or at most double hard scattering event , when the scatterer belongs to a composite structure the way it is used here , the above eikonal approximation is only a short - wave approximation , that alone does not support the persistence of initial state interaction effects at very large energies . this derives from the fact that we do not know the asymptotic properties of the operator @xmath16 ( see below ) . in addition , the above eikonal approximation does not support automatically factorization , since it is applied at single point amplitude level . the added initial state interactions ( the @xmath16 matrix ) consist of two terms : ( i ) anti - hermitean scalar mean field , ( ii ) anti - hermitean spin - orbit mean field . hermitean terms have been tested and they affect the results . alone , these terms do not produce t - odd distributions ( by definition , since they they are intrinsically t - even ) and do not change the main qualitative features of the presented results . not to overload this work with a many - parameter phenomenology , i have limited myself to terms that are not intrinsically t - even . a remark is important : strong and electromagnetic interactions are t - even and hermitean . as well known in nuclear physics@xcite , relevant anti - hermitean terms originate in the projection of hermitean interactions on a subspace , including only a part of all those degrees of freedom that are able to exchange energy / momentum within a characteristic interaction time relevant for the problem . if one were able to include all the relevant degrees of freedom in the formalism , there would be no room for anti - hermitean interactions ( see @xcite for a long discussion about these points ) . the results of this calculation show that also most of the considered anti - hermitean terms are not effective , for the purpose of a sivers asymmetry . the key interaction term is one of the three components of the spin - orbit scalar product . a chain of qualitative arguments presented in section iii relates imaginary spin - orbit terms to the high - energy hadron - nucleon analyzing power and recoil polarization . these observables are nonzero at as large beam energies as 300 gev ( for the case of quasi - forward scattering@xcite ) or 25 - 30 gev ( for the case of large transferred momenta up to 7 gev / c , see e.g.@xcite ) . their behavior at larger energies is not known , and there is no commonly accepted model that allows for an extrapolation@xcite . this has two consequences . on the one side , at energies @xmath11 100 gev we face the possibility of relevant sivers - like asymmetries with this origin . on the other side , it is impossible to decide whether this is a leading twist effect . for this reason , as above anticipated , it is impossible to decide whether the @xmath16 operator appearing in the rescattering factor @xmath15 is nonzero at very large energies . because of this , in the following the terms `` sivers asymmetry '' and `` sivers effect '' are preferred to `` sivers function '' . the latter is appropriate in the case of a leading twist contribution . experimentally , it may be impossible to distinguish between the two at the presently available energies . where not differently specified , all variables will refer to the center of mass of the colliding hadrons . let @xmath18 @xmath1 @xmath19 , be the quark impact parameter and @xmath20 @xmath1 @xmath21 the transverse momentum conjugated with it . let @xmath22 be the large light - cone component of the hadron momentum , so that @xmath23 is the quark @xmath24 momentum conjugated with @xmath25 . i substitute @xmath25 with the rescaled coordinate @xmath26 not to work with a singularity of the fourier transform in the infinite momentum limit @xmath22 @xmath27 @xmath28 . since the inclusive process is described here in terms of squared amplitudes , and these amplitudes are calculated before being squared , @xmath17 is not bound to be positive , as it happens in the ordinary treatment based on a two - point correlator with intermediate real states . in that case @xmath17 has the meaning of the difference between the light - cone positions of two points . here it describes the light - cone position of one of the two only . i represent the initial `` unperturbed '' quark state in the form @xmath29 so our hadron consists in a coherent superposition of plane wave states with given @xmath0 , @xmath20 and transverse spin , each with amplitude @xmath30 or @xmath31 . i suppose that the parent hadron has @xmath32polarization @xmath4 , and that one initial state only contributes to the final distribution function . the expected distribution has the form is the sivers function . since this work refers to energies @xmath11 10@xmath33300 gev , i will speak of `` sivers asymmetry '' referring to the full second term @xmath34 . ] @xmath35 the sivers asymmetry can of course be isolated by subtracting two terms like the previous one , corresponding to opposite hadron polarizations . here i limit myself to searching for @xmath36asymmetric terms in the above @xmath37 unpolarized quark distribution corresponding to one assigned hadron transverse polarization . to introduce initial state interactions , i identically write @xmath38 as a twice iterated fourier transform , and in the intermediate stage i substitute each plane wave spinor by a spinor that contains the distortion due to the initial state interactions . writing only the @xmath39dependence for simplicity , it means that in the undistorted plane wave @xmath40\vec f_{pw}(x')\ ] ] ( where @xmath41 is the identity matrix and in the last passage i have only highlighted the piece to be modified ) the free field operator @xmath42 is substituted by the more general matrix operator @xmath43 reproducing a field subject to the action of initial state interactions : @xmath44 more precisely , initial state interactions in eikonal approximation affect the quark light - cone path starting from @xmath17 @xmath1 @xmath45 and reaching the hard interaction point @xmath17 , along fixed impact parameter lines ( see the discussion in refs.@xcite and @xcite , and compare the figures describing final state interactions for deep inelastic scattering in ref.@xcite with those for initial state interactions in drell - yan in ref.@xcite ) . these initial state interactions are here averaged by an effective mean field containing absorbing and spin orbit terms . so , each plane wave is substituted by a wave with eikonal phase distorted by this local field : @xmath46 where @xmath16 is a 2x2 matrix operator . in this subsection i refer the quark spin , orbital and total angular momentum to the parent hadron rest frame . in absence of initial state interactions , we may assume that we are able to calculate the fourier transform eq.([eq : fourier1 ] ) and write it directly in impact parameter representation as ( @xmath47 means `` plane wave '' ) @xmath48 where my main interest is for the very simple @xmath49wave state @xmath50 and as a second choice for the p - wave state @xmath51 eq.([eq : groundstate0 ] ) reproduces a space - time fluctuation of the hadron ground state into a quark+spectator state . eqs.([eq : groundstate1s ] , [ eq : groundstate1p ] ) are the impact parameter space projections of the states @xmath52 , @xmath53 . of course , other terms may be included . i limit to these two possibilities . the above states eqs . ( [ eq : groundstate1s ] ) and ( [ eq : groundstate1p ] ) imply a positive / negative transversity ( since these states transport information on the polarization of the parent hadron ) but do not allow for any @xmath54odd asymmetry , including a sivers asymmetry , in absence of initial state interactions . both the above states imply @xmath55 @xmath1 @xmath4 for the quark and the parent hadron in the hadron rest frame . this is the limit possibility . more in general we may imagine that a state where the parent hadron is fully polarized with transverse spin @xmath3 @xmath1 @xmath4 , corresponds to a quark mixed configuration of the kind @xmath56 for @xmath57 @xmath58 @xmath59 evidently the quark transports little or no information on the parent hadron polarization state , so it is logically impossible to get a nonzero hadron - polarization - related function , unless some very indirect mechanism is imagined . so , in the following i exclude this possibility . for nonzero @xmath59 @xmath60 @xmath57 , the results i get must be diluted by the factor @xmath61 . indeed , substituting the quark @xmath62 initial state with the quark @xmath63 initial state , the asymmetries that are calculated in the following simply reverse their sign . for @xmath64 and @xmath65 , i simply take gaussian shapes @xmath66 . the same is done for the relevant functions @xmath67 and @xmath68 later introduced to describe initial state interactions . in practice , the underlying hadron - quark - spectator vertex is a space - time version of the vertex adopted in @xcite ( a gaussian quark - diquark vertex ) . the parameters for these gaussian functions are chosen not to get too unrealistic distributions . since for @xmath0 @xmath1 0 the distribution is large , the above must be considered an implementation of a sea+valence state . this is not a decisive detail , because the used initial state interactions lead to a zero sivers effect at @xmath0 @xmath1 0 . for @xmath0 @xmath1 1 the parameters are tuned so to have a small distribution value , that can not be zero however . with a logarithmic mapping it could be possible to produce a distribution that is zero at @xmath0 @xmath1 1 . this increase of complication would not be worthwhile since this work does not focus on the @xmath0 @xmath58 1 region where a completely different physics should be included . i assume that the distorting factor @xmath69 @xmath70 @xmath71 $ ] of eq.([eq : dw1 ] ) does not depend on @xmath0 or @xmath20 . this simplifies much the calculations since it allows for transporting @xmath69 out of the fourier transform eq.([eq : fourier1 ] ) and applying directly it to the function @xmath72 of eq.([eq : groundstate0]).dependent initial state interaction starting from eq.([eq : groundstate0 ] ) , sacrificing something at interpretation level . ] so , this equation is modified to ( dw means `` distorted wave '' ) : @xmath73 in the calculations , the exponential operator is approximated by a quasi - continuous product : @xmath74 where the product starts from a negative and large enough @xmath75 value where interactions may be neglected , and stops at @xmath17 . the @xmath16 matrix is @xmath76 all the coefficients are supposed to introduce reasonably small corrections , at least for @xmath2 @xmath77 3 gev / c where we know that any asymmetry due to initial state interactions is at most 30 % . the @xmath78 term is a scalar absorption term , associated with spreading of the quark momentum and so to damping of the quark initial state . it assumes underlying chaotic interactions , that because of this lack of coherence deplete any given @xmath79 state without a direct coherent enhancement of another one , as it would happen in the case of a hermitean interaction . a part of the lost flux is recovered because of diffraction , but in the average some flux is lost from the elastic channel . the @xmath80 terms are spin - orbit terms , since in a basis where @xmath3 is diagonal , as the one i are using here , we may write @xmath81 defining @xmath82 and remembering that , at large @xmath22 , in the hadron collision c.m . frame @xmath83 ( here @xmath84 is referred to the hadron collision c.m . frame ) the above may be rewritten as @xmath85 and we see that @xmath16 contains a scalar absorption term plus a spin - orbit term . since it appears in a real exponential ( without an explicit factor `` i '' in the argument ) , for real @xmath86 the spin - orbit term is a anti - hermitean one . for imaginary @xmath86 , it is hermitean . since by definition the latter can not produce @xmath87odd effects , i have focused my attention on the case of real @xmath86 . this corresponds to the nuclear physics case of an imaginary spin - orbit potential . more in general , we will have a complex potential , able to introduce @xmath87odd effects if its imaginary part is nonzero . aiming at studying the simplest possible case , i limit to a pure anti - hermitean term . with the parameter values here assumed ( see below ) , the combined action of nonzero @xmath88 and @xmath86 is such as to produce absorption through all the region affected by serious initial state interactions . this absorption is spin - orbit - selective . the functions @xmath67 , @xmath68 have been chosen with gaussian form , and their widths satisfy the conditions : @xmath67 @xmath58 @xmath89 , @xmath68 @xmath58 @xmath90 . this is motivated by the following facts : ( i ) initial state interactions can not take place too far from the hard quark - antiquark vertex ; ( ii ) the projectile and the target are supposed to have similar shapes ; ( iii ) in terms of the longitudinal rescaled quantity @xmath17 @xmath1 @xmath91 , leading twist effects ( if any ) must take place over a finite @xmath17 range in the scaling limit @xmath22 @xmath27 @xmath28 ; if they are next - to - leading , at any finite @xmath22 for which they assume a non - negligible value they take place over a finite ( scale - dependent ) @xmath17 range ; ( iv ) since i assume that initial state interactions have incoherent character , the @xmath92 functions are wavefunctions , while the @xmath93 functions are densities @xmath11 @xmath94 . the choice of using all gaussian functions , with correlated widths , is aimed to simplicity and to reducing the number of independent parameters . presently , nonzero effects of spin - orbit terms are measured in exclusive hadron - nucleon interactions at rather large energies . their origin in terms of fundamental interactions is not fully explained . so they must be considered phenomenological interactions . what is argued in the present work is that these interactions are present at quark - quark level , where they preserve the same generic structure they have at hadron - hadron level . as a consequence , their effect should be visible not only in a few exclusive channels , but in a wider class of hadron - hadron induced processes , including semi - inclusive scattering and drell - yan . although elastic channel measurements are the most precise available , up to now spin - orbit effects have been found in any exclusive channel where they have been searched for via dedicated experiments . in the following i give a qualitative account ( i ) of the present - day knowledge on spin - orbit interactions in hadron - hadron interactions at high energies , ( ii ) of the assumptions that are necessary to pass from hadron - hadron spin - orbit interactions to the quark - mean field interactions introduced in the previous section . the arguments summarized in this subsection may be reconstructed from refs.@xcite , that also contain a long list of references concerning theoretical models and previous measurements . several papers on this subject , or touching this subject , have been written especially in the years before 1985 . writing the amplitude for the elastic scattering between a normally polarized beam particle and an unpolarized target particle as @xmath95 @xmath70 @xmath96 @xmath97 @xmath98 , the spin - orbit potential is the core part of the impact parameter space representation of @xmath98 . in other words , a nonzero normal spin analyzing power in hadron elastic scattering on hadron targets is equivalent to a spin - orbit coupling like the one appearing in eq.([eq : t1 ] ) of the previous section . as a specific example , from eqs.(49 ) and ( 53 ) of ref.@xcite one may directly deduce the spin - orbit terms in eq.([eq : t1 ] ) of the present work , taking into account that in the case of a gaussian density one has @xmath99 @xmath100 @xmath101 ( in @xcite , the same 2-dimensional formalism used here is employed ) . experimentally , an unexpectedly large normal analyzing power ( or , equivalently , a large recoil polarization ) is found in nucleon - hadron exclusive processes like elastic scattering . in the quasi - forward diffraction - dominated region , this is nonzero up to beam energies 300 gev . at large transferred momenta ( up to 7 gev / c ) it is rather large up to beam energy 30 gev . what happens at larger energies is not known , and it has been guessed but not demonstrated that such terms can survive asymptotically . the separation between the two regimes ( small and large transferred momenta ) is not obvious in the data . comparing small and large angle data ( that normally refer to different energy regimes ) taking as a starting point the peak at very small angles due to electromagnetic - strong interference , and then increasing the angle , the transferred momentum dependence of the analyzing power or recoil polarization shows a series of diffraction or interference peaks and changes of sign . the peaks do not decrease in magnitude , and at the largest transferred momenta the size of the effect seems to increase in an uncontrollable way , together with error bars . i remark that the region that theoretically should imply the transition between the two regimes ( transferred momenta between 0.5 and 3 gev / c ) is also the most important for a nonzero and measurable sivers asymmetry . at intermediate energies the origin of the measured spin - orbit terms may be reasonably interpreted for pion - proton diffractive elastic scattering . in this case two dominating regge trajectories ( pomeron and rho ) mix , leading to interference between two terms with phase difference 90@xmath102 in the helicity - flip and helicity - non - flip amplitudes . in the case of quasi - forward elastic proton - proton scattering , several regge poles and cuts potentially contribute and the situation is less clear . because the presence of the discussed observables requires a phase difference 90@xmath102 between the interfering helicity - flip and helicity - non - flip amplitudes , contributions from @xmath103 poles / cuts are needed to explain a nonzero analyzing power or recoil polarization . so , an unexpected survival of these observables at large energies would contradict the standard idea that only pomeron contributes asymptotically to small - angle elastic scattering . for the case of large transferred momentum , there are a lot of competing models ( e.g. references 5 - 22 in ref.@xcite ) . in all of them some non - trivial mechanism is added to a standard pqcd set of processes . indeed , pqcd may be properly applied in this region , leading to zero normal analyzing power because of helicity conservation . so , pqcd can not be ignored , and at the same time it can not be applied in the most straightforward way . to pass from the measurements of normal spin asymmetries in elastic scattering to the spin - orbit potential contained in the previous section , some assumptions are needed . assumption ( a ) : at least a part of the high - energy spin - orbit interactions between hadrons can be reduced to an incoherent sum of spin - orbit interactions between quarks . assumption ( b ) : the absorption part of these quark - quark spin - orbit interactions is relevant . these two assumptions are plausible and questionable at the same time , because of our lack of knowledge about the fundamental mechanisms determining the spin - orbit coupling at hadron level . in the case of large angle scattering , assumption ( a ) could be naively justified because of the short wavelength perturbative regime . on the other side , in this regime pqcd may be applied , and it says that spin - orbit interactions should not exist at all ( both at quark and at hadron level ) , while they are there . in the case of quasi - forward scattering , we may imagine that the spin - orbit term in hadron - hadron scattering is associated with an interference term between two t - channel regge pole exchanges . although it is possible to imagine the same process with the same exchanged poles taking place between two individual quarks @xmath104 and @xmath105 , small transverse momenta imply a large degree of coherence between two processes like @xmath106 and @xmath107 scattering . so the possibility of extracting the incoherent part of these interactions and estimate its relevance would require at least to know what exactly is exchanged , and this is not completely clear presently . concerning assumption ( b ) , it is easy to imagine a large absorption part in quark - hadron scattering , for the same reasons why hadron - hadron scattering is absorption - dominated . however , this argument can not be transferred directly from the hadron level to the quark level . indeed , the absorption part of the hadron - hadron scattering potential derives from the inelasticity of the process . in other words , from the direct loss of flux of the initial channel . but what is a hard inelastic process at hadron level may be a perfectly elastic process at quark level , in the normally employed approximation where quarks are free particles . for the specific case of the production of t - odd effects , i have long discussed this point in my previous work ref.@xcite . summarizing very briefly , since a quark is never asymptotically free , inelasticity is not determined by a modification of the quark internal state or by extra particle production , but also by the behavior of the surrounding environment . this has little relevance in the analysis of t - even effects in hard processes , because of the separation between hard and soft scales . in t - odd effects however , soft scales acquire indirect relevance . in particular , elastic quark - quark in - medium scattering leads to a finite imaginary part in the quark propagator , i.e. the quark behaves like a free but unstable particle . as a consequence of this inelasticity , if spin - orbit interactions may be transferred from hadron to quark level an imaginary part is likely to be present , giving an argument for the plausibility of assumption ( b ) . at finite beam energies @xmath11 10 - 100 gev , from assumption ( a ) and ( b ) the possibility follows of writing the cumulative effect of spin - orbit quark - quark interactions in the exponentiated form eq.([eq : dw2 ] ) where a quark interacts with a mean - field potential along a straight path . exploiting the fact that for finite @xmath22 , @xmath17 may be one - to - one related in a non - singular way to the longitudinal space variable @xmath108 in the rest frame of the unpolarized particle , we may just treat the interaction in glauber - like style@xcite and proceed as in high - energy hadron - nucleus collisions . with things done this way , exponentiation is just a useful short - wavelength approximation , but does not prove that one is considering leading twist terms . in other words , i can not presently support the following assumption : assumption ( c ) : the operator @xmath16 of eq.([eq : dw1 ] ) is finite in the limit @xmath22 @xmath27 @xmath28 . formal considerations apart , it is obvious that such an assumption could make sense if we knew the @xmath22 @xmath27 @xmath28 behavior of spin - orbit effects in nucleon - hadron elastic scattering . all calculations refer to @xmath109 @xmath1 0 , so in the following only the @xmath36dependence appears explicitly . figures 1 to 4 have been calculated with the s - wave state , figures 5 and 6 with the p - wave one . the free parameters have the same values in all figures 1 to 6 , and their list follows : for the gaussian function / density widths : @xmath64 : @xmath110 @xmath1 3.5 . @xmath67 : @xmath110 @xmath1 2 . @xmath65 : @xmath111 @xmath1 0.9 . @xmath68 : @xmath111 @xmath1 0.6 . i have used @xmath67 @xmath58 @xmath89 and @xmath68 @xmath58 @xmath90 , so to have two independent parameters only . for the interaction matrix : @xmath88 @xmath1 0.2 , @xmath86 @xmath1 0.1 . these mean an overall 20 % reduction of the quark distribution for @xmath2 @xmath1 0 , entirely due to the parameter @xmath88 . at large @xmath2 on the contrary the distribution is enhanced . the spin - orbit parameter @xmath86 produces local flux modifications with zero @xmath112average . the fourier transform for @xmath113 @xmath1 0 is not sensible to these . for nonzero @xmath113 , @xmath86 produces asymmetry . distribution function for @xmath113 @xmath1 0 , as a function of @xmath0 . @xmath113 is the component of @xmath20 orthogonal to the initial hadron polarization @xmath114 @xmath115 . for the parameter values , see the beginning of the `` results '' section in the text . [ c0],width=340 ] dependence of the quark distribution @xmath116 for @xmath0 @xmath1 0.6 . the asymmetry is made more evident by the logarithmic plot . [ c4],width=340 ] distribution of the asymmetry @xmath117 for @xmath0 @xmath1 0.6 . it is the left - right asymmetry of the distribution reported in the previous figure . [ c2],width=340 ] as a function of @xmath0 for @xmath113 @xmath1 4 . at this @xmath113 we have the peak value of the asymmetry , for each @xmath0 . [ c1],width=340 ] dependence of the quark distribution @xmath116 for @xmath0 @xmath1 0.6 . [ c4d],width=340 ] of the quark distribution reported in the previous figure . [ c3d],width=340 ] in fig.1 i show the distribution function @xmath116 for @xmath113 @xmath1 0 in the @xmath118range ( 0,1 ) . in fig.2 i show the corresponding @xmath36distribution @xmath116 for @xmath0 @xmath1 0.6 . a logarithmic plot has been chosen to give more evidence to the large@xmath119 asymmetry , caused by a nonzero @xmath86 . in fig.3 i show the asymmetry @xmath120 @xmath70 @xmath117 , for @xmath0 @xmath1 0.6 , as a function of @xmath113 in the @xmath113 range ( 0,5 ) gev / c . with @xmath121 i mean @xmath122 . in fig.4 i show the same asymmetry for fixed @xmath113 @xmath1 4 gev / c ( i.e. at its peak value ) as a function of @xmath0 . many more ( not shown ) distributions and asymmetries have been produced changing the values of all the above parameters . the result is that figs.1 to 4 are general enough and contain all the relevant qualitative features of the found asymmetries . by tuning parameter values , the asymmetry may be made larger / smaller , and its peak may be shifted towards larger / smaller @xmath0 or @xmath113.integrated distribution functions being strongly affected by initial state interactions , so this is considered a boundary condition to be respected . ] summarizing the general properties deduced by systematic parameter tuning activity i find : \1 ) for small values of the parameters @xmath88 , @xmath86 ( both @xmath123 0.2 ) one already obtains peak values of the asymmetry @xmath124 @xmath11 1 ( see fig.4 ) . this is however reached at @xmath113 @xmath125 4 gev / c , where experimental data would easily present large error bars making it difficult to distinguish between e.g. 60 % and 30 % asymmetries . range like @xmath126 in the valence region , to collect much more than 300 events with @xmath127 @xmath128 4 gev / c is not trivial . ] for @xmath113 up to 3 gev / c the asymmetry is smaller than 30 % , i.e. much smaller than the peak value . a consequence of the use of gaussian shapes is the presence of this rather pronounced peak at large @xmath113 , that however would have scarce influence on an event - weighted asymmetry ( dominated by @xmath113 @xmath58 1@xmath332 gev / c ) . \2 ) changing the gaussian distribution parameters it is possible to change the shape of the asymmetries , so to have the peak asymmetry e.g. at 3 gev / c . this would be far from anything observed up to now ( compare with the fits by refs.@xcite ) . \3 ) for @xmath113 @xmath128 5 gev / c , we find oscillations near zero , that could be of numeric origin . the fast decrease immediately following the peak at @xmath113 @xmath1 4 gev / c is however stable with respect to changes of the numerical parameters ( number of integration points , integration range cutoffs ) . \4 ) asymmetries obtained via anti - hermitean spin - orbit terms are zero at @xmath0 @xmath1 0 . @xmath124 increases with @xmath0 up to a maximum and then decreases at larger @xmath0 , seemingly to reach zero at the unphysical value @xmath0 @xmath1 @xmath28 . the fact that the asymmetry is zero for @xmath0 @xmath1 0 is a consequence of the symmetries of the model , and of the fact that the @xmath0 @xmath1 0 component of the fourier transform is just a plain @xmath129average . in a more realistic model this property should be anyway present for another reason . here , we have assumed @xmath118independent interactions , but accordingly to eqs.([eq : t1]-[eq : t4 ] ) , the spin - orbit potential is @xmath130 at small @xmath0 ( in a semi - classical approximation , assuming continuous @xmath84 ) . at a semi - classical level , it is reasonable to imagine that a wee parton has comparatively small @xmath131 and @xmath132 in the hadron collision c.m . frame , and so negligible spin - orbit interactions . \5 ) alone , a nonzero @xmath88 is not able to produce a sivers - like asymmetry . nonzero @xmath86 is required . on the other side , @xmath86 could produce asymmetry for @xmath88 @xmath1 0 too , but this combination ( @xmath88 @xmath1 0 , @xmath86 @xmath128 0 ) would imply an unphysical local increase of particle flux . with the chosen values of the coefficients we have spin - selective absorption , but anyway absorption , with the exception of large@xmath133 regions where initial interactions are anyway suppressed by @xmath134 . \6 ) in the p - wave case the @xmath36event distribution assumes the obvious shape shown in fig.5 . at the distribution peaks of fig.5 the asymmetry is @xmath11 5 % and has the same sign of the s - wave asymmetry of figs 1 - 4 . in the distribution tails @xmath113 @xmath128 3 gev / c the asymmetry reverses its sign . to analyze in detail situations where both waves ( s and p ) are relevant one should however introduce a more realistic different radius for the @xmath49wave and the @xmath135wave distributions . \7 ) the non - diagonal terms of the interaction matrix eq.([eq : t1 ] ) have practically no role . i.e. , removing the diagonal @xmath136 terms from the interaction matrix produces immediately zero asymmetry , while removing the @xmath137 terms , or changing their sign , only produces negligible changes in the asymmetry shape of figs . 3 and 4 . the role of the @xmath138 terms may be understood if one approximates the action of the damping potential in a homogeneous form . then a nonzero @xmath86 ( together with a nonzero @xmath88 ) means that the two components @xmath139 and @xmath140 of a spinor @xmath141 are substituted by damped exponentials : @xmath142 evidently at large negative values of the product @xmath143 we have dominance of the spin state @xmath144 , and the opposite at large positive @xmath143 . this asymmetry is detected by the @xmath145 fourier transform . introducing further approximations ( substituting the gaussian functions with simple cutoffs of the integration ranges , and taking @xmath88 @xmath1 0 ) shows that the so simplified problem enjoys a kind of @xmath146 invariance . as a consequence , any time a parameter is changed so to decrease the @xmath147 range of the asymmetry , it also increases the corresponding @xmath148 range and viceversa . a systematic parameter tuning work confirms that this property is approximately present in the full model . some final observations : the author of this work has remarked in @xcite that damping terms in initial state interactions contribute producing t - odd distributions , so he can not claim surprise for the results of the present calculation . what is however surprising is the non - effectiveness of the non - diagonal terms in the @xmath16 matrix . since one can not exclude that this is due to the exaggerated level of symmetry contained in the here used unperturbed state , a deeper study needs to be devoted to this point . also , one can not exclude that a more complicated structure of initial states may lead to @xmath36asymmetries in presence of @xmath149 initial state interactions . this is what happened e.g. in refs.@xcite , where a t - odd structure was produced in presence of a spin - independent ( final state ) interaction . in that case however , the @xmath150 of final state interactions was not spin independent , despite their hamiltonian was . this was due to the elaborate shell - model structure of the initial states . e.g. , in @xcite it was possible to get an asymmetry from @xmath151c , but not from @xmath152o ( fully filled @xmath153 and @xmath154 shells in the latter case , only @xmath153 in the former ) . summarizing , starting from the assumption that the quark total angular momentum is dominantly oriented as the parent hadron spin , it is possible to build a sivers - like asymmetry via mean field initial state interactions of imaginary spin - orbit kind . with these interactions , a nonzero sivers function is present also starting from a simple @xmath155 s - wave ground state for the quark . phenomenological interactions of this kind are known in high - energy hadron and nuclear physics . for values of the parameters such as to guarantee a small overall effect of initial state interactions ( @xmath58 20 % distribution damping at small @xmath2 ) the qualitative @xmath156distribution of the calculated asymmetries follows the typical pattern proposed by widespread parameterizations . in the chosen interaction matrix , the only effective terms are the ( spin - orbit selective ) diagonal absorption ones . in other words , spin rotating interactions are not decisive . also , spin - independent absorption alone is not sufficient . it is not possible however to exclude that the no - effectiveness of these terms is related to the excess of simplicity of the initial configuration . with the present day knowledge of spin - orbit hadronic interactions , it is not possible to establish whether their effects persist at very large energies . consequently it is not possible to establish whether a sivers - like asymmetry generated by them is a leading twist one or just an intermediate energy effect . s.boffi , c.giusti , and f.pacati , phys.rep.*226 * 1 ( 1993 ) . s.boffi , c.giusti , f.pacati , and m.radici , `` electromagnetic response of atomic nuclei '' , vol 20 of oxford studies in nuclear physics ( oxford university press , oxford , 1996 ) .

i study the effect of scalar and spin - orbit absorption potentials , in the production of a nonzero sivers - like asymmetry in hadron - hadron high energy collisions ( drell - yan and single spin asymmetries ) . a basic model is built for the intrinsic state of a quark in the projectile hadron . s - wave and p - wave 2-component states are considered . before the hard event , this quark is subject to absorbing mean fields simulating interactions with a composite target . the relevant interaction terms are found to be the imaginary diagonal spin - orbit ones . spin rotating terms , and scalar absorption , seem not to be decisive . for @xmath0 @xmath1 0 the found sivers asymmetry vanishes , while at larger @xmath0 its qualitative dependence on @xmath0 , @xmath2 follows the usual trends met in available models and parameterizations . given the present - day knowledge of the considered phenomenological interactions , it is not possible to establish whether the related sivers - like asymmetry is a leading twist - one . high energy hadron - hadron scattering , sivers asymmetry , spin - orbit forces .

math-ph0506053

ever since mark kac posed the question `` can one hear the shape of a drum ? '' @xcite , there has been a great deal of interest in finding relations between the geometry of a manifold or a graph and spectral properties of the laplacian defined on it . the impressive works @xcite , which have been chosen by way of example , witness the steady progress achieved in recent years and provide further references . whereas laplacians on manifolds dominated the scene in the earlier years , the rise of spectral graph theory @xcite in the late 1980s and 90s has contributed to deepen our understanding of the discrete case . spectral theory of random graphs , however , is still a widely open field . the very recent contributions @xcite take a probabilistic point of view to derive heat - kernel estimates for laplacians on _ supercritical _ bernoulli bond - percolation graphs in the @xmath0-dimensional hyper - cubic lattice . on the other hand , traditional methods from spectral theory are used in @xcite to investigate the integrated density of states of laplacians on _ subcritical _ bond - percolation graphs . depending on the boundary condition that is chosen at cluster borders , two different types of _ lifshits asymptotics _ at spectral edges were found @xcite . for example , the integrated density of states of the neumann laplacian behaves as @xmath1 at the lower spectral edge for bond probabilities @xmath2 below the percolation threshold @xmath3 . we have put quotation marks here , because , strictly speaking , one should take appropriate logarithms on both sides . the lifshits exponent @xmath4 in is independent of the spatial dimension @xmath0 . this was explained by the fact that , asymptotically , @xmath5 is dominated by the smallest eigenvalues which arise from very long _ linear clusters _ in this case . in contrast , for the dirichlet laplacian and @xmath6 , it was found that @xmath7 we note that @xmath8 . the lifshits exponent in comes out as @xmath9 , because the dominating small dirichlet eigenvalues arise from large _ fully connected cube- or sphere - like clusters_. thus , depending on the boundary condition ( and the spectral edge ) different geometric graph properties show up in the integrated density of states . we refer to the literature cited in @xcite for a discussion of other spectral properties of these and closely related operators , for the history of the problem and what is known in the physics literature . lifshits asymptotics for a neumann laplacian on erds rnyi random graphs are studied in @xcite . in this paper we pursue the investigations of @xcite and ask what happens to and in the _ supercritical phase _ of bond - percolation graphs . clearly , one would not expect the contribution of the finite clusters to alter the picture completely . but for the infinite percolating cluster , the story may be different . indeed , we will prove that the percolating cluster produces a _ van hove asymptotics _ @xmath10 in the neumann case for @xmath11 . there is also an additional lifshits - tail behaviour due to finite clusters , but it is hidden under the dominating asymptotics . loosely speaking , is true because the percolating cluster looks like the full regular lattice on very large length scales ( bigger than the correlation length ) for @xmath11 . on smaller scales its structure is more like that of a jagged fractal . the neumann laplacian does not care about these small - scale holes , however . all that is needed for to be true is the existence of a suitable @xmath0-dimensional , infinite grid . in contrast , the dirichlet laplacian does care about holes at all scales so that continues to hold for @xmath12 , as we shall prove . low - lying dirichlet eigenvalues require large fully connected cube- or sphere - like regions , and this is a large - deviation event . closely related large - deviation results for laplacians on percolation graphs have been obtained in @xcite . to be precise , @xcite refer to the pseudo - dirichlet laplacian @xmath13 in the sense of our definition [ deltadef](ii ) below . considering both site- and bond - percolation graphs , and using a discrete version of the method of enlargement of obstacles , antal @xcite derives the long - time asymptotics for the mean ( i.e. annealed ) hitting - time distribution of the set of absent sites ( resp . bonds ) for the random walk generated by @xmath13 . biskup and knig work in the setting of the parabolic anderson model , which contains @xmath13 on _ site_-percolation graphs as a special case . in particular , they establish a lifshits tail for the corresponding integrated density of states , see also remark [ bikorem ] . this paper is organised as follows . in the next section we give a precise statement of our results in theorems [ lifshits ] and [ hove ] . section [ lifshitsproof ] is devoted to the proof of theorem [ lifshits ] . in this proof we follow the strategy laid down in @xcite , see also @xcite . the goal there was to establish lifshits tails in the context of random schrdinger operators . finally , section [ hoveproof ] contains the proof of theorem [ hove ] , where we apply the recent deep heat - kernel estimates from @xcite . to set up the mathematical arena , let us first recall some notions from bernoulli bond percolation . for @xmath14 , a natural number , we denote by @xmath15 the ( simple hyper - cubic ) lattice in @xmath0 dimensions . being a graph , the lattice @xmath16 has the _ vertex set _ @xmath17 and the _ edge set _ @xmath18 given by all unordered pairs @xmath19 of nearest - neighbour vertices @xmath20 , that is , those vertices which have euclidean distance latexmath:[$|x - y| : = \bigl(\sum_{\nu=1}^{d } @xmath17 are canonically represented as @xmath0-tuples @xmath22 with entries from @xmath23 . next , we consider the probability space @xmath24 , which is endowed with the usual product sigma - algebra , generated by finite cylinder sets , and equipped with a product probability measure @xmath25 . elementary events in @xmath26 are sequences of the form @xmath27 , and we assume their entries to be independently and identically distributed according to a bernoulli law @xmath28 with _ bond probability _ @xmath290,1[$ ] . to a given @xmath30 , we associate an edge set @xmath31 . a _ bond - percolation graph in @xmath17 _ is the mapping @xmath32 with values in the set of subgraphs of @xmath15 . given @xmath33 , the _ vertex degree _ @xmath34 counts the number of edges in @xmath35 which share @xmath36 as a common vertex . [ deltadef ] the random operators @xmath37 , respectively @xmath38 , are called vertex - degree operator , respectively adjacency operator , of bond - percolation graphs in @xmath17 . their realisations , @xmath39 , respectively @xmath40 , act on the hilbert space of complex - valued , square - summable sequences indexed by @xmath17 according to @xmath41 for all @xmath42 , all @xmath33 and all @xmath30 . with these definitions , we introduce _ laplacians on bond - percolation graphs _ for three different `` boundary conditions '' at non - fully connected vertices + [ cols= " > , < , < " , ] here @xmath43 stands for the identity operator on @xmath44 . the motivation and origin of the terminology for the different boundary conditions are discussed in @xcite together with some basic properties of the operators . [ genergodic ] the random self - adjoint laplacians are ergodic with respect to @xmath17-translations . hence , their spectra and the spectral subsets arising in the lebesgue decomposition are all equal to non - random sets with probability one . in particular , the spectrum is @xmath25-almost surely given by @xmath45 $ ] for all @xmath46 , as was shown in @xcite . next , we define the quantity of our main interest for this paper , the integrated density of states of @xmath47 . to this end let @xmath48 be the sequence which is concentrated at the point @xmath33 , i.e. @xmath49 and @xmath50 for all @xmath51 . moreover , @xmath52 stands for the heaviside unit - step function , which we choose to be right continuous , viz . @xmath53 for all real @xmath54 and @xmath55 for all real @xmath56 . [ ndef ] for every @xmath290,1[$ ] and every @xmath46 we call the function @xmath57 with values in the interval @xmath58 $ ] the _ integrated density of states of _ @xmath47 . the integrated density of states @xmath59 is the right - continuous distribution function of a probability measure on @xmath60 . the set of its growth points coincides with the @xmath25-almost - sure spectrum @xmath61 $ ] of @xmath47 . it is shown in @xcite that the laplacians are related to each other by a unitary involution , which implies the symmetries @xmath62 for their integrated densities of states for all @xmath63 . the limits on the right - hand sides of ensure that the discontinuity points of @xmath59 are approached from the correct side . [ fininf ] by ergodicity , definition [ ndef ] of the integrated density of states coincides with the usual one in terms of a macroscopic limit of a finite - volume eigenvalue counting function . more precisely , let @xmath64 stand for bounded cubes centred at the origin with volume @xmath65 . for every @xmath46 let @xmath66 be the finite - volume restriction of @xmath47 to @xmath67 introduced in def . 1.11 in @xcite . then there exists a set @xmath68 of full probability , @xmath69 , such that @xmath70\ ] ] holds for all @xmath71 and all @xmath72 , except for the ( at most countably many ) discontinuity points of @xmath59 , see lemma 1.12 in @xcite . in section [ lifshitsproof ] we will construct another finite - volume restriction of @xmath13 , for which holds , too . let @xmath73 denote the critical bond probability of the percolation transition in @xmath17 . we recall that @xmath74 for @xmath75 , otherwise @xmath760,1[$ ] , see e.g. @xcite . despite the title of this paper , our first main result covers the non - percolating phase @xmath770,p_{c}[$ ] and the critical point @xmath78 , too . [ lifshits ] assume @xmath79 and @xmath290,1[$ ] . then the integrated density of states @xmath59 of the laplacian @xmath47 on bond - percolation graphs in @xmath17 exhibits a _ lifshits tail _ at the lower spectral edge @xmath80 and at the upper spectral edge @xmath81|}{\ln ( 4d -e ) } = -\ ; \frac{d}{2 } \qquad \mathit{for } \quad \mathrm{x } \in \{\mathrm{n } , \widetilde{\mathrm{d}}\ } \,.\ ] ] the theorem follows directly from the upper and lower bounds in lemma [ liflemma ] below , together with the subsequent remark [ lifrelate ] . in fact , the bounds of lemma [ liflemma ] provide a slightly stronger statement than theorem [ lifshits ] . [ lifrelate ] the lifshits tails at the upper spectral edge are related to the ones at the lower spectral edge by the symmetries . in the non - percolating phase , @xmath770,p_{c}[$ ] , the content of the theorem is known from @xcite , where it is proved by a different method . the method of @xcite , however , does not seem to extend to the critical point or the percolating phase , @xmath82p_{c},1[$ ] . the lifshits asymptotics of theorem [ lifshits ] are determined by those parts of the percolation graphs , which contain large , fully - connected cubes . this also explains why the spatial dimension enters the lifshits exponent @xmath9 . [ bikorem ] we expect that can be refined in the case @xmath83 as to obtain the constant @xmath84 an analogous statement is known from thm . 1.3 in @xcite for the case of _ site_-percolation graphs . moreover , it is demonstrated in @xcite that the bond- and the site - percolation cases have similar large - deviation properties . our second main result complements theorem [ lifshits ] in the percolating phase . [ hove ] assume @xmath85 and @xmath29p_{c},1[$ ] . then the integrated density of states of the neumann laplacian @xmath86 on bond - percolation graphs in @xmath17 exhibits a _ van hove asymptotics _ at the lower spectral edge @xmath87}{\ln e } = \frac{d}{2 } \,,\ ] ] while that of the dirichlet laplacian @xmath88 exhibits one at the upper spectral edge @xmath89}{\ln ( 4d -e ) } = \frac{d}{2 } \,,\ ] ] where @xmath90 . the theorem follows directly from the upper and lower bounds in lemma [ hovelemma ] below , together with the symmetries . in fact , the bounds of lemma [ hovelemma ] provide a slightly stronger statement than theorem [ hove ] . lemma [ hovelemma ] relies mainly on recent estimates @xcite for the long - time decay of the heat kernel of @xmath86 on the percolating cluster . the reference value @xmath91 in results from the mean number density of zero eigenvalues of the neumann laplacian @xcite . it is given by @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the mean number density of clusters , see e.g. chap . 4 in @xcite , and @xmath94 the mean number density of isolated vertices . the counterpart of theorem [ hove ] for the non - percolating phase , @xmath770,p_{c}[$ ] , was proved in @xcite . there , @xmath5 was shown to have a different kind of lifshits asymptotics with a lifshits exponent @xmath4 at the lower spectral edge , see also section [ intro ] , and the same is true for @xmath95 at the upper spectral edge . this type of lifshits behaviour is caused by large ( isolated ) linear clusters , which explains why the spatial dimension does not influence the lifshits exponent . this behaviour is also present for @xmath77p_{c},1[$ ] , but hidden under the more dominant van hove asymptotics caused by the percolating cluster . at the critical point @xmath78 , the behaviour of @xmath5 at the lower spectral edge , respectively that of @xmath95 at the upper spectral edge , is an open problem in this section we prove the lifshits - tail behaviour of theorem [ lifshits ] . thanks to the symmetries , it suffices to consider the lower spectral edge only . [ liflemma ] for every @xmath79 and every @xmath770,1[$ ] there exist constants @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath980,\infty[$ ] such that @xmath99 holds for all @xmath1000 , \varepsilon_{\mathrm{d}}[$ ] . the left inequality in , i.e. the lower bound on @xmath95 , was proved in lemma 2.9 in @xcite . the middle one simply reflects the operator inequality @xmath101 , which is valid for all @xmath30 . so it remains to prove the upper bound on @xmath102 . we follow the strategy of the proof in @xcite , see also chap . 2.1 in @xcite . to do so , we have to fix some notation , first . given a bounded cube @xmath103 and @xmath104 , we introduce the boundary degree @xmath105 as the cardinality of the set of edges in the regular lattice @xmath15 that connect @xmath36 with @xmath106 . the restriction @xmath107 with @xmath108 of any realisation @xmath35 of a bond - percolation graph to @xmath109 is obtained by keeping only vertices and edges within @xmath109 , and @xmath110 stands for the associated vertex degree of @xmath104 . in particular , @xmath111 is the edge set of the fully connected cube @xmath112 , that is the restriction of the regular lattice @xmath15 to @xmath109 . finally , let @xmath67 be the hilbert space of complex - valued ( finite ) sequences indexed by @xmath109 , and , given any subgraph @xmath113 of @xmath114 , we introduce the operator @xmath115 , @xmath116 , where @xmath117 for all @xmath118 and all @xmath104 . now , we define the restriction of the pseudo - dirichlet laplacian @xmath13 to the cube @xmath109 with neumann conditions along the boundary @xmath119 of @xmath109 as the random bounded self - adjoint operator @xmath120 with realisations @xmath121 for all @xmath122 . next we claim that @xmath123\ ] ] holds for all @xmath63 . this is so , because ( i ) the operator @xmath124 differs from the finite - volume restriction @xmath125 in remark [ fininf ] by a perturbation whose rank is at most of the order of @xmath126 , the surface area of the cube @xmath109 . hence , remains true for @xmath127 and with @xmath125 being replaced by @xmath124 on its right - hand side , @xmath128\,.\ ] ] ( ii ) on the other hand , @xmath124 is designed in such a way that @xmath129 holds on @xmath130 for all bounded cubes @xmath131 with @xmath132 and for all @xmath30 . hence , @xmath133 gives rise to a subergodic process and we conclude from the ackoglu krengel subergodic theorem that the right - hand side of equals the right - hand side of again for all continuity points of the limit and uniformly for @xmath134 in a set of probability one . ( iii ) from this we have for all continuity points of both sides . but since both sides of are right - continuous functions of @xmath135 , equality holds for all @xmath63 , and the derivation is complete . from we infer the upper bound @xmath136\,,\ ] ] where the non - negative random variable @xmath137 stands for the smallest eigenvalue of the random operator @xmath120 . the aim is to obtain a simple large - deviation estimate for the probability in . this will be achieved with the help of analytic perturbation theory along the lines of @xcite , see also sec . in @xcite . we write @xmath138 for the neumann laplacian of the fully connected cube @xmath114 and @xmath139 . given @xmath140 $ ] , we introduce @xmath141 so that @xmath142 . we want to construct an upper bound for the probability that @xmath137 is small . denoting the bottom eigenvalue of @xmath143 by @xmath144 , we use the following ideas . [ monotone ] the function @xmath58 \ni t \mapsto e_{\lambda}(t)$ ] is non - decreasing , @xmath145 and @xmath146 . [ aptapply ] this function can be linearised , if its argument is small enough . more precisely , there exist constants @xmath1470,\infty[$ ] , which depend only on the spatial dimension @xmath0 , such that @xmath148 for all @xmath149 $ ] . here , we have set @xmath150 . [ largedev ] the slope @xmath151 obeys a large - deviation estimate . given any @xmath1520 , 1-p[$ ] , there exists a constant @xmath1530,\infty[$ ] , which depends on @xmath2 and @xmath0 , such that @xmath154 \le \e^{-\gamma |\lambda| } \,.\ ] ] we will prove with a perron frobenius argument in lemma [ groundstate ] and discuss observations and below . for the time being , let us go on to estimate the probability that @xmath137 is small . suppose @xmath155 . then we conclude from , the triangle inequality and that @xmath156 provided @xmath157 is small enough . so we need to adjust @xmath158 and @xmath159 such that @xmath160 . moreover , we aim to achieve that the right - hand side of is bounded from above by some @xmath161 . this is accomplished in the following way . without restriction we can assume that , in addition , @xmath162 . then we set @xmath163 and choose the size of the cube such that @xmath164 for this to make sense , the right - hand side of has to exceed 2 . so , we restrict ourselves to low energies , say @xmath1650 , \varepsilon_{\mathrm{d}}[$ ] , and summarise this argument as @xmath166 note that @xmath96 depends only on @xmath2 and @xmath0 . altogether , we infer from eq . , observation , implication and observation that @xmath167 \le \mathbb{p } [ e'_{\lambda_{e}}(0 ) \le \alpha ] \le \e^{-\gamma |\lambda_{e}| } \le \e^{-\alpha_{u}e^{-d/2 } } \,,\ ] ] where @xmath1680,\infty[$ ] is a constant that depends only on @xmath2 and @xmath0 . next , we verify observations and above . observation relies on a deterministic result from analytic perturbation theory . to this end we consider the operator family @xmath169 for @xmath170 . here , @xmath171 is the neumann laplacian of @xmath114 and @xmath172 the perturbation with @xmath30 arbitrary , but fixed . the bottom eigenvalue @xmath173 of @xmath174 is an isolated simple eigenvalue . its isolation distance @xmath175 is determined by the magnitude of the smallest non - zero eigenvalue of @xmath174 . this distance obeys the estimate @xmath176 for some constant @xmath1770,\infty[$ ] , which follows from reducing the eigenvalue problem for @xmath174 to that of a linear chain by separation of variables and applying a cheeger - type inequality , see e.g. ( 2.6 ) in @xcite . moreover , we have the uniform bound @xmath178 for the operator norm of the perturbation so that @xmath179 has one isolated eigenvalue @xmath180 in the complex disc @xmath181 provided @xmath182 . we refer to @xcite , chap . ii , 1 , secs . 1 , 2 and chap . vii , 3 , secs . 1 , 2 and 4 for a detailed exposition of the general method . elementary function theory then gives an estimate for the second derivative of @xmath180 , and taylor s theorem yields . details of the argument , geared towards our application here , can also be found in sec . 4.1.10 in @xcite . concerning observation , we refer again to analytic perturbation theory . the feynman hellmann formula yields @xmath183 where @xmath184 , the normalised vector in @xmath67 with equal components , is the ground state of the unperturbed operator @xmath185 . therefore , recalling @xmath186 and the definition in , we have @xmath187 for all @xmath30 . we recall that the @xmath188 s , which indicate the presence of an edge in the bond - percolation graph , are i.i.d . bernoulli distributed with mean @xmath2 . hence , follows from standard large - deviation estimates , see e.g. inequality ( 27.4 ) in @xcite or thm . 1.4 in @xcite . so far we have deferred the proof of observation in the above demonstration . this is a deterministic result which we address now in [ groundstate ] let @xmath189 be a bounded cube , let @xmath190 be a subgraph of the fully connected cube @xmath114 and let @xmath191 be the finite - volume laplacian on @xmath67 . for @xmath192 let @xmath193 be the smallest eigenvalue of @xmath194 where @xmath195 . then the function @xmath58 \ni t \mapsto \mathfrak{e}(t)$ ] is non - decreasing . we observe from the definition of @xmath196 and that @xmath197 for all @xmath198 and all @xmath104 . given @xmath140 $ ] let us rewrite @xmath199 . in particular , @xmath200 acts as @xmath201 for all @xmath198 and all @xmath104 . equations and show that the self - adjoint linear operator @xmath202 which lives on the finite - dimensional hilbert space @xmath203 , has only non - negative matrix elements @xmath204 for all @xmath205 . together with the min - max principle , this implies that one can choose the eigenvector(s ) corresponding to the _ largest _ eigenvalue of @xmath206 in such a way that all their components in the basis @xmath207 are non - negative . hence , the same is true for the eigenvector(s ) corresponding to the _ smallest _ eigenvalue of @xmath208 . thus , another application of the min - max principle yields @xmath209 for all @xmath210 , because the scalar product involving @xmath196 is non - negative by . in this section we prove the van hove asymptotics of theorem [ hove ] . again , it suffices to consider the lower spectral edge , because of the symmetries . that asymptotics follows from let @xmath216 denote the event that the origin belongs to the percolating cluster and , for @xmath63 , define @xmath217 which is the contribution of the percolating cluster to the integrated density of states of the neumann laplacian . we write @xmath218 for its laplace transform , where @xmath219 . as is well known , the laplace transform of can be related to the mean return probability of a continuous - time , simple random walk @xmath220 on the percolating cluster . more precisely , this random walk is the markov process on @xmath221 defined by the following set of rules : suppose the process is at @xmath222 . then , after having waited there for an exponential time of parameter one , one of the @xmath223 neighbours of @xmath36 in @xmath221 , say @xmath224 , is chosen at random with probability @xmath225 . if @xmath226 , then the process jumps immediately to @xmath224 , otherwise there will be no move . the procedure then starts afresh . assuming that @xmath227 is the starting point of the process , we denote its law by @xmath228 . the process @xmath229 is generated by the neumann laplacian in the sense that the transition probability for going from @xmath36 to @xmath224 within time @xmath157 is given by @xmath230 for all @xmath231 and all @xmath232 in the same connected component as @xmath36 and @xmath224 . from this it follows that @xmath233 hence , @xmath234 is the ( conditional ) mean return probability at time @xmath235 for the process on the percolating cluster for @xmath236p_{c},1]$ ] . [ heatkernel ] assume @xmath85 and @xmath29p_{c},1[$ ] . then there exist constants @xmath2370,\infty[$ ] and @xmath2381,\infty[$ ] , all of which depend only on @xmath2 and @xmath0 , such that @xmath239 holds for all @xmath240 . in view of , the lower bound in proposition [ heatkernel ] can be found as eq . ( 30 ) in appendix d in @xcite . that paper also contains a `` quenched '' upper bound , i.e. an upper bound for @xmath241 , which is valid for @xmath25-almost every @xmath242 . unfortunately , it is not clear how to take the probabilistic expectation thereof , that is , to get an `` annealed '' upper bound . on the other hand , the authors of @xcite prove an annealed upper bound in their thm . 8.1 . but this bound includes an additional logarithmic factor . the strongest results , both annealed and quenched , are those of barlow @xcite , and is a special case thereof . however , his results apply to a random walk which is generated by @xmath243 instead of @xmath86 . hence , some additional comments are needed to adapt his results , and we address this issue now . according to the preceding remark the proposition is established , if we show that barlow s quenched upper bound for the return probability , i.e. the special case @xmath244 of the upper bound in thm . 2 in @xcite , applies also to the random walk generated by @xmath86 . eventually , the upper bound in thm . 2 in @xcite is reduced to prop . 3.1 in @xcite via thm . 1 , 6.1 , thm . 5.7 and thm . 3.8 the latter being nothing but the off - diagonal generalisation of prop . 3.1 , so we do not need it here . the reduction does not make use of any specific properties of the random walk s generator . hence , all that remains to check is prop . 3.1 . in @xcite . it turns out that some of the constants in the proof of prop . 3.1 must be modified for our purpose , but this does not have any consequences . in addition , the proof of prop . 3.1 also requires estimates ( 1.7 ) and ( 1.8 ) of lemma 1.1 in @xcite . estimate ( 1.8 ) follows from estimate ( 1.5 ) , as is argued in the proof of lemma 1.1(b ) in @xcite . this argument applies in our situation , too . so , in the end , we have to verify the validity of ( 1.7 ) and ( 1.5 ) in @xcite for the random walk generated by @xmath86 . estimate ( 1.5 ) is seen to hold as a special case of cor . 11 in @xcite . the upper bound in estimate ( 1.7 ) can be inferred , for example , from thm . ii.5 in @xcite , which is a general result for ultracontractive markov semigroups . ( actually , we refer to the first of the two theorems with the same number ii.5 in @xcite . ) to verify statement ( ii ) of that theorem , one may use the application following it together with the reasoning in cor . v.2 and its proof with the choice @xmath245 . this choice corresponds to a weak isoperimetric inequality which merely reflects that the percolating cluster contains an infinitely long path . from this point of view , the weak @xmath246-decay of the upper bound in estimate ( 1.7 ) does not come as a surprise . finally , the lower bound in estimate ( 1.7 ) arises solely from the uniform growth condition @xmath247 for the volume of a ball around @xmath222 with radius @xmath248 . such type of results are well known for heat kernels on manifolds and also for discrete - time random walks @xcite . to employ them here , we decompose @xmath249 \text{jumps up to time $ t$ } \end{array } \biggr)\,,\ ] ] using the stochastic independence of all building blocks of @xmath229 . here , the contraction @xmath250 is the transition matrix of a discrete - time random walk on @xmath221 , which controls the directions of the jumps of @xmath229 . the number of attempted jumps up to time @xmath157 is governed by a poisson distribution with mean @xmath157 . using this , the lower bound in ( 1.7 ) follows from thm . 3(ii ) in @xcite applied to @xmath251 . [ tauber ] let @xmath252 be a positive borel measure on @xmath253 . suppose there are constants @xmath2540,\infty[$ ] such that the laplace transform @xmath255 exists for all @xmath240 and obeys @xmath256 then there exist constants @xmath2570,\infty[$ ] such that @xmath258\bigr ) \le c_{u } e^{\delta}\ ] ] holds for all @xmath1650 , t_{0}^{-1}]$ ] . we express @xmath259 ) = \int_{\mathbb{r}^{+}}\mu(\d\lambda ) \ , \theta ( 1- \lambda /e)$ ] in terms of the right - continuous heaviside unit - step function and observe the elementary inequality @xmath260 , which is valid for all @xmath261 and all @xmath262 . the upper bound in is obvious now . for the lower bound , one has to choose @xmath263 large enough such that the constant , which arises from the application of both estimates in , is strictly positive . proposition [ heatkernel ] and lemma [ tauber ] establish the desired van hove bounds for @xmath266 . therefore , it remains to show that the finite clusters do not spoil this behaviour . since @xmath267 for all @xmath268 , only an appropriate upper bound is required for the contribution of the finite clusters . we shall show in eq . below that @xmath269 obeys even a lifshits - type upper bound , which will then complete the proof . the lifshits behaviour for the contribution of the finite clusters in the percolating phase arises from the cluster - size distribution in the same way as it was shown to arise in the non - percolating phase in @xcite . indeed , we have @xmath270 for all @xmath1650,\infty[$ ] . here @xmath271 is the event that the origin belongs to a finite cluster , say @xmath272 , and @xmath273 denotes the number of its vertices . inequality follows from repeating the steps that lead to the first inequality in eq . ( 2.24 ) in @xcite with @xmath274 instead of @xmath5 . for @xmath11 the cluster - size distribution on the right - hand side of decays sub - exponentially according to thm . 8.6.5 in @xcite so that we obtain @xmath275 for all @xmath1000,\infty[$ ] with some constants @xmath2760,\infty[$ ] , which depend only on @xmath2 and @xmath0 . this completes the proof .

we investigate laplacians on supercritical bond - percolation graphs with different boundary conditions at cluster borders . the integrated density of states of the dirichlet laplacian is found to exhibit a lifshits tail at the lower spectral edge , while that of the neumann laplacian shows a van hove asymptotics , which results from the percolating cluster . at the upper spectral edge , the behaviour is reversed . and laplacian , percolation , integrated density of states

astro-ph0406007

neutral hydrogen gas ( ) on the edges of spiral galaxies is only very loosely gravitationally bound . therefore , when spiral galaxies interact , the outer can be easily disturbed ( hibbard & van gorkom 1996 ) . during a merger , the may be heated and ionised , or may cool into molecular ( @xmath4 ) clouds within the remnant ( hibbard & van gorkom 1996 ) . it may be tidally driven into the centre of the galaxy and converted into molecular gas , or it could be turned into stars when tidal streams collide and become compressed . the gas may also escape the interacting system and disperse , becoming too diffuse to detect , or perhaps ionised . this paper re - examines the evidence for deficiency in compact groups of galaxies using a new survey , the parkes all sky survey . compact groups of galaxies are excellent places to look for interactions and mergers between ( spiral ) galaxies . a compact group is defined as having several galaxies with similar redshifts within a small area of the sky , which are also isolated from surrounding galaxies . this ensures that the cores of clusters are excluded from the definition . a compact group generally has a low velocity dispersion , @xmath5250 km s@xmath6 ( hickson 1997 ) , and a crossing time much smaller than the hubble time , meaning interactions and mergers are very likely . although the fraction of spirals in the field is higher ( @xmath580% ) , the fraction of compact group galaxies which are spirals is still @xmath550% ( hickson 1997 ) . although interactions are thought to be common in compact groups , the star - formation rate ( sfr ) , and the amount of molecular gas in the galaxies in the compact groups , are only weakly enhanced in comparison to field galaxies ( leon et al . they concluded that only compact groups with a very small mean separation of @xmath730 kpc had a strong @xmath4 enhancement . verdes - montenegro et al . ( 1998 ) also showed that while 20% of compact groups had an apparent deficiency of co emission , the rest had co and fir properties similar to isolated galaxies . both leon et al . ( 1998 ) and verdes - montenegro et al . ( 1998 ) concluded that tidal interactions in compact groups were very important in the groups evolution . the aim of this paper is to determine the extent to which the in compact groups has been affected by the environment . this has been investigated previously by williams & rood ( 1987 , hereafter wr87 ) , huchtmeier ( 1997 , hereafter h97 ) and verdes - montenegro et al . ( 2001 ) , all of whom observed subsamples of the hickson compact groups ( hcgs , hickson 1982 ) . their results indicated that the average amount of in the groups was between 40% and 50% of the mass expected by summing the mean mass in comparable field galaxies . williams & rood ( 1987 ) compared the content of the compact groups with that of a reference sample of loose groups ( rlg ) , and with a sample of 204 spiral galaxies in the rc2 ( de vaucouleurs et al . 1976 ) . in the south , wr87 observed hcgs 3 , 14 , 16 , 19 , 22 , 23 , 25 , 26 , 30 , 31 , 40 , 62 , 64 , 67 , 88 , 89 and 97 . the comparison loose groups were selected to have the same number of galaxies as the compact groups , and to have the same joint distribution of galaxy luminosity , hubble morphological type . the expected masses therefore were a function of the luminosity of the galaxies . twenty - seven of the 34 detected compact groups had less than the comparable loose group . a similar procedure was used by huchtmeier ( 1997 ) , using an explicit relation between the integrated blue luminosities of the groups and the expected masses of the groups . the groups observed in the south were hcgs 4 , 14 , 19 , 21 , 22 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 30 , 40 , 42 , 48 , 62 , 67 , 87 , 91 and 97 . in comparison to four nearby groups , a reference sample of 146 galaxies ( huchtmeier & richter 1988 ) , and to the virgo cluster spirals , several compact groups appeared to have a very low mass - to - blue luminosity ratio . these authors did not consider how the mass of the compact groups related to the distribution of masses in the comparison samples . instead , only the average values of the sample galaxy masses were used . however , any two galaxies with identical optical measurements ( eg . diameter , morphology , luminosity ) will not necessarily have the same mass . there may be a dependence of the mass on these observables , but the scatter in this correlation is significant . verdes - montenegro et al . ( 2001 ) compiled the data from wr87 and h97 , and added vla imaging of 16 hcgs ( 2 , 16 , 18 , 23 , 26 , 31 , 33 , 40 , 44 , 49 , 54 , 79 , 88 , 92 , 95 , 96 ) . using all 72 groups from the combined sample , verdes - montenegro et al . ( 2001 ) calculated the mean `` deficiency '' to be def@xmath8 , where def@xmath9 - \log[{\rm m(hi)}_{\rm observed}]$ ] . a comparison sample from haynes & giovanelli ( 1984 ) was used . this comparison sample is also used in this paper and is described in section [ estimators ] . calculated values of def@xmath10 suggested that compact groups contained only 40% of the mass of comparable field galaxies . verdes - montenegro et al . ( 2001 ) also deduced that an evolutionary sequence for hcgs could be followed , beginning with being associated with individual galaxies , through to the gas enveloping the entire group , to a group having no detectable . this paper compares the content of the galaxies in compact groups with estimated values of mass for field galaxies . the distribution of mass in the reference field galaxies will be specifically included in the comparison . thus it is possible to identify groups with masses outside the expected range . the upper limits of the non - detected groups are also taken into account using the statistical methods of buckley & james ( 1979 ) . this paper first deals with the selection of the group sample ( section [ samplesel ] ) , and then with the observations , reduction and the derived parameters ( section [ obsresults ] ) . the mass estimation methods are described in section [ estimators ] , as well as the estimated content of the groups . section [ discussion ] compares the relative contents of the compact groups and the reference sample . for this paper , h@xmath11 mpc@xmath6 compact groups were selected from the optical catalogues of hickson ( 1982 , hereafter h82 ) and prandoni et al . ( 1994 , hereafter p94 ) . the sample included all compact groups which had a declination @xmath12 , and a velocity @xmath13 km s@xmath6 . a total of 62 groups satisfied these criteria , and are the primary sample of this paper . hipass covers the entire southern sky up to a declination of @xmath14 , over the velocity range @xmath15 km s@xmath6 ( barnes et al . 2001 ) . using the 13-beam multibeam instrument on the parkes radio telescope , the survey was completed in march 2000 . the velocity resolution of the survey is 18.0 km s@xmath6 , and the rms noise per channel is typically 13 mjy . the hickson compact groups ( h82 ) - for which a complete catalogue of properties of the constituent galaxies is available ( hickson 1993 ) - were selected so that a direct comparison with previous results could be made . the southern compact groups ( scgs , p94 ) were selected by an automatic routine , and therefore have the potential to be a more complete and less biased sample ( p94 ) . however , there has not been a published follow - up survey of the member galaxies , and thus the scgs do not have complete redshift information . h82 selected groups from the red palomar observatory sky survey ( poss ) plates by eye , with each of the groups satisfying specific criteria . firstly , the groups needed to be compact and isolated . specifically , there needed to be at least 4 galaxies within 3 magnitudes of the brightest galaxy , all within a circle of angular radius @xmath16 , the group radius . the isolation criteria specified that there should be no galaxies within 3 magnitudes of the brightest galaxy within @xmath17 of the group centre . the magnitude concordance was used to select physically associated groups without any redshift information , while the isolation criteria ensured that the cores of clusters , and associations in clusters were not identified as compact groups . p94 selected groups in the same way as h82 , except that the search was on cosmos scans of plates taken with the united kingdom schmidt telescope ( ukst ) , and the search algorithm was machine implemented . the miriad task * mbspect * was used to inspect the hipass spectrum for each group , which was made by averaging over a region of 5@xmath185 pixels , centered on the optically determined position of the group . each hipass pixel is 4 arcminutes on a side . this 20@xmath1920@xmath20 averaging area ensures that all flux coming from the groups is accounted for , as the largest group in the sample has an optical diameter of @xmath21 . the spectra were examined by eye for emission lines , and groups with evidence of emission were selected for reobservation . the hcg spectra were searched at each group s known optical velocity ( hickson 1993 ) . the scgs however , do not have comprehensive velocity information for all their member galaxies , and thus the entire velocity range of hipass was examined at each scg position on the sky . in total , 19 hcgs and 21 scgs showed possible emission . twelve hcgs and ten scgs were clear non - detections . the primary sample for this paper is shown in table [ basicdata ] . column ( 1 ) gives the name of the compact group , and columns ( 2 ) & ( 3 ) give the position of the group in j2000 coordinates . .basic observational data for the compact group sample and pointed observations using the mx mode . descriptions of the quantities in each column are given in the text . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] finally , this result can be contrasted to that found by solanes et al . ( 2001 ) who studied the deficiency in spiral galaxies found in clusters . they found that within 1 abell radius ( 1 r@xmath22 ) of the cluster centre , spiral galaxies show strong deficiency , while in the outer parts of the cluster , the contents were similar to those found in the field . as the galactic densities of compact groups can approach that of the cores of rich clusters ( h82 ) , it is interesting then that compact groups do not show the same deficiency . solanes et al . ( 2001 ) concluded that hydrodynamical effects caused by the interaction of the with the hot intracluster medium in the centre of the clusters was the cause of the deficiency . they also found stripping was a relatively recent event ( a few gyr ago ) for the deficient galaxies , as the optical properties of the galaxies have not been affected . one possibility then for the normal content of the compact group sample investigated in this paper is the lack of a hot intragroup medium to strip the . this agrees with x - ray observations of the hcgs from ponman et al . ( 1996 ) , who concluded that only 20% of groups had diffuse x - ray emission with luminosity greater than 10@xmath23 ergs . this luminosity is an order of magnitude weaker than the weakest cluster emission reported by solanes et al . * this study has shown that southern compact groups in the hcg catalogue appear have a content consistent with the hypothesis that they are comprised of galaxies similar to those found in the field . * in comparing the mass estimation methods of hg84 and h97 , it was found that they all give similar results , although the scatter in the relationships prevents them from predicting the mass of an isolated galaxy accurately . * the observations of the detected compact groups all have measured contents within the predicted range for their expected content . however , the majority of groups were not detected in this study , and so the content of the compact group population as a whole is not yet known . * the survey has not been significantly affected by biasing due to interlopers lying far outside the group radius ; nor from faint galaxies not listed as part of the compact groups , but contributing to the mass . * the in the compact groups may have evolved through interactions , and star - formation , but it is clear that the fraction of consumed is not large . it is possible that depletion is correlated with morphological evolution towards earlier types , which would reduce the expected mass of the group . * a survey of these groups with much higher sensitivity , leading to more detections or more stringent upper limits , will give a clearer picture on their content . the authors would like to thank the hipass team for the data used for our detection experiment , and the staff at the parkes radio telescope for assistance / troubleshooting during our observing runs . thanks also to donald payne , martin zwaan , and stacey mader for observing assistance . thanks to martin meyer for the use of * mmspect * , and for providing us with the hipass catalogue . js thanks melbourne university for financial assistance through a melbourne university postgraduate scholarship . the parkes telescope is part of the australia telescope , which is funded by the commonwealth of australia for operation as a national facility managed by csiro . this work has made use of the miriad software package . this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration . barnes , d. g. , 1998 , in asp conf . ser . , 145 , astronomical data analysis software and systems vii , ed . r. albrecht , r. n. hook , h. a. bushouse ( san francisco : astronomical society of the pacific ) , p 32 barnes , d. g. , staveley - smith , l. , de blok , w. j. g. , oosterloo , t. , stewart , i. m. , wright , a. e. , banks , g. d. , bhathal , r. et al . , 2001 , mnras , 322 , 486 braun , r. , burton , w. b. , 1999 , a&a , 341 , 437 buckley , j. , james , i. , 1979 , biometrika , 66 , 429 chamaraux , p. , 1987 , a&a , 177 , 326 chamaraux , p. , balkowski , c. , fontanelli , p. , 1986 , a&a , 165 , 15 de vaucouleurs , g. , de vaucouleurs , a. , corwin , h. g. , 1976 , in second reference catalogue of bright galaxies , ( austin : university of texas press ) haynes , m. p. , giovanelli , r. , 1984 , aj , 89 , 758 hibbard , j. e. , van gorkom , j. h. , 1996 , aj , 111 , 655 hickson , p. , 1982 , apj , 255 , 382 hickson , p. , 1993 , in atlas of compact groups of galaxies , ( new york : gordon and breach science publishers ) hickson , p. , 1997 , ara&a , 35 , 357 huchtmeier , w. k. , 1997 , a&a , 325 , 473 huchtmeier , w. k. , richter , o. g. , 1988 , a&a , 203 , 237 isobe , t. , feigelson , e. d. , nelson , p. i. , 1986 , apj , 306 , 490 karachentseva , v. e. , 1973 , astrofizicheskie issledovaniia izvestiya spetsialnoj astrofizicheskoj observatorii , 8 , 3 leon , s. , combes , f. , menon , t. k. 1998 , a&a , 330 , 37 meyer , m. , zwaan , m. , webster , r.l . , staveley - smith , l. , ryan - weber , e. , drinkwater , m.j . , barnes , d.g . , howlett , m. et al . 2004 , mnras , 350 , 1195 nilson , p. , 1973 , in uppsala general catalogue of galaxies , ( acta universitatis upsaliensis . nova acta regiae societatis scientiarum upsaliensis - uppsala astronomiska observatoriums annaler , uppsala : astronomiska observatorium ) ponman , t. , bourner , p. d. j. , ebeling , h. , 1996 , roentgenstrahlung from the universe , 357 prandoni , i. , iovino , a. , macgillivray , h. t. , 1994 , aj , 107 , 1235 sadler , e. m. , oosterloo , t. , morganti , r. , 2002 , in the dynamics , structure & history of galaxies , ( san francisco : astronomical society of the pacific ) , 215 sandage , a. , tammann , g. a. , 1981 , in revised shapley - ames catalog of bright galaxies , ( washington , d.c . : carnegie institute of washington ) schneider , s. e. , helou , g. , salpeter , e. e. , terzian , y. , 1986 , aj , 92 , 742 solanes , j. m. , manrique , a. , garcia - gomez , c. , gonzalez - casado , g. , giovanelli , r. , haynes , m. p. , 2001 , apj , 548 , 97 verdes - montenegro , l. , yun , m. s. , perea , j. , del olmo , a. , ho , p. t. p. 1998 , apj , 497 , 89 verdes - montenegro , l. , yun , m. s. , williams , b. a. , huchtmeier , w. k. , del , olmo a. , perea , j. , 2001 , a&a , 377 , 812 williams , b. a. , rood , h. j. , 1987 , apjs , 63 , 265 zepf , s. e. , de carvalho , r. r. , ribeiro , a. l. b. 1997 , apjl , 488 , 11

the content of hickson compact groups in the southern hemisphere is measured using data from the parkes all - sky survey ( hipass ) , and dedicated observations using the narrow band filter on the multibeam instrument on the parkes telescope . the expected mass of these groups was estimated using the luminosity , diameter and morphological types of the member galaxies , calibrated from published data . taking careful account of non - detection limits , the results show that the compact group population that has been detected by these observations has an content similar to that of galaxies in the reference field sample . the upper limits for the undetected groups lie within the normal range ; improvement of these limits will require a large increase in sensitivity . = 2em = 15.5 cm = 22.6 cm = -1.0 cm = 0.5 cm = 0.5 cm @xmath0school of physics , university of melbourne , victoria , australia 3010 + affiliated with the australia telescope national facility , csiro + @xmath1school of physics , university of melbourne , victoria , australia 3010 + @xmath2nsf mps distinguished research fellow , australia telescope national facility , epping , new south wales , australia 1710 + @xmath3department of physics , university of queensland , queensland , australia 4072 + * keywords : * galaxies : evolution - galaxies : interactions - methods : observational

1702.03997

the plasma membrane is a complex fluid where lipids and proteins continuously interact and generate signaling platforms in order to communicate with the outside world . one of the key mechanisms by which membrane molecules search reaction sites is based on lateral diffusion . quantitative imaging methods , such as single - particle tracking @xcite , spatiotemporal image correlation spectroscopy @xcite , fluorescence correlation spectroscopy ( fcs ) @xcite , and sted - fcs @xcite , show that the dynamics of proteins and lipids in the plasma membrane often deviate from normal diffusion . in particular , the mean square displacement ( msd ) does not grow linearly in time as expected for brownian motion @xcite . this behavior suggests processes that hinder diffusion . since the formation of protein complexes is governed by diffusion - mediated encounters , hindered diffusion plays fundamental roles in cell function . unveiling the underlying mechanisms leading to the observed anomalous diffusion on the cell membrane is critical to understanding cell behavior . anomalous diffusion in the plasma membrane can be caused by macromolecular crowding @xcite , transient binding @xcite , heterogeneities @xcite , and membrane compartmentalization by the underlying cytoskeleton @xcite . in recent years it has become evident that a single mechanism can not account for the complex dynamics observed in the plasma membrane @xcite . we have shown that interactions with clathrin coated pits ( ccps ) cause anomalous diffusion and ergodicity breaking @xcite . however , it was observed that this process coexisted with a different anomalous diffusion mechanism attributed to diffusion within a fractal topology . experimental evidence for the organization of the plasma membrane by the cortical actin cytoskeleton has been provided by measurements in cell blebs , spherical protrusions that lack actin cytoskeleton @xcite , and in the presence of actin - disrupting agents @xcite . the picket - fence model explains these observations by postulating that the mobility of membrane - bound molecules is hindered by the actin - based cytoskeleton in close proximity to the plasma membrane , leading to transient confinement @xcite . confinement and segregation of membrane components can have important physiological consequences by allowing the formation of functional domains on the cell surface . however , in spite of the vast evidence that has accumulated over the last two decades , a direct observation of the dynamic compartmentalization of membrane proteins by underlying actin fences is challenging due to the spatial and temporal resolutions required for its visualization . here we employ superresolution imaging and single - particle tracking of membrane proteins to elucidate the compartmentalization of the plasma membrane by intracellular structures . while tracking individual voltage - gated potassium channels as described in our previous studies @xcite , we found that these membrane proteins exhibited anomalous diffusion on the cell surface . we now report that the anticorrelated dynamics are best modeled by obstructed diffusion instead of fractional brownian motion and we directly visualize the transient confinement of potassium channels by cortical actin in live cells . in order to characterize the cortical actin meshwork , we employ stochastic optical reconstruction microscopy ( storm ) to obtain superresolution images in fixed cells . we find a non - integer fractal dimension for the actin cortex and a broad distribution of compartment sizes as expected for a self - similar structure . these observations consistently explain the anticorrelated subdiffusive motion of membrane proteins and provide new insights on the hierarchical organization of the plasma membrane . voltage - gated potassium channels kv1.4 and kv2.1 were expressed in human embryonic kidney ( hek ) cells , labeled with quantum dots ( qds ) @xcite , and imaged using total internal reflection fluorescence ( tirf ) microscopy at 50 frames / s , so that individual molecules could be detected on the cell surface . kv1.4 and 2.1 are similar in size , 654 and 853 amino acids , respectively , but share less than 20% overall amino acid identity @xcite . they are placed into distinct gene subfamilies because of this low identity . they are most similar within a central core domain composed of six transmembrane alpha helices and the ion conducting pore . in contrast , they share no amino sequence identity within the cytoplasmic n- and c - terminal regions ; each kv1.4 subunit has 402 cytoplasmic amino acids while the kv2.1 subunits have 624 . both channels exist as homotetrameric structures giving the functional channel 24 membrane spanning domains and a total of either 1608 or 2496 cytoplasmic amino acids . figure [ fig : turn](a ) shows representative trajectories of kv1.4 channels . the motion of the ion channels was initially evaluated in terms of their time - averaged msd , @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the total experimental time , @xmath2 the particle position , and @xmath3 the lag time , i.e. , the time difference over which the msd is computed . when a particle displays brownian diffusion , the msd is linear in lag time , i.e. , @xmath4 . in contrast , anomalous diffusion is characterized by a different msd scaling , namely msd @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the anomalous exponent . anomalous diffusion is classified as subdiffusion when @xmath7 and superdiffusion when @xmath8 . figure [ fig : turn](b ) shows the msd of 20 individual trajectories . the msds of kv1.4 as well as kv2.1 channels show subdiffusive behavior , albeit with large apparent fluctuations . figures [ fig : turn](c ) and [ fig : turn](d ) show the msds averaged over 1,312 kv1.4 ( @xmath9 cells ) and 6,385 kv2.1 ( @xmath10 cells ) trajectories , respectively , @xmath11 . throughout the manuscript we employ overlines to denote time averages and brackets to denote ensemble averages . the anomalous exponent @xmath6 of kv1.4 was found to be 0.89 and that of kv2.1 was 0.74 , indicating subdiffusion in both cases . several distinct mathematical models lead to subdiffusion @xcite . among the most well - accepted types of subdiffusion in biological systems , we encounter ( i ) obstructed diffusion , ( ii ) fractional brownian motion ( fbm ) , and ( iii ) continuous time random walks ( ctrw ) . both fbm @xcite and obstructed diffusion @xcite are models for subdiffusive random walks with anticorrelated increments that have been extensively used in live cells . fbm describes the motion in a viscoelastic fluid @xcite , which can be caused by macromolecular crowding @xcite . fbm is a generalization of brownian motion that incorporates correlations with power - law memory . it is characterized by a hurst exponent @xmath12 that translates into an anomalous exponent @xmath13 . obstructed diffusion describes the motion of a particle hindered by immobile ( or slowly moving ) obstacles , e.g. , percolation . as the concentration of immobile obstacles increases , the availability of space decreases . near a critical concentration known as percolation threshold , the obstacles form a fractal with dead ends in all length scales . in particular , the reduction of the available space results in anomalous diffusion with a recurrent exploration pattern . a ctrw is a generalization of a random walk where a particle waits for a random time between steps @xcite . when the waiting times are asymptotically distributed according to a power law such that the mean waiting time diverges , the ctrw is subdiffusive . these three models describe very distinct physical underlying mechanisms but they can yield similar sublinear msd scaling , particularly in obstructed diffusion and fbm models . thus the msd analysis is insufficient to elucidate the type of random walk . different tests beyond the msd have been employed to distinguish among types of subdiffusive random walks , including _ p_-variations @xcite , first passage probability distribution @xcite , mean maximal excursion @xcite , gaussianity @xcite , and fractal dimensions @xcite . here we employ the distribution of directional changes , i.e. , the turning angles , a tool that probes correlations in the particle displacements and has been shown to contain information on the complexity of a random walk @xcite . figure [ fig : turn](e ) illustrates the construction of turning angles from a particle trajectory . in simple brownian motion , the turning angles are uniformly distributed . contrastingly , when the steps are correlated the distribution of turning angles is not uniform @xcite . figures [ fig : turn](f ) and [ fig : turn](g ) show the distribution of turning angles of kv1.4 and kv2.1 for different lag times ( 1,312 kv1.4 tracks , 10 cells and 6,385 kv2.1 tracks , 14 cells ) . both distributions peak at @xmath14 indicating the particles are more likely to turn back than to move forward . in other words , kv channels have a preference to go in the direction from where they came rather than to persist moving in the same direction . this property is a fingerprint of subdiffusive random walks with anticorrelated increments . besides the shape of the distribution , the dependence on lag time bears valuable information . strikingly , we observe that the distribution is independent of lag time , i.e. , we measure the same distribution of directional changes whether the lag time is 20 ms or 1 s. we examined numerical simulations of fbm and obstructed diffusion and found that they have distinctive attributes in their distribution of directional changes . figure [ fig : turn](h ) shows the distribution of directional changes for subdiffusive fbm simulations with hurst exponents @xmath15 and @xmath16 . even though the distributions peak at @xmath17 , the probability density function is different from the experimental data [ figs . [ fig : turn](f ) and [ fig : turn](g ) ] . in our experimental data , the turning angle distributions increase sharply as @xmath18 approaches @xmath17 and most of the deviations from a uniform distribution are above @xmath19 . however , fbm gives rise to a gradual increase that takes place mainly in the range @xmath20 . further , the turning angles of fbm reach a plateau , in contrast to our measurements . conversely , obstructed diffusion , strongly resembles our experimental results . figure [ fig : turn](i ) shows the turning angle distribution for obstructed diffusion simulations in a square lattice with obstacle concentrations @xmath21 and @xmath22 @xcite . note that @xmath22 is slightly above the percolation threshold . these results show that the motion of kv channels in the plasma membrane is better modeled by percolation , i.e. , obstructed diffusion , rather than motion in a viscoelastic medium , i.e. , fbm . potential obstacle candidates for obstructed diffusion in the plasma membrane are the cortical cytoskeleton , lipid rafts , and extracellular glycans . by evaluating the msd and turning angle distribution of @xmath3c318 , a mutant in which the last 318 amino acids of the c - terminus of kv2.1 channel had been deleted @xcite , we found that the anticorrelated diffusion originates from interactions with intracellular structures . we observed that @xmath3c318 channels diffuse freely in the plasma membrane , @xmath23 with a diffusion coefficient @xmath24/s [ fig . [ fig : turn](j ) , n=3114 tracks , 5 cells ] . further , the distribution of turning angles of @xmath3c318 was flattened , as expected for brownian diffusion [ fig . [ fig : turn](k ) ] , indicating the intracellular c terminal domain of kv2.1 plays a key role in the anticorrelations within the particle trajectory . even though the distribution of turning angles in the @xmath3c318 mutant is close to that in brownian motion , a small peak is still noticeable at @xmath17 suggesting additional complexities in the plasma membrane . in contrast to kv1.4 , which is homogeneously distributed on the cell membrane , a subpopulation of kv2.1 channels forms micron - sized clusters that localize to endoplasmic reticulum ( er)-plasma membrane junctions @xcite . thus , we expect both the er and the cortical cytoskeleton introduce intracellular interactions with kv2.1 channels . to identify the origin of the observed anticorrelated diffusion , we analyzed the motion of non - clustered kv2.1 channels , i.e. , the channels that reside outside er - plasma membrane junctions . we labeled kv2.1 channels both with green fluorescent protein ( gfp ) and qds @xcite . while all the channels were labeled with gfp , only a small fraction included qds in order to enable both single - particle tracking and cluster identification [ supplementary fig . we observed that the distribution of directional changes of non - clustered channels is indistinguishable from that of the overall population [ supplementary fig thus , we can exclude interactions with the er as the cause for anticorrelated subdiffusion . these observations suggest that diffusion is hindered by intracellular components , possibly the cortical cytoskeleton , in agreement with a membrane - skeleton fence model @xcite . we observed that the distribution of turning angles were independent of lag times [ figs . [ fig : turn](f ) and [ fig : turn](g ) ] within the probed spatial and temporal scales . these observations indicated the anticorrelated subdiffusion of kv channels did not have an evident characteristic time scale . this type of random walk is consistent with diffusion on a self - similar structure , i.e. , a fractal subspace . in order to visualize the difference between diffusion on a fractal structure , and diffusion on a meshwork with a characteristic length scale , we performed simulations of motion of a particle in the presence of permeable fences that introduce compartments with a well - defined length scale [ supplementary fig . s3 ] . in these simulations , we observed that the distribution of turning angles is not time invariant ; the peak at @xmath17 grows as we increase the lag - time up to a characteristic time , and then it decays when the lag - time increases further [ supplementary figs . s3(b ) and s3(c ) ] . thus , hop - diffusion with a narrow distribution of confinement sizes exhibits a time - dependent turning angle distribution ( with a well - defined characteristic time scale ) , in contrast to our experimental results where the turning angle distribution is time - invariant . we observed that kv channels undergo obstructed diffusion . the @xmath3c318 mutant data indicated that hindering of the particle motion originated within cytoplasmic structures in close proximity to the plasma membrane , in agreement with previous experimental evidence of transient confinement by the actin - based cytoskeleton @xcite . thus we examined the cortical actin as a candidate for the observed obstructed diffusion in the plasma membrane . we imaged the cortical actin in live hek cells using the photoactivatable probe tdeosfp @xcite via an actin binding peptide ( abp ) that reversibly binds to f - actin @xcite . previous studies showed that expression of abp - tdeosfp does not affect the organization of the cytoskeleton @xcite . by activating a sparse subset of tdeosfp and individually localizing them with high precision , we generated photoactivated localization microscopy ( palm ) images using localizations from 100 frames ( 2 s ) , yielding a smooth video of the dynamic actin meshwork ( supplementary video s1 ) . both excitation and photoactivation were implemented in total internal reflection fluorescence ( tirf ) so that only the actin adjacent to the plasma membrane was imaged . the dissociation of abp - tdeosfp occurs with a time constant on the order of 40 s @xcite , thus the exchange within 2-s imaging is negligible . figure [ fig : effect](a ) shows a representative palm reconstruction of actin . although the number of localizations in 100 frames is not adequate to fully resolve the cortical actin and some faint fluorescent single - filament structures might be missed in the images , we could use the reconstructed palm image to study the interactions of the potassium channels with the actin cortex in live cells . previous breakthrough experiments have reported simultaneous imaging of cortical actin cytoskeleton and single - particle tracking @xcite . here , to the best of our knowledge , we perform for the first time simultaneous single - particle tracking measurements and imaging cortical actin with superresolution . in order to find out whether actin - delimited domains as identified by palm hinder diffusion and compartmentalize the cell surface , we imaged and tracked kv1.4 and kv2.1 channels on the cell surface while simultaneously imaging the cortical actin . channels often remained confined within the areas enclosed by actin indicating actin acted as a barrier to channel diffusion . figures [ fig : effect](a ) and [ fig : effect](b ) show kv2.1 channel tracks for one video overlaid on the last reconstructed image of the cortical actin . however , this visualization method suffers from overlaying long trajectories on a single reconstruction image of the actin meshwork . in addition to being constrained by actin structures , some trajectories exhibit confinement within small nanoscale domains that do not appear to be enclosed by actin . we have previously shown that kv channels exhibit frequent immobilizations when the channels are captured within clathrin - coated pits @xcite . thus , the cortical actin cytoskeleton is not the sole mechanism by which the mobility of kv channels is hindered . in order to deal with these complexities , we evaluated the msds as a function of proximity to actin . given that actin hinders channel motility , we expect the particles to explore smaller areas when they are confined within smaller compartments . to test the actin fence hypothesis , we overlaid channel trajectories on the corresponding palm image of actin obtained in 2 s , a time scale in which the actin structure is fairly persistent [ supplementary video 1 ] , with a sliding time window 0.2 s. for example , trajectories of the channels from 0 to 2 s were overlaid on the first reconstructed actin frame and the trajectories in the interval 200 ms to 2.2 s were overlaid on the second actin palm frame . then we partitioned the trajectories into 200-ms intervals and classified each segment according to the maximum distance @xmath25 of the particle to the nearest actin feature , calculated using an euclidean distance map algorithm . we evaluated the ensemble - averaged msd @xmath26 of all the segments located at a specific distance away from actin , i.e. , we averaged the squared displacements in 200 ms of the particles transiently located a given distance from actin . figures [ fig : effect](c ) and [ fig : effect](d ) show the msd as a function of distance - to - actin for kv1.4 and kv2.1 . for both channels we observed that as molecules dwell closer to actin their msd decreases . as a control of our method , we performed the same analysis for @xmath3c318 channels . because of the lack of the intracellular domain , these channels should not have any interaction with the cortical cytoskeleton . we observed that the msd of @xmath3c318 channels is independent of distance from actin [ fig . [ fig : effect](e ) ] , which demonstrates the effect of intracellular structure in the transient confinement of kv channels . when imaging live cells with palm , the number of frames used in the reconstruction is restricted by the cell dynamic nature . a low number of frames results in insufficient detected particles to accurately determine the structure , also having a deleterious effect on resolution . in contrast , very high spatial resolution can be obtained in fixed cells by collecting data over long times @xcite . therefore , we used tirf - storm to visualize the compartments formed by cortical actin in fixed cells . actin was labeled with phalloidin conjugated to alexa fluor 647 , which binds actin filaments with high specificity without significantly enlarging them @xcite . a total of 50,000 frames where used in the reconstruction . in our storm reconstructions we observed both thick and thin actin structures , fig [ fig : storm](a ) . the finest structures that we observed had a cross section standard deviation of 20 nm ( fwhm=48 nm ) . figure [ fig : storm](b ) shows the average cross section profile of 20 lines aligned by the center of each line . the thickness of these lines in the reconstruction is governed by the localization accuracy , @xmath27 nm ( mean @xmath28 sd , supplementary fig . s4 ) , which sets a lower bound on storm resolution . thus we are unable to determine whether these structures are individual filaments ( 10 nm in diameter ) or actin bundles . we employed a watershed segmentation algorithm @xcite to identify actin - delimited compartments in the storm reconstructions [ figs . [ fig : storm](c ) and [ fig : storm](d ) ] across the whole cell . the average percentage of the watershed meshwork covered by actin was @xmath29 ( mean @xmath28 sd , n=9 cells ) . figure [ fig : storm](e ) shows the distribution of compartment areas ( @xmath30 compartments ) . the areas of the compartments are fitted well by a log - normal distribution , which is a subexponential heavy - tailed distribution in the sense that it decays more slowly than any exponential tail @xcite . the log - normal distribution is in good agreement with kolmogorov s model for the distribution of particle sizes after repeated breakage @xcite . when a particle is divided into fragments in such a way that the fragment proportions are independent of the original particle size , a log - normal distribution emerges in the particle sizes after random repeated fragmentation . analogously , actin - delimited compartments are split into smaller compartments by growing actin filaments and thus their distribution is predicted to be log - normal . ( pearson correlation coefficient @xmath31 in log scales ) . representative example of box counting algorithm in one cell where the exponent yields @xmath32.,width=8 ] in addition to the compartment area distribution , the relation between perimeter and area contains valuable information . perimeter - area relations have been extensively used to investigate the properties of complex planar shapes @xcite . as expected , we observe that areas and perimeters of the different compartments are highly correlated [ fig.[fig : fractal](a ) ] . this correlation indicates shape homogeneity among different compartments @xcite . furthermore , the area exhibits the same scaling over the whole observed range , @xmath33 , where @xmath34 and @xmath35 are compartment area and perimeter , indicating the same statistical character at different scales , and suggesting that compartments formed by cortical actin are scale - invariant in the observed range . such scale invariance is a hallmark of a self - similar fractal structures . fractals are characterized by scaling properties governed by a non - integer dimension @xmath36 , i.e. , an anomalous dependence of the `` mass '' on the linear size of the system with @xmath37 . in a regular object such as a line , square , or cube , we would refer to its mass @xmath38 as the length , area or volume , respectively . in these regular cases the mass scales as @xmath39 , where the @xmath40 is the linear size and @xmath41 is the spatial dimension . on the other hand , fractals such as a sierpinsky gasket or a percolation cluster differ from euclidean spaces and display a fractional dimension @xcite . usually the capacity dimension is obtained using a box - counting algorithm that quantifies the mass scaling . in brief , the structure is placed on a grid , the number of occupied `` boxes '' are counted , and the process is iterated for finer grids . the number of occupied boxes scales as @xmath42 , where @xmath43 is the box length . figure [ fig : fractal](b ) shows the computation of the fractal dimension of the cortical actin meshwork from the storm image in a representative cell . the box counting analysis shows the actin structure exhibits statistical self - similarity over more than three decades . our data indicate the fractal dimension of the meshwork is @xmath44 ( @xmath45 cells ) . our current understanding of the plasma membrane is that of a complex partitioned fluid where molecules often undergo anomalous diffusion and can be segregated according to their function . we observe that k@xmath46 channels perform a random walk with antipersistent nature , i.e. , a random walk with an increased probability of returning to the site it just left . however elucidating the mechanisms that cause anomalous diffusion is not trivial because several different subdiffusion models lead to similar msd scaling . the analysis of k@xmath46 channel motion is further complicated by the occurrence of immobilizations with power law sojourn times , which introduce deviations from gaussian functions in the distribution of displacements @xcite . thus , we can not employ gaussianity - based tests to distinguish among complex antipersistent random walks . we find that the distribution of directional changes provides a robust test for the type of random walk . the measured channel trajectories are shown to be well described by obstructed diffusion but not by fbm . we observed that the kv2.1 intracellular domain played a key role in the anomalous diffusion , in agreement with previous observations showing that the depth at which a membrane protein extends into the cytoplasm determined how frequently it encountered mechanical barriers @xcite . the obvious candidate to obstruct the motion of proteins with large intracellular domains is the actin cytoskeleton . thus , we visualized the cortical actin with high temporal and spatial resolution and evaluated its effect on membrane protein dynamics . considering that some faint single - filament actin structures might not be accurately detected by palm imaging , we can miss some interactions between actin and membrane proteins . notwithstanding , we found that kv channels are transiently confined by permeable actin fences , confirming existing models for membrane compartmentalization as an organizing principle of the actin cytoskeleton @xcite . by studying the diffusion of kv2.1 channels outside er - plasma membrane junctions , we verified that the observed subdiffusion is not due to interactions with er . other intracellular components such as intermediate filaments could also hinder protein diffusion and further compartmentalize the cell membrane , but these cytoskeletal filaments were not studied in the present work . previous single - particle tracking works using lipids labeled with 40-nm gold nanoparticles have observed the compartmentalization of the plasma membrane of hek293 cells , with 70-nm mean compartment size @xcite . however , this compartmentalization occurs with molecules having virtually no cytoplasmic domains and with a residence time close to 3 ms . at time scales above 50 ms , gold - labeled lipids were found to exhibit brownian diffusion with an effective diffusion coefficient @xmath47 @xcite , similar to our observations for @xmath3c318 kv2.1 mutant . ion channels are observed to undergo anticorrelated anomalous diffusion over at least two orders of magnitude in time . in terms of percolation theory , this hints the cell surface is maintained close to criticality , i.e. , near the percolation threshold . however , this hypothesis seems highly unlikely . a more feasible explanation stems from the emergence of a scale - invariant structure under the plasma membrane . we directly observed that , within the probed spatial scale , the actin cortex has in fact a self - similar nature . it is possible to speculate that actin fractality develops from its branching structure . hierarchically branched structures have a fractal dimension @xmath36 such that @xmath48 , where @xmath49 is the bifurcation ratio and @xmath50 is the length - order ratio @xcite . the bifurcation ratio can be interpreted as the average number of branches that emerge after a bifurcation and the length - order ratio is defined as the ratio between incoming branch length and the length of the emerging branches until the next bifurcation @xcite . actin branching is driven by the arp2/3 complex @xcite with a bifurcation ratio @xmath51 . here we measure a meshwork fractal dimension @xmath32 , which can arise from a branching pattern with @xmath52 or , in other words , the daughter branch being on average @xmath53 shorter than the mother branch . the fractal dimension of the cytoskeleton is in line with a broad range of fractal geometries found in biology ranging from the lung alveoli to subcellular structures such as mitochondrial membranes and the endoplasmic reticulum @xcite . we propose that the fractal nature of the actin cortex is employed by the cell to organize the plasma membrane . the complexity of this structure leads to a hierarchical organization with domains in multiple length scales and the development of nested compartments . such a dynamic hierarchical organization facilitates the active segregation of domains with different functions and the maintenance of reactants near reaction centers . furthermore , the fractal nature of the cortical actin has broad implications for anomalous diffusion , for instance it could bridge the gap between the plasma membrane hop diffusion models and diffusion in a fractal that leads to anomalous dynamics over broad time scales . we foresee that a self - similar cytoskeleton structure also influences active actomyosin - mediated organization of the plasma membrane @xcite in such a way that these processes can take place over multiple length scales . in conclusion , our findings show that the plasma membrane is compartmentalized in a hierarchical fashion by a dynamic cortical actin fractal . we find that the anomalous diffusion of potassium channels is best modeled by obstructed diffusion or diffusion in a fractal . by combining palm imaging with single - particle tracking we were able to directly visualize the hindering effect of cortical actin on the diffusion of the membrane proteins . we characterized the compartments formed by cortical actin using superresolution imaging in fixed cells and found evidence for the self - similar topology of this structure . hek 293 cells ( passage 42 - 49 ; american type culture collection ) were cultured in phenol red dulbecco s modified eagle s medium ( dmem ) , supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum ( fbs ; gibco ) at 37 @xmath54c . cells were transfected to express a kv2.1 or kv1.4 construct with an extracellular biotin acceptor domain that , when coexpressed with a bacterial biotin ligase , results in biotinylated kv channels on the cell surface @xcite . for live - cell actin imaging cells were transfected with 3 @xmath55 g of abp - tdeos . abp is the actin - binding sequence of abp140 from _ s. cerevisiae _ consisting of 17 amino acids @xcite . kv2.1-loopbad - gfp ( 3 @xmath55 g ) was employed to identify kv2.1 clusters on the cell surface . for single - particle tracking , biotinylated channels were labeled with qds . cells were incubated for 10 minutes in hek imaging saline with 1 nm streptavidin - conjugated qd705 or qd655 ( invitrogen ) and 10 mg / ml bovine serum albumin ( bsa ) @xcite at 37 @xmath54c . following incubation the cells were rinsed again six times with hek imaging saline to ensure the removal of any unbound qds . the diameter of the qds is in the range 10 - 15 nm , thus given that kv channels are similar in size to the qds , it is highly unlikely that the kv : qd stoichiometry is higher than 1:1 . we have previously shown that qd conjugation does not alter kv channel diffusion @xcite . imaging was performed in an objective - based tirf microscope built around an ix71 olympus body . sample temperature was kept at 37 @xmath54c using objective and stage heater ( bioptechs ) . a 405-nm laser was used to activate tdeosfp fluorophore , while 473-nm and 561-nm lasers were used to excite it in its inactive and active states , respectively . cells were plated on matrigel - coated 35 mm petri dishes . after 12 hours the cells were fixed and labeled with alexa fluor 647-phalloidin ( invitrogen ) . image stacks were obtained using the same setup as live cell imaging . a continuous illumination of 638-nm laser was used to excite the alexa fluor 647 . the laser power before the objective was 30 mw . to maintain an appropriate density of activated molecules , 405-nm laser was used in some experiments . 50,000 frames were collected to generate a superresolution image . the fractal dimension of the actin cortex was computed using a box - counting algorithm . the thresholded binary actin image was placed on a grid of square boxes of size @xmath43 and the number of occupied boxes was counted . the process was repeated for grids of boxes with different sizes . the number of occupied boxes scales as @xmath56 where @xmath36 is the capacity dimension , or simply the fractal dimension . results show mean and s.e.m . unless indicated otherwise . all experimental results were obtained from multiple different dishes and days . the number of distinct imaging regions , i.e. , different cells is indicated in the text . we thank keith lidke and sheng liu for the codes for palm reconstruction , maxime dahan for providing the plasmids to express abp - tdeos , and aubrey weigel , liz akin , mara gracia gervasi , phil fox , ben johnson , and xinran xu for useful discussions . we gratefully acknowledge the support of nvidia corporation with the donation of a geforce gtx titan used for this research . d.k . and j.l.h . thank nikki curthoys for technical advice with superresolution microscopy during the initial stages of the project . this work was supported by the national science foundation under grant 1401432 ( to dk ) and the national institutes of health under grant r01gm109888 ( to mmt ) . 70ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * ( ) @noop * * ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) in @noop _ _ , vol . ( ) pp . @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ , vol . ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( )

a broad range of membrane proteins display anomalous diffusion on the cell surface . different methods provide evidence for obstructed subdiffusion and diffusion on a fractal space , but the underlying structure inducing anomalous diffusion has never been visualized due to experimental challenges . we addressed this problem by imaging the cortical actin at high resolution while simultaneously tracking individual membrane proteins in live mammalian cells . our data confirm that actin introduces barriers leading to compartmentalization of the plasma membrane and that membrane proteins are transiently confined within actin fences . furthermore , superresolution imaging shows that the cortical actin is organized into a self - similar meshwork . these results present a hierarchical nanoscale picture of the plasma membrane .

astro-ph0211213

we would like to know if agn really have accretion disks . predictions of the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) are hard to make , and model dependent , and so are not a robust test . instead , i consider effects that test the generic idea of blackbody emission at a range of temperatures from a flat surface . from a tilted flat surface , we should see a standard @xmath0 dimming plus whatever atmospheric limb darkening effects might apply . for superluminal sources we can derive a fairly accurate viewing angle to the jet . for a sample of 21 such sources rokaki _ et al _ ( 2002 ; see also these proceedings ) have measured the @xmath1 equivalent width ( ew ) , which gives the relative continuum brightness if the face on ew is always the same . the results show two separate effects . at small angles ew has a steep @xmath2 dependence , presumably due to relativistic jet beaming . at larger angles , ew declines more gently with @xmath2 , and the simplest model , with @xmath0 dimming and standard thin disk limb darkening , fits extremely well . the data are not good enough to distinguish rival disk models , but the general idea of a flat tilted emitter is strongly endorsed . the seds of luminous quasars peak in the uv , roughly as expected for blackbody emission from around a billion solar mass black hole . ( actually , observed seds are a little cooler than expected .. ) . the spectral index curves slowly from @xmath3 in the optical , through @xmath4 near the peak , and finally steepening to @xmath5 in the far - uv and onwards through the soft x - ray excess . ( elvis _ et al _ 1994 ) . however lower luminosity seyfert galaxies often have @xmath6 , and dwarf agn have @xmath7 ( e.g. ho filippenko and sargent 1996 ; ho , these proceedings ) . in fact @xmath8 and @xmath9 change slowly and systematically with luminosity ( mushotzky and wandel 1989 ; zheng and malkan 1993 ; puchnarewicz _ et al _ 1996 ; see fig . this change is consistent with the big blue bump ( bbb ) shifting to lower frequency with lowering luminosity , from blue bump to green bump to red bump , in a manner reminiscent of a cooling blackbody . of course accretion disks are not single blackbodies , but the sum of blackbodies . one can show that if an sed @xmath10 is made of the sum of blackbody emitting areas , and that each sub - area changes temperature by the same factor @xmath11 , then the new sed can be expressed in terms of the old one by the scaling formula @xmath12 ( lawrence 2002 in preparation ) . one expects accretion discs to behave just this way when varying accretion rate or central heating rate , and roughly this way when varying black hole mass , as long as one considers emission coming well away from the inner boundary . as a result , if one has a template sed , then one can use the scaling formula to predict all other seds without having to know how the sed was made - i.e. whether it was from a thick disk , donut , flared disk , etc . the scaling simply tests the idea that the sed is made from the sum of blackbodies . -0.2 cm -0.2 cm i took two template seds - 3c273 , from kriss _ et al _ 1999 , and h1946 + 786 from kuhn _ et al _ 1995 - and calculated the expected @xmath8 vs luminosity track . the result is shown in fig . 1 and shows an impressive agreement remembering that this prediction has no adjustable parameters . it starts to break down at the low end , but this could easily be due to boundary conditions , or the effect of reddening etc . the extreme ends of the diagram require the controlling parameter , e.g. accretion rate , to vary by something like a factor of a million . seyfert galaxy optical - uv variations show the bbb getting bluer when brighter . do these variations also follow the sum - of - blackbodies scaling law ? 1 indicates the low and high states of ngc 5548 , from peterson _ et al _ 1991 . clearly the colour variations are far too strong . a single black body track is almost this steep , but the wide range of temperatures needed to explain the sed produces a far flatter track . a possible explanation is that the colour changes result from mixing a variable blue component of approximately fixed shape with a static red component . perhaps then the @xmath13 locus we see in fig . 1 represents a kind of baseline stable state for agn accretion discs heated by gravity / viscosity , with the thickness of the correlation caused by various degrees of mixing of a second variable component that has a different heating source . from the point of view of accretion disc models , or indeed any models where the energy is generated through an extended structure , there are two problems with seyfert galaxy optical - uv variations . ( i ) the timescale - months - is far shorter than the viscous timescale expected for stable accretion discs , which is hundreds of years . ( ii ) variations occur simultaneously at different wavelengths , whereas emission at different wavelengths should arise at very different radii . fluctuations travelling at sound speed should then produce delays of order months . et al _ ( 1991 ) proposed that much of what we see is reprocessed radiation , so that fluctuations co - ordinate at light speed . that paper discussed optical fluctuations driven by uv , but most authors since have assumed that the variable uv itself is driven by variations in the observed x - ray source . the reprocessing idea seems to have been dramatically confirmed by observations of ngc 7469 , which shows that there _ are _ delays , but on a timescale of hours to days , and with delay varying as @xmath14 exactly as expected for a simple centrally heated disc model ( collier _ et al _ 1998 , wanders _ et al _ 1997 ) . so accretion discs score well on the brightness - angle test , and on the luminosity - colour test , but fail to match observed variations , unless we drop the idea of local gravitational heating and instead have a second heating source , which dominates in the uv regions , and which communicates across the disk at light speed . for some years the second heating source has generally been identified with the observed x - ray source . however , the x - ray heating model has two serious problems . first , simultaneous uv and x - ray observations of n7469 have not shown the expected correlation , with the x - ray emission if anything _ trailing _ the uv ( nandra _ et al _ 1998 ) . second , the x - ray luminosity is substantially less than the uv luminosity - by a factor of a few in low luminosity seyferts , and by a factor of twenty in quasars . we arrive then at the strange conclusion that agn accretion disks seem to be externally heated , but by an agent that we do not see . furthermore this mystery agent must carry most of the primary energy in agn . this then is the _ ghost in the machine_. what else could heat the observed variable uv source ? if we require external heating at light speed , there would be seem two possibilities - an unseen radiation source , or particles . the most obvious radiation source is euv emission from the very inner disk . in observed terms there is just enough energy - essentially we are talking about the right hand side of the bbb heating the left hand side . however in flat discs , and even in flared discs , it is hard for the outer disc to see enough of the inner disc . ( gravitational bending helps , but probably not enough ) . particles are an interesting and under - explored possibility . we want such particles to deposit their energy in the disc as heat before radiating , so protons are a much better bet than electrons . if they are not to cool on local electrons before hitting the disk , then they are probably high energy protons . one such possibility is virialised protons at @xmath15k from a two - temperature inner region , if a thin cold disc can co - exist with it . this possibility has been considered by spruit and hardt ( 2000 ) , although they assume that such protons heat an x - ray corona , which in turn heats the disc , rather than heating the cold disc itself . a second source of high energy protons could be from a standing shock near the black hole ( e.g. kazanas and ellison 1986 ) . it could well be that much of the accretion energy is generated in the `` plunging region '' inside 3@xmath16 , with most of the mass disappearing , but a large fraction of the energy being channelled into ultrarelativistic particles that escape . as these will follow field lines it is likely that most of these particles will end up in the disc . however they may lose most of their energy on the way , or at the skin of the disc , producing more gamma - rays than we observe . finally , bombardment by such particles may significantly alter abundances in the disc . skibo ( 1997 ) has in fact already argued that features in the wings of the x - ray fe line can be attributed to emission from just such enhanced abundances produced by cosmic rays . the above discussion assumes that the disc is _ externally _ heated , persuaded by the consistency of the time - delay versus wavelength result with the expected light - travel time . however the near - simultaneity of variations more generally drives us to drop the idea of distributed local heating . another possibility then is that much of the energy is generated near the black hole in some unknown form , and transmitted through the _ interior _ of the disc , perhaps by fast shocks , emerging at a larger radius as ( approximately ) nice simple black - body radiation . this makes an agn seem more like a star , but with a nastier geometry . probably in fact we need both local and central energy generation . collier , s. , _ et al_. : 1998 , apj , 500 , 162 . elvis , m. _ et al_. : 1994 , apjsupp , 95 , 1 . kazanas , d . , and ellison , d.c . : 1986 , apj , 304 , 178 . kriss , g.a . , _ et al_. : 1998 , apj , 527 , 683 . krolik , j.h . , _ et al_. : 1991 , apj , 371 , 541 . kuhn , o. , _ et al_. : 1995 , apj , 438 , 643 . ho , l.c . , filippenko , a.v . , and sargent , w.l.w . : 1996 , apj , 462 , 183 . mushotzky , r.f . , and wandel , a. : 1989 , apj , 339 , 674 . nandra , k. , _ et al_. : 1998 , apj , 505 , 594 . peterson , b. , _ et al_. : 1991 , apj , 368 , 119 . puchnarewicz , e.m . , _ et al_. : 1996 , mnras , 281 , 1243 . rokaki e. , _ et al_. : 2002 , mnras , submitted . skibo , j.g . : 1997 , apj , 478 , 522 . spruit , h.c . , and haardt , h. : 2000 , mnras , 315 , 751 . wanders , i. , _ et al_. : 1997 , apj , 113 , 69 . zheng , w. , and malkan , m.a . : 1993 , apj , 415 , 517 .

i examine simple tests for the presence of accretion disks in agn - changes of surface brightness with viewing angle , changes of colour temperature with luminosity , and behaviour during variability . agn observations pass the first two tests but fail the third , unless there is some previously unobserved source of heating - the `` ghost in the machine '' .

cs0206011

with the recent appearance of the internet and the world - wide web , understanding the properties of growing networks with popularity - based construction rules has become an active and fruitful research area @xcite . in such models , newly - introduced nodes preferentially attach to pre - existing nodes of the network that are already `` popular '' . this leads to graphs whose structure is quite different from the well - known _ random graph _ @xcite in which links are created at random between nodes without regard to their popularity . this discovery of a new class of graph theory problems has fueled much effort to characterize their properties . one basic measure of the structure of such networks is the _ node degree _ @xmath5 defined as the number of nodes in the network that are linked to @xmath0 other nodes . in the case of the random graph , the node degree is simply a poisson distribution . in contrast , many popularity - driven growing networks have much broader degree distributions with a stretched exponential or a power - law tail . the latter form means that there is no characteristic scale for the node degree , a feature that typifies many networked systems @xcite . power laws , or more generally , distributions with highly skewed tails , characterize the degree distributions of many man - made and naturally occurring networks @xcite . for example , the degree distributions at the level of autonomous systems and at the router level exhibit highly skewed tails @xcite . other important internet - based graphs , such as the hyperlink graph of the world - wide web also appear to have a degree distribution with a power - law tail @xcite . these observations have spurred a flurry of recent work to understand the underlying mechanisms for these phenomena . a related example with interest to anyone who publishes , is the distribution of scientific citations @xcite . here one treats publications as nodes and citations as links in a citation graph . currently - available data suggests that the citation distribution has a power - law tail with an associated exponent close to @xmath6 @xcite . as we shall see , this exponent emerges naturally in the _ growing network _ ( gn ) model where the relative probability of linking from a new node to a previous node ( equivalent to citing an earlier paper ) is strictly proportional to the popularity of the target node . in this paper , we apply tools from statistical physics , especially the rate equation approach , to quantify the structure of growing networks and to elucidate the types of geometrical features that arise in networks with physically - motivated growth rules . the utility of the rate equations has been demonstrated in a diverse range of phenomena in non - equilibrium statistical physics , such as aggregation @xcite , coarsening @xcite , and epitaxial surface growth @xcite . we will attempt to convince the reader that the rate equations are also a simple yet powerful analysis tool to analyze growing network systems . in addition to providing comprehensive information about the node degree distribution , the rate equations can be easily adapted to analyze both heterogeneous and directed networks , the age distribution of nodes , correlations between node degrees , various global network properties , as well as the cluster size distribution in models that give rise to independently evolving sub - networks . thus the rate equation method appears to be better suited for probing the structure of growing networks compared to the classical approaches for analyzing random graphs , such as probabilistic @xcite or generating function @xcite techniques . in the next section , we introduce three basic models that will be the focus of this review . in the following three sections , we then present rate equation analyses to determine basic geometrical properties of these networks . we close with a brief summary . the models we study appear to embody many of the basic growth processes in web graphs and related systems . these include : * the _ growing network _ ( gn ) @xcite . nodes are added one at a time and a single link is established between the new node and a pre - existing node according to an attachment probability @xmath7 that depends only on the degree of the `` target '' node ( fig . [ network ] ) . + + [ network ] * the _ web graph _ ( wg ) . this represents an extension of the gn to incorporate link directionality @xcite and leads to independent , dynamically generated in - degree and out - degree distributions . the network growth occurs by two distinct processes @xcite that are meant to mimic how hyperlinks are created in the web ( fig . [ io - growth ] ) : * * with probability @xmath8 , a new node is introduced and it immediately attaches to an earlier target node . the attachment probability depends only on the in - degree of the target . * * with probability @xmath9 , a new link is created between already existing nodes . the choices of the originating and target nodes depend on the out - degree of the former and the in - degree of the latter . + * the _ multicomponent graph _ ( mg ) . nodes and links are introduced _ independently _ @xcite . ( i ) with probability @xmath8 , a new _ unlinked _ node is introduced , while ( ii ) with probability @xmath9 , a new link is created between existing nodes . as in the wg , the choices of the originating and target nodes depend on the out - degree of the former and the in - degree of the latter . step ( i ) allows for the formation of many clusters . because of its simplicity , we first study the structure of the gn @xcite . the basic approaches developed in this section will then be extended to the wg and mg models . we first focus on the node degree distribution @xmath5 . to determine its evolution , we shall write the rate equations that account for the change in the degree distribution after each node addition event . these equations contain complete information about the node degree , from which any measure of node degree ( such as moments ) can be easily extracted . for the gn growth process in which nodes are introduced one at a time , the rate equations for the degree distribution @xmath10 are @xcite @xmath11 the first term on the right , @xmath12 , accounts for processes in which a node with @xmath13 links is connected to the new node , thus increasing @xmath5 by one . since there are @xmath14 nodes of degree @xmath13 , the rate at which such processes occur is proportional to @xmath15 , and the factor @xmath16 converts this rate into a normalized probability . a corresponding role is played by the second ( loss ) term on the right - hand side ; @xmath17 is the probability that a node with @xmath0 links is connected to the new node , thus leading to a loss in @xmath5 . the last term accounts for the introduction of new nodes with no incoming links . we start by solving for the time dependence of the moments of the degree distribution defined via @xmath18 . this is a standard method of analysis of rate equations by which one can gain partial , but valuable , information about the time dependence of the system with minimal effort . by explicitly summing eqs . ( [ nk ] ) over all @xmath0 , we easily obtain @xmath19 , whose solution is @xmath20 . notice that by definition @xmath21 is just the total number of nodes in the network . it is clear by the nature of the growth process that this quantity simply grows as @xmath22 . in a similar fashion , the first moment of the degree distribution obeys @xmath23 with solution @xmath24 . this time evolution for @xmath25 can be understood either by explicitly summing the rate equations , or by observing that this first moment simply equals the total number of link endpoints . clearly , this quantity must grow as @xmath26 since the introduction of a single node introduces two link endpoints . thus we find the simple result that the first two moments are _ independent _ of the attachment kernel @xmath7 and grow _ linearly _ with time . on the other hand , higher moments and the degree distribution itself do depend in an essential way on the kernel @xmath7 . as a preview to the general behavior for the degree distribution , consider the strictly linear kernel @xcite , for which @xmath27 coincides with @xmath28 . in this case , we can solve eqs . ( [ nk ] ) for an arbitrary initial condition . however , since the long - time behavior is most interesting , we limit ourselves to the asymptotic regime ( @xmath29 ) where the initial condition is irrelevant . using therefore @xmath30 , we solve the first few of eqs . ( [ nk ] ) directly and obtain @xmath31 , @xmath32 , _ etc_. thus each of the @xmath5 grow linearly with time . accordingly , we substitute @xmath33 in eqs . ( [ nk ] ) to yield the simple recursion relation @xmath34 . solving for @xmath35 gives @xmath36 returning to the case of general attachment kernels , let us assume that the degree distribution and @xmath27 both grow linearly with time . this hypothesis can be easily verified numerically for attachment kernels that do not grow faster than linearly with @xmath0 . then substituting @xmath33 and @xmath37 into eqs . ( [ nk ] ) we obtain the recursion relation @xmath38 and @xmath39 . finally , solving for @xmath35 , we obtain the formal expression @xmath40 to complete the solution , we need the amplitude @xmath41 . using the definition @xmath42 in eq . ( [ nkgen ] ) , we obtain the implicit relation @xmath43 which shows that the amplitude @xmath41 depends on the entire attachment kernel . for the generic case @xmath44 , we substitute this form into eq . ( [ nkgen ] ) and then rewrite the product as the exponential of a sum of a logarithm . in the continuum limit , we convert this sum to an integral , expand the logarithm to lowest order , and then evaluate the integral to yield the following basic results : @xmath45 , & $ 0\leq\gamma<1$;\cr k^{-\nu } , \quad \nu>2 , & $ \gamma=1$;\cr { \rm best\ seller } & $ 1<\gamma<2$;\cr { \rm bible } & $ 2<\gamma$.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus the degree distribution decays exponentially for @xmath46 , as in the case of the random graph , while for all @xmath47 , the distribution exhibits robust stretched exponential behavior . the linear kernel is the case that has garnered much of the current research interest . as shown above , @xmath48}$ ] for the strictly linear kernel @xmath49 . one might anticipate that @xmath50 holds for all _ asymptotically _ linear kernels , @xmath51 . however , the situation is more delicate and the degree distribution exponent depends on microscopic details of @xmath7 . from eq . ( [ nkgen ] ) , we obtain @xmath52 , where the exponent @xmath53 can be tuned to _ any _ value larger than 2 @xcite . this non - universal behavior shows that one must be cautious in drawing general conclusions from the gn with a linear attachment kernel . , out - degree @xmath54 , and total degree 9.,scaledwidth=25.0% ] [ degrees ] as an illustrative example of the vagaries of asymptotically linear kernels , consider the shifted linear kernel @xmath55 . one way to motivate this kernel is to explicitly keep track of link directionality . in particular , the node degree for an undirected graph naturally generalizes to the in - degree and out - degree for a directed graph , the number of incoming and outgoing links at a node , respectively . thus the total degree @xmath0 in a directed graph is the sum of the in - degree @xmath56 and out - degree @xmath57 ( fig . [ degrees ] ) . ( more details on this model are given in the next section . ) the most general linear attachment kernel for a directed graph has the form @xmath58 . the gn corresponds to the case where the out - degree of any node equals one ; thus @xmath59 and @xmath60 . for this example the general linear attachment kernel reduces to @xmath61 . since the overall scale is irrelevant , we can re - write @xmath7 as the shifted linear kernel @xmath55 , with @xmath62 that can vary over the range @xmath63 . to determine the degree distribution for the shifted linear kernel , note that @xmath64 simply equals . using @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath30 , we get @xmath67 and hence the relation @xmath53 from the previous paragraph becomes @xmath68 . thus a simple additive shift in the attachment kernel profoundly affects the asymptotic degree distribution . furthermore , from eq . ( [ nkgen ] ) we determine the entire degree distribution to be @xmath69 finally , we outline the intriguing behavior for super - linear kernels . in this case , there is a `` runaway '' or gelation - like phenomenon in which one node links to almost every other node . for @xmath70 , all but a finite number of nodes are linked to a _ node that has the rest of the links . we term such an overwhelmingly popular node as a `` bible '' . for @xmath71 , the number of nodes with a just a few links is no longer finite , but grows slower than linearly in time , and the remainder of the nodes are linked to an extremely popular node that we now term `` best seller '' . full details about this runaway behavior are given in @xcite . as a final parenthetical note , when the attachment kernel has the form @xmath72 , with @xmath73 , there is preferential attachment to poorly - connected sites . here , the degree distribution exhibits faster than exponential decay , @xmath74 . when @xmath75 , the propensity for avoiding popularity is so strong that there is a finite probability of forming a `` worm '' graph in which each node attaches only to its immediate predecessor . a practically - relevant generalization of the gn is to endow each node with an intrinsic and permanently defined `` attractiveness '' @xcite . this accounts for the obvious fact that not all nodes are equivalent , but that some are clearly more attractive than others at their inception . thus the subsequent attachment rate to a node should be a function of both its degree and its intrinsic attractiveness . for this generalization , the rate equation approach yields complete results with minimal additional effort beyond that needed to solve the homogeneous network . let us assign each node an attractiveness parameter @xmath76 , with arbitrary distribution , at its inception . this attractiveness modifies the node attachment rate as follows : for a node with degree @xmath0 and attractiveness @xmath77 , the attachment rate is simply @xmath78 . now we need to characterize nodes both by their degree and their attractiveness thus @xmath79 is the number of nodes with degree @xmath0 and attractiveness @xmath77 . this joint degree - attractiveness distribution obeys the rate equation , @xmath80 here @xmath81 is the probability that a newly - introduced node has attractiveness @xmath77 , and the normalization factor @xmath82 . following the same approach as that used to analyze eq . ( [ nk ] ) , we substitute @xmath65 and @xmath83 into eq . ( [ nk - het ] ) to obtain the recursion relation @xmath84 for concreteness , consider the linear attachment kernel @xmath85 . then applying the same analysis as in the homogeneous network , we find @xmath86 to determine the amplitude @xmath41 we substitute ( [ nk - het ] ) into the definition @xmath87 and use the identity @xcite @xmath88 to simplify the sum . this yields the implicit relation @xmath89 this condition on @xmath41 leads to two alternatives : if the support of @xmath77 is unbounded , then the integral diverges and there is no solution for @xmath41 . in this limit , the most attractive node is connected to a finite fraction of all links . conversely , if the support of @xmath77 is bounded , the resulting degree distribution is similar to that of the homogeneous network . for fixed @xmath77 , @xmath90 with an attractiveness - dependent decay exponent @xmath91 amusingly , the total degree distribution @xmath92 is no longer a strict power law @xcite . rather , the asymptotic behavior is governed by properties of the initial attractiveness distribution near the upper cutoff . in particular , if @xmath93 ( with @xmath94 to ensure normalization ) , the total degree distribution exhibits a logarithmic correction @xmath95 in addition to the degree distribution , we determine _ when _ connections occur . naively , we expect that older nodes will be better connected . we study this feature by resolving each node both by its degree and its age to provide a more complete understanding of the network evolution . thus define @xmath96 to be the average number of nodes of age @xmath97 that have @xmath13 incoming links at time @xmath22 . here age @xmath97 means that the node was introduced at time @xmath98 . the original degree distribution may be recovered from the joint age - degree distribution through @xmath99 . for simplicity , we consider only the case of the strictly linear kernel ; more general kernels were considered in ref . the joint age - degree distribution evolves according to the rate equation @xmath100 the second term on the left accounts for the aging of nodes . we assume here that the probability of linking to a given node again depends only on its degree and not on its age . finally , we again have used @xmath101 for the linear attachment kernel in the long - time limit . the homogeneous form of this equation implies that solution should be self - similar . thus we seek a solution as a function of the _ single _ variable @xmath102 rather than two separate variables . writing @xmath103 with @xmath104 , we convert eq . ( [ ck1 ] ) into the ordinary differential equation @xmath105 we omit the delta function term , since it merely provides the boundary condition @xmath106 , or @xmath107 . the solution to this boundary - value problem may be simplified by assuming the exponential solution @xmath108 ; this is consistent with the boundary condition , provided that @xmath109 and @xmath110 . this ansatz reduces the infinite set of rate equations ( [ fk1 ] ) into two elementary differential equations for @xmath111 and @xmath112 whose solutions are @xmath113 and @xmath114 . in terms of the original variables of @xmath97 and @xmath22 , the joint age - degree distribution is then @xmath115 thus the degree distribution for fixed - age nodes decays _ exponentially _ , with a characteristic degree that diverges as @xmath116 for @xmath117 . as expected , young nodes ( those with @xmath118 ) typically have a small degree while old nodes have large degree ( fig . [ age ] ) . it is the large characteristic degree of old nodes that ultimately leads to a _ power - law _ total degree distribution when the joint age - degree distribution is integrated over all ages . .,scaledwidth=40.0% ] the rate equation approach is sufficiently versatile that we can also obtain much deeper geometrical properties of growing networks . one such property is the correlation between degrees of connected nodes @xcite . these develop naturally because a node with large degree is likely to be old . thus its ancestor is also old and hence also has a large degree . in the context of the web , this correlation merely expresses that obvious fact that it is more likely that popular web sites have hyperlinks among each other rather than to marginal sites . to quantify the node degree correlation , we define @xmath119 as the number of nodes of degree @xmath0 that attach to an ancestor node of degree @xmath120 ( fig . [ corr - def ] ) . for example , in the network of fig . [ network ] , there are @xmath121 nodes of degree 1 , with @xmath122 . there are also @xmath123 nodes of degree 2 , with @xmath124 , and @xmath125 nodes of degree 3 , with @xmath126 . for the case @xmath127 and @xmath128.,scaledwidth=20.0% ] for simplicity , we again specialize to the case of the strictly linear attachment kernel . more general kernels can also be treated within our general framework @xcite . for the linear attachment kernel , the degree correlation @xmath119 evolves according to the rate equation @xmath129 the processes that gives rise to each term in this equation are illustrated in fig . [ corr - re ] . the first two terms on the right account for the change in @xmath130 due to the addition of a link onto a node of degree @xmath13 ( gain ) or @xmath0 ( loss ) respectively , while the second set of terms gives the change in @xmath130 due to the addition of a link onto the ancestor node . finally , the last term accounts for the gain in @xmath131 due to the addition of a new node . ) . the newly - added node and link are shown dashed.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] as in the case of the node degree , the time dependence can be separated as @xmath132 . this reduces eqs . ( [ nkl ] ) to the time - independent recursion relation , @xmath133 this can be further reduced to a constant - coefficient inhomogeneous recursion relation by the substitution @xmath134 to yield @xmath135 solving eqs . ( [ a ] ) for the first few @xmath0 yields the pattern of dependence on @xmath0 and @xmath120 from which one can then infer the solution @xmath136 from which we ultimately obtain @xmath137.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the important feature of this result is that the joint distribution does not factorize , that is , @xmath138 . this correlation between the degrees of connected nodes is an important distinction between the gn and classical random graphs . while the solution of eq . ( [ nkl - sol ] ) is unwieldy , it greatly simplifies in the scaling regime , @xmath139 and @xmath140 with @xmath141 finite . the scaled form of the solution is @xmath142 for fixed large @xmath0 , the distribution @xmath143 has a single maximum at @xmath144 . thus a node whose degree @xmath0 is large is typically linked to another node whose degree is also large ; the typical degree of the ancestor is 37% that of the daughter node . in general , when @xmath0 and @xmath120 are both large and their ratio is different from one , the limiting behaviors of @xmath143 are @xmath145 here we explicitly see the absence of factorization in the degree correlation : @xmath146 . in addition to elucidating the degree distribution and degree correlations , the rate equations can be applied to determine global properties . one useful example is the _ out - component _ with respect to a given node * x * this is the set of nodes that can be reached by following directed links that emanate from * x * ( fig . [ in - out ] ) . in the context of the web , this is the set of nodes that are reached by following hyperlinks that emanate from a fixed node to target nodes , and then iteratively following target nodes ad infinitum . in a similar vein , one may enumerate all nodes that refer to a fixed node , plus all nodes that refer these daughter nodes , _ etc_. this progeny comprises the in - component to node * x * the set from which * x * can be reached by following a path of directed links . [ in - out ] for simplicity , we study the in - component size distribution for the gn with a constant attachment kernel , @xmath147 . we consider this kernel because many results about network components are _ independent _ of the form of the kernel and thus it suffices to consider the simplest situation ; the extension to more general attachment kernels is discussed in @xcite . for the constant attachment kernel , the number @xmath148 of in - components with @xmath149 nodes satisfies the rate equation @xmath150 the loss term accounts for processes in which the attachment of a new node to an in - component of size @xmath149 increases its size by one . this gives a loss rate that is proportional to @xmath149 . if there is more than one in - component of size @xmath149 they must be disjoint , so that the total loss rate for @xmath148 is simply @xmath151 . a similar argument applies for the gain term . finally , dividing by @xmath152 converts these rates to normalized probabilities . for the constant attachment kernel , @xmath153 , so asymptotically @xmath154 . interestingly , eq . ( [ ik ] ) is almost identical to the rate equations for the degree distribution for the gn with linear attachment kernel , except that the prefactor equals @xmath155 rather than @xmath156 . this change in the normalization factor is responsible for shifting the exponent of the resulting distribution from @xmath6 to @xmath157 . to determine @xmath148 , we again note , by explicitly solving the first few of the rate equations , that each @xmath158 grows linearly in time . thus we substitute @xmath159 into eqs . ( [ ik ] ) to obtain @xmath160 and @xmath161 . this immediately gives @xmath162 this @xmath163 tail for the in - component distribution is a robust feature , _ independent _ of the form of the attachment kernel @xcite . this @xmath163 tail also agrees with recent measurements of the web @xcite . the complementary out - component from each node can be determined by constructing a mapping between the out - component and an underlying network `` genealogy '' . we build a genealogical tree for the gn by taking generation @xmath164 to be the initial node . nodes that attach to those in generation @xmath165 form generation @xmath166 ; the node index does not matter in this characterization . for example , in the network of fig . [ network ] , node 1 is the `` ancestor '' of 6 , while 10 is the `` descendant '' of 6 and there are 5 nodes in generation @xmath167 and 4 in @xmath168 . this leads to the genealogical tree of fig . [ genealogy ] . . the nodes indices indicate when each is introduced . the nodes are also arranged according to generation number.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] [ genealogy ] the genealogical tree provides a convenient way to characterize the out - component distribution . as one can directly verify from fig . [ genealogy ] , the number @xmath169 of out - components with @xmath149 nodes equals @xmath170 , the number of nodes in generation @xmath171 in the genealogical tree . we therefore compute @xmath172 , the size of generation @xmath165 at time @xmath22 . for this discussion , we again treat only the constant attachment kernel and refer the reader to ref . @xcite for more general attachment kernels . we determine @xmath172 by noting that @xmath172 increases when a new node attaches to a node in generation @xmath173 . this occurs with rate @xmath174 , where @xmath175 is the number of nodes . this gives the differential equation for @xmath176 with solution @xmath177 , where @xmath178 . thus the number @xmath169 of out - components with @xmath149 nodes equals @xmath179 note that the generation size @xmath172 grows with @xmath165 , when @xmath180 , and then decreases and becomes of order 1 when @xmath181 . the genealogical tree therefore contains approximately @xmath182 generations at time @xmath22 . this result allows us to determine the diameter of the network , since the maximum distance between any pair of nodes is twice the distance from the root to the last generation . therefore the diameter of the network scales as @xmath183 ; this is the same dependence on @xmath184 as in the random graph @xcite . more importantly , this result shows that the diameter of the gn is always small ranging from the order of @xmath185 for a constant attachment kernel , to the order of one for super - linear attachment kernels . in the world - wide web , link directionality is clearly relevant , as hyperlinks go _ from _ an issuing website _ to _ a target website but not vice versa . thus to characterize the local graph structure more fully , the node degree should be resolved into the _ in - degree _ the number of incoming links to a node , and the complementary _ out - degree _ [ degrees ] ) . measurements on the web indicate that these distributions are power laws with different exponents @xcite . these properties can be accounted for by the web graph ( wg ) model ( fig . [ io - growth ] ) and the rate equations provide an extremely convenient analysis tool . let us first determine the average node degrees ( in - degree , out - degree , and total degree ) of the wg . let @xmath186 be the total number of nodes , and @xmath187 and @xmath188 the in - degree and out - degree of the entire network , respectively . according to the elemental growth steps of the model , these degrees evolve by one of the following two possibilities : @xmath189 that is , with probability @xmath8 a new node and new directed link are created ( fig . [ io - growth ] ) so that the number of nodes and both the total in- and out - degrees increase by one . conversely , with probability @xmath190 a new directed link is created and the in- and out - degrees each increase by one , while the total number of nodes is unchanged . as a result , @xmath191 , and @xmath192 . thus the average in- and out - degrees , @xmath193 and @xmath194 , are both equal to @xmath195 . to determine the degree distributions , we need to specify : ( i ) the _ attachment rate _ @xmath196 , defined as the probability that a newly - introduced node links to an existing node with @xmath56 incoming and @xmath57 outgoing links , and ( ii ) the _ creation rate _ @xmath197 , defined as the probability of adding a new link from a @xmath198 node to a @xmath199 node . we will use rates that are expected to occur in the web . clearly , the attachment and creation rates should be non - decreasing in @xmath56 and @xmath57 . moreover , it seems intuitively plausible that the attachment rate depends only on the in - degree of the target node , @xmath200 ; _ i.e. _ , a website designer decides to create link to a target based only on the popularity of the latter . in the same spirit , we take the link creation rate to depend only on the out - degree of the issuing node and the in - degree of the target node , @xmath201 . the former property reflects the fact that the development rate of a site depends only on the number of outgoing links . the interesting situation of power - law degree distributions arises for asymptotically linear rates , and we therefore consider @xmath202 the parameters @xmath203 and @xmath204 must satisfy the constraint @xmath205 and @xmath206 to ensure that the rates are positive for all attainable in- and out - degree values , @xmath207 and @xmath208 . with these rates , the joint degree distribution , @xmath209 , defined as the average number of nodes with @xmath56 incoming and @xmath57 outgoing links , evolves according to @xmath210\\ & & \hskip 0.285 in + q\left[{(j-1+\lambda_{\rm out})n_{i , j-1 } -(j+\lambda_{\rm out})n_{ij}\over j+\lambda_{\rm out } n}\right ] + p\,\delta_{i0}\delta_{j1}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first group of terms on the right accounts for the changes in the in - degree of target nodes by simultaneous creation of a new node and link ( probability @xmath8 ) or by creation of a new link only ( probability @xmath190 ) . for example , the creation of a link to a node with in - degree @xmath56 leads to a loss in the number of such nodes . this occurs with rate @xmath211 , divided by the appropriate normalization factor @xmath212 . the factor @xmath213 in eq . ( [ nij ] ) is explicitly written to make clear these two types of processes . similarly , the second group of terms account for out - degree changes . these occur due to the creation of new links between already existing nodes hence the prefactor @xmath190 . the last term accounts for the introduction of new nodes with no incoming links and one outgoing link . as a useful consistency check , one may verify that the total number of nodes , @xmath214 , grows according to @xmath215 , while the total in- and out - degrees , @xmath216 and @xmath217 , obey @xmath218 . by solving the first few of eqs . ( [ nij ] ) , it is again clear that the @xmath219 grow linearly with time . accordingly , we substitute @xmath220 , as well as @xmath221 and @xmath222 , into eqs . ( [ nij ] ) to yield a recursion relation for @xmath223 . using the shorthand notations , @xmath224 the recursion relation for @xmath223 is @xmath225n_{ij } = ( i-1+\lambda_{\rm in})n_{i-1,j}+a(j-1+\lambda_{\rm out})n_{i , j-1 } + p(1+p\lambda_{\rm in})\delta_{i0}\delta_{j1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the in - degree and out - degree distributions are straightforwardly expressed through the joint distribution : @xmath226 and @xmath227 . because of the linear time dependence of the node degrees , we write @xmath228 and @xmath229 . the densities @xmath230 and @xmath231 satisfy [ ii ] ( i+b)i_i & = & ( i-1+_in)i_i-1 + p(1+p_in)_i0 , + ( j+1q+_outq)o_j & = & ( j-1+_out)o_j-1+p1+p_outq_j1 , respectively . the solution to these recursion formulae may be expressed in terms of the following ratios of gamma functions [ i - sol ] i_i&=&i_0(i+_in)(b+1)(i+b+1)(_in ) , + [ o - sol ] o_j&=&o_1(j+_out ) ( 2+q^-1+_out q^-1 ) ( j+1+q^-1+_out q^-1)(1+_out ) , with @xmath232 and @xmath233 . from the asymptotics of the gamma function , the asymptotic behavior of the in- and out - degree distributions have the distinct power law forms @xcite , [ in ] i_i~i^-_in , _ in&=&2+p_in , + 0.7 in o_j~j^-_out , _ out&=&1+q^-1+_out pq^-1 , with @xmath234 and @xmath235 both necessarily greater than 2 . let us now compare these predictions with current data for the web @xcite . first , the value of @xmath8 is fixed by noting that @xmath236 equals the average degree of the entire network . current data for the web gives @xmath237 , and thus we set @xmath238 . now ( [ in ] ) contain two free parameters and by choosing them to be @xmath239 and @xmath240 we reproduced the observed exponents for the degree distributions of the web , @xmath241 and @xmath242 , respectively . the fact that the parameters @xmath203 and @xmath204 are of the order of one indicates that the model with linear rates of node attachment and bilinear rates of link creation is a viable description of the web . in addition to the degree distributions , current measurements indicate that the web consists of a `` giant '' component that contains approximately 91% of all nodes , and a large number of finite components @xcite . the models discussed thus far are unsuited to describe the number and size distribution of these components , since the growth rules necessarily produce only a single connected component . in this section , we outline a simple modification of the wg , the multicomponent graph ( mg ) , that naturally produces many components . in this example , the rate equations now provide a comprehensive characterization for the size distribution of the components . in the mg model , we simply separate node and link creation steps . namely , when a node is introduced it does not immediately attach to an earlier node , but rather , a new node begins its existence as isolated and joins the network only when a link creation event reaches the new node . for the average network degrees , this small modification already has a significant effect . the number of nodes and the total in- and out - degrees of the network , @xmath243 now increase with time as @xmath221 and @xmath244 . thus the in- and out - degrees of each node are time independent and equal to @xmath245 , while the total degree is @xmath246 . as in the case of the wg model , we study the case of a bilinear link creation rate given in eq . ( [ ac ] ) , with now @xmath247 to ensure that @xmath248 for all permissible in- and out - degrees , @xmath207 and @xmath249 . we study local characteristics by employing the same approach as in the wg model . we find that results differ only in minute details , _ e.g. _ , the in- and out - degree densities @xmath230 and @xmath231 are again the ratios of gamma functions , and the respective exponents are @xmath250 notice the decoupling the in - degree exponent is independent of @xmath204 , while @xmath235 is independent of @xmath251 . the expressions ( [ inout ] ) are neater than their wg counterparts , reflecting the fact that the governing rules of the mg model are more symmetric . to complement our discussion , we now outline the asymptotic behavior of the joint in- and out - degree distribution . although this distribution defies general analysis , we can obtain partial and useful information by fixing one index and letting the other index vary . an elementary but cumbersome analysis yields following limiting behaviors @xmath252 with @xmath253 we also can determine the joint degree distribution analytically in the subset of the parameter space where @xmath254 , _ i.e. _ , @xmath255 . in what follows , we therefore denote @xmath256 . the resulting recursion equation for the joint degree distribution is @xmath257 with @xmath258 . because the degrees @xmath56 and @xmath57 appear in eq . ( [ nij * ] ) with equal prefactors , the substitution @xmath259 reduces eqs . ( [ nij * ] ) into the constant - coefficient recursion relation @xmath260 we solve eq . ( [ m ] ) by employing the generating function technique . multiplying eq . ( [ m ] ) by @xmath261 and summing over all @xmath262 , we find that the generating function @xmath263 equals @xmath264 . expanding @xmath265 in @xmath266 yields @xmath267 which we then expand in @xmath268 by employing the identity @xmath269 . finally , we arrive at @xmath270 from which the joint degree distribution is @xmath271 thus again , the in- and out - degrees of a node are correlated : @xmath272 . let us now turn now to the distribution of connected components ( clusters , for brevity ) . for simplicity , we consider models with undirected links . let us first estimate the total number of clusters @xmath273 . at each time step , @xmath274 with probability @xmath8 , or @xmath275 with probability @xmath190 . this implies @xmath276 the gain rate of @xmath273 is exactly equal to @xmath8 , while in the loss term we ignore self - connections and tacitly assume that links are always created between different clusters . in the long - time limit , self - connections should be asymptotically negligible when the total number of clusters grows with time and no macroscopic clusters ( _ i.e. _ , components that contain a finite fraction of all nodes ) arise . this assumption of no self - connections greatly simplifies the description of the cluster merging process . consider two clusters ( labeled by @xmath277 ) with total in - degrees @xmath278 , out - degrees @xmath279 , and number of nodes @xmath280 . when these clusters merge , the combined cluster is characterized by @xmath281 thus starting with single - node clusters with @xmath282 , the above merging rule leads to clusters that always satisfy the constraint @xmath283 . thus the size @xmath0 characterizes both the in - degree and out - degree of clusters . to simplify formulae without sacrificing generality , we consider the link creation rate of eq . ( [ ac ] ) , with @xmath284 . then the merging rate @xmath285 of the two clusters is proportional to @xmath286 , or @xmath287 let @xmath288 denotes the number of clusters of mass @xmath0 . this distribution evolves according to @xmath289 the first set of terms account for the gain in @xmath288 due to the coalescence of clusters of size @xmath290 and @xmath291 , with @xmath292 . similarly , the second set of terms accounts for the loss in @xmath288 due to the coalescence of a cluster of size @xmath0 with any other cluster . the last term accounts for the input of unit - size clusters . these rate equations are similar to those of irreversible aggregation with product kernel @xcite . the primary difference is that we explicitly treat the number of clusters as finite . one can verify that the total number of nodes @xmath293 grows with rate @xmath8 and that the total number of clusters @xmath294 grows with rate @xmath295 , in agreement with eq . ( [ n ] ) . solving the first few eqs . ( [ comp ] ) shows again that @xmath288 grow linearly with time . accordingly , we substitute @xmath296 into eqs . ( [ comp ] ) to yield the time - independent recursion relation @xmath297 a giant component , _ i.e. _ , a cluster that contains a finite fraction of all the nodes , emerges when the link creation rate exceeds a threshold value . to determine this threshold , we study the moments of the cluster size distribution @xmath298 . we already know that the first two moments are @xmath299 and @xmath300 . we can obtain an equation for the second moment by multiplying eq . ( [ mk ] ) by @xmath301 and summing over @xmath302 to give @xmath303 . when this equation has a real solution , @xmath304 is finite . the solution is @xmath305 and gives , when @xmath306 , to a threshold value @xmath307 . for @xmath308 ( @xmath309 ) all clusters have finite size and the second moment is finite . in this steady - state regime , we can obtain the cluster size distribution by introducing the generating function @xmath310 to convert eq . ( [ mk ] ) into the differential equation @xmath311/q}.\ ] ] the asymptotic behavior of the cluster size distribution can now be read off from the behavior of the generating function in the @xmath312 limit . in particular , the power - law behavior @xmath313 implies that the corresponding generating function has the form @xmath314 here the asymptotic behavior is controlled by the dominant singular term @xmath315 . however , there are also subdominant singular terms and regular terms in the generating function . in eq . ( [ gen ] ) we explicitly included the three regular terms which ensure that the first three moments of the cluster - size distribution are correctly reproduced , namely , @xmath316 , @xmath317 , and @xmath318 . finally , substituting eq . ( [ gen ] ) into eq . ( [ cz ] ) we find that the dominant singular terms are of the order of @xmath319 . balancing all contributions of this order in the equation determines the exponent of the cluster size distribution to be @xmath320 this exponent satisfies the bound @xmath321 and thus justifies using the behavior of the second moment of the size distribution as the criterion to find the threshold value @xmath322 . for @xmath323 there is no giant cluster and the cluster size distribution has a power - law tail with @xmath324 given by eq . ( [ tau ] ) . intriguingly , the power - law form holds for any value @xmath309 . this is in stark contrast to all other percolation - type phenomena , where away from the threshold , there is an exponential tail in cluster size distributions @xcite . thus in contrast to ordinary critical phenomena , the entire range @xmath309 is critical . as a corollary to the power - law tail of the cluster size distribution for @xmath309 , we can estimate the size of the largest cluster @xmath325 to see how `` finite '' it really is . using the extreme statistics criterion @xmath326 we obtain @xmath327 , or @xmath328 this is very different from the corresponding behavior on the random graph , where below the percolation threshold the largest component scales logarithmically with the number of nodes . thus for the random graph , the dependence of @xmath329 changes from @xmath185 just below , to @xmath184 , just above the percolation threshold ; for the mg , the change is much more gentle : from @xmath330 to @xmath184 . these considerations suggest that the phase transition in the mg is dramatically different from the percolation transition . very recently , simplified versions of the mg were studied @xcite . numerical @xcite and analytical @xcite evidence suggest that the size of the giant component @xmath331 near the threshold scales as @xmath332 therefore , the phase transition of this dynamically grown network is of infinite order since all derivatives of @xmath331 vanish as @xmath333 . in contrast , static random graphs with any desired degree distribution @xcite exhibit a standard percolation transition @xcite . in this paper , we have presented a statistical physics viewpoint on growing network problems . this perspective is strongly influenced by the phenomenon of aggregation kinetics , where the rate equation approach has proved extremely useful . from the wide range of results that we were able to obtain for evolving networks , we hope that the reader appreciates both the simplicity and the power of the rate equation method for characterizing evolving networks . we quantified the degree distribution of the growing network model and found a diverse range of phenomenology that depends on the form of the attachment kernel . at the qualitative level , a stretched exponential form for the degree distribution should be regarded as `` generic '' , since it occurs for an attachment kernel that is sub - linear in node degree ( _ e.g. _ , @xmath44 with @xmath2 ) . on the other hand , a power - law degree distribution arises only for linear attachment kernels , @xmath51 . however , this result is `` non - generic '' as the degree distribution exponent now depends on the detailed form of the attachment kernel . we investigated extensions of the basic growing network to incorporate processes that naturally occur in the development in the web . in particular , by allowing for link directionality , the full degree distribution naturally resolves into independent in - degree and out - degree distributions . when the rates at which links are created are linear functions of the in- and out - degrees of the terminal nodes of the link , the in- and out - degree distributions are power laws with different exponents , @xmath234 and @xmath235 , that match with current measurements on the web with reasonable values for the model parameters . we also considered a model with independent node and link creation rates . this leads to a network with many independent components and now the size distribution of these components is an important characteristic . we have characterized basic aspects of this process by the rate equation approach and showed that the network is in a critical state even away from the percolation threshold . the rate equation approach also provides evidence of an unusual , infinite - order percolation transition . while statistical physics tools have fueled much progress in elucidating the structure of growing networks , there are still many open questions . one set is associated with understanding dynamical processes in such networks . for example , what is the nature of information transmission ? what governs the formation of traffic jams on the web ? another set is concerned with growth mechanisms . while we can make much progress in characterizing networks with idealized growth rules , it is important to understand the actual rules that govern the growth of the internet . these issues appear to be fruitful challenges for future research . it is a pleasure to thank francois leyvraz and geoff rodgers for collaborations that led to some of the work reported here . we also thank john byers and mark crovella for numerous informative discussions . finally , we are grateful to nsf grants int9600232 and dmr9978902 for financial support . recent reviews from the physicist s perspective include : s. h. strogatz , nature * 410 * , 268 ( 2001 ) ; r. albert and a .- barabsi , rev . phys . * 74 * , 47 ( 2002 ) ; s. n. dorogovtsev and j. f. f. mendes , adv . xx * , xxx ( 2002 ) . s. r. kumar , p. raphavan , s. rajagopalan , and a. tomkins , in : _ proc . 8th www conf . _ ( 1999 ) ; s. r. kumar , p. raphavan , s. rajagopalan , and a. tomkins , in : _ proc . 25th vldb conf . _ ( 1999 ) ; j. kleinberg , r. kumar , p. raghavan , s. rajagopalan , and a. tomkins , in : _ proceedings of the international conference on combinatorics and computing _ , lecture notes in computer science , vol . 1627 ( springer - verlag , berlin , 1999 ) .

approaches from statistical physics are applied to investigate the structure of network models whose growth rules mimic aspects of the evolution of the world - wide web . we first determine the degree distribution of a growing network in which nodes are introduced one at a time and attach to an earlier node of degree @xmath0 with rate @xmath1 . very different behaviors arise for @xmath2 , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 . we also analyze the degree distribution of a heterogeneous network , the joint age - degree distribution , the correlation between degrees of neighboring nodes , as well as global network properties . an extension to directed networks is then presented . by tuning model parameters to reasonable values , we obtain distinct power - law forms for the in - degree and out - degree distributions with exponents that are in good agreement with current data for the web . finally , a general growth process with independent introduction of nodes and links is investigated . this leads to independently growing sub - networks that may coalesce with other sub - networks . general results for both the size distribution of sub - networks and the degree distribution are obtained .

astro-ph0211135

molecular clouds are observed through the emission of a number of molecular transitions that provide a wealth of information about their chemical composition , gas temperature and density , magnetic field strength , fractional ionization , structure and kinematics . this information is essential to our understanding of the process of star formation . the interpretation of molecular emission line maps is not always unique . the main source of uncertainty is the absence of the third spatial dimension ( along the line of sight ) in the observational data . statistical properties of the velocity and density distributions along the line of sight are difficult to disentangle . furthermore , the components of the gas velocity on the plane of the sky are unknown . two dimensional images of molecular clouds are usually converted into three dimensional `` objects '' using the radial velocity instead of the third spatial dimension . this method can be useful to separate individual mass condensations from each other , since it is conceivable that their relative velocity is larger than their internal one . however , velocity blending or the lack of well defined condensations along the line of sight may cause significant uncertainties ( issa , maclaren & wolfendale 1990 ; adler & roberts 1992 ; ballesteros paredes , vazquez semadeni & scalo 1999 ; pichardo et al . 2000 ; ostriker , stone & gammie 2001 ; lazarian et al . 2001 ; ballesteros paredes & mac low 2002 ) . due to the difficulty of a direct interpretation of the observational data , a `` forward approach '' that starts from a rather general theoretical model and synthesizes its observational properties can be more instructive . different models may sometimes satisfy the same set of observational constraints , but they should also provide guidance for further observational studies that could help select the correct model . ideally , numerical models to be compared with observed spectral line data cubes should be based on the numerical solutions of the mhd equations , in the regime of highly super sonic turbulence , and on radiative transfer calculations . in some works , stochastic fields are used instead of the solution of the mhd equations and in most studies the radiative transfer calculation is omitted , in favor of density weighted velocity profiles . the first large synthetic spectral maps of molecular transitions computed by solving the non lte radiative transfer through the density and velocity data cubes obtained as the numerical solution of the mhd equations were presented by padoan et al . ( 1998 ) , based on juvela s radiative transfer code ( juvela 1997 ) , and were used in a number of works ( e.g. padoan et al . 1999 , 2000 , 2001 ) . another new radiative transfer code has also been used more recently to generate synthetic spectral maps from mhd simulations ( ossenkopf 2002 ) . a number of statistical methods have been proposed to compare numerical models of turbulence with large spectral maps of molecular clouds ( see for example scalo 1984 ; kleiner & dickman 1985 , 1987 ; stutzki & gusten 1990 ; gill & henriksen 1990 ; houlahan & scalo 1992 ; hobson 1992 ; langer , wilson , & anderson 1993 ; williams , de geus & blitz 1994 ; miesch & bally 1994 ; miesch & scalo 1995 ; lis et al . 1996 ; blitz & williams 1997 ; heyer & schloerb 1997 ; stutzki et al . 1998 ; miesch , scalo & bally 1999 ; falgarone et al . 1994 ; padoan et al . 1999 ; mac low & ossenkopf 2000 ; bensch , stutzki & ossenkopf 2001 ) . in this work we apply the spectral correlation function ( scf ) method , proposed by rosolowsky et al . ( 1999 ) and further developed in padoan , rosolowsky & goodman ( 2001 ) , to a number of observational and synthetic spectral maps . we show that the slope and normalization of the scf of observational maps correlate with the spectral line width . theoretical models of molecular clouds should therefore yield synthetic spectral maps reproducing such correlations , but not all of them can . in the next section we briefly define the scf , and in 3 we present the observational data used in this work . the computation of the theoretical models and synthetic spectral maps is presented in 4 . results from numerical models are compared with the observational data in 5 and are discussed in 6 . conclusions are drawn in 7 . the spectral correlation function ( scf ) measures the spatial correlation of spectral line profiles within a spectral map . it is sensitive to the properties of both the gas mass distribution and the gas velocity field ( rosolowsky et al . 1999 ; padoan , rosolowsky & goodman 2001 ; padoan et al . 2001 ; ballesteros paredes , vazquez semadeni & goodman 2002 ) . let @xmath2 be the antenna temperature as a function of velocity channel @xmath3 at map position @xmath4 . the scf for spectra with spatial separation @xmath5 is : @xmath6 where the average is computed over all map positions @xmath4 . @xmath7 is the scf uncorrected for the effects of noise , @xmath8 ^ 2 } { \sigma_vt(\vecr , v)^2+\sigma_vt(\vecr+\vecdr , v)^2 } } \right\rangle _ { \vecdr } , \label{2}\ ] ] where the average is limited to separation vectors @xmath9 with @xmath10 , and @xmath11 is the scf due to noise alone , @xmath12 and @xmath13 is the `` spectrum quality '' ( see discussion in padoan , rosolowsky & goodman 2001 ) . @xmath13 is defined as the ratio of the rms signal within a velocity window @xmath14 and the rms noise , @xmath15 ( over all velocity channels ) , @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the width of the velocity channels . in the present work we compute the scf of both observational and synthetic spectral maps , obtained by computing the radiative transfer through the three dimensional density and velocity fields of numerical simulations of super sonic mhd turbulence . the result is typically a power law for @xmath18 that extends up to a separation @xmath5 comparable to the map size , reflecting the self similarity of super sonic turbulence ( padoan , rosolowsky & goodman 2001 ) . the power law behavior is sometimes interrupted at an intermediate scale , possibly suggesting the presence of a physical mechanism limiting the inertial range of turbulence . an example of a scf that defines an intermediate scale is the scf of the hi survey of the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) by kim et al . ( 1998 , 1999 ) . padoan et al . ( 2001 ) have recently been able to map the gas disk thickness of the lmc , assuming it is related to the intermediate scale defined by the break in the scf power law . the absolute value of @xmath18 at any @xmath19 and the slope of the @xmath18 power law for any given region depends on which molecular tracer is used ( padoan , rosolowsky & goodman 2001 ) . transitions probing higher gas density produce more fragmented integrated intensity maps than transitions probing lower gas density , and their scf is therefore steeper . in order to compare the scf of observational and synthetic maps it is therefore important to solve the radiative transfer through the model density and velocity fields accurately for the same molecular transition that is observed . in this work our aim is to compute the scf of observational data in order to provide constraints for theoretical models . the best constraints come from computing the scf of spectral maps of a specific molecular transition over a large range of line width and linear size . observationally , small scale and narrow line width objects are usually mapped out with high density tracers , while larger objects are instead usually probed with lower density tracers . @xmath0co provides a good compromise , since it is the only molecule for which very large maps containing thousands of spectra have been obtained with a significant range of resolution . in this work we have therefore chosen to use observational and synthetic maps of the j=10 line of @xmath0co . we have used 11 @xmath0co maps . for each map , we have listed in table 1 the approximate size , the distance , the rms velocity computed as the standard deviation of the line profile averaged over the whole map , the telescope beam size , the spatial sampling , the width of the velocity channels and the spectral quality defined in the previous section . smaller maps have been obtained from portions of the maps of the taurus , perseus and rosette molecular cloud complexes and the scf has been computed for each of them . the position of these smaller maps within the molecular cloud complexes is shown in figures 1 and 2 . they have been called t1 to t7 in taurus , p1 to p5 in perseus , r1b in the rosette molecular cloud map by blitz & stark ( 1986 ) and r1 and r2 in the rosette molecular cloud map by heyer et al . ( 2001 ) . the scf of each map has been approximated with a power law , over the range of spatial separations where a power law fit is relevant . for each power law fit we compute its slope , , and its absolute value at 1 pc , : @xmath20 the values of , , @xmath1 ( the line of sight rms velocity ) and the galactic coordinates of the center of each map are given in table 2 . the scf of maps of molecular cloud complexes and some smaller regions are shown in figure [ fig5 ] . we solve the compressible mhd equations in a staggered mesh of @xmath21 computational cells , with volume centered mass density and thermal energy , face centered velocity and magnetic field components , edge centered electric currents and electric fields and with periodic boundary conditions . the code uses shock and current sheet capturing techniques to ensure that magnetic and viscous dissipation at the smallest resolved scales provide the necessary dissipation paths for magnetic and kinetic energy . a more detailed presentation of the numerical method can be found elsewhere . ( padoan & nordlund 1999 ) . for the purpose of the present work we have computed numerical solutions of the mhd equations using an isothermal equation of state , and a random driving force . in all experiments , the initial density is uniform , and the initial velocity is random . we generate the velocity field in fourier space , and we give power , with a normal distribution , only to the fourier components in the shell of wave - numbers @xmath22 . we perform a helmholtz decomposition , and use only the solenoidal component of the initial velocity . however , a compressional component of the velocity field develops almost immediately due to the flow compressibility . the external driving force is generated on large scales in the same way as the velocity field . the initial magnetic field is uniform , and is oriented parallel to the @xmath23 axis : @xmath24 . because of the limited numerical resolution we have chosen not to model the collapse of turbulent density fluctuations . gravity has therefore been neglected . we have recently started to compute turbulent self gravitating flows with a numerical mesh of 500@xmath25 cells . results of the analysis of these larger simulations including self gravity will be presented in future works . we have run a number of mhd simulations in a @xmath21 computational mesh , with periodic boundary conditions . the simulations are intended to describe the turbulent dynamics in the interior of molecular clouds . the two most important numerical parameters in the models are the rms sonic and alfvnic mach numbers , @xmath26 and @xmath27 . the rms sonic mach number is here defined as the ratio of the rms flow velocity and the speed of sound . the alfvnic mach number is defined as the ratio of the rms flow velocity and the alfvn velocity , @xmath28 , where b is the volume averaged magnetic field strength . all the models used in this work have @xmath29 , except for model e that has @xmath30 , according to the suggestion that the dynamics of molecular clouds is essentially super alfvnic ( padoan & nordlund 1999 ) . our numerical simulations conserve magnetic flux , and so the volume averaged magnetic field is constant in time . as a consequence , also the value of @xmath27 as defined above remains constant . however , the value of @xmath31 grows with time ( until equilibrium is reached ) due to compression and stretching of magnetic field lines ( see padoan & nordlund 1999 ) . if we define the alfvn velocity using the rms value of the magnetic field strength , instead of its volume average , then the typical alfvnic mach number in our super alfvnic runs is @xmath32 , because of the formation of regions with large value of magnetic field strength ( mainly dense regions , as found in observations ) . the sonic mach number of observed turbulent motions in molecular clouds is @xmath33 on the scale of several parsecs , and decreases toward smaller scale . the turbulent velocity becomes comparable to the speed of sound only on very small scale , @xmath34 pc . in order to study the effect of the sonic mach number on the scf , we have computed mhd models with different values of @xmath26 , @xmath35 , 5 , 2.5 , 1.25 and 0.625 . each model has been run for approximately six dynamical times ( the dynamical time is here defined as the ratio of half the size of the computational box and the rms flow velocity ) , in order to achieve a statistically relaxed state , independent of the initial conditions . the velocity and density fields from the final snapshot of each model have been used to compute @xmath0co @xmath36 spectra , solving the radiative transfer with a non lte monte carlo code ( 4.2 ) . while the mhd calculations are independent of the physical value of the average gas density , the size of the computational mesh ( or the column density ) and the kinetic temperature , these physical parameters are necessary inputs for the radiative transfer calculations . the models are scaled to physical units assuming a value for i ) the kinetic temperature , @xmath37 , that determines the physical unit of velocity ( the numerical unit of velocity is the speed of sound ) ; ii ) the average gas density , @xmath38 ; iii ) the size of the computational box , @xmath39 . for all models we have assumed @xmath40 k , typical of molecular clouds . the dependence of observed average gas density and cloud size on the observed rms turbulent velocity ( or sonic mach number , assuming a constant value of @xmath37 ) is well approximated by empirical larson type relations ( larson 1981 ) . however , the size velocity relation has a large intrinsic scatter ( falgarone , puget & perault 1992 ) , and both the size velocity and density size relations have been criticized by several authors ( loren 1989 ; kegel 1989 ; scalo 1990 ; issa , maclaren & wolfendale 1990 ; adler & roberts 1992 ; vazquez - semadeni , ballesteros - paredes & rodriguez 1997 ; ostriker , stone & gammie 2001 ; ballesteros paredes & mac low 2002 ) . for these reasons , we scale the mhd models in four different ways . these four sets of models are all based on the same five mhd turbulence models and differ from each other only in the way they are rescaled to physical units when computing the radiative transfer . models a1 to a5 and b1 to b5 have all the same value of the average density , @xmath41 @xmath42 . models a1 to a5 have all the same size @xmath43 pc and column density @xmath44 @xmath45 ; models b1 to b5 have @xmath46 pc and @xmath47 @xmath45 . models a1r to a5r and b1r to b5r are rescaled using the larson type relations : @xmath48 where a temperature @xmath40 k is assumed , and @xmath49 that is equivalent to a constant mean surface density . models a1r to a5r have the same column density as models a1 to a5 , that is @xmath50 @xmath42 in equation ( [ larson2 ] ) ; they also have sizes @xmath5110 , 2.5 , 0.625 , 0.156 and 0.039 pc respectively , which implies @xmath52 in equation ( [ larson1 ] ) . models b1r to b2r have the same column density as models b1 to b5 , that is @xmath53 @xmath42 in equation ( [ larson2 ] ) ; they have sizes @xmath5120 , 5 , 1.25 , 0.31 and 0.078 pc respectively , which implies @xmath54 in equation ( [ larson1 ] ) . finally , the equipartition model ( model e ) has been computed only for one value of the rms sonic mach number , @xmath35 . it is rescaled to the larson type relations only once , for a size of 10 pc and a column density of @xmath44 @xmath45 . for this model we have computed spectral maps along 5 different directions , three orthogonal to the faces of the numerical mesh , as in the other experiments , and two along diagonal directions , at an angle of 54.7@xmath55 with the average magnetic field ( @xmath23 axis ) . maps from diagonal directions sample lines of sight of different length at different map positions ( longer at the central position than near the corners ) . however , the number of computational cells along each line of sight is on the average even larger than in maps from orthogonal directions , since a diagonal line of sight often cuts through the computational cells away from their center ( close to their corners ) . furthermore , the maps are computed only for a region of size equivalent to that of maps from orthogonal directions ( @xmath56 cells ) , eliminating the corners of the computational mesh . as a result , only a few percent of the spectra are generated from lines of sight sampling less than 50 computational cells . a fraction of the the lines of sight close to the map edges are nevertheless shorter than the energy injection scale ( approximately half the size of the computational mesh ) . this may introduce a bias toward smaller line width , since velocity differences are expected to grow with increasing distances . this bias or its effect on the scf should be small , since our results seem to vary smoothly as a function of the angle between the line of sight and the direction of the average magnetic field . the models a4 , a5 , b3 , b4 and b5 have velocity dispersion significantly smaller than found observationally at the scale of 5 pc . they are not used here to test the validity of models with such low velocity dispersion , but rather to test the ability of the scf method to rule them out as poor description of molecular cloud turbulence . in order to test the ability of the scf to rule out unphysical models , we have also computed two stochastic models , s2 and s4 . in both models the density field is a random field with a log normal probability distribution function , and a power law power spectrum with power law exponent equal to -1 ( the approximate value found in our mhd models ) . the velocity field is generated as a gaussian field , also with power law power spectrum . the power law exponent of the velocity field power spectrum is -2 ( close to the actual value in the mhd models ) in model s2 and -4 in model s4 . for the purpose of computing the radiative transfer and the synthetic spectral maps , both models have been scaled to a physical size @xmath46 pc and a column density @xmath57 @xmath45 . these two stochastic models are unphysical in the sense that they are not solutions of the fluid equations . statistical properties such as the power spectrum and the probability density function of density and velocity may be similar to those of flows obtained by solving the fluid equations , but their phase correlations are unphysical . this is in part illustrated by the fact that these stochastic models look clumpy , rather than filamentary as real clouds and mhd models . furthermore , their velocity and density fields can not be self consistent because they are computed independently of each other . it is shown below that the scf method can indeed rule out these unphysical models . the sonic rms mach number , @xmath26 , the average gas density , @xmath38 , and the physical size , @xmath39 , of the different models used for the radiative transfer computations are given in table 3 . the radiative transfer calculations were carried out with a monte carlo program which is a generalization of the one - dimensional monte carlo method ( bernes 1979 ) into three dimensions . the model cloud is divided into small , cubic cells in which physical properties are assumed to be constant . the discretization allows the inclusion of arbitrary kinetic temperature and molecular abundance variations . however , in the present calculations , the temperature and relative abundances are kept constant . the 2.73 k cosmic background is used as the external radiation field . there are important differences between our program and the normal monte carlo method , and some principles of the implementation are given below . a detailed description is given elsewhere ( juvela 1997 ) . in the basic monte carlo method radiation field is simulated with photon packages , each representing a number of real photons . the packages are created at random velocities at random locations and sent toward random directions . each package is followed through the cloud and interactions between photons and molecules are counted . later this information is used to solve new estimates for the level populations of the molecules . in our method the radiative transfer is simulated along random lines going through the cloud . initially , as a photon package enters the cloud it contains only background photons . as the package goes through a cell in the cloud some photons emitted by this cell are added to the package and , in particular , the number of photons absorbed within the emitting cell is calculated explicitly . this becomes important when cells are optically thick and , compared with normal monte carlo simulation , ensures more accurate estimation of the energy transfer between cells . in our program each simulated photon package represents intensity of all simulated transitions and doppler shifts at the same time . the number of individual photon packages is correspondingly smaller , and in the present case we use 240000 photon packages per iteration . the lines are divided into 70 fixed velocity channels . there is no noise associated with random sampling of doppler shifts . the simulated velocity range was adjusted according to the velocity range found in the model clouds . the channels are narrow compared with the total line widths and smaller than or equal to the smallest intrinsic line widths in the cells . the velocity discretization is therefore not expected to affect the results of the calculations . the density and velocity fields from the mhd simulations are sampled on a numerical mesh of @xmath21 cells . to speed up the radiative transfer calculations the density and velocity fields were rebinned into a mesh of @xmath58 cells by linear interpolation . the velocity dispersion between neighboring cells in the original @xmath21 data cube was used to approximate the turbulent line width within each cell of the new @xmath58 data cube . this velocity dispersion should apply to a scale slightly larger than the size of the cells in the @xmath58 mesh . however , this is approximately compensated by the fact that numerical dissipation in the mhd simulations decreases significantly the velocity dispersion on very small scale , below the actual turbulent inertial range value at that scale . on each iteration new level populations are solved from the equilibrium equations and iterations are stopped when the relative change is below @xmath592.0@xmath6010@xmath61 in all cells . only the six lowest levels were tested for convergence . the relative changes tend to be largest on the upper levels where the level populations become very small and , on the average , the convergence of the relevant first energy levels is much better than the quoted limit . the total number of energy levels included in the calculations was nine , a number clearly sufficient in case of excitation temperatures below 10k . the collisional coefficients were taken from flower & launay ( 1985 ) and green & thaddeus ( 1976 ) . the final level populations were used to calculate maps of 90@xmath6290 spectra toward three directions perpendicular to the faces of the mhd data cube . for the equipartition model e spectra were calculated also along two diagonal directions . in these cases the maps of 90@xmath6290 spectra do not extend over the whole projected cloud area . each spectrum corresponds to the intensity calculated along one line of sight ( spectra are not convolved with a larger beam ) . the spectra contain 60 velocity channels as in the monte carlo simulation . the results were compared with spectra calculated assuming lte conditions . the comparison showed that for typical physical conditions found in molecular clouds the lte assumption would be unsuitable ( padoan et al . most observational and theoretical spectral maps yield a scf that can be approximated by a single power law within a range of spatial separations , often spanning over an order of magnitude . from each power law fit we compute its slope , , and its value at 1 pc , , defined as in ( [ alphadef ] ) . we also compute the value of the velocity dispersion , @xmath1 , from each map , measured as the standard deviation of the @xmath0co @xmath36 spectrum averaged over the entire map . the values of , and @xmath1 computed from the observational maps are given in table 2 , while the values of the same quantities from the theoretical models are given in table 3 . every model provides three sets of values , because spectral maps have been computed using three orthogonal directions for the line of sight . each group of three sets of values can be interpreted as the same model cloud being `` observed '' from different directions , or as three different model clouds with comparable rms velocity . in the equipartition model , e , the rms velocities inferred from different directions are very different from each other , the largest rms velocity being found in the direction parallel to the mean magnetic field ( along the @xmath23 axis ) , and the lowest in the directions perpendicular to the magnetic field . for this model we have also computed spectral maps from two more lines of sight , corresponding to diagonal directions across the computational box . figure [ fig6 ] shows the scf of the model a1r , with line of sight parallel to the direction of the mean magnetic field . the scf of the equipartition model e is also shown for four lines of sight , two diagonal , one parallel to the direction of the mean magnetic field and one perpendicular to it to it . the figure shows that the scf of model e is very sensitive to the line of sight , due to the large variations of the rms velocity in different directions relative to the mean magnetic field . the velocity dispersion relative to the speed of sound , or the value of the sonic mach number , is the most important physical parameter characterizing the nature of the turbulence . we therefore study the dependence of the scf on the turbulent velocity dispersion ( or the rms sonic mach number , ) and propose to use this dependence to test theoretical models against the observational data . in figure [ fig7 ] the slope of the scf is plotted against the line of sight velocity dispersion . the top panels show the models of constant size and constant average gas density ( models a1 to a5 -left , and b1 to b5 -right ) ; the bottom panels show the models rescaled according to larson type relations ( models a1r to a5r -left and b1r to b5r -right ) . the observations indicate a strong correlation between and @xmath1 , over an order of magnitude in @xmath1 . a least square fit to the observational data gives : @xmath63 and for the super sonic and super alfvnic models rescaled with larson type relations ( a1r to a5r ) : @xmath64 consistent with the observational result ( the uncertainty in the exponent is the standard deviation from the least square fit ) . the corresponding models not scaled with the larson type relations ( a1 to a5 ) are also indistinguishable from the observational result ( see figure [ fig7 ] top left panel ) . models of type b ( right panels of figure [ fig7 ] ) have instead values of significantly smaller than the average ones from the observational data . the stochastic models s2 and s4 are indistinguishable from each other ; they are also totally inconsistent with the empirical @xmath1 relation , which allows them to be ruled out as invalid by the scf method . finally , the equipartition model e provides values that are consistent with the observations , and comparable to the super alfvnic models , apart from a larger scatter of values between different lines of sight . we interpret the increase of with @xmath1 as a consequence of the increasing compressibility of the turbulent flow ( @xmath1 is roughly proportional to the rms sonic mach number of the flow because the temperature in all the models is @xmath40 k , and approximately the same in the observed regions ) . the value of is in general found to grow with increasing density contrast , probably due to the increasing concentration of the mass along the line of sight around one or few dense cores , which helps decorrelating the spectra from each other . the value of is plotted against @xmath1 in figure [ fig8 ] . the top panels show the models of constant size and the bottom panels the models scaled with the larson type relations , as in figure [ fig7 ] . the values of and @xmath1 from the observational maps are weakly correlated , with slightly increasing with increasing @xmath1 : @xmath65 a tight correlation is instead found in the models of constant size ( top panels of figure [ fig8 ] ) , with decreasing with increasing @xmath1 . this inconsistency between the models and the observations is most likely due to the fact that molecular clouds of 5 to 20 pc of size ( as assumed by these models ) are never found with velocity dispersion as low as assumed in models a4 , a5 and b3 , b4 and b5 . the bottom panels of figure [ fig8 ] show that the inconsistency is in fact mostly resolved as soon as the model sizes are scaled according to the larson type relation . for the models a1r to a5r we obtain : @xmath66 if models with @xmath67 km / s were not included ( justified by the absence of such low velocity dispersions in the observational sample ) , the slope of the least square fit would be @xmath68 , fully consistent with the observations . the equipartition model yields values of and @xmath1 consistent with the observations in all directions , but the one parallel to the mean magnetic field . it could be concluded that either none of the observed objects has a significant component of the magnetic field along the line of sight , or that all of them have a magnetic field weaker than predicted by the equipartition model , consistent with the super alfvnic models . in figure [ fig9 ] we have plotted observations and models on the plane . the constant size models are again inconsistent with the observations , as is expected since the observational maps span a large range of scales . when the models are scaled according with the larson type relations and the realistic average column density of @xmath69 @xmath45 ( myers & goodman 1988 ) , the observed scatter in the plane is reproduced . the trend of the absolute value of to increase with for large values of both of them is also reproduced , between models with rms mach 5 and 10 ( a2r and a1r respectively ) ; however , models with rms mach of 20 or 30 would be necessary to fit the and values measured for the rosette molecular cloud , which can be appropriately resolved only with a numerical resolution in excess of @xmath70 computational cells . while the stochastic models s2 and s4 are only marginally inconsistent with the observations in this plot , the line of sight parallel to the direction of the mean magnetic field and one of the two diagonal lines of sight in the equipartition model e are again inconsistent with the observational data . the scf has been proposed as a statistical tool to test the validity of theoretical models describing the structure and dynamics of star forming clouds ( rosolowsky et al . 1999 ) . in a previous work we improved the scf method by studying its dependence on spatial and velocity resolution and on instrumental noise ( padoan , rosolowsky & goodman 2001 ) . here we have applied that improved scf to a number of large @xmath0co maps of molecular cloud complexes and obtained empirical correlations that can be used to test theoretical models . of the theoretical models we have computed some compare well with the empirical correlations and some do not , which shows that the scf can be used as an effective tool to rule out inappropriate or unphysical models . the empirical correlations we have obtained relate the values of , and @xmath1 with each other . the @xmath1 correlation rules out the unphysical stochastic models ( s2 and s4 ) . such models were found to produce spectral line profiles similar to observational ones by dubinski , narayan & phillips ( 1995 ) . they have also been used as models of the density field in molecular clouds by stutzki et al . ( 1998 ) and to calibrate their principal component analysis by brunt & heyer ( 2002 ) . the scf @xmath1 correlation shows that stochastic models are inappropriate to describe the structure of molecular cloud complexes . models not scaled with larson type relations ( a1a5 , b1b5 ) and models with larger than average column density ( b1b5 , b1r b5r ) have also been compared with the empirical scf correlations to show that incorrectly scaled models are readily ruled out by the scf method . the @xmath1 and the correlations do not favor the model with equipartition of kinetic and magnetic energies ( model e ) . such model yields too small values of or too large values of compared with the observational data , when seen in the direction parallel to the average magnetic field . of the two diagonal directions , one is consistent with the data and the other is not . a possible interpretation is that none of the observed regions has an average magnetic field oriented close to the direction of the line of sight . the equipartition model starts to be inconsistent with the observational data when seen along the diagonal directions , at an angle of 54.7@xmath55 to the average magnetic field . the line of sight should be within such an angle to the magnetic field in approximately 40% of the cases , assuming random orientation of the average magnetic field in the observed regions . an alternative interpretation is that all the observed regions have an average magnetic field strength smaller than in the equipartition model , and consistent with super alfvnic conditions . the super alfvnic models rescaled with larson type relations are in fact able to reproduce the empirical scf correlations . however , the total number of truly independent directions on the sky in the present observational sample is still small . more regions should be studied to rule out the equipartition model based on the scf results . the analysis of the mhd models could in principle give different results if self gravity was taken into account . however , the introduction of self gravity is not expected to decrease the value of and increase the value of , as necessary to make the equipartition model consistent with the observational correlation . the main effect of self gravity is the collapse of the densest regions , increasing the density contrast beyond the level due to the turbulence alone . this could slightly increase the value of because we interpret the increase of with @xmath1 in the mhd models as due to the increased compressibility of the turbulent flow . an increase in the value of is not expected because the local collapse of dense cores can not increase the correlation between spectra at large distances ( for a given value of an increase in would correspond to an increase in the scf at large spatial separation ) . nevertheless , the effect of self gravity should be tested by including it in the numerical solution of the mhd equations . the numerical resolution should also be larger than in the present work to resolve the initial phase of the gravitational collapse of dense cores . we have only recently started to compute self gravitating flows in a numerical mesh of @xmath71 cells , and their analysis will be presented in future works . padoan & nordlund ( 1997 , 1999 ) have proposed that the dynamics of molecular clouds on large scales is consistent with super alfvnic turbulence and inconsistent with the equipartition model . in numerical simulations of super - alfvnic turbulence the average magnetic energy grows with time , even if flux is conserved ( the average magnetic field is constant ) . the magnetic field strength is increased locally mainly in regions of compression in super sonic turbulence , and in part by stretching of field lines . even if initial conditions are such that the turbulence is highly super - alfvnic , magnetic pressure is often larger than thermal pressure in the postshock gas , due to the amplification of the magnetic field components perpendicular to the shock direction . equipartition of dynamic pressure , @xmath72 , and magnetic pressure , @xmath73 , is therefore achieved locally , but not necessarily over the whole flow . for example , in super sonic and super - alfvnic runs at a resolution of @xmath74 , the ratio of volume average magnetic and dynamic pressures relaxes at a value @xmath75 , starting from initial conditions with @xmath76 ( padoan et al . comparable values are found in the numerical experiments used in this work . the amplification of the magnetic field by the turbulence therefore does not alter the super alfvnic character of the flow . the correlation between local magnetic field strength and gas density in super sonic and super alfvnic turbulence has a very large scatter , and a well defined upper envelope with @xmath77 , both consistent with the observational data ( padoan & nordlund 1997 , 1999 ; ostriker , stone & gammie 2001 ; passot & vazquez semadeni 2002 ) . the largest values of the magnetic field strength are generally found in dense cores , but some dense cores may have a relatively weak magnetic field . however , dense cores assembled by turbulent shocks are not expected to have internal super alfvnic turbulence , because of the dissipation of kinetic energy in the shocks and of the amplification of the magnetic field in the compressed gas . observational evidence for an approximate equipartition of turbulent and magnetic energy in dense cores would therefore not be inconsistent with the super alfvnic character of the large scale flow that assembles them . the comparison between our theoretical models and the observational data could be improved if more regions with sub sonic turbulence were available in the observational sample . small velocity dispersion is found in small objects , according to larson s velocity size relation , or to the power spectrum of turbulence . the spatial resolution in single dish surveys is typically too low to sample a small object ( fraction of a parsec ) with a very large spectral maps ( several thousands of spectra ) . the only exceptions in the observational sample used in this work are l1512 and l134a . these two large maps of nearby clouds with very low velocity dispersion were obtained by falgarone et al . ( 1998 ) as part of their iram key project , focused on regions of relatively low column density at the edges of molecular cloud complexes . maps of large regions with very large velocity dispersion are instead more easily obtained from observations than in numerical simulations . assuming a gas kinetic temperature of the order of 10 k , a line of sight ( one dimensional ) velocity dispersion in excess of 2 km / s corresponds to a sonic rms mach number of the flow @xmath78 . in the present work we have not computed numerical flows with @xmath79 , since that would require a larger numerical resolution ( the density contrast grows linearly with the alfvnic mach number and therefore with the value of @xmath26 if the average magnetic field strength is not varied ) . for this reason the models do not reach the largest values of @xmath1 , and obtained from the observations ( from the maps of the rosette molecular cloud complex ) . the progression of models toward increasing values of @xmath26 suggests that a model with @xmath78 would likely fit the observed values found in the rosette molecular cloud complex , where the observed velocity dispersion is in excess of 2 km / s . this is illustrated in figure [ fig10 ] . the top panel of figure [ fig10 ] shows the for the observational data . the shaded area shows the range of values covered by the theoretical models a1r to a5r . the bottom panel shows the same plot for the model a1r to a5r . each diagonal segment connects the values for the three directions of each model . the values of and @xmath39 of the models are also given in the plot . the arrow marks the direction of increasing suggesting that models with @xmath80 may fit the observations with the largest velocity dispersion . in the present work we have computed the spectral correlation function ( scf ) of spectral maps of molecular cloud complexes and regions within them , observed in the j=10 transition of @xmath0co . we have found that the scf is a power law over approximately an order of magnitude in spatial separation . the power law slope of the scf , , its normalization , , and the spectral line width averaged over the whole map , @xmath1 , have been computed for all the observational maps . we have obtained empirical correlations between these quantities and have proposed to use them to test the validity of theoretical models of molecular clouds . theoretical models of spectral line maps have been generated by computing the radiative transfer through the numerical solutions ( density and velocity fields ) of the magneto - hydrodynamic ( mhd ) equations , for turbulent flows with different values of the rms sonic and alfvnic mach numbers , and also through stochastic density and velocity fields with different power spectra . super - alfvnic mhd models rescaled according to larson type relations are in the best agreement with the empirical correlations . unphysical stochastic models are instead ruled out . mhd models with equipartition of magnetic and kinetic energy of turbulence do not reproduce the observational data when their average magnetic field is oriented approximately parallel to the line of sight . finally , mhd models not rescaled according to larson type relations are also inconsistent with the observational data . we can not exclude the possibility that different physical models for the dynamics of molecular clouds , or even unphysical models , that we have not tested here , would satisfy the empirical correlations found in this work . however , we have shown that the scf method is able to rule out certain unphysical or incorrectly scaled models . reproducing these scf results should be considered as a necessary ( but not sufficient ) condition for the validity of theoretical models describing the structure and the dynamics of molecular clouds . models for which the scf or similar statistical tests can not be computed to allow a quantitative comparison with observed spectral maps can not be legitimately evaluated . the comparison between theory and observations presented in this work requires significant computational resources . numerical simulations of three dimensional turbulent flows must be run at large resolution and the radiative transfer has to be computed in three dimensions in order to generate synthetic spectral maps of the observed molecular transitions . the type of models and the physical parameters investigated in this work are therefore limited to a few significant cases . future work should investigate the scf of a larger variety of models , including different magnetic field intensities and flows with gravitationally collapsing cores . we are grateful to eve ostriker and jim stone for helpful comments on our model data comparison . the referee report by enrique vazquez semadeni has also contributed to improve this work . this work was supported by an nsf galactic astronomy grant to ag . the work of pp was partially performed while pp held a national research council associateship award at the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology . mj acknowledges the support of the academy of finland grant no . 1011055 . * figure captions : * + * table [ t1 ] * main parameters of the observed spectral maps : approximate size , distance , rms velocity over the whole map , telescope beam , spatial sampling , velocity channel width , average spectrum quality and bibliographic reference . + * table [ t2 ] * spectral line width averaged over the whole map , @xmath1 , power law slope of the scf , and scf normalization , , galactic longitude , @xmath81 , and galactic latitude , @xmath82 , of the center of all the observed maps and selected regions within them . + * table [ t3 ] * first three columns from the left : model name , rms sonic mach number of the flow and physical size of the computational mesh . following columns : line of sight velocity dispersion , scf slope and scf normalization , repeated for the three orthogonal directions for which synthetic spectral maps have been computed in each model . values for the diagonal directions of model e are not given ( they are within the ranges of values covered by the other three directions parallel and perpendicular to the mean magnetic field ) . + * figure [ fig1 ] : * top panel : velocity integrated intensity map of the perseus molecular cloud complex in the j=1 - 0 transition of @xmath0co ( padoan et al . bottom panel : same as top panel , but for the taurus molecular cloud complex ( mizuno et al . smaller regions within the maps where the scf has also been computed are highlighted . + * figure [ fig2 ] : * same as in figure [ fig1 ] , but for the rosette molecular cloud complex . top panel from heyer et al . ( 2001 ) ; bottom panel from blitz & stark ( 1986 ) . + * figure [ fig5 ] : * top left panel : the scf averaged over the entire map of the perseus , rosette and taurus molecular cloud complexes . solid lines are least square fits to the power law sections of the scf . the exponents @xmath83 of the power law fits are also given in the figure . top right panel : scf of the whole map of the perseus molecular cloud complex and of smaller regions within the same map . bottom left panel : scf of the taurus molecular cloud complex and of smaller regions within the same map . bottom right panel : scf of pvceph and hh300 . + * figure [ fig6 ] : * the scf computed from mhd models . asterisk symbols are for the super - alfvnic model a1r in the @xmath84 direction ( parallel to the mean magnetic field ) . diamond symbols are for the equipartition model in the @xmath85 and @xmath84 direction ( perpendicular and parallel to the average magnetic field direction respectively ) and along two diagonal directions ( @xmath86 and @xmath87 ) . the slope of the scf increases with increasing rms velocity . the scf is therefore weakly dependent on the direction of the line of sight for the super - alfvnic model , while it is much steeper in the direction parallel to the magnetic field ( larger rms velocity ) than in the perpendicular direction in the equipartition model . + * figure [ fig7 ] : * scf slope versus velocity dispersion . the top panels show the models of constant size and constant average gas density as asterisks ( models a1 to a5 left , b1 to b5 right ) ; the bottom panels show the models rescaled according to larson type relations as asterisks ( models a1r to a5r left , b1r to b5r right ) . observational values are shown as squares , the equipartition model as triangles and the stochastic models as diamonds . + * figure [ fig8 ] : * scf value at 1 pc versus velocity dispersion . different panels show different models as in figure [ fig7 ] . symbols are also as in figure [ fig7 ] . + * figure [ fig9 ] : * scf slope versus scf value at 1 pc . symbols and panels as in figure [ fig7 ] . + * figure [ fig10 ] : * top panel : values of and from the observations . some of the symbols are labeled with the region name . the shaded area shows the range of values covered by the models a1r to a5r . bottom panel : same shaded area as in the top panel . diagonal segments shows the range of values of and for the three directions of each model . the rms sonic mach number of the corresponding model is given on the right hand side of each segment , while the value of the linear size is given on the left hand side . the arrow indicates the progression of models toward larger values of sonic mach number , . lcc|ccc|ccc|ccc & & & & x & & & y & & & z & + model & & 0 & & & & & & & & & + + a1 & 10.0 & 5 & 1.13 & 0.30 & 0.37 & 1.36 & 0.32 & 0.34 & 1.24 & 0.35 & 0.31 + a2 & 5.0 & 5 & 0.56 & 0.25 & 0.46 & 0.71 & 0.30 & 0.39 & 0.67 & 0.28 & 0.42 + a3 & 2.5 & 5 & 0.30 & 0.19 & 0.55 & 0.38 & 0.24 & 0.48 & 0.36 & 0.21 & 0.52 + a4 & 1.2 & 5 & 0.17 & 0.13 & 0.66 & 0.17 & 0.15 & 0.64 & 0.18 & 0.16 & 0.61 + a5 & 0.6 & 5 & 0.12 & 0.13 & 0.68 & 0.11 & 0.10 & 0.71 & 0.12 & 0.14 & 0.66 + b1 & 10.0 & 20 & 1.21 & 0.26 & 0.64 & 1.42 & 0.27 & 0.61 & 1.33 & 0.27 & 0.59 + b2 & 5.0 & 20 & 0.61 & 0.22 & 0.70 & 0.77 & 0.26 & 0.65 & 0.72 & 0.24 & 0.67 + b3 & 2.5 & 20 & 0.33 & 0.18 & 0.73 & 0.41 & 0.23 & 0.68 & 0.39 & 0.20 & 0.71 + b4 & 1.2 & 20 & 0.18 & 0.14 & 0.77 & 0.19 & 0.15 & 0.77 & 0.21 & 0.17 & 0.75 + b5 & 0.6 & 20 & 0.13 & 0.13 & 0.79 & 0.13 & 0.11 & 0.81 & 0.14 & 0.14 & 0.78 + + a1r & 10.0 & 10 & 1.13 & 0.30 & 0.44 & 1.36 & 0.32 & 0.42 & 1.23 & 0.35 & 0.39 + a2r & 5.0 & 2.5 & 0.56 & 0.23 & 0.41 & 0.72 & 0.30 & 0.32 & 0.66 & 0.26 & 0.37 + a3r & 2.5 & 0.62 & 0.30 & 0.18 & 0.41 & 0.37 & 0.21 & 0.34 & 0.35 & 0.20 & 0.37 + a4r & 1.2 & 0.16 & 0.16 & 0.12 & 0.45 & 0.15 & 0.13 & 0.42 & 0.17 & 0.15 & 0.38 + a5r & 0.6 & 0.04 & 0.10 & 0.11 & 0.41 & 0.10 & 0.08 & 0.49 & 0.11 & 0.12 & 0.39 + b1r & 10.0 & 20 & 1.21 & 0.26 & 0.64 & 1.42 & 0.27 & 0.61 & 1.33 & 0.27 & 0.59 + b2r & 5.0 & 5 & 0.60 & 0.22 & 0.55 & 0.76 & 0.23 & 0.49 & 0.69 & 0.20 & 0.53 + b3r & 2.5 & 1.25 & 0.33 & 0.15 & 0.52 & 0.40 & 0.18 & 0.45 & 0.37 & 0.16 & 0.49 + b4r & 1.2 & 0.31 & 0.18 & 0.12 & 0.50 & 0.18 & 0.13 & 0.47 & 0.19 & 0.14 & 0.44 + b5r & 0.6 & 0.08 & 0.12 & 0.10 & 0.46 & 0.12 & 0.09 & 0.52 & 0.13 & 0.12 & 0.42 + + e & 10.0 & 5 & 0.73 & 0.21 & 0.46 & 0.81 & 0.25 & 0.43 & 1.90 & 0.49 & 0.22 + + s2 & 10.0 & 20 & 1.37 & 0.15 & 0.52 & 1.29 & 0.15 & 0.53 & 1.31 & 0.14 & 0.53 + s4 & 10.0 & 20 & 1.23 & 0.16 & 0.47 & 1.17 & 0.15 & 0.49 & 1.17 & 0.17 & 0.46 +

we compute the spectral correlation function ( scf ) of @xmath0co j=10 maps of molecular cloud complexes . the scf is a power law over approximately an order of magnitude in spatial separation in every map . the power law slope of the scf , , its normalization , , and the spectral line width averaged over the whole map , @xmath1 , are computed for all the observational maps . the values of , and @xmath1 are combined to obtain empirical correlations to be used as tests for theoretical models of molecular clouds . synthetic spectral maps are computed from different theoretical models , including solutions of the magneto - hydrodynamic ( mhd ) equations with different values of the rms mach number of the flow and stochastic models with different power spectra of the velocity field . in order to compute the radiative transfer from the mhd models it is necessary to assign the models a physical scale and a physical density . when these assignments are made according to larson type relations the best fit to the observational correlations is obtained . unphysical stochastic models are instead ruled out by the empirical correlations . mhd models with equipartition of magnetic and kinetic energy of turbulence do not reproduce the observational data when their average magnetic field is oriented approximately parallel to the line of sight .

1311.7272

quantum tensor networks are a competitive tool to study strongly correlated quantum systems on a lattice . their history begins with the density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) @xcite - an algorithm to minimize the energy of a matrix product state ( mps ) ansatz in one dimension ( 1d ) , see ref . @xcite for a comprehensive review of mps algorithms . in the last decade mps was generalized to a 2d `` tensor product state '' widely known as a projected entangled pair state ( peps ) @xcite . another type of tensor network is the multiscale entanglement renormalization ansatz ( mera ) @xcite , and the branching mera @xcite , that is a refined version of the real space renormalization group . being variational methods , the quantum tensor networks do not suffer form the notorious fermionic sign problem , and thus they can be applied to strongly correlated fermions in 2d @xcite . a possible breakthrough in this direction was an application of the peps ansatz to the t - j model @xcite , which is a strong coupling approximation to the celebrated hubbard hamiltonian of the high temperature superconductivity @xcite . an energy of the ground state was obtained that could compete with the best variational monte - carlo results @xcite . the tensor networks also proved to be a powerful tool to study topological spin liquids ( tsl ) . the search for realistic models gained momentum after white demonstrated the spin - liquid nature of the kagome antiferromagnet @xcite . this result was obtained by a _ tour de force _ application of a quasi-1d dmrg . the dmrg investigation of tsl s was elevated to a higher degree of sophistication in ref . unfortunately , the mps tensor network underlying the dmrg suffers from severe limitations in two dimensions , where it can be used for states with a very short correlation length only . in contrast , the peps ansatz in fig . [ figpeps ] is not restricted in this way . its usefulness for tsl has already been demonstrated . in ref . @xcite it was shown how to represent the rvb state with the peps ansatz in an efficient way . in ref . @xcite peps was used to classify topologically distinct ground states of the kagome antiferromagnet . finally , in ref . @xcite peps demonstrated a tsl in the antiferromagnetic @xmath1 model . in contrast to the ground state , finite temperature states have been explored so far mostly with the mps @xcite . in a way that can be easily generalized to 2d , the mps is extended to finite temperature by appending each lattice site with an ancilla @xcite . a thermal state is obtained by an imaginary time evolution of a pure state in the enlarged hilbert space starting from infinite temperature . however , the thermal states are of more interest in 2d , where they can undergo finite temperature phase transformations . a thermal peps with ancillas was considered in ref . @xcite , where a finite temperature phase diagram of the 2d quantum ising model in a transverse field was obtained . this approach is further developed in this paper to a fermionic thermal peps , with a benchmark application to a 2d spinless hubbard model . before we proceed , let us note that the peps with ancillas is not the only way to attack the strongly correlated thermal states . a very interesting alternative was developed in a series of papers @xcite where , instead of the imaginary time evolution , a tensor network representing the partition function is contracted by subsequent tensor renormalizations in the imaginary time and space dimensions . yet another interesting alternative , presented in ref . @xcite , is based on linear optimization of local density matrices at finite @xmath2 . finally , alternative representations for fermionic states are also developed @xcite . the paper is organized as follows . in section [ tpeps ] we introduce fermionic peps with ancillas at finite temperature and outline the algorithm in most general terms . in brief section [ hubbard ] the hubbard model for spinless fermions on a square lattice is introduced with a hoping term , a symmetry breaking term , and a nearest - neighbor ( nn ) attraction . the following section [ suzuki ] introduces the imaginary time evolution operator , its second order suzuki - trotter decomposition for the spinless hubbard model , and their diagrammatic representation in terms of the tensor network . the peps tensors require renormalization / truncation of their bond indices after every suzuki - trotter gate . the renormalization procedure is described in section [ renormalization ] , where it is illustrated with a series of diagrams . it is a variation on the corner matrix renormalization @xcite . in section [ results ] we report benchmark results of the algorithm in the spinless hubbard model . we conclude in section [ summary ] . we consider spinless fermions on an infinite square lattice with a hamiltonian @xmath3 . every site has two fock states numbered by their fermionic occupation number @xmath4 . every site is accompanied by a fermionic ancilla with fock states @xmath5 . the enlarged hilbert space is spanned by fock states @xmath6 , where the ordered product runs over all lattice sites @xmath7 . the infinite temperature state @xmath8 is obtained from a pure state in the enlarged space by tracing out the ancillas , ( 0 ) = tr_a|(0)(0)| , where |(0 ) = _ s ( every site with its ancilla . the state @xmath9 at a finite @xmath10 is obtained from | ( ) e^-12h |(0 ) u ( ) |(0 ) after an imaginary time evolution . for an efficient simulation of the evolution we represent @xmath11 by a peps on the checkerboard lattice , see fig . [ figpeps ] . the lattice has two sublattices , @xmath12 and @xmath13 , with the same tensor , @xmath14 and @xmath15 respectively , at every site of the sublattice . here @xmath16 and @xmath17 are fermion and ancilla indices respectively , and @xmath18 are bond indices to contract the tensor with its nearest neighbors . the tensors are parity preserving : only the tensor elements with an even sum @xmath19 can be non - zero . by construction , the ansatz is translationally invariant with respect to diagonal moves , but when the tensors @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the same ( up to a gauge transformation on bond indices ) it gains full translational invariance . the state is | ( ) = _ \{a_s , i_s } _ a , b[\{a_s , i_s } ] _ s|a_s , i_s . here the sum runs over all indices @xmath20 at all sites . the amplitude @xmath21 $ ] is the tensor contraction in fig . . the initial product state ( [ psi0 ] ) can be represented by a^ia_ltrb = b^ia_ltrb = ^ia r0 _ b0 [ a0 ] with the minimal bond dimension @xmath22 . and @xmath23 . in ( b ) , the amplitude @xmath24 $ ] with all bond indices connecting nearest - neighbors tensors contracted . the index contraction is represented by a line connecting two tensors . each crossing between two lines implies a fermionic swap factor : when the indices on both lines are odd , then their contribution to the contraction is multiplied by @xmath25 . the inclusion of this swap gate follows the strategy proposed by corboz _ the tensors make a checkerboard lattice with sublattices @xmath12 and @xmath13 . the ansatz becomes translationally invariant when the tensors @xmath26 ( modulo a gauge transformation on the bond index ) . ] we proceed with the spinless hubbard hamiltonian & = & - _ s_a , s_b c_s_a^c_s_b + h.c . + + & & - _ s_a , s_b c_s_a c_s_b + h.c . + + & & - g _ s_a , s_b ( n_s_a-12)(n_s_b-12 ) + & & h_ba + h_ab + h _ [ calh ] here the index @xmath27 ( @xmath28 ) runs over the sublattice @xmath12 ( @xmath13 ) , @xmath29 is a fermionic annihilation operator , and @xmath30 is the occupation number . the @xmath31-term is an explicit @xmath32 symmetry breaking @xmath0-wave pairing , and the @xmath33-term is a nearest - neighbor attraction . we define elementary infinitesimal evolution operators : u_ab(d ) & & e^-12d h_ab = _ s_a , s_b ( 1 + 12 d c_s_b^c_s_a ) , + u_ba(d ) & & e^-12d h_ba = _ s_a , s_b ( 1 + 12 d c_s_a^c_s_b ) , + u_(d ) & & e^-12d h _ = _ s_a , s_b ( 1 + 12 d c_s_a c_s_b ) , + u_g(d ) & & e^-12d h_g + & & _ s_a , s_b , where @xmath34 . each of the evolution operators is a product of @xmath35-site gates . they are the building blocks for the second order suzuki - trotter decomposition . on the tensors @xmath12 and @xmath13 , compare with eqs . ( [ a],[b ] ) . here each crossing between two lines implies a fermionic swap factor @xmath36 . the operator @xmath37 when its bond index @xmath38 , or @xmath39 when @xmath40 . notice that the tensor @xmath41 is parity preserving : the sum of its three indices is even . notice also that when more than one index @xmath40 the contraction is zero : a creation / annihilation operator can not be applied more than once . ] the action of the hopping operator , say , @xmath42 maps the tensors @xmath12 and @xmath13 to new tensors : & & ( a)^ia_i(l , s_l),i(t , s_t),i(r , s_r),i(b , s_b ) = [ a ] + & & _ s,0 a^ia_ltrb+ + & & _ s,1 s_s_tls_s_tas_s_las_s_rb _ j i |c| j a^ja_ltrb , + & & ( b)^ia_i(l , s_l),i(t , s_t),i(r , s_r),i(b , s_b ) = [ b ] + & & _ s,0 b^ia_ltrb+ + & & _ s,1 s_s_tls_s_tas_s_las_s_rb _ j i |c^| j b^ja_ltrb , see the diagrams in figure [ figaprime ] . here the gate indices @xmath43 and @xmath44 . an odd @xmath40 means a transfer of one fermion along the bond @xmath45 . @xmath46 is an invertible parity - preserving index function . @xmath36 is a fermionic swap factor : @xmath47 when both @xmath17 and @xmath48 are odd and @xmath49 otherwise . equations ( [ a],[b ] ) are an exact map , but the new tensors @xmath50 and @xmath51 have the bond dimension @xmath52 instead of the original @xmath53 . the same is true for the action of @xmath54 , see the diagrams in figure [ figadelta ] , & & ( a)^ia_i(l , s_l),i(t , s_t),i(r , s_r),i(b , s_b ) = [ adelta ] + & & _ s,0 a^ia_ltrb+ + & & _ s,1 s_s_tls_s_tas_s_las_s_rb _ j i |c| j a^ja_ltrb , + & & ( b)^ia_i(l , s_l),i(t , s_t),i(r , s_r),i(b , s_b ) = [ bdelta ] + & & _ s,0 b^ia_ltrb+ + & & _ s,1 s_s_tls_s_tas_s_las_s_rb ( -1)^s_b+s_r _ j i |c| j b^ja_ltrb , just as for the action of @xmath55 , the same for both @xmath12 and @xmath13 , ( a)^ia_i(l , s_l),i(t , s_t),i(r , s_r),i(b , s_b)= ^s/4 ( i-12)^s/2 a^ia_ltrb . [ ag ] since @xmath55 does not transfer fermions between different sites , in eq . ( [ ag ] ) the gate indices @xmath56 are even and @xmath46 is preserving the parity of @xmath45 . on the tensors @xmath12 and @xmath13 , ( [ adelta],[bdelta ] ) . the factors @xmath57 and @xmath58 are represented here by the self - crossing loops . ] after every gate @xmath59 , the new bond dimension @xmath52 has to be truncated back to @xmath53 in a way least distortive to the new peps @xmath60 build out of @xmath50 and @xmath51 . this is done by an application of isometries @xmath61 that map from @xmath52 to @xmath53 dimensions : _ l,t,r,b w_l^l w_t^t w_r^r w_b^b ( a)^ia_ltrb = ( new ) a^ia_ltrb , see fig . [ figrenb]d . @xmath61 must be parity preserving for the new @xmath12 to preserve parity . the isometries should be optimized to be the least destructive to the norm squared @xmath62 . the construction of the best isometry described in figs . [ figaa],[figcvh],[figrenc],[figrenb ] is a variant of the corner matrix renormalization @xcite . it requires calculation of tensor environments for @xmath50 and @xmath51 in the network representing the norm squared @xmath62 . this environment can not be calculated exactly in an efficient way . this is why it is replaced by an effective environment , made of the environmental tensors @xmath63 and @xmath2 , that should appear to the tensors @xmath50 and @xmath51 as close to the exact one as possible . the environmental tensors are contracted with each other by the environmental indices of dimension @xmath64 . increasing @xmath64 should make the effective environment more accurate . at the beginning of the time evolution the environmental tensors @xmath65 are initialized with random numbers . after every time step we add weak noise to the converged tensors before they are re - used in the next time step . the noise prevents the tensors from being trapped in a subspace of a lower dimension @xmath53 or @xmath64 . a bit more technical issue concerns the construction of the new @xmath63 and @xmath2 in figs . [ figrenc]c and [ figrenc]d respectively . in principle , all @xmath64 leading singular vectors @xmath66 can be used in this contraction , even those corresponding to singular values equal to numerical zero . by construction , the `` zero vectors '' do not make any difference when @xmath65 are contracted as in the norm - squared of peps . however , we found the algorithm to be unstable unless we set the ( numerically inaccurate ) zero vectors to zero . the inaccuracies do make a difference when the renormalized @xmath65 are contracted in a way different than the norm - squared . this truncation requires a cut - off that sets the minimal singular value that is considered to be non - zero . its net effect is that the algorithm occasionally operates with an effective @xmath67 that is less than the declared @xmath64 . with its conjugate that makes a transfer matrix @xmath17 . here @xmath68 is an invertible parity - preserving index function . ] . this contraction can not be done exactly , hence it is approximated by the contraction on the rhs with the corner matrices @xmath63 and the transfer matrices @xmath2 . their ( red ) environmental indices have an environmental bond dimension @xmath64 . the parity - preserving @xmath63 s and @xmath2 s should be optimized so that to the transfer matrix @xmath17 in the center its environment on the rhs should appear the same as its exact environment on the lhs as much as possible . their iterative construction is described in fig . [ figrenc ] . ] are obtained by repeating a renormalization procedure until convergence . the procedure has four steps . in step ( a ) , the corner matrices @xmath63 are expanded to include the adjacent @xmath2-tensors and transfer matrices @xmath17 or @xmath48 . in step ( b ) , the expanded corner matrices @xmath69 are contracted to form a matrix whose singular value decomposition is truncated to @xmath64 leading singular values @xmath70 . the corresponding left and right singular vectors define the parity - preserving isometries @xmath71 and @xmath72 . in step ( c ) , the isometries are used to renormalize the expanded corner matrices @xmath69 and make new corner matrices @xmath63 . in step ( d ) , the same isometries are used to renormalize expanded @xmath2-tensors and make new tensors @xmath2 . the four - step procedure is repeated until convergence of the singular values . ] have been converged , one can renormalize the bond indices of the new peps tensors @xmath50 and @xmath51 . the renormalization proceeds in four steps . in ( a ) , the diagram would be an approximate representation of the norm squared of the state , if not for the one uncontracted bond in the center . the diagram is an environment @xmath73 for the uncontracted bond . in ( b ) , each of the two indices of @xmath73 can be represented by two indices of dimension @xmath52 in such a way that the right / left index corresponds to the top / bottom tensor @xmath50 or @xmath51 in fig . [ figaa ] . after the left indices of @xmath73 are traced out , one obtains an environment @xmath74 for an uncontracted bond in the top peps layer . in ( c ) , the environment @xmath74 is subject to a singular value decomposition that is truncated to the @xmath53 leading singular values @xmath75 . their corresponding singular vectors define the isometries @xmath76 and @xmath77 . in ( d ) , the isometries renormalize the tensors @xmath50 and @xmath51 back to new tensors @xmath12 and @xmath13 with the original bond dimension @xmath53 . this renormalization completes the action of the evolution gate @xmath59 . ] here we summarize results for the hamiltonian ( [ calh ] ) with or without the symmetry - breaking @xmath31-term or the interaction @xmath33-term . we begin with the exactly solvable case when the quartic interaction @xmath78 . the ground state does not satisfy the area law for entanglement , but this does not preclude accurate description of its high temperature properties . in the absence of the @xmath32 symmetry - breaking @xmath31-term , all imaginary time evolutions preserve the average density @xmath79 within numerical precision . with the @xmath31-term the density is preserved with a precision of @xmath80 . nonzero local averages are the nn hopping term @xmath81 and the nn anomalous term @xmath82 . both are obtained from a nn two - site reduced density matrix @xmath83 . the numerical @xmath83 can be compared with its exact counterpart @xmath84 . their difference can be quantified by an error - , where @xmath85 , that gives an idea about the order of magnitude of the errors of individual matrix elements . a more demanding test , that goes beyond the nn @xmath83 , is a two - site correlator : c_r= c^_x , y c_x+r , y between sites @xmath86 and @xmath87 . again , it can be compared with its exact counterpart . results for the fermi sea ( @xmath88 ) are shown in figure [ delta0 ] . for the bond dimensions @xmath89 they are accurate up to @xmath90 , see fig . [ delta0]a . in this range of @xmath53 , systematic convergence to the exact result with increasing @xmath53 is last seen around @xmath91 , see figs . [ delta0]b and [ delta0]c . figure [ delta0]d shows the short - ranged correlator @xmath92 at @xmath91 . the values of @xmath92 are accurate down to @xmath80 . apparently , the accuracy of the following evolution of the fermi sea towards higher @xmath10 is limited by the bond dimension @xmath53 . in function of @xmath10 . in ( b ) , focus on @xmath93 showing convergence to the exact result with increasing bond dimension @xmath53 . in ( c ) , the error of the two - site reduced density matrix @xmath83 in function of @xmath10 . in ( d ) , modulus the correlation function @xmath94 at @xmath91 . the exact @xmath95 for even @xmath96 and numerically it is small indeed , especially for @xmath97 . ] results for noninteracting fermions with the explicit symmetry breaking @xmath31-term are shown in figure [ delta01 ] for @xmath98 . up to @xmath99 the overall error of the two - site density matrix is the smallest for the largest bond dimension @xmath97 , see fig . [ delta01]c . the algorithm was not optimized to maximize accuracy of any particular observable or figure of merit , hence it is not quite surprising that the relative accuracy of the nn hopping term turns out better than the same accuracy of the nn anomalous term simply because the hopping term is much stronger than the anomalous one . indeed , the error of @xmath100 in fig . [ delta01]d is less than the error of the anomalous term in fig . [ delta01]a . the values of the correlators @xmath92 in fig . [ delta01]d are accurate down to @xmath80 . the exact @xmath95 for even @xmath96 , and the corresponding numerical values decay to zero with increasing bond dimension @xmath53 . in function of @xmath10 . in ( b ) , focus on @xmath93 showing convergence to the exact result with increasing bond dimension @xmath53 . in ( c ) , the overall error of the two - site reduced density matrix @xmath83 . in ( d ) , modulus of the correlation function @xmath94 at @xmath91 . the exact @xmath95 for even @xmath96 and numerically it is small . ] with @xmath101 the system becomes non - integrable . figure [ g1 ] shows results for a weak interaction with @xmath102 on top of @xmath98 . the interaction enhances the @xmath0-wave pairing as measured by the anomalous term . both the anomalous term in fig . [ g1]a and the dominant correlators @xmath92 in fig . [ g1]b appear converged in @xmath53 up to @xmath91 . in function of @xmath10 . in ( b ) , modulus the correlation function @xmath94 at @xmath91 . @xmath94 seems to tend to @xmath103 for even @xmath96 . ] a strong interaction @xmath104 introduces a high - temperature symmetry breaking phase transition from the symmetric phase with half - filling , where @xmath105 , to a symmetry - broken phase where either @xmath106 or @xmath107 . it belongs to the universality class of the 2d classical ising model with @xmath108 playing the role of the order parameter . the correlation length in the density - density correlation function d_r = n_x+r , y n_x , y -n_x+r , y n_x , y[dr ] diverges near the critical @xmath109 . the critical correlations do not necessarily mean that the state can not be described by a peps with a finite bond dimension , but the environmental bond dimension must diverge if we want an accurate environmental tensors either for calculation of expectation values or making a time step in the imaginary time evolution @xcite . in order to smooth out the phase transition , we add to the hamiltonian ( [ calh ] ) an explicit symmetry breaking term _ bias = -2 g b _ s n_s [ calhb ] with a tiny bias @xmath48 . with a strong enough bias , it becomes possible to evolve the state across the critical regime with a finite environment . results for @xmath104 are collected in figure [ cr ] . in fig . [ cr]a we show the order parameter as a function of inverse temperature for different values of the bias . decreasing the bias results in a less analytic and more critical - looking curve . figure [ cr]b shows the density - density correlator in the middle of the critical regime for a bias @xmath110 and @xmath111 . again , the weaker bias allows for longer - range and more critical correlations . the plots for different bond dimensions @xmath89 demonstrate convergence with increasing @xmath53 , especially at shorter distances where the correlations are more substantial . the tails of the correlation functions are exponential , as is inevitable for a finite environmental bond dimension , but their correlation length increases with decreasing bias . finally , figures [ cr]c and d show the correlation function for @xmath110 and @xmath111 respectively at several values of @xmath10 close to @xmath109 . in function of @xmath10 for different values of the bias @xmath48 . with decreasing @xmath48 the function develops a non - analytic criticality . in ( b ) , the connected density - density correlation function ( [ dr ] ) for @xmath112 ( blue ) and @xmath113 ( green ) , and for bond dimensions @xmath89 . in ( c ) , the correlator @xmath114 at the bias @xmath110 in the critical regime where the correlation length is the longest . in ( d ) , the same as in c but for a weaker bias @xmath111 that allows for longer correlations . ] we presented an efficient tensor network algorithm for simulation of finite temperature fermionic systems and its benchmark application to spinless fermions with @xmath0-wave pairing . the imaginary time evolution proved to be accurate at high temperatures . a strong nearest - neighbor attraction introduces a high - temperature symmetry - breaking continuous phase transition . with a tiny symmetry - breaking term the imaginary time evolution across the transition proved to be smooth , but it still allowed for long range correlations in the critical regime . * * this work was supported in part by the polish national science center ( ncn ) through grant 2011/01/b / st3/00512 . the research was carried out in part with the equipment purchased thanks to the financial support of the european regional development fund in the framework of the polish innovation economy operational program ( contract no . poig.02.01.00 - 12 - 023/08 ) . f. verstraete and j. i. cirac , cond - mat/0407066 ; v. murg , f. verstraete , and j. i. cirac , phys . rev . a * 75 * , 033605 ( 2007 ) ; g. sierra and m. a. martn - delgado , arxiv : cond - mat/9811170 ; t. nishino and k. okunishi , j. phys . soc . jpn . * 67 * , 3066 ( 1998 ) ; y. nishio , n. maeshima , a. gendiar , and t. nishino , cond - mat/0401115 ; j. jordan , r. ors , g. vidal , f. verstraete , and j. i. cirac , phys . rev . lett . * 101 * , 250602 ( 2008 ) ; z .- c . gu , m. levin , and x .- wen , phys . b * 78 * , 205116 ( 2008 ) ; h. c. jiang , z. y. weng , and t. xiang , phys . rev * 101 * , 090603 ( 2008 ) ; z. y. xie , h. c. jiang , q. n. chen , z. y. weng , and t. xiang , phys . . lett . * 103 * , 160601 ( 2009 ) ; p .- c . chen , c .- y . lai , and m .- f . yang , j. stat . mech . : theory exp . ( 2009 ) p10001 ; r. ors and g. vidal , phys . b * 80 * , 094403 ( 2009 ) . g. vidal , phys . lett . * 99 * , 220405 ( 2007 ) ; g. vidal , phys . * 101 * , 110501 ( 2008 ) ; l. cincio , j. dziarmaga , and m. m. rams , phys . lett . * 100 * , 240603 ( 2008 ) ; g. evenbly and g. vidal , phys . lett . * 102 * , 180406 ( 2009 ) ; g. evenbly and g. vidal , phys . b * 79 * , 144108 ( 2009 ) . t. barthel , c. pineda , and j. eisert phys . a * 80 * , 042333 ( 2009 ) ; p. corboz and g. vidal , phys . b * 80 * , 165129 ( 2009 ) ; p. corboz , g. evenbly , f. verstraete , and g. vidal , phys . rev . a * 81 * , 010303(r ) ( 2010 ) ; c. v. kraus , n. schuch , f. verstraete , and j. i. cirac , phys . a * 81 * , 052338 ( 2010 ) ; c. pineda , t. barthel , and j. eisert , phys . rev . a * 81 * , 050303(r ) ( 2010 ) gu , f. verstraete , and x .- wen , arxiv:1004.2563 ( 2010 ) . f. verstraete , j. j. garcia - ripoll , and j. i. cirac , phys . rev * 93 * , 207204 ( 2004 ) ; m. zwolak and g. vidal , phys . . lett . * 93 * , 207205 ( 2004 ) ; a.e . feiguin and s.r . white , phys . b * 72 * , 220401 ( 2005 ) . z. y. xie , h. c. jiang , q. n. chen , z. y. weng , t. xiang , phys.rev.lett . * 103 * , 160601 ( 2009 ) ; h.h . zhao , z.y . xie , q.n . chen , z.c . wei , j.w . cai , t. xiang , phys . b * 81 * , 174411 ( 2010 ) ; w. li , s .- j . ran , s .- s . gong , y. zhao , b. xi , f. ye , and g. su , phys . lett . * 106 * , 127202 ( 2011 ) ; z. y. xie , j. chen , m. p. qin , j. w. zhu , l. p. yang , and t. xiang , phys . b * 86 * , 045139 ( 2012 ) ; shi - ju ran , wei li , bin xi , zhe zhang and gang su , phys . b * 86 * , 134429 ( 2012 ) ; s .- j . ran , b. xi , t. liu , and g. su , phys . b * 88 * , 064407 ( 2013 ) ; a. denbleyker , y. liu , y. meurice , m. p. qin , t. xiang , z. y. xie , j. f. yu , h. zou , arxiv:1309.6623 . r. j. baxter , j. math . phys . * 9 * , 650 ( 1968 ) ; j. stat * 19 * , 461 ( 1978 ) ; t. nishino and k. okunishi , j. phys . . jpn . * 65 * , 891 ( 1996 ) ; r. ors and g. vidal , phys . rev . b * 80 * , 094403 ( 2009 ) ; r. ors , phys . rev . b * 85 * , 205117 ( 2012 ) ; r. ors , arxiv:1306.2164 .

an algorithm for imaginary time evolution of a fermionic projected entangled pair state ( peps ) with ancillas from infinite temperature down to a finite temperature state is presented . as a benchmark application , it is applied to spinless fermions hopping on a square lattice subject to @xmath0-wave pairing interactions . with a tiny bias it allows to evolve the system across a high - temperature continuous symmetry - breaking phase transition .

1306.1760

all different brane solutions in eleven - dimensional supergravity are the classical solitons of m - theory , so there has been lot of interest and achievement in constructing and classifying the brane solutions of eleven - dimensional supergravity @xcite-@xcite . these solutions generate the p branes and the solitons of string theory that in turn make a way to understand the quantum theory of black holes . the black hole structure can be considered as some wrapped specific p branes around some compact manifoldes . moreover the supergravity brane solutions are the systems that provide evidence for the bulk - boundary holography duality @xcite-@xcite . one other important feature of the solutions is whether they are stable supersymmetric solutions or not . it turns out that in general , orthogonal intersecting system of m2 and m5 branes preserve some number of supersymmetry and are stable systems @xcite . it is also a well known fact that for supersymmetric solutions of supergravity , the metric functions can be obtained in terms of harmonic functions @xcite-@xcite . the harmonic functions are on the transverse space to brane systems and related to the saturated bps bound of the brane systems . as long as the near core region of supersymmetic bps solutions of brane sysytems is of importance in bulk - boundary duality , numerous solutions of orthogonal intersecting m branes have been constructed @xcite-@xcite , @xcite-@xcite . however , to find the brane solutions that are not restricted to the near core region of d4 , d5 or d6 branes , one can lift the corresponding brane to an embedded self - dual ( or anti - self - dual ) space in eleven - dimensional supergravity @xcite . upon dimensional reduction , the m - brane solutions with self - dual ( or anti - self - dual ) transverse space yield systems of p branes that are not restricted to the near core of d4 , d5 or d6 branes . instead the solutions are on near core of lower dimensional branes , such as d2 where its world - volume theory enjoys remarkable properties such as renormalizability . moreover , the lower dimensional brane is always fully localized in the world volume of higher dimensional brane and the system preserves some suspersymmetries . the method works very well for a single m2 or m5 brane , as by assuming an ansatz for the eleven dimensional metric , the supergravity equations of motion reduce to one partial differential equation that can be solved mainly by numerical methods after imposing the proper boundary conditions @xcite-@xcite . in this paper , we consider a system of two intersecting m2 branes and find a class of exact analytic solutions to supergravity equations of motion . the equations of motion consist of two coupled partial differential equations . the equation of motion for the metric function of one membrane depends on the metric function of second membrane in the system . upon dimensional reduction , we get a system of three d branes in type iia supegravity . we explicitly calculate the number of preserved supersymmetries by finding the solutions to the killing spinor equation and show the system of two m2 branes preserves four supersymmetries . the outline of the article is as follows . in section [ sec : supergravitysolutions ] , we briefly discuss the eleven dimensional supergravity equations of motion and the ansatz for the eleven - dimensional metric . in section [ sec : tn ] , we present our exact analytical solutions to the two coupled differential equations for the metric functions of two m2 branes . we find a second set of solutions to the equations of motion by analytically continuing the separation constant that appear in the first exact analytical solutions . in sections [ sec : bianchi ] , we consider the four dimensional triaxial bianchi ix space as a part of the overall transverse space to two membranes . although it is very unlikely to find an analytical solutions to equations of motion , however we find approximate analytical solutions for the membrane metric functions . in section [ sec : supersymmetry ] , we find the explicit solutions to the killing spinor equation for the system of two m2 branes . we show all of the solutions presented in sections [ sec : tn ] and [ sec : bianchi ] preserve four supersymmetries . in section [ sec : summary ] , we wrap up the article by concluding remarks and future possible research directions . the equations of motion for the bosonic fields of @xmath0 supergravity are given by @xcite @xmath1 , \label{gmingg}\\ \nabla_{m}f^{mnpq } & = -\frac{1}{576}\varepsilon^{m_{1}\ldots m_{8 } npq}f_{m_{1}\ldots m_{4}}f_{m_{5}\ldots m_{8 } } , \label{df}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath2}$ ] is the field strength of the three form gauge field @xmath3 . the solutions to equations of motion ( [ gmingg ] ) and ( [ df ] ) may preserve partial supersymmetry if there exists non - trivial killing spinors that satisy the killing spinor equation . the killing spinor equation indicates that the supersymmetric variation of the gavitino field vanishes . we consider a system of two m2 branes in which the branes are located in @xmath4 and @xmath5 with the metric @xcite @xmath6 where @xmath7 and @xmath8 . moreover , we consider the dependence of the metric functions on transverse coordinates as @xmath9 and @xmath10 , so the metric functions @xmath11 and @xmath12 depend on the overall transverse coordinates @xmath13 while @xmath11 depends also on the relative transverse coordinates @xmath14 . this means the first brane is completely localized on transverse directions while the second brane is delocalized along the relative transverse directions . we notice that the delocalization of a brane in a brane configuration is necessary for the decoupling limit of the theory living on the other brane worldvolume @xcite . we also show ( in section [ sec : supersymmetry ] ) the presence of self - dual ( or anti - self dual ) space @xmath15 in transverse space to both m2 branes implies partial preserved supersymmetry for the system . in this regard , in section [ sec : tn ] , we consider the four dimensional self - dual transverse space @xmath15 in ( [ ds11genm2 ] ) as @xmath16 where @xmath17 and @xmath18 . the range of coordinates are , @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 where @xmath22 . in section [ sec : bianchi ] , we consider the system of two m2 branes ( [ ds11genm2 ] ) in background of self - dual triaxial bianchi ix space @xmath23 where the @xmath24 invariant one forms @xmath25 s are [ sigma.b.0 ] @xmath26 and @xmath27 in ( [ fbianchi ] ) , @xmath28 are three arbitrary constants that can be chosen as @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 . the constant @xmath32 is positive and @xmath33 . we notice @xmath34 and coordinate @xmath35 always should be greater than or equal to @xmath36 . moreover , we consider the four - form field strength @xmath37 in terms of metric functions @xmath11 and @xmath12 as @xmath38 dimensional reduction of the metric ( with components @xmath39 ) together with the four - form field strength ( [ 4field ] ) to @xmath40 along one of the compact spatial coordinates in the transverse space ( e.g. @xmath41 ) yields type iia supergravity solutions . the fields of type iia supergravity could be read from the relations @xmath42 , @xmath43 and @xmath44 , where @xmath45 and @xmath46 take values in ten dimensions . the winding number @xmath47 , shows how many times the membrane wraps around the compact dimension @xcite . in the following sections , we set @xmath48 . the type iia rr four - form @xmath49 and nsns three - form field strength @xmath50 are related to ( [ 4field ] ) by @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the radius of circle parameterized by @xmath41 . the metric and the four - form field strength ( [ 4field ] ) satisfy the equations of motion ( [ gmingg ] ) and ( [ df ] ) contingent on functions @xmath11 and @xmath12 satisfy the following set of coupled differential equations @xmath53 @xmath54 the solutions to equation ( [ laph1 ] ) for the first membrane metric function @xmath11 depend on the solutions to equation ( [ laph2 ] ) for the second membrane metric function @xmath12 . we can find the solutions to the first differential equation by separating the coordinates as @xmath55 where @xmath56 is the charge of m2 brane . this separation of variables gives an exact solution for @xmath12 in the near core region of second m2 brane . the equation reduces to two ordinary decoupled differential equations for @xmath57 and @xmath58 that are given by @xmath59 @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the separation constant . the solutions to are given by @xmath62 in terms of modified bessel functions @xmath63 and @xmath64 and @xmath65 , @xmath66 are two constants . to have a finite solution far away from the branes , we have to choose the constant @xmath67 . moreover , the solutions to ( [ odef2c ] ) are given by @xmath68 where @xmath69 stands for the kummer function of type @xmath70 and @xmath71 , @xmath72 are two constants . in what follows in the present section , we show the first and second term of ( [ odef2cs ] ) by @xmath73 and @xmath74 respectively . figure [ fig : figure1 ] shows the behaviour of solution @xmath73 , where the solution vanishes at infinity . the near horizon limit of @xmath74 ( equation ( [ limit2 ] ) ) requires that we choose the constant @xmath75 in ( [ odef2cs ] ) . vanishes far away from the branes . the constants @xmath61 and @xmath76 are set to @xmath77.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] the general solution for the metric function @xmath78 is a superposition of different solutions given by ( [ odef1cs ] ) and ( [ odef2cs ] ) for different values of @xmath61 , @xmath79 where @xmath80 is an arbitrary function of the separation constant @xmath61 . to determine and fix the function @xmath80 , we consider the limits [ limitflat ] @xmath81 in which the transverse space to m2 branes approaches to @xmath82 @xmath83 where @xmath84 . to obtain ( [ sixdimlimits ] ) , we consider @xmath85 and the coordinate @xmath41 is redefined to @xmath86 by @xmath87 . in the limits ( [ limitflat ] ) where the transverse space to m2 branes is flat , the metric function @xmath78 must approach to @xmath88 . the proper choice of @xmath80 in the general solution ( [ mh2cs ] ) leads to the required behaviour of the metric function @xmath78 in the limits ( [ limitflat ] ) . in the limits ( [ limitflat ] ) , the differential equation ( [ odef2c ] ) for @xmath58 can be simplified to @xmath89 the solutions to ( [ odef2capp ] ) are given by @xmath90 in terms of bessel functions where @xmath91 and @xmath92 are two constants . comparing with , one can show @xmath93 hence the metric function in the limits ( [ limitflat ] ) becomes @xmath94 we choose @xmath75 in integrand of ( [ limith1 ] ) since in the limits ( [ limitflat ] ) , the radial function @xmath95 diverges . the solution to integral equation ( [ limith2 ] ) for @xmath80 is given by @xmath96 . so the general solution for the second membrane metric function @xmath78 reads as @xmath97 furnished with the general solution for @xmath78 , we can find the general solution to the second differential equation for the first membrane metric function @xmath98 . the differential equation ( [ laph1 ] ) is separable if we separate the coordinates by @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the charge of first m2 brane . substituting ( [ h1metricfunction ] ) in ( [ laph1 ] ) and using equation ( [ odef1c ] ) for @xmath57 , we get the differential equation for @xmath101 @xmath102 where @xmath103 . the solution to ( [ secondh ] ) is @xmath104 where @xmath105 is the wronskian of @xmath73 and @xmath74 . hence , the general solution for the metric function of first membrane @xmath98 is a superposition of solutions ( [ odef1cs ] ) and ( [ hrps ] ) of the form @xmath106 the weight function @xmath107 in ( [ h1taub ] ) can be determined by comparing the general solution ( [ h1taub ] ) to the well known solution of m2 brane in the limits ( [ limitflat ] ) where the six dimensional flat transverse space to membranes has the line element ( [ sixdimlimits ] ) . in the limits ( [ limitflat ] ) , the source term in the inhomogeneous differential equation ( [ secondh ] ) approaches to @xmath108 so , we find that in the limits ( [ limitflat ] ) , the solution to inhomogeneous equation ( [ secondh ] ) for @xmath101 is given by @xmath109 moreover , a tedious calculation shows that the special solution ( [ zr.2 ] ) also can be obtained directly from the solution ( [ hrps ] ) in appropriate limits ( [ limitflat ] ) . the dependence of first membrane metric function @xmath11 on @xmath35 and @xmath110 in the background of transverse space to m2 branes is given by @xmath111 @xcite . hence , we get @xmath112 as an integral equation for the function @xmath107 . the solution to equation ( [ intforg ] ) is @xmath113 and so we get the general solution for the m2 brane function @xmath98 @xmath114 where @xmath101 is given by ( [ hrps ] ) . in addition to exact membrane solutions ( [ mh2cstaub ] ) and ( [ h1taubf ] ) , we can obtain a new set of solutions for the membrane metric functions by analytically continuing the separation constant @xmath61 that appears in separated differential equations ( [ odef1c ] ) and ( [ odef2c ] ) to @xmath115 . the differential equation changes to @xmath116 where the solutions are given by @xmath117 in terms of bessel functions . the other differential equation takes the form @xmath118 the solutions to ( [ odef2ic ] ) are @xmath119 where @xmath69 and @xmath120 are the kummer functions of type @xmath70 and @xmath121 respectively ( figure [ fig : figure2 ] ) and @xmath122 , @xmath123 are two constants . we show the first and second term of ( [ odef2ics ] ) by @xmath124 and @xmath125 . ( dashed ) and @xmath125 ( solid ) in equation ( [ odef2ics ] ) . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] the only acceptable solution at infinity is @xmath125 and so we may write the general solution for the metric function @xmath126 as @xmath127 to determine the weight function @xmath128 , we consider the limits , in which one can show @xmath129 consequently , we get the integral equation for @xmath128 as @xmath130 we find the solution to integral equation ( [ mh2icsflat ] ) for @xmath131 is given by @xmath132 and so the general solution for the metric function @xmath126 is @xmath133 furnished by the new solution ( [ mh2ics2 ] ) for @xmath126 , we separate the coordinates in the first membrane metric function by @xmath134 to separate the differential equation ( [ laph1 ] ) . plugging ( [ h2tildesep ] ) in ( [ laph1 ] ) and using equation ( [ odef1ics ] ) for @xmath135 , we find the following equation for @xmath136 @xmath137 where @xmath138 . the solution to ( [ secondhh ] ) is @xmath139 where @xmath140 is the wronskian of @xmath141 and @xmath141 . so , we can write the general solution for the metric function @xmath142 as @xmath143 where @xmath144 is given by . to determine and fix the weight function @xmath145 , we compare the solution ( [ h1taubic ] ) to the known solution of membrane function in the limits ( [ limitflat ] ) , where the transverse space to membranes becomes flat . in the limits ( [ limitflat ] ) , the differential equation ( [ secondhh ] ) reduces to @xmath146 we find that the solution to equation ( [ secondhhflat ] ) is given by @xmath147 comparing the equation ( [ h1taubic ] ) in which @xmath136 is given by ( [ hicflat ] ) to the solution of membrane function where the transverse space is flat yields an integral equation for @xmath145 . the solution to the integral equation is given by @xmath148 and so , the metric function for the first m2 brane takes the form @xmath149 dimensional reduction of all two - membrane solutions in this section yields the field content and metric of type iia string theory . the dimensional reduction along the coordinate @xmath41 of ( [ h1h2h ] ) gives the nsns dilaton and the rr one - form by @xmath150 and @xmath151 . the antisymmetric nsns two - form is zero and the only non - zero components of rr three - form are @xmath152 and @xmath153 . the ten - dimensional metric read as @xmath154 , \label{metri}\end{aligned}\ ] ] that describes a system of three d branes . we have explicitly checked the solution ( [ metri ] ) along with the dilaton , rr one - form and rr three form exactly satisfy all the supergravity equations of motion in ten dimensions . for the second set of solutions ( [ mh2ics2 ] ) and ( [ hhtilde ] ) , @xmath155 and @xmath12 should be replaced by @xmath142 and @xmath126 in the ten - dimensional nsns and rr fields and the metric ( [ metri ] ) . in this section , we consider the triaxial bianchi ix space ( [ bix ] ) as a part of transverse space to two m2 branes . requiring that the metric and the four - form field strength ( [ 4field ] ) satisfy the equations of motion ( [ gmingg ] ) , ( [ df ] ) gives the following two coupled differential equations for the metric functions @xmath11 and @xmath12 @xmath156 \right\ } \frac{\partial h_2}{\partial r}+2\sqrt{f(r)}\frac{\partial^2 h_2}{\partial r^2}+2\left [ \frac{\partial^2 h_2}{\partial { \rho}^2}+\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial h_2}{\partial { \rho } } \right]=0 , \nonumber \\ \label{biaeq2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath157 \right\ } \frac{\partial h_1}{\partial r}&+&2\sqrt{f(r)}\frac{\partial^2 h_1}{\partial r^2}+2\left [ \frac{\partial^2 h_1}{\partial { \rho}^2}+\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial h_1}{\partial { \rho } } \right ] \nonumber \\ & = & -2h_2\left [ \frac{\partial^2 h_1}{\partial x_1 ^ 2}+\frac{\partial^2 h_1}{\partial x_2 ^ 2 } \right ] . \label{biaeq1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we choose @xmath158 which means @xmath29 and @xmath159 that we show simply by @xmath160 . the differential equations ( [ biaeq2 ] ) and ( [ biaeq1 ] ) then reduce to @xmath161 to find the solutions to differential equation ( [ pdep.2 ] ) , we separate the coordinates as @xmath162 . we get two separated ordinary differential equations for @xmath163 and @xmath101 that are given by @xmath164 where @xmath61 is the separation constant . the solutions to are @xmath165 where @xmath65 and @xmath66 are two constants . to find the solutions to ( [ pde.2 ] ) , we define the new positive variable @xmath166 by @xmath167 . in terms of variable @xmath166 , the differential equation becomes @xmath168 although it is very unlikely to find any exact analytic solutions to equation ( [ eqcosh ] ) , however we can approximate @xmath169 by @xmath170 to find the approximate analytic solutions . figure [ diffplot ] shows the difference between the actual function and the approximation , @xmath171 , as a function of @xmath172 . the maximum difference @xmath173 occurs at @xmath174 . and @xmath175 as function of @xmath172.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] the analytic solutions to equation ( [ eqcosh ] ) are given by @xmath176 in terms of modified bessel functions where @xmath177 and @xmath178 are constants . figure [ fig : figure16 ] shows the typical behaviour of solutions ( [ twos ] ) in terms of @xmath172 where @xmath179 and @xmath180 are the first and second terms in ( [ twos ] ) respectively . we may write the general solution for the metric function @xmath12 as a superposition of the different solutions for @xmath163 and @xmath181 with different values of @xmath61 and @xmath180 solutions in ( [ twos ] ) as function of @xmath172 where we set @xmath182 . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] @xmath183 where we choose the constants @xmath184 in ( [ gofrho ] ) and ( [ twos ] ) and @xmath185 is the weight function . the weight function can be fixed by comparing the equation ( [ mh2csbix ] ) in the limit @xmath186 , where the transverse space to membranes is flat , to the metric function @xmath187 in the asymptotic flat region . in the asymptotic flat limit , one can set @xmath188 and so @xmath189 . hence the solutions ( [ twos ] ) reduce to @xmath190 and so the metric function @xmath12 ( [ mh2csbix ] ) in asymptotic region must satisfy @xmath191 the solution to integral equation ( [ inteqforh2 ] ) is @xmath192 and so we get the general form of the metric function @xmath12 @xmath193 quite interestingly , the integral in ( [ h2tsol ] ) can be done analytically and we get @xmath194 figure [ fig : figure43 ] shows how @xmath12 varies versus @xmath110 and @xmath35 where we set @xmath195 . ( [ h2tsol ] ) versus @xmath196 and @xmath197 , where we set @xmath195.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] to find the solutions to for @xmath98 , we consider @xmath198 where @xmath163 satisfies . upon substituting ( [ h1sep ] ) in equation ( [ pdep.1 ] ) , we find the differential equation for @xmath199 that is given by @xmath200 or in terms of new positive variable @xmath166 as @xmath201 to find the approximate analytic solutions to equation ( [ odettc ] ) , we approximate @xmath202 by @xmath170 in equation which yields @xmath203 the solution to ( [ odettcs ] ) is given by @xmath204 and so , the general approximate analytical solution for the metric function @xmath11 is @xmath205 in ( [ h1tsol1 ] ) , the weight function @xmath206 must be chosen such that in asymptotic flat region , the solution ( [ h1tsol1 ] ) approaches to @xmath207 . one can find the appropriate solution for @xmath206 is @xmath208 and finally we find @xmath209 although it seems we may obtain a second set of solutions for the metric functions by analytically continuing the separation constant @xmath61 to @xmath115 , however the calculation shows that the second set of solutions are exactly the same as the solutions ( [ h2tsol ] ) and ( [ h1sol ] ) . the number of preserved supersymmetry for any solution of supergravity in eleven dimensions is determined by the number of solutions to the killing spinor equation . the killing spinor equation is given by @xcite @xmath210 where @xmath211 s and @xmath212 s are the dirac matrices in eleven dimensions and the spin connection coefficients , respectively . the capital indices @xmath213 denote the eleven dimensional world coordinates and @xmath214 denote the tangent space coordinates in eleven dimensions . using ( [ killingspinor ] ) for the solution ( [ ds11genm2 ] ) with the transverse space ( [ h1h2h ] ) or ( [ bix ] ) and the four - form field strength ( [ 4field ] ) , one finds @xmath215 that means at most one - fourth of the supersymmetry can be preserved due to the presence of two m2 branes . moreover from the first and second terms of ( [ killingspinor ] ) for the solution ( [ ds11genm2 ] ) with the transverse space ( [ h1h2h ] ) , we get the following equations @xmath216 \varepsilon = 0 , & & \label{speq2 } \\ \partial_{\theta}\varepsilon+\left [ \left ( \frac{n}{4(r+n)}-\frac{1}{2 } \right ) \gamma^{{r}{\theta } } -\frac{n}{4(r+n ) } \gamma^{{\phi}{\psi } } \right ] \varepsilon = 0 , & & \label{speq3 } \\ \partial_{\phi}\varepsilon+ \bigg [ \sin ( \theta ) \left(\frac{n } { 4(n+r ) } -\frac{1}{2}\right)\gamma^{{r}{\phi } } + \cos ( \theta ) \left(\frac{n^2 } { 4(n+r)^2 } -\frac{1}{2}\right)\gamma^{{\theta}{\phi } } + & & \nonumber \\ + \frac{n \sin ( \theta ) } { 4(n+r ) } \gamma^{{\theta}{\psi } } -\cos ( \theta ) \left(\frac{n^2 } { 4(n+r)^2}\right)\gamma^{{r}{\psi } } \bigg ] \varepsilon = 0 . & & \nonumber \\ \label{speq4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we note that in equations ( [ speq1])-([speq4 ] ) , only the subscript of derivative operator is a world coordinate . for notational simplification , we use the same letters for both world and tangent coordinates . the solution to equations , and is @xmath217 \exp \left[{\frac{\theta}{2}\gamma^{{\phi}{\psi}}}\right ] \exp \left[{\frac{\phi}{2}\gamma^{{\theta}{\phi}}}\right]\tilde{\varepsilon } , \label{spsol}\ ] ] where @xmath218 is independent of @xmath219 and @xmath220 . substituting ( [ spsol ] ) in ( [ speq2 ] ) yields an equation for @xmath218 that implies @xmath221 if @xmath218 is independent of coordinate @xmath41 , too . the projection operator in ( [ project3 ] ) eliminates another half of the supersymmetry . so , only one - eighth of supersymetry is preserved for the system of two m2 branes , given by fields ( [ ds11genm2 ] ) , ( [ h1h2h ] ) and ( [ 4field ] ) . a similar calculation shows the system of two m2 branes with transverse space ( [ bix ] ) leads to three projection equations ( [ proj012 ] ) , ( [ proj034 ] ) and ( [ project3 ] ) . hence the number of preserved sypersymmetries is the same as the system of two m2 branes with the transverse space ( [ h1h2h ] ) . moreover , we notice the dimensional reduction to ten dimensions does not change the number of preserved supersymmetries . this is in agreement with the fact that the ten - dimensional metric ( [ metri ] ) describes a system of three d branes and preserves four supersmmetries . by embedding self - dual curvature geometries in @xmath0 supergavity , we find new class of systems with two m2 branes . to d=11 supergravity . the first set of solutions is exact and the analytical metric functions for two membranes are presented in equations ( [ mh2cstaub ] ) , ( [ h1taubf ] ) along with the four - form field strength ( [ 4field ] ) . the second set of solutions is approximate where the two membrane metric functions are given by ( [ h2tsol ] ) , ( [ h1sol ] ) . the four - form field strength again is given by ( [ 4field ] ) . moreover the analytical continuation of separation constant in the first set of solutions gives a new set of solutions that the membrane metric function are given by ( [ mh2ics2 ] ) and ( [ hhtilde ] ) . for all of these solutions the brane functions are convolution of a decaying function with a damped oscillating function . the weight function for all solutions can be found by comparing the convolution integral to the membrane metric function in appropriate limits in which the overall transverse space to membrane becomes flat . dimensional reduction of these supergravity solutions to 10 dimensions provides realization of system of three d branes in type iia string theory . we explicitly solve the killing spinor equation and show all the supergravity configurations preserve 1/8 of the supersymmetry in agreement with the system of three d branes after dimensional reduction . it would be interesting to construct new solutions for the system of two m2 branes on other types of bianchi space @xcite as the overall transverse space .

we present an exact analytic class of solutions for a system of two membranes in eleven - dimensional supergravity . one brane in the system is completely localized along the overall and relative transverse coordinates while the other brane in the system is localized only along the overall transverse coordinates . the membrane configuration preserves four supersymmetries . moreover we find some approximate solutions for the system of two membranes with a bianchi space as the overall transverse space to both membranes . all supergravity solutions preserve 1/8 of the supersymmetry . upon dimensional reduction , the solutions provide intersecting configurations of three d - branes in type iia supergravity . * supergravity solutions of two m2 branes * + a. m. ghezelbash , r. oraji + department of physics and engineering physics , + university of saskatchewan , saskatoon , saskatchewan s7n 5e2 , canada +

astro-ph0508051

sato et al . ( 2005 ) recently presented the discovery of a planetary companion to the bright g0 iv star hd 149026 . the star exhibits a time - variable doppler shift that is consistent with a sinusoid of amplitude @xmath8 m s@xmath9 and period @xmath10 days , which would be produced by the gravitational force from an orbiting planet with @xmath11 @xmath12 . furthermore , at the predicted time of planet - star conjunction , the star s flux declines by 0.3% in the manner expected of an eclipse by a planet of radius @xmath13 @xmath14 ( given an estimate of the stellar radius , 1.45 @xmath15 , that is based on the stellar parallax and effective temperature ) . sato et al . ( 2005 ) observed three such eclipses . this discovery is extraordinary for at least two reasons . firstly , the occurrence of eclipses admits this system into the elite club of bright stars with detectable planetary transits . of all the previously - known transiting systems , only hd 209458 ( charbonneau et al . 2000 ; henry et al . 2000 ) and tres-1 ( alonso et al . 2004 ; sozzetti et al . 2005 ) have parent stars brighter than @xmath16 , and therefore only they are amenable to a number of fascinating measurements requiring a very high signal - to - noise ratio . among these studies are ( i ) the search for satellites and rings ( brown et al . 2001 ) , ( ii ) the search for period variations due to additional companions ( wittenmyer et al . 2005 ) , ( iii ) the detection of ( or upper limits on ) atmospheric absorption features in transmission ( charbonneau et al . 2002 ; brown , libbrecht , & charbonneau 2002 ; deming et al . 2005a ) , ( iv ) the characterization of the exosphere ( bundy & marcy 2000 ; moutou et al . 2001 , 2003 ; vidal - madjar et al . 2003 , 2004 ; winn et al . 2004 ; narita et al . 2005 ) , ( v ) the measurement of the angle between the sky - projected orbit normal and stellar rotation axis ( queloz et al . 2000 ; winn et al . 2005 ) , and ( vi ) the search for spectroscopic features near the times of secondary eclipse ( richardson et al . 2003a , 2003b ) , and ( vii ) the direct detection of thermal emission from the planet ( charbonneau et al . 2005 ; deming et al . charbonneau ( 2004 ) reviews these techniques and related investigations . secondly , the planet is the smallest and least massive of the 8 known transiting extrasolar planets . this makes hd 149026b an important test case for theories of planetary structure . sato et al.(2005 ) argued that , once the effects of stellar insolation are included , the small planetary radius implies that the planet has a large and dense core . in particular , assuming a core density @xmath17 , their models predict a prodigious core mass of 78 earth masses , or 74% of the total mass of the planet . this , in turn , would seemingly prove that the planet formed through core accretion , as opposed to direct collapse through a gravitational instability . a system of such importance should be independently confirmed , and the determination of its basic parameters should be refined through multiple observations . with this as motivation , we performed photometry of hd 149026 on two different nights when transits were predicted by sato et al . these observations and the data reduction procedures are described in 2 . the model that we used to determine the system parameters is described in 3 , and the results are discussed in 4 . our data are available in digital form in the electronic version of this article , and from the authors upon request . we observed hd 149026 ( @xmath18 , @xmath19 ) on ut 2005 june 6 and ut 2005 july 2 with the 48-inch ( 1.2 m ) telescope of the f. l. whipple observatory ( flwo ) located at mount hopkins , arizona . we used minicam , an optical ccd imager with two @xmath20 chips . in order to increase the duty cycle of the observations , we employed @xmath21 binning , which reduced the readout and overhead time to 20 s. each binned pixel subtends approximately @xmath22 on the sky , giving an effective field of view of about @xmath23 for each ccd . fortunately , there exists a nearby object of similar brightness and color ( hd 149083 ; @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath26 @xmath27 , @xmath28 ) , which we employed as an extinction calibrator . we selected the telescope pointing so that both stars were imaged simultaneously . we defocused the telescope so that the full - width at half - maximum ( fwhm ) of a stellar image was typically 15 binned pixels ( 9@xmath29 ) , and we used automatic guiding to ensure that the centroid of the stellar images drifted no more than 3 binned pixels over the course of the night . in addition to enabling longer integration times , this served to mitigate the effects of pixel - to - pixel sensitivity variations that were not perfectly corrected by our flat - fielding procedure . on ut 2005 june 6 , we gathered 5.5 hrs of sdss @xmath0-band observations with typical integration times of 8 s and a cadence of 28 s. the conditions were photometric , and the frames span an airmass from 1.01 to 1.74 . on ut 2005 july 2 , we gathered 4.4 hrs of sdss @xmath2-band observations with integration times of 6 s and a median cadence of 26 s. the field appeared to remain free of clouds for the duration of the observations , which spanned an airmass range of 1.01 to 1.43 , although occasional patches of high cirrus could be seen in images from the mmt all - sky camera . we converted the image time stamps to heliocentric julian day ( hjd ) at mid - exposure . the images were overscan - subtracted , trimmed , and divided by a flat - field image . we performed aperture photometry of hd 149026 and the comparison star hd 149083 , using an aperture radius of 15 binned pixels ( 9@xmath29 ) for the ut 2005 june 6 data , and an aperture radius of 20 binned pixels ( 12@xmath29 ) for the ut 2005 july 2 data . we subtracted the underlying contribution from the sky for both the target and calibrator by estimating the counts in an annulus exterior to the photometric aperture . the relative flux of hd 149026 was computed as the ratio of the fluxes within the two apertures . normalization and residual extinction corrections are described in 3 . tophat is an automated telescope located on mt . hopkins , arizona , which was designed to perform multi - color photometric follow - up of transiting extrasolar planet candidates identified by the hat network ( bakos et al . since tophat has not previously been described in the literature , we digress briefly to outline the principal goals and features of the instrument . wide - field transit surveys must contend with a large rate of astrophysical false positives , which result from stellar systems that contain an eclipsing binary and precisely mimic the single - color photometric light curve of a jupiter - sized planet transiting a sun - like star ( brown 2003 ; charbonneau et al . 2004 ; mandushev et al . 2005 ; torres et al . although multi - epoch radial velocity follow - up is an effective tool for identifying these false positives ( e.g. latham 2003 ) , instruments such as tophat and sherlock ( kotredes et al . 2004 ) can be fully - automated , and thus offer a very efficient means of culling the bulk of such false positives . tophat is a 0.26 m diameter f/5 commercially - available baker ritchey - chrtien telescope on an equatorial fork mount developed by fornax inc . a 1@xmath3025-square field of view is imaged onto a 2k@xmath312k peltier - cooled , thinned ccd detector , yielding a pixel scale of 2@xmath322 . the time for image readout and associated overheads is 25 s. well - focused images have a typical fwhm of 2 pixels . a two - slot filter - exchanger permits imaging in either @xmath1 or @xmath33 . the components are protected from inclement weather by an automated asymmetric clamshell dome . we observed hd 149026 on ut 2005 july 2 , the same night as the flwo 1.2 m @xmath2 observations described above . in order to extend the integration times and increase the duty cycle of the observations , we broadened the point spread function ( psf ) by performing small , regular motions in ra and dec according to a prescribed pattern that was repeated during each 13 s integration ( see bakos et al . 2004 for details ) . the resulting psf had a fwhm of 3.5 pixels ( 7@xmath327 ) . we gathered 4.8 hrs of @xmath1 observations with a cadence of 68 s , spanning an airmass range of 1.01 to 1.45 . we converted the time stamps in the image headers to hjd at mid - exposure . we calibrated the images by subtracting the overscan bias and a scaled dark image , and dividing by an average sky flat from which large outliers had been rejected . we evaluated the centroids of the target and the three brightest calibrators in each image . for each star , we summed the flux within an aperture with a radius of 8 pixels ( 17@xmath326 ) , and subtracted a local sky estimate based on the median flux in an annulus exterior to the photometric aperture . we divided the resulting time series for the target by the statistically - weighted average of the time series for the three calibrator stars . the resulting relative flux time series was then corrected for normalization and residual extinction effects as described in the following section . we attempted to fit simultaneously ( i ) the 3 photometric time series discussed above , ( ii ) the @xmath34 photometry of 3 transits presented by sato et al . ( 2005 ) , and ( iii ) the 7 radial velocities that were measured by sato et al . ( 2005 ) when the planet was not transiting . we did not attempt to fit the 4 radial velocities measured during transits , which would have required a model of the rossiter - mclaughlin effect ( queloz et al.2002 ; ohta , taruya , & suto 2004 ; winn et al . 2005 ) . we modeled the system as a circular keplerian orbit . following sato et al . ( 2005 ) , we assumed the stellar mass ( @xmath35 ) to be @xmath36 and the stellar radius ( @xmath37 ) to be @xmath38 . the free parameters were the planetary mass ( @xmath39 ) , planetary radius ( @xmath40 ) , orbital inclination ( @xmath41 ) , orbital period ( @xmath42 ) , central transit time ( @xmath43 ) , and the heliocentric radial velocity of the center of mass ( @xmath44 ) . we included 2 free parameters for each of our 3 photometric time series : an overall flux scaling @xmath45 ; and a residual extinction coefficient ( @xmath46 ) to correct for differential extinction between the target star and the comparison object , which have somewhat different colors . these are defined such that the relative flux observed through an airmass @xmath47 is @xmath48 times the true relative flux . the residual extinction corrections were small but important at the millimagnitude level ; for example , in the @xmath0 band , we found @xmath49 . the 3 time series presented by sato et al . ( 2005 ) were already corrected for airmass , so we allowed each of these to have only an independent flux scaling . finally , we allowed the data from each spectrograph ( keck / hires and subaru / hds ) to have an independent value of @xmath44 . we computed the model radial velocity at each observed time as @xmath50 , where @xmath51 is the line - of - sight projection of the orbital velocity of the star . we calculated the model flux during transit using the linear limb - darkening law @xmath52 , where @xmath53 is the normalized stellar surface brightness profile and @xmath54 is the cosine of the angle between the normal to the stellar surface and the line of sight . we employed the `` small planet '' approximation as described by mandel & agol ( 2002 ) . we held the limb darkening parameter @xmath55 fixed at a value appropriate for a star with the assumed properties , and for the bandpass concerned , according to the models of claret & hauschildt ( 2003 ) and claret ( 2004 ) . these values were @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 . the goodness - of - fit parameter is @xmath60 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 are the observed and calculated radial velocities , of which there are @xmath63 , and @xmath64 and @xmath65 are the observed and calculated fluxes , of which there are @xmath66 . of the flux measurements , 679 are our @xmath0-band measurements , 574 are our @xmath2-band measurements , 237 are our @xmath1-band measurements , and 820 are the @xmath67/2 measurements of sato et al . we minimized @xmath68 using an amoeba algorithm ( press et al . 1992 ) . the radial velocity uncertainties @xmath69 were taken from table 2 of sato et al . ( 2005 ) . to estimate the uncertainties in our photometry , we performed the following procedure . we expect the two dominant sources of uncertainty to be scintillation noise ( @xmath70 ) and poisson noise ( @xmath71 ) . young ( 1967 ) advocated an approximate scaling law for the fractional error due to scintillation noise ( see also dravins et al . 1998 ) : @xmath72 where @xmath47 is the airmass , @xmath73 is the diameter of the aperture , @xmath74 is the exposure time , and @xmath75 is the altitude of the observatory . for each of our 3 time series , we assumed that the noise in each point obeyed @xmath76 where @xmath70 was calculated with eq . [ eq : scintillation ] . we determined the constant @xmath77 by requiring @xmath78 for that particular time series . thus we did _ not _ attempt to use the @xmath68 statistic to test the validity of the model ; rather , we assumed the model is correct , and sought the appropriate weight for each data point . the results for @xmath77 ranged from 1.2 to 1.5 . to estimate the uncertainties in each of the three sato et al . ( 2005 ) time series ( which were already corrected for airmass ) , we simply assigned an airmass - independent error bar to all the points such that @xmath78 . the results agreed well with the rms values quoted in table 5 of sato et al . ( 2005 ) . after assigning the weight of each data point in this manner , we analyzed all the data simultaneously and found the best - fitting solution . this solution is overplotted on the data in figure 1 . our photometry , after correcting for the overall flux scale and for airmass , is given in table 1 . we estimated the uncertainties in the model parameters using a monte carlo algorithm , in which the optimization was performed on each of @xmath79 synthetic data sets , and the distribution of best - fitting values was taken to be the joint probability distribution of the parameters . each synthetic data set was created as follows : 1 . we randomly drew @xmath66 flux measurements @xmath80 from the real data set . we drew these points with replacement , i.e. , we allowed for repetitions of the original data points . this procedure , recommended by press et al . ( 1992 ) , estimates the probability distribution of the measurements using the measured data values themselves , rather than the more traditional approach of assuming a certain model for the underlying process . this procedure was impractical for the radial velocity measurements , because the number of data points is too small . instead , in each realization , we discarded a single radial velocity measurement chosen at random . this was intended as a test of the robustness of the results to single outliers . to each of the remaining @xmath81 radial velocities , we added a random number drawn from a gaussian distribution , with zero mean and a standard deviation equal to the quoted 1 @xmath82 uncertainty . 3 . to account for the uncertainty in the stellar properties , we assigned a stellar mass by picking a random number from a gaussian distribution with mean @xmath36 and standard deviation @xmath83 . likewise , for the stellar radius , we used a gaussian distribution with a mean of @xmath38 and a standard deviation of @xmath84 . we note that this procedure does not take into account the intrinsic correlation between these two variables that is expected from models of stellar structure and evolution . assuming a stellar mass - radius relation would provide an independent constraint that would reduce the overall uncertainty on the planetary radius ( cody & sasselov 2002 ) . we elected not to make such an assumption because the stellar age , and therefore its evolutionary state , are not known with sufficient precision . the best - fitting model is illustrated in fig . 1 . the estimated probability distribution for each model parameter is shown in fig . 2 . some of the parameters have correlated uncertainties , as shown in fig . in addition to showing correlations among the model parameters , fig . 3 shows the distributions for three fundamental properties of a single - transit light curve : the transit depth in the absence of stellar limb - darkening , defined as @xmath85 ; the transit duration , defined as the time between first and fourth contact ( @xmath86 ) ; and the ingress duration , defined as the time between first and second contact ( @xmath87 ) . since we have assumed a circular keplerian orbit , the ingress and egress durations are equal . the contact times can be calculated from our model parameters via the relations @xmath88 where @xmath89 is the semi - major axis , given by kepler s law @xmath90 . we found that the probability distributions did not depend significantly on which of the 7 radial velocity measurements were discarded , with the important exception of the third subaru / hds measurement ( @xmath91 m s@xmath9 at hjd 2453208.909939 ) . when this point was dropped , the results for the orbital period , planetary mass , and velocity offsets changed by 1 @xmath82 . in fig . 2 , the solid histograms show the results of the @xmath92 trials for which @xmath93 was discarded , and the dotted histograms show the results of all @xmath79 trials . we believe that either the model fails to accurately describe @xmath93 within its quoted uncertainty ( due to a missing ingredient such as a nonzero eccentricity within the quoted uncertainty . in the best - fitting model , @xmath94 and @xmath95 . ] or an additional planetary companion ) , or that the true uncertainty in this measurement is larger than the estimate ( due to stellar jitter or some other source of systematic error ) . in support of this claim , we note that this single point makes a disproportionate contribution to @xmath96 . when any single radial velocity measurement besides @xmath93 is dropped , the minimum @xmath96 ranges from 13 to 19 . yet when @xmath93 is dropped , @xmath97 . in table 2 , we present the results for the cases in which @xmath93 is dropped . our intention is to avoid biased results from an oversimplified model or an underestimated uncertainty . the one - dimensional probability distribution for @xmath41 shows that the majority of solutions favor @xmath98 , but a peak is evident at @xmath99 ( see the lower left panel of fig . 2 ) . we identify these maximum-@xmath41 solutions by applying an arbitrary cut - off of @xmath100 , and we display these solutions with a distinct coloring in fig . 3 . these solutions , which account for 9% of the total , represent a pile - up at equatorial configurations owing to the numerical constraint @xmath101 . we exclude this solution subset prior to determining the best - fit values and confidence limits listed in table 2 . we note that the duration of ingress and egress is significantly shorter for hd 149026 than for either hd 209458 or tres-1 . the available photometry samples the times of ingress and egress only sparsely . we encourage high - cadence monitoring of these key portions of the transit curve . tabulation of the observed time of each eclipse is of interest because deviations from the predictions of a single - period ephemeris could indicate the presence of planetary satellites or additional planetary companions ( brown et al . 2001 , miralda - escud 2002 ) . in particular , terrestrial planets that induce a radial - velocity perturbation below current detection limits can nonetheless be detected through accurate eclipse timing ( holman & murray 2005 , agol et al . we searched for evidence of timing anomalies as follows . we constructed a model transit light curve for each of the 4 bandpasses [ @xmath0 , @xmath2 , @xmath1 , and @xmath34 ] , based on the optimal parameters appearing in table 2 and the appropriate limb darkening coefficient ( 3 ) . for each of the 6 extinction - corrected , normalized light curves ( identified by an index @xmath104 ) , we then evaluated the @xmath68 of the fit as a function of assumed time of center of eclipse , @xmath105 . after we identified the optimal value for @xmath105 , we assigned uncertainties by identifying the timing offsets at which the value of @xmath68 had increased by 1 . we list these values in table 3 , and plot the `` observed minus calculated '' ( @xmath106 ) residuals in figure 4 . the typical timing precision is 2 minutes , which is comparable to results from other ground - based photometry ( for a tabulation of @xmath106 for other transiting - planet systems , see charbonneau et al . 2005 for tres-1 , and wittenmyer et al . 2005 for hd 209458 ) . we find no evidence for deviations from the predictions of a constant orbital period . we encourage future monitoring of the times of eclipse of this system . in particular , space - based observations ( brown et al . 2001 ) should achieve a substantial improvement in timing precision , and thus permit a more sensitive search for perturbing planets . due to its favorable apparent brightness , the hd 149026 system will be particularly amenable to a variety of follow - up studies . such pursuits will be more observationally challenging than was the case for hd 209458 , owing to the smaller size of the planet relative to the parent star . nonetheless , we are certain that such challenges will be met and overcome . now that a handful of transiting planets of bright stars have been identified , the long - sought - after goal of comparative exoplanetology may be realized . we are very grateful to b. sato , d. fischer , g.laughlin , and the other members of the n2k consortium , for sharing their results in advance of publication . we thank t. spahr , r. kirshner , and m. hicken for swapping telescope nights on short notice , and h. knutson for assistance with the remote observations . some of the minicam observations on the flwo 48-inch telescope were obtained and reduced with support from the kepler mission to sao and psi . the tophat observations were supported by nasa grant nng04gn74 g . work by j.n.w . was supported by nasa through grant hst - hf-01180.02-a , and work by g.b . was supported by nasa through grant hst - hf-01170.01-a , awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc . , for nasa , under contract nas 5 - 26555 . flwo48 & g & @xmath107 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 + flwo48 & g & @xmath110 & @xmath111 & @xmath109 + flwo48 & g & @xmath112 & @xmath113 & @xmath109 + flwo48 & g & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & @xmath109 + flwo48 & g & @xmath116 & @xmath117 & @xmath109 @xmath35 [ @xmath118 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 & @xmath121 + @xmath37 [ @xmath15 ] & @xmath123 & @xmath120 & @xmath121 + @xmath39 [ @xmath12 ] & @xmath125 & @xmath126 & @xmath127 + @xmath40 [ @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 & @xmath131 + @xmath42 [ days ] & @xmath132 & @xmath133 & @xmath134 + @xmath135 [ hjd ] & @xmath136 & @xmath137 & @xmath138 + @xmath41 [ deg ] & @xmath139 & @xmath140 & @xmath141 + @xmath142 [ m s@xmath9 ] & @xmath144 & @xmath145 & @xmath146 + @xmath147 [ m s@xmath9 ] & @xmath148 & @xmath149 & @xmath150 llllll sato et al . ( 2005 ) & 2453504.8689 & @xmath1518.0 & 0.0019 & @xmath1520.0022 & @xmath1521.15 + sato et al . ( 2005 ) & 2453527.8727 & @xmath1530.0 & 0.0017 & @xmath1510.0018 & @xmath1511.09 + this work [ flwo48 @xmath0 ] & 2453527.8728 & @xmath1530.0 & 0.0012 & @xmath1510.0018 & @xmath1511.41 + sato et al . ( 2005 ) & 2453530.7503 & @xmath1521.0 & 0.0012 & @xmath1510.0002 & @xmath1510.17 + this work [ flwo48 @xmath2 ] & 2453553.7587 & @xmath1529.0 & 0.0010 & @xmath1520.0003 & @xmath1520.32 + this work [ tophat @xmath1 ] & 2453553.7597 & @xmath1529.0 & 0.0023 & @xmath1520.0012 & @xmath1520.51

we report @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 photometric time series of hd 149026 spanning predicted times of transit of the saturn - mass planetary companion , which was recently discovered by sato and collaborators . we present a joint analysis of our observations and the previously reported photometry and radial velocities of the central star . we refine the estimate of the transit ephemeris to @xmath3 = ( 2453527.87455^{+0.00085}_{-0.00091 } ) + ( 2.87598^{+0.00012}_{-0.00017 } ) \ n$ ] . assuming that the star has a radius of @xmath4 and a mass of @xmath5 , we estimate the planet radius to be @xmath6 , which implies a mean density of @xmath7 . this density is significantly greater than that predicted for models which include the effects of stellar insolation and for which the planet has only a small core of solid material . thus we confirm that this planet likely contains a large core , and that the ratio of core mass to total planet mass is more akin to that of uranus and neptune than that of either jupiter or saturn .

0812.1128

statistical mechanics of random networks gained recently many applications in interdisciplinary sciences . the list of references is already very rich ; in almost each year new monographies appear @xcite . in theory , the promising challenge is to investigate collective phenomena in networks @xcite . more than often it is useful to decorate nodes @xmath7 with additional variables , as ising spins @xmath8 . properties of such networks are of interest for theory of computations , as inference problems , but also for the theory of disordered magnetic systems . here we are interested in the spin - glass phase of the small - world random networks . + for trees , where closed loops are absent , there is a consistent theory of ising magnetism , i.e. the bethe theory @xcite . once the loops appear in the system , the bethe theory becomes an approximation . in our system , small loops are introduced when we enhance the clustering coefficient @xcite . still , the results of the bethe theory are useful as a point of reference . as it was demonstrated in @xcite , the accordance of the numerical results with this theory was deteriorated when @xmath0 increases . on the other hand , there is at least one periodic two - dimensional ising lattice when all bonds are antiferromagnetic , the density of frustration is high and the transition temperature is positive ; this is one of the archimedean lattices @xcite . the ground state of this system is highly frustrated , but at least some of the energy barriers between different states remain finite . although at zero field the net magnetization is zero , there is no disorder in the system ; therefore it is hard to speak about the spin - glass phase . then , the @xmath9 ) archimedean lattice can be compared to our system in the case where @xmath0 is maximal . + recently we investigated the transition from the paramagnetic to the spin - glass phase in the random erds - rnyi network with enhanced clustering coefficient @xmath0 @xcite . the enhancement is introduced by adding new links between neighbours of the same sites @xcite . in this way , @xmath0 varied from almost zero to about 0.3 . the main result was the transition temperature @xmath10 dependence on the clustering coefficient @xmath0 . however , in the numerical plots the transition was partially hidden by the contribution of spins which could flip with zero energy cost . that is why here we investigate the same transition in the regular random network , where the degree of each node is an odd number - here it is equal to three . in such systems no spin can flip at zero energy cost in zero external magnetic field . + in the next section we show the method and the numerical results . in section iii the transition temperature @xmath2 is compared with the predictions of the bethe theory . short discussion closes the text . initial form of the constructed network is prepared as an even number @xmath11 of unlinked nodes . the system is divided into two equal parts . three dangling links are assigned to each node . then , the links of one part of nodes are randomly joint to links of the second part . in this way , initially the system is bipartite , with the clustering coefficient @xmath0 equal to zero provided that the number of nodes is large enough . next step is performed for each node with the probability @xmath12 : the node is substituted by a group of three nodes , mutually linked . after this substitution , three previous neighbours of the node are linked to the nodes of the group . in this way , the degree of each node remains exactly three . as the ising interaction is exclusively antiferromagnetic , the frustration is purely geometrical . when @xmath3 , there is no frustration . the density of frustrated bonds increases with @xmath0 . if @xmath13 , the clustering is maximal and for each node , two out of its three neigbours are linked to each other ; then @xmath14 . the final number of nodes is @xmath15 ; for each @xmath12 the amount @xmath11 is chosen as to get approximately the same @xmath16 . + the heat - bath monte carlo algorithm is applied to investigate the magnetic properties : the susceptibility @xmath17 , the specific heat @xmath18 and the edwards - anderson order parameter @xmath1 . @xmath17 can be calculated from the field derivative of the magnetization @xmath19 or from the variance of the spectrum of @xmath20 . similarly @xmath18 can be obtained from the temperature derivative of energy or from the variance of the energy fluctuations . the parameter @xmath1 is calculated from the formula @xcite @xmath21 ^ 2\ ] ] the antiferromagnetic exchange integral @xmath22 is set to -1 . as a rule , the calculations are performed for @xmath16 equal at least @xmath23 spins . the time of calculation - after a necessary transient - was usually @xmath24 steps , where one step is equivalent to probing @xmath16 spins in random order . the results are limited to temperature @xmath25 , where the transient time for relaxation of energy was smaller than @xmath26 timesteps . + in fig . 1 we show the magnetic susceptibilities @xmath27 for different values of the clustering coefficient @xmath0 . the temperature is expressed in energy units @xmath28 . the finite size effect is checked for @xmath3 and @xmath29 ; the differences between @xmath30 and @xmath31 are invisible . as a rule , the plots obtained from the field derivative of the magnetization coincide with those from the variance of the magnetization at zero field above the transition temperature . below @xmath2 , the curves split for intermediate values of @xmath0 ( between 0.1 and 0.29 ) . the plots for the magnetic specific heat obtained from the variance of energy ( figs . 2 and 3 ) and from its thermal derivative coincide in most cases , even below @xmath2 and for intermediate values of @xmath0 . however , the data from the maxima of the specific heat are known to provide an evaluation of the upper limit of the transition temperature @xmath2 rather than @xmath2 itself . the results on @xmath2 obtained by different methods are compared in fig . as we see , there is a systematic split between @xmath2 obtained from @xmath32 and @xmath2 obtained from @xmath18 , but the character of the curve @xmath33 is preserved . in fig . 4 we show the data on @xmath2 obtained from the thermal dependence of the edwards - anderson order parameter @xmath1 . these data also show a decrease of @xmath2 with @xmath0 . however , this decrease persists till @xmath34 , where our numerical results are less reliable . + for @xmath3 the network is bipartite . although the interaction is antiferromagnetic , the system is equivalent to a ferromagnet . to see this , we have to flip spins at half of nodes and to invert simultaneously the sign of all exchange integrals @xmath22 from -1 to + 1 . the formula for the curie temperature ( @xmath35 ) for the regular bethe lattice with the coordination number @xmath36 is @xcite for @xmath39 the system contains loops and it is no more equivalent to a ferromagnet . on the other hand , the network is no more a regular bethe lattice . the number of second neighbours decreases gradually with @xmath12 from 6 when @xmath40 to 4 when @xmath13 . the latter case is , however , in some sense more regular than the one with smaller @xmath12 , because all nodes have again the same number of the second neighbours . then the nel temperature ( @xmath38 ) between the paramagnetic and the antiferromagnetic phase is to be found from where @xmath43 is the average branching parameter , i.e. @xmath44 , where @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) is the average number of first ( second ) neighbours @xcite . + although the data from the specific heat fit better to the bethe theory , it is known that the position of the maximum of @xmath18 is rather the upper bound of the transition temperature than this temperature itself . + the numerical results indicate , that for @xmath3 the low - temperature phase is antiferromagnetic . they also suggest that for @xmath47 and @xmath48 the system becomes a spin glass . however , the identity of this phase remains not clear . for @xmath14 the system can be compared to the @xmath49 archimedean lattice @xcite with random rewiring . we can expect that the ground state is degenerated in the same way as in this archimedean lattice . however , the condition is that the rewiring does not destroy the small triangles introduced when @xmath0 is enhanced . in this way the frustration is not altered by rewiring : the frustration remains local . then , there is frustration and disorder , but the disorder does not influence the frustration . on the other hand , the energy barriers between the local energy minima remain finite , because the system can move from one minimum to another by flipping a finite amount of spins . although the system behaves as a spin glass , some ingredients of this mysterious phase are missing . + to summarize , our intention was to compare the numerical results on the transition temperature @xmath2 with the results of the bethe approximation . in ref . @xcite , distinct departures have been found between the bethe theory and the numerical experiment . here the departure is smaller and quantitative rather than qualitative . as a rule , the transition temperature is overestimated by the bethe approximation . most important difference between the system considered in this text and the system discussed in ref . @xcite is the degree distribution . this suggests , that the qualitative departure of the results of ref . @xcite from those of the bethe approximation is due to the variance of the degree distribution . + 88 a .- barabasi , _ linked : how everything is connected to everything else and what it means for business , science , and everyday life _ , plume books , new york 2003 . s. n. dorogovtsev and j. f. f. mendes , _ evolution of networks : from biological nets to the internet and www _ , oxford up , oxford 2003 . , eds . s. bornholdt and h. g. schuster , wiley - vch , berlin 2003 . r. pastor - satorras and a. vespignani , _ evolution and structure of the internet : a statistical physics approach _ , cambridge up , cambridge 2004 . r. durrett , _ random graph dynamics _ , cambridge up , cambridge 2006 . g. caldarelli , _ scale - free networks _ , oxford up , oxford 2007 . s. n. dorogovtsev and a. v. goltsev , _ critical phenomena in complex networks _ , rev . mod . phys . * 80 * ( 2008 ) 1275 . s. katsura and m. takizawa , _ bethe lattice and bethe approximation _ , prog . * 51 * ( 1974 ) 82 . r. j. baxter , _ exactly solved models in statistical mechanics _ , academic press , london 1982 . j. m. mooij and h. j. kappen , _ on the properties of the bethe approximation and loopy belief propagation on binary networks _ , j. stat . mechanics : theory and experiment ( 2005 ) p11012 . p. holme and b. j. kim , _ growing scale - free networks with tunable clustering _ , e * 65 * ( 2002 ) 026107 . a. maka , k. malarz and k. kuakowski , _ clusterization , frustration and collectivity in random networks _ , c * 18 * ( 2007 ) 1765 . m. j. krawczyk , k. malarz , b. kawecka - magiera , a. z. maksymowicz and k. kuakowski , _ spin - glass properties of an ising antiferromagnet on the archimedean @xmath49 lattice _ , b * 72 * ( 2005 ) 24445 . k. binder and a. p. young , _ spin glasses : experimental facts , theoretical concepts , and open questions _ , rev . * 58 * ( 1986 ) 801 .

we consider a regular random network where each node has exactly three neighbours . ising spins at the network nodes interact antiferromagnetically along the links . the clustering coefficient @xmath0 is tuned from zero to 1/3 by adding new links . at the same time , the density of geometrically frustrated links increases . we calculate the magnetic specific heat , the spin susceptibility and the edwards - anderson order parameter @xmath1 by means of the heat - bath monte carlo simulations . the aim is the transition temperature @xmath2 dependence on the clustering coefficient @xmath0 . the results are compared with the predictions of the bethe approximation . at @xmath3 , the network is bipartite and the low temperature phase is antiferromagnetic . when @xmath0 increases , the critical temperature falls down towards the values which are close to the theoretical predictions for the spin - glass phase . * magnetism of frustrated regular networks * anna maka - kraso@xmath4 and krzysztof kuakowski@xmath5 _ faculty of physics and applied computer science , agh university of science and technology , al . mickiewicza 30 , pl-30059 krakw , poland + _ @[email protected] _ pacs numbers : 75.30.kz , 64.60.aq , 05.10.ln_ _ keywords : antiferromagnetism , spin glass , disorder , frustration , regular random networks _

0812.3088

the realization of rovibrationally stable dense samples of ultracold diatomic molecules remains one of the major goals in the field of atomic and molecular physics . while cooling diatomic alkali molecules was seen as a logical next step following the optical cooling of atoms , many of the possible applications currently under investigation extend beyond atomic and molecular physics . testing fundamental symmetries based on high - precision spectroscopy of ultracold molecules @xcite or the attempts to detect the time variation of fundamental constants @xcite are examples of such applications . another one is ultracold chemistry , where the interacting species and products are in a coherent quantum superposition state and could be realized by controlling reactive collisional processes @xcite . important insights about new phases of matter could be gained from strong anisotropic dipole - dipole interaction between ultracold dipolar molecules @xcite . finally , ultracold polar molecules could also represent an attractive platform for quantum computation @xcite . many of those applications require dense samples of ultracold polar molecules in the lowest rovibrational state that makes them collisionally stable and long - lived . translationally ultracold ( 100 nk - 1 mk ) molecules are produced from an ultracold atomic gas by photoassociation ( pa ) @xcite or magnetoassociation ( ma ) @xcite . in a typical pa scheme , a pair of colliding atoms is photoassociated into a bound electronically excited molecular state that spontaneously decays , forming molecules in the electronic ground state . in magnetoassociation , a magnetic field is adiabatically swept across a feshbach resonance , converting two atoms in a matching scattering state into a molecule . both techniques produce weakly bound molecules in highly excited vibrational states of the ground electronic potential . such molecules have to be rapidly transferred to deeply bound vibrational states before they are lost from the trap due to inelastic collisions . stimulated raman adiabatic passage ( stirap ) @xcite has recently attracted significant interest as an efficient way to produce deeply bound molecules , starting from feshbach molecules @xcite . it allows to realize high transfer efficiency and preserve the high phase - space density of an initial atomic gas . in stirap , the laser pulses , coupling an initial and a final state to an intermediate excited state , are applied in a counter - intuitive sequence where a pump pulse is preceeded by a stokes pulse . during the transfer , the system stays in a `` dark '' state , _ i.e. _ , a coherent superposition of initial and final states , preventing any losses that would otherwise occur from the excited state . by adiabatically changing amplitudes of the laser pulses , the `` dark '' state evolves from the initial to the final state , resulting in nearly 100% transfer efficiency @xcite . efficient adiabatic passage from the continuum requires laser pulses shorter than the coherence time of the continuum @xcite . the adiabaticity condition of stirap , @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the transfer time , therefore implies a large effective rabi frequency @xmath6 for the pulses . in addition , dipole matrix elements between the continuum and the bound state are usually small , and so the pump pulse that couples the continuum and the excited state would require a very high intensity , which proves impractical . thus the previous stirap experiments @xcite , being restricted by the very short coherence time of the continuum , used a feshbach molecular state as an initial state . the small continuum - bound dipole matrix elements can be dramatically increased by photoassociating atoms in the vicinity of a feshbach resonance . it has been shown , both theoretically and experimentally , that the photoassociation rate increases in the presence of a feshbach resonance by several orders of magnitude @xcite . this can be explained by considering that delocalized scattering states acquire some bound - state character due to admixture of a bound level associated with a closed channel , resulting in a large increase of the franck - condon factor between the initial scattering state and the final excited state . the recently proposed feshbach optimized photoassociation ( fopa ) technique @xcite relies on this enhancement to directly reach deeply bound ground state vibrational levels from the scattering continuum . consequently , photoassociation in the vicinity of a feshbach resonance is expected to increase molecular formation rate up to @xmath7 molecules / s @xcite . in the present work , we combine the approach used in fopa with stirap for reducing the required pulse intensity . we predict highly efficient transfer of an entire atomic ensemble into the lowest rovibrational level in the molecular ground state . the paper is organized as follows . in section ii , we derive a theoretical model of a combined atomic and molecular system . fano theory is used to describe the interaction of a bound molecular state with the scattering continuum , represented as closed and open channel , respectively . the resulting continuum states are coupled by two laser fields to the vibrational target state in the ground state via the intermediate excited molecular electronic vibrational state . in section iii , we present the results of numerical solutions of the model for several alkali dimers . we find optimal rabi frequencies and profiles of stirap pulses for those systems . finally , we conclude in section iv . we consider a three level system as represented in figure [ levels ] . the ground level labeled @xmath8 is the final product state to which a maximun of population must be transfered . typically , this level will be the lowest virational level ( @xmath9 ) of a ground molecular potential . this ground level is coupled to an excited bound level @xmath10 of an excited molecular potential via a stokes pulse depicted by the blue down - arrow in figure [ levels ] . this level @xmath10 is itself coupled via a pump pulse ( red up - arrow ) to an initial continuum of unbound scattering states @xmath11 of energies @xmath12 ( grey area in figure [ levels ] ) . if we denote @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 the time dependent amplitudes associated to the final , intermediate , and initial states @xmath8 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 , respectively , then the total wave function @xmath16 of the system is given by : @xmath17 is transferred to a final target state @xmath8 via an intermediate state @xmath10 . both @xmath11 and @xmath8 are coupled to @xmath10 by a pump and a stokes pulse , respectively labeled @xmath18 and @xmath19 . a bound level @xmath20 corresponding to a closed channel can be imbedded in the continuum.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] no restriction applies to the definition of the continuum state @xmath11 as it can be associated to either a single - channel or a multi - channel scattering state . in this work , we consider the multi - channel case in which a bound level @xmath20 associated to a closed channel is embedded in the continuum of scattering states @xmath21 of an open channel . when the energy of @xmath21 coincides with that of @xmath20 , a so - called feshbach resonance @xcite occurs . these are common in binary collisions of alkali atoms due to hyperfine mixing and the tuning of the zeeman interaction by an external magnetic field , hence the possibility to control interatomic interactions with a magnetic field . following the fano theory presented in ref . @xcite , the scattering state @xmath11 can be expressed as : @xmath22 with @xmath23 and @xmath24 here , @xmath25 is the phase shift due to the interaction between @xmath20 and the scattering state @xmath26 of the open channel . we assume @xmath27 $ ] . the width of the feshbach resonance , @xmath28 , is weakly dependent on the energy , while @xmath29 is the interaction strength between the open and closed channels . the position of the resonance , @xmath30 , includes an interaction induced shift from the energy of the bound state @xmath31 . if we label @xmath32 the energy of the state @xmath33 , the total hamiltonian @xmath34 is given by : @xmath35 the light - matter interaction hamiltonian @xmath36 takes the form : @xmath37 where @xmath38 are the pump and stokes laser fields of polarization @xmath39 , respectively , while @xmath40 and @xmath41 are the dipole transition moments between the states @xmath10 and @xmath8 , and @xmath10 and @xmath11 , respectively . in this form the hamiltonian already takes into account mixing between the bound state of the closed channel and scattering states of the open channel . the schrdinger equation describing stirap conversion of two atoms into a molecule is : @xmath42 for simplicity , we set the origin of the energy to be the position of the ground state @xmath8 , and use the rotating wave approximation with @xmath43 , @xmath44 , and @xmath45 . the schrdinger equation becomes : @xmath46 where @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and @xmath49 is the dissociation energy of the ground electronic potential with respect to the state @xmath8 . the rabi frequencies of the fields are @xmath50 ( assumed real ) , @xmath51 . the previous system of three equations can be reduced into a two - equation system by eliminating the continuum amplitude @xmath52 in eq.([eq : cont - ampl ] ) . introducing a solution in the form of @xmath53 into eq.([eq : cont - ampl ] ) , we get @xmath54 where @xmath55 is some moment before the collision of the two atoms . the resulting continuum amplitude is @xmath56 inserting this result into eq . ( [ eq : c2 ] ) , we obtain a final system of equations for the amplitudes of the bound states : @xmath57 + the third term of eq . ( [ eq : c2-new ] ) , labelled @xmath58 , corresponds to the back - stimulation term , whereas the last term , labelled @xmath59 , corresponds to the source function . in this source term , the initial amplitude of the continuum wave function @xmath60 describing a collision at @xmath61 of two atoms with relative energy @xmath62 has been discussed in various contributions @xcite . a gaussian wavepacket provides the most classical description of a two - atom collision characterized by a minimal uncertainty relation between the energy bandwidth @xmath63 of the wavepacket and the duration of the collision : @xmath64 futhermore , the rabi frequency of the field coupling continuum states @xmath11 to the state @xmath10 is given by @xcite @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the dipole matrix element between an unperturbed scattering state @xmath26 and the state @xmath10 , and @xmath67 is the fano parameter , expressed as : @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the polarization vector of the pump field , and @xmath70 is the dipole matrix element between bound states @xmath10 and @xmath20 . the @xmath67 factor is essentially the ratio of the dipole matrix elements from the state @xmath10 to the bound state @xmath20 ( modified by the continuum ) and to an unperturbed continuum state @xmath26 . this factor can be made much larger than unity , and as will be shown below , the total dipole matrix element from the continuum can be enhanced by this factor in the presence of the resonance . the magnitude of @xmath67 can be controlled by the choice of the vibrational state @xmath10 . selecting a tightly bound excited vibrational state will increase the bound - bound and decrease the continuum - bound dipole matrix elements , resulting in larger @xmath67 . on the contrary , choosing a highly excited state close to a dissociation threshold decreases @xmath67 . using the expressions given in eqs.([s_epsiton_t0 ] ) , ( [ eq : rabi - fr ] ) , and ( [ eq : q ] ) for the initial amplitude of the continuum wave function , the rabi frequency between the continuum state @xmath11 and the excited bound state @xmath10 , and the fano parameter , respectively , we obtain the following complete expression for the source term : @xmath71 with @xmath72 , and where the function @xmath73 is defined as @xmath74 we assume that the unperturbed continuum is structureless and the coresponding rabi frequency @xmath75 depends only weakly on the energy . we also extend @xmath49 to @xmath76 to have the initial continuum wavefunction normalized to unity : @xmath77 . we can as well obtain a complete expression for the back - stimulation term @xmath58 . we have : @xmath78 extending the lower integration limit allows for an analytical solution for the integrals over energy and time , leading to the following expression for the back - stimulation term : @xmath79 ( t'-t ) } \right ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this work , we consider two different cases : first , when @xmath80 , _ i.e. _ , when the width @xmath81 of the feshbach resonance is much larger than the thermal energy spread @xmath63 of the colliding atoms , and second when @xmath82 . by considering these two limiting cases of broad and narrow resonances , more practical expressions for both the source term @xmath59 and the back stimulation term @xmath58 can be found . the derivation of the final system of equations is given in [ appendixa ] . here , we only describe the solutions of these systems for both broad and narrow resonances . using the parameters of the stokes and pump photoassociating pulses listed in table [ table : res - par ] for a broad ( @xmath83 mk ) and a narrow ( @xmath83 @xmath3k ) feshbach resonance , we obtain the results depicted in fig . [ resonances1 ] , with the left column corresponding to the broad resonance , and the right column to the narrow resonance . the top row shows the variation of the rabi frequencies over the time period required for the population transfer calculated using eqs.([eq : c1-new ] ) and ( [ eq : c2-new ] ) along with population in the intermediate state @xmath10 ( middle row ) and final state @xmath8 ( bottom row ) . ( middle row ) and target state @xmath84 ( bottom row ) for the stirap sequence . the left column is for a broad feshbach resonance , while the right column is for a narrow resonance ( see table [ table : res - par ] for values of parameters used ) . the dashed blue lines in the left column are the results obtained without resonance , when the parameters are adjusted to obtain the same overall transfer fraction as for the broad resonance . stokes rabi frequency is in units of @xmath7 s@xmath85 , while the pump rabi frequency is in dimensionless units @xmath86 in the broad resonance limit and @xmath87 in the narrow resonance limit . note that the scale for the rabi frequencies in the narrow resonance case is 40 times the scale for the broad resonance , and the magnitude of the pump rabi frequency is enlarged 10 times for better visibility . ] for the broad case , we considered a feshbach resonance with a width @xmath88 mk , which is a typical value for broad resonances ( see examples in appendix a.1 ) , and a thermal atomic ensemble with an energy bandwidth @xmath89 @xmath3k . we see that the transfer can reach @xmath90% of the continuum state into the target state @xmath84 ( see fig . [ resonances1 ] c ) . the parameters of the gaussian laser pulses we used ( optimized rabi frequencies , durations and delays of laser pulses ) are given in table [ table : res - par ] : the peak intensities of the stokes and pump fields were calculated from rabi frequencies as @xmath91 and @xmath92 , where we use eq.([eq : q ] ) to estimate the continuum - bound dipole matrix element @xmath93 , resulting in @xmath94 . .parameters of the stokes and pump photoassociating pulses providing optimal population transfer shown in fig.[resonances1 ] . we use @xmath95 , @xmath96 s@xmath85 , and @xmath97 d ( 1 d=@xmath98 esu cm = 0.3934 @xmath99 ) . rabi frequencies are modeled by gaussians @xmath100 , where @xmath101 refer to the stokes and pump pulse , respectively . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ table : res - par - avg ] given the adiabatic photoassociation probability @xmath102 for two colliding atoms with relative energy @xmath12 , we can calculate the number of atoms photoassociated during the time overlap @xmath5 of the stokes and pump pulses . during this time , the atom with the energy @xmath103 , where @xmath3 is the reduced mass , will collide with atoms in the volume @xmath104 , where @xmath105 is the collision cross - section . the impact parameter for the collision corresponding to a partial wave with angular momentum @xmath106 is @xmath107 . the number of collisions that atoms with a relative energy in the interval @xmath108 will experience during the transfer time is therefore @xmath109 , where @xmath110 is the spectral density of the atoms ( @xmath111 is the density of the sample ) . finally , @xmath112 for ultracold @xmath113-wave collisions , and the fraction of atoms in the energy interval @xmath108 photoassociated by the two pulses is @xmath114 , or @xmath115 the total fraction of atoms photoassociated by a pair of pulses is @xmath116 , where we assumed that @xmath102 does not significantly vary within the ensemble , and approximated it by the averaged value . considering as an example @xmath117li atoms at t=100 @xmath3k with an atomic density @xmath118 @xmath119 , an overlap time @xmath120 @xmath3s , and assuming @xmath121 , the fraction of atoms photoassociated by the stokes and pump pulses is @xmath122 : for heavier atoms @xmath123 . it will therefore require @xmath124 pairs of pulses to convert an entire atomic ensemble into deeply bound molecules . since only a small fraction of atoms can be transferred to @xmath8 by a pair of stirap pulses , a train of pulse pairs can be applied to photoassociate the entire atomic ensemble . to prevent excitation of molecules in @xmath8 by subsequent pulses , they have to be removed before the next pair of pulses is applied . this could be realized by applying , after each pair of stokes and pump pulses , a relatively long pulse resonant to a transition from @xmath8 to some other vibrational level in the excited electronic potential which decays spontaneously to a deep vibrational state in the ground electronic potential . this long pulse would optically pump molecules out of the state @xmath8 to deeper vibrational states in the ground electronic potential . it therefore has to be longer than the spontaneous decay time of the excited state . care has to be taken that the excited state does not decay back into the scattering continuum . this would empty the @xmath8 state and deposit molecules into ground potential vibrational states according to franck - condon factors before the next pair of pulses arrives . finally , after all atoms have been converted into molecules the recently demonstrated optical pumping for molecules method @xcite can be applied , which would transfer molecules from all populated vibrational states into the ground level @xmath125 . the optimal strategy is to actually choose an excited state that decays mostly to the @xmath125 level . this would allow one to avoid storing molecules in unstable vibrational states and using the optical pumping method . if such a state can not be directly reached from @xmath8 , a four - photon stirap transfer can be applied @xcite , which provides efficient transfer to deeply bound molecular states . it allows one to choose the final state @xmath8 , from which the excited state decaying predominantly to @xmath125 can be easily reached . in this case rotational selectivity can also be preserved , since only @xmath126 and @xmath127 states will be populated . the total time required to photoassociate the whole atomic ensemble and transfer it to the @xmath125 level can be estimated as follows . as the numerical results show , adiabatic passage requires @xmath128 @xmath3s , the follow - up pulse emptying state @xmath8 can have a @xmath129 ns duration , if the excited state lifetime is tens of ns , resulting in the whole sequence @xmath130 @xmath3s . then the train of @xmath131 pulse pairs will take @xmath132 s. the final step , optical pumping to the @xmath125 level , requires @xmath133 hundred @xmath3s , so the overall formation time is @xmath132 s. given an illuminated volume @xmath134 mm@xmath135 and an atomic density @xmath136 @xmath119 the resulting production rate is expected to be @xmath137 molecules / s . this compares well with the recent experiment on stirap production of ground state krb molecules starting from the feshbach state , where the entire cycle including creation of feshbach molecules takes @xmath138 s @xcite . combining photoassociation and coherent optical transfer to molecular ground vibrational states can allow one to convert an entire atomic ensemble into deeply bound molecules , and to produce a high phase - space density ultracold molecular gas . we have analyzed photoassociative adiabatic passage in a thermal ultracold atomic gas near a feshbach resonance . the presence of a bound state imbedded in and resonant with scattering continuum states strongly enhances the continuum - bound transition dipole matrix element to an excited electronic state , thus requiring less laser intensity for efficient transfer . in the limit of a wide resonance when compared to the thermal spread of collision energies , the dipole matrix element is enhanced by the fano parameter @xmath67 . choosing a tightly bound excited vibrational state , @xmath67 can be made much larger than unity , resulting in the intensity of the pump pulse required for efficient adiabatic passage to be @xmath139 times smaller than in the absence of the resonance . we modeled the adiabatic passage using typical parameters of alkali dimers and found intensities and durations of stirap pulses providing optimal transfer . intensities of the pump pulse , coupling the continuum to an excited state , were found to be a few kw/@xmath140 , which is @xmath129 times smaller than without resonance . optimal pulse durations are several @xmath3s , resulting in energies per pulse @xmath138 @xmath3j for a focus area of @xmath141 mm@xmath142 . if the feshbach resonance is narrow compared to the thermal energy spread of colliding atoms , adiabatic passage is hindered by destructive quantum interference . the reason is that electromagnetically induced transparency significantly reduces the transition dipole matrix element from the scattering continuum to an excited state in the presence of the bound feshbach state . in the narrow resonance limit , photoassociative adiabatic passage is therefore more efficient if the resonance is far - detuned . due to low atomic collision rates at ultracold temperatures , only a small fraction of atoms can be converted into molecules by a pair of photoassociative pulses . to convert an entire atomic ensemble , a train of pulse pairs can be applied . we estimate that @xmath131 pulse pairs will associate an atomic gas of alkali dimers with a density @xmath143 @xmath119 in an illuminated volume of @xmath141 mm@xmath135 in @xmath144 s , resulting in extremely high production rates of @xmath137 molecules / s . high transfer efficiencies combined with low intensities of adiabatic photoassociative pulses also make the broad resonance limit attractive for quantum computation . for example , a scheme proposed in @xcite can be realized , where qubit states are encoded into a scattering and a bound molecular states of polar molecules . to perform one and two - qubit operations , this scheme requires a high degree of control over the system , which our model readily offers . finally , marrying fopa and stirap is a very promising avenue to produce large amounts of molecules , for a variety of molecular species . in fact , although we described here examples based on magnetically induced feshbach resonances , such resonances are extremely common , and can be induced by several interactions , such as external electric fields or optical fields . even in the absence of hyperfine interactions , other interactions can provide the necessary coupling , such as in the case of the magnetic dipole - dipole interaction in @xmath145cr @xcite . this research was partially founded by the national science foundation , army research office , and the u.s . department of energy , office of basic energy sciences . in this appendix , we discuss eqs.([eq : c1-new ] ) and ( [ eq : c2-new ] ) for various relative widths of the feshbach resonance @xmath81 with respect to the thermal energy spread @xmath63 of the colliding atoms . we first describe the case of a broad resonance , _ i.e. _ , when the width of the feshbach resonance greatly exceeds the thermal energy spread ( @xmath146 ) , and second consider the opposite situation of a narrow resonance ( @xmath147 ) . finally , we briefly present the case where there is no resonance . the typical thermal energy spread for colliding atoms in photoassociation experiments with non - degenerate gases is @xmath149 @xmath3k . the broad resonance case occurs for resonances having a width of several gauss ( @xmath134 mk ) , for which we have @xmath150 . a wide variety of systems exhibit broad resonances . for instance , they can be found in collision of @xmath117li atoms at 834 g for the @xmath151 channel ( @xmath152 g= 40 mk ) and in @xmath153li at 736 g for the @xmath154 channel ( @xmath155 g = 19 mk ) . we note here that these values of @xmath81 are slightly different than the magnetic " width @xmath156 usually given and based on the modelling of the scattering length . the source function can be readily calculated from eq.([eq : s ] ) by noticing that the rabi frequency term can be set at @xmath157 corresponding to the maximum of the gaussian function in the integrand . using the function @xmath73 defined in eq.([eq : g ] ) , the result takes the form @xmath158 where @xmath159 is the source function without a resonance given below in eq.([eq : sorce - nr ] ) . strictly speaking , this expression is valid for @xmath160 , but since @xmath80 eq.([eq : s - wide ] ) is a good approximation for a wide range of detunings @xmath161 . the back - stimulation term ( [ eq : back - stimulation ] ) can be further simplified in the limit of a broad resonance . in this case , both @xmath162 and @xmath163 change on a time scale @xmath164 , _ i.e. _ , slowly compared to the decay time @xmath165 of the exponent . therefore , we can rewrite ( [ eq : back - stimulation ] ) as : @xmath166c_{2}(t){\cal e}^{2}_{p}(t).\ ] ] the system ( [ eq : c1-new])-([eq : c2-new ] ) in the case of a broad resonance becomes : @xmath167c_{2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath168 is the continuum - bound rabi frequency in the absence of resonance . we also added a spontaneous decay term @xmath169 , assuming that the excited molecules dissociate into high energy continuum states and the resulting atoms leave a trap . from eq.([eq : s - wide ] ) , one can see that in a broad resonance case , the source amplitude is enhanced by the factor @xmath170 when compared to the unperturbed continuum case . this factor has a maximum at @xmath171 , with the corresponding maximum value @xmath172 for @xmath173 . this situation occurs when the width of the resonance is of the order of a few micro - gauss or less . examples of narrow resonances include @xmath117li@xmath174na at 746 g for the @xmath175 channel ( @xmath176 mg = 1 @xmath3k ) @xcite , or @xmath117li@xmath177rb at 882 g for the @xmath175 channel ( p - wave , @xmath178 mg = 1.3 @xmath3k ) . we note that the source term expressed in eq.([eq : s ] ) can be rewritten in a time representation : @xmath179 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we introduced the dimensionless variables @xmath180 , @xmath181 , @xmath182 ; @xmath183 and @xmath184 are modified bessel and struve functions . one can see from this expression that the source function is a sum of the pure source function of the unperturbed continuum , given by the first term in square brackets , and of the admixed bound state , given by the integral . the coefficient @xmath182 , which is the ratio of the feshbach resonance width to the width of the thermal energy spread , gives the ratio of contributions from the bound state and the unperturbed continuum , respectively . it is then easier to notice that in the limit of a narrow resonance , the gaussian function in the integrand of eq.([eq : source ] ) is much narrower than the bessel and struve functions , which change on the time scale @xmath185 . therefore the source term can be aproximated as : @xmath186 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath187 , the real part of the source function is given by the first term in the square brackets , which is a pure continuum source function , while the imaginary part is due to the admixed bound state and its magnitude depends on the product @xmath188 . using asymptotic expansions of modified bessel and struve functions @xmath189 , @xmath190 , it is seen from eq.([eq : s - narrow - res ] ) that the contribution to the source function from the bound state decays on the time scale @xmath191 , while the contribution from the unperturbed continuum decays on the time scale @xmath192 .

we develop a complete theoretical description of photoassociative stimulated raman adiabatic passage ( stirap ) near a feshbach resonance in a thermal atomic gas . we show that it is possible to use _ low intensity _ laser pulses to directly excite the continuum at a feshbach resonance and transfer nearly the entire atomic population to the lowest rovibrational level in the molecular ground state . in case of a broad resonance , commonly found in several diatomic alkali molecules , our model predicts a transfer efficiency @xmath0 up to 97% for a given atom pair , and up to 70% when averaged over an atomic ensemble . the laser intensities and pulse durations needed for optimal transfer are @xmath1 w/@xmath2 and several @xmath3s . such efficiency compares to or surpasses currently available techniques for creating stable diatomic molecules , and the versatility of this approach simplifies its potential use for many molecular species .

astro-ph0311380

the recent advance in modern cosmology due to new and improved telescopes and techniques seems to overthrow the long - lasting paradigm or hope of an einstein - de sitter ( eds ) universe . from the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) @xcite , along with studies of large scale structure ( lss ) , @xcite and the lyman @xmath1 forest @xcite ( ly@xmath1 ) etc . it is inferred that the universe consists of roughly 30 % matter ( cold dark matter , cdm and ordinary matter ) and 70 % dark energy . furthermore , measurements of the apparent magnitude of type ia supernovae ( sne ) have been used by two collaborations @xcite to estimate the values of the total matter energy density @xmath2 , which includes cdm , and the density in dark energy , e.g. @xmath3 . type ia sne are believed to be so - called standard candles , i.e. they show a very small scatter in intrinsic luminosity after empirical corrections @xcite , and by measuring the apparent magnitudes , the cosmology - dependent luminosity distance can be inferred . the supernovae look fainter than they would in an eds universe favouring both a non - zero @xmath3 and @xmath4 . combined with cmb data from boomerang and maxima @xcite , they end up at approximately the same values as the above - mentioned cmb , lss and ly@xmath1 measurements . however , there is a number of potential systematic errors that can contaminate the measurements . first , inter- and/or intra - galactic dust may obscure the light from the sne and make them look fainter . this has been investigated in e.g. @xcite . it is also still unclear whether there is any evolution of the sn brightness with redshift . many potential sources of evolution have been proposed , such as differing progenitor composition @xcite or host galaxy morphology ( and thereby redshift ) dependence @xcite just to name a few . furthermore , if photons can oscillate into axions , the sne will also look fainter due to the reduced number of received photons . this has been addressed e.g. in reference @xcite . a fourth possible contaminant is magnification or de - magnification by gravitational lensing . having a large sample of sne this can be corrected for statistically @xcite , but when studying single sne , the lensing effects need a careful treatment . this was the case with the farthest known sn so far , sn1997ff , at a redshift of 1.7 . the vicinity of the line - of - sight to this sn was unusually dense in galaxies and modelling of the individual lens galaxies was required . this was done by @xcite who conclude a large possible magnification depending on the lens masses and concentrations . bentez et al . @xcite conclude a magnification of [email protected] mag . in this paper we present the well - known multiple lens - plane method applied to the calculation of the magnification of any point- or extended source . section [ sec : lensing ] describes this method in a general way . furthermore , we model the lenses as spherically symmetric navarro - frenk - white ( nfw ) or singular isothermal sphere ( sis ) halos and the lensing properties of these are described in sections [ subs : nfw ] and [ subs : sis ] . for more information on under which circumstances each halo type is appropriate , see e.g. reference @xcite . the method and models are manifested in a ` fortran 77 ` program , q - let , obtainable from the author upon request or it can be downloaded at ` http://www.physto.se/~cg/qlet/qlet.htm ` . the program is described in the text in section [ sec : program ] . in reference @xcite , an early version of q - let was used to estimate the magnification of the abovementioned sn1997ff . section [ sec : ramone ] describes the application of the code to the recently discovered supernova sn2003es . this section introduces the multiple lens - plane method and gives the important equations needed in the study of multiple light deflection . for more details , see reference @xcite . we also describe the lensing properties of the nfw and sis halo profiles . we start by projecting the mass of each massive object ( e.g. galaxy ) onto a plane at the respective object redshift . in the @xmath6:th plane , this gives a surface mass density @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the impact parameter of the light - ray in each plane ( see figure [ fig : mullens ] ) . the justification for this projection is that the light is deflected only in the very vicinity of the lens in most cases and then travels practically unimpeded until it reaches the observer or another lens , situated far away from the preceding one . from figure [ fig : mullens ] , where most quantities are defined , we see that the position of the light - ray in each plane can be obtained recursively from the observed position @xmath9 through @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the angular diameter distance between redshifts @xmath12 and @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 . with @xmath16 lens - planes we find the source position as @xmath17 . for convenience we use , in each plane , dimensionless quantities defined by @xmath18 where @xmath19 is an arbitrary scale length in the @xmath6:th plane which , if chosen as @xmath20 , makes @xmath21 the angular impact parameter in each plane . furthermore , the _ convergence _ is @xmath22 where ( in geometrised units ) @xmath23 is called the _ critical density _ due to its relation to the ability of a lens to produce multiple images . if we also define @xmath24 , the _ scaled deflection potential _ @xmath25 , needed for the magnification and defined through @xmath26 becomes @xmath27 in these units where @xmath28 is the source position , the lens equation is given by @xmath29 we now want to find the magnification as a function of image position . let @xmath30 denote the jacobian matrix of the lens equation @xmath31 furthermore we need @xmath32 @xmath33 where @xmath34 @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 . this gives @xmath38 as @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the 2@xmath412 unit matrix . the @xmath42:s can be found by recursion and by noting that @xmath43 ; @xmath44 finally , the magnification is given by @xmath45 negative values of @xmath46 indicates images of reversed parity relative to the unlensed image . the use of the navarro - frenk - white model calls for a brief description of its lensing properties . before projection onto the lens plane , the nfw profile is given by @xmath47 where @xmath48 and @xmath49 are scale parameters that can be determined once e.g. the mass is specified , @xmath50 is the radial co - ordinate . the projected surface mass density will be circularly symmetric and we no longer need vector notation on the impact parameter but instead choose @xmath51 as the radial co - ordinate with the origin at the lens centre . if we choose @xmath52 ( cf . equation ( [ eq : dimless1 ] ) ) and define @xmath53 , then @xmath54 where @xmath55 and @xmath56 . the deflection angle is @xmath57 where @xmath58 and the magnification will be given by @xmath59^{-1}. \label{eq : mag5}\ ] ] a flaw of this model is that the total mass diverges when integrated out to infinity . however , this is not too serious since the deflection angle only is sensitive to the mass inside the impact radius , and the magnification is sensitive to this mass and the convergence at this point ( for circularly symmetric lenses ) . thus all mass outside the impact radius is unimportant . a single nfw halo gives either one or three images , where the primary image has @xmath60 , the secondary @xmath61 and the tertiary @xmath62 . the singular isothermal sphere model , also used here , is based on the assumption that the dark matter in the halo behaves as particles in an ideal gas trapped in their gravitational potential . the gas is assumed to be in thermal equilibrium and the resulting density profile before projection ( in geometrised units ) is @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the line - of - sight velocity dispersion of the particles . if we choose @xmath65 the equations for convergence , deflection angle , intrinsic source position and magnification become very simple for this model : @xmath66 @xmath67 and @xmath68 and @xmath69 as with the nfw model , the sis will give an infinite mass when integrated to infinity but the argument above regarding deflection angle and magnification also holds here . when considering a single sis halo it can give either one or two images depending on the impact parameter . primary images have @xmath60 and secondary have @xmath61 . the quick lensing estimation tool , q - let is a ` fortran 77 ` code written in order to quickly be able to estimate the lensing effects on a point source or an extended object . the structure of the code is as follows * read the input datafile and sort the planes * check if parameter values are allowed * present a choice between a point- or an extended source with elliptical image shape , alternatively a square grid ( see section [ subs : output ] ) * compute magnifications and positions of light rays * present a choice of how to output the results a used supplied datafile contains the cosmological parameters , the source redshift and position and the lenses redshifts , positions , velocity dispersions _ or _ masses and finally their halo type . the mass should be @xmath70 , i.e. the mass within the radius ( @xmath71 ) within which the average energy density is 200 times the critical density at the lens redshift . a point source must be put at the origin . for the case of an elliptical image , the origin will be put at the source centre and the ellipse will be centered at user specified co - ordinates which should be taken as ( 0,0 ) if an elliptical image only is studied . the possibility of putting the ellipse off - origin is useful to study e.g. a sn that is offset from its host galaxy centre and the galaxy shape is to be investigated . the sn is put at the origin and the host galaxy central co - ordinates are given as input . if a square grid ( see section [ subs : output ] ) is used , it will be centered at @xmath72 . the angular positions of the lensing galaxies should of course be assigned with respect to this origin and should be given in arcseconds . the velocity dispersions and masses should be given in @xmath73 and @xmath74 respectively . see section [ subs : input ] for an example of an input file . if only @xmath70 is given for a sis lens , this mass will be used to calculate the corresponding velocity dispersion since @xmath75 is the parameter used to determine the lensing strength for this halo type . if , on the other hand , only @xmath75 is given for a nfw lens , this velocity dispersion will be used to calculate the corresponding @xmath70 for a * sis * lens and assuming @xmath76 is the same for the nfw halo for a discussion of the validity of this . ] . this is done since the lensing properties of the nfw halo depends upon @xmath70 in our calculations . if , for some reason , both the mass and velocity dispersion are given , the mass ( velocity dispersion ) will be ignored for the sis ( nfw ) lens . all distances are computed using the filled beam approximation and it is also with respect to an homogeneous universe that the magnification is given . due to computational complications ( and perhaps lack of connection to reality ) there are some approximate restrictions on the input parameters . however , these restrictions do not severely limit the usefulness of the code as can be seen in table [ tab : restr ] where the allowed parameter ranges are presented . furthermore , some of them are not very strict and depends on the values of the other parameters making these ranges approximate only . especially extremely low or high hubble parameters ( @xmath77 or @xmath78 might lead to problems . lc source redshift & @xmath79 + lens redshift & @xmath80 $ ] + lens mass @xmath81 $ ] & @xmath82 + lens velocity disp . @xmath83 $ ] & 5@xmath84 + hubble parameter & @xmath85 + mass energy density & @xmath86 + energy density in cosmological const . & @xmath87 + combined restrictions & @xmath88 or + when using nfw halo & @xmath89 and @xmath90 + the information needed by q - let to be able to compute the magnification and deflection of a light ray is the following : the values of the cosmological parameters , i.e. @xmath91 , @xmath92 and @xmath3 , the source redshift and position , the lenses redshifts and positions , their velocity dispersion or mass and their halo types ( nfw or sis ) . this information is collected in an input datafile which could have the following appearance : .... 0.7 0.3 0.7 1.7 0 0 0 0 xxx 0.923 -4.1 3.01 138 0 nfw 0.655 2.6 -1.11 0 1e12 sis 0.322 -3.32 5.11 0 9.87e10 nfw 1.453 -2.32 -0.4 180.0 0 sis 0.011 -2.34 2.32 0 6.5e9 nfw 0.234 -4.1 3.01 190 0 sis 0.254 -5.23 -2.43 100.3 0 nfw .... the entries are : + [ cols= " > , > , > , > , > , > " , ] + where subscript 1 refers to the image plane and @xmath6 refers to the chosen plane . the file will contain a quite large amount of rays in order to see the shape better ( of order 1 - 5@xmath93 , depending on the size of the ellipse ) . to see the result , just plot the file with the desired columns . when a square grid is chosen , the output file will look exactly like in the ellipse - case , the difference is that the grid is square and pre - defined to be 20@xmath94 . this grid can be used if the image(s ) has ( have ) a shape not described by an ellipse . when trying to estimate the intrinsic shape of an object like this , you plot the 4:th and 5:th columns making cuts using the 2:nd and 3:rd columns as to only include the rays making up the image(s ) . if instead wishing to see e.g. what an intrinsically elliptical source looks like in the image plane , you make the cut using the 4:th and 5:th columns , even though the grid in the source plane is not evenly distributed it will be possible as long as it covers the area where the cut is made . sn2003es was found at a redshift of 0.968 in the hubble deep field north ( hdf - n ) in april 2003 by the goods / hst transient search , as part of the hst treasury program @xcite . as the host galaxy seems to be an elliptical , it is most likely a type ia sn @xcite . since these are used as standard candles to determine the redshift - distance relation in the quest for the cosmological parameters , it is very important to study the potential magnification by gravitational lensing . there are several possible lens candidates close to the line - of - sight of sn2003es so a close inspection is necessary . the data on the host and lens galaxies has been taken from three different references ; @xcite . since the redshift information differ significantly in the different catalogs , we used the principle to take the spectroscopic redshifts when available and the photometric redshifts otherwise . if two catalogs had only photometric redshifts , the most recent result was used . however , as a worst case scenario regarding the amount of magnification , we also computed the magnification including four galaxies from one of the older catalogues which , in the most recent catalogue , were determined to be background galaxies at @xmath95 . hereafter we call these gh after gwyn and hartwick of reference @xcite . to estimate the velocity dispersion that is needed in the lensing calculation , we took the observed luminosities and best fit galaxy morphology from @xcite and performed cross - filter k - corrections to rest frame @xmath96 using galaxy templates provided by the snoc package @xcite . the tully - fisher ( t - f ) relation for spirals ( s`x`x ) and faber - jackson ( f - j ) relation for ellipticals ( ell ) and irregulars ( irr ) were used to derive an approximate velocity dispersion . the relations are given by @xmath97 and @xmath98 where @xmath99 is the normalisation of the velocity dispersion , @xmath100 is the absolute magnitude in @xmath96 and @xmath101 is a typical magnitude taken to be @xmath102 @xcite . within a radius of 10@xmath103 we found 9 lensing galaxies excluding gh and 13 lenses including it . the redshifts , velocity dispersions , positional data and galaxy types can be found in table [ tab : ramgalinf ] . clrrrc cat . no & & @xmath104-pos . @xmath105 $ ] & @xmath106-pos . @xmath105 $ ] & @xmath107 & gal . type + 526 & 0.120 & -3.74 & -8.60 & 0.136 & scd + 539 & 0.120 & -2.55 & -7.93 & 0.112 & scd + 549 & 0.952@xmath108 & 1.62 & -8.29 & 0.924 & ell + 622 & 0.440 & 4.76 & -2.59 & 0.332 & scd + 623 & 0.960 & -6.80 & 2.58 & 0.334 & scd + 631 & 0.321@xmath108 & 1.69 & -0.52 & 0.460 & irr + 662 & 0.511@xmath108 & 2.71 & 2.88 & 0.557 & irr + 693 & 0.600 & 2.52 & 6.85 & 0.402 & ell + 700 & 0.040 & -1.52 & 9.28 & 0.098 & sbc + + 582 & 0.904 & -9.73 & -0.62 & 0.401 & scd + 607 & 0.776 & 1.64 & -3.07 & 0.431 & sbc + 610 & 0.296 & 0.87 & -2.43 & 0.218 & scd + 696 & 0.904 & 8.52 & 4.51 & 0.682 & irr + + 619 & 0.968@xmath108 & -0.475 & -0.710 & ( 1.290 ) & ell + we used the q - let code to compute the magnification of sn2003es and also to find the intrinsic shape of the host galaxy . this is done in order to see that the observed elliptical shape is not contrived from an intrinsically very complicated shape that is never observed in reality . the normalisation of the velocity dispersion is quite poorly known @xcite and we choose to present the magnification as a function of this normalisation . for the host galaxy shape calculation we used a value of @xmath109 km / s , obtained as an average in reference @xcite for a mixture of galaxy morphologies . however , the shape is not distorted very much even with @xmath99 as high as 300 km / s , although it is translated and more strongly magnified . the result on the magnification is found in figure [ fig : rammag ] . we have used models where all halos are assumed to be either of nfw or sis type . the figure also shows the result both when including the four gh galaxies and when excluding them . as is seen , in the region of @xmath99 between 150 and 200 km / s , i.e. around 170 km / s , the magnification varies between roughly 1.08 and 1.27 depending on the the model and the presence of the gh galaxies . this corresponds to a magnitude shift of @xmath110 mag , a significant change that could dominate the uncertainty ( the intrinsic magnitude spread in type ia sne is roughly between 0.1 and 0.2 mag @xcite ) . note also that higher @xmath99 have been obtained e.g. in reference @xcite , where a value for the sis of roughly 275 km / s was obtained for the dark matter in ellipticals . in figure [ fig : move ] , we display the intrinsic ( unlensed ) position relative to the observed position at ( 0,0 ) , depending on @xmath99 and the model ( nfw / sis and gh incl./gh excl . ) . we see that the shift is only weakly depending on the halo type for this lens system under our assumptions . finally , we show the intrinsic shape of the host galaxy for a @xmath99 of 170 km / s @xcite in figure [ fig : ramell ] . this plot _ also _ shows the small difference in deflection between nfw and sis halo models under our assumptions . the shapes were computed including the gh galaxies . the axis ratios of both the nfw and sis case are roughly 0.9 , making them perfectly normal e1 galaxies so no constraints on the magnification or model can be inferred from the host galaxy shape . one of the approximations that may be criticised is the fact that we extend the halos out to infinity . however , the lensing effect at large impact radii is very small . for sn2003es , the lenses with large impact radii contribute very little to the total magnification which is dominated by galaxies no . 631 and 662 . putting @xmath70 of the nfw equal to that of the sis for a given velocity dispersion is not obviously a good approximation . the most likely measured quantities are the luminosity or velocity dispersion of the lens and the luminosity may be used to estimate a velocity dispersion either via the tully - fisher or faber - jackson relation . when a velocity dispersion is obtained , the best way would be to use it directly on the nfw profile . however , as opposed to the sis , the nfw velocity dispersion depends on the radius . by following okas and mamon in reference @xcite it is possible to obtain the line - of - sight velocity dispersion , @xmath111 , for well resolved sources , or , for small or distant sources , the `` aperture velocity dispersion '' , @xmath112 , which is the average over an aperture centered on the object . we calculated both these quantities as a function of radius and found that @xmath112 did not fall off dramatically . as an example , in a case where we put the sis velocity dispersion ( @xmath113 ) to 170 km / s to get the parameters for the nfw and then compute the corresponding nfw velocity dispersions , @xmath112 varies roughly by @xmath114% and @xmath115% around 170 km / s between radii @xmath116 and @xmath117 . the line - of - sight velocity dispersion varies more , @xmath118% to @xmath119% in the same range . however , at a radius of _ roughly _ @xmath120 , there is a quite small scatter around the sis value of less than @xmath12115% . this seems to be valid for a large range of redshifts and velocity dispersions . it also seems valid in low @xmath122- and low density universes . thus in almost all cases it is possible to find a radius at which @xmath123 , with this radius being roughly equal to @xmath120 . inverting the velocity dispersion - mass relation for the nfw is quite time - consuming , and this , along with the ambiguity due to the dependence of @xmath75 on radius and the fact that the difference seems not to be significant , motivates using the simpler conversion via the sis . however , if this conversion is unsatisfactory , it is always possible for the user to supply @xmath70 instead , in which case of course no conversion is needed . for the irregular galaxies we have used the faber - jackson relation which is valid for ellipticals . an approximation which is difficult to say to what extent it affects the results , and in which direction . using the tully - fisher relation on the irregulars would increase the magnification even further , but at most by @xmath12115 - 20% . whether the halo models we use are good descriptions of real halos is still under debate . we are using spherically symmetric models , which might be an oversimplification but the ellipticity of the dark matter in the observed halos is in practice very seldom known ( see e.g. reference @xcite for the effects of ellipticity in lensing ) . so , unless some new model is very different from the sis and nfw , the results for sn2003es is likely to remain . we have found that sn2003es is likely to have been significantly magnified by gravitational lensing , a fact that must be taken into account when trying to use this ( likely type ia ) sn to infer cosmological parameters . either a more thorough analysis of the lensing galaxies is needed to take the effect into account or the sn should be used only to set a lower limit on the distance or maybe even be excluded from the sample if not having large statistics . in that case some sne are likely to be de - magnified and the effect can be assumed to average to @xmath124 . the fact that the intrinsic shape of the host galaxy looks perfectly normal makes it practically impossible to use this shape to put constraints on the magnification of sn2003es . if an extremely unusual shape would have been obtained , it could perhaps have affected the reliability of the model . we have presented the multiple lens - plane method of gravitational lensing along with its implementation in q - let , a ` fortran 77 ` code that can be used to quickly estimate the lensing effects on either a point source or to obtain the intrinsic shape of an elliptical image . a square grid in the image plane is also possible for user - defined image shapes . the code was applied to sn2003es , a sn ( most likely type ia ) discovered in the hdf - n . using both nfw and sis type halos and estimating the velocity dispersions from the observed luminosities via the faber - jackson and tully - fisher relations we found that sn2003es is likely to have been significantly magnified by gravitational lensing and that this problem should be addressed in detail before using sn2003es in estimates of the cosmological parameters . the author would like to thank julio navarro for permission to use his code for calculation of the nfw parameters , phillip helbig for permission to use his code for calculations of cosmological distances , ariel goobar , joakim edsj and edvard mrtsell for useful discussions , suggestions and proofreading . finally , the author thanks tomas dahln . this project was funded by the swedish research council . 99 d n spergel et al . , 2003 _ astrophys . suppl . _ * 148 * 175 c l kuo et al . , _ submitted to apj _ [ astro - ph/0212289 ] t j pearson et al . , 2003 _ apj _ * 591 * 556 w j percival et al . , 2001 _ mon . not . soc . _ * 327 * 1297 r a c croft et al . , 2002 _ apj _ * 581 * 20 n y gnedin and a j s hamilton , 2002 _ mnras _ * 334 * 107 s perlmutter et al . , 1999 _ apj _ * 517 * 565 a g riess et al . , 1998 _ astronom . _ * 116 * 1009 m m phillips,1993 _ apj _ * 413 * l105 s perlmutter et al . , 1997 _ apj _ * 483 * 565 p de bernardis et al . , 2002 _ apj _ * 564 * 559 m e abroe et al . , 2002 _ mnras _ * 334 * 11 a goobar , l bergstrm and e mrtsell , 2002 _ astron . & astrophys . _ * 384 * 1 a aguirre,1999 _ apj _ * 512 * l19 a aguirre , 1999 _ apj _ * 525 * 583 h umeda , k nomoto , c kobayashi , i hachisu and m kato , 1999 _ apj _ * 522 * l43 p hflich , k nomoto , h umeda and j c wheeler , 2000 _ apj _ * 528 * 590 i domnguez , p hflich and o straniero , 2001 _ apj _ * 557 * 279 m sullivan et al . , 2003 _ mnras _ * 340 * 1057 e mrtsell and a goobar , 2003 _ jour . of cosm . and astropart . phys . _ * 0304 * 003 r amanullah , e mrtsell and a goobar , 2003 _ a&a _ * 397 * 819 g f lewis and r a ibata , 2001 _ mnras _ * 324 * l25 e mrtsell , c gunnarsson and a goobar , 2001 _ apj _ * 561 * 106 a g riess et al . , 2001 _ apj _ * 560 * 49 n bentez et al . , 2002 _ apj _ * 577 * l1 l - x li and j p ostriker , 2002 _ apj _ * 566 * 652 p schneider , j ehlers and e falco , 1992 _ gravitational lenses _ ( berlin : springer verlag ) e l okas and g a mamon , 2001 _ mnras _ * 321 * 155 l g strolger , goods treasury team , 2003 _ iau circ._*8140 * 1 + see also : _ http://www.stsci.edu/ftp/science/goods/transients.html _ s van den bergh and g a tammann , 1991 _ ann . rev . of astron . & astrophys . _ * 29 * 363 a fernndez - soto , k m lanzetta and a yahil , 1999 _ apj _ * 513 * 34 + see also : _ http://bat.phys.unsw.edu.au/~fsoto/hdfcat.html _ a goobar et al . , 2002 _ a&a _ * 392 * 757 s d j gwyn and f d a hartwick , 1996 _ apj _ * 468 * l77 + see also : _ http://astrowww.phys.uvic.ca/grads/gwyn/pz/hdfn/ _ j g cohen et al . , 2000 _ apj _ * 538 * 29 p j e peebles , 1993 _ principles of physical cosmology _ ( princeton : princeton university press ) g wilson , n kaiser , g a luppino and l l cowie , 2000 _ apj _ * 556 * 601 p fisher et al . , 2000 _ aj _ * 120 * 1198 m hamuy et al . , 1996 _ aj _ * 112 * 2391 m fukugita and e l turner , 1991 _ mnras _ * 253 * 99 c r keeton , c s kochanek and u seljak , 1997 _ apj _ * 482 * 604

q - let is a fortran 77 code that enables a quick estimate of the gravitational lensing effects on a point- or an extended source . the user provided input consists of the redshifts , angular positions relative to the source , mass or velocity dispersion estimate and halo type for the lens galaxies . the considered halo types are the navarro - frenk - white and the singular isothermal sphere . the code uses the so - called multiple lens - plane method to find the magnification and intrinsic shape of the source . this method takes into account the multiple deflections that may arise when several mass accumulations are situated at different redshifts close to the line - of - sight . the q - let code is applied to the recently discovered supernova , sn2003es , which is likely to be of type ia as its host galaxy is classified as an elliptical . we find that sn2003es is likely to have been significantly magnified by gravitational lensing and that this should be considered in high-@xmath0 studies if this sn is to be used to determine the cosmological parameters . q - let was motivated by the supernova searches , where lensing can be a problem , but it can also be applied to any simple lens system where a quick estimate is wanted , e.g. the single lens case .

cond-mat0611403

foams are studied both as unique industrial materials and also as a paradigm for complex fluids in general . in addition , many properties of foam arise from the collective effects of soap film interactions , which in turn derive from the chemistry and physics of static and flowing surfactant layers . thus , both microscipic and macroscopic properties can be probed in foam experiments . in particular , two dimensional ( 2d ) foams allow easy access to many properties of bubbles and foam since each bubble and each soap film interaction can be observed and analyzed @xcite . a series of studies by cantat and coworkers @xcite probes the relationship between the elastic and rheological properties of mono- and bi - disperse foams by studying the behavior of isolated large bubbles in a flowing monodisperse background field . under certain conditions a large bubble will flow faster than the surrounding bubbles , pushing its way thorough the background flow . cantat et al . explained their observations by including the effects of both the frictional drag on individual soap films and the elastic stress in the background flow . the elastic energy ultimately drives the bubble rearrangements necessary to let the large bubble through . debregeas et al . , the first to study shear banding in foam , used couette flow to generate shear stresses in a two dimensional foam @xcite . the shear bands in their experiments are formed and maintained by topological rearrangements at band interfaces that relax local stress . since the shear is quantifiable , these experiments allow one to study the energy dissipated via topological rearrangements ( e.g. t1 and t2 ) as well as their time scales . unlike these previous experiments which couple frictional dissipation to topological dissipation , our configuration largely eliminates topological dissipation . we generated extended parallel shear bands by injecting air into a background flow . the injected air parted the background flow producing three bands : two bands of background flow surrounding a central band with a different bubble structure and flow rate ( figs . [ raw ] , [ injection ] , and supplemental material ) . although severe topological rearrangements necessarily occur as the background flow is pushed aside ( fig . [ injection ] ) , stable coexistence of the shear bands incurs little topological cost . in a strict sense , a t1 transition occurs each time a soap film separating two large bubbles in the channel passes by a border between two small bubbles in the background flow . however , by the symmetry of the configuration , these transitions superimpose only a small periodic perturbation onto the overall dissipation . we consistently reproduced the shear bands over a range of experimental parameters such as background flow rate , air injection rate and foam thickness . simple geometric analysis reveals that the experimental parameters are insufficient to predict the relative size of the shear band . we hypothesize that the size emerges spontaneously to minimize drag dissipation in the system . by including both the drag between soap films and the glass plates and the drag of one soap film against another , we successfully predict the shear band height selection . furthermore , we obtain an estimate of the ratio of film - glass drag to film - film drag : @xmath0 . although many theoretical and experimental efforts have studied the film - glass drag ( see appendix a ) , this paper is the first , to our knowledge , to compare it to film - film drag . we hope our result leads to further experimental and theoretical study . our setup consists of a bubble generator and a hele - shaw cell ( hsc ) . the hsc consists of two sheets of 1/2 plate glass which we separated by one to three metal shims ( 0.8 mm ) creating a flow cell approximately 15.5 cm wide and 71 cm long . the hsc is sealed to the bubble generator at one end and open at the other . approximately 30 cm from the bubble generator , the top hsc plate has a 1 mm hole centered side to side . we injected air into the background flow through this port to generate the shear band . the bubble generator consists of a small tank ( @xmath11 liter ) made of polycarbonate sheet . we generated bubbles by injecting air into the soap solution ( 85 % distilled water , 10 % joy dish soap , 5 % glycerol ) through a submerged manifold with four independent heads to which we can attach standard syringe needles ( 0.24 @xmath2 i.d . to 0.58 @xmath2 i.d . ) . the size of the bubbles each needle produces is very sensitive to the rate of air flow , so we controlled the rate of foam generation ( and therefore the rate of foam flow through the cell ) with the size and number of active needles rather than the rate of air . one difficulty in generating foam with multiple needles driven by the same air supply is maintaining the identical pressure drop in each needle . to handle this , we passed air from a high pressure high volume source through a fine needle valve , and then distributed this low pressure high volume air to each needle , independently , via a four - valve fish tank manifold . we also controlled the air to the air injection port with a fine needle valve . we began each trial by adjusting needle size and flow rate to form a stable , monodisperse foam flow throughout the hsc with bubble size @xmath3 . then we began passing air through the air injection port . small bubbles in the background flow inflated as they passed under the injection port , and these inflated bubbles formed a band of large bubbles flowing down the center of the hsc ( figs . [ raw ] , [ injection ] ) . we took images of this channel under 45 different conditions in which we manipulated three mechanical parameters : the distance between the plates ( 0.8 @xmath2 , 1.6 @xmath2 , and 2.4 @xmath2 ) , the background foam flow rate ( 0.5 @xmath4 to 3.5 @xmath4 ) , and the air injection rate ( 0 to 0.1 @xmath4 ) . for each of the 45 configurations we recorded movies using a 1024x1044 pixel ccd camera at the fastest rate the camera would shoot ( @xmath5 30 fps ) for 200 frames . we post - processed the images with matlab scripts to track individual bubbles and calculate bubble flux . although in the experiments we controlled the rate of bubble generation and air injection rate , we were not able to simultaneously measure these rates . however , the volume flow rate of air ( both to the bubble generator and the air injection port ) directly correspond to the volume flux of bubbles produced . we measured the areas ( @xmath6 ) and velocities ( @xmath7 ) of bubbles via image analysis , and then calculated the volume flux of bubbles @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the separation between the hsc plates.because the inflated bubbles formed band of relatively stable width , one bubble wide , these `` bubbles '' actually took the form of individual soap films spanning a channel between two regions of background flow . the velocity of the central band was always in the same direction as the background flow , and the speed was always equal to or greater than that of the background flow . as in cantat s experiments @xcite , below a threshold value of air injection , the central band moved in unison with the background flow ( i.e. at the same speed ) . above this threshold it moved faster . in this case , the single soap film separating large bubbles in the channel remained in contact with the soap films of the bubbles bounding the channel , though on average perpendicular to these films , as it moved along them ( see fig . [ raw ] and online movie ) . intermittently , a line of bubbles perpendicular to the flow would take the place of the single soap film , however , we do not consider this as part of the phenomenon we analyzed in this study . if we injected air still faster , we passed another threshold above which the channel became unstable and fingered into the background flow . due to the narrow width of our channel , we have not yet investigated this fingering . although it would be interesting to investigate , following cantat et al . , the orgin of the threshold behavior , our chief question was how the width of the channel is determined by the parameters we experimentally controlled : channel depth ( number of spacers ) , background foam flux ( bubble generation rate ) and channel bubble flux ( air injection rate ) , size of background bubbles , and the width of the hsc . our theoretical analysis suggested that the channel width was really only a function of the ratio of the two fluxes with a single fitting parameter , the ratio of film - film drag to film - glass drag . the control variables determine the volume flux of channel bubbles in a strictly geometric manner . but this flux can occur in a narrow , fast channel or a wide , slow one . we hypothesize that the system selects this width in some optimal way . we make the following simplifications : we model the drag force on an element of bubble wall as a linear response that arises independently from components of velocity proportional to and perpendicular to the element of bubble wall , and we model the bubbles in the foam as squares and rectangles with sides oriented parallel and perpendicular to the flow ( fig . [ cartoon ] ) . based on these assumption , which we elaborate in appendix a , we express the power dissipated by a soap film of length @xmath10 parallel and perpendicular to the direction of bubble flow as @xmath11 and @xmath12 respectively . to calculate the power dissipated by the background flow , we consider a block of width @xmath13 of small background flow bubbles , where @xmath14 is the width of the channel bubbles . the height of the flow on either side of the channel is @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the number of bubbles . each small bubble contributes one parallel and one perpendicular film . considering the drag these generate , we write @xmath17 for the power dissipated by this block of bubbles . the power dissipated by a large bubble is the power dissipated by the motion of a single soap film which is perpendicular the flow . the height of the soap film is @xmath18 , it moves at a velocity @xmath19 , and has a depth @xmath9 , which is the distance between the plates . the drag generated by contact with the glass plates dissipates a power @xmath20 while the drag generated by the relative motion of this film against the bubbles bounding the channel is @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the drag coefficient ( per unit length ) for one soap film moving across another such as at the interface where a film separating channel bubbles meets the idealized continuous film that defines the central channel . the power flux is the power dissipated per unit distance along the hsc . we calculate this by dividing the total power by the width @xmath14 of our hypothetical block . combining equations [ backgroundblock],[pchannel1 ] , [ prelative ] and making the associations @xmath23 , @xmath24 and @xmath25 , we express the power flux as @xmath26 since we experimentally control fluxes , not velocities , we express the power dissipation in terms of fluxes . the fluxes of small bubble flow and large bubble flow are @xmath27 and @xmath28 respectively . the large bubble width @xmath14 arises from two factors : how much the area of a small bubble fills due to injection , and the selected height of the channel , @xmath29 . let the air be injected at a rate @xmath30 . if the background flow of small bubbles is moving at a velocity @xmath31 , then a small bubble of diameter @xmath10 spends about @xmath32 time units crossing the injection port . in doing so , it expands to an area @xmath33 . the flux of single small bubbles under the air injection point is @xmath34 . the total flux of channel bubbles is the sum of the flux of single small bubbles under the air injection point and the flux of injected air , i.e @xmath35 . thus , @xmath36 . putting this in equation ( [ pflux ] ) yields an expression for the dissipated power flux in terms of only the experimental control parameters ( @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath39 , and @xmath9 ) , the friction , and the undetermined value of @xmath29 : @xmath40 we assume that the system selects the channel height @xmath29 in order to minimize this function . setting @xmath41 and using the dimensionless parameters @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 , and @xmath45 , we obtain the solution @xmath46 where @xmath47 and @xmath48 . we fit the experimental data to equation [ solution ] using least squares and obtained the value @xmath49 ( fig . [ graph ] ) . we can conclude two things from the success of our model . first , the assumption that the system optimizes the channel width to minimize the dissipation is valid . second , the film - film drag is much weaker than the film - glass drag . one aspect of our analysis that lends confidence to this assertion is that our fit substantially improves when we scale the film - film drag by the length of the interface , i.e. @xmath9 . that the film - glass drag should be larger seems reasonable since the fluid in the glass lubrication layer has a no - slip boundary condition at the glass surface , while a soap film is free to flow . we know of no theoretical calculation or other experiment to which we can compare our observation of the film - glass drag being two orders of magnitude larger than the film - film drag . the drag on films parallel and perpendicular to the flow only enters equation [ solution ] as the sum @xmath50 . our success in modeling the results from this experiment suggests that future experiments could similarly measure relative drag on films parallel and perpendicular to the flow . we have observed that injecting air into a steady background flow in a two dimensional foam can generate a stable shear band when the rate of injection is neither too low ( in which case a band forms but moves in consort with the background foam ) nor too high ( in which case the shear band becomes unstable ) . we have observed that , for given experimental conditions , the channel chooses a unique height to minimze drag dissipation . we have formulated a simplified theory based on this hypothesis which appears to adequately explain the relationship . our theory contains a single fitting parameter which expresses the ratio of the drag coefficient of soap film motion against the glass plates to the drag coefficient for soap film motion against another soap film : @xmath51 . rebecca perry participated in this project as an nsf funded reu student at indiana university during the summer of 2006 . perry received her b.s . from bowdoin college in may , 2007 the analysis of the flow field in a soap film which moves while in contact with the surfactant layer coating a sheet of glass is the subject of lubrication theory , and has been studied in depth @xcite . well verified theory shows that the drag force should scale as the velocity to the 2/3 power . however , to first order , reasonable agreement with experiments can often be obtained by assuming the force scales linearly with velocity @xcite . evidently , for small values of the capillary number ( in our case , @xmath52 ) , the difference is not significant . therefore , for mathematical simplicity , we use the linear relationship . since the drag force actually depends on fluid flow at the interface between the soap film and the lubrication layer on the glass , lubrication theory also predicts that the drag will depend on the orientation of this interface to the direction of motion . in `` viscous froth '' simulations of two dimensional foam flow , cantat et al . only applied viscous drag to the motion of soap films normal to the film @xcite . we extend this by assuming that we can decompose the drag for an interface with arbitrary orientation into components parallel and perpendicular to the soap film . therefore , we express the force per unit length of soap film as@xmath53 \vec v$ ] . this unit length of soap film dissipates power equal to @xmath54 . , the volume of bubbles passing through a slice of the hsc per unit time , by measuring the area ( @xmath6 ) and velocity ( @xmath7 ) of the bubbles . when the separation between the hsc plates is @xmath9 , the flux is @xmath8 . , width=312 ] versus the normalized bubble flux @xmath55 . ( see fig . [ cartoon ] for nomenclature ) . the theoretical model developed using fig . [ cartoon ] leads to the mathematical relationship between @xmath56 and @xmath57 expressed in [ solution ] . adjusting the single fitting parameter @xmath58 provides a good fit with @xmath49.,width=312 ]

we have generated a novel form of shear banding in a 2d foam and measured the relative magnitude of drag forces on soap films at different lubrication layers . we injected air part way along a flowing bubble field in a narrow hele - shaw cell . the injected air inflates bubbles as they flow by , and these bubbles form a shear band down the middle of the hele - shaw cell . this channel appears to select a height that minimizes the total dissipation . fitting data to a simple theoretical model , we show that the drag force on a soap film in contact with the wetting layer on a plate of glass is two orders of magnitude larger than the drag on a soap film in contact with another free soap film .

1006.3734

the calice ( _ _ * cal*__orimeter for a _ _ * li*__near _ _ * c*__ollider _ _ * e*__xperiment ) collaboration performed tests of new calorimeter technologies for the planned international linear collider ( ilc ) . several prototypes were investigated during the testbeam phase at desy ( 2006 ) , cern ( 2006 & 2007 ) and fnal ( 2008 & 2009 ) . the analog hadron calorimeter ( ahcal , @xcite ) has been successfully used in all five test - beams . it is a sampling calorimeter with a size of @xmath0 with 38 layers using 2 cm of steel as absorbing material , resulting in a depth of approximately @xmath1 ( @xmath2 for pions ) . the active layers have a very granular structure , using scintillator tiles from @xmath3 up to @xmath4 . each scintillator tile is read out with a silicon photomultiplier . r0.5 this granular structure allows for identification of tracks generated by minimum ionizing particles ( mip ) passing through ( parts of ) the detector . this capability is an excellent tool for detector calibration@xcite and provides the possibility for detailed studies of the shower substructure . this article presents an algorithm for the identification of mip - like track segments within hadronic showers ( see section [ sec : tracking ] ) . a few examples of identified mip tracks are displayed in figure [ fig : typicalevent ] . as one can see , the tracks provide information on the 3d substructure of hadronic showers . this information is used for confronting monte carlo simulations with data ( section [ sec : mcdata ] ) . to provide a clean sample of tracks by minimum ionizing particles in the environment of a hadronic shower , which includes regions of high local particle density , specific selections criteria for the calorimeter cells used by the tracking algorithm are necessary . a sample of the detector cells very likely being traversed only by a single particle is selected by imposing an isolation criterion , illustrated in figure [ fig : isolationcriterion ] . a hit is called isolated if there is no direct neighbour cell with a hit within the same layer . the tracking algorithm will only use hits fulfilling this criterion . as there is no magnetic field in the calice experiment , the presented algorithm was optimized for finding straight tracks . the tracking algorithm used for identification of single particle tracks is a local search method working layer by layer . a track is followed from the beginning to the end . the algorithm has the following steps : 1 . search for isolated hits in all layers using the introduced isolation criterion . a cell is called hit if the energy deposited exceeds @xmath5mip . a mip is defined as the most probable energy deposition of a single passing minimum ionizing particle . 2 . use the isolated hits as start point ( seed ) , starting from the first layer in beam direction . for each of these points : 1 . increment by one layer in beam direction and search for unused isolated hits that can continue the current track . the search window is @xmath6 cells in @xmath7 and @xmath8 ( when @xmath9 is beam axis ) , resulting in 9 checked cells . for a 1d illustration see figure [ fig : trackingalgorithm ] . 2 . repeat last step until the end of the detector is reached or no continuation hit can be found . the algorithm allows for gaps , i.e. maximum one consecutive layer with no hit . 3 . once the track is completed , start over with the remaining isolated hits in the detector to find more tracks . as the algorithm works layer - wise for each track there is a maximum of one hit per layer . with the isolation criterion it is then very likely that the found track was generated by a single particle . the characteristics of mip - like tracks reflects the spatial structure of hadronic showers . by comparing to simulation the shower modeling provided by the different physics lists can be validated . here , the two following parameters were chosen : track angle and track length . the comparison was done using these physics lists from mokka / geant4@xcite : + ` qgsp_bert ` , ` qgsp_bert_trv ` , ` qgs_bic ` , ` lhep ` , ` ftf_bic ` , ` ftfp_bert ` the comparison of the actual distribution is done for @xmath10 data at an energy of @xmath11gev . for energies in the range from @xmath12gev up to @xmath13gev the mean value was used for comparison . the track angle is sensitive to the scattering angle of secondary particles created in hadronic showers and hence the shower structure . the comparison for the angle distribution of the tracks is shown in figure [ fig : mcdata:25gev : trackangle ] for @xmath11gev . the distribution shows many tracks at angles @xmath14 lower than @xmath15 ( @xmath16 of all tracks ) . as in every event the incident particle is not inclined , the initial track of the incoming particle is major contributor to those at low angles . if we go to higher angles , the number of tracks found decreases until it vanishes for @xmath17 . this is not necessarily due to the shower shape but the incapability of the used algorithm to identify tracks at very large angles . all physics lists considered with the exception of ` lhep ` and ` qgs_bic ` provide an angular distribution of tracks that is similar to the one observed in data . the tracks produced by ` lhep ` and ` qgs_bic ` have too low average angles . this can be seen as well when comparing the mean value for the complete energy range shown in figure [ fig : mcdata : all : trackangle ] . ` lhep ` is significantly below the data over the whole energy range , while ` qgs_bic ` performs better but is still too low . the remaining physics lists are again quite close together and reproduce the result from data better , while they all tend to produce tracks at lower angles than testbeam data , especially for higher energies . + the track length gives the distance a particle travels before participating in a hadronic interaction , in units of ahcal layers : @xmath18 the slope of the distribution is sensitive to high energy cross sections , especially for secondary particles created in or after the first hadronic interaction . the results of the comparison can be seen in fig . [ fig : mcdata : tracklength ] . for the mean value for all energies ( figure [ fig : mcdata : all : tracklength ] ) the physics lists all show good agreement with the testbeam data . especially for energies higher than @xmath19gev the difference between simulation and test beam data is at the order of 1% , with a slight tendency towards longer tracks in the simulation . noise hits can influence the isolation criterion which can lead to tracks being aborted early . if the amount of noise is not added correctly during the digitization phase of the simulated data , this will lead to a constant offset between all physics lists and the testbeam data . the track length for the @xmath11gev run in figure [ fig : mcdata:25gev : tracklength ] shows the exponential fall - off expected from the hadronic interaction of particles passing through matter . the peak at @xmath20layers is coming from punch through hadrons and from muons coming from @xmath21 decays . the amount of muons and punch - through pions is well reproduced by the simulation . to be able to study tracks coming from the incoming beam particle ( `` primary '' tracks ) and tracks being created in hadronic interaction ( `` secondary '' tracks ) individually , the histogram from figure [ fig : mcdata:25gev : tracklength ] is split into two : for the primary tracks a histogram containing only tracks starting in layer 1 or 2 ( figure [ fig : mcdata:25gev : tracklengthfirstlayer ] ) and for the secondary tracks a histogram containing tracks starting in layer 3 or later . the histogram containing the secondary tracks can be seen in figure [ fig : mcdata:25gev : tracklengthafterfirstlayer ] . those tracks are created mainly by secondary particles coming from the shower core and hence is sensitive to the correct modeling of high energy cross sections within the physics list . here the difference between testbeam data and simulation is below 10% , with the simulation producing less shorter tracks , but on average all physics lists produce tracks that are longer than the ones from testbeam data , which can be seen as well in figure [ fig : mcdata : all : tracklength ] . the fluctuations at the end are due to insufficient statistics ( compare with statistical error indicated by the gray area , here shown for the ` lhep ` physics list ) . the exponential decrease is reproduced well by all physics lists , demonstrating a good description of the cross sections in the models . the punch - through particles can be seen as well in figure [ fig : mcdata:25gev : tracklengthfirstlayer ] showing the primary tracks . all physics lists recreate the peak around the full detector length of @xmath20layers . this indicates a good understanding of the simulation of the beamline , including the decay of pions to muons and the trigger . the exponential fall is interrupted for track lengths around 28 - 30 layers . this is due to the change in the geometry of the ahcal from fine to coarse after the first 30 layers . two particles resolved in the fine granularity might become unresolved and give non - isolated hits , therefore ending the track . hence many tracks will stop in layer 30 , leading to the observed length distribution for tracks starting at the front face of the ahcal . this discontinuity in track length can be seen both for testbeam data as well as for all simulations . however , the discontinuity is more pronounced in all considered physics lists compared to testbeam data , indicating potential problems in the digitization , i.e. in the simulation of the optical crosstalk which might differ for different tile sizes and hence creates a different number of fake hits , changing the number of isolated hits . a simple tracking algorithm has been developed that is capable of identifying tracks created by minimum ionizing particles in hadronic showers . the algorithm relies on isolated hits and works on a layer - by - layer basis . the intrinsic track properties track angle and track length are used as parameters in a comparison between testbeam data and simulations created with various physics lists . for the given data the four physics lists ` qgsp_bert ` , ` qgsp_bert_trv ` , ` ftf_bic ` and ` ftfp_bert ` all give results that are close together and comparable to testbeam data , with a slight advantage in favor of the ` qgsp_bert(_trv ) ` lists .

using the high granular calice analog hadron calorimeter ( ahcal ) a tracking algorithm capable of identifying mip - like tracks within hadronic showers is presented . such an algorithm provides excellent tools for detector calibration and for studies of the substructure of hadronic showers . the properties of the identified tracks are used as observables for a monte - carlo to data comparison .

astro-ph0508423

the distribution of stellar metallicities in the halo of the galaxy has been intensively studied for many years , especially since it was recognized in the early 1980 s that the halo contains field stars with [ fe / h ] lower than that of the lowest metallicity globular clusters . the central difficulty of this enterprise is that low - metallicity stars , especially those with [ fe / h ] @xmath1 , are extremely rare in the solar neighborhood , comprising no more than @xmath2% of the stars within a few kpc of the sun . as a direct consequence , knowledge of the form of the metallicity distribution function ( mdf ) , in particular the shape of its low - metallicity tail , has long been limited by small - number statistics . the difficulty of isolating a `` fair '' sample of halo stars based on in - situ studies has left astronomers with little choice but to identify likely halo stars based on their motions . spectroscopic follow - up of stars selected from proper - motion surveys has allowed the determination of at least a reasonably accurate picture of the global shape of the halo mdf . the studies of ryan & norris ( 1991 ) and carney et al . ( 1996 ) were able to demonstrate that the mdf of halo stars peaks at a metallicity [ fe / h ] @xmath3 , including tails extending up to the solar metallicity on the high side , and to metallicities at least down to [ fe / h ] = @xmath4 , or slightly below , on the low side . both suggested mdfs are consistent with one another , and with the predictions of the so - called `` simple model '' ( e.g. hartwick 1976 ) . the actual shape of the mdf at the lowest metallicities , and its precise cutoff , is limited by the small numbers of stars in these samples . even taken together , these surveys only include some 250 very metal - poor stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath5 , and but a handful with [ fe / h ] @xmath6 . recent kinematically unbiased surveys for metal - poor stars have revealed the presence of at least two hyper metal - poor ( hmp ) stars , with [ fe / h ] @xmath7 ( christlieb et al . 2002 ; frebel et al . the presence of these two stars raise several additional questions concerning the nature of the mdf , including : * what is the shape of the low - metallicity tail of the halo mdf , and in particular , is it continuous ? * does there exist a sharp cutoff of the halo mdf , and if so , at what metallicity does it occur ? * is the halo mdf constant throughout the halo , or does it vary with distance ? the answers to these , and other questions about the nature of the halo mdf , can only be obtained from much larger samples of very metal - poor stars , ideally chosen in - situ in the halo of the galaxy , well outside the solar neighborhood . fortunately , due to the collective efforts of many of the astronomers present at this conference , we have arrived at the point where the results of the large - scale objective prism surveys ( the hk survey of beers and colleagues ; beers et al . 1985 , 1992 , beers 1999 , and the he s of christlieb and colleagues ; christlieb 2003 ) can now begin to shed light on at least some of these questions . below we summarize the present picture of the low - metallicity tail of the halo mdf as obtained by these two efforts . we then consider the information provided by the large numbers of very metal - poor stars contained in the most - recent public data release of the sloan digital sky survey ( york et al . 2000 ) , and its planned extension , sdss - ii , which includes the segue program . the hk survey ( formerly known as the preston - shectman survey ) was initiated over 25 years ago . during the course of the survey , a total of some 300 objective - prism plates covering 2800 deg@xmath8 in the northern hemisphere and 4100 deg@xmath8 in the southern hemisphere were obtained . the selection of candidate metal - poor stars was accomplished based on visual inspection with a binocular 10 x microscope . since the visual inspection was performed without the benefit of the stellar colors ( hence temperatures ) it was expected that the hk - survey candidates would carry a rather severe temperature - related bias . the potential bias becomes less of a problem at the lowest metallicities , below [ fe / h ] @xmath9 , where the caii k lines of even quite cool stars are difficult to detect at the resolution of the survey . medium - resolution ( 1 - 2 ) spectroscopic and broadband photometric follow - up of candidate metal - poor stars from the hk survey has been underway for two decades . for the majority of this period , the spectroscopic follow - up was conducted with single - slit spectroscopy using 1.5m-2.5 m telescopes at a variety of observatories . most recently , the use of the 6df multiplexed spectrograph on the uk schmidt telescope made it possible to obtain more than one hundred such spectra simultaneously , hence the pace of this effort was sped up considerably . table 1 lists the total number of spectra of hk survey candidates ( including large numbers of field horizontal - branch and other a - type stars in addition to the metal - poor candidates ) obtained to date . this table also lists the numbers of hk survey stars with available spectroscopy that have had optical broadband photometry ( primarily @xmath10 ) measured thus far . near - ir @xmath11 from the 2mass point source catalog ( cutri et al . 2003 ) is also available for over 90% of the hk - survey stars with available spectroscopy . the he s objective - prism survey provides the opportunity to greatly increase the number of very metal - poor stars identified by the hk survey . it reaches about two magnitudes deeper than the hk survey ( @xmath12 vs. @xmath13 ) and also covers regions of the southern sky not sampled by the hk survey ; a total of about 8225 deg@xmath8 of the sky above @xmath14 is presently available from the he s . another 1275 deg@xmath8 covered by the he s is now being scanned and analyzed for candidates . the selection of metal - poor candidates from the he s database of digital objective - prism spectra is performed using quantitative criteria including automatic spectral classification ( christlieb , wisotzki , & grasshoff 2002 ) . the strength of the caii k line is determined using the @xmath15 line index ( beers et al . 1999 ) , as measured directly from the objective - prism spectra . due to the broad wavelength range covered by the he s spectra it is also possible to determine @xmath16 directly from the prism spectra , with an accuracy on the order of @xmath2 mag . stars that have caii k lines weaker than expected for their estimated @xmath16 colors and an approximate metallicity of [ fe / h ] @xmath17 are selected as low - metallicity candidates . medium - resolution spectroscopic follow - up of candidate metal - poor stars from the he s has been underway for the past five years , primarily with 2.5m-4 m class telescopes . the use of larger telescopes and substantially more efficient spectrographs than were available for much of the hk survey follow - up results in a much faster assembly of this information . the he s has also benefitted from multiplex follow - up with the 6df instrument . table 1 summarizes the numbers of he s targets ( including stars other than metal - poor candidates ) with available medium - resolution spectroscopy obtained to date . broadband optical photometry ( primarily @xmath18 ) is only now being obtained for the metal - poor he s candidates ( beers et al . , in preparation ) ; about 80% of the stars with available spectroscopy have @xmath11 from 2mass . all of the sdss stars discussed below have available @xmath19 photometry . .[tab : observations ] observational follow - up of surveys [ cols="<,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] many astronomers may not be aware that the publicly available medium - resolution ( 2.5 ) spectroscopy and @xmath19 photometry from the sdss includes substantial numbers of stars in the milky way . at present , through the dr3 release , these total over 70,000 stars . analysis pipelines have been developed ( and are presently being refined ) , and value added catalogs that summarize best estimates of atmospheric parameters ( t@xmath20 , log g , [ fe / h ] ) , as well as radial velocities , distance estimates , and proper motions , are now being assembled ( beers et al . 2004 ) . by the time the final data from the main sdss are released ( presently anticipated to be june 2006 ) , the number of stars with similar data should be well over 100,000 . most stars contained in the sdss database were not targeted specifically to be metal - poor halo objects , and indeed they represent a complex assembly of objects selected for calibration and reddening determinations , directed studies of various classes of stars ( e.g. horizontal - branch stars , carbon stars , white dwarfs , late - type k and m dwarfs , etc ) , as well as objects originally targeted as quasars that turned out to be stars . in spite of its rather inhomogeneous assembly , the sdss stellar database does provide a useful means for sampling the tail of the halo mdf ( though one of course must be open to the issues of selection bias ) . the abundance calibration of beers et al . ( 1999 ) is used to obtain estimates of [ fe / h ] for the hk and he s stars . this method relies on the variation of the caii @xmath15 index with @xmath21 color as a function of [ fe / h ] . this approach works well , obtaining abundance errors on the order of @xmath22 dex over the color range @xmath23 and for stars with abundances @xmath24 } \le -0.5 $ ] . near the red end of the color range , and near the high - metallicity end as well , saturation of the caii k lines becomes more of an issue ; at these extremes this method tends to underestimate the true metallicity of a given star . at the very lowest metallicities , below [ fe / h]@xmath25 , the approach could _ over_-estimate the true metallicity , as a result of contamination of the caii k line by interstellar caii , or by molecular carbon features in the spectra of carbon - enhanced metal - poor stars . in fact , both of these situations arose in the cases of the medium - resolution discovery spectra of the two known hmp stars he 0107 - 5240 and he 1327 - 2326 . not all of the hk / hes objects have available @xmath21 colors at present . thus , we have developed techniques that can be used to estimate this color , based on a calibration of the strength of the balmer h@xmath26 line . previous tests indicate that the colors estimated in this manner should be good to on the order of about 0.03 mags over the range @xmath27 . for cooler stars the rapidly declining strength of the h@xmath26 line with increasing @xmath21 renders the technique less useful . we are fortunate that many of the stars in the hk / hes surveys have 2mass @xmath11 available . this information is particularly useful for the redder stars that lack @xmath16 photometry , as a newly designed calibration based on @xmath15 and @xmath28 has been developed in order to provide estimates of [ fe / h ] for such stars . new methods have been developed for the estimation of metallicities ( and other atmospheric parameters ) for stars in the sdss spectroscopic database ( allende prieto et al . 2004 , 2005 ) , and are used in combination with the beers et al . ( 1999 ) and wilhelm , beers , & gray ( 1999 ) approaches in order to obtain estimates of [ fe / h ] that are accurate to on the order of 0.20 to 0.25 dex over the temperature range 4,000 k @xmath29 10000 k. carbon - enhanced metal - poor ( cemp ) stars , which are identified with large frequency in all three surveys , present special challenges because their optical colors can be confounded by the presence of molecular carbon features . a new calibration , based on the @xmath15 and @xmath30 indices and @xmath28 , directly tied to stars with a range of ( externally known ) [ fe / h ] and carbon abundances , has been developed by rossi et al . ( 2005 ) , and is used to estimate [ fe / h ] and [ c / fe ] for such stars . figure 1 ( left panel ) shows the distribution of [ fe / h ] for some 6000 stars from the hk survey that have measured @xmath21 or inferred colors that fall in the range where our adopted calibrations can be applied . note that the distinctly bi - modal character of this distribution is simply the result of the imperfect selection of candidate low - metallicity targets ; the large number of stars with [ fe / h @xmath31 are the `` mistakes '' . the 1200 stars with metallicities [ fe / h ] @xmath5 are the sought - after objects . figure 1 ( right panel ) shows a similar plot for the he s stars . although the total number of targets is only about half of the hk survey stars , the far higher efficiency of the he s in the identification of very metal - poor stars has greatly reduced the number of mistakes with [ fe / h ] @xmath32 . as a result , the total number of he s stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath5 exceeds that of the hk survey by some 300 stars . there are almost twice as many [ fe / h ] @xmath33 stars found in the he s as have been identified in the hk survey . the combined samples of stars from the hk and he s includes some 2700 stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath5 and almost 400 stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath34 . note that we have not yet eliminated the hk - survey stars that were rediscovered by the he s . hence , these numbers will be reduced somewhat in the final tally . there are two issues that need to be resolved before we can use the results of these two surveys to place strong constraints on the shape of the low metallicity tail of the halo mdf . clearly , owing to the manner in which the surveys were constructed ( to find the lowest metallicity stars ) , a bias is introduced as metallicity rises above [ fe / h ] @xmath35 . our plan to correct for this is to compare the shapes of the mdfs for stars in the range @xmath36 } \le -2.0 $ ] with those of the kinematically - based surveys discussed earlier , and derive a `` bias correction factor '' that can by applied to the numbers of stars in this interval to account for the fraction lost by the selection of candidates . a similar exercise was performed for the hk survey stars by beers et al . ( 1998 ) , who showed that the hk survey results available at that time appeared to become biased above [ fe / h ] @xmath37 . the second issue involves performing a careful check on the abundance estimates for the many cemp stars that are found at low metallicity in both surveys . experience has shown that it is possible to underestimate the metallicity of the cooler , or more carbon - enhanced stars , even when making use of the new techniques of rossi et al . we therefore have to evaluate such stars on a spectrum - by - spectrum basis , and either remove them or correct their abundances . figure 2 shows the low - metallicity tail of the combined hk and he s mdfs , which ( for now ) provides us with our best representation of the shape of this function . because of worries concerning the derived [ fe / h ] for the cemp stars noted above , we show two versions of the combined mdf . the left panel is the complete set of stars . the right panel is the same distribution , but with the stars with estimated [ c / fe ] @xmath38 removed . two features are evident in these diagrams . ( 1 ) the low - metallicity cutoff appears at [ fe / h]@xmath25 , although the small numbers of stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath39 still make the actual location of the cutoff somewhat uncertain . the other feature is the possibility of a small `` bump '' in the mdf at around [ fe / h ] @xmath35 . in order to be certain about the presence of this bump , one would ideally like to obtain higher quality medium - resolution spectra ( and photometry where needed ) of the hk / hes stars with metallicities [ fe / h ] @xmath1 , using a single telescope / detector combination and consistent s / n targets . now that we know which stars to point at , and with the use of high - efficiency modern spectrographs on 4m - class telescopes , this should indeed be feasible on a reasonably short time scale . note as well that , due to the increase in the numbers of low - metallicity stars discovered over the course of the hk / hes surveys that have now been studied at high spectroscopic resolution , we have at our disposal a much larger set of objects with which one could obtain an improved calibration of the metallicity - estimation procedures employed in the original survey effort . by the time of publication of this volume , we will be almost one - third of the way through the next great expansion of the observational database of the lowest - metallicity stars in the galaxy . the survey effort , known as segue , will employ the same telescope ( the arc 2.5 m telescope on apache point , new mexico ) , imager , spectrographs , and reduction pipeline as the original sdss , to dramatically increase our knowledge of the stellar populations of the milky way . segue , which begins in july 2005 and will end in july 2008 , will obtain some 3500 additional square degrees of calibrated @xmath19 photometry at lower galactic latitude than the original sdss , so as to better constrain the important transition from the disk population(s ) to the halo . most importantly , segue will obtain medium - resolution spectroscopy for 250,000 stars in the magnitude range @xmath40 , in 200 directions covering the sky available from apache point . segue targets will be chosen to explore the galaxy at distances from 0.5 to 100 kpc from the sun . one of the primary segue categories is obtained from photometric pre - selection of likely very metal - poor ( vmp ) stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath1 . tests carried out to date indicate that it is reasonable to expect that segue will yield a sample of at least 25,000 vmp stars , a factor of ten times the present number of such stars known from the summed hk and he s efforts . although the majority of these vmp stars will be too faint for easy high - resolution spectroscopic follow - up on 8m-10 m class telescopes , there will be at least several thousand that _ are _ sufficiently bright . plans are presently being made to undertake heres - like `` snapshot '' high - resolution spectroscopy ( see christlieb et al . 2004 , barklem et al . 2005 , and contributions from these authors in this volume ) with the hobby - eberly telescope , followed by higher s / n studies of the most interesting objects that are revealed . we can obtain a preview of the halo mdf that will be revealed by segue from inspection of the distribution of metallicities for stars that have been observed ( in a highly heterogeneous manner ) during the course of the original sdss allende prieto et al . ( 2005 ) have produced an `` as observed '' mdf for the subset of sdss stars in dr-3 with derived temperatures between 5000 k and 7000 k , where the abundance determination techniques developed for segue are expected to work best . figure 3(a ) shows the distribution of height above the galactic plane as a function of estimated [ fe / h ] for over 20,000 stars that fall in this temperature interval . figure 3(b ) shows the mdfs for two sub - samples of these stars , those with a distance from the galactic plane @xmath41 kpc ( 14714 stars ; solid histogram ) and those with @xmath42 kpc ( 2655 stars ; dashed histogram ) . the nearby cut in @xmath43 distance comprises a mix of halo and thick - disk stars , while the more distant sample should be essentially all halo stars . it is remarkable how well the as - observed mdf of the sdss dr-3 halo sample mimics our expectation of what a `` fair '' sample of the halo mdf should look like , though we re - emphasize that , owing to the peculiar selection of targets , this sample should not be construed as such . there may be a few stars in dr-3 with metallicities below [ fe / h ] = @xmath44 , but these objects will have to be confirmed with high - resolution spectroscopy before a firm claim can be made as to their existence . note that , as part of the segue target selection , there will be a very large ( @xmath45 ) number of g - type dwarfs covering the distance range from a few kpc out to 10 - 12 kpc from the sun , and which are chosen in a `` metallicity blind '' fashion . this sample will provide the opportunity not only to construct an in - situ sample of stars from which a fair mdf of the halo can be obtained , but also will enable determination of the fraction of vmp stars in the solar neighborhood contributed by the metal - weak thick - disk population ( see , e.g. chiba & beers 2000 ; beers et al . clearly , the study of the mdf of the halo has entered a new era . the prodigious samples of halo stars that now exist from the hk survey , the he s , the sdss , and those that will be identified in the soon to - be - executed segue survey are finally producing sufficiently large numbers of objects to address the questions raised above , as well as to ( no doubt ) raise many new ones . now is the time to develop plans for the high - resolution spectroscopic follow - up of the many thousands of segue stars that will soon become available . t.c.b . and y.l . acknowledge support from grants ast 00 - 98508 , ast 00 - 98549 , ast 04 - 06784 , and phy 02 - 16783 , physics frontier centers / jina : joint institute for nuclear astrophysics , awarded by the us national science foundation . n.c . acknowledges financial support through a henri chretien international research grant administered by the american astronomical society , and from the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft under grants ch 214/3 and re 353/44 . j.e.n . and m.s.b . acknowledge support from grant dp0342613 awarded by the australian research council . c.a.p . acknowledges support from nasa grants nag5 - 13057 and nag5 - 13147 . c.r . acknowledges financial support from nasa grant hst - hf-01143.01-a . acknowledges funding from the research corporation and from ast 03 - 07571 , awarded by the us national science foundation . thanks the brasilian institutes fapesp and cnpq for financial support . allende prieto , c. et al . 2004 , in _ origin and evolution of the elements , carnegie observatories astrophysics series _ , eds a. mcwilliam & m. rauch ( cambridge univ . press : cambridge ) , ( astro - ph/0304352 )

we report on the distribution of metallicities , [ fe / h ] , for very metal - poor stars in the halo of the galaxy . although the primary information on the nature of the metallicity distribution function ( mdf ) is obtained from the two major recent surveys for metal - poor stars , the hk survey of beers and collaborators , and the hamburg / eso survey of christlieb and collaborators , we also discuss the mdf derived from the publicly available database of stellar spectra and photometry contained in the third data release of the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss dr-3 ) . even though the sdss was not originally planned as a stellar survey , significant numbers of stars have been observed to date dr-3 contains spectroscopy for over 70,000 stars , at least half of which are suitable for abundance determinations . there are as many very metal - poor ( [ fe / h ] @xmath0 ) stars in dr-3 as have been obtained from all previous survey efforts combined . we also discuss prospects for significant expansion of the list of metal - poor stars to be obtained from the recently funded extension of the sdss , which includes the project segue : sloan extension for galactic understanding and exploration .

1009.4609

there is a significant interest in constructing simple stochastic models with avalanches reflecting properties of various natural phenomena , but only part of them have the advantage of being solvable . one way to make models analytically tractable is to use the mean - field approximation . however , requirements of exact results can force further simplifications in a model . for example , in terms of self - organized criticality , in spite of the fact that the mean field theory of such critical phenomena was already proposed @xcite , dhar made further simplifications for distinguished btw model @xcite ( a unified view of mean - field picture of stochastic self - organized critical models is presented in @xcite ) . we point out also that considering structure of abelian algebras leads to analytical results in some sand - pile and related stochastic models @xcite . solvable simple models can also be constructed in the field of directed percolation ; for an extremely simple one , see @xcite . another way towards solvability is to consider stochastic properties as non - essential and study deterministic models ; see such an approach for sand - pile in @xcite . in the context of deterministic cellular automata , an analytic approach related to solvability is investigated as part of the theory of integrable systems and may employ sophisticated methods . we underline that construction of integrable cellular automata is definitely not an easy task . our aim here is to follow the ideas of analytic approach and apply them to construction of _ stochastic _ automata . in the article we propose and analyse in a direct elementary way the random domino automaton ( rda ) - a new slowly driven systems exhibiting avalanche phenomena . we prefer here an elementary self - contained approach to the description of the automaton and we make no use of applicable markov processes terminology . we stress here , all results , except of equation ( see @xcite for details ) , have elementary derivation in the text below . on the other hand , in spite of its simple formulation and being analytically tractable , automaton covers wide range of behaviours depending on the choice of the parameters . the application of the rda model for studying ito equation is investigated in our parallel papers @xcite . an inspiration for defining the rule for the domino automaton comes from very simplified view of earthquakes . it corresponds to two tectonic plates moving with relative constant velocity . the wedge may be irregularly rough , and relative motion can be locked in some places , producing stress accumulation . beyond some threshold of stress , a relaxation took place . the size of relaxation depends on the nearby accumulated stress . rda is inspired by earthquakes ; however , a direct reproducing of realistic - like behaviour of such complicated phenomena is obviously beyond its scope in the present form . nevertheless , construction and analysis of models is one of primary aims in geosciences @xcite . there are many very simplified cellular automata models focusing on specific features of the investigated behaviour in the field . here we point out a sequence of papers @xcite , where some interesting cellular automata models were presented . finally , as an unexpected property we mention an interesting link between stochastic cellular automata and integer sequences ( see @xcite or the on - line encyclopedia of integer sequences ) . it is known , how to obtain catalan numbers out of the bond directed percolation on a square lattice @xcite . our cellular automaton in specific case leads to motzkin numbers ( for details see @xcite ) . plan of the article is as follows . in section [ sec : autdef ] we introduce a definition of random domino automaton with rebound parameters . section [ sec : eqs ] contains full combinatorial derivation of equations for the distribution of clusters , which describes stationary state of the automaton . several exact formulas - balance relations , average size of clusters and avalanche , general formula for all moments - are displayed . we finish with introducing special form of rebound parameters , which leads to two distinguished special cases studied in details in next section [ sec : speccases ] . these cases correspond to exponential and inverse - power distributions as shown below . the obtained analytical results are compared with simulations . section [ sec : concl ] gives a resume of results presented in the article as well as directions for future work . appendix [ app : empty_cl_derv ] contains derivation of complementary set of equations , describing empty clusters of the automaton . in the random domino automaton model , the space consists of discrete number @xmath0 of cells on a line , and we assume periodic boundary conditions . each cell may be in one of two states : empty state , when it is empty , or occupied state , when contains a ball . the evolution of the automaton is given by the following update procedure performed in each discrete time step . a ball is added to the system to the randomly chosen cell and we assume each cell to be equally possible . if the chosen cell is empty , there are two possibilities : it becomes occupied with probability @xmath1 or the ball is rebounded with probability @xmath2 leaving the state of the automaton unchanged . if the chosen place is already occupied , there are also two possibilities : the ball is rebounded with probability @xmath3 or with probability @xmath4 the incoming ball triggers a relaxation . by relaxation we mean : balls from the chosen cell and from all its adjacent occupied cells are removed . thus , the relaxation produces an avalanche of size equal to the number of cells changing their state . then the update procedure repeats in the next time step . all possibilities are shown schematically on the diagram below . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] the average size of a cluster is the same as the average size of an avalanche , because any cluster , regardless of its size , has the same chance to become an avalanche . hence , both balance equations lead to the same result @xmath5 table [ tab : table2 ] contains values of average density and average cluster / avalanche size obtained from equations and simulation in an exemplary case where @xmath6 . the size of lattice is set to @xmath7 in order to avoid restrictions for size of avalanches , which are relatively bigger comparing to the previous case . a simple form of @xmath8 together with balance equations and alows to reduce the set of equations - to the solvable recurrence . the formulas for @xmath9s are rational functions of @xmath10 and @xmath0 only . the explicit form of solutions and relation to the motzkin numbers is presented in @xcite . figure [ fig : figb ] presents exact values of @xmath9s compared in log - log scale with the simulation result in the exemplary case described above . the slope of the distribution of @xmath9 approximates inverse - power distribution in the middle part of a range of sizes @xmath11 ; for bigger values of @xmath11 , values of @xmath9 decrease quicker . this property agrees with convergence of moments of @xmath9 we use above . for value of @xmath10 closer to @xmath12 the straight part of the plot extends for bigger values of @xmath11 . in the limit case @xmath13 , the distribution is given by the following power law @xcite @xmath14 we proposed and studied properties of simple stochastic cellular automaton with avalanches inspired by an extremely simplified model of earthquakes . the main goal was to construct a simple model with `` transparent '' mathematical structure , which would enable obtaining exact results yet covering a wide range of behaviours . the rule of the automaton allows to derive from the first principles ( using elementary combinatorics ) the set of equations describing the average values of the model parameters . these equations leads to equations for moments and to neat formulas for average cluster and avalanche sizes in terms of the zero and the first moments . after analysis of moment equations , we considered in detail two cases which differ by the form of parameter @xmath15 responsible for triggering of avalanches . we obtained exponential type and inverse - power type distributions of clusters within uniform framework . ( the distribution of avalanches @xmath16 is easily obtained from the formula @xmath17 . ) the quasi - equilibrium assumption seems to be justified by simulation results . the exponential case @xmath18 is not fully analytically solvable ; nevertheless , the closed set of equations leads to several exact relations . moreover , an approximate formula for @xmath9 was derived , and intimate relation to percolation was pointed out . hence , the proposed approach can be regarded as an extension of percolation approximation results , and can provide basis for exact treatment of other models . the automaton rule clearly states that there is a `` coupling '' between the adjacent cells , since the relaxations takes out the whole cluster , so treating cluster not cells as independent is a substantial improvement in the presented case . the case @xmath19 is fully solvable , and all variables are expressed as rational functions of ratio @xmath20 of rebound parameters only . the shape of the distribution of clusters @xmath9 approximate an inverse - power distribution in the various ranges of variable @xmath11 , depending on chosen parameters . in the limit case , distribution tends to @xmath21 . the critical density is equal to @xmath22 . the limit case of the presented automaton reduces the set of equations to the recurrence , which leads to known integer sequence - the motzkin numbers ( see @xcite ) . this result establishes a new , remarkable link between the combinatorial object and the stochastic cellular automaton . the first application of rda - related to ito equation - is already studied in our parallel papers @xcite . the model serves as a fully controlled stochastic `` phenomenon '' and an applicability of the reconstruction of the ito equation from generated time series was tested . due to its simplicity , it allows to derive exactly the suitable ito equation , and analytical results were compared with histogram method . the obtained results are part of broader studies of the privilege concept and its role for appearance of inverse - power distributions @xcite . the model posses also some properties which may be used in seeking of applications to natural phenomena and checking their adequacy . for example , in the context of earthquakes , the discrete nature of the model makes possible an adjustment of positions and sizes of cells to the geological structure of a fault . bending and shrinking of the 1-d grid have no influence on equations ; the only important feature is an order of cells . in this context , relations describing average size of cluster @xmath23 and avalanche @xmath24 may be interpreted as relations giving their dependence on the density of energy on the wedge . the model establishes one - to - one correspondence between distribution of avalanches ( i.e. observable quantity ) and respective parameter @xmath25 responsible for triggering avalanches , as it was illustrated in two cases considered above . we emphasize that the relation works in both directions . fixing rebound parameters leads to various distributions of avalanches , but also , for any distribution @xmath9 , one can easily find unique values of rebound parameters @xmath25 by simple use of the set of equations - . thus , within the proposed model , one can infer about triggering properties from `` observed '' statistics of avalanches . for an earthquake interpretation , it would give an insight into properties of microscopic mechanism of releasing energy on a fault on the basis of already collected data . last but not least , we propose few generalizations possibly leading towards more realistic extensions of the model . each element of the presented automaton - including the incidence rule - can be subjected to various modifications . to be more specific , one can consider different geometry of the array ( for example , a tree shaped like bethe lattice or any in bigger dimension ) , different capacities of cells and different kinds of balls distributed to the system . also there are many kinds of dependence of energy release threshold on other parameters ( on space position , on states of cells in a neighbourhood etc . ) . we leave these topics for further investigations . in analogy to the set of equations - for clusters , one can deduce the following set of equations for the empty clusters . * losses . * there are two following possibilities . + * ( a ) * occupation of any cell belonging to the empty @xmath26-cluster . the probability is just @xmath27 * ( b ) * provoking an avalanche . an empty cluster of the length @xmath26 is lost when one of the two adjacent clusters is knocked out and forms an avalanche . @xmath28 the probability is @xmath29 it comes from the probability of knocking out of @xmath11-cluster times the probability that on the end of the cluster is empty @xmath26-cluster , times two ends , summed for all possible values of @xmath11 . * gains . * again , there are two possibilities . + * ( a ) * shortening an empty cluster . an empty cluster of a length @xmath26 can be obtained from a bigger one of the length @xmath30 when an incoming ball hits its @xmath31th empty cell @xmath32 or symmetrically , its @xmath33th cell . hence the relevant gain term is of the form @xmath34 * ( b ) * provoking an avalanche . if an incoming ball knock out the cluster of the length @xmath35 surrounded by two empty clusters of the respective lengths @xmath36 and @xmath37 , @xmath38 then the empty cluster of the length @xmath26 is created . therefore , for @xmath39 this leads to the following term @xmath40 this is the probability of knocking out of the @xmath41-cluster times probability the @xmath42-empty cluster is on the left times probability the empty @xmath43-cluster is on the right , for all possible values of @xmath42 . * balance equations . * the set of equations for the average values in the quasi equilibrium is of the form @xmath44 equation may be written as @xmath45 and equation , valid for @xmath46 is @xmath47 thus , on right hand sides there are terms @xmath48 with @xmath49 only . * balance of @xmath50 out of empty clusters . * the set of equation for empty clusters can be treated by methods we use in subsection [ ssec : mom ] in order to derive relations for respective moments . below we consider zero moment for @xmath51 , which leads also to equation . this is implied by the fact that the number of empty clusters is equal to the number of clusters ( see equation ) . to perform sum of and for all values of @xmath26 notice the following identities : @xmath52 @xmath53 and @xmath54 in the last identity we assumed that it is allowed to change the order of summation with respect to indices @xmath41 and @xmath26 . thus , a sum of and for all @xmath26 leads directly to @xmath55 it is the balance equation already obtained . this work was partially supported by the project intas 05 - 1000008 - 7889 .

we introduce the stochastic domino cellular automaton model exhibiting avalanches . depending of the choice of the parameters , the model covers wide range of properties : various types of exponential and long tail ( up to inverse - power ) distributions of avalanches are observed . the stationary state of automaton is described by a set of nonlinear discrete equations derived in an exact way from elementary combinatorial arguments . these equations allow to derive formulas explaining both various exponential and inverse power distributions relating them to values of the parameters . the exact relations between the state variable of the model ( moments ) are derived in two ways : from direct arguments and from the set of equations . excellent agreement of the obtained analytical results with numerical simulations is observed .

1301.1874

the formation of planets in protoplanetary disks is strongly tied to the existence of dust which makes up about 1% of the total mass of the disk @xcite . the basic collisional growth model assumes that , as a first step toward planet formation , kilometer - size planetesimals are formed by sticking collisions of dust particles which are only held together by surface forces @xcite . there are some issues in planetesimal formation which are not yet understood . somewhat problematic is inward drift especially of meter - size bodies . in a standard disk the pressure is supposed to decrease with distance from the star @xcite . the gas is therefore supported by a pressure gradient and rotates with sub - keplerian velocity . small solids couple to the gas and thus also rotate more slowly than keplerian . however , solid bodies are not supported by the pressure gradient . this leads to an inward drift of the solid bodies which for a meter size body in a minimum mass nebula can be as large as 1 au in 100 years @xcite . such an inward mass transport of solids leads to a redistribution of matter : the outer part of the disk becomes depleted in solids , while the inner part becomes enriched . the physics of the inner 1 au of protoplanetary disks strongly depends on the fate of this incoming matter : it might contribute to the local planet formation process and add mass to forming planetary bodies , it might evaporate and be accreted by the star , or it might be recycled in some more complex way . as the physics in the inner part of the disk is complex the evolution of solid bodies is still an open question . to address this problem , we started to investigate a mechanism of particle recycling which is especially active in this inner region of a protoplanetary disk and , more specifically , close to the inner edge of a disk within the inner 1 au . there is a growing number of observations which show that , in some phases , protoplanetary disks contain inner gaps which are optically thin but still contain gas , while the outer part is still dense and optically thick @xcite . in other words , solids at the inner edge of a disk are embedded in a gaseous environment and are illuminated by the star . + @xcite first described a mechanism that significantly erodes dusty bodies to small particles under very general conditions , e.g. by mere illumination and at low gas pressure ( kw m@xmath2 of intensity and mbar gas pressure ) . @xcite showed that this erosion process also works under the conditions of transitional disks . there will most likely be a small shell at the inner edge of a disk where the conditions for particle erosion are met @xcite . every dusty body which enters this zone and which is too small to hold its dust by gravity ( sub - planetesimal ) is subject to erosion by this process . different scenarios are possible as to how this contributes to the evolution of the disk . the dust might , for example , be transported upward and outward over the disk by photophoresis . such a model has been suggested by @xcite . at later times or throughout the optical thin inner parts the dust might also be transported by photophoresis in the midplane @xcite . @xcite showed that the erosion process is a suitable mechanism to explain the existence of small dust particles which are observed in protoplanetary disks over their entire lifetime . the dust might also be recycled locally and added probably more efficiently than by the original larger bodies to existing large planetesimals or protoplanetary bodies to boost their growth . these aspects are speculative and not the main focus of this paper which reports on experiments that analyze the gravity dependence of the light induced erosion mechanism providing basic input for future modeling . + acts on the surface particles . when this force overcomes gravity and cohesion , the surface particles are lifted . a crater is formed where again temperature gradients develop . if the illuminated spot is limited in size , the developing crater might prevent further release of particle . ] a sketch of the light induced erosion mechanism is shown in figure [ fig : fig1 ] : the illumination of a dusty surface first leads to a solid - state greenhouse ( ssg ) effect . this effect is known to exist for ice and comets @xcite . it means that visible light enters a porous body and is absorbed over some depth , but as the body is opaque to infrared radiation only the top surface can cool by thermal emission . therefore , the maximum temperature is below the surface . in recent years it was shown that this is also true for purely dusty surfaces @xcite . if temperature gradients across a particle exist as in the case of an ssg profile , and if the particle is embedded in a gaseous environment , a photophoretic force acts on the particle from the warm to the cold side . hence , the surface particles of an illuminated dust bed are subject to a lifting force . if this force is stronger than gravity and cohesion , aggregates are ejected . the ssg and photophoresis are the basis for light induced erosion of dusty bodies . the physics behind this has been studied in a number of works @xcite . + in protoplanetary disks , dust particles on dusty sub - planetesimals are bound by cohesion and gravity . however , the gravitational force is small due to the small mass of the objects . therefore photophoretic forces acting on the particles have to overcome less gravity and the effect of dust erosion induced by illumination is more intense compared to larger bodies or laboratory experiments . in the first microgravity experiments @xcite showed that the threshold light flux for particle erosion indeed depends on the gravity level . at low gravity cohesion eventually becomes the dominant opposing force . the erosion rate was not measured in the experiments of @xcite : however , this is important in determining how rapidly a body can be eroded or what mass flux it might provide in small particles if it crosses the erosion zone in a protoplanetary disk . + to quantify the effect of light induced erosion for application to ( sub)-planetesimal recycling we carried out low gravity experiments and determined the gravity dependence of the erosion rate . the experiments were carried out during the first _ joint european partial - g parabolic flight _ campaign . on this campaign , over 3 days , 13 parabolas at 0.16@xmath0 , 12 parabolas at 0.38@xmath0 and 6 parabolas at 0@xmath0 ( @xmath0 @xmath3 9.81 m s@xmath2 ) were provided . we also developed a preliminary model which agrees well with the experimental results . a sketch of the experimental setup is shown in figure [ fig : fig2 ] . four separate chambers are placed in one vacuum chamber . each chamber contains a dust sample with a depth of 2 cm covering a total area of 6 @xmath4 . for the campaign reported here the chambers were filled with basalt powder with a broad size distribution between @xmath5 and @xmath6 @xmath7 m . we consider this dust particle size range suitable to simulate the dust in protoplanetary disks . they include micron - size particles discussed @xcite with reference to the matrix in chondrites ( typically a few microns but occasionally up to about 20 @xmath7 m @xcite ) . the constituents in interplanetary dust particles or cometary material are smaller , on the order of 0.1 @xmath7 m @xcite which might not be adequatley represented in our experiment sample . on the other hand , chondrites largely consist of chondrules of submillimeter size , so the larger grain fraction in our sample might correlate with these dimensions . certainly , the size dependence of the erosion mechanism should be considered in more detail in the future . + the dust samples were dried at about 500 k for 24 hr and were stored in a desiccator until they were placed in the vacuum chamber just before the experiments . the ambient pressure of air in the vacuum chamber was then set to @xmath8 @xmath1 0.9 mbar for all experiments . + during each experimental run one sample was illuminated by a diode laser of 2 w optical output at 655 @xmath1 10 nm . the laser profile was homogenized by coupling the laser to an optical fiber and projecting the fiber outlet onto the sample surface with a size of 25 @xmath1 4 mm@xmath9 . the average intensity was 12 kw m@xmath2 which varied by 17 % within the spot . this corresponds to the inner regions of a protoplanetary disk @xmath10 0.4 au where the light flux for a star similar to the sun is @xmath11 kw m@xmath2 . an accelerometer was used to measure the residual gravity acting on the experiment . the experimental chamber was supported by vibrational attenuators to prevent any influence of airplane vibrations , which might reduce the cohesion between the dust particles . released aggregates were observed from the side by a camera at 60 images per second . + measurements ( images ) were taken for 1@xmath0 , the acceleration phase at 1.7@xmath0 and the low - gravity phase at 0.16@xmath0 ( moon level ) or 0.38@xmath0 ( mars level ) . to confine the dust within the individual chambers , they were enclosed in a glass cylinder . this cylinder and the chambers were independently rotatable by a rotational feedthrough from the outside . after each parabola , and hence before every new experiment , the inside of the rotating glass cylinder was cleaned by a small strip of foam . this ensured that the laser and the camera view were not affected by dust . rotating the inner , dust containig part of the chambers ensures that for every new experiment a fresh spot of the dust surface was illuminated . this prevented selection effects , e.g. , that all ejectable particles ( e.g. of a certain size fraction ) were already released . after removing the background noise of the camera images the average gray scale value was taken as a relative measurement for the ejected mass or particle number . this assumed that the ejected particle distribution stays constant with time , that averaging is done over a significantly large number of particles and that the image is not saturated with particles . as we provide new spots for each experiment , observe well separated aggregates and take an average over a large number of aggregates in typically 900 images for a given @xmath0-phase , we consider the gray value as a suitable measure . shows an overlay of 100 images of the ejected aggregates at different g - levels . the number of ejected aggregates clearly increases with lower gravitational acceleration . + a parabolic flight has the advantage that different gravity levels can be tested with the same dust sample in a short period of time . however , the effects of the transitions between the different @xmath0-levels have to be filtered out . they induce a higher erosion rate during the transitions from high-@xmath0 to low-@xmath0 . this is due to the release of gravitational and photophoretic tension from the dust bed , as higher gravity levels require a steeper temperature gradient for erosion . it takes a certain time before the new equilibrium temperature profile is established at which aggregates are ejected regularly . shows which data were selected to determine the number of ejected aggregates in the different phases . in the 1@xmath0-phase of every parabola the laser and camera were turned on . first erosions occur after 2 - 3 s. during the transition from 1.7@xmath0 to lower @xmath0-levels , massive particle releases appear ( peaks in figure [ fig : fig3 ] ) . these releases are an artifact of the tension release as previously mentioned and are not used to determine the erosion rate . after the transition particle releases occur continuously at lower @xmath0-levels for about 10 s. the dust bed surface changes as the laser spot removes particles and creates an erosion crater ( see also figure [ fig : fig1 ] ) . the presence of a crater rim induces edge effects , which efficiently reduce the erosion rate , especially in the low gravity phase with high erosion rates . therefore , we do not include the later times for averaging . after the data reduction , a measure of the erosion rate is given as the average brightness of all images within a single @xmath0-phase . as the brightness is an arbitrary measure of the erosion rate , the different @xmath0-phases of one parabola are scaled to a value of 1 at 1@xmath0 . + the parabolic flight provided results for 12 parabolas : 6 moon parabolas and 6 mars parabolas . figures [ fig : fig5 ] and 6 [ fig : fig6 ] show the data sets for the moon and mars parabolas . + we further average over all parabolas ( 6 data points for 0.16@xmath0 and 0.38@xmath0 and 12 data points for 1@xmath0 and 1.7@xmath0 ) and obtain the average ejected mass rate over gravity . in figure [ fig : fig8 ] , all ( averaged ) experimental data are presented in the context of the model developed below . . the results from the experiments are presented in gray , the average value in black and the black line shows the trend for the averaged data according to the model developed in section 3 . ] . the results from the experiments are presented in gray , the average value in black and the black line shows the trend for the averaged data according to the model developed in section 3 . ] the continuous aggregate ejections from the dust bed are caused by an inverse temperature gradient below the dust bed s surface and a photophoretic force @xmath12 @xcite . in detail the idea behind the light induced aggregate ejections is the following : @xcite showed , that if a dust bed is illuminated from the top , the maximum temperature @xmath13 is up to some 100 @xmath7 m below the surface this is called ssg . hence , there is a temperature gradient @xmath14 pointing from @xmath13 toward the cooler surface ( inverse temperature gradient ; @xmath15 as depth within the dust bed ) . typical thermal conductivities @xmath16 of the dust bed are on the order of @xmath17 w m@xmath18 k@xmath18 @xcite . the inverse temperature gradient then takes values of @xmath19 10@xmath20 k m@xmath18 at 10 @xmath21kw m@xmath2 illumination @xcite . + the upper most aggregates have a temperature gradient along their surface . small particles with a temperature gradient in a gaseous environment are affected by a photophoretic force which can be written for spherical particles as @xcite @xmath22 where @xmath23 is gas pressure . @xmath24 and @xmath25 are particle and gas dependent parameters determining the pressure @xmath25 at which the photophoretic force @xmath24 is a maximum . @xmath26 is a gas dependent parameter , @xmath27 is the accommodation coefficient , @xmath28 is the particle radius and @xmath14 is the temperature gradient over the particle s surface . particles in the @xmath7 m regime are most strongly affected by photophoresis at mbar pressure . the experiment was carried out on the ground at 6 mbar ambient pressure and at an intensity of 12 kw m@xmath2 . ] photophoresis acts on the upper - most aggregates in illuminated dust beds . the threshold for particle ejection can be written as follows @xcite : @xmath29 with gravity @xmath30 , where @xmath31 is the environmental gravitational acceleration , @xmath32 is the ejected mass , and @xmath33 is the cohesion force . if the photophoretic force @xmath12 overcomes gravity and cohesion , aggregates are released from the dust bed s surface . the mass ejection rate @xmath34 with @xmath35 as time interval depends on the time scale at which the threshold temperature gradient ( see e.g. equation ( [ eq : roha2 ] ) ) within the illuminated dust bed is reset after an ejection . the temperature evolution toward equilibrium within the dust bed follows an exponential dependence @xcite . if the threshold gradient to induce particle release is reached after a time span @xmath35 much smaller than the exponential timescale ( large light flux ) the temperature gradient can be approximated by a linear increase with time @xmath36 therefore the threshold temperature gradient after a time span @xmath35 can be written as @xmath37 with equation ( [ eq : gradient2 ] ) the photophoretic force ( equtation ( [ eq : roha3 ] ) ) can be written as @xmath38 with @xmath39 . hence , after the time interval @xmath35 the threshold photophoretic force ( @xmath40 , eq.([eq : threshold ] ) ) is reached @xmath41 and aggregates are released in steps always after an average time @xmath42 the mass ejection rate therefore is @xmath43 equation ( [ eq : rate ] ) was used to fit the experimental data , and gives and @xmath44 @xmath1 1.2 m s@xmath2 . @xmath45 is scalable arbitrarily as it accounts for the nature of the brightness measurement as the relative measurement for one part . however , @xmath46 contains information on the cohesive force by which an ejected mass fraction is bound to the dust bed . + due to the low resolution of the analyzed images we can not give an accurate assumption for the eroded particle mass @xmath32 . hence , we can not estimate the exact value of @xmath33 from our experiments . + the acceleration @xmath46 from the model fits the accelerations measured in first follow - up laboratory experiments , shown in figure [ fig : fig7 ] : basalt powder with a broad size distribution between @xmath5 and @xmath6 @xmath7 m was placed in a vacuum chamber with 6 @xmath1 0.9 mbar ambient pressure . it was then illuminated by a laser with 12 @xmath1 1 kwm@xmath2 and a spot size of 5 @xmath1 0.5 mm radius . the resulting ejection of dust aggregates was measured at a camera with 500 images per second , so the accelerated aggregates could be tracked . we measured accelerations of 14.4 @xmath1 4.9 m s@xmath2 , averaged over nine ejected aggregates , which is only twice as high as the acceleration measured on the parabolic flight . this factor two can be explained by the fact that we could not use exactly the same dust sample that we had on board for the parabolic flight . + to visualize the influence of the cohesion we plot the ejection rate of equation ( [ eq : rate ] ) divided by the factor @xmath47 for the experimental data ( average values of the @xmath0-phases ) which effectively normalizes the experimental data to 1 at 0@xmath0 . in figure [ fig : fig8 ] , the value @xmath48 is then varied by a factor @xmath49 to show the general dependence on @xmath48 . there is a prominent increase in the ejection rate towards smaller @xmath46 where it becomes more and more dominant at @xmath50 while cohesion is negligible for @xmath51 . for the experimental values using . the experimental value ( squares ) for @xmath46 is varied by a factor @xmath49 with @xmath52 ( bottom to top ) . the color gradient indicates that the more aggregates that are ejected , the more light is shielded from reaching the dust bed s surface . from the experiments , we estimate that an increase of the rate up to factor of 10 might be realistic for low cohesive powders . ] this simple model neglects self - shielding of the dust bed by ejected aggregates . the more dust that is ejected , the more light is shielded from reaching the surface . depending on the relation between the ejection rate and the rate at which aggregates are transported away from the ejection location , e.g. by gas drag in protoplanetary disks , the optical thickness of the layer above the dust bed s surface will increase . from the experiments and based on the assumption that the light flux might be reduced to less than @xmath53 of it s intensity , ejection rates that are increased by a factor 10 likely still do not affect the ejection rate . this might set an upper limit to the ejection rate but it is only a rough estimate here which has to be quantified in the future . for planetary bodies the effect might lead to a size sorting over time where large particles fall back down while small grains get entrained into the atmosphere . the effect of light induced dust ejections can be a key process of recycling dust during the formation of planets in protoplanetary disks . planetesimals or smaller dusty bodies at the inner edge can be partly eroded @xcite . the position of the edge in a number of transition , pre - transition and full disks has been modeled by @xcite . here , pre - transition disks relate to a disk with substantial matter within the gap modeled by an optically thin inner wall at the dust sublimation radius and a second outer wall . in table [ tab : table1 ] , we extract their modeled radii of the disks and the luminosities of the host stars . based on the photophoresis the lift force on particles depends on the environmental parameters light flux @xmath54 , gas pressure @xmath23 and gas temperature @xmath55 . in the free molecular flow regime ( low pressure ) equation [ eq : roha1 ] simplifies and connects these three parameters to @xmath56 @xcite , with a parameter @xmath57 dependent on the dust bed . + our experiments show that particle eruptions continuously occur at all gravity levels at the used light flux @xmath58 kw m@xmath2 , pressure @xmath59 mbar and temperature @xmath55 of about @xmath60 k. we did not probe the threshold condition where no dust is lifted but our values are consistent with threshold conditions measured for eruptions at 1@xmath0 by @xcite . he found @xmath61 kw m@xmath2 at 1 mbar and 300 k. therefore , we expect that light induced erosion occurs as long as @xmath62 kw m@xmath2 pa k@xmath18 @xcite . + in a minimum mass solar nebula @xcite with given pressure , temperature and luminosity dependence this condition is reached at a distance of about 0.4 au or mercury s orbit @xcite . + for observed extrasolar systems we only know the luminosities for certain , not the pressure or temperature at the midplanes . to determine the distance of the dividing line between erosion and stability for the different objects , we assume that the dividing line is where the light flux of the host star equals that of a solar - type star in a minimum mass solar nebula or @xmath63 au @xmath64 ( table [ tab : table1 ] ) . the implicit assumptions in this equation are that the gas pressure at this distance and the temperature are the same as in the minimum - mass solar nebula at 0.4 au . + for the temperature this is a consistent assumption as the blackbody radiation temperature which defines the temperature of the disk in the minimum - mass solar nebula would be the same at the same incoming light flux . the pressure is less certain but one might argue that more luminous stars have denser disks . we therefore assume the pressure to be equal to that in a minimum mass solar nebula at the dividing line . however , more complex models would not change the following general statement . + we always find the erosion limit within the gap of the pre - transitional disks . in general , erosion is possible at the inner edges of full disks , although melting or sintering of particle ensembles might be an issue which has to be studied in further detail . for full disks and pre - transitional disks erosion might clearly provide the small dust observed over the lifetime of the disk . as the erosion limit distance is closer to the star than the outer wall in pre - transitional disks , particles released by the erosion mechanism can drift outward to this second wall by photophoresis and enhance the particle density locally @xcite . this will induce an enhanced growth of dust aggregates . at the outer wall the growing bodies are safe from destruction unless they are scattered or drift inward again to the inner erosion zone during further evolution and recycling . the holes of transitional disks are all larger than the erosion limit distance . as they have a largely reduced density it is unclear to what extent erosion will work here . the erosion limit distance would shift inward significantly . earlier calculations by @xcite showed that , for example , in the case of tw hya erosion close to the star would still be possible but this strongly depends on the gas content . the erosion zone likely decreases in thickness with time . however , even if it were only a very thin zone , dusty bodies traversing it might be significantly eroded . in the optical but thin still slightly gaseous hole , the dust would be transported by photophoresis and locally increase the particle density again . therefore , at early full disk times erosion will influence the particle recycling at the inner edge . in later pre - transitional and transitional evolution times of the clearing phase the light induced erosion will be an important factor in shaping the size distribution or even triggering later formation of larger bodies at the outward moving edge . + the experiments reported here show that the number of ejected particles increases strongly with decreasing @xmath0-levels . the experiments performed on a parabolic flight display an inverse dependence on gravity and specific cohesion . the ejection rate is higher by a factor two in 0.16@xmath0 than in 1@xmath0 for the basalt sample used . the importance of gravity deduced from these data can more clearly be seen in the model . if cohesion is reduced the ejection rate might be up to one or two orders of magnitude more efficient at low-@xmath0 . lower cohesion does not change the ejection rate strongly at high @xmath0-levels . as a consequence of microgravity on small planetesimals or sub - planetesimals , the effect is more intense than observed from ground - based experiments so far . @xcite estimated from 1@xmath0 experiments a mass - loss rate of 10@xmath65 kg s@xmath18 m@xmath2 or about 10@xmath66 kg year@xmath18 for an area 1 m@xmath9 in size . low gravity conditions would boost this value by a factor of a few . this compares well to the mass of a porous dusty body of meter size with a density of 1 g @xmath67 . the total mass is some @xmath68 kg . it is therefore possible to erode , in less than one year , a significant part of such a body if it consists of loosely bound dust close to the disk edge . as the erosion zone is a fraction of an au @xcite the experiments show that an object that passes the edge will efficiently lose mass ( figure [ fig : fig9 ] ) . even for objects that lose mass but are not completely destroyed the effect is important as it provides a non - gravitational force on the body and will change the orbital parameters ; the details , however , are beyond the scope of this paper . the mechanism is more efficient in an atmosphere consisting of hydrogen instead of air . the equation [ eq : roha2 ] by @xcite for the photophoretic force shows a dependence on different parameters . the maximum force is proportional to a gas dependent parameter @xmath69 this parameter contains the dynamic viscosity of the gas @xmath70 and the average thermal velocity c , which is proportional to the square root of 1/@xmath7 , the inverse molar mass . assuming @xmath71 = 17.1 @xmath7pa@xmath72s and @xmath73 = 8.4 @xmath7pa@xmath72s , as well as @xmath74 = 29 g mol@xmath18 and @xmath75 = 2.31 g / mol , we get @xmath76 = 1.75 @xmath77 @xmath78 . the maximum force is therefore 1.75 times higher in a protoplanetary disk than on earth . in principle the erosion mechanism might compete with regrowth as a body moves through the disk and collects dust particles . this is an interesting aspect as it changes the surface morphology and the susceptibility for re - erosion . to what degree this process is important depends on the position of the dividing line with respect to the inner edge of the optically thick disk . if erosion only occurs in the transitional zone far away from the edge then this whole zone is optically thin by definition and re - growth is not important . this might be explained as follows . assuming all dust particles to be spherical with a radius of 5 @xmath7 m , the particle cross section is 78.5 @xmath77 10@xmath79 m@xmath9 . the disk would be optically thick if its cross section were completely covered with dust particles . at typical distances of 0.5 au and with a scale height of 0.1 au this would be 7 @xmath77 10@xmath80 m@xmath9 . dividing by the particle cross section , this gives 9 @xmath77 10@xmath81 particles . spread out over an estimated 0.5 au in distance the particle density would be @xmath82 particles m@xmath83 . the largest drift velocities considered in disk models are on the order of 50 m s@xmath18 . if a body of 1 m radius colleced dust at these speeds the growth rate would be 26.7 particle per second or with a particles density of 2000 kg m@xmath83 it would be 3 @xmath77 10@xmath84 kg s@xmath18 . compared to the erosion rate this worst case estimate shows that re - growth is negligible . + this changes at the edge . if the transition zone is only , for example , 100,000 km thick the particle density would be 127.3 particles m@xmath83 and the mass growth 2 @xmath77 10@xmath85 kg s@xmath18 . this is a factor of 500 less than the erosion rate under perfect conditions , but for non - perfect conditions , e.g. , further toward the dark side of the edge growth and erosion might be comparable . + another application of the effect at low gravity is found on mars . by adjusting the conditions ( light flux and temperature ) to mars , dust entrainment in the atmosphere might be explained @xcite . the low - gravity experiments suggest higher erosion rates on mars . + most dust samples that absorb visible radiation show light - induced ejection . we have quantified the gravity effect for a single sample so far . we have experimental evidence that cohesion in the context of this ejection mechanism can vary strongly for different dust samples , but quantification is subject to future research . overall , erosion of a dusty body at the low - gravity conditions of small bodies at the inner edges of protoplanetary disks is a major recycling process of dust , and is important in the context of planet formation . this work was supported by the deutsches zentrum fr luft- und raumfahrt ( dlr ) , the federal ministry of economics and technology germany ( bmwi ) , the european space agency ( esa ) and the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( dfg ) . + we thank the anonymous reviewer for valuable comments .

transporting solids of different sizes is an essential process in the evolution of protoplanetary disks and planet formation . large solids are supposed to drift inward ; high - temperature minerals found in comets are assumed to have been transported outward . from low - gravity experiments on parabolic flights we studied the light - induced erosion of dusty bodies caused by a solid - state greenhouse effect and photophoresis within a dust bed s upper layers . tje gravity levels studied were 0.16@xmath0 , 0.38@xmath0 , 1@xmath0 , and 1.7@xmath0 . the light flux during the experiments was 12 @xmath1 2 kw m@xmath2 and the ambient pressure was 6 @xmath1 0.9 mbar . light - induced erosion is strongly gravity dependent , which is in agreement with a developed model . in particular for small dusty bodies ( ( sub)-planetesimals ) , efficient erosion is possible at the optically thin inner edges of protoplanetary disks . light - induced erosion prevents significant parts of a larger body from moving too close to the host star and be being subsequently accreted . the small dust produced continues to be subject to photophoresis and is partially transported upward and outward over the surface of the disk ; the resulting small dust particles observed over the disk s lifetime . the fraction of eroded dust participates in subsequent cycles of growth during planetesimal formation . another fraction of dust might be collected by a body of planetary size if this body is already present close to the disk edge . either way , light induced erosion is an efficient recycling process in protoplanetary disks .

1603.04911

one of the main issues in multi - obstacle , multi - agent environments is the collision avoidance assessment . usually the avoidance constraints have to be considered both between an agent and fixed obstacles and between any two agents . the problem is intensively studied , yet actual , in the literature but is usually tilted towards heuristic approaches or online validations . the first usually lacks stability and performances guarantees and the later is easily boggled into numerical issues @xcite . an alternative approach is to solve offline the difficult trajectory generation part of the overall problem , online only a straightforward trajectory tracking is employed . this reduces significantly the online computations and allows stability and performance analysis . the caveat is that the trajectory to be computed has to respect the dynamics of the agent and to validate the collision avoidance constraints at all times @xcite . an interesting implementation is represented by flat trajectory design which guarantees that the corresponding system dynamics are respected ( with the caveat that state and input constraints are not easily accounted for @xcite ) . this construction shifts the state and input constraints into constraints over the flat output . to handle this , usually , the flat output is project over some basis functions which means that only the coefficients of the projections need to be found . in this sense , b - spline functions represent an ideal choice since they have enough flexibility @xcite and nice theoretical properties ( of which we will make extensive use throughout the paper ) . the present work builds on results sketched in @xcite and further advances the topic in several directions . foremost , we provide exact and sub - optimal formulations of the collision avoidance problems between an agent and the obstacles and between any tho agents . in both cases we make use of the geometrical properties of the b - spline functions which allow to bound locally the trajectories obtained through them . hence , the collision problems become separation problems between sets of consecutive points . in the exact case , these constraints lead to nonlinear formulation where both the control points and the separation hyperplanes are variables . a simplified ( and hence sub - optimal approach ) is to select the separation hyperplanes from the support hyperplanes of the obstacles therefore reducing the problem to a mixed integer formulation . both methods make use of a multi - obstacole framework and are tested and compared over extensive simulations . the rest of the paper is organized as follows : tackles flat output and b - spline characterizations , discusses flat trajectory generation and presents the main results of the paper which are then illustrated in . draws the conclusions . the minkowski sum of two sets , @xmath0 and @xmath1 is denoted as @xmath2 . @xmath3 denotes the convex hull of set generated by the collection of points @xmath4 . the problem of designing reference trajectories in a multi - agent multi - obstacle environment is in general a difficult one . a popular approach is to parametrize them through flatness constructions @xcite . in this section we will describe some of the basics of flat trajectory and their parametrization via b - spline basis functions . a nonlinear time invariant system : [ eq : contsys ] ( t)=f(x(t),u(t ) ) , where @xmath5 is the state vector and @xmath6 is the input vector is called differentially flat if there exists the flat output @xmath7 : [ eq : flat_out ] z(t)=(x(t),u(t),(t ) , , u^(q)(t ) ) such that the states and inputs can be algebraically expressed in terms of @xmath8 and a finite number of its higher - order derivatives : [ eq : diff_a ] x(t)&=&(z(t),(t ) , , z^(q)(t ) ) , + u(t)&=&(z(t),(t),,z^(q)(t ) ) . [ rem : flatinput ] for any system admitting a flat description , the number of flat outputs equals the number of inputs @xcite . in the case of linear systems @xcite the flat differentiability ( existence and constructive forms ) is implied by the controllability property . within the multi - agent framework , the most important aspect of construction is that it reduces the problem of trajectory generation to finding an adequate flat output . this means choosing @xmath8 such that , via mappings @xmath9 , various constraints on state and inputs are verified . since the flat output may be difficult to compute under these restrictions , we parametrize @xmath8 using a set of smooth basis functions @xmath10 : [ eq : paramflat ] z(t)=_i=1^n_i ^i(t ) , _ i . parameter @xmath11 depends on the number of constraints imposed onto the dynamics @xcite . there are multiple choices for the basis functions @xmath10 . among these , _ b - spline _ basis functions are well - suited to flatness parametrization due to their ease of enforcing continuity and because their degree depends only up to which derivative is needed to ensure continuity @xcite . a b - spline of order @xmath12 is characterized by a _ knot - vector _ @xcite [ eq : knot_vector ] t=\{_0,_1 _m } , of non - decreasing time instants ( @xmath13 ) which parametrizes the associated basis functions @xmath14 : @xmath15 for @xmath16 and @xmath17 . considering a collection of _ control points _ [ eq : control_points ] p=\{p_0,p_1 p_n } , we define a _ b - spline curve _ as a linear combination of the control points and the b - spline functions [ eq : bspline_curve ] z(t)=_i=0^n b_i , d(t)p_i = pb_d(t ) where @xmath18 and @xmath19 . this construction yields several interesting properties @xcite : 1 . [ p:1 ] @xmath8 is @xmath20 in any @xmath21 and @xmath22 in any @xmath23 ; 2 . [ p:3 ] at a time instant @xmath24 , @xmath8 depends only on the b - splines @xmath25 ; consequently , the b - spline curve @xmath8 lies within the union of all convex hulls formed by all @xmath12 successive control points ; 3 . [ p:5 ] the ` r ' order derivatives of b - spline basis functions can be expressed as linear combinations of b - splines of lower order ( @xmath26 with matrices @xmath27 of appropriate dimensions and content ) ; 4 . taking the first and last @xmath12 knot elements equal ( @xmath28 and @xmath29 ) leads to a _ clamped b - spline curve _ where the first and last control points coincide with the curve s end points . let us consider for exemplification the b - spline basis functions defined by parameters @xmath30 and @xmath31 with the knot vector of length @xmath32 and with components equally sampled between @xmath33 and @xmath34 . using these elements we construct the b - spline curve which we depict in . note that the convex - hulls determined by all @xmath31 consecutive control points ( property [ p:3 ] ) contain the curve : z(t)_i=3 5\{p_i-3,p_i-2,p_i-1,p_i } , t. in particular , the patterned shape depicted in the figure denotes region @xmath35 which contains the curve @xmath8 for any @xmath36 $ ] . let us consider a collection of @xmath37 way - points and the time stamps associated to them : [ eq : wt ] w=\{w_s } t_w=\{t_s } , for any @xmath38 . the goal is to construct a flat trajectory which passes through each way - point @xmath39 at the time instant @xmath40 ( or through a predefined neighborhood of it @xcite ) , i.e. , to find a flat output @xmath8 such that [ eq : xconstr ] x(t_s)=(z(t_s), z^(r)(t_s))=w_s , s=0 n . [ rem : waypoints ] note that here we assume that the way - points are defined over the entire state . arguably there might be situations where only a subspace of the state is of interest ( e.g. , only the position components of the state ) . making use of the b - spline framework we provide a vector of control points and its associated knot - vector such that is verified ( parameter @xmath12 is chosen such that continuity constraints are respected ) : [ eq : flatconstraints ] ( b_d(t_s),p)=w_s , s=0 n , where @xmath41 is constructed along property [ p:5 ] . let us assume that the knot - vector is fixed ( @xmath42 , @xmath43 and the intermediary points @xmath44 are equally distributed along these extremes ) . then , we can write an optimization problem with control points @xmath45 as decision variables whose goal is to minimize a cost @xmath46 along the time interval @xmath47 $ ] : [ eq : flatcost ] p=&_p _ t_0^t_n||(b_d(t),p)||_qdt + & with @xmath48 a positive symmetric matrix . the cost @xmath49 can impose any penalization we deem necessary ( length of the trajectory , input variation , input magnitude , etc ) . in general , such a problem is nonlinear ( due to mappings @xmath50 and @xmath51 ) and hence difficult to solve . a nonlinear mpc iterative approach has been extensively studied @xcite . with these tools at hand we can propose various methods for collision avoidance in a multi - agent multi - obstacle environment . let us consider a collection of polyhedral obstacles [ eq : obstacles ] o=\{o_1 o_n_o } and assume that the k - th agent follows a trajectory @xmath52 during the interval @xmath53 $ ] , generated as in through a collection of control points @xmath54 and the associated knot vector @xmath55 . consequently , the collision avoidance conditions mentioned earlier can be formulated as follows : 1 . collision avoidance between the k - th agent and l - th obstacle : [ eq : real_avoidance_ao ] r_k(t)o_l , t , 2 . collision avoidance between the @xmath56-th and @xmath57-th agents ( for any @xmath58 : [ eq : real_avoidance_aa ] r_k_1(t)r_k_2(t ) , t. the distinctive feature of conditions is that they require a continuous time interval ( @xmath47 $ ] ) validation ( i.e. , imposing constraints at discrete time instants @xmath59 along the interval is not deemed sufficient ) . consequently , we make use of property property [ p:3 ] which allows to bound the continuous b - spline parametrized curve by its control points . coupling this with the _ separating hyperplane theorem _ ( a well - known construction @xcite which states that for any two disjoint convex objects there exists a separating hyperplane ) several results are attainable . first , we provide a slight reformulation of proposition 1 from @xcite . [ prop : avoid ] the k - th agent is guaranteed to avoid obstacles , i.e. , to verify , if there @xmath60 s.t . [ eq : avoidance ] _ j\{i - d+1 i}(c_il^k)^p_j^k_x^-1(o_l ) ( c_il^k)^x , for @xmath61 and @xmath62 . condition states that there exists a hyperplane defined by its normal @xmath63 which separates the points @xmath64 from the obstacle @xmath65 . since , according to property [ p:3 ] , the curve is contained in @xmath66 it follows that is a sufficient condition to verify . in note the use of mapping @xmath67 . this appears because the obstacle avoidance constraint is the state - space whereas is in the control point space . a similar reasoning is employed for the inter - agent collision condition . [ prop : avoid_inter ] the pair ( @xmath68 ) of agents , with @xmath69 , is guaranteed to avoid collision , i.e. , to validate , if there @xmath70 s.t . : [ eq : avoid_inter ] _ i_2}(c_i_1i_2^k_1k_2)^p_j^k_2 , for all possible pairs @xmath71 which validate [ eq : intersection_aa_indices ] \{(i_1,i_2 ) : [ _ i_1^k_1,_i_1 + 1^k_1]}. recall that ( as per property [ p:3 ] ) a region @xmath72 contains the b - spline curve in the time interval @xmath73 $ ] . applying this to the agents @xmath56 and @xmath57 means that all regions corresponding to indices should not intersect as they contain overlapping time instants . the separation is enforced by which is a sufficient condition for . [ rem : avoid_simpl ] eq . can be avoided altogether if the b - spline parametrizations share the same knot vector ( i.e. , @xmath74 ) . in such a case , variable @xmath75 becomes @xmath76 and condition is simplified to [ eq : avoid_inter2 ] _ j\{i - d+1 i}(c_i^k_1k_2)^p_j^k_1_j\{i - d+1 i}(c_i^k_1k_2)^p_j^k_2 , for all @xmath77 . verifying ( or ) is difficult in practice due to the presence of bi - linear terms ( e.g. , in both @xmath78 and @xmath79 are variables ) . hereafter we propose a simpler ( and hence sub - optimal ) implementation . the main idea is that instead of letting the separating hyperplane from or [ prop : avoid_inter ] be itself a variable , we choose from within a predefined pool of hyperplanes . a natural choice is to select from the support hyperplanes of the obstacles . by definition , such a hyperplane contains on one side the obstacle and hence , it remains only to check whether the control points lie on the opposite side . the selection of the active hyperplane is done through decision variables ( i.e. , binary variables ) which leads to a mixed - integer pseudo - linear formulation . to generate the collection of hyperplanes , we consider the polyhedral sets bounding is a polyhedral set as well . in general this might not hold , but in that case a polyhedral approximation can be obtained . ] @xmath80 and take the support hyperplanes which characterize them : [ eq : hyp ] h_m=\{x : h_m^x = k_m } , m=1 m . each of these hyperplanes partitions the space in two `` half - spaces '' : @xmath81 taking into account all possible combinations of half - spaces leads to a hyperplane arrangement which divides the space into a collection of disjoint cells which are completely characterized by sign tuples @xcite : [ eq : hyparr ] h= _ a()= _ ( _ m=1^m h_m^(m ) ) where @xmath82 denotes the collection of all feasible ( corresponding to non - empty regions @xmath83 ) sign tuples . each of these tuples can be allocated to either 1 . the admissible domain @xmath84 : [ eq : sigma_adm ] ^=\ { : a()o = } , 2 . or the interdicted domain @xmath85 : [ eq : sigma_int ] ^=\ { : a()o } , where @xmath86 and @xmath87 . with these elements we can provide the following corollaries . [ cor : avoid ] for an obstacle @xmath88 with @xmath89 , a sufficient condition to guarantee corresponds a single sign tuple . ] is : @xmath90 for @xmath91 . taking in he binary variable ` @xmath92 ' means that the i - th region @xmath93 of the k - th agent sits on the opposite side of the obstacle @xmath88 with respect to the the m - th hyperplane . the converse , taking ` @xmath94 ' means that inequality is discarded since the right hand term is sufficiently large to ignore the values on the left side ( assuming that ` @xmath95 ' was taken as a sufficiently large positive constant ) . condition forces that for any consecutive @xmath96 points at least one of the inequalities is enforced since at least one of the variables @xmath97 has to be zero . furthermore , we relax ( in addition to the simplification proposed in ) into the following corollary . [ cor : avoid_inter ] the pair ( @xmath68 ) of agents , with @xmath69 , is guaranteed to avoid collision , i.e. , to validate , if : @xmath98 for @xmath91 . the binary variables @xmath99 denote whether the i - th regions @xmath100 and @xmath101 are separated through the m - th hyperplane ( whenever @xmath102 the inequality is enforced and otherwise is discarded ) . assures that at least one of the hyperplanes is active . several remarks are in order . considers a simultaneous computation of trajectories . an alternative is to compute them iteratively such that from the point of view of the current agent the obstacles to be avoided at @xmath103 $ ] become : oo(_l < k\{p_i - d+1^l p_i^l } ) where besides the obstacles , the i - th regions @xmath104 of the previous agents ( with index @xmath105 and whose trajectories are hence already computed ) are also considered as obstacles . an agent may have a safety region around it ( i.e. , because the agent can not be reduced to a point or due to the presence of disturbances in the dynamics ) . whatever the reason , and the modality to obtain it , a safety region @xmath106 can be attached to the k - th agent . consequently , the collision avoidance constraints become : [ eq : real_avoidance_ao2 ] \{r_k(t)}s_ko_l , t , and [ eq : real_avoidance_aa2 ] \{r_k_1(t)}s_k_1\{r_k_2(t)}s_k_2 , t. the previous results can be easily adapted to constraints by enlarging the obstacles ( @xmath107 ) and by requiring a larger inter - distance between agents respectively ( @xmath108 ) . lastly , it is worth mentioning that in all previous propositions and corollaries there is no guarantee of feasibility for the optimization problems . the solution is to incrementally increase the number of variables ( i.e. , the control points ) until a feasible solution is reached . we revisit the test case from @xcite . a 2d 3-dof model of an airplane in which the autopilot forces coordinated turns ( zero side - slip ) at a fixed altitude : [ eq : modeln ] ( t)&=v_(t ) ( t ) , + ( t)&=v_(t ) ( t ) , + ( t)&= the state variables are represented by the position @xmath109 and the heading ( yaw ) angle @xmath110 $ ] rad . the input signals are the airspeed velocity @xmath111 and the bank ( roll ) angle @xmath112 , respectively . we take as flat output the position components of the state , @xmath113 which permits to compute the remaining variables : @xmath114 note that in the heading component of the state appear 1st order and in the roll angle input appear 2nd order derivatives of the flat outputs . hence , if we wish to have smooth state and input ( their derivatives to be continuous ) it follows that the b - spline parametrization has to have at least degree @xmath31 . further , we consider way - points which fix only the position components of the state and time - stamps at which the trajectory has to pass through them . thus we manage to skirt some of the thornier numerical aspects : the dependence between the b - spline basis functions and the position components is linear ( @xmath115 ) , and hence the cost and constraints will be easily written . we take as cost to be minimized the length of the curve since we would like to have the shortest path which respects the constraints , i.e. , @xmath116 . this translates into the integral cost : & _ t_0^t_n ||z(t)||dt=_t_0^t_n ||p m_1b_d-1(t)||dt + & = _ i , j([p m_1]_i)^t(_t_0^t_nb_i , d-1(t)b_j , d-1(t)dt)[p m_1]_j where matrix @xmath117 links @xmath118 and @xmath119 as in property property [ p:5 ] and @xmath120_i$ ] extracts the i - th column from the argument . since the inner integrals can be computed numerically , we have now a quadratic formulation of the cost and we can use it for the various constructions from , see also @xcite for a similar treatment of cost computations . for illustration purposes we consider @xmath121 hyperplanes : h= -0.5931 & 0.8051 + 0.1814 & 0.9834 + -0.0044 & 1.0000 + -0.1323 & 0.9912 + -0.7011 & -0.7131 + 0.8152 & -0.5792 + 0.4352 & 0.9003 + 1.0000 & -0.0075 + -0.5961 & -0.8029 , h= 4.2239 + 0.1719 + 0.9975 + 0.2728 + 3.6785 + 0.0317 + 1.6598 + 4.5790 + 1.0280 which lead to a hyperplane arrangement where the interdicted tuples @xmath122 correspond to three obstacles . further , we take three way - points ( initial , intermediary and final ) though which the trajectory has to pass at predefined times : w=\{-9 + -0.5 , 0 + 1.5 , 6 + 0 } , t_w=\{0 , 5 , 10}. + we compute a flat trajectory ( parametrized by @xmath123 and @xmath124 ) which passes through the given way - points , minimizes the total path - length and respects one of the following scenarios : i ) without any collision avoidance restriction ; ii ) with collision avoidance as in ; iii ) with collision avoidance as in . the obstacles , their support hyperplanes and the resulting trajectories are depicted in . scenarios ii ) and iii ) both accomplish the task of avoiding the obstacles with comparable computation times and path lengths . figures [ fig : avoid_b ] and [ fig : avoid_c ] show details of the collision avoidance . in both cases the 1st and 3rd convex regions are considered ( @xmath125 and @xmath126 ) together with their separating hyperplanes . in these hyperplanes are the 1st and respectively 3rd support hyperplane whereas in the separating hyperplanes are the result of the optimization problem and are @xmath127 , @xmath128 . as mentioned earlier , the result of the optimization problem ( computation time , total length of the trajectory ) depends heavily on the number of control points @xmath129 and degree @xmath12 . we illustrate these evolutions in . several remarks are in order . first , it seems that after an initial decrease in the path length the future reductions are negligible and at a significant computation time for the mixed - integer method . next , and somewhat surprising , is that the non - linear method is extremely sensitive to parameter variations ( number of control points , degree , positioning and number of the way - points , etc ) such that the results obtained are not trustworthy . the one advantage of the latter over the former is that it may provide a feasible solution for small values of @xmath130 . .evolution of trajectories characteristics for degree @xmath31 in the non - linear and mixed - integer formulations . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the collision avoidance between two agents is similar and not depicted here . all the numerical simulations have been done using yalmip @xcite and mpt toolboxes @xcite in matlab 2013a . the nonlinear solver used was the ipopt solver @xcite . this paper considers collision avoidance in a multi - agent multi - obstacle framework . using differential flatness for trajectory generation and b - splines for the flat output parametrization we show that the restriction can be validated at all times . exact and sub - optimal constructions are provided . future work may consist in analysis of the feasibility of the problem , relaxation of way - point restrictions ( similar with work done in @xcite ) , etc . this work was supported by a grant of the romanian national authority for scientific research and innovation , cncs uefiscdi , project number pn - ii - ru - te-2014 - 4 - 2713 . m. burger and k. pettersen , `` smooth transitions between trajectory tracking and path following for single vehicles and formations , '' in _ estimation and control of networked systems _ , 2010 , pp . 115120 . a. aguiar and j. hespanha , `` trajectory - tracking and path - following of underactuated autonomous vehicles with parametric modeling uncertainty , '' _ ieee transactions on automatic control _ , 52 , no . 8 , pp . 13621379 , 2007 . i. prodan , s. bencatel , r.and olaru , j. sousa , c. stoica , and s .- niculescu , `` receding horizon flight control for trajectory tracking of autonomous aerial vehicles , '' _ control engineering practice _ , 21 , no . 10 , pp . 13341349 , 2013 . j. de don , f. suryawan , m. seron , and j. lvine , `` a flatness - based iterative method for reference trajectory generation in constrained nmpc , '' in _ nonlinear model predictive control_.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emspringer , 2009 , pp . 325333 . f. suryawan , j. de dona , and m. seron , `` methods for trajectory generation in a magnetic - levitation system under constraints , '' in _ 18th mediterranean conference on control and automation _ , 2010 , pp . 945950 . f. suryawan , `` constrained trajectory generation and fault tolerant control based on differential flatness and b - splines , '' ph.d . dissertation , school of electrical engineering and computer science , the university of newcastle , australia , 2012 . m. fliess , j. lvine , p. martin , and p. rouchon , `` flatness and defect of non - linear systems : introductory theory and examples , '' _ international journal of control _ , vol . 61 , no . 6 , pp . 13271361 , 1995 . f. stoican , i. prodan , and d. popescu , `` flat trajectory generation for way - points relaxations and obstacle avoidance , '' in _ control and automation ( med ) , 2015 23th mediterranean conference on_.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emieee , 2015 , pp . 695700 . a. wachter and l. t. biegler , `` on the implementation of a primal - dual interior point filter line search algorithm for large - scale nonlinear programming , '' _ mathematical programming _ , 106 , no . 1 , 2557 , 2006 .

this paper considers the collision avoidance problem in a multi - agent multi - obstacle framework . the originality in solving this intensively studied problem resides in the proposed geometrical view combined with differential flatness for trajectory generation and b - splines for the flat output parametrization . using some important properties of these theoretical tools we show that the constraints can be validated at all times . exact and sub - optimal constructions of the collision avoidance optimization problem are provided . the results are validated through extensive simulations over standard autonomous aerial vehicle dynamics . obstacle avoidance , flat trajectory , b - spline basis , mip ( mixed - integer programming ) , uav ( unmanned aerial vehicle ) .

1607.01400

in this paper , we propose a clustering - based iterative algorithm to solve certain optimization problems in machine learning when data size is large and thus it becomes impractical to use out - of - the - box algorithms . we rely on the principle of data aggregation and then subsequent disaggregations . while it is standard practice to aggregate the data and then calibrate the machine learning algorithm on aggregated data , we embed this into an iterative framework where initial aggregations are gradually disaggregated to the extent that even an optimal solution is obtainable . early studies in data aggregation consider transportation problems @xcite , where either demand or supply nodes are aggregated . zipkin @xcite studied data aggregation for linear programming ( lp ) and derived error bounds of the approximate solution . there are also studies on data aggregation for 0 - 1 integer programming @xcite . the reader is referred to rogers _ et al _ @xcite and litvinchev and tsurkov @xcite for comprehensive literature reviews for aggregation techniques applied for optimization problems . for support vector machines ( svm ) , there exist several works using the concept of clustering or data aggregation . evgeniou and pontil @xcite proposed a clustering algorithm that creates large size clusters for entries surrounded by the same class and small size clusters for entries in the mixed - class area . the clustering algorithm is used to preprocess the data and the clustered data is used to solve the problem . the algorithm tends to create large size clusters for entries far from the decision boundary and small size clusters for the other case . et al _ @xcite developed screening rules for svm to discard non - support vectors that do not affect the classifier . et al _ @xcite and doppa _ et al _ @xcite proposed a second order cone programming ( socp ) formulation for svm based on chance constraints and clusters . the key idea of the socp formulations is to reduce the number of constraints ( from the number of the entries to number of clusters ) by defining chance constraints for clusters . after obtaining an approximate solution by solving the optimization problem with aggregated data , a natural attempt is to use less - coarsely aggregated data , in order to obtain a finer approximation . in fact , we can do this iteratively : modify the aggregated data in each iteration based on the information at hand . this framework , which iteratively passes information between the original problem and the aggregated problem @xcite , is known as _ iterative aggregation disaggregation _ ( iad ) . the iad framework has been applied for several optimization problems such as lp @xcite and network design @xcite . in machine learning , @xcite used hierarchical micro clustering and a clustering feature tree to obtain an approximate solution for support vector machines . in this paper , we propose a general optimization algorithm based on clustering and data aggregation , and apply it to three common machine learning problems : least absolute deviation regression ( lad ) , svm , and semi - supervised support vector machines ( s@xmath0vm ) . the algorithm fits the iad framework , but has additional properties shown for the selected problems in this paper . the ability to report the optimality gap and monotonic convergence to global optimum are features of our algorithm for lad and svm , while our algorithm guarantees optimality for s@xmath0vm without monotonic convergence . our work for svm is distinguished from the work of yu _ et al _ @xcite , as we iteratively solve weighted svm and guarantee optimality , whereas they iteratively solve the standard unweighted svm and thus find only an approximate solution . on the other hand , it is distinguished from evgeniou and pontil @xcite , as our algorithm is iterative and guarantees global optimum , whereas they used clustering to preprocess data and obtain an approximate optimum . et al _ @xcite and doppa _ et al _ @xcite are different because we use the typical svm formulation within an iterative framework , whereas they propose an socp formulation based on chance constraints . our data disaggregation and cluster partitioning procedure is based on the optimality condition derived in this paper : relative location of the observations to the hyperplane ( for lad , svm , s@xmath0vm ) and labels of the observations ( for svm , s@xmath0vm ) . for example , in the svm case , if the separating hyperplane divides a cluster , the cluster is split . the condition for s@xmath0vm is even more involved since a single cluster can be split into four clusters . in the computational experiment , we show that our algorithm outperforms the current state - of - the - art algorithms when the data size is large . the implementation of our algorithms is based on in - memory processing , however the algorithms work also when data does not fit entirely in memory and has to be read from disk in batches . the algorithms never require the entire data set to be processed at once . our contributions are summarized as follows . 1 . we propose a clustering - based iterative algorithm to solve certain optimization problems , where an optimality condition is derived for each problem . the proposed algorithmic framework can be applied to other problems with certain structural properties ( even outside of machine learning ) . the algorithm is most beneficial when the time complexity of the original optimization problem is high . we present model specific disaggregation and cluster partitioning procedures based on the optimality condition , which is one of the keys for achieving optimality . 3 . for the selected machine learning problems , i.e. , lad and svm , we show that the algorithm monotonically converges to a global optimum , while providing the optimality gap in each iteration . for s@xmath0vm , we provide the optimality condition . we present the algorithmic framework in section 2 and apply it to lad , svm , and s@xmath0vm in section 3 . a computational study is provided in section 4 , followed by a discussion on the characteristic of the algorithm and how to develop the algorithm for other problems in section 5 . we start by defining a few terms . a _ data matrix _ consists of _ entries _ ( rows ) and _ attributes _ ( columns ) . a machine learning optimization problem needs to be solved over the data matrix . when the entries of the original data are partitioned into several sub - groups , we call the sub - groups _ clusters _ and we require every entry of the original data to belong to exactly one cluster . based on the clusters , an _ aggregated entry _ is created for each cluster to represent the entries in the cluster . this aggregated entry ( usually the centroid ) represents one cluster , and all aggregated entries are considered in the same attribute space as the entries of the original data . the notion of the _ aggregated data _ refers to the collection of the aggregated entries . the _ aggregated problem _ is a similar optimization problem to the original optimization problem , based on the aggregated data instead of the original data . _ declustering _ is the procedure of partitioning a cluster into two or more sub - clusters . we consider optimization problems of the type @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the number of entries of @xmath3 , @xmath4 is @xmath5 entry of @xmath3 , and arbitrary functions @xmath6 and @xmath7 are defined for every @xmath8 . one of the common features of such problems is that the data associated with @xmath3 is aggregated in practice and an approximate solution can be easily obtained . well - known problems such as lad , svm , and facility location fall into this category . the focus of our work is to design a computationally tractable algorithm that actually yields an optimal solution in a finite number of iterations . our algorithm needs four components tailored to a particular optimization problem or a machine learning model . 1 . a _ definition of the aggregated data _ is needed to create aggregated entries . 2 . _ clustering and declustering procedures ( and criteria ) _ are needed to cluster the entries of the original data and to decluster the existing clusters . an _ aggregated problem _ ( usually weighted version of the problem with the aggregated data ) should be defined . an _ optimality condition _ is needed to determine whether the current solution to the aggregated problem is optimal for the original problem . the overall algorithm is initialized by defining clusters of the original entries and creating aggregated data . in each iteration , the algorithm solves the aggregated problem . if the obtained solution to the aggregated problem satisfies the optimality condition , then the algorithm terminates with an optimal solution to the original problem . otherwise , the selected clusters are declustered based on the declustering criteria and new aggregated data is created . the algorithm continues until the optimality condition is satisfied . we refer to this algorithm , which is summarized in algorithm [ algo_aid ] , as _ aggregate and iterative disaggregate _ observe that the algorithm is finite as we must stop when each cluster is an entry of the original data . in the computational experiment section , we show that in practice the algorithm terminates much earlier . create clusters and aggregated data * do * solve aggregated problem check optimality condition * if * optimality condition is violated * then * decluster the clusters and redefine aggregated data * while * optimality condition is not satisfied in figure [ fig : ex_decluster ] , we illustrate the concept of the algorithm . in figure [ fig : ex_decluster_1 ] , small circles represent the entries of the original data . they are partitioned into three clusters ( large dotted circles ) , where the crosses represent the aggregated data ( three aggregated entries ) . we solve the aggregated problem with the three aggregated entries in figure [ fig : ex_decluster_1 ] . suppose that the aggregated solution does not satisfy the optimality condition and that the declustering criteria decide to partition all three clusters . in figure [ fig : ex_decluster_2 ] , each cluster in figure [ fig : ex_decluster_1 ] is split into two sub - clusters . suppose that the optimality condition is satisfied after several iterations . then , we terminate the algorithm with guaranteed optimality . figure [ fig : ex_decluster_3 ] represents possible final clusters after several iterations from figure [ fig : ex_decluster_2 ] . observe that some of the clusters in figure [ fig : ex_decluster_2 ] remain the same in figure [ fig : ex_decluster_3 ] , due to the fact that we selectively decluster . we use the following notation in subsequent sections . 1 . @xmath9 : index set of entries , where @xmath2 is the number of entries ( observations ) 2 . @xmath10 : index set of attributes , where @xmath11 is the number of attributes 3 . @xmath12 : index set of the clusters in iteration @xmath13 4 . @xmath14 : set of clusters in iteration @xmath13 , where @xmath15 is a subset of @xmath16 for any @xmath17 in @xmath18 5 . @xmath19 : last iteration of the algorithm when the optimality condition is satisfied the multiple linear least absolute deviation regression problem ( lad ) can be formulated as @xmath20 where @xmath21 \in \mathbb{r}^{n \times m}$ ] is the explanatory variable data , @xmath22 \in \mathbb{r}^{n}$ ] is the response variable data , and @xmath23 is the decision variable . since the objective function of is the summation of functions over all @xmath24 in @xmath16 , lad fits , and we can use aid . let us first define the clustering method . given target number of clusters @xmath25 , any clustering algorithm can be used to partition @xmath2 entries into @xmath25 initial clusters @xmath26 . given @xmath27 in iteration @xmath13 , for each @xmath28 , we generate aggregated data by where @xmath32 and @xmath33 . to balance the clusters with different cardinalities , we give weight @xmath34 to the absolute error associated with @xmath15 . hence , we solve the aggregated problem @xmath35 observe that any feasible solution to is a feasible solution to . let @xmath36 be an optimal solution to . then , the objective function value of @xmath36 to with the original data is @xmath37 the above procedure keeps cluster @xmath15 if all original entries in the clusters are on the same side of the regression hyperplane . otherwise , the procedure splits @xmath15 into two clusters @xmath47 and @xmath48 , where the two clusters contain original entries on the one and the other side of the hyperplane . it is obvious that this rule implies a finite algorithm . in figure [ fig : lad ] , we illustrate aid for lad . in figure [ fig : lad_1 ] , the small circles and crosses represent the original and aggregated entries , respectively , where the large dotted circles are the clusters associated with the aggregated entries . the straight line represents the regression line @xmath36 obtained from an optimal solution to . in figure [ fig : lad_2 ] , the shaded and empty circles are the original entries below and above the regression line , respectively . observe that two clusters have original entries below and above the regression line . hence , we decluster the two clusters based on the declustering criteria and obtain new clusters and aggregated data for the next iteration in figure [ fig : lad_3 ] . now we are ready to present the optimality condition and show that @xmath36 is an optimal solution to when the optimality condition is satisfied . the optimality condition presented in the following proposition is closely related to the clustering criteria . [ proposition_f_and_e_equivalent ] if @xmath41 for all @xmath42 have the same sign for all @xmath28 , then @xmath36 is an optimal solution to . in other words , if all entries in @xmath15 are on the same side of the hyperplane defined by @xmath36 for all @xmath28 , then @xmath36 is an optimal solution to . further , @xmath49 .

we propose a clustering - based iterative algorithm to solve certain optimization problems in machine learning , where we start the algorithm by aggregating the original data , solving the problem on aggregated data , and then in subsequent steps gradually disaggregate the aggregated data . we apply the algorithm to common machine learning problems such as the least absolute deviation regression problem , support vector machines , and semi - supervised support vector machines . we derive model - specific data aggregation and disaggregation procedures . we also show optimality , convergence , and the optimality gap of the approximated solution in each iteration . a computational study is provided .

0808.0534

the search for the last unobserved particle of the standard model ( sm ) , the higgs boson , has been a major goal of high energy physics for many years , and is a central part of fermilab s tevatron program . direct searches at the cern lep collider have set a 95% c.l . limit on the higgs boson mass of @xmath6 gev @xcite . taking into account this limit , precision electroweak measurements indirectly constrain the sm higgs boson mass to be lower than 190 gev at the 95% c.l . @xcite , which is within reach of the fermilab tevatron collider experiments . previous cdf and results on higgs searches were combined in the tevatron higgs combination presented in april 2008 @xcite . both cdf and have recently reported new and updated searches for the sm higgs boson @xcite-@xcite and their combination @xcite . in this note , we combine the most recent results of all such searches in collisions at which are sensitive to a high mass ( 155 - 200 gev / c@xmath3 ) higgs : the searches for a sm higgs boson decaying to @xmath7 pairs ( the @xmath8 s then decaying leptonically ) and produced through gluon - gluon fusion ( ) , vector boson fusion ( vbf ) , or in association with vector bosons ( and @xmath9 with hadronic @xmath10 decays ) in data corresponding to integrated luminosities of 3.0 at cdf and 3.0 at d . to simplify their combination , the searches are separated into mutually exclusive final states ( see table [ tab : cdfacc ] and [ tab : dzacc ] ) referred to as `` analyses '' in this note . selection procedures for each analysis are detailed in refs . @xcite , and are briefly described below . event selections are similar for the corresponding cdf and d analyses . for the analyses , a large and two opposite - signed , isolated leptons ( any combination of electrons or muons ) are selected , defining three final states ( @xmath11 , @xmath12 , and @xmath13 ) for d . cdf separates the events into five non - overlapping samples , first by separating the events by jet multiplicity ( 0 , 1 or 2 ) , then subdviding the 0 and 1 jet samples in two , one having a low signal / bacgkround ( s / b ) ratio , the other having a higher one . the presence of neutrinos in the final state prevents reconstruction of the higgs boson mass , so other variables have to be used for separating signal from background . in these analyses , the final discriminants are neural - network outputs based on several kinematic variables @xcite . these include likelihoods constructed from matrix - element probabilities as input to the neural network , for cdf . all analyses in these channels have been updated with more data and analysis improvements compared to our previous combination @xcite . the cdf and d experiments also contribute analyses , where the associated @xmath8 boson and the @xmath8 boson from the higgs boson decay which has the same charge are required to decay leptonically , thereby defining like - sign dilepton final states ( @xmath14 , @xmath15 , and @xmath16 ) containing all decays of the third @xmath8 boson . in these analyses , cdf derive the limits from a counting experiment , while for dthe final variable is a likelihood discriminant formed from several topological variables . higgs boson signals ( gluon - gluon fusion , vector boson production , or associated production with vector bosons ) are simulated using pythia @xcite , and cteq6l @xcite parton distribution functions at leading - order ( lo ) . the signal cross sections are normalized to next - to - next - to - leading order ( nnlo ) calculations @xcite , and branching ratios from hdecay @xcite . the @xmath17 production cross section is also corrected for two - loop electroweak corrections @xcite . for both cdf and d , events from multijet ( instrumental ) backgrounds ( `` qcd production '' ) are measured in data with different methods , in orthogonal samples . for cdf , backgrounds from other sm processes were generated using pythia , alpgen @xcite , mc@nlo @xcite and herwig @xcite programs . for d , these backgrounds were generated using pythia , alpgen , and comphep @xcite , with pythia providing parton - showering and hadronization for all the generators . background processes were normalized using either experimental data or next - to - leading order calculations from mcfm @xcite . integrated luminosities , and references to the collaborations public documentation for each analysis are given in table [ tab : cdfacc ] for cdf and in table [ tab : dzacc ] for d . the tables include the ranges of higgs boson mass ( @xmath18 ) over which the searches were performed , but the combination presented in this note is performed only for search of higgs bosons with mass of 155 gev / c@xmath3 or above . we also show in figure [ fig : combollr-2 ] the 1-@xmath22 distribution as a function of the higgs boson mass , which is directly interpreted as the level of exclusion of our search . for instance , both our observed and expected results exclude a higgs boson with @xmath23 165 gev/@xmath5 at @xmath24 92% c.l . cdf collaboration , `` search for higgs boson production in association with w boson with 2.7 '' , + cdf conference note , http://www-cdf.fnal.gov/physics/new/hdg/hdg.html cdf collaboration , `` search for the standard model higgs boson in the missing et and b - jets signature '' , + cdf conference note , http://www-cdf.fnal.gov/physics/new/hdg/hdg.html cdf collaboration , `` search for zh in 2.4 fb-1 '' , + cdf conference note , http://www-cdf.fnal.gov/physics/new/hdg/hdg.html cdf collaboration , `` search for @xmath26 production using 3.0 fb@xmath25 '' , + cdf conference note , http://www-cdf.fnal.gov/physics/new/hdg/hdg.html cdf collaboration , `` combined upper limit on standard model higgs boson production '' , + cdf conference note , http://www-cdf.fnal.gov/physics/new/hdg/hdg.html collaboration , `` combined upper limits on standard model higgs boson production from the d0 experiment with 1.1 - 2.4 fb@xmath25 '' d conference note 5756 . a. djouadi , j. kalinowski and m. spira , `` hdecay : a program for higgs boson decays in the standard model and its supersymmetric extension , '' comput . commun . * 108 * , 56 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9704448 ] . t. junk , nucl . instrum . meth . a434 , p. 435 - 443 , 1999 , a.l . read , `` modified frequentist analysis of search results ( the @xmath38 method ) '' , in f. james , l. lyons and y. perrin ( eds . ) , _ workshop on confidence limits _ , cern , yellow report 2000 - 005 , available through cdsweb.cern.ch .

0.3 in we combine results from cdf and d searches for a standard model higgs boson ( @xmath0 ) in collisions at the fermilab tevatron at @xmath1 tev . with 3.0 of data analyzed at cdf , and 3.0 at d , the 95% c.l . upper limits on higgs boson production are a factor of 1.2 , 1.0 and 1.3 higher than the sm cross section for a higgs boson mass of @xmath2165 , 170 and 175 gev / c@xmath3 , respectively . we exclude at 95% c.l . a standard model higgs boson of @xmath4 gev/@xmath5 . based on simulation , the ratios of the corresponding median expected upper limit to the standard model cross section are 1.2 , 1.4 and 1.7 . compared to the previous higgs tevatron combination , more data and refined analysis techniques have been used . these results extend significantly the individual limits of each experiment and provide new knowledge on the mass of the standard model higgs boson beyond the lep direct searches . + _ preliminary results _ 0.5 in

0904.4682

recent discoveries of red - skewed iron lines in spectra of neutron star ( ns ) sources serpens x-1 @xcite , 4u 1820 - 30 , gx 349 + 2 ( * ? ? ? * c08 hereafter ) and 4u 1636 - 536 @xcite show that the phenomenon of red - skewed lines is not restricted to black hole ( bh ) sources . in this paper we report on the discovery of the asymmetric iron line in the _ suzaku _ spectrum of the ns source cygnus x-2 ( cyg x-2 ) . therefore , cyg x-2 is the fifth ns source which shows strongly asymmetric iron line profile . this indicates that the red - skewed lines in ns sources may be as common as in bh sources . more generally , asymmetric emission lines appear to be abundant in both types of accretion powered x - ray sources . it is crucial to correctly identify the physical origin of the red - skewness of these lines because they can be potentially used to study the properties of the accretion close to accreting objects as well as to constrain the fundamental characteristics of compact objects . c08 interpreted the @xmath1 iron line profiles in terms of relativistically red - shifted emission due to reflection off the accretion disk very close to a compact object . this scenario is commonly accepted as an explanation of strongly red - skewed iron lines in bh sources @xcite . the main motivation for applying the relativistic line formation scenario to the ns case was the fact that the inner radius of the accretion disk , which was predicted by the relativistic line model was consistent with the interpretation of the highest observed kilohertz quasi - periodic oscillation ( khz qpo ) frequency in this sources as a keplerian frequency at this radius . a red - skewed profile of emission lines can be also produced by repeated electron scattering in a diverging outflow as proposed by @xcite , lt07 hereafter , see also references therein . in the framework of the wind model the fluorescent iron line k@xmath2 is formed in the partly ionized wind as a result of illumination by central source . electron scattering of the iron k@xmath0 photons within the ionized expanding flow leads to a decrease of their energy ( redshift ) . this photon redshift is an intrinsic property of any outflow for which divergence is positive . recently @xcite confirmed using multidimensional monte - carlo simulation that for sufficiently high wind densities , moderate fe k@xmath2 emission lines can be formed and that electron scattering in the flow may cause these lines to develop extended red wings . we examine the red - skewed line profile observed in cyg x-2 both in terms of the relativistic paradigm and in the framework of the wind downscattering . the main obstacle in analyzing the high spectral resolution data with the wind model is that analytical solution is not available for the general formulation of this problem . lt07 used monte carlo ( mc ) simulations to model the line profiles produced in the wind environment . in the presented work we provide a consistent analysis of the line profile with the wind model by introducing the lt07 mc code into xspec astrophysical data analysis package . we find that the wind outflow model is able to reproduce the red - skewed line profile with the fit quality similar to that shown by the relativistic reflection models . therefore , in order to distinguish between these two models one has to consider their consistency in a broader phenomenological context . for example , c08 proposed to look for high frequency quasi - periodic oscillations ( hf qpos ) as an additional evidence of a keplerian disk existence close to a ns , which then would necessitate the presence of the reflection components in energy spectra . in contrast , the presence of the opaque wind in the system would result in smearing the signal coming from the central region . this smearing effect leads to a suppression of the fast variability of x - ray emission . unfortunately , high time resolution observations by _ rossi x - ray timing explorer _ ( _ rxte _ ) , simultaneous with the _ suzaku _ observations analyzed in this paper , are not available . thus , we resort to a study based on the _ rxte _ data set with similar spectral characteristics . our comparative analysis indicates that the source was in low variability state during these observations which is more consistent with the wind / outflow scenario . description of _ suzaku _ and supporting _ rxte _ observations as well as details of our spectral fitting are presented are presented in 2 . we discuss implications of the relativistic and wind outflow red - skewed line formation scenarios in cyg x-2 in 3 . conclusions follow in 4 . cyg x-2 is a low mass x - ray binary ( see * ? ? ? * for review ) which exhibits a z - shape color - color diagram @xcite . the observations of thermonuclear x - ray bursts @xcite identified the nature of the compact object in cyg x-2 as a neutron star . @xcite used the _ rxte _ burst data to estimate the ns mass to be about 1.4 solar masses and radius to be about 9 km . @xcite reported the simultaneous detection of twin khz peaks at 500 and 860 hz and highest single khz qpo at 1007 hz . cyg x-2 was observed by _ @xcite on may 16 , 2006 for a total exposure of 39 ksec ( observation i d : 401049010 ) . however , during more than a half of the observation the satellite were operating in the medium telemetry mode which led to the telemetry saturation and resulted in data unusable for scientific analysis . during intervals when the high telemetry setting were utilized the foreground illuminated xis detectors ( i.e. xis 0 , 2 and 3 ) operated in 3@xmath33 event editing mode with burst clock and 1/4 window settings . the 3@xmath33 event editing mode is not available for the xis 1 for this observation . we therefore used data from xis 0 , 2 , and 3 collected when high telemetry rate was utilized . we reduce the _ suzaku _ xis and hxd data using the _ xselect _ data analysis tool following the guidelines given by _ suzaku _ data analysis guide . the xis images indicate that strong pile - up in the center of the source point spread function ( psf ) leads to a characteristic `` crater '' . in order to remove piled - up data we extracted xis spectra from the annulus regions with the outer radius set to the maximum allowed by the xis detector field of view ( @xmath4 arcsec ) and the inner radius was manually selected to excise the most piled - up inner core of psf ( @xmath5 arcsec ) . the spectra and corresponding responses were extracted by _ xselect _ extractor and _ xisresp _ , _ xisrmfgen _ tools . spectra and responses for individual detectors were then added using _ mathpha _ and _ addrmf _ ftools . we linearly rebin xis spectral and response data to obtain 1024 spectral channels . hxd / pin spectrum was corrected for non - x - ray and cosmic x - ray background . we fit xis and pin spectra jointly in xspec using 0.7 - 9.0 kev energy range for xis data and 15.0 - 40.0 kev range for pin data fixing the cross - normalization factor between xis and pin spectra at unity . due to large calibration uncertainties we also ignore 1.5 - 2.5 kev range for xis spectrum . for the continuum spectra we choose the sum of thermal ( bbody ) and comptonized ( comptt ; * ? ? ? * ) components , modified by interstellar photoelectric absorption according to @xcite . when we directly fit the data with this model we observe three distinct narrow features in the residuals ( see figure [ line_res ] , left panel a ) . first , we see a line signature at 6 - 7 kev , which is the primary target of our investigation . we also observe a weak excess around 3.2 kev and a prominent line at 1 kev . the feature at 3.2 kev is probably an instrumental artifact . the line at 1 kev was reported previously from cyg x-2 @xcite and presumably belongs to the source spectrum . both features are well represented by gaussian shape ( see residuals on panel b of figure 1 ) . in addition to these narrow lines we observe a building - up excess towards higher energies in xis spectrum . this indicates a presence of a residual pile - up in the regions close to the excised central part of the psf . to mitigate this effect we utilize the xspec pileup convolution model designed to model pile - up effect in ccd detectors . the xspec implementation of the pile - up model was initially designed to describe this effect in _ chandra _ data . however , the model , developed in @xcite , is valid for _ suzaku _ xis detectors also . _ suzaku _ psf of xis ccds is broader and spreads around larger number of pixels . therefore , pile - up model for the xis spectra would require larger number of regions to be considered for pile - up . to model pile - up in xis detectors we used the following parameter settings for the _ pileup _ xspec model : 2 second time frame , maximum of 10 photons to pile up , unity for grade correction and morphing parameter and 5% of psf to consider for pile - up . the number of detector regions to consider independently for pile - up was allowed to change which led to the best fit value of 38 regions . this is consistent with the number of 3@xmath33 pixel regions close to excised central core of psf . this approach successfully removed the hard excess due to the pile - up effect . finally , we excluded 4.5 - 7.5 kev energy range where the line emission is expected to be significant and fit the spectrum again to obtain the fit quality of @xmath6 . the result is shown in panel d of fig . [ line_res ] . the final best - fit parameters for the continuum model are following : hydrogen column @xmath7 @xmath8 for wabs ; seed photons temperature @xmath9 kev , electron temperature @xmath10 kev , optical depth @xmath11 for comptt and _ bbody _ temperature @xmath12 kev . the energy , sigma and equivalent width ( @xmath13 ) for gaussians used to fit lines are @xmath14 kev , @xmath15 kev , @xmath16 ev and @xmath17 kev , @xmath18 kev , @xmath19 ev . when we include the iron k@xmath0 emission region ( 4.5 - 7.5 kev energy band ) and fit the spectrum with the relativistic and wind line models the parameter ranges of the above continuum parameters change insignificantly ( see table 1 ) . this indicates that continuum model weakly depends on the assumed line model . it is worth noting that the values of the continuum parameters imply that during this _ suzaku _ observation cyg x-2 was in the `` high / soft '' state characterized by high opacity of geometrically thin configuration . panel e in fig . [ line_res ] shows the residuals of the best - fit model with iron region noticed in the data . the apparent line profile is broad and red - skewed . in fact , the fit with the gaussian line model ( model 1 ) produces the worst fit quality among the applied models @xmath20 ( see table 1 ) . we apply physically motivated models to describe this red - skewed line profile . namely , the relativistic models diskline @xcite and laor @xcite and the wind outflow model windline ( lt07 mc code ) . we refer to these models as model 2 , 3 and 4 respectively . the parameters of the laor and diskline models are : the line energy @xmath21 , inner and outer disk radius @xmath22 and @xmath23 , emissivity index @xmath24 and inclination angle @xmath25 . during fitting these relativistic models to the data the value of @xmath23 was fixed at its default value of 1000 @xmath26 and 400 @xmath26 for diskline and the laor respectively . to avoid unphysical results we required the value of the inner radius @xmath22 to be greater than @xmath27 as dictated by the ns compactness limit ( see e.g. * ? ? ? the windline model is not a part of the standard set of xspec models and is implemented as a local model during our modeling . the windline model calculates the line profile by means of mc simulations . the main parameters of the model are the input line energy @xmath21 , the optical depth of the wind @xmath28 , the wind electron temperature @xmath29 and the dimensionless wind speed @xmath30 . the additional fixed parameter of the model is the number of individual photons @xmath31 to be used in the mc simulation . we did nt observe any significant dependence of the @xmath32-statistic behavior on the number of photons used in our line simulations for @xmath31 higher than 3@xmath310@xmath33 . for the presented study we used 5@xmath310@xmath33 photons in the windline mc simulations . we summarize the results of our modeling and fit quality in table 1 . the resulting values of @xmath34 for models 2 , 3 and 4 are 1.31 , 1.30 and 1.32 respectively . in figure [ windline_fit ] we present the unfolded view of spectral fit with model 4 where we used 5@xmath310@xmath35 photons in the mc simulation . we also utilize the data from two _ rxte _ observations made on july 25 , 2006 and september 4 , 2004 ( obs . ids 92039 - 01 - 01 - 01 and 90030 - 01 - 39 - 00 correspondingly ) to investigate the evolution of timing properties of cyg x-2 . we extract the _ rxte_/pca energy spectra from standard2 data modes and we use high resolution modes to calculate power density spectra ( pds ) . we fit _ rxte _ energy spectra in xspec with the model wabs(comptt+bbody+gaussian ) , where gaussian is used to model the iron line . @xmath36 column density was fixed at @xmath37 . we obtain the following best - fit values . for obsid 92039 - 01 - 01 - 01 , comptt : @xmath38 kev ( unconstrained ) , @xmath39 kev , @xmath40 , bbody : @xmath41 kev , gaussian : @xmath42 kev , @xmath43 kev , @xmath44 ev . for obsid 90030 - 01 - 39 - 00 , comptt : @xmath45 kev , @xmath46 kev , @xmath47 , bbody : @xmath48 kev , gaussian : @xmath49 kev , @xmath50 kev , @xmath51 ev . _ spectral parameters for observation i d 90030 - 01 - 39 - 00 match closely those for the _ suzaku _ spectrum_. all sky monitor ( asm ) counts rates in 1.5 - 3/3 - 5/5 - 12 kev energy ranges are 14.06/14.85/14.03 cnts / s and 13.8/14.07/13.2 cnts / s during may 15 , 2006 ( date of _ suzaku _ observation ) and during september 4 , 2004 ( date of 90030 - 01 - 39 - 00 _ rxte _ observation ) respectively , showing almost the same fluxes and source hardness . this also strongly indicates that during the _ suzaku _ observation 401049010 and _ rxte _ observation i d 90030 - 01 - 39 - 00 cyg x-2 was almost in the same state . thus , we can arguably assume that the timing characteristics of the source during _ rxte _ observation 90030 - 01 - 39 - 00 should also be similar to those of the _ suzaku _ observation . in figure [ rxte ] we present _ rxte _ energy spectra along with the power spectra related to _ observations 90030 - 01 - 39 - 00 ( red ) , which are expected to be similar to the analyzed _ suzaku _ observations , and for the observation 92039 - 01 - 01 - 01 ( black ) . the presented evidence for the red - skewed iron line in cyg x-2 along with the detection of the asymmetric lines in serp x-1 , 4u 1820 - 30 , gx 349 + 2 ( * ? ? ? * c08 ) and 4u 1636 - 536 @xcite , increases a number of ns showing this effect to five . this indicates that red - skewed line may be as abundant in ns sources as in bhs ( e.g. * ? ? ? c08 interpreted these observed line appearances as the evidence of relativistic distortion due to the reflection from inner disk located close to the ns surface . the main argument in the association of the line skewness with the inner disk is that the highest observed kilohertz qpo in these sources is consistent with the keplerian frequency at the inner disk radius predicted by the line profile . the diskline model , when applied to the _ suzaku _ ( model 2 ) , leads to the best fit value for the disk inner radius equal to the lower limit set by the model , i.e @xmath52 , which formally translates to the radius of @xmath53 km for the ns mass of 1.4@xmath54 . model 3 , which employs the laor component to represent the iron line , exhibits the same statistical performance as model 2 and yields the radius of 9.5 @xmath26 or 20 km . we should note that the laor model was formulated for the extreme kerr bh case [ see @xcite ] . in this model the spin parameter @xmath55 was assumed to be close to unity . a moderately rotating accreting ns is expected to have a spin parameter less than 0.5 . the ns spin in cyg x-2 is not exactly known but if the difference between khz qpo of @xmath56364 hz is taken as a spin estimate then the space - time background near cyg x-2 should satisfy schwarzshild metric within 10% margin of error . c08 found that their values of @xmath22 were consistent with the inner disk radius predicted by the beat - frequency model @xcite from khz qpo values . maximum khz qpo value observed in cyg x-2 is 1007 khz , which translates to 16.7 km radius if interpreted as a keplerian frequency at the inner disk . this inferred radius is in between the @xmath22 values obtained using diskline and laor models . interpretation of the highest khz qpo peak as a keplerian frequency is not unique . in the framework of the transition layer ( tl ) model the _ lower _ khz qpo peak is classified as a keplerian frequency ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . the tl model successfully describes the behavior of khz qpos in ns sources . the tl model qpo classification leads to the inner disk edge radius of of 22.5 km . beyond this radius the accreting gas enters the tl to adjust its motion to the rotation of the central star . while the value of the disk inner radius given by the diskline model for the iron line can be considered to be in satisfactory agreement with the beat - frequency qpo model , it is harder to reconcile with the tl paradigm . the red - skewed line - khz qpo connection is based on the _ highest observed _ khz qpo values ( c08 ) . however , the duty cycle of khz qpos is low . as noted by c08 , the most compelling evidence for the inner disk origin of the line would come from the simultaneous observation of the khz qpos and the red - skewed iron line . at the time of this writing these two effects were not observed simultaneously from the same source . the reason for absence of the simultaneous detection of khz qpos and broad iron line may be a lack of the correlated observation of high spectral resolution x - ray telescopes ( i.e. _ suzaku_/xmm - newton ) and _ rxte_. the cyg x-2 _ suzaku _ observation analyzed in this paper is a striking example how this lack of simultaneous coverage creates an obstacle in conducting scientific investigation . namely , we have to search _ rxte _ archive for observation with similar spectral characteristics to estimate timing properties ( see the previous section and the discussion below ) while simultaneous _ rxte _ data would allow directly test timing properties more reliably . a general idea about the fast timing properties can be inferred based on the archival _ rxte _ data by matching the spectral parameters shown by _ rxte _ instruments with those observed in the _ suzaku _ spectrum in question . this approach is justified by the firmly established correlations between spectral characteristics and timing properties in ns lmxbs @xcite and particularly in cyg x-2 @xcite . we searched _ rxte _ archive for pointing observations nearest to may 16 , 2006 . despite the fact that _ rxte _ usually conducts frequent monitoring of cyg x-2 , we found that _ observation was made in the middle of 140 day gap in _ rxte _ monitoring of this source . this , and the fact that cyg x-2 is changing its state on a daily basis , does not permit us to test subsecond timing variability directly with _ rxte_. therefore , we have to resort to search for matching spectral properties and rely on spectral - variability correlations . we found that the nearest _ observation with the spectrum similar to the one shown by _ suzaku _ was performed on september 4 , 2004 ( obsid 90030 - 01 - 39 - 00 , see the previous section ) . to compare this observation with the spectral state characterized by harder spectrum and lower opacity we arbitrarily choose the observation 92039 - 01 - 01 - 01 which is fit by comptt model with parameters @xmath40 and @xmath57 . in figure [ rxte ] we show the energy and power spectra for these observations . it is clear that the variability for frequencies higher than 0.1 hz is strongly suppressed and a `` forest''-type pds appears at frequencies above 0.1 hz . the photon spectrum related to this pds closely matches the _ suzaku _ spectral data . this effect of variability suppression can be readily explained by a smearing of a signal in the opaque wind of optical depth @xmath58 because the suppression factor is related to the opacity in the wind as @xmath59 . a higher gaussian equivalent width of 115 ev related to 90030 - 01 - 39 - 00 _ rxte _ observation with respect to that of 86 ev during 92086 - 01 - 01 - 01 observation is another factor to support the low variability - strong line connection . the broad band variability continuum observed in pds can be produced by diffusion of disk small perturbations propagating towards central object . these disk perturbations result in a modulation of inner mass accretion rate , which then leads to variability in the x - ray flux @xcite . @xcite developed a theory of the diffusive propagation of perturbations in the disk and presented a model for the power spectrum formation . application of the diffusion theory to the fourier power spectra of cyg x-2 and bh source cyg x-1 led to the conclusion that the fast x - ray variability is produced in two configurations : in a large cold outer accretion disk and a compact geometrically thick configuration ( i.e. transition layer ) . long - term variations of the accretion matter supply at the outer accretion disk edge lead to changes of the source spectral state . specifically , in high - soft state the innermost region becomes very compact and relatively cold as a result of the strong mass accretion . presumably , this is the state which we are dealing with in the case of _ rxte _ observation 90030 - 01 - 39 - 00 and the _ suzaku _ observation . however , in this case strong accretion disk presumably extended close to the central object should produce high frequency perturbations leading to a broad band pds continuum or khz qpos in the range @xmath60 hz . none of these is seen in our data . this may be attributed to wind / outflow attenuation . it could present a problem for the relativistic disk reflection model of the iron emission line production . we note however , that the origin of fast variability and physical processes governing its evolution are not yet fully understood . therefore , the above arguments does not provide a solid proof for the wind line model or a dismissal of the relativistic reflection scenario . futures studies on the asymmetric emission lines in x - ray binaries should address the above points using more substantial observational data . observation of millisecond variability in the same data which would require wind opacities of 2@xmath563 would provide grounds for the rejection of the wind model . such cases have not been observed yet . on the other hand , further evidence of the correlation of `` forest''-type pds with the asymmetric line would rule out relativistic reflection paradigm . cyg x-2 is a z source @xcite and presumably accretes at a rate close to the eddington limit . therefore , strong outflows are expected in this source , naturally leading to the production of the red - wing of the iron line in this wind / outflow configuration . this hypothesis is supported by the fact that z sources have strong radio counterparts . @xcite analysis of radio / x - ray correlation in z and bright atoll sources that radio and comptonized emission in these sources originate in same optically thick plasma with the temperature 2.5 - 3 kev near ns . moreover , strong requirement for the disk illumination to be concentrated very close to its inner edge @xcite in the relativistic line formation scenario led @xcite to consider the production of fluorescent emission within the innermost stable orbit region where matter spirals into the compact object . however , as indicated by the models of @xcite and @xcite , the ionization of such a disk by the intense x - ray radiation might further invalidate some of basic assumptions associated with this interpretation . these arguments indicate that the wind / outflow paradigm may indeed be at work as ( or at least contribute to ) an origin of the red - skewness in the iron lines in compact sources . we present the analysis of the _ suzaku _ spectrum from ns cyg x-2 . we discover an k@xmath0 iron line which shows significant red - wing . this is the fifth ns source so far to show asymmetric line profile . we analyze the line in terms of the relativistic emission from the inner accretion disk and in terms of the wind outflow model . we conclude that both model are acceptable according to the statistical performance . however , the wind model appears to give more adequate explanation which does not require the accretion disk inner edge to advance close to ns surface . we also consider the line production scenarios in the context of the timing properties . we identify _ rxte _ observation which has spectrum very similar to that during _ suzaku _ observation which shows the red - skewed line . these _ rxte _ data indicate that the source fast variability is strongly suppressed , which can be attributed to smearing in a strong wind . this lack of high frequency variability weakens the red - skewed line connection with khz qpo and strengthens its connection to a wind / outflow phenomena . ballantyne , d.r . , ross , r.r . & fabian , a.c . 2001 , mnras , 327 , 10 bhattacharyya , s. , & strohmayer , t. e. 2007 , , 664 , l103 cackett , e. m. , et al.2008 , , 674 , 415 davis j.e . 2001 , , 562 , 575 56 fabian , a. c. , rees , m. j. , stella , l. , & white , n. e. 1989 , , 238 , 729 fabian , a. c. 1995 , mnras , 277 , l11 hasinger , g. & van der klis , m. 1989 , a&a , 225 , 79 laming , j.m . & titarchuk , l. 2004 , apj , 615 , l121 laor , a. 1991 , , 376 , 90 lattimer , j. m. , & prakash , m. 2007 , , 442 , 109 laurent , p. & titarchuk , l. 2007 , , 656 , 1056 lewin , w. h. g. , van paradijs , j. , & van den heuvel , e. p. j. 1995 , cambridge astrophysics series , cambridge , ma : cambridge university press , |c1995 , edited by lewin , walter h.g . ; van paradijs , jan ; van den heuvel , edward p.j . lyubarskii , yu . , e. 1997 , mnras , 292 , 679 miller , j. m. 2007 , , 45 , 441 miller , m. c. , lamb , f. k. , & psaltis , d. 1998 , , 508 , 791 mitsuda , k. , et al . 2007 , , 59 , 1 morrison , r. , & mccammon , d. 1983 , , 270 , 119 nandra , k. et al . 1999 , apj , 523 , l17 nayakshin , s. , kazanas , d. & kallman , t.r . 2000 , apj , 537 , 833 osherovich , v. , & titarchuk , l. 1999 , , 522 , l113 paizis , a. , et al . 2006 , , 459 , 187 pandel , d. , kaaret , p. , & corbel , s. 2008 , , 688 , 1288 reynolds , c.s . & begelman , m.c . 1997 , apj , 488 , 109 sim , s. a. , long , k. s. , miller , l. , & turner , t. j. 2008 , , 388 , 611 smale , a. p. 1998 , apj , 498 , l141 smale , a. p. , et al . 1993 , apj , 410 , 796 sobolev , v. v. 1957 , soviet astron . , 1 , 678 sunyaev , r. a. , & titarchuk , l. g. 1980 , a&a , 86 , 121 titarchuk , l. 1994 , , 434 , 570 titarchuk , l. 2002 , , 578 , l71 . titarchuk , l. , & shaposhnikov , n. 2002 , , 570 , l25 titarchuk , l. , kuznetsov , s. , & shaposhnikov , n. 2007 , , 667 , 404 titarchuk , l.g . , osherovich , v.a . & kuznetsov , s.i . 1999 , apj , 525 , l129 titarchuk , l. , shaposhnikov , n. & arefiev , v. 2007 , apj , 660 , 556 titarchuk , l. & wood , k. 2002 , apj , 577 , l23 wijnands , r. , et al . 1998 , , 493 , l87 lllll @xmath36 , @xmath61 ......... & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath63 , kev ...... & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath64 , kev ........... & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath65 , kev ......... & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath66 .................... & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath21 , kev .......... & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath67 , kev ............. & [email protected] & - & - & - + @xmath24 ................... & - & [email protected] & 3.0 & - + @xmath22 , @xmath26 .......... & - & 6.0 & [email protected] & - + @xmath68 , deg ............. & - & [email protected] & [email protected] & - + @xmath28 ..................... & - & - & - & [email protected] + @xmath30 , @xmath69 .......... & - & - & - & [email protected] + @xmath29 , kev ......... & - & - & - & [email protected] + @xmath70 , ev .......... & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 37@xmath6215 + @xmath71 ............ & 251.2/187 & 243.3/185 & 241.4/186 & 243.5/185 +

we report on the _ suzaku _ observation of neutron star low - mass x - ray binary cygnus x-2 which reveals a presence of the iron k@xmath0 emission line . the line profile shows a significant red wing . this discovery increases the number of neutron star sources where red - skewed iron lines were observed and strongly suggests that this phenomenon is common not only in black holes but also in other types of accreting compact objects . we examine the line profile in terms of models which attribute its production to the relativistic effects due to reflection of x - ray radiation from a cold accretion disk and also as a result of the line formation in the extended wind / outflow configuration . both models are able to adequately represent the observed line profile . we consider the results of line modeling in the context of subsecond variability . while we were unable to conclusively disqualify one of the models , we find that the wind paradigm has several advantages over the relativistic disk reflection model .

cond-mat0305299

there are many kinds of networks including probably the most influential network of all , the world wide web @xcite . this network is a popular one to analyze because of its size and easy accessibility for statistical analysis . however , there are many other networks that share some of the properties of the web and some that do not . among these networks we find social networks @xcite , collaboration nets @xcite , industrial and business related networks @xcite , transportation nets @xcite and many biological related nets such as food , ecological , and protein interaction networks @xcite and neural networks @xcite . the mathematical description of networks started with the fundamental works of erds and rnyi @xcite , which in the absence of reliable data on large networks were rarely compared to real networks . recently , the computational boom has provided us an increasing number of types of networks and more data on these networks . one of the most exciting discoveries is the scale - free structures of certain evolving networks @xcite . these nets have power law degree distribution , where only a few vertices have many connections to the others and the rest of the graph is rarely connected . to explain the origin of this scale free structure of networks barabsi _ et al_. @xcite suggested the mechanism of preferential attachment and emphasized the key role of growth . in their model the probability of a new node connecting to an existing node is proportional to the degree of the target node . variations on this model include networks where there is aging of nodes , nonlinear attachment probabilities , and re - wiring are allowed . probably the most obvious feature of real networks that is missing from most of the models studied by mathematicians and physicists are characteristics of individual nodes in real networks which influence the connection probability . thus , if the nodes represent individual persons , it is obvious that in many circumstances two people are more likely to become connected in some form of relationship because of the nature of their individual characteristics . our model is motivated by the need to incorporate this idea . a similar idea was used in a preferential attachment model by bianconi and barabsi @xcite who assigned to each new node a fitness parameter . in their model a larger fitness parameter may overcompensate the smaller probability of attachment . in our study we propose a simple model of growing networks whose statistical properties are identical to a more complicated model containing nodes with distinct characteristics . we will calculate the edge distribution of the growing network , the distribution of cluster sizes and the emergence of a giant cluster . we will also show how the number of attempted connections made when a new node is added determines the position and type of the phase transition as well as the cluster size distribution . we first consider a social network model where each node has individual characteristics or traits . each node that is added to the network is assigned a permanent set of random traits which could be coded as an ordered binary string or vector of length @xmath8 . when a node is added it chooses randomly @xmath9 possible partners from the already existing nodes , or if there are less then @xmath10 ( because the simulation has not yet reached time step @xmath11 ) it chooses all the existing nodes as possible partners . a trait distance between the new node and one of its possible partners is calculated based on their trait vectors ( @xmath12 , @xmath13 ) using a distance measure , @xmath14 , such as the hamming distance . then a connection is formed between the two nodes with a probability determined from a given probability distribution over the distance function @xmath15 . different functions , @xmath16 , correspond to different soicopsychological situations . thus , if we wish to model the case where people are more likely to link together if they have similar traits , then @xmath16 would be a monotonically decreasing function of @xmath17 . for this case , the simplest @xmath16 would be to form a link if @xmath17 is below some threshold . this procedure is repeated for each possible partner of the new node . thus , each new node can have initially up to @xmath18 links with the other existing nodes . existing nodes can have more than @xmath18 links as more nodes are added to the network and link up with the existing nodes . there are no multiple links between pairs of nodes . because each node is given a random trait vector , and the nodes to link to are also chosen randomly , many properties of the network simply depend on the probability @xmath19 , that two chosen nodes will link together : @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the probability of the distance @xmath17 between two nodes , and the sum is over all possible distance values . thus , the model is reduced to the following procedure . at each time step we add a node to the network , and attempt to link with @xmath18 existing nodes which are chosen at random . an actual connection is made with a probability @xmath19 . the asymptotic behavior of the network in the limit of large time @xmath22 , does not depend on the initial condition of starting with a single isolated vertex . although frequently structural properties of a network of nodes with trait vectors depends only on @xmath19 , there are other properties which will depend on the detailed form of @xmath16 and the nature of the trait vectors . examples of such properties include the distribution of traits in different parts of the network and the correlation of traits with distance in the network . for example , one can imagine a very simple network of nodes representing men and women . in one network the probability of forming a link is independent of sex , and in the other persons prefer to link up with members of the opposite sex . as long as the mean probability of two chosen nodes linking together is the same in the two scenarios the structural properties of the two networks will be the same , but the distribution of men and women within the network will be quite different in the two cases . in this paper we confine ourselves to the structural properties of networks and are considering these other non - structural properties in our current research . the expected number of edges at a node is approximately @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the time - step when it was created , ( the smaller @xmath25 is , the older the node is ) @xmath22 is the total simulation time , @xmath1 is the probability that two nodes form a connection , @xmath26 is the maximum number of initial connections of a newly created node , and @xmath27 is the @xmath28 harmonic number given by the formula @xmath29 for @xmath30 , and @xmath31 . this equation shows that the number of edges of a node heavily depends on the age of the node . equation ( [ eq : kn ] ) slightly overestimates the number of connections for the oldest nodes in the network in two respects . first , the above formula assumes that a node always has @xmath2 possible initial connections . however , multiple connections between a pair of nodes are not allowed , and there are less than @xmath2 available partners for the initial connections of a node created before or in the @xmath32 time step ( overestimation of initial connections ) . second , the term for the late connections assumes that a node has a @xmath33 chance of being selected as the partner of the @xmath34 node ( which chooses @xmath2 possible partners out of @xmath35 already existing nodes ) . however , for a node created in time step @xmath36 , this term yields a probability of being chosen greater than @xmath37 between time steps @xmath38 and @xmath2 ( where @xmath39 ) that is unacceptable again because multiple connections between a pair of nodes are not allowed ( overestimation of late connections ) . below is the formula correcting these errors , but will use the simpler , uncorrected formula in the remaining part of our paper because the errors are negligible . @xmath40 & \textrm{if } n\leq k+1\\ \delta k\left ( \alpha _ { t}-\ln \left ( n-1\right ) -\frac{1}{2\left ( n-1\right ) } \right ) & \textrm{if } n > k+1\ , , \end{array}\right . \end{array}\ ] ] using @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the euler - mascheroni constant @xcite , and @xmath43 . note that the first @xmath10 nodes are expected to have the same number of connections ( because @xmath44 does not depend on @xmath45 in their case ) , and the edge number starts breaking down exponentially for nodes created after time step @xmath10 ( fig . [ fig : kn_ca ] and [ fig : kn_si]_a _ ) . this means that this growth mechanism is identical to that where the first @xmath46 nodes are created in the same time step . we now wish to determine the edge distribution , @xmath47 , equal to the probability that a node picked at random has on average @xmath48 edges . we return to eq . ( [ eq : kn ] ) ignoring the correction term in eq . ( [ eq : kn_c ] ) , and write the formula for @xmath49 in the simpler form ( fig . [ fig : kn_ca ] and [ fig : kn_si]_a _ ) : @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the same used in eq . ( [ eq : kn_c ] ) . using eq . ( [ eq : kn_a ] ) , neglecting the term @xmath52 in eq . ( [ eq : kn_a ] ) for @xmath25 large enough , and knowing that the age distribution of nodes is uniform , we analytically approximate the edge distribution of the network with the following exponential @xmath53 we used the standard transformation rule for random variables , @xmath54 with @xmath55 . for sufficiently large @xmath22 , due to the definition of @xmath51 , this can be effectively approximated by a distribution which is independent of @xmath22 ( fig . [ fig : kn_ca ] and [ fig : kn_si]_b _ ) : @xmath56 we can also determine a slightly different degree or edge distribution which is the percentage of nodes with @xmath57 edges . denote by @xmath58 the expected number of nodes with degree @xmath59 at time @xmath22 . the number of isolated nodes , @xmath60 , will increase by @xmath61 , which is the probability of the addition node not connecting to any existing node , and decrease on average by @xmath62 : @xmath63 the formula for the expected number of nodes of degree @xmath64 is a bit complicated . for ( @xmath65 ) there are two ways to increase @xmath66 : either selecting degree @xmath35 nodes for connection with the new node or the new node having exactly @xmath59 edges . for ( @xmath67 ) , the new node can not contribute to @xmath68 . the decrease will be proportional to the probability of choosing a degree @xmath59 node for attachment . these equations are correct as @xmath70 , and numerical simulations show that @xmath71 . substituting this form into the equations for @xmath72 we obtain @xmath73 this degree distribution @xmath74 decays exponentially consistent with our previous result for @xmath47 . in some network models , such as the preferential attachment models , all the nodes belong to a single cluster . for such models the focus is on the degree distribution and the distance between nodes in the network . however , our network can contain a number of disconnected clusters of nodes . then the key questions become what is the cluster size distribution and is there a phase transition between a collection of finite size clusters and the appearance of a giant cluster much larger than the rest . the transition is similar to that in percolation , with our parameter @xmath19 playing the role of the site occupation probability in a percolation model . the key difference between our model and percolation models is that our nodes do not sit on a lattice structure , and there is thus no geometric constraints . the definition of a giant cluster in our model is somewhat different than a spanning cluster in percolation models . nevertheless , some of the behavior is similar . our model is similar to one by calloway _ et al_. @xcite where an infinite order phase transition was found . in that model after a node was added to the network , two nodes were picked at random and connected with probability @xmath19 . our model is more general in that we consider the effect of making more than one link at any given time . also , in our model the new links are between the added node and exisiting nodes , whereas in the model by calloway _ et al _ the new links are between any two nodes in the network . to determine the cluster distribution we use a procedure similar to the one we used to calculate the degree distribution . the cluster number @xmath75 denotes the expected number of clusters of size @xmath76 . on average , at each time step , @xmath61 isolated nodes arrive at the network and @xmath77 nodes will be chosen for attachment reducing @xmath78 . thus , @xmath79 is described by @xmath80 for @xmath81 new clusters of size @xmath76 come from connecting the new node to a cluster of size @xmath82 or if @xmath83 using the new node to make connections between smaller clusters whose sizes add up to @xmath76 . reducing @xmath84 will be @xmath85 nodes from clusters of size @xmath76 connecting to the new node . thus , we have @xmath86 @xmath87 @xmath88 @xmath89 @xmath90 the first sum in eq . ( [ eq : cd3 ] ) determines the number of sums in the next term . each of these sums represent a cluster that is melted into the @xmath76 sized cluster . these equations are valid for @xmath91 , where the probability of closed loops tends to zero . the giant cluster , if there exists one , is an exception in which connection of nodes in loops is not negligible . thus , eq . ( [ eq : cd3 ] ) holds only for the finite sized clusters in the network . this property lets us determine a generating function which we can use to find the size of the giant cluster . our simulations show that solutions of eqs . ( [ eq : cd ] ) , ( [ eq : cd2 ] ) and ( [ eq : cd3 ] ) are of the steady state form @xmath92 . using this form in eqs . ( [ eq : cd ] ) , ( [ eq : cd2 ] ) and ( [ eq : cd3 ] ) , we find @xmath93 @xmath94 @xmath95 generally we can not obtain a simpler equation for the cluster size distribution @xmath96 , except for @xmath3 . substituting @xmath3 into the eqs . ( [ eq : cd4 ] ) , ( [ eq : cd5 ] ) and ( [ eq : cd6 ] ) we obtain after some algebra the general result @xmath97 which can be written in the form : @xmath98 where @xmath99 denotes the gamma - function . ( [ eq : cd2k1 ] ) shows that the cluster size distribution for @xmath3 always follows a power - law distribution . this result is confirmed by simulations shown in the left graph of fig . [ fig : clx ] . distributions of cluster sizes for @xmath100 ( right graph of fig . [ fig : clx ] ) , in contrast to @xmath3 show power - law behavior only near the phase transition . fig . [ fig : s1 ] shows the simulation results for @xmath101 , the ratio of the average size of the largest cluster to the total number of nodes versus the connection probability @xmath1 . the figure suggests that there is a smooth transition in the appearance of @xmath101 at a specific value of @xmath19 between @xmath102 and @xmath103 which depends on the parameter @xmath104 to predict the position of a possible phase transition @xmath105 @xcite , we will use a generating function for the cluster size distribution @xcite . to derive the generating function we use the iterative eqs . ( [ eq : cd4 ] ) , ( [ eq : cd5 ] ) , and ( [ eq : cd6 ] ) . the generating function will be of the form : @xmath106 where @xmath107 is the probability that a randomly chosen node is from a cluster of size @xmath108 . multiplying both size of eqs . ( [ eq : cd4 ] ) , ( [ eq : cd5 ] ) and ( [ eq : cd6 ] ) by @xmath109 , and summing over @xmath110 we derive a differential equation for @xmath111 @xmath112 rearranging for @xmath113 we obtain @xmath114 which can be further simplified to @xmath115 the generating function for the finite size clusters is exactly one at @xmath116 when there is no giant cluster in the network and @xmath117 otherwise . hence @xmath118 without an analytic solution for eqs . ( [ eq : gf5 ] ) , we calculate @xmath119 numerically by integrating eqs . ( [ eq : gf5 ] ) with the initial condition @xmath120 where @xmath121 is small . this is equivalent to starting with a cluster of only one node . in fig . [ fig : s1 ] there are results from direct simulations of the model ( symbols ) and solid lines from the integration of the generating function . the agreement is good which verifies the approximations . to discuss the phase transition location we first consider the cases @xmath122 . consider the expected value that a randomly chosen node belongs to a finite size cluster . we can determine this quantity in terms of the generating function @xmath111 @xmath123 for those values of @xmath1 where no giant cluster exists , @xmath124 , @xmath125 and both the numerator and denominator of eq . ( [ eq : gf5 ] ) goes to zero as @xmath126 . using lhopital s rule we derive a quadratic equation for @xmath127 . the solution of this equation is @xmath128 for @xmath129 . because as @xmath130 all clusters will have size 1 , one can show that the correct solution of eq . ( [ eq : pt2 ] ) is the one with the negative sign . in addition from eq . ( [ eq : pt2 ] ) we can find the location of the phase transition . it is the value of @xmath1 where the solution of eq.[eq : pt2 ] becomes complex : @xmath131 in the region where there is a giant cluster @xmath132 , eq . ( [ eq : gf5 ] ) becomes as @xmath133 @xmath134 which is still not solvable analytically . making the approximation @xmath135 when @xmath136 , we can simplify eq . ( [ eq : pt4 ] ) close to @xmath105 : @xmath137 where @xmath138 , @xmath139 , and @xmath140 . in fig . [ fig : g1 ] we show the simulation results and the above derived theoretical functions for @xmath141 . we can see that for @xmath142 , where we have an explicit expression for @xmath141 in terms of the parameters @xmath2 and @xmath1 the fit is very good . for @xmath139 the fit is good close to the phase transition point , where the approximation @xmath143 holds . although below @xmath144 the description of @xmath141 is very good , it seems that the location of the phase transition and the value of the function @xmath141 above @xmath105 is somewhat different than the data . also if we carefully check fig . [ fig : g1 ] at the jumps , we find that the larger the jump the less accurate the theory seems to be . this can be explained as follows . at the critical point the average size of finite clusters jumps , hence much larger clusters appear in the network . as we can only simulate for a finite time large ( but not the giant ) clusters are underrepresented . the weights of them computed from the simulation data are less then they would be in an infinitely long simulation . away from the transition regime fewer finite size clusters remain beside the giant cluster in the network , and thus the distribution can be specified better . although the formalism using the generating function can be done for @xmath3 , the meaning of a giant cluster is problematic . in section [ sec : cluster ] we showed that the size - distribution of clusters for @xmath3 always follows a power - law which means there is no obvious border between the ` giant ' cluster and smaller clusters . there is not a sharp break between the largest and the next largest cluster . the physical reason for this is that clusters grow only by the addition of newly added nodes . this is different than the case for @xmath145 and in percolation models where clusters can also grow by a link combining two clusters . in this sense no giant cluster appears in the network except for @xmath146 . ( [ eq : gf5 ] ) becomes @xmath147 which becomes @xmath148 in the limit @xmath149 with @xmath129 . applying lhopital s rule yields @xmath150 at @xmath151 , @xmath152@xmath153 , which means the average size of finite clusters approaches infinity . from the definition of @xmath111 in eq . ( [ eq : gf1 ] ) and the power - law cluster size distribution for @xmath96 , it follows that @xmath129 for any @xmath154 . to see that @xmath155@xmath156 as @xmath149 for @xmath157 , we consider the sum form of the generating function in eq . ( [ eq : gf1 ] ) . for large @xmath108 , @xmath158 eq . ( [ eq : cd2k1 ] ) , and @xmath159 , which can not be summed for @xmath160 when @xmath161 the probability of a new node not joining a cluster is higher then joining , and thus the weight of small clusters is higher than that of larger clusters , and hence the average size remains finite . as @xmath162 , the probability of forming clusters increases and so do the weight of large clusters . to show the nature of our phase transitions @xcite , we numerically integrated eq . ( [ eq : gf5 ] ) for different values of @xmath2 near the corresponding critical @xmath105 . in fig.[fig : loglogs ] the linear parts of the log(-log(s ) ) plots suggest that @xmath163 and because all derivatives of @xmath101 vanish at @xmath105 , the transition is of infinite order . table [ tbl : fl ] contains the parameters of the fitted straight lines in fig . [ fig : loglogs ] . as the calculations were done close to the numerical limit and referring to the similar results in @xcite we conjecture that @xmath164 equals @xmath165 for all @xmath2 . this result suggests that the mechanism of the transition is common and the number of possible partners for each node to link to determines the speed of emergence of the giant cluster @xmath166 these results are in accord with eq . ( [ eq : pt5 ] ) , the average cluster size decrease is approximately independent of @xmath167 but the size of the jump and the rate of decrease is driven by @xmath2 . the present model was intended to gain insight into the evolution of various social networks by considering mechanisms that account for heterogeneity in the population of participating entities . to analyse the statistical properties of the generated network we simplified the model . we found that the structure of the network dramatically changes when the number of possible links to a newly added node increases from @xmath3 to @xmath100 . with @xmath3 the network does not form a giant cluster but the average cluster size goes to infinity ( at @xmath168 ) in contrast to @xmath169 , where the giant cluster appears in an infinite - order phase transition and the average cluster size jumps discontinuously but remains finite . the size of the jump corresponds to how slowly the giant cluster overcomes the other competitive large clusters . however , there is no transition for @xmath3 , where none of the clusters can absorb other clusters . the distribution of the size of finite clusters always follows an exponential distribution , both below and above the critical point for @xmath83 , while the model studied in @xcite is in a critial state below and at the critical point and exhibits an exponential distribution of cluster size above the transition as in a berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless phase transition . thus , even though there are disconnected clusters as in our model , there are significant differences in the behavior of the cluster size distribution . our model is similar to a previous model of callaway _ et al . _ @xcite , but there are essential differences in several points due to nature of the growth algorithm : in the model of callaway _ et al . _ network growth and connection formation are independent while in our model only newly added nodes form connections . also , in our model multiple connections might be formed in one time step depending on parameters @xmath18 and @xmath19 . this difference is well reflected in the generating function derived for the two models . the structural properties of our model are more relevant to many social networks than other growth models such as preferential attachment because the degree distribution is exponential which is closer to real social systems and because there are clusters of nodes which represents the reality of social systems where people usually form various communities which are relatively isolated from each other . as long as the distribution of nodal traits are random , then the structural properties which we have discussed in this paper do not depend on the nature of the traits and thus our network model should be relevant to any social network . the next step is to analyze the distribution of traits on a social network . this will vary depending on how the attachment rule depends on the values of these traits even though the structural properties of the network remains the same . we will discuss the distribution of traits on a network in a future publication . we introduced a model of growing social networks and analyzed its statistical properties . our analytical calculations showed that these growing networks exhibit exponential degree distributions . we gave an explicit description of the expected number of edges which showed an exponential dependence on the age of a node . we also showed that emergence of a giant cluster and the cluster - size distribution strongly depend on the number of possible initial partners . numerical simulations suggested that the generated networks have scale free cluster distributions only at the phase transition point . in all other regions of the phase space the cluster distribution was exponential . in the absence of an exact solution for eq . ( [ eq : gf5 ] ) , we showed numerical results suggesting that the order of the phase transition is infinite , which is similar to the results found by @xcite . we acknowledge support from the henry r. luce foundation , the national science research council ( otka ) grant no . t038140 , and the national science foundation , grant no .

in this study we introduce and analyze the statistical structural properties of a model of growing networks which may be relevant to social networks . at each step a new node is added which selects @xmath0 possible partners from the existing network and joins them with probability @xmath1 by undirected edges . the ` activity ' of the node ends here ; it will get new partners only if it is selected by a newcomer . the model produces an infinite - order phase transition when a giant component appears at a specific value of @xmath1 , which depends on @xmath2 . the average component size is discontinuous at the transition . in contrast , the network behaves significantly different for @xmath3 . there is no giant component formed for any @xmath1 and thus in this sense there is no phase transition . however , the average component size diverges for @xmath4 . @xmath5__department of biophysics kfki research institute for particle and nuclear physics of the hungarian academy of sciences budapest , hungary _ _ @xmath6__center for complex systems studies , kalamazoo college , kalamazoo , mi 49006 , usa _ _ _ @xmath7physics department , kalamazoo college , kalamazoo , mi 49006 , usa _

0905.1662

the equilibrium ( thermodynamic ) isotope effect ( eie ) is defined as the effect of isotopic substitution on the equilibrium constant . denoting an isotopolog with a lighter ( heavier ) isotope by a subscript _ ( _ h _ ) , the eie is defined as the ratio of equilibrium constants@xmath6 where @xmath7 _ _ _ _ and @xmath8 are molecular partition functions per unit volume of reactant and product . we study a specific case of eie - the equilibrium ratio of two isotopomers . in this case , the eie is equal to the equilibrium constant of the isotopomerization reaction , @xmath9 where superscripts _ r _ and _ p _ refer to reactant and product isotopomers , respectively . usually , equilibrium isotope effects are computed only approximately:@xcite in particular , effects due to indistinguishability of particles and rotational and vibrational contributions to the eie are treated separately . furthermore , the vibrational motion is approximated by a simple harmonic oscillator and the rotational motion is approximated by a rigid rotor . in general , none of the contributions , not even the indistinguishability effects can be separated from the others.@xcite however , at room temperature or above the nuclei can be accurately treated as distinguishable , and the indistinguishability effects can be almost exactly described by symmetry factors . on the other hand , the effective coupling between rotations and vibrations , anharmonicity of vibrations , and non - rigidity of rotations can in fact become more important at higher temperatures . for simplicity , from now on we denote these three effects together as anharmonicity effects and the approximation that neglects them the harmonic approximation ( ha ) . in some cases the effects of anharmonicity of the born - oppenheimer potential surface on the value of eie can be substantial.@xcite ishimoto _ _ have shown that the isotope effect on certain barrier heights can even have opposite signs , when calculated taking anharmonicity effects into account and in the ha.@xcite our goal is to describe rigorously equilibria at room temperature or above . therefore , two approximations that we make are the born - oppenheimer approximation and the distinguishable particle approximation ( we treat indistinguishability by appropriate symmetry factors ) . the error due to the born - oppenheimer approximation was studied for h / d eie by bardo and wolfsberg,@xcite and by kleinman and wolfsberg,@xcite and was shown to be of the order of 1 % in most studied cases . since we assume that nuclei are point charges , the born - oppenheimer approximation implies that the potential energy surface is the same for the two isotopomers . the differences of born - oppenheimer surfaces due to differences of nuclear volume and quadrupole of isotopes can be important for heavy elements@xcite , but these are not studied in this work . symmetry factors themselves result in an eie equal to a rational ratio , which can be computed analytically . in order to separate the symmetry contributions from the mass contributions to the eie , it is useful to introduce the reduced reaction free energy,@xmath10 where @xmath11 and @xmath12 are the symmetry factors discussed in more detail in sec . [ sec : examples ] . to include the effects of quantization of nuclear degrees of freedom beyond the ha rigorously we use the feynman path integral representation ( pi ) of the partition function . the quantum reduced reaction free energy can then be computed by thermodynamic integration with respect to the mass of the isotopes . to compute the derivative of the free energy efficiently , we use a generalized virial estimator . the advantage of this estimator is that its statistical error does not increase with the number of imaginary time slices in the discretized path integral . as a consequence , converged results can be obtained in a significantly shorter simulation than with other estimators . the ultimate goal would be to combine the path integral methodology with _ ab initio _ potentials . however , since millions of samples are required , the computational expense results in the following compromise : first , the equilibrium isotope effects are computed using _ ab initio _ potentials , but as usual , within the ha . then all anharmonicity corrections are computed using the pi methodology , but with semiempirical potentials . in other words , we take advantage of the higher accuracy of the _ ab initio _ potentials to compute the harmonic contribution to the eie and then make an assumption that the anharmonicity effects are similar for _ ab initio _ and semiempirical potentials . after describing theoretical features of the method , we apply it to hydrocarbons used in experimental measurements of isotope effects on [ 1,5 ] sigmatropic hydrogen transfer reactions . two of them were recently used by doering _ @xcite who reported equilibrium ratios of their isotopomers . this allows us to validate our calculations as well as to discuss the apparent discrepancy in measurements of doering _ et al . _ from a theoretical point of view . the outline of the paper is as follows : in sec . [ sec : method ] , we describe a rigorous quantum - mechanical methodology to compute the eie . section [ sec : examples ] presents the [ 1,5 ] sigmatropic hydrogen shift reactions on which we test the methodology , explains how _ ab initio _ methods can be combined with the pi to compute the eie , and discusses in detail symmetry effects in these reactions . section [ sec : computational - details ] explains the implementation of the method in amber 10 and describes details of calculations and error analysis of our pimd simulations . results of calculations are presented and compared with experiments in sec . [ sec : results ] . section [ sec : discussion - and - conclusions ] concludes the paper . eie can be calculated by a procedure of thermodynamic integration@xcite with respect to the mass . this method takes advantage of the relationship@xmath13,\label{eq : ti}\ ] ] where @xmath14 is the ( quantum ) free energy and @xmath15 is a parameter which provides a smooth transition between isotopomers @xmath16 and @xmath17 . this can be accomplished , e.g. , by linear interpolation of masses of all atoms in a molecule according to the equation @xmath18 in contrast to the partition function itself , the integrand of eq . @xmath19 is a thermodynamic average and therefore can be computed by either monte carlo or molecular dynamics simulations . classically , the eie is trivial and eq . can be evaluated analytically . when quantum effects are important , this simplification is not possible . to describe quantum thermodynamic effects rigorously , one can use the path integral formulation of quantum mechanics.@xcite in the path integral formalism , thermodynamic properties are calculated exploiting the correspondence between matrix elements of the boltzmann operator and the quantum propagator in imaginary time.@xcite in the last decades , path integrals proved to be very useful in many areas of quantum chemistry , most recently in calculations of heat capacities,@xcite rate constants,@xcite kinetic isotope effects,@xcite or diffusion coefficients.@xcite let @xmath20 be the number of atoms , @xmath21 the number of spatial dimensions , and @xmath22 the number of imaginary time slices in the discretized pi ( @xmath23 gives classical mechanics , @xmath24 gives quantum mechanics ) . then the pi representation of the partition function @xmath25 in the born - oppenheimer approximation is @xmath26,\label{eq : pi_qr}\\ c & \equiv\left(\frac{p}{2\pi\hbar^{2}\beta}\right)^{npd/2}\prod_{i=1}^{n}m_{i}^{pd/2}.\label{eq : pi_prefactor}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath27 is the set of cartesian coordinates associated with the @xmath28@xmath29 time slice , and @xmath30 is the effective potential @xmath31 the @xmath22 particles representing each nucleus in @xmath22 different imaginary time slices are called `` beads . '' each bead interacts via harmonic potential with the two beads representing the same nucleus in adjacent time slices and via potential @xmath32 attenuated by factor @xmath33 with beads representing other nuclei in the same imaginary time slice . by straightforward differentiation of eq . we obtain the so - called thermodynamic estimator ( te),@xcite @xmath34 a problem with expression is that its statistical error grows with the number of time slices . a similar behavior is a well known property of the thermodynamic estimator for energy,@xcite where the problem is caused by the kinetic part of energy . of imaginary time slices in the path integral . all results obtained by 1 @xmath35 long simulations ( with the time step 0.05 @xmath36 ) of compound * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * ( @xmath38 ) using gaff force field , normal mode pimd , and nos - hoover chains of thermostats . [ fig : gve_te_values ] ] of imaginary time slices in the path integral . all results obtained by 1 @xmath35 long simulations ( with the time step 0.05 @xmath36 ) of compound * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * ( @xmath38 ) using gaff force field , normal mode pimd , and nos - hoover chains of thermostats . note that the rmse of the gve is not only non - increasing ( as expected from theory ) , but in fact decreases slightly with increasing @xmath22 , which is due to the decrease of correlation length.[fig : gve_te_errors ] ] the growth of statistical error of the thermodynamic estimator for energy is removed by expressing the estimator only in terms of the potential and its derivatives using the virial theorem.@xcite in our case , a similar improvement can be accomplished , if a coordinate transformation , @xmath39 is introduced into eq . prior to performing the derivative . here , the `` centroid '' coordinate is defined as @xmath40 in other words , first the `` centroid '' coordinate @xmath41 is subtracted , and then the coordinates are mass - scaled . resulting generalized virial estimator ( gve)@xcite takes the form @xmath42 . \label{eq : gve}\ ] ] its primary advantage is that the root mean square error ( rmse ) of the average , @xmath43 , is approximately independent on the number of imaginary time slices @xmath22,@xmath44 in this equation @xmath45 denotes the length of the simulation and @xmath46 is the correlation length . the convergence of values and statistical errors of both estimators as a function of number @xmath22 of imaginary time slices for systems studied in this paper is discussed in section [ sec : computational - details ] . as expected , up to the statistical error they give the same values as can be seen in fig . [ fig : gve_te_values ] . nevertheless , when quantum effects are important , and a high value of @xmath22 must be used , the gve is the preferred estimator since it has much smaller statistical error and therefore converges much faster than the te ( see fig . [ fig : gve_te_errors ] ) . thermodynamic average in eq . can be evaluated efficiently using the path integral monte carlo ( pimc ) or path integral molecular dynamics ( pimd ) . in pimc , gradients of @xmath47 in eq . result in additional calculations since the usual metropolis monte carlo procedure for the random walk only requires the values of @xmath47 . this additional cost can be , however , reduced either by less frequent sampling , or by using a trick in which the total derivative with respect to @xmath15 ( not the gradients ! ) is computed by finite difference.@xcite in case of pimd , the presence of gradients of @xmath47 in eq . does not slow down the calculation since forces are already computed by a propagation algorithm . although in principle , a pimc algorithm for a specific problem can always be at least as efficient as a pimd algorithm , in practice it is much easier to write a general pimd algorithm and so pimd is usually the algorithm used in general software packages . since pimd was implemented in amber 9,@xcite we have implemented the methodology described above for computing eies into amber 10.@xcite this implementation is what was used in calculations in the following sections . in pimd , equation is augmented by fictitious classical momenta @xmath48 , @xmath49.\label{eq : pi_qp}\ ] ] the normalization prefactor @xmath50 is chosen in such a way that the original prefactor @xmath51 in eq . is reproduced when the momentum integrals in eq . are evaluated analytically . the partition function is formally equivalent to the partition function of a classical system of cyclic polyatomic molecules with harmonic bonds . each such molecule represents an individual atom in the original molecule and interacts with molecules representing other atoms via a potential derived from the potential of the original molecule.@xcite this system can be studied directly using well developed methods of the classical molecular dynamics . it is useful to see how the general path integral expressions , , and behave in the low and high temperature limits . as temperature decreases , the difference of the reduced free energies of isotopomers approaches the difference of their zero point energies ( zpes ) . therefore , still assuming that indistinguishability is correctly described by symmetry factors , the low temperature limit of the eie is equal to @xmath52,\label{eq : eie_low_temp}\ ] ] where @xmath53 denotes the zpe . at high temperature , the system approaches its classical limit . in this limit , we can set the number of imaginary time slices @xmath23 , and the eie can be computed analytically using partition function , which becomes@xmath54.\end{split}\label{eq : q_class}\ ] ] again , for isotopomers the mass dependent factors cancel out upon substitution into eq . , along with all other terms except for the integrals . although the born - oppenheimer potential surface is the same for all isotopomers , the integrals do not cancel out since the integration is not performed over the whole configuration space , but only over parts attributed to reactants or products . particles are treated as distinguishable in the classical limit and the volumes of the configuration space corresponding to reactants and products are generally different . after the reduction , eie becomes exactly equal to the ratio of the symmetry factors , @xmath55 we examine the eie for four related compounds . the parent compound ( 3__z__)-penta-1,3-diene ( compound * 1 * ) is the simplest molecule to model the [ 1,5 ] sigmatropic hydrogen shift reaction . two of its isotopologs , tri - deuterated ( 3__z__)-(5,5,5-@xmath56h@xmath37)penta-1,3-diene ( * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * ) and di - deuterated ( 3__z__)-(1,1-@xmath56h@xmath5)penta-1,3-diene ( * 1 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * ) ( see fig . [ fig : equlibrium_pent ] ) were used by roth and knig to measure an unusually high value of the kinetic isotope effect ( kie ) on the [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift reaction with respect to the substitution of hydrogen by deuterium.@xcite this result pointed to a significant role of tunneling in [ 1,5 ] sigmatropic hydrogen transfer reactions . subsequently , much theoretical research was devoted to the study of this reaction . here we calculate final equilibrium ratios of products of this reaction , which , to our knowledge , were not theoretically predicted so far . hydrogen shift reaction in ( 3__z__)-(5,5,5-@xmath56h@xmath37)penta-1,3-diene ( * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * ) and in ( 3__z__)-(1,1-@xmath56h@xmath5)penta-1,3-diene ( * 1 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * ) . if all contributions except for those due to symmetry factors @xmath58 and @xmath59 were neglected , one would obtain approximate equilibrium constants @xmath60 and @xmath61 in both cases.[fig : equlibrium_pent ] ] two other compounds , 2-methyl-10-(10,10-@xmath56h@xmath5)methylenebicyclo[4.4.0]dec-1-ene ( * 2 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * ) and 2,4,6,7,9-pentamethyl-5-(5,5-@xmath56h@xmath5)methylene-11,11a - dihydro-12_h_-naphthacene ( * 3 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * ) ( see fig . [ fig : equilibria_cyclic ] ) , were recently used by doering _ _ to confirm and possibly refine the experimental value of the kie on the [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift.@xcite in contrast to ( 3__z__)-penta-1,3-diene * * ( * * compound * 1 * ) , where the s-_trans _ conformer incompetent of the [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift is the most stable , pentadiene moiety in compounds 2 and 3 is locked in the s-_cis _ conformation . this not only increases the reaction rate , but also rules out the ( very small ) effect of the eie on the kie due to the shift in s-_cis_/s-_trans _ equilibrium . for both molecules doering _ et al . _ reported final equilibrium ratios of isotopomers . despite the similarity of compounds * 2 * and * 3 * , these ratios are qualitatively different . indeed , one motivation for measuring eie in compound * 3 * was that doering _ et al . _ suspected that in the case of * 2 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * the equilibrium ratio might be modified by unwanted side reactions , mainly dimerizations . one of our goals is to elucidate this discrepancy from the theoretical point of view . as can be seen in figs . [ fig : equlibrium_pent ] and [ fig : equilibria_cyclic ] , the final equilibrium of the [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift reaction of all examined compounds can be described as an outcome of two reactions . the second reaction ( leading from deuterio - methyl - dideuterio - methylene to dideuterio - methyl - deuterio - methylene in tri - deuterated compounds and from dideuterio - methyl - methylene to deuterio - methyl - deuterio - methylene in di - deuterated compounds ) produces a mixture of species that differ by the orientation of the mono - deuterated methylene group . due to a high barrier for rotation of this group , the two products can not be properly sampled in a single pimd simulation . therefore an additional pimd simulation is necessary , as shown on the example of * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * in fig . [ fig : pimd-3steps - pent ] . the reduced free energy of the second step is then calculated as @xmath62,\label{eq : f_red_2step_pimd}\ ] ] where 1/2 is the ratio of symmetry factors and @xmath63 and @xmath64 stand for equilibrium constants obtained by the second and third pimd simulations , respectively . together they represent the second reaction step . hydrogen shift reaction in ( 3__z__)-(5,5,5-@xmath56h@xmath37)penta-1,3-diene ( * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * ) . half white , half black spheres represent deuterium atoms . the methyl group , in contrast to methylene , rotates during simulations . [ fig : pimd-3steps - pent ] ] unfortunately , at present the pimd method can not be used in conjunction with higher level _ ab initio _ methods , due to a high number of potential energy evaluations needed . semiempirical methods , which can be used instead , do not achieve comparable accuracy . we therefore make the following two assumptions : first , we assume that the main contribution to the eie can be calculated in the framework of ha . second , we assume that selected semiempirical methods are accurate enough to reliably estimate the anharmonicity correction . the anharmonicity correction is calculated as @xmath65 with these two assumptions , we can take advantage of both pimd and higher level methods by adding the semiempirical anharmonicity correction to the ha result calculated by a more accurate method . the ha value of @xmath66 is obtained by boltzmann averaging over all possible distinguishable conformations , @xmath67},\label{eq : f_red_ha}\ ] ] where @xmath68 is the number of `` geometrically different isomers '' of a reactant . by geometrically different isomers we mean species differing in their geometry , not species differing only in positions of isotopically substituted atoms . @xmath69 is the electronic energy ( including nuclear repulsion ) of @xmath70 isomer , @xmath11 is the symmetry factor and @xmath71 are partition functions of the nuclear motion of @xmath11 isotopomers . @xmath72 , @xmath12 , @xmath73 denote analogous quantities for the product . although symmetry effects can be computed analytically , for the reactions studied in this paper they are nontrivial and so we discuss them here in more detail . as mentioned above , we are interested in moderate temperatures ( above @xmath74 @xmath2 ) where quantum effects might be very important but the distinguishable particle approximation remains valid . in this case , effects of particle indistinguishability and of non - distinguishing several , in principle distinguishable minima , by an experiment can be conveniently unified by the concept of symmetry factor . in our setting , we will call `` symmetry factor '' the product@xmath75 here , @xmath76 refers to the number of distinguishable minima not distinguished by the experiment and @xmath77 are the usual rotational symmetry numbers * * * * of symmetric rotors . the symmetry numbers are present only if either the whole molecule or some of its parts are treated as free or hindered classical symmetrical rotors . ( in this case , the number of minima of the hindered rotor potential is not included in @xmath76 . ) the symmetry numbers are not present if rotational barriers are so high that the corresponding degrees of freedom should be considered as vibrations . the concept can be illustrated on an example of the mono- and non - deuterated methyl group in a rotational potential with three equivalent minima 120@xmath78 apart . at low temperatures , when hindered rotation of the methyl group reduces to a vibration , the symmetry factor is determined only by @xmath76 . in the case of mono - deuterated methyl group there are three in principle distinguishable minima corresponding to three rotamers , which are , as we suppose , considered to be one species by the observer . therefore @xmath79 . in the case of non - deuterated methyl there is only one distinguishable minimum and @xmath80 . at higher temperatures , when the methyl group can be treated as a hindered rotor , its contribution to the symmetry factor is determined only by rotational symmetry number @xmath81 , where @xmath82 for a mono - deuterated methyl group and @xmath83 for a non - deuterated methyl group . from definition , it is clear that the high and low temperature pictures are consistent and give the same ratios of symmetry factors . partition functions @xmath84 and @xmath85 needed in calculation of the reduced free energy in eq . are computed as sums of partition functions of @xmath86 and @xmath87 isotopomers . in this subsection , we will discuss the accuracy of four electronic structure methods used in our calculations . ab initio mp2 and the b98 density functional method,@xcite both in combination with the 6 - 311+(2df , p ) basis set , were used for calculations within the ha . semiempirical am1@xcite and scc - dftb@xcite methods were used in both ha and pimd calculations . this allowed us to compute the error introduced by the ha . aside from symmetry factors , the eie is dominated by vibrational contributions . therefore we concentrate mainly on the accuracy of ha vibrational frequencies . according to merrick _ _ et al.,__@xcite who tested the performance of mp2 and b98 methods by means of comparison with experimental data for a set of 39 molecules , rmse of zpes is 0.46 @xmath88 at mp2/6 - 311+(2df , p ) and 0.31 @xmath88 at b98/6 - 311+(2df , p ) level of theory . appropriate zpe scaling factors are equal to 0.9777 and 0.9886 respectively . corresponding rmses of frequencies are 40 @xmath89 and 31 @xmath90 therefore , a slightly higher accuracy can be expected from the b98 functional . the accuracy of both semiempirical methods is significantly worse than the accuracy of higher level _ ab initio _ methods . according to witek and morokuma , the rmse of am1 frequencies in comparison to experimental values for 66 molecules is 95 @xmath89 with frequency scaling factor equal to 0.9566.@xcite the error of vibrational frequencies obtained using scc - dftb depends on parametrization . we tested two parameter sets : the original scc - dftb parametrization@xcite and the parameter set optimized with respect to frequencies by malolepsza _ _ et al.__@xcite ( further designated scc - dftb - mwm ) . the error of vibrational frequencies calculated with the original scc - dftb parameters was studied by krger _ _ et al.__@xcite the mean absolute deviation from the reference values calculated at blyp / cc - pvtz for a set of 22 molecules was 75 @xmath89 . the error of the reference method itself , as compared to an experiment with a slightly smaller set of molecules was 31 @xmath89 . in the above mentioned study performed by witek and morokuma , rmse of 82 @xmath89 with scaling factor 0.9933 was obtained.@xcite the scc - dftb - mwm mean absolute deviation of experimental and calculated frequencies for a set of 14 hydrocarbons is indeed better and is equal to 33 @xmath89 instead of 59 @xmath89 for the original parametrization . @xcite the suitability of am1 , scc - dftb , scc - dftb - mwm , and several other semiempirical methods for our systems was tested by comparison of eie values in the ha and of potential energy scans with the corresponding quantities computed with mp2 and b98 . results of this comparison are presented in the appendix . the am1 method is shown to reproduce _ ab initio _ eies in the ha very well , but fails to reproduce scans of potential energies of methyl and vinyl group rotations . therefore , in addition to am1 method we used the scc - dftb method , which is , among the semiempirical methods tested by us , the best in reproducing _ ab initio _ potential energy scans . on the other hand , compared to am1 , scc - dftb gives a worse eie in the ha . statistical rmses of averages of pimd simulations were calculated from the equation @xmath91 where @xmath81 is the rmse of one sample . correlation lengths @xmath46 were estimated by the method of block averages.@xcite at constant temperature , the correlation length decreases with increasing number of imaginary time slices . also , for constant number of imaginary time slices , the correlation length decreases with increasing temperature . finally , the correlation length stays approximately constant at different temperatures , if the number of imaginary time slices is chosen so that @xmath92 is converged to approximately the same precision . in our systems , correlation length is close to 3.5 @xmath93 . the eie was studied at four different temperatures : 200 , 441.05 , 478.45 , and 1000 @xmath2 using the normal mode version of pimd.@xcite to control temperature , the nos - hoover chains with four thermostats coupled to each pi degree of freedom were used.@xcite . different numbers @xmath22 of imaginary time slices had to be used at different temperatures , since at lower temperatures quantum effects become more important , and the number of imaginary time slices necessary to maintain the desired accuracy increases . to examine the required value of @xmath22 as a function of temperature we used the gaff force field.@xcite whereas the accuracy of vibrational frequencies calculated using the gaff force field is relatively low [ rms difference of gaff and b98/6 - 311+(2df , p ) frequencies of compound * 1 * is equal to 125 @xmath89 ] , the potential should be realistic enough for the assessment of the convergence with respect to @xmath22 . for example , the difference of potential energies @xmath95 between s-_cis _ and s-_trans _ conformations of compound * 1 * is 4.3 @xmath96 as compared to 2.7 @xmath96 obtained by mp2/6 - 311+(2df , p ) or 3.5 @xmath96 obtained by b98/6 - 311+(2df , p ) . to check the convergence at 478.45 @xmath2 , we calculated values of the integral in eq . for the deuterium transfer reaction in * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * with 40 and 48 imaginary time slices ( using simpson s rule with 5 points ) . their difference is equal to 0.00005 @xmath97 0.00040 @xmath96 . this is less than the statistical error of the calculation on the model system , which itself is smaller than the error of production calculations , since the model calculation was 10 times longer than the longest production calculation . therefore , taking into account the accuracy of production calculations , @xmath98 can be considered the converged number of imaginary time slices . this is further supported by the observation of the convergence of the single value of the gve at @xmath38 . the relative difference of gve values obtained with 40 and 48 imaginary time slices is equal to 0.22 @xmath97 0.02 % , whereas the difference between 40 and 72 imaginary time slices equals to 0.39 @xmath97 0.04 % . the discretization error is asymptotically proportional to @xmath99 . by fitting this dependence to the calculated values , we estimated the difference between the values for @xmath98 and for the limit @xmath24 to be less than 0.6 % . this is only three times more than the difference between @xmath98 and @xmath100 . therefore , if the integral converges similarly as the gve , we can use the aforementioned difference between 40 and 48 imaginary time slices as the criterion of convergence . the convergence of the gve with the number of imaginary time slices is displayed in fig . [ fig : gve_te_values ] . since 441.05 @xmath2 is close enough to 478.45 @xmath2 we used the same value of @xmath22 at this temperature . to check the convergence at 200 and 1000 @xmath2 , we observed only the convergence of the single value of the gve . at 200 @xmath2 the relative difference of gve values at @xmath38 obtained with @xmath101 and @xmath102 is 0.03 @xmath97 0.07 % . based on the comparison with the previous result , @xmath101 is considered sufficient . at 1000 @xmath2 , the relative difference of gve values at @xmath38 for @xmath103 and @xmath104 equals to 0.1 @xmath97 0.02 % , so that 24 imaginary time slices are used further . the time step at 441.05 and 478.45 @xmath2 was 0.05 @xmath36 to satisfy the requirement of energy conservation . at 200 and 1000 @xmath2 , a shorter step of 0.025 @xmath36 was used due to the increased stiffness of the harmonic bonds between beads at 200 @xmath2 and due to the increased average kinetic energy at 1000 @xmath2 . the simulation lengths differed for different molecules . for both isotopologs of compound * 1 * simulation length of 1 @xmath35 ensured that the system properly explored both the s-_trans _ and the s-_cis _ conformations . convergence was checked by monitoring running averages and by comparing the ratio of the s-_trans _ and s-_cis _ conformers with the ratio calculated in the ha . the length of converged pimd simulations of compound * 2 * was 500 @xmath93 . convergence was checked again using running averages and by visual analysis of trajectories to ensure that the system properly explored all local minima . for compound * 3 , * the simulation length was 400 @xmath93 . the integral in eq . was calculated using the simpson s rule . using the am1 potential , the gve was evaluated for five values of @xmath15 , namely for @xmath105 . convergence was checked by comparison with values obtained using the trapezoidal rule . since the dependence of the estimator on the parameter @xmath15 is almost linear , the difference between the two results remained well under the statistical error . using the scc - dftb potential , the dependence on @xmath15 was less smooth . as a result , nine equidistant values of @xmath15 were needed to achieve similar convergence . in one case , as many as 17 values of @xmath15 had to be used . lcccc & 1@xmath106 step @xmath66 & @xmath107 & 2@xmath108 step @xmath66 & @xmath107 + + am1 ( pimd ) & 0.0395 & [email protected] & -0.0154 & [email protected] + scc - dftb ( pimd ) & 0.1245 & [email protected] & -0.0616 & [email protected] + b98 ( ha ) + @xmath109 & 0.0587 & & -0.0248 & + mp2 ( ha ) + @xmath109 & 0.0770 & & -0.0338 & + + am1 ( pimd ) & -0.0283 & [email protected] & 0.0191 & [email protected] + scc - dftb ( pimd ) & -0.1142 & [email protected] & 0.0610 & [email protected] + b98 ( ha ) + @xmath109 & -0.0466 & & 0.0282 & + mp2 ( ha ) + @xmath109 & -0.0645 & & 0.0372 & + the pimd calculations were performed using amber 10.@xcite the part of amber 10 code , which computes the derivative @xmath110 with respect to the mass was implemented by one of us and can be invoked by setting itimass variable in the input file . several posible ways to compute the derivative are obtained by combining one of two implementations of pimd in ` sander ( ` either the multisander implementation or the les implementation ) with either the nos - hoover chains of thermostats or the langevin thermostat , with the normal mode or `` primitive '' pimd , and with the te or gve . calculating the value of @xmath110 for compound * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * using gaff force field , at @xmath38 , @xmath111 @xmath2 , and for several values of @xmath22 , we confirmed that all twelve possible combinations give the same result . for example , fig . [ fig : gve_te_values ] shows the agreement of the gve and te . nevertheless , the twelve methods differ by rmses of @xmath110 ( due to different statistical errors of estimators and correlation lengths ) and by computational costs . as expected , the most important at higher values of @xmath22 is the difference of statistical errors of gve and te . figure [ fig : gve_te_errors ] compares the dependence of the rmse of the gve and te on the number @xmath22 of imaginary time slices . for @xmath112 , the converged simulation with gve is approximately 100 times faster than with te . less significant differences of rmses are due to differences in correlation lengths . as expected , for primitive pimd with langevin thermostat the correlation length depends strongly on collision frequency @xmath113 of the thermostat . the correlation length is approximately 450 - 500 @xmath36 for @xmath114 @xmath115 , falling down quickly to 120 - 150 @xmath36 for @xmath116 @xmath115 and to 5 @xmath36 for @xmath117 @xmath115 , then rising slowly again . this can be compared to correlation length of 10 - 20 @xmath36 of the primitive pimd thermostated by nos - hoover chains of 4 thermostats per degree of freedom . a smaller difference can be found between correlation lengths of the normal mode ( 3 - 8 @xmath36 ) and primitive pimd ( 10 - 20 @xmath36 ) . all pimd calculations were performed in amber 10.@xcite all mp2 and b98 calculations as well as am1 and pm3 semiempirical calculations in the ha were done in gaussian 03 revision e01.@xcite dftb and scc - dftb calculations in the ha used the dftb+ code , version 1.0.1.@xcite scc - dftb harmonic frequencies were computed numerically using analytical gradients provided by the dftb+ code . the step size for numerical differentiation was set equal to 0.01 @xmath118 . this value was also used by krger _ _ et al.__@xcite in their study validating the scc - dftb method and their frequencies differed from purely analytical frequencies of witek _ _ et al.__@xcite by at most 10 @xmath89 . to diagonalize the resulting numerical hessian , we used the ` formchk ` utility included in the gaussian program package . ( 3__z__)-penta-1,3-diene ( compound * 1 * ) is the simplest of examined molecules . its non - deuterated isotopolog has three distinguishable minima : the s-_trans _ conformer , which is the global minimum and two s-_cis _ conformers related by mirror symmetry . strictly speaking , in pentadiene the s-_cis _ species have actually _ gauche _ conformations due to sterical constraints . in their original experiments , roth and knig studied two isotopologs , * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * and * 1 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57*. the eies of both isotopologs were computed using the pimd methodology of sec . [ sec : method ] at 478.45 @xmath2 . resulting reduced free energies are listed in table [ tab : f_pentadiene ] . note that the anharmonicity correction is very similar for am1 and scc - dftb methods , even though the main part of obtained in the ha ( substantially differs for the two methods . this indicates that the corrections are fairly reliable in this case and can be used to correct results of higher level methods obtained in the ha . the anharmonicity correction is as large as 20 % of the final value of the reduced free energy . unfortunately , the difference between mp2 and b98 in the ha is still approximately four times larger than the anharmonicity correction . .equilibrium ratios of [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift reactions of * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * and * 1 - 1,1-__d__@xmath57 * at 478.45 @xmath2 . [ tab : eq_ratios_pentadiene ] [ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ] to conclude , the combination of higher level methods in the ha with pimd using semiempirical methods for the rigorous treatment of effects beyond the ha proved to be a viable method for accurate calculations of eies . using the generalized virial estimator for the derivative of the free energy with respect to the mass we were able to obtain accurate results at lower temperatures in reasonable time ( @xmath0 times faster than with thermodynamic estimator ) , since the statistical error is independent on the number of imaginary time slices . two semiempirical methods , am1 and scc - dftb , were used for calculation of the anharmonicity correction , both giving very similar results . calculations showed , that the anharmonicity effects account up to 30 % of the final value of the reduced free energy of considered reactions . the anharmonicity correction always decreases the absolute value of the reduced reaction free energy . this is consistent with the qualitative picture in which higher vibrational frequencies of hydrogens are lowered by the anharmonicity of a potential more than lower frequencies of deuteriums . this in turn is due to a higher amplitude of vibrations of lighter hydrogen atoms . the lower difference between frequencies of unsubstituted and deuterated species results in the lower absolute value of the reduced reaction free energy . unfortunately , the inaccuracy of the _ ab initio _ electronic structure methods used in our study is still of at least the same order as the anharmonicity corrections . for isotopologs of compound * 1 * , we predicted equilibrium ratios and free energies of the [ 1,5 ] sigmatropic hydrogen shift reaction . a comparison with experimental results was not possible due to a low precision of the original measurement . for compound * 2 * , the disagreement between theoretical and experimental data supports the suspicion by authors of the measurement that the accuracy of their results was compromised by dimerization side reactions . on the other hand , the agreement of theoretically calculated ratios with experimental observations in the case of compound * 3 * suggests that the isolation of the [ 1,5 ] hydrogen shift reaction from disturbing influences was successfully achieved and the observed eie and kie can be considered reliable . we acknowledge the start - up funding provided by epfl . we express our gratitude to daniel jana for his assistance with scc - dftb calculations , to h. witek for providing us the set of frequency optimized scc - dftb parameters , and to j. j. p. stewart for the mopac2007 code used for testing the pm6 method . to determine the suitability of semiempirical methods used in our pimd calculations , we first compared values of the eie in the ha . the b98 and mp2 methods served as a reference . as can be seen from fig . 6 in the paper , which shows the temperature dependence of @xmath66 of the first step of deuterium transfer reaction in * 1 - 5,5,5-__d__@xmath37 * , the difference between b98 and mp2 at temperatures below 500 @xmath2 is close to 0.02 kcal / mol . so is the difference between am1 and b98 methods . on the other hand , the scc - dftb method clearly overestimates the extent of eie compared to both higher level methods . a very similar trend was observed in all examined reactions . other semiempirical methods tested were pm3@xcite and scc - dftb - mwm , which are not included in fig . 6 in the paper for clarity the pm3 method overestimates the eie similarly to scc - dftb , whereas the scc - dftb - mwm curve is somewhat closer to _ ab initio _ curves than the scc - dftb one . to conclude , from this point of view am1 is the preferred semiempirical method . during simulations , the pentadiene molecule often passes two potential energy barriers . these are the barrier for the hindered rotation of the methyl group and the barrier for the rotation of the vinyl group , which connects s-_trans _ and s-_cis _ conformations . relaxed potential energy scans of these two motions were employed as the second criterion to assess the relevancy of semiempirical methods . methods tested were mp2 , b98 , am1 , scc - dftb , scc - dftb - mwm , pm3 , rm1,@xcite pm3carb-1,@xcite pddg / pm3,@xcite and pm6.@xcite potential surface scans with pm3carb1 , rm1 , pm3/pddg methods were calculated using the public domain code mopac 6 . pm6 potential surface scans were performed in mopac 2007.@xcite results for the methyl group rotation are shown in fig . [ fig : methyl_scan ] . the height of the am1 barrier is only 0.005 @xmath96 . moreover , positions of minima do not agree with b98 and mp2 . on the other hand , the scc - dftb method matches higher level methods closely . from other semiempirical methods pm3 performs best in this aspect . the height of the barrier is relatively well reproduced also by pddg / pm3 , rm1 and scc - dftb - mwm methods , but positions of extrema of the potential energy surface are incorrect . figure [ fig : vinyl_scan ] shows potential energy scans of the s-_trans_/s-_cis _ rotation of the vinyl group . again , the scc - dftb method matches higher level methods closely . all other methods ( with the exception of dftb ) give too low barrier heights as well as too low energy differences between s-_trans _ and s-_cis _ conformations . also note that the potential energy surfaces of pm3 and related methods ( pddg / pm3 and pm3carb-1 ) are not smooth in the gauche region . this peculiarity of the pm3 potential surface can be seen also in the potential surface scan performed by liu _ _ et al.__@xcite based on these results we concluded that none of the semiempirical methods except for scc - dftb is able to sufficiently improve the am1 potential energy surface . whereas the frequency optimized variant of the scc - dftb method ( scc - dftb - mwm ) improves the eie in the ha , it does not retain the scc - dftb accuracy in the potential surface scans . hence we decided to use the am1 and scc - dftb potentials for pimd calculations . to conclude , am1 performs very well in ha , but it can not properly describe potential surfaces of the two rotational motions realized during simulations . on the other hand , scc - dftb gives worse results in ha , but it reproduces both barriers very well .

a general and rigorous methodology to compute the quantum equilibrium isotope effect is described . unlike standard approaches , ours does not assume separability of rotational and vibrational motions and does not make the harmonic approximation for vibrations or rigid rotor approximation for the rotations . in particular , zero point energy and anharmonicity effects are described correctly quantum mechanically . the approach is based on the thermodynamic integration with respect to the mass of isotopes and on the feynman path integral representation of the partition function . an efficient estimator for the derivative of free energy is used whose statistical error is independent of the number of imaginary time slices in the path integral , speeding up calculations by a factor of @xmath0 at @xmath1 @xmath2 and more at room temperature . we describe the implementation of the methodology in the molecular dynamics package amber 10 . the method is tested on three [ 1,5 ] sigmatropic hydrogen shift reactions . because of the computational expense , we use ab initio potentials to evaluate the equilibrium isotope effects within the harmonic approximation , and then the path integral method together with semiempirical potentials to evaluate the anharmonicity corrections . our calculations show that the anharmonicity effects amount up to @xmath3 of the symmetry reduced reaction free energy . the numerical results are compared with recent experiments of doering and coworkers , confirming the accuracy of the most recent measurement on 2,4,6,7,9-pentamethyl-5-(5,5-@xmath4h@xmath5)methylene-11,11a - dihydro-12_h_-naphthacene as well as concerns about compromised accuracy , due to side reactions , of another measurement on 2-methyl-10-(10,10-@xmath4h@xmath5)methylenebicyclo[4.4.0]dec-1-ene .

1110.6056

the polarization bell states of a pair of quantized spatiotemporal electromagnetic modes @xmath0 and @xmath1 are @xmath2 and @xmath3 where @xmath4 and @xmath5 , for @xmath6 , denote single - photon states of horizontal and vertical polarization , respectively . these states form a maximally - entangled basis for the two - qubit hilbert space of single - photon states for modes @xmath0 and @xmath1 . as such , they are extremely important for applications such as quantum teleportation @xcite , quantum superdense coding @xcite , and quantum key distribution @xcite , as well as their fundamental role in the clauser - horne - shimony - holt ( chsh ) inequality @xcite . the standard approach to generating these states is to post - select the biphoton output from spontaneous parametric downconversion ( spdc ) @xcite , and the standard approach to verify their entanglement behavior is via quantum - interference measurements @xcite . recently , chen _ et al . @xcite reported an experiment that mimicked the quantum - interference behavior seen with an spdc entanglement source using two independent pseudothermal light beam obtained by passing laser light through a rotating ground - glass diffuser . their experiments were carried out in the low - flux regime using photon - coincidence counting , and they provided a quantum - mechanical explanation that ascribed their observations to two - photon interference , just as is the case for spdc light . _ it has long been known that the semiclassical theory of photodetection in which light is treated as a classical electromagnetic wave and the fundamental photodetection noise is the shot noise arising from the discreteness of the electron charge produces quantitatively identical predictions to those obtained from quantum photodetection theory when the illumination is in a classical state , i.e. , a coherent - state or a statistical mixture of such states . see @xcite for a detailed review of this topic . except for any excess noise it may carry , laser light is coherent - state light . moreover , its propagation through ground - glass diffusers , free space , optical fibers , and beam splitters are all linear transformations , for which classical - state inputs yield classical - state outputs . it follows that there must be an explanation for the experiments reported in @xcite that relies on semiclassical photodetection theory , i.e. , one that only needs classical electromagnetic waves . our purpose in this paper is to present that explanation . furthermore , although we will begin with a treatment that applies to low - flux operation using photon - coincidence counting , our approach readily extends to high - flux operation using photocurrent cross - correlation . the remainder of the paper is organized as follows . in sec . 2 we describe the modified mach - zehnder interferometer with photon - coincidence counting in the low - flux regime that was employed in @xcite . in sec . 3 we introduce our classical - light model for this interferometer , and use it to derive the singles and coincidence rates as functions of the interferometer s differential time delay and its polarization - analysis angles . here we will show that our results explain the observations reported in @xcite . finally , in sec . 4 , we indicate how our theory can be extended to high - flux operation with photocurrent cross - correlation , and we provide some concluding remarks about the implications of our work . the configuration for the experiment from @xcite is shown in figure 1 . a continuous - wave mode - locked ti : sapphire laser operating at @xmath7 nm wavelength with 78mhz pulse - repetition frequency and a @xmath8fs pulse duration illuminated an interference filter , to somewhat increase the pulse duration , followed by a rotating ground - glass diffuser , to render the light spatially incoherent . the diameter @xmath9 mm output beam from the diffuser was divided by the 50 - 50 beam splitter bs1 , with the resulting output beams propagating @xmath10 mm ( from the diffuser ) to collection planes , one of which could be offset , longitudinally , by @xmath11 . each collection plane contained the tip of a single - mode fiber , whose transverse coordinates , @xmath12 and @xmath13 , satisfied @xmath14 , where @xmath15 m is the correlation length of the speckles cast in these planes . the fibers routed the light they collected to polarizers p1 and p2 , set for orthogonal polarizations that we shall take to be @xmath16 and @xmath17 , respectively , before entering the 50 - 50 beam splitter bs2 . the outputs from bs2 then underwent polarization analysis , by analyzers a1 and a2 set for angles @xmath18 and @xmath19 with respect to @xmath16 , prior to single - photon detection . computer processing completed the experiment by averaging the detector outputs over many pulses to obtain the singles rates @xmath20 and @xmath21 and the coincidence rate @xmath22 . is the nominal ground - glass to fiber - tip propagation distance , and @xmath11 is a variable offset in one arm . p1 and p2 are polarizers that select orthogonal polarizations that we shall take to be @xmath16 and @xmath17 , respectively . a1 and a2 are polarization analyzers set for angles @xmath18 and @xmath19 , respectively . @xmath23 and @xmath24 are single - photon detectors , width=360 ] chen _ et al . used quantum - mechanical analysis to show that @xmath22 consisted of a background term plus a quantum interference term that is proportional to @xmath25 when @xmath26 . their background term arises from what in a related prior experiment @xcite they called `` self - intensity correlations . '' these correlations can be measured by summing the coincidence rates when a beam block is placed in front of the fiber tip at @xmath12 and when a beam block is placed in front of the fiber tip at @xmath13 . subtracting the self - intensity correlations from the full coincidence rate obtained at @xmath26 then yields , according to theory , a unity - visibility quantum interference pattern . that background - subtracted quantum - interference pattern can then be used to obtain a violation of the chsh inequality , in the same manner that is done @xcite for the polarization - entangled signal and idler obtained from an spdc source . the experimental data from @xcite bears out this theory : the authors report @xmath27% visibility in their background - subtracted quantum - interference pattern at @xmath26 . _ chen _ et al . do not attempt to explain their experiments with a classical - light model , i.e. , with semiclassical photodetection theory . in their previous work on a related anticorrelation experiment @xcite , they claimed there was no classical - light explanation for their results . we , however , have shown that such is not the case @xcite . in particular , we reported a straightforward classical - field analysis that reproduced the essential characteristics of the anticorrelation observed in @xcite . our demonstration is especially important for the following reason . were chen _ @xcite correct in asserting that their anticorrelation measurement could not be explained in this manner it would present quantum optics with a major conundrum : either laser light that has undergone linear transformation is _ not in a coherent state or a random mixture of coherent states , or the quantum and semiclassical theories of photodetection _ can make different quantitative predictions for the measurement statistics of classical - state light . in the present paper , we shall extend our scalar - wave model from @xcite to provide a classical - light explanation for the simulated bell - state reported in @xcite . the linear velocity of the ground - glass diffuser where it was illuminated in @xcite was @xmath280.8 m/s , so that for the @xmath29fs and @xmath30fs post - if pulse durations considered therein it is fair to say that the ground glass was completely stationary while a single laser pulse propagated through it . we shall assume that to be the case for the experiments in @xcite . the differential time delay @xmath31 corresponding to the longitudinal variation @xmath11 was @xmath32ps in @xcite and we will assume that the photodetectors employed therein had the same @xmath33ns coincidence gate as in @xcite . hence , with @xmath34ps , we have that @xmath35 . because the fibers are single mode , and because their transverse coordinates have been set to ensure that the light beams they collect are uncorrelated , we will assume ( cf . @xcite ) that @xmath36 and @xmath37 , the positive - frequency _ classical fields emerging from polarizers p1 and p2 , respectively , are given by @xmath38 and @xmath39 here : @xmath40 and @xmath41 are independent , identically distributed , zero - mean , isotropic , complex - valued gaussian random variables with common mean - squared strength @xmath42 representing constant - in - time speckle ; @xmath43 is a transform - limited gaussian pulse normalized to satisfy @xmath44 with @xmath45 being the post - if pulse duration ; and @xmath46 , @xmath47 are orthogonal unit vectors along the @xmath16 and @xmath17 directions . note that in ( [ eplus ] ) and ( [ eminus ] ) we have chosen @xmath48 units , so that the average energy in either field is @xmath49 , i.e. , @xmath50 is their average photon number . _ _ et al . used photon - coincidence counting , their experiment was necessarily in the low - brightness regime wherein @xmath51 prevails . as a result , we can say that the singles rates ( counts / gate ) and the coincidence rate ( coincidences / gate ) obey @xcite @xmath52 and @xmath53 in these expressions : @xmath54 is the photodetectors quantum efficiency ; the complex envelopes of the fields that illuminate detectors @xmath23 and @xmath24 are @xmath55 and @xmath56 where we have suppressed all propagation delays except for the interferometer s differential delay @xmath57 . using the statistics of @xmath40 and @xmath41 , along with the disparities between @xmath45 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 , it is easy to evaluate the singles rates and the coincidence rate . _ the statistical independence of the @xmath40 and @xmath41 , and their mean - squared strengths , immediately gives us @xmath59 & + & \left . \langle |v_-|^2\rangle \sin^2(\theta_k)\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\,|f(t-\delta t/2)|^2\right ) \\[.05 in ] & \approx & \frac{\eta n}{2 } , \quad \mbox{for $ k = a , b$},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the approximation follows from @xmath60 . similarly , for the coincidence rate , the statistical independence of @xmath40 and @xmath41 leads to @xmath61 & + & c_a^2s_b^2\langle |v_+|^2\rangle \langle |v_-|^2\rangle \int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\,|f(t_+)|^2\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,|f(u_-)|^2 \nonumber \\[.05 in ] & + & c_b^2s_a^2\langle |v_+|^2\rangle \langle |v_-|^2\rangle\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\,|f(t_-)|^2\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,|f(u_+)|^2 \nonumber \\[.05 in ] & -&2c_ac_bs_as_b\langle |v_+|^2\rangle \langle |v_-|^2\rangle\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\!\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,{\rm re}[f^*(t_+)f^*(u_-)f(t_-)f(u_+ ) ] \nonumber \\[.05 in ] & + & \left.s_a^2s_b^2\langle |v_-|^4\rangle \int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\,|f(t_-)|^2\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,|f(u_-)|^2\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath62 and @xmath63 , for @xmath64 , @xmath65 , for @xmath66 , and the first and last terms on the right are the self - intensity correlations . following @xcite , we shall suppress these self - intensity correlations they can be found by first measuring the coincidence rate with @xmath36 blocked and then measuring the coincidence rate with @xmath37 blocked by subtracting them from @xmath22 and focus our attention on @xmath67 & + & c_b^2s_a^2\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\,|f(t_-)|^2\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,|f(u_+)|^2 \nonumber \\[.05 in ] & -&\left.2c_ac_bs_as_b\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\!\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,{\rm re}[f^*(t_+)f^*(u_-)f(t_-)f(u_+ ) ] \right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the mean - squared values of @xmath40 and @xmath41 . now , by exploiting @xmath68 and some trigonometric identities , we can reduce the preceding expression to @xmath69 . \label{ctilde}\ ] ] at this point we are ready to compare our classical - light theory with the experimental results from @xcite . there it is shown that @xmath70 leads to an anticorrelation dip of width @xmath28@xmath45 in @xmath71 as @xmath57 is scanned through zero . moreover , this anticorrelation dip has near - unity visibility , viz . , @xmath72 from ( [ ctilde ] ) we find @xmath73 in agreement with those observations . likewise , chen _ et al . find that when @xmath74 and @xmath75 there is a near - unity visibility correlation peak of width @xmath28@xmath45 in @xmath71 as @xmath57 is scanned through zero . from ( [ ctilde ] ) we get @xmath76 for this case , as was found in the experiment . finally , at @xmath77 , @xcite reports simulated bell - state quantum - interference when @xmath78 is varied . that characteristic is present in ( [ ctilde ] ) , where we find @xmath79 when @xmath77 . collectively , these matches between the chen _ et al . experimental results and the predictions of our classical - light theory are consistent with their experimental configuration s illuminating its detectors with classical - state light _ and the quantitative agreement of the quantum and semiclassical theories of photodetection for such illumination . because light is quantum mechanical , and photodetection is a quantum measurement , the quantum explanation of their work is of course the fundamental one , but we have just shown that it is _ not necessary to invoke a quantum description of the light to explain their results . _ _ _ _ our work in sec . 3 presumed low - flux ( single - photon ) operation , specifically @xmath80 , in deriving the singles and coincidence rates for the figure 1 experiment . et al . raised the question of what would happen if the illumination in this experiment was performed in the high - flux regime , wherein @xmath81 prevails @xcite . with our classical - light theory , it is easy to answer that question . suppose that @xmath82 are as given in sec . 2 except that @xmath81 . also assume that the single - photon detectors in figure 1 are replaced by shot - noise limited pin photodiodes , whose photocurrent outputs are @xmath83 and @xmath84 , respectively , and that the singles and coincidence - rate measurements are replaced by average photocurrent and photocurrent cross - correlation measurements , @xmath85 , for @xmath86 , and @xmath87 . we then have that @xcite @xmath88 & + & \left . \langle |v_-|^2\rangle \sin^2(\theta_k)\int\!d\tau\,|f(\tau-\delta t/2)|^2h(-\tau)\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath89 is the electron charge and @xmath90 is the photodiodes baseband impulse response , which is normalized to satisfy @xmath91 to make the connection to the case of photon - coincidence counting , we shall ignore causality and take @xmath90 to be @xmath92 0 , & \mbox{otherwise,}\end{array}\right . \label{impulseresp}\ ] ] with @xmath33ns , so that we again have @xmath60 . we then can reduce our expression for the average photocurrents to the following simple form : @xmath93 _ for the photocurrent cross - correlation we have @xmath94 & + & c_a^2s_b^2\langle |v_+|^2\rangle \langle |v_-|^2\rangle \int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\,|f(t_+)|^2\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,|f(u_-)|^2 \nonumber \\[.05 in ] & + & c_b^2s_a^2\langle |v_+|^2\rangle \langle |v_-|^2\rangle\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\,|f(t_-)|^2\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,|f(u_+)|^2 \nonumber \\[.05 in ] & -&2c_ac_bs_as_b\langle |v_+|^2\rangle \langle |v_-|^2\rangle\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\!\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,{\rm re}[f^*(t_+)f^*(u_-)f(t_-)f(u_+ ) ] \nonumber \\[.05 in ] & + & \left.s_a^2s_b^2\langle |v_-|^4\rangle \int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\,|f(t_-)|^2\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,|f(u_-)|^2\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used ( [ impulseresp ] ) for @xmath90 , and the first and last terms on the right come from self - intensity correlations . subtracting the self - intensity correlations from @xmath95 , and using @xmath96 to denote the result , we arrive at @xmath97 & + & c_b^2s_a^2\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\,|f(t_-)|^2\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,|f(u_+)|^2 \nonumber \\[.05 in ] & -&\left.2c_ac_bs_as_b\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!dt\!\int_{-t/2}^{t/2}\!du\,{\rm re}[f^*(t_+)f^*(u_-)f(t_-)f(u_+ ) ] \right ) \\[.05 in ] & \approx & \frac{q^2\eta^2 n^2}{4t^2}\!\left[\sin^2(\theta_a - \theta_b ) + \frac{\sin(2\theta_a)\sin(2\theta_b)}{2}(1-e^{-\delta t^2/\tau_p^2})\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus the _ same simulated bell - state behavior seen in photon - coincidence counting in low - flux operation will be present in the photocurrent cross - correlation in high - flux operation . _ let us conclude with a brief meta - lesson that can be gleaned from what we have done . @xcite use quantum analysis to show that photon - coincidence counting in the figure 1 configuration after subtraction of self - intensity correlations mimics bell - state quantum interference . because classical - state light is employed in their experiments , their observations have an equivalent quantitative explanation from semiclassical photodetection theory . moreover , as we have just seen , that same mimicking of bell - state quantum interference will be present in photocurrent cross - correlations , taken in high - flux operation , after self - intensity correlations are subtracted . in the high - flux regime , it is clear that semiclassical theory ascribes the interference pattern to intensity - fluctuation correlations between @xmath98 and @xmath99 . inasmuch as the experimental results from @xcite _ can not distinguish between the quantum and semiclassical theories , it is disingenuous to claim that the figure 1 configuration generates bell states , as opposed to simulating the quantum - interference pattern produced by detection of a bell state . after all , bell states are entangled states , and entangled states are nonclassical . hence their photodetection statistics _ can not be fully and properly quantified by semiclassical photodetection theory . in this regard we note that post - selection , which is used to identify bell - state photon pairs produced by spdc , is very different from subtracting the self - intensity correlations in the figure 1 experiment to see bell - state quantum interference . this is because post - selection is just selecting the occurrence of a photon coincidence , i.e. , it can be performed on a pulse - by - pulse basis , whereas subtracting the self - intensity correlations in figure 1 requires collecting averages of coincidences with both beams present at bs2 and with only one beam or the other present on that beam splitter . _ _ _ this work was sponsored by the darpa information in a photon program under u.s . army research office grant no . w911nf-10 - 1 - 0404 . 99 bennett c h , brassard g , crpeau c , jozsa r , peres a and wootters w k 1993 1895 bennett c and wiesner s j 1992 2881 ekert a k 1991 057902 clauser j f , horne m , shimony , a and holt r a 1969 880 kwiat p g , mattle k , weinfurter h , zeilinger a , sergienko a v and shih y 1995 4337 chen h , peng t , karmakar s and shih y 2011 _ new j. phys . _ * 13 * 083018 shapiro j h 2009 _ ieee j. sel . quantum electron . _ * 15 * 1547 chen h , peng t , karmakar , s , xie , z and shih y 2011 _ phys . rev . a _ * 84 * 033835 shapiro j h 2011 arxiv:1110.5691 [ quant - ph ]

recently , chen _ et al . [ new j. phys . * 13 * ( 2011 ) 083018 ] presented experimental results , accompanied by quantum - mechanical analysis , showing that the quantum interference behavior of bell states could be simulated in a modified mach - zehnder interferometer whose inputs are pseudothermal light beams obtained by passing laser light through a rotating ground - glass diffuser . their experiments and their theory presumed low - flux operation in which the simulated quantum interference is observed via photon - coincidence counting . we first show that the chen _ et al . photon - coincidence counting experiments can be fully explained with semiclassical photodetection theory , in which light is taken to be a classical electromagnetic wave , and the discreteness of the electron charge leads to shot noise as the fundamental photodetection noise . we then use semiclassical photodetection theory to show that the _ same simulated quantum interference pattern can be observed in high - flux operation , when photocurrent cross - correlation is used instead of photon - coincidence counting . _ _ _

1205.6495

the gammev chameleon afterglow search ( chase ) reported seeing an anomalous afterglow in their apparatus after having shone a high - power pulsed laser into the bore of a cryogenic vacuum chamber immersed in a magnetic field @xcite . the experiment was designed to produce a population of chameleon particles ( scalar or pseudoscalar particles with possible couplings to matter and electromagnetic fields ) via induced photon - chameleon oscillations within the magnetic field . after turning off the laser , this chameleon population would diminish as individual particles re - convert into photons and escape the apparatus @xcite . this afterglow of photons would indicate the presence of chameleon particles , provided that the properties of the regenerated photons matched the predictions from the chameleon field theory . the fact that an afterglow signal was observed ( hereafter called the `` orange glow '' for reasons described shortly ) was troubling as various properties of the orange glow were not consistent with theoretical predictions . chameleon theory predicts an afterglow with specific dependence on the laser polarization and the magnetic field strength , as well as equivalent ingoing and outgoing photon energies . by contrast , the orange glow had none of these properties , being independent of both laser polarization and magnetic field , having outgoing photons at a variety of wavelengths dominated by contributions in the orange and red portions of the spectrum ( hence the name ) , and having an unanticipated dependence on the temperature of the vacuum chamber . in this article we present all of our data that pertains materially to the characterization of the orange glow signal . we do not claim any specific explanation of the source or cause of the orange glow , though the dependence upon temperature suggests strongly that the effect is due to some chemical or material property that is excited by the input laser . indeed , some of the general properties of the orange glow match luminescent behavior seen in some vacuum products @xcite , though the details differ . the ultimate sensitivity of the chase experiment was not limited by the presence of the orange glow , though some modifications to the data analysis software and to the science operations were needed in order to achieve the design goals . the data and discussion presented here may be useful for the design of future experiments that use high intensity light sources in conjunction with single photon detectors in a cryogenic environment . this paper is organized as follows . we discuss the design of the chase apparatus ( [ design ] ) followed by multiple sections presenting data used to characterize the orange glow including some of our initial observations ( [ oddruns ] ) , data taken using broadband optical filters ( [ color ] ) , our initial characterization data and science data ( [ sciruns ] ) , and different vacuum chamber temperatures ( [ tempruns ] ) . all of this information is presented in roughly the order that it was gathered . we discuss potential implications of the orange glow and a comparison with previously observed luminescence from @xcite in the discussion ( [ discussion ] ) . the chase apparatus comprises a laser / optical system , a superconducting magnet , vacuum system , and a single photon detector . a schematic of the apparatus is shown in figure [ schematic ] . the laser is a continuum surelite i-20 nd : yag laser , frequency doubled to 532 nm . it provides approximately 3 watts of green light in 5ns pulses at a rate of 20 hz . the laser was shone into the bore of a superconducting tevatron dipole magnet . the laser light passed through two anti - reflection coated 1 bk7 glass windows held within the bore of the magnet by two brass clips attached to an aluminum support rod . after passing through the magnet , the beam was deflected by a `` pick - off mirror '' into a power meter used to monitor the laser performance . the magnet itself was energized with fields up to 5 tesla ( currents up to 5040 amps ) and as low as 0.05 tesla for science operations . several calibration runs were conducted with no magnetic field . when operating , the @xmath0 cm diameter bore of the magnet cools to 4 kelvin from the liquid helium circulating near the magnet coils ( within the magnet itself the bore has a slightly square - shaped cross section , but that is of little consequence here ) . cryo - pumping by the cold walls of the chamber in conjunction with three ion pumps yielded a vacuum pressure at or below @xmath1 torr . when operating at room temperature the pressure maintained by the ion pumps would occasionally rise slowly by a factor of a few but remained below @xmath2 torr . the photodetector was a hamamatsu h7422p-40 photo multiplier tube ( pmt ) that had @xmath3 hz of dark rate noise . the pmt was housed inside a separate , dark `` pmt box '' and was optically isolated from the laser , magnet bore , and power meter by a gate valve . during operations , the edges of the pmt box were taped closed with metal tape and a dark shroud was laid over the box in order to prevent stray light from the environment from contaminating the measurements . ultimately , when the pmt was exposed to the entire apparatus up to , but not including the `` laser box '' that housed the laser and steering optics there was a @xmath4hz excess of photons due in part to electromagnetic discharge from the ion pumps @xcite . a typical science run consisted of shining the laser through the bore of the magnet and onto the power meter while the pmt was isolated by the `` pmt gate valve '' . following laser operations , a second `` laser gate valve '' located near the laser box was closed , the pmt gate valve was opened , and the pick - off mirror was retracted from the beam path by a pneumatic piston . any photons streaming from the magnet bore and vacuum system were focused onto the pmt photocathode by a lens with a 4 focal length . a custom - made aluminum shutter located between the lens and the pmt was cycled open and closed at intervals of a few seconds ( nominally 15 seconds open and 15 seconds closed , though these times were adjusted frequently during the investigation of the orange glow ) . these optical components are shown in figure [ schematic ] . a final note on the apparatus was the presence of four gate valves . the two optical gate valves ( pmt and laser ) have been mentioned and were used essentially as optical elements to independently isolate the laser and pmt from each other and from the bore of the magnet . two other `` vacuum gate valves '' were located on either side of the magnet bore and were used to isolate the magnet bore from the rest of the vacuum system when needed . two residual gas analyzers ( rgas ) were connected to the apparatus , but were not powered during any of the operations studied herein . these vacuum gate valves , rgas , and pressure gauges are not shown in figure [ schematic ] . the orange - colored afterglow was first seen during a test run of the full apparatus . the magnet was cold but not energized , and all other components were configured for science operations . immediately after observing the glow we ran a series of tests to diagnose its source and cause . checking the seals and materials inside the pmt box and conducting several test runs using the laser and manipulating the different vacuum gate valves showed that the orange glow originated within the bore of the magnet . we ran a series of tests to determine how much illumination was required in order to saturate the orange glow signal including several runs with increasingly shortened laser operations and some where the q - switch timing on the laser was changed in order to reduce its output power . visual inspection of the pmt output showed no noticeable difference between operating the laser for a full 15 minutes and operating it for as little as 15 seconds ( roughly the limit of the operation software ) . adjusting the q - switch until the average power was reduced to 0.2 watts with an exposure time of 100 seconds finally produced a noticeable drop in the orange glow amplitude . .list of relevant parts . [ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ] we ran a series of tests of the different materials that may have had some residue inside the magnet bore , as well as some spare optical elements . these elements as well as some of the optical filters that we used to diagnose the color content are shown in table [ parts ] . placing either an additional interior window ( identical to the 1 " windows located inside the magnet ) or an additional vacuum window in the beam path inside the pmt box showed no increase in the orange glow . had the orange glow come from the windows we would have expected a @xmath5 increase in the signal . samples of kimwipes , apiezon - l o - ring grease , ball vac kote 44147 , and leybold he-175 roughing pump oil all vacuum materials that are commonly used with the tevatron magnets were placed in the pmt box near the power meter and pick - off mirror ( but not directly in the beam itself ) and illuminated with scattered laser light from the pick - off mirror . we observed no qualitative increase in the orange glow . an important note , however , is that the pmt box is at room temperature . no tests of these vacuum materials or the 1 , interior window were done at temperatures near 4 k. nevertheless , the vacuum windows are always at room temperature and can therefore be ruled out as the orange glow source . following science operations we noted a significant temperature dependence of the orange glow . previous studies of the luminescence of vacuum products ( particularly apiezon products ) have shown such temperature dependence @xcite . however , there are some slight differences between the effects reported in @xcite and the orange glow which may indicate that the orange glow is either a somewhat different effect , comes from a different material , or that it is produced in a somewhat different manner . we discuss these differences in the observations below , but first present what we know about the orange glow signal . we conducted a series of tests using several optical filters inserted between the focusing lens and the pmt . the expected chameleon afterglow signal would be at the same 532 nm green wavelength of the incident laser . our first test used a 10nm - wide filter centered at 530 nm , where the chameleon signal was expected . following that test we used 40nm - wide filters centered at 550 nm , 600 nm , 650 nm , and 700 nm as well as a short - pass filter that nominally transmits visible light with wavelengths shorter than 550 nm . the part numbers for these filters are given in table [ parts ] . for each color test we operated the laser for three minutes after which afterglow data were aquired for roughly two minutes . the data reduction and calculation of errors is done following the procedures outlined in @xcite . the resulting time series for each of the six filters is shown in figure [ filterplot ] . the most significant afterglow signals appear in the tests using the 650 nm ( orange ) and 700 nm ( red ) filters . we saw a 4.1@xmath6 signal when we used the short - pass filter . it is not clear from our data if this excess is due to green light that was otherwise filtered by the 530 nm and 550 nm bandpass filters ( e.g. lying in a gap between the wavelength coverage of the two filters ) , a correlated statistical fluctuation in the pmt hits , a nonlinear upconversion of the incident green light into photons of shorter wavelength , or light bleeding through the filter at longer wavelengths beyond its effective range . when modeling the time dependence of this signal , a single exponential model yields a good fit to the data from the orange filter . however , it is not a good fit to the data from the red filter and is a very poor fit to the full - spectrum orange glow data . rather , a model of the form @xmath7 which gives the decay of a population of excited states through the direct emission of photons and through photon emission mediated by a `` self - interaction '' of two excited particles from within the population . here @xmath8 is the dark rate of the pmt , @xmath9 normalizes the initial orange glow rate , @xmath10 is the decay rate for direct emission , and @xmath11 describes the contribution of the self - interaction mediated emission it is a number between 0 and 1 that describes the relative contribution on the direct and self - interaction components . this model was used to describe the luminescence observed in @xcite ) , and with different parameter values it gives a reasonable fit to the orange glow data suggesting that the orange glow may be generated by such a mechanism . an analysis of the data from the red and orange bands shows a reasonably significant difference in the decay rate @xmath10 for the two sets of data . the parameter @xmath11 is not well constrained by the orange - band data that we have . nevertheless , a single exponential model for the orange band data ( setting @xmath12 in equation ( [ model ] ) ) yields a decay constant of roughly @xmath13 s@xmath14 while a fit to the red data ( allowing @xmath11 to float ) gives a decay constant of @xmath15 s@xmath14 , a roughly 3@xmath6 difference . a markov chain monte carlo analysis of the parameter errors in this model , which accounts for its nonlinear nature , yields a similarly small likelihood that these two decay constants are the same . unfortunately , the data from the orange band are not adequate to give a meaningful direct comparison of the two colors using equation ( @xmath16 ) . and , with no high resolution spectroscopic data we do not know the full extent of this possible energy dependence of the decay rate . nevertheless , this difference in the decay constants is consistent with the observed properties that were reported in @xcite which stated that the orange glow had a fast - falling initial phase followed by a slower tail . the single - exponential model for the orange glow that was used in the chase analysis @xcite is justified as data from the first 120 seconds were not analyzed . thus , the fast decay portion was eliminated _ a priori _ and , in the limit of late time , equation ( [ model ] ) behaves as a pure exponential . the fitted parameter values of the full - spectrum orange glow that we find in this study ( reported below ) agree well with the parameter values used in the analysis of chase data . after finishing the color tests we conducted a series of runs to measure the shape of the orange glow signal and to determine an appropriate cycle for opening and closing the shutter during science operations . for the science runs , we chose to leave the light unfiltered . while this added a systematic effect that needed accomodation in the data analysis we decided it was better to have the orange glow information available for study than to remove it via filtering ( besides , simply implementing a filter would not guarantee zero transmission of the orange glow and may have necessitated the same adjustments to the data analysis anyway ) . we ran a series of 14 `` calibration '' runs with no magnetic field to characterize the temporal profile of the signal and thereby determine the adjustments to our operations and data analysis necessary to reach our design goals ; we eventually selected a 15 second open/15 second closed shutter cycle . our `` science '' data consisted of 16 runs each with differing laser polarization or a differing magnetic field strength . the runs at 5 tesla were repeated for each laser polarization . each of these science and calibration runs had at least 90 seconds of illumination by the laser at full power a time much longer than needed to saturate the orange glow and four runs illuminated the chamber for five hours . the amount of time that we took data with the pmt following illumination differed from run to run , but ranged between 6 minutes and 45 minutes . we will show later that the orange glow was independent of the magnetic field and laser polarization . for now , we average together the data for all of the calibration and science runs . figure [ fullplot ] shows these data along with three fitted models a single exponential model , the model given in equation ( [ model ] ) from section [ color ] ( used by @xcite in their study ) , and a `` preferred '' model that incorporates both a quickly falling exponential and a long - term direct plus self - interaction component : @xmath17 where @xmath8 is the dark rate of the pmt , @xmath18 and @xmath19 are the normalizations of the fast and slow components respectively with corresponding decay constants @xmath20 and @xmath21 , and @xmath11 characterizes the contribution from the self - interaction of the slow - decay component . the residuals from these model fits are shown in figure [ residsplot ] . from figures [ fullplot ] and [ residsplot ] it is clear that a single exponential is not a good fit to the data and that the preferred model is best over the duration of the data . it also appears that there remains unmodeled physics happening in the first few seconds even with the preferred model . this unmodeled physics may be from intermediate timescale decays of the population , which would be consistent with an energy dependence of the decay signal as suggested by the color data . since the goal here is not to completely characterize the orange glow , but rather to show its basic properties in an effort to guide future experimental design , we do not attempt to model these data further . ) ( blue / dashed ) , and from the preferred model equation ( [ goodmodel ] ) ( black / solid).[fullplot],scaledwidth=45.0% ] , scaledwidth=45.0% ] we divided the science runs into groups with vertical and horizontal laser polarization and refit the model from equation ( [ goodmodel ] ) in an effort to identify any significant polarization dependence of the orange glow . we held the dark rate fixed at 30 hz with these tests because the science runs have gaps in the data that cause poor convergence due to increased parameter degeneracy . similarly , we conducted a second test of the science runs by dividing the data into those with magnetic fields less than 1 tesla and those with magnetic fields greater than or equal to 1 tesla . neither of these tests showed a significant difference between the two respective datasets in the fitted parameter values . both tests gave differences that were formally near 1@xmath6 ( estimated from the parameter covariance matrix ) . we did not conduct an mcmc error analysis in these cases as the formal errors will over - estimate the differences , implying that these values are conservative . following science operations we planned a series of runs for further study of the orange glow but with the magnet at room temperature . however , the orange glow signal was very weak at best at room temperature . this temperature dependence was not expected . consequently , we flowed cryogens through the magnet with differing input temperatures in order to see how the orange glow changed with temperature . figure [ ratevstemp ] shows the initial photon count rate averaged over the first ten seconds as a function of the temperature of the injected cryogen . as the bore of the magnet approaches liquid helium temperatures the orange glow signal rises significantly . we note that the magnet , and particularly the magnet operation equipment , is not designed to operate under these conditions and the temperature of the bore of the magnet is not uniform along its length ( in some cases changing by several tens of kelvins . thus , while the shape of the temperature dependence seems to be continuous , the orange glow may have a simple , power - law temperature dependence , or it may be caused by some abrupt phase transition . this transition would occur at different locations within the bore depending upon the input temperature of the cryogen . suppose , for example , that the glow is due to some residual gas that boils off the walls during laser operations and then emits light as it re - freezes to the surfaces when the laser is turned off . then , only the portion of the bore that is below the freezing point will emit the orange glow and how much of the surface is below that temperature will depend upon the input cryogen temperature . given this possibility , we do not know if the temperature dependence of the orange glow is smooth or abrupt . the chase apparatus is not ideal for studying temperature dependence and so we do not provide a more detailed analysis . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] while we do not know the source of the orange glow seen in the chase experiment , it does have many properties similar to the observed luminescence from vacuum products reported in @xcite . specifically , the orange glow shows a temperature dependence , is broadband , lasts for at least a few seconds , and is in the visible portion of the spectrum . ( the temperature dependence , in particular , is likely the reason that the orange glow did not obviously appear when we tested the vacuum products at room temperature if one of those products is indeed the source . ) however , there are some important , though somewhat subtle , differences that distinguish the orange glow from previous reports though the differences in the setup and execution of the two experiments may explain some of these differences . first , the wavelength where the orange glow peaks is longer than 670 nm instead of between 500 and 600 nm as reported in @xcite . it may be that this difference in the peak caused by the fact that our light source is a 532 nm wavelength laser instead of the uv lamp and broadband source that were tested in @xcite . this difference in initial illumination could prevent much of the excitation of the material at higher energy leaving only the low frequency tail of the previously reported luminescence . second , the orange glow is dominated at later times by a decay with a lifetime that is an order of magnitude longer than that reported in @xcite . it may be that the likely dependence of the decay time with emitted photon energy a new effect reported here might account for this difference . since the orange glow peaks at lower energy , which also appears to have longer decay times , perhaps the glow seen in @xcite is dominated by the higher energy , faster decaying components while the orange glow from chase is dominated by the lower energy , longer lifetime excitations that are produced by the lower energy photons that initially illuminate the material . finally , the temperature dependence observed in @xcite is concave - down instead of concave - up as seen here . however , the temperature control of the chase apparatus is very poor and involves sizeable temperature gradients along the length of the chamber as the operation at intermediate temperatures is far outside of the design of the equipment . thus , further investigation of the orange glow is needed in order to better characterize its temperature dependence and to see if the dependence really is different than that reported in @xcite . here we merely state that the temperature dependence exists and that it is a significant effect . further characterization of the orange glow lies beyond the scope of this work . nevertheless , the information contained herein is enough to inform the design of future experiments where the detection of single photons is important ( e.g. for quantum optics , axion or chameleon searches , etc . ) . either these experiments will need to test the instrument and its associated commercial products that they are using in order to choose build an apparatus that does not exhibit this behavior , or they will need to devise a method of operation to account for this effect . for chase , this orange glow did not preclude the achievement of the design sensitivity due to the fact that chase was looking for either a very long timescale decay , beyond the timescale of the orange glow , or looked for a signal with a specific polarization and magnetic field dependence . however , if chase were to use a photon detector with much less dark rate ( such as a transition edge sensor ) , then it is possible that the orange glow would have proven a fundamental limitation in the absense of using an effective optical or mechanical means to filter the excess photons . we thank peter mazur , amanda weltman , and william wester for their efforts and discussions related to this work the staff at the fermilab magnet test facility . this work is supported by the u.s . department of energy office of science at the fermi national accelerator laboratory operated by fermi research alliance , llc under contract no . de - ac02 - 07ch11359 and by uchicago argonne , llc , operator of argonne national laboratory ( `` argonne '' ) . argonne , a u.s . department of energy office of science laboratory , is operated under contract no . de - ac02 - 06ch11357 . government retains for itself , and others acting on its behalf , a paid - up nonexclusive , irrevocable worldwide license in said article to reproduce , prepare derivative works , distribute copies to the public , and perform publicly and display publicly , by or on behalf of the government .

we present data from our investigation of the anomalous orange - colored afterglow that was seen in the gammev chameleon afterglow search ( chase ) . these data includes information about the broad band color of the observed glow , the relationship between the glow and the temperature of the apparatus , and other data taken prior to and during the science operations of chase . while differing in several details , the generic properties of the afterglow from chase are similar to luminescence seen in some vacuum compounds . contamination from this , or similar , luminescent signatures will likely impact the design of implementation of future experiments involving single photon detectors and high intensity light sources in a cryogenic environment .

0908.1499

deformations of the bosonic heisenberg algebra by parameters have known successful achievements in mathematical physics @xcite-@xcite and in nonlinear physics ( e.g. nonlinear quantum optics ) @xcite-@xcite . one of the simplest deformation of the bosonic algebra , a one parameter @xmath0-deformation , was introduced by arik and coon @xcite and is defined by @xmath10 clearly , one recovers the ordinary fock algebra of the harmonic oscillator at the limit @xmath11 , with then @xmath12=\mathbb{i}$ ] . the most of studies pertaining to such deformations are made with the parameter @xmath130,1]$ ] . however , in @xcite , a study was performed even for complex values of @xmath0 . concerning the issue of convergence , infinite products and deformed exponential series require at least that the modulus @xmath14 . this leads to the consideration that @xmath15 , with @xmath16 the unit complex disc but the zero . keeping in mind these last remarks , nothing prevents to perform the following limit @xmath17 reminiscent of a fermionic algebra @xcite-@xcite . it then raises many natural questions . is it possible to understand the generators associated to this limit as fermions ? then , in the case of a positive answer , is there a mapping from the bosonic operators ( defined for @xmath18 ) to fermionic ones ( defined for @xmath19 ) , i.e. a kind of supersymmetry ? recent years , many investigations on @xmath0-deformed algebras and supersymmetry have been undertaken dealing with @xmath0-deformed supersymmetric factorization @xcite or differential representation , intertwining properties and coherent states @xcite ( and more references therein ) . nevertheless , as far as we can establish , none of them focuses on the complete study of the product of these deformed algebras for different parameters @xmath0 . so doing , one will immediately generate a full deformed universal algebra of all different deformed generators acting on a unique representation hilbert space . we propose to investigate how the notions of @xmath1 grassmann grading and supersymmetry can be extended to this multi - deformed enveloping algebra . in this paper , we introduce the notion of @xmath0-deformed grading on the enveloping algebra generated by all products in different deformed heisenberg algebras . this notion generalizes the ordinary grassmann grading and , moreover , by defining a generalized @xmath0-graded bracket , one is able to recover , in each subalgebra , the correct structure for bosonic , fermionic , @xmath1 graded and basic deformed bosonic algebras . the extension of grassmann parity affords us to understand ordinary associative superalgebras and their @xmath1 graded structure ( the usual framework of supersymmetry ) as limit algebras when the parameter @xmath20 . we then determine the modified supersymmetric hamiltonian and its deformed supercharges mapping some deformed fermions on deformed bosons . the paper s outline is as follows . the following section is dedicated to the definition and basic properties of the @xmath0-deformation of the heisenberg algebra in the sense of arik and coon , for complex parameter @xmath0 , and its representation . the limit @xmath2 is clarified . afterwards , section 3 addresses the algebraic settlement of the deformed structure producing the general @xmath0-deformed grading . the particular case of ordinary grassmann parity is discussed . section 4 investigates the extended notion of supersymmetry on the enveloping algebra . the specific limit @xmath21 , producing a modified version of the ordinary supersymmetry , is also discussed . the paper ends by some remarks in section 5 and an appendix provides useful identities and illustrations . let us consider the arik and coon deformation of the heisenberg algebra @xcite @xmath22 with parameter a complex number @xmath0 . if we regard @xmath23 as the adjoint of @xmath24 , it follows that , by hermitian conjugation of ( [ qdef0 ] ) , @xmath25 . by simple substraction of these equations , one ends with @xmath26 from the positivity of @xmath27 . hence , @xmath0 should be a real parameter . however , introducing a new operator @xmath28 , let us reconsider the same kind of deformed structure , namely @xmath29 and relax the previous condition of adjoint property between @xmath24 and @xmath28 . then , nothing can be said , _ a priori _ , on the parameter @xmath0 . we will place ourself in this general situation such that , @xmath30 , @xmath31 . all the following main equations are again valid outside the unit disc . only the notion of convergence of functions series and infinite products involved in deformed special function theory has to be reconsidered . we are not dealing with these ideas here , but we want , as much as possible , to have a theory with interesting properties for the theoretician community . ] @xmath320,1],\;\ ; \varphi_q \in [ 0,2\pi[.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to define the power function of @xmath0 , namely @xmath33 , one uses the complex form of the exponential function @xmath34 , where @xmath35 stands for the principal branch of complex logarithm . a realization of the algebra ( [ qdef ] ) is also well known . to construct it , one starts with the ordinary bosonic operators @xmath36 and @xmath37 , fulfilling @xmath12=\mathbb{i}$ ] with the number @xmath38 , generating the ordinary number operator in the fock hilbert space @xmath39 . then we define @xmath40_q}{n+1}}a|n\rangle,\quad a_q^\natural |n\rangle=\sqrt{\frac{[n]_q}{n}}a^\dagger|n\rangle,\quad [ n]_q = \frac{1-q^n}{1-q},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where one refers to @xmath41_q$ ] as the @xmath0-basic number of the theory . note that @xmath41_q$ ] is not necessarily self - adjoint . indeed , @xmath42_q)^\dag=[n]_{\bar q}$ ] , which is not @xmath41_q$ ] unless @xmath0 is real . the adjoint of the operator @xmath24 can be expressed as @xmath43_{\bar q}}{n}}a^\dagger \label{adjoi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from which it appears possible to define naturally a self - adjoint deformed number operator as @xmath44_{\bar q}[n]_q}}$ ] . from ( [ adjoi ] ) , a relation between @xmath45 and @xmath28 can be inferred : @xmath46 we are then in position to define properly the unary operation @xmath47 which is the adjoint operation composed with the complex conjugation . the operator @xmath48 , viewed as a matrix , can be understood as the transpose of @xmath24 . moreover , it can be checked that @xmath49 , therefore @xmath47 is an involution ; we also have @xmath50 . for a real parameter @xmath0 , the definitions of @xmath23 and @xmath51 coincide . let us briefly mention the limit @xmath52 . the corresponding basic number @xmath41_0 $ ] proves to be the constant operator @xmath53 . this implies that @xmath54 and @xmath55 are mutually inverse in the fock space without the vacuum @xmath56 . as a result of the triviality of the @xmath57-commutator , the @xmath57-deformed algebra is again a lie algebra . then the enveloping algebra over @xmath58 becomes a division algebra ( other relations concerning division algebras built over the heisenberg generators are available in @xcite ) . let us focus now on the limit @xmath2 of the algebra ( [ qdef ] ) . this limit can be written as @xmath59 a prime remark would be that , recalling that @xmath31 , the above limit could be performed only by avoiding the forbidden value @xmath60 ; this can be done by varying continuously @xmath0 along a straight line if @xmath0 does not belong to the segment @xmath610,1]$ ] . in the case @xmath130,1]$ ] , then the same limit can be only made by choosing a contour through the complex plane . noting that , in any state @xmath62 , @xmath63_{-1}|n\rangle = \lim_{q\to -1 } [ n]_q |n\rangle = \frac{1-(-1)^n}{2 } |n\rangle = \left\{\begin{array}{cc } 0 , & { \rm if}\ ; n=2p \\ 1\,|n\rangle , & { \rm if}\ ; n=2p+1 \end{array}\right . \label{limn}\end{aligned}\ ] ] then we infer the following representation for the operators @xmath64 let us recall that a fermionic algebra is usually defined by a set of algebraic relations @xmath65 the anticommutation rule is already satisfied by the pair @xmath66 . checking , that for any @xmath67 , @xmath68_q[n]_q}|n-2\rangle$ ] , @xmath69_q[n+2]_q}|n+2\rangle$ ] , one infers from ( [ limn ] ) that , indeed , for any state , @xmath70 and @xmath71 . thus , the pair @xmath66 is close to what one usually refers to as a fermionic algebra . for this reason , we will refer henceforth to these operators to fermions and to their algebra , to a fermionic algebra . here , more rigorously , the operators @xmath66 are fermionic operators with an infinite dimensional representation space which is a direct sum of ordinary two dimensional fermionic representation spaces . the notion of @xmath1 grassmann grading for associative complex superalgebras @xcite will find , in the next lines , an extension according to the present @xmath0-deformed study . but before , for the sake of rigor , let us put in algebraic terms the definition of the deformation of the heisenberg algebra ( [ qdef ] ) . * building a @xmath0-grading on the enveloping algebra . * for all @xmath67 , we introduce the deformed complex heisenberg algebra with its three generators and deformed commutator as the pair @xmath72_q\right ) . \label{hesdef}\end{aligned}\ ] ] some remarks are in order at this stage . first , the deformed heisenberg algebra @xmath73 is not a lie algebra unless that one considers the limit points @xmath74 . the jacobi identity fails to be satisfied in the general situation when @xmath75 . note also that these algebras are not disjoint since @xmath76 , for @xmath77 . the data of the pair ( [ hesdef ] ) are equivalent to the data of a complex vector space @xmath73 and a constraint ( equivalence relation ) @xmath78_q=\mathbb{i}$ ] on the tensor algebra built out of its generators . next , let us give the definition of the @xmath0-grading of generators of any @xmath73 and find an extension for any element of the enveloping algebra spanned by all @xmath73 s , @xmath67 . this concept will be introduced by the data of two attributes related to the parameters @xmath0 : the `` degree '' , denoted by @xmath79 , and the `` radius '' , denoted by @xmath80 . by convention , elements of @xmath81 are of degree @xmath82 and we define the degree of the generators of @xmath73 as @xmath83 given a generator of @xmath73 , its degree becomes a real parameter in the segment @xmath84 which can be viewed as the normalized phase of the deformation parameter @xmath0 . for instance , the degree of an ordinary ( heisenberg ) boson is @xmath85 , while the degree of the operators @xmath86 reproducing a well defined notion of @xmath1 grassmann parity for these limit . we will characterize the generators of @xmath73 , by another quantity that we will refer to as its `` radius '' or `` length '' which is nothing but @xmath87 given the modulus @xmath88 of the deformation parameter @xmath0 . at this stage , the following deformed bracket for elementary generators can be defined @xmath89_{q , q'}:= x_{q}\,y_{q ' } - g(q , q')y_{q'}\,x_{q},\qquad g(q , q'):=e^{i\pi|x_{q}||y_{q'}|}\ell(x_{q})\ell(y_{q ' } ) . \label{gradef}\ ] ] a quick verification , using ( [ deg ] ) and ( [ leng ] ) , yields the following limits @xmath90_{1,1 } = [ a_{1},a^\dag_{1}]_{q=1}= a_{1 } a^\dag_{1 } - a^\dag_{1 } a_{1 } = \mathbb{i } , & & \label{com}\\ { \rm ( fermion)}\;\ , g(-1,-1)=-1 : \;\,[a_{-1},a^\dag_{-1}]_{-1,-1 } = [ a_{-1},a^\dag_{-1}]_{q=-1}= a_{-1 } a^\dag_{-1 } + a^\dag_{-1 } a_{-1 } = \mathbb{i } , & & \label{antic}\\ { \rm ( q - def . ) } \;\,g(q , q)=q : \;\,[a_{q},a^\dag_{q}]_{q , q } = [ a_{q},a^\dag_{q}]_{q}= a_{q } a^\dag_{q } - qa^\dag_{q } a_{q } = \mathbb{i}.&&\end{aligned}\ ] ] another interesting property of the deformed bracket ( [ gradef ] ) is that it reproduces the @xmath1 graded bracket between fermion and bosons . in other words , in addition to ( [ com ] ) and ( [ antic ] ) , the bracket of a fermion and a boson is a commutator , because of @xmath91 . having properly defined the notion of @xmath0-grading of basic generators , let us go further by defining similar ideas for more complex structures . the ( noncommutative ) product of elements of two algebras @xmath73 and @xmath92 lies in the complex vector space @xmath93 . by iteration , one can build monomials in basic generators living in a product of deformed algebras @xmath94 , @xmath95 . taking the complex span of these monomials , one forms a complex vector space . negative integer powers of generators can be defined algebraically as @xmath96 , @xmath97 , where the inverse of @xmath98 , i.e. @xmath99 , acts by representation such that @xmath100 or @xmath101 ( right or left inverse ) . further precisions on the division algebra generated by the heisenberg operators @xmath24 and @xmath23 can be found in @xcite . the overall algebra spanned by any linear combination of any kind of products of generators ( including inverse integer powers ) will be called the deformed enveloping algebra denoted by @xmath102 . we would like to give a sense to the notion of grading for any elements of the enveloping algebra @xmath102 . we start by the degree and radius of bilinear products which can be defined as @xmath103 where @xmath98 and @xmath104 are generators of @xmath73 and @xmath92 , respectively . it is remarkable that @xmath105 and @xmath106 . integer powers of elementary generators of @xmath73 belonging to @xmath107 can be also assigned with a degree and a radius as @xmath108 more generally , the following relations , valid for finite products of integer powers of elementary generators , stand for definition : @xmath109 some products of basic generators admit a spectral decomposition of the form @xmath110 ) |n \rangle \langle n|$ ] , where @xmath111)\in \mathbb{c}$ ] , any function of number operators being a typical example . for this kind of operators , rational and real powers also have a rigorous definition . for instance , one sets @xmath112))^{\alpha } |n \rangle \langle n|$ ] , @xmath113 . in this situation of a possible diagonal decomposition of an operator being a product of elementary generators , the formulas ( [ prodgen ] ) can be extended to real powers : @xmath114 in order to compute the deformed bracket of composite elements in @xmath102 , one has to perform first the decomposition in sum of monomials in the elementary generators before the computation . finally , the general bracket for any monomials @xmath115 and @xmath116 can be expressed as follows ( an explicit example is provided in the appendix ) @xmath117_{g(q_i , q_j)}:= a_{q_i}\,b_{q_j } - g(q_i , q_j)b_{q_j}\,a_{q_i } , \qquad g(q_i , q_j):=e^{i\pi|a_{q_i}||b_{q_j}|}\ell(a_{q_i}b_{q_j } ) . \label{gradef3}\ ] ] in conformity with the above definition of degree , the degree of a product of two fermions is @xmath118 ( for instance @xmath119 ) and not @xmath82 as it is customarily the case in the context of @xmath1 superalgebras . this does not lead to any contradiction and the anticommutator ( [ antic ] ) is still valid and based on the product of degrees . although one is tempted to take for definition of the degree a kind of number modulo @xmath118 ( or @xmath120 from ( [ deg ] ) ) , the study can be pursued in this general context proving that there is no need to make further assumptions in the definition ( [ deg ] ) . * @xmath121-grading and matrix representation . * as a prime interesting feature with implications in supersymmetry , we discuss the matrix representation . let us recall that the ordinary notion of @xmath1 grading applied to matrix algebras @xcite can be introduced by the data of two integers @xmath122 and @xmath123 , and the decomposition of any element of @xmath124 , the set of square matrices of dimension @xmath125 with coefficients in the field @xmath126 , into four submatrices of dimensions @xmath127 , @xmath128 , @xmath129 and @xmath130 @xcite , i.e. @xmath131 a matrix is said to be `` even '' if its entries belong either to @xmath132 or to @xmath133 and `` odd '' if its entries belong to the matrices @xmath134 or @xmath135 . one can check that any product of matrices obeys to the law @xmath136 , @xmath137 , @xmath138 such that the matrix product is stable under this grading . the same idea can be simply illustrated in ordinary matrix formulation of supersymmetry where the supersymmetric hamiltonian is diagonal ( even quantity ) and supercharges consist in off diagonal matrices ( odd elements ) . one thing remains to be clarified : if the ordinary bosonic modes @xmath139 and @xmath140 or usual fermionic operators @xmath141 and @xmath142 admit a matrix representation onto the fock hilbert space basis , it can be suggested to find the equivalent feature such that the notion of @xmath1 grading as previously discussed can be readily read from their matrix representation . at first , using the conventional matrix representation of bosonic modes , nothing can be said . however , if one organizes the states differently such that we write the fock basis in the following form @xmath143 then the ordinary boson @xmath144 and fermion @xmath145 have the following matrices with respect to the order ( [ orde ] ) @xmath146 the associated adjoint operators can be easily inferred . in this context , the notion of `` odd '' matrix can be affected to either the pair @xmath147 or to the pair @xmath148 . then , legitimately in this context , the fermions @xmath148 can be seen as `` odd '' elements while the fact that the operators @xmath147 can be also seen as `` odd '' quantities becomes confusing . nevertheless , another interesting feature emerges : multiplying `` odd '' matrices , for instance @xmath149 ( of degree @xmath82 ) , or @xmath150 ( of degree @xmath118 ) will produce `` even '' elements ( as they should be ) which are the bosonic and fermionic numbers , respectively . this section aims at defining a general notion of supersymmetry on the enveloping algebra @xmath102 . the technical difficulty comes from the fact that operators are noncommuting objects in contrast to the situation of ordinary supersymmetric quantum theory . in addition , for different @xmath0 s , all @xmath0-deformed operators act on an identical hilbert space ( the fock hilbert space ) . * @xmath151-supersymmetry . * in this paragraph , we define , as a guiding model to next discussions , a supersymmetric theory on the enveloping subalgebra spanned only by products in @xmath152 and @xmath153 . supersymmetry is realized through a set of charges commuting with a hamiltonian . operators mapping in a deformed way fermions @xmath145 and @xmath154 to bosons @xmath155 and @xmath156 are identified . the converse is essentially not true due to the deformation . simple properties allow us to investigate which kind of operators can generate a supersymmetry . we will restrict the study to the situation of a supersymmetry generated by only quadratic products of operators which is , in fact , the closest possible to the ordinary notion of supersymmetry where a hamiltonian appears as a ( supersymmetrically ) factorized by bilinear operators : the supercharges @xcite . these latter operators generically are of the form of a product of bosons and fermions . these supercharges via a graded structure maps bosonic to fermionic degrees of freedom and vice versa . let us then list the possible minimal bilinears , built from products of the fermions @xmath145 and @xmath154 by bosons @xmath155 and @xmath156 . bearing in mind that the order of operators is important , @xmath157 monomials are of interest @xmath158_{-1}}{n+1}}\,a^2,\;\;\;\ ; \tilde{\mathfrak{q}}_{1}=a_{1}a_{-1}=\sqrt{\frac{[n+2]_{-1}}{n+2}}\,a^2,\\ & & \tilde{\mathfrak{q}}_{1}^\dag = a^\dag_{-1}a^\dag_{1}=\sqrt{\frac{[n]_{-1}}{n}}(a^\dag_{1})^2 , \;\;\;\ ; \mathfrak{q}_{1}^\dag = a^\dag_{1}a^\dag_{-1}=\sqrt{\frac{[n-1]_{-1}}{n-1}}(a^\dag_{1})^2,\\ & & \mathfrak{q}_{2}=a^\dag_{1}a_{-1}=\sqrt{\frac{[n]_{-1}}{n}}n = a_{-1}^\dag a_{1},\;\;\;\ ; \tilde{\mathfrak{q}_{2 } } = a_{-1}a^\dag_{1}=\sqrt{\frac{[n+1]_{-1}}{n+1}}(n+1)=a_{1}a_{-1}^\dag,\end{aligned}\ ] ] all of degree ) . the degrees of the other operators can be derived in a similar way . ] 1 and radius @xmath159 . note that @xmath160 and @xmath161 are self - adjoint . a set of hermitian hamiltonian operators can be readily obtained from these operators @xmath162_g = \mathfrak{q}_{1}\mathfrak{q}_{1}^\dag + \mathfrak{q}_{1}^\dag\mathfrak{q}_{1}= 2[n+1]_{-1}(n+1),\\ & & \tilde{\mathfrak{h}}_{1 } = [ \tilde{\mathfrak{q}}_{1},\tilde{\mathfrak{q}}_{1}^\dag ] _ g = \tilde{\mathfrak{q}}_{1}\tilde{\mathfrak{q}}_{1}^\dag + \tilde{\mathfrak{q}}_{1}^\dag\tilde{\mathfrak{q}}_{1 } = 2[n]_{-1}n , \\ & & \mathfrak{h}_{2 } = ( \mathfrak{q}_{2})^2 = [ n]_{-1}n,\\ & & \tilde{\mathfrak{h}}_{2 } = ( \tilde{\mathfrak{q}_{2}})^2 = [ n+1]_{-1}(n+1).\end{aligned}\ ] ] we are now in position to define the basic hermitian supersymmetric hamiltonian ( up to some energy scale @xmath163 that we omit ) @xmath164_{-1}n = a^\dag_1 a_1 \ , a_{-1}^\dag a_{-1},\;\;\ ; and the following supersymmetric algebra can be verified @xmath165_{g}=0= [ { \mathcal q}^\dag,\mathfrak{h}_{\rm ss}]_{g},\;\;\ ; [ { \mathcal q},{\mathcal q}^\dag]_g= \mathfrak{h}_{\rm ss},\quad { \mathcal q } : = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\mathfrak{q}_{1 } , \label{susyalg}\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}_{2},\mathfrak{h}_{\rm ss}]_{g}=0,\quad \mathfrak{h}_{\rm ss}= ( \mathfrak{q}_{2})^2 . \label{susy2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus the formulation allows to generate a @xmath166 supersymmetry ( with three different symmetries ) . the other operators @xmath167 and @xmath161 have a simple meaning , in the present context . they define the partner charges allowing the construction of another supersymmetric hamiltonian @xmath168 , the so - called superpartner of @xmath169 , obtained by reversing the order of operators , namely @xmath170_g$ ] . to the question `` is this notion of @xmath151-supersymmetry equivalent to the ordinary one ? '' , the answer is no . a hint to recognize this fact is the form of the ordinary supersymmetric hamiltonian @xmath171 , where @xmath172 and @xmath173 are the bosonic and fermionic number operators , respectively . here the supersymmetric hamiltonian @xmath169 is clearly not of this form . however , the operator @xmath174 can be rebuilt as @xmath175_{-1}n + [ n+1]_{-1}(n+1)= n + [ n+1]_{-1}$ ] . from this point out view , the supersymmetries ( [ susyalg ] ) or ( [ susy2 ] ) appear therefore as the basic ones even though it is not true that all properties of the ordinary supersymmetry can be recovered . in the following , we focus on the evidence of the deformation of the ordinary supersymmetry if the symmetry is realized as ( [ susyalg ] ) or ( [ susy2 ] ) . let us check if the ordinary properties of supercharges are satisfied . first , the square of non hermitian supercharges are usually vanishing quantities , here @xmath176 this shows that the supersymmetry is actually realized in a deformed way . second , supercharges used to map bosons onto fermions and conversely . in the present situation , any @xmath0-commutation relation does not lead to interesting results . nevertheless , after scrupulous analysis ( see appendix ) , one can reach the following interesting algebras @xmath177_g = [ n]_{-1 } a_{1 } , \label{eq1}\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}_{1}^\dag , a_{-1}^\dag ] _ g = [ n-1]_{-1 } a^\dag_{1 } , \label{eq2}\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}_{2 } , a_{-1}]_g = [ n+1]_{-1 } a_{1 } , \label{eq3}\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}_{2 } , a_{-1}^\dag ] _ g = [ n]_{-1 } a^\dag_{1 } , \label{eq4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] revealing that fermions are actually mapped on deformed bosons ( up to a function of the fermionic number operator ) . the converse is not true ( see appendix ) pointing out the peculiar aspects of this deformed supersymmetry . * @xmath178-supersymmetry . * in this last paragraph , we define in a more general context of @xmath0-deformation , the notion of deformed supersymmetry . we start by the simple remark that , as shown above , elements of the heisenberg algebra @xmath179 can be seen as deformed supersymmetric partners of elements of @xmath180 . the complex number @xmath181 is obtained after a rotation by @xmath182 from the complex number @xmath159 . the notion of supersymmetry could find an equivalence in @xmath102 , mapping generators of @xmath73 onto a generator of @xmath183 , with @xmath184 a transformation of @xmath0 : @xmath185 where @xmath186 and @xmath187 are real functions . the above case of @xmath151-supersymmetry corresponds to @xmath188 , a simple rotation @xmath189 in the complex plane by an angle @xmath182 . however , we will assume that @xmath190 and @xmath191 ; so doing , we write @xmath192 , thereby defining @xmath193 and @xmath194 . the second step is to define again bilinears which are of interest . it does not take long to find the following operators ( the same notation as in the previous paragraph is used but operators now refer to different quantities ) @xmath195_{\bar q}[n+2]_{q}}{(n+1)(n+2)}}\,(a_1)^2,\;\;\;\ ; \tilde{\mathfrak{q}}_{1}= a_{q } a_{\bar q}= \sqrt{\frac{[n+1]_{q}[n+2]_{\bar q}}{(n+1)(n+2)}}\,(a_1)^2,\\ & & \tilde{\mathfrak{q}}_{1}^\natural = a^\natural_{\bar q}a^\natural_{q}= \sqrt{\frac{[n]_{\bar q}[n-1]_{q}}{n(n-1)}}(a^\dag_{1})^2 , \;\;\;\ ; \mathfrak{q}_{1}^\natural = a^\natural_{q}a^\natural_{\bar q}= \sqrt{\frac{[n]_q[n-1]_{\bar q}}{n(n-1)}}(a^\dag_{1})^2,\\ & & \mathfrak{q}_{2}=a^\natural_{q}a_{\bar q}=\sqrt{[n]_{\bar q}[n]_q}= a_{\bar q}^\natural a_{q},\;\;\;\ ; \tilde{\mathfrak{q}_{2 } } = a_{\bar q}a^\natural_{q}= \sqrt{[n+1]_{\bar q}[n+1]_q}= a_{q}a_{\bar q}^\natural.\end{aligned}\ ] ] they all share the same degree @xmath196 and the same radius @xmath197 . we also notice that @xmath160 and @xmath161 remain hermitian , while @xmath198 and @xmath199 become adjoint of one another . in order to obtain a hermitian hamiltonian operator , we consider the operator generated by @xmath160 @xmath200_{\bar q}[n]_q=(\{n\}_{\bar q , q})^2,\qquad \sqrt{\frac{\varphi_{\bar q}}{\pi}}\right ) , \quad \ell(\mathfrak{h}_2 ) = r_q f(r_q ) \label{ham}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and require that @xmath160 is a symmetry of @xmath201 with respect to the deformed bracket . we are led to the following @xmath202_g= \sqrt{[n]_{\bar q}[n]_q}[n]_{\bar q}[n]_q \left[1 -e^ { 2i\pi\left(\sqrt{\frac{\varphi_{q}}{\pi } } + \sqrt{\frac{\varphi_{\bar q}}{\pi}}\right)^2}(r_q f(r_q))^{\frac{3}{2}}\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] a set of necessary and sufficient conditions for @xmath203_g= 0 $ ] to hold is @xmath204 which can be easily solved by @xmath205 lying outside of the unit disc corresponding to @xmath206 : @xmath207 , @xmath208.,width=226,height=226 ] ( -60,125 ) @xmath209 ( -165,115 ) @xmath210 ( -100,20 ) @xmath211 ( 123,45 ) @xmath0 ( 150,82 ) @xmath212 ( 158,65 ) @xmath213 ( 160,48 ) @xmath214 ( 126,100 ) @xmath215 ( 70,85 ) @xmath216 ( 62,27 ) @xmath217 ( 143,20 ) @xmath218 ( 120,175 ) @xmath219 lying outside of the unit disc corresponding to @xmath206 : @xmath207 , @xmath208.,width=162,height=6 ] before regarding the phase @xmath220 problems , let us focus on the equation @xmath221 having a drastic consequence . indeed , if @xmath2220,1]$ ] , then @xmath223 . this is to say that if we impose @xmath224 , then obligatory we will restrict to the situation where @xmath225 in order to get relevant solutions . enlarging the scope of value of @xmath226 , another interesting feature emerges : superpartners of operators with deformation parameter @xmath0 strictly inside of the unit disc @xmath227 are operators with parameter @xmath184 lying strictly outside of the unit disc ( and vice - versa ) ; superpartners of operators labeled by a @xmath0 belonging to the unit circle @xmath228 are operators with parameter still on the circle . concerning the phase , the case @xmath229 , for @xmath230 refers to the trivial point @xmath231 . we will focus only on points @xmath232 encoding values where partners differ from one another . it turns out that for @xmath233 , there always exists a value @xmath234 since one can show that @xmath235\!]$ ] . more generally , solving the first condition of ( [ phas ] ) , for @xmath236 , one infers the following constraints on @xmath220 @xmath237\!],\;\ ; k_p(\varphi_q ) = \left(\sqrt{p\pi } - \sqrt{\varphi_{q}}\right)^2 \in [ 0,2\pi[.\end{aligned}\ ] ] these solutions imply that , regardless of their modulus which can be fixed to be equal @xmath238 , given @xmath0 fixing once for all @xmath88 and @xmath220 , there are at least @xmath118 and at most @xmath239 parameters @xmath240 , @xmath241\!]$ ] , providing good parameter candidates for different supersymmetries @xmath242 for at least @xmath118 and at most @xmath239 different models defined by @xmath243 , such that @xmath244_g=0 $ ] ( see figure 1 and figure 2 ) . in the particular situation of the so - called @xmath151-supersymmetry as built in the previous paragraph , given @xmath245 , the above solutions are consistent and reduce to the unique possibility of @xmath246 in ( [ k+ ] ) such that @xmath247 , thus implying a unique choice for @xmath248 . finally , the constraint such that @xmath249 is actually too strong and more solutions can be determined by relaxing this condition . in fact , it seems that an infinite set of inequivalent ( modulo @xmath120 ) solutions of the phase equation ( [ phas ] ) are available due to the fact that @xmath250 is a nonlinear function of @xmath220 . a careful analysis and the meaning of these solutions will be treated in a subsequent work . the meaning of supersymmetry is not clear when considering the other operators @xmath198 and @xmath199 . a hermitian hamiltonian can be easily identified using the deformed bracket @xmath251_g$ ] . however , the set of conditions in order to impose @xmath252= 0=[\tilde{\mathfrak{q}}_{1}^\natural,\mathfrak{h}_{1}]$ ] is more involved . moreover , the resulting operator @xmath253 is not equal to @xmath201 ( [ ham ] ) . other more complicated issues arise when one reverses the order of the basic generators . the former @xmath166 @xmath151-deformed supersymmetry is therefore explicitly broken in the general deformation theory , with a reduced number of supercharges equal to @xmath254 . let us turn to the properties of the mapping boson - fermions . the following relations can be obtained : @xmath255= { \textstyle\left[\sqrt{\frac{[n]_{\bar q}[n+1]_{\bar q}[n]_q}{[n+1]_q}}- e^{i\sqrt{\varphi_{\bar q}(\varphi_{\bar q } + \varphi_{q } ) } } f(r_q)\sqrt{r_q}[n+1]_{\bar q}\right ] a_q},\label{gende}\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}_{2 } , a_{\bar q}^\natural]= { \textstyle\left[[n]_{\bar q}- e^{i\sqrt{\varphi_{\bar q}(\varphi_{\bar q } + \varphi_{q } ) } } f(r_q)\sqrt{r_q}\sqrt{\frac{[n-1]_{\bar q}[n]_{\bar q}[n-1]_q}{[n]_q } } \right ] a^\natural_q},\label{gende2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] which at the limit @xmath18 and @xmath256 , characterized by @xmath257 , @xmath258 and @xmath259 , reproduce correctly ( [ eq3 ] ) and ( [ eq4 ] ) . hence , one draws the conclusion that @xmath260 and @xmath261 are deformed partners of @xmath262 and @xmath263 , respectively . we have succeeded in setting a notion of @xmath0-grading onto the deformed enveloping algebra built from all possible products of @xmath0-deformed heisenberg algebras for different parameters @xmath67 , @xmath227 being the complex disc of radius one without @xmath82 . this notion of @xmath0-grading encompasses in specific limit the ordinary notion of @xmath1 grading of ordinary associative superalgebra . a generalized bracket is defined on the enveloping algebra which reproduces the ordinary bosonic , fermionic , @xmath1 graded and @xmath0-deformed commutators for corresponding subspaces in the total algebra . the formalism is then used to show that the notion of supersymmetry can be extended and , even , realized in the present situation where the fermions do not commute with bosons . in the specific instance such that @xmath264 , a supersymmetric hamiltonian has been defined and its @xmath166 supersymmetry properly identified with new deformed features . finally , in the full @xmath0-deformed theory , we have identified many kinds of operators ( restricting the deformed phase parameter in @xmath265 ) which are able to define different supersymmetric models . in the general context of deformation , the @xmath166 @xmath151-supersymmetry is explicitly broken and at least @xmath254 supercharge can be defined in any @xmath266-deformed supersymmetric model . m.n.h . thanks the national institute for theoretical physics ( nithep ) and its director prof . frederik g. scholtz for hospitality during a pleasant stay in stellenbosch where this work has been initiated . j.b.g . thanks pr . michal kastner , pr . jan govaerts and pr . bo - sture skargerstam for helpful discussions . this work was supported under a grant of the national research foundation of south africa and by the ictp through the oea - icmpa - prj-15 . this appendix provides useful relations and explicit illustrations to the text . we start by illustrating the kind of computations involved by the generalized @xmath0-graded bracket . let us calculate , for the specific instance , the bracket of the monomials of the form @xmath267 and @xmath268 ( as appeared in computing the bracket of the supercharge @xmath269 and supersymmetric hamiltonian @xmath270 ) . given the complex numbers @xmath271 and @xmath272 , @xmath273 , we have @xmath274_g = a_{q_1}^\natural a_{q_1 ' } a_{q_2}^\natural a_{q_2 ' } a_{q_3}^\natural a_{q_3'}\cr & & - ( -1)^{|a_{q_1}^\natural a_{q_1'}||a_{q_2}^\natural a_{q_2'}a_{q_3}^\natural a_{q_3'}| } \sqrt{r_{q_1}r_{q_1'}r_{q_2}r_{q_2'}r_{q_3}r_{q_3 ' } } a_{q_2}^\natural a_{q_2'}a_{q_3}^\natural a_{q_3 ' } a_{q_1}^\natural a_{q_1'}\cr & & = a_{q_1}^\natural a_{q_1 ' } a_{q_2}^\natural a_{q_2 ' } a_{q_3}^\natural a_{q_3 ' } \label{cal}\\ & & - ( -1)^{(|a_{q_1}|+|a_{q_1'}^\dag|)(|a_{q_2}^\natural|+| a_{q_2'}|+|a_{q_3}^\natural|+| a_{q_3'}| ) } \sqrt{r_{q_1}r_{q_1'}r_{q_2}r_{q_2'}r_{q_3}r_{q_3 ' } } a_{q_2}^\natural a_{q_2'}a_{q_3}^\natural a_{q_3'}a_{q_1}^\natural a_{q_1 ' } .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] now fixing @xmath275 , @xmath276 , @xmath277 and @xmath278 , the expression ( [ cal ] ) reduces to @xmath279&= & [ a_{1}^\dag a_{-1 } , a^\dag_1 a_1 \ , a_{-1}^\dag a_{-1}]_g\cr & = & a_{1}^\dag a_{-1}a^\dag_1 a_1 \ , a_{-1}^\dag a_{-1 } - ( -1)^{(1 + 0)\cdot(0 + 0 + 1 + 1 ) } a^\dag_1 a_1 \ , a_{-1}^\dag a_{-1 } a_{1}^\dag a_{-1}\cr & = & \sqrt{[n]_{-1}n } [ n]_{-1}n - [ n]_{-1}n \sqrt{[n]_{-1}n } = 0 , \label{cal2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] showing that @xmath160 is a symmetry of @xmath169 . of course , using an ordinary commutator this statement becomes obvious since both @xmath160 and @xmath169 are pure functions of the number operator @xmath280 . but here , the difficulty resides in the fact that we use a different commutation relation which turns out to simplify in the form of the ordinary commutator . we give the complete set of commutation relations between the supercharges @xmath198 , @xmath281 and @xmath160 and the basic degrees of freedom @xmath144 , @xmath282 , @xmath283 and @xmath284 . the following relations hold : @xmath285 @xmath286 @xmath287_g = ( n+2)a_{-1 } - \sqrt{[n]_{-1}n}a_1= { \textstyle { \left [ ( n+2)\sqrt{\frac{[n+1]_{-1}}{n+1 } } - \sqrt{[n]_{-1}n } \right]}}a_1 , \label{equa1}\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}_{1 } , a^\dag_{-1}]_g = [ n]_{-1 } a_{-1},\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}_{1 } , a_{1}]_g = { \textstyle { \left[\sqrt{\frac{[n+1]_{-1}}{n+1}}-\sqrt{\frac{[n+2]_{-1}}{n+2}}\right ] } } ( a_{1})^3,\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}_{1 } , a_{-1}]_g = { \textstyle { \sqrt{\frac{[n+1]_{-1}[n+3]_{-1}}{(n+1)(n+3)}}(a_{1})^3= \frac{[n+1]_{-1}}{\sqrt{(n+1)(n+3)}}(a_{1})^3}}. \label{equa2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath285 @xmath288 @xmath289_g = { \textstyle { \left [ \sqrt{\frac{[n-1]_{-1}}{n-1 } } - \sqrt{\frac{[n-2]_{-1}}{n-2 } } \right]}}(a^\dag_1)^3 , \\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}^\dag_{1 } , a^\dag_{-1}]_g = { \textstyle { \frac{[n]_{-1}}{\sqrt{n(n-2)}}}}(a^\dag_{1})^3,\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}^\dag_{1 } , a_{1}]_g = a^\dag_{1 } \sqrt{[n]_{-1}n } - ( n+1 ) a^\dag_{-1}= { \textstyle { \left [ \sqrt{[n-1]_{-1}(n-1 ) } - ( n+1)\sqrt{\frac{[n]_{-1}}{n}}\right ] } } a^\dag_{1},\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}^\dag_{1 } , a_{-1}]_g = [ n-1]_{-1 } a^\dag_{1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath285 @xmath290 @xmath291_g = \left [ \sqrt{[n]_{-1}n } - \sqrt{[n-1]_{-1}(n-1 ) } \right]a^\dag_1 , \\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}_{2 } , a^\dag_{-1}]_g = [ n]_{-1}a^\dag_{1},\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}_{2 } , a_{1}]_g = \sqrt{[n]_{-1}n}a_{1 } - ( n+1 ) a_{-1}= \left [ \sqrt{[n]_{-1}n } - \sqrt{[n+1]_{-1}(n+1)}\right ] a_{1},\\ & & [ \mathfrak{q}_{2 } , a_{-1}]_g = \sqrt{[n+1]_{-1}(n+1 ) } a_{-1}=[n+1]_{-1 } a_{1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in summary , these operators map bosons on a mixed combination of bosons and fermions which can not be reduced to a deformation of a fermion . on the other hand , fermions can be exactly mapped onto bosons up to a deformation function or a nonlinearity appearing as a power of a bosonic operator .

the notion of @xmath0-grading on the enveloping algebra generated by products of @xmath0-deformed heisenberg algebras is introduced for @xmath0 complex number in the unit disc . within this formulation , we consider the extension of the notion of supersymmetry in the enveloping algebra . we recover the ordinary @xmath1 grading or grassmann parity for associative superalgebra , and a modified version of the usual supersymmetry . as a specific problem , we focus on the interesting limit @xmath2 for which the arik and coon deformation of the heisenberg algebra allows to map fermionic modes to bosonic ones in a modified sense . different algebraic consequences are discussed . nithep-09 - 12 + icmpa - mpa/2009/21 + * @xmath0-graded heisenberg algebras and deformed supersymmetries * joseph ben geloun@xmath3 and mahouton norbert hounkonnou@xmath4 @xmath5_national institute for theoretical physics ( nithep ) _ + _ private bag x1 , matieland 7602 , south africa _ + @xmath6_international chair in mathematical physics and applications _ + _ ( icmpa unesco chair ) , 072 b.p . 50 cotonou , republic of benin _ + @xmath7_dpartement de mathmatiques et informatique _ + _ facult des sciences et techniques , universit cheikh anta diop , senegal _ e - mails : @[email protected],@[email protected] msc codes : 16w35 , 17a70 , 81r50 , 17b35 + pacs numbers : 03.65.fd , 03.65.-w , 11.30.pb + keys words : @xmath0-oscillator algebras , associative superalgebra , supersymmetry .

1604.00894

video streaming applications have become over the past few years the dominant applications in the internet and generate the prevalent part of traffic in today s ip networks ; see for instance guillemin et al . @xcite for an illustration of the application breakdown in a commercial ip backbone network . video files are currently downloaded by customers from large data centers , like google s data centers for youtube files . in the future , it is very likely that video files will be delivered by smaller data centers located closer to end users , for instance cache servers disseminated in a national network . it is worth noting that as shown in guillemin et al . @xcite , caching is a very efficient solution for youtube traffic . while this solution can improve performances by reducing delays , the limited capacity of those servers in terms of bandwidth and computing can cause overload . one possibility to reduce overload is to use bit rate adaptation . video files can indeed be encoded at various bit rates ( e.g , small and high definition video ) . if a node can not serve a file at a high bit rate , then the video can be transmitted at a smaller rate . it is remarkable that video bit rate adaptation has become very popular in the past few years with the specification of mpeg - dash standard where it is possible to downgrade the quality of a given transmission , see schwarz et al . @xcite , sieber et al . @xcite , aorga et al . @xcite , vadlakonda et al . @xcite and fricker et al . adaptive streaming is also frequently used in mobile networks where bandwidth is highly varying . in this paper , we investigate the effect of bit rate adaptation in a node under saturation . we assume that customers request video files encoded at various rates , say , @xmath3 for @xmath4 , with @xmath5 . jobs of class @xmath6 require bit rate @xmath3 . the total capacity of the communication link is @xmath0 . if @xmath7 is the state of the network at some moment , with @xmath8 being the number of class @xmath9 jobs , the quantity @xmath10 has to be less than @xmath0 . the quantity @xmath11 is defined as the _ occupancy _ of the link . the algorithm has a parameter @xmath1 and works as follows : if there is an arrival of a job of class @xmath12 , * if @xmath13 then the job is accepted ; * if @xmath14 then the job is accepted but as a class @xmath15 job , i.e. it has an allocated bit rate of @xmath16 and service rate @xmath17 ; * if @xmath18 , the job is rejected . for @xmath19 , jobs of class @xmath9 arrive according to a poisson process with rate @xmath20 and have an exponentially distributed transmission time with rate @xmath21 additionally , it is assumed that @xmath22 to study this allocation scheme , a scaling approach is used . it is assumed that the server capacity is very large , namely scaled up by a factor @xmath23 . the bit rate adaptation threshold and the request arrival rates are scaled up accordingly , i.e. @xmath24 _ performances of the algorithm . _ our main result shows that , for the downgrading policy and if @xmath25 is chosen conveniently , then 1 . the equilibrium probability of rejecting a job converges to @xmath26 as @xmath23 goes to infinity ; 2 . the equilibrium probability of accepting a job without downgrading it converges to @xmath27 as @xmath23 goes to infinity . see theorem [ theoeq ] and corollary [ corol ] . the above formula gives an explicit expression of the success rate of this allocation mechanism . the quantity @xmath28 , the probability of downgrading requests , can be seen as the `` price '' of the algorithm to avoid rejecting jobs . the scaling has been introduced by kelly to study loss networks . see kelly @xcite . the transient behavior of these networks under this scaling has been analyzed by hunt and kurtz @xcite . this last reference provides essentially a framework to establish convenient convergence theorems involving stochastic averaging principles . this line of research has been developed in the 1990 s to study uncontrolled loss networks where a request is rejected as soon as its demand can not be accepted . when the demand can be adapted to the state of the network , for controlled loss networks , several ( scarce ) examples have been also analyzed during that period of time . one can mention bean et al . @xcite , zachary and ziedins @xcite and zachary @xcite for example . our model can be seen as a `` controlled '' loss networks instead of a pure loss network . controlled loss networks may have mechanisms such as trunk reservation or may allocate requests according to some complicated schemes depending on the state of the network . in our case , the capacity requirements of requests are modified when the network is in a `` congested '' state . contrary to classical uncontrolled loss networks , as it will be seen , the markov process associated to the evolution of the vector of the number of jobs for each class is not reversible . additionally , the invariant distribution of this process does not seem to have a closed form expression . kelly s approach @xcite is based on an optimization problem , it can not be used in our case to get an asymptotic expression of some characteristics at equilibrium . for this reason , the equilibrium behavior of these policies is investigated in a two step process : 1 . transient analysis . we investigate the asymptotic behavior of some characteristics of the process on a finite time interval when the scaling parameter @xmath23 goes to infinity . 2 . equilibrium . the stability properties of the limiting process are analyzed , we prove that the equilibrium of the system for a fixed @xmath23 converges to the equilibrium of the limiting process . for our model , the transient analysis involves the _ explicit _ representation of the invariant distribution of a specific class of markov processes . it is obtained with complex analysis arguments . as it will be seen , this representation plays an important role in the analysis of the asymptotic behavior at equilibrium . it should be noted that related models have recently been introduced to investigate resource allocation in a cloud computing environment where the nodes receive requests of several types of resources . we believe that this domain will receive a renewed attention in the coming years . see stolyar @xcite and fricker et al . @xcite for example . in some way one could say that the loss networks are back and this is also a motivation of this paper to shed some light on the methods that can be used to study these systems . we consider a system in overload . because of bit rate adaptation , requests may be downgraded but not systematically rejected as in a pure loss system . as it will be seen , the stability properties of this algorithm are linked to the behavior of a markov process associated to the occupation of the link . under exponential assumptions for inter - arrival and service times , this process turns out to be , after rescaling by a large parameter @xmath23 , a bilateral random walk instead of a reflected random walk as in the case of loss networks . using complex analysis methods , an explicit expression of the invariant distribution of this random walk is obtained . with this result , the asymptotic expression of the probability that , at equilibrium , a job is transmitted at its requested rate ( and therefore does not experience a bit rate adaptation ) is derived . this paper is organized as follows : in section [ model ] , we present the model used to study the network under some saturation condition . convergence results when the scaling factor @xmath23 tends to infinity are proved in section [ secmod ] . the invariant distribution of a limiting process associated to the occupation of the link is computed in section [ secinv ] by means of complex analysis techniques . applications are discussed in section [ app ] . * acknowledgments * + the authors are very grateful to an anonymous referee for pointing out a gap in the proof of theorem [ theoeq ] in the first version of this work . one considers a service system where @xmath29 classes of requests arrive at a server with bandwidth / capacity @xmath0 . requests of class @xmath9 , @xmath30 , arrive according to a poisson process @xmath31 with rate @xmath20 . a class @xmath9 request has a bandwidth requirement of @xmath3 units for a duration of time which is exponentially distributed with parameter @xmath21 . for the systems investigated in this paper , there is no buffering , requests have to be processed at their arrival otherwise they are rejected . without any flexibility on the resource allocation , this is a classical loss network with one link . see kelly @xcite for example . this paper investigates allocation schemes which consist of reducing the bandwidth allocation of arriving requests to a minimal value when the link has a high level of congestion . in other words the service is downgraded for new requests arriving during a saturation phase . if the system is correctly designed , it will reduce significantly the fraction of rejected transmissions and , hopefully , few jobs will in fact experience downgrading . we introduce @xmath1 , the parameter @xmath2 will indicate the level of congestion of the link . it is assumed that the vector of integers @xmath33 is such that @xmath34 . the condition @xmath16 is used to simplify the presentation of the results and to avoid problems of irreducibility in particular but this is not essential . if the network is in state @xmath7 and if the occupancy @xmath11 is less than @xmath2 , then any arriving request is accepted . if the occupancy is between @xmath2 and @xmath35 , it is accepted but with a minimal allocation , as a class @xmath15 job . finally it is rejected if the link is fully occupied , i.e. @xmath36 . it is assumed that @xmath37 , for @xmath19 , i.e. class 1 jobs are served with the smallest service rate . mathematically , the stochastic model is close to a loss network with the restriction that a job may change its requirements depending on the state of the network . this is a controlled loss network , see zachary and ziedins @xcite . it does not seem that , like in uncontrolled loss networks , the associated markov process giving the evolution of the vector @xmath38 has reversibility properties , or that its invariant distribution has a product form expression . related schemes with product form are trunk reservation policies for which requests of a subset of classes are systematically rejected when the level of congestion of the link is above some threshold . see bean et al . @xcite and zachary and ziedins @xcite for example . concerning controlled loss networks , mathematical results are more scarce . one can mention networks where jobs requiring congested links are redirected to less loaded links . several mathematical approximations have been proposed to study these models . see the surveys kelly @xcite and zachary and ziedins @xcite . in our model , in the language of loss networks , the control is on the change of capacity requirements instead of a change of link . the invariant distribution being , in general , not known , a scaling approach is used . the network is investigated under kelly s regime , i.e. under heavy traffic regime with a scaling factor @xmath23 . it has been introduced in kelly @xcite to study the equilibrium of uncontrolled networks . the arrival rates are scaled by @xmath23 : @xmath20 is replaced by @xmath39 as well as the capacity @xmath0 by @xmath40 and the threshold @xmath2 by @xmath41 which are such that @xmath42 for @xmath43 . for @xmath30 and @xmath44 , @xmath45 denotes the number of class @xmath9 jobs at time @xmath46 in this system and @xmath47 . it will be assumed that the system is overloaded when the jobs have their initial bandwidth requirements @xmath48 with @xmath49 and @xmath50 , @xmath19 . the first condition gives that , without any change on the bandwidth requirement of jobs , the system will reject jobs . the second condition implies that the network could accommodate all jobs without losses ( with high probability ) if all of them would require the reduced bit rate @xmath16 and service rate @xmath17 . it should be noted that , from the point of view of the design of algorithms , the constant @xmath25 has to be defined . if one takes @xmath51 then , @xmath52 hold . if @xmath53 , it is not difficult to see that the system is equivalent to a classical underloaded loss network with one link and multiple classes of jobs . there is , of course , no need to use downgrading policies since the system can accommodate incoming requests without any loss when @xmath23 is large . see kelly @xcite or section 7 of chapter 6 of robert @xcite for example . in this section , we prove convergence results when the scaling parameter @xmath23 goes to infinity . these results are obtained by studying the asymptotic behavior of the occupation of the link around @xmath41 , @xmath54 in the context of loss networks , the analogue of such quantity is the number of empty places . the following proposition shows that , for the downgrading policy , the boundary @xmath40 does not play a role after some time if condition holds . [ propbound ] under condition and if the initial state is such that @xmath55 then , for @xmath56 , there exists @xmath57 such that , for @xmath58 , @xmath59 define @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the process of the number of jobs of an independent @xmath62 queue with @xmath63 , service rate @xmath17 and arrival rate @xmath49 and , for @xmath30 , @xmath64 where @xmath65 is a sequence of i.i.d . exponentially distributed random variables with rate @xmath21.the quantity @xmath66 is the number of initial class @xmath9 jobs still present at time @xmath46 . using theorem 6.13 of robert @xcite , one gets the convergence in distribution @xmath67 and , consequently , @xmath68 since @xmath69 for @xmath19 , @xmath70 by condition . note that the asymptotic occupancy , when @xmath23 is large , remains below the initial occupancy . if @xmath71 and @xmath72 such that @xmath73 , let @xmath74 then , on the event @xmath75 , the downgrading policy gives that the identity in distribution @xmath76 holds . condition gives the existence of @xmath77 such that @xmath78 convergence shows that the sequence @xmath79 converges in distribution to @xmath77 . note that , if @xmath80 , as long as the process @xmath81 stays above @xmath41 on @xmath82 , a relation similar to holds . by using again convergence , one gets that , as @xmath23 goes to infinity , the process @xmath83 remains below @xmath84 with probability close to @xmath15 on @xmath85 . the proposition is proved . we are now investigating the asymptotic behavior of the process @xmath86 defined by relation . the variable indicates if the network is operating in saturation at time @xmath46 , @xmath87 , or not , @xmath88 . in pure loss networks , when @xmath23 is large , up to a change of time scale , the analogue of this process , the process of the number of empty places converges to a reflected random walk in @xmath89 . in our case , as it will be seen , the corresponding process is in fact a random walk on @xmath90 . [ def1 ] for @xmath91 , let @xmath92 be the markov process on @xmath90 whose @xmath93-matrix @xmath94 is defined by , for @xmath95 and @xmath30 , @xmath96 with @xmath97 . the following proposition summarizes the stability properties of the markov process @xmath98 . [ propm ] if @xmath91 , then the markov process @xmath92 is ergodic if @xmath99 with @xmath100 @xmath101 denotes the corresponding invariant distribution . the markov process @xmath92 on @xmath90 behaves like a random walk on each of the two half - lines @xmath89 and @xmath102 . definition implies that if @xmath103 , then the drift of the random walk is positive when in @xmath102 and negative when in @xmath89 . this property implies the ergodicity of the markov process by using the lyapounov function @xmath104 , for example . see corollary 8.7 of robert @xcite for example . one now extends the expression @xmath101 for the values @xmath105 . this will be helpful to describe the asymptotic dynamic of the system . see theorem [ thlds ] further . [ def2 ] one denotes @xmath106 , the dirac measure at @xmath107 when @xmath108 , with @xmath109 and @xmath110 if @xmath111 , with @xmath112 for @xmath113 , denote by @xmath114 a poisson process on @xmath115 with rate @xmath116 and @xmath117 an i.i.d . sequence of such processes . all poisson processes are assumed to be independent . classically , the process @xmath118 can be seen as the unique solution to the following stochastic differential equations ( sde ) , @xmath119 with initial condition @xmath120 such that @xmath121 . [ thlds ] under condition , if the initial conditions are such that @xmath122 and @xmath123 then there exists continuous process @xmath124 such that the convergence in distribution @xmath125 holds for any function @xmath126 with finite support on @xmath90 . furthermore , there exists @xmath127 such that @xmath128 satisfies the differential equations @xmath129 where @xmath101 , for @xmath130 , is the distribution of proposition [ def1 ] and definition [ def2 ] . it should be noted that , since the convergence holds for the convergence in distribution of processes , the limit @xmath131 is a priori a _ random _ process . by using the same method as hunt and kurtz @xcite , one gets the analogue of theorem 3 of this reference . fix @xmath56 such that @xmath132 , from proposition [ propbound ] , one gets that the existence of @xmath133 such that @xmath134 which implies that the boundary condition @xmath135 in the evolution equations can be removed . consequently , only the boundary condition of @xmath86 at @xmath26 plays a role which gives relation as in hunt and kurtz @xcite . note that , contrary to the general situation described in this reference , we have indeed a convergence in distribution because , for any @xmath136 , @xmath92 has exactly one invariant distribution ( which may be a dirac mass at infinity ) by proposition [ propm ] . see conjecture 5 of hunt and kurtz @xcite . the following proposition gives a characterization of the equilibrium point of the dynamical system @xmath131 . [ fpprop ] under conditions and , there exists a unique equilibrium point @xmath137 of the process @xmath138 defined by equation given by @xmath139 where @xmath140 with @xmath141 . the process @xmath142 is ergodic in this case . assume that there exists an equilibrium point @xmath143 of @xmath138 defined by equation , it is also an equilibrium point of the dynamical system defined by equation , then @xmath144 with @xmath145 . one gets @xmath146 we now show that the vector @xmath147 is on the boundary , i.e. @xmath148 if we assume that @xmath149 from theorem [ thlds ] and the definition of @xmath86 , we know that , for the convergence of processes , the following relation holds @xmath150 for @xmath151 , @xmath152 and @xmath153 , @xmath154 by using again theorem [ thlds ] and the fact that @xmath147 is an equilibrium point of the dynamical system , we have , for the convergence in distribution @xmath155).\ ] ] the left - hand side of the above expression can be arbitrarily close to @xmath15 when @xmath156 is large . by convergence of the sequence @xmath157 to @xmath158 , one gets that , for the convergence in distribution , the relation @xmath159 holds for @xmath56 , which implies that @xmath160 . thus relation holds . finally , relations and give relation . one concludes therefore that @xmath161 , the associated process @xmath142 is necessarily ergodic by proposition [ propm ] and relations . to prove that the @xmath147 defined by relations and is indeed an equilibrium point of the dynamical system defined by equation , one has to show that the right - hand side of equation is indeed equal to @xmath162 . this is proved in proposition [ propfp2 ] of section [ secinv ] . in this section our main result establishes the convergence of the invariant distribution of the process @xmath86 as @xmath23 gets large . this will give in particular the convergence with respect to @xmath23 of the probability of not downgrading a request at equilibrium . [ lem22 ] if the process @xmath163 is the process @xmath164 at equilibrium then , for any @xmath56 and @xmath165 , @xmath166 let @xmath164 be the process with initial state empty , then one can easily construct a coupling such that the relation @xmath167 holds almost surely , where @xmath168 is the @xmath62 queue associated to class @xmath9 requests . one deduces that , @xmath169 where @xmath170 is a poisson random variable with parameter @xmath171 and @xmath172 is the stochastic ordering of random variables . one can therefore construct another coupling such that @xmath173 where @xmath174 is a stationary version of the @xmath62 queue associated to class @xmath9 requests . the lemma is then a consequence of the following convergence in distribution of processes , @xmath175 for @xmath176 , see theorem 6.13 pp . 159 of robert @xcite for example . [ defla ] let @xmath177 be the dynamical system on @xmath178 satisfying @xmath179 with @xmath180 [ lem3 ] if @xmath181 and if there exists an instant @xmath165 such that @xmath182 for @xmath183 $ ] then @xmath177 and @xmath184 coincide on the time interval @xmath185 $ ] , where @xmath131 is the solution of equations with @xmath186 . the proposition is a simple consequence of the representation of the differential equations defining the dynamical system @xmath131 and of the explicit expression of the quantity @xmath187 given by relation when @xmath103 , see relation . the next proposition investigates the stability properties of @xmath177 . let @xmath188 be the hyperplane @xmath189 if @xmath190 then @xmath191 for all @xmath44 and @xmath177 is converging exponentially fast to @xmath147 defined in proposition [ fpprop ] . it is easily checked that @xmath192 so that if @xmath193 , then the function @xmath194 is constant and equal to @xmath25 , hence @xmath195 for all @xmath196 . for @xmath176 , @xmath197 with @xmath198 in matrix form , if @xmath199 , it can be expressed as @xmath200 with @xmath201 and @xmath202 with @xmath203 if @xmath204 is an eigenvector for the eigenvalue @xmath205 of @xmath206 , then @xmath207 hence , @xmath205 is an eigenvalue if and only if it is a solution of the equation @xmath208 if @xmath209 is the number of distinct values of @xmath21 , @xmath210 , such that @xmath211 , then the above equation shows that an eigenvalue is a zero of a polynomial of degree at most @xmath209 . using conditions , it is easy to check that the relation @xmath212 holds . in particular @xmath26 is not an eigenvalue and , consequently @xmath206 is invertible . due to the poles of @xmath213 at the @xmath214 , @xmath210 and the relations @xmath212 and @xmath215 for @xmath210 , one has already @xmath209 negative solutions of the equation @xmath216 . all eigenvalues of @xmath206 are thus negative , consequently , @xmath217 converges to @xmath26 . ( see corollary 2 of chapter 25 of arnold @xcite for example . ) equation can be solved as @xmath218 therefore the function @xmath219 has a limit at infinity given by @xmath220 which is clearly @xmath221 . the proposition is proved . one can now prove the main result of this section . [ theoeq ] if @xmath147 is the quantity defined in proposition [ fpprop ] , then the equilibrium distribution of @xmath86 converges to @xmath222 when @xmath23 goes to infinity . recall that @xmath223 and let @xmath224 be the invariant distribution of @xmath118 . it is assumed that the distribution of @xmath225 is @xmath224 for the rest of the proof . in particular @xmath86 is a stationary process . one first proves that @xmath226 converges in distribution to @xmath147 . the boundary condition @xmath227 gives that the sequence of random variables @xmath226 is tight . if @xmath228 is a convergent subsequence to some random variable @xmath229 , by theorem [ thlds ] , one gets that , for the convergence in distribution , the relation @xmath230 holds , where @xmath131 is a solution of equation with initial point at @xmath231 . note that @xmath131 is a stationary process , its distribution is invariant under any time shift . by lemma [ lem22 ] one has that the relation @xmath232 , for @xmath176 , holds almost surely on any finite time interval and , by proposition [ propbound ] , @xmath233 also holds almost surely on finite time intervals . assume that @xmath234 holds . the odes defining the limiting dynamical system are given by @xmath235 as long as the condition @xmath236 holds , hence on the corresponding time interval , one has @xmath237 so that @xmath238 since @xmath239 , there exists some @xmath240 such that @xmath241 . hence , by stationarity in distribution of @xmath131 , one can shift time at @xmath133 and assume that @xmath242 . on this event @xmath243 similarly , since @xmath244 for all @xmath176 , @xmath245 and the last quantity is independent of @xmath246 . relations and show that @xmath247 and , by equations and , they also hold for @xmath46 in a small neighborhood @xmath85 of @xmath26 independent of @xmath246 so that @xmath248 for @xmath249 . consequently , the dynamical system @xmath131 never leaves @xmath250 . lemma [ lem3 ] shows that the two dynamical systems @xmath131 and @xmath177 ( with @xmath251 ) coincide . hence , on one hand @xmath131 is a stationary process and , on the other hand , it is a dynamical system converging to @xmath147 , one deduces that it is constant and equal to @xmath147 . we have thus proved that the sequence @xmath226 converges in distribution to @xmath147 . using again theorem [ thlds ] , one gets that , for the convergence in distribution , @xmath252 holds for any function @xmath126 with finite support on @xmath90 . by using the stationarity of @xmath86 and lebesgue s theorem , one obtains @xmath253 the theorem is proved . since a job arriving at time @xmath46 is not downgraded if @xmath254 , one obtains the following corollary . [ corol ] as @xmath23 goes to infinity , the probability that , at equilibrium , a job is not downgraded in this allocation scheme is converging to @xmath255 defined in proposition [ fp ] , @xmath256 we assume in this section that @xmath99 , as defined in proposition [ propm ] , so that @xmath92 is an ergodic markov process . the goal of this section is to derive an explicit expression of the invariant distribution @xmath101 on @xmath90 of @xmath92 . at the same time , proposition [ propfp2 ] below gives the required argument to complete the proof of proposition [ fpprop ] on the characterization of the fixed point of the dynamical system . in the following we denote by @xmath257 a random variable with distribution @xmath258 . for @xmath259 , we will use the notation @xmath260 for sake of simplicity , we will use @xmath261 and @xmath262 . with the notation @xmath263 the random variable @xmath257 is such that @xmath264 where @xmath265 and @xmath266 are polynomials defined by @xmath267,\\ \displaystyle p_2(z ) = \sum\limits_{j=1}^j \left[\rule{0mm}{4 mm } \lambda_j z^{{a_j } + a_j } + \mu_j \ell_j z^{{a_j}-a_j } -(\lambda_j + \mu_j \ell_j ) z^{a_j } \right ] . \end{cases}\ ] ] for @xmath268 define @xmath269 such that @xmath270 , for @xmath271 . equilibrium equations for @xmath92 give the identity @xmath272 where @xmath94 is the @xmath93-matrix of @xmath92 given by equation . after some simple reordering , one gets the relation @xmath273 by using the definition of @xmath274 and @xmath275 , equation can be rewritten as equation . [ propfp2 ] if @xmath103 then @xmath276 in particular if @xmath277 is given by relation then @xmath278 note that the right - hand side of the last relation is precisely @xmath255 of relation which is the result necessary to complete the proof of proposition [ fpprop ] . with the same notations as before , from relation , @xmath279 holds for @xmath280 , with @xmath281 . by definition of @xmath282 and @xmath283 , @xmath284 since @xmath15 is a zero of @xmath265 and @xmath266 , this gives the relation @xmath285 using the expression of @xmath286 , with some algebra , one gets @xmath287 the proposition is proved . relation is valid on the unit circle , however the function @xmath288 ( resp . @xmath289 ) is defined on @xmath290 ( resp . @xmath291 ) . this can then be expressed as a wiener - hopf factorization problem analogous to the one used in the analysis of reflected random walks on @xmath89 . this is used in the analysis of the @xmath292 queue , see chapter viii of asmussen @xcite or chapter 3 of robert @xcite for example . in a functional context , this is a special case of a riemann s problem , see gakhov @xcite . in our case , this is a random walk in @xmath90 , with a drift depending on the half - space where it is located . the first ( resp . second ) condition in the definition of the set @xmath250 in definition implies that the drift of the random walk in @xmath293 ( resp . in @xmath89 ) is positive ( resp . negative ) . the first step in the analysis of equation is to determine the locations of the zeros of @xmath265 and @xmath266 . this is the purpose of the following lemma . [ lemma1][lemma2](location of the zeros of @xmath265 and @xmath266 ) let @xmath38 be in @xmath250 . 1 . polynomial @xmath266 has exactly two positive real roots @xmath15 and @xmath2940,1[$ ] . there are @xmath295 roots in @xmath296 and @xmath295 roots whose modulus are strictly greater than @xmath15 . polynomial @xmath265 has exactly two positive real roots @xmath15 and @xmath297 . the @xmath295 remaining roots have a modulus strictly smaller than @xmath15 . one first notes that @xmath266 is a polynomial with the same form as the @xmath126 defined by equation ( 13 ) in bean et al . @xcite ( with @xmath298 , @xmath299 and @xmath300 ) . the roots of @xmath93 are exactly the roots of @xmath126 . lemma 2.2 of bean et al . @xcite gives assertion ( _ i _ ) of our lemma . the proof of assertion _ ( ii ) _ uses an adaptation of the argument for the proof of lemma 2.2 of bean et al . define the function @xmath301 . recall that @xmath265 is a polynomial with degree @xmath302 . there are exactly two real positive roots for @xmath265 . indeed , @xmath303 and it is easily checked that @xmath126 is strictly concave with @xmath304 since @xmath99 , by the second condition in definition . hence @xmath265 has a real zero @xmath305 greater than @xmath15 . let @xmath306 be fixed , note that @xmath307 . define @xmath308 so that @xmath309 . fix some @xmath310 . by expressing these functions in terms of real and imaginary parts , @xmath311 one gets @xmath312 with @xmath313 cauchy - schwarz s inequality gives the relation @xmath314 since @xmath315 for @xmath316 , @xmath317 . thus , @xmath318 since @xmath319 , @xmath320 can be chosen so that @xmath321 . from the above relation and equation , one gets that for @xmath322 , the relation @xmath323 holds . by rouch s theorem , one obtains that , for any @xmath324 , @xmath265 has exactly @xmath325 roots in @xmath326 . one concludes that @xmath265 has exactly @xmath325 roots in @xmath327 . it is easily checked that if @xmath281 and @xmath328 then the real part of @xmath329 is positive , hence @xmath330 can not be a root of the polynomial @xmath265 . consequently , @xmath265 has exactly @xmath295 roots in @xmath290 . the lemma is proved . [ def2 ] for @xmath331 , denote by @xmath332 the set of the zeros of @xmath333 different from @xmath15 . define @xmath334 with @xmath49 and the same notations as before . by definition , function @xmath335 is holomorphic in @xmath290 and @xmath291 and , from relation , is continuous on @xmath336 . the analytic continuation theorem , theorem 16.8 of rudin @xcite for example , gives that @xmath335 is holomorphic on @xmath337 . for @xmath338 , @xmath339 since the cardinality of @xmath340 ( resp . @xmath341 ) is @xmath342 ( resp . @xmath343 ) , the holomorphic function @xmath335 is therefore bounded on @xmath337 . by liouville s theorem , @xmath335 is constant , equal to @xmath344 . therefore @xmath345 recall that @xmath346 is a generating function , in particular @xmath347 . plugging the previous expressions for @xmath288 and @xmath289 in @xmath348 , one gets the relation @xmath349 hence , using equation , @xmath350 where @xmath351 is introduced in definition [ defla ] . note that @xmath352 is positive . we can now state the main result of this section . [ invariant ] if @xmath99 defined by relation , then the invariant measure @xmath353 can be expressed , for @xmath354 , as @xmath355 where @xmath305 is defined in lemma [ lemma1 ] , and @xmath265 and @xmath266 by relation , @xmath356 for @xmath357 , @xmath358 is the coefficient of degree @xmath359 of the polynomial @xmath360 note that , for @xmath361 , @xmath362 for @xmath338 , @xmath363 since @xmath364 by lemma [ lemma1 ] , @xmath289 has the following partial fraction decomposition @xmath365 denote @xmath366 then @xmath367 one concludes by using the expression of @xmath352 obtained before . using the probability generating function @xmath369 of @xmath370 from equation , one can derive an explicit expression of the mean , the variance and the skewness of such distribution . the skewness of a random variable @xmath371 is a measure of the asymmetry of the distribution of @xmath371 , @xmath372 ^ 3)}\ ] ] see doane and seward @xcite for example . [ mean_variance_skew ] if @xmath373 is a random variable with distribution @xmath370 then @xmath374 where , for @xmath375 , @xmath376 and @xmath377 with @xmath378 defined in proposition [ invariant ] . the proof is straightforward , modulo some tedious calculations of the successive derivatives of @xmath369 evaluated at @xmath15 . figure [ figdist ] shows that the distribution of @xmath379 is significantly asymmetrical . for this example @xmath380 , @xmath381 and @xmath382 . with the parameters @xmath383 , @xmath384 , @xmath385 , @xmath386 and @xmath387 . in this case , a request which can not be accommodated is rejected right away . recall that , with probability @xmath15 , our algorithm does not reject any request . the purpose of this section is to discuss the price of such a policy . intuitively , at equilibrium the probability @xmath388 of accepting a job at requested capacity in a pure loss system is greater that the corresponding quantity @xmath389 for the downgrading algorithm . see proposition [ propcmp ] below . a further question is to assess the impact of such policy , i.e. the order of magnitude of the difference @xmath390 . under the same assumptions about the arrivals and under the condition @xmath391 with @xmath392 , then , as @xmath23 gets large , the equilibrium probability that a request of class @xmath19 is accepted in the pure loss system is converging to @xmath393 , where @xmath394 is the unique solution of the equation @xmath395 see kelly @xcite . consequently , the asymptotic load of accepted requests is given by @xmath396 under the downgrading policy , the equilibrium probability that a job is accepted without degradation is given by @xmath255 , the asymptotic load of requests accepted without degradation is @xmath397 for @xmath398 . note that , when the service rates are constant equal to @xmath15 , then @xmath388 ( resp . @xmath389 ) is the asymptotic throughput of accepted requests ( resp . of non - degraded requests ) . the representation of these quantities gives that the relation to prove is equivalent to the inequality @xmath400 by using the fact that @xmath401 and equation , it is enough to show that the quantity @xmath402 is positive . but this is clear since @xmath403 and the terms of both series of the right hand side of this relation are non - negative due to the fact that @xmath404 . numerical experiments have been done to estimate the difference @xmath390 , see figure [ figccmp ] . the general conclusion is that , at moderate load under condition ( @xmath405 ) , the downgrading algorithm performs quite well with only a small fraction of downgraded jobs . as it can be seen this is not anymore true for high load where , as expected , most of requests are downgraded but nobody is lost . we consider now a link with large bandwidth , @xmath406 gbps , in charge of video streaming . requests that can not be immediately served are lost . video transmission is offered in two standard qualities , namely , _ low quality _ ( lq ) and _ high quality _ ( hq ) . from aorga _ et al . _ @xcite , the bandwidth requirement for youtube s videos at 240p is 1485 kbps , and for 720p it is 2737.27 kbps . using the values above , after renormalization , one takes @xmath16 , @xmath407 and @xmath408 , @xmath409 . jobs arrive at rate @xmath410 in this system asking for hq transmission , but clients accept to watch the video in lq . in particular @xmath411 . service times are assumed to be the same for both qualities and taken as the unity , @xmath412 . condition is satisfied when @xmath413 we define @xmath414 , with @xmath415 . the quantity @xmath416 is defined as the largest value of @xmath417 such that the loss probability of a job is less than @xmath56 . with the notations of section [ secinv ] , we write @xmath418 note that this is an approximation , since the variable @xmath379 corresponds to the case when the scaling parameter @xmath23 goes to infinity . by using the explicit expression of the distribution of @xmath379 of proposition [ invariant ] , figure [ fig_alpha ] plots the threshold @xmath419 that ensures a loss rate less than @xmath420 as a function of @xmath420 , for several values of @xmath410 . in the numerical example , taking @xmath421 is sufficient to get a loss probability less than @xmath422 . now let @xmath423 be the value of @xmath255 defined by corollary [ corol ] for @xmath424 . recall that @xmath425 is the asymptotic equilibrium probability that a job is not downgraded is given by relation , @xmath426 for comparison , @xmath427 is defined as the corresponding acceptance probability when no control is used in the system . we show in figure [ fig_down ] the relation between these quantities and the workload @xmath410 , for fixed loss rates of @xmath428 , @xmath429 and @xmath430 . we have @xmath431 , see robert ( * ? ? ? * proposition 6.19 ) . the difference @xmath432 can be seen as the fraction of jobs which are downgraded for our policy but lost in the uncontrolled policy . intuitively it can be seen as the price of not rejecting any job . notice also that the curves plotting @xmath423 for @xmath433 , @xmath429 , @xmath430 are close and that @xmath427 is larger than @xmath255 . one remarks nevertheless that , for high loads , the system can not hold these demands , because our policy is no longer effective . javier aorga , saioa arrizabalaga , beatriz sedano , maykel alonso - arce , and jaizki mendizabal . s dash implementation analysis . in _ proceedings of the 19th international conference on communications _ , volume 50 of _ recent advances in electrical engineering series _ , pages 6166 , zakynthos , ionion , greece , 06 2015 . fabrice guillemin , thierry houdoin , and stphanie moteau . volatility of youtube content in orange networks and consequences . in _ proceedings of ieee international conference on communications , icc 2013 , budapest , hungary , june 9 - 13 , 2013 _ , pages 23812385 , 2013 . fabrice guillemin , bruno kauffmann , stphanie moteau , and alain simonian . experimental analysis of caching efficiency for youtube traffic in an isp network . in _ 25th international teletraffic congress , itc 2013 , shanghai , china , september 10 - 12 , 2013 _ , pages 19 , 2013 . christian sieber , tobias hofeld , thomas zinner , phuoc tran - gia , and christian timmerer . implementation and user - centric comparison of a novel adaptation logic for dash with svc . in _ im13 _ , pages 13181323 , 2013 . stan zachary and ilze ziedins . loss networks . in richard j. boucherie and nico m. van dijk , editors , _ queueing networks _ , volume 154 of _ international series in operations research & management science _ , pages 701728 . springer us , 2011 .

we consider a server with large capacity delivering video files encoded in various resolutions . we assume that the system is under saturation in the sense that the total demand exceeds the server capacity @xmath0 . in such case , requests may be rejected . for the policies considered in this paper , instead of rejecting a video request , it is downgraded . when the occupancy of the server is above some value @xmath1 , the server delivers the video at a minimal bit rate . the quantity @xmath2 is the bit rate adaptation threshold . for these policies , request blocking is thus replaced with bit rate adaptation . under the assumptions of poisson request arrivals and exponential service times , we show that , by rescaling the system , a process associated with the occupancy of the server converges to some limiting process whose invariant distribution is computed explicitly . this allows us to derive an asymptotic expression of the key performance measure of such a policy , namely the equilibrium probability that a request is transmitted at requested bitrate . numerical applications of these results are presented . ' '' '' ' '' ''

astro-ph9911366

it is well known that radio waves propagating in the interstellar medium ( ism ) are scattered by the irregularities in the galactic electron density . the scattering in turn gives rise to a number of observable phenomena . among others , these include angular broadening and intensity fluctuations ( both in time and frequency ) of compact radio sources . while a nuisance in many radio astronomical observations , these phenomena can be used to investigate the nature of the irregularities in the interstellar plasma density . these density irregularities are in turn believed to follow the fluctuations in the interstellar kinetic and magnetic energies . ideally one would like to invert observations of radio scintillation and scattering to determine the statistics of the plasma density . as noted by narayan ( 1992 ) this inverse problem is not well posed and one must rely on modeling methods . a complete prediction of scintillation observables requires an _ a priori _ knowledge of both the form of the spatial power spectrum of the electron density fluctuations and the distribution of the scattering material along the line of sight . for a given profile of the distribution of the scattering material , one may compare observations and predictions and so constrain the functional form of the spectrum . the power spectrum provides useful insight into the physics of the plasma irregularities . hence a knowledge of the form of the density spectrum becomes central in both predicting scintillation phenomena and understanding the physics of the interstellar plasma . in this paper , we revisit the investigation of the form of the density spectrum . a commonly used model for the density spectrum has been based on a power - law model with a large range between `` inner '' and `` outer '' scales ( e.g. rickett 1977 ) : @xmath1 \ , \mbox{. } \label{eq : extpowerlaw } \ ] ] here @xmath2 is the magnitude of the three - dimensional wavenumber @xmath3 . @xmath4 denotes the strength of fluctuations ( with a weak dependence on distance @xmath5 ) . @xmath6 is the spectral exponent , and @xmath7 and @xmath8 are the inner and outer scales respectively . for @xmath9 , we obtain the _ simple _ power - law model : @xmath10 . armstrong , rickett , & spangler ( 1995 ) have constructed an empirical density spectrum by combining radio scintillation observations in the local ism ( @xmath11 1 kpc ) with measurements of the differential faraday rotation angles and large - scale electron density gradients . they have shown the power spectrum to be consistent with a simple kolmogorov power - law model ( @xmath12 ) over an astronomical 10 orders of magnitude in wavenumber scale ( @xmath13m@xmath14m@xmath15 ) . the kolmogorov spectrum in density suggests a turbulent cascade in the magnetic and kinetic energies . this has lead to several theoretical investigations of the generation and maintenance of hydromagnetic turbulence in the ism ( e.g. pouquet , 1978 ; higdon 1984 & 1986 ; biskamp , 1993 : sridhar & goldreich 1994 ; goldreich & sridhar 1995 and 1997 ) . however , the armstrong et al . study combined observations from many lines of sight and the scatter among them leaves a substantial uncertainty in the exponent @xmath6 . a list of symbols is given in table 3 . in spite of the positive evidence for the simple kolmogorov spectrum , substantial observational inconsistencies remain . for instance , long - term refractive intensity scintillations of some pulsars have modulation indices as much as a factor of 2 larger than predicted by the simple kolmogorov model ( cf.gupta , rickett , & coles 1993 ) . other discrepancies are revealed in the diffractive dynamic spectra of pulsars . on some occasions , periodic fringes are observed , which are not predicted by the simple kolmogorov model ( cf . roberts & ables 1982 ; cordes & wolszczan 1986 ; rickett , lyne , & gupta 1997 ; gupta , bhat & rao , 1999 ) ; in addition , sloping bands in the dynamic spectra often persist longer than predicted by the model ( cf.gupta , rickett , & lyne 1994 ; bhat , rao & gupta , 1999b bhat , gupta & rao , 1999c ) . further for some pulsars , the decorrelation bandwidth has larger amplitude variations than predicted for the kolmogorov spectrum ( bhat , gupta & rao , 1999c ) . such anomalies suggest the presence of large refractive structures giving rise to the focusing and defocusing of the scattered ray bundles . the interference of the ray bundles can also explain the occasional fringes observed in the dynamic spectra of some pulsars . given the relatively frequent occurrence of such events , one can ask whether they can be considered as mere occasional anomalies or should be considered as a widespread phenomenon intrinsic to the spectrum on a grand scale . the observational inconsistencies suggest the need for an enhancement in the power on the large `` refractive '' ( 10@xmath16 m to 10@xmath17 m ) spatial scales relative to the power on the small `` diffractive '' ( 10@xmath18 m to 10@xmath19 m ) scales . there are several means by which this ratio may be enhanced . one is to include the inner scale cut - off in the density spectrum , which reduces the power at small scales ( coles et al . 1987 ) ; these authors proposed inner scales of @xmath20 m. , though this does not correspond to any obvious physical scale . physically , the inner scale corresponds to the scale at which the turbulent cascade dissipates and becomes a source of heating for the plasma ( spangler , 1991 ) . the value of the inner scale is largely unknown . using different methods , spangler & gwinn ( 1990 ) , kaspi & stinebring ( 1992 ) , and gupta et al . ( 1993 ) have reported values for the inner scale ranging from @xmath21 to @xmath22 meters . in proposing the smaller values , spangler & gwinn ( 1990 ) argued that the inner scale is the larger of the ion inertial length , @xmath23 ( where @xmath24 is the alfvn speed , and @xmath25 is the ion cyclotron frequency ) , and the ion larmor radius , @xmath26 ( where @xmath27 is the ion thermal speed ) ; they obtained parameters for the warm ionized medium in reasonable agreement with observations . in a recent discussion , minter & spangler ( 1997 ) have suggested ion - neutral collisional damping and wave - packet steepening as possible dissipation mechanisms for the turbulence in the diffuse ionized gas , which would make the mean - free path for ion - neutral collisions a possible value for the inner scale . however , this is thought to be larger than the maximum values proposed to explain the observations , making it a less convincing dissipation mechanism . observationally , the kolmogorov model with a large inner scale predicts refractive modulation indices consistent with pulsar measurements ( gupta et al . it has also been proposed to explain the occasional periodic fringes , with an inner scale on the order of the fresnel scale ( cordes , pidwerbetsky , & lovelace 1986 ; goodman et al . . however , rickett et al . ( 1997 ) reported a fringe event for the pulsar b0834 + 06 that could not be explained as the effect of a large inner - scale spectrum . the event requires similar conditions to those needed to explain the extreme scattering events ( fiedler et al . 1987 ) . another way to enhance the ratio of the power between the refractive and diffractive scales in the spectrum is to steepen the spectrum with spectral exponents @xmath28 ( blandford & narayan 1985 ; goodman & narayan 1985 ; romani , narayan , & blandford 1986 ) . while power - law spectra with @xmath29 11/3 have a turbulence connotation , spectra with @xmath30 might involve some forms of turbulence , but are also consistent with a distribution of non - turbulent structures with a range of spatial scales . such steep spectra with @xmath31 predict refractive modulation indices close to unity ( goodman & narayan 1985 ) , which is substantially larger than the range 30 to 40 % observed from the nearby pulsars . on this basis rickett & lyne ( 1990 ) and armstrong et al . ( 1995 ) have rejected spectra steeper than 4 for the interstellar plasma . however , the special case of @xmath32 has been given little attention . we can conceive of a power - law model with spectral exponent @xmath32 given by : @xmath33 hereafter , we refer to this model as the `` @xmath32 model . '' blandford & narayan ( 1985 ) briefly discussed this special case without including a cut - off at low wavenumbers . it is interesting to note that even though the kolmogorov spectral exponent @xmath12 is very close to 4 , the @xmath32 model has a very different physical implication . its physical origin has been rarely discussed , and it has not been formally compared with observations . physically , this spectrum suggests the random distribution in location and orientation of discrete discontinuous objects across the line of sight . an `` outer '' scale , @xmath34 , is included to account for the typical size of such objects . the `` inner '' scale here would correspond to the scale of the sharpness of a typical discontinuity . we assume the `` inner '' scale to be smaller than the diffractive scale of scintillations , and hence has no significant effect on the scintillations . the @xmath32 model could characterize stellar wind boundaries , supernova shock fronts , sharp boundaries of hii regions at the strmgren radius , or any plasma `` cloud '' with sufficiently sharp boundaries ( transition regions shorter than the diffractive scintillation scale ) which may cross the line of sight . note that , though turbulence is not necessarily implied by the model , strong turbulence which has steepened to form shocks would also be described by the @xmath32 model . in these models a single discrete object crossing the line of sight could also explain the `` extreme scattering events '' observed in the flux density variations of extra - galactic sources ( e.g. fiedler et al . we note that the analysis of such events have been primarily based on geometrical optics involving a single `` cloud '' ( goodman et al . 1987 ; cordes et al . 1986 ; cordes & wolszczan 1986 ; roberts & ables 1982 ; ewing et al . 1970 ) . our analysis of the @xmath32 model includes the `` wave optics '' effects when the line of sight passes through very many such clouds . the ism is assumed to consist of a random assembly of discrete structures with abrupt density steps which may be independent of each other . if the @xmath32 model were compatible with all of the scintillation observations , it would remove the implication of interstellar plasma turbulence with an inertial range spanning as much as 10 orders of magnitude in scale , which has become the canonical model for iss phenomena . it would , however , still be consistent with turbulence that has steepened into shocks . we start with a simple derivation of the @xmath32 model in section [ sec : deriv ] . in section [ sec : structfn ] , we give equations for the wave structure function for the @xmath32 model and compare predictions in section [ sec : decbw ] , the variation of the diffractive decorrelation bandwidth with frequency is used to test the @xmath32 model against the simple kolmogorov model and the kolmogorov model with an inner - scale ( hereafter , the `` inner - scale '' model ) . in section [ sec : mr ] , the observed variation of the refractive scintillation index with the normalized diffractive decorrelation bandwidth is compared with theoretical predictions for the simple kolmogorov , inner - scale , and @xmath32 models . we use theoretical results from a previous paper ( lambert & rickett 1999 ; hereafter , lr99 ) , in which we developed the theory of diffractive scintillations in a medium modeled by these spectra , and we add details of the theory for refractive scintillation in appendix a. in appendix b , we discuss the use of the square of the second moment to approximate the intensity correlation function for diffractive scintillation with @xmath32 . in section [ sec : conclusion ] we give a discussion and our conclusions . in this section , we give a simple derivation of the @xmath32 model . consider first a random distribution in space of identical plasma structures ( blobs ) . the resulting electron density may be described as the convolution of a three - dimensional poisson point process with the density profile of one individual blob . this is the spatial analog of shot noise , in which each charge carrier contributes the same temporal profile of current arriving at randomly distributed times . in the wavenumber domain , the power spectrum of the electron density is then given by the spectrum of the poisson point process multiplied by the squared magnitude of the fourier transform of one blob . the spectrum of the poisson point process is a constant equal to the number density , @xmath35 , of the blobs in space ( papoulis 1991 ) . thus the power spectrum of the medium follows the same shape as that of an individual blob . a similar description applies to water droplets in a fog and many naturally occurring media , as discussed by ratcliffe ( 1956 ) . if the blobs are asymmetrical and randomly oriented , one must also average the spectrum over the possible angles of orientation . the basic feature of structures with discontinuous boundaries is that their power spectrum has an asymptotic behavior at large wavenumbers that varies as ( wavenumber)@xmath36 . this is the spatial analog of the idea that the temporal spectrum of any pulse shape with an abrupt rise or fall has a high - frequency asymptote as ( frequency)@xmath37 . the prime example is a rectangular pulse , for which the spectrum is a sinc - squared function , whose high - frequency envelope follows this law . the simplest spatial example is spherical blobs of radius @xmath38 with uniform density @xmath39 inside and zero outside ; clearly , an added uniform background density does not affect the power spectrum . the three - dimensional spatial fourier transform of an _ isotropic function @xmath40 of radial distance @xmath41 is given by ( tatarskii 1961 ) : @xmath42 where @xmath2 is the magnitude of the wavenumber . for any function @xmath40 that falls to zero beyond a radius @xmath38 , the integral will vary as @xmath43 in the high - wavenumber limit @xmath44 , making @xmath45 . for the spherical blobs of size @xmath38 we have : @xmath46 for the squared magnitude of the fourier transform , for very small and large values of @xmath47 : @xmath48 { \displaystyle q^{-4 } \ ; a^2 f_0 ^ 2 /(8\pi^4 ) \ , \mbox { , } } & q a > > 1 \ , \mbox{. } \\ \end{array } \right . \label{eq : magsqspherefourier } \ ] ] the spectrum of the electron density is then @xmath49 . we can approximate this by equation ( [ eq : beta4 ] ) , which exactly matches equation ( [ eq : magsqspherefourier ] ) at small and large values of @xmath50 , with @xmath51 and @xmath52 . _ there are evident generalizations to make the model more like a real medium . the spheres could have a probability distribution for their radii , which would weight the average of the square of equation ( [ eq : spherefourier ] ) . the spheres could have smoothly varying density inside and an abrupt boundary at radius @xmath38 . as with the pulse example , the high - wavenumber behavior would not change . more realistic models would include anisotropic structures with random orientations and a distribution of scales . for example , consider a circular cylinder as a model for an anisotropic blob , with a particular radius and thickness . its fourier transform can be computed with respect to its major axes . this can then be transformed to tilted axes and the result averaged over an isotropic distribution of angles of tilt . evidently the result will also be isotropic ; we have solved this approximately and find a spectrum with the same high - wavenumber _ asymptotic form as equation ( [ eq : beta4 ] ) , where the `` outer scale , '' @xmath53 , is the smaller of the thickness and radius . this result could be averaged over a probability distribution of radii and thicknesses and a similar conclusion reached , with @xmath53 as a weighted average of the smallest dimension . planar sheets at random angles are modeled as very flat cylinders and provide a crude representation of a distribution of shocks . another simplified model would be ellipsoids of different sizes , eccentricities , and orientations , and again we expect a similar result . _ we conclude that the @xmath32 spectrum is an approximate description of the power spectrum for a medium with a random distribution of discontinuous structures , in the limit for wavenumbers greater than the reciprocal of the smallest dimension across the structures . we note that for wavenumbers at or below about @xmath54 the functional form depends on the detailed shapes , though it will be much less steep than @xmath55 . thus equation ( [ eq : beta4 ] ) will not be generally applicable at the lowest wavenumbers . similarly , in practice there is a finite scale over which the density jump occurs ( e.g. shock thickness ) . this can be modeled by convolving the idealized discontinuous structures with a suitable narrow , say , gaussian function which thus provides a very high - wavenumber cut - off beyond which the spectrum falls rapidly to zero . consequently , we consider a spectrum with an inverse fourth power law between inner and outer scales , though these do not have the same connotations as inner and outer scales in a turbulent cascade . we do not discuss the physical origin of the supposed discontinuous plasma structures beyond the ideas formulated in the introduction , such as supernova shock fronts , stellar wind boundaries or sharp boundaries of hii regions at the strmgren radius . there needs to be no physical coupling between the individual blob structures , and there is no turbulent cascade implied by the @xmath32 spectrum . however , we note that shocks developing from the steepening of very strong turbulence could also be described by the model , and so if successful , the model would not rule out such strong turbulence , though in this case the @xmath32 range does not correspond to an inertial cascade as does the 11/3 spectrum . in the following sections , we give the necessary scintillation theory needed to develop equations for the scintillation observables corresponding to the @xmath32 model , which we then compare with iss observations . we concentrate on measurements which are sensitive to the form of the density spectrum and are relatively insensitive to the distribution of scattering material along the line of sight . central to the description of the second moment and the coherence function for intensity is the phase structure function . the longitudinal gradient of the phase structure function is related to the electron density spectrum through ( cf . coles et al . 1987 ) : @xmath56 \kappa d\kappa \ , \mbox{. } \label{eq : long_grad_phase_strucfunc } \ ] ] here @xmath57 is the speed of light , @xmath58 is the classical electron radius , and @xmath59 is the radio frequency . for a plane wave incident on a scattering medium , the line of sight integral of @xmath60 gives the structure function of the geometric optics phase , also called the _ wave _ structure function , @xmath61 . for the spherical wave geometry applicable to a pulsar at distance @xmath62 , the separation @xmath63 at the observer s plane is projected back to the point of integration , giving @xmath64 . the integrals are evaluated explicitly in equations ( 13 ) , ( 17 ) , and ( 21 ) of lr99 for a uniform scattering medium with the simple power - law , inner - scale , and @xmath32 spectral models , respectively . in the extended scattering geometry , the field coherence length at the observer , @xmath65 , is defined by : @xmath66 . for a screen of thickness @xmath67 at distance @xmath68 from the pulsar , the wave structure function at the observer becomes @xmath69 , which has an explicit dependence on the screen location . in lr99 , we found it useful to define a coherence scale @xmath70 for the screen by its phase structure function @xmath71 , which is independent of the screen location . note that in applying equation ( [ eq : long_grad_phase_strucfunc ] ) , we are assuming that the screen thickness , @xmath67 , is much greater than the outer scale @xmath53 and small compared to total distance @xmath62 . here , we repeat the equation for the phase structure function of the @xmath32 model in a thin layer ( screen ) . substituting the @xmath32 model for the density spectrum into equation ( [ eq : long_grad_phase_strucfunc ] ) , integrating , and multiplying by the screen thickness , @xmath67 , we obtain : @xmath72 \ , \mbox { , } \label{eq : struc4exact } \ ] ] where @xmath73 is the first order modified bessel function of the second kind , and @xmath74 is the scattering measure . equation ( [ eq : struc4exact ] ) may be approximated by the following logarithmic expression : @xmath75 \ , \mbox { , } \label{eq : struc4 } \ ] ] which matches the full bessel expression at both large and small values of the argument . the detailed shape , near where the structure function flattens , is governed by the shape of the low - frequency turnover in our model spectrum , equation ( [ eq : beta4 ] ) ; however , as noted above , the turnover shape depends on details of the density profiles in the plasma blobs which are not constrained in our density model . the logarithmic structure function for the @xmath32 model has far - reaching consequences . as the outer scale becomes larger , the structure function approaches a square - law . however , due to the presence of the logarithm , this occurs only slowly ; that is , only at the limit as @xmath63 goes to zero does the @xmath32 model structure function become exactly square - law . a square - law structure function for the medium is a convenient mathematical model , but as noted in lr99 , in a real medium the structure function must eventually saturate at very large separations . nevertheless , the square - law structure function has been widely used since it provides a valid approximation for scales smaller than the reciprocal of the wavenumber at which the spectrum is cut - off . the fact that the @xmath32 model structure function deviates from a pure square - law , even for very large values of the outer scale , makes this model interesting and an independent investigation worthwhile . in figure [ fig : slope ] , we have plotted the structure function of the @xmath32 model and its effective local logarithmic slope , @xmath76 , versus the transverse spatial lag , @xmath63 , for various values of the outer scale , @xmath53 ( see equation 20 of lr99 ) . to illustrate the shapes , we have chosen @xmath77 km for all curves . the thin dashed lines correspond to the simple kolmogorov model with logarithmic slope of 5/3 , and the thin dotted lines correspond to the square - law structure function . the plot shows how slowly the local slope approaches 2 ; even for @xmath78 , the slope is 1.95distinctly less than 2 . the points in the upper panel correspond to measured local exponent of the wave structure function obtained from vlbi observations , as tabulated by spangler & gwinn ( 1990 ) . in principle , this method of comparison provides a good test for the form of the density spectrum . these authors presented a similar plot corresponding to the inner - scale model , for which @xmath76 is close to 2.0 for @xmath63 less than the inner scale and close to 5/3 for @xmath63 greater than the inner scale , with a transition occurring over about a decade in @xmath63 . they derived estimates of the inner scale ranging from 50,000 to 200,000 meters , for the highly scattered sources that they studied . whereas there is some uncertainty in some of the estimates of @xmath79 , there are several examples in which values greater than 5/3 are reliably observed ( e.g. trotter et al . , 1998 ) . as can be seen , there is also reasonable agreement with the @xmath32 model . assuming the model to be correct , a separate model - fitting to each observation yields an outer scale in the range @xmath80 to @xmath81 meters . these values are much smaller than the parsec scales of supernova remnants and interstellar clouds . however based on this comparison alone , we are unable to discriminate between the inner - scale and @xmath32 models since they both provide equally satisfactory agreement with the observations . hence further independent tests are needed , and in the following sections , we present comparisons with two other scintillation observables which in the end argue against the @xmath32 model as a universal description of the ionized ism . the diffractive decorrelation bandwidth , @xmath82 , is perhaps the easiest iss observable to measure . it is the frequency - difference for a decorrelation to 50% of the correlation function for diffractive intensity scintillations . these are usually recorded as a dynamic spectrum centered on a given radio frequency , @xmath59 , for a pulsar . observations of @xmath82 for one pulsar at a wide range of radio frequencies have provided an important test of power - law models for the interstellar density spectrum on that particular line of sight . when the diffractive scale is far from the inner and outer scales , one expects @xmath83 , which for the simple kolmogorov model is @xmath84 , in both screen and extended medium geometries . in this section we re - examine the published measurements and compare them with theory for the three different spectral models . since the scaling laws are all so steep , in figures [ fig : vela ] and [ fig : other ] , we have plotted the observations logarithmically as @xmath85 . overplotted are lines giving the theoretical predictions for our three spectral models , with the simple kolmogorov model as a line of slope 0.4 . before giving our conclusions , we must discuss the error bars and various corrections to the data and also the method for deriving the theoretical predictions . decorrelation bandwidth data , collected together by cordes , weisberg , & boriakoff ( 1985 ; hereafter , cwb ) , for pulsars psr b0833@xmath8645 ( vela ) , psr b0329@xmath8754 , psr b1642@xmath8803 , psr b1749@xmath8628 , and psr b1933@xmath8716 are shown in figures [ fig : vela ] and [ fig : other ] . we have also included recently measured points by johnston et al . ( 1998 ) for the vela pulsar . these are @xmath89 and @xmath90 . the data are shown as solid circles if derived from dynamic spectra and as solid stars if derived from pulse broadening measurements . the latter become easier to estimate at low frequencies , where the resolution bandwidth required for the former becomes too narrow for an adequate signal - to - noise ratio . the conversion of an estimate of a pulse broadening time to a decorrelation bandwidth relies on the uncertainty relation @xmath91 . unfortunately , the `` constant '' @xmath92 takes on different values for different geometries and spectral models . for the @xmath32 model , it is also very weakly dependent on frequency . in table 1 of lr99 , we gave numerical values for @xmath92 for the three spectral models with spherical waves in both a screen and an extended medium geometry . for a given geometry , the smallest @xmath92 is for the kolmogorov spectrum and the largest ( by about 50% ) is for the square - law structure function . thus in figures [ fig : vela ] and [ fig : other ] we plot , as solid and open stars , the values converted using @xmath92 for the kolmogorov and square - law structure function models , respectively . we display the predictions for extended medium and note that the screen values are only about 20% less for each spectrum . thus in comparing data with the theory for the @xmath0 and inner - scale models , the data should lie between the extremes of the open and solid stars , depending on the outer and inner scales , respectively . note that the value of @xmath92 in equation ( 7 ) of the taylor et al . ( 1993 ) catalog is more than 50% greater than values computed by lr99 , since it concerns the mean pulse delay rather than the 1/e decay time of the pulse . the second correction to the data concerns the effects of refractive scintillation at the higher radio frequencies , which are closer to the transition to weak scintillation . gupta et al . ( 1994 ) gave a heuristic theory of the effect and expressions for the bias to the diffractive @xmath82 due to refractive shifts ; lr99 discussed the effect from the work of codona et al . ( 1986 ; hereafter , ccffh ) . in figures [ fig : vela ] and [ fig : other ] , we have plotted as open circles @xmath82 corrected for this effect using equation ( d6 ) of gupta et al . ( 1994 ) , who also estimated the variability in estimates of @xmath82 due to the refractive modulation . we used this to estimate an error bar on the open circles , which is typically larger than the error bars quoted by the original observers , plotted on the solid circles . in summary , the open circles and their error bars provide the best direct estimates of @xmath82 and the indirect estimates lie between the open and solid stars . the theory of diffractive scintillations has been discussed by many authors ; we will use the results of section 6 in lr99 for a point source ( spherical waves ) either in an extended scattering medium or with a screen at @xmath68 from the pulsar and @xmath93 from the observer ( with @xmath94 ) . following usual practice , we assume the strong scattering limit , in which the frequency decorrelation function for intensity is the squared magnitude of the diffractive component of the two - frequency second moment of the field . the validity of this approximation is examined in appendix b , where we find that it introduces a small error for the @xmath32 model , which however is negligible compared to the errors in the observations . the decorrelation bandwidth , @xmath82 , can be defined in terms of a normalized bandwidth , @xmath95 : @xmath96 here @xmath59 is the ( geometric ) mean of the two frequencies , and the parameter @xmath97 determines the strength of scattering ; @xmath57 is the speed of light and @xmath98 is the effective scattering distance . for a uniform scattering medium , @xmath99 , and for a screen geometry , @xmath101 is the field coherence scale where the appropriate phase structure function equals unity ; for the uniform scattering medium , it is defined at the observer , and for a screen , it is @xmath70 which is independent of the distances to the pulsar and screen , and leads to @xmath102 as the appropriate strength of scattering parameter . the computations presented in lr99 include a tabulation of the normalized bandwidth @xmath95 for the various models under discussion , and associated plots of the intensity decorrelation function itself . for the simple kolmogorov model , a constant value for @xmath95 is obtained regardless of the frequency or distance ( 0.773 and 0.654 for the extended medium and screen geometries , respectively ) . thus the frequency dependence of @xmath82 reflects the frequency dependence of @xmath65 , giving @xmath83 . cwb used this to estimate @xmath6 from observations of @xmath82 . we now compare the observations with theoretical scaling laws for the two other spectral models . there are , however , some complications . the quantity @xmath95 is no longer exactly independent of frequency , and @xmath65 depends on both frequency and the outer scale , @xmath103 , or the inner scale , @xmath104 , that parameterize the other two models . consider the details for the discontinuity spectrum . in figure [ fig : vela ] , we plot @xmath105 versus @xmath106 as observed for the vela pulsar . in figure [ fig : vela]a , we have plotted theoretical curves for @xmath32 model with various outer scales . we use equation ( [ eq : delta_nu_d ] ) for the models and so need the variation of both @xmath65 and @xmath95 with @xmath59 . for a screen , we determine @xmath70 from equation ( [ eq : struc4 ] ) for the @xmath32 model , and eliminate the scattering measure @xmath107 using the same equation for @xmath108 at a reference frequency of 1 ghz . this gives a relation between @xmath109 and @xmath106 , with @xmath110 as a parameter . for an extended scattering medium , we use equation ( 21 ) of lr99 to determine @xmath65 at the observer , and the same method as for the screen to eliminate @xmath107 . in figure [ fig : vd ] , we show the variation of @xmath95 with @xmath111 at a fixed frequency ( computed by lambert 1998 and described in lr99 ) . this is combined with the @xmath65@xmath106 relation to obtain the relation of @xmath95 to @xmath106 . for the curves in figure [ fig : vela ] , @xmath108 is determined so that , for each value of @xmath53 , the model @xmath112 fits the measured values near 1ghz . for most of the models of interest @xmath113 , and then the logarithm functions vary much more slowly than the @xmath114 term in equation ( [ eq : struc4 ] ) . in which case there is nearly a linear relation @xmath115 . furthermore , figure [ fig : vd ] shows that as @xmath65 changes , the parameter @xmath95 changes very slowly . consequently , for a very wide range of the outer scale , a good approximation is @xmath116 , which reflects the fact that the underlying structure function then approaches a square - law behavior . consider the plot for the vela pulsar psr b0833@xmath8645 ( figure [ fig : vela ] ) for which the data are most extensive . although we have computed curves and data corrections for both the screen and extended scattering geometries , we only show the extended medium results in figure [ fig : vela ] because the two plots are so similar . in the comparison with the screen model , the star points are lowered about 0.08 vertical units ( 20% ) , and the @xmath32 model curves are very slightly steeper functions of frequency . however , the scatter among the observations is greater than the differences in the models between screen and extended geometries . in the vela plot , we see that the @xmath32 model agrees somewhat better with the observations than does the simple kolmogorov model . this pulsar is known to lie in a highly scattered region , and hence the presence of discontinuities , as incorporated in the @xmath32 model , is perhaps reasonable . however , the conclusion is not strong , since the data are also reasonably fitted by an inner scale in the range @xmath117 km to @xmath118 km , as can be found from figure [ fig : vela]b . for the other pulsars ( figure [ fig : other ] ) , the data show a stronger frequency dependence than predicted by both the simple kolmogorov and @xmath32 models . however , the inconsistencies between the measurements at different frequencies are even greater , and better observations are needed , before such comparisons could discriminate between the models . a recent series of measurements at 327 mhz ( bhat et al . 1999a , b , c ) documents the variability of @xmath82 , and a similar long sequence of such measurements at other frequencies is needed on the same pulsars , before reliable conclusions can be reached from the frequency scaling observations . slow variations in the flux of pulsars are caused by refractive interstellar scintillation ( riss ) , and can be characterized by the rms deviation in flux density normalized by its mean , or scintillation index , @xmath119 . riss is due to inhomogeneities in the interstellar electron density on scales much larger than those responsible for diffractive scintillation , as characterized by the decorrelation bandwidth . there are now measurements of both phenomena on a substantial number of pulsars , from which we can constrain the density spectrum on each line of sight . the relation of the refractive scintillation index , @xmath119 , to the normalized diffractive decorrelation bandwidth , @xmath120 , depends on the ratio of the power in the density spectrum at the large refractive scales ( @xmath121 m to @xmath122 m ) to the power at the smaller diffractive scales ( @xmath123 m to @xmath81 m ) . we compare pulsar measurements gathered from the literature with theoretical predictions by plotting @xmath119 versus @xmath120 ( cf . rickett & lyne 1990 and gupta et al . related tests have been made by armstrong et al . ( 1995 ) , bhat et al . ( 1999a ) and smirnova , shishov , & stinebring ( 1998 ) . @xmath119 measurements at 610 mhz are listed in table [ table : mr610 ] and include the results of long - term monitoring observations by smirnova et al . ( 1998 ) , and older measurements near 100 mhz are listed in table [ table : mr100 ] . the tables also include the decorrelation bandwidth obtained from diffractive scintillation , typically observed at a different radio frequency , scaled to the observing frequency for @xmath119 . we used the kolmogorov scaling law @xmath124 , and we note that the minor differences that result from changes in the scaling law for other spectral models are insignificant in the comparison . the 100 mhz data consist of @xmath119 measurements at 73.8 mhz , 81.5 mhz , and 156 mhz . the pulsars observed at 610 mhz are primarily located at distances @xmath125 kpc , whereas the pulsars observed at 100 mhz are nearer at distances @xmath126 kpc . figures [ fig : mr4 ] and [ fig : mrin ] show plots of the theoretical and measured refractive scintillation index versus the normalized decorrelation bandwidth in separate panels for the two sets of measurements . theoretical curves are also shown in the figures for different spectral models in both the screen and extended medium geometries . the dashed line corresponds to the simple kolmogorov model ( @xmath127 ) , and the solid lines in figures [ fig : mr4 ] and [ fig : mrin ] correspond to the @xmath32 and inner - scale models , respectively . in section [ sec : decbw ] we noted that variable refraction tends to decrease the measured decorrelation bandwidth and used an expression from gupta et al . ( 1994 ) to apply a nominal correction to measured values . in the table of data from near 100 mhz , we have made use of the recently published measurements of bhat et al . ( 1999a ) . they monitored the apparent decorrelation bandwidth near 327 mhz for 20 nearby pulsars , many of which have @xmath119 measurements in table [ table : mr100 ] . they found the bandwidth to vary by factors 3 - 5 and discussed the influence of varying refraction as a refractive bias . from their measurements , they derived a corrected decorrelation bandwidth , which we have scaled ( using the @xmath84 scaling law ) to the frequency at which @xmath119 was observed . these gave values typically 25 times bigger than obtained from earlier measurements ( e.g. cordes 1986 ) . the pulsar b0809 + 74 was not observed by bhat et al . ( 1999a ) ; however , the recent weak scintillation observations of this pulsar by rickett et al . ( 1999 ) similarly suggests that earlier decorrelation bandwidth measurements overestimated the strength of scattering . the effect of these changes is to shift the plots to the right in figures [ fig : mr4 ] and [ fig : mrin ] by about half a decade , compared to figure 5 of gupta et al . there is only one pulsar ( b0329 + 54 ) in table [ table : mr610 ] common to the bhat et al . ( 1999a ) observations , and its decorrelation bandwidth has also been corrected for the refractive bias . since the pulsars observed at 610 mhz were mostly more heavily scattered , the refractive bias correction is substantially smaller ( see gupta et al . 1994 ) and has been ignored . the theory of refractive scintillations has been known since the 1970s and was applied to pulsar flux variations by rickett et al . for example , prokhorov et al . ( 1975 ) described how the modulation index for intensity can exceed unity in strong scattering in their equations ( 4.53 ) _ et . we use the notation of coles et al . ( 1987 ) and confine our discussion to spherical wave sources , propagating in a scattering plasma which is either concentrated in a screen or extended uniformly between source and observer . the `` low - frequency '' approximation for the intensity covariance function is given by equation ( 10 ) of coles et al . ( 1987 ) , from which we obtain the normalized refractive variance , @xmath128 , by setting the spatial offset equal to zero : @xmath129 dy \right\ } \times \nonumber \\ & & \sin^2\left [ 0.5 \kappa^2 r_{{\rm f},l}^2 x(1-x)\right ] \ , \kappa d\kappa \ , dx \ , \mbox { , } \label{eq : crextmed } \ ] ] where : @xmath130 \\ r_{{\rm f},l } & = & \sqrt{lc/2 \pi \nu } \mbox{. } \nonumber \label{eq : h } \ ] ] here the transverse wavenumber is @xmath131 , and @xmath132 , where @xmath5 is the distance along the line of sight measured from the source . for the screen geometry , both the density spectrum and the gradient in the phase structure function @xmath133 are concentrated in a thin layer of thickness @xmath67 at distance @xmath68 from the source and @xmath93 from the observer . thus the @xmath134 and @xmath135 integrations in equation ( [ eq : crextmed ] ) give @xmath136 , and we find it useful to define an equivalent fresnel scale @xmath137 : @xmath138 the @xmath139 integration in equation ( [ eq : crextmed ] ) involves the product of the density spectrum , decreasing as a steep power of @xmath139 , times the high - pass fresnel filter @xmath140 up to @xmath141 , times the low - pass exponential term that cuts off wavenumbers above @xmath142 , where @xmath143 is the radius of the scattering disc . hence in strong scattering ( @xmath144 ) we only consider the @xmath145 part of the fresnel filter . consequently , the integration depends on the ratio @xmath146 or @xmath147 . for an extended scattering medium the line - of - sight integration softens the exponential cut - off in the @xmath139 integration , but the basic relationships remain the same . as others have noted the level of refractive scintillation is greater in an extended medium than in a screen with the same observed diffractive scintillation . _ the canonical spectral model in iss studies of pulsars has been the simple kolmogorov spectrum @xmath148 . by fitting this model to diffractive scintillation observations , observers have estimated the scattering measure , @xmath149 , toward many pulsars . when divided by the pulsar distance , this gives a line - of - sight average of @xmath4 , which is found to vary greatly from one direction to another and to increase dramatically for distant pulsars seen at low galactic latitudes ( e.g. cwb ) . taylor & cordes ( 1993 ) have developed a smoothed model for the galactic plasma density distribution , which includes enhanced scattering in spiral arms and toward the galactic center . however , there are also large random variations on much finer spatial scales , which would produce a scatter in a plot of @xmath119 against distance of dispersion measure . for a simple power - law spectrum both @xmath119 and @xmath120 depend on @xmath107 through a single strength of scattering parameter . thus for the kolmogorov spectrum the variation of @xmath119 with @xmath120 is independent of distance or frequency and is given by a single dashed line in each plot in figures [ fig : mr4 ] and [ fig : mrin ] . if the scattering medium is uniform , the strength of scattering is @xmath150 . for the screen it becomes @xmath151 , and in that case , the dashed theoretical line is independent of the location of the screen between the source and the observer . this point is substantiated in appendix a , where the theory is laid out in more detail . according to this screen model , along each line of sight there is a scattering layer with a certain @xmath107 , which determines both @xmath119 and @xmath120 , but @xmath107 is not necessarily related to the pulsar distance . the theoretical curve with @xmath107 as the variable is independent of where the layer is located along the line of sight . for the @xmath32 and inner - scale models , the theoretical curves for @xmath119 versus @xmath120 depend on the extra parameter @xmath53 or @xmath104 , respectively . details of the theory are given in appendix a , where the relevant parameters are shown to be @xmath152 and @xmath153 . since @xmath70 depends on frequency , @xmath107 , and distance , then @xmath119 also depends somewhat on frequency and distance . in order to fix the frequency dependence of the theoretical @xmath119 values , we have separated the measurements into two groups ( at 610 mhz and near 100 mhz ) . the distance dependence is dealt with by assuming that @xmath154 distance . whereas this is clearly appropriate for the extended scattering medium , it is less clear for the screen model , since the screen model supposes that @xmath107 is not necessarily related to distance . however , it is reasonable that , if on a long line of sight there is a single region that dominates the scattering , its @xmath107 value will statistically increase with line - of - sight distance . indeed the experimentally derived scattering measure increases faster with distance than if the medium were uniform ( see figure 1 of cordes et al . ( 1991 ) . in figure [ fig : mr4 ] we show the theoretical curves for @xmath119 in the @xmath32 model , which are relatively flat where @xmath155 . as @xmath97 increases ( @xmath120 decreases ) , @xmath156 increases , and when @xmath157 the scintillations are suppressed . in a screen this occurs when @xmath158 . inspection of figure [ fig : mr4 ] shows that the measured @xmath119 values at 100 mhz are above the prediction of the simple kolmogorov model for the extended medium geometry . these measurements can , however , be modeled with the @xmath32 spectrum with suitable specific choices of outer scale , @xmath53 . the screen geometry is inconsistent with the measurements at 100 mhz for both the simple kolmogorov and @xmath32 models . for the 610 mhz data , the measured @xmath119 values are mostly in agreement with the prediction of the simple kolmogorov model for the extended medium geometry ; however , they lie below the predictions of the @xmath32 model . for the screen geometry , the measured @xmath119 values are above the simple kolmogorov model curve . however , for the @xmath32 model , though less convincingly , an agreement with the measurements can be found by suitable choices of the outer scale , @xmath53 . the most striking feature of the figure is the good agreement with the uniform extended kolmogorov model for most of the pulsars . this result , relies most heavily on the excellent data from smirnova et al . ( 1998 ) , who also note this agreement . we are persuaded by this figure that the @xmath32 model can not be viewed as a global alternative to the kolmogorov spectrum . we also conclude that for the medium - distance pulsars measured at 610 mhz , @xmath119 does not agree with the screen geometry . it appears that even if the scattering medium is not uniform on scales of a few kpc , there is not a single region that dominates the scattering . computations of @xmath119 due to a patchy distribution along the line of sight could test what distribution would start to approximate the uniformly extended medium . turning to a comparison with the alternative inner - scale spectrum in figure [ fig : mrin ] , the 100 mhz observations could be explained by very large values of @xmath104 ( @xmath159 m to @xmath121 m ) in a screen configuration or by more modest , but still large , values of @xmath104 ( @xmath81 m ) in an extended medium . the latter was essentially the proposal made by coles et al . ( 1987 ) for the nearby lines of sight . the 610 mhz points are relatively lower than those at 100 mhz . for an inner scale spectrum in a screen , large values of @xmath104 ( @xmath81 m to @xmath159 m ) would be necessary ; and in an extended medium 60% of the points lie near the simple kolmogorov model , with the rest requiring inner scale values ( @xmath123 m to @xmath81 m ) . the 610 mhz data in our analysis come from riss observations of 21 pulsars made by stinebring and are described in more detail by smirnova et al . ( 1998 ) , who also compare the results with various models for the spectrum and spatial distribution of the electron density . they note that 4 pulsars which are seen through known hii regions or supernovae remnants show relatively elevated values for @xmath119 , and find 3 other pulsars with similar behavior . these are the points which lie above the kolmogorov line in figure [ fig : mrin]b . their interpretation is that for these objects the scattering is concentrated into regions either near the pulsar or near the earth , and that these regions are characterized by an inner scale near @xmath160 m . their spectrum model is very similar to our inner - scale model , except that the cut - off is characterized by a steep power - law rather than by an exponential function . we find a somewhat larger numerical value for the inner scale required to match those objects . we also note that the theoretical @xmath119 values are consistently higher for an extended medium , and so require a more modest inner scale . however , an important result of our analysis is an alternative explanation for the relatively high @xmath119 values seen for some pulsars . we suggest that pulsar lines of sight can pass through discrete clouds with increased plasma density on large scales , that steepen the low - wavenumber spectrum as opposed to cutting off the high - wavenumbers . a discontinuity spectrum ( @xmath32 ) is one way that the spectrum can be steepened , but smoother structures on scales larger than @xmath121 m ( @xmath161 au ) would also boost the low - wavenumbers and could cause similar enhancements of refractive compared to diffractive scintillations . such enhancements are likely to be associated with hii regions or supernova remnants . a similar idea was also discussed by lestrade , rickett , & cognard ( 1998 ) in the context of extreme scattering events in pulsar timing measurements . to take this idea further , a composite between the kolmogorov and the @xmath32 or steeper spectra should be investigated , particularly one in which the line of sight is not uniformly weighted . smirnova et al . ( 1998 ) also note that the strength of scattering increases very much faster with distance and dispersion measure than if the medium were statistically uniform . the distant pulsars in their sample are mostly observed at low galactic latitudes and so are subject to the enhanced density and turbulence described by the taylor & cordes ( 1993 ) model . it appears that most distant pulsars follow the uniform extended kolmogorov model with inner scale smaller than @xmath162 m . thus although these lines of sight are subject to enhanced scattering in the inner galactic plane , the spectrum effectively follows the kolmogorov law and the plasma is dispersed enough to approximate a uniform scattering medium . there are presumably discrete refracting structures present along these lines of sight , but their contribution to the density spectrum is masked by the higher densities of the inner galaxy , which still follow an apparently turbulent spectral form . [email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected] rickett & lyne ( 1990 ) & b0531 + 21 & 2&0 & 610&0 & 2&96@xmath163 & 0&327 & 0&052 & b0531 + 21 & 2&0 & 610&0 & 2&96@xmath163 & 0&402 & 0&095 kaspi & stinebring ( 1992 ) & b0329 + 54 & 1&4 & 610&0 & 0&44 & 0&39 & 0&07 & b0833@xmath8645 & 0&55 & 610&0 & 1&29@xmath164 & 0&11 & 0&01 & b1749@xmath8628 & 1&2 & 610&0 & 5&13@xmath163 & 0&26 & 0&05 & b1911@xmath8604 & 2&29 & 610&0 & 1&91@xmath165 & 0&20 & 0&03 & b1933 + 16 & 7&8 & 610&0 & 1&82@xmath165 & 0&18 & 0&04 & b2111 + 46 & 5&22 & 610&0 & 2&69@xmath165 & 0&16 & 0&05 & b2217 + 47 & 2&31 & 610&0 & 0&26 & 0&21 & 0&02 stinebring et al . ( 1999 ) & b0136@xmath16657 & 2&9 & 610&0 & 5&7@xmath165 & 0&15 & 0&02 & b0329@xmath16654 & 1&4 & 610&0 & 0&350 & 0&37 & 0&02 & b0525@xmath16621 & 2&3 & 610&0 & 0&30 & 0&31 & 0&01 & b0531@xmath16621 & 2&0 & 610&0 & 4&0@xmath163 & 0&32 & 0&01 & b0736@xmath8640 & 2&1 & 610&0 & 9&0@xmath167 & 0&03 & 0&01 & b0740@xmath8628 & 1&9 & 610&0 & 3&5@xmath165 & 0&13 & 0&01 & b0818@xmath8613 & 2&5 & 610&0 & 0&061 & 0&23 & 0&01 & b0833@xmath8645 & 0&5 & 610&0 & 1&50@xmath164 & 0&24 & 0&01 & b0835@xmath8641 & 4&2 & 610&0 & 7&0@xmath164 & 0&21 & 0&02 & b1641@xmath8645 & 4&6 & 610&0 & 7&0@xmath168 & @xmath1690&1 & 0&05 & b1642@xmath8603 & 0&5 & 610&0 & 0&770 & 0&46 & 0&04 & b1749@xmath8628 & 1&5 & 610&0 & 6&0@xmath163 & 0&25 & 0&02 & b1818@xmath8604 & 1&6 & 610&0 & 4&0@xmath164 & @xmath1690&1 & 0&05 & b1859@xmath8603 & 8&1 & 610&0 & 5&0@xmath167 & @xmath1690&05 & 0&03 & b1911@xmath8604 & 3&2 & 610&0 & 8&0@xmath164 & 0&22 & 0&01 & b1933@xmath16616 & 3&5 & 610&0 & 2&0@xmath165 & 0&24 & 0&02 & b1946@xmath16635 & 7&9 & 610&0 & 3&0@xmath170 & @xmath1690&05 & 0&03 & b2111@xmath16646 & 5&0 & 610&0 & 3&0@xmath165 & 0&15 & 0&01 & b2217@xmath16647 & 2&5 & 610&0 & 0&20 & 0&30 & 0&01 [email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected] cole et al . ( 1970 ) & b0809 + 74 & 0&31 & 81&5 & 1&38@xmath165 & 0&45 & 0&18 & b0834 + 06 & 0&72 & 81&5 & 1&3@xmath165 & 0&39 & 0&11 & b1919 + 21 & 0&66 & 81&5 & 1&2@xmath165 & 0&53 & 0&18 helfand et al . ( 1977 ) & b0329 + 54 & 1&4 & 156&0 & 5&7@xmath165 & 0&35 & 0&08 & b0823 + 26 & 0&38 & 156&0 & 1&0@xmath163 & 0&46 & 0&11 & b1133 + 16 & 0&27 & 156&0 & 2&9@xmath163 & 0&50 & 0&08 & b1508 + 55 & 1&93 & 156&0 & 7&0@xmath165 & 0&41 & 0&07 & b1919 + 21 & 0&66 & 156&0 & 1&4@xmath163 & 0&50 & 0&07 & b2217 + 47 & 2&31 & 156&0 & 6&45@xmath164 & 0&41 & 0&11 gupta et al . ( 1993 ) & b0329 + 54 & 1&4 & 73&8 & 3&1@xmath164 & @xmath1710&15 & & b0809 + 74 & 0&31 & 73&8 & 8&90@xmath164 & 0&34 & 0&06 & b0834 + 06 & 0&72 & 73&8 & 8&6@xmath164 & 0&16 & 0&03 & b0950 + 08 & 0&12 & 73&8 & 0&17 & 0&45 & 0&05 & b1133 + 16 & 0&27 & 73&8 & 1&6@xmath165 & 0&18 & 0&02 & b1237 + 25 & 0&56 & 73&8 & 1&8@xmath165 & 0&30 & 0&06 & b1508 + 55 & 1&93 & 73&8 & 3&8@xmath164 & 0&28 & 0&09 & b1919 + 21 & 0&66 & 73&8 & 7&5@xmath164 & @xmath1710&21 & in this paper , the theory of the @xmath32 model for the electron density spectrum was derived for discontinuous density structures and compared with pulsar observations . a new feature of our analysis is the inclusion of an `` outer scale '' needed in any realistic model . the model is characterized by an effective exponent @xmath76 of the structure function , which remains between 1.95 and 1.6 over a very wide range of @xmath53 values ( cf . figure [ fig : slope ] ) . this at first seems a promising explanation for the spread in the estimates of @xmath79 derived from vlbi observations of the angular broadening profile , as observed on heavily scattered lines of sight . as discussed in section [ sec : decbw ] , from figures [ fig : vela ] and [ fig : other ] , we find that the @xmath32 model provides a somewhat better agreement with the measurements of the diffractive decorrelation bandwidth versus frequency for pulsar psr b0833@xmath8645 ( vela ) than does the simple kolmogorov model . this might arise from refractive scattering effects caused in the supernova remnant associated with the vela pulsar . four other pulsars with decorrelation bandwidths measured against frequency show an appreciably stronger frequency dependence than the predictions of both the simple kolmogorov and @xmath32 models . however , there are substantial inconsistencies among the measurements and better observations are clearly needed , especially in view of the variability in @xmath112 documented by bhat at al . ( 1999c ) . the predictions of the @xmath32 model for the variation of the refractive scintillation index with the diffractive decorrelation bandwidth are in partial agreement with the observations . as discussed in section [ sec : mr ] , the values of @xmath119 measured near 100 mhz are above the prediction of the simple kolmogorov model and had previously been explained as the effect of an inner scale , substantially larger than the values invoked by spangler & gwinn 1990 . however , the measurements are also consistent with the @xmath32 model with suitable choices of the outer scale . for the 610 mhz data , most of the measured @xmath119 values are in good agreement with the prediction of the simple kolmogorov model for the extended medium , and they lie below the curves of the @xmath32 model . however , there are a significant number of good - quality observations , which lie somewhat above the kolmogorov line . we suggest an alternative to a large inner scale on those lines of sight , that they pass through regions of enhanced density , which cause enhanced refractive scattering ; these regions must have less small - scale substructure than in a turbulent medium and could include discontinuities . based on the above considerations , we reject the @xmath32 model as a universal spectral model for the interstellar electron density fluctuations . the corollary is to strengthen the evidence for the kolmogorov density spectrum , which in turn suggests a turbulent process in the interstellar plasma . however , the simple kolmogorov spectrum is not a universal model either , since it disagrees with several of the @xmath119 observations . since the @xmath32 model provides reasonable agreement for many of these discrepant observations , we propose that enhancements in the large scale part of the spectrum ( which need not be described by discontinuities in density ) occur on these lines of sight . with such enhancements causing the increase in refractive scintillation , there is no need to invoke the relatively large inner scales proposed by coles et al . ( 1987 ) . as proposed by spangler & gwinn ( 1990 ) , a relatively small inner scale is then likely , controlled by the ion inertial length or larmor radius . [ cols= " < , < " , ] it appears that different spectral models need to be considered for different lines of sight . a widely distributed turbulent plasma with occasional large ionized structures that increase the effective average power density , @xmath172 , at low wavenumbers ( large scales : @xmath121 m to @xmath173 m ) is thus a model that needs further formal investigation . very similar conclusions have been reached by lestrade et al . ( 1998 ) and by bhat et al . ( 1999b , c ) . this model could also explain the occasional `` extreme scattering events '' and episodes of fringes in dynamic spectra when a line of sight passes through a particular discrete density enhancement . new theoretical work is needed to quantify the expected statistics of these propagation events . it is likely that numerical modeling will be necessary to model non - stationary scattering media . * acknowledgements : this work was supported by the nsf under grant ast-9414144 . * here we derive expressions for the refractive modulation index , @xmath119 , as a function of the normalized diffractive decorrelation bandwidth , @xmath120 , for the inner - scale and @xmath32 models . the simple kolmogorov model is included as a special case where the inner scale goes to zero . a general integral expression for the refractive scintillation index is given by equation ( [ eq : crextmed ] ) . with the medium concentrated into a thin layer ( thickness @xmath67 at @xmath68 from the source ) and an assumption of isotropy in the density spectrum , the equation becomes : @xmath174 \nonumber \\ & & \times \sin^2\left(\frac{r_{\rm f , scr}^2 \kappa^2}{2}\right ) \kappa \ , d\kappa \ , \mbox{. } \label{eq : app : mrscreen } \ ] ] for both the inner - scale and @xmath32 models , the exponential function in equation ( [ eq : app : mrscreen ] ) may be approximated by the gaussian ( coles et al . 1987 ) : @xmath175 \simeq \exp\left [ -(r_{\rm f , scr } u_{\rm scr})^2 \kappa^2 \right ] \ , \mbox { , } \label{eq : app : gauss } \ ] ] where @xmath137 is the fresnel scale and @xmath102 is the strength of scattering , as defined in section [ sec : mr ] . we now substitute models for the density spectrum @xmath176 , given by equations ( [ eq : extpowerlaw ] ) ( with @xmath177 ) and ( [ eq : beta4 ] ) and obtain relations between @xmath119 and the scattering measure @xmath74 . to these we add the connections between @xmath107 and @xmath70 , for each spectral model , from the equations for the phase structure functions ( 17 ) , ( 11 ) , and ( 21 ) of lr99 . for the inner - scale model , we obtain : @xmath178^{(2-\alpha)/\alpha } \ , \mbox { , } \label{eq : app : sminscale } \ ] ] where @xmath179^{\alpha/(\alpha-2 ) } \ , \mbox{. } \label{eq : app : mualpha } \ ] ] then substituting for @xmath107 we obtain an integral for @xmath128 , which can be solved analytically using standard techniques ( see e.g. appendix 2 of rickett 1973 ) : @xmath180^{(2-\alpha)/\alpha } \times \nonumber \\ & & \left [ ( \cos\psi)^{-\alpha/2 } \cos(\psi\alpha/2 ) - 1 \right ] \ , \times \nonumber \\ & & \left [ ( l_i/2s_{\rm 0,scr})^2 + u_{\rm scr}^4 \right]^{\alpha /2 } \ , \mbox { , } \label{eq : app : mrscreeninscale } \ ] ] where @xmath151 , and @xmath181 is given by : @xmath182 \ , \mbox{. } \label{eq : app : thetae } \ ] ] we see that @xmath119 depends on @xmath102 with @xmath153 as a parameter . similarly the diffractive decorrelation bandwidth , @xmath120 , depends on @xmath102 through equation ( [ eq : delta_nu_d ] ) with @xmath95 as a parameter , which is a very slow function of @xmath153 as discussed in section [ sec : decbw ] . for the simple power - law model we set @xmath183 , and in the strong scattering limit ( @xmath184 ) , equation ( [ eq : app : thetae ] ) gives @xmath185 , and we obtain the asymptotic expression : @xmath186 putting this together for the simple kolmogorov model with @xmath127 , we have the simple relation : @xmath187 , plotted as the thick dashed lines in the screen plots in figures [ fig : mr4 ] and [ fig : mrin ] . for the general inner - scale model , with @xmath104 non - zero , we show computed curves in figure [ fig : mrin ] . we can recognize two regimes . consider first the case of small @xmath104 . with sufficiently strong scattering , @xmath188 , @xmath189 . however , there is a complication in portraying this behavior in a plot versus @xmath190 for fixed inner scale , because of the variation of @xmath137 with distance , which is not specified by the horizontal variable @xmath190 . we deal with this by obtaining an approximate scaling of @xmath137 with @xmath190 . when @xmath191 , equation ( [ eq : app : sminscale ] ) relates @xmath192 , or @xmath193 . we now argue that on average @xmath154 pulsar distance @xmath194 , and eliminating @xmath107 , we see that , @xmath195 . with these scalings and @xmath188 , we see : @xmath196 here @xmath197 is the fresnel scale for a `` reference '' pulsar , and the last version in equation ( [ eq : mr.asymptote1 ] ) comes from using the kolmogorov exponent @xmath198 , which gives the asymptotic slope of 1/8 for curves at the lower left of figure [ fig : mrin ] . now with @xmath199 and @xmath137 fixed , let @xmath70 increase ( i.e. less scattering ) until @xmath200 . the inner scale is no longer important , and we get the same relation as for the simple kolmogorov spectrum : @xmath201 ; visible where the curves steepen with increasing @xmath190 . for larger inner scales , the curves in figure [ fig : mrin ] show a pronounced peak . these occur for inner scales greater than the fresnel scale and will be associated with focusing and caustics . since our treatment only includes the first order term in the low wavenumber expansion , it is not reliable in the region of the peak . goodman et al . ( 1987 ) have discussed caustics at length for the same inner - scale spectrum . they note that when @xmath202 , the scintillation power spectrum starts to fill in at scales intermediate between the diffractive and refractive wavenumbers . their equation ( 2.5.7 ) gives an estimate of the variance in this extra term as : @xmath203 with fixed @xmath104 , @xmath204 increases much more steeply with decreasing @xmath102 than does @xmath128 . thus as @xmath205 decreases , there are fewer and fewer independent phase perturbations across the scattering disc . when @xmath206 , focusing represented by @xmath207 occurs . we note that the theoretical @xmath119 versus @xmath208 plots in gupta et al . ( 1993 ) omit the focusing condition and are wrong for inner scales greater than the fresnel scale . the effect of higher order terms in the low - wavenumber expansion has been studied by dashen & wang ( 1993 ) . they obtain a more efficient expansion scheme that gives improved accuracy near the peak in scintillation index . nevertheless , it seems that a reliable prediction for the behavior near the peak in scintillations requires numerical evaluation . this becomes even more necessary in treating an extended scattering medium . we also note that the drop in @xmath119 as scattering gets weaker past the peak in figure [ fig : mrin ] is real . it represents the fact that when a square - law structure function applies for scales from @xmath70 up to the scattering disc size , there is insufficient phase curvature and the scintillations remain weak even though @xmath144 . in such circumstances the `` scattering disc '' is a misnomer , since an observer would see only a single angle of arrival , that could wander over a region of scale @xmath205 . turning to the screen analysis of the @xmath32 model , we relate @xmath70 to @xmath107 using equation ( 21 ) from lr99 , where the phase structure function equals one . this gives the following analog of equation ( [ eq : app : sminscale ] ) for the inner - scale model : @xmath209 \right\}^{-1 } \mbox{. } \label{eq : app : smbeta4 } \ ] ] substituting the @xmath32 model for the density spectrum in equation ( [ eq : app : mrscreen ] ) and letting @xmath210 , we obtain : @xmath211 \ ; \sin^2 ( r_{\rm f , scr}^2 \eta/2 ) \ ; d\eta \label{eq : app : mrscreenb4_1 } \ ] ] in order to evaluate this integral , we let @xmath212 represent the integrand , and we let @xmath213 be the same as @xmath212 but with @xmath214 set equal to zero . we can then rewrite the integral in equation ( [ eq : app : mrscreenb4_1 ] ) as : @xmath215 \right\}^{-1 } \times \nonumber \\ & & \left\ { \int_0^{\infty } g_1(\eta ) d\eta - \int_0^{\infty } [ g_1(\eta ) - g(\eta ) ] d\eta \right\ } \label{eq : app : mrscreenb4_2 } \ ] ] the first integral can be evaluated analytically ( see e.g. & 1965 ) . in strong scattering , the exponential term cuts off the oscillations of the sine term , which can be approximated by its argument , and the @xmath216 becomes negligible for values of @xmath217 larger than @xmath218 . with these approximations we can also do the second integral . putting these together , we obtain : @xmath219 \right\}^{-1 } \times \nonumber \\ & & \left\ { 4 u_{\rm scr}^2 \tan^{-1}(u_{\rm scr}^{-2 } ) - 2 u_{\rm scr}^4\ln ( 1 + u_{\rm scr}^{-4 } ) - \right . \nonumber \\ & & \left . 2 \zeta \ , [ ( 2 + \zeta ) \ , e^{\zeta } \ , { \rm e_1}(\zeta ) - 1 ] \right\ } \ , \mbox { , } \label{eq : app : mrscreenb4 } \ ] ] where @xmath220 is the exponential integral , @xmath221 . in the latter form @xmath222 is the refractive scale ( equal to scattering disk radius ) . again , @xmath119 is related to @xmath120 through : @xmath223 . the resulting curves are shown in the screen panels of figure [ fig : mr4 ] . consider the asymptotic behavior for @xmath128 in equation ( [ eq : app : mrscreenb4 ] ) as a function of @xmath102 . as the strength of scattering @xmath102 increases , @xmath120 decreases ( @xmath224 ) . in equation ( [ eq : app : mrscreenb4_1 ] ) , the exponential term cuts off the integral ( at @xmath225 ) before the oscillations of the sin@xmath226 fresnel filter , which then approximates @xmath227 . if also @xmath228 , we can ignore @xmath218 in the denominator and the remaining @xmath229 cancels the @xmath230 from the fresnel filter , and the integral depends only on @xmath231 . in this approximation , @xmath128 is then simply proportional to the slowly varying logarithmic term , which explains the relatively flat part of the curves in figure [ fig : mr4 ] ; under these conditions , in equation ( [ eq : app : mrscreenb4 ] ) the first two terms in the curly brackets sum to 2 and the last term is negligible . with @xmath53 fixed , now let @xmath102 increase , making @xmath156 increase . eventually @xmath232 becomes greater than one when the scattering disk becomes greater than the outer scale . at this point the exponential term cuts off the integral below @xmath218 , where the spectrum flattens . as @xmath102 increases even further , the integral decreases steeply , causing the down - turn at very small @xmath120 . we again note that our expressions rely on the first order of an expansion and will not be reliable near the peak in the scintillation index . however , there is not the same focusing condition that applied for very large inner scales . in order to obtain expressions for @xmath119 for the two spectrum models in the _ uniform extended medium geometry , we must complete the line - of - sight integrals in equation ( [ eq : crextmed ] ) in addition to following the steps used in the screen geometry . for each distance @xmath233 in the line of sight , there is also an integration over variable @xmath135 in the exponential cut - off . if @xmath234 , this @xmath135-integration yields @xmath235 , where @xmath236 . this again provides a low - pass cut - off at the reciprocal of the radius of the effective scattering disk , where @xmath237 . we define the scattering strength by @xmath238 , with the field coherence scale @xmath239 , as in lr99 , defined where the spherical wave structure function equals unity , measured in the observing plane . for the other spectrum models there is not such a simple relation for the @xmath135-integration , but there is still an effective cutoff given by a similar equation . when the @xmath134-integration is completed , the effective fresnel scale is actually smaller than @xmath240 due to averaging over the @xmath241 . _ in analogy with the screen geometry , we make use of identities similar to those given by equations ( [ eq : app : sminscale ] ) and ( [ eq : app : smbeta4 ] ) . for the extended medium , these identities are in turn derived from the _ wave _ structure functions for the inner - scale and @xmath32 models ( cf . the identities obtained thus will be similar to those for the screen geometry , except that for the inner - scale model , ( 1 ) there will be a factor of 3 on the right side of equation ( [ eq : app : sminscale ] ) , and ( 2 ) the 1 in square brackets is replaced by @xmath242^{\alpha/(\alpha-2 ) } \approx 1.8 $ ] for the kolmogorov exponent . for the @xmath32 model , the only change will be a factor of 3 on the right side of equation ( [ eq : app : smbeta4 ] ) . we use all of the aforementioned identities for the inner - scale and @xmath32 models and compute the @xmath134 integral numerically , since it can not be carried out analytically . the shapes of the curves bear a close relationship to the screen results , though the extended medium values generally lie above the associated screen values at the same @xmath190 . the second moment of intensity is needed to describe the fluctuations of intensity . under strong scintillation conditions , separate forms can be used for refractive and diffractive fluctuations , since their spatial scales differ by several orders of magnitude . in lr99 , as elsewhere in the iss literature , the correlation of diffractive scintillations is approximated by the squared magnitude of the second moment of the field , leading to the simple result that the spatial scale of the diffractive scintillations is equal to the scale where the phase structure function equals unity ( @xmath65 ) . however , goodman and narayan ( 1985 ) showed that for steep spectra ( @xmath243 ) this is no longer the case and the diffractive scale can be larger than @xmath65 . here we examine this question for the @xmath32 spectrum . we give the details for a phase screen with plane wave source , which are readily generalized to a spherical wave source . the two - frequency intensity cross - spectrum at wavenumber @xmath244 for a screen at distance @xmath62 is given by the fourier - like integral equation ( 17 ) of ccffh . this depends on the combination of structure functions @xmath245 , which for a plasma screen can be written as : @xmath246 where @xmath247 and @xmath248 are the two radio wavenumbers , @xmath249 is their geometric mean , @xmath250 is their arithmetic mean , @xmath251 , @xmath252 , and @xmath253 is evaluated at @xmath249 ; @xmath254 is a spatial offset which is the variable of integration . consider first the single frequency case @xmath255 ) . in the limit of very large @xmath139 , the first four structure functions saturate and sum to zero . the last two are equal and @xmath256 , which gives the simple diffractive limit mentioned above . this is the zero - order term of an expansion , which is obtained in terms of the sum of the first four terms as a small quantity . the zero order result requires full saturation , which requires @xmath257 . in diffractive scintillation @xmath258 ; hence , the condition becomes that the refractive scale @xmath259 . our concern here is to consider what happens when the diffractive @xmath139 is not large enough for saturation of @xmath253 . for shallow density spectra ( @xmath260 ) , small argument approximations to the structure function follow an exponent @xmath261 , and the zero - order term gives a good approximation even when @xmath262 . however , for steep spectra goodman and narayan ( 1985 ) showed that the leading term in the structure function follows a square law , which exactly cancels in @xmath245 ; the result is that the high wavenumber limit depends on the next term in the structure function expansion , which yields a diffractive scale that is greater than the scale @xmath65 ( defined by the square law term ) . now we consider the case for @xmath32 model , when the scattering disc @xmath156 is smaller than the outer scale @xmath53 . here we can approximate equation ( [ eq : struc4 ] ) by : @xmath263 as for the steep spectra , the leading term in the structure function follows a square law , which cancels when substituted into equation ( [ eq : v4 ] ) . @xmath245 can then be approximated for large @xmath139 by expanding in @xmath264 . the result is : @xmath265 } { s_0 ^ 2 \ln(4/s_0 ^ 2\kappa_o^2 ) } \ , \mbox{. } \label{eq : v4approx}\ ] ] here @xmath97 is the strength of scattering defined in equation ( [ eq : delta_nu_d ] ) ; @xmath266 is the angle between vectors @xmath139 and @xmath267 . we note that for a kolmogorov spectrum in the high - wavenumber limit , @xmath245 also includes terms in @xmath268 , which would be accounted for in the higher order terms of the expansion . a result similar to equation ( [ eq : v4approx ] ) is given by dashen & wang ( 1993 ) , though for a 1-dimensional phase screen . in considering the spectrum of intensity fluctuations ( eq . 17 of ccffh ) , one can show that the dominant wavenumber is approximately @xmath269 with these substitutions in @xmath245 , which we then set @xmath270 , we solve for @xmath271 ; this gives an approximate equation for the diffractive spatial scale @xmath272 : @xmath273 under the condition assumed in this approximation , @xmath274 , we find @xmath275 . however , in practice the ratio @xmath276 never becomes large . with a large outer scale , say @xmath277 pc , and typical observing conditions @xmath278 m and @xmath279 , we find @xmath280 . thus the diffractive scale could be 70% greater than @xmath65 and would slowly approach @xmath65 for smaller outer scales . turning to the two - frequency intensity correlation ( @xmath281 ) in the diffractive limit of large @xmath139 , the results of ccffh still apply . namely , that the last two terms of equation ( [ eq : v4 ] ) largely control the decorrelation versus frequency . they group the remaining terms into a filter that depends only on @xmath139 and a smaller term that becomes the basis of the expansion . the filter term was discussed by lr99 and shown to be important only as the strength of scattering decreases . it is the last two terms in @xmath245 that determine the zero - order result , so we looked at the effect of the higher order terms . the quantity that we are ultimately concerned with is the cross - correlation of intensity at offset frequencies at the same observing point . this comes from the integral of the cross - spectrum . equations ( 31 ) through ( 34 ) of ccffh give the zero and first order terms of the cross spectrum in terms of the spectrum of refractive index fluctuations in the layer . for the @xmath32 spectrum we reduced these to a sum of confluent hypergeometric functions , which can be explicitly computed . for a sample observing condition we found that the higher order terms for the cross - spectrum itself were significant compared to the zero - order term ; however when integrated to give intensity cross - correlation , they only had a minor effect on the decorrelation bandwidth itself ( @xmath282% increase ) . the reason for this appears to be the dominant effect of the last two terms in the @xmath245 summation with unequal frequencies . to summarize we find a modest ( logarithmic ) increase in the diffractive scale relative to the field coherence scale @xmath65 , but that this remains less than a factor of 1.7 for the likely iss parameters . this is accompanied by a smaller increase in the decorrelation bandwidth relative to the calculations of lr99 , which relied on the normal zero - order expansion at high wavenumbers . this small offset in the decorrelation bandwidth is negligible compared to the measurement errors for the observations under consideration . we assume that the conclusions reached here for a screen would also apply for an extended scattering medium . stinebring , d. r. , smirnova , t. v. , hovis , j. , kempner , j. c. , myers , e. b. , hankins , t. h. , kaspi , v. m. , & nice , d. j. 1996 , in `` pulsars : problems and progress '' , ed . johnston , s. , walker , m. a. , & bailes , m. , proceedings of iau colloquium 160 , asp conference series , 105 , 455

we develop the theory of interstellar scintillation as caused by an irregular plasma having a power - law spatial density spectrum with a spectral exponent of @xmath0 corresponding to a medium with abrupt changes in its density . an `` outer scale '' is included in the model representing the typical scale over which the density of the medium remains uniform . such a spectrum could be used to model plasma shock fronts in supernova remnants or other plasma discontinuities . we investigate and develop equations for the decorrelation bandwidth of diffractive scintillations and the refractive scintillation index and compare our results with pulsar measurements . we consider both a medium concentrated in a thin layer and an extended irregular medium . we conclude that the @xmath0 model gives satisfactory agreement for many diffractive measurements , in particular the vlbi meaurements of the structure function exponent between 5/3 and 2 . however , it gives less satisfactory agreement for the refractive scintillation index than does the kolmogorov turbulence spectrum . the comparison suggests that the medium consists of a pervasive background distribution of turbulence embedded with randomly placed discrete plasma structures such as shocks or hii regions . this can be modeled by a composite spectrum following the kolmogorov form at high wavenumbers and steepening at lower wavenumbers corresponding to the typical ( inverse ) size of the discrete structures . such a model can also explain the extreme scattering events . however , lines of sight through the enhanced scattering prevalent at low galactic latitudes are accurately described by the kolmogorov spectrum in an extended medium and do not appear to have a similar low - wavenumber steepening .

1607.07042

muons have been undispensible probes in fundamental ( and applied ) physics for a long time . their completely unexpected discovery is ascribed to anderson and neddermeyer.@xcite muons have already been seen earlier by kunze@xcite albeit without claiming detection of a new particle . actually muons were until the 1940s mostly considered to be the predicted and searched for pions . in 1960 muonium ( mu ) , the hydrogen - like bound state of a positive muon and an electron ( @xmath2e@xmath3 ) , was unambiguously detected by hughes and coworkers.@xcite muons and mu continue to play a role of utmost importance in precision tests of the standard model of particle physics as well as in the search for new physics beyond it . they can be produced in comparatively large quantities , they live long enough for many applications and they decay sufficiently fast in a parity violating , self polarization - analyzing weak process ( @xmath4 ) which makes them most versatile . actually , the discovery of parity violation ( pv ) in nuclear @xmath5 decay@xcite was instantaneously followed by the demonstration of pv in muon decay.@xcite later it has been shown that the v - a structure of the standard model weak interaction follows already solely from muon decay experiments , including inverse muon decay.@xcite the reader will find an excellent review on fundamental muon physics@xcite and many references concerning the important role of low momentum muons , pions and neutrons in precision physics in ref . . below , a brief status update on muon activities at psi is presented without explicitly connecting to the standard - model extension ( sme ) and its coefficients.@xcite however , given the fact that all precision experiments acquire time stamped data sets , a wealth of opportunities exists for corresponding analyses . psi s hipa complex with its unique beam power provides the largest intensities of low momentum pions , muons and ultracold neutrons to fundamental physics experiments . the arrangement of the pion production targets as part of the beam optics of the proton beam onto the continuous spallation neutron source sinq at psi guarantees a highly efficient pion and muon production . the full proton beam intensity can be used while about 70% of the beam continues with only a small energy loss to the spallation target of sinq . most of the recent particle physics experiments used low momentum beams of both polarities ( @xmath2 , @xmath6 ) for measurements with stopped muons in low mass targets . prime examples of such efforts yielded ( i ) the new limit of @xmath7 ( 90% c.l . ) for the charged lepton flavor violating decay @xmath8 by the meg collaboration,@xcite using @xmath9/s @xmath2 of about 28mev / c ( 4mev kinetic energy ) stopping after some degrader in an about 200@xmath10 m thick polyethylene target and ( ii ) the measurements of 2s-2p lamb shift transitions in muonic hydrogen and deuterium by the crema collaboration,@xcite stopping about 600/s @xmath6 of only 3kev kinetic energy in a 20 cm long target filled with about 1hpa of h@xmath11 or d@xmath11 , respectively , and determining the nuclear rms charge radii of both proton and deuteron to about @xmath12 precision . these two experiments were conducted at hipa s @xmath13e5 beamline ( see the beamline overview map@xcite ) which presently is the world s highest intensity low momentum muon beam for particle physics . even slightly higher intensities are obtained at the @xmath10e4 beam@xcite which is usually dedicated to condensed matter studies with muon spin rotation ( @xmath10sr ) but has recently also been applied to study mu production into vacuum.@xcite a very successful series of experiments was conducted by the mulan,@xcite mucap,@xcite and musun@xcite collaborations , initially in the @xmath13e3 and later in the @xmath13e1 beam areas.@xcite the 1ppm measurement of the positive muon lifetime by mulan resulted in a 0.5ppm determination of the fermi coupling constant @xmath14 . mucap measured the @xmath6 lifetime in a high - purity protium target and determined the singlet capture rate to 1% and by that the weak pseudoscalar coupling @xmath15 of the proton to 7% . musun is under way to determine the muon capture rate on deuterons by the same technique . various new muon experiments are under way and progress has recently been reported at psi s annual particle physics users meeting.@xcite the meg ii experiment aims at a sensitivity to @xmath8 of @xmath16 . the mu3e collaboration pursues a search for the charged lepton flavor violating decay @xmath17 in two phases , first aiming at @xmath18 and later @xmath19 at the new himb . studies for himb already benefit conventional meson target designs.@xcite himb will provide @xmath20/s below 30mev / c to the phase-2 mu3e experiment . the beamline will open up new possibilites for statistically limited muon experiments in general . the muse collaboration will compare muon and electron scattering on hydrogen at the @xmath13m1 beamline@xcite and decisively test the difference in rms charge radii obtained so far by electron scattering and ordinary hydrogen spectroscopy versus the muonic atom result.@xcite the crema collaboration has meanwhile finished data taking on the 2s-2p lamb shift transitions in @xmath21he and is now turning to the laser spectroscopy of the ground state hyperfine splitting in h and @xmath22he . also spectroscopy of heavy muonic atoms is regaining interest , e.g. , the mux collaboration is setting out to measure the charge radii of @xmath23ra and other heavy , radioactive isotopes . a lot of progress is also being made by the mucool collaboration with the development of a very high brightness beam of slow @xmath2.@xcite together with ref . this development will allow for an improved measurement of the mu 1s-2s transition@xcite and pave the way for a test of the free fall of mu,@xcite the mass of which is dominated by the antimatter , second generation lepton . illuminating discussions with colleagues , especially at cpt16 , and continued support of psi s accelerator and beam line groups and psi / eth technical services , the swiss national science foundation ( 200020_159754 ) and the eth zrich ( eth-35 14 - 1 ) are gratefully acknowledged .

the paul scherrer institut in switzerland operates the high intensity proton accelerator facility hipa . a 590mev kinetic energy proton beam of presently up to 2.4ma is sent to target stations producing pions , muons and neutrons for fundamental and applied physics . the beam power of 1.4mw provides the world s highest intensities of low momentum muons which can be stopped in low mass targets . rates of surface muons of up to about @xmath0/s are being provided to various unique precision particle physics experiments . two feasibility studies are ongoing to considerably improve the available muon beams . the high intensity muon beamline , himb , could deliver on the order of @xmath1/s surface muons and the stopped muon cooler , mucool , aims at a gain factor of @xmath1 in phase space quality while sacrificing only less than 3 orders of magnitude in intensity for low energy @xmath2 . these beams will allow a new generation of precision physics experiments with stopped muons and muonium atoms .

1608.05837

graphene systems , which are composed of one or a few carbon monatomic layers , have attracted much attention due to their unusual electronic properties even at room temperature , such as a high carrier mobility , thermal and structural stabilities , low spin orbit , hyperfine interactions , long spin relaxation length , and gate - tunable spin transport , and their potential for applications in nanoelectronic and spintronic devices @xcite.currently , there is a continuous interest in blg properties , both theoretically and experimentally . a bilayer graphene consists of two single graphene layers and has two different stacking arrangements : ab ( bernal ) and aa . energy band gap in blg nanoribbon and nanoflake could be controlled by substrate properties and the applied vertical electric field , so these structures could be used as a channel material in carbon - based transistors @xcite . moreover , several studies have been performed , both theoretically and experimentally , on transport properties in blg structure @xcite . interestingly , blg field - effect - transistors with high on / off current ratios at room temperature have been reported @xcite . in blg nanoribbons with zigzag edges , electronic transport is dominated by edge - states similar to those of single - layer graphene @xcite . these states are expected to be spin - polarized and make zigzag - edge blg nanoribbons junctions attractive for spin - polarized transport @xcite . on the other hand , long spin relaxation length in bilayer graphene nanoribbons and few - layer graphene flakes was observed at room temperature @xcite . moreover , spin - filtering and spin - dependent transport properties of blg with ferromagnetic electrode and gate , external magnetic field , and exchange field have been investigated theoretically and experimentally @xcite . another important feature of graphene in spintronic devices is its magnetoresistance . giant magnetoresistance ( gmr ) in graphene junction with ferromagnetic electrodes @xcite and magnetic states of zigzag edges have been extensively investigated @xcite . but there has been a little attention to the magnetoresistance effects in blg junction @xcite . in this paper , we studied the coherent magnetic transport properties of a blg nanoflake connected to two single - layer zigzag graphene nanoribbon ( zgnr ) electrodes . the results showed that the application of a magnetic field only on blg as a channel changes the spin configuration and conductivity of the blg zigzag edge and induces a perfect spin - polarized conductance in the ab- stacked blg structures . moreover , we studied the magnetic transport properties by changing blg width and length connected between zgnr electrodes . finally , we found a gmr up to @xmath0 and suggested that the gmr could be tuned by varying blg width and length . we simulated the system depicted in fig . 1a using a @xmath1-orbital tight - binding model and hubbard repulsion treated in the mean - field approximation . this formalism that includes @xmath2 interaction in blg induces localized magnetic moments in zigzag - edge atoms . we wrote the mean - field hamiltonian in the ab - stacked blg as follows @xcite : @xmath3 where @xmath4 ( @xmath5 ) stands for the creation ( annihilation ) operator of an electron with spin @xmath6 located on site . the tight - binding parameters @xmath7 were fixed to their bulk values equal to @xmath8 for the in - plane nearest neighbors of i and j and @xmath9 for the interlayer hopping parameter @xcite , and @xmath10 is the on - site coulomb interaction . the greens function of the junction is expressed as @xmath11^{-1}.\ ] ] where @xmath12 , @xmath13 are the self - energy matrices due to the connection of right and left zgnr electrodes to the channel , respectively . the spin - dependent density of states ( dos ) of the blg in the presence of electrodes is given by @xmath14 accordingly , the magnetic moment at each atomic site can be expressed as @xmath15 according to the landauer - buttiker formalism @xcite the spin - dependent conductance and currents can be written as @xmath16.\ ] ] using @xmath17 , the coupling matrices @xmath18 can be expressed as @xmath19 $ ] . also , the spin - dependent currents can be written as @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the fermi@xmath22dirac distribution function and consider the effect of temperature . we calculate the magnetoresistance of each device as @xmath23 we solved equation 1 - 3 self consistently by an iteration method . by choosing anti - ferromagnetic ( afm ) and ferromagnetic ( fm ) spin configurations as initial conditions in blg nanoflake , different spin configurations of afm and fm were achieved , respectively . moreover , the effect of single - layer graphene nanoribbon as an electrode on blg was added via self - energies , and the green function of blg was subsequently calculated . finally , the new expectation values of number operators were replaced in the hamiltonian , and this process was repeated until convergence was achieved@xcite . note that in the bilayer graphene nanoflake , the upper single - layer graphene was only connected to the lower one through single - band tight binding model in the first nearest neighbors approximation . the effect of electrodes on the upper monoatomic sheet was indirectly added through the hopping parameter between two monatomic sheets in blg nanoflake . modulation of hopping parameter between electrodes and blg could broaden electron energy level and consequently lead to the decrease of edge magnetism in blg nanoflakes@xcite . and length @xmath24 attached between semi - infinite zgnr electrodes , ( b ) ( top view ) and ( c ) ab - stacked blg as a channel with afm and fm spin configurations on zigzag edges , respectively . open ( red in online version ) and filled ( blue in online version ) circles represent spin - down and spin - up densities , respectively . the magnetic moments are within [ -0.25:0.25 ] @xmath25 and [ -0.05:0.25 ] @xmath25 in cases b and c , respectively . ] and @xmath24 ) with afm ( a and c ) and fm ( b and d ) spin configurations . ( a ) and ( b ) show the density of states , and ( c ) and ( d ) show the transmission coefficient of the blg junction . the solid ( dashed ) line is for minority- ( or majority- ) spin electrons . ] we considered ab - stacked blg as a channel connected between two semi - infinite single - layer zgnr electrodes . a similar junction ( monolayer - bilayer junction ) was proposed in previous works and its electronic and transport properties were investigated even under applied biases @xcite . the number of armchair rows along x direction , @xmath26 , defines a blg length and the number of zigzag rows along y direction , @xmath27 , defines a blg width . thus , blg length and width are @xmath28 and @xmath29 , respectively , with a=2.42(fig . anti - ferromagnetic ( afm ) spin configuration of ab - stacked blg ( see fig . 1b ) is more stable than other spin configurations . however , in the presence of an external magnetic field , the edge spin orientations become parallel and blg structure would have ferromagnetic ( fm ) spin configuration along all zigzag edges , similar to monolayer graphene nanoribbons and flakes @xcite ( see fig . we considered two different spin configurations in blg junction . rectangular blgs with afm spin configuration along zigzag edge have a zero net magnetic moment according to the lieb s theorem @xcite . due to external magnetic field applied perpendicular to blg , it has a fm spin configuration and a net magnetic moment in the channel . consequently , the degeneracy between up- and down - spin electrons breaks . according to the prediction of density functional theory , the spin - correlation length limits long - range magnetic order to 1 nm at room temperature@xcite , therefore in our calculation the semi - infinite zgnrs do not include edge magnetism and all spin - dependent scatterings are induced by the localized magnetic moments in blg . in other words , the effect of edge magnetic moments on the zigzag - shaped edges in these zgnr electrodes was intentionally not included in our calculations in order to emphasize on the role of magnetic field in blg geometry and its magnetic edge - states in generating spin - polarized currents and gmr . we showed in fig . 2 the spin - dependent destiny of states and conductance as some functions of energy for the device depicted in fig . 1 with afm and fm spin configurations in blg . by comparing density of states and conductance for afm an fm cases , it is clear that due to the influence of external magnetic field on the edge - states in the blg nanoflake , the conductance and density of states of the blg junction do not vanish at the band center . therefore , the electronic structure and conductance strongly change with the spin orientation of the zigzag edge - state . moreover , the density of states and conductance for the two spin sub - bands are non - degenerate in fm case ( see figs . 2b and 2d ) . hence , in the fm case , conductance and energy spectra around the fermi energy indicate a high conductivity and a spin - polarized behavior . generally , magnetic transport properties of zgnr / ab - stacked blg / zgnr junction are strongly dependent on the magnetization of the zigzag edge - states in blg . in fm case , when the electron conduction through the nonmagnetic zgnr as electrodes arrives at blg nanoflake , different scatterings occur for majority- and minority - spin electrons . hence , the transmission coefficients for spin - up and spin - down electrons are different . for more clarification , we plotted spin polarization ( @xmath30 ) as a function of energy and with @xmath24 and four different widths in fig . 3 . interestingly , a high spin polarization near the fermi energy and in a large energy region could be obtained for the ab - stacked blg junction with different widths . it is clear that , the spin polarization depends on the blg width . for example , in blg of widths @xmath31 and @xmath32 , the spin polarization through the junction will be different from that of a blg of widths @xmath33 and @xmath34 . in summary , blg of widths @xmath31 and @xmath32 shows a perfect spin polarization in a large energy region . as width increases , some non - spin - polarized local density is produced around the fermi energy due to the effect of non - magnetic edge state of zgnr as electrodes , and spin polarization values are therefore strongly modulated by increasing width near the fermi energy . and fm spin configuration . ] in order to see the sensitivity of the device to a switching magnetic field , we plotted the zero - bias magnetoresistance as @xmath35 as a function of blg length for four widths , as shown in fig . 4a . the junction , made entirely of carbon , produces a giant magnetoresistance ( gmr ) up to @xmath36 . 4a shows the zero - bias magnetoresistance changes in a wide range from @xmath37 to @xmath36 . our results showed that the gmr in the junction is sensitive to the width and length of blg nanoflakes . moreover , we can produce a higher magnetoresistance in blg junction by using a longer blg nanoflake . interestingly , for a blg longer than 1 nm , gmr increases as channel length increases and its width decreases , and the gmr could be controlled by changing the blg length and width . generally , mr in a ab - stacked blg strongly increases ( decreases ) with length ( width ) . as length increases , the total magnetic moment in blg nanoflake increases and this increase produces a larger spin splitting and gmr in these devices . but as width increases , some non - spin - polarized local density is produced around the fermi energy due to the effect of non - magnetic edge state of zgnr as electrodes , and therefore decreases gmr in our devices . at 100 k. ] in fig . 4 ( b ) , we plotted the gmr as a function of bias voltage with @xmath24 and various widths at 100 k. for zigzag graphene nanoribbon , the spin correlation length at 100 k is about 3 nm @xcite . therefore , spin configuration in a blg having nx=12 does not change significantly by temperature . as blg width increases the conductance value around fermi energy ( @xmath38 ) in afm state increases , and at low bias voltage the current also increases , so gmr value decreases from @xmath39to @xmath37 as blg width increases . moreover , the gmr slop as a function of bias voltage ( fig . 4b ) remains constant by varying the blg width . generally , the zigzag edge - state in the ab - stacked blg is strongly modulated by the applied external magnetic field and produce gmr in a large bias region from -80 to 80 mv . note that gmr value in our proposed blg junction is about that in single - layer zgnr junction @xcite . it suggests that our proposed device might possess some advantages in construction of blg - based spin devices . moreover , in order to keep the transport in the ballistic regime , the bias voltage is assumed to be very small , implying that electrons are transmitted through the channel with energies close to the fermi level @xmath40 . the spin - unpolarized zigzag - edge bilayer graphene nanoribbons show a sharp peak at the fermi energy , and so they have a metallic behavior in aa- and ab - stacking arrangements . however , for the spin resolved solution , ab - stacked and aa - staked cases show different electronic properties . interestingly , ab - stacked bilayer graphene is semiconducting and metallic depending on the afm and fm spin configuration , respectively ( similar to ab - stacked blg nanoflake ) @xcite . in contrast to ab - stacked , aa - stacked bilayer graphene in spin - resolved situation is metallic @xcite and does not show obvious changes in band structure by changing spin configuration . hence , in the aa - stacked case , the conductance could not be modulated by magnetization of the zigzag edges and this structure could not show a significant magnetoresistance effect . the magnetoresistance and coherent spin transport properties of zigzag - edge blg nanoflake attached between two semi - infinite zgnr electrodes were investigated by using a tight binding model , a mean field hubbard hamiltonian , and the landauer - buttiker formalism . our results showed that by designing a graphene - based structure and utilizing the property of intrinsic magnetic edge - states of blg , one could generate gmr by applying an external magnetic field in the small part of the junction , without coupling ferromagnetic leads . in ab - stacked blg , the conductance could be strongly modulated by magnetization of the zigzag - edge blg and by applying a magnetic field , a perfect spin - polarized current and a gmr up to @xmath36 could be generated . ab - stacked blg width and length have significant effects on the magnetic transport and gmr properties in zgnr / ab - stacked blg / zgnr . our results showed that the ab - stacked blg has a strong modulating ability for the spin - dependent transport and it might possess some advantages in construction of carbon - based spin devices . this work is financially supported by university of kashan under grant no . 468825 . j. b. oostinga , h. b. heersche , x. liu , a. f. morpurgo and l. m. k. vandersypen , nat . mater . 7 , 151 ( 2007 ) . b. ghosh , j. appl . 109 , 013706 ( 2011 ) . v. h. nguyen , a. bournel , and p. dollfus , j. appl . 109 , 073717 ( 2011 ) . t. j. echtermeyer , m. c. lemme , m. baus , b. n. szafranek , a. k. geim , and h. kurz , ieee . electron device lett 29 , 952 ( 2008 ) . a. saffarzadeh and r. farghadan , appl . 98 , 023106 ( 2011 ) . x. zhong , r. pandey , and s. p. karna , carbon 50 , 784 ( 2012 ) . x. li , k. m. borysenko , m. b. nardelli , and k. w. kim , phys . rev . b 84 , 195453 ( 2011 ) . f. xia , d. b. farmer , y. lin , and p. avouris , nano lett . 10 , 715 ( 2010 ) . t. y. yang , j. balakrishnan , f. volmer , a. avsar , m. jaiswal , j. samm , s. r. ali , a. pachoud , m. zeng , m. popinciuc , g. guntherodt , b. beschoten , and b. ozyilmaz , phys . 107 , 047206 ( 2011 ) . w. han and r. k. kawakami , phys . 107 , 047207 ( 2011 ) . y. sato , k. takai , and t. enoki , nano lett . 11 , 3468 ( 2011 ) . e. mccann and m. koshino , rep . 76 , ( 2013 ) 056503 s. s. gregersen , j. g. pedersen , s. r. power , and a. p. jauho , phys . rev . b 91 , 115424 ( 2015 ) . san - jose , r. v. gorbachev , a. k. geim , k. s. novoselov , and f. guinea , nano lett . 14 , 2052 ( 2014 ) . y. ouyang , p. campbell , and j. guo , appl . 92 , 063120 ( 2008 ) . j. m. pereira , p. vasilopoulos , and f. m. peeters , nano lett . 7 , 946 ( 2007 ) . h. zhang , j. w. huang , j. velasco jr , k. myhro , m. maldonado , d. d. tran , z. zhao , f. wang , y. lee , g. liu , w. bao , and ch . n. lau , carbon 69 , 336 ( 2014 ) . e. v. castro , n. m. r. peres , j. m. b. lopes dos santos , a. h. castro neto , and f. guinea , phys . 100 , 026802 ( 2008 ) . l. pisani , j. a. chan , b. montanari , and n. m. harrison , phys . b 75 , 064418 ( 2007 ) . b. sahu , h. min , and s. k. banerjee , phys . b 81 , 045414 ( 2010 ) . b. sahu , h. min , a. h. macdonald , and s. k. banerjee , phys . rev . b 78 , 045404 ( 2008 ) . h. lee , y. w. son , n. park , s. han , and j. yu , phys . b 72 , 174431 ( 2005 ) . y. guo , w. guo , and c. chen , j. phys . c 114 , 13098 ( 2010 ) . g. p. gui , g. kadayaprath , s. m. tan , e. c. faliakou , c. choy , a. ward , and r. ahern , plast reconstr surg . 121 , 17 ( 2008 ) . a. orellana , l. rosales , l. chico , and m. pacheco , j. appl . phys . 113 , 213710 ( 2013 ) . y. yu , q. liang , and j. dong , phys . lett . a 375 , 2858 ( 2011 ) . j. f. liu and k. s. chan , nanotechnology 22 , 395201 ( 2011 ) . j. bai , r. cheng , f. xiu , l. liao , m. wang , a. shailos , k. l. wang , y. huang , and x. duan , nat . nanotechnol . 5 , 655 ( 2010 ) . y. t. zhang , h. jiang , f. q. sun , and x. c. xie , phys . b 81 , 165404 ( 2010 ) . k. gopinadhan , y. j. shin , i. yudhistira , j. niu , and h. yang , phys . rev . b 88 , 195429 ( 2013 ) . r. farghadan and e. saievar - iranizad , solid state commun . 151 , 1763 ( 2011 ) . w. y. kim and k. s. kim , nat . nanotechnol . 3 , 408 ( 2008 ) . f. munoz - rojas , j. fernandez - rossier , and j. j. palacios , phys . 136810 ( 2009 ) . j. li , z. h. zhang , x. q. deng , z. q. fan , and g. p. tang , carbon 93 , 335 ( 2015 ) . z. f. wang and f. liu , appl . 99 , 042110 ( 2011 ) . j. nilsson , a. h. castroneto , f. guinea , and n. m. r. peres , phys . b 76 , 165416 ( 2007 ) . buttiker m , imry y , landauer r and pinhas s 1985 phys . b 31 6207 r. farghadan and a. saffarzadeh , j. phys . condens . matter 22 , 255301 ( 2010 ) . s. krompiewski nanotechnology 25 , 465201 , 2014 k. m. m. habib , f. zahid , and r. k. lake , appl . 98 , 192112 ( 2011 ) . t. nakanishi , m. koshino , and t. ando , phys . b 82 125428 ( 2010 ) . m. koshino , t. nakanishi , and t. ando , phys . rev . b 82 , 205436 ( 2010 ) . j. w. gonzalez , h. santos , e. prada , l. brey , and l. chico , phys . b 83 , 205402 ( 2011 ) . d. yin , w. liu , x. li , l. geng , x. wang , and p. huai , appl . 103 , 173519 ( 2013 ) .

coherent spin transport through bilayer graphene ( blg ) nanoflakes sandwiched between two electrodes made of single - layer zigzag graphene nanoribbon was investigated by means of landauer - buttiker formalism . application of a magnetic field only on blg structure as a channel produces a perfect spin polarization in a large energy region . moreover , the conductance could be strongly modulated by magnetization of the zigzag edge of ab - stacked blg , and the junction , entirely made of carbon , produces a giant magnetoresistance ( gmr ) up to @xmath0 . intestinally , gmr and spin polarization could be tuned by varying blg width and length . generally , mr in a ab - stacked blg strongly increases ( decreases ) with length ( width ) . 1 cm

1609.00569

the sunspot number series was introduced in the 1860s by rudolf wolf of zrich and became the most commonly used index of long - term solar variability ever since . the sunspot number series is longer than 400 years , including the maunder minimum ( ) , and is composed of observations from a large number of different observers . since they used different instruments and different techniques for observing and recording sunspots , it is unavoidable that data from different observers need to be calibrated to each other to produce a homogeneous dataset . the first inter - calibration of data from different observers was performed by rudolf wolf in the mid-19th century . he proposed a simple linear scaling between the different observers ( the so - called @xmath0factors ) so that the data ( count of groups and sunspots ) from one observer should be multiplied by a @xmath0factor to rescale it to another reference observer . the value of the correction @xmath0factor is assumed to be rigidly fixed , as found by a linear regression , for each observer , and it characterizes the observer s quality in a relative way with respect to the reference observer . since then , this method has always been used until very recently ( ) . the @xmath0factor approach utilizes the method of ordinary linear least square regression forced through the origin . this method is based on several formal assumptions which are usually not discussed , but their violation may lead to incorrect results : 1 . _ linearity _ , _ i.e. _ the relation between two variables @xmath4 and @xmath5 can be described as linear in the entire range of the @xmath4-values . this assumption is invalid for the sunspot ( group ) numbers , as shown by or and discussed here , because of the essential nonlinearity . 2 . _ random sample _ , _ i.e. _ the pairs of @xmath4- and @xmath5-values are taken randomly from the same population and have sufficient lengths . this assumption is valid in this case . zero conditional mean _ , _ i.e. _ normality and independence of errors , implying that all errors are normally distributed around the true values . this assumption is also invalid since the errors are asymmetric and not normal ( ) . _ constant variance ( homoscedasticity)_. this assumption is violated since the variance of the data is not constant but depends on the level of solar activity so that the variance of the data points is much larger for periods of high activity than around solar minima . x - values are supposed to be known exactly without errors . this assumption is invalid since data from the calibrated observer ( x - axis ) can be even more uncertain than those by the reference observer ( y - axis ) . 6 . additionally , forcing through the origin is assumed for the @xmath0factors . this assumption is also invalid as shown by , since no spot reported by an observer does not necessarily mean that an observer with a better instrument would not see some small spots . we do not discuss here the issue of collinearity , since this assumption is not directly applied to the regression problem considered here . accordingly , five out of six assumptions listed above are invalid in the case of sunspot numbers making the linear scaling calibration by @xmath0factor formally invalid . this method was reasonable in the mid-19th century for interpolations to fill short gaps in observations , but now we aim to develop a more appropriate method for a direct calibration of different observers to each other . several indirect methods of solar - observer calibration have been introduced recently ( ) but here we focus on a direct inter - calibration based on modern statistical methods . it was proposed recently ( ) that the `` quality '' of a solar observer can be quantified not by a relative @xmath0factor but by the observational acuity threshold , _ i.e. _ the minimum size of a sunspot group the observer can see considering the used instrumentation , technique and eyesight . this quantity [ @xmath1 ( in millions of the solar disc , msd ) has a clear meaning all sunspot groups bigger than @xmath3 are reported while all the groups smaller than @xmath3 are missed by the observer . we note that weather conditions and age or experience may lead to variations of the actual threshold for a given observer in time , but here we consider that the threshold is constant in time . this is also assumed in the @xmath0factor methodology . the threshold would be consistent with the @xmath0factor if the fraction of small ( @xmath6 ) groups on the solar disc was roughly constant and independent on the level of solar activity . however , as many studies imply ( ) , the fraction of small groups varies with solar activity : it is large around solar minima and decreases with the level of solar activity . accordingly , the use of the linear @xmath0factor method may lead to a distortion of the calibrated sunspot numbers ( ) . in this article we study the relation between sunspot group counts by a `` poor '' observer and those by the reference `` perfect '' observer , using the reference dataset described in section [ sec : data ] . in section [ sec : dist ] we study the distribution of sunspot group sizes and its dependence on the level of solar activity . its effect on observations by solar observers of different quality and their inter - calibrations are discussed in section [ sec : obs ] . we propose the use of a new nonlinear @xmath2factor to calibrate data from a `` poor '' observer to the reference conditions depending on the level of solar activity , in a more realistic manner than that offered by the traditionally used linear @xmath0factor . we base our analysis on the royal greenwich observatory ( rgo ) data series of sunspot groups with their areas . this series is referred to as the reference dataset throughout this article . although the rgo data series starts in 1874 , there are indications that its quality might be variable before 1900 ( ) or even before 1915 ( ) due to the `` learning '' curve , although other studies did not find this effect or attributed it only to the very early part of the rgo record before 1880 ( ) . to stay on the conservative safe - side , we consider here rgo data only for the period 19161976 when the data series is homogeneous in quality . we have checked that the result remains qualitatively the same if the period of 18741915 is included into the analysis . since the rgo series was terminated in 1976 , we also stop our reference dataset at that time , not extending it with data from the _ solar observing optical network _ ( soon ) because of a possible transition inhomogeneity ( ) . to make the results compatible with the direct observations , we used in our analysis the uncorrected ( for foreshortening ) whole area of sunspot groups , _ i.e. _ as it is seen from earth . we consider sunspot groups , not individual spots , since several closely located spots indistinguishable by the observer can be seen as one blurred spot even with a poor telescope and thus are more representative for the actual data . from the reference rgo data series we compiled files of daily numbers of sunspot groups with different observational acuity thresholds [ @xmath1 quantified as the group areas in msd , so that a group is counted ( observed ) if its uncorrected total area is not smaller that the threshold value in msd . the corresponding daily number of groups is denoted as @xmath7 where the subscript @xmath8 denotes the value of the threshold in msd . for example @xmath9 denotes the number of groups with area @xmath10 msd for each day . the number of groups without applying any threshold ( @xmath11 , _ i.e. _ the total number of groups in the reference dataset irrespectively of their size ) is called the reference series @xmath12 . for the analysis of data by rudolf wolf and alfred wolfer ( section [ sec : ww ] ) we used the daily number of sunspot groups as presented in the database of here we investigated how size of sunspot groups changes with solar activity . this is usually studied using the mean size of sunspot groups ( ) but this may be confusing because the size distribution of spots is highly asymmetric and the mean value is not a robust feature . figure [ fig : map]a depicts the cumulative distribution function ( cdf ) of sunspot - group sizes ( uncorrected total area in msd ) for the reference dataset ( section [ sec : data ] ) . cdf(@xmath3 ) is defined as the fraction of the sunspot groups with area not smaller than the given value of the area threshold [ @xmath1 . by definition cdf(0 ) is equal to unity ( each group has a non - zero size ) . the black curve shows the global cdf for all the sunspot groups ( about 119300 groups ) in the reference dataset . the blue dotted line represents the cdf for 920 groups ( 46 days ) for high activity days with 20 groups ( @xmath13 ) reported . the red dashed curve depicts the cdf for 2781 days with low activity ( only one group reported , @xmath14 ) . one can see that there is a significant fraction of large groups even for low - activity days : @xmath1510% of groups have area greater than 500 msd . the group - size distribution changes with the level of solar activity : while the cdf for low - activity days is lower than the global cdf , the distribution for high - activity days is significantly higher . for example , as one can see from figure [ fig : map]a , the relative contribution of large sunspot groups ( @xmath16 msd ) doubles for high - activity days ( @xmath13 ) with respect to low - activity days ( @xmath14 ) . this implies that the rise of activity is mostly due to the emergence of large sunspot groups , indicating that the sunspot - group size distribution changes with the level of solar activity . to generalize the study of the cdf dependence on the level of solar activity , we plotted in figure [ fig : map]b a contour plot of the cdf as a function of the activity level ( quantified in @xmath17 ) and the group size ( quantified in msd ) . all the cdf were normalized to that at the low - activity level ( @xmath14 , see red dashed line in figure [ fig : map]a ) so that cdf(@xmath14 ) is unity for all @xmath3 . one can see that the shape of cdf changes with the level of solar activity so that the fraction of large spots is growing , while the fraction of small spot decreases with activity . for example , the brown spot in the top - right corner implies that the relative fraction of groups with area @xmath18 msd is nearly doubled for high - activity days ( @xmath13 ) compared to low - activity days ( @xmath14 ) , as discussed above for figure [ fig : map]a . in the subsequent section we study how the fact that the size distribution of sunspot groups changes with the level of solar activity affects solar observers of different quality and their mutual inter - calibration . we assume ( similar to and ) that a solar observer is imperfect and has an observational acuity threshold [ @xmath1 for the ( uncorrected for foreshortening ) sunspot - group area so that he / she reports all the groups bigger than @xmath3 and miss all the groups smaller than @xmath3 . accordingly , we simulated a set of sunspot - group records produced by pseudo - observers synthesized from the reference dataset and characterized only by the acuity threshold [ @xmath1 . we define the `` correction factor '' @xmath19 as the ratio of the number of sunspot groups @xmath12 reported by the perfect observer ( @xmath11 ) to that @xmath20 by an imperfect observer with the finite acuity threshold [ @xmath8 ] ( @xmath22 ) , as a function of @xmath17 : @xmath23 figure [ fig : cf ] depicts ( @xmath19 - 1 ) as function of @xmath20 for several values of the threshold @xmath3 . one can see that the relative observational errors ( the fraction of missed sunspot groups to the `` true '' number of groups ) of a `` poor '' observer rapidly decrease with the level of solar activity . for example , while the observer with @xmath24 msd would count roughly @xmath25/@xmath26 less groups at very low activity @xmath27 , the fraction of missed small groups is only 20 - 25% for the high activity days @xmath28 . it is obvious that applying a constant correction factor ( as used in the @xmath0factor method ) is inappropriate , since this would distort the entire series and overcorrect the periods of high solar activity . here we introduce the @xmath2factor to correct sunspot - group counts by an `` imperfect '' observer to the reference observer . the concept of the @xmath2factor is similar to that of the @xmath0factor but depends on the level of solar activity quantified as @xmath20 . in figure [ fig : rgo50 ] we depict the relation between the reference and `` poor '' observers for the acuity threshold of @xmath29 msd . panel a shows the conversion matrix for the reference observer and the one with @xmath3 , constructed in the same way as by , for all days during the period 19161976 . the matrix represents the statistics of the reported @xmath30values for the two observers , normalized to unity in each column so that it represents the probability density function ( pdf ) of the number of groups reported by the reference observer @xmath12 for the days when the poor observer reported @xmath31 groups . one can see that the poor observer always counts less groups than the reference one ( all shaded areas lie above the diagonal ) , but the shape of the relation is not clear and could seemingly be approximated by a straight line . to verify our previous assertion , we show in figure [ fig : rgo50]b the pdf for the difference between the observers , _ i.e. _ @xmath32 as a function of @xmath31 . one can see that the relation is essentially nonlinear but bends to become flat at high activity . while the actual spread of the distribution ( grey shading ) is wide , this feature is clearly visible from the mean values ( orange dots on the plot ) of @xmath33 that form a smooth curve which tends to reach a saturation at high values of @xmath31 . this relation is very smooth and we approximate it with a simple euqation @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the mean value of @xmath12 at @xmath36 , @xmath37 is the asymptotic value ( shown as the horizontal dotted line in fig . [ fig : rgo50]b ) , and @xmath38 defines the exponential rate . we note that @xmath39 represents the mean number of sunspot groups reported by the reference observer for days when the `` poor '' observer reports no sunspot group . for this particular case , @xmath40 implying that on average the reference observer sees 0.64 sunspot groups on days when the `` poor '' observer with @xmath29 msd reports no groups because of their small size . since the value of @xmath39 is fixed for a given observer , equation ( [ eq : exp ] ) includes two free parameters @xmath38 and @xmath37 . we fitted this relation to the mean values of @xmath41 ( orange dots in fig . [ fig : rgo50]b ) using the @xmath42 method . the best - fit parameters for the dependence shown in fig . [ fig : rgo50]b are : @xmath43 , @xmath44 . the value of @xmath42 for 14 degrees of freedom ( dof ) is 15 , implying a good fit . the correction factor @xmath45 ( see equation [ eq : ca ] ) can be computed from the difference @xmath41 as @xmath46 as shown in fig . [ fig : rgo50]c . the proposed empirical relation ( blue curve ) describes the dependence of @xmath19 on @xmath20 quite well . we note that this curve was not fitted again to the data points but simply recalculated from that shown in panel b. the value of @xmath19 is not defined for @xmath36 . we have repeated the exercise described in section [ sec : imp ] , _ i.e. _ fitting equation [ eq : exp ] to the difference @xmath41 , for different values of the observational acuity threshold [ @xmath1 from 10 to 200 msd . this range corresponds to actual observers with proper telescopes ( ) . generally , an observer with the visual acuity threshold exceeding 100 msd would be considered as one with very poor quality . some examples of the fits are shown in figure [ fig : fits ] for several values of @xmath3 . although the fits were actually done for the @xmath47 distributions ( similar to that shown in fig . [ fig : rgo50]b ) , we show here the @xmath2factors . we see that the equation fits the data almost perfectly when the statistic is good but the errors bars of the data points increase for higher values of @xmath20 because of a poorer statistic . . the fit is always good in the entire range of the @xmath3 values analyzed here , and the values of @xmath42 are typically around 1 _ per _ dof with a variability between 0.5 and 1.5 _ per _ dof , indicating a good agreement . it is interesting to note that the best - fit curves tend to slightly overestimate the @xmath2factor for the highest activity periods ( see figure [ fig : fits ] ) . this implies that an `` imperfect '' observer appears not as bad as it should be according to its acuity limitation . however , this tendency is not statistically significant , and we do not consider it in this study . since we use the method of minimizing @xmath42 to fit the curve , the contribution of these points is small . the dependence of the parameters of the empirical relation on the value of @xmath3 is shown in figure [ fig : par ] . one can see a smooth growth of the parameters with increasing acuity threshold . the parameter @xmath39 raises from its obvious zero value to nearly 1.5 . the parameter @xmath37 grows from its obvious zero value to about eight and tends to saturate there . the parameter @xmath38 varies between 0.15 and 0.27 . the empirical relation studied here ( equations [ eq : exp][eq : cc ] ) implies that the fraction of small sunspot groups is not constant as a function of solar activity level , but declines exponentially with the activity as is apparent from figure [ fig : fits ] . over the solar cycle , the number of sunspot groups increases mostly because of large groups , while the amount of small groups remains nearly constant in accordance with the analysis presented in section [ sec : dist ] . here we study the relation between the sunspot - group numbers reported by two classical sunspot observers of the second half of the 19th century : rudolf wolf and alfred wolfer , both from zrich observatory . they were primary observers for the wolf ( and its successor the international ) sunspot number series and thus defined the values of the sunspot numbers the late 19th and earlier 20th centuries . a scaling @xmath0 factor of 1.66 is traditionally applied to the sunspot ( group ) number by wolf to match it with wolfer in quality , as initially proposed by wolfer himself . this factor was used continuously ( ) in the daisy - chain procedure to calibrate the sunspot number series ever since . thus , it is important to verify the inter - calibration of the two observers . we use all the days ( 4385 in total ) when we have observations from both observers for the period 18761893 . this analysis is close to that of but is focused on the use of the proposed parameterization ( equation ( [ eq : exp ] ) ) . figure [ fig : ww]a shows a conversion matrix , constructed in the same way as that in figure [ fig : rgo50 ] but for the wolfer _ vs. _ wolf data , so that wolfer is now the reference observer and wolf is a `` poor '' one . one can see that wolfer was indeed a better observer than wolf since he reported more groups than wolf did , for the same days . this is shown by as the grey area in figure [ fig : ww]a that lies systematically above the diagonal ( red dotted line ) . on the other hand , the blue dashed line ( the @xmath0factor of 1.66 ) lies systematically above the grey area for @xmath48 . figure [ fig : ww]b depicts the difference @xmath49 as function of @xmath50 , similar to figure [ fig : rgo50]3 . one can see that the relation between the number of groups reported by the two observers is not linear , but again has the same shape of an asymptotic approach to the constant difference . the value of @xmath39 was found to be @xmath51 , implying that wolfer on average reported 0.4 sunspot groups for days when wolf reported none , due to the difference in the instrumentation and eyesight . mean values of the distribution ( orange balls in the figure ) can be fitted well by equation ( [ eq : exp ] ) with @xmath52 . the linear relation ( @xmath0factor of 1.66 , the blue dashed line ) does not describe the relation in a reasonable way as it systematically overestimates the corrected wolf s records for days with mid- and high - activity ( @xmath48 ) . figure [ fig : ww]c shows the correction factor ( @xmath53 ) as a function of @xmath50 . it is obviously nonlinear : while wolf underestimated ( comparing to wolfer ) the number of groups by a factor of two during the low activity periods ( one sunspot group _ per _ day ) , his under - count of groups was only 20% for the days with a number of groups exceeding eight . accordingly , the assumption of the constancy of the correction @xmath0factor at the level of 1.66 ( the blue dashed line ) is invalid in this case . a principle assumption behind the @xmath0factor methodology ( see section [ sec : intro ] ) is that the relation between the number of sunspots ( groups ) reported by different observers is linear . however , as shown here for the example of two famous observers , the relation between the number of sunspot groups reported by them is essentially nonlinear and , when applying the constant @xmath0factor , leads to underestimate of the number of groups during low activity but overestimate is during high activity periods . this is illustrated in figure [ fig : aug93 ] , where daily group numbers are shown for august 1893 ( a month with high activity ) by both observers : the original group counts by wolfer , the counts by wolf corrected using the constant @xmath0factor of 1.66 , and the counts by wolf corrected using equation ( [ eq : exp ] ) . we see that for the period from 6th to 26th of august , when the temporal profiles of the number of groups by wolf and wolfer were close to each other , indicating that they reported the same sunspot activity evolution , the correction based on the @xmath0factor yields a good agreement for the days with moderate activity ( @xmath54 ) but systematically overestimates counts by 34 groups ( 4060% ) for the days with high activity ( @xmath55 ) . on the other hand , the nonlinear method proposed here reproduces the level for the entire period correctly . we have studied the distribution of sunspot group size or area and its dependence on the level of solar activity . we show that the size distribution of sunspot groups can not be assumed constant but varies significantly with solar activity . the fraction of small groups , which can be potentially missed by an `` imperfect '' solar observer , is found to be not constant but decreasing with the level of solar activity . an empirical relation ( equation ( [ eq : exp ] ) ) is proposed which describes the amount of small groups as a function of the solar activity level . it is shown that the number of small groups asymptotically approaches a saturation level so that high solar activity is largely defined by big groups . we have studied the effect of the changing sunspot group area on the ability of realistic observers to see and report the daily number of sunspot groups . it is shown that the relation between the numbers of sunspot groups as seen by different observers with different observational acuity thresholds ( defined by the quality of their instrumentation and eye sights ) is strongly non - linear and can not be approximated by a linear scaling , in contrast to how it was traditionally done earlier . we propose to use the observational acuity threshold @xmath3 to quantify the quality of each observer , instead of the relative @xmath0factor used earlier . the value of @xmath3 means that all sunspot groups bigger than @xmath3 would be reported while all the groups smaller than @xmath3 missed by the observer . we have introduced the non - linear @xmath2factor , based on the observer s acuity threshold @xmath3 , which can be used to correct each observer to the reference conditions . the method has been applied to a pair of principal solar observers of the 19th century , rudolf wolf and alfred wolfer of zrich . we have shown that the earlier used linear method to correct wolf data to the conditions of wolfer , using the constant @xmath0factor of 1.66 , tends to overestimate of solar activity around solar maxima . this result presents a new tool to recalibrate different solar observers to the reference conditions . a full recalibration based on the new method will be a subject of a forthcoming work . igu and gak acknowledge support by the academy of finland to the resolve center of excellence ( project n@xmath56 . t.c . acknowledges the postgraduate fellowship of the international max planck research school on physical processes in the solar system and beyond . the authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest . 25 # 1isbn # 1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1_#1_#1*#1*#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#2#1#1#1#1#1_#1_#1#1#1*#1*#1#1#1_#1_#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1 # 1http://dx.doi.org/#1 [ ] # 1http://arxiv.org / abs/#1 [ ] # 1http://adsabs.harvard.edu / abs/#1[]#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1#1

the distribution of the sunspot group size ( area ) and its dependence on the level of solar activity is studied . it is shown that the fraction of small groups is not constant but decreases with the level of solar activity so that high solar activity is largely defined by big groups . we study the possible influence of solar activity on the ability of a realistic observer to see and report the daily number of sunspot groups . it is shown that the relation between the number of sunspot groups as seen by different observers with different observational acuity thresholds is strongly non - linear and can not be approximated by the traditionally used linear scaling ( @xmath0factors ) . the observational acuity threshold [ @xmath1 is considered to quantify the quality of each observer , instead of the traditional relative @xmath0factor . a nonlinear @xmath2factor based on @xmath3 is proposed , which can be used to correct each observer to the reference conditions . the method is tested on a pair of principal solar observers , wolf and wolfer , and it is shown that the traditional linear correction , with the constant @xmath0factor of 1.66 to scale wolf to wolfer , leads to an overestimate of solar activity around solar maxima .

1106.4526

the identification of high proper motion stars is an important tool to identify neighboring stars . the lhs catalog @xcite listed over four thousand stars with proper motions near or above half an arcsecond per year but only 73 stars with motions above two arcseconds per year . digitized photographic sky surveys and the more recent digital optical and near - infrared sky surveys have allowed many new proper motion stars to be identified . currently , the simbad database lists some 108 stars ( including white dwarfs and brown dwarfs ) with motions above two arcseconds per year . nevertheless , high proper motion stars remain to be identified . at low galactic latitudes , crowding makes it difficult to correctly pair stars , even though important progress has been made to bring the completeness in the galactic plane to at least 90% @xcite and perhaps as high as 99% @xcite . @xcite also estimate that incompleteness sets in at @xmath0 for low galactic latitudes ( @xmath1 ) but @xmath2 at high latitudes , and remark that independent surveys are needed to fully assess completeness of their catalog . unfortunately , the vast number of reddened background stars makes it difficult to identify cool , nearby objects by photometry alone . a second potential source of incompleteness is that for very large motions , the stars may move so far that automated pairing programs fail . the relatively recent discovery of such objects as a white dwarf moving at 2.55 `` /yr @xcite and an m6.5 dwarf moving at 5.05 ' ' /yr @xcite , both detectable on the photographic plate surveys , are illustrative . third , cooler objects , particularly brown dwarfs , are too faint for photographic plates , though these can often be selected by infrared colors alone . these problems can be addressed with a new infrared sky survey . the wide - field infrared survey explorer ( wise ) has surveyed the entire sky in four mid - infrared filters @xcite , allowing a comparison with the near - infrared two micron all - survey ( 2mass ) @xcite , even in the galactic plane . the wise explanatory supplement demonstrates that the matching of the two surveys is good to 0.2 `` for high signal - to - noise stars , and that 99.9% of wise stars match 2mass sources to within 3 arcseconds . the time baseline is approximately a decade , so objects with @xmath3 ' ' /yr are expected to move out of the matching window . the high reliability and completeness of wise and 2mass allow us to search for previously unidentified proper motion stars . in this _ , we report on two particularly important sources . our strategy is based on the fact that nearby hydrogen - burning stars should appear as relatively bright , high signal - to - noise sources in both wise and 2mass . we initially obtained a list of possible proper motion stars by querying the wise preliminary source catalog for stars with @xmath4 that lacked 2mass pairings within three arcseconds . we then matched this list with the @xcite catalog of stars with motions greater than 0.15 arcseconds per year . we found that nearly all lspm stars had @xmath5 and @xmath6 ( with the exception of a few very bright stars affected by saturation ) , and so we applied these color cuts to the sample . this selection for initial analysis , it should be noted , is intended to select main sequence stars and will likely exclude white dwarfs and brown dwarfs . we furthermore excluded known stars by requiring no simbad sources within 12 arcseconds and no matches to the ppmxl catalog @xcite . this left only 118 sources , each of which were examined in the digitized sky survey , 2mass and wise images . because we had made no additional cuts based on wise source quality , this list included many bright star artifacts , as expected in the preliminary processing . however , we also found we recovered a number of known proper motion stars , such as the 5 " /yr star so 025300.5 + 165258 @xcite [ wisep j025303.27 + 165214.2 ] which move quickly enough that they were not excluded by the simbad query , as well as previously unknown stars . we extended this analysis to @xmath7 without difficulty . for yet lower galactic latitudes , @xmath8 , we found we could exclude most of the bright star artifacts , and none of the proper motion stars , by requiring that the source not be extended ( @xmath9 ) in wise . we also had to drop the w3 color cuts , because the 12 micron data do not reach as deep in regions of high background . no matches at the lowest latitude to ppmxl were attempted given its potential unreliability in crowded fields . the resulting 492 sources were also examined by eye , and 229 appear to be genuine proper motion objects . the main sources of false matches in the plane were apparently real but non - moving sources whose 2mass detections were masked or flagged due to nearby bright stars in the crowded fields . as expected , most of the genuine high proper motion stars were listed by @xcite or more recent publications @xcite . complete details and a full list of detected stars will be presented in a future publication , where we will assess completeness and reliability . only one previously unknown source with motion above two arcseconds per year was detected in the 58% of the sky in the preliminary release that is , we are able identify pairings for all other bright wise stars , as we define them above . wisep j191239.91 - 361516.4 is at @xmath10 and lies in a moderately crowded field . we also discuss a second source , wisep j190648.47 + 401106.8 , with a proper motion of 0.48 " /yr at @xmath11 . further analysis of the other proper motion stars detected and the effect of relaxing the color constraint is ongoing and will be reported in a later paper . we identify wisep j191239.91 - 361516.4 with 2mass j19123922 - 3614555 , denis 191239.2 - 361455 , and usno - b 0537 - 0751534 . a finder chart is shown in figure [ fig0 ] . the wise and 2mass photometry and astrometry are listed in table 1 , and in addition , @xmath12 from denis @xcite and @xmath13 from usno - b @xcite . the wise observations are from 1 april 2010 to 7 april 2010 and the 2mass observations are from 25 june 1999 . since the wise positions are tied directly to the 2mass positions , we can compute the proper motion of 2.09 `` /yr directly . the reported wise-2mass positional uncertainties of 0.2 '' lead to an uncertainty of the proper motions of 0.02 `` /yr . ( we can also directly compare wise-2mass proper motions to those reported in the lspm catalog , and we find that the standard deviation of the differences is 0.013 ' ' /yr in each coordinate , which can be attributed primarily to the wise-2mass uncertainties . ) the photometry is consistent with a mid - m ( @xmath14 m4 ) dwarf . the photometry and a 3200k model atmosphere @xcite are plotted in figure [ fig1 ] . comparing to the parallax sample of @xcite , we expect @xmath15 for @xmath16 for a disk main sequence dwarf . this suggests a distance of 13 parsecs and @xmath17 km / s , but if the star is metal - poor , it would be closer with a lower velocity , and a distance within 10 parsecs is possible . ( if an equal - luminosity binary , it may be more distant . ) a trigonometric parallax is needed . according to simbad , it is the 103rd fastest proper motion star known . we identify wisep j190648.47 + 401106.8 ( hereafter w1906 + 40 ) with 2mass j19064801 + 4011089 and sdss j190648.29 + 401107.6 @xcite . the ten photometric observations are shown in figure [ fig1 ] , with @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 . the wise observations are from 16 april 2010 to 22 april 2010 and the 2mass observations are from 23 may 1998 . a finder chart is shown in figure [ fig3 ] . both @xmath22 and @xmath23 are consistent with a late - m or an early - l type @xcite . a low - resolution irtf spex @xcite spectrum was obtained on 19 april 2011 and processed using spextool @xcite . it is shown in figure [ fig2 ] . we classify w1906 + 40 as spectral type l1 . the source may be a hydrogen - burning star or a brown dwarf . according to the relations of @xcite , the distance is @xmath24 parsecs and the tangential velocity is @xmath25 km / s , but again , a trigonometric parallax is needed . the most compelling property of this nearby l dwarf is that it lies in the kepler mission field @xcite , as kepler i d 4996077 , making it the coolest dwarf known in the field . it was not on the kepler observing list , but examination of the kepler full field images ( ffi ) shows that w1906 + 40 is detected . ddt monitoring with kepler will provide a unique time series for an ultracool dwarf , which are known to have large flares with a duty cycle of @xmath26% @xcite . we have identified two nearby proper motion stars at low galactic latitudes , demonstrating the value of an infrared proper motion survey based on the wise and 2mass catalogs . @xcite note that an important wise mission objective is to identify unknown , nearby low - luminosity brown dwarfs . proper motion selection using wise promises to also contribute to the solar neighborhood _ stellar _ census over the entire sky , including the galactic plane . the objects detected here are consistent with the evidence @xcite that the vast majority of high proper motion hydrogen - burning stars have been detected . @xcite , however , estimates that a third of nuclear - burning stars within 33 parsecs remain unidentified but have motions below 0.15 " /yr . wise and 2mass photometry and astrometry appear to be accurate enough to allow many of these to be identified , even at low galactic latitudes , although optical follow - up will be required . this publication makes use of data products from the wide - field infrared survey explorer , which is a joint project of the university of california , los angeles , and the jet propulsion laboratory / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration . this publication makes use of data products from the two micron all sky survey , which is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and the infrared processing and analysis center / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration and the national science foundation . this research has made use of the nasa/ ipac infrared science archive , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with nasa . this research has made use of the vizier catalogue access tool , cds , strasbourg , france . this research has made use of the simbad database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france . the digitized sky surveys were produced at the space telescope science institute under u.s . government grant nag w-2166 . the images of these surveys are based on photographic data obtained using the oschin schmidt telescope on palomar mountain and the uk schmidt telescope . the plates were processed into the present compressed digital form with the permission of these institutions . the uk schmidt telescope was operated by the royal observatory edinburgh , with funding from the uk science and engineering research council ( later the uk particle physics and astronomy research council ) , until 1988 june , and thereafter by the anglo - australian observatory . the blue plates of the southern sky atlas and its equatorial extension ( together known as the serc - j ) , as well as the equatorial red ( er ) , and the second epoch [ red ] survey ( ses ) were all taken with the uk schmidt . lrlrrrrrrrr [email protected] & 0.78 & -1.94 & 9.52 & 9.01 & 8.77 & 8.55 & 8.35 & 8.20 & 8.17 + j190648.47 + 401106.8 & 0.44 & -0.18 & 13.08 & 12.26 & 11.77 & 11.45 & 11.22 & 10.77 & @xmath28 +

we report two nearby high proper motion dwarfs of special interest identified using the preliminary data release of the wide - field infrared survey explorer ( wise ) and the two micron all - sky survey ( 2mass ) . wisep j191239.91 - 361516.4 has a motion of 2.1 arcseconds per year . photometry identifies it as a mid - m dwarf . wisep j190648.47 + 401106.8 is a spectroscopically confirmed l1 dwarf in the _ kepler mission _ field with a motion of 0.48 arcseconds per year . the estimated distance is 17 parsecs . both lie at relatively low galactic latitudes and demonstrate the possibility of discovering proper motion stars independently of the historic photographic sky surveys .

0906.3618

modelling of the nucleosynthesis of the heavy elements ( e.g. in the astrophysical r- and p - processes ) requires knowledge of the rates of thousands of reactions . in lack of experimental data , the reaction rates are usually obtained from statistical model calculations . statistical models utilize different input parameters which strongly influence the calculated cross sections and hence the reaction rates . besides the astrophysical conditions , inaccurate nuclear input parameters used in the reaction rate calculations can be responsible for the fact that the nucleosynthesis models are not able to reproduce well the heavy element abundances observed in nature @xcite . therefore , the measurement of the relevant reaction cross sections is of high importance to check the results of statistical model calculations and to help choose the best input parameters . it has been found that the results of statistical model calculations strongly deviate from the measured cross section values in the case of reactions involving alpha particles . the reason of this discrepancy is that the calculated cross sections show a strong dependence on the alpha - nucleus optical potential and this potential is ambiguous at the astrophysically relevant low energies ( see e.g. @xcite ) . therefore , the need for experimental cross sections is more pronounced in the case of alpha - induced reactions . realizing this need , the cross sections of the @xmath0eu(@xmath5)@xmath6 tb and @xmath0eu(@xmath1,n)@xmath2 tb reactions have been measured at astrophysically relevant energies using the activation technique . in this method , the cross section is deduced from the off - line measurement of the reaction products , @xmath6 tb and @xmath2 tb . the half - life of the reaction products enter into the calculation of the cross section , and thus the uncertainty of the half - life values directly contributes to the uncertainty of the obtained cross sections . @xmath6 tb does not have any long lived isomer and the half - life of its ground state is relatively well known : [email protected] @xcite . the situation for @xmath2 tb is , however , more complicated @xcite . its ground state decays by @xmath7 emission and electron capture to @xmath2gd with a half - life of t@[email protected] . @xmath2 tb is has two long - lived isomeric states with unknown excitation energies but well established level ordering . the m1 isomer decays both by internal transition to the ground state and by @xmath7 and electron capture to @xmath2gd with a half - life of t@[email protected] . the m2 isomer decays almost exclusively by @xmath7 and electron capture to @xmath2gd ; there is only a weak internal transition to the m1 state . one can note that the half - life of the m1 isomer has an unusually large uncertainty of more than 4% . this is because ambiguous data can be found in the literature . the measurements can be grouped into two categories . in the first group three half - life values of about 10h can be found by vylov et al . ( [email protected] @xcite ) , by berkes et al . ( [email protected] @xcite ) and by nedovesov et al . ( [email protected] @xcite ) . in the second group , two less precise and lower half - life values can be found by lau and hogan ( [email protected] @xcite ) and sousa et al . ( [email protected] @xcite ) . in the compilation @xcite , a recommended value of [email protected] is given with a remark : _ an unweighted average was chosen because the two more precise values are also the highest and may include an unaccounted for contribution from the 22.7 h isomer . _ if one accepts that some of the available half - life measurements involve a hidden systematic error , the half - life of the m1 isomer can have an uncertainty of up to 10% . since the preliminary analysis of the @xmath0eu(@xmath1,n)@xmath2 tb cross section measurement shows that the m1 isomer is by far the most strongly populated state in @xmath2 tb , the uncertainty of the m1 isomer half - life substantially influences the obtained cross section of the @xmath0eu(@xmath1,n)@xmath2 tb reaction . therefore , a high precision experiment has been carried out aiming at the determination of the m1 isomer half - life . in section [ sec : experimental ] the details of the experiment are presented . section [ sec : analysis ] shows the data analysis and the results are presented in section [ sec : results ] . @xmath2 tb sources have been produced by the @xmath0eu(@xmath1,n)@xmath2 tb reaction . the targets have been prepared by evaporating eu@xmath10o@xmath11 enriched to 99.2% in @xmath0eu onto thin al foils . the use of enriched @xmath0eu target was necessary because the ( @xmath1,n ) reaction on the heavier eu isotope leads to @xmath12 tb ( t@[email protected] ) and the decay of this isotope is followed by a strong @xmath13-radiation with similar energy to the one from @xmath2 tb used in the analysis ( see sec . [ sec : gammacounting ] ) . a thin ( @xmath14 10@xmath15g/@xmath16 ) al protective layer has been evaporated onto each target in order to prevent the produced @xmath2 tb nuclei from diffusing out of the source during the half - life measurement . .[tab : sources ] details of the source preparation [ cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ] a number of possible systematic uncertainties may influence the obtained half - life results . first of all , any change of the detection efficiency in the course of the measurement leads to the alteration of the measured half - life . such a change can be caused either by geometrical effect ( e.g. changes in the source detector distance ) or instabilities of the intrinsic efficiency of the detector . this possibility can be tested by comparing the results of several measurements . as can be seen in table [ tab : results ] the results of the five measurements are in perfect agreement , the standard deviation of the points is as low as 0.1% . however , to give a conservative estimation , the difference between the highest and the lowest value , 0.24% , has been adopted for the detection efficiency systematic uncertainty . the reliable dead - time determination of the data acquisition system is also of high importance . the five sources have been measured under different conditions regarding the initial dead - time of the system and gave consistent results . nevertheless , the dead - time provided by the multichannel analyzer has been tested using a pulse generator . the signals from the pulse generator have been fed into the counting system using the test input of the detector preamplifier . the observed number of pulser signals in the spectrum has been compared with the sent signals ( measured by a counter ) and from the ratio the dead - time could be calculated . it was found that the dead - time provided by the acquisition system was precise within about 0.3% in the dead - time range encountered in the present experiment . this 0.3% uncertainty translates into less than 0.1% uncertainty of the half - life value , therefore 0.1% has been adopted for the dead - time determination systematic uncertainty . the effect of detection efficiency changes and dead - time determination can also be studied using a reference source with precisely known half - life . the half - life of the reference source should preferably be close to that of the investigated isotope . the backing of the eu targets contained some copper impurity . during @xmath1-bombardment the @xmath17cu(@xmath1,n ) reaction takes place with high cross section producing @xmath18ga . the half - life of this isotope is [email protected] @xcite , similar to that of @xmath2tb@xmath19 . the decay of this isotope could well be seen in all but one samples . the half - life of @xmath18ga was determined by measuring the 1039kev @xmath13-radiation following its decay . the obtained results are also listed in table [ tab : results ] . the values obtained on the different sources are again in good agreement , and their weighted average is in agreement with the literature value . this independently supports the findings about the efficiency and dead - time related systematic uncertainties . in the case of @xmath2 tb a very important source of uncertainty in the m1 isomer half life is the possible contribution of the m2 isomer and the ground state leading to decays through the 540kev transition . the m2 isomer is known to decay by isomeric transition to the m1 state providing a continuos feeding of that state . the m2 decay branching ratio to the m1 state is , however , only 1.8%@xmath40.6% @xcite . on the other hand , the m2 isomer is only very weakly populated by the @xmath0eu(@xmath1,n)@xmath2 tb reaction . gavriljuk et al . @xcite found that the cross section ratio to the m2 and m1 states is @[email protected] at 15.6mev @xmath1-energy . we have also calculated this ratio by measuring and comparing the characteristic @xmath13-radiations for the two isomers . we found @xmath20 values in the range between 1.2% and 2.7% for the measured 5 different @xmath1-energies . the combination of the low cross section ratio and the low isomeric transition decay ratio results in a maximum of 0.08% feeding of the m1 state by the m2 decay ( here a conservative upper limit of two sigma deviation from the isomeric transition literature value was taken ) . this feeding influences the determined m1 half - life by at most 0.1% and therefore this value is taken as the systematic uncertainty from the m2 feeding . our half - life determination was based on the assumption that the 540.2kev @xmath13-radiation comes exclusively from the m1 decay , as measured by e.g. sousa et al . @xcite . a small contribution of the ground state decay to this @xmath13-line can , however , not be excluded . this is especially important because our analysis shows that the ground state is strongly populated not only by the decay of the m1 state but also directly by the ( @xmath1,n ) reaction ( typically @[email protected] ) . to test this possibility , a chi square analysis has been performed . a hypothetical ground state decay contribution to the 540.2kev @xmath13-line has been assumed and the goodness - of - fit was checked by the reduced chi square value as a function of the ground state decay contribution . the results of this test can be seen in fig . [ fig : chisquare ] . the minimum of the chi square curve is at zero ground state contribution to the 540.2kev @xmath13-line . this confirms the result of @xcite that this line can be associated solely with the m1 isomer . at the point where the reduced chi square increases by one , the obtained half life changes by 0.27% . this value is taken for the systematic uncertainty from ground state decay contribution . the adopted value for the half - life of the @xmath2tb@xmath19 isomer and its statistical uncertainty is calculated as the weighted average of the five measured samples . this gives [email protected] . the total uncertainty is the quadratic sum of the statistical uncertainty and the following partial systematic uncertainties : detection efficiency ( 0.24% ) , dead - time determination ( 0.1% ) , m2 isomer feeding ( 0.1% ) and ground state decay contribution ( 0.27% ) . the final result is t@[email protected] with a total uncertainty of 0.4% . the half - life value obtained in the present work is significantly higher than the recommended value in the literature ( [email protected] @xcite ) and its uncertainty is one order of magnitude lower . it should be pointed out that our value is in agreement with the results of @xcite , @xcite and @xcite , in marginal agreement with @xcite but in serious disagreement with @xcite . since our value is more precise than any of the previous results and it is in agreement with the available most precise values , the result of our measurement is recommended as the adopted value and the quandary of the compilation cited in sec . [ sec : introduction ] seems to be solved . with the high precision half - life of @xmath2tb@xmath19 determined in the present work , a systematic uncertainty in the @xmath0eu(@xmath1,n)@xmath2 tb cross section measurement is significantly reduced . this work was supported by erc grant 203175 , gvop-3.2.1.-2004 - 04 - 0402/3.0 . and otka ( k68801 , t49245 ) . gy . . is a bolyai fellow . g. r. is supported by the visegrd fund . w. rapp , j. grres , m. wiescher , h. schatz , f. kppeler , astrophy . j. 653 ( 2006 ) 474 . t. rauscher , phys . c 73 ( 2006 ) 015804 . gyrky et al . , phys . c 74 ( 2006 ) 025805 . reich , nuclear data sheets 104 ( 2005 ) 1 . reich , r.g . helmer , nuclear data sheets 85 ( 1998 ) 171 . t. vylov et al . , izv . nauk sssr , ser.fiz . , 36 ( 1972 ) 718 . i. berkes , r brenier , g. marest , j. phys . g , 9 ( 1983 ) 213 . nedovesov , y.v . kholnov , g.e . shukin , proc . spectrosc . struct . at . nuclei , baku , ( 1976 ) 109 . lau , j.j . hogan , phys . c 8 ( 1973 ) 715 . sousa , l.l . riedinger , e.g. funk , j.w . mihelich , nucl . phys . a 238 ( 1975 ) 365 . leo , techniques for nuclear and particle physics experiments , springer - verlag 1992 m.r . bhat , nuclear data sheets 83 ( 1998 ) 789 . gavriljuk , v.a . zheltonozhskij , v.b . kharlanov , 40th conf . spectroscopy nucl . struct . , leningrad ( 1990 ) 347 .

the precise knowledge of the half - life of the reaction product is of crucial importance for a nuclear reaction cross section measurement carried out with the activation technique . the cross section of the @xmath0eu(@xmath1,n)@xmath2 tb reaction has been measured recently using the activation method , however , the half - life of the 10 h isomer in @xmath2 tb has a relatively high uncertainty and ambiguous values can be found in the literature . therefore , the precise half - life of the isomeric state has been measured and found to be t@[email protected] . with careful analysis of the systematic errors , the uncertainty of this half - life value has been significantly reduced . @xmath2 tb isomeric state , measured half - life , gamma - spectroscopy 23.35.+g , 23.40.-s , 25.55.-e , 27.70.+q

1509.03955

the parameter estimation is one of most important ingredients in various fields of both the classical and quantum worlds metrology06prl , metrology11np . the task of quantum estimation is not only to determine the value of unknown parameters but also to give the precision of the value . it is a vital issue on how to improve the estimation precision which is closely related to the quantum cramr - rao inequality and quantum fisher information ( qfi ) fisher , jiliangxuejiuchan , jiliangxuejiuchan2,wangxiaoguangzongshu , xiaomin , xiangguoyong , kexue , pra2012 that determines the bound of the parameter s sensitivity theoretically by @xcite @xmath0where @xmath1 means the time of experiments , and @xmath2 is the qfi with the symmetric logarithmic derivative @xmath3 defined by @xmath4 . ( [ crbound ] ) implies that the larger qfi means higher sensitivity of the parameter estimation . the pioneer work on the quantum parameter estimation were proposed by caves @xcite who showed that the precision of phase estimation can beat the shot - noise limit ( standard quantum limit ) . later , lots of jobs with the similar aims are proposed , such as based on maximally correlated states winelind , n00n states @xcite , squeezed states @xcite , or generalized phase - matching condition @xcite , and so on . in practical scenarios , it is inevitable for a quantum system to interact with environments , the precision of quantum estimation will be influenced by different extents @xcite . in recent years , enormous effects have been devoted to how to improve the precision of parameter estimation in the case of open systems . for example , the precision spectroscopy using entangled state in the presence of markovian dephasing @xcite and non - markovian noise @xcite are investigated ; the qfi under decoherence channels @xcite or in a quantum - critical environment @xcite are analyzed ; the qfi measured experimentally with photons and atoms are reported @xcite ; it is also reported that the qfi subject to non - markovian thermal environment @xcite could show revival and retardation loss ; the parameter - estimation precision in noisy systems could be enhanced by dynamical decoupling pulses tigao - wangxiaoguang , redesigned ramsey - pulse sequence @xcite or error correction @xcite are also shown ; noisy metrology beyond the standard quantum limits is possible when the noise is concentrated along some spatial direction @xcite . however , if the environment we considered is a squeezed reservoir , how the qfi is influenced by the reservoir s parameters ? the squeezed reservoir has been widely studied in quantum information processing . for example , the squeezed light ( reservoir ) @xcite or finite - bandwidth squeezing @xcite for inhibition of the atomic phase decays and its application in microscopic fabry - prot cavity @xcite . in addition , some other considerations of the squeezing reservoir were also discussed , such as the quantum entanglement dynamics @xcite , heat engine recycle @xcite , geometric phase observable @xcite , etc . the physical realization of the squeezed reservoir has also been proposed both in theory and in experiment based on various techniques such as the four - wave mixing @xcite , the parametric down conversion wulingan , the suitable feedback of the output signal corresponding to a quantum nondemolition measurement of an observable @xcite , control the parameter of the driven laser @xcite , quantum conversion of squeezed vacuum states @xcite or energy - level modulation @xcite , the atomic systems in cavity qed @xcite or dissipative optomechanics system @xcite and so on . the reduction of the radiative decay of the atomic coherence in squeezed vacuum has been realized in the superconducting circuit and microwave - frequency cavity system @xcite . in this paper , we will investigate the effects of reservoir squeezing on the qfi based on the non - perturbation processing @xcite . we consider a phase estimation scheme which a two - level system with an imposed unknown phase interacts with a squeezed reservoir before the final optimal measurements . to find the influences induced by the reservoir , we derive the non - perturbative master equation by the path integral method lujingjifen . in terms of the master equation , we obtain the exact analytic expression of qfi which is related to the precision of parameter estimation . it can be found that the qfi depends on the estimated parameter and the decay of qfi can be reduced by the squeezed reservoir compared with thermal ( vacuum ) reservoir . in particular , if the appropriate squeezing phase matching condition is satisfied , the decay of qfi can be prevented prominently by the reservoir squeezing . this paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ sec2 ] , the parameter estimation scheme is introduced and the non - perturbation master equation is obtained . in sec . [ sec3 ] , the exact analytic expression of qfi for the estimated parameter is obtained and the effects of reservoir squeezing on the qfi are investigated . the conclusion are given in the end . the setup of the parameter estimation is sketched in fig . [ scheme ] . the input state is a two - level superposed state @xmath5 . after the phase gate ( @xmath6 ) is operated on the input state @xmath7 , the output state is given by @xmath8let the system ( @xmath9 ) interacts with a squeezed reservoir , the quantum fisher information ( qfi ) of the final state can be obtained via optimal measurement . the inverse of square root of the qfi is related to the precision of parameter estimation according to eq . ( [ crbound ] ) regardless of the experiment times @xmath10 . the initial state of the squeezed reservoir coupled to the system is given by @xmath11 where the squeezed operator @xmath12 and the thermal state @xmath13 are given by @xmath14here @xmath15 is the squeezed parameter , @xmath16 is the reference phase of squeezed field and the parameter @xmath17 with @xmath18 and @xmath19 denoting the boltzsman constant and temperature , respectively . noting that the thermal state @xmath13 will become the vacuum state @xmath20 if the temperature @xmath21 , whilst the environment will become the squeezed vacuum reservoir @xmath22 @xcite . the total hamiltonian of the system and reservoir reads @xmath23with @xmath24where @xmath25 denotes the transition frequency of the two - level system , @xmath26 is the raising / lowering operators of the system , @xmath27 is the creation ( annihilation ) operators of the squeezed reservoir and @xmath28 is the strength of coupling between the system and environment . in order to get the master equation for the reduced system , we would like to employ the non - perturbative master equation which can be given , in the schrdinger picture , by path integral method @xcite as @xmath29where @xmath30 denotes the reduced density matrix of the system , @xmath31 denotes the partial trace of squeezed reservoir and @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 are the super operators defined by@xmath35 , \\ { l_{0}}\rho & = & [ { h_{s}}+{h_{bath}},\rho ] , \\ { l_{int}}\rho & = & [ { h_{int}},\rho ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] assuming the initial state of system plus reservoir is product state @xmath36 , through tedious but straightforward derivation , the non - perturbative master equation in the interaction picture can be given by @xmath37where the coefficients @xmath38 and @xmath39 are represented by @xmath40with @xmath41 denoting average photon number . in this paper , the structure of squeezed reservoir is supposed as the lorentz form @xmath42where @xmath43 is the spectral width of the reservoir and connects with the reservoir correlation time as @xmath44 , @xmath45 is the decay of the system and determines the relaxation time scale as @xmath46 . performing the continuum limit of the bath mode , the time correlation function can be expressed as @xcite @xmath47 and the coefficient @xmath48 in the master equation ( [ eq - master ] ) is @xmath49 one can prove that the non - perturbative master equation ( [ lujingjinfen ] ) coincides with the second - order time - convolutionless ( tcl ) master equation for the two - level system interacting with a thermal reservoir breuer , lujingjifen . because no markovian approximation is used , it will lead to non - markovian dynamics for a qubits coupling to a ( squeezed ) thermal reservoir intuitively . however , just like the second - order tcl master equation for the two - level system interacting with vacuum reservoir , the phenomenon of temporary backflow of information @xcite can not be revealed . if the markovian limit is considered , the characteristic correlation time of reservoir @xmath50 is sufficiently shorter than the system s @xmath51 , i.e , @xmath52 , so the lorentz spectrum will become a flat form , i.e. , @xmath53 , and the coefficient @xmath54 . thus , the widely used markovian master equation scully , breuer can be easily obtained from the eq . ( [ eq - master ] ) , @xmath55 for the initial system state ( [ rhoout ] ) , the solution of the master equation given by ( [ eq - master ] ) can be solved straightforward , which reads @xmath56where the elements of density matrix are @xmath57 , \notag \\ \rho _ { s}^{01}(t ) & = & \rho _ { s}^{10}(t)^{\ast } , \rho _ { s}^{00}(t)=1-\rho _ { s}^{11}(t ) . \label{zhongjian}\end{aligned}\]]here , the parameters @xmath58 are given by @xmath59it is worth noting that the solution of markovian master equation ( markovian ) can be obtained by just replacing the parameter @xmath60 by @xmath61 in eq . ( [ canshu ] ) . and @xmath62 ( @xmath63 ) . panel ( a ) is under the condition @xmath64 , and panel ( b ) is under @xmath65 . for both panels , @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 . ] the explicit expression of the qfi for the estimated parameter @xmath69 is given by @xcite @xmath70where @xmath71 are the eigenvalues of estimated state and @xmath72 are the corresponding eigenvectors . for pure states , the qfi can be simplified as @xmath73 . substituting the estimated state ( [ rhos ] ) into the formula of qfi ( [ fisher1 ] ) , the first term of eq . ( [ fisher1 ] ) is @xmath74 $ ] with @xmath75 $ ] and the second term is @xmath76% + 2b_{1}^{2}b_{2}^{2}\right\}/m$ ] . summing the two terms , we can obtain he analytic expression of qfi for the estimated parameter @xmath69 @xmath77where the parameters @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 are given in eq . ( [ canshu ] ) . from the analytic qfi ( [ fisher ] ) , one can obviously find that the qfi depends on the estimated parameter @xmath69 and squeezed phasing parameter @xmath81 . it varies as @xmath69 with the periodicity @xmath82 , and as @xmath83 with periodicity @xmath84 . a vivid illustrations of such relations are given by fig . [ various ] . with various temperatures without squeezing . panel ( a ) is based on the master equation ( [ eq - master ] ) with @xmath66 and panel ( b ) respects to the markovian master equation ( [ markovian ] ) . here we set @xmath85 ( blue dotted line ) , @xmath86 ( black dotted - dashed line ) , @xmath87 ( red dashed line ) , 2@xmath87 ( green line ) , respectively . ] in order to show the effects of the reservoir squeezing , we will first give a brief demonstration of the behavior of qfi without squeezing . that means we consider the reservoir as a standard thermal reservoir . in this case , the qfi given in eq . ( [ fisher ] ) can be simplified as @xmath88the dynamics of @xmath89 with different temperatures are plotted in fig . [ temperature ] with @xmath90 based on master equation ( [ eq - master ] ) in panel ( a ) and based on markovian master equation given by eq . ( [ markovian ] ) in panel ( b ) . in both conditions , one can find that the qfi with high temperature will decay more rapidly than that with low temperature . comparing panels ( a ) with ( b ) for the same temperature , one can also see that the qfi under markovian limit decays faster . consider the relation between the qfi and the precision of parameter estimation , i.e. , @xmath91 , fig . [ temperature ] tells that 1 ) the precision of parameter estimation will become lower if the reservoir gets hotter ; 2 ) the markovian treatment will reduce the estimation precision . at zero temperature . the qfi in panels ( a ) and ( c ) are given under the condition @xmath92 and @xmath93 , while panels ( b ) and ( d ) plot the qfi under the markovian limit at @xmath94 . the blue dotted line , black dashed - dotted line , red dashed line and green line correspond to the reservoir squeezing @xmath95 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 , respectively . in ( a ) and ( b ) , @xmath99 , and in ( c ) and ( d ) , @xmath100 is satisfied for different @xmath101 and @xmath102 all the time . the sub - panel in ( a ) is the enlarged view in the vicinity of @xmath103 . ] comparing eqs . ( [ fisher ] ) and ( [ thermal ] ) , one can find that the decay of qfi can be reduced , i.e. , @xmath104 , if the following condition for @xmath69 and @xmath83 is satisfied , @xmath105this implies that the decay of qfi in the squeezed reservoir can be reduced duo to the reservoir squeezing . this is obviously illustrated in fig . matching(a ) and [ matching](b ) where the horizontal lines corresponds to the case without squeezing . it is apparent that the squeezing makes a large number of qfi surpass the horizontal lines , namely , the decay of qfi has been reduced . in particular , one can see that with the increasing of squeezing parameter @xmath15 , the qfi is turning high and that the region below the horizontal lines is getting small . in fact , this can be easily understood in physics . in contrast to the case without squeezing , the squeezing divided the imposed phase @xmath106 into two parts respectively related to the squeezing relevant parameters @xmath79 and @xmath80 which has the opposite behaviour with @xmath15 ( see eq . ( [ canshu ] ) ) . when @xmath107 or @xmath108 , @xmath80 plays the dominant role in the quantum fisher information due to the derivative relation , which shows that the quantum fisher information becomes large with the increasing @xmath15 . on the contrary , @xmath79 will play the dominant role . this relation is obviously shown in fig . [ matching ] ( a ) and ( b ) . that is , the competition between the @xmath109 and @xmath110 lead to the reducing or increasing the decay of the qfi under reservoir squeezing for the different regions @xmath111 . from the above analysis , one can find that the squeezing phase parameter @xmath83 may play a significant role in the effects of the precision of parameter estimation . we will show it in the following . from the analytic qfi of parameter @xmath106 eq . ( [ fisher ] ) , one can find that when @xmath112 or @xmath82 , the qfi can reach the maximum with other parameters fixed . in this case , we say that @xmath16 and @xmath113 satisfy the _ squeezing phase matching_. if the estimated phase @xmath113 happens to be in the vicinity of squeezing phase matching , i.e. , @xmath114 with @xmath115 a small quantity , one will find that the decay of qfi will be prevented thoroughly , which can be found in fig . [ matching](c ) and [ matching](d ) , where we assume @xmath116 . the most obvious role of the ( approximate ) squeezing phase matching in fig . [ matching ] is that the regions below the horizontal lines in fig . matching(a ) and fig . [ matching](b ) are eliminated , which is just shown in fig . [ matching](c ) and [ matching](d ) . in addition , one will find that in fig . [ matching](c ) and [ matching](d ) , the qfi with squeezing do nt depend on the estimated phase @xmath106 . the reason is that we have chosen the same @xmath115 for all @xmath106 . in fact , it is not necessary to do so . thus we can conclude that the negative role of the reservoir squeezing could be compensated by the squeezing phase matching . in fact , fig . [ matching ] illustrates the different between the cases vacuum reservoirs with and without squeezing , since we have set the temperature to be zero . in order to find out the influence of temperature accompanied by the squeezing , we plot the qfi in fig . [ simulaneous ] as a function of the reservoir squeezing @xmath15 and the temperature @xmath19 at @xmath117 under condition @xmath118 and the approximate squeezing phase matching condition @xmath116 . it is shown that with the squeezing phase matching , the reservoir squeezing @xmath15 always plays the positive role in restraining the decay of qfi , but the temperature plays a negative role . ( in the unit of @xmath119 ) and the squeezing parameter @xmath15 under condition @xmath120 and @xmath121 . here @xmath122 is satisfied for different @xmath101 and @xmath123 all the time . ] as is mentioned previously , the master equation ( [ eq - master ] ) does not reveal the phenomenon of temporary information back flow hanshimaerkefu , feima - breuer , feima - breuser1,luxiaoming . however , it does not mean that the environment does not impact the dynamics of the qfi , which can be easily found from eq . ( [ fisher1 ] ) . in order to intuitively demonstrate such relations , we plot the qfi under different spectral widths @xmath124 for @xmath125 , @xmath126 and squeezing matching condition @xmath127 in fig . [ lambda ] . one can easily find that the smaller the spectral width is , the more slowly the qfi decays . for various spectral widths . here we set @xmath125 , @xmath126 with squeezing phase matching @xmath128 satisfied . the spectral width @xmath129 are chosen as @xmath130 , @xmath131 , @xmath132 , @xmath133 , respectively . ] in summery , we have investigated the effects of reservoir squeezing on the precision of parameter estimation based on non - perturbation procedures . the exact analytic expression of the quantum fisher information ( qfi ) is obtained . the qfi depends on the estimated phase @xmath106 and the reservoir squeezing parameter @xmath15 , @xmath16 . we have shown that the decay of the qfi can be reduced by the reservoir squeezing , in particular , when taking into account the _ squeezing phase matching_. we would like to thank dr . h. z. shen and jiong cheng for fruitful discussions . this work was supported by the national natural science foundation of china , under grants no.11375036 and 11175033 and the xinghai scholar cultivation plan .

the effects of reservoir squeezing on the precision of parameter estimation are investigated analytically based on non - perturbation procedures . the exact analytic quantum fisher information ( qfi ) is obtained . it is shown that the qfi depends on the estimated parameter and its decay could be reduced by the squeezed reservoir compared with thermal ( vacuum ) reservoir , in particular , if the squeezing phase matching is satisfied . quantum fisher information , squeezed reservoir , non - perturbative master equation

astro-ph9812358

lmc x-1 is one of four extremely luminous ( @xmath1 ergs s@xmath2 ) x - ray binaries in the large magellanic cloud . the source has long been known to show a rather soft x - ray spectrum ( @xmath3 kev ; markert & clark 1975 ) and irregular x - ray variability by at least a factor of three ( griffiths & seward 1977 , johnston , bradt , & doxsey 1979 ) . however , its optical identification was uncertain for many years . the source lies within the bright emission nebula n159 ( henize 1956 ) containing many early - type stars ( see finding chart of region in cowley , crampton , & hutchings 1978 ) . based on the rather uncertain x - ray position , it was originally thought that the b5 supergiant r148 ( @xmath4 ) was the optical counterpart , although the peculiar o7 iii star ( star # 32 of cowley et al . ) @xmath5 away could not be ruled out . recent analysis of @xmath6 high - resolution imager data has confirmed that star # 32 ( @xmath7 ) is the most probable identification ( cowley et al . spectroscopic studies of this star reveal an orbital period near 4 days and a probable mass for the compact star of @xmath8 ( hutchings , crampton , & cowley 1983 , hutchings et al . 1987 ) , making it a strong black - hole candidate . because lmc x-1 is so luminous , its x - ray properties were studied even with the earliest x - ray detectors . white & marshall ( 1984 ) discussed the complex character of its x - ray spectrum , showing that it could not be described by a simple model because of the high - energy excess above 3 kev . thus a two - component model with a soft thermal spectrum and plus a hard high - energy tail was needed . they pointed out the similarity in spectral properties of lmc x-1 to another black - hole candidate , lmc x-3 , and they were the first to recognize that an unusually soft x - ray spectrum may be a reliable signature of a black - hole candidate . using _ ginga _ data , ebisawa , mitsuda , & inoue ( 1989 ) also found a two - component model was needed to fit the spectrum : an ultrasoft blackbody ( @xmath9 kev ) and a hard power law ( photon index @xmath102.5 ) . later , schlegel et al . ( 1994a , 1994b ) modeled the spectrum , based on broad band x - ray telescope ( bbxrt ) data , finding results similar to those of ebisawa et al . ebisawa et al . undertook a timing analysis of their _ ginga _ data and found quasi - periodic oscillations ( qpo ) with a peak frequency of 0.0751 hz in one of the observations . they concluded that the qpo came from the hard - tail component , which was unusually bright at the time in comparison to the thermal component . qpo were not found in the bbxrt data ( schlegel et al . ) , confirming the transient nature of these aperiodic signals . since the presence of qpo might be related to the spectral state of the system , we undertook a series of observations with rossi x - ray timing explorer ( @xmath0 ) over a period of nine months to search for qpo and to further define their origin . a series of nine observations were made between 1996 february and 1996 october . table 1 lists the details of the observational data , in reverse time order , following the numbering system of the @xmath0 science data center . only data from the proportional counter array ( pca ) were analyzed due to the very low net count rate for events with energies @xmath1116 kev . each observation was broken into two or three segments due to earth occultations or passages through the south atlantic anomaly . in 1996 march , two proportional counter units ( pcu ) were found to be discharging , making it necessary to shut them down periodically . the result was that some observations were made with only three of the five pcu operating ( observations # 4 , # 6 , and # 7 ) , as noted in table 1 . observation # 3 experienced a shutdown of two pcu during the second half of the exposure , so it was necessary to analyze this observation in two parts ( # 3a and # 3b ) . background - subtracted light curves , using 16-s time bins , were derived for the 25.9 kev and 5.915.9 kev energy ranges . the spectral hardness within each bin was found by calculating the ratio of counts , @xmath12 ( 5.915.9 kev)/(25.9 kev ) . typical values for the hardness ratio are @xmath100.10.2 ; mean values for each observation are listed in table 1 . the light and @xmath13 curves for observations # 2 , # 3b and # 4 are shown in fig . 1 . the selected observations span a wide range of source intensity and hardness . in observation # 3b ( ` average ' count rate ; lowest @xmath13 ) lmc x-1 was in a quiescent mode with minimal flickering , while in both # 2 ( second highest count rate ; highest @xmath13 ) and # 4 ( lowest count rate ; ` average ' @xmath13 ) the source varied rapidly on a time scale of minutes . examination of all of the observations reveals no dependence of the source s flickering characteristics on either the count rate or hardness . however , for each observation the plot of hardness ratio is similar to that of the high - energy count rate , implying the ratio is driven primarily by the number of 5.915.9 kev counts . @xmath14 data for the black hole candidate gx339@xmath154 in its very high state ( miyamoto et al . 1991 ) show the same behavior ( see their fig . 2 ) . while in this very high state , the source is 23@xmath16 more intense and shows significantly enhanced variability ( on timescales of minutes ) compared to when it is in a ( relatively quiescient ) high state ( makishima et al . although the @xmath0 observations also show various degrees of short - term variability , there is no clear indication that lmc x-1 enters a very high spectral state . to test the dependence of @xmath13 on the source count rate , we used data from all observations to construct the hardness - intensity diagrams shown in fig . 2 . the plot of @xmath13 versus low - energy count rate has no significant relationship between the parameters however , the plot of @xmath13 versus 5.915.9 kev count rate exhibits a very strong correlation which is also present in each of the individual observations . this dependence confirms the trend inferred from examination of the simple light and hardness - ratio curves . we examined the data for time lags between high and low - energy photons by calculating the cross - correlation of the two light curves . a small positive lag , in the sense that high - energy photons tend to arrive after their low - energy counterparts , was found for all observations . however , the mean lag time in each case was comparable to the 0.025-s step used in the calculations , so that the results are not conclusive . to further investigate the temporal variations , power density spectra ( pds ) were constructed using the background - subtracted data , rebinned at 0.125-s resolution . within an observation , the fourier transformation was calculated for each 512-s data segment ( 4096 points ) , covering the frequency range 0.0024 hz . typically , each pds represents the average of @xmath1011 individual transforms . two sets of pds were made , one covering the entire pca energy range ( 260 kev ) and the other restricted to primarily those photons in the hard spectral tail ( 5.915.9 kev ) . no significant differences between these were found . in fig . 3 we present the power density spectrum ( 5.915.9 kev ) for observation # 7 . the power density increases at low frequency ( i.e. , red noise ) and can be modeled in terms of a power law plus a constant ( i.e. , power @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the power index ) . fitted values of the power index , for both the 5.915.9 kev and 260 kev pds , are listed in table 2 . the average indices are @xmath19 and 0.87 for the restricted and full energy ranges , respectively . there is no significant dependence of the modeled power index with either the hardness ratio or the source count rate . for comparison , ebisawa et al . ( 1989 ) measured an index of 0.81 in a @xmath14 observation taken when lmc x-1 was in an x - ray bright state . if present , quasi - periodic oscillations would appear as a broad peak in the pds . none of our observations shows this signature , although ebisawa et al . found strong qpo near 0.0751 hz in some of the @xmath14 data , with weaker qpo around 0.142 hz . ( most likely , this other peak is the second harmonic . ) upper limits for the amplitude of qpo signals in the @xmath0 observations were found by calculating the percent r.m.s . variation of the average excess power ( after subtracting the fitted model ) between 0.05 and 0.10 hz . typical 3@xmath20 limits are @xmath100.8% for the 260 kev pds , as listed in table 2 . for comparison , the amplitudes of the primary and secondary @xmath14 qpo peaks were 2.9% r.m.s . and 1.8% r.m.s . , respectively . hence , the power found in the @xmath14 qpo was much larger than the upper limits placed on the @xmath0 data . clearly , the appearance of qpo in lmc x-1 is a transient phenomenon , as further documented by the lack measurable qpo in bbxrt observations of this source ( schlegel et al . 1994a , 1994b ) . the x - ray energy spectrum of lmc x-1 was separately fit by two multi - component models over the energy range 3.615.9 kev . the soft thermal component was represented by both a blackbody and by a multicolor disk model ( mitsuda et al . 1984 ; makishima et al . 1986 ) , while the high - energy excess was always accounted for using a simple power law . within limitations imposed by an uncertain background subtraction at low energies in the @xmath0 data , both combinations yield acceptable fits . the intervening hydrogen absorption was fixed at @xmath21 @xmath22 in all cases , since the derivation of @xmath23 as a free parameter is very sensitive to errors in background subtraction . mean values for the fitted parameters , which are similar to those of ebisawa et al . ( 1989 ) and schlegel et al . ( 1994a ) , are summarized in table 3 . since the hardness ratio depends on source intensity , further modeling was performed on data selected by pca count rate count ( i.e. , 130140 cnts s@xmath2 , 140150 cnts s@xmath2 , etc . ) . the results of this fitting for the blackbody plus power - law model are shown in fig . 4 . within each observation , we find a trend for an increasing ` scale ' of the power law ( i.e. , comparable to intensity provided the photon index is constant ) with increasing source count rate ( 3.615.9 kev ) . the remaining parameters are nearly constant within a given observation , although a slight increase in temperature of the thermal component may be present at higher count rates . we note that the fitted parameters are highly coupled . if the temperature of the soft component were held constant , then the dependence of the power - law scale on count rate would become even more pronounced . the all sky monitor ( asm ) aboard @xmath0 provides nearly continuous monitoring of the entire sky , producing long - term light curves for bright , persistent x - ray sources as well as discovering new transient sources . we have examined the lmc x-1 data in this public archive . they compare well with the mean count rates for our pointed observations , as presented in this paper . overall , the source varied by about a factor of two through the nine months during which our observations were taken . analysis of @xmath103500 asm data points taken over 76 weeks of observing does not reveal any significant periods in the range 0.520 days , including at the optically determined orbital period of 4.22 days . this result has been confirmed by scientists on the instrument team ( levine 1997 ) . in addition to searching for periods in the asm observations , we have folded our @xmath0 data on the 4.22-day orbital period . the phase coverage is poor because the observations were only obtained at nine discrete times . as it turned out , no observations were obtained between spectroscopic phases 0.9 to 1.3 , leaving a large gap in the phase plots . from the folded data there is no clear indication of any trends related to the orbital period either in the count rate or the hardness ratio . additional data obtained at more closely spaced intervals are need to determine if any small orbital modulation or other signature is present in the x - ray data . we obtained a series of @xmath0 observations of the black - hole candidate lmc x-1 to search for quasi - periodic oscillations and examine their behavior with source intensity . no qpo were detected , although ebisawa et al . had detected them in lmc x-1 when the source was in a bright state . comparison of the source intensity during the @xmath0 and _ ginga _ observations suggests that lmc x-1 never became as bright during our @xmath0 observations as when qpo were found in _ ginga _ data . however , because of the uncertainty of the background subtraction with the @xmath0 data , it is difficult to compare these data sets . in addition , no other periodic behavior was found , either on the orbital period or any other in the range of 0.5 - 20 days . fits of the x - ray spectral energy distribution require a two - component model , and the values derived are similar to those found by previous workers . a strong correlation was detected between the hardness ratio and the high - energy count rate , indicating that changes in the x - ray spectrum of lmc x-1 come from the high - energy tail . + radius of blackbody@xmath24 & 40 km + temperature of blackbody & 0.88 kev + photon index of power law & 2.44 + scale of power law & @xmath27 photons kev@xmath2 @xmath22 s@xmath2 at 10 kev + @xmath23 & @xmath28 atoms @xmath22 ( fixed ) + + projected size of inner disk radius@xmath29 & 22 km + temperature of inner disk radius & 1.17 kev + photon index of power law & 1.45 + scale of power law & @xmath30 photons kev@xmath2 @xmath22 s@xmath2 at 10 kev + @xmath23 & @xmath28 atoms @xmath22 ( fixed ) +

the luminous x - ray binary and black - hole candidate lmc x-1 has been observed with the rossi x - ray timing explorer ( @xmath0 ) to search for quasi - periodic oscillations ( qpo ) , previously reported in its high state . the source was observed monthly in a series of nine observations . analysis of the temporal variations shows no evidence for qpo or other periodic changes , but correlations between the high - energy light curve and hardness of the spectrum are described . spectral fits with two - component models demonstrate that the hardness variations come from changes in the intensity of the high - energy power - law tail .

hep-ph0011357

from the atmospheric and solar neutrino data , there is increasing evidence for neutrino oscillations@xcite . if this is a correct interpretation , the standard model ( sm ) has to be extended to incorporate the small masses of the neutrinos suggested by data . there have been several ideas proposed in literature to generate small neutrino masses . the zee - model is one of such attempts@xcite . in this model , all flavor neutrinos are massless at the tree level , and their small masses are induced radiatively through one - loop diagrams . for such a mass - generation mechanism to work , it is necessary to extend the higgs sector of the sm to contain at least two weak - doublet fields and one weak - singlet charged scalar field . although some studies have been done to examine the interaction of the leptons and the higgs bosons in the zee - model@xcite , the scalar ( higgs ) sector of the model remains unexplored in detail . in this paper we study the higgs sector of the zee - model to clarify its impact on the higgs search experiments , either at the cern lep - ii , the run - ii of the fermilab tevatron , the cern large hadron collider ( lhc ) , or future linear colliders ( lc s ) . experimental search for the higgs boson has been continued at the cern lep and the fermilab tevatron experiments . in the lep - ii experiments , the higgs boson with the mass less than about 110 gev has been excluded if its production cross section and decay modes are similar to those of the sm higgs boson@xcite . run - ii of the tevatron can be sensitive to a sm - like higgs boson with the mass up to about 180 gev , provided that the integrated luminosity of the collider is large enough ( about @xmath2)@xcite . furthermore , the primary goal of the cern lhc experiments is to guarantee the discovery of a sm - like higgs boson for its mass as large as about 1 tev@xcite , which is the upper bound of the sm higgs boson mass . ( for a higgs boson mass beyond this value , the sm is no longer a consistent low energy theory . ) when the higgs boson is discovered , its mass and various decay properties will be measured to test the sm and to distinguish models of new physics at high energy scales . for example , the allowed mass range of the lightest cp - even higgs boson ( @xmath0 ) can be determined by demanding the considered theory to be a valid effective theory all the way up to some cut - off energy scale ( @xmath3 ) . for @xmath4 gev ( i.e. , the planck scale ) , the lower and upper bounds of the sm higgs boson masses are 137 gev and 175 gev , respectively @xcite . the higgs mass bounds for the two - higgs - doublet - model ( thdm ) were also investigated@xcite with and without including the soft - breaking term with respect to the discrete symmetry that protects the natural flavor conservation . it was found in ref . @xcite that the lower bound of the lightest cp - even higgs boson is about 100 gev in the decoupling regime where only one neutral higgs boson is light as compared to the other physical states of higgs bosons . the higgs sector of the zee - model is similar to that of the thdm except for the existence of an additional weak - singlet charged higgs field , so that the physical scalar bosons include two cp - even , one cp - odd and two pairs of charged higgs bosons . in this paper , we shall first determine the upper and lower bounds for the lightest cp - even higgs boson mass ( @xmath5 ) as a function of the cut - off scale @xmath6 of the zee - model , using renormalization group equations ( rge s ) . we show that the upper and lower mass bounds for @xmath0 are almost the same as those in the thdm . we also study the possible range of the higgs - boson self - coupling constants at the electroweak scale as a function of @xmath6 . by using these results , we examine effects of the additional loop contribution of the singlet charged higgs boson to the partial decay width of @xmath7 . we show that , by taking @xmath8 gev , the deviation of the decay width from the sm prediction can be about @xmath920% or nearly @xmath1010% for @xmath11 between 125 gev and 140 gev when the mass of the isospin singlet charged higgs boson is taken to be around 100 gev . the magnitude of the deviation becomes larger for lower cutoff scales and smaller masses of the singlet charged higgs boson . if we choose @xmath12 gev and the singlet charged higgs boson mass to be 100 gev , the positive deviation can be greater than @xmath1030% ( @xmath1040% ) for @xmath13 gev ( @xmath14 gev ) . such a deviation from the sm prediction could be tested at the lhc , the @xmath15 lc and the @xmath16 option of lc@xcite . we also discuss phenomenology of the singlet charged higgs boson at present and future collider experiments , which is found to be completely different from that of the ordinary thdm - like charged higgs bosons . to detect such a charged higgs boson at lep - ii experiments , experimentalists have to search for their data sample with @xmath17 or @xmath18 plus missing energy , in contrast to the usual detection channels : either @xmath19 or @xmath20 decay modes . this paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ sec : zeemodel ] , we introduce the higgs sector of the zee - model and review the neutrino masses and mixings in this model which are consistent with the atmospheric and solar neutrino observations . numerical results on the possible range of the mass and coupling constants of the higgs bosons are given in sec . [ sec : rge_analysis ] . in sec [ sec : h-2gamma ] , we discuss the one - loop effect of the extra - higgs bosons in the zee - model to the partial decay width of @xmath7 and its impacts on the neutral higgs - boson search at high - energy colliders . the phenomenology of the charged higgs boson that comes from the additional singlet field is discussed in sec . [ sec : charged ] . in sec . [ sec : conclusion ] , we present additional discussions and conclusion . relevant rge s for the zee - model are given in the appendix . to generate small neutrino mass radiatively , the zee - model contains a @xmath21 singlet charged scalar field @xmath22 , in addition to two @xmath21 doublet fields @xmath23 , and @xmath24 . the zee - model lagrangian is written as : @xmath25 where @xmath26 @xmath27 where @xmath28 ( @xmath29 are the generation indices , and @xmath30 \nonumber \\ & & + \sigma _ { 1}\left| \omega^{-}\right| ^{2}\left| \phi _ { 1}\right| ^{2}+ \sigma _ { 2}\left| \omega^{-}\right| ^{2}\left| \phi _ { 2}\right| ^{2}+ \frac{1}{4}\sigma _ { 3}\left| \omega^{-}\right| ^{4 } \ , . \label{higgs_potential } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in the above equations , @xmath31 is the left - handed quark doublet with an implicit generation index while @xmath32 and @xmath33 denote the right - handed singlet quarks . similarly , @xmath34 and @xmath35 denote the left - handed and right - handed leptons in three generations . the charge conjugation of a fermion field is defined as @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is the charge conjugation matrix ( @xmath38 ) with the super index @xmath39 indicating the transpose of a matrix . also , @xmath40 and @xmath41 with @xmath42 . without loss of generality , we have taken the anti - symmetric matrix @xmath43 and the coupling @xmath44 to be real in the equations ( [ fij_int ] ) and ( [ higgs_potential ] ) . in order to suppress flavor changing neutral current ( fcnc ) at the tree level , a discrete symmetry , with @xmath45 , @xmath46 , @xmath47 , is imposed to the higgs sector of the lagrangian , which is only broken softly by the @xmath48 term and the @xmath49 term . under the discrete symmetry there are two possible yukawa - interactions ; that is , for type - i @xmath50 and for type - ii , @xmath51 where @xmath52,@xmath53,@xmath54 are diagonal yukawa matrices and @xmath55 is the cabibbo - kobayashi - maskawa ( ckm ) matrix . later , we shall only keep the top yukawa coupling constants @xmath56 in our numerical evaluation of the rge s . ] . in that case , there is no difference between the yukawa couplings of the type - i and the type - ii models . finally , for simplicity , we assume that all @xmath57 and @xmath58 are real parameters . let us now discuss the higgs sector . the @xmath59 symmetry is broken to @xmath60 by @xmath61 and @xmath62 , the vacuum expectation values of @xmath63 and @xmath64 . ( they are assumed to be real so that there is no spontaneous cp violation . ) the number of physical higgs bosons are two cp - even higgs bosons ( @xmath65,@xmath66 ) , one cp - odd higgs boson ( @xmath67 ) and two pairs of charged higgs boson ( @xmath68 , @xmath69 ) . we take a convention of @xmath70 and @xmath71 . in the basis where two higgs doublets are rotated by the angle @xmath72 , with @xmath73 , the mass matrices for the physical states of higgs bosons are given by @xmath74 \,,\ ] ] for cp - even higgs bosons , @xmath75 for cp - odd higgs boson , and @xmath76 \,,\ ] ] for charged higgs bosons . here , @xmath77 and @xmath78 . the vacuum expectation value @xmath79 ( @xmath80 gev ) is equal to @xmath81 . mass eigenstates for the cp - even and the charged higgs bosons are obtained by diagonalizing the mass matrices ( [ neutralmassmatrix ] ) and ( [ chargedmassmatrix ] ) , respectively . the original higgs boson fields , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath22 , can be expressed in terms of the physical states and the nambu - goldstone modes ( @xmath82 and @xmath83 ) as @xmath84 where the angle @xmath85 and @xmath86 are defined from the matrices which diagonalize the @xmath87 matrices @xmath88 and @xmath89 , respectively . namely , we have @xmath90 where @xmath91 and @xmath92 . the mixing angles @xmath93 and @xmath94 then satisfy @xmath95 which show that @xmath93 and @xmath94 approaches to @xmath96 and zero , respectively . ] , when @xmath97 is much greater than @xmath98 , @xmath99 and @xmath100 ; i.e. , in the decoupling regime . in this limit , the massive higgs bosons from the extra weak - doublet are very heavy due to the large @xmath101 so that they are decoupled from the low energy observable . although neutrinos in this model are massless at the tree level , the loop diagrams involving charged higgs bosons , as shown in fig . [ fig : neutrino_mass ] , can generate the majorana mass terms for all three - flavors of neutrinos . it was shown @xcite that at the one - loop order , the neutrino mass matrix , defined in the basis where the charged lepton yukawa - coupling constants are diagonal in the lepton flavor space , is real and symmetric with vanishing diagonal elements . more explicitly , we have @xmath102 with @xmath103 where @xmath104 @xmath105 is the charged lepton mass for type - i . for type - ii , @xmath106 should be replaced by @xmath107 . note that eq . ( [ nmass2fij ] ) is valid for @xmath108 . the phenomenological analysis of the above mass matrix was given in ref . it was concluded that , in the zee - model , the bi - maximal mixing solution is the only possibility to reconcile the atmospheric and the solar neutrino data . here we give a brief summary of their results , for completeness . let us denote the three eigenvalues for the neutrino mass matrix , cf . ( [ neutrino3x3 ] ) , as @xmath109 , @xmath110 and @xmath111 , which satisfy @xmath112 . the possible pattern of the neutrino mass spectrum which is allowed in the zee - model is @xmath113 , with @xmath114 , and @xmath115 , where @xmath116 ev@xmath117 from the atmospheric neutrino data , and @xmath118 ev@xmath117 ( msw large angle solution ) or @xmath119 ev@xmath117 ( vacuum oscillation solution ) from the solar neutrino data ) , only the hierarchy pattern @xmath120 , rather than @xmath121 , is realized in the zee - model@xcite ] . thus , we have @xmath122 ( @xmath123 ) and @xmath124 . the approximate form of the neutrino mass matrix is given by @xmath125 where the upper ( lower ) sign corresponds to @xmath126 ( @xmath127 ) case , and the corresponding maki - nakagawa - sakata ( mns ) matrix@xcite which diagonalizes the neutrino mass matrix is @xmath128 in the above equations , we took the limiting case where @xmath129 and @xmath130 and @xmath131 in the notation of ref . @xcite . ] . from eqs ( [ nmass2fij ] ) and ( [ bimaximal_neutrino_mass ] ) , we obtain @xmath132 therefore , the magnitudes of the three coupling constants should satisfy the relation @xmath133 . this hierarchy among the couplings @xmath134 is crucial for our later discussion on the phenomenology of the singlet charged higgs bosons . for a given value of the parameters @xmath135 , @xmath136 , @xmath107 and @xmath49 , the coupling constants @xmath134 can be calculated from eq . ( [ nmass2fij ] ) . for example , for @xmath137gev , @xmath138gev , @xmath139 , @xmath140gev and @xmath141ev , we obtain @xmath142 . as in this example , when @xmath143 is rather heavy and the lighter charged higgs boson @xmath144 is almost a weak singlet , i.e. the mixing angle @xmath94 approaches to zero , it is unlikely that there are observable effects to the low energy data@xcite ; e.g. , the muon life - time , the universality of tau decay into electron or muon , the rare decay of @xmath145 , the universality of @xmath146-boson decay into electron , muon or tau , and the decay width of @xmath147 boson . when @xmath148 are small , we do not expect a large rate in the lepton flavor violation decay of a light neutral higgs boson , such as @xmath149 ( the largest one ) , @xmath150 , or @xmath151 ( the smallest one ) . on the contrary , as to be discussed in section iv , the decay width of @xmath1 can significantly deviate from the sm value . finally , the phenomenological constraints on @xmath152 were derived in ref . @xcite . from the consistency of the muon decay rate and electroweak precision test it was found that @xmath153 where @xmath154 is the fermi constant , and @xmath155 this means that the @xmath134 can not be @xmath156 unless the charged higgs boson masses are at the order of 10 tev . in this section , we determine the bounds on the mass of the lightest cp - even higgs boson as a function of the cut - off scale of the zee - model by analyzing the set of renormalization group equations ( rge s ) . we also study the allowed ranges of the coupling constants , especially @xmath157 and @xmath158 in eq . ( [ higgs_potential ] ) . in sec . iv , they will be used to evaluate how much the partial decay width of @xmath159 can deviate from its sm value due to the one - loop contribution from the singlet charged higgs boson . the mass bounds are determined in the following manner . for each set of parameters defined at the electroweak scale , the running coupling constants are calculated numerically through rge s at the one - loop level . we require that all the dimensionless coupling constants do not blow up below a given cut - off scale @xmath3 , and the coupling constants satisfy the vacuum stability condition . we vary the input parameters at the electroweak scale and determine the possible range of the lightest cp - even higgs boson mass as a function of @xmath3 . in a similar manner , we also study the allowed ranges of various higgs boson self - coupling constants at the electroweak scale as well as a function of the lightest cp - even higgs boson mass . we derived the one - loop rge s for the zee - model , and listed them in the appendix for reference . for simplicity , in the rge s , we have neglected all the yukawa coupling constants ( @xmath160 , @xmath161 , @xmath162 ) but the top yukawa coupling @xmath163 .. ] although we kept the new coupling constants @xmath43 in the rge s listed in the appendix , we have neglected @xmath43 in the numerical calculation . this is because the magnitudes of these coupling constants are numerically too small to affect the final results unless the singlet - charged scalar - boson mass is larger than a few tev [ cf . ( [ f12value ] ) ] . the dimensionless coupling constants relevant to our numerical analysis are the three gauge - coupling constants @xmath164 , @xmath165 , @xmath166 , the top yukawa - coupling constant @xmath163 , and eight scalar self - coupling constants , @xmath57 ( @xmath167 ) and @xmath168 ( @xmath169 ) . there are five dimensionful parameters in the higgs potential , namely @xmath170 , @xmath171 , @xmath48 , @xmath172 and @xmath44 . instead of @xmath170 , @xmath171 , @xmath48 , we take @xmath173 , @xmath174 , and @xmath78 , as independent parameters , where @xmath79 ( @xmath80 gev ) characterizes the weak scale and @xmath101 the soft - breaking scale of the discrete symmetry . in the actual numerical calculation we first fix @xmath174 and @xmath175 . for a given mass ( @xmath176 ) of the lightest cp - even higgs boson , we solve one of the @xmath57 , which is chosen to be @xmath177 here , in terms of other @xmath57 . we then numerically evaluate all dimensionless coupling constants according to the rge s . from @xmath176 to @xmath175 we use the sm rge s , which are matched to the zee - model rge s at the soft - breaking scale @xmath175 . and @xmath49 are only relevant to the charged scalar mass matrix . in principle , our numerical results also depend on these parameters through the renormalization of various coupling constants from the scale of @xmath5 to the charged scalar mass . since these effects are expected to be small , we calculate the rge s as if all the scalar - bosons except @xmath0 decouple at the scale @xmath101 . ] we requires the following two conditions to be satisfied for each scale @xmath178 up to a given cut - off scale @xmath3 . 1 . applicability of the perturbation theory implies + @xmath179 2 . the vacuum stability conditions must be satisfied . the requirement that quartic coupling terms of the scalar potential do not have a negative coefficient in any direction leads to the following conditions at each renormalization scale @xmath178 : 1 . @xmath180 2 . @xmath181 + @xmath182 + @xmath183 + where @xmath184 . 3 . if @xmath185 and @xmath186 , then @xmath187 if @xmath185 and @xmath188 , then @xmath189 if @xmath186 and @xmath188 , then @xmath190 [ when @xmath191 , @xmath192 and @xmath193 are all negative , the above three conditions are equivalent . ] in addition to the above conditions , we also demand local stability of the potential at the electroweak scale , namely , we calculate the mass spectrum of all scalar fields at the extremum of the potential and demand that all eigenvalues of the squared scalar mass are positive . we scan the remaining seven - dimensional space of @xmath57 and @xmath168 and examine whether a given mass of the lightest cp - even higgs boson is allowed under the above conditions . in this way we obtain the allowed range of @xmath5 as a function of @xmath174 and @xmath175 , for each value of the cut - off scale @xmath3 . the allowed mass range of the lightest cp - even higgs boson for @xmath194 gev . @xmath6 is the cut - off scale . ] first , we discuss our result in the decoupling case , in which the soft - breaking scale @xmath101 is much larger than the electroweak scale @xmath195 , and the masses of all the higgs bosons but @xmath0 ( and @xmath196 ) are at the order of @xmath197 , which leads to @xmath198 and @xmath199 ) , the masses of @xmath0 and @xmath196 are dominated by the @xmath200 component of the mass matrix in eq . ( [ neutralmassmatrix ] ) and the @xmath201 component of that in eq . ( [ chargedmassmatrix ] ) , respectively . the mass of @xmath0 is determined by the self - coupling constants @xmath202 , while that of @xmath196 depends not only on the self - couplings constants @xmath203 but also on the free mass parameter @xmath204 . as noticed in the footnote 7 , from @xmath5 to @xmath101 , the sm rge are used in our analysis , even if the mass of @xmath196 is smaller than @xmath101 . the effect of @xmath196 on the mass bound of @xmath0 is expected to be small , because at the one - loop level the primary effect is through the running of @xmath205 , whose contribution to the right - handed side of the rge for the higgs - self coupling constant is small . ] . in fig . [ fig : z1000 ] , the allowed range of @xmath176 is shown as a function of @xmath174 for @xmath206 gev . ( we take the pole mass of top quark @xmath207 gev , @xmath208 for numerical calculation . ) the allowed ranges are shown as contours for six different values of @xmath3 , i.e. @xmath4 , @xmath209,@xmath210,@xmath211,@xmath212 and @xmath213 gev . for most values of @xmath174 , except for small @xmath174 region , the upper bound of @xmath176 is about @xmath214 gev and the lower bound is between @xmath215 gev and @xmath216 gev for the cut - off scale @xmath6 to be near the planck scale . the numerical values in this figure are very close to those in the corresponding figure for the thdm discussed in ref . @xcite . compared to the corresponding lower mass bound in the sm , which is @xmath217 gev when using the one - loop rge s , the lower mass bound in this model is reduced by about @xmath218 gev to @xmath219 gev . the reason is similar to the thdm case : the lightest cp - even higgs boson mass is essentially determined by the value of @xmath220 for @xmath221 to be larger than about 2@xmath222 , where @xmath220 plays the role of the self - coupling constant of the higgs potential in the sm can not be too large to ignore the contribution of the bottom quark in the case with the type - ii yukawa interaction . ] . on the right - hand side of the rge for @xmath220 , cf ( [ rge_lambda2 ] ) , there are additional positive - definite terms @xmath223 as compared to the rge for the higgs self - coupling constant in the sm . these additional terms can improve vacuum stability , and allow lower values of @xmath176 . therefore , one of the features of the model is to have a different mass range for the lightest cp - even higgs boson as compared to the sm higgs boson , for a given cut - off scale . the allowed mass range of the lightest cp - even higgs boson for @xmath224 gev . ] next , we show our result for @xmath101 to be around @xmath79 . in fig . [ fig : z100 ] , we present the @xmath5 bound for @xmath225 gev . in this case , the allowed range of @xmath5 is reduced as compared to that in the decoupling case , and lies around @xmath226 for large @xmath107 . notice that we have not included phenomenological constraints from the @xmath227 , @xmath228 parameter and the direct higgs boson search experiment at lep . as mentioned before , the mass bounds obtained from the rge analysis are the same for the type - i and type - ii models without these phenomenological constraints . however , it was shown in ref . @xcite that the @xmath227 data can put a strong constraint on the allowed range of the higgs boson mass for @xmath229@xmath230 gev in the type - ii thdm , whereas there is no appreciable effect in the type - i model . this is because a small @xmath101 implies a light charged higgs boson in the thdm which can induce a large decay branching ratio for @xmath227 in the type - ii model@xcite data also give strong constraints on the charged higgs bosons in the type - ii thdm@xcite . ] . we expect a similar constraint from the @xmath227 data on the type - ii zee - model , when @xmath101 is small . in fig . [ fig : zeem ] , we show the upper and lower bounds of @xmath5 as a function of @xmath101 for various values of @xmath6 . for given @xmath101 , we scan the range of @xmath107 for @xmath231 . we find that the obtained @xmath5 bounds are almost the same as those for the thdm . the primary reason for this is that the new coupling constants @xmath157 , @xmath158 and @xmath232 do not appear directly in the mass formula for @xmath176 , and therefore , do not induce large effects on the bounds of @xmath5 . the allowed range of @xmath233 and @xmath5 for various @xmath6 values . ] the allowed range of @xmath234 and @xmath5 for various @xmath6 values . ] the allowed range of @xmath233 and @xmath234 for @xmath235 gev . ] the allowed range of @xmath233 and @xmath234 for @xmath236 gev . ] the allowed range of @xmath237 and @xmath5 for various @xmath6 values . ] we also investigate the allowed range of coupling constants @xmath157 , @xmath158 and @xmath232 . for this purpose , we fix @xmath157 ( or @xmath158 , @xmath232 ) as well as @xmath174 and @xmath175 to evaluate the upper and the lower bounds of @xmath176 for each @xmath3 value . in this way , we determine the possible range of @xmath157 ( or @xmath158 , @xmath232 ) under the condition that the theory does not break down below the cut - off scale @xmath3 . in fig . [ fig : s1range ] , we present the allowed range of @xmath157 and @xmath176 for different choice of @xmath3 in the case of @xmath206 gev and @xmath238 or @xmath239 . a similar figure is shown for the possible range of @xmath158 in fig . [ fig : s2range ] . we see that the maximal value of @xmath157 and @xmath158 is around @xmath240 for @xmath241 gev if we take the cut - off scale to be @xmath242 gev . for smaller value of @xmath3 the allowed ranges of @xmath168 becomes larger . for example , @xmath157 can exceed @xmath243 for @xmath244 gev . we have calculated for other value of @xmath174 and checked that these figures does not change greatly between @xmath245 and @xmath239 . we also present the allowed range in the @xmath157 and @xmath158 plane for a fixed value of @xmath176 in figs . [ fig : s12range_m1000_mh125 ] and [ fig : s12range_m1000_mh140 ] for @xmath246 gev and @xmath247 gev , respectively . for either value of @xmath176 with @xmath248 , both @xmath157 and @xmath158 can be as large as 0.5 ( 2 ) for @xmath4 ( @xmath212 ) gev . the allowed range of @xmath249 and @xmath5 for various values of @xmath6 is given in fig . [ fig : s3range ] . it is shown that , @xmath249 has to be larger than zero , due to the vacuum stability condition . the maximal value of @xmath232 is about @xmath243 ( 3 ) for @xmath4 ( @xmath212 ) gev and @xmath206 gev . the impact of these new coupling constants on the collider phenomenology is discussed in the next section . in this section , we study the phenomenological consequences of the higgs boson mass and the higgs - boson - coupling constants derived in the previous section . the important feature of the higgs sector of the zee - model is that there are an additional weak doublet and a singlet charged higgs boson . the physical states of the higgs particles are two cp - even higgs bosons , one cp - odd higgs boson and two pairs of charged higgs bosons . therefore , the higgs phenomenology is quite close to the ordinary two - higgs - doublet model . one unique difference is the existence of the additional weak - singlet charged higgs boson . the effect of this extra charged higgs boson is especially important when @xmath175 is much larger than the @xmath250 boson mass , i.e. in the decoupling regime . in such a case , the heavier cp - even higgs boson , the cp - odd higgs boson as well as one of the charged higgs bosons have masses approximately equal to @xmath175 , and these heavy states are decoupled from low energy observables . ( note that the condition on the applicability of the perturbation theory forbids too large self - couplings among the higgs bosons . hence , in the limit of large @xmath101 , the heavy higgs bosons decouple from the low energy effective theory . ) the remaining light states are the lighter cp - even higgs boson @xmath0 and the lighter charged higgs boson @xmath196 which mainly comes from the weak - singlet . in the previous section , we show that , even in the decoupling case , there can be large difference in the allowed range of @xmath5 between the zee - model and the sm . similarly , we expect that , even in the decoupling case , the presence of the additional weak - singlet charged higgs boson can give rise to interesting higgs phenomenology . since the lighter charged higgs boson @xmath196 can couple to higgs bosons and leptons , it can affect the decay and the production of the neutral higgs bosons at colliders through radiative corrections . in the following , we consider the decay width of @xmath251 as an example . for a sm higgs boson , the partial decay width ( or branching ratio ) of @xmath7 is small : @xmath252 kev ( or @xmath253 ) for @xmath246 gev , and @xmath254 kev ( or @xmath255 ) for @xmath247 gev , with a 175 gev top quark . nevertheless , it is an important discovery mode of the higgs boson at the lhc experiments for @xmath5 less than twice of the @xmath146-boson mass . needless to say that a change in the branching ratio of @xmath256 would lead to a different production rate of @xmath257 . at future @xmath15 lc s , the branching ratio of @xmath159 can be determined via the reaction @xmath258 and @xmath259 with a 16 - 22% accuracy@xcite . at the photon - photon collision option of the future lc s , the partial decay width of @xmath7 can be precisely tested within a 2 % accuracy@xcite by measuring the inclusive production rate of the higgs boson @xmath0 . clearly , a change in the partial decay width of @xmath7 will lead to a different production rate for @xmath0 . in the zee - model , such a change is expected after taking into account the loop contribution of the extra charged higgs boson . we find that the deviation from the sm prediction can be sizable , and therefore testable at the lhc and future lc s . the partial decay width of @xmath7 is calculated at the one - loop order . similar to our previous discussion , we limit ourselves to the parameter space in which @xmath260 , and keep only the top quark contribution from the fermionic loop diagrams . including the loop contributions from the @xmath146 boson and the charged higgs bosons @xmath261 and @xmath196 together with the top quark loop contribution , we obtain@xcite @xmath262 with @xmath263 where @xmath264 and @xmath265 is the mass of the internal lines in the loop diagram . @xmath266 and @xmath267 are given by @xmath268 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath269 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath270 with @xmath271 ^{2 } & \mbox { if}\ ; r\geq 1\\ -\frac{1}{4}\left [ \ln \frac{1+\sqrt{1-r}}{1-\sqrt{1-r}}-i\pi \right ] ^{2 } & \mbox { if}\ ; r<1 \end{array}\right . .\ ] ] in the decoupling case of the model , namely @xmath272 , the above formulae are greatly simplified . this limit corresponds to @xmath273 and @xmath274 , so that the light charged higgs boson @xmath69 is identical to the weak - singlet higgs boson @xmath275 . thus , we have @xmath276 and both the top - quark and the @xmath146 boson loop contributions reduce to their sm values . we like to stress that the weak - singlet higgs boson does not directly couple to the quark fields in the limit of @xmath277 . therefore , it does not affect the decay rate of @xmath278 at the one - loop order . similarly , being a weak singlet , it also gives no contribution to the @xmath279 parameter . hence the low - energy constraint from either the @xmath278 decay or the @xmath279 parameter on the zee - model in the limit of @xmath280 is similar to effects of that on the thdm . let us examine at the one - loop effect of the weak - singlet charged higgs boson on the decay width of @xmath159 in the decoupling limit . let us recall that in fig . [ fig : s12range_m1000_mh140 ] , the size of the new couplings @xmath281 and @xmath282 can be as large as 2 simultaneously , if the cut - off scale is at the order of @xmath283 gev . for the zee - model to be a valid low energy effective theory up to @xmath284 gev , @xmath281 and @xmath282 can not be much larger than @xmath285 . to illustrate the implications of this result , we show in figs . [ fig : ratio125_140 ] ( a ) and [ fig : ratio125_140 ] ( b ) the ratio ( @xmath286 ) of the @xmath287 width predicted in the zee - model to that in the sm , @xmath288 , as a function of the coupling constant @xmath282 and the charged higgs boson mass @xmath136 . here , for simplicity , we have set @xmath289 so that the @xmath107 dependence drops in the decoupling case , cf . ( [ eq : decoup ] ) . for illustrations , we consider two cases for the mass of the lighter cp - even higgs boson : @xmath246 gev and @xmath247 gev . as shown in the figures , the ratio @xmath290 can be around 0.8 for @xmath291 and @xmath292 gev . this reduction is due to the cancellation between the contribution from the @xmath196-boson loop and the @xmath146-boson loop contributions . to have a similar reduction rate in @xmath293 for a heavier @xmath196 , the coupling constant @xmath282 ( and @xmath281 ) has to be larger next , as shown in figs . 7 and 8 , @xmath281 and @xmath282 do not have to take the same values in general , and they can be less than zero . in the case where both @xmath281 and @xmath282 are negative , the contribution of the @xmath196-loop diagram and that of the @xmath146-loop diagram have the same sign , so that @xmath286 can be larger than 1 . such an example is shown in fig . [ fig : ratio125_140_negatives2 ] ( a ) , where the ratio @xmath286 for @xmath246 gev is shown as a function of @xmath294 at various negative @xmath282 values with @xmath295 and @xmath296 . we consider the case with @xmath297 , @xmath298 or @xmath299 , which is consistent with the cut - off scale @xmath8 , @xmath300 or @xmath301 gev , respectively . in the case of @xmath8 gev ( @xmath301 gev ) , the deviation from the sm prediction can be about + 6% ( + 30% ) for @xmath302 gev . in fig . [ fig : ratio125_140_negatives2 ] ( b ) , the similar plot of the ratio @xmath286 is shown for @xmath247 gev with @xmath295 and @xmath296 . each case with @xmath303 , @xmath304 or @xmath305 is consistent with @xmath8 , @xmath300 or @xmath301 gev , respectively . the correction is larger in the case with @xmath247 gev than in the case with @xmath246 gev for a given @xmath6 . the deviation from the sm prediction can amount to about + 8% ( + 40% ) for @xmath8 gev ( @xmath301 gev ) when @xmath306 gev . larger positive corrections are obtained for smaller @xmath294 values . such a deviation from the sm prediction can be tested at the lhc , the @xmath15 lc and the @xmath16 option of lc . before concluding this section , we remark that if @xmath5 is larger than @xmath307 such that the decay mode @xmath308 is open , the total decay width of @xmath0 can be largely modified from the sm prediction for large @xmath309 . in terms of @xmath310 , the partial decay width of @xmath311 is given by @xmath312 where @xmath313 . in fig . [ fig : hsswidth ] ( a ) , we show the partial decay width @xmath314 for @xmath315 gev with @xmath316 , cf . ( [ eq : decoup ] ) , for the allowed range of @xmath5 from 100 gev to 500 gev . in fig . [ fig : hsswidth ] ( b ) , the ratio of @xmath314 to the total width of the sm higgs boson ( @xmath317 ) is shown as a function of @xmath5 for each value of @xmath318 . this is to illustrate the possible size of the difference between the total width of the lightest cp - even higgs boson @xmath0 in the zee - model and that of the sm higgs boson gev , which allows a wide range of values for @xmath319 s , @xmath136 and @xmath5 . ] . clearly , the impact of the @xmath320 decay channel is especially large in the small @xmath5 region . we note that @xmath317 can be determined to the accuracy of 10 - 20% at the lhc and the lc if @xmath321 , and to that of a couple of per cents if @xmath322@xcite . ( @xmath323 is the mass of the @xmath147-boson . ) hence , measuring the total width of the lightest neutral higgs boson can provide a further test of the zee - model for @xmath324 . the change in the total width also modifies the decay branching ratio of @xmath325 , hence yields a different rate of @xmath326 for a given @xmath5 . ( in the sm , the branching ratio of @xmath325 is about 1/3 for @xmath327 gev . ) needless to say that for @xmath328 , the production mode of @xmath329 is also useful to test the zee - model . further discussion on this possibility will be given in sec . in the zee - model , two kinds of charged higgs bosons appear . if there is no mixing between them ( @xmath330 ) , the mass eigenstates @xmath331 and @xmath332 correspond to the thdm - like charged higgs field and the singlet higgs field @xmath275 , respectively . the case with @xmath330 occurs in the limit of @xmath333 and @xmath100 ; i.e. in the decoupling limit . the detection of @xmath332 can be a clear indication of the zee - model . as to be shown later , its phenomenology is found to be drastically different from that of the thdm - like charged higgs bosons @xmath331@xcite . here , we discuss how the effects of this extra charged boson can be explored experimentally . we first consider the case with @xmath330 , and then extend the discussion to the case with a non - zero @xmath94 . the @xmath334 boson decays into a lepton pair @xmath335 with the coupling constant @xmath134 . the partial decay rate , @xmath336 , is calculated as @xmath337 and the total decay width of @xmath334 is given by @xmath338 by taking into account the hierarchy pattern of @xmath134 , cf . ( [ eq21 ] ) and ( [ eq22 ] ) , and by assuming @xmath302 gev and @xmath339 , the total decay width and the life time ( @xmath340 ) is estimated to be . if we take @xmath341 gev or @xmath342 gev , @xmath343 can become one order of magnitude larger than @xmath344 , while still being consistent with the phenomenological bounds discussed in sec . @xmath345 this implies that @xmath196 decays after traveling a distance of @xmath346 m , which is significantly shorter than the typical detector scale . therefore , @xmath332 decays promptly after its production , and can be detected at collider experiments . the main production channel at the lep - ii experiment may be the pair production process @xmath347 , similar to the production of the thdm - like charged higgs boson @xmath348 . the matrix - element squares for the @xmath349 production ( @xmath350 ) are given by @xmath351 where @xmath352 and @xmath353 ( @xmath354 ) for the incoming electron @xmath355 ( @xmath356 ) ; @xmath357 and @xmath358 ( @xmath354 ) for @xmath359 ( @xmath360 ) ; @xmath361 , @xmath362 , @xmath363 , and @xmath364 is the scattering angle of @xmath365 in the @xmath15 center - of - mass ( cm ) frame whose energy is @xmath366 . for the other electron - positron helicity configuration ( @xmath367 and @xmath368 ) , the cross sections are zero . thus the total cross section for the @xmath320 pair production is given by @xmath369 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , the production rates of @xmath143 and @xmath334 are different . we note that the ratio of cross sections for @xmath370 and @xmath371 production , @xmath372 , is @xmath373 at @xmath374 gev assuming that the masses of @xmath331 and @xmath332 are the same . this ratio is independent of the masses of @xmath375 and @xmath376 for a fixed cm energy . ( only the difference between @xmath377 and @xmath378 coupling constants determines this ratio . ) the lower mass bound of the thdm - like charged boson @xmath379 can be obtained by studying its @xmath19 and @xmath380 decay modes , completely in the same way as the charged higgs boson search in the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm)@xcite . similar experimental constraints may be obtained for the extra charged bosons @xmath332 . the situation , however , turns out to be fairly different from the @xmath331 case . first of all , decays of @xmath332 are all leptonic . secondly , the branching ratios of various @xmath332 decay modes are estimated as @xmath381 where we have used the relations given in eqs . ( [ eq21 ] ) and ( [ eq22 ] ) . clearly , the branching ratio into the @xmath382 mode is very small , so that it is not useful for detecting @xmath332 at all . this is different from the case of detecting the ordinary thdm - like charged higgs boson , which preferentially decays into heavy fermion pairs ( e.g. @xmath19 and @xmath20 ) . instead of studying the @xmath383 mode , the @xmath384 and @xmath385 modes can provide a strong constraint on the mass of @xmath332 . in fact , the branching ratio of @xmath386 or @xmath387 is almost 100 % , so that we have @xmath388 , where @xmath389 and @xmath390 represent @xmath391 or @xmath392 ( not @xmath393 ) . let us compare this with the cross section @xmath394 , where @xmath395 . as seen in fig . [ fig : zee_pair ] , the cross section @xmath396 is comparable with @xmath397 . therefore , by examining the lep - ii data for @xmath398 ( where @xmath399 , @xmath400 or @xmath401 , in contrast to @xmath402 for the @xmath331 case ) , the experimental lower bound on the mass of @xmath332 can be determined . such a bound can be induced from the smuon search results at the lep experiments@xcite in the case that neutralinos are assumed to be massless . from the @xmath403 data accumulated up to @xmath404 gev@xcite , we find that the lower mass bound of @xmath332 is likely to be 80 - 85 gev for the @xmath330 cases . [ we note that the right - handed smuon ( @xmath405 ) in the mssm carries the same @xmath406 quantum number as the weak - singlet charged higgs boson ( @xmath332 for @xmath407 ) . ] we next comment on @xmath332-production processes at hadron colliders and future lc s . at hadron colliders , the dominant production mode is the pair production through the drell - yan - type process . the cross sections for @xmath408 at the tevatron run - ii energy ( @xmath409 tev ) and @xmath410 at the lhc energy ( @xmath411 tev ) are shown as a function of @xmath136 in fig . [ fig : zee_hadron ] for @xmath412 . at future lc s , the @xmath332 boson may be discovered through the above - discussed pair - production process from the electron - positron annihilation if @xmath413 . in fig . [ fig : zee_lc ] , we show the total cross section of @xmath414 for @xmath330 as a function of @xmath136 for @xmath415 , @xmath416 , and @xmath417 gev . finally , we like to discuss the case with a non - zero @xmath94 , in which @xmath334 is a mixture of the singlet charged higgs boson state ( @xmath418 ) and the doublet charged higgs boson state ( @xmath419 ) . let us see how the above discussion is changed in this case . the doublet charged higgs bosons with the mass of @xmath420 gev mainly decay into the @xmath421 and @xmath422 channels . thus , the branching ratio of the decay process @xmath423 , where @xmath389 represents @xmath391 and @xmath392 , is expressed in a non - zero @xmath94 case as @xmath424 where @xmath425 ( @xmath426 ) is the total width of @xmath365 at @xmath330 with the same mass as the decaying @xmath334 on the left - hand side of the above equation . the formula of @xmath427 is given in eq . ( [ s2width_0 ] ) , while @xmath428 , which is the same as the total decay width of the charged higgs boson in the thdm is given by @xmath429 where @xmath430 are fermion pairs which are kinematically allowed . in the type - ii yukawa couplings , we have @xmath431 in the thdm , the total decay width of the charged higgs boson ( @xmath419 ) for @xmath432 gev is about 470 kev . hence , if the mixing angle @xmath94 is not so small , the decay pattern of @xmath334 is dominated by that of the thdm charged higgs boson @xmath419 . in fig . [ fig : nonmix ] , we plot the branching ratio @xmath433 as a function of @xmath434 at @xmath302 gev for several values of @xmath343 . we only show the case with @xmath435 , where the result is independent of the type of the yukawa interaction . the coupling constant @xmath343 is taken to be @xmath436 and @xmath437 ( @xmath438 ) , which satisfy the phenomenological constraints given in sec . as expected , the branching ratio decreases as @xmath94 increases . when @xmath439 , @xmath433 is smaller than 10% for @xmath440 . for the smaller @xmath343 values , the branching ratio reduces more quickly . the branching ratio is not sensitive to @xmath294 unless the mass exceeds the threshold of the decay into a @xmath441 or @xmath442 pair . above the threshold of the @xmath441 pair production , the decay rate of @xmath443 is large due to the large mass of the top quarks , so that @xmath433 is substantial only for very small values of @xmath94 . finally , while the decay branching ratio can change drastically depending on the mixing angle @xmath94 , the production cross section for @xmath414 remains unchanged . in conclusion , the process @xmath444 can also be useful for testing the zee - model in the non - zero @xmath94 case , provided @xmath434 is not too large . in this paper , the higgs sector of the zee - model has been investigated , in which neutrino masses are generated radiatively . this model contains extra weak - doublet higgs field and singlet charged higgs field . we have studied indirect effects of these extra higgs bosons on the theoretical mass bounds of the lightest cp - even higgs boson , which are obtained from the requirement that the running coupling constants neither blow up to a very large value nor fall down to a negative value , up to a high - energy cut - off scale @xmath3 . for @xmath4 gev , the upper bound of @xmath176 is found to be about @xmath214 gev , which is almost the same value as the sm prediction . in the decoupling regime ( @xmath445 ) , the lower bound is found to be about @xmath446 gev for @xmath4 gev , which is much smaller than the lower bound in the sm , and is almost the same as that in the thdm . for smaller @xmath447 values , the bounds are more relaxed , similar to that of the sm . we have also investigated the allowed range of the coupling constants relevant to the weak - singlet higgs field . the most striking feature of the zee - model higgs sector is the existence of the weak - singlet charged higgs boson . we have examined the possible impact of the singlet charged - higgs boson on the neutral higgs boson search through radiative corrections . we found that its one - loop contributions to the @xmath7 width can be sizable . in the allowed range of the coupling constants the deviation from the sm prediction for this decay width can be about @xmath448% or near @xmath449% for @xmath302 gev and @xmath8 gev , depending on the sign of the coupling constants @xmath203 . the magnitude of the deviation is larger for lower @xmath6 values or for smaller @xmath136 values . for example , a positive deviation over @xmath450-@xmath451% is possible for @xmath452-@xmath14 gev , @xmath453 gev , and @xmath454 gev . in the decoupling limit ( i.e. when @xmath455 , where @xmath456 and @xmath199 ) , we expect that the production cross sections for @xmath457 , @xmath458 and @xmath459 in the zee - model are the same as those in the sm . however , a sizable change in the decay branching ratio of @xmath159 can alter the production rate of @xmath257 at the lhc , where this production rate can be determined with a relative error of 10 - 15%@xcite . also , such a deviation in the branching ratio of @xmath159 directly affects the cross section of @xmath460 , which can be measured with an accuracy of 16 - 22% at the future @xmath15 lc ( with @xmath461 gev and the integrated luminosity of 1 ab@xmath462)@xcite . therefore , the zee - model with low cut - off scales can be tested through the @xmath463 process at the lhc and the @xmath15 lc s . at the future photon colliders , the enhancement ( or reduction ) of the @xmath463 partial decay rate will manifest itself in the different production rate of @xmath0 from the sm prediction . a few per cent of the deviation in @xmath464 can be detected at a photon collider@xcite , so that the effects of the singlet charged higgs boson can be tested even if the cutoff scale @xmath6 is at the planck scale . the collider phenomenology of the singlet charged higgs boson has turned out to be completely different from that of the thdm - like charged higgs boson . the singlet charged higgs boson mainly decays into @xmath465 ( with @xmath466 or @xmath18 ) , while the decay mode @xmath467 is almost negligible due to the relation @xmath468 . this hierarchy among the coupling constants @xmath134 results from demanding bi - maximal mixings in the neutrino mass matrix generated in the zee - model to be consistent with the neutrino oscillation data . on the other hand , the thdm - like charged higgs boson decays mainly into either the @xmath19 mode or the @xmath380 mode , through the usual yukawa - interactions . hence , to probe this singlet charged higgs boson using the lep - ii data , experimentalists should examine their data sample with @xmath469 , @xmath470 , @xmath471 or @xmath403 , while the experimental lower mass bound of the thdm - like charged higgs boson is obtained from examining the @xmath472 , @xmath473 and @xmath474 events . using the published lep - ii constraints on the mssm smuon production ( assuming the lightest neutralinos to be massless ) , we estimate the current lower mass bound of this singlet charged higgs boson to be about 80 - 85 gev . the tevatron run - ii , lhc and future lc s can further test this model . finally , we comment on a case in which the singlet charged higgs boson ( @xmath332 for @xmath330 ) is the lightest of all the higgs bosons . for @xmath475 , the higgs sector of the zee - model can be further tested by measuring the production rate of @xmath476 . the branching ratio for @xmath329 can be large . for instance , for @xmath477 gev and @xmath306 gev , this branching ratio is about 12% for each @xmath478 , @xmath479 , @xmath480 or @xmath401 . the branching ratio decreases for larger masses of @xmath0 . moreover , the total decay width of @xmath0 can be largely modified when the decay channel @xmath481 is open . in this case , the decay branching ratios of @xmath482 , @xmath483 are also different from the sm predictions . in conclusion , the distinguishable features of the zee - model from the sm and the thdm can be tested by the data from lep - ii , the tevatron run - ii and future experiments at lhc and lc s . we are grateful to the warm hospitality of the center for theoretical sciences in taiwan where part of this work was completed . cpy would like to thank h .- j . he , j. ng and w. repko for stimulating discussions . sk was supported , in part , by the alexander von humboldt foundation . gll and jjt were supported , in part , by the national science council of r.o.c . under the grant no nsc-89 - 2112-m-009 - 035 ; yo was supported by the grant - in - aid of the ministry of education , science , sports and culture , government of japan ( no . 09640381 ) , priority area `` supersymmetry and unified theory of elementary particles '' ( no . 707 ) , and `` physics of cp violation '' ( no . 09246105 ) ; cpy is supported by the national science foundation in the usa under the grant phy-9802564 . here , we summarize the relevant rge s to our study . for the gauge coupling constants , we have [ sec : rgelist ] @xmath484 the rge s for the higgs - self - coupling constants of the doublets are calculated at the one - loop level as @xmath485 and those with respect to the additional singlet charged higgs are given by @xmath486 finally , the rge s for the yukawa - type coupling constants are obtained at one - loop level as @xmath487 where @xmath488 s.t . petcov , ; j. liu , ; b.k . pal , ; w. grimus , and g. nardulli , ; a.y . smirnov and z .- j . tao , ; p.h . frampton and s.l . glashow , ; g.c . mclaughlin and j.n . ng , ; a.s . jaurabh and s.d . rindani , ; k. cheung , o.c.w . kong , ; k. cheung , o.c.w . kong , hep - ph/0003276 ; y. koide and a. ghosal , . n. cabibbo , l. maiani , g. parisi and r. petronzio , _ nucl . _ b * 158 * ( 1976 ) 295 ; m. lindner , _ z. phys . _ c * 31 * ( 1986 ) 295 ; g. altarelli and i. ishidori , _ phys . _ b * 337 * ( 1994 ) 141 ; j.a . casas , j.r . espinosa , and m. quirs , _ phys . _ b * 342 * ( 1995 ) 171 ; _ ibid . _ b * 382 * ( 1996 ) 374 ; j.r . espinosa and m. quirs , _ phys . _ b * 353 * ( 1995 ) 257 ; m. quirs , iem - ft-153/97 , in _ perspectives on higgs physics ii , ed . g.l . kane _ , world scientific , singapore ; t. hambye and k. riesselmann , . h. komatsu , ; r.a . flores and m. sher , _ ann . ( ny ) _ * 148 * ( 1983 ) 295 ; m. sher , _ phys . _ * 179 * ( 1989 ) 273 ; d. kominis and r.s . chivukula , ; s. kanemura , t. kubota and e. takasugi , ; s. nie and m. sher , ; a. akeroyd , a. arhrib , e. naimi , . e. boos , j .- c . brient , d.w . reid , h.j . schreiber , and r. schanidze , hep - ph/0011366 ; rick van kooten , talk at the berkeley linear collider meeting in march 2000 ( http://needmore.physics.indiana.edu/~rickv/nlc/talks/berkeley_2000/berkeley_2000.html ) . m. ciuchini , g. degrassi , p. gambini and g.f . giudice , _ nucl . _ b * 527 * ( 1998 ) 21 ; p. ciafaloni , a. romanino and a. strumia , _ nucl . _ b * 524 * ( 1998 ) 361 ; f. borzumati and g. greub , _ phys . _ d * 58 * ( 1998 ) 074004 ; t.m . aliev and e.o . iltan , _ phys . _ d * 58 * ( 1998 ) 095014 . v. drollinger and a. sopczak , hep - ph/0102342 . s. kanemura , t. kasai , g .- lin , y. okada , j.j . tseng , and c .- p . yuan , hep - ph/0010233 . m. dima , talk given at lcws 2000 ( fermilab , october 2000 ) + http://www-lc.fnal.gov/lcws2000/ ; + aleph collaboration , . aleph collaboration , .

to generate small neutrino masses radiatively , the zee - model introduces two higgs doublets and one weak - singlet charged higgs boson to its higgs sector . from analyzing the renormalization group equations , we determine the possible range of the lightest cp - even higgs boson ( @xmath0 ) mass and the higgs boson self - couplings as a function of the cut - off scale beyond which either some of the coupling constants are strong enough to invalidate the perturbative analysis or the stability of the electroweak vacuum is no longer guaranteed . using the results obtained from the above analysis , we find that the singlet charged higgs boson can significantly modify the partial decay width of @xmath1 via radiative corrections , and its collider phenomenology can also be drastically different from that of the charged higgs bosons in the usual two - higgs - doublet models . # 1#2#3#4#1 * # 2 * ( # 4 ) # 3 _ to appear in physical review d _

astro-ph0511302

the detection of stellar orbits @xcite close to sgr a * has proven that the galactic center ( gc ) hosts a massive black hole ( mbh ) with a mass of @xmath1 . sgr a * appears rather dim in all wavelengths , which is explained by accretion flow models @xcite . in the near infrared ( nir ) it was detected after diffraction limited observations at the 8-m class telescopes had become possible @xcite . usually the emission is not detectable . however , every few hours sgr a * flares in the nir , reaching up to @xmath2mag . a first flare spectrum was obtained by @xcite , showing a featureless , red spectrum ( @xmath3 with @xmath4 ) . we observed the gc on 2005 june 18 from 2:40 to 7:15 ut with sinfoni @xcite , an adaptive optics ( ao ) assisted integral field spectrometer which is mounted at the cassegrain focus of eso - vlt yepun ( ut4 ) . the field of view was [email protected] for individual exposures , mapped onto 64@xmath532 spatial pixels . we observed in k - band with a spectral resolution of fwhm @xmath6 nm . the first 12 integrations lasted @xmath7min each . during those we noticed nir activity of sgr a * and we switched to 4 minute exposures . we followed sgr a * for another 32 exposures . in total we interleaved nine integrations on a specifically chosen off field ( 712 w , 406 n of sgr a * ) . the seeing was @xmath80.5 and the optical coherence time @xmath9ms , some short - time deteriorations excluded . the ao was locked on the closest optical guide star ( @xmath10 , 10.8 e , 18.8 n of sgr a * ) , yielding a spatial resolution of @xmath11mas fwhm , close to the diffraction limit of ut4 in k - band ( @xmath12mas ) . our detection triggered immediate follow - up observations with visir , a mid - infrared ( mir ) instrument mounted at eso - vlt melipal ( ut3 ) . from 5:25 ut onwards visir was pointing to the gc . at the position of sgr a * no significant flux was seen . a conservative upper limit of 40@xmath13mjy ( not dereddened ) at 8.59@xmath14 m is reported ( lagage et al . , in prep ) . the reduction of the sinfoni data followed the standard steps : from all source data we subtracted the respective sky frames to correct for instrumental and atmospheric background . we applied flatfielding , bad pixel correction , a search for cosmic ray hits , and a correction for the optical distortions of sinfoni . we calibrated the wavelength dimension with line emission lamps and tuned on the atmospheric oh - lines of the raw frames . finally we assembled the data into cubes with a spatial grid of 12.5@xmath13mas / pix . for all 44 cubes we extracted a collapsed image ( median in spectral dimension ) of a rectangular region ( [email protected] ) centered on sgr a * and containing the three s - stars s2 , s13 , and s17 . we determined the flux of sgr a * from a fit with five gaussians to each of these images . four gaussians with a common width describe the four sources . the fifth gaussian ( with a width @xmath15 wider , typical for the halo from the imperfect ao correction ) accounts for the halo of the brightest star s2 ( @xmath16mag ) . the halos of the weaker sources ( all @xmath17mag ) could be neglected for the flux measurement . we fixed the positions of all sources ( known a - priori from a combined cube ) and the amplitude ratios for the stars . five parameters were left free : an overall amplitude , the background , the width , the flux ratio halo / s2 , and @xmath18 , the flux ratio sgr a*/s2 . this procedure disentangles real variability from variations in the background , the strehl ratio , and the seeing . as a crosscheck we determined @xmath18 in a second way for all images ; for both sgr a * and s2 we measured the flux difference between a signal region centered on source and a reasonable , symmetric background region . the such determined values agreed very well with the fits . for further analysis we used the fitted ratios and included the difference between the two estimates in the errors . the value of the spectral power law index @xmath19 crucially depends on the background subtraction . subtracting too much light would artificially make the signal look redder than it is . hence , a reasonable choice for the background region excludes the nearby sources s2 and s17 . furthermore , the background flux is varying spatially . actually sgr a * lies close to a saddle point in the background light distribution , caused by s2 and s17 ( see fig . [ adb ] ) . in the east - west direction the background has a maximum close to sgr a * and in the north - south direction a minimum . a proper estimate of the background can be achieved in two ways : a ) working with small enough , symmetric apertures , and b ) subtracting from the signal an off state obtained at the position of sgr a * from cubes in which no emission is seen . we used the first method as well as two variants of the second . + * small apertures : * the local background at a position @xmath20 can be estimated by averaging over a small , symmetric region centered on @xmath20 . given the background geometry we have chosen a ring with inner radius @xmath21pix and outer radius @xmath22pix . the circular symmetry was only broken since we explicitely excluded those pixels with a distance to s17 and s2 smaller than 3 and 7 pixels respectively . unfavorable of this method is that the local background is only approximated , since a sufficiently large region has to be declared as signal region . + * off state subtraction : * the local background can be extracted from cubes in which no signal is seen . since the seeing conditions change from cube to cube , one still has to correct for the varying amount of stray light in the signal region . we estimate this variation by measuring the difference spectrum between signal and off cube in a stray light region . the latter must not contain any field stars and should be as far away from the nearby sources as sgr a*. we used two stray light regions to the left and to the right of sgr a * , between 5 and 10 pixels away . the disadvantage of this method is that one needs a suitable off state . the latter point is critical for our data . even though sgr a * has not been detected directly in the first three cubes , the light at its position appears redder than the local background . assuming that this light is due to a very dim , red state of sgr a * , we would subtract too much red light and artificially make the flare too blue . in this sense , this method yields an upper limit for @xmath19 . + * constant subtraction : * the off state method can be varied to obtain a lower limit for @xmath19 . assuming that the true off state spectrum has the color of s2 , one can demand that it is flat after division by s2 . in our data , the s2 divided off state spectrum is rising towards longer wavelengths . hence , in this third method we estimate the background at blue wavelengths and use that constant as background for all spectral bins . we obtained spectra as the median of all pixels inside a disk with radius @xmath21pix centered on source minus the median spectrum of the pixels in the selected off region . in order to correct for the interstellar extinction we then divided by the s2-spectrum ( obtained in the same way as the signal ) . next the temperature of s2 is corrected by multiplying by the value of @xmath23 of a blackbody with @xmath24k . after binning the data into 60 spectral channels it is finally fit with a power law @xmath25 . with this definition , red emission has @xmath26 . the error on @xmath19 is obtained as the square sum of the formal fit error and the standard deviation in a sample of 20 estimates for @xmath19 obtained by varying the on and off region selection . we observed a strong ( flux density up to @xmath27mjy or @xmath28ergs / s ) , long ( more than 3 hours ) flare which showed significant brightness variations on timescales as short as 10 minutes ( fig . [ lightcurve ] , top ) . while the data is not optimal for a periodicity search ( poorer sampling than our previous imaging data ) , it is worth noting that the highest peak in the periodogram ( significance of @xmath29 ) lies at a period of @xmath30min this is also the timescale found by @xcite , who identify the quasi - periodicity with the orbital time close to the last stable orbit ( lso ) of the mbh . we divided the data into three groups : a ) the cubes of the first peak near @xmath31min ( `` preflare '' ) , b ) the cubes at @xmath32min with @xmath33@xmath34 0.25 ( `` dim state '' ) , and c ) the cubes at @xmath32min with @xmath33@xmath35 0.25 ( `` bright state '' ) . for the three sets we created combined cubes in which we determined @xmath19 , using all three background estimates . in all cases we obtained the correct spectral index @xmath36 for s17 ( a star with a spectrum similar to s2 but a flux comparable to sgr a * ) . for sgr a * we get : + [ cols=">,^,^,^",options="header " , ] + the values obtained from the small apertures lie between the values from the other two methods , consistent with the idea that they yield upper and lower limits . the absolute values vary systematically according to the chosen background method . however , independent from that , it is clear that the preflare is redder than the dim state which in turn is redder than the bright state . an obvious question then is whether flux and @xmath19 are directly correlated . hence , we applied the spectral analysis to the individual cubes . we kept the data in which sgr a * is detected , the error @xmath37 and the spectral index for s17 does not deviate more than @xmath38 from the expected value . the resulting spectral indices appear to be correlated with the flux ( fig . [ lightcurve ] , [ corr ] ) . the values match the results in @xcite and @xcite . bright flares are indeed bluer than weak flares , as suspected by @xcite and consistent with the earlier multi - band observations of @xcite . our key new result is that this even holds within a single event . for all three background methods it is clear that the main event was preceded by a weak , red event . for the small apertures and the constant subtraction method instantaneous flux and spectral index are correlated . for the off state subtraction method one could instead group the data into a preflare at the beginning and a bluer , brighter main event . we checked our data for contamination effects . if stray light would affect the flare signal , @xmath19 should be correlated with the seeing ( measured by the width from the multiple fits ) . since we did not find such a correlation , we exclude significant contamination . theoretical models predict that the mm - ir emission from sgr a * is synchrotron emission from relativistic electrons close to the lso @xcite . radiatively inefficient accretion flow ( riaf ) models with a thermal electron population ( @xmath39k ) produce the observed peak in the submm but fail to produce enough flux at 2@xmath14 m . the nir emission requires transiently heated or accelerated electrons as proposed by @xcite . a conservative interpretation of our data is suggested by fig . [ corr ] , middle . there was a weak , red event before and possibly independent from the main flare which was a much bluer event . plausibly the preflare is then due to the high - energetic tail of the submm peak @xcite . the main flare requires nevertheless a population of heated electrons . a more progressive interpretation follows from the correlation between flux and @xmath19 ( fig . [ corr ] , left & right ) . it suggests that the nir variability is caused by the combination of transient heating with subsequent cooling and orbital dynamics of relativistic electrons . in the following subsections we will exploit this idea . in the absence of continued energy injection , synchrotron cooling will suppress the high energy part of the electron distribution function . this results in a strong cutoff in the nir spectrum with a cutoff frequency decreasing with time . at a fixed band one expects that the light becomes redder as the flux decreases . this can cause the correlation between flux and @xmath19 . the observed flare apparently needs several heating and cooling events . the synchrotron cooling time is comparable to the observed timescale of decaying flanks as in fig . [ lightcurve ] ( top ) or @xcite . in a riaf model @xcite the magnetic field @xmath40 is related to the accretion rate @xmath41 . for disk models with @xmath42yr @xcite one has @xmath43 g at a radial distance of @xmath44 ( schwarzschild radii ) . the cooling time for electrons emitting at @xmath45 m for @xmath46 g is @xmath47 this is similar to the orbital timescale , making it difficult to disentangle flux variations due to heating and cooling from dynamical effects due to the orbital motion . the timescale of @xmath0 minutes for the observed variations suggests orbital motion close to the lso as one possible cause . any radiation produced propagates through strongly curved space - time . beaming , multiple images , and doppler shifts have to be considered @xcite . recent progress has been made in simulating these effects when observing a spatially limited emission region orbiting the mbh @xcite . that the emission region is small compared to the accretion disk can be deduced from x - ray observations . @xcite report similar timescales for x - ray- and ir - flares . this excludes that the x - ray emission is synchrotron light as one would expect cooling times @xmath48min ( eq . [ cool ] ) . the x - ray emission is naturally explained by ic scattering of the transiently heated electrons that have a @xmath49-factor of @xmath50 . the ic process scatters the seed photon field up according to @xmath51 . given @xmath52hz for x - rays the seed photon frequency is @xmath53hz - the submm regime . the x - ray intensity for the synchrotron - self - compton case is given by @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the seed photon field luminosity in units of @xmath56ergs / s and @xmath57 the radius of the emission region . the highest value of @xmath55 compatible with the mir- and submm - data is reached for a flat spectrum ( @xmath58 ) of the heated electrons . thus , @xmath59 . via equation ( [ l37 ] ) we have @xmath60 . from the observed ratios @xmath61 $ ] we derive @xmath62 . that means , the emission region has to be a small spot . a plausible dynamical model is discussed in paumard et al . ( in prep ) . it reproduces typical lightcurves as observed by @xcite or in fig . [ lightcurve ] . due to the doppler effect the observed light corresponds to different rest frame frequencies depending on the orbital phase . if the source spectrum is curved , flux and spectral index appear correlated . following this interpretation , the emission during the brightest part originates from a rest - frequency with larger @xmath19 than the dimmer state emitted at shorter wavelengths . such a concavely curved spectrum is naturally expected from the synchrotron models . agol , e. 2000 , , 538 , l121 bonnet , h. et al . 2004 , eso messenger , 117 , 17 broderick , a. & loeb , a. 2005 , mnras , 363 , 353 broderick , a. & loeb , a. , , 636 , l109 broderick , a. & loeb , a. , mnras , submitted ( astro - ph/0509237 ) eckart , a. et al . 2004 , a&a , 427 , 1 eckart , a. et al . , a&a , in press ( astro - ph/0512440 ) eisenhauer , f. et al . 2003 , proc . spie , 4841 , 1548 eisenhauer , f. et al . 2005 , , 628 , 246 genzel , r. et al . 2003 , nature , 425 , 934 ghez , a. et al . 2003 , , 586 , l127 ghez , a. et al . 2004 , , 601 , l159 ghez , a. , salim , s. , hornstein , s. , tanner , a. , lu , j. , morris , m. & becklin , e. 2005 , , 620 , 744 ghez , a. et al . 2005 , , 635 , in press hollywood , j. & melia , f. 1997 , apjs , 112 , 423 hollywood , j. , melia , f. , close , l. , mccarthy , d. , dekeyser , t. 1999 , , 448 , liu , s. & melia , f. 2001 , , 561 , l77 liu , s. , petrosian , v. & melia , f. 2004 , , 611 , l101 liu , s. , melia , f. & petrosian , v. 2006 , , 636 , l798 markoff , s. , falcke , h. , yuan , f. & biermann , p. 2001 , a&a , 379 , l13 melia , f. , liu , s. & coker , r. 2000 , apj , 545 , l117 melia , f. , liu , s. & coker , r. 2001 , apj , 553 , 146 narayan , r. , yi , i. , & mahadevan , r. 1995 , , 374 , 623 paumard , t. et al . 2005 , an , 326 , 568 quataert , e. & narayan , r. 1999 , , 520 , 298 quataert , e. & gruzinov , a. 2000 , , 539 , 809 quataert , e. 2003 , ans , 324 , 435 schdel , r. et al . 2002 , nature , 419 , 694 yuan , f. , quataert , e. & narayan , r. 2003 , 598 , 301

we have observed a bright flare of sgr a * in the near infrared with the adaptive optics assisted integral field spectrometer sinfoni . within the uncertainties , the observed spectrum is featureless and can be described by a power law . our data suggest that the spectral index is correlated with the instantaneous flux and that both quantities experience significant changes within less than one hour . we argue that the near infrared flares from sgr a * are due to synchrotron emission of transiently heated electrons , the emission being affected by orbital dynamics and synchrotron cooling , both acting on timescales of @xmath0 minutes .

nucl-th0110010

recently @xcite a semiempirical shell model mass equation ( ssme ) based on proton magic number z = 126 @xcite was shown to have a high predictive power in the interior of major shell regions beyond lead n @xmath1 and with 126 @xmath2 n @xmath2 184 . we refer to them respectively as region a and region b , like in refs . [ 1,2 ] . ] . the equation has been proposed as a substitute inside the above regions for the previous ssme @xcite which is based on z = 114 as the highest proton magic number and it stops there . tabulated masses with separation and decay energies for both regions are available @xcite . in the present work the predicted masses ( eq . ( 1 ) of ref . @xcite , referred to as eq . ( 1 ) in the sequel , and table b of ref . @xcite ) are applied to the results of recent superheavy elements ( she ) experiments . we first address the smoothness of the predictions and their overall agreement with @xmath3 systematics . then we test the agreement of the equation with the data observed in several recent fusion - evaporation she experiments where the produced nuclei are identified by their decay ties to known daughter isotopes . finally we address the interpretation problem in some recent hot fusion experiments where the observed decay chains do not connect the parent to a known daughter , and several reaction channels are in principle possible . inside a shell region the mass surface predicted by eq . ( 1 ) is smoother than the empirical surface and does not account for fine structure effects . this is illustrated in fig . 1 showing q@xmath4 systematics for the heaviest n @xmath5 140 even - z nuclei from pu through z = 110 @xcite . respective full and empty circles denote experimental values and values estimated from systematics . the small circles connected by thin lines show the predictions of eq . ( 1 ) . as a rule both the experimental and the predicted isotopic lines show similar negative trends when n increases , and they shift upwards rather uniformly when z increases . for the experimental lines , though , this regular pattern breaks down for nuclei in the vicinity of the deformed doubly submagic nucleus ( n@xmath6 , z@xmath6 ) @xmath7fm ( n@xmath6 = 152 , z@xmath6 = 100 ) , and presumably even more so near @xmath8hs ( n@xmath6 = 162 , z@xmath6 = 108 ) @xcite ( see also fig . 5 . ) . in these neighborhoods the trend of isotopic lines between n = n@xmath6 and n = n@xmath6 + 2 is positive , and the vertical distance between isotopic lines with z = z@xmath6 and z = z@xmath6 + 2 for n @xmath9 n@xmath6 is larger than for other z values . none of these submagic number effects is shown by the predicted thin lines systematics . ( see also refs . @xcite . ) in the ssme non - smooth abrupt local changes , which are associated with subshell and deformation effects , are assumed to have been smoothed out by configuration interaction ( eq . ( 4 ) of ref . @xcite ) , and the mass equation describes a smooth surface representing their average . the deviations from the average are mostly small , though , resulting in the above mentioned overall high - quality predictive power . for the 57 experimental @xmath3 values measured in region b after the equation was adjusted @xcite the respective average deviation @xmath10 and rms deviation @xmath11 of the predicted values from the data are @xmath128 and 220 kev ( table ii of ref . ( for all the 115 data points shown in fig . 1 , both experimental and estimated from systematics , the corresponding values are @xmath1233 and 214 kev . ) we now address the agreement of the equation with @xmath0-decay energies observed in the cold fusion production experiments of elements 107 - 112 @xcite ( see also refs . @xcite and @xcite ) . figs . 2 - 5 show the measured and the predicted @xmath3 values , assuming that the decays go through or near the g.s . fig . 5 shows as well the @xmath3 values observed in hot fusion experiments producing @xmath13sg @xcite and @xmath14bh @xcite , where in refs . @xcite and @xcite the @xmath0-chains were studied after chemical separation of the recoiling evaporation residue ( evr ) parent , leading to chemical identification . the figures show as well the @xmath15 and @xmath16 values for the plotted data points . on the whole they are not large , with @xmath16 values compatible with the above quoted 220 kev value from table ii of ref . the respective overall @xmath15 and @xmath16 values for all the 32 data points in figs . 2 - 5 are 86 and 337 kev . the largest individual deviations occur for z = 107 , 108 and 110 in fig . 5 , with respective values of 659 , 712 and @xmath12605 kev . these seem to be too large for the above quoted value of 220 kev , and they correspond to a kink observed in the @xmath17112 @xmath3 chain at z = 108 . if this kink is a genuine submagic number effect due to the crossing of n = 162 on the way from z = 108 to z = 110 @xcite , then fig . 5 illustrates the oversmoothness of the predicted masses as compared to the empirical data with its discontinuities in the vicinity of doubly submagic nuclei . ( see sect . the pertinent submagic numbers in the present case are n@xmath6 = 162 and z@xmath6 = 108 . closer scrutiny of figs . 1 and 5 reveals stronger magicity of @xmath8hs as compared to @xmath7fm . in hot fusion - evaporation she experiments , when the compound nucleus ( cn ) is produced at a sufficiently high excitation energy ( e@xmath18 ) , there are often several conceivable open emission channels for forming the parent , which would lead to different observable @xmath0-decay chains . when the @xmath0-decay chain starting from the evr parent nucleus does not connect to a known daughter isotope , comparing different predictions to the observed data might facilitate the choice between different conceivable interpretations . we consider from this point of view some recent she experiments @xcite . in refs . @xcite a @xmath19 cm target was bombarded by 240 mev @xmath20ca ions . three observed three - members @xmath0-decay chains are assigned to the nuclide @xmath21116 and its sequential decay down to @xmath22110 . the cn formed in the reaction is @xmath23116 at e@xmath24 27 mev obtained from the cm and ca masses @xcite and the predicted mass of the cn @xcite . at this higher energy more channels for particle emission might be open than in the cold fusion experiments considered in sect . iii , including up to @xmath25 and also @xmath26 or @xmath0 emission . four conceivable evr parents in addition to the assigned parent @xmath21116 are considered in table i. their corresponding formation channels , the estimated values of their excitation energies ( e@xmath27 ) in tables i and ii are obtained from the kinematics of the reactions assuming that the evaporated neutrons have zero kinetic energy and the evaporated charged particles ( @xmath26 and @xmath0 ) have a kinetic energy which is equal to their potential energy at the top of the coulomb barrier . higher kinetic energies of the evaporated particles would reduce the estimates given in the tables . this is the case for the @xmath28 channels , with an average c.m . neutron kinetic energy of about 1 mev per neutron @xcite . ] when formed , and the deviations @xmath15 and @xmath16 from the data of the corresponding predicted @xmath3 values , assuming that the @xmath0-decays go through or near the g.s . , are given in the table . for the @xmath29 formation channel assigned by the authors the estimated e@xmath27 value of the parent nucleus @xmath30 is too low ( less than 2 mev ) to have a reasonable production cross section . moreover , the 758 kev @xmath16 value of the predicted @xmath3 values is too large . on the other hand , for the @xmath31 channel leading to the evr parent @xmath32 the corresponding estimated e@xmath27 value and the value of @xmath16 are @xmath214 mev and 466 kev which are reasonable . this might lend support to a scenario based on the @xmath31 ( and possibly also @xmath25 ) channel . the last two members of the @xmath0-decay chains seen in this experiment agree with the two - members @xmath0-decay chains observed before in a z = 114 experiment @xcite . if they are the same , a formation of the present z = 116 parent by @xmath31 ( or @xmath25 ) emission would imply the same formation channel for the z = 114 evr parent in ref . @xcite , rather than the assigned @xmath29 channel . 6 compares the experimental @xmath3 values with the predictions of eq . ( 1 ) for assumed @xmath31 , @xmath25 and @xmath29 evaporation channels . the improvement when going from @xmath29 to @xmath31 is clear . as a second example we consider the experiment reported in ref . a @xmath33pu target was bombarded by 236 mev @xmath20ca ions . an observed three - members @xmath0-decay chain is considered a good candidate for originating from the parent @xmath34114 and its sequential decay down to @xmath17hs ( z = 108 ) . for the @xmath25 formation channel assigned by the authors , leading to the evr parent @xmath35 , the respective estimated e@xmath27 value and the @xmath16 value are @xmath29 mev and 905 kev . the @xmath16 value is too large . if the assignment of the authors is confirmed this might indicate that the decay chain does not proceed through levels in the vicinity of the g.s . on the other hand , for the @xmath26 or @xmath0 channels , leading to the respective evr parents @xmath36113 or @xmath37112 , the respective e@xmath27 and @xmath16 values are 8 or 9 mev and 414 or 363 kev . this might lend some support to scenarios based on the @xmath26 or @xmath0 evaporation channels . 7 compares the experimental @xmath3 values with the predictions of eq . ( 1 ) for assumed @xmath38 and @xmath0 evaporation channels . the advantage of the @xmath26 or @xmath0 assignments over @xmath25 and @xmath31 is obvious . .conceivable evr parents of the @xmath0-decay chain [ 25,27 ] with their formation channels , their estimated values of e@xmath27 , and the deviations @xmath15 and @xmath16 from the data of the corresponding predicted @xmath3 values . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ]

a recently published highly extrapolatable semiempirical shell model mass equation is shown to describe rather well the energies of several seemingly well identified @xmath0-decay chains with known end product nuclei observed in superheavy elements research . the equation is also applied to the interpretation problem of some recent hot fusion - evaporation experiments with unknown end products and several conceivable reaction channels . some plausible interpretations are indicated . _ the racah institute of physics , the hebrew university of jerusalem , _ _ jerusalem 91904 , israel _ pacs numbers : 21.10.dr , 21.60.cs , 27.90.+b

0901.4601

one of the most active topics in current electromagnetics research is the study of artificial structures where permittivity @xmath0 and permeability @xmath1 are engineered . this allows them to have values not available in natural materials , or which can not normally be obtained at the desired operating frequency . a particularly interesting example is materials having a permittivity of zero at some frequency @xcite . in such structures the wavelength becomes infinite , and wave propagation over distances much larger than the free space wavelength can be treated as quasi - static . since this qualitative behavior is still observable even when the complex permittivity is close to but not identically zero , the term epsilon - near - zero ( enz ) has been coined to describe it . as one interesting application of enz materials , it has been shown theoretically that a narrow enz channel would support complete transmission of a signal incident from a larger waveguide @xcite , despite the large geometric mismatch . this was subsequently demonstrated experimentally in systems where the enz response was engineered via a surface pattern @xcite , and also using the natural dispersion characteristics of a rectangular waveguide near its cut - off frequency without the use of any composite structure @xcite . using the cut - off waveguide approach , it is straightforward to tailor the center - frequency and bandwidth of this transmission effect by modifying the geometry of the waveguide . it has also been shown that the enz tunneling frequency is sensitive to a dielectric cavity included within the waveguide , thus it can be used for sensing @xcite . this paper aims to demonstrate experimentally that the tunneling effect can be dynamically controlled by placing a tuning element within the waveguide . this allows for efficient control of the enz transmission , with potential applications in tunable slow - light structures . we also demonstrate that the introduction of nonlinearity into the system allows the enz resonance to be controlled by the incident wave itself . the structure under consideration is presented in fig . [ fig : structure](a ) , where rectangular waveguides of width @xmath2 and height @xmath3 feed a signal through a narrow section of width @xmath2 , height @xmath4 , and length @xmath5 , which exhibits the enz property at microwave frequencies . since the enz tunneling occurs at the cut - off frequency of the fundamental te@xmath6 mode of the narrow section , the feeding sections of waveguide are made from a material with a higher dielectric constant to ensure that their te@xmath6 mode is propagating . in refs . an equivalent circuit model was given for the structure , with the feeding waveguides , enz channel and dielectric cavity represented by sections of transmission line , as shown in fig . [ fig : structure](b ) . the reactances at the transition due to the excitation of evanescent higher - order modes @xcite have previously been shown to have a negligible effect on the enz tunneling . equation was then derived as the condition for full transmission of an enz system including a cavity with a different dielectric constant from the rest of the enz channel : @xmath7 here @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 and @xmath12 represent the impedance and wavenumber of each section and @xmath13 . the subscript @xmath14 refers to the enz channel , and @xmath15 to the dielectric cavity within it , and all relevant dimensions are given in fig . [ fig : structure](a ) . equation has one solution associated with enz tunneling , and an infinite number of solutions corresponding to the fabry - perot resonances along the channel . it can be used to show how the enz transmission frequency will change due to a change in dielectric constant of the cavity , which could potentially include the whole length of the enz section . this could be used in a sensing configuration where the cavity is filled with some material of unknown dielectric constant , or alternatively for tuning if the dielectric constant can be controlled externally . at microwave frequencies , tuning is much more readily achieved using lumped nonlinear components , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : lumped_structure](a ) . this can be regarded as a limiting case of a dielectric inclusion of small cross - section , however it is much more convenient to include the lumped elements into the equivalent circuit model , as shown in fig . [ fig : lumped_structure](b ) we are most interested in capacitive lumped inclusions , however the insertion of a narrow conducting element between the top and bottom of the waveguide will also result in some additional inductance in the equivalent circuit model @xcite , due to the excitation of higher - order evanescent modes . thus we consider here a series inductance @xmath16 and capacitance @xmath17 with a shunt connection between the transmission line section , noting that the values in the equivalent circuit model also include the effect of parasitics and the excitation of higher - order modes . the resultant expression for complete transmission is : @xmath18 this also has solutions for the enz and fabry - perot resonances , and generalizes the dielectric sensing and tunability of this structure to include lumped elements . thus the study of lumped nonlinear inclusions can yield much insight into the broader behavior of nonlinear enz systems . it should be noted that the impedance @xmath11 of a waveguide mode is not uniquely defined @xcite , however for consistency with the circuit model of fig . [ fig : lumped_structure ] we are required to use the following definition : @xmath19 we have confirmed numerically that the introduction of a lumped linear capacitance can be used to tune the frequency of the enz response . figure [ fig : tuning_ideal ] shows the transmission response with @xmath20nh as @xmath17 is varied , calculated using our equivalent circuit model . ] it can be seen that the maximum magnitude of the transmission is not changed , but the resonant frequencies are shifted and the quality factor is increased by the additional capacitance . the electric field within the channel at the enz transmission frequency was analyzed in the commercial electromagnetics solver cst microwave studio @xcite for a channel loaded with a 4pf capacitor . it was found that a phase variation of only 4@xmath21 occurred over the length of the channel , which is one third of the free space wavelength . the complete transmission and low phase variation confirm that the essential features of the enz coupling have been maintained . to confirm the tunability , we use an experimental configuration and parameter retrieval procedure similar to that described in ref . , with @xmath22 mm , @xmath23 mm and @xmath24 mm . the input and output waveguides consist of ptfe ( teflon ) beams covered in conductive tape , fed by a coaxial connector attached to a probe . smaller probes are placed within these waveguides to measure the amplitudes of the modes propagating inside the waveguide and to find the transmission and reflection parameters of the enz channel . the transmission through the system is measured at 1601 frequency points using a network analyzer , and by measuring the amplitude and phase of all the incident and reflected waves within the feeding waveguides , we are able to solve for the scattering parameters of the enz channel . the enz channel itself is fabricated from brass sheet and blocks . to introduce a tunable capacitance , we use an smv1231 varactor diode , with capacitance tunable between 0.45 - 2.35pf . this is soldered to a small piece of circuit - board introduced into the enz channel . as shown in fig . [ fig : lumped_structure](a ) there is a direct electrical connection at one end and a small inductor - capacitor network at the other to allow dc biasing whilst still maintaining a low impedance rf connection to the channel wall . figure [ fig : tuning_narrow](a ) shows the measured transmission as a result of tuning the dc voltage and hence the diode capacitance . the observed frequency shift is similar to that predicted by the equivalent circuit model , as shown in fig . [ fig : tuning_ideal ] , although there is as a reduction in the transmission amplitude and quality factor for higher capacitance values . the discrepancy is due to the parasitic capacitance , inductance and resistance of the diode , the inductance due to the interruption in the waveguide , as well as the influence of the circuit board and biasing components . however , it is clearly shown that high transmission can still be achieved for a substantial tuning range , and that for quite reasonable values of voltage the enz resonance can effectively be switched on and off by the control signal . ] the numerical results obtained from cst microwave studio are shown in fig . [ fig : tuning_narrow](b ) for comparison , corresponding to the diode capacitance for each voltage in fig . [ fig : tuning_narrow](a ) . by adding a parasitic inductance of 3.5nh and a parasitic capacitance of 0.1pf due to the circuit board and biasing circuit , we are able to achieve reasonable agreement with experiments . we note that exact agreement is difficult due to the high sensitivity of the channel resonance to small variations in component values and to minor geometrical imperfections . ] the equivalent circuit results presented in ref . show that the sensitivity of the channel to the dielectric change is independent of the height of the enz waveguide section . defined in eq . scales as @xmath25 . we see that the right hand side of the equation remains constant , since @xmath26 and @xmath27 scale proportionally and inversely with @xmath4 respectively . in the fraction on the right hand side , the terms @xmath28 and @xmath29 both scale as @xmath30 , thus it also remains unchanged . in practice there would be a small frequency change due to the shunt susceptance at the discontinuities which we neglect here . ] in contrast , the sensitivity to a lumped capacitance is strongly dependent on the height of the waveguide , since this modifies @xmath27 , but has only a small effect on @xmath16 and @xmath17 due to evanescent higher - order modes . to demonstrate this effect we have repeated the experimental and numerical results with a another channel , as shown in fig . [ fig : tuning_wide ] . it can be seen that the increase in the channel height improves the tunability of the structure . to achieve agreement with experimental results , the parasitic inductance was changed to 2.6nh , to reflect the necessarily different dimensions of the biasing structure in this experimental configuration . ] as this structure is strongly resonant and exhibits a high phase velocity , it is clear that it should have a correspondingly low group velocity . since the enz tunneling theory is also applicable in plasmonic systems @xcite , a nonlinear enz channel coupled to external waveguides could be used as a tunable slow - light structure . in order to demonstrate this effect and to analyze the response of this system to a signal with finite bandwidth , we have calculated the group delay from the experimentally measured transmission . the effective group index , calculated as @xmath31 , is shown in fig . [ fig : tuning_delay ] . it should be noted that this quantity is calculated for the finite structure rather than an infinite enz channel , as discussed in ref . . the effective group index can reach 25 for the measured structures , and the maximum delay corresponds to the transmission peak as expected . to put these results in context , we consider the frequency variation of the imaginary part of the input impedance of the system , which closely corresponds to the group delay . at the frequency of enz tunneling with no tuning elements , it can be evaluated in closed form as : @xmath32 where the effective wavenumber @xmath33 is given by : @xmath34 and @xmath35 and @xmath36 are the dielectric constants of the media filling the output and enz channels , respectively . this suggests that to first order reducing the height @xmath4 of the enz section will increase the delay proportionally . this is confirmed by the results in fig . [ fig : tuning_delay ] for the structures without a diode , however the additional losses introduced in the tuned structures complicate the picture somewhat . ] external control of enz tunneling has a great deal of potential to increase the flexibility and utility of the phenomenon . an even more exciting prospect is that the impinging field can self - modulate the enz response . a narrow channel containing a nonlinear dielectric material will show an enhanced nonlinear response due to the strong field confinement . the phase uniformity of the transmission offers interesting opportunities for multi - frequency nonlinear processes such as harmonic generation and parametric amplification . since phase matching conditions are highly critical to the efficiency of these processes , the essentially quasi - static nature of the fields at the enz frequency should be of great benefit for the required dispersion engineering . here we show that a nonlinear inclusion made from a pair of oppositely oriented diodes in series exhibits a self - modulation property , and thus serves as a proof - of - concept for nonlinear enz tunneling . the principle is equally applicable if the material parameters are based on those of resonant metamaterial composites , with many authors showing that their electric or magnetic resonant frequency can be controlled by an external or incident field ( e.g. refs . ) . figure [ fig : self_tuning ] shows the results of this self - tuning effect . increasing the incident power has the effect of reducing the effective capacitance of the diode and hence bringing transmission closer to the situation without the diode , consistent with the application of a higher dc bias . it is also clear that we achieve a lower level of tuning in the narrow channel . again this is consistent with the dc tuning results , however it is difficult to quantify this effect . this is due to our feed structure which does not provide uniform coupling to the waveguide over the whole frequency band , hence the incident power on the enz section has strong variation with frequency . we have demonstrated experimentally that the epsilon - near - zero tunneling effect can be dynamically controlled by introducing a lumped nonlinear element . this allows the frequency of enz tunneling to be tuned or suppressed by an external signal , which generalizes previous results showing the sensitivity of the phenomenon to a dielectric change within the cavity . in addition , the nonlinearity of the inclusion allows the response to be modulated by an impinging wave , which combined with the low phase delay across the structure should allow the observation of many interesting nonlinear effects . dp thanks prof n. engheta and his group for their warm hospitality during his visit to the university of pennsylvania . dp and yk acknowledge support from the australian national university and the australian research council .

the epsilon - near - zero ( enz ) tunneling phenomenon allows full transmission of waves through a narrow channel even in the presence of a strong geometric mismatch . here we experimentally demonstrate nonlinear control of the enz tunneling by an external field , as well as self - modulation of the transmission resonance due to the incident wave . using a waveguide section near cut - off frequency as the enz system , we introduce a diode with tunable and nonlinear capacitance to demonstrate both of these effects . our results confirm earlier theoretical ideas on using an enz channel for dielectric sensing , and their potential applications for tunable slow - light structures .

0802.4442

one of the key questions in the field of nanoelectromechanical systems ( nems ) @xcite is the effect of mechanical motion on the electric properties of the systems . it is equally important for undestanding of fundamental questions such as behavior of non - equilibrium , dissipative , driven systems and for the prospects of nems practical applications , such as switches , relays , and actuators . electron motion in both external ac electromagnetic fields ( see _ e.g. _ ref . @xcite ) and subject to time - dependent noise @xcite have been extensively studied in the past . the new feature brought by nems is that not only electrons move in the field created by the mechanical vibrations ( for brevity , phonons ) , but also the phonons are created by the electron motion through the nems device . the phonons are generally driven out of equlibrium thus creating the feedback for the electron motion . in this article , we concentrate on nems operating in the single electron tunneling ( set ) regime . these include experimental realizations based on single molecules @xcite , semiconductor beams @xcite , and suspended carbon nanotubes @xcite . in set regime a nems can be represented as a set device coupled to a mechanical ( harmonic ) oscillator . the coupling is provided by a force ( typically of electrostatic origin , see _ e.g. _ ref . @xcite ) acting on the oscillator . the value of the force depends on the charge state of the set device , providing the feedback . this feedback can be strong even if the electron - phonon coupling is weak : indeed , if one consideres an set next to the coulomb blockade threshold , only two charge states , say , @xmath0 and @xmath1 , with @xmath2 being the number of electrons at set , are important . the occupation of set above the coulomb blockade threshold fluctuates between zero and one , providing a force which is a random telegraph signal . the signal swings an underdamped oscillator to large amplitudes , which in their turn affect the transport properties of the set device by modifying the tunnel matrix elements and the energy difference between the two charge states . the transport properties of nems devices depend on a number of parameters . one is the coupling strength @xmath3 , defined as the square of the ratio of the displacement of the oscillator center under the action of the force at the amplitude of the zero - point motion , @xmath4 , where @xmath5 and @xmath6 are the mass and the frequency of the oscillator , and @xmath7 is the difference of the forces acting on the oscillator in the charge states @xmath1 and @xmath8 . in is important that the planck constant is in the denominator , and thus strong coupling actually means quantum regime . other parameters determining the behavior are given by ratios of various energy scales characterizing the nems device . the most relevant one is the ratio between the typical tunnel rate @xmath9 and the oscillator frequency @xmath6 . surprisingly , the strong - coupling ( quantum regime ) is more extensively studied in the literature . assuming the oscillator is underdamped , for @xmath10 and @xmath11 , the behavior of the system is dominated by franck - condon physics . the tunnel rates are modified due to emission of phonons in the course of electron tunneling @xcite . for the coupling to a single mode , this leads to the steps in the current as the function of the applied bias voltage , the height of the step is determined by the coupling constant @xcite . for @xmath12 the electron level width becomes bigger than the distance between the steps , and franck - condon structure disappears . however , in this regime the motion of the oscillator is much slower than the electron tunneling , and one can use born - oppenheimer approximation , considering electrons in the quasi - stationary field potential provided by the oscillator . in this situation , the oscillator may become bistable , and the electron tunneling is dominated by switching events between the two states of the oscillator @xcite . all these phenomena are the manifestation of strong mechanical feedback . similar effects have been studied in ref . @xcite in the context of superconducting nems . it is less obvious that strong feedback is also possible at weak coupling @xmath13 . this is the classical regime , where boltzmann equation serves as the starting point @xcite . ref . @xcite studied the low - frequency case @xmath12 . the oscillator motion in this case is described by fokker - planck equation with effective diffusion and effective damping ( originating from the electron tunneling out of the set device ) , both determined by the energy dependence of the tunnel rates . it turns out that the strong feedback regime is feasible , but the behavior of the current strongly depends on the energy dependence of the tunnel rates . for instance , in the two most commonly investigated cases electron tunneling through a single level and electron tunneling through a continuum of levels with the constant density , like in a single electron transistor , the strong feedback does not appear . four distinct regimes have been identified : ( i ) no phonons generated ; ( ii ) the oscillations are generated with the fixed finite amplitude ; ( iii ) the oscillator is bistable , one state has the oscillations with zero amplitude , and another one the oscillations with a finite amplitude ; ( iv ) the system is bistable , with the two states representing the oscillations with two different amplitudes . in the regimes ( ii ) , ( iii ) , and ( iv ) current is strongly modified with respect to the case when the phonons are not generated . a quantity even more sensitive to the oscillations is the current noise . the natural measure of the current noise in set devices is poisson value of the zero - frequency spectral density @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 being the average current @xcite . it turns out that the noise is strongly enhanced avove the poisson value in the regimes ( ii ) , ( iii ) , and ( iv ) , and may even become super - poissonian in the regime ( i ) , when the current is not renormalized . in this article , we consider the only regime not addressed so far : weak coupling @xmath13 and high frequency @xmath11 . we show that it shares many features with the low - frequency classical regime described above . even though we have not been able to identify any bistable regimes , we still find the two regimes of zero and finite amplitude , the latter demonstrating strong mechanical feedback . we find that the noise , in contrast to the low - frequency case , is always sub - poissonian . at weak coupling , the motion of the oscillator is classical , and the behavior of the system is characterized by the joint distribution function , @xmath17 . here , @xmath2 is the charge state of the set . we assume that the set is biased close to the edge of one of the coulomb diamonds , so that only two charge states are important for transport , for definiteness @xmath8 and @xmath1 . furthermore , @xmath18 and @xmath19 are the coordinate and the velocity of the oscillator . the starting point of our classical approach is the boltzmann ( master ) equation for the distribution function @xcite , @xmath20 = 0 ; \\ \cal{f}&= & - m { \omega}^2 x - \frac{m { \omega}v}{q}+ f_n \ ; ; \label{force}\\ \mbox{st}\ [ p ] & = & ( 2n-1 ) \left ( \gamma^{+}(x ) p_0 - \gamma^{-}(x ) p_1 \right ) \ , \label{rates2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which holds for an arbitrary relation between @xmath6 and @xmath9 . here , the total force @xmath21 acting on the oscillator is the sum of the elastic force , friction force , and charge - dependent coupling force , respective to the order of terms in eq . ( [ force ] ) , @xmath22 is the quality factor . we count the position of the oscillator from its equilibrium position in the @xmath8 state . in this case , the `` collision integral '' @xmath24 $ ] in the right - hand side represents single electron tunneling . there are four tunnel rates , @xmath25 , where the subscripts @xmath26 and @xmath27 denote tunneling through the left or right junction , and the superscripts @xmath28 and @xmath29 correspond to the tunneling to and from the island , respectively ; @xmath30 . each rate is a function of the corresponding energy cost @xmath31 associated with the addition / removal of an electron to / from the island in the state @xmath32 via left or right junction ( @xmath33 ) . two independent energy differences are determined by electrostatics and depend linearly on the voltages . there is also a contribution to each energy from the shift of the oscillator , @xmath34 , @xmath35 , where @xmath36 are the corresponding energy differences in the absence of mechanical motion . the condition @xmath37 means that the motion of the oscillator is very slow compared with the typical time an electron spends in the set device . in this situation , the probabilities @xmath38 and @xmath39 average over the fast osicllator motion . in the leading order , if we parameterize @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 , these probabilities do not depend on @xmath43 . consequently , we expand the probabilities in the following way , @xmath44 with @xmath45 . here and below we disregard the terms proportional to @xmath46 , @xmath47 , with @xmath48 . this procedure is similar to the transformation of boltzmann equation into the diffusion equation in the semi - classical theory of electron transport in metals . we can obtain a closed set of equations for @xmath49 by multiplying eq . ( [ mastereq ] ) with @xmath50 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 and subsequently averaging over the phase , throwing out @xmath53 and @xmath54 terms . it is important that the tunnel rates only depend on the coordinate and not of velocity of the oscillator , and thus are functions of @xmath55 and not @xmath56 . after some algebra , we obtain @xmath57 , @xmath58 where the angluar brackets denote averaging over the phase @xmath43 , and the function @xmath59 obeys the equation @xmath60 and we have disregared the mechanical damping @xmath61 . the stationary solution of eq . ( [ mastereq1 ] ) is easily found as @xmath62 note that , similarly to the low - frequency case @xmath63 , the distribution ( [ stationary ] ) is very sharp . indeed , the typical energy @xmath64 is of the order of the applied voltage @xmath65 , and all energies which occur in eq . ( [ stationary ] ) are in our classical consideration much bigger that the quantum energy @xmath66 of the oscillator . the function @xmath67 can have positive as well as negative sign . if it becomes negative at some values of energy ( amplification instead of the dissipation ) , there is a possibility that the strong feedback regime emerges . the stability regions in the gate - bias voltage plane . bold solid lines indicate the edge of the coulomb diamonds . insets show the sketch of @xmath59 in each region . the horizontal lines indicate bias voltages used for current and noise scans in figs . 2 and 3 . ] to illustrate the energy dependence of the probability , we have chosen exponential energy dependence used previously for low frequencies in ref . @xcite , @xmath68 the factor @xmath69 accounting for the spin degeneracy of the state @xmath1 . for concrete illustration , we choose @xmath70 , @xmath71 , and @xmath72 . in the figures , @xmath73 , the gate @xmath74 and bias @xmath75 voltages are measured in the units of @xmath76 , the parameter associated with the energy dependence of the tunneling rates , with the value smaller than the charging energy . 1 presents the regions in gate - bias voltage plane corresponding to the two regimes . in the regime ( i ) , the probability distribution has a sharp peak around zero energy . since the energy represents the mechanical motion of the oscillator , it corresponds to the positive damping at any energy and the absence of mechanical feedback phonons are not generated by the electron tunneling events . in the regime ( ii ) , the distribution function sharply peaks around a finite value of the oscillator energy : mechanical oscillations are generated . we were not able to detect the existence of the bistable regimes , similar to ( iii ) and ( iv ) described in the introduction . the regime ( ii ) of phonon generation only emerges outside the coulomb diamonds . for ( i ) , the distribution function can be approximated as @xmath77 where we have normalized the solution . for ( ii ) , we have the gaussian centered around the most probable value @xmath78 , @xmath79 the current is found as @xmath80 fig . 2 shows the results for the voltage dependence of the current . the trace ( a ) is taken in the regime ( i ) , and the current is not modified by mechanical motion . the traces ( b ) , ( c ) and ( d ) cross the region ( ii ) , and the current dependence in this regime deviates from the one without mechanical motion . the deviations are stronger for higher bias voltages ; additional peaks in the current develop . current modification in strong feedback regime for different bias voltages . the dashed ( solid ) lines give the current modified ( unmodified ) by mechanical motion . the modification is restricted to the regime to region ( ii ) where the phonon generation of takes place . ] the current noise spectral power at zero frequency is found from the expression @xcite @xmath81 and @xmath82 solves the equation @xmath83 . in contrast to the low - frequency case , @xmath84 is a first - order differential operator . this fact simplifies the calculations and readily provides analytical estimates for noise in the two regimes . we parameterize @xmath85 , and the equation for @xmath19 reads @xmath86 solving it and substituting the result to the expression for noise , we obtain @xmath87 this expression can be evaluated with the use of the approximations ( [ zeropeak ] ) , ( [ onepeak ] ) . in the regime ( i ) , we write @xmath88 , where the second derivative is evaluated at @xmath89 . substituting this into the expression for noise , we obtain @xmath90 the comparison with the poisson value of noise @xmath91 gives the estimate @xmath92 . in the high - frequency regime @xmath93 , both factors are small , and thus in the regime ( i ) the mechanically - induced noise is always sub - poissonian . in the regime ( ii ) , expanding @xmath94 , we obtain @xmath95 the estimate for the noise power is @xmath96 . it is not surprising that the noise is relatively higher than in the regime ( i ) , where there is no mechanical motion induced . however , the noise is still below the poisson value , which means that the behavior of the current noise is dominated by the shot noise . mechanical contribution to current noise for different bias voltages . ( a ) region ( i ) ; ( b ) region ( ii ) . ] in this article , we studied current and current noise for an set device coupled to an underdamped harmonic oscillator in the only regime not considered so far : weak coupling @xmath13 and high frequency @xmath97 . we find that , similarly to other regimes , coupling to mechanical modes of the oscillator phonons excited by the tunneling of electrons through the set device , may have a strong effect on the transport properties of the set device . this is the phenomenon of strong mechanical feedback . however , we also find that the feedback effects are the weakest of all the regimes . it was very much expected that the effect of phonons on electron transport is stronger for stronger coupling . but we also find that for high frequencies the effects are less pronounced than for low frequencies . indeed , no bistability regimes have been discovered , the strong feedback only manifests in oscillations with a fixed amplitude . the mechanical contribution to the current noise is small as compared with the shot noise contribution . it still can be serparated from the white shot noise due to its frequency dependence , however , the noise behavior is less spectacular than for low oscillator frequencies , where it is sometimes exponentially enhanced in comparison with the poisson value . in this article , we assume that the energy dependence of the tunnel rates is not too strong . all our results are expressed in terms of the tunnel rates averaged over the period of mechanical oscillations . one can imagine an opposite situation strongly energy - dependent rates ( but at each energy still below the frequency of the oscillator ) . since the oscillator moves quickly on the scale of the typical time the electron spends in one of the set charge states , the instant tunnel rate performs fast oscillations with a big amplitude . in this situation , it is the easiest for an electron to tunnel when the tunnel rate is the highest , which typically would correspond to the maximum displacement of the oscillator . in this _ synchronization _ regime , the electron jumps are synchronized with the oscillator period . the condition for the appearance of the syncrtonization regime is @xmath98 , where @xmath99 is the shift of the mechanical energy if the oscillator is displaced between the two extreme positions . presumably , in the syncronization regime the transport properties are determined by the maximum ( rather than the averaged ) value of the tunnel rate over the oscillation period . detailed analysis of the sincronization regime lies outside the scope of this article , but we expect that the current is enhanced as compared with the `` regular '' strong - feedback regime considered above , whereas the current noise is suppressed since the electron stream becomes more regular .

we investigate strong mechanical feedback for the single - electron tunneling device coupled to an underdamped harmonic oscillator in the high - frequency case , when the mechanical energy of the oscillator exceeds the tunnel rate , and for weak coupling . in the strong feedback regime , the mechanical oscillations oscillated by the telegraph signal from the set in their turn modify the electric current . in contrast to the earlier results for the low frequencies , the current noise in not enhanced above the poisson value .

nucl-th0301029

during the last years , ample evidence for the presence of intruder excitations , in particular at and near closed - shell regions @xcite has been accumulated throughout the nuclear mass table . such intruder excitations , which give rise to shape coexistence and collective band structures , are particularly well documented in the @xmath2 ( sn ) and @xmath1 ( pb ) mass regions . they can be associated with many - particle many - hole proton excitations across the closed shells @xcite but can also be studied , in an equivalent way , using potential energy surface calculations @xcite . after the discovery of @xmath0 intruder excitations in the even - even pb nuclei , down to mass @xmath3 @xcite , the development of recoil and recoil - decay - tagging ( rdt ) techniques and of heavy - ion induced fusion - evaporation reactions @xcite have led to a wealth of new data on collective bands in the pb isotopes that have neutron number near @xmath4 . the large number of experiments carried out over the last few years are described in a review paper by julin _ et al . _ study of the fine - structure of alpha decay of the very neutron - deficient nuclei has also proven to be an excellent tool @xcite to identify excited @xmath0 states and was used for the first observation of a set of three low - lying @xmath0 excitations in @xmath5pb @xcite . the above two major experimental techniques have been instrumental in exploring unexpected new phenomena concerning intruder states and shape coexistence . with these methods , data have become available on @xmath6pb @xcite , @xmath5pb @xcite , @xmath7pb @xcite and @xmath8pb @xcite . the experimental evidence for close - lying @xmath0 excitations and for associated collective band structures ( see fig . [ pbrudi ] ) has brought about the need to explore and study the effects of mixing among these structures . a first attempt using two - level mixing for the low - lying @xmath0 and @xmath9 excitations in @xmath10pb was carried out by van duppen _ et al . _ the importance of mixing between bands was put in a broader context by dracoulis @xcite in the os - pt - hg - pb region . more recently , detailed two - band mixing calculations @xcite and an attempt to perform a three - band mixing study in @xmath5pb @xcite have been reported , albeit all starting from phenomenological band - mixing assumptions . so , there is a clear need to perform a detailed study of these nuclei . we also mention that intruder @xmath0 states and associated bands have been studied in the neutron - deficient pt nuclei @xcite down to mass @xmath11 and in the po nuclei @xcite in an effort to distinguish collective vibrational excitations from intruder states . deformed mean - field calculations @xcite have indicated the possibility of obtaining oblate and prolate minima close to the spherical ground - state configuration in the total energy surface for the pb nuclei for neutron numbers close to @xmath4 . in the hg nuclei with a ground state corresponding to a slightly deformed oblate configuration , a second , prolate configuration is predicted with minimal energy near mid - shell ( @xmath4 ) , while in the pt nuclei a crossing of both minima is found and the prolate deformed minimum becomes the lowest configuration at mid - shell . in the po nuclei the situation is more complicated @xcite with an oblate minimum which approaches the spherical ground - state configuration near @xmath12 , and a prolate minimum which becomes dominant in the ground state for even lower neutron numbers . the above studies have the drawback that only the static potential energy surface properties are studied . many - particle many - hole ( @xmath13p-@xmath14h ) excitations can not be incorporated easily in full large - scale shell - model studies because of the extremely large dimensions of the model spaces involved . these @xmath13p-@xmath14h excitations , however , can be handled within an algebraic framework of the interacting boson model ( ibm ) @xcite . the inclusion in ibm of the simplest 2p-2h intruder excitations in the form of two extra nucleon pairs ( two bosons ) and the study of the mixing with the regular configurations was suggested by duval and barrett @xcite and applied in the pb region to the hg nuclei @xcite , the pt nuclei @xcite and the po nuclei @xcite . these ibm - mixing calculations , however , generally implied the introduction of many parameters . calculations including up to 6p-6h excitations have been carried out , using a simplified hamiltonian , with the aim of studying high - spin properties and backbending within the ibm configuration mixing picture by j. jolie et al @xcite . in an effort to remove the obstacle of introducing many parameters when carrying out such ibm configuration mixing calculations with various mp - nh excitations , the symmetries connecting particle and hole bosons have been put forward in an algebraic framework and led to the introduction of a new label , called _ intruder spin _ or @xmath15 spin @xcite and to applications in the pb region @xcite . in this approach , explored in detail in a series of papers @xcite , both the particle and hole shell - model configurations are handled as interacting particle- and hole - like @xmath16 and @xmath17 bosons . the method also allows , in principle , the mixing of two dynamical symmetries . the experimental need to explore three families each with a different intrinsic structure ( spherical , oblate and prolate or , in a spherical shell - model language , the 2p-2h and 4p-4h intruder excitations next to the regular ones of 0p-0h type ) forms the starting point of the present study . an exploratory calculation of this kind within an algebraic framework has already been reported @xcite but was confined to the @xmath0 band heads . in this paper an ibm - mixing calculation that describes the three different intrinsic ` shape ' configurations is performed , and applied to the very neutron - deficient pb nuclei . the regular ( reg ) 0p-0h states are described in terms of @xmath18 bosons while the intruder 2p-2h and 4p-4h states require @xmath19 and @xmath20 bosons , respectively . the model space thus consists of the sum of three symmetric u(6 ) representations @xmath21\oplus[n+2]\oplus[n+4]$ ] . the model hamiltonian has the form @xmath22 the different parts are @xmath23 with the @xmath17-boson number operator @xmath24 and the quadrupole operator @xmath25 where @xmath26 stands for a regular , 2p-2h or 4p-4h configuration . the parameter @xmath27 corresponds to the single - particle energy needed to create a 2p-2h excitation , corrected for the gain in binding energy due to pairing . likewise , @xmath28 corresponds to the single - particle energy needed to create a 4p-4h excitation ( corrected for pairing ) , with @xmath29 . eigensolutions depend primarily on the ratio @xmath30 . for @xmath31 the solution is vibrational while for @xmath32 it is rotational . in addition , the parameter @xmath33 in the quadrupole operator ( [ q ] ) determines whether the solution is su(3 ) ( axially deformed , @xmath34 ) or so(6 ) ( triaxially unstable , @xmath35 ) . the hamiltonians used in ( [ hamiltonian ] ) represent the simplest parametrisation of the ibm which encompasses its different limits , u(5 ) vibrational , su(3 ) rotational and so(6 ) @xmath36 soft . often a rotational term @xmath37 is added but this is not needed here . the mixing of the different configurations is induced by @xmath38 , which is assumed to be of lowest possible order in the @xmath16 and @xmath17 bosons , @xmath39 with @xmath40 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 mixes the regular ( 0p-0h ) and 2p-2h configurations while @xmath43 mixes the 2p-2h and 4p-4h configurations . note that care is taken to introduce different ( 0p-0h)-(2p-2h ) and ( 2p-2h)-(4p-4h ) mixing parameters , @xmath44 and @xmath45 , respectively , and that there is no direct mixing between the 0p-0h and 4p-4h configurations . the latter statement is suggested by the observation that the matrix element of a two - body interaction between 0p-0h and 4p-4h states is zero . to obtain an estimate of the relation between @xmath44 and @xmath45 , assume in first approximation that the dominant component of the 2p-2h and 4p-4h configurations involves pairs of particles ( holes ) in a single @xmath46 ( @xmath47 ) shell coupled to zero angular momentum . for a pairing force the following ratio of mixing matrix elements is obtained : @xmath48 in the limit of large shells , the mixing between the 2p-2h and 4p-4h @xmath0 states is thus twice as strong as that between the ground state and the 2p-2h states . in contrast , the corresponding ratio , obtained with the mixing hamiltonian ( [ mix ] ) and a u(5 ) vibrational classification of states , equals @xmath49 in the limit of large boson number , @xmath50 should thus be twice as big as @xmath51 to recover the ratio in eq . ( [ ratio ] ) . in the present application to the pb isotopes , the boson number @xmath18 is such that the square root in eq . ( [ u5 ] ) equals about 0.8 , by which factor @xmath50 should be reduced to account for the finite boson number . another and perhaps more important fact is that both eqs . ( [ ratio ] ) and ( [ u5 ] ) are derived for a spherical configuration . it is clear that deformation may drastically change the ratio of mixing matrix elements and , specifically , it may reduce both matrix elements because of the smaller overlap between states with different deformation . thus the microscopic estimate @xmath52 can not be adhered to rigidly and several calculations corresponding to different combinations of mixing matrix elements must be explored . in the even - even pb nuclei , @xmath53 valence neutrons form a ground state which is predominantly of seniority zero , @xmath54 . this can be viewed as a condensate of neutron pairs coupled to @xmath0 . excited states are first built from one broken pair ( @xmath55 ) with @xmath56 , next two broken pairs ( @xmath57 ) @xmath58 and so on . to describe these spherical states in an ibm context , we consider the hamiltonian ( [ reg ] ) with a spherical structure [ symmetry limit u(5 ) ] and which has @xmath59 as the only parameter . we fix this parameter to the @xmath60 state of the heavier pb isotopes @xmath61 to 204 , where the @xmath13p-@xmath14h intruder states are high in energy and have little effect on the low - excited spherical states ( see fig . [ pbrudi ] ) . we do not consider the one broken pair @xmath62 ( @xmath63 boson ) or @xmath64 ( @xmath26 boson), states , which can only be described within extended boson models . a constant hamiltonian for this regular configuration , @xmath65 , yields a constant excitation energy for the @xmath60 state , independent of the number of bosons . the excitation energy of the observed states , however , changes slightly with mass number @xmath66 ( because of shell effects ) . we choose @xmath67 mev ; this value is a compromise between a @xmath60 state which is somewhat too low and other states that increase too rapidly in energy with angular momentum . a better fixing of @xmath59 could have been obtained by a variation of @xmath59 linear with the number of bosons . for the sake of simplicity this is not done here . the spectroscopic information on the neutron - deficient pb isotopes is limited . we use @xmath15-spin symmetry arguments in order to find the ibm parameters of the two intruder configurations in pb from corresponding bands in neighbouring nuclei where more experimental information is available . before deriving the parameters for the 2p-2h configuration in pb , we first show in fig . [ pb_2p2h ] the correspondence between the experimental 2p-2h intruder band in @xmath68pb the only pb isotope where it is known(left panel ) and the intruder analogue regular 0p-4h ground - state band in @xmath69pt ( middle panel ) . this 0p-4h band is also shown for other pt isotopes from mass numbers @xmath70 to 200 , where the coexisting 2p-6h intruder configuration lies high in energy and has little influence on the 0p-4h band . the right - hand panel of fig . [ pb_2p2h ] shows an ibm calculation of the 0p-4h band in the pt isotopes which , using a constant hamiltonian @xmath71 with @xmath72 given in eq . ( [ q ] ) . the band head of the @xmath36 band , the @xmath73 level , is also taken into account in order to restrict the possible parameter values . the parameter @xmath33 is fixed in order to reproduce the observed ratio @xmath74 @xmath75 which is 0.00732 in @xmath69pt @xcite and 0.00485 in @xmath76pt @xcite . theoretical values are 0.00711 and 0.00500 , respectively . it is seen that the experimental spectra for pb and pt are very similar up to @xmath64 . intruder spin symmetry appears to be a good approximation , and so it seems reasonable to use the 0p-4h parameters of pt to describe the pb intruder 2p-2h configuration . in the same way we derive the parameters for the 4p-4h configuration in pb . in fig . [ pb_pt_w6 ] we show the observed analogue bands of the 4p-4h intruder configuration in the pb isotopes ( left panel ) , the 2p-6h intruder configuration in the pt isotopes ( second panel ) and the regular 0p-8h ground - state configuration in the w isotopes ( third panel ) . in the right - hand panel of fig . [ pb_pt_w6 ] , an ibm calculation for this 0p-8h band in the w isotopes is shown , with the hamiltonian ( [ h ] ) again with constant parameters for all isotopes . this calculation also includes the @xmath73 level , the bandhead of the @xmath36 band . the parameter @xmath33 is fixed from the experimental ratio ( [ r ] ) in @xmath8w , which lies in the range 0.02520.0295 according to the different references in @xcite ; the calculated ratio is 0.0276 . again , @xmath15-spin symmetry seems to be valid in this case and we use the 0p-8h parameters of w to describe the 4p-4h configuration in pb . with the three parameter sets ( @xmath77 ) determined previously for the regular , 2p-2h and 4p-4h configurations , a mixing must now be supplied that reproduces the experimental features of the three - configuration coexistence in the pb isotopes ( the extra parameters @xmath78 ) . the final set of parameters is given in table [ table ] . in table [ table2 ] , we present results on the mixing of the three configurations ( reg , 2p-2h and 4p-4h , respectively ) in the first three @xmath0 excited states . one clearly notices a rapid stabilization , close to 100% , for the @xmath79 state at the spherical configuration . the @xmath80 and @xmath81 states indicate a strong mixing between the 2p-2h and 4p-4h configurations . rather quickly , a dominance of the 2p-2h configuration is observed from @xmath82 up to heavier masses in the @xmath80 state . in table [ table3 ] , we identify , for @xmath83 , the bands which contain mainly the 2p-2h ( called `` 2p-2h '' band ) and the 4p-4h ( called `` 4p-4h '' band ) configuration for a particular @xmath84 value . one notices the `` 4p-4h '' band is related to the @xmath80 band head and follows up the @xmath85 states , whereas the `` 2p-2h '' band is connected to the @xmath81 band head and follows up the @xmath86 states , respectively . the results in tables [ table2 ] and [ table3 ] are particularly illuminating in showing the mixing effects within the ibm configuration mixing . note that with constant parameters for all pb isotopes identical results are obtained for corresponding isotopes that are symmetric around the middle of the shell . the result of such a mixing calculation is shown in fig . [ pb_sph ] ( left panel ) . from the comparison with the experimental situation , see fig . [ pb_sph ] ( right panel ) , the slope with which the intruder states gain binding energy towards midshell is too steep , an effect that is independent of the mixing . apparently , @xmath15-spin symmetry is not satisfied completely . a possible cause for these differences between the experimental and theoretical band structures is the fact that the ibm parameters are obtained from separate calculations for the 2p-2h intruder excitations ( fig . [ pb_2p2h ] ) and 4p-4h intruder excitations ( fig . [ pb_pt_w6 ] ) . in the final calculation for the even - even pb nuclei , which includes the 2p-2h and 4p-4h intruder families together with the regular spherical configuration , the extra mixing effects will cause specific perturbations that may show up as a breaking of @xmath15-spin symmetry and may also affect the @xmath66-dependence of the intruder band energies . possible improvements can be expected from a more elaborate mixing study , treating _ all _ known data for the neutron - deficient pb isotopes and relevant nuclei in the @xmath87 region . a further constraint would also be imposed by the condition that the lowest - lying proton 2p-2h @xmath0 excitations approach the observed energy at @xmath88 mev in @xmath89pb . such extensive calculations , aiming to describe besides energy spectra and band structures also known electromagnetic ( mostly e2 and e0 ) properties , isotopic and isomeric shifts and nuclear ground - state binding energies , will be pursued in the near future . very recently , calculations have been carried out by c. vargas et al . @xcite , in order to determine total energy surfaces , starting from the ibm parameters derived in the present paper ( see also table [ table ] ) , using boson coherent states . we have explored in the present paper the possibility to describe the coexistence and mixing of three different families of excitations , corresponding to different intrinsic structures as observed in the pb isotopes . in a mean - field approach the three configurations correspond to spherical , oblate and prolate shapes while in a shell - model description they arise as regular 0p-0h states and 2p-2h and 4p-4h excitations across the @xmath1 proton shell . previous studies of such three - configuration systems were limited to the @xmath0 band heads ( without the associated bands ) either in a mean - field @xcite or an ibm @xcite approach , or , in @xmath5pb , to a phenomenological band - mixing calculation @xcite . the present description is based on the ibm - configuration mixing approach which was originally proposed for two configurations @xcite . in an ibm framework the three configurations are described as @xmath18- , @xmath90- and @xmath91-boson states . to reduce the number of parameters that appear in such a configuration mixing calculation , use is made of the concept of intruder - spin symmetry @xcite , relating configurations with different numbers of particle ( @xmath92 ) and hole ( @xmath93 ) bosons ( i.e. , fermion pairs ) , but with a constant sum @xmath94 in this way experimental excitation energies in adjacent pt and w nuclei are used to fix the essential ibm parameters . the final result is a reasonably good description of the observed bands and their variation with mass number @xmath66 . as outlined at the end of section [ 3config ] , ways to improve the present results will need extensive calculations spanning the region of neutron deficient w , os , pt , hg , pb , po and rn nuclei as well as nuclei near the @xmath87 doubly - closed shell . the authors are grateful to m. huyse , w. nazarewicz and p. van duppen for stimulating discussions on the shell - model interpretation and to j. jolie and j.l . wood for help in building the various parts of this description . financial support of the iwt , the `` fwo - vlaanderen '' and the dwtc ( grant iuap # p5/07 ) is acknowledged . rf also receives financial support from a marie curie fellowship of the european community ( contract number 2000 - 00084 ) . .parameters of the ibm - calculation of the three coexisting configurations in the pb isotopes , as shown in fig . [ pb_sph ] . all parameters are in mev , except for @xmath33 , which is dimensionless . [ cols=">,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]

a three - configuration mixing calculation is performed in the context of the interacting boson model with the aim to describe recently observed collective bands built on low - lying @xmath0 states in neutron - deficient lead isotopes . the configurations that are included correspond to the regular , spherical states as well as two - particle two - hole and four - particle four - hole excitations across the @xmath1 shell gap .

1202.0304

inflation @xcite postulates that the very early universe underwent a period of accelerated expansion . it is typically described via the dynamics of the inflaton , a scalar effective degree of freedom coupled to gravity . quantum fluctuations of the inflaton and other light fields constitute the most widely studied mechanism for producing primordial density perturbations ( for reviews see refs . these perturbations induce temperature fluctuations in the cosmic microwave background radiation ( cmb ) and , as a consequence of their gravitational growth , lead to the formation of the large scale structure of the universe ( lss ) . a key corollary of the inflationary hypothesis is that precise measurements of the cmb and the distribution of galaxies in the sky constrain the physical mechanism that drives the accelerated expansion , opening a remarkable window into the physics of the very early universe . in recent years , high - quality observations of the cmb have been provided by the wmap satellite @xcite , acbar @xcite , the south pole telescope ( spt ) @xcite and the atacama cosmology telescope ( act ) @xcite , while the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) @xcite has probed the density perturbations at low redshifts . further , data from the planck satellite @xcite will soon be available to the cosmological community , and several major lss surveys are now underway or are being planned . inflation can be realized in a vast number of ways , and these scenarios are typically distinguishable via their predictions for the statistical properties of the primordial perturbations . some models are purely _ ad hoc _ , while others satisfy naturalness constraints , or can be derived from candidate theories of fundamental physics . given the plethora of models that exist , it is fruitful to consider the corresponding inverse problem : given cosmological data , can we deduce the mechanism underlying inflation ? this problem is often referred to as _ reconstruction _ ideally , reconstruction would recover the effective action of the `` inflationary sector '' of high energy physics , but carrying out this program for a fully general scenario is not likely to be feasible , even with data from the next generation of astrophysical experiments . consequently , present - day implementations of reconstruction incorporate a ( sometimes implicit ) prior restricting attention to a specific category of models usually a single inflaton with a canonical kinetic term , minimally coupled to einstein gravity . this paper builds on the slow roll reconstruction algorithm , proposed by easther and peiris @xcite . slow roll reconstruction does not require the slow roll _ approximation _ , but rather relies on the truncated hamilton - jacobi slow roll _ expansion _ this is a phenomenological description of inflation , obtained by expanding the hubble parameter as a power series , with the inflaton field as the independent variable or `` clock '' . we focus on scales which are directly probed by observations , making minimal assumptions regarding the reheating mechanism and the expansion history of the universe during the `` primordial dark age '' @xcite . given the long history of the inflationary inverse problem , slow roll reconstruction has a number of antecedents . in particular , other approaches to the inverse problem based on the hamilton - jacobi equations include ref . @xcite and `` monte carlo reconstruction '' @xcite , which was further developed in refs @xcite . separately , @xcite constrained the slow roll parameters by requiring that the duration of inflation was sufficient to solve the classic cosmological problems , while cline and hoi reconstructed inflationary models that allow for a significant running of the scalar spectral index within the hamilton - jacobi formalism @xcite . leach and collaborators constrained inflation by writing the spectral indices in terms of the slow roll parameters @xcite . a similar scheme to slow roll reconstruction was discussed in refs . likewise , ref . @xcite used the wmap5 dataset and sdss data release 7 lrg data to constrain the hubble slow roll parameters , while ref . @xcite obtained constraints on the power spectra of curvature and tensor perturbations using priors based on single field slow roll inflationary models . we implement slow roll reconstruction within modecodehiranya / modecode ] , a publicly available solver for the inflationary background and perturbations @xcite . as shown by liddle @xcite the background dynamics corresponding to the truncated slow roll hierarchy can be solved analytically , yielding the corresponding inflationary potential @xmath3 . adding this potential to the menu of models supported within modecode yields a simple and robust implementation of slow roll reconstruction . further , modecode performs a full numerical computation of the inflationary perturbation spectrum , making no use of the slow roll approximation when computing the power spectrum . we then estimate the slow roll parameters using the wmap7 data , and the recent spt and sdss dr7 data releases . the principal advantage of implementing slow roll reconstruction within modecode is that , by using the nested sampler multinest @xcite with cosmomc @xcite , we compute bayesian evidence at each order in the truncated slow roll hierarchy . this information determines the number of slow roll parameters that are required to account for the data , and thus the optimal order at which to truncate the hierarchy . in addition , we carefully construct the priors for the slow roll parameters to ensure that the computed evidence values are realistic @xcite . finally , we compute two heuristic model selection statistics the profile likelihood ratio and the akaike information criterion for the truncated slow roll hierarchy , and compare these to the bayesian inferences . this is the third in a sequence of papers on bayesian analysis of inflation , and optimal approaches to constraining inflationary models with astrophysical data . the first @xcite focussed on estimating the free parameters in specific inflationary models , while the second @xcite addressed the model selection problem in inflation and the computation of bayesian evidence . the paper is organized as follows : in section [ sec : srr ] we describe slow roll reconstruction and summarize its strengths . section [ sec : method ] contains a detailed description of our analysis , and summarizes the data used to generate the constraints . we present our results in section [ sec : results ] , and summarize the implications of our findings in section [ sec : conclusions ] . during inflation the background metric is well - described by the flat friedmann robertson walker metric @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the scale factor and , as usual , the hubble parameter @xmath6 where dots denote derivatives with respect to time , @xmath7 . inflation is , by definition , a period of accelerated expansion during which @xmath8 . slow roll reconstruction @xcite is based on the inflationary flow hierarchy . this is obtained by rewriting the second friedmann equation , @xmath9 , as @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the reduced planck mass and primes denote derivatives with respect to @xmath12 . we define the slow roll parameters , @xmath13 : @xmath14 ^ 2 \equiv \epsilon\ ] ] for @xmath15 , and @xmath16 for @xmath17 . these are related to the hubble slow roll parameters by noting that @xmath18 and @xmath19 @xcite . we obtain the hamilton - jacobi equations @xcite by differentiating @xmath20 with respect to @xmath12 , yielding an infinite hierarchy of differential equations where @xmath21 is determined by the two previous terms in the expansion . if @xmath22 for all @xmath23 at a specific value of @xmath12 , the hierarchy truncates , and these terms must be zero for all values of @xmath12 . as pointed out by liddle @xcite , this ensures that the higher - order derivatives of @xmath24 vanish for all @xmath12 , which is equivalent to requiring that @xmath24 is a polynomial of finite order , @xmath25 where a subscript @xmath26 denotes a quantity evaluated at @xmath27 . multiplying @xmath28 by a constant leaves the @xmath20 unchanged ; as we will see below , @xmath29 corresponds to the overall energy scale of the inflationary era . the coefficients @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 in equation ( [ eq : srrdef ] ) are then related to the hubble slow roll parameters by @xmath33 the system is not modified by the shift @xmath34 , but this rescaling does implicitly redefine the @xmath35 . we remove this ambiguity without loss of generality by assuming that the slow roll parameters are measured at the instant at which @xmath36 . further , the slow roll hierarchy simplifies when @xmath37 , leading to a distinct class of solutions , and we test both n - parameter " and low-@xmath0 n - parameter " models @xcite in what follows . given an expression for @xmath24 we can always obtain the corresponding potential @xmath3 @xcite by recalling that @xmath38 and replacing @xmath39 with @xmath40 , @xmath41\,.\label{eq : v}\end{gathered}\ ] ] this expression is a function of the @xmath35 and thus the slow roll parameters , so slow roll reconstruction can be implemented by adding equation ( [ eq : v ] ) to the `` menu '' of inflationary models supported by modecode @xcite . the fourier components of the scalar and tensor modes @xmath42 and @xmath43 are obtained by solving @xmath44 where @xmath45 and the subscript @xmath46 denotes a derivative with respect to conformal time @xmath47 . initial conditions for these modes are set by the bunch - davies vacuum when the mode @xmath48 is well within the horizon , and the amplitude of the power spectrum , defined by @xmath49 is computed from the solution when the mode is much larger than the horizon and frozen in : @xmath50 as usual , @xmath51 denotes the curvature perturbations in comoving gauge , and sometimes the notation @xmath52 is used . the amplitude of the power spectrum can also be computed in the slow roll approximation . evaluated at @xmath53 ( the scale which exits the horizon as @xmath27 ) , the amplitude is given in terms @xmath29 and the slow roll parameters by : @xmath54 ^ 2}{\pi\epsilon_\ast } \frac{h_\ast^2}{8\pi}\ , , \label{eq : asr}\ ] ] where @xmath55 denotes @xmath56 to second order in the slow - roll expansion . here , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 is the euler - mascheroni constant @xcite . slow roll reconstruction treats the individual terms in the slow roll hierarchy as free parameters . by implementing the potential , equation ( [ eq : v ] ) , within modecode @xcite we obtain posterior distributions for @xmath59 ( or subsets of these variables ) and compute bayesian evidence to determine the optimal truncation - order for this expansion . modecode modifies cosmomc @xcite , which is used in conjunction with the multinest sampler @xcite . consider the probability distribution for a set of parameters @xmath60 , given a model @xmath61 and the data @xmath62 , denoted by @xmath63 @xcite . bayes theorem yields the _ posterior _ @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the likelihood , @xmath66 is the prior , and @xmath67 is the bayesian evidence . since the probability is normalized to unity we can compute the evidence directly , via @xmath68 which is an @xmath69-dimensional integral over a volume defined by the parameter ranges permitted by the prior . using bayes theorem again , we have @xmath70 given the _ a priori _ probability ratio @xmath71 , @xmath72 yields the ratio of probabilities for the two models , in the light of the data . any _ a priori _ preference for @xmath73 over @xmath74 is quantified by @xmath71 ; this ratio is always set to unity in our analysis . consequently , the evidence ratio @xmath72 expresses the relative betting odds " for two models . the evidence , equation ( [ eq : evidence ] ) , depends on both the value ( or height , given that this is a positive definite integrand ) of the likelihood @xmath75 and the total volume of the parameter space . the evidence thus encodes the understanding that a model in which @xmath75 has a substantial amplitude over a large fraction of the permitted parameter volume is more predictive than one which does not @xcite . we fix @xmath27 to correspond to the time when the pivot scale @xmath53 leaves the horizon and choose @xmath76 . we sample the slow roll parameters at the pivot scale , with priors specified in section [ sec : models ] . in principle , the initial value of the field @xmath77 is determined by the value of @xmath12 at the onset of inflation , or at which the density approaches planckian values . in practice , the largest physical scale to which data are sensitive is @xmath78 and we set @xmath77 by solving for the value of @xmath12 at which the mode with wavenumber @xmath79 leaves the horizon . the initial value of @xmath80 is fixed using the slow roll attractor @xmath81 . we discard models for which inflation breaks down ( _ i.e. _ @xmath82 ) as the field evolves from @xmath83 to @xmath27 , as these scenarios are not consistent with the assumption that the primordial universe is inflating . the smallest scale we consider is @xmath84 which we take to be @xmath85 , the smallest scale accessible to cosmological observations . the power spectrum is computed from the amplitudes of the solutions to the mode equations when the corresponding scale is far outside the horizon , so for self - consistency we require inflation to last until @xmath84 is a hundred times larger than the horizon . assuming @xmath28 to be roughly constant during inflation ( which is consistent with limits from data ) , this puts a lower bound on the number of @xmath86-folds of inflation occurring after the pivot scale leaves the horizon , @xmath87 we discard models with fewer than @xmath88 @xmath86-folds , measured from the instant @xmath53 leaves the horizon . as implemented here , slow roll reconstruction only considers the piece of the potential which is directly probed by cosmological data . this amounts to marginalizing over the value of @xmath12 at which inflation ends physically , this can occur for example because the potential has a sharp `` cliff '' at some value of @xmath12 for which @xmath82 when computed from equation ( [ eq : v ] ) . alternatively , this algorithm can also be implemented by evolving @xmath12 until inflation naturally terminates ( @xmath89 ) and then imposing a prior based on the total number of @xmath86-foldings that occur after the pivot scale leaves the horizon @xcite . by contrast , in this analysis we assume nothing about the evolution of the universe after @xmath84 has reached its asymptotic value after leaving the horizon . the parameters which define the hubble slow roll model to third order in the expansion defined in eq . are @xmath29 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 and @xmath92 . but for all the models we consider , @xmath29 can , in principle , vary over many orders of magnitude and there is little clear _ a priori _ theoretical justification for restricting this range . however , given the slow roll parameters , we see from equation that @xmath29 is strongly correlated with the amplitude of the primordial spectrum . consequently , we treat @xmath56 , the amplitude of the primordial scalar power spectrum , for which the choice of prior range is more straightforward , as an independent parameter with a logarithmic prior . we allow a range that is generous relative to current constraints on this parameter ( e.g. ref . however our results do not depend significantly on the specific choice , and setting a narrower range in the prior would implicitly inject information from the data used to compute the posterior . we obtain @xmath29 directly from equation , given values for @xmath55 and the slow roll parameters . this is the one point at which we use the slow roll _ approximation _ ; the precise amplitude of the power spectrum at the pivot @xmath56 extracted from a numerical solution of the mode equations differs slightly from @xmath55 . in principle we could solve numerically for the exact value of @xmath29 needed to reproduce @xmath56 , but @xmath29 only changes at the level of a few percent if this is done . note that the slow roll approximation is used only in order to set this prior ; for the likelihood computation the numerical solution for @xmath56 is used . the specific set of models we consider is : * `` @xmath90 only '' : @xmath93 , @xmath90 and @xmath55 are varied . * `` @xmath91 only '' : @xmath94 , @xmath95 , @xmath91 and @xmath55 are varied . * `` @xmath90 , @xmath91 '' : @xmath95 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 and @xmath55 are varied . * `` @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath92 '' : all parameters varied . the `` @xmath91 only '' case is the `` low-@xmath0 , 1-parameter '' scenario described in ref . @xcite : when @xmath0 is much smaller than @xmath96 , it effectively decouples from the slow roll hierarchy , meaning that the inflationary dynamics are then independent of the exact value of @xmath0 and are determined by the other slow roll parameters , @xmath1 in this case . we implement this by fixing @xmath90 to a small , finite value and have checked that the results we obtain are insensitive to the specific choice at which we fix @xmath90 . we consider both uniform and logarithmic priors on @xmath90 , and impose uniform priors on @xmath91 and @xmath92 . since the tensor - to - scalar ratio is strongly correlated with @xmath0 , a uniform prior for this parameter biases the analysis toward models where inflation occurs at high energy scales , which are likely to produce a significant background of tensor perturbations @xcite likewise , @xmath55 is drawn from a logarithmic prior . the prior ranges for all model parameters are listed in table [ tab : ranges ] , while the priors for other free cosmological parameters are specified in table [ tab : cosmoranges ] . .prior ranges for the model parameters . runs are performed with both log and uniform priors on @xmath90 ; the corresponding ranges are given in the first two rows . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] in table [ tab : parameters ] we list the mean values and 68% confidence levels for the slow roll parameters at the pivot scale , for all the scenarios we considered . note that the biggest improvement attained by including the spt and lrg data is in the measurement of @xmath91 , for which the data indicates a non - zero value , but this improvement is not highly significant ( @xmath97 ) . note also that when @xmath92 is included , it is measured to be very small , with large uncertainties ; this already hints at the fact that its inclusion is not required in order to fit the data . lv , jn and cw are supported by fp7-ideas-phys.lss 240117 ; lv and cw are also supported by micinn grant aya2008 - 03531 . hvp is supported in part by marie curie grant mirg - ct-2007 - 203314 from the european commission , and by stfc and the leverhulme trust . re is partially supported by the united states department of energy ( de - fg02 - 92er-40704 ) and national science foundation ( career - phy-0747868 ) . this work began during a course at the icc in barcelona , supported by the erc grant fp7-ideas-phys.lss 240117 . we acknowledge the use of the legacy archive for microwave background data ( lambda ) . support for lambda is provided by the nasa office of space science . r. easther and h. peiris , ( 2011 ) , 1112.0326 . f. feroz and m. hobson , mon.not.roy.astron.soc . * 384 * , 449 ( 2008 ) , 0704.3704 . f. feroz , m. hobson , and m. bridges , mon.not.roy.astron.soc . * 398 * , 1601 ( 2009 ) , 0809.3437 . a. lewis and s. bridle , phys.rev . * d66 * , 103511 ( 2002 ) , astro - ph/0205436 . b. a. reid , l. verde , r. jimenez , and o. mena , jcap * 1001 * , 003 ( 2010 ) , 0910.0008 . a. x. gonzalez - morales , r. poltis , b. d. sherwin , and l. verde , ( 2011 ) , 1106.5052 . h. akaike , iee t. automat . contr . * 19 * , 716 ( 1974 ) . w. h. press , s. a. teukolsky , w. t. vetterling , and b. p. flannery , ( 1992 ) , cambridge university press . j. skilling , aip conference proceedings of the 24th interna- tional workshop on bayesian inference and maximum entropy methods in science and engineering * 735 * , 395 ( 2004 ) . m. bridges , f. feroz , m. hobson , and a. lasenby , ( 2008 ) , 0812.3541 . f. feroz , k. cranmer , m. hobson , r. ruiz de austri , and r. trotta , jhep * 1106 * , 042 ( 2011 ) , 1101.3296 , 21 pages , 9 figures , 1 table/ minor changes following referee report . matches version accepted by jhep . z. huang , l. verde , and f. vernizzi , ( 2012 ) , 1201.5955 . d. schlegel , m. white , and d. eisenstein , ( 2009 ) , 0902.4680 . euclid consortium , http://www.euclid - ec.org/.

we implement slow roll reconstruction an optimal solution to the inverse problem for inflationary cosmology within modecode , a publicly available solver for the inflationary dynamics . we obtain up - to - date constraints on the reconstructed inflationary potential , derived from the wmap 7-year dataset and south pole telescope observations , combined with large scale structure data derived from sdss data release 7 . using modecode in conjunction with the multinest sampler , we compute bayesian evidence for the reconstructed potential at each order in the truncated slow roll hierarchy . we find that the data are well - described by the first two slow roll parameters , @xmath0 and @xmath1 , and that there is no need to include a nontrivial @xmath2 parameter .