Re: ANTM Top 10

Originally Posted by woundedwindow;3018581;

I agree with most of those, but in mine I'd also add Brittany (C4) and make Melrose waaaaaaaaaay higher.

I didn't think Brittany (C4) was that great, she was pretty ordinary looking and a little hoochie. Good for an ANTM girl, but not good for a real model. I put Melrose on the list because of her post-show work, but I didn't place her too high because with her age, I don't know if she would have gotten that work without the exposure of ANTM. Plus, my list title implies that these girls were too good to do well on ANTM. Melrose generally had a perky personality and drama, which is what ANTM generally likes to see. But nonetheless, she's a great model.

Re: ANTM Top 10

Originally Posted by Dax;3018968;

I love the list, but I don't consider Ann that good. In the show the girl wasn't that good. My list would be the same but including Amanda C3 and with no Ann.

Welll, she wouldn't be on the list if it weren't for her post-show career. But post-show, she proved to be a very well-rounded model. As for Amanda, same thing as I said about Melrose. Great model, but I'm not sure at her age she could work without the exposure of ANTM.

Re: ANTM Top 10

Shannon and Yaya are downers? Oh well, your opinion. Also, no Mollie Sue on worst eliminations? IMO, #10 on the eliminations list should be #1.

I actually had Mollie Sue on it, but I figured it wouldn't look right since I had the top three of cycle six (which included Jade) as the best. Her elimination was total B.S., though.

Shannon, I like her, but I don't really think she deserved top three. I don't know...I haven't watched that much of cycle one so my opinion may change if I watch more

And Yaya really did not impress me that much. I don't think her spider shot is nearly as good as everyone else thinks it is, and I thought that she just went down from there. Her best shots for me were her Jamaican swimsuit, Dooney & Bourke, and CoverGirl.