Product review: Bare Escentuals Buxom Lash mascara in Blackest Black. So right now this is the mascara I use daily and I absolutely love it. For the longest time I was looking for a mascara that didn't leave black under my eyes after wearing it all day, and then one day in Sephora I bought this little guy and it's been going well ever since. The brush is one of those more plastic ones (for lack of a better term) as opposed to the classic bristled mascara brush, but it's got a million tiny tips on it, so it makes your eyelashes look really full and separated. You can get it at Sephora or online somewhere for about $13. (I'm pretty sure this comes in blue and possibly other colors too, which is always fun) A close second would have to be Loreal's Extra Volume Collagen Plumping Mascara in Black.  Sometimes I'm really weary about drugstore products but I'm a repeat buyer of this one, and both Loreal and Revlon seem to do a FABULOUS job in terms of having quality products. The brush is different on this one, more a classic mascara brush, but it works just about the same as the Buxom lash one. You can pick this up at your local CVS/Walgreens/Target for about $8.