dataset/3d_effect_generation_three-view_reference_0001/eval.json

{
    "questions": [
        {
            "question": "Consistency with the input reference image:",
            "0_point_standard": "The 3D rendering output lacks logical consistency with the input three-view sketch, showing significant differences in shape or structure, contradicting the reference image.",
            "1_point_standard": "The 3D rendering output maintains logical consistency with the input three-view sketch, with coherent structure, faithfully presenting the object's intended form."
        },
        {
            "question": "Completeness of detail representation:",
            "0_point_standard": "The 3D rendering lacks some fine details or specific design elements from the input sketch, resulting in a simplified or incomplete representation.",
            "1_point_standard": "The 3D rendering fully captures all details and intricate features from the input sketch, providing a complete and accurate representation of the object."
        },
        {
            "question": "Consistency of material and texture representation:",
            "0_point_standard": "The 3D rendering fails to accurately represent the materials or textures specified or implied in the input sketch, leading to inconsistencies that affect realism.",
            "1_point_standard": "The 3D rendering consistently and realistically represents materials and textures from all angles, effectively enhancing the object's appearance and credibility."
        },
        {
            "question": "Adherence to text description instructions:",
            "0_point_standard": "The 3D rendering generated by the model fails to meet specific requirements in the text description, lacking the changes or enhancements specified in the instructions.",
            "1_point_standard": "The model effectively follows and incorporates the specific instructions provided in the text description, accurately reflecting all required modifications or features."
        },
        {
            "question": "Integration of realistic lighting and shadows:",
            "0_point_standard": "The lighting and shadow effects in the 3D rendering are unrealistic or poorly handled, with unnatural or inconsistent light source effects, affecting the overall image quality.",
            "1_point_standard": "Lighting and shadow effects are realistically integrated in the rendering, creating a natural sense of depth and enhancing the three-dimensional effect, complementing the object design."
        },
        {
            "question": "Aesthetic unity and visual appeal:",
            "0_point_standard": "The 3D rendering lacks visual harmony, with elements appearing uncoordinated or poorly combined. The design may suffer from disproportionate elements, distracting artifacts, or inconsistent styles, making the image appear visually unbalanced or unrefined.",
            "1_point_standard": "The 3D rendering displays a strong aesthetic unity, with harmonious combinations and balanced proportions. The style is consistent, and the image has a refined, appealing appearance that meets professional design standards."
        }
    ]
}