Royal Berkshire Fire Authority announced on Tuesday it would close Pangbourne station as part of plans to help it save £1.4m.
In the public consultation, the closure of Pangbourne station was the most popular option.
The closure of Wargrave station in Wokingham Borough was deferred for a year, but Pangbourne station in West Berkshire is to close permanently.
The Royal Berkshire Fire and Rescue Service said there was a possibility Wargrave station could close if funding was not found elsewhere and if the station, which is currently manned part-time by retained firefighters, did not increase its availability from 2.4% to 60%.
West Berkshire Conservative councillor Emma Webster - who sits on the fire authority, said: "I understand the concerns raised by residents and the local community.
"I think the most important thing that people need to remember is that residents across the whole of Berkshire will remain safe.
"If they need to dial 999 they will get the service they expect in a prompt and timely manner to assist them in their hour of need."

Timothy Geaney admitted taking or permitting the images to be taken between April 2004 and February 2014.
He was made the subject of a community payback order and put on the sex offenders register earlier this year.
He has now been removed from his profession's register following a General Teaching Council Scotland hearing.
In February, Dumfries Sheriff Court heard how most of the images he had downloaded were of young boys partially dressed in erotic poses with no sexual activity.
In addition to his payback order he was ordered to take part in a special programme for sex offenders.
A GTC Scotland hearing was told that the nature of the offence meant Geaney had "condoned and participated in an industry that violates and abuses children".
It heard that his conduct was "fundamentally incompatible" with being a registered teacher.
The panel found that Geaney had failed to uphold the standards expected of the profession.
It also noted that the offending behaviour had taken place over a lengthy period of time "demonstrating that there was a pattern of behaviour, as opposed to an isolated incident".
"Given the volume of images and the duration of the conduct, taken with the lack of evidence of remedial action, the panel was of the view that there was a strong likelihood of the offending behaviour recurring," it concluded.
The panel found him unfit to teach and removed him from the professional register.
Geaney, who was 69 at the time he was sentenced, was not present at the hearing.
He was prohibited from applying to re-register for a period of two years.

Holders Hibernian or Hearts will host the winners of another replay, between Clyde and Ayr United.
Celtic, already League Cup winners, will entertain Championship side St Mirren and Partick Thistle travel to Aberdeen in the two clear-cut ties.
Rangers host the winner of the replay between Hamilton Academical and Championship side Dunfermline Athletic.
Media playback is not supported on this device
It means the Premiership's top three sides have been handed home ties in the quarter-finals to be played over the weekend of 4/5 March.
The other hosts will be either Hearts, sitting fourth, or last year's winners after the Edinburgh rivals drew 0-0 at Tynecastle on Sunday.
Championship leaders Hibs also played their neighbours at the same stage last season, winning a replay at Easter Road, and went on to beat Rangers in the final.
Last season's runners-up won the last of this weekend's fifth-round ties, edging out Championship outfit Greenock Morton 2-1 in Glasgow.
Media playback is not supported on this device
The Ibrox side, presently under caretaker manager Graeme Murty after Mark Warburton's departure on Friday, will find out their opponents on Tuesday, when Premiership rivals Hamilton entertain Dunfermline.
League Two outfit Clyde host Ayr of the Championship on the same night, while Hibs host Hearts the following Wednesday.
Premiership leaders Celtic will be strong favourites to progress having been drawn at home to St Mirren, who are currently bottom of the Championship.
Aberdeen, sitting second in the top-flight, host Thistle in an all-Premiership tie.
Aberdeen v Partick Thistle
Celtic v St Mirren
Hearts or Hibernian v Ayr United or Clyde
Rangers v Dunfermline Athletic or Hamilton Academical
Ties to be played over the weekend of 4/5 March.
Plans have been announced to close a fire station in Berkshire.
[NEXT_CONCEPT]
A Dumfries and Galloway music teacher found with more than 21,000 indecent images of children has been struck off.
[NEXT_CONCEPT]
Celtic, Rangers and Aberdeen were all handed home ties after the draw for the Scottish Cup quarter-finals.