On a similar list, IGN rated the episode 106 out of 113 episodes, writing "it felt appropriate for Lost's third season to begin with an episode only featuring Jack, Sawyer and Kate, since their abduction by the Others was a big part of Season 2's conclusion.
Na sličnoj listi IGN je postavio epizodu na 106. od 113. mjesta uz obrazloženje: "Bilo je prikladno da treća sezonoa Izgubljenih započne s epizodom u kojoj se pojavljuju samo Jack, Sawyer i Kate zbog njihove otmice od strane Drugih na kraju druge sezone.