"All the Best Cowboys Have Daddy Issues" was watched by 18.88 million Americans and was met with positive reviews from critics, with several reviewers commending the scene in which Jack saves Charlie Pace.
Epizodu All the Best Cowboys Have Daddy Issues gledalo je 18.88 milijuna Amerikanaca, a dobila je izrazito pozitivne kritike od kojih je posebno hvaljena bila scena u kojoj Jack spašava Charlieja.