Although he said the song may feel a bit calculated, Bill Lamb of About.com complimented the song's "acoustic Jason Mraz vibe, the subtle seasonal touches, and adult sound.
Selvom han sagde at sangen kunne føles en smule beregnende, Bill Lamb ved About.com roste sangen's "akustiske Jason Mraz vibe, det hårfine sæsonbetonede touch, og den voksne lyd.