In 2006, Is This It was ranked at number 48 by The Observer in the publication's list of The 50 Albums That Changed Music, while Mojo featured it at number 33 in its list of 100 Modern Classics, 1993–2006.
I år 2006 blev Is This It nummer 48 i The Observer på deres liste Top 50 Albums That Changed Music, mens Mojo præsenterede det som nummer 33 på deres liste 100 Modern Classics 1993-2006.