In 2012, Schulman became the host and executive producer of the follow up show Catfish: The TV Show for MTV, with his filmmaking partner Max Joseph, where he introduces couples in real life who have fallen for each other online but have yet to meet.
I 2012, blev Schulman vært og producent på det efterfølgende program Catfish: The TV Show på MTV, med sin filmmager-makker Max Joseph, hvor han introducerer par i det virkelig liv, der er blevet forelsket i hinanden online men endnu ikke har mødt.