According to the New York Post, all 26 members of the musical cast brought charges that Quaid "physically and verbally abused his fellow performers" and that the show closed rather than continuing to Broadway because of Quaid's "oddball behavior".
Ifølge New York Post, anlagde alle de 26 medvirkende skuespillere sag mod Quaid med begrundelsen, at han havde "psykisk and mundtligt overfuset sine kollegaer", og at showet snarere lukkede ned end at fortsætte Broadway på grund af Quaids "oddball behavior".