He received glowing praise from his division commander, Maj. Gen. John C. Robinson, and a subordinate wrote that, "I wish to say one word outside of my regiment in regard to Generals Baxter and Robinson.
Han fik overstrømmende ros af din divisionskommandør, generalmajor John C. Robinson, og en underordnet skrev, at "jeg ønsker at sige et ord udenfor mit regiment om generalerne Baxter og Robinson.