While less serious than the previous season's mid-season finale "You're Getting Old", McGee enjoyed the "sweet, empathetic core" to the episode, and the juxtaposition of Cartman's desire to play matchmaker with the racism that motivated it.
Selvom den var mindre seriøs en den tidligere sæsons midtvejsfinale, "You're Getting Old", var McGee glad for den "søde, empatiske kerne" i afsnittet, og Cartmans ønske om at være "Kirsten Giftekniv", selvom det var racisme der motiverede det.