On January 20, 2009 it was announced that Bonsante would defend his Minnesota middleweight title against challenger Andy Kolle at Grand Casino Hinckley on March 27 of the same year.
Den 20. januar 2009 blev det meddelt, at Bonsante ville forsvare sin Minnesota mellemvægttitel mod udfordreren Andy Kolle på Grand Casino Hinckley den 27. marts samme år.