Christopher John Farley of The Wall Street Journal commented that Michele, Riley and McHale have "the most distinctive voices" of all the Glee cast members, suggesting that Michele's rendition of "Don't Rain on My Parade" would "have some listeners hoping she'll be sharing her talents with Broadway again soon."
Christopher John Farley fra The Wall Street Journal kommenterede, at Michele, Riley og McHale har "de mest markante stemmer" af alle Glee'a medlemmer, og tyder på, at Micheles udgave af "Don't Rain on My Parade" at der ville "værehave nogle lyttere, som håber hun vil at dele sine talenter med Broadway snart igen."