A flurry of infidelities forces the two apart, though Finn succeeds in winning Rachel back in the season two finale despite Rachel warning him that upon graduation she will be leaving Ohio for good.
En byge af utroskab tvinger de to fra hinanden, selvom Finn lykkes at vinde Rachel tilbage i finalen i sæson to, trods Rachel advarer ham om, at hun efter endt uddannelse vil forlade Ohio for evigt.