The reviewer at TinyMixtapes.com said that "'Magic' is magnificently, triumphantly corny, enough to give Steve Miller and that guy from The Outfield a run for their money.
Anmelderen fra TinyMixtapes.com sagde at "'Magic' er fantastisk, triumferende forloren, nok til at give Steve Miller og den der fyr fra The Outfield kamp til stregen.