Longstreet, however, saw that the divisions of Reynolds and Schenck extended south of the Warrenton Turnpike, overlapping half of his line, and he argued against making the attack at that time.
Longstreet derimod så, at Reynolds og Schenks divisioner fortsatte syd for Warrenton landevejen og overlappede halvdelen af hans linje, og han argumenterede imod at angribe på dette tidspunkt.