Lamb gave the album a four-star rating, calling it "an enduring collection" of "solid holiday music", and was delighted by the animated "Deck the Rooftop", a blend of "Deck the Halls" and "Up on the House Top".
Lamb gav albummet fire stjerner, og kalder det "en varig samling" af "solid ferie musik", og var henrykt over den animerede "Deck the Rooftop", en blanding af " Deck the Halls" og "Up on the House Top".