Jon Dolan of Rolling Stone commented that Matthew Morrison "couldn't rap his way out of a 98° rehearsal", and Allmusic's Andrew Leahey wrote that Cory Monteith and Dianna Agron "can't sing nearly as well as their co-stars".
Jon Dolan fra Rolling Stone kommenterede, at Matthew Morrison "kunne ikke rappe hans vej ud af en 98° generalprøve", og Allmusics Andrew Leahey skrev, at Cory Monteith og Dianna Agron "kan ikke synge nær så godt som deres co-stjerner".