His brigade suffered greatly, mostly due to a high prisoner rate as hundreds of men became confused in the narrow streets of Gettysburg and ended up being captured by oncoming Confederates.
Hans brigade led store tab, mest i form af tilfangetagelser, da hundreder af hans mænd blev forvirrede af de smalle gader i Gettysburg og endte med at blive taget til fange af de fremstormende konfødererede.