At the beginning of the second season, Quinn rejoins the Cheerios and again becomes the captain, regaining her popularity, though later in the season she quits to remain faithful to New Directions.
I begyndelsen af den anden sæson, genindtræder Quinn hos Cheerios og bliver igen kaptajnen, for at genvinde sin popularitet, men senere i sæsonen, forbliver hun tro mod New Directions.