Runners-up Lindsay Pearce and Alex Newell were given prizes of a two-episode arc on Glee, and Cameron Mitchell, who quit the competition in episode 7, won the "fan favorite" competition and the associated $10,000 prize.
Lindsay Pearce og Alex Newell fik desuden en præmie af at være med i to episoder i Glee, og Cameron Mitchell, der forlod konkurrencen i episode 7, vandt "fanfavorit" konkurrencen, og den tilhørende $ 10.000 præmie.