Kyle Buchanan of New York lamented the fact that Jane Lynch was not the one singing "You're a Mean One, Mr. Grinch", calling it a "missed opportunity", while Wieselman was confused at Lang's appearance on the track, wondering if previous guest star Olivia Newton-John would have been a better choice.
Kyle Buchanan fra New York beklagede, at Jane Lynch ikke var den der sang "You're a Mean One, Mr. Grinch", og kalder det en "forspildt mulighed", mens Wieselman var forvirret om Lang deltagelse på tracket, og gad vide om tidligere gæstestjerne Olivia Newton-John ville have været et bedre valg.