Rachel soon realizes that the celibacy club is really a place where teens try to get as physically close to each other as possible without technically engaging in any kind of sexual activity, and she impresses Finn by saying celibacy club doesn't work because it is normal for teenagers to want to have sex.
Rachel indser hurtigt, at cølibatklubben er et sted, hvor teenagere forsøger at kom så fysisk tæt på hinanden som muligt, uden teknisk set at deltage i nogen form for seksuel aktivitet, og hun imponerer Finn ved at sige cølibatklubben ikke fungerer, fordi det er normalt for teenagere at have ønsker om sex.