However, AfterEllen.com's Christie Keith was critical of her appearance, and wrote, "Since Lindsay is one of the reasons I couldn't stand to watch The Glee Project, and no, she can't sing remotely as well as Lea Michele, and none of the boys there was close to being as darling as Kurt, I was forced to suspend disbelief when the whole experience devastated Kurt and Rachel."
Men AfterEllen.com's Christie Keith var mere kritiske over hendes udseende, og skrev: "Lindsay er en af de grunde til, at jeg ikke kan se se The Glee Project , og nej, hun kan ikke synge på afstand såvel som Lea Michele, og da ingen af drengene der var, var tæt på at være så stor en darling som Kurt, blev jeg tvunget til at suspendere min vantro, når hele oplevelsen har ødelagt Kurt og Rachel. "