Raymund Flandez of The Wall Street Journal praised Riley's rendition of "Bust Your Windows" as "showstopping", Vocal Adrenaline's "Mercy" as "leg-splits-over-shoulders exciting", and deemed the Acafellas performance of "I Wanna Sex You Up" "corny" but noted: "this is about high school.
Raymund Flandez fra The Wall Street Journal roste Rileys udgave af "Bust your Windows" som "showstopping", Vocal Adrenalines "Mercy" som "ben-Splits-over-skuldre spændende" og anså Acafellas performance "I Wanna Sex You Up" som "corny", men bemærkede:".. det handler om high school.