After routing the Federal cavalry from their position covering Darbytown Road, Field's and Hoke's divisions assaulted the main Union defensive line along New Market Road and were repulsed.
Efter at have slået Unionens kavaleri på flugt fra deres positioner, som dækkede Darbytown Road, angreb Fields og Hokes divisioner Unionens hovedforsvarslinie langs New Market Road, men blev slået tilbage.