Mike Hale of The New York Times also disapproved of New Directions joining in with the deaf choir, writing that "Imagine": "was shaping up to be the best thing in the episode" until New Directions "torpedoed the moment."
Mike Hale fra New York Times misbilligede også New Directions deltagelse med døvekoret, og skriver, at "Imagine: "ser ud til at være det bedste i episoden", indtil New Directions" torpederede øjeblikket."