In December 2012, TV Guide named the rendition of "Don't Rain on My Parade" one of Glee's best performances, commenting: "Glee has done Broadway many times, but rarely better than this."
I december 2012 navngav TV Guide "Don't Rain on My Parade"-udgaven som en af "Glees bedste præstationer, og kommenterer: "Glee har lavet Broadway mange gange, men sjældent bedre end dette."