After four seasons, Oxford returned to League Two in 2010 via the playoffs, and six seasons later achieved promotion to League One, after finishing 2nd in League Two in 2016.
Efter fire sæsoner, rykkede Oxford tilbage til League Two i 2010 gennem playoff, og seks sæsoner senere opnåede de oprykning til League One, efter at være endt som 2'er i League Two i 2016.