McCall was mixed regarding "In the Dark"'s lyrical content and called the line "do your work on me/Open up my body and do some surgery" the "grossest pillow talk" since The Black Eyed Peas' "My Humps".
McCall schrieb zum Inhalt von In the Dark zur Zeile „do your work on me/Open up my body and do some surgery“ das „grobstes Kissen-Gespräch“ seit My Humps von The Black Eyed Peas.