Under the Radar's Laura Studarus described Hurry Up, We're Dreaming as a "remarkable accomplishment" and a "double album of stunningly ambitious, synth-soaked dreams".
Laura Studarus von Under the Radar beschrieb Hurry Up, We're Dreaming als „bemerkenswerte Leistung“ ("remarkable accomplishment") und ein „Doppelalbum von atemberaubend anspruchsvollen, synthiegetränkten Träumen“ ("double album of stunningly ambitious, synth-soaked dreams").