The staff members of Slant Magazine placed "All Is Full of Love" at number 59 on their list of "The 100 Best Singles of the 1990s", writing: "Though it has been as oft-remixed as any other Björk single from the landmark Homogenic set, no version quite achieves the ethereal effect that the album mix of the song does.
Die Mitarbeiter des Slant Magazine platzierten All Is Full of Love auf Platz 59 ihrer Liste der „100 besten Singles der 1990er“ mit der Begründung: “Though it has been as oft-remixed as any other Björk single from the landmark Homogenic set, no version quite achieves the ethereal effect that the album mix of the song does.