Their next two albums, The Sufferer & the Witness (2006) and Appeal to Reason (2008), were also successful and peaked at number ten and number three on the Billboard 200 chart, respectively.
Наступныя два альбомы, The Sufferer & the Witness і Appeal to Reason, таксама былі паспяховымі і трымаліся на 10 і 3 месцы ў чарце Billboard 200 адпаведна.