kochi parent of the student who alleged of being given a wrong question paper for the class x board exam has questioned cbses allegation that she brought her brothers question paper of 2016in a reply affidavit filed by the parent through advocate razia beevi pj it is pointed out that the student was studying in 8th standard when her brother took the board exams and there is no chance of being able to come to the exam hall with such a question paperif the petitioner was writing the examination by using a different question paper she ought to have brought it into the examination hall in spite of thorough checking by the school authorities the superintendent or teachers have not detected any such papers that was being brought by the petitioner into the examination hall during the course of body examination said the affidavit by the parent while refuting cbses allegationcbse had also alleged that the student did not complain about being given a wrong question paper during the examination responding to it the parent has informed the court that the student became aware of being given a wrong question paper only when she discussed answers with classmates and friends after coming out of the examination hall therefore cbses contention is not sustainable the affidavit saidit was also alleged by cbse that the student could not secure high marks in earlier exams such as the model test the parent contends that the student could secure pass marks in majority of the examinationsyet another allegation raised by cbse in its affidavit to the high court was that the student was copying answers replying to it the affidavit said if the petitioner was copying the answers from the question paper to the answer book the invigilator ought to have noticed such practice within the examination hall however the petitioner had written same answer in the question paper supplied to her so as to enable her to verify whether it is correct or not in the absence of any detection of such a malpractice by the petitioner within the examination hall by the invigilators the averments and allegations contained in the said paragraph is not sustainable the parent has demanded that the court should direct for appropriate action to enable the student to continue her studies at least in the next academic year