of the whole way health care works will exactly krugman which means that whatever people said about supporting it as it came closer the floor it would have had mass defections the obama obamacare is conservative not in a political sense but in a sort of ordinary life sense it leaves the system that most americans have pretty much intact and that was what made it possible you can say in the abstract oh people were in favor of the ideas behind a radical transformation of the whole system it wasnt going to happen this was going to happen and it did will well i agree with paul to this extent that the obama bill is fundamentally timid in that it did not attack what everyone knows is the source of our main problem which is employerprovided health insurance which tangles up a high inflationary product health insurance health care with the wage system in this country krugman i guess im not everyone because i dont agree i mean the fundamental problem we have is thirdparty payment which is necessary you cant run health care unless somebody pays else pays the bills in extreme cases which is where most of the money is but we dont have a system that is very good providing incentives to limit costs and this bill takes some important steps in that direction crosstalk tapper but i want to move on to another topic brazile but can i give a crosstalk tapper donna do yes go ahead brazile david frum because dave is a good person it once again shows that this the republican party has a small tent that they are not diverse and they are not welcoming and i think its bad for the parties good for democrats though crosstalk tapper i just want to switch i want to switch topics for one second peggy because this is a lot on health care and we have a lot to talk about today but i do want to make one point and that is the wydenbennett bill included an individual mandate which is what all of these states are suing the obama administration over it included an individual mandate but moving on brazile that was a nixon idea tapper because theres some good politics going on right now over the weekend former alaska governor sarah palin was out there stumping for her former boss senator john mccain in arizona we talked to some of the people who attended these two rallies and heres what they had to say begin video clip unidentified male i came here to see sarah palin because she totally rocks unidentified female i am supporting jd hayworth unidentified female i wanted to see sarah i heard most of her speech in there i didnt agree with a lot of it because we dont support john mccain im supporting jd hayworth end video clip tapper jd hayworth is of course the republican challenger to incumbent