to reserve more than 50 per cent of the vacant seatsopposing kudesias arguments the varsity counsel anurag singh submitted that following the central governments 2019 law which adds ten per cent more reservation the fifty per cent reservation limit stands exceeded and the provision of the up public services reservation for scheduled castes scheduled tribes and other backward classes act 1994 stands repealedthe up governments counsel alok saran too adopted the lu counsels argumentsfollowing the arguments and counterarguments over the legality of the september 2019 advertisement for filling up the 180 vacancies the bench said the controversy as to whether the up governments september 2 2019 order adopting the central enactment can repeal the up public services reservation for sc st and obc act 1994 requires consideration