Nemeth signed a contract with the WWE in 2004 and competed in their developmental territory, Ohio Valley Wrestling (OVW). He debuted on the main roster in 2005 and played the role of Kerwin White's caddy. He was sent back down to OVW and later called back up where he was a member of The Spirit Squad, performing under the ring name Nicky.
n iː m ə θ WORD_BOUNDARY s aɪ n d WORD_BOUNDARY ʌ WORD_BOUNDARY k ɑ n t ɹ æ k t WORD_BOUNDARY w ɪ ð ð ə WORD_BOUNDARY d ʌ b ə l j uː d ʌ b ə l j uː iː WORD_BOUNDARY ɪ n WORD_BOUNDARY t uː WORD_BOUNDARY θ aʊ z ə n d WORD_BOUNDARY f ɔ ɹ WORD_BOUNDARY æ n d WORD_BOUNDARY k ə m p iː t ɪ d WORD_BOUNDARY ɪ n WORD_BOUNDARY ð ɛ ɹ WORD_BOUNDARY d ɪ v ɛ l ə p m ɛ n t ə l WORD_BOUNDARY t ɛ ɹ ɪ t ɔ ɹ i WORD_BOUNDARY oʊ h aɪ oʊ WORD_BOUNDARY v æ l i WORD_BOUNDARY ɹ ɛ s ə l ɪ ŋ WORD_BOUNDARY oʊ v iː d ʌ b ə l j uː WORD_BOUNDARY h iː WORD_BOUNDARY d eɪ b j uː d WORD_BOUNDARY ɔ n ð ə WORD_BOUNDARY m eɪ n WORD_BOUNDARY ɹ ɑ s t ə ɹ ɹ WORD_BOUNDARY ɪ n WORD_BOUNDARY t uː WORD_BOUNDARY θ aʊ z ə n d WORD_BOUNDARY f aɪ v WORD_BOUNDARY æ n d WORD_BOUNDARY p l eɪ d WORD_BOUNDARY ð ə WORD_BOUNDARY ɹ oʊ l WORD_BOUNDARY ʌ v WORD_BOUNDARY k ɜː w ɪ n WORD_BOUNDARY w aɪ t z WORD_BOUNDARY k æ d i WORD_BOUNDARY h iː WORD_BOUNDARY w ʌ z WORD_BOUNDARY s ɛ n t WORD_BOUNDARY b æ k WORD_BOUNDARY d aʊ n WORD_BOUNDARY t ʊ WORD_BOUNDARY oʊ v iː d ʌ b ə l j uː WORD_BOUNDARY æ n d WORD_BOUNDARY l eɪ t ə ɹ WORD_BOUNDARY k ɔ l d WORD_BOUNDARY b æ k WORD_BOUNDARY ʌ p WORD_BOUNDARY w ɛ ɹ WORD_BOUNDARY h iː WORD_BOUNDARY w ʌ z ʌ WORD_BOUNDARY m ɛ m b ə ɹ ɹ WORD_BOUNDARY ʌ v ð ə WORD_BOUNDARY s p ɪ ɹ ɪ t WORD_BOUNDARY s k w ɑ d WORD_BOUNDARY p ə ɹ f ɔ ɹ m ɪ ŋ WORD_BOUNDARY ʌ n d ə ɹ WORD_BOUNDARY ð ə WORD_BOUNDARY ɹ ɪ ŋ WORD_BOUNDARY n eɪ m WORD_BOUNDARY n ɪ k i WORD_BOUNDARY