6399
Did any writing systems, or even failed attempts at them, exist for Japanese
before kanji was imported from China?
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-08-04T02:00:24.007
6397
2012-08-05T09:36:17.137
91
question
history orthography
Did any writing systems exist before kanji was imported?
There are some dubious claims collectively called 神代文字. The dominant view in
academia is that these are fake.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-08-04T02:31:57.320
6398
2012-08-04T02:52:05.643
2012-08-04T02:52:05.643
91
6397
answer
Does history belong on this site? Anyway, I just flickered through my history
book and came up with this.

First off, from Wikipedia and common sense: Hanzi is said to have come into
existence around 2650 BC. "Common people" didn't just go write things for fun
"back in the day", that was something for the wealthy. (emperors and such)

Now, though legend says the first emperor of Japan lived around 600 BCE, the
first recognized by text is princess/queen/empress(?) Himiko, written in the
Chinese text Weizhi around 297 CE. The first text to recognize Japan at all is
a Chinese text (Hanshu) written around 87 CE.

A prince Shootoku is said to have written the first Japanese "constitution" at
604 CE. An image of Chinese text is given, though it's not saying not much
about it.. Around this time is also when Japan started to record its own
history in text. Nothing is mentioned about what writing system they had, but
Japan was influenced a lot by China and Korea. The constitution itself was
merely some Buddhist guidelines, meaning Chinese text was reasonably imported
along with Buddhism.

The first Japanese collection of poems, Kaifuusoo, was given out at 751 CE.
Here it says it was written in Japanese, though with Chinese characters
because they didn't have their own writing system yet. Some characters were
used for their meanings, others because their readings resembled the Japanese
words.

..not exactly conclusive evidence, but it's something, and too long to be left
as a comment, so here we go. I guess they could still have had some primitive
cave-like drawings, but I don't know if that's technically classified as text
by linguists and such.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-08-04T08:16:22.027
6399
2012-08-05T09:36:17.137
2012-08-05T09:36:17.137
531
1173
6397
answer