97252
I came across this sentence in a light novel by 北川恵海 called 『ちょっと今から人生かえてくる』

> 言われるがまま就活を終了した。

My translation is something like: " I did what I was told and finished my job
hunting. " My question is: what is the difference between 言われたまま and 言われるがまま？
CC BY-SA 4.0
2022-11-16T19:36:59.257
97244
2022-11-17T13:03:47.403
2022-11-16T22:08:03.640
30454
54985
question
grammar word-choice word-usage
What is the difference between 言われたまま and 言われるがまま？
`verb + がまま` is a [fixed phrase from classical
Japanese](https://japanese.stackexchange.com/a/42724/5010). This が is an old
possessive particle (see [this
question](https://japanese.stackexchange.com/a/88931/5010)). A phrase like
this often has a deeper nuance than what's written literally. Here, がまま has a
sense of "without any chance of questioning" or "at someone's mercy".
言われるがまま就活を終了した strongly suggests this person had no control over what he did
or did not understand what he was doing.

言われたまま is a phrase that follows the standard Japanese grammar and just means
"as [I] was told". If you _voluntarily_ followed someone's instruction
understanding most of it, 言われたまま is better.

For example, saying 言われたまま発注しました or 言われたとおり発注しました to your boss is usually okay
("I placed an order just as I was told"). But saying 言われるがまま発注しました to your
boss sounds like you're either irresponsible or angry.

See also: [What does ～がままになる
mean?](https://japanese.stackexchange.com/q/33329/5010)
CC BY-SA 4.0
2022-11-17T02:45:54.093
97252
2022-11-17T13:03:47.403
2022-11-17T13:03:47.403
5010
5010
97244
answer