61781
Is it possible to write Japanese in pure Kanji?

I think I have seen in one TV news show in Osaka that they are showing
snippets of newspaper written in all Kanji.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2018-09-26T08:04:17.657
61767
2020-04-14T23:05:18.360
31382
question
kanji
Is it possible to write Japanese in pure Kanji?
Kanji in Japanese is ideographic, meaning that each character has a set
meaning. As such, it is possible to string several together to get larger
words with greater nuance.... This Stack Exchange talks about long Japanese
words:

[What is the longest word in
Japanese?](https://japanese.stackexchange.com/questions/9424/what-is-the-
longest-word-in-japanese)

Notice, however, in one of the examples on that page, that the long English
word "antidisestablishmentarianism" cannot simply be rendered with kanji, in
Japanese (英国国教会の廃止に反対する主義). This is because the Japanese explanation of the
concept includes a possession marker, a preposition and a verb, all of which
involve the use of hiragana.

The Japanese language needs these hiragana portions to represent verb
conjugations, and to denote movement/placement/relationship, etc... So if you
saw a string of PURE kanji, it is likely to be a singular name or idea, not a
fully formed sentence or a complete thought.

Chinese, on the other hand, IS written completely with hanzi (the Chinese
version of kanji), so it is possible you saw a clip from a Chinese newspaper
being discussed on a Japanese show.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2018-09-26T08:45:04.073
61769
2018-09-26T08:45:04.073
29347
61767
answer
If you saw that the newspaper had only Chinese characters (specifically, no
hiragana or katakana), you are likely looking at a Chinese newspaper. Modern
Japanese has used hiragana in the newspaper for at least 70 years (likely
longer).

This [wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hiragana) page gives an
(extremely) brief history of hiragana, but it appears to have been around
since AD 500. Hiragana wasn't officially formalized into the system until much
after the 500's, but you may be hard pressed to find a date.

The fact that the hiragana system was [reformed in
1900](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_script_reform)* suggests to me
that its appearance in newspapers _could_ date until 1900, if not earlier. The
appearance of a standard Kanji list in 1946 ([Tōyō
kanji](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T%C5%8Dy%C5%8D_kanji)) indicates to me
that use of hiragana in newspapers was at least formalized at around the same
time.

*The wikipedia article on script reform may be more what you are looking for in terms of information. I highly suggest you give it a look.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2018-09-26T13:03:03.930
61775
2018-09-26T13:22:39.097
2018-09-26T13:22:39.097
22352
22352
61767
answer
### Is it possible to write Japanese in pure Kanji?

Yes.

This is mostly historical, however, such as the
[_Man'yōshū_](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Man%27y%C5%8Dsh%C5%AB) poetry
collection dating to roughly 759. The University of Virginia has [published
this online](http://jti.lib.virginia.edu/japanese/manyoshu/AnoMany.html) in
all-kanji Old Japanese, as well as modernized orthography (spelling), and
kana-only for clarification of the sound values.

As others have noted, modern Japanese makes extensive use of kana as a
required element to specify particles, the inflected endings of verbs and
adjectives, and other elements of the language.

### ... snippets of newspaper written in all Kanji

Newspapers are a special context. Space is a premium, so shorter forms are
preferred, especially in headlines and captions. This kind of "headline-ese"
is a weird version of Japanese, leaving out most particles and inflections.
Grammatically, most headlines are parseable as noun stacks.

In a brief search, I couldn't find any headlines that were _only_ in kanji,
but the following examples come close.

  * [名古屋城木造化、名古屋市副市長「１０月の許可厳しい」](https://www.asahi.com/articles/ASL9T2W9XL9POIPE00Y.html?iref=comtop_list_cul_n04)
  * [安倍政権銘柄の持続力 人材・建設に思惑先行](https://www.nikkei.com/article/DGXMZO35777830W8A920C1EN1000/)

If you think about it, "headline-ese" is weird in any language: English
newspapers use a similar kind of special grammar for headlines to tighten
things up. Examples:

  * [Montgomery College’s Takoma Park campus lifts lockdown](https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/montgomery-county-takoma-park-is-on-lockdown/2018/09/26/9e10b18e-c18d-11e8-a1f0-a4051b6ad114_story.html?utm_term=.2eb86799bf78)
  * [Uber drivers suing for better pay lose critical ruling](https://www.bostonglobe.com/business/2018/09/25/uber-drivers-suing-for-better-pay-lose-critical-ruling/9qjHCbQgVlCxVG1pko8yTO/story.html)

That said, if you saw whole newspaper articles written without kana, then no,
that would have been Chinese, not Japanese.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2018-09-26T17:45:04.723
61781
2018-09-26T17:45:04.723
5229
61767
answer
No. It is not possible to write standard Modern Japanese in kanji only. You
may see newspaper headlines without kana particles but that is an artificial
use of orthography to save space on the page. Headlines do not reflect
grammatical or syntactic norms within the language itself.

Historically, there was a time when only kanji were used. When kanji were
first borrowed from Chinese, different reading systems were used
experimentally, including a system in which only kanji were used. However,
this created difficulties for readers, especially when trying to represent
verbal inflexions and grammatical particles. For example, the particle には used
to be written as 庭 (niwa), but such usage requires the reader to understand
that in this case, the kanji character is to be used only phonetically and not
for its meaning. Ultimately, this and other attempts proved too cumbersome and
the issue was only resolved with the ongoing evolution of kana. From then
onwards, the so-called 'mixed writing' was adopted and has become standard. In
fact, you cannot write Japanese without including kana to represent particles,
verb endings, okurigana, honorifics, etc.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2018-09-27T14:18:29.173
61797
2020-04-14T23:05:18.360
2020-04-14T23:05:18.360
25875
25875
61767
answer