2074
I think we all are familiar with する verbs, which are verbs that are formed by
appending する to nouns. Examples include 勉強する, 愛する etc. This pattern is very
convenient because it can be appended to almost anything, such as ライクする (to
'Like' a Facebook post).

There is another common verbification pattern, which is the つく verbs. Examples
include 嘘つく, 傷つく etc. However, unlike する which simply means "to do", つく has a
lots of meanings and kanji characters. When I queried in WWWJDIC, つく has at
least 8 variants, including but not limited to 付く, 就く, 点く, 突く, 着く etc. While I
observe many of these verbs are made of 付く, there are some that are made of
different variants like 落着く {おちつく} and 楯突く {たてつく}, and some even have multiple
variants, for example うそつく can be written as both 嘘付く and 嘘吐く. **How do we
tell (apart from referring to a dictionary of course) which つく that made up a
particular つく verb, for example むかつく?**

There is also a question on particles on the extended verb phrase. For
example, while 傷つく is 傷をつく and 嘘つく is 嘘をつく, 気づく is actually 気がつく. What about,
again, むかつく? Is it むかをつく or むかがつく? In a Google search, I even saw むかとつく. **So,
in general, how do we actually tell which particle is used in a particular
verb?**
CC BY-SA 3.0
2011-07-20T06:06:03.557
2070
2020-03-31T19:23:50.490
2011-07-20T06:18:02.737
28
112
question
particles verbs homophonic-kanji
Dissecting つく verbs
> How do we tell which つく that made up a particular つく verb

You can't. It's vocabulary, there's just no rule to decide one or the other.
You need to know their meaning. I would list them all here, but there are
really too many and each one of them would probably need special attention.

Even knowing the meaning of each つく verb, you would still have a chance to use
the wrong one (ex: 嘘付く = attach a lie? Nobody would know 付く is the one to
choose) Most of these are fixed expressions and most of them probably have
deep etymological origin.

> how do we actually tell which particle is used in a particular verb?

It's like making a normal sentence. You need to know how
transitive/intransitive verbs work, how to mark the subject, action...etc.
There are a lot of possibilities for each つく verb: (see [questions about
particles](https://japanese.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/particles))

味方に付く、気が付く。。。
CC BY-SA 3.0
2011-07-20T07:45:24.323
2072
2011-07-20T07:45:24.323
2017-04-13T12:43:44.260
-1
2070
answer
Before I come back to a rough rubric for determining which kanji to use, let
me take a stab at the second half of your question: namely, how to tell which
particle to use. This is a relatively simple problem in most cases. If the
verb is transitive (i.e. it can have an object), it uses を. If the verb is
intransitive (it _can't_ have an object), then it uses が. This is why it's
気が付く, because 付く is an intransitive verb. The transitive form of 付く is 付ける,
which leads us to another phrase you've likely heard before... 気を付ける.

The problem is that some つく are transitive, and others are intransitive.
Unfortunately, you just have to memorize the lists.

>   * **Transitive (を):** 突く、吐く
>   * **Intransitive (が):** 付く、着く
>

That covers all the main ones. Basically, everything except 突く and 吐く are
intransitive and therefore use が.

Now, moving back to the first part of your question: how to tell which つく is
part of a given word. The first rule of thumb seems to be that for just about
anything, you seem to be able to use 付く (even the transitive ones like 吐く,
strangely enough). Other than this exception, if you think about the word, and
understand the meanings of the various つく, you should be able to figure it out
with at least a decently high degree of accuracy. Here's a list:

>   * **突く (also 衝く, 撞く, 捺く) - to thrust/strike**  
>  If the idea requires pinpoint accuracy or is aggressive, this could be your
> word. A relatively obvious example is 雲突く【くもつく】 (to tower: "to thrust
> through the clouds"). One less obvious is 毒突く【どくづく】 (to curse at someone:
> "to attack someone with poison [of the mouth? :p]).
>
>   * **吐く - to breathe/expel**  
>  The most common example is 嘘【うそ】を吐【つ】く (to lie: "to spit lies"). It's
> usually used either for speaking negative things or breathing -- usually
> outward, e.g. ため息を吐く (to breath a sigh).
>
>   * **着く - to reach/arrive**  
>  If you think about it, words such as 落ち着く begin to make sense. We use a
> very similar metaphor in English: "settle down." One's mood reaches a more
> normal point after falling. Occasionally, it is also used in things having
> to do with clothing (that would normally be 付く), probably due to the kanji's
> use in 着る【きる】 (and less commonly, 着く【はく】).
>
>

There are several others, but these are the main ones. Many of them can
arbitrarily be replaced with 付く, which actually seems to have subsumed some of
the less common ones (such as 点く and 憑く). Unfortunately, this answer is
already _much_ too long, and covering every one of the extremely large number
of つく verbs is likely beyond the scope of this website.

One final note: No dictionary that I can find lists a kanji for the つく in
むかつく, but if I were to guess, I would say 着く ("reaching an irritated state").
Alternately, 付く, which seems to be a relatively safe bet quite a bit of the
time. However, it seems that this word, at least, is normally only written in
kana.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2011-07-20T08:00:01.117
2074
2020-03-31T19:23:50.490
2020-03-31T19:23:50.490
9831
384
2070
answer
I think to approach this problem, you need to recognize that `つく` isn't a word
with many different meanings, from "stick" to "tell lies" to "stab".

The situation you are facing is that these are different words that happen to
be [homonyms](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homonym) (words that sound the
same). `吐く`, `突く`, `付く`, `着く`, and all the rest are distinct entities, not all
aspects of some common thing.

Now, before some [etymologist](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Etymologist) jumps
all over me and points out some potential relationships, note I am not saying
they don't potentially share roots or commonalities. I'm just saying that _in
this situation_ the possible commonalities in the origins of these words
aren't as useful as the differences as their modern usage.

Once you see that these are different words with different kanji, you can see
that this isn't like taking a word and adding `する` in order to make it a verb.
This is just a matter of putting words together to refine a meaning. It's like
adding `出す` to `取る` to make `取り出す【とりだす】` to mean "pull out" instead of simply
using `取る` to mean just "pull".

That you sometimes see it in hiragana isn't an indication that this is some
kind of grammatical form, just that in all likelihood, the author just chose
to not use kanji, as Japanese often do as a matter of course.

In order to figure out what words go with which version of `つく`, there is no
rule book, it will just depend on the sense of the resulting two word
combination. `嘘つく` is not going to be `嘘点く`, because what would it mean to
light with a lie? I suppose you could get poetic, but let's just keep to
common, every day usages. The point is that the normal combination is `嘘吐く`,
because `吐く` means to tell lies (I like to think it means that lies are
"spat").

Unfortunately, not all combinations are obvious. The only way to be sure in an
unclear case, though, is to use a dictionary or ask someone.

Also, last note, it just happens that sometimes okurigana is omitted in some
of these kinds of kanji combinations. So `落ち着く` can also be written as `落着く`.
The middle `ち` is dropped, so to a beginner it might appear as a kanji
compound, but it's really just a two word combination.

Hope that helps.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2011-07-20T08:51:46.397
2076
2011-07-20T08:51:46.397
119
2070
answer