18252
Is the term "フリーマーケット" sometimes assumed to be derived from, or meaning, "Free
market", as opposed to "Flea market"? (That is, having a [false
etymology](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_etymology))

There is a phrase "Free market" in English, but it has an unrelated meaning to
"Flea market". (To be fair, describing a "Flea market" as "Free" makes some
sense, as it's outdoors and vendors presumably have fewer restrictions than if
they had a store in a shopping centre)

I've come across some sites talking about this in Japanese, such as
[Wikipedia](http://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E8%9A%A4%E3%81%AE%E5%B8%82#.E3.83.95.E3.83.AA.E3.83.BC.E3.83.9E.E3.83.BC.E3.82.B1.E3.83.83.E3.83.88),
and this Japanese-language site about [Japanese
English](http://www.eieigo.com/index.php?%E3%83%95%E3%83%AA%E3%83%BC%E3%83%9E%E3%83%BC%E3%82%B1%E3%83%83%E3%83%88%E3%80%80free%20market%20%E3%81%AF%E3%80%81%E5%92%8C%E8%A3%BD%E8%8B%B1%E8%AA%9E%EF%BC%9F),
but haven't found any info in English.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-08-16T08:08:56.293
18247
2014-08-17T03:18:52.003
91
question
etymology loanwords false-etymology
Is "フリーマーケット" sometimes assumed to be derived from "Free"?
Both links explain that フリーマーケット comes from "flea market" not "free market"
but the term needs some disambiguation.

蚤 (のみ）is the 漢字 for flea and the プログレッシブ dictionary lists 蚤の市 as "a flea
market"

The following extract from your second link explains the above and that フリー is
not "free" but "flea":

> [Q:]英語でフリーマーケットは？
>
> [A:] ...フリーマーケットとは蚤の市のことであり、flea （蚤） ＋ market（市、市場） ＝ flea market
> となります。フリーは、 free ではなく、flea の方なんです。

In the first link we are told to be careful because the Japanese for free
market in its true (English) sense is 自由市場:

> free marketとは、経済学用語[、]..自由市場のこと..なので注意が必要である

According to the sites, the term フリーマーケット seems to be used more for large
scale events aimed at families and young people, taking place in places such
as car parks of stadia on particular days. There is no hard and fast rule and
there are other terms for other markets for old things.

As pointed out in the comments, フリーマーケット is not really 和製英語 as it is based on
an English expression rather than a "Japanese made English" such as "nighter"
(ナイター）for an evening game of baseball under floodlights. However if its use is
restricted to a specific type of market for old things then it has a 和製
nature. This gets more complicated if it gets taken to be derived from (and
perhaps written as) "free market" in English/Romaji. If such a market is held
in a free open space then I suppose some people may even infer this as
reflected in the name but I don't see that written in your links which seek to
disambiguate the term.

(So, to summarise, yes it seems some people might mistakenly think the phrase
refers to "free" as in "free market" but not necessarily in a physical sense.)
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-08-16T09:04:41.093
18248
2014-08-17T00:35:45.040
2020-06-17T08:18:27.500
-1
1556
18247
answer
To answer the title question first, yes, it is. Roughly, I am going to say
that it happens incidentally 90% of the time and intentionally the rest of the
time.

This comes from innocent ignorance 80-90% of the time as the English word
"flea" is simply not known nearly as widely as the word "free" among the
average people. The word 「フリー」(from "free") is already very common and most of
us just never questioned our notion "フリー = free".

There is the old term that everyone knows 「[蚤]{のみ}の[市]{いち}」, which literally
means "flea market" but we just fail to make the connection between 「蚤」 and
"flea". 「蚤の市」, by the way, is the translation of its original French term "le
marché aux puces". It does not come from "flea market" in English in case that
is what you thought.

So, it was coincidental in the vast majority of cases. However, there are
times when people who are actually familiar with the English term "flea
market" use on purpose "free market" as the "spelling" for THEIR own flea
markets. This is where what OP states in his paragraph #2 comes in. I have
personally seen advertisement where "Free Market" is used in its English
spelling with an explanation saying that freedom is the key word. You can sell
anything for whatever prices you want. You can even choose to barter instead
of sell. You are free to do anything!

Finally, a word on the tricky term 「自由市場」. It has not been explained fully as
I type.

When read 「じゆうしじょう」, it means "the free market (system)" as an economics term.

When read 「じゆういちば」, it is (part of) a proper noun for a "flea market" type of
an event or place that someone is running.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-08-17T02:53:12.383
18252
2014-08-17T03:18:52.003
2014-08-17T03:18:52.003
18247
answer