13050
I thought if you say "I don't smoke cigarettes" that would be "[Watashi wa]
tabako o suimasen". But I just saw something that said it would be "tabako wa
suimasen". Are they interchangable? Is there a difference?
CC BY-SA 3.0
2013-10-08T03:25:25.243
13049
2013-10-08T04:38:17.173
769
question
negation
Which is the proper way to say "I don't X"?
There are actually three options.

>   1. [タバコを吸いません]{LLLLLLLLL}  
>  tobacco-OBJ smoke-NEG-POLITE  
>  "I don't smoke tobacco."
>
>   2. [タバコは吸いません]{LLLLLLLLL}  
>  tobacco-TOP smoke-NEG-POLITE  
>  "I don't smoke tobacco."
>
>   3. [タバコは吸いません]{LLLHLLLLL}  
>  tobacco-CON smoke-NEG-POLITE  
>  "I don't smoke _tobacco_ , (but I do smoke something else)."
>
>

1 and 2, (marking タバコ with the object marker and topic marker, respectively),
are semantically the same.

However, 3 (marking タバコ with the contrastive marker, which is also は but has a
raised pitch) has the implication that you smoke something else.

So, to answer your question, for a transitive verb, marking the object with を
or は both always work (assuming that you aren't constructing an embedded
clause), but depending on how は is pronounced, it can potentially have the
contrastive meaning.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2013-10-08T04:19:57.180
13050
2013-10-08T04:38:17.173
2013-10-08T04:38:17.173
3097
3097
13049
answer