I'm trying to translate a sentence containing "which one of you" into
Japanese, like in "Which one of you took my sandwich?".

Google's search bar was no help - a query for `"which one of you" in Japanese`
gave me あなたのその1, which seems to mean "the first of you", and the page results
were all for results that simply contained "which one of you" and "Japanese"
on the same page.

It seems like it would be something like "あなたたちにどの人" (which person among you),
but as I'm not experienced, I don't know if that's the correct form.

I don't want something as general as "誰" (who), because I want to refer to a
specific group of people.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2013-10-05T07:15:17.753
13018
2017-07-27T02:10:48.700
2013-10-05T07:21:02.160
2923
2923
question
word-choice
How do you say "which one of you"?
Try to translate meaning, not words. Towards doing this, think of 2 or 3
different ways express what you want to say in English. Match those against
your understanding of Japanese grammar. btw: Fight hard not to use second
person pronouns. Avoiding them sounds more natural, but also pushes one
further away from direct word translations.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2013-10-05T13:01:59.243
13026
2013-10-05T13:01:59.243
3962
13018
answer
As a previous answer mentioned, never try to translate directly as far as word
choice goes. Always translate the intended meaning instead.

That being said, "Which one of you?" is a question in English that is asking
basically "Who" within a group of people. Consider the following phrase:

> あなたたちの中の、(誰/どの人）ですか？  
>  Within (all of) you, who is it?

That being said, this is a phrase you'd be using to select one specific person
out of a specific group of people.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-07-26T21:20:52.833
51786
2017-07-27T02:10:48.700
2017-07-27T02:10:48.700
9831
21684
13018
answer