13382
I am having a bit of trouble separating の and もの when they serve the purpose
of turning a verb phrase into a noun.

The の noun seems to satisfy a few purposes... It seems to be like "one"...
like when you say "the red one is mine" "赤いのは私のです" And it also seems to be
work like "~ing" "It is hard to swim" "泳ぐのが難しい”

At least in the first example, I can give "one" meaning and explain it... The
second one is kind of like the "to" in "to swim" isn't it?

I want to know if you can give の a meaning, or have some way to visualize it
in order to distinguish it from もの?
CC BY-SA 3.0
2013-11-10T07:47:50.637
13380
2013-11-10T10:07:40.657
3754
question
grammar
The の noun... does it have any intrinsic meaning?
There are two separate things to pick apart here.

In your two examples, as you suspect の is really performing two different
functions in your two examples. It's only in 「泳ぐのが難しい」that it's really turning
the verb phrase into a noun; in 「赤いの」it's acting as a placeholder noun, which
is modified by the adjective.

You can't use もの to nominalise a verb phrase - 「泳ぐもの」will always mean
"swimmer" or "the one that swims", not "swimming". (as an aside, you can also
use 「泳ぐ事」to mean "swimming")

Now, as to your question about the difference between の and もの when used as a
placeholder noun, there is a difference in nuance.

先週買ったもの - the thing I bought last week 先週かったの - the one that I bought last
week

「先週かったの」implies that there are many things under consideration, but the one
I'm interested in is the one I bought last week. With もの you're just talking
about a singular object, but the implication with の is that it's a specific
object out of many.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2013-11-10T10:07:40.657
13382
2013-11-10T10:07:40.657
4164
13380
answer