What does ものが mean in this sentence : 私 は あなた に あげる もの が 何も ない。

As far as I understood, ものが means "nothing". But then why do we also have 何も,
which also means "nothing"?
CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-07-12T14:13:33.013
87453
2021-07-13T01:06:02.420
41663
question
grammar
What does ものが mean in this sentence
What gave you the idea that ものが means 'nothing'? A natural sounding
translation of the sentence might be 'I have nothing to give to you', but
literally it's 'There are no things I will give to you.'

もの is simply 'things', and が is serving its usual grammatical purpose of
marking a subject. 何も here is acting as mere emphasis for a negative sentence,
much like in the sentence 何も心配する必要はない.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-07-12T14:16:59.940
87454
2021-07-12T14:16:59.940
9971
87453
answer
「ものが」is not one word. It is two (「もの」("thing") + 「が」(subject particle))

Here, the modifying clause「あなた に あげる」("give to you") is put on the front
of「もの」("thing(s)") to make「あなた に あげる もの」("thing(s) to be given to you").

This whole construction is then made the subject of the larger sentence by
tacking on the subject particle (が), thus:

  * 私は -- "as for me"
  * あなたにあげるもの -- "(the) thing(s) to be given to you"
  * が (subject particle)
  * 何も -- "nothing" (used with a negative verb)
  * ない -- "isn't" (so 何もない basically means "(there) is nothing" or "(there) isn't anything")

--> "As for me, the things to be given to you are nothing." --> "There is
nothing for me to give you" / "There is nothing I will give you" / etc.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-07-13T01:06:02.420
87460
2021-07-13T01:06:02.420
35230
87453
answer