32489
I was watching [this
video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G3_-LuElzfA&index=7&list=PLINFE8v4DOhsq0scG83kB5CRnowYWGSH7)
explaining から. In it (at :08 and again at 2:29), the instructor shows a scene
where he is drinking water, and says ”暑いから水を飲みました。”, then a buzzer noise and a
big red X shows up. He then goes on to a scene where he is taking off his
shirt and says, ”暑いから脱｛ぬ｝ぎました”. This sentence gets a ding and a green circle.
He doesn't explain this, so I can't tell if he is making some kind of joke
(perhaps about his preference for getting nude vs drinking water in response
to hot weather), or if he is saying the first sentence is wrong for some
reason. Is it? Why?

Note that I would have asked in a comment on the video, but someone already
did that 6 months ago and hasn't gotten a response from the author of the
video.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-02-26T16:25:28.523
32486
2016-02-26T22:56:22.597
2016-02-26T22:56:22.597
13577
question
word-choice nuances particle-から
Is there something wrong with this sentence? 暑いから水を飲みました。
I think 暑いから水を飲みました is natural.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-02-26T17:18:36.687
32489
2016-02-26T17:18:36.687
7320
32486
answer