57595
Is my translation of "What are you cooking?" in Japanese below correct?

> 何を炊いている？

Any inputs or feedback will be greatly appreciated.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2018-03-29T12:42:37.413
57594
2020-01-10T11:26:45.860
2018-03-30T06:45:29.283
5464
29215
question
translation
Asking "What are you cooking?" in Japanese
The most common phrase among the native speakers would definitely be:

> 「何{なに}を作{つく}ってるの？」 informally
>
> 「何を作っているんですか？」 less informally

These can be used regardless of the cooking method -- boiling, stir-frying,
deep-frying, baking, etc.

Your sentence:

> 「何を炊{た}いている（の）？」

is a little bit tricky, making your question a very good one. Why so?

That is because in many parts of Japan, including Tokyo, the only thing one
can 炊く is rice. In other words, the verb 「炊く」 is almost reserved for cooking
rice. So, that sentence could sound strange to many.

For that reason, I thought of Kansai (region around Osaka, Kyoto, Kobe) when I
first read your sentence as 「炊く」 is used for boiling almost anything in
Kansai.

Even in Kansai, however, you could _**not**_ say 「何を炊いてるの？」 to a person who is
cooking something using an oven or frying something using a frying pan.

Thus, all in all, the safest verb choice would be 「作る」.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2018-03-29T13:00:09.947
57595
2020-01-10T11:26:45.860
2020-06-17T08:18:27.500
-1
57594
answer