I am currently learning that 〜ています can be used to express a state that
resulted from a previous action, e.g.

> でんきがついています。

All examples in my textbook (Minna No Nihongo - Lesson 29) use intransitive
verbs. But there exists a transitive counterpart to つく, namely つける. My
question is now, what is difference of the earlier mentioned sentence to the
following one

> でんきをつけています。

Is the semantic of 〜ています in the second sentence different from the one in the
first sentence?
CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-04-29T09:21:22.837
86372
2021-04-30T10:23:08.580
43748
question
grammar て-form transitivity
Using 〜ています with intransitive and transitive verbs
Transitivity is not important to determine the meaning of ている. It depends more
on the meaning of each verb:

| progressive ("is doing") | perfect aspect ("has done")  
---|---|---  
**transitive** | ～を食べている  
is eating ～ | ～を超えている  
has surpassed ～  
**intransitive** | 走っている  
is running | 死んでいる  
has died (is dead)  
  
As for 電気をつけています, つける is usually an easy instant action, so it can mean "I've
(already) turned on the light (of the room for you)", but 電気をつけてあります is more
common for this meaning. When there are many lights, 電気をつけています can mean
"(Currently) I'm turning on (all) the lights (on this floor)" as well. It
depends on the context.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-04-30T04:38:20.533
86394
2021-04-30T04:49:30.923
2021-04-30T04:49:30.923
5010
5010
86372
answer
Depending on the context, [電気]{でんき}をつけています may describe an ongoing action.
(Lesson 14)

When it describes a resulting state, it is different from [電気]{でんき}がついています in
that that state is as intented, from the speaker’s viewpoint.

> [電気]{でんき}がついています。  
> The lights are on.

> [電気]{でんき}をつけています。  
> We have the lights on (intentionally).
CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-04-30T10:23:08.580
86400
2021-04-30T10:23:08.580
43676
86372
answer