74264
We all know that に indicates the position of the object (i.e. where it is). I
just came across a sentence where の was used to indicate position with respect
to objects.

> ねこはテーブルの上。In here the cat is on the table.

So, my question is shouldn't we use に instead of の as a position marker.
Thereby making the sentence to :

> ねこはテーブルに上. The cat is on the table

like we do in other scenarios? (Eg. 店は角にあります "shop is on the corner"or
あそこに家があります "The house is over there"). In these scenarios (as that of
examples), we are marking the position as well, like we are doing when we
indicate the position of the cat.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2020-02-05T10:18:33.300
74261
2020-02-05T14:58:37.280
2020-02-05T14:58:03.267
22352
36729
question
grammar particles particle-に particle-の
の and に difference in position maker
> We all know that に indicates the position of the object (i.e. where it is).

Well, not exactly. に indicates the location of existence, but in connection to
verbs. In other words it indicates the location that a _verb_ happens, or
where you intend the verb to happen. You cannot, therefore use に to indicate
where an item is.

In your example sentences 店は角にあります, and あそこに家があります, your verb is ある, or to
exist (for inanimate objects). You will probably learn more about this later,
but 家があります is actually a verb phrase, meaning that the に in the sentence still
modifies ある, even though there is a noun (家) between the particle and the
verb.

* * *

As you have probably no doubt learned by now, の is a possessive term for nouns
(i.e. ' _my_ radio'). While many grammar books will tell us the location of a
noun can also be denoted by の (like
[this](https://www.punipunijapan.com/grammar-lesson-3-particle-%E3%81%AE-no/)
one), I prefer to think if the の as possessive still.

So when we say things like ベッドの上, I think 'the bed's top.' Using the の to
indicate position describes where an _item_ is. の cannot be used to modify a
verb, as is with the case with に.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2020-02-05T14:53:09.600
74264
2020-02-05T14:58:37.280
2020-02-05T14:58:37.280
22352
22352
74261
answer