91331
> いたずらに会議体を作って、賛否両論を並べ、これ以上時間を費やすのは賢明とは思えません。([source](https://www.toshiharu-
> furukawa.jp/2012/5))
>
> しかし、何時までも状況改善を待つことは賢明とは思えません。([source](https://www.kodomo-
> kai.or.jp/kochi/2021_unei_hoshin/))
>
>
> 今日のあなたの服装はとても仕事向きの服装とは思えませんが。([source](https://kakiokoshi.hatenablog.com/entry/2016/11/03/155340))

I am under the impression after a 名詞/形容動詞, 「だとは思えません」 and the だ-less 「とは思えません」
both seem to occur. But I've always learned that と思う calls for だ if the it
follows a 名詞/形容動詞. What's happening? Is it the particle は or the structure
思えない that's key to this change?
CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-11-22T08:06:49.010
91305
2021-11-24T08:42:41.593
30454
question
copula auxiliaries
It seems だ can be omitted in とは思う?
I’m not sure if this と should be grammatically categorized as quotative. If it
is, the quoted part consists of only the adjective 賢明 in the first and second
sentences, and only the noun phrase 仕事向きの服装 in the third, as what precedes
them in each sentence (excluding the adverb とても in the third) is the topic of
the main clause and not part of the quote.

For the sake of explanation, let me take out the main part of the second
sentence as an example and mark the quoted part with brackets.

>   1. 状況改善を待つことは［賢明］とは思えません。
>

This sentence (#1) sounds no less natural to me than the following version
with だ (#2).

>   2. 状況改善を待つことは［賢明だ］とは思えません。
>

Now, let us replace the topic marker は with が to put the topic into the quote
as the subject.

>   3. ［状況改善を待つことが賢明］とは思えません。
>   4. ［状況改善を待つことが賢明だ］とは思えません。
>

If the と is indeed quotative, I would expect the latter (#4) to sound much
more natural than the former (#3). However, this doesn’t seem to be the case
as the version without だ (#3) still sounds natural enough to me.

In contrast, of the following pair, in which とは思えません is changed to と思います to
make the と undoubtedly quotative, the former (#5) does sound significantly
less natural than the latter (#6).

>   5. ［状況改善を待つことが賢明］と思います。(?)
>   6. ［状況改善を待つことが賢明だ］と思います。
>

This unnaturalness remains after the contrastive は is restored, too.

>   7. ［状況改善を待つことが賢明］とは思います。(?)
>   8. ［状況改善を待つことが賢明だ］とは思います。
>

This leads me to think that, despite the verb 思う, the と in `Ａが／はＢとは思わない／思えない`
may better be understood along the same lines as that in such expressions as
`Ａが／はＢとは限らない` than as a typical quotative と as in `Ｘと思う`.
CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-11-24T08:42:41.593
91331
2021-11-24T08:42:41.593
43676
91305
answer