1490
Is 呪縛 usually used to refer to a good spell or a bad one (like a curse)?

I mean the dictionary writes the english meaning as: **spell/curse** but I was
wondering what sort of nuance would be attached to 呪縛 ?

Because I was watching this show and they were saying stuff like: it's not a
curse (呪い), but a spell (呪縛)

So well from that i grasp that.. uh the nuances of 呪い are evil spells/curses,
whereas the nuances of 呪縛 are neutral spells/good spells?
CC BY-SA 3.0
2011-06-24T19:08:58.213
1483
2011-06-27T17:27:03.427
2011-06-25T02:21:59.100
290
264
question
usage vocabulary nuances
What's the difference in the nuances that 呪縛【じゅばく】 and 呪い【のろい】 convey?
I've learnt it. It is like this :

`呪縛 > のろい > まじない` (from strongest to weakest curse)

まじない is a spell but not the others if I'm taking the meaning of spell and
curse right. 呪縛 has more anger, and まじない has more hope.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2011-06-25T00:16:35.510
1490
2011-06-25T02:08:18.527
2011-06-25T02:08:18.527
290
426
1483
answer
These words can be characterized by two facets:

  * effect of the spell
  * intention of the spell-caster

* * *

Lets deal with 呪縛 first by looking at its two Kanjis:

  * 呪: spell, curse
  * 縛: to truss, to bind

So 呪縛される literally means to be restricted by a spell.

  * effect: partially or wholly restrict someone's movement or thought
  * intention: mostly bad, sometimes good depending on the context (or neutral if you're bound by a past event.)

> 忍者が呪縛の術をとなえた。A ninja cast a spell of paralysis. [effect:
> paralysis][intention: good if you're an ally of the ninja, bad for the
> enemy]
>
> 過去の呪縛にとらわれる。Fettered by the past. [effect: restriction of
> thought][intention: neutral]

* * *

呪う translates directly to "curse".

  * effect: something bad, like bad fortune or death.
  * intention: bad

> 末代まで呪ってやる! I curse you forever!

Note that nothing may happen even if you were 呪われた by someone. Anything can
happen in between the act of cursing and the effect to take place. On the
contrary, 呪縛された means you're already bound by a spell.

Also, 呪い can have an on/off state; you can "be under a 呪い"(呪いがかかっている), "break
a 呪い"(呪いをとく). This is similar to 呪縛: you can "be under a 呪縛"(呪縛にかかっている),
"break a 呪縛"(呪縛をとく). The difference is that 呪縛 has a constant effect on the
victim, while 呪い takes effect in a (series of) short event(s) (though it
depends largely on the content of the curse).
CC BY-SA 3.0
2011-06-26T16:53:22.227
1533
2011-06-27T17:27:03.427
2020-06-17T08:18:27.500
-1
128
1483
answer