So I was reading _A Dictionary of Basic Japanese Grammar_ , and in the part
where it explains the uses of いる as an auxiliary verb after て it says
something like that: "(...) Also, verbs like 言う and 思う with a third person
subject require the ~ている pattern if the sentence expresses a present state."
And then there's this example sentence:

> ウエストさんは日本語がやさしいと思っている。

My question is: why does it have to be 思っている? And can I use 思っている as well when
speaking in the first person, or is it wrong?
CC BY-SA 4.0
2012-08-21T20:17:00.603
6538
2021-12-27T22:32:54.160
2021-12-27T22:32:54.160
30454
1392
question
grammar verbs
思っている/言っている with a third person subject?
This seems to be "just a rule", there's some discussion of it [at this
question](https://japanese.stackexchange.com/questions/3708/who-is-doing-the-
thinking).

Some surrounding thoughts to think about though. Non-stative verbs in the
plain form are interpreted as talking about the future, unless the action is
generic or habitual. `ジョンが食べる` means either "John will eat", or "John
eats(habitually/regularly)". To talk about an activity that continues, you
switch to the stative form ～ている. (See Derek's excellent coverage
[here](https://japanese.stackexchange.com/a/3140/29))

In the case of 言う or 思う, the non-past seems to have an implication of "I
(typically) say" or "I (tend to) think". Moving that to the stative seems to
pick up an implication of "I (obstinately) say ...", or "I'm (stuck)
thinking...". It seems to be polite to emphasize the ephemeral nature of your
own statements or thoughts.

Confusingly, the structure that implies boorishness in oneself is seen as a
virtue of consistency in someone else.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-08-21T21:58:50.903
6540
2012-08-22T16:17:24.437
2017-04-13T12:43:44.397
-1
29
6538
answer