For example, I was listening to a song, and the lyric
願いや野望や空想が知らない次元【レベル】へドアをたたいて came up. Don't you usually need to use a の to
make 知らない次元へのドア or else 知らない次元へ might get confused as modifying たたいて? Because
of this, I'm not really sure of the meaning of the lyrics.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-11-20T00:11:12.813
19596
2014-11-20T15:51:18.477
2014-11-20T04:10:01.490
3437
7712
question
grammar usage
Do you need to use の when using へ to modify a noun?
You are right, this sentence is normally written in this way (Let's forget the
furigana レベル for now):

> 知らない次元へ **の** ドアをたたく  
>  knock at the door leading to the unknown dimension

And because "の" is omitted, I feel this 知らない次元へ actually modifies たたく. If it
were not in the lyrics, I would say such wording is at least highly unnatural.
(And I might also say that hope and dream don't usually knock at the door
after all.)

> 社長室へのドアを叩いた: OK (not necessarily the final door of the president room)  
>  社長室のドアを叩いた: OK (the (final) door of the president room)  
>  社長室へドアを叩いた: Incorrect

But in lyrics, such things can happen in order to stay in a certain rhythm.
The meaning of the lyrics itself doesn't change greatly, but it may be
translated as something like "Toward the unknown dimension, knocking at the
door," to emphasize the "adverbial" feeling.
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-11-20T03:06:22.237
19598
2014-11-20T03:59:17.760
2014-11-20T03:59:17.760
5010
5010
19596
answer
日本語で失礼します。 この場合は「ドアを叩く」を慣用句としてひとつの動詞としてみなすほうが、「叩く」を単独の動詞とするよりも自然な解釈になります。
「ドアを叩く」＝「進む・導く」のように置き換えられるので、「知らない次元へ導いて」となり、「の」を省略したとみなさなくても良くなります。
とはいえ、「～へのドアを叩く」と書くほうが一般的な表現です（その場合でも一つの動詞として見なせる）。
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-11-20T15:51:18.477
19607
2014-11-20T15:51:18.477
7762
19596
answer