832
A little while back I was working my way through the Book "Japanese Sentence
Patterns for Effective Communication" When I got to page 156 it explains the
topic of the section which is "The te form of a verb, followed by ください,
expresses a polite request or command...." It then gives some examples and
asks you to solve a few problems. One of the sentences to translate was
"Please carry this chair to the conference room"

I worked out the problem like so

会議室にこのいすを運んでください。

however the answer the book gives is

このいすを会議室に運んでください。

This seemed very strange because the conference room is a direct object of the
chair. I am also aware that を can mean the space through which something is
going, but again that usage seems incorrect since we are talking about a
destination.

Can anybody explain this usage of the を particle and if my answer makes any
more or less sense than the book answer? If I had never seen this sentence
before Im sure I could make out what it means, but the way it uses the を
particle is tripping me up. Thanks!
CC BY-SA 3.0
2011-06-08T23:05:47.053
831
2011-06-09T00:11:23.423
2011-06-08T23:32:16.973
125
235
question
grammar particles particle-を
Use of the particle を to mean where something is going?
The two sentences are actually completely grammatically equivalent. Phrases
ending in particles can be placed in an arbitrary order so long as they all
precede the verb. That's because the particles indicate the function of the
phrase, not the word order. For example, the following two sentences are also
grammatically equivalent:

私は東京に行きます。 東京に私は行きます。

Now, even though they mean the same thing, the emphasis is not the same.
Usually the subject precedes any objects, for example. But getting a feel for
how word order affects emphasis is something that can really only come through
practice, except that things at the front of the sentence are generally
emphasized more. For instance, the first one is just "I'm going to Tokyo", but
the second one might seem more like, "Tokyo? As it happens, I'm going there."
CC BY-SA 3.0
2011-06-08T23:20:32.247
832
2011-06-08T23:20:32.247
224
831
answer
The direct object marker を always comes straight after the direct object, not
before it. You can have a place as the direct object with を (町を歩く) but here
the direct object is still the chair, not the conference room. The sentence is
basically このいすを運んでください, but with some extra information placed in the middle
(会議室に).

To my ears, the book answer sounds more correct. Your sentence sounds correct,
but sort of stiff. Your sentence has the を in the correct place, but you don't
necessarily need for the verb to follow directly. You can put some extra
information between を and the verb:

寿司を笑顔で食べる (すしをえがおでたべる) Eat sushi with a happy face.

This page explains particles better than I can:  
<http://www.guidetojapanese.org/learn/grammar/verbparticles>
CC BY-SA 3.0
2011-06-09T00:01:31.207
836
2011-06-09T00:11:23.423
2011-06-09T00:11:23.423
36
36
831
answer