 that was think about 1992 it's a lot a lot different a campaign but the message that clinton effectively i come from a place called hope right also from a blue-collar town also talking about the future joe biden is 81 years old he is we don't even know it's hard to talk about the future it's hard to and and jd vance in a different way was talking about his own blue-collar roots in a town called middle middletown ohio and speaking about the