 And as it becomes larger... That's not a birthmark. That's tattooing. You can see it. Tattooing, of course. And Mr. Gaines had a brilliant idea. How to make use of a tattooed birthmark and Miss Magna to help him out. Blind as he was, Horace Crail saw through it. That's why Hugh Gaines had to kill him. No, you don't, Gaines. Mr. Walton.