 And she gave it to a black friend. The picture showed the words Black Lives Matter with four round shapes in different tones of brown, beige, and yellow, which was intended to, quote, represent her friends. The girl's family filed a lawsuit last year against the Capistrano Unified School District, claiming her First Amendment rights were violated. But U.S. Central District Judge, that's a federal judge, David Carter, he's about 80 years old, and he was first appointed by Bill Clinton.