 Archbishop Chaput of Philadelphia, he's recently got retired because, or Godel accepts his resignation immediately, but lets his cronies like Donald Wuerl, who covered up sexual abuse, continue on in reigning the red cassock of a cardinal. Chaput said this, and this is actually a brilliant summation of Benedict. He said, for Pope Benedict, the Catholic does not have to publicly renounce his faith to be an apostate. In other words, to no longer be Catholic.