 The original toy, which was made over and over again in different incarnations for years to come, is by far the most valuable. The original one. Okay? Considering how mainstream the toy is, it's no surprise that it can go for up to $200,000, the original toy, if it's new and in the original box. You think people are faking these? Counterfeiting them? For that kind of money, $200,000? Yes.