 The reason they sided with the defendants, in this case the government, is that that injunction, and I think we mentioned this when Bhattacharya was there the first time talking about this, that injunction went way too far. The Fifth Circuit, again, went way too far. You don't grant injunctions willy-nilly, especially when someone doesn't have standing. Bhattacharya and the other plaintiffs could not show that they were actually damaged by the government's actions, and they sued the wrong people.