 I switched my dogs to the Lucy's Pet formula several years ago. Both my puppy that I rescued five years ago, she's in the car next to me if you hear her whine. Oh, I can hear her, okay. And my senior dog, both were on that, and they love it. I do the duck and quinoa Lucy Pet formula. You know, I hear this every single day. Once people have tried Lucy Pet formulas for life, pet food for their dog or their cat,