 interpretation of the rules and he said he'd gotten advice on that that those kind of personal hospitalities that's gifts and you don't have to disclose it and furthermore he's never had business before the court so there's no conflict he's just you know has a rich friend and the guy likes to take him on vacation and why not so that's that's the issue with Justice Thomas the Democrats and AOC as we call her think that because he did not disclose those trips on his annual disclosure reports that