 It was a terrible thing that happened to him. A singer to lose his voice. And all from just an accident. From a thoughtless quarrel between some other people and... He was just a bystander. Ah, that was just his version, Miss Brooks. They didn't know he'd been hurt that badly. Stanton even said he went around to the hospital afterwards, but the guy wouldn't even see him. And Carlotti offered financial help, but the guy turned him down. Carlotti says he never had a voice in the first place. Just a failure who wanted something to blame it on. Yeah, yeah, yeah.