 thanks for having me so kimberly how did you happen to come across this opinion and then get through it before it was removed well we knew that opinions were going to be coming yesterday the supreme court gave us a little advance notice but even though it's the end of the year there's still a lot of really big consequential cases that are pending at the court and so in addition to me going to the court to get a physical copy of the opinion i had a number of colleagues at bloomberg law who were watching the court's website