 a lot of progressive thinkers on the left going back in history that essentially have said that well you know the blacks can't really take care of themselves and these are left-wing individuals saying this such as Paul Fitzhugh America's first sociologist he was like oh they can't take care of themselves so we have to have slavery this is what essentially the left was saying in the 1850s and if you look at just like today you're talking about the cities like look at New York one of the