 Because he does have the two Super Bowls. And along the way, he did beat Tom Brady both times. So you can't take that away from him. But does the eye test, do the numbers tell you that that guy's a Hall of Famer? Back to Troy Aikman. Worst player in the Hall of Fame. I won't hold his rookie season against him. All rookies suck. It's all good. But he especially sucked. He had nine touchdowns, 18 interceptions. The team won one game.