 Favre got to more Super Bowls. Forget the fact that Favre was more beloved. Favre was like middle American ethos. People loved Favre. Loved Favre. We've always been errands a bit more aloof. So Favre has more Super Bowls. Favre has a better playoff win percentage. Favre has more come-from-behind playoff wins in the fourth quarter. Favre also went to Minnesota. And if you remember his first year, Favre was insane.