 It's never happened before. In all the years that baseball has existed, we've never had an exclusive DH ever win the MVP award. The closest, I believe, was Juan Gonzalez, who won in 1996. But that's also because he played at least some time, part-time, in the outfield. If all you're doing is coming up, swinging a bat, and sitting down for 25 minutes at a time, I have a hard time giving you MVP consideration today.