 Columbia President Manoush Shafiq called their comments deeply upsetting and antithetical to university values, saying they convey a lack of concern for Jewish students. A fourth person, the dean of Columbia College, was also involved in the texting, but apologized and will keep his job. In a message to students today, he vowed to rebuild trust and healing. So far, no comment from the other deans. Tovia Smith in PR News.