 and the walk-up quarterfinal so how do the English FA plan to replace him and which names are high up on the shot list let's bring in BBC's Mike Williams who joins me now thank you very much Mike for your time so Southgate did not win a trophy for England he did not bring the champagne football the fans were clamouring for but achieved for the squad has he been overly criticised in your view hi George great to be back with you on Newsday I think