 had known for a year. This wasn't shocking to people on the right, or listen to ABC, or Howie Carr, or any right-wing station, because they were playing the actual clips every day. Whereas MSNBC, you had that one second where he was coherent, and they would play the one second and go, oh my God, he looks good. Nobody ever says, oh, Biden looks good. Oh, if you play one second, he does.