 forgiven they were like pre-forgiven because they had these sweetheart interest rates on them compared to what a private loan would have been so now the whole thing is forgiven so what they've essentially done i mean they're going to keep going right there's i think ultimately 1.2 trillion or something in loans that was one of the main assets of the federal government set against the 35 trillion dollars in debt so apparently he's just giving that away he's giving it to buy votes but of course what rankles is that he's giving it to relatively rich people