 Well, hey, that's not how he treated conscious experiences like the delicious taste of my Earl Grey tea. I mean, for that concept, he seemed to want to throw it away. He wanted to claim that these subjective experiences are like Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny. He said consciousness is an illusion. Well, maybe there's no contradiction there. He wanted to follow the science wherever it takes us. With free will, it takes us to a more sophisticated understanding of human autonomy. But with consciousness, it takes us to a skeptical approach.