 the ruling was there sort of as we see sometimes when they do this when they kick the can is there was there sort of a wink and a nod to say hey if we saw if it was like this it was more narrow if the argument was made differently we may have ruled differently on it or we may have people will mind people will mind the decision for that i don't think so but i'm sure others will say that this language or that language supports their position so but at the end of the day it's a standing decision