 Now it seems so fateful. At the time, it seemed like a very strange blip. So you basically had, in 2012, Obama's reelection. He beats Mitt Romney for president. And the common wisdom was that Romney's greatest liability, the real reason he lost, was that he'd used issues like immigration way too conservatively and alienated broad segments of the electorate. And so while that was the broad consensus following the 2012 election,