 Crestman noticed a deer in the water and the group of dogs were attempting to chase the animal. We went on fishing for 10 or 15 minutes and Gordon said, Hey guys, if you don't mind, we really need to go check on these dogs because they're way out there in that water, Gist said. Gist and Carlisle had Crestman lead them over to the pups. Once the boat arrived on the scene, the three men were left stunned.