 Joe Biden that inherited a recovering economy. And listen, all presidents spent too much from Bush, Obama, Trump and Biden. I mean, it was Bill Clinton and Newt Gingrich that managed to get things actually Newt Gingrich that managed to get things under under control. But even that's an issue. But they they want you to think, hey, money is just a construct. But for the left, listen, it's all been worth it for them.