 case uh the supreme court today ruled that the plaintiffs did not have standing i'm thinking what are you talking about what kind of rulings that but let's talk about it we'll find out uh janine eunice is counsel for the new civil liberties alliance which represented the plaintiffs she's here just to give us a little clarity on this hey uh janine thank you for your time fill me in what went down how did this what was give me give me your perspective on the ruling