text: NCAA tournament BYU has made the NCAA tournament 31 times, with the Cougars having a record of 15–35.
  NIT
  BYU has made the National Invitation Tournament fifteen times, going 19–13. The Cougars were champions in 1951 and 1966.
  NAIA Tournament
  BYU made two appearances in the NAIA Tournament, going 2–2.
  Individual honors
  Retired numbers
  The Cougars have retired the numbers of four players in their history, with the most recent being the jerseys of Hutchins and Minson on February 16, 2013.
  National Players of the Year
  Danny Ainge (1981)
  Jimmer Fredette (2011)
  All-Americans
  Elwood Romney (1931–32)
  Mel Hutchins (1951)
  Roland Minson (1951)
  Joe Richey (1953)
  John Fairchild (1965)
  Dick Nemelka (1966)
  Krešimir Ćosić (1972–73)
  Danny Ainge (1980–81)
  Devin Durrant (1984)
  Michael Smith (1988)
  Jimmer Fredette (2010–11)
  Conference Players of the Year
  John Fairchild (1965)
  Danny Ainge (1981)
  Devin Durrant (1983)
  Timo Saarelainen (1985)
  Michael Smith (1988)
  Mekeli Wesley (2001)
  Rafael Araújo (2004)
  Keena Young (2007)
  Lee Cummard (2008)
  Jimmer Fredette (2011)
  Tyler Haws (2014)
  Kyle Collinsworth (2015)
  Individual records
  Points scored, single game: 52, Jimmer Fredette, March 11, 2011 vs. New Mexico
  Points scored, season: 1,068, Jimmer Fredette, 2010–11
  Points scored, career: 2,720, Tyler Haws, 2009–10, 2012–15
  Field goals made, single game: 22, Jimmer Fredette, March 11, 2011, vs. New Mexico
  Field goals made, season: 346, Jimmer Fredette, 2010–11