text: 24. Mt 26:40–42, with Vox Christi
  25. "" by Albert, Duke in Prussia, stanza 1:
  26. Mt 26:43–50, with Vox Christi and Judas (bass)
  27. Aria  –  (soprano, alto – Chorus II) and  (Chorus I & II)
  28. Mt 26:51–56, with Vox Christi
  29.  (Chorale fatasie, text by Sebald Heyden) [1727/1729 version: ""; 1742 and 1743–1746 versions: ripieno soprano choir added to soprano line]
  Part Two
  30. Aria  –  (alto [bass in the 1727/1729 version] – Chorus II)
  31. Mt 26:57–60a
  32. "" by Adam Reusner, stanza 5:
  33. Mt 26:60b–63a, with Witnesses (alt, tenor) and High Priest (bass)
  34–35. Recitative  and Aria  (tenor)
  36. Mt 26:63b–68, with Vox Christi, High Priest (bass), and Turba on  (Chorus I & II), and on  (Chorus I & II)
  37. "" by Paul Gerhardt, stanza 3:
  38. Mt 26:69–75, with Maid I and II (sopranos), Peter (bass) and Turba on  (Chorus II)
  39. Aria  (alto)
  40. "" by Johann Rist, stanza 6:
  41. Mt 27:1–6, with Judas (bass), High Priest I and II (basses) and Turba on  (Chorus I & II)
  42. Aria  (bass)
  43. Mt 27:7–14, with Vox Christi and Pilate (bass)
  44. "" by Paul Gerhardt, stanza 1: Befiehl du deine Wege