text: Pick of the Pops then returned every week in September 2005, on a Sunday afternoon, again presented by Winton. BBC moved the show to a Saturday lunchtime slot in April 2009, where it remains today.
  Tony Blackburn
  Tony Blackburn replaced Winton in 2010. He was dismissed by the BBC in February 2016 for sexual abuse allegations.
  Paul Gambaccini
  Mark Goodier presented temporarily, replaced in turn by Paul Gambaccini in 2016.
  Noel Gallagher guest-hosted the show on 29 May 2021, to mark his birthday. Gary Davies guest hosted the show on 21 and 28 August 2021 and 2 July 2022.
  Steve Wright
  Steve Wright hosted the show starting in 2023.
  Mark Goodier
  Gary Davies took over as an interim host in 2024, following Wright's sudden death.  Goodier would return to the show to take over from Wright on a permanent basis from 6 July 2024, following his decision to leave Greatest Hits Radio. Goodier's first show featured 1986 and 1998, and saw the return of listener messages being read out, as well as continuing to be live.
  Presenters
  Franklin Engelmann (1955)
  Alan Dell (1956 and 1957–58)
  David Jacobs (September 1956 – September 1957; March 1958 – September 1961; September – December 1962)