text: ROH World Television Championship (1 time)
  ROH Triple Crown Champion
  ROH Hall of Fame (class of 2022)
  SoCal Uncensored
  Rookie of the Year (2000)
  Total Nonstop Action Wrestling
  TNA Television Championship (1 time)
  TNA World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
  TNA World Tag Team Championship (2 times) – by himself (1 time) and with Magnus (1 time)
  TNA X Division Championship (5 times)
  King of the Mountain (2008)
  Maximum Impact Tournament (2011)
  TNA X Division Championship Tournament (2014)
  Super X Cup (2005)
  Feast or Fired (2009 – World Heavyweight Championship contract)
  TNA Turkey Bowl (2007)
  Gauntlet for the Gold (2007 – TNA World Heavyweight Championship)
  Wild Card Tournament (2011) – with Magnus
  TNA Grand Slam Champion
  TNA Triple Crown Champion
  TNA Year End Awards (6 times)
  Mr. TNA (2006, 2007)
  X-Division Star of the Year (2006)
  Feud of the Year (2006, 2007)
  Finisher of the Year (2007)
  Twin Wrestling Entertainment
  TWE Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
  Ultimate Pro Wrestling
  UPW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
  UPW No Holds Barred Championship (1 time)
  Wrestling Observer Newsletter
  Best Brawler (2005, 2006)
  Most Outstanding Wrestler (2005)
  Pro Wrestling Match of the Year (2005)
  WWE
  NXT Championship (3 times)
  WWE United States Championship (2 times)
  Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic (2015) – with Finn Bálor