When you remove the main ingredient from a pruduct does it become something else...? should it change name...???depends whether your a government body or your motives are based on profit... since people seem quite content to buy lemonade with no lemons in and fruit sweets and drinks wiht no fruit in why not sell tiger balm with no true 'tiger power' in it either...??However I did check my facts  this time and see the menthol in the origianl recipe so I stand corrected there. thanks.. p.   ;9)