I was so excited about this shoe from all the good reviews.  But when I got it, not only did I realize the shoe ran REALLY big - it wouldn't even stay on my foot! - but it also had a very "plastic" look to it.  Honestly, it just looked really cheap and very old fashioned for this 35 year old :-)  I could never give prophet 1 star because honestly, they have a lot of great shoes, but this just wasn't one of them.