I used to wear and love Docs back when I was a punk rock high school kid, so I am very excited that they are making boots for former punk rock high school kids turned indie rock legal assistants.

Now, I'm not at all sure of what constitutes "athletic calves," but I'm an athlete (martial artist and casual cyclist) who has calves, so I guess mine fit that description?  These boots were tight around the top the first time I put them on, giving me something of a calf muffin top.  After a few hours though, they had stretched quite nicely.  The fit is snug, but not bindingly tight.  I can wear them over a pair of jeans just fine.  For me, the comfort disconnect is in the ankles.  They're very stiff where the decorative band goes around the ankle and the shaft kept folding in a way that irritated my skin.  After one wearing, they are already loosening up.  I think within a week this will be a non issue. If not, I'll be sure to edit this review accordingly.

Ankles aside, these are extremely comfortable every day boots that put a bit more swing in your hips than the average pair of low heeled shoes.  Buy them if you want to celebrate your femininity while embracing your inner tom boy.  I'd advise other athletes with calves to order them, wear them around a carpeted area for a bit so as not to mess up the soles, and if they don't expand enough for you, send them back.

Enjoy!