I love this boot! I'm short - 5'3" with thin legs so when it's pulled all the way up, it's a little more than 2 inches over my knees making it almost a thigh high (not a surprise because I bought a 'thigh boot', although from another brand, and that ended up being a crotch boot on me!!).  I got the midnight stretch and it's very obvious that it's 'plastic' but it's a nice plastic look if there is such a thing.  The heel and toe are not super pointed nor is the toe too rounded so it's not 'dated'.  It is super easy to wear and walk in.  It has a zipper from ankle to mid calf which comes in handy for pulling down/fixing jean legs.  Awesome boot for price.