I bought this to help me simplify my wallet situation.  I had a 3 sided wallet but it was geting to thinck.  I needed to thin it out.  The leather brown wallet by Moga arrived in good shape.  The plastic window had some scratches on it.  After organizing what I need and don't need in my wallet, I now feel less burden.  I would have given it 5 STARS, but the wallet has a weird leather/mildew smell to it (more leather than mildew, but you can still smell it).  I am hoping that it will dissipate as time goes on.  Other thatn that it was a keen purchase after searching all the other similar style wallets.  And believe me I searched hard. It was the most inexpensive conservative brown leather credit card holder wallet Amazon has.  I hope this helps out.