I got the black suede and am extremely satisfied! I've been looking for a bootie since they are so versatile for fall/winter, but wanted to wait to get a good deal. $20 is great and it is TTS.  Also, the ruching on the upper vamp comes in handy...you can wear them over and over and not have to worry about it getting creased and looking worn out after a short time.  Very comfortable too which, like the other reviewer, I didn't expect as the heel is high. Highly recommend!