I originally gave these 4 stars, even though they left black dye on my feet, however I've changed the review to one star because the sandals only lasted one summer season and I expect my shoes to last longer than that.  I ordered the black pair and I was also disappointed that the black turned to a dirty and old looking gray and did not maintain the black color for very long.  I would not buy these shoes again and probably will not buy another shoe with a cork bottom, I don't think it's as durable.  I now wear these sandals as my go to shoe when I'm doing something really messy and don't care what happens to my shoes, like painting.