Oh my gosh, I love these boots!!! They fit perfectly:  The calf is actually the right size (not too tight), the heel is the right height, they have good support, and they don't scrunch up your toes like most department store boots do.  They are great!  Other reviews I saw online before my purchase mentioned that you should order down a half size, but I went with my regular size and they are the perfect width and fit.
I am 100% satisfied, this is the boot I've been looking for for 8 years!