So far I am very happy.  They look good, not dressy but not horrid and are warm.  Any one with diabetes will tell you that cold feet are a problem and these do well.  I am going to water/stain proof them.
I wear 8 to 8 1/2 and the 9s are fine but if you wear 8 1/2 or 9 you will probably want the 10s.

The soles are OK but not great over rough ground and they don't provide much of any arch or ankle support--no surprise.

I will update when I have some wear experience.

A fellow fire fighter got a pair about 6 weeks before me and wore them in the sow and slush.  At this point they are pretty ratty.  Not recommend for other than in house and good conditions on the deck or side walk.  But good if you stay out of the blood and the mud and the beer!  Seem to wear well.