I don;t know what sort of person left the other review.  everyone knows kid;s costumes run small. Most peter Pan costumes are FELT for crying out load. this is a good costume IMHO as it has pants instead of tights. tights would be more traditional but would only last  five minutes on most boys if you could get them to wear tights in the first place. costume looks very much like the beloved Disney one without the high Disney price. You should add a belt pouch and a rubber dagger to this for authenticity