Positives:  Warm, look just as pictured & does the job

Negatives:  runs a little big.  I bought my normal shoe size, but they were pretty loose out of the box.  I'm hoping they don't stretch any or they'll be falling off alot.  Made in China - this is a negative for me.  I avoided the UGG scuffs because they're also now made in China, and the quality has suffered when you read recent reviews compared to older ones.  I have no problem paying premium prices for quality products and to provide a living wage to those making them, but I refuse to pay premium prices for lower quality goods made using cheap labor.  Although I wasn't happy to find these were made in China, I didn't lower my rating due to that since the cost was relatively modest.  To be honest, if I had known they were made in China I would have kept shopping for another brand, though.  I hope I will get at least a few years use from these.  If not I'll update my review!

*after using these for a year & 1/2 they did stretch out even more & I had to get rid of them.  They're so loose they fly off my foot & are too dangerous to attempt going down a flight of stairs.  Definately should have gotten at least 1 size smaller than my usual.