These shoes are SO CUTE and are a MUST HAVE for any little girl! I bought these for my 16 month old and we get lots of complaints on them. She's been wearing them for 2 months so far (she doesn't wear them everyday) and they have seemed to hold there own and aren't all messed up on the top yet. Nothing aggravates me more than when we shoes get scuffed up and plastic starts peeling on the tops of them. And so far so good with these.