I'm 5'10" and 130 lbs, so I got the medium tall size, and they fit great.  I ordered them in caramel, which is great for my caucasian skin.  I wanted tights that would match closely to my skin.  I'm not super pale OR tan, so this was a perfect match and doesn't make my legs look way more tan than the rest of my body.  The quality of the fishnet is great, I'm not quite sure what WOULD put a hole in these unless you took some scissors or a cigarette to them or something!  They're great for kind of sucking in leg fat (lol) and covering cellulite, which is a must for me since I professionally dance and don't want to be worrying about that in front of all those people.  I like the solid foot at the bottom.  The only reason I gave this 4 out of 5 stars was the waistband.  I'm sure it's a plush and comfortable waistband for someone who is stick skinny and/or solid muscle (I'm thin but a little soft here and there), but it was so tight it gave me a very unflattering muffin top.  To fix this I completely cut the waistband off, and it was perfect.  The tights don't ravel, frey, or break, even after I cut off the waistband.  After that adjustment they were perfect and looked awesome under my costume!  I definitely reccomend these tights.