I cannot write a complete review at this time as we have not had the kind of weather in which I would need to wear them.  That said, here are my thoughts on the boots from just trying them on.

They feel a bit flimsy, and the fit is narrow.  If one has a wide forefoot, they will feel small.

The lining is thin,  but since I haven't been able to wear them for any extended time in the snow, I can't speak to their warmth.

I will update this review once I've had a chance to really use them.