I'm giving three stars.  Everyone has a different body type to fit and we find it lucky when a pair of jeans fits perfectly.  I ordered two pairs of these Lee jeans;  One in this Black and the other in Spy.  Two pair, the same size, one fit and one didn't.  I ordered a size larger than normal ... mainly because of the reviews but also because (I can't believe I'm admitting this) I've gained a couple pounds since the holidays and have yet to lose them.  There is a difference in the materials of both of these jeans.  The Black seemed to be a lot rougher/stiffer.  The Spy felt like a good solid material, yet comfortable to wear.  The Spy fit great.  The Black I had about a 1 inch gap at the waist to button them.  If they had had enough stretch to them I could've nudged it a bit tighter and kept them.  The Spy jeans had just the right amount of stretch/give.  They fit nicely at my waist which has been my biggest WOE when it comes to finding jeans.  I'm sending back the Black and I'm going to try the Onyx.  Wish me luck.