This boot is comfortable because of the shape and "eggcrate" cushioning. I ordered 2 sizes just in case and the smaller (8) is fine. I have found that manufacturers who offer wide widths are usually comparable to regular widths in other brands. Don't know why this would be but if you need a little extra room in the width but don't want a longer length , this boot - and other styles by Softwalk - is a good bet. BTW, black is not a good description; this is really charcoal grey and weathered looking which is fine with me!