I like these boots.  They did run a little small, which other reviews warned me about.  I usually wear a size 9, I ordered a 9 and half, which fit fine.  They are well made, look like the picture.  The inside of these matches the outside.  They are comfortable and I get a lot of compliments on them.  I haven't worn them through any bad weather yet, but they look like they can take it with wiping off after.