I'm giving this shoe a 4 out of 5 rating based on what I believe to be discrepancies with the toe formation along the shoes I received.  In the photo, the toe of this shoe is slim but the shoe I received was slightly raised higher, taking away from a slimmer profile.  I have worn Kenneth Cole shoes for many years and can testify to the quality of their product.  This Reaction shoe is still a handsome shoe, I was just expecting a shoe with lower relief along the toe.