The reviews for this boot were so opposite in perspective that I waited a long while to try it. However I really needed a black ankle boot for work so I decided to try it. It is narrow through the ankle and calf but that was not a problem for me. I have a wide forefoot so what some people thought looked unfashionable was a perfect fit for me. The leather which felt hard for some reviewers softened up for me quickly. The other surprise was that the wobbleboard on this boot felt even better than the Mukluk. I am delighted to have what I think is a nice pant boot that is also comfortable when standing for long periods.