Unlike other reviewers, I think the shaft on this boot is plenty wide enough for my "athletic" (i.e., plump!) calves. I even got skinny jeans to fit inside. Also, the sizing and foot width were just perfect. They are very comfortable for walking (albeit perhaps not long distances or for hours at a time) because of the wider heel and platform. I got the black, so I can't comment too much on the color -- it is as it appears in the photo. Overall, I was very pleased with these boots and have received several compliments when wearing them.