These boots are pretty (shiny, deep black like in the picture), and they fit ok with skinny pants, that's why I am giving 3 stars.

 I always buy boots in 7 (but wear most sandals in 6.5) because my feet are a little wide and my calves are muscular (or chubby if you prefer), even though I am short and slim. So these in 7 fit exactly right, and I can even wear with skinny pants (they feel tight but it's fine), but any other pants I can't. And since these are rain boots, ideally you wear over your pants to protect them right?! Since it would limit my choice  of clothes I decided to return and get boots 14.5' wide, which fit me better.