Purchased these for my 14yr old daughter in Illinois who rides and tends to horses all winter.  The boots definitely overcame the frostbite in her toes experienced when riding in the cold, and fit in Western Saddle stirrups.  They seem to be holding up well to the winter muck and cleaning stalls.  The top drawstring detached on one boot so will be attempting a replacement, but definitely will stay with this make/model boot.