Appearance: 5/5
The colors match the picture, and are nice and vibrant.

Fit: 4/5
I wear size 39 men's Vibrams, or size 9 women's shoes. Based on the size chart, I ordered a Medium in these socks. They fit fine in my Vibrams, but I'm definitely ordering Small next time. Also, the toes are really long, as some other reviewers have mentioned, though addressing this only adds a few seconds to putting them on, and doesn't seem to affect the final fit.

Feel: 5/5
So soft! Though, I admit I can't tell the difference once they're on my feet.

Durability: 5/5
Granted, I've only had them for a couple of months, and worn/washed them less than a dozen times, but they seem to be holding up fine so far. Also, they are not picking up any dye from the insides of my shoes, which is an issue with the striped Injinji toe socks.