I have been wanting a pair of brown leather boots for over ten years. I am at the point where I can no longer wear sandles regularly and have to wear insoles in my shoes. I managed to get these on sale in the Dark Brown Harvest and I LOVE them. They are so comfortable. I got a size UK 7 and I wear a women's US 8.5, but I have wide feet. They were too big without the insoles!!! Once I added the gel insoles and the heal insole, they were still big, but didn't flop around when I walked. Without the insoles in they flopped around. I probably wouldn't have been okay going a size smaller, but it's really hard to tell. If I didn't have to put in insoles I would definitely try the smaller size... maybe even with the insoles still. It's hard to tell. Sorry. Hope this helps. :P