First the positives. This watch looks great. I absolutely love the silver finish, and the style. It's got a rugged look but also can be quite casual. It seems to keep time as well as any Quartz driven battery watch, maybe a few seconds deviation after a few days but nothing too noticeable. If I were looking for precision I'd buy an automatic mechanical watch. The hands are very easy to read in a glance and the indiglo back-light works fairly well.

The strap is... interesting. It's got a nice green nylon outer, with a soft leather inner lining. I like it, but I'll probably change it for something more durable.

Now for the bad. When I first tried to set the time on this watch, the pin pulled all the way out of the watch. That's not good. I pushed it back in, and it seemed to stay, so I figured maybe just a small assembly mishap. It was pretty tough setting the date, the "middle position" was very hard to hit. After 2 days, I decided to return it for an exchange. When I press in the pin, it no longer lights up. If I fuss with it, edging it in and out a few times I get get it to glow, but it's a pain. Hopefully my replacement won't have this issue. I'll update the review when I get it.

Edit: The replacement has worked flawlessly. Updated to 4 stars