I purchased these from another source about a year ago. They have held up fairly well during that time. At this point, they are beginning to fall apart. The inseam of where the thumb and the finger meet has begun to de-thread a little. The grips have worn down a considerable amount, but are not considered obsolete at this point. The edges of the fingers have begun to fray a little bit, not much, but upon closer inspection it is noticeable.
The palm portion has help up great, it has started to wear down, but no holes have appeared on the outside. Though on the inside, I can feel where my finger tips have worn down the palm material fairly thin. You notice it when you grab something.
The top side shows little wear and the velcro is still holding up very well.
I purchased a medium, and the fit is slightly snug. The large was too big, and the small way too small.
In term of warmth? They are thin gloves so don't expect miracles. I am however able to go about my business in colder weather and take my hand out of my pockets and do simple tasks. They provide a barrier against the cold, though not a solution. Thicker gloves would be recommended for anything under 20F.
As far as tactile abilities go? I have full functionality an full dexterity.
Would I recommend them? Yeah, I suppose so, but I did get mine when they were on sale.