I think it's true to size. I bought a half size larger than I normally wear because 1. that was all that was left and 2. I figured I would wear thick socks and some sort of insert for arch support. With crew socks and a slim insert, its still a little large. I'll need thicker socks for the fit to be right. But that's ok and the color is nice and rich, and it's a good shape. The top of the boot just grazes the ankle instead of going above the ankle, which is a better look for me. It doesn't provide much arch support so you do need inserts. At $100 not worth it, but on sale for half that, definitely a good buy.