I bought this to replace like items where the zipper had failed because the tiny metal tab broke.  It also has a good, useable clip to attach the case to a belt loop, etc.  Good value for the money.  For my purposes I would prefer that this would be smaller and shaped more like a hot dog bun, and the zipper track could be sturdier.  I would pay more for these improvements.

Update:  After only two months, the vinyl pull tag on the zipper fell apart.  The zipper slide is big enough that I can use that, or put a ring through it.

Update2:  August 1 and the webbing holding on the belt clip has ripped and failed.  More like a one-star now than four.