I found it to comfortable and roomy for a big guy like me and I like that I've been able to maintain the depth of color by washing it inside out and not drying it in the dryer (except for a couple times by accident). I don't give it 5 stars because, like all sweaters I've come across for big men, the sleeves run long---way long. My arms may be too short but I don't encounter the sleeve length problem with shirts, suit jackets, coats, etc. so I don't think it's my arms.