I am one of those extraordinarily picky shoe people.  I have been looking for ankle boots to suit me for three years.  When I saw these online I knew it was the look that I wanted but the price made me worry since I couldn't feel them first but I went for it and overall and am very pleased.  They are actually reasonably comfortable the look on is fantastic. The slightly rounded toe keeps my size nine foot looking petite without looking too casual. The missing star is for the quality of leather.  It is really quite thin and looks like I could tear it with only a few scuffs but that really remains to be seen.  It actually creases an wrinkles temporarily when you bend your foot.  This isn't a problem for the look...it looks normal to see that it's just...I know my leather and the way this crinkles I can tell its a thin crinkle if that makes any sense.  :)  So  I am keeping them and am happy I will probably just have to wear them carefully...  A usually difficult thing to do for me.  At 95 dollars the leather should have been more substantial.