I rated this a 4-star because I did not feel the product itself was problematic, however this ring it is much darker than the picture portrays.  I am still deciding if I really like it.  If you cannot tell from the picture the etching is flush with the surface of the ring.  I am fine with that; it is the darkness I am not sure about.  In the picture it looks similar to a white gold or platinum ring but it almost has a black shiny quality to it.

We bought two rings this one first for me and it was too wide and too large of a size.  I anticipated that so that became my husband's ring.  I got the 5mm for me and it looks better on my hand.  We like that the rings match, it looks excellent on my husband, I just cannot decide if it is feminine enough for me.

I am a nurse and my engagement ring and wedding band with diamonds are just not practical and over time my husband's ring became too tight.  So this was a good option for replacement.

Pros:
Shiny
Very sturdy
Great deal $39.95
No chance of bending, breaking or scratching.
Comfortable
Seems true to size based on measurements at a jeweler

Cons:
Darker than pictured
May not look quite as feminine

Hope this is helpful!

Update: 2/4/13....I am not wearing this anymore.  I decided that it really is not for me same reasons I stated in my cons and another con that I did not mention above was that it is thick as in stands out from finger.  It was confortable but felt to clumsy after awhile.  My husband still likes his.