I don't know what kind of product the bad reviewers got, but it certainly wasn't what I got. The product I received is durable (mind you, I was cautious about it and thus trimmed my nails before hand).The product looks great and feels smooth to the touch. I am 5'3" and it fit well enough to be worn with a garter belt. I would recommend this product to others looking at this, as this material is not as flimsy as some of the other stockings I have purchased from other specialty stores.