I am actually on my second pair of these boots.  I love them and wear them constantly.  I would recommend them to anyone looking for a nice fall boot but not wanting to shell out a lot of money for something nicer.

*Pros*
1) Price - cheap, cheap, cheap!!

2) Fit - These boots fit true to their size.  I find the soles comfortable and the height just right (at 5'1" they come up about 2 inches below my knees).  They have a zipper from top to bottom to close so they are easy to put on.  The width at the top is fine for me, just big enough to wear skinny jeans underneath.  If you have wider calves though these are definitely going to be too tight.  I will say they do stretch out a bit so keep that in mind if you cramming jeans in there often.

*Cons*
1) Durability - my only compliant is they aren't made to last.  After about a month the sole started to tear away from the shoe.  I fixed it with some super glue and they have been fine since but they definitely aren't the kind of boots that are going to last you 10 years.  Count on wearing them for about a season and having to purchase new ones.

2) Not weather proof - I didn't expect them to be waterproof or anything but these definitely aren't something to wear on even a damp day unless you want wet socks.  They also have pretty minimal padding and the faux suede just doesn't protect against the elements.  I double up on socks when I wear these to keep my feet warm when in normal boots I am normally fine.