I didn't want to give these shoes three stars, because there is nothing wrong with them, but they aren't as great as other Frye shoes I've bought.  They are pretty true to size, and width, and are quite comfortable.  The top exposes a little more foot than I like, but not enough to show the dreaded "toe cleavage."  My main complaint really is that while other Frye shoes that have the distressed leather look in pics have a great quality of leather that is thick and soft and smooth (with the variation in color built into the leather) the distressed look here is more of a surface thing, and the lighter color is on top, and rougher.  Also- these are less of a rich chocolate, and a bit more of a duller brown.  Again, a nice shoe, but not what I'd hoped.  They would go well with casual jeans.  (I guess.  casual jeans and casual heels are an odd combination for me)