I would've rated it 5 stars for quality and aesthetics, but the cons were significant.

PROS:
super easy to put on (much easier than most kimono-style onesies)
great quality
soft
really cute

CONS:
too small: My daughter (not a huge baby) is just shy of 4 months old and this onesie barely snaps comfortably over her disposable diaper. (Not the case over her cloth diapers.) I can't see how this will still fit her over the next 2 months, which means it isn't a great value because we just received the onesie.
wider neck than pictured: exposes a little too much chest for cool weather