I love how comfortable these boots are.  I wore them over yoga tights and jeans most of this fall, until it started to get wet and cold outside.  The boots may be cozy, but they aren't exactly weatherproof and I'm pretty sure water would go right through them.  Still, I'd have given these five stars until I noticed a few days ago that the soles are becoming delaminated--the layers are peeling apart--about two inches from the toe has already pulled away.  That's a real disappointment.  A couple of months of wear, a product over $100, and it's falling apart already?  Trust me--I've worn the boots a lot but I haven't been hard on them.  Lots of walking on carpeted floors and driving--nothing that should lead to soles falling apart.  I've enjoyed these boots a lot and will probably repair the soles (if I can), but buyer beware.