I have had these for six months and they are just one of the best boots ever. The fit is perfect, they fit like a glove, and the assembly appears quite sturdy and has held up quite well. It is a work boot so I would not suggest wearing it as a dress boot, but when cleaned up it presents well. It has fairly good water proofing, I have not gotten wet feet even though in wet tracks. Thus they are sturdy, fit well, and would definitely get another pair when necessary, or even before.