I've tried on this boot locally and thought it would be safe to order the same size online.... NO.  These boots were maked my size, but ran a full size short, and the arch area was super tight.  The lesson is that Frye boots are not cut identically and you really do have to try on the pair you plan to buy before you buy them
I had to pay shipping (twice) to return these because they did not fit.  Learn from my mistake.