Great length (I'm 5'2" It is mid calf or longer), color, fabric, style.  It is warm, I live in Northern CA, hate the cold, it does the job.  No problem with shipment. I got the XS, maybe it is a little small for me, but it's okay, I can have suit jackets under it without a problem and somehow it feels okay.  But if not zipped, I need a good scarf because there is no extra.