Just got these, and they are very comfortable, fit well, and appear well made.  That said, the leather is very coarse and stitching is light brown.  They look somewhat dressy on the picture, but they are not.  This style is very casual and will not go with anything other than khakis--not dressy enough for wool, ridiculous and tacky with jeans.  While I rated it 4/5 for comfort and quality, I really wish they had better pictures.  As it is I'll be returning these just because the styling isn't right.