I got this shoe for a river rafting trip in the Grand Canyon.  Normally I wear an 8.5 in athletic shoes, but I got this shoe in an 8 and it fit perfect.  These shoes are really comfortable, easy on and off, and not too bad looking.  I used them for several side hikes where I hiked about 2 hours.  I didn't even wear socks with them on the hikes, never got a blister, and they worked well.  Not a hiking shoe, but good for short hikes.  The traction is great whether it was sheer rocks, in the water, or on slippery, slimy areas.  They drained well when filled with water.  The only reason for not giving it 5 stars is that I don't think they were quick dry.  They did dry overnight, but otherwise stayed wet.  They aren't mesh, but more of a plastic/strange material that stayed a little wet.  They did dry fine overnight though in cold temperatures without having to remove the inserts.
These were my first pair of water shoes, so I have nothing to compare them to.  But they were a good price, comfortable, drained water fast, and had good traction.  A pretty good shoe.