I love these boots.  I usually wear an 8 1/2, but had to send these back for a 9 1/2 and perhaps could have used a 10.
This boot does run quite small.  As soon as I got them I did the Mink Oil treatment to keep them waterproof and in good shape.  I got them on sale and the price was very good.  They are quite good looking and do well for casual wear as well as for a New Years Eve bash.  I almost hate to wear them they are in such pristine condition now.  I guess Frye will keep making boots, though.
Buy a pair!