I had to return this item because I ordered 1/2 size larger than my regular size (which is what I typically do for boots), but they run pretty large, so I would order your true size. They didn't have this item in my size, so I returned them. My review is based on inspection upon receipt and walking in them around the house.
Pros:
Grained leather is super nice. It appears pretty sturdy and the boots have a very pretty look to them. They are attractive looking. Heel is perfect size (under 3 in) and they are very comfortable to walk in.
Can be worn with skirts both casual and business/dress. Also great with tights.
The boot is not too tight all around - which I like so that you can wear it with skinny jeans.
Cons:
They appear to be large around ankle and foot. Would not wear them with pants for this reason.
There's a 'Peter Pan' lining at the top of the boot (not THAT noticeable, but not something I like).
Would not wear them with pants.
They run pretty large.
Not sure if they would be long lasting - due to how sole under toes is done (heel will/would last). Not sure how I'd care for them.

My order was through Shoe Metro. I give thumbs down because I didn't get free return label for shipping (unless you want store credit - ShoeMetro only. This would be OK if it was AMAZON credit!). Had to pay for shipping out of my pocket. For an item that was $100+ I give both Amazon and ShoeMetro thumbs down for this.