I just got these boots from Amazon, and right out of the box I knew they were keepers.

The leather is really beautiful, though perhaps the color is not quite as warm as that shown in the website image. Perhaps because of that, the color of the wooden heel stood out to me more in person than online, too, but I got used to it pretty quickly. I get compliments on these boots every time I go out. The thing people usually notice is the strap that goes across the laces at the top - haven't really seen too many boots with this.

In terms of the sizing, I stuck is the normal width, even though I have a wide foot. I have another pair of Timberlands that I did the same with, so I knew from experience that the initial snugness I felt would go away after a day or so. I can wear these with medium-thick socks and be completely comfortable. Love these boots!!