I'm an avid hiker in "Rocksylvania" and buy ultralite gear.  I saw these boots adviertised as 1 lb somewhere on the web, but they are 1# 12oz.  I am used to hiking in Saloman Trail runners which truly are comfortable and light.  I wanted something waterproof for winter and these reviews (and zappos) convinced me to try the purple (which is sharp).

My opinion:

These have no cushioning are are no better, softer, or lighter than any other hiking boot Ive owned through the past 2 decades.  I'd call them sturdy and stiff with a very good grip.

Furthermore, on steep downhills my toes were jamming into the hard front and were sore.  At the end of 15 miles my feet were sore, which is never the case with my Saloman's (which are soft and cushy inside, very protective on outside, and light).

I see why boots are out for hiking and backpacking.  All these reviews made me think these were comfortable.  Same old same old in a cool color.