I'll chime in to confirm what other reviewers have said--these boots are ideal for slim calves and long legs. I'm 5'6" and they hit a little high on me (a little bit over the lower edge of my kneecap), but not too high to make them unwearable. I've been searching everywhere for a tall boot to fit my 12" calves and not look ridiculous. These look great with leggings and cords/jeans tucked in. (Though I can see how the zipper detail at the top might snag tights.) I'd say they're true to size. Unfortunately, these either weren't made in a 9.5 or they've since sold out. A 9.5 would be perfect for me, but I was able to squeeze into a 9 and I think it will be ok. My toes graze the front, but the rounded toe gives a little more room. I tried both the black and khaki, and the khakis have just a smidge more room in foot length and are a tiny bit shorter in shaft height, so I'm keeping them. The khaki are a great neutral color. I can't believe this sale price--grab 'em while you can!