The good: This shoe is definitely good looking and felt very comfortable.  I ordered two prs of different color.  The bad:  Out of the box, I noticed one of the shoes had the appearance that the sole was separating from the leather.  This did not leave me with a good feeling on the quality of either prs, so, I returned them both.  Now the great:  Amazon gets 5 stars for being a great company to do business, but I am rating this particular shoe and for that reason it gets a two.  Sebago makes great shoes,  I just don't feel comfortable giving these a try.