This is really a nice pair of shoes with traditional design.  They are very light and great for daily wear.  Couple negatives prevent a 5/5 score.

1.  The shoes are quite slippery on first use given the leather soles but improved after a week or so.
2.  The heels are rubber which do not produce the "click-clack" noises, which I like (but this is personal preference).
3.  First couple wears, these shoes were uncomfortable because they dug into the back of my ankles and actually cause abrasion at the lateral malleolus (that bony protrusion on the side of the ankle) but got better after a while.