I'm so glad I found these--I have been looking for years for an orthotic-friendly sandal and these are great. I can now give them 5 stars because I'm done breaking them in. I would have given them 1 star in the first month I had them--they were killing my heals--rubbing huge blisters up and down my calcaneal (Achilles') tendon, but that's possibly because I had my orthotics in which make my feet sit lower in the shoe than the insert that comes with them. I stuck it out, really out of necessity--I've never found another pair of sandals my orthotics will go in that have a supportive base--and it's paid off. I can wear them all day now with no discomfort. I think they're really cute (of course, I'm stuck with all orthotic-friendly shoes now, so my definition of a cute shoe has changed a bit!) I got the light neutral color so they go with everything, and they've held up well--I've now had them a year and a half. I also now own the lace up shoes and two pairs of Mary Jane-style shoes from the same Dansko collection--Arcadia, I believe. They all have the issue of being slightly too deep when I take out the inserts they come with and put in my own, but so far it hasn't been a real problem and they bother my chronic peroneal tendonitis less than any of my other shoes. I hope they keep making these sandals--I would buy another pair even though they need some breaking-in time.