I love the style of these boots, but it is clear that they were manufactured at two totally different times, possibly in different places. The soles are constructed of different materials, not perhaps obvious when you're walking down the street, but certainly when you are eyeing them when you open the box. Even the font and color of the size number is totally different (not that that affects the overall appearance). The color is described as "distressed" and indeed they are that - if you are expecting something to look like a shiny new boot, these don't; they black stain is rubbed in inconsistently throughout the boot. They are a bit narrow in the heel. I typically wear an 8.5 or 9, and I bought a 9 in these. I have athletic calves at 14.5" and they allow room to tuck in a pair of skinny jeans without being too saggy.