Bought the Hush Puppies Strategy WW, Dunham Bryce Oxford 4E, Rockport Editorial offices plain toe 4E as I have wide feet with a bothersome bunion on the left foot.

Hush puppies definitely the best built of the 3 pairs with the full leather upper vs. the nylon cloth inside the Rockport and Dunham.

Rockport looks a bit sleeker than the Hush Puppies, but feels far less 'substantial'.  Also slightly less wide than the Hush Puppies which was rubbing against my bunion a bit.

Dunham looks the most casual of the three because of the stitching on the side of the sole and the sole being a more casual design than the Hush Puppies and Rockports.

Hush Puppies is the only pair of the three that hugs my heel so there is little slippage.  The leather around the ankle has a nice snug feel compared with the Dunhams and Rockports.

The Hush Puppies leather is the shiniest (perhaps just a bit much) of the three pairs - time will tell how this holds up.  FWIW, it's also apparently waterproof, and not heavy like other waterproof shoes I've owned in the past.

I intend to keep the Hush Puppies as they are the most comfortable on account of the snug heel, little slippage and wide toe box.  Also because it appears to be built the best of the three and I really abuse my shoes.  Will post an update in a few weeks.