overall I'd say these are decent gloves.  I can't speak to long term durability as I just received them.

As soon as I took them out of the bag they were shipped in, I could tell right away they were severely dry.  I have some leather conditional on hand, so I rubbed in a fair amount; probably about an oz. total.  They are much more pliable and feel a lot better.  So, do your self a favor, if you don't already have some, get a good conditioner.  Even if they were shipped well moisturized, this is something you should have on hand for long term care anyway.

I have pretty large hands and the XL work well.  If I did XXL, I'd have excess space in fingertips.  As it is, my fingers do feel a little jammed up, but with I'm breaking them in and I think they will be fine.

again, not knowing if they will last long, I'd say these are a good pair of gloves for the price.  I'm sure with proper care they will  last long enough where I don't feel like I got ripped off.