I have been on a mission to find the perfect button down collar dress shirts for a while.  I ordered this shirt in blue and the color, cut and fit of this shirt was good but the material had a little bit of a shine to it that isn't obvious in the picture.

I am 6' tall and 190lbs.  My shirt size is 16/34 so I ordered the 16/34-35 shirt.  The shirt fit pretty well.  The sleeves were probably closer to a 35 than a 34 but was still acceptable.  The fit is more of what I would consider a "tailored fit" than what you would consider a "slim fit."  Not too boxy but not too skinny.

I was looking for a good classic oxford or pinpoint oxford button-down collar dress shirt.  I ended up returning this shirt and ordering the LL Bean wrinkle resistant classic oxford dress shirt for around the same price.  I found the material and construction of the LLB shirt to be much better and it also comes in exact sizes so I was able to order a 34" sleeve.

If you don't mind a little bit of shininess to your shirt this shirt will probably work well for you.