I bought these for my daughter as she is potty training. These are reward undies. She regularly wears pullups, but we want to switch her over to these once she goes to the potty on a more regular basis. Right now it's a hit or miss.  The carters undies are very comfortable for her, they have extra padding in the crotch area and a built in plastic-y liner, but it doesn't make any sound when she walks around in them. The colors are great, and makes her feel like a big girl. I would highly recommend these for other kids.