I wear a 6.5 EE shoe, I also overpronate. It is incredibly hard to find comfortable shoes under $100.  I have gone a few times to professional shoe stores to be fitted. I've tried Brooks and New Balance.  I have a wide toe base and my toe tends to push out the mesh on the New Balance shoes over time.  I do not have this problem with Brooks.  I have inserts I use that I purchased from a sports store.  My brooks allows these to fit in well and I am so much more comfortable in the Brooks Addiction than any shoes I have ever worn.  It stops my hips and knees from hurting and greatly reduces my overpronation.  It is very hard for me to find my size anywhere, let alone finding last years model that is cheaper.  Love this shoe!