This is yet another good looking, water proof boot from Timberland.  To summarize, here is what I think:
*Disclaimer: I am writing this having just taken the boot out of the box a few minutes ago

Pros
- The boot looks solidly made, from good material.
- Comfortable.  There is a slight cushion effect when I walk.  Doesn't need breaking in.
- There are many ugly water/snow proof boots out there.  This is probably as good looking as they get.

Cons
- The Burnished Brown color is slightly darker than I what I had wanted.  Not a big deal as it's still a nice color but just beware if you are picky.
- As many reviewers have said before, buy one size down.  I am normally a size 10 and a 9 fits me perfectly.
- They are a little bit too roomy above the toes.  Could be a little more slim (I'm such a New Yorker...)

All in all, great boot to wear for the snow/rain.  I had a pair of Timberlands that last me a solid 5 years before I decided that they just got too stinky for me to use.  These will last me a long time, I'm sure.