I have mixed feelings about these very cute, stylish boots.  I love that part.  I don't like the lack of cushion in the bottom of the boot, like it is non-existent.  Also, I did not realize that rubber toed boots are not going to keep your feet warm.  You will need to wear the proper wool socks with these boots.  I am keeping them as I don't spend a lot of time outside in the snow and mainly just need to get from point A to point B, so for that they are nice.  Easy on, easy off and they keep your pants dry, a must.  I will admit, I tend to get cold feet (no pun intended) easier than the next person so maybe ok for you.