I had ordered a black tie, but the seller contacted me to say they were sold out, and asked if charcoal would be an acceptable replacement. I'd planned on picking up a grey tie at some point anyway, and I didn't have a pressing need for a black one, so I accepted; figured I'd buy a black one later. Like every Jacob Alexander clip-on tie I've bought, it's well-made, with a good clip, a nice-sized bow, and a lovely satin finish. It feels good and looks great; I often use it to break up a black shirt, or complement a grey coat. Would definitely recommend.