I got this set of gloves for three reasons:
1) Color scheme looks pretty good
2) It should keep my hands warm
3) Metal fingertips for using a smart phone

Well, I'll give it two stars for looking pretty good.  The globes are pretty well made with good attention to detail, especially around the fingers.

It all starts to go wrong from there, though.  First, the sizing is a little too snug - I usually take a medium glove, but I should have got a large in these.  Next, as another reviewer noted, these aren't winter gloves.  They're not going to keep your fingers toasty for a day in the cold or snow.  They're better as wind protection on an Autumn day.  Last, the metal fingertips are not nearly as effective as others I've tried.  The metal pieces need to be smaller so that the phone can actually interpret them as a finger.  These pads are too large, so the screen just doesn't really pick it up at all.