This boot is very nice, has a great insole, and is well made but the fit of the leg is terrible.  I'm very athletic (marathoner,skier,etc) and I have large muscular calves almost a full 14" around.  This boot is practically 16" around at the calf...I measured it a couple times because I didn't actually believe it could be so massive. If you want a cute tight fitting boot at the calf this is not for you unless you actually have 16" calves.