I am a northeast girl living in south Florida, so I have multiple pairs of rain boots, including a pair of knee high Hunters - which I love. But I only wear the Hunters in complete downpours. My only complaint about the Hunters is that there is a lot of space in the show, so my feet slosh around a bit when i wear them and I hate that.

But the rest of the time, I just need something quick to pull on for a puddle day, cool morning, or walking the trails in the state park. I searched all over the Internet for a pair of "cute" all weather boots. I searched Columbia and Sorel, and had settled on a pair of Sorel's, but one more search proved worthwhile for this super cute shoe!

A lot of people complained of the shoe being snug, but if you know anything about timberland boots, they have always run a bit narrow. Depending on your foot, you might have to size down. I wear a 8.5 to 9 in heels and a 8 in flats, so I ordered the seven first to evaluate the size and yep the 7 was too small. The price was good, that I gave the 7 to my babysitter and ordered the 8 for myself (both in the classic Timberland tan and wheat colors) and they are a perfect fit - no sloshing! I have already enjoyed a couple puddle days, one cool day, and am looking forward to a hike through the state park in a couple weeks.

As others have commented, the buckle is just for show. You can lace the laces, but they don't tighten.

In short, give them a try!