I have a pair of these shoes in brown that I bought some time ago.  I love them, although they are getting older now and starting to show smudges and wear.  They are still comfortable, but don't look as good as they did.  I feel I got my money out of them and am not disappointed at all on their life.  They looked great with jeans or dress pants, and are comfortable and well built, although sometimes my friends would tease and call them my "manly shoes".  The only reason I haven't replaced this particular shoe yet is because I have gotten spoiled with the other Eastland shoes that are slip-ons, where these require lacing.  Not to sound lazy, but it is much easier when your hands are full to slip the shoes on or off at the door, rather than lacing in or out.  If an oxford is what you are looking for, I would recommend this one without reservation. They are comfortable, solid, and I didn't slip and slide in them in bad weather either.