But one star off for the slouch factor.  I have large calves so for sure thought these would stay up.  Nope.  But to be fair I did wear them with leggings so maybe jeans would help hold them up a bit more?  Don't get me wrong, they do not look bad slouched down, I just prefer them up.  They ARE supremely comfy though.  Just as comfy as my expensive U boots.  I would buy these again for sure.