This Canyon Brown scarf is a totally different color and material texture than is the Carhartt Men's Acrylic Watch Hat Canyon Brown (Sold by Smooth Shop). The cap is a light brown whereas the scarf is more of a dark olive brown. While I just got them and don't know how well they hold up after wearing and washing, as new items, other than the color and material texture difference, I would rate one or the other a 5 on its own. But for supposedly a matching hat and scarf, that don't match in material texture or color, not even close, they suck.