I bought these for my 12 yo daughter. She loves them and they fit well (went up a size as they run a little small with all the fur inside-plus I'm hoping they'll still fit her next year!). The main reason I'm giving them only 4 instead of 5 stars is that the inside seam of one book came undone after just 3 weeks of normal use. I sent them back and received a replacement, but that was just last week. I don't yet know whether these will hold up. I'm hoping it was just one bad boot and not an indicator of overall quality. I have a different style of Bearpaws and have had them over a year with no problem, so I'm fairly confident the replacement boots will be okay.