I chose one star bc these shoes were very uncomfortable. They actually made my feet hurt! I bought these bc they had such good reviews and I really liked the look of them. I have worn asics for about 10 years and have always been an asics fan but this style is not good for me. It felt like cardboard around your foot. I mildly pro-nate and was fit for the gel kayano 11 about 7 years ago and last week I was fitted again and they changed me to the GT 2000 asics. I really love those, they have a lot of cushion and are a much better shoe for me.