Shoes are basically cute & very comfortable.  The shiny part makes them look a bit like snow boots when you have them on, which I don't really care for.  But other than that, love that you can just slip them on & go!  Like others have said, the fit is a little awkward.  I wear 8-1/2 & went up to 9 based on recommendations.  The toe box feels comfortable because of this, however, the back part tends to slip off your heal a bit if you're wearing thin socks.  That's OK since I bought these mainly for colder weather, so will likely be wearing thicker socks most of the time anyway.