I am so happy with these shoes.  They are a little pointier than I expected but I quickly came to like that.  I have already owned a couple of other pairs of shoes from Aerosoles, and these are just as comfortable as my previous pairs.

The first day I wore these I went to volunteer to get out the vote.  I expected to be making phone calls but ended up being asked to canvass, walking around for a few hours knocking on people's doors.  I was nervous about walking for so long in shoes that I hadn't broken in yet, but I needn't have worried!  Straight out of the box these were some of the most comfortable shoes I've owned.  I also constantly get compliments on the style and color.

There are a couple of small things.  The buckles seem like they are a little further forward than I would expect, but they don't look funny or anything.  The little suede loop that you tuck the strap through is kind of hard to get it through sometimes.  They also turn my feet blue on the sides of my heels.  It mostly washes off in one shower though and is usually completely gone after two.  None of these things are enough to deter me from loving them whole-heartedly and rating them 5 stars!