I love the look of these boots! They're the perfect cognac color, and fit my larger cafls perfectly. I gave 4 stars though because my pair seemed to have little imperfections (discoloring, scuffs) that I still can't tell we're purposeful to the type of boot, or actual imperfections. Also, they don't really look like real leather. Even with those negatives, I still really like them and would consider them a great find!