I was hoping that this shoe fit because I love the arch support my Orthaheel sandals give me. I wanted a closed shoe for the colder weather.  I was wearing the shoe around the house to make sure that nothing hurt and they starting squeaking. I also noticed that the heel of the shoe is very wide.  I had midweight socks on and the heel of the shoe still flopped when I walked. I was also disappointed in the look of the material. It looked kind of cheap.  Had to return them.