I ordered the brown snakeskin shoe. The description says that these were leather shoes. However, some of the comments from other customers indicated that other colors were not leather. I decided to take a chance. These turned out to be cloth. Amazon needs to figure out a way to accurately indicate what the shoe material is when they have different colors in the same style. I can't speak for the sizing - I decided to return them as soon as I saw the material. I personally do not like to wear man-made or cloth shoes because they wreck havoc on my feet. I'm only giving it one star because I feel this is false advertising.