I bought this in January.  Shipping was super fast and I was very pleased with the ring upon arrival.  The comfort-fit band is easy to wear.  It's now April and even with daily wear, all the stones are still in place and the color is flawless.  I'm a SAHM, so that means my rings are exposed to laundry, dishes, gardening, and dirty diapers all day long.  Even the tickle monster can't destroy this ring!  My only reason for holding out on the 5th star is personal preference- the edges on either side of the stones are squared giving it what I consider a cheaper appearance.