If this review was for comfort only, then I would give 5 stars. They run true to size and have great support for flat - incredibly comfortable, cushy soles. You could walk around all day in these shoes. Also, the brown leather is a nice, rich shade and the bow is a good, feminine detail. However, the overall shoe shape is like a potato and makes my slightly narrow feet look very wide. I did not find these to be flattering.  I expect a ballet flat to be slim and delicate looking. These are too clunky for me. I have to give only 3 stars because they lack style.