I absolutely love the color and the style -- it's a nice, versatile boot and so far these are wearing well with daily use. They are comfortable to wear all day, as they are not quite as heavy as some winter boots can be.  I got a 9 (usually I wear an 8/8.5) and these fit perfectly -- maybe too perfectly -- although the the ankles are a bit wide.

While they keep my feet dry, the "warmth" rating on the included tags has got to be an exaggeration, because my toes are freezing in these boots (after about 30-45 minutes of being outside), and because of the exact fit, I can't get a thick sock in there that might keep my feet warmer. In fact, I suspect that my feet are actually sweating inside the boot and that's why they feel cold. A 10 would be waaaay too large for me, so I'll have to experiment with different socks if I want to keep these boots. Also, the tread on the bottom is not particularly impressive.

Edited: I'm taking off one star because these boots leak all along the edge between the rubber bottom and the textile shaft, as well as the top of the shoe. They are also not fast drying. Don't wear these boots in rain, sleet, or deep snow.