I love this coat.  I gave it a 4 because the pockets are very high.  I'm 5'7" and the pockets hit my ribcage.  But I wore this all over Europe in late winter and it was very rainy and very cold in some places.  I was warm and dry the whole time.  I carried an umbrella because there are no waterproof qualities, but that was fine with me for a coat that is so beautiful that I've gotten compliments on it on 3 continents.