Let me start by saying I am not giving up on these shoes but the pair I received appeared mismatched. The right shoe was far bigger, bigger than mere stretching out would accomplish, and it was such a darker color my husband asked me why I was wearing two different colored shoes. I am receiving a replacement next week and hope for better luck.

***Update***
I received the replacement pair of the Park Hills flat in mint and happily they not only match in size and color but they also feel true to size or maybe a tiny bit on the roomy side. They seem comfortable out of the box but that might be the roominess talking. Looking forward to testing them out...

Btw as another reviewer pointed out the mint is a pleasant pewter shade.