I just received these last night, ordered the tan in size 8.5.  I am really disappointed as these sandals are so cute but incredibly wide.  So wide that they slip off my foot.  I wear a medium width shoe and these are almost as wide as Fitflops, which those of you who own them know they are cut wide.  The sizing width, whether it is from the manufacturer or supplier is mislabeled, should be labeled as a wide width.  Therefore, I give them 4 / 5 stars due to sizing mislabeling.
1) Arrived within days of order placement
2) Came well packaged
3) Gorgeous sandal / very fashion forward
4) Leather quality nice for the price, very soft, and color (tan) is great
5) Footbed is incredibly comfortable
6) Non-slip sole, easy to walk in
7) Sandal is a standard WIDE Width