I've had a pair of these same boots, in hickory/tan color, for more than a year, and really enjoy them for wearing around the house, or just hanging out at a friend's place, etc.  They'd held up well overall - just some wearing of the fleece on the inside sole; but then, I don't really ever wear them outside, or do a lot of walking in them.  They are the closest look to the big expensive "U" brand I've found, at a much better price, and so very comfy and soothing.

So I decided to get another pair in gray to alternate with the tan ones.  The quality appears equally good, and actually the fleece is already holding up better than my first did.  However, while I ordered the same size (9 - I'm usually 9/9.5), these fit noticeably smaller all around, including length, but especially the circumference at the ankle, which makes tucking pants in more effort. To some extent this will probably improve as the fleece gets worn/compressed.  I would also say that I'm less enthused about the gray color than I'd hoped.  It's a little more bluish than charcoal, and so matte and fine it looks almost more like ultrasuede than the real thing.

If I had intended to wear them more publicly, I might have returned these for another color, or tried a few different pairs of the same size, to see how they vary in fit and appearance.  But for my purposes, at this price, it wasn't worth the trouble -- I'll just keep these and enjoy them.