I'm amending my previous review:
I have the 'milkshake' color which has been permenantly discolored so I have to accept that my shoes look dirty all the time. I can deal with that. I cannot deal with the fact that the sole comes apart at the toe area. Within two weeks of occasional wear the rubber detached and now flaps while I walk. The rest of the shoe seems sturdy so I'll keep 3 stars, but I have take them to be resoled which is absolutely ridiculous considering how little they've been worn. I would recommend a different oxford to anyone in the market. Should have gone with the Cole Haan....

I was between this shoe and the Cole Haan oxford but chose this one because the style was similar but the color was more muted. I didn't want to regret spending what I think is not an insignificant amount of money on shoes that will be totally dated in a year. These definitely have a masculine vibe to them and will not live up to the scrutiny of a good men's shoe review. My boyfriend scoffed that they were cheap shoes because the soles were not stitched. I personally have not seen a pair of women's shoes under $200 with a stitched sole. If anyone finds a pair, please let me know.

That being said, they're comfortable, run a smidge larger than expected (not quite a half size), and look like the picture. They're a more solid shoe than many. I recommend a colorful lace to make them a little less like you stole your grandfather's shoe... unless that's what you're going for and then by all means.