I like this shoe overall, but a couple things bother me:

 - It's a "polished" shoe, which means unlike other boat shoes I've used you can scuff/scratch the shoe's finish, leaving marks that don't look good.
 - The interior of the shoe isn't as kind to bare feet (which is how I wear these types of shoes) - the comfort isn't bad, but it's not great either.

They look very nice, the sole looks like it will last a long time, the materials and construction quality are good.

I usually wear a 13 or 13W and the size I ordered  (12WW) is OK (a little thin, but OK).