My son said he would give it 5 stars. It is his favorite hat. I love it that it is reversible. The mushroom on the mostly-black side is stitched, which is very nice. The mushroom on the green side is starting to crack just slightly from it being rolled up and put into coat pockets. But that is to be expected after a while with screen print. But I love that the stitched mushroom won't have that problem.