I purchased the FRYE Wallace Saddle (Tan/Black) in March for my college-age son. He had seen the style previously and told me he would like a pair one day. I purchased them based upon his normal FRYE size of 12D (he has two other FRYE shoes/boots), the fit was perfect. In fact, every pair has been a perfect fit. He has told me they are actually the most comfortable pair he owns which is saying something, since he wears Frye shoes everyday. The Wallace has a rubber sole and heel which adds to the comfort. The style is excellent because different without being over-the-top, and he doesn't see his shoe coming & going on his campus. They are so comfortable, he told me today he would like them in a second color!