Pros:
* Price - I got them (5-10 years ago) on sale for $25.
* Style - At the time, the square toe look was "in" even though it's gone out of style since.

Cons:
* Heavy - my shins would be a little sore after wearing them if I hadn't in a while.
* Uncomfortable - I usually only wore them for dressier occasions and they were fine but when I tried to wear them all day at work, my feet started hurting and I had to get insoles.

Other:
* Durable - they have held up fairly well over these years but then again I really only wore them on average maybe once a month.
* Sizing - fine but they felt a little loose especially if wearing dress socks.