As first I considered ordering this in a Size 9 based on other reviews, but I'm glad I went it a Size 8.5. It seemed snugged at first, but once broken into, it fits perfectly. I love wearing this shoe for going to classes, yoga, running errands, etc. It easily slips on and off. It seems silly, but I wear little feet liners with these shoes. It doesn't show, and keeps them clean. I hear if you continuously wear Toms without any socks, they stink really bad, which is how most of my flats end up. So just a good tip to keep the smelliness at bay.