The only reason I don't give this a 5 star review is the sizing issue.  I actually had to return the 8.5 and exchange it for a 9, and even so it's just barely right.  Nevertheless, they're cute as can be, and very comfortable.  I think as they "soften" the fact that my toes are just about touching the end of the shoe will be a non-issue.

So definitely, if you're on the fence about which size to choose, opt for the next half (or even full) size up.