The Ice Maiden (black) is a keeper. I'm usually a size 7.5/8 and though these boots in size 8 were a tad too roomy, they were worth keeping because all its other features make it worth wearing. They're stylish, have a tongue so that you can tuck in pants, and are comfortable to walk in. They're not clunky like most other snow boots. I haven't worn them in the snow yet, so I can't say if they stay dry even after the snow melts on the boot, or if they're waterproof (sometimes melted snow seeps in through the seams of winter boots.) so I'll find out when I wear them out.