I gave it 4 stars because, I use theses bibs on an open cab tractor with a snow blower, and the seat always ends up having snow on it, as the snow melt , it infiltrate the bib through the crotch seam , so every time I get them off there is a little wet spot inside,nothing major, other than that it is Carhartt quality, totally waterproof, thick material, good quality, just not made to seat your butt in water.