This shoe gets a good rating because overall I do love it. I think the hesitations I have are because of my particular foot. I have 80% Nine West shoes. In pumps I am a 10.5 - ALWAYS. So I ordered a 10.5, but it was sliding off the back of my foot just enough to annoy me or embarrass me if given the opportunity. Yet the width was IDEAL. So I got some heel cushions which helped but darn it by the end of the day, my toes were squeezed a bit tight so I feel like I couldn't win there. And I KNOW a 10 would have been too tight.

I should mention that the photo of this shoe doesn't do it justice. I ordered the gunmetal grey and hotdamn this shoe is sexy. The insole is surprisingly comfortable.  And the platform is really unique looking but I think unlike many platforms, you don't feel like you are walking on stilts.