I love Clarks shoes.  I needed these boots for walking my puppy in the snow.  They are very well made.  They are waterproof.  The only thing I do not like about them is that they do not keep my feet warm.  I had to put wool inserts into them.  I wish they would have come in wide sizes.  I do not normally wear a wide shoe but these do run narrow and because of that I had to return my size and go one full size up.  If not for this I would have given them 5 stars.