These boots are very comfortable, good looking and a good value for the money. So, why didn't I give them five stars? Well:

1) The finish is not great (straightness of the seams, and the top rim of the boot are not particularly well done). It is good, but not great. It is fine for a riding boot, but I felt that it needed to be mentioned. Do not get me wrong; they do look good, are all nice leather and the fit is excellent.
2) The side closure, although works well and are easy to put on (despite of their 12" height), they leave a bit of a gap (you can actually put your finger in and touch your socks. It is NOT a gap in the sense that you can SEE the socks from the side (the leather does overlap for about 1/2") but enough to get some cold air in in a chilly day. This of no consequence in most riding weather, but it'd be great if the closure was better engineered.

Altogether a nice pair of boots SPECIALLY if you need a high heel. These have about a 1.9" heel (approx.) which goes a long way to making riding a tall bike a bit more comfortable and safe. The heel is well designed and not obtrusive at all.

The boots I ordered are EE (wide), fit perfectly well (i.e. they are wider than the normal width) and very, very comfortable.

In summary, although not perfect (what is?), they are a great pair of boots; even more so if you compare them against boots costing twice as much--or more--which are stiff, short, not so comfortable, and have low heels. I kept mine and would buy another pair when the time comes.