Needed a basic black loafer to replace a pair that finally fell apart after years of wear.  I like the Clarks  brand and generally find the shoes from this company to be comfortable and supportive.  This particular loafer has great arch support, however, I wish the insole padding was a little softer yet supportive (hence the 4 star rating).  I think I'm not quite a 7 or a 7 1/2 in this shoe (more like a 7 1/4) so I went with the 7 1/2 as I will wear socks with these shoes anytime that I wear them and I did not want the shoes to be too tight.