I had been looking for some shoe boots because I already had high heel knee high boots.  Came across these on amazon and the heel looked right; not too high.  I decided to order them and they are perfect.  I have them on now and they are very comfortable too.  I do agree with the other review regarding the shaft being a little wider than normal.  But for those who legs are a little thicker, these would work our perfect for you.  But if you have very thin legs, they may look like they are too big for you.  Again, I love, love, love these boots.