I ordered this for my boss for Christmas.  The tie appears to be well made and is fairly substantial.  The fabric is absolutely gorgeous!  The deep red to lighter red with the black accents are very striking and attractive.  He's worn it with light grey, white, and a very pale blue vertical stripe shirts and it looks very nice and professional.  The pocket square is a nice touch to bring the look together, but the pocket square wasn't as well made as the tie.  Granted, it probably doesn't need to be any more well made, but still.... I'd like to see some effort put into finishing out the edges with more than a simple binding.  If that happened this would definitely be a 5 star item.  The price was very reasonable for what I got.  I'd buy it again.