Well, I've been wearing them non-stop for three weeks, so these shoes go up a star to 4. Just wish they had a more structure. I'll probably buy another pair soon cause the fur is just perfect for chilly San Francisco / Oakland non-rainy weather.

I do like these shoes. But, they are not going to last, which is why I give them 3 stars. They are a little loose and the material flimsy, the shoe structure is less than I expected. Calling them outdoor slippers is about right. If these were beefed up I'd buy nothing but these for the Northern CA bay area, where the fog keeps the air chilled.