I chose the Roxy "Fargo" boot (twice) because it was a little lighter weight and looked better on me personally with slender legs but they run small. It was difficult to find a pair that fit. I had to try several times before I got a pair that was not too tight. They don't loosen up much after wearing them a while so, if you can't walk away in them, don't try to break them in and think they will stretch. They won't unless you get them wet. The "Fargo" is a little slouchy looking and the shaft is not too high. The shaft was a bit thinner and is softer made.

I wear them all day, every day, in cold weather. Warm and very comfortable in Ohio weather. Not for slush at all so you will want to treat them with weather protector before they get wet. They wear fairly well on dry ground. Not made for rough play or work but I really liked the style. Two years on the first pair and they still look great in black. I tuck the pants inside with a little layering at the top. Nice side zippers for easy on and off. The zippers create a nice snug fit at the ankle and allow air to circulate inside while they are not being worn. This boot looks much better on than in the picture.

Roxy needs to work on quality control on the size of these Fargo's. They Run small in 7 1/2

Update 3/20/13: Really love this boot! They are holding up well on the 3rd season's use. I wear them every day and still get compliments. They are warm and very comfortable. Don't walk through water with them because they will soak up water and lose their shape in the toe and instep area. Keep them dry if at all possible!

Update 11/24/14 / 4th Season: Still wearing the first pair. They are getting a little loose but I still get compliments. The sole is holding up well. I sprayed the inside with all purpose, odor eliminator, anti microbial to keep them fresh.
I don't walk in the rain, through slush, puddles or wet grass.  Just keep them dry and don't let moisture soak in. Easy on, Easy off. They were definitely worth what I paid for them. Love the style and bought more for when this pair is finished.