I love mine! I found these to be very sparkly and nice...perfect for the second hole in my ears (I have two on each side....which my husband doesn't like! ha ha!!) I really don't understand why people say they are "small". They are 1/5 carat TOTAL weight, so each earring is half that. Just like it says. Maybe people don't understand the size they are ordering. I did post a picture above of mine in comparison with other earrings I have so you can see.

I didn't have any issue with the clarity. They aren't flawless or even SI (slightly included) or VSI (very slightly included) (and the price and description reflects that), but mine are pretty nice. Again, maybe people don't understand the inclusion scale and expect very very good diamonds. Unfortunately, if that is what you want, you will pay for it. I suppose there are variations in the different pairs of I2-I3 items, and it is sort of a luck of the draw on how far on one end of the "I3" versus the good end of "I2". Maybe I got lucky, but I really like mine.

I do like that they are real gold (not sterling, not plated) and real diamonds. I have no problem with CZ, and I do have some jewelry made from it, but sometimes I like the real thing. :)  I also like that they don't have screw backs. I get it that expensive diamond earrings feel safer with them, but sometimes they are rough to shove through my ears and hurt a little. My butterfly clasps fit well and tight. TIP: If you (over time) do feel the clasps are too loose, you can gently squeeze them together (NOT on the post, but empty) with tweezers. The scroll-shape of each circular side will be closer together and when the post slides in, it will hold on more securely. I have done this with a few pairs of gold earrings (especially yellow gold) as gold is a softer metal and that thin shape of the clasp will loosen a little over time.