Loved the look, sale price, design, and feel of the leather. Fit was a little big for me, but amazon was out of stock on the size I would have needed. But the deal breaker for me was the annoying little buckle on the back heel of the boot.  It made noise with every step. Some might be fine with this, but it annoyed me.  Another reviewer mentioned it and said she will probably tape it, but that's just not acceptable to me for a pair of docs so I returned them and got a different style of docs.  Too bad for these.