It's a comfy pair of sandals but the opening is bigger than Keen Whisper. I do not need to tighten my Whisper to have a good fit but have to with Owyhee. But with Whisper, my little toe gets out at times but Owyhee keeps my little toe in. U'll have to decide which fits u like better. For me I got them both!!!

I only gave it a 3 star coz of the big opening..... Like the opening of Whisper more......