I previously had regular Red Wind Boots and these do not compare to them in quality or comfort at all. I figured that they are made by Red Wing so I at least expected similliar comfort but was really dissapointed in these. The first thing is that the insole is hard as a rock and feels cheap comapred to my old Red Wings. The second problem is that there is no linning inside of these and that really makes them feel cheap! If you are expecting Red Wing quality you will barely be able to tell that these are made by the same company. I would not buy another set of these again!