This shoe looks great with jeans or shorts.  The fit is about 1/2 size longer for me.  I normally wear a 9 1/2 and it feels like there is plenty of wiggle room in the front.  Maybe, this is done intentionally to allow one to slip them on and off without lacing.  The main thing is the width which I found to be true for a normal D.  This shoe will conform and mold to your feet and becomes more comfortable over a short period of time.  For me, I love the look and feel.  The quality is there, so no negatives from me.  I would not wear these hiking or for long walks.  It is perfect for casual wearing and boating.  Sebago makes a lot of different colors so you can match your style from the rugged look to preppy.