The band I replaced (very similar) was much thinner and worked better right out of the package.  I had a bit of difficulty getting this one "mounted" on the watch because the band is thicker and didn't want to fit under the pins.  But, once I got it attached and used it for a while, it's good, but not great.  I much preferred the previous band.  (same style, but different manufacturer)  I will look for the "other" brand next time.  There is nothing wrong with the band, this is just my preference.