I am giving the Jambu boots four stars because once you work out all the kinks, they are really comfortable and that is what a good pair of shoes is all about. The Jambu boots run small, really small! You need to go up one size, or at the very minimum a half size. The inner lining is a separate piece and moves when you try to to put them on and can get crunched up. The calf width is small to medium so if you have really big calves, they will be very tight.  By now you are probably wondering why I gave these four stars, well if you get the right size and get your foot into them, they are like a second skin. The rubber sole is designed to conform to the contours of your foot and it does this really well. I don't even feel like I am wearing shoes much less boots when I have them on. I can wear them all day and be comfortable. I can hike about in them, take long walks with my puppy or just hang around and they are comfortable from when I put them on till I take them off. They look great with pants, tucked in or not, skirts, dresses and leggings. Both the brown and charcoal are neutral colors and work with anything in my wardrobe, except dress up dresses :-)

Pros:  Light weight, comfortable, durable, stylish, able to tuck pants into them, look good with both pants and skirts

Cons: Run small (size up), Separate inner liner, smaller calf width size