I chose 3-stars because the strap is too short for the shoe. If the strap is pulled up onto the ankle it forces the foot against the shoe in an uncomfortable way because it is at least 1/2 inch or more shorter than the shoe size. If you look closely at the picture you can see how it is shorter. I like the shoes; however they seem to be an exaggerated shape for a normal foot. In other words the shape of the shoe is a bit too curved to fit a normal foot. It is as if these were designed without a foot in mind and just designed to match the Crocs that first came out. The color is good and they are well constructed. I just use them to slip on and wear out in the yard for quick trips. I would have liked to have used the strap, but since it was too short for both wearing as a strap on my ankle and to have across the top of my foot I cut it off. Had the strap been as long as the shoe I would have given it 4-stars and if the shape had been more straight (following the form of a regular foot) I would have given it a 5-star review. Oh well. I am going to keep them, but I am looking for a better pair that fits my needs. I guess this is another lesson in "you get what you pay for!"