I have been looking for riding boots for several months and the Lucky Hibiscus was the one! These boots do run large so I went down a half a size. I was swimming in a size 9 and the shaft fit loose as well. The 8.5 fit with just the right amount of feet room and the shaft is fitted but this did not bother me, knowing after some wear, the leather will soften and loosen. The boot is well made and comfortable. The leather is beautiful and has a nice finish. I highly recommend this purchase!