The only downside so far is the lack of Auto-Close feature which makes it easier for one-handed operation stepping inside your car for example. Other than that, this is close to my ideal umbrella...stylish, strong, and functional. As far as the perfect rating, I do love this umbrella and I don't miss the Auto-Close feature that much. Its much easier to close the umbrella compared to my other compact umbrellas (hardly any friction between the main shaft and supporting rib hub). I'd rather have the performance and durability versus compact and convenience. Just a few observations to help make your decision...

+ Nice pronounced arc shape of the umbrella, more so than compact umbrellas,  which provides both wind resistance and better coverage from sideways approaching rain.
+ Lightweight for its size, due to the main shaft and handle made of wood instead of aluminum.
+ Fully closed fiberglass tubes for supporting ribs, not like some cheap, open-channel (cross-section) aluminum ribs.
+ Umbrella's length is roughly 3 ft fully closed and the diameter of the canopy when fully open is roughly 40 inches across.
+ Fabric of the canopy is both stylish and functional. Seems more pliable than typical nylon.

- No Auto-Close feature, but its fairly easy to pull the umbrella to the closed position.
- Wooden shaft is not entirely rigid, does bend under slight pressure. It's less stiff than bamboo for example.
- Its not totally wind-proof, as it did invert when I jumped in the air and yanked down really fast, but it took a couple tries though.