My excitement upon opening the Amazon box quickly turned to disappointment.  First, the shoe was quite heavy as others have mentioned.  In regard to fit, my heel kept popping-out.  I realize a very thick sock might have made a difference, but I want a rain shoe that can be worn with any type sock.  Besides, I wore a regular athletic sock with these, not some ultra thin sheer.  I took advantage of Amazon's excellent return policy and ordered the 10s.  This time my heel didn't pop-out, but the shoes didn't feel snug either.  More importantly, my toes touched the front, so these were defintely too small.  The Baffin's do not come in a 10 1/2. The shoelace serves no utile purpose, the shoe cannot be tightened.  I'm gonna try a competitor "Duck-like" shoe.