I also have the Frye Campus Lug Boot in Walnut.  I bought Melissa in Black.  The Campus boot is made in the U.S.; the Melissa is made in Mexico.  I was a little disappointed they were not made in the U.S.  These are great boots though.  I usually wear a 9 and these fit well in a size 9.  They are comfortable and supportive.  I wear them several times a week and they still look like new after three months of wear.  I have walked miles at a time in them and my feet have been very happy and I have plantar fasciitis so that is really saying something.  Some key differences in this boot and the Campus boot:

  1.  The leather is stiffer and somewhat shiny.
  2.  They are narrower in the footbed.
  3.  The shaft is narrower-especially in the ankle area.
  4.  The heel is slightly lower.
  5.  The toe is more rounded than squared like the Campus.

All in all, I like them...but I love, love, love my Campus boots.