I chose this rating because they are just the right size, fitting as stated, and really do give my kid that 'classic' look under his other shirts.
I like that these last FOREVER [mostly because little kids don't sweat :) so no yellowish areas haha] and stains get out at least for me. I dislike that they DO tend to shrink after a while. *NOTE they do not after the first wash. I noticed this.
I recommend this to anyone with a little boy who dresses their son in that 'classic' way.