I liked that this boot was not big and clunky like most pack boots, and yet felt quite warm and was waterproof.  However, when I walked in them, it felt like I was walking on a hard surface floor with only socks on, even though it was on the carpeting in my house.  I do have to admit I have tender feet, but not all boots are this way for me.  There just wasn't enough cushioning in the insole, and I have had poor results adding or replacing insoles.  I wanted them for snowy winter walks in the park so I found a good boot elsewhere (Keen Anchorage Mens Boot).