Ok, so I love the Chestnut color. Ordered the Toyah's in the same size; and they were too small; but awesome arch support. These have almost no arch support; but have the wonderful sole that will never wear out. They don't fit great; but I really like them. Much flatter than Toyah's. Ordered arch/metatarsal inserts for these since they are so flat inside. As usual with Keen's; high quality. I would recommend these but you may need to put in extra arch supports....The elastic piece at the top is also a nice touch; and they don't look as 'clunky' as the Toyah's....so it's kinda a give and take between these two Mary Jane models!