So I am not a big boot person, but I will say that these boots are nice.  They are true to size.  They come with a white wax on them that provides more of a worn look. This CAN be buffed out if you prefer not to have it. I really like it and have received compliments on them from multiple people.  The bottom of the shoes are a little slick, due to them being leather, so I would recommend that you scuff them up first prior to walking on stairs or any wet surfaces.  Frye boots are pricey, but well worth it when you look at the quality and how long they will last.  You get what you pay for.  I like these better than the zip up James style. I ordered both but kept these only.  Hope this helps!