I gave these to my daughter for Christmas and she loves them. She is brand-conscious, and since she loved Roxy when she was little, she associates it with being little, so it's not one of her favorite brands anymore. Regardless, she is very happy with these slippers. Might I even say ecstatic? The fit seems true to size. In terms of warmth, there is little coverage of the top of the foot, obviously; in our house the main issue is our cold floor. The sole is sturdy enough and the upper fabric does not touch the ground as it does sometimes with slippers, such that she has worn these to school. These are not the slippers for someone who cant't stand toe cleavage, or who can't stand mismatching. It must have been a design choice that the two slippers are not identical to each other, as no attempt was even made for them to match up. My daughter likes it, others may not.