Just received the boots today, put them on and was instantly impressed. They are very well made and look like they will last for years to come. As far as the sizing make sure your order a size down, I did much research before ordering and all the reviews were spot on. For a general comparison ill use Nike Running shoes which many people own, I wear a size 12 in Nike running shoes, I orded a size 11 in the boots and I still have some wiggle room, if you like your boots tight and your a size 12 you could even get away with size 10.5`s. The leather is high quality, I was somewhat surprised with the sole of the shoes as its a somewhat rubbery and soft, If your walking on tile floors it produces little noise, it adds to the comfort of the boots. They have moderate arch support and feel great on my heels. I am normally a die hard timberland fan but wanted to try something new, was a little worried these would look a little to "fashion flashy"  but they are very rugged and masculine once you throw them on with a pair of nice jeans. Also after much research I applied KIWI mink oil to waterproof them and they darkened the color to a very slight degree but it is essential you do this if your going to be walking through snow/rain/sleet with them. So I suggest you buy a pair if your debating, they are unique from every other boots in every way, they won't disappoint!!