I normally wear 9E but I had to settle for 9D since my size wasn't available.  Sure enough, it was a little tight but nothing that couldn't be remedied by a little break-in with some leather stretcher which I have done.  I agree with the reviewer who noted the "plasticky" look of it but then it's a loafer and I'm not wearing it to a wedding.  As for the lady who said it was coming apart at the seams, well, I don't know about that.  I've been wearing it for about a month now and have noticed no such symptoms.