These are very good shoes with a sort of nostaglic look.  They are a somewhat wide though in the D medium with.
If you have a wider foot they will fit you very well.  Length is right on.  They are very comfortable and you can where them all day
they are well constructed and take a great shine.  The leather is very smooth and the inside is lined very nicely.
I would give them a 5, star rating, but the width is a little wider then it shold be for a D.
These look very sharp for dress and also look good with blue genes. The Amazon price is an excellent by for this quality shoe.
I really like them just wish they were a little less wide...