FIRST, by way of comparison (Everyone should include this when writing about product sizing!!!):  I ordered a size Regular (NOT Tall) medium. My measurements are 73.5" tall, 40" chest, 15.5 neck, 34" sleeve length, 32" waist, 163lbs.

Aside from a slightly tight fit in the shoulders, as others here have noted, this parka in size medium is a great off-the-rack fit for me.  And although the shoulders are a little tight, there is still room for me to wear the Woolrich Hanover vest under it.

One negative is that the draw-string around the waist only pulls in the back half of the parka without pulling in the sides or front.  This not only allows cold air to enter, but also does nothing to eliminate a boxy look from the front (well, really a rectangular look). Come on, Woolrich, make the draw-string pull in the sides and front, too!

The other thing I didn't like is the plastic zipper.  It works, all right, but it looks cheap.  But at least it's a two way zipper, and one that is not hard to start.

The parka shell is not shiny, as I feared, so that's another plus, although it's still not the most expensive looking material, either.  But for the sale price of around $100, overall it's a nice parka.