This was cheaper than the Bumpkins long sleeve bib and so I thought I would give it a go.  Here are the minor things that I dislike in comparison to the other product:
- the wrist isn't elasticized, and actually for my son, the sleeve is a little long, so I have to fold it over a bit and sometimes food gets caught in there.
-the pocket is a little bit less deep.
-over time, with repeated wringing, the bib looks a little worn but actually it's holding up fine.
Again, these are minor drawbacks and I still think it's a good value.