Based on previous reviews about these running big, I ordered my 'normal' size 11 knowing a bit big is far better than a bit small.  When the shoes arrived, they were very snug.  I had to return and order a half size larger.  (good thing Amazon's ordering/return system works so well)  Receive the 'right' size as promised.  The shoes are pretty comfortable but do have a few quirks.  First off, there is a slight pinch on the top of the big toe where the leather bends while walking.  Secondly, there is a decided 'pop' in the leather with each step, again in the toe area as the leather bends then relaxes with each step.  I'm hopeful that once worn a bit, both issues will remedy themselves.  The shoes are very nice looking and I've had several compliments on them already.  The toe pinch does seem to be going away and I hope the popping sound does as well.  The shoes appear to be very well made.  They are not light as the sole seems to be very durable.  All in all, I'm glad I ordered them as I expect them to be great shoes.  Just not the slipper feel I'd hoped for, but are very comfortable none the less.