These boots are adorable and I like the flaps both up and down.  I found them true to size, however, they are quite stiff initially and take some working in.  Also, consider ordering half a size up if you want to wear wool socks.  Otherwise, the shape is cute and they feel well-made.

Update - the flaps frayed within a couple of wears --past the allowance for an Amazon return.  I contacted the company directly and they replaced the boots right away.  No problems with the second pair.