I was looking for a brown pair of riding boots.  I wanted something that wasn't too big in the calf.  Comfort was a must because I won't wear a shoe that isn't comfortable.  These boots are awesome.  The colour is perfect, they fit well around my legs without being too bulky/gappy (I'm 5'8, 130 lbs).  Super cute, buckle detailing is awesome.  Very comfortable - wore them the entire first day without a single issue.  I bought them in black, too, and am keeping both pairs.