I am normally a size 10, and the size 9.5 I purchased fit perfectly. The shoes looked amazing and were very comfortable.
However, after wearing the shoes to the office only twice, the finish on the leather on the cap of the right toe started peeling off. By the time I noticed it, over a square inch had already peeled up.
I then began to inspect the shoe for other damage and noticed large needle sized holes that went through the same spot just under the stitching on the ankle of both the right and left shoe. On the inside of the shoe, you can see the pin holes easier, and there appears to be tiny scorch marks. I am not sure if this is from the manufacturing process and is used to hang the shoes during coating or drying, but it is noticeable from past arms length while holding the shoe.
I was very excited to own my first pair of Florsheim shoes, but after this purchase, I am not sure I'd be willing to order another pair. Especially when I can get an almost identical shoe from Bass for 10-15% cheaper.

As a side note, I called Florsheim customer service to inform them of the quality issue, and she told me to just handle it through Amazon and then the call was either dropped on her end or I was hung up on, as I was in an area with full reception.
I'm sure it was just an accident, but it didn't do much to help the sour taste in my mouth, especially after hearing how exceptional their customer service normally is.