I am wearing these for the first time today, and although they are comfortable for the most part, I am finding that my right foot doesn't stay put in the boot.  I normally wear an 8.5w, but I'm wondering with the cut of these if I could have done an 8.5m.  I also actually had to put on a thicker sock to help give my foot a little more cushioning as these boots definitely are lacking in that area.  But I have a feeling that by the end of today, the ball of my foot may have a friction and pressure blister simply from how much my foot has moved around in the boot.  I give the boot 5 stars for looks, but only 2 for true comfort.

This is not my first Annie's purchase and I can see a trend that A. you get what you pay for, and B. what you don't get is a quality insole to help absorb the shock your foot takes with each step, and that each step can actually feel flimsy.  I weigh 145 lbs and it makes me feel like if I weighed much more than that, that the arch or total sole in general may not be able to withstand it.  I am going to try putting in toe/foot cushions to see if that helps, but if not, as cute as they are they will be going back.