I bought this because it was on sale ($19) to replace with my room shoes which was a fake shearling boots priced at $25 two years ago.

Pros: #1. Price (You have to get it at sale price, otherwise, no reason to get this.
#2. Even though it is a paper thin, still a real shearling!  That means it doesn't smell like a manmade one when you wear 8 hours a day at work!

Cons: many reviewers already stated, though.
Soles are like a cardboard just no cushioning, arch support, flexibility at all. These even make a plasticky noise when you walk.
May require to be cautious when you walk on the street where you may slip easily due to inflexibility of the sole.
In addition to the above;
If it wasn't the price, things would bother me further were:
Shape of shoes that is very very widely rounded. This would be helpful to wide width people, but I'm on a narrow side, so my feet kinda slide sideways.
Shaft size are way bigger so that my legs are swing in them.  Probably thick legs people benefit from this.

So, sounded like lots of lots of complainants, right? Why is the 5 star?
My use is solely room shoes at work where I sit in front of computer all day except going to bathroom so in the reality, cons of these boots are not really matters in my case.