Well, at least the fit on my 10.5's were indeed true.  Everything else about these was pretty much awful, especially for $90, which should get you a decent shoe.  The leather (really?) was either the cheapest I've ever seen or was really vinyl or pleather, very glossy/shiny and completely lacking in depth and hard as a rock, not supple at all.  The worst part though was after I tried them on.  The area right as your foot enters the toe of the shoe pinches a lot as you walk.  There is almost no padding in the toe, and the combination of these factors had the ball of my left foot going all numb and tingly within just 6 steps and a turn... really!