=================
1=Bad, 10=Good
=================
Quality 4
Comfort 9
Durability 4
Materials 7
Fashion 4
Sizing 9
=================
[UPDATE]  After a month the shoes started wearing oddly.  All the stitching on the uppers is coming apart. The material the uppers is made from seems to be cheap and if they really are leather is some kind of poly impregnated leather.  Too bad. On the brown pair,  the coloring looks sprayed on.

I wear Oxford shoes to work every day. Tired of retying my shoes during the day or un-knotting double knots I decided to try slip-ons. Out of sheer luck I chose these Dockers. I bought a brown pair and a black pair and the black pair lasted over two years wearing them 75% of the time.  The brown pair lasted almost three.  After these wore out I decided to save a few bucks on another brand at Kohls but they didn't last but a few months before they were shabby and severely scuffed. So I decided to snag another pair of Dockers.  The quality seems to be exactly the same but the removable insole now has a gel pad on the heel,  a nice little comfort improvement. I highly recommend these shoes.