I really like this scarf for what it is, but I gave it 4 stars because the picture is a little misleading.  It looks like a warm winter scarf in the photo, but the knit on this scarf is incredibly loose.  When you pick up the scarf, it is more holes than fabric.  I was a little skeptical at first, but when you fold it over and put it on, it looks great.  This is a great scarf to dress up a plain outfit, and the red color is very nice and saturated.  I highly recommend, but only if you are looking for an accessory and not something to keep you warm in the snow.