I originally rated this boot higher, but given the fact I've gotten different type boots since then, consider them better, and view this boot as WAY over priced for its qualities, I down rated it to something more appropriate. If you're determined to buy USA made boots, accept that you're gonna pay more than necessary - $100 to $150 more most likely - and that higher price does not necessarily translate into a better boot. Danner makes a lot of boots, some of which are outstanding, I just wish they weren't so darn over priced.

You may want to consider the actual military equivalent: the Danner ICH 7" Military Comfort Boot. It is slightly taller and has a slightly different lacing system. Other than that, they are identical. It is also way over priced. I like this boot, but had I known about the ICH 7" military version I would have probably gotten it originally since its added height means a bit deeper water before moisture enters and maybe slightly better ankle support. To be honest, for a variety of reasons I would have probably never gotten the boot at all.

I intended for the Danner Crater Rim to be a backup, secondary boot, and since getting the others, that is exactly what it has become. It does have some good qualities - qualitites that should costs $100 to $150 less that what you have to pay.

Pros: The abrasion/water proofing thing that encircles the boot is not just glued on like most others, it is also stitched, which means it will NOT come off. Little things like that are actually big things and demonstrate design quality considerations that pay off when the going gets tough. I like its soul design. It appears to work well regardless of terrain. It also does appear to be a very durable boot.

Cons? First and foremost they cost way too much compared to other boots just as good or better. Second, I wish the tongue was a bit longer - 1/4 inch or so. When tied, the laces are near the very top extreme of the tongue, and they must be tied carefully to insure the tongue remains under the laces. That problem is not present on the military version. For most people it probably wouldn't matter. To be honest it may be because I have freakishly large calves. Third, they do not have adequate ankle support if you are looking for anything more than a basic hiking boot. If you intend to get a backpacking boot, you would be better served with the Oboz Wind River II or Beartooth models OR one of the Lowa offerings. Even the Vasque Bitterroot will beat this boot for backpacking and will cost less. I review that Bitterroot boot and consider it to possibly be the best for the price though not necessarily the best you can get.

This is a "boot" in every good sense of the word if you forget the hefty price - one you need not hesitate to get dirty and wet. I would wear others for extreme hiking with a backpack due to their additional ankle support and stride enhancement due to a stiffer soul, but other than that I often put on these when I intend to go where I expect trouble, filth, moisture, or rugged terrain.