Bought this on the Cyber Monday deals as I have wanted a nice peacoat since Peter Bishop wore won in Fringe. This thing is amazing! It is warm enough for the cold temps (27 this morning) and looks great on me. Thanks to another review here I knew to just cut the thread keeping the side pockets closed, not sure if I would have liked it as much without the pockets. One thing to note, the bib is nice but when left unzipped a bit it scratches the dickens out of my neck from the zipper tread. I just curled it into the coat a little bit to stop that from happening.

All in all I like this peacoat, it looks nice and is very much worth the $75 I got it for. I am not sure what the negative reviews are talking about in terms of quality or fit, mine looks good and fits perfectly (5'5" 170) with the only exception being it is a little tight around my arms as I am rather muscular.

*Review Edit*

So it has been a couple months since I purchase this. I still like the coat overall, but I have already had two buttons fall off due to faulty sewing on the manufacturers part. In fact out of the 6 buttons on the front I think only 3 of them are not getting lose and losing thread. Not a huge dealbreaker if you have some small sewing skills, but still rather annoying to have such a renown brand have issues with buttons of all things. Dropping this down to a 4 star.