I gave this 4 stars because it really does seem to be a good quality boot and it's nice looking too. I wasn't able to use them though because they are a very narrow fit. some people said to order a whole size up. That might work, but if you ask me, I think it would just make for a longer then I need narrow boot. If you have slim feet, I would recommend this boot. But if you have wide, or average feet, I would say no. Too bad, cause I loved the look and the sole looked like it would get good traction in the woods..