I purchased this exact same wallet from JCPenney many years ago and it is starting to wear.  Was very happy to find this.  The folks who said it was different as pictured probably ordered the other wallet like it (with the rectangular shaped strap).  I also ordered one of those and it is too small for my needs.  It doesn't have a separation in the money clasp area (like this one does) and it doesn't  have as many credit card slots.  I need plenty for Medical cards for my family.  IT really is a well made wallet and I love that it is made of leather as that lasts much longer than other wallets.  I really wear out my wallets and purses, and these last a long time.  I have a red one, so I cannot tell you about the other colors, but I am going to order a few more now for the future, in case they stop making them.