I gave it a 4 because it is tight in the upper shaft, never had that happen before. There is no way to wear it with leggings.  It's ok because for me this boot is for skirts and dresses. Also, the leather accessory strap does not lie flat against the boot, but instead hangs there a bit, but maybe will flatten over time. It is comfortable with a dressy yet not too high heel height. Good silhouette.