Super bummed out over these boots! After spying the gorgeous oxbloody red in vintage leather, I made my 2nd attempt to fall in love w/Frye. (Last year, the "Carson Tab Shortie" was a bitter disappointment). But ya gotta get back up on the horse.

As advised after reading dozens of reviews at various sites, i ordered the Jenna in a 1/2 size down. Though they fit a bit snugly in the toe bed, they were very wide at the heel. As I know this sort of leather eventually stretches, I, too, would advise ordering 1/2 down unless you wear a really thick sock. I wouldn't go as far as to say they were comfy--they're stiff, extremely heavy, and clearly require a break-in period. But I have an edgy fashion sense and am willing to endure some pain for the fabulous rock n roll meets moto look that this boot brings. Or does it?

The fit was exceptionally unflattering. So much for moto boots, more like rain galoshes. The top of the shaft--generous but not ridiculous for those with average calves--was not my issue. Rather, the ankle area was the big problem. I have dainty ankles but they're certainly not freakishly small. Yet the leather gaped around them and caused the least flattering silhouette I've encountered in a long, long time. (And I'm a total bootaholic). So having a block of leather add 3 inches of width to my ankle is not a good look--one I haven't rocked since the 1st grade when mom forced me into the aforementioned galoshes. I'm ok with a masculine, un slimming boot, but on me these looked more like footwear for Dr. Frankenstein's monster.

Additionally, diligent shoppers my notice that in various images, the Jenna Studded Short's hardware varies from a beautiful gold/brass to a silvery gunmetal. This may not matter to some, but I much prefer the brass. And I got the silver. I realize that a artisan brand like Frye will not produce identical dye lots or assembly line hardware, but not knowing exactly what you're getting is a tricky position. Had these fit well and appeared flattering, I could have overlooked the hardware. But at this price point, I need to LOVE the boots.

The color is indeed lovely, true to the online images and fairly even. I'm pretty tired of the intentionally distressed look, but these have just the right touches. I can't vouch for all the finishes, but my pair was evenly treated and clearly quality made.

Bottom line is Frye is tricky to fit. Many rave their Fryes are ideal straight out of the box. However a wide heel bed (slipped w/ every step), an oversized blocky ankle area, and supremely stiff leather means I'm back to the drawing board. It's trial & error with this brand.