Initially I was a bit concerned about ordering these boots, as I read reviews that were either "great!!!" or "bad!!!", lots of complaints about the boot shaft being too tall, off sizing, and difficulties getting them on and off, etc.  I'm very glad I decided to order them anyways, and I have always been happy with all of my other Betsey Johnson shoes.  I do think these boots run slightly small, as I always wear a 7.5 but went with an 8, and the 8 fits great with socks on.  I am also only 5'4" and I find that the shaft height is perfect, right at/below my knees, which is perfect, and the shaft width is great, too.  I have very narrow calves ("chicken legs"), but I loved the adjustable buckle at the top of the shaft, which I put on the tightest setting, and the fit is very comfortable and looks good, but not too large/wide, perfect with my jeans tucked in.  I find that the back zipper makes getting these boots on and off very easy, so I'm not sure about the complaints I read about these boots being difficult in this area, I actually find it to be the exact opposite.  Again, I have a narrow foot, and thin calves, so perhaps this makes the experience different for me??  The grey distressed leather is so stylish; the boots have a great worn-in look and they have a moto-western style I love, which is a great alternative to my more dressy, polished riding boots.  The leopard print lining is cute and classic Betsey Johnson, the weight and quality of the leather is nice, and the sole of the boot is hard, substantial, and solid, which leads me to believe these boots will be sturdy and long lasting.  Please note, if you buy the grey leather, it is distressed and not completely smooth, so if you don't want nicks, creases, and that "lived in" look, I would suggest another color/finish.  I had previously research a similar looking pair of Frye boots for months but had trouble justifying spending $300+, and I found that these boots are a great option for those ladies like me, looking for that Frye style without spending quite so much $$$.