As with most synthetic leather shoes, there is an associated smell, however it does not last long. Honestly I found it quite pleasing, although I've read many reviews in which people are disgusted with it. I am more disgusted at the thought of wearing dead animal skin on my feet! I prefer synthetic leathers. These shoes are fairly comfortable and pretty well made considering the low cost. These were the first Ollios I ever purchased. Since then I have purchased two other pairs of the oxfords. I really like the price and quality of these shoes and will probably buy more in the future when the ones I have wear out. One thing to keep in mind is that while these are considered "boots" there is only tread on the front of the shoe, not the heel. They could potentially be slippery in the winter months. They aren't really practical for extreme weather.