I picked these boots because I wanted a non-snow boot that still looked decent with jeans.  It's been snowing a lot here and I did not want ruin my really nice boots.  That being said, it did not expect them to be of the highest quality but was surprised that they looked nicer than I expected.  I'm 5'8" and they almost come up to my knees.  The footbed isn't the most comfortable but I think I'll just buy some inserts.  I have received a lot of compliments on them.  They definitely are doing the job and I actually ordered the other color too.