I bought these boots for my teen and she loves them. The fit for her foot length was as described. The calf width of the boot was good but my teen has to wear her skinny jeans or other form fitting pants. Otherwise, the boots won't zip over the bulk. My teen has worn them for a couple of weeks and they seem to be holding up well to every day wear for a high school girl. I don't think they could withstand a lot of rain and/or snow but walking around inside a high school they are doing just fine.