I bought this tray because when I come home I have my keys, my watch, and my wallet that I immediately take off. I wear a couple different watches depending on the situation and day, so I liked having four quadrants because then I can have both watches and my keys and my wallet all put away. I had another tray, but I am fussy, and I noticed that when I just dumped everything into the other tray, the keys would scratch my watches, so I wanted something to separate them. Overall, it is a good product. I have only had it a few months, but the stitching seems to be good, and it is not falling apart. It is just a storage tray so that is all you can expect from something like this. The reason I gave it an average rating, was because the individual quadrants are a little small. They are fine for my keys and watches, but it doesn't really fit my wallet. I still put my wallet in it, but it is just kind of crammed in and hangs out a bit (and I carry a slim wallet, with only a few bills and a couple credit cards). Not the end of the world, but still would like the tray to be a little bigger for the price.