I really wanted these boots to work for me, but after trying two different sizes they just didn't fit right.  I have wide feet and sometimes I am a 2E and sometimes I am a 4E.  But the problem with these wasn't the width, it was the length.  Both 10 and 10 1/2 didn't feel right. My big toes hit on the top of the upper, even with the 10 1/2 which is was a bit to large for me.  Other than fit the style, features and quality were exactly what I was looking for.  Everyone has different shaped feet and I have no doubt these will be perfect for someone, just not me.