The seller was great -- fast shipping, great boot.  The boot looked pretty good.  It was a bit off color than I wanted, maybe a bit too shiny.  However, I would've kept them and used them had the calf area been wide enough.  I measured my calf ahead of time, 14.5", but apparently that's too tight.  It went on, it just was uncomfortable.  Because of the tightness there the ankle area was baggy.  I think the calf area would've eventually stretched out, but I didn't want to risk it, plus with the bagginess of the ankle, I was worried that'd get worse.  If you have smaller calves, then get this boot, it is so cute.