I read the reviews before purchasing these, so was aware that the boots might be too big for my calves, as that was mentioned repeatedly.  I felt it was worth the risk, though, so purchased them to try.  Sure enough, WAY too large for my calves.  Large enough that they did't even work over pants, let alone with a dress.  As others mentioned, they smelled of real leather, and were just as attractive in person.  I was sad to send them back, but they would have looked ridiculous on me.  Also, the ankles were too large.  All around, just not fitted enough.  But great boots if they fit.