I ordered these to wear with skirts and dresses with tights.  They are a gorgeous boot and well made. I don't have a wide foot but I do have a bunion and prefer a boot that allows for my toes to stretch out, and these work great for me.  I love that the boots are waterproof and have a nice smooth zippers on both sides. That being said they would be a better fit for me with socks than tights, perhaps because of the shape of my foot.  I run a lot and have one calf that sometimes limits my boot options, and hese boots were not tight for this calf.  I ordered my usual size in La Canadienne.  In the end they ended up looking very similar to another pair of boots I already had so I sent them back and kep the other LC pair I had ordered. Sadly budget did not justify another similar boot in the same color.  I didn't rate it 5 starts because I only tried them on and don't know how they would wear over time.