After reading previous reviews that the boot was great for people with a small calf, I thought these would fit me perfectly. However, this boot does not fit snugly around my calves and there's a little gap (not enough for me to return though). It's interesting because the boot is tight all the way up my leg, but then flares out a bit at the top, where the small gap around my calf is. It's not too bad though, so I'd say this is a good boot for someone with normal/slightly thin calves.

That being said, these boots are very comfortable! When I first put them on, the bottom part of the boot was a little stiff, but it softened out after wearing them less than an hour. I also love the look of these boots. I wanted more of a mid-calf boot, and this is probably closer to knee-high, but it's still not too tall/a great height for someone 5'2". Overall, I'd recommend! A great boot for the price for sure and seems to be good quality.

**Update: I've had these boots for a little over 3 months, and the material on a spot on the front of the boot rubbed off, so there's now a black hole on the front of my brown boot. Really annoying that I haven't had the boots that long (and this is really my only complaint!). I guess you get what you pay for though..