I bought these boots for the snow and I love them.  They have not leaked and they keep my feet nice and toasty.  Only complaints are that since the inserts don't stretch to allow for tucking in of your pants or wearing thick socks, I end up wearing thin socks and then the bottom of my feet get blisters because I slide around in the boots a bit.  The shoes apparently run a little bit big, which would be fantastic if you could wear thick socks with them but...  I may have to unstitch the inserts to allow for thicker socks.