I love these boots.  I've had the boots a couple months now, so I've had plenty of time to form a solid opinion of them.  But from the first day I put them on, they felt as comfortable as slippers.  The leather is worn in just right, nice and supple but not flopping all over the place.  I have 7 or 8 pairs of sneakers, some dress shoes and another pair of Frye boots.  These Rogans are hands down more comfortable than all of them.

I wear these on my motorcycle, on hikes through dirt trails, all day at work, walking, bicycling ... pretty much any time I leave the house now, I throw these on.  The 2nd day I had them, I wore them walking around all night on Halloween, for about 4 hours.  Zero discomfort, it was amazing. Heck, I've even come home from work and fallen asleep with these things still on my feet.

 For me, there really is no downside to these boots.  Then there's of course the aesthetics of the boots.  They look awesome, nuff said.  Although I'd imagine they'd look goofy in shorts ;)

So far they're holding up great.  I've already put them through some heavy use and plan on putting them through much more.  Price might be a bit high to some, but these are worth every penny. I wear between a size 9-10 in all my other shoes, my Rogans are a 9 and the fit is perfect.

Far as I'm concerned, you can't go wrong with these.  They're durable,  look great and fit great. Can't really ask for much more !