For a long time, Frye has made the best quality boots that is worth every penny. I recently bought a pair and return them (it was my fault for not reading the other comments) for a half size smaller. The size fits as is!, if you have wide feet order the W's or half size D's of course. So, if your a Size 9 your are a 9. Okay, I have to say the Red Wood Color is gorgeous, it cost more than the other boot colors. IT'S WORTH IT. I feel so fortunate that Amazon had these as the last size 9! You can wear the pants tuck in or out. I recommend people to wear the Khaki Color pants hands down. If you want to get a pair Frye boots they are worth it!