This is an update.  I brought these for my husband who needed non laced boots as a xmas gift. He loved them at first (so I originally scored this a 4). Initially it was a little snug and now the left one causes his big to to hurt) - so the fit was not very good. The tan / natural looks very nice. It also did come with a scuff mark on one of the boots. Now the velcro flap is becoming too loose. He has had it for only 1.5 month.

For what we paid, we are becoming less happy with this product.  That said, we still like that its great for someone who cannot use both hands to tie a lace or boot.  As far as the price shortly after we bought it, (12/26) Ralph Lauren has the same one we bought for $75 / 0 shipping, we paid $129 on Amazon.  This is something I've noticed even within Amazon. Different companies may have significant price difference, so for those giving this serious thought shop around before hitting the purchase button.