These are probably some of the softest shoes I have ever worn.  They run a tiny bit bigger, probably because they are so soft. Although I am not returning mine since I have a need to hang onto any shoe that feels good and will just wear a bigger sock, there is a lot of softness inside so try 1/2 size smaller, also and pick the one you like, return the other.  Color is really nice, looks so cute like a loafer should!