Love the shoe, but I'm returning it for the 2nd time for same reason!  The middle of the accent broach on the right shoe was loose.  It jingles in when shaken by hand and clanks when I walk.  Not a good sound to hear as a bride is walking down the aisle!  On both occasions that I returned them for a replacement, I've asked that they check them before sending them to me.  I hope this third pair works!  I really love them, but the wedding is getting close and I don't have it in me to keep doing this!