Regarding the Keen Men's Dillon Clog Shoe. I like Keen shoes and earlier I bought a style similar to this, the Keen Men's Dillon Clog Shoe. That was 6 months ago. I really liked that shoe, and the Dillon Clog Shoe is a nice looking shoe. Unfortunately, I had more trouble with size on this one than on any other order I have made at Amazon.

My shoe size is 10.5. As I have aged, sometimes I need an eleven. I never need a 10 or smaller.

So, I ordered a 10.5 of this shoe. It was too large. I returned it and ordered a 10. It was too large and I returned it and ordered a 9.5. The fit was better, but still too large. I returned and did not try again. On the basis of this experience, I think you might have a real problem with fit. Amazon has been very prompt and good about accepting the returns, but I am not interested enough to try a 4th size.