When I received them today (in just 1 week to Australia), my first reaction was how beautiful the boots looked. I am 5'3" and 54kg. Based on reviews, I went one size up (I am usually a size US8 or Aus 6) and so I got myself a size 9 which is too big for me.

I reckon the boots still deserve a 5 star  rating and that it is actually true to size (in my case) and it was my mistake for not trusting the sizes. I buy other Amazon shoes at size 8. The RL size 9 is way too big even at the calves, and the leftover room in my feet is about 3 fingers wide at the toes. I still love the look and it is very comfortable, no strong plastic smells from this pair.

For those who still wish to go one size up if you think your calves may be a bit on the broad side, you can always add some sole underlays if you're going 1 size up. I added some ugg boots wool bases (or lamb wool sole underlays) and it then fitted me well. The top of the boots have side buckles so these can be tightened up at the calves.

I will be giving these boots away and ordering myself another pair in a size 8 this time! Otherwise, in terms of packaging, looks and quality, it is a pretty good pair of wellington boots!

1 year later: the boots are still great, but the back Ralph Lauren label at the base of the shoe has come off..