I really like these leggings. I got the cobblestone color and they look great. I like that the fabric is imperfect it gives the color a less uniform and more interesting look. I would definitely order by the waist size on the size chart rather than the what size you are (2, 4, 6, etc). I am a 4 usually and ordered the small, but I have a 27 inch waist and I think that the medium might have fit a little less tightly. They are a bit difficult to get on, but that might be fixed by sizing.