Great boot for the rain and goes with anything, dress up or down. I ordered the wheat but they sent the grey which I kept because it looks great with jeans. The toes could be a bit wider but the rest of the footbed was comfy and the whole boot is warm. Someone else mentioned it is a bit like a rainboot which I agree with, being from Seattle we have lots of wet weather.  I've been wearing them for a couple of months now and they are standing up great. I rated it a 4 instead of a 5 because of the narrow toes.