I got these for my sister-in-law for Christmas and must say she has excellent taste :). They were on her wishlist.  They are adorable boots and I like that the upper is soft and comfy looking.  Seems they will be more comfortable than rain boots that are plastic all the way up.  Very pleased with the purchase though I have not tried them on as her feet are two sizes smaller than mine.  Lucky for her as I would want to keep them :)