I've had the opportunity to wear the shoes a time or two and find them to be very comfortable even though they feel a little long.  The shoes are well made, but what Naturalizer isn't?  I'm grateful to find a shoe that is a Narrow because no one makes reasonably priced, stylish shoes in my width (4A.)  I also like that the shoes are a Mary Jane style.  It makes the shoes easier for me to wear since my feet are so very narrow.  Even though I have to use inner soles to pad the shoe out a little, I'm still happy.  Inner soles are a way of life for me.  The 4 stars are because of the width, but this is my personal issue.  Otherwise, the shoes are great, and so was the price.  Thanks Amazon!