This was the first pair of shoes I ordered on Amazon.  Reasonable price, great reviews, free shipping.  Arrived within a week.  My first impression was that they did not look like leather at all, more plastic-y look and feel.  They were too large for my feet and loose fitting.  The boot height was not as high as I expected and the opening was very wide and felt weird around my leg.  I immediately put them back in the box and wrapped it up for return shipping.  This cost me another $12 to ship back.  I've bought shoes online before and other sites do NOT charge for return shipping so I will not be ordering shoes on Amazon again.  I ended up with a very nice pair of Rockport Toloni black leather boots.  I am extremely happy with those (bought them at a department store near home).