I love these shoes!  I ordered a half size up since I usually need a little extra room in heels; unfortunately they were too big to the point of slippage (my fault).  I am returning them for a half size smaller.  As for comfort, I only walked around my apartment to try them on but they seemed pretty darn comfortable.  I definitely did not kick them off immediately, which is a good sign since I'm a wuss in heels.  They have a nice patent shine, but may be scuffed easily.  I am looking forward to getting the correct size and would recommend these to a friend.