I have been trying to find form fitting boots for awhile. And although there still is some wiggle room for my calves, these are definitely made for women with calves on the smaller side (in a completely good way) there's still room with jeans AND knee high socks on so don't worry about them being too small. People have been complaining about the comfort- if you're not used to 4 inch heels you probably won't like them. It's my job to acclimate to heels fast so these aren't horrible by any means. I was expecting to walk on wood from these reviews but they aren't bad. I would HIGHLY recommend them. Super cute!