I give thi shoe a 5 star rating because they are beautiful comfortable shoes. I have worn them only one time and mostly sat so I cannot say how they hold up all day. I wear 91/2 or 10. I ordered The smaller size after reading reviews of how large they are for size. My toes felt squeezed from all the padding in the footbed. I am sure they will break in in that area but my first thought was I should have ordered the 10. I ordered Pewter expecting a grayish taupe color and these are a soft brown. They look like the picture,I just expected different shade. Classy looking and comfortable. Can't beat that.