I purchased the pink one for my 13 month old little girl. Those little boots looked so cute, and kept her feet warm. Since she just started walking, after 2 days, they started to get so dirty, they didn't look pink anymore. I think those are for kids that don't walk yet, otherwise they will look terrible, but will still keep your little one's feet warm! I would give it a 5 star if they didn't get dirty as fast.