The reviews on this bag are all over the place and I think I may know why.  I own several of these and when they are actually made by Rothco with the Rothco tag they are very thick, excellent quality.  However some sellers are providing a bag that looks like the Rothco but is much thinner canvas and not nearly as sturdy.  I just received my latest order of three and the two that were sold by "Campers Haven" were the thin canvas, where the one purchased from "Direct Premium Buys" was the nice heavy, well constructed bag. As with all secondary sellers their inventory changes, so this review may become dated. Please note I am posting on 12/18/12.