5'6" 125lbs size 8 shoe slightly wider feet and a 14" circumference calf.  I have been searching for a nice tall boot that doesn't gap around the calf and can be worn with jeans and skirts.  This is it.  It measures wider than I would like at the top but has a buckled gusset so you can tighten it to wear without tights and loosen for skinny jeans.  The leather is exquisite...soft and textured but strong enough to stand up on its own and be durable.  The sole has good traction and the footbed is very comfortable.  I have tried the frye campus boot - nice narrow calf but hard to get in and out of and not so comfortable, the Franco Sarto Clint - very dressy and tall..not quite narrow enough at calf, and the Merrell Captiva strap which has 16" calf circumference and looks awful on a narrow calf, but has a amazing footbed.

The Fairmont is the only one I really like...my only critique would be the gussets which look a little dumpy but will probably flatten out and become less noticeable as I wear them.