I just bought this coat and so far I like it! To be fair, I'm a Wisconsin gal, and I need a good warm coat. so far March has been quite cold, but not deep freeze, so I can't give any information about it's warmth in really cold weather, however what I know thus far I like. I wanted a coat that would cover the tops of my thighs, and not be too long, and this coats length is perfect! I find it to be warm but not too warm. It seems to distribute body heat evenly and not retain too much where you're sweltering. The zipper is a little flimsy, and the hood seemed far too big. I found the belt cumbersome, so I removed it along with the hood, and the coat is still stylish and functional! Overall I would recommend. The fit is true to size and for the price I think you get what you pay for!