I recently bought these Kamik boots after my 15 year old thinsulate "Tundra" duck boots developed tears in them.  I chose these Kamiks because they looked comfortable, had good reviews and were reasonably priced.  Kamik is a familiar name too.  It's true that they are very warm and comfortable inside, like slippers.  I didn't realize how thin the bottoms were to my old boots until I wore these Kamiks.  They have a more substantial, thicker bottom.  I had fallen twice in my old duck boots on black ice, fracturing my arm each time.  It was time to look for a boot with better traction.  I've shoveled snow twice in these Kamik Brooklyns and they seem to have better traction than my old boots. My feet have stayed dry and warm each time. They are warmer than my old duck boots. I have not tried them yet in slushy, wet snow though. They are quick and easy to get on, pull the laces and tie a bow. The laces are plenty long enough too.  An extra pair of blue laces came with the brown pair of boots. The liner is part of the boot, not something you pull out.  Shipping was quick.

I'm normally a size 7 shoe and I ordered a size 8 boot.  There is plenty of wiggle room.  I may have been able to fit in the size 7 boot, but I didn't want to take any chances with the boot feeling tight, since it is a personal preference to have more room.  I can wear these with a thin or thick sock comfortably.  With a size 8, they appear slightly clunky on me, but I'm happy with them because they are so warm and cozy.  I look forward to putting them on whenever I go out this winter.  The brown color was a good choice.  I wear my pant legs over the boot and they are comfortable to walk in, not rigid like some boots are. I would recommend going 1/2 size over your normal shoe size, but no more than one size up.  Thank you previous reviewers for helping me to make a good choice!

Update: February 21, 2014 ~~~ These boots have held up well and have remained comfortable and warm but when worn in deep puddles they aren't waterproof. I haven't slipped on the snow or ice while wearing these and I still like them very much but they are best for snow, not puddles of water. I've worn them frequently this winter.