I give it a four star with a caveat. The Rose Navy Daisy is a good-looking shoe with a very comfortable toe-box area. I wear a Euro 37-38 (7 to 7.5) and bought a size 7 for use with a thin sock for warmer-weather gardening. The shoe was too loose on my foot, especially in the heel area. Trust me, I didn't want to return them given the cuteness and comfort factor (and will forever envy those who can wear them), but I was concerned about sliding out of them during active gardening. It's possible a whole size down (though unusual for me to go to a size 6) might have helped. I might consider a different style, too, like the Rue, or another garden shoe that will fit more securely on my foot.