Although I was unable to keep these boots, I rate them 5 stars.  I am hard to fit in shoes/boots.  Didn't think I'd ever find that a size 11 was small!  I'd say they aren't true to size.  If I never wore socks they might fit but would still hurt my corny-toes.  Not blaming the boot for any of this. The pair I got had a fault in that the zipper caught on the inner gore that makes it water proof.  I probably would get along with that if they had fit.  Just a matter of moving that gore out the way each time it caught on it.  They were a beautiful brown color and I think any of the color choices would be pretty.  Design was superb, comfy (if they fit).