I had an old tumi for about 18 years and for the last 3 years it really should have been replaced but I couldn't find anything that I liked. The cheap stitching and plastic windows on every wallet I looked at turned me off. A friend suggested I take a look at the Saddleback product and I'm glad I did - this wallet is amazing well made. I honestly believe this will be the last wallet I ever have to buy. I went with the Tobacco Brown and already a few months in the color is starting to darken and is taking on some really nice shading - like a nice pair of selvedge denim jeans fading over time but in reverse.