At the "sale" price, I could not pass up getting a couple of Keds penny loafers to wear around the house.  I was looking for leather, black preferably, but these shiny ones popped up and seemed to fit the need.  They are leather -  but sadly made in China.  I have no idea what kind of feet the Chinese think we have -  these shoes  would almost fit a circular foot.  Too wide from the penny strap back, I know I should have gotten a narrow, but the seller was "out of stock" -  have to wear thick socks just to keep them on.  Bought those things you put in heels of shoes, but the insides are padded fabric so I am not sure how well they will "stick".  The sole is good, and I like that it wraps up the side of the shoe since I plan on using them mostly outside in bad weather.  They are wortht he $17 but definitely NOT the $58  they supposedly sold for.