I bought these when I couldn't find the Steve Madden Banditts anywhere.  These are super similar, and I love  them.  A lot of people mentioned in their reviews that the strap gets loose.  I mean, it's supposed to be loose, but if you order the right size, I can't see that being a problem.  The strap isn't supposed to help keep the shoe on anyways.  They also mentioned that they scruff easily.  Nobody is rougher on their shoes than me, and mine have been just fine.