Saw these online; day-dreamed about them for weeks; finally broke down and bought them - a little skeptical because of very few reviews online and the ones I saw were 50/50.  LOVE THEM!  I wouldn't get them in black because there are so many black boots out there and these are pricey.  I purchased the charcoal because one reviewer had mentioned the mix of dark grey/brown hue and that holds true. They are a perfect color boot, and perfect style, to be incredibly versatile - wear with black/navy/browns and casual/snappy-casual/dressy.  They fit true to size for me (I'm a solid 9.5 in just about everything), but put a little muscle into it the first time or two you put them on - sit down and use the TABS!

The calf/side view is very nice. They do have a very mild slouch effect around the ankle, but it is overall a very attractive boot.

I am strongly considering the cogna color...

Also comfortable.  For my first Frye, and a decent heel, these do not disappoint!  4/5 stars because of price. Goodness! (worth it - they are leather, treat yourself)