I have tried 3 different sizes/widths of this shoe. One was huge, the other MUCH too small. These were the best, though they don't fit properly. They fall off my feet, and if I put a "cookie" in the heel portion to help keep my foot from slipping out, they become too small in the toe box. I have to wear heavy socks to keep them on, and the shoes pull the socks down at the heel, so by the time I walk a block, my socks are under my feet instead of on them. Additionally, the leather under the kiltie is discolored, as though they had been sitting on the shelf for more than 10 years. I only kept these shoes because they remind me of when I owned a (very comfortable) pair when I was young, and I had my heart set on another pair. I know they'll be in the closet more than on my feet. My enjoyment will probably come from just looking at them, because they are a pretty shoe. The extreme variance in sizing/widths is a problem I've always had with BASS shoes for some reason. I'll try on the same style in the same size and one will fit completely differently from the other. In my opinion, this reflects a serious quality control issue in the manufacturing process. Also, someone mentioned the sole of the shoes are slippery. I found this to be true, but thought it would improve as I walked on cement and got some traction "imprinted" into the sole. No go. They are still very slippery. Next time I'm going to try another brand's penny loafers. These ended up being an expensive mistake.