Long time user of the Timberland boat shoe, but read that it has declined in quality, they were recently bought out.  These Sebago's got some good review, so I thought I'd try them.  Great shoe, well made, nice thick leather, I can see these will last.

I usually wear a 9.5, though sometimes fit into a 9.  The 9.5 size I ordered were definitely too big.  I returned them and got the size 9, perfect fit.