My husband likes these boots.  I'm only giving them three stars because these are the full steel toes and really how much can you like them?  Or even find anything comfortable about them?  But having said that my husband says these are the best steel toes for what he needs.  He walks in oily crap all day too and the sole is good for that and doesn't fall apart or slip.  He still has to buy the Dr. Scholl liners though because the arch is not good for him but you know its a work boot so what do you want?