I ordered these earrings as a Christmas gift and match to my fiancee's sapphire engagement ring. The first set of earrings that I received was a stunning disappointment. The stones were quite different in shape and thus color. In addition, the edges of both stones were either finished extremely roughly or covered in some sort of adhesive - I didn't bother to investigate further than looking. I reached out to the merchant, who advised me to do a return through Amazon and order another pair.

I'm glad that I did. The replacement pair is perfect - the stones match, the finish is excellent, and they even made her cry when she opened them. Since she's comparing them to a very high quality engagement ring with genuine sapphire in the same size, that speaks volumes of the quality.

If not for the issue with the first pair, I'd give these a 5. I will consider ordering from FineJewelers in the future.