I gave this robe two stars for the beautiful color of the plaid and for the sewn in robe tie-belt (I hate losing those), but found it otherwise a terrible disappointment. It should be described as a sherpa shawl <em>collar</em> as there is no lining. Worse than that however is that I ordered an extra-large. The robe I received was small enough that I checked the label, thinking I'd received (or even accidentally ordered) a medium. It is an extra-large according to the label, but it's barely big enough for my petite mother to wear comfortably. Sizes run small is a huge understatement. I haven't washed it yet and can only hope it doesn't shrink or it won't be much use to my mother either.