I'm never quite sure how to review jewelry.  How well you like the look of a piece of jewelry is subjective to your personal taste.  The colors incorporated in a piece are also subjective.  Then you can be influenced by birth stones, gold, silver and more which are not as subjective.  On this piece the birth stone aspect was not particularly important.  The gold plate over sterling gives it a subjective positive for looks.  The weight of the piece has a nice feel, it feels like quality. (again subjective)  Bottom line the recipient said it was beautiful and thanked me profusely.  Being a reasonable judge of character, I feel that the response was honest and once again subjective.  She likes it so I am happy with it.