After reading some of the reviews about these shoes I was a little worried about how they'd fit, and if they'd fall apart on me within hours of wearing them.  I am happy to say that my fears have been put to rest; these little beauties are absolutely adorable (as one reviewer said, even cuter in person and on the feet than on the website), and they fit like a dream straight out of the box!  I am typically a size 6 1/2, but can wear anything from 5 1/2 to 7 (I know, I know...wtf, right?!)  As has already been pointed out, these don't come in half sizes, so I ordered a size 7, and am very happy I did. They fit PERFECTLY with my thick wool socks, and will be a little roomier with thinner ones.  Regarding issues about the strap breaking: I think if one is careful not to pull the strap too tightly, there  will be less likelihood of ripping.  My one concern is the patent strip around the sole, which has a seem on the inner side, so it's hidden from view for the most part, but I worry about it peeling off...will have to wait and see, and avoid puddles in the mean time.  For now, I am very pleased with these little babies, and plan to wear them with everything.