I so wished these would fit, as I have been looking for something to wear around the yard, out in the rain, etc.  Size 8 is too small, size 9 is too big.  I'm an 8 1/2.  Wish they came in half sizes.  Even with a heavy sock the 9's are still too long.  So disappointed.  They were "cut" low on the upper which was what I was looking for b/c I have a very high instep and I can't wear the rain shoes that come up high on the foot.  I had high hopes, but I was disappointed.  Please consider making these in half sizes and I will definitely buy a pair.  Returning the product. :(