First the good! These boots ran true to size and fit my rather wide foot just fine. The price also seems pretty fair for the quality of construction. You can definitely tell they aren't real leather, but I've seen far worse synthetic leather.

The "meh". This could be an artifact from my desktop not being calibrated correctly, but I thought the Dark Brown looked more grey in real life. Could be good or bad depending on what you're looking for. There also isn't much to recommend these boots comfort-wise. Not really any padding or support to speak of, but some inserts may fix that for you.

I ended up returning these not because they were inherently bad boots, but they just didn't quite fit the bill for me.