For the current price of $72, this is a good value.  The length of the shoe is true to size and the materials and finish are good.

However, some negatives are;
- It is a bit wider than a "D" size.
- The ankle opening is much larger than it needs to be given it has an elastic panel as well as a zipper on the inside. It should be more form fitting.  The wider opening often catches and lifts the bottom of my pants, which can be annoying. On the plus, you could probably stuff your wallet or keys or pants inside there.