Maybe I should give this boot a 4, because it could be vastly improved by simply adding your own thick insole.  There is simply not enough on the bottom of this boot to have enough insulation from walking on a frozen ground.  The bottom of a boot is the most important part to me.

This boot is cute, I love the feel of the inside and out.  There is ample insulation on the colored top half. And you can even slip your foot in and wear it without having to lace it up!!

The rubber bottom keeps out any dampness from melting snow or slush.  Within the rubber portion, the top inside is extremely padded and almost luxurious feeling.  There is plenty of give to wear thick socks IF YOU BUY A FULL SIZE UP.

The HUGE problem with the DESIGN of this boot is that the sole is only slightly thicker than the rubber side walls!!!!  Do not be tricked by the texture on the bottom, it is NOT thick at all. I can press my thumb on the inside and clearly feel the outline of it from the outside.  Also, there is not enough texture to have any gripping power.

I can only imagine what stepping on rocks would feel like.  I am sending these back.  To bad, since I love everything except the sole of this boot.  I would keep it if I were buying based on Looks alone.  But hey, it's a boot and I want to keep my feet warm and not feel every little pebble I step on!