I bought these for work and had lots of trouble with them. My shoe size is anywhere between a 10 and an 11 though my last pair of work shoes were a 10. I tried these out in a 10 and they still felt huge on me. I haven't worn anything smaller since middle school and I've worn numerous brands over the years. Some of the other reviews make a similar observation so I have to wonder if there are huge discrepancies with this particular model from shoe to shoe. FWIW the insole in mine were bright red.

They irritated my heels and ankles when I wasn't walking and showed lots of signs of wear immediately, even on a slow night of bartending. I decided to return these and try a pair of Rockports rather than trying a smaller size.

They look nice enough and they're slip-resistant but I would look elsewhere. Thank God for Amazon's great return policies.