I love the boots. They fit fairly well, not too wide, not too narrow. They are slightly long but that is an individual taste, and I'd rather that than too short. I love the look and the wooly interior and suede finish. They are warm, indeed waterproof, and they appear sturdy. The only change I would make would be the ties. Instead of having to tie them, I would have rather had the stretchy cords and clip than shoe strings. But, they are easy to get on and off, feel and look so good on that the shoe strings are quite acceptable. I've only had them 2-3 weeks, so the jury is not out yet, but they are poking their heads through the door!