I love these things so much.  The fit is just right for me.  I have a pretty narrow, long foot.  Many boots are too loose around the ankle area, and the play makes my feet tired.  These go on and come off perfectly and are snug while walking.  The fur lining is nice and warm.  There's been a little shedding, but that's to be expected with something new.  Hopefully it will subside over time.  My shoe size tends to be either 10 or 10.5 and size 10 was a perfect fit.  So if you find you are often between two sizes, opt for the smaller size here.

Update:
These boots have now seen me through two Chicago winters, the last of which was pretty brutal. I wore these things daily, yet they still have some tread left to them.  I should get another Winter out of them easily. I have to be careful with uneven tread wear, because my knees are sensitive to uneven stresses.  However, that's not the boot's fault.  The upper on this boot is in perfect shape and the lining did stop shedding for the most part. Like many well made, leather shoes, the upper will easily outlast the sole.

When I can no longer wear these comfortably, I will try to buy the same exact boot again. Hopefully they will still make this model and not have cut corners on the manufacturing.