I can't give this item 5 stars because it's not a top-quality, leather belt, but I wasn't expecting buttery soft leather for this price.  It is, however, a very good quality leather belt for under $30. Leather is smooth and matte.  Hardware is sturdy and good looking.
You should order this belt in the same size as the waist of your pants. Do NOT order up in size. Boy friend is a 36" waist and this belt was too big on the tightest hole in the 38". Amazon was very quick in its refund process and sending me a new 36" one. 36" belt fits him perfectly on the middle hole.