These really are nice and affordable boot liners-- they come in a very cute, sturdy and gift-worthy box (to boot:) and are super soft and snuggly. Acc to other reviews of this product (in black), I ordered the next size up, and this seems to be the way to go, as these have just a bit of wiggle room in the Large I ordered although my child wears a 10. Btw- although the picture looks a little red, these are quite magenta! As the black was unavailable in the L when I ordered, I tried these for my son...can't do it to him. They will never work with his batman boots-- but Amazon was gracious enough to give me a full refund- thanks Amazon!!