UPDATE: Put these boots on to go out the door and realized the seam is coming apart on the bottom. There is already a small hole. I saw another review where they said the same thing and the seller would not refund them. BEWARE!!
-The fit
The foot was very narrow! I have a  AAA narrow foot. I usually wear a 6.5 or 7. I got these in a 7 and they just barely fit snuggly. They will work for me, but if you have a wide foot they may not. If you have an average foot, I would go up a half size.
The shaft was good -very tall and plenty of room in the calf. I have average size calves and had a little room to spare, but not much. they do have stretch pieces on the inside so I think larger calved women could do well with these.
-The look
very shiny black. Looked as pictured. Not the trendiest I've ever seen but a good solid black. I was pleased.
-The smell
They smelled horrible; not like leather, like a toxic cheap smell. I've had them for a couple days airing out in a spare room and I think they will be ok. But I couldn't have worn them straight out of the box.

Side note -packinging was very nice. They came in a large tall box so as to not crease them.

Overall a good boot for an average price. I would recommend them.