I love Naturalizer.  I own several pairs of shoes made by this brand and they're all excellent and comfortable as well - even those with more than 2" heel.  This pair of boots is no exception.  Now, I don't wear them that often so they still look brand new.  I've worn them maybe 7-8 times so far.  They go with everything.  On the sizing - I have a wide calf and the boots have elastic "panels" on each side making the fit even better - not saggy and not so tight that blood circulation is cut off.  As far as the shoe part, they seem to be true to size.  I've found that Naturalizer can run a bit big but I don't find it true for this pair.  I did buy these at Amazon even thought it doesn't have the verification mark by the review.