I originally bought this shoe in a 9 (I wear 8.5).  I love the look of this shoe but could not wear the 9.  The edges of the shoe cut into my foot everywhere and rubbed my heel.  I then bought the 8.5 wide.  It made no difference.  This shoe has to be the most uncomfortable shoe I've ever put on.  It is stiff and the edges dig into the foot.  I returned it.  Disappointed because I do love the look.  Can't they make this shoe with a soft leather????