I got these boots in black because I own and a pair of brown Ash Scott boots, which I love that are basically the same design but more expensive. I figured I could save a few bucks by getting these from NYLA, but in the end, I don't think it's worth it. I still love the design, simple, yet sturdy, not too much hardware going on and can go with anything, but the soles are SUPER slippery (no texture whatsoever except slightly on the heel) and the leather is not as buttery and thick as the Ash pair. The money I saved NOT buying another pair of Ash boots will go to waste by having to go to a shoe repair place and get these resoled. Besides the slippery sole, the zipper is not as smooth as it could be and the leather is not great quality, but for this price, there's not much more they can do. Fits true to size though.