I am a perfect size 8 but when i received the shoes they were "just" too tight, so i returned them and just got the 8.5. Fit like a glove. Wearing them now to break them in and they are heaven already. I travel quite a bit so i love how these fit my foot like a high heel slipper; the front top part of the shoe comes up high enough to make my foot feel secure and comfortable for my many airport strolls but still low enough it doesn't look or feel like a high heel loafer. They look great with the jeans I have on and will work with many of my dress pants. The heel height is average so it will work with jeans and some of my longer dress pants. love how the pointed toes and tassels make my feet appear sleek. May order the other color just because these are so well fitting!