My husband is about 5ft 9in and over 200lb. He has wide shoulders and I was worried about this coat fitting.

I bought him a large, based on other reviews. The coat fits him very nicely. Its a little snug on the shoulders, but the arm length is great and the coat lays on him correctly. He is able to layer successfully and has stated he loves the coat.

the scarf is thin, but he found that to be to his advantage.