My biggest concern when buying these was that a previous reviewer said that the distressing made the boot look really fake and the left and right didn't even match each other. While I don't think anyone would be tricked into thinking they are leather, the material and finish are fine and match each other well. The style is so dang cute, I just love 'em! They are quite comfortable. I bought a 7 1/2, I normally wear a 7. I probably could have gone with a 7 but this is fine too. Again, I was basing my choice on previous reviews. I think they are a great boot tucked into a skinny jean, under a boot cut jean or even with a skirt. Very versatile, really comfortable and super cute, yep, love 'em!