About three years ago I bought a pair of doc wingtips but they were shoes...I loved them great quality, tough and comforatable.  So I decided to get the fitzroy for winter...I was sadly disappointed.  The leather is cheap feeling, very waxy and too light for leather, nothing feels real on it., the inside liner is nylon, not leather.  The inside is ripping apart on me.  the sole is starting to separate from the shoe, and they smell weird...not like any leather shoe I have owned before...I can't wait for them to fall apart so I can buy a different shoe or better quality...

My only real hope is that somehow I accidentaly bought the vegan leather shoe...but it does not look like it.

It could be worse, but nothing like my first pair.