I ordered these in the Cognac color and I got a blond mustard color instead. They were MUCH lighter than the picture.  Not only that, but one shoe was noticably lighter than the other.  There were also a few water mark stains on them.  The leather IS thin (like some of the other reviews mentioned), but I was aware of that because I saw them in the store first (the color I saw in the store was NOT what I got).  I've thought about trying to treat them with a leather conditioner to see if they'll darken up, but haven't decided if I'll just return them instead.

I gave them two stars because I do love the fit.