After reading several reviews regarding sizing I decided to order my true 8.5 size.  I could never wear an 8, but could probably wear a 9 (other shoes) so I wasn't sure which way to go (I have other Fryes in 8.5).  My feet are not narrow by any means, and I my toes are all the same length, so they're actually kinda wide all the way through.  My feet fit wonderfully in these with no discomfort anywhere.  Great price!!