These are nice boots. Really cute on. Light. I usually wear a 9 and these are right at the point of being too snug. My feet are a little wide across the ball of the foot area so it presses on my pinky toe a bit and my big toes just about to the end. I would have replaced them with a 9.5 if they had it. There was a nick on the left boot harness that crosses over the arch of the foot that they tried to cover with something. It is a dark oval smudge with a tiny bit of white fuzz poking out. The crinkles on the top of the boot aren't crinkles of the left boot also. It is more of a big fold. Like they pulled the material too tight. I'd say if made correctly with no flaws an excellent boot!