I have two negatives. While it makes a fine outer wear garment - say over a hooded sweatshirt - it is a bit too stiff for inner wear over a typical permanent-press sport shirt. I don't wear t-shirts so some of the scratchiness comes through too. I really like the hand warmer pockets, but the upper vest pockets should be higher up on the chest.

Very well constructed and durable. And yes, made in America!