I was looking for a dress ankle boot and finally settled on the Cinteresting from Aerosoles.

While I really liked the styling of the boot, especially the contrast stitching on top, I returned it. The reasons were:

A) The heel height was not comfortable, it was just a bit too high for me to be able to walk in it comfortably. Of course this is strictly personal preference but it just did not work for me.
B) The opening was too big around the ankle (and I do not have particularly thin ankles) so that I felt my foot was slipping out. When I tried to adjust it with the buckle, I could not get the thorn into the next hole, it was so small. I didn't try to force it because I did not want to ruin the strap.
C) One boot had visible glue in a spot along where the sole meets the leather. That was also where one could see a rough leather cut along the edge. Even though it was in an area where most people probably wouldn't notice it, this was the final reason why the boot went back. It just didn't look like great quality.