I have been searching for the right black leather boots the past 2 seasons.  My biggest gripes: ridiculously high heel (4in+) or the calf part is so wide I look like I'm in  waders.

But this boot - just right.  I think I saw some reviews saying the calf was too tight.  Which could be likely as it seems  like every other boot out there is too wide for me so maybe I have more narrow calves. In any case, this fits like a glove (even with jeans tucked in).

For me the size ran a little big. I normally take 10.5 - 11 but went with a 10.  Feels like the right fit and I'm betting will also stretch a little in time.