I bought the red jacket on sale, a fantastic value for the shell alone.  The coordinating fleece comes with pockets (inside and outside) and thumb loops, and is nice alone or as a lining.  I prefer not to zip it in if there's a chance I'll want to take off one layer but not both, but the zip-in feature is nice and makes the jacket more streamlined.  I like that there are underarm vents as I can get pretty hot walking around all zipped up and hooded, even in cold rainy weather.  The waterproofing has withstood several downpours, and the adjustable hood keeps most of the rain out of my face (without an ugly bill).  I considered giving the jacket 5 stars, but  it looks and feels a bit bulky/unflattering (I can wear layers underneath, so that's ok) and I would have preferred purple over red.  I still like it better than any of the other jackets I tried on and I would recommend it.