However I still rate them a 4 star because the leather is awesome.  The calf fit my 15 inch calf with a straight leg jean. Color was awesome. I think there may have been a workmanship issue with the right toe box, because the left boot fit perfectly.  This particular shoe box looked like it had been around a bit in shipping, so I bet it was because of this weird ridge on the left side of the foot bed in the right boot that wouldn't let your foot go flat. Yes I would be willing to try this maker and size again, but in a store probably to make sure the footbed is smooth not with a ridge. The one I received may have been an irregular, but nothing on the box indicated it.  I debated keeping the boot and taking it to a shoemaker to get the shoe bed fixed, but with the cost, it was easier to return it and get a boot that fit both feet.