I give them 5/5 for quality and performance for the price. I'm a 13 Wide. Fit was right on and comfortable. Confident sole. One thing I need to explain. I was transitioning from wearing only western boots with high heels, to see if it helped my knee pain. After wearing these for two days, I developed an intense pain on the rear of one heel. I quit wearing them for a few days, and the pain cleared and did not return when I resumed wearing these shoes. It may have been a tendon stretching because of the lower heel. Or it may have been a break-in thing with there shoes. They have a pad at the top of the heel box, and the pain felt much like a deep bruise. So, you may have a break-in experience.