I bought these boots to get me through the winter. I hate boots that go over the ankles so I was looking for a boot that felt like a sneaker but protected like a boot. This came close but didn't quite fit the bill. I did give it a high rating because it did do exactly what it says it is going to do. It just didn't fit my specific needs. The shoe is comfortable but only with thick boot socks. I tried it with regular white athletic socks and I felt it needed a bit more cushioning. It protected my foot well and when I tested it on snow and ice it gave excellent traction and kept my foot dry and warm. However, for my tastes it was a bit too heavy. I wanted something light for everyday use and the Detroit was really heavy and without the thick sock it would have felt uncomfortable. I returned them and bought the KEEN Men's Targhee II Waterproof Trail Boot. This "boot" fit my needs and was comfortable and light and protected my foot well from the elements. I don't doubt that the Keen Utility is a well made boot it just doesn't fit my exact needs