This boot was very true to size. I am a 7-7.5 and ordered the 7.5 and it fits perfectly. The leather is distressed looking, so if you are looking for something all shiny and black this isn't the boot for you. Some areas are rubbed a white/grey color. You can definitely dress up or dress down this boot easily. I'd say my only complaint is that the zipper is very loud as you walk. Right now I've placed a little tape on the underside of the zipper and it appears to have stopped the rubbing. Awesome boots though!