I got to agree that for Cole Haan this is a very poorly made boot. The boots are great, very stylish and do look fantastic on small calves... no gaps, no need for extra socks and look perfect with skirts - I was very pleased when I bought them.  However, the sole of the shoe came off after about 3 weeks. The boots were very comfy and I wore them almost every day, but still I expected them to last a bit longer! I will probably try to return them and see if I could order another pair.