I bought this before there were any reviews, because I liked the look, and the ability to keep my ears warm without having to wear a hat.  This is very cute, the only surprise (which I could not tell from the pictures) was that it ties in the back, which means it often gets tangled in my hair.  I am going to have to figure out how to button it, or perhaps will just sew it with elastic at a comfortable length.  At any rate, I still wear it because it's soft, comfortable, pretty, and easy to carry just in case we get one of our very common sudden temperature drops.