These boots (dark brown) are gorgeous! They can be dressed up or down, and worn with practically anything. The leather is soft and beautifully rustic. They are very comfortable, with a cushy insole. I ordered my normal size 7, and they were too long in the foot. Went down to a 6 1/2, and they fit perfectly, although it will be a little tougher to tuck in my jeans. Love the straps, which help to adjust the fit. Love the heel, which adds some height, but is still comfortable.

Edit, one day later:  I was admiring my boots in the bright daylight, and they are two different colors--one boot obviously lighter and redder than the darker brown one. Also, one boot is an inch shorter than the other. I get that there may be subtle differences in the leather, but this was far from subtle! Back they are going and a replacement is on the way (a simple process, but still a hassle). Hopefully the next pair will be acceptable. For a boot at this price point, the boots should be perfect.

Final update: replacement pair was shipped within two days. This time, the boots are perfect. Worth the hassle and the wait.