When I first got these boots, I was thrilled. They are not as humongous as most other 'duck' boots, and they are super warm and fuzzy. I had had these for about a year and a half before I actually took them through some mud and water, and let me tell you, they ARE NOT waterproof. I kid you not, I was standing in maybe three inches of water and my poor feet got soaked. :( I have Raynaud's disease so I have very poor circulation to my feet, meaning they get super cold in the winter. Needless to say, wet feet in the middle of a farm in 25 degree temperatures is not good. If you want warm boots to walk around the town in, then yes, by all means purchase these boots. If you do, however, intend to wear them through water or even snow, I suggest you look elsewhere.