I have these boots in black and taupe.  Today was my first day wearing the taupe and I did not make it two blocks before a woman stopped me on the street and demanded to know where I got them.  They are beautiful boots--compliments are never-ending!

The other reviewers are right about the calf potentially being tight; I am 5'5, 138lbs and do not have any problem with the boots being too tight.  They fit snugly but comfortably with knee high socks and skinny jeans on.

The other reviewers are also right about the heel not feeling like 3"; these are boots you can walk in all day without your feet hurting.  I wear flats almost every day, but I feel fine in these boots.