Okay, I have been on a hunt for a replacement for some Mudd shoes that I've had since I was in middle school. They finally broke and were unsafe to walk on, so I was on the search for a pair of shoes with a RUBBER SOLE because I hate hate hate when every time I walk on hard floors, I click around obnoxiously loud. I bought a couple pairs, only to return them because they were "clicky" heels. These shoes are very cute, and finally have a rubber sole! I'm tempted to buy another pair as backup just in case I can't find these again when I need a replacement. The toe is slightly rounded but not too bad, and the buckle is cute. The tongue of the shoe sometimes pushes in when I'm sliding my foot in, but nothing I can't handle. They fit perfectly with my slightly thick socks. Great shoes. Would buy again and again.