I have been looking high and low for the perfect, shorter, leather black flat rubber soled boot for two years. I think I found the perfect boot for my needs. This shoe is immediately comfortable out of the boots, looks great with jeans, leggings, and skirts/dresses, and is well made.  I like the harness-style detail, and the heel has just the right amount of height while still being flat.  This keeps it rugged and moto-style while maintaining a little feminine flair.
For some reason, the description says "manmade sole" but the soles are made of rubber, which is a big deal for me (I live in NYC and walk 3-4 miles a day).  Zappos and other retailers with info on this product specify the rubber sole.