After using this coat for the best couple weeks, I really think it deserves the 5/5 stars. It's cute, really warm and I can tell that it's a great quality jacket. I would highly recommend this item!

Update: still love the look of the coat, and it is warm ... but its starting to fall apart. Some of the seams are ripping by the buttons. I have treated the coat well and I have the proper size, so this isn't due to customer error. I might be crazy, but when I pay almost $200 for coat, I believe it should last a least couple winters ... not a couple months.