I saw a girl on the subway with these boots and fell in love with the color (the green ones). But I'm not a huge fan for several reasons.

First of all they are SO wide in the legs. I don't have absurdly skinny legs, but these boots are definitely made for the "big-boned" ladies among us. They wrinkle on me at the ankles and sort of flap around and make me walk like a penguin. Or neanderthal.

Then the arch support- instead of a bump under the arch, the bump is under the ball of your foot, so after wearing them for just a half hour or so, your feet start to ache like other reviews have noted. The biggest downside in my opinion is the weird fabric band on the top of the boots. There is a 1" rim of green jersey fabric on the top of the boot, and it's just a bit more faded/dirty looking than the bright green rubber. It looks like it will get scruffy-looking after a few more wears.

They are lightweight though, and haven't had any leakage at all.