Okay so the shoe is adorable I have one issue which is why they did not get the 5th star shoe runs small.  I am typically an 8.5 in Jessica Simpson My daughter who wears an 8.5 shoe just the same It was tight on her foot I ordered this shoe for her and I am going to have to reorder this in a half size larger I am hoping it will give her the room she needs the shoe is adorable and I love it great look will look for 9 and report sizing then!