Like others have said, these do look like rain boots in shape and material but that's ok because I was looking for some stylish comfortable rain boots.  I've worn them a few times in the rain and they've done their job keeping my feet dry.  The liner also does a great job of keeping my feet and calves warm.  I have large calves (14.5" diameter) and these boots fit comfortably.  However the top of the boot shafts taper outward so they don't fit snugly around my calves.  The leather is also quite stiff which is good because it doesn't crumple and wrinkle around the ankle but also bad because it cuts into my ankles when I walk, though it's not too bad after the leather has been broken in.  Having a little heel is great but the foot bed could also use a little more arch support.  The rubber sole is great and doesn't squeak when wet like regular rain boots.  Overall, an almost perfect pair of boots.
UPDATE: After a few weeks of wear, the leather has softened and no longer cuts into my ankle. I also got some gel heel pads for better arch support and the boots are perfect now.