I have had these galoshes for a little over a week and they've been great, although they're the first I've had so I don't know how they compare to others.  Based on other reviewers saying they run small I ordered the 2XL size for my size 11 feet and they seem to be great, but maybe a tad larger than I need.  They have a thin rubber membrane that stretches over the button to fasten it that has broken on one of them, but there is thicker rubber around it so I don't think the tear will spread further.