I too had the issue with the right toe box being too small and hurting my feet. I wear a size 9 in ALL nine west shoes and purchased a 9 in these boots.  The left boot was fine but the right was just not doable.  Also, the boots are wide and will fit around someone with wider calfs which is good but that makes the ankle area really baggy.  I loved the color and embellishment but sadly these had to go back.