I just bought a pair of Tony Lama Boots Men's Aztec Shrunken CT2023 Boot,Aztec Shrunken Shoulder/British Tan Vegas, and they are Made in the USA, and were extremely well made.  So.... thinking to myself, well, here are a pair of $80+ Justin Boots, also Made in the USA.... let's give them a whirl!

Not so fast pardner!  Yes the boots are Made in the USA, and they appear to be well made, specifically, the stitching and the sole.  However, you DO get what you pay for, and these $88 boots are about 1/3 the quality of the Tony Lama $230 boots.  The hide they use for the uppers is pretty thin!  I mean, compared to the Tony Lama boots, they feel PAPER thin (which of course is an exaggeration...but you get the idea).  The Tony Lama hide is 3mm thick, the Justin boot hide is only about 1mm.  Heck, even my dress shoes have thicker leather on the uppers.  Fit on the boot is also much tighter especially around the ankle area.  The boot calf uses fairly thin leather, too, and so its not as firm as the Tony Lama boots, and I suspect in time, these will wrinkle and flop down.  The ankle opening of the boot is also fairly tight, and even though I ordered an 8.5 E boot, it was a bit of struggle to get my foot into the boot, even wearing thin dress socks.  I don't think I'll be able to get my foot past the ankle opening if I wear thicker athletic socks or even wool socks.

I'm giving these boots 1 2.5 - 3 star rating only.  They don't seem as well made as say Tony Lama boots, although I cannot say what they are like compared to the other brands available.  I can only compare to what I have. I will keep them, see how they wear.  For $89, if they last a year, that works out okay.  I will try to update once I've had these boots out for a while.  In the meantime, its silicone spray to protect what leather there is, and then a test drive in them.

UPDATE:
Just looked again, and price on these boots has jumped to $125.  If that's the case, not worth it!  Spend a bit more and get a boot that has BETTER materials!