I read all the reviews before ordering this boot. I initially chose a size 8, then right before ordering, went with a 7, and I am glad I did. I am a true size 7. I was worried about what others said about getting them on...I didn't have a problem. I agree that they are really, really roomy in the foot part, and pretty snug round the calf. They feel strange, because they look like dressy leather boots, but FEEL like rain boots. So, I think psychologically, I just need to adjust to the fact that these are waterproof boots, not dress boots. I LOVE them. They are super warm (I live in coastal Alaska, with lots of rain, wet snow, and ice). I don't even have to wear thick socks, just normal socks. My jeans still tuck in, even better than with my leather dress boots, because of the neoprene lining on the inside of the shaft. The kept my legs super warm, but not hot. The jeans don't bunch up and feel uncomfortable. There's not a lot of room for my tucked in jeans, but it worked without being too tight, and I think I have pretty average calves. Taking them off was hard; I needed help from my husband. :) They will break in. SO worth the price. I finally have a pair of Bogs that look stylish and grown up, not little kid-ish with a weird polka dot pattern. Can't wait to wear them all winter with everything in my closet. Lovely boot. Might get the black pair now. I recommend ordering two sizes then returning the one that doesn't fit as well.