I find these shoes very comfortable to wear but I don't leave the insole that came with them because its arch support is a bit to low but I have replaced insole with aetrex sandilistars mosaic insoles & they are now perfect. Now the sizing on these can be alittle tricky, with the original insole they are too tight but without original insoles they fit good with bare feet in them the sze 10. The 10.5 ones with original insoles in fit good but not enough arch support but u can fit orthonics into these if need be.
I have a few of these shoes same style but different colors & paterns & have had lots of comments about them. I find they are wearing well so far. The 4 star rating is because of the insoles they need a higher arch support otherwise your foot tends to roll in which is not good & could cause problems