I was looking for a boot like this, something that looked a little worn and would feel that way too. They were very comfortable at once, even though I think they will need some breaking in still.  It has a soft upper and the finish is nice but vintage looking with good quality craftsmanship. Ariat boots have been known for their quality.  I was given a gift certificate for this purchase and I'm thankful because I am wearing these boots on a daily basis, which is what I was looking for.