The headline should read, too small, then too big.  Unfortunately, my husband has a very high instep and this created a fit problem for him.  We tried a regular 14 first and he could not get his foot in the boot, BUT, we liked the boots so much we tried again. This time we bought a 14W, but this didn't work either, as they were then to loose on his feet.  This was a great disappointment because he really liked the boots.  Again, this was not the fault of the boots at all, just one of those things that cannot be helped, as in "weird shaped feet" for pull on boots.....LOL! He will have to get lace up boots instead.  If you can wear pull on boots, don't hesitate to get these, they are very nice!