I have been eyeing these boots for 2 months.  After reading Amazon's mixed reviews, I finally broke down and got them in black.  I wanted to love them, I really did, but I'm returning them.  The style is cute as can be, but they're the quality of a bargain brand boot.  The heel is cheap, leather and zipper are flimsy.  As for fit, I'm petite and struggle to find boots that aren't huge on my calves, but found these to be a really nice fit for me.  Another reviewer commented that the boots she received were different widths which I thought was a fluke, but mine were also. One foot was much looser around the ankle than the other.  Weird.