Purchased this for my 8 year old for a piano recital and she looked beautiful in them.  Although there is a heel, the shoe is not too grown up.

Pros:
Fit - True to size, we sized up a 1/2 size due to her wide feet and the fit was perfect.  Adjustabable velcro strap, easy on and off.
Durability - She used the pedals on the grand piano for three songs and there were no scratches on her shoes.  She also played outside in the shoes, still no scratches.
Looks - Beautiful, perfect for special occasion dresses or church.  Pretty strap.  High polished patent leather (not cheap looking).
Comfort - My very picky daughter (who loves her brothers shoes) did not complain one bit.  She was in these shoes for 3 hours.
Cost - Less than twenty bucks you can't get that at payless, what a bargin.
Safety - Non skid soles

Cons:
Would have been nice to see all sizes in wide width.
Need more colors!

I highly recommend these shoes for your little girl.  She will love them and so will you.  And with the free shipping and returns you can't go wrong.