She picked these out for her own gift.  It has not been cold enough for her to really use them, but it is what she wanted so I will rate them at 5 stars.

Ok, this is a text from my wife:

No. I don't like them.  The mitten part does not stay on, thumb hole on one glove is larger making my thumb always stick out and the velcro is cheap so the mitten part does not stay held back when trying to use as gloves.

Guess, they are not worth the money, don't waste yours!