The shoe has proven to be warm and comfortable while looking cute, too. I would have preferred more curves around its sides, but apart from that very personal opinion, it's a good shoe with great traction and insulating and water-repelling properties. Definitely suitable for cold, wet/snowy weather. It also came with instructions on how to further waterproof it with silicone, which I did, so I'm very sure this pair of shoes will see me through the winter snow.