*Update* Oct 2013
I like these boots. They are warm and comfortable. No glitz or glamour, no bells/whistles, but functional comfort in cold weather. I wasn't really after attractive cool-looking boots, so that these are NOT, is not an issue!

*Initial Review*
I got the chocolate color. 8.5, my normal size in running shoes. Fit well out of the box, then my feet felt like they sunk in and are now confined to the foot pattern in the boots, which would be ok if I'd ordered in a size 8. They are warm, but clunky, and I drag my feet when wearing them. The buttons are not meant to be undone, though they are un-doable. I don't recommend the Chocolate color: these boots seem dirty even when they are not. I chose these after a long time of looking for boots on Amazon. I wanted warm, tallish, somewhat moisture-proof boots for work. These are not a fashion statement, in fact they are what I imagine clod-hoppers to be, and I feel like I have mitts on my feet. But I like them. This review is probably not helping you!