Pros:
- Comes exactly as shown (I got the black/grey Shemagh)
- Blocks winter wind well
- Light weight
- Surprisingly very warm

Cons:
- Decent construction; there are many loose ends to the Shemagh I ordered that often get stuck on the zipper of the jacket pocket I keep it in. This causes it to tighten up on certain threads (which you can just pull back to normal).
- From closer inspection, the Shemagh's different threads for some of the colors are not actually fully sown into one another, it looks frail at this level (the different colors only slightly layer).

Misc.
- It is BIG (as told in the dimensions)

Summary:
A good product for cold weather that can be used as directed as a Shemagh, or as a scarf or bandanna. Close up, the construction might not look fantastic, but it hasn't disappointed me yet otherwise (great for the cold and wind).

*************UPDATE**************
If you intend to actually wear this a Shemagh in the U.S., I might recommend that you don't. Based off of personal experience, one time at night I was walking by a woman and she screamed (x.x"---maybe thinking I was a terrorist or something)... unless that's the kind of reaction you want, you might want to just use this a a bandanna or scarf.