I had heard all the good reviews for this boot, so I decided to take the plunge.  I normally wear a 12/13 depending on the brand, so I tried on a 12 in the store.  It still seemed a little big so I ended up ordering the 11.5 from Amazon and it's perfect, if not a little big.  I can wear this boot anywhere and with anything.  I bought some Sno Seal and am hoping it won't turn the Beeswax color too dark, but once its sealed I will wear this boot all winter long.