Ordered a size too small the first time based on a review posted here.  I have a 34" waist, and the 36" belt fits perfectly with just enough tip left.  The belt is thick, but is classy enough for jeans or business casual.  I wear dockers to work, and jeans at night so this belt will get a lot of use from me.  The sheen is satin, not glossy, which is great for a more casual look.