I'm quite happy with this purchase.  I generally wear a 9W or 9 1/2M.  I ordered the size 10. They are comfortable and there is enough room to put socks that aren't too bulky under them in winter rainy or snowy days. I like the pattern, but they're a little darker and more muted than I thought they would be. I saw someone else wearing them in the turquoise color and I think I would have preferred those, but I think I'll stick with what I have.