I really like these boots - they are super comfortable and the color is great. I would give them 5 stars, but they are already getting creased across the top from bending when I walk. That means the leather is a cheaper grade and will not hold up as well - but for a boot that is under $50, that's to be expected. I won't be able to wear them to work once they get beat up, but they are great for going out on weekends to concerts were I have to stand for long periods of time.