My daughter really likes these boots.  They are nice and warm and she likes that they go up a little higher for the deep MN snow.  Her previous boots were size 2 but I bought these at size 4 (hoping that she can wear them again next winter).  She said they are definitely big in the foot area but they are tight in the ankle to put on - even with the strap loose.  However, there is no problem with them falling off.  I have no complaints.  Color is true to picture.