I love the Smartwool products, so I had to give this at least something of a rating.  However, it was a second, but not advertised as such.  One of the straps was twisted before being sewn into place. If it had been advertised as a second and priced much lower, I would have been happy to find a way to repair it.  It was a bad surprise, and I would have returned it but I couldn't find the package or the receipt and was on my way to a ski trip.