Sorels seem to be the new Uggs these days, so, sure enough, I decided to follow the trend and got me some Tivolis. I got to test them yesterday as we got tons of snow in MN, and I walked through slushy parking lots and sidewalks. I got home with aching and wet feet! Waterproof, you say? What a joke. My cheap rubber boots provide better water resistance than these! Warm? Another joke. Not warm at all. Plus, no arch support, and my foot kept sliding forward even in the right size. All I can say is: these boots are trendy and look cool but that's about it. They are not for snow or rain!