I usually wear an 8 or 8 and a half. In theses shoes I probably should be wearing a 9 but I ordered an 8, having no option to try them on obviously. Because they are a tiny bit small and they are essentially fabric, it makes the toe a little pointy where my big toe is.  They feel fine, but personally I think they look slightly weird because of the point, though I don't think anyone else notices that when I am wearing them but me. They are comfortable but in my opinion maybe a little expensive for the overall quality of the shoe; I expected it to feel a little more substantial, but it is sold to to be like a flip flop so I guess "buyer beware" on that.

 I think part of the design of the shoe is for it to look like it has been worn a lot, with the "stuffing" (fluffy material) sort of coming out at the seams. Mine actually have some soon-to-be holes where the seam isn't quite sewn all the way, so if that is what you want, definitely buy these shoes. As for me I could spend a little more for one that is made better.