I was going to take a star off just because they are very narrow in the calf, but they are so gorgeous and the quality so high that they are definitely worth a 5-star rating. Ok, they are just a bit too snug in the calf for me when I wear them with skinny jeans but they are fine if I'm wearing them with tights and a skirt, and no doubt the leather will stretch a bit over time.
They are great if you want the "Katniss" look or even the Mori girl look, which I love. These boots are very versatile and very comfortable with good grip soles. I can see them lasting a very long time with the right care (I also bought some Frye leather conditioner to keep the leather in good shape). I would say they are definitely worth the $400 for aesthetics and overall quality.