I've had these boots for about a year now and I still love them!  They are super comfortable and nice looking.  They are mid-calf, not knee-high.  I have narrow feet and thinner calves, and they are not too bulky, but not tight either, just right.  I treated them thoroughly with a water resistant spray when I first purchased them and will probably treat them again after this winter. I gave them only 4 stars because they are not very warm.  We're having a very cold winter and often the bottoms of my feet get super cold when outside, and the suede gets wet in the snow.  Still, I love them and wear them to work often.  But for being outside in bad weather I wear my waterproof warm Keens or Sorels.