The only reason I scored this a 4 is that I like shoes roomy, so I exchanged my orginial order for 1 size larger.  I love the chesnut color.  The clogs are very warm, almost warmer without socks, even in MN winters.  The soles are non-skid, which are great when it snows or when it's slippery outside.  I would highly recommend this to anyone who wants warm feet with simple on/off access to shoes when it is cold outside!