I bought these boots last year (not on amazon, I have wide feet so I need to try them on before I buy them as some brands I need to go a size up) and they had been great.

They were very comfortable, warm, bone dry (at first) and had good enough support that I could walk all day pheasant hunting in them when needed.

The bad is that in the last year I used them for approx. a total of 24 days worth of foot in boot time (two pheasant hunting trips and deer season in MN).  This year while in South Dakota it rained, the next day with just wet grass (not standing water) my feet got soaked.  Didn't bring a backup pair of boots because the La crosse boots and waders I've had in the past lasted for years (usually either outgrew them or wore them out) without problems.  very disappointing.

I live in the La Crosse, WI area where the company used to make its boots, now that their made in China it seems that the quality has slipped.  I was able to get a new pair under warranty (had two weeks left on the 1yr warranty!) and will try these boots again.  Hopefully it was just a fluke, if this new pair leaks then its a quality control problem.

Just as a final note I had a pair of Rockys I literally wore the camo off of before I got rid of them, lasted about 7 years through pheasant, deer, duck hunting, fishing, snow blowing etc.  Bought a new pair of Rocky boots (that these La Crosses ended up replacing) that leaked in under a year....as you might guess they were made in China as well.  Two years of wet feet in a row and I'm starting to see a pattern with the made in china crap.

UPDATED 11-2013.

Another year later and another slow leak in the boot.  Just enough to get the socks damp.  Not sure if I'm expecting to much out of a pair of boots or what but after 1 pheasant and 1 deer season again...boots are leaking slightly.  Going to try waterproofing them with spray but disappointed in these boots and lowered my rating down to 2 stars (They are still darn comfortable). Honestly from now on I'll probably just buy the walmart specials...half the cost and made in china as well.  No difference in quality from what I can see (have a pair of 400 gram walmart Bramahas that cost $30 bucks...so far no leaks in those at 1/3 the cost).

I sure miss the old American made La Crosse Boots...those were darn good...these news ones are not.