I really wish I could rate this boot after wearing them for awhile.  Unfortunately, the seller sent me two left boots of completely different brands & I had to wait forever to get a refund.  It wasn't an easy return and I had to request permission via customer service to do the return & wait for UPS to show up with the return label. The one Enzo boot was very scratched up, not as described.  I did try it on and it seemed like it would be fairly comfortable if I actually got to use them; however, it was pretty bulky.  It did appear as though it would fit my larger calf adequately. I didn't like the leather very much.  It was pretty rough and I wanted a smoother leather.  So all in all, it was a bad experience, not of the manufacturer's making, but of the seller's negligence. 3 stars reflects my overall opinion of the boot, not the experience with the seller.