This shirt is well made, warm and comfortable,I like to wear it with a undershirt,because the fabric is wool and and a little coarse. Why 2 stars? It is snaps,not buttons (that would be fine if they was stable). The first time I wore it,I took it off and noticed a hole where the male end of the snap was supposed to be. On the good side,it was the inside not the outside. I purchased a set of snaps from a sewing center and replaced the inside snap. Doesn't match the snap on the outside,but looks perfect from the outside. I bought a set that has more than one snap,If a outside snap falls off,I would give it 1 star,and have to replace all the snaps. Too bad, it is a nice shirt-Can't Justify buying another one.