I was looking for a winter weather boot that would keep my feet warm, be comfortable to walk in, protect from wetness, and one in which I could shove my pants in to protect my pants/jeans when walking from the train.  This boot does it all.  the warm lining goes into the toe/foot area, so my feet are never cold.  I am able to fit my pants in the boot as the laces allow you to loosen/tighten as you need.  They resist the water/wetness and the bottom tread is great for the slippery Chicago sidewalks.  They are also very comfortable. I use them to walk to and from the train station, about 4 city blocks/half mile one way.  They are comfortable and my feet border on a wide in the toebox area, so these are roomy enough to fit my foot comfortably.  I ordered an 8, which is what I use in running shoes; i normally wear a 7 or 7 1/2 in dress shoes.

They also are not terribly ugly as many winter boots can be. I have received compliments on them.  So what more can I want out of winter boot.