I don't like clunky shoes/boots. I searched to try to find something that would satisfy my need for a sturdy, waterproof hiking boot and desire for un-clunky. Then, of course, they had to look good and make my feet look small! I decided these were as close as I was going to find. I do like how they look. They are clunky but I guess only as much as necessary. I do feel sure footed and secure with them on! Pretty comfortable. I have only worn them a couple of times and so far okay. I'm having the most problem with the upper part rubbing around my legs. You cannot cinch them tight at the top.