I had my eye on these boots for a while, so I finally got them, and they are just as great looking in person as they are in the pics! (I got the black w/ the plaid interior)

PROS: these are great looking boots, really soft leather that doesn't need to be broken in like traditional hard leather Docs.

CONS: They DO run a bit big. I tend to prefer my boots to be a half size too big so I can put in insoles and wear thick socks, but these are still quite roomie even with the added insole and thick socks. I ordered my standard size.

That wouldn't be too much of an issue, except for the seam at the Achilles tendon. If you look at the pics, there is that ankle height seam for where the boot folds down. That rubs on the tendon and so far I haven't figured out how to remedy that. I'm not sure if that would be better or worse if the shoes were more snug.

So, fairly comfortable but due to the rubbing I won't be wearing them for anything requiring lots of walking.

***UPDATE***
I ended up buying another pair one size down and they fit perfectly!