Well, it looks a little nicer in the pic and when it came in my daughter noticed a rattle.  I had to tighten all the prongs because the setting was loose.  This is decent but I imagine if WalMart carried this ring it would be $5-10.  Aside from having to tighten it quite a bit this was decent as far as cheap rings go.  (She has only had it a few days though.)

Overall my daughter really likes it.

UPDATE:  The stone fell out of the ring and my daughter can't find it.  I am very disappointed so I removed stars.