I haven't worn these out yet. I just got them last week! But I was looking for a way to pack a set of waterproof boots for traveling. Something that could be worn in both cold snowy conditions and wet rainy tepid days. Plus they actually had to be wearable! I almost gave up looking til I saw these in one of my fitness magazines! I went online and bought them here on Amazon because they were cheaper than buying directly from Timberland's website.
They arrived so quickly and to my surprise, were amazingly compact. I was won over when I put them on-pretty comfy!
Now these shoes are really unisex. I bought a "mens" pair because I also needed a color that would be neutral for travel and I wasn't too keen on the womens color selection.
Since it hasn't rained I can't yet speak to how they are in the elements. I'll have to add another post. These aren't cheap, but if you travel over different weather conditions in a course of a trip, the simple fact  they pack no bigger than one sneaker is worth the price of giving it a chance.