I had the same problem as another reviewer with one shoe being bigger than the other, only my right shoe was too tight and the left one was loose. Had to return them. Oddly enough, I remembered having this issue with a pair of shoes before and realized it was also a pair of Naturalizers. Also, I don't always need to wear a wide, but the wide on this shoe wasn't enough. I wear and 8.5-9 and 9 wide in this shoe wasn't wide enough. The Clark's Dara 3 Boot looks very similar (I own a pair) and a 9 wide in that shoe with thick socks fits me great. You can try out that boot if you like the look but are concerned with the fit.