No doubt they would win 5 stars from me if it was just about looks. I love them. But there are a couple of not-so-great points I need to deduct: they don't breathe very well. Your feet could get sweaty if you get too warm. Also, the navy (ebony?) color textile on top wrinkles too easily when you walk. I'm not talking the permanent kind of wrinkle when your shoes get old, just the wrinkle that appears when you bend the shoe: the top layer of the textile is very thin (nylon?) and it will show too many of those wrinkles whenever the show is not perfectly straight (stretched) - you can actually see it in the pictures. All in all, those are minor points, but something good to know about when you buy online, since you can't touch it. Overall a great purchase, I'll keep them.