These earrings were as described - they are real silver (they do not irritate my very sensitive ears).  They are shiny and have not tarnished at all in the time I have worn them.  The posts are a little long for my liking, but they are easily cut if you have the proper tools.  I took off one star because the post does not have a catch for the earring back.  I believe this is because the earrings are so inexpensive.  For the price, however, these cannot be beat.  They are the perfect size (check how large you want the ball of the earring before you buy!) and are high quality for the cost.