Went for this after reading the reviews that a phone with case doesn't fit the Vera Bradley. The phone is snug and doesn't slide all the way to the bottom but the button/tab still reaches to keep it in. Switching over to this from a wallet made me realize how many stupid store cards i have and i finally started using my Key Ring app. Would be nice if this had a metal key ring to clip on my keys when need be but the strap works just as well.