I found this product after days of searching for something that both looked nice and could take the cold Vermont winters. I ordered a size 12 after reading the reviews (I normally wear a size 13). The 12 way far too large, I had to return them and purchase the size 11.5, which is still slightly too big, but work with some wool socks.
I received the pair of 11.5s around October 20th. Everything seemed perfect, kept my feet warm, extremely comfortable, and seemed to keep water out.
That's where I was wrong. The toe of the boot started to leak earlier today, it appears that the tip of the toe is glued down to the rubber rather than stitched, and this glue is separating. I am literally experiencing deterioration of the product in just over one month of light use.
I'm going to try as hard as I can to get these boots immediately replaced or returned, which will be difficult because it's been just over a month.
Beware when purchasing these boots, they look good, but don't live up to Timberlands quality reputation at all.