I have only gotten the tall Uggs in the past, but wanted a short pair to wear with my boot leg jeans (the tall Uggs bulge out the calves of the boot cut jeans and make them look funky) on the days when I don't want to wear skinny jeans, so I thought the short Uggs would be the ideal solution. These seemed a little tight across the top of my foot, the left foot worse than the right one, even though I got the size I usually get. I've only worn them once, so maybe they will stretch out and feel more comfortable in time, they are supposed to "fit snug" according to the user instructions. They are fine, just seem a little flimsy-er and not as well made as a previous pair of Uggs. I guess time will tell if they are as durable.

Checking back in, have had these boots for 10 months now. At first they were tight across the top of my foot, but they have stretched out a bit and are so comfortable! I wore them on vacation to Portland and walked everywhere in them...they kept my feet warm and cozy and comfortable. They are holding up very well so far. I highly recommend spraying them with waterproof spray when you first get them, the dirt just brushes right off, they still look brand new. I can wear them with either skinny or boot leg jeans. Highly recommend!