My wife is a 5.5 B and they fit great as her other Tony Lama Shoes.
The big concern I had was the mildew with the White chalky powered substance that were over them. The boot was either stored in a moist area or flood area (Amazon or the manufacturer) and some of the leather had moisture damaged. It was a little difficult for us to take care of the mildew, as you have to kill it or it does come back. I was able to apply mildew killer and then re-treat the leather. Normally we would have returned the boot, but tI felt confident it could be brought back ti a good state.

Stitching is consistent and tight,
leather good quality from a decent strip of hide.
Color ( a little off, due to mildew).
Arch, comfortable
Throat of boot nice and tight and good design