Yes, the shoes are quite shiny when new, but they are also so PRETTY!
They are very comfortable, right out of the box.  I normally wear an 8 wide, but in these I wear a 7.5 wide.
I did have to return the first pair for a smaller size, but the service was good.
I'm very happy with these, and I own 2 other styles from this maker.  Be aware, each style will vary your sizing slightly.