I have narrow feet, and bought these shoes in the slim width.  The elastic around the heel, though it may look just a bit uncool, really keeps them on my feet.  Hurray!  Based on other reviews, I ordered a full size larger than usual. That was good advice!  The shoes fit well and are quite comfortable, although they haven't yet had much wear.
I did not give five stars to these shoes because of the unfortunate shiny black soles!  Cheap-looking on a relatively expensive pair of shoes.  Hopefully they will wear well. The pewter leather is lovely; it will go with everything.
All in all, I'm satisfied with this purchase.