I joined the boot craze. I'm an 8.5 but I bought a 9. I could have bought an 8.5 and been fine. But these boots are so comfortable that even at half-a-size too big I will keep them forever. I'm 5'3" and these cover my calf. The soles are soft and sturdy, the boots are well-made and very attractive. Great for cold and rainy weather. Good with leggings and skinny jeans.