I ordered this boot in black and in tan and love both!  I did heed the advice of other reviewers and ordered up a size.  The tan are a bit tighter than the black in the calf area.  I won't be able to tuck pants into them, but I can wear them with skirts and dresses....and probably be able to wear leggings with them.  I noticed many of the reviewers purchased these for costumes, so I was a bit hesitant about the quality, but had a pair of boots made from this same material and I loved them so much because the material stretched and lasted for years.  I think the quality is great.  If there are any brown left, I may order those as well.