I ordered this coat based on the other reviews, but I found the coat to be lacking in the type of structure that creates flattering curves. The "belt" on the back isn't fully sewn in and looks totally out of place. The overall cut is not very fitted and the way the front panel with the snaps is constructed makes it balloon out from the torso.
The coat does get three stars for comfort and warmth. It's incredibly cozy and the lining makes it silky smooth on the inside.
Perhaps this coat would be perfect with some tailoring, but for the price I don't think it should need any.
5'8" 150 lbs ordered a size 8.