Gosh I wanted these bad- I ordered the black and brown! I love Madden Girl too.....however these are really LOW quality and look cheap. I am really disappointed. I wasn't expecting high quality for less than $40 but I wasn't expecting paper either.

Positive: the size was correct and the tassel cute.  Id order a 1/2 size up to accommodate cozy socks-they offer zero cushion or support-socks helped.

Fast forward a month- I decided to keep them because the price was so great. I wore the black pair yesterday for the first time and even got a compliment.  They probably are a one season boot due to quality, and they attract lint and puppy hair so make sure u have a tape roller available. OH: and I wore them with warm fuzzy chenille socks-that was great!!!