I love these boots and get lots of compliments on them.  I've had them for about 3 months and they've been tested on several New England snow storms and have held up great. They keep my feet warm and dry and look cute too! The only complaint I have is that some of the design has already worn off of one of the tips (black mark where it was part of a greet flower) - it blends in to the pattern so only I notice, but for the price of these I would have thought I'd get through a season before that happened.  But the functionality is still worth it! I usually wear an 8/12 and got a size 9 and they're fine. I think at 8 would have worked too since they're pretty wide and roomy.  All in all I love them and would buy them again!