Disappointed it had plastic buttons. Frustrated that you can throw it in the dryer. Not sure how the cream colored arm patch will hold up as it's not seamed. But I like the look and feel when wearing it. Seems well made, but I rarely wear stuff that requires this much care to be honest. Sizing seemed good in the shoulders and arm length, though it will be tight if you've got a beer gut I think. I'll see hold it holds up after a few more washes and revisit a 4th star if it does.