Pros: Bought these for my wife and she loves them.  Very comfortable and nice looking boots.  She gets lots of compliments.

Cons: The only complaint is that they seem to be a bit large in the calf and she has average size legs.  When I read the reviews that did not seem to be an issue because of the buckles.  Tightening the buckles makes the boots seem a bit bunched at the top.

Otherwise very nice.