these boots feel really good all over my feet. I'm deducting a star because of two things: 1) I ordered charcoal, and the ones I got were brown, and 2) they are like pythons to get on (really tight leg hole with no zipper/laces OR tab in the back to help pull them on) luckily I have slender limbs and it's only a short squish before they are on.
Other than that they are so nice! I decided to keep mine rather than return them because they are very good quality, good soles with traction, well stitched, warm and furry all over the inside, and the fabric on the upper part is heavy and strong.