I live in Wisconsin and was looking for a boot that would be waterproof, comfortable to walk around my neighborhood and still look cute (not big and clunky). These are perfect. Also, when I get to and am actually spending time in the bars and restaurants my feet aren't too warm, a problem I had with my Sorels. I have a slightly wide foot and they are plenty roomy with enough room if you wanted for some thick socks (though they are warm enough to not need thick socks). Also, they come up and stop just below my athletic calf which is good because I have a hard time finding boots that go over my calf. I've worn them with several different jeans tucked into them (the side zipper makes this easy). I get many compliments on them.