I like this boot a lot. I have little one's that I chase around the house, so these boots work well because of the low wide heel, rubber sole and being super comfy (if I wanted, I could literaly run in them)! I'm an average petite gal (5'2) so the top of the boot is a bit big. A bit loose around my calves but you really can't tell when you are wearing jeans with them. I've tried them w/a skirt and it was too obvious for me that I didn't feel comfortable wearing them without pants, leggings, etc.
I still love them though for the price, comfort and casual (and a bit above casual with the right outfit). Can't go wrong with comfortable, stylish, black boots!!