This case arrived quickly.  I received the dark blue one (they choose) and it came from Kikkerland Design.  It does not show finger prints, it really is anodized aluminum, and it holds more than 15 cards comfortably in a clean, slim design.  I found it a very good value for the price (about $4.50) and free shipping.  Perhaps the low star reviews are for card holders that came from a different supplier.  I know that Amazon often changes suppliers for seemingly the same item.  I have no complaints whatsoever about the card holder I received.  If you want to be able to choose the color, you should buy a different item.  It states, after all, assorted colors.