I love these boots. They are so "city cowgirl" which perfectly describes me living in Atlanta with our urban farm.  They look great with dresses. They are too snug on my calf to accommodate skinny jeans, but they are cute enough that I can forgive them for that.

As far as fit, I have a wide foot and usually opt for size 8.5, but I went with the 8 since they have the pointy cowboy toe, and that was the right decision for me. The bottoms are slick right out of the box, so I scuffed them up on the sidewalk so I didn't bust it somewhere.