My coat finally arrived today (YAY!) Overall, I like the coat. The quilting on the pockets and sleeve cuffs gives it a little extra style, and it reaches to my knees. The down filling will keep me warm, and apparently it's water-resistant too! I like that it is simple, without any rhinestones or fur, and the navy blue on the lining is subtle, but a nice touch. I would say it seems fairly well-made. I wore it outside today briefly and it did keep me very warm. However... one thing that I don't like about the coat is that it is not slimming whatsoever. I thought that the belt would help give me some shape, but it doesn't help. I am 5'2", 135 pounds and ordered M, which fit fine, maybe a little loose even. But if I had to do it again, I would order the S next time in the hopes that it would look slimmer. Also, its annoying that the lining gets caught in the zipper often, so you have to be careful when zipping it up. Overall though, a good buy for the price and the quality.