This case was exactly what I expected. It's made out of dimpled aluminum, the latches close securely, and it provides storage for my collection that is much safer that my sock drawer.
It's true that if your watches are much bigger than 42mm they will fit, but will not be prevented from touching each other; mine are all smaller than that, so it's not a problem. To really separate larger watches, they would have had to design the case with fewer spaces, farther apart.  Or you could leave an empty compartment between very big watches.
The supplied pillows are usable, but a little too soft for my taste. This is not a problem; I could cut my own out of stiffer foam, or use the ones that come with new watches if I needed to.
Some reviewers are complaining about the quality of the locks and keys.  It's true, they're not great, but I bought this case for storage, not for security.  Very serious cases with secure locks cost more like $200 and this one does what I need it to do for much less.
I would buy this one again, and may do so, if my collection gets any bigger.