I haven't owned a pair of waterproof boots since I was a kid. I took my time and read lot's of reviews and decided that the Bogs Roper Boot was perfect for me. I usually wear a size 9.5 and bought a size 10, in case I wanted to wear thick socks. So far my boots are excellent. They are very comfortable, warm, but not to warm (live in the Pacific Northwest), and they keep my feet completely dry. I'm sold...