I read through a lot of these reviews before I finally decided to order the boots. Last year I purchased a very expensive pair of Steve Madden boots and they wore out in a season. I was very disappointed and decided to see if I could find a bargain this year. (So if they wear out, who cares!). First, I have to admit, I am rough on my shoes. I am a photographer who does a lot of walking on various sorts of terrain and weather for shoots. Yet, I still want to look fashionable while at work. So far I am very happy with these boots. They were true to color and size. I ordered them in tan and I even love the red zipper on the back (I am a fan of that extra pop of color). My only wish is that the heal height was a little shorter, it is only about an inch, but I am a pretty tall. I do not like wearing tall shoes, and it is virtually impossible to find a cute pair of flat boots. So, I usually resort to adding that extra inch to my height. Compared to the style options for flat boots, it wasn't that big of deal. Obviously in a side by side comparison to expensive leather boots, they are not they same. But if you want something that looks fashionable, without spending a lot of money, these are a great deal. I say these boots are especially great for the type of person who wants something new every season. You get a super cute pair of boots at a great price.