This boot is so-so. They are not super comfortable (they really don't have much cushioning on the insole) but they are okay because they are new. Time will tell if they are durable. Durability has been an issue I have had with the last four pairs of Timberland Pro boots I have owned. I worked in sloppy mud yesterday wearing these boots and they did keep my feet dry so that was a plus. I guess I could recommend these boots but don't expect too much. As I stated, they are middle of the road, maybe a step higher than the cheap boots I used to buy at Payless.