I bought these because I had previous experience with tarnish-free silver.  The size is perfect for everyday wear and they are simple yet the tarnish-free of the silver adds a bit of sparkle.  Some commenters thought the shine was gaudy and preferred a less shiny or more matte finish but with the simple style the shine is just right. I would have given these a 5 but one of the earrings had a dimple on it.  They are light weight, easy to get on, I don't have to polish the silver, and they were the right size. I'd by these again.