There is nothing really "wrong" with the gloves.  They are a little thin but the quality is acceptable and the price and speed of delivery was great.  The XL however is not a "man's" XL.  They fit me (average-ish female) a little big but my 6'3" husband could barely get them on. They would have fit ours needs perfectly if they had an XXL size available.  So...if you are ordering for "normal" people they should be great.