I would have given 5 starts, but for Dr. Scholl's shoes who should know feet better than anyone, these boots pinch on the pinky toes (so they  lose a start)!  The boots are true to size, look great! And can wear them 3 different ways!  Been getting lots of compliments on Sweater Cover.  They think they are leg warmers at first, but I tell them it's part of the boots.

I have to wear super thin socks or else my feet would start hurting by lunch time.  It pinches on the pinky toes, especially if the socks seam is right on your toe.  These boots look great and got it really cheap.  But disappointed that I can't wear them too long.