The right and left boot seem to fit differently on my feet.  The foot portion of the left boot is a bit snugger than the right, and the right calf area is tighter than the left.  Also, it seems that these were made for women with narrow feet.  Maybe it's just the pair I received, but I'm going to keep and slowly stretch them out via wearing for short periods of time as it is made of leather.  Also like other reviews, I'd say these boots run half a size small.  It doesn't seem that way to me as it's a tight fit on the sides of my feet, but for the price (I got them about 60% off) I'd say it's a valuable purchase.