I bought this one simply because I needed another color.  They are lightweight and a light weave but cheap enough that you can buy another one if you wear it out.  It will work as a winter scarf despite being thin.  When rolled and doubled up it keeps out the wind.  Since it is cotton it will pull heat from your neck/body when wet.  That can be a benefit in the summer but if it gets wet from melted snow in the winter its a disadvantage.  Overall satisfied.  My original one is holding up well but I have yet to Machine wash it.  More to come.