Overall I think these are a great choice for someone who is wearing them occasionally. If you live on a farm and want to wear them daily, then go with BOGS. But, for the discounted price I bought these at, they are a great value for what you get.

They are easy on/off. I don't even need to use my hands. They are very comfortable on my shin, they do not dig in at all when I walk.

I'm a pretty consistent 8.5 in shoes and I bought a 9 and they are perfect.

My feet stay pretty warm in them. I'm not wearing them for extended periods, but for the 10-15 minutes at a time I'm out in the cold my feet do not get cold at all and in fact felt warm.

My only criticism is that they are slippery on the bottom. BOGS have a nice rubber bottom but these do not. If you do a lot of walking on ice for some reason than there are probably other boots out there that are a better choice.