Haven't worn them out yet but they are beautiful!  They seem comfy and true to size; I probably could have gone with the 8 but with socks and over jeans I think the 8.5 will work well.  They are simple and have clean lines which I love. Not sure how I feel about the textured, pebbled leather as I usually prefer a smoother look but the price, look and comfort makes up for any doubts I may have.  I was disappointed to see that these boots are made in China; I had assumed that a higher end boot like Cole Haan would be made either here in America or in Europe.