These boots were a beautiful dark, dark chocolate brown and fit well! I ordered them with hesitation because I don't ever order boots online. I like to try them on directly at the store. But I took a chance. I measured my entire foot, shaft, calves, etc. Then, I googled "how to measure my feet/legs against boots measurements" to make sure they fit well. So let's say - I did my research before I bought. I also read the reviews saying these would fit well over larger calves (which is what I have). so I ordered them. The boots arrived quickly and fit perfectly. I did buy separate gel insoles to wear with them, which helps tremendously when wearing these around the office all day. I bought my exact size  8.5 medium width  and they fit well, even with the added insoles. I would not have been happy if I bought a half size larger than what I normally wear. I didn't adust the ties when I wore these with skinny jeans, but when I wear them with a dress/tights, I may adjust them by tying the ties tighter, so they stay on my legs better. I love them!