Love these! Comfy, beautiful shoe. I'm a size 9, and they fit perfectly and true to size.
Also, I'm 5'3" and 150lbs. I have what I'd call 'thick calves'...and these boots fit GREAT. I'm sure someone will understand what I'm saying here, but I don't want 'muffin top' on my legs b/c the shaft of a taller boot is too tight on my calf. These are PEFECT!!! Nice thick sole with decent traction...and very soft, nice leather. Highly recommend. I can't speak to what others are saying about them only lasting a season or discoloring, as I haven't worn them outdoors yet, but I walked around the house in them for a good hour last nite and they were very comfy and warm.