I bought this boot in the taupe, size 8, as I am a perfect size 8. It was $497 with tax (rounded). It fit perfectly right out of the box and was everything I expected from a quality boot, but I think Frye is milking their name here... I have numerous boots--all leather, including the soles--most with leather-lined shafts that are much thicker than this boot's, and none of them were priced over $300. I would value this boot at $325 max--hence only 4 stars. The main reason I forked out this much money to splurge on these was because I received a huge bonus. Again, the boot is what I wanted, and I expect them to last a long time, but this is the last time I will go this high for a pair of boots, on principle alone. I found a gorgeous pair of Ivanka Trump leather equestrian boots for $300 online. They had originally listed for $500. If you want great deals, they are out there. However, if money is not an issue for you, then you should be very happy with these.