i only gave this product 3 stars becasue the boots are not water proof at all and i do not know how she will wear them in the winter time with the snow. For the price you would think they would have some sort of water resistant to them but they do not. we went trick or treating and it was sprinkling and her feet got soaked. Alsoi feel like these boots are waaayy over priced. My daughter does love them and so do all of her friends we get compliments everywhere we go.