I should give it 5 stars because I've repurchased these several times over the last two years.  Yet, I buy them because my daughter likes them. I don't think they have ever fit right. The size 4 runs small (big enough for my daughter at 3 to early 4, who is in the 50% range for weight and height).  Now that she is 4.5, I had to go to the next size up because I don't feel they stretch well. The next size up is 6 which are super baggy in the butt.  I wish they would stretch more. Then the sizing would make more sense. Or, they need to make a size 5.

The color stays true and so does the emblems. They don't rip. They look thin, though. Well, I suppose if they were better quality in terms of thickness and stretch, they would be more expensive.