Upon first inspection of these boots when I got them in the mail, they seemed well made and light weight for how big they are. After testing them on a camping trip this past weekend, they held up extremely well and kept my feet warm. They grip well on both rock and gravel/dirt surfaces. Didn't get to test how waterproof they actually are, but I suspect they would hold up well because they don't breath all that well (feet were a little sweaty at the end of the day, but that's to be expected). They are actually quite comfortable on the soles, but the back side over my ankle irritated my skin a bit from its forward angle. In fairness, I wasn't wearing hiking socks, which would have provided more thickness and comfort.

Overall, I'm very happy with my purchase. For the price, you won't find a better pair of hiking boots. The meager cost also makes you feel better about roughing them up a bit.