I'm not very pleased with the boots.

1 - I ordered coal.  From the pictures and the description, I expected the boots to be dark--almost black.  They're much lighter than the pictures ... more heather than coal.

2 - The leather on one of the boots is dry and looks old and weathered.  The leather on the other boot seems to be fine.

3 - The sizing seems off.  I ordered the same size boot I always order (and I've ordered a lot of boots!), but they feel like they're at least a full size too big.  The shoe part is too large while the legs (shaft?) are too narrow.  I normally have no trouble wearing boots over my calves.  These, however, are difficult to zip.  All in all, the loose feet and tight calves make them very uncomfortable.

4 - I just think they're funny-looking.  I love the way these boots look on Amazon.  I hate the way they look on my feet.