I've been very happy with this shoe! Fits true to size.  Mine do make a squishy noise, but I am only conscious of it in very quiet environments, i.e. the library.  I walk a lot, and rather athletically (I'm just not someone who strolls leisurely), and overall these are very comfortable and supportive, although a couple of times the inside ankle strap caused some discomfort.  As for looks, the patent leather gives an otherwise sporty looking shoe some distinction, and I wear them with casual skirts and dresses, but I would never consider this a "dress-up" shoe.