I love these Steve Madden Women's Bonanza Tall Shafted Flat boots. They are nice quality and comfortable. I got them in the gray. I wear a 7 1/2-8, ordered the 7 1/2 and they fit perfectly. The sole is flat but very comfortable. BUT, I have larger calves even though I'm really short, and unfortunately, could not get the shaft up over my calves, so I have to wear the boots all scrunched down. So I am just warning all you ladies with larger calves to measure them and read the description of boots carefully so you know you'll be able to pull them up.