I bought these boots in a 7.5 black velvet.  In the picture the black pleather looked cheap and the patent was too shiny so, I went with the velvet and I'm so happy I did. They are a rich deep black and not at all shiny like some velvet can be.  It did have a spot on the outside of the ball of the foot where it was resting/rubbing in the box but it wasn't noticeable once they were on, only up close. Since my calves are 14 3/4" (BIG), I couldn't believe that these fit!  They make my legs look soooo long and lean which is great since I'm only 5'3" and have muscular legs.  The platform looks great and adds extra comfort under foot as well.  So, glad I got them, now I can wear dresses in winter avoid your hemline being shorter than the top of your boots. Now it'll just be a long unbroken leg line and then my skirt.  Can't believe I found a pair of boots that are cute, actually fit me, are versatile and such a steal!  Ah--Mazing!