these could be a 5 star IF they fit! haven't had a chance to find out. I just returned my corduroy crocs today. Couldn't wait for them to come as I have other winter crocs I love. I got the same size as my mommoths which are very comfy and roomy, these were at least a size smaller. My toes hit the end and the liner is not so thick that it will change. I love the look and other wise think I would love them. came on here to order the next size up but after reading the other review I'm not sure. I haven't had any problems with my others. I love my crocs but wanted ones more water proof....???