I gave these to my little sister for christmas. The color was really pretty and they fit her well. She wears sizes 8.5 to 9 in shoes and I got her an 8. I gave a three because they ar not mine so I can't give a really detailed opinion, however, if you want boots you can just pull on these are not the ones for you. They take time to tie and tie correctly. Not a ton of time but atleast a minute or two