I think some of these older reviews are for a different shirt than I bought; I actually wanted to the shirt that they were reviewing because it's the shirt that you'd get at the BX, and I've loved those since I was in the Air Force.

Unfortunately, the shirts I bought seem to actually be an upgrade over the previous version. These fit larger, and seem to be really abject to any shrinkage. Also, they're much thicker, which is not something I was looking for at all. Hence the three star review.

That being said, just because it's not the shirt I wanted doesn't make it a bad shirt. It's actually a pretty good shirt; tight seems, thick, and un-shrinkable. The sleeves are a little long, though, and it tends to not taper as well as the older model.

Bottom Line: If you're looking for the old black soffee shirt that we wore with our BDU's, this isn't it.