From the fabulous reviews, I guess I was expecting a $200 bag for $18.95.  The bag was disappointing in two main respects: the "red" is a dull red, anot the bright red that I thought was in the picture.  Second, the zipper is not attached all along the top of the bag -- it is a bit unusual in that it closes about half the length of the bag leaving the sides open for things to fall out unless you snap the attached tabs on top of the zipper and then it would be less of a risk.  It's a complicated (and clever) design, but I just wanted a simple bag with a zipper that would keep everything inside.

So instead of keeping it, I will give the bag to a friend who loves giraffes -- a nice surprise gift!