These sandals were great right out of the box.  I have a narrow foot and tend to wear 8 1/2's in my dressier shoes and 9 in my sneakers.  The 8 1/2 fit me just fine.  I went with the flinstone color because I love blue.  It was hard to tell on my computer if the accents were grey or tan/brownish, they are both.
I agree with some reviews that mentioned the ankle strap being a little high, it is a little high, however I have kept it a little looser and it doesn't bother me.  The strap could be a tad longer, but it isnt' a show stopper for me.  With all the straps on the sandal these can easily be adjusted for narrow or wider feet.  The insole is cushy and makes them more tolerable for longer wear during the day.  Plus there is adequate arch support.
For a water sandal these can't be beat for comfort, style and price.  I highly recommend them.