I ordered a bunch of boots, and this one had everything I wanted in a boot- slight wedge heel but mostly flat, classy enough to wear to work but casual enough to wear with jeans, and a great dark brown color. I didn't mind the gold toned zip on the outside. The leather is stiff enough to stand on its own, but the boots are comfortable.
But the shaft is just much too wide. I have skinny legs and am used to having a boot a little wide on my leg, but these were just much too wide.

Also, while there is a little rubber for grip under the front part of the foot, be wary that the small heel is a little slippery.

If you have wide calves, these would be great for you.