Everything about this boot was great (fit, quality, etc) - except the color.  I chose the gray thinking they would look cute tucked into skinny jeans. No. Next, I tried them untucked (ick!).  They seriously looked like grandpa's galoshes. Before giving up, I even tried them with a black and gray skirt (YUK! Think peasant woman wearing a faded flowery kerchief tied under her chin and bent over in a barren field digging for roots.)

I already have ugly boots for tromping through slush, so I returned these.

Good luck  with the other colors, I imagine if a low-healed sporty boot is what you're looking for, they'll be fine.