Overall, I am very pleased with this boot.  Being someone who hates walking in heels, this boot provides a comfortable fit without sacrificing style.  The heel is just high enough to make my legs look longer, but I don't feel like I'm walking in heels at all.  The suede is very soft, as others have noted.  I also have trouble with boots because of my calves, but these fit without any problems, even with jeans tucked in, and without any problems with cutting of circulation to my feet.  They are also very true to size.

However, as others have noted, the color is darker than advertised (I got the light brown, but they look like the medium or dark brown, but they still look great).  They do indeed slouch, more than the photo would suggest, but I think they look pretty good if they're somewhat slouchy.  I don't think they look "piratey" like one reviewer wrote, but I can see how she would make such a comment.  Also, as others have said, they are more like mid-calf boots, rather than tall boots, especially with the slouch.

The positives outweigh the negatives for me.  Primarily, I look for comfort in a shoe, and these meet and exceed those expectations.  It is a bonus that they are cute and fashionable.  I recommend them, especially since they're on sale!