I believe I've already reviewed the Cayman... and how I would never wear them and couldn't figure out why they are so popular.  Bought some on a (beer run) side trip while camping on a river and was ever so impressed how I could wear them in the water.  And who would have thought this ugly (yellow) shoe could be so comfortable.

Shopping today for yet another pair (already have the flip-flops now) with my friend Kathy.  Her shoe collection rivals that of Carrie Bradshaw and she wouldn't be caught dead in them.  I purchased a red pair of these Mary Janes (opting to wear them out of the store instead of my trusty Burks), and I literally forced her to try them on.
She hesitantly did as I asked (under duress) and had to admit her surprise at how comfortable they are, but she did say they looked to big.  Told her I would buy her a pair for her b-day and then she was ever so excited to find her signature pink in a pair of Caymans that fit her better.  She also wore hers out of the store.

And I agree.... they don't 'fit' like regular shoes, but this doesn't matter to me as long as I have happy feet.

Again... these shoes ARE butt-ugly.  And there's nothing exciting about the colors either, but if you want a practical summer shoe...esp good for beach and water please trust me and at the least get to a store that sells them and try them on.  But don't be confused... there are a few types of knock offs that are comfortable, but the plastic (or whatever they are.... alien fabric?) is much softer.

And did I mention how picky I am?  Took me years to try these shoes.  And if Kathy will wear them, I think even Carrie Bradshaw has a pair or two.

AND if that weren't cool enough!  They even have a website.... get this... you can recycle them!

I'm 56yrs old and that is my story.
xox

Oh.... did I mention the slides I have in my cart??