I've owned a pair in brown for 3 months and liked them. They look like good quality leather, but very soft on bare legs. Have done well in the snow. I just wipe them off.
Then I totally fell in love with them when I had to walk 3/4 miles in them. So comfortable. The heels seem to have a little give with each step, not the wobbly kind, just enough to minimize impact on your feet. The toe room worked well for me as well.
So I went and ordered another pair in black!
I understand these boots may not work for everyone, so FYI I wear size 6 and am 113 pounds.