I gave this boot five stars.  Not because it's the best boot, but because it's the best boot for the price (about $40).  I was very hesitant to purchase them because of the price but I'm very happy with them.  They're not the highest quality of leather but the details, like the wing tip toes which are slightly curved, truly make them a cute boot.  I did read the other reviews and bought a bigger size.  I usually wear a 9.5 and can sometimes fit into a 9, but I bought these in a 10.  They fit like a charm and actually make my feet look pretty small!  I have slightly wide feet and my toes of have plenty of wiggle room without them being too big in front.  The only issue I have, that can be fixed by taking them in, is that the heel has slipped out from under me so I have to very careful when walking.  My calves are average and they fit great there too.  I highly recommend these boots if you don't feel like spending a lot of money.  Not sure how they will hold up.  We'll see.