I purchased these oxfords because my sports medicine doctor specially recommended them with my custom orthotics.  I had to buy a pair one full shoe size larger than my typical shoe size to comfortably fit my feet with the orthotics.

Pros:
My new shoes were comfortable the from the first moment I put them on
Work well with custom orthotics

Cons:
They are not as shiny as some Oxfords I've owned
They do not look particularly round near the toes (my oxford style preference)

[Reviewer Addition] After 6 months of use:
My shoes are still completely comfortable to wear
They scuff up more than any other pair of Oxfords I have previously owned
My pair developed a squeaking sound that comes from the heel.  If I press my thumbs hard into a heel, I hear a sound as if the outer heel is sticking to something in the inner heel for a moment, then releasing