I would give these shoes a 5 except that there isn't enough toe room. I bought the version with laces in 10 1/2. I've been wearing New Balance shoes size 10 1/2 for the last 3+ years (2-3 pairs) and they always fit perfectly before this, so I don't know what's going on with this shoe. I find that my toes are constantly pressing against the end of the shoe whether sitting or standing. I also agree with one of the other reviewers that the soles are a little hard and stiff, although I haven't found that to cause any comfort problems. After this experience I will probably get my next pair of New Balance shoes in the store so I can try them on first, since apparently their construction is not consistent across different shoe lines.