I have lusted over this boot for months and when I found it on sale here I couldn't help myself! On every level this boot delivers! The somewhat distressed leather is soft and thick and the color is beautiful (I got brown). The heel height is perfect and comfortable for a full day of wear. With the rounded toe I opted for a 7 (I am usually a 7.5) and it is perfect. The shaft is pretty wide but it sits well (not too slouchy) and looks great with jeans or leggings. (I do think its a bit awkward wearing jeans over the boot, however, with such a wide leg shaft.) In the week since I received these, I've worn them out a few times, mostly just around town but also to a very muddy/slushy festival. I cleaned them easily with a nubuck/suede brush - I think that they will definitely only get better with age and actual wear! I have never gotten more compliments on a pair of shoes as I have with these. I even had a man chase me down to get the name and brand so that he could surprise his girlfriend who had just fallen in love with them! They are pretty much boot perfection and will last a lifetime!