I had a pair of Sandler of Boston shoes that were very similar to these, they finally wore out.  I wear a size 7 medium, and these seem almost true to size, maybe 1/2" longer than a normal size 7, but fit ok due to the square toe area.  They are fairly comfortable straight out of the box, I suspect they will be really comfortable after a couple more days of wearing them.

I like the elastic goring on both sides, makes them easier to put on.  The soles are hard plastic, and they looked like they may be slick to wear, but they have good traction, better than the leather soles on my old shoes.  The remainder of the shoe is leather; I purchased the black in smooth leather.

I was a little afraid to order these, the pictures almost make them appear to be elf shoes with the toes curled up, but they don't appear that way when you see them in person.

The reason for a 4 star rating instead of a 5 star? They make a clomping noise, even when walking on the carpeting at work.