After looking for years  (yes, years!) for a nice pair of tall brown leather boots, I was about to give up on finding a decent pair under $175. I was about to order something more expensive when I came across these. After reading the reviews I decided for this price they were worth a shot. I usually err on the larger side of 7.5 for sizing, but got the 7 after reading the recommendations. They fit great, the leather is nice, I love the flat heel and the rubber edging provides some protection for the leather. These are riding boots that one might actually wear to go riding - that's how sturdy they are. I received lots of compliments on them and noticed after one wearing the shaft felt roomier, which is nice for my muscular calves. I can actually tuck a pair of jeans in there and zip them up. Yay!