This shoe looked just as pictured. The fit was true to size. I wore them out one day after they arrived and my baby toe on the left was in great pain. I looked in the left shoe and seen that the maker didn't cut off the excess material like it was made on the right foot. But for the money I paid I've kept them and will work on that left shoe. The right foot was real comfy. All in all besides the left shoe needing some cutting off of the material inside, they seem to be a real nice flat. If the left shoe didn't need repair I'd give them a 4 1/2 star for a flat. I try many flats on and most are very uncomfortable.