I am 5'3" and 110 lbs., and the 6 short was both too long and too baggy. I could pull the pants off without undoing them. Not a plus. I sent them back and ordered a 4 short, but those are on backorder and won't get here in time for my trip south. Which is a drag, but no one's fault. I'm grateful for the free return special on jeans, because I would hate to pay extra to ship them back. We'll see how the smaller size does, and in the meantime I'll wear my tired old buttonflys.

Received the replacement pretty quickly, and while the size 4 fits better, I think I could almost wear a size 2.  This has to be the result of the screwy sizing system that has come into vogue, where what used to be an 10 is now called a 6, and 6 is called 2, etc. so that young girls can wear 0's and feel super skinny. It makes it difficult for the rest of us to figure out what size we are. I am small, but in the old days I would not have worn a 2. There were no twos. I guess I'll keep these because they sort of fit, and might shrink a bit when I wash and dry.

The one other thing worth mentioning is that the sticker on the leg that indicates size left a strip of adhesive that for some reason has slightly discolored the material. Not terrifically obvious, but definitely there. I don't think it will wash out because the glue  has made the patch lighter. Kind of odd, but not a deal breaker. The jeans are comfortable, and quite nice looking, even though they are still a bit too baggy. A fair value for the price, but I'm glad I didn't pay more.