I noticed the bad review and am wondering, as the person that left a comment on that review stated, if she had a defective pair.  It could also be that Saucony is not a good brand for her feet.

Saucony has proved to be a great shoe for me.  I have a normal arch and a little bit of a wider foot.  I've had about 7 or 8 pairs and all have been great.  I'm a personal trainer and avid athlete and live in athletic shoes.

I love this shoe.  I purchased it for about $40 at a local retailer in my city and didn't have high expectations.  I'm now trying to get a second pair.  I love the look, I have the charcoal gray/black/blue style, as I don't like white on my shoes because it stains easily.  They are great in rough trail hikes and for tough indoor workouts, since it's a lightweight trail shoe and not heavy duty trail, but does give more rigid support outdoors than a typical running shoe.  This is one of the more perfect pairs of shoes I've ever had.