My husband bought me these earrings for our anniversary.
Pros: From the picture, I thought they would be a little old-fashioned, but they are very stylish and go with everything, from dressy to casual.  They look elegant but not flashy.  The size is perfect; I wouldn't recommend ordering the smaller size.
Cons: There is a little ding on the side of one of the stones (not that I expect anyone to get close enough to my ear to notice!), and I wish the earrings had come with some sort of certificate of authenticity or diamond rating card.