I normally wear a 9 and ordered an 8.5 based on reviews. The boots came and were gorgeous but to my shock, seemed a bit big. They were okay with thick socks but not wanting to settle for okay, even at this great price for Frye boots, I decided to order an 8 and see which fit better. The 8 just came and it fits perfectly, so the 8.5 is going back. I am giving the boots 4 instead of 5 stars b/c the sizing seems a little crazy.

If you order these boots definitely order at least a half size down, and consider going a full size. I do wear the equivalent of an 8 in wide shoes, like Birkenstocks, if that is helpful...