I am rating these sandals as 5 stars because they are exactly the look, heel height, comfort etc. that I wanted - and that is very hard to find. However, you really do need to go to a wide width even if you usually always wear a medium width, like I do. This is my first pair of wide shoes EVER, and I am glad I listened to the other reviewers, because I'm sure I would not have fit into the medium width. Other than that these sandals are perfect though!!!