Be forewarned that Stuhrling offers an extra year of warranty to those who post positive reviews. Read these all with a grain of salt.

However, the rating here is sincere. I do love the watch. This is my second Sturhling; my first being a Ladies Wall Street. That one had a problem with the band (which I replaced). But I'm still fond of that watch and I do like the brand.

I did specifically want a rose gold watch and something smaller than the Wall Street, which is really quite large. The Gatsby is still very large, but a more palatable size for me. (Though I am a geek and love love love the self-winding of the Wall Street.) I'll post a pic of the two so that you can see the size comparison -- something I wondered about when buying this one.

I have a large wrist, maybe 7.25", and this fits, on the last hole.

Four stars because I do not like the clasp. I did need to read the instructions, but once you get it, you're set; it's not continually confusing. There are two things that don't work for me about the band. One is that the last hole is very close to the end of the band, which means that the keeper needs to be overlapping with the clasp mechanism to do its thing. This makes the watch harder to get on and off than it would be for those with smaller wrists because I have to futz with the keeper. (Or, okay, I could ditch the keeper maybe.) The second thing is that the clasp is a thick wad of metal on your wrist, 1/4 inch thick when you're wearing it. I'm sure I don't hold my wrists correctly when typing (I rest them on the surface in front of the keyboard), but I find it uncomfortable... it's maybe twice as thick as other watches I own.

Still, I am very pleased. (No, really.)