Let me start by saying quite simply, I love this pair of earrings.
The price is excellent, even at the list price of $20, these are an excellent value. (Though, I lucked out getting them as a gold box deal, quite a bargain!)
The sterling silver setting is very well done, substantial and well crafted, polished to a high shine.
And the stones, this is where I was blown away. All six were perfectly matched, and a deep garnet 'red'. I am very familiar with garnets and own a lot of them in varying price ranges, these are beautiful, especially for their price point. I expected some variances in shades, orange/pink/ruddy brown, but was so happy with them being just as clear as the online picture.
The size is dainty, which is what I wanted, but they are still very noticeable in part because they have a good amount of movement, making them really catch the light.
I would give these as a gift, but I'm so much happier keeping them to wear myself!