I am 6'2", 220 pounds, athletic, chest size 48, 36/38 waist. This is usually in the mid to high end of the XL range. This coat was a tight fit on my shoulders (although perfect on waist and chest) and had to be returned for an XXL. Other folks have had tailoring issues as well. So there may be some inconsistency. The coat itself was very well made, a mid-weight wool, with very nice inside seams. I look forward to receiving my XXL. At $69.99 it seems like a great deal. I just wish they had Navy, or Black available, besides Charcoal.

Note: I just got the XXL and I am not impressed by the cut and fit. Most peacoats are tailored to the athletic/military physique, wide shoulders, athletic but not bulky chest, trim waist. This line of jackets is tailored to those who have shoulders, chest, waist; that are basically the same measurement. So while this coat fits my shoulders, it is huge on the chest and waist. It doesn't have that classic, military cut to it. Also, the charcoal color just doesn't have the 'snap' that the classic dark navy, or even black, has. I may keep it as a knock around coat, or return it. It is only worth the $69 I paid, but not a penny more.