I'd like to start this review by addressing Simple's 'Vegan' philosophy. For those not aware, Simple manufactures all of their shoes in a non-animal byproduct super environmentally friendly way. This shoe actually features a bottom made from a recycled tire. I have to say that initially this philosophy had absolutely no impact on my buying decision whatsoever. I typically discount this kind of marketing as BS; just companies hopping on the green bandwagon because that is what is in right now.

The difference with Simple is...well, simple: they make a QUALITY product. Their shoes are well made and while I may reflexively dismiss environmentalism in a company I respect quality products. I also respect products made in the country by small companies. So the vegan philosophy didn't win me just because it's vegan. It won me because the result is a good shoe, made in the country by a small, locally owned company. Grand slam. Simple won a devoted customer in me.

On to the shoe itself. I purchased these after returning a similar pair of Sanuks to Amazon. I returned my Sanuks first because they were hideously ugly (the picture did not do them justice) and because the sole was a sort of cheap rubber flip-flop thing which was very uncomfortable. The Gumshoe has, as its name implies, a sort of soft gummy sole which is much more comfortable on my feet. The recycled tire bottom seemed kind of odd at first, but it functions exceptionally well and despite its light weight feels as though it will withstand long a series of hard days. All of that, and it's a pretty stylish shoe.

The Only reason I am not giving it a full five stars is because of the fit. I ordered a full size up (13 from my regular 12) on other reviewers' advice and it is just a LITTLE too big. Comfortable but a shade too large for me to feel truly secure wearing them. Unfortunately, there is no 12.5 available (though this is common to shoe manufactures. Lucky me.) and I am certain a 12 would be too small. So if you can get a half size bigger then do so. If not, I am personally well enough satisfied with my 13s to keep and wear them anyhow so consider a full size.