I bought the ring and the earrings that match.  The stones in both are beautiful, they catch the sunlight and sparkle very nicely for a garnet.  The only reason I didn't give the ring 5 stars is becuase the silver is really, really, shiny. I am sure I will bang it up and give a patina in no time though.  I agree with the other review that commented that the stones are probably lab created, but honestly, no will be able to the difference.