I wear a 6.5 wide. That is what I ordered.  First of all do I agree that the shoes look not too bad, although the front is quite wide looking but maybe thats because its a wide size.  There are a few problems I noticed so far,  1. The front edge of the upper rubs against the bed of my toenail making a sore spot. This is because the front part of the arch strap is quite tight and holds my foot back too far. The shoe itself is not too small, as I can see there is still lots of toe-room left on the front of the shoe.  2. the lining of the upper is man-made smooth material, which makes my feet slide back easily.  . Due to (1) and (2)  my feet are still too far back and walking in them feels awkward .  3. The footbed is harder than i had hoped and it is  not very molded, it is more flat, and it is also not supportive in the arch.  The sole is stiff and hard enough to make me sound like a horse clip clopping around.  I really hope these sandals soften up and feel better after a few more days of breaking in.