I bought the forest green in my size (10) and they fit really well. I have plantar fasciitis as well but these shoes gave me no fatigue, even without my insoles. I wore them all day in the city and felt no achy feeling afterward. I absolutely love them... Crocs are actually coming out with stylish shoes! I'm so happy! I'm actually really surprised many people reviewed it so low... the comfort level is amazing! I have not had any problems with the velvet scuffing.