I received these for Christmas in the Black Kid Suede. The material is so smooth and beautiful and they look great on, but the small toebox was very uncomfortable. I would definitely order at least a half size up (this one is narrow in the toe). Unfortunately, I'll have to return mine because of the sizing issue.

Update 1/4/11: I returned the ones I received for Christmas and ordered a half size up. They fit perfectly now! I'm still only giving 4 stars because of that narrow toe box, and because I haven't taken these babies for a spin yet so I don't know how they'll do long term.