I ordered these over Uggs because they look more like a real boot, rather than slipper/moon boot. These boots are more constructed, and not as bulky as Uggs.  They are super warm, stylish and the classic Dr. Martens sole, makes them pretty cool too.  The suede is of good quality, and I don't mind that the fleece isn't wool.  It's warm and my feet are dry when I take them off.  Just wish they had a little more arch and ankle support, but they are what they are.  I bought them for wearing around town, but plan on treating them before wearing in rainy conditions.  The shaft is wide enough to easily tuck regular pants into, but not too wide.  I found them to be very true to size.  Overall, I am really pleased with these.  They look great in black, and the price was right ($82 through amazon, $130+ everywhere else).