I usually wear 7.5-8 so after reading the reviews I got an 8M and they fit fine, although with thicker socks they are pretty snug.

At first the shoe part seemed very stiff and they have very high arch supports but I am wearing them today and have been walking around and they are very comfy and look beautiful! I have high arches though so they might not work for some people. I also have skinny calves and these are a good cut for me with jeans tucked in or with stockings.

Minus one star for two reasons: one is that they scratch extremely easily (I got the medium brown) but I treated them with waterproofing stuff and the scratches rubbed out.

The other thing has nothing to do with the boots but I was sent a pair that had clearly been returned and not repackaged properly. The boots were unzipped and unwrapped and the cardboard inserts were loose in the box. However I examined them very carefully and they were spotless and still brand new so I am happy with them.