I read the reviews on this boot, and it sounded like the perfect boot for me...and it was, eventually!  Firstly, the reviews that said this boot runs small to size are NOT correct.  I wear an 8.5 and ordered a size 9, based on posted reviews.  However, the size 9 was entirely too big!  I returned item and ordered the size 8.  It fit perfectly.  Also, yes, the calves do run small in this boot, which is just right for my thin legs.  However, the toe area of the boot is plenty wide (actually wider than I would prefer), but it is okay because it allows plenty of room for my wide feet in toe area!  Overall gave this product 4 stars, but only because the toes are wider than I like (otherwise would have given 5 stars).  Also, I should mention the lining in this boot - it makes the boot very comfortable and wearable for everyday...something other brands/styles are lacking!  Great looking boot!

FOLLOW-UP: I've had these boots for a while, but have only worn them a handful of times.  Problem: if you have wide feet,they are perfect...but if you have high arches, they are PAINFUL and NUMBING.  The boots go on easily enough and fit nicely, but if you wear them for more than an hour or so, the top of the boot applies too much pressure on the foot, causing discomfort (not pain); after an hour or so, my feet become numb due to lack of blood circulation - the pressure caused by the boots literally cuts the blood supply to foot off!  To the boot's defense, I do have a high arch, and thin ankles, so this boot will probably work well for most.  I tried the size larger, but the boots were so large they slipped up/down while walking.  I am sad that I cannot wear these boots for outings (because they look and fit NICELY), but oh well.  It's too late to return them, so I am simply stuck with them.  I am shopping for a replacement, basic pair now...