I LOVE this boot!  For years I've been wearing Uggs and the last couple of winters have not been too kind to my boots.  I decided on trying these because they are cute and waterproof.  I read many reviews on many websites and ordered a wide and medium because many said it ran narrow.  My feet are between a medium and wide width and I tried both.  At first, I felt the medium was fine. But when I walked around the sole is rounded and I felt like I was rolling to the side.  And when I tried to pull them off I was literally on my back tugging because I have tightened the laces and the space that was left couldn't free my wider than normal foot.  I was laughing and tugging for quite a bit.  The wide width worked better for me.  The sole was more stable and even after I tightened the laces I could get my fat foot out.  The nice thing about them is that I have small ankles and calves and I was able to tighten the laces so the boots looked nice and snug with my jeggings on.  The height was perfect for me even though I'm a whopping 5' 2". They are a great buy!