I was a little nervous about ordering these boots in red after seeing the previous review about the red being awful. Fortunately for me, the boots I received look exactly like the picture, deep shiny red with dark fur trim. The boots are rated to -20F and have a really good tread, so they are functional as well as attractive. They fit me true to size, and I feel like I could wear thick socks with them, but don't think I would ever need to. I am extremely happy with this purchase.