Just received these boots in the mail! They are very well made and look pretty sturdy. After reading every review I could find I decided to order an 11, I am normally a 9 to 9.5. They fit practically perfect. Great with thick socks, and just a slight looseness with thin socks. The liner is thin but nice feeling while wearing and makes them easy to get on and off. Many people stated there is not room to tuck jeans in, I had no problem getting my boot cut jeans inside, plenty of room. They also look nice under the jeans too. These boots have a very practical utility look to them. Not really a "dress up" kind of look, but would be great for daily errands and they appear sturdy enough to accompany my feet to the stable while I teach horseback riding lessons. My main advice is don't be afraid of the size! I was so worried to order an 11 for fear they would be huge.....but hooray they are perfect.