okay so i'm giving this boot a 5 star because IF you get the right size it should be a great boot.  i am normally a 7.5-8, so i got the 8B(m) to be safe.  with just normal thickness socks i couldn't even get it on!!  first off it is SUPER narrow, so if you have an even remotely wide foot, defineitly get the C/D width.  also because of all the furry fleece inside go up a half size especially if you want to wear thick socks.  had to send these back and decided to go with the granby tall boot in a 8.5 C/D and it is a perfect fit.  the boot is killer overall being waterproof, cozy, and super durable.  just be aware of the small/narrow sizing and go up a bit.  i have never ordered a 8.5 in my life, so trust me when i say this boot runs small.