We bought these for our 11 year old niece for Christmas, and she really likes them. They are appropriate for her age and very pretty on her. However, the stone is so clear that she thought they were pink in the light rather than blue. The blue is not nearly as striking in person as it is in the photo. Had the main selling point of the earrings been the blue topaz, I would have been extremely disappointed. Also, the quality of the earrings leaves a bit to be desired; I would not recommend them for someone over the preteen/early teen years.