If I were to rate this shoe on quality alone it would surely get 5-stars. I bought the brown one for a friend and he loves it dearly. However, he was rather disappointed because it did not fit perfectly. It is short and not true to size. A 1/2 size up would have done the job. Unfortunately, I could not return them because I live in Jamaica and by time I got them from my friend in USA who had received them for me, the return date was long passed. I had to give same to a relative of mine. Wanted to purchase another with a bigger size but the brown was not avaiable for anything near the price I had paid for them.