First, I already own two great pair of boots, Bean style ankle height and a pair 10" high..both have served me well..my reason for buying these boots is that we recently had 24" snow..I decided I should have a very tall pair for certain weather conditions, plus these would be great in a flood  ( I hope we don't get a flood)...I liked the price..they are water proof . I read the reviews and the one negative review actually helped me out because I learned the sizes run big, and I was able to visualize what size to order. The boots are close to a perfect fit, with room for heavy socks. Toes are steel. The boots seem well made and the price was just right. I'm pleased.