The boots look great and so far they feel great. I tried them on Dec. 7 and they kept my feet warm from the cold weather. At the present moment I cannot comment on how they are in the rain or snow; however, I will update my review when I encounter that weather.

The only slight criticism I have is that the fifth eyelid is made out of material and looks like it can break of the laces are pulled to tight after a period of time

In any case I will update my review as I use them when it snows.

Update
December 28, 2010
 OK I had a chance to try them out after the snow storm passed through NJ and they kept my feet nice and warm.

January 28, 2011

OK with the recent two major snow storms that hit Northern New Jersey, I finally had a real chance to test out these boots. They did keep my feet warm when I had to walk in ankle deep snow.