I bought these boots because they are just so cute I couldn't resist them.  They have pretty good reviews too, and Sorel is a great brand, so I really thought I was making a great selection.  WRONG.  I live in New York City, and these boots are so not good for here.  They are great on the snow, and keep my feet wonderfully warm and dry.  But I slip on ice constantly, and I slide around in the subway tunnels - wet shoes + dirty ground = not fun.  I am shocked at how poor the traction is.

Reviews I read prior to purchase said to order a half size up, so I did, and they are too big.  I have to wear 2 pairs of socks any time I wear these boots or I can hardly walk.  Many people complained about the ankle being too tight - and those people are nuts!  The adjustable straps loosen as I walk, so I've started saftey pinning them.  It's just ridiculous.  I am SO DISAPPOINTED in these boots.  They're so cute, but it's NOT WORTH IT. 2 stars for warmth & waterproof.