These are great boots!  We've been getting snow every couple of days, so I've worn these almost everyday since I got them.  They're durable, warm and comfortable.  They're waterproof and I got some leather conditioner to help keep them that way.  I wear a size 12 in pants and my thick calves often deter me from buying tall boots, but these have plenty of room for someone larger than me without being so big that they look silly.  They're cute enough for me and I love the rubber tips so I don't scuff them.  Sometimes my feet overheat in them, but I think I figured out which socks are causing that so I'll just not wear them with those socks anymore.  I can walk all day in them and they work under pants, skirts or over skinny jeans (not that I wear skinny jeans, but I can tell they have enough room).  I'm glad I bought these and I hope they last me a long time.