I have been searching for lace up boots for a while now.  I received these boots today and was so excited to try them on.  What a disappointment!!!  I ordered my usual size (7 1/2) and was shocked at how big they were.  They were easily bigger than an 8 1/2 or 9.  The tops of the boots were huge as well.  I have an average size calf and these boots gaped open a good 2 - 3 inches around my calves.  Plus they had scuffs on the bottom and toes like they had been previously worn and returned.  The soles were also poorly attached - there were gaps around the bottoms with visible glue showing at several spots.  I am usually very pleased with the quality of products I purchase from Amazon but this was a huge let down.  Now I am back to searching for the perfect lace up boots .....