I love these boots! I purchased the chestnut color, which is gorgeous. The boots are cute and comfortable all day, and even fit my larger calves with jeans tucked in. They are a bit spacious, so you may want to go a size down. If you are wearing these with no socks or thin ones, I would definitely recommend a size down, but you may want the extra space of your regular size when wearing thick socks for freezing weather. I was happy to keep mine in my real size, which is perfect with thick snowboard socks, but a bit loose and clunky sock-free.

One star off because one of the cords that holds the toggle came loose from the boot and I can't figure out how to get it back on! I've now just tucked it under the other cord and am hoping that that one doesn't come loose too. Also, when you first get the boots, the shearling lining is very fluffy and shedding and gets all over everything (the boots also fit a bit snugger at first). After a few wears, the lining compacts, giving you more foot space, and also keeping the shearling from getting all over pants that you've tucked in, socks, or your feet.

Overall, other than the lost cord, I love everything about these boots and I will be buying another pair for this winter!