I got these boots in the chestnut color when they were one of amazon's goldbox deals - what a great buy! I love these boots! I wear size 9 normally and ordered a size 9 - no problems here. Any smaller/bigger and I don't think they would have fit. I read the other reviews ahead of time so I knew about the ties/boot opening all the way down (even though you can't completely tell this from the picture) and I honestly was a little nervous about it and almost didn't order because of it - I'm VERY glad I did, though! They really are NOT that hard to tie and keep shut tight, and the bows/tie always look cute. The tying just takes you an extra 30 seconds to put on when you're getting ready. If you live in an area with heavy snow/freezing temps, I could see how some may have some complaints (because of the side opening and cold air getting in maybe?), but they work well for me and keep my feet plenty warm and comfy. Overall, I'm extremely happy with my purchase and would definitely recommend.