These boots are the best I've ever found. I have owned a pair of Bogs now for 2 years and they are as comfortable and warm as the day I bought them. I had actually begun taking their great value for granted until my brother visited from Chicago and tried them on walking our dog on a frigid night in the snow. He couldn't stop remarking about how comfortable they are and how warm they kept his feet despite the weather and deep snow. I'm buying him a pair for Christmas. I know he'll think of them as his best gift under the tree. You can't go wrong with these boots. I even put them on barefoot when taking the dog out and the lining really does keep my feet warm and prevents odor. Like I've said, I've owned a pair for 2 years now and they're as comfortable and odor free as when I bought them.