I looked a long time for an un-girly pair of boots and was definitely smitten when I saw these.  After searching and finding a price I could swallow, I bought them in the Gaucho color. I LUV THEM! I have a regular width foot that is a straight size 9 (with the exception of some designer slingbacks - in those I sometimes need to get a 9-1/2 to prevent the dreaded 'heel hangover').  After reading other reviews, I decided to buy a 9 and an 8-1/2.  When I got them, the 9 was too big, even on my slightly bigger right foot, but the 8-1/2 was perfect. The first time I wore them, I did experience the difficulty other reviewers described in getting my foot in/out of the boot, as well as the inflexibility of the shaft and sole.  I've owned Frye boots before and never had ANY issues with blisters or soreness with new boots, so I took a chance.  I walk to work and though I initially felt a little Frankenstein-ish while walking, that cleared up very quickly.  I worked all day, walked home, and had no blisters or other residual soreness due to the boots' stiffness.  The second time I wore them, it was noticeably easier (but still a bit of a struggle) to get in/out of the boots and the soles/heel/shaft felt more molded to my foot. I've now worn the boots about 6 times and they are easy to get on and off but don't feel floppy or loose, and the sole has loosened and bends.  These are substantial boots, which I like (the sole is more 'there' and overall they may feel a little heavier, depending on what you're used to wearing on your feet).  These more masculine design features add to the ruggedness I wanted in my un-girly boots, so mission accomplished!  When I've worn them out in the cold and wet, my feet stay dry and they look great.  Lots of compliments!  I can't wait to try them out with dresses and shorts in the other seasons.  I wanted to deduct only 1/2-star for the initial breaking-in time, but half stars are not allowed.  This is a great, versatile boot with many styling options.  I just bought the same style in black, too!