I received these boots for Christmas, and I've really enjoyed them. The most amazing part is how warm they keep my (usually very cold) feet. I live in central Maine so I'm no stranger to snow and very cold temps, and I was so impressed with how warm my feet stayed with just one pair of wool socks on. Love that they are waterproof (well, haven't sloshed in any puddles yet, but I'm pretty confident) and that I don't have to fuss with any laces when trying to get out the door with 3 kids. I agree that these run a bit small - I usually wear an 8.5 and the 9 is perfect for me, and almost too snug with a really thick pair of socks, but midweight wools are fine. I'm now looking at the men's boots for my husband, as he's been searching for a pair of waterproof winter boots that are actually waterproof - as nothing seems to be, even though it is stated on the product. I think these might be the way to go!