First off, I would like to say that the sizing on these boots is at least two sizes off. I ordered three of these because my brother, my dad and I were going canoeing and we all ordered one size less than what we normally get. REgardless, the the boots were still waaay to big for all of us.
As far as quality goes, they are really mediocre, but I guess you get what you pay for. After a week of canoeing and portaging somewhat frequently, the boots were about ready to fall apart. Both my brother and my dad threw theirs away because theirs were just unusable when we were done.
I give it three stars because they are so cheap and they did do what we wanted them to do (last for exactly one week).