Starting with the positives - these boots are SO cute.  They are the perfect boot shape - slender in the ankles/calf, and the rounded toe is super flattering.  I got the brown color, and it is a gorgeous, rich, warm brown color.  The slouch adds some interest without looking sloppy.

However, the chemical smell of these boots is outrageous.  I debated sending them back for that reason alone, but I'm holding out hope that it fades after a while.  I'm not usually sensitive to smells, but these boots have a really, really strong odor.  I also had hoped the leather would be a little more substantial, for this price.  It's ok, but I have less expensive leather boots that feel much softer to the touch.  I also worry a bit about the sole - it is a little thin.

Even with those complaints, I decided to keep the boot.  It is just so comfortable, and soooo flattering.  I had been searching a long time for a flat boot, and these were exactly what I was envisioning.