These are my first pair of Aussie boots and I have to say that I am really pleased with them.  The color is beautiful and the quality is fantastic!  I love that they have a rubber sole, water resistant and have some arch and foot support ... I know that the competitor has none of these features.  I also like that these are actually made by an Aussie company using Aussie sheep.  They are really comfortable too.  I have a 6.5 size foot and ordered the size 7, the length is great and I put an insole in under the foot bed lining for a little extra support.  They look great both high and with the tops rolled down to show off the lining.  The only reason why I did not give them 5 stars is because the ankle does seem to be a little bit loose and there is no way to tighten the toggles (I guess I could tie them in knots).  This is just a minor issue to me and does not cause me to love the boots anyless.