I was a little nervous about how this boot will actually look, but i LOVE them. I got them the very next day with 2 -day shipping, and I couldn't be happier. They are EXTREMELY comfortable, and very well-made. I think I am going to have these boots for a long, long, long time. The shaft is a little loose, so if you have skinny calves, be wary. They come right at my knee, and I am barely 5'5", so very tall people, also be advised. However, I LOVE them. I got them in both the black and the tan so they can always go with what I'm wearing. Definitely boots to wear over jeans...not so sure these will look that good with a mini skirt/ dress. Like I mentioned, the shaft is not fitted at all.