I wear an 11W & have moderately flat feet. These shoes offer virtually no arch support & I can feel it within an hour of putting them on. At first they are comfortable, and I will say there is no toe pinching, heel cutting or any of that going on. My feet begin to feel fatigued too quickly, though, and that's just walking on carpet, not even doing any physical activity like vacuuming or something like that. Flats aren't the best for flat feet, I know, but my knees can no longer take high heels. Even low heels can throw my knees & back out of whack if they're not well-built, so I thought I'd try these as an occasional alternative, when I need dressier shoes than my normal Saucony or New Balance running shoes (which is best for daily wear in terms of keeping my feet, knees & back happy over the long haul) in the fall & winter. (SoftSpots Tela sandals are my spring/summer pick for comfortable yet inexpensive sandals that I can wear all day & night.) For women w/ normal or high arches, these might be perfectly fine.

I bought these in black & they look nice enough- a simple pair of shoes that can be dressed up or down, they look nice w/ hosiery. If one is simply looking for an inexpensive pair of flats that'll only be used occasionally & won't be used for a lot of walking or other physical activity, they're okay. If one is wearing these daily, I would question that, because these are not shoes built to really support the feet over a long-term basis. Ultimately, I have learned that I typically get what I pay for, and I will try on a more expensive, but better-built, fal/winter dress shoe next time.