I love-love-love this boot. Before wearing it, I sprayed it with a water and stain repellent to further protect the leather. It does scratch up, but it will give the shoe a cool aged look over the years. My favorite part about this boot is that I feel like I'm walking on air. The same feel you get from the sole of a pair of Teva sandals, very light but very stable. I did not have the calf problem some of the women had. I love the zipper and strap detailing, as well. I wanted a "traveler" style--a hipper look but with the functionality of traipsing all over town! They've also got just the right level of insulation for a chilly, rainy day. I will wear these boots for years to come.

Update: This is still my favorite boot! I've hiked in these things. I was not as diligent in waterproofing, so there is a little bit of wear to it, but I think it adds character. The foot bed is still super comfortable. I will probably buy these, again in a few years if they are still making them. I hope they do continue to make them.