They are much better than the over-rated Uggs.  Waterproof and cute!  I am a dog walker, so I walk in all kinds of weather and these boots are super comfortable, warm and so far, my feet have stayed dry.  I have not worn them yet in snow or icy conditions, but I have worn them in rainy, wet weather and my feet stayed warm and dry.  Half the price of uggs, much better looking, and most importantly for me, weather resistant!  My uggs got soaked immediately when I'd walk in any wet conditions---even a little morning dew---it was like wearing a pair of socks outside.  These are awesome!  Highly recommend to anyone who walks a lot.