These boots were too good to be true.  The price was great, especially the lightning deal, but in my opinion that its the only thing good about them.  The sole was a very thick piece of cardboard, no arch support or give in them at all.  The sizing was quite off, I usually wear a 6.5 or a 7 and I bought a 5.5 and a 6 and they were both enormous on my feet.  The lining seemed to be ok and the outer leather was nice BUT...the sole is what was a deal killer for me.  Sent them back and would definitely not recommend them.