The reason I rated the shoe a 4 - it was about a 1/2 size small for me which meant returning and getting the next size up - a hassle for me.

As far as the shoe itself, it is sturdy and well made.  I have been using them for a month now - not much for road miles because of the snow in northern WI, but lots of gym work.  I like the arch support for my very high arches and also the off-set lacing system that does not cut across the top of my feet.

I would buy them again.