Firstly, the shoe looks great. Found the right size for the AE#5 last: 10.5, EEE. Wore them twice, and found them quite comfortable. One morning, putting them on to go to work, I noticed a strange "line" on the side of the heel. Upon closer inspection, the "line" was a fracture going all around the heel. The other shoe was even worse! So, after 2 wears, the heels are falling off of an expensive pair of shoes. Amazon doesn't say if the Allen Edmonds they sell are seconds or not, but given the obvious lack of construction standards, I believe they are indeed seconds, or "defects". I don't know if I should return them, contact Allen Edmonds, or bring them to a local cobbler. Any way I go, very disappointing.