I'm very pleased with these.  I was a bit nervous that they'd be too small after reading the other reviews, but I thought the fit was on target.  I normally wear a 9.5 or 10 and I ordered a 10.  The fit is to the bigger side on me.  They slipped on without a problem, there is a narrowing at the ankle but I didn't have any problems getting them on.  They are very stiff, but they seem like they'll be nice and warm in wet, slushy weather.