Bought the McTavish black with brown stitching. I get compliments about them all the time. They are beautiful shoes. They are a bit clunky due to the thick sole but they don't feel like it. They're like a second skin. I intend to switch to all Allen Edmonds shoes over time because they are absolutely fantastic. Make sure you get the size and the "last" right and you'll love them. They do run large I went down to an 8D and I usually wear an 8.5 or 9. The 8's are almost too big. Great shoes and made in the USA, but expensive.