I read all the reviews and decided to take a chance on these boots and order the brown in my normal size of 9. First I like the color which in my opinion is not too far off the picture. I have slender feet and calves which makes these boots a perfect fit. The toe area is narrow, however that works for me along with the 14.75 circumference. The leather is on the rugged side which I had expected from the description of the boot. The lining is very comfortable along with the soles. Wow, this boot is so comfortable to walk in. Wish I needed black boots as I would buy a second pair...I never do that. Great buy for the price. Buy them!