I just got mine today and I am so so so happy with them, they're sooooo pretty and they make my legs look HOT! Honestly, the picture on amazon does not do these shoes justice. They are a true shiny patten leather and like others have said, the color is lighter in person (I'm light skinned and the Pietra color blends perfectly). I also noticed that other reviews said they run small so I went a half size up, I *might* have been able to squeeze into a 5, but I'm glad I didn't risk it and got a 5.5, the little bit of room I do have will be perfect for some cushioned insoles.

The only reason I give these a 4 instead of a 5 is that they could be a little bit more comfortable (maybe some cushion in the ball) and some of the stitching is a tad uneven, but I'm overall VERY happy with these, especially for the price!