This boot is made really well, is comfortable right out of the box, and fits my small-ish calf perfectly. No doubt this boot would last for more than one winter. The leather has a matte finish and the sole is quite sturdy, which makes the boot look rather rugged. This was a bit of a surprise, since I was expecting it to look dressier, and therefore it was too casual for me. But this is an excellent boot for walking, and would be warm with woolly socks in the winter. Runs true to size. Also, Amazon service is impeccable.