I am on my third Step 2 umbrella, as the last two have only lasted one season each.  We even live in CA, with limited rain or extreme weather, but this umbrella does not seem to last.  It's frustrating, because I am careful to fold it down when there is wind, and I have been conscientious with it.  The only reason I'm ordering another is that my kids need shade and it's the only umbrella that will fit the table.  I'm not sure I would have bought the Naturally Playful set if I would have known I was going to spend an extra $50 on umbrellas.