Was so excited to get these boots. They are definitely more burgundy than red, but beautiful.  Its true about the ankles fitting loose, but much better with a thick sock or insole.  Normally I am a 6.5-7. I ordered the 7, but should have gone with the 6.5. I also find that they show scratches and scuff easily, so I'm looking for a good shoe polish to cover them up. Love the though.