I ordered these in November for my two teenage daughters who were going on a school retreat for the weekend.  They had a lot of activities to do outside in the cold weather.  My daughters loved them.  They normally wear a size 8 or 8 1/2, but I ordered two size 9's (because there were no half sizes available at the time) and they were pretty good for each.  They said they were comfortable to walk in and they liked the way they looked.  Most importantly, they kept their feet warm outside!  My daughter commented that some of their friends complained of cold feet, but they did not have that issue.  We looked for hours, and these were the best looking boots for the price.  They have only worn them a dozen times or so, so I do not know how they will hold up.  They seem sturdy and still look new.