I have wanted a cute pair of knee high black boots for a few years.  I love Frye, but can't afford them, lol!  These came in at a great price, $84 or so.  I read reviews on Amazon and other shoe websites and bought 1/2 size down.  Glad I did.  They may be a bit long in the heel even doing this.  Keep in mind these are pull on boots, no zipper.  The calf fit is great, I have an athletic calf, nowhere near super skinny, and these fit tight to my calf.  If your calf is larger, these will be much too tight.  Amazon has the best price, by far!