This is my third Shemagh and now I can compare it with the regular Rothco and also one from Army Universe.
This one is Foliage Green - which is  more a gray with a tint of green,  a very nice, camouflage color.
It actually smelled nice but I washed it anyway, like all new clothes.
I was surprised that the water stayed clean unlike the other two Shemaghs which I had to wash twice and rinse a few times.
There were a few loose threats and minor mistakes in the pattern.
It is supposed to be lightweight but I hardly noticed a difference.
It is soft, like the other Shemagh from Rothco  and
it is the largest of the three with 43" x 43"

So, I have learned that there is very little difference in the quality of the Shemaghs from India or Pakistan.
In the future I will select a Shemagh by price and color.

Added after purchasing two more and experience with washing.
I liked the lightweight Shemagh better and purchased 2 more. If I need a scarf to keep me warm, there are wool or acrylic scarves. I used the Shemagh in warm weather where I can also dip it in water to keep me cool.
After I washed the Shemaghs and put them in the dryer, they shrunk to 27" x 37"
But that is no problem. They don't actually shrink, they just crinkle up.
All you need to do is iron with a steam iron - or use a spray bottle to get them lightly wet and then iron. They will be back to full size in a minute.
Also - I bought the black and white Shemaghs because I wanted to dye them in a color of my choice. I used Rit Dye which is always an experience for me because the end result will always surprise me. I used  Denim Blue. The first scarf turned very dark, almost purple. I rinsed it and put the second scarf in rinse-water and it is now a denim blue color.