You would have to be a very picky shoe buyer to give this product a low review rating. I just got my boots and I was in anticipation of either a good or pad product. Well, I can tell you I am glad I made this purchase. I had bought a similar pair of boots at DSW for 99+tax, I am taking them back and ordering another pair of these. A lot are wondering about the smell... If you are going to sleep with your boots on or sleep with them next to your pillow, do not buy them. The price and quality of the product is greater the advantage to that of a temporary smell. I have had other boots with similar problem and yes the smell will always be present minimally but will be there. Again, you will feel it if you put them next to your pillow at night. I am very satisfied as you can read. Good luck to all.