So, how can so many reviews be wrong?  Well, they're likely not.  As usual, it simply depends on your perspective.  If you're used to shopping at Walmart and Old Navy for your clothes, you may very well give this belt a 5 Star rating.  If you're used to nicer things, you're likely to give it a lower rating.

Most belts are made of two components:

1. The belt itself - in this case made of canvass and I would say the quality of the canvass is 4 Stars.  It lays nicely and is of fairly decent quality.  Time will tell how it wears.

2. The buckle and belt nose piece - 1 Star at best.  It's cheap and mine would not secure itself to the belt without modification of the hardware that included glue.

Obviously, my issue is with the hardware.  Although it has only happened once, I'm always wondering when the buckle will separate from the belt.  I personally would not buy this belt again at any price.

Sorry, I can't recommend this one.