I had been looking for a boot that could stand up to the figid temps and snow of Northern WI. I couldn't afford to pay for a top-of-the-line boot, but still wanted the same features/quality: warm, good gripping sole, lightweight, rugged. If you're interested in a trendy slouch boot to wear around the city for the office, evening, or other such events, I don't think this would suit your needs.

This boot is a workhorse. It's warm enough to keep even the coldest feet warm in subzero temps and a foot of snow. The soles rugged grip will keep you from sliding and falling despite the terrain. The added protection along the sides helps to keep you above the salt and slush. Even w/ the high sides, I sprayed them twice w/ a suede protection which has really helped. When they get wet or dirty, let them dry and brush them  w/ a soft toothbrush.

 These boots will most likely keep their shape over time. I've worn them for over 3 months and have only noticed some breaking in around the ankle. Even though the ankle area is snug when you take them on on/off, I don't notice any tightness when I walk. I do use them inside since they're so light and comfortable, unless you tend to have sweaty feet. I don't recommend wearing w/out socks. I haven't noticed any problem w/ the piling coming apart or starting to bunch.

 The reviews regarding size are true. Buy them at least a half size bigger than your typical shoe. I wear 8-8 1/2. I bought a 9 and can only wear a light sock, which is enough for me. I couldn't imagine wearing a heavy sock w/ these boots.

Bearpaw makes good boots. Don't waste your $ on Emus or other pricey brands when you'll find these boots will give you the same quality for a quarter of the money.