I just got these boots this morning and I ordered them two days ago! I have been searching for a good sturdy beautiful brown boot and these are it! I got these boots in the nutmeg color. The nutmeg is not the color shown on here, it is a dark brown-grayish destroyed color, look on other sites for the real color of these boots. Anyways this boot has a slim fit, but with my slightly muscular calfs they still fit great, even with jeans. They are comfortable in both the shaft and the foot I am a 8.5 and I got and 8.5 and they fit perfectly with a little wiggle room. The height is also perfect, Im 5'8 and it stops right below my knee. Most of all I love the good quality of the Nutmeg oily leather and the subtle almond toe shape. I'm so glad I chose these boots, they are very good quality for the price I paid!