I ordered these boots on the Today's Deal at a great price, it didn't show any 1/2 sizes available, so I went with the larger size because of the reviews that said they were tight across the instep. I wear an 8.5 normally but prefer a size 9 in boots because heavier winter socks need extra space. I tried on these boots in a size 9 but there is no way the size 9 will work even if I wear 3 pairs of thick socks. They aren't trendy looking but if you want a comfortable, practical boot that looks great with jeans tucked in, these are it. They are soft, the sole looks like it would be great in ice or slippery surfaces and the insulation is soft and should keep feet warm in the cold weather. I am going to try to exchange for a size 8 and hope they work. Definitely order down if you decide to get these boots.