I really like this shoe, it provides great support, was very easy on my feet to get used to (huge issue because I am type 2 diabetic and because of that have to be very careful of my feet) and I was able to start wearing them all day right away. The sizing was a little tight but not overly so and have been able to adjust with how tight I make the laces. The water proofing (goretex) works great and no problems there. The reason it didn't get 5-stars is because the leather of the shoe itself is not conditioned to be waterproof so it will get wet and you have to dry it out. It doesn't hurt the shoe but you still have a case of wet leather. I would recommend conditioning the leather first thing and you will be good to go. Thanks