I should have paid attention the size comments the other reviewers made.  I am between a size 2 and a size 4, so I usually go for the 4 because I'd rather have my clothes a little loose than a tad tight.  In this case, however, loose was an understatement.  I could literally pull the skirt up and down without unzipping it.  A size smaller should be perfect.  Great skirt overall, so I'll give it four stars.