I am giving this item 4 stars because of a few minor issues I had with it.  First,the waist button is sort of difficult to button and unbutton. You have to play with it a little. I imagine with time the button hole should ease up a bit making the button easier to open and close.  Second, these shorts are made out of lot thinner material then the picture and description depicted.  Overall for the price it is a decent pair of everyday shorts.

Update 8/4/2012

I have changed my rating to two stars because the middle back belt loop fell off completely leaving a hole in the back along the belt line.  It was clearly poor workmanship.