This is my first pair of Pliner boots. The quality is outstanding, the color and texture of the leather is very rich! The style is a bit "daring" compared to my usual straight-laced look; but because these are so unique and beautiful, I decided to go for it! I did not have the same trouble as one of the other reviewers as far as stitching...so that may be an isolated issue.  Sizing is perfect. I wear an 8.5 and these fit true to size. As far as shaft diameter, I have a 14.25" calf and these fit well enough to tuck in a pair of skinny jeans as well as with an above-the-knee skirt. Gorgeous boot ladies!!