Let me start by saying that I do have slightly wide feet, so keep that in mind.  The quality of this boot appears to be excellent.  I have not yet worn them in torrential rains, so I can't speak to their performance in those conditions; however, they were great on a miserably drizzley day.  I usually wear a 9.5, so ordered the 10 after reading others' reviews.  The length is great, but they are a little tight across the bridge of my feet.  I also want to say that the comfort is great-they provide a little arch support, and are well cushioned.  So, all in all, a good buy, but only if you have non-wide feet!