I ordered the Joan of Arctic after trying on a friends Kate the Great boot, also by Sorel, which I loved! I have huge calf muscles, so was very excited to find a boot that fit!!! I like these boots, however the function of the snaps on the liner is kind of annoying. The snaps are always coming undone and do nothing to help keep the liner in the boot when removing the boot. That being said, it kept my feed dry and warm through the winter and I look forward to colder weather so I can wear them again!