These boots are great. I just got them today and took to them instantly. I read in reviews that others had trouble with the calf size for "muscular calves"...I did not have this problem, The sizing is perfect, well fitting. The leather is substantial and looks durable. The soles are very comfortable but would Perhaps benefit from an insert but NOT necessary. I ordered a Ten when I sometimes wear a 9.5. I have extra room for socks, but not Too much room. The elastic ties around the shaft aren't really functional, I tried tightening them and it didn't really do anything. I thought these boots maybe could scrunch down, but they can't. The leather is too stiff. The lining is flannel and cozy but not hot. I want these more for a winter footwear that can get wet, not so much for snowstorms--although I would use them for that too. These are low priced because they are last season colors I am guessing---the only color difference being the Gold logo! ha.