I bought these shoes for a specific purpose - navigating rough city streets in Italy.  For that purpose, these shoes were great!  Although the bottom of my foot was comfortable from the first time I wore them, I did have to break in the top.  After several long walks, the material had stretched out enough that it no longer pressed down uncomfortably on the top of my foot.  I adapted to the rocker motion quickly, and did find that my feet were not very tired at the end of a long day of walking.  The sturdy construction handled cobblestones and pavement with ease, and the Mary Jane design meant I could easily pack small things in the shoes to save space in my luggage.  With jeans or long pants, the style is not as much of a factor since all but the toe is hidden, and I have worn these for walks since returning from my trip because they are so comfortable.  However, with capris or a skirt (I wore them with both types of apparel in Italy), they look big and clunky - almost orthopedic.  I like the rich brown color, and they were much more comfortable than similar shoes I tried on, I just won't be wearing them as sandals this summer.  I wear them with extra low cotton "sock" liners (available at Kohl's in black and tan - approx $7 for 3), which do not show at all and reduce foot sweat and discomfort.  These shoes are highly recommended for form and function, but not for fashion.