I bought these for my 2 y.o. daughter for use with her Halloween costume. They fit nicely and look cute overall, but they have slightly thick look (almost like orthopedic shoes) that I don't love. They seem to be well made and the turned-up toe helps keep the patent upper from getting scuffed. My daughter likes them and doesn't complain of pinching or rubbing. They go with almost any outfit, so I would recommend them as an all-purpose dressy-but-comfortable girl shoe. Price is hard to beat.