The toe protection is only for the big toe.  The foot bed is thinner and lighter in material.  The tread is not as gripey as Venice or Newport.

However, the overall weight is lighter and the last is based on women's feet (narrower) thus makes it look more feminine and cuter.

I bought these knowing the above.  I don't use them for long/rock scrambling hikes, only if water crossing is unavoidable and for camp site footwear.  They will be good for beach combing, strolling farmer's market, light city street walking and so on.  Because they are smaller in profile and lighter, packability is better than Venice and Newport.

Before one blames the product, one should ask herself "did I indeed choose the right footware for the intented purpose?".  This model has a lot to offer as long as it is used under the right circumstances.

My shoe size is 6.5M but I bought Whisper in 7M.  They are not loose or big.  With the draw cord adjustment I can wear my aqua socks with them for my water crossing needs.