There are things about the Baffin slipper that I love and things that I am very disappointed in. In retrospect, I would not purchase these again.

The slippers were very comfortable on the beginning. I purchased an X-large and typically were men's size 9-10 shoes (9.5 being the sweet spot with most manufactures). The sizing worked out fine although the slipper felt a bit tight at the beginning, but the inside sole flattened pretty quickly and gave the slipper more room. Even after several months use, the sizing feel fine and I do not have issues with the slipper sliding off my foot. The construction and materials on the outside of the slipper are great and fairly durable. I would advise not to take them outside for even brief excursions. A minimal exposure to brick, stray rocks, or a concrete surface will scuff and tear into the external sole fabric quickly.

On the negative side, I was surprise with how  big the slippers were. I had intended to use these as travel slippers to help with cold floors that I often find in hotel rooms. The Baffin slippers, however, were far to large to pack into a carry-on sized rolling bag. They do not compress well and therefore take up too much space to justify for their intended use.

Second, I mentioned the inside insole flattened fairly quickly. This is not entirely accurate. They flattened unevenly. I have a slight supination in my step, which means I have a tendency to step each foot on the outside of the foot. It's very slight, but enough to cause the wear on these slippers to be uneven. The net effect to it creates further unbalance and makes the supination and unbalance worst. The flattening is permanent and did not resolve after washing the slipper.

I took away one star for unbalance and uneven wear of the inside insole and one star for the combination of the less durable outside sole and bulk of the slipper.