When I read the feedback saying that the shirt was too small, I almost didn't get this shirt. I went ahead and ordered an XL, and it fits PERFECTLY. I'm 6'5" and about 240, 42" chest in case anyone is trying to get a sense of scale.

Perhaps some people don't know what "fitted" means. It means the shirt is SUPPOSED TO BE trimmer than your average shirt. Unlike the standard XL shirt, which is made to fit people who are both big and tall, I don't feel like I'm drowning in this shirt.

I'm still a fan of classic style, and I just can't get into the gaudy MMA style shirts or the faux-retro/vintage shirts that the hipsters love. This shirt looks good on its own.

The material is soft, so it also sits nicely on your body. The shirt shows off form a little bit without making it look like a muscle shirt, or that you're trying too hard. I'll definitely be buying a couple more. Above all, it's really comfortable and soft.

UPDATE: I now own at least one of each color shirt. If anyone can be called an expert on these shirts, it's probably me. One word of caution: the royal blue dye seems to be the only one that isn't going to last. Despite equal washes, it's beginning to show some very premature wear. I love these shirts, but I would avoid royal.