I will say in advance, I am NOT someone who generally has cold feet.  I don't tend to care what boots I'm wearing, as most of them are fine for me.  Bottom line, I'm not that picky.  That said, I'm pleased with these.  I like the style and these were a good deal.  They were cheap and seem fairly warm.  They remind me a glorified version of something I might find on the rack at kmart or something.  The quality isn't going to blow you away, but they are not bad either.

concerns:

1. I hate removable liners.  The price was low enough that I went ahead anyway on these but I wish the liners had a clip, snap, or button to keep them in the boot.  They do not, so every time I try and take them off the liner comes right out first.

2. I have WIDE feet.  The reviewer who said they run small is correct.  But I want to clarify, in my experience they run small BUT not narrow.  There's a big difference for many of us with wide feet.  I tend to order 1 whole size larger to try and accomodate my width (and generally some larger socks).  I was VERY surprised when these were close to correct in length.  They certainly seem to run smaller in length then most brands.  As I said though, many times that also comes with narrow width.  On these it didn't.  They seem plenty wide and comfortable for me.