I ordered Montrail's Molokini in a size 9 (I wear a size 9/12-10 in most shoes). I did this based on the reviews and the length is perfect. The footbed material is soft and has a lot of give, but not TOO much give, so very comfortable. The piece between the toes is hardly noticeable, so again very comfortable. I'm deducting one star only because I was expecting a lot of arch support based on the previous reviews I'd read, and though there certainly is more than what most flat flip flops have, there wasn't as much as I expected. I loved the idea of baking in the oven for 3 minutes to heat the material for a more custom fit, but I really didn't notice a difference once I did that. This is a nice knock around sandal, and very comfortable...but for those who need a lot of firm arch support, they're really not made for that. I did find them to be really wide, so perhaps that's why I'm not feeling that arch support others have mentioned.