I would give this boot 5 stars if it weren't for the very thin sole at the ball of the foot.  For being a lower heeled boot, it's surprisingly uncomfortable in the front of the foot after walking a lot.  BUT, it's really easily fixed by putting a little padded insert in the front!

I love these boots because they can be dressed up or down depending on the rest of your outfit.  At first I thought they were too big on me and probably could have gone with a 6.5, but it's actually nice to have the extra room when you're walking around a lot like I do (I've worn them around NYC several times).  They fit really nicely on the legs and are the perfect height (I'm 5'2", 125, size 7, substantial calves- runner).

I love these boots!  They were the perfect lower-heel option without looking ridiculous on someone short like me.