I purchased both the black and brown b/c the prices were right. I ended up keeping the black only b/c I thought the contrast of black and wood was more noticeable. These boots are very stylish, and I have received compliments. Another reviewer was right in that there is no real padding, but I am a person that adds footpetals to nearly all of my shoes simply b/c whatever shoe I wear, I HAVE to be able to walk in for at least 10 hours. So that's not a dealbreaker for me. The brown was OK, but kind of blah in comparison. I'm happy with my purchase.