I bought these boots several months ago and I am absolutely delighted with the quality of the leather, construction and the wear.  They are extremely comfortable to wear for an entire day.  I agree that the top of the boot is very wide and I would not wear with skirts/dresses, however as I mostly wear pants/jeans they are perfect.  All my pants/jeans sit over the top of the boot which is entirely satisfactory.  The quality of the buckle detail is not as good as many boots on the market.  I would recommend this product.