Pros:
=>These are Very Very Comfortable.
=>Looks awesome
=>The fit is perfect for me, I wear a size 6 and ordered a size 6.
=>The price was crazy awesome
=>The shaft is a tiny bit wider than the "Emma" boot so if you half larger calves as I do (I cycle a lot), then you'll like these.

Slight Cons:
=>I ordered black, I did spray them with protective spray - but even after, the color rubbed off a little bit on my hands if you touch them.  I am not sure if this is common for this brand, or just the black suede (I have no issues of color rub off with my 10" Emma Hickory/Champagne  color) No color rub off on my jeans yet as they have so far been tucked in.

=>Not quite a 12" boot - the ones I received measure 11.5" from bottom of sole to top of shaft

At the end of the day though I am happy with my purchase - I may order another pair if this color rub off issue dissipates.

Would have given 5 stars if the color rub off did not occur.