I tried this adorable shoe in 4 sizes - 2 in wide (and I've never worn a wide before).  I have NEVER EVER had such a problem getting a shoe to fit - and I finally gave up.  I went with my normal size--too tight in width, I went up 1/2 a size--too long and the width was also too tight, then I tried the wide in my normal size-- it was about 1/4" too long for my foot, but the width seemed acceptable, so finally I tried the wide in 1/2 size smaller than my normal size -- it was again too tight in the width (length was ok!) It even seemed tighter than the normal size/normal width!  ARGH! I think the sizing of this shoe is done haphazardly or 'cut from memory'.

I now have to call Amazon again as when I called to tell them the problems I had with this shoe (and I already paid for 1 return) - I got a free return shipping label - but then this morning I got an email and noticed they charged me a $12 restocking fee.  Not ok.  Update, a hour later - read the fine print. You have 30 days to return shoes/clothing or you get a 20% cost of the item charge.  I was so mad about the shoes and the inconsistent/inaccurate sizing I let them sit around too long before I finally called Amazon.  You think when I got the return shipping label the representative would have also waived the late return charge?  I did get the fee waived with my second contact (this will be a 1x only thing).  I guess I am spoiled with other online companies having a much more generous time frame for unworn or defective merchandise returns. Overall I love Amazon - but again, read their (not terribly easy to find) policies.