I have mixed feelings about these shoes - they're rated as a top walking shoe and are holding up quite well for that purpose (I've been doing a lot of hard surface walking lately).  The sole has outlasted my friend's sport shoe walker sole.  The insole is resisting any chafing too.

However, I feel like something has "settled" inside the sole and my foot feels like it wants to roll to the outside when I am standing still.  It just feels unstable now.  I'm quite confused by this as there is no unusual wear on the outsole.  Maybe the flexibility of the sole allows this?

Overall, these shoes are fitting my requirement for a classier walking shoe that wears well.  I have no doubt that these shoes will last the year of 2 mile/day walks I intend for them.  I'm on the fence if this is enough to remain loyal to the Rockport brand though...