I bought this Pea Coat in 2011-2012. This is a great coat and I've worn it during every Northeast winter since than.  The Jacket itself has held up and the only damage has been that the inside liner of the pockets have ripped (not a big deal and were easily sewn repaired). It is very warm and when combined with a hoodie/fleece underneath will keep you toasty in 20 degrees and under temps. I've had it dry-cleaned and it takes to the cleaning well, looking brand new afterwards.  I'm writing this review now, hoping that I can guide others through the mixed reviews. Glancing over a few newer reviews I see the sizing has probably changed from back when I purchased this coat. This seems to be why (depending on the date of the person reviewing) the coast seems overly large to some and smaller to others.  I am 6'0, 190lbs Male. I wear a 46R jacket and when I bought this coat in 2012 I went with a MEDIUM which fit like a Large and left a good amount of space for a fleece underneath.  The jacket is still easily wearable without anything underneath and does not look overly large at all. I was very happy with what I received. What I've noticed now in 2016 is in the product description the material has changed.  My coat has 80% wool 20% polyester.  This newer version is listed at 70% wool 30 % polyester.  In my experience I have found that a higher Wool% lends itself to an overall longer lasting and warmer coat.  Because of this I cannot say how this new 2016-2017 version is compared to what I purchased years ago.  With the material/sizing change I am not sure what to think but will leave my review based on the product I received in 2012.  If this new version coat is like the one I received years ago I would give it 5 stars for sure as it has seen me through some bitter cold days. Hope this helps!