Pros: beautiful and funky for a cheap boot. Live them! Complaints all the time.
I have a 13" calf and rarely can find a boot that doesn't look like I'm swimming in them.

Cons: first pair I got had a warped heel support and had to be returned. However my next pair showed up fast.
I have high arches so the instep was really tight, nothing a couple of wearing a didn't cure. I have arch supports in them now and they are fine.

These fit like narrow sized shoe. If you lean towards the upper size of a medium fit, these are going to be supper tight. I would also recommend a half size increase. Te toe box isn't small, but it is a but narrow. That extra half size gives you better wiggle room.