I really like the looks of these boots and the price was excellent on Amazon. I ordered a half size down, like every review seems to mention. I'm a 7 in every shoe I've ever owned...ordered this in 6.5. I have an average width foot and these feel a touch narrow (I'm guessing due to the decrease in size) but they are still a touch long and my heel slips like crazy. I wouldn't want to size down to a 6 as I feel those would be far too narrow. I put an insert in, which does help with the slipping. However the insert does raise my foot up a touch and the leather is VERY stiff in the ankle and forefoot. I'm hoping this loosens and softens with time because I don't want to go through the hassle of returning. In my opinion, these are not comfortable out of the box: they are stiff and there is no arch support. I'm just hoping that these are the type of shoes that need to be broken in for a month or so before they feel good. Looks: 5 stars Comfort and sizing: 2 stars (for now)