Since I've recently moved to NYC, I've been in the market for a boot that fit the following requirements: Black Leather, Waterproof, Warm, Sufficient Grip, Comfortable, and Stylish.  Well, needless to say, it wasn't an easy task.  But, I'm happy to say that this boot is everything I wanted!  Granted, I've only just received them and have only worn them once, but after walking all day in rainy conditions, my feet were dry and comfortable. They are also lightweight with a nice grip!  I am really pleased with the boot, and am super picky when it comes to my shoes. Even more so now that my feet are essentially my  new vehicle, so I must be sure and take very good care of them. I will update if I find fault in the next 3 months, but as of right now, I consider these boots to be the perfect fit!  True to size, ordered my usual size 9 and fit perfectly. My feet are wide, but are not crowded or uncomfortable, although I find the shaft to be a bit snug for my calves, but am sure the leather will stretch a little to accomidate. Going for the Brown pair next! They are a steal at this price!!! Satisfied customer!  :)