After over a year of searching for knee high riding style boots that fit my calf and still look good, I can finally say I've found them! I normally wear between an 8.5 and 9M. I ordered the 9 and with socks they are fine in the width and only slightly long. I plan on adding a thin insert to help with length and to make the footbed softer. My calves measure 16" and these wide shaft boots fit perfectly even with skinny jeans tucked in. The ankle area is good, not too wide or slouchy so my ankle still looks small (which they are). I am 5'6" and they fall about an inch below my knee. The leather is vey nice and soft on the upper shaft however the foot area is a bit stiff and shiny/polished looking. I personally prefer a more distressed looking boot and these are not that but I do think they will scuff easily so that could work in my favor. Overall, I'm impressed with these brown Franco Sarto boots and can't wait for cooler weather!

**UPDATE**
January 7, 2013 - I've had these for 3 months. I wear them about 3 times per week. They have not really stretched out but they have become VERY comfortable. I am very pleased with them and how they are wearing. They have scuffed a bit but the scuffs actually give the boots a more distressed look, which as I mentioned in my previous review, is a good thing for me. You won't be disappointed. These really are very nice boots!!