I have not used the boots in the rain or snow yet. But I did walk around the house with them and they are comfortable, warm and seem to be able to hold through not only rain but also snow. The reason for the 4 stars is that it makes my feet look like I'm wearing duck shoes, they are kind of wide in the front and looks a little awkward. Other than that I think these are great boots high enough and the handles make it so easy to pull up, the calf area is big enough to put jeans insides and I beleive that once I use it in the rain or snow, I'm sure it will keep my feet dry.