I looked long and hard for boots that were properly weatherproof (let's face it, waterproofing spray won't cut it in a slush puddle or a downpour) but also stylish and office-appropriate. These are it! I have them in the Chianti Patent, which may be a little forward for some, but I have gotten many compliments already and the low heel is very tasteful. They are well-constructed and incredibly comfortable on the streets of NYC. They are on the narrow side, however, both in the shaft and the foot. I sized up half a size (usually a reliable 7.5, got these in 8) and they are perfect with tights or dress socks. I am able to tuck skinny jeans into them but I have pretty slender calves; they do have elastic, so there is some give, but not a ton. Very happy with my choice.