I've been wearing these shoes for some time now.  I have over pronation, not bad enough that the doctor wants to have molded orthotics, but I use the Dr. Scholls brand to provide some relief as I walk a lot.  One of the best aspects of these shoes is that they fit very well, even with the orthotic.  Some brands I need to order a wide to fit correctly, but the normal "D" (medium) size is A-ok on my foot.

Overall, very comfortable.  I walk a lot throughout the day and have persnickety feet, I've found a new favorite brand! So far they are wearing very well.  They did stretch a bit, but nothing I am concerned about.  I have a few scratches on the leather already, but they still shine up well.  The laces are also more durable than most I receive from off the shelf shoes.  The bottoms are wearing very well too!

I bought two pair, (not the same models) but both are wearing consistently so I know this isn't a fluke.  Good shoes, buy and enjoy!