I find it very comfortable. Warm, and has managed to keep me dry through a downpour. I love the inner pocket, about the perfect size for fitting inside Kindle; a second would have been really useful though as I find I've more to carry than I would like to entrust to outer pockets.

Due to the inner pocket, I find it's comfortable to stash my gloves and hat in there when it is really bad one, after making it indoors.

But I take a star off because a lot of it looks like it's coming undone; undoubtedly it will look like it's falling apart by next winter. The hood, which I've used all of three times isn't looking like-new after only a few wears and a single wash. Also, a few buttons look like they won't be lasting as the thread on more than a couple is coming out, it seems only a matter of time until they come off.

Still, I love the coat. It is, while a bit large, quite comfortable as it keeps me warm despite the rain or snow, and allows enough movement that I enjoy wearing it when going out.