I was seeking a bag to do carry-on only for what will be a number of international trips this year where wheels will not be an option.  I'd been packing lighter and lighter as I became a better traveler and no longer needed the wheels.  As a huge fan of RIck Steve, I had to check out the Convertible Carryon.

First, it is an excellent, spacious, easy to pack bag.  I packed my entire packing list without needing to expand the pack, and still have space to spare.  In face, I cinched down all the compression straps.  There are several very thoughtful compartments, like the one in the lid for laundry or shoes, and several extremely handy pockets on the front.  I loved the document pocket in the bottom- it was such a smart traveler item.

I also really liked that it's sort of boxy and not "cool" looking, so it's classic and sort of dull.  That's the best way to travel- not flashy.

My issue was with the straps.  The hip belt and shoulder straps fit fine, but the straps pull at my shoulder.  After my trial walks of 30 minutes and 35 minutes, I had deep irritated red marks.  I do have narrow, bony shoulders, so this may be more my particular frame than an actual design flaw.  The bag is very floppy, and has no frame or suspension.  So I couldn't cinch it with a sternum strap or adjust the straps from the top (like on a hiking backpack).  I did find a bag that does have those features- stiffer sides, a sternum strap, and suspension on the tops of the shoulders.  If this bag had suspension or a sternum strap, I'd have kept it.

I am sad to return it since I do like Rick Steves and turn to his work for travel guidance all the time, but the straps are just irritating my shoulders too much.