I was very happy with these shoes when they arrived.  They fit perfectly and are stylish and well made and surprisingly comfortable.  They even looked great on my big feet (size 9).  The only reason I didn't rate them a 5 is because the little flap over the heel often flips up and I have to push it back down or the cuff of my pants get caught up on it.  I was looking for a slightly more rubberized sole but the traction on these is okay.