I should have read the reviews first, that'll teach me! I am a solid 7.5 to 8 and I ordered the 8 size, but they were far too small. Tried putting one on and the lining ripped immediately. I bet I could wear a 9 in this boot. Odd how off the sizes are and I think these are boots made in the USA? Well, had to send them back. Unsure if I will buy another pair of these, might just go to the store and get them, they are cheaper in most stores from what I saw shopping yesterday.