I absolutely love these boots. My feet never got cold or wet once during the winter even though I was walking through up to 2 feet of snow at times. They are amazing. The only reason that I give them 4 stars is that I found they ran a little small for the foot(I ordered 1.5 sizes up from mine and with a thick pair of socks they fit perfectly) and too  large for the ankle area which made them get a crease and without thick socks it would cut into the back of my foot.