I have been on 2 hikes so far with these (about 10miles). 1 hike was through moderate-tougher hilly terrain with a number of rocky patches, the other was on varried terrain but mostly on paved/well worn dirt trails. I bought a half size (11 vs 10.5) larger than I normally wear. I am glad that I did, these boots seem a half size small (I tried a 10.5 Baltro and it was too tight). I am 230# with a 5-7lbs day pack.

Pros:

1) this boot fits the heel and side of the foot very nicely. The toe box is roomy.
2) the ankle support is firm but not too stiff - if you want ankle support for constantly rocky terrain, choose a higher calf boot
3) It is an active walker. The toe area of the sole curves upward so that when your foot comes down, it encourages you to keep walking
4) The stiff sole with well spaced lugs to keep from clogging up with mud.
5) The boot itself is true to fit. this boot is crafted as opposed to softer more generic fitting day hikers.
6) When standing upright (not moving), you feel as if nothing is gonna knock you down - a very solid stance.
7) the lacing system is solid. A classic lace up boot system with an ankle lace point slightly behind the others for a tight fit. The eyelets seem sound and durable.
8) I really don't notice the boot weight much. For a full grain boot, I think it is rather light.

Cons:

1) The boot only comes in D width. My feet are between D & E. So for me this boot will take a while to break in
2) The active walking system will take getting used to as it does put a bit more stress on your toe bottoms.

I have some hot spots with this boot due to the width issue and the fact that it is full grain leather vs a softer leather/synthetic boot. But I feel the break in time will be worth it. This boot is very well constructed