I got the black nappa. They are very comfortable, fit true to size, and mostly perfect. However, they come up a little too high in the back and it irritates my heel. Usually Me Too is my go to brand for comfortable flats that you can wear out of the box without blisters. (Believe me, I've tried maybe 20 different brands of simple black ballet flats.) My one problem with Me Too is that they only last about a year and then the sole wears so thin you have to throw them out (my last pair I had almost exactly a year and by the end there was a hole in the bottom). That said, I wore them A LOT in all sorts of weather conditions. If you wear them less and not get them wet, they'll probably last longer. Anyway, I'm hesitant to spend $90 for me toos that I know will wear out in a year, especially if I don't like the feel of the heel, so I'm gonna send these back. If you like these but don't like how high the heel comes up in back, try the Me Too Lucca.