I bought these in grey about 5 months ago (order placed Nov 7, 2011).

Pluses:
- Very cute.  I received many compliments about how nice they looked with jeans, i.e. "Those make your feet look tiny!"  ;)
- Love the colors
- Easy to slip on and off
- Very comfortable, no breaking in required

Minuses:
- Water goes right in - zero weather resistance
- The shoes have completely worn out after about 6 months.  The fiber band around the bottom is fraying and falling off, bottoms are about worn through, and inner lining of sole is falling out.  I only wore them on weekends, and believe me, I am not doing a whole lot of walking around!  ;)

So at the price, they are worth it for a disposable shoe.  I just wish they would last longer...