I got these in the mail a couple of weeks ago, and while I haven't worn them out yet (it won't be "fall" here for about another two months), I have worn them around the house to make sure they fit and are comfortable, and I really, really like them! I am an exact 9.5 and I ordered a 9 as most other reviewers said they run a bit big, and they were right. I think a few others had commented to order up, but the 9 fits just fine...I even think I could wear some thick socks with them and still have some toe room. This is my first pair of FitFlop brand anything, but the "wobble board" sole is easy and comfortable to walk around in, and it's cleverly concealed in the design so it doesn't LOOK like a toning shoe. I don't kid myself expecting any super-great butt toning as a result, but I guess every little bit helps! The picture doesn't really do the shoe justice--the sole isn't as obvious in person as it is in the 3/4 view online. From the side, it's pretty incognito, or at least I think so. I think these are much cuter than Uggs since they are a bit more streamlined in fit.

The tops can either be folded down to show the shearling lining or left up, which I like very much. The best thing about these is that they still came most of the way up my calf--sometimes, "tall" boots and I have issues since I have very long legs. I am guessing on a shorter person (I'm 5'10") they would probably be knee-height, but they come to approximately two or three inches below my knee, which is fine with me--they don't cut my calf off at the middle, which is a very unfortunate look (I know from experience, sadly!).

I think these are going to be perfect with some skinny jeans, but would also look right with a corduroy or tweed skirt. The reason they don't get the full five stars is because the sides around the ankle are so soft, I am worried that they may get too soft and permanently crease there, causing them to droop or sag around that area. Also, as another reviewer noted, the sole isn't lined with shearling like an Ugg-type boot is, so you must always wear socks with these, but that's not really too big of an issue. All in all, I'm very pleased with my purchase.