I hate the color. It's darker than I expected (or how it seems on the photo). The boots itself is really comfortable and the sizing, as suggested from other reviewers I ordered half size smaller and it does feel perfect.
My fianc wanted me to cancel this order and i did but it got delivered anyway so I thought if I love it I'll just keep it. I don't totally love it however my fianc says it looks great on me and he told me to keep it so I'm keeping it lol. He said the color will be the way I want as it wears off

Update may 15 2012:
Hey I'm really glAd I purchased this. If I didn't I wouldn't have anything cool to wear to WA trip (to see future in-laws) we r going this week!! We live in TX and all I wear are sandals coz it's usually hot. It's raining a lot today so I wear the rain boots from NYC (lol); it rains fairly a lot in Georgetown. Anyway, in 60-70 degree weather I can't live without a pair of Durango! ;)
Btw I have fairly wide feet, no trouble with the sizing (half size smaller), but of course in the beginning it FELT tight. That's how it's supposed to be, and the leather just works around ur feet. :) My feet can breathe in these. I don't trust anything but leather these days, lol. Let's see what else.. In NYC I had these boots too, maybe, the same brand or different brand, idk, but very similar design. I wore that pair ALL THE TIME, EVERYDAY in fall-winter, rain or shine and they were awesome. Got many compliments and I guess my fianc told me to keep these because these look like them which i wore when we met.. :)

Update 11/14/2013:

I've been married for over a yr now, and I came back to my review because my mother-in-law really likes my boots and she wants to purchase them as well! ^o^ now I also own a pair of fancy brown Cavender boots with rose patterns (also in brown color) outside part that it is hard to tell unless u look very closely, which I really love. It looks very pretty. But this one has good memory...because it looks just like the boots I wore when I met my hubby. ^_^ I feel like this is good luck boots. I highly recommend them. XD Changed my review to 5 stars! Oh I think I should mention that I even wore them for mountain hiking in the rain in WA like a yr ago!!! XD my hubby had to clean them for me afterwards and it's still in a perfectly good shape! Lol