Should you buy this? YES. MOST DEFINITELY, EMPHATICALLY YES.

Pros: VERY comfortable. So comfortable. Really, really soft and comfortable.

Cons: boring colors **UPDATE** Just kidding. They have fun colors.

If you haven't noticed by now, there boxers are extremely comfortable. The cotton is soft and pliant, which is an odd word to have to use to describe clothing but not all cotton products are the same. These offer no resistance to movement, do not constrict the waistline with the elastic, and don't chafe. I'm buying more - enough to replace my entire underwear drawer with just these. Seriously, you're doing yourself a disservice if you don't buy these. I paid ~$11, but I would buy these again at the list price of $23 without hesitation. As it is, they're on sale for 50% off, so I'm just going to buy twice as many.

**UPDATE**

So I went ahead and bought two more packs from the same retailer (NY Lingerie; I don't think men's underwear really qualifies, but that's ok). One pack was the same color I had already gotten, a monochrome grayscale, but the other pack contained green and purple. Odd choices for colors, but I'm happy with them. I felt it would be a disservice to not throw that out there when I specifically mention color as a "con". Would be nice to let you pick colors, though...