The auto open Totes umbrella that I bought back in the 1980's is still going strong. It withstood strong winds and was a best buy from Consumer Reports at that time. The only reason I'm shopping for a new one now is that it is finally starting to rip a little. After reading all the reviews I'll hold on to the one I have until the new one is fully tested and tried. I got the new Totes auto open/close umbrella but had no reason to use it until hurricane Irene hit town. The winds may not have been as bad in up state NY as elsewhere but it stood up well just the same. I am as pleased with this umbrella as with my old Totes (this one was even cheaper to buy as well).
Thank you for all your reviews.