After trying several different types/brands of climbing shoes, I decided to give the Katana lace a try.  It has a very comfortable fit for a lace shoe and locks in great.  Once the shoe is broken in, the smearing is no problem.  Edging with this shoe is amazing.  There is enough rubber on the sole that when you stick your foot down, there is no doubt that you aren't going anywhere.  I am sold on this shoe and don't plan on venturing to a different type/brand anytime soon.