When I started thinking about potty training my 20 month old daughter I bought her these and a package of the Gerber training pants.  My daughter prefers these.  She always picks these out to wear over the others.  I like them because they are less of a boy-short design like the others AND they have the no-mess lining which keeps her little accidents from getting all over her clothes and carpet without having to wear bulky plastic pants over them.  I gave them 4 stars because they seem a little short in the bum, but fit ok around the legs and in the front...