True to size, generous toe box.  Nice platform look without being ridiculously over the top.  Have purchased this style in 6.5 and 7 and have found both to be comfortable and wearable, not too narrow.  Cushioned foot bed.  Quality construction and materials. Another reviewer was displeased because some of the styles are "not leather."  Some of them are canvas, some are leather, some are suede, some are patent and MIGHT be vinyl, or they MIGHT be patent leather.

November 2011:  It is necessary to update and downgrade rating on this shoe.  It's still sexy, nice to look at, fits ok.  Great if you're just sitting there, looking nice.  Like everyone else, I "walk right out" of these shoes no matter how many heel grips, cushion pads, and anything else you can think of.  The only thing that works is I bought some 11 or 12 inch nylon cat collars and wrapped them around the shoe and buckled them on top of my foot.  Works great if you secure the strap on the bottom of the shoe with a little double-face foam tape to keep the strap from slipping down.  This only works if you're wearing slacks and the slacks hide the strap.  The other thing I tried is those elastic dress clips, the ones with the suspender-type clasp clipped to the shoe.  The only problem with those is that they leave indentations on the sides of the shoe.

The shoes look great.  You just can't walk in them, even if you size down, you still can't walk in them and they'll be uncomfortable.  Great for sitting.

Still rate them a 3 because they are very attractive shoes.

UPDATE:  Found another way to make these wearable.  Use heavy duty sticky back hook and loop tape and make some straps out of sturdy upholstery-type clear plastic and make some invisible straps to go across top of vamp.  Works well, but the hook and loop does catch on nylon hose.  Sort of like those clear plastic straps for lingerie.  Could probably use those straps and modify for the shoe with the sticky hook and loop tape.