These boots are beautiful and comfortable and I might have kept them except the shaft isn't tall enough for me.  The shaft height is 15 1/2 inches according to the product description, but I need at least an inch and a half more for the boots to look good with shorter skirts or above-the-knee dresses.  I also want slightly heftier and higher heels.  I am 5'5 and 150 pounds and dainty heels like these don't look flattering on me.

I gave these boots a 4 star anyway because I'm sure they will feel and look wonderful on another woman.