I have AE shoes that are 15 years old and look nearly new and I find this specific belt to be of the same quality as their shoes.

The leather is clearly of high quality, it is well stitched, well finished, and has a casual but attractive die.  I also like the somewhat wider size (38mm) which goes well with jeans and the like.

And, Yes, this belt is made in the USA which is an unusual bonus these days.