I have owned my pair for 4+ years and could not be happier with them. I don't know about Uggs. Have never owned a pair. Bearpaws - I don't understand the high rating on them, because the young gals that I know have had them fall apart. These will not fall apart. I wear them outside when it is wet and rainy and my feet still stay warm. I wear them without socks. I have spilt coffee along with everything else under the sun on mine. I love them. I have worn my pair so much that the soles are starting to wear though. I tend to drag my feet. They are my best friend in the winter time. Sorry about that sweetie! They might not be the most stylish. They might not be the most popular. But they darn sure keep my feet warm.