First off, I ordered a size 6 UK (I'm a size 8/8.5 US) and it fits pretty well, with enough extra space that I could wear thick socks and it'd still be comfortable.

I ordered these because I was looking to replace a pair of GI boots I've had for 6 years, and these had that edgy look I love (and I've always wanted a pair of Dr. Martens).  I ended up ordering the black noir based on another reviewer saying how the smooth black is made out of softer leather compared to the noir, and therefore, tends to get beaten up easier.  As I expect to use these daily, I needed something that could handle all the walking I do on campus and, hopefully, stand up to the salt during the winter. (I'll update my review if anything pops up)

On the side of color, I rubbed off most of the wax, and then used the wonder balsam to remove the rest.  Due to the stiff leather, there are creases were part of the white wax remains, so it looks like an aged, rugged black boot, which I absolutely love.