The material was premium, and they fit me true to size. However, I would actually give these 2.5 stars.
First, though this is supposed to be a skinny jean, it is a slim & straight leg.
Second, when I tried them on, I kept looking and looking and looking trying to figure it out...something was "off." Within a few minutes I realized that the side seams that should run down the outsides of your leg are about an inch off and run straight down the front of the leg. When I was facing the mirror, I could clearly see the side seams on the front of the leg and the jeans just seemed crooked or ill-fitting. My best guess is that the seams attempt to delineate a "skinny" leg. Needless to say, I've returned these.