At first the shoes felt too big. Usually wear a size 9, but with wool socks they became better. Also, the right one, when not wearing long socks, was really rough on my Achilles and cut it up. Since I've worn them, the leather has become increasingly softer. Vee nice shoes now. Also, be not weary of initial scratches; they will all blend together and become one. They say don't wipe with water but I use water on paper towel to clean outside of shoes (had bar tar on them).

Ps I usually wear a 9-9.5 running shoe (9.5 asics, 9.5 saucony, 9 in Brooks)

With thick socks these shoes fit all right but maybe a tad big. Doesn't effect my walking since I'm used to them now. If I buy again I may go with an 8.5. But 9 wouldn't necessarily be bad.