I bought these boots based on the other reviews.  I was looking for comfy boots to keep my feet warm during a football game.  I received these boots several days before the game.

I ordered Birch colored boots, the color did not match the color Amazon showed, they are darker and have a green hue to them. The color matches the Bearpaw website exactly, so double check before you order.  I contacted Amazon about this and they were very helpful, I ended up keeping the boots because the color grew on me)

I wore the boots for short periods of time prior to the game.  They fit well, I ordered size 8, usually I'm an 8-8.5 narrow feet.  The boots feel a little wide, but that works if I want to wear thick socks.  I wore these boots with wool socks to an afternoon football game, temp was low 60s/high 50s , my feet were fine for the first 1.5-2 hours, but then they started getting cold.  Not freezing cold, but not as warm as I expected per the reviews.  Also my feet started to hurt.  I think it might be the lack of arch support, but wearing these shoes for 4+ hours of mostly standing was very uncomfortable.

Maybe my expectations were too high, but based on other reviews these boots were described as very comfy & warm. They are great for short periods of time, taking the dog out first thing in the morning, etc.  But I would never wear them all day long.

Also waterproofing them is a must!