I'm updating my reviews on this product, because I think I got a little carried away before.  My previous review stated that people who were complaining about the width of these things were Bigfoot.  I have a wide foot myself, and their complaints caused me to order a size vastly larger than I needed, and I still feel that that's true.  These people must have freak-feet.  But the fact of the matter is, after I returned the Crocs from Shoebuy for a refund, I went out to a physical store to try on some Crocs.  As it turned out, not only were the Crocs that were my size wide enough, but I could actually wear a size down.  I usually wear a 10, and I ended up buying a 9.  This NEVER EVER EVER happens to me.  I could have worn the Crocs which were my size easily enough, but I preferred the 9's, which were a nice, firm fit.  I also intended them as house shoes, and will not be using the heel strap.  The heel strap actually does make my toe hit the front a bit uncomfortably, but as I said- I won't use them.  I only tested that out for the sake of sizing evaluation.

So, the long and short of it is that I would

SERIOUSLY RECOMMEND GETTING THE SIZE YOU WEAR

If you have a wide foot, and it is generally the case that you can buy a shoe labeled "wide width", you DO NOT need to scale up for Crocs.  Crocs in this design will EASILY fit wide width feet.

As far as this seller goes, Shoebuy's customer service was good, and when I need a new pair, I am sure I will simply order from them.