I had a previous let-down experience with my first pair of Sanuks, a pair of brown leather Boardrooms.  Based on other reviews of these Shore Leaves and what I was able to find online, I was hoping to not have a repeat performance with these.  However after having owned and worn these shoes for the last 2 months, I am again disappointed.

Pros:
1.  Like all Sanuks, comfortable.
2.  They do look good both laced up and without laces, for a casual look.
3.  The rubber sole is more durable than the typical Sanuk "sandal" style foam soles.

Cons:
1.  My main disappointment - the shoe's ability generate and retain odor.  I did not have this problem with the Boardrooms, and have not had odor issues with any other footwear I own.  For some reason, these shoes have developed a very strong odor that I haven't been able to get rid of through any methods - fabric odor remover (Febreeze fabric stuff), leaving them out in the sun repeatedly and for 2 days on end for drying, and putting it through the washing machine.  The odor is very noticeable and basically has made these shoes unwearable.  There's very minor "build-up" of gunk in the shoes, mostly lint from socks and its all been easily removed.
2.  I've noticed the soles separating from each shoe in various places - on the right, it is separating where the shoe bends during walking.  On the left, its separating at the front and in the back.  In both cases, it seems that some leather is tearing away with the rubber sole.
3.  Cost - I think these are among the most expensive pairs of Sanuks.  If it were not for the above two issues, I might consider it a decent value.

I hope I got a bad pair.  But either way, I'm now 0 for 2 with Sanuks unfortunately.