Love them...but only after some tweaking in the insoles. The black became a rich, deep black after I waterproofed them with Sofsole. Now they're beautiful. So here's my take on size: Like many people, I ordered one size down. When I put them on, my toes were way too scrunched in front and after ten minutes, began to hurt. So I paid to send them back, erg, then I finally got my actual size and I'm fine. I should add, they have already loosened a wee bit in one month. Not sure if this is stretch, or just fleece packing a little.
Pros:
  Toasty, don't feel sweaty and no stinky feet. They seem softer than my Ugg Ultimates. The outer soles are very flexible so I can role my feet when I walk (ergonomically good) and tip toe around my second floor apt. But only after insole tweaks. Here's why.
Cons:
  1. They WILL slide up and down which can potentially cause hot spots on the back of the foot and just feel sloppy. Now, I will say I do have tender feet, but you may be fine with all of this;
  2. In spite of their boasting, insoles have very little arch support. So I got some to put under inserts, which took care of the slipping too. After living in Uggs for years, I can feel that Emu inserts are not as cushy as the Ugg inserts (They look better, but who's looking), so I bought a pair of Uggers ($15.00 on website) and slipped them in. Aah, now they're perfectly comfy and they don't slip...30 extra dollars later. But hey! I pamper my feet and it was well worth it to have the right fit.
  3. Tread is very shallow and can quickly cake with snow making them slippery. Unless you're agile on ice and don't break easily, this could be a hazard.

UPDATE: It is now January 2016, almost 4 years later, and I'm still warm in my awesome Emus. They still look and feel great.  keep them brushed and water proofed (you can keep the insoles brushed up too) I replace the insoles every year with the UGG inserts, still found here on Amazon. This keeps them fitting snug.