I rated these shoes one star because I just don't believe any shoe should look this beat up after 3.5 months.  I have very rarely worn the shoes outside, mostly just around the house.  I don't think they would exist if I ventured out in them.  They look sloppy and overrun because the width has stretched so much. And, they stretched width-wise very soon after I started wearing them.
I don't think anyone with a slightly narrow foot could wear these.  My width is between B and C and these are probably at least a D now.  Both of the ties have ripped off, and I probably only tied them a few times.  They're comfortable because they're such a wreck they're barely touching my feet anymore.  I need to buy new mocassins, but I definitely won't be buying these again.