If you're familiar with the USA Carhartt T's from about 10 years back, these are not the same. The material is thinner on the newer version, and they fit slightly bigger. The colors also fade faster, and these wear faster. Still a good shirt, but disappointing if you are familiar with the older version of these t-shirts.

Update: As Carhartt continues to manufacture these shirts in new and different countries, the fit and quality of the fabric has become more and more inconsistent. Therefore my rating is dropping.

I would pay the premium for the old USA shirts, but not for the new variations of the shirt. It's not worth it, and the inconsistencies. Especially online since sizing is hit or miss.