The other Built NY Case I have is the Scoop one (which I still am using since buying it a couple of years ago) and I admit that overall, the Scoop model is better than this.  The main reason is because the Scoop doesn't come with the hood.  I agree with some of the other reviewers who brought up the fact that the hood gets in the way when you're trying to take your camera out (and insert it back) in a hurry.  I originally purchased this case for my Sony Cybershot DSC-HX9V, but unfortunately it was WAY TOO TIGHT of a fit.  If you are perhaps thinking of purchasing this camera, be forewarned that it is truly meant to fit very slim cameras (like a Canon Elph).  My other P&S camera, the Leica C-Lux 3 is thin in general so it had no problem fitting in this case, but again, if you have a camera with similar dimensions to the DSC-HX9V, do not purchase this!