This is my third pair of Dc martens, and I bought the black in a size 6. I am usually a 8.5 - 9 in shoes American sizing. These are the first pair that do not need to broken in. Since I won't be wearing these everyday, I am happy that I cant slip them on and won't be in pain. They are really soft leather, and the they come with regular laces and the ribbon which I love. I cant wait to wear them with a short skirt or tight jeans. They are sooo cool, tough but still feminine. I highly recommend. Some reviews say the black looks dark gray, but they look black to me. If you don't have time to break them in, get the black. Hope I was helpful. XOXO Love these and will probably buy the black noir too!