I saw these in a magazine and loved them, so I read a lot of reviews before making my purchase. Most of the reviews said they ran large so I ordered an 8.5 (I usually wear 8.5-9). They are a little roomy but so worth it because they are so cute and comfortable! I didn't know the insole would be so comfy, definitely a plus. I tried "tightening" the leather straps to make them more snug, but they leather is either disconnected or tied down at the front before the laces and cannot be tightened. The metal brackets that serve as the hole for the leather hurt a little at the widest part of my foot if I lace them too light, so I just consider them for what they are- slip ons. Four/five stars because of the lacing issue. Overall they are very comfortable, they provide support for my back (I have sciatica), and look amazing.