These boots are very comfortable. The shaft is the perfect size for my calves. I have skinny to average calves and they were snug. If you have athletic or larger calves, these may not work for you. I really like the buckle detail. It keeps the ankle area from bunching up, a big problem I often have since I have really skinny ankles. The foot area is true to size. Everything is great, except for one thing. I don't like how it dips down at the top of the boot. I knew this before I bought the boots, but I thought I could overlook it. However, I simply can't. It gives it more of a country western vibe and that was not what I was looking for. I was looking for more of an equestrian riding boot look. I wish the top was just straight. There is really nothing wrong with the boot. It's just a personal preference of style. I really don't want to send these back, but I must.