Pay close attention to the photo and you will see that SIX are the SAME color pattern.  Unfortunately I did not analyze the photo and was under the impression (when ordering) that the "Color Variety" of 12 socks would be evenly distributed between the four choices.  Instead, I received 6 black/red/gray, and two of each of the others. The socks themselves are dress-socks thin but not overly so, and the first pair that I just put on has a flaw in the weave in a noticeable spot.  I originally would have given these a one star because of the variety disparity, but the photo, on closer inspection, indicates the imbalance so these get a three star because of the reasonable price for reasonable socks.