These received much praise from my coworkers.  It was a gift for a woman who is leaving after 10 years of working there.  She seemed to love them, I just wish they had been more rounded and not so oblong.  Still, it was a workable gift and she enjoyed it.  So I guess that is what counts.  The color was good and nicely even, no blotches.  No blemishes that I could find.  So yeah, I would get these again.