I purchased both the tall Bogs boots (rubber to ankle, then neoprene from ankle to knee) and these. I much prefer the tall ones, the fit is WAY more comfortable. These are an awkward height and the top edge rubs against the middle of my calf. They're also tricky to get on and off, they don't have the nice little handle/grip things like the tall boots, and there's not a lot of room in the leg. Couldn't tuck jeans in if I wanted to. I'm sure they are warm and waterproof, but not comfortable. I'd return them but the cost of shipping them back is nearly half the cost of the boots. Ebay, here we come.