I loved the styling of these shoes the minute I saw them, but was worried about fit and comfort and so agonized for quite a while before finally buying them. I got them in 6M, though I often have to go down to a 5.5 in heels over 2 inches high. 6M fits perfectly well! Not so tight that I can't wear thin socks or tights, but not so loose that they would slide off or feel uncomfortable even in bare feet (though I don't recommend wearing these without socks, as your feet will sweat and develop blisters pretty quickly!). They stay put and are surprisingly comfortable to walk in. They're among my most comfortable heels and definitely the most comfortable over 2 inches (even beating out a pair of Hush Puppies).

As for looks... I got the brown plaid and what you see is what you get. In size 6, the toe seems a bit short in proportion to the rest of the shoe (compared to the size 8 pictured, anyway), making my feet look even smaller than they are and thus pushing it closer to "cute" instead of "sexy" territory. I don't mind, but others with smaller feet should be aware! My one gripe is that the height of the heel makes it look more 60s than the lower 1940s style oxford I would've preferred, but no other shoe I've found was anywhere close to my ideal, so I remain happy with these!