I ordered the 7.5 in Redwood. I'm 5'4" with skinny ankles and athletic calves of 15", just so you guys know I don't have monstrously huge legs or "cankles". These are beautiful boots, but not as described. I expected them to be tight at first, but I couldn't even pull them up over my calves at all. So I busted out my tape measure and it turns out, the shaft opening was only 14" circumference. There would be no way I could even wear a tall sock with them, let alone leggings or skinny jeans! I know leather stretches with time, but I think the shaft diameter is way too small and therefore beyond a matter of just stretching. And, I shouldn't have to pay to take expensive, yet apparently defective, boots to a cobbler just to make them wearable! I'm very sad since they are otherwise very pretty boots but I have to return them. I saw another reviewer say they shaft opening was 17", so it's possible there is a lot of inconsistency with the sizing, an indication of sub-par manufacturing processes. For the amount they charge for these boots, they should have a better quality control system in place.