I'm going ahead with a five star because if mine didn't have a manufacturing defect on one shoe they would be perfect. They made my size 12 foot look smaller and very stylish which is something I never get. I would go for a replacement but for me the toe post was also too far forward by about 1/2 inch. I feared they would slip off and cause a fall. If you get a good pair with no defects I can see this being the only scandal/flipflop you will ever want to wear.

They are high quality so I am not letting my fluke one shoe spoil the whole line. I would recommend them and will probably end up getting another pair as they felt wonderful. Oh I got the spice color and it is a very attractive color, not blazing red, has more purple to it and looks rich.