I got these boots in a Gold Box special, and am thrilled that I did.  They fit great and look really sharp, not at all like some of the cheap rain boots out there.  The rubber sole is thick and comfortable to walk in, and the shaft is wide enough for my jeans to fit inside nicely (I have average calves).  I got the brown color, and it's a rich, dark brown like nice leather.  I'm a size 8 and found them a teensy bit short, but I'm afraid a size 9 would be much too big.  If in doubt, I'd suggest ordering two sizes and trying them with thick socks.  One note to keep in mind is that because they're rubber, they don't breathe AT ALL.  I wore them to do some gardening on a warm day and found that my lower leg got incredibly hot and sweaty (gross, I know).  These are definitely cold-weather boots only, for use with breathable/wicking socks.

Highly recommended.