I'm not usually one to return things that I purchase on Amazon but I did return these boots. Typically I do a lot of research and reading of reviews before I buy something. I went against my gut and decided to take a chance on these boots because of the positive reviews. I also bought a bigger size than normal, based on reviews and the fact that I have wide feet.  But the size 10s were way too big for me (I'm usually a 9 - 9.5). Unfortunately I was also disappointed in the quality. They were quite thin and I don't think they would have been particularly warm nor do I think they would they have held up very well. This is a classic case of "you get what you pay for".  They only cost $25 (in my case) but they're also of a quality that you would expect for $25 (which makes sense). Having said that, they didn't necessarily look bad, so if you're not planning to wear them very often or in cold weather, maybe you would be happy with them.  I'm guessing it also makes a difference which color you get (the ones I purchased were camel).