I am reviewing the second pair of these boots that I received.  One of the boots in the first pair began to squeak during the first day of wearing.  Amazon was great, though, and shipped a replacement pair even before I returned the first pair.  The boots are comfortable with a nice heel.  I was looking for boots with a wide width shaft that were stylish and comfortable, something that is not easy to find.  These boots definitely fit that description.  My only small negative comment is that I would have liked a little more arch support.  Overall, though, I would recommend these boots.