I really like these shoes. They are perfect for work (I have the black suede and black patent). They are high quality - I wore them all over cobblestone streets for a week and they were still lookin' good, and pretty comfortable. They are true to size - I am almost always a 9.5, and the 9.5 fit perfectly. I really like the soft, cushy sole - it feels great under foot. The only issue I have is they rise fairly high in the back, and gave me a bit of a blister. I'd give them a 4.5/5 and would recommend to a friend.