I wear nothing but oxfords and really do like this shoe.  The design is really nice, the shape of the shoe is really nice as well.  The shoe also is very comfortable with hardly any "break-in" time.  The only things that kept me from giving it 5 stars is that it's not as shiny as I would prefer and secondly, when I went to polish the shoe, some parts took to much of color and came out a little to dark....  I think perhaps an issue with the way the leather was dyed...  That said you have to really look to notice it and no one else could probably notice at all... So...4 stars.. Other than that, a great shoe.