I would have given the slippers 4 1/2 stars simply because they fit a little snug, so I would recommend ordering a size up unless you aren't going to wear socks. Half sizes would help, but since that wasn't possible, I would have ordered a 9 rather than an 8 simply because I like wearing socks with slippers during the winter. On the plus side, these are cozy enough to wear with bare feet. Otherwise, these are great slippers and in fact the best slippers I've bought. I work from home and so most days I live in slippers and I like comfort - these take care of that. Warm, comfortable and durable, I would recommend these slippers to anyone.