I originally ordered this shoe in pewter and then black i like both of them they just did not go with my daughters ensembles as i wanted the black i am still considering purchasing I really like them I give $ stars because they are good for price and cute the picture you see is what you get  my daughter is between a 5.5 and 6 penidng the designer i ordered a 5.5 and she has a lil room by the time she put on a tight i figured it would fill her just fine.