***EDIT***
Two years into wearing this shoe every work day. Some light wear is apparent, but they still have years of life left in them. Still very comfortable. The sole has worn some, making them a little less slip-resistant. Overall, still a great purchase that have gotten me through 2+ years of 40+ hour work weeks and show no sign of giving up.
Still ugly as sin.
***END EDIT***

I'm a manager at a restaurant, so I needed a shoe that could stand up to 40-50+ hours a week while keeping my feet comfortable. I'd heard a lot of good things about Crocs, but resisted for the longest time because they're ugly as sin. I've had my Crocs for a week now, here are my ratings:

Fit: 4 stars. I wear size 13 in all other brands, and Crocs size 13 is a tiny bit loose.this is minimized by the way the shoes seem to mold to my foot as I wear them.

Material/Construction: 5 stars. They have protected my feet from hot oil and a dropped meat cleaver, with hardly a mark. The sole is very slip resistant as well. The seem to not smell as bad as other shoes I've worn, and after washing them for the first time today, they look and feel like brand new.

Durability: Tentatively 5 stars. They've held up great for the first week, but 40-50 hours a week take their toll. I will update in a couple months.

Comfort: 5 stars. This was the category that mattered most to me, and these shoes don't disappoint. I especially love the small bumps on the inside.

Looks: -12 stars. I think Crocs are hideous and would never wear them outside of work.

Overall: 5 stars. I can't hold the looks against them, because I knew exactly what they looked like before I bought them. These shoes are way more comfortable than my old shoes with gel insoles were. I'm glad I finally got over the ugliness prejudice and got myself a pair.