I ordered the medium brown color - my first Sebago Saranac boot. At first, the leather around the heel was very stiff; I had to force my heel into the boot. However after wearing, the leather has relaxed and is more supple. The fit is large; about a half size. I have slender feet with skinny ankles and at first it was difficult to get a good fit. However, a thick sock or an inner sole has soaked up the extra space in the foot and I now find that these boots fit well and are very comfortable. Very pleased with the latex forefoot cushion and support feature as comfort under the arch is essential. The dark suede at the top teams well with the medium brown leather. Plenty of room to tuck in leggings or jeans. I like the rugged sole as it provides good grip. This boot has many practical features but is still very stylish. A good cold weather boot, but I would wear it at other times of the year. I would recommend the Sebago Saranac boot, providing you get the right size. A great price and excellent service from Amazon!!!