UPATE:  Having worn these boots now several times, including for a 2-day outdoor education trip with my fourth grade students, I've raised my rating from 4 to 5 starts.  Perfect support, all-day comfort, and they kept my feet cozy even when outdoors for hours in 40 degree weather.  A super purchase!

These boots were comfortable and fit well right out of the box.  They are much lighter than my old clunky pair which I love.  Still evaluating what appears right now to be a weight vs. support trade off.  In the long run, I think these lighter well-fitting boots will be the winner.