These inexpensive boots are peachy! Know that they are very casual, not dressy.  Like wearing a pair of sneakers- really, that comfortable. The tread is super good, too. They are, however, for thinner calves. My calf is just over 12 inches and there is just enough room to fit in skinny jeans without being too bulky or tight.  I wear a 7.5 in most shoes but I got an 8 so I can wear thicker socks in winter.  Fit is perfect and roomy but not too loose at all and toe area isn't narrow like most boots.  Note: boots are not real high, a few inches from the knee.