I got these boots because of the price and other reviews.  I usually wear a 7.5 B, so I ordered an 8.  The shoe is large and roomy.  My foot moves around in the shoe when I walk.  I did not find the upper part of the boot constricting or narrow.  I actually stuffed my boot-cut jeans in the boot and still did not feel it to be tight.

The bottom part of the shoe is a more bulky-looking than I would have liked.  My husband asked if they were galoshes.