Based on the other reviews, I decided to order a size up. Since the shoes are slides, I figured that I could probably still wear them if they were too big. I'm a size 9. I ordered  a size 40. The shoes fit me perfectly. However, be warned that they were almost too small. My toes and heal both reach the end of the footbeds, and I have no room to spare. So, if you are a size 9, please order at least a 40.

The leather is good quality, it is soft and the shoes do not rub. The shoebeds are comfortable, but I would not say that they are the most comfortable shoes ever. They are what I expected - good, solid, walking sandals. Overall, I am happy with my purchase. Thanks to all the other reviewers who warned me that size might be an issue!