These are great boots that keep your feet warm - probably not in super-cold climates, but more than suitable for a San Francisco winter...! They'll definitely keep my feet dry in the rain.

I ordered the black boots, and the fit is perfect for my size 5 feet when I ordered a size 5.5 (although, I usually order a 6 for boots... these 5.5's are perfect, though). They are incredibly comfortable, and just as important, they're really well-made and seem like they'll last a long while. The black boots have a really great, funky retro-look, and they're awesome with skinny jeans.