I have had these for almost a year and wore them almost everyday last winter. Literally every day.  They have held up very well.  They are very warm and I sometimes wear them without socks to keep my feel from sweating.  In the cold snowy weather with socks you feet will be very happy.  I also like the fit because you can adjust the laces to fit your calves. I can wear skinny legged pants inside the boot but they are slim enough to fit under boot-cut or wider legged pants.

My feet were totally dry all last season with heavy wear BUT I noticed a couple of weeks ago that my feet got wet in a rain storm. Perhaps if i get them professionally treated they will be waterproof again.  It would be worth it because after such heavy wear they are still warm and comfy.  and i still get compliments on them because they are so different than the usual winter boot.