I am a huge Clarks Booty fan. This one I am not so sure. The suede feels soft and comfortable. The rubber bottom feels good. But, lately I'm feeling a slight pain on the top of my right foot. Could be from the upper stiching. I am a size 8 and I purchased an 8 1/2, maybe a 9 would have been better. I'll keep trying to stretch it. So, it gets a 3 star for now.