I love the Fatbaby boots and this pair is no exception. They are actually better than my other pair because it looks like Ariat finally figured out that their pull strap stitching causes skin irritation and added a fabric covering. I love the insoles because they are cushy and very comfortable to walk on. The reason I didn't give 5 stars is because they are a bit tight when you first get them, as others have mentioned. Also, this particular pair has defective stitching on sole of the right boot, which mars the appearance. I didn't want to bother to send them back, but it's a bit bothersome. Other than that these are great boots. They break in very quickly and are extremely comfortable to stand in for long periods or for walking in. I recommend them.