I was really excited when I got these shoes but when I opened the box they looked like they had been broken-in already,had noticeable scratching and fit looser than the same sized pair I had previously tried on at a store.  I'm not sure if I failed to read on the site somewhere that these shoes were previously owned or something but if it did, then I'll fix my review.

I only have a couple days left to decide to return/exchange them but I don't even know what size I should order now. Should I assume the next pair will be broken-in and size down or order another of the same size...

My first time ordering shoes from amazon, hooray for first time experiences :\