I gave these a four-star because they fill a bit stiff and I don't know if that will ever break in. I've worn them a dozen times and they still feel that way. I am referring to the soles not bending very much, ... the strap between and over the top is fine. Also, one reason I like these is they have a feature I look for in slip-ons which is some built in arch support.  I've owned other reefs and, while these look very pretty, I prefer a sole that bends more so will enjoy this pair but will not buy another.
Update (more than a year later) These still have their great look but never really 'broke in' so feels like a stiff sole. If they were a little more flexible I'd give them a five stars review as all else is nice.