Overall the boots are very comfortable.  The oxford brown is a rich deep brown that are sometimes hard to find nowadays.  The only problem I had was that the right boot felt larger than the left foot to the extend that I had to put in an insert.  The boots appear to be the same size from the outside though.  Overall they feel a bit larger than the size which is 5 1/2.  I firtst attributed that to the very soft leather which is great for comfort and my rather skinny feet (not narrow, just skinny).  However I also have a pair in black in the same size and they felt true to size. In fact you can see that the brown pair is slightly larger than the black!  Other than the issue with inconsistent sizes these are very nice dress boots especially with slacks.  BTW the delivery was super fast!  I ordered on a Monday and got them on Wednesday which was great!