Living in the Wood River Valley of Idaho means snow, thawing, ice, more snow etc. I have found the ICEtrekkers far superior to the Yak when it comes to walking on ice or ice that is covered with a dusting of snow. The cleats are what make the difference. The Yak Trak tends to skate across the ice or any hard surface which has lead to slips or falls. After searching for alternatives, I bought a pair of ICEtrekkers last winter. I have spent many mornings behind my snow blower and walking our dogs. I am more than satisfied. I bought a pair for my wife to replace her Yak Traks and she also agrees, far superior to Yak Traks.