I really like this boot, but the first pair I had to return because they felt too small. I ordered the next size up, and they feel slightly too large. I am keeping the second pair because I like the boot a lot, but it's a annoying that it's a little too big. Other reviews have mentioned problems with sizing, so mine is not a unique problem with these boots. Also, these were a really popular boot this year, as I noticed a lot of women in my geographical area also own them (NYC metro area).