Just got these boots, size 10, which is what I wear in almost everything I wear.

Initial observations:
- Seem very well made - good value for the money
- Slightly tight in the toe box, but I have this issue with other boots to occasionally
- Dye color of boot is more consistent than in the photos, but sure they will get more worn-in look over time
- I read elsewhere that they are loose in the heel, that is very true for me
- Good looking boot!

Are they keepers?
If I did not have to pay shipping back, I would probably return these, only due to the loose heel, but realize that may be unique to my foot shape. I think I do have a narrow heel.
So, I'll probably keep them.

Have not tested if they are waterproof yet.