I give these boots a top rating because they are really cute, comfortable and durable.  From one of the reviewers I knew ahead of time that the shaft was too short for jeans to tuck in so I was prepared for that issue.  I love the slight pointed toe.  I haven't worn them with leggings so I'm wondering if they'll tuck into those.  I've had lots of compliments on them from my almost adult girls who are picky about boots.  These are one of my favorite pair and that means something coming from the lady that owns 10 pair of boots!  I thought too that the price couldn't be beat.