I think these are probably pretty nice if they fit, but they don't. Background: I am generally a size 7 to 7-1/2, perhaps a 6-1/2 in open-toe shoes and an 8 in athletic wear.

After reading reviews about how these slippers run large, I ordered the 6.5-7.5. They are definitely too small! Have to pay $4.98 to return them. After reading more reviews, I was surprised to see so many varying opinions with regard to size. Just differing opinions or does the sizing actually vary?

Well, I'll either order a clog-style (where fit isn't so critical) or perhaps go to a shoe store, not up to trying for another pair of the same.