I bought these after someone I know recommended them. "They're soooo comfortable!"

Yes. Yes they WERE.

I was loving them when I first received them, thinking they were super comfy and squishy. My only gripe was that the right shoe was a tad shorter than the left, so my heel was flush with the very end of the shoe. At least it fit. They were soooo comfortable!

Then, I remember taking them out for maybe their...4th spin? I walked in them all day and started feeling something under one of my feet. At first I thought some dirt was trapped between my foot and the shoe, but when I got home I saw that the finish (the top layer) had peeled off. I was not impressed, and exchanged them on Amazon for a new pair. Well, I have my new pair, I wear them - but they are no where NEAR as comfortable as that first pair. They are much firmer and not so squishy. However, I think this pair is more even in length. So....final decision? I guess I'm not really sure. I loved how the first pair felt but was sad to see them disintegrate so quickly, and now my second pair is not as comfy but seems to be holding up better. Not sure I'd buy another pair because it seems the quality really varies. Guess it's just an average flip flop after all.

**UPDATE**

Still 3 stars. After some shower shoes failed me on a vacation, I used these in the shower and for walking around. They seemed to dry out enough, which I was grateful for, but I'm tossing them now, because water + yoga mat material = stinky shoes. Guess that second pair held up, which was nice, but the quality variances were too much for me to order yet another pair.