I love these leggings and the feel like they will be more than adequate in the cool fall and winter months in NYC.  I bought them to be able to run out the door in a second and still look 'decent' - throw on a t-shirt or sweater, tunic or baby doll dress and you've got a nice (quirky) look.  I've worn them with my UGG's and with sandals they look really good.  In spite of the worry/concern I had over them being a bit shiny (you know, from the spandex) they aren't!

The price is good - but defo by them through prime as I waited a good week for these to arrive from the Fashion Rack.

I wear a size 8 and I am 5'9" and bought these in medium - they fit perfectly.

---
Edited to add an update!  I purchased them AGAIN - twice!  Yep. We've moved to Germany, Italy and England since I last reviewed but we are back in the US and my other two pairs were starting to look as many years old as they are!  They arrived in two days - are exactly as described and I'm tickled the quality has not disintegrated along with their AA brand!  I hope they stick around - but I think I won't chance it and I am going to stock up!