This is our second pair of these shoes.  The first we got a local store, the second we ordered at amazon as we needed a wide width and the price was better.  My daughter seems to find these shoes comfortable (she's three) and they have never caused any sores or rubbing and have always been worn with tights.  The elastic closure separate from the tie is very helpful.  I had no problems with the seller or the packaging and the shipping was fast as promised.