This is my first pair of boots in general, and I love them. Be careful on the sizing, as they definitely do run big. I wear 10.5 to 11 usually, and I'm sending my 10s back for a 9.5.

The reason I gave 4 stars is that they scuff so incredibly easily. The bottom portion of the shoe is like an eraser to the leather- if you kick one shoe with the other, it's going to leave a massive mark. Be sure to get some saddle soap or something similar.