I thought these boots were so adorable and when they offered such a good deal I had to get them!  I admit, when I got them out of the box I was weary.  They looks way too wide.  I put them on and they look just as cute as I imagined!  I wear between 8.5 and 9 and got the 9. My toe is almost at the tip but I think the 9.5 would have been too big. I live in LA where it doesn't get too cold and not too many rainy days.  I got these for early mornings on the soccer field and I think they are going to be great!

Average arch support, no problem slipping them in and out, not tight in the arch.