I just got these boots yesterday. I normally wear an 8.5 ladies and got the 9. I was worried about all the reviews saying they run 2 sizes small and won't pull on if you have a high instep, but they fit fine!! They are really soft and warm, and I like them in general.
The one thing that I don't like is just how HUGE they are on the outside!! There is a seam where the blue part of the boot connects with the sole, and it sticks out about 1/4 an inch all the way around, adding some serious gerth to your foot and making it seem clownish. I didn't buy powder blue boots to look "normal," so it's not a deal breaker to me, and the price was under thirty bucks, so I'm keeping them. I just wish they weren't quite as big on the outside.