I went with this option because it had good reviews and I liked the combination of the wood with leather accents.

Pros:
- It's quite heavy and substantial.
- Feels well made and quality.
- Solid, sturdy bright silver hinges.
- Opens smoothly and lid stays open easily.
- Good value for money compared to others I priced out.
- Nice finish. No chips or cracks. Seams fit nicely, stitching on leather is well done.
- Pillows are a good size, nestle nicely in the slots and are completely removable.

Neutral:
- Other reviews are right; Color is definitely more red in person. It's not bad but might be surprising if you're expecting it to be more brown.

Cons:
- Despite description saying "glass" it's actually plastic but, that said, it still does look good.
- Leather accents are little more croc print than I realized.

Overall I'm very pleased with it. Taking off one star for the fact it is sold as glass but is actually plastic. It's a gift for my fiance since he's started getting a decent collection of watches and no place to put them. I feel very comfortable presenting it to him and think he will enjoy it.