I never have purchased shoes online, always figured it was something I would want to try first, but this sale came up on these boots and I rolled the dice.  Typical quick shipping by Amazon, which is so common its boring, until things don't ship as expected than I get cranky!  I have never worn boots this high on the leg, over the ankle before, but I loved a pair of Timberlands shoes I bought over 10 years ago (still going, if not strong after a puppy attack at the 7 year point, at least holding on and they are so comfortable I can't bear the idea of getting rid of them), so wanted to give these a try.  They are not too heavy, compared to dedicated hiking boots I own, yet provide pretty firm support for the ankle.  The first day I wore them they were fine till about the 4-5 hour point and than my right leg started hurting right where they leg meets the top of the shoe, not horrible pain, but annoying level pain.  Was worried this would not be a good fit, but figured all decent weight and supportive boots I have ever owned have needed some level or breaking in, so I kept at it.  Another day or two of 5-8 hour each day and the pain was gone, either I got used to the contact or the shoe broke in a bit or both.  Now I can go all day with them without discomfort.  They seem very well made, have not tested the waterproof part and live in pretty warm area so don't know about the warmth factor.  But for wearing all day for work when I am walking around they have been nice, and I bet they get better with age, when someday they will fit "like an old shoe".  Very happy I picked these up on the gold box special. Hope they hold up as well as my last pair of Timberlands.
Pros - Look very nice, comfortable after some break in, light in weight, appear well made.  I wear a size 9 for 80% of shoes, ordered a 9 and they fit fine.
Cons - Mild pain first 2 times I wore (but have never worn boots this high so maybe my acclimation), shoelaces similar to last several boots/shoes I have gotten, they don't seem to adhere to themselves and loosen almost instantly unless I double knot, but this seems typical with these laces these days, not sure why, but it does irritate me.