UPDATE: I originally rated this as 4 stars, but am lowering it just a week later.

The thing is, when I reach into a drawer to get a blanket sleeper for my daughter, I ALWAYS go for carters or something else.  When I see these I just can't put them on.  They are just so stiff and thin compared to the soft plush fleece of other better quality brands.  I finally decided to just pack them up with her too-small clothes - even though these fit her now.  I really hate the thought of putting these on her.

Below is my original review:

--
I've generally avoided Gerber because when I've felt things like onesies in stores, the cotton on Gerber has been stiff and not very soft compared to Carters etc.  It's also generally less expensive, but not by much if you shop sales.

Now that the weather is getting cold, I bought a few warmer sleepers from Carters and babygap - and both on major sales which made them not all that much more expensive than Gerber.  But I needed more warm sleepers, and I figured that fleece is fleece ... so Gerber is probably fine.

I got this 2-pack and the price was great.  But it is DEFINITELY the case that the quality is not up to par.  The fleece is thin and not as soft as what I expect from baby blanket sleepers.  Some of the other sleepers I got my daughter are ones I'd love to crawl into myself.  That's not the case with these.  I mean, they are definitely fine - this isn't a negative review.  It's just that they aren't that super soft quality I look for in baby clothes.

Pros: Nice bright colors
Cons: Stiffer fleece than other brands

Conclusion:  These are ok if you are on a very tight budget or just need some emergency backups.  If you can afford to spend a little more, scout out the various sales and get some of the higher quality brands.  They are definitely much softer.

I will probably stuff one of these in my diaper bag.  I kept a cute footie in my diaper bag, where it sat unused for a couple of months and then my daughter outgrew it.  So now diaper bag emergency outfits are ones that I won't care if she never wears.  And that's where these go.