These shoes are light weight, and leather, so for someone with a narrow foot they would be very good. For that I would give it 5 stars.
We bought them because my daughter has a wide foot and these are available in wide sizes. She measures for a size 5 on the charts, so we ordered a 6W. The length was just a little too long, but that would have been acceptable. It is not by any stretch of the imagination a wide shoe. We tried multiple strategies to stretch the forefoot (rendering it unreturnable of course) but did not succeed in widening it enough to make it wearable for her. For us I would give it 0 stars.