I knew I wanted boots, but just couldn't find a pair that spoke to me.  These were too girly, those were too tough, those were beautiful quality but boring styling, these were really cool but complete junk - and then I found THESE boots!  For me, a perfect balance: tall and slender for femininity, weathered leather, buckles and low heel for slight edge.  In terms of fit: I found them comfortable right out of the box, despite minimal cushioning in footbed.  They are definitely long but narrow in the toe box.  If I had a narrow foot I'd go at least a 1/2 size down, but I'm a "full-footed gal," so these work, with no slippage.  They do look kind of bigger than normal to me on, but since I have small feet (6) that's not a problem.  Because of the elasticized back the calf fits well over tights, leggings, and jeans, always looking snug without feeling tight.  The leather quality is good, not great - Frye's they ain't, but neither are they Rocket Dog.  The ankle has sagged but I still like the look and the top does touch the inside of my knee when I sit, but it doesn't bother me.  They did smell chemically and weird at first - I couldn't sleep in the same room with them! - but that wore off within a week or so.  All the cons are worth it for the look and comfort, though.  Bottom line: I love them!