I purchased the normal width like I normally do, but the toe area just didn't feel right.  I could tell that with any amount of walking, it would become uncomfortable.  I'm always leary to purchase any non leather shoes anyway since they are sure not to stretch...but definitely didn't want to take the chance if I could already feel them against my toes.  I returned them and tried the wide width and they fit great!  I was afraid the wide width would be too wide everywhere else and look or feel off, but they weren't much larger than the regular...just enough to feel comfortable in the toe.  They are very cute in the croc and I'm glad I tried the wider width!