These boots are stunning in person.  The leather is great quality, the fit (for me) was great in the shoe box and the calf.  My problem was that the boot shaft is far too long for anyone 5'3 and under.  The shaft came up past my mid-knee, causing my knee cap to be pushed on uncomfortably while taking normal strides.  I love the boots but unfortunately had to return them due to the knee issues.  The shaft is 18.5in from the arch; anyone as short as I am will probably want boots 18 and under.