I ordered cognac in my regular size. The product photo shows a smooth leather shoe but mine are nubuck and they look more like taupe. The toes are also smoothed over as if with wear and one shoe's heel is scuffed, which makes me think these were a return. Still, I like the style so I tried them on. I am tired of wearing my Sketcher's mary janes and these are a very nice change. They are comfortable when walking on hard floors. The buckles are a classic touch. Because they are not like the photo, I gave them 4 stars.