I ordered these for my wife.  For the quality of the boot in terms of materials and workmanship, the price is very good.  My wife has a wide foot and she was happy with the fit and said the cushion insole was the best she has ever felt.  There was also enough room in the shaft to tuck in jeans without compromising the fit, yet they are not so big that they looked oversized when worn over bare legs.  In the end, though, it was the overall style that made her choose to send them back.

These are not ugly boots, in my opinion.  The style is cute.  The chocolate color is nice compared to others.  I will say this:  If you care about how your legs look from the back, these are not the boots for you.  The design is clever in accommodating larger calves, but it is not the most attractive.