Ordered this boot in black. Okay rain boot. Upper shaft of boot is very stiff. Hurts the back of my leg when laced, so I usually lace very loosely or not at all. (Upper is slightly softening up after wearing a few times, but still too stiff on back of my leg.)  Not much arch support, barely roomy enough to put arch support insole inside. Width was okay, but a little tight in the bunion/ball of the foot area. Boot runs a little small lengthwise, ordered 1/2-1 size larger.  Otherwise, okay.  UPDATE:  Walked the dog about half a mile in steady, but not pouring, rain.  Boots are not 100% waterproof, even when laced snugly.  My feet got a little wet, not terrible, still better than shoes, but a rain boot should keep your feet DRY!