I am kind of an odd size and have always had trouble finding comfortable underwear. Never briefs because the ribbing is usually tight around my thighs. Never boxers because the butt is usually too long and too tapered. My waist is a true 34, but I have rather broad thighs and a shapely butt. I also have a rather long torso and hobbit legs, which has always made shopping for pants/underwear difficult. If you are one of those guys who often has to buy pants an inch or two larger in the waist in order to feel comfortable in the leg then you understand exactly how I feel. I ordered a medium and they fit like a dream. Not tight, but not at all loose either. Exactly what I have been trying for years to find. Unfortunately I hate elastic waistbands, which is why I have been avoiding trying these. The waist could be more comfortable, but the elastic is not tight either. Everything seems to fit perfectly. The only reason I gave 4 stars instead of 5 is because I am also quite hairy and these underwear have a tendency to catch and pull on hairs as I walk. I still think they are one of the best pairs I have worn in a long time and have ordered more. Need to come in different colors though.