The shoes fit true to size for me.  I like the extra room in the toe box.  They are big, boxy shoes as shown in the photographs but at least they are comfortable.  I'm wearing them for a round trip commute and a full work day with lots of walking around and these shoes are good for both.  If you are reading this then you probably know there are very few workable options for cleat compatible shoes with all day walking comfort.  These are the best I found.

A hint about pedals to use with these shoes:  First I tried the usual Shimano type cleats and pedals.  The cleats stood just a touch proud of the bottom of the tread, causing the shoes to "click" on hard floors as I walked, leaving marks in the floor.  Since I have marble and hardwood floors in my house that was not going to work.  Also, my old Shimano pedals have a generous platform (sorry, they are 10 years old and I don't know the model type) and it was nearly impossible to click into the pedals with these shoes.  I switched to crank brothers style pedals, the Candy in this case.  The Crank Bros pedals have a smaller cleat that does not extend outside the rubber of the shoe and does not scratch up the floors.  The Candy have a small platform but I can still click in fine with these shoes.

One minor quibble, the tread pattern on these shoes is a relatively fine grid.  They seem to pick up mud and never let it go.  Only the most energetic door mat scuffing will knock enough loose to allow you to walk on carpet without leaving a trail of muddy footsteps.

Room for improvement?  A chunkier tread to release mud more easily and a darker color option.  Otherwise buy these shoes.  I'll give them 5 stars despite these small points.