These are rugged boots and should soften in time and use.  Good balance and insulated while you wear them.  I purchased my regular size and it fits snug - though I can't wear wool socks in them.  If your feet feel claustrophobic in tight (but not uncomfortable) boots, I would recommend a half size bigger.  One note to the seller... Please make sure you wrap something to cover the box.  All you did was wrap the boot box with plastic, with "Georgia Boots" clearly visible.  Not a good shipping practice, for obvious reasons.