I liked these so much despite the reviews, I ordered them anyway.  This must have been one of those rare times that the reviews didn't apply.  I found these comfortable, didn't slip off my heels.  I must say the toe bed is just a tad snug but I think once I wear them they'll be fine.  I am happy with my pumps, I'm not one to wear sky high heels so the heel height was perfect for me, and they're quite sharp looking.  I'm pleased with my purchase!