I love these boots!  My feet stay warm and dry and they are great looking with my jeans.  I find them very comfortable for long wearing, however, I have to put a pair of boot socks over my regular socks to fill the foot bed.  To get my foot past the ankle bend, I have to tug.  Once past the ankle bend, the foot bed runs a bit larger than the size should.  That's the reason for a 4 star rating vs. a 5 star.