These boots WILL keep you dry and warm. They have a leg hugging liner that seems made of the same stuff used for wet suits, and this prevents anything from spilling inside. The shaft is really tall, and I like how much they protect my lower legs as well as my feet. I definitely don't consider them inside boots by any means--they look like they're made for a barnyard, and I've tested them in that kind of setting and they're tops for that. The down side, for me anyway, is that they're difficult to take off due to the tightness of the lining, and they are difficult to walk in because the rubber is so heavy and inflexible at the ankles. I have really big calves, though, and am happy they fit at all. Also, the heavy tread on the bottom DOES make it easier to walk on the ice, but also holds onto mud and muck more than some reviewers state. I hose them off, but still a stray clod of something always manages to come inside with me.

These are the best boots imaginable for horrible outdoor conditions where you don't want to worry about them coming off in deep mud, or snow and ice falling inside, or your feet beginning to freeze as you tote bales of hay around the stable. They aren't for miles long hikes even though they do have decent arch support. As far as looks go, they are plug ugly. No getting around it. I would never wear them with a skirt, or even in a casual "lets go to the movies" scenario. That's just NOT what they do! I love them for what they are: utilitarian footwear. They are an essential tool for negotiating tough Midwest winters, as much as decent gloves and a warm coat. I purchased these happily from Amazon at an amazing price and quick delivery.