I absolutely love these boots! They look expensive and they are definitely comfy.  I ordered a 1/2 size up from 8.5 to a 9 because the reviews said that were a bit narrow.  They weren't too narrow for my feet though and I think that they fit true to size because the 9 was a bit big for me seeing as I tried the shoes on with stockings.  However, if you plan on wearing thick socks with them then I'd definitely go the 1/2 size up.  So I'm going to keep the 9.  A great buy guys..... I just received them 2 days ago and they have become my go to boot already (no breaking in required) and the compliments I've received make me feel like I made a great choice.