These are very stylish and nice looking boots.

Positives:
Comfortable
True to size
Initial finish seems good and leather seems to be good quality
Does not scuff easily
Basic cedar shoe trees fit in easily

Negatives:
Finish on rubber sole wears away quickly
Laces with shoe are not very good, will need to buy a new set

Comments:
The comments on these shoes being slippery out of the box is true. They are, but that goes away after walking in them the first day or two. I wouldn't describe it as a huge issue.