If I could still get good kids mocs from lands end or llbean I would give these three stars by comparison. But these seem to be the best available, durable shoe for girls that isn't a silly mary Jane style (which gets snow in it). These are nicely made and fit pretty well. I wish they were available in wide. The flower stitching is a nice touch and the colors are good.
But they stink!  The lable says they are treated with anti-bacterial chemicals to prevent odor (ironic).  I don't like that and wish it had been disclosed in the description. I don't know if it's the chemicals or just the plastics, but the shoes have a strong chemical odor. They are outside off gassing right now, and I trust the smell will fade, but I don't want my kids breathing whatever it is.
Offer them in wide and ease up on the chemical residue and this would be they perfect shoe.