I have owned many boots, even Fryes, which I love, but these are my all time favorite boots.  I can wear them with anything rain or shine.  I wear mine with skirts, skinny jeans, leggings, etc.  I have never treated these boots, and they still look great after 3 years. I get tons of compliments on them all the time.  I am ordering a new pair now as I the treads are wearing down at the ball of my foot but that is just because I wear them ALL the time. These are high quality, practical and I love that they are a little edgy but still go w/ everything.  I do have skinny calves and I feel they fit true to size.  However, they do have a narrow shaft and may not fit if you have larger calves.  For me, I absolutlely love them and am very happy with the fit and wear.  They are one of the best boots I've ever owned.