I've been on the hunt for a high heel dark brown peep-toe pump in a size 11 for about 2 years. Do you have any idea how hard this exact set of requirements are to find? Well, a couple of months ago, I did one of my periodic searches to see if this magic unicorn of a shoe had finally surfaced on the Web. In no time, I found them here on Amazon. And they were under $100 too! I thought I had struck gold. Imagine when I received them and saw how sturdy and well made and BEAUTIFUL these shoes were.

Now imagine me trying them on and realizing they were - too tight.

You should know, I really wear a 10.5. But that size is so hard to find in a stylish shoe that I just wear an 11. And frankly after an all day session, it's just better if your shoe has a little more room than less. But I decided to wear these Heidi Klum shoes thinking they were going to stretch. I shouldn't have because after almost ten wears, I feel like I am even more aware of the tightness each time I wear them. So while I'm disappointed that this shoe is not true to size, if you simply go a size up from what you usually wear I bet you'll be THRILLED with these shoes.