I hedged for several days before buying these boots due to the cost. I have a larger foot, so buying shoes can get tricky. Usually a 12, I purchased the 11M and hoped for the best. I'm glad I gave these boots a shot, because not only do they fit my big foot, but they're some of the most comfortable shoes I own! I love the style and color (chocolate/walnut) and the sole has enough tread and is thick enough to keep me from sliding on ice. I would recommend that ladies with larger calves consider going a size up; I have muscular calves and the top of the boot is pretty snug. However, now that I've been wearing them for a few days, the leather is stretching a bit and seems to be fitting better now.

All in all, a great boot whose benefits definitely outweigh the (minuscule) flaws. One of my best Amazon purchases, and I make a lot!