This ring was chosen by my husband as a replacement wedding ring when he lost his at swim practice. He loves Celtic knots and chose this design over the other Celtic design rings. This ring is definitely substantial. Not cheap in look or feel. The metal is much darker than in the picture. More a pencil lead color.  Correspondingly the engraving is more difficult to see, but is visible upon closer inspection. If you want the design of your ring to be obvious, don't do any laser etching. Go for inlay or grooves. The best feature of this ring is the comfort band. IT IS COMFORTABLE! He keeps commenting on how comfortable it is compared to other rings he has worn. I, too, wear a comfort band ring and it simply feels better than a standard band!  Overall, comfort is the stand out feature of this ring. 3 stars for looks because the etching is subtle. 5 stars for comfort. Thus, 4 stars overall.