I ordered these because they are waterproof and had a larger calf opening.  I love the dark brown color, and the style.  The leather at the top of the boot is nice and soft, and they have a hard, structured toe box.  I am disappointed at how sloppy they feel on my feet.  I ordered these in 9W, am normally an 8.5/9.  My other Timberland boots are 9.5 W and are a tad too long, but I don't like having my toes smashed.  Also, I always order half to full size larger and wides so I can put my own insoles in them for more comfort and to accomodate for a small bunion.  These, with 3/4 length insoles in them, squish the top of my foot just a tad, but have way too much room in the ankle area. I'm hoping that since they are leather they will stretch around the top of my foot.  Adding the insoles helped a little with how sloppy they are, but still slip on my foot when I walk.  They have very minimal padding in the bottom, definitely wouldn't attempt standing or walking long distances without my own insoles in them.  But, they are one of the very few cute, waterproof, and wide width boots that also fit my muscular 16" calves. They fit very well around my calves and would easily accomodate wider calves because of the elastic panel that goes from about 2 inches above my ankle to the top of the boot. I will be able to wear these over leggings or skinny jeans with no problems.  So I'll keep them since I do live in a climate where we have wet springs and falls and get snow as early as October and stays as late as April, and need some fashionable waterproof boots that don't hinder my driving while running around town. I really wanted them to be the perfect boot so I could order them in the light brown color too, but the sloppy, non fitted ankle has told me to hold off, break these in, and see how much it really bothers me.