These are really lovely boots. I got the "Smoke" in an 8.5 (I am usually an 8 but prefer a larger fit in boots so I can wear insoles and thick socks). The 8.5 fit (Although they are on the larger side) and the colour is gorgeous. I actually loved them so much I managed to find an 8 in the "Burnt red" - and ordered those too! They are a better fit still lots of room- in fact they are definately a larger fit so you could stick to your true size or perhaps go 1/2 a size down! The smoke is a classic brown colour (not the usual reddish tinge) and the red is a lovely deeper blue/red - not at all orangey! Gorgeous with jeans (They still fit well and aren't too tight on the calves)or with skirts and dresses, so very versatile. Both my pairs have evenly matched heels - so no complaints there! They are fully lined with leather inside the shaft too... Great quality - I would definitely recommend!