Pros - These boots look good.  The Sweater part at the top is snug around your leg so no snow can fall down into your boot.  The rubber soles seam like they have good traction.  These boots are partially made from recycled materials.
Cons - They are not knee high, maybe on a shorter person.  I bought the 8 1/2 and they come just above my calf and I am 5'7.  The boots are very thin.  They don't seem to be very insulated.  I bought these out of season and have not tried them in the snow yet, but I am skeptical they will be warm enough. They are snug and won't be able to fit thermal socks in.  Hopefully my feet will at least be dry.
If you are short and are looking for cute, light- weight boots for a climate that does not get a lot of snow, these are for you.  I would never pay full price for these.  I can't even imagine why they cost as much as they do.  They don't seem like superior quality - made in china.  My advice is save the money you would have spent on these and get a better pair of boots.