I almost gave four stars but for the price of these (even on sale) I'm disappointed in the fit so I'm going with three.  These flip flops are cute and fairly comfortable but the strap that goes over the foot is snug and this is not usually an issue with me when I try on flip flops.  After wearing them around the house over the weekend,  they're beginning to loosen up so I decided to take a chance and keep them.  I do like the fact that there's plenty of cushioning at the heels and balls of my feet and the Nubuk fabric is soft.

 Update:  After about a month of wearing these shoes the strap that was tight loosened up and they are really comfortable.  I now own several pairs of Fitflop sandals because they are so comfortable.  I still think they are pricey so I try to wait form them to go on sale before I buy them.