Bought these for my daughter. Tried the Nomad Puddles first but they run really big. She and I wear a 7 1/2 so I got the 8 and it was way too big. The colors were great with the Puddles but unwearable. Read the reviews and most said the Sloggers were true to size. So I ordered the 8 and they fit perfectly. Love that they are American made. Some reviewers had a problem with the 2 boots not being exactly the same. Well that happens when you have a full decor. I think it's lovely. As a matter of fact I may bet the lighter color as an additional gift for my daughter.