Like many other reviewers here, I finally caved after hearing so much about the amazing Frye boots.  They are everything as promised: solid, handmade boots with real soles that really will be comfortable, as well as keeping your feet warm and dry, and lasting forever if you take care of them.

I ordered my normal size in boots (8.5), and found them to fit perfectly with my normal socks.  I will say that they're a little sticky to get into the first few times, because the back of the heel, and the arch on top of the foot are a little tight (but this changes with time) - so be aware that they may feel tight the first few times, but that doesn't necessarily mean that you have the wrong size.

These require some breaking in.  I would recommend going on a few long walks or walking around the house with thick socks on to get the heels and arch to conform to your foot, otherwise you may end up with some initial blisters on your heel.  Once this is done though - ultimate comfort!  Amazing arch and heel support, good grip around the ankle, and no sliding inside the boot.