My wife and I have both returned our original orders. I am a size 7, she is a 5. They were too small for our fingers. I got a 7.5 and it fits like a 7. She is sending her's back today to get a size 5.5. She originally got a 6 on accident thanks to Amazon's website. Other than that, they look great. I've already gotten a compliment on it. We are a little dismayed by the sizing issue as we have been married for a month now and I just got my ring, but my wife hasn't. I think it is fair to say it is both our fault and the seller's. They did contact me when I returned mine to tell me they could help me size it correct and did acknowledge their rings don't follow the standard sizing rules. I would buy from them again, if I was a jewelry person anyway. One more thing, they have some nickel in the coating which we are allergic too. Our fingers were a tiny bit red when we first put them on, but that didn't last to the next day.