I read the reviews and decided to order in spite of the negative comments; I'm glad I did.  The bag I received looks exactly like the bag in the picture.  As far as the smell, it reminds me of a saddle.  I suppose anyone unfamiliar with different types of leather may consider the smell somewhat "musty", but it smells like leather to me.  Also, there is plenty of room for a cell phone, checkbook, small notebook and glasses; perfect for garage saling, frees both hands! No complaints here, I'm happy with my purchase, and would recommend to a friend.