I really liked the shoes - very cute and the charcoal is a great color that can pair well with just about anything. The problem for me was that one shoe was quite comfortable and the other was really narrow near the toes and I have narrow feet. One was also much tighter near the ankle than the other and just fit weirdly. I could have asked for a replacement but decided that I need to just buy shoes in person to avoid this problem.

I kept the rating high at 4 stars though because the shoes were 1) very good looking, 2) very good price, and 3) at least one of the shoes was comfortable. I wish that they had fit!