I have been a big fan of the Montrail shoes over the years but have found them to run fairly narrow in size.  This shoe is no exception... even though it appears to have a wider than normal toe box I find it still somewhat restricted.  Wearing the shoes gives me a less than soft foot strike. Also the removable insoles are really not much.  I know the shoe manufacturers cut costs in this area so you should expect to buy some aftermarket insole replacements for the shoes if you plan to really use them for running.  I would rate this shoe with a lot of other trail running shoes in the $35-40 range.  I am tempted to return them but it may be cost prohibitive due to return shipping costs... Will use them for knock arounds.  Your mileage may vary.