Although I would never disagree with Nancy Drew over a mystery, I must say I had a different experience with these sandals.  I find them very comfortable and stylish.  I bought the green with brown top, and they look fantastic with shorts or jeans--I have a narrow foot and these really look nice on.  I'm between a 9 and 9/12 in size and ordered these in size 40 and they fit perfectly.  I ordered the same thing yesterday in the blue and white.  They are a great buy and I will finish the season and save them for next year.  El Naturalista makes some great shoes.