The color and midcalf height of the boot were satisfactory however the quality was not as expected which is reflected in the low price of the item.  Size 9 boot length was very short. Size 10 would be too large. Sole appears glued and would not offer enough traction protection for the snow and ice.  The stitching along the seams were not the best quality and may not withstand the entire winter season. Although these boots appeared comfortable indoors, we are preparing for the cold weather so I don't believe they would offer much warmth outdoors in the cold NY snow. I recommend Bearpaw reinforce the stitching, improve sole traction and resize the boot for a more accurate fit.  Boots were immediately returned to the manufacturer through Amazon.