Likes:

The watch band was very soft, didn't chafe against skin, and was flexible (not stiff) making this watch feel comfortable enough to wear for a long period of time.  The size and weight of the watch and face was fine; it didn't feel too heavy on the wrist.  It looks nice and being water proof is a big plus.  It is nice enough to wear with your suit, but not too fancy for jeans and a polo.  The band is well-made, well-stitched solid leather.  The box it came in was also very nice and I mention it only because the presentation of the watch in its box just echoed the quality of the product itself.

Also a plus is the two-stage time adjustment.  Pulling out the adjuster one click changes the date; two clicks changes the time. A lot of watches have this, but having another watch that doesn't makes this a good feature to my husband. Note that the watch changes the date when you've passed 12 twice, so be sure to change the date right after an automatic roll over or you risk being off half a day.

Dislikes:

The numbers are very big. It would be great for someone who is visually impaired. This is a style issue (maybe that's just not my husband's style) and will not be a negative for everyone.

It has no light, which is a con because you can't tell what time it is, except during the day or in good light.  So wearing the watch to a presentation given in the dark means you can't read your watch to know what time it is. This is a bigger issue than number size, because this makes the watch non-functional in certain circumstances.