For costume purposes, this petticoat will work just fine. I was hesitant at first because some of the other reviews stated it fit a bit small. I am a size 10 and wasn't wanting the muffin top effect due to the band fitting too tightly. It is stretchy but yes, a bit tighter than I prefer- but for a one night Halloween party- I will make this work. The polka dots are a cute touch- can't see them really from far away. The tulle is scrunched up but with some adjustments is straightens out.