Out the box these appeared extremely wide. They look more like gardening boots than rain boots. I was pleased after trying them on. FYI: The handles are functional to pull them on. A nice and unusual alternative from my tall rain boots. To my surprise these kept my toes warm during New York City snowfall. And the floral pattern adds to the charm. They are comfortable. As a 8.5 I ordered the size 9 in Black/Olive combo. Although these felt a half size small, they worked for me.