I'm giving these two stars because I think that if I had received a good one it would have been a really cool thing to own.  The first one I received worked well and the body was very nice, but the face of the watch had been significantly mis-cut and so everything was noticeably off to one side.  I debated keeping it because I bought it mostly for the novelty of the skeleton style and it kept good time.  I decided I'd just return it and get another one, but the second was significantly worse.  it failed to keep time, I'd wind it in the morning and it would be off 15-30 min by the end of the work day.  The case was noticeably banged up. The face was still off, though not to the same degree as the first, maybe half as much.  Anyway, I'm returning it and I'll wait until I can get a nicer mechanical pocket-watch.

I actually think that the issue is just poor quality control, and since there's free return shipping I would say that if you order one and it keeps time and looks good then keep it. Just make sure that you check it for accuracy and look for obvious defects.  If this is your kind of thing then it is a pretty cool watch, maybe I just got a couple of bad ones.