I tried the black leather in the store, it was a nice fit, so I bought 4, but not the leather, I bought various colors in suede. I wear heels all the time and have several JS shoes. The suede fits 1/2 size small, I could barely get 4 hrs out of them, and I wear my 4 inch heels 10-12 hrs per day, 5 days a week. There was toe cleavage, which I didn't like and they hurt my feet. Ill be returning the 3 I didn't wear yet. Disappointed. I don't even care to try 1/2 size up. They will probably be too big. Cant be bothered!