Nice boots, not clunky, very comfortable, but not warm at all. I wear 7.5, ordered 8.5 per reviews and because I wear thick wool socks in winter. An 8 might have fit also but I would have put in liners and been happy had these been warm boots. They are rated to -25 but would not keep my feet warm when I took off my Uggs to try them on in the house! I am returning them because I want warm feet.