I ordered a pair for my son and husband.  Both love them.  I had to send both pair to my son in Virginia because oddly, Amazon won't send this product directly to an APO address (only complaint I have).  My son first thought they were a bit narrow, but on second wearing, they felt very comfortable and now he wears them daily.  He normally wears an 8 1/2 or 9 and the 9 fits well.

My husband's experience was the same.  He broke a toe 15 years ago which makes finding a comfortable shoe difficult.  Initially, the shoes were tight and he took them off after only a couple hours.  But, he wore them the next day and they stretched out perfectly.  He spent 3 hours washing cars in December cool temperatures and they passed the test.  Comfortable and water proof.  His normal size 11 fit perfectly.  He wears them each weekend and they'll be perfect walking in city snow and water in January.

Based on this experience, you can't go wrong with these shoes for day to day city wear and dress down days at work during Fall/Spring/Winter months.  The added benefit: they look great.