I will be returning these. Honestly I'm not sure why more people haven't mentioned this - I ordered the Tan Paris pair and the finish on the 'leather' is SO fake-looking! The weathering/spotted fading look just makes them scream fake leather. I don't need real leather boots by any stretch, but they ones I keep must as least possibly pass for leather. These will not, except at a long distance. I'm bummed to be returning them, as the design is super-cute. They fit my large calves, which is awesome. Maybe slightly larger than your shoe size but not problematic. Would be wonderful except for the finish. As a friend said: "if those cost $20, they'd be great. But not for $80!"