I bought these boots to replace rubber knee boots for bowhunting and am happy with them.  The boots fit well, feel true to size and are comfortable for walking around the woods.  A pair of quality medium to heavy-weight boot socks provided good fit.  My rubber knee boots w/ 1200g thinsulate did not fit well, were not comfortable for walking and were no warmer.

The boots arrived on time and included Kenetrek boot dressing to waterproof/condition the leather.  The rubber,leather and leather conditioner all seem to be relatively scent free.  I've had deer downwind of me on several occasions with no visible reactions so I know the boots don't stink. The soles provide good traction.  My only tweak would be to have the heel 1/8" to 3/16" taller but that's just personal preference.  All-in-all, a quality boot with great fit and function.

One previous review noted moisture build-up in the boots.  Since feet sweat in any weather and rubber doesn't breathe, it is important to remove the liners, preferably every night, to allow them to dry.  Damp boots/liners will cause cold feet in cooler temps, regardless of the socks, if you're sitting still for any amount of time.  If possible, place the boots themselves on a boot dryer with the liners near a heat duct and they will be dry next day.

I have done a few all-day treestand sits in temps from 20 - 40 deg. F and noted cold coming up through the soles.  I've tried 2 remedies, air activated toe warmers and an additional wool felt insole between the boot and the liner.  The toe warmers worked well and as anticipated, with my toes never being cold or warm.  The additional insole snugged up the fit but not excessively, however the tighter fit may cause problems if walking all day.  I am going to try a thinner insole between the boot and liner to see what effect that has. I am also going to try a thicker wool felt liner and see if that helps.  In colder temps (under 20 deg F) a combination of both measures may be needed.

Pros - good fit, comfortable, good foot & ankle support, odor free, good traction with K-talon soles, quality construction.

Cons - not as warm as I'd hoped, cold came up through the soles, mud sticks in the tread but comes out easily when dry.