So it took me awhile to decide to keep these boots as they were a bit snug in the width, but not tight in length.  I walked around the house in them an hour or so for several days -and they loosened up perfectly, molding to my feet.  Ive worn these out about 3 times now, and today when I got home I didn't bother taking them off  - thats how comfortable they are.  For me they were true to size.  If foot width is an issue for you, Id suggest going with the wider width, tho mine did stretch out width-wise to perfection.  I can wear them with tights and skirts - or skinny jeans - both look great.  The ties make them totally adjustable to accommodate both.  I really like the bottom of the boot -they look like a hiking boot - making them great for all winter conditions, no slipping! But don't discount them because of the sole - these boots are beautiful enough for a night out on the town!  They are edgy combat boots with a feminine tailored feel!  I'm really happy I got them.  As far as quality goes - while they are not up to par with my expensive Frye boots, for the money, these are a deal!