I've been wearing this coat for about 2 weeks now. My reasons for giving it four stars:

1. It's a cute and flattering A-line shaped coat-- I've gotten a lot of compliments on the style and color (camel).
2. It is narrow through the shoulders. I have narrow shoulders and many coats look sloppy with too much fabric around the shoulders. This coat fits well without being too tight through the shoulders.
3. It was a bit tight through the chest area so I simply moved the chest area buttons a bit closer to the edge of the coat and this fixed the issue. (C/D cup)
4. The waist is comfortable in proportion to the shoulders and the tie belt ensures a good fit.

5. The only issue is this coat is faux wool so not terribly warm, hence the four stars. Okay for my climate which doesn't get much colder than the 20s but if  your climate hovers around zero you might not stay warm enough. On the other hand, faux wool will not shrink up over time as real wool does so I expect this coat to retain its size.

I have a curvy figure and the proportions of this coat work really well, narrow in the shoulders and waist, with more room in the behind/hips due to the pleats and flare of the hem.  You might need to move the buttons if you are bigger in the chest but this is a minor fix.