I really like this boot out of the box and, but am not impressed with the finish on the leather.  After wearing only a few times, there are some scratches into the leather finish (ankle and toe area)from normal wear.  The boots are a light brown color with a medium dark distress finish.  Unfortunately, the scratches reveal a very light tan leather color underneath the finish and are very noticeable.  Buffing helps only slightly.
The fit is great - I ordered a half size up - just like I do with all boots.  I have a wide toe area and narrow ankles - and the boots fit very well. There is plenty of room at the calf also.  I am 5' tall and the boot-top is about 2 inches below mid calf.

UPDATE - After one year - I upped the rating to 4, almost 5- These boots are so comfortable that I have gotten over the scuff issue.  They now just look like comfy boots should look - well & often-worn.  They have held up well after being worn for 8+ hours a day and 3-4 days a week this past year.  IF I were to lose these I would be heartbroken.