I so badly wanted to love these boots!  I tried 3 different sizes hoping I would find the right fit.  They are extremely heavy and simply not comfortable.  The shaft seems too big around the calf.  The heel is way to wide and causes lots of blisters (in 3 different sizes).  They are really difficult to get on and off.  The only thing I like about the boots is the way they look.  But, that depends on the color.  Some are far superior than others.  I love the distressed look b/c otherwise they scratch easily and just look damaged.  I have given them a good shot.  I have worn each pair for over 6 months and I do not feel they "break-in" or begin to feel better with time.  I do have a narrow foot so perhaps that contributes to the ill fit.  However, if it were only one issue I would totally love the boots.  However, with all of the problems I hate to say these boots simply do not live up to all the hype.  Very disappointed!