First I want to say that I love these boots. Second don't listen to the reviews that say that they run small...my shoe size is a 7 1/2 but I ordered an 8 because everyone said they run pretty tight. But I have them and I have to wear double socks with them which is not too much of an inconvience. I did buy an insole which helped a bit. Besides that I constantly get nice compliments about my "sweater" boots. They are very warm and extra comfy. Perfect with my skinny jeans or any boots that are a little loose at the bottoms otherwise if you try to wear them underneath your jeans and they're too tight they'll make your jeans bunch up. Also I've worn these boots in snow and they haven't got wet. I wouldn't suggest water since they are cloth material. The good thing about the boots is that they have a really good thick rubber sole. Overall I would recommend these boots. Hope my review has helped.