This is a really nice flat on paper, rather than in practice. Online, these appeared to be very sturdy and structured, however, this is often not the case. I own these in natural, which is a true to color. It is a very nice nude color and goes perfectly with other neutral tones.

However, the fit and construction of this flat leave a lot to be desired. These are not very solid.  I'm a size 7, but got these in a 7.5 because I feared they'd be too small and would have to be sent back. Well, the 7.5 is not exactly a perfect fit. The shoe is quite loose in the sides, but there is enough room for my toes. The elastic heel is actually a lot looser than I expected. Although the shoes stay on my feet, the elastic heel is a little bit uncomfortable, consider that the shoe is half a size bigger than my usual size. Lastly, this shoe is FLAT. You literally feel everything underneath your feet! The sole too thin, even for ballet flats. My advice would be to buy insoles to put in the shoes because these are not meant for long walks. 3.5 stars.

UPDATE: 9 March. I just received these in black (from Amazon) in my true size 7. I tried them on one foot with the 7.5 (from another online store) and the other 7. Definitely order half a size up because the size 7 barely fit and wasn't very comfortable. I sent the size 7 back and reordered a size 7.5.

UPDATE 23 JULY 2013: I still own both the black and neutral flats. I'm actually really satisfied with both pairs of shoes. These need to be broken in, so they will (unfortunately) be a little bit uncomfortable for the first couple of wears. I wear both pairs of shoes often and would highly recommend them. I'll give these 4 stars.