I bought these boots to replace a previous pair of cognac colored boots that I adored.  The sienna color that I ordered was a bit darker than what I was expecting and there were some slight marks on the leather however I did not mind too much since I was going to mark them from basic wear anyways. They fit great and I can wear either a 7.5 or 8 but the 7.5 fit fine. Very comfortable and the heel is not too high and they are not tight around my calves.  I would recommend these boots.