I have never had a pair of really nice boots... I wanted some for this coming winter, and I cannot be more pleased with them. I have always heard Timberland makes some of the best boots, and this seems true to me. I have only had them for several days now, and they are already extremely comfortable. I wear a size 14, and got the wide. They are perfect. They are nice and tight and do not slide around on my feet. There is also just the perfect amount of space that I can wear thicker socks if I want to. I am not sure about other people saying they run too large, because I always wear a size 14 and they are great. The leather is nice and thick and the stitching is done very well. I am extremely pleased, and am glad I have a nice pair of boots that are waterproof for the winter. They seem like they are going to last me a long time!