I read many of the reviews for this charm. I will say that I don't agree with those who gave it only a few stars. We all know that starfish have been renamed sea stars! It is a beautiful charm with detail. Much like real Sea Stars which I have collected in New Jersey, Maine and Hawaii, the charm is a great replica. My son and his girlfriend bought me a bracelet and two charms for my birthday. And I have been very careful to add one charm at a time. I currently have 8 charms and each one represents something very special to me and has a story. This sterling silver starfish is a perfect size and fits perfectly on my bracelet! It's a great find at a great price!