I paid attention to previous reviews and ordered a half size down from my normal size and the fit is perfect.  The quality of this boot is fantastic with leather lining the shank.  I bought the distressed black which, to me, looks a little too brown, but easy enough to polish up if you want them to look more black.  I agree the bottom is a bit slick but nothing a little twist on some concrete won't take care of.  The first time I wore them they felt like my favorite pair of Frye boots and the compliments I got!!!  I am admittedly a bootaholic; these are my new favorites by a long stretch.  Buy them!  Don't hesitate!  Best boot deal I've ever gotten.