I gave a 3 star for overall good quality but with issue.

Good looking bag, nice packaging like a high-end product should be. Leather is soft and of good quality. BUT the oil finishing coating does rub off...I rubbed the surface with a white tissue to see if the color rubs off after I saw another review addressing this issue - IT DOES!  So beware if you wear this on light clothing, as it will stain your clothing if you wear it frequent. I ordered the black one, so I can not speak for other color if they rub off or not. Bottom line, if you wear jeans or dark color clothing, you're probably OK, but you might have an issue if you wear light color clothing. Not sure if the stained on the clothing can be washed off either.