I was nervous to order this boot due to the sizing. I am a classic 10.5 which no one makes, so I usually buy an 11, which isn't an option. However, I fell in love with the classic styling and risked ordering a size 10. I am glad I did! I ordered the brown leather which is a beautiful shade of brown and the leather is very soft yet still structured. I have normal to thin sized calves and find some boots are too baggy in the leg, but not these. They work with or without pants tucked in.
I did have the same issue as other reviewers in that they are a bit hard to get on and off. I had a problem with one boot and not the other being tight across the opening of the foot of the boot. I bet this will solve itself with wear as the leather stretches out over time.
My only negative is how smooth the bottom of the boots are. I will have to take them outside for a good scuffing to make them less slippery on smooth floors.