I am on the fence about this boot. Not really sure how I feel I am keeping the boot because they were a steal in price.  the buckle on the side showed some resistance witht the glue.  on the pic i loved the style  of the boot, they fit great I ordered the all black. I have nice calves and so often i have to be sure a boot can measure up and it indeed did. I typically wear an 8 in 9west and the boot fits great on my foot also looks good just some cosmetic blemishes but willing to keep them