The fit is fine, I wear a 14 and they fit well. Just large enough to slip on easy.

Not uncomfortable, but the soles are rubber and look cheap.

I bought the Dark Brown Leather, which is easily the worst, lowest quality leather I have ever seen, or worn. They are beyond distressed, they look and feel oily. The "leather" (Rockport's description, not mine) is more like filthy suede. It is soft, oily, worn, and you cannot polish them or clean them.

Rockport should include a Salvation Army box with these boots so at you can deliver them more quickly to where they ultimately will end up.