These are very pretty shoes and I really like that they are more feminine than a lot of other oxfords. About a year ago I bought the cognac color in my usual Frye size, which is the smaller of the two sizes I go between. They are very roomy in the toe box but good for a narrow foot, extremely comfortable and a good work shoe. The quality is very good, especially the sole and heel. Only 4 stars because the color was slightly different between the two shoes but I've noticed that over the past year the difference has become less noticeable.