I've had Rockports before and thought they were the best shoes ever, so I really had high hopes for these.

They fit my foot fine, a little narrower than usual, so they hug the foot better. However, it's incredibly uncomfortable if you are going up an incline when the shoe needs to move with your foot a little. The soul is hard and it hurts my foot.

The leather looks pretty worn on the shoe with creases and a chunk of the leather has pealed off. I've had the shoes for about 1 month. I wear these shoes daily for work and do a lot of walking, so these may not have been the best shoes for constant wear.

Previously I had a pair of Docker's from Ross and they were great.

UPDATE: I've worn these shoes for a year now. They've loosened up over time and are more comfortable. Although they do look really worn. Lots of creases and missing pieces of leather. I don't think I've ever owned a pair of dress shoes that have worn out so quickly.