Based on thorough online research, these boots seemed a practical, if not indulgent, investment. I'm at the point in my life where I was willing to pay a premium price for a more enduring pair of boots, which would be cheaper in the long run than replacing $50-$125 boots every year or so. Based on the descriptions of several different Web sites, I assumed these boots would hold up substantially longer, and be more comfortable, than conventional boots. I could hardly wait to get them.

But what I expected to be "ultimate" black boots turned out to be a bit less than what I anticipated. The exterior style and quality of leather is excellent, and the deerskin inner lining is incredibly soft. I also appreciate the emphasis on natural materials. Even the packaging was stellar. But the boots didn't fit right. I wear a standard 8.5, no problem, so based on multiple reviews at various Web sites, I ordered an 8. For me, the fit is odd: even with thin socks, I found these boots are too narrow yet my feet slid in the heels. Breaking them in or ordering up wouldn't solve the problem. Further, in truth, the much-touted sole is at best marginally more comfortable than a "typical" $100-$150 boot; certainly not the cushy comfort widely advertised and clearly indicated by the product name. I have never spent this much money on a pair of boots in my life. I wonder why these expensive boots are made in China not the US. Indications are they're made with low-wage labor yet the boots cost a premium, certainly more than most boots made in USA. I thought they'd be worth the investment. Not even close. I returned them posthaste. I'm left wondering whose interests are being served by the "typical" online reviews of these boots. Were they posted by sales reps?