I got my first pair new with tags from a consignment store, if I can find and 11 shoe, it's a minor miracle. I loved them so much I came to Amazon and bought more. These shoes are so amazingly comfortable. I have a wide foot and these fit perfectly. I loved them so much I tossed out all my other sandals and bought 2 more pair of the Carly sandals, I'll probably buy more before summer is over. I wore these when I walked around Washington D.C for 8 hours, never had sore feet!