I bought the Oakley Tactical to use primarily as a motorcycle riding boot.  While there are probably a lot of better motorcycle-specific boots on the market, for what the Oakley Tactical does, it does wonderfully.  The size was perfect for my foot.  I had read that it does run big so to order a 1.2 size smaller than normal.  I heeded this advice and it worked perfect.  The boot looks outstanding with a pair of jeans, and was very comfortable out of the box.  There was virtually no break-in period required.  The good, the bad and ugly:

The Good:

+ Appearance/Looks.  A classic looking boot, nice lines.
+ Virtually break-in free.  The base and leather is very soft and flexible.  For me, there wasn't any break-in required.
+ Good traction from the sole.

The Bad:

+ Not fully waterproof.  While Oakley doesn't market this boot as a waterproof boot, I would expect some level of inherent protection regardless.  Water can easily seep in between the tongue and shoelace holes.
+ Fit is about 1/2 size large so plan accordingly.
+ No steel toe or shank (for weight reduction).

The Ugly:

+ Nothing.

While the price might be a deterrent, this boot would serve well for "dry" hiking, motorcycle riding or even as a work book.  It's lack of a steel toe and shank might not make this an ideal boot for working with power tools.