Beautiful boots! I ordered an 8.5 and they fit great. 8.5 is what I usually wear in most shoes: running shoes, heels etc. this was actually the 2nd pair of Frye boots I tried on from Amazon. The first pair were shipped super fast but the left boot was significantly smaller than the right which I know other reviewers have mentioned happening to them. The boots clearly were marked 8.5 on both but the left was much smaller, I couldn't get it on my foot! So I packed them up and filled out the exchange/return info on Amazon on a Wednesday and Amazon had shipped me out another pair that same day and I had the new boots on Friday. UPS picked up the boots I was returning on Thursday. As I mentioned these boots (the 2nd pair) fit wonderfully and they smell heavenly! Very stylish and comfortable.