I recently purchased my Boggs from Amazon and gave them a test run during a lake effect snow storm that hit my area.

* I found that sizing up was best for me.  I wear a 10.5 shoe, so I ordered an 11.  The 11 seemed a tiny bit loose on me.  I happened to see these same boots at a chain shoe store and tried a 10.  While it was nice and snug, the back dug into my Achilles tendon and was pretty painful.  So add me to the list of customers wanting Boggs to make half-sizes and suggesting that you also size up when ordering.

* The upper part of the boot is very wide and not at all snug against my calf.  It's actually kind of awkward.  I can either wear tighter pants and tuck them inside of the boot, but have to deal with snow and rain coming inside of the boot.  Or, I can wear bootcut pants and put the cuffs outside of the boot.  The bad part about the latter is that my pants shift when I sit certain ways and when I get up, the cuffs will land on the top of the boot.  It's not a massive problem, but it is an inconvenience to have to adjust the bottom of my pants so that I don't have skin exposed to the wind.

* They've kept my feet dry.  I don't know that I'd say my feet were toasty with a regular pair of socks, but they definitely were not cold in temps in the lower 20's with windchill.  Job well done by my Boggs.

* They are fairly large.  When I put them on, I felt like the old man neighbor in the first Home Alone movie.  They're definitely more functional than they are stylish, so I agree with other viewers that you may not want to wear them to a business meeting or dinner party.

* They feel totally indestructible.

* The treads were good for walking on slick surfaces.

All in all, I'd recommend these Boggs.  There are a few design quirks, but I wouldn't have any reservations about telling you that these are a solid, functional pair of boots.