i rarely review items unless i feel compelled.  this boot is precious & the quality is great. despite reviews warning against the calf being tight, i took a chance because i assumed my calves were thin enough to fit & to be extra sure, i ordered a half size up. i consider myself to be fairly thin and have never had a problem with any type of boot before but these were crazy tight at the calf.  i mean, so tight that they suctioned to my leg and i could barely get the boot off (even with only tights on).  i couldn't even get them over my skinny jeans.  so sad because they are freaking adorable & i have no choice but to return them.  if they fit you, i am jealous :(