These boots are beautiful in person for Tan Waxy Suede I picked. It doesn't really look like suede; it looks like leather, but that only applys to the size 8.5 that I got...

I normally wear size 8; I ordered both size 8 and size 8.5 based on the reviews of its tightness.  I think it is true to size, size 8.5 is a bit loose fitting; too bad, the openings are big to my claves.  On the other hands, the size 8 is the best fit, and it's a bit tight to wear in/out, the openings are slightly smaller but better than size 8.5.  However, the quality of the leather is so inconsistant for these two pairs.  the right size one is awful that look like cheap leather.  I have few suede boots in good brands, and they aren't like that. The boots are very slippy and need to have additional services for that.

It seems a great price for Frye's boots even suede only, but still they are expensive to me. For this kind of cheap quality of leather, it isn't worth this price. Since the leather quality is bad, I'm afraid the boots that may look better initally but end up will become that awful looking, so I even didn't bother to exchange and return both back immediately without any regret.