Previously had Asics Nimbus but new version didn't control my overpronation so tried these. I am 5'7" and 170 lbs, run 3.5 miles 3 times per week. I have 4E width and these shoes were plenty wide and fit good. However, running in them there was much less cushion than I was used to with the Nimbus. I had joint pain at the end of my runs. Ended up going with the Asics Kayano 18 ($150). I felt they were worth the higher price as I can run in them without any joint pain and I am well isolated from the shock of running on asphalt. The Kayano are narrower, even in 4E, but after stretching them out they worked well.