These boots Surpassed my expectations for comfort -- the pile lining is warm and cushions the foot inside the boot. I'm on my feet all day, do a lot of walking over uneven terrain and take a long walk when I get home in the evening -- these boots feel great all the way!

I'm skeptical about any so-called waterproof leather boot, but so far these have kept my feet dry.

I work as an estate gardener and my work boots take a lot of abuse from water, dirt, dust, fertilizer and more. These boots are almost too nice for my purposes. I ordered the boots online and thought the lower part of the boot was rubber, as it is on other duck boots. For practical purposes, I wish the toe and lower section of the boot were rubber. I cant walk across the lawn in the morning without getting the toes of my boots wet. Throughout the day, I find myself constantly stopping to wipe water splashes off my toes.  I also apply a light spray of silicone waterproofing every night after taking the boots off.