Every pair of shoes/sneakers I own are a size 9.5 and even other timberland Shoes I own are 9.5's. I listened to the other reviews and ordered these in a size 9. They do run large, and the 9's are a good fit. Even with the 9's I could slip a pair of thicker socks in there when it gets really cold. As for anything I have no comment as I just got them.
They look good (brown), and feel good on.<a data-hook="product-link-linked" class="a-link-normal" href="/Timberland-Men-s-Earthkeepers-6-Lace-Up-Boot-Lace-Up-Boot/dp/B001BFFTO0/ref=cm_cr_arp_d_rvw_txt?ie=UTF8">Timberland Men's Earthkeepers 6" Lace-Up Boot Lace-Up Boot</a>&nbsp;I will reserve the 5th star when I wear them some more.

UPDATE: October 15, 2012. I have had a chance to wear these several times on short hikes (2 miles) and use them for a camping weekend in Northern NY. They are comfortable, warm and I have no complaints. Just remember they run 1/2 size large. These are not deep freeze boots. They are great everyday wear, and light to moderate use winter boots. What I also like is that they are not heavy to wear. I don't feel like I'm clunking about in them.