I normally buy Ecco shoes but because of my wide feet, I usually have to buy a size or two larger.  These J & M fit very well and were comfortable from the first time I wore them (dress shoes, other than Ecco, normally give me blisters).  I live in San Francisco and walk and/or take public transportation everywhere so I'm pretty hard on dress shoes.  I need something durable with good support that also looks good.  These shoes are all that and more.  I would give them five stars but still not quite the perfect fit for my high instep.