i've been looking for mary jane's for a while and decided that i'd give these a try since they were so reasonably priced.  they also come in wide sizes, and that's a plus.  i just received them and i have yet to wear them.  i did try them on.  while they are super cute, they are also really big. my feet get wider the closer you get to my toes, so my feet are sort of like...ducks feet?!  lol.  anyway, i imagine these would be comfortable enough for people that have the longer second toe.  my second toe is much shorter than my big toe, that combined with the duck-like shape of my feet, causes these shoes to be a bit uncomfortable.  the way the toe area is designed it leaves a huge gap between my smaller toes and the end of the shoe, and presses my big toe into my other toes.

i realize that the shape of my feet are not the norm, but i know a few other people with similar problems and i thought i'd point these things out.  to be make it clear...the toe area has it's longest point in front of where the second toe would be.  anyone with a wide width across their toes might find these uncomfortable.

they are also a lot bigger than i expected.  i usually wear a regular 9 1/2 and these wide width 9's feel a lot more like a 10 or a 10 1/2 to me.

they are cute though.