When I found these shoes, they were exactly what I wanted for oxfords! Now I want the black and natural colours as well. I got the white pair and they look exactly like the picture. I disagree that they are cheaply made. I think they're excellent quality for the price and the laces aren't even as bad as I was led to believe. I'm in between an 8.5 and a 9. I always go with the bigger size for oxfords, and they fit perfectly. My only complaint is that they aren't as pointy as I would have liked. They look more like ballerina shoes but they're still great!