In the interest of full disclosure, I have several paris of Reebok comparable shoes and give them high marks for the time I've had them in service or the past couple of years.  I bought these Puma kicks after receiving a recommendation from a guy at the local gym who has the same issue as my own, meaning vulnerable or bad feet.  The first thing I noticed with this Puma brand shoe is a snugger fit.  Still comfortable but giving the impression of a little better support because the foot is less likely to move around during use.

That feature is important because of possible slippage leading to falling and attendant injury during a jog or intense weight workout at the gym.  I gave the Pumas a test on both counts & must say I was impressed.  The support was excellent and stability a shade better than with the Reeboks so the Pumas get on the scoreboard early. They're also lighter in weight by an ounze or two or at least, seem so to me.  Now, 'early' is important to note because I obviously have no way of knowing how well they'll hold up in the weeks and months ahead.  The Reeboks have been excellent in that regard but if the Pumas prove to have quality longevity, I'll improve my ranking to a full 5 stars.  At first blush, the Pumas have been impressive.