I bought these shoes for my 7 and 4 year old daughters in navy and wanted black as well to match other outfits.  They are well made and neither of my kids had difficulty breaking them in. The styling is attractive and the rubber soles make it easy to run around in.  They look nice when paired with dresses and skirts or leggings and pants.  I appreciate Stride Rite's ability to keep little girl shoes looking like little girls shoes! They are a practical choice for our family! Over all, no complaints!