This is the third  pair I have bought over the course of 5+ years. I order the brown/brown color.

First pair was 5 stars, the next 4 stars.  This one three stars:  The dye color of the leather in the shoe is poorly matched.  Also, the foot insert is problematic.  It is removable (good), but the end covering the ball of the foot is not stiff and tends to fold up with use. Also, I swear the number of stitches per inch used to make the shoe has gone down with this last attempt, making the shoe look cheaper than earlier versions.

The sole remains well crafted and should withstand long hard use. The shoe remains well priced.

Oct 6, 2011 update:  this pair lasted only 4 months before the stiching along the side gave way (on both shoes).  On prior pairs, this took more than 2 years to occur.  I must conclude that the shoe maker is substituting lower quality stitching on newer shoes.  I would now give 2 stars to these shoes.