These look great, until you put the on. The very top of the calf is tight, but the rest of it is baggy. This gives you a really weird baggy effect from your ankle to the top of the boot. They won't just stand up straight like other rainboots. I agree that the foot portion of the boot runs big (I wear and 6 and ordered a 5) but the top of the boot is like a rubber band, and it just... isn't flattering.