I purchased these for my 5 year old daughter. She is VERY hard on shoes. It seems like I am purchasing shoes every couple of weeks because she has scuffed up the toes of the does to bad to wear. These she has done the same thing but they are better quality of shoe so it's not as bad and you  can make it look acceptable with shoe polish.  They are very good quality and she is as girlie as they come. She loves the beaded decoration, which have not fallen off after a month and to me that's a lot lol.
I will be purchasing more of this brand and most likely this shoe again in several months to come.