I read the pros and cons before buying. I appreciate these Amazon ratings and usually give more weight to the highest stars, ignoring many of the one-star comments because some people are simply difficult to please in this age in which we live. Now . . . .
my boots arrived and had the odor common to new shoes (like having the pleasing smell of a new car). The fit was nice and the convenience of the zippers is welcomed. Yes, I recommend these shoes for anyone wanting a nice dress boot.