This jacket is, to me, a HUGE improvement over her previous fleece jacket because it is fitted.  My wife has a waist, and the previous jacket made her look like she had a little bit of a belly.  This one doesn't, so that's good. (Take note, ladies! ha!)

The longer length in both the body and the sleeves are also a welcome departure from the previous jacket -- this jacket looks like it fits much better on her.

Four stars because I think that the description is a little misleading... I thought that the whole jacket was lined, but only the hood is lined with nylon.