I've only worn these shoes for light hikes like upper Yosemite, so I don't know how they would work with more strenuous hikes.  Very good ankle protection, solid sole, as expected not waterproof in mesh areas, not super comfortable to wear for long periods, not much traction on slippery surfaces as you would expect with a good pair of winter boots. I bought these about 8 months ago and they seem to be holding up pretty well.