I wasn't particularly attracted to the boot in the picture but the reviews were so positive that I wanted to see what all the fuss was about.  The boots are much cuter in person.  The picture makes them look kinda bulky but they are not.  They are trim and shapely on the outside.  They do not feel like bulky clodhoppers and will transition easily to indoor wear. I typically wear a 9-wide or 9.5.  I ordered a 9 C/D and think it is just right. I put on my thickest SmartWool socks, walked around a bit and they were so comfy I didn't want to take them off. I don't think they will be warm enough to get me through the Minnesota winter, perhaps into December.  I'll let you know!  Now I'm off to browse for more Propet shoes.

UPDATE:  I've been wearing them for month now and almost never take them off!  They are cute, go well with my clothing, and sooooo comfy--indoors and outdoors.  I have walked a mile in them more than once.

UPDATE, 2013:  These boots are the best shoe I have every owned.  I wore them last year from October to April.  They always kept my feet at the perfect temperature and they still look brand new.  On New Year's Eve it was -14 degrees, factoring in the windchill made it about -20.  We drank more wine than we expected and decided to walk about a mile to our house and return for the car in the morning.  My feet stayed toasty warm the whole way home.