To be fair, I will rank a 3 out of 5, I believe the problem with these particular shoes is that the pair I received were very old stock - over 2 years old and I believe that led to the very early breakdown of the shoes.  I know others with the Rogue Racers and they have held up and they are liked.

After two trail runs, approximately 60 miles, my Rogues were unusable, the supports collapsed, the heel separated, the mesh was torn.  The seller made good on another pair of shoes (Lasportiva Raptor) that so far I am loving!