Ok, these might not be "great" ear warmers and if I had paid $5. or more would have given them a 1 star however having paid less than 4 bucks I consider these a 3.

The metal (or plastic) internals that hold the ear muffs in place won't hold more than a few times and there isn't a lot of insulation however it's not all bad as these are great for "throw-away" ear warmers as they do keep my ear a little warm.

If you want "real" ear warmers that keep your ears warm, last for any length of time then these are not them.