I ordered an XL charcoal colored peacoat.  When it arrived in a large sturdy bag (i.e. not a box) so I was concerned that it could have been damaged in shipping.  But it was not damaged at all, I got lucky, the bag held up.  It also shipped with a sturdy hanger, a nice cheap bonus.

I put it on immediately.  It smelled good, like it should, of new clean fabric.  It is peace of mind knowing I didn't somehow get a jacket that was returned after some stinky fella wore it around for a couple days.  As I mentioned, I ordered the XL because I'm 6'2" (almost 220 lbs).  I nearly got the large, as I'm not overweight, but I read in some reviews that the arms/shoulders seem small to some.  I do note that the arms on my peacoat are indeed skinny.  The chest fits a little better/looser, but the torso is a tiny bit too large. Very roomy.  It'd be nice if they put larger sleeves on a smaller size.  I certainly wouldn't fit into a large, which I nearly bought instead of this one.  You can't please everyone, we are all shaped very differently, so ordering online can be a gamble.

It doesn't look exactly as it does here in the pictures with the Zoolander-esque male models; no "narrow" or "tapered" torso appearance, for sure, but it is still quite stylish.  Also, the color I ordered, charcoal, appears a little bit lighter than it does compared to the pictures.  This doesn't bother me.  I usually prefer black but I already have too much black in my wardrobe.

Overall, I would give it 5 stars for an excellent, stylish, warm, well-made jacket.  But the slight difference in appearance, compared to the advertised pictures, I would have to subtract a star.  I took a chance and ordered online because I understand that Amazon generally has good return policies.  But there is no need for me to find out :)