Cons: I had to order up 1/2 size because they didn't come in 10.5 (most boots don't), and I wasn't sure about the look of the "tongue" or the color.  I needn't have worried.  The shoe portion fits well, although the ankle area could be a little tighter, but it's not sloppy, just a little loose (as is the heel - doesn't slip exactly, just isn't firmly in place, but I have a very narrow heel, so this is better than most.)  I like the leather - it has a subtly interesting look, and the tongue doesn't look strange when on your leg - it fits in with whatever you're wearing.  The sides of the boot fit my leg exactly, which is really a plus - comfortably, not too tight, but as if it was made for me (at the widest point, my calf size is 1.5").  It comes up to the bottom of my knee, and doesn't rub against anything - the inside is smooth and comfy.  It has a zipper the entire length of the boot, which makes it easy to put on (one boot has a very stiff zipper that I'm hoping will loosen up).  They are also stylish.  It's not cold enough to know how they will be in truly cold weather (it may snow tonight, but it's around freezing).  The only Q in my mind is about the zipper....except for that they are really nice boots.
Update:  You need to waterproof the boots, because they don't come waterproofed - I sprayed it on twice, but we've had such a warm winter it hasn't been much of a test.