These boots fit really well right out of the box, even on my wide feet and big calves (good to know if you, too, have wider than average calves). Unfortunately, one of the boots looked completely different from the other one. The shaft of the right boot was wrinkled, shiny, and plastic-looking. The left boot was okay, but when I had both on, the pair looked really weird. It almost looked as though the right boot shaft was made out a different type of leather and it had a cheap look to it, which didn't show up in the photos on Amazon. Rather disappointing, but that is an occupational hazard when ordering items sight unseen on the internet! I will be returning these promptly.