I only gave these shoes a 4 star ONLY because the style was not was I was looking for. The toe was very pointy and I felt a little weird weiring such a pointy boot. Not sure if this style is supposed to be that pointy but they were almost hard to walk in. They were VERY comfortable. A snug fit too, so if you have wider feet and a bigger calf then these boots are not for you. I have small boney stick legs so these boots were a dream for me, but alas, I returned them for the pointyness. The color grey matches the picture spot on and I love the fact that they are pull on boots that are fitted. They are sexy boots for those bold enough to wear them.