I have these boots in black, and hesitated because I wasn't sure I would like the style - but for the price, I took a chance.  I ordered up a half size, which was absolutely necessary - they couldn't be any shorter and still fit (I wear a 10.5 normally).  They are rated to -25 degrees, which for me never works, but still gives a ballpark figure.  The boot is a little stiff, but I think it's softening a bit; the heel slips, but the front couldn't be any narrower (this is more my wide-at-the-front feet than a failing of this company's boot).  The best surprise was the looks - they look almost elegant, but still are easy to slip on and to tuck pants into.  The little zipper is handy if you're having any trouble slipping them on.  They are a little heavy, but that also means sturdy.  the footbed isn't bad - some padding, and removable if you want to substitute your own.  Oh, and the suede is waterproof.  Nice design!

Chloe