I wanted a light weight jacket with lots of pockets (yes, pocket fetish I suppose but I do use them) and capable of keeping me dry as I do things like rush from car to door.
The good:  It is comfortable, fit well, well made, and the pockets are both numerous and practical for my use.  It does shed water well enough for dashes from car to door.  I have not tried to stand in a rain so I cannot speak to its ability to withstand longer wettings.
I bought the tan and so far it has resisted stainings.
The bad:  It does have a 1/2 zipper in order to facilitate quick access to weapons for those who need that.  The velcro below the zipper does not hold the jacket together.  Fortunately, I do not live in a world where I anticipate gun battles while, for example, going to the grocery so this feature is not needed.  I fixed it by putting in a full length zipper.  The jacket is built for a full length zipper to facilitate putting one in.  Worked real well and I am quite satisfied.
Actually, if I were to need a coat that facilitates a quick draw I believe that the market features those that have built in holsters which would do better in a higher intensity than I live in environment.
Also, it lacks and needs a set of hand warmer pockets.  I miss those.
Bottom line - I rated it a three overall.  A four (almost a 5) for quality and overall features but I knocked a star off for the zipper and (mainly) lack of hand warmer pockets.  If you are looking for a good buy in this sort of jacket, this is worth looking at seriously.  But beware the couple of flaws I noted.