It's a good shoe. I just got it so still have to test it outside, esp with the rain. I've experienced what other reviewers here say about the size. I'm an 8.5 and I usually get a 9 which I did in this case. With a pair of regular socks, it's a snug fit. Too snug for what I prefer. I should have ordered a 9.5. Not related to the shoe, is Amazon's very late delivery. I ordered on Sep 30. It only started to be delivered on Oct 5! The estimated delivery is Oct 11. But on Oct 8, Columbus Day, the tracking says they made a delivery attempt at 8AM. They sent it through Fedex Smartpost but is actually through USPS. So, #1, the post office does not work on Columbus Day (I called their 800 #). #2, at 8AM I was definitely home. #3, there was no slip/notice of the delivery whatsoever. So, I made a trek on Oct 9 to the local post office without nothing, just my word and pictures of the tracking history online.  I was lucky it was there and I got it.