This is a fantastic looking wingtip oxford at a bargain price. I bought the oyster suede (off white, not gray) and they look really good with a dark idigo or red pair of skinny jeans. I wear an 11 medium, bought the 11 medium, and they fit perfectly. Ordinarily, I would order 1/2 size larger and add a pair of Dr. Scholl's foot pillow inserts, and these shoes would have benefited from that, as there is practically no arch support and the cushioning is quite modest (feels like a dress shoe). But because of the elongated toe (the hot look in a wingtip oxford now), I felt a half size bigger would make the shoes look too long. There is literally an inch of shoe in the toe that goes unfilled, but otherwise they fit just fine. The quality is mid-level but better than expected at this price point, and since I only plan to wear them occasionally, I think they'll last a long time. Mainly, they look great, are fairly lightweight, and should work well for a 4 to 5-hour outing. Another reviewer mentioned a Pentel white eraser works well to clean up marks on the light suede. I'll try that, but I've also already sprayed them 3 times with a protective suede coating. You can spend $150 to $350 on a shoe that looks like this, and it'll no doubt be better quality, but I'd much rather pay this price for a shoe I'll wear just occasionally. Finally, my wife is a fashion stylist and is very critical of what I wear, and she gave me her "thumbs up." I'd say you can't go wrong, and if you don't mind a little extra length, you can get a 1/2 size larger and add more cushioning and comfort with a set of Dr. Scholl's foot pillows.