I have had two pairs of these . They fit great , are light weight, and tractible .
Gore-Tex is truly waterproof; waterproofed leathers aren't. The problem I've had with walking three or so miles a day is the fabric insert .
Although these are stitched well , the fabric is cut short and not folded over and hemmed when sewn into the leather , so after several weeks the fabric becomes internally frayed and pulls out of the leather through the stitching on both pairs ; so I know it wasn't just  a fault with the first pair .
That's too bad , because I really like the fit and comfort.
There is a similar shoe with leather sides and no fabric -but they aren't Gore-Tex.