Ok as with my other Frye boots this is a good quality well made boot which is going to last forever. The style and design is awesome especially if you have an athletic calf, the slouch is very flattering. You will need to put some sort of insole for added comfort as the sole is quite hard, easy fix though. I don't have a wide foot but i found them were a bit tight so i had my local shoe repair guy stretch them a bit and now they are perfect. The reason i have given them 4 stars though is because i ordered the Dark Brown, which in the pic is a nice shiny leather, instead i recieved a Dark pebbled suede leather, unfortunelty im in Australia and its to expensive to post them back. Lucky for me i still love them  and although slightly dissapointed in Amazons muckup i will still love these boots!