I have wanted these boots for a long, long time.  My husband surprised me with them this week and they are just what I hoped!  But, I do have to exchange them for a half size smaller. I usually wear a 9.5 or 10 and have a slightly narrower than average foot but not enough that buy "narrow" shoes.  This boot is a 10 and is very roomy and a little too loose around my heel. I'll get a 9.5 and I'm sure they'll be perfect.  The only other issue is that on the right boot, there's a little bit of white fabric showing outside the seaming that joins the foot part to the shaft in two places.  Looking down you can see it clearly.  If I was keeping these boots I'd take a black sharpie to it but the left boot doesn't have this problem so that makes it very obvious on the right boot.  That's the only reason it's getting 4 stars instead of 5.  I'm keeping my fingers crossed that exchanging for the half size smaller will land me the perfect boots and no flawed seaming.