First things first: this is a cheap boot. The leather is faux, there is no lining and no insole padding to speak of. Once you accept those parameters, you're in for a pleasant surprise. The zipper in the side is substantial and opens deep into the arch so it's not a strain to get my heel in. The toe is a classy almond shape, not crazy-pointed. The heel is a nice height--three inches, very walkable, and not so high that your foot looks contorted. Also the heel has a graceful curved taper with a nice substantial base where it meets the sole. Feels steady to walk on.

I am 5'6" and a size 2-4, athletic build. I got my usual size 8.5 and they fit pretty darn good; a little loose in the toe box but since I plan to install insoles that's a good thing. I have slim ankles and muscular thighs. They feel loose around my ankles but they don't look baggy. Likewise they feel clingy around my thighs--really they come just about 2 inches over the knee, and I have a 28-inch inseam--but they don't squish the fat and they don't seem inclined to fall down. The pleather does have a bit of shine, rather like a glazed leather, but it doesn't scream "plastic" to me.

For a costume boot I couldn't ask for better. In fact, these are classy enough I may wear them on the street. With an aftermarket insole they will be very comfortable, I think.