I purchased these boots after having my heart set on getting Sorel's. The Columbias are comfortable, seem to be true to size, keep my feet warm and dry. Yes they are heavy, but I expect that for this type of boot. I have been in water almost up to the laces with them and no leaks. I have tried thick socks on a really cold day and discovered that thinner is better.

I thought I would have buyer's remorse on settling for these instead of the Sorel's, but I am very glad I bought these. The only thing I don't like about them is the colour. I hate the Shimmer colour but it is just a thin line and does not impact how the boots function.