I bought this exact same pair of shoes 18 years ago. Had them re-soled 3 times, replaced worn laces 6-7 times, but these shoes have remained in great shape. Recently the sole of these old shoes started coming detached, and scuff marks were getting more pronounced, so I decided it was finally time to replace.

The new shoes are beautiful, extremely professional looking, and very comfortable. Other reviewers have commented that it takes some time to break them in. I agree that the leather uppers are firm on arrival, but that's what I expect from a brand new pair of leather shoes. On first putting on my new pair of shoes, I can tell they are of the same quality and caliber of the ones I purchased 18 years ago.

I have two other pairs of Johnston & Murphy shoes - another style for work, and a different style for casual use. The shoes have all been extremely well made, and have retained their shape, their comfort and their tight stitching after many years.