I got these because they filled several of my requirements -- I wanted plain boots, no buckles.  Wanted a rubber sole that would be good on wet slippery surfaces.  Wanted almond or rounded toe, not western style  Preferred no zipper.  I really love these-- got them last year and wore them a lot.  They are very comfortable and easy to keep looking good.  (Mine are brown leather).  Because they have that slanted top-- higher on the outside of the boot than the inside, they have a bit of edge.  The only bit of a concern is that they're fairly heavy -- not in an absolute sense but if you're used to wearing Uggs you'll notice the difference.  Also unlike others I find that there is a little space between the top inside of the boot and my leg, even with jeans tucked in.  They have a bit of a cavalier look to them-- not real fitted.  But they couldn't be and still be a pull on with no zipper.