I was reluctant to buy these because of the negative reviews.  They came fast, the price was very good and the fit was excellent.  I don't know if you are aware of this, but New Balance makes shoes with different lasts - that is why the same size in New Balance may fit you differently - they are made to a different pattern.

These are made with a wider toe box and narrower heel.  My husband has had them for several months and they are still in great shape. They look great and hold their shape very well. We are very happy to have them.  He is very hard to fit.