I don't know what the other reviewer is saying about it being shiny it's not shiny at all. It's not dull either but I wouldn't call it shiny. Also about it not being slim fit it is slim fit maybe you got a size bigger than you are it fits me perfectly. If you get the proper size it should fit to your body perfectly maybe you don't know your actual size. I don't know about a tie not working but I did use it with a bow tie and had no problems at all. In case anyone is wondering I got it in black, carbon, and white.

Like the other reviewer said if you do plan on getting the white color version of this shirt you might want to wear some sort of undershirt because your nipples will be visible had no problem with the black and carbon color with this situation. The fabric is a bit thin but I don't see that as a negative in most dress up shirts the fabric is usually thin. The only thing I wish is that they had a more variety of colors.