This boot lives up to the reputation of Frye boots.  It's sturdy, well-built, but beautiful to look at. (I bought mine in burnt red, which is a nice subdued color ... looks great with jeans, khakis, olive cargo pants, etc.)  I normally wear an 8.5, so I ordered that.  The fit is quite roomy, and I could probably do with an 8.0.  But I'm glad to have the extra room for thick socks ... and just for general comfort.