When I removed them from the box, one boot had a 2 inch scuff right on the toe.  I was able to rub out most of the scuff.

Also - these dark brown boots don't look exactly like the picture.  All stitching on the boot is a very light tan color, which you cannot see in the picture.  Because of this, I am tempted to send them back.  However, the boots still look good - I just prefer less visible stitching.

Normally wear 8.5 wide, so based on reviewers' recommendations I ordered 7W and they fit live a glove.  The only issue with the fit is that they are extremely hard to get on and off for my wide feet.  I have to loosen the laces quite a bit.  Hopefully, they break in and this will not be an issue.

Next complaint is about the top of the boot that rests on the back of your calf.  It is cushioned, but very uncomfortable.  I bent and creased this area on the boots for about 3-4 minutes.  This softened it up a bit, but I guess they are just not broken in yet.  I only worn them once.

Now for the good - the cushioning of this boot is VERY comfortable.  These boots are super lightweight and go great with jeans.  I feel that I got a great deal considering how much they sell for on the Timberland site.

I am only removing a star due to the stitching that's not visible in the pics.  I'm sure they will break in fine and there really isn't a better looking or more versatile boot out there - in my opinion.