These are amazingly comfortable! When I bought them, they were so cushy and warm. A few years later, they're less squishy but have held up quite well, and are still very warm. They're warm enough to wear in cold New England winters.

I would recommend sizing down. I'm normally a size 6, but size 5 in these fit well.

They're admittedly not the most attractive boot, but they look pretty good with jeans or leggings. I got the chocolate color, and they've held up very well. I get any spots out with vinegar and water, or suede cleaner. I've had them for several years, and I wear them often.