I spent several months looking through stores for a decent pair of waterproof snowboots with good traction and not covered in tassles and fake fur and easily damaged suede.  A pair of boots I wouldn't have to replace every year because the uppers were falling apart and the tread had worn away.  And, ideally, a pair I was not going to spend two hundred dollars on.  The stores failed me.
Turning to the internet, I vacillated between several shoes before settling on these, primarily based on the reviews.  They are everything I hoped.  I liked that they are lace-up, because I have skinny ankles that tend to wobble around in boots that can't be adjusted.  Listening to other reviewers, I bought a half size up and they fit perfectly, with no need to break in.  The shape is sufficiently roomy enough for thick socks, but they're warm enough that I don't need them.  The contoured footbed is supportive without wanting inserts, and the lining is thick and comfortable. This one may just be me, but I'm delighted that though they don't have zippers I've been able to slide them on and off, which is fantastic.
Since getting them I have tromped on slush, snow, and ice without slipping, and the coloration (I got wheat/oatmeal) will make any salt stains less glaring.  I expect to have these boots for a very long time.