I have waited six months to write this review so I could be fair . I really wanted to say nice things about these boots but after they have  been in service for six months here is what I have learned. On the plus side they are the most comfortable boots I have ever owned. The waterproofing is about 95% effective. On the down side the soles are almost worn flat. They provide little to no positive traction which could prove to be a problem on a ladder or roof. The stitching below and on the side of the steel toe cover is coming unstitched. You would expect a work boot to last longer than six months especially at this price. So if you want to work the boots at light duty with maybe indoor work they might hold up for you. But if you are going to work them hard don't expect them to hold up. I will not be choosing these boots again. Anyone have any recommendations on a great workboot?