I've had these shoes for almost a year now and I still love them. They fit true to size and had awesome traction in the winter snow and ice we get here in Minnesota. They kept my feet warm, though we didn't have a very cold winter last year, so they really weren't put to the test.  We'll see this year if they hold up in below zero temps.  They are also pretty stylish, for an all terrain shoe. I've had both men and women comment on them when I've worn them to work.  They did get a bit warm wearning them all day inside, but they looked great with my jeans!  They are also super easy to slip on and off, which I love. I have two dogs and when they need to go outside, they need to go N.O.W.! I don't have time to sit down, pull on and lace up my heavy duty snow boots, so these are perfect.  They say they are all season shoes, but for me, they are too warm for summer wear.  They are great for spring and fall though, when it tends to rain and/or the grass gets dewey in the morning.