These boots are BEAUTIFUL! Since I have not worn them for a season (or at all) yet, I cannot speak to their durability. They are rubber and have a soft lining, and do seem well-constructed and sturdy. I wear size 7 or 71/2 shoe, so ordered size 8 to allow for socks. I would have preferred to compare sizes 7 and 8 but don't feel like ordering another pair just to try them on. What I like most about these boots is that there is NOTHING like them in any stores I have been to and they will brighten up the dreariest day.