I've only used these Bogs Walkers part-time for a month or less, but so far I'm fully satisfied.  The large, wide toe box adds greatly to their comfort for me.  There's a tradeoff -- they're harder to get on and off than I expected; it helps to sit while pulling them on, and then smooth one's sock inside the stretchable band.  Once they're on, this band is snug but comfortable, just right to properly hold the foot in place.  The grippy soles stay surprisingly clean -- they're not bad at all about tracking dirt, leaves, and debris if I end an outdoor session with a short walk on grass.  So far, they seem to be very good shoes, and just as described.