Bogs are comfy & I loved the embossed finish (almost like a paisley). The foot area is generous (I tried the 10, but it tended to rub on my heel) and the calf area is snug at the very top, due to the neoprene material (but this helps it stay on my leg better and I think I could still fit it over skinny jeans or thinner pants). The comfort and support of the footbed and warmth (and what appiears to be the lasting quality) made them worth the $ for me!