After a year and ~3,000 miles of daily commuting in these shoes I can recommend them highly. First, they are comfortable to wear both on and off the bike. The sole is pretty stiff (which is good) so they aren't great for walking long distances, but if you had to you'd probably be fine. Second, they are easy to get on and off so they make great commuting shoes where you're putting them on and taking then off at least twice a day. Finally, they are ventilated well enough that your feet won't overheat in summer, but substantial enough that if you pair them with wool socks and neoprene shoe covers your feet will be fine in them down to about 0 degrees F. (When the temp is below that I pull out the winter boots.)

Bottom line: a great, year-round cycling shoe. I'd give them five stars except that after a few months the Velcro on one of the straps pulled off. All the others are fine and I'm sure I could get it replaced, but it was still  a disappointing flaw in an otherwise great product.