I have bought quite a few hats this year.  I've always liked baseball hats, but not the way I look in them. And, there are times and places where you need a hat. Most of the hats I have bought are cheap, or the bill is flat/odd, or the hat is too tall(I'm not an umpire!), or there is something else going on that makes me dislike it.  None of that is a problem with this hat.  One more thing: I am very particular about what I wear.

Color - The hat is a good black, not an 'optical blue'.  If you soak it a few times, it releases a lot of dye, but retains its color.  After several months, lots of sun, and occasional rain, it is still black.  I have a couple of other colors; they are all true to the pictures, bleed color initially if soaked(but retain their color) and look good. (In case you're wondering, I soak all my hats and bandanas to get the excess dye out of them. I have been caught in heavy rain with a new hat and had it bleed all over my clothes.)

Shape - The bill is exactly the right shape.  There is no need to bend, shape, or wear it sideways.  The shape of the hat makes it clear how it should be worn.  The low profile is also good.  It sits pretty much right on top of your head, without much space.  The hat doesn't have panel backings or anything to make it round in the front and crushed in the back; it's the same all around.

Overall, this is a really good all-around hat, and if you want a low-profile hat, you will like it in many colors.  The reason I gave it only 4 stars is that because it's not shaped, the front of the hat may tend to fold in around the seam on the front panels.  That said, it is still a great hat.