Let me speak of this shoe's virtues first: Great style with the cable knit material and stud detail. I have received many compliments. They really look fashionably adorable and for practicality's sake, they are warm. But what's important to note is that whereas they are the right size, the fit above and around the foot is loose, so loose in fact, I feel I might slip out of them while walking. Hasn't happened yet, but I'm not confident it won't. Maybe wear with heavier socks for snugness? Not the kind of clogs to go trapsing around town in. Also, the sole is very heavy, clunky on hardwood floors. I do love the way they look though, especially for the fall. I have no regrets as I bought them on sale.