Pros: snug fit with the ability to work rope and such while staying warm.
Cons: fingers are a bit short (for me) I don't have exceptionally long fingers.
I ordered an XL based on the measuring guide and other reviews, but think a Large
would have fit a bit more snugly. I didn't return them for the smaller size due to
the finger issue.
They are the warmest glove of this type I've found so far.