I'm completely upset with these boots.  I ordered them a week and a half ago, and when they came in today ONE of the shoes was worn.  It had some serious scuffs on the toe and heel--as if someone had caught them on the edge of some stairs.  The sole showed serious ware, and the strap over the laces had a huge indent and black marks where the backle had been adjusted a couple times and dug into the leather.  Also, the laces had dirt marks where it had been laced up then loosened so you could see where the gromets used to sit on the laces.

Not only was ONE show worm, but I went up a half size as recommended and should have gone up a full size, these boots are very tight over the top of the foot.