OK... This is an update from the initial review.  I have tried both the Altra Instinct and the Altra Provision. Based on Looks and Quality I think that the Provision is by far a better shoe.... BUT... As far as foot comfort goes in both running (jogging for me) and daily wear I much prefer the Instinct.  For some reason the Provision with it's firmer midsole doesn't quite jive with my foot. The bottom line for me is always go for 'comfort'.  I'm afraid that my Provisions are going back.  Too bad because overall I think that they are a better shoe. A lot of people are very happy with the Provision so try what works for you.  Altra makes good stuff.