I want to like these boots, but they are really heavy and have just a bit too much extra room in them. If you're standing in place, and have thicker feet or wear huge socks they may work well for you, and the construction and stitching is good. The weight is heavier than any other boot I own in the size and price range, and it wears my feet out over a longer day. I'll pull them out for going out for a couple of hours since they look fairly nice, but I wouldn't recommend these to walk around all day in. More of a 3.5 star boot, but for the price I expect a less weight.