I wear an 8.5 but usually order a 9 in boots. But I ordered an 8.5 because they were cheaper than the 9's. They fit snug but not so snug that they're uncomfortable. I just like a little room for tights but I'll have to wear thin trouser socks. The color is a rich dark roast brown Not a red brown. But I am totally happy considering the price I paid. I'm 5'5" and they come just over my knee but I have really long legs. I love nine west boots they seem especially comfortable to me.