I walk 7 miles a day as a letter carrier for the post office. I go up and down stairs and hills between homes and wanted a shoe that would last for close to a year. I am about to replace this shoe with another pair just like them (Moab Rover) after 10 months. The shoes are wearing through the sole and the top seams that have been glued a couple of places, are coming apart in some places again. When I first tried these on, the insoles were immediately replaced. There wasn't enough cushion in the insoles that came with the shoe for me to be comfortable all day for 8 to 10 hours but the rest of the shoe was comfortable and supportive. They are the kind of shoes you're not thinking about all day. I walked through rainy days and didn't have issues with any leaks, I walked in fall and winter temperatures and felt comfortable above 32 degrees. From a manufacturing standpoint, I though they held up pretty good but not great so I kept it at 4 stars. The interior seam on both sides of the shoes opened up after 6 months. The interior heal has some cracks and tears but that was all I experienced on the inside of the shoe. Like I said, I've ordered a replacement pair so they are doing the job and are far superior to any of the postal shoes offered. Below are photos from 10 months of wear and tear.