Even though Im rating this shoe a 4 I want to emphasize that I love, love, love this pair of shoes. They are so beautiful and classy/chic looking. The shade of pewter matches most every outfit. They look great dressed up or down. I am comfortable wearing them with both dresses and jeans. So why a rating of 4 and not 5. Well, I read the reviews and read the sizing information on the product page which both said the shoe ran small. Therefore I bought a half size larger than my normal size. The shoes run a little big on me. I couldn't reorder because they didn't have my size. So I decided to keep the shoes and get inserts to help with sizing. The inserts actually make the shoes too tight. But, Im not giving up! Leather stretches and I am looking forward to a very comfortable fit after wearing these adorable shoes a few times. If you get the right size you will surely love these shoes. I am very happy with my Earth Anthem shoes.