I'm loving these shoes. They've been great in the snow and winter weather, very warm. I highly recommend getting these only for those temperatures though, they do not breath and your feet will sweat and they will need aired out/odor control eventually, especially after long hikes.

I've used these on a lot of terrain but they are comfortable for all of it. Very cushioned on the feet and the padding on the sides from the weatherproofing keeps things from hitting your ankles on hikes. I've tried on a lot of different hiking mids and these were the best all around cushion/arch support I could find. It feels like how those gimmicky shoes that say they have "air cushions" that wear out in a few weeks are supposed to feel, but these shoes hold up to the test.

I just bought the Redmond low non waterproof version for summer and they are also great, that's how much I loved the waterproof mids. I can't recommend these enough.