4 stars because I love how they look, super cute and i get compliments often. For the price, not bad but don't expect great quality. These are not waterproof, nor leather. Sole is starting to separate from material. I've owned them for about a year. Also, they run large. I'm normally a size 7 med width. They were very roomy. Bought a second pair, went down to size 6, perfect for me. Very flat foot bed also..these are no Uggs!