Bought as a gift for my husband. Watch was running when he opened it. So I think it had been returned. All tags and clear coverings we're still on the watch. My husband likes this watch and after it was set for our time zone, it keeps good time. I have one exactly like it in rose gold that I have had several years and it keeps perfect time.
When this watch arrived it too was out of the tin. After looking at the tin, I think it is a design flaw. Most all tins I have had the top fits over the bottom of the of the tin. The Fossil watch tin, the top fits inside the bottom of the tin allowing the weight of the watch to knock the top off. Mystery solved? We both love these watches and would recommend for anyone wanting a good practical watch.