I received these today.  They seem to have good clips on them.  I am giving these a 3 star review because when I opened the package, they had a very strong smell of mold.  The cardboard, plastic and suspenders had that pungent smell. I don't think it's the dye, it smells like mildew.  Because they seem well made, I am not returning them.  I am soaking the suspenders in a solution of baking soda and then will air dry them.  I can't wear them as they are.  They smell so bad.  If that does not work, I'm going to toss them and not buy this brand again.