Not only too big all around, but the insole was not leather. My error: I failed to note that in the description. Two years ago I purchased through Amazon the perfect loafer from Naturalizer--leather all over, inside and out, including a leather insole and fit like a dream. I thought I'd found it in this shoe. After returning the Saban to Amazon, I've looked at every single pair of Naturalizer loafers available through Naturalizer and Amazon but none has a leather insole. It appears Naturalizer has stopped making fine loafers that are leather through and through. What a shame.