First of all, these are amazing quality boots! I am only giving this boot 4 stars because of the sizing. I went through SO many reviews, not just on Amazon but on other websites as well and so many people said these ran big. I am often between an 8.5 and a 9, but consider myself a true 8.5. I just recently got some new riding boots in a different brand and ended up getting a size 9 and they are a little too big, so with all of these reviews saying these boots ran big I decided not to risk it and ended up getting an 8.5. However, I wish I would have gotten a 9. My toe is right at the edge of the boot, and I definitely don't think I can wear thick socks with these. They aren't uncomfortably small, but it is annoying enough that I really wish i would have gone up to a 9. Other than the sizing issues, these boots are fantastic! I definitely recommend them, but I recommend sizing up if you are between sizes.