These gloves are pretty good. We are using them as our back-up gloves. They are warm, and our 3-year old son thinks it's cool to zipper his hands in. But the wrist part isn't really long enough to fit over his coat, so there's always a little gap, and the zipper doesn't quite fit over his sleeve so it won't go up all the way, which means they don't stay on as well as his primary mittens. But overall they are good gloves.