I own the Coach Olive Loafer in four different colors and I love them.  However, they were not available for good price in the Beechwood color. Therefore, I purchased them in this style: the Arlene. They fit exactly the same as the Olive loafer and are the same excellent quality leather (in my opinion, Coach has the softest, most durable leather in this price range compared to their competition). My only complaint is the bottoms; I didn't realize when I purchased these that the bottoms were not solid rubber, but are leather with cut of for rubber. The first time wearing them, a lot of the leather color in the mid-section under the shoe scraped off, so now it looks gray.  Had I been more cognizant, I would have purchased a different style loafer with solid rubber bottoms.