I give a 4 only because I received all the bright colors and I ordered 2 packs.  If you look at the photo they are shades of beige, grey, light grey, camel and two light pastels.  I would have preferred those, but I received bright blue, pink, green, light blue, grey....it is OK....I will wear them all the time, but I like my panties to match my bras....just my thing