I LOVE these hats. I have had mine for over a year and a half, and have recommended them to friends and bought them as a gift for others as well and no one has ever complained. They really do hold their shape even after being crushed for some time. If you leave it crushed for months at a time, it will be harder to regain its original shape (friend left hers in the trunk under stuff and its a little warped), but by no means is that the fault of the hat and she is still happy with it. If you take care of it and help it retain its shape, it holds beautifully and is a really comfortable hat that comes in gorgeous colors. Its been great when hiking, driving in my Jeep it stays on even with the top down, and just a really good looking hat! If you're up in the air about it, buy it. They sell these at REI as well, if you're curious about sizing or trying it for a feel.