These are robust, and relatively wide, though they seem pretty 4E to me for a 5E shoe.. when I really need an 8E that cannot be found.
They're...  not comfortable, and I get blisters in them when walking long distances not matter what I try to do with laces, a problem I do tend to have, but can normally sort out by adjusting things.
I wanted shoes that lasted longer than the NB shoes I normally have to buy because noone else makes shoes even remotely wide enough, but these aren't wide enough, are uncomfortable even compared to other not wide enough shoes, and have generally underwhelmed me.  They do seem to be built to last, but... that's the only thing keeping their rating from slipping further.
They appear to be as waterproof as they claim.