I will give it 3 stars, because it's a lovely jacket and I would have loved to keep it. But the fit is not for me. I  am 5'3", 115, and the small fit well enough to keep IF the sleeves had not been so long.  Apparently, the "Small Short" does not exist, but that would be my size.  I tried the Medium Short and I was swimming in it. (Although the sleeves on that one were a perfect length!)
(If you are 5'4" or shorter and around 140lbs or more, the Medium Short would be perfect for you!)