Initial review, after a weekend of full use.  Price was right, fit is right on for my foot.  I opted not to go water proof because waterproof boots always make my feet so hot they get uncomfortable.  I use boots like these for daily wear not just camping/hiking.  I wore them around my house and while out walking my property and doing yard work.  The inserts are very comfortable, as is the rest of the boot.  They are a little lower than I expected and my pants will ride on top of the pull tab quite often but not a huge deal.  As long as they hold together as long as my Salomon boots I'll be happy with them.