I would rate them a 5 for the waterproof, but when it comes to comfort/cushy feel on the long walks in the rain they are more of a 2. I wouldn't want to wear them for long jaunts, but they are perfect for walking the dogs in the PNW. Hope they make a model that has more cushioning. The dream would be the Hoka mixed with the waterproof of Salomon. The pull to tighten string is interesting... I just wish there was a quicker way to roll it up and stick it in the little hiding place. When your fingers are cold or you are wearing gloves it takes a bit more time.