I have older Dr. Scholl's diabetes socks, which have lasted way beyond a normal socks life (like 8 years several pairs) These looked the same in the package and on the mannequin legs.  The top appeared the same as well.  However, these are a bit smaller, tighter weave and do not go up the calf as far.  They fall in an awkward place on the calf and heal.  I am 5'5", my shoe size is 8 (sometimes narrow), I have thin ankles and lower legs right up to the bottom of my calves, which then are of regular medium calf size. I have always worn standard regular women's sized socks.  These socks just aren't quite cut right and even the heal doesn't come up far enough on the back of the foot.  These for me are actually a bit uncomfortable and I have to keep pulling them into position.  Unfortunately, I bought like 10 pair, as I thought these were like the ones I have had (for too many years) and once washed these definitely weren't the same. I feel the fit is for a smaller than average woman's foot and would be better on a small foot and shorter leg.  Additionally, I get the diabetic socks because if a sock is too tight I swell around the seam and I found diabetic socks are great for keeping swelling down.  I do not have diabetes so I cannot attest to the usefulness in said regard. I still give these socks perhaps 2.5 stars as they are quite thick and sturdy and not made cheaply. So for the people these socks might fit, you should have a durable, long-lasting pair of socks.