The shoe is almost perfect. My true size is 9.5. My feet are somewhat wide, and flat. That said, the shoes are perfectly comfortable, due to the softness of the leather. They are just long enough (barely!) if they were any shorter in length, they would be uncomfortable. The foot bed feels nice and seems to be lightly padded. The yellow color is sophisticated and not gaudy at all. In fact, it's practically a lighter mustard color. The things I don't like so much are the wavy part at the top. Some of those were bent when the shoes arrived and I had to lay a book on top of the shoes to straighten them out. Also, because my feet are somewhat flat, the shoes seem to bow outward on the sides, which causes the wavy part to look less flattering. It would look much better if the wavy/scalloped part would cradle the foot, rather than sticking up or leaning away from the foot. Because of the lovely color and comfort of the shoe, I've decided to keep them, but I think the styles without the scalloped top would look better on me.