I bought a size 14 - I am 5'2, 165lbs but my weight is pretty proportionate and this dress clearly looked too big on me, although not baggy or anything. You could just tell that it should have been a little bit more fitted than it was. The length hits below my knees and for a short girl, that doesn't work. I still gave it 4 stars because buying the wrong size was my fault. The dress (if I bought the correct size) would have been awesome. The uniqueness of the collar and cuffs set it off. I wore it without the belt because unfortunately the belt cheapened the look of the dress. I received a lot of compliments - goes well with black or red shoes.