I had previously ordered one of the extra long tanks from active basic without the shelf bra and in comparison the other one seemed a bit more flimsy and was looser at the bottom hem. This one feels slightly more substantial. It's not as thick a material as some of my other camis ( I really like the ones from BLVD, but they are currently not available with Prime), but it will do, especially for the price point. The length was long, as well, which I prefer when I wear leggings. I ordered the small and it fit as expected. I'm 5', 112 lbs, 32F (or if I used American bra sizing I'd be closer to a 34d). Since the Blvd tanks that I like so much haven't been available, I have tried several other of the cheaper brands available on Amazon and I have found that they all really vary within the brand. Even my Blvds. Some would be slightly shorter, some would seem tighter. It seems like a gamble what you will get. So take that as you will. I will probably order some more of these. I like the Shelf tanks to sleep in or to just wear around the house. They certainly do not offer enough support that a person could go out in public without a bra or get the lift that a bra provides, but they are fine for my purpose.