Quality of leather = 5 stars
Look of shoe = 5 stars
Comfort of shoe (toe box) = 3 stars
Sizing is generous, especially when you consider the subtle amount of stretch you will get with leather over time. I typically wear a 6.5 (or 37) and I would suggest sizing down by 1/2 size or order your preferred size and a half size smaller. (i.e. 6 & 6.5)

I opted to return this pair. Though they were visually to my liking, the level of toe comfort was certainly lacking. If Cole Haan offered a similar style with an almond or round toe, I would absolutely purchase a pair.