Buyer beware. This shoe came used and scuffed right out of the box. We always use caution with shoes and pat & leather warranted the extra mile in caution; but as soon as I took it out there was obvious scuffs on the back (heel) and side of the shoe (only took out the right shoe; left stayed wrapped). This is vendor related and not necessarily the manufacturer.

The 3-star is based on the shoe quality and not related to the obvious prior usage that caused the scratches.

Now for the shoe review. We bought this for our 11yo size 4 and this shoe was 1/2 to full size TOO LARGE, and the toe part of the shoe is rather large. The toe area seemed as if it was meant for someone of a much larger/heavier body that would have much fuller toes. I can literally place a finger on top of her toes while she wears the shoes and barely touch one another. The strap was another minor issue; the bow on the strap is fixed too close to the buckle (too close to the end of the strap) and does not allow you to adjust the strap correctly to fit your ankle.
The shoe is very pretty and would otherwise make for a great shoe; but too many little flaws to give it a better rating.