I really liked the boot and as soon as I tried it on it fit perfect and looked perfect. I was completely set in on keeping it until I realized that there was a small split of the leather on one side of the the left boot. I think that maybe someone with not a narrow foot tried too hard to put it on because the boots kinda look like they've been around, which I sort of liked because the leather seemed a bit softer and broken in. Anyways, they are nice boots but one was ripped so I'm returning them.