These shoes are well constructed and look like they'll last forever.  We'll see how the elastic holds out because that's always the first to go on well-built shoes.  More traction was expected from CAT, but overall, the shoe is of excellent quality. Durable thick leather, comfortable foot cushion, good height.  Look a little boxy to wear with a dress, but great with pants.  The buckle caused soreness in both feet and a lasting injury on one (a few days).  With socks okay.  Hope this goes away when they break in.  Runs large. I ordered 8 which is always safe. They're too long but will be okay..