I've ordered these shirts twice; the first time was a few years ago and I love them. The fabric was thick and durable and the fit was great, long enough without fitting like a tent like you sometimes get with tall sizes. After a couple of years, I ordered a couple new ones. Unfortunately, there was a noticeable dip in quality; the necks on the new batch stretched out in weird ways, and they got holes in the armpits after only a few wearings/washings. I don't know if I got a bad batch the second time, or if the overall quality has dipped over the last couple of years, but it wasn't consistent.

Five stars for the first batch I ordered, 1 star for the second.