For the price I gave it a solid 4 stars.  It's not without it's problems though.  First, Amazon needs some better pictures on here.  There's small variations that make a difference in person.  There's models with cases that are black, dark grey, dark grey w/bronze tint, light grey, light grey w/bronze tint, and brushed silver, hands that are matte and polished, seconds hands that are white, matte, and polished, dials that are dark grey and black, lettering that is medium grey, light grey, white, and tan, and so on, but it's really hard to tell these differences by the pictures.  There's also variations from low cost production - I ordered a replacement for one that came in broken and there were differences in case color.  I've also seen them in stores with other production variations.  I ordered a bunch and had to send most of them back because of that, and also some looked used and one arrived broken.  It ticks pretty loud, and if you take it off and place it on a hard surface such as a table you can actually hear it across a quiet room.  The crown on one that I kept actually pulled completely out once when I tried to set the time!  I pushed it back in and it hasn't come back out since then.

This is just a personal preference, but the smaller set of numbers are too big in relation to the larger numbers and it makes the dial look too busy.  From a few feet away on models with higher contrast between the dial/numbers it looks like there's a bunch of words written around the dial instead of numbers.  On most other field watches you'll see that that the inner set of numbers are much smaller.

Still, it's a good looking watch, rugged in appearance, and makes for a good beater watch that you won't mind actually wearing and getting a little dinged up when you go outdoors.  I hike mountains, backpack, climb, scramble, camp, kayak, and go to the beach a lot, and I can't imagine wearing the $500 Hamilton Khaki Field 40mm Automatic that I had while doing those things without getting it scratched up.  Sure the Hamilton looked a lot nicer when you are staring at it on your wrist. But from a normal viewing distance that your girlfriend or friends would see it from there wasn't a huge difference.  The straps on these things are pretty good too, especially considering the price.  Good, non "plasticky" watch straps are surprisingly expensive and/or hard to find!