I love this pair of shoes - in the white ones I already had.  They fit perfectly and were comfortable the first time I put them on.  I am returning the black pair I just received because while the left shoe fit perfectly, the right shoe had a tight place that couldn't be fixed.  It is right above where the laces start, and it is too tight even with the laces removed.  I don't know the names of all the pieces of a shoe, so I can't be more specific than that.  It seems as though two pieces didn't quite meet so they were pulled tight to make it work.

As for the fit rating, the shoes fit so I had to pick that, but it overlooks the one place they were "too small".