I would actually give it minus stars if I could. Of course, the window to return is quite short and I'd say for good reason. This isn't an item you wear every day, but by the 3rd wearing, it had split along the toe bend line. It was already too late to return it so I used a boot repair glue and sealed it. The very next time I wore them, Ta Da - another split! This one didn't even have the excuse of a bend line, it was on the side. At this point, I consider them garbage - after wearing them a total of 4 times! Total garbage. Buyer beware!