So to start off I wore the Reef sandals with the bottle openers on the bottom for a year and I loved them, and they were correctly sized. I got a size ten of these phantom sandals and it was way to small, but I went ahead and returned for an 11, they were also too small and different from the first pair, like different materials used in the strap.
Finally ordered a 12 and they actually fit (my size ten feet) but the under part of the straps are cratchy and uncomfortable, and I have medium high arches but the arch bump on these is huge, I was worried id roll my ankle again because they made both my feet tilt outward. And they just look ugly, these fit as in my feet will go in them but the back is almost level with my heel while the front sticks out like 2 inches past my toes, pic included of the size 12s