I bought the same size I wear in traditional canvas Toms, and unfortunately, this was a mistake. They fit different and have a narrow toe compared to the canvas Toms. They are SUPER cute and I got a lot of compliments the one time I wore them (people couldn't believe Toms makes dress shoes this cute!) but wearing them one time killed my poor feet because they're a size too small. I haven't dared wear them since, and since Ive worn them, cant return them.