I would give five stars if the toe was a LITTLE less rounded, but otherwise, they are great.  Especially for the price. Saved me a trip boot-shopping.  Never ordered boots online before, but am happy with purchase.  Like the color, the fit.  I am a 7 1/2, ordered a 7, and they fit fine.  Overall, very satisfied.  My skinny jeans fit inside, which I am really happy about.