Love these boots.

Pros
Price is cheap
True to size
Look expensive
No smell
Fast delivery
Comfy
No need to break in
Fits my wide calf with no problems

Cons
Last about a year or some times a little longer
Belt around the bottom of the boot makes noise. To fix it tighten it.

To sum it up i love these boots and have purchased them in black 3x. I have to re purchase about every year. I look for other boots and haven't found any that compare.