These t-shirts are soft and comfortable, definitely nicer than the Hanes Beefy-T, but they are LONG. Why?? Nobody wants a T-shirt that hovers somewhere around mid-thigh! I bought them to wear around the house and in bed, so I don't care, but this would be a problem if I had any intention of wearing them outdoors. The sizing around the chest and shoulders is accurate enough. I recommend washing in cold water only, because these definitely shrink.
Tl;dr:
PROS: Very soft fabric, nice colors, good fit around chest and shoulders
CONS:Shrinks, too long