Darn near perfect! Fit snug but not tight, insulated, thick soles, padded collar, will keep my feet warm to very cold temps. Watertight, they will be great for non snow, or light snow conditions or rainy cold spring weather.. These are a great bargain and should last for a few years. I have a similar pair I bought from Amazon 3 yrs ago, I still use them, they are holding up well, I expect these will also. They are different brand than the older pair I have, which is lighter and not insulated as well as subject pair. This new pair will be set aside for colder weather.