I have little feet.  It means I have extremely limited selection (oh how I wish I had a size 10 foot!) and when I find something that actually fits, is high quality, and looks good I am probably happier than I should be.  This shoe fits as expected, and as other reviewers have said may chafe a bit at the ankles as the edge breaks in, but that is maybe two wearings.  The shoe is comfortable, stealthy and on most slacks or jeans look like dress boots.

I will get the brown ones too now that I know these are keepers.  I am in California so I won't be able to test the waterproof aspect much, but as good as these are I expect they'd work just fine in wet weather.