I'm not sure why some Gloria Vanderbilt Amanda jeans fit perfect and feel great,  while others seem stiff,  less stretchy / comfortable.  These are not as comfortable as some of my Amanda jeans, so I only gave them 3 stars.

Overall, GV Amanda jeans are the best I have ever found.  They have a classic fit and the stretch makes them very comfy!  Most are soft and well made.

Maybe some people are selling the rejects?