I got a number of compliments on these boots.  Look great, nice to wear with just about anything.  They aren't really waterproof, but there's a spray that can solve that problem.  I have long, narrow feet with an over-pronation problem.  It's tough to find boots that feel comfortable right away, but these did.  Of course, there's really no arch support, but they, at least, have a substantial sole, so I could walk around for hours without discomfort.

My only reason for not giving 5 stars was because they aren't waterproof.