*2 MONTH UPDATE*
Ive bumped these from two stars to three. After having worn them for a while now, they have broken in slightly, but still fit like a size 9 (even though they're a 10.5) Personally, I still wouldnt recommend going through the trouble of ordering these.

The saving grace to these shoes is that they look/feel awesome. I eagerly anticipate my return going through so I can order a different size, which leads me to why this is rated so low:

I wear a 9, sometimes a 8.5. I owned a pair of the original Mesh Portmore's, which ran about .25 of a size too small. Figuring as much, I went ahead and ordered a 9.5. I honest to goodness couldn't even get my foot in! I'm going to need at LEAST a 10.5 for these to even be wearable.
These shoes are awesome, and to me - they're worth sending them back to get the right size. However, if you want a pair of shoes you won't have to reorder 12 times, I would not recommend.