These are a really good looking pair of boots. My foot is between a regular and wide. I ordered a pair of ramblers in 11.5 Wide and now that they have broken in are just a touch too big. I ordered these in an 11.5 Regular. Initially I thought I would have to return them as they were very tight in my feet. I decided instead to stretch them with a technique I learned on youtube. I gently stretched them to speed up the break in period and they are now extremely comfortable. I wear them almost every day. The Ramblers are now my yard work/woodshop boot. (I may invest in a pair in 11.5 regular In the future because they are a handsome boot.)
All in all, I am very happy with the boots. I recommended them to a friend and he purchased a pair of Ariats as his first western boot also.

I would recommend going to a western shop and being properly fitted rather than going through a trial and error process. Luckily, amazon makes it very easy to return and exchange items.