Im a little unsure how to rate these. I had to return them because I ordered my usual size, 9 1/2, but they were way too long. I measured and there was about 1 1/2 inches between my big toe and the end of the shoe. I would have ordered a size down but they were also too thin. Im giving them 4 stars because they came in perfect condition, looked good, and looked as though they would breathe well. They also refunded me for my return promptly. They might be great for people with thin feet, possibly consider ordering 1/2 a size down. If you have avg or above avg width feet l would suggest considering another shoe.