I would give 3.5 stars but I can't do halves. My main issues that there is no arch support in these shoes. I had to in insoles because I need arch support,so it made the shoes a bit tight. Easy fix with a heater or hair dryer.  My other issue is that I had been wearing these boots for about a week and the rubber heels are peeling off. Doesn't help that there doesn't seem to be any glue holding the heel done just 3 nails.

Now after those issues. The shoes are great. I've been wearing them in the rain and and they don't get soaked though. They feel good to walk in for hours.