This is my first front-close bra, so I'm not sure how it compares to others. That said, it feels comfortable and secure, and the adjustable straps are GREAT. I like wearing tank tops, and the different strap placements are variable enough that I can hide the straps easily, and since they're smooth with no lace or embellishments, it's very discreet. The cups and back are smooth, so it doesn't show though something close-fitting.
The only thing keeping this from 5 stars is that the lining isn't quite as thick as I would have liked. I have to be careful when the weather is a little on the nippy side, so to speak. If you order the correct cup size, and if you don't have that issue as much, you should be fine with ribbed shirts, even if they're close-fitting. If you're more towards my end of the spectrum, though, I wouldn't plan to wear this with a smooth monochrome top.