Was looking for a good walking shoe with support.....not a major hiking boot.  Something light weight for all day walking for an up coming trip overseas and my Keens are just too heavy for my needs.  After reading the reviews from others who suggested going up in size - I decided to purchase the 9.5 ( normally I wear an 8.5 or 9)  Bingo - the fit is just right.  My inserts fit perfectly making the boot fit extremely comfortably.  I too recommend going up at least half to a whole size.  The blue is dark but feels extremely neutral and I think they will go with everything in my wardrobe.