I always put 3 stars because those are the reviews I read.  The good news is these are really good pants. They are great material, cut right and a good length. I've bought 2 pairs now and going to get more. They are a bit small, meaning I wear 35 and ordered 36 based on reviews and they are just a touch tight at first and then sort of 'wear in' to fit just right. Order a size larger than normal, meaning I can wear some 34" and these have to be 36" to fit me.  The fit and feel great, the material is tough but comfortable. Hope this helps.