Good quality shoe, especially for $18.  Looks better than the pictures.  Sized correctly; uppers are actual swede and man made materials and very good quality; tongue is comfortable and lacing is good quality nylon.  Insole is thin and provides little cushion, but is comfortable throughout a day's wear.  I have no complaints, and would buy again.  To manufacturer, I would recommend a thicker, more comfortable insole (insert) for 5 a star rating.