Had the size been correct I might have rated higher.  I ordered an 8 (my normal size). I did return them for a size larger.  These boots appear to be very well made and durable. I only wore them around the house before deciding I needed to order a larger size to accommodate thick socks. With thin socks or barefoot, they fit well but I want these for snow and other recommendations state they keep your feet warmer with thick socks.  In my two hour trial around the house, they did keep my feet quite toasty.  Although we don't have snow often, I still need a good warm pair to go out sledding and playing.(Still a kid at heart.) I have not yet had a chance to try them out in the snow yet.  Will update my review after that.