So I rate this shirt 3 stars for the following reasons:
1.) The collar is incredibly small and almost choking. I have a 16 neck and I wear Size L in 95% of my shirts. Im very athletic and fit not fat. Check out the picture. One is another well known brand in Large. The neck difference is substantially different.
2.) The shirt is tight fitting so if you're not comfortable with a shirt that shows every curve or muscle of your body don't buy it. The sleeves cover the first 5% of my bicep basically where the bicep meets the deltoids. Its so tight fitting Im scared if I breathe too hard itll rip. Which brings me to #3.
3.) - When I think of vintage shirts I think of the super soft shirt that feels like its been made to sleep in its so comfortable. Like real vintage shirts or old Rock concert shirts. This shirt is not that kind of soft. Granted its better than just your everyday cotton used for free promo shirts or cheap tourist style t-shirts. Its nicer than that. But only because its thinner so therefore a little air can flow through it.