Overall this boot is great. It's a high quality fashion boot: real leather, rubber in the sole, and carefully made. It looks great!

I bought this to wear at work, where I'm on my feet the whole shift. It wasn't terrible, but it's so much better with insoles added in. I also found that I need to wear thin socks with it because the heel rubs hard against my socks and rubs my skin. No problem with thin dress socks. The fit is good, but not much room to spare. Thin socks prevents my pinkie toes from rubbing against the side, and I have narrow feet.

4/5 stars because they're very good, but needed insoles and are slightly snug in some areas and fit perfectly in others.