Here are the pluses:

The fit of the Yukata is excellent. The size chart was precisely accurate for me (60, 190 pounds, size LL).

Some reviewers  did not like the velcro belt. I found it to be good-looking and easy to use.

The appearance of this Yukata is terrific. The first time I wore it in front of my girlfriend she gasped. In a good way. She calls me her Shogun. LOL

Here are the minuses:

The colors are limited. I wish they made one in red, or in red and white. Either would be much sharper than gray.

The fabric is odd. The description says it is 100% cotton. It feels like monofilament (heavy synthetic) fishing line. It is a bit rough.

Summary:

All in all Im reasonably pleased. If the fabric felt like cotton I would have given it five stars.