I received this shirt last night.  I have not washed it or ironed it so this review is about the shirt brand new, not whether it holds up.  I ended up returning it today (the next day) before I wrote this review.

Overall it is a very nice shirt.  But it was too short to tuck in.  Great for a casual look, untucked.  I included a photo next to another TH slim fit shirt of the same neck and sleeve size.  I lined the collar buttons up and measured them side by side.  There was a significant difference.  And if casual untucked is what you are going for, then this is the shirt for you.  It was well made with no loose strings.  Although it says non-iron, it was still very wrinkled compared to my other non-iron shirts even though it was brand new.  My other non-iron shirts (I have quite a few from a variety of brands) are ACTUALLY non-iron.  This shirt was CRAZY wrinkled.  But, I returned it with no problems at all and I was generally impressed by the vibrancy of the colors and pattern.  Material was a bit thinner than any other TH dress shirts I own, but not sheer either.  I would give it 3 stars for a dress shirt.  But as an untucked casual I give it 4.