At about $/tie, it's really hard for me to be critical of these ties.  They are a bit shorter than most, but I'm 5'10 and they are just long enough.  How well they stand up over time seems to vary a bit depending on the weave and finish, but they look fine through quite a few wearings.  And sure, not all of the styles in a package of 6 are ones I probably would have picked out individually.  But let's be rational here... you get 6 ties for less than the price of 1 in most men's departments.  The value (i.e., bang for the buck) of these ties is amazing if you ask me.  I'd definitely recommend them.