Ordered by my wife: "I normally wear a size 7.5/8, and have flat feet. Based on the reviews, I sized up. Despite the fact that I have virtually no arch, my feet are still very narrow. I found that while the toe box fit, the rest of the shoe was loose. The shoe felt "long" on my foot as well. I also felt that the shoe was incredibly boxy--my husband said that the shoes looked oversized and boxy. This could have been because the size that I ordered wasn't working for me. While I also found the Ashby loafer to have the same issues with sizing/length, I felt that the Ashby loafer looked more attractive and less boxy when worn."