My 15 month old is a messy eater and the Bumkins bibs we were using were not getting washed as fast as we needed them, so I figured these would be perfect since a quick rinse would solve my problems. I put the bib on my daughter and turned to get her plate and within seconds she had the bib off. I thought I didn't hook it properly, so I put it back on and she had it right back off. All it took was a few tugs and she had it off. I really wanted to love these bibs since they would save me time and washes, but it looks like we will be going back to the Bumkin bibs.