Your expectations will determine your satisfaction with this one. Be aware its thin. The black one is somewhat sheer. Its also not big enough to do fancy styles on a big girl. Im 53 185 lbs and I cannot wear it as pictured, tied behind the neck. I can only wear it tied around my waist or bust. Nevertheless I love it. It makes a great cover up in the sweltering heat because of how thin it is. And I plan on using it as a fabulous scarf in the winter. Definitely getting more. Seriously its been 107 lately and I am wearing it every morning and evening. Take note that the fabric is certainly delicate and youll have to take care not to snag it or stress the fibers by tying it too tightly.