I gave this 4 stars because they are nice looking, however, I had to send them back because they weren't wide enough.  I found on Amazon  a really cute pair of red shoes, that are actually wide, with about an inch heel and the shoe flatters, the foot.  Since I could depend on the fit, I ordered another color in that brand.  However, these Clarks are beautiful.  It's only my chubby feet that can't in.