I absolutely am in love with this little duffel bag! Dont be fooled by other reviews.. its the exact size stated in the description (16) and its PERFECT to use as a personal item on airlines. There was no smell in the one I received. I took one star away due to the quality of the hardware on the long strap (see pics). It may not hold up if the bag is stuffed to capacity. However its still a great little duffle and Im so happy I purchased it. Im thinking of getting these as gifts for my nieces for the holidays. Let me know if the pics are helpful 