The reviews confused me - some good and some not so good - but I took a chance anyways. I normally wear XS but just received moved up to a S since I've been hitting the gym and my chest/shoulders have been growing. After reading reviews, I ordered a M. It was still tight fitting on me (which is perfectly fine), but I wanted it to be a little loose. One of my shirts had a hole all the way down the side seam. Honestly, you're taking a chance with these shirts. if you want to order them, go ahead but make sure to order AT LEAST TWO SIZES UP and don't be surprised if there's some wear and tear.

Something I just remembered that was a little odd: only one of my shirts had a tag on it.. made me wonder if I got a hand-me-down or a return...