I was worried about the quality due to some poor reviews, but these boots are great. Very nice quality. Faux fur lining is all on the inside, and the soles are extremely thick and durable. The knit is not water-proof, duh, but the soles are, like the description would suggest. Seems like other reviewers were confused about this. They are super comfortable, warm and cozy, and well made. These cost much less than other well known brands I have purchased, and the quality is much better. FYI, I purchased the black knit boots.