The shoes fit very well and were comfortable from the time I put them on. They look great and have a really good grip. Why not five stars? Like some other people, I am totally amazed that they would sew the lace to the shoe. Not only that but in a place that makes it virtually impossible to replace the lace even if you were to try and cut it out. That's what happens when you move production to China - yes made in China so says the label sewn on the tongue. I have worn Dunham for many years and always been very happy. I thought other reviewers had just not looked at the assembly well enough. Probably the last Dunhams I will purchase. Exactly what happens when you take your eyes off the product and start looking at the bottom line only. No doubt the shoes will outlast the laces but maybe that is the whole plan. For $130 you would think you should be able to wear them longer than the laces last. Too bad.