Well-made, fit as expected, good price, arrived promptly in good shape, would -- no, WILL order again.
Now here's the long version...
My husband has worn Johnson & Murphy penny loafers for years, but griped that the soles wore out way too quickly. He caught a pair of burgundy Cole Haan Pinch Grand Penny Loafers  on sale at Dillard's a couple of months ago, and LOVED them immediately. He's an old-school healthcare professional (no comfy scrubs and logs for my boy, oh no!) and wears them almost daily for work along with the dress shirt, dress slacks, tie, and white coat. Then one day he was cleaning up in the office and spilled bleach on them. I mean, *I* couldn't see where the spots were after he put polish on them, until I turned a bright light on. But yeah, okay, whatevs -- came here, found another burgundy pair, more than the sale price at Dillard's but less than a new pair of Johnson & Murphys. All is well.
The bleached pair is at the shoe repair shop, getting dyed black.
--In particular, the Pinch Grand has a textured section on the sole that he says is much better than the J&Ms, which were kind of slippery. The CH Pinch Penny Loafer lacks this detail. --