Im giving it a 3 because although they were way too tight, narrow, and the sizing was small, the soles did seem like theyd be comfortable and I liked the color (ordered both the gray and solid black) and price. They offer these shoes on the American Eagle website for double the price! So disappointed I must return them. I would not recommend these shoes for anyone on the regular width line and if you do have a more narrow foot, I would recommend AT LEAST a half size bigger than your normal size if not even a whole size bigger.