For a size 8, I found these to be a bit large; I had to add a couple of heel guards (one on top of another) to keep them from slipping off my heels.  I normally wear 8 1/2 W but ordered the 8 W given other reviews.  The rest of the shoe is perfect.  These are incredibly comfortable, despite the heel height.  I wear them all day at the office, much of the time sitting but still my feet and legs feel great, and I'm in my 50s so have given up on a lot of heels.  I don't come home wanting to kick them off as I sometimes do with other shoes.  They are a nice heavy leather that you can see and feel.