Nice Boots. Only time will tell if they hold up half as well as Redwings or Thorogoods. I figured at $100 less, they were worth a try. I have to clarify the "Fit as expected" heading. The only reason the boots fit as expected is because i ordered a half size smaller than usual. This was after reading many reviews that recommended i do so. I would recommend the same, as the half size smaller fit me perfectly.
I would also recommend a decent pair of insoles to replace the ones (with no arch support) that came with the boots. They are stiff out of the box, so treat them with your favorite leather conditioner/waterproofing and expect a little break in time. Mine are already comfortable after one solid work week.
I will try to update in 6 months or when they fall apart. Which ever comes first.