I don't feel that I should rate it less than a "4" just because it didn't fit perfectly. It was snug, but then I am a wide-foot gal. Sometimes I can do a "B" if the shoe runs a hair large. In this case, I was just hoping that a regular size would have been that (a hair larger).
Bottom line, though, is that it is VERY attractive, and the shoe IS comfortable (the insole).