Quality-wise, this shirt is good. It's well-made, the fabric is both sturdy and comfortable, and the stitching is strong.

But style-wise, the buttoned oxford collar seems weird on a casual shirt like this. Maybe it's just me (and my wife), but I don't really like the way I look in this. My work attire is pretty formal, so I'm no stranger to this sort of look, but on a short-sleeved shirt it just seems off.