Not for me. I have wider calves but these seemed to be so short on my leg. I'm 5'7''. They really fell below the knee and made me look frumpy. The fit was okay. I'm a 9 1/2/10 and usually go bigger for boots since you wear a thicker sock.  These worked fine with ankle socks. No rub. Definitely sturdy, firm boot. I just wasn't happy with the style. If it's your taste, then I say they're a good investment for a long time rough boot. Not for me. Wished I could have returned but I wore them to see if my taste would change.  Ended up selling at a yard sale and it broke my heart that I paid too much for something I didn't love. Trust it went to a good home and will get good wear.