I've purchased several pairs of boots at this price point over the past few years, and so far these exceed expectations. They are by far the most comfortable that I've had, including a larger opening at the top that allows pants to be tucked inside easily and allows for much more natural gait. Size seems pretty accurate - I wear a 9 or 9.5 shoe, and the size 9 in these boots is a tad snug with socks, but comfortable.