The boots are probably great but I never wore them. Many of the reviews note that they easily fit wide calves, but apparently my calves are unusually wide because they did not fit mine....well they did if I wore them with bare legs, but not over pants. I tried ordering 2 different sizes, a 9 and a 10 (normally I wear a 9). The 9 fit my feet perfectly but not my calves. The 10 was too big for my feet and still did not fit my calves. So, Ive given them a 3 stars for not having different boot opening sizes. :-/