These definitely did the job of poofing out the flower girl dresses.  Some reviewers have said that it didn't have enough poof, but I think they were probably using them under cotton dresses. I used them under dresses with tull material in the skirt, and it added the perfect amount of poof.  I also liked the draw string feature that help to adjust to my 2yr old and 4yr old's waist lines.  I had to trim the skirt a little at the bottom of the 2yr old's petticoat, because it was a tad too long.

The only thing I hated about this product, is that it has a strong fish odor.  I used febreeze twice and had it under the fan for two days in a row, and the smell was still faintly there by the time the wedding came.  Pretty gross. Did the job, but would not buy again due to the smell.