I did not buy these boots on Amazon, but came looking so I can get a new pair. I really like how they fit and how they look. I have them in the lighter color which I see many people are stating it is not the same color. I think it is pretty darn close. May not be as light as some of the picture show, but it is pretty accurate. The boots are comfortable and sturdy and provide a cute rugged look. The only reason I did not give them five stars (and the reason I want a new pair) is because the material on the toe of the boots is scuffed off and it looks bad. Cant recall if I have had these one year or two. Regardless, at this price Ill get another pair to look fresh!