After just over a year of near daily use in our garden, chicken run, dog run, and yard, these little boots are going strong!  Easy to rinse off when they get muddy, even after the mud dries for a few days. The color has held fast. Easy to slip on with bare feet or thick socks, definitely waterproof, and comfortable enough to wear all day working outside. My only complaint is that, as you can see from the pic, the piping is coming off. Kind of a bummer but overall not a huge deal.  I kinda want to order them and yellow too! 