It should probably be 2-stars but these did fit well and I felt they had a lot of stability.  The problem is that I ordered these about three weeks ago and thinking I had to break them in before my hiking trip (next week) I wore them a couple of times to the gym and for a few short city walks (like 30 minutes each, nothing strenuous).  And they've already torn in a really odd spot.  Around the inside rim and it looks like it might be from the hard plastic inside the fabric?  I'm not entirely sure but I really would've expected at least a couple months before this kind of wear, especially for a running shoe where I probably actually only ran two or three times in on a treadmill.  They also aren't really black or dark like the photo.  More of a gray.
They were about $50 so I didn't expect too much out of them and, able to look passed the color, liked the fit.  I'll still wear them on my trip and hopefully a quick sew job will extend the life.. but I am sadly disappointed.