Firstly, the four stars rating is because the shoes I received runs one size smaller in comparison to other sandals I buy.  I bought the Neon Citron Patent color (size 9 my usual size) and it is absolutely beautiful! The sandal is lightly padded and felt comfortable when I tried them on.  I am not sure if there is an explanation to the fit of true size for some customers, while for the rest of us it runs larger or smaller, however, with that being said I am going up one size and try again because I do love the sandals.

I definitely recommend buying these shoes, and as far as fit is concerned, well take a chance on your true size or start a half size larger.  And if that fails, Amazon will accept your returns very easily.