Bought these for my son who has large, wide feet. They fit great and he says they are the most comfortable shoe he's had in ages. However, the sole has ripped away from the upper part of the shoe after only 2 months of wear. He is hard on shoes, but I've never bought anything for him that has torn up this quickly. He enjoyed them for a couple of months though. I have to say, shoes lasted much longer when they were stitched to the sole rather than glued like this...and I can't afford Redwings.
Update: He begged me to buy these again, so I did. He loves these shoes and they are very comfy for a big guy. I hope these last longer than the last pair!