Got this because of brand and Ice color for Spring use. The extra large feels a tad smaller than usual but fits just good enough room wise. Thankfully no feather leakage so far. The pictures flatter the jacket but it is still decent in person. I say this because it is not as plump looking to see or touch in person.. I'm not sure I would have bought this if I had actually inspected it first. The overall quality is not easy to rate because the jacket is very light weight. it is very comfortable which is a big plus. I'm knocking off a star due to the extra large size being between a large and extra large. Remember that light weight in this case means not for cold temps. This jacket is fine between 50 and 60 degrees roughly so keep that in mind. Order up a size if you intend to wear something bulky under it for colder weather use. For me, I intend to put this over long and short tee shirts on cooler mornings when I walk my dog or run an errand. Finally, I suggest you pick a great color choice available with Spring or early Fall in mind. Make it a fun addition to your outerwear when the temperature and mood seem right.