I wasn't sure how to answer the "How does this product fit?" question. Here is why:

I am a pretty solid 7.5 in all shoe styles BUT in Frye I am almost always a size 7. This boot was reviewed as being way too small, here and elsewhere on internet tubes but I had run into this issue before and no matter what the reviews say (TOO BIG! TOO SMALL!) I still end up in a size 7. Seeing reviews that only 55% thought it was true to size made me pause. I ordered an 8 (Go up a FULL size!) and they were comically big so I ordered my usual size and they were too small, so I finally ended up in a 7.5...Sorry for the hassle Amazon! :(

This boots are awesome. I have both Black & Charcoal. I think of Charcoal as grey/blackish but for Frye, Charcoal is most certainly a dark brown.