So far so good.  I wore a 10.5 in my other Stacy Adams but they were more of a boxy toe.  I ordered the same in this shoe and they fit fine but I can see how some might think they run big.  This shoe has more of a point to it than other dress shoes that I've had so I don't expect my toe to come as close to the end as normal.  It's a style thing and I think they look good.  I expect that if I ordered a size down my small  toes would be cramped on the sides.