I ordered the black faux leather in 8 wide calf (normally I am a regular 8 in boots). I was happy with the look of these boots when they arrived, and they fit perfectly true to size. I got wide calf because I like the look of a looser fit on the calf. In terms of aesthetics and fit, everything was good. The next day, I wore them to my office job. Somehow, by the end of the day the faux leather fabric had rubbed off of the tip of one of the boots...how that managed to happen while sitting at a desk all day is beyond me. I bought these specifically for work, and now they are damaged and completely useless. Needless to say, I am currently in the process of returning them. Terrible quality and not worth the money.