The only reason I didn't give this 5 stars is due to time in the shoe. The shoe is comfortable and doesn't look bad at all. My initial walking in it have been good but I haven't walked a great distance in it yet. Fit is good. I typically wear a 14 but after getting another pair of Brooks I went with the wider shoe and that was better (even though I don't typically go with a wide shoe). The shoes were sent out and arrived quickly so no issues with the seller. Overall it's a good shoe so far. Time will tell how it holds up and how it makes my feet feel.