The good: the shoes were great with water and mud, didn't rub anywhere, and didn't make the three year olds feet hot, which is a consideration here in Arizona. He got them on and off himself easily, and loves the bright colors.

Not so good: These shoes lasted our 3yp just about a month - see picture. The price was right so I took a risk getting sandals without the reinforced toe (like keens) and shame on me for doing it because he destroyed them. FYI, he is an active three year old and wore them bike riding, on the climbing structure, and generally just running around.

Sizing: We initially got a size larger with the intention of letting him grow into his sandals over the summer, but they were huge. We returned the larger for his current size with the understanding that theyd only last a short time, which was okay since they weren't expensive. Obviously now its a moot point.