I've never owned crocs before but took a job where I have to walk from a parking garage to my building, which is no short jaunt. So, I tried what the nurses use. At first they're crazy comfy but they don't STAY like that for the whole time, but I do have high arches so that may be a reason. To (me) they seem to run a bit large but that could be because they're a wide shoe? In all fairness I'd like to give a 3.5/5 But they don't have that option:)