I wanted to love these because they appeared well-constructed, and I loved the color and style when they arrived.  However, it is difficult to rate these as I didn't keep them long because of the firm arch support in the footbed of the shoe, which doesn't work for my flat feet.  It actually caused them to hurt within a few minutes of trying them on. So, for someone with an arch these shoes may be great but they didn't work for this flat-footed person.