I actually loved these shoes so much, I've worn them out.  After reordering them, I found them to feel small and not the same quality leather, so I tried the larger size, but then it seemed too large.  Perhaps it is just this style, because I have since ordered another style, Bay, and they seem good in my size, 5 1/2.  Haven't worn them yet, so my opinion may be premature.  Just be careful of the company you order from.  Virtual Exchanges will charge you shipping and $20 off your refund, if you need to return them.  I was fuming, but thankfully, Amazon took care of the problem.  They are so great!!!  Had these been the same quality as the first pair I bought, I would have given them 10 stars!  I believe the company has been sold, so who knows where they are actually being made!!