I had high hopes for this beautiful shoe, tried on the right shoe..fit was perfect very comfortable, just a tad stiff in the heal...tried on the left then I noticed something was off....someone had cut the elastic goring out of both sides of the left shoe, so it just flopped as I took a step...plus there was dirt marks...I was so upset..what a waste of shipping, and then my time and effort returning the item to UPS to shop back.  I gave this shoe 1 star due to the horrible condition of the pair I received, otherwise I would of given it 4 Stars.