Ive bought 5 pairs of these jeans now. I love the dark wash. They were the first pair I bought and fit exactly as I wanted them to in my waist and thighs. I have large calves and some straight leg jeans are still too slender and hug my calves, but these were perfect. I bought a black pair next, but they were tighter in the waist and hips and not as comfortable. I bought more of the dark wash and they were just like my first pair. The antique wash fit the same as the dark wash. Im so happy I found these jeans. I will buy more of the blue ones. Hoping if I lose weight and go down a size that the black ones will fit the way I want them too as well!