These shoes look to have an identical outsole as the cloth version "Crocs Men's Swiftwater Casual Slip On Flat"&nbsp;<a data-hook="product-link-linked" class="a-link-normal" href="/crocs-Men-s-Swiftwater-Casual-Slip-On-Fashion-Sneaker-Black-Graphite-13-M-US/dp/B01N7K6Z10/ref=cm_cr_arp_d_rvw_txt?ie=UTF8">crocs Men's Swiftwater Casual Slip On Fashion Sneaker, Black/Graphite, 13 M US</a>&nbsp;which I already owned and loved.  So I thought great- I'd get the same fit and feel.  WRONG.  These leather versions are way too tight over the top of my feet.  Comparing the cloth version with the leather  version, side by side, they do seem to have the same outsole and even almost identical removable insoles.  However the leather versions have much less leather over the top of your feet than the cloth versions have cloth.  It is like the manufacturer wanted to save money by skimping on the leather they used!  If you completely remove the insole from the leather version, and wear it with the insole missing, you get about the same fit as the cloth version.  I found this leather version tightness to be the case with both of two pairs ordered about 2 months apart.  So I guess its by design.  Obviously Croc's Fit Department is a croc of something.
If you look at the attached picture, you can see the cloth version on the inside and the leather version on the outside.  Note the height of the seam at the top of the toes relative to the sole.  Obviously they left out about 1/8 inch of leather on of the sides of leather shoes making a horribly tight fit over the toes and top of your foot.