Great for the price! I used the cloth for the dubbin and it worked great. I have a pair of doc martens from the 90s and parts of the black finish have worn off to show brown underneath. The wonder balsam didn't help make this black, but it did help make the leather look more and feel more supple and shiny. I have some cracks in the shoes which feel better now that the wonder balsam and dubbin have been applied. Highly recommend, especially since if you bought each product individually they would cost over $40!