I have the exact same David Archy t-shirt product in v-neck and love it for when I'm wearing a suit.  So I wanted the same except with a crew neck for more business casual look.  I'm very disappointed in this product for several reasons.  First, even though I bought the exact same XL (I'm 6'3" and 220 lbs) this t-shirt is very big on me.  Even after a few washes it still has a very blouse-like fit, which is completely different than the same product in a v-neck version.  Second, the length has shrunk so much that it's hard for it to stay tucked in.  So think about that...washing will not shrink the blousy fit but it will shrink up the length?  Frustrating.  Third, and this is the worst, the crew neck feature actually fits more like a stretched out and pulled crew neck of an old t-shirt that's been worn several hundred times.  The opening at the neck is so wide that with some of my button down shirts you can't even see I'm wearing it, which pretty much defeats the entire purpose of a crew neck t-shirt.

I would've given just 1 star, but bumped it to 2 because the material is so comfortable and i'll wear this under sweaters / sweatshirts, etc.  But it falls far short of what it was sold as.