The shoes have a rich color and great detail. The insoles don't seem to be "stuck down" very well and shifted in the shoe when I tried them on. They also run very small. I ordered one size up based upon reviews and had to return. I purchased a second pair a full size larger. The big issues I experienced were with the second pair I purchased. The shoes arrived and had been obviously worn. There was dirt and hair stuck to the bottom. The little silky knots that hold the straps were not bright red, but more of a dirty red/brown. The shoes had a bad odor. I sent the second pair back as well. The big positive, is the refund time was quick; same day as I shipped the item.