I love these jeans. I ordered a size up because the brown version "at size" was a little tighter than I wanted, not uncomfortable, but not the give I expected. Ordered in blue a size up....and they're SUPER loose. One wash and hot dry, they're right where I want. A good amount of give, comfy fabric, definitely buying more.
Only reason 4/5 is the inconsistent sizing between colours. A shart of which colours fit/stretch how would put these at a perfect rating :)