Comparing these to my classic 1461 in black smooth leather. The caparathian version is a bit more tailored, has a darker sole, and far better leather which won't look like a clown shoe when worn. Quality is great as usual with all doc martens. My old pair was a size 11 but I bought these in a 10 because I don't want them to look too large on my feet and they will eventuallt stretch to my size. Size down IF you don't mind a week or so of pain, then they will fit like a glove, a very tight glove.