Got the oiled black. Really like the look. Would be a 5 star, but they run large. I have a narrow small foot, and my foot is sliding all over in inside. I read the reviews and saw that they are supposed to be about a pinky tip big, but maybe they could create something better to keep your foot from sliding. I tried adding an insert, but the insert seemed to interfere with the arch support thats built into the shoe. Once I put the insert in, the shoe was actually painful at the arch. So I took it out. If I wear compression socks with this shoe, my foot slides  around even more. Definitely not designed for socks that are synthetic of any type.