Had to return because they were too small. My 10 yr old daughter is wearing size 4 in athletic and dress shoes. I got a size 5 in these boots and her toes were bumping against the end. They were a bit tight on the arch -tho her feet probably have a high arch. But these are so cute! And such a steal at $14.99! We were sad to let them go. She liked how the rubber felt "soft." They were packaged beautifully, too. Even had a little hummingbird key chain that came with the boots. We'd buy a size up if they were in stock.