I love the skirt, it feels like it's decent material and it's a cute A-line shape. I am 5'2.5" and 135 lbs and the medium fit a little loose around my waist, but I think a small would be too small. It is about 4 inches too long on me and falls much lower then in the picture.  I plan on hemming it to make it the length I want. I would purchase this skirt again even with the modifications I need to make