The only reason they got 4/5 stars is the fact they run just a bit small. I normally wear about an 8 or 8.5. The 8.5 JUST fit, and the 9's were perfect. This is my fourth pair of these shoes (different colors). Sizing is great and unlike other reviews, the laces ARE long enough to lace all the way up. If you are on the heavier size and have thick calves, then I could see how the lacing might be too short. I don't have tiny calves or anything, as I am a runner. For the average person of normal weight and size, these should fit perfect. I always get a lot of compliments when I wear them.