My daughter loves these shoes. This is our second pair.  I am only giving it 3 stars despite that my daughter loves them because they scuff up super easily.  My daughter isn't super hard on shoe but like any kid she does end up scuffing any of her nice shoes.  These were no different.  To get us through the season since these were black I did use a black permanent marker to fill in the scuffs since these were her favorite shoes.  Our first pair were size 9 and she was 3 yo and we just bought our second pair in size 10 and she's 4 yo.  She says they are comfortable (and she's picky with clothes and shoes as she has sensory issues with shoes and clothes) and loves the sparkle on the top of the shoe.  They look really nice in the fall with her school outfits. I use these as school "dress" shoes since I know she will scuff them up pretty easily.  They run true to size.