These are not perfect--I had 2 problems. On the very first lacing-up, one of the metal loops at the top broke off. And, I wasn't even tightening the laces when it happened. Fortunately, I had some rivets, so I was able to fix this problem by riveting the metal loop back on the boot. The other problem was that I didn't like the insole "feel". Kind of pebbly or bumpy. So, I got some heavy felt inserts (about $4).  Now, I really like these boots. They are warm (in Wisconsin winter), fit well and feel nice, and they are durable. The sole doesn't show any wear, yet, and I've worn them a lot. I got the size I normally wear (9) and the fit is really good. For the money, these are great boots. Just don't expect perfect.