They are actually a 4 1/2. They are a bit snug across the knuckles but not enough for me to rate these a 4. They are so soft and warm I love everything else about them I bought them in 4 colors. I get compliments all the time. I can drive and do everything I need to do and still keep warm. My pinkie finger is there, lol, but the fur is so long you can barely see it.