Purchased the natural color in 8.5 C/D.  Had bought a similar Easy Spirit style last year and those were comfortable right out of the box, loved them and wore daily all summer long. Returning these because the synthetic straps are not smooth and pliable like my old pair. Stiff and abrasive, chafing my skin. To be fair, usually have trouble finding comfortable sandals because I have sensitive skin. Shame because the soles, like my old pair, are very supportive for a sandal, and they fit well.