I'd give these 5 stars but for the inconsistency between the right and left feet on sizing.  My right foot is a  size longer than my left but this pair fit my right foot (the longer foot) perfectly whereas the left shoe was too short for my left foot (where usually the left foot is usually swimming in 11M).  I'm keeping these because I don't want to deal with the whole "return at your own cost" policy Amazon seems to have randomly instituted recently (to return these for $12 USPS & to just get $3.99 back for postage from Amazon is stupid when I paid near nothing for these sandals on sale).  They are great sandals if they fit correctly, but just be aware of sizing inconsistencies & Amazon's new weird Prime return policy.