Got the beige (they look almost blush, nice color) with black. The beige strap is patent look or shiny and then the black part is matte. Very well made, at first glance they look like high end slip ons/slippers in leather. Very well made, very comfy. A little sporadic squeak when walking but not all the time.  This color is very classy looking may be able to wear these to the office with nice slacks and tailored jacket for spring/summer. Very nice and only $40!!

I want these in black and tortoise for days I wear all black. Itd be another classic look!

Fit: true to size. I wear 9.5 and since this didn't come in half sizes, I got the 10. It has a little room but not overly loose. I think 9 would be a tad uncomfortable especially when it gets super hot this summer.

Ps
I didn't experience the strong smell that a couple of ppl had mentioned. But mine came well packaged, complete with dust bag. I think that probably added to the feeling of high end on top of the classic and neutral color combo I got.