So, I actually hate these, but that's because I realized I don't like belly bands in general. These belly bands do what they are supposed to do and I imagine are as comfortable as they can be, so I'm giving them 4 stars. One of them lost a thread after a couple of uses, so there's that. Not sure how it will continue to hold up.

They hold up my pants and don't ride up, but if I'm wearing a lighter color, or it's moderately tight, you can kind of see where my pants are unbuttoned. I'll probably still use them some, and if you like these things or want to try them, it's probably worth it.