These shoes were comfy the first time I slipped them on my feet -- I am usually a size 8, and these fit pretty much as expected (although I would not want to wear them with heavy socks, as they are a little snug in the toe for me.)  Still, I don't fault the shoes - just my feet probably aren't quite as dainty as they were twenty years ago! (But an 8 1/2 would probably be too big.)  But I do love them - They look nice with almost anything (I got the black mesh) - I can dress them up or wear them with jeans. And they are comfortable enough for long walks.  I also think they are a bargain.  I might have to buy another pair!