I feel like I've been looking for these forever - a simple granny style with a sturdy heel and not-too-pointed toe. The best part though is that they make my long skinny "rat feet" look cute and tiny, even without pants over the top of them. I've always wanted something like this to wear with skirts or a shirtdress but normally my feet look too huge in boots without some pant coverage. These don't look big from any angle I look forward to having them for years! They also feel like they're lined with felt or something, so even though they fit snug (I got narrows because I have skinny feet) there's no rubbing or pinching or compressing anywhere.

If you are a true narrow these might not be narrow enough for you - I typically take a narrow in most modern shoes but a regular in vintage shoes. Apparently there's vanity sizing in shoes now too!