Hoka's are the softest ride out there.  Their design philosophy is pretty simple.  Lots of EVA!

I started wearing the Cliftons several years ago and just transitioned into the Bondi 5 for even MORE cushioning.
After 40 years of running, my knees are somewhat worn and these, indeed, have a bit more padding.
But, I'm dinging it one star for:

CONS:
- WHIMPY SHOE LACES!  What's up with Hoka's tiny, thin laces designed for elves?!  I prefer more robust, oval ones because they synch easier and stay synched.
- Uppers.  They have a plastic-like quality to them.  Not quite "soft"  and comfy enough.
- Price.  $140 (on sale)?  Really?!  For some Chinese-made, mostly EVA, vinyl, shoes with minimalist shoe strings that cost them, like, $2 each to produce?!

PROS:
- Probably the most cushiony shoe out there.
- Some folks complained that the toe box is too big or too small, but I find this version just right.
- Big heal loop.  Good job!
- Average wear.  I run a measly 10 miles/week and they last about a year before becoming compressed and "hard".

BOTTOM LINE:
It's a solid, soft ride and I guess shelling out 12 bucks a month for a hobby I enjoy isn't so bad.