I initially ordered the Ellie years ago and loved them.  However, I inadvertently ruined them by my own doing.  So I re-ordered them only to receive a pair that looked similar but definitely was wider in the calf and overall less fitted.  Not happy.  I returned those and decided to order the Naomis to see if they would fit better.

Lo and behold they fit just like how my Ellies used to fit.  Not sure what happened there.  Im pretty sure these are the old Elllies.

Anyway I love the Naomi.  Im 51 and these hit right below my knee.  I have slim calves and these are fitted on me which is the way I like them.  When boots are too wide in the calf I feel like a messy pirate.  I think that if you need wide calf boots, these may be real tight.  I typically wear size 6.5 and ordered a size 7 and they fit perfectly.  I sometimes have to walk several blocks from the train station to the office and these boots are comfy enough for that and even to wear all day.  And they definitely will keep you dry!