I love these boots, they are sturdy and more comfy than expected. I have high arches and heel pain so I need shoes with still soles. I replaced the insoles with my own but they don't hurt at all which isn't common for me. However, the black classic has started to flake off after about 2 months of almost daily wear. In not on my feet much and not hard on my shoes so this is a little disappointing. I may buy again to see if I got a faulty pair because they are perfect otherwise! Wish I could find an affordable version in real leather!