These are the perfect boots for a girl with shorter legs. They hit right below my calf so it helps make my legs look longer. I have to return my pair due to damage but I will definitely get another pair.
I am usually a 7 or 7.5 shoe because I have very wide feet. I would actually go with a 7 in these (I ordered 7.5) because they are slightly loose.
I am removing a star from the rating because these do not seem like practical winter boots - just fashionable and comfy. I haven't worn them, but I don't think they would hold up in the winter climate whatsoever.