The reason I am giving it a 3* is the neck is too small. When I ordered a 3XLT I assumed the neck would accommodate the neck of someone this big, it does not. Although the material is heavy and the shirt is very well made, the dang neck fits right at the neckline which makes it a bit uncomfortable. He wears 3XLT white t-shirts around the house and as he is lounging around when we travel. I wanted to buy him different colors of shirts, but to find one this heavy and well made is hard these days. I suppose for the price one can't be too picky.  If you have a neck size of 17+ I would think twice about buying these shirts unless you don't mind the neck fitting snug.