I really wanted to love this shoe, but the sizing is just weird. I wear an 8.5 almost wide, but the 8.5 W was huge. I ordered the regular 8 and it fit great, with wiggle room. But my toes hit the top of the shoe which is kind of hard, almost like the shoe wasn't tall enough, even though I could move my foot around. Strange. I then tried the 8.5 regular, but that was too big and didn't provide enough support. I returned all of them, but I'm still feeling like I want this shoe!