I REALLY like this jacket - I've been searching for a 3/4 length, soft structure jacket forever...

Anyway, I gave it 4 stars only because the sleeves on the XL boarder on being a tad too long.  BE AWARE that this is a FITTED jacket (which is what I wanted) and it's warm so you won't be piling on sweaters underneath.

I'd suggest you go a size up - which is what I did.