I wanted a good looking, but inexpensive, pair of shoes that I could wear "in the field" for my client, as colleagues have warned me that shoes can get beat up on these trips (and no, I have no idea why we can't wear boots).  These fit the bill nicely.

PRO
1. These were comfortable from the moment I put them on.  No 'breaking in' required!!
2. They stay comfortable after a full day, whether in the field on in the office.
3. They are light, so they reduce the weight you have to carry if you pack them.
4. Nice price point, especially on sale.

CON
1. The leather and lining are not of the same quality you'll get from a more expensive shoe (though at this price, that is a bit unfair)..
2. I don't feel as much support as in other shoes, and that makes me wonder how long they will remain comfortable.
3. the color in the pair I received was a little uneven, but a little polish (I used cordovan) evened things up nicely.

So far, I'm happy with the shoe, and the I am curious to see how well they will hold up over the course of six months or a year.