Im a huge fan. I love how they look. I love how I can stand in a puddle and remain 120% dry. I love how easy they are to put on. I do wish they carried half sizes. Im usually a 9 1/2 and because of everyones reviews I ordered a 9. They fit comfortably but my toes do touch the top. 10s would definitely be too big. I also don't love how the foot insert isn't attached to the boot. It moves around and is a real nuisance. But. Not enough for me to not wear them.

Half sizes.
Foot insert attached.

And Id give 5...nah, 6 stars! 