Positives:
Lovely color
Fabric nice weight--not too heavy, not too light
Fabric doesn't fade at all!  (That's amazing!)

Drawbacks:
Cuffs are almost as large as the sleeve so look more like sweatshirt cuffs than blouse cuffs; unattractive
Fabric is puckered where it is sewn to the collar
Body of shirt is quite long--tunic length (this might be fine for someone 5' 10" tall, but I'm short)

Since it took almost a month to get this shirt (Woman Within indicated it might be lost), I reordered it, and then got the original.  To return, they charge an ungodly $7.50!  I'll have to decide if I like it well enough to keep two, or sell one on eBay.