First, the good:  These are good cedar shoe trees.  I would put them up against any other trees I have, including the Allen Edmonds private labelled Woodlore trees I own.  Those might be slightly better but not significantly so.

Plus they come with shoe bags.  How great is that?  Well, it was pretty great the first time I bought these when the bags were high quality, breathable fabric bags with a drawstring and plastic cinch to keep the bags closed and dust out.

Sadly, there seems to have been a product change, swapping out the fabric bags for cheap nylon or plastic bags.  The new bags don't seem to be breathable and don't have the plastic clip on the drawstring to keep them closed.  These new bags don't add anything of value for me.

So, all in all, they're decent trees at a decent price.  I wouldnt consider the new bags a value-add.  Certainly not the amazing value they were the first time I bought them