If I were going based only on fit or appearance, this would be a six star review.  These shoes are comfortable and cute.

That said, they arrived smelling so strongly of chemicals that wearing them was impossible.  The smell gave me a headache and was super pervasive.  I would smell them the whole time I was trying to wear them.  I read in the Asks that this smell went away for some people.  Its months later and Ive had them sitting outside and they still smell terrible.  I threw them away.