The product arrived on time and as expected. The fit is a bit large, but I would not go to a smaller size. I've been able to use them in cold temperatures with the hand warmer in the pouch. My hands were warm at about 30 degrees. My fingertips were harder to warm. They were never uncomfortable. I have not worked in the rain since getting the gloves. I expect they will be no worst than any other advertised waterproof gloves as long as you don't have to hold wet objects I believe they are well made to keep your hands dry. I work at the airport so I'm touching items that are wet and generally the other products I've tried soak up water. In my area, we have more cold nights than rainy nights.