I love love LOVE the tall version of this boot.  This shares some of the things I like, the wide front footbed (compared to all other galoshes I've tried which tend to run incredibly narrow and especially pinchy in the toe), the super lightweight material that flexes and is easy to walk in, the incredibly comfortable sole even for standing and walking all day at work, and the variety of non-black options (I live somewhere sunny and HOT).  However!  The inclusion of the pull holes in the short style means you are really limited in terms of depth of mud/water you can step in, and you really don't need the pull holes with the boot being so short.  Also, the opening at the top of the boot is a lot wider than needed - a taller boot needs a lot of space to get your foot through, but in this short style, the opening size just collects dirt and stones.  I empty these out 10 or 12 times a day.