I bought three of these--one for each of my two sisters and one for me.  They both love it.  I like it, too, but I find the ring heavier than I think it needed to be to hold a sweater or jacket, which is why I bought it.  Perhaps the ring needs to be that heavy to work properly, but I would have preferred lighter.  Anyway, that is why the 4 stars.  Otherwise, the clip is very well made, substantial, not cheap-looking at all.