In all fairness, Im sometimes between sizes so the larger one was too big so I will return and order half a size smaller. Man are these comfortable!! Soft, plenty of cushion....if the half size smaller fits me, Im certain I will buy other colors. Great quality just like I would expect from Ariat. These seem like the perfect spring/summer shoe when you don't want to wear open toes but can get away with footies and a boat style shoe. These are way cuter than most boat shoes and they don't make your feet look like....well...boats. I def think they are worth the price tag and I haven't even tried on the correct size!! They are as comfortable as slippers but seem pretty sturdy/well made too. Great detail. Love!!