Becca writing this review. The right shoe took some time to stuff and break in which is not unusual for me. The left shoe was only a little snug so I cannot consider them to be too small in fit. While I have no other issues with them, I feel four stars is the fairest rating. The heel cover likes to hold onto mud stains while the rest of the shoe cleans easily. The height of the sturdy heel makes them comfortable for all day wear.