I really like these shoes...I have a slightly wide foot and these pushed the limit but fit great.  The reason for a 4 out of 5 is they is quality is good but not top of the line.  They had a smell when I first got them and the leather needed some tending too.  They are light weight...thin bottom but stitched. I am going to use Saddle soap on them and hopefully get them to last longer and condition the leather.  But really a great shoe for the price and some caring I think these shoes will last decent....all relative to the price and if you know how to care for leather.