The fitting is somewhat tight. I am a size 4 at Payless, Size 3 in Payless kids and it was a great fit on the foot. However, I also have wide feet and it did not have a wide fit for sizes 5/5 1/2. However, after one day of wearing them at work, nine hours total with some sitting and some standing it seems to fit perfectly. I am thinking about buying another pair in the similar color, though I might risk a 5 1/2 just to see if it fits better.

EDIT: I am revising my review to 5 stars because after two months these have become my favorite shoes. They have worn in perfectly, they are always comfortable, and I will buy another pair in the same size!