I bought this jacket for my husband who is 5'10' and about 200 lbs.  It's a bit roomy as I wanted him to be able to fit a fleece jacket under it when needed.  It is loose enough without being baggy to look good with or without the fleece.  He's worn it a bit likes the feel and says it keeps the wind out.  It finally rained to test out the waterproof part - it's waterproof all right!  We stood out in the rain about 4 hrs, some of it was drizzle, most a steady rain. His shirt was dry when he took the jacket off.  His only wish was the hood was a bit stiffer at the top.  He said it kind of plastered around his head instead of creating a hood that stood out a bit.  His solution is to get a baseball hat and that will keep the rain off his face.  I would buy it again for sure!