Five Stars for the shoes, but one star for Amazon getting a good looking pair shipped to me.

I love the shoe but I have had a terrible time getting a decent unscuffed and unused pair. The first pair looked to have never been worn, but they had a bad scuff on the left shoe. They were shipped in a bag rather than an Amazon box, so I'm sure that had something to do with it. The actual shoe box was torn to bits. The replacement pair looked as though they had been worn to a wedding with a dance floor and then returned. The shoes were not only scuffed, but there was weir on the bottom and the heals shine had been rubbed to a flat finish. They were however shipped in a sturdy box and the actual shoe box was ok.