It is just ok. I ordered this one because I ordered a black one just like it a few months ago and it has been great. The leather on the backside of this brow one however is flaking off onto my pants and one of the snaps failed which held the belt keeper in place. Either the brown is poor quality or I just received a defective one. In any case, I cannot return it because I dyed it oxblood red to match my redwing boots.