Typical Chaco comfort and design.  Nobody can match the footbed for support and feel.  Also the best-looking chukka design out there.  If/when Merrell decides to design a nice-looking looking functional chukka, then I will have something to compare with. Two concerns: durability of the lace hooks; and living in Colorado, traction in the winter is a must.  But for now, comfort and style earn 4 stars easily.