5 stars for now, which may change as I've had time to wear them. I was hesitant at first to order these after reading the bad reviews, but I didn't have the same problems with packaging. Mine came in a very nice box, and the earrings have a great sparkle to them. They have a rich color and overall I'm quite happy with the condition in which I received them. The earrings feel sturdy, not cheap like some users have said of theirs. I've included pictures so you can see their size. I'm wearing the peach-colored ones.

EDIT (3/9): I think some of the bad reviews are from people who ordered a different size than me. I ordered the 6mm set of 12 pairs. Your mileage may vary depending on the size and cut. Perhaps they come from different suppliers. Still very happy with my purchase!