I would love to keep this pair. I ordered a size 6 W, which, in some Clark's styles would be just right. But for this one, I think need to try 5 1/2 W. The sizing is so inconsistent and it depends on the kind of shoes your ordering with this brand. This is my first order through Amazon prime wardrobe and stoked that I can try my orders for 7 days and only pay what I keep. Awesome!