First off I purchased because I LOVE my Ariat boots, the best boots I ever owned.  I was looking for something great for walking with a great fit and comfort and craftsmanship I found in my boots. These shoes are not in my opinion super cute and they make my size 9 foot look very long. (I believe because the short lace bed makes the top of the foot look extra long).  The color is nice.  I tried them on and they are a bit wide for my feet, but I have a narrow foot so its wasn't a big surprise, (the boots I wear with heavy socks and never noticed them being too wide).  as soon as i tried them on though the feel comfortable and I can snug up the laces.  The insole is different with the massaging little cushion bubble things. I am taking these on vacation to WDW next week and will be doing a lot of walking.  I will post an update on the comfort after lots of walking.  One last note I noticed the back part of and the side of the shoe that I was expecting to be leather is more like rubber.  All man made materials.