I would give these shoes a 10.  I selected these after reading reviews for 2018, it took time.  I just hiked 5 days straight in rocky
terrain and sand and in the AZ mtns., they felt like they were made just for me.  My last pair Aslo I've had for years, I used Orthotics in these from day one, they have lasted for years.  My new Merrell's fit my expectation.  I bought the size I normally wear 8.5.  I loved the Soloman's and Keen's but for two different reasons I chose these.