I have learned that the Woman Within brand runs large. I ordered the 1X because the size chart indicated that size for my 40" waist and 50" hips. The soft fabric material has a generous amount of give/stretch. I don't care for baggy shapeless garments, even in my home or yard. Because I rinsed them before wearing, I don't think they can be returned. But I'll check and will let you know if they allow an exchange. Also, the petite cut was too long for my 29" (inseam) leg.