3 stars just for how cute they look. They take a while to break in, and definitely form blisters on the backs of my heels. Also, there's weird fabric (almost fur-looking) on the soles. The fabric started to come loose and picked up all kinds of dirt after walking for 5 minutes, so I took a pair of scissors to cut it away from the shoe, and found that there's a rubber/plastic sole with a cute pattern on underneath. Why it's covered up with weird fur, I'm not sure, but once it's gone, no issues.