Conflicted on this one.  I was definitely transported back to the 90s, which I loved.  The flannel was nice and heavy and the fit was pretty good.  I am a little baffled as to why the breast pockets don't have function buttons though (they are sewn on the front flap).  After going through the wash, the pocket flaps stick up all funny, so it is obvious they are sewn on the top and not actually functional.  It looks weird.  I'll probably "fix" it by sewing down the pockets, but I am not a huge fan of having to modify new clothing.  Otherwise, it is a very nice shirt.  I haven't messed with the side button scrunching yet.  That also seems odd.  The look reminds me of maternity clothing.  This isn't a deal breaker though and I certainly might like it once I give it a go.  Overall, nice product, just be aware of the pocket/button issue.