Okay so after reading the reviews I was hesitant on what size to order... Normally I am a solid 8 but was afraid of them being too small cause of the reviews... So I ordered a 8 and a 9 which I am glad I did. The 9 left a little bit of room for thicker socks if I want.  The 8 did fit but was a little tight. They are super warm!!  Went out for a walk with them today. The laces are super long I had to wrap them around my leg to tie them.... The only thing that I don't like is the creasing in the toes... I'm wondering if eventually they will crack... Even so at $15 not a bad deal! I would definitely recommend these boots.