I love the shoes a lot that I bought the black leather ones from another vendor too.  The fit is a little different.  This Mushroom nubuck material is soft and very comfortable.  I can walk all day and no problem.  I don't even have to break in.  Someone mentioned that the front of the shoes digs into the feet and I found it true to the black leather shoes but not these mushroom nubuck ones.  I have thin feet and if it digs into mine, it probably will dig into most people's feet.  I have been wearing the black leather pair last week and the roughness is reduced but I think I still have to wear it a little longer to make it completely comfortable. Overall, I like the style and design, simple  but elegant.  Good looking on ankle pants.