I loved my Reef Dreams, so when they broke down after a few years I needed a new pair of sandals for summer.  I wear an 8.5 and got a 9 to ensure they would be long enough.  I got these and was happy with their appearance, the materials look high quality.  I tried them on and they seemed a little snug across my foot but I was leaving for vacation the next day so I just threw them in my bag thinking they'd stretch out and conform to my feet after some wear.  After wearing them for a few hours, I had painful red rub marks and the beginnings of blisters across the inside and outside of my foot where the strap was.  The foot bed was comfortable, but the pain from the straps made it so I couldn't even wear these sandals a second time.  Huge bummer, I loved my other sandals from Reef.