I got these boots for my boyfriends nephew his mom told me what size so they'd be a little big and he could grow into them. He loves them and I have seen him wear them everytime it rains with his fireman rain jacket. The reason it is not getting 5 stars is because one of the straps broke off on one side. I'm pretty sure a 5 year old doesn't use much strength to put these on. I expected more quality from Carter's.