I bought these shoes one day shy of two months ago. Already there is a hole in the sole. I am not a heavy person, (BMI ~20), but I walk a lot. Even though I only wear these shoes two or three days a week for a total of (maybe!) 100 miles, there is a hole in them. After a month, they already showed signs that there was a problem, but I kept wearing them to see when a hole would wear through the sole.

The leather upper is decent quality, but the outsole isn't made for any reasonable use, especially in urban areas where walking is common. So, while the shoe looks fine from above, it is time to trash them.