I received the boots quickly.  They look just like the pix.  No weird smell, they fit perfect.  The heels matched.  I also put my orthotics in the bottom of them, wore 2 pair of socks AND a leg warmer!  They were perfect.  I wore them for 6 hours the first night and no problems!

I do have to say, if you have bigger calves these would be the boots for you.  My calves are so...so, not big not narrow or thin, but it seems that there is extra room there if you need it.

I also noticed the zipper was extra convenient taking the shoes on and off if need be.

I have no complains and yes the bottoms are water proof, where the material starts and the rubber ends would be where they become not so water proof.  So, make sure you  understand that.  You will not have dry feet if you stand in 5 inches of water.  Just letting you know!

Happy Trails!!