I found Old West by accident, and they are my favorite boot brand.  Yes, they are inexpensive, but they fit perfectly, wear well, and are cheap enough to not have a heart attack if you scuff them up!  These are real leather upper and shaft... not faux-leather (vinyl), and the soles wear very well.  I wear boots every day... from the farm-chores to riding motorcycles to a night on the town with my wife, these are my go-to boots.  I do recommend if you want an insole (as these are true cowboy style, no fancy cushion insole), you should order half-size up to make room.  I wear 9.5D in dress-shoes and boots, and these fit perfectly (a little snug at first, but break-in fast) and are true-to-size.

I have a couple pair of Old West boots that are several years old... and they clean-up to near-new looks... and they feel like second-skin!  I've never had a pair of Old West boots "fall apart" on me... yes, they "wear-out", but you'll get several good years out of them before they need replacing.  I can't say that about some of my more expensive brands... some of which were retired after only a year or two.

My oldest son recently switched to Old West (after asking about mine), and he is quite pleased that he can buy 3-4 pair of Old West for what he was paying for one pair of Ariat (which he would wear-out or destroy in less than a year).  The pair he bought 6-months ago (just like these) still look great, and have less wear than his more expensive brands after the same amount of wearing.