The 3 stars is for the sizing. definitely order at least 1 size over. If they had half sizes I'd say a size and a half over. I see many reviews mention the palm of these gloves being too smooth. I'd say this depends on one's driving style.

If you're a go with the flow stay in the lane, around town driver, sure, you may want something a little more grippy, but if you drive with performance and need that wheel to return on its own, these are great as there is little resistance. I did not keep them due to the fit, so I'd also acknowledge they may wear through as they are a bit thin ion the palm as well.