These boots are great - very comfortable, easy to wear and keep my feet pretty warm.

I am not a fan of winter and I hate being cold, but I live in New England and needed good boots. I was leery about ordering boots with a removable lining because I was afraid they would come out every time I took the boots off. I needn't have worried - the liners stay in place great.

I wear a 7 in all casual shoes and boots but a 7 1/2 in all athletic sneakers. I ordered a 7 and am glad I did. When I first put them on I thought they felt a little snug, but within a day or wearing them I was happy with the fit. There is no need to wear the thickest, heaviest socks out there with these and if you do, you will have to order a 1/2 size up. I wear regular athletic socks or the lightweight wool socks.

I have felt my toes were a little cold on some days when the weather is particularly bitter, which is why I have them 4 stars. But I'm not sure there is a product in existence to keep my completely toasty all winter long when it's negative 10 degrees, so I would say they're more of a 4 1/2 stars. Would certainly buy them again and recommend.