So when I put these on, I found that the top of my foot really hurt. I wore them walking around for about ten minutes, and they gave way, considerably. They're going to be a bit tight because of the shearling, but with time, they will give way for your foot. Unless the tips of your toes are rammed against the front of the shoe, I don't recommend going up the one half size larger. All Frye boots are notoriously difficult to get on at first, and should be worn in small increments, but after a few wears, they will be the most amazing boots you've ever owned. I own several pair, and this is almost always the case. Frye are the most incredibly made shoes, they last and keep their looks over time. Well worth the investment.