Keen Rose vs. Keen Bali Strap Review
In most shoes I am a 6.5 (typically), but sometimes 7. In the Rose, the 7 fit perfect. In the Bali Strap, the 6 fit perfectly. I have normal sized feet & ankles, but total princess & the pea feet. If there's a chance of getting a blister, I will most definitely get one until I have built up a callous.

Rose: Has a lot more support, better/softer materials, better traction on bottom, can wear right out of the box all day, love that it did NOT have a 2nd adjustable strap on the back of the ankle (more streamlined look/less clunky). A bit narrower overall. My feet are pretty normal sized/width, so it was visible that the shoes were a tad too narrow but they were still very comfortable. I have no idea why people are having a hard time with the ankle strap being too small unless they have very large ankles/feet. I thought it was by far the most comfortable sport sandal of any I've ever tried.

Bali Strap: Love the wider toe box (comfy), and love the placement of the straps which was more flattering to my feet. Did not like the material used around the ankle. It was very scratchy and will give me blisters if I were to wear all day. I was devastated it bothered me so much as I love the look of these. If it wasn't for the ankle straps being so scratchy, I would've kept these shoes. Also it is a bit slippery on bottom, however I've read other reviewers say that it's fine once you start using them outside. Also, while it might be nice to adjust the 2nd strap on the back of the ankle, I did not like the way it looked...very clunky (but could live with it). I will say that for those that have the pinky toe escaping, they probably need to size down a half size. Perhaps they can't do this if they have wide feet, but I had no issues with sizing down - it was a perfect fit.

Overall: The Rose is much more comfortable, but I prefer the look of the Bali Strap...if only they could combine the two! I chose the Rose as I will be using these shoes for Disney World and need something that can go all day for a week, but I'm tempted to keep the Bali Strap for other uses where I will not be doing as much walking.