I bought these for my mom for her recent trip to Iceland. When I asked her how they held up for her she said they were absolutely perfect and she was so happy with them. They are not meant to be warm, just meant to keep you dry and they did their job. She wishes they came in more color options as she felt like her outfits lacked color but she didn't mind because she wore these through blizzard like conditions and was perfectly dry. They fit true to size and can be adjusted for a better fit. Based off her recommendation, if I ever needed a pair, I would definitely purchase these or myself.