When I got these at first, I wasn't going to keep them. I have a couple other combat boots, the Jenna and the Sabrina. Compared to the leather boot, it just wasn't as lush. however, over time, these grew on me, and so I kept them. They will never be as durable as Frye's leather, so I make sure that they only come out for special occasions. Otherwise, these boots are really lovely. I love the green color, it goes with a surprising number of things, and they are just funky looking, without looking quirky and clown-like.