I selected "fit as expected" but it was slightly small but not enough for me to select "somewhat small". I have a tall 5 year old. I only gave it 3 stars because the dress that is more red started ripping at the seams just after 4 months. For the price, it was fine - personally, I don't expect $12 dresses to last forever but I'm sure some would consider that too expensive. Just depends on your perception of "expensive" I guess. In the end, my daughter loves both dresses.