I have not had a good experience with this shoe.  I wanted a good basic high quality leather walking Mary Jane that I could wear with pants or skirts if I were traveling.  This doesnt deliver.  The leather was stiff and dug into the outside of my ankle on my right foot and my toes press against the end of the toe box (I do not have long toes either and the arch fits as it should so I knew I shouldnt go up a half size).  The worst part of it is that, after only having worn them about two weeks, I stubbed my toe on a curb and then the leather started peeling off!  On the positive side, the width of the toes is good, there is excellent arch support and a very comfortable foot bed; however, because of the peeling leather and the short toe box, I would not recommend this shoe.