I purchased a 2nd pair because I wore out my first pair. They were my favorite black flats. They are just as comfortable as Tieks for a fraction of the price. I would have given them 5 stars but, the quality has gone down hill - The leather used to be much softer.  The black dye bleeds onto my feet, which did not happen with my previous pair. 

Im a pretty solid 8.5 W or 9 C, but got the 9W because the last pair ran just a tad short. The 9W is much better. Overall, its an okay shoe and I hope this pair lasts as long as my first pair, and I hope it stops dying my feet black. (Even with socks)