I really like the way these shoes fit. They are very accommodating of my sensitive feet, and the leather and insoles now fit like a glove. The look is very sharp and simple as well.

As with any slip-on, there is a greater likelihood you will experience heel movement, especially with the stiffer midsole. I found that by getting some Pedag heel grips, the heel fit was just snug enough to eliminate most of the heel movement. The "Josh" model is a tie-up version of this shoe that allows for better control of heel movement. For some reason, my pair of Joshes isn't quite as comfy as the Jackson slip-ons, mostly in the heel.

My main complaint with this shoe is that after a little more than a year of very moderate use, the stitching holding the elastic fabric to the upper came loose. It unraveled on one side of one shoe, so I had it repaired. Right after the repair, I noticed the same stitching was starting to unravel on the other shoe as well (see photo). I don't think the problem is with the stitching itself, but with the elastic material, which seems to fail at the location of the stitches. I was tempted to buy another pair in the black color, but given these material failures, I'm going to hold off unless there's a crazy good deal. For the asking price, I think it's reasonable to expect greater durability. While I haven't had my Joshes as long, they are holding up just fine (no elastic).