Four stars because it suits my purpose and I like the thin soft material. It would be 3 otherwise d/t shrinkage, but I'm wearing mine inside. I like that the V neck is not as deep or wide as pictured, which often is an issue for me. For once it is not too long, not as long as on the model (The large, which came slightly small for me, fits me about 2-3'' shorter than her and I'm 5'6"  though maybe she's short).. It isn't completely boxy but is not as shaped at the waist as some women's t shirts.  For me the shape is fine  for outside just not dressy. Though I found it reasonable that it ran about 1/2 size too small, as others said it shrunk excessively to the point it was unflattering. One caveat  I'm washing in WARM and drying on WARM which isn't recommended for this shirt. so maybe I'm not fair. OTOH I believe T-shirts shouldn't have to be treated with kid gloves, washed on COLD, but, some shrinkage should be expected on warm but this was a lot. It was easy to stretch it back out width wise but I'd not do that except it was a sleep shirt so I don't care as much about how it looks.
 Note ::Many people complain about heather GREY being 10% poly. Almost ALL heather gray t-shirts are 5-10%poly even though the rest of the colors can be 100% cotton. 10% poly doesn't impact the feel; it feels like 100% cotton. I think it reasonable that the seller would forget to mention that about ONE color. That said, a few people obviously got shipped the wrong shirt (I read the reviews extensively) because they had poly in a non-gray shirt. They obviously got the wrong shirt. The vast % of poly complaints are with the light gray though.
 I'm ordering the pink one now in one size up (XL) and if it's same as the gray, there's a good chance it'll be good for summer outside even with shrinkage..