These boots are cute. I've worn them over jeans and with a short sweater dress. I have skinny legs and they fit my legs perfectly - probably won't work if you have thick legs. I ordered a size up per the other reviews, but I wish I'd ordered my exact size. I make them work with heavy socks though. They are lined so they're very warm. HERE'S WHY I'M ONLY GIVING 3 STARS. The boot is basically a high heel shoe with a sleeve for your leg. It's kind of like if you took a "flash dance" legging and sewed it into a heel you liked - then BAM - you get these. In the dimely lit room they look great. But in the light they look cheap because of how they're stiched together. I also had to add a non-slip pad to each shoe. I couldn't be that girl who slipped in front of everyone.  They're cheap so I'm glad I bought them but I probably won't again.