I really like these boots. They look like the picture and fit as I'd expect them to. My only complaint is that they are a little stiff particularly in the toes and while I wouldn't say they're uncomfortable, I definitely wouldn't wear them if I was going to be walking a lot during the day. They work fine for regular use. Also, I have non-existent calves and the regular calf size fits me perfect. They are snug on my legs and not at all loose like boots normally are which is great. If you have anything other than very slim calves, order the wide leg size.