So at one point, I have purchased these in every color. No, I didn't get to keep them all! I have a ton of Frye boots, so I just kept the ones that I thought would complement the others. Anyway, I have to say that they were all very beautiful. If you are planning on wearing these in the snow, I would suggest going up a half or whole size so that you can wear them with socks. I bought some in my exact size, and a whole size larger, and the ones in my size fit like a glove. I doubt, even with loosening that they will accommodate thick socks. That said, I want to give a plug for the not-as-often purchased tan ones. They were one of the pairs that I kept (I managed to get all three at a steep discount so that it added up to one new pair!). The tan is great every day shoe, because it can take a beating and look the same. They look great with leggings or boyfriend jeans. Same with the Dakota Black. So these are the two I'd recommend for snow or heavy rain wear. I would be hesitant to get the suede for every day wear, but people do it. I had a tougher time returning the Charcoal, because they're different and would look good with faded jeans. I have another pair (Sabrina buckle) in the stiffer Veggie Black pair, and my feeling is that these don't wear as well, and are tougher to break in. If you're after the most beautiful boot, I would say the Cherry and the Cognac are always the most beautiful, in any Frye style. I would have a hard time wearing those every day, because I'd hate to wreck the leather. Still, either is great for wear with black, charcoal, gray, white or denim. Oh, I will also say this - I find them very comfortable. I have a leg injury, and I have a good amount of extra weight on my body, so that pretty much any shoe with heels is uncomfortable after a good couple of hours, but not these.