The reason I gave the sandals 4 stars instead of 5 is because they do fit small I normally wear an 8.5 or 9 and the sandals that I ordered are size 9 however my toes were pretty much hanging off the end a little bit and if I slid my foot back then my heel was sliding off the back! I would like to reorder these sandals so I guess if I do reorder them I will go for a 9.5. I ordered a size 9 medium I don't know if they have wide width but if you tend to have wider feet you would probably not fit these sandals very well. Anyway these sandals are really cute and comfortable from what I could tell when I tried them on! I do recommend them!