The idea of carrying my cell phone and i.d. in a scarf instead of a purse is a great idea. However, when items were in the scarf, it was pretty clear things were in there; it was bulky/lumpy, and the scarf hung strangely. I think under a jacket or vest it would be okay for that purpose, but  my vests and jackets have pockets for that purpose already. The scarf seemed well made, the pocket just didn't meet my expectations.