I had to throw my two cents in because the reviews that are telling you THEY KNOW they received fakes because of the inserts or the accessories, are just wrong.

There are a LOT of people telling you that the insert (the inner sole lining) should not come out, its supposed to be brown leather, its not supposed to be squishy.
Actually, TOMS makes shoes that yes, have a brown leather insert that isn't particularly squishy...
BUT...THEY MAKE VEGAN TOMS TOO.

The vegan TOMS have inserts that are NOT brown leather (cause, vegan) are quite squishy, and are removable.
It is not fake. It is the vegan version. Stop disparaging the seller of this is your only proof that its fake. You can buy TOMS with inserts exactly like this from Nordstrom, Zappos and TOMS itself. Right now. No, those retailers don't sell fake TOMS.
The majority of the other I got fakes reviews are people claiming if they don't come in a bag, or don't come with a fabric TOMS logo flag, they are fake. Er, no. Again, you can buy from TOMS or Nordies or Journeys or any other legitimate retailer and get TOMS in a cardboard box with no bag or fabric flag included. I haven't gotten a flag for some time now. Its a little decal nowadays, like a small bumper sticker. I haven't seen a pair sold in a fabric bag for awhile either.
Im not saying you cant get fakes here. You need to vet your sellers. But please don't flip out or throw them away or demand your money back calling people crooks if these two things are your only reason. Those are still real TOMS.
TOMS are very comfortable shoes, and they do get a little looser over time, so if you're a half size AND narrow, you might size down. If your foot is wide, Id probably buy the half size or even size up. If you leave your toenails longer, and I guess you know who you are, order up, because your toe will poke the end of the toe box out.
Super comfy shoes, but because they are simply constructed, they're not going to last you years like nice loafers or boat shoes or pumps. Theyll look pretty tired in a year or two if you wear them often. Its not fake. But thats why its nice to buy them here; the basic colors are cheap. People collect them, so yes, the limited colors and patterns can be more than retail here; well, its nice to know they're available but I tend towards the basic colors/materials. Great value.
Happy trails!