I must give these boots a five star, because once I got the right size, I LOVE THEM!  I originally ordered a 6 1/2 to wear with heavier socks (my normal size is 6 - 6 1/2 for socks).  I could barely get my foot into them.  As I REALLY wanted a pair, I reordered a size 7 1/2, which I have never worn before.  And, they fit!  Cushy bottom, thick protective sole, stylish design - a cross between a moccasin and a low boot.