Quality of material, stitching, back pockets and side leg pocket size are very nice.  Additional drawstring at the waist is a nice touch for a an adjustable waist if your waistline fluctuates a little.  Coal color is a very dark smoky gray, with a bluish tone. I prefer classic colors on the color wheel, not 'muddy' color versions, so love the color.  I would have rated the pants a 5 star if the bottom of the leg opening was not quite so wide.  I also purchased the Columbia Women's Saturday Trail Pants and I like the narrower leg profile.  Photo is comparison of prAna Halle 14 short to Columbia Women's Saturday Trail Pant in 14 short.  Halle is 30" inseam and STP is 29.5". Note tapering of Columbia ("Nightshadow" on top) vs prAna ("Coal" underneath).  Columbia material is also a little lighter, so depending on whether you are looking for a more durable material that is a little heavier weight, the prAna may suit your needs. Wish the pants had snap closure (like Columbia) versus buttons, especially since you have the drawstring.  Not a plus when you have to hit the restroom in a hurry and have to unbutton AND untie.  Front slash pockets a little small which is typical for women's pants. Annoying that men get deeper pockets.  By the way, Columbia "Nightshadow" is what I consider "muddy" color version of navy blue.