I'm giving it 4 stars only because I haven't worn it yet. Fits well, looks well made, (I'll update if that changes). Gun Metal color a little shinier than my usual black coats, but it's a welcomed change for me. Zipper worked well when tested. I wish it had buttons or snaps as well. Attractive, a little puffier than my short North Face, but I think it's a good buy.
Now I have to wait until it gets cold again.