I have tried three different pairs of Nautilus Safety Toe shoes.  The 1392, 1340 and 1317.  The first pair I ordered in my usual size of 11.  I usually get a wide size and these were offered as extra wide so I chose that width.  When I put them on my first thought was that these were just as comfortable as my New Balance Sneakers.  But when I stood up my big toe was hitting the end of the shoe.  The width was just right.  I sent them back.  I wanted to get another pair of 1392 in 11.5 but it wasn't offered in a wide width.  So I ordered a pair of 1340 in a 11.5 wide (not extra wide).  I tried them on and the length was OK but the width was not.  So I ordered a pair of 1317 in a 11.5 extra wide.  When they came in my toes were still rubbing.  I started to order a pair of 12 extra wide but then changed my mind.  After three attempts I figured Nautilus just wasn't going to work for me.  I wanted these because they are advertised as having an "extra wide" toe cap.  Still not enough room for my toes.  I think they would be very comfortable if you can find a pair that fits.