The fit was not what I needed for my foot to accommodate hallux rigidus with small bone spur. These are a bit snug on top and sides of forefoot and hit right on my big toe bone spur.  The lack of forefoot space began to show itself when I tried to put my foot in the boot after loosening laces  quite a bit. The soles are not as stiff as I need, but for a normal foot I think these would be a great boot with fit as expected.  The design with air venting yet protection appeared well thought out. I bought a different brand that fits me better but would probably feel too big for someone with normal feet.