The off white shoes were true to size, but the pink ones were much larger, both in width and length, than the size marked.  Not sure if this was a manufacturer error in marking, or if the sizing is really that inconsistent for the same model of shoe - I am guessing the former.  The vendor (shoemall) pushed back against free return, too, but did eventually agree.  I do like these shoes, and good narrow shoes are hard to find, but can't buy them if the sizing is so inconsistent unless there is an easier free return process.