Working great so far... if they last a year I will make it five stars.  For 35 bucks it is worth it.  I work in the service industry and dress shoes were just hurting my feet too much.  Hopefully these last a bit.

(One month update) These are still holding up great.  I use them about 4-5 days a week, and they are really comfortable.  I just wipe them down with a towel, and use them in a fine dining restaurant.  They are a great purchase.