These shoes are really nice.  I however, fell prey to the reviews.  I am a size seven (7) took the other customers review into consideration and size down.  Wrong decision.  I bought the size 6 and it is way small.  There was no half size, if there were, they would probably fit perfectly.  Since, I really like them, I will purchase the size 7.
I gave it 3 stars since the error in sizing is mine.  I therefore cannot speak about whether or not it is comfortable etc.