Mixed opinion on this. I ordered a size 10, but I received two pairs--a size 10 and a size 11. The size 10 fit ok (I wear a 9.5), but the upper was low (forward), kinda more like a women's shoe, and it was a bit narrow. The size 11 was too large of course, but I didn't order it anyway. What was interesting was that, although they were supposed to be two sizes of the same shoe, they were actually two different shoes. All that said, although I returned them both, at first glance the quality for the price was fair. I think they would last a long season. Any complaints about the insole falling out is just silly. It's simply not glued in. Which is fine--take it out, use it as a template to cut an Dr Scholls insert. You'll need it, because these shoes are flat and firm.