if  the fabric weren't SO soft I would have given a 2 star. the problem is the shape---  this is NOT a women's shape shirt. it is a tube that has no  concept of where the  waist should be.  it  fit great to the bottom of the breasts, but then there was NO contour; no cut in under the breast and no contouring for the waist. I think  this was the most unflattering button-down shirt I have ever bought. Fortunately I'm a tailor so I will  be able to alter them myself- once I lose some weight. the size is right, if you are  tube-shaped, not woman-shaped.