I accidentally one click ordered this dress while deliberating on it. I decided to let it come since I was considering it anyway and had time to return if need be.
I think (especially for the price) the dress is well made. It's a pretty safe choice as well since it is a true wrap dress you can tighten or loosen as you need around the waist. It is very flowy (which I wanted for the beach) but also a tad long, not enough to concern me.
I'm 5ft4, 145 lbs, 34D. I carry most of my weight in my hips which meant the top of the dress was larger on me than anticipated but still wearable by far.
I think it would be safe to say you could size down one of you weren't super chesty in order to get a more fitted look.
I ordered the floor length dress