Just received this shirt (and four of its companions!) in the mail.  So far, having been through the washer and dryer, the shirts have held their color and form.  Reading other reviews helped me to order up a size - this DOES say "slim fit", so order accordingly.  The listed measurements also helped.  As personal tastes, the only things I would caution:
- One more button on the bottom is something I would appreciate.  I'm not someone who tucks my button-down shirts in, so having a large flap at the bottom isn't appealing.  (See the picture of the wine colored shirt.)
- This is NOT a pop-out-of-the-wach-perfectly shirt.  You WILL need to iron/steam this shirt (see the picture of the orange shirt).  I don't mind that one bit, but some folks like wrinkle-free without having the extra step for ironing.
Something I love about this shirt is the length of the cuff.  It's perfect for folding back - although some more buttons to hold back the fold would be nice, too!
Overall, I highly recommend these shirts - they come at a great price and to me, the quality is there.