FINAL UPDATE: The sandals are broken in now and they really are very comfortable for fake leather. I raised them to 4 stars for comfort. If they were real leather they would totally be a 5 star shoe.
UPDATE:  I had to lower the rating from 5 to 1 star. The sandals are wearable for an hour or so but after that they gave me two blisters. Im thinking they may just need to be broken in. I thought they were leather when I purchased them but when I saw them, I realized they are NOT. I thought Id keep them even though they weren't leather because they felt comfortable but that ended about an hour in.  The shoe bed does have a nice cushioned step and they look ok but fake leather is uncomfortable and unforgiving. I would not buy them again and I would definitely not buy any show made out of THIS stuff. 

First review: I THINK they fit as expected but the last two pairs of foot gear I purchased from amazon feel small-ish, Im wondering if my foot grew. Anyway, the sandals feel very comfy SO FAR. I just put them on a few minutes ago and they're a little snug but the foot bed feels nice and padded. So far, I love the sandals. If they turn out to be crap Ill be updating my review but for now, I love them.