I love the cushion insole.  I have an old pair of softwalk shoes that are my favorite and the insole is as comfortable as the first day.  The sandals ran short (outside 3 toes hung off edge).  A 10.5 would probably be better, but not available.  The leather was stiff and not soft as I had expected, which caused some discomfort where the straps cross the foot.  I needed these to be a comfortable walking sandal for a trip.  Wish it had worked.  I would try another style or closed shoe in future.