I want to love this. The fabric is perfect, nice and thick while still being soft.

I bought too large. I'm 5'3" on a good day, currently breastfeeding so 34G and 165lbs give or take. Bought a XXL as I've been wearing L (2 sizes up based on reviews). I should have bought an XL. However, the length is goofy on me. Just feels like it makes me look boxy and short. I think if I were a couple inches taller and bought an XL, this would have been my go-to shirt.