I would normally give this shoe 5 out of 5 stars for ALMOST everything because overall it's mostly excellent:

-Fits great - this is one of the best fitting shoes I have ever owned available in wide size.
-Extremely comfortable.
-Looks great.
-Very easy to put on and take off.
-Feels very durable.
-Waterproof**.

**HOWEVER, I am only going to give it 3 out of 5 stars because of one reason - traction is VERY poor when the ground or floor is slightly wet, particularly when walking on non-porous surfaces, like smooth asphalt and bathroom tiles.  I have only had theses shoes for a few months, and there have already been a number of times I almost slipped / fell while wearing these shoes.  I particularly bought this model of Merrell's since it is supposed to be WATERPROOF, and you'd expect to be able to wear these shoes on rainy days, right?

If you live in a dry climate, or only expect to wear these on trails, then it's no problem, but if you live in a city, or your driveway / parking lot is paved, and hilly or inclined, then I suggest avoiding these shoes.