Love these boots!!  I have two pair of them now - tan and black.  I got the tan ones first and loved my tan ones so much, I bought a black pair.  I get so many compliments on these boots.  I wear them with the back of them high and the tongue folded down.  So comfortable and easy to keep clean (just throw them in the washer).  I almost always wear a 9M in shoes.  Sometimes 8.5.  I ordered these in a 9M and they fit perfectly.  Per the description, they are baggy and a loose fitting boot - but I love how comfortable they are.