Overall my husband likes the coat very much.  He says it is light weight and yet very warm.  He is 5'8" and 160 lbs and the medium fit well. He uses it primarily for ice fishing here in Montana and all the pockets are very handy for that activity.  He has had two issues. First the metal zipper pulls would turn sideways and jam at a 45 deg. angle making it very hard to operate the zippers.  The square topped pull is too wide or not wide enough for the hole they are mounted in.  He took a handheld grinding tool and rounded the corners on all the zippers and they function fine now.  He also had the cell phone pocket in the inside lower right blow out on first use.  Probably manufacturing error. It is very wind proof which is a must here east of the Rockies.  Lastly you cannot beat the price of this coat for what you get.  With no serious abuse the coat should last many years.