In my opinion, these are not up to Frye quality and look. They do not look as nice and modern and unique as other Frye boots. Leather looks more like PU leather. Lining is thin comparing to Uggs (that I personally ware on bare feet in coldest days). This one I would need to ware with socks. They are also very tight at arch area even if you go 1/2 size or even size bigger. I got them in 7.5 (my regular Frye size), and I did not feel comfortable. My friend ordered in 6.5 and also had the same issue. She tried mine 7.5, and while she found that length of boots feet area was longer, it still was uncomfortable in arch area.
But if you have narrow feet then you may fill comfortable.
Conclusion is that even if we put that narrow arch part aside, it doesn't worth even discount price, in my opinion. Therefore three stars only.
Sorry Frye, love you, but you could've done better with this one.