Love! I wasn't sure what to expect but I love these boots. They are so comfortable. I have a pair of Koolaburra's that I really liked and wanted another pair in a different color and decided to try these because I could not get my size or color in the other brand. They are actually more comfortable than my other ones. Will definitely buy another pair in a different color. There was even a slight discoloration on the plate on the back of the boot, but honestly I don't even care because these fit so great.

***Follow up*** They seem to be well waterproofed...I have shoveled snow in them and they still look great!!