I loved these shoes when they came. They fit well and seemed comfortable. They looked great and got a lot of compliments. But after I wore them on a walk I realized that they are lacking in support and made my feet hurt. I would still have given them a good rating because fit is a very personal thing. But now after less than 6 months of using these very lightly, they are starting to rip at the toes.  So I am downgrading them to 2 stars.