They did not hold up for the first day of wear at school;  my daughter and i are both very disappointed.  She is not that rough on shoes, she's very girly and into crafts .. So I knew she hadn't been running around dragging her toes along the asphalt! Day 2, black fabric  around the toes was already exposed. The imitation leather has peeled off. She normally outgrows her shoes before that happens. I paid $25, which isn't a ton, but definitely more than anyone would pay for one day of wear.  On the other hand, my daughter loves them and doesn't want to give them up.. Now she's upset with me for needing to return them!
The boots i got her at target 3 months ago are still in good shape and i paid a little less. It's disappointing.
The pic was taken after 4 days of wear.  Even the sole is already very worn. I gave 2 stars because they are really cute!