These fit the bill perfectly for my purpose, which is to slip them on quickly and go outside in winter and mud season to get the mail or work in the garden, or whatever else might take a few minutes to an hour or more. And with the tab on the heel, they're very easy to remove. They are actually a little taller than I expected at 15" but I'll use them for a while and if that's still an issue, I plan to just cut 2 or 3 inches off the top. The top is nice and wide for tucking pants legs into.

As far as sizing goes, I ordered a size 11 (one up from my shoe size) and they're a little loose, but that's OK, because with heavier socks they're just about right. I found the footbed comfortable and smooth.

I can't say how these will hold up for heavy or steady use, but for the price these sell for, I don't think you can really expect to get that sort of performance out of them.

Nice boots overall.