I have these exact shoes, same color and size that fit so perfectly. I ordered my usual 9.5 and receieved such a tiny pair of flats. I tried to walk around in them at home to break them in.. But that didn't work too well. I honestly didn't have the same issue with the previous pair, they fit well from the start. (I still have the shoes, they're just in terrible condition lol.) I had to return the shoes, I may reorder a half size up because the flats are lovely while they last. Now for the price, you should know that they don't last years.