I absolutely love these jeans for my daughter. She's been wearing them for the last 3 years. She is on a skinny side (i buy her slim whenever available) and these jeans in slim fir her great. In fact i tried getting them in redular width and even though they work, there is just a little too much room in her btbutt/thigh area. I disagree that they sit low, i would not like that. I think they sit just right, look great, good quality and last until she grows out of them. I'll probably keep buying them until she gets tired of wearing them. The best i have found for a tall skinny girl so far.