My 5 star review is for the Vionic brand only, as I ordered these in my size and received a size that was completely off the charts small (wrong one) so I never got to wear these.  They don't sell these anymore and I am totally bummed.  But, the wrong ones I received looked awesome.  If I could have worn a shoe 4 sizes smaller than the ones I ordered I would have.  Don't know why Vionic stopped making the Gerrit.  One of the best built, nicest looking sandals out there.