I really like these boots! They are comfortable! But in the Size 39 for my 8.5 feet, my toes run into the end of the boot. I have long toes.
I am saying this in case someone needs help in ordering for size. I needed to reorder a size 40 in these for me, even though I normally wear 8.5. They seemed to fit alright at first, but after walking around in my apt I noticed my toes running into the end of the boot.
The boots are wonderful! The thick rubber soles will be great for traction.  I do not know what is all the fuss in the reviews, unless some got a boot that was not as described, or were sent the faux leather version instead of the leather version by mistake. There are two versions of these boots, (see the questions and answers section),  faux leather, and  real leather.
I got the black leather boots b/c I did not want the extra maintenance of nubuck - it is more work to clean and maintain nubuck, although I really liked the color. I live in an area where in spring and fall there is a lot of puddles and mud and it is difficult to keep nubuck and suede type boots clean. The smooth leather you can clean more easily.
These boots are wonderfully made and are not floppy as some said, but stay right up. The metal thing around the perimeter helps to keep it in place, but the leather is thick, sturdy and stiff enough to stand up on it's own. I have not had any trouble with the buckles coming unbuckled yet, but if they do I can use an upholstery needle and thread and stitch it in place, using a thimble to help push the needle through, it is not that hard to stitch leather.
These are a wonderful mid-calf boot and look very attractive on the legs, and are well made, the shape is appealing, they are sturdy and have a good thick rubber sole. They can go with many different styles and outfits. What more could a girl want?