Shoes fit great  they shoe it self is hold up well, I am very happy with the comfort and the weight of the shoes as I am in them for up to 10 hrs or more a day. I would give them a 4 or 5 however the eyelets are continue to come apart, had the fist one fixed now 5 more broke not worth it to fix them will cost me more to fix all than the shoes are worth.  I don't know why they would use plastic eyelets on work shoes?