Great idea for gardening. The fit is very snug and I cut into the elastic to slip it on easier. On second thought I should have opted for clogs for my gardening.  This shoe might be good walking around in a river with rocks,  but than there are specifically made products for getting around in river walks. I ware size 8 and this is really snug.  Probably great for walking in rain if you wear socks with it. Really fun looking and really well made product. It did not fit me, that was my only problem.