I really like this item!  It is great quality - especially for the price. It is pretty poofy as shown in the pictures. There are two tiers of fabric making it so poofy. I wanted more of a flat fit - so I just cut out one layer and now its just the right amount of poof for me. I am 58 and 190 pounds and bought an XL. It fits perfectly - just the right length to peak out from dresses that are just a smidge too short. Falls above my knee. Ive been pretty critical of some of my Amazon clothing purchases but his product is great. Definitely recommend if you are looking for an extender that adds some poof.