I really like these shirts. Others have questioned the "100% cotton" claim, and I agree that this shirt is definitely not all cotton, but has some kind of elastic blend. I personally think this is a plus, and I have no problem with it. The shirts actually seem of really high quality compared to others I've purchased. My favorite thing about them is, because of the stretchy fibers, when I roll my sleeves up, they stay rolled up, instead of deforming like pure cotton sleeves often do, and rolling back down my arms. I've washed them a few times and have yet to see an shrinkage. As an aside, I personally don't like the extra buttons on the right side, and I was able to cut them off easily without ruining any other stitches.

One thing of note: when I purchased the tan and brown shirts, the colors were way off, and not in a good way. I still like them, but I mostly wear them around the house when I'm not going out. The white and grey colors are fantastic, though, and exactly what you'd expect.

All in all, I'm a fan, and am probably going to pick up a few more in the near future.