Christmas gift for my boyfriend and he loves them!  In fact... he used the nose wipe right after opening (what a weirdo, right?) :) He also likes the carbon color.  He hasn't used them in the mountains yet, but since they come with liners they should be warm enough.  Size medium was perfect for him (he's 5'8 and around 160lbs.... if that helps with glove sizing?).  If you're reading this and you trust my portrayal of my boyfriends reaction, you don't care that I am NOT a glove connoisseur, and you don't care that I may be a bit intoxicated because it's Friday night, then buy the gloves my friend!