I would give 5 stars if they offered this in 1/2 sizes. If you go bigger than your half size, the shoe is heavy and wide enough it's more work to walk with feeling like you're trying to keep the shoe on. If you go smaller, then the edge of your heel hits the little stitching lip at the back of the sole. Since it's not a place where you normally have any part of a shoe hitting, it can easily (and did for me) create a deep blister. Other than that, the style is super cute, fun and a comfortable shoe in every way. My GF is an even size and loves this shoe!