I really hated to return these because they were too short in the length and my toe ran into the end of the boot. I got them on sale, and the sale price was only for size 8, and I wear 8-1/2. These are really nice boots! super warm and durable. yes they are a little clunky but that helps for the trudging through the snow! the sole is rubber and really good for traction. They look cute. If I can find them in my size at the sale price again I will  buy another pair that fits!