I really liked these shoes - the color, style, and materials.  But when I put them on, both my daughter and husband each commented that my heel was hanging off the back, so I returned them.  To be fair, I have a high instep, and I think the top leather strap would have stretched a little to let my foot slide down some.  They felt solid and well made.  I toyed with getting the next larger size, but have not...yet.  I may still, because I do like these shoes!