I gave these three stars because they are still incredibly comfortable; however, the manufacturer has changed the shape and sizing.

This is the third pair I've purchased because they are my favorite, most comfortable, go-with-everything flip-flops.  I always get a size 7 and my feet are a little bit wide.  The 7's always fit great.  This time, though, my heel is right at the edge.  Also, they cut the foot on bed on this weird slant that make them too narrow now.  My outer foot hangs over the side.  I'm 5'7" and 140 pounds, so it's not a weight issue - it's definitely a change in the way they are made.  I'm really disappointed because I would have the same problem if I sized up to a size 8 -- they would be too narrow.