Simply put these are the most comfortable boots I have ever owned. I measure a 12 on a brannock device and the 11.5 fit perfectly.  The leather is super soft and comfortable, with little to no break-in required. I will have to be careful with water (leather sole), but love the old school look of these boots.  Great to see there are still good American brands to buy. One thing to note is I would make sure Amazon is the seller.  I had to return one pair that came through a 3rd party (but still Prime)....it was clear that the boots were used, soles were scuffed up - clearly someone had worn them and one of the speed hooks was completely ripped out of the boot.