I didn't have any of the fit problems other people have had. I almost let myself be dissuaded from buying it, and I'm glad I didn't give way. It's such a fun print, and the cotton is soft and thick and a cozily perfect weight for warmer summer nights. I find the tendency to open out around the legs is solved by tying the inner tie. I'm 5'4" 145 lbs, 38-30-38, and the XL fit just right. I'm giving it 4 stars because it is a little boxy, which I'm hoping will go away with laundering