I was so sad when these shoes came they where much to tight and I have a black pair same style and they fit perfect.  it is best if you can try them on before buying them because if you were to try three different pairs on they all are going to fit different I found out by going to JC Penney and I tried a 8 1/2 and they where also to tight I ordered the navy blue pair because they only sale them on line so took a chance and took a bad one because they where much to tight and it was the same shoe as I have at home so I have to send them back for a refund.  I was hoping they fit perfect but they did not.