Perfect.
We are always in pursuit of the perfect...bag, coat, pair of boots etc. You know what I mean; the one that goes with everything, is stylish and looks fantastic, yet practical and comfortable. I have spent more money than I care to consider on boots from Frye, la Canadienne, Frank Sarto, Bandalino, Uggs, to a new pair or Bed Stu, and everything in between. I was hesitant to try these because I own a pair of CH loafers that are okay, but not great. I'm so glad I did because THESE are the boots. They feel great straight out of the box, the leather is smooth, soft and buttery, not stiff at all. The padding and support was far better than I expected and actually wowed me. Laces plus the zipper on the back (instead of the side) make it easier than usual to make adjustments for thicker or thinner socks. The height is great, not to high or low where it would sit in a place that rubs. Good traction, rubber (so quiet) sole. I don't recall if they were advertised to be waterproof, and I can only give partial info for that. I have worn them in snow (<2in) and slushy melted snow and stayed dry. I have not worn them in snow or water that came up over the sole.
Only time will tell if they are durable. If they hold up I will be getting at least one more pair in black, and that would be the first time I thought enough of a pair of boots to buy more than one pair of the same.