I like these shoes a lot. I think they look smart and they seem pretty well made. I would have given 5 stars, but they tend to cut into my ankle area and the sides of the back of my foot quite a bit. They also rub on my baby toe and my second to baby toe and have left me with a couple blisters after 3 days of wearing. I do like them though- I just think they are a little too stiff. They fit perfect though.