Film "Defiance ditampa kanthi ulasan beragam seka para Juru Kritik" Adhedhasar "Tomat Rotten", film kang nduweni rating 57%, adhedhasar 180 ulasan, kanthi rating rata-rata 5.9 / 10. Adhedhasar "Metacritic", film kasebut nduwe nilai 58 saka 100, adhedhasar 34 kritik, nuduhake "rata-rata ulasan".