Pay by Experience Level for. Median of all compensation (including tips, bonus, and overtime) by years of experience. For many Incident Managers, more experience generally translates to higher pay.The average beginner in this position makes around $61K, but folks who have been around for five to 10 years see a markedly higher median salary of $80K. After working for 10 to 20 years, Incident Managers make a median salary of $84K.ay by Experience Level for. Median of all compensation (including tips, bonus, and overtime) by years of experience. For many Incident Managers, more experience generally translates to higher pay.