members current paul arnush - drums rob batke - keyboard , laptop steven batke - vocals , guitar tim batke - vocals , guitar , keyboard scott gallant - bass former joel hitchcock nathan seatter discography albums high expectations/low results ( october 18 , 2005 ) m4 ( december 11 , 2007 ) faunts remixed ( november 18 , 2008 ) feel.love.thinking.of ( february 17 , 2009 ) left here alone - ep ( november 17 , 2012 ) singles m4 , pt .