2009年2月12號，艾勤賢上訴成功，無罪釋放，但林炳昌嘅定罪仍維持，仲要加刑。林炳昌卒之喺2010年6月28號上訴成功，獲撤消所有控罪。
On February 12, 2009, Ai Qinxian successfully appealed and was acquitted, but Lin Bingchang's conviction was upheld, and the sentence was increased. On 28 June 2010, Lam successfully appealed and all charges were dropped.