Using that logic, it must also be 'silly' to want an all white North America or Australia. Why is there a difference between considering South Africa a white country and considering the USA a white country? Do blacks have more right to the African continent than Amerinds had in the American continents, in your view?  At the End of the day, the US, SA and Oz were all built by white men on huge, sparsely habited tracts of land. There was nothing there before then, which could be considered a nation in any meaningful sense. Therefore, all can be correctly considered as white countries in which no 'native' should have the 'right' to lay any claim. I see a difference, because in South Africa the Blacks have still always been the majority. But in America, and Australia the natives have been nearly wiped out, they only make up about 1%of the US population and I'm sure there can't be that high of a percentage of aborigines in Australia either. The White settlers of South Africa/Rhodesia made one big mistake....they didn't wipe out the Zulus, they left too many of them, and they paid for it. :o