On XXXX XXXX, 2014 I opened a case against XXXX XXXX and XXXX XXXX because they opened a collection which was closed as Identity Theft on XXXX XXXX, 2014. 

In that time, I explained to them that I have not ever live in NY, so it is not reasonable that I ask for a service in a place that I do not live and I do not planning to live. 
I work here in XXXX XXXX, I studied here, and I have been raised and live all my live here in XXXX. 
Also, I have an excellent credit ( which is affected by this again ). I do not have that kind of behavior about not paying my debts. 

Those cases were XXXX, and XXXX, which you have in your system. 
Both of them closed as Identity Theft. So why XXXX XXXX are trying to open this again after a year? It is not fair and they are damaging my credit.