I continue to dispute an invalid lien labeled under ID # XXXX with Transunion. My initial dispute was of XXXX invalid and prematurely placed liens in the public records section of my file and one was removed but not the other. These liens have been removed as they were joint liens with another indiviual who has since cleared and removed them from his reports as well. Yet, TransUnion keeps denying me a proper investigation and the proof of verification which I requested via certified mail, such as the descriptions and the procedures used to verify the liens that have since been removed from my file at the clerks office. They deny me any documentation and though they have deleted XXXX lien they refuse to remove the XXXX invalid one. XXXX has already deleted XXXX liens because they are unverifiable and no longer on record at the county clerks recorders office. So how does Transunion have the ability or the evidence to keep this lien on file when I have informed them many times that it needs to be deleted from my file and the public records section of my credit report with them. Please, can the government assist me in holding them accountable for denying me my right to an accurate credit report and a proper investigation? Transunion continues to ignore my correspondences and refuses to provide me proof and yet they deleted the other lien and XXXX deleted both. It is very hurtful and I have to spend so much money fighting them on this invalid and unverifiable lien on my record while the other bureaus remove them without hesitation. Please help me.