When my kids were younger, we shopped often at American Eagle Outfitters.
I used to shop there when I was in college - I think most of their target audience is college students. But even now as a 29 year old, I still shop there because their jeans are the only ones that fit me well. 
I do like their sizing at it seems very consistent with each style.
Yeah. I do hope their sizing stays consistent - otherwise I'll probably have to spend hours discovering another brand of jeans that fits me. Shopping is not something I terribly enjoy. 
I'm not a big shopper either and I also found the pricing at American Eagle to be reasonable.
Do you ever shop at Aerie? I think they're also owned by American Eagle