2098
William Marsden  was born in the village of Thornhill , near Dewsbury, in Yorkshire, the youngest of eight children. When he left school he was apprenticed to a wholesale druggist in Sheffield. In 1816, he moved to London where he took up an apprenticeship to a surgeon-apothecary before setting up on his own. At the end of 1824 he enrolled as a student of surgery at St Bartholomew's Hospital under the famous surgeon and lecturer John Abernethy (1764-1831). In April 1827 Marsden passed his MRCS examination to qualify as a full surgeon. He became an MD in 1838.
 place of birth: William Marsden , Thornhill
Given a phrase that describes the relationship between two words, extract the words and the lexical relationship between them. The output format should be "relation1: word1, word2; relation2: word3, word4". 
Option: place of death, place of birth, education degree, education institution 
Text: {0} 
Answer:
 place of birth: William Marsden , Thornhill