19451
Because of an editing error , the Metro Matters column yesterday , about the removal of Rashid Khalidi , a Columbia University professor , from a course that advises New York City teachers on how to talk about the Middle East gave an incorrect title in some copies for Ari L. Goldman of Columbia 's Graduate School of Journalism , who criticized the action against Professor Khalidi .
 place lived: Rashid Khalidi, New York City; person of company: Ari L. Goldman, Columbia University; location contains: New York City, Columbia University; place of birth: Rashid Khalidi, New York City; person of company: Rashid Khalidi, Columbia University
Given a phrase that describes the relationship between two words, extract the words and the lexical relationship between them. The output format should be "relation1: word1, word2; relation2: word3, word4". 
Option: ethnicity, place lived, geographic distribution, company industry, country of administrative divisions, administrative division of country, location contains, person of company, profession, ethnicity of people, company shareholder among major shareholders, sports team of location, religion, neighborhood of, company major shareholders, place of death, nationality, children, company founders, company founded place, country of capital, company advisors, sports team location of teams, place of birth 
Text: {0} 
Answer:
 place lived: Rashid Khalidi, New York City; person of company: Ari L. Goldman, Columbia University; location contains: New York City, Columbia University; place of birth: Rashid Khalidi, New York City; person of company: Rashid Khalidi, Columbia University