###Instruction: Multi-class classification, answer with one of the labels:['no_consensus', 'delete', 'keep', 'comment', 'merge', 'redirect'] : ###Input:  Q10314373: Kim Min Su (Q10314373) : association football player : ( delete | history | links | entity usage | logs ) Fails WD:N . Kacamata ( talk ) 00:54, 11 June 2023 (UTC) @ Kacamata : Why shouldn't he meet the notability criteria? -- Gymnicus ( talk ) 17:37, 11 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Fails all three points in WD:N . No valid sitelinks, therefore fails point 1. He can't be described using serious and publicly available references (this is why it was deleted from pt.WP), therefore fails point 2. It's not structural necessary, therefore failing point 3. Kacamata ( talk ) 17:51, 11 June 2023 (UTC) He can be clearly described by serious and publicly available references through the Transfermarkt. He has both a player and staff profile there. Only the player profile is currently incorporated. Keep - Gymnicus ( talk ) 18:13, 11 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Let me see if I understand, so I avoid making this mistake again, Transfermarkt is considered a reliable source by WD and therefore any soccer player with a profile there is considered notable per WD standards? Kacamata ( talk ) 18:29, 11 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Fails all three points in WD:N . No valid sitelinks, therefore fails point 1. He can't be described using serious and publicly available references (this is why it was deleted from pt.WP), therefore fails point 2. It's not structural necessary, therefore failing point 3. Kacamata ( talk ) 17:51, 11 June 2023 (UTC) He can be clearly described by serious and publicly available references through the Transfermarkt. He has both a player and staff profile there. Only the player profile is currently incorporated. Keep - Gymnicus ( talk ) 18:13, 11 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Let me see if I understand, so I avoid making this mistake again, Transfermarkt is considered a reliable source by WD and therefore any soccer player with a profile there is considered notable per WD standards? Kacamata ( talk ) 18:29, 11 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) He can be clearly described by serious and publicly available references through the Transfermarkt. He has both a player and staff profile there. Only the player profile is currently incorporated. Keep - Gymnicus ( talk ) 18:13, 11 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Let me see if I understand, so I avoid making this mistake again, Transfermarkt is considered a reliable source by WD and therefore any soccer player with a profile there is considered notable per WD standards? Kacamata ( talk ) 18:29, 11 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Let me see if I understand, so I avoid making this mistake again, Transfermarkt is considered a reliable source by WD and therefore any soccer player with a profile there is considered notable per WD standards? Kacamata ( talk ) 18:29, 11 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Fails all three points in WD:N . No valid sitelinks, therefore fails point 1. He can't be described using serious and publicly available references (this is why it was deleted from pt.WP), therefore fails point 2. It's not structural necessary, therefore failing point 3. Kacamata ( talk ) 17:51, 11 June 2023 (UTC) He can be clearly described by serious and publicly available references through the Transfermarkt. He has both a player and staff profile there. Only the player profile is currently incorporated. Keep - Gymnicus ( talk ) 18:13, 11 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Let me see if I understand, so I avoid making this mistake again, Transfermarkt is considered a reliable source by WD and therefore any soccer player with a profile there is considered notable per WD standards? Kacamata ( talk ) 18:29, 11 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) He can be clearly described by serious and publicly available references through the Transfermarkt. He has both a player and staff profile there. Only the player profile is currently incorporated. Keep - Gymnicus ( talk ) 18:13, 11 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Let me see if I understand, so I avoid making this mistake again, Transfermarkt is considered a reliable source by WD and therefore any soccer player with a profile there is considered notable per WD standards? Kacamata ( talk ) 18:29, 11 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Let me see if I understand, so I avoid making this mistake again, Transfermarkt is considered a reliable source by WD and therefore any soccer player with a profile there is considered notable per WD standards? Kacamata ( talk ) 18:29, 11 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) He can be clearly described by serious and publicly available references through the Transfermarkt. He has both a player and staff profile there. Only the player profile is currently incorporated. Keep - Gymnicus ( talk ) 18:13, 11 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Let me see if I understand, so I avoid making this mistake again, Transfermarkt is considered a reliable source by WD and therefore any soccer player with a profile there is considered notable per WD standards? Kacamata ( talk ) 18:29, 11 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Let me see if I understand, so I avoid making this mistake again, Transfermarkt is considered a reliable source by WD and therefore any soccer player with a profile there is considered notable per WD standards? Kacamata ( talk ) 18:29, 11 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Gymnicus Let me see if I understand, so I avoid making this mistake again, Transfermarkt is considered a reliable source by WD and therefore any soccer player with a profile there is considered notable per WD standards? Kacamata ( talk ) 18:29, 11 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC) Transfermarkt is sufficient to identify, but it is not a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) .  I don't see that the player profile provides useful sources, but perhaps I'm missing something. Bovlb ( talk ) 01:12, 17 June 2023 (UTC) @ Bovlb : It doesn't matter whether the Transfermarkt player ID is a Wikidata property for an identifier that suggests notability (Q62589316) or not. Because the addition of these statements does not take place on the basis of any consensus, but can only be carried out by users. It is certainly the case that Kim Min Su (Q10314373) is at the lower end of the notability scale, but in my opinion he still skips it because, according to Transfermarkt data, he was on the bench for at least one game in K League 1, the highest league in South Korea. From my point of view, he is notable enough because he sets himself apart from a very, very large part of the world population. Gymnicus ( talk ) 09:44, 17 June 2023 (UTC)