The first two of those were also included were made public, they are in the issue's papers  it did not  make  public  the county council's proposal as to who should be participants for each topic  since those were matters for the  the panel er to to ma take a view of  and I understood er from er  the question  er the answer to the question  that it had been made clear that er the information had been made public  except as always Chairman,er our legal office's of the council always like that caveat that in case anything had been missed out  I had just in fact suggested that perhaps not everything had been made public  so  I anticipated a possible supplementary question from Mr .