He lost to incumbent County Executive Dennis McNerney 60 % - 40 % in the November election .
Following a competitive and at times , heated campaign , Caliguire defeated Donovan 51 % to 49 % for the Republican nomination .
Caliguire lost to incumbent County Executive Dennis McNerney 60 % - 40 % in the November election .
Following a competitive and at times , heated campaign , Caliguire defeated Donovan 51 % to 49 % for the Republican nomination .