Yogi Berra matched it in the bottom of the fifth with a home run of his own .
The Yankee lead looked safe until a leadoff home run by Gil Hodges and two - run home run by pinch - hitter George Shuba chased Reynolds in the sixth .
Yogi Berra matched it in the bottom of the fifth with a home run of his own , and the Yankee lead looked safe until a leadoff home run by Gil Hodges and two - run home run by pinch - hitter George Shuba chased Reynolds in the sixth .