Carter was replaced as coach in 1958 by club legend Gerry Callahan , who served as captain - coach until 1959 .
Premierships followed in 1958 and 1959 , to give the club five flags in six years .
Carter was replaced as coach in 1958 by club legend Gerry Callahan , who served as captain - coach until 1959 , and premierships followed in 1958 and 1959 , to give the club five flags in six years .