Wilma 's eye passed directly over Cozumel .
Despite Emily being a powerful storm , it was the larger , stronger , slower - moving Hurricane Wilma that caused the most destruction when it hit the island in October .
Hurricane Wilma 's eye passed directly over Cozumel .
Despite Emily being a powerful storm , it was the larger , stronger , slower - moving Hurricane Wilma that caused the most destruction when it hit the island in October .