DeWine promised to deliver his wife 's homemade chocolate - covered peanut butter Buckeye candies to Hutchison if Texas won .
Hutchison promised to give DeWine some Blue Bell ice cream .
DeWine promised to deliver his wife 's homemade chocolate - covered peanut butter Buckeye candies to Hutchison if Texas won , while Hutchison promised to give DeWine some Blue Bell ice cream .