In November 1865 , he beat Democrat H.H. Hartley .
In November 1865 , he was re-elected to the Court as an Associate Justice , serving from January 1866 to January 4 , 1870 .
In November 1865 , he beat Democrat H.H. Hartley , and was re-elected to the Court as an Associate Justice , serving from January 1866 to January 4 , 1870 .