The first take on the book , provided by Charles Larson in 1978 , suggests McWhorter may be more than an editor .
Scholars have debated the extent to which McWhorter was an editor or collaborator .
The first take on the book , provided by Charles Larson in 1978 , suggests editor may be more than an editor .
Scholars have debated the extent to which McWhorter was an editor or collaborator .