Cincinnati later re-retired the number 5 for Johnny Bench .
Jump up ^ The Reds retired Hershberger 's # 5 after his death in 1940 , but returned it to circulation two years later .
The Reds later re-retired the number 5 for Johnny Bench .
Jump up ^ The Reds retired Hershberger 's # 5 after his death in 1940 , but returned it to circulation two years later .