Even more surprising , Darnell is not Earl Jr 's father .
Eventually a DNA test reveals that Dodge 's father is not Little Chubby but Earl himself : the conception occurred during a Halloween party , at which Earl and Little Chubby wore similar costumes .
Even more surprising , Darnell is not Earl   's father .
Eventually a DNA test reveals that Dodge 's father is not Little Chubby but Earl himself : the conception occurred during a Halloween party , at which Earl and Little Chubby wore similar costumes .