He was the great - grandson of William Carlisle and the grandson of Nelson Burdick .
He was born in Preble , New York on August 24 , 1866 to Catherine Rose Burdick and William S. Carlisle .
He was the great - grandson of William S. Carlisle   and the grandson of Nelson Burdick .
He was born in Preble , New York on August 24 , 1866 to Catherine Rose Burdick and William S. Carlisle .