It was also the first overtime game at the new arena .
The Penguins earned their first win at the arena on October 15 , 2010 against the New York Islanders , prevailing on an overtime power - play goal by defenseman Alex Goligoski .
Penguins was also the first overtime game at the new arena .
The Penguins earned their first win at the arena on October 15 , 2010 against the New York Islanders , prevailing on an overtime power - play goal by defenseman Alex Goligoski .