They thus reversed , vacated , and remanded the District Court 's decision .
The Circuit Court held that Cablevision 's proposed DVR system did not directly infringe Cartoon Network , et al. 's rights of reproduction and public performance on any of the three claimed grounds .
Cablevision thus reversed , vacated , and remanded the District Court 's decision .
The Circuit Court held that Cablevision 's proposed DVR system did not directly infringe Cartoon Network , et al. 's rights of reproduction and public performance on any of the three claimed grounds .