Democrat Paul Aronsohn challenged Garrett .
New Jersey 's 5th congressional district -- Scott Garrett ( R ) won in 2004 with 58 % of the vote against Anne Wolfe ( D ) in what is normally a Republican district .
D Paul Aronsohn challenged Scott Garrett .
New Jersey 's 5th congressional district -- Scott Garrett ( R ) won in 2004 with 58 % of the vote against Anne Wolfe ( D ) in what is normally a Republican district .