Judge John McKaie saw it 116 - 112 .
Joe Pasquale had it 115 - 113 for Thurman while judge Kevin Morgan scored the bout 115 - 113 for Garcia , as did the Herald .
Judge John McKaie saw it 116 - 112 , and Joe Pasquale had it 115 - 113 for Thurman while judge Kevin Morgan scored the bout 115 - 113 for Garcia , as did the Herald .