Colgate returns one of the best quarterbacks in the FCS , Gavin McCarney , who ranked ninth nationally in total offense ( 314.8 ypg ) .
Was the fifth - place finisher in the Walter Payton Award voting as a junior .
Colgate returns one of the best quarterbacks in the FCS , Gavin McCarney , who ranked ninth nationally in total offense ( 314.8 ypg ) and was the fifth - place finisher in the Walter Payton Award voting as a junior .