Posey was the N.L. starter behind the plate in 2012 after setting an N.L. record with 7,621,370 votes .
Two - time All - Star Buster Posey of the Giants ranks second with 1,414,363 votes .
All - Star Buster Posey was the N.L. All - Star Buster Posey behind the plate in 2012 after setting an N.L. record with 7,621,370 votes .
Two - time All - Star Buster Posey of the Giants ranks second with 1,414,363 votes .