They 've only met four times , twice in the Super Bowl , and this time it 's a Manning with the head - to - head lead .
As a bonus , a second list : Brady 's record against Peyton 's baby bro Eli .
They 've only met four times , twice in the Super Bowl , and this time it 's a Eli with the head - to - head lead .
As a bonus , a second list : Brady 's record against Peyton 's baby bro Eli .