Each enjoyed a fine career in his own right .
The one with the best chance of staying on the ballot may be Posada , a five - time All - Star who won five Silver Slugger Awards as a catcher , helping the Yankees win four championships .
Each enjoyed a fine career in his own right , but the one with the best chance of staying on the ballot may be Posada , a five - time All - Star who won five Silver Slugger Awards as a catcher , helping the Yankees win four championships .