A horror show performance in the FFA Cup means Andrew Redmayne still needs to convince many he 's a starting XI ' keeper .
While Tyson is a popular squad personality it 's debatable if keeper 's an on - field improvement on Liam Reddy .
A horror show performance in the FFA Cup means Andrew Redmayne still needs to convince many he 's a starting XI ' keeper , and while Tyson is a popular squad personality it 's debatable if he 's an on - field improvement on Liam Reddy .