Winnall was replaced by Ivan Toney after 65 minutes and the on - loan Newcastle striker made an instant impact .
Winnall is the Tykes ' 18 - goal leading scorer who had been a big injury doubt in the build - up to the final .
Winnall , the Tykes ' 18 - goal leading scorer who had been a big injury doubt in the build - up to the final , was replaced by Ivan Toney after 65 minutes and the on - loan Newcastle striker made an instant impact .