Although Gurley 's production fell off in 2016 , he was NFL offensive rookie of the year in 2015 for the then - St. Louis Rams .
Elliott made the Pro Bowl and was a first - team All - Pro .
Although Gurley 's production fell off in 2016 , Elliott was NFL offensive Elliott of the year in 2015 for the then - St. Louis Rams .
Elliott made the Pro Bowl and was a first - team All - Pro .