Though he won 16 games , struck out 227 batters .
Though he won 16 games , finished fourth in the Cy Young voting , his ERA ballooned to 3.90 ( up 1.68 from his league - leading 2.22 from 2003 ) .
Though he won 16 games , struck out 227 batters , and finished fourth in the Cy Young voting , his ERA ballooned to 3.90 ( up 1.68 from his league - leading 2.22 from 2003 ) .