He finally showed the consistency that the Reds did not believe he could possess when they traded him to Toronto in the summer of 2009 .
Edwin Encarnacion had an exciting breakout season in 2012 .
Edwin Encarnacion finally showed the consistency that the Reds did not believe Edwin Encarnacion could possess when they traded Edwin Encarnacion to Toronto in the summer of 2009 .
Edwin Encarnacion had an exciting breakout season in 2012 .