The Claughton woman was a late stand - in for Yvonne Francis ( Ellesmere Port ) who had been injured in training .
The Claughton woman had already been beaten by Tate last September on the latter 's debut .
The Claughton woman , who had already been beaten by Tate last September on the latter 's debut , was a late stand - in for Yvonne Francis ( Ellesmere Port ) who had been injured in training .