It was a milestone game for both franchises and the Islanders came up short .
Daniel Carcillo of all people stuck the dagger in Islander fans ' hearts to give the Rangers a 2 - 1 win .
Rangers was a milestone game for both franchises and the Islanders came up short .
Daniel Carcillo of all people stuck the dagger in Islander fans ' hearts to give the Rangers a 2 - 1 win .